tokens
list | idx
int64 0
894k
| text
stringlengths 316
895
| cluster
int64 0
999
|
|---|---|---|---|
[
"site",
".",
"the",
"con",
"##sei",
"##l",
"sc",
"##ola",
"##ire",
"cat",
"##hol",
"##ique",
"de",
"providence",
"(",
"cs",
"##c",
"providence",
")",
"represents",
"the",
"two",
"french",
"catholic",
"schools",
"in",
"the",
"city",
",",
"saint",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"francois",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"xavier",
"and",
"saint",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"thomas",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"d",
"'",
"a",
"##quin",
",",
"while",
"the",
"con",
"##sei",
"##l",
"sc",
"##ola",
"##ire",
"via",
"##mond",
"##e",
"operates",
"two",
"french",
"public",
"schools",
",",
"the",
"elementary",
"ecole",
"les",
"rapid",
"##es",
"and",
"the",
"secondary",
"ecole",
"second",
"##aire",
"franco",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"je",
"##unes",
"##se",
".",
"there",
"are",
"also",
"two",
"independent",
"christian",
"elementary",
"schools",
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
"—",
"sar",
"##nia",
"christian",
"school",
"and",
"temple",
"christian",
"academy",
".",
"lamb",
"##ton",
"college",
",",
"which",
"offers",
"two",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"year",
"programs",
"and",
"diploma",
"##s",
","
] | 2,200 |
site . the con ##sei ##l sc ##ola ##ire cat ##hol ##ique de providence ( cs ##c providence ) represents the two french catholic schools in the city , saint @ - @ francois @ - @ xavier and saint @ - @ thomas @ - @ d ' a ##quin , while the con ##sei ##l sc ##ola ##ire via ##mond ##e operates two french public schools , the elementary ecole les rapid ##es and the secondary ecole second ##aire franco @ - @ je ##unes ##se . there are also two independent christian elementary schools in sar ##nia — sar ##nia christian school and temple christian academy . lamb ##ton college , which offers two @ - @ year programs and diploma ##s ,
| 393 |
[
"is",
"one",
"of",
"ontario",
"'",
"s",
"21",
"colleges",
"of",
"applied",
"arts",
"and",
"technology",
".",
"it",
"has",
"a",
"full",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"time",
"en",
"##rol",
"##ment",
"of",
"3",
"@",
",",
"@",
"500",
"and",
"a",
"part",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"time",
"en",
"##rol",
"##ment",
"of",
"about",
"8",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
".",
"it",
"is",
"the",
"city",
"'",
"s",
"only",
"post",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"secondary",
"school",
".",
"there",
"are",
"four",
"radio",
"stations",
"that",
"originate",
"from",
"sar",
"##nia",
",",
"although",
"other",
"stations",
"re",
"##bro",
"##ad",
"##cast",
"their",
"signal",
"there",
",",
"notably",
"ck",
"##ti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fm",
",",
"a",
"first",
"nations",
"produced",
"station",
"from",
"kettle",
"point",
",",
"and",
"cbe",
"##g",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fm",
"and",
"cbe",
"##f",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"3",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fm",
",",
"simulcast",
"##s",
"of",
"cbc",
"radio"
] | 2,201 |
is one of ontario ' s 21 colleges of applied arts and technology . it has a full @ - @ time en ##rol ##ment of 3 @ , @ 500 and a part @ - @ time en ##rol ##ment of about 8 @ , @ 000 . it is the city ' s only post @ - @ secondary school . there are four radio stations that originate from sar ##nia , although other stations re ##bro ##ad ##cast their signal there , notably ck ##ti @ - @ fm , a first nations produced station from kettle point , and cbe ##g @ - @ fm and cbe ##f @ - @ 3 @ - @ fm , simulcast ##s of cbc radio
| 62 |
[
"one",
"and",
"ic",
"##i",
"radio",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"canada",
"premiere",
",",
"respectively",
",",
"from",
"windsor",
",",
"ontario",
".",
"cho",
"##k",
",",
"country",
"/",
"news",
"/",
"sports",
"cf",
"##g",
"##x",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fm",
"the",
"fox",
",",
"adult",
"contemporary",
"ch",
"##ks",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fm",
",",
"active",
"rock",
"sar",
"##nia",
"does",
"not",
"have",
"a",
"network",
"television",
"station",
"of",
"its",
"own",
",",
"although",
"it",
"has",
"a",
"community",
"channel",
"on",
"co",
"##ge",
"##co",
",",
"which",
"is",
"the",
"cable",
"television",
"provider",
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
".",
"cable",
"systems",
"pipe",
"in",
"stations",
"from",
"kitchener",
"and",
"toronto",
".",
"the",
"city",
"'",
"s",
"main",
"daily",
"newspaper",
"is",
"the",
"sar",
"##nia",
"observer",
",",
"owned",
"by",
"post",
"##media",
",",
"which",
"purchased",
"sun",
"media",
"in",
"2014",
"for",
"$",
"316",
"million",
".",
"a",
"weekly",
"newspaper",
"called",
"the",
"sar"
] | 2,202 |
one and ic ##i radio @ - @ canada premiere , respectively , from windsor , ontario . cho ##k , country / news / sports cf ##g ##x @ - @ fm the fox , adult contemporary ch ##ks @ - @ fm , active rock sar ##nia does not have a network television station of its own , although it has a community channel on co ##ge ##co , which is the cable television provider in sar ##nia . cable systems pipe in stations from kitchener and toronto . the city ' s main daily newspaper is the sar ##nia observer , owned by post ##media , which purchased sun media in 2014 for $ 316 million . a weekly newspaper called the sar
| 673 |
[
"##nia",
"journal",
"began",
"distribution",
"in",
"march",
"2014",
".",
"it",
"is",
"distributed",
"to",
"30",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
"households",
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
",",
"bright",
"’",
"s",
"grove",
",",
"point",
"edward",
"and",
"co",
"##run",
"##na",
".",
"the",
"community",
"publications",
"sar",
"##nia",
"this",
"week",
",",
"lamb",
"##ton",
"county",
"smart",
"shop",
"##per",
"and",
"business",
"trends",
"are",
"owned",
"by",
"bow",
"##es",
"publishing",
".",
"the",
"monthly",
"business",
"oriented",
"newspaper",
"first",
"monday",
"is",
"owned",
"by",
"huron",
"web",
"printing",
"and",
"graphics",
".",
"lamb",
"##ton",
"shield",
"publishing",
"has",
"been",
"in",
"operation",
"since",
"november",
"2010",
"and",
"runs",
"an",
"on",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"line",
"only",
"news",
"website",
",",
"lamb",
"##ton",
"##shi",
"##eld",
".",
"com",
",",
"delivering",
"local",
"news",
"and",
"services",
"to",
"the",
"sar",
"##nia",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"lamb",
"##ton",
"area",
".",
"there",
"are",
"two",
"magazines",
"currently",
"published"
] | 2,203 |
##nia journal began distribution in march 2014 . it is distributed to 30 @ , @ 000 households in sar ##nia , bright ’ s grove , point edward and co ##run ##na . the community publications sar ##nia this week , lamb ##ton county smart shop ##per and business trends are owned by bow ##es publishing . the monthly business oriented newspaper first monday is owned by huron web printing and graphics . lamb ##ton shield publishing has been in operation since november 2010 and runs an on @ - @ line only news website , lamb ##ton ##shi ##eld . com , delivering local news and services to the sar ##nia @ - @ lamb ##ton area . there are two magazines currently published
| 3 |
[
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
",",
"business",
"trends",
"and",
"report",
"on",
"industry",
".",
"business",
"trends",
"is",
"distributed",
"through",
"city",
"hall",
"and",
"report",
"on",
"industry",
"is",
"sent",
"to",
"executives",
"in",
"surrounding",
"businesses",
".",
"report",
"on",
"industry",
"articles",
"are",
"available",
"online",
".",
"=",
"=",
"notable",
"people",
"=",
"=",
"among",
"sar",
"##nia",
"'",
"s",
"distinguished",
"residents",
"are",
"retired",
"canadian",
"space",
"agency",
"astronaut",
"chris",
"had",
"##field",
",",
"who",
"flew",
"on",
"two",
"nasa",
"space",
"shuttle",
"missions",
"and",
"served",
"as",
"the",
"first",
"canadian",
"commander",
"of",
"the",
"international",
"space",
"station",
"during",
"expedition",
"35",
".",
"the",
"nobel",
"laureate",
"george",
"andrew",
"ol",
"##ah",
"moved",
"to",
"sar",
"##nia",
"from",
"his",
"native",
"hungary",
"to",
"join",
"dow",
"chemical",
"in",
"1957",
".",
"james",
"doo",
"##han",
",",
"the",
"well",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"known",
"star",
"trek",
"actor",
",",
"attended",
"high",
"school",
"in",
"sar"
] | 2,204 |
in sar ##nia , business trends and report on industry . business trends is distributed through city hall and report on industry is sent to executives in surrounding businesses . report on industry articles are available online . = = notable people = = among sar ##nia ' s distinguished residents are retired canadian space agency astronaut chris had ##field , who flew on two nasa space shuttle missions and served as the first canadian commander of the international space station during expedition 35 . the nobel laureate george andrew ol ##ah moved to sar ##nia from his native hungary to join dow chemical in 1957 . james doo ##han , the well @ - @ known star trek actor , attended high school in sar
| 230 |
[
"##nia",
".",
"harmonica",
"vi",
"##rt",
"##uo",
"##so",
"mike",
"stevens",
"still",
"lives",
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
"and",
"tours",
"all",
"over",
"the",
"world",
";",
"he",
"is",
"also",
"notable",
"for",
"his",
"extensive",
"work",
"with",
"aboriginal",
"youth",
".",
"many",
"notable",
"sar",
"##nian",
"##s",
"are",
"athletes",
"and",
"others",
"associated",
"with",
"sports",
",",
"such",
"as",
"nhl",
"hall",
"of",
"fame",
"##r",
"dino",
"ci",
"##cca",
"##relli",
",",
"former",
"nhl",
"star",
"pat",
"verb",
"##ee",
"##k",
",",
"retired",
"nhl",
"referee",
"kerry",
"fraser",
",",
"current",
"nhl",
"star",
"steven",
"st",
"##am",
"##kos",
",",
"champion",
"curl",
"##er",
"steve",
"bi",
"##ce",
",",
"and",
"golfer",
"mike",
"weir",
",",
"who",
"was",
"the",
"2003",
"masters",
"champion",
".",
"dominique",
"peg",
"##g",
",",
"a",
"sar",
"##nia",
"gymnast",
",",
"won",
"a",
"bronze",
"medal",
"in",
"floor",
"exercise",
",",
"at",
"the",
"world",
"cup",
"event",
"in",
"cot",
"##t",
"##bus",
"in"
] | 2,205 |
##nia . harmonica vi ##rt ##uo ##so mike stevens still lives in sar ##nia and tours all over the world ; he is also notable for his extensive work with aboriginal youth . many notable sar ##nian ##s are athletes and others associated with sports , such as nhl hall of fame ##r dino ci ##cca ##relli , former nhl star pat verb ##ee ##k , retired nhl referee kerry fraser , current nhl star steven st ##am ##kos , champion curl ##er steve bi ##ce , and golfer mike weir , who was the 2003 masters champion . dominique peg ##g , a sar ##nia gymnast , won a bronze medal in floor exercise , at the world cup event in cot ##t ##bus in
| 639 |
[
"march",
"2012",
".",
"the",
"honourable",
"alexander",
"mackenzie",
",",
"second",
"prime",
"minister",
"of",
"canada",
",",
"was",
"buried",
"at",
"lake",
"##view",
"cemetery",
",",
"sar",
"##nia",
",",
"where",
"a",
"monument",
"has",
"been",
"erected",
".",
"the",
"1910s",
"–",
"1930s",
"actress",
"marie",
"pre",
"##vos",
"##t",
"was",
"also",
"born",
"there",
".",
"katherine",
"ryan",
",",
"comedian",
",",
"writer",
",",
"presenter",
"and",
"actress",
",",
"was",
"born",
"in",
"sar",
"##nia",
"in",
"1983",
"she",
"now",
"resides",
"in",
"london",
",",
"england",
".",
"=",
"french",
"cruiser",
"sul",
"##ly",
"=",
"the",
"french",
"cruiser",
"sul",
"##ly",
"was",
"an",
"armored",
"cruiser",
"of",
"the",
"g",
"##lo",
"##ire",
"class",
"that",
"was",
"built",
"for",
"the",
"french",
"navy",
"in",
"the",
"early",
"1900s",
".",
"she",
"was",
"named",
"in",
"honor",
"of",
"maxim",
"##ili",
"##en",
"de",
"beth",
"##une",
",",
"duke",
"of",
"sul",
"##ly",
",",
"trusted",
"minister",
"of",
"king"
] | 2,206 |
march 2012 . the honourable alexander mackenzie , second prime minister of canada , was buried at lake ##view cemetery , sar ##nia , where a monument has been erected . the 1910s – 1930s actress marie pre ##vos ##t was also born there . katherine ryan , comedian , writer , presenter and actress , was born in sar ##nia in 1983 she now resides in london , england . = french cruiser sul ##ly = the french cruiser sul ##ly was an armored cruiser of the g ##lo ##ire class that was built for the french navy in the early 1900s . she was named in honor of maxim ##ili ##en de beth ##une , duke of sul ##ly , trusted minister of king
| 361 |
[
"henry",
"iv",
".",
"the",
"ship",
"struck",
"a",
"rock",
"in",
"ha",
"long",
"bay",
",",
"french",
"indochina",
"in",
"1905",
",",
"only",
"eight",
"months",
"after",
"she",
"was",
"completed",
",",
"and",
"was",
"a",
"total",
"loss",
".",
"=",
"=",
"design",
"and",
"description",
"=",
"=",
"the",
"g",
"##lo",
"##ire",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"class",
"ships",
"were",
"designed",
"as",
"enlarged",
"and",
"improved",
"versions",
"of",
"the",
"gu",
"##ey",
"##don",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"class",
"armored",
"cruisers",
"by",
"emile",
"bert",
"##in",
".",
"her",
"crew",
"numbered",
"61",
"##2",
"officers",
"and",
"men",
".",
"the",
"ship",
"measured",
"139",
"@",
".",
"@",
"8",
"meters",
"(",
"45",
"##8",
"ft",
"8",
"in",
")",
"overall",
",",
"with",
"a",
"beam",
"of",
"20",
"@",
".",
"@",
"2",
"meters",
"(",
"66",
"ft",
"3",
"in",
")",
".",
"sul",
"##ly",
"had",
"a",
"draft",
"of",
"7",
"@",
".",
"@",
"7"
] | 2,207 |
henry iv . the ship struck a rock in ha long bay , french indochina in 1905 , only eight months after she was completed , and was a total loss . = = design and description = = the g ##lo ##ire @ - @ class ships were designed as enlarged and improved versions of the gu ##ey ##don @ - @ class armored cruisers by emile bert ##in . her crew numbered 61 ##2 officers and men . the ship measured 139 @ . @ 8 meters ( 45 ##8 ft 8 in ) overall , with a beam of 20 @ . @ 2 meters ( 66 ft 3 in ) . sul ##ly had a draft of 7 @ . @ 7
| 944 |
[
"meters",
"(",
"25",
"ft",
"3",
"in",
")",
"and",
"displaced",
"10",
"@",
",",
"@",
"01",
"##4",
"metric",
"tons",
"(",
"9",
"@",
",",
"@",
"85",
"##6",
"long",
"tons",
")",
".",
"sul",
"##ly",
"had",
"three",
"propeller",
"shafts",
",",
"each",
"powered",
"by",
"one",
"vertical",
"triple",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"expansion",
"steam",
"engine",
",",
"which",
"were",
"rated",
"at",
"a",
"total",
"of",
"20",
"@",
",",
"@",
"500",
"indicated",
"horsepower",
"(",
"15",
"@",
",",
"@",
"300",
"kw",
")",
".",
"twenty",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"four",
"belle",
"##ville",
"water",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"tube",
"boilers",
"provided",
"steam",
"for",
"her",
"engines",
".",
"she",
"had",
"a",
"designed",
"speed",
"of",
"21",
"@",
".",
"@",
"5",
"knots",
"(",
"39",
"@",
".",
"@",
"8",
"km",
"/",
"h",
";",
"24",
"@",
".",
"@",
"7",
"mph",
")",
".",
"she",
"carried",
"up",
"to",
"1",
"@"
] | 2,208 |
meters ( 25 ft 3 in ) and displaced 10 @ , @ 01 ##4 metric tons ( 9 @ , @ 85 ##6 long tons ) . sul ##ly had three propeller shafts , each powered by one vertical triple @ - @ expansion steam engine , which were rated at a total of 20 @ , @ 500 indicated horsepower ( 15 @ , @ 300 kw ) . twenty @ - @ four belle ##ville water @ - @ tube boilers provided steam for her engines . she had a designed speed of 21 @ . @ 5 knots ( 39 @ . @ 8 km / h ; 24 @ . @ 7 mph ) . she carried up to 1 @
| 981 |
[
",",
"@",
"590",
"long",
"tons",
"(",
"1",
"@",
",",
"@",
"620",
"t",
")",
"of",
"coal",
"and",
"could",
"steam",
"for",
"12",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
"nautical",
"miles",
"(",
"22",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
"km",
";",
"14",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
"mi",
")",
"at",
"a",
"speed",
"of",
"10",
"knots",
"(",
"19",
"km",
"/",
"h",
";",
"12",
"mph",
")",
".",
"sul",
"##ly",
"'",
"s",
"main",
"armament",
"consisted",
"of",
"two",
"194",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"mill",
"##imeter",
"(",
"7",
"@",
".",
"@",
"6",
"in",
")",
"45",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"caliber",
"guns",
"were",
"mounted",
"in",
"single",
"gun",
"turrets",
"fore",
"and",
"aft",
".",
"her",
"intermediate",
"armament",
"was",
"eight",
"45",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"caliber",
"canon",
"de",
"164",
"mm",
"model",
"##e",
"1893",
"guns",
".",
"four",
"of",
"these",
"were",
"in",
"single",
"gun",
"turrets",
"on",
"the",
"sides"
] | 2,209 |
, @ 590 long tons ( 1 @ , @ 620 t ) of coal and could steam for 12 @ , @ 000 nautical miles ( 22 @ , @ 000 km ; 14 @ , @ 000 mi ) at a speed of 10 knots ( 19 km / h ; 12 mph ) . sul ##ly ' s main armament consisted of two 194 @ - @ mill ##imeter ( 7 @ . @ 6 in ) 45 @ - @ caliber guns were mounted in single gun turrets fore and aft . her intermediate armament was eight 45 @ - @ caliber canon de 164 mm model ##e 1893 guns . four of these were in single gun turrets on the sides
| 985 |
[
"of",
"the",
"ship",
"and",
"the",
"other",
"four",
"were",
"in",
"case",
"##mates",
".",
"for",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"torpedo",
"boat",
"defence",
"she",
"carried",
"six",
"45",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"caliber",
"100",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"mill",
"##imeter",
"(",
"3",
"@",
".",
"@",
"9",
"in",
")",
"guns",
"in",
"case",
"##mates",
"and",
"eighteen",
"47",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"mill",
"##imeter",
"(",
"1",
"@",
".",
"@",
"9",
"in",
")",
"hot",
"##ch",
"##kis",
"##s",
"guns",
".",
"she",
"was",
"also",
"armed",
"with",
"five",
"450",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"mill",
"##imeter",
"(",
"18",
"in",
")",
"torpedo",
"tubes",
";",
"two",
"of",
"these",
"were",
"submerged",
"and",
"the",
"others",
"were",
"above",
"water",
".",
"the",
"water",
"##line",
"armored",
"belt",
"of",
"the",
"g",
"##lo",
"##ire",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"class",
"ships",
"was",
"170",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"6",
"@",
".",
"@",
"7",
"in",
")"
] | 2,210 |
of the ship and the other four were in case ##mates . for anti @ - @ torpedo boat defence she carried six 45 @ - @ caliber 100 @ - @ mill ##imeter ( 3 @ . @ 9 in ) guns in case ##mates and eighteen 47 @ - @ mill ##imeter ( 1 @ . @ 9 in ) hot ##ch ##kis ##s guns . she was also armed with five 450 @ - @ mill ##imeter ( 18 in ) torpedo tubes ; two of these were submerged and the others were above water . the water ##line armored belt of the g ##lo ##ire @ - @ class ships was 170 mill ##imeters ( 6 @ . @ 7 in )
| 985 |
[
"thick",
"amid",
"##ship",
"##s",
"and",
"tape",
"##red",
"to",
"106",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"4",
"@",
".",
"@",
"2",
"in",
")",
"towards",
"the",
"bow",
"and",
"stern",
".",
"above",
"the",
"main",
"belt",
"was",
"another",
"belt",
",",
"127",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"5",
"in",
")",
"thick",
"that",
"also",
"tape",
"##red",
"to",
"106",
"mm",
"at",
"the",
"ends",
"of",
"the",
"ship",
".",
"the",
"con",
"##ning",
"tower",
"had",
"armored",
"sides",
"150",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"5",
"@",
".",
"@",
"9",
"in",
")",
"thick",
".",
"the",
"main",
"gun",
"turrets",
"were",
"protected",
"by",
"173",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"6",
"@",
".",
"@",
"8",
"in",
")",
"of",
"armor",
"and",
"the",
"intermediate",
"turrets",
"by",
"120",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"4",
"@",
".",
"@",
"7",
"in",
")",
".",
"the",
"flat",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"lower",
"armored",
"deck",
"was",
"45",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"1"
] | 2,211 |
thick amid ##ship ##s and tape ##red to 106 mill ##imeters ( 4 @ . @ 2 in ) towards the bow and stern . above the main belt was another belt , 127 mill ##imeters ( 5 in ) thick that also tape ##red to 106 mm at the ends of the ship . the con ##ning tower had armored sides 150 mill ##imeters ( 5 @ . @ 9 in ) thick . the main gun turrets were protected by 173 mill ##imeters ( 6 @ . @ 8 in ) of armor and the intermediate turrets by 120 mill ##imeters ( 4 @ . @ 7 in ) . the flat part of the lower armored deck was 45 mill ##imeters ( 1
| 987 |
[
"@",
".",
"@",
"8",
"in",
")",
",",
"but",
"increased",
"to",
"64",
"mill",
"##imeters",
"(",
"2",
"@",
".",
"@",
"5",
"in",
")",
"as",
"it",
"slope",
"##d",
"down",
"to",
"the",
"sides",
"of",
"the",
"ship",
".",
"sul",
"##ly",
"was",
"laid",
"down",
"at",
"the",
"forge",
"##s",
"et",
"chant",
"##iers",
"de",
"la",
"med",
"##iter",
"##rane",
"##e",
"shipyard",
"in",
"la",
"se",
"##yne",
"on",
"24",
"may",
"1899",
"and",
"launched",
"on",
"4",
"june",
"1901",
".",
"the",
"ship",
"was",
"completed",
"in",
"june",
"1904",
"and",
"sent",
"to",
"french",
"indochina",
"for",
"her",
"first",
"commission",
".",
"on",
"7",
"february",
"1905",
"sul",
"##ly",
"struck",
"a",
"rock",
"in",
"ha",
"long",
"bay",
";",
"her",
"crew",
"was",
"not",
"injured",
".",
"her",
"guns",
"and",
"equipment",
"were",
"salvage",
"##d",
",",
"but",
"the",
"ship",
"broke",
"in",
"two",
"and",
"was",
"abandoned",
"as",
"a",
"total",
"loss",
"."
