submission_title
stringlengths
21
221
submission_text
stringlengths
0
3.4k
submission_score
int64
3.34k
70.8k
submission_url
stringlengths
73
106
submission_date
stringdate
2019-01-01 13:47:56
2022-12-31 19:17:44
top_comment_1
stringlengths
19
729
top_comment_2
stringlengths
0
3.06k
top_comment_3
stringlengths
3
4.65k
top_comment_4
stringlengths
4
5.05k
top_comment_5
stringlengths
0
3.67k
top_comment_6
stringlengths
8
3.81k
top_comment_7
stringlengths
0
4.55k
top_comment_8
stringlengths
0
3.69k
top_comment_9
stringlengths
0
3.96k
top_comment_10
stringlengths
0
3.43k
top_comment_1_classification
stringclasses
2 values
top_comment_2_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_3_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_4_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_5_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_6_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_7_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_8_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_9_classification
stringclasses
5 values
top_comment_10_classification
stringclasses
5 values
ambiguity_score
float64
0
1
flanT5_instruction
stringlengths
242
3.63k
llama2_instruction
stringlengths
313
4.01k
AITA for walking out of a job interview?
around this time last year, i was in the job hunt and was looking at tech sales positions in my area. i’d been in this career about ten years, and had been recently laid off. i was granted an interview at a relatively large startup downtown, and after the initial phone screen, i did my research and went on site for my in-person interview. admittedly, i got there about 25 minutes early, which was pushing obnoxious, but nobody was at the front desk. so i signed in using the ipad, took a seat, and waited. i waited until the time of the interview, got up, looked around, and started trying to get the attention of people walking around, as nobody had acknowledged me to this point. at 15 minutes past the interview scheduled time, a lady came into the lobby and asked what i was there for. i let her know i had an interview scheduled for 15 minutes ago. she asked me to hold on and went back into the office, and a few minutes later, came back with an agenda with materials laid out about the company. the agenda confirmed that were were supposed to have already started, and that i had two interviewers in the next two 30-minute blocks. a new person came over and sat me in a room and told me to read over the materials to get familiar. i did this for 45 minutes, and when the vp of sales didn’t show up to interview me, i got pissed, stood up, and left. i found my way to the front desk and told the person who was not there before and had likely no idea who i was that i was ending my interview, and to have a great day. about 15 minutes later, i got a frantic call from the recruiter saying the vp was looking for me and that they wanted to start my interview. i answered that if they weren’t willing to respect my time, then i knew all i needed to know about what working there would be like. i told several folks this story, and it’s been a 50/50 on whether or not i did the right thing, or that i don’t know the circumstances and that i could have stuck around and at least interviewed and let them know later on. aita?
19,744
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/gqayhg/aita_for_walking_out_of_a_job_interview/
2020-05-25 13:28:04
nta from the sounds of it, they were 1 hr+ late and didn't offer any reason to you while you were there. that's an enormous red flag.
nta- the interview goes both ways. if they aren’t organized enough now or they don’t respect your time you can’t expect much different once you’re hired.
if the roles were reversed i gurantee you they wouldn't even interview you. job interviews go both ways, nta op.
nta. extremely unprofessional of them. even if it was an honest mix up or something, they were at fault and no way in hell you should have waited around any longer. you probably taught them a lesson (hopefully) and avoided an awful workplace. if they were a decent company they would have ringed you the next day after figuring it out and tried to rebook the interview with their deepest apologies, but i reckon that didn't happen.
yeah, i ended up taking a job at a nonprofit. thanks!
nta- i would have expected to say 'there's been an emergency and vp is running behind but will be with you shortly" not just left you sitting waiting. totally rude to waste your time without an apology.
nta. red flags even before you start working.
nta. when i interview people, i am acutely aware that i am representing my company and as such, it’s as much my job to impress candidates as it is theirs to impress me. the way that company treated you was inexcusable. interviewers showing up an hour late tells me that upper management doesn’t value the time or efforts of their reports. the fact that they were searching desperately for you but never called you directly to offer an apology tells me that they would try to gaslight their way through mistakes and would try to shift blame anywhere but themselves. you did exactly the right thing, op. let them hire folks who don’t know any better, because you’re better off nearly anywhere else.
nta - i once had a strange interview like this except i was dumb enough to stick around for the interview, i went into a tiny box room with the two founders and when they revealed they expected me to work for free for the first two months, i stopped suppressing that dodgy weatherspoons curry i had for lunch, lifted my ass up and let the unholy fart unleash and they looked at me in shock and i said "sorry i was holding that in just in case i was interested" i then walked out and closed the door behind me leaving them in that stench.
so, to answer the initial question: the recruiter scheduled a follow up call with me a few days later to apologize and explain that they were having a busy quarter. i ended up telling her that my issue wasn’t largely with her (though a small part of it was), but rather with the vp who presumably wants to add me to their team, but couldn’t be bothered to pop his head in and say he’s running late. in fact, neither of my interviewees showed up. i also let her know that the fact that he didn’t apologize himself but was using her to do it said volumes. i wished her well.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: around this time last year, i was in the job hunt and was looking at tech sales positions in my area. i’d been in this career about ten years, and had been recently laid off. i was granted an interview at a relatively large startup downtown, and after the initial phone screen, i did my research and went on site for my in-person interview. admittedly, i got there about 25 minutes early, which was pushing obnoxious, but nobody was at the front desk. so i signed in using the ipad, took a seat, and waited. i waited until the time of the interview, got up, looked around, and started trying to get the attention of people walking around, as nobody had acknowledged me to this point. at 15 minutes past the interview scheduled time, a lady came into the lobby and asked what i was there for. i let her know i had an interview scheduled for 15 minutes ago. she asked me to hold on and went back into the office, and a few minutes later, came back with an agenda with materials laid out about the company. the agenda confirmed that were were supposed to have already started, and that i had two interviewers in the next two 30-minute blocks. a new person came over and sat me in a room and told me to read over the materials to get familiar. i did this for 45 minutes, and when the vp of sales didn’t show up to interview me, i got pissed, stood up, and left. i found my way to the front desk and told the person who was not there before and had likely no idea who i was that i was ending my interview, and to have a great day. about 15 minutes later, i got a frantic call from the recruiter saying the vp was looking for me and that they wanted to start my interview. i answered that if they weren’t willing to respect my time, then i knew all i needed to know about what working there would be like. i told several folks this story, and it’s been a 50/50 on whether or not i did the right thing, or that i don’t know the circumstances and that i could have stuck around and at least interviewed and let them know later on. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> around this time last year, i was in the job hunt and was looking at tech sales positions in my area. i’d been in this career about ten years, and had been recently laid off. i was granted an interview at a relatively large startup downtown, and after the initial phone screen, i did my research and went on site for my in-person interview. admittedly, i got there about 25 minutes early, which was pushing obnoxious, but nobody was at the front desk. so i signed in using the ipad, took a seat, and waited. i waited until the time of the interview, got up, looked around, and started trying to get the attention of people walking around, as nobody had acknowledged me to this point. at 15 minutes past the interview scheduled time, a lady came into the lobby and asked what i was there for. i let her know i had an interview scheduled for 15 minutes ago. she asked me to hold on and went back into the office, and a few minutes later, came back with an agenda with materials laid out about the company. the agenda confirmed that were were supposed to have already started, and that i had two interviewers in the next two 30-minute blocks. a new person came over and sat me in a room and told me to read over the materials to get familiar. i did this for 45 minutes, and when the vp of sales didn’t show up to interview me, i got pissed, stood up, and left. i found my way to the front desk and told the person who was not there before and had likely no idea who i was that i was ending my interview, and to have a great day. about 15 minutes later, i got a frantic call from the recruiter saying the vp was looking for me and that they wanted to start my interview. i answered that if they weren’t willing to respect my time, then i knew all i needed to know about what working there would be like. i told several folks this story, and it’s been a 50/50 on whether or not i did the right thing, or that i don’t know the circumstances and that i could have stuck around and at least interviewed and let them know later on. aita? [/INST] nta from the sounds of it, they were 1 hr+ late and didn't offer any reason to you while you were there. that's an enormous red flag. </s>
AITA for crashing my wife’s birthday party and taking her home.
my wife turned 30 this week. i’m 26m. we’ve always had a strong relationship and i love her so much. my wife has a best friend from childhood jimmy 28m. i didn’t know him that well but this year we’ve gotten to know each other and have gotten close. he’s my best bud and like an older brother to me in a lot of ways. my wife goes all out for my birthday parties and i love them. she’s more of a stoic introvert so i thought it would be nice to throw her a surprise 30th birthday with just her and me and make it a special event. i wanted to make her a gift she would love. jimmy’s an incredible artist and for the past two months i’ve been taking lessons from them. my wife was curious why i was spending so much time away from home with jimmy but i made vague excuses because i couldn’t tell her i was making a gift for her. she’s made a couple comments but never seemed upset. i told her a week before her birthday that i had made plans with jimmy. i have a job with flexible hours so it’s not uncommon for me to do it. she wasn’t upset or anything. when her birthday came, it was all i could do not to say anything. when she left for work, i put my plan in action. i decorated the place. i brought out the cake. i learned from youtube and stored it at our friend’s house. i got a dozen bouquets of flowers. i got her a few other gifts too. she was supposed to come home at 5:30 but she didn’t. i waited hours for her but she didn’t come home. i called jimmy and he said he hadn’t seen her. i called her and she didn’t pick up. i checked her location and she was at a restaurant. i went to the restaurant and she was there with her friends. they were eating a birthday cake and she had presents. i never met these friends of hers before. i think they’re from her work. she seemed sad. she wasn’t smiling or energetic. i wanted to take her home and show her my gift so she would be happy. i came over to her and told her she had to come home. we grabbed her things and left. on the uber back, she didn’t say anything. at home she started crying. she has been sleeping on the couch and she avoids me. my wife hasn’t talked to jimmy either. i told my mom and she called me an asshole. i don’t know why. aita?
16,485
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/z4o1sz/aita_for_crashing_my_wifes_birthday_party_and/
2022-11-25 21:00:16
yta. you didn’t use the critical piece of surprise party planning where you have her home at a certain time for a “good reason”. you just made it look like you were blowing her off, and she made other plans. you honestly just made it look like you remembered her birthday at the last minute and went overboard to try to make up for it. and instead of apologizing, you forced her to appreciate your thoughtfulness.
yta. you told her you had plans on her birthday and she made her own plans. when you plan a surprise, it’s on you to make sure the person will be available. the plans she made with her friends were not less important that your poorly executed surprise.
yta. you shouldn't be interrupting you wife's dinner for your awful execution of her birthday surprise. you also seem really hung up on the fact she went out which is odd to me. perhaps the dinner plans only materlised that day. friend: "hey op's wife, what are you doing for your birthday tonight?" op's wife: "nothing - i think my husband forgot" friend: "no no no, you aren't doing nothing for your birthday - we are going to get dinner" maybe your wife looked sad at dinner becuase she thought her husband didn't do anything for her birthday.
yta. you tried to do something nice, but you went about it the wrong way. surprises are often a bad idea. this is a case and point. you told your wife you wouldn’t be free on her birthday, so she made other plans. you embarrassed her in front of her friends, friends who had taken her out for her birthday. of course she is upset.
yta you’ve been sneaking around and giving her vague half-@ssed excuses about where you go. the day of her birthday you tell her you have plans and will be busy… so she makes plans on her own, goes and tries to celebrate her bday anyway because you’ve been acting distant and aloof. then you crash that and drag her away? the “surprise” wasn’t for her - it was about you. “look what i did! look how awesome i am!” you made her feel like crap, for weeks, then on her birthday made her feel even worse.
what is actually wrong with you? people were celebrating her birthday and you dragged her away?
wow… you *tracked her* when she didn’t answer you and then you *forced her to go home with you*. you sound insecure at best and fucking abusive at worst. absolutely yta. editing to add based on your constant “she doesn’t go out ever, she doesn’t have any other friends, why would she have friends i haven’t met, why would i have to ask her to come straight home” makes me lean even more towards you are probably controlling and she is trying to find a fucking way out. i hope she does and you realize that not communicating with your partner isn’t *romantic*, it is fucked up. editing to add the tracking isn’t out of the ordinary in relationships. what is concerning to me is that he was tracking her when she was avoiding him. she didn’t want to answer his calls or texts at the moment so she almost certainly didn’t want him *showing up because he tracked her location*.
yta i'm guessing she thought you forgot and that jimmy did too, so her other friends or maybe her work friends took her out to try and cheer her up. i get you planned something very special for her, but in the future you need to at least say something like "don't make plans, we already have some but i can't tell you what". in your wife's eyes both you and her best friend totally forgot about her special day, by the way 30 or any 10 year is considered a milestone. please apologize and tell her how much you love her, that next time you will let her know that there are at least plans, even if you can't give details. i personally know what it's like to feel forgotten, but the end of the day when my hubby didn't acknowledge or my best friend because they had planned a surprise party my mood was 100% ruined as i thought they had forgotten. please, please, please communicate better. again you don't have to tell her details, just let her know that there are at least plans and make sure to wish her happy birthday immediately on her birthday.
info: why didn’t you just join the group at the restaurant? and tell her there is a surprise at home when she’s ready? did you say anything in the uber? did she see the flowers/decor and not say anything? how many days ago was this, and why haven’t you apologized for not communicating adequately yet?
yta. i hate surprise birthdays where the main message is “i’ve forgotten your birthday” you can do surprises without that part. i don’t know why people get such a boner for purposely hurting there loved ones before making them happy.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my wife turned 30 this week. i’m 26m. we’ve always had a strong relationship and i love her so much. my wife has a best friend from childhood jimmy 28m. i didn’t know him that well but this year we’ve gotten to know each other and have gotten close. he’s my best bud and like an older brother to me in a lot of ways. my wife goes all out for my birthday parties and i love them. she’s more of a stoic introvert so i thought it would be nice to throw her a surprise 30th birthday with just her and me and make it a special event. i wanted to make her a gift she would love. jimmy’s an incredible artist and for the past two months i’ve been taking lessons from them. my wife was curious why i was spending so much time away from home with jimmy but i made vague excuses because i couldn’t tell her i was making a gift for her. she’s made a couple comments but never seemed upset. i told her a week before her birthday that i had made plans with jimmy. i have a job with flexible hours so it’s not uncommon for me to do it. she wasn’t upset or anything. when her birthday came, it was all i could do not to say anything. when she left for work, i put my plan in action. i decorated the place. i brought out the cake. i learned from youtube and stored it at our friend’s house. i got a dozen bouquets of flowers. i got her a few other gifts too. she was supposed to come home at 5:30 but she didn’t. i waited hours for her but she didn’t come home. i called jimmy and he said he hadn’t seen her. i called her and she didn’t pick up. i checked her location and she was at a restaurant. i went to the restaurant and she was there with her friends. they were eating a birthday cake and she had presents. i never met these friends of hers before. i think they’re from her work. she seemed sad. she wasn’t smiling or energetic. i wanted to take her home and show her my gift so she would be happy. i came over to her and told her she had to come home. we grabbed her things and left. on the uber back, she didn’t say anything. at home she started crying. she has been sleeping on the couch and she avoids me. my wife hasn’t talked to jimmy either. i told my mom and she called me an asshole. i don’t know why. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my wife turned 30 this week. i’m 26m. we’ve always had a strong relationship and i love her so much. my wife has a best friend from childhood jimmy 28m. i didn’t know him that well but this year we’ve gotten to know each other and have gotten close. he’s my best bud and like an older brother to me in a lot of ways. my wife goes all out for my birthday parties and i love them. she’s more of a stoic introvert so i thought it would be nice to throw her a surprise 30th birthday with just her and me and make it a special event. i wanted to make her a gift she would love. jimmy’s an incredible artist and for the past two months i’ve been taking lessons from them. my wife was curious why i was spending so much time away from home with jimmy but i made vague excuses because i couldn’t tell her i was making a gift for her. she’s made a couple comments but never seemed upset. i told her a week before her birthday that i had made plans with jimmy. i have a job with flexible hours so it’s not uncommon for me to do it. she wasn’t upset or anything. when her birthday came, it was all i could do not to say anything. when she left for work, i put my plan in action. i decorated the place. i brought out the cake. i learned from youtube and stored it at our friend’s house. i got a dozen bouquets of flowers. i got her a few other gifts too. she was supposed to come home at 5:30 but she didn’t. i waited hours for her but she didn’t come home. i called jimmy and he said he hadn’t seen her. i called her and she didn’t pick up. i checked her location and she was at a restaurant. i went to the restaurant and she was there with her friends. they were eating a birthday cake and she had presents. i never met these friends of hers before. i think they’re from her work. she seemed sad. she wasn’t smiling or energetic. i wanted to take her home and show her my gift so she would be happy. i came over to her and told her she had to come home. we grabbed her things and left. on the uber back, she didn’t say anything. at home she started crying. she has been sleeping on the couch and she avoids me. my wife hasn’t talked to jimmy either. i told my mom and she called me an asshole. i don’t know why. aita? [/INST] yta. you didn’t use the critical piece of surprise party planning where you have her home at a certain time for a “good reason”. you just made it look like you were blowing her off, and she made other plans. you honestly just made it look like you remembered her birthday at the last minute and went overboard to try to make up for it. and instead of apologizing, you forced her to appreciate your thoughtfulness. </s>
AITA for bringing a really sassy doctor's note to school for a medical excemption?
so my school made this dumb rule that nobody can have a water or drink bottle with them because a couple seniors got caught drinking vodka at school. the only exception is if you have a form signed by your doctor saying there's a medical reason you need it. and carry the note with you whenever you have a water bottle so you can show it to teachers or administration. now, my doctor who i have my yearly checkup with is also one of my mom's best friends, and last week she and her daughter were coming around to hang out with our family. i was telling her and my mom about the school rule and they thought it was silly too. my doctor was talking about how unhealthy it was to not let kids drink water all day, and sell them sugary sodas at lunch i asked if she'd sign a doctor's note allowing me a water bottle and she said od course. so i printed out the form and she signed it. there was a section saying to describe the medical need and she wrote "water is necessary for life" which my mom thought was funny but also thought might get the note rejected, like it was obviously meant for specific medical conditions or disabilities. but she said that if anyone had a problem with it, to have them call her and they'd get a piece of her mind. so i took the note to school and a bunch of teachers told me i couldn't have a water bottle and i said i had a note. most of them didn't read it closely enough to see the reson but out of the two that did, one laughed about it and asked if it was real. i said it was, she could call the number on the form. she seemed satisfied. the other teacher threatened to take the note away, saying medical exemptions were not a joke, it was a disrespectful thing to do, disrespectful to the school's rules and disrespectful to people who had an actual medical need, to treat it as a joke. i know my doctor hadn't meant it as a joke about actual medical problems... aita for bringing a sassy doctor's note to school? it said my medical need to be allowed to have a water bottle was "water is necessary for life"
18,637
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/f1v41u/aita_for_bringing_a_really_sassy_doctors_note_to/
2020-02-10 19:08:54
nta - water is a human right. screw your school.
nta she’s right, it’s vital for life, the school shouldn’t let those that were drinking vodka ruin it for everyone else especially since being hydrated allows your brain to work properly. do they expect a bunch of dehydrated kids to learn any info when their brains are malnourished?
nta &gt;saying medical exemptions were not a joke, it was a disrespectful thing to do, disrespectful to the school's rules and disrespectful to people who had an actual medical need, to treat it as a joke. making a kid go all day without drinking water is a joke, water is an actual "medical" need for every human ever. the other teacher can fuck right off.
nta &gt; it was a disrespectful thing to do, disrespectful to the school's rules and disrespectful to people who had an actual medical need and this teacher is acting disrespectful toward your doctor and your medical exemption. after all, there was no lie there.
nta. you school sound alike it's run by a bunch of dumbasses. not letting students drink water can lead to dehydration making it more difficult for you to learn besides all the other bad stuff that comes with dehydration. this is a horrible thing for your school to do to its students, you should leak this info to your local news.
nta. it continually amazes me that public institutions in the u.s. are allowed to treat children less well than the geneva convention allows the government to treat prisoners of war. i get that kids can be little assholes at times, but that doesn't excuse schools treating the children under their care as some kind of hostile legion of combatants. the shit i hear--not letting students have water, not letting them go to the bathroom during class or giving them enough time to use the bathroom between classes, throwing away hot lunches in front of them because their school lunch account is empty, etc.--absolutely blows me away. i've heard so many stories of students at all grade levels literally pissing themselves in class because their power-tripping teachers won't let them use the bathroom. banning water bottles because of hysterics around controlled substances just reeks of the eight-o'clock-news fabrications along the lines of "are *your* children getting high off soup cans?!" the whole thing is absurd. all that to say: fight the power, kid. drink your water while maintaining sarcastic eye contact with your teacher, and enjoy every drop.
stfu you know you're not the asshole
nta. that policy is absolutely ridiculous. students are human beings too. hope that one teacher tries to take a different student’s note and gets in massive trouble
nta. that is so stupid. tell that teacher to call the number on your slip. let her enjoy a good scolding by a medical professional.
nta they can’t tell you you can’t drink water, especially if you have a doctors note. also you can put vodka (or any alcohol) in soda too sooo
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: so my school made this dumb rule that nobody can have a water or drink bottle with them because a couple seniors got caught drinking vodka at school. the only exception is if you have a form signed by your doctor saying there's a medical reason you need it. and carry the note with you whenever you have a water bottle so you can show it to teachers or administration. now, my doctor who i have my yearly checkup with is also one of my mom's best friends, and last week she and her daughter were coming around to hang out with our family. i was telling her and my mom about the school rule and they thought it was silly too. my doctor was talking about how unhealthy it was to not let kids drink water all day, and sell them sugary sodas at lunch i asked if she'd sign a doctor's note allowing me a water bottle and she said od course. so i printed out the form and she signed it. there was a section saying to describe the medical need and she wrote "water is necessary for life" which my mom thought was funny but also thought might get the note rejected, like it was obviously meant for specific medical conditions or disabilities. but she said that if anyone had a problem with it, to have them call her and they'd get a piece of her mind. so i took the note to school and a bunch of teachers told me i couldn't have a water bottle and i said i had a note. most of them didn't read it closely enough to see the reson but out of the two that did, one laughed about it and asked if it was real. i said it was, she could call the number on the form. she seemed satisfied. the other teacher threatened to take the note away, saying medical exemptions were not a joke, it was a disrespectful thing to do, disrespectful to the school's rules and disrespectful to people who had an actual medical need, to treat it as a joke. i know my doctor hadn't meant it as a joke about actual medical problems... aita for bringing a sassy doctor's note to school? it said my medical need to be allowed to have a water bottle was "water is necessary for life"
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> so my school made this dumb rule that nobody can have a water or drink bottle with them because a couple seniors got caught drinking vodka at school. the only exception is if you have a form signed by your doctor saying there's a medical reason you need it. and carry the note with you whenever you have a water bottle so you can show it to teachers or administration. now, my doctor who i have my yearly checkup with is also one of my mom's best friends, and last week she and her daughter were coming around to hang out with our family. i was telling her and my mom about the school rule and they thought it was silly too. my doctor was talking about how unhealthy it was to not let kids drink water all day, and sell them sugary sodas at lunch i asked if she'd sign a doctor's note allowing me a water bottle and she said od course. so i printed out the form and she signed it. there was a section saying to describe the medical need and she wrote "water is necessary for life" which my mom thought was funny but also thought might get the note rejected, like it was obviously meant for specific medical conditions or disabilities. but she said that if anyone had a problem with it, to have them call her and they'd get a piece of her mind. so i took the note to school and a bunch of teachers told me i couldn't have a water bottle and i said i had a note. most of them didn't read it closely enough to see the reson but out of the two that did, one laughed about it and asked if it was real. i said it was, she could call the number on the form. she seemed satisfied. the other teacher threatened to take the note away, saying medical exemptions were not a joke, it was a disrespectful thing to do, disrespectful to the school's rules and disrespectful to people who had an actual medical need, to treat it as a joke. i know my doctor hadn't meant it as a joke about actual medical problems... aita for bringing a sassy doctor's note to school? it said my medical need to be allowed to have a water bottle was "water is necessary for life" [/INST] nta - water is a human right. screw your school. </s>
AITA for telling the judge of a scholarship competition that if she already knew who she wanted to win, to cut the crap and just let us all go home?
i'm in high school, we had a final presentation before winter break, and we had judges from the community come in to reward the best presentations. like not actual court room judges, just people who were involved in stuff locally. the prize was some scholarship money for college. our classrooms judge was a mom who in the school board and when we were doing the presentations she was showing really obvious favoritism to her daughter's best friend who i know is tight with that family. i know her presentation wasn't even her own, it was plagarized a lot and not very good, i saw her doing it in the computer lab days earlier. it was annoying how the "outside judge"kept going back to coo over this one presentation even after everyone had moved on and other people had presented. it was super awkward, like she was praising this one girl after a different kid had just presented?? like maybe pay attention to the person who's at the podium, not your little favorite?? it was my turn but i'd already seen her phoning it in when watching the last few, playing on her phone even! not paying attention. i felt like it was pretty obvious she'd already decided who would would win. and that frustrated me, i'd worked really hard on mine and if her behavior is in the last few presentations was gonna continue, i knew she wouldn't even be listening. so i went up and said "look, we all know you already know who you're gonna give the prize to, we've all seen you play on your phone and ignore everyone who came after your daughters best friend, so can we just cut the crap and go home? i'm not gonna stand up here and give a presentation to someone who's disrespecting our efforts and playing on their phone when anyone who's not a friend of your family is talking." she sure paid attention then, and went to talk to my teacher in a whisper. my teacher sent me to the principal's office. the girl i expected to win, won... no surprise there. but i felt good i'd at least said something. a bunch of my friends in class said i was totally right when i called out that bs, and we all knew it, i wasn't saying anything we didn't all see. my principal kept telling me that it didn't seem like i was taking my college apps seriously and i said that i didn't think i'd be going to college, i got stuck with debt already and i'm gonna need a job right away this spring. anyway i got detention aita for saying what i did instead of doing my final presentation for the project?
27,428
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/f0rue1/aita_for_telling_the_judge_of_a_scholarship/
2020-02-08 13:53:24
nta. this judge was not impartial and should not have been a judge in the first place. the fact that the school did not address that is an issue.
nta. i'd see if there's a dispute process. it's obvious that this person should not have been judging this competition.
wtf is this country where we make children perform like show ponies to compete over meager sums of money to avoid generating crippling debt by continuing their education...
nta. but it sounds like you could have told her your opinion and still given the presentation.
hey, fyi, if she picked the person without giving good attention to the others and obviously picked who it was from personal favoritism... that's taxable. that's a gift. i'd go to the organization she's from and report what happened and also let them know that if there wasn't a proper look into why the judge wasn't an impartial 3rd party then you'll report the abuse for tax fraud. how do i know this? my mom was on a community board that helped with scholarships. we agreed that i wouldn't apply to those scholarships unless i was super qualified and that she stepped down from judging that year. and they gave fake names to everyone's essays. i didn't win. i got other scholarships so that's ok. my family is really involved with scholarships from the local suburbia women's society (aka old stay at home moms - they actually do really great social projects such as raising $100k to update the local park and bought instruments for the high school band). they also helped raise over $400k this year for the children's hospital (but many groups were involved with that one, so not entirely from them). the entire group takes it very seriously is it looks like there's impartiality.
nta you called out an unfair situation and you should take it further
info was she the only judge?
nta this is why you need several judges
nta - you’re my hero.
nta- a judge should be completely neutral and respectful of everyone's efforts, and she was neither. you were right to call her out and well done for doing so- everyone was thinking it, you were just brave enough to say it.
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
null
NTA
INFO
NTA
NTA
NTA
0.005167
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm in high school, we had a final presentation before winter break, and we had judges from the community come in to reward the best presentations. like not actual court room judges, just people who were involved in stuff locally. the prize was some scholarship money for college. our classrooms judge was a mom who in the school board and when we were doing the presentations she was showing really obvious favoritism to her daughter's best friend who i know is tight with that family. i know her presentation wasn't even her own, it was plagarized a lot and not very good, i saw her doing it in the computer lab days earlier. it was annoying how the "outside judge"kept going back to coo over this one presentation even after everyone had moved on and other people had presented. it was super awkward, like she was praising this one girl after a different kid had just presented?? like maybe pay attention to the person who's at the podium, not your little favorite?? it was my turn but i'd already seen her phoning it in when watching the last few, playing on her phone even! not paying attention. i felt like it was pretty obvious she'd already decided who would would win. and that frustrated me, i'd worked really hard on mine and if her behavior is in the last few presentations was gonna continue, i knew she wouldn't even be listening. so i went up and said "look, we all know you already know who you're gonna give the prize to, we've all seen you play on your phone and ignore everyone who came after your daughters best friend, so can we just cut the crap and go home? i'm not gonna stand up here and give a presentation to someone who's disrespecting our efforts and playing on their phone when anyone who's not a friend of your family is talking." she sure paid attention then, and went to talk to my teacher in a whisper. my teacher sent me to the principal's office. the girl i expected to win, won... no surprise there. but i felt good i'd at least said something. a bunch of my friends in class said i was totally right when i called out that bs, and we all knew it, i wasn't saying anything we didn't all see. my principal kept telling me that it didn't seem like i was taking my college apps seriously and i said that i didn't think i'd be going to college, i got stuck with debt already and i'm gonna need a job right away this spring. anyway i got detention aita for saying what i did instead of doing my final presentation for the project?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm in high school, we had a final presentation before winter break, and we had judges from the community come in to reward the best presentations. like not actual court room judges, just people who were involved in stuff locally. the prize was some scholarship money for college. our classrooms judge was a mom who in the school board and when we were doing the presentations she was showing really obvious favoritism to her daughter's best friend who i know is tight with that family. i know her presentation wasn't even her own, it was plagarized a lot and not very good, i saw her doing it in the computer lab days earlier. it was annoying how the "outside judge"kept going back to coo over this one presentation even after everyone had moved on and other people had presented. it was super awkward, like she was praising this one girl after a different kid had just presented?? like maybe pay attention to the person who's at the podium, not your little favorite?? it was my turn but i'd already seen her phoning it in when watching the last few, playing on her phone even! not paying attention. i felt like it was pretty obvious she'd already decided who would would win. and that frustrated me, i'd worked really hard on mine and if her behavior is in the last few presentations was gonna continue, i knew she wouldn't even be listening. so i went up and said "look, we all know you already know who you're gonna give the prize to, we've all seen you play on your phone and ignore everyone who came after your daughters best friend, so can we just cut the crap and go home? i'm not gonna stand up here and give a presentation to someone who's disrespecting our efforts and playing on their phone when anyone who's not a friend of your family is talking." she sure paid attention then, and went to talk to my teacher in a whisper. my teacher sent me to the principal's office. the girl i expected to win, won... no surprise there. but i felt good i'd at least said something. a bunch of my friends in class said i was totally right when i called out that bs, and we all knew it, i wasn't saying anything we didn't all see. my principal kept telling me that it didn't seem like i was taking my college apps seriously and i said that i didn't think i'd be going to college, i got stuck with debt already and i'm gonna need a job right away this spring. anyway i got detention aita for saying what i did instead of doing my final presentation for the project? [/INST] nta. this judge was not impartial and should not have been a judge in the first place. the fact that the school did not address that is an issue. </s>
AITA for not paying for my siblings to go to uni?
i'm 29f, my siblings are 19f, 19f(twins) and 17m. about a year ago i won a rather large amount of money. since then i paid off my mortgage, bought a rental home, paid for my parents to spent 2 months on holiday, paid off their mortgage and bought each of my younger siblings either a car or(in the case of my brother) a motorbike. i have recently started planning my wedding to my partner of 4 years. originally we were going to have a very low budget wedding because neither of us were particularly wealthy and have little financial support from our parents(hers are homophobic and mine are just not well off enough to spend money on a wedding), but now we plan on having a slightly bigger wedding. however during these discussions my mother has been getting increasingly upset at the amount im spending(wedding will be around 40-50k all up including honeymoon and partner is contributing 12k, so its not like we're spending an astronomical amount), and has repeatedly suggested that we stick to our low budget plans and give money to her for my siblings college funds instead. these comments have been confusing me because she has told me in the past that she got 20k when i was born to put towards my college fund from her parents and then 10k for each of my siblings. i got though college on scholarships and my part time job so presumably she has 50k already for my siblings college fund. this came to a head about a week ago when she came with me to go to my fitting for my wedding dress and she saw the price tag($3k), she had a complete meltdown in the store about me wasting money and how she needed it and i confronted her about the college fund. she admitted that she and my dad had spent the money on trips away, alcohol and gambling a d now there was almost nothing left. i said if she wasted 50k meant for her children's college funds then why should i give her any more? at this point she stormed out after throwing her glass of wine on my dress(that cost $300 to clean) and has since said that she's not coming to my wedding and will stop my dad/siblings from coming. aita here?
21,346
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hmryph/aita_for_not_paying_for_my_siblings_to_go_to_uni/
2020-07-07 10:21:14
nta. it's in no way your fault or responsibility that your mother squandered her own children's college fund. if you want to help your siblings through college it should be at your discretion and not at her demand.
nta - she's toxic. it's money for your future you've already done more than enough for your family. you bothers can work hard and get a solarship or do what most do take out loans and work. if you let then ride your coattails you won't be helping them in the long run.
very much nta. in fact, your mother seems ta here. she waisted your siblings' college funds on booze, trips, and gambling. if it were for keeping them fed or a roof over their heads, that would be different, but it was for cheep fun and thrills. you are in the right here and it is reasonable to deny her any money, especially after you already have given her so much. now, if your siblings come to you for college help, i would not deny them outright, but come up with a plan with them. clearly, you are more financially stable than your parents so at least hear them out. also, suggestion, community college? i'm in one right now and it's just as good as the first 2 years at a university, well, depending on which one you go to.
nta. if their house is paid off, they can use that as equity to take out a loan to repay their debt to your siblings. if you’re feeling generous, provide tuition money directly to your siblings. your parents clearly can’t manage finances.
nta it's your money to do with as you please, if you decide to collect it all in cash and use for a camp fire that's your choice, no one has any say to what you use it for. give the money to her and she's 100% going to gamble it away, your folks obviously have a gambling addiction. the fact she's trying to manipulate you by saying that you're spending too much money on your wedding, shows she's isn't even considering you in any way or fashion, all she see is the money she could be spending. don't let her rob you of your desired wedding. if you do decide to assist your siblings with their college fees, handle the expenses directly, don't even give your siblings the money cause your parents might find a way to collect it from them.
nta she didn't want the money for your siblings, she wanted it for herself.
you won a chunk of money and with it paid off their mortgage and sent them on a 2 month vacation? that is an extreme level of generosity. plus the vehicles on top of it for your siblings? sooooooo nta. you have every right to spend your money the way that you see fit. period. the fact that your parents squandered your siblings college money and then took a sizeable amount of gift money from you and then demanded that you fork over even more money is the height of selfishness. they screwed your siblings over, not you. and your mother trying to shift the blame is pathetic. if you help your siblings, it is your choice. and it's a hard choice. you and your partner need to sit down and hash this out to prevent any future resentments or regrets on either side. but whatever decision you make won't be wrong. again, your parents are greedy, dishonest and irresponsible. they caused this massive issue, dumped it in your lap and are trying to make you the bad guy to deflect. then they had an opportunity to funnel the money coming to them back into the college fund but choose to take care of themselves first, again. the balls, on your mother at least, are astounding. nta.
nta you've been very generous and she's being extremely pushy. you already bought all your siblings cars which will help them support themselves through college, and paid off your parents debts. it's your money and you can do whatever you want, including having a nice wedding. even if you do change your mind later and help your siblings, don't give the money to her, give it directly to them. she's proven she can't be trusted with it.
[deleted]
nta, but i think this is fake. she spent the college fund on alcohol? seriously? that’s a grocery item that you would not withdraw from a college fund to buy. it all just sounds too stereotypical, like it’s being written by a 15 year old kid.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm 29f, my siblings are 19f, 19f(twins) and 17m. about a year ago i won a rather large amount of money. since then i paid off my mortgage, bought a rental home, paid for my parents to spent 2 months on holiday, paid off their mortgage and bought each of my younger siblings either a car or(in the case of my brother) a motorbike. i have recently started planning my wedding to my partner of 4 years. originally we were going to have a very low budget wedding because neither of us were particularly wealthy and have little financial support from our parents(hers are homophobic and mine are just not well off enough to spend money on a wedding), but now we plan on having a slightly bigger wedding. however during these discussions my mother has been getting increasingly upset at the amount im spending(wedding will be around 40-50k all up including honeymoon and partner is contributing 12k, so its not like we're spending an astronomical amount), and has repeatedly suggested that we stick to our low budget plans and give money to her for my siblings college funds instead. these comments have been confusing me because she has told me in the past that she got 20k when i was born to put towards my college fund from her parents and then 10k for each of my siblings. i got though college on scholarships and my part time job so presumably she has 50k already for my siblings college fund. this came to a head about a week ago when she came with me to go to my fitting for my wedding dress and she saw the price tag($3k), she had a complete meltdown in the store about me wasting money and how she needed it and i confronted her about the college fund. she admitted that she and my dad had spent the money on trips away, alcohol and gambling a d now there was almost nothing left. i said if she wasted 50k meant for her children's college funds then why should i give her any more? at this point she stormed out after throwing her glass of wine on my dress(that cost $300 to clean) and has since said that she's not coming to my wedding and will stop my dad/siblings from coming. aita here?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm 29f, my siblings are 19f, 19f(twins) and 17m. about a year ago i won a rather large amount of money. since then i paid off my mortgage, bought a rental home, paid for my parents to spent 2 months on holiday, paid off their mortgage and bought each of my younger siblings either a car or(in the case of my brother) a motorbike. i have recently started planning my wedding to my partner of 4 years. originally we were going to have a very low budget wedding because neither of us were particularly wealthy and have little financial support from our parents(hers are homophobic and mine are just not well off enough to spend money on a wedding), but now we plan on having a slightly bigger wedding. however during these discussions my mother has been getting increasingly upset at the amount im spending(wedding will be around 40-50k all up including honeymoon and partner is contributing 12k, so its not like we're spending an astronomical amount), and has repeatedly suggested that we stick to our low budget plans and give money to her for my siblings college funds instead. these comments have been confusing me because she has told me in the past that she got 20k when i was born to put towards my college fund from her parents and then 10k for each of my siblings. i got though college on scholarships and my part time job so presumably she has 50k already for my siblings college fund. this came to a head about a week ago when she came with me to go to my fitting for my wedding dress and she saw the price tag($3k), she had a complete meltdown in the store about me wasting money and how she needed it and i confronted her about the college fund. she admitted that she and my dad had spent the money on trips away, alcohol and gambling a d now there was almost nothing left. i said if she wasted 50k meant for her children's college funds then why should i give her any more? at this point she stormed out after throwing her glass of wine on my dress(that cost $300 to clean) and has since said that she's not coming to my wedding and will stop my dad/siblings from coming. aita here? [/INST] nta. it's in no way your fault or responsibility that your mother squandered her own children's college fund. if you want to help your siblings through college it should be at your discretion and not at her demand. </s>
AITA For not telling my BF about strippers at a bachelorette party
my bf and i have been together for almost 4 years. we met in college, started dating our junior year and are part of the same friend group. a couple friends of ours were supposed to get married last summer, but had to delay it to this year. we are both in the wedding party and were invited to the bachelor/bachelorette parties. during the planning for the bachelor party, my bf told me that the best man wanted to go to a strip club and the groom got the go-ahead from the bride. i am very uncomfortable with strip clubs, just always have been. i am not trying to shame sex workers in any way, but strip clubs just always grossed me out. i told my bf this and told him i would feel much better if he didn't participate in that part of the bachelor party. i wasn't going to tell him he can't go to the party at all, just that when other people go to a strip club, that he finds something else to do. we kind of got into a fight about it because he was worried that he would be the only one not going to the club and would therefore be alone at a bar or have to leave altogether if the rest of the party wanted to stay there for a long time. i understand that part, but i was pretty firm that i didn't want him to go to the club part of it and he eventually relented. the parties were scheduled for the same weekend and the bachelorette party got a hotel suite for the night. well, it turns out that the maid of honor hired a couple of male strippers to come to the room for a private show. i wasn't really comfortable with it and tried to leave, but the rest of the girls pretty much made me stay. after the parties, i asked my bf how the bachelor party went and he pretty much just said it was fun and that he hung out at a bar with another couple guys while the rest went to a strip club for an hour or so. he asked how my party went and i told him it was fun, but didn't mention the male strippers. i don't know why i didn't tell him, i just didn't. at the wedding reception a couple weeks later, i was talking with some people and noticed my bf talking with a group of people in the wedding party across the room and they were all laughing except my bf. i keep looking at them and eventually my bf looks at me and he's just staring daggers at me. like, i have never seen him look at me like that before and i felt really uncomfortable. he was really cold with me the rest of the night and he ended up getting pretty drunk and passing out at the hotel as soon as we got there. on the car ride home the next day he finally opened up and told me that one of the bridesmaids had told him about the strippers and he was pissed that i would tell him not to go to a strip club and then go and hang out with male strippers in a private hotel room show. he said that was way worse than any strip club and that i was a huge asshole and hypocrite for it. he said he feels like i'm hiding something because i didn't tell him about the strippers and he doesn't believe me that nothing happened.
4,102
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/oxcfi3/aita_for_not_telling_my_bf_about_strippers_at_a/
2021-08-03 20:41:16
yta, how did the other girls "make you stay"? why couldn't you go to the hotel bar? and why didn't you tell your bf and explain the situation?
yta - how would you not be the asshole here? you made a big stink about the idea of him going to the strip club, yet you participated in the exact same thing. and then lied about it, too. plus, i actually kind of agree that your situation is worse (private room thing vs strip club itself) objectively, you're a hypocrite. while it doesn't necessarily make you a bad person, yes, you're definitely the asshole.
yta. obviously. how are you even asking this? &gt; but the rest of the girls pretty much made me stay. no they didnt. you could have left but you probably put up minimal resistance and got convinced to stay incredibly easily. &gt; i don't know why i didn't tell him, i just didn't. you know *exactly* why you didnt tell him. &gt;he said he feels like i'm hiding something because i didn't tell him about the strippers and he doesn't believe me that nothing happened. if my partner did this to me i'd definitely be suspicious, this is a massive betrayal of trust.
yta. you glossed over how the rest of the girls "pretty much made" you stay. it sounds like they exerted social pressure. of course, that was the same kind of social pressure your boyfriend faced, although he had advance notice. you asked your boyfriend to conform to your standards, but you did not conform to them yourself. then, you committed a lie by omission by not telling your boyfriend what happened after the fact. from beginning to end you are wrong. for the record, i am not comfortable in strip clubs either.
yta. you're a literal hypocrite. you didn't want your boyfriend doing something, and then you turned around and did the exact thing you didn't want him doing. no one /forced/ you to stay, you just had 0 backbone and got peer pressured into staying. yikes.
&gt; he said that was way worse than any strip club and that i was a huge asshole and hypocrite for it. is there something in his assessment you disagree with?
yta. and a hypocrite. how could you possibly not be ta? you told him he wasnt allowed to have strippers in the full knowledge there were strippers at your bachelorette party . and then didnt tell him about stating afterwards when there was a 100% chance he would find out. "made you stay". how exactly? exactly in the same way your bf didnt allow anyone to peer-pressure him into going to the strip club. "he doesnt believe me that nothing happened". i wouldnt believe anything you say. everything he said is justified.
yta. you chose to stay in the room with strippers. unless they tied you up, knocked you out, or put a gun to your head, you were not forced to stay. you could have chosen to leave. you chose to lie (by omission) to your boyfriend. you were hiding things from him, and he's right to feel hurt by it.
a classic "rules for thee, but not for me" situation. clearly yta short of them welding the doors shut i doubt very much that they made you stay. and you should have told your boyfriend. i'll bet any amount of money if the tables were turned you'd be furious at him.
yta you're a liar. no reason he should trust you.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my bf and i have been together for almost 4 years. we met in college, started dating our junior year and are part of the same friend group. a couple friends of ours were supposed to get married last summer, but had to delay it to this year. we are both in the wedding party and were invited to the bachelor/bachelorette parties. during the planning for the bachelor party, my bf told me that the best man wanted to go to a strip club and the groom got the go-ahead from the bride. i am very uncomfortable with strip clubs, just always have been. i am not trying to shame sex workers in any way, but strip clubs just always grossed me out. i told my bf this and told him i would feel much better if he didn't participate in that part of the bachelor party. i wasn't going to tell him he can't go to the party at all, just that when other people go to a strip club, that he finds something else to do. we kind of got into a fight about it because he was worried that he would be the only one not going to the club and would therefore be alone at a bar or have to leave altogether if the rest of the party wanted to stay there for a long time. i understand that part, but i was pretty firm that i didn't want him to go to the club part of it and he eventually relented. the parties were scheduled for the same weekend and the bachelorette party got a hotel suite for the night. well, it turns out that the maid of honor hired a couple of male strippers to come to the room for a private show. i wasn't really comfortable with it and tried to leave, but the rest of the girls pretty much made me stay. after the parties, i asked my bf how the bachelor party went and he pretty much just said it was fun and that he hung out at a bar with another couple guys while the rest went to a strip club for an hour or so. he asked how my party went and i told him it was fun, but didn't mention the male strippers. i don't know why i didn't tell him, i just didn't. at the wedding reception a couple weeks later, i was talking with some people and noticed my bf talking with a group of people in the wedding party across the room and they were all laughing except my bf. i keep looking at them and eventually my bf looks at me and he's just staring daggers at me. like, i have never seen him look at me like that before and i felt really uncomfortable. he was really cold with me the rest of the night and he ended up getting pretty drunk and passing out at the hotel as soon as we got there. on the car ride home the next day he finally opened up and told me that one of the bridesmaids had told him about the strippers and he was pissed that i would tell him not to go to a strip club and then go and hang out with male strippers in a private hotel room show. he said that was way worse than any strip club and that i was a huge asshole and hypocrite for it. he said he feels like i'm hiding something because i didn't tell him about the strippers and he doesn't believe me that nothing happened.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my bf and i have been together for almost 4 years. we met in college, started dating our junior year and are part of the same friend group. a couple friends of ours were supposed to get married last summer, but had to delay it to this year. we are both in the wedding party and were invited to the bachelor/bachelorette parties. during the planning for the bachelor party, my bf told me that the best man wanted to go to a strip club and the groom got the go-ahead from the bride. i am very uncomfortable with strip clubs, just always have been. i am not trying to shame sex workers in any way, but strip clubs just always grossed me out. i told my bf this and told him i would feel much better if he didn't participate in that part of the bachelor party. i wasn't going to tell him he can't go to the party at all, just that when other people go to a strip club, that he finds something else to do. we kind of got into a fight about it because he was worried that he would be the only one not going to the club and would therefore be alone at a bar or have to leave altogether if the rest of the party wanted to stay there for a long time. i understand that part, but i was pretty firm that i didn't want him to go to the club part of it and he eventually relented. the parties were scheduled for the same weekend and the bachelorette party got a hotel suite for the night. well, it turns out that the maid of honor hired a couple of male strippers to come to the room for a private show. i wasn't really comfortable with it and tried to leave, but the rest of the girls pretty much made me stay. after the parties, i asked my bf how the bachelor party went and he pretty much just said it was fun and that he hung out at a bar with another couple guys while the rest went to a strip club for an hour or so. he asked how my party went and i told him it was fun, but didn't mention the male strippers. i don't know why i didn't tell him, i just didn't. at the wedding reception a couple weeks later, i was talking with some people and noticed my bf talking with a group of people in the wedding party across the room and they were all laughing except my bf. i keep looking at them and eventually my bf looks at me and he's just staring daggers at me. like, i have never seen him look at me like that before and i felt really uncomfortable. he was really cold with me the rest of the night and he ended up getting pretty drunk and passing out at the hotel as soon as we got there. on the car ride home the next day he finally opened up and told me that one of the bridesmaids had told him about the strippers and he was pissed that i would tell him not to go to a strip club and then go and hang out with male strippers in a private hotel room show. he said that was way worse than any strip club and that i was a huge asshole and hypocrite for it. he said he feels like i'm hiding something because i didn't tell him about the strippers and he doesn't believe me that nothing happened. [/INST] yta, how did the other girls "make you stay"? why couldn't you go to the hotel bar? and why didn't you tell your bf and explain the situation? </s>
AITA for refusing to change my daughters bedroom for my pregnant SIL?
my sil (28) is visiting for christmas and was sleeping in my daughters (16) bedroom. from the first day she's been here all she's done is complain about how my daughters bedroom is decorated. her walls are black and she has a bunch of rock posters on her walls. my sil is very christian and she says that it's evil and that she can have no part in it. she kept asking me to make my daughter change it/take the posters down. i spoke to my daughter about it and she said that if her aunt doesn't like it then she doesn't have to sleep in there. i honestly agreed and didn't feel like fighting with an teenage girl over a poster. anyways, right before bed last night i could hear my daughter kind of yelling and crying. when i went to see what had happened i saw that her aunt had taken all her stuff off of the walls and had "accidentally" ripped one of them which was signed by the artist. my daughter was freaking out and my sil explained that the "evil" posters gave her anxiety and that when she got anxious the baby wouldn't stop kicking and she couldn't sleep. i told my daughter to tape the ripped poster back together and that she could put all of it back up in the morning. i told my sil that if she didn't like it she could sleep on the couch or find a hotel. my wife doesn't like the way my daughters room is decorated either and of course she sided with her sister. she told my daughter that if she put them back up then she would rip them all up. she told me that she "couldn't believe that i would suggest that her sister should leave". aita?
19,079
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/k5k7nt/aita_for_refusing_to_change_my_daughters_bedroom/
2020-12-02 22:36:07
nta - she is a guest in your house: your house, your rules. how dare she infringe on your hospitality by telling your daughter how to decorate her bedroom. if she doesn't like it then she can book a hotel room or airbnb. your wife is also an ah for enabling her sister and using the situation to undermine your daughter's right to her identity and interests.
nta - but christmas is still 20+ days away, and it is completely unreasonable to make a teenager give up her room for that length of time for someone who destroys their belongings and disrespects them. maybe point out to your wife that choosing her sister over her daughter will effect the kind of relationship they have for the next few years at least and teenagers can be petty when the feel the need.
nta. only ah here are your wife and her sister. way to alienate her daughter and clearly show that the sister/aunt has priority over the teen that lives in the house.
nta-, why the fuck is your sil staying for an entire month? if i was your daughter i would be pissed about having to share my living space with a grown child for an entire month, what a breach of her privacy and sense of home. is your wife not your daughter's mom? i can't imagine telling my daughter or niece that i would rip their shit up because i don't like the fengshui. she(sil) is a guest in your home, it isn't her place to decide what goes or stays on the walls. i say this as i know i would put my sil in her place or out my front door if she did this to my kid.
nta. sil's behavior shows a complete lack of respect for your daughter as a person. hopefully you have a non-demonic couch for her to sleep on.
nta!!!!!! wow, fuck off old aunt and let your teenage girl (who sounds fucking rad as hell btw) live her life. my god, they are posters lol. this christian cult lady sounds like an absolute nightmare and i would be kicking her to the curb just as soon as she replaces your daughters art. this is your house that you fucking live in and the audacity of her touching anything in your home (as a guest) without express permission is actually shocking.
esh you shouldn’t have kicked your daughter out of her room for your sil in the first place and once she started destroying and changing your daughter’s room, she should have been out of there. she doesn’t get to come into your daughter’s space and change it around or destroy her property. your wife is as ridiculous as her sister, she should be defending your daughter and not co-signing your daughter being made to feel unwelcome in her own home. poor kid.
info: does your wife and daughter have a good relationship? it sounds like your wife cares more about her sister than her own daughter.
nta. your sil and wife are tas. it's your daughter's room. like you said, if she is uncomfortable, she can sleep somewhere else. your sil should also pay for the poster that she destroyed.
nta but also kinda info - is this you and your wife’s child? or is wife the stepmom? either way i’d be concerned at your wife telling a 16 year old that she would rip up all her decorations because sil doesn’t like them.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
ESH
INFO
NTA
NTA
0.032022
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my sil (28) is visiting for christmas and was sleeping in my daughters (16) bedroom. from the first day she's been here all she's done is complain about how my daughters bedroom is decorated. her walls are black and she has a bunch of rock posters on her walls. my sil is very christian and she says that it's evil and that she can have no part in it. she kept asking me to make my daughter change it/take the posters down. i spoke to my daughter about it and she said that if her aunt doesn't like it then she doesn't have to sleep in there. i honestly agreed and didn't feel like fighting with an teenage girl over a poster. anyways, right before bed last night i could hear my daughter kind of yelling and crying. when i went to see what had happened i saw that her aunt had taken all her stuff off of the walls and had "accidentally" ripped one of them which was signed by the artist. my daughter was freaking out and my sil explained that the "evil" posters gave her anxiety and that when she got anxious the baby wouldn't stop kicking and she couldn't sleep. i told my daughter to tape the ripped poster back together and that she could put all of it back up in the morning. i told my sil that if she didn't like it she could sleep on the couch or find a hotel. my wife doesn't like the way my daughters room is decorated either and of course she sided with her sister. she told my daughter that if she put them back up then she would rip them all up. she told me that she "couldn't believe that i would suggest that her sister should leave". aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my sil (28) is visiting for christmas and was sleeping in my daughters (16) bedroom. from the first day she's been here all she's done is complain about how my daughters bedroom is decorated. her walls are black and she has a bunch of rock posters on her walls. my sil is very christian and she says that it's evil and that she can have no part in it. she kept asking me to make my daughter change it/take the posters down. i spoke to my daughter about it and she said that if her aunt doesn't like it then she doesn't have to sleep in there. i honestly agreed and didn't feel like fighting with an teenage girl over a poster. anyways, right before bed last night i could hear my daughter kind of yelling and crying. when i went to see what had happened i saw that her aunt had taken all her stuff off of the walls and had "accidentally" ripped one of them which was signed by the artist. my daughter was freaking out and my sil explained that the "evil" posters gave her anxiety and that when she got anxious the baby wouldn't stop kicking and she couldn't sleep. i told my daughter to tape the ripped poster back together and that she could put all of it back up in the morning. i told my sil that if she didn't like it she could sleep on the couch or find a hotel. my wife doesn't like the way my daughters room is decorated either and of course she sided with her sister. she told my daughter that if she put them back up then she would rip them all up. she told me that she "couldn't believe that i would suggest that her sister should leave". aita? [/INST] nta - she is a guest in your house: your house, your rules. how dare she infringe on your hospitality by telling your daughter how to decorate her bedroom. if she doesn't like it then she can book a hotel room or airbnb. your wife is also an ah for enabling her sister and using the situation to undermine your daughter's right to her identity and interests. </s>
AITA thinking of leaving marriage because step-daughter got herself knocked up...
yeah, i know this sounds awful. my (32m) wife's (35f) daughter (16f) recently announced she is pregnant. she claims she doesn't know who the father is. i suspect she actually does and doesn't want to say, for whatever reason. i mean how much unprotected sex is a 16 year old really having? it can't be that hard to narrow it down for goodness sake. anyway, moving on. she is adamant on keeping the baby. abortion is out of the question apparently. wife completely supports her decision and is excited about having her first grand kid. they're both ecstatic. the problem i have with this is: 1. my wife's daughter is not going to be the one to look after this kid. she's still in school and fully intends to go to college. my wife and i will 100% end up looking after it. 2. i am going to be the one paying tens of thousands of dollars to raise this kid. my wife works part time and makes very little money. i don't have a problem with this as it lets her do volunteer work that she enjoys, but it means the financial burden of this kid will be 100% on me. 3. i wanted to have at least one kid with my wife. she's entering her late 30s so it's now or never. i feel like this kid will mean the two of us will never have our own because of both the emotional and financial burden raising it will put on us. i raised my concerns with my wife and her response was expected but disappointing. "this isn't up to you. this is her decision to make. we will support her." i agree it's her decision, but why do i have to support her? as it stands now, i'm thinking of cutting my losses and leaving the marriage if her daughter has this child. i'm not prepared to put off starting my own family for the sake of her daughter, nor am i prepared to pay to raise it. i fully intend to let them know this before the baby is born so they can make an informed decision on whether they can support it. aita?
18,431
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/bmywa5/aita_thinking_of_leaving_marriage_because/
2019-05-10 14:22:35
nta. your wife is an asshole for saying "**we** will support her". this is the only life you've got. if you don't want to be a step-grandfather at 32, that's for you to decide not her.
nah i think you need to start the conversation with your wife again, with less focus on what your step daughter should or shouldnt do, and more on what this means for your marriage and your future as a family, whether you still plan to have a child etc. that is the real focus, and you should be careful in the conversation not to make it all about the step daughter, because imo it doesn't sound like that is the real issue.
nta. your wife is in her 30s and her daughter is 16. how old was she when she had her daughter? she probably sees herself in the situation and is overly defensive because of this. how could she tell her she can't do something she did? either way, your life would be completely changed by this and the fact that your wife isn't acknowledging that and having a discussion about it is not okay.
i don't have an opinion but this sub is so fucking weird sometimes. i fully expected to come in here and see yta's across the board. i guess you caught them on a good day lmao. for what it's worth, if you're going to cut and run over anything, this is probably the right thing to cut and run over. you're getting hit with a lot of responsibility over shit your wife should have done differently raising her daughter. looking at the ages it looks like she had her daughter pretty fucking young as well all things considered, and young moms tend to raise future young moms.
nta but tell her as soon as is humanly possible that you are not sticking around. don't linger and be wishy washy until the 38th week. gather them together and tell them both "i am not raising a child i had no say in bringing into the world. i do not support this so i will be taking a pass. if you two want this, i won't stop you but i will have no part."
so, ultimately nah for me (cause i'm female and i can definitely understand emotionally being unable to go through with an abortion but i get your feelings too). one thing i wanted to mention, is your daughter may have been with someone older (adult male in her life, coach, that weird guy whose graduated but hangs around school explicitly to hit on underage girls) who preyed on her. that may be why she's not saying because she knows it will get him in trouble. she thinks she loves him but he's just taking advantage of her. i would breach this topic very delicately if you decide to.
nta. she had a kid at 19, and now she wants her kid to have a kid at 16? get the hell out before her kid's kid's having a kid when you're 45, and you're supposed to take care of that one, too.
nta - that's your decision to make. you have zero obligation to be financially responsible for this. would like to point out that your wife must have been a 16 year old mom, too. what was that like for her? how much did her parents help her? maybe she just thinks that's the norm.
a totally unrelated red flag: the daughter says she doesn't know who the father is- i bet she does. and i bet he's a lot older than 16 and knows he will go to jail if she tells the truth. or it's some dumb kid who doesn't want to be a daddy or pay child support and he convinced her not to tell anyone. you guys need to figure out who the father is asap. tell her that if you guys will be taking care of the baby, you'll be doing a dna test you'll submit to the police to make sure the daddy pays child support. then sit back and watch her 16 year old plan crumble. this whole thing seems to hinge on the idea that the daddy isn't involved. find the dad and tell him he'll be taking care of the baby half the time and i bet her plan will change a lot
nta. it's a sad story and a difficult decision that do make it sound like you're the asshole, but i think your reasons are justified. she's 16, she not supposed to be having children now. if she and her mother want to ignore all the trouble this kid will bring, it's extremelly unfair to drop it all on you, which is what will probably will end up happening. i think you're being smart here. good luck man
NTA
NAH
NTA
YTA
NTA
NAH
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0.06929
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: yeah, i know this sounds awful. my (32m) wife's (35f) daughter (16f) recently announced she is pregnant. she claims she doesn't know who the father is. i suspect she actually does and doesn't want to say, for whatever reason. i mean how much unprotected sex is a 16 year old really having? it can't be that hard to narrow it down for goodness sake. anyway, moving on. she is adamant on keeping the baby. abortion is out of the question apparently. wife completely supports her decision and is excited about having her first grand kid. they're both ecstatic. the problem i have with this is: 1. my wife's daughter is not going to be the one to look after this kid. she's still in school and fully intends to go to college. my wife and i will 100% end up looking after it. 2. i am going to be the one paying tens of thousands of dollars to raise this kid. my wife works part time and makes very little money. i don't have a problem with this as it lets her do volunteer work that she enjoys, but it means the financial burden of this kid will be 100% on me. 3. i wanted to have at least one kid with my wife. she's entering her late 30s so it's now or never. i feel like this kid will mean the two of us will never have our own because of both the emotional and financial burden raising it will put on us. i raised my concerns with my wife and her response was expected but disappointing. "this isn't up to you. this is her decision to make. we will support her." i agree it's her decision, but why do i have to support her? as it stands now, i'm thinking of cutting my losses and leaving the marriage if her daughter has this child. i'm not prepared to put off starting my own family for the sake of her daughter, nor am i prepared to pay to raise it. i fully intend to let them know this before the baby is born so they can make an informed decision on whether they can support it. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> yeah, i know this sounds awful. my (32m) wife's (35f) daughter (16f) recently announced she is pregnant. she claims she doesn't know who the father is. i suspect she actually does and doesn't want to say, for whatever reason. i mean how much unprotected sex is a 16 year old really having? it can't be that hard to narrow it down for goodness sake. anyway, moving on. she is adamant on keeping the baby. abortion is out of the question apparently. wife completely supports her decision and is excited about having her first grand kid. they're both ecstatic. the problem i have with this is: 1. my wife's daughter is not going to be the one to look after this kid. she's still in school and fully intends to go to college. my wife and i will 100% end up looking after it. 2. i am going to be the one paying tens of thousands of dollars to raise this kid. my wife works part time and makes very little money. i don't have a problem with this as it lets her do volunteer work that she enjoys, but it means the financial burden of this kid will be 100% on me. 3. i wanted to have at least one kid with my wife. she's entering her late 30s so it's now or never. i feel like this kid will mean the two of us will never have our own because of both the emotional and financial burden raising it will put on us. i raised my concerns with my wife and her response was expected but disappointing. "this isn't up to you. this is her decision to make. we will support her." i agree it's her decision, but why do i have to support her? as it stands now, i'm thinking of cutting my losses and leaving the marriage if her daughter has this child. i'm not prepared to put off starting my own family for the sake of her daughter, nor am i prepared to pay to raise it. i fully intend to let them know this before the baby is born so they can make an informed decision on whether they can support it. aita? [/INST] nta. your wife is an asshole for saying "**we** will support her". this is the only life you've got. if you don't want to be a step-grandfather at 32, that's for you to decide not her. </s>
AITA for wanting my daughters birthday party to be about her?
my daughter (6) just had her birthday party today. there’s a little girl with special needs in the class and according to school policy, we had to invite the entire class including the special needs girl. my daughter isn’t friends with her so there isn’t a reason for her to be invited or have to come. not only did we invite the kid, my wife called her mom and found out what toys she likes and made sure to have it at the party for her. she also put together a separate meal for the girl and set up our guest room for her and her mom in case she gets overwhelmed. in my opinion, if we have to invite her we’ll invite her but there’s no need to make this one little girl special and the center of attention. she had her own toys, her own food, and a different costume. it was a princess party and everyone was a princess or prince except for the special needs kid, who was a unicorn. after the party i told my wife that i don’t like that she went out of her way to make another little girl the center of attention at our daughters birthday party. my wife got defensive and said she was just trying to be inclusive and accommodating to the little girl and her needs but now she’s talking about play dates and after the party bullshit it looks like my daughter is always going to come in second to someone else’s kid. i told my wife i don’t want her to force our daughter to spend time with this special girl just to make the special one the center of attention and she called me a dick. i’m currently sleeping in the guest room and she’s setting up a play date for the girls this week. am i the asshole for wanting my daughters events to be about her and not some random kid?
5,355
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/zos98m/aita_for_wanting_my_daughters_birthday_party_to/
2022-12-18 06:45:26
yta. not once did you mention your daughter's feelings or reactions in all of this. you don't actually care about putting her first, you just don't want to accommodate a special needs kid. you are literally grouchy because you have to be nice to a six year old. that is about as ah as you can get dude.
yta it doesn't even sound like your daughter minded the unicorn costume, the special food, or the extra room. your wife is accommodating and inclusive. you're not and that's unfortunate. i understand wanting your daughter to feel special at her birthday party. what i'm failing to understand is how accommodating a special needs child takes away from your daughter's fun ??
yta 100% your wife did a wonderful thing to include a little girl who probably gets left out a lot. she didn't make the birthday party about her, she made it so she could be a participant in the party. no one sang happy birthday to her. no one brought her presents. everyone's focus was still on your daughter, except maybe yours because you were so worried that a girl with special needs was being included. even just the way you call her the "special needs girl" screams ah. thank goodness your wife isn't like you and is teaching your daughter that she can be friends with someone who is different than her.
yta as a woman in a wheelchair, let me school you on your ableist behavior. 1. she's not a “special girl”. she is a girl with a disability. if you want to talk about your issue with having a disabled child at your kid's birthday party, then don’t be an asshole and learn the correct language. your daughter sounds more mature than you. 2. depending on the disability, certain clothes are off limits because they’re difficult. for example, jeans are very hard to put on me, so i wear leggings. it’s easier for everyone involved. but again, since you’re an asshole, this thought never occurred to you. her mom is most likely the only one who dresses her, so she probably had to pick a costume that would be easier to put on her. also, maybe she didn’t have the money to buy her a princess costume. did you think of that? are you really going to shame her because she wasn’t wearing the right costume? 3. i’ve been ostracized my whole life for being disabled. it’s totally out of my control, but in case you didn’t know…no one can control if they have a disability or not. i hated the attention that being different brought me. but here you are, upset because a little girl might have taken away your daughter’s spotlight. trust me dude, i don’t want to have a spotlight on me because i look different. but i do, and again…i can’t control that. so once again here you are focusing on her because she’s different from your daughter and her other friends. 4. do you have any idea what it’s like being raised in a world that doesn’t accommodate disabilities? do you have to make sure every restaurant you go to has wheelchair access? do you have to figure out if your wheelchair can fit in a public restroom stall every time you go somewhere? why don’t you go out with your bro's and have a pint of beer, but your over sized head doesn’t fit through the door. so you have to hold it until you get home. how long do you think you’ll last? do you know down to the minutes how long you have until you burst? in a world of able bodied people, we don’t get special accommodations like your wife made for that little girl unless they have to because it’s illegal. you should be so lucky to have a partner that considers other people’s needs. you should worship your wife for caring enough about other people in order to make them feel comfortable. you should be ashamed for your ignorance.
as someone who’s disabled kid has been excluded at every turn, yta. your wife is teaching your daughter how to be a kind, empathic human, and you’re having a temper tantrum over a disabled 6 year old being allowed to exist equitably with her peers. come on…
yta. how did you type this out and think that you’re right?
is this what the world is coming to? you’re teaching your 6yo daughter “its all about me” did you ever consider that your wife and daughter might actually like the other little girl? or do you think she’s an unlikeable monster bc of her random differences? royal yta
yta and i’m sure the special needs girl felt extremely included in the event, shame on you for trying to dim her spotlight
yta. sounds like the girl is on the spectrum, and a 6 year old autistic child receiving accommodations is not the end of the world.
yta. i’m not sure this is real. could anybody be that dumb?
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my daughter (6) just had her birthday party today. there’s a little girl with special needs in the class and according to school policy, we had to invite the entire class including the special needs girl. my daughter isn’t friends with her so there isn’t a reason for her to be invited or have to come. not only did we invite the kid, my wife called her mom and found out what toys she likes and made sure to have it at the party for her. she also put together a separate meal for the girl and set up our guest room for her and her mom in case she gets overwhelmed. in my opinion, if we have to invite her we’ll invite her but there’s no need to make this one little girl special and the center of attention. she had her own toys, her own food, and a different costume. it was a princess party and everyone was a princess or prince except for the special needs kid, who was a unicorn. after the party i told my wife that i don’t like that she went out of her way to make another little girl the center of attention at our daughters birthday party. my wife got defensive and said she was just trying to be inclusive and accommodating to the little girl and her needs but now she’s talking about play dates and after the party bullshit it looks like my daughter is always going to come in second to someone else’s kid. i told my wife i don’t want her to force our daughter to spend time with this special girl just to make the special one the center of attention and she called me a dick. i’m currently sleeping in the guest room and she’s setting up a play date for the girls this week. am i the asshole for wanting my daughters events to be about her and not some random kid?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my daughter (6) just had her birthday party today. there’s a little girl with special needs in the class and according to school policy, we had to invite the entire class including the special needs girl. my daughter isn’t friends with her so there isn’t a reason for her to be invited or have to come. not only did we invite the kid, my wife called her mom and found out what toys she likes and made sure to have it at the party for her. she also put together a separate meal for the girl and set up our guest room for her and her mom in case she gets overwhelmed. in my opinion, if we have to invite her we’ll invite her but there’s no need to make this one little girl special and the center of attention. she had her own toys, her own food, and a different costume. it was a princess party and everyone was a princess or prince except for the special needs kid, who was a unicorn. after the party i told my wife that i don’t like that she went out of her way to make another little girl the center of attention at our daughters birthday party. my wife got defensive and said she was just trying to be inclusive and accommodating to the little girl and her needs but now she’s talking about play dates and after the party bullshit it looks like my daughter is always going to come in second to someone else’s kid. i told my wife i don’t want her to force our daughter to spend time with this special girl just to make the special one the center of attention and she called me a dick. i’m currently sleeping in the guest room and she’s setting up a play date for the girls this week. am i the asshole for wanting my daughters events to be about her and not some random kid? [/INST] yta. not once did you mention your daughter's feelings or reactions in all of this. you don't actually care about putting her first, you just don't want to accommodate a special needs kid. you are literally grouchy because you have to be nice to a six year old. that is about as ah as you can get dude. </s>
AITA for asking my tattoo artist to lower my price for my tattoo after she constantly got up to go to the bathroom?
my tattoo artist charges $125 an hour, my tattoo was done by the hour and in the end, i was there for a little over 2 hours, so in the end before a tip my tattoo was $270. i wouldn’t have had an issue with this, but my tattoo artist had gotten up 7 times to use the bathroom and was gone for at least 5 minutes each time and left her timer going. i asked if there was anyway i could get the time she was in the bathroom taken off and she made a face and then kindly said no. i didn’t argue so i just paid for my tattoo but left a lower tip than usual. she emailed me this morning and asked me not to book with her anymore because she said i disrespected her and her work, i’m upset because she does amazing work but i don’t feel that i was wrong. if she had gotten up once or twice i wouldn’t have cared.
19,358
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/n15b9v/aita_for_asking_my_tattoo_artist_to_lower_my/
2021-04-29 14:16:52
nta. you should reply and provide a review on yelp and other sites that of your two hours for which you were fully charged, she spend nearly 40 minutes of it in the bathroom on 7 trips and did not stop the clock. that's a definition of being unprofessional. if she was sick, she should have still discounted 30 minutes to make up for the time. there are many other tattoo artists - i suggest branching out for a new favorite.
nta you should review her online to make others aware. you shouldn’t have even given a tip. side question by why would you tip someone who charges 125 an hour anyway? you have paid for their time and talent and they are not a waiter or waitress on a tipped minimum wage? they get the whole thing as the artist. would you tip a doctor charging you 125 an hour too? or a lawyer? guess it’s very different in the the us compared to u.k. and europe and how we see things.
nta at first i was gonna say yta but 7 times!? in two hours no less? i would leave a review of the shop saying that. it's unfortunate she turned you down, but that's her choice. it doesn't mean you shouldn't warn other people of her practices.
nta i get 90 minute specialty massages. if my guy leaves for even 5 minutes he adds 5 min to the end. if you charge by the hour, you better be there the whole hour
i would say nta. if she is using a timer to get an exact work time she should pause it when she has to go to the bathroom. i get if she was having a bad tummy day or something but it's a bit unfair to charge you for that.
nta lmao she doesn’t want you to book her again because you caught on to how she’s making alittle extra $$$ i’d say email her boss or something
nta. find an artist who only charges skin time, my uncle owns a shop and him and the other artist will only ever charge skin time.
nta sounds like she was padding her time. either way, she charged for time she didn't work. that is unethical and you should let the owner know and write a review if they aren't going to do anything about it.
nta - 35 mins in the bathroom and still charging you for it? no way.
assuming you were looking at the timer and are not being hyperbolic when you say she was gone for 5 minutes 7 times, that's over half an hour of time she wasn't actually working on the tattoo and imo should not be chargeable. she does charge for part of an hour (125 x 2 is 250 so the extra 20 before tip came from somewhere) rather than an "anything over x is 1 hour rate" attitude, so it is totally reasonable to want to take this 35min off the bill. she should have at a minimum been pausing the timer after the 1st time she went to the bathroom - i feel like one time is probably okay, we're all human, but more than once in two hours is already a bit ridiculous let alone 7 times. nta
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my tattoo artist charges $125 an hour, my tattoo was done by the hour and in the end, i was there for a little over 2 hours, so in the end before a tip my tattoo was $270. i wouldn’t have had an issue with this, but my tattoo artist had gotten up 7 times to use the bathroom and was gone for at least 5 minutes each time and left her timer going. i asked if there was anyway i could get the time she was in the bathroom taken off and she made a face and then kindly said no. i didn’t argue so i just paid for my tattoo but left a lower tip than usual. she emailed me this morning and asked me not to book with her anymore because she said i disrespected her and her work, i’m upset because she does amazing work but i don’t feel that i was wrong. if she had gotten up once or twice i wouldn’t have cared.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my tattoo artist charges $125 an hour, my tattoo was done by the hour and in the end, i was there for a little over 2 hours, so in the end before a tip my tattoo was $270. i wouldn’t have had an issue with this, but my tattoo artist had gotten up 7 times to use the bathroom and was gone for at least 5 minutes each time and left her timer going. i asked if there was anyway i could get the time she was in the bathroom taken off and she made a face and then kindly said no. i didn’t argue so i just paid for my tattoo but left a lower tip than usual. she emailed me this morning and asked me not to book with her anymore because she said i disrespected her and her work, i’m upset because she does amazing work but i don’t feel that i was wrong. if she had gotten up once or twice i wouldn’t have cared. [/INST] nta. you should reply and provide a review on yelp and other sites that of your two hours for which you were fully charged, she spend nearly 40 minutes of it in the bathroom on 7 trips and did not stop the clock. that's a definition of being unprofessional. if she was sick, she should have still discounted 30 minutes to make up for the time. there are many other tattoo artists - i suggest branching out for a new favorite. </s>
AITA for asking my husband to check on me while playing video games?
my husband is an avid computer gamer - mostly wow-type games. approximately five nights of the week, he'll play games online from the time that our son goes to bed at 8:00 or 8:30 to about 12:30, so at least four continuous hours. that in itself is not at all an issue for our relationship. he spends plenty of time with me and our son, and i have my own hobbies that he isn't interested in that i engage in when he's online. a few nights ago i was doing laundry while he was playing online, and i stepped on a toy that my son had left on the basement stairs. i fell pretty hard and dropped the basket. luckily because of the way my weight was shifted i fell backwards rather than forwards, resulting in a bruise on my butt but i was otherwise fine. the laundry basket clattered down the stairs, ricocheted off some basement furniture, shot laundry everywhere. it was a huge racket. it woke up my son. my husband, who had his headphones on, heard literally nothing. it dawned on me that if something really bad happened to me, my husband wouldn't know about it for potentially four hours - like what if i broke my leg falling down the stairs? so i asked if he would be willing, for my peace of mind, to just pop out of his office at the mid-point each night just to check on me. like literally, just say hi and go back to gaming. he thinks this is a huge overreaction and a waste of time. i know for a fact that he isn't actively playing the entire time and he sometimes takes breaks to go to the bathroom or get a snack or whatever, so how is this different? aita?
25,533
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hnn6gj/aita_for_asking_my_husband_to_check_on_me_while/
2020-07-08 19:03:54
nta - my so is a gamer similar to yours and in between games he has always came to check on me, kiss me etc. he has always done this from when we were dating to now living together. i think it’s really important, not only to check up on you but to let you know he is thinking of you (or maybe i have gotten used to it!!)
nta i think that’s a fair compromise for him playing wow 5 nights a week for four hours
nta. i don’t know much about wow, but every game has some kind of breaking point in it that leaves time to go and do little things (like going to the bathroom). all you’re asking for is some peace of mind that he, as your husband, should be happy to do for you.
nta, there's a story somewhere on reddit about a guy upstairs playing games with noise cancelling headphones. people broke in and attacked his wife (possibly sexually assaulted her, i can't remember). this is a totally valid request.
nta: i do it all the time for my wife, don’t see why he can’t.
nta. this is a basic courtesy you are asking for from someone who is your partner and is supposed to care for you. it's funny because this is something that actually happened-ish to myself and my husband a few years ago. i was taking a bath and he was playing video games. i dropped something and it made a very loud noise which he heard. like 5 minutes later he checked on me and asked if i was ok. i asked about the delay, curious as to why he was checking now, and he said he wanted to wait until his he loaded, since he wasn't sure something was wrong. i explained that if something were i might already be dead by the time he checked. now i can't drop the shampoo without him making sure i am ok.
nta. i had this same issue with my husband the other day. he was playing with headphones on and i was in the kitchen putting dishes away (i’m pregnant btw) and the whole cabinet came off the wall and almost crushed me! i reacted super quickly and caught it and began screaming for help and nothing. a neighbor came in running before my husband even noticed. i was pretty shook. i told him he needed to lower the volume cause the baby and i could’ve been seriously hurt if the neighbor hadn’t come to help me.
nta. this reminds me of the post where the guy was gaming with noise cancelling headphones on and didn’t realize his wife was being raped downstairs. she was being assaulted for 10 mins before he realized something was wrong...
how about only one ear covered by the headphones? could solve both your problems. i nta. but i think the timing is off as he thinks you're simply doing this simply because you fell down. which to men doesn't necessarily make sense
nta i was engaged to a gamer who would literally play all day (lost his job and refused to get another one). we’re talking wake up at noon, game until 4/5am. one day i fell in the shower - products smashed all over the floor, tile broken etc. loud. absolutely no reaction whatsoever. luckily i was ok apart from a few bruises and a sore head but i could have easily cracked my head open. i just kinda sat there crying in self pity for a while, then went back out and he just completely ignored the obvious mess i was in - asked him also to check in and got a hard no. yeah... he’s gone now.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my husband is an avid computer gamer - mostly wow-type games. approximately five nights of the week, he'll play games online from the time that our son goes to bed at 8:00 or 8:30 to about 12:30, so at least four continuous hours. that in itself is not at all an issue for our relationship. he spends plenty of time with me and our son, and i have my own hobbies that he isn't interested in that i engage in when he's online. a few nights ago i was doing laundry while he was playing online, and i stepped on a toy that my son had left on the basement stairs. i fell pretty hard and dropped the basket. luckily because of the way my weight was shifted i fell backwards rather than forwards, resulting in a bruise on my butt but i was otherwise fine. the laundry basket clattered down the stairs, ricocheted off some basement furniture, shot laundry everywhere. it was a huge racket. it woke up my son. my husband, who had his headphones on, heard literally nothing. it dawned on me that if something really bad happened to me, my husband wouldn't know about it for potentially four hours - like what if i broke my leg falling down the stairs? so i asked if he would be willing, for my peace of mind, to just pop out of his office at the mid-point each night just to check on me. like literally, just say hi and go back to gaming. he thinks this is a huge overreaction and a waste of time. i know for a fact that he isn't actively playing the entire time and he sometimes takes breaks to go to the bathroom or get a snack or whatever, so how is this different? aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my husband is an avid computer gamer - mostly wow-type games. approximately five nights of the week, he'll play games online from the time that our son goes to bed at 8:00 or 8:30 to about 12:30, so at least four continuous hours. that in itself is not at all an issue for our relationship. he spends plenty of time with me and our son, and i have my own hobbies that he isn't interested in that i engage in when he's online. a few nights ago i was doing laundry while he was playing online, and i stepped on a toy that my son had left on the basement stairs. i fell pretty hard and dropped the basket. luckily because of the way my weight was shifted i fell backwards rather than forwards, resulting in a bruise on my butt but i was otherwise fine. the laundry basket clattered down the stairs, ricocheted off some basement furniture, shot laundry everywhere. it was a huge racket. it woke up my son. my husband, who had his headphones on, heard literally nothing. it dawned on me that if something really bad happened to me, my husband wouldn't know about it for potentially four hours - like what if i broke my leg falling down the stairs? so i asked if he would be willing, for my peace of mind, to just pop out of his office at the mid-point each night just to check on me. like literally, just say hi and go back to gaming. he thinks this is a huge overreaction and a waste of time. i know for a fact that he isn't actively playing the entire time and he sometimes takes breaks to go to the bathroom or get a snack or whatever, so how is this different? aita? [/INST] nta - my so is a gamer similar to yours and in between games he has always came to check on me, kiss me etc. he has always done this from when we were dating to now living together. i think it’s really important, not only to check up on you but to let you know he is thinking of you (or maybe i have gotten used to it!!) </s>
AITA for taking back my dresser from my stepdaughter?
f30 when i first married my husband (m36) and moved in with him i decided to give my stepdaughter my old dresser and nightstand from my parents house. my set was much nicer and she loved it so we got rid of her old dresser during the move. it’s been about 4 years now and my husband and i have a 2 year old daughter and are expecting another girl in february. we have been co-sleeping with our daughter since she was born and she has shared our room, but now we need to move her into her own room. i have always wanted my children to have my old things from my childhood and that included the dresser set. when we gave my stepdaughter the dresser i had made it clear to my husband that once we had children our children would be using it since it is mine. he agreed and still agrees with me so we decided to discuss it with my stepdaughter. she was upset that we were taking it away, we tried to ask her to downsize her things so that she can store her clothes in the closet but she refused saying we should just buy a new dresser for our daughter. so after she left we decided to leave her clothes on her bed and take the dresser out ourselves. after she came back the next weekend she waited until we left the house and moved the dresser back into her room. my husband had another discussion with her and we let her know that was unacceptable. now her mother is involved and is calling us telling us we are being unreasonable and should just buy and new set. the thing is my husband and i have also decided to stop buying new clothes for my stepdaughter as we already send her mother child support and we need both the money and space. once she grows out of her clothes she will not need a dresser so there is no point in buying a new one when we need to save money. tldr: i am taking back my dresser that i gave to her a few years ago so that my daughter can have it and she is refusing to let us have it back
3,522
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/yxzmyy/aita_for_taking_back_my_dresser_from_my/
2022-11-17 19:48:54
yta. i have no idea who you think you are. but you are one thing, a extremely terrible stepmother who is very selfish and apparently only cares about her own flesh and blood. your husband is still required to buy his own daughter things even though he is paying child support. you gave her the dresser and night stand without telling her the deal behind it! you cannot take it back, you told the wrong person about the deal and now you have to deal with the fact that you cannot use it for your own flesh and blood. i used caps lock, maybe that way you understood how wrong you are.
yta. you and your husband. that poor kid. you are making a massive difference between her and *”your”* child, and it is gross. she existed when you married your husband, you do not get to treat her like an inconvenient third wheel. and shame on your husband for actively going along with this crap.
yta. way to make sure your stepdaughter knows that you don’t consider her your daughter and that she comes second to the new baby.
you’re really leaning in to some unpleasant stereotypes about step parents. yta
yta- why wouldn’t you have just bought a different dresser for your step daughter if you knew you’d be wanting this for your own kids one day. it’s definitely a slap in the face to your step daughter… like “oh sorry my “real” child is here now so you’re not important enough to have this” … the fact that you aren’t even suggesting getting her a new one of her own and you’re just taking hers is so horrible.
yta. a big one. you gave your stepdaughter something. then you are trying to take it back for your 'real' kid. as if this child isn't going through enough stress having a new half sister. now you are making her feel she has been replaced. major ah move. the irony is, you probably could have sold her on buying her a new set for her birthday or christmas,saying she was so grown up that she deserved a new set and the baby should have the old used one. see, that would have made her feel important..instead you decide to take a shit on her. not spending money on her because of your new baby. are your trying to be the evil step mom? because, congrats you are nailing it.
&gt;i have always wanted my children to have my old things from my childhood and that included the dresser set. and you did that. your kid has your things. just not your bio kid. but she is your kid nonetheless. yta.
yta you keep saying that you gave the dresser to your stepdaughter. you didn’t seem to tell your stepdaughter that you were letting her use your old dresser until your real children needed it. now you’re not only taking back the furniture but you’re also telling your stepdaughter to downsize and that you’re done spending money on her. soon you’ll be wondering why your stepdaughter resents her half-siblings. pay attention! sheesh. go to some estate sales and buy another dresser.
yta!!! you are talking about your stepkid as if she doesn't mean anything. the damn dresser is in your house who cares which one of your three daughters are using it! if i would be your stepkid i would be thinking that i was good enough before your own kids ce along but now that you do have them im nothing anymore. would she move out with it then your on your right but now your just the biggest ah. that your husband is agreeing is also weird af. but i believe you are making him do that. shame on you
yta if you knew you wanted to give your biological child your childhood dresser, you could have: * not given it to your stepdaughter * bought your stepdaughter a new dresser of her choosing and framed it as something good/her growing out of the other dresser instead, you moved it when she wasn't there. i wouldn't be surprised if your stepdaughter stops coming to your house as soon as she's able to make that decision for herself. though, perhaps that's what you're hoping will happen.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: f30 when i first married my husband (m36) and moved in with him i decided to give my stepdaughter my old dresser and nightstand from my parents house. my set was much nicer and she loved it so we got rid of her old dresser during the move. it’s been about 4 years now and my husband and i have a 2 year old daughter and are expecting another girl in february. we have been co-sleeping with our daughter since she was born and she has shared our room, but now we need to move her into her own room. i have always wanted my children to have my old things from my childhood and that included the dresser set. when we gave my stepdaughter the dresser i had made it clear to my husband that once we had children our children would be using it since it is mine. he agreed and still agrees with me so we decided to discuss it with my stepdaughter. she was upset that we were taking it away, we tried to ask her to downsize her things so that she can store her clothes in the closet but she refused saying we should just buy a new dresser for our daughter. so after she left we decided to leave her clothes on her bed and take the dresser out ourselves. after she came back the next weekend she waited until we left the house and moved the dresser back into her room. my husband had another discussion with her and we let her know that was unacceptable. now her mother is involved and is calling us telling us we are being unreasonable and should just buy and new set. the thing is my husband and i have also decided to stop buying new clothes for my stepdaughter as we already send her mother child support and we need both the money and space. once she grows out of her clothes she will not need a dresser so there is no point in buying a new one when we need to save money. tldr: i am taking back my dresser that i gave to her a few years ago so that my daughter can have it and she is refusing to let us have it back
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> f30 when i first married my husband (m36) and moved in with him i decided to give my stepdaughter my old dresser and nightstand from my parents house. my set was much nicer and she loved it so we got rid of her old dresser during the move. it’s been about 4 years now and my husband and i have a 2 year old daughter and are expecting another girl in february. we have been co-sleeping with our daughter since she was born and she has shared our room, but now we need to move her into her own room. i have always wanted my children to have my old things from my childhood and that included the dresser set. when we gave my stepdaughter the dresser i had made it clear to my husband that once we had children our children would be using it since it is mine. he agreed and still agrees with me so we decided to discuss it with my stepdaughter. she was upset that we were taking it away, we tried to ask her to downsize her things so that she can store her clothes in the closet but she refused saying we should just buy a new dresser for our daughter. so after she left we decided to leave her clothes on her bed and take the dresser out ourselves. after she came back the next weekend she waited until we left the house and moved the dresser back into her room. my husband had another discussion with her and we let her know that was unacceptable. now her mother is involved and is calling us telling us we are being unreasonable and should just buy and new set. the thing is my husband and i have also decided to stop buying new clothes for my stepdaughter as we already send her mother child support and we need both the money and space. once she grows out of her clothes she will not need a dresser so there is no point in buying a new one when we need to save money. tldr: i am taking back my dresser that i gave to her a few years ago so that my daughter can have it and she is refusing to let us have it back [/INST] yta. i have no idea who you think you are. but you are one thing, a extremely terrible stepmother who is very selfish and apparently only cares about her own flesh and blood. your husband is still required to buy his own daughter things even though he is paying child support. you gave her the dresser and night stand without telling her the deal behind it! you cannot take it back, you told the wrong person about the deal and now you have to deal with the fact that you cannot use it for your own flesh and blood. i used caps lock, maybe that way you understood how wrong you are. </s>
AITA for playing music over my Bluetooth speaker on a public hiking trail?
where to begin with this... i guess i need to say up front i'm not an outdoors type person. but i was sort of excited to go on a hike yesterday. we are in san diego for the fourth of july and my cousin said it would be really fun if me and my friends went on a hike while she (cousin) had to work. we went to a place called cowles mountain which i guess is about 45 minutes away from the hotel downtown. when we got there it was pretty crowded and we saw a group of guys coming down who were just blasting rap music. i was like wow that would be an awesome way to not get bored on the hike so i went back to my car and got my blue tooth speaker from my pack and hit my favorite spotify list. most people didn't seem to mind but i did notice that we started to get occasional dirty looks. but finally one person stopped me and told me it was incredibly rude to play music outloud and that i should be using headphones. i told her that i was playing music for our group. and she basically that it's still very rude and against the rules but she kept walking. we decided we just weren't going to make it to the top so we stopped at a kind of flat spot and sat down for a while and this is when things actually got kind of scary. this guy and his girlfriend came up to us and said again that i should be using headphones. i told her that we were in a group. she said that it didn't matter most people were trying to enjoy quiet nature. i told her that that its public land. she said "if you weren't such an ignorant fat bitch you would have noticed the sign at the bottom that said no speakers." i basically shut down because i'm not good at confrontation but my friend asked her if she wanted to repeat herself. so the girlfriend called her a fat bitch as well and her boyfriend had to drag her away she was so upset. i didn't want any more hassle so i turned off the speaker and they walked away but the girl was just glaring at us and i was actually scared that they would slash my tires or something at the bottom. i have been reliving the confrontation over and over again and didn't sleep last night. i admit to being fully ignorant because i don't do a lot of outdoor stuff but was that really a big deal? i mean at least one other group we saw was doing it so i can't be that out of touch? all i was trying to do was make it a little more enjoyable and really meant no offense. i posted this on another sub and was referenced here so i'm a little scared just because of the title but please be honest with me. was i doing something wrong? edit in advance: using a throwaway
6,301
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/c9490s/aita_for_playing_music_over_my_bluetooth_speaker/
2019-07-04 16:02:34
yta and the worst kind of ass hole. &amp;#x200b; there is a time and place for everything. except forcing your shitty musical tastes on other people in public. there is never a time for that. terrible hiking etiquette and terrible attitude when confronted about your terrible hiking etiquette. &amp;#x200b;
yta, you should have used headphones. nobody wants to hear your music while they are hiking to enjoy nature.
yta. most people hike to get away from top-40 hits, and those that don't are typically courteous enough to bring headphones. it's also a safe bet that people who feel the need to blast their music around random strangers usually have a poor ability to read the room as far as taste goes. yta because "everyone sucks here" would be validating your inappropriate behaviour. that woman never should have called you names, but the other couple who explained it politely, the various people giving you dirty looks, and whoever put up the sign i'm betting exists are perfectly valid. i'm also tempted to ask for info about the music you were playing, because i really want to picture how different of an experience from nature this was for the people who enjoy it.
yta. i almost went with everyone sucks here because i completely disagree with her calling you a fat bitch, but she and others had asked you before it escalated and you still said no. there’s rarely a time or place for anyone to listen to their music without headphones in while in public.
