_id
stringlengths 38
40
| version_id
stringlengths 36
36
| text
stringlengths 269
5.11k
| text_embedding
listlengths 1.02k
1.02k
| question
stringlengths 0
440
| question_embedding
listlengths 1.02k
1.02k
⌀ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:23
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
206. On or about June 1995 I said to Bob words to the effect:
"Can we somehow complete the shed? The mess in the backyard is just piling up".
Bob took hold of my arm and dragged me down the back stairs from the kitchen to the backyard. I stumbled down the stairs, bumping the railings and losing my footing on the way. Bob pointed to the pile of timber, roofing and windows, which were all for the Wetcheck business, and Bob said to me:
Bob: "What the fuck to do you call that? [indicating towards the disassembled shed]
Me: The shed's not for me or Station Ave, it's purely for Wetcheck's storage.
Bob: I can't fuckin' stand the sound of your fuckin' voice or the fuckin' sight of you. Get out of my fuckin' sight. Disappear. If you don't, I'll fuckin' kill you. I'm fuckin' out of here. I'm going to pack my stuff and find somewhere else to live. Don't come back till I'm gone. I promise you I'll fuckin' kill you."
207. I went to the train station across the road and sat there for a couple of hours. I felt numb. I returned later that afternoon but Bob's ute was still there, so I knew he had not gone. I stayed hidden in the tool room downstairs. I could hear Bob on the phone upstairs, making enquiries for shared accommodation and then gathering his gear, loading the ute and leaving. .
208. Bob returned a few days later while I was at home. He had a list with him and he said to me:
Bob: "I'm just here to get the rest of my things."
Me: "Can I have my video player back?"
209. Bob left again. I do not know where he went. A few days later, Bob returned again and stayed. He resumed living at Gaythorne. I did not agree to him staying. Bob is charming but I was afraid of him and said nothing.
132I am prepared to accept the defendant in respect of the incident although there is no independent corroboration. Given the fact that she left the house I also accept it was an assault and that there was a battery.
6. Alleged assault in 1996 (removal from the house)
133The defendant's evidence was as follows:
237. On two occasions during the seven or eight months we lived in Maroochydore, Bob told me to leave. On the first occasion Bob yelled at me "Get out of my fucking place. I'll get a fucking flat bed truck and pitch your fucking gear over the fucking balcony". The reason for this outburst of rage was unclear to me.. I was shaking and in fear of Bob and what he might do to me.
I telephoned David and said "Would you please come and pick me up", which he did. I stayed with David at Gaythorne. I did not contact Bob. A week or two later Bob came to Gaythorne and drove me back to Maroochydore.
I do not recall saying "Yes" to resuming our relationship; I simply did not say "No", nor did I have the courage to do so. I recall during this time Bob paid $1,000.00 as part payment of monies owing to the inheritance account.
134Under cross examination she said:
Q. And if I could then take you to paragraphs 237 and 238, thank you. I am suggesting to you, ma'am, that the conversation that you have put there you have made up, haven't you?
A. No, I haven't. And the fact being that I didn't even know what he was referring to. It was a flat bed truck. Because it's the first time I have ever heard the term "flat bed truck".
Q. David did come and collect you on one occasion, is that right?
A. He did, yes.
135I accept the evidence and given the defendant's lack of understanding of the threat and the fact that she vacated the house I find there was an assault.
7. Alleged assault in 1996 (second removal from the house)
136The defendant's evidence was:
238. On the other occasion Bob and I were in bed. He yelled at me "Get out of my fucking bed". I have no recall of why he said this. I was afraid. I left the bed and I slept on the lounge. I was ashamed and on this occasion I did not ring David.
The next morning Bob said to me "get in the car. I'm driving you to Enoggera." Bob drove me to Gaythorne where David was living at the time with his girlfriend Jill and I stayed with him at Gaythorne.
|
[
0.0034670820459723473,
0.026349280029535294,
-0.038211628794670105,
0.020091312006115913,
0.004458587151020765,
-0.09129387140274048,
0.02033180370926857,
0.029480615630745888,
0.009197038598358631,
0.010011275298893452,
0.0035380765330046415,
0.050310298800468445,
-0.04840577766299248,
-0.007549472618848085,
0.003760499646887183,
-0.028229545801877975,
0.010659834370017052,
-0.06405789405107498,
0.0010490023996680975,
-0.004389413632452488,
0.015812821686267853,
-0.04907345399260521,
0.028596404939889908,
0.007535379379987717,
0.011647796258330345,
0.01935703679919243,
-0.009273197501897812,
-0.00582004152238369,
-0.041186198592185974,
0.021586786955595016,
0.03191806748509407,
0.027327578514814377,
0.011514704674482346,
-0.0015982681652531028,
-0.04628218710422516,
0.008341922424733639,
0.015238475985825062,
-0.0050461143255233765,
-0.0267037320882082,
0.001580351497977972,
-0.038036298006772995,
0.039826273918151855,
0.020527198910713196,
-0.02299657091498375,
-0.02842489257454872,
-0.05256228893995285,
-0.02142033725976944,
-0.006786567158997059,
-0.005893215071409941,
0.03590403497219086,
0.0026096252258867025,
-0.008289779536426067,
0.03352530673146248,
0.021241897717118263,
-0.017197534441947937,
0.00496058352291584,
-0.0028473027050495148,
0.020148050040006638,
-0.0630631148815155,
-0.030797265470027924,
-0.010329347103834152,
-0.01439524907618761,
-0.019717775285243988,
-0.014591068960726261,
-0.0005831235321238637,
0.11571914702653885,
-0.02256343513727188,
-0.02556617744266987,
-0.02012111060321331,
-0.04081844910979271,
-0.011549541726708412,
-0.012816979549825191,
-0.024257341399788857,
-0.011967307887971401,
-0.06124282628297806,
0.044402942061424255,
0.005005904473364353,
0.011698730289936066,
-0.018995113670825958,
0.030192971229553223,
0.08325131982564926,
-0.020672814920544624,
0.035850562155246735,
0.0032434638123959303,
-0.036769114434719086,
0.02691773697733879,
-0.016514141112565994,
0.008434301242232323,
-0.0022913727443665266,
-0.02604648284614086,
0.00040141670615412295,
0.012212526053190231,
0.04824553057551384,
-0.0663442313671112,
-0.008574433624744415,
0.012155778706073761,
-0.010696491226553917,
0.0058066206984221935,
-0.03332486003637314,
0.02376401051878929,
0.037822235375642776,
-0.03380748629570007,
-0.022869586944580078,
-0.009941654279828072,
0.01749894581735134,
0.012442771345376968,
0.043884336948394775,
0.0031814544927328825,
0.029196374118328094,
-0.02635643631219864,
0.041404858231544495,
0.035262610763311386,
-0.015401793643832207,
-0.026955924928188324,
-0.02854621782898903,
-0.023662826046347618,
-0.024804195389151573,
-0.03565479442477226,
0.041941288858652115,
-0.010875897482037544,
0.07999357581138611,
0.0369403213262558,
0.042039331048727036,
-0.029399896040558815,
-0.028904911130666733,
0.017086559906601906,
0.00588414678350091,
-0.012615086510777473,
-0.033567868173122406,
0.04431714862585068,
-0.03587738424539566,
-0.014883761294186115,
-0.04251483455300331,
-0.03667910397052765,
-0.026754749938845634,
-0.0013850098475813866,
0.06409566104412079,
0.024244818836450577,
0.030233541503548622,
-0.047503549605607986,
0.03645528107881546,
0.012944101355969906,
-0.0015812378842383623,
-0.054456308484077454,
0.031011004000902176,
-0.01509030070155859,
0.01570809818804264,
-0.03348164260387421,
0.010722871869802475,
0.002525074640288949,
-0.0003751732292585075,
0.01036838162690401,
-0.00013698634575121105,
0.0025989797431975603,
0.027710121124982834,
-0.018117396160960197,
0.00980917178094387,
-0.01990138739347458,
-0.02090633474290371,
0.003026755293831229,
0.03591125085949898,
0.002974793314933777,
-0.03232783451676369,
-0.033201269805431366,
0.030722472816705704,
0.013464470393955708,
-0.009834476746618748,
0.010694107972085476,
-0.007445866707712412,
-0.030907688662409782,
0.01391793042421341,
-0.06421952694654465,
0.021880367770791054,
-0.023543229326605797,
0.03979708254337311,
0.02856016531586647,
0.03002680093050003,
-0.00303438538685441,
0.010907173156738281,
-0.05870271474123001,
0.009461695328354836,
0.008218895643949509,
-0.00012547186634037644,
-0.026815228164196014,
-0.05746035277843475,
0.04085636883974075,
-0.027613617479801178,
-0.00026945542776957154,
-0.016529874876141548,
0.047108665108680725,
-0.0070892805233597755,
-0.00428025284782052,
0.014383296482264996,
0.02416599541902542,
0.04184648394584656,
-0.012349679134786129,
-0.00630759634077549,
-0.028103690594434738,
0.011038271710276604,
0.009778890758752823,
0.01222884189337492,
0.018696488812565804,
0.052669987082481384,
-0.04310467839241028,
-0.042276591062545776,
-0.012038147076964378,
-0.04501397907733917,
-0.023072097450494766,
-0.015508770942687988,
-0.08214184641838074,
-0.03418612480163574,
0.01762748882174492,
0.024552278220653534,
0.011732587590813637,
-0.007176474668085575,
-0.01474080141633749,