] | 2,212 |
@ . @ 8 in ) , but increased to 64 mill ##imeters ( 2 @ . @ 5 in ) as it slope ##d down to the sides of the ship . sul ##ly was laid down at the forge ##s et chant ##iers de la med ##iter ##rane ##e shipyard in la se ##yne on 24 may 1899 and launched on 4 june 1901 . the ship was completed in june 1904 and sent to french indochina for her first commission . on 7 february 1905 sul ##ly struck a rock in ha long bay ; her crew was not injured . her guns and equipment were salvage ##d , but the ship broke in two and was abandoned as a total loss .
| 969 |
[
"=",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"=",
"norman",
"gary",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"(",
"born",
"december",
"8",
",",
"1953",
")",
"is",
"an",
"american",
"political",
"scientist",
",",
"activist",
",",
"professor",
",",
"and",
"author",
".",
"his",
"primary",
"fields",
"of",
"research",
"are",
"the",
"israeli",
"–",
"palestinian",
"conflict",
"and",
"the",
"politics",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
",",
"an",
"interest",
"motivated",
"by",
"the",
"experiences",
"of",
"his",
"parents",
"who",
"were",
"jewish",
"holocaust",
"survivors",
".",
"he",
"is",
"a",
"graduate",
"of",
"bingham",
"##ton",
"university",
"and",
"received",
"his",
"ph",
".",
"d",
"in",
"political",
"science",
"at",
"princeton",
"university",
".",
"he",
"has",
"held",
"faculty",
"positions",
"at",
"brooklyn",
"college",
",",
"rutgers",
"university",
",",
"hunter",
"college",
",",
"new",
"york",
"university",
",",
"and",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"university",
"where",
"he",
"was",
"an",
"assistant",
"professor",
"from",
"2001",
"to",
"2007",
".",
"in",
"2007",
",",
"after",
"a",
"highly"
] | 2,213 |
= norman fin ##kel ##stein = norman gary fin ##kel ##stein ( born december 8 , 1953 ) is an american political scientist , activist , professor , and author . his primary fields of research are the israeli – palestinian conflict and the politics of the holocaust , an interest motivated by the experiences of his parents who were jewish holocaust survivors . he is a graduate of bingham ##ton university and received his ph . d in political science at princeton university . he has held faculty positions at brooklyn college , rutgers university , hunter college , new york university , and de ##pa ##ul university where he was an assistant professor from 2001 to 2007 . in 2007 , after a highly
| 196 |
[
"publicized",
"feud",
"between",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"an",
"academic",
"opponent",
",",
"alan",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"tenure",
"bid",
"at",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"was",
"denied",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"was",
"placed",
"on",
"administrative",
"leave",
"for",
"the",
"2007",
"–",
"2008",
"academic",
"year",
",",
"and",
"on",
"september",
"5",
",",
"2007",
",",
"he",
"announced",
"his",
"resignation",
"after",
"coming",
"to",
"a",
"settlement",
"with",
"the",
"university",
"on",
"generally",
"undisclosed",
"terms",
".",
"an",
"official",
"statement",
"from",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"strongly",
"defended",
"the",
"decision",
"to",
"deny",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"tenure",
",",
"stated",
"that",
"outside",
"influence",
"played",
"no",
"role",
"in",
"the",
"decision",
".",
"in",
"2008",
",",
"he",
"was",
"banned",
"from",
"entering",
"israel",
"for",
"10",
"years",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"taught",
"at",
"sa",
"##kar",
"##ya",
"university",
"middle",
"east",
"institute",
"in",
"turkey"
] | 2,214 |
publicized feud between fin ##kel ##stein and an academic opponent , alan der ##sho ##witz , fin ##kel ##stein ' s tenure bid at de ##pa ##ul was denied . fin ##kel ##stein was placed on administrative leave for the 2007 – 2008 academic year , and on september 5 , 2007 , he announced his resignation after coming to a settlement with the university on generally undisclosed terms . an official statement from de ##pa ##ul strongly defended the decision to deny fin ##kel ##stein tenure , stated that outside influence played no role in the decision . in 2008 , he was banned from entering israel for 10 years . fin ##kel ##stein taught at sa ##kar ##ya university middle east institute in turkey
| 94 |
[
"between",
"2014",
"and",
"2015",
".",
"=",
"=",
"personal",
"background",
"and",
"education",
"=",
"=",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"written",
"of",
"his",
"jewish",
"parents",
"'",
"experiences",
"during",
"world",
"war",
"ii",
".",
"his",
"mother",
",",
"mary",
"##la",
"hu",
"##sy",
"##t",
",",
"grew",
"up",
"in",
"warsaw",
",",
"survived",
"the",
"warsaw",
"ghetto",
",",
"the",
"maj",
"##dan",
"##ek",
"concentration",
"camp",
",",
"and",
"two",
"slave",
"labor",
"camps",
".",
"her",
"first",
"husband",
"died",
"in",
"the",
"war",
".",
"she",
"considered",
"the",
"day",
"of",
"her",
"liberation",
"as",
"the",
"most",
"horrible",
"day",
"of",
"her",
"life",
",",
"as",
"she",
"realized",
"that",
"she",
"was",
"alone",
",",
"her",
"parents",
"and",
"siblings",
"gone",
".",
"norman",
"'",
"s",
"father",
",",
"zach",
"##aria",
"##s",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"active",
"in",
"hash",
"##ome",
"##r",
"hat",
"##zai",
"##r",
",",
"was",
"a",
"survivor",
"of",
"both",
"the"
] | 2,215 |
between 2014 and 2015 . = = personal background and education = = fin ##kel ##stein has written of his jewish parents ' experiences during world war ii . his mother , mary ##la hu ##sy ##t , grew up in warsaw , survived the warsaw ghetto , the maj ##dan ##ek concentration camp , and two slave labor camps . her first husband died in the war . she considered the day of her liberation as the most horrible day of her life , as she realized that she was alone , her parents and siblings gone . norman ' s father , zach ##aria ##s fin ##kel ##stein , active in hash ##ome ##r hat ##zai ##r , was a survivor of both the
| 250 |
[
"warsaw",
"ghetto",
"and",
"the",
"auschwitz",
"concentration",
"camp",
".",
"after",
"the",
"war",
"they",
"met",
"in",
"a",
"displaced",
"persons",
"camp",
"in",
"lin",
"##z",
",",
"austria",
",",
"and",
"then",
"emigrated",
"to",
"the",
"united",
"states",
",",
"where",
"his",
"father",
"became",
"a",
"factory",
"worker",
"and",
"his",
"mother",
"a",
"home",
"##maker",
"and",
"later",
"a",
"book",
"##keeper",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"mother",
"was",
"an",
"ardent",
"pac",
"##if",
"##ist",
".",
"both",
"his",
"parents",
"died",
"in",
"1995",
".",
"of",
"his",
"parents",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"recalled",
"that",
"\"",
"they",
"saw",
"the",
"world",
"through",
"the",
"prism",
"of",
"the",
"nazi",
"holocaust",
".",
"they",
"were",
"eternal",
"##ly",
"ind",
"##eb",
"##ted",
"to",
"the",
"soviet",
"union",
"(",
"to",
"whom",
"they",
"attributed",
"the",
"defeat",
"of",
"the",
"nazis",
")",
",",
"and",
"so",
"anyone",
"who",
"was",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@"
] | 2,216 |
warsaw ghetto and the auschwitz concentration camp . after the war they met in a displaced persons camp in lin ##z , austria , and then emigrated to the united states , where his father became a factory worker and his mother a home ##maker and later a book ##keeper . fin ##kel ##stein ' s mother was an ardent pac ##if ##ist . both his parents died in 1995 . of his parents , fin ##kel ##stein has recalled that " they saw the world through the prism of the nazi holocaust . they were eternal ##ly ind ##eb ##ted to the soviet union ( to whom they attributed the defeat of the nazis ) , and so anyone who was anti @ - @
| 250 |
[
"soviet",
"they",
"were",
"extremely",
"harsh",
"on",
"\"",
".",
"they",
"supported",
"the",
"soviet",
"union",
"'",
"s",
"approval",
"of",
"the",
"creation",
"of",
"the",
"state",
"of",
"israel",
",",
"as",
"en",
"##un",
"##cia",
"##ted",
"by",
"gr",
"##omy",
"##ko",
",",
"who",
"stated",
"that",
"the",
"jews",
"had",
"earned",
"the",
"right",
"to",
"a",
"state",
",",
"but",
"thought",
"that",
"israel",
"had",
"sold",
"its",
"soul",
"to",
"the",
"west",
"and",
"\"",
"refused",
"to",
"have",
"any",
"truck",
"with",
"it",
"\"",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"grew",
"up",
"in",
"borough",
"park",
",",
"then",
"mill",
"basin",
",",
"both",
"in",
"brooklyn",
",",
"new",
"york",
",",
"where",
"he",
"attended",
"james",
"madison",
"high",
"school",
".",
"in",
"his",
"memoir",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"recalls",
"his",
"strong",
"youthful",
"identification",
"with",
"the",
"outrage",
"that",
"his",
"mother",
",",
"witness",
"to",
"the",
"gen",
"##oc",
"##idal",
"atrocities",
"of",
"world"
] | 2,217 |
soviet they were extremely harsh on " . they supported the soviet union ' s approval of the creation of the state of israel , as en ##un ##cia ##ted by gr ##omy ##ko , who stated that the jews had earned the right to a state , but thought that israel had sold its soul to the west and " refused to have any truck with it " . fin ##kel ##stein grew up in borough park , then mill basin , both in brooklyn , new york , where he attended james madison high school . in his memoir , fin ##kel ##stein recalls his strong youthful identification with the outrage that his mother , witness to the gen ##oc ##idal atrocities of world
| 166 |
[
"war",
"ii",
",",
"felt",
"at",
"the",
"carnage",
"wrought",
"by",
"the",
"united",
"states",
"in",
"vietnam",
".",
"one",
"childhood",
"friend",
"recalls",
"his",
"mother",
"'",
"s",
"\"",
"emotional",
"investment",
"in",
"left",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"wing",
"humanitarian",
"causes",
"as",
"bordering",
"on",
"hysteria",
"\"",
".",
"he",
"had",
"\"",
"internal",
"##ized",
"[",
"her",
"]",
"ind",
"##ign",
"##ation",
"\"",
",",
"a",
"trait",
"which",
"he",
"admits",
"rendered",
"him",
"\"",
"ins",
"##uf",
"##fera",
"##ble",
"\"",
"when",
"talking",
"of",
"the",
"vietnam",
"war",
",",
"and",
"which",
"im",
"##bu",
"##ed",
"him",
"with",
"a",
"\"",
"ho",
"##lier",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"than",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"thou",
"\"",
"attitude",
"at",
"the",
"time",
"which",
"he",
"now",
"regrets",
".",
"but",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"regards",
"his",
"absorption",
"of",
"his",
"mother",
"'",
"s",
"outlook",
"—",
"the",
"refusal",
"to",
"put",
"aside",
"a",
"sense",
"of",
"moral",
"outrage"
] | 2,218 |
war ii , felt at the carnage wrought by the united states in vietnam . one childhood friend recalls his mother ' s " emotional investment in left @ - @ wing humanitarian causes as bordering on hysteria " . he had " internal ##ized [ her ] ind ##ign ##ation " , a trait which he admits rendered him " ins ##uf ##fera ##ble " when talking of the vietnam war , and which im ##bu ##ed him with a " ho ##lier @ - @ than @ - @ thou " attitude at the time which he now regrets . but fin ##kel ##stein regards his absorption of his mother ' s outlook — the refusal to put aside a sense of moral outrage
| 719 |
[
"in",
"order",
"to",
"get",
"on",
"with",
"one",
"'",
"s",
"life",
"—",
"as",
"a",
"virtue",
".",
"subsequently",
",",
"his",
"reading",
"of",
"no",
"##am",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
"played",
"an",
"important",
"role",
"in",
"tailor",
"##ing",
"the",
"passion",
"bequeathed",
"to",
"him",
"by",
"his",
"mother",
"to",
"the",
"necessity",
"of",
"maintaining",
"intellectual",
"rig",
"##or",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"completed",
"his",
"undergraduate",
"studies",
"at",
"bingham",
"##ton",
"university",
"in",
"new",
"york",
"in",
"1974",
",",
"after",
"which",
"he",
"studied",
"at",
"the",
"ecole",
"pr",
"##ati",
"##que",
"des",
"haute",
"##s",
"etudes",
"in",
"paris",
".",
"a",
"deep",
"admire",
"##r",
"of",
"paul",
"sw",
"##ee",
"##zy",
",",
"he",
"was",
"an",
"ardent",
"mao",
"##ist",
"and",
"was",
"devastated",
"by",
"the",
"news",
"of",
"the",
"trial",
"of",
"the",
"gang",
"of",
"four",
",",
"an",
"event",
"which",
"\"",
"totally",
"devastated",
"\"",
"him",
",",
"and",
"led",
"him"
] | 2,219 |
in order to get on with one ' s life — as a virtue . subsequently , his reading of no ##am cho ##ms ##ky played an important role in tailor ##ing the passion bequeathed to him by his mother to the necessity of maintaining intellectual rig ##or . fin ##kel ##stein completed his undergraduate studies at bingham ##ton university in new york in 1974 , after which he studied at the ecole pr ##ati ##que des haute ##s etudes in paris . a deep admire ##r of paul sw ##ee ##zy , he was an ardent mao ##ist and was devastated by the news of the trial of the gang of four , an event which " totally devastated " him , and led him
| 170 |
[
"to",
"abandon",
"marxism",
"–",
"lenin",
"##ism",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"received",
"his",
"master",
"'",
"s",
"degree",
"in",
"political",
"science",
"in",
"1980",
",",
"and",
"later",
"his",
"phd",
"in",
"political",
"studies",
",",
"from",
"princeton",
".",
"his",
"doctoral",
"thesis",
"was",
"on",
"zion",
"##ism",
".",
"before",
"gaining",
"academic",
"employment",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"was",
"a",
"part",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"time",
"social",
"worker",
"with",
"teenage",
"drop",
"##outs",
"in",
"new",
"york",
".",
"he",
"then",
"taught",
"successively",
"at",
"rutgers",
"university",
",",
"new",
"york",
"university",
",",
"brooklyn",
"college",
",",
"and",
"hunter",
"college",
"and",
"at",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"university",
"in",
"chicago",
".",
"during",
"the",
"first",
"int",
"##if",
"##ada",
",",
"he",
"spent",
"every",
"summer",
"from",
"1988",
"in",
"the",
"west",
"bank",
",",
"a",
"guest",
"of",
"palestinian",
"families",
"in",
"he",
"##bron",
"and",
"beit",
"sa",
"##ho",
"##ur",
".",
"according"
] | 2,220 |
to abandon marxism – lenin ##ism . fin ##kel ##stein received his master ' s degree in political science in 1980 , and later his phd in political studies , from princeton . his doctoral thesis was on zion ##ism . before gaining academic employment , fin ##kel ##stein was a part @ - @ time social worker with teenage drop ##outs in new york . he then taught successively at rutgers university , new york university , brooklyn college , and hunter college and at de ##pa ##ul university in chicago . during the first int ##if ##ada , he spent every summer from 1988 in the west bank , a guest of palestinian families in he ##bron and beit sa ##ho ##ur . according
| 194 |
[
"to",
"the",
"new",
"york",
"times",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"left",
"hunter",
"college",
"in",
"2001",
",",
"\"",
"after",
"his",
"teaching",
"load",
"and",
"salary",
"were",
"reduced",
"\"",
"by",
"the",
"college",
"administration",
".",
"in",
"his",
"own",
"rec",
"##oll",
"##ection",
",",
"he",
"enjoyed",
"teaching",
"at",
"hunter",
"(",
"1992",
"–",
"2000",
")",
"and",
"was",
"'",
"un",
"##cer",
"##emon",
"##iously",
"kicked",
"out",
"of",
"'",
"the",
"school",
"after",
"begging",
"them",
"to",
"keep",
"him",
"on",
"with",
"just",
"two",
"courses",
"a",
"semester",
"(",
"$",
"12",
"@",
",",
"@",
"000",
"a",
"year",
")",
".",
"hunter",
"set",
"conditions",
"that",
"would",
"have",
"required",
"him",
"to",
"spend",
"four",
"days",
"a",
"week",
",",
"which",
"he",
"thought",
"unacceptable",
".",
"beginning",
"with",
"his",
"doctoral",
"thesis",
"at",
"princeton",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"career",
"has",
"been",
"marked",
"by",
"controversy",
".",
"a",
"self"
] | 2,221 |
to the new york times , fin ##kel ##stein left hunter college in 2001 , " after his teaching load and salary were reduced " by the college administration . in his own rec ##oll ##ection , he enjoyed teaching at hunter ( 1992 – 2000 ) and was ' un ##cer ##emon ##iously kicked out of ' the school after begging them to keep him on with just two courses a semester ( $ 12 @ , @ 000 a year ) . hunter set conditions that would have required him to spend four days a week , which he thought unacceptable . beginning with his doctoral thesis at princeton , fin ##kel ##stein ' s career has been marked by controversy . a self
| 196 |
[
"@",
"-",
"@",
"described",
"\"",
"forensic",
"scholar",
"\"",
",",
"he",
"has",
"written",
"sharply",
"critical",
"academic",
"reviews",
"of",
"several",
"prominent",
"writers",
"and",
"scholars",
"whom",
"he",
"accuse",
"##s",
"of",
"mis",
"##re",
"##pres",
"##enting",
"the",
"documentary",
"record",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"defend",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"policies",
"and",
"practices",
".",
"his",
"writings",
"have",
"dealt",
"with",
"politically",
"charged",
"topics",
"such",
"as",
"zion",
"##ism",
",",
"the",
"demographic",
"history",
"of",
"palestine",
"and",
"his",
"allegations",
"of",
"the",
"existence",
"of",
"a",
"\"",
"holocaust",
"industry",
"\"",
"that",
"exploits",
"the",
"memory",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
"to",
"further",
"israeli",
"and",
"financial",
"interests",
".",
"citing",
"linguist",
"and",
"political",
"activist",
"no",
"##am",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
"as",
"an",
"example",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"notes",
"that",
"it",
"is",
"\"",
"possible",
"to",
"unite",
"exact",
"##ing",
"scholarly",
"rig",
"##or",
"with",
"sc",
"##athing",
"moral",
"outrage",
",",
"\""
] | 2,222 |
@ - @ described " forensic scholar " , he has written sharply critical academic reviews of several prominent writers and scholars whom he accuse ##s of mis ##re ##pres ##enting the documentary record in order to defend israel ' s policies and practices . his writings have dealt with politically charged topics such as zion ##ism , the demographic history of palestine and his allegations of the existence of a " holocaust industry " that exploits the memory of the holocaust to further israeli and financial interests . citing linguist and political activist no ##am cho ##ms ##ky as an example , fin ##kel ##stein notes that it is " possible to unite exact ##ing scholarly rig ##or with sc ##athing moral outrage , "
| 277 |
[
"and",
"supporters",
"and",
"det",
"##rac",
"##tors",
"alike",
"have",
"remarked",
"on",
"the",
"pole",
"##mic",
"##al",
"style",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"work",
".",
"its",
"content",
"has",
"been",
"praised",
"by",
"eminent",
"historians",
"such",
"as",
"raul",
"hi",
"##lberg",
"and",
"av",
"##i",
"sh",
"##lai",
"##m",
",",
"as",
"well",
"as",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"described",
"himself",
"as",
"\"",
"an",
"old",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"fashioned",
"communist",
",",
"\"",
"in",
"the",
"sense",
"that",
"he",
"\"",
"see",
"[",
"s",
"]",
"no",
"value",
"whatsoever",
"in",
"states",
".",
"\"",
"=",
"=",
"academic",
"career",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"on",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"in",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"doctoral",
"thesis",
",",
"he",
"examined",
"the",
"claims",
"made",
"in",
"joan",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me"
] | 2,223 |
and supporters and det ##rac ##tors alike have remarked on the pole ##mic ##al style of fin ##kel ##stein ' s work . its content has been praised by eminent historians such as raul hi ##lberg and av ##i sh ##lai ##m , as well as cho ##ms ##ky . fin ##kel ##stein has described himself as " an old @ - @ fashioned communist , " in the sense that he " see [ s ] no value whatsoever in states . " = = academic career = = = = = on from time im ##me ##mori ##al = = = in fin ##kel ##stein ' s doctoral thesis , he examined the claims made in joan peters ' s from time im ##me
| 94 |
[
"##mori",
"##al",
",",
"a",
"best",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"selling",
"book",
"at",
"the",
"time",
".",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"\"",
"history",
"and",
"defense",
"\"",
"of",
"israel",
"deals",
"with",
"the",
"demographic",
"history",
"of",
"palestine",
".",
"demographic",
"studies",
"had",
"tended",
"to",
"assert",
"that",
"the",
"arab",
"population",
"of",
"ottoman",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"controlled",
"palestine",
",",
"a",
"94",
"%",
"majority",
"at",
"the",
"turn",
"of",
"the",
"century",
",",
"had",
"d",
"##wind",
"##led",
"towards",
"par",
"##ity",
"due",
"to",
"massive",
"zionist",
"immigration",
".",
"peters",
"radically",
"challenged",
"this",
"picture",
"by",
"arguing",
"that",
"a",
"substantial",
"part",
"of",
"the",
"palestinian",
"people",
"were",
"descended",
"from",
"immigrants",
"from",
"other",
"arab",
"countries",
"from",
"the",
"early",
"19th",
"century",
"onwards",
".",
"it",
"followed",
",",
"for",
"peters",
"and",
"many",
"of",
"her",
"readers",
",",
"that",
"the",
"picture",
"of",
"a",
"native",
"palestinian",
"population",
"overwhelmed",
"by",
"jewish"
] | 2,224 |
##mori ##al , a best @ - @ selling book at the time . peters ' s " history and defense " of israel deals with the demographic history of palestine . demographic studies had tended to assert that the arab population of ottoman @ - @ controlled palestine , a 94 % majority at the turn of the century , had d ##wind ##led towards par ##ity due to massive zionist immigration . peters radically challenged this picture by arguing that a substantial part of the palestinian people were descended from immigrants from other arab countries from the early 19th century onwards . it followed , for peters and many of her readers , that the picture of a native palestinian population overwhelmed by jewish
| 313 |
[
"immigration",
"was",
"little",
"more",
"than",
"propaganda",
",",
"and",
"that",
"in",
"actual",
"##ity",
"two",
"almost",
"simultaneous",
"waves",
"of",
"immigration",
"met",
"in",
"what",
"had",
"been",
"a",
"relatively",
"un",
"##pop",
"##ulated",
"land",
".",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"had",
"been",
"praised",
"by",
"figures",
"as",
"varied",
"as",
"barbara",
"tu",
"##chman",
",",
"theodore",
"h",
".",
"white",
",",
"eli",
"##e",
"wi",
"##ese",
"##l",
",",
"and",
"lucy",
"da",
"##wi",
"##do",
"##wicz",
".",
"saul",
"bell",
"##ow",
",",
"for",
"one",
",",
"wrote",
"in",
"a",
"jacket",
"endorsement",
"that",
":",
"\"",
"millions",
"of",
"people",
"the",
"world",
"over",
",",
"sm",
"##oth",
"##ered",
"by",
"false",
"history",
"and",
"propaganda",
",",
"will",
"be",
"grateful",
"for",
"this",
"clear",
"account",
"of",
"the",
"origins",
"of",
"the",
"palestinians",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"asserted",
"that",
"the",
"book",
"was",
"a",
"\"",
"monumental",
"hoax",
"\"",
"."