&gt; she said that it didn't matter most people were trying to enjoy quiet nature yta. completely agree that people go on hikes to enjoy the naturalness of nature. loud music can disturb that. i understand that you're with a group of friends but you're on a hike, not at a party.
yta. i love hiking. i want to get out in nature. away from the busy life. hear the sounds of birds, the wind, flowing water... it's very peaceful and mentally refreshing. you blasting music ruins that. can you seriously not enjoy a hike or being out in nature without being unplugged for a day?? enjoy the scenery and beauty of it without technology for once. it's incredibly rude and inconsiderate to everyone else on the trail who has to listen to it. you are ruining the experience for everyone. you and your friends are being very selfish. it also scares the wildlife. these are animals who aren't used to hearing these things, and now you've ruined a bird watcher or another hiker from seeing certain wildlife because you've scared them off.
yta for sure. people who blast their music out loud in public places and especially on hikes are the worst.
yta. if you were in a waiting room, still the asshole. if you were on a bus, the asshole. walking down a sidewalk with a few people around, the asshole. in line for a ride at an amusement park, the asshole. absolutely no one else wants to listen to whatever shitty noises are coming from your phone. the guys coming down the hill listening to rap? also the assholes.
yta. 1)listen to your music on your headphones like an adult 2) if you want to listen in a group do not do that in a public place. 3) if you find hikes so boring don't go on one. i don't agree with the manner in which you were confronted, but the fact that you are still actually questioning whether it was asshole move to blast your music in nature is beyond me. especially after multiple dirty looks and confrontations? are you that dense? expect to be confronted about asshole behavior when behaving like an asshole
yta. everyone hates the group blasting shitty music. go somewhere else if you want to do that.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: where to begin with this... i guess i need to say up front i'm not an outdoors type person. but i was sort of excited to go on a hike yesterday. we are in san diego for the fourth of july and my cousin said it would be really fun if me and my friends went on a hike while she (cousin) had to work. we went to a place called cowles mountain which i guess is about 45 minutes away from the hotel downtown. when we got there it was pretty crowded and we saw a group of guys coming down who were just blasting rap music. i was like wow that would be an awesome way to not get bored on the hike so i went back to my car and got my blue tooth speaker from my pack and hit my favorite spotify list. most people didn't seem to mind but i did notice that we started to get occasional dirty looks. but finally one person stopped me and told me it was incredibly rude to play music outloud and that i should be using headphones. i told her that i was playing music for our group. and she basically that it's still very rude and against the rules but she kept walking. we decided we just weren't going to make it to the top so we stopped at a kind of flat spot and sat down for a while and this is when things actually got kind of scary. this guy and his girlfriend came up to us and said again that i should be using headphones. i told her that we were in a group. she said that it didn't matter most people were trying to enjoy quiet nature. i told her that that its public land. she said "if you weren't such an ignorant fat bitch you would have noticed the sign at the bottom that said no speakers." i basically shut down because i'm not good at confrontation but my friend asked her if she wanted to repeat herself. so the girlfriend called her a fat bitch as well and her boyfriend had to drag her away she was so upset. i didn't want any more hassle so i turned off the speaker and they walked away but the girl was just glaring at us and i was actually scared that they would slash my tires or something at the bottom. i have been reliving the confrontation over and over again and didn't sleep last night. i admit to being fully ignorant because i don't do a lot of outdoor stuff but was that really a big deal? i mean at least one other group we saw was doing it so i can't be that out of touch? all i was trying to do was make it a little more enjoyable and really meant no offense. i posted this on another sub and was referenced here so i'm a little scared just because of the title but please be honest with me. was i doing something wrong? edit in advance: using a throwaway
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> where to begin with this... i guess i need to say up front i'm not an outdoors type person. but i was sort of excited to go on a hike yesterday. we are in san diego for the fourth of july and my cousin said it would be really fun if me and my friends went on a hike while she (cousin) had to work. we went to a place called cowles mountain which i guess is about 45 minutes away from the hotel downtown. when we got there it was pretty crowded and we saw a group of guys coming down who were just blasting rap music. i was like wow that would be an awesome way to not get bored on the hike so i went back to my car and got my blue tooth speaker from my pack and hit my favorite spotify list. most people didn't seem to mind but i did notice that we started to get occasional dirty looks. but finally one person stopped me and told me it was incredibly rude to play music outloud and that i should be using headphones. i told her that i was playing music for our group. and she basically that it's still very rude and against the rules but she kept walking. we decided we just weren't going to make it to the top so we stopped at a kind of flat spot and sat down for a while and this is when things actually got kind of scary. this guy and his girlfriend came up to us and said again that i should be using headphones. i told her that we were in a group. she said that it didn't matter most people were trying to enjoy quiet nature. i told her that that its public land. she said "if you weren't such an ignorant fat bitch you would have noticed the sign at the bottom that said no speakers." i basically shut down because i'm not good at confrontation but my friend asked her if she wanted to repeat herself. so the girlfriend called her a fat bitch as well and her boyfriend had to drag her away she was so upset. i didn't want any more hassle so i turned off the speaker and they walked away but the girl was just glaring at us and i was actually scared that they would slash my tires or something at the bottom. i have been reliving the confrontation over and over again and didn't sleep last night. i admit to being fully ignorant because i don't do a lot of outdoor stuff but was that really a big deal? i mean at least one other group we saw was doing it so i can't be that out of touch? all i was trying to do was make it a little more enjoyable and really meant no offense. i posted this on another sub and was referenced here so i'm a little scared just because of the title but please be honest with me. was i doing something wrong? edit in advance: using a throwaway [/INST] yta and the worst kind of ass hole. &amp;#x200b; there is a time and place for everything. except forcing your shitty musical tastes on other people in public. there is never a time for that. terrible hiking etiquette and terrible attitude when confronted about your terrible hiking etiquette. &amp;#x200b; </s>
AITA for telling my Fiance to get over himself?
i'm engaged to my fiance (sam/41) and we're getting married soon. i will say that he was married before and had a 13 year old son who passed away 4 years ago. let me tell you he is still pretty much grieving, not judging him for that but his grieving can and will cloud his thinking sometimes. we're currently in the wedding planning phase, he asked that we "reserve" a chair at the venue for his deceased son. i was dumbfounded when i heard this but he said that he knows his son will be there for him spriritually and he'd like to reserve a seat for him out of respect and to make him feel "included", i tried to be gentle because this seemed insane and told him we can't do that because guests will be asking questions and will think he's mentally unstable. i asked him to let go of this idea but he offered a compromise by leaving the last chair (in the very back) empty so no one will notice. i felt uneasy and asked him to just let it go but he kept bringing it up saying he gets a say since it's his wedding and his son was and will always be family, i had a fight with him telling him it's my wedding too and i don't people to laugh at us. he said i have nothing to lose if i say yes and that i'm being selfish. i snapped and told him to get over himself and he got quiet suddenly and stopped arguing then shut down completely. i then heard him sob while he was smoking outside and refused to speak to me, didn't even let me sit with him. he has been like this eversince the fight and has been avoiding me. i could have blown this out of propotion but i thought his request will weird out many guests and make our wedding a laughing stock. *editing to add that i didn't think that such thing was common. i admit that i should've handled the conversation better but the guests i was referring to are my male cousin, they're terrible and make fun of everything and take every opportunity to turn an event into a laughing stock. i can't keep them from attending because they're family but at the same time don't want to give them a chance to hurt sam's feelings or make rude comments. i love sam and sympathize with his struggle but i feel like he's being dismissive of my feelings and thoughts.*
14,235
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/u4wb9h/aita_for_telling_my_fiance_to_get_over_himself/
2022-04-16 12:00:35
yta. a wedding is about both of you. he offered a comprise. you're putting your foot down...why? what he wants is harmless and also really sweet. 'guests will be asking questions and will think he's mentally unstable.' 'i don't people to laugh at us.' so...don't invite ahs to your wedding? i'm sorry but given how callous you're being i'd be surprised if there even is a wedding now.
yta unequivocally. a huge gaping one. he lost his child. you don't get over that. you made him sob over a chair. think about that for a minute. the way you're approaching this is disgusting. you're the one that needs to get over yourself. if i were him i would be calling the whole wedding off. the disrespect is unreal.
you are right about his grief clouding his thinking sometimes. he must've been totally clouded over when he agreed to marry you. you come across as a very cold hearted, self obsessed person. you don't deserve him. yta
yta - leaving a front row seat open at the ceremony and having an “in memory” table with some pictures of loved ones you wish could attend at the reception are both very common wedding practices for people who have lost close family members.
yta. no one is going to think he's mentally unstable or insane, thats all in your head. its quite common to have emty chairs for this reason, if you place a photo on the chair its clear what you are doing. they are usually in the family section where they belong not as an afterthought in the back. interestingly you felt only your fiance's age was relevant here. given you care more about people laughing at you than your fiance's very valid feelings perhaps you shouldn't be marrying him. the only clouded judgement here is yours. you are the one who needs to get over yourself and stop caring about what other guests might think. i'd be very surprised if he marries you after this. he deserves better.
yta. a massive one. like....couldn't be more of one. he should not only get his empty seat at the very front, but there should be a photo of his son in that seat. he will always be a father and the fact that you're trying to erase his son from an important day in his life and belittling his feelings is a really big indicator of how the rest of his life with you will be. i hope he sees that before it's too late (for him).
yta. that is a beautiful way to have his deceased child still included in the wedding and everyone who would laugh at that or think him 'mentally unstable' should not be someone you want at your wedding anyway
yta. wow. never seen an easier one on this sub ever
yta, majorly. i''ve been at multiple weddings where an empty chair was reserved for a deceased loved one. there's no reason any guest will make fun of you or think he's unstable. it's not going to ruin the aesthetic of your wedding...cuz that's what you seem to be worried about. secondly, how dare you try to invalidate his grieving. he lost a child for gosh sake. shame on you. *edited formating*
i have never seen anyone post on this site who was more of ta than this.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm engaged to my fiance (sam/41) and we're getting married soon. i will say that he was married before and had a 13 year old son who passed away 4 years ago. let me tell you he is still pretty much grieving, not judging him for that but his grieving can and will cloud his thinking sometimes. we're currently in the wedding planning phase, he asked that we "reserve" a chair at the venue for his deceased son. i was dumbfounded when i heard this but he said that he knows his son will be there for him spriritually and he'd like to reserve a seat for him out of respect and to make him feel "included", i tried to be gentle because this seemed insane and told him we can't do that because guests will be asking questions and will think he's mentally unstable. i asked him to let go of this idea but he offered a compromise by leaving the last chair (in the very back) empty so no one will notice. i felt uneasy and asked him to just let it go but he kept bringing it up saying he gets a say since it's his wedding and his son was and will always be family, i had a fight with him telling him it's my wedding too and i don't people to laugh at us. he said i have nothing to lose if i say yes and that i'm being selfish. i snapped and told him to get over himself and he got quiet suddenly and stopped arguing then shut down completely. i then heard him sob while he was smoking outside and refused to speak to me, didn't even let me sit with him. he has been like this eversince the fight and has been avoiding me. i could have blown this out of propotion but i thought his request will weird out many guests and make our wedding a laughing stock. *editing to add that i didn't think that such thing was common. i admit that i should've handled the conversation better but the guests i was referring to are my male cousin, they're terrible and make fun of everything and take every opportunity to turn an event into a laughing stock. i can't keep them from attending because they're family but at the same time don't want to give them a chance to hurt sam's feelings or make rude comments. i love sam and sympathize with his struggle but i feel like he's being dismissive of my feelings and thoughts.*
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm engaged to my fiance (sam/41) and we're getting married soon. i will say that he was married before and had a 13 year old son who passed away 4 years ago. let me tell you he is still pretty much grieving, not judging him for that but his grieving can and will cloud his thinking sometimes. we're currently in the wedding planning phase, he asked that we "reserve" a chair at the venue for his deceased son. i was dumbfounded when i heard this but he said that he knows his son will be there for him spriritually and he'd like to reserve a seat for him out of respect and to make him feel "included", i tried to be gentle because this seemed insane and told him we can't do that because guests will be asking questions and will think he's mentally unstable. i asked him to let go of this idea but he offered a compromise by leaving the last chair (in the very back) empty so no one will notice. i felt uneasy and asked him to just let it go but he kept bringing it up saying he gets a say since it's his wedding and his son was and will always be family, i had a fight with him telling him it's my wedding too and i don't people to laugh at us. he said i have nothing to lose if i say yes and that i'm being selfish. i snapped and told him to get over himself and he got quiet suddenly and stopped arguing then shut down completely. i then heard him sob while he was smoking outside and refused to speak to me, didn't even let me sit with him. he has been like this eversince the fight and has been avoiding me. i could have blown this out of propotion but i thought his request will weird out many guests and make our wedding a laughing stock. *editing to add that i didn't think that such thing was common. i admit that i should've handled the conversation better but the guests i was referring to are my male cousin, they're terrible and make fun of everything and take every opportunity to turn an event into a laughing stock. i can't keep them from attending because they're family but at the same time don't want to give them a chance to hurt sam's feelings or make rude comments. i love sam and sympathize with his struggle but i feel like he's being dismissive of my feelings and thoughts.* [/INST] yta. a wedding is about both of you. he offered a comprise. you're putting your foot down...why? what he wants is harmless and also really sweet. 'guests will be asking questions and will think he's mentally unstable.' 'i don't people to laugh at us.' so...don't invite ahs to your wedding? i'm sorry but given how callous you're being i'd be surprised if there even is a wedding now. </s>
AITA For banning my former Mother-in-Law from my house because she keeps showing up and letting herself in?
my former mother in law is 52 years old and i am 32 years old. back when i was 23 i married i got my then girlfriend pregnant, we married soon after and she gave birth to our little girl. 2 years after my wife got extremely sick and passed soon after, leaving me with our daughter. i decided to move several states away back to my own parents as i work a lot and my parents volunteered to help me with my daughter. this went on for a while until i made a good promotion and had enough saved up to get my own house half an hour away from my parents and since then watching my daughter during the day while i am at work is split between the nanny i hired and my parents, before you think i am taking advantage, my parents insist on watching her. my daughter is 8 now in case you wonder and i generally work 8 to 6. my former mother in law decided to move to the town i live because she wants to be close to her granddaughter/my daughter. i initially had no issue with this, after all my wife was her only child and my daughter her only grandchild. i only started having an issue when she actually moved. since she moved here she was at my house pretty much all day including when i got home after work and the weekends. she would even be there when my daughter was at school and no one was home to clean. after having multiple conversations and arguments with her where i stated i was of the opinion her behavior was innapropriate and she was crossing boundaries she finally toned it down for a while, however slip ups were and are common. last week was the last straw for me, since the past year and a half i have started dating again and met a woman, however due to corona we have not been able to spend much time together with everything opening up here i invited her over after asking my parents to watch my daughter, when we were "fooling around" on the couch my ex mother in law let herself in of course without calling, knocking or asking and proceeded to lose her shit and accused me of cheating and disrespecting my deceased wife. i finally had enough, i went over, snatched my key from her, forced her oit of my home and told her she is no longer welcome in my house. she really has no one else and several people including my parents have weighed in asking me to change my mind, i am not sure if i am the asshole here.
19,346
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/lnmcyv/aita_for_banning_my_former_motherinlaw_from_my/
2021-02-19 18:08:00
nta because of three main reason: 1. this is your house 2. this is your kid 3. this is your life you lost your wife (i’m genuinely sorry for your loss), you grieved, you accepted your loss and then you moved on. you’re not cheating on anyone and you’re well within your right to not allow her into your property. keep her away for your kid. her reaction tells me that she’ll try and push her mindset of you “cheating” on to your daughter. just remember that you are the parent and that you have your own life.
nta, you've warned her multiple times, if she wants to see her grandchild she should call you and ask either come over or take your daughter out somewhere. i would not give the keys back.
nta. why does this woman have a key/access code to your home? she is 100% the ah. good locks make good neighbors. i wouldn't recommend giving anyone a key who doesn't live in your house unless you're going to be gone except one person whom you can trust to not do this (like your parents or a friend).
nta you are entitled to your own privacy and it should be expected for an adult to respect another adults private and personal space. showing up constantly and letting herself in... that’s too much. however, i’d remember that your deceased wife’s mother is clearly without anyone. her only child is dead. her only grandchild with you. this can’t be easy for her. you absolutely need to establish and enforce boundaries. but this isn’t just an overbearing mil. this is a grief stricken and lonely mil. please try to come to a compromise, for the memory of your wife and her daughter.
she crossed the line and you are nta. change your locks asap. i would highly recommend giving her time with your daughter that is not at your house, and be clear that you are an adult allowed to make your own romantic choices and she should not be discussing that with your kid. either supervised visits at a park, or letting your daughter go to your mils house for short visits if you are comfortable. but do not let that woman in your home and do not allow her to continue to think you are expecteted to be celibate for her own comfort. that's not sane or reasonable. of course if she crosses lines you are welcome to cut her off, and should. but i don't really get the sense that you are at that point yet. if you are, then so be it you make the choices that are best for you. however, my take is that this may be the confrontation that was needed to shock her into reality and hopefully keeping her at arms legnth will get the point across that she was was way out of line and needs to adjust.
nta. she is violating boundaries big time! the loss of her daughter does not entitle her to invade your home and your life. your wife died, you did not. it is completely reasonable to move on when the time is right.
.... cheating on your deceased wife? she just bypassed all boundaries and went straight for alarmingly delusional. before i was thinking “this woman has no boundaries” now i’m thinking “this woman needs therapy and you need to change your locks” (taking her key works just as well hopefully). i do you think you’ll eventually need to have a conversation with her, because i doubt this is the end of it. whether or not she’s physically busting in your house like the kool-aid man and accusing you of having an affair, this is going to make things tense. i think that family therapy would be necessary before any further contact happens, therapy between you and mil, therapy for grandma, and therapy for the three of you including your daughter. it sounds like she genuinely does not understand that her daughter is gone, but it is not your responsibility to make her understand either. it is her responsibility to stay out of your house and stop with this interloping, she is actively going to sabotage any chance you have at happiness or moving on. nta
i’m gonna play devil’s advocate up until she accused you of cheating etc. she lost her daughter, son in law and grandchild in different ways, she obviously hasn’t dealt with the grief or loss in a healthy way which has manifested itself this way. she crossed a line when she accused you of cheating on your wife who has passed. i think what you all need is to have a sit down talk. your parents, her and you. maybe even your daughter. you don’t owe her this or anything else btw, but it seems as though she hasn’t dealt with the loss and having her remaining family move away probably broke her a little bit. my advice is to sit down with everyone, and have a nice calm discussion, ask her why she’s been doing these things, if there’s anything you can do to help her mental state, if it’s something possible to fix it could be worth fixing for your daughters sake. people can do weird and messed up shit when they aren’t in their right state of mind and even though that doesn’t excuse the actions, it can certainly explain them and give an avenue to help fix or obtain the help she needs.
if i read correctly, your wife has been gone for at least 5 years. nta. your mil needs grief counseling and boundaries.
nta - but you should change your locks regardless. you don't know that she didn't make copies.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my former mother in law is 52 years old and i am 32 years old. back when i was 23 i married i got my then girlfriend pregnant, we married soon after and she gave birth to our little girl. 2 years after my wife got extremely sick and passed soon after, leaving me with our daughter. i decided to move several states away back to my own parents as i work a lot and my parents volunteered to help me with my daughter. this went on for a while until i made a good promotion and had enough saved up to get my own house half an hour away from my parents and since then watching my daughter during the day while i am at work is split between the nanny i hired and my parents, before you think i am taking advantage, my parents insist on watching her. my daughter is 8 now in case you wonder and i generally work 8 to 6. my former mother in law decided to move to the town i live because she wants to be close to her granddaughter/my daughter. i initially had no issue with this, after all my wife was her only child and my daughter her only grandchild. i only started having an issue when she actually moved. since she moved here she was at my house pretty much all day including when i got home after work and the weekends. she would even be there when my daughter was at school and no one was home to clean. after having multiple conversations and arguments with her where i stated i was of the opinion her behavior was innapropriate and she was crossing boundaries she finally toned it down for a while, however slip ups were and are common. last week was the last straw for me, since the past year and a half i have started dating again and met a woman, however due to corona we have not been able to spend much time together with everything opening up here i invited her over after asking my parents to watch my daughter, when we were "fooling around" on the couch my ex mother in law let herself in of course without calling, knocking or asking and proceeded to lose her shit and accused me of cheating and disrespecting my deceased wife. i finally had enough, i went over, snatched my key from her, forced her oit of my home and told her she is no longer welcome in my house. she really has no one else and several people including my parents have weighed in asking me to change my mind, i am not sure if i am the asshole here.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my former mother in law is 52 years old and i am 32 years old. back when i was 23 i married i got my then girlfriend pregnant, we married soon after and she gave birth to our little girl. 2 years after my wife got extremely sick and passed soon after, leaving me with our daughter. i decided to move several states away back to my own parents as i work a lot and my parents volunteered to help me with my daughter. this went on for a while until i made a good promotion and had enough saved up to get my own house half an hour away from my parents and since then watching my daughter during the day while i am at work is split between the nanny i hired and my parents, before you think i am taking advantage, my parents insist on watching her. my daughter is 8 now in case you wonder and i generally work 8 to 6. my former mother in law decided to move to the town i live because she wants to be close to her granddaughter/my daughter. i initially had no issue with this, after all my wife was her only child and my daughter her only grandchild. i only started having an issue when she actually moved. since she moved here she was at my house pretty much all day including when i got home after work and the weekends. she would even be there when my daughter was at school and no one was home to clean. after having multiple conversations and arguments with her where i stated i was of the opinion her behavior was innapropriate and she was crossing boundaries she finally toned it down for a while, however slip ups were and are common. last week was the last straw for me, since the past year and a half i have started dating again and met a woman, however due to corona we have not been able to spend much time together with everything opening up here i invited her over after asking my parents to watch my daughter, when we were "fooling around" on the couch my ex mother in law let herself in of course without calling, knocking or asking and proceeded to lose her shit and accused me of cheating and disrespecting my deceased wife. i finally had enough, i went over, snatched my key from her, forced her oit of my home and told her she is no longer welcome in my house. she really has no one else and several people including my parents have weighed in asking me to change my mind, i am not sure if i am the asshole here. [/INST] nta because of three main reason: 1. this is your house 2. this is your kid 3. this is your life you lost your wife (i’m genuinely sorry for your loss), you grieved, you accepted your loss and then you moved on. you’re not cheating on anyone and you’re well within your right to not allow her into your property. keep her away for your kid. her reaction tells me that she’ll try and push her mindset of you “cheating” on to your daughter. just remember that you are the parent and that you have your own life. </s>
AITA for sleeping with my cousin?
this is a throwaway account which i will probably nuke. &amp;#x200b; me and my family have a big country house and my parents decided to have my uncle, his wife and their son (who we'll call tom) over this last weekend as the weather seemed quite lovely. tom isn't blood related to me as he was adopted one year before i was born and he knows this. we're both of age. neither mine nor his family has enough free time to travel much so this was a good opportunity for us to catch up. i recently broke up with my boyfriend and am going through a rough patch. nothing serious, just a lot of negative emotions. i was excited to spend some time with family and get my mind off things. we catch up, have a fantastic dinner, drinks are flowing and i got quite tipsy. me and tom were snap chatting each other and making fun of our drunk parents. suddenly our convo got a bit more playful. i put down my phone and tried to pay more attention to the heated brexit debate that was taking place. i couldn't be bothered to listen so picked my phone up again and started downright flirting with tom. we keep chatting over snapchat throughout the entire night. it got quite late and everybody went to bed, me and tom kept texting each other. i tell him to come to my room so we can watch a film. he did and as you can imagine we never got around to seeing the film. &amp;#x200b; the morning after, tom and his parents were leaving early so i got up to say my goodbyes. i went back in to have breakfast and enjoy the rest of the weekend. my parents came in the room and started shouting at me. my mum is a light sleeper so when she heard movement upstairs she woke up. she proceeded to hear us have sex. and god was she upset. i got called pretty much every name in the book. she said that she will not get over it and even if she does she will not forget it. both mum and dad are not currently speaking to me. i am not sure if they will tell my uncle or aunt and i really hope not. &amp;#x200b; my argument is that he isn't related to me, and there were no strings attached. we both made that clear when we woke up in the morning. my parents said i am a disgrace to this family. &amp;#x200b; aita?
5,687
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/budy1w/aita_for_sleeping_with_my_cousin/
2019-05-29 12:17:30
yta. &amp;#x200b; he's still socialized as your cousin, and hooking up at a family country house while your entire family is there is a dick move. sleep with who you want, you're both consenting adults, but yta for putting your family in the middle of it.
what in the yeehaw fuck. he was adopted the year before you were born so you’ve always known him as your cousin? nah i guess? but weird and pretty gross.
yta you fucked your cousin and your mother had to hear it. blood related or not, he is considered your cousin. fyi, parents don't want to hear their children having sex, with anyone.
esh. like i get that he’s not blood related to you, but come on you still have that familial tie. and now imagine how every family event is going to go from now on. nsa or not there will still be that “hey i slept with you” association.
yta wow maybe my family is just ugly because there are a lot of family sex stories lately and i don't like looking at my family never mind... 😝 urgh no. oh you're not related. still keep it private. no one wants to explain to great aunt ellen with dementia that you're fuckin. if you want to make this into a thing then be discreet and come out as an actual couple respectfully. i knew a dude who fucked his cousins. yes two women and another man cousins. i have no idea if they are blood related but that is still how people who forget his name describe him. tony the cousin fucker.
yta seriously, not sure how anyone comes to a different conclusion. glad you didn’t engage in incest, but cmon...that shit is weird. if you really needed to get laid maybe leaving the home you were sharing with your families would have been a good start. as it stands, your decision was selfish and obviously caused quite a stir with your mom. not to say you can’t have sex or whatever...just that your decision making here was fucked up.
if you had an adopted brother, would you justify having sex with him just bc you aren't blood related? no. its the same logic with your cousin.
yta i was adopted when i was a baby and i’ve never thought of having sex with any family member. i’m technically not blood related to any of them but i still see them as my family.
[removed]
alabama?
YTA
NAH
YTA
ESH
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
null
null
0.042848
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: this is a throwaway account which i will probably nuke. &amp;#x200b; me and my family have a big country house and my parents decided to have my uncle, his wife and their son (who we'll call tom) over this last weekend as the weather seemed quite lovely. tom isn't blood related to me as he was adopted one year before i was born and he knows this. we're both of age. neither mine nor his family has enough free time to travel much so this was a good opportunity for us to catch up. i recently broke up with my boyfriend and am going through a rough patch. nothing serious, just a lot of negative emotions. i was excited to spend some time with family and get my mind off things. we catch up, have a fantastic dinner, drinks are flowing and i got quite tipsy. me and tom were snap chatting each other and making fun of our drunk parents. suddenly our convo got a bit more playful. i put down my phone and tried to pay more attention to the heated brexit debate that was taking place. i couldn't be bothered to listen so picked my phone up again and started downright flirting with tom. we keep chatting over snapchat throughout the entire night. it got quite late and everybody went to bed, me and tom kept texting each other. i tell him to come to my room so we can watch a film. he did and as you can imagine we never got around to seeing the film. &amp;#x200b; the morning after, tom and his parents were leaving early so i got up to say my goodbyes. i went back in to have breakfast and enjoy the rest of the weekend. my parents came in the room and started shouting at me. my mum is a light sleeper so when she heard movement upstairs she woke up. she proceeded to hear us have sex. and god was she upset. i got called pretty much every name in the book. she said that she will not get over it and even if she does she will not forget it. both mum and dad are not currently speaking to me. i am not sure if they will tell my uncle or aunt and i really hope not. &amp;#x200b; my argument is that he isn't related to me, and there were no strings attached. we both made that clear when we woke up in the morning. my parents said i am a disgrace to this family. &amp;#x200b; aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> this is a throwaway account which i will probably nuke. &amp;#x200b; me and my family have a big country house and my parents decided to have my uncle, his wife and their son (who we'll call tom) over this last weekend as the weather seemed quite lovely. tom isn't blood related to me as he was adopted one year before i was born and he knows this. we're both of age. neither mine nor his family has enough free time to travel much so this was a good opportunity for us to catch up. i recently broke up with my boyfriend and am going through a rough patch. nothing serious, just a lot of negative emotions. i was excited to spend some time with family and get my mind off things. we catch up, have a fantastic dinner, drinks are flowing and i got quite tipsy. me and tom were snap chatting each other and making fun of our drunk parents. suddenly our convo got a bit more playful. i put down my phone and tried to pay more attention to the heated brexit debate that was taking place. i couldn't be bothered to listen so picked my phone up again and started downright flirting with tom. we keep chatting over snapchat throughout the entire night. it got quite late and everybody went to bed, me and tom kept texting each other. i tell him to come to my room so we can watch a film. he did and as you can imagine we never got around to seeing the film. &amp;#x200b; the morning after, tom and his parents were leaving early so i got up to say my goodbyes. i went back in to have breakfast and enjoy the rest of the weekend. my parents came in the room and started shouting at me. my mum is a light sleeper so when she heard movement upstairs she woke up. she proceeded to hear us have sex. and god was she upset. i got called pretty much every name in the book. she said that she will not get over it and even if she does she will not forget it. both mum and dad are not currently speaking to me. i am not sure if they will tell my uncle or aunt and i really hope not. &amp;#x200b; my argument is that he isn't related to me, and there were no strings attached. we both made that clear when we woke up in the morning. my parents said i am a disgrace to this family. &amp;#x200b; aita? [/INST] yta. &amp;#x200b; he's still socialized as your cousin, and hooking up at a family country house while your entire family is there is a dick move. sleep with who you want, you're both consenting adults, but yta for putting your family in the middle of it. </s>
AITA for telling my girlfriend that she needs to shave her legs?
here me out, before you all throw the misogynist card. i'll keep it as short as possible. as background information, my girlfriend is very high-maintenance. she doesn't wear makeup or do fancy things with her hair, but she's always spending money on creams and oils and masks or whatever to put on her face and skin. she says it helps moisturize and keep her skin and pores healthy. honestly, i say that anything from health stores and brands is a waste of money but it's her money so i don't say much. she is also very controlling when it comes to me and my apartment. my housemates and i are very busy and we hardly have guests over to entertain them. it's not like there are dead rats in the corners of the place but she doesn't like the occasional sweater thrown on the floor or dishes in the sink and she's always telling me to stop doing that. on to the story, we were invited to my friend's wedding and because i live much closer to the venue, she stayed the night (cue the complaining about dishes, paper on floor, etc.). i had a long day so i decided not to shower, which again she complained about but let it go since i told her i'd shower in the morning. in the morning when we were getting ready, i decided not to shower because i overslept and thought that washing my face and putting some cologne and deodorant would be more than sufficient. my girlfriend obviously protested saying that i was gross, so i got pretty annoyed and told her that it's gross that she doesn't shave her legs because it's a huge turn off and it's disgusting. it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. i know i can't force her to do anything but it's expected, you know? we're going to a damn wedding. things escalated and she got mad, saying that not showering was not the same thing as not shaving, especially is guys are not expected to shave. but society has already made that call. she then changed her clothes from slacks and a blouse to a dress that went to her knee, making her legs even more obvious. my mom says that i'm ta and is siding with sabz. this is ridiculous, aita?
5,373
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ffeu01/aita_for_telling_my_girlfriend_that_she_needs_to/
2020-03-08 16:25:42
yta &gt; told her that it's gross that she doesn't shave her legs because it's a huge turn off and it's disgusting. it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. a) lots of girls don't wear makeup or heels*, b) if you want a girlfriend who wears those things, go get you one. c) you not showering is not comparable to her not shaving her legs. whether or not she shaves her legs doesn't affect her cleanliness. not showering certainly does.
i have heard you out and you are a misogynist yta
yta showering is hygiene shaving is cosmetic. you can’t compare them.
&gt;doesn't wear makeup or heels or normal things girls are supposed to do well fuck me with a broomstick i've just found out that after 24 years i've not been a girl doing girl things after all. thank you for enlightening me to the fact i am, apparently, some weird alien creature and not a normal girl, oh great wise man. yta mate. and you are a misogynist. i assume when you're demanding she shave her legs for hygiene you also remove all your body hair?
yta, not showering at night or in the morning is gross. she called you out on it because you stunk, and i am surprised she even agreed to sleep in the same bed with you without washing. a bit of clean hair on her legs is not gross, and it’s awful that you called her natural body disgusting. then you insulted her about not doing things “normal” girls do? christ dude, you acted like a huge fucking ass.
yta. she doesn't "need" to shave and women aren't "supposed" to wear makeup or high heels. some choose to, some don't. if it's such a turnoff for you that she chooses not to and you find her unshaven legs gross and disgusting, why are you even with her?
yta high maintenance? really? so her trying to have nice skin is high maintenance now? how does this play into anything? she keeps you on top of cleaning. i personally need that kick in the butt. your examples and your hyperbolic statements don’t even match. and i don’t thing you actually care about her shaving her legs. you just don’t sound like you want to be in the relationship at all. and everyone’s right, cleanliness and shaving aren’t the same.
"here me out, before you all throw the misogynist card." lmfao. yta. you actually think a little hair on the legs is disgusting, but using cologne to cover up not showering is fine? you're a piece of work.
op: &gt;before you all throw the misogynist card... also op: &gt;it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. what's does "normal things girls are **_supposed_** to do" even mean? not shaving is not the same as not showering for 2 days. it's not unhygienic to not shave but it's unhygienic to not shower. if you think not shaving is just as unhygienic, then you'll be doubly unhygienic if you don't shave your legs on top of not showering. yta.
yta absolutely. don't know why you told people not to throw the misogynist card right before telling a super mysoginist story, but here we are. to be fair, your gf doesn't sound amazing here either, but you are a much bigger ah in this scenario. honestly not sure why you guys are dating bc from your telling it doesn't sound like you even like eachother much. edit after re-reading. never mind your gf sounds fine. you're the only ah here 🤷🏼‍♀️
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: here me out, before you all throw the misogynist card. i'll keep it as short as possible. as background information, my girlfriend is very high-maintenance. she doesn't wear makeup or do fancy things with her hair, but she's always spending money on creams and oils and masks or whatever to put on her face and skin. she says it helps moisturize and keep her skin and pores healthy. honestly, i say that anything from health stores and brands is a waste of money but it's her money so i don't say much. she is also very controlling when it comes to me and my apartment. my housemates and i are very busy and we hardly have guests over to entertain them. it's not like there are dead rats in the corners of the place but she doesn't like the occasional sweater thrown on the floor or dishes in the sink and she's always telling me to stop doing that. on to the story, we were invited to my friend's wedding and because i live much closer to the venue, she stayed the night (cue the complaining about dishes, paper on floor, etc.). i had a long day so i decided not to shower, which again she complained about but let it go since i told her i'd shower in the morning. in the morning when we were getting ready, i decided not to shower because i overslept and thought that washing my face and putting some cologne and deodorant would be more than sufficient. my girlfriend obviously protested saying that i was gross, so i got pretty annoyed and told her that it's gross that she doesn't shave her legs because it's a huge turn off and it's disgusting. it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. i know i can't force her to do anything but it's expected, you know? we're going to a damn wedding. things escalated and she got mad, saying that not showering was not the same thing as not shaving, especially is guys are not expected to shave. but society has already made that call. she then changed her clothes from slacks and a blouse to a dress that went to her knee, making her legs even more obvious. my mom says that i'm ta and is siding with sabz. this is ridiculous, aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> here me out, before you all throw the misogynist card. i'll keep it as short as possible. as background information, my girlfriend is very high-maintenance. she doesn't wear makeup or do fancy things with her hair, but she's always spending money on creams and oils and masks or whatever to put on her face and skin. she says it helps moisturize and keep her skin and pores healthy. honestly, i say that anything from health stores and brands is a waste of money but it's her money so i don't say much. she is also very controlling when it comes to me and my apartment. my housemates and i are very busy and we hardly have guests over to entertain them. it's not like there are dead rats in the corners of the place but she doesn't like the occasional sweater thrown on the floor or dishes in the sink and she's always telling me to stop doing that. on to the story, we were invited to my friend's wedding and because i live much closer to the venue, she stayed the night (cue the complaining about dishes, paper on floor, etc.). i had a long day so i decided not to shower, which again she complained about but let it go since i told her i'd shower in the morning. in the morning when we were getting ready, i decided not to shower because i overslept and thought that washing my face and putting some cologne and deodorant would be more than sufficient. my girlfriend obviously protested saying that i was gross, so i got pretty annoyed and told her that it's gross that she doesn't shave her legs because it's a huge turn off and it's disgusting. it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. i know i can't force her to do anything but it's expected, you know? we're going to a damn wedding. things escalated and she got mad, saying that not showering was not the same thing as not shaving, especially is guys are not expected to shave. but society has already made that call. she then changed her clothes from slacks and a blouse to a dress that went to her knee, making her legs even more obvious. my mom says that i'm ta and is siding with sabz. this is ridiculous, aita? [/INST] yta &gt; told her that it's gross that she doesn't shave her legs because it's a huge turn off and it's disgusting. it's bad enough that she doesn't wear makeup or heals or normal things girls are supposed to do. a) lots of girls don't wear makeup or heels*, b) if you want a girlfriend who wears those things, go get you one. c) you not showering is not comparable to her not shaving her legs. whether or not she shaves her legs doesn't affect her cleanliness. not showering certainly does. </s>
AITA for blowing up at my boyfriend 'just because he was ignorant'? (His words)
i'll try to keep this short. i (19f) slept over at my boyfriends (23m) place, and i unexpectedly got my period during the night (irregular cycle). he freaked out. i was embarrassed, and offered to wash the sheets. he wasn't having any of it, and basically told me i must be irresponsible and disgusting, yelling the whole time. at that point i got annoyed too, and told him he was acting like a real asshole. i went to take a quick shower and was about to go home when he stopped me to continue the argument. i explained to him that i can't control when they happen, that they can be irregular as hell, and that they're not that gross (he was talking about throwing away the sheets, the stain wasn't even that big and i put them in the washer before i showered.) he told me that he didn't know those things, and that i'm unreasonable for being mad at him for just a misunderstanding, and that he couldn't have known since they didn't teach him that in school. obviously i'm not mad at him for not knowing, i'm mad at him for assuming he knew better and reacting by yelling at me. he's mad because.. i'm mad, and he thinks i can't be mad about ignorance, since it's not his fault. i apologised for calling him an asshole, but he doesn't want to apologise for yelling. aita? i only want him to apologise for yelling.
20,803
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/kvw14w/aita_for_blowing_up_at_my_boyfriend_just_because/
2021-01-12 17:21:55
nta- but those are some huge red flags. apologizing will tell him he is right to go screaming about his assumption. you need to sit with him and have a calm , rational conversation about what you are mad about and how he could have acted differently, and if he is unwilling or incapable of doing so then the relationship is probably doomed.
nta. he’s a grown ass man, his lack of education is his own fault and no one else’s. as other people have already said, a man who doesn’t know how the reproductive system works has no business having sex with anyone. i had an unexpected period start when i was staying the night with my husband when we first started dating. i left early for work so he mentioned it to me later that days. i was mortified and apologized over and over and offered to replace the sheets, and he laughed at me. “it’s fine, i already washed them and put them back on the bed. it’s not like you did it on purpose.” which is the only correct response.
nta - 1. he shouted at you first 2. he is 23 years old, using school as an excuse doesn’t fly, he has had plenty of time to educate himself 3. he treated it as if it was a serious bio hazard that needed to be dealt with majorly 4. he tried to turn it around and make you responsible for how he acted
"i'm ignorant so it's your fault i yelled at you" is that someone you wanna spend your time with? nta
ignorance - "ah, you got period blood on the sheets?! why didn't you put down protection; didn't you know it was about to happen? does blood stain permanently?" assholery - "you're disgusting and irresponsible! let me yell at you aggressively and make sure you know just how lowly i think of you as a person." the first example is an ignorant person *addressing the issue, making their assumptions known, and inviting new information to inform them*. the second example is an ignorant **asshole** *lashing out at a person - not the issue, and entrenched in their assumptions instead of inviting correction*. nta. you shouldn't have apologized for calling an asshole an asshole.
nta. you’re dating an asshole.
nta. he's a 23-year-old man, even if he didn't know that you could get your period unexpectedly his reaction is all out of whack especially since you woke up and offered to fix the mess. how is it you're unreasonable when he was the one shouting at you?
nta - and really, sex education needs to be better, why didn't his own mother tell him this stuff? did she think he wouldn't ever find out about it?
nta i think its messed up that he specifically stopped you to continue the argument, does he do that alot?
23 years old? you can find much better. nta but lose this weight.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'll try to keep this short. i (19f) slept over at my boyfriends (23m) place, and i unexpectedly got my period during the night (irregular cycle). he freaked out. i was embarrassed, and offered to wash the sheets. he wasn't having any of it, and basically told me i must be irresponsible and disgusting, yelling the whole time. at that point i got annoyed too, and told him he was acting like a real asshole. i went to take a quick shower and was about to go home when he stopped me to continue the argument. i explained to him that i can't control when they happen, that they can be irregular as hell, and that they're not that gross (he was talking about throwing away the sheets, the stain wasn't even that big and i put them in the washer before i showered.) he told me that he didn't know those things, and that i'm unreasonable for being mad at him for just a misunderstanding, and that he couldn't have known since they didn't teach him that in school. obviously i'm not mad at him for not knowing, i'm mad at him for assuming he knew better and reacting by yelling at me. he's mad because.. i'm mad, and he thinks i can't be mad about ignorance, since it's not his fault. i apologised for calling him an asshole, but he doesn't want to apologise for yelling. aita? i only want him to apologise for yelling.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'll try to keep this short. i (19f) slept over at my boyfriends (23m) place, and i unexpectedly got my period during the night (irregular cycle). he freaked out. i was embarrassed, and offered to wash the sheets. he wasn't having any of it, and basically told me i must be irresponsible and disgusting, yelling the whole time. at that point i got annoyed too, and told him he was acting like a real asshole. i went to take a quick shower and was about to go home when he stopped me to continue the argument. i explained to him that i can't control when they happen, that they can be irregular as hell, and that they're not that gross (he was talking about throwing away the sheets, the stain wasn't even that big and i put them in the washer before i showered.) he told me that he didn't know those things, and that i'm unreasonable for being mad at him for just a misunderstanding, and that he couldn't have known since they didn't teach him that in school. obviously i'm not mad at him for not knowing, i'm mad at him for assuming he knew better and reacting by yelling at me. he's mad because.. i'm mad, and he thinks i can't be mad about ignorance, since it's not his fault. i apologised for calling him an asshole, but he doesn't want to apologise for yelling. aita? i only want him to apologise for yelling. [/INST] nta- but those are some huge red flags. apologizing will tell him he is right to go screaming about his assumption. you need to sit with him and have a calm , rational conversation about what you are mad about and how he could have acted differently, and if he is unwilling or incapable of doing so then the relationship is probably doomed. </s>
AITA- went to the nurse and she was a close family friend
so i had to go to the nurse to get bloods. i didn’t recognise her at first with the mask and lack of makeup but it turned out to be my daughters old best friend. this girl has slept at my house 100s of times, i’ve taken her on holiday, she was at my wedding and we only had 30 guests! about 5 years ago she got pregnant and my daughter moved away and they have very different lives now and have drifted apart so i’ve only seen her a couple of times in passing at the hospital (i’m also a nurse). but bearing in mind how much she knows me i was flabbergasted to find her in the gp surgery and obviously having access to all my medical notes which i am really uncomfortable with. i want to complain but i don’t want to get her in trouble and i guess the damage is done, but i really do not want her accessing my records. aita if i make a complaint?
3,818
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/xewpow/aita_went_to_the_nurse_and_she_was_a_close_family/
2022-09-15 13:21:16
yta if you complain. she was just doing her job for the patient assigned to her and you're acting like she maliciously singled you out and went out of her way to treat you so she could dig through your medical records.
yta if you complain bruh. that’s her job… not like she purposely went out of her way to become a nurse to have access to your medical records
yta she did absolutely nothing wrong, if you are uncomfortable then go to a different doctor.
yta this isn't a complaint you should make. you merely request a different provider once you realize you know the care provider. don't escalate things that don't need to be escalated.
a complaint for what? if you want a different nurse it's on you to ask. this girl doesn't care about your records and isn't poking about in your files; you're someone's mom, not bts.
yta. you don’t make a complaint. that’s the not the solution. you contact clinical records and ask that your file not be accessed by her. your a nurse. that shouldn’t be that hard to figure out. that doesn’t single her out for a complaint. it simply puts a lock on your file, so that she can not look at your records. the hospital then flags if she does look. it’s simple privacy law. your medical records should be protected from people looking at them with no valid reason. you can also request a record of who has looked at your records. you can then ask in the future to not have her administer care as you know her.
ywbta. it's her job. if you are a nurse too, this is a stupid question tbh. how would you feel if someone reported they didn't want to work with you? you'd be getting in trouble for something out of your control and for doing... your job. just ask the front desk for someone different due to conflict of interest or... you know... doctor patient confidentiality helps you too... don't be jerk
yta as a nurse yourself, you know that confidentiality is a massive thing. whether she takes your blood or not, by working at the gp office she likely would have access to your medical records anyway. what makes you think that she'd be remotely interested in looking at your medical records in the first place?
ywbta report her for what exactly? just take your medical needs elsewhere.
info: are you angry she saw you as a patient or because she works in the gp sugary that you attend? also is there a reason you want to make a complaint rather than just requesting a different staff member? you are very welcome to request that this woman not be involved in your care in the future because you know her and are uncomfortable with this but if you are insinuating she should not work there at all in case she accesses your records and this is why you want to complain that is completely unreasonable.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: so i had to go to the nurse to get bloods. i didn’t recognise her at first with the mask and lack of makeup but it turned out to be my daughters old best friend. this girl has slept at my house 100s of times, i’ve taken her on holiday, she was at my wedding and we only had 30 guests! about 5 years ago she got pregnant and my daughter moved away and they have very different lives now and have drifted apart so i’ve only seen her a couple of times in passing at the hospital (i’m also a nurse). but bearing in mind how much she knows me i was flabbergasted to find her in the gp surgery and obviously having access to all my medical notes which i am really uncomfortable with. i want to complain but i don’t want to get her in trouble and i guess the damage is done, but i really do not want her accessing my records. aita if i make a complaint?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> so i had to go to the nurse to get bloods. i didn’t recognise her at first with the mask and lack of makeup but it turned out to be my daughters old best friend. this girl has slept at my house 100s of times, i’ve taken her on holiday, she was at my wedding and we only had 30 guests! about 5 years ago she got pregnant and my daughter moved away and they have very different lives now and have drifted apart so i’ve only seen her a couple of times in passing at the hospital (i’m also a nurse). but bearing in mind how much she knows me i was flabbergasted to find her in the gp surgery and obviously having access to all my medical notes which i am really uncomfortable with. i want to complain but i don’t want to get her in trouble and i guess the damage is done, but i really do not want her accessing my records. aita if i make a complaint? [/INST] yta if you complain. she was just doing her job for the patient assigned to her and you're acting like she maliciously singled you out and went out of her way to treat you so she could dig through your medical records. </s>
AITA for tricking my husband to coming to a school event and inviting her to my house?
my mother and husband hate each other. that's the most basic way to put it. truth is that my husband feels that he is treated as less than my other sibling's spouses because of his skin colour, and my mother feels that he is way too dumb for my standards. however, i personally feel that my mother does not show any favouritism or harsh treatment of my husband. because of this, my husband cannot stand my mother and has recently begun to even be in the same room as her. "oh your mom's going to be at christmas? i'm going to a friend's house." "oh your mom's going to the kid's event? i'll just stay at home." frankly it's insanely demoralising for me, and i hate my husband when he backs out of something just because my mom is going to be there, and it's worse when he demands that my mom not go because he wants to be there. in my opinion, he's the one with the big issue, he should be the one to leave the kid's events. recently one of my kids was having a big football match and he wanted his father there. my mother also wanted to be there so i tried telling my son that he couldn't have his father there. he was adamant, so i told my husband that my mother was not going to be there. he arrives, and obviously, so does my mother, and they are immediately bickering. he makes a comment about how racist my mother is, and then she fires back saying she was never racist. i told them to shut up and sent my husband to sit somewhere else for a while. i decided that since the game ended late, i'll bring my mom back to my home and make her some dinner. my husband threw a hissy fit over this and was screaming about me always "choosing my mother over him" and i was like, "of fucking course i'm going to put my mom over my husband. she's the woman who singlehandedly raised me and 3 other kids. she's literally a goddess for not giving some of us for adoption." my husband stormed out and i'm left wondering if i've done something wrong. aita?
6,507
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/r2lunl/aita_for_tricking_my_husband_to_coming_to_a/
2021-11-26 12:15:28
yta. she thinks he’s stupid, why? your son asked for his dad to be there, not your mother. sounds like you’re the one with the favouritism issue considering you decided to have mum there anyway.
info: &gt;recently one of my kids was having a big football match and he wanted his father there. my mother also wanted to be there so i tried telling my son that he couldn't have his father there. why and how does your mother's wish take precedence over your **son** and your **husband**?
&gt;who singlehandedly raised me and 3 other kids. she's literally a goddess for not giving some of us for adoption this is where i became certain the mother is writing this post. also hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha. no, you're not a goddess.
info: are you married to your husband, or your mother? who do you want to be by your side in 30 years time? why does your husband think your mother is racist?
yta for not standing up to your racist mother.
yta your mother is now a part of your extended family, and you continually choose her over your immediate family. even your son wanted his father at his sports game, you told him that wasn’t possible, and you forced your racist mother upon your husband, then brought her into your family home knowing full well what would happen. what is wrong with you? if your mother is racist, she should be kept far away not only from your husband, but from your children who are presumably mixed race. the way you speak about your husband is disgraceful. you are clearly not supporting him or shutting down any bad language your mother is using, and that will be impacting your kids! i wouldn’t be surprised if this ends your marriage, and to be blunt, it is entirely your fault. you need to apologise profusely to your husband for the way you have treated him as well as allowed your mother to treat him, and tell your mother to get in line, if you have any hope of salvaging what you have basically destroyed.
yta. i can barely imagine anyone (not on a verge of divorce) treating their so like this. the way you write about husband... it is like you really are the mother pretending to be a daughter? or husband, idk, seems fishy. in case you are the daughter. you know they hate each other. your son asked for his dad specifically. you lied to your husband. and then you sent him away like a child.
info obviously this was written by the mother not the daughter. did you do this because you thought it would make you sound more sympathetic if it sounded like your daughter was on board, or are you just off your meds?
yta you deliberately did a bait and switch, inviting your mother to your son's game, choosing your mother over your husband and your son's father. you are blind to how your mother treats him because you think she can do no wrong, so she continues to do it, because she is "literally a goddess." you then double down and invite her over and make her dinner???? your husband leaves and you are wondering if you've done something wrong? i can just picture your mother sitting there with the cat who ate the canary smile as you once again choose her over your husband.
yta. why would he make up racism? do you think he wants to be treated poorly for the colour of his skin?? you literally said that your mom thinks he’s dumb- is her treating him poorly much of a stretch? your whole approach to this issue is awful. you’re enabling your mother’s racism. you’re manipulating your husband. you are consistently not only allowing him to be treated badly by your family but also in this case, treating him badly yourself. if you want to stay married this man, you need to fix this shit because no one is going to allow themself to be demeaned for the rest of their life. i’d have left years ago.
YTA
INFO
null
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
0.052378
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my mother and husband hate each other. that's the most basic way to put it. truth is that my husband feels that he is treated as less than my other sibling's spouses because of his skin colour, and my mother feels that he is way too dumb for my standards. however, i personally feel that my mother does not show any favouritism or harsh treatment of my husband. because of this, my husband cannot stand my mother and has recently begun to even be in the same room as her. "oh your mom's going to be at christmas? i'm going to a friend's house." "oh your mom's going to the kid's event? i'll just stay at home." frankly it's insanely demoralising for me, and i hate my husband when he backs out of something just because my mom is going to be there, and it's worse when he demands that my mom not go because he wants to be there. in my opinion, he's the one with the big issue, he should be the one to leave the kid's events. recently one of my kids was having a big football match and he wanted his father there. my mother also wanted to be there so i tried telling my son that he couldn't have his father there. he was adamant, so i told my husband that my mother was not going to be there. he arrives, and obviously, so does my mother, and they are immediately bickering. he makes a comment about how racist my mother is, and then she fires back saying she was never racist. i told them to shut up and sent my husband to sit somewhere else for a while. i decided that since the game ended late, i'll bring my mom back to my home and make her some dinner. my husband threw a hissy fit over this and was screaming about me always "choosing my mother over him" and i was like, "of fucking course i'm going to put my mom over my husband. she's the woman who singlehandedly raised me and 3 other kids. she's literally a goddess for not giving some of us for adoption." my husband stormed out and i'm left wondering if i've done something wrong. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my mother and husband hate each other. that's the most basic way to put it. truth is that my husband feels that he is treated as less than my other sibling's spouses because of his skin colour, and my mother feels that he is way too dumb for my standards. however, i personally feel that my mother does not show any favouritism or harsh treatment of my husband. because of this, my husband cannot stand my mother and has recently begun to even be in the same room as her. "oh your mom's going to be at christmas? i'm going to a friend's house." "oh your mom's going to the kid's event? i'll just stay at home." frankly it's insanely demoralising for me, and i hate my husband when he backs out of something just because my mom is going to be there, and it's worse when he demands that my mom not go because he wants to be there. in my opinion, he's the one with the big issue, he should be the one to leave the kid's events. recently one of my kids was having a big football match and he wanted his father there. my mother also wanted to be there so i tried telling my son that he couldn't have his father there. he was adamant, so i told my husband that my mother was not going to be there. he arrives, and obviously, so does my mother, and they are immediately bickering. he makes a comment about how racist my mother is, and then she fires back saying she was never racist. i told them to shut up and sent my husband to sit somewhere else for a while. i decided that since the game ended late, i'll bring my mom back to my home and make her some dinner. my husband threw a hissy fit over this and was screaming about me always "choosing my mother over him" and i was like, "of fucking course i'm going to put my mom over my husband. she's the woman who singlehandedly raised me and 3 other kids. she's literally a goddess for not giving some of us for adoption." my husband stormed out and i'm left wondering if i've done something wrong. aita? [/INST] yta. she thinks he’s stupid, why? your son asked for his dad to be there, not your mother. sounds like you’re the one with the favouritism issue considering you decided to have mum there anyway. </s>
AITA for telling my girlfriend that it’s weird that she says “I love you” to her brother?
my(26m) girlfriend(24f) has a brother(19m) who goes to college only about an hour from where we live. he sometimes visits my girlfriend, and whenever he leaves from the visit, my girlfriend says that she loves him, and he usually returns a thumbs-up(which is kind of funny), but i think it shows he’s a bit weirded out as well by her saying she loves him. i understand saying “i love you” to your parents or kids, but it feels weird to say it to a sibling, since while i do love my brother, never in a million years would i say that to him. i told my girlfriend this, and she seemed kind of weirded out by what i said. she said that there was no problem with what she says, and that i was the one being weird.
5,312
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ud6aba/aita_for_telling_my_girlfriend_that_its_weird/
2022-04-27 15:31:27
yta. expressing emotions is good, actually. don't be the guy who, on his deathbed, wishes he'd told the people he loves how he felt. you love your brother? tell him! you love your girlfriend? tell her! you love that bird that's trying to steal crumbs from your lunch? tell it!
yta who gets jealous over a sibling? good lord
just because you're too emotionally stunted to say "i love you" to your brother doesn't make it weird that your girlfriend does. yta
yta this is a you issue, not a her issue.
info: do you have the emotional range of a teaspoon?
wow does that reveal a lot about you. yta. go find a therapist.
yta. if you felt a little weirded out and kept it to yourself, that would be one thing. why oh why would you tell her that? you should always let the ones you love know it. your assumption that the brother’s thumbs up indicates he’s weirded out is way outa line (i hope you didn’t share that assumption with your gf). that’s you projecting your insecurities on someone else.
yta. i have 4 brothers. everytime, with out a fail, i tell my brothers “i love you”. you never know when you’re going to lose someone. always say you love them before y’all depart. you got some issues with showing affection.
yta. stop acting like a child and trying to make her totally normal relationship with her brother seem weird. mind your own business and grow up.
so your girlfriend shows affection to her brother, and that upsets you... why? that's a you problem, yta
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0.003
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my(26m) girlfriend(24f) has a brother(19m) who goes to college only about an hour from where we live. he sometimes visits my girlfriend, and whenever he leaves from the visit, my girlfriend says that she loves him, and he usually returns a thumbs-up(which is kind of funny), but i think it shows he’s a bit weirded out as well by her saying she loves him. i understand saying “i love you” to your parents or kids, but it feels weird to say it to a sibling, since while i do love my brother, never in a million years would i say that to him. i told my girlfriend this, and she seemed kind of weirded out by what i said. she said that there was no problem with what she says, and that i was the one being weird.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my(26m) girlfriend(24f) has a brother(19m) who goes to college only about an hour from where we live. he sometimes visits my girlfriend, and whenever he leaves from the visit, my girlfriend says that she loves him, and he usually returns a thumbs-up(which is kind of funny), but i think it shows he’s a bit weirded out as well by her saying she loves him. i understand saying “i love you” to your parents or kids, but it feels weird to say it to a sibling, since while i do love my brother, never in a million years would i say that to him. i told my girlfriend this, and she seemed kind of weirded out by what i said. she said that there was no problem with what she says, and that i was the one being weird. [/INST] yta. expressing emotions is good, actually. don't be the guy who, on his deathbed, wishes he'd told the people he loves how he felt. you love your brother? tell him! you love your girlfriend? tell her! you love that bird that's trying to steal crumbs from your lunch? tell it! </s>
AITA for not letting my daughter get acrylics?
i (40f) have a daughter (14f) who asked me if one of her christmas presents could be a trip to the nail salon. she wanted to get long acrylics done like she sees a lot of other girls wearing. i am going to be honest and say that i think acrylic nails are a waste of money when press-ons are much cheaper and can look just as good when done properly, even though they don't last quite as long. i wear press ons pretty regularly, which she knows. when she asked if i would take her i said no, and explained my reasoning. i told her that she could look online or i'd take her to ulta and get her press ons that i'd show her how to do. since that sounds cheap, and because it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about where the money is going, i told her i would try and get her a hair appointment and she could get something fancy done. my daughter objected - saying that nobody gets press ons done and that press ons don't look good. admittedly, i felt hurt as i think i do pretty good on my nails. i told her that she can take my offer or leave it, but she won't be disrespectful. she continued to complain about how she'd be made fun of for having press ons and not the real thing. i told her if she got her own money i'd take her to the salon but i am not paying for something i feel is a waste of money. my husband says i'm being too harsh, and that acrylics are a status symbol for girls now. i said that she's 14, she doesn't need a symbol of her status. he pointed out that we could afford a trip to the nail salon. i agreed, but reiterated that it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about the worth. my husband grumbled for a bit and now they are both unhappy with me. aita?
6,740
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/zen6xl/aita_for_not_letting_my_daughter_get_acrylics/
2022-12-07 00:31:29
yta. there’s a difference between her getting acrylics once as a christmas present and regularly spending the money on it. going to the salon is a whole experience. she was gonna realize how much work is required to maintain them and you’d have been able to convert her to press ons then. instead of whatever you’re doing now, this could’ve been a learning moment. why do you dismiss your husband’s opinion on this? does he not get an equal say on what his daughter gets for christmas?
i'm going with yta she's requesting this as a gift not a general every day thing. and just because you don't find value in the gift doesn't mean she won't. the gift is not for you it's for her. and while press on nails might be good enough for you it's not what she's wanting. and given that this isn't a money issue i think it's reasonable for her to get the nails she's wanting. this is like refusing to buy a kid a toy they want for xmas just because you wouldn't play with the toy. edited for typo
yta if you had declined because acrylics are damaging. you might have a case. however, your daughter thinks press ons are tacky trash. she is correct. this is more about your ego than your daughter’s happiness.
my nail tech won't put acrylic/gel nails on my 14 year old. could be a personal preference for her or perhaps state mandates. but your daughter wants the experience. it's fun. i get you think it's a 'waste of money' but it's a christmas present. i know i don't own any gifts from my 14th christmas- so ultimately *any* gift is a waste of money at that age. let her get the nails. if she wants to pay for upkeep, that's fair to 'make' her do so. but what she wants for christmas is about what she wants... not what you feel about it. edit to add: yta for making her christmas present about you. example: i hate the color pink. my niece loves it. i won't avoid pink for her present because i feel a certain way. that's ridiculous.
yta, you can say no, but you are not being consistent. it's not about the amount spent, but what you want isn't worth the value-- how does this make sense especially to a teen who wants the acrylics and not the hair appointment. at that point it seems like you want to control her more than say no. she isn't trying to insult you by not wanting press on nails, but if she has seen one girl teased for press on nails, she is going to be reluctant to compromise here. she is asking for a christmas present, not a year long commitment. you can say no, but trying to compromise for something that is similar and what you want rather than what she asked for without more reasons than "this is how i do it" feels more like control and judgment of what she values than you actually listening to what she wants.
yta. why is it your decision what is “worth” it to your daughter? she’s asked for it as a christmas present. would you also reject other presents about her interests if you don’t think they’re worth it?
acrylics are absolutely awful for your natural nails so i wouldn't recommend them at all but gel nails are way better and look just as pretty. alternatively you could take her to the salon and let the techs know what you are willing to compromise on with your daughter and go from there.
nta. the problem with acrylics is it’s not just one appointment, it’s an appointment every 4-6 weeks to keep them up. when she has money of her own, she can spend it every 4-6 weeks.
the problem with acrylics is you have to keep doing them. so who will be paying for fills and fixes? if it’s a one time deal she’s bound for disappointment after a few weeks, but sometimes kids just need to learn.
sheesh, yta for being overly controlling of your daughter, and dismissing your husband. she asked for a special christmas treat. take her and let her get the nails done.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
NTA
null
YTA
0.04134
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (40f) have a daughter (14f) who asked me if one of her christmas presents could be a trip to the nail salon. she wanted to get long acrylics done like she sees a lot of other girls wearing. i am going to be honest and say that i think acrylic nails are a waste of money when press-ons are much cheaper and can look just as good when done properly, even though they don't last quite as long. i wear press ons pretty regularly, which she knows. when she asked if i would take her i said no, and explained my reasoning. i told her that she could look online or i'd take her to ulta and get her press ons that i'd show her how to do. since that sounds cheap, and because it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about where the money is going, i told her i would try and get her a hair appointment and she could get something fancy done. my daughter objected - saying that nobody gets press ons done and that press ons don't look good. admittedly, i felt hurt as i think i do pretty good on my nails. i told her that she can take my offer or leave it, but she won't be disrespectful. she continued to complain about how she'd be made fun of for having press ons and not the real thing. i told her if she got her own money i'd take her to the salon but i am not paying for something i feel is a waste of money. my husband says i'm being too harsh, and that acrylics are a status symbol for girls now. i said that she's 14, she doesn't need a symbol of her status. he pointed out that we could afford a trip to the nail salon. i agreed, but reiterated that it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about the worth. my husband grumbled for a bit and now they are both unhappy with me. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (40f) have a daughter (14f) who asked me if one of her christmas presents could be a trip to the nail salon. she wanted to get long acrylics done like she sees a lot of other girls wearing. i am going to be honest and say that i think acrylic nails are a waste of money when press-ons are much cheaper and can look just as good when done properly, even though they don't last quite as long. i wear press ons pretty regularly, which she knows. when she asked if i would take her i said no, and explained my reasoning. i told her that she could look online or i'd take her to ulta and get her press ons that i'd show her how to do. since that sounds cheap, and because it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about where the money is going, i told her i would try and get her a hair appointment and she could get something fancy done. my daughter objected - saying that nobody gets press ons done and that press ons don't look good. admittedly, i felt hurt as i think i do pretty good on my nails. i told her that she can take my offer or leave it, but she won't be disrespectful. she continued to complain about how she'd be made fun of for having press ons and not the real thing. i told her if she got her own money i'd take her to the salon but i am not paying for something i feel is a waste of money. my husband says i'm being too harsh, and that acrylics are a status symbol for girls now. i said that she's 14, she doesn't need a symbol of her status. he pointed out that we could afford a trip to the nail salon. i agreed, but reiterated that it isn't about the dollar amount, it's about the worth. my husband grumbled for a bit and now they are both unhappy with me. aita? [/INST] yta. there’s a difference between her getting acrylics once as a christmas present and regularly spending the money on it. going to the salon is a whole experience. she was gonna realize how much work is required to maintain them and you’d have been able to convert her to press ons then. instead of whatever you’re doing now, this could’ve been a learning moment. why do you dismiss your husband’s opinion on this? does he not get an equal say on what his daughter gets for christmas? </s>
AITA for not doing anything after discovering that my wife deleted my daughter's novel?
throwaway for privacy reasons. i have been married to my wife hannah (36) for 2 years, she and my daughter morgan (16) don't have a daughter-mother relationship, to be completely transparent here...they both fight often and just don't get along. morgan used to spend most of her time at her mom's but now is staying with us for school. i remember hannah telling me about a novel morgan has been writing on her laptop, she admitted to sneaking and looking at it without morgan's knowledge but she praised her writing style and story telling so i thought that was a positive thing. yesterday, i got back home and found morgan and her mom yelling at hannah. i asked what was happening and morgon told me that hannah deleted her novel, hannah said that morgan created a character in the novel using her description and name and making her the villian, not only that but she wrote bad words about her, mirgan argued that it was just a character and hannah had no business snooping on her laptop to begin with. hannah broke down crying after my ex wife thratened her. i just watched the 3 of them fight and did nothing nor said a single word. i stepped out for a minute to get fresh air and moments later, hannah unloaded on me about how i should've defended her in the argument instead of acting so cowerdly, morgan and her mom also said that i should've done something when hannah decided to snoop then delet morgan's months worth of work. it just became too much with the 3 of them berating me and yelling in my face. morgan went home with her mom and she was crying and refused to speak to me and hannah checked into a hotel also refusing to speak to me. the texts from both sides kept coming in both telling me i should've done something and should've took their side in the argument. i just had to stay out of this one, i was on my feet the entire week working, both mental and physical health are down the drain and i'm tired of them fighting all the time then blaming me for my actions/or lack of. both are expecting me to get involved and do something to fix this but i haven't done anything yet. am i the asshole for not getting involved?
14,906
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/su6x3a/aita_for_not_doing_anything_after_discovering/
2022-02-16 21:27:44
yta hanna should pay for the recovery services to get the novel back (this will run $1500-$3000 and wont guarantee that it is successful). there is no question who ta is here and its both you and hannah. the laptop should be powered off and not used until it is sent in for recovery to give it the bast chance of succeeding. &gt;it just became too much with the 3 of them berating me and yelling in my face. well you arent going to have a great time here either.
yta. as is hannah. your daughter was writing fiction, and probably processing some stuff with that writing. hannah snooped, then deleted her work. work which was in no way public or created to hurt hannah. you are ta for not realizing how profoundly hannah fucked up here and how inappropriate her behavior was.
[removed]
[removed]
yta- defend your daughter. awww, your wife was the villain in her story? wife would have never known had she minded her own business.
yta. your daughter needed you and you completely bailed on her. take the computer to a professional. it's possible they can recover the writing. also, anyone who would treat my daughter like that would be out of my life in a hurry.
yta write what you know. that's people are encouraged to write about. sometimes one character is a mix of different people in the author's life. sometimes it's a complete fabrication. did you ever consider that maybe this novel could be your daughter's way of working through her feelings? even if it was a complete vilification of your wife, this is a novel. it may not get published. it may end up being a bestseller. chances are, it would have stayed on her computer, basically a digital version of a diary. your wife did a terrible thing. *multiple* terrible things: 1. she snooped on your daughter's computer. she's not the mother, and even if she were, i would have issues with that. 2. she turned a creation of your daughter's imagination into an argument about herself. 3. she deleted months worth of work because she didn't like how one character was written. your wife needs to apologize. you need to apologize. because you should *absolutely* have done something. you should have stood up for your daughter's right to privacy and the freedom to write a book. yta
bruh.....you get one shot to not fuck up a relationship with your daughter. that ship is sailing already and it's leaky. are you really so dense that you can't see that the way your daughter sees your gf is way more important than the way you do? maybe take a long look at what you've been blind to. if you had your priorities in the right place you would have told your gf she wasn't ever in the right for snooping on your daughters laptop.
yta for not defending your daughter when your wife destroyed her creative property. and automatic yta for marrying a woman who seems to be verbally abusive to your kid. your #1 concern when marrying this woman should have been her relationship to your daughter. ultimate dad fail.
you allowed your asshole wife to invade your daughter's privacy on multiple occasions, and thought it a "positive thing." you learned that your asshole wife deleted your daughter's intellectual property that took a lot of time and hard work and that didn't make you livid. you want to play switzerland in a situation where your asshole wife unambiguously victimized your daughter. gee, hmm, i don't know, yta?
YTA
YTA
null
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: throwaway for privacy reasons. i have been married to my wife hannah (36) for 2 years, she and my daughter morgan (16) don't have a daughter-mother relationship, to be completely transparent here...they both fight often and just don't get along. morgan used to spend most of her time at her mom's but now is staying with us for school. i remember hannah telling me about a novel morgan has been writing on her laptop, she admitted to sneaking and looking at it without morgan's knowledge but she praised her writing style and story telling so i thought that was a positive thing. yesterday, i got back home and found morgan and her mom yelling at hannah. i asked what was happening and morgon told me that hannah deleted her novel, hannah said that morgan created a character in the novel using her description and name and making her the villian, not only that but she wrote bad words about her, mirgan argued that it was just a character and hannah had no business snooping on her laptop to begin with. hannah broke down crying after my ex wife thratened her. i just watched the 3 of them fight and did nothing nor said a single word. i stepped out for a minute to get fresh air and moments later, hannah unloaded on me about how i should've defended her in the argument instead of acting so cowerdly, morgan and her mom also said that i should've done something when hannah decided to snoop then delet morgan's months worth of work. it just became too much with the 3 of them berating me and yelling in my face. morgan went home with her mom and she was crying and refused to speak to me and hannah checked into a hotel also refusing to speak to me. the texts from both sides kept coming in both telling me i should've done something and should've took their side in the argument. i just had to stay out of this one, i was on my feet the entire week working, both mental and physical health are down the drain and i'm tired of them fighting all the time then blaming me for my actions/or lack of. both are expecting me to get involved and do something to fix this but i haven't done anything yet. am i the asshole for not getting involved?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> throwaway for privacy reasons. i have been married to my wife hannah (36) for 2 years, she and my daughter morgan (16) don't have a daughter-mother relationship, to be completely transparent here...they both fight often and just don't get along. morgan used to spend most of her time at her mom's but now is staying with us for school. i remember hannah telling me about a novel morgan has been writing on her laptop, she admitted to sneaking and looking at it without morgan's knowledge but she praised her writing style and story telling so i thought that was a positive thing. yesterday, i got back home and found morgan and her mom yelling at hannah. i asked what was happening and morgon told me that hannah deleted her novel, hannah said that morgan created a character in the novel using her description and name and making her the villian, not only that but she wrote bad words about her, mirgan argued that it was just a character and hannah had no business snooping on her laptop to begin with. hannah broke down crying after my ex wife thratened her. i just watched the 3 of them fight and did nothing nor said a single word. i stepped out for a minute to get fresh air and moments later, hannah unloaded on me about how i should've defended her in the argument instead of acting so cowerdly, morgan and her mom also said that i should've done something when hannah decided to snoop then delet morgan's months worth of work. it just became too much with the 3 of them berating me and yelling in my face. morgan went home with her mom and she was crying and refused to speak to me and hannah checked into a hotel also refusing to speak to me. the texts from both sides kept coming in both telling me i should've done something and should've took their side in the argument. i just had to stay out of this one, i was on my feet the entire week working, both mental and physical health are down the drain and i'm tired of them fighting all the time then blaming me for my actions/or lack of. both are expecting me to get involved and do something to fix this but i haven't done anything yet. am i the asshole for not getting involved? [/INST] yta hanna should pay for the recovery services to get the novel back (this will run $1500-$3000 and wont guarantee that it is successful). there is no question who ta is here and its both you and hannah. the laptop should be powered off and not used until it is sent in for recovery to give it the bast chance of succeeding. &gt;it just became too much with the 3 of them berating me and yelling in my face. well you arent going to have a great time here either. </s>
AITA for asking my daughter and her fiancè to change their wedding date so my other daughter could attend?
i have 2 daughters, april (24), and kate (22), kate is getting married this march. now none of us knew the date til we got the invitations. when april got her invitation, she called me saying that since she's due this month (she's expecting her baby) then the chance of her attending her sister's wedding is slim. it dawned on me and we started discussing all possible scenarios and april said that even if she gave birth a week or 2 before the wedding then she won't be able to attend either because she'll need time to settle and recover. i agreed with her but was hasitant wheb she suggested i talk kate into moving her wedding at least 2 months. i called kate and told her about the conversation april and i had, i asked if she could consider moving the wedding date a couple of months so april could attend and she shut it down immediately. i said that her sister cares about her enough to want to be in the wedding so bad and she should really consider because it's better to wait then have a wedding with missing family members. she said mine and april's request was unrealistic and selfish because she and her fiance spent money on the venue, invitations, food etc. i said i understand but really is those things more important than her sister's presence at the wedding? god blessed them with a good relationship and missing the wedding without a doubt will make april hurt. kate ruedly said this isn't about april but i warned her that april might get so hurt she'd consider letting her meet the baby once he arrives. kate got mad and told me to stop bullying her into doing what april want and told me it's her wedding and no ond has the right to tell her what to do. i asked what's with this attitude and she hung up. i tried calling her and her fiance asked me to stop forcing the issue and let the sisters work this out hut i think that as their mother it's my role to navigate through their disagreements. they said i'm meddling but i think i'm trying to work this issue out. aita?
6,642
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/sq9yz2/aita_for_asking_my_daughter_and_her_fiancè_to/
2022-02-11 21:22:35
yta. are you well? what exactly are you thinking? unless you are going to pay for a new venue and new invites, re-coordinate the wedding party, pay for any new flights for wedding party members who have booked non-refundable travel, and handle all the calls from confused attendees who get the re-invite, then no, this is not reasonable.
yta march is next month… either april and kate aren’t close enough that kate didn’t know that april was pregnant or she knew and didn’t care. or the date has been set for over 9 months and you and april just didn’t care enough to ask for details of the wedding. you cannot expect for a bride and groom to reschedule their wedding, lose all the deposits on less than a month notice.
yta. when kate said no the first time you should have accepted that.
yta. you asked and got a no and that should have been the end of it. &gt;kate ruedly said this isn't about april but i warned her that april might get so hurt she'd consider letting her meet the baby once he arrives. is that true? if so april is an asshole too. if it's not you're an even bigger asshole
sooo...let me break it down for you: you: "kate, will you change your wedding date?" kate: no you: "kate will you change your wedding date" kate: no you: "kate, will you change your wedding date?" kate: noooooooo you: "kate, will you change your wedding date?" kate: stop asking me i said no. you: "geesh whats up with the attitude" you: " calls kate", hmm wonder what you where going to ask.... needless to say yta
yta. you are 100% bullying her and ignoring her concerns. it’s a month away!! she probably wouldn’t be able to move it, most venues are probably booked through next year and she lose out on money. you paying for all of that so your daughter can attend?! you act like she can snap her fingers and make it happen. then you threatened her with the possibility of not meeting her niece/nephew?
yta. kate is right, this isn't about april, it's about kate and her fiance. if kate and april have such a close relationship, then why did april call you about this and not kate? the invitations have gone out, there is no changing the date at this point. ultimately, this issue is between your two adult daughters, so you need to back off.
yta. from your post it's obvious which of your daughters is your favorite. kate knows it and you should be ashamed of yourself.
yta kate knew the due date, i presume? so she knew there was a possibility of her sister not making it. it's her wedding. she's paying for it. she made her decision regardless. maybe she just wants a day where you're not favouring her sister over her? &gt;i warned her that april might get so hurt she'd consider letting her meet the baby once he arrives. what made you think that issuing this threat on april's behalf would make you a decent parent to either daughter? if that *is* a genuine concern for you then you're admitting what kind of person you think april is. and it's not good.
yta. kate is getting married in a month, it's too late to reschedule now without them losing a ton of money in deposits. april will just have to miss the wedding. and no, it's not your role to navigate your daughters' disagreements, they're grown women now and can sort their own sh!t out. stay out and stop meddling.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i have 2 daughters, april (24), and kate (22), kate is getting married this march. now none of us knew the date til we got the invitations. when april got her invitation, she called me saying that since she's due this month (she's expecting her baby) then the chance of her attending her sister's wedding is slim. it dawned on me and we started discussing all possible scenarios and april said that even if she gave birth a week or 2 before the wedding then she won't be able to attend either because she'll need time to settle and recover. i agreed with her but was hasitant wheb she suggested i talk kate into moving her wedding at least 2 months. i called kate and told her about the conversation april and i had, i asked if she could consider moving the wedding date a couple of months so april could attend and she shut it down immediately. i said that her sister cares about her enough to want to be in the wedding so bad and she should really consider because it's better to wait then have a wedding with missing family members. she said mine and april's request was unrealistic and selfish because she and her fiance spent money on the venue, invitations, food etc. i said i understand but really is those things more important than her sister's presence at the wedding? god blessed them with a good relationship and missing the wedding without a doubt will make april hurt. kate ruedly said this isn't about april but i warned her that april might get so hurt she'd consider letting her meet the baby once he arrives. kate got mad and told me to stop bullying her into doing what april want and told me it's her wedding and no ond has the right to tell her what to do. i asked what's with this attitude and she hung up. i tried calling her and her fiance asked me to stop forcing the issue and let the sisters work this out hut i think that as their mother it's my role to navigate through their disagreements. they said i'm meddling but i think i'm trying to work this issue out. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i have 2 daughters, april (24), and kate (22), kate is getting married this march. now none of us knew the date til we got the invitations. when april got her invitation, she called me saying that since she's due this month (she's expecting her baby) then the chance of her attending her sister's wedding is slim. it dawned on me and we started discussing all possible scenarios and april said that even if she gave birth a week or 2 before the wedding then she won't be able to attend either because she'll need time to settle and recover. i agreed with her but was hasitant wheb she suggested i talk kate into moving her wedding at least 2 months. i called kate and told her about the conversation april and i had, i asked if she could consider moving the wedding date a couple of months so april could attend and she shut it down immediately. i said that her sister cares about her enough to want to be in the wedding so bad and she should really consider because it's better to wait then have a wedding with missing family members. she said mine and april's request was unrealistic and selfish because she and her fiance spent money on the venue, invitations, food etc. i said i understand but really is those things more important than her sister's presence at the wedding? god blessed them with a good relationship and missing the wedding without a doubt will make april hurt. kate ruedly said this isn't about april but i warned her that april might get so hurt she'd consider letting her meet the baby once he arrives. kate got mad and told me to stop bullying her into doing what april want and told me it's her wedding and no ond has the right to tell her what to do. i asked what's with this attitude and she hung up. i tried calling her and her fiance asked me to stop forcing the issue and let the sisters work this out hut i think that as their mother it's my role to navigate through their disagreements. they said i'm meddling but i think i'm trying to work this issue out. aita? [/INST] yta. are you well? what exactly are you thinking? unless you are going to pay for a new venue and new invites, re-coordinate the wedding party, pay for any new flights for wedding party members who have booked non-refundable travel, and handle all the calls from confused attendees who get the re-invite, then no, this is not reasonable. </s>
AITA for keeping an emergency family iphone secretly hidden in the car my daughter drives so I can always track the location of the car?
well the cat’s out of the bag on this one, but it doesn’t matter because now i have justification to reinstate previous, more stringent cell phone rules. my daughter is 16 and as most 16 year olds, she has her own phone with less parental control. but i still have sensible rules like no turning off iphone tracking, always answer my texts or calls immediately or within a reasonable time frame when not in school or practice, no dead battery excuses. but i know teenagers can be sneaky, so i have a backup tracking plan that i keep secret from her. i have an extra older version iphone on my family plan that i use as an emergency phone. i hide this phone somewhere in the car that i let my daughter drive, kept on silent. it’s always charged so i can track it when my daughter is out. this past weekend, my daughter told me she was going to her friend brett’s house to prepare for an academic competition and an oratory event. when i checked on her iphone and the secret iphone, the locations matched up. she was at her friend’s house. after dinner, i checked again. curiously, her iphone’s location was at her friend’s house, but my secret iphone was clearly in downtown near all the bars and nightlife. i called my daughter and she told me everything was fine, including the car. i drove to my car’s find iphone location to see if maybe it was wrong, and eventually found my car parked along the street near the lgbt night life area. i called brett’s father (brett’s parents are divorced and the dad does not live with brett, and brett’s mom had the night shift so i called the dad). before brett’s dad got there, i walked around asking the bouncers at the bars if they had seen my daughter or her friend (i showed them photos). i finally talked to one who remembered turning away my daughter and brett earlier in the night for trying to use fake ids. i was livid. i wandered the area and eventually found my daughter and brett hanging out at a coffee house. i waited for brett’s dad to park before going in. i asked him what his understanding of the situation was, and he told me as far as his ex told him, the kids were supposed to be at home doing prep work for a oratory competition. i told brett’s dad where i was and he and i walked into the cafe together to retrieve our kids. after we returned home, my daughter confessed to trying to sneak into a gay club with brett, who apparently is closeted to his parents and school. she was most upset that i outed brett to his parents this way. but she has not given me any reason to trust her or her friend brett given their behavior this weekend. stricter rules are on the way. she continues to think i am the biggest villain in her entire world but really, if i hadn’t installed an emergency phone in the car, i wouldn’t have known the shenanigans these two were up to under the guise of studying. sure, i violated her and brett’s privacy, but i feel it’s justified.
12,553
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/fclhar/aita_for_keeping_an_emergency_family_iphone/
2020-03-02 23:48:13
yta. kids do this shit *because* of parents like you. quit fucking stalking your child.
[removed]
[deleted]
yta for the hidden tracking device. yes, it sucks your daughter lied, and sucks even more that she tried to use a fake id. at least she got turned away and was just drinking coffee. yes, it could have been worse, but that's what happens with teenagers sometimes. they go out, they push boundaries, and they can be stupid. i was no exception to that. but all this has done is shown your daughter that you never trusted her, and will likely cause her to have severe trust issues with you for a long time to come. i'm 30, and still am overly secretive to my mom because of her always snooping around my room when i was a teenager. she's going to try to dig up what's going on with me, anyway, so what's the point in telling her anything? i can see this being the same with her. you really damaged that trust and that makes you the bigger asshole than your teenage daughter trying to sneak into a bar.
yta, and massively so. this post is so strange that i genuinely wonder whether it’s a troll post. let me ask you: *why* do you feel the need to track your daughter’s every move without her knowledge? has your daughter given you any reason to distrust her? because i find that weird as hell. granted, i didn’t get an iphone until i was 23, but i can’t understand why you would need to know where your daughter is at every given moment. especially because, by tracking her primary phone movements all the time, you’ve just given her a reason to deliberately leave her phone behind if she goes somewhere...leaving her possibly stranded without a phone. your daughter’s takeaway is that you don’t trust her, you never trusted her, and now, she’s not going to trust you. you didn’t even call her to ask her where she was or give her a chance to explain. you did not have an iphone growing up because they didn’t exist yet; your parents didn’t secretly track *your* every move. how would you have felt as a teenager if your parents secretly installed a gps somewhere in your body of clothes?
yta. you outed a teen before they were ready and obsessively stalked your daughter. sixteen is old enough to begin earning some independence, and i would guess she snuck around like this because she already knows you aren’t a safe adult she can trust. you owe your daughter an apology and a sincere discussion about both of your expectations - hearing her out and not being a controlling figure. unless you’ve left something out about your daughter being a drug dealer or underage sex worker, she doesn’t deserve to be policed like this.
yta you want to bonsai your daughter to stop her from growing up. pure and simple. and youre a bully. you doing sneaky things behind her back = fine, but heaven forbid she does something sneaky = big trouble. do you want to estrange your daughter? because that's how you estrange your daughter.
yta you outed a gay kid to his family. i don't see why you couldn't have retrieved your daughter without ruining brett's life as well. you were cruel to him for the sake of being cruel, and honestly yta is too gentle a judgment for creatures like you.
yta. you're not teaching your child how to be an adult, or that actions have consequences, you're teaching her to lie better. next time, she's just going to take someone else's car and leave her phone behind. hell, she may get so paranoid that she changes clothing before going places she isn't supposed to be! you need to look at why your daughter doesn't feel comfortable telling you the truth about where she's going or what she's doing. don't be surprised when she cuts ties with you as soon as possible, as a result of your over controlling parenting.
congratulations asshole. you've just completely alienated your daughter from your life by not trusting her to be a teenager. i don't know what sort of sheltered childhood you had, but at least where i'm from, teenagers sneak out. they do things against their parents wishes. they form their own opinions and become adults. you can't just be a helicopter parent and if you think this sort of stalking antisocial behaviour towards her is going to help you or her or anyone else involved in this, you are completely wrong. this is how you get thrown in a care home once you're old enough, and forgotten about. the only 'stricter rules' that need to be put in place are the ones about you and your boundaries between you and your kids. how the fuck is she meant to develop intimate relationships and meaningful connections with people when her creepy parent is watching her every move? have you ever had every moment of your life monitored like you're in some sort of real life truman show? you need to seriously re-evaluate your priorities bud. if i was your daughter, i would hit the road as soon as i was old enough and never look back. and it would be completely your doing. yta, 100% completely and utterly yta.
YTA
null
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: well the cat’s out of the bag on this one, but it doesn’t matter because now i have justification to reinstate previous, more stringent cell phone rules. my daughter is 16 and as most 16 year olds, she has her own phone with less parental control. but i still have sensible rules like no turning off iphone tracking, always answer my texts or calls immediately or within a reasonable time frame when not in school or practice, no dead battery excuses. but i know teenagers can be sneaky, so i have a backup tracking plan that i keep secret from her. i have an extra older version iphone on my family plan that i use as an emergency phone. i hide this phone somewhere in the car that i let my daughter drive, kept on silent. it’s always charged so i can track it when my daughter is out. this past weekend, my daughter told me she was going to her friend brett’s house to prepare for an academic competition and an oratory event. when i checked on her iphone and the secret iphone, the locations matched up. she was at her friend’s house. after dinner, i checked again. curiously, her iphone’s location was at her friend’s house, but my secret iphone was clearly in downtown near all the bars and nightlife. i called my daughter and she told me everything was fine, including the car. i drove to my car’s find iphone location to see if maybe it was wrong, and eventually found my car parked along the street near the lgbt night life area. i called brett’s father (brett’s parents are divorced and the dad does not live with brett, and brett’s mom had the night shift so i called the dad). before brett’s dad got there, i walked around asking the bouncers at the bars if they had seen my daughter or her friend (i showed them photos). i finally talked to one who remembered turning away my daughter and brett earlier in the night for trying to use fake ids. i was livid. i wandered the area and eventually found my daughter and brett hanging out at a coffee house. i waited for brett’s dad to park before going in. i asked him what his understanding of the situation was, and he told me as far as his ex told him, the kids were supposed to be at home doing prep work for a oratory competition. i told brett’s dad where i was and he and i walked into the cafe together to retrieve our kids. after we returned home, my daughter confessed to trying to sneak into a gay club with brett, who apparently is closeted to his parents and school. she was most upset that i outed brett to his parents this way. but she has not given me any reason to trust her or her friend brett given their behavior this weekend. stricter rules are on the way. she continues to think i am the biggest villain in her entire world but really, if i hadn’t installed an emergency phone in the car, i wouldn’t have known the shenanigans these two were up to under the guise of studying. sure, i violated her and brett’s privacy, but i feel it’s justified.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> well the cat’s out of the bag on this one, but it doesn’t matter because now i have justification to reinstate previous, more stringent cell phone rules. my daughter is 16 and as most 16 year olds, she has her own phone with less parental control. but i still have sensible rules like no turning off iphone tracking, always answer my texts or calls immediately or within a reasonable time frame when not in school or practice, no dead battery excuses. but i know teenagers can be sneaky, so i have a backup tracking plan that i keep secret from her. i have an extra older version iphone on my family plan that i use as an emergency phone. i hide this phone somewhere in the car that i let my daughter drive, kept on silent. it’s always charged so i can track it when my daughter is out. this past weekend, my daughter told me she was going to her friend brett’s house to prepare for an academic competition and an oratory event. when i checked on her iphone and the secret iphone, the locations matched up. she was at her friend’s house. after dinner, i checked again. curiously, her iphone’s location was at her friend’s house, but my secret iphone was clearly in downtown near all the bars and nightlife. i called my daughter and she told me everything was fine, including the car. i drove to my car’s find iphone location to see if maybe it was wrong, and eventually found my car parked along the street near the lgbt night life area. i called brett’s father (brett’s parents are divorced and the dad does not live with brett, and brett’s mom had the night shift so i called the dad). before brett’s dad got there, i walked around asking the bouncers at the bars if they had seen my daughter or her friend (i showed them photos). i finally talked to one who remembered turning away my daughter and brett earlier in the night for trying to use fake ids. i was livid. i wandered the area and eventually found my daughter and brett hanging out at a coffee house. i waited for brett’s dad to park before going in. i asked him what his understanding of the situation was, and he told me as far as his ex told him, the kids were supposed to be at home doing prep work for a oratory competition. i told brett’s dad where i was and he and i walked into the cafe together to retrieve our kids. after we returned home, my daughter confessed to trying to sneak into a gay club with brett, who apparently is closeted to his parents and school. she was most upset that i outed brett to his parents this way. but she has not given me any reason to trust her or her friend brett given their behavior this weekend. stricter rules are on the way. she continues to think i am the biggest villain in her entire world but really, if i hadn’t installed an emergency phone in the car, i wouldn’t have known the shenanigans these two were up to under the guise of studying. sure, i violated her and brett’s privacy, but i feel it’s justified. [/INST] yta. kids do this shit *because* of parents like you. quit fucking stalking your child. </s>
AITA for interrupting my exhusband's birthday and taking my daughter home because she was there without consent?
me f35 and my exhusband m37 got separated 1 year ago, we share custody of our 15 yo daughter. my exhusband has her for certain days, and his birthday didn't fall on one of these days. in fact, it fell on one of the days where my daughter is supposed to be with me. he called me so we could discuss letting him have my daughter on the day of his birthday but i told him no because it is not his day to have her, he got my daughter involved and she said she really wants to go but i said no because i have my reasons. my exhusband dropped it but on the day of his birthday, i went to pick my daughter up from school but i discovered that he came and took straight to the restaurant where his birthday party was taking place. i was fuming i called him but he didn't pick up, i then called my daughter and she said she was with him. i used location feature to track her phone and got the address. i showed up and interrupted the party, my exhusband started arguing with me but i told he had no consent to have my daughter with him that day but he said my daughter wanted to be there for his birthday. my former mil tried to speak to me and i told her to stay out of it then told my daughter to grab her stuff cause we were going home. my exhusband and family unloaded on me and i tried to ignore them and just leave but my daughter made it hard for me. i took her home eventually and grounded her for agreeing to leavd school with her dad when it wasn't his day. her dad called me yelling about how bitter and spiteful i was to deprive my daughter from attending his birthday, i told him it's basic respect and boundaries but he claimed it was just me being spiteful and deliberately hurtful towards him that i didn't even care how it affected my daughter. i hung up but more of his family members started blasting me on social media saying i showed up and made a scene at the restaurant. went as far as calling me 'unstable'.