0.04344894737005234,
-0.05098381265997887,
0.007067366968840361,
0.030937572941184044,
0.007604554295539856,
-0.030009806156158447,
0.009015746414661407,
-0.019124522805213928,
0.00698105338960886,
0.008542508818209171,
-0.010517263785004616,
0.02161732316017151,
-0.004758846014738083,
-0.046378254890441895,
0.07743328809738159,
0.0000220383135456359,
0.023634640499949455,
-0.01017780788242817,
0.0035471152514219284,
-0.0039982907474040985,
-0.01719927228987217,
0.04359820857644081,
0.018781127408146858,
-0.0003615973691921681,
0.002251208294183016,
0.01885514333844185,
-0.06594417989253998,
0.007446933537721634,
0.007090848870575428,
-0.02115342766046524,
0.015951190143823624,
-0.030698221176862717,
0.045556724071502686,
-0.020224692299962044,
-0.0378347709774971,
-0.03045593947172165,
0.015908997505903244,
-0.016004858538508415,
-0.004259693901985884,
0.018455246463418007,
0.012094760313630104,
0.0022736021783202887,
0.00486272107809782,
-0.01865694299340248,
-0.009684879332780838,
0.03789961710572243,
0.026165563613176346,
-0.007682138122618198,
-0.005854567047208548,
0.00020857540948782116,
-0.07018084079027176,
-0.03871724009513855,
-0.00006000949360895902,
0.00006504213524749503,
0.004079224541783333,
-0.0032638777047395706,
-0.010077646002173424,
-0.015055995434522629,
0.00525108864530921,
0.005602691788226366,
0.022957714274525642,
-0.0553135946393013,
0.007217660080641508,
-0.022904377430677414,
0.027013754472136497,
-0.023196084424853325,
0.0017981252167373896,
-0.009810645133256912,
0.033915191888809204,
0.042739387601614,
-0.006082924548536539,
-0.03040429949760437,
0.028992287814617157,
-0.03710965812206268,
0.014025970362126827,
0.020618503913283348,
0.03286631405353546,
0.006547465454787016,
-0.07105596363544464,
-0.028683412820100784,
-0.0064265732653439045,
-0.15653124451637268,
0.007724655792117119,
0.03748257830739021,
-0.008687925525009632,
0.025300689041614532,
0.018010742962360382,
-0.055336058139801025,
0.0012950163800269365,
-0.0392976775765419,
-0.010595106519758701,
0.020255310460925102,
-0.0484137125313282,
-0.020423797890543938,
-0.0012272987514734268,
0.03964141383767128,
-0.03408009931445122,
-0.015956556424498558,
0.01265393290668726,
0.052923984825611115,
-0.04040531441569328,
0.04903152212500572,
0.01787608489394188,
0.04851152002811432,
-0.00558893010020256,
-0.03160003945231438,
0.011951243504881859,
0.04929957538843155,
-0.02641914412379265,
-0.03958329185843468,
-0.02657843381166458,
-0.026463326066732407,
0.008590026758611202,
-0.017484743148088455,
0.03705696761608124,
0.021523598581552505,
0.07570643723011017,
0.03306230157613754,
-0.09871816635131836,
-0.013789942488074303,
-0.007055697031319141,
0.01748332381248474,
0.02030840702354908,
-0.06478503346443176,
0.02729387767612934,
0.02108323946595192,
-0.06078752875328064,
-0.01601944863796234,
0.01584296114742756,
-0.06541768461465836,
-0.008209957741200924,
0.007241192273795605,
-0.003014966147020459,
-0.028079984709620476,
-0.05044254660606384,
-0.014913863502442837,
0.036791104823350906,
0.03238535299897194,
0.05962666496634483,
-0.022092735394835472,
0.030561186373233795,
-0.01901509054005146,
-0.04840723052620888,
0.05360058322548866,
0.022411132231354713,
-0.02354014851152897,
-0.015015676617622375,
0.017802570015192032,
-0.03115604817867279,
-0.012718785554170609,
-0.04062861576676369,
0.01635998860001564,
-0.048042211681604385,
0.024913018569350243,
-0.00613428745418787,
0.04152112454175949,
0.05043529346585274,
-0.030132511630654335,
-0.0363130122423172,
0.00283222203142941,
-0.11255578696727753,
0.028228776529431343,
0.024406645447015762,
-0.04396061226725578,
-0.022470908239483833,
0.017691370099782944,
-0.016598161309957504,
-0.00908899586647749,
0.012053929269313812,
0.04784081503748894,
0.22894759476184845,
0.05401916429400444,
-0.05400487035512924,
-0.022671299055218697,
-0.0327829085290432,
0.01987968012690544,
0.013160746544599533,
-0.0020766621455550194,
0.03946693241596222,
-0.04508805274963379,
-0.027031943202018738,
0.028201745823025703,
-0.00833189208060503,
-0.023102860897779465,
-0.0007951876614242792,
0.000020204812244628556,
-0.01654105819761753,
-0.003009802894666791,
0.07587860524654388,
0.0007421186892315745,
0.032905884087085724,
-0.022580601274967194,
0.04801349341869354,
-0.01956569403409958,
-0.027325503528118134,
-0.04205017909407616,
0.00002297802348039113,
0.05281038209795952,
-0.01786026544868946,
0.015069822780787945,
-0.022409634664654732,
-0.009957535192370415,
0.0167434923350811,
0.00911451131105423,
-0.006153714377433062,
0.03203785419464111,
0.011209676042199135,
-0.05587919428944588,
-0.03647901117801666,
0.007316384930163622,
-0.014483939856290817,
-0.020568987354636192,
-0.02177216298878193,
-0.04598259925842285,
-0.019851861521601677,
-0.012299994938075542,
0.0012123854830861092,
-0.009831391274929047,
-0.06321267783641815,
0.013266637921333313,
0.01242838241159916,
0.024986207485198975,
-0.015105008147656918,
0.015506567433476448,
-0.0501011461019516,
0.005127179902046919,
0.02896476536989212,
0.016843566671013832,
-0.0004224018775857985,
0.04516458883881569,
-0.013408091850578785,
0.03314539045095444,
-0.0803178921341896,
0.030772583559155464,
0.02012750878930092,
-0.0022417299915105104,
0.0042068809270858765,
0.007810001727193594,
0.0147679029032588,
-0.021444108337163925,
-0.005267652682960033,
0.014642118476331234,
0.007162979803979397,
-0.008941136300563812,
0.06410211324691772,
-0.05299338698387146,
-0.017663151025772095,
0.045808713883161545,
0.024205245077610016,
0.02952256053686142,
0.010000795125961304,
-0.04718026518821716,
-0.021553240716457367,
-0.019551541656255722,
0.008278156630694866,
0.034807413816452026,
-0.0012751799076795578,
0.038139235228300095,
-0.016604047268629074,
-0.0066804238595068455,
0.012139109894633293,
0.01648951880633831,
-0.05027000978589058,
0.015366442501544952,
0.025015302002429962,
-0.023875700309872627,
0.009514073841273785,
0.04525401443243027,
0.016354696825146675,
-0.005860236473381519,
0.01788501627743244,
0.0036181409377604723,
0.025152314454317093,
0.012654496356844902,
0.03219825401902199,
-0.018878614529967308,
-0.016202451661229134,
0.031248755753040314,
-0.013885564170777798,
-0.015610906295478344,
-0.013652708381414413,
0.030630264431238174,
0.0006661772495135665,
-0.02328120730817318,
-0.018610237166285515,
0.0189309511333704,
-0.026209132745862007,
0.004602326545864344,
0.003885542508214712,
0.030860433354973793,
-0.0220445916056633,
-0.029144316911697388,
-0.06664975732564926,
0.04525338485836983,
-0.004658818244934082,
-0.031202131882309914,
-0.010148546658456326,
-0.011424935422837734,
-0.0022531410213559866,
0.034757860004901886,
0.008654922246932983,
-0.03184729814529419,
-0.0228367131203413,
0.02093369886279106,
0.07626204937696457,
0.0074982005171477795,
0.006465293001383543,
-0.020842237398028374,
-0.020564831793308258,
0.027668528258800507,
0.018359404057264328,
0.02126944065093994,
-0.040296200662851334,
0.0036491008941084146,
0.003729150164872408,
0.015018397942185402,
-0.050833042711019516,
0.004366392735391855,
-0.04857306182384491,
0.016473358497023582,
0.03525600954890251,
0.010746738873422146,
0.0029362954664975405,
-0.062445707619190216,
0.011410171166062355,
-0.04525002837181091,
-0.020866885781288147,
-0.004904092289507389,
0.03504260256886482,
-0.05683857202529907,
0.04851328954100609,
0.010576807893812656,
0.02234538085758686,
0.03842645511031151,
0.0289448332041502,
0.05138672515749931,
-0.022059094160795212,
0.005617465823888779,
0.002524366369470954,
-0.02712319605052471,
-0.06723738461732864,
-0.022338135167956352,
-0.03601956367492676,
-0.012913508340716362,
0.012419503182172775,
0.03507983684539795,
-0.02434140257537365,
0.003671445185318589,
0.031679101288318634,
-0.00036207857192493975,
0.002962334780022502,
0.016662193462252617,
-0.01907576061785221,
0.03894958645105362,
-0.023682881146669388,
-0.014529519714415073,
0.00821772776544094,
0.009365454316139221,
0.008933836594223976,
-0.010516086593270302,
-0.023012805730104446,
0.0880938470363617,
-0.01926356554031372,
0.01954568363726139,
0.03790746629238129,
-0.005936615634709597,
0.03927885740995407,
0.030633725225925446,
0.005030268337577581,
-0.009736031293869019,
0.01012340560555458,
-0.002998505951836705,
-0.02763175591826439,
0.022981733083724976,
-0.002273202408105135,
-0.0038844940718263388,
0.027562418952584267,
0.03050532191991806,
-0.027874071151018143,
-0.02754824236035347,
0.018949413672089577,
-0.03163917362689972,
-0.033378493040800095,
-0.02078179270029068,
0.014337694272398949,
-0.039538100361824036,
0.03223877027630806,
0.05701502040028572,
0.00226214830763638,
-0.026698581874370575,
-0.03853839263319969,
-0.022219087928533554,
0.016793588176369667,
-0.018556401133537292,
0.026755575090646744,
0.022531094029545784,
0.027887586504220963,
-0.025721965357661247,
-0.0012903633760288358,
-0.01966538280248642,
0.0017812536098062992,
-0.004026998765766621,
0.028926901519298553,
-0.006973257288336754,
-0.029204946011304855,
0.012848717160522938,
0.000036774777981918305,
-0.00506266113370657,
0.05466986820101738,
-0.024983910843729973,
0.07702779024839401,
-0.0033541605807840824,
0.0061745429411530495,