] | 2,225 |
immigration was little more than propaganda , and that in actual ##ity two almost simultaneous waves of immigration met in what had been a relatively un ##pop ##ulated land . from time im ##me ##mori ##al had been praised by figures as varied as barbara tu ##chman , theodore h . white , eli ##e wi ##ese ##l , and lucy da ##wi ##do ##wicz . saul bell ##ow , for one , wrote in a jacket endorsement that : " millions of people the world over , sm ##oth ##ered by false history and propaganda , will be grateful for this clear account of the origins of the palestinians . " fin ##kel ##stein asserted that the book was a " monumental hoax " .
| 83 |
[
"he",
"later",
"opined",
"that",
",",
"while",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"received",
"widespread",
"interest",
"and",
"approval",
"in",
"the",
"united",
"states",
",",
"a",
"scholarly",
"demonstration",
"of",
"its",
"fraud",
"##ule",
"##nce",
"and",
"un",
"##rel",
"##ia",
"##bility",
"aroused",
"little",
"attention",
":",
"\"",
"by",
"the",
"end",
"of",
"1984",
",",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"had",
".",
".",
".",
"received",
"some",
"two",
"hundred",
"[",
"favorable",
"]",
"notices",
".",
".",
".",
"in",
"the",
"united",
"states",
".",
"the",
"only",
"'",
"false",
"'",
"notes",
"in",
"this",
"cr",
"##es",
"##cend",
"##oin",
"##g",
"chorus",
"of",
"praise",
"were",
"the",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"which",
"ran",
"a",
"highly",
"critical",
"review",
"by",
"bill",
"farrell",
";",
"the",
"small",
"chicago",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"based",
"newsweek",
"##ly",
"in",
"these",
"times",
",",
"which",
"published",
"a",
"condensed",
"version",
"of",
"this",
"writer",
"'",
"s"
] | 2,226 |
he later opined that , while peters ' s book received widespread interest and approval in the united states , a scholarly demonstration of its fraud ##ule ##nce and un ##rel ##ia ##bility aroused little attention : " by the end of 1984 , from time im ##me ##mori ##al had . . . received some two hundred [ favorable ] notices . . . in the united states . the only ' false ' notes in this cr ##es ##cend ##oin ##g chorus of praise were the journal of palestine studies , which ran a highly critical review by bill farrell ; the small chicago @ - @ based newsweek ##ly in these times , which published a condensed version of this writer ' s
| 98 |
[
"findings",
";",
"and",
"alexander",
"cock",
"##burn",
",",
"who",
"devoted",
"a",
"series",
"of",
"columns",
"in",
"the",
"nation",
"exposing",
"the",
"hoax",
".",
".",
".",
".",
"the",
"periodicals",
"in",
"which",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"had",
"already",
"been",
"favorably",
"reviewed",
"refused",
"to",
"run",
"any",
"critical",
"correspondence",
"(",
"e",
".",
"g",
".",
"the",
"new",
"republic",
",",
"the",
"atlantic",
"monthly",
",",
"commentary",
")",
".",
"periodicals",
"that",
"had",
"yet",
"to",
"review",
"the",
"book",
"rejected",
"a",
"manuscript",
"on",
"the",
"subject",
"as",
"of",
"little",
"or",
"no",
"consequence",
"(",
"e",
".",
"g",
".",
"the",
"village",
"voice",
",",
"dissent",
",",
"the",
"new",
"york",
"review",
"of",
"books",
")",
".",
"not",
"a",
"single",
"national",
"newspaper",
"or",
"columnist",
"contacted",
"found",
"news",
"##worthy",
"that",
"a",
"best",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"selling",
",",
"e",
"##ff",
"##us",
"##ively",
"praised",
"'",
"study",
"'"
] | 2,227 |
findings ; and alexander cock ##burn , who devoted a series of columns in the nation exposing the hoax . . . . the periodicals in which from time im ##me ##mori ##al had already been favorably reviewed refused to run any critical correspondence ( e . g . the new republic , the atlantic monthly , commentary ) . periodicals that had yet to review the book rejected a manuscript on the subject as of little or no consequence ( e . g . the village voice , dissent , the new york review of books ) . not a single national newspaper or columnist contacted found news ##worthy that a best @ - @ selling , e ##ff ##us ##ively praised ' study '
| 166 |
[
"of",
"the",
"middle",
"east",
"conflict",
"was",
"a",
"thread",
"##bar",
"##e",
"hoax",
".",
"\"",
"no",
"##am",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
"later",
"re",
"##mini",
"##sc",
"##ed",
":",
"\"",
"i",
"warned",
"him",
",",
"if",
"you",
"follow",
"this",
",",
"you",
"'",
"re",
"going",
"to",
"get",
"in",
"trouble",
"—",
"because",
"you",
"'",
"re",
"going",
"to",
"expose",
"the",
"american",
"intellectual",
"community",
"as",
"a",
"gang",
"of",
"fraud",
"##s",
",",
"and",
"they",
"are",
"not",
"going",
"to",
"like",
"it",
",",
"and",
"they",
"'",
"re",
"going",
"to",
"destroy",
"you",
".",
"\"",
"in",
"1986",
",",
"the",
"new",
"york",
"review",
"of",
"books",
"published",
"ye",
"##hosh",
"##ua",
"por",
"##ath",
"'",
"s",
"review",
"and",
"an",
"exchange",
"with",
"critics",
"of",
"the",
"review",
"in",
"which",
"he",
"criticized",
"the",
"assumptions",
"and",
"evidence",
"on",
"which",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"thesis",
"relied",
",",
"thus",
"lending",
"independent",
"support"
] | 2,228 |
of the middle east conflict was a thread ##bar ##e hoax . " no ##am cho ##ms ##ky later re ##mini ##sc ##ed : " i warned him , if you follow this , you ' re going to get in trouble — because you ' re going to expose the american intellectual community as a gang of fraud ##s , and they are not going to like it , and they ' re going to destroy you . " in 1986 , the new york review of books published ye ##hosh ##ua por ##ath ' s review and an exchange with critics of the review in which he criticized the assumptions and evidence on which peters ' s thesis relied , thus lending independent support
| 83 |
[
"from",
"an",
"expert",
"in",
"palestinian",
"demographics",
"to",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"doctoral",
"critique",
".",
"in",
"the",
"house",
"journal",
"of",
"the",
"american",
"council",
"on",
"foreign",
"relations",
",",
"foreign",
"affairs",
",",
"william",
"b",
".",
"quan",
"##dt",
",",
"the",
"edward",
"ste",
"##tti",
"##nius",
"professor",
"of",
"politics",
"at",
"the",
"university",
"of",
"virginia",
"and",
"authority",
"on",
"middle",
"eastern",
"politics",
",",
"later",
"described",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"critique",
"of",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"as",
"a",
"\"",
"landmark",
"essay",
"\"",
"and",
"a",
"\"",
"victory",
"to",
"his",
"credit",
"\"",
",",
"in",
"its",
"\"",
"demonstration",
"\"",
"of",
"the",
"\"",
"sho",
"##ddy",
"scholarship",
"\"",
"of",
"peters",
"'",
"book",
".",
"israeli",
"historian",
"av",
"##i",
"sh",
"##lai",
"##m",
"later",
"praised",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"thesis",
",",
"saying",
"that",
"it",
"had",
"established",
"his",
"credentials"
] | 2,229 |
from an expert in palestinian demographics to fin ##kel ##stein ' s doctoral critique . in the house journal of the american council on foreign relations , foreign affairs , william b . quan ##dt , the edward ste ##tti ##nius professor of politics at the university of virginia and authority on middle eastern politics , later described fin ##kel ##stein ' s critique of from time im ##me ##mori ##al as a " landmark essay " and a " victory to his credit " , in its " demonstration " of the " sho ##ddy scholarship " of peters ' book . israeli historian av ##i sh ##lai ##m later praised fin ##kel ##stein ' s thesis , saying that it had established his credentials
| 196 |
[
"when",
"he",
"was",
"still",
"a",
"doctoral",
"student",
".",
"in",
"sh",
"##lai",
"##m",
"'",
"s",
"view",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"had",
"produced",
"an",
"\"",
"una",
"##ns",
"##wer",
"##able",
"case",
"\"",
"with",
"\"",
"ir",
"##re",
"##fu",
"##table",
"evidence",
"\"",
",",
"proving",
"that",
"peters",
"'",
"book",
"was",
"both",
"\"",
"prep",
"##ost",
"##ero",
"##us",
"and",
"worthless",
"\"",
".",
"according",
"to",
"no",
"##am",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
",",
"the",
"controversy",
"that",
"surrounded",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"research",
"caused",
"a",
"delay",
"in",
"his",
"earning",
"his",
"ph",
".",
"d",
".",
"at",
"princeton",
"university",
".",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
"wrote",
"in",
"understanding",
"power",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"\"",
"literally",
"could",
"not",
"get",
"the",
"faculty",
"to",
"read",
"[",
"his",
"dissertation",
"]",
"\"",
"and",
"that",
"princeton",
"eventually",
"granted",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"his",
"doctorate",
"only",
"\"",
"out",
"of"
] | 2,230 |
when he was still a doctoral student . in sh ##lai ##m ' s view , fin ##kel ##stein had produced an " una ##ns ##wer ##able case " with " ir ##re ##fu ##table evidence " , proving that peters ' book was both " prep ##ost ##ero ##us and worthless " . according to no ##am cho ##ms ##ky , the controversy that surrounded fin ##kel ##stein ' s research caused a delay in his earning his ph . d . at princeton university . cho ##ms ##ky wrote in understanding power that fin ##kel ##stein " literally could not get the faculty to read [ his dissertation ] " and that princeton eventually granted fin ##kel ##stein his doctorate only " out of
| 196 |
[
"embarrassment",
"[",
"for",
"princeton",
"]",
"\"",
"but",
"refused",
"to",
"give",
"him",
"any",
"further",
"professional",
"backing",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"published",
"portions",
"of",
"his",
"thesis",
"in",
"the",
"following",
"publications",
":",
"\"",
"di",
"##sin",
"##form",
"##ation",
"and",
"the",
"palestine",
"question",
":",
"the",
"not",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"so",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"strange",
"case",
"of",
"joan",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
"\"",
",",
"chapter",
"2",
"of",
"blaming",
"the",
"victims",
":",
"spur",
"##ious",
"scholarship",
"and",
"the",
"palestinian",
"question",
"(",
"1988",
")",
";",
"and",
"\"",
"a",
"land",
"without",
"a",
"people",
"(",
"joan",
"peters",
"'",
"\"",
"wilderness",
"\"",
"image",
")",
"\"",
",",
"chapter",
"2",
"of",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"of",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
"(",
"1995",
")",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
"=",
"=",
"="
] | 2,231 |
embarrassment [ for princeton ] " but refused to give him any further professional backing . fin ##kel ##stein published portions of his thesis in the following publications : " di ##sin ##form ##ation and the palestine question : the not @ - @ so @ - @ strange case of joan peters ' s from time im ##me ##mori ##al " , chapter 2 of blaming the victims : spur ##ious scholarship and the palestinian question ( 1988 ) ; and " a land without a people ( joan peters ' " wilderness " image ) " , chapter 2 of image and reality of the israel @ - @ palestine conflict ( 1995 ) . = = = the holocaust industry = = =
| 166 |
[
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
":",
"reflections",
"on",
"the",
"exploitation",
"of",
"jewish",
"suffering",
"was",
"published",
"in",
"2000",
".",
"here",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"argues",
"that",
"eli",
"##e",
"wi",
"##ese",
"##l",
"and",
"others",
"exploit",
"the",
"memory",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
"as",
"an",
"\"",
"ideological",
"weapon",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"purpose",
",",
"writes",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"is",
"to",
"enable",
"the",
"state",
"of",
"israel",
",",
"\"",
"one",
"of",
"the",
"world",
"'",
"s",
"most",
"formidable",
"military",
"powers",
",",
"with",
"a",
"ho",
"##rre",
"##ndo",
"##us",
"human",
"rights",
"record",
",",
"[",
"to",
"]",
"cast",
"itself",
"as",
"a",
"victim",
"state",
";",
"\"",
"that",
"is",
",",
"to",
"provide",
"israel",
"\"",
"immunity",
"to",
"criticism",
".",
"\"",
"he",
"all",
"##ege",
"##s",
"what",
"he",
"calls",
"a",
"\"",
"double",
"shake",
"##down",
"\"",
"by",
"\"",
"a",
"rep",
"##elle",
"##nt",
"gang",
"of",
"pluto"
] | 2,232 |
the holocaust industry : reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering was published in 2000 . here , fin ##kel ##stein argues that eli ##e wi ##ese ##l and others exploit the memory of the holocaust as an " ideological weapon . " the purpose , writes fin ##kel ##stein , is to enable the state of israel , " one of the world ' s most formidable military powers , with a ho ##rre ##ndo ##us human rights record , [ to ] cast itself as a victim state ; " that is , to provide israel " immunity to criticism . " he all ##ege ##s what he calls a " double shake ##down " by " a rep ##elle ##nt gang of pluto
| 94 |
[
"##crats",
",",
"hood",
"##lum",
"##s",
"and",
"hu",
"##cks",
"##ters",
"\"",
"seeking",
"enormous",
"legal",
"damages",
"and",
"financial",
"settlements",
"from",
"germany",
"and",
"switzerland",
",",
"money",
"##s",
"which",
"then",
"go",
"to",
"the",
"lawyers",
"and",
"institutional",
"actors",
"involved",
"in",
"pro",
"##cu",
"##ring",
"them",
",",
"rather",
"than",
"actual",
"holocaust",
"survivors",
".",
"the",
"book",
"received",
"a",
"hostile",
"reception",
"in",
"some",
"quarters",
",",
"with",
"critics",
"charging",
"that",
"it",
"was",
"poorly",
"researched",
"and",
"/",
"or",
"allowed",
"others",
"to",
"exploit",
"it",
"for",
"anti",
"##se",
"##mit",
"##ic",
"purposes",
".",
"the",
"german",
"historian",
"hans",
"mom",
"##ms",
"##en",
"di",
"##spar",
"##aged",
"the",
"first",
"edition",
"as",
"\"",
"a",
"most",
"trivial",
"book",
",",
"which",
"appeals",
"to",
"easily",
"aroused",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"semitic",
"prejudice",
"##s",
"\"",
".",
"israeli",
"holocaust",
"historian",
"israel",
"gut",
"##man",
"called",
"the",
"book",
"\"",
"a",
"lamp",
"##oon"
] | 2,233 |
##crats , hood ##lum ##s and hu ##cks ##ters " seeking enormous legal damages and financial settlements from germany and switzerland , money ##s which then go to the lawyers and institutional actors involved in pro ##cu ##ring them , rather than actual holocaust survivors . the book received a hostile reception in some quarters , with critics charging that it was poorly researched and / or allowed others to exploit it for anti ##se ##mit ##ic purposes . the german historian hans mom ##ms ##en di ##spar ##aged the first edition as " a most trivial book , which appeals to easily aroused anti @ - @ semitic prejudice ##s " . israeli holocaust historian israel gut ##man called the book " a lamp ##oon
| 4 |
[
"\"",
",",
"stating",
"\"",
"this",
"is",
"not",
"research",
";",
"it",
"isn",
"'",
"t",
"even",
"political",
"literature",
".",
".",
".",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"even",
"think",
"it",
"should",
"be",
"reviewed",
"or",
"critique",
"##d",
"as",
"a",
"legitimate",
"book",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"book",
"was",
"also",
"harshly",
"criticized",
"by",
"brown",
"university",
"professor",
"om",
"##er",
"bart",
"##ov",
"and",
"university",
"of",
"chicago",
"professor",
"peter",
"novi",
"##ck",
".",
"however",
",",
"pre",
"##emi",
"##nent",
"holocaust",
"scholar",
"raul",
"hi",
"##lberg",
"said",
"the",
"book",
"expressed",
"views",
"hi",
"##lberg",
"himself",
"sub",
"##scribe",
"##d",
"to",
"in",
"substance",
",",
"in",
"that",
"he",
"too",
"found",
"the",
"exploitation",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
",",
"as",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"describes",
",",
"\"",
"det",
"##est",
"##able",
"\"",
".",
"asked",
"on",
"another",
"occasion",
"if",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"analysis",
"might",
"play",
"into",
"the",
"hands",
"of"
] | 2,234 |
" , stating " this is not research ; it isn ' t even political literature . . . i don ' t even think it should be reviewed or critique ##d as a legitimate book . " the book was also harshly criticized by brown university professor om ##er bart ##ov and university of chicago professor peter novi ##ck . however , pre ##emi ##nent holocaust scholar raul hi ##lberg said the book expressed views hi ##lberg himself sub ##scribe ##d to in substance , in that he too found the exploitation of the holocaust , as fin ##kel ##stein describes , " det ##est ##able " . asked on another occasion if fin ##kel ##stein ' s analysis might play into the hands of
| 718 |
[
"neo",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"nazis",
"for",
"anti",
"##se",
"##mit",
"##ic",
"purposes",
",",
"hi",
"##lberg",
"replied",
":",
"\"",
"well",
",",
"even",
"if",
"they",
"do",
"use",
"it",
"in",
"that",
"fashion",
",",
"i",
"'",
"m",
"afraid",
"that",
"when",
"it",
"comes",
"to",
"the",
"truth",
",",
"it",
"has",
"to",
"be",
"said",
"openly",
",",
"without",
"regard",
"to",
"any",
"consequences",
"that",
"would",
"be",
"und",
"##es",
"##ira",
"##ble",
",",
"embarrassing",
"\"",
".",
"other",
"critics",
"claim",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"evidence",
"is",
"highly",
"selective",
"and",
"/",
"or",
"dubious",
"and",
"that",
"his",
"arguments",
"would",
"be",
"based",
"on",
"a",
"mis",
"##int",
"##er",
"##pre",
"##tation",
"of",
"history",
"and",
"a",
"questionable",
"use",
"of",
"sources",
".",
"the",
"historian",
"david",
"cesar",
"##ani",
"wrote",
"that",
"while",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"abs",
"##ol",
"##ves",
"swiss",
"banks",
"of",
"serious",
"misconduct",
"towards",
"holocaust",
"survivors",
"and"
] | 2,235 |
neo @ - @ nazis for anti ##se ##mit ##ic purposes , hi ##lberg replied : " well , even if they do use it in that fashion , i ' m afraid that when it comes to the truth , it has to be said openly , without regard to any consequences that would be und ##es ##ira ##ble , embarrassing " . other critics claim fin ##kel ##stein ' s evidence is highly selective and / or dubious and that his arguments would be based on a mis ##int ##er ##pre ##tation of history and a questionable use of sources . the historian david cesar ##ani wrote that while fin ##kel ##stein abs ##ol ##ves swiss banks of serious misconduct towards holocaust survivors and
| 2 |
[
"depicts",
"them",
"as",
"victims",
"of",
"a",
"jewish",
"terror",
"based",
"on",
"a",
"sentence",
"from",
"an",
"important",
"report",
"annex",
",",
"he",
"had",
"ignored",
"the",
"report",
"body",
"which",
"describes",
"dec",
"##eit",
"##ful",
"actions",
"by",
"swiss",
"banks",
",",
"inappropriate",
"closing",
"of",
"accounts",
",",
"failure",
"to",
"keep",
"adequate",
"records",
",",
"and",
"so",
"on",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"criticism",
"of",
"alan",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"'",
"s",
"the",
"case",
"for",
"israel",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"shortly",
"after",
"the",
"publication",
"of",
"the",
"book",
"the",
"case",
"for",
"israel",
"by",
"alan",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"der",
"##ided",
"it",
"as",
"\"",
"a",
"collection",
"of",
"fraud",
",",
"fa",
"##ls",
"##ification",
",",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
",",
"and",
"nonsense",
"\"",
".",
"during",
"a",
"debate",
"on",
"democracy",
"now",
"!",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"asserted",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz"
] | 2,236 |
depicts them as victims of a jewish terror based on a sentence from an important report annex , he had ignored the report body which describes dec ##eit ##ful actions by swiss banks , inappropriate closing of accounts , failure to keep adequate records , and so on . = = = criticism of alan der ##sho ##witz ' s the case for israel = = = shortly after the publication of the book the case for israel by alan der ##sho ##witz , fin ##kel ##stein der ##ided it as " a collection of fraud , fa ##ls ##ification , pl ##agi ##aris ##m , and nonsense " . during a debate on democracy now ! , fin ##kel ##stein asserted that der ##sho ##witz
| 94 |
[
"lacked",
"knowledge",
"about",
"specific",
"contents",
"of",
"his",
"own",
"book",
".",
"he",
"also",
"claimed",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"did",
"not",
"write",
"the",
"book",
",",
"and",
"may",
"not",
"have",
"even",
"read",
"it",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"noted",
"20",
"instances",
",",
"in",
"as",
"many",
"pages",
",",
"where",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"cites",
"the",
"same",
"sources",
"and",
"passages",
"used",
"by",
"joan",
"peters",
"in",
"her",
"book",
",",
"in",
"largely",
"the",
"same",
"sequence",
",",
"with",
"el",
"##lip",
"##ses",
"in",
"the",
"same",
"places",
".",
"in",
"two",
"instances",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"reproduce",
"##s",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"errors",
"(",
"see",
"below",
")",
".",
"from",
"this",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"concluded",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"had",
"not",
"checked",
"the",
"original",
"sources",
"himself",
",",
"contrary",
"to",
"the",
"latter",
"'",
"s",
"claims",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein"
] | 2,237 |