19,870
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/s4imz3/aita_for_interrupting_my_exhusbands_birthday_and/
2022-01-15 11:44:47
yta you should have let him have her on the birthday. why make such a big deal? yes, your ex shouldn't have picked her up after you said no to the switch. but once he did, you should have left her and dealt with it afterwards. all you're accomplishing now is alienating your daughter. she's 15 and enjoying her time with dad. let her.
"i have my reasons" info: those better be some damn good reasons because until you elaborate, yta in my book. you hate your ex more than you love your daughter, and you proved it with your actions in this scenario.
yta. your daughter wants to spend her dad's birthday with her dad. how is her attending the party affecting you. as far as i know custody agreements are negotiable for a day or two. &gt;because i have my reasons. what is/are your reasons?
yta. "my daughter said she really wants to go" "she said on the phone she was with him". your child is 15, not 5. she can make informed decisions about whether or not she wants to go to he father's birthday party. she also was honest and told you where she was, so you knew she was safe. but that meant nothing to you, apparently. there was no reason for you to behave the way you did.
you hurt your daughter to be petty to your ex. yta. a custody agreement is flexible as long as supervised visitation isn't required. you could have easily made up the day.
yta she is 15 she can decide were she wants to be ...and as soon as she is 16 that will be at dad's full time! congratulations on pushing your teenager away
yeah yta she’s 15 and wanted to spend her dad’s birthday with him. you made a scene and exerted unnecessary control to make a point. what you’re actually doing is being irrational and alienating your child. keep it up and you risk permanently damaging your relationship with her.
yta your ex is right you're bitter and spiteful. your only reason why he couldn't have her is because "it isn't his day" he didn't even want her for the day it would be a few hours at most but you're so hellbent on hurting him via your daughter that you cannot see how much of a huge gaping ah that you are. you could've waited until he dropped her off after and talked to him and explained your reasons, but you went and caused a scene in public. you have major issues.
[deleted]
yta, as much as you would like it to be the case your daughter is not your property. your husband cannot steal a 15 year old girl. that’s her father and she wanted to spend his birthday with him. you don’t like him, so you turned up and caused a scene. you don’t care about your daughters wellbeing at all. you only care about being spiteful. i really hope your daughter posts on reddit one day and is given advice to fully move in with her dad. she’s old enough to make that decision. before i sign off - a custody agreement is for the benefit of the child. the courts keep in mind wants best for the child. usually they want both bio parents involved in the child’s life in some way as it’s *usually* the best ( maybe not in this case because you harm your child). do not for a second think the custody agreement is about you
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: me f35 and my exhusband m37 got separated 1 year ago, we share custody of our 15 yo daughter. my exhusband has her for certain days, and his birthday didn't fall on one of these days. in fact, it fell on one of the days where my daughter is supposed to be with me. he called me so we could discuss letting him have my daughter on the day of his birthday but i told him no because it is not his day to have her, he got my daughter involved and she said she really wants to go but i said no because i have my reasons. my exhusband dropped it but on the day of his birthday, i went to pick my daughter up from school but i discovered that he came and took straight to the restaurant where his birthday party was taking place. i was fuming i called him but he didn't pick up, i then called my daughter and she said she was with him. i used location feature to track her phone and got the address. i showed up and interrupted the party, my exhusband started arguing with me but i told he had no consent to have my daughter with him that day but he said my daughter wanted to be there for his birthday. my former mil tried to speak to me and i told her to stay out of it then told my daughter to grab her stuff cause we were going home. my exhusband and family unloaded on me and i tried to ignore them and just leave but my daughter made it hard for me. i took her home eventually and grounded her for agreeing to leavd school with her dad when it wasn't his day. her dad called me yelling about how bitter and spiteful i was to deprive my daughter from attending his birthday, i told him it's basic respect and boundaries but he claimed it was just me being spiteful and deliberately hurtful towards him that i didn't even care how it affected my daughter. i hung up but more of his family members started blasting me on social media saying i showed up and made a scene at the restaurant. went as far as calling me 'unstable'.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> me f35 and my exhusband m37 got separated 1 year ago, we share custody of our 15 yo daughter. my exhusband has her for certain days, and his birthday didn't fall on one of these days. in fact, it fell on one of the days where my daughter is supposed to be with me. he called me so we could discuss letting him have my daughter on the day of his birthday but i told him no because it is not his day to have her, he got my daughter involved and she said she really wants to go but i said no because i have my reasons. my exhusband dropped it but on the day of his birthday, i went to pick my daughter up from school but i discovered that he came and took straight to the restaurant where his birthday party was taking place. i was fuming i called him but he didn't pick up, i then called my daughter and she said she was with him. i used location feature to track her phone and got the address. i showed up and interrupted the party, my exhusband started arguing with me but i told he had no consent to have my daughter with him that day but he said my daughter wanted to be there for his birthday. my former mil tried to speak to me and i told her to stay out of it then told my daughter to grab her stuff cause we were going home. my exhusband and family unloaded on me and i tried to ignore them and just leave but my daughter made it hard for me. i took her home eventually and grounded her for agreeing to leavd school with her dad when it wasn't his day. her dad called me yelling about how bitter and spiteful i was to deprive my daughter from attending his birthday, i told him it's basic respect and boundaries but he claimed it was just me being spiteful and deliberately hurtful towards him that i didn't even care how it affected my daughter. i hung up but more of his family members started blasting me on social media saying i showed up and made a scene at the restaurant. went as far as calling me 'unstable'. [/INST] yta you should have let him have her on the birthday. why make such a big deal? yes, your ex shouldn't have picked her up after you said no to the switch. but once he did, you should have left her and dealt with it afterwards. all you're accomplishing now is alienating your daughter. she's 15 and enjoying her time with dad. let her. </s>
AITA For telling my husband to just deal with my mom
my husband and i just had our first child 8 weeks ago, a beautiful baby girl. after she was born i asked my mom to come stay with us for a couple weeks to help with everything because i had a quiet traumatic birth and we are new parents. after those couple of weeks i realized how nice it was to have an extra person to help with daily household stuff or to give one of us a break if the baby wakes up during the night, so i asked my mom to stay longer. i did this without talking to my husband about it and pretty much just told him about it after i already asked my mom to stay. he was kind of mad about it, but i told him i was still recovering and he's just going to need to deal with my mom being here longer. i have 12-weeks of maternity leave, but my husband only had 6 so he recently went back to work. when he comes home he will take over the baby duties and he's great at giving her baths and getting her to sleep. it warms my heart to see how good he is with our baby girl. the problem though is that he shows me almost zero affection or attention. when i was pregnant he would give me daily foot rubs and tell me how beautiful i am and how much he loves me. now, i can barely get a good morning or good night out of him. his excuse is that he's tired from work and pretty much being on solo baby duty after he gets home. he told he he has a finite amount of energy and can't pamper me the same way anymore. the other night after the baby went to sleep i asked him to give me foot rub like he used to. he said he was exhausted and just wanted an hour to himself before he goes to sleep. he said i should ask my mom for a foot rub but i said thats not the same. he told me he never gets a break between work and the baby so i'm just going to have to deal with being lower on his priority list right now. i feel like that was a low blow to use my own words against me like that. but it got me wondering if i was an asshole for making that decision unilaterally before. aita here?
6,128
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/kgw6nt/aita_for_telling_my_husband_to_just_deal_with_my/
2020-12-20 15:47:18
yta for asking your mother to move in without consulting your husband first. it is his house too. also your mother helps you with the baby, and you don’t work? but your husband works then comes home to take care of the baby with no help at all? then you ask him to rub your feet? as if he hasn’t had a hard day with working and taking care of the baby with no help. edit to add: before anyone says anything about the fact that she just gave birth. i gave birth in may and did perfectly fine with no help. yes it is very tiring being a mother, but that is what comes with the territory.
yta sorry first making a decision that should have been made as a couple and doing it just yourself. &amp;#x200b; but info: you say your husband gave you daily foot rubs while you were pregnant and basically take care of your child solo once he get's home from work. when is the last time you gave him a foot rub or catered to him. to me it sounds like he went from catering yo you, now catering to the baby. now you want him to do both but who's making sure he's a top priority
your poor husband. works all day to provide for the family (including your mum's living costs?) and when he gets home you and your mum clock off and leave him to do everything. and then you complain he is tired? yta for days.
yta. your mom’s two week visit is now 8 and holding? it’s time for her to go home. you were an ah to invite her to stay that long without discussing it with him.
yta. not just for ignoring him when it came to making such a large decision about the home life he has, but for also trying to make him pamper you after he spent the entire time after work taking care of the baby. how do you think he feels? you get help from you mom while he's at work, when he doesn't get help from either of you after work (if how you've explained it is true.). you don't have to go back to work yet, and you have the audacity to ask for a footrub? chill out. maybe don't put so much on your husband then be surprised he's tired. maybe if you want your husband to show you some affection, show him some respect.
are you giving your husband footrubs and telling him he's wonderful? he's working and looking after a baby, and you've kept your mum on without speaking to him and are expecting to be pampered. the baby is the centre of the home now, not you. why are you expecting special treatment when you don't appear to be considering your partner? yta
you did not say what your husband's relationship was with your mother. you also failed to mention if she is present when you want your feet rubbed etc. it is bothersome that you made a unilateral decision for your joint home. &amp;#x200b; &gt; he's just going to need to deal with my mom being here longer. how much longer? when you go back to work who will be the baby's primary caretaker? your mother? &amp;#x200b; &gt; he never gets a break between work and the baby he is the sole caretaker of the baby when he is home, you on the other hand have your mother helping you. &amp;#x200b; &gt; i'm just going to have to deal with being lower on his priority list right now. perhaps he has determined in his head that you have placed him lower on your priority list. furthermore, it seems that all of your issues are focused on what he can do for you. what have you done for him?
yta. you should have discussed it beforehand with your husband. how would you feel if he moved his mother in without talking to you about it first? i’m betting you probably wouldn’t be too keen on that idea.
yta. like you said you are new parents. he still cannot experience being a parent on his own without mil around all the time. he had no say in the decision, just because you had the baby doesn’t mean you make the rules. my spouse and i talk about all things before decision are made, and once we had a child communication got even more important.
of course yta you don't just move another person in without discussing it
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my husband and i just had our first child 8 weeks ago, a beautiful baby girl. after she was born i asked my mom to come stay with us for a couple weeks to help with everything because i had a quiet traumatic birth and we are new parents. after those couple of weeks i realized how nice it was to have an extra person to help with daily household stuff or to give one of us a break if the baby wakes up during the night, so i asked my mom to stay longer. i did this without talking to my husband about it and pretty much just told him about it after i already asked my mom to stay. he was kind of mad about it, but i told him i was still recovering and he's just going to need to deal with my mom being here longer. i have 12-weeks of maternity leave, but my husband only had 6 so he recently went back to work. when he comes home he will take over the baby duties and he's great at giving her baths and getting her to sleep. it warms my heart to see how good he is with our baby girl. the problem though is that he shows me almost zero affection or attention. when i was pregnant he would give me daily foot rubs and tell me how beautiful i am and how much he loves me. now, i can barely get a good morning or good night out of him. his excuse is that he's tired from work and pretty much being on solo baby duty after he gets home. he told he he has a finite amount of energy and can't pamper me the same way anymore. the other night after the baby went to sleep i asked him to give me foot rub like he used to. he said he was exhausted and just wanted an hour to himself before he goes to sleep. he said i should ask my mom for a foot rub but i said thats not the same. he told me he never gets a break between work and the baby so i'm just going to have to deal with being lower on his priority list right now. i feel like that was a low blow to use my own words against me like that. but it got me wondering if i was an asshole for making that decision unilaterally before. aita here?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my husband and i just had our first child 8 weeks ago, a beautiful baby girl. after she was born i asked my mom to come stay with us for a couple weeks to help with everything because i had a quiet traumatic birth and we are new parents. after those couple of weeks i realized how nice it was to have an extra person to help with daily household stuff or to give one of us a break if the baby wakes up during the night, so i asked my mom to stay longer. i did this without talking to my husband about it and pretty much just told him about it after i already asked my mom to stay. he was kind of mad about it, but i told him i was still recovering and he's just going to need to deal with my mom being here longer. i have 12-weeks of maternity leave, but my husband only had 6 so he recently went back to work. when he comes home he will take over the baby duties and he's great at giving her baths and getting her to sleep. it warms my heart to see how good he is with our baby girl. the problem though is that he shows me almost zero affection or attention. when i was pregnant he would give me daily foot rubs and tell me how beautiful i am and how much he loves me. now, i can barely get a good morning or good night out of him. his excuse is that he's tired from work and pretty much being on solo baby duty after he gets home. he told he he has a finite amount of energy and can't pamper me the same way anymore. the other night after the baby went to sleep i asked him to give me foot rub like he used to. he said he was exhausted and just wanted an hour to himself before he goes to sleep. he said i should ask my mom for a foot rub but i said thats not the same. he told me he never gets a break between work and the baby so i'm just going to have to deal with being lower on his priority list right now. i feel like that was a low blow to use my own words against me like that. but it got me wondering if i was an asshole for making that decision unilaterally before. aita here? [/INST] yta for asking your mother to move in without consulting your husband first. it is his house too. also your mother helps you with the baby, and you don’t work? but your husband works then comes home to take care of the baby with no help at all? then you ask him to rub your feet? as if he hasn’t had a hard day with working and taking care of the baby with no help. edit to add: before anyone says anything about the fact that she just gave birth. i gave birth in may and did perfectly fine with no help. yes it is very tiring being a mother, but that is what comes with the territory. </s>
AITA for not letting my girlfriend order a second helping of chips and salsa at a Mexican restaurant?
my (28m) girlfriend's (25f) birthday recently passed. i offered to take her out to her favorite restaurant--a local mexican place--to celebrate. my treat. i own a townhome and am a member of an hoa. i was just hit with a violation concerning my back deck. i recieved a letter informing me that i have 60 days to replace 3 boards on my deck and the entire staircase; either that or i have to produce a signed contract with a contractor stating that the work is going to be done. if i don't i'm going to be subject to penalties. i haven't had a great year financially and so this is stressing me out. however, i wanted to treat my girlfriend. so, we arrived at the restaurant. i ordered a pacifico, she ordered a margarita, and then we both placed our orders for our entrees when our drinks arrived along with an order of chips and salsa. it was pretty busy there and our entrees were taking a while. we were both hungry and polished off the chips and salsa pretty quickly. she said "let's get some more chips and salsa." she was about to flag down our server when i said "no, let's just wait for our entrees. i don't want to pay for extra chips and salsa." i had noticed when i read the menu that extra chips and salsa would cost $5 and i didn't want to pay it. she responded "seriously? you're treating me to a dinner at my favorite restaurant for my birthday but you're going to cheap out on chips and salsa? if i want a second margarita are you going to tell me 'no'?" i told her that i had factored in extra money for drinks but that i wasn't paying extra so that we could gorge ourselves on chips and salsa because it wasn't worth it. aita?
7,051
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/wbtxk9/aita_for_not_letting_my_girlfriend_order_a_second/
2022-07-30 09:56:40
yta i get having many financial problems, but those 5$ arent gonna solve your financial problems. 5$ extra for treating your girl goes a long way tho. its only her birthday once a year
then you shouldn't have gone out to dinner if you can't afford it. there are other ways to celebrate a birthday (lunch, just drinks, homecooked meal, picknick). had she ordered something very expensive then okay but it's just chips and salsa. yta eta i geeeeeeet it. it's picnic. i'm dutch. picknick is dutch. i use autocorrect and sometimes english words get corrected in similair dutch words. y'all know this sub isn't just for americans right?
yta - it's her birthday and you offered to take her out to dinner. did you discuss a budget? did you say you'd kindly ask a server how long until your entrees? did you really think $5 was worth putting a sour note on the night? part of being in a loving and supportive relationship is give and take. those "extra drinks" you factored in could have been adjusted so you'd drink something cheaper and she could have the $5 chips and salsa.
yta. your back deck may be a concern but it doesn’t sound completely pressing if you have your paperwork in order. but i digress. if $5 was a make it or break it amount, why offer to treat dinner? in my mind, you’re feeling stressed and instead of dealing with it, you’re using your girlfriend to take out your aggression. you put an arbitrary price - $5 - on her enjoyment and turned the focus on yourself in the process. i hope this is a one off event but if you spoil someone’s birthday outing with intent and actions how do you normally act?
yta. i would cry. it's her birthday and it's only once a year. that's cruel. 😭 you could've cooked for her at home if you're that pinched on budget. $5 chips and salsa... poor gf.
hahahaha. this is too funny! you “my treat. i own a townhome and am a member of an hoa. i ordered a pacifica. i don’t want to pay for extra chips and salsa.” yta, even if it just was a date. it’s your girlfriend and her birthday. this is so embarrassing!
yta. it's 5 fucking dollars
you can’t say you’re treating her to a birthday dinner if you’re cheaping out on it. it’s her birthday, she should be able to gorge herself on some chips and salsa if she wanted to. the deck story is a lame attempt on your part to gather some sympathy to you treating her like shit on her birthday. the $5 you saved from not ordering chips and salsa isn’t going to get you any closer to fixing your deck. yta big time man. it’s her birthday, treat her and let her do and order what she wants.
let me get this straight……. you factored in for additional drinks……… margaritas where i live are $8 for a house sm and up to $15 for a house lg…… but said no to a $5 chips and salsa? really? does she know your financial struggle? did you give her the low down on what you could afford for the night at dinner?
yta. what the f does your deck have to do with $5 chips and salsa? you were fully trying to farm sympathy before going into the real story about you being cheap af on your girlfriends birthday.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my (28m) girlfriend's (25f) birthday recently passed. i offered to take her out to her favorite restaurant--a local mexican place--to celebrate. my treat. i own a townhome and am a member of an hoa. i was just hit with a violation concerning my back deck. i recieved a letter informing me that i have 60 days to replace 3 boards on my deck and the entire staircase; either that or i have to produce a signed contract with a contractor stating that the work is going to be done. if i don't i'm going to be subject to penalties. i haven't had a great year financially and so this is stressing me out. however, i wanted to treat my girlfriend. so, we arrived at the restaurant. i ordered a pacifico, she ordered a margarita, and then we both placed our orders for our entrees when our drinks arrived along with an order of chips and salsa. it was pretty busy there and our entrees were taking a while. we were both hungry and polished off the chips and salsa pretty quickly. she said "let's get some more chips and salsa." she was about to flag down our server when i said "no, let's just wait for our entrees. i don't want to pay for extra chips and salsa." i had noticed when i read the menu that extra chips and salsa would cost $5 and i didn't want to pay it. she responded "seriously? you're treating me to a dinner at my favorite restaurant for my birthday but you're going to cheap out on chips and salsa? if i want a second margarita are you going to tell me 'no'?" i told her that i had factored in extra money for drinks but that i wasn't paying extra so that we could gorge ourselves on chips and salsa because it wasn't worth it. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my (28m) girlfriend's (25f) birthday recently passed. i offered to take her out to her favorite restaurant--a local mexican place--to celebrate. my treat. i own a townhome and am a member of an hoa. i was just hit with a violation concerning my back deck. i recieved a letter informing me that i have 60 days to replace 3 boards on my deck and the entire staircase; either that or i have to produce a signed contract with a contractor stating that the work is going to be done. if i don't i'm going to be subject to penalties. i haven't had a great year financially and so this is stressing me out. however, i wanted to treat my girlfriend. so, we arrived at the restaurant. i ordered a pacifico, she ordered a margarita, and then we both placed our orders for our entrees when our drinks arrived along with an order of chips and salsa. it was pretty busy there and our entrees were taking a while. we were both hungry and polished off the chips and salsa pretty quickly. she said "let's get some more chips and salsa." she was about to flag down our server when i said "no, let's just wait for our entrees. i don't want to pay for extra chips and salsa." i had noticed when i read the menu that extra chips and salsa would cost $5 and i didn't want to pay it. she responded "seriously? you're treating me to a dinner at my favorite restaurant for my birthday but you're going to cheap out on chips and salsa? if i want a second margarita are you going to tell me 'no'?" i told her that i had factored in extra money for drinks but that i wasn't paying extra so that we could gorge ourselves on chips and salsa because it wasn't worth it. aita? [/INST] yta i get having many financial problems, but those 5$ arent gonna solve your financial problems. 5$ extra for treating your girl goes a long way tho. its only her birthday once a year </s>
AITA for not letting my wife buy things with words on them?
obviously some context and examples are needed, but i generally dislike things that have a message written on them and have told my wife i don't want things like that in the house. for example: 'live laugh love' or 'keep calm and...' are super tacky, in my opinion, and have no place in a house. i think that if you're going to hang something on the wall it needs to be something meaningful, but abstract enough that other people can find their own meaning in it. also, i think they're incredibly lazy decorating, you're basically saying 'i am not worth finding something i *actually* like, i'm fine with a $20 sticker! maybe the only thing i need to turn my life around is a 4'x8' sticker that tells me "you are so loved"". i've also extended the rule to the clothes my toddler wears (everyone knows that i'm not putting on a shirt with words on it). and my wife will occasionally show me clothes with generic phrases like 'future heart breaker' or 'daddy's source of constant frustration' written in generic typeface. i'll veto, and she will complain a little, but in general understands my point of view. basically, i don't want my kid to be used as a billboard for either companies or shitty hot takes. on the plus side, i have a ton of photos where i won't have to explain some stupid meme to my kid when she grows up ("you see, there was this thing called 'the chive' back before you were born..."). when the kid is older they can decide what they want to wear, but until they're a little older i don't want my kid in it. am i the asshole for not being flexible on this? it's gotten to the point where we go to people's homes and she'll point out every example of words she sees in people's decor and poke fun at me. but yes, i am inflexible on this rule, if she wants to build an 'eat pray love' nest (the basic girl version of a neckbeard nest), then she can put that stuff in her office.\]
3,351
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/cty30t/aita_for_not_letting_my_wife_buy_things_with/
2019-08-22 14:19:04
yta, please unclench. good grief, you seem like a joyless martinet.
yta. you consistently refer to the child as your child, not both of your child. your house, not your shared home. you seem to crave this kind of control and it’s not healthy for the kid or your wife.
yta for setting “rules” for your adult wife. and this is coming from someone who *hates* those “live laugh love” things. if you’re that concerned with home decor, then before you nix her ideas, come up with an alternative. also with kids clothes, literally no one cares except your wife, so let her do whatever she wants. she only has like 2 more years before the kid starts picking out his own clothes, so why take that from her?
yta &gt;you're basically saying 'i am not worth finding something i actually like, i'm fine with a $20 sticker! what if you **actually** like the $20 sticker? you sound like a total snob, it's her home/kid too but you seem to be laying down the law, having everything your way.
yta not for the preference over "word" things (i think they're weird, too), but because you unilaterally set rules over what can and can't happen in the house. this is the way a dictator, not a partner acts. it's not about you setting rules and not being flexible, it's that you set rules in the first place and that you appear to have veto power over everything she does and your daughter wears. no idea why your wife follows these rules, but a better approach would be talking to figure out together how things will operate rather than you laying down the law.
info: so.... when your kid is older they can have things with words on them, but your wife, the already grown person cannot? or in the context of her you mean home decor specifically... like you're not telling her she cant wear a shirt with words on it as well, correct?
yta for being a frustratingly normative, patronizing, and elitistic snob. there is nothing worse than those people that think that they can decide what "true" art is and what "good taste" is. you can be happy that your seems to nonetheless love you, because this appears to be a, by times, though challenge.
nta but i'm prepared for downvotes i have the same opinion and my wife and i have compromised and really limited the amount of things in the house that has corny writing on it. you have to compromise a bit on the house but i think its fine to have a hard line with the kid
nah you have to live in the house and look at the decorations every day too. if something is truly that offensive to your eyes, you shouldn't have to put up with it. this is no different than when women won't let their husbands buy reclining chairs with cup holders because they think they're ugly and don't want it in their house. if that policy extended to her office as well you'd be an asshole. but shared space is just that, shared space.
yta, your wife has just as much right to decorate her home and buy clothes for her baby as you do. is this really a real post?
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
NTA
NAH
YTA
0.146375
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: obviously some context and examples are needed, but i generally dislike things that have a message written on them and have told my wife i don't want things like that in the house. for example: 'live laugh love' or 'keep calm and...' are super tacky, in my opinion, and have no place in a house. i think that if you're going to hang something on the wall it needs to be something meaningful, but abstract enough that other people can find their own meaning in it. also, i think they're incredibly lazy decorating, you're basically saying 'i am not worth finding something i *actually* like, i'm fine with a $20 sticker! maybe the only thing i need to turn my life around is a 4'x8' sticker that tells me "you are so loved"". i've also extended the rule to the clothes my toddler wears (everyone knows that i'm not putting on a shirt with words on it). and my wife will occasionally show me clothes with generic phrases like 'future heart breaker' or 'daddy's source of constant frustration' written in generic typeface. i'll veto, and she will complain a little, but in general understands my point of view. basically, i don't want my kid to be used as a billboard for either companies or shitty hot takes. on the plus side, i have a ton of photos where i won't have to explain some stupid meme to my kid when she grows up ("you see, there was this thing called 'the chive' back before you were born..."). when the kid is older they can decide what they want to wear, but until they're a little older i don't want my kid in it. am i the asshole for not being flexible on this? it's gotten to the point where we go to people's homes and she'll point out every example of words she sees in people's decor and poke fun at me. but yes, i am inflexible on this rule, if she wants to build an 'eat pray love' nest (the basic girl version of a neckbeard nest), then she can put that stuff in her office.\]
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> obviously some context and examples are needed, but i generally dislike things that have a message written on them and have told my wife i don't want things like that in the house. for example: 'live laugh love' or 'keep calm and...' are super tacky, in my opinion, and have no place in a house. i think that if you're going to hang something on the wall it needs to be something meaningful, but abstract enough that other people can find their own meaning in it. also, i think they're incredibly lazy decorating, you're basically saying 'i am not worth finding something i *actually* like, i'm fine with a $20 sticker! maybe the only thing i need to turn my life around is a 4'x8' sticker that tells me "you are so loved"". i've also extended the rule to the clothes my toddler wears (everyone knows that i'm not putting on a shirt with words on it). and my wife will occasionally show me clothes with generic phrases like 'future heart breaker' or 'daddy's source of constant frustration' written in generic typeface. i'll veto, and she will complain a little, but in general understands my point of view. basically, i don't want my kid to be used as a billboard for either companies or shitty hot takes. on the plus side, i have a ton of photos where i won't have to explain some stupid meme to my kid when she grows up ("you see, there was this thing called 'the chive' back before you were born..."). when the kid is older they can decide what they want to wear, but until they're a little older i don't want my kid in it. am i the asshole for not being flexible on this? it's gotten to the point where we go to people's homes and she'll point out every example of words she sees in people's decor and poke fun at me. but yes, i am inflexible on this rule, if she wants to build an 'eat pray love' nest (the basic girl version of a neckbeard nest), then she can put that stuff in her office.\] [/INST] yta, please unclench. good grief, you seem like a joyless martinet. </s>
AITA for throwing them out of a house that we own. Son and future In-Laws decide to exclude his family from wedding. They thought son owned the house not us.
my wife and i bought a four bedroom house in pa that my son lives in. our son went to college in pa and wanted to stay in the area. so we bought the house as a second home, we live in nj and commute into manhattan for work. we figured that he would have a place to live and we could visit every so often and spend some quality time together. we pay the taxes and services / maintenance on the house, our son pays for his groceries and the house utilities. all was going well for a few years, our son meets a girl and they get serious. we met her and she seems nice enough. the announce their engagement and she moves into the house with our son. now for the problem: the wedding !!! we hold a little get to know you bbq at the pa house, my son and daughter are there, as are our sons fiancé and her parents, and sisters. we all seem to be getting along well, my wife, daughter and the fiancé go into the house along with her mother an sisters and my son. a few minutes later my wife and daughter come out and are really upset. the come over and tell me we're leaving and driving back to nj. i try to find out what happened. once we get back to nj and they calmed down they tell me that our son and his fiancé along with her family don't want us at the wedding. according to what i was told "we're not their kind of people". i was livid, i called my son and asked him wth this was about. he tells me that her family feel that we are not good enough and will embarrass them at a family wedding and that we are all uninvited from the wedding. i let a week go by to calm myself down and drive back to the pa house, the new future in-laws are in the house along with the fiancé. it appears that they all moved into the house they ask me why i'm there, i tell them that since we aren't invited to the wedding, i was coming over to talk to my son. they tell me to leave their house. i lost it, and told them that they had 30 days to get out. tell my son i'm selling the house and he could find somewhere else to live with all of you. i go to a realtor in town and list the house for sale. they call my son at work and tell him what i said. apparently they thought that he owned the house. he calls me and asks why i'm selling his house, i tell him i paid for it along with the taxes on it and it is mine. he was living there rent free, but since he doesn't want us in his new life, he has to get out. i tell him the same as i told his future in-laws they have 30 days to get out then i'll get a lawyer and get them evicted. am i the ah for taking a hard stance on this. he is my son but thein-laws seem to take over and we no longer count.
33,295
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/vnl1hw/aita_for_throwing_them_out_of_a_house_that_we_own/
2022-06-29 17:19:30
nta. and i want an update on this because it sounds nuts. what kind of people do they think you are? how was your son ok with excluding his whole family? do you think your son’s been brainwashed by his fiancée? how did he think the house was “his” when he didn’t pay the taxes on it? so many questions.
nta….you don’t need a lawyer in 30 days, you need one now. i am not familiar with pa tenant laws etc but you need to follow everything by the book so that can’t contest anything. i would also go back and video tape, with time stamp, the entire property, inside and out, so they can be held accountable for any damage done
nta. they all moved into your house?? that's so bizarre. tell them they're not your kind of people, aka, squatters. 🤣
nta. i actually find it hilarious he is soo entitled to the house he didn't even expect you to take it back after his actions. i believe this is exactly the reality check he needed.
nta. but your son must not be very smart. what did he think would happen if he let his in laws try to kick you out of a house you own? why would you let people whose openly say you aren't good enough live rent free in your house?
nta. excluding his family from the wedding for ridiculous reasons is a pretty big fu to you and your family. he is experiencing the natural consequences of his actions.
nta- rock on man. he was wrong and there is no amount of excuses or words to convince otherwise. it overall seems toxic and there is no reason why he should allow anyone to exclude his family. i could understand if maybe you haven't been supportive or there were issues but based off what i read it baffles me why he would even do this. don't let in keep going forward if this is the life he wants they can find another house together not use you for an easy life.
nta. what is wrong with your son?????
not our kind of people? what, not mooches?
nta are you in the market for a new son?
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my wife and i bought a four bedroom house in pa that my son lives in. our son went to college in pa and wanted to stay in the area. so we bought the house as a second home, we live in nj and commute into manhattan for work. we figured that he would have a place to live and we could visit every so often and spend some quality time together. we pay the taxes and services / maintenance on the house, our son pays for his groceries and the house utilities. all was going well for a few years, our son meets a girl and they get serious. we met her and she seems nice enough. the announce their engagement and she moves into the house with our son. now for the problem: the wedding !!! we hold a little get to know you bbq at the pa house, my son and daughter are there, as are our sons fiancé and her parents, and sisters. we all seem to be getting along well, my wife, daughter and the fiancé go into the house along with her mother an sisters and my son. a few minutes later my wife and daughter come out and are really upset. the come over and tell me we're leaving and driving back to nj. i try to find out what happened. once we get back to nj and they calmed down they tell me that our son and his fiancé along with her family don't want us at the wedding. according to what i was told "we're not their kind of people". i was livid, i called my son and asked him wth this was about. he tells me that her family feel that we are not good enough and will embarrass them at a family wedding and that we are all uninvited from the wedding. i let a week go by to calm myself down and drive back to the pa house, the new future in-laws are in the house along with the fiancé. it appears that they all moved into the house they ask me why i'm there, i tell them that since we aren't invited to the wedding, i was coming over to talk to my son. they tell me to leave their house. i lost it, and told them that they had 30 days to get out. tell my son i'm selling the house and he could find somewhere else to live with all of you. i go to a realtor in town and list the house for sale. they call my son at work and tell him what i said. apparently they thought that he owned the house. he calls me and asks why i'm selling his house, i tell him i paid for it along with the taxes on it and it is mine. he was living there rent free, but since he doesn't want us in his new life, he has to get out. i tell him the same as i told his future in-laws they have 30 days to get out then i'll get a lawyer and get them evicted. am i the ah for taking a hard stance on this. he is my son but thein-laws seem to take over and we no longer count.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my wife and i bought a four bedroom house in pa that my son lives in. our son went to college in pa and wanted to stay in the area. so we bought the house as a second home, we live in nj and commute into manhattan for work. we figured that he would have a place to live and we could visit every so often and spend some quality time together. we pay the taxes and services / maintenance on the house, our son pays for his groceries and the house utilities. all was going well for a few years, our son meets a girl and they get serious. we met her and she seems nice enough. the announce their engagement and she moves into the house with our son. now for the problem: the wedding !!! we hold a little get to know you bbq at the pa house, my son and daughter are there, as are our sons fiancé and her parents, and sisters. we all seem to be getting along well, my wife, daughter and the fiancé go into the house along with her mother an sisters and my son. a few minutes later my wife and daughter come out and are really upset. the come over and tell me we're leaving and driving back to nj. i try to find out what happened. once we get back to nj and they calmed down they tell me that our son and his fiancé along with her family don't want us at the wedding. according to what i was told "we're not their kind of people". i was livid, i called my son and asked him wth this was about. he tells me that her family feel that we are not good enough and will embarrass them at a family wedding and that we are all uninvited from the wedding. i let a week go by to calm myself down and drive back to the pa house, the new future in-laws are in the house along with the fiancé. it appears that they all moved into the house they ask me why i'm there, i tell them that since we aren't invited to the wedding, i was coming over to talk to my son. they tell me to leave their house. i lost it, and told them that they had 30 days to get out. tell my son i'm selling the house and he could find somewhere else to live with all of you. i go to a realtor in town and list the house for sale. they call my son at work and tell him what i said. apparently they thought that he owned the house. he calls me and asks why i'm selling his house, i tell him i paid for it along with the taxes on it and it is mine. he was living there rent free, but since he doesn't want us in his new life, he has to get out. i tell him the same as i told his future in-laws they have 30 days to get out then i'll get a lawyer and get them evicted. am i the ah for taking a hard stance on this. he is my son but thein-laws seem to take over and we no longer count. [/INST] nta. and i want an update on this because it sounds nuts. what kind of people do they think you are? how was your son ok with excluding his whole family? do you think your son’s been brainwashed by his fiancée? how did he think the house was “his” when he didn’t pay the taxes on it? so many questions. </s>
AITA for calling my fiancé a jerk?
my (28f) fiancé (38m) proposed to me last week, we've been dating for 2 years, he has a 15 yo daughter from a previous marriage, her mom passed again 5 years ago and i have a 6 yo son. when my fiancé and i started to date, i noticed that his daughter had the master bedroom, i found it weird because i've never seen a child taking over the master bedroom before , but he brushed it off saying that the house was ''hers'' so it was normal she slept there, *with no further explanation,* i thought he meant as in inheritance from when he passed away which still was weird because he was alive, but either way, i didn't say anything because we were only beginning and i knew it wasn't my business. now that we're engaged, i said that i wanted to move here to live together for a while before we decided the wedding date, he said that we could do it or we could get our own house now because we will have to do it regardless , i asked what was wrong with this one and he said nothing, but that it was her daughter's, to be honest now i did get a little mad, i said it wasn't fair he called it his daughter's when we were about to get marry and he was supposed to adopt my son, so now the house should be theirs and not only hers, i also said i wanted his daughter out of the master because it was ours. he got a little nervous and said that the house really belonged to his late wife and when she passed, the house became his daughters. he has enough money for maybe 60% of a house, but that we will have to pay off the rest together, i was shocked and said that he could ask her daughter for the house because she's only 15 and he is her dad but he said no, that it was her daughters. i got angry and called him a jerk because he should've told me the truth before and he said that it's not like we will be homeless or anything, we still have 3 years and maybe 4 after that because his daughter will leave for college, he said he has always known he has to move out and that's why he saved. i asked what else belonged to his daughter that i didn't know of and he said that his car ( a 2020 kia) the car that i always use will be hers when she leaves for college. i called him a jerk again and left with my son to my parents house. when i told my family my brother laughed because i talked and acted like a gold digger and called me an ah i felt betrayed and lied , am i really ta? i think i'm justified
14,446
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/uhy0l2/aita_for_calling_my_fiancé_a_jerk/
2022-05-04 03:57:21
yta. he told you the house belonged to his daughter. that you chose to not ask what he meant and assumed he really owned it is your own fault. you deceived yourself. it is her inheritance from her dead mother, and you want a share of it. the girl has already lost her mother, but that’s not enough - now you’re demanding a share of her inheritance go to people the mother never even met. how can you think that’s reasonable?
yta, it sounds like his wife did the right thing to insure that her daughter always has a home - considering you’re now trying to push her out of it.
yta, your brother is right, you sound like a gold digger.
yes, you are yta. why do you feel entitled to your fiancé's late wife's house? it now belongs to their daughter. grow up and start sharing financial responsibility with your fiance.
yta you are not entitled to his house or his car and the fact that they are actually his daughter’s means you are even less entitled to them. your brother has the correct assessment. don’t marry this man, he and his daughter deserve better than you.
~~info~~ yta: i don't understand how it's lies and betrayal? he did tell you, you just thought it meant something different. you didn't ask for clarification, he didn't offer it, probably a mistake on both sides as you should have had that talk before getting engaged. it's a weird situation for sure but you can't just take his daughter's house from her so yta for that. sure you aren't getting what you thought you were getting in terms of living space after marriage but it's that the only reason you were with him? if so then, yeah you do sound like a gold digger. if not then talk to him. there's a lot of talking it seems like you are missing before you get married so may as well start now.
i'm gonna say yta. what exactly didn't he tell you? he said it was her house which you interpreted as inheritance which was correct. you were just wrong in who she'd inherited the house from. granted he could've been more specific but he was not wrong in saying its her house when it is. i do think it's kinda shitty of you to ask him to go to her and ask if he can have the house to move in his new wife to be and her son. also to give up the master bedroom in a house she'd now be the master of. you're mad because a car you use all the time isn't his? why is that a problem for you? don't you have a vehicle? i don't think he's being a jerk i think he's respecting his late wife's will and her wishes which have nothing to do with you. it is weird you got mad about being told that stuff that's not yours not being yours just cause you were going to be married. it does come across as a bit gold diggery to me.
no way you took his car after your tantrum?? 😭
yta. the house doesn’t belong to your future husband. stop acting like an entitled ah and trying to literally steal from a child.
have you never talked about your financial future/house plans before getting engaged?? it seems very strange to me that this has never come up in more detail than the intial thing about the daughter's bedroom.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
null
YTA
null
0.005167
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my (28f) fiancé (38m) proposed to me last week, we've been dating for 2 years, he has a 15 yo daughter from a previous marriage, her mom passed again 5 years ago and i have a 6 yo son. when my fiancé and i started to date, i noticed that his daughter had the master bedroom, i found it weird because i've never seen a child taking over the master bedroom before , but he brushed it off saying that the house was ''hers'' so it was normal she slept there, *with no further explanation,* i thought he meant as in inheritance from when he passed away which still was weird because he was alive, but either way, i didn't say anything because we were only beginning and i knew it wasn't my business. now that we're engaged, i said that i wanted to move here to live together for a while before we decided the wedding date, he said that we could do it or we could get our own house now because we will have to do it regardless , i asked what was wrong with this one and he said nothing, but that it was her daughter's, to be honest now i did get a little mad, i said it wasn't fair he called it his daughter's when we were about to get marry and he was supposed to adopt my son, so now the house should be theirs and not only hers, i also said i wanted his daughter out of the master because it was ours. he got a little nervous and said that the house really belonged to his late wife and when she passed, the house became his daughters. he has enough money for maybe 60% of a house, but that we will have to pay off the rest together, i was shocked and said that he could ask her daughter for the house because she's only 15 and he is her dad but he said no, that it was her daughters. i got angry and called him a jerk because he should've told me the truth before and he said that it's not like we will be homeless or anything, we still have 3 years and maybe 4 after that because his daughter will leave for college, he said he has always known he has to move out and that's why he saved. i asked what else belonged to his daughter that i didn't know of and he said that his car ( a 2020 kia) the car that i always use will be hers when she leaves for college. i called him a jerk again and left with my son to my parents house. when i told my family my brother laughed because i talked and acted like a gold digger and called me an ah i felt betrayed and lied , am i really ta? i think i'm justified
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my (28f) fiancé (38m) proposed to me last week, we've been dating for 2 years, he has a 15 yo daughter from a previous marriage, her mom passed again 5 years ago and i have a 6 yo son. when my fiancé and i started to date, i noticed that his daughter had the master bedroom, i found it weird because i've never seen a child taking over the master bedroom before , but he brushed it off saying that the house was ''hers'' so it was normal she slept there, *with no further explanation,* i thought he meant as in inheritance from when he passed away which still was weird because he was alive, but either way, i didn't say anything because we were only beginning and i knew it wasn't my business. now that we're engaged, i said that i wanted to move here to live together for a while before we decided the wedding date, he said that we could do it or we could get our own house now because we will have to do it regardless , i asked what was wrong with this one and he said nothing, but that it was her daughter's, to be honest now i did get a little mad, i said it wasn't fair he called it his daughter's when we were about to get marry and he was supposed to adopt my son, so now the house should be theirs and not only hers, i also said i wanted his daughter out of the master because it was ours. he got a little nervous and said that the house really belonged to his late wife and when she passed, the house became his daughters. he has enough money for maybe 60% of a house, but that we will have to pay off the rest together, i was shocked and said that he could ask her daughter for the house because she's only 15 and he is her dad but he said no, that it was her daughters. i got angry and called him a jerk because he should've told me the truth before and he said that it's not like we will be homeless or anything, we still have 3 years and maybe 4 after that because his daughter will leave for college, he said he has always known he has to move out and that's why he saved. i asked what else belonged to his daughter that i didn't know of and he said that his car ( a 2020 kia) the car that i always use will be hers when she leaves for college. i called him a jerk again and left with my son to my parents house. when i told my family my brother laughed because i talked and acted like a gold digger and called me an ah i felt betrayed and lied , am i really ta? i think i'm justified [/INST] yta. he told you the house belonged to his daughter. that you chose to not ask what he meant and assumed he really owned it is your own fault. you deceived yourself. it is her inheritance from her dead mother, and you want a share of it. the girl has already lost her mother, but that’s not enough - now you’re demanding a share of her inheritance go to people the mother never even met. how can you think that’s reasonable? </s>
AITA for “looking poor”?
soo my family used to be really poor but my parents have worked hard and now they’re very wealthy. that’s basically the gist of it. so for college, i moved into a off campus house with 5 other guys and i’m sharing a room with this one dude. i don’t have a job rn so my parents pay my rent and also give me money whenever i need it for like food and general spending. the thing is i really don’t like depending on my parents for money so i’m trying to self suffice. i have money from a previous job that i use. because of this, i live pretty frugally which made my roommates think i was kinda poor. they would offer to pay for me and whenever i would say i’ll pay them back, they always said don’t worry about it. i thought it was kinda weird but i didn’t really think much of it. so last night, i was hanging out with my housemates and i mentioned my family was dumb rich and they were all shocked and they said they thought i was poor which is why they’ve been giving me stuff. they got really pissed off and i don’t really know what to do. they have a point but assuming i was poor was kinda dumb on their part. so anyway, aita?
3,356
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/dgjgap/aita_for_looking_poor/
2019-10-11 18:48:20
yta for accepting their money and not paying them back. why are you okay with taking money from your housemates, but not from your own parents?
yta. you claim you want to be self sufficient and claim not to want to accept money from your wealthy parents who can afford to help you, yet it seems you have no problem accepting money from your friends who likely are broke and don't have wealthy parents like you do. i know it sounds harsh but just use it as a learning opportunity. if i were you, i'd offer to buy the guys all beer and dinner and then apologize for the miscommunication. explain that while your parents are wealthy you are trying to live frugally and be responsible and you didn't mean to give the impression that you were struggling financially. remember these are your buddies who have been trying to help you and maybe right now they're feeling taken advantage of and wondering if you are a true friend or a leech. so be quick to right this wrong because i think your friends are worth keeping. (edited for grammar/clarity)
yta not for how you look but for borrowing money from friends when your parents are rich. if you’re taking loans from friends you’re failing at self-sufficiency. since you have an alternative choice — your parents — that’s not cool.
you're the idiot. you've been so used to getting things just handed to you, you haven't learned to just say no. that was an option you had. instead of offering to pay them back, just decline whatever it is in the first place. or make it a point to pay them back. it wasn't dumb on their part to assume you didn't have money when you would demonstrate to them that you didn't have money. if anything, that attitude make you a bit of an asshole. they don't live your life. they can't read your mind. they can only act on the information you give them. what to do is to simply apologize. pay them back for the stuff you'd say you'd pay them back for. they feel taken advantage of.
yta because you kept taking advantage of their generosity.
yta. agree with the person who said it's not because you look poor but because you took advantage of their generosity when you knew you had other options, which are your parents. it's far more humiliating (to me) that you'd take money from friends on multiple occasions but have some shame in taking from your parents.
info. have you bought them food or other stuff? if not, then yta, not for looking poor, but for taking their offers and not really considering doing anything in return. if you knew they thought you were poor, then why would it be "weird" for them to offer you stuff? that's what kind friends do. so from now on, just return the favor from time to time and if you don't want to depend on your parents' money, don't depend on your friends' money either.
yta for accepting the free stuff. i've been in the same situation, due to the fact that i'm just super low-effort about buying new clothes etc, but i offset that by *not accepting charity*. there's no excuse for having money and mooching anyway.
i n f o did you actually pay them back? because wow, ywbta if you didn't.
" i have money from a previous job that i use." then why didn't you use it?? "...i live pretty frugally which made my roommates think i was kinda poor." no, acting like you didn't have any money even when you claimed you had money from a previous job is what made them think you were kinda poor. "they would offer to pay for me and whenever i would say i’ll pay them back, they always said don’t worry about it. i thought it was kinda weird but i didn’t really think much of it." it never once dawned on you that they were saying that because they thought you were in need of help? it never dawned on you that what you were doing was wrong because you had the means to pay them back? really?? either you enjoy using people or you need to seriously work on your awareness and empathy of others around you. you just shrugged it off and went blissfully on your way. you never once said to yourself this is not right what i'm doing? really?? pay them back and apologize. yta
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: soo my family used to be really poor but my parents have worked hard and now they’re very wealthy. that’s basically the gist of it. so for college, i moved into a off campus house with 5 other guys and i’m sharing a room with this one dude. i don’t have a job rn so my parents pay my rent and also give me money whenever i need it for like food and general spending. the thing is i really don’t like depending on my parents for money so i’m trying to self suffice. i have money from a previous job that i use. because of this, i live pretty frugally which made my roommates think i was kinda poor. they would offer to pay for me and whenever i would say i’ll pay them back, they always said don’t worry about it. i thought it was kinda weird but i didn’t really think much of it. so last night, i was hanging out with my housemates and i mentioned my family was dumb rich and they were all shocked and they said they thought i was poor which is why they’ve been giving me stuff. they got really pissed off and i don’t really know what to do. they have a point but assuming i was poor was kinda dumb on their part. so anyway, aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> soo my family used to be really poor but my parents have worked hard and now they’re very wealthy. that’s basically the gist of it. so for college, i moved into a off campus house with 5 other guys and i’m sharing a room with this one dude. i don’t have a job rn so my parents pay my rent and also give me money whenever i need it for like food and general spending. the thing is i really don’t like depending on my parents for money so i’m trying to self suffice. i have money from a previous job that i use. because of this, i live pretty frugally which made my roommates think i was kinda poor. they would offer to pay for me and whenever i would say i’ll pay them back, they always said don’t worry about it. i thought it was kinda weird but i didn’t really think much of it. so last night, i was hanging out with my housemates and i mentioned my family was dumb rich and they were all shocked and they said they thought i was poor which is why they’ve been giving me stuff. they got really pissed off and i don’t really know what to do. they have a point but assuming i was poor was kinda dumb on their part. so anyway, aita? [/INST] yta for accepting their money and not paying them back. why are you okay with taking money from your housemates, but not from your own parents? </s>
AITA for refusing to accept my niece's mother's day card?
i (24f) am childfree. my entire family is fully aware of that. my parents always wanted grandchildren, and my sister has already popped out two, so fortunately they never gave me much grief for my choice. in fact, they've been as supportive as they could be. this incident happened months ago, on mother's day, but the topic has recently come up again. on mother's day lunch, my 5 yo niece gave cards to each female member of the family- my sister (her mom), my sil ( my brother's wife), her grandma and me. my card had "to the best ani (that's what she calls me) ever. happy mother's day" obviously she didn't make the card herself, and my sister had a hand in this. i really think this was a jab to the fact that i don't have children, so i politely refused the card, saying that i'm not your mom and you can give me a card like that on my birthday. she looked a bit upset like she was about to turn on the waterworks, but her mom said something to her and she shut up. i felt a bit bad because it wasn't my niece's fault that her mom used a mother's day card as a weapon against my choices and was about to say something when the food arrived and she quickly cheered up. my birthday was yesterday, and my niece gave me a card saying "happy birthday ani". i joked to my sister that this time it looks like a real heartfelt card inatead of a backhanded jibe at me. my sister pretended to look confused and then i reminded about the mother's day card incident. she got mad and said "oh yeah, the card you made my daughter cry over. i'm sorry your niece loves you so much that she spent her time making a mother's day card for you." i told her that she wasn't fooling anyone and there was no need to give me a mother's day card. it was also sexist to give every woman a mother's day card, even women who weren't moms. she told me that her daughter had done the same for all the male relatives on father's day too, but i think that that's beside the point as all the men in my family are fathers already. she also said that "mother's day" also applies to loving aunts. aita?
5,049
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/wibgum/aita_for_refusing_to_accept_my_nieces_mothers_day/
2022-08-07 09:13:31
yta such projection and insecurity in your own decision. some people just take any and every opportunity to be faux offended.
yta. so much. 1. you’re projecting your own insecurities onto everyone else. 2. you’re convinced that you are the center of everything. 3. you made your niece cry because you wouldn’t accept her handmade card. i don’t have any kids, and i’m a dude… but if your niece made me a card for mother’s day the most critical thing i would say (after thanking her profusely) would be “i’ll have to find a good place to put this up so everyone can see it.” if you’re making your niece cry, you’re doing something wrong. even if your sister were actually trying to orchestrate some sort of passive-aggressive proxy insult via your niece (and that is a big if), refusing the card from your niece is always going to be an asshole move. you could have said something to your sister in private after thanking your niece. she may well have replied “wtf are you talking about? it’s a card from your niece because she loves you and didn’t want you to feel left out!” that’s my bet, anyway.
yta if it was just one made for you, you would have a point but she gave them to every female family member and it wouldn't have hurt to accept it and bin it at home. i'm also child free by choice
yta. good thing you’re child free because you’re cruel to children for no reason. what did you honestly think? big hallmark was coming after you on mother’s day because you niece made a mother’s day card? because that’s just as ridiculous as what you assumed. there’s being childfree and then there’s whatever the fresh hell this is. i also suggest you do a little dictionary dive into the s section and look up sexist. a 5 year old giving you a card being sexist is such a reach. like god damn you really heard “reach for the stars” and ran with that didn’t you? get over yourself.
i bet nobody cares that youre childfree, why the hell do you have to be so militant about it? the kid just wanted to give you a card. yta
yta. if a child gave me a homemade card celebrating the wedding anniversary of the man in the moon, i would accept it happily. it's a way to show we care about people. small children love to make cards and will seize on any opportunity to do so for the people they love. that's an observation based on a lifetime of experience, not a paranoid delusion based on placing myself at the centre of the universe.
yta as a staunchly childfree woman who does not enjoy children at all, you are a gigantic asshole!!! not everything is a slight against cf folks, but even it was, you accept the card from the child, thank them and discuss it privately with her mom to discuss your offense it was not ok whatsoever to make your 5 year old niece feel rejected and upset, she doesnt understand, all she sees is her aunt being mean to her
yta. it was a gesture of love and you slapped it away. just to protect your fragile identity. it’s not as if the child free police would be knocking your door down to arrest you for crimes against ideology! congrats on being completely over the top and i hope that your niece can see past this ridiculousness and realise she did nothing wrong.
yta. i have zero desire to be parent. everyone knows this. but if my niece or nephew give me a card on a mother's or father's day i'll give them a big hug that they see me as another parental figure. my mom's sister is like a second mother to me. i do not call her mom but every mother's day i take out my mom and her (my mom 100% comfortable with this). it doesn't mean she feels like my mom or gets offended - she just feels appreciated and loved too. grow the fuck up.
yta - even if it was a backhanded jibe by your sister as you seem to think, despite everyone getting a mother's day card (so that's some projection on your part), the child doesn't friggin' know that! she just thinks she's gifting her aunty something, and said aunty has rejected her. you take the card and talk it over with the adults later out of earshot. what you did was incredibly mean spirited. i'm childfree - it doesn't give you a pass to be actively mean to kids.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (24f) am childfree. my entire family is fully aware of that. my parents always wanted grandchildren, and my sister has already popped out two, so fortunately they never gave me much grief for my choice. in fact, they've been as supportive as they could be. this incident happened months ago, on mother's day, but the topic has recently come up again. on mother's day lunch, my 5 yo niece gave cards to each female member of the family- my sister (her mom), my sil ( my brother's wife), her grandma and me. my card had "to the best ani (that's what she calls me) ever. happy mother's day" obviously she didn't make the card herself, and my sister had a hand in this. i really think this was a jab to the fact that i don't have children, so i politely refused the card, saying that i'm not your mom and you can give me a card like that on my birthday. she looked a bit upset like she was about to turn on the waterworks, but her mom said something to her and she shut up. i felt a bit bad because it wasn't my niece's fault that her mom used a mother's day card as a weapon against my choices and was about to say something when the food arrived and she quickly cheered up. my birthday was yesterday, and my niece gave me a card saying "happy birthday ani". i joked to my sister that this time it looks like a real heartfelt card inatead of a backhanded jibe at me. my sister pretended to look confused and then i reminded about the mother's day card incident. she got mad and said "oh yeah, the card you made my daughter cry over. i'm sorry your niece loves you so much that she spent her time making a mother's day card for you." i told her that she wasn't fooling anyone and there was no need to give me a mother's day card. it was also sexist to give every woman a mother's day card, even women who weren't moms. she told me that her daughter had done the same for all the male relatives on father's day too, but i think that that's beside the point as all the men in my family are fathers already. she also said that "mother's day" also applies to loving aunts. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (24f) am childfree. my entire family is fully aware of that. my parents always wanted grandchildren, and my sister has already popped out two, so fortunately they never gave me much grief for my choice. in fact, they've been as supportive as they could be. this incident happened months ago, on mother's day, but the topic has recently come up again. on mother's day lunch, my 5 yo niece gave cards to each female member of the family- my sister (her mom), my sil ( my brother's wife), her grandma and me. my card had "to the best ani (that's what she calls me) ever. happy mother's day" obviously she didn't make the card herself, and my sister had a hand in this. i really think this was a jab to the fact that i don't have children, so i politely refused the card, saying that i'm not your mom and you can give me a card like that on my birthday. she looked a bit upset like she was about to turn on the waterworks, but her mom said something to her and she shut up. i felt a bit bad because it wasn't my niece's fault that her mom used a mother's day card as a weapon against my choices and was about to say something when the food arrived and she quickly cheered up. my birthday was yesterday, and my niece gave me a card saying "happy birthday ani". i joked to my sister that this time it looks like a real heartfelt card inatead of a backhanded jibe at me. my sister pretended to look confused and then i reminded about the mother's day card incident. she got mad and said "oh yeah, the card you made my daughter cry over. i'm sorry your niece loves you so much that she spent her time making a mother's day card for you." i told her that she wasn't fooling anyone and there was no need to give me a mother's day card. it was also sexist to give every woman a mother's day card, even women who weren't moms. she told me that her daughter had done the same for all the male relatives on father's day too, but i think that that's beside the point as all the men in my family are fathers already. she also said that "mother's day" also applies to loving aunts. aita? [/INST] yta such projection and insecurity in your own decision. some people just take any and every opportunity to be faux offended. </s>
AITA for talking to my MIL like a kid when she touched my belly?
my husband and i are expecting our firs baby (yei!), we've have some ups and downs with his parents because they don't understand boundaries, but overall it's been really good. for some context, i (24f) come from an abusive home and i can't stand being touched, before getting pregnant this wasn't a problem with my in-laws, but now that i'm carrying a baby, it's been awful with my mil and my sil because they think they can touch my belly whenever they want to. both my husband and i have talked to them, and said that while i would rather they don't touch me at all, i can understand this is a big thing as a family, so i would simply like being asked instead of just feeling a hand at random times, but they rarely do it, so i just move when they touch me. now, onto the subject, a week ago my best friend threw me a baby shower and i invited my in-laws and since i don't have any blood family left, we let them invite 10 more people which included aunts-cousins and my husband's grandparents. it was an overall lovely moment, but at one time, i was sitting eating cake while my mil talked with my fil's sister, and while telling her something about the baby, she put her hand in my belly and idk, i just didn't like it. so i took her hand, removed it and said ''no, no, you know i've told you not to touch without asking firs. you know how to ask first, do you? it's easy!'' with the most condescending voice i had. both my mil and my fil's sister looked at me shocked, and then my fil's sister laughed but my mil got red in the face. when it was done, my mil approached me and said that what i did wasn't nice and she just ''slipped'' so i didn't had to treat her like a kid. i just smiled and said that she touching me after being asked a million times not to was a kid behavior and i just called her out on that. she left, very sad, and when we got home, my fil called my husband and said he would love for both of us to apologize to each other, but i said no. so he called me an ah.
19,736
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/xlogjp/aita_for_talking_to_my_mil_like_a_kid_when_she/
2022-09-23 05:22:35
nta. i hate being touched. everyone thinks being pregnant makes you public property. stand your ground, enforce your boundaries, and tell her off every time.
nta. sometimes people don't understand when you ask nicely. my friend grabbed a strangers boob when the stranger touched her belly. the stranger was shocked and my friend said "oh i thought we were grabbing each other's bodies, my bad!"
nta the proper response from your mil would have been, "i'm so sorry, op. you're right. you've been very clear about this and i let it slip my mind. i'll remember to ask permission before touching you in the future. please forgive me." there, done and dusted. but instead, she chose to be offended.
nta. i was far more dramatic when i was pregnant. i wore a shirt that said “you can touch my belly if i can punch your face.”
"not touching another person is a thing you do all the time. i won't come see any of you unless you can manage to do something you do every day and something you've done since meeting me." nta
nta. i don't think anyone appreciates being touched without consent, let alone someone with an aversion to being touched in the first place. if someone can't respect your wishes even after being told so many times, they deserve to be called out. also, being asked to apologize because 'you both were at fault' is infuriating, especially when you weren't at fault at all. i say talk it out with mil since she's family but you weren't in the wrong here.
nta she has been told multiple times not to touch you without permission. you were nicer than most people would have been. since the asking part is too difficult for her. i would just completely ban touching all together.
nta. you have on many occasions asked to not be touched and they’ve ignored that boundary. you weren’t wrong to call her out in front of your fil’s sister. was it slightlyyy combative? yes and she deserved it. but, you shouldn’t have to tolerate triggers and swallow your reaction for others to be comfortable. reprimanding her in a public way definitely got the point across and i don’t think she’ll be doing it again. op, you don’t have to have a traumatic background in order for their to be a valid reason to not want to be touched. you don’t want to be touched and you don’t owe anyone an explanation.
nta. i accidentaly elbowed an old man hard in his gut. he came from behind and put both hands on my babynest. i was in line to the atm, and he was a silent stranger. too bad for him that i wasn't dressed in my uniform, he might have not approached me at all had he known i was a soldier at the time. i had to show security my military id to explain why i reacted so instantly like that. they also told him off for touching a stranger from behind in line to an atm. why would i not think he was after my money? stupid old man. your mil is lucky you were so nice. i would be done at that point.
nta. you did that really well. and when the baby comes, and you give them baby boundaries, they know they had better toe that line!
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my husband and i are expecting our firs baby (yei!), we've have some ups and downs with his parents because they don't understand boundaries, but overall it's been really good. for some context, i (24f) come from an abusive home and i can't stand being touched, before getting pregnant this wasn't a problem with my in-laws, but now that i'm carrying a baby, it's been awful with my mil and my sil because they think they can touch my belly whenever they want to. both my husband and i have talked to them, and said that while i would rather they don't touch me at all, i can understand this is a big thing as a family, so i would simply like being asked instead of just feeling a hand at random times, but they rarely do it, so i just move when they touch me. now, onto the subject, a week ago my best friend threw me a baby shower and i invited my in-laws and since i don't have any blood family left, we let them invite 10 more people which included aunts-cousins and my husband's grandparents. it was an overall lovely moment, but at one time, i was sitting eating cake while my mil talked with my fil's sister, and while telling her something about the baby, she put her hand in my belly and idk, i just didn't like it. so i took her hand, removed it and said ''no, no, you know i've told you not to touch without asking firs. you know how to ask first, do you? it's easy!'' with the most condescending voice i had. both my mil and my fil's sister looked at me shocked, and then my fil's sister laughed but my mil got red in the face. when it was done, my mil approached me and said that what i did wasn't nice and she just ''slipped'' so i didn't had to treat her like a kid. i just smiled and said that she touching me after being asked a million times not to was a kid behavior and i just called her out on that. she left, very sad, and when we got home, my fil called my husband and said he would love for both of us to apologize to each other, but i said no. so he called me an ah.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my husband and i are expecting our firs baby (yei!), we've have some ups and downs with his parents because they don't understand boundaries, but overall it's been really good. for some context, i (24f) come from an abusive home and i can't stand being touched, before getting pregnant this wasn't a problem with my in-laws, but now that i'm carrying a baby, it's been awful with my mil and my sil because they think they can touch my belly whenever they want to. both my husband and i have talked to them, and said that while i would rather they don't touch me at all, i can understand this is a big thing as a family, so i would simply like being asked instead of just feeling a hand at random times, but they rarely do it, so i just move when they touch me. now, onto the subject, a week ago my best friend threw me a baby shower and i invited my in-laws and since i don't have any blood family left, we let them invite 10 more people which included aunts-cousins and my husband's grandparents. it was an overall lovely moment, but at one time, i was sitting eating cake while my mil talked with my fil's sister, and while telling her something about the baby, she put her hand in my belly and idk, i just didn't like it. so i took her hand, removed it and said ''no, no, you know i've told you not to touch without asking firs. you know how to ask first, do you? it's easy!'' with the most condescending voice i had. both my mil and my fil's sister looked at me shocked, and then my fil's sister laughed but my mil got red in the face. when it was done, my mil approached me and said that what i did wasn't nice and she just ''slipped'' so i didn't had to treat her like a kid. i just smiled and said that she touching me after being asked a million times not to was a kid behavior and i just called her out on that. she left, very sad, and when we got home, my fil called my husband and said he would love for both of us to apologize to each other, but i said no. so he called me an ah. [/INST] nta. i hate being touched. everyone thinks being pregnant makes you public property. stand your ground, enforce your boundaries, and tell her off every time. </s>
AITA for putting a private conversation on loud speaker which cost my brother his 18 year relationship
ok guys i’m extremely tried and it’s been a long ass day so please excuse any poor grammar or spelling mistakes to begin my brother ben (39m fake name ) has been in a relationship with abby(39 fake name) 18 years. they’ve been engaged 8 years they’ve nearly gotten married 3 years ago but months before the wedding ben chickened out. they went to therapy and basically because our dad left us he has issues with commitment. we thought over the last year he was finally gonna step up for abby and be the partner she deserves. he did seem a bit anxious leading up to the big day but assured everyone he was ok today they were meant to get married but as abby and us bridesmaids were about to enter the church ben was no where to be found everyone tried to calm her down saying it was traffic or he probably had a monster hangover. well an hour passed, than two, than three and than after the four hour mark abby said fuck she was going back to the hotel call her when he landed. my family looked panicked and nervous trying to get through to ben or the groomsmen who had not arrived yet my other brothers and brother in laws (sister’s husband) went looking for him thinking he got hurt or arrested the night before i went back to the hotel with a very broken looking abby. we drank and ate food for another hour before i got a text from my brother in law saying they found him in a bar and they were trying to talk him into going to his own wedding. my sister rang her husband and heard him in the background he was literally acting like a 5 year old who didn’t want to go to the doctor honestly guys i had enough at this stage he mess this girl about too long and frankly leading someone along for 18 years is just cruel so he’s here’s were i maybe the asshole of the century. i walked into abby’s room and told her be quiet than i rang my brother in law put him on loud speaker and asked him what was going on than for him to put ben on the phone the drunk fool started saying shit like he didn’t think she was the one and he is only with her because they’ve been together to long and he is scared to be alone i let her hear everything i won’t lie i felt like a monster when she started crying. abby than grabbed the phone told him he had one hour to get to the church or it was over for good long story short ben ended up at the church 20 minutes later and abby took off her dress than left the hotel alone so he ended being left a the alter and she went on the honeymoon alone. i’ve been disowned by everyone expect two siblings (sisters) and i had to get abby’s maid of honour to collect my suitcase from outside the hotel (mom dumped out when she found out) i’m the full blame for ruining their relationship and 98% of my family hates me
22,822
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/u90414/aita_for_putting_a_private_conversation_on_loud/
2022-04-21 23:06:29
nta. you did her a favor by having her hear it. you did something no one else ever did for her. the truth to move on. everyone saying y t a or e s h have their own issues with being told the whole truth.
nta. should have been done a decade ago before she wasted all her good years on your brother
nta personally i think she needed to hear his true thoughts. i hope she meets someone on the vacation.
nta your family is an ah for hating you. they are all ruining this girl's life. yes, she is partly responsible for staying for so long, but everyone else is enabling him! your brother trying to convince him to go to the wedding is an ah, he is a grown man! also, you didn't make ben say anything. he said all of that on his own.
nta, you just did abby a huge favor: i mean not showing up for over 4 hours to your wedding and being together 18 years is a huge red flag. and if she still wanted to marry him after that’s , she really needed to hear the words he said out loud. she still had hope. she deserves better, good on you. your family is delusional if they think you’re the reason they didn’t get married. he’s the reason. period
nta - you didn’t say the words. you didn’t make his choices. you simply opened her eyes (and ears) to the truth. may the flying spaghetti monster bless you. as for those that have blamed you for your brother’s actions, may the flying spaghetti monster curse them with a sudden allergy to their favorite food.
nta, you didnt cost your brother his relationship, his own shitty actions did that. was it the best way to go about it? maybe not, but you saved her from wasting any more years of her life on him
nta. i'd want someone like you on my team. it no doubt sucked for abby to hear what your brother said, but it seemed like you had her best interests in mind when you did what you did. there may have been a better way to do what you had done, but it was a highly emotional situation, so it is what it is. i think abby deserves to hear what your brother thinks of her. now she can do what she deems fit with this information. i really hope she leaves your brother, because she deserves to marry someone who enthusiastically wants to marry her. if you and abby get along and like each other, i hope you can be there for her and help her as she processes the end of this 18 year long relationship.
i might be alone here, but i think you're nta.
i cant believe im saying this but nta you are the speaker phone hero gotham *needs*.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: ok guys i’m extremely tried and it’s been a long ass day so please excuse any poor grammar or spelling mistakes to begin my brother ben (39m fake name ) has been in a relationship with abby(39 fake name) 18 years. they’ve been engaged 8 years they’ve nearly gotten married 3 years ago but months before the wedding ben chickened out. they went to therapy and basically because our dad left us he has issues with commitment. we thought over the last year he was finally gonna step up for abby and be the partner she deserves. he did seem a bit anxious leading up to the big day but assured everyone he was ok today they were meant to get married but as abby and us bridesmaids were about to enter the church ben was no where to be found everyone tried to calm her down saying it was traffic or he probably had a monster hangover. well an hour passed, than two, than three and than after the four hour mark abby said fuck she was going back to the hotel call her when he landed. my family looked panicked and nervous trying to get through to ben or the groomsmen who had not arrived yet my other brothers and brother in laws (sister’s husband) went looking for him thinking he got hurt or arrested the night before i went back to the hotel with a very broken looking abby. we drank and ate food for another hour before i got a text from my brother in law saying they found him in a bar and they were trying to talk him into going to his own wedding. my sister rang her husband and heard him in the background he was literally acting like a 5 year old who didn’t want to go to the doctor honestly guys i had enough at this stage he mess this girl about too long and frankly leading someone along for 18 years is just cruel so he’s here’s were i maybe the asshole of the century. i walked into abby’s room and told her be quiet than i rang my brother in law put him on loud speaker and asked him what was going on than for him to put ben on the phone the drunk fool started saying shit like he didn’t think she was the one and he is only with her because they’ve been together to long and he is scared to be alone i let her hear everything i won’t lie i felt like a monster when she started crying. abby than grabbed the phone told him he had one hour to get to the church or it was over for good long story short ben ended up at the church 20 minutes later and abby took off her dress than left the hotel alone so he ended being left a the alter and she went on the honeymoon alone. i’ve been disowned by everyone expect two siblings (sisters) and i had to get abby’s maid of honour to collect my suitcase from outside the hotel (mom dumped out when she found out) i’m the full blame for ruining their relationship and 98% of my family hates me
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> ok guys i’m extremely tried and it’s been a long ass day so please excuse any poor grammar or spelling mistakes to begin my brother ben (39m fake name ) has been in a relationship with abby(39 fake name) 18 years. they’ve been engaged 8 years they’ve nearly gotten married 3 years ago but months before the wedding ben chickened out. they went to therapy and basically because our dad left us he has issues with commitment. we thought over the last year he was finally gonna step up for abby and be the partner she deserves. he did seem a bit anxious leading up to the big day but assured everyone he was ok today they were meant to get married but as abby and us bridesmaids were about to enter the church ben was no where to be found everyone tried to calm her down saying it was traffic or he probably had a monster hangover. well an hour passed, than two, than three and than after the four hour mark abby said fuck she was going back to the hotel call her when he landed. my family looked panicked and nervous trying to get through to ben or the groomsmen who had not arrived yet my other brothers and brother in laws (sister’s husband) went looking for him thinking he got hurt or arrested the night before i went back to the hotel with a very broken looking abby. we drank and ate food for another hour before i got a text from my brother in law saying they found him in a bar and they were trying to talk him into going to his own wedding. my sister rang her husband and heard him in the background he was literally acting like a 5 year old who didn’t want to go to the doctor honestly guys i had enough at this stage he mess this girl about too long and frankly leading someone along for 18 years is just cruel so he’s here’s were i maybe the asshole of the century. i walked into abby’s room and told her be quiet than i rang my brother in law put him on loud speaker and asked him what was going on than for him to put ben on the phone the drunk fool started saying shit like he didn’t think she was the one and he is only with her because they’ve been together to long and he is scared to be alone i let her hear everything i won’t lie i felt like a monster when she started crying. abby than grabbed the phone told him he had one hour to get to the church or it was over for good long story short ben ended up at the church 20 minutes later and abby took off her dress than left the hotel alone so he ended being left a the alter and she went on the honeymoon alone. i’ve been disowned by everyone expect two siblings (sisters) and i had to get abby’s maid of honour to collect my suitcase from outside the hotel (mom dumped out when she found out) i’m the full blame for ruining their relationship and 98% of my family hates me [/INST] nta. you did her a favor by having her hear it. you did something no one else ever did for her. the truth to move on. everyone saying y t a or e s h have their own issues with being told the whole truth. </s>
AITA for telling my daughter the truth about why I wasn’t in her life?
to start, my ex and i were 19 when she got pregnant. we had recently broke up and she found out a couple weeks later that she was pregnant. she said she planned to get an abortion but only wanted her sister there. so i was always under the belief that she had aborted. she only contacted me once saying it was done and we didn’t speak again. fast forward 19 yrs later, i found out a month ago that was a lie. my ex passed away 3 years ago and my daughter kara has been living with her uncle. he was the one to reach out to give me a heads up after she expressed an interest in wanting us to connect. he and i spoke at length because i was feeling some pretty strong emotions like rage for never being told about her. my ex had backed out of the abortion but didn’t want me involved because we were broken up so decided just not to tell me. but he told me that kara doesn’t know about that. apparently i wasn’t ready for fatherhood because we were both young so i bailed. i couldn’t believe it. rob (her uncle) told me he knows his sister was wrong for that but promised kara doesn’t have any negative feelings towards me and my ex never painted me as some villain, just a young guy who knew he couldn’t properly care for her. he asked me not to tell kara this when we talk if she asks and because it could hurt the way she saw her mom. i never actually confirmed i would. kara messaged me and we’ve been talking. i’ve met her twice and it’s been crazy emotional. looking at this girl who looks just like me and hurting that we’re just barely getting to know each other so far our conversations have only been about what her life was like, how my life is, what her wants/future goals are, and getting to know each other. we met again tuesday and she finally decided to ask the obvious questions about what made me not be involved. how did i feel, what went through my mind, did i ever think about her,etc. i had been thinking about what to do but in that moment i just didn’t have it in me to lie so i was honest. that i was told about the abortion, had no idea she even existed until now, but that i still really want to be in her life and have the chance to be her father if she wants that. kara was a bit emotional, we talked some more, and said she still wants me involved. that night my messages were blowing up. not just from rob but her grandparents as well. they’re all outraged for telling kara about her mom because she yelled at all of them and is refusing to even take their calls. yes, the lie was terrible but i just ruined the image she had of her late mother for my own benefit. rob called me a selfish dick for not taking into consideration how this would affect kara finding out about this. so right now i feel like shit. i get “honesty is the best policy” but in this case i don’t know if i was an asshole for doing it. i’m still learning this whole “dad” business so don’t know if i dropped the ball here.
29,642
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ln04z1/aita_for_telling_my_daughter_the_truth_about_why/
2021-02-18 23:09:36
nta! your ex lied, your ex created this mess. i’m sorry she has passed, but she did this. you have no obligation to continue a lie you had no part of. your daughter deserved the truth.
you said "fast forward 19 yrs later"? so your daughter is 19 now. she's an adult and deserves to know the truth. you should not be expected to make yourself out to be a deadbeat dad just to avoid tainting the memory of her mother. nta.
nta. the people who lied to her for her entire life are to blame for her being upset at the lies. you are not obligated to take the heat for the lies of others. i do hope you are planning on staying in her life now, it would be shitty to drop that info and disappear, but if you stick around she deserves to know the truth so that your newly-found connection isn't built on a lie from the start.
nta. how terrible for both you and your daughter. you didn't ruin the image of her mom, you told her the truth. her mom decided not to abort her and must have loved her immensely. as for the whole family cover up, she has ever right to be mad. she missed out on 19 years with you because of it. i have to ask though, is there a reason why mom didn't want you in the daughter's life then? was it a bad breakup? it seems like something is missing here.
nta- not to speak ill of the dead, but kara's mother did this to herself. it was unfair to both you and kara to keep you apart for all these years, and doubly unfair to expect you to maintain a lie. will it be painful for kara to process this, and reconcile the truth with her own image of her mother/family? absolutely. however, the truth is the truth. i hope you and kara continue to build a strong bond!
nta. your ex robbed you and kara of 19 years of relationship together. that is a lot to rebuild. to also have kara believe you left is asking too much. you can't build a solid foundation on a lie. you can now discuss with kara, how her mom thought she was doing the best, even if you both disagree. and that her family followed her mom, and there's no need to punish them. they could have lied again and tell her "we didn't really know the guy", instead of letting you know so you both can establish a relationship. i wish you the very best; you have lots to catch up.
nta. did ‘rob’ ever call his sister a selfish dick for keeping her child from her father and vice versa ?!?
nta. kara will have to reconcile what she now knows with how she feels about her mother, likely with the help of a therapist, but she deserves to know the truth. her entire life has had a massive lie at the heart of it up until this point; imagine trying to keep up that lie while building a relationship with your daughter. that would be unforgivable, imo, and for what? her mother’s family need to face up to what your ex did, and the part they’ve played in it for the past 19 years. and they can start by acknowledging that you are not the bad guy here.
nta. so... someone lied to you and your daughter denying you a relationship that should've existed her entire life and they're blaming you for the fallout that occurs because you clarified it? no. rob does not get to call you anything. her grandparents also. you are her father and they cut you out of her life for *19 years*. they can take the fallout for that.
nta she deserved to know , it’s her life not theirs
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: to start, my ex and i were 19 when she got pregnant. we had recently broke up and she found out a couple weeks later that she was pregnant. she said she planned to get an abortion but only wanted her sister there. so i was always under the belief that she had aborted. she only contacted me once saying it was done and we didn’t speak again. fast forward 19 yrs later, i found out a month ago that was a lie. my ex passed away 3 years ago and my daughter kara has been living with her uncle. he was the one to reach out to give me a heads up after she expressed an interest in wanting us to connect. he and i spoke at length because i was feeling some pretty strong emotions like rage for never being told about her. my ex had backed out of the abortion but didn’t want me involved because we were broken up so decided just not to tell me. but he told me that kara doesn’t know about that. apparently i wasn’t ready for fatherhood because we were both young so i bailed. i couldn’t believe it. rob (her uncle) told me he knows his sister was wrong for that but promised kara doesn’t have any negative feelings towards me and my ex never painted me as some villain, just a young guy who knew he couldn’t properly care for her. he asked me not to tell kara this when we talk if she asks and because it could hurt the way she saw her mom. i never actually confirmed i would. kara messaged me and we’ve been talking. i’ve met her twice and it’s been crazy emotional. looking at this girl who looks just like me and hurting that we’re just barely getting to know each other so far our conversations have only been about what her life was like, how my life is, what her wants/future goals are, and getting to know each other. we met again tuesday and she finally decided to ask the obvious questions about what made me not be involved. how did i feel, what went through my mind, did i ever think about her,etc. i had been thinking about what to do but in that moment i just didn’t have it in me to lie so i was honest. that i was told about the abortion, had no idea she even existed until now, but that i still really want to be in her life and have the chance to be her father if she wants that. kara was a bit emotional, we talked some more, and said she still wants me involved. that night my messages were blowing up. not just from rob but her grandparents as well. they’re all outraged for telling kara about her mom because she yelled at all of them and is refusing to even take their calls. yes, the lie was terrible but i just ruined the image she had of her late mother for my own benefit. rob called me a selfish dick for not taking into consideration how this would affect kara finding out about this. so right now i feel like shit. i get “honesty is the best policy” but in this case i don’t know if i was an asshole for doing it. i’m still learning this whole “dad” business so don’t know if i dropped the ball here.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> to start, my ex and i were 19 when she got pregnant. we had recently broke up and she found out a couple weeks later that she was pregnant. she said she planned to get an abortion but only wanted her sister there. so i was always under the belief that she had aborted. she only contacted me once saying it was done and we didn’t speak again. fast forward 19 yrs later, i found out a month ago that was a lie. my ex passed away 3 years ago and my daughter kara has been living with her uncle. he was the one to reach out to give me a heads up after she expressed an interest in wanting us to connect. he and i spoke at length because i was feeling some pretty strong emotions like rage for never being told about her. my ex had backed out of the abortion but didn’t want me involved because we were broken up so decided just not to tell me. but he told me that kara doesn’t know about that. apparently i wasn’t ready for fatherhood because we were both young so i bailed. i couldn’t believe it. rob (her uncle) told me he knows his sister was wrong for that but promised kara doesn’t have any negative feelings towards me and my ex never painted me as some villain, just a young guy who knew he couldn’t properly care for her. he asked me not to tell kara this when we talk if she asks and because it could hurt the way she saw her mom. i never actually confirmed i would. kara messaged me and we’ve been talking. i’ve met her twice and it’s been crazy emotional. looking at this girl who looks just like me and hurting that we’re just barely getting to know each other so far our conversations have only been about what her life was like, how my life is, what her wants/future goals are, and getting to know each other. we met again tuesday and she finally decided to ask the obvious questions about what made me not be involved. how did i feel, what went through my mind, did i ever think about her,etc. i had been thinking about what to do but in that moment i just didn’t have it in me to lie so i was honest. that i was told about the abortion, had no idea she even existed until now, but that i still really want to be in her life and have the chance to be her father if she wants that. kara was a bit emotional, we talked some more, and said she still wants me involved. that night my messages were blowing up. not just from rob but her grandparents as well. they’re all outraged for telling kara about her mom because she yelled at all of them and is refusing to even take their calls. yes, the lie was terrible but i just ruined the image she had of her late mother for my own benefit. rob called me a selfish dick for not taking into consideration how this would affect kara finding out about this. so right now i feel like shit. i get “honesty is the best policy” but in this case i don’t know if i was an asshole for doing it. i’m still learning this whole “dad” business so don’t know if i dropped the ball here. [/INST] nta! your ex lied, your ex created this mess. i’m sorry she has passed, but she did this. you have no obligation to continue a lie you had no part of. your daughter deserved the truth. </s>
Aita: For leaving home after my husband said I was embarrassing him when I was crying?
i (28f) lost my brother after two years of fighting cancer, he was only 32 years old and he passed away three weeks ago, i feel so devastated and unable to think clearly, my brother and i were so close, even after i got married and moved out, i was the one who was by his side so i knew what he was going through. it's awful and unfair that he had to suffer and feel all this pain while he should've been living a good life, i spent time with him at the hospital, i was staying with him in his apartment to clean up and cook for him after he called me and told me he spent nights without dinner, he was in a rough condition and needed help,parents are both deceased, my dad's last words were that we needed to take care of each other. my husband would refuse to take meals over to my brother, never visited him, always complains that i pay too much attention to my brother and was negative and unsupportive. in the morning,when i received a call telling me that my brother passed away, i wanted him to drive me to the hospital because i was shaking and crying, almost fainting but he told me he needed to drink something first and acted so cold and didn't look affected by news. after the funeral, and i remember this moment specifically when i was with my aunt, we were both crying especially me, what happened really hit me at that moment, guests were standing around, my husband walked in and saw me sitting crying, he approached me and told me to get up because i was embarrassing him, he repeatedly said this, and couldn't react right away but i blew up on him when we got home for what he said and called him inconsiderate and selfish, only caring about appearance, he yelled back at me saying that i was acting nuts at the funeral and he needed to act, criticized my aunt's and cousin's clothes and said he regreted even going, we argued for few minutes and then i went to my brother's apartment to calm down, the next day he tried to apologize and asked when i was coming home, and now he's livid that i'm still won't go home and is guilt trip me into coming home by talking about how much he cared about my brother and that he was "affected" by this loss as well.
18,773
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/j8c9nc/aita_for_leaving_home_after_my_husband_said_i_was/
2020-10-10 02:08:54
nta. i’m so sorry for your loss. also leave this guy. how are you embarrassing him by crying at a funeral. op your husband has shown you who he is now, i think you need to leave him
[removed]
nta, your husband is a cruel, self centred asshole. he is not a force for good in your life. you deserve someone who will support you through thick and thin, as you would for them. he won’t change. he tried to manipulate you into coming home but couldn’t even keep up the brief charade of caring for you in your grief. it was all about him and his needs. he was “affected too” (yeah, right). ditch this asshole.
nta, this is grounds for divorce. not only does it seem he was jealous of the time and attention you gave to your own brother, but he is also shallow and doesn't care about your feelings. he was embarrassed you were crying at your own brother's funeral?? he needs to get a grip. leave him, i would never forgive him for his behavior. him just refusing to take food to your brother while he was sick would have been the end of it for me.
he reprimanded you for crying at a funeral. i dont think you need it pointed out to you that none of his behaviour is normal and that you've done nothing wrong. hope you stay in a safe place to grieve 🖤
omfg, nta. if i were you, i'd divorce him immediately. anyone who is that uncaring, cruel, selfish, and outright disrespectful towards my family would immediately get shown the door. i lost my mother to cancer when i was really young, i understand your pain, and he has no right to treat you that way. husband or not, that is disgusting behavior imo. sending as much support as i can your way!
first off i am sorry for your loss, second i am angry for you. i can't imagine. my question to you op....is he typically like this? does he show empathy for others in general? how does he treat you normally? idk i don't think i could be with someone who couldn't emotionally support me. did your family notice him making comments? i have so many questions. i dont like to pick sides here but definitely take some time for yourself here to feel all the feelings. but maybe re-evaluate your relationship. definitely nta.
nta divorce that jerk now. he clearly doesn't love you. no one deserves a man that behaves that way. no regard for you or your feelings. what a dickhead.
nta. that is some stone cold shit. did you spell ex-husband incorrectly because...wow...just wow.
i think it’s pretty obvious who the asshole is. why even post this?
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (28f) lost my brother after two years of fighting cancer, he was only 32 years old and he passed away three weeks ago, i feel so devastated and unable to think clearly, my brother and i were so close, even after i got married and moved out, i was the one who was by his side so i knew what he was going through. it's awful and unfair that he had to suffer and feel all this pain while he should've been living a good life, i spent time with him at the hospital, i was staying with him in his apartment to clean up and cook for him after he called me and told me he spent nights without dinner, he was in a rough condition and needed help,parents are both deceased, my dad's last words were that we needed to take care of each other. my husband would refuse to take meals over to my brother, never visited him, always complains that i pay too much attention to my brother and was negative and unsupportive. in the morning,when i received a call telling me that my brother passed away, i wanted him to drive me to the hospital because i was shaking and crying, almost fainting but he told me he needed to drink something first and acted so cold and didn't look affected by news. after the funeral, and i remember this moment specifically when i was with my aunt, we were both crying especially me, what happened really hit me at that moment, guests were standing around, my husband walked in and saw me sitting crying, he approached me and told me to get up because i was embarrassing him, he repeatedly said this, and couldn't react right away but i blew up on him when we got home for what he said and called him inconsiderate and selfish, only caring about appearance, he yelled back at me saying that i was acting nuts at the funeral and he needed to act, criticized my aunt's and cousin's clothes and said he regreted even going, we argued for few minutes and then i went to my brother's apartment to calm down, the next day he tried to apologize and asked when i was coming home, and now he's livid that i'm still won't go home and is guilt trip me into coming home by talking about how much he cared about my brother and that he was "affected" by this loss as well.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (28f) lost my brother after two years of fighting cancer, he was only 32 years old and he passed away three weeks ago, i feel so devastated and unable to think clearly, my brother and i were so close, even after i got married and moved out, i was the one who was by his side so i knew what he was going through. it's awful and unfair that he had to suffer and feel all this pain while he should've been living a good life, i spent time with him at the hospital, i was staying with him in his apartment to clean up and cook for him after he called me and told me he spent nights without dinner, he was in a rough condition and needed help,parents are both deceased, my dad's last words were that we needed to take care of each other. my husband would refuse to take meals over to my brother, never visited him, always complains that i pay too much attention to my brother and was negative and unsupportive. in the morning,when i received a call telling me that my brother passed away, i wanted him to drive me to the hospital because i was shaking and crying, almost fainting but he told me he needed to drink something first and acted so cold and didn't look affected by news. after the funeral, and i remember this moment specifically when i was with my aunt, we were both crying especially me, what happened really hit me at that moment, guests were standing around, my husband walked in and saw me sitting crying, he approached me and told me to get up because i was embarrassing him, he repeatedly said this, and couldn't react right away but i blew up on him when we got home for what he said and called him inconsiderate and selfish, only caring about appearance, he yelled back at me saying that i was acting nuts at the funeral and he needed to act, criticized my aunt's and cousin's clothes and said he regreted even going, we argued for few minutes and then i went to my brother's apartment to calm down, the next day he tried to apologize and asked when i was coming home, and now he's livid that i'm still won't go home and is guilt trip me into coming home by talking about how much he cared about my brother and that he was "affected" by this loss as well. [/INST] nta. i’m so sorry for your loss. also leave this guy. how are you embarrassing him by crying at a funeral. op your husband has shown you who he is now, i think you need to leave him </s>
AITA for serving my boyfriend's parents pizza for dinner?
hi. so this happened last night. i'm still hella confused by this whole thing. so, i f28 have been dating my boyfriend m31 for 7 months. his family are of italian origins and they take a lot of pride in it. they invited me over to their house several times. last night, his parents came over to the apt for the first time. they said they were visiting a friend and decided to stop by for dinner. i freaked out when they said dinner because it was late, and i was working and had no time to cook. so i ordered pizza for all of us. the second his parents saw the pizza they got pissed. his dad gave me a nasty stare then said that i "intentionally" served them pizza just because they were "italians" in other words he claimed i was mocking them and their food and assuming that just cause they're italian then they'd only eat italian food which he called "racist". i was confused i said i didn't think it was interepreted that way but he said "if you have asian guests over do you serve them susi? how would you like if we only serve you macdonalds and fries every time you visit since that's what americans eat?" i was stunned by his words. basically, he was saying that just because they're italian then i shouldn't assume they'd like to have pizza but...who doesn't like pizza?. he and my boyfriend's mom got up and said they wanted to leave. my boyfriend tried to get them to stay and take it easy but they left eventually. he blew up saying i messed by serving them pizza and "insulting them indirectly" he told me to call and apologize but i said no and that i didn't have time to cook anything after they showed up unexpectedly. he got more upset and asked if his parents needed permission to visit *him* i backed off thinking he'd call down. nut he kept saying i insulted his parents and i need to apologize. i'm utterly and genuinly confused. aita,?