0.03530591353774071,
-0.00997442938387394,
-0.0058697122149169445,
-0.025528384372591972,
-0.02309015765786171,
-0.004779251758009195,
0.01243099570274353,
-0.0038582105189561844,
0.0018782805418595672,
-0.011953762732446194,
-0.00756456283852458,
0.015497921034693718,
0.029288915917277336,
0.04773429036140442,
-0.012767373584210873,
-0.028994951397180557,
0.005489205941557884,
0.0031225569546222687,
0.01435164362192154,
-0.014625300653278828,
0.03222987428307533,
-0.03212602064013481,
-0.05527777597308159,
0.055443521589040756,
-0.013482767157256603,
-0.022691907361149788,
-0.03937670961022377,
0.014335895888507366,
-0.014084677211940289,
-0.031273726373910904,
-0.014433369971811771,
0.031577520072460175,
0.017480259761214256,
-0.019910093396902084,
0.006810920313000679,
0.014346600510179996,
-0.0011651706881821156,
-0.014395459555089474,
0.007090246770530939,
0.020400606095790863,
0.06427788734436035,
-0.023691166192293167,
0.030185291543602943,
0.02226094715297222,
0.020227229222655296,
0.03896143287420273,
-0.042911745607852936,
0.038760364055633545,
-0.00701619079336524,
-0.035969194024801254,
0.030085457488894463,
0.014383203350007534,
0.005832640454173088,
0.010187570005655289,
0.07078875601291656,
-0.006597356870770454,
-0.009968454949557781,
-0.018658539280295372,
0.0584174282848835,
-0.028303826227784157,
0.005847493652254343,
0.019121695309877396,
-0.0040307603776454926,
0.027985038235783577,
-0.02726701647043228,
0.04078841954469681,
-0.016849681735038757,
0.01837119087576866,
-0.07745271921157837,
0.005980289075523615,
-0.0008477620431222022,
0.01086551882326603,
-0.008085766807198524,
0.003766104346141219,
-0.027027437463402748,
0.012987696565687656,
0.02700895443558693,
0.018226072192192078,
0.029298318549990654,
-0.010571788065135479,
0.0010096713667735457,
-0.0295136496424675,
0.050319135189056396,
0.0012451837537810206,
-0.02190340682864189,
-0.0164653193205595,
0.003336929017677903,
-0.026340486481785774,
0.005054063629359007,
-0.01170085184276104,
0.032620206475257874,
0.06065235659480095,
0.001737128710374236,
0.02400209754705429,
-0.021758606657385826,
0.054776694625616074,
-0.06373937427997589,
-0.02571268379688263,
0.01281163189560175,
0.08338889479637146,
0.00522808451205492,
-0.0011421687668189406,
-0.03104032389819622,
0.008885172195732594,
-0.025164952501654625,
0.009967987425625324,
0.02187086082994938,
0.0008108207839541137,
-0.0259163249284029,
-0.004729831125587225,
-0.056211601942777634,
0.052796829491853714,
-0.0359722301363945,
-0.03980567306280136,
-0.024526109918951988,
-0.0019355976255610585,
0.011668969877064228,
-0.008980154059827328,
0.010013598017394543,
0.005708571057766676,
-0.013242837972939014,
-0.012688401155173779,
0.037467021495103836,
0.03609483316540718,
0.0081821633502841,
0.009940050542354584,
0.02650275081396103,
0.03395829349756241,
-0.00791852455586195,
0.005139496643096209,
0.013619952835142612,
-0.02535594440996647,
0.0026172546204179525,
0.03476026654243469,
0.006266847252845764,
0.030114956200122833,
0.014738432131707668,
-0.03551425039768219,
-0.04061298817396164,
-0.047801870852708817,
-0.010322116315364838,
0.0020242684986442327,
0.06078432872891426,
-0.05467058718204498,
0.0510934554040432,
0.0071147773414850235,
0.05013206601142883,
-0.01645791530609131,
-0.002973317401483655,
-0.042742930352687836,
0.03142879903316498,
-0.14861568808555603,
0.050211939960718155,
0.020840881392359734,
-0.025248492136597633,
-0.017827816307544708,
0.010758045129477978,
-0.03906930238008499,
0.016235975548624992,
-0.0018032476073130965,
0.029488541185855865,
0.029648249968886375,
0.025233520194888115,
0.05889221653342247,
-0.025650370866060257,
-0.08102008700370789,
0.042592693120241165,
-0.009653438813984394,
-0.007684281561523676,
-0.03973032161593437,
0.03913073614239693,
0.03222762793302536,
-0.01632726937532425,
0.03394404053688049,
-0.026201065629720688,
0.023802174255251884,
-0.01497592218220234,
0.022522620856761932,
-0.018870947882533073,
-0.01101742684841156,
-0.0006803241558372974,
-0.02031666785478592,
-0.03707507625222206,
-0.007804414257407188,
0.05477456748485565,
-0.007524338085204363,
0.05298452451825142,
0.02343590557575226,
0.0003850214125122875,
-0.03472194820642471,
0.021705422550439835,
-0.017994999885559082,
0.0033593387342989445,
0.037026625126600266,
-0.026232296600937843,
-0.004100131802260876,
-0.002766722347587347,
0.008677631616592407,
0.034031886607408524,
-0.028666960075497627,
-0.01857598125934601,
0.00529203936457634,
0.006236718501895666,
-0.018803926184773445,
0.03463839739561081,
0.0037300875410437584,
-0.01589665561914444,
-0.01319797895848751,
-0.012730387039482594,
-0.04390469565987587,
0.02186720259487629,
-0.027559475973248482,
-0.008004316128790379,
-0.04445964843034744,
0.02512182854115963,
0.02567564696073532,
0.011281318962574005,
0.0020214314572513103,
-0.018630478531122208,
0.007346025202423334,
-0.025984585285186768,
-0.045953523367643356,
-0.04313119500875473,
0.023985547944903374,
-0.02217579446732998,
-0.015512604266405106,
-0.009916861541569233,
-0.0384746715426445,
0.004093262366950512,
-0.029540102928876877,
-0.01560777984559536,
-0.03470788896083832,
0.014939786866307259,
-0.008600420318543911,
-0.026602044701576233,
0.015221063047647476,
0.0187396053224802,
-0.01578296348452568,
-0.027081109583377838,
-0.0029048286378383636,
0.004271368496119976,
-0.04663177579641342,
0.01272086426615715,
0.007343960925936699,
0.04889651760458946,
0.0058066630735993385,
0.003881048411130905,
-0.0360906682908535,
-0.024680718779563904,
-0.04967917501926422,
0.002357321558520198,
-0.005670229438692331,
-0.002543928101658821,
-0.022457748651504517,
0.027721285820007324,
-0.021443191915750504,
-0.0008722182828933001,
0.03866753727197647,
-0.021129952743649483,
-0.01814720220863819,
0.004621123895049095,
-0.004268901888281107,
-0.03181959688663483,
-0.0657481774687767,
-0.009790314361453056,
-0.060555148869752884,
0.004267578013241291,
-0.0012578682508319616,
0.04382086172699928,
-0.023420611396431923,
0.00792220514267683,
0.012489854358136654,
0.01314790453761816,
-0.012171614915132523,
-0.022673040628433228,
-0.036977268755435944,
-0.005181290674954653,
0.03781576082110405,
-0.03157549351453781,
0.026991285383701324,
-0.02746419981122017,
-0.019147101789712906,
-0.012122112326323986,
0.008367094211280346,
0.05023971572518349,
0.028747275471687317,
-0.003677121829241514,
-0.04588642343878746,
0.010685148648917675,
-0.018667345866560936,
-0.05982057377696037,
0.014077508822083473,
-0.027245763689279556,
0.019057273864746094,
-0.03970272094011307,
-0.006103052757680416,
0.015046374872326851,
0.03316853940486908,
0.006241296883672476,
-0.023792970925569534,
-0.026744503527879715,
-0.02767820656299591,
0.037510279566049576,
-0.021110162138938904,
0.04305014759302139,
-0.026562832295894623,
0.0016052403952926397,
0.06235581636428833,
0.03404015675187111,
0.00007733905658824369,
0.04066479951143265,
0.012995137833058834,
-0.011465361341834068,
-0.0034140734933316708,
0.020612122491002083,
-0.011145138181746006,
0.003970463294535875,
-0.003613370470702648,
0.014305738732218742,
-0.053401220589876175,
0.023639241233468056,
-0.029322626069188118,
-0.00039228121750056744,
0.017089033499360085,
0.007479704916477203,
-0.0068288338370621204,
-0.03186711296439171,
0.00894513726234436,
-0.02154707908630371,
0.06805027276277542,
-0.023712877184152603,
0.029483981430530548,
0.011958478018641472,
0.0067252530716359615,
0.007464378606528044,
0.060845665633678436,
0.061751194298267365,
0.026906432583928108,
0.07502543926239014,
-0.03151015192270279,
0.009844421409070492,
-0.004152139648795128,
-0.0020731999538838863,
0.022033248096704483,
-0.010523988865315914,
0.029239805415272713,
-0.02645464800298214,
-0.05254707112908363,
0.0686650201678276,
0.04148922488093376,
0.02744344435632229,
-0.00813567079603672,
-0.03415778651833534,
-0.051151253283023834,
-0.035447411239147186,
-0.02528206631541252,
-0.01573982834815979,
-0.01517488993704319,
-0.03804047033190727,
0.0015150675317272544,
0.055119406431913376,
-0.05769742280244827,
0.014891263097524643,
-0.004141522105783224,
0.016332659870386124,
-0.005919221322983503,
0.017773421481251717,
-0.02632874995470047,
0.013535785488784313,
-0.015305863693356514,
0.010553643107414246,
0.028243115171790123,
0.026709631085395813,
-0.010461505502462387,
-0.06210510432720184,
-0.007571077905595303,
0.014801973477005959,
-0.039251431822776794,
0.0035962373949587345,
-0.03891376033425331,
-0.034997642040252686,
-0.023907598108053207,
0.006990055087953806,
0.014279510825872421,
0.04361313581466675,
0.020511379465460777,
-0.010726438835263252,
-0.0525241382420063,
0.003951058257371187,
-0.0358746238052845,
0.001905129523947835,
0.0077906115911901,
-0.01984100602567196,
0.009894469752907753,
0.003499599639326334
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:32
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
I think there were substantial contributions by the plaintiff in respect of the farm in contrast to the contributions by the defendant. The plaintiff denied these contributions but he does not suggest that he did them. Accordingly, I am satisfied that the defendant did them.