lacked knowledge about specific contents of his own book . he also claimed that der ##sho ##witz did not write the book , and may not have even read it . fin ##kel ##stein noted 20 instances , in as many pages , where der ##sho ##witz ' s book cites the same sources and passages used by joan peters in her book , in largely the same sequence , with el ##lip ##ses in the same places . in two instances , der ##sho ##witz reproduce ##s peters ' s errors ( see below ) . from this fin ##kel ##stein concluded that der ##sho ##witz had not checked the original sources himself , contrary to the latter ' s claims . fin ##kel ##stein
| 2 |
[
"suggests",
"that",
"this",
"copying",
"of",
"quota",
"##tions",
"amounts",
"to",
"copying",
"ideas",
".",
"examining",
"a",
"copy",
"of",
"a",
"proof",
"of",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"he",
"managed",
"to",
"obtain",
",",
"he",
"found",
"evidence",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"had",
"his",
"secret",
"##aria",
"##l",
"assistant",
",",
"holly",
"beth",
"billing",
"##ton",
",",
"check",
"in",
"the",
"harvard",
"library",
"the",
"sources",
"he",
"had",
"read",
"in",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"book",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"answered",
"the",
"charge",
"in",
"a",
"letter",
"to",
"the",
"university",
"of",
"california",
"'",
"s",
"press",
"director",
"lynne",
"with",
"##ey",
",",
"arguing",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"had",
"made",
"up",
"the",
"smoking",
"gun",
"quota",
"##tion",
",",
"in",
"that",
"he",
"had",
"changed",
"its",
"word",
"##ing",
"(",
"from",
"'",
"cite",
"'",
"to",
"'",
"copy",
"'",
")",
"in",
"his",
"book",
".",
"in",
"public",
"debate"
] | 2,238 |
suggests that this copying of quota ##tions amounts to copying ideas . examining a copy of a proof of der ##sho ##witz ' s book he managed to obtain , he found evidence that der ##sho ##witz had his secret ##aria ##l assistant , holly beth billing ##ton , check in the harvard library the sources he had read in peters ' s book . der ##sho ##witz answered the charge in a letter to the university of california ' s press director lynne with ##ey , arguing that fin ##kel ##stein had made up the smoking gun quota ##tion , in that he had changed its word ##ing ( from ' cite ' to ' copy ' ) in his book . in public debate
| 267 |
[
"he",
"has",
"stated",
"that",
"if",
"\"",
"somebody",
"borrowed",
"the",
"quote",
"without",
"going",
"to",
"check",
"back",
"on",
"whether",
"mark",
"twain",
"had",
"said",
"that",
",",
"obviously",
"that",
"would",
"be",
"a",
"serious",
"charge",
"\"",
";",
"however",
",",
"he",
"insisted",
"em",
"##pha",
"##tically",
"that",
"he",
"himself",
"did",
"not",
"do",
"that",
",",
"that",
"he",
"had",
"indeed",
"checked",
"the",
"original",
"source",
"by",
"twain",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"threatened",
"libel",
"action",
"over",
"the",
"charges",
"in",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"book",
",",
"as",
"a",
"consequence",
"of",
"which",
",",
"the",
"publisher",
"deleted",
"the",
"word",
"\"",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
"\"",
"from",
"the",
"text",
"before",
"publication",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"agreed",
"to",
"remove",
"the",
"suggestion",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"was",
"not",
"the",
"true",
"author",
"of",
"the",
"case",
"for",
"israel",
"because",
",",
"as",
"the",
"publisher",
"said"
] | 2,239 |
he has stated that if " somebody borrowed the quote without going to check back on whether mark twain had said that , obviously that would be a serious charge " ; however , he insisted em ##pha ##tically that he himself did not do that , that he had indeed checked the original source by twain . der ##sho ##witz threatened libel action over the charges in fin ##kel ##stein ' s book , as a consequence of which , the publisher deleted the word " pl ##agi ##aris ##m " from the text before publication . fin ##kel ##stein agreed to remove the suggestion that der ##sho ##witz was not the true author of the case for israel because , as the publisher said
| 267 |
[
",",
"\"",
"he",
"couldn",
"'",
"t",
"document",
"that",
"\"",
".",
"asserting",
"that",
"he",
"did",
"consult",
"the",
"original",
"sources",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"said",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"is",
"simply",
"accusing",
"him",
"of",
"good",
"scholarly",
"practice",
":",
"citing",
"references",
"he",
"learned",
"of",
"initially",
"from",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"book",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"denies",
"that",
"he",
"used",
"any",
"of",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"ideas",
"without",
"citation",
".",
"\"",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
"is",
"taking",
"someone",
"else",
"'",
"s",
"words",
"and",
"claiming",
"they",
"'",
"re",
"your",
"own",
".",
"there",
"are",
"no",
"borrowed",
"words",
"from",
"anybody",
".",
"there",
"are",
"no",
"borrowed",
"ideas",
"from",
"anybody",
"because",
"i",
"fundamentally",
"disagree",
"with",
"the",
"conclusions",
"of",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"book",
".",
"\"",
"in",
"a",
"foot",
"##note",
"in",
"the",
"case",
"for",
"israel",
"which",
"cites",
"peters",
"'",
"s"
] | 2,240 |
, " he couldn ' t document that " . asserting that he did consult the original sources , der ##sho ##witz said fin ##kel ##stein is simply accusing him of good scholarly practice : citing references he learned of initially from peters ' s book . der ##sho ##witz denies that he used any of peters ' s ideas without citation . " pl ##agi ##aris ##m is taking someone else ' s words and claiming they ' re your own . there are no borrowed words from anybody . there are no borrowed ideas from anybody because i fundamentally disagree with the conclusions of peters ' s book . " in a foot ##note in the case for israel which cites peters ' s
| 702 |
[
"book",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"explicitly",
"denies",
"that",
"he",
"\"",
"relies",
"\"",
"on",
"peters",
"for",
"\"",
"conclusions",
"or",
"data",
"\"",
".",
"in",
"their",
"joint",
"interview",
"on",
"democracy",
"now",
",",
"however",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"cited",
"specific",
"passages",
"in",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"in",
"which",
"a",
"phrase",
"that",
"he",
"says",
"peters",
"coined",
"was",
"incorrectly",
"attributed",
"to",
"george",
"or",
"##well",
":",
"\"",
"[",
"peters",
"]",
"coins",
"the",
"phrase",
",",
"'",
"turns",
"##pe",
"##ak",
"'",
",",
"she",
"says",
"she",
"'",
"s",
"using",
"it",
"as",
"a",
"play",
"off",
"of",
"george",
"or",
"##well",
"which",
"as",
"all",
"listeners",
"know",
"used",
"the",
"phrase",
"'",
"news",
"##pe",
"##ak",
".",
"'",
"she",
"coined",
"her",
"own",
"phrase",
",",
"'",
"turns",
"##pe",
"##ak",
"'",
".",
"you",
"go",
"to",
"mr",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"'",
"s"
] | 2,241 |
book , der ##sho ##witz explicitly denies that he " relies " on peters for " conclusions or data " . in their joint interview on democracy now , however , fin ##kel ##stein cited specific passages in der ##sho ##witz ' s book in which a phrase that he says peters coined was incorrectly attributed to george or ##well : " [ peters ] coins the phrase , ' turns ##pe ##ak ' , she says she ' s using it as a play off of george or ##well which as all listeners know used the phrase ' news ##pe ##ak . ' she coined her own phrase , ' turns ##pe ##ak ' . you go to mr . der ##sho ##witz ' s
| 719 |
[
"book",
",",
"he",
"got",
"so",
"confused",
"in",
"his",
"massive",
"borrowing",
"##s",
"from",
"joan",
"peters",
"that",
"on",
"two",
"occasions",
",",
"i",
"'",
"ll",
"cite",
"them",
"for",
"those",
"who",
"have",
"a",
"copy",
"of",
"the",
"book",
",",
"on",
"page",
"57",
"and",
"on",
"page",
"153",
"he",
"uses",
"the",
"phrase",
",",
"quote",
",",
"george",
"or",
"##well",
"'",
"s",
"'",
"turns",
"##pe",
"##ak",
"'",
".",
"'",
"turns",
"##pe",
"##ak",
"'",
"is",
"not",
"or",
"##well",
",",
"mr",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"you",
"'",
"re",
"the",
"felix",
"frankfurt",
"##er",
"chair",
"at",
"harvard",
",",
"you",
"must",
"know",
"that",
"or",
"##well",
"would",
"never",
"use",
"such",
"a",
"cl",
"##unk",
"##y",
"phrase",
"as",
"'",
"turns",
"##pe",
"##ak",
"'",
"\"",
".",
"james",
"o",
".",
"freed",
"##man",
",",
"the",
"former",
"president",
"of",
"dartmouth",
"college",
",",
"the",
"university",
"of",
"iowa"
] | 2,242 |
book , he got so confused in his massive borrowing ##s from joan peters that on two occasions , i ' ll cite them for those who have a copy of the book , on page 57 and on page 153 he uses the phrase , quote , george or ##well ' s ' turns ##pe ##ak ' . ' turns ##pe ##ak ' is not or ##well , mr . der ##sho ##witz , you ' re the felix frankfurt ##er chair at harvard , you must know that or ##well would never use such a cl ##unk ##y phrase as ' turns ##pe ##ak ' " . james o . freed ##man , the former president of dartmouth college , the university of iowa
| 775 |
[
",",
"and",
"the",
"american",
"academy",
"of",
"arts",
"and",
"sciences",
",",
"has",
"defended",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
":",
"i",
"do",
"not",
"understand",
"[",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"]",
"charge",
"of",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
"against",
"alan",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
".",
"there",
"is",
"no",
"claim",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"used",
"the",
"words",
"of",
"others",
"without",
"at",
"##tri",
"##bution",
".",
"when",
"he",
"uses",
"the",
"words",
"of",
"others",
",",
"he",
"quotes",
"them",
"properly",
"and",
"generally",
"cites",
"them",
"to",
"the",
"original",
"sources",
"(",
"mark",
"twain",
",",
"palestine",
"royal",
"commission",
",",
"etc",
".",
")",
"[",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"]",
"complaint",
"is",
"that",
"instead",
"he",
"should",
"have",
"cited",
"them",
"to",
"the",
"secondary",
"source",
",",
"in",
"which",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"may",
"have",
"come",
"upon",
"them",
".",
"but",
"as",
"the",
"chicago",
"manual",
"of"
] | 2,243 |
, and the american academy of arts and sciences , has defended der ##sho ##witz : i do not understand [ fin ##kel ##stein ' s ] charge of pl ##agi ##aris ##m against alan der ##sho ##witz . there is no claim that der ##sho ##witz used the words of others without at ##tri ##bution . when he uses the words of others , he quotes them properly and generally cites them to the original sources ( mark twain , palestine royal commission , etc . ) [ fin ##kel ##stein ' s ] complaint is that instead he should have cited them to the secondary source , in which der ##sho ##witz may have come upon them . but as the chicago manual of
| 273 |
[
"style",
"emphasizes",
":",
"'",
"importance",
"of",
"at",
"##tri",
"##bution",
".",
"with",
"all",
"re",
"##use",
"of",
"others",
"'",
"materials",
",",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"to",
"identify",
"the",
"original",
"as",
"the",
"source",
".",
"this",
"not",
"only",
"bo",
"##lster",
"##s",
"the",
"claims",
"of",
"fair",
"use",
",",
"it",
"also",
"helps",
"avoid",
"any",
"accusation",
"of",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
".",
"'",
"this",
"is",
"precisely",
"what",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"did",
".",
"responding",
"to",
"an",
"article",
"in",
"the",
"nation",
"by",
"alexander",
"cock",
"##burn",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"also",
"cited",
"the",
"chicago",
"manual",
"of",
"style",
":",
"cock",
"##burn",
"'",
"s",
"claim",
"is",
"that",
"some",
"of",
"the",
"quotes",
"should",
"not",
"have",
"been",
"cited",
"to",
"their",
"original",
"sources",
"but",
"rather",
"to",
"a",
"secondary",
"source",
",",
"where",
"he",
"believes",
"i",
"stumbled",
"upon",
"them",
".",
"even",
"if",
"he",
"were"
] | 2,244 |
style emphasizes : ' importance of at ##tri ##bution . with all re ##use of others ' materials , it is important to identify the original as the source . this not only bo ##lster ##s the claims of fair use , it also helps avoid any accusation of pl ##agi ##aris ##m . ' this is precisely what der ##sho ##witz did . responding to an article in the nation by alexander cock ##burn , der ##sho ##witz also cited the chicago manual of style : cock ##burn ' s claim is that some of the quotes should not have been cited to their original sources but rather to a secondary source , where he believes i stumbled upon them . even if he were
| 2 |
[
"correct",
"that",
"i",
"found",
"all",
"these",
"quota",
"##tions",
"in",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"book",
",",
"the",
"preferred",
"method",
"of",
"citation",
"is",
"to",
"the",
"original",
"source",
",",
"as",
"the",
"chicago",
"manual",
"of",
"style",
"emphasizes",
":",
"\"",
"with",
"all",
"re",
"##use",
"of",
"others",
"'",
"materials",
",",
"it",
"is",
"important",
"to",
"identify",
"the",
"original",
"as",
"the",
"source",
".",
"this",
".",
".",
".",
"helps",
"avoid",
"any",
"accusation",
"of",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
".",
".",
".",
"to",
"cite",
"a",
"source",
"from",
"a",
"secondary",
"source",
"(",
"'",
"quoted",
"in",
".",
".",
".",
"'",
")",
"is",
"generally",
"to",
"be",
"discouraged",
".",
".",
".",
".",
"\"",
".",
".",
".",
"to",
"which",
"cock",
"##burn",
"responded",
":",
"quoting",
"the",
"chicago",
"manual",
"of",
"style",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"art",
"##fully",
"implies",
"that",
"he",
"followed",
"the",
"rules",
"by",
"citing"
] | 2,245 |
correct that i found all these quota ##tions in peters ' s book , the preferred method of citation is to the original source , as the chicago manual of style emphasizes : " with all re ##use of others ' materials , it is important to identify the original as the source . this . . . helps avoid any accusation of pl ##agi ##aris ##m . . . to cite a source from a secondary source ( ' quoted in . . . ' ) is generally to be discouraged . . . . " . . . to which cock ##burn responded : quoting the chicago manual of style , der ##sho ##witz art ##fully implies that he followed the rules by citing
| 268 |
[
"\"",
"the",
"original",
"\"",
"as",
"opposed",
"to",
"the",
"secondary",
"source",
",",
"peters",
".",
"he",
"mis",
"##re",
"##pres",
"##ents",
"chicago",
"here",
",",
"where",
"\"",
"the",
"original",
"\"",
"means",
"merely",
"the",
"origin",
"of",
"the",
"borrowed",
"material",
",",
"which",
"is",
",",
"in",
"this",
"instance",
",",
"peters",
".",
"now",
"look",
"at",
"the",
"second",
"bit",
"of",
"the",
"quote",
"from",
"chicago",
",",
"cha",
"##ste",
"##ly",
"separated",
"from",
"the",
"preceding",
"sentence",
"by",
"a",
"dem",
"##ure",
"three",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"point",
"el",
"##lip",
"##sis",
".",
"as",
"my",
"associate",
"kate",
"levin",
"has",
"discovered",
",",
"this",
"passage",
"(",
"\"",
"to",
"cite",
"a",
"source",
"from",
"a",
"secondary",
"source",
".",
".",
".",
"\"",
")",
"occurs",
"on",
"page",
"72",
"##7",
",",
"which",
"is",
"no",
"less",
"than",
"590",
"pages",
"later",
"than",
"the",
"material",
"before",
"the",
"el",
"##lip",
"##sis",
",",
"in"
] | 2,246 |
" the original " as opposed to the secondary source , peters . he mis ##re ##pres ##ents chicago here , where " the original " means merely the origin of the borrowed material , which is , in this instance , peters . now look at the second bit of the quote from chicago , cha ##ste ##ly separated from the preceding sentence by a dem ##ure three @ - @ point el ##lip ##sis . as my associate kate levin has discovered , this passage ( " to cite a source from a secondary source . . . " ) occurs on page 72 ##7 , which is no less than 590 pages later than the material before the el ##lip ##sis , in
| 548 |
[
"a",
"section",
"titled",
"\"",
"citations",
"taken",
"from",
"secondary",
"sources",
".",
"\"",
"here",
"'",
"s",
"the",
"full",
"quote",
",",
"with",
"what",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"left",
"out",
"set",
"in",
"bold",
":",
"\"",
"'",
"quoted",
"in",
"'",
".",
"to",
"cite",
"a",
"source",
"from",
"a",
"secondary",
"source",
"(",
"\"",
"quoted",
"in",
"\"",
")",
"is",
"generally",
"to",
"be",
"discouraged",
",",
"since",
"authors",
"are",
"expected",
"to",
"have",
"examined",
"the",
"works",
"they",
"cite",
".",
"if",
"an",
"original",
"source",
"is",
"unavailable",
",",
"however",
",",
"both",
"the",
"original",
"and",
"the",
"secondary",
"source",
"must",
"be",
"listed",
".",
"\"",
"so",
"chicago",
"is",
"clearly",
"insisting",
"that",
"unless",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"went",
"to",
"the",
"originals",
",",
"he",
"was",
"obliged",
"to",
"cite",
"peters",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"con",
"##clusive",
"##ly",
"demonstrated",
"that",
"he",
"didn",
"'",
"t",
"go",
"to",
"the"
] | 2,247 |
a section titled " citations taken from secondary sources . " here ' s the full quote , with what der ##sho ##witz left out set in bold : " ' quoted in ' . to cite a source from a secondary source ( " quoted in " ) is generally to be discouraged , since authors are expected to have examined the works they cite . if an original source is unavailable , however , both the original and the secondary source must be listed . " so chicago is clearly insisting that unless der ##sho ##witz went to the originals , he was obliged to cite peters . fin ##kel ##stein has con ##clusive ##ly demonstrated that he didn ' t go to the
| 2 |
[
"originals",
".",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
",",
"q",
"##ed",
",",
"plus",
"added",
"time",
"for",
"will",
"##ful",
"distortion",
"of",
"the",
"language",
"of",
"chicago",
"'",
"s",
"guidelines",
",",
"cobb",
"##ling",
"together",
"two",
"separate",
"discussions",
".",
"on",
"behalf",
"of",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"harvard",
"law",
"school",
"dean",
"elena",
"ka",
"##gan",
"asked",
"former",
"harvard",
"president",
"derek",
"bo",
"##k",
"to",
"investigate",
"the",
"assertion",
"of",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##aris",
"##m",
";",
"bo",
"##k",
"ex",
"##one",
"##rated",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"of",
"the",
"charge",
".",
"in",
"an",
"april",
"3",
",",
"2007",
"interview",
"with",
"the",
"harvard",
"crimson",
",",
"\"",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"confirmed",
"that",
"he",
"had",
"sent",
"a",
"letter",
"last",
"september",
"to",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"faculty",
"members",
"lobbying",
"against",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"tenure",
".",
"\"",
"in",
"april",
"2007",
",",
"dr",
".",
"frank",
"men",
"##et"
] | 2,248 |
originals . pl ##agi ##aris ##m , q ##ed , plus added time for will ##ful distortion of the language of chicago ' s guidelines , cobb ##ling together two separate discussions . on behalf of der ##sho ##witz , harvard law school dean elena ka ##gan asked former harvard president derek bo ##k to investigate the assertion of pl ##agi ##aris ##m ; bo ##k ex ##one ##rated der ##sho ##witz of the charge . in an april 3 , 2007 interview with the harvard crimson , " der ##sho ##witz confirmed that he had sent a letter last september to de ##pa ##ul faculty members lobbying against fin ##kel ##stein ' s tenure . " in april 2007 , dr . frank men ##et
| 196 |
[
"##re",
"##z",
",",
"a",
"former",
"editor",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"in",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"chief",
"of",
"the",
"ucla",
"law",
"review",
",",
"published",
"an",
"analysis",
"of",
"the",
"charges",
"made",
"against",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"by",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"finding",
"no",
"merit",
"in",
"any",
"single",
"charge",
"and",
"concluding",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"had",
"mis",
"##re",
"##pres",
"##ented",
"matters",
".",
"in",
"a",
"follow",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"up",
"analysis",
"he",
"concluded",
"that",
"he",
"could",
"find",
"'",
"no",
"way",
"of",
"avoiding",
"the",
"inference",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"copied",
"the",
"quota",
"##tion",
"from",
"twain",
"from",
"peters",
"'",
"s",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
",",
"and",
"not",
"from",
"the",
"original",
"source",
"'",
",",
"as",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"claimed",
".",
"in",
"an",
"interview",
"given",
"for",
"the",
"film",
"american",
"radical",
":",
"the",
"trials",
"of",
"norman"
] | 2,249 |
##re ##z , a former editor @ - @ in @ - @ chief of the ucla law review , published an analysis of the charges made against fin ##kel ##stein by der ##sho ##witz , finding no merit in any single charge and concluding that der ##sho ##witz had mis ##re ##pres ##ented matters . in a follow @ - @ up analysis he concluded that he could find ' no way of avoiding the inference that der ##sho ##witz copied the quota ##tion from twain from peters ' s from time im ##me ##mori ##al , and not from the original source ' , as der ##sho ##witz claimed . in an interview given for the film american radical : the trials of norman
| 94 |
[
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"in",
"2009",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"said",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
":",
"\"",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"think",
"he",
"is",
"a",
"jew",