19,576
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/xr7f2d/aita_for_serving_my_boyfriends_parents_pizza_for/
2022-09-29 13:08:05
nta. i mean, if your boyfriend was so upset that his parents got pizza, why didn't he cook for them?
nta it sounds like they were looking for a reason to be upset. when people don't have time to cook, they order pizza. your guests being of italian origin makes no difference, and they are just being assholes
pro tip: him: my parents/friends/colleagues have just dropped by for dinner! you: cool, what are you cooking? beginning and end of it.
nta ordering out for pizza is as "american" as it gets. they were just looking for an excuse to be insulted. anyway, why was it your responsibility to order dinner? your boyfriend was there, and they're *his* parents; *he* should have been responsible for providing dinner.
nta! why didn’t your boyfriend prepare dinner for his parents? they decided to stop by last minute “uninvited” for dinner. your boyfriend and his parents are tas.
nta—there are a lot of red flags here. 1. why was it assumed to be your responsibility to arrange dinner for his parents? 2. why do his parents believe it’s ok to stop by unexpectedly and on top of that, that dinner would be provided? 3. why didn’t your boyfriend stand up for you and tell his parents that when they stop by with no notice they should expect something easy (like pizza)? 4. he yelled at you after they left instead of apologizing for them stopping by unannounced and then getting angry with you. get out now. it will only get worse from here.
literal marinara flags! nta. i'm italian and a chicagoan to boot, so i have feelings about pizza. the only way someone ordering me a pizza could be insulting would be if they put pineapple on it. (i kid, i'll eat pretty much anything) bf's parents suck and it probably won't get much better. if they are so proudly italian they might be way more involved in his life than you realize. sometimes that's great! but these parents? oof.
nta- also italian isn't a race so you can't be "racist". also unless they were born in italy, they are not italian they are (insert whatever country they are in). also your boyfriend is a jerk-off. he's a 31 year old but still has to protect mommy and daddy?
nta why didn’t your boyfriend make his parents dinner if he’s so worried about it? ordering pizza for unexpected dinner guests is pretty normal. his parents sound exhausting. marina flag.
please tell me after only 7 months you aren’t living with this asshole. nta. he and his parents are rude af though.
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: hi. so this happened last night. i'm still hella confused by this whole thing. so, i f28 have been dating my boyfriend m31 for 7 months. his family are of italian origins and they take a lot of pride in it. they invited me over to their house several times. last night, his parents came over to the apt for the first time. they said they were visiting a friend and decided to stop by for dinner. i freaked out when they said dinner because it was late, and i was working and had no time to cook. so i ordered pizza for all of us. the second his parents saw the pizza they got pissed. his dad gave me a nasty stare then said that i "intentionally" served them pizza just because they were "italians" in other words he claimed i was mocking them and their food and assuming that just cause they're italian then they'd only eat italian food which he called "racist". i was confused i said i didn't think it was interepreted that way but he said "if you have asian guests over do you serve them susi? how would you like if we only serve you macdonalds and fries every time you visit since that's what americans eat?" i was stunned by his words. basically, he was saying that just because they're italian then i shouldn't assume they'd like to have pizza but...who doesn't like pizza?. he and my boyfriend's mom got up and said they wanted to leave. my boyfriend tried to get them to stay and take it easy but they left eventually. he blew up saying i messed by serving them pizza and "insulting them indirectly" he told me to call and apologize but i said no and that i didn't have time to cook anything after they showed up unexpectedly. he got more upset and asked if his parents needed permission to visit *him* i backed off thinking he'd call down. nut he kept saying i insulted his parents and i need to apologize. i'm utterly and genuinly confused. aita,?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> hi. so this happened last night. i'm still hella confused by this whole thing. so, i f28 have been dating my boyfriend m31 for 7 months. his family are of italian origins and they take a lot of pride in it. they invited me over to their house several times. last night, his parents came over to the apt for the first time. they said they were visiting a friend and decided to stop by for dinner. i freaked out when they said dinner because it was late, and i was working and had no time to cook. so i ordered pizza for all of us. the second his parents saw the pizza they got pissed. his dad gave me a nasty stare then said that i "intentionally" served them pizza just because they were "italians" in other words he claimed i was mocking them and their food and assuming that just cause they're italian then they'd only eat italian food which he called "racist". i was confused i said i didn't think it was interepreted that way but he said "if you have asian guests over do you serve them susi? how would you like if we only serve you macdonalds and fries every time you visit since that's what americans eat?" i was stunned by his words. basically, he was saying that just because they're italian then i shouldn't assume they'd like to have pizza but...who doesn't like pizza?. he and my boyfriend's mom got up and said they wanted to leave. my boyfriend tried to get them to stay and take it easy but they left eventually. he blew up saying i messed by serving them pizza and "insulting them indirectly" he told me to call and apologize but i said no and that i didn't have time to cook anything after they showed up unexpectedly. he got more upset and asked if his parents needed permission to visit *him* i backed off thinking he'd call down. nut he kept saying i insulted his parents and i need to apologize. i'm utterly and genuinly confused. aita,? [/INST] nta. i mean, if your boyfriend was so upset that his parents got pizza, why didn't he cook for them? </s>
AITA For not considering my parents adopted children as my siblings and not being willing to take them in if something happens to my parents
i know the title probably makes me sound horrible, but there is a lot more to the story. so my parents had me very late in their lives after a crapton of tries and being told they could not have kids. well here i am, but my dad was 51 and my mom 45 when i was born. despite their age they were amazing parents, loving, caring, strict but fair and they were in a very good financial position in large part due to their age, so they put me through very good schools and paid my tuition to uni and so on, in other words i had a great youth and was set up for success. well i am 26 now, i am doing well for myself, however the problem started 3 years ago. they missed having me in the house, it felt empty they said so they were considering adoption from another country where laws are more lacking as in our country their age would likely prevent them from even being considered, i told them that this was a horrible idea due to thrir age. last year they succeeded in adopting a little girl and her brother aged 3 and 5 and i have only met them a few times so far all times they were extremely shy and frankly, i am not close to them at all as i live halfway across the country so obviously i do not consider them my siblings but more so as my parents kids. issue is my dad is now 77 and my mom is 71, they are still very fit for their age and have a live in nanny to help out, but lets be honest, they are in the agegroup where it is likely the end is near. so i visited them a week ago and asked them what their plans were for the kids if they die before they are adults and they were pretty much lost for words, looked confused and answered "obviously you will take them in, you are their brother." i pretty much had the same rwaction as they had to my question and told them there was no way, i hardly know them, i am not close to them, i do not consider them my siblings and i certainly wont take care of two kids. went over about as well as you can expect, loads of yelling and screaming which led to me leaving, i have not spoken to them since apart from my mom sending me messages to reconsider. obviously i do feel bad though, there is no one else who can take care of them, no other family, no close friends, just me, so they'll end up in the foster system. but am i the asshole?
20,760
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hon97j/aita_for_not_considering_my_parents_adopted/
2020-07-10 11:27:48
nta. adopting at their age is a terrible idea. they *know* they will die soon. frankly, 10-20 years at most is what they can expect. you don't adopt a child because "the house is empty", you get a bloody dog. it shows incredible selfishness and short-sightedness on their part because they clearly haven't given much thought on what will happen to them once they're dead or too old to care for a teenager.
nta. how can they make a decision to adopt two young children so late in life and then make the assumption that when they inevitably pass you will be responsible for caring for them? that is truly fucked up. they are not your responsibility.
bro nta. it’s very inconsiderate of them. they almost kind of adopted those kids on your behalf. why didn’t they get a cat or something sheesh.
nta, you did not agree to be a parent so why would you take these kids that have no relationship to you
nta. it was their decision to adopt children at their age. they should face the consequences and make plans for the future that don't involve you giving up your life as you know it for a -frankly- reckless decision you had no part in.
normally i would let it slide these children are human beings. esh except the young children. your parents should have talked to you about their assumptions before the adoption but you assuming the kids will be fine in foster care if the worst comes is pretty hard hearted. the losers are the kids. sad
nta. it was irresponsible for them to adopt two kids at their ages without a plan for what happens when they die.
nta you're not being ungrateful for refusing your adopted siblings. it was your parent's decision to adopt the kids. you should not be forced to be a parent if you are not ready.
going to go against popular opinion here and say esh. obviously your parents are selfish assholes for treating these kids like dogs they just adopted because they were lonely. however, the kids themselves are the victims in this and people saying the parents need to “face the consequences of their actions” aren’t thinking this through. it won’t be the parents who face any consequences, it’ll be the children who are put through the foster system if op won’t take them in. i think it’s an asshole move to let the kids go into foster care, assuming you are financially and logistically able to take them in when your parents die.
nta. but figure out something other than foster care for the kids. it is not their fault their adoptive parents are careless and selfish. and foster care in this country is a problem,. 1- these kids won't be little anymore when it happens- so they are likely to end up in a group home. 2- and i say this from experience, i have volunteered in this system in 3 states, over 20 yr: a child that goes into foster care is at increased risk of molestation and physical abuse. and financial abuse- something like 80% of foster kids have ruined credit when they age out because someone stole their identity when they were in care. 3- you do not have to be the caregiver. but please, because the kids are not the asshole here, start discussing legitimate plans for these kids if they pass before they are grown. this could be a family friend, or someone else in the community they are currently residing (because moving 2 kids into a virtual strangers home after the death of their parents is pretty traumatic- it would be better if the kids know this person. maybe work through their church to identify someone willing. be a part of the process and solution, since you clearly see your parents are not doing so. 4- none of this is your responsibility. i am only asking that, as a child advocate, you consider that the kids are not eh asshole here, and kids deserve better than this plan.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
ESH
NTA
NTA
ESH
NTA
0.054
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i know the title probably makes me sound horrible, but there is a lot more to the story. so my parents had me very late in their lives after a crapton of tries and being told they could not have kids. well here i am, but my dad was 51 and my mom 45 when i was born. despite their age they were amazing parents, loving, caring, strict but fair and they were in a very good financial position in large part due to their age, so they put me through very good schools and paid my tuition to uni and so on, in other words i had a great youth and was set up for success. well i am 26 now, i am doing well for myself, however the problem started 3 years ago. they missed having me in the house, it felt empty they said so they were considering adoption from another country where laws are more lacking as in our country their age would likely prevent them from even being considered, i told them that this was a horrible idea due to thrir age. last year they succeeded in adopting a little girl and her brother aged 3 and 5 and i have only met them a few times so far all times they were extremely shy and frankly, i am not close to them at all as i live halfway across the country so obviously i do not consider them my siblings but more so as my parents kids. issue is my dad is now 77 and my mom is 71, they are still very fit for their age and have a live in nanny to help out, but lets be honest, they are in the agegroup where it is likely the end is near. so i visited them a week ago and asked them what their plans were for the kids if they die before they are adults and they were pretty much lost for words, looked confused and answered "obviously you will take them in, you are their brother." i pretty much had the same rwaction as they had to my question and told them there was no way, i hardly know them, i am not close to them, i do not consider them my siblings and i certainly wont take care of two kids. went over about as well as you can expect, loads of yelling and screaming which led to me leaving, i have not spoken to them since apart from my mom sending me messages to reconsider. obviously i do feel bad though, there is no one else who can take care of them, no other family, no close friends, just me, so they'll end up in the foster system. but am i the asshole?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i know the title probably makes me sound horrible, but there is a lot more to the story. so my parents had me very late in their lives after a crapton of tries and being told they could not have kids. well here i am, but my dad was 51 and my mom 45 when i was born. despite their age they were amazing parents, loving, caring, strict but fair and they were in a very good financial position in large part due to their age, so they put me through very good schools and paid my tuition to uni and so on, in other words i had a great youth and was set up for success. well i am 26 now, i am doing well for myself, however the problem started 3 years ago. they missed having me in the house, it felt empty they said so they were considering adoption from another country where laws are more lacking as in our country their age would likely prevent them from even being considered, i told them that this was a horrible idea due to thrir age. last year they succeeded in adopting a little girl and her brother aged 3 and 5 and i have only met them a few times so far all times they were extremely shy and frankly, i am not close to them at all as i live halfway across the country so obviously i do not consider them my siblings but more so as my parents kids. issue is my dad is now 77 and my mom is 71, they are still very fit for their age and have a live in nanny to help out, but lets be honest, they are in the agegroup where it is likely the end is near. so i visited them a week ago and asked them what their plans were for the kids if they die before they are adults and they were pretty much lost for words, looked confused and answered "obviously you will take them in, you are their brother." i pretty much had the same rwaction as they had to my question and told them there was no way, i hardly know them, i am not close to them, i do not consider them my siblings and i certainly wont take care of two kids. went over about as well as you can expect, loads of yelling and screaming which led to me leaving, i have not spoken to them since apart from my mom sending me messages to reconsider. obviously i do feel bad though, there is no one else who can take care of them, no other family, no close friends, just me, so they'll end up in the foster system. but am i the asshole? [/INST] nta. adopting at their age is a terrible idea. they *know* they will die soon. frankly, 10-20 years at most is what they can expect. you don't adopt a child because "the house is empty", you get a bloody dog. it shows incredible selfishness and short-sightedness on their part because they clearly haven't given much thought on what will happen to them once they're dead or too old to care for a teenager. </s>
AITA... for refusing to let someone order an item off the menu
i’m a waitress at a restaurant chain know for their ice cream. (do with that what you will) and i have a semi regular family that comes in every once in a while. every time they come in they order their youngest child mac and cheese. the first time i served them, the child threw up all over the booth. i didn’t think much of it, just that he was sick or had an upset stomach. i clean up the booth. the next time was the same thing. mac and cheese then puke. again in the booth and on the table. this is an every time occurrence, the kid orders mac end cheese then throws up. the kid never gets to the bathroom, and most the time he doesn’t even make an attempt to leave the table. i believe once he started walking to the bathroom. this most recent time they came in and i was their waitress the child went to order mac and cheese again, and i asked the mom. “is he okay to have that? he gets sick every time....” the mom said “oh yah kraft mac and cheese makes him sick, but he wants it.”. i said “ma’am, i’m sorry but i don’t think your child should order this if you know he’s going to puke from eating it. and quite frankly i really don’t want to have to clean up vomit tonight” the mom threw a bit of a fit, but when i said, “why are you allowing your child to order a food that makes him sick, just to have someone else clean it up.” and the manager had came over and was agreeing with me, she ordered him chicken tenders and fries instead. was i in the wrong for not wanting/allowing him to order the mac and cheese that makes him sick? i’ve shared this story with a few people and i’ve had some mixed reactions. aita?
18,652
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/myqeqm/aita_for_refusing_to_let_someone_order_an_item/
2021-04-26 05:25:52
nta i have never heard of such a ridiculous thing. i can guarantee the mother isn't giving her child mac n cheese at home. but since she doesn't have to clean up the mess she doesn't care. what confuses me the most is that the mom knows that the mac n cheese makes him sick and still let's him eat it. they sounds like bad parenting.
nta if this has happened regularly. i can’t even fault you for the phrasing being rude because honestly they might need a little rude to wake them up. and yeah that your manager supported you.
nta- what is wrong with this lady? this kid obviously cannot tolerate it. honestly, i’m a mom myself. i would have been mortified if my kid vomited in a restaurant. i know things happen, but to let this happen multiple times and think it’s not a big deal is beyond me.
surely that’s a health hazard right now nta. i think you handled it quite well
nta. it's bad for you &amp; it's bad for the kid's health. i'm glad your manager supported you.
nta. this sounds more than reasonable. the parents need a reality check and need to learn to say no to their child. i'm glad your boss was on your side instead of being one of those scared the-customer-is-always-right bosses.
so if the child wanted to play with matches or knives, it is fine because that's what he wants?? she needs to be a parent and put her foot down geez... nta apparently you are a better parent than she is :/
nta if this is a regular occurrence, which you and other employees have confirmed, with the manager on your side in this scenario, you have a right to refuse a form a service as long as you're not discriminating. in this case your refusal seems rational and non discriminatory for obvious safety reasons.
so many questions... why does mac and cheese make him sick? is this a known allergy? is the mom not concerned? is it a dairy thing? why does he want it if it makes him sick? why does the mom let him order something that is going to make him sick? who brings there child to a restaurant to puke? why does she expect you to clean up after he keeps puking? do they sit there after he pukes or is that the cue to leave? does she not have to clean his clothes? does she have to feed him again if he just puked his dinner up? but mostly... wtf?! nta
nta, and i'm glad your manager agreed, that could've sucked for you. those parents are assholes
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i’m a waitress at a restaurant chain know for their ice cream. (do with that what you will) and i have a semi regular family that comes in every once in a while. every time they come in they order their youngest child mac and cheese. the first time i served them, the child threw up all over the booth. i didn’t think much of it, just that he was sick or had an upset stomach. i clean up the booth. the next time was the same thing. mac and cheese then puke. again in the booth and on the table. this is an every time occurrence, the kid orders mac end cheese then throws up. the kid never gets to the bathroom, and most the time he doesn’t even make an attempt to leave the table. i believe once he started walking to the bathroom. this most recent time they came in and i was their waitress the child went to order mac and cheese again, and i asked the mom. “is he okay to have that? he gets sick every time....” the mom said “oh yah kraft mac and cheese makes him sick, but he wants it.”. i said “ma’am, i’m sorry but i don’t think your child should order this if you know he’s going to puke from eating it. and quite frankly i really don’t want to have to clean up vomit tonight” the mom threw a bit of a fit, but when i said, “why are you allowing your child to order a food that makes him sick, just to have someone else clean it up.” and the manager had came over and was agreeing with me, she ordered him chicken tenders and fries instead. was i in the wrong for not wanting/allowing him to order the mac and cheese that makes him sick? i’ve shared this story with a few people and i’ve had some mixed reactions. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i’m a waitress at a restaurant chain know for their ice cream. (do with that what you will) and i have a semi regular family that comes in every once in a while. every time they come in they order their youngest child mac and cheese. the first time i served them, the child threw up all over the booth. i didn’t think much of it, just that he was sick or had an upset stomach. i clean up the booth. the next time was the same thing. mac and cheese then puke. again in the booth and on the table. this is an every time occurrence, the kid orders mac end cheese then throws up. the kid never gets to the bathroom, and most the time he doesn’t even make an attempt to leave the table. i believe once he started walking to the bathroom. this most recent time they came in and i was their waitress the child went to order mac and cheese again, and i asked the mom. “is he okay to have that? he gets sick every time....” the mom said “oh yah kraft mac and cheese makes him sick, but he wants it.”. i said “ma’am, i’m sorry but i don’t think your child should order this if you know he’s going to puke from eating it. and quite frankly i really don’t want to have to clean up vomit tonight” the mom threw a bit of a fit, but when i said, “why are you allowing your child to order a food that makes him sick, just to have someone else clean it up.” and the manager had came over and was agreeing with me, she ordered him chicken tenders and fries instead. was i in the wrong for not wanting/allowing him to order the mac and cheese that makes him sick? i’ve shared this story with a few people and i’ve had some mixed reactions. aita? [/INST] nta i have never heard of such a ridiculous thing. i can guarantee the mother isn't giving her child mac n cheese at home. but since she doesn't have to clean up the mess she doesn't care. what confuses me the most is that the mom knows that the mac n cheese makes him sick and still let's him eat it. they sounds like bad parenting. </s>
AITA for refusing to cut my hair for my father's wedding?
dad (42) and my his fiancee (alice 28) are getting married in november this year. i (15f) didn't really like alice because i think she replaced my mom too soon. my mom died of cancer 2 years ago and she and dad started dating 8 months after. i try to be as polite as i can whenever she's around or starts a conversation with me. dad never forced me to have a relationship with her and i can also see that she's not interested in having one. after they got engaged, alice approached me and said we needed to talk. she said she has a clear vision of how she wants her wedding to be and that i have to comply so that everything will be perfect. i said sure and asked her what i need to do. she said, "first, i want you to cut your hair short; second, you can't wear heels and lastly, only wear light make up and no fake lashes. okay?" i let her finish before i responded. i said i can do the second and third but i will not be cutting my hair. my mom loves my hair and helped me grow them thick and healthy. i got my blonde wavy hair from my mom so i will keep it long. alice accused me of wanting to upstage her. i said that's not what i'm trying to do and i think it's unfair since i know she didn't make these demands on her other female guests. she then called me a selfish brat and told me she'll tell my dad about how i "disrespected her". my dad then got involved and told me to just cut my hair because it will grow back anyway. i said her request is ridiculous and i'd rather not attend their wedding than to cut my hair. i think i have put my dad in a tight situation and i am now considering cutting my hair because i know my presence in the wedding will make my dad happy. but growing my hair back to lower back length will take a long time. aita if i refuse to cut my hair?
21,337
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/p9x3tf/aita_for_refusing_to_cut_my_hair_for_my_fathers/
2021-08-23 10:34:51
nta. your dad is only telling you to acquiesce to cut your hair because alice already successfully cut off his balls.
oh, no, nta. _do not cut your hair_. punishment haircuts are real, and it sounds like your ta step-mother just wants to hurt and humiliate you. your dad's a real ta too for supporting this ridiculous demand from a woman who is twice your age who hilariously thinks you're trying to upstage her. someone here is a "selfish brat" but it certainly isn't you.
nta...your body, your choice. if alice is worried about being upstaged by a 15 year old girl, she's got bigger issues than hair style.
&gt;my mom died of cancer 2 years ago and she and dad started dating 8 months after wait, you've had 2 years since your mom died? &gt;i think she replaced my mom too soon that's absolutely a fair response, and your dad should bear this in mind. &gt;she said she has a clear vision of how she wants her wedding to be and that i have to comply so that everything will be perfect off the bat, she's making her wedding a you problem. you're 15, and you've known her less than 2 years. if the wedding has a problem, it's not going to be you. &gt;first, i want you to cut your hair short not a reasonable request for anyone at a wedding, she's the ah for this request alone. &gt;my mom loves my hair and helped me grow them thick and healthy. i got my blonde wavy hair from my mom so i will keep it long. alice accused me of wanting to upstage her alice is doubly an asshole. &gt;she'll tell my dad about how i "disrespected her" tripling down on being an asshole. &gt;my dad then got involved and told me to just cut my hair because it will grow back anyway your dad became an asshole here. also, he never taught her to respect you, so he's an asshole for that. she wouldn't have asked you in the first place if she'd had any respect for you. &gt;her request is ridiculous and i'd rather not attend their wedding than to cut my hair you're 15. you're old enough to stay home or at a friend's house for the duration. first of all, good on you for standing up for yourself. your dad's fiancée is an asshole, and she has no respect for you, or the grief you've spent 2 years processing. to go off like that after finding out it's something you treasure because of your mom, i'm disappointed in your dad for staying with her. there are some things you never do, and disrespecting a child's deceased parent is one of them. please find something fun to do on the day, and maybe tell someone outside of the situation what's going on. grandparents or a family friend, someone who knows you and would stand up for you. nta
you have not put your father in a situation, rather he and alice have put you in one. this is not a valid request to make of anyone, and your father’s bride to be had no room to ask it.
nta stepmom is jealous of you, which is creep as sh*t. who looks at a minor with "you'll upstage me!" don't cut your hair.
are you friggin kidding me? what kind of insane bridezilla insists that non-entourage guests cut their hair!!! (not that asking bridal party to cut their hair isn’t crazy also). is your dad insane for not putting her in her place? what the hell!!! this is absolutely outrageous. you aren’t an accessory at her wedding for goodness sake! does your grandma or grandpa know what your father is allowing? nta x 1000h
nta- do not cut your hair and any self respecting father would never tell you to. she is pulling a power play and is going to became a nightmare in your life once she gets a ring in it. at 15 you still have a couple of years on the clock but seriously plan your escape. is studying overseas or boarding school an option?
nta at all. what you are being asked to do is way over the line. that said, is there some kind of compromise possible? like a hat? being as bald as an egg, im afraid i cant offer any other alternatives due to ignorance. but dont cut your hair for a wedding of all things. also lol @ "it will grow back". wtf! i would have been tempted to respond with "will it take longer to grow back than your marriage will last?". dont say that btw. lol
nta. didn’t even have to read the whole thing to know my answer. it’s very simple. if someone cares about you, they will not try to change what is not toxic. i have never heard of someone asking someone else to alter their body/physical appearance for a wedding. seems like your stepmom is very insecure and that’s not your problem in the least.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: dad (42) and my his fiancee (alice 28) are getting married in november this year. i (15f) didn't really like alice because i think she replaced my mom too soon. my mom died of cancer 2 years ago and she and dad started dating 8 months after. i try to be as polite as i can whenever she's around or starts a conversation with me. dad never forced me to have a relationship with her and i can also see that she's not interested in having one. after they got engaged, alice approached me and said we needed to talk. she said she has a clear vision of how she wants her wedding to be and that i have to comply so that everything will be perfect. i said sure and asked her what i need to do. she said, "first, i want you to cut your hair short; second, you can't wear heels and lastly, only wear light make up and no fake lashes. okay?" i let her finish before i responded. i said i can do the second and third but i will not be cutting my hair. my mom loves my hair and helped me grow them thick and healthy. i got my blonde wavy hair from my mom so i will keep it long. alice accused me of wanting to upstage her. i said that's not what i'm trying to do and i think it's unfair since i know she didn't make these demands on her other female guests. she then called me a selfish brat and told me she'll tell my dad about how i "disrespected her". my dad then got involved and told me to just cut my hair because it will grow back anyway. i said her request is ridiculous and i'd rather not attend their wedding than to cut my hair. i think i have put my dad in a tight situation and i am now considering cutting my hair because i know my presence in the wedding will make my dad happy. but growing my hair back to lower back length will take a long time. aita if i refuse to cut my hair?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> dad (42) and my his fiancee (alice 28) are getting married in november this year. i (15f) didn't really like alice because i think she replaced my mom too soon. my mom died of cancer 2 years ago and she and dad started dating 8 months after. i try to be as polite as i can whenever she's around or starts a conversation with me. dad never forced me to have a relationship with her and i can also see that she's not interested in having one. after they got engaged, alice approached me and said we needed to talk. she said she has a clear vision of how she wants her wedding to be and that i have to comply so that everything will be perfect. i said sure and asked her what i need to do. she said, "first, i want you to cut your hair short; second, you can't wear heels and lastly, only wear light make up and no fake lashes. okay?" i let her finish before i responded. i said i can do the second and third but i will not be cutting my hair. my mom loves my hair and helped me grow them thick and healthy. i got my blonde wavy hair from my mom so i will keep it long. alice accused me of wanting to upstage her. i said that's not what i'm trying to do and i think it's unfair since i know she didn't make these demands on her other female guests. she then called me a selfish brat and told me she'll tell my dad about how i "disrespected her". my dad then got involved and told me to just cut my hair because it will grow back anyway. i said her request is ridiculous and i'd rather not attend their wedding than to cut my hair. i think i have put my dad in a tight situation and i am now considering cutting my hair because i know my presence in the wedding will make my dad happy. but growing my hair back to lower back length will take a long time. aita if i refuse to cut my hair? [/INST] nta. your dad is only telling you to acquiesce to cut your hair because alice already successfully cut off his balls. </s>
AITA for telling my mom’s new husband that she has kids?
when i was 15, my mom left the family. for a long time, no one knew where she was or even if she was okay. eventually, it was discovered that she was just “too overwhelmed” and left to handle herself. my brothers and i were raised by our uncle and my dad from that point on, but it was hard. i became like my brothers’ mom and had to grow up quicker than i probably should’ve. i got into therapy and a few years back and have been doing better. recently, i found my mom on facebook. it was by pure mistake because i reconnected with some other maternal family members that i guess are friends with her. she had the same first name and looks pretty much the same, with just a different last name. the more i looked at her page, however, i saw that she had gotten remarried not long after she left my dad and had basically started a new family. she has kids ranging in age from 2-10 years old. my husband told me to leave it alone, but i was so angry and i just couldn’t handle it, so i ended up finding out her husband’s fb and messaged him, saying that his wife had 5 other kids that she had abandoned, did he know that? my mom ended up messaging me, pissed, saying i had made her husband mad because he didn’t know. to me, that’s not my problem. you can’t just run off and neglect my responsibilities. however, my brothers and husband think i was the asshole. aita?
22,535
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/g088b0/aita_for_telling_my_moms_new_husband_that_she_has/
2020-04-13 00:33:18
nta, she left her family to "handle herself" she can handle her husband being mad about the whole thing. her own fault for not saying anything til now, you did him a favor.
nta. this man is not nothing to you— he’s your stepfather. you have a right to be acknowledged to your stepfather and siblings. your mother cannot erase you, no matter how much she may want to in order to avoid dealing with her own enormity. since she can’t be trusted to do so, you had every right to do it yourself. your mother is not a colleague or casual acquaintance with strict rules of civility and boundaries that demand observance. your mother committed a grave betrayal of her duties to you and inflicted grave wounds as a result. she treated you as though you are nothing. you are not nothing. you are valuable and did not deserve to be abandoned. by announcing your presence in the world to her husband, you are letting her know you’re still here in the only way that would make her listen. she can’t ignore that anymore and that’s a good thing in my books.
nta, because your action was justified. building up for years being a mother to your brother. seeing her being a mom to other children. basically ignoring you ever existed. i'm sure it brought you to tears and anger. idc what anyone say i feel you were in the right .
nta. you're her kid. she did that to you. he has kids with her. fair warning. if she doesn't like having to own being a shit person, she shouldn't be a shit person in the first place. and it's not your fault she hid her shit. how were you to know she didn't even mention you existed, let alone she bailed on you (and your sibs). that's all on her. that's her shit show.
nta if i was the new husband, i'd like to have known. i guess he's prepared for what is to come.
nta - i don’t know what’s up with the asshole verdicts. from my perspective, all you did was tell the guy something he has every right to know. your mother is 100% ta. in a relationship, trust is everything. that is one hell of a thing to lie about for so long. if i were him, i’d be questioning the foundation my relationship is based on. if she can lie about having 5 children, she can lie about absolutely anything.
nta. hey, better he knows what she is capable of...nothing says she won't pull the same stunt again on her new family.
nta- did she ever tell you "it's a secret"? it's information, that is all. and, did she ever actually divorce your dad? is she even legally married to this new guy?
leaning towards a nta here. you don’t owe her anything, but there is clearly still a lot of hurt there. if anything it shows how much she hurt you and your family. sorry dude.
nta. you owe her nothing lol. shes a total asshole and you're allowed to message someone. if they didnt wanna be found/messaged maybe they shouldn't have public profiles on social media
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: when i was 15, my mom left the family. for a long time, no one knew where she was or even if she was okay. eventually, it was discovered that she was just “too overwhelmed” and left to handle herself. my brothers and i were raised by our uncle and my dad from that point on, but it was hard. i became like my brothers’ mom and had to grow up quicker than i probably should’ve. i got into therapy and a few years back and have been doing better. recently, i found my mom on facebook. it was by pure mistake because i reconnected with some other maternal family members that i guess are friends with her. she had the same first name and looks pretty much the same, with just a different last name. the more i looked at her page, however, i saw that she had gotten remarried not long after she left my dad and had basically started a new family. she has kids ranging in age from 2-10 years old. my husband told me to leave it alone, but i was so angry and i just couldn’t handle it, so i ended up finding out her husband’s fb and messaged him, saying that his wife had 5 other kids that she had abandoned, did he know that? my mom ended up messaging me, pissed, saying i had made her husband mad because he didn’t know. to me, that’s not my problem. you can’t just run off and neglect my responsibilities. however, my brothers and husband think i was the asshole. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> when i was 15, my mom left the family. for a long time, no one knew where she was or even if she was okay. eventually, it was discovered that she was just “too overwhelmed” and left to handle herself. my brothers and i were raised by our uncle and my dad from that point on, but it was hard. i became like my brothers’ mom and had to grow up quicker than i probably should’ve. i got into therapy and a few years back and have been doing better. recently, i found my mom on facebook. it was by pure mistake because i reconnected with some other maternal family members that i guess are friends with her. she had the same first name and looks pretty much the same, with just a different last name. the more i looked at her page, however, i saw that she had gotten remarried not long after she left my dad and had basically started a new family. she has kids ranging in age from 2-10 years old. my husband told me to leave it alone, but i was so angry and i just couldn’t handle it, so i ended up finding out her husband’s fb and messaged him, saying that his wife had 5 other kids that she had abandoned, did he know that? my mom ended up messaging me, pissed, saying i had made her husband mad because he didn’t know. to me, that’s not my problem. you can’t just run off and neglect my responsibilities. however, my brothers and husband think i was the asshole. aita? [/INST] nta, she left her family to "handle herself" she can handle her husband being mad about the whole thing. her own fault for not saying anything til now, you did him a favor. </s>
AITA for kicking my boyfriend's parents out of our apartment after his mom called me a bitch?
back in march his parents decided they wanted to come "wait quarantine out" at our apartment. for starters they never asked. his mother called and told me that they were on their way and to prepare our spare bedroom for them. i was already apprehensive about them staying with us because his parents have always been extremely rude to me. they are overly critical of everything i say and do. they are massive control freaks who feel entitled to always be in charge. so right off the bat things are miserable. they verbally abuse me daily, tell me what i can and can't do in my own apartment, and are overall just the worst. out of everything, the air conditioning caused the biggest debacle. where i live it has been 85-90 almost every day. i normally keep my air on 70, but when they started complaining, i turned the air up to 75. this is already a little toasty for me, but i was willing to be a little hot to try to keep the peace. this was not good enough for them. they don't want the air on. period. they want the heat on. and they turn it on every single opportunity they get. i wake up in the middle of the night covered in sweat. i have told them to stop countless times. yesterday i finally cracked. i put about 10 pieces of duct tape over the thermostat with a note attached that said "do not touch the thermostat while i am at work". 6pm i walk into my apartment and am automatically hit by a hotter and more humid heat than it is outside. duct tape and note have been torn off the thermostat and they have the heat on 98 fucking degrees. i go into the guest room and say "why could you not follow the simple instruction of do not touch the thermostat. this is my home. i am tired of you saying rude things to me. i am tired of you treating me like a child and creating your own rules for my apartment. you either need to be respectful towards me and learn to accept my boundaries or go back to your own house." his mother said and i disdainfully quote, "you have no right to barge in here without knocking. that was not only an invasion of privacy but you need to take the attitude out of your tone. i've dealt with much bigger bitches than you before." she went on for 30 minutes and i just tuned her out. when she was done talking i told her to get out. now my boyfriend is angry with me because i couldn't just let them have their way. he wants me to call his mom and apologize but i don't think i should have to. i may have been rude to her, but it was only because i have spent the past two months dealing with her abuse and trying to politely ask her to stop treating me that way. i got tired of politely asking someone to stop treating me like shit in my own home in which i was letting them live in for free. i also got tired of my boyfriend refusing to defend me and allowing her to say and do whatever she wanted. i am trying to understand their perspective although it just doesn't seem reasonable to me. if reddit determines i am the asshole, i will call and apologize.
27,873
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/gon4bm/aita_for_kicking_my_boyfriends_parents_out_of_our/
2020-05-22 17:00:28
nta. and i would seriously consider a future with him if he's not willing to support you now, it will only be worse in the future when it comes to his parents.
nta. why do you even stay with your boyfriend? he’s clearly choosing his mother over you every single time. you should be kicking all three out
nta you should probably kick your boyfriend out too, he sucks
alright guys so my boyfriend and i just had a very long conversation. i admitted to him that i vented on reddit and i screen shotted a bunch of comments for him to read through. he was mostly silent for awhile and got a little emotional. eventually he asked me if i showed him all these comments because i was planning on leaving him. i told him no, i wasn't going to just dump him without giving him the chance to work through our issues if he was willing to. i explained to him that i understand his past trauma with his mother, but it doesn't make it okay for him to enable her to be abusive towards me. he agreed that he was in the wrong and he should have made a bigger effort to step in and defend me. he also apologized for asking me to call his mother and apologize. i told him that i wasn't going to make him choose between me and his mother, but if we were going to have a healthy relationship he would have to start going to therapy and he would have to confront his mother about her behavior. i told him i would stand by him and support him as he did it, but it was something he would have to do on his own. i told him that we were setting some hard boundaries and one of those boundaries would be that his parents are no longer allowed to stay with us. ever. he agreed that was for the best and admitted he's been miserable these past two months too. he mentioned that cutting off his family might be what is healthiest for his mental health and how that is something he would discuss with the psychiatrist when he goes. i told him that i was extremely hurt that not only was he willing to prioritize his mother over me, but he was willing to cause me pain to satiate her need for control. it bothered me a lot that he made me really feel like i was the asshole to the point that i made this post to try to gain perspective. after that he told me he would call his mother and request she apologize for treating me so poorly the past two months. honestly that is a really big step for him and i am very proud of him for that. it shows me that he is willing to work on his issues. i do think seeing a professional might help him process these emotions better and develop healthier coping mechanisms. overall, right now it seems like we're going to be okay relationship wise as long as he is committed to actually following through with his promises. thank you to everyone who commented!! you have been extremely helpful. i will keep you guys updates on any new developments.
nta they were under your roof. they came unannounced (but what i've seen from this story i would think that your bf knew before and he said okay before telling you anything). they overstayed their welcome and tried to change your life style in your house. unacceptable. i don't know how bad the heated argument was at the very end but she shouldn't have called you a bitch no matter what. they are the ones that need to apologize. your boyfriend sucks. how dependent is he to his parents that he bends over backwards to ignore all the shit they do and ask you to apologize? just kick him to the curb next to his beloved parents too.
nta - i'm having trouble figuring out who are the biggest assholes : your bf's parents for their obnoxious behavior or your bf for allowing it. i think i am going to go with the bf for demanding you be the one to apologize.
nta. and holy shit, why are they even there in the first place if they have their own home? do not try to understand their perspective, it is horrifically flawed. i'd be having a serious talk with bf as well, he is clearly putting them well before you.
nta - send the boyfriend with them since he is siding with them. you deserve better. it sounds like they were being rude guests.
absolutely nta. it is your house and they are guests - basic respect for your rules is not too much to ask. honestly, i would be rethinking my relationship with the boyfriend, too. he doesn't defend you and wants you to be uncomfortable in your own home to keep his parents happy. not to mention, do you really want to marry into a family that thinks it's okay to keep the house and 98 flippin' degrees?!
nta. and i’d be breaking up.
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: back in march his parents decided they wanted to come "wait quarantine out" at our apartment. for starters they never asked. his mother called and told me that they were on their way and to prepare our spare bedroom for them. i was already apprehensive about them staying with us because his parents have always been extremely rude to me. they are overly critical of everything i say and do. they are massive control freaks who feel entitled to always be in charge. so right off the bat things are miserable. they verbally abuse me daily, tell me what i can and can't do in my own apartment, and are overall just the worst. out of everything, the air conditioning caused the biggest debacle. where i live it has been 85-90 almost every day. i normally keep my air on 70, but when they started complaining, i turned the air up to 75. this is already a little toasty for me, but i was willing to be a little hot to try to keep the peace. this was not good enough for them. they don't want the air on. period. they want the heat on. and they turn it on every single opportunity they get. i wake up in the middle of the night covered in sweat. i have told them to stop countless times. yesterday i finally cracked. i put about 10 pieces of duct tape over the thermostat with a note attached that said "do not touch the thermostat while i am at work". 6pm i walk into my apartment and am automatically hit by a hotter and more humid heat than it is outside. duct tape and note have been torn off the thermostat and they have the heat on 98 fucking degrees. i go into the guest room and say "why could you not follow the simple instruction of do not touch the thermostat. this is my home. i am tired of you saying rude things to me. i am tired of you treating me like a child and creating your own rules for my apartment. you either need to be respectful towards me and learn to accept my boundaries or go back to your own house." his mother said and i disdainfully quote, "you have no right to barge in here without knocking. that was not only an invasion of privacy but you need to take the attitude out of your tone. i've dealt with much bigger bitches than you before." she went on for 30 minutes and i just tuned her out. when she was done talking i told her to get out. now my boyfriend is angry with me because i couldn't just let them have their way. he wants me to call his mom and apologize but i don't think i should have to. i may have been rude to her, but it was only because i have spent the past two months dealing with her abuse and trying to politely ask her to stop treating me that way. i got tired of politely asking someone to stop treating me like shit in my own home in which i was letting them live in for free. i also got tired of my boyfriend refusing to defend me and allowing her to say and do whatever she wanted. i am trying to understand their perspective although it just doesn't seem reasonable to me. if reddit determines i am the asshole, i will call and apologize.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> back in march his parents decided they wanted to come "wait quarantine out" at our apartment. for starters they never asked. his mother called and told me that they were on their way and to prepare our spare bedroom for them. i was already apprehensive about them staying with us because his parents have always been extremely rude to me. they are overly critical of everything i say and do. they are massive control freaks who feel entitled to always be in charge. so right off the bat things are miserable. they verbally abuse me daily, tell me what i can and can't do in my own apartment, and are overall just the worst. out of everything, the air conditioning caused the biggest debacle. where i live it has been 85-90 almost every day. i normally keep my air on 70, but when they started complaining, i turned the air up to 75. this is already a little toasty for me, but i was willing to be a little hot to try to keep the peace. this was not good enough for them. they don't want the air on. period. they want the heat on. and they turn it on every single opportunity they get. i wake up in the middle of the night covered in sweat. i have told them to stop countless times. yesterday i finally cracked. i put about 10 pieces of duct tape over the thermostat with a note attached that said "do not touch the thermostat while i am at work". 6pm i walk into my apartment and am automatically hit by a hotter and more humid heat than it is outside. duct tape and note have been torn off the thermostat and they have the heat on 98 fucking degrees. i go into the guest room and say "why could you not follow the simple instruction of do not touch the thermostat. this is my home. i am tired of you saying rude things to me. i am tired of you treating me like a child and creating your own rules for my apartment. you either need to be respectful towards me and learn to accept my boundaries or go back to your own house." his mother said and i disdainfully quote, "you have no right to barge in here without knocking. that was not only an invasion of privacy but you need to take the attitude out of your tone. i've dealt with much bigger bitches than you before." she went on for 30 minutes and i just tuned her out. when she was done talking i told her to get out. now my boyfriend is angry with me because i couldn't just let them have their way. he wants me to call his mom and apologize but i don't think i should have to. i may have been rude to her, but it was only because i have spent the past two months dealing with her abuse and trying to politely ask her to stop treating me that way. i got tired of politely asking someone to stop treating me like shit in my own home in which i was letting them live in for free. i also got tired of my boyfriend refusing to defend me and allowing her to say and do whatever she wanted. i am trying to understand their perspective although it just doesn't seem reasonable to me. if reddit determines i am the asshole, i will call and apologize. [/INST] nta. and i would seriously consider a future with him if he's not willing to support you now, it will only be worse in the future when it comes to his parents. </s>
AITA for giving money to one daughter and not the other?
i have three children: mary (23f), fiona (19f) and jacob (7m). my daughters are from my first marriage, jacob is my husband's son. mary was always the responsible one. she had good grades and was very responsible with money. she worked from age 16 onwards every summer and after she graduated, she picked up a job that she held throughout university. i know for a fact that she saved most of the money, using it only for major purposes. i was always very proud of her for the fact that she could pay for everything herself and never asking for a single cent. fiona, on the other hand, was never good with money. she had several low paying jobs over the last few summers but spent everything she had on clothes or other accessoires she didn't really need. when she turned 18, i paid for her driver's licence. i also gave her an allowence of 20$ a week since she got a boyfriend, so she could occasionally pay for dates, etc. fiona moved in with her boyfriend this january after we got into a pretty nasty fight. we have since made amends and she recieves 300$ a month from her father. note, that i still occasionally pay for her expenses, for example for gas or some spare change so she can take out her boyfriend on dates. the works. also, fiona is still in school. mary is graduating university with a bachelor's degree. she told me that she could no longer work her job because the restrictions don't allow her workplace to employ her anymore. she approached me, asking if i could help her out with some money to pay for the extra driving lessons she had to take. i asked her how many extra lessons she had to pay for and she sheepishly admitted that she had to take six extra lessons. i was honestly shocked. one lesson costs 50$ and now she had to pay 300$. plus, she doesn't even have her driver's licence yet. i flat out refused to give her any money towards that because her sister didn't need any extra lessons and drives just fine. mary teared up at this point. she said that she knew she shouldn't have asked me, that i had always favoured her sister, that i had never considered giving her some money towards major purchases which made her save up and never buy anything just for fun. she also said that she would give me the money back as soon as possible. i must admit, i laughed at that. that made mary mad and she started screaming at me which she never did. she further accused me of spending so much money on her sister even though she always blows it on useless stuff. i tried exlaining to her that most of the money i've given to fiona was so she could invite her boyfriend on dates so he didn't have to pay for everything and that she didn't have a boyfriend until recently so she didn't need money. mary left crying, calling me a nasty ah. i also talked to my husband about it and now he is mad at me, too. he told me to think about it and apologize to my daughter but i don't think i should.
4,978
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/htxfxl/aita_for_giving_money_to_one_daughter_and_not_the/
2020-07-19 08:48:27
yta. i'm really confused about why you keep giving fiona money when she "was never good with money," but when the hard-working daughter you're supposedly very proud of lost her job due to the pandemic, you were "honestly shocked" that she asked for what is ultimately a fairly small amount of money for an important purpose. it actually does sound like you favour fiona if you're happy to pay for dates for her and her boyfriend but not to help mary when she's experiencing genuine financial difficulty.
yta. your blatant favouritism will lead to nothing but resentment from your daughter. she is angry and rightfully so. just because she was independent does not mean that she doesn’t need support every once in a while. she might cut you off forever for not helping her in need and that would be justified. and the fact that you acknowledge this and yet decide not to help her shows how much you favour your other daughter more and the kind of parent you are. so yes, you are the asshole. i do hope that you mend your relationship before it gets too late you apologising
yta my god you openly admit you have no problem spending money, and giving an allowance to one child, but you rebuff the hardworking one in a moment of need? you’re either a convincing troll or an awful mother.
[deleted]
yta without any doubt in my mind, and without any chance of me thinking otherwise. i have very little to say that wouldn't break the rule about being civil. you laughed in the face of the daughter who never asked for much, and who promised to pay you back, when you've spent so much on the daughter who wasted the money on non necessities. jesus christ.
yta. you admitted yourself that mary never asked for anything and only used her money for major purposes. and now, that one time she asks you refuse. and do you know what's funny about that? due to you writing it seems like mary payed for her driving lessons herself, while you payed your little fiona the whole driving license. and not only that. your paying fiona's whole living expenses. mary had to learn how to spend her money while fiona could spend hers on useless stuff because "mother pays". the only "favor" your doing fiona is turning her into an entitled brat.
major yta. this really took a turn midway! totally expected fiona to get angry for you rightfully helping mary for once, and then we would've all happily agreed fiona to be the ah. when the daughter that generally does better for once asks for something, how can you say no without clearly stating you're playing favorites? this really feels like it was written by on-looker, or mary. just because it doesn't make sense to write this story and not recognize what an ah you are as op while writing it.
yta what the fuck? you can't see how making one sibling work and giving the other extra play money isn't unfair?? you want to keep giving one daughter date money but won't help the other /who lost their job during a pandemic/ bc... what? she doesn't have a boyfriend?
yta... at this point the only thing you haven't done is flat out say that you prefer fiona over mary, even though fiona can't get her act together. hopefully your financial planning is in order to support fiona for her entire life because you have trainer her the bank of mom is always open.
yta. why on earth do you and your husband give fiona $300 a month if the very idea of lending mary the same amount once is unthinkable? this makes no sense.
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i have three children: mary (23f), fiona (19f) and jacob (7m). my daughters are from my first marriage, jacob is my husband's son. mary was always the responsible one. she had good grades and was very responsible with money. she worked from age 16 onwards every summer and after she graduated, she picked up a job that she held throughout university. i know for a fact that she saved most of the money, using it only for major purposes. i was always very proud of her for the fact that she could pay for everything herself and never asking for a single cent. fiona, on the other hand, was never good with money. she had several low paying jobs over the last few summers but spent everything she had on clothes or other accessoires she didn't really need. when she turned 18, i paid for her driver's licence. i also gave her an allowence of 20$ a week since she got a boyfriend, so she could occasionally pay for dates, etc. fiona moved in with her boyfriend this january after we got into a pretty nasty fight. we have since made amends and she recieves 300$ a month from her father. note, that i still occasionally pay for her expenses, for example for gas or some spare change so she can take out her boyfriend on dates. the works. also, fiona is still in school. mary is graduating university with a bachelor's degree. she told me that she could no longer work her job because the restrictions don't allow her workplace to employ her anymore. she approached me, asking if i could help her out with some money to pay for the extra driving lessons she had to take. i asked her how many extra lessons she had to pay for and she sheepishly admitted that she had to take six extra lessons. i was honestly shocked. one lesson costs 50$ and now she had to pay 300$. plus, she doesn't even have her driver's licence yet. i flat out refused to give her any money towards that because her sister didn't need any extra lessons and drives just fine. mary teared up at this point. she said that she knew she shouldn't have asked me, that i had always favoured her sister, that i had never considered giving her some money towards major purchases which made her save up and never buy anything just for fun. she also said that she would give me the money back as soon as possible. i must admit, i laughed at that. that made mary mad and she started screaming at me which she never did. she further accused me of spending so much money on her sister even though she always blows it on useless stuff. i tried exlaining to her that most of the money i've given to fiona was so she could invite her boyfriend on dates so he didn't have to pay for everything and that she didn't have a boyfriend until recently so she didn't need money. mary left crying, calling me a nasty ah. i also talked to my husband about it and now he is mad at me, too. he told me to think about it and apologize to my daughter but i don't think i should.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i have three children: mary (23f), fiona (19f) and jacob (7m). my daughters are from my first marriage, jacob is my husband's son. mary was always the responsible one. she had good grades and was very responsible with money. she worked from age 16 onwards every summer and after she graduated, she picked up a job that she held throughout university. i know for a fact that she saved most of the money, using it only for major purposes. i was always very proud of her for the fact that she could pay for everything herself and never asking for a single cent. fiona, on the other hand, was never good with money. she had several low paying jobs over the last few summers but spent everything she had on clothes or other accessoires she didn't really need. when she turned 18, i paid for her driver's licence. i also gave her an allowence of 20$ a week since she got a boyfriend, so she could occasionally pay for dates, etc. fiona moved in with her boyfriend this january after we got into a pretty nasty fight. we have since made amends and she recieves 300$ a month from her father. note, that i still occasionally pay for her expenses, for example for gas or some spare change so she can take out her boyfriend on dates. the works. also, fiona is still in school. mary is graduating university with a bachelor's degree. she told me that she could no longer work her job because the restrictions don't allow her workplace to employ her anymore. she approached me, asking if i could help her out with some money to pay for the extra driving lessons she had to take. i asked her how many extra lessons she had to pay for and she sheepishly admitted that she had to take six extra lessons. i was honestly shocked. one lesson costs 50$ and now she had to pay 300$. plus, she doesn't even have her driver's licence yet. i flat out refused to give her any money towards that because her sister didn't need any extra lessons and drives just fine. mary teared up at this point. she said that she knew she shouldn't have asked me, that i had always favoured her sister, that i had never considered giving her some money towards major purchases which made her save up and never buy anything just for fun. she also said that she would give me the money back as soon as possible. i must admit, i laughed at that. that made mary mad and she started screaming at me which she never did. she further accused me of spending so much money on her sister even though she always blows it on useless stuff. i tried exlaining to her that most of the money i've given to fiona was so she could invite her boyfriend on dates so he didn't have to pay for everything and that she didn't have a boyfriend until recently so she didn't need money. mary left crying, calling me a nasty ah. i also talked to my husband about it and now he is mad at me, too. he told me to think about it and apologize to my daughter but i don't think i should. [/INST] yta. i'm really confused about why you keep giving fiona money when she "was never good with money," but when the hard-working daughter you're supposedly very proud of lost her job due to the pandemic, you were "honestly shocked" that she asked for what is ultimately a fairly small amount of money for an important purpose. it actually does sound like you favour fiona if you're happy to pay for dates for her and her boyfriend but not to help mary when she's experiencing genuine financial difficulty. </s>
AITA for making my nephew a dinosaur quilt? My sister is deeply Christian
my sister and i weren't raised religious. she went off to uni at 18 and became a christian when she started dating another christian. basically the point is she doesn't believe anymore that dinosaurs exist. she's now married to a man who isn't religious which is a sore point for her that he won't convert. i have a niece (9) and a nephew (6). a couple of weeks ago while watching them, my nephew mentioned his quilt i made him was getting too short so i told them both to go into my craft room and pick some fabrics they each want on a quilt. i could easily open a fabric shop with all the fabric i have so they had a rare time picking out their fabrics. my niece went for some space/galaxy themed and my nephew picked out some dinosaur fabrics. i thought nothing of it and got to work. today i went over with their quilts, excited to see their reaction. they were so happy until my sister noticed my nephew's quilt and asked 'what the fuck?!'. i was confused and she quickly went on a rant about her knowing dinosaurs don't exist and how dare i try brainwash her child like that. i told her he picked out the fabric himself, i genuinely didn't make the connection and i would let him pick more fabric for a different quilt. by this point my nephew is crying saying he doesn't want a different quilt so my sister called my bil in telling him to set me straight. he basically shrugged and asked what the big deal was, it's only fabric, their son likes the fabric, it's his son too and he believes in dinosaurs so he should get a say on the quilt too if it's such a big deal. my parents are now involved and despite not being religious, they are pissed at me for what i've done. no one but my bil believes it was a genuine mistake or oversight and they think i've set out to mock my sister's beliefs. i honestly didn't think i'd have to vet my nephew's fabric choices with my sister as all the fabric they had access to was kid friendly prints. the stuff with swearing etc is kept elsewhere as they like going into my craft room edit thank you good people of reddit for your comments and advice. if there's anymore comments tomorrow i'll try reply to them! i'm off to sleep now and here's hoping i don't dream of dinosaurs ;) night night!
20,403
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/i9vw78/aita_for_making_my_nephew_a_dinosaur_quilt_my/
2020-08-14 22:33:43
nta. if she’s so sure dinosaurs aren’t real what’s the problem? would she be pissed if a unicorn fabric was picked? or dragons?
lmao. i don’t believe in dragons, but my son has dragon sheets. nta for an array of reasons, the simplest being that you did something nice by making the quilt and letting the child pick out the fabric. it must take a lot of effort to not believe in dinosaurs.
nta i’m a christian and i know he mentions dinosaurs of coarse they didn’t have that name. behemoth (job 40:15-24). in job, this creature is described as having a tail like a cedar and an herbivore diet. it also says this colossal beast had large bones like beams of bronze. leviathan (job 41) he describes a crocodile like animal to have armor plated skin that no hook can pierce. so very uninformed if she thinks that, god made every creature she should know that. she should go read her bible again.
[deleted]
nta and just so you know the majority of christians aren’t like that 😭 dinosaurs don’t go against christianity. anyways definitely nta and i don’t see why your parents are siding with her
what does being christian have to do with dinosaurs? she sounds crazy.
why can’t he have a quilt of mythical animals? would she object to unicorns or dragons?
obvs nta and may i suggest a visit to a natural history museum for your sister...
this is baffling. i’m a deeply committed christian, and i don’t dispute that dinosaurs existed at some point. i may disagree with some details of the prevailing theories about them, but i’m reasonably sure they were real. unless your gift was intentionally meant to provoke her, nta. your sister sounds kind of nuts, and her behavior is unbecoming for a christian.
nta. he picked the fabric and half the couple believes in dinosaurs. and even if they were both dinosaur truthers, you have no obligation to pretend you share their delusions around their children. you don't have to pretend that dinosaurs are a socialist conspiracy or that the earth is flat or whatever other weird shit your sister believes just because her kids are around. they are going to be exposed to reality eventually.
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
null
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my sister and i weren't raised religious. she went off to uni at 18 and became a christian when she started dating another christian. basically the point is she doesn't believe anymore that dinosaurs exist. she's now married to a man who isn't religious which is a sore point for her that he won't convert. i have a niece (9) and a nephew (6). a couple of weeks ago while watching them, my nephew mentioned his quilt i made him was getting too short so i told them both to go into my craft room and pick some fabrics they each want on a quilt. i could easily open a fabric shop with all the fabric i have so they had a rare time picking out their fabrics. my niece went for some space/galaxy themed and my nephew picked out some dinosaur fabrics. i thought nothing of it and got to work. today i went over with their quilts, excited to see their reaction. they were so happy until my sister noticed my nephew's quilt and asked 'what the fuck?!'. i was confused and she quickly went on a rant about her knowing dinosaurs don't exist and how dare i try brainwash her child like that. i told her he picked out the fabric himself, i genuinely didn't make the connection and i would let him pick more fabric for a different quilt. by this point my nephew is crying saying he doesn't want a different quilt so my sister called my bil in telling him to set me straight. he basically shrugged and asked what the big deal was, it's only fabric, their son likes the fabric, it's his son too and he believes in dinosaurs so he should get a say on the quilt too if it's such a big deal. my parents are now involved and despite not being religious, they are pissed at me for what i've done. no one but my bil believes it was a genuine mistake or oversight and they think i've set out to mock my sister's beliefs. i honestly didn't think i'd have to vet my nephew's fabric choices with my sister as all the fabric they had access to was kid friendly prints. the stuff with swearing etc is kept elsewhere as they like going into my craft room edit thank you good people of reddit for your comments and advice. if there's anymore comments tomorrow i'll try reply to them! i'm off to sleep now and here's hoping i don't dream of dinosaurs ;) night night!
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my sister and i weren't raised religious. she went off to uni at 18 and became a christian when she started dating another christian. basically the point is she doesn't believe anymore that dinosaurs exist. she's now married to a man who isn't religious which is a sore point for her that he won't convert. i have a niece (9) and a nephew (6). a couple of weeks ago while watching them, my nephew mentioned his quilt i made him was getting too short so i told them both to go into my craft room and pick some fabrics they each want on a quilt. i could easily open a fabric shop with all the fabric i have so they had a rare time picking out their fabrics. my niece went for some space/galaxy themed and my nephew picked out some dinosaur fabrics. i thought nothing of it and got to work. today i went over with their quilts, excited to see their reaction. they were so happy until my sister noticed my nephew's quilt and asked 'what the fuck?!'. i was confused and she quickly went on a rant about her knowing dinosaurs don't exist and how dare i try brainwash her child like that. i told her he picked out the fabric himself, i genuinely didn't make the connection and i would let him pick more fabric for a different quilt. by this point my nephew is crying saying he doesn't want a different quilt so my sister called my bil in telling him to set me straight. he basically shrugged and asked what the big deal was, it's only fabric, their son likes the fabric, it's his son too and he believes in dinosaurs so he should get a say on the quilt too if it's such a big deal. my parents are now involved and despite not being religious, they are pissed at me for what i've done. no one but my bil believes it was a genuine mistake or oversight and they think i've set out to mock my sister's beliefs. i honestly didn't think i'd have to vet my nephew's fabric choices with my sister as all the fabric they had access to was kid friendly prints. the stuff with swearing etc is kept elsewhere as they like going into my craft room edit thank you good people of reddit for your comments and advice. if there's anymore comments tomorrow i'll try reply to them! i'm off to sleep now and here's hoping i don't dream of dinosaurs ;) night night! [/INST] nta. if she’s so sure dinosaurs aren’t real what’s the problem? would she be pissed if a unicorn fabric was picked? or dragons? </s>
AITA because I refuse to go and visit my special needs stepsister in hospital even though she’s very sick? I low key hate her.
i’m 15 years old. i have a stepsister who is a couple years older than me and she is really seriously disabled. i’m not sure what’s wrong with her because no one ever wants to discuss it with me but she’s non verbal, breaks her bones a lot, and has severe epilepsy and will have many fitting episodes. she also doesn’t understand stuff. that’s probably the easiest way to put it. she’s just a human body with nothing inside. she’s my stepmoms daughter. my stepmom married my dad 3 years ago and they dated only for a year before that. i don’t know my stepmom very well and i don’t really get on with her. we are respectful to each other but i’m basically living with strangers because she’s so busy with her daughter and my dad. i am always on my own and i used to hate it but i’m used to it now. ever since they moved in to live with us life changed drastically for me because all the care now revolves around my stepsister. that’s fine, i get it, but both my stepmom and my dad ask me to do things for my stepsister that i don’t want to do and i resent doing. stuff like staying home when i want to go to the mall with my friends, they’re disappointed that i don’t get her anything for her birthday with my very limited funds, etc. my own mom passed away when i was small so i can’t go and stay anywhere else and all in all i’m just a lot more angry than i used to be because they seem really disappointed whenever i say i don’t want to do anything for her. even stuff like feeding her- like- i don’t want to sit there feeding her banana pudding and wiping her drool. i didn’t ask for this. anyway, she recently fell a few days ago and had a seizure for 8 minutes. she was taken to hospital and the doctors want to keep her in and look after her. i don’t want to go and visit her. i remember seeing my mom in hospital before she died and i just hate hospitals and i sort of hate my stepsister and i just don’t want to go and visit someone who doesn’t even know i’m there. my stepmom is really upset with me and so is my dad. they haven’t yelled at me or anything but they are both being super cold towards me because i don’t want to visit. my grandma who lives in canada called me up out the blue and told me it was okay and i don’t need to force myself to go to the hospital so i’m assuming my dad has told her i’m refusing to go. he keeps pleading with me but i keep telling him i’m not doing it. i told him hospitals remind me of mom and he got even more upset and said my stepsister might die and i need to stop being so selfish towards my stepmom. i just want to know what reddit thinks because half my friends think i should go and the other half think i’m justified in saying no.
38,510
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/d1btlg/aita_because_i_refuse_to_go_and_visit_my_special/
2019-09-08 14:48:36
nta. you sound like an average teenager who has had a lot of life experiences early on. if going to the hospital upsets you, don't go. and don't be afraid to tell your dad what you need, which is his undivided attention for a minute! if you're in school, talk to a counselor or teacher, or ask to be referred to therapy. you have a real asset in your grandma. call her and talk with her often. she may be a good way to get through to your dad. hang in there. i'm sorry life is tough right now.
nah. you're right, you didn't ask for this, you're not your sister's carer, and having lost your mom you're understandably uneasy around hospitals. but please rethink the idea that "she’s just a human body with nothing inside." people with disabilities are still people. and while i don't think you should be the one feeding her, it does seem strange that you don't give her birthday gifts. even something small would be a kind gesture. you're in a really difficult situation, and i sympathise, but there has to be a middle ground between being her carer and rejecting her altogether.
nta i completely disagree with the notion you should be there as support for your dad and step mom. you are a child. it’s not your role to be their support system (although in a healthy dynamic this will shift as you get older). as far as how you feel about your stepsister- i completely understand why you haven’t formed a bond with her and feel like you can’t. it’s completely reasonable. i do think you should find a different way to verbalize it- saying you have no bond with her is different than saying she’s just nothing and it’s less offensive to people.
nta at all. i hate situations like this where everyone is getting a bad deal and the other kid/s get forgotten. you may have to pull your dad to the side and talk to him how you’re feeling forgotten.
nta for not wanting to go visit or be responsible for your stepsister’s care/wellbeing. that’s just not an appropriate responsibility to ask a 15 year-old to take on, and it makes sense you have a lot of issues around hospitals because of your mom. sounds like you have a ton of (very understandable) resentment around your situation which makes a lot of sense — especially since you didn’t choose it, and you don’t feel any real connection with your stepmom or stepsister. that said, you are slightly ta for how you describe your stepsister, and for “hating” her — she is a person, albeit one with a ton of challenges who can’t interact in a typical way. it’s not her fault those challenges make your life so difficult.
nta. your stepmom and dad are assholes for expecting you to take care of her. you didn't ask for any of this. you don't have a relationship with her and she's not related to you. i'm sorry you're going through this. you're only 15 and still a child who needs their father.
nta. i don't think they're assholes for wanting you to go visit her in the hospital, but they *are* assholes for (at least partially) neglecting you and leaving you to more or less grow up on your own because they're so focused on your sister.
[deleted]
nah your dad and step mom are understandable in wanting you to go but they should also understand your reasoning in bit wanting to go. sorry about you mom and good luck to you.
nah. if she's as disabled as you say, she won't be aware that you're there or who you are. you'd be doing it to support your dad and stepmother, which of course would be a nice thing to do. you shouldn't be put in the position of caregiver for her though. and buying presents for her seems pointless.
NTA
NAH
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NAH
NAH
0.006547
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i’m 15 years old. i have a stepsister who is a couple years older than me and she is really seriously disabled. i’m not sure what’s wrong with her because no one ever wants to discuss it with me but she’s non verbal, breaks her bones a lot, and has severe epilepsy and will have many fitting episodes. she also doesn’t understand stuff. that’s probably the easiest way to put it. she’s just a human body with nothing inside. she’s my stepmoms daughter. my stepmom married my dad 3 years ago and they dated only for a year before that. i don’t know my stepmom very well and i don’t really get on with her. we are respectful to each other but i’m basically living with strangers because she’s so busy with her daughter and my dad. i am always on my own and i used to hate it but i’m used to it now. ever since they moved in to live with us life changed drastically for me because all the care now revolves around my stepsister. that’s fine, i get it, but both my stepmom and my dad ask me to do things for my stepsister that i don’t want to do and i resent doing. stuff like staying home when i want to go to the mall with my friends, they’re disappointed that i don’t get her anything for her birthday with my very limited funds, etc. my own mom passed away when i was small so i can’t go and stay anywhere else and all in all i’m just a lot more angry than i used to be because they seem really disappointed whenever i say i don’t want to do anything for her. even stuff like feeding her- like- i don’t want to sit there feeding her banana pudding and wiping her drool. i didn’t ask for this. anyway, she recently fell a few days ago and had a seizure for 8 minutes. she was taken to hospital and the doctors want to keep her in and look after her. i don’t want to go and visit her. i remember seeing my mom in hospital before she died and i just hate hospitals and i sort of hate my stepsister and i just don’t want to go and visit someone who doesn’t even know i’m there. my stepmom is really upset with me and so is my dad. they haven’t yelled at me or anything but they are both being super cold towards me because i don’t want to visit. my grandma who lives in canada called me up out the blue and told me it was okay and i don’t need to force myself to go to the hospital so i’m assuming my dad has told her i’m refusing to go. he keeps pleading with me but i keep telling him i’m not doing it. i told him hospitals remind me of mom and he got even more upset and said my stepsister might die and i need to stop being so selfish towards my stepmom. i just want to know what reddit thinks because half my friends think i should go and the other half think i’m justified in saying no.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i’m 15 years old. i have a stepsister who is a couple years older than me and she is really seriously disabled. i’m not sure what’s wrong with her because no one ever wants to discuss it with me but she’s non verbal, breaks her bones a lot, and has severe epilepsy and will have many fitting episodes. she also doesn’t understand stuff. that’s probably the easiest way to put it. she’s just a human body with nothing inside. she’s my stepmoms daughter. my stepmom married my dad 3 years ago and they dated only for a year before that. i don’t know my stepmom very well and i don’t really get on with her. we are respectful to each other but i’m basically living with strangers because she’s so busy with her daughter and my dad. i am always on my own and i used to hate it but i’m used to it now. ever since they moved in to live with us life changed drastically for me because all the care now revolves around my stepsister. that’s fine, i get it, but both my stepmom and my dad ask me to do things for my stepsister that i don’t want to do and i resent doing. stuff like staying home when i want to go to the mall with my friends, they’re disappointed that i don’t get her anything for her birthday with my very limited funds, etc. my own mom passed away when i was small so i can’t go and stay anywhere else and all in all i’m just a lot more angry than i used to be because they seem really disappointed whenever i say i don’t want to do anything for her. even stuff like feeding her- like- i don’t want to sit there feeding her banana pudding and wiping her drool. i didn’t ask for this. anyway, she recently fell a few days ago and had a seizure for 8 minutes. she was taken to hospital and the doctors want to keep her in and look after her. i don’t want to go and visit her. i remember seeing my mom in hospital before she died and i just hate hospitals and i sort of hate my stepsister and i just don’t want to go and visit someone who doesn’t even know i’m there. my stepmom is really upset with me and so is my dad. they haven’t yelled at me or anything but they are both being super cold towards me because i don’t want to visit. my grandma who lives in canada called me up out the blue and told me it was okay and i don’t need to force myself to go to the hospital so i’m assuming my dad has told her i’m refusing to go. he keeps pleading with me but i keep telling him i’m not doing it. i told him hospitals remind me of mom and he got even more upset and said my stepsister might die and i need to stop being so selfish towards my stepmom. i just want to know what reddit thinks because half my friends think i should go and the other half think i’m justified in saying no. [/INST] nta. you sound like an average teenager who has had a lot of life experiences early on. if going to the hospital upsets you, don't go. and don't be afraid to tell your dad what you need, which is his undivided attention for a minute! if you're in school, talk to a counselor or teacher, or ask to be referred to therapy. you have a real asset in your grandma. call her and talk with her often. she may be a good way to get through to your dad. hang in there. i'm sorry life is tough right now. </s>
AITA for refusing to let my brother meet my son after what he told me at my husband's funeral?
my late husband passed away from a car accident when i was 4 months pregnant. it's been difficult without him but my family did so much to support me. i moved in with them month after. at the funeral, my older brother asked for a minute to talk then asked me if i really wanted to go through with my pregnancy . i was shocked when i heard this but even more shocked when he suggested that i "make the right decision, not an emotional decision and reconsider having my son". he gave many reasons why including the fact how "single/widowed mom" are considered too much of "baggage" for so many men to date. i lost it on him and kicked him out. that was the last time we saw each other. my son is now 3 weeks old. whole family met him and were happy to welcome him. my parents asked if i could let my brother come meet my son even for few hours. i refused but they said i was making a mistake robbing my son of a future loving relationship with his uncle. they asked that i don't let my emotions dictate a decision that might have a lasting impact but i said no. my extended family got involved and started pushing especially after my brother started insisting saying my husband was a dear friend of his and what i'm doing right now would make my husband upset if he saw it. am i being bitter and selfish?
18,765
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/weptti/aita_for_refusing_to_let_my_brother_meet_my_son/
2022-08-02 22:57:22
nta, every time he says how much of a dear friend he was, remind him of that "talk" from his "dear" friends funeral. hell remind the whole damn family of it.
nta. you don't have to allow anyone in your child's life that you don't want to. that includes family. your brother said some pretty awful and tactless things (while you were still at the funeral of the father of your child). i'm assuming he also hasn't bothered to apologize but still feels he is entitled to have a relationship with your son and has no problem emotionally manipulating you in order to get what he wants? yeah no. you're not the ah here. tell your extended family that the discussion is closed and anyone who brings it up again will not be seeing your son for a long time. if and when you want your son to have a relationship with your brother you will let him know.
nta. he told you to get rid of your baby because he would be a burden and not a joy. he is not someone to let be around a new life. what a callus and awful thing to say, you are well within your rights to deny him
has he acknowledged and apologized for his hurtful comments? does your family know the reason you’re refusing to see him?
nta. are your parents aware of the “comforting words” your brother imparted? how can grandparents be happy that one kid advocated for termination of the grandkid - at the funeral?
nta, consider letting the family know what your reasons are.
nta &gt;brother started insisting saying my husband was a dear friend of his and what i'm doing right now would make my husband upset if he saw it. if your brother was such a dear friend of your husband, then he would've been there to assist you during your pregnancy, as the wife of his "dear friend" and help his nephew, the child if his late "dear friend", thrive through life with you. instead he thinks that his "dear friend's" child is a burden and didn't deserve to exist because a relationship with another man is more important and should've been your top priority, not the child you wanted to have. did you tell them that your brother wanted you to get rid of the grandson, cousin, etc. that they claim to love so much because another man would view him as baggage? you aren't robbing your son from receiving love from an uncle, you're protecting him from the toxicity that a so-called uncle would give him. what love could someone like him, who thinks children from a previous relationship are burdens to a new relationship, possibly give to your child? additionally, wtf tells someone else to abort a planned (assuming) pregnancy at the funeral of their spouse?! that's fucked up in every way! especially, when it's the funeral of your "dear friend"
nta your baby your choice. if he wanted to be a part of your kid’s life he could have acted right and offered you support - not told you to terminate because he personally finds single moms tiresome. fuck him
nta they guy didn't even bother to come apologize, but your supposed to instantly forgive the man who walked up to his grieving sister, at her husbands funeral, to tell her that if she did not abort her baby no man was ever going to want to date her. big ol fuck that. your not robbing your son of his relationship with his uncle, his uncle is robbing him of that relationship by being an asshole.
esh. his phrasing was bad, but his heart was coming from a position of caring about you. it's not a bad thing for him to be worried about you being pressured to continue the pregnancy. it's just not worth it to cut your brother completely out of the rest of your life over something like this.
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
ESH
0.013095
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my late husband passed away from a car accident when i was 4 months pregnant. it's been difficult without him but my family did so much to support me. i moved in with them month after. at the funeral, my older brother asked for a minute to talk then asked me if i really wanted to go through with my pregnancy . i was shocked when i heard this but even more shocked when he suggested that i "make the right decision, not an emotional decision and reconsider having my son". he gave many reasons why including the fact how "single/widowed mom" are considered too much of "baggage" for so many men to date. i lost it on him and kicked him out. that was the last time we saw each other. my son is now 3 weeks old. whole family met him and were happy to welcome him. my parents asked if i could let my brother come meet my son even for few hours. i refused but they said i was making a mistake robbing my son of a future loving relationship with his uncle. they asked that i don't let my emotions dictate a decision that might have a lasting impact but i said no. my extended family got involved and started pushing especially after my brother started insisting saying my husband was a dear friend of his and what i'm doing right now would make my husband upset if he saw it. am i being bitter and selfish?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my late husband passed away from a car accident when i was 4 months pregnant. it's been difficult without him but my family did so much to support me. i moved in with them month after. at the funeral, my older brother asked for a minute to talk then asked me if i really wanted to go through with my pregnancy . i was shocked when i heard this but even more shocked when he suggested that i "make the right decision, not an emotional decision and reconsider having my son". he gave many reasons why including the fact how "single/widowed mom" are considered too much of "baggage" for so many men to date. i lost it on him and kicked him out. that was the last time we saw each other. my son is now 3 weeks old. whole family met him and were happy to welcome him. my parents asked if i could let my brother come meet my son even for few hours. i refused but they said i was making a mistake robbing my son of a future loving relationship with his uncle. they asked that i don't let my emotions dictate a decision that might have a lasting impact but i said no. my extended family got involved and started pushing especially after my brother started insisting saying my husband was a dear friend of his and what i'm doing right now would make my husband upset if he saw it. am i being bitter and selfish? [/INST] nta, every time he says how much of a dear friend he was, remind him of that "talk" from his "dear" friends funeral. hell remind the whole damn family of it. </s>
AITA for making my SIL feel like shit about her weight?
35f and my sil is 46f. i have 3 children, the oldest being 16m. for my birthday last week my son went out and bought me this swinging hammock chair that i had been wanting for 2 years and it cost him quite a bit of his saved money (which i fully intend to put back in to his bank account so he can continue saving). he was so excited to see me open this gift and couldnt wait to help me set it up. i told him he shouldnt have, that it was a lot of money and his response was "you never get anything nice. i wanted you to have it." and it was true. i usually dont get anything for my birthday or christmases outside of tupperware or soaps. so it might sound stupid but i have cherished this swing ever since he got it for me, especially where i finally have something nice that's mine. my sil comes over once a week to see all of us and she immediately headed straight for my swing (which my son hooked up on our deck). i told her to please not sit on it and she said "is there a weight limit?" so i told her yes, 250lbs and i even showed her the box to confirm. she was not upset about this. she just said "that's a bummer, they need to make something capable of holding us big girls". i simply agreed with her and went about my business. at this point my husband shows up from work. when i went inside to grab us some drinks her and my husband are talking on the porch and not even 5 minutes later i hear a loud crash and my husband say "fuck, are you alright?" i go out and sure enough she had sat in my swing and the crochet netting around the hook snapped on one side, causing her to fall right on her ass. she is sitting there laughing, gets up and says "i guess i need to learn to listen." so i lost it. as i said above, i literally never get anything nice. never. this is the one thing that i had that was mine and it didnt even take someone a freaking week before they ruined it for me. so i said "i literally just fucking told you not even 20 minutes ago that it would not hold you and to please not fucking sit in it." she makes some comment about "usually the weight limit is a lie. i thought it would hold." so i said "the weight limit probably would have held if you were only 50lbs heavier than it, not 150." (she is 420ish lbs because she is one of those girls who eat food on camera for money and she absolutely loves her weight). but regardless, instead of apologizing or offering to compensate me for my destroyed item, she has resorted to saying i'm a shit bag for making her feel like her weight is a problem and my husband is on her side. "its just a fucking swing". aita?
26,767
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/vbay7f/aita_for_making_my_sil_feel_like_shit_about_her/
2022-06-13 12:22:12
nta tell your husband that he can buy you a new one because if it’s “just a fucking swing”
nta. your sil needs to compensate you for it. as well as apologize. she is heavy. she knows it. she deliberately sat in your swing even though she knew the weight limit was lower than her weight. as far as i'm concerned, she has pretty much broken it intentionally. also, any decent person gets embarrassed when they break something that doesn't belong to them, no matter how it happens. especially if the owner gets upset about it. instead she is playing the "you fat-shamed me" card to get out of the situation.
nta. she destroyed something special of yours and didn’t even apologize. i’m sure she’s very embarrassed but she *knew* the consequences of her actions and did it anyway. your husband sucks too.
nta but what kind of marriage do you have where you comment multiple times you have nothing that's yours and never get gifts aside from soap and tupperware? that honestly sounds terrible
nta. you weren't fat shaming her. she literally ignored and dismissed your warning about the weight limit on your cherished birthday present, and now she is 100% responsible for destroying it but refusing to take responsibility. you were simply holding her accountable for what she did, and you are absolutely entitled to be angry. she is the ah for this and your husband is an ah as well, for not supporting you.
nta. the swing could hold 250 lbs. she weighs 420. in this case, her weight *was* the problem. she knowingly demolished your property. she owes you a new swing, especially as it had sentimental value for you.
nta. "dear hubby, pay for the replacement and we can all laugh together. don't want to pay for the replacement for something you think is no big deal? then stand back and watch the fireworks."
nta her weight isn't the problem, it's her inability to listen and be respectful of other people and their things. also what the hell is your husband doing? your son noticed you don't have nice things, but has your husband? why is he okay with his sister breaking your gifts?
nta. many things for like construction and stuff will usually be able to hold double what is stated for safety reasons to guarantee it will hold the limit marked on it without strain e.g. if it says 5kg, it might be able to lift 10kg at a strain, but this makes it a guarantee that it can lift 5kg consistently without breaking or strain. your swing likely did have some ability to hold over 250lbs for safety reasons, but it is not a crane, no way was it going to be able to hold 170lbs over the stated limit. not fond of your husband here much either, it doesn't much seem like he values you or your possessions very much if you literally never get anything nice even though you have a husband and three kids??? your eldest son should not in fact, be the only one that thinks you deserve nice things.
nta, and tell your husband if he’s not going to hold her accountable for paying to replace it, *he* needs to find a way to cover the cost without that putting a crimp in any of *your* plans. she destroyed someone else’s brand-new possession. that *alone* should have her embarrassed and wanting to make amends. the fact she *went out of her way* to check whether there might be an issue with her using it, was told there might be, and did it anyway? i don’t know *where* she gets off thinking you’re not allowed to point out she’s being delusional in her refusal to take any responsibility whatsoever.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: 35f and my sil is 46f. i have 3 children, the oldest being 16m. for my birthday last week my son went out and bought me this swinging hammock chair that i had been wanting for 2 years and it cost him quite a bit of his saved money (which i fully intend to put back in to his bank account so he can continue saving). he was so excited to see me open this gift and couldnt wait to help me set it up. i told him he shouldnt have, that it was a lot of money and his response was "you never get anything nice. i wanted you to have it." and it was true. i usually dont get anything for my birthday or christmases outside of tupperware or soaps. so it might sound stupid but i have cherished this swing ever since he got it for me, especially where i finally have something nice that's mine. my sil comes over once a week to see all of us and she immediately headed straight for my swing (which my son hooked up on our deck). i told her to please not sit on it and she said "is there a weight limit?" so i told her yes, 250lbs and i even showed her the box to confirm. she was not upset about this. she just said "that's a bummer, they need to make something capable of holding us big girls". i simply agreed with her and went about my business. at this point my husband shows up from work. when i went inside to grab us some drinks her and my husband are talking on the porch and not even 5 minutes later i hear a loud crash and my husband say "fuck, are you alright?" i go out and sure enough she had sat in my swing and the crochet netting around the hook snapped on one side, causing her to fall right on her ass. she is sitting there laughing, gets up and says "i guess i need to learn to listen." so i lost it. as i said above, i literally never get anything nice. never. this is the one thing that i had that was mine and it didnt even take someone a freaking week before they ruined it for me. so i said "i literally just fucking told you not even 20 minutes ago that it would not hold you and to please not fucking sit in it." she makes some comment about "usually the weight limit is a lie. i thought it would hold." so i said "the weight limit probably would have held if you were only 50lbs heavier than it, not 150." (she is 420ish lbs because she is one of those girls who eat food on camera for money and she absolutely loves her weight). but regardless, instead of apologizing or offering to compensate me for my destroyed item, she has resorted to saying i'm a shit bag for making her feel like her weight is a problem and my husband is on her side. "its just a fucking swing". aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> 35f and my sil is 46f. i have 3 children, the oldest being 16m. for my birthday last week my son went out and bought me this swinging hammock chair that i had been wanting for 2 years and it cost him quite a bit of his saved money (which i fully intend to put back in to his bank account so he can continue saving). he was so excited to see me open this gift and couldnt wait to help me set it up. i told him he shouldnt have, that it was a lot of money and his response was "you never get anything nice. i wanted you to have it." and it was true. i usually dont get anything for my birthday or christmases outside of tupperware or soaps. so it might sound stupid but i have cherished this swing ever since he got it for me, especially where i finally have something nice that's mine. my sil comes over once a week to see all of us and she immediately headed straight for my swing (which my son hooked up on our deck). i told her to please not sit on it and she said "is there a weight limit?" so i told her yes, 250lbs and i even showed her the box to confirm. she was not upset about this. she just said "that's a bummer, they need to make something capable of holding us big girls". i simply agreed with her and went about my business. at this point my husband shows up from work. when i went inside to grab us some drinks her and my husband are talking on the porch and not even 5 minutes later i hear a loud crash and my husband say "fuck, are you alright?" i go out and sure enough she had sat in my swing and the crochet netting around the hook snapped on one side, causing her to fall right on her ass. she is sitting there laughing, gets up and says "i guess i need to learn to listen." so i lost it. as i said above, i literally never get anything nice. never. this is the one thing that i had that was mine and it didnt even take someone a freaking week before they ruined it for me. so i said "i literally just fucking told you not even 20 minutes ago that it would not hold you and to please not fucking sit in it." she makes some comment about "usually the weight limit is a lie. i thought it would hold." so i said "the weight limit probably would have held if you were only 50lbs heavier than it, not 150." (she is 420ish lbs because she is one of those girls who eat food on camera for money and she absolutely loves her weight). but regardless, instead of apologizing or offering to compensate me for my destroyed item, she has resorted to saying i'm a shit bag for making her feel like her weight is a problem and my husband is on her side. "its just a fucking swing". aita? [/INST] nta tell your husband that he can buy you a new one because if it’s “just a fucking swing” </s>
AITA for having a wedding and not disclosing we were already legally married?
about two months ago, my husband and i got “married” in a beautiful ceremony. it was so much fun. we went on a honeymoon after. the price tag makes me wheeze, but my parents were insistent on paying for 95% of it, saying it’s their only daughter’s wedding. as a result, the wedding was way more fancy than something my husband or i could afford! my husband and i paid the rest — his family did not contribute (which is fine!). the wedding was lovely, but missing one piece - the marriage license. about a year and a half ago, i was going through some serious health issues (the issues are resolved now, thankfully!). i had recently graduated from school and didn’t have health insurance. my husband and i decided to get married so i could join his health insurance. it was a quick justice of the peace ceremony. we were always planning to have a ceremony at some point in the future. a few months after that, he “proposed” (something i didn’t see coming!), the wedding occurred, and here we are today, planning for kids. very few people knew we got legally married about a year and a half ago. we weren’t trying to be deceptive. however, part of it was that i wasn’t comfortable revealing my health issues. my husband respected this. my parents knew about our legal marriage, but his mother did not. his mom (i’ll call her carol) and i aren’t close. she’s fine enough in low doses, but... we’re currently in the process of moving. this past weekend, his mother came to help us pack up things. as we were packing files (birth certificate, social security cards, etc.), somehow our marriage license must’ve slipped out. carol picked it up and kept insisting we need to frame it. and then she noticed the date. carol lost it. she insisted we lied to everyone. she said our wedding ceremony was just a “gift grab” (our wedding website stated that someone’s presence was gift enough— we still got many generous gifts and we are forever grateful). carol went and called her twin sister, my husband’s aunt, and the sister called and lashed out at us. she said we were sneaky and deceptive. she is saying she may want her gift back—something we are fine with giving her. for me and my husband, the legal wedding was just so i could get insurance. a means to an end. our wedding date is what we will celebrate. are we assholes for not being more upfront? i’ve been really upset and confused and waffle back and forth. my husband insists we are not assholes.
30,757
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/d9m02m/aita_for_having_a_wedding_and_not_disclosing_we/
2019-09-26 16:27:42
nta. there is a reason why you only take carol in small doses
nta also keep in mind that gifts are just that. once somebody gifts you something, sole ownership of that thing goes to you.
nta. also, your husband deserves an extra shout out for backing your decision. there's far, far too many feckless spouses out there who will side with "mommy and daddy" over their partner. and those partners deserve better.
i suspect she's just hurt she didn't know you'd already been married a year and a half. her son didn't tell her and i can see why she'd be upset. lots of people have ceremonies after they're already married, it's not uncommon. older people sometimes don't get legally married force variety of reasons (like benefits from a deceased spouse) and just have a commitment ceremony.
how is it a gift grab if you didn't have one a year and a half ago? like, if you'd done a real wedding back then, there would have been a reception anyway so... nta. but if you haven't found away to explain things to her, figure out a way to tell her while leaving the unwanted specifics out and have your husband explain the situation. you won't wanna be on your mil's bad side from the proverbial gate.
nta being legally married unlocks certain powers that can make life better. y'all did that and that was wise. the ceremony / reception is to celebrate the couple, and also a good way to see friends and relatives that aren't close by. the fact that y'all were legally married doesn't diminish the celebration. carol is being an asshole because she feels entitled to know every detail about you and her son, and her not knowing a socially irrelevant (but legally very relevant) detail wounds her little heart. this is a perfect application for the non-apology "i'm sorry you feel that way, but we made the right decision "
nta. i understand carol feeling hurt at her son not telling her he was married, but your health and legal relationship status are your business. nor should you be denied a big family affair just because your circumstances forced you to get a marriage license. she was way out of line.
nta. your husband probably should've told his mum, but carol sounds ridiculous. give her gift back &amp; be done with it.
nta. op, my boyfriend (i guess legally husband) and i did the exact same thing. i had some health issues and his insurance was excellent. so we got legally married and didn't really tell anyone. my parents are extremely judgmental and would not be okay with this so i just don't tell them. i keep them on an information diet anyway. to us, it's not a marriage, just another legal document. when we have the actual proposal, ring, ceremony, etc., that to us is the real wedding, a public declaration of our love and commitment. we don't even call each other husband and wife because we don't see it like that. don't let people on this thread tell you otherwise. you did what you did and it benefited you in the end, that's all that matters. btw, the healthcare i received saved my life without breaking my bank. sometimes a rarity in the us!
nah but people do get touchy about this and she's his mom, i can totally understand why she got upset not knowing you've actually been married almost 2 years ago.
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NAH
0.000485
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: about two months ago, my husband and i got “married” in a beautiful ceremony. it was so much fun. we went on a honeymoon after. the price tag makes me wheeze, but my parents were insistent on paying for 95% of it, saying it’s their only daughter’s wedding. as a result, the wedding was way more fancy than something my husband or i could afford! my husband and i paid the rest — his family did not contribute (which is fine!). the wedding was lovely, but missing one piece - the marriage license. about a year and a half ago, i was going through some serious health issues (the issues are resolved now, thankfully!). i had recently graduated from school and didn’t have health insurance. my husband and i decided to get married so i could join his health insurance. it was a quick justice of the peace ceremony. we were always planning to have a ceremony at some point in the future. a few months after that, he “proposed” (something i didn’t see coming!), the wedding occurred, and here we are today, planning for kids. very few people knew we got legally married about a year and a half ago. we weren’t trying to be deceptive. however, part of it was that i wasn’t comfortable revealing my health issues. my husband respected this. my parents knew about our legal marriage, but his mother did not. his mom (i’ll call her carol) and i aren’t close. she’s fine enough in low doses, but... we’re currently in the process of moving. this past weekend, his mother came to help us pack up things. as we were packing files (birth certificate, social security cards, etc.), somehow our marriage license must’ve slipped out. carol picked it up and kept insisting we need to frame it. and then she noticed the date. carol lost it. she insisted we lied to everyone. she said our wedding ceremony was just a “gift grab” (our wedding website stated that someone’s presence was gift enough— we still got many generous gifts and we are forever grateful). carol went and called her twin sister, my husband’s aunt, and the sister called and lashed out at us. she said we were sneaky and deceptive. she is saying she may want her gift back—something we are fine with giving her. for me and my husband, the legal wedding was just so i could get insurance. a means to an end. our wedding date is what we will celebrate. are we assholes for not being more upfront? i’ve been really upset and confused and waffle back and forth. my husband insists we are not assholes.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> about two months ago, my husband and i got “married” in a beautiful ceremony. it was so much fun. we went on a honeymoon after. the price tag makes me wheeze, but my parents were insistent on paying for 95% of it, saying it’s their only daughter’s wedding. as a result, the wedding was way more fancy than something my husband or i could afford! my husband and i paid the rest — his family did not contribute (which is fine!). the wedding was lovely, but missing one piece - the marriage license. about a year and a half ago, i was going through some serious health issues (the issues are resolved now, thankfully!). i had recently graduated from school and didn’t have health insurance. my husband and i decided to get married so i could join his health insurance. it was a quick justice of the peace ceremony. we were always planning to have a ceremony at some point in the future. a few months after that, he “proposed” (something i didn’t see coming!), the wedding occurred, and here we are today, planning for kids. very few people knew we got legally married about a year and a half ago. we weren’t trying to be deceptive. however, part of it was that i wasn’t comfortable revealing my health issues. my husband respected this. my parents knew about our legal marriage, but his mother did not. his mom (i’ll call her carol) and i aren’t close. she’s fine enough in low doses, but... we’re currently in the process of moving. this past weekend, his mother came to help us pack up things. as we were packing files (birth certificate, social security cards, etc.), somehow our marriage license must’ve slipped out. carol picked it up and kept insisting we need to frame it. and then she noticed the date. carol lost it. she insisted we lied to everyone. she said our wedding ceremony was just a “gift grab” (our wedding website stated that someone’s presence was gift enough— we still got many generous gifts and we are forever grateful). carol went and called her twin sister, my husband’s aunt, and the sister called and lashed out at us. she said we were sneaky and deceptive. she is saying she may want her gift back—something we are fine with giving her. for me and my husband, the legal wedding was just so i could get insurance. a means to an end. our wedding date is what we will celebrate. are we assholes for not being more upfront? i’ve been really upset and confused and waffle back and forth. my husband insists we are not assholes. [/INST] nta. there is a reason why you only take carol in small doses </s>
AITA for giving away my grandparents’ gift intended for my fiancé
every year, my grandparents give $300 to their single grandchildren and $500 to their married grandchildren, along with a note that says “to share with your spouse”. when opening up our gifts this year, i noticed my cousin, who had recently married his gay boyfriend, only received $300 while my fiancé and i received $500. i handed two hundreds from my envelope to my cousin in front of everyone, which caused quite the scene. my family is very religious and refuse to accept gay marriage as legitimate. they refuse to acknowledge his husband as a member of our family and tell him he is going to hell unless he changes his lifestyle. i defended my decision by saying, “we’re not married yet, and they are. i think there’s been a mistake”. conversations quickly devolved, resulting in both my cousin and i leaving shortly after. my family insights it was not my money to give and my actions disrespected both my grandparents and my fiancé. my fiancé feels my family was welcoming her, and i rejected her in front of everyone. aita?