180So far as renting the Grafton units I accept that the defendant set the rent which she achieved which was substantially better than the real estate agent's initial estimate. No doubt this is why the units became valuable.
181In respect of the business Ace High Hats it seems clear that both parties contributed equally to this business until they decided to cease business.
182I have already earlier dealt with the driving which the plaintiff had to do because the defendant could not drive. Another matter they both attended to equally was the care and welfare of the defendant's brother George, who was disabled and suffered from cerebral palsy. The plaintiff gave evidence that he contributed to the same degree as the defendant to the care and welfare of George.
183Given the particular work done on the farm in my view the non-financial contributions I have been discussing, favour the plaintiff over the defendant.
Claim for adjustment under s 20
184The plaintiff originally claimed a 100% of the parties' property but at the hearing submitted that the assessment of the parties' contributions should result in a division of the parties' property, excluding the lotto proceeds, as to 60% to the plaintiff and 40% to the defendant.
However the orders sought by the plaintiff are for a different result, namely a division of the assets of 40% to the plaintiff and 60% to the defendant, and according to the submissions this reflects the instructions of the plaintiff, not the analysis of this case by applying the authorities.
185The defendant for her part seeks an adjustment, which after what she says are appropriate add backs, give her 85% of the parties assets.
Global or asset by asset approach and the erosion principle
186In Norbis v Norbis (1985-1986) 161 CLR 513 at 523 the High Court said the following:
"Although it is natural to assess financial contributions under s79 (4)(a) by reference to individual assets, it is also natural to assess the contribution of a spouse as homemaker and parent either by reference to the whole of the parties' property or to some part of that property.
For ease of comparison and calculation it will be convenient in assessing the overall contributions of the parties at some stage to place the two types of contribution on the same basis, i.e. on a global or, alternatively, on an "asset-by-asset" basis.
Which of the two approaches is the more convenient will depend on the circumstances of the particular case. However, there is much to be said for the view that in most cases the global approach is the more convenient.
It follows that the Full Court is quite entitled to prescribe that approach as a guideline in order to promote uniformity of approach within the Court. In saying this we are not to be understood as denying the legitimacy of the trial judge's ascertainment in the first instance of the financial contributions of the parties by reference to particular assets.
It is difficult to conceive how the trial judge in many cases could otherwise take account of such contributions as he is required to by s.79 (4)(a) of the Act . In this respect we agree with the comment of Nygh J.
in G and G that, although mathematical precision is certainly not required, there is ordinarily a need to know the circumstances in which assets were acquired and the general extent of each party's contribution to them."
187The same considerations which apply to Family Law referred to by the High Court in Norbis v Norbis apply to decisions under the Property (relationships) Act 1984. There are numerous cases dealing with this Act but it is useful to note the following two comments by the Court of Appeal.
|
[
0.013963364064693451,
0.02432350255548954,
-0.023261476308107376,
0.054921068251132965,
0.00007331799861276522,
-0.0888795554637909,
0.03641198202967644,
0.021943287923932076,
0.008576982654631138,
-0.012353001162409782,
-0.046709682792425156,
0.0646435096859932,
-0.03846314549446106,
0.01757752150297165,
0.024436581879854202,
-0.004725558217614889,
0.002432950073853135,
-0.01151193119585514,
-0.029938051477074623,
0.00047841324703767896,
-0.03397082909941673,
0.019417067989706993,
0.04719143360853195,
-0.01492907851934433,
0.005864358507096767,
0.03505055606365204,
-0.06713762879371643,
-0.004781963303685188,
0.07577839493751526,
0.01492508128285408,
-0.015048938803374767,
-0.020848803222179413,
-0.006187601014971733,
-0.021318070590496063,
-0.003600877709686756,
-0.04750896617770195,
-0.004527944605797529,
0.007213372737169266,
-0.022634092718362808,
0.001937895081937313,
0.020340679213404655,
0.02658170834183693,
0.025114990770816803,
-0.030735382810235023,
0.051073212176561356,
-0.027343906462192535,
-0.029919354245066643,
-0.03673720732331276,
-0.04027412086725235,
0.014372984878718853,
-0.04272996634244919,
0.013176502659916878,
0.05277729034423828,
-0.05242244526743889,
0.016331233084201813,
0.039097171276807785,
-0.0064102355390787125,
-0.04019307717680931,
-0.04280157387256622,
-0.020670883357524872,
-0.017254997044801712,
-0.01257992535829544,
-0.030024686828255653,
-0.035967521369457245,
0.019208524376153946,
0.04993146285414696,
-0.015348982997238636,
-0.012667565606534481,
-0.027067920193076134,
-0.03175864368677139,
-0.04097217693924904,
-0.0018235257593914866,
-0.023910339921712875,
-0.0017786851385608315,
-0.04046208783984184,
-0.0036932919174432755,
0.012181095778942108,
0.001186948618851602,
-0.0009263867395929992,
-0.006518479436635971,
0.0005237356526777148,
-0.03189331293106079,
0.020877374336123466,
0.012771093286573887,
-0.02771921642124653,
0.010288281366229057,
-0.003666636999696493,
0.017781473696231842,
0.000983176869340241,
0.011431656777858734,
-0.04031124711036682,
-0.0034751929342746735,
0.017442919313907623,
-0.02539287507534027,
0.006270352751016617,
0.022581374272704124,
-0.06249111890792847,
0.028615228831768036,
-0.00901761930435896,
-0.001008135499432683,
-0.011371403001248837,
0.037131745368242264,
0.0293269045650959,
-0.00870722159743309,
0.019588744267821312,
0.02188694290816784,
0.02547016367316246,
0.047507911920547485,
0.0396796353161335,
-0.002653558272868395,
-0.013302365317940712,
-0.014742338098585606,
-0.009354746900498867,
0.014908596873283386,
-0.030019141733646393,
-0.031253647059202194,
0.008487862534821033,
-0.00853684265166521,
-0.0005791466101072729,
-0.002271292032673955,
0.04927796125411987,
0.0005062686977908015,
0.09384728968143463,
0.0045847659930586815,
-0.055823300033807755,
0.030817745253443718,
-0.013591855764389038,
0.0015566156944260001,
-0.03398946672677994,
0.011867998167872429,
-0.004870356526225805,
-0.004937161225825548,
-0.027109479531645775,
-0.06655767560005188,
-0.005475156474858522,
-0.017259743064641953,
0.02402927353978157,
0.04082579165697098,
0.015125823207199574,
-0.04258345067501068,
0.040048446506261826,
0.03339342027902603,
-0.04633526876568794,
-0.0016299855196848512,
0.03332187607884407,
0.011457160115242004,
0.03067193552851677,
0.00241554225794971,
-0.04703113064169884,
-0.03118872456252575,
0.009866874665021896,
0.011428858153522015,
0.04070986807346344,
-0.024084120988845825,
0.03473546355962753,
-0.023557370528578758,
0.024292172864079475,
0.0004736213886644691,
0.04791271314024925,
0.024224063381552696,
-0.00656474195420742,
0.034800365567207336,
-0.03434386104345322,
-0.05983094125986099,
-0.03762068971991539,
-0.02176319994032383,
0.006008601281791925,
0.03089212439954281,
-0.004393275827169418,
-0.02212369069457054,
0.03449609875679016,
0.0006307215662673116,
0.02597198821604252,
-0.038317516446113586,
-0.00029953327612020075,
0.01806897483766079,
0.03721585497260094,
0.0064353845082223415,
0.015185880474746227,
-0.041405089199543,
0.010960551910102367,
0.008220827206969261,
-0.008356140926480293,
0.0029511756729334593,
-0.005904626566916704,
0.02187170833349228,
-0.002571743680164218,
-0.02616354264318943,
0.05743046849966049,
-0.005959732923656702,
-0.007881666533648968,
-0.058606281876564026,
0.05101408809423447,
-0.01650204509496689,
0.008606011979281902,
-0.022030407562851906,
-0.0091128284111619,
-0.036890365183353424,
0.016214784234762192,
-0.03247735649347305,
-0.02529924176633358,
0.011199829168617725,
0.046904049813747406,
0.011534716933965683,
-0.06955239176750183,
0.016655156388878822,
-0.0762857049703598,
0.0017892725300043821,
0.023306285962462425,
-0.012144510634243488,
0.027917901054024696,
0.021485934033989906,
0.0474848710000515,
0.019559144973754883,
-0.013314428739249706,
-0.02032654546201229,
0.017247259616851807,
-0.0003174273297190666,
-0.016441427171230316,
-0.0040382808074355125,
-0.011662935838103294,
0.00838997308164835,
0.01552613265812397,
0.009689122438430786,
0.057935915887355804,
0.025860298424959183,
-0.02818467654287815,
0.0032071752939373255,
0.08579985797405243,
-0.05376278981566429,
0.027804596349596977,
0.025118930265307426,
0.007146215997636318,
-0.05358850210905075,
0.030388198792934418,