".",
"he",
"'",
"s",
"jewish",
"only",
"on",
"his",
"parents",
"'",
"side",
".",
"\"",
"=",
"=",
"controversies",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"tenure",
"denial",
"and",
"resignation",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"in",
"september",
"2006",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"sent",
"members",
"of",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"'",
"s",
"law",
"and",
"political",
"science",
"faculties",
"what",
"he",
"described",
"as",
"\"",
"a",
"dos",
"##sier",
"of",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"most",
"e",
"##gre",
"##gio",
"##us",
"academic",
"sins",
",",
"and",
"especially",
"his",
"outright",
"lies",
",",
"mis",
"##qu",
"##ota",
"##tions",
",",
"and",
"distortion",
"##s",
"\"",
"and",
"lobbied",
"professors",
",",
"alumni",
"and",
"administrators",
"to",
"deny",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"tenure",
".",
"de"
] | 2,250 |
fin ##kel ##stein in 2009 , der ##sho ##witz said of fin ##kel ##stein : " i don ' t think he is a jew . he ' s jewish only on his parents ' side . " = = controversies = = = = = tenure denial and resignation = = = in september 2006 , der ##sho ##witz sent members of de ##pa ##ul ' s law and political science faculties what he described as " a dos ##sier of norman fin ##kel ##stein ' s most e ##gre ##gio ##us academic sins , and especially his outright lies , mis ##qu ##ota ##tions , and distortion ##s " and lobbied professors , alumni and administrators to deny fin ##kel ##stein tenure . de
| 94 |
[
"paul",
"'",
"s",
"political",
"science",
"committee",
"investigated",
"his",
"accusations",
"against",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"concluded",
"that",
"they",
"were",
"not",
"based",
"on",
"legitimate",
"criticism",
".",
"the",
"department",
"subsequently",
"invited",
"john",
"me",
"##ars",
"##heimer",
"and",
"ian",
"lust",
"##ick",
",",
"two",
"independent",
"academics",
"with",
"known",
"expertise",
"on",
"the",
"israel",
"–",
"palestine",
"conflict",
",",
"to",
"evaluate",
"the",
"academic",
"merit",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"work",
";",
"they",
"came",
"to",
"the",
"same",
"conclusion",
".",
"also",
"in",
"2006",
",",
"the",
"washington",
"post",
"noted",
"\"",
"the",
"ad",
"##l",
"repeatedly",
"accused",
"\"",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"of",
"being",
"a",
"\"",
"holocaust",
"den",
"##ier",
"\"",
"and",
"that",
"\"",
"these",
"charges",
"have",
"proved",
"basel",
"##ess",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"mother",
"survived",
"the",
"maj",
"##dan",
"##ek",
"concentration",
"camp",
",",
"his",
"father",
"survived",
"the"
] | 2,251 |
paul ' s political science committee investigated his accusations against fin ##kel ##stein and concluded that they were not based on legitimate criticism . the department subsequently invited john me ##ars ##heimer and ian lust ##ick , two independent academics with known expertise on the israel – palestine conflict , to evaluate the academic merit of fin ##kel ##stein ' s work ; they came to the same conclusion . also in 2006 , the washington post noted " the ad ##l repeatedly accused " norman fin ##kel ##stein of being a " holocaust den ##ier " and that " these charges have proved basel ##ess . " fin ##kel ##stein ' s mother survived the maj ##dan ##ek concentration camp , his father survived the
| 251 |
[
"auschwitz",
"concentration",
"camp",
",",
"and",
"most",
"of",
"his",
"family",
"died",
"in",
"the",
"holocaust",
"in",
"early",
"2007",
",",
"the",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"political",
"science",
"department",
"voted",
"nine",
"to",
"three",
",",
"and",
"the",
"college",
"of",
"liberal",
"arts",
"and",
"sciences",
"personnel",
"committee",
"five",
"to",
"zero",
",",
"in",
"favor",
"of",
"giving",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"tenure",
".",
"the",
"three",
"opposing",
"faculty",
"members",
"subsequently",
"filed",
"a",
"minority",
"report",
"opposing",
"tenure",
",",
"supported",
"by",
"the",
"dean",
"of",
"the",
"college",
",",
"chuck",
"such",
"##ar",
".",
"such",
"##ar",
"stated",
"he",
"opposed",
"tenure",
"because",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"\"",
"personal",
"and",
"reputation",
"dem",
"##ean",
"##ing",
"attacks",
"on",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"benny",
"morris",
",",
"and",
"the",
"holocaust",
"authors",
"eli",
"##e",
"wi",
"##ese",
"##l",
"and",
"je",
"##rzy",
"ko",
"##sin",
"##ski",
"\"",
"were",
"inconsistent",
"with",
"de",
"##pa"
] | 2,252 |
auschwitz concentration camp , and most of his family died in the holocaust in early 2007 , the de ##pa ##ul political science department voted nine to three , and the college of liberal arts and sciences personnel committee five to zero , in favor of giving fin ##kel ##stein tenure . the three opposing faculty members subsequently filed a minority report opposing tenure , supported by the dean of the college , chuck such ##ar . such ##ar stated he opposed tenure because fin ##kel ##stein ' s " personal and reputation dem ##ean ##ing attacks on der ##sho ##witz , benny morris , and the holocaust authors eli ##e wi ##ese ##l and je ##rzy ko ##sin ##ski " were inconsistent with de ##pa
| 196 |
[
"##ul",
"'",
"s",
"\"",
"vincent",
"##ian",
"\"",
"values",
";",
"as",
"examples",
"of",
"the",
"latter",
",",
"such",
"##ar",
"argued",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"lacked",
"respect",
"for",
"\"",
"the",
"dignity",
"of",
"the",
"individual",
"\"",
"and",
"for",
"\"",
"the",
"rights",
"of",
"others",
"to",
"hold",
"and",
"express",
"different",
"intellectual",
"positions",
"\"",
".",
"amidst",
"considerable",
"public",
"debate",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"actively",
"campaigned",
"to",
"block",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"tenure",
"bid",
".",
"in",
"june",
"2007",
",",
"a",
"4",
"–",
"3",
"vote",
"by",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"university",
"'",
"s",
"board",
"on",
"promotion",
"and",
"tenure",
"(",
"a",
"faculty",
"board",
")",
",",
"affirmed",
"by",
"the",
"university",
"'",
"s",
"president",
",",
"the",
"rev",
".",
"dennis",
"holt",
"##sch",
"##ne",
"##ider",
",",
"denied",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"tenure",
".",
"the",
"university",
"denied",
"that",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
","
] | 2,253 |
##ul ' s " vincent ##ian " values ; as examples of the latter , such ##ar argued that fin ##kel ##stein lacked respect for " the dignity of the individual " and for " the rights of others to hold and express different intellectual positions " . amidst considerable public debate , der ##sho ##witz actively campaigned to block fin ##kel ##stein ' s tenure bid . in june 2007 , a 4 – 3 vote by de ##pa ##ul university ' s board on promotion and tenure ( a faculty board ) , affirmed by the university ' s president , the rev . dennis holt ##sch ##ne ##ider , denied fin ##kel ##stein tenure . the university denied that der ##sho ##witz ,
| 94 |
[
"who",
"had",
"been",
"criticized",
"for",
"his",
"campaign",
"against",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"tenure",
",",
"played",
"any",
"part",
"in",
"this",
"decision",
".",
"at",
"the",
"same",
"time",
",",
"the",
"university",
"denied",
"tenure",
"to",
"international",
"studies",
"assistant",
"professor",
"me",
"##hre",
"##ne",
"la",
"##rud",
"##ee",
",",
"a",
"strong",
"supporter",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"despite",
"unanimous",
"support",
"from",
"her",
"department",
",",
"the",
"personnel",
"committee",
"and",
"the",
"dean",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"stated",
"that",
"he",
"would",
"engage",
"in",
"civil",
"di",
"##so",
"##bed",
"##ience",
"if",
"attempts",
"were",
"made",
"to",
"bar",
"him",
"from",
"teaching",
"his",
"students",
".",
"the",
"faculty",
"council",
"later",
"affirmed",
"the",
"right",
"of",
"professors",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"la",
"##rud",
"##ee",
"to",
"appeal",
",",
"which",
"a",
"university",
"lawyer",
"said",
"was",
"not",
"possible",
".",
"council",
"president",
"anne",
"bartlett",
"said",
"she",
"was"
] | 2,254 |
who had been criticized for his campaign against fin ##kel ##stein ' s tenure , played any part in this decision . at the same time , the university denied tenure to international studies assistant professor me ##hre ##ne la ##rud ##ee , a strong supporter of fin ##kel ##stein , despite unanimous support from her department , the personnel committee and the dean . fin ##kel ##stein stated that he would engage in civil di ##so ##bed ##ience if attempts were made to bar him from teaching his students . the faculty council later affirmed the right of professors fin ##kel ##stein and la ##rud ##ee to appeal , which a university lawyer said was not possible . council president anne bartlett said she was
| 400 |
[
"\"",
"'",
"terribly",
"concerned",
"'",
"correct",
"procedure",
"was",
"not",
"followed",
"\"",
".",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"'",
"s",
"faculty",
"association",
"considered",
"taking",
"no",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"confidence",
"votes",
"on",
"administrators",
",",
"including",
"the",
"president",
",",
"because",
"of",
"the",
"tenure",
"denial",
"##s",
".",
"in",
"a",
"statement",
"issued",
"upon",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"resignation",
",",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"called",
"him",
"\"",
"a",
"prolific",
"scholar",
"and",
"an",
"outstanding",
"teacher",
"\"",
".",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"expressed",
"outrage",
"at",
"the",
"compromise",
"and",
"this",
"statement",
"in",
"particular",
",",
"saying",
"that",
"the",
"university",
"had",
"\"",
"traded",
"truth",
"for",
"peace",
"\"",
".",
"in",
"june",
"2007",
",",
"after",
"two",
"weeks",
"of",
"protests",
",",
"some",
"de",
"##pa",
"##ul",
"students",
"staged",
"a",
"sit",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"in",
"and",
"hunger",
"strike",
"in",
"support",
"of",
"both",
"professors",
"denied",
"tenure"
] | 2,255 |
" ' terribly concerned ' correct procedure was not followed " . de ##pa ##ul ' s faculty association considered taking no @ - @ confidence votes on administrators , including the president , because of the tenure denial ##s . in a statement issued upon fin ##kel ##stein ' s resignation , de ##pa ##ul called him " a prolific scholar and an outstanding teacher " . der ##sho ##witz expressed outrage at the compromise and this statement in particular , saying that the university had " traded truth for peace " . in june 2007 , after two weeks of protests , some de ##pa ##ul students staged a sit @ - @ in and hunger strike in support of both professors denied tenure
| 399 |
[
".",
"the",
"illinois",
"conference",
"of",
"the",
"american",
"association",
"of",
"university",
"professors",
"also",
"sent",
"a",
"letter",
"to",
"the",
"university",
"'",
"s",
"president",
"stating",
":",
"\"",
"it",
"is",
"entirely",
"illegitimate",
"for",
"a",
"university",
"to",
"deny",
"tenure",
"to",
"a",
"professor",
"out",
"of",
"fear",
"that",
"his",
"published",
"research",
".",
".",
".",
"might",
"hurt",
"a",
"college",
"'",
"s",
"reputation",
"\"",
"and",
"that",
"the",
"association",
"has",
"\"",
"explicitly",
"rejected",
"col",
"##leg",
"##ial",
"##ity",
"as",
"an",
"appropriate",
"criterion",
"for",
"evaluating",
"faculty",
"members",
"\"",
".",
"in",
"a",
"2014",
"interview",
",",
"professor",
"matthew",
"abraham",
",",
"author",
"of",
"out",
"of",
"bounds",
":",
"academic",
"freedom",
"and",
"the",
"question",
"of",
"palestine",
",",
"described",
"the",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"tenure",
"case",
"as",
"\"",
"one",
"of",
"the",
"most",
"significant",
"academic",
"freedom",
"cases",
"in",
"the",
"last",
"fifty",
"years",
"\"",
",",
"claiming",
"the"
] | 2,256 |
. the illinois conference of the american association of university professors also sent a letter to the university ' s president stating : " it is entirely illegitimate for a university to deny tenure to a professor out of fear that his published research . . . might hurt a college ' s reputation " and that the association has " explicitly rejected col ##leg ##ial ##ity as an appropriate criterion for evaluating faculty members " . in a 2014 interview , professor matthew abraham , author of out of bounds : academic freedom and the question of palestine , described the fin ##kel ##stein tenure case as " one of the most significant academic freedom cases in the last fifty years " , claiming the
| 196 |
[
"case",
"demonstrated",
"\"",
"the",
"substantial",
"pressure",
"outside",
"parties",
"can",
"place",
"on",
"a",
"mid",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"tier",
"religious",
"institution",
"when",
"the",
"perspectives",
"advanced",
"by",
"a",
"controversial",
"scholar",
"threaten",
"dominant",
"interests",
"\"",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"denied",
"entry",
"to",
"israel",
"in",
"2008",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"on",
"may",
"23",
",",
"2008",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"was",
"denied",
"entry",
"to",
"israel",
",",
"according",
"to",
"unnamed",
"shin",
"bet",
"security",
"officials",
",",
"because",
"\"",
"of",
"suspicions",
"involving",
"hostile",
"elements",
"in",
"lebanon",
"\"",
"and",
"that",
"he",
"\"",
"did",
"not",
"give",
"a",
"full",
"accounting",
"to",
"inter",
"##ro",
"##gat",
"##ors",
"with",
"regard",
"to",
"these",
"suspicions",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"had",
"previously",
"visited",
"south",
"lebanon",
"and",
"met",
"with",
"lebanese",
"families",
"during",
"the",
"2006",
"lebanon",
"war",
".",
"he",
"was",
"banned",
"from",
"entering",
"israel",
"for",
"10"
] | 2,257 |
case demonstrated " the substantial pressure outside parties can place on a mid @ - @ tier religious institution when the perspectives advanced by a controversial scholar threaten dominant interests " . = = = denied entry to israel in 2008 = = = on may 23 , 2008 , fin ##kel ##stein was denied entry to israel , according to unnamed shin bet security officials , because " of suspicions involving hostile elements in lebanon " and that he " did not give a full accounting to inter ##ro ##gat ##ors with regard to these suspicions . " fin ##kel ##stein had previously visited south lebanon and met with lebanese families during the 2006 lebanon war . he was banned from entering israel for 10
| 254 |
[
"years",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"was",
"questioned",
"after",
"his",
"arrival",
"at",
"ben",
"gu",
"##rion",
"airport",
"near",
"tel",
"aviv",
"and",
"detained",
"for",
"24",
"hours",
"in",
"a",
"holding",
"cell",
".",
"after",
"speaking",
"to",
"israeli",
"attorney",
"michael",
"sf",
"##ard",
"he",
"was",
"placed",
"on",
"a",
"flight",
"back",
"to",
"amsterdam",
",",
"his",
"point",
"of",
"origin",
".",
"in",
"an",
"interview",
"with",
"ha",
"##are",
"##tz",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"stated",
"\"",
"i",
"did",
"my",
"best",
"to",
"provide",
"absolutely",
"candi",
"##d",
"and",
"comprehensive",
"answers",
"to",
"all",
"the",
"questions",
"put",
"to",
"me",
".",
"i",
"am",
"confident",
"that",
"i",
"have",
"nothing",
"to",
"hide",
".",
".",
".",
"no",
"suicide",
"missions",
"or",
"secret",
"rendezvous",
"with",
"terrorist",
"organizations",
".",
"\"",
"he",
"had",
"been",
"travelling",
"to",
"visit",
"friends",
"in",
"the",
"west",
"bank",
"and",
"stated",
"he",
"had",
"no",
"interest",
"in",
"visiting"
] | 2,258 |
years . fin ##kel ##stein was questioned after his arrival at ben gu ##rion airport near tel aviv and detained for 24 hours in a holding cell . after speaking to israeli attorney michael sf ##ard he was placed on a flight back to amsterdam , his point of origin . in an interview with ha ##are ##tz , fin ##kel ##stein stated " i did my best to provide absolutely candi ##d and comprehensive answers to all the questions put to me . i am confident that i have nothing to hide . . . no suicide missions or secret rendezvous with terrorist organizations . " he had been travelling to visit friends in the west bank and stated he had no interest in visiting
| 173 |
[
"israel",
".",
"sf",
"##ard",
"said",
"banning",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"from",
"entering",
"the",
"country",
"\"",
"recalls",
"the",
"behavior",
"of",
"the",
"soviet",
"bloc",
"countries",
"\"",
".",
"=",
"=",
"reception",
"=",
"=",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"books",
"are",
"an",
"attempt",
"to",
"examine",
"the",
"works",
"of",
"mainstream",
"scholarship",
".",
"the",
"authors",
"whose",
"work",
"he",
"has",
"thus",
"targeted",
",",
"including",
"daniel",
"jonah",
"gold",
"##ha",
"##gen",
"and",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"along",
"with",
"others",
"such",
"as",
"benny",
"morris",
"whose",
"work",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"also",
"cited",
"in",
"his",
"scholarship",
",",
"have",
"in",
"turn",
"accused",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"of",
"gross",
"##ly",
"mis",
"##re",
"##pres",
"##enting",
"their",
"work",
",",
"and",
"selective",
"##ly",
"quoting",
"from",
"their",
"books",
".",
"according",
"to",
"raul",
"hi",
"##lberg",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"displays",
"\"",
"academic",
"courage",
"to",
"speak",
"the"
] | 2,259 |
israel . sf ##ard said banning fin ##kel ##stein from entering the country " recalls the behavior of the soviet bloc countries " . = = reception = = fin ##kel ##stein ' s books are an attempt to examine the works of mainstream scholarship . the authors whose work he has thus targeted , including daniel jonah gold ##ha ##gen and der ##sho ##witz , along with others such as benny morris whose work fin ##kel ##stein has also cited in his scholarship , have in turn accused fin ##kel ##stein of gross ##ly mis ##re ##pres ##enting their work , and selective ##ly quoting from their books . according to raul hi ##lberg , fin ##kel ##stein displays " academic courage to speak the
| 94 |
[
"truth",
"when",
"no",
"one",
"else",
"is",
"out",
"there",
"to",
"support",
"him",
".",
".",
".",
"i",
"would",
"say",
"that",
"his",
"place",
"in",
"the",
"whole",
"history",
"of",
"writing",
"history",
"is",
"assured",
",",
"and",
"that",
"those",
"who",
"in",
"the",
"end",
"are",
"proven",
"right",
"triumph",
",",
"and",
"he",
"will",
"be",
"among",
"those",
"who",
"will",
"have",
"triumph",
"##ed",
",",
"albeit",
",",
"it",
"so",
"seems",
",",
"at",
"great",
"cost",
".",
"\"",
"in",
"a",
"peer",
"review",
"for",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
",",
"av",
"##i",
"sh",
"##lai",
"##m",
"said",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"\"",
"has",
"a",
"most",
"impressive",
"track",
"record",
"in",
"exposing",
"spur",
"##ious",
"american",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"jewish",
"scholarship",
"on",
"the",
"arab",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israeli",
"conflict",
".",
"\"",
"he",
"praised",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"for",
"\"",
"all",
"the",
"sterling",
"qualities",
"for",
"which"
] | 2,260 |
truth when no one else is out there to support him . . . i would say that his place in the whole history of writing history is assured , and that those who in the end are proven right triumph , and he will be among those who will have triumph ##ed , albeit , it so seems , at great cost . " in a peer review for beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h , av ##i sh ##lai ##m said that fin ##kel ##stein " has a most impressive track record in exposing spur ##ious american @ - @ jewish scholarship on the arab @ - @ israeli conflict . " he praised fin ##kel ##stein for " all the sterling qualities for which
| 253 |
[
"he",
"has",
"become",
"famous",
":",
"er",
"##udi",
"##tion",
",",
"original",
"##ity",
",",
"spark",
",",
"met",
"##ic",
"##ulous",
"attention",
"to",
"detail",
",",
"intellectual",
"integrity",
",",
"courage",
",",
"and",
"formidable",
"forensic",
"skills",
".",
"\"",
"sara",
"roy",
"stated",
"that",
"her",
"shared",
"experience",
"with",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"as",
"a",
"child",
"of",
"holocaust",
"survivors",
"engaged",
"in",
"research",
"on",
"the",
"palestinian",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israeli",
"conflict",
"gave",
"her",
"a",
"unique",
"position",
"to",
"comment",
".",
"according",
"to",
"roy",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"scholarship",
"is",
",",
"\"",
"exceptional",
"both",
"for",
"its",
"brilliance",
"and",
"rig",
"##or",
".",
"in",
"the",
"fields",
"of",
"middle",
"eastern",
"studies",
"and",
"political",
"science",
"his",
"work",
"is",
"considered",
"seminal",
"and",
"there",
"is",
"no",
"doubt",
"that",
"both",
"disciplines",
"would",
"be",
"intellectual",
"##ly",
"weaker",
"without",
"it",
".",
"norman",
"'",
"s",
"power",
"and"
] | 2,261 |