27,708
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/klazu5/aita_for_giving_away_my_grandparents_gift/
2020-12-27 20:38:36
nta. your silence and acceptance of the money would have been complicit in your grandparent's homophobia. good for you. your fiancée needs to see the bigger picture.
nta. the money was a gift so it was yours to do whatever you wanted with. you made a point to your family and stuck up for your cousin’s relationship. good for you. maybe have a word with your fiancé to reiterate it wasn’t a message for her.
nta- you framed it perfectly for making it fit into their gifting rules. they're just mad that you called out their bigotry. keep up the good work!
nta - your family sucks...anyways you can just give 250 to your fiance and say that you gave money from your half to your cousin
info: did the resulting situation and early departure upset your cousin? would he have preferred to fly under the radar and enjoy the festivities and deal with it later? if the answer to the question is “no, it did not bother him.” then nta. that $500 was your money, to do whatever you want with. you can give it away, you can make a paper fan out of it, you can practice origami, you can spend it on anything. it was yours. and your family sounds like a bunch of bigots.
nta. you didn't reject your fiancée in front of everyone because, according to the note they said "share with your spouse." you don't have one yet. once you opened that envelop it *became* your money.
i don't think you're ta for giving your gift away. it was your money to do with what you want. i think you did an incredibly generous thing. also how you said "you think there's been a mistake" was a really nonconfrontational way to address the intended slight against your cousin and open dialogue. it really sucks your fiance felt disrespected or hurt. i can see how she would feel awkward when trying to fit in with your fam. i feel for her. at the same time, if i were the fiance i would feel proud of you for defending your cousin who was obviously slighted. i know those were two opposing statements. i don't think you could have seen that unintended consequence of giving your gift to your cousin. so in that situation i don't feel like you're ta. i'm really proud of you for doing a generous thing. it wasn't the easy thing, you did it anyway. side note, damn what the hell is gram and gramps doing that they can give 300 and 500 to their grandkids?!?!
nta, you are the 1 true ally your cousin has and i guarantee you, he will remember that act for decades to come. info: how the hell does your fiancé think your action was a rejection of her? rules are pretty clear: married couples get the $500. you not only aren’t married (yet), but you were also protecting your cousin and his husband from bigoted people. she should be backing your efforts, not disagreeing with them.
&gt;my fiancé feels my family was welcoming her, and i rejected her in front of everyone. ummmmmmmmm, you didn't reject her, you correctly stated you weren't married *yet*, and stood up for your cousin at the same time. i'd have some concerns about her feeling hurt in this situation, i'd be proud of you if it were me in her shoes. nta, but i think you're not getting cash from grandma anymore. maybe you can celebrate the holidays with cousin and spouse?
nta, once you give a gift, it doesn't belong to you anymore, so it was your money to dispense as you please. it's pretty obvious why you chose to dispense it that way, it sounds like your fiancee is scraping the barrel for a reason it make it about her and not your family's homophobia.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
INFO
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: every year, my grandparents give $300 to their single grandchildren and $500 to their married grandchildren, along with a note that says “to share with your spouse”. when opening up our gifts this year, i noticed my cousin, who had recently married his gay boyfriend, only received $300 while my fiancé and i received $500. i handed two hundreds from my envelope to my cousin in front of everyone, which caused quite the scene. my family is very religious and refuse to accept gay marriage as legitimate. they refuse to acknowledge his husband as a member of our family and tell him he is going to hell unless he changes his lifestyle. i defended my decision by saying, “we’re not married yet, and they are. i think there’s been a mistake”. conversations quickly devolved, resulting in both my cousin and i leaving shortly after. my family insights it was not my money to give and my actions disrespected both my grandparents and my fiancé. my fiancé feels my family was welcoming her, and i rejected her in front of everyone. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> every year, my grandparents give $300 to their single grandchildren and $500 to their married grandchildren, along with a note that says “to share with your spouse”. when opening up our gifts this year, i noticed my cousin, who had recently married his gay boyfriend, only received $300 while my fiancé and i received $500. i handed two hundreds from my envelope to my cousin in front of everyone, which caused quite the scene. my family is very religious and refuse to accept gay marriage as legitimate. they refuse to acknowledge his husband as a member of our family and tell him he is going to hell unless he changes his lifestyle. i defended my decision by saying, “we’re not married yet, and they are. i think there’s been a mistake”. conversations quickly devolved, resulting in both my cousin and i leaving shortly after. my family insights it was not my money to give and my actions disrespected both my grandparents and my fiancé. my fiancé feels my family was welcoming her, and i rejected her in front of everyone. aita? [/INST] nta. your silence and acceptance of the money would have been complicit in your grandparent's homophobia. good for you. your fiancée needs to see the bigger picture. </s>
AITA for asking my husband to stay with his family while he’s unemployed?
my husband (32) and i (30) have been married for just over a year now and things couldn’t be rockier. i have a good job and make a decent amount of money, whereas my husband made not as much as me. due to this, and the fact he was still living with his parents when we got married, we decided he would move in with me and i would continue to pay the rent and bills as long as he put money toward other things we may need as a couple. my name is the only one on the lease. however, once we got married, he started to cut down on his work hours without saying anything first. he gave the explanation that i made plenty of money for the both of us so he could just work part time and do the work around the house while i was the main breadwinner. i was fine with this, a little upset that he had just assumed this would be okay but i didn’t say anything as this felt fair. he did do some work around the house initially, but spent the majority of his time going out to the bar, playing video games, etc. to the point where i was the one both working *and* doing the cooking, cleaning and other household chores. my husband told me he was laid off two months ago for reasons out of his control. i assumed in this time that he would begin job hunting, and i began to pay for everything. while i do earn a decent amount of money, it’s not to the point where i can pay for rent, bills, groceries, insurance, contribute to emergency savings and finance the lifestyle my husband had started indulging in. i began paying for his nights out, subbing him money for trips to look for work, etc. all while i was under the assumption he would be searching for a new job. at least to finance his hobbies. about a week ago, i asked him how the job hunt was going and he told me that he didn’t feel like it was worth it. he said to me that he was comfortable with what we had now and i wasn’t happy to say the least. i confronted him about how i was doing everything to finance and take care of our household while he sat around and played video games (i was being an ass here, i’ll admit) and during this argument he let slip that he had actually quit and never looked for another job. i was furious that he had lied to me and told him i didn’t want him in my home right now. fast forward to now. my in-laws are understanding to an extent but are calling me an asshole for not wanting him to come back home until he gets a job. i have seen my husband in this time but never in our home, always out somewhere. i no longer pay for everything and his attitude toward me is making me question our entire relationship. he’s calling me an asshole for doing this to him, and i’m beginning to think he’s right. am i an asshole?
18,915
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/wr5rq7/aita_for_asking_my_husband_to_stay_with_his/
2022-08-18 01:09:29
nta good grief the amount of marinara here is ridiculous. 1. he cut down his hours w/o discussing it 2. he quit his job and lied about it 3. he spends his time partying with his buddies and having you foot the bill 4. he lied about job searching 5. he won't help keep up the household. sounds like only seeing him in passing is best. dont let him back into the house unless you just want a mooch, lazy, roommate that won't pay rent.
nta your husband is totally taking advantage of you. he didn't give you any choice in any of this--he just made decisions and forced you to go along with them. divorce him. he's literally dead weight and you're better off without him.
nta. don't cave. &gt;making me question our entire relationship. atta girl. keep questioning.
&gt;he’s calling me an asshole for doing this to him, ok but what does he call what he's doing to you? nta
nta. and to everyone who’s saying divorce isn’t the answer here, i strongly disagree. he lied to you about quitting in order to manipulate you into financing him fully. any adult knows you don’t make decisions like that without at least consulting your spouse. it’d be one thing if he quit and then told you right away. but he purposefully constructed a lie to guide you to acceptance of his desire to not work. he knew he should’ve discussed it with you, but chose manipulation instead. that is a dangerous foundation for a marriage. what else does / will he lie about to get his way? being passively controlling is still a removal of your free will. leave.
nta if the situations were reversed and he was here we'd be calling you a gold digger. divorce his ass before you end up stuck with him and his family for 18 years at minimum.
nta. lol at him saying he’s comfortable with how things are now. of course he’s comfortable. he’s not doing anything.
block the in-laws and contact a lawyer. they raised a dud and want you to take care of it. nta you deserve better.
nta oh shit you married my ex, how awful for you. no kidding, he pulled almost exactly this on me. except i never agreed to 'sure you work part time and do the house'. he just quit a job, lied about looking for one for a couple of months, and then gave up the pretence. when i pushed on him needing to find work because i wouldn't be financing us both past next month's deadline that he had agreed to two month ago, he kept pushing 'why i can't be a house husband? i do so much around here, i can look after the house and you can be the breadwinner, that's how it used to be in the old days for women, why not?' like dude you don't even cook, you don't clean up after dinner, you don't do laundry, like you maybe sweep now and then that's it, and this is a one bed apartment with no pets or kids that i could clean entirely in two hours, i don't want a housekeeper and no you don't just get my money for sitting on your ass scrolling the internet all day. i think you've absolutely handled this correctly. he can come back to the relationship when he shows he's not just leeching off it, and not before.
get a lawyer and protect your assets now! document everything. please tell me you had a prenup 🙏 i'm a firm believer in prenup for everyone, just tack it on the marriage license.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my husband (32) and i (30) have been married for just over a year now and things couldn’t be rockier. i have a good job and make a decent amount of money, whereas my husband made not as much as me. due to this, and the fact he was still living with his parents when we got married, we decided he would move in with me and i would continue to pay the rent and bills as long as he put money toward other things we may need as a couple. my name is the only one on the lease. however, once we got married, he started to cut down on his work hours without saying anything first. he gave the explanation that i made plenty of money for the both of us so he could just work part time and do the work around the house while i was the main breadwinner. i was fine with this, a little upset that he had just assumed this would be okay but i didn’t say anything as this felt fair. he did do some work around the house initially, but spent the majority of his time going out to the bar, playing video games, etc. to the point where i was the one both working *and* doing the cooking, cleaning and other household chores. my husband told me he was laid off two months ago for reasons out of his control. i assumed in this time that he would begin job hunting, and i began to pay for everything. while i do earn a decent amount of money, it’s not to the point where i can pay for rent, bills, groceries, insurance, contribute to emergency savings and finance the lifestyle my husband had started indulging in. i began paying for his nights out, subbing him money for trips to look for work, etc. all while i was under the assumption he would be searching for a new job. at least to finance his hobbies. about a week ago, i asked him how the job hunt was going and he told me that he didn’t feel like it was worth it. he said to me that he was comfortable with what we had now and i wasn’t happy to say the least. i confronted him about how i was doing everything to finance and take care of our household while he sat around and played video games (i was being an ass here, i’ll admit) and during this argument he let slip that he had actually quit and never looked for another job. i was furious that he had lied to me and told him i didn’t want him in my home right now. fast forward to now. my in-laws are understanding to an extent but are calling me an asshole for not wanting him to come back home until he gets a job. i have seen my husband in this time but never in our home, always out somewhere. i no longer pay for everything and his attitude toward me is making me question our entire relationship. he’s calling me an asshole for doing this to him, and i’m beginning to think he’s right. am i an asshole?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my husband (32) and i (30) have been married for just over a year now and things couldn’t be rockier. i have a good job and make a decent amount of money, whereas my husband made not as much as me. due to this, and the fact he was still living with his parents when we got married, we decided he would move in with me and i would continue to pay the rent and bills as long as he put money toward other things we may need as a couple. my name is the only one on the lease. however, once we got married, he started to cut down on his work hours without saying anything first. he gave the explanation that i made plenty of money for the both of us so he could just work part time and do the work around the house while i was the main breadwinner. i was fine with this, a little upset that he had just assumed this would be okay but i didn’t say anything as this felt fair. he did do some work around the house initially, but spent the majority of his time going out to the bar, playing video games, etc. to the point where i was the one both working *and* doing the cooking, cleaning and other household chores. my husband told me he was laid off two months ago for reasons out of his control. i assumed in this time that he would begin job hunting, and i began to pay for everything. while i do earn a decent amount of money, it’s not to the point where i can pay for rent, bills, groceries, insurance, contribute to emergency savings and finance the lifestyle my husband had started indulging in. i began paying for his nights out, subbing him money for trips to look for work, etc. all while i was under the assumption he would be searching for a new job. at least to finance his hobbies. about a week ago, i asked him how the job hunt was going and he told me that he didn’t feel like it was worth it. he said to me that he was comfortable with what we had now and i wasn’t happy to say the least. i confronted him about how i was doing everything to finance and take care of our household while he sat around and played video games (i was being an ass here, i’ll admit) and during this argument he let slip that he had actually quit and never looked for another job. i was furious that he had lied to me and told him i didn’t want him in my home right now. fast forward to now. my in-laws are understanding to an extent but are calling me an asshole for not wanting him to come back home until he gets a job. i have seen my husband in this time but never in our home, always out somewhere. i no longer pay for everything and his attitude toward me is making me question our entire relationship. he’s calling me an asshole for doing this to him, and i’m beginning to think he’s right. am i an asshole? [/INST] nta good grief the amount of marinara here is ridiculous. 1. he cut down his hours w/o discussing it 2. he quit his job and lied about it 3. he spends his time partying with his buddies and having you foot the bill 4. he lied about job searching 5. he won't help keep up the household. sounds like only seeing him in passing is best. dont let him back into the house unless you just want a mooch, lazy, roommate that won't pay rent. </s>
AITA for telling my sister-in-law she's not getting a dime of my brother's inheritance?
i have a brother and i am 15 years older than he is. our parents died when i was 21 and i took in my brother. the only proper thing my parents did was invest in real estate and left behind a will that left me and my brother half. however, i am the trustee of my brother's half until he is 35. my brother married at 22. he's 25 now. i don't like his wife. she's self-centered, a bitch, nasty and can't be nice. but my brother is in love with her. they are very open about never having children, which both saddens and relieves me at the same time. my brother also has some health issues as well. whenever my brother needed money and he did not have it (he works as a machinist) , he would have to ask me. i run his half of the inheritance. i sold all the real estate my parents owned and made a ton of money. i am very strict with what i approve, much to my brother's anger. i tell him i might his brother, but i am also the bank and banks just don't give money out. for example, he wanted to buy his wife a $25,000 necklace and i refused. $25,000 is a drop in the bucket, but that money isn't going to wasted on stuff like that. recently, he wanted to buy a nice house and asked for money. i told him that it was probably the smartest thing he's ever asked money for. it's a nice house and a good investment. it will give my brother a good project to work on. i said i would, but only if the house deed is in the name of the trust. he asked why. i told him because i didn't want his wife getting it if something should happen. he started up with his whole "it's my money" rant and i told him it is, but i control it for another 10 years. his wife ended calling me (i haven't spoken to her in years). she tried making the issue of the house as something for my brother. i told her that the trust is between me and my brother and it's none of her business. she has no claim to it. she asked what did she do to me that made me "hate" her. i said i didn't hate her, i just want to make sure she doesn't get any of the trust money. the idea of my brother getting ill and dying and all that money going to her makes me sick to my stomach. he lost both parents when he was 7, had health issues and has a massive trust. i am just doing everything i can legally do watch out for his best interests. i have not heard from them in 2 weeks.
5,337
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hi0o12/aita_for_telling_my_sisterinlaw_shes_not_getting/
2020-06-29 14:18:11
yta so, you've beocme the controlling parent now. i suppose as executor of the estate you have that right, but the cost seems high.
yta. he is an adult, and adults get to make decisions that other people disapprove of. you are using the money to control him, and from the way you talk, i suspect the reason you don’t like his wife is that she stands up to you. if you give a damn about your brother’s long-term financial health, set him up with a financial advisor who specializes in helping people lay out budgets and plan for the future. the way you are going now, the second he gets control of the trust , he will burn through the money and cut off all contact with you until he comes begging for yours.
yta - there’s a difference between helping him responsibly manage money and being vindictive because you don’t like his wife. it is his money ultimately, not yours. if i were in his position, i would want to know that my spouse was taken care of in the event of my death, and not shamelessly evicted and left homeless by my family. sure, he doesn’t need to buy 25k necklaces, but having the deed to his home in his own name is completely reasonable.
just remember that in 10 years time, it could be you have no brother anymore.
nta he will be thankful when he’s 35 and there’s still actual money left. he will be able to do whatever he wants with it while being more responsible than now. an inheritance should never go to the daughter or son in law. unless the parents specifically told you they wanted that. you can put the money in a house you both live if, but if you were to get divorced the money should go back to the original owner.
nah - as a psudo-parent and the person responsible for this money until he's 35, you're doing things exactly right. smart use of the money and not having control while he's young and growing up was your parent's plan, and it's a good one. he's in love and wants to take care of his wife. that's what he should want. you may think she sucks, but he's dedicated to his spouse. that's a good quality. your sil is right that you're controlling the money. it may be well-intentioned control, but it's still control. you need to set up something for the wife in case he dies. term life insurance is pretty cheap. she deserves at least that. you may also want to let him blow some money. not $15k necklaces, but he needs to learn to spend the money correctly if he's ever going to manage it well at 35. that will include some stupid, wasteful purchases. but better some small dumb spending vs him blowing it on his 35th birthday because he's never learned. teach him to handle money she give him some rope to learn and mess up now and learn.
reddit is stupid. nta by a mile. your brother is immature and will go bankrupt before he’s 35 if he ever controls the money. £25k for a necklace wtf it does sound like you’re a bit controlling but you wouldn’t have to be if your brother wants to make unwise decisions
your math doesn't make sense. if you're 15 years older than him, and your parents died when you were 21, then he would have been 6 years old at the time - not 10 years old as you later stated. i call bs
nta. i'm sorry but if he wanted to spend 25,000 on a necklace, then clearly he isn't responsible enough to handle his own trust. also for anyone saying that op is manipulative... sure, but his brother is willingly contributing to that. if i were his brother, i would just cut off op for a decade then get my trust after that. but he can't survive on his own even though he and his wife are both able-bodied adults which proves yet again, how irresponsible he is with money.
yta. your brother has cystic fibrosis, which has an average life expectancy of 37 years, and you are making him wait until 35 to be able to live with it!? what is the money being saved for - your account when he dies? he should be able to do everything he wants with his family unit (him and his wife) until the end.
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
NTA
NAH
NTA
null
NTA
YTA
0.834889
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i have a brother and i am 15 years older than he is. our parents died when i was 21 and i took in my brother. the only proper thing my parents did was invest in real estate and left behind a will that left me and my brother half. however, i am the trustee of my brother's half until he is 35. my brother married at 22. he's 25 now. i don't like his wife. she's self-centered, a bitch, nasty and can't be nice. but my brother is in love with her. they are very open about never having children, which both saddens and relieves me at the same time. my brother also has some health issues as well. whenever my brother needed money and he did not have it (he works as a machinist) , he would have to ask me. i run his half of the inheritance. i sold all the real estate my parents owned and made a ton of money. i am very strict with what i approve, much to my brother's anger. i tell him i might his brother, but i am also the bank and banks just don't give money out. for example, he wanted to buy his wife a $25,000 necklace and i refused. $25,000 is a drop in the bucket, but that money isn't going to wasted on stuff like that. recently, he wanted to buy a nice house and asked for money. i told him that it was probably the smartest thing he's ever asked money for. it's a nice house and a good investment. it will give my brother a good project to work on. i said i would, but only if the house deed is in the name of the trust. he asked why. i told him because i didn't want his wife getting it if something should happen. he started up with his whole "it's my money" rant and i told him it is, but i control it for another 10 years. his wife ended calling me (i haven't spoken to her in years). she tried making the issue of the house as something for my brother. i told her that the trust is between me and my brother and it's none of her business. she has no claim to it. she asked what did she do to me that made me "hate" her. i said i didn't hate her, i just want to make sure she doesn't get any of the trust money. the idea of my brother getting ill and dying and all that money going to her makes me sick to my stomach. he lost both parents when he was 7, had health issues and has a massive trust. i am just doing everything i can legally do watch out for his best interests. i have not heard from them in 2 weeks.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i have a brother and i am 15 years older than he is. our parents died when i was 21 and i took in my brother. the only proper thing my parents did was invest in real estate and left behind a will that left me and my brother half. however, i am the trustee of my brother's half until he is 35. my brother married at 22. he's 25 now. i don't like his wife. she's self-centered, a bitch, nasty and can't be nice. but my brother is in love with her. they are very open about never having children, which both saddens and relieves me at the same time. my brother also has some health issues as well. whenever my brother needed money and he did not have it (he works as a machinist) , he would have to ask me. i run his half of the inheritance. i sold all the real estate my parents owned and made a ton of money. i am very strict with what i approve, much to my brother's anger. i tell him i might his brother, but i am also the bank and banks just don't give money out. for example, he wanted to buy his wife a $25,000 necklace and i refused. $25,000 is a drop in the bucket, but that money isn't going to wasted on stuff like that. recently, he wanted to buy a nice house and asked for money. i told him that it was probably the smartest thing he's ever asked money for. it's a nice house and a good investment. it will give my brother a good project to work on. i said i would, but only if the house deed is in the name of the trust. he asked why. i told him because i didn't want his wife getting it if something should happen. he started up with his whole "it's my money" rant and i told him it is, but i control it for another 10 years. his wife ended calling me (i haven't spoken to her in years). she tried making the issue of the house as something for my brother. i told her that the trust is between me and my brother and it's none of her business. she has no claim to it. she asked what did she do to me that made me "hate" her. i said i didn't hate her, i just want to make sure she doesn't get any of the trust money. the idea of my brother getting ill and dying and all that money going to her makes me sick to my stomach. he lost both parents when he was 7, had health issues and has a massive trust. i am just doing everything i can legally do watch out for his best interests. i have not heard from them in 2 weeks. [/INST] yta so, you've beocme the controlling parent now. i suppose as executor of the estate you have that right, but the cost seems high. </s>
AITA for canceling my girlfriend's Blue Apron subscription?
so my girlfriend and i have been living together for a few months now, and in that time she has become really reliant on her blue apron subscription for most of our meals. i have told her multiple times that i don't like the food - it's not my style and i would prefer not to eat it, but i've forced myself several times to be polite. she's basically told me that it's not my choice what she chooses to eat, but she neglects to realize that even though it's her home, we're both living there now and sacrifices need to be made on both ends. i put up with her disgusting box of food for a few weeks, but i reached a point where i couldn't take it anymore, and frankly i was off-put by her laziness and reluctance to actually cook a meal. i took it upon myself to log onto her laptop and cancel the subscription - keep in mind, this was a decision that affected both of us, and she hasn't really seemed to care much for what i want. she assumed it was a technical error for a while until i informed her what i did, which sent her into total hysterics. i'm honestly tired of hearing her complain and i'm tired of her laziness, especially in a time when she's not the only person in the house. would you guys agree that i was at least justified to cancel the blue apron subscription, considering the circumstances? **tl;dr: canceled my girlfriend's food box subscription because she was being lazy about cooking and i don't like the meals, she hasn't been accommodating to me at all about it.**
3,504
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/gqff64/aita_for_canceling_my_girlfriends_blue_apron/
2020-05-25 17:40:32
yta. you were upset by her laziness, but you never bothered to make a meal yourself?
yta. you call her lazy for not cooking what you want? so, why don't you cook? it sounds like you're the one being lazy.
yta just make your own food. blue apron is a really helpful service and its her money anyway. that wasnt your call to make.
yta. why are you incapable of making your own meals?
yta. she’s cooking you dinner and you’re complaining about it? you’re a grown ass adult. cook your own damn food if you don’t like what she’s making in her house. how dare you go on her computer and cancel her subscription. i’d dump your ass
yta let me get this straight.. you move in to your girlfriends place. you assume she will do all the cooking because you are too lazy to learn, but eating together is important to you because of *your* family tradition - so you cancel her subscription for meals she likes, and cooks, via her laptop, without telling her- because they arent your style? and you call her lazy? you sound awful.
yta, and that's so incredibly disrespectful. she is taking the time to make a proper meal- that's why she gets blue apron instead of takeout, you selfish simpleton! apologize profusely, and i hope she leaves your controlling ass
yta. how are you ta? let me count the ways... you aren’t taking any responsibility for feeding yourself—if you don’t like the food, make your own damn meals. you opened her account without her permission and made changes to it. you lied by omission when you didn’t tell her immediately what you did, and you allowed her to believe that there was a problem with the company or their system. you don’t seem to respect her at all (see all the above information and throw in the “she’s lazy” insults). grow up, learn to feed yourself, and keep your paws off other people’s laptops and accounts. if you cannot do this, do everyone a favor and stay single until your adulting skills improve.
info: were you paying for the food or covering other expenses in exchange such that you were effectively paying for it? (if you are being expected to contribute to it and dislike it, n-t-a, you don’t have to pay for food you do not want, but if it’s just her subscription and her use of it doesn’t affect you financially, e.g., you aren’t covering other bills in exchange for her getting the food, y-t-a.)
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
INFO
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: so my girlfriend and i have been living together for a few months now, and in that time she has become really reliant on her blue apron subscription for most of our meals. i have told her multiple times that i don't like the food - it's not my style and i would prefer not to eat it, but i've forced myself several times to be polite. she's basically told me that it's not my choice what she chooses to eat, but she neglects to realize that even though it's her home, we're both living there now and sacrifices need to be made on both ends. i put up with her disgusting box of food for a few weeks, but i reached a point where i couldn't take it anymore, and frankly i was off-put by her laziness and reluctance to actually cook a meal. i took it upon myself to log onto her laptop and cancel the subscription - keep in mind, this was a decision that affected both of us, and she hasn't really seemed to care much for what i want. she assumed it was a technical error for a while until i informed her what i did, which sent her into total hysterics. i'm honestly tired of hearing her complain and i'm tired of her laziness, especially in a time when she's not the only person in the house. would you guys agree that i was at least justified to cancel the blue apron subscription, considering the circumstances? **tl;dr: canceled my girlfriend's food box subscription because she was being lazy about cooking and i don't like the meals, she hasn't been accommodating to me at all about it.**
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> so my girlfriend and i have been living together for a few months now, and in that time she has become really reliant on her blue apron subscription for most of our meals. i have told her multiple times that i don't like the food - it's not my style and i would prefer not to eat it, but i've forced myself several times to be polite. she's basically told me that it's not my choice what she chooses to eat, but she neglects to realize that even though it's her home, we're both living there now and sacrifices need to be made on both ends. i put up with her disgusting box of food for a few weeks, but i reached a point where i couldn't take it anymore, and frankly i was off-put by her laziness and reluctance to actually cook a meal. i took it upon myself to log onto her laptop and cancel the subscription - keep in mind, this was a decision that affected both of us, and she hasn't really seemed to care much for what i want. she assumed it was a technical error for a while until i informed her what i did, which sent her into total hysterics. i'm honestly tired of hearing her complain and i'm tired of her laziness, especially in a time when she's not the only person in the house. would you guys agree that i was at least justified to cancel the blue apron subscription, considering the circumstances? **tl;dr: canceled my girlfriend's food box subscription because she was being lazy about cooking and i don't like the meals, she hasn't been accommodating to me at all about it.** [/INST] yta. you were upset by her laziness, but you never bothered to make a meal yourself? </s>
AITA for sabotaging my little brother's food on purpose?
my little brother is 18. i'm 20. i am staying with my family for the holidays and thought it'd be a nice time but i forgot that they treat me like a housekeeper. i do almost all the chores and i don't mind if its my chore. obviously, if i notice the dishwashers full, i empty it. if i cook, i clean up. if i make a mess, i clean up. however, if my little brother makes a mess. he makes me clean up. if i refuse and tell him to do it himself, he tells my parents and they side with him and just bug me until i do it. my brother also asks me to cook for him. he pulls out brownie mix and is like "make this." i always am like: "sure, i can make it but you have to help." he gets mad and says "i helped by taking out the box!" and when i refused to make stuff for him or tell him to make it himself, he'll throw a fit and tell our parents. lately, he keeps asking me to make stuff and i get frustrated going back and forth about why can't he make shit himself or just ask our parents. so i make the food he asks, but i always add stuff he doesn't like. (coincidentally, he hates a ton of stuff i love to eat ) so if he asks for brownies and refuses to help, i put nuts in it. he hates them and i like them. he came over to see the brownies and got mad at me and told me he hated nuts and can't eat the brownies anymore. i just said, "too bad, make it yourself next time or help me and tell me not to put nuts in." i thought he'd learn his lesson to at least help but he keeps asking for stuff and i just keep putting stuff in that he doesn't like. he finally got fed up and said he's not eating because i keep making stuff with stuff he doesn't like. i just shrugged and told him to make his own food then. he told my parents of course and they just told me to stop being an asshole and make food for him. it was my last day at home so i just told them to make food for him if they're so concerned before i left. now my parents are upset with me and my brother is angry with me and i am wondering if i was too petty
22,752
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/khmocx/aita_for_sabotaging_my_little_brothers_food_on/
2020-12-21 18:11:50
nta, when i was reading i thought your brother was like 5 then i went back and realized he was **18**!???? thank god you're out of there
it sounds like your parents have really different standards for the two of you and much higher expectations on you - i'm guessing this is gender-based, though you didn't mention. anyway i think this is hilarious, and you should consider putting it in r/maliciouscompliance. your brother is legally an adult and certainly old enough to handle making a box of brownie mix, and he's way past the point where he can stand to learn that if he wants something done a certain way, he can do it himself. nta and well played.
i feel so, so sorry for the poor person who's going to end up with ops brother for a partner.
nta, he sounds like an idiot, why would you parents expect you to cater to him?
nta. reading the title i was thinking otherwise, because you just don’t fuck with someone’s food, but you are not the asshole at all. your brother is an entitled little brat who should be more than capable of making food for himself at his age. you know what’s in the food and so does he, he just chooses not to eat it. honestly you should make it a rule with your parents going forward that you will not coming to their house anymore unless they make it clear you will not be expected to cook for your brother.
nta- this is long, but relevant. i know what the future looks like for all of you if your parents don't put an end to your brother's crap now. i'm 38. my sister is 22. my parents treat her like yours do your little brother. when said sister was 11 i went to my parents for a visit. my dad asked me to clean my sisters room while i was there. this was a normal request that i had always obliged, but was sick of because she was old enough to do it herself. not to mention that they raised me with entirely different rules, and that shit wouldn't have flown with them when i was her age. so, i told him that if i did it i was going to bag everything up and put it in the store room in the garage. he must have thought i was joking and said ok. so i did it. that night i got a call from dad. he was pissed, but i explained that she was never going to learn if they didn't make her do it herself. i suggested a plan. for every week that she kept her room clean she got to open one bag. (there were seven bags total.) she would have to sort through the contents and throw out broken stuff and properly put away what she wanted to keep. if she kept up with that stuff for a week she could open another bag. you get the point i'm sure. it should have taken her just under two months to have all of her stuff back. fast forward five years, and my dad discovers the bags still in the store room. he opens them and calls my sister out there. she sees the contents and starts crying because her childhood toys are ruined. keep in mind that she is, at this point, way beyond playing with toys, especially the age range of toys in the bags. she didn't ever do anything to *earn* her stuff back and learn some responsibility. *she* let it sit there and rot. yet my dad still called me and yelled at me. he placed all of the blame on me for her stuff being ruined. she was never made to do anything. they just bought her new stuff and the bags in the garage store room were forgotten. somehow that is my fault, and it is still brought up regularly by both of them as an example of my carelessness and irresponsibility. are you as appalled as i am every time they bring it up? as i said, she is now 22. she is living at home, and still won't clean her room. her best friend has ocd and can't stand being in her room. when she does come over, about three times a year, my sisters room will finally get cleaned because the friend will have anxiety attacks. so the friend cleans it to avoid putting herself through the stress. in fact, i am currently at my parents about to shampoo the living room carpet behind the tv. why, you may want to know? because my sisters cat had kittens, she never litter trained them, and for two months they used behind the tv as their pee palace. my sister was supposed to do it, but she went christmas shopping with dad instead. i refuse to allow my toddler in here for christmas until it is cleaned. on top of that, our mom has her own anxiety issues, is bipolar and adjusting to new medicine. so, if i don't do it, it won't get done. this will be my families last christmas visiting their home for the holiday because now it will be expected that i clean for them to make it decent and safe for my little one. (she was already excited to come and i don't want to ruin her christmas. next year she will know well in advance to not look forward to visiting mere and pawpaw's house for the holidays.) your brother is going to end up just as lazy and entitled as my sister. my advice, put your foot down now. don't cater to him anymore. and make your parents read my comment so they can catch a glimpse in to the future if they don't make your brother grow the hell up. they'll have one kid that doesn't care about anyone but himself and another that refuses to set foot in their house.
nta and sounds like your parents are enabling your brother. don’t come over again until they agree to stop coddling him and know that he in no way is your grown son, he’s theirs . if they want to make food for him, they can. if he makes a mess - it’s their responsibility to clean it if he won’t.
info: are you female? is it sure sounds like he's the little prince and you're his servant.
my older brother once told me he bought a cake and said i could have some. it was in the kitchen and all i had to do was make it... fine, i'll bake you a cake. as the box is literally in my hand he said how cool it was that i could make a cake from scratch... then he was confused there was no frosting, cause the picture on the box had frosting and was shocked you have to buy frosting and cake separately. fortunately i can make frosting from scratch... but damn dude... you stupid.
this is where you get petty and go, "okay well i opened the box. your turn."
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
INFO
null
null
0.007141
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my little brother is 18. i'm 20. i am staying with my family for the holidays and thought it'd be a nice time but i forgot that they treat me like a housekeeper. i do almost all the chores and i don't mind if its my chore. obviously, if i notice the dishwashers full, i empty it. if i cook, i clean up. if i make a mess, i clean up. however, if my little brother makes a mess. he makes me clean up. if i refuse and tell him to do it himself, he tells my parents and they side with him and just bug me until i do it. my brother also asks me to cook for him. he pulls out brownie mix and is like "make this." i always am like: "sure, i can make it but you have to help." he gets mad and says "i helped by taking out the box!" and when i refused to make stuff for him or tell him to make it himself, he'll throw a fit and tell our parents. lately, he keeps asking me to make stuff and i get frustrated going back and forth about why can't he make shit himself or just ask our parents. so i make the food he asks, but i always add stuff he doesn't like. (coincidentally, he hates a ton of stuff i love to eat ) so if he asks for brownies and refuses to help, i put nuts in it. he hates them and i like them. he came over to see the brownies and got mad at me and told me he hated nuts and can't eat the brownies anymore. i just said, "too bad, make it yourself next time or help me and tell me not to put nuts in." i thought he'd learn his lesson to at least help but he keeps asking for stuff and i just keep putting stuff in that he doesn't like. he finally got fed up and said he's not eating because i keep making stuff with stuff he doesn't like. i just shrugged and told him to make his own food then. he told my parents of course and they just told me to stop being an asshole and make food for him. it was my last day at home so i just told them to make food for him if they're so concerned before i left. now my parents are upset with me and my brother is angry with me and i am wondering if i was too petty
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my little brother is 18. i'm 20. i am staying with my family for the holidays and thought it'd be a nice time but i forgot that they treat me like a housekeeper. i do almost all the chores and i don't mind if its my chore. obviously, if i notice the dishwashers full, i empty it. if i cook, i clean up. if i make a mess, i clean up. however, if my little brother makes a mess. he makes me clean up. if i refuse and tell him to do it himself, he tells my parents and they side with him and just bug me until i do it. my brother also asks me to cook for him. he pulls out brownie mix and is like "make this." i always am like: "sure, i can make it but you have to help." he gets mad and says "i helped by taking out the box!" and when i refused to make stuff for him or tell him to make it himself, he'll throw a fit and tell our parents. lately, he keeps asking me to make stuff and i get frustrated going back and forth about why can't he make shit himself or just ask our parents. so i make the food he asks, but i always add stuff he doesn't like. (coincidentally, he hates a ton of stuff i love to eat ) so if he asks for brownies and refuses to help, i put nuts in it. he hates them and i like them. he came over to see the brownies and got mad at me and told me he hated nuts and can't eat the brownies anymore. i just said, "too bad, make it yourself next time or help me and tell me not to put nuts in." i thought he'd learn his lesson to at least help but he keeps asking for stuff and i just keep putting stuff in that he doesn't like. he finally got fed up and said he's not eating because i keep making stuff with stuff he doesn't like. i just shrugged and told him to make his own food then. he told my parents of course and they just told me to stop being an asshole and make food for him. it was my last day at home so i just told them to make food for him if they're so concerned before i left. now my parents are upset with me and my brother is angry with me and i am wondering if i was too petty [/INST] nta, when i was reading i thought your brother was like 5 then i went back and realized he was **18**!???? thank god you're out of there </s>
AITA for confronting a worker who corrected me in front of my children?
yes this is a fake account and no i’m not using real names. here’s some background: i’m a single mom of two kids, emmi (6f) and oscar (8m). since they were very little i have lied to my children about needing “tickets” to play on the playground. i especially use this lie at the zoo and museums where admission is expensive and because as a single mother with a deadbeat ex i want my kids to get the full experience of what i paid for and not waste our time on something we can get for free at our neighborhood park. so today i took emmi and oscar to the zoo to enjoy the animals and to get out of the house. plus it’s all outdoors and i felt safe taking them there during covid restrictions. this is when the confrontation happened. we get to the ticket counter and oscar excitedly asks me about tickets for the playground. as i’m trying to tell oscar “no we didn’t get tickets for the playground this time, just the animals” the woman at the ticket counter tells my son “oh sweetie you don’t need a ticket for the playground, it’s free!” i could have died! i’m stomach sunk and i couldn’t help but glare at the woman. i reminded e and o we were here to see the animals but they were obviously excited and asked the lady if it’s true! she happily says “yes honey it’s always free” i told them we had to see all the animals first so we might not have time. plus with covid right now it wouldn’t be a good idea to play with the other kids. emmi asks if we can do the playground first instead and i replied “ nope i’m sorry it’s the rules” the woman looked at me confused. i payed $68 for one adult and 2 children’s tickets! thats a lot of money! you can see why i’d lie! so i buy the tickets and shoo my children ahead to sanitize their hands. now here’s the aita part. my kids are out of earshot and i turn to the woman and i sternly told her “do us all a favor and keep your mouth shut about the damn playground. i did not just pay you people almost $70 for something we can do for free at home. i paid to see the animals” the woman was visibly taken aback and and asked if something was wrong. i told her it’s fairly obvious that i was trying to avoid the playground. she told me she was only trying to help and i informed her that “if you were truly trying to help you should have gone along with me, the parent, and not address my kids directly and correct me in front of them. you’re going to cause a lot of headache for parents wanting to get their money’s worth” i called my mother afterward and she informed me i was an ass hole for telling the woman off for doing her job. maybe i was but i still think a worker should keep their mouth shut when it’s obvious a parent is trying to avoid something with their kids. aita?
3,786
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/k8rzcv/aita_for_confronting_a_worker_who_corrected_me_in/
2020-12-07 23:10:28
yta. the worker was just doing her job, it's not her fault you chose to lie to your children for whatever arbitrary reason.
this is very odd. you paid $70 for the zoo and are mad that the park is included in the price but won't let your children use it because you could get it for free at home? then take them to the regular park instead of spending so much for the zoo and don't get mad at the ticket lady who was just doing her job. yta
[deleted]
she was doing her job. you are absolutely the asshole. she cannot read minds and instantly know you lied to your children, told them that, and cover for you, while giving you the tickets. your mom is right. yta
yta. no, it wasn’t obvious why you were lying to your children. for all she knew, you could’ve misunderstood and thought the playground was an extra expense. also, it’s not anyone else’s job to play along with the lies you tell your kids just because you want to make it easier on yourself to tell them no. maybe learn how to say no instead of lying to your kids and expecting random strangers to magically know your intentions and play along.
yta- there is no way she could have known you decided to *lie* to your kids about a park (a *perk* that you also pay for with the $70) other than your nasty attitude afterwards. that is her job. she hypes kids and informs adults. they are 6 and 8, not 3! "can we go to the park?" "unfortunately, no. there's a bad virus going around and the park could make you sick. thankfully, we can still see the animals!" they are waaaaaay too old for you to be lying to them like that. how long were you planning on lying to them?
yta. pretty much everyone would have reacted exactly as the ticket counter woman did. who would ever think that a mom would lie to her kids about having to pay to go to the playground? no one. there was no clue that there was anything she was supposed to be "going along with." she was only being friendly and helpful to your kids. just tell your kids no.
yta this woman was not a mind reader, she had no way of knowing that you told your kids it cost money to play on a playground. it may seem obvious to you but it may not seem obvious to others. it is not common to lie to children about having to pay to go to a playground, so why on earth would she assume that's what you had done? really, they are six and eight years old, it was only a matter of time before they found out playgrounds are free. i had my kids convinced for a long time that the toy/candy vending machines at the grocery store were broken, but eventually another parent busted me by generously giving my kids quarters and showing them how they worked while i was paying for groceries.
yta. that lady doesn't get paid enough to deal with people like you. it's not her fault you've told your children some flimsy lie for years. how about just parenting up and telling your children that there's no time for the playground today? they're grade schoolers for pete's sake. they should be able to not throw a tantrum over not visiting a playground.
yta. this particular parenting practice (lying about “needing tickets”) is not something most (if any) parents do and it’s not reasonable to expect the woman to read your mind. that it seems “obvious” to you doesn’t mean it is to everyone. i mean, come on. that lie was going to catch up with you eventually one way or another.
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: yes this is a fake account and no i’m not using real names. here’s some background: i’m a single mom of two kids, emmi (6f) and oscar (8m). since they were very little i have lied to my children about needing “tickets” to play on the playground. i especially use this lie at the zoo and museums where admission is expensive and because as a single mother with a deadbeat ex i want my kids to get the full experience of what i paid for and not waste our time on something we can get for free at our neighborhood park. so today i took emmi and oscar to the zoo to enjoy the animals and to get out of the house. plus it’s all outdoors and i felt safe taking them there during covid restrictions. this is when the confrontation happened. we get to the ticket counter and oscar excitedly asks me about tickets for the playground. as i’m trying to tell oscar “no we didn’t get tickets for the playground this time, just the animals” the woman at the ticket counter tells my son “oh sweetie you don’t need a ticket for the playground, it’s free!” i could have died! i’m stomach sunk and i couldn’t help but glare at the woman. i reminded e and o we were here to see the animals but they were obviously excited and asked the lady if it’s true! she happily says “yes honey it’s always free” i told them we had to see all the animals first so we might not have time. plus with covid right now it wouldn’t be a good idea to play with the other kids. emmi asks if we can do the playground first instead and i replied “ nope i’m sorry it’s the rules” the woman looked at me confused. i payed $68 for one adult and 2 children’s tickets! thats a lot of money! you can see why i’d lie! so i buy the tickets and shoo my children ahead to sanitize their hands. now here’s the aita part. my kids are out of earshot and i turn to the woman and i sternly told her “do us all a favor and keep your mouth shut about the damn playground. i did not just pay you people almost $70 for something we can do for free at home. i paid to see the animals” the woman was visibly taken aback and and asked if something was wrong. i told her it’s fairly obvious that i was trying to avoid the playground. she told me she was only trying to help and i informed her that “if you were truly trying to help you should have gone along with me, the parent, and not address my kids directly and correct me in front of them. you’re going to cause a lot of headache for parents wanting to get their money’s worth” i called my mother afterward and she informed me i was an ass hole for telling the woman off for doing her job. maybe i was but i still think a worker should keep their mouth shut when it’s obvious a parent is trying to avoid something with their kids. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> yes this is a fake account and no i’m not using real names. here’s some background: i’m a single mom of two kids, emmi (6f) and oscar (8m). since they were very little i have lied to my children about needing “tickets” to play on the playground. i especially use this lie at the zoo and museums where admission is expensive and because as a single mother with a deadbeat ex i want my kids to get the full experience of what i paid for and not waste our time on something we can get for free at our neighborhood park. so today i took emmi and oscar to the zoo to enjoy the animals and to get out of the house. plus it’s all outdoors and i felt safe taking them there during covid restrictions. this is when the confrontation happened. we get to the ticket counter and oscar excitedly asks me about tickets for the playground. as i’m trying to tell oscar “no we didn’t get tickets for the playground this time, just the animals” the woman at the ticket counter tells my son “oh sweetie you don’t need a ticket for the playground, it’s free!” i could have died! i’m stomach sunk and i couldn’t help but glare at the woman. i reminded e and o we were here to see the animals but they were obviously excited and asked the lady if it’s true! she happily says “yes honey it’s always free” i told them we had to see all the animals first so we might not have time. plus with covid right now it wouldn’t be a good idea to play with the other kids. emmi asks if we can do the playground first instead and i replied “ nope i’m sorry it’s the rules” the woman looked at me confused. i payed $68 for one adult and 2 children’s tickets! thats a lot of money! you can see why i’d lie! so i buy the tickets and shoo my children ahead to sanitize their hands. now here’s the aita part. my kids are out of earshot and i turn to the woman and i sternly told her “do us all a favor and keep your mouth shut about the damn playground. i did not just pay you people almost $70 for something we can do for free at home. i paid to see the animals” the woman was visibly taken aback and and asked if something was wrong. i told her it’s fairly obvious that i was trying to avoid the playground. she told me she was only trying to help and i informed her that “if you were truly trying to help you should have gone along with me, the parent, and not address my kids directly and correct me in front of them. you’re going to cause a lot of headache for parents wanting to get their money’s worth” i called my mother afterward and she informed me i was an ass hole for telling the woman off for doing her job. maybe i was but i still think a worker should keep their mouth shut when it’s obvious a parent is trying to avoid something with their kids. aita? [/INST] yta. the worker was just doing her job, it's not her fault you chose to lie to your children for whatever arbitrary reason. </s>
AITA for telling my husband to stop disrespecting our surrogate?
me (f34), my husband hunter (m37) suffered from fertility problems, we recently decided to get a surrogate who's a friend of a friend. we were busy getting everything done legally, we already had a contract in place. my egg was used so no worries in this regard, plus our surrogate is a respectful, kind woman who's been keeping her part of the contract in tact, but it's hunter who's starting to act strange, i've noticed that he's been focusing his all attention on our surrogate like skipping work to visit her or get her things she didn't ask for, chat with her all the time on social media and also constantly offering to do things for her like .... drive her places and sometimes even invite her out or offer to repair stuff for her. she complained to me about this and even told me about things he's been doing that i didn't even know about, like bringing her gifts. i tried speaking to him about what this looks like but he said that he's doing what he's doing for his son and not her, still i asked that he tone it down and respect the woman's space. he got mad at me and accused me of being jealous of the woman who's carrying my own child and said that this makes me look bad. i said our surrogate was the one who complained about his behavior and he said that this wasn't true. apparently this made him somewhat angry so i gave him time to cool down a bit. yesterday, our surrogate called me saying that hunter came over and told her guests to leave, i asked why and she said that he wanted to show her the 9k car he bought for her. i was shocked, she said she declined the car and asked him to leave but he started arguing with her about using public transportation and risking our baby's wellbeing. i was fuming i called him demanding he get home and he did eventually. once he got back i picked up a fight with him and yelled at him saying that he's been nothing but overstepping, disrespectful, and inappropriate towards our surrogate, again he explained the car wasn't for her but to ensure that the baby is safe. i told him to stop disrespecting the woman and stop using the baby as an excuse to stomp all over her boundaries. he ranted about how he was just trying to make this work and that i should do the same if not more, he even accused me of not loving our son as much he does but this isn't the way and putting 9k for car without telling me? he left the house for a while then came back and refused to speak to me. i might've been hard on him, he might've just been oblivious so i'm less sure seeing his reaction now.
20,137
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/tjb2po/aita_for_telling_my_husband_to_stop_disrespecting/
2022-03-21 12:49:30
nta. this is upsetting behavior. it's one of two things: 1. he has a crush on her, or 2. he thinks he has a right to police pregnant womens' bodies it's inappropriate regardless. you should quietly assist her in getting an attorney to draft a cease and desist letter to him. you may or may not get the baby, but frankly i'm not sure your marriage (specifically just your husband and his odd behavior, none of your doing) is in a place to need a baby right now.
nta reading that creeped me out on a deep level. he sounds like a stalker that’s obsessed. does he not realise that stressing her out by being intense and domineering could harm the baby. he needs help and possibly a restraining order.
nta. he’s actually endangering the successful arrival of your son because he’s not only causing stress to your surrogate, he’s also making her so uncomfortable that she might seek legal recourse to break the contact. maybe schedule a formal meeting with lawyers and your surrogate so she can express her needs officially? that might be a way for your husband to actually see the severity of his behavior.
nta. have him seek therapy before baby is born.
nta. i’m concerned for your surrogate, you, and your son.
nta. stop being a go-between for your surrogate and husband though. i think she needs to talk to him directly (maybe with you also present in the room if she’s not comfortable alone with him), so he knows it’s coming from her. also do you guys share finances at all?? $9k is a lot to spend without even mentioning it to his wife!!
nta, and also yikes. (seriously, i hope this turns out to be the plot of a movie i didn’t catch and not something involving real-life people.) your surrogate needs a lawyer to figure out how to protect herself for the duration of this pregnancy, and hunter needs therapy to figure out why he thinks this is okay. and you probably need *both* those things separately yourself to figure out your path forward if he continues to act like this, because it does *not* bode well for how parenting as a team is going to go.
nta... but if i was your surrogate, i'd be demanding he either gets counseling or a restraining order. his behavior is highly irregular and inappropriate. he needs a third party to come in and say, this is not acceptable, because he won't listen to either of you. there's some sort of anxiety going on about this baby that needs to be dealt with... by causing the surrogate stress, he's indirectly affecting his own child negatively. maybe if explained to him that way he'll cool his jets.
whoa whoa whoa first off, nta that said, you gently brought up very reasonable boundaries and he didnt just continue to violate them, he like, stomped all over them as hard as he could. i feel sorry for you that you are having a baby with this person. i would seriously consider ending the relationship and talking to lawyer about what a healthy coparenting relationship might look like- this i s seriously that. bad. counseling at the very least. good god. this reads like a psychotic break dude. not being facetious. dead-ass psychotic. alarming. the surrogate could land a restraining order for crap of this startling magnitude. it throws your legal custody of this kid into actual jeopardy depending on the state. whatever you do about this you need to act *fast to protect your future custody of this kid. even i f that means legally separating from him and demonstrating that you are stable.* &amp;#x200b; editing to say: my mom was institutionalized most of my childhood. i do unfortunately have a lot of experience with breaks, and the cusp start of a bad episode would often look about like this. it looks different for different people. some breaks were hard and fast. others would start more slowly with erratic off the rails shit that looked a lot like this. in a day or so from this stage of unstable, cops would need to be involved to keep me safe from my mom. thats where *im* coming from anyway*. genuinely no disrespect intended by my use of the word psychotic break*, all im saying here is that this is enough of a departure from reality to scare the absolute hell out of me. my childhood was rough though, so; theres that.
nta, but man, red flags all over !!!! that left me very uneasy...
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: me (f34), my husband hunter (m37) suffered from fertility problems, we recently decided to get a surrogate who's a friend of a friend. we were busy getting everything done legally, we already had a contract in place. my egg was used so no worries in this regard, plus our surrogate is a respectful, kind woman who's been keeping her part of the contract in tact, but it's hunter who's starting to act strange, i've noticed that he's been focusing his all attention on our surrogate like skipping work to visit her or get her things she didn't ask for, chat with her all the time on social media and also constantly offering to do things for her like .... drive her places and sometimes even invite her out or offer to repair stuff for her. she complained to me about this and even told me about things he's been doing that i didn't even know about, like bringing her gifts. i tried speaking to him about what this looks like but he said that he's doing what he's doing for his son and not her, still i asked that he tone it down and respect the woman's space. he got mad at me and accused me of being jealous of the woman who's carrying my own child and said that this makes me look bad. i said our surrogate was the one who complained about his behavior and he said that this wasn't true. apparently this made him somewhat angry so i gave him time to cool down a bit. yesterday, our surrogate called me saying that hunter came over and told her guests to leave, i asked why and she said that he wanted to show her the 9k car he bought for her. i was shocked, she said she declined the car and asked him to leave but he started arguing with her about using public transportation and risking our baby's wellbeing. i was fuming i called him demanding he get home and he did eventually. once he got back i picked up a fight with him and yelled at him saying that he's been nothing but overstepping, disrespectful, and inappropriate towards our surrogate, again he explained the car wasn't for her but to ensure that the baby is safe. i told him to stop disrespecting the woman and stop using the baby as an excuse to stomp all over her boundaries. he ranted about how he was just trying to make this work and that i should do the same if not more, he even accused me of not loving our son as much he does but this isn't the way and putting 9k for car without telling me? he left the house for a while then came back and refused to speak to me. i might've been hard on him, he might've just been oblivious so i'm less sure seeing his reaction now.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> me (f34), my husband hunter (m37) suffered from fertility problems, we recently decided to get a surrogate who's a friend of a friend. we were busy getting everything done legally, we already had a contract in place. my egg was used so no worries in this regard, plus our surrogate is a respectful, kind woman who's been keeping her part of the contract in tact, but it's hunter who's starting to act strange, i've noticed that he's been focusing his all attention on our surrogate like skipping work to visit her or get her things she didn't ask for, chat with her all the time on social media and also constantly offering to do things for her like .... drive her places and sometimes even invite her out or offer to repair stuff for her. she complained to me about this and even told me about things he's been doing that i didn't even know about, like bringing her gifts. i tried speaking to him about what this looks like but he said that he's doing what he's doing for his son and not her, still i asked that he tone it down and respect the woman's space. he got mad at me and accused me of being jealous of the woman who's carrying my own child and said that this makes me look bad. i said our surrogate was the one who complained about his behavior and he said that this wasn't true. apparently this made him somewhat angry so i gave him time to cool down a bit. yesterday, our surrogate called me saying that hunter came over and told her guests to leave, i asked why and she said that he wanted to show her the 9k car he bought for her. i was shocked, she said she declined the car and asked him to leave but he started arguing with her about using public transportation and risking our baby's wellbeing. i was fuming i called him demanding he get home and he did eventually. once he got back i picked up a fight with him and yelled at him saying that he's been nothing but overstepping, disrespectful, and inappropriate towards our surrogate, again he explained the car wasn't for her but to ensure that the baby is safe. i told him to stop disrespecting the woman and stop using the baby as an excuse to stomp all over her boundaries. he ranted about how he was just trying to make this work and that i should do the same if not more, he even accused me of not loving our son as much he does but this isn't the way and putting 9k for car without telling me? he left the house for a while then came back and refused to speak to me. i might've been hard on him, he might've just been oblivious so i'm less sure seeing his reaction now. [/INST] nta. this is upsetting behavior. it's one of two things: 1. he has a crush on her, or 2. he thinks he has a right to police pregnant womens' bodies it's inappropriate regardless. you should quietly assist her in getting an attorney to draft a cease and desist letter to him. you may or may not get the baby, but frankly i'm not sure your marriage (specifically just your husband and his odd behavior, none of your doing) is in a place to need a baby right now. </s>
AITA for this prank I pulled on my gf?
girlfriend annie(23f) and me(36m), together 2 years. she is a phd student and i work as an accountant, so i support us both financially. no kids, we were trying but she has had health issues that cause it to not be a priority right now. this is relevant. the other day i called her while she was out to coffee with a friend. my intention for the phone call was to ask her what she'd be making for dinner but as it was ringing i had an idea for a prank. she answered and i put on a fake voice to tell her i was a doctor calling from the local hospital and i had some test results, asking if now was a good time to talk about them. she said yes so i made up some bullshit on the spot but she started crying like 2 minutes in to the conversation so of course i broke character and told her it was me. she started yelling at me which was embarrassing because i told my colleague what i was doing and she called me some really horrible names in front of him and completely disrespected me for what i thought was a harmless prank. she wasn't hurt, and my colleague tells me that it was a huge overreaction on her part. i admit it was a bit tasteless but it was a spur of the moment kind of thing and i feel like we all have those lapses of judgment sometimes. some of my friends are telling me that it was no big deal, but their girlfriends all say i'm a jerk and have backed up my girlfriend. she still hasn't come home and i think she's staying with a study buddy or something like that from her university and has barely spoken to me. &amp;#x200b;
4,775
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/mg895c/aita_for_this_prank_i_pulled_on_my_gf/
2021-03-30 04:53:05
yta. how is it that a 36 year old accountant thinks it’s appropriate or funny to call their 23 year old phd student girlfriend and “prank” them with serious news from a hospital? what part of this was she supposed to find funny?
&gt;
why is a phd student with such an immature ah? oh wait is she studying you? yta especially because you've not even been brave enough to detail what you said. or you are a very unimaginative troll who really needs to work on details in their sh!tposts.
yta. pro life tip: pranks are only funny if the victim laughs too. you were cruel. and also you suck for "trying" to impregnate a 23 year old student you aren't married to.
yta let's see. you terrorize your gf with supposed news from the doctor. how exactly is that funny? a lot of pranks suck, but this was just mean. obviously she was hurt, even though it didn't bother you any. so you're expectation is that because you thought it was harmless and fun and 'nobody got hurt,' she shouldn't be bothered. under that supposition, say someone pointed an unloaded gun at you that you thought was loaded and threatened to shoot you. suppose they thought that was funny, even though you're desperately afraid. and of course, no harm was actually done. the gun was unloaded. it's just a prank. you pointed a metaphorical gun at her and threatened her with some of her worst fears. did i say that was just mean? i mean it was mean and cruel. if i was her, i'd be seriously rethinking if you were someone who i wanted to be with since you could so casually commit such cruelty and not even know you were doing it.
yta. you're 36 and pulling this high school shit? grow the f up!
yta. phd student here with chronic illnesses and doc appointments. my husband **comforts** me when i get bad test results. you intentionally scared a stressed-out, probably feeling-crappy, woman who was *finally taking self-care time with a friend.* you knew all of this and decided it would be funny to ruin her relaxing time and make her fearful of new, bad results. you fucking suck. you have a lot to do to try and regain her trust. her health is never something to joke about. once you get another thousand people telling you yta, show her this thread as part of your apology. yikes.
yta this is so unbelievable that i cannot accept a reality in which someone would do this.
what in the world is a grown 36 year old man doing toying with a young woman's emotions like that? poor girl has health problems and probably already lives with fear over them. yet, you decided to take advantage of that for your own sick amusement. there is nothing wrong with a silly harmless prank in which nobody gets hurt, but you hurt her and made her cry in fear with your childish sense of "humor." so, the answer is yta! \*edited to fix a minor grammar error.
yta exactly what reaction were you hoping for when you called your girlfriend, pretending to be a doctor, and telling her she has some health issue? was she supposed to laugh? be grateful when you told her it was just her insensitive, asshole boyfriend playing a prank because you thought it was funny to terrorize her about her health? what was the goal here? the prank wasn’t ‘harmless’, dick. you terrorized your girlfriend for your own amusement and have the audacity to bitch about how she disrespected you because she didn’t appreciate your sick ‘sense of humor’? your colleague is a total idiot but if he/she finds your sick ‘humor’ funny than, perhaps you should date them. this wasn’t ’a bit tasteless’ or a ‘lapse in judgment’. it was beyond cruel to make your girlfriend believe you were a doctor giving her bad news about her test results. that’s really fucked up. i hope she stays with her study buddy and gives some serious thought to your entire relationship. clearly, you don’t give a damn about her feelings and are happy to manipulate them for your own amusement. dude, you’ve set the bar so low for acceptable behavior that she’d be infinitely better off with just about anyone else.
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: girlfriend annie(23f) and me(36m), together 2 years. she is a phd student and i work as an accountant, so i support us both financially. no kids, we were trying but she has had health issues that cause it to not be a priority right now. this is relevant. the other day i called her while she was out to coffee with a friend. my intention for the phone call was to ask her what she'd be making for dinner but as it was ringing i had an idea for a prank. she answered and i put on a fake voice to tell her i was a doctor calling from the local hospital and i had some test results, asking if now was a good time to talk about them. she said yes so i made up some bullshit on the spot but she started crying like 2 minutes in to the conversation so of course i broke character and told her it was me. she started yelling at me which was embarrassing because i told my colleague what i was doing and she called me some really horrible names in front of him and completely disrespected me for what i thought was a harmless prank. she wasn't hurt, and my colleague tells me that it was a huge overreaction on her part. i admit it was a bit tasteless but it was a spur of the moment kind of thing and i feel like we all have those lapses of judgment sometimes. some of my friends are telling me that it was no big deal, but their girlfriends all say i'm a jerk and have backed up my girlfriend. she still hasn't come home and i think she's staying with a study buddy or something like that from her university and has barely spoken to me. &amp;#x200b;
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> girlfriend annie(23f) and me(36m), together 2 years. she is a phd student and i work as an accountant, so i support us both financially. no kids, we were trying but she has had health issues that cause it to not be a priority right now. this is relevant. the other day i called her while she was out to coffee with a friend. my intention for the phone call was to ask her what she'd be making for dinner but as it was ringing i had an idea for a prank. she answered and i put on a fake voice to tell her i was a doctor calling from the local hospital and i had some test results, asking if now was a good time to talk about them. she said yes so i made up some bullshit on the spot but she started crying like 2 minutes in to the conversation so of course i broke character and told her it was me. she started yelling at me which was embarrassing because i told my colleague what i was doing and she called me some really horrible names in front of him and completely disrespected me for what i thought was a harmless prank. she wasn't hurt, and my colleague tells me that it was a huge overreaction on her part. i admit it was a bit tasteless but it was a spur of the moment kind of thing and i feel like we all have those lapses of judgment sometimes. some of my friends are telling me that it was no big deal, but their girlfriends all say i'm a jerk and have backed up my girlfriend. she still hasn't come home and i think she's staying with a study buddy or something like that from her university and has barely spoken to me. &amp;#x200b; [/INST] yta. how is it that a 36 year old accountant thinks it’s appropriate or funny to call their 23 year old phd student girlfriend and “prank” them with serious news from a hospital? what part of this was she supposed to find funny? </s>
AITA for dancing well at a wedding?
background: my sister and i have never gotten along. i don't know why, i wish i did so i could fix it but so it goes. i had invited her to come country dancing with me every time i was home, but she never wanted to go. my date for the wedding was my swing dance partner. we tore up the floor all night long. any time a country song was on, we'd go dance whether the dance floor was empty or full. we were having a blast which was great because i really didn't want to be there since my sister put my ex of 7 years in the bridal party (the groom didn't really know him at all and turns out he doesn't really like the groom). my dance partner asked my sister if she wanted to dance at least three times, she declined, and danced quite a few times with the maid of honor who doesn't swing dance, but can sure follow a lead and killed it! a few members of my family have told me that my dancing at the wedding was inappropriate and i should have toned it down. they have even gone so far as to tell me that i hired a professional dancer to be my date (he isn't... i met him jr year of college when we started dancing weekly together at a bar) so my question is, am i the asshole for dancing like i know how to dance or should i have dialed it back a but for the wedding?
14,887
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/cocpeh/aita_for_dancing_well_at_a_wedding/
2019-08-10 03:10:57
yta. it’s one thing to dance well at a wedding, as your title says, but completely out of bounds to do arials, as seen in your comments, on a dance floor. that’s not welcoming dance behavior, it’s intimidating. you may know what you’re doing, but other people may be worried about being hit by a leg or a stray shoe. that’s for professional dance events, not a wedding unless you’re specifically asked to do so. have a little common sense. oh wait, no, you were showing off at a wedding and making it about your great dance skills.
yta think of what it would look like if a nba player showed up at a neighborhood pickup game and played like a championship was at stake. would you be like, wow he is having a great time and looks so cool or would you be thinking, wow what a jerk - did he really just slam the ball away from that 15 year-old? the aerials and what not? over the top and too show offy for a wedding dance floor.
pal, you were doing ariels. that’s tooo much for a wedding that’s not yours. it’s good to have fun for a few songs, but doing stunts like that is not appropriate.
yta, unfortunately. i'm a professional ballroom dancer and my husband is my dance partner. we make it a point to never partner dance at a wedding (except ours and even that was low key) one time we started to do a few basic moves in the corner and my aunt immediately called us out on it. no one wants to see it and definitely no one wants to dodge legs/feet. sounds like you came prepared to show off (referencing the adidas shorts) and aerial's are a huge breach of etiquette on a social dance floor. it's frustrating to know how to dance but not show it, but time and place. that was neither imo.
likely yta. maybe nah. weddings are meant to be danced at, but the bride and groom are also meant to be the center of attention. it sounds like you might have lacked a little self awareness, but someone could've approached you during the evening if your behavior was an issue. maybe your dress flew up and you it was a bit risqué? either way, if i had a problem, especially if it was my sister, i would have sent my mom to ask you to tone it down and if you didn't respect that then you would definitely be ta. it also seems like you acted out of bitterness a bit. your relationship with your sister or your dissatisfaction with the groomsmen have nothing to do with the dancing issue. it comes across that you wanted to show her up.
yta, dancing so wildly that you need shorts under your dress in case you flash the other guests and doing stunts etc is not appropriate at a wedding, unless other people do it too and it’s ‘normal’. there is dancing and there is giving a show. you did the latter.
doing anything at some else's wedding that calls attention to yourself is kinda a dick move. im leaning towards yta. have fun when it's not making others uncomfortable.
info: did he lift you off the ground at any point?
yta. it's your responsibility not to be distracting at a wedding. this dictates what you wear, how you behave, etc. i might have rounded this up to participating-not-trying-to-distract if it was not for the fact that your post makes you sound like an asshole. a *few* family members confronted you about this? when three people tell you you're an asshole, you're probably an asshole.
yta, it's your sister's day and you made yourself the center of attention but far from that, thank you for posting an aita that actually warrants a response
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
0.00388
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: background: my sister and i have never gotten along. i don't know why, i wish i did so i could fix it but so it goes. i had invited her to come country dancing with me every time i was home, but she never wanted to go. my date for the wedding was my swing dance partner. we tore up the floor all night long. any time a country song was on, we'd go dance whether the dance floor was empty or full. we were having a blast which was great because i really didn't want to be there since my sister put my ex of 7 years in the bridal party (the groom didn't really know him at all and turns out he doesn't really like the groom). my dance partner asked my sister if she wanted to dance at least three times, she declined, and danced quite a few times with the maid of honor who doesn't swing dance, but can sure follow a lead and killed it! a few members of my family have told me that my dancing at the wedding was inappropriate and i should have toned it down. they have even gone so far as to tell me that i hired a professional dancer to be my date (he isn't... i met him jr year of college when we started dancing weekly together at a bar) so my question is, am i the asshole for dancing like i know how to dance or should i have dialed it back a but for the wedding?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> background: my sister and i have never gotten along. i don't know why, i wish i did so i could fix it but so it goes. i had invited her to come country dancing with me every time i was home, but she never wanted to go. my date for the wedding was my swing dance partner. we tore up the floor all night long. any time a country song was on, we'd go dance whether the dance floor was empty or full. we were having a blast which was great because i really didn't want to be there since my sister put my ex of 7 years in the bridal party (the groom didn't really know him at all and turns out he doesn't really like the groom). my dance partner asked my sister if she wanted to dance at least three times, she declined, and danced quite a few times with the maid of honor who doesn't swing dance, but can sure follow a lead and killed it! a few members of my family have told me that my dancing at the wedding was inappropriate and i should have toned it down. they have even gone so far as to tell me that i hired a professional dancer to be my date (he isn't... i met him jr year of college when we started dancing weekly together at a bar) so my question is, am i the asshole for dancing like i know how to dance or should i have dialed it back a but for the wedding? [/INST] yta. it’s one thing to dance well at a wedding, as your title says, but completely out of bounds to do arials, as seen in your comments, on a dance floor. that’s not welcoming dance behavior, it’s intimidating. you may know what you’re doing, but other people may be worried about being hit by a leg or a stray shoe. that’s for professional dance events, not a wedding unless you’re specifically asked to do so. have a little common sense. oh wait, no, you were showing off at a wedding and making it about your great dance skills. </s>
AITA for walking out on date night after my BF got me a bikini instead of a purse?
throwaway...me (25f) and my bf "seth" (28m) have been together for 2 years. yesterday we went out for date night, and we decided to go hang out at the mall before going to dinner. while we were there, i came across an adorable purse that i loved. before i could say anything, seth looked at the price tag and said, "woah! $40.00? that's way too expensive, so don't get any ideas, haha." i was kinda bummed, but i chuckled and told him i agree, it is too expensive. shortly after this, i had to rush into the bathroom, and i was in there for about 20 minutes. after i came back, seth said that he had a surprise to show me at dinner. i was excited, because i figured he must've bought me something, maybe even the purse. after we arrived at the restaurant, seth grabbed his backpack and told me to close my eyes. after i opened my eyes, seth was holding up a hot pink bikini from the mall. at first i was confused, then i asked him how much it cost, and he told me $45.00! i then asked him how could he buy something that costs more then the purse i saw? he said, "i know, but i saw this bikini and i just couldn't say no. it's just so you, babe!" i don't know what came over me, but i felt so hurt and insulted in that moment. when it's something i want, it's too expensive, but when it's something he wants, price isn't a problem. i don't even wear bikinis, i've never once worn a bikini, so that made the gift even more weird. i put the bikini back in his backpack, got up, and drove home. he's furious with me, called me a spoiled brat, and said that i was being petty. aita?
18,730
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ow5cd5/aita_for_walking_out_on_date_night_after_my_bf/
2021-08-02 02:06:52
nta that bikini wasn’t a gift for you at all, it was entirely for himself that he expected you to go along with because he called it a *gift*. he is mad because you didn’t give him credit for his thoughtless “gift” that after 2 years together, he should have known wasn’t something you’d like. he’s calling you a petty spoiled brat for not appreciating his selfish attempt to make you a model for his gift to himself. **buy yourself the purse and tell him ***he*** can wear the bikini.**
it's the thought that counts. and in this case it seems he was thinking of himself. so nta.
nta. what's the difference between the purse and bikini (besides $5)? one makes his dick go up. the other doesn't. he bought the gift for him, not you. he needs to get his $&amp;#) together. &amp;#x200b;
nta not only is it something he wants, it's objectifying. you are not a spoiled brat. you have standards. you deserve someone who will treat you better.
nta this wasn't a gift for you. this was something he bought basically for himself, he wants you to wear it for his viewing pleasure
nta. he's ta for name calling after being a crappy gift giver. **go to the mall and buy yourself that purse!**
nta it's not even about the price, he bought you something you'd never wear. the fact he knows that is even more messed up. he likely wanted you to wear it for him which makes it a gift for him, not you. i'm sorry dude.
nta - his “gift” wasn’t for you, it was for him. he wanted to see you in a sexy bikini.
nta, take off the glasses rose glasses and look at the flags. it will save you heart ache.
oh, look. another post, another boyfriend that needs to be shown the door. reddit makes me grateful af that i'm asexual. the bikini wasn't for you. it was for his dick. buy yourself the nice ass purse, dump the douche. nta
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: throwaway...me (25f) and my bf "seth" (28m) have been together for 2 years. yesterday we went out for date night, and we decided to go hang out at the mall before going to dinner. while we were there, i came across an adorable purse that i loved. before i could say anything, seth looked at the price tag and said, "woah! $40.00? that's way too expensive, so don't get any ideas, haha." i was kinda bummed, but i chuckled and told him i agree, it is too expensive. shortly after this, i had to rush into the bathroom, and i was in there for about 20 minutes. after i came back, seth said that he had a surprise to show me at dinner. i was excited, because i figured he must've bought me something, maybe even the purse. after we arrived at the restaurant, seth grabbed his backpack and told me to close my eyes. after i opened my eyes, seth was holding up a hot pink bikini from the mall. at first i was confused, then i asked him how much it cost, and he told me $45.00! i then asked him how could he buy something that costs more then the purse i saw? he said, "i know, but i saw this bikini and i just couldn't say no. it's just so you, babe!" i don't know what came over me, but i felt so hurt and insulted in that moment. when it's something i want, it's too expensive, but when it's something he wants, price isn't a problem. i don't even wear bikinis, i've never once worn a bikini, so that made the gift even more weird. i put the bikini back in his backpack, got up, and drove home. he's furious with me, called me a spoiled brat, and said that i was being petty. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> throwaway...me (25f) and my bf "seth" (28m) have been together for 2 years. yesterday we went out for date night, and we decided to go hang out at the mall before going to dinner. while we were there, i came across an adorable purse that i loved. before i could say anything, seth looked at the price tag and said, "woah! $40.00? that's way too expensive, so don't get any ideas, haha." i was kinda bummed, but i chuckled and told him i agree, it is too expensive. shortly after this, i had to rush into the bathroom, and i was in there for about 20 minutes. after i came back, seth said that he had a surprise to show me at dinner. i was excited, because i figured he must've bought me something, maybe even the purse. after we arrived at the restaurant, seth grabbed his backpack and told me to close my eyes. after i opened my eyes, seth was holding up a hot pink bikini from the mall. at first i was confused, then i asked him how much it cost, and he told me $45.00! i then asked him how could he buy something that costs more then the purse i saw? he said, "i know, but i saw this bikini and i just couldn't say no. it's just so you, babe!" i don't know what came over me, but i felt so hurt and insulted in that moment. when it's something i want, it's too expensive, but when it's something he wants, price isn't a problem. i don't even wear bikinis, i've never once worn a bikini, so that made the gift even more weird. i put the bikini back in his backpack, got up, and drove home. he's furious with me, called me a spoiled brat, and said that i was being petty. aita? [/INST] nta that bikini wasn’t a gift for you at all, it was entirely for himself that he expected you to go along with because he called it a *gift*. he is mad because you didn’t give him credit for his thoughtless “gift” that after 2 years together, he should have known wasn’t something you’d like. he’s calling you a petty spoiled brat for not appreciating his selfish attempt to make you a model for his gift to himself. **buy yourself the purse and tell him ***he*** can wear the bikini.** </s>
AITA for telling my sister I didn't appreciate her leaving her baby with us, when we were about to leave, to go to the bathroom?
throwaway, i'm 25 and sara's 28. me and my sister 'sara' are on good terms, but we aren't close by any means. we see each other during family events and things like that, and text occasionally but that's about it. one of my cousin's kids turned 1, so a few days ago they had a birthday party and invited friends and family. sara has a 3 month old daughter and sara was at the party. she came later and we chatted a little bit. so everyone was starting to leave, me and my husband 'alex' were also about to leave when sara came up to me and asked if i could keep an eye on my niece for a few minutes while she ran to the bathroom. now, i want to add i don't have an issue with this specifically, my problem was that she saw that we were about to go, yet she left without waiting for our answer. after she came back, i told her that i didn't really appreciate her leaving like that without even waiting for an answer. i said that there were still a few other people around she could've asked, who weren't leaving. sara replied that she didn't really think it through and saw me, so she came to me. this isn't the first time sara's pulled things like this, not with me particularly but with our parents, who bend over backwards to do favors for her. i do understand the situation and her circumstances, now with an infant, but there's a limit. i told her i get it but maybe she should 'think things through' for once. she started crying and said she's very overwhelmed. we ended up leaving after that and i do feel kind of bad for what i said to her, but i don't think it warranted crying. alex agrees with me that sara was overreacting a little bit, so aita?
5,686
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/xwsyo4/aita_for_telling_my_sister_i_didnt_appreciate_her/
2022-10-06 01:53:29
yta jesus christ i bet it took you longer to write this out than it did to just wait for her to pee.
yta. your sister. with a 3 month told. asked you. to watch your niece. so she could pee. unless you were on your way to perform life saving surgery, you can watch your niece for 2 minutes while she pees. you realize this is probably the first time in a while she’s been able to pee without an audience? she’s 3 months pp. she’s still healing. not sleeping well. body is a mess and hormones are still running crazy. so yes. again yta.
are you serious bro????!!!!! yes yta. she went to use the bathroom for a few minutes, she didn’t even leave the house. did staying a few extra minutes really hurt you? just admit you really don’t like your sister and everything she does annoys you. just say that.
yta. do you have a habit of making big deals out of little inconveniences ? she is three months postpartum give the woman a break and let her wee in peace ! look her hormones are wacky , her pelvic floor is probably a mess. when she said she had to go believe me she had to go.
you really had to criticise her for asking her sister for a quick favour so she could go to the toilet... and then having a go at her, your sister with three month old, likely sleep deprived, crying because you criticised her? for asking for help that took only a few minutes? are you serious? hard yta
how. dare. she? imagine the audacity of thinking that *your own sister* would be willing to watch your kid for 3 minutes while you used the bathroom. three. whole. minutes? obviously, sister needs to start wearing adult diapers because that was totally unreasonable. **yta**. and i bet your sister is tired of being judged and condescended to by you. maybe you could try to have some empathy for 3 minutes next time. although, if i were your sister, i would never ask you for anything ever again -- not even to even pass me a tissue. god, you were so horrible.
i understand why you two aren’t close and it’s not her fault. you sound cold and jealous.
yta how long did it take for you sister to use the restroom? was it really a huge inconvenience to you to wait a couple of minutes? it seems a rather petty thing to blow out of proportion.
yta. it cost you what 2 minutes. yes, she should have waited for an answer, but in the grand scheme of things this isn't that big deal.
tbh this is a pretty ridiculous reason to get upset and make someone cry. yta not sure why this was such a big deal to you.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: throwaway, i'm 25 and sara's 28. me and my sister 'sara' are on good terms, but we aren't close by any means. we see each other during family events and things like that, and text occasionally but that's about it. one of my cousin's kids turned 1, so a few days ago they had a birthday party and invited friends and family. sara has a 3 month old daughter and sara was at the party. she came later and we chatted a little bit. so everyone was starting to leave, me and my husband 'alex' were also about to leave when sara came up to me and asked if i could keep an eye on my niece for a few minutes while she ran to the bathroom. now, i want to add i don't have an issue with this specifically, my problem was that she saw that we were about to go, yet she left without waiting for our answer. after she came back, i told her that i didn't really appreciate her leaving like that without even waiting for an answer. i said that there were still a few other people around she could've asked, who weren't leaving. sara replied that she didn't really think it through and saw me, so she came to me. this isn't the first time sara's pulled things like this, not with me particularly but with our parents, who bend over backwards to do favors for her. i do understand the situation and her circumstances, now with an infant, but there's a limit. i told her i get it but maybe she should 'think things through' for once. she started crying and said she's very overwhelmed. we ended up leaving after that and i do feel kind of bad for what i said to her, but i don't think it warranted crying. alex agrees with me that sara was overreacting a little bit, so aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> throwaway, i'm 25 and sara's 28. me and my sister 'sara' are on good terms, but we aren't close by any means. we see each other during family events and things like that, and text occasionally but that's about it. one of my cousin's kids turned 1, so a few days ago they had a birthday party and invited friends and family. sara has a 3 month old daughter and sara was at the party. she came later and we chatted a little bit. so everyone was starting to leave, me and my husband 'alex' were also about to leave when sara came up to me and asked if i could keep an eye on my niece for a few minutes while she ran to the bathroom. now, i want to add i don't have an issue with this specifically, my problem was that she saw that we were about to go, yet she left without waiting for our answer. after she came back, i told her that i didn't really appreciate her leaving like that without even waiting for an answer. i said that there were still a few other people around she could've asked, who weren't leaving. sara replied that she didn't really think it through and saw me, so she came to me. this isn't the first time sara's pulled things like this, not with me particularly but with our parents, who bend over backwards to do favors for her. i do understand the situation and her circumstances, now with an infant, but there's a limit. i told her i get it but maybe she should 'think things through' for once. she started crying and said she's very overwhelmed. we ended up leaving after that and i do feel kind of bad for what i said to her, but i don't think it warranted crying. alex agrees with me that sara was overreacting a little bit, so aita? [/INST] yta jesus christ i bet it took you longer to write this out than it did to just wait for her to pee. </s>
AITA for buying a $50,000 guitar for $4,000 and refusing to sell it back when the buyer found out the real value?
this happened a while back. my wife and i still talk about it every once in a while. she's on my side and most of our friends and family are. however when it happened it was like ww3 between us and her co-workers and others. here we go...i've been playing the guitar for 22 years. i know guitar values and whatnot very well. i'm very into the guitar market. at my wife's old company she was hanging out with co-workers one day after work and she mentioned that i play guitar. a co-worker who i guess is very popular at work said that his dad passed away and he was selling his dads things. his dad had a guitar and asked my wife if i'd be interested in it. my wife texted me and i said to have him send me the info on the guitar and the price. the next day he texted me the pics and price. it was a 1952 telecaster in mint condition. he had the original receipts which was crazy! (that's how i knew the date). i asked what he wanted for it and he said he "looked up telecasters online and he thinks $4,000 is fair". i texted back, "i'll take it for $4,000" and went to pick it up. the guitar had no sentimental value to him at all. here's the issue at hand. the guitar was/is worth approximately $50,000 depending on the buyer and i knew it. when i got the guitar i told my wife the price and what it was worth. she was floored. fast forward two weeks her co-worker tells my wife he just found out what the guitar was actually worth from a family friend and wanted it back. she said, "well he really likes the guitar and he knew it was worth $50,000 which is why he was floored you offered it to him for $4,000. he really likes it and i doubt he will sell it back, but you can ask." (probably not the smartest thing for her to say, but she was caught off guard and it's not her fault or problem). he contacted me and asked to buy it back. i said that it's not for sale. he then said i scammed him and he was going to "sue me and take my wife to hr for being a part of the scam." which was nuts, but he actually did contact hr. they were cool about it and said it's not their problem. it's between him and me. over the next few months he made things very uncomfortable for my wife at work. he would bug her constantly about it. she eventually had to go to hr for harassment and they actually let him go (she complained twice and he was warned and didn't stop). he's contacted me several times about it so i got a restraining order for harassment too. i blocked him too. i haven't heard from him in about a year. aita?
26,700
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ftum7d/aita_for_buying_a_50000_guitar_for_4000_and/
2020-04-02 21:08:51
nta. when you sell something it is your responsibility to know or determine what its worth not the person you are selling to.
esh. you blatantly took advantage of him and his ignorance. he sucks because he didn’t research it enough, and then harassed you and your wife to the point it got him fired. just a whole messy situation. i don’t think you should sell it back to him. you paid a price he gave you (bad on him). you just seriously took advantage of him (bad on you).
esh. harassing you and your wife is not okay whatsoever regardless of circumstance. but let's be real, you did prey on his ignorance and took advantage of it, which makes you suck, too. harsh lesson for the guy (double whammy in losing something of value and going crazy and being fired in the process). hes an idiot because he should have done his research. you on the other hand, will justify in your head why you think you're in the right and won't lose any sleep over it. but -- consider this: insider trading is wrong because of information asymmetry - ie, someone profits because of others' ignorance - the balance of knowledge of information is not the same. similarly, there was major information asymmetry between you and this guy - you knew way more about the value of the guitar because it is one of your passions. you profited from this asymmetry. granted, not illegal (as insider trading is), but if it were me, i would feel really guilty about taking this kind of advantage over someone. this is $46k we're talking about.
i'm a bit conflicted because it seems there may be more to the story but i'm gonna say yta. you knew what it was worth and blatantly ripped the guy off. he just lost his dad and was probably having a hard time and just wanting to unload stuff but you could have leveled with the guy and told him the truth. sure you may not have ended up with the guitar but now you seem like a greedy prick
yta. i can't believe how many votes on here for the opposite! this guy sold his late dad's possession in good faith and you took advantage. this isn't even a random person, a colleague and assume some kind of friend? for everyone going on about how the guy should have "researched" properly, if he doesn't know anything about guitars he probably had no way of knowing what he was looking for. what a shitty thing to do, you should have told him what it was worth.
yta - 100% without question that was an asshole move, doesn't mean you have to give it back. the non asshole move would be to tell him its value before purchasing, not knowingly take it for almost nothing.. the majority of people would have done the exact same thing in your situation, doesn't mean it isnt an asshole move.
i feel like this thread highlights the dissonance between reality and reddit extremely well. how can someone possibly think this is the morally right thing to do. yta, that was really low.
morally yta ( and you know it ), you took advantage of him for your own gain, simple as. in the world we live in this happens daily, so nothing new, but now you gotta live with it.
[deleted]
yta. there’s a legal aspect and a moral aspect to this. i can’t speak to the legal side (and this isn’t a legal sub, though it might be worth a post to one). but from a moral standpoint, yeah, they should have done better research. but you knowingly took advantage of a grieving co-worker, to the tune of tens of thousands of dollars of their inheritance. that’s just an asshole thing to do. i mean, put yourself in their shoes. imagine you passed away, and your wife was grieving - how would you want the people in her life to treat her? secretly thrilled at making a massive profit from her grief and ignorance? no, right?
NTA
ESH
ESH
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
0.06929
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: this happened a while back. my wife and i still talk about it every once in a while. she's on my side and most of our friends and family are. however when it happened it was like ww3 between us and her co-workers and others. here we go...i've been playing the guitar for 22 years. i know guitar values and whatnot very well. i'm very into the guitar market. at my wife's old company she was hanging out with co-workers one day after work and she mentioned that i play guitar. a co-worker who i guess is very popular at work said that his dad passed away and he was selling his dads things. his dad had a guitar and asked my wife if i'd be interested in it. my wife texted me and i said to have him send me the info on the guitar and the price. the next day he texted me the pics and price. it was a 1952 telecaster in mint condition. he had the original receipts which was crazy! (that's how i knew the date). i asked what he wanted for it and he said he "looked up telecasters online and he thinks $4,000 is fair". i texted back, "i'll take it for $4,000" and went to pick it up. the guitar had no sentimental value to him at all. here's the issue at hand. the guitar was/is worth approximately $50,000 depending on the buyer and i knew it. when i got the guitar i told my wife the price and what it was worth. she was floored. fast forward two weeks her co-worker tells my wife he just found out what the guitar was actually worth from a family friend and wanted it back. she said, "well he really likes the guitar and he knew it was worth $50,000 which is why he was floored you offered it to him for $4,000. he really likes it and i doubt he will sell it back, but you can ask." (probably not the smartest thing for her to say, but she was caught off guard and it's not her fault or problem). he contacted me and asked to buy it back. i said that it's not for sale. he then said i scammed him and he was going to "sue me and take my wife to hr for being a part of the scam." which was nuts, but he actually did contact hr. they were cool about it and said it's not their problem. it's between him and me. over the next few months he made things very uncomfortable for my wife at work. he would bug her constantly about it. she eventually had to go to hr for harassment and they actually let him go (she complained twice and he was warned and didn't stop). he's contacted me several times about it so i got a restraining order for harassment too. i blocked him too. i haven't heard from him in about a year. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> this happened a while back. my wife and i still talk about it every once in a while. she's on my side and most of our friends and family are. however when it happened it was like ww3 between us and her co-workers and others. here we go...i've been playing the guitar for 22 years. i know guitar values and whatnot very well. i'm very into the guitar market. at my wife's old company she was hanging out with co-workers one day after work and she mentioned that i play guitar. a co-worker who i guess is very popular at work said that his dad passed away and he was selling his dads things. his dad had a guitar and asked my wife if i'd be interested in it. my wife texted me and i said to have him send me the info on the guitar and the price. the next day he texted me the pics and price. it was a 1952 telecaster in mint condition. he had the original receipts which was crazy! (that's how i knew the date). i asked what he wanted for it and he said he "looked up telecasters online and he thinks $4,000 is fair". i texted back, "i'll take it for $4,000" and went to pick it up. the guitar had no sentimental value to him at all. here's the issue at hand. the guitar was/is worth approximately $50,000 depending on the buyer and i knew it. when i got the guitar i told my wife the price and what it was worth. she was floored. fast forward two weeks her co-worker tells my wife he just found out what the guitar was actually worth from a family friend and wanted it back. she said, "well he really likes the guitar and he knew it was worth $50,000 which is why he was floored you offered it to him for $4,000. he really likes it and i doubt he will sell it back, but you can ask." (probably not the smartest thing for her to say, but she was caught off guard and it's not her fault or problem). he contacted me and asked to buy it back. i said that it's not for sale. he then said i scammed him and he was going to "sue me and take my wife to hr for being a part of the scam." which was nuts, but he actually did contact hr. they were cool about it and said it's not their problem. it's between him and me. over the next few months he made things very uncomfortable for my wife at work. he would bug her constantly about it. she eventually had to go to hr for harassment and they actually let him go (she complained twice and he was warned and didn't stop). he's contacted me several times about it so i got a restraining order for harassment too. i blocked him too. i haven't heard from him in about a year. aita? [/INST] nta. when you sell something it is your responsibility to know or determine what its worth not the person you are selling to. </s>
AITA for refusing to buy my step-daughter a car like my daughter's?
this is a throwaway account for privacy reasons. i(f38) have a 16 years old daughter. about 7 years ago her dad and i divorced because he found out he was gay. him being the only bread winner (and a high earner at that) and me being a housewife, he preferred to let us live in our house (a big one in a gated community) and continued paying all our expenses and giving me spending money to maintain my lifestyle. 2 years later i met my current husband, a year later we married and he moved in with me and my daughter. him and my ex are great friends, especially since my ex is still very much a part of our life. also as a wedding gift he gave me his half of the house. now i own it in full. my husband has a daughter with his ex, they have shared castody and she lives with us half the time. the problem is that my ex pays for our daughter to go to a really expensive private school, buys her expensive gifts; and for her birthday he bought her a $60k car. my husband can't afford the same for his daughter. my daughter and her step-sister do not have the best relationship, mainly because my husband's ex hoped that they would be getting back together, and keeps poisoning her daughter. my daughter used to share her stuff untill her step-sister started ruining them on purpose. that was when my husband made a rule that they can't borrow from each other. i stay out of it since she refuses to see me as a parent and i won't force her. my husband has a good job, but nothing as close as to what my ex earns, and since we both decided that the house is enough help from my ex, our income is just what he earns. which in my opinion is more than enough. now my step-daughter's 16th birthday is coming up, she asked for the same car that my ex gave my daughter. we refused of course and said we would buy her a car that fits our budget. she threw a tantrum and threatened my husband that she would never talk with him again if he didn't get her the same car. he is wavering but i refuse, $60k+ is just under what he makes a year, it will drown us in debt (we are still paying off his student loans and some medical debt he has). but on the other hand he loves his daughter a lot, and i feel partly responsible since she wouldn't have asked for it if my daughter didn't get the car for her birthday. so aita?