-0.006259215530008078,
0.011071658693253994,
0.007723621092736721,
-0.01536960992962122,
0.007401072885841131,
-0.0013034457806497812,
-0.009441706351935863,
0.003886673366650939,
-0.037882182747125626,
-0.026350123807787895,
0.01484602503478527,
-0.05151129141449928,
0.03251348435878754,
0.007988429628312588,
-0.05741351842880249,
0.025278987362980843,
-0.0015591896371915936,
-0.009432023391127586,
-0.01722165383398533,
-0.006522942800074816,
0.005076034460216761,
0.02017180435359478,
-0.00977798830717802,
0.042431607842445374,
-0.03969085216522217,
-0.008033057674765587,
0.02122528851032257,
0.02755298838019371,
0.023288043215870857,
-0.009406028315424919,
-0.011380533687770367,
-0.037896156311035156,
-0.004218585789203644,
-0.0008012052858248353,
0.05430269613862038,
0.021337762475013733,
0.01645728014409542,
-0.04020169377326965,
-0.016097664833068848,
0.023072421550750732,
0.02837536484003067,
0.01996254175901413,
-0.030180340632796288,
0.050643157213926315,
-0.002110150409862399,
-0.01192724984139204,
-0.006362540181726217,
-0.0037538683973252773,
-0.029644038528203964,
0.022498253732919693,
0.014196647331118584,
0.000972248672042042,
0.018640795722603798,
0.004366985056549311,
-0.050499193370342255,
0.04678204283118248,
-0.04935413971543312,
0.06871870160102844,
-0.02513761632144451,
-0.06308403611183167,
-0.024767285212874413,
0.008453326299786568,
-0.13807623088359833,
0.011154933832585812,
0.029674530029296875,
0.02757074311375618,
0.012803737074136734,
0.061834488064050674,
-0.030880464240908623,
-0.001323636039160192,
0.01442204974591732,
-0.00508459098637104,
-0.016460569575428963,
-0.07895659655332565,
-0.029588697478175163,
-0.008714607916772366,
-0.028084278106689453,
-0.023925209417939186,
0.019730951637029648,
0.02029643952846527,
0.022813504561781883,
-0.006174350157380104,
-0.00412310566753149,
0.0045943716540932655,
-0.03767571970820427,
0.02312338910996914,
0.011669982224702835,
0.00756762595847249,
0.01152004860341549,
0.04162394627928734,
-0.007045795675367117,
-0.033389605581760406,
-0.024709325283765793,
-0.04872104898095131,
-0.00474518071860075,
0.00866283942013979,
-0.009622885845601559,
0.02595219947397709,
0.04242264851927757,
-0.03094431757926941,
-0.018805013969540596,
-0.04404623433947563,
0.036109015345573425,
0.07510584592819214,
-0.019024457782506943,
0.018393825739622116,
-0.008982754312455654,
-0.05949224531650543,
-0.0051288302056491375,
-0.049884866923093796,
-0.03643395006656647,
0.07224299758672714,
-0.017747247591614723,
0.025105571374297142,
-0.03177306428551674,
-0.022664112970232964,
-0.043234147131443024,
-0.025923164561390877,
0.037317629903554916,
0.051702916622161865,
0.05473022907972336,
0.009085044264793396,
-0.02979842573404312,
-0.029526976868510246,
0.025859985500574112,
0.00802663154900074,
-0.011534170247614384,
0.02017519623041153,
-0.013880650512874126,
-0.007890353910624981,
0.07397967576980591,
-0.035798437893390656,
-0.009091653861105442,
-0.01567809283733368,
0.02816840633749962,
-0.008275371044874191,
-0.006458578631281853,
0.017308810725808144,
0.0690523087978363,
-0.002322701271623373,
0.0064201150089502335,
-0.08810655772686005,
0.041559409350156784,
0.008257453329861164,
0.00802504364401102,
0.03131326287984848,
-0.0009252094314433634,
-0.018644534051418304,
0.003582385601475835,
-0.00482809916138649,
0.049467917531728745,
0.23441477119922638,
0.00904989242553711,
0.035867828875780106,
0.000714419933501631,
-0.007414356805384159,
-0.03136632964015007,
0.033122219145298004,
0.036477670073509216,
0.05015990510582924,
-0.033816445618867874,
-0.056425321847200394,
0.07061988115310669,
0.013946150429546833,
0.012046579271554947,
-0.031598303467035294,
0.03142506629228592,
-0.043975796550512314,
-0.03297697380185127,
0.05960310250520706,
-0.013761447742581367,
0.01258593425154686,
-0.01881834864616394,
0.025967927649617195,
0.0293970238417387,
-0.04114773869514465,
-0.013863944448530674,
-0.01045685913413763,
0.07807870954275131,
0.0010143304243683815,
0.030684661120176315,
-0.009698928333818913,
-0.034589733928442,
0.027773702517151833,
0.03088163584470749,
-0.015883682295680046,
0.02631988748908043,
-0.029268791899085045,
0.017771374434232712,
0.03489920496940613,
0.0560297966003418,
-0.002292684745043516,
-0.022596100345253944,
-0.035387344658374786,
-0.04515829682350159,
0.03259984403848648,
0.0005935576045885682,
-0.007467424497008324,
0.031997598707675934,
-0.0179292019456625,
0.0000943294508033432,
-0.0046853418461978436,
0.030358819290995598,
-0.03557644784450531,
-0.006670372560620308,
-0.016100794076919556,
0.021486973389983177,
-0.00590108847245574,
0.05333705618977547,
-0.032746367156505585,
0.016810258850455284,
-0.014103456400334835,
-0.0006943065673112869,
0.019160106778144836,
-0.03468912094831467,
-0.025549685582518578,
0.02535528503358364,
-0.05563116446137428,
-0.04044514149427414,
0.02271932177245617,
0.017235752195119858,
0.013850023970007896,
-0.004289285279810429,
-0.0009843669831752777,
0.03161059319972992,
0.056785065680742264,
0.020362718030810356,
0.018870782107114792,
-0.0031689719762653112,
-0.009958929382264614,
-0.035069789737463,
-0.06410841643810272,
-0.02007986232638359,
-0.009711378253996372,
-0.005529899150133133,
-0.0051160696893930435,
-0.0072730970568954945,
-0.04733496904373169,
0.03844429925084114,
0.02538267709314823,
-0.012333463877439499,
-0.02693629451096058,
-0.037642594426870346,
-0.0011986757162958384,
0.0021115667186677456,
-0.01299279648810625,
0.012434905394911766,
0.034226953983306885,
-0.004589283373206854,
-0.017669513821601868,
-0.05380750447511673,
0.014352411031723022,
0.03486839681863785,
-0.012404844164848328,
-0.0019244601717218757,
0.023841943591833115,
-0.020971525460481644,
-0.012244610115885735,
0.006858630105853081,
-0.06318103522062302,
-0.00563089968636632,
-0.017169242724776268,
0.03748079016804695,
0.0012592264683917165,
0.009586864151060581,
0.01466748584061861,
0.00791575200855732,
0.0024228475522249937,
0.03450898453593254,
0.017193255946040154,
-0.00893088337033987,
-0.022925006225705147,
-0.01195607241243124,
-0.008149445056915283,
-0.03893107548356056,
0.0007631483022123575,
-0.03992230072617531,
-0.000804281618911773,
-0.02874101512134075,
0.0027344473637640476,
0.017649786546826363,
0.00048583143507130444,
-0.021367104724049568,
-0.06375805288553238,
0.05441617965698242,
0.026549963280558586,
-0.012172005139291286,
-0.008066191338002682,
0.02075284905731678,
-0.01753389462828636,
-0.0011214406695216894,
-0.04683266952633858,
0.0158999003469944,
-0.0008713033748790622,
-0.00759539008140564,
0.002484444761648774,
0.01574402116239071,
-0.03387470170855522,
0.028576985001564026,
-0.0015678944764658809,
-0.0027063332963734865,
-0.009349623695015907,
-0.014088048599660397,
-0.03883390128612518,
-0.011650879867374897,
-0.00903252325952053,
0.02151736430823803,
0.009016517549753189,
-0.024474631994962692,
0.0804188996553421,
-0.02723083645105362,
-0.006517796777188778,
-0.004400432109832764,
-0.0053901029750704765,
0.04571622237563133,
-0.0014075504150241613,
0.07641146332025528,
0.020407086238265038,
0.01685992255806923,
0.03199151158332825,
-0.042610619217157364,
-0.021241653710603714,
-0.02861854061484337,
-0.014497249387204647,
0.008720058016479015,
0.018211467191576958,
0.017108535394072533,
-0.0035466456320136786,
0.04931235685944557,
0.0019253295613452792,
-0.04655391350388527,
0.026162164285779,
0.017510686069726944,
-0.035207439213991165,
-0.00509638013318181,
-0.020820479840040207,
-0.02740594372153282,
0.0044725434854626656,
-0.005667367950081825,
-0.00042417054646648467,
-0.022029254585504532,
-0.018764834851026535,
0.08681409060955048,
-0.01002331543713808,
-0.031188232824206352,
0.008265078067779541,
0.042935438454151154,
0.019533080980181694,
0.03178343176841736,
0.02782108075916767,
-0.02504214644432068,
-0.030306648463010788,
0.008874624967575073,
0.008263427764177322,
0.006669700611382723,
0.057579003274440765,
-0.0005686037475243211,
-0.00262332521378994,
-0.007865863852202892,
-0.017846377566456795,
-0.023200053721666336,
0.023437898606061935,
0.014823628589510918,
-0.048828430473804474,
-0.012774919159710407,
0.029029419645667076,
0.013150055892765522,
0.03168990835547447,
0.04576612636446953,
-0.037870630621910095,
-0.062440175563097,
-0.03758148476481438,
-0.007630989421159029,
-0.014204403385519981,
-0.1072917953133583,
-0.01335969939827919,
0.02453772909939289,
-0.013672656379640102,
0.01644354872405529,
-0.015466964803636074,
-0.001333146938122809,
-0.00036300200736150146,
-0.03114033304154873,
0.03334979712963104,
-0.01628202758729458,
-0.00011787049152189866,
-0.044055040925741196,
0.016709240153431892,
0.012796035036444664,
0.01950770430266857,
-0.049735575914382935,
0.03644848242402077,
-0.021346742287278175,
0.06025833636522293,
0.05885928496718407,
-0.0015766120050102472,
-0.05685925483703613,
-0.01902155391871929,
-0.00929357297718525,
0.03755777329206467,