he has become famous : er ##udi ##tion , original ##ity , spark , met ##ic ##ulous attention to detail , intellectual integrity , courage , and formidable forensic skills . " sara roy stated that her shared experience with fin ##kel ##stein as a child of holocaust survivors engaged in research on the palestinian @ - @ israeli conflict gave her a unique position to comment . according to roy , fin ##kel ##stein ' s scholarship is , " exceptional both for its brilliance and rig ##or . in the fields of middle eastern studies and political science his work is considered seminal and there is no doubt that both disciplines would be intellectual ##ly weaker without it . norman ' s power and
| 94 |
[
"value",
",",
"however",
",",
"do",
"not",
"em",
"##ana",
"##te",
"only",
"from",
"his",
"scholarship",
"but",
"from",
"his",
"character",
".",
"his",
"life",
"’",
"s",
"work",
",",
"shaped",
"largely",
"but",
"not",
"entirely",
"by",
"his",
"experience",
"as",
"a",
"child",
"of",
"survivors",
"has",
"been",
"and",
"continues",
"to",
"be",
"informed",
"by",
"a",
"profound",
"concern",
"with",
"human",
"dignity",
"and",
"the",
"danger",
"of",
"de",
"##hum",
"##ani",
"##zation",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"israeli",
"newspaper",
",",
"ha",
"##are",
"##tz",
",",
"stated",
"that",
"\"",
"[",
"i",
"]",
"t",
"is",
"difficult",
"to",
"sy",
"##mp",
"##athi",
"##ze",
"with",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"opinions",
"and",
"preferences",
",",
"especially",
"since",
"he",
"decided",
"to",
"support",
"hezbollah",
",",
"meet",
"with",
"its",
"fighters",
"and",
"visit",
"the",
"graves",
"of",
"some",
"of",
"its",
"slain",
"operatives",
".",
"\"",
"still",
",",
"it",
"continued",
"to",
"say",
"that",
"he",
"should"
] | 2,262 |
value , however , do not em ##ana ##te only from his scholarship but from his character . his life ’ s work , shaped largely but not entirely by his experience as a child of survivors has been and continues to be informed by a profound concern with human dignity and the danger of de ##hum ##ani ##zation . " the israeli newspaper , ha ##are ##tz , stated that " [ i ] t is difficult to sy ##mp ##athi ##ze with fin ##kel ##stein ' s opinions and preferences , especially since he decided to support hezbollah , meet with its fighters and visit the graves of some of its slain operatives . " still , it continued to say that he should
| 82 |
[
"not",
"be",
"banned",
"from",
"entering",
"israel",
",",
"because",
"\"",
"meetings",
"with",
"hezbollah",
"operatives",
"do",
"not",
"in",
"themselves",
"constitute",
"a",
"security",
"risk",
"\"",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"2009",
"film",
"about",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"american",
"radical",
":",
"the",
"trials",
"of",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"is",
"an",
"award",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"winning",
"documentary",
"film",
"about",
"the",
"life",
"and",
"career",
"of",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"released",
"in",
"2009",
"and",
"directed",
"by",
"david",
"ridge",
"##n",
"and",
"nicolas",
"rossi",
"##er",
".",
"it",
"has",
"been",
"screened",
"in",
"amsterdam",
"idf",
"##a",
",",
"in",
"toronto",
"hot",
"doc",
"##s",
"and",
"in",
"more",
"than",
"40",
"other",
"national",
"and",
"international",
"venues",
",",
"it",
"received",
"a",
"fresh",
"##ness",
"rating",
"of",
"100",
"%",
"on",
"film",
"review",
"aggregator",
"rotten",
"tomatoes",
".",
"the",
"same",
"year",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein"
] | 2,263 |
not be banned from entering israel , because " meetings with hezbollah operatives do not in themselves constitute a security risk " . = = = 2009 film about fin ##kel ##stein = = = american radical : the trials of norman fin ##kel ##stein is an award @ - @ winning documentary film about the life and career of norman fin ##kel ##stein , released in 2009 and directed by david ridge ##n and nicolas rossi ##er . it has been screened in amsterdam idf ##a , in toronto hot doc ##s and in more than 40 other national and international venues , it received a fresh ##ness rating of 100 % on film review aggregator rotten tomatoes . the same year fin ##kel ##stein
| 94 |
[
"appeared",
"in",
"defamation",
"(",
"hebrew",
":",
"ה",
"##ש",
"##מ",
"##צ",
"##ה",
";",
"translit",
".",
"hash",
"##mat",
"##sa",
")",
"a",
"documentary",
"film",
"by",
"award",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"winning",
"israeli",
"filmmaker",
"yo",
"##av",
"sham",
"##ir",
".",
"criticism",
"has",
"been",
"leveled",
"against",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"from",
"several",
"angles",
".",
"the",
"first",
"sources",
"are",
"responses",
"from",
"those",
"whose",
"work",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"discussed",
".",
"daniel",
"gold",
"##ha",
"##gen",
",",
"whose",
"book",
"hitler",
"'",
"s",
"willing",
"execution",
"##ers",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"criticized",
",",
"claimed",
"his",
"scholarship",
"has",
"\"",
"everything",
"to",
"do",
"with",
"his",
"burning",
"political",
"agenda",
"\"",
".",
"alan",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"has",
"written",
"that",
"peter",
"novi",
"##ck",
",",
"professor",
"of",
"history",
"at",
"the",
"university",
"of",
"chicago",
"and",
"a",
"noted",
"holocaust",
"historian",
"whose",
"work",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"says",
"inspired",
"the"
] | 2,264 |
appeared in defamation ( hebrew : ה ##ש ##מ ##צ ##ה ; translit . hash ##mat ##sa ) a documentary film by award @ - @ winning israeli filmmaker yo ##av sham ##ir . criticism has been leveled against fin ##kel ##stein from several angles . the first sources are responses from those whose work fin ##kel ##stein has discussed . daniel gold ##ha ##gen , whose book hitler ' s willing execution ##ers fin ##kel ##stein criticized , claimed his scholarship has " everything to do with his burning political agenda " . alan der ##sho ##witz has written that peter novi ##ck , professor of history at the university of chicago and a noted holocaust historian whose work fin ##kel ##stein says inspired the
| 2 |
[
"holocaust",
"industry",
",",
"has",
"strongly",
"criticized",
"the",
"latter",
"'",
"s",
"work",
",",
"describing",
"it",
"as",
"\"",
"trash",
"\"",
".",
"similarly",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
",",
"whose",
"book",
"the",
"case",
"for",
"israel",
"and",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"response",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
"sparked",
"an",
"ongoing",
"feud",
"between",
"the",
"two",
",",
"has",
"claimed",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"com",
"##plicity",
"in",
"a",
"conspiracy",
"against",
"pro",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israel",
"scholars",
":",
"\"",
"the",
"mode",
"of",
"attack",
"is",
"consistent",
".",
"cho",
"##ms",
"##ky",
"selects",
"the",
"target",
"and",
"directs",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"to",
"probe",
"the",
"writings",
"in",
"minute",
"detail",
"and",
"conclude",
"that",
"the",
"writer",
"didn",
"'",
"t",
"actually",
"write",
"the",
"work",
",",
"that",
"it",
"is",
"pl",
"##agi",
"##ari",
"##zed",
",",
"that",
"it",
"is",
"a",
"hoax",
"and",
"a",
"fraud"
] | 2,265 |
holocaust industry , has strongly criticized the latter ' s work , describing it as " trash " . similarly , der ##sho ##witz , whose book the case for israel and fin ##kel ##stein ' s response beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h sparked an ongoing feud between the two , has claimed fin ##kel ##stein ' s com ##plicity in a conspiracy against pro @ - @ israel scholars : " the mode of attack is consistent . cho ##ms ##ky selects the target and directs fin ##kel ##stein to probe the writings in minute detail and conclude that the writer didn ' t actually write the work , that it is pl ##agi ##ari ##zed , that it is a hoax and a fraud
| 718 |
[
",",
"\"",
"arguing",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"leveled",
"charges",
"against",
"many",
"academics",
",",
"calling",
"at",
"least",
"10",
"\"",
"distinguished",
"jews",
"'",
"hu",
"##cks",
"##ters",
"'",
",",
"'",
"hoax",
"##ters",
"'",
"(",
"sic",
")",
",",
"'",
"thieves",
"'",
",",
"'",
"ex",
"##tort",
"##ion",
"##ists",
"'",
",",
"and",
"worse",
".",
"\"",
"although",
"the",
"back",
"and",
"forth",
"between",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"received",
"the",
"most",
"attention",
"and",
"attracted",
"significant",
"controversy",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"maintained",
"that",
"\"",
"the",
"real",
"issue",
"is",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"human",
"rights",
"record",
".",
"\"",
"israeli",
"historian",
"om",
"##er",
"bart",
"##ov",
",",
"writing",
"for",
"the",
"new",
"york",
"times",
"book",
"review",
",",
"judged",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
"to",
"be",
"marred",
"by",
"the",
"same",
"errors",
"he",
"den",
"##oun",
"##ces",
"in",
"those",
"who",
"exploit"
] | 2,266 |
, " arguing that fin ##kel ##stein has leveled charges against many academics , calling at least 10 " distinguished jews ' hu ##cks ##ters ' , ' hoax ##ters ' ( sic ) , ' thieves ' , ' ex ##tort ##ion ##ists ' , and worse . " although the back and forth between fin ##kel ##stein and der ##sho ##witz received the most attention and attracted significant controversy , fin ##kel ##stein has maintained that " the real issue is israel ' s human rights record . " israeli historian om ##er bart ##ov , writing for the new york times book review , judged the holocaust industry to be marred by the same errors he den ##oun ##ces in those who exploit
| 137 |
[
"the",
"holocaust",
"for",
"profit",
"or",
"politics",
":",
"it",
"is",
"filled",
"with",
"precisely",
"the",
"kind",
"of",
"shrill",
"hyper",
"##bol",
"##e",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"right",
"##ly",
"de",
"##pl",
"##ores",
"in",
"much",
"of",
"the",
"current",
"media",
"h",
"##ype",
"over",
"the",
"holocaust",
";",
"it",
"is",
"br",
"##im",
"##ming",
"with",
"the",
"same",
"indifference",
"to",
"historical",
"facts",
",",
"inner",
"contradiction",
"##s",
",",
"stride",
"##nt",
"politics",
"and",
"dubious",
"context",
"##ual",
"##izations",
";",
"and",
"it",
"o",
"##oz",
"##es",
"with",
"the",
"same",
"smug",
"sense",
"of",
"moral",
"and",
"intellectual",
"superiority",
".",
".",
".",
"like",
"any",
"conspiracy",
"theory",
",",
"it",
"contains",
"several",
"grains",
"of",
"truth",
";",
"and",
"like",
"any",
"such",
"theory",
",",
"it",
"is",
"both",
"irrational",
"and",
"ins",
"##idi",
"##ous",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"accused",
"journalist",
"jeffrey",
"goldberg",
"of",
"\"",
"tor",
"##turing",
"\"",
"or",
"\""
] | 2,267 |
the holocaust for profit or politics : it is filled with precisely the kind of shrill hyper ##bol ##e that fin ##kel ##stein right ##ly de ##pl ##ores in much of the current media h ##ype over the holocaust ; it is br ##im ##ming with the same indifference to historical facts , inner contradiction ##s , stride ##nt politics and dubious context ##ual ##izations ; and it o ##oz ##es with the same smug sense of moral and intellectual superiority . . . like any conspiracy theory , it contains several grains of truth ; and like any such theory , it is both irrational and ins ##idi ##ous . fin ##kel ##stein has accused journalist jeffrey goldberg of " tor ##turing " or "
| 296 |
[
"being",
"an",
"accessory",
"to",
"torture",
"of",
"\"",
"palestinian",
"prisoners",
"during",
"his",
"idf",
"service",
"in",
"the",
"first",
"int",
"##if",
"##ada",
",",
"based",
"on",
"statements",
"made",
"in",
"goldberg",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"prisoners",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"says",
"that",
"goldberg",
"admits",
"to",
"personally",
"sending",
"prisoners",
"to",
"the",
"z",
"##in",
"##zan",
"##a",
",",
"which",
"he",
"says",
"has",
"been",
"repeatedly",
"condemned",
"as",
"torture",
"in",
"human",
"rights",
"reports",
".",
"goldberg",
"referred",
"to",
"the",
"all",
"##ega",
"##tion",
"as",
"\"",
"ridiculous",
"\"",
"and",
"he",
"had",
"\"",
"never",
"laid",
"a",
"hand",
"on",
"anybody",
".",
"\"",
"goldberg",
"said",
"his",
"\"",
"principal",
"role",
"\"",
"was",
"\"",
"making",
"sure",
"prisoners",
"had",
"fresh",
"fruit",
".",
"\"",
"he",
"characterized",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"as",
"a",
"\"",
"ridiculous",
"figure",
"\"",
"and",
"accused",
"him",
"of",
"\"",
"lying",
"and",
"purposely",
"mis",
"##rea",
"##ding",
"my"
] | 2,268 |
being an accessory to torture of " palestinian prisoners during his idf service in the first int ##if ##ada , based on statements made in goldberg ' s book prisoners . fin ##kel ##stein says that goldberg admits to personally sending prisoners to the z ##in ##zan ##a , which he says has been repeatedly condemned as torture in human rights reports . goldberg referred to the all ##ega ##tion as " ridiculous " and he had " never laid a hand on anybody . " goldberg said his " principal role " was " making sure prisoners had fresh fruit . " he characterized fin ##kel ##stein as a " ridiculous figure " and accused him of " lying and purposely mis ##rea ##ding my
| 249 |
[
"book",
".",
"\"",
"=",
"=",
"statements",
"on",
"israel",
"=",
"=",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"is",
"a",
"sharp",
"critic",
"of",
"the",
"state",
"of",
"israel",
".",
"discussing",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"book",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
",",
"israeli",
"historian",
"av",
"##i",
"sh",
"##lai",
"##m",
"stated",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"critique",
"of",
"israel",
"\"",
"is",
"based",
"on",
"an",
"amazing",
"amount",
"of",
"research",
".",
"he",
"seems",
"to",
"have",
"read",
"everything",
".",
"he",
"has",
"gone",
"through",
"the",
"reports",
"of",
"israeli",
"groups",
",",
"of",
"human",
"rights",
"groups",
",",
"human",
"rights",
"watch",
"and",
"peace",
"now",
"and",
"b",
"'",
"ts",
"##ele",
"##m",
",",
"all",
"of",
"the",
"reports",
"of",
"amnesty",
"international",
".",
"and",
"he",
"deploy",
"##s",
"all",
"this",
"evidence",
"from",
"israeli",
"and",
"other",
"sources",
"in",
"order",
"to",
"sustain",
"his",
"critique",
"of",
"israeli"
] | 2,269 |
book . " = = statements on israel = = fin ##kel ##stein is a sharp critic of the state of israel . discussing fin ##kel ##stein ' s book beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h , israeli historian av ##i sh ##lai ##m stated that fin ##kel ##stein ' s critique of israel " is based on an amazing amount of research . he seems to have read everything . he has gone through the reports of israeli groups , of human rights groups , human rights watch and peace now and b ' ts ##ele ##m , all of the reports of amnesty international . and he deploy ##s all this evidence from israeli and other sources in order to sustain his critique of israeli
| 254 |
[
"practices",
",",
"israeli",
"violations",
"of",
"human",
"rights",
"of",
"the",
"palestinians",
",",
"israeli",
"house",
"demolition",
"##s",
",",
"the",
"targeted",
"assassination",
"##s",
"of",
"palestinian",
"militants",
",",
"the",
"cutting",
"down",
"of",
"trees",
",",
"the",
"building",
"of",
"the",
"wall",
"—",
"the",
"security",
"barrier",
"on",
"the",
"west",
"bank",
",",
"which",
"is",
"illegal",
"—",
"the",
"restrictions",
"imposed",
"on",
"the",
"palestinians",
"in",
"the",
"west",
"bank",
",",
"and",
"so",
"on",
"and",
"so",
"forth",
".",
"i",
"find",
"his",
"critique",
"extremely",
"detailed",
",",
"well",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"documented",
"and",
"accurate",
".",
"\"",
"in",
"a",
"telephone",
"interview",
"with",
"today",
"'",
"s",
"za",
"##man",
",",
"in",
"2009",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"stated",
":",
"i",
"think",
"israel",
",",
"as",
"a",
"number",
"of",
"commentators",
"pointed",
"out",
",",
"is",
"becoming",
"an",
"insane",
"state",
".",
"and",
"we",
"have",
"to",
"be",
"honest",
"about"
] | 2,270 |
practices , israeli violations of human rights of the palestinians , israeli house demolition ##s , the targeted assassination ##s of palestinian militants , the cutting down of trees , the building of the wall — the security barrier on the west bank , which is illegal — the restrictions imposed on the palestinians in the west bank , and so on and so forth . i find his critique extremely detailed , well @ - @ documented and accurate . " in a telephone interview with today ' s za ##man , in 2009 , fin ##kel ##stein stated : i think israel , as a number of commentators pointed out , is becoming an insane state . and we have to be honest about
| 254 |
[
"that",
".",
"while",
"the",
"rest",
"of",
"the",
"world",
"wants",
"peace",
",",
"europe",
"wants",
"peace",
",",
"the",
"us",
"wants",
"peace",
",",
"but",
"this",
"state",
"wants",
"war",
",",
"war",
"and",
"war",
".",
"in",
"the",
"first",
"week",
"of",
"the",
"massacre",
"##s",
",",
"there",
"were",
"reports",
"in",
"the",
"israeli",
"press",
"that",
"israel",
"did",
"not",
"want",
"to",
"put",
"all",
"its",
"ground",
"forces",
"in",
"gaza",
"because",
"it",
"was",
"preparing",
"attacks",
"on",
"iran",
".",
"then",
"there",
"were",
"reports",
"it",
"was",
"planning",
"attacks",
"on",
"lebanon",
".",
"it",
"is",
"a",
"lunatic",
"state",
".",
"when",
"asked",
"how",
"he",
",",
"as",
"the",
"son",
"of",
"holocaust",
"survivors",
",",
"felt",
"about",
"israel",
"’",
"s",
"operation",
"in",
"gaza",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"replied",
":",
"it",
"has",
"been",
"a",
"long",
"time",
"since",
"i",
"felt",
"any",
"emotional",
"connection",
"with",
"the",
"state",
"of"
] | 2,271 |
that . while the rest of the world wants peace , europe wants peace , the us wants peace , but this state wants war , war and war . in the first week of the massacre ##s , there were reports in the israeli press that israel did not want to put all its ground forces in gaza because it was preparing attacks on iran . then there were reports it was planning attacks on lebanon . it is a lunatic state . when asked how he , as the son of holocaust survivors , felt about israel ’ s operation in gaza , fin ##kel ##stein replied : it has been a long time since i felt any emotional connection with the state of
| 254 |
[
"israel",
",",
"which",
"relentless",
"##ly",
"and",
"brutally",
"and",
"inhuman",
"##ly",
"keeps",
"these",
"vicious",
",",
"murderous",
"wars",
".",
"it",
"is",
"a",
"van",
"##dal",
"state",
".",
"there",
"is",
"a",
"russian",
"writer",
"who",
"once",
"described",
"van",
"##dal",
"states",
"as",
"gen",
"##ghi",
"##s",
"khan",
"with",
"a",
"telegraph",
".",
"israel",
"is",
"gen",
"##ghi",
"##s",
"khan",
"with",
"a",
"computer",
".",
"i",
"feel",
"no",
"emotion",
"of",
"affinity",
"with",
"that",
"state",
".",
"i",
"have",
"some",
"good",
"friends",
"and",
"their",
"families",
"there",
",",
"and",
"of",
"course",
"i",
"would",
"not",
"want",
"any",
"of",
"them",
"to",
"be",
"hurt",
".",
"that",
"said",
",",
"sometimes",
"i",
"feel",
"that",
"israel",
"has",
"come",
"out",
"of",
"the",
"boil",
"##s",
"(",
"sic",
")",
"of",
"the",
"hell",
",",
"a",
"satan",
"##ic",
"state",
".",
"the",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"defamation",
"league",
"has",
"described",
"fin",
"##kel"
] | 2,272 |
israel , which relentless ##ly and brutally and inhuman ##ly keeps these vicious , murderous wars . it is a van ##dal state . there is a russian writer who once described van ##dal states as gen ##ghi ##s khan with a telegraph . israel is gen ##ghi ##s khan with a computer . i feel no emotion of affinity with that state . i have some good friends and their families there , and of course i would not want any of them to be hurt . that said , sometimes i feel that israel has come out of the boil ##s ( sic ) of the hell , a satan ##ic state . the anti @ - @ defamation league has described fin ##kel
| 697 |
[
"##stein",
"as",
"an",
"\"",
"ob",
"##ses",
"##sive",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"zionist",
"\"",
"filled",
"with",
"\"",
"vi",
"##tri",
"##olic",
"hatred",
"of",
"zion",
"##ism",
"and",
"israel",
".",
"\"",
"on",
"being",
"called",
"an",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"zionist",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"said",
":",
"\"",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"a",
"superficial",
"term",
".",
"i",
"am",
"opposed",
"to",
"any",
"state",
"with",
"an",
"ethnic",
"character",
",",
"not",
"only",
"to",
"israel",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"is",
"an",
"advocate",
"of",
"a",
"two",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"state",
"solution",
"to",
"the",
"israeli",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestinian",
"conflict",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"hezbollah",
"and",
"hamas",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"expressed",
"solidarity",
"with",
"hezbollah",
"and",
"hamas",
"with",
"respect",
"to",
"defensive",
"actions",
",",
"alleging",
"that",
"israel",
"had",
"invaded",
"lebanon",
"as",
"a",
"signal",
"of",
"rejection"
] | 2,273 |
##stein as an " ob ##ses ##sive anti @ - @ zionist " filled with " vi ##tri ##olic hatred of zion ##ism and israel . " on being called an anti @ - @ zionist fin ##kel ##stein has said : " it ' s a superficial term . i am opposed to any state with an ethnic character , not only to israel . " fin ##kel ##stein is an advocate of a two @ - @ state solution to the israeli @ - @ palestinian conflict . = = = hezbollah and hamas = = = fin ##kel ##stein has expressed solidarity with hezbollah and hamas with respect to defensive actions , alleging that israel had invaded lebanon as a signal of rejection