18,619
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/si5hfh/aita_for_refusing_to_buy_my_stepdaughter_a_car/
2022-02-01 21:00:35
nta. your ex bought your daughter the car, right? so tell your step daughter that her mother can buy her a car to make it equal.
nta, like you said you can't afford it, that is enough reason to not buy it. if she continues tell her in the spirit of fairness her mom should be the one getting it for her, since your daughter got it from the parent that is not part of your relationship
nta. it is way out of your budget. the fact that you guys are offering to buy her a car at all is more than a lot of teenagers get. is it unfair that your daughter has a $60k car while your stepdaughter won’t? i mean, i can see how it seems that way from a teenager’s perspective. but your daughter received that gift from her father - not from you or your new husband. it would be one thing if you and hubby decided to buy your daughter a car but not your stepdaughter. but she can’t demand a gift from *you* that your daughter got from someone else.
nta. really, it seems almost irresponsible for any 16yo to have a $60k car. i hope your ex is paying for that insurance too.
nta. stepdaughter will have to learn sometime that others will possess things that she wants but isn’t able to afford. some kids don’t even get cars for their 16th birthday at all. she sounds entitled. though hopefully your daughter isn’t flaunting her $60k car in the stepdaughter’s face.
nta. i understand you step daughter is going thru some big emotions, but i have to be blunt and say she need some big counseling to go with that. she's not emotionally capable of understanding, and needs some help outside the family.
the stepdaughter is playing her parents against each other. you are doing well with being the adult bystander in this craziness. i wouldn't be surprised if stepdaughter asked to live with her mom for a while... believe me, it won't last. but she needs for one of her parents to call out her behavior. nta!
nta. your ex could afford it and your current husband can't. that's all there is to it. that's life. he doesn't need to go into debt over a car.
stick to your guns. the girls have different fathers and gifts will reflect that. it's a reality she néeds to accept.
nta. she's 16, time for her to learn we can't all get what we want or what someone else has. you don't have the money. even if you did, it would be much better spent clearing up his debt, going towards both of your retirement, or into a college fund. spending that kind of money on a car is ridiculous, let alone for a 16 year old (no offense to your daughter).
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: this is a throwaway account for privacy reasons. i(f38) have a 16 years old daughter. about 7 years ago her dad and i divorced because he found out he was gay. him being the only bread winner (and a high earner at that) and me being a housewife, he preferred to let us live in our house (a big one in a gated community) and continued paying all our expenses and giving me spending money to maintain my lifestyle. 2 years later i met my current husband, a year later we married and he moved in with me and my daughter. him and my ex are great friends, especially since my ex is still very much a part of our life. also as a wedding gift he gave me his half of the house. now i own it in full. my husband has a daughter with his ex, they have shared castody and she lives with us half the time. the problem is that my ex pays for our daughter to go to a really expensive private school, buys her expensive gifts; and for her birthday he bought her a $60k car. my husband can't afford the same for his daughter. my daughter and her step-sister do not have the best relationship, mainly because my husband's ex hoped that they would be getting back together, and keeps poisoning her daughter. my daughter used to share her stuff untill her step-sister started ruining them on purpose. that was when my husband made a rule that they can't borrow from each other. i stay out of it since she refuses to see me as a parent and i won't force her. my husband has a good job, but nothing as close as to what my ex earns, and since we both decided that the house is enough help from my ex, our income is just what he earns. which in my opinion is more than enough. now my step-daughter's 16th birthday is coming up, she asked for the same car that my ex gave my daughter. we refused of course and said we would buy her a car that fits our budget. she threw a tantrum and threatened my husband that she would never talk with him again if he didn't get her the same car. he is wavering but i refuse, $60k+ is just under what he makes a year, it will drown us in debt (we are still paying off his student loans and some medical debt he has). but on the other hand he loves his daughter a lot, and i feel partly responsible since she wouldn't have asked for it if my daughter didn't get the car for her birthday. so aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> this is a throwaway account for privacy reasons. i(f38) have a 16 years old daughter. about 7 years ago her dad and i divorced because he found out he was gay. him being the only bread winner (and a high earner at that) and me being a housewife, he preferred to let us live in our house (a big one in a gated community) and continued paying all our expenses and giving me spending money to maintain my lifestyle. 2 years later i met my current husband, a year later we married and he moved in with me and my daughter. him and my ex are great friends, especially since my ex is still very much a part of our life. also as a wedding gift he gave me his half of the house. now i own it in full. my husband has a daughter with his ex, they have shared castody and she lives with us half the time. the problem is that my ex pays for our daughter to go to a really expensive private school, buys her expensive gifts; and for her birthday he bought her a $60k car. my husband can't afford the same for his daughter. my daughter and her step-sister do not have the best relationship, mainly because my husband's ex hoped that they would be getting back together, and keeps poisoning her daughter. my daughter used to share her stuff untill her step-sister started ruining them on purpose. that was when my husband made a rule that they can't borrow from each other. i stay out of it since she refuses to see me as a parent and i won't force her. my husband has a good job, but nothing as close as to what my ex earns, and since we both decided that the house is enough help from my ex, our income is just what he earns. which in my opinion is more than enough. now my step-daughter's 16th birthday is coming up, she asked for the same car that my ex gave my daughter. we refused of course and said we would buy her a car that fits our budget. she threw a tantrum and threatened my husband that she would never talk with him again if he didn't get her the same car. he is wavering but i refuse, $60k+ is just under what he makes a year, it will drown us in debt (we are still paying off his student loans and some medical debt he has). but on the other hand he loves his daughter a lot, and i feel partly responsible since she wouldn't have asked for it if my daughter didn't get the car for her birthday. so aita? [/INST] nta. your ex bought your daughter the car, right? so tell your step daughter that her mother can buy her a car to make it equal. </s>
AITA for asking my uninvited stepmother to leave my wedding?
i (f25) recently just got married to my wonderful husband (m26). a little bit of background, my parents divorced each other when i was around 14. shortly after, my dad met and remarried another woman let's call her brenda. with split custody and me having a good/close relationship with both of my parents, i would spend half a week at my mother’s house and the other half at my father and brenda’s house. i have 4 siblings, 3 of which are boys and then there's my sister and i. my sister and i have always been “daddies girls” and i've just recently realized now that growing up, all of brenda’s disdain towards my sister and i but not our brothers probably stemmed from jealousy. a few examples, making little comments when my dad would buy gifts for us such as “they don't need that” “they’ll grow up to be spoiled brats” etc...but never had anything to say when my dad would buy things for my brothers. would make comments on my weight and appearance, would generally seem annoyed anytime i tried to talk to her, went as far as making false assumptions to my father that i was having sex and may be pregnant, as we got a little bit older, she'd have no problem with letting our brothers use her car but always said no to my sister and i, she was in general just a very mean woman for no reason. fast forward a couple of years, i haven't been in contact with brenda that much, only seen her a couple of times when i’d go visit my dad and she remained the same ol’ mean brenda like i always knew. well, recently when time for my wedding came around my dad brought brenda as his plus-one without my knowledge. when i saw her, immediately i was upset. while technically, she is kind of family, i obviously only wanted people who i am on good terms with and have good relationships with at my wedding. so, i told my husband who politely asked her to leave and offered to escort her. now a few days after i'm getting angry messages from my dad saying what i did was “unacceptable” and how “brenda’s feelings are very hurt, and found what i did disheartening and very embarrassing” which i find very laughable honestly. the problem is my dad wants me to apologize to her and says i am not welcomed to their home anymore unless i apologize. even after explaining why i did what i did to my dad he won't accept my answer. so aita and should i just apologize for the sake of my dad and i’s relationship?
5,189
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/qjfdcq/aita_for_asking_my_uninvited_stepmother_to_leave/
2021-10-31 01:38:12
yta but only because your post sounds like you didn't tell your dad before hand that brenda wasn't invited.
info did you make sure to establish prior to the wedding day that she was not invited? edit : judging by ops lack of response, this is a clear yta. you can't give someone a plus one (especially your father who's been married to your step mother for years) and expect that he wouldn't bring her without explicit instruction. that one's on you, op.
yta if you didn’t tell your dad his wife wasn’t invited. for sure. you let him bring a plus one - but even if you hadn’t, it was safe to assume he’d bring his wife if you did not tell him specifically she was not invited.
yta. if you didn't want her to be there, that should have been made clear well before the wedding. if you gave you dad an invite plus one without saying that he couldn't bring his wife, he wasn't wrong to bring his wife if you didn't tell her and your dad that she wasn't welcome to the wedding, you were very very wrong to have her escorted out and owe her an apology.
yta your stepmother is married to your father. they are a social unit and must be invited together. if you did not want her to attend, you should have made it clear to your father well in advance of the wedding. throwing her out was not classy or acceptable, especially since you did not tell your father she was not invited. if your dad has made your continued relationship with him contingent on an apology to brenda, you have to decide how important your dad is in your life.
why did you give him a plus one. of course he would bring his wife. if you didn’t tell him she wasn’t welcome then yta.
yta you invited your dad and then was surprised that he brought his wife? and then you asked her to leave in the middle of the wedding celebration? definitely an asshole move. i get that she's a rotten stepmom, but you could have either chosen to set that aside and have your dad and stepmom there, or you could have told your dad way before the wedding that you aren't comfortable with stepmom there, so he could have decided whether or not to attend without her and not had all this drama.
uninvited means previously invited, then you withdrew the invitation. info: did you mean brenda wasn't ever invited? did you give your dad a +1 on his invitation? did you specifically tell your dad she wasn't invited?
edit to change to yta because the only answer you've given isn't satisfactory. you could have avoided the entire situation. if it was a genuine oversight, the mature thing would have been to just ignore her. it's not like you didn't have a new husband and your friends to concentrate on. throwing her out was rude - she wasn't behaving badly. if you kinda knew it was going to happen and we're prepared to throw her out as revenge, doubly yta. and you _should_ have known your dad would bring his wife of 10 years, especially as the estrangement between you and your stepmother doesn't seem to be at all formal or public. &gt;well, recently when time for my wedding came around my dad brought brenda as his plus-one without my knowledge. when i saw her, immediately i was upset. while technically, she is kind of family, i obviously only wanted people who i am on good terms with and have good relationships with at my wedding. ~~i n f o~~ first, i'm assuming that you didn't actually put "plus one" on the single named person invites. because if you had, 100% of people would assume that the wife would be the plus one. my questions: - did you invite any other halves of a married couple, excluding the other half? - did you specifically tell your father that only he was invited and not his wife of 10 years? - has there been an actual event and formal break where you've officially gone low or no contact with brenda? where you've made it clear to your dad that you are actively avoiding all contact with her because of how she treated you? cause it just sounds like you only see her when you visit your dad, which could be super normal even if you did like her. if any of that was "no" then y t a. it's extremely rare to invite only one half of a married couple. you absolutely needed to make that explicit to your father before the wedding. almost anyone would assume that both he and your stepmother would be invited. and lots of married couple have wedding guests they don't particularly know or even like, because they come with a guest they do really like, or another reason. if you answered "yes" and he brought her without discussing it with you, then n t a.
yta - it sounds like you didn’t tell your dad that she wasn’t invited. she is his wife and your stepmom. it would be totally reasonable for them to assume that she would be included.
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
0.016
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (f25) recently just got married to my wonderful husband (m26). a little bit of background, my parents divorced each other when i was around 14. shortly after, my dad met and remarried another woman let's call her brenda. with split custody and me having a good/close relationship with both of my parents, i would spend half a week at my mother’s house and the other half at my father and brenda’s house. i have 4 siblings, 3 of which are boys and then there's my sister and i. my sister and i have always been “daddies girls” and i've just recently realized now that growing up, all of brenda’s disdain towards my sister and i but not our brothers probably stemmed from jealousy. a few examples, making little comments when my dad would buy gifts for us such as “they don't need that” “they’ll grow up to be spoiled brats” etc...but never had anything to say when my dad would buy things for my brothers. would make comments on my weight and appearance, would generally seem annoyed anytime i tried to talk to her, went as far as making false assumptions to my father that i was having sex and may be pregnant, as we got a little bit older, she'd have no problem with letting our brothers use her car but always said no to my sister and i, she was in general just a very mean woman for no reason. fast forward a couple of years, i haven't been in contact with brenda that much, only seen her a couple of times when i’d go visit my dad and she remained the same ol’ mean brenda like i always knew. well, recently when time for my wedding came around my dad brought brenda as his plus-one without my knowledge. when i saw her, immediately i was upset. while technically, she is kind of family, i obviously only wanted people who i am on good terms with and have good relationships with at my wedding. so, i told my husband who politely asked her to leave and offered to escort her. now a few days after i'm getting angry messages from my dad saying what i did was “unacceptable” and how “brenda’s feelings are very hurt, and found what i did disheartening and very embarrassing” which i find very laughable honestly. the problem is my dad wants me to apologize to her and says i am not welcomed to their home anymore unless i apologize. even after explaining why i did what i did to my dad he won't accept my answer. so aita and should i just apologize for the sake of my dad and i’s relationship?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (f25) recently just got married to my wonderful husband (m26). a little bit of background, my parents divorced each other when i was around 14. shortly after, my dad met and remarried another woman let's call her brenda. with split custody and me having a good/close relationship with both of my parents, i would spend half a week at my mother’s house and the other half at my father and brenda’s house. i have 4 siblings, 3 of which are boys and then there's my sister and i. my sister and i have always been “daddies girls” and i've just recently realized now that growing up, all of brenda’s disdain towards my sister and i but not our brothers probably stemmed from jealousy. a few examples, making little comments when my dad would buy gifts for us such as “they don't need that” “they’ll grow up to be spoiled brats” etc...but never had anything to say when my dad would buy things for my brothers. would make comments on my weight and appearance, would generally seem annoyed anytime i tried to talk to her, went as far as making false assumptions to my father that i was having sex and may be pregnant, as we got a little bit older, she'd have no problem with letting our brothers use her car but always said no to my sister and i, she was in general just a very mean woman for no reason. fast forward a couple of years, i haven't been in contact with brenda that much, only seen her a couple of times when i’d go visit my dad and she remained the same ol’ mean brenda like i always knew. well, recently when time for my wedding came around my dad brought brenda as his plus-one without my knowledge. when i saw her, immediately i was upset. while technically, she is kind of family, i obviously only wanted people who i am on good terms with and have good relationships with at my wedding. so, i told my husband who politely asked her to leave and offered to escort her. now a few days after i'm getting angry messages from my dad saying what i did was “unacceptable” and how “brenda’s feelings are very hurt, and found what i did disheartening and very embarrassing” which i find very laughable honestly. the problem is my dad wants me to apologize to her and says i am not welcomed to their home anymore unless i apologize. even after explaining why i did what i did to my dad he won't accept my answer. so aita and should i just apologize for the sake of my dad and i’s relationship? [/INST] yta but only because your post sounds like you didn't tell your dad before hand that brenda wasn't invited. </s>
AITA for saying that i can’t do any chores in December and following through?
i (f30) run a small online business from home. november and december are my busiest time of the year when i make a lot of money that allows me to work less during the year. i’ve been doing this since i was 25 so i’ve got a decent idea of what i can and cannot do. and focusing on work only for 1-2 months is a sacrifice i’m willing to make for chill rest of the year. this year, i’ve moved in with my boyfriend (m35). well, technically he moved in with me because i own the house so it was a no brainier for him to move in with me. we split chores half and half. he works full time (37.5 hours a week). when he moved in, i had a talk with him letting him know that i can’t do any chores in november/december and asked if he could pick up the slack because i’m physically unable to do any chores as i can be working anything between 12-18 hours a day (i take a full january off to decompress). he said he doubted i worked that much but we will see. i asked again in september and october to make sure he was aware that i won’t be doing anything (i meal prepped in advance) and i felt he kind of dismissed me. mid november, we had an argument about my chores not being done and i reminded him of what i told him. he said that he thought i wasn’t being serious and told me there’s no way he’d do 100% of chores because he’s working too. i said fine, don’t do my chores, they can wait until i have time. that’s how it was when i lived alone, no problem, i don’t make much mess anyway. he wasn’t happy but dropped it. we haven’t seen each other much because i’ve been working so much but he’s been more and more pissed off and blew up at me today regarding the chores. he said i had to have a better work life balance and to grow up because the house was a mess. i told him if it was a mess it was his fault because i barely leave my office. he called me a lazy bitch. i told him k didn’t have time for arguing and went back working. he stood in front of my locked office door shouting how he couldn’t believe i was bei mg serious about not doing chores and it was an asshole move to leave it all to him. he thinks i’m a major asshole for basically disappearing for 2 months and following through with not doing chores. am i really the asshole for saying i won’t do chores and following through? sorry for any typos, i’m on mobile and my autocorrect hates me.
17,985
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/zcj17j/aita_for_saying_that_i_cant_do_any_chores_in/
2022-12-04 19:30:17
nta. someone who called me a lazy bitch in my house, wouldn't be living in it much longer.
he called you a lazy bitch? that kind of disrespect and rudeness in a relationship would not fly with me and he’d be out.
nta wow. your boyfriend is showing his true colors. **believe him.** i know that right now you don’t have time to rearrange your life but once january comes around you should give yourself the gift of losing the deadbeat boyfriend. for what it’s worth, i’m married and both me and my husband have gone through times where we had to pick up the slack for each other for whatever reason. and it’s not always a work reason, there could be health issues, the birth of a child, travel and a billion other things that come up. your boyfriend is showing you that he will throw a fit and call you names whenever he needs to support you. this is bad. really bad. it should be a dealbreaker.
anyone who called me a lazy bitch for refusing to clean up their mess when i'm working 12-18 hour days would be out of my house so fast that the door would hit them on the way out.
so basically… you warned him when he moved in, and courteously reminded him multiple times since then… and he still thought you weren’t being serious…? and then… you did exactly what you said you were going to do… and he’s upset… because you were honest? seriously…? you’re working. it’s not like you’re just sitting on your ass and letting a mess pile up. you’re working hard for the sake of your personal business… and it’s not like it was any different before him. nta.
nta. girl this man is living in the house you own and he won’t help out with chores so you can continue with the business that allows him to live there. you told him and he chose to assume you were lying. honestly this should be all you need to know. i know people with businesses like this. i just expect not to have any meaningful interaction with them from mid-nov until the new year. you need to be aware that if you plan on having children with him this is exactly how he will be. “i doubt looking after a new born is *that* much work, but we’ll see.” also, the behavior you are describing and the language he is using towards you is abuse. 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
nta. you told him, repeatedly. he chose to blow that off. then when the reality hit of what you had repeatedly told him, he called you names and told you to grow up. in your house. it’s not even about whether you could do the chores or not. it’s about how he handles things he doesn’t want to hear and how he reacts and treats you when the reality hits the fan. i’d be re-thinking the whole relationship.
nta. you said him moving into your house was a no brainer - kicking him out requires even less brain power than that.
nta how much can that be? especially if you told him, to just leave yours undone. i assume you would do everything in january if you have the month off. i just cant grasp that you talked and talked and talked about it and he just ignored it.
nta. you told him how it would be and he's pissed off that you were honest. maybe he needs to move out if he has such a big problem with it.
NTA
null
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (f30) run a small online business from home. november and december are my busiest time of the year when i make a lot of money that allows me to work less during the year. i’ve been doing this since i was 25 so i’ve got a decent idea of what i can and cannot do. and focusing on work only for 1-2 months is a sacrifice i’m willing to make for chill rest of the year. this year, i’ve moved in with my boyfriend (m35). well, technically he moved in with me because i own the house so it was a no brainier for him to move in with me. we split chores half and half. he works full time (37.5 hours a week). when he moved in, i had a talk with him letting him know that i can’t do any chores in november/december and asked if he could pick up the slack because i’m physically unable to do any chores as i can be working anything between 12-18 hours a day (i take a full january off to decompress). he said he doubted i worked that much but we will see. i asked again in september and october to make sure he was aware that i won’t be doing anything (i meal prepped in advance) and i felt he kind of dismissed me. mid november, we had an argument about my chores not being done and i reminded him of what i told him. he said that he thought i wasn’t being serious and told me there’s no way he’d do 100% of chores because he’s working too. i said fine, don’t do my chores, they can wait until i have time. that’s how it was when i lived alone, no problem, i don’t make much mess anyway. he wasn’t happy but dropped it. we haven’t seen each other much because i’ve been working so much but he’s been more and more pissed off and blew up at me today regarding the chores. he said i had to have a better work life balance and to grow up because the house was a mess. i told him if it was a mess it was his fault because i barely leave my office. he called me a lazy bitch. i told him k didn’t have time for arguing and went back working. he stood in front of my locked office door shouting how he couldn’t believe i was bei mg serious about not doing chores and it was an asshole move to leave it all to him. he thinks i’m a major asshole for basically disappearing for 2 months and following through with not doing chores. am i really the asshole for saying i won’t do chores and following through? sorry for any typos, i’m on mobile and my autocorrect hates me.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (f30) run a small online business from home. november and december are my busiest time of the year when i make a lot of money that allows me to work less during the year. i’ve been doing this since i was 25 so i’ve got a decent idea of what i can and cannot do. and focusing on work only for 1-2 months is a sacrifice i’m willing to make for chill rest of the year. this year, i’ve moved in with my boyfriend (m35). well, technically he moved in with me because i own the house so it was a no brainier for him to move in with me. we split chores half and half. he works full time (37.5 hours a week). when he moved in, i had a talk with him letting him know that i can’t do any chores in november/december and asked if he could pick up the slack because i’m physically unable to do any chores as i can be working anything between 12-18 hours a day (i take a full january off to decompress). he said he doubted i worked that much but we will see. i asked again in september and october to make sure he was aware that i won’t be doing anything (i meal prepped in advance) and i felt he kind of dismissed me. mid november, we had an argument about my chores not being done and i reminded him of what i told him. he said that he thought i wasn’t being serious and told me there’s no way he’d do 100% of chores because he’s working too. i said fine, don’t do my chores, they can wait until i have time. that’s how it was when i lived alone, no problem, i don’t make much mess anyway. he wasn’t happy but dropped it. we haven’t seen each other much because i’ve been working so much but he’s been more and more pissed off and blew up at me today regarding the chores. he said i had to have a better work life balance and to grow up because the house was a mess. i told him if it was a mess it was his fault because i barely leave my office. he called me a lazy bitch. i told him k didn’t have time for arguing and went back working. he stood in front of my locked office door shouting how he couldn’t believe i was bei mg serious about not doing chores and it was an asshole move to leave it all to him. he thinks i’m a major asshole for basically disappearing for 2 months and following through with not doing chores. am i really the asshole for saying i won’t do chores and following through? sorry for any typos, i’m on mobile and my autocorrect hates me. [/INST] nta. someone who called me a lazy bitch in my house, wouldn't be living in it much longer. </s>
AITA for telling my daughter to stop crying because this wasn’t about her?
i have a 28 year old daughter and a 33 year old son. i remarried one year ago to my wife (30f) and i had told her while dating that i was in my sixties and wasn’t aiming to have more kids. for the past few weeks my wife had started acting strange and said she felt sick and tired. the other day my wife and i were visiting my daughter and her boyfriend who just got an apartment together. my wife was on edge the whole time. finally she blurted out that she found out that she’s pregnant. she looked apprehensive so i asked why she was treating this like bad news. she said she wasn’t sure how i’d feel about the news. so i told her that it was unexpected but that especially recently i’ve come to really value children in a way that i couldn’t when i was younger and was either away from home altogether or working 13 hour days, six days a week. i told her that my business is very much hands off now and this time around i have time and resources and am so excited to devote that to our child. and that i would do everything to make our child the happiest child with the happiest family. my daughter was in the adjacent room but i didn’t notice that she had walked in. she started sniffing and when i asked what’s wrong she started full on crying. she curtly said “ congratulations” and started walking out. i caught up with her in the hallway and she spun around and said “ great to see that you’ve finally calmed down dad- if only it happened 25 years ago and not just because of age.“ i told her that i was only trying to make my wife feel better and to she didn’t have to cry and yell because this wasn’t about her. this was about letting an anxious woman i loved know that she and her child would want for nothing and worry about nothing. she looked furious and said “ yeah- this is about a kid who is going to get a chill, indulgent dad and a happy mom because he got him the second time around.” after that my wife and i left because we knew we weren’t welcome at the moment. aita for defending what i said and for telling my daughter that this really has nothing to do with her and everything to do with a baby i intend to be a great dad to?
6,857
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/m4vbtu/aita_for_telling_my_daughter_to_stop_crying/
2021-03-14 13:48:46
yta. yes, you were just trying to make your wife feel better, but in the process you insinuated that this child would be more loved and wanted then your daughter was, within earshot of her. i bet that stung. she wanted to talk to you about how her feelings were hurt. you should have said you were sorry, her feelings are valid, that you didn’t mean to hurt her feelings and that you were just trying to make your wife feel better. instead you immediately dismissed her very rational feelings, when you’re the one who said the very tasteless thing in your daughters’ home. when someone is telling you their feelings are hurt, it’s crazy mean and insensitive to tell them why they shouldn’t be.
yta. the way you made your wife feel better hurt your daughter’s feelings, as it made her feel you cared more about your new wife than you ever have about her. unfortunately this was compounded when your reaction to her upset was to *prove* that your wife’s happiness is more important to you than your daughter’s. you: i am glad this time round i will be a better father. daughter: i am upset because you were not a good father and never acknowledged that to me. you: you don’t matter! your feelings are not important to me right now. what is important is my wife’s feelings, because she is pregnant with a child i will actually love. that’s what your daughter heard.
[deleted]
yta so you lied to your wife? or to your daughter? cause there's no way you could mean both things you said, they are contradictory. also, if your daughter resents you for crappy parenting or whatever she's 100% entitled to her feelings and anyone has no say.
yta you decided to tell her how excited you were because you really value children *now* while in your daughters home. how exactly were your adult children supposed to take that (because there’s a pretty clear implication that you didn’t value them)? that was a conversation you should have had with your wife privately in your own home. you could have just reassured her that even thought you thought you didn’t want more children that you’re very excited. simple as that. instead you went on and on about all the things you’re willing to do for this kid that you weren’t for your other kids (spend time with them, spend all this money on them, *value them*). you’re whole speech to your wife highlights how much you plan to be a good father to this child because you couldn’t be bothered with the older ones.
yta. that comment your daughter made about the 25 years reveals a lot about you. also your wife is ta for telling you in the most inappropriate place. there is clearly some history here and she was trying to make a scene by telling you in your daughter’s own home. have a good think about why your daughter is upset. if you don’t you’ll probably still be a shit father to the new kid, how could you not if you don’t know what went wrong the first time around. then go and apologise to your daughter without your wife being there.
yta.. but your wife too. there was zero reason your wife just had to tell you this while you were visiting your daughter and her boyfriend in their new home. you have your own home, no need to make the visit with your daughter about her. but you were also t a for not recognizing the pain you've caused your daughter, by being a crappy, uninvolved, absentee father to her. instead you doubled down, and insulted your daughter, when your wife and you had already made the new home visit about you, her and the pregnancy.
what's up with all these old men going after women half their age, and having children with them? it's disgusting on so many levels. yta for dismissing your daughter's feelings: if she resents you for being a bad parent, maybe you should sit down and talk with her? it feels like you're already putting the unborn baby before your daughter, no wonder she's hurt. it is also about her since the baby will be her half-sibling.
yta. also...i kinda doubt this pregnancy was an accident. 30 year olds don’t marry nasty old men unless there’s $$$ involved so this baby is an insurance policy.
yta- you literally said you value this child nore than your daughter in your daughters home.
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i have a 28 year old daughter and a 33 year old son. i remarried one year ago to my wife (30f) and i had told her while dating that i was in my sixties and wasn’t aiming to have more kids. for the past few weeks my wife had started acting strange and said she felt sick and tired. the other day my wife and i were visiting my daughter and her boyfriend who just got an apartment together. my wife was on edge the whole time. finally she blurted out that she found out that she’s pregnant. she looked apprehensive so i asked why she was treating this like bad news. she said she wasn’t sure how i’d feel about the news. so i told her that it was unexpected but that especially recently i’ve come to really value children in a way that i couldn’t when i was younger and was either away from home altogether or working 13 hour days, six days a week. i told her that my business is very much hands off now and this time around i have time and resources and am so excited to devote that to our child. and that i would do everything to make our child the happiest child with the happiest family. my daughter was in the adjacent room but i didn’t notice that she had walked in. she started sniffing and when i asked what’s wrong she started full on crying. she curtly said “ congratulations” and started walking out. i caught up with her in the hallway and she spun around and said “ great to see that you’ve finally calmed down dad- if only it happened 25 years ago and not just because of age.“ i told her that i was only trying to make my wife feel better and to she didn’t have to cry and yell because this wasn’t about her. this was about letting an anxious woman i loved know that she and her child would want for nothing and worry about nothing. she looked furious and said “ yeah- this is about a kid who is going to get a chill, indulgent dad and a happy mom because he got him the second time around.” after that my wife and i left because we knew we weren’t welcome at the moment. aita for defending what i said and for telling my daughter that this really has nothing to do with her and everything to do with a baby i intend to be a great dad to?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i have a 28 year old daughter and a 33 year old son. i remarried one year ago to my wife (30f) and i had told her while dating that i was in my sixties and wasn’t aiming to have more kids. for the past few weeks my wife had started acting strange and said she felt sick and tired. the other day my wife and i were visiting my daughter and her boyfriend who just got an apartment together. my wife was on edge the whole time. finally she blurted out that she found out that she’s pregnant. she looked apprehensive so i asked why she was treating this like bad news. she said she wasn’t sure how i’d feel about the news. so i told her that it was unexpected but that especially recently i’ve come to really value children in a way that i couldn’t when i was younger and was either away from home altogether or working 13 hour days, six days a week. i told her that my business is very much hands off now and this time around i have time and resources and am so excited to devote that to our child. and that i would do everything to make our child the happiest child with the happiest family. my daughter was in the adjacent room but i didn’t notice that she had walked in. she started sniffing and when i asked what’s wrong she started full on crying. she curtly said “ congratulations” and started walking out. i caught up with her in the hallway and she spun around and said “ great to see that you’ve finally calmed down dad- if only it happened 25 years ago and not just because of age.“ i told her that i was only trying to make my wife feel better and to she didn’t have to cry and yell because this wasn’t about her. this was about letting an anxious woman i loved know that she and her child would want for nothing and worry about nothing. she looked furious and said “ yeah- this is about a kid who is going to get a chill, indulgent dad and a happy mom because he got him the second time around.” after that my wife and i left because we knew we weren’t welcome at the moment. aita for defending what i said and for telling my daughter that this really has nothing to do with her and everything to do with a baby i intend to be a great dad to? [/INST] yta. yes, you were just trying to make your wife feel better, but in the process you insinuated that this child would be more loved and wanted then your daughter was, within earshot of her. i bet that stung. she wanted to talk to you about how her feelings were hurt. you should have said you were sorry, her feelings are valid, that you didn’t mean to hurt her feelings and that you were just trying to make your wife feel better. instead you immediately dismissed her very rational feelings, when you’re the one who said the very tasteless thing in your daughters’ home. when someone is telling you their feelings are hurt, it’s crazy mean and insensitive to tell them why they shouldn’t be. </s>
AITA for telling my BF that if he doesnt go to work, hes no longer using ANYTHING of mine (including my car AND wifi)?
28f/29m been together for like 4 years i think. i love this guy to death but when i say he is lazy, that is seriously a huge fucking understatement and doesnt even shed an ounce of light on the actual problem. hes also a gaming junkie-like the worst of their kind. for example, when a game is being released, he waits up until midnight to purchase the game (no matter how expensive) and will binge on it for weeks straight while hardly sleeping. during this time you will be lucky to get so much as a "hello" out of him without him getting pissed for you disrupting him. but still expects people to literally cater to his every need so that he doesnt have to get up to do anything. i dont entertain this because i'm not his fucking mother. anyways, a year and a half ago i had to give him an ultimatum. you either get a fucking job and start supporting yourself or you can leave and go mooch off someone else. he chose to get a job. lasted a month before he quit. found another job 2 months later, lasted 2 weeks and quit. he was unemployed for 11 months when he finally landed this job in september. assassins creed was just released, what, 2 weeks ago and he started calling out every. single. day. started staying up until 4am playing his game, would sleep until 8-10am and then be right back at it while asking me to cook and cater to him. yesterday i unplugged and hid his xbox. i knew he was going to call out and jump on his game. as i suspected, that's exactly what he tried doing. he picked a fight with me. said he hated working and i was forcing him to waste away his life. claimed he was depressed, though that's the first i've heard of it. he then tells me to get off my lazy ass and do something for once. i told him to leave. he takes my car because his is "on its last leg"- his words. hes not in work clothes so i know he wasnt going to work. i texted him and said "if you arent going to work, bring my car back. and if you plan on flaking on this job like the rest of them, you will not be using my car or my internet. make your choice." he texted back saying "you trying to mother me all the time is a fucking turn off. you holding things against me all the time also makes you a fucking asshole." aita?
19,224
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/k05722/aita_for_telling_my_bf_that_if_he_doesnt_go_to/
2020-11-24 13:42:59
nta but girl... follow through with that ultimatum... he's lazy and never going to change
yta to yourself for still being in this relationship.
nta. why are you with this guy? it sounds more like you are mothering a child rather than being an equal partner in a relationship. your boyfriend has an addiction if he's depriving himself of sleep to play games constantly. you could tell him that he needs to seek therapy or leave, but you've already issued a similar ultimatum once. **he blew his one chance.** don't continue to let him freeload off you.
you seem like you’re looking for permission to dump him. do it. you have all our permission. spending four years on this shitshow does not mean you have to spend any more. he doesn’t respect you. he doesn’t help with chores because he doesn’t want to. he doesn’t help financially because he doesn’t want to. i don’t care how funny he is or how good he is in bed when he’s not glued to a console. does he have a sibling you can talk to, or maybe there’s a mutual friend? you might need back up when you kick him out. we’re all rooting for you, op.
nta. what does this guy bring to your life? i couldn’t even get past the first paragraph. this is a grown ass man. you described the lives of 14 year old boys that were in my classes. throw out the boy and get a man. he can live in a tent made out of the red flags he dropped. 🚩🚩🚩
nta clearly but i want to clarify something: you are acting like his mother. estop doing this to yourself, you said yourself you aren't his mother so stop acting like it. even if you don't cook every meal or do every single chore you are babying him. you shouldn't have to hide the xbox of a grown ass man for him to understand he needs to go to work- he needs to learn control by himself. whether you see it or not, you are treating him like a child: you provide for him, he uses your things as of they were his and he early doesn't have any ambition to leave this position. this guy is a moocher, he is using you. i also am pretty sure you do more house chores. you really need to think about whether this is the future you want. stop assuming he will change and be with someone who you enjoy the current state of, not some hypothetical ideal of your current man. i think it's also unfair to expect him to change to a massive extent if he doesn't want to. if you aren't happy with him then you need to accept that.
yeah, i do all the house chores. he actually looks at me in disgust if the dishes arent done but doesnt lift a finger to help in anyway unless his family or buddies are coming over. and even then its half assed. idk, you're right.
yta for staying in this relationship when you should dump him.
info: &gt;i love this guy to death does he love you?
whoa, that's ridiculous... gotta say he must give amazing sex because wtf are you getting out of this relationship?? you're not the ah at all... he's a child with no desire to be a man.. you deserve better
NTA
YTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
null
YTA
INFO
null
0.449301
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: 28f/29m been together for like 4 years i think. i love this guy to death but when i say he is lazy, that is seriously a huge fucking understatement and doesnt even shed an ounce of light on the actual problem. hes also a gaming junkie-like the worst of their kind. for example, when a game is being released, he waits up until midnight to purchase the game (no matter how expensive) and will binge on it for weeks straight while hardly sleeping. during this time you will be lucky to get so much as a "hello" out of him without him getting pissed for you disrupting him. but still expects people to literally cater to his every need so that he doesnt have to get up to do anything. i dont entertain this because i'm not his fucking mother. anyways, a year and a half ago i had to give him an ultimatum. you either get a fucking job and start supporting yourself or you can leave and go mooch off someone else. he chose to get a job. lasted a month before he quit. found another job 2 months later, lasted 2 weeks and quit. he was unemployed for 11 months when he finally landed this job in september. assassins creed was just released, what, 2 weeks ago and he started calling out every. single. day. started staying up until 4am playing his game, would sleep until 8-10am and then be right back at it while asking me to cook and cater to him. yesterday i unplugged and hid his xbox. i knew he was going to call out and jump on his game. as i suspected, that's exactly what he tried doing. he picked a fight with me. said he hated working and i was forcing him to waste away his life. claimed he was depressed, though that's the first i've heard of it. he then tells me to get off my lazy ass and do something for once. i told him to leave. he takes my car because his is "on its last leg"- his words. hes not in work clothes so i know he wasnt going to work. i texted him and said "if you arent going to work, bring my car back. and if you plan on flaking on this job like the rest of them, you will not be using my car or my internet. make your choice." he texted back saying "you trying to mother me all the time is a fucking turn off. you holding things against me all the time also makes you a fucking asshole." aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> 28f/29m been together for like 4 years i think. i love this guy to death but when i say he is lazy, that is seriously a huge fucking understatement and doesnt even shed an ounce of light on the actual problem. hes also a gaming junkie-like the worst of their kind. for example, when a game is being released, he waits up until midnight to purchase the game (no matter how expensive) and will binge on it for weeks straight while hardly sleeping. during this time you will be lucky to get so much as a "hello" out of him without him getting pissed for you disrupting him. but still expects people to literally cater to his every need so that he doesnt have to get up to do anything. i dont entertain this because i'm not his fucking mother. anyways, a year and a half ago i had to give him an ultimatum. you either get a fucking job and start supporting yourself or you can leave and go mooch off someone else. he chose to get a job. lasted a month before he quit. found another job 2 months later, lasted 2 weeks and quit. he was unemployed for 11 months when he finally landed this job in september. assassins creed was just released, what, 2 weeks ago and he started calling out every. single. day. started staying up until 4am playing his game, would sleep until 8-10am and then be right back at it while asking me to cook and cater to him. yesterday i unplugged and hid his xbox. i knew he was going to call out and jump on his game. as i suspected, that's exactly what he tried doing. he picked a fight with me. said he hated working and i was forcing him to waste away his life. claimed he was depressed, though that's the first i've heard of it. he then tells me to get off my lazy ass and do something for once. i told him to leave. he takes my car because his is "on its last leg"- his words. hes not in work clothes so i know he wasnt going to work. i texted him and said "if you arent going to work, bring my car back. and if you plan on flaking on this job like the rest of them, you will not be using my car or my internet. make your choice." he texted back saying "you trying to mother me all the time is a fucking turn off. you holding things against me all the time also makes you a fucking asshole." aita? [/INST] nta but girl... follow through with that ultimatum... he's lazy and never going to change </s>
AITA for going no-contact with my parents after learning they had lied to me about my allergies all my life?
hey everyone. i am 19 years old and my parents are in their 50s. for as long as i can remember, i have been allergic to several things: * dairy * wheat/flour/gluten * legumes since i was a young child, my parents have completely kept all of them out of our house. while other kids ate breakfast cereals, i ate fish and assorted pickled vegetables for breakfast. while other kids had lunchables, i had grilled chicken or fish with, again, assorted vegetables (usually sweet potatoes). while other kids ate birthday cake at the birthday party, i had an apple. i never questioned this until a couple of months ago. i was at my aunt's house for my birthday party, and she made brownies for everyone. for me, she took great steps to make them with almond flour and avoided all of my allergies. i started eating them and thought little of it until my aunt suddenly looked at me and, in a panicked way, asked which plate i took the brownies from. i pointed from the one where i got my brownies, and she immediately stood up and told me we had to get my epipen. she raced to ask my mother for it, and i sat there scared out of my mind because i had never mistakenly eaten flour before. i noticed my mother had calmed her down, and then she said that we don't have to worry because she had switched the plates of brownies, and after all i had eaten the ones made with almond flour. i found this incredibly odd because, really, why would she swap the plates? that doesn't even make sense. but for the time being i let the issue rest. it didn't sit well with me for about a week and i finally went to get an allergy test. the doctor started with a skin prick test, and lo and behold, i didn't react to any of the above substances. then he ordered a blood test, and when the results came in, they said that i had absolutely no intolerance to any of the foods i'm supposed to be allergic to. i was furious and called my mother. she eventually admitted that she lied to me because she wanted me to be on a paleolithic diet, and wanted me to be able to avoid all temptations. she raised me with a lie about her own health, but she keeps insisting that i try to see it from her perspective. she spams my phone with messages about how healthy i am--that i never had acne, that i have been in great shape my whole life, that i have strong teeth and bones, and even that i got onto a d1 college tennis team. she has started calling me ungrateful for her intervention and insisting that i really should be glad i never got "carb addicted." i don't know what to think. i carried around an epipen for all those years--one that i suspect may be fake seeing as my mother never got me to replace it--and i don't even know anymore. am i the asshole and an ungrateful son for losing it over this?
27,562
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/h808dd/aita_for_going_nocontact_with_my_parents_after/
2020-06-13 04:07:22
nta- you spent your entire life thinking that you could easily die because your mom wanted you on a special diet??? allergies are incredibly serious and while you can grow out of them, to be lied to is unnecessary. what your mom did was manipulative and poor parenting. she easily could have had you on a diet like that without lying and making you fear for your life.
nta. also, tell your aunt about your mom's lie. she should know that your mom made her put in extra effort for who knows how many times, and caused her to go into a panic about you potentially having an allergic reaction, when in reality your mom had lied about your allergies. i feel bad your aunt went through that. what your mom did was so terrible. she needs to face the consequences for her actions. cut contact until she understands just how bad her actions were.
nta. your mom sounds like those vegan/vegetarian people who don't feed their dogs/cats meat
nta-please try out cheese, you won't regret
no, you’re nta, and you may want to check out a subreddit called r/raisedbynarcissists, you might find the support you need to get through this :)
absolutely positively not the asshole. she can't raise her kid on a lie and expect him to be on with it, no matter how you turned out. you missed out on sweets as a kid and lunchables, which are wonderful. and i feel like she lied about switching the plates just to calm her down. she wouldn't have known which plate you were gonna eat from.
nta that could even be described as munchausen syndrome by proxy (msbp) what your mother did. to maintain such a lie for so long. wow. but oh my, you get to try all the cheeses now! and legumes! you shall feast
nta she lied while probably extolling the virtues of truth, some insight and acknowledgment from her about that would do wonders, but seeing that she doubled down based on her giving you no credit for the positives you have achieved through you own actions and not because she lied to you and seeming to shame you for not being grateful: she’s the asshole.
[deleted]
nta. she did not need to do this. many people grow on different diets and food restrictions without needing to be lied to. it's not about temptation, it's about education. if she went so far as to always make food and desserts that didn't have the things she told you are allergic, she didn't need to lie. now you know the truth and not only ruined your relationship with her, erased all trust you had on her, it will also make you consume everything you couldn't. and i say, go for it! choose your own diet and keep away for some time. now that she doesn't control this part of you anymore, she can get a little crazy.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: hey everyone. i am 19 years old and my parents are in their 50s. for as long as i can remember, i have been allergic to several things: * dairy * wheat/flour/gluten * legumes since i was a young child, my parents have completely kept all of them out of our house. while other kids ate breakfast cereals, i ate fish and assorted pickled vegetables for breakfast. while other kids had lunchables, i had grilled chicken or fish with, again, assorted vegetables (usually sweet potatoes). while other kids ate birthday cake at the birthday party, i had an apple. i never questioned this until a couple of months ago. i was at my aunt's house for my birthday party, and she made brownies for everyone. for me, she took great steps to make them with almond flour and avoided all of my allergies. i started eating them and thought little of it until my aunt suddenly looked at me and, in a panicked way, asked which plate i took the brownies from. i pointed from the one where i got my brownies, and she immediately stood up and told me we had to get my epipen. she raced to ask my mother for it, and i sat there scared out of my mind because i had never mistakenly eaten flour before. i noticed my mother had calmed her down, and then she said that we don't have to worry because she had switched the plates of brownies, and after all i had eaten the ones made with almond flour. i found this incredibly odd because, really, why would she swap the plates? that doesn't even make sense. but for the time being i let the issue rest. it didn't sit well with me for about a week and i finally went to get an allergy test. the doctor started with a skin prick test, and lo and behold, i didn't react to any of the above substances. then he ordered a blood test, and when the results came in, they said that i had absolutely no intolerance to any of the foods i'm supposed to be allergic to. i was furious and called my mother. she eventually admitted that she lied to me because she wanted me to be on a paleolithic diet, and wanted me to be able to avoid all temptations. she raised me with a lie about her own health, but she keeps insisting that i try to see it from her perspective. she spams my phone with messages about how healthy i am--that i never had acne, that i have been in great shape my whole life, that i have strong teeth and bones, and even that i got onto a d1 college tennis team. she has started calling me ungrateful for her intervention and insisting that i really should be glad i never got "carb addicted." i don't know what to think. i carried around an epipen for all those years--one that i suspect may be fake seeing as my mother never got me to replace it--and i don't even know anymore. am i the asshole and an ungrateful son for losing it over this?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> hey everyone. i am 19 years old and my parents are in their 50s. for as long as i can remember, i have been allergic to several things: * dairy * wheat/flour/gluten * legumes since i was a young child, my parents have completely kept all of them out of our house. while other kids ate breakfast cereals, i ate fish and assorted pickled vegetables for breakfast. while other kids had lunchables, i had grilled chicken or fish with, again, assorted vegetables (usually sweet potatoes). while other kids ate birthday cake at the birthday party, i had an apple. i never questioned this until a couple of months ago. i was at my aunt's house for my birthday party, and she made brownies for everyone. for me, she took great steps to make them with almond flour and avoided all of my allergies. i started eating them and thought little of it until my aunt suddenly looked at me and, in a panicked way, asked which plate i took the brownies from. i pointed from the one where i got my brownies, and she immediately stood up and told me we had to get my epipen. she raced to ask my mother for it, and i sat there scared out of my mind because i had never mistakenly eaten flour before. i noticed my mother had calmed her down, and then she said that we don't have to worry because she had switched the plates of brownies, and after all i had eaten the ones made with almond flour. i found this incredibly odd because, really, why would she swap the plates? that doesn't even make sense. but for the time being i let the issue rest. it didn't sit well with me for about a week and i finally went to get an allergy test. the doctor started with a skin prick test, and lo and behold, i didn't react to any of the above substances. then he ordered a blood test, and when the results came in, they said that i had absolutely no intolerance to any of the foods i'm supposed to be allergic to. i was furious and called my mother. she eventually admitted that she lied to me because she wanted me to be on a paleolithic diet, and wanted me to be able to avoid all temptations. she raised me with a lie about her own health, but she keeps insisting that i try to see it from her perspective. she spams my phone with messages about how healthy i am--that i never had acne, that i have been in great shape my whole life, that i have strong teeth and bones, and even that i got onto a d1 college tennis team. she has started calling me ungrateful for her intervention and insisting that i really should be glad i never got "carb addicted." i don't know what to think. i carried around an epipen for all those years--one that i suspect may be fake seeing as my mother never got me to replace it--and i don't even know anymore. am i the asshole and an ungrateful son for losing it over this? [/INST] nta- you spent your entire life thinking that you could easily die because your mom wanted you on a special diet??? allergies are incredibly serious and while you can grow out of them, to be lied to is unnecessary. what your mom did was manipulative and poor parenting. she easily could have had you on a diet like that without lying and making you fear for your life. </s>
WIBTA if I give a family heirloom belonging to my late wife to my adopted daughter?
my late wife kate passed away about 12 years ago. they have a family heirloom that has passed down several generations (starting from her great grandmother) from mothers to their first daughters, on their 18th (or thereabouts) birthdays. the heirloom itself is not highly valuable in a financial sense, but the history makes it very valuable to the people in the family. i currently possess it after kate passed away and i always intended to give it to my daughter, claire, on her 18th birthday. she is currently 16. i married my current wife about 8 years ago. my step daughter, sarah, (whom i have adopted and consider my own daughter) is 17 years and 11 months old, her 18th birthday is in a month. my wife has also adopted claire and we all consider each other as just one family. my wife asked me to give the heirloom to sarah on her birthday to continue the tradition. i was hesitant because i always intended it to give it to claire who is kate's only daughter as this is what she would have wanted and is the continuation of the tradition. my wife counters that this belongs to our family now and we should give it to our eldest daughter on her 18th birthday, and therefore this should be sarah. i told her that while i consider sarah to be my daughter but she's not kate's daughter, this belongs to kate and should go to kate's daughter. my wife said claire is her daughter, not anyone else's and wife accused me of playing favorites and told me that if i truly consider sarah to be my daughter then i'll do the right thing for her or that i haven't really accepted sarah as a real daughter yet. i consulted my son (from kate, 25 years old) and he told me that if i do this he's going to walk from the birthday party and that he bets he won't be the only one. he said if i do this i should be ready for severe consequences. he left in a very frustrated way. his argument in the end was that "this isn't yours to give away. it was mom's and now belongs to claire." my wife thinks my son is overreacting and it's only because due to his age and moving out he's never bonded with sarah like claire and i have, so he doesn't consider sarah to be his real sister, otherwise he'd be happy for her. my wife thinks claire will be happy about this since she considers sarah to be her big sister and it will bring the girls even closer together because sarah will happily share it with claire and they'll both have it. so would i be the asshole if i did what my wife wants me to do and give the heirloom to sarah?
17,951
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/vvym1j/wibta_if_i_give_a_family_heirloom_belonging_to_my/
2022-07-10 19:09:36
yta for even considering it. your wife is also an even bigger ah for pressuring you to do it. it belonged to kate. it's you who adopted sarah, kate didn't. it should stay with kate's children. give it to claire on her 18th birthday. i don't trust your wife around it. you should seriously consider giving it to your son (or ideally kate's mother, if she's still alive) for safekeeping.
&gt;"this isn't yours to give away. it was mom's and now belongs to claire." your son is absolutely right. this is kate's inheritance to be passed down to *her* daughter. yta for even considering this and your wife is behaving dreadfully
yta if you and kate adopted sarah together, it would make sense for her to get the necklace. but kate never knew sarah so the necklace should 100% go to claire. if claire didn't exist, i would say it should go to one of kate's nieces. sarah would not make the list because she did not know kate. i am shocked your wife even suggested it. it was way out of line, the necklace belongs to kate's family.
yes you would be ta if the heirloom doesn't go to claire. it was kate's. it should go to kate's daughter. your wife needs to understand it's not yours to give. i'm sorry to say this but all her arguments against this seem like an attempt to emotionally manipulate you into giving it to sarah. and while it may make sarah feel happy, you would be robbing claire of something that was her mother's. maybe give it to your son to hold on to until claire is 18.
this is kind of unbelievable. are you a troll? of course the heirloom needs to go to kate's oldest daughter claire. not kate's widowed husband's new wife's oldest daughter sarah. that's not even a question. what kind of weird power play is this from the new wife? it's odd. you should tell her it's odd... and suggest she go talk it out with a therapist.
ywbta. this is a multi-generational heirloom and your late wife would have given it to claire if she was still living. sarah is your family, but she was not and is not your late wife’s family. your son is right, your current wife is wrong. if you give this heirloom to sarah, please know that your son, claire, and possibly many of your late wife’s family members will never forgive you for it.
yeah, yta if you do. it isn't your family's heirloom. it's kate's. this isn't about whether sarah is your daughter - of course she is. it is about whether sarah is **kate's** daughter. which she isn't. if it was from your mother - and your mother wanted it passed to your daughter - no problem. but it was from your mother in law. kate's mother. kate's grandmother. it should go to kate's daughter.
info what on earth reasoning did your wife have for why her daughter should get an inheritance from your first wife?
yta if you give away the heirloom intended for yours and kate’s daughter. your wife may have adopted claire, but kate will always be her mom. that is such a cruel thing to say, and shame on you for not correcting her. at the end of the day, because this came from her mom, it will mean a lot more to claire than sarah. sarah is your daughter too. but i’m sorry, she will not understand or appreciate the significance of something belonging to a woman she never met. please, learn from this guy https://www.reddit.com/r/amitheasshole/comments/vbzs2z/aita_for_telling_my_husband_he_should_be_ashamed/?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=ios_app&amp;utm_name=iossmf if you give it to sarah, be prepared to lose claire and your son.
i'm glad to see in comments that you seem to be resolved to give the heirloom to claire, but your son's reaction and your wife's blatant sense of entitlement gives me the impression that this isn't the first time this sort of thing has been an issue. i would suggest that you do some serious soul-searching and look back to see if there were other times that your current wife tried to erase your previous wife's memory (her insistence that claire is \*her\* daughter, not anyone else's for example, is creepy af), and perhaps talk with your son and really listen to his perspective on this.
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
null
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
null
0.007141
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my late wife kate passed away about 12 years ago. they have a family heirloom that has passed down several generations (starting from her great grandmother) from mothers to their first daughters, on their 18th (or thereabouts) birthdays. the heirloom itself is not highly valuable in a financial sense, but the history makes it very valuable to the people in the family. i currently possess it after kate passed away and i always intended to give it to my daughter, claire, on her 18th birthday. she is currently 16. i married my current wife about 8 years ago. my step daughter, sarah, (whom i have adopted and consider my own daughter) is 17 years and 11 months old, her 18th birthday is in a month. my wife has also adopted claire and we all consider each other as just one family. my wife asked me to give the heirloom to sarah on her birthday to continue the tradition. i was hesitant because i always intended it to give it to claire who is kate's only daughter as this is what she would have wanted and is the continuation of the tradition. my wife counters that this belongs to our family now and we should give it to our eldest daughter on her 18th birthday, and therefore this should be sarah. i told her that while i consider sarah to be my daughter but she's not kate's daughter, this belongs to kate and should go to kate's daughter. my wife said claire is her daughter, not anyone else's and wife accused me of playing favorites and told me that if i truly consider sarah to be my daughter then i'll do the right thing for her or that i haven't really accepted sarah as a real daughter yet. i consulted my son (from kate, 25 years old) and he told me that if i do this he's going to walk from the birthday party and that he bets he won't be the only one. he said if i do this i should be ready for severe consequences. he left in a very frustrated way. his argument in the end was that "this isn't yours to give away. it was mom's and now belongs to claire." my wife thinks my son is overreacting and it's only because due to his age and moving out he's never bonded with sarah like claire and i have, so he doesn't consider sarah to be his real sister, otherwise he'd be happy for her. my wife thinks claire will be happy about this since she considers sarah to be her big sister and it will bring the girls even closer together because sarah will happily share it with claire and they'll both have it. so would i be the asshole if i did what my wife wants me to do and give the heirloom to sarah?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my late wife kate passed away about 12 years ago. they have a family heirloom that has passed down several generations (starting from her great grandmother) from mothers to their first daughters, on their 18th (or thereabouts) birthdays. the heirloom itself is not highly valuable in a financial sense, but the history makes it very valuable to the people in the family. i currently possess it after kate passed away and i always intended to give it to my daughter, claire, on her 18th birthday. she is currently 16. i married my current wife about 8 years ago. my step daughter, sarah, (whom i have adopted and consider my own daughter) is 17 years and 11 months old, her 18th birthday is in a month. my wife has also adopted claire and we all consider each other as just one family. my wife asked me to give the heirloom to sarah on her birthday to continue the tradition. i was hesitant because i always intended it to give it to claire who is kate's only daughter as this is what she would have wanted and is the continuation of the tradition. my wife counters that this belongs to our family now and we should give it to our eldest daughter on her 18th birthday, and therefore this should be sarah. i told her that while i consider sarah to be my daughter but she's not kate's daughter, this belongs to kate and should go to kate's daughter. my wife said claire is her daughter, not anyone else's and wife accused me of playing favorites and told me that if i truly consider sarah to be my daughter then i'll do the right thing for her or that i haven't really accepted sarah as a real daughter yet. i consulted my son (from kate, 25 years old) and he told me that if i do this he's going to walk from the birthday party and that he bets he won't be the only one. he said if i do this i should be ready for severe consequences. he left in a very frustrated way. his argument in the end was that "this isn't yours to give away. it was mom's and now belongs to claire." my wife thinks my son is overreacting and it's only because due to his age and moving out he's never bonded with sarah like claire and i have, so he doesn't consider sarah to be his real sister, otherwise he'd be happy for her. my wife thinks claire will be happy about this since she considers sarah to be her big sister and it will bring the girls even closer together because sarah will happily share it with claire and they'll both have it. so would i be the asshole if i did what my wife wants me to do and give the heirloom to sarah? [/INST] yta for even considering it. your wife is also an even bigger ah for pressuring you to do it. it belonged to kate. it's you who adopted sarah, kate didn't. it should stay with kate's children. give it to claire on her 18th birthday. i don't trust your wife around it. you should seriously consider giving it to your son (or ideally kate's mother, if she's still alive) for safekeeping. </s>
AITA for keeping the engagement ring and giving up asking to propose (after propose) in front of my parents and in-laws?
my (25f) girlfriend, molly (26f) for the last... 6 months started with a joke that i've already made clear that i don't like. it consists of her saying "no" quickly to anything i ask. i know it sounds silly, but i ask her to get a glass of water for me, she says no and after 1 minute, i'm almost getting up, she says she's joking and gets some water. i ask her to wash the dishes, she says no.... i say i love you, she says no... i ask her to take her clothes, she says no. everything is joking and after 30s/1min, she does it, but she is "addicted" to doing it. i've already made it clear several times that i don't like it, even more so in i love you (she's the only person i can say that, so it's special to me). and there are things that are serious and i need her to answer seriously. and if she says no to everything jokingly, i can't tell when she's saying a real no (it's already happened). i keep saying this is boring and i don't like it, she stops doing it and goes back to doing it after a week. after a brief discussion because she played this prank in front of our friends (me asking "love, can you get me some medicine?" and she with no kidding), she stopped doing it for 1 month. yesterday, we welcomed my parents, in-laws and our 2 best friends to our house. everyone knew that i was going to propose to her and i called them, because we always planned this proposal with our loved ones attending, participating in this special day. i asked her to marry me and she said a quick no and i was so grumpy/panic/upset (everyone looking in shock) for 30s for her to laugh and say she was joking, finally saying yes. i was so embarrassed and…disappointed? i put the ring box back in and said i'd take it out to cool off. i didn't even let her say anything. she kept texting me (no answering calls), saying it was just a joke and that i knew she always did that. she said that i left an difficult situation in the house because it was very clear that i had given up on propose and did in front of my parents and in-laws. she stressed that i was making the situation uncomfortable because of a silly joke. well, i slept in a hotel and i'm still in it. my parents supported me, but my in-laws calling me ah for giving up on proposing, disproportionately humiliating their daughter. i just really think there's time for jokes and that moment wasn't clearly, she knew i didn't like it and decided to do it anyway. aita?
27,815
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/wloe2s/aita_for_keeping_the_engagement_ring_and_giving/
2022-08-11 10:48:07
nta why would you sign up for this permanently?
nta your girlfriend just learned a much-needed lesson on why you don’t joke and say no when you mean yes. and you are not making the situation uncomfortable because of a “silly joke” — she is. she knew you don’t like it (and honestly, who would? that would annoy the fuck out of most people) but she did it anyway. what next? is she going to jokingly say no during your ceremony?
nta. out of all the things that are wrong from her side, one that stands out to me the most is that afterward she still puts the blame on you and does not even apologize. if you see that your partner is hurt by something you did (yes, even a joke) any well-adjusted human being would apologize. also, if other people are not laughing, i wouldn't even call it a joke. and you are correct to think that there is time and place for jokes. i can imagine how hurtful and embarrassing it was to hear the ''no'' to your proposal in front of your family. such a dick move.
nta, and this is coming from a family who does it a lot. me and my siblings love to be like "can you grab me a drink when you go past?" with a quick "nope" only to do it anyway with all the variations. the sibling or our mom (who loves to do this with us as well) usually just say "oh, okay!" cause we know the joke. here's the thing, we don't do the joke with our dad. while the rest of us finds it funny, he is quick to feel upset and not understand when our 'no' is joking like you do, so we don't do it. we don't do it because we love and respect him and know it can be quickly upsetting to him, and he loves other pranks/jokes with us so we just find other things to share the fun in with him. i would also like to add we never do it in serious situations or things that need an actual answer or conversation, there are times and places for these things which she is not understanding. this is not about you 'taking it too seriously' or anything else, if she truly loved and respected you, she would stop. it's simple to remember and do as someone who has almost their entire immediate family doing it on a daily basis, who also remember and don't do it for one of them out of *love and respect*. i have to stress that because that is the huge issue here and she needs to work on what she is willing to compromise on if she ever wants to have a life with you with both of you happy. i wish you the best and i hope she either wakes up and realizes she is completely in the wrong here, or you find someone who is willing to do that for you. nta, you are right and keep your boundary here.
nta. i am sorry this happened to you and i don't think you're overreacting. a joke is a joke only if all involved people are laughing and you made it clear months ago that you didn't find it funny. the first question one should always ask if "why this particular joke", especially if someone claims they cannot stop it. so maybe your girlfriend (not fiancée) should take a look at herself and ask herself that question, especially if she couldn't even manage it in a more serious and emotional situation. i would hold off on proposing until you both get that cleared up (also, since saying "no" to i love you is veeeery strange, it's not even a request by you?)
nta. i'd take no for an answer if i were you.
nta. you have repeatedly told her that you don't enjoy this joke especially in serious or romantic contacts, then when it was time for the most serious and most romantic moment she whips it right out. the only person that was making the situation uncomfortable and humiliating was her. you asked something very clear and direct and she fucked it up hard.
nta. you made yourself clear. she's acting like a child. marriage proposals aren't for children. she may have saved you the cost of a divorce later though.
nta and the in-laws need to step off. you humiliated her? uhm, no. she humiliated *you* on instinct because apparently she thinks she’s hilarious when she isn’t. i’d be so upset if i were you and honestly i don’t know how you’ve put up with 6 months of no’s as an automatic response. that would really shut me down. rethink your whole relationship op.
nta but why do you plan your life with someone who has been disrespecting a clear and easy boundary you have for 6 months and is now letting your in laws bash you ? i’m not saying live but at least try couple’s counseling before proposing again because i don’t see it getting better. edit typo
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my (25f) girlfriend, molly (26f) for the last... 6 months started with a joke that i've already made clear that i don't like. it consists of her saying "no" quickly to anything i ask. i know it sounds silly, but i ask her to get a glass of water for me, she says no and after 1 minute, i'm almost getting up, she says she's joking and gets some water. i ask her to wash the dishes, she says no.... i say i love you, she says no... i ask her to take her clothes, she says no. everything is joking and after 30s/1min, she does it, but she is "addicted" to doing it. i've already made it clear several times that i don't like it, even more so in i love you (she's the only person i can say that, so it's special to me). and there are things that are serious and i need her to answer seriously. and if she says no to everything jokingly, i can't tell when she's saying a real no (it's already happened). i keep saying this is boring and i don't like it, she stops doing it and goes back to doing it after a week. after a brief discussion because she played this prank in front of our friends (me asking "love, can you get me some medicine?" and she with no kidding), she stopped doing it for 1 month. yesterday, we welcomed my parents, in-laws and our 2 best friends to our house. everyone knew that i was going to propose to her and i called them, because we always planned this proposal with our loved ones attending, participating in this special day. i asked her to marry me and she said a quick no and i was so grumpy/panic/upset (everyone looking in shock) for 30s for her to laugh and say she was joking, finally saying yes. i was so embarrassed and…disappointed? i put the ring box back in and said i'd take it out to cool off. i didn't even let her say anything. she kept texting me (no answering calls), saying it was just a joke and that i knew she always did that. she said that i left an difficult situation in the house because it was very clear that i had given up on propose and did in front of my parents and in-laws. she stressed that i was making the situation uncomfortable because of a silly joke. well, i slept in a hotel and i'm still in it. my parents supported me, but my in-laws calling me ah for giving up on proposing, disproportionately humiliating their daughter. i just really think there's time for jokes and that moment wasn't clearly, she knew i didn't like it and decided to do it anyway. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my (25f) girlfriend, molly (26f) for the last... 6 months started with a joke that i've already made clear that i don't like. it consists of her saying "no" quickly to anything i ask. i know it sounds silly, but i ask her to get a glass of water for me, she says no and after 1 minute, i'm almost getting up, she says she's joking and gets some water. i ask her to wash the dishes, she says no.... i say i love you, she says no... i ask her to take her clothes, she says no. everything is joking and after 30s/1min, she does it, but she is "addicted" to doing it. i've already made it clear several times that i don't like it, even more so in i love you (she's the only person i can say that, so it's special to me). and there are things that are serious and i need her to answer seriously. and if she says no to everything jokingly, i can't tell when she's saying a real no (it's already happened). i keep saying this is boring and i don't like it, she stops doing it and goes back to doing it after a week. after a brief discussion because she played this prank in front of our friends (me asking "love, can you get me some medicine?" and she with no kidding), she stopped doing it for 1 month. yesterday, we welcomed my parents, in-laws and our 2 best friends to our house. everyone knew that i was going to propose to her and i called them, because we always planned this proposal with our loved ones attending, participating in this special day. i asked her to marry me and she said a quick no and i was so grumpy/panic/upset (everyone looking in shock) for 30s for her to laugh and say she was joking, finally saying yes. i was so embarrassed and…disappointed? i put the ring box back in and said i'd take it out to cool off. i didn't even let her say anything. she kept texting me (no answering calls), saying it was just a joke and that i knew she always did that. she said that i left an difficult situation in the house because it was very clear that i had given up on propose and did in front of my parents and in-laws. she stressed that i was making the situation uncomfortable because of a silly joke. well, i slept in a hotel and i'm still in it. my parents supported me, but my in-laws calling me ah for giving up on proposing, disproportionately humiliating their daughter. i just really think there's time for jokes and that moment wasn't clearly, she knew i didn't like it and decided to do it anyway. aita? [/INST] nta why would you sign up for this permanently? </s>
AITA for accusing my girlfriend of getting pregnant intentionally?
i’ve been dating my girlfriend for 4 years, living together for one year now. we’re both 26. our relationship has been great for the most part but i noticed that since we moved in together my girlfriend has been talking more and more about having children, her pinterest is filled with stuff about baby clothes, nursery decorating and raising kids (as well as tons of wedding stuff). she follows a lot of family accounts on instagram she would once in a while send me videos of kids and say “lol this is totally our future kid) i was very adamant that i wanted to wait until we could afford a house, pay off some debts and establish our careers before getting married and then we would have kids. she just finished her masters and i finished physiotherapist school and would love to start my own physiotherapy business in the future. she always agreed that we weren’t ready for kids but it was obvious she had intense baby fever. my girlfriend is on birth control and takes the depo provera shot every 3 months. 3 days ago my girlfriend tells me that she’s 2 months pregnant and she just found out. i was absolutely shocked. honestly i suggested an abortion at this point but my girlfriend was adamant against it and said she was pretty excited for the baby and was mad i was even suggesting abortion. so honestly, i did accuse her of intentionally getting pregnant because it honestly just made the most sense. she was acting so excited like it was planned, her past behaviour showed she was looking forward to a baby and i never followed up to make sure she was getting all her shots. she had been on the same form of birth control our entire relationship with barely a pregnancy scare and suddenly she’s pregnant? when i accused her of getting pregnant on purpose she got mad at me and says she would have never done that and she knows that it isn’t the perfect time to have a child and she been getting all her depo shots but “god had other plans” and we could make it work. i again accused her of lying and this was just too much of a coincidence. we argue back and forth and she gets really angry and runs away to her moms house. she then texts me a picture of a receipt for her most recent depo shot 9 weeks ago with the caption “you are a fucking asshole”. she blocked me and refuses to respond to any of my messages. i already apologized many times but i honestly don’t think i was the asshole to question her intentionally getting pregnant. from my point of view it made sense. i really hope we can make this work but am i really the asshole here, when looking at my perspective of the situation?
11,021
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/e1359t/aita_for_accusing_my_girlfriend_of_getting/
2019-11-24 19:22:50
yta big time here. just because a she has always dreamed of a mom doesn’t mean she would undermine your trust and sabotage your current life plans. do you not trust her as a person at all? considering that she’s open about wanting kids it makes sense that she would want to keep an oops baby because in her mind it just changed the timing, not the occurrence.
yta if pregnancy was a major no no then you should have been more involved in actual birth control. you were happy with her having 100% responsibility. no birth control is 100%. &gt;she had been on the same form of birth control our entire relationship with barely a pregnancy scare and suddenly she’s pregnant? welcome to the world of women! we punish ourselves with birth control that causes all manner of side effects and then bam! pregnant anyway. you didn't question her, you interrogated her and accused her of trapping you with a baby, not the same thing.
yta. holy shit. you are 100% wrong in this case. someone can want to be a mom, but know better. birth control fails. it's why if you really want to be sure that you don't knock a girl up you use a damn condom on top of whatever she's using.
yta and you already know it. you were the asshole from the moment you didn't wear a condom, since you were so against having a child, and you've only gotten worse. frankly, you don't sound ready to be a father. you're not showing the capacity for carrying for another person, or taking responsibility for yourself, let alone a child. i hope, for the sake of the baby, she doesn't return. it seems it would be in the child's best interest if you didn't try for custody.
yta. you didn't ask. you accused. repeatedly.
yta. first you could have insisted on wearing a condom. doesn’t sound like you were doing your part. secondly, she’s pregnant and you suggest an abortion?! thirdly, this is reality now, and she’s in a very vulnerable place right now, and she needs you to be supportive. why are you with her if her getting pregnant is such an issue?
yta she just finished her masters. she’s obviously thinking about the next major life milestones. she can picture herself marrying you and having a baby with you. you didn’t just accuse her of getting pregnant intentionally, you refused to believe her and called her a liar. twice. and to make it worse you used your past history of no/few pregnancy scares, pinterest, her refusal to have an abortion, and her happiness as your proof. stop thinking about your own perspective, and put yourself in her shoes. how would you feel if the person you love refused to believe you are telling the truth because you were happy about something?
100% yta. not to mention where tf is your trust in this 4 year relationship??!
i got pregnant on the depot shot and didn’t find out until i was 3 months into my pregnancy. birth control is not 100%, if you really wanted to lower the chances of her getting pregnant you also should have used birth control.
yta. you accused her of getting pregnant on purpose and then argued about it when she told you she had been getting her shots. you didn't believe her denials and kept arguing until she left. i get being shocked by unexpected news, but there is no 100% effective form of birth control and you didn't take any responsibility for your sperm by wearing a condom. liking baby clothes and posting about her hopes of having children in the future is not sufficient evidence for accusing someone of purposefully getting pregnant, and as it turns out, you were wrong. apologizing is not enough, you need to say more than 'i'm sorry i accused you of getting pregnant on purpose.' you need to say, 'i'm sorry i'm the kind of asshole who immediately gets defensive and angry when someone gives me bad news. i'm sorry i'm the kind of asshole who immediately assumed that my so would lie to me and trap me. i promise i'll try to become a better asshole.'
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i’ve been dating my girlfriend for 4 years, living together for one year now. we’re both 26. our relationship has been great for the most part but i noticed that since we moved in together my girlfriend has been talking more and more about having children, her pinterest is filled with stuff about baby clothes, nursery decorating and raising kids (as well as tons of wedding stuff). she follows a lot of family accounts on instagram she would once in a while send me videos of kids and say “lol this is totally our future kid) i was very adamant that i wanted to wait until we could afford a house, pay off some debts and establish our careers before getting married and then we would have kids. she just finished her masters and i finished physiotherapist school and would love to start my own physiotherapy business in the future. she always agreed that we weren’t ready for kids but it was obvious she had intense baby fever. my girlfriend is on birth control and takes the depo provera shot every 3 months. 3 days ago my girlfriend tells me that she’s 2 months pregnant and she just found out. i was absolutely shocked. honestly i suggested an abortion at this point but my girlfriend was adamant against it and said she was pretty excited for the baby and was mad i was even suggesting abortion. so honestly, i did accuse her of intentionally getting pregnant because it honestly just made the most sense. she was acting so excited like it was planned, her past behaviour showed she was looking forward to a baby and i never followed up to make sure she was getting all her shots. she had been on the same form of birth control our entire relationship with barely a pregnancy scare and suddenly she’s pregnant? when i accused her of getting pregnant on purpose she got mad at me and says she would have never done that and she knows that it isn’t the perfect time to have a child and she been getting all her depo shots but “god had other plans” and we could make it work. i again accused her of lying and this was just too much of a coincidence. we argue back and forth and she gets really angry and runs away to her moms house. she then texts me a picture of a receipt for her most recent depo shot 9 weeks ago with the caption “you are a fucking asshole”. she blocked me and refuses to respond to any of my messages. i already apologized many times but i honestly don’t think i was the asshole to question her intentionally getting pregnant. from my point of view it made sense. i really hope we can make this work but am i really the asshole here, when looking at my perspective of the situation?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i’ve been dating my girlfriend for 4 years, living together for one year now. we’re both 26. our relationship has been great for the most part but i noticed that since we moved in together my girlfriend has been talking more and more about having children, her pinterest is filled with stuff about baby clothes, nursery decorating and raising kids (as well as tons of wedding stuff). she follows a lot of family accounts on instagram she would once in a while send me videos of kids and say “lol this is totally our future kid) i was very adamant that i wanted to wait until we could afford a house, pay off some debts and establish our careers before getting married and then we would have kids. she just finished her masters and i finished physiotherapist school and would love to start my own physiotherapy business in the future. she always agreed that we weren’t ready for kids but it was obvious she had intense baby fever. my girlfriend is on birth control and takes the depo provera shot every 3 months. 3 days ago my girlfriend tells me that she’s 2 months pregnant and she just found out. i was absolutely shocked. honestly i suggested an abortion at this point but my girlfriend was adamant against it and said she was pretty excited for the baby and was mad i was even suggesting abortion. so honestly, i did accuse her of intentionally getting pregnant because it honestly just made the most sense. she was acting so excited like it was planned, her past behaviour showed she was looking forward to a baby and i never followed up to make sure she was getting all her shots. she had been on the same form of birth control our entire relationship with barely a pregnancy scare and suddenly she’s pregnant? when i accused her of getting pregnant on purpose she got mad at me and says she would have never done that and she knows that it isn’t the perfect time to have a child and she been getting all her depo shots but “god had other plans” and we could make it work. i again accused her of lying and this was just too much of a coincidence. we argue back and forth and she gets really angry and runs away to her moms house. she then texts me a picture of a receipt for her most recent depo shot 9 weeks ago with the caption “you are a fucking asshole”. she blocked me and refuses to respond to any of my messages. i already apologized many times but i honestly don’t think i was the asshole to question her intentionally getting pregnant. from my point of view it made sense. i really hope we can make this work but am i really the asshole here, when looking at my perspective of the situation? [/INST] yta big time here. just because a she has always dreamed of a mom doesn’t mean she would undermine your trust and sabotage your current life plans. do you not trust her as a person at all? considering that she’s open about wanting kids it makes sense that she would want to keep an oops baby because in her mind it just changed the timing, not the occurrence. </s>
AITA for no longer inviting my brother to my house?
last weekend i had a small get together for immediate family only (they are in our social bubble) for my sons birthday. my brother brought my nephew (8m) to my house. he has a history of being destructive to people’s homes, and my brother and sil do not discipline him. according to them he just doesn’t listen so they just give him what he wants. this is not the first time my nephew has destroyed my house, or other relatives for that matter, and i finally had enough. the last time they were over, my son (17m) him mistreating our cat. after they left and saw that he dumped out all of our soap and shampoo in the bathroom on the floor when my daughter (15f) slipped on the tiles. this last visit he drew all over a brand new couch with the markers sil brought for him to color with. i had asked her to not let him color on the couch, instead he should color at the kitchen table so it could be washed off. when i confronted my sil about it she told me “it’s just a couch, you can get slip covers.” i told her that wasn’t the point, that once again he has come to my house and destroyed something and i was tired of having to pay to clean/replace the things he destroyed. my brother intervened and said that i was being over dramatic and that he was just a kid. i told my brother that they needed to leave. the next day i called him and told him that they werent welcome back into my house and that they could either pay for someone to come clean the couch or for the cost of a replacement. my brother told me that it was never going to happen. an hour later i get a call from my other sister who congratulated me for sticking to my guns and she plans to do the same. my mom got wind of this and called me and told me that i was being out of line and that nephew doesn’t mean to do this and that it was an accident. that according to sil you can barely see it and i was just trying to get a free couch. so i sent my mom a picture of the doodles on my couch that nephew made. she now agrees my brother should absolutely pay to clean the couch or replace it but that i am going too far by banning them from my home. i told her i disagreed and that he can always go to her house and destroy her stuff if she wants to see us all together. aita for not inviting them to my house anymore?
20,425
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/je4rm3/aita_for_no_longer_inviting_my_brother_to_my_house/
2020-10-19 16:19:59
nta. 8 is old enough to know better then to draw on furniture. that's something i'd expect from a 4 year old.
[deleted]
your nephew is the asshole. it's like your brother and sister-in-law rubbed their assholes together and made a bigger asshole. yantah years ago my sister came into town with her little monsters. my wife had enough when they were rubbing their hands across our fridge knocking off all the magnets and child art. she laid into them like they were her own kids. had them in line real quick. my sister must have been numb to their antics. she suddenly started keeping a closer eye on her sons. i predict bad things for your nephew. stay strong. your brother is betraying a family trust by not respecting your home. document all future encounters. they sound like they are not above trying to turn your mother against you. oh, and we want to see the pictures :d
nta accidents are one thing, but the incidents you're describing seem pretty deliberate and like they could be prevented with better parental supervision.
&gt;my brother intervened and said that i was being over dramatic and that he was just a kid. normal 8yos know that it's not ok to color on someone else's couch. hell, my daughter has more-or-less learned this lesson, and she's *2*. nta.
nta that kid is way too old not to know right from wrong and your brother is a spineless douche also : &gt;my son (17m) him mistreating our cat. i've watched enough netflix serial killer stuff to know he's gonna grow up to wear people's skin
nta you shouldn't have to deal with property damage every time you get a visit from your entitled brother and his entitled family.
nta, hold your ground and send them the bill asap. take it to small claims if you must. that kid needs to start being disciplined. hes 8 and acts like a monster. his parents need to wake up and parent him. i would have kicked them out the second time he destroyed something and billed for it.
nta. firstly, supervising your child is different from expecting an infant to behave at 8m. he has time to picasso your couch and cause the fall for your daughter, sounds like this child is unattended a lot of the time, free to roam. i would absolutely not invite them back until a new couch was purchased. stick to your guns. "mom, this isn't the first incident where they've failed to watch the child in my home. they don't bring a playpen to contain him, don't supervise him at all or respect my wishes to use certain areas of my home for activities because they don't have any basic respect. they told you it was a little doodle, they lied to your face and now you can see the damage isn't minor in the photos, see that they lied and they manipulated you into calling to scold me. they're welcome back, without the child leaving their sight (if they have to get a little leash for him or lock him in a playpen to scream the whole time because he's not getting his way, sometimes needs must as the devil drives) after they've paid to replace the brand new couch that was damaged by their poor parenting and lack of responsibility." this is a very fair ask. no one's expecting them to do anything but control their child or stay home. the idea that anyone thinks that is unreasonable is laughable. if the child destroyed furniture in a store, they'd be paying for it, and the idea that your family would come into your home, ruin your nice belongings, injure your child (slips in bathrooms can be deadly) and then call you an ah.... that's next level. at least your sister supports you and backs you even if your mom is crazy like your brother.
nta. it really isn’t acceptable for a kid that is 8 years old to be destroying things like that. seems pretty rude and disrespectful that ur brother wouldn’t even discipline his kid or offer to pay for ur destroyed stuff. also the fact that the kid was mistreating the cat is a big red flag and honestly protect ur pets and ur house before anything else. ur daughter slipped and could have gotten really injured from what this kid did. don’t let them back in the house it really seems like ur brother and his wife have no regard for anyone else and are very entitled.
NTA
null
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: last weekend i had a small get together for immediate family only (they are in our social bubble) for my sons birthday. my brother brought my nephew (8m) to my house. he has a history of being destructive to people’s homes, and my brother and sil do not discipline him. according to them he just doesn’t listen so they just give him what he wants. this is not the first time my nephew has destroyed my house, or other relatives for that matter, and i finally had enough. the last time they were over, my son (17m) him mistreating our cat. after they left and saw that he dumped out all of our soap and shampoo in the bathroom on the floor when my daughter (15f) slipped on the tiles. this last visit he drew all over a brand new couch with the markers sil brought for him to color with. i had asked her to not let him color on the couch, instead he should color at the kitchen table so it could be washed off. when i confronted my sil about it she told me “it’s just a couch, you can get slip covers.” i told her that wasn’t the point, that once again he has come to my house and destroyed something and i was tired of having to pay to clean/replace the things he destroyed. my brother intervened and said that i was being over dramatic and that he was just a kid. i told my brother that they needed to leave. the next day i called him and told him that they werent welcome back into my house and that they could either pay for someone to come clean the couch or for the cost of a replacement. my brother told me that it was never going to happen. an hour later i get a call from my other sister who congratulated me for sticking to my guns and she plans to do the same. my mom got wind of this and called me and told me that i was being out of line and that nephew doesn’t mean to do this and that it was an accident. that according to sil you can barely see it and i was just trying to get a free couch. so i sent my mom a picture of the doodles on my couch that nephew made. she now agrees my brother should absolutely pay to clean the couch or replace it but that i am going too far by banning them from my home. i told her i disagreed and that he can always go to her house and destroy her stuff if she wants to see us all together. aita for not inviting them to my house anymore?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> last weekend i had a small get together for immediate family only (they are in our social bubble) for my sons birthday. my brother brought my nephew (8m) to my house. he has a history of being destructive to people’s homes, and my brother and sil do not discipline him. according to them he just doesn’t listen so they just give him what he wants. this is not the first time my nephew has destroyed my house, or other relatives for that matter, and i finally had enough. the last time they were over, my son (17m) him mistreating our cat. after they left and saw that he dumped out all of our soap and shampoo in the bathroom on the floor when my daughter (15f) slipped on the tiles. this last visit he drew all over a brand new couch with the markers sil brought for him to color with. i had asked her to not let him color on the couch, instead he should color at the kitchen table so it could be washed off. when i confronted my sil about it she told me “it’s just a couch, you can get slip covers.” i told her that wasn’t the point, that once again he has come to my house and destroyed something and i was tired of having to pay to clean/replace the things he destroyed. my brother intervened and said that i was being over dramatic and that he was just a kid. i told my brother that they needed to leave. the next day i called him and told him that they werent welcome back into my house and that they could either pay for someone to come clean the couch or for the cost of a replacement. my brother told me that it was never going to happen. an hour later i get a call from my other sister who congratulated me for sticking to my guns and she plans to do the same. my mom got wind of this and called me and told me that i was being out of line and that nephew doesn’t mean to do this and that it was an accident. that according to sil you can barely see it and i was just trying to get a free couch. so i sent my mom a picture of the doodles on my couch that nephew made. she now agrees my brother should absolutely pay to clean the couch or replace it but that i am going too far by banning them from my home. i told her i disagreed and that he can always go to her house and destroy her stuff if she wants to see us all together. aita for not inviting them to my house anymore? [/INST] nta. 8 is old enough to know better then to draw on furniture. that's something i'd expect from a 4 year old. </s>
AITA for screaming at my sister at my engagement party
18,857
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/v4una6/aita_for_screaming_at_my_sister_at_my_engagement/
2022-06-04 18:19:10
nta. she literally made a move on your fiancé. your family is blind if they do not understand what she's doing.
nta and shame on your family for enabling her behaviour all these years. congrats on the wedding, go forth and live your best life, your sister can wallow in the misery of her own creation.
nta. you let out your true feelings, and it was deserved. honestly your twin seems psychotic. in no way are you the asshole, from her showing up trying to best you in dress to her making digs at your personality and throwing herself at your fiancé? it just got worse and worse. your family shouldn’t be trying to force this relationship on you and if anyone deserved to be scolded it would be your sister. i’m surprised you didn’t go no contact sooner, you and your fiancé should sit your family down (those who have an issue) and explain why this situation is not only bizarre but extremely uncomfortable to the both of you.
nta. she fucked around and found out. after a speech like that she had whatever you said and probably more coming to her.
nta: please respond to your entire family by asking them why they aren't telling her to get over herself. because you were fine when she came along and gave that speech. you're not the one who created this situation - again - and you are tired of being held responsible for behaving better than she does. acknowledge that the most hurtful pieces were over the line and you were so mad that you lost your cool, but overall - yeah, you're just tired of this dynamic entirely. you've had a lifetime of it, please tell her to get over herself and stop making you responsible for making everything okay.
nta m got what she deserved. don’t apologize. point out that m made a toast that was rude, nasty and completely out of line. ask who paid for m’s dress and makeover. then draw that line. tell them that, if they prefer m, they’re welcome to choose her psychosis over attending your wedding. stay strong and don’t kowtow to m’s enablers.
nta. it's about time you told her off and everyone finally heard what she has done to you. it's only a matter of time though before she starts creeping on fiance though so you may want to keep an eye out. also, 10 dollars says she wears white to your wedding because you know your mom is going to force you to have her there by using either the "if she isn't invited i'm not going" card or "i paid something so i get to decide your wedding". be prepared for either case by being ok for your mom to not come and don't let her pay for anything if you can afford it.
honestly, at this point, i would tell the family on her side that they, too, are welcome to fuck right off along with her. you’re done being treated like this, and expected to just accept it to keep the peace. nta.
nta. she came obviously trying to show you up and then made a very public pass at your fiance and then your mom did nothing about it but coddle her because her feelings are hurt. i would uninvite your family and go low to no contact. they are toxic and seemingly never going to change. you don't deserve that toxicity.
nta. i'd tell your parents to stay home as well. think of this: your mother knows your sister's past. your mother knew what you were wearing. your sister ended up with a dress similar to yours and professional hair and makeup. your sister is unemployed. who do you think bought her fancy dress and hair and makeup? probably her parents who she lives with.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context:
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> [/INST] nta. she literally made a move on your fiancé. your family is blind if they do not understand what she's doing. </s>
AITA for not wanting to get rid of my gang tattoos “for the sake of my daughter”?
i spent 7 years in prison and i got out three years ago. i’m now 30. i was a criminal and a horrible person. i did a lot of fucked up stuff, most of it related to my gang. i currently have a two year old daughter, mia. me and the mom aren’t married but we share custody of mia. when mia was born, i was already halfway out the door of the gang and the birth of mia gave me the push i needed. i moved away with mia and her mom and we tried our best to start over. i love mia with all my heart. she saved my life. i have a lot of gang related tattoos. and i do mean a lot. they are pretty prominently displayed on me and are noticeable. mia’s mother has been after me to get rid of them or cover them up with other tattoos. the thing is, i don’t think i want to do that. it’s not that i’m proud of them, or like them, it’s that they remind me of how far i’ve come and i don’t want to forget it. i don’t want to forget what happened. i don’t think i should get to just forget it like that. i eventually broke down and told her this after she asked me again yesterday about it. she got super upset with me and said that i needed to do it for the “sake of our daughter” and that if i didn’t then that meant i missed “the life.” she also said that i was putting my daughter in danger because somebody could recognize my tattoos and cause trouble for me. i told her i haven’t been in that life for years and that it’s unfair for her to say that as she knows that i love mia. i’m honestly conflicted. i’ve gone back and forth about what to do with my tattoos and i thought that i had reached a reasonable decision. aita?
6,567
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/dm7xx6/aita_for_not_wanting_to_get_rid_of_my_gang/
2019-10-23 23:39:20
yta but only gently though. you dont need your tattoos to remember. you dont need anything to remember how far you've come. if anything, you're daughter could be that for you. letting you know how far you've come, how far shes going to go. i know you want to keep them as a memory, but it's ok to let go now. her mother is right in that it could be dangerous. not just gangs trying to start trouble, but you could be unnecessarily harrassed by police due to the tattoos as well. you sound like a wonderful dad, and i hope everything goes well.
yta, but i get where you're coming from. you don't need a physical reminder of your past. that past landed you in prison, and your daughter's mother has a point in regards to your tattoos potentially causing problems for you in the future. if it's truly in your past, let it go. cover them up.
very gently yta. they mean something to you, and it’s great you’ve move on. but everyone else will see them as gang tattoos and judge them. you are asking mia to accept that strangers will judge her dad because they remind you of how far you’ve come.
yta- there could be so many negative consequences for your daughter. if the only reason you have them is as 'a reminder' then i think your daughter should be the priority. if they are distinctly gang tattoos, i would get rid of the ones you can't cover. a back tattoo for example, i wouldn't worry about, but a face,neck, forearm or hand tattoo i would look into getting it altered to something else or removed. going forward, if you pick your daughter up from school, will other parents tell their children not to be friends with her? what if they see you with her at the shops, will they not invite your daughter to play dates or birthday parties? what if she does really well at school and you interview for an elite school or program? or if she goes for a job interview at a cafe and the owner sees you dropping her off? i would seriously consider addressing some of the gang tattoos if you want to maintain a healthy relationship with your daughter in public.
oof, this is tough, but yta. i understand your feelings, and the sort of atonement it represents to you. but if your baby mama is at all right about your tattoos possibly eliciting unwanted attention, especially violence, then you should cover them. you want your daughter to have a safe home, and a safe dad. eventually she'll start school too, and it'll get around if her dad looks like a felon, it'll get her bullied and cost her friends when other moms hear about it. you served your time, you deserve to get to move forward. if you don't want to do it for yourself, do it for your daughter.
yta (partially) mia's mom makes a very good point of someone seeing the tattoos and making trouble/violence against mia. i think you should compromise and cover/remove the ones that are visible to the public. and keep the ones that are typically hidden by clothing. as your daughter ages your tattoos could cause more trouble for mia as well. not that it's _correct_ to do so, but i imagine that future teachers and her classmates parents will judge you harshly and/or isolate her from their children. you might say "who needs those assholes who would judge her for that?" but the answer is - mia. mia deserves to have the best opportunity to make friends and have a good relationship with her teachers. this _will_ be affected if her dad is covered in gang tattoos. seriously, can you imagine a typical suburban family inviting the "gang kid" to the sleepover? no matter how adorable and sweet mia is she will be left out if people are scared of you.
info. isn't it dangerous to be walking around with gang tattoos if you're no longer in the gang? hell, the trouble with the cops alone is going to disrupt your ability to be a present father. to say nothing of getting a steady job...
info: is she right? could the tattoos cause trouble for your daughter if recognized?
nah — hey dude it's great that you turned your life around for the better. but i also understand the mother's concern, and your daughter's safety should be a higher priority. is there a way you could add to the tattoo in a way that further symbolizes your transformation without totally covering it up? in the future if your daughter asks about the tattoo, it can open up a conversation about how you learned from past mistakes and became the best version of yourself.
i think your reasoning is good and it's your right to decide, so i vote nah, but you should be aware that it's a pretty common response for normal, non-criminal people to be revolted when they see people with gang tattoos like you, and you're always going to be "mia's father, the gangbanger" that the other parents don't trust.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
INFO
NAH
NAH
0.158114
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i spent 7 years in prison and i got out three years ago. i’m now 30. i was a criminal and a horrible person. i did a lot of fucked up stuff, most of it related to my gang. i currently have a two year old daughter, mia. me and the mom aren’t married but we share custody of mia. when mia was born, i was already halfway out the door of the gang and the birth of mia gave me the push i needed. i moved away with mia and her mom and we tried our best to start over. i love mia with all my heart. she saved my life. i have a lot of gang related tattoos. and i do mean a lot. they are pretty prominently displayed on me and are noticeable. mia’s mother has been after me to get rid of them or cover them up with other tattoos. the thing is, i don’t think i want to do that. it’s not that i’m proud of them, or like them, it’s that they remind me of how far i’ve come and i don’t want to forget it. i don’t want to forget what happened. i don’t think i should get to just forget it like that. i eventually broke down and told her this after she asked me again yesterday about it. she got super upset with me and said that i needed to do it for the “sake of our daughter” and that if i didn’t then that meant i missed “the life.” she also said that i was putting my daughter in danger because somebody could recognize my tattoos and cause trouble for me. i told her i haven’t been in that life for years and that it’s unfair for her to say that as she knows that i love mia. i’m honestly conflicted. i’ve gone back and forth about what to do with my tattoos and i thought that i had reached a reasonable decision. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i spent 7 years in prison and i got out three years ago. i’m now 30. i was a criminal and a horrible person. i did a lot of fucked up stuff, most of it related to my gang. i currently have a two year old daughter, mia. me and the mom aren’t married but we share custody of mia. when mia was born, i was already halfway out the door of the gang and the birth of mia gave me the push i needed. i moved away with mia and her mom and we tried our best to start over. i love mia with all my heart. she saved my life. i have a lot of gang related tattoos. and i do mean a lot. they are pretty prominently displayed on me and are noticeable. mia’s mother has been after me to get rid of them or cover them up with other tattoos. the thing is, i don’t think i want to do that. it’s not that i’m proud of them, or like them, it’s that they remind me of how far i’ve come and i don’t want to forget it. i don’t want to forget what happened. i don’t think i should get to just forget it like that. i eventually broke down and told her this after she asked me again yesterday about it. she got super upset with me and said that i needed to do it for the “sake of our daughter” and that if i didn’t then that meant i missed “the life.” she also said that i was putting my daughter in danger because somebody could recognize my tattoos and cause trouble for me. i told her i haven’t been in that life for years and that it’s unfair for her to say that as she knows that i love mia. i’m honestly conflicted. i’ve gone back and forth about what to do with my tattoos and i thought that i had reached a reasonable decision. aita? [/INST] yta but only gently though. you dont need your tattoos to remember. you dont need anything to remember how far you've come. if anything, you're daughter could be that for you. letting you know how far you've come, how far shes going to go. i know you want to keep them as a memory, but it's ok to let go now. her mother is right in that it could be dangerous. not just gangs trying to start trouble, but you could be unnecessarily harrassed by police due to the tattoos as well. you sound like a wonderful dad, and i hope everything goes well. </s>
AITA i uploaded a video the school made onto youtube and it got put into a cringe compilation? school is fucking pissed
my school last year made this really dumbass video where the teachers and students were trying to parody a pop song and make it school related while doing stupid dances like the whip and fortnite shit. it had teachers and some students, it was obviously cringe as hell. i uploaded it onto youtube and it got like maybe 5-10 k views. then some huge youtube channel that focuses on cringe compilations of various different things uploaded it into a "school cringe compilation" and that got around several hundred thousand views or so. i won't send the video cuz that'll break the rules here. the school has launched and investigation trying to discover who was responsible for the upload and they're pissed because it "tarnished" the school's reputation and they're blaming it on the decrease in enrollment. they sent out a massive email to us and they are urging us to turn ourselves in if we're involved and the very very very severe consequences will be reduced. i made an anonymous email and basically mocked the email and made jokes and memes and sent an email out to the entire school. the teachers have accused me and some of my friends and searched my computer but i wiped it cleaner than hillary clinton's email server. the school can't prove shit and they're so crazy trying to figure it out. look i get i might be the asshole for the anyomous email, and i feel bad for that so don't call me an asshole for that, but am i the asshole for everything else?