0.02304782345890999,
-0.01313523855060339,
-0.029672883450984955,
0.012798548676073551,
-0.026108672842383385,
-0.0031405079644173384,
0.02179252915084362,
0.027908610180020332,
0.02912692353129387,
-0.06483928114175797,
-0.06596888601779938,
0.012260573916137218,
0.02605617046356201,
0.010095532052218914,
-0.030153336003422737,
-0.027020258828997612,
-0.04276004806160927,
0.0028688537422567606,
-0.0026878132484853268,
-0.011915507726371288,
-0.011745622381567955,
-0.012202097102999687,
0.014106941409409046,
-0.037474170327186584,
-0.056937217712402344,
-0.00023328424140345305,
-0.00002435822352708783,
-0.015597176738083363,
-0.004905481357127428,
0.059129197150468826,
0.02261759154498577,
0.02780156210064888,
-0.0022643604315817356,
0.03381596505641937,
0.052752383053302765,
-0.017047325149178505,
0.0016602487303316593,
0.035356637090444565,
0.03899925574660301,
-0.0003125946968793869,
-0.0271967314183712,
0.03475091606378555,
0.0012656430481001735,
-0.023267051205039024,
0.03295233100652695,
-0.013482902199029922,
-0.0011145913740620017,
0.025622516870498657,
0.03464207798242569,
-0.0054542734287679195,
0.00972354132682085,
-0.03616733476519585,
-0.0350998230278492,
0.0016852844273671508,
-0.047062963247299194,
-0.004174553323537111,
0.02908744476735592,
0.014234760776162148,
-0.05483748018741608,
-0.03462494537234306,
-0.004080822691321373,
-0.0281365979462862,
-0.04129018634557724,
0.026886126026511192,
-0.04189034923911095,
-0.006579805165529251,
0.055395644158124924,
0.014702821150422096,
0.00629876833409071,
-0.017139339819550514,
0.03583376109600067,
0.021947436034679413,
0.00828973762691021,
-0.034224215894937515,
-0.02400929480791092,
-0.030181217938661575,
-0.025368256494402885,
0.05767000466585159,
0.002128561958670616,
-0.007228273898363113,
0.02157309278845787,
-0.03457820415496826,
-0.009269118309020996,
-0.02519434317946434,
0.02672472782433033,
0.038012392818927765,
-0.045171014964580536,
0.03261149302124977,
-0.062380921095609665,
0.05048524960875511,
-0.022344078868627548,
-0.00534824701026082,
-0.02110881730914116,
0.10152266174554825,
-0.002466832986101508,
-0.014699893072247505,
0.010306875221431255,
0.0334477573633194,
0.006081289611756802,
0.04101133346557617,
0.021750401705503464,
-0.007333483546972275,
0.012725123204290867,
-0.03419096767902374,
-0.03950835391879082,
0.03643167391419411,
-0.0405922569334507,
0.034413259476423264,
-0.014453654177486897,
0.06416361778974533,
-0.06108968332409859,
-0.01404266245663166,
0.004179408773779869,
0.018684308975934982,
-0.020783817395567894,
0.036048341542482376,
0.021002285182476044,
-0.011422778479754925,
-0.00661485455930233,
0.0008227115031331778,
-0.003046683967113495,
0.05453087016940117,
-0.024609947577118874,
-0.007122808136045933,
-0.01511574536561966,
-0.048975054174661636,
-0.015254472382366657,
-0.026670480147004128,
-0.01049781497567892,
-0.011919267475605011,
0.0031496998853981495,
-0.015080783516168594,
-0.04248005896806717,
-0.09996802359819412,
-0.0017617272678762674,
-0.024772334843873978,
-0.005877363961189985,
0.006523451302200556,
0.019807565957307816,
-0.005372114945203066,
0.00037508097011595964,
-0.030877556651830673,
0.05911517143249512,
-0.001584488432854414,
-0.018778767436742783,
-0.1405492126941681,
-0.0009433583472855389,
0.014918702654540539,
0.005774985067546368,
-0.06506749242544174,
0.007561990525573492,
-0.034888967871665955,
-0.01247935276478529,
0.0029790354892611504,
-0.0007310757646337152,
-0.008034388534724712,
0.007157590705901384,
0.008614652790129185,
0.000014556941096088849,
-0.017479248344898224,
0.019010884687304497,
-0.0022272130008786917,
-0.012518716976046562,
-0.019295068457722664,
0.04142211005091667,
0.001407889649271965,
0.002800189657136798,
-0.0074345762841403484,
-0.01707197166979313,
0.020578458905220032,
-0.05683116987347603,
-0.04928680509328842,
0.0076644401997327805,
-0.04751887917518616,
-0.0012710201554000378,
-0.003024015575647354,
-0.035895951092243195,
0.025659028440713882,
-0.009238428436219692,
0.015643367543816566,
-0.009427348151803017,
-0.015752237290143967,
0.014246086589992046,
-0.04321252554655075,
-0.0350341796875,
-0.022688239812850952,
0.019882678985595703,
-0.04542010650038719,
0.00805585365742445,
0.005803111009299755,
0.046140287071466446,
0.03735540062189102,
-0.019694596529006958,
-0.010250748135149479,
-0.03716744855046272,
-0.021386127918958664,
0.018646230921149254,
0.01997060328722,
0.06439410895109177,
-0.005367453210055828,
0.0006494823028333485,
-0.019066760316491127,
-0.026918703690171242,
-0.012531229294836521,
0.03690187260508537,
0.02795894630253315,
-0.0037382442969828844,
-0.013142630457878113,
-0.034367285668849945,
-0.014811795204877853,
-0.0003624176315497607,
-0.03846529871225357,
-0.021900294348597527,
0.0015477228444069624,
0.0045730359852313995,
0.010074766352772713,
-0.016461972147226334,
0.03234362602233887,
-0.020794110372662544,
0.017746930941939354,
0.004426474217325449,
-0.01420681830495596,
-0.0032796859741210938,
-0.04283105954527855,
0.026974499225616455,
-0.034871093928813934,
-0.008790234103798866,
-0.0058198911137878895,
-0.031273771077394485,
0.05787048116326332,
0.015518237836658955,
0.00014920663670636714,
-0.0005393823375925422,
0.02489997074007988,
-0.05163707211613655,
-0.04900987446308136,
-0.007655237801373005,
-0.006351682357490063,
-0.0286747794598341,
-0.006805683486163616,
0.02561253122985363,
-0.00028513703728094697,
0.007855222560465336,
-0.03916759788990021,
-0.01826534792780876,
0.012784600257873535,
-0.04537993669509888,
0.039740629494190216,
-0.023275095969438553,
-0.042027536779642105,
0.011055373586714268,
-0.04675031080842018,
-0.043535057455301285,
0.02143203280866146,
-0.0032387191895395517,
-0.04308890178799629,
-0.0065363431349396706,
-0.017781393602490425,
0.046044446527957916,
-0.026782039552927017,
0.03329794108867645,
0.0035939172375947237,
0.027654334902763367,
-0.043946754187345505,
0.006091329734772444,
0.013057521544396877,
-0.024611523374915123,
-0.007449784316122532,
-0.029138652607798576,
0.0202472060918808,
0.032149892300367355,
0.046431832015514374,
-0.005445287097245455,
0.05363073572516441,
0.0005982705624774098,
0.04115752503275871,
-0.016126198694109917,
-0.0073579708114266396,
0.019687743857502937,
0.004021181724965572,
0.018584728240966797,
-0.010690651834011078,
0.03230128064751625,
-0.012715221382677555,
-0.031178303062915802,
0.010492217727005482,
0.002498830435797572,
0.0013729857746511698,
0.000057355224271304905,
-0.05474719777703285,
-0.03761034086346626,
0.03438962996006012,
0.03202627971768379,
-0.015824012458324432,
-0.058225102722644806,
0.011241300031542778,
0.00014520758122671396,
-0.007218579761683941,
0.09137528389692307,
-0.0043680001981556416,
-0.030325228348374367,
0.009204802103340626,
-0.01434226706624031,
0.011963676661252975,
0.05366028845310211,
0.03236107528209686,
-0.039950188249349594,
-0.02032809890806675,
-0.008507204242050648,
-0.030288754031062126,
0.011865338310599327,
-0.02333908900618553,
0.003310303669422865,
-0.04248266667127609,
0.006552558857947588,
0.019047440961003304,
0.041094861924648285,
-0.023402703925967216,
-0.011486344039440155,
0.012585209682583809,
-0.009069327265024185,
0.0030221526976674795,
0.046838268637657166,
0.01950429007411003,
-0.008264044299721718,
0.02537638507783413,
0.05605009198188782,
0.005293447524309158,
0.03777218610048294,
-0.022381266579031944,
0.02692384086549282,
-0.02155187912285328,
0.04114815220236778,
0.0012719997903332114,
-0.019646387547254562,
0.006742136087268591,
-0.013567776419222355,
0.07815099507570267,
-0.031020358204841614,
0.03716329112648964,
0.048716407269239426,
-0.0020470954477787018,
-0.002589849289506674,
0.027331748977303505,
0.007193850353360176,
0.04148445650935173,
-0.03377426788210869,
-0.04072318226099014,
-0.008613265119493008,
0.02490558847784996,
-0.024299366399645805,
-0.00824638269841671,
-0.03325074538588524,
-0.017551248893141747,
0.025616776198148727,
-0.050228603184223175,
0.02371930703520775,
0.013563933782279491,
0.07656995952129364,
-0.017727550119161606,
-0.00040261319372802973,
0.004049774259328842,
0.0224732868373394,
-0.01678803376853466,
0.005629232153296471,
0.009005408734083176,
0.021863114088773727,
-0.010527006350457668,
-0.03196483477950096,
0.02267957106232643,
0.053154509514570236,
-0.045285921543836594,
-0.02440912276506424,
0.0012966640060767531,
0.034624725580215454,
0.014910424128174782,
-0.03793447092175484,
0.004988599568605423,
0.030957195907831192,
0.005148343276232481,
-0.028102409094572067,
-0.019404366612434387,
-0.0032761627808213234,
0.007299900054931641,
0.004886014387011528,
-0.030568309128284454,
0.0002997321425937116,
-0.012287632562220097,
0.017009085044264793
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:12
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
Question: - do me the courtesy of looking at paragraph 318 and tell me what its opening words are?