| 254 |
[
"when",
"hamas",
"was",
"seeking",
"a",
"diplomatic",
"settlement",
"with",
"israel",
".",
"he",
"also",
"condemned",
"what",
"he",
"said",
"was",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"refusal",
"\"",
"to",
"ab",
"##ide",
"by",
"international",
"law",
"[",
"and",
"]",
"to",
"ab",
"##ide",
"by",
"the",
"opinion",
"of",
"the",
"international",
"community",
"\"",
"to",
"settle",
"the",
"conflict",
".",
"\"",
"i",
"was",
"of",
"course",
"happy",
"to",
"meet",
"the",
"hi",
"##z",
"##bu",
"##llah",
"people",
",",
"because",
"it",
"is",
"a",
"point",
"of",
"view",
"that",
"is",
"rarely",
"heard",
"in",
"the",
"united",
"states",
".",
"i",
"have",
"no",
"problem",
"saying",
"that",
"i",
"do",
"want",
"to",
"express",
"solidarity",
"with",
"them",
",",
"and",
"i",
"am",
"not",
"going",
"to",
"be",
"a",
"coward",
"of",
"(",
"sic",
")",
"a",
"h",
"##yp",
"##oc",
"##rite",
"about",
"it",
".",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"care",
"about",
"hi",
"##z",
"##bu",
"##llah",
"as",
"a"
] | 2,274 |
when hamas was seeking a diplomatic settlement with israel . he also condemned what he said was israel ' s refusal " to ab ##ide by international law [ and ] to ab ##ide by the opinion of the international community " to settle the conflict . " i was of course happy to meet the hi ##z ##bu ##llah people , because it is a point of view that is rarely heard in the united states . i have no problem saying that i do want to express solidarity with them , and i am not going to be a coward of ( sic ) a h ##yp ##oc ##rite about it . i don ' t care about hi ##z ##bu ##llah as a
| 230 |
[
"political",
"organization",
".",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"know",
"much",
"about",
"their",
"politics",
",",
"and",
"any",
"##how",
",",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"irrelevant",
".",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"live",
"in",
"lebanon",
".",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"a",
"choice",
"that",
"the",
"lebanese",
"have",
"to",
"make",
":",
"who",
"they",
"want",
"to",
"be",
"their",
"leaders",
",",
"who",
"they",
"want",
"to",
"represent",
"them",
".",
"but",
"there",
"is",
"a",
"fundamental",
"principle",
".",
"people",
"have",
"the",
"right",
"to",
"defend",
"their",
"country",
"from",
"foreign",
"o",
"##cc",
"##up",
"##iers",
",",
"and",
"people",
"have",
"the",
"right",
"to",
"defend",
"their",
"country",
"from",
"invaders",
"who",
"are",
"destroying",
"their",
"country",
".",
"that",
"to",
"me",
"is",
"a",
"very",
"basic",
",",
"elementary",
"and",
"un",
"##com",
"##pl",
"##icated",
"question",
".",
"\"",
"while",
"condemning",
"the",
"targeting",
"of",
"civilians",
"to",
"achieve",
"a",
"political",
"goal",
",",
"fin"
] | 2,275 |
political organization . i don ' t know much about their politics , and any ##how , it ' s irrelevant . i don ' t live in lebanon . it ' s a choice that the lebanese have to make : who they want to be their leaders , who they want to represent them . but there is a fundamental principle . people have the right to defend their country from foreign o ##cc ##up ##iers , and people have the right to defend their country from invaders who are destroying their country . that to me is a very basic , elementary and un ##com ##pl ##icated question . " while condemning the targeting of civilians to achieve a political goal , fin
| 822 |
[
"##kel",
"##stein",
"has",
"stated",
"he",
"believes",
"hezbollah",
"has",
"the",
"right",
"to",
"target",
"israeli",
"civilians",
"as",
"long",
"as",
"\"",
"israel",
"persist",
"##s",
"in",
"targeting",
"[",
"lebanese",
"]",
"civilians",
"until",
"israel",
"cease",
"##s",
"its",
"terrorist",
"acts",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"claims",
"that",
"an",
"equivalence",
"exists",
"between",
"hamas",
"and",
"the",
"state",
"of",
"israel",
"in",
"regards",
"to",
"the",
"military",
"policy",
"of",
"targeted",
"killings",
"during",
"the",
"second",
"int",
"##if",
"##ada",
".",
"according",
"to",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"\"",
"the",
"record",
"shows",
"that",
"israel",
"has",
"routinely",
"targeted",
"civilians",
"for",
"killing",
"\"",
"and",
"\"",
"israel",
"ind",
"##is",
"##cr",
"##imi",
"##nate",
"##ly",
"kills",
"civilians",
"\"",
".",
"he",
"concludes",
"that",
"\"",
"the",
"argument",
",",
"among",
"human",
"rights",
"organizations",
"at",
"any",
"rate",
"is",
"that",
".",
".",
".",
"in",
"effect",
",",
"there",
"’",
"s",
"no",
"difference",
"between"
] | 2,276 |
##kel ##stein has stated he believes hezbollah has the right to target israeli civilians as long as " israel persist ##s in targeting [ lebanese ] civilians until israel cease ##s its terrorist acts . " fin ##kel ##stein claims that an equivalence exists between hamas and the state of israel in regards to the military policy of targeted killings during the second int ##if ##ada . according to fin ##kel ##stein " the record shows that israel has routinely targeted civilians for killing " and " israel ind ##is ##cr ##imi ##nate ##ly kills civilians " . he concludes that " the argument , among human rights organizations at any rate is that . . . in effect , there ’ s no difference between
| 254 |
[
"ind",
"##is",
"##cr",
"##imi",
"##nate",
"##ly",
"killing",
"civilians",
"and",
"targeting",
"civilians",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"argued",
"one",
"of",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"primary",
"motivation",
"##s",
"for",
"launching",
"the",
"2008",
"offensive",
"in",
"gaza",
"was",
"that",
"hamas",
"was",
"\"",
"signaling",
"that",
"it",
"wanted",
"a",
"diplomatic",
"settlement",
"of",
"the",
"conflict",
"along",
"the",
"june",
"1967",
"border",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"believes",
"hamas",
"had",
"joined",
"the",
"international",
"community",
"in",
"\"",
"seeking",
"a",
"diplomatic",
"settlement",
"\"",
"and",
"describes",
"hamas",
"'",
"s",
"stance",
"towards",
"israel",
"prior",
"to",
"the",
"war",
"as",
"a",
"\"",
"peace",
"offensive",
".",
"\"",
"=",
"=",
"statements",
"on",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
"=",
"=",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"had",
"made",
"many",
"criticisms",
"of",
"the",
"boycott",
",",
"dive",
"##st",
"##ment",
"and",
"sanctions",
"movement",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"stated",
"that",
"\"",
"i",
"think"
] | 2,277 |
ind ##is ##cr ##imi ##nate ##ly killing civilians and targeting civilians . " fin ##kel ##stein argued one of israel ' s primary motivation ##s for launching the 2008 offensive in gaza was that hamas was " signaling that it wanted a diplomatic settlement of the conflict along the june 1967 border . " fin ##kel ##stein believes hamas had joined the international community in " seeking a diplomatic settlement " and describes hamas ' s stance towards israel prior to the war as a " peace offensive . " = = statements on the b ##ds movement = = fin ##kel ##stein had made many criticisms of the boycott , dive ##st ##ment and sanctions movement . fin ##kel ##stein stated that " i think
| 230 |
[
"the",
"solidarity",
"movement",
"has",
"the",
"right",
"tactics",
".",
"i",
"support",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
".",
"but",
"i",
"said",
"it",
"will",
"never",
"reach",
"a",
"broad",
"public",
"until",
"and",
"unless",
"they",
"are",
"explicit",
"on",
"their",
"goal",
".",
"and",
"their",
"goal",
"has",
"to",
"include",
"recognition",
"of",
"israel",
",",
"otherwise",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"a",
"non",
"##star",
"##ter",
".",
"\"",
"elsewhere",
",",
"he",
"has",
"stated",
"that",
"he",
"supports",
"a",
"\"",
"lower",
"##case",
"\"",
"b",
"##ds",
",",
"making",
"the",
"same",
"point",
"about",
"tactics",
"and",
"goals",
".",
"in",
"february",
"2012",
",",
"the",
"jewish",
"chronicle",
"in",
"england",
"stated",
"that",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"\"",
"launched",
"a",
"b",
"##list",
"##ering",
"attack",
"\"",
"on",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
",",
"saying",
"it",
"was",
"a",
"\"",
"h",
"##yp",
"##oc",
"##rit",
"##ical",
",",
"dish",
"##ones",
"##t",
"cult",
"\"",
",",
"\"",
"["
] | 2,278 |
the solidarity movement has the right tactics . i support the b ##ds . but i said it will never reach a broad public until and unless they are explicit on their goal . and their goal has to include recognition of israel , otherwise it ' s a non ##star ##ter . " elsewhere , he has stated that he supports a " lower ##case " b ##ds , making the same point about tactics and goals . in february 2012 , the jewish chronicle in england stated that fin ##kel ##stein " launched a b ##list ##ering attack " on the b ##ds movement , saying it was a " h ##yp ##oc ##rit ##ical , dish ##ones ##t cult " , " [
| 86 |
[
"l",
"]",
"ike",
"the",
"mu",
"##nch",
"##kin",
"cult",
"in",
"oz",
",",
"\"",
"that",
"tries",
"to",
"clever",
"##ly",
"pose",
"as",
"human",
"rights",
"activists",
"while",
"in",
"reality",
"their",
"goal",
"is",
"to",
"destroy",
"israel",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"stated",
"that",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
"has",
"had",
"very",
"few",
"successes",
",",
"and",
"that",
"just",
"like",
"a",
"cult",
",",
"the",
"leaders",
"pretend",
"that",
"they",
"are",
"hugely",
"successful",
"when",
"in",
"reality",
"the",
"general",
"public",
"rejects",
"their",
"extreme",
"views",
".",
"in",
"june",
"2012",
",",
"in",
"an",
"appearance",
"on",
"democracy",
"now",
"!",
",",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"elaborated",
"on",
"his",
"criticisms",
"of",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
":",
"the",
"problem",
"as",
"i",
"see",
"it",
"with",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
"is",
"not",
"the",
"tactic",
".",
"who",
"could",
"not",
"support",
"boycott",
",",
"dive",
"##st",
"##ment",
"and",
"sanctions",
"?"
] | 2,279 |
l ] ike the mu ##nch ##kin cult in oz , " that tries to clever ##ly pose as human rights activists while in reality their goal is to destroy israel . fin ##kel ##stein stated that the b ##ds movement has had very few successes , and that just like a cult , the leaders pretend that they are hugely successful when in reality the general public rejects their extreme views . in june 2012 , in an appearance on democracy now ! , fin ##kel ##stein elaborated on his criticisms of the b ##ds movement : the problem as i see it with the b ##ds movement is not the tactic . who could not support boycott , dive ##st ##ment and sanctions ?
| 94 |
[
"of",
"course",
"you",
"should",
".",
"and",
"most",
"of",
"the",
"human",
"rights",
"organizations",
",",
"church",
"organizations",
"have",
"moved",
"in",
"that",
"direction",
".",
"the",
"problem",
"is",
"the",
"goal",
".",
".",
".",
"the",
"official",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
",",
"they",
"claim",
"to",
"be",
"ag",
"##nostic",
",",
"neutral",
"—",
"whatever",
"term",
"you",
"want",
"to",
"use",
"—",
"on",
"the",
"question",
"of",
"israel",
".",
"you",
"can",
"’",
"t",
"reach",
"a",
"broad",
"public",
"if",
"you",
"are",
"ag",
"##nostic",
"on",
"the",
"question",
"of",
"israel",
".",
"the",
"broad",
"public",
"wants",
"to",
"know",
",",
"where",
"do",
"you",
"stand",
"?",
"and",
"if",
"you",
"claim",
"not",
"to",
"have",
"a",
"stand",
",",
"you",
"lose",
"them",
".",
"the",
"b",
"##ds",
"movement",
",",
"it",
"always",
"says",
",",
"and",
"i",
"’",
"m",
"using",
"their",
"language",
",",
"\"",
"we",
"are",
"a",
"rights",
"@",
"-"
] | 2,280 |
of course you should . and most of the human rights organizations , church organizations have moved in that direction . the problem is the goal . . . the official b ##ds movement , they claim to be ag ##nostic , neutral — whatever term you want to use — on the question of israel . you can ’ t reach a broad public if you are ag ##nostic on the question of israel . the broad public wants to know , where do you stand ? and if you claim not to have a stand , you lose them . the b ##ds movement , it always says , and i ’ m using their language , " we are a rights @ -
| 719 |
[
"@",
"based",
"organization",
".",
"we",
"are",
"based",
"in",
"international",
"law",
".",
"\"",
"i",
"agree",
"with",
"that",
".",
"that",
"’",
"s",
"where",
"you",
"have",
"to",
"go",
":",
"rights",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"based",
"international",
"law",
".",
"but",
"the",
"international",
"law",
"is",
"clear",
".",
"you",
"read",
"the",
"last",
"sentence",
"of",
"the",
"2004",
"international",
"court",
"of",
"justice",
"opinion",
"on",
"the",
"wall",
"that",
"israel",
"has",
"been",
"building",
"in",
"the",
"west",
"bank",
",",
"and",
"the",
"last",
"sentence",
"says",
",",
"\"",
"we",
"look",
"forward",
"to",
"two",
"states",
":",
"a",
"palestinian",
"state",
"alongside",
"israel",
"and",
"at",
"peace",
"with",
"its",
"neighbors",
".",
"\"",
"that",
"'",
"s",
"the",
"law",
".",
"and",
"if",
"you",
"want",
"to",
"go",
"past",
"that",
"law",
"or",
"ignore",
"the",
"israel",
"part",
",",
"you",
"’",
"ll",
"never",
"reach",
"a",
"broad",
"public",
".",
"and",
"then"
] | 2,281 |
@ based organization . we are based in international law . " i agree with that . that ’ s where you have to go : rights @ - @ based international law . but the international law is clear . you read the last sentence of the 2004 international court of justice opinion on the wall that israel has been building in the west bank , and the last sentence says , " we look forward to two states : a palestinian state alongside israel and at peace with its neighbors . " that ' s the law . and if you want to go past that law or ignore the israel part , you ’ ll never reach a broad public . and then
| 720 |
[
"it",
"'",
"s",
"a",
"cult",
".",
"then",
"it",
"’",
"s",
"pointless",
",",
"in",
"my",
"opinion",
".",
"we",
"'",
"re",
"wasting",
"time",
".",
"and",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"only",
"a",
"wasting",
"of",
"time",
".",
"it",
"becomes",
"—",
"and",
"i",
"know",
"it",
"'",
"s",
"a",
"strong",
"word",
",",
"and",
"i",
"hope",
"i",
"won",
"'",
"t",
"be",
"fault",
"##ed",
"for",
"it",
",",
"but",
"it",
"becomes",
"historically",
"criminal",
",",
"because",
"there",
"was",
"a",
"time",
"where",
"whatever",
"we",
"said",
",",
"it",
"made",
"no",
"difference",
".",
"nobody",
"was",
"listening",
".",
"you",
"could",
"shout",
"whatever",
"you",
"want",
"—",
"who",
"cares",
"?",
"but",
"now",
",",
"actually",
",",
"we",
"can",
"reach",
"people",
".",
"there",
"is",
"a",
"possibility",
".",
"i",
"’",
"m",
"not",
"saying",
"a",
"certainty",
".",
"i",
"'",
"m",
"not",
"even",
"saying",
"a",
"probability",
".",
"but"
] | 2,282 |
it ' s a cult . then it ’ s pointless , in my opinion . we ' re wasting time . and it ' s only a wasting of time . it becomes — and i know it ' s a strong word , and i hope i won ' t be fault ##ed for it , but it becomes historically criminal , because there was a time where whatever we said , it made no difference . nobody was listening . you could shout whatever you want — who cares ? but now , actually , we can reach people . there is a possibility . i ’ m not saying a certainty . i ' m not even saying a probability . but
| 822 |
[
"there",
"is",
"a",
"possibility",
"that",
"we",
"can",
"reach",
"a",
"broad",
"public",
".",
"and",
"so",
",",
"we",
"have",
"to",
"be",
"very",
"careful",
"about",
"the",
"words",
"we",
"use",
",",
"and",
"we",
"have",
"to",
"be",
"very",
"careful",
"about",
"the",
"political",
"strategy",
"we",
"map",
"out",
".",
"otherwise",
",",
"we",
"'",
"re",
"going",
"to",
"sq",
"##uan",
"##der",
"a",
"real",
"opportunity",
".",
"and",
"i",
"don",
"'",
"t",
"want",
"to",
"sq",
"##uan",
"##der",
"it",
".",
"2014",
":",
"method",
"and",
"madness",
":",
"the",
"hidden",
"story",
"of",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"assaults",
"on",
"gaza",
",",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
"(",
"2014",
")",
"2014",
":",
"old",
"wine",
",",
"broken",
"bottle",
":",
"ari",
"sha",
"##vi",
"##t",
"'",
"s",
"promised",
"land",
",",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
"(",
"2014",
")",
"2012",
":",
"knowing",
"too",
"much",
":",
"why",
"the"
] | 2,283 |
there is a possibility that we can reach a broad public . and so , we have to be very careful about the words we use , and we have to be very careful about the political strategy we map out . otherwise , we ' re going to sq ##uan ##der a real opportunity . and i don ' t want to sq ##uan ##der it . 2014 : method and madness : the hidden story of israel ' s assaults on gaza , or books , new york ( 2014 ) 2014 : old wine , broken bottle : ari sha ##vi ##t ' s promised land , or books , new york ( 2014 ) 2012 : knowing too much : why the
| 825 |
[
"american",
"jewish",
"romance",
"with",
"israel",
"is",
"coming",
"to",
"an",
"end",
",",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
"(",
"2012",
")",
"isbn",
"978",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"93",
"##59",
"##28",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"77",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"5",
"2012",
":",
"what",
"gandhi",
"says",
"about",
"non",
"##vio",
"##lence",
",",
"resistance",
"and",
"courage",
",",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
":",
"2012",
",",
"isbn",
"978",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"93",
"##59",
"##28",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"79",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"9",
"2011",
":",
"\"",
"gold",
"##stone",
"rec",
"##ants",
".",
"richard",
"gold",
"##stone",
"renew",
"##s",
"israel",
"'",
"s",
"license",
"to",
"kill",
"\"",
",",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
"(",
"2011",
")",
",",
"isbn",
"978",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"93",
"##59",
"##28",
"@",
"-",
"@"
] | 2,284 |
american jewish romance with israel is coming to an end , or books , new york ( 2012 ) isbn 978 @ - @ 1 @ - @ 93 ##59 ##28 @ - @ 77 @ - @ 5 2012 : what gandhi says about non ##vio ##lence , resistance and courage , or books , new york : 2012 , isbn 978 @ - @ 1 @ - @ 93 ##59 ##28 @ - @ 79 @ - @ 9 2011 : " gold ##stone rec ##ants . richard gold ##stone renew ##s israel ' s license to kill " , or books , new york ( 2011 ) , isbn 978 @ - @ 1 @ - @ 93 ##59 ##28 @ - @
| 349 |
[
"51",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"5",
"2010",
":",
"this",
"time",
"we",
"went",
"too",
"far",
":",
"truth",
"and",
"consequences",
"of",
"the",
"gaza",
"invasion",
".",
"or",
"books",
",",
"new",
"york",
":",
"2010",
".",
"[",
"2",
"]",
";",
"isbn",
"978",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"93",
"##59",
"##28",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"43",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"0",
"2005",
":",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
":",
"on",
"the",
"mis",
"##use",
"of",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"semi",
"##tism",
"and",
"the",
"abuse",
"of",
"history",
".",
"university",
"of",
"california",
"press",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"520",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"245",
"##9",
"##8",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"9",
".",
"2nd",
"updated",
"ed",
".",
",",
"university",
"of",
"california",
"press",
".",
"june",
"2008",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"520",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"249",
"##8",
"##9"
] | 2,285 |
51 @ - @ 5 2010 : this time we went too far : truth and consequences of the gaza invasion . or books , new york : 2010 . [ 2 ] ; isbn 978 @ - @ 1 @ - @ 93 ##59 ##28 @ - @ 43 @ - @ 0 2005 : beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h : on the mis ##use of anti @ - @ semi ##tism and the abuse of history . university of california press ; isbn 0 @ - @ 520 @ - @ 245 ##9 ##8 @ - @ 9 . 2nd updated ed . , university of california press . june 2008 ; isbn 0 @ - @ 520 @ - @ 249 ##8 ##9
| 349 |
[
"@",
"-",
"@",
"5",
",",
"contains",
"an",
"appendix",
"written",
"by",
"frank",
"j",
".",
"men",
"##et",
"##re",
"##z",
",",
"der",
"##sho",
"##witz",
"vs",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
".",
"who",
"'",
"s",
"right",
"and",
"who",
"'",
"s",
"wrong",
"?",
",",
"pp",
".",
"36",
"##3",
"–",
"94",
"@",
",",
"@",
"2000",
":",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
":",
"reflections",
"on",
"the",
"exploitation",
"of",
"jewish",
"suffering",
",",
"ve",
"##rso",
";",
"isbn",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"85",
"##9",
"##8",
"##4",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"48",
"##8",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"x",
".",
"1998",
":",
"a",
"nation",
"on",
"trial",
":",
"the",
"gold",
"##ha",
"##gen",
"thesis",
"and",
"historical",
"truth",
"(",
"co",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"written",
"with",
"ruth",
"bet",
"##tina",
"bi",
"##rn",
")",
",",
"henry",
"holt",
"and",
"co",
".",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"80",
"##50",
"@",
"-"
] | 2,286 |
@ - @ 5 , contains an appendix written by frank j . men ##et ##re ##z , der ##sho ##witz vs fin ##kel ##stein . who ' s right and who ' s wrong ? , pp . 36 ##3 – 94 @ , @ 2000 : the holocaust industry : reflections on the exploitation of jewish suffering , ve ##rso ; isbn 1 @ - @ 85 ##9 ##8 ##4 @ - @ 48 ##8 @ - @ x . 1998 : a nation on trial : the gold ##ha ##gen thesis and historical truth ( co @ - @ written with ruth bet ##tina bi ##rn ) , henry holt and co . ; isbn 0 @ - @ 80 ##50 @ -