3,369
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ftnozo/aita_i_uploaded_a_video_the_school_made_onto/
2020-04-02 14:53:24
yta. you didn't have the right to upload it to youtube because it wasn't your video. you clearly did that to make fun of it which in other contexts is called bullying. just because many other reddit users would have done the same thing in that situation doesn't mean it's not an asshole thing to do. it just means many other reddit users are also assholes.
yta i'm so glad i grew up during a time where not everything you filmed got posted on the internet. all teens make awkward and cringy videos. that's their thing. the way you described the video, it sounds awkward but making fun of adults is one thing. there were kids involved too and now it's on the internet forever. they did not hurt anyone with the video.
yta i know i'm going to get downvoted to hell, but "cringe" has gotten, well, cringy. it uses to be about all of us sharing a moment of someone being shitty and universally cringing, now it's "hey you did something un-ironically and it sucked! cringe" no one was hurt by them making a stupid video, they aren't famous youtubers or public figures essentially agreeing to be discussed online, it's just kids from your school. personally i think it's more cringey to make fun of your classmates for doing nothing wrong.
yta. it was reasonable for the school to expect that you would not breach its copyright. you have embarrassed the school as a whole. more important, you have embarrassed many blameless members of the school community.
info - where did the school upload this video? if it was on a public domain i’m not really sure what the consequences could be for this or why they’re upset about it. it’s 2020, everything that’s released on the internet has a chance to go viral. i’m sure the students and teachers wouldn’t be upset if it went viral in a good way. that sounds like it may have even been their original intention. i do feel bad for the kids in the video - i was in a video that went viral in a bad way and received millions of views and i was bullied and harassed as a result. but i also participated in the video with the full knowledge it could go viral just as i’m sure these students and professors did. again, it’s just a risk of putting videos of yourself out on the public domain at this point. if you took it from a private class or private school page then yta. if it was already visible for anyone to see, then esh. consider the potential mental health consequences your actions could’ve had on the students/professors, and think twice before doing something which the only point of is humiliating others.
yta. i mean ya they made the video public in the first place but think of those poor ppl who were featured in it, they must be getting so much hate. it wasnt your decision to put them up there imo, if they wanted it in a cringe comp they woulda uploaded it to youtube themselves.
yta if you can see teachers and children in there, which i assume is the case. you dont just upload other people and their faces or bodies or actions on yt or anywhere else without their consent
what the hell are these answers? reddits entire premise is pretty much reposting other people's work and videos. there is rarely any consent given for these reposts. if there is something wrong with this then you may as well boycott the entirety of this website.
esh. you, for uploading a video a lot of people made probably expecting it to be private, and the school for making it into such a big deal when there is no proof that it was purely a negative thing and caused the enrollment numbers to drop.
nta lmaoooo. these comments and your school are taking this was too seriously.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
null
ESH
NTA
0.099413
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my school last year made this really dumbass video where the teachers and students were trying to parody a pop song and make it school related while doing stupid dances like the whip and fortnite shit. it had teachers and some students, it was obviously cringe as hell. i uploaded it onto youtube and it got like maybe 5-10 k views. then some huge youtube channel that focuses on cringe compilations of various different things uploaded it into a "school cringe compilation" and that got around several hundred thousand views or so. i won't send the video cuz that'll break the rules here. the school has launched and investigation trying to discover who was responsible for the upload and they're pissed because it "tarnished" the school's reputation and they're blaming it on the decrease in enrollment. they sent out a massive email to us and they are urging us to turn ourselves in if we're involved and the very very very severe consequences will be reduced. i made an anonymous email and basically mocked the email and made jokes and memes and sent an email out to the entire school. the teachers have accused me and some of my friends and searched my computer but i wiped it cleaner than hillary clinton's email server. the school can't prove shit and they're so crazy trying to figure it out. look i get i might be the asshole for the anyomous email, and i feel bad for that so don't call me an asshole for that, but am i the asshole for everything else?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my school last year made this really dumbass video where the teachers and students were trying to parody a pop song and make it school related while doing stupid dances like the whip and fortnite shit. it had teachers and some students, it was obviously cringe as hell. i uploaded it onto youtube and it got like maybe 5-10 k views. then some huge youtube channel that focuses on cringe compilations of various different things uploaded it into a "school cringe compilation" and that got around several hundred thousand views or so. i won't send the video cuz that'll break the rules here. the school has launched and investigation trying to discover who was responsible for the upload and they're pissed because it "tarnished" the school's reputation and they're blaming it on the decrease in enrollment. they sent out a massive email to us and they are urging us to turn ourselves in if we're involved and the very very very severe consequences will be reduced. i made an anonymous email and basically mocked the email and made jokes and memes and sent an email out to the entire school. the teachers have accused me and some of my friends and searched my computer but i wiped it cleaner than hillary clinton's email server. the school can't prove shit and they're so crazy trying to figure it out. look i get i might be the asshole for the anyomous email, and i feel bad for that so don't call me an asshole for that, but am i the asshole for everything else? [/INST] yta. you didn't have the right to upload it to youtube because it wasn't your video. you clearly did that to make fun of it which in other contexts is called bullying. just because many other reddit users would have done the same thing in that situation doesn't mean it's not an asshole thing to do. it just means many other reddit users are also assholes. </s>
WIBTA if I turned in a group of doctors that initially refused to treat me for a life-threatening illness bc they refused to believe it was possible for me to have it?
ok, so for context i am a disabled military vet from my time spent overseas. 36 year old, female. i rely on the treatment from the va systems for my healthcare. which in my personal experiences has always been wonderful in my area. a few weeks ago i was rushed to the er with what was the worst head pain i had ever felt and it had come on in an instant. ct ended up being clear and it was diagnosed as a migraine. the next day is when hell started for me. enter two weeks of near-constant agonizing pain. a severely swollen left temple, bad jaw pain, my vision in my left eye was getting worse/seeing double, and there were other symptoms stacked on top of those. i had been requesting to be seen immediately by my gp (i have most of these requests backed up in emails) and was blown off. i had a strong hunch at what was wrong with me even though (according to the wise dr. google) not suppose to get temporal arteritis until at least age 50. i just wanted to be taken seriously bc i know my body. i feel i have a good grasp on my personal pain levels bc of injuries i have suffered in the military and this was the worst pain i have ever experienced by leaps and bounds. and it never relented. finally, my gp saw me and instantly changed her tune. to start treatment i was to get a biopsy of my left temporal artery. the ent doctor called me to set that appointment up. only he wouldn't. he told me i had an actual 0% chance of having this and i was wasting mine and theirs if i came it bc i was too young. he made it clear that he was not entertaining the idea of seeing me at all and ended the phone call. it took another 24 hours of fights/emails/phone calls and being treated like crap to get the biopsy set up for the following morning. hey, guess what-i freaking have it. i am being treated for it but i have suffered permanent vision loss in my left eye bc of the delay in treatment. let alone what else bc i haven't even been fully informed on the extent of this disease yet. i want accountability. i want this drastic mistake to be learned from and other people not to suffer my same type of treatment. only people around me are telling me my anger is "too much." that i would be the asshole if i "went after doctors' careers" really? looking for the judgment so i can make sense of this all and make a decision. and oh yeah. i would have died as a result of this remaining untreated and it could have happened at any time. so, that's what people are basing their opinion on. "you didn't die/they ended up saving your life/it could have been worse." thoughts?
20,592
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/npwpq6/wibta_if_i_turned_in_a_group_of_doctors_that/
2021-06-01 15:32:20
nta, seriously drs need to stop acting like females dont know what they are talking about. you know your body, and you knew something was wrong.
nta. report them, make noise, hold them accountable. you're extremely lucky to have come out of this alive, but the next person may not be. i'm really sorry this happened to you. i'm glad you caught it and made them listen, and i hope the treatment is as effective and painless as possible. best wishes for your recovery.
nta report them and sue their unprofessional nuts
so how many women do they need to ignore before it's right to go off on someone's career? and in actuality, it will probably just make their liability insurance go up, not take away their license. nta go ahead and sue. hey, thank you for the award, internet stranger! (i just noticed it &amp; didn’t get a pm about it or i’d have thanked you that way)
get a medical malpractice lawyer, not an ambulance chaser, a proper lawyer
nta. doctors are absolutely trained to think horses not zebras, but you also don't decide that the black and white striped animal with four hooves and a short spiky mane and a terrible disposition is a horse just because zebras don't live in the area. it sucks to make a mistake but they do need to be reported. they probably won't lose their careers but they will receive a reprimand and notation on their records, and it might save someone down the line as the details of your case are circulated. you are absolutely right to report this and keep following up. you may be sparing someone else down the line.
nta. people commenting you didn’t die…but you lost your eye to their medical incompetence. those same people would react the same way you are if it had happened to them. you need to go get some consults with lawyers and at minimum report them to your states medical board. if these doctors are part of a va hospital, i would also contact the hospital to see what your options are but contact your own lawyers prior to doing.
va employee here there are absolutely avenues for you to bring this up and see that it gets addressed. contact the facility and ask to speak to the patient advocate. they are there to handle this type of complaint, if that doesn't work look up the medical center director and call their office directly. if there is a provider who is delaying care and causing harm the facility administration wants to know about it, saying nothing is the worst thing you can do. help us make sure the va is providing great care to veterans like you. nta thank you for your service!
nta, get them, get them, get them!! my dad’s issues were made so much worse by fucking doctors with god complexes and people not wanting to say anything because...they’re doctors!! they’re human, make mistakes and should be held accountable. i’m so sorry you had to go through this and i hope everything gets better. thank you for your service.
nta. i'm a physician. after the first paragraph, i was thinking "this is going to be something unusual like temporal arteritis." by the first comma of the second sentence of the second paragraph, i knew what it was going to be. i'm based in the uk, and certainly in my med school, temporal arteritis was one of those conditions utterly hammered into us due to the potential for loss of sight. regardless of your demographics, there's no reasonable reason why you shouldn't have had the biopsy done immediately on suspicion of it being temporal arteritis. ultimately, this should be raised as a learning event. certainly in the uk, i believe you would be able to raise a claim on this. you were referred with barn door temporal arteritis symptoms, they had a duty of care and any reasonable doctor would have suspected it. it's doubtful this sort of thing would be career ending, but certainly is a prime example of when you should be listening to the symptoms and not the demographics.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: ok, so for context i am a disabled military vet from my time spent overseas. 36 year old, female. i rely on the treatment from the va systems for my healthcare. which in my personal experiences has always been wonderful in my area. a few weeks ago i was rushed to the er with what was the worst head pain i had ever felt and it had come on in an instant. ct ended up being clear and it was diagnosed as a migraine. the next day is when hell started for me. enter two weeks of near-constant agonizing pain. a severely swollen left temple, bad jaw pain, my vision in my left eye was getting worse/seeing double, and there were other symptoms stacked on top of those. i had been requesting to be seen immediately by my gp (i have most of these requests backed up in emails) and was blown off. i had a strong hunch at what was wrong with me even though (according to the wise dr. google) not suppose to get temporal arteritis until at least age 50. i just wanted to be taken seriously bc i know my body. i feel i have a good grasp on my personal pain levels bc of injuries i have suffered in the military and this was the worst pain i have ever experienced by leaps and bounds. and it never relented. finally, my gp saw me and instantly changed her tune. to start treatment i was to get a biopsy of my left temporal artery. the ent doctor called me to set that appointment up. only he wouldn't. he told me i had an actual 0% chance of having this and i was wasting mine and theirs if i came it bc i was too young. he made it clear that he was not entertaining the idea of seeing me at all and ended the phone call. it took another 24 hours of fights/emails/phone calls and being treated like crap to get the biopsy set up for the following morning. hey, guess what-i freaking have it. i am being treated for it but i have suffered permanent vision loss in my left eye bc of the delay in treatment. let alone what else bc i haven't even been fully informed on the extent of this disease yet. i want accountability. i want this drastic mistake to be learned from and other people not to suffer my same type of treatment. only people around me are telling me my anger is "too much." that i would be the asshole if i "went after doctors' careers" really? looking for the judgment so i can make sense of this all and make a decision. and oh yeah. i would have died as a result of this remaining untreated and it could have happened at any time. so, that's what people are basing their opinion on. "you didn't die/they ended up saving your life/it could have been worse." thoughts?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> ok, so for context i am a disabled military vet from my time spent overseas. 36 year old, female. i rely on the treatment from the va systems for my healthcare. which in my personal experiences has always been wonderful in my area. a few weeks ago i was rushed to the er with what was the worst head pain i had ever felt and it had come on in an instant. ct ended up being clear and it was diagnosed as a migraine. the next day is when hell started for me. enter two weeks of near-constant agonizing pain. a severely swollen left temple, bad jaw pain, my vision in my left eye was getting worse/seeing double, and there were other symptoms stacked on top of those. i had been requesting to be seen immediately by my gp (i have most of these requests backed up in emails) and was blown off. i had a strong hunch at what was wrong with me even though (according to the wise dr. google) not suppose to get temporal arteritis until at least age 50. i just wanted to be taken seriously bc i know my body. i feel i have a good grasp on my personal pain levels bc of injuries i have suffered in the military and this was the worst pain i have ever experienced by leaps and bounds. and it never relented. finally, my gp saw me and instantly changed her tune. to start treatment i was to get a biopsy of my left temporal artery. the ent doctor called me to set that appointment up. only he wouldn't. he told me i had an actual 0% chance of having this and i was wasting mine and theirs if i came it bc i was too young. he made it clear that he was not entertaining the idea of seeing me at all and ended the phone call. it took another 24 hours of fights/emails/phone calls and being treated like crap to get the biopsy set up for the following morning. hey, guess what-i freaking have it. i am being treated for it but i have suffered permanent vision loss in my left eye bc of the delay in treatment. let alone what else bc i haven't even been fully informed on the extent of this disease yet. i want accountability. i want this drastic mistake to be learned from and other people not to suffer my same type of treatment. only people around me are telling me my anger is "too much." that i would be the asshole if i "went after doctors' careers" really? looking for the judgment so i can make sense of this all and make a decision. and oh yeah. i would have died as a result of this remaining untreated and it could have happened at any time. so, that's what people are basing their opinion on. "you didn't die/they ended up saving your life/it could have been worse." thoughts? [/INST] nta, seriously drs need to stop acting like females dont know what they are talking about. you know your body, and you knew something was wrong. </s>
AITA For refusing to stop having girls night ins just because my boyfriend thinks it's wrong?
[throwaway because he has myet main accounts password] hi so i've been seeing this guy "will" 27m for months now. he's so sweet and funny and creative. fun fact: he drives 2 cars that he adjusted/fixed on his own. we don't live together but we do meet at my place every weekend. he called and asked what we will be doing on friday and i said i wanted to host a gni since it was my turn. he asked what the heck was a gni i said a girls night in and he got quiet then asked if i was being series. i was confused as he started talking about how outdated and sooo 1950s those events are and said that i should stop promoting and advocating for those events as they are sooo toxic and flatout reek of misogyny. i was shocked by his long rant but he said that was his honest opinion. i told him regardless i still plan to host the event after he tried talking me out of it and suggested we go out together. he threw a fit after he suggested bringing his guy friends to join us and i refused since this is not how gnis work!. he called me a sexist and misogynistic for having a girls night in and making it so obvious instead of being ashamed of myself. he said that my mentality will cause me issues in the future especially if i behave like that in a professional work setting. let me tell you i was blown away by how he got so worked up like that over me just missing my girls and wanting to spend time with them. we argued some more and he hung up on me after i said i will not stop hosting or being part of gnis nomatter what he says about it. i tried to call and apologize for lashing out later but he sent a text saying he was hurt by how i handled our small disagreement and needs time to process what he just found out about my personality. this hurt me but my friendship and the bond i share with my girlfriends is huge and i don'the want to risk years of friendships by no longer being part of our bonding activities. aita? for making this my hill to die on like he says?
20,723
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/qqtcn7/aita_for_refusing_to_stop_having_girls_night_ins/
2021-11-10 12:30:10
nta how is girls night sexist?? no offense but you've said that you've only been dating a couple of months and he throws a tantrum over you not picking him over spending time with your friends. that's a red flag.
found out what? that you like to hang out with your girlfriends? why is it not okay but him going out with his mates its alright? hes so freaking dramatic. nta
run🏃‍♀️
[removed]
nta i really hope you can see all the red flags he is putting out here.
coming from a man, run away from this boy. completely nta. flipping out about a girl's night or needing me time or any time separate from him is a huge red flag and shows how clingy and controlling he will be down the line.
this man is manipulative. i feel gni are healthy and important. it sounds like he wants to isolate you from you friends. screams 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩nta
nta. change your passwords and lose this controlling ah. now.
what he found out about your personality???? what? that you like hanging out with your friends? i’d say you run as fast as you can because that man just showed his true colors real quick. nta also, nothing wrong with gni. me and the boys host weekly board game nights and those are the best.
wtf a girls night in is you being misogynistic? when someone presents you with an enormous red flag like this you have only one thing to do. break it off, block (because he will gaslight and harass you) and delete and move on. nta
NTA
NTA
null
null
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: [throwaway because he has myet main accounts password] hi so i've been seeing this guy "will" 27m for months now. he's so sweet and funny and creative. fun fact: he drives 2 cars that he adjusted/fixed on his own. we don't live together but we do meet at my place every weekend. he called and asked what we will be doing on friday and i said i wanted to host a gni since it was my turn. he asked what the heck was a gni i said a girls night in and he got quiet then asked if i was being series. i was confused as he started talking about how outdated and sooo 1950s those events are and said that i should stop promoting and advocating for those events as they are sooo toxic and flatout reek of misogyny. i was shocked by his long rant but he said that was his honest opinion. i told him regardless i still plan to host the event after he tried talking me out of it and suggested we go out together. he threw a fit after he suggested bringing his guy friends to join us and i refused since this is not how gnis work!. he called me a sexist and misogynistic for having a girls night in and making it so obvious instead of being ashamed of myself. he said that my mentality will cause me issues in the future especially if i behave like that in a professional work setting. let me tell you i was blown away by how he got so worked up like that over me just missing my girls and wanting to spend time with them. we argued some more and he hung up on me after i said i will not stop hosting or being part of gnis nomatter what he says about it. i tried to call and apologize for lashing out later but he sent a text saying he was hurt by how i handled our small disagreement and needs time to process what he just found out about my personality. this hurt me but my friendship and the bond i share with my girlfriends is huge and i don'the want to risk years of friendships by no longer being part of our bonding activities. aita? for making this my hill to die on like he says?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> [throwaway because he has myet main accounts password] hi so i've been seeing this guy "will" 27m for months now. he's so sweet and funny and creative. fun fact: he drives 2 cars that he adjusted/fixed on his own. we don't live together but we do meet at my place every weekend. he called and asked what we will be doing on friday and i said i wanted to host a gni since it was my turn. he asked what the heck was a gni i said a girls night in and he got quiet then asked if i was being series. i was confused as he started talking about how outdated and sooo 1950s those events are and said that i should stop promoting and advocating for those events as they are sooo toxic and flatout reek of misogyny. i was shocked by his long rant but he said that was his honest opinion. i told him regardless i still plan to host the event after he tried talking me out of it and suggested we go out together. he threw a fit after he suggested bringing his guy friends to join us and i refused since this is not how gnis work!. he called me a sexist and misogynistic for having a girls night in and making it so obvious instead of being ashamed of myself. he said that my mentality will cause me issues in the future especially if i behave like that in a professional work setting. let me tell you i was blown away by how he got so worked up like that over me just missing my girls and wanting to spend time with them. we argued some more and he hung up on me after i said i will not stop hosting or being part of gnis nomatter what he says about it. i tried to call and apologize for lashing out later but he sent a text saying he was hurt by how i handled our small disagreement and needs time to process what he just found out about my personality. this hurt me but my friendship and the bond i share with my girlfriends is huge and i don'the want to risk years of friendships by no longer being part of our bonding activities. aita? for making this my hill to die on like he says? [/INST] nta how is girls night sexist?? no offense but you've said that you've only been dating a couple of months and he throws a tantrum over you not picking him over spending time with your friends. that's a red flag. </s>
AITA for spraying my fiancé’s ex with a hose?
my fiancé has two teenage children with his ex. his ex can be extremely inappropriate towards him but he claims that’s just her personality. for some context she works in the entertainment industry and i guess is kind of sexy/flirty with everyone but it is very upsetting when i feel like i live in her shadow. his mom adores her. his kids obviously want their mom but i totally respect that she is the kids mom and will always be in the picture. the other day they went to one of their daughters games and out to eat and he dropped her at our house to get her car. i asked him why her shirt was wet and he said he rolled the car window down so she’d get hit with a sprinkler. he’s a big prankster and has done similar to me but i just seemed inappropriate with her. she rolled her eyes and told me to calm down it was just a joke and that i need to grow up and i’m prudish and dumb. they chatted for a few minutes and i took our hose and sprayed her because like she said it’s just water. she got really mad and said some nasty things. he kind of laughed but also said i shouldn’t have done it and now i’m concerned because his daughters aren’t speaking to me and the older one cussed me out before she left for school.
3,344
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/s9bbby/aita_for_spraying_my_fiancés_ex_with_a_hose/
2022-01-21 13:58:05
yta. childish af. you know your husband did it due to it being a prank but you did it due to malice. i do think you should talk to your fiancé about setting some boundaries, because if you do marry him before setting boundaries your marriage will include her.
yta. inappropriate and yea, of course his daughters are going to be angry with you. you did a petty thing. your husband needs to set boundaries. get angry with him, not her.
yta. i'm actually embarrassed for you. this competition with your fiancé's ex is pitiful. spraying her with a hose? not your finest hour. you just look jealous and insecure.
yta - you acted out of anger and jealousy, not a desire to have fun and be playful. motivation matters and i genuinely am not surprised her children won't speak with you now. seeing an adult act like a child and lash out against your mom has got to be infuriating.
yta your husband pulled the "prank" any issues you had with it are his fault, not hers. the fact took that as a light hearted joke didnt mean you were justified in a much more severe act as a mean spirited of jealousy.
esh you need to reevaluate your relationship with this man. it will not end well.
yta. don't make this a pissing contest with their mother. you don't need that smoke
esh. there needs to be boundaries set into play here. your fiancé’s ex shouldn’t be flirting with someone who is off limits. your fiancé is encouraging the behavior by rolling the window down so she got wet. and you shouldn’t have stooped to the same level. next time try expressing your feelings by mature conversation.
yea yta. you need to talk to your husband about your concerns and if he just dismisses you then you need to move on not retaliate like a child towards the ex.
info: why are you in a relationship with someone you suspect still has a thing for his ex??? you were annoyed your *fiancé* rolled down the window &amp; got his ex's shirt wet. instead of talking to your fiancé you tried to stop the flirting* by punishing the ex by spraying her. an act so obviously full of bad intentions that your step-kids aren't talking to you because you're mean to their mum. *so why would you get engaged to someone you think is still in love with their ex?* you're turned a relationship problem you have with your fiancé into an issue you have with the ex/co-parent, who's clearly only focusing on keeping a good relationship between her kids &amp; their dad &amp; grandma. *you mentioned your fiancé likes pranks, so it's unclear if he was flirting or trying to make his kids laugh by splashing their mum.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
ESH
YTA
ESH
YTA
INFO
0.013266
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my fiancé has two teenage children with his ex. his ex can be extremely inappropriate towards him but he claims that’s just her personality. for some context she works in the entertainment industry and i guess is kind of sexy/flirty with everyone but it is very upsetting when i feel like i live in her shadow. his mom adores her. his kids obviously want their mom but i totally respect that she is the kids mom and will always be in the picture. the other day they went to one of their daughters games and out to eat and he dropped her at our house to get her car. i asked him why her shirt was wet and he said he rolled the car window down so she’d get hit with a sprinkler. he’s a big prankster and has done similar to me but i just seemed inappropriate with her. she rolled her eyes and told me to calm down it was just a joke and that i need to grow up and i’m prudish and dumb. they chatted for a few minutes and i took our hose and sprayed her because like she said it’s just water. she got really mad and said some nasty things. he kind of laughed but also said i shouldn’t have done it and now i’m concerned because his daughters aren’t speaking to me and the older one cussed me out before she left for school.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my fiancé has two teenage children with his ex. his ex can be extremely inappropriate towards him but he claims that’s just her personality. for some context she works in the entertainment industry and i guess is kind of sexy/flirty with everyone but it is very upsetting when i feel like i live in her shadow. his mom adores her. his kids obviously want their mom but i totally respect that she is the kids mom and will always be in the picture. the other day they went to one of their daughters games and out to eat and he dropped her at our house to get her car. i asked him why her shirt was wet and he said he rolled the car window down so she’d get hit with a sprinkler. he’s a big prankster and has done similar to me but i just seemed inappropriate with her. she rolled her eyes and told me to calm down it was just a joke and that i need to grow up and i’m prudish and dumb. they chatted for a few minutes and i took our hose and sprayed her because like she said it’s just water. she got really mad and said some nasty things. he kind of laughed but also said i shouldn’t have done it and now i’m concerned because his daughters aren’t speaking to me and the older one cussed me out before she left for school. [/INST] yta. childish af. you know your husband did it due to it being a prank but you did it due to malice. i do think you should talk to your fiancé about setting some boundaries, because if you do marry him before setting boundaries your marriage will include her. </s>
WIBTA if I made a donation in the name of an acquaintance who does not support the cause?
i’m (28m) am getting married this year to another man (27m). most of our guests have been very supportive, but we received a letter from one couple telling us that they do not support us and won’t be able to attend our “event”. they also stated that they hope we find “the truth”. while i’m disappointed, this also means that we’ll save a little money on the wedding on food/alcohol/etc. i think it’s obvious that they’re ta for sending this letter, but i wondering wibta for taking the following action: i would like to donate the money i will save to an lbgtq organization in their name. i’m hoping that i or the organization will be able to send them a receipt/thank you for the donation. wibta? throwaway as there are giveaways to my identity on my main account.
4,648
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/h171oj/wibta_if_i_made_a_donation_in_the_name_of_an/
2020-06-11 20:14:48
yta- but i fully support it and am also an asshole! every year for xmas i give my conservative relatives a donation in their name to whatever cause upsets them the most at the time. planned parenthood, gun control advocacy, etc. this year it’s looking like they’ll be donating to blm!
if we ever needed a “justifiable asshole” judgement. what you’re doing is not harming anyone other than rubbing some much needed ire in an overly inflated egos of two bigots. nta. go for it.
ywbta this takes trolling to a whole new level. you’d be wrong to do it, but at the same time you would be fucking *awesome* if you did this. if it’s okay with you, i shall borrow your idea and use it myself in future. sometimes being in the wrong is justifiably right. this is one such time.
nta. every christmas i donate to planned parenthood in mike pence’s name because fuck him.
yta. don't drag the org into this. cause if they call the org and demand the money back, the org isn't going know this is a spite donation. they will have to verify that they aren't part of some scam, being used for scam purposes, forcing them to review other donations.
yta, but 99% of the people that read this and commented would be, also me. i really hope u do that op! fuck homophobic people!
nta. combating homophobia never makes you the asshole.
i mean esh, but i actually don't know anyone that wouldn't be on board for that. sometimes you just gotta say f\*ck the high road. i think this is one of those times.
ha! that’s a great idea! nta also, congratulations.
ywbta. this childish game can be played ad infinitum. bigot can make a large retaliatory donation in your name to an organization that offends you. both of you can keep loosing until you stop. or you can tell them to fuck right off. start this phase of your life as an adult, not a passive-aggressive adolescent.
YTA
NTA
YTA
NTA
YTA
YTA
NTA
ESH
NTA
YTA
0.686375
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i’m (28m) am getting married this year to another man (27m). most of our guests have been very supportive, but we received a letter from one couple telling us that they do not support us and won’t be able to attend our “event”. they also stated that they hope we find “the truth”. while i’m disappointed, this also means that we’ll save a little money on the wedding on food/alcohol/etc. i think it’s obvious that they’re ta for sending this letter, but i wondering wibta for taking the following action: i would like to donate the money i will save to an lbgtq organization in their name. i’m hoping that i or the organization will be able to send them a receipt/thank you for the donation. wibta? throwaway as there are giveaways to my identity on my main account.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i’m (28m) am getting married this year to another man (27m). most of our guests have been very supportive, but we received a letter from one couple telling us that they do not support us and won’t be able to attend our “event”. they also stated that they hope we find “the truth”. while i’m disappointed, this also means that we’ll save a little money on the wedding on food/alcohol/etc. i think it’s obvious that they’re ta for sending this letter, but i wondering wibta for taking the following action: i would like to donate the money i will save to an lbgtq organization in their name. i’m hoping that i or the organization will be able to send them a receipt/thank you for the donation. wibta? throwaway as there are giveaways to my identity on my main account. [/INST] yta- but i fully support it and am also an asshole! every year for xmas i give my conservative relatives a donation in their name to whatever cause upsets them the most at the time. planned parenthood, gun control advocacy, etc. this year it’s looking like they’ll be donating to blm! </s>
AITA for letting my daughter help me set up my wife’s board game?
yesterday was my wife’s birthday, and i got her a new board game as a present. for background we have a 3 year old girl and just had a baby and she’s been a little down but she’s taking medication for it. we were popping out the pieces after we got home from buying the game and my wife asked me to please stop and that she wanted us to do it later so our 3 year old doesn’t mess with it or lose pieces, as it’s a game she really wanted and it was a little expensive. i figured i might as well keep going as we weren’t doing anything at that moment anyway. she asked me to stop again but i was halfway through doing it. our daughter was busy with a new toy but then came over and started messing with the pieces, i started to tell her to stop but my wife said “fine, if you’re going to be popping them out around her you may as well let her help as it’s going to be double the work trying to stop her from helping”. so our toddler helped me get things set up. we didn’t end up playing that night, but we played tonight, and a piece was pretty much broken from my daughter ripping it. my wife was pretty upset at her brand new game being messed up before we ever played, not at our daughter but at me for not putting the game up around our toddler. i reminded her she said it was fine if our toddler helped. aita?
3,877
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/xtf5y8/aita_for_letting_my_daughter_help_me_set_up_my/
2022-10-02 04:16:41
yta are you seriously that dense? she clearly told you not to put the game together around your toddler. then when your toddler starts to screw up her new game, she is exasperated that you didn’t listen to her and tells you that you might as well keep going and screwing up her game because you’ve already started. read the room better next time because it’s clear as day what your wife was telling you.
yta &gt; i reminded her she said it was fine if our toddler helped. no. she asked you to stop twice. what wasn't clear to you then? why did you just forget that part? she asked you nicely to stop setting it up, you kept doing it. then the toddler got involved. and she gave up because you clearly weren't going to listen to or respect her requests regarding her own gift, and it was going to take some form of argument to get you to listen. 100% your fuck up here.
yta your wife told you twice to not set up the game in your toddler's presence so that she won't mess up the pieces. to be clear its not your kid's fault for messing up the game, she's three and clearly just wanted to help. you did opposite of what your wife requested and you are here asking internet strangers if you are at fault for what happened? also you wife finally gave in when she realized that you were not going to listen to her, that does not mean she was okay with what you did
yta for two reasons. the most important is that yta for having no idea yta when it’s completely obvious. brand new game your wife wanted and you don’t assume a toddler will rip it up? and on top of that, your wife was nervous about it. that’s when you should’ve stopped. actually you should’ve not even open this with daughter around. what you should’ve done is not touched the wrapping and let your wife open it. since she loves board games, i guarantee she enjoys taking off the wrapping and feeling the new parts herself, so you took that from her. but you really can’t see why she’s upset? she told you it was ok? she said “fine” because you weren’t taking no for an answer and she was exhausted by you. all of this should’ve been obvious. buy her a new one and give it to her with an apology.
yta you should have just waited until she was ready, and considered her feelings instead of just casually dismissing her and doing what you wanted. she was obviously right that you shouldn't do it, and 100% because of you, something got damaged. question: do you normally gaslight her and ignore her feelings in other aspects of your marriage? your post is just a long victim blaming way of you justifying being a jerk.
yta she didn’t say it was fine she said stop twice but you ignored her. you didn’t even let her set up her own present! your also owe her a new one that’s not ripped by a toddler! because if you had stopped when she asked the first time it never would have happened! seriously you think she was fine!
this isn't the first time you've completely ignored your wife telling you no and then blamed her for something going wrong, is it? maybe next time, respect your wife's request to stop doing something when she asks. yta
yta. after reading this i am so happy i am single. first, your wife got a present for her birthday and you were unpacking it. that is not how gifts work! what was your wife doing? maybe you could have helped her with that? second, she told you twice to put it away, because she wanted to unpack her gift together away from the three year old who could break something. you choose not to listen! third, your child comes over to help (your wife already knew that would happen) your wife gives in (because it's impossible to get a three year old to stop 'helping' without crying, your wife has ppd and i am wondering who would have to deal with the crying child - not really because i am sure it would be your wife) and your child breaks something (what a surprise didn't see that coming and neither did your wife?!). fourth, you remind your wife she was ok with your child helping (really, are you that dense?!) and are surprised she is not angry at the three year old (whose entire mission in life is to break stuff but it is up to the adults to prevent that from happening!).
yta. i don’t even under how you went from she said to stop to i figured i should keep going? did you read what you wrote because that doesn’t even make sense? was the gift even for her? because it sure doesn’t sound like it. it sounds like it’s for you. that’s uncool and immature.
seriously?!? she asked you at least 3 different times to stop and to put her gift away, but you decided to completely ignore her and do whatever you wanted with her game? what is wrong with you? is this a recurring issue: she says no, and you do whatever you want anyway, because "nothing else is going on, might as well plow through my wife's boundaries" yta
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: yesterday was my wife’s birthday, and i got her a new board game as a present. for background we have a 3 year old girl and just had a baby and she’s been a little down but she’s taking medication for it. we were popping out the pieces after we got home from buying the game and my wife asked me to please stop and that she wanted us to do it later so our 3 year old doesn’t mess with it or lose pieces, as it’s a game she really wanted and it was a little expensive. i figured i might as well keep going as we weren’t doing anything at that moment anyway. she asked me to stop again but i was halfway through doing it. our daughter was busy with a new toy but then came over and started messing with the pieces, i started to tell her to stop but my wife said “fine, if you’re going to be popping them out around her you may as well let her help as it’s going to be double the work trying to stop her from helping”. so our toddler helped me get things set up. we didn’t end up playing that night, but we played tonight, and a piece was pretty much broken from my daughter ripping it. my wife was pretty upset at her brand new game being messed up before we ever played, not at our daughter but at me for not putting the game up around our toddler. i reminded her she said it was fine if our toddler helped. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> yesterday was my wife’s birthday, and i got her a new board game as a present. for background we have a 3 year old girl and just had a baby and she’s been a little down but she’s taking medication for it. we were popping out the pieces after we got home from buying the game and my wife asked me to please stop and that she wanted us to do it later so our 3 year old doesn’t mess with it or lose pieces, as it’s a game she really wanted and it was a little expensive. i figured i might as well keep going as we weren’t doing anything at that moment anyway. she asked me to stop again but i was halfway through doing it. our daughter was busy with a new toy but then came over and started messing with the pieces, i started to tell her to stop but my wife said “fine, if you’re going to be popping them out around her you may as well let her help as it’s going to be double the work trying to stop her from helping”. so our toddler helped me get things set up. we didn’t end up playing that night, but we played tonight, and a piece was pretty much broken from my daughter ripping it. my wife was pretty upset at her brand new game being messed up before we ever played, not at our daughter but at me for not putting the game up around our toddler. i reminded her she said it was fine if our toddler helped. aita? [/INST] yta are you seriously that dense? she clearly told you not to put the game together around your toddler. then when your toddler starts to screw up her new game, she is exasperated that you didn’t listen to her and tells you that you might as well keep going and screwing up her game because you’ve already started. read the room better next time because it’s clear as day what your wife was telling you. </s>
AITA for billing my boyfriend for the makeup his daughter destroyed?
my (30f) boyfriend (33m) has a 2yr old daughter who i absolutely love to death. i'm definitely in mom mode with her since she lives with us most of the time. this morning she, yet again, got into my makeup and completely destroyed my jeffree starr eyeshadow palettes. this has to be the millionth time she gets into it and destroys it and it's finally at the point of no return 😔😔 i had to throw out 4 pallets worth a little over $200. he doesn't think he should have to buy me new pallettes because he thinks i should have put them up out of her reach. my counter argument is that they have a specific place where they go and he needs to just teach her to not be getting things that are not hers. with his logic we would have to put everything up out of her reach and that's physically impossible. she's at the age where she needs to start learning not to be touching things that are not hers. he says that because i refuse to put them up out of her reach it's my own fault and he shouldn't have to buy me new ones. we're not exactly in the best financial situation at the moment and $200 for makeup is ridiculous but i feel like it's the principle. my daughter is 7 years old and i've had make up her entire life. i had to teach her to not be touching things that were not hers. and that's because my daughter loves makeup too and i'm pretty sure if i ask her to bring me anything that the baby has destroyed of hers she has quite a few things as well. and my daughter doesn't have cheap makeup she also has jeffree star cosmetics because she takes care of her things. she's been getting very frustrated with having a little sister because of how destructive she is and my daughter has a lot of things. i feel like we just need to teach her to not grab things that are not hers. aita for wanting him to replace the makeup she destroyed??
3,733
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/tl8rj9/aita_for_billing_my_boyfriend_for_the_makeup_his/
2022-03-23 19:12:48
yta: while i know you exaggerated it, you claim this is the millionth time she done this. but you refuse to move them because "thats where they go". she's 2 you're the adult here you can make it so she can't get them but you refuse. this is on you also don't say you're in "mom mode" until she does something wrong and you say we'll not my kid
yta she’s two and jeffree star is a racist
you’re not in the “best financial situation at the moment” because you buy your 7 year old daughter jeffrey star cosmetics. yta for so many reasons
hi, i’ve been actively working in preschools and daycares since i was 14 or 15. i’m in college working towards a degree in early childhood education. she’s two, she’s probably not even forming complete sentences at this point. your boyfriend can try to teach her not to touch things she’s not going to listen. point blank period. he’s right, you need to put them out of reach of her. most makeup pallets also contain dangerous chemicals and if she happened to digest one, it would be your fault
lol i’m not sure, but my theory is she found out who jeffree starr is and she doesn’t want you supporting them 😂😂
yta for supporting jeffrey starr.
info: a couple of questions.... one... why weren't either of you watching the toddler? and why after getting into the makeup a "million" times have you not moved it yet? toddlers get into stuff. it's what they do.
question when is a two year old getting enough unsupervised time to do this? who is supposed to be looking after her?
you lost me at jeffree starr
~~nah but~~ i agree with your bf - put your things away where the 2yr old can't reach them. replace "jeffree starr eyeshadow palettes" with "rat poison." still okay with you to leave them where the 2yr old can reach them?
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
null
YTA
INFO
null
null
NAH
0.105326
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my (30f) boyfriend (33m) has a 2yr old daughter who i absolutely love to death. i'm definitely in mom mode with her since she lives with us most of the time. this morning she, yet again, got into my makeup and completely destroyed my jeffree starr eyeshadow palettes. this has to be the millionth time she gets into it and destroys it and it's finally at the point of no return 😔😔 i had to throw out 4 pallets worth a little over $200. he doesn't think he should have to buy me new pallettes because he thinks i should have put them up out of her reach. my counter argument is that they have a specific place where they go and he needs to just teach her to not be getting things that are not hers. with his logic we would have to put everything up out of her reach and that's physically impossible. she's at the age where she needs to start learning not to be touching things that are not hers. he says that because i refuse to put them up out of her reach it's my own fault and he shouldn't have to buy me new ones. we're not exactly in the best financial situation at the moment and $200 for makeup is ridiculous but i feel like it's the principle. my daughter is 7 years old and i've had make up her entire life. i had to teach her to not be touching things that were not hers. and that's because my daughter loves makeup too and i'm pretty sure if i ask her to bring me anything that the baby has destroyed of hers she has quite a few things as well. and my daughter doesn't have cheap makeup she also has jeffree star cosmetics because she takes care of her things. she's been getting very frustrated with having a little sister because of how destructive she is and my daughter has a lot of things. i feel like we just need to teach her to not grab things that are not hers. aita for wanting him to replace the makeup she destroyed??
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my (30f) boyfriend (33m) has a 2yr old daughter who i absolutely love to death. i'm definitely in mom mode with her since she lives with us most of the time. this morning she, yet again, got into my makeup and completely destroyed my jeffree starr eyeshadow palettes. this has to be the millionth time she gets into it and destroys it and it's finally at the point of no return 😔😔 i had to throw out 4 pallets worth a little over $200. he doesn't think he should have to buy me new pallettes because he thinks i should have put them up out of her reach. my counter argument is that they have a specific place where they go and he needs to just teach her to not be getting things that are not hers. with his logic we would have to put everything up out of her reach and that's physically impossible. she's at the age where she needs to start learning not to be touching things that are not hers. he says that because i refuse to put them up out of her reach it's my own fault and he shouldn't have to buy me new ones. we're not exactly in the best financial situation at the moment and $200 for makeup is ridiculous but i feel like it's the principle. my daughter is 7 years old and i've had make up her entire life. i had to teach her to not be touching things that were not hers. and that's because my daughter loves makeup too and i'm pretty sure if i ask her to bring me anything that the baby has destroyed of hers she has quite a few things as well. and my daughter doesn't have cheap makeup she also has jeffree star cosmetics because she takes care of her things. she's been getting very frustrated with having a little sister because of how destructive she is and my daughter has a lot of things. i feel like we just need to teach her to not grab things that are not hers. aita for wanting him to replace the makeup she destroyed?? [/INST] yta: while i know you exaggerated it, you claim this is the millionth time she done this. but you refuse to move them because "thats where they go". she's 2 you're the adult here you can make it so she can't get them but you refuse. this is on you also don't say you're in "mom mode" until she does something wrong and you say we'll not my kid </s>
AITA For making the only woman at our job quit?
this occurred over the course of months and i was recently telling my family about this story and my sister got mad at me and called me a sexist, but none of my actions had anything to do with that: i work at a small client service office, it only has about 50 people, all male (with the exception of a few support staff that were women). at the beginning of 2019 we had a new hire to our professional team who was a female. she initially fit right in at the beginning, but slowly she started to make changes and change our workplace for the worse: prior to her joining, we had a very relaxed atmosphere. we'd curse, talk more explicitly, etc. no one seemed to mind, even our direct managers didn't care. but she complained about foul language and behavior and soon our hr person got involved and told us we had to keep it more professional. additionally, she was catty and would report people every so often. essentially she was making the workplace sterile and boring. we couldn't "let loose" as much and all conversations had to be workplace appropriate. our team would even have our own little events like going out drinking together afterwards/go to concerts together, and obviously we excluded her, which she got wind of and, obviously reported it. so now we weren't allowed to hang out as a team unless all were invited after work. i eventually told our team to not help her out with any projects and give her the bare minimum of assistance if she needed it. most of the team agreed and within a few months time her performance dropped. i also made sure to report her every time she inconvenienced me. she eventually had a mini-breakdown and ended up quitting. obviously at work the immediate team celebrated but my sister apparently thought it was sexist? i told her if this had been a male doing it, we would have excluded him too.
5,750
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hk0e2j/aita_for_making_the_only_woman_at_our_job_quit/
2020-07-02 16:39:36
yta you terrorized a random woman trying to do her job because she was probably reporting for legitimate fucking reasons lmao, what you consider "foul language" was probably super sexually charged to her, i don't trust a man who down plays the reasons a woman reported him to hr.
&gt; all conversations had to be workplace appropriate you know, probably because it’s a workplace. yta
yta - so she didn’t like you guys swearing and being gross, so you deliberately excluded and bullied her? regardless of her gender, that’s an awful way to treat anybody.
yta. someone pointed out your hostile work environment and you deliberately made it more hostile.
my journey reading this post: "wait, how do you have an office of 50 people that's pretty much all male?" "oh. that's how." yta. it's not a relaxed atmosphere. it's clear that the word "behavior" that was casually thrown in about her complaint is doing a lot of heavy lifting. then, because she complained about being excluded for not wanting her workplace to be a frat, you all sabotaged her work. this place sounds awful.
yta. first, no one thought it was an issue that the company consisted of all men in the "important" roles while women were relegated to support staff? what is this, 1950? beyond that, you absolutely were sexist. i can only imagine what a boys' club it was there and what the "explicit" talk really was. it's not unreasonable to want to come to work in a professional environment, and if your behavior rose to the level of her complaining to hr, the problem is not her. that poor woman. i hope she finds a job where she's treated with respect and dignity.
yta and although we always only hear one side of the story on this sub, i get the feeling she was probably more justified in her complaints to hr than is described...
question (is that better)- so are you telling me you essentially terrorized someone for wanting to feel comfortable in their work place lmfao? yta x 1000
yta for sexist bullying and deliberately creating a hostile work environment. i hope she sues your company for everything they've got - she'll win.
holy fuck yta! “obviously we didn’t invite her”. poor baby could swear and talk shit about women and got his feelings hurt so he decided to sabotage her career.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: this occurred over the course of months and i was recently telling my family about this story and my sister got mad at me and called me a sexist, but none of my actions had anything to do with that: i work at a small client service office, it only has about 50 people, all male (with the exception of a few support staff that were women). at the beginning of 2019 we had a new hire to our professional team who was a female. she initially fit right in at the beginning, but slowly she started to make changes and change our workplace for the worse: prior to her joining, we had a very relaxed atmosphere. we'd curse, talk more explicitly, etc. no one seemed to mind, even our direct managers didn't care. but she complained about foul language and behavior and soon our hr person got involved and told us we had to keep it more professional. additionally, she was catty and would report people every so often. essentially she was making the workplace sterile and boring. we couldn't "let loose" as much and all conversations had to be workplace appropriate. our team would even have our own little events like going out drinking together afterwards/go to concerts together, and obviously we excluded her, which she got wind of and, obviously reported it. so now we weren't allowed to hang out as a team unless all were invited after work. i eventually told our team to not help her out with any projects and give her the bare minimum of assistance if she needed it. most of the team agreed and within a few months time her performance dropped. i also made sure to report her every time she inconvenienced me. she eventually had a mini-breakdown and ended up quitting. obviously at work the immediate team celebrated but my sister apparently thought it was sexist? i told her if this had been a male doing it, we would have excluded him too.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> this occurred over the course of months and i was recently telling my family about this story and my sister got mad at me and called me a sexist, but none of my actions had anything to do with that: i work at a small client service office, it only has about 50 people, all male (with the exception of a few support staff that were women). at the beginning of 2019 we had a new hire to our professional team who was a female. she initially fit right in at the beginning, but slowly she started to make changes and change our workplace for the worse: prior to her joining, we had a very relaxed atmosphere. we'd curse, talk more explicitly, etc. no one seemed to mind, even our direct managers didn't care. but she complained about foul language and behavior and soon our hr person got involved and told us we had to keep it more professional. additionally, she was catty and would report people every so often. essentially she was making the workplace sterile and boring. we couldn't "let loose" as much and all conversations had to be workplace appropriate. our team would even have our own little events like going out drinking together afterwards/go to concerts together, and obviously we excluded her, which she got wind of and, obviously reported it. so now we weren't allowed to hang out as a team unless all were invited after work. i eventually told our team to not help her out with any projects and give her the bare minimum of assistance if she needed it. most of the team agreed and within a few months time her performance dropped. i also made sure to report her every time she inconvenienced me. she eventually had a mini-breakdown and ended up quitting. obviously at work the immediate team celebrated but my sister apparently thought it was sexist? i told her if this had been a male doing it, we would have excluded him too. [/INST] yta you terrorized a random woman trying to do her job because she was probably reporting for legitimate fucking reasons lmao, what you consider "foul language" was probably super sexually charged to her, i don't trust a man who down plays the reasons a woman reported him to hr. </s>
Aita for giving a woman a taste of her own behavior
i'm sitting at the airport and this older lady sat down right next to me and took her ipad out and starts watching a show quite loud. to me this is a foul in public however i just ignored it and put my earbuds in. after a while i made a phone call using my earbuds. literally 30 seconds into my call she interrupts me and asks me to quit being rude and talk quietly so she can hear her show. i was as polite as i could and said that not only herself but everyone for about 10 feet and i could hear her show word for word and that making a phone call isn't rude but watching a show on your device full volume in a public waiting area is actually very rude and that is why people use headphones. she said she has every right to enjoy her show without being interrupted by a rude and selfish phone call or having to use headphones. i said she was absolutely right and i am completely wrong, please enjoy your show while we wait for the plane and i will do the same. i then proceeded to take out my ipad and open ice cubes good cop bad cop music video and play it full volume on my device without my earbuds. i have never seen someone storm off so mad. quick edit. i turned the music video off almost immediately after she left.
26,611
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/aphmhd/aita_for_giving_a_woman_a_taste_of_her_own/
2019-02-11 15:58:46
nta. i'm glad you did it. fuck her and everyone like her.
nta - please crosspost to /r/pettyrevenge :)
nta because you didn't start with trying to fight fire with fire. first you ignored her. then you asked her not to. it was only when both of these failed that you gave her a taste of her own medicine. you were as reasonable as can be expected in this situation.
nta. i think you handled the situation well. some people are really crazy.
nta, but jesus christ, i feel bad about the people caught in the crossfire! if she hadn’t have left, what was your plan? if she hadn’t left i would’ve said esh for making those other poor bastards have to listen to twice as much shit lol
ymh. yes my hero. thanks for doing that, keep doing things like it to people who deserve it. you're the passive aggressive hero we need. &amp;#x200b;
nta. glad you stood up to that insufferable behavior. i hate when people do that.
am i the asshole for dishing some sweet epic justice to a lady and then everyone stood up and clapped?
nta. yeah, she was clearly rude. and you were a bit rude back but it wasn't out of proportion. and it worked, and the people around you were probably glad she moved along.
nta. hopefully she'll invest in some headphones now.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
null
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm sitting at the airport and this older lady sat down right next to me and took her ipad out and starts watching a show quite loud. to me this is a foul in public however i just ignored it and put my earbuds in. after a while i made a phone call using my earbuds. literally 30 seconds into my call she interrupts me and asks me to quit being rude and talk quietly so she can hear her show. i was as polite as i could and said that not only herself but everyone for about 10 feet and i could hear her show word for word and that making a phone call isn't rude but watching a show on your device full volume in a public waiting area is actually very rude and that is why people use headphones. she said she has every right to enjoy her show without being interrupted by a rude and selfish phone call or having to use headphones. i said she was absolutely right and i am completely wrong, please enjoy your show while we wait for the plane and i will do the same. i then proceeded to take out my ipad and open ice cubes good cop bad cop music video and play it full volume on my device without my earbuds. i have never seen someone storm off so mad. quick edit. i turned the music video off almost immediately after she left.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm sitting at the airport and this older lady sat down right next to me and took her ipad out and starts watching a show quite loud. to me this is a foul in public however i just ignored it and put my earbuds in. after a while i made a phone call using my earbuds. literally 30 seconds into my call she interrupts me and asks me to quit being rude and talk quietly so she can hear her show. i was as polite as i could and said that not only herself but everyone for about 10 feet and i could hear her show word for word and that making a phone call isn't rude but watching a show on your device full volume in a public waiting area is actually very rude and that is why people use headphones. she said she has every right to enjoy her show without being interrupted by a rude and selfish phone call or having to use headphones. i said she was absolutely right and i am completely wrong, please enjoy your show while we wait for the plane and i will do the same. i then proceeded to take out my ipad and open ice cubes good cop bad cop music video and play it full volume on my device without my earbuds. i have never seen someone storm off so mad. quick edit. i turned the music video off almost immediately after she left. [/INST] nta. i'm glad you did it. fuck her and everyone like her. </s>
AITA for yelling at my parents that their polyamory fucked up my childhood?
37,157
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ihp8sc/aita_for_yelling_at_my_parents_that_their/
2020-08-27 17:22:52
nta, do not back down and allow them to get you to recant, op. notice that they said “we’re sorry you feel this way”, not “we’re sorry for doing xyz”. they gave you a non-apology. for making your childhood basically a wallflower to an orgy, no less.
nta it wasn't your parents polyamory that f*cked you up though it was there bad parenting. they allowed strange adults around you all the time and neglected you when those strangers were around, they put you in potentially dangerous situations by doing so. having a committed poly partner who is not a stranger and known to you prob would have been fine, but a string of randoms or new people that would seriously mess with any kid.
nta. really? they would leave complete strangers in the house without them for you to come home to? they made their sex lives front and center and their priority. any child would resent that.
nta upside, your parents seem to be ah through obliviousness and neglect and might be open to apologizing and trying to fix what they can. maybe message your dad that you are not in a place to talk at the moment and will get back to them, then talk to your therapist and develop a timeline for when and how you can talk. as to not bringing it up before: parents do not get the luxury of assuming everything is okay because the kid never complained. parents have to ask, they have to check, and they have to find ways of communicating if the kid can't talk to them. your parents screwed up, kids cannot be expected to know something is wrong or know how to communicate it.
nta. and be careful that this wanting a nice calm chat isn’t just your parents getting you in their house then trying to bully you into taking part in their documentary. they were totally neglectful people who deserve all you anger.
nta. poly did not mess you up. their way of poly messed you up. i have seen this go good and bad from friends. try to speak with your parents. if they don't know how hard it hit you, they cannot try to make amends.
nta the fact that you could come home and find random people there is concerning, what if the person was dangerous?
nta your feelings are so real and valid. they were so wrapped up in their own lives they couldn’t see what they were doing to you. you saying it to them may have made them realize they had neglected you.
nta. i'll preface this by admitting i don't know too much about the dynamics of polyamorous relationships, and i have no desire to entertain one. that much being said, what consenting adults do in their own time is entirely their business. your parents are still in the wrong, though. as is the case with any parent, introducing a partner to a child is a delicate process. furthermore, that parent needs to ensure that this new relationship doesn't change the dynamic of the preexisting relationship they have with their children. they owe it to their children to be parents before they owe their partner anything. your parents completely failed to integrate these people into your lives in a healthy way and prioritized their romantic relationships before their relationship with you as parents. furthermore, by allowing these people in and out of your life like this, you were forced to grow up in an extremely volatile and unstructured environment. honestly? coming home to strangers in your house could be downright traumatic! it could be dangerous! it's completely unacceptable. anyway! your father's apology wasn't genuine. he wasn't apologizing for his behavior; he feigned sympathy and simultaneously pinned this on you and your feelings. this communicates to me that he doesn't regret his actions, doesn't see fault in them, and probably isn't ready to consider your perspective. only when he and your mother are ready to openly reflect on their decisions as parents will they be ready for this conversation. otherwise, you're wasting your time. you're not mad at them for being polyamorous. you're mad at them for prioritizing their partners over you and failing to provide a structured upbringing in a stable environment.
nta. not sure why everyone is tripping over themselves to say they’re pro-poly and it was just that your parents that did it wrong? seems invalidating. you’re not obligated to like the lifestyle if you had a bad experience.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context:
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> [/INST] nta, do not back down and allow them to get you to recant, op. notice that they said “we’re sorry you feel this way”, not “we’re sorry for doing xyz”. they gave you a non-apology. for making your childhood basically a wallflower to an orgy, no less. </s>
AITA for lettingmy child climb on a rock?
hi, i'm a 34 year old woman and my 3 children are a 12 year old boy, a 9 year old boy and a 7 year old girl. my husband is a 35 year old man. a couple weeks ago we went on a trip to visit some historical sites in several countries in europe (basically like a roadtrip). my husband had a terrible headache on the fourth day of our trip so he stayed at the hotel while our children and i went to a dolmen. when we got there my children were a bit bored so i let them run around and play for a bit (there weren't a lot of people so they were not bothering anyone) and than my 9 year old climbed on one of the boulders of the dolmen. he looked so proud of himself when he managed to climb up so i wanted to take a photo of him but than a girl (around 19 i'd say) walked up to me and sarcastically asked "do you let your kids climb on their grandparent's graves like that too?". needless to say, i got a bit angry and told her to mind her own bussiness and said that a 5000 year old dead guy won't mind it if a child climbs on a rock. her face looked like i just killed a puppy in front of her and she walked away. when we got back to the hotel i told my husband about it and he said that it's a bit tasteless to let someone climb on what's "essentially a gravestone". i got mad because he wouldn't support me and undermined me in front the children like that. i went to the bathroom where i called my sister to tell her what happend. she said that the girl shouldn't have approached me like that but that i was also wrong for the way i responded to her. i told her that the girl was out of line talking to someone that's older then her like that and i hung up. it's been a couple weeks now and it just hasn't been sitting right with me. i've been thinking that maybe i am the asshole and i guess i can see why someone would see a dolmen as a grave. so, am i the asshole for letting my child climb on a rock?
7,253
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ql3k3m/aita_for_lettingmy_child_climb_on_a_rock/
2021-11-02 12:55:13
yta i had to go look up what a dolmen is, but yta for letting your kid climb on that. it is clearly a thing with ritual significance and they also look somewhat precarious - like lot of people climbing on them could topple them. you are also the ah for thinking that she couldn't call you out on letting your kids climb a tomb because she happens to be younger than you. even old people get to be called out when they do stupid shit.
yta- i've just checked out what dolems' are, and they appear to be pretty clearly at least revered as graves, or at least thought of as that type of thing. so no, you probably shouldn't have let your kid climb. was anyone else climbing it? because if no, then you're in the wrong. &amp;#x200b; &gt; i told her that the girl was out of line talking to someone that's older then her like that. also this. you're not owed respect just because you're older. if you were doing something impolite, out of order, or overall looked down upon, she had every right to tell you so.
yta. those are historical sites and not a playground.
yta it’s a historical site as well as a grave site. your actions are exactly why historical sites are ruined and destroyed and governments, archeologists, and historical societies struggle to keep them safe (like putting fences around them to keep people like you out). and one more thing, your age means nothing when you are doing something wrong. you don’t get a free pass from young people telling you that you are wrong just because you are older. you don’t automatically gain respect either. i also like how you essentially want your husband to lie to you to make you feel like you were right. sorry, if you made a mistake the first person to tell you should be your so because they are the one you should trust the most with these kind of judgements. instead you got mad at him for not supporting you for being wrong. you have a lot to work on.
yta it's distasteful and ignorant, you could have taken it as an opportunity to educate your children about respecting their surroundings and especially burial grounds. the fact that you got mad at your husband for not taking your side is even worse. it's okay to admit you were wrong and it's especially okay for your children to see you can be wrong. do better
yta for letting your kids run wild and climb on a memorial, yes.
yta. it's a historical site, not a playground. it's also pretty much the same thing as a grave, and yes it is disrespectful to have your children climbing all over it. secondly, you saying "well she's younger than me so she shouldn't have said anything" is absolute drivel. what nonsense. she took you to task because, even though you're older than her, you didn't have the good sense or grace to keep your children from climbing on things they've no business climbing. you're not entitled to do whatever you want without reproach just because you're older than some people.
yta. it isnt about climbing a rock it is about respect. she was right, you wouldnt let him do this on a gravestone, this isnt any different. -
yta - you’re raising your children to become permanent assholes that just get to do whatever they feel like and then come up with horrid excuses for why nobody should ever give them a hard time. teaching them that when your husband mildly calls you out on obvious selfish behavior is “undermining” is maybe the worst thing you’ve done here, but teaching them that the responsible young woman was “out of line” simply because you’re older is also terrible. these kids are going to grow up incredibly entitled and closed-minded if this story is any indication.
yta this is why so many historical sites are surrounded by giant fences.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: hi, i'm a 34 year old woman and my 3 children are a 12 year old boy, a 9 year old boy and a 7 year old girl. my husband is a 35 year old man. a couple weeks ago we went on a trip to visit some historical sites in several countries in europe (basically like a roadtrip). my husband had a terrible headache on the fourth day of our trip so he stayed at the hotel while our children and i went to a dolmen. when we got there my children were a bit bored so i let them run around and play for a bit (there weren't a lot of people so they were not bothering anyone) and than my 9 year old climbed on one of the boulders of the dolmen. he looked so proud of himself when he managed to climb up so i wanted to take a photo of him but than a girl (around 19 i'd say) walked up to me and sarcastically asked "do you let your kids climb on their grandparent's graves like that too?". needless to say, i got a bit angry and told her to mind her own bussiness and said that a 5000 year old dead guy won't mind it if a child climbs on a rock. her face looked like i just killed a puppy in front of her and she walked away. when we got back to the hotel i told my husband about it and he said that it's a bit tasteless to let someone climb on what's "essentially a gravestone". i got mad because he wouldn't support me and undermined me in front the children like that. i went to the bathroom where i called my sister to tell her what happend. she said that the girl shouldn't have approached me like that but that i was also wrong for the way i responded to her. i told her that the girl was out of line talking to someone that's older then her like that and i hung up. it's been a couple weeks now and it just hasn't been sitting right with me. i've been thinking that maybe i am the asshole and i guess i can see why someone would see a dolmen as a grave. so, am i the asshole for letting my child climb on a rock?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> hi, i'm a 34 year old woman and my 3 children are a 12 year old boy, a 9 year old boy and a 7 year old girl. my husband is a 35 year old man. a couple weeks ago we went on a trip to visit some historical sites in several countries in europe (basically like a roadtrip). my husband had a terrible headache on the fourth day of our trip so he stayed at the hotel while our children and i went to a dolmen. when we got there my children were a bit bored so i let them run around and play for a bit (there weren't a lot of people so they were not bothering anyone) and than my 9 year old climbed on one of the boulders of the dolmen. he looked so proud of himself when he managed to climb up so i wanted to take a photo of him but than a girl (around 19 i'd say) walked up to me and sarcastically asked "do you let your kids climb on their grandparent's graves like that too?". needless to say, i got a bit angry and told her to mind her own bussiness and said that a 5000 year old dead guy won't mind it if a child climbs on a rock. her face looked like i just killed a puppy in front of her and she walked away. when we got back to the hotel i told my husband about it and he said that it's a bit tasteless to let someone climb on what's "essentially a gravestone". i got mad because he wouldn't support me and undermined me in front the children like that. i went to the bathroom where i called my sister to tell her what happend. she said that the girl shouldn't have approached me like that but that i was also wrong for the way i responded to her. i told her that the girl was out of line talking to someone that's older then her like that and i hung up. it's been a couple weeks now and it just hasn't been sitting right with me. i've been thinking that maybe i am the asshole and i guess i can see why someone would see a dolmen as a grave. so, am i the asshole for letting my child climb on a rock? [/INST] yta i had to go look up what a dolmen is, but yta for letting your kid climb on that. it is clearly a thing with ritual significance and they also look somewhat precarious - like lot of people climbing on them could topple them. you are also the ah for thinking that she couldn't call you out on letting your kids climb a tomb because she happens to be younger than you. even old people get to be called out when they do stupid shit. </s>
AITA For doing a welfare check on my girl who's living in a dangerous environment?
my girl (28f) and i (32m) have been together 8 months. she lives with her friend jarrod (27m) who owns the home. jarrod seemed like a great guy, very friendly, down-to-earth and weeks from becoming a physiatrist. medical studies were demanding of him, but we all got along well whenever i was over. i’m a cop. where we live marijuana is common but still illegal. as a law enforcer, i honour the law but also anti-drugs for personal reasons. its not harmless, my peers who smoked marijuana in school are now deadbeats and my best mate got rejected from the army because he’d used marijuana before and now drives trucks. i have not discussed this view with my girl but i think being a law enforcer implies my stance plus nothing about her life gives me reason to suspect she thinks drug use is ok. sometimes when jarrod hung with us i suspected he had used marijuana. i’m trained to suspect it but jarrod’s profile didn’t fit an addict nor would my girl accept living with one. likely my judgement was wrong and he was tired from studies. unfortunately, my instincts were correct. a few weeks ago i arrived at my girl’s house before she had. i let myself in and went to the balcony, jarrod was there. we were casually chatting when he just puffs on a joint and then even offers me a puff. i’m fuming, this guy literally offered a cop drugs so clearly he’s offered my girl drugs. i’m terrified for her safety in this environment. really, as a law enforcer it is my civic duty to enforce the law but my judgement was that jarrod could be reasoned with. i made him aware of my obligation and that his drug use also hurts society and others around him, as well as himself. as a cop and because he lives with my girl, i’ll charge him if my girl is put in danger again. he denied the severity of his use, said he will stop around me but doesn’t respect my attitude or behaviour in his house. mildly insulting response after letting him off but understandable it wasn't taken well. he’s an addict and i’ve made use harder for him in his own home. my girl comes home, we both explain what’s unfolded, my girl says its a lot and i should go home for the night. the next day the city's in lockdown, i’m not able to address with jarrod nor my girl what happened. the last few week she’s talking to me less and less. my anxiety knowing my girl is locked down in such a toxic situation is overwhelming. last week i decided to do a welfare check but send my partner in. he did it but afterwards said that was f\*cked up of me. later that night my girl cut it entirely and filled a complaint against me. i truly didn’t believe i did anything wrong and was just trying to protect my girl but i’ve lost my girl and in career trouble. but both my girl and my partner think i’m f\*cked so maybe i am. aita.
6,833
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/q0h1u5/aita_for_doing_a_welfare_check_on_my_girl_whos/
2021-10-03 12:46:33
yta - the phrase “my girl” is coming across as very creepy. looks like karma really is what they say.
yta - please take a different career path
maybe i’m dangerously off my head on crazy drugs but i suspect this may not be real. if it is, it’s not just **yta, but also you are unstable**. loss of perspective, abuse of power, possessive behaviour, paranoia. are you sure you don’t misuse drugs? i’d never suggest anyone should lose their job but you should at least undergo retraining.
yta. when they say bad cops, they mean you. you think your job gives you moral authority. you think you're allowed to just let yourself into someone else's house that you don't live with? seriously, just stop. your girl probably smokes too. and it doesn't make anyone a bad person. she's waiting to break up with you because she's afraid of bad cops btw.
yta and your ex girl isn't in a toxic situation. she just left one 👏
yta, the only toxic situation your girl is in is the relationship with you.
yta. the fact that marijuana is now legal in so many states should say something to you. this isn’t about the law. it’s about your personal anti-drug crusade and weird possessiveness over “your girl” which is a super creepy way to talk by the way. you then abused your standing by having a welfare check performed. you’re the toxic one here.
i nfo: what the hell is wrong with you. did you watch some of the many sensationalizing anti-weed documentaries made in like, the 1960s? are you from the 1950s? that would actually explain a lot. you don't have a girlfriend anymore, and you deserve that. you deserve to be in career trouble. you are using your job to harass someone who is not in danger or being forced to do anything. you are part of the reason that so many people believe there's no good cops. yta.
yta. the "my girl" comments are creepy, possessive and massive red flags, not to mention the intrusive welfare check . highly recommend therapy to help you overcome some of this controlling ownership before it gets worse. women are not possessions to be owned, they are people.
yta... also, i have a bone to pick with you: &gt;my best mate got rejected from the army because he’d used marijuana before and now drives trucks. soooo, he was rejected from a job where you really aren't paid all that well, you're subjected to conditions that frequently give people ptsd, other mental issues, or physical injuries that disqualify them from future service and turn them over to an overworked and underpaid va system, and now he is working in a field where *starting* pay at a *bottom of the barrel* company is around $40k per year and the industry averages $50k-$80k for *company* drivers.... i think pot saved your mate's life.... (of course, this is coming from a us perspective, so if the trucker situation is much different there, let me know please)
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my girl (28f) and i (32m) have been together 8 months. she lives with her friend jarrod (27m) who owns the home. jarrod seemed like a great guy, very friendly, down-to-earth and weeks from becoming a physiatrist. medical studies were demanding of him, but we all got along well whenever i was over. i’m a cop. where we live marijuana is common but still illegal. as a law enforcer, i honour the law but also anti-drugs for personal reasons. its not harmless, my peers who smoked marijuana in school are now deadbeats and my best mate got rejected from the army because he’d used marijuana before and now drives trucks. i have not discussed this view with my girl but i think being a law enforcer implies my stance plus nothing about her life gives me reason to suspect she thinks drug use is ok. sometimes when jarrod hung with us i suspected he had used marijuana. i’m trained to suspect it but jarrod’s profile didn’t fit an addict nor would my girl accept living with one. likely my judgement was wrong and he was tired from studies. unfortunately, my instincts were correct. a few weeks ago i arrived at my girl’s house before she had. i let myself in and went to the balcony, jarrod was there. we were casually chatting when he just puffs on a joint and then even offers me a puff. i’m fuming, this guy literally offered a cop drugs so clearly he’s offered my girl drugs. i’m terrified for her safety in this environment. really, as a law enforcer it is my civic duty to enforce the law but my judgement was that jarrod could be reasoned with. i made him aware of my obligation and that his drug use also hurts society and others around him, as well as himself. as a cop and because he lives with my girl, i’ll charge him if my girl is put in danger again. he denied the severity of his use, said he will stop around me but doesn’t respect my attitude or behaviour in his house. mildly insulting response after letting him off but understandable it wasn't taken well. he’s an addict and i’ve made use harder for him in his own home. my girl comes home, we both explain what’s unfolded, my girl says its a lot and i should go home for the night. the next day the city's in lockdown, i’m not able to address with jarrod nor my girl what happened. the last few week she’s talking to me less and less. my anxiety knowing my girl is locked down in such a toxic situation is overwhelming. last week i decided to do a welfare check but send my partner in. he did it but afterwards said that was f\*cked up of me. later that night my girl cut it entirely and filled a complaint against me. i truly didn’t believe i did anything wrong and was just trying to protect my girl but i’ve lost my girl and in career trouble. but both my girl and my partner think i’m f\*cked so maybe i am. aita.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my girl (28f) and i (32m) have been together 8 months. she lives with her friend jarrod (27m) who owns the home. jarrod seemed like a great guy, very friendly, down-to-earth and weeks from becoming a physiatrist. medical studies were demanding of him, but we all got along well whenever i was over. i’m a cop. where we live marijuana is common but still illegal. as a law enforcer, i honour the law but also anti-drugs for personal reasons. its not harmless, my peers who smoked marijuana in school are now deadbeats and my best mate got rejected from the army because he’d used marijuana before and now drives trucks. i have not discussed this view with my girl but i think being a law enforcer implies my stance plus nothing about her life gives me reason to suspect she thinks drug use is ok. sometimes when jarrod hung with us i suspected he had used marijuana. i’m trained to suspect it but jarrod’s profile didn’t fit an addict nor would my girl accept living with one. likely my judgement was wrong and he was tired from studies. unfortunately, my instincts were correct. a few weeks ago i arrived at my girl’s house before she had. i let myself in and went to the balcony, jarrod was there. we were casually chatting when he just puffs on a joint and then even offers me a puff. i’m fuming, this guy literally offered a cop drugs so clearly he’s offered my girl drugs. i’m terrified for her safety in this environment. really, as a law enforcer it is my civic duty to enforce the law but my judgement was that jarrod could be reasoned with. i made him aware of my obligation and that his drug use also hurts society and others around him, as well as himself. as a cop and because he lives with my girl, i’ll charge him if my girl is put in danger again. he denied the severity of his use, said he will stop around me but doesn’t respect my attitude or behaviour in his house. mildly insulting response after letting him off but understandable it wasn't taken well. he’s an addict and i’ve made use harder for him in his own home. my girl comes home, we both explain what’s unfolded, my girl says its a lot and i should go home for the night. the next day the city's in lockdown, i’m not able to address with jarrod nor my girl what happened. the last few week she’s talking to me less and less. my anxiety knowing my girl is locked down in such a toxic situation is overwhelming. last week i decided to do a welfare check but send my partner in. he did it but afterwards said that was f\*cked up of me. later that night my girl cut it entirely and filled a complaint against me. i truly didn’t believe i did anything wrong and was just trying to protect my girl but i’ve lost my girl and in career trouble. but both my girl and my partner think i’m f\*cked so maybe i am. aita. [/INST] yta - the phrase “my girl” is coming across as very creepy. looks like karma really is what they say. </s>
AITA for pressing charges against my son?
my son (28) was visiting us for a couple days and was at my house alone babysitting my daughters kid. according to my son, the other day my 4-year-old granddaughter (his niece) pulled down the tv and broke it. my son told us that he took the tv to the dump as it was shattered and useless. my daughter and son-in-law (my 4yo granddaughters parents) felt very bad for what had happened and paid the cost of the tv that day. my husband was watching our security cameras and our son's story doesn't hold up. we never see our granddaughter breaking the tv. all that we see is our son taking away the tv that is not shattered. we asked our son about this and he said that the security camera must have cut out the part that shows our granddaughter breaking the tv. eventually i got a call from my son's girlfriend that lives with him. she said that she knew what was going on and felt guilty. she basically told us that our son had made up the story about the tv breaking and stole it and took it to their house to watch. i filed a police report and his girlfriend let the police into their house to get us our tv back. we do plan on pressing charges against him. he stole our tv and made my daughter pay for it. that is messed up on so many levels. aita for pressing charges?
33,031
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hk5vqi/aita_for_pressing_charges_against_my_son/
2020-07-02 21:29:33
nta at all! if you don't press charges, he'll think he can get away with stuff like this! not cool! frankly, you're not only not the asshole, you absolutely did the right thing and should be praised for it! i'm glad his girlfriend had the integrity to come clean! if it's his first offense, he can plea down to a misdemeanor and get some community service, and hopefully learn his lesson before does something that gets him years behind bars!
nta i usually don't agree with involving the police in family disputes but in this case, it was warranted. he blatantly lied about and to a child, forced the hand of your daughter to pay for the replacement cost of the tv, and stole the tv. if confronted, the situation could have escalated, so filing the police report was the right thing to do. what i'm wondering is what his long game was? like, you would come over to his place, see your old tv and not notice?
[deleted]
i think it’s within your rights to do so... but pressing charges in a situation like this feels extreme. info: have you ever had serious issues with his behavior in the past? e: a prison record will fundamentally ruin someone’s life the majority of the time, and i don’t think a stolen tv is enough to justify that personally. i would only pursue this on my own child until all other avenues - such as counseling/therapy - have been exhausted. if op’s family have already tried to get help for the son, then fine, report them to the cops. for me that would be the absolute last straw to protect the rest of my family. further, the brother was entrusted with the caretaking of a child. i find that strange if he *did* have a history of erratic or damaging behavior. it just strikes me as totally disproportionate to subject someone to the hellscape that is the criminal justice system for something like this.
[deleted]
nta he stole from you.
esh just because i think calling the police and pressing charges against your child should be a last resort, not a first choice. a lot of steps need to come before involving the police. you clearly trusted him since he was alone in your home babysitting his niece. you don’t go from trust to charges without first hitting all the steps in between. (you know: talking ... banning him from your home ... insisting that he return your tv ... that sort of thing)
family or not, theft is theft. you have every right to press charges against your son for what he did. if you don't do anything, he'll have this mentality that he can get away with anything when it comes to you guys. nta.
nta he needs help.
yta you've put charges on your son for something that could have been handled within the family. sounds like your son is probably going through a tough time to get to the point of doing that. why don't you be a parent and figure it out between yourselves.
NTA
NTA
null
INFO
null
NTA
ESH
NTA
NTA
YTA
0.243004
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my son (28) was visiting us for a couple days and was at my house alone babysitting my daughters kid. according to my son, the other day my 4-year-old granddaughter (his niece) pulled down the tv and broke it. my son told us that he took the tv to the dump as it was shattered and useless. my daughter and son-in-law (my 4yo granddaughters parents) felt very bad for what had happened and paid the cost of the tv that day. my husband was watching our security cameras and our son's story doesn't hold up. we never see our granddaughter breaking the tv. all that we see is our son taking away the tv that is not shattered. we asked our son about this and he said that the security camera must have cut out the part that shows our granddaughter breaking the tv. eventually i got a call from my son's girlfriend that lives with him. she said that she knew what was going on and felt guilty. she basically told us that our son had made up the story about the tv breaking and stole it and took it to their house to watch. i filed a police report and his girlfriend let the police into their house to get us our tv back. we do plan on pressing charges against him. he stole our tv and made my daughter pay for it. that is messed up on so many levels. aita for pressing charges?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my son (28) was visiting us for a couple days and was at my house alone babysitting my daughters kid. according to my son, the other day my 4-year-old granddaughter (his niece) pulled down the tv and broke it. my son told us that he took the tv to the dump as it was shattered and useless. my daughter and son-in-law (my 4yo granddaughters parents) felt very bad for what had happened and paid the cost of the tv that day. my husband was watching our security cameras and our son's story doesn't hold up. we never see our granddaughter breaking the tv. all that we see is our son taking away the tv that is not shattered. we asked our son about this and he said that the security camera must have cut out the part that shows our granddaughter breaking the tv. eventually i got a call from my son's girlfriend that lives with him. she said that she knew what was going on and felt guilty. she basically told us that our son had made up the story about the tv breaking and stole it and took it to their house to watch. i filed a police report and his girlfriend let the police into their house to get us our tv back. we do plan on pressing charges against him. he stole our tv and made my daughter pay for it. that is messed up on so many levels. aita for pressing charges? [/INST] nta at all! if you don't press charges, he'll think he can get away with stuff like this! not cool! frankly, you're not only not the asshole, you absolutely did the right thing and should be praised for it! i'm glad his girlfriend had the integrity to come clean! if it's his first offense, he can plea down to a misdemeanor and get some community service, and hopefully learn his lesson before does something that gets him years behind bars! </s>
AITA For throwing all of my sons belongings out of his window?
my 17 year old recently got busted playing cruel pranks on one of his classmates, it involved a girl, a date, and then a series of photos of the student being stood up circulating around the school. my son fessed up to it. i gave him the choice to either write an apology letter to the classmate he 'pranked' or he could be grounded for 3 weeks. my son chose the 3 weeks, i suppose that's a pride thing. he's spent the better part of it in his bedroom because he's been studying for assignments and exams and i was fine with that, he's always been good with his grades and he puts a lot of work into passing. about 4 days until the end of his punishment and i asked him if he'd like to watch a movie with the rest of the family, he said no, his test at school was the next day and had to study, fine by me. i'm usually at work before he wakes up (gone by 6:30) so i went into his room before bed to wish him good luck only to find his room empty!. i searched the house for him, figuring he could have gone down for snacks or to use the bathroom but he was completely gone. it was then that my husband discovered he'd cleverly removed the security screen from his bedroom window and had been sneaking out. so, i proceeded to throw his belongings out of the window, he said he was going to be in his room and that's where he went so i figured that's where all of his stuff belonged. x box, lamps, computer, clothes, posters, yes, even the bed was dismantled and thrown out into the backyard. we kept all the lights on and retired to our bedroom like we always do (it was about 10pm at this point) and when i went downstairs, there was my son sitting at the table with a glass of juice, saying he came down for a study break. when he finished his juice he went back upstairs and came down a few minutes later. he didn't seem remorseful at all at being caught and merely said 'okay busted, where's my stuff' i told him it was all in his room. he found it all outside and threw a teenage temper tantrum about how unfair it was, i told him he could either write an apology letter to us and we'd help him move his stuff in or he could move his own stuff back in provided he wanted to move back in and put it all back together himself. we got our apology letter and helped move things back in and set his room back up with everything that wasn't broken. on top of this, he had to finish off his grounding and apologize to the classmate he 'pranked' the grounding lifted as planned and he went to stay with my sister for the weekend in the country to clear his head. he must have told her what happened because i received a nasty phone call about how much of an ah i am and how that was way too much for such a small offense. i personally feel as though it was justified after he'd completely ignored his punishment and lied and thought he was being sly about it. aita?
6,535
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/tk08on/aita_for_throwing_all_of_my_sons_belongings_out/
2022-03-22 10:52:40
yta for the weak punishments. doesn’t seem like you’re teaching him anything. you ground him yet he has an xbox and computer in his room?
esh. gee, wonder where your son got his total inability to distinguish things like “fun pranks” or “appropriate punishments” from wanton cruelty. what exactly do you think you accomplished with all this, other than wasting your own time and money on wrecking the stuff *you* presumably bought him? what lesson do you think he learned, besides “op’s a dick”?
nta but i would've handled it differently. never would've given him the option of not apologizing publicly.
that's not a prank. that's straight out bullying and reputation breaking. what he did was a pure ah move and if you allow him to treat girls like this now as a teen, how is he going to treat them as he gets older? apology letter? no. that requires face to face. secondly, he's sneaking out of the house. thats in no way is a "small offense" his sister gets no say in how you parent your son. period. would i have thrown out everything that i paid for? no. that's plain dumb cus guess who is paying to replace them. i wouldve taken the door off the hinges. taken the xbox, computer etc. left him with nothing but clothes and a bed. he could earn the rest back.
yta for an ineffective and stupid punishment nta for punishing him, should have punished him better
esh him for the obvious. bullying, sneaking out. you for your wildly inconsistent and disproportionate punishments. 1. an apology letter is not really a punishment. apologizing for what you did wrong is the bare minimum requirement for taking accountability. this is a very weak punishment option for his actions. 2. grounding him in a way that takes nothing from him but his ability to leave the house is not punishing him in any meaningful way either. 3. throwing all of his stuff outside in response to him sneaking out is simultaneously a pretty big overreaction to his actions and a discordantly inconsistent punishment considering how you've dealt with his other misbehavior in the story. the way you disciplined your son here is all over the place. he needs firm consequences for his actions that are also consistently proportional to what he's being punished for. what you did was punish him lightly for his major misbehavior and harshly for his relatively lesser offense. it's no wonder his own behavior is out of bounds.
why did you give him a choice in the first place? apologising to the poor girl should have been mandatory. why did you give him an easy out? did you even talk to him about the severity and cruelty of his 'prank'? he doesn't seem like he has learnt anything to be honest.
yta. a better punishment for bullying would have been to demand he publicly apologize to her and then get him in some kind of counseling. based on your reaction to him sneaking out, family counseling might be a good place to start? he definitely deserves a harsh punishment but what message are you really sending by grounding him but still letting him have all of his entertainment in his room? also, totally understand the anger and need for escalating punishment once you found out he was sneaking out but trashing his personal belongings is an emotional outburst response on your part. not a good example, at all. you just showed him it’s okay to lash out and disrespect someone’s property when you’re angry. next time, increase punishment and remove his belongings.
yeah yta. you are meant to be teaching him how to be a grown up but instead you throw all his stuff out the window! you let him keep all this stuff when he's meant to be grounded. who was watching him to make sure that he was doing what he was meant to?
yta, this is ridiculous. you effed up on the punishment and then you throwing tantrum like three years old and destroy your son's things (i belive mostly things you bought him with your hard earned money). first of all the public apology should have been mandatory. and keeping all his electronics in room where he is supposed to be grounded, like, really? and not regularly checking on grounded teenager? big mistake from your side.
YTA
ESH
NTA
null
YTA
ESH
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
0.091339
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my 17 year old recently got busted playing cruel pranks on one of his classmates, it involved a girl, a date, and then a series of photos of the student being stood up circulating around the school. my son fessed up to it. i gave him the choice to either write an apology letter to the classmate he 'pranked' or he could be grounded for 3 weeks. my son chose the 3 weeks, i suppose that's a pride thing. he's spent the better part of it in his bedroom because he's been studying for assignments and exams and i was fine with that, he's always been good with his grades and he puts a lot of work into passing. about 4 days until the end of his punishment and i asked him if he'd like to watch a movie with the rest of the family, he said no, his test at school was the next day and had to study, fine by me. i'm usually at work before he wakes up (gone by 6:30) so i went into his room before bed to wish him good luck only to find his room empty!. i searched the house for him, figuring he could have gone down for snacks or to use the bathroom but he was completely gone. it was then that my husband discovered he'd cleverly removed the security screen from his bedroom window and had been sneaking out. so, i proceeded to throw his belongings out of the window, he said he was going to be in his room and that's where he went so i figured that's where all of his stuff belonged. x box, lamps, computer, clothes, posters, yes, even the bed was dismantled and thrown out into the backyard. we kept all the lights on and retired to our bedroom like we always do (it was about 10pm at this point) and when i went downstairs, there was my son sitting at the table with a glass of juice, saying he came down for a study break. when he finished his juice he went back upstairs and came down a few minutes later. he didn't seem remorseful at all at being caught and merely said 'okay busted, where's my stuff' i told him it was all in his room. he found it all outside and threw a teenage temper tantrum about how unfair it was, i told him he could either write an apology letter to us and we'd help him move his stuff in or he could move his own stuff back in provided he wanted to move back in and put it all back together himself. we got our apology letter and helped move things back in and set his room back up with everything that wasn't broken. on top of this, he had to finish off his grounding and apologize to the classmate he 'pranked' the grounding lifted as planned and he went to stay with my sister for the weekend in the country to clear his head. he must have told her what happened because i received a nasty phone call about how much of an ah i am and how that was way too much for such a small offense. i personally feel as though it was justified after he'd completely ignored his punishment and lied and thought he was being sly about it. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my 17 year old recently got busted playing cruel pranks on one of his classmates, it involved a girl, a date, and then a series of photos of the student being stood up circulating around the school. my son fessed up to it. i gave him the choice to either write an apology letter to the classmate he 'pranked' or he could be grounded for 3 weeks. my son chose the 3 weeks, i suppose that's a pride thing. he's spent the better part of it in his bedroom because he's been studying for assignments and exams and i was fine with that, he's always been good with his grades and he puts a lot of work into passing. about 4 days until the end of his punishment and i asked him if he'd like to watch a movie with the rest of the family, he said no, his test at school was the next day and had to study, fine by me. i'm usually at work before he wakes up (gone by 6:30) so i went into his room before bed to wish him good luck only to find his room empty!. i searched the house for him, figuring he could have gone down for snacks or to use the bathroom but he was completely gone. it was then that my husband discovered he'd cleverly removed the security screen from his bedroom window and had been sneaking out. so, i proceeded to throw his belongings out of the window, he said he was going to be in his room and that's where he went so i figured that's where all of his stuff belonged. x box, lamps, computer, clothes, posters, yes, even the bed was dismantled and thrown out into the backyard. we kept all the lights on and retired to our bedroom like we always do (it was about 10pm at this point) and when i went downstairs, there was my son sitting at the table with a glass of juice, saying he came down for a study break. when he finished his juice he went back upstairs and came down a few minutes later. he didn't seem remorseful at all at being caught and merely said 'okay busted, where's my stuff' i told him it was all in his room. he found it all outside and threw a teenage temper tantrum about how unfair it was, i told him he could either write an apology letter to us and we'd help him move his stuff in or he could move his own stuff back in provided he wanted to move back in and put it all back together himself. we got our apology letter and helped move things back in and set his room back up with everything that wasn't broken. on top of this, he had to finish off his grounding and apologize to the classmate he 'pranked' the grounding lifted as planned and he went to stay with my sister for the weekend in the country to clear his head. he must have told her what happened because i received a nasty phone call about how much of an ah i am and how that was way too much for such a small offense. i personally feel as though it was justified after he'd completely ignored his punishment and lied and thought he was being sly about it. aita? [/INST] yta for the weak punishments. doesn’t seem like you’re teaching him anything. you ground him yet he has an xbox and computer in his room? </s>
AITA for giving my twin sons different allowances?
i (43m) have four kids. the two oldest are twin boys (both 14m) and then we have two girls (10f and 7f). all of them are pretty responsible kids, and consistently do their chores as they're meant to. we have a little chart that says what all their jobs are, with each of their roles being proportional to their ages. the boys take on the largest number of responsibilities, which each of them alternating jobs every week. officially, their allowances have been as follows for a while: boys: both $15 a week 10-year-old: $10 7-year-old: $2, mostly for symbolic purposes lol obviously, as the girls age, they'll start making more money, just as they'll start doing more work around the house. but here's the thing. one of my boys (call him a to differentiate) is a real leader in the home. he's just naturally brilliant with people, is constantly dealing with conflicts between his sisters and his brother, takes charge in rough situations, and is really considerate of others. he's always been the "frontman" between his brother and him, with him speaking for both of them while his brother hangs back. though we've never told him to, and though it's not his responsibility, he's always been a real help to his mother and me in keeping the house running smoothly. his brother (call him b), on the other hand, is much more reserved. he keeps to himself. that's not a problem, but we do recognize that a takes on more "emotional labor" in the household than b. so, my wife and i have been giving a an extra $5 a week for the past year, so he's been making $20 while b's been making $15. we think that's fair, since a's taken on more responsibilities in the house, even if they weren't responsibilities we told him to take on. the boys both have debit cards (got them when they were 13), so we put the money directly into their accounts and neither of them see money getting exchanged. a does know he makes more money, though. last week, however, b found out his brother was making more money than him. they were online shopping for video games, and b questioned why a was able to afford stuff he couldn't (a hasn't really spent his extra money, so it's accumulated a fair bit). a admitted to him that he's been making more. b is absolutely furious with us. he says that it's totally unfair that they've been doing the same amount of chores, but a's been making more money. but we don't really know how to explain to him that a deserves recognition for the less easily quantifiable work he does in our family. thoughts?