Answer: "In the morning."
Question: "In the morning Bob drove away"
Answer: Right.
Question: You're just constructing arguments to try and persuade the Court that the truth.
Answer: No you said to me...
Then at line 38:-
"Question: So your lengthy dissertation on driving at night when you've been drinking doesn't really...
Answer: That's correct it doesn't apply.
Question: ...assist does it?
Answer: No it doesn't but it certainly applies in terms of working drinking and working in the shed.
63This in my view illustrates his argumentative nature.
64There are other more serious matters. In his affidavit of 22 September 2009, paragraph 25 the plaintiff, referring to a discharge of a mortgage to the ANZ Bank over the property at 30 River Road Harwood owned by Ms Mulcahy and her son Wade, said as follows:-
On the basis that the property has been re-mortgaged and the bank required all parties' signatures prior to discharge I believe that someone forged my signature on the Discharge Authority.
65The mortgage had been re-financed with the Bendigo Bank Limited.
At T598, line 9:-
Question: And you have taken care to make sure that everything in your affidavit was true?
Answer: Yes.
Line 12:-
Question: Where is the forgery of your signature, a signature that purports to be that of you, Robert Cooper?
Line 17:-
Answer: It's not there,
Line 21:-
Answer: No it doesn't exist.
At T599, line 4:-
Question: Do you still maintain there's been a forgery?
Answer: No I do not.
66There was no re-examination of the plaintiff in respect of this matter.
67It was submitted that this exemplifies a sworn allegation of criminal conduct that was patently untrue and shows how much was required to get just one frank admission of an obvious truth from this witness. In my view it exemplifies a careless attitude to evidence.
68An example of a tendency to exaggerate appears starting at T605, line 26 - 40. The plaintiff was asked questions about paragraph 516 of his affidavit of 4 November 2010 where he deposed he "spent many nights with her in Brisbane and we had a full and active sexual life" after 24 September 2007 the date of separation.
T605, line 43:-
Question: That was the date (24 September 2007) you deposited Ms Mulcahy in Brisbane for dental treatment?
Answer: I think that was the day yes.
Question: That is true is it? That by her invitation you spent many nights with her in Brisbane.
Answer: Yes I did.
T606, line 1:-
Question: Could I suggest to you that in an email on 7 August 2008 you wrote these words
"Think about how many times you invited me to come and see you and spend some time with you. Grand total since October once."
Your words or not?
Answer: Yes my words.
(the period involved was some 10 months).
69It was submitted the plaintiff was caught out lying in an affidavit. He went on later in evidence to give an explanation, which was a most curious interpretation of "invitation" given his use of the word invitation in his email. Plainly he was exaggerating.
70The plaintiff's conduct in an attempt to settle the case shows that he is quite capable of attempting to gain an advantage by not disclosing the whole circumstances. At T588, line 25, Cooper agreed that he had his then solicitors file a Notice of Ceasing to Act on 31 August 2010.
This was 20 days after the $30 million lottery win. At T588, line 27, Cooper agreed he came to Sydney to negotiate a settlement on his own behalf with the solicitor representing the defendant. At T591, in answer to question as to why he elected to undertake his own defence at lines 5 - 10, the plaintiff replied:-
For various reasons I was, I believed I was facing bankruptcy. I was facing losing the relationship which I held very strongly with my new partner, now my wife, caused by, I believed a deliberate attempt to - and in fact it was a stated attempt that I was going to be bought to my knees and if that involved me being sent bankrupt, well so be it and it was at that point.
At T591, line 10:-
|
[
-0.017097080126404762,
0.04301827400922775,
-0.01519281417131424,
-0.022195011377334595,
-0.009763414040207863,
-0.04353375732898712,
0.007886307314038277,
-0.020266007632017136,
-0.0029267622157931328,
-0.006139835808426142,
-0.020927779376506805,
0.05221353471279144,
-0.014610663056373596,
-0.017522094771265984,
-0.004625014029443264,
-0.02447064220905304,
0.028949012979865074,
-0.0357605516910553,
-0.018786346539855003,
-0.021299170330166817,
-0.012773185968399048,
0.005842532496899366,
0.08220843225717545,
0.038642093539237976,
0.017977219074964523,
0.033361829817295074,
-0.022079937160015106,
0.007769462186843157,
0.02356415055692196,
-0.011567167937755585,
0.02192395180463791,
-0.03885606303811073,
0.001975787803530693,
-0.031041869893670082,
0.024065310135483742,
0.020564530044794083,
0.013031496666371822,
0.009579991921782494,
-0.029933705925941467,
0.017768248915672302,
0.014816174283623695,
0.032240863889455795,
0.0072341724298894405,
-0.02095991186797619,
0.03900320455431938,
-0.02648584358394146,
0.010687476955354214,
-0.010634062811732292,
0.008060568943619728,
0.021780943498015404,
-0.02431773580610752,
-0.008557175286114216,
0.05949138477444649,
0.027443721890449524,
-0.014773069880902767,
0.031126925721764565,
-0.006664359010756016,
-0.009369457140564919,
-0.04977833479642868,
-0.025477338582277298,
0.010149450972676277,
-0.037490274757146835,
-0.013311459682881832,
-0.029408913105726242,
-0.04612196236848831,
0.09064140915870667,
-0.007708219811320305,
0.01276728417724371,
-0.011659025214612484,
-0.04856383800506592,
-0.0041599883697927,
0.006707364227622747,
0.015878301113843918,
-0.021007977426052094,
-0.10262743383646011,
0.0054336716420948505,
0.009343582205474377,
0.04258599877357483,
-0.019310805946588516,
0.06921481341123581,
0.035280369222164154,
0.019554320722818375,
-0.012293285690248013,
0.010775885544717312,
-0.05882112681865692,
-0.029956722632050514,
-0.03500388190150261,
0.04297768697142601,
-0.015722762793302536,
-0.019528919830918312,
-0.033574655652046204,
0.011587156914174557,
0.03654324263334274,
-0.08315413445234299,
-0.0063324132934212685,
-0.015160948969423771,
-0.06219470128417015,
0.01777593046426773,
-0.012854640372097492,
0.04165687412023544,
0.05072301998734474,
0.011410420760512352,
0.005685378797352314,
-0.0320260226726532,
-0.01201691199094057,
-0.005470047704875469,
0.007463879883289337,
0.030319705605506897,
0.012669886462390423,
-0.012102894484996796,
0.005914807319641113,
0.002259255386888981,
0.023991676047444344,
0.027559565380215645,
0.002115448471158743,
0.003275491064414382,
-0.007869761437177658,
-0.039957769215106964,
0.0164489708840847,
0.0069594429805874825,
0.03137422725558281,
0.03324158489704132,
0.029794415459036827,
-0.025918925181031227,
-0.05836771801114082,
0.006461832206696272,
-0.013704989105463028,
0.03932328149676323,
-0.03250429034233093,
0.0038150781765580177,
-0.026118462905287743,
-0.0002150251530110836,
-0.011490111239254475,
-0.06043267250061035,
-0.049223899841308594,
-0.0009969932725653052,
0.06697896122932434,
-0.0008478346862830222,
0.013193919323384762,
-0.051026541739702225,
0.028541527688503265,
0.014783239923417568,
0.03860102593898773,
-0.02337264083325863,
0.02835862524807453,
-0.05477583035826683,
0.028862081468105316,
-0.034437526017427444,
-0.03343570977449417,
-0.009815477766096592,
0.015504497103393078,
0.0070907920598983765,
0.019737761467695236,
0.009895764291286469,
0.044485773891210556,
-0.04824117571115494,
0.028557542711496353,
0.0003541623882483691,
0.02061733976006508,
0.017889907583594322,
-0.01508754026144743,
0.017019744962453842,
-0.029725125059485435,
-0.032567016780376434,
-0.0140962153673172,
-0.0038617788814008236,
0.004384986124932766,
0.02431679703295231,
-0.04043203592300415,
-0.0421319417655468,
0.015318569727241993,
-0.0026495822239667177,
0.0288644190877676,
-0.029910828918218613,