| 349 |
[
"@",
"58",
"##7",
"##2",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"9",
".",
"1996",
":",
"the",
"rise",
"and",
"fall",
"of",
"palestine",
":",
"a",
"personal",
"account",
"of",
"the",
"int",
"##if",
"##ada",
"years",
".",
"minneapolis",
":",
"u",
"of",
"minnesota",
"p",
",",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"81",
"##66",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"285",
"##9",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"9",
".",
"1995",
":",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"of",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
",",
"ve",
"##rso",
";",
"isbn",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"85",
"##9",
"##8",
"##4",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"44",
"##2",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1",
"1987",
":",
"from",
"the",
"jewish",
"question",
"to",
"the",
"jewish",
"state",
":",
"an",
"essay",
"on",
"the",
"theory",
"of",
"zion",
"##ism",
"(",
"thesis",
")",
",",
"princeton",
"university",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"articles",
"and",
"chapters",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"\"",
"di",
"##sin",
"##form"
] | 2,287 |
@ 58 ##7 ##2 @ - @ 9 . 1996 : the rise and fall of palestine : a personal account of the int ##if ##ada years . minneapolis : u of minnesota p , isbn 0 @ - @ 81 ##66 @ - @ 285 ##9 @ - @ 9 . 1995 : image and reality of the israel @ - @ palestine conflict , ve ##rso ; isbn 1 @ - @ 85 ##9 ##8 ##4 @ - @ 44 ##2 @ - @ 1 1987 : from the jewish question to the jewish state : an essay on the theory of zion ##ism ( thesis ) , princeton university . = = = articles and chapters = = = " di ##sin ##form
| 349 |
[
"##ation",
"and",
"the",
"palestine",
"question",
":",
"the",
"not",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"so",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"strange",
"case",
"of",
"joan",
"peter",
"'",
"s",
"'",
"from",
"time",
"im",
"##me",
"##mori",
"##al",
".",
"'",
"\"",
"in",
"blaming",
"the",
"victims",
":",
"spur",
"##ious",
"scholarship",
"and",
"the",
"palestinian",
"question",
".",
"ed",
".",
"edward",
"w",
".",
"said",
"and",
"christopher",
"hitch",
"##ens",
".",
"ve",
"##rso",
"press",
",",
"1988",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"86",
"##0",
"##9",
"##1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"88",
"##7",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"4",
".",
"chapter",
"two",
",",
"part",
"one",
":",
"\"",
"peace",
"process",
"or",
"peace",
"panic",
"?",
"-",
"the",
"sc",
"##our",
"##ge",
"of",
"palestinian",
"mode",
"##ration",
"\"",
",",
"middle",
"east",
"report",
",",
"19",
"(",
"1989",
")",
"3",
"/",
"158",
",",
"pp",
".",
"25",
"–",
"26",
"@",
",",
"@",
"28"
] | 2,288 |
##ation and the palestine question : the not @ - @ so @ - @ strange case of joan peter ' s ' from time im ##me ##mori ##al . ' " in blaming the victims : spur ##ious scholarship and the palestinian question . ed . edward w . said and christopher hitch ##ens . ve ##rso press , 1988 ; isbn 0 @ - @ 86 ##0 ##9 ##1 @ - @ 88 ##7 @ - @ 4 . chapter two , part one : " peace process or peace panic ? - the sc ##our ##ge of palestinian mode ##ration " , middle east report , 19 ( 1989 ) 3 / 158 , pp . 25 – 26 @ , @ 28
| 91 |
[
"@",
"-",
"@",
"30",
"@",
",",
"@",
"42",
"\"",
"zionist",
"orientation",
"##s",
"\"",
",",
"scandinavian",
"journal",
"of",
"development",
"alternatives",
"9",
"(",
"march",
"1990",
")",
"1",
"@",
".",
"@",
"p",
".",
"41",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"69",
"\"",
"bay",
"##t",
"sa",
"##hur",
"in",
"year",
"ii",
"of",
"the",
"int",
"##if",
"##ada",
".",
"-",
"a",
"personal",
"account",
"\"",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
"19",
"(",
"winter",
"1990",
")",
"2",
"/",
"74",
",",
"pp",
".",
"62",
"–",
"74",
"\"",
"israel",
"and",
"iraq",
".",
"-",
"a",
"double",
"standard",
"\"",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
"20",
"(",
"1991",
")",
"2",
"/",
"78",
"@",
".",
"@",
"pp",
".",
"43",
"–",
"56",
"\"",
"reflections",
"on",
"palestinian",
"attitudes",
"during",
"the",
"gulf",
"war",
"\"",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"21",
"(",
"1992",
")",
"3",
"/",
"83"
] | 2,289 |
@ - @ 30 @ , @ 42 " zionist orientation ##s " , scandinavian journal of development alternatives 9 ( march 1990 ) 1 @ . @ p . 41 @ - @ 69 " bay ##t sa ##hur in year ii of the int ##if ##ada . - a personal account " , journal of palestine studies 19 ( winter 1990 ) 2 / 74 , pp . 62 – 74 " israel and iraq . - a double standard " , journal of palestine studies 20 ( 1991 ) 2 / 78 @ . @ pp . 43 – 56 " reflections on palestinian attitudes during the gulf war " , journal of palestine studies , 21 ( 1992 ) 3 / 83
| 320 |
[
",",
"pp",
".",
"54",
"–",
"70",
"\"",
"reflex",
"##ions",
"sur",
"la",
"res",
"##pon",
"##sa",
"##bil",
"##ite",
"de",
"l",
"´",
"etat",
"et",
"du",
"ci",
"##toy",
"##en",
"dans",
"le",
"con",
"##fl",
"##it",
"arab",
"##o",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israeli",
"##en",
"\"",
"(",
"reflections",
"on",
"the",
"responsibility",
"of",
"state",
"and",
"citizen",
"in",
"the",
"arab",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israeli",
"conflict",
")",
",",
"in",
"l",
"'",
"homme",
"et",
"la",
"societe",
",",
"l",
"'",
"harm",
"##att",
"##an",
"1994",
",",
"114",
",",
"s",
".",
"37",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"50",
"\"",
"w",
"##hit",
"##her",
"the",
"`",
"peace",
"process",
"'",
"?",
"\"",
",",
"new",
"left",
"review",
",",
"(",
"1996",
")",
"218",
",",
"p",
".",
"138",
"\"",
"securing",
"occupation",
":",
"the",
"real",
"meaning",
"of",
"the",
"w",
"##ye",
"river",
"memorandum",
"\"",
",",
"new",
"left",
"review",
",",
"(",
"1998"
] | 2,290 |
, pp . 54 – 70 " reflex ##ions sur la res ##pon ##sa ##bil ##ite de l ´ etat et du ci ##toy ##en dans le con ##fl ##it arab ##o @ - @ israeli ##en " ( reflections on the responsibility of state and citizen in the arab @ - @ israeli conflict ) , in l ' homme et la societe , l ' harm ##att ##an 1994 , 114 , s . 37 @ - @ 50 " w ##hit ##her the ` peace process ' ? " , new left review , ( 1996 ) 218 , p . 138 " securing occupation : the real meaning of the w ##ye river memorandum " , new left review , ( 1998
| 254 |
[
")",
"232",
",",
"pp",
".",
"128",
"–",
"39",
"contributor",
"to",
"the",
"politics",
"of",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"semi",
"##tism",
".",
"ed",
".",
"alexander",
"cock",
"##burn",
"and",
"jeffrey",
"st",
".",
"clair",
".",
"ak",
"press",
",",
"2001",
";",
"isbn",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"90",
"##25",
"##9",
"##3",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"77",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"4",
".",
"\"",
"lessons",
"of",
"holocaust",
"compensation",
"\"",
",",
"in",
"palestinian",
"refugees",
":",
"the",
"right",
"of",
"return",
".",
"ed",
".",
"nas",
"##eer",
"ar",
"##uri",
".",
"pluto",
"press",
",",
"2001",
",",
"s",
".",
"272",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"275",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"74",
"##53",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"1776",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"6",
".",
"\"",
"ab",
"##ba",
"e",
"##ban",
"with",
"foot",
"##notes",
"\"",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"vol",
"32",
".",
"(",
"2003"
] | 2,291 |
) 232 , pp . 128 – 39 contributor to the politics of anti @ - @ semi ##tism . ed . alexander cock ##burn and jeffrey st . clair . ak press , 2001 ; isbn 1 @ - @ 90 ##25 ##9 ##3 @ - @ 77 @ - @ 4 . " lessons of holocaust compensation " , in palestinian refugees : the right of return . ed . nas ##eer ar ##uri . pluto press , 2001 , s . 272 @ - @ 275 ; isbn 0 @ - @ 74 ##53 @ - @ 1776 @ - @ 6 . " ab ##ba e ##ban with foot ##notes " , journal of palestine studies , vol 32 . ( 2003
| 349 |
[
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"74",
"–",
"89",
"\"",
"prospects",
"for",
"ending",
"the",
"occupation",
"\"",
",",
"anti",
"##pod",
"##e",
",",
"35",
"(",
"2003",
")",
"5",
",",
"pp",
".",
"83",
"##9",
"–",
"45",
"contributor",
"to",
"radicals",
",",
"rabbis",
"and",
"peace",
"##makers",
":",
"conversations",
"with",
"jewish",
"critics",
"of",
"israel",
",",
"by",
"seth",
"far",
"##ber",
".",
"common",
"courage",
"press",
",",
"2005",
".",
"isbn",
"1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"56",
"##75",
"##1",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"326",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"3",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"camp",
"david",
"ii",
"negotiations",
".",
"-",
"how",
"dennis",
"ross",
"proved",
"the",
"palestinians",
"ab",
"##orted",
"the",
"peace",
"process",
"\"",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"vol",
".",
"36",
"(",
"2007",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"39",
"–",
"53",
"\"",
"dennis",
"ross",
"and",
"the",
"peace",
"process",
":",
"sub",
"##ord",
"##inating",
"palestinian",
"rights"
] | 2,292 |
) , pp . 74 – 89 " prospects for ending the occupation " , anti ##pod ##e , 35 ( 2003 ) 5 , pp . 83 ##9 – 45 contributor to radicals , rabbis and peace ##makers : conversations with jewish critics of israel , by seth far ##ber . common courage press , 2005 . isbn 1 @ - @ 56 ##75 ##1 @ - @ 326 @ - @ 3 . " the camp david ii negotiations . - how dennis ross proved the palestinians ab ##orted the peace process " , journal of palestine studies , vol . 36 ( 2007 ) , pp . 39 – 53 " dennis ross and the peace process : sub ##ord ##inating palestinian rights
| 320 |
[
"to",
"israeli",
"'",
"needs",
"'",
"\"",
",",
"institute",
"for",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"2007",
";",
"isbn",
"0",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"88",
"##7",
"##28",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"308",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"x",
"=",
"=",
"others",
"on",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"his",
"works",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"academic",
"reviews",
"of",
"books",
"by",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"mass",
"##ad",
",",
"joseph",
".",
"\"",
"deco",
"##nst",
"##ru",
"##cting",
"holocaust",
"consciousness",
"\"",
",",
"review",
"essay",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"vol",
".",
"32",
",",
"no",
".",
"1",
".",
"(",
"autumn",
",",
"2002",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"78",
"–",
"89",
".",
"cole",
",",
"tim",
".",
"\"",
"representing",
"the",
"holocaust",
"in",
"america",
":",
"mixed",
"motives",
"or",
"abuse",
"?",
"\"",
",",
"the",
"public",
"historian",
",",
"vol",
".",
"24",
",",
"no",
"."
] | 2,293 |
to israeli ' needs ' " , institute for palestine studies , 2007 ; isbn 0 @ - @ 88 ##7 ##28 @ - @ 308 @ - @ x = = others on fin ##kel ##stein and his works = = = = = academic reviews of books by fin ##kel ##stein = = = mass ##ad , joseph . " deco ##nst ##ru ##cting holocaust consciousness " , review essay , journal of palestine studies , vol . 32 , no . 1 . ( autumn , 2002 ) , pp . 78 – 89 . cole , tim . " representing the holocaust in america : mixed motives or abuse ? " , the public historian , vol . 24 , no .
| 194 |
[
"4",
".",
"(",
"fall",
",",
"2002",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"127",
"–",
"31",
"ho",
"##og",
"##lund",
",",
"eric",
".",
"reviewed",
"work",
":",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"of",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
"by",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"vol",
".",
"33",
",",
"no",
".",
"3",
",",
"special",
"issue",
"in",
"honor",
"of",
"edward",
"w",
".",
"said",
".",
"(",
"spring",
",",
"2004",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"123",
"–",
"124",
".",
"pe",
"##lham",
",",
"nicolas",
".",
"reviewed",
"work",
":",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"in",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
".",
"by",
"norman",
"g",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"international",
"affairs",
",",
"vol",
".",
"72",
",",
"no",
".",
"3",
",",
"ethnicity",
"and",
"international",
"relations",
".",
"(",
"july",
"1996",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"62"
] | 2,294 |
4 . ( fall , 2002 ) , pp . 127 – 31 ho ##og ##lund , eric . reviewed work : image and reality of the israel @ - @ palestine conflict by norman fin ##kel ##stein , journal of palestine studies , vol . 33 , no . 3 , special issue in honor of edward w . said . ( spring , 2004 ) , pp . 123 – 124 . pe ##lham , nicolas . reviewed work : image and reality in the israel @ - @ palestine conflict . by norman g . fin ##kel ##stein , international affairs , vol . 72 , no . 3 , ethnicity and international relations . ( july 1996 ) , pp . 62
| 94 |
[
"##7",
"–",
"28",
".",
"pa",
"##ppe",
",",
"il",
"##an",
".",
"\"",
"valuable",
"new",
"perspectives",
",",
"\"",
"reviewed",
"work",
":",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"of",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
".",
"by",
"norman",
"g",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
",",
"journal",
"of",
"palestine",
"studies",
",",
"vol",
".",
"26",
",",
"no",
".",
"4",
".",
"(",
"summer",
",",
"1997",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"113",
"–",
"15",
".",
"bei",
"##nin",
",",
"joel",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"palestinian",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"israeli",
"conflict",
"after",
"oslo",
"\"",
",",
"reviewed",
"work",
":",
"image",
"and",
"reality",
"of",
"the",
"israel",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"palestine",
"conflict",
"by",
"norman",
"g",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
".",
"middle",
"east",
"report",
",",
"no",
".",
"201",
",",
"israel",
"and",
"palestine",
":",
"two",
"states",
",",
"ban",
"##tus",
"##tan",
"##s",
"or",
"bin",
"##ation",
"##alis"
] | 2,295 |
##7 – 28 . pa ##ppe , il ##an . " valuable new perspectives , " reviewed work : image and reality of the israel @ - @ palestine conflict . by norman g . fin ##kel ##stein , journal of palestine studies , vol . 26 , no . 4 . ( summer , 1997 ) , pp . 113 – 15 . bei ##nin , joel . " the palestinian @ - @ israeli conflict after oslo " , reviewed work : image and reality of the israel @ - @ palestine conflict by norman g . fin ##kel ##stein . middle east report , no . 201 , israel and palestine : two states , ban ##tus ##tan ##s or bin ##ation ##alis
| 254 |
[
"##m",
"?",
".",
"(",
"oct",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"dec",
"1996",
")",
",",
"pp",
".",
"45",
"–",
"47",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"reviews",
"of",
"books",
"by",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"b",
"##lok",
"##ker",
",",
"bas",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
")",
",",
"nr",
"##c",
"handel",
"##sb",
"##lad",
",",
"february",
"24",
",",
"2006",
".",
"pa",
"##ppe",
",",
"il",
"##an",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
")",
",",
"book",
"##for",
"##um",
"(",
"february",
"/",
"march",
"2006",
")",
"de",
"za",
"##yas",
",",
"alfred",
".",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
"in",
"frankfurt",
"##er",
"all",
"##ge",
"##mei",
"##ne",
"ze",
"##itung",
"(",
"february",
"3",
",",
"2006",
")",
"mer",
"##kley",
",",
"paul",
"charles",
".",
"these",
"pigs",
"on",
"the",
"face",
"of",
"the",
"earth",
":",
"israel",
"'"
] | 2,296 |
##m ? . ( oct @ - @ dec 1996 ) , pp . 45 – 47 . = = = reviews of books by fin ##kel ##stein = = = b ##lok ##ker , bas ( review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h ) , nr ##c handel ##sb ##lad , february 24 , 2006 . pa ##ppe , il ##an ( review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h ) , book ##for ##um ( february / march 2006 ) de za ##yas , alfred . review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h in frankfurt ##er all ##ge ##mei ##ne ze ##itung ( february 3 , 2006 ) mer ##kley , paul charles . these pigs on the face of the earth : israel '
| 76 |
[
"s",
"most",
"relentless",
"critic",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
",",
"in",
"christianity",
"today",
"(",
"january",
"/",
"february",
"2006",
")",
"mar",
"##qu",
"##see",
",",
"mike",
".",
"\"",
"israel",
",",
"fraud",
"and",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
"\"",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
";",
"january",
"2006",
")",
"pr",
"##ash",
"##ad",
",",
"vijay",
".",
"z",
"magazine",
"reviews",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
".",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
".",
"z",
"magazine",
"november",
"2005",
"volume",
"18",
",",
"number",
"11",
"gordon",
",",
"ne",
"##ve",
".",
"ne",
"##ve",
"gordon",
":",
"review",
"of",
"norman",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
",",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
".",
"review",
"of",
"beyond",
"chu",
"##tz",
"##pa",
"##h",
":",
"on",
"the",
"mis",
"##use",
"of",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"semi",
"##tism",
"and"
] | 2,297 |
s most relentless critic ( review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h , in christianity today ( january / february 2006 ) mar ##qu ##see , mike . " israel , fraud and chu ##tz ##pa ##h " ( review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h ; january 2006 ) pr ##ash ##ad , vijay . z magazine reviews beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h . review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h . z magazine november 2005 volume 18 , number 11 gordon , ne ##ve . ne ##ve gordon : review of norman fin ##kel ##stein ' s , beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h . review of beyond chu ##tz ##pa ##h : on the mis ##use of anti @ - @ semi ##tism and
| 125 |
[
"the",
"abuse",
"of",
"history",
",",
"by",
"norman",
"g",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
".",
"history",
"news",
"network",
",",
"october",
"12",
",",
"2005",
"bog",
"##dan",
"##or",
",",
"paul",
".",
"the",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"phenomenon",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
")",
",",
"judaism",
"(",
"fall",
"2002",
")",
"abs",
"##e",
",",
"tobias",
".",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"f",
"##oll",
"##ies",
":",
"the",
"dangers",
"of",
"vulgar",
"anti",
"@",
"-",
"@",
"zion",
"##ism",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
")",
",",
"what",
"##ne",
"##xt",
"##jou",
"##rna",
"##l",
".",
"co",
".",
"uk",
";",
"accessed",
"november",
"1",
",",
"2015",
"bart",
"##ov",
",",
"om",
"##er",
".",
"\"",
"a",
"tale",
"of",
"two",
"holocaust",
"##s",
"\"",
"(",
"review",
"of",
"the",
"holocaust",
"industry",
")",
",",
"new",
"york",
"times",
"book",
"review",
",",
"august",
"6",
",",
"2000",
"="
] | 2,298 |
the abuse of history , by norman g . fin ##kel ##stein . history news network , october 12 , 2005 bog ##dan ##or , paul . the fin ##kel ##stein phenomenon ( review of the holocaust industry ) , judaism ( fall 2002 ) abs ##e , tobias . fin ##kel ##stein ' s f ##oll ##ies : the dangers of vulgar anti @ - @ zion ##ism ( review of the holocaust industry ) , what ##ne ##xt ##jou ##rna ##l . co . uk ; accessed november 1 , 2015 bart ##ov , om ##er . " a tale of two holocaust ##s " ( review of the holocaust industry ) , new york times book review , august 6 , 2000 =
| 94 |
[
"=",
"=",
"profiles",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"garner",
",",
"mandy",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"good",
"jewish",
"boys",
"go",
"into",
"battle",
".",
"\"",
"times",
"higher",
"education",
"supplement",
"16",
"december",
"2005",
".",
"nap",
"##ars",
"##tek",
",",
"ben",
".",
"\"",
"his",
"own",
"worst",
"enemy",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"jerusalem",
"post",
"12",
"december",
"2005",
".",
"ray",
"##ner",
",",
"jay",
".",
"\"",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"'",
"s",
"list",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"observer",
"16",
"july",
"2000",
".",
"she",
"##leg",
",",
"ya",
"##ir",
".",
"\"",
"the",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"pole",
"##mic",
".",
"\"",
"ha",
"'",
"are",
"##tz",
"30",
"march",
"2001",
".",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"critics",
"of",
"fin",
"##kel",
"##stein",
"and",
"replies",
"=",
"=",
"=",
"daniel",
"gold",
"##ha",
"##gen",
",",
"the",
"new",
"discourse",
"of",
"avoidance",
"at",
"the",
"way",
"##back",
"machine",
"(",
"archived",
"december"
] | 2,299 |
= = profiles of fin ##kel ##stein = = = garner , mandy . " the good jewish boys go into battle . " times higher education supplement 16 december 2005 . nap ##ars ##tek , ben . " his own worst enemy . " the jerusalem post 12 december 2005 . ray ##ner , jay . " fin ##kel ##stein ' s list . " the observer 16 july 2000 . she ##leg , ya ##ir . " the fin ##kel ##stein pole ##mic . " ha ' are ##tz 30 march 2001 . = = = critics of fin ##kel ##stein and replies = = = daniel gold ##ha ##gen , the new discourse of avoidance at the way ##back machine ( archived december
| 94 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.