10,950
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/fxbnct/aita_for_giving_my_twin_sons_different_allowances/
2020-04-08 18:17:30
yta you are punishing one son for having a more reserved personality. resolving conflicts with his siblings etc is not his job, the household chores are.
yta. you obviously favor a. you are giving b less money due to his personality, not the chores, which you admit they perform equally.
if you’ve been doing this for a year, that’s 52 weeks. 52 times 5 is 260. you’ve given one of your sons an extra $260 for being an extrovert. duh, yta
yta you’re basically punishing son b for not being as outgoing as son a which, now that he knows his brother “earns” more, will do mental damage. i know this from experience. allowances are for physical tasks done not emotional ones.
yta many twins seek differences between each other, and you've now given them one that mum and dad value twin a more than twin b. i get where you're coming from with the emotional labour stance, but by "rewarding" twin a for his personality, you're inadvertently showing twin b that you prefer twin a's personality more, and by extention that you prefer twin a over twin b. emotional labour is not something you can healthily apply to your kids. that's between you and your wife. you're showing twin b that his personality isn't worth rewarding, and that he isn't worth as much as their twin. you're also giving twin a an ego boost, which has a chance of going wrong. they could take it out on their twin by putting them down, and having "proof" that their parents think twin a is more valuable than twin b. not exactly a dynamic worth encouraging. oof.
yta surprise fact - people have different personalities and demeanor. one of your twins happens to have a higher emotional iq and the other is a bit more introverted. you even say in the post that you can't explain to b why he's making less money - of course he's upset.
yta 100 percent. you are playing favorites plain and simple. were you that naive to think son b wouldn't find out and react negatively?
yta, one is extroverted and the other is introverted. in essence you are rewarding one for different brain chemistry. i know b can learn a's skill, but at 14... in the real world introverts get shit on a lot and passed over because of poor networking skills despite having the adequate competencies but do you really have to execute that reality in your home to a 14 year old...
hi reddit, we treat one of our children as if he’s better than the others, to the point where we’ve discussed it as a couple. he is clearly our favorite child. however, the less favored child doesn’t seem to know his place! why doesn’t he understand that his brother is just better than him? please co-sign my bullshit, u/throw53047
yta- paying a 14 for emotional labor doesn’t really make sense. of course this is causing conflict, it always will. your son who is getting the lower pay will probably internalize this into being less loved. can’t you just rationalize that one of your sons has more leadership skills without needing to pay him for this trait? would you pay one child more if they were smarter, or better looking?
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (43m) have four kids. the two oldest are twin boys (both 14m) and then we have two girls (10f and 7f). all of them are pretty responsible kids, and consistently do their chores as they're meant to. we have a little chart that says what all their jobs are, with each of their roles being proportional to their ages. the boys take on the largest number of responsibilities, which each of them alternating jobs every week. officially, their allowances have been as follows for a while: boys: both $15 a week 10-year-old: $10 7-year-old: $2, mostly for symbolic purposes lol obviously, as the girls age, they'll start making more money, just as they'll start doing more work around the house. but here's the thing. one of my boys (call him a to differentiate) is a real leader in the home. he's just naturally brilliant with people, is constantly dealing with conflicts between his sisters and his brother, takes charge in rough situations, and is really considerate of others. he's always been the "frontman" between his brother and him, with him speaking for both of them while his brother hangs back. though we've never told him to, and though it's not his responsibility, he's always been a real help to his mother and me in keeping the house running smoothly. his brother (call him b), on the other hand, is much more reserved. he keeps to himself. that's not a problem, but we do recognize that a takes on more "emotional labor" in the household than b. so, my wife and i have been giving a an extra $5 a week for the past year, so he's been making $20 while b's been making $15. we think that's fair, since a's taken on more responsibilities in the house, even if they weren't responsibilities we told him to take on. the boys both have debit cards (got them when they were 13), so we put the money directly into their accounts and neither of them see money getting exchanged. a does know he makes more money, though. last week, however, b found out his brother was making more money than him. they were online shopping for video games, and b questioned why a was able to afford stuff he couldn't (a hasn't really spent his extra money, so it's accumulated a fair bit). a admitted to him that he's been making more. b is absolutely furious with us. he says that it's totally unfair that they've been doing the same amount of chores, but a's been making more money. but we don't really know how to explain to him that a deserves recognition for the less easily quantifiable work he does in our family. thoughts?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (43m) have four kids. the two oldest are twin boys (both 14m) and then we have two girls (10f and 7f). all of them are pretty responsible kids, and consistently do their chores as they're meant to. we have a little chart that says what all their jobs are, with each of their roles being proportional to their ages. the boys take on the largest number of responsibilities, which each of them alternating jobs every week. officially, their allowances have been as follows for a while: boys: both $15 a week 10-year-old: $10 7-year-old: $2, mostly for symbolic purposes lol obviously, as the girls age, they'll start making more money, just as they'll start doing more work around the house. but here's the thing. one of my boys (call him a to differentiate) is a real leader in the home. he's just naturally brilliant with people, is constantly dealing with conflicts between his sisters and his brother, takes charge in rough situations, and is really considerate of others. he's always been the "frontman" between his brother and him, with him speaking for both of them while his brother hangs back. though we've never told him to, and though it's not his responsibility, he's always been a real help to his mother and me in keeping the house running smoothly. his brother (call him b), on the other hand, is much more reserved. he keeps to himself. that's not a problem, but we do recognize that a takes on more "emotional labor" in the household than b. so, my wife and i have been giving a an extra $5 a week for the past year, so he's been making $20 while b's been making $15. we think that's fair, since a's taken on more responsibilities in the house, even if they weren't responsibilities we told him to take on. the boys both have debit cards (got them when they were 13), so we put the money directly into their accounts and neither of them see money getting exchanged. a does know he makes more money, though. last week, however, b found out his brother was making more money than him. they were online shopping for video games, and b questioned why a was able to afford stuff he couldn't (a hasn't really spent his extra money, so it's accumulated a fair bit). a admitted to him that he's been making more. b is absolutely furious with us. he says that it's totally unfair that they've been doing the same amount of chores, but a's been making more money. but we don't really know how to explain to him that a deserves recognition for the less easily quantifiable work he does in our family. thoughts? [/INST] yta you are punishing one son for having a more reserved personality. resolving conflicts with his siblings etc is not his job, the household chores are. </s>
AITA for yelling at my husband's mother for announcing my pregnancy using my husband's facebook account?
i f23 found out that i was pregnant very recently, it was not planned and my husband and i are trying to make a decision regarding going through with the pregnancy. here's the thing, i told him to not tell anyone but he ended up telling his mom but made her swear that she won't tell. he didn't tell her we aren't sure about it but just to stay quiet. well, she begged and begged that she announce it on her facebook under the guise of using our permission but i said absolutely not and lied and said my husband and i wanted to announce it ourselves later if we decide to go through with it. just a day ago i found out she logged into my husband's facebook account and dropped the bomb (made the announcement and yes she pretended to be my husband!) behind our back. i was floored i called her and she said she figured if she made the announcement using one of our social media accounts then we won't mind and it'd still look like we made the announcement. but like i stated earlier, we're still trying to make a decision. i lost my temper and yelled at her which made her cry. i said she overstepped and messed up completely then hung up. my husband came into the room yelling about my poor treatment and abuse towards his mom. i told him his mom violated our privacy and put us in more pressure to finally make a decision for the baby since the family are now calling to say "congratulations", he said that it was his fb so none of my privacy was "violated"and that i shouldn't have yelled and hurt her feelings and made her cry no matter what, period. he demanded i apologize and we'll talk about the pregnancy later but i didn't give an answer and refused when he tried to force me to go to her house and "grovel" with apologies. aita?
20,501
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/u2pi5b/aita_for_yelling_at_my_husbands_mother_for/
2022-04-13 12:45:38
nta. quite frankly, you need to truly consider if you want to have a child with this man, because this behavior (his, and his mother's) is only a wind-up. it will get worse.
nta. think hard about whether you want to be tied to this family for the next 18 years. is your husband going to yell at you and side with his mom every time you disagree about your kid? termination and say you miscarried is one option. sounds like your husband's family is trying to force your hand. this marriage sounds over already tbh.
nta. abortion and divorce.
nta- this moment should tell you everything about the support you will get from both your husband and mil in both stressful and private situations. her behavior and his support won't get better with the addition of an infant. use this information to guide your decisions on the future.
nta - you have a problem larger than your pregnancy! you have a momma boy, not a husband. secondly, how on earth does she have is fb password? **terminate the marriage** and decide later about the pregnancy.
nta. i have a very strong suspicion that your mil and husband conspired to do this, hence his reluctance to confront mil. personal opinion, you should have a very direct conversation with your husband. if he had a hand in violating your trust then you have a decision to make...
nta. if you were wavering about what to do, his bullying may help you make your final decision.
nta - yeetus that fetus. you are being given front row seats to the hell of your existence having a baby with your terrible husband.
get an abortion yesterday and leave this mess. nta
nta and i'd reconsider the marriage. you don't want to raise a kid with a man who will side with his mother under any circumstances. parenting with a partner is tough enough... parenting with a partner who defers to mommy is impossible
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i f23 found out that i was pregnant very recently, it was not planned and my husband and i are trying to make a decision regarding going through with the pregnancy. here's the thing, i told him to not tell anyone but he ended up telling his mom but made her swear that she won't tell. he didn't tell her we aren't sure about it but just to stay quiet. well, she begged and begged that she announce it on her facebook under the guise of using our permission but i said absolutely not and lied and said my husband and i wanted to announce it ourselves later if we decide to go through with it. just a day ago i found out she logged into my husband's facebook account and dropped the bomb (made the announcement and yes she pretended to be my husband!) behind our back. i was floored i called her and she said she figured if she made the announcement using one of our social media accounts then we won't mind and it'd still look like we made the announcement. but like i stated earlier, we're still trying to make a decision. i lost my temper and yelled at her which made her cry. i said she overstepped and messed up completely then hung up. my husband came into the room yelling about my poor treatment and abuse towards his mom. i told him his mom violated our privacy and put us in more pressure to finally make a decision for the baby since the family are now calling to say "congratulations", he said that it was his fb so none of my privacy was "violated"and that i shouldn't have yelled and hurt her feelings and made her cry no matter what, period. he demanded i apologize and we'll talk about the pregnancy later but i didn't give an answer and refused when he tried to force me to go to her house and "grovel" with apologies. aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i f23 found out that i was pregnant very recently, it was not planned and my husband and i are trying to make a decision regarding going through with the pregnancy. here's the thing, i told him to not tell anyone but he ended up telling his mom but made her swear that she won't tell. he didn't tell her we aren't sure about it but just to stay quiet. well, she begged and begged that she announce it on her facebook under the guise of using our permission but i said absolutely not and lied and said my husband and i wanted to announce it ourselves later if we decide to go through with it. just a day ago i found out she logged into my husband's facebook account and dropped the bomb (made the announcement and yes she pretended to be my husband!) behind our back. i was floored i called her and she said she figured if she made the announcement using one of our social media accounts then we won't mind and it'd still look like we made the announcement. but like i stated earlier, we're still trying to make a decision. i lost my temper and yelled at her which made her cry. i said she overstepped and messed up completely then hung up. my husband came into the room yelling about my poor treatment and abuse towards his mom. i told him his mom violated our privacy and put us in more pressure to finally make a decision for the baby since the family are now calling to say "congratulations", he said that it was his fb so none of my privacy was "violated"and that i shouldn't have yelled and hurt her feelings and made her cry no matter what, period. he demanded i apologize and we'll talk about the pregnancy later but i didn't give an answer and refused when he tried to force me to go to her house and "grovel" with apologies. aita? [/INST] nta. quite frankly, you need to truly consider if you want to have a child with this man, because this behavior (his, and his mother's) is only a wind-up. it will get worse. </s>
AITA for pretending to not know my wife when she blew up at an old lady?
i am (23m) and my wife is (24f). she is a lovely person, and absolutely not the sort to blow up for no reason. however, hormones have taken the toll on her, and as she enters her second trimester, things have been a little tense. earlier, we were at a grocery store, and i had our (2f) daughter while my wife was in the dairy aisle. we were a few feet away, when i heard some old lady ask my wife how far along she was. my wife answered. i assumed all was well until i heard my wife go - "you don't touch somebody's stomach without asking them! how would you feel if i did that to you, huh? are you fucking dumb?' i turned to stare at them, only to find that the whole store was staring at them as well. i didn't know what to do, and didn't know how to defend my wife's words against an old lady with a walker, and so i turned back around and continued to browse a cookie display. my wife didn't say anything, just walked away, and after a moment or two, i followed her, only to find that she was pissed off, not at the lady, but me for just turning around and pretending not to know her. she accused me of not caring about her enough to defend her and then took the our daughter from me so that she could give me the cold shoulder. i've been thinking about it for awhile and am honestly torn. on one hand, i was embarrassed and didn't want to cause a scene, but shes my wife and i should've been there for her.
4,189
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/kirne8/aita_for_pretending_to_not_know_my_wife_when_she/
2020-12-23 11:47:28
yta dude. a stranger touched your wife without her consent and your response is to pretend you don't know her? come on. i don't blame your wife for going off on that woman. people for some ungodly reason tend to act like pregnant people are public property and it's freaking aggravating to ward off grabby hands from nosy strangers.
&gt;an old lady with a walker yta and the old lady too. yes she's old and frail but that's not all she is. she's an adult with decades of experience that should have taught her not to touch strangers body's whether there is a baby in there or not. you shouldn't have pretended you didn't know your wife, you should have been there to help her move away.
yta. you didn’t defend your pregnant wife against a stranger touching her body without permission. and then you ignored her like she wasn’t your wife.
* info * what if a man touched her instead of the old woman? i do think you'd care. your wife would and did because she is being touched either way. your wife was touched without her consent. esh except wife &gt;absolutely not the sort to blow up for no reason this is a reason to blow up. her body. also pandemic. &gt;however, hormones have taken the toll on her, and as she enters her second trimester, things have been a little tense. you're blaming her reaction on hormones, not the blatant disrespect to her bodily autonomy. you also ignored her in the store and didn't stand up for her or comfort her. thanks for the awards!!!! op, please think about the first question, old lady vs dude touching your wife without her consent.
yta someone touched your wife, during a pandemic, and made your pregnant wife uncomfortable in public, and you just blame it on hormones and pretend not to know her? to avoid causing scenes, you gonna do the same thing when your toddlers inevitably have tantrums in public? will you just walk away from them instead of doing something about it? your wife could’ve used nicer words, but she has the right not to be touched if she didn’t ask for it, even by little old ladies with a walker. what if it had been a little old man with a walker? seriously...
yta i’m a caregiver for the elderly. oftentimes we get hit, shouted at, and abused by people who are completely aware of what they’re doing (i.e., they don’t have alzheimer’s disease). do you know what we do when that happens? we tell them that their behavior is unacceptable and we walk away. we defend ourselves. if the behavior continues, they are evicted from the facility. old people are not stupid. old people are not children. just because she has a walker doesn’t mean she’s some fragile old woman who can’t handle consequences for her actions. if anything she should be held more responsible because she’s had decades of life experience to know that what she did was unacceptable. not only did you not support your wife, but she probably lost respect for you because you’re a grown man who acted like a coward while your wife was standing up for herself. i know we’re trying to get away from traditional gender roles but as a woman, if i was pregnant, i would expect my husband to be on high alert for any disrespect toward me and i would also feel extremely embarrassed to be with him if he was so afraid of an old woman that he *pretended not to know me* just to avoid confrontation. that’s your unborn child growing in her. if anything your instinct should be to defend her, especially in a pandemic.
yta. you are the asshole for not defending your wife. it is totally within her rights to feel uncomfortable and violated when a stranger 1. asks her how far along she is (big no no) and 2. touches her without permission. so because of those two reasons old lady is also an asshole. your wife felt violated and that was her reaction. we are also living in covid times, where no one should be touching anyone. i don't blame her at all, though her reaction may have been a tad extreme.
yta, stand by your woman and how would you like it if people grabbed your belly without invitation.
yta. that’s the most pathetic conflict averse behavior i’ve heard of occurring. you should be ashamed of yourself.
yta even now you're undermining her reaction by chalking it up to hormones. someone touched her without her consent. old lady or not, she is allowed to react strongly to that. especially if you're in an area affected by the virus. good for your wife for standing up for herself. shame on you for not doing the bare minimum to back her up.
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0.003
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i am (23m) and my wife is (24f). she is a lovely person, and absolutely not the sort to blow up for no reason. however, hormones have taken the toll on her, and as she enters her second trimester, things have been a little tense. earlier, we were at a grocery store, and i had our (2f) daughter while my wife was in the dairy aisle. we were a few feet away, when i heard some old lady ask my wife how far along she was. my wife answered. i assumed all was well until i heard my wife go - "you don't touch somebody's stomach without asking them! how would you feel if i did that to you, huh? are you fucking dumb?' i turned to stare at them, only to find that the whole store was staring at them as well. i didn't know what to do, and didn't know how to defend my wife's words against an old lady with a walker, and so i turned back around and continued to browse a cookie display. my wife didn't say anything, just walked away, and after a moment or two, i followed her, only to find that she was pissed off, not at the lady, but me for just turning around and pretending not to know her. she accused me of not caring about her enough to defend her and then took the our daughter from me so that she could give me the cold shoulder. i've been thinking about it for awhile and am honestly torn. on one hand, i was embarrassed and didn't want to cause a scene, but shes my wife and i should've been there for her.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i am (23m) and my wife is (24f). she is a lovely person, and absolutely not the sort to blow up for no reason. however, hormones have taken the toll on her, and as she enters her second trimester, things have been a little tense. earlier, we were at a grocery store, and i had our (2f) daughter while my wife was in the dairy aisle. we were a few feet away, when i heard some old lady ask my wife how far along she was. my wife answered. i assumed all was well until i heard my wife go - "you don't touch somebody's stomach without asking them! how would you feel if i did that to you, huh? are you fucking dumb?' i turned to stare at them, only to find that the whole store was staring at them as well. i didn't know what to do, and didn't know how to defend my wife's words against an old lady with a walker, and so i turned back around and continued to browse a cookie display. my wife didn't say anything, just walked away, and after a moment or two, i followed her, only to find that she was pissed off, not at the lady, but me for just turning around and pretending not to know her. she accused me of not caring about her enough to defend her and then took the our daughter from me so that she could give me the cold shoulder. i've been thinking about it for awhile and am honestly torn. on one hand, i was embarrassed and didn't want to cause a scene, but shes my wife and i should've been there for her. [/INST] yta dude. a stranger touched your wife without her consent and your response is to pretend you don't know her? come on. i don't blame your wife for going off on that woman. people for some ungodly reason tend to act like pregnant people are public property and it's freaking aggravating to ward off grabby hands from nosy strangers. </s>
AITA for not sitting outside with my daughter
a bit of backstory, im on mobile so sorry for format. so my daughter (23 f) doesnt leave her room much at all. she tends to play video games way too much as she says it helps her depression. i frequently ask her to sit outside with me in our garden as a bit of sunshine might help her feel better yet she always refuses either saying she doesnt want to or shes busy playing games with her friends. i recently bought a hammock for my husband and my daughter took a liking to it. she has sat in it every day since. today she asked if i would sit outside with her and i refused saying im busy watchinng tv. she got a little offended and said i always ask her to go outside and now she is i wont sit with her. am i the asshole for not going outside with her?
3,349
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/gpy49n/aita_for_not_sitting_outside_with_my_daughter/
2020-05-24 21:47:04
yta. you push her to go outside and she asked for your support. you were too busy watching tv to support your depressed child. she asked to spend time with you outside and you opted to watch tv. you didn't ask her to wait up for you to be done. you shut her down.
yta because you are the parent, and your kiddo finally showed interest in doing the thing you have been trying to get her to do. it's a discouraging response, not a supportive one.
info: did you really not want to or are you being petty?
yta. i get that you're trying to make a point. but, at the expense of shutting your daughter down when she reaches out seems counter productive. there were better ways to handle this.
yta i’m not sure how bad your daughter’s depression is, but her asking you to sit with her is an obvious olive branch. she’s inviting you to spend time with her, and you’re behaving childishly by refusing because she refused before. you need to be the bigger person and realise that she is less rational 1. as she’s depressed and 2. as she’s a child. if i were you i’d apologise and say you’d love to spend time with her.
yta and a hypocrite at that. how dare you moan about her for refusing to go outside with you, downplaying her depression and then turn around and do the same to her. shame on you.
yta this is the reason people stay in their rooms. pushing and pushing them to do something you want them to do (leave their room, exercise more, sit in the garden etc etc) and then essentially punishing them for it? you say so yourself you frequently asked her to sit outside with you and the one time she is willing to you dont say "maybe later" you refused because you wanted to watch tv. do you honestly think she is going to ask you again or join you the next time you ask with this behaviour? it's the same as saying "why dont you come out of your room?" and then when she does "oh my god she has risen" or some other equally sarcastic response. it just makes her less willing to and builds resentment.
info: why won't you sit outside? to prove a point or something else?
i remember once that i used to have hard time remembering to roll up the car window before my mom shut the car off. she'd sigh in exasperation, complain, turn the car back on, and ask me to roll up the window. one day, i remembered before she shut the car off, and i announced it happily. all my mom did was complain about the other times i forgot. i was so proud of myself for finally remembering, and all i got was scolding instead of affirmation. so. i looked her dead in the eye, and rolled the window back down. gentle yta, but yeah. same basic concept. you didn't mean to, but you shut her down when she finally accomplished what you wanted.
nah and this sub has lost its damn mind. no, you don't have to drop everything to go sit outside just because you've offered to do so in the past. you're not at her beck and call forever.
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
INFO
YTA
NAH
0.067375
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: a bit of backstory, im on mobile so sorry for format. so my daughter (23 f) doesnt leave her room much at all. she tends to play video games way too much as she says it helps her depression. i frequently ask her to sit outside with me in our garden as a bit of sunshine might help her feel better yet she always refuses either saying she doesnt want to or shes busy playing games with her friends. i recently bought a hammock for my husband and my daughter took a liking to it. she has sat in it every day since. today she asked if i would sit outside with her and i refused saying im busy watchinng tv. she got a little offended and said i always ask her to go outside and now she is i wont sit with her. am i the asshole for not going outside with her?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> a bit of backstory, im on mobile so sorry for format. so my daughter (23 f) doesnt leave her room much at all. she tends to play video games way too much as she says it helps her depression. i frequently ask her to sit outside with me in our garden as a bit of sunshine might help her feel better yet she always refuses either saying she doesnt want to or shes busy playing games with her friends. i recently bought a hammock for my husband and my daughter took a liking to it. she has sat in it every day since. today she asked if i would sit outside with her and i refused saying im busy watchinng tv. she got a little offended and said i always ask her to go outside and now she is i wont sit with her. am i the asshole for not going outside with her? [/INST] yta. you push her to go outside and she asked for your support. you were too busy watching tv to support your depressed child. she asked to spend time with you outside and you opted to watch tv. you didn't ask her to wait up for you to be done. you shut her down. </s>
AITA for getting my family to do a "swear tax" after my dad told me off for swearing? (My dad and brothers cuss like sailors but apparently me cussing is unladylike?)
i am living with my family, it's me a 15 year old girl, my twin brothers who are 17, and my parents. my dad cusses a lot, and so do my older brothers. but apparently the standards are different for me, my dad overheard me saying a couple cuss words when i was on the phone with my friends and he got mad at me for my language, and for how trashy and unladylike it was. this wasn't the first time he called me (and only me) out for bad language, but it was the one that frustrated me the most because i could tell there was a double standard. i thought of calling him out on his language and hipocracy, but then i had a different idea. --- i said that yeah, it was a bad habit i was forming and didn't want to make a pattern... because if i got in the habit of cussing a lot, that wouldn't make me come off well when i start getting jobs or going to college. and as i was growing up, i wanted to learn how to speak respectfully and intelligently. but it was hard to keep from bad habits, when i heard him and my brothers having potty-mouth-syndrome so often. they're setting an example whether they realize it or not... so i wanted to work on things for myself, but also together as a family. i suggested we make a "swear tax" where if anyone swears in front of anyone else who's participating, they give a dollar to each person who heard them. i'd want that rule for myself because it would keep me accountable and i'd really like it if the family joined me for it... ---- so my dad said he'd join, and so would my mom. they got my brothers to be a part of it too. they didn't really have a choice, my parents decided to make it a rule. i know it's kinda petty but i wanted to make the point that my dad and brothers swear a lot and i almost never do. in the few months we've had the rule, i've gotten about 250 dollars from hearing my dad and brothers cuss, and have not sworn once. it's kinda making my brothers angry because they often cuss when they're mad, and i ask them for money, so they get madder and cuss more, so i get more money until they shut up. my dad actually got mad at me too, he was having some drinks, calling his brother and talking, and i came over after and asked for 18 dollars. he actually said he wouldn't give me that much, and there should be a cutoff. he gave me 5 dollars which sends a weird message... like swearing is bad, unless you wanna swear a lot, then it's cool?? i feel like i've made my point already so really now i'm just continuing to "want the family to learn not to cuss" for the money, and it's really making my brothers mad. aita for having the idea for the "family swear tax" after my dad got angry at me for swearing? i did it because i know i swear the least out of my family but i was the only one getting in trouble for it
29,068
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/hfr4xe/aita_for_getting_my_family_to_do_a_swear_tax/
2020-06-25 18:17:04
nta they agreed to it, they have to play by the rules
nta that was actually genius way to handle the situation. i would have been petty and angry and would just swear more, especially after the “unladylike” comment.
nta and this is amazing. you definitely shouldn't get in trouble for it because you proposed the deal and they agreed. not your fault for enforcing the new rule.
nta, so long as you aren't misusing the rule. for example, if your dad was talking on the phone in a room seperate from you and you went and sat in the room unannounced for the sole purpose of gaining money. otherwise, good on you for fighting the double standard and making bank while doing it
don't spew profanities. enunciate them clearly, like a fucking lady. nta
nta. this was delightfully clever of you and a very fair way to point out the double standard. and all they have to do is make it stop is quit yelling at you for swearing when they do it all the time.
nta. would have been easier for your dad to stop being a sexist hypocrite but he decided to play the game instead.
nta that is fucking genius... and i owe you a dollar now, sorry!
nta. just simply tell dad... "like father, like daughter. don't like it? don't swear. if you owe $18 but can only pay $5? then i get 13 free swear words on my tab."
nta. technically speaking, it’s un-ladylike to swear, but it’s also in-gentlemanly to swear as well. so effectively, based on the fact that you’re the only one held to this standard, you’re the lady of the house and they are your subordinates since none of them rank above commoner.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i am living with my family, it's me a 15 year old girl, my twin brothers who are 17, and my parents. my dad cusses a lot, and so do my older brothers. but apparently the standards are different for me, my dad overheard me saying a couple cuss words when i was on the phone with my friends and he got mad at me for my language, and for how trashy and unladylike it was. this wasn't the first time he called me (and only me) out for bad language, but it was the one that frustrated me the most because i could tell there was a double standard. i thought of calling him out on his language and hipocracy, but then i had a different idea. --- i said that yeah, it was a bad habit i was forming and didn't want to make a pattern... because if i got in the habit of cussing a lot, that wouldn't make me come off well when i start getting jobs or going to college. and as i was growing up, i wanted to learn how to speak respectfully and intelligently. but it was hard to keep from bad habits, when i heard him and my brothers having potty-mouth-syndrome so often. they're setting an example whether they realize it or not... so i wanted to work on things for myself, but also together as a family. i suggested we make a "swear tax" where if anyone swears in front of anyone else who's participating, they give a dollar to each person who heard them. i'd want that rule for myself because it would keep me accountable and i'd really like it if the family joined me for it... ---- so my dad said he'd join, and so would my mom. they got my brothers to be a part of it too. they didn't really have a choice, my parents decided to make it a rule. i know it's kinda petty but i wanted to make the point that my dad and brothers swear a lot and i almost never do. in the few months we've had the rule, i've gotten about 250 dollars from hearing my dad and brothers cuss, and have not sworn once. it's kinda making my brothers angry because they often cuss when they're mad, and i ask them for money, so they get madder and cuss more, so i get more money until they shut up. my dad actually got mad at me too, he was having some drinks, calling his brother and talking, and i came over after and asked for 18 dollars. he actually said he wouldn't give me that much, and there should be a cutoff. he gave me 5 dollars which sends a weird message... like swearing is bad, unless you wanna swear a lot, then it's cool?? i feel like i've made my point already so really now i'm just continuing to "want the family to learn not to cuss" for the money, and it's really making my brothers mad. aita for having the idea for the "family swear tax" after my dad got angry at me for swearing? i did it because i know i swear the least out of my family but i was the only one getting in trouble for it
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i am living with my family, it's me a 15 year old girl, my twin brothers who are 17, and my parents. my dad cusses a lot, and so do my older brothers. but apparently the standards are different for me, my dad overheard me saying a couple cuss words when i was on the phone with my friends and he got mad at me for my language, and for how trashy and unladylike it was. this wasn't the first time he called me (and only me) out for bad language, but it was the one that frustrated me the most because i could tell there was a double standard. i thought of calling him out on his language and hipocracy, but then i had a different idea. --- i said that yeah, it was a bad habit i was forming and didn't want to make a pattern... because if i got in the habit of cussing a lot, that wouldn't make me come off well when i start getting jobs or going to college. and as i was growing up, i wanted to learn how to speak respectfully and intelligently. but it was hard to keep from bad habits, when i heard him and my brothers having potty-mouth-syndrome so often. they're setting an example whether they realize it or not... so i wanted to work on things for myself, but also together as a family. i suggested we make a "swear tax" where if anyone swears in front of anyone else who's participating, they give a dollar to each person who heard them. i'd want that rule for myself because it would keep me accountable and i'd really like it if the family joined me for it... ---- so my dad said he'd join, and so would my mom. they got my brothers to be a part of it too. they didn't really have a choice, my parents decided to make it a rule. i know it's kinda petty but i wanted to make the point that my dad and brothers swear a lot and i almost never do. in the few months we've had the rule, i've gotten about 250 dollars from hearing my dad and brothers cuss, and have not sworn once. it's kinda making my brothers angry because they often cuss when they're mad, and i ask them for money, so they get madder and cuss more, so i get more money until they shut up. my dad actually got mad at me too, he was having some drinks, calling his brother and talking, and i came over after and asked for 18 dollars. he actually said he wouldn't give me that much, and there should be a cutoff. he gave me 5 dollars which sends a weird message... like swearing is bad, unless you wanna swear a lot, then it's cool?? i feel like i've made my point already so really now i'm just continuing to "want the family to learn not to cuss" for the money, and it's really making my brothers mad. aita for having the idea for the "family swear tax" after my dad got angry at me for swearing? i did it because i know i swear the least out of my family but i was the only one getting in trouble for it [/INST] nta they agreed to it, they have to play by the rules </s>
AITA for buying my kids pets without the approval of my ex?
i'm divorced (6years) and remarried (2years). i have two sons with my ex, 11m and 13m. my wife has one son, 9m. my kids mom lives less than a mile away. it's close enough for the kids to walk over, but far enough to be separate space. my boys move back and forth between their moms and my house usually once a week. we're flexible especially during the summer because of travel, kid activities, etc. my wife's son lives with us full time. my wife and i have been talking with the kids about getting a pet that they would personally be responsible for at our house. this has been going on since december and we told the kids we would pull the trigger on the pets when all of our summer travel was done. since then, the kids have been excited about the prospect of having their own pets. we asked them to research their chosen pet, determine what its needs were and what kind of common health problems that kind of pet could have and how to avoid them. the kids all presented their reports and did an awesome job starting out as responsible pet owners. my kids started thinking about how they would take care of their pets when they were with their mom. we presented their options as we saw them: come over from time-to-time, ask for help from someone that's here all the time, bring the pets back and forth. they decided they would like it best if they could bring their pets back and forth between the houses. we said that it would be ok with us, but they had to talk to their mom about it. i let them know that it was their responsibility to initiate that conversation. two weeks ago i reach out to my ex to see what her answer is regarding the pets moving back and forth. she lets me know the kids approached that conversation saying "dad says we can bring the pets back and forth", i apologize and let her know that wasn't my intent. i clarify that we're fine with any of their three options for caring for these pets. she replies "in concept, i don't disagree with it.", and also late in the conversation "it's totally unfair to expect her to secondarily be responsible for these pets." i'm confused, but leave that conversation feeling certain that she doesn't want to participate, so i decide that i will take care of the pets while the boys are away. yesterday we bought the youngest two their pets. they are ecstatic, and it's adorable how they're caring for them. i get an angry message from my ex stating that the "purchase of their pets is an imposition on them regardless of whether they go to their house or not." and a bit of patronization "i understand that you and (wife) are excited about having an autonomous family unit of your own, but you continually make decisions together in a vacuum that impact the wider scope of immediate family, and it's really not ok." am i the asshole for pulling the trigger on these pets without her approval?
3,847
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/oo59dv/aita_for_buying_my_kids_pets_without_the_approval/
2021-07-20 16:16:03
yta. take care of the pets yourself while your kids are at their mom’s….. telling the kids they can take a pet to her house before even discussing it with her directly is ridiculous and telling the kids they need to come over there to your house during her time with them is also ridiculous. you set her up to be the bad guy. you handled this so wrong.
yta specifically, this: &gt;we presented their options as we saw them: come over from time-to-time, ask for help from someone that's here all the time, bring the pets back and forth. let's look at those: 1. **come over from time-to-time**: is this supported by your custody agreement? if not, this can easily read as you trying to make an end-run around your court-ordered custody arrangement under the guise of "teaching the kids responsibility with a pet". 2. **ask for help from someone that's here all the time**: they're 11 and 13. if you *choose* to get them a pet that needs to stay at your house, it's not their responsibility to "find" someone to take care of it; it's **your** responsibility to take care of it. 3. **bring the pets back and forth**: you made this suggestion before talking to your ex about it to verify that it would be okay. at first glance, this reads as you purposefully putting your ex in a bind; either she says yes (thus validating your attempt to make decisions on her behalf), or she says no (turning her into "the bad guy"). what you're doing here is manipulative as hell. if you want to get them a pet, fine. but the correct approach is to not make (or even suggest) any changes to visitation, and proactively say that you'll take care of the pet when your kids aren't with you, and the pet will stay with you and not go to your ex's house. basically, get *yourself* a pet that your kids have some responsibility over instead of getting **them** a pet.
op i think the situation would have been different if you and your wife bought a family pet that would only stay at your house. the expectation then would be that you didn’t need to discuss it with your ex-wife. however, you opted to buy your sons their own pets. that’s a parenting decision you should have discussed with your ex/their mom. i am afraid your ex is right and while i don’t think you did this to inconvenience or upset any one you made assumptions without actually talking to her about it.
"we presented their options as we saw them: come over from time-to-time, ask for help from someone that's here all the time, bring the pets back and forth. they decided they would like it best if they could bring their pets back and forth between the houses. " &amp;#x200b; &amp;#x200b; that makes it yta &amp;#x200b; if you get them pets, you need to take care of them when they are at their mom's without involving her.
yta. in the end, the kids are certainly going to want to go back and forth more to take care of the pets which would impact the time they spend at their mothers. you put her in the position of being the bad guy because she doesn't want the responsibility of the pets and she saw that your kids were probably disappointed. and it sounds like it's not the first time you make a decision that would impact the way custody works. yta because you are supposed to be parenting with her but instead of talking to her first to see what were the actual options you could present to the kids, you went to the kids and got them all excited about it and giving them an option that makes their mother look bad.
what pets? i'm curious as to know what kinda pets you got. also, yta. you basically made her look like the bad guy by saying they could bring the animals back and forth and having her being put on the spot to say no. i can understand why she's pissed at that. you can get the pets yourself and they can be taken care of at your house. you can take care of them when the boys aren't there. depending on what pets you got. it can't be that hard.
op i think the situation would have been different if you and your wife bought a family pet that would only stay at your house. the expectation then would be that you didn’t need to discuss it with your ex-wife. however, you opted to buy your sons their own pets. that’s a parenting decision you should have discussed with your ex/their mom. i am afraid your ex is right and while i don’t think you did this to inconvenience or upset any one you made assumptions without actually talking to her about it. yta
yta. you told your kids they could have the pets in both houses without asking her. you set expectations on the boys and now she's the mean parent that won't let the kids have the pets at her place, or the parent that will eventually end up taking care of a pet that she didn't sign up for, and she had no input on choosing. you said the pets will always stay at your place. can you guarantee that your boys, who will love these pets and can walk to your ex's will never take them there? that if you and your wife need to leave your place and the kids are staying at you ex's, she won't end up having them over? i don't know what kind of co-parenting relationship you have with her, but would it have kill you to check with her beforehand?
mmmm yeah yta. i think you're probably sincere in not understanding the problem, and you do sound logical. but you're focusing on "but she doesn't have to have them at her house" and seem to be missing that one of the other options you gave your kids - repeat, \*gave your kids\*, not her - was that they could "come over \[to yours\] from time to time" - ie, spend less time with her. her options have become: 1: have animals in her house that she made known she didn't want 2: lose time with her sons 3: (if they choose the "have someone else do the looking after" option) know that at the very least her sons have \*another\* reason to wish they were with you. (that "family unit" comment is very telling, i think.) even worse, having forced her to nix 1 and look like the bad guy, you gave \*the kids\* the choice between 2 and 3. her least-worst option is 3, but she can't even choose it herself. she has to hope the kids do, and even \*if\* they do, you know as well as anyone that won't be the last she hears of it. if they don't spent the next few years trying to persuade her to let the pets come to hers, forcing her to be the bad guy, the mean parent, over and over again, at the \*very least\* she's going to have to hear about these pets all the time and know how much her kids miss them. she must be \*dreading\* the pets becoming a reason (or an excuse) to spend less time with her. and all that's leaving aside the "are our kids responsible enough to have pets/is this how we want them to learn responsibility" question that, yes, should really have been down to both of you. you made these plans with your kids without talking to her about it, forced her to be the bad guy when she did eventually find out, ignored her opinion completely when she did get the chance the give it, and the result is that she may well get less time (or less willing time) with her kids. yeah, i can see why she's pissed.
yta for the options you presented. the only option is for you guys to take care of the pets when they’re gone- not try to lessen their time with their mother or make their mother into the bad guy for not agreeing to have the pets in her home. *they* also should not have been the one having this conversation with your ex, *you* would have been.
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm divorced (6years) and remarried (2years). i have two sons with my ex, 11m and 13m. my wife has one son, 9m. my kids mom lives less than a mile away. it's close enough for the kids to walk over, but far enough to be separate space. my boys move back and forth between their moms and my house usually once a week. we're flexible especially during the summer because of travel, kid activities, etc. my wife's son lives with us full time. my wife and i have been talking with the kids about getting a pet that they would personally be responsible for at our house. this has been going on since december and we told the kids we would pull the trigger on the pets when all of our summer travel was done. since then, the kids have been excited about the prospect of having their own pets. we asked them to research their chosen pet, determine what its needs were and what kind of common health problems that kind of pet could have and how to avoid them. the kids all presented their reports and did an awesome job starting out as responsible pet owners. my kids started thinking about how they would take care of their pets when they were with their mom. we presented their options as we saw them: come over from time-to-time, ask for help from someone that's here all the time, bring the pets back and forth. they decided they would like it best if they could bring their pets back and forth between the houses. we said that it would be ok with us, but they had to talk to their mom about it. i let them know that it was their responsibility to initiate that conversation. two weeks ago i reach out to my ex to see what her answer is regarding the pets moving back and forth. she lets me know the kids approached that conversation saying "dad says we can bring the pets back and forth", i apologize and let her know that wasn't my intent. i clarify that we're fine with any of their three options for caring for these pets. she replies "in concept, i don't disagree with it.", and also late in the conversation "it's totally unfair to expect her to secondarily be responsible for these pets." i'm confused, but leave that conversation feeling certain that she doesn't want to participate, so i decide that i will take care of the pets while the boys are away. yesterday we bought the youngest two their pets. they are ecstatic, and it's adorable how they're caring for them. i get an angry message from my ex stating that the "purchase of their pets is an imposition on them regardless of whether they go to their house or not." and a bit of patronization "i understand that you and (wife) are excited about having an autonomous family unit of your own, but you continually make decisions together in a vacuum that impact the wider scope of immediate family, and it's really not ok." am i the asshole for pulling the trigger on these pets without her approval?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm divorced (6years) and remarried (2years). i have two sons with my ex, 11m and 13m. my wife has one son, 9m. my kids mom lives less than a mile away. it's close enough for the kids to walk over, but far enough to be separate space. my boys move back and forth between their moms and my house usually once a week. we're flexible especially during the summer because of travel, kid activities, etc. my wife's son lives with us full time. my wife and i have been talking with the kids about getting a pet that they would personally be responsible for at our house. this has been going on since december and we told the kids we would pull the trigger on the pets when all of our summer travel was done. since then, the kids have been excited about the prospect of having their own pets. we asked them to research their chosen pet, determine what its needs were and what kind of common health problems that kind of pet could have and how to avoid them. the kids all presented their reports and did an awesome job starting out as responsible pet owners. my kids started thinking about how they would take care of their pets when they were with their mom. we presented their options as we saw them: come over from time-to-time, ask for help from someone that's here all the time, bring the pets back and forth. they decided they would like it best if they could bring their pets back and forth between the houses. we said that it would be ok with us, but they had to talk to their mom about it. i let them know that it was their responsibility to initiate that conversation. two weeks ago i reach out to my ex to see what her answer is regarding the pets moving back and forth. she lets me know the kids approached that conversation saying "dad says we can bring the pets back and forth", i apologize and let her know that wasn't my intent. i clarify that we're fine with any of their three options for caring for these pets. she replies "in concept, i don't disagree with it.", and also late in the conversation "it's totally unfair to expect her to secondarily be responsible for these pets." i'm confused, but leave that conversation feeling certain that she doesn't want to participate, so i decide that i will take care of the pets while the boys are away. yesterday we bought the youngest two their pets. they are ecstatic, and it's adorable how they're caring for them. i get an angry message from my ex stating that the "purchase of their pets is an imposition on them regardless of whether they go to their house or not." and a bit of patronization "i understand that you and (wife) are excited about having an autonomous family unit of your own, but you continually make decisions together in a vacuum that impact the wider scope of immediate family, and it's really not ok." am i the asshole for pulling the trigger on these pets without her approval? [/INST] yta. take care of the pets yourself while your kids are at their mom’s….. telling the kids they can take a pet to her house before even discussing it with her directly is ridiculous and telling the kids they need to come over there to your house during her time with them is also ridiculous. you set her up to be the bad guy. you handled this so wrong. </s>
AITA for asking questions about my co worker's daughter
my co-worker has a daughter who has a bit of fame, she's not a celebrity or anything but she is "public", to give an idea, she's verified on twitter and has a wikipedia page, albeit small and outdated by a couple years. i find her very interesting and entertaining and occasionally check on her socials to see what she's up to. i ask him about her sometimes as well and he sometimes tells little stories about her. he and his wife divorced when she was 18. on her social accounts, i've noticed she only has 3 posts in total about her dad on instagram, one in 2020 for his birthday, one in 2019 which was a photo with him and her brother on fathers day and one in 2016 i think on his birthday too which was an old photo when she was a child. for her mum (who still has the same marriage surname) she has a lot more photo's and posts about her and is definitely a lot more affectionate for her too. additionally, she also uses on her twitter and instagram, her stage surname rather than her actual surname (aka his). i felt like i could trust asking him how things are between him and her (an his son too), he's asked me very personal questions about my divorce in the past and i've worked with him for a quite a while and am on pretty good terms with him as a work partner and friend. we spoke for a bit until i asked why he doesn't appear in any photos on her accounts, her sarcastically replied he was camera shy. i said fair enough. i then asked why she likes using the stage name on her twitter and instagram (it's also the surname i think of a family that is close to her/her family) and he replied that he "doesn't really fucking know" (he sounded like a mix of sarcastic,angry and disinterested). i asked a few more questions, he didn't really seem interested in answering, i could tell he was getting a bit annoyed so i stopped. the next day, i arrive at work and he pretty much is ghosting and ignoring me. i don't think much of it until later the day when the boss comes and takes me aside and gives me a warning, apparently i was asking him "provocative" and "harassing" questions, despite him not looking too bothered when i asked them. i go and try to talk to him and he just tells me to fuck off and leaves. this nonsense reminds me of the crap someone in primary school would do. i've tried to contact him and nothing and i'm very annoyed at the moment and want to know did i do anything wrong?
6,411
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/y39llj/aita_for_asking_questions_about_my_co_workers/
2022-10-13 20:47:03
yta, you first seem to have an unhealthy obsession over his daughter and you didn't quickly grasp that they dont have a great relationship but you kept pestering him about it.
yta. why are you so invested in his daughter's life and relationship with her dad that you're scrolling back 5+ years to count how many photos she's posted of him? that's creepy and weird and your questions were invasive and nosy.
yta learn to mind your business. her profile might be public but you’ve scrolled back to 2016 to find those photos - that’s just creepy af. if he wanted to talk to you about it he would.
yta. perhaps they don't have a great relationship but you also outed the fact that you're borderline obsessed with his daughter to him. i think that would make anybody uncomfortable. this is very weird behaviour.
might be the creepiest post i’ve read on here….
yta i got creeped out reading this post. if you're going to ask personal questions at work (and 99% of the time you shouldn't), you have to be able to quickly and accurately be able to pick up to the verbal and physical signs that your questions aren't welcome. on top of being really intrusive into his personal life, your interest in his daughter seems over-the-top...the details you rattle off about her are just too much. this guy just wants to work, not air out the whole history of his relationship with his daughter. he's probably also trying to protect her from people who think she's public property because she has some prominence. that's you, op. he's protecting her from people like you who make people feel unsafe online.
yta. it's one thing to do a deep dive on somebody's socials at 3am out of curiosity, it's another thing to go pester their friends and loved ones with personal questions about them. and it's another thing entirely to *keep* pestering them even after you've had a formal warning and been told to fuck off by the person you're pestering. you've been told to leave this guy alone, but you're still chasing him around trying to make him soothe your ego. leave him alone.
yta - your dive into her socials is way too deep and then you used that to interrogate a man about very personal things. there were multiple points in that conversation where you should have stopped but you didn’t. you were rude, intrusive and blind to social cues.
yta - why does any of this matter to you??? you asked this guy a bunch of questions about his daughter based on what you've seen on the internet and not what he's told you. he's clearly not prominent on her social media because he's not super comfortable with it and people like you are exactly why. because it's none of your business.
yta. this seems like it’s bordering on stalking, honestly.
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
null
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
YTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: my co-worker has a daughter who has a bit of fame, she's not a celebrity or anything but she is "public", to give an idea, she's verified on twitter and has a wikipedia page, albeit small and outdated by a couple years. i find her very interesting and entertaining and occasionally check on her socials to see what she's up to. i ask him about her sometimes as well and he sometimes tells little stories about her. he and his wife divorced when she was 18. on her social accounts, i've noticed she only has 3 posts in total about her dad on instagram, one in 2020 for his birthday, one in 2019 which was a photo with him and her brother on fathers day and one in 2016 i think on his birthday too which was an old photo when she was a child. for her mum (who still has the same marriage surname) she has a lot more photo's and posts about her and is definitely a lot more affectionate for her too. additionally, she also uses on her twitter and instagram, her stage surname rather than her actual surname (aka his). i felt like i could trust asking him how things are between him and her (an his son too), he's asked me very personal questions about my divorce in the past and i've worked with him for a quite a while and am on pretty good terms with him as a work partner and friend. we spoke for a bit until i asked why he doesn't appear in any photos on her accounts, her sarcastically replied he was camera shy. i said fair enough. i then asked why she likes using the stage name on her twitter and instagram (it's also the surname i think of a family that is close to her/her family) and he replied that he "doesn't really fucking know" (he sounded like a mix of sarcastic,angry and disinterested). i asked a few more questions, he didn't really seem interested in answering, i could tell he was getting a bit annoyed so i stopped. the next day, i arrive at work and he pretty much is ghosting and ignoring me. i don't think much of it until later the day when the boss comes and takes me aside and gives me a warning, apparently i was asking him "provocative" and "harassing" questions, despite him not looking too bothered when i asked them. i go and try to talk to him and he just tells me to fuck off and leaves. this nonsense reminds me of the crap someone in primary school would do. i've tried to contact him and nothing and i'm very annoyed at the moment and want to know did i do anything wrong?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> my co-worker has a daughter who has a bit of fame, she's not a celebrity or anything but she is "public", to give an idea, she's verified on twitter and has a wikipedia page, albeit small and outdated by a couple years. i find her very interesting and entertaining and occasionally check on her socials to see what she's up to. i ask him about her sometimes as well and he sometimes tells little stories about her. he and his wife divorced when she was 18. on her social accounts, i've noticed she only has 3 posts in total about her dad on instagram, one in 2020 for his birthday, one in 2019 which was a photo with him and her brother on fathers day and one in 2016 i think on his birthday too which was an old photo when she was a child. for her mum (who still has the same marriage surname) she has a lot more photo's and posts about her and is definitely a lot more affectionate for her too. additionally, she also uses on her twitter and instagram, her stage surname rather than her actual surname (aka his). i felt like i could trust asking him how things are between him and her (an his son too), he's asked me very personal questions about my divorce in the past and i've worked with him for a quite a while and am on pretty good terms with him as a work partner and friend. we spoke for a bit until i asked why he doesn't appear in any photos on her accounts, her sarcastically replied he was camera shy. i said fair enough. i then asked why she likes using the stage name on her twitter and instagram (it's also the surname i think of a family that is close to her/her family) and he replied that he "doesn't really fucking know" (he sounded like a mix of sarcastic,angry and disinterested). i asked a few more questions, he didn't really seem interested in answering, i could tell he was getting a bit annoyed so i stopped. the next day, i arrive at work and he pretty much is ghosting and ignoring me. i don't think much of it until later the day when the boss comes and takes me aside and gives me a warning, apparently i was asking him "provocative" and "harassing" questions, despite him not looking too bothered when i asked them. i go and try to talk to him and he just tells me to fuck off and leaves. this nonsense reminds me of the crap someone in primary school would do. i've tried to contact him and nothing and i'm very annoyed at the moment and want to know did i do anything wrong? [/INST] yta, you first seem to have an unhealthy obsession over his daughter and you didn't quickly grasp that they dont have a great relationship but you kept pestering him about it. </s>
WIBTA if I report the nurse practitioner at urgent care to HR for basically slut shaming me?
i've \[f21\] recently encountered a new sexual partner. we used a condom, but after words i felt a little uneasy as to this was the first time i have ever hooked up with someone i just met. my previous sexual partners have all been someone i have developed deep connections with in some kind of way. while condoms greatly reduce the chance of contracting a sti, it cannot provide absolute protection. a few days ago, i noticed my discharge changed to a white substance that's different from my normal discharge and the first thing that came to my head was an std. i have never had one before and i have no idea the symptoms, but an std was all i could think about. i went to an urgent care because i wanted to see if there was maybe a simpler answer to this problem (yeast infection or uti) and if not, i wanted to send my urine off for an std screening. my doctor asked me a series of questions (when did you become sexually active, when was your last sexual partner, how many sexual partners, etc.) , all of which i was up front and honest about so she could better treat me. it came time for her to make a diagnosis and tell me the best course of action. she says based on my symptoms, i am showing hallmark signs of a yeast infection, but she will send my urine off for a culture and std screen along with a swob from my vagina so she can tell what type of yeast is growing down there. as i'm about to get my keys and stand up to walk out, she says "dear, will you sit down for just another moment." i sat back down and looked up at her, curious as to what she wanted to talk about. "with all of that being said, you're 21 years old, you really need to guard and protect your character,". i looked at her like "what the fuck" and she continued "well you know, guys get to have sex all they want and nothing bad comes out of it for them but you know us as women we can't be doing that as much because we have to protect our character,". at this point, i was pretty fucking angry. you could tell by my silence and the way my lips were pressed together. i thought that maybe it couldn't get any worse, then she proceeded to say "you're going to want to have kids one day, and the way you're living your life now could really hurt you and your chances of having a kid with a good man,". i was open and honest with this woman in hopes that it would help her better treat me and in turn i get slut shamed for it? i posted this in a forum about sexual education and i was getting advice to report her to hr. i don’t want to go after anybody’s job, but i don’t want other women to have to go through this same thing just for having sex. will i be the asshole if i report her to hr or should i leave it alone?
23,103
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/cemg2f/wibta_if_i_report_the_nurse_practitioner_at/
2019-07-18 02:18:37
nta. 150% report her to hr. do it right now. this is rude, regressive, none of her business and could actually deter women from getting care. you'll be doing yourself and every other woman who walks through those doors a kindness.
nta. definitely report that. she is there to help you medically, not try to force her values on you.
nta, definitely report this, it’s bullshit. but hr is for employees, not patients. you’ll want to report this to a clinic manager or customer service.
nta at all her job is to provide health care, not moral judgement. i won't go into how dated and fucked her comments are - but bringing her own personal beliefs into it are out of line.
nta. i'm a nurse and i would report the shit out of this woman if she treated me or worked with me. in our line of work, we definitely have to ask probing questions or make recommendations that some people see as intrusive, but only if there's a legitimate medical reason, which we explain--e.g. "i don't care whether or not you do cocaine, i'm not going to call the cops on you, but please tell me if there's cocaine in your system because giving you a beta blocker with cocaine in your system could kill you." recommending safe sexual behaviors like consistent condom use and frequent sti testing for your health and the health of your partners would have been totally appropriate. lecturing you about the effect casual sex will have on your "character" is a hundred miles over the line.
nta. that is awful and totally unprofessional. you went for medical advice not a lesson of character.
nta &amp;#x200b; this isn't 1950 and she's a stranger. you're an adult and can obviously handle yourself. she isn't in charge of your chastity belt keys and this was incredibly out of line. i'd definitely report her as that wasn't her place.
nta. she's your doctor, not your mother. she crossed the line between professional and personal, and that's not okay. report her.
&gt;i sat back down and looked up at her, curious as to what she wanted to talk about. &gt; &gt;you could tell by my silence and the way my lips were pressed together. fanfiction alert.
nta. report her
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
null
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i've \[f21\] recently encountered a new sexual partner. we used a condom, but after words i felt a little uneasy as to this was the first time i have ever hooked up with someone i just met. my previous sexual partners have all been someone i have developed deep connections with in some kind of way. while condoms greatly reduce the chance of contracting a sti, it cannot provide absolute protection. a few days ago, i noticed my discharge changed to a white substance that's different from my normal discharge and the first thing that came to my head was an std. i have never had one before and i have no idea the symptoms, but an std was all i could think about. i went to an urgent care because i wanted to see if there was maybe a simpler answer to this problem (yeast infection or uti) and if not, i wanted to send my urine off for an std screening. my doctor asked me a series of questions (when did you become sexually active, when was your last sexual partner, how many sexual partners, etc.) , all of which i was up front and honest about so she could better treat me. it came time for her to make a diagnosis and tell me the best course of action. she says based on my symptoms, i am showing hallmark signs of a yeast infection, but she will send my urine off for a culture and std screen along with a swob from my vagina so she can tell what type of yeast is growing down there. as i'm about to get my keys and stand up to walk out, she says "dear, will you sit down for just another moment." i sat back down and looked up at her, curious as to what she wanted to talk about. "with all of that being said, you're 21 years old, you really need to guard and protect your character,". i looked at her like "what the fuck" and she continued "well you know, guys get to have sex all they want and nothing bad comes out of it for them but you know us as women we can't be doing that as much because we have to protect our character,". at this point, i was pretty fucking angry. you could tell by my silence and the way my lips were pressed together. i thought that maybe it couldn't get any worse, then she proceeded to say "you're going to want to have kids one day, and the way you're living your life now could really hurt you and your chances of having a kid with a good man,". i was open and honest with this woman in hopes that it would help her better treat me and in turn i get slut shamed for it? i posted this in a forum about sexual education and i was getting advice to report her to hr. i don’t want to go after anybody’s job, but i don’t want other women to have to go through this same thing just for having sex. will i be the asshole if i report her to hr or should i leave it alone?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i've \[f21\] recently encountered a new sexual partner. we used a condom, but after words i felt a little uneasy as to this was the first time i have ever hooked up with someone i just met. my previous sexual partners have all been someone i have developed deep connections with in some kind of way. while condoms greatly reduce the chance of contracting a sti, it cannot provide absolute protection. a few days ago, i noticed my discharge changed to a white substance that's different from my normal discharge and the first thing that came to my head was an std. i have never had one before and i have no idea the symptoms, but an std was all i could think about. i went to an urgent care because i wanted to see if there was maybe a simpler answer to this problem (yeast infection or uti) and if not, i wanted to send my urine off for an std screening. my doctor asked me a series of questions (when did you become sexually active, when was your last sexual partner, how many sexual partners, etc.) , all of which i was up front and honest about so she could better treat me. it came time for her to make a diagnosis and tell me the best course of action. she says based on my symptoms, i am showing hallmark signs of a yeast infection, but she will send my urine off for a culture and std screen along with a swob from my vagina so she can tell what type of yeast is growing down there. as i'm about to get my keys and stand up to walk out, she says "dear, will you sit down for just another moment." i sat back down and looked up at her, curious as to what she wanted to talk about. "with all of that being said, you're 21 years old, you really need to guard and protect your character,". i looked at her like "what the fuck" and she continued "well you know, guys get to have sex all they want and nothing bad comes out of it for them but you know us as women we can't be doing that as much because we have to protect our character,". at this point, i was pretty fucking angry. you could tell by my silence and the way my lips were pressed together. i thought that maybe it couldn't get any worse, then she proceeded to say "you're going to want to have kids one day, and the way you're living your life now could really hurt you and your chances of having a kid with a good man,". i was open and honest with this woman in hopes that it would help her better treat me and in turn i get slut shamed for it? i posted this in a forum about sexual education and i was getting advice to report her to hr. i don’t want to go after anybody’s job, but i don’t want other women to have to go through this same thing just for having sex. will i be the asshole if i report her to hr or should i leave it alone? [/INST] nta. 150% report her to hr. do it right now. this is rude, regressive, none of her business and could actually deter women from getting care. you'll be doing yourself and every other woman who walks through those doors a kindness. </s>
Aita For telling my soon to be mother in-law if she wants kids she can adopt one
i'm a 25 year old female, and i'm blind. the whole idea of having kids scares me, and i honestly don't want any; and my fiance is also fine with this decision. before christmas my fiance and i went to see his mother, and aside from my parents they are the only other people we visit in person. while we were there, the subject of children came up; which is usual for his mom. she actually naggs us about having kids quite a bit especially after we got engaged. while we were talking she asked me when i was going to have her a baby, i told her i didn't know because i don't want kids. just like everyone else i've told this to, she tells me i don't mean that. then says i have to have her a grand baby. this of corse made my blood boil, and i planely told her that if she wanted a baby so badly she could adopt one. the'n my fiance spoke up and told her that we'd probably be more willing to have kids if people didn't nag us about it. then i asked her if i had "baby farm" tattooed on my forehead. she says yes because i'm a woman and that's what i'm suppose to do. she doesn't care that i'm blind, and having a child would be a struggle for me, she just wants me to pump her out a grand child. am i the asshole?
18,866
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/km1tnx/aita_for_telling_my_soon_to_be_mother_inlaw_if/
2020-12-28 23:32:08
nta. your uterus, your business. end of.
nta. your fiance needs to get his mother in line. she has every right to be disappointed, but that isn't anything she should be sharing with you.— that's what friends and a therapist are for.
nta, but your fiance should not have given her hope where there is none. additionally, not all women want to be mother's and that's perfectly ok.
nta - but you and your fiancé are giving your future mil contradicting messages. if the answer is that you guys don't intend to have kids, your fiancé should be straight with his mother. he shouldn't tell her that there are things that might change your mind (even if he says it dismissively or sarcastically, to her he's opening the door on the idea of you having kids). having said that, future mil is terrible. women are not baby machines and she does not get a say in whether you and your fiancé have kids. she just needs to stop. edited to change the judgment, i realized that my e s h applied to everyone but you, making you nta.
nta. you told her to mind her business and she didn’t. your fiancé meant well with his response but it wasn’t good enough. he is the one that needs to lay it down to his mother that it’s not happening and he needs to let her know you both feel that way and not just you. you do not owe it to anyone to have a child that you don’t want.
women like your mother-in-law are the reason people dealing with infertility feel "less than". a person with a uterus is not mandated to have children because of their biological gender. you have every reason to be concerned about caring for a small, helpless human. also, i misread the title and thought that you said that if she wanted a child she could adopt you. nta
nta. if a blind woman can see how ugly she is being, your future mil should be able to as well.
nta, you shouldn’t feel pressured to appease anyone that sees you as nothing more than a broodmare. her comments are gross af, sorry you have to deal with that.
nta nta nta coming from a fellow female, you are not her personal grandbaby incubator™. she wants kids without the pooping, peeing, screaming, or puking aspect. it is totally understandable and fair to not want children, it is your body and your choice. women are not just baby machines! (see betty white! she's childfree and doesn't regret it a day in her life). her disgusting viewpoint on women only being good for breeding needs to be shut down asap. also, if she thinks that a woman is supposed to pump out babies, why doesn't she just 'pump out' another kid since it's 'what she's supposed to do'?
nta it doesn't sound totally as if you and your fiancé are on the same page though. if you are he should be shutting his mother down hard, not leaving open bit of hope. regardless, you don't owe anyone a grandchild for any reason.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i'm a 25 year old female, and i'm blind. the whole idea of having kids scares me, and i honestly don't want any; and my fiance is also fine with this decision. before christmas my fiance and i went to see his mother, and aside from my parents they are the only other people we visit in person. while we were there, the subject of children came up; which is usual for his mom. she actually naggs us about having kids quite a bit especially after we got engaged. while we were talking she asked me when i was going to have her a baby, i told her i didn't know because i don't want kids. just like everyone else i've told this to, she tells me i don't mean that. then says i have to have her a grand baby. this of corse made my blood boil, and i planely told her that if she wanted a baby so badly she could adopt one. the'n my fiance spoke up and told her that we'd probably be more willing to have kids if people didn't nag us about it. then i asked her if i had "baby farm" tattooed on my forehead. she says yes because i'm a woman and that's what i'm suppose to do. she doesn't care that i'm blind, and having a child would be a struggle for me, she just wants me to pump her out a grand child. am i the asshole?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i'm a 25 year old female, and i'm blind. the whole idea of having kids scares me, and i honestly don't want any; and my fiance is also fine with this decision. before christmas my fiance and i went to see his mother, and aside from my parents they are the only other people we visit in person. while we were there, the subject of children came up; which is usual for his mom. she actually naggs us about having kids quite a bit especially after we got engaged. while we were talking she asked me when i was going to have her a baby, i told her i didn't know because i don't want kids. just like everyone else i've told this to, she tells me i don't mean that. then says i have to have her a grand baby. this of corse made my blood boil, and i planely told her that if she wanted a baby so badly she could adopt one. the'n my fiance spoke up and told her that we'd probably be more willing to have kids if people didn't nag us about it. then i asked her if i had "baby farm" tattooed on my forehead. she says yes because i'm a woman and that's what i'm suppose to do. she doesn't care that i'm blind, and having a child would be a struggle for me, she just wants me to pump her out a grand child. am i the asshole? [/INST] nta. your uterus, your business. end of. </s>
AITA for refusing to pay back my cousin after my baby ruined her blouse?
hi all. i gave birth four weeks ago, and we decided to have a ''baby ceremony'', where everyone gets to meet our lovely daughter charlotte. my cousin alice and her parents were among the guests. the first thing i'll say about her is that she has expensive taste. she's the sort of person who has a *minimum* price range for how much she spends on clothing. she doesn't own anything that isn't designer and has some items of clothing that cost thousands. she is a banker and still lives with parents so can afford the lifestyle. it was alice's turn to hold the baby and she was happy to at first, but suddenly charlotte vomited on her. alice handed charlotte back to me and ran off crying, and spent the rest of the event crying in the car. i went to see her to apologise but she didn't want to hear any of it. my mum gave her one of her shirts which was too big for her and she felt completely upset and humiliated. today i got a call from my mum, saying that she'd been on the phone to her sister (alice's mum) saying that they want me to reimburse the cost of the blouse (roughly £1800) since it was completely ruined. i have said no. at the end of the day we all know what babies can be like. she took a risk wearing something so expensive knowing a baby was nearby and unfortunately it backfired. i feel bad for her but it was not my fault. am i doing the right thing by refusing to pay up?
33,899
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/cw43oc/aita_for_refusing_to_pay_back_my_cousin_after_my/
2019-08-27 12:58:45
nta. common sense to not wear expensive clothing around newborns unless you are okay with risking this happening. she should have known better.
nta she is demanding 1800 from a woman who just had a baby?? at best you should pay for dry cleaning!
nta. wearing expensive designer shit around what is potentially a living vomit machine is one of the stupidest things you can think of to do. counter them with "i'll happily pay for the dry cleaning on the shirt as a matter of responsibility but nothing more as £1800 on a shirt is something that we can't afford to spend at all and alice should have known that when she attended wearing that"
nta - not only is alice an asshole, but an idiot for wearing expensive clothing around a month old baby. what the fuck does she think babies that old do? they cry, eat, sleep, shit, and throw up. it's completely on her, and if she doesn't like it, well tough titty said the kitty.
info. had alice actually spent any time around babies before? info. why so negative about the fact that she has expensive taste?
esh. you sound incredibly judgemental towards your cousin and what she spends her money on. seems like she has worked hard for the things she has and probably in her career appearance matters. also someone who hasn't been around children wouldn't know how much babies puke. you should have warned her about what could happen. in the end if your child ruins something it's up to you to pay for it even if it's not directly your fault. for instance if your baby puked in an uber you would still be expected to pay for it. she's an asshole about the way she reacted but if my shirt was ruined i would also be upset.
esh your kid did ruin her property and it didn't seem like you made any effort to make it right at the time but who wears something that expensive around an unpredictable baby. you should have offered to pay to get it cleaned when it happened and apologized. you acted like you didn't care at all when you know her clothing means a lot to her.
esh. i don't think it's fair to say cousin is the asshole because she likes nice things. i don't think it's fair to say she needs to dress differently to visit a new parent. i think both of those statements actually make you an asshole. it wasn't like you asked her to babysit and she wore expensive clothing. according to your description, that's how she dresses. everyone else showed up and didn't get vomited on, so why would she expect to? prior to this she was not asking you to fund her clothing choices, so what she wears and hoe much they cost should not affect you. your child will do more than vomit on people. they will tear up things, break things, etc. as the responsible parent you may end up paying costs you didn't anticipate paying. this is one of those times, in my opinion. being a new parent or old parent doesn't excuse you from doing the right thing. maybe the blouse can be dry cleaned or somehow otherwise repaired. if not, in my opinion, you should put money towards a replacement. next time, maybe offer a diaper or blanket to put over themselves in case someone wants to hold the baby to mitigate this. and, i get it. when i was a new parent, i didn't know what to expect. things happened i wasn't prepared for. i had to learn quickly to be prepared after being caught unawares. shit happens. vomit happens. but the right thing to do is to fix the situation. the cousin sucks because instead of coming to you, her and her parent reached out to yours. that's not adult behavior.
yta, slightly. i get what you are saying, but how far do you take this. if your child breaks someone's property, do you say "well, we know what kids are like" i don't know this person, but maybe you should've given her a spit up rag or something to cover herself with
info - are you willing to offer to pay for it to be dry cleaned?
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
INFO
ESH
ESH
ESH
YTA
INFO
0.537037
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: hi all. i gave birth four weeks ago, and we decided to have a ''baby ceremony'', where everyone gets to meet our lovely daughter charlotte. my cousin alice and her parents were among the guests. the first thing i'll say about her is that she has expensive taste. she's the sort of person who has a *minimum* price range for how much she spends on clothing. she doesn't own anything that isn't designer and has some items of clothing that cost thousands. she is a banker and still lives with parents so can afford the lifestyle. it was alice's turn to hold the baby and she was happy to at first, but suddenly charlotte vomited on her. alice handed charlotte back to me and ran off crying, and spent the rest of the event crying in the car. i went to see her to apologise but she didn't want to hear any of it. my mum gave her one of her shirts which was too big for her and she felt completely upset and humiliated. today i got a call from my mum, saying that she'd been on the phone to her sister (alice's mum) saying that they want me to reimburse the cost of the blouse (roughly £1800) since it was completely ruined. i have said no. at the end of the day we all know what babies can be like. she took a risk wearing something so expensive knowing a baby was nearby and unfortunately it backfired. i feel bad for her but it was not my fault. am i doing the right thing by refusing to pay up?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> hi all. i gave birth four weeks ago, and we decided to have a ''baby ceremony'', where everyone gets to meet our lovely daughter charlotte. my cousin alice and her parents were among the guests. the first thing i'll say about her is that she has expensive taste. she's the sort of person who has a *minimum* price range for how much she spends on clothing. she doesn't own anything that isn't designer and has some items of clothing that cost thousands. she is a banker and still lives with parents so can afford the lifestyle. it was alice's turn to hold the baby and she was happy to at first, but suddenly charlotte vomited on her. alice handed charlotte back to me and ran off crying, and spent the rest of the event crying in the car. i went to see her to apologise but she didn't want to hear any of it. my mum gave her one of her shirts which was too big for her and she felt completely upset and humiliated. today i got a call from my mum, saying that she'd been on the phone to her sister (alice's mum) saying that they want me to reimburse the cost of the blouse (roughly £1800) since it was completely ruined. i have said no. at the end of the day we all know what babies can be like. she took a risk wearing something so expensive knowing a baby was nearby and unfortunately it backfired. i feel bad for her but it was not my fault. am i doing the right thing by refusing to pay up? [/INST] nta. common sense to not wear expensive clothing around newborns unless you are okay with risking this happening. she should have known better. </s>
AITA for telling my wife that the only reason she says 'money doesn't matter' is because we're rich?
i (48m) and my wife (47f) both have very well paying jobs. i am a pediatric doctor and she's an attorney, which have allowed us and our kids (20f), (17m) and (15m) to have a more than comfortable lifestyle. my wife has a tendency to say things like 'money doesn't matter' and that 'material things don't matter' and she says them all the time, which kinda irks me because she's right, but i was raised in a poor family, and i know that she wouldn't be saying the same thing if we were middle-class. but i haven't said anything up until this morning. i had made a comment about needing a better watch, and my wife was saying her usual 'money doesn't matter'. i told her that she was only saying that because we are rich and because she has never experienced being without money in any sense. predictably, she got upset with me, and now i'm wondering if perhaps i overreacted and went too far.
28,190
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/ktuqop/aita_for_telling_my_wife_that_the_only_reason_she/
2021-01-09 17:09:21
nta. people who have always had money seem to be delusional about it. money absolutely does matter when you’re poor.
nta but your wife is only an asshole very gently. it‘s difficult to understand and accept your privilege when you‘ve grown up with it. i once said something akin to „money doesn‘t matter“ or „money doesnt buy happiness“ to a friend and got a proper lecture by a friend. it went summat like this: you only say money doesn‘t matter because you have it, it buys you a good university, nice holidays and good care altogether. these are things that make you happy/happier that you buy with the money that you say doesnt matter.
nta - alex, can i get " things only rich people say" for $500? &amp;#x200b; money matters a lot to most people, especially now, unfortunately.
nah. she’s probably never had to think about it like that before, and pointing it out made her uncomfortable. since it was bothering you, you’re def not an ah for pointing it out, and i honestly don’t think she’s an ah for being upset - as long as she uses this as a chance to learn. if she continues to hold a grudge or something then my answer would change.
nta-i will say money isn't everything, but it sure fucking helps.
nah ~~info:~~ can you be clearer about what sort of context she's saying this in? because it could be either really offensive or really not. for example, when you "made a comment about needing a better watch," was she suggesting that you shouldn't be reluctant to spend the money on a better watch? that you should be satisfied with the watch you have? that she'd be happy to buy you one?
yta. your wife said money doesn't matter when you mentioned you needed a new watch, which normally would mean: get the watch you need because money isn't an issue. so you blindsided her about your lack of privilege during your childhood and how you don't like her comments about money? you've been with her for long enough to have teenage/adult children and you choose this random moment about a $40 watch to do this? info. does she disregard others lack of privilege? does she flaunt her privilege? what does she actually mean when she says "money doesn't matter"? money matters, especially when you don't have it, but the way you chose to go about this doesn't make sense and seems immature for your education and age.
nah. i can't call your wife an ah for being oblivious to her privilege and you aren't one for calling out her obliviousness. you guys need to sit down and have a talk about her comments bothering you and what you guys can do going forward. you guys just need to communicate better.
nta - i grew up below the poverty line, like you, was very lucky to move into a very well paying career. money matters. anyone who doesn't think it matters has never had to decide between buying milk and buying bread (and you buy the bread because, let's be honest, milk is a luxury item at that point).
ehhh i'm gonna go nah. you're talking about a new watch, your wife, in turn, says "money doesn't matter", what i get from that is, she's telling you to get a watch that is good and not worry about price. but it seems if y'all needed to be conservative about money this would be totally different. you were kind of an ah because you bit her head of abt it, and if it bothers you so much why don't you sit down with her and have an adult conversation.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NAH
NTA
NAH
YTA
NAH
NTA
NAH
0.093295
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i (48m) and my wife (47f) both have very well paying jobs. i am a pediatric doctor and she's an attorney, which have allowed us and our kids (20f), (17m) and (15m) to have a more than comfortable lifestyle. my wife has a tendency to say things like 'money doesn't matter' and that 'material things don't matter' and she says them all the time, which kinda irks me because she's right, but i was raised in a poor family, and i know that she wouldn't be saying the same thing if we were middle-class. but i haven't said anything up until this morning. i had made a comment about needing a better watch, and my wife was saying her usual 'money doesn't matter'. i told her that she was only saying that because we are rich and because she has never experienced being without money in any sense. predictably, she got upset with me, and now i'm wondering if perhaps i overreacted and went too far.
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i (48m) and my wife (47f) both have very well paying jobs. i am a pediatric doctor and she's an attorney, which have allowed us and our kids (20f), (17m) and (15m) to have a more than comfortable lifestyle. my wife has a tendency to say things like 'money doesn't matter' and that 'material things don't matter' and she says them all the time, which kinda irks me because she's right, but i was raised in a poor family, and i know that she wouldn't be saying the same thing if we were middle-class. but i haven't said anything up until this morning. i had made a comment about needing a better watch, and my wife was saying her usual 'money doesn't matter'. i told her that she was only saying that because we are rich and because she has never experienced being without money in any sense. predictably, she got upset with me, and now i'm wondering if perhaps i overreacted and went too far. [/INST] nta. people who have always had money seem to be delusional about it. money absolutely does matter when you’re poor. </s>
AITA for not letting my brother and SIL see my daughter after they threw away her medicine
i have a 4 year old daughter, emma. i am an alcoholic and i’ve been sober for 2 years. my brother was emma’s court appointed guardian from when she was 15 months old to just before her 3rd birthday. i had to fight for almost a year to get her back. my brother and sil are still upset that i “took emma from them” and have called cps on me numerous times and make it clear that they don’t trust me to take care of my own kid. they love emma and emma loves them so i try to take her to see them a couple times a month. a couple weeks ago, emma caught the stomach flu from someone at her preschool. i’m in school full time and had a midterm that day so i asked my brother to watch her for a couple hours so i could take my test. they said they were happy to take her so i brought her to their house that morning with her medicines, a schedule saying when she’s supposed to take which medicine and the dosage, a bottle of pedialyte, and a few changes of clothes. i came to pick her up after the midterm and half her medicines, her clothes, and her pedialyte were gone. when i asked about it they said they threw away all of her medicines and the pedialyte because they were liquids and they were already opened so i could’ve put something in there to make her sick/sleep (not that it helps much but i never hurt my daughter or gave her anything that wasn’t recommended by her pediatrician). they also said i shouldn’t be giving her tylenol and motrin (again, her doctor said it’s fine) so they didn’t buy her any motrin. then i asked about the nausea medicine (prescription) and they said they didn’t think she needs prescription meds for the stomach flu. they also felt her clothes weren’t good enough for her so they gave it to their neighbor for their garage sale and bought her new clothes, meaning they most likely took her shopping when she was sick and should’ve been resting. i left with emma and haven’t spoken to them since except to tell them they will not be allowed anywhere near my kid unsupervised. i’m working on thanksgiving so i was going to drop emma off with my parents so she could see my family but i still don’t want her to be around them without me so i’m leaving her with her babysitter instead. now my family is giving me a hard time for not letting my brother and sil see emma and are excusing what they did by saying they were just worried about her. aita for not letting my daughter see my brother and sil
24,175
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/r0ltvz/aita_for_not_letting_my_brother_and_sil_see_my/
2021-11-23 20:02:02
nta. your brother and sil are sabotaging your recovery and relationship with your child. i wouldn't be surprised to see then talk negatively about you and your history as she gets older. you may need some distance to feel safer and have the mental capacity to deal with them.
nta. they aren’t worried about emma, they are trying to sabotage your parenting efforts so they can regain custody of your daughter. it was lovely that they gave her a safe place to be when it was needed, but you’ve earned your daughter and deserve to be her mother without these people treating you this way.
nta ... my so works for cps and i just read this to him. he said you should absolutely report this to your social worker. they put your daughter in danger by throwing away her meds and it needs to be documented since they keep calling cps on you. congratulations on your sobriety!
nta you need to stand your ground here. they are constantly putting you in danger of losing your child by calling cps on you. they threw away prescribed medication. they are acting as if emma is their daughter and undermining your decisions as a parent. they need to be cut out of your and emma’s life immediately.
nta &gt; i try to take her to see them a couple times a month. #stop.
nta you regained custody. they threw away opened bottles of medication because they were afraid even though you could give the child anything, at any point? i am sure you appreciated them getting temporary custody when it was needed but she is back in your custody now.
nta your brother and sil weren't worried about emma they still think that they are emma's guardians and they feel that she needs protection from you and that they know your child so much better. they need a reality check, and they get a time out. but you need to prepare for continued cps visits, and they will send minions in the form of family members saying that they were only concerned and worried and only want the best for emma. send the message back that they blew it, and you aren't comfortable having emma around them anymore.
nta but a bit naïve to leave your child with people who relentlessly call cps on you...?
nta. the medications were prescribed by a doctor. they do not have medical knowledge sufficient to overrule a licensed professional, and should not have thrown it away. a fever can be very dangerous to a child if not brought down, and dehydration is an issue in children with the flu who might not be aware enough to know they need a drink. their actions were not in your daughter's best interests and seemed more about being anti you than pro her. they endangered her to prove you wrong, and i don't blame you for keeping her away from them.
nta. i understand that they were her guardians for a while and it might be difficult for them to accept that you are the parent and your decisions are now the ones that matter. that being said, what they did was completely inappropriate and uncalled for. i agree that they will continue to disrespect your decisions and should not be left alone with your child. their actions created these consequences, so they can deal with them.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
0
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: i have a 4 year old daughter, emma. i am an alcoholic and i’ve been sober for 2 years. my brother was emma’s court appointed guardian from when she was 15 months old to just before her 3rd birthday. i had to fight for almost a year to get her back. my brother and sil are still upset that i “took emma from them” and have called cps on me numerous times and make it clear that they don’t trust me to take care of my own kid. they love emma and emma loves them so i try to take her to see them a couple times a month. a couple weeks ago, emma caught the stomach flu from someone at her preschool. i’m in school full time and had a midterm that day so i asked my brother to watch her for a couple hours so i could take my test. they said they were happy to take her so i brought her to their house that morning with her medicines, a schedule saying when she’s supposed to take which medicine and the dosage, a bottle of pedialyte, and a few changes of clothes. i came to pick her up after the midterm and half her medicines, her clothes, and her pedialyte were gone. when i asked about it they said they threw away all of her medicines and the pedialyte because they were liquids and they were already opened so i could’ve put something in there to make her sick/sleep (not that it helps much but i never hurt my daughter or gave her anything that wasn’t recommended by her pediatrician). they also said i shouldn’t be giving her tylenol and motrin (again, her doctor said it’s fine) so they didn’t buy her any motrin. then i asked about the nausea medicine (prescription) and they said they didn’t think she needs prescription meds for the stomach flu. they also felt her clothes weren’t good enough for her so they gave it to their neighbor for their garage sale and bought her new clothes, meaning they most likely took her shopping when she was sick and should’ve been resting. i left with emma and haven’t spoken to them since except to tell them they will not be allowed anywhere near my kid unsupervised. i’m working on thanksgiving so i was going to drop emma off with my parents so she could see my family but i still don’t want her to be around them without me so i’m leaving her with her babysitter instead. now my family is giving me a hard time for not letting my brother and sil see emma and are excusing what they did by saying they were just worried about her. aita for not letting my daughter see my brother and sil
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> i have a 4 year old daughter, emma. i am an alcoholic and i’ve been sober for 2 years. my brother was emma’s court appointed guardian from when she was 15 months old to just before her 3rd birthday. i had to fight for almost a year to get her back. my brother and sil are still upset that i “took emma from them” and have called cps on me numerous times and make it clear that they don’t trust me to take care of my own kid. they love emma and emma loves them so i try to take her to see them a couple times a month. a couple weeks ago, emma caught the stomach flu from someone at her preschool. i’m in school full time and had a midterm that day so i asked my brother to watch her for a couple hours so i could take my test. they said they were happy to take her so i brought her to their house that morning with her medicines, a schedule saying when she’s supposed to take which medicine and the dosage, a bottle of pedialyte, and a few changes of clothes. i came to pick her up after the midterm and half her medicines, her clothes, and her pedialyte were gone. when i asked about it they said they threw away all of her medicines and the pedialyte because they were liquids and they were already opened so i could’ve put something in there to make her sick/sleep (not that it helps much but i never hurt my daughter or gave her anything that wasn’t recommended by her pediatrician). they also said i shouldn’t be giving her tylenol and motrin (again, her doctor said it’s fine) so they didn’t buy her any motrin. then i asked about the nausea medicine (prescription) and they said they didn’t think she needs prescription meds for the stomach flu. they also felt her clothes weren’t good enough for her so they gave it to their neighbor for their garage sale and bought her new clothes, meaning they most likely took her shopping when she was sick and should’ve been resting. i left with emma and haven’t spoken to them since except to tell them they will not be allowed anywhere near my kid unsupervised. i’m working on thanksgiving so i was going to drop emma off with my parents so she could see my family but i still don’t want her to be around them without me so i’m leaving her with her babysitter instead. now my family is giving me a hard time for not letting my brother and sil see emma and are excusing what they did by saying they were just worried about her. aita for not letting my daughter see my brother and sil [/INST] nta. your brother and sil are sabotaging your recovery and relationship with your child. i wouldn't be surprised to see then talk negatively about you and your history as she gets older. you may need some distance to feel safer and have the mental capacity to deal with them. </s>
AITA for telling my husband's female friend "He might be your best friend but you're not his"?
long story short my husband has one of those female friends, i'll call her sarah. her and i get along fine, but every once in awhile she'll make a comment or sit a little too close or touch him a lot, or compete with me on how close the are, or how well she knows him. she's one in a big group of about 11 friends. i've talked to my husband about her several times but it's so many added up micro-actions that it's hard to tell her off for one singular thing, without looking crazy. well this past weekend, the group of friends got together for the first time since we're now all boosted. my husband and i eloped a few weeks ago and this was the first time most were seeing us since. sarah came right up and got in our face as the group was congratulating us to tell my husband how disappointed she was in him for not telling her about our ceremony, not inviting her, not even sending her a photo. he told her nobody except our parents knew, nobody was invited, and we don't have our professional photos back. this girl started sobbing. how could he do this to her, that she wanted him to be her man of honor when she gets married (she's single), and he didn't even invite her to his, and their friendship now "needed some serious tlc to recover". this is in front of a whole group. i couldn't take it anymore and said "he might be your best friend, but you're not his, and this was between me and him, you were not even a consideration." there were so frosty "ooo's" from the crowd and she left the house. the crowd is split. they were all my husband's friends before i came into the picture and some think it was uncalled for and that i should've just let my husband handle it. i was mad in the moment but now i don't know. too far? tldr; i told my husband's female friend she wasn't his best friend and embarrassed her in front of all her friends, aita?
20,355
https://www.reddit.com/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/s8smfk/aita_for_telling_my_husbands_female_friend_he/
2022-01-20 20:51:52
nta - she stepped over the line with her sobbing and demands publically and she needs tlc? she's got a whole relationship in her head that may or may not exist - and your husband needs to draw that line in the sand.
nta: but i’m curious as to why your husband hasn’t distance himself from someone who doesn’t respect your relationship?
nta. she was trying to make your marriage about her and her feelings.
nta &amp; i wish you could see how hard my eyes rolled reading this post. talk about no boundaries. she’s so transparently into your husband it’s almost painful. while you definitely could have let him handle her, you weren’t out of line in the least. this girl needs to know where she stands, &amp; that’s well behind you. nicely done.
nta. i have an exact similar scenario with an actual sarah. the girl was horrid. after around 6 months of dating i told my bf (now fiance years later) that she made me uncomfortable and unfortunately i didn't feel like being in a relationship with a person who had such an inappropriate friend (as she was all over him and they would go to dinner ect). it wasn't an ultimatum as i honestly was just going to cut my losses as i've been through alot and didn't want the drama. fortunately, he recognized her behavior, but over the years she has still crossed some lines. i love how the first thing she ever said to me was "i knew him first so youll have to just get over that he will always choose me" basically saying that she was the hot friend and he would always drool over her in favor of me and if they had plans i'd have to deal. thank god that didn't happen, but i did find out months later that she asked him to break up with me because she was willing to try things out (i guess she rejected him in the past). ofcourse he said no. some women just love the attention. they don't actually want the man, just the drooling. she does it with all their friends, even the married ones. all that to say, good for you!
personally i think esh here you: sometimes people snap - and like i said, i don't blame you for that - but it really could've been done in a more polite way and in a more private way. her: she should have understood the initial statement of *"nobody except our parents knew, nobody was invited."* once knowing that no one was invited, she should've let it go and move on. husband: he ought to put a stop to some of her actions, and reactions, since she would most likely respond better to him rather than you - if he is letting it go while knowing you're not fond of how she touches him and talks to him, then he is also an ah. sorry to say - but i really do think that everyone is the ah in this situation - some more than others.
info: what was your husband’s reaction to what you said?
nta. your husband is absolutely the asshole for allowing that situation to even happen, and “sarah” needs to hit a wall or two. if your husband is incapable of establishing boundaries he’ll be forcing you to do it. this is no longer just about your husband and a “buddy”. you’re his wife, and that ring makes that your territory too. he needs to man up and make some big-boy decisions about the groupies.
waaaay nta. my best friend is a guy (38m) and i(37f) would never behave like that. we are super close, but even when he’s single, i still don’t act like that. she’s got some major insecurities or she is secretly in love with him. edit to add: you need to set boundaries since your husband doesn’t seem to be setting them.
esh. your husband needs to grow a spine and make it clear to this "friend" exactly where they stand. she's obviously an asshole for her terribly inappropriate behaviour. you could have handled this situation much better, all you really succeeded in doing is making an even worse scene and showing her that she *is* getting to you.
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
NTA
ESH
INFO
NTA
NTA
ESH
0.09992
Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. Conflict context: long story short my husband has one of those female friends, i'll call her sarah. her and i get along fine, but every once in awhile she'll make a comment or sit a little too close or touch him a lot, or compete with me on how close the are, or how well she knows him. she's one in a big group of about 11 friends. i've talked to my husband about her several times but it's so many added up micro-actions that it's hard to tell her off for one singular thing, without looking crazy. well this past weekend, the group of friends got together for the first time since we're now all boosted. my husband and i eloped a few weeks ago and this was the first time most were seeing us since. sarah came right up and got in our face as the group was congratulating us to tell my husband how disappointed she was in him for not telling her about our ceremony, not inviting her, not even sending her a photo. he told her nobody except our parents knew, nobody was invited, and we don't have our professional photos back. this girl started sobbing. how could he do this to her, that she wanted him to be her man of honor when she gets married (she's single), and he didn't even invite her to his, and their friendship now "needed some serious tlc to recover". this is in front of a whole group. i couldn't take it anymore and said "he might be your best friend, but you're not his, and this was between me and him, you were not even a consideration." there were so frosty "ooo's" from the crowd and she left the house. the crowd is split. they were all my husband's friends before i came into the picture and some think it was uncalled for and that i should've just let my husband handle it. i was mad in the moment but now i don't know. too far? tldr; i told my husband's female friend she wasn't his best friend and embarrassed her in front of all her friends, aita?
<s>[INST] <<SYS>> Classify the interpersonal conflict as either 'you're the a**hole (yta)' when the writer is causing the conflict or 'not the a**hole (nta)' when someone other than the writer is causing the conflict and explain your choice. <</SYS>> long story short my husband has one of those female friends, i'll call her sarah. her and i get along fine, but every once in awhile she'll make a comment or sit a little too close or touch him a lot, or compete with me on how close the are, or how well she knows him. she's one in a big group of about 11 friends. i've talked to my husband about her several times but it's so many added up micro-actions that it's hard to tell her off for one singular thing, without looking crazy. well this past weekend, the group of friends got together for the first time since we're now all boosted. my husband and i eloped a few weeks ago and this was the first time most were seeing us since. sarah came right up and got in our face as the group was congratulating us to tell my husband how disappointed she was in him for not telling her about our ceremony, not inviting her, not even sending her a photo. he told her nobody except our parents knew, nobody was invited, and we don't have our professional photos back. this girl started sobbing. how could he do this to her, that she wanted him to be her man of honor when she gets married (she's single), and he didn't even invite her to his, and their friendship now "needed some serious tlc to recover". this is in front of a whole group. i couldn't take it anymore and said "he might be your best friend, but you're not his, and this was between me and him, you were not even a consideration." there were so frosty "ooo's" from the crowd and she left the house. the crowd is split. they were all my husband's friends before i came into the picture and some think it was uncalled for and that i should've just let my husband handle it. i was mad in the moment but now i don't know. too far? tldr; i told my husband's female friend she wasn't his best friend and embarrassed her in front of all her friends, aita? [/INST] nta - she stepped over the line with her sobbing and demands publically and she needs tlc? she's got a whole relationship in her head that may or may not exist - and your husband needs to draw that line in the sand. </s>