0.023731036111712456,
0.016466718167066574,
0.06534065306186676,
0.003927878104150295,
0.010316765867173672,
-0.048659492284059525,
-0.014002024196088314,
0.03314904496073723,
-0.0034017027355730534,
0.0037861960008740425,
-0.00978072825819254,
0.008155111223459244,
-0.00557028129696846,
-0.012712156400084496,
0.016064928844571114,
-0.015847787261009216,
-0.012059279717504978,
-0.04413756728172302,
0.018942583352327347,
0.012344777584075928,
-0.007744763977825642,
-0.022562826052308083,
0.019602717831730843,
-0.031897976994514465,
0.01849629543721676,
-0.03023413009941578,
-0.007362683769315481,
0.038593925535678864,
0.06569872796535492,
-0.019806141033768654,
0.003167523769661784,
-0.0028316215611994267,
-0.04857873544096947,
-0.01580009236931801,
0.036825019866228104,
-0.023876698687672615,
0.027695082128047943,
-0.013863160274922848,
0.01896105520427227,
0.05053718015551567,
0.003601835109293461,
0.006665028166025877,
0.01128690131008625,
-0.01421942189335823,
0.039339613169431686,
0.011150289326906204,
-0.021171169355511665,
0.008921027183532715,
0.015575351193547249,
-0.02281969040632248,
-0.001085100113414228,
0.030773114413022995,
-0.0052191391587257385,
0.0428321473300457,
-0.01664699986577034,
-0.0644061341881752,
0.054011669009923935,
0.006297399755567312,
0.0012933517573401332,
-0.01193892303854227,
0.0031117433682084084,
0.026783684268593788,
0.024122124537825584,
0.03530101105570793,
0.013499647378921509,
-0.011319334618747234,
-0.03728940337896347,
-0.0132234375923872,
0.006710469722747803,
-0.031438618898391724,
0.014004582539200783,
-0.0255522932857275,
-0.0015134565765038133,
0.01927424967288971,
0.010651679709553719,
-0.004911597818136215,
-0.015792693942785263,
-0.046370070427656174,
-0.013969555497169495,
-0.0063554816879332066,
0.027916034683585167,
0.03192847594618797,
0.05046764388680458,
0.01617260091006756,
0.03537936881184578,
0.016726918518543243,
0.037331946194171906,
0.017975669354200363,
0.030088329687714577,
0.017084874212741852,
-0.008526339195668697,
-0.011453360319137573,
-0.05681523680686951,
-0.04215465858578682,
-0.024322835728526115,
-0.010228957049548626,
0.03387000784277916,
0.01135062612593174,
-0.019496256485581398,
-0.03575437515974045,
0.030029887333512306,
0.009405518881976604,
0.0115868104621768,
-0.07668541371822357,
0.005492457654327154,
0.0013248131144791842,
0.03636382147669792,
0.027434276416897774,
0.0029793630819767714,
-0.016185790300369263,
0.008042617700994015,
0.012716537341475487,
0.021925216540694237,
-0.02428305335342884,
0.014282841235399246,
-0.020390335470438004,
-0.01166900061070919,
-0.0063742781057953835,
0.04362223669886589,
0.014642439782619476,
-0.02234574593603611,
-0.03646411746740341,
-0.012614087201654911,
-0.15471144020557404,
0.014780113473534584,
0.022871635854244232,
-0.00844120979309082,
0.006372450385242701,
0.03839043527841568,
-0.014594403095543385,
0.02022513747215271,
-0.0302178543061018,
-0.02060423418879509,
0.02469559758901596,
-0.05838404968380928,
-0.014043894596397877,
0.01878991350531578,
-0.006736032664775848,
-0.02330675907433033,
-0.00009762097761267796,
0.018195562064647675,
0.018199902027845383,
-0.032374057918787,
0.021462026983499527,
-0.0007978815701790154,
0.05216459557414055,
-0.0021889768540859222,
0.0016890353290364146,
0.010833591222763062,
0.020319582894444466,
-0.003920345101505518,
-0.015084563754498959,
-0.03564624488353729,
-0.03691939264535904,
-0.020625198259949684,
-0.01922045648097992,
0.011205514892935753,
0.009690692648291588,
0.07237543910741806,
0.01006238628178835,
-0.05943723022937775,
-0.04962208867073059,
-0.03703489899635315,
0.0046849921345710754,
0.04933204874396324,
-0.04493730515241623,
0.04222089424729347,
0.017861399799585342,
-0.018892765045166016,
0.020559772849082947,
-0.026212526485323906,
-0.05314459279179573,
0.003362312214449048,
-0.012378302402794361,
0.00721356738358736,
-0.02233383059501648,
0.0007634334033355117,
-0.008109156973659992,
-0.024378109723329544,
0.03776682913303375,
0.07797516137361526,
-0.02416711486876011,
0.017562301829457283,
0.006895208731293678,
-0.05469692125916481,
0.04139849171042442,
0.015455186367034912,
-0.03616680949926376,
-0.020717769861221313,
-0.0029217794071882963,
0.009256409481167793,
-0.03381546959280968,
0.007231186144053936,
0.04438367113471031,
-0.017622357234358788,
0.00689831143245101,
0.019202925264835358,
-0.004049436654895544,
0.021282503381371498,
-0.0104782460257411,
-0.037952616810798645,
-0.00017895930795930326,
-0.12010281533002853,
0.03150152042508125,
0.006985812447965145,
-0.0077743129804730415,
0.007844911888241768,
0.010960537940263748,
-0.004237212240695953,
0.003280828008428216,
-0.014375095255672932,
0.00329469027929008,
0.25967901945114136,
0.013439903035759926,
-0.023287830874323845,
0.00022519132471643388,
0.028018750250339508,
-0.027124248445034027,
-0.016020972281694412,
0.027719732373952866,
0.018046565353870392,
-0.03839318826794624,
-0.0018055086256936193,
0.0016863829223439097,
0.0010199707467108965,
0.024488652125000954,
-0.0672096461057663,
0.014858447015285492,
-0.04344341903924942,
-0.02717461809515953,
0.0746467113494873,
0.01843496784567833,
0.022797895595431328,
-0.020144781097769737,
0.011069006286561489,
0.018782230094075203,
-0.04871286824345589,
-0.0329614095389843,
0.044778913259506226,
0.014580363407731056,
-0.0008522418793290854,
0.03141133859753609,
-0.05490412563085556,
-0.0030682827346026897,
-0.0067572216503322124,
-0.018164020031690598,
0.019204935058951378,
0.03595039248466492,
-0.004518354777246714,
0.018155546858906746,
-0.07586954534053802,
0.05550416558980942,
0.003906572237610817,
-0.02497490681707859,
-0.03704635053873062,
-0.03571901470422745,
-0.013025659136474133,
-0.0017185957403853536,
-0.003951690159738064,
0.01428486779332161,
-0.06994973868131638,
0.02391236461699009,
0.007235030643641949,
0.011166460812091827,
-0.017473392188549042,
0.029789891093969345,
-0.024506021291017532,
0.03201853111386299,
0.007693210616707802,
0.024659035727381706,
-0.01519626472145319,
0.04969470575451851,
-0.05681507661938667,
0.027922824025154114,
-0.02385888248682022,
0.03582831844687462,
-0.016692791134119034,
-0.004499872215092182,
-0.03101932443678379,
-0.03416774049401283,
0.05722863972187042,
0.010019895620644093,
0.028075166046619415,
0.0012744999257847667,
0.03179611265659332,
0.04043102636933327,
0.03542759642004967,
0.02537272498011589,
-0.02208603173494339,
0.01588633470237255,
-0.01831456460058689,
0.02095324732363224,
-0.00608551362529397,
-0.04532769322395325,
-0.004292923025786877,
-0.01153478492051363,
0.012792136520147324,
0.0017103764694184065,
-0.03185019642114639,
0.058120377361774445,
0.02573898248374462,
-0.0030393179040402174,
-0.021583184599876404,
-0.01870546117424965,
-0.009041973389685154,
-0.012489412911236286,
0.021636078134179115,
0.014047487638890743,
0.030041277408599854,
-0.0001583946286700666,
-0.00008112993236863986,
-0.03016723319888115,
0.000644783372990787,
-0.009511209093034267,
0.0394454300403595,
-0.033640652894973755,
0.056129153817892075,
-0.01697523333132267,
-0.020426059141755104,
-0.05457645282149315,
-0.0459672249853611,
-0.007850101217627525,
-0.00952244084328413,
0.03851178288459778,
-0.010903638787567616,
0.011311599053442478,
0.02915160544216633,
0.06599799543619156,
0.0071770865470170975,
0.010110166855156422,
0.060139250010252,
0.04160654917359352,
-0.03366037830710411,
-0.022964920848608017,
-0.017627043649554253,
0.008534866385161877,
-0.04191610962152481,
0.020677680149674416,
-0.013439280912280083,
-0.014694452285766602,
-0.003880657022818923,
0.017627891153097153,
-0.0117501774802804,
-0.022573988884687424,
-0.054518360644578934,
-0.021043580025434494,
0.07356368750333786,
0.007381136994808912,
0.06634610146284103,
-0.0075058708898723125,
-0.051877643913030624,
0.018726974725723267,
0.010252929292619228,
-0.008156942203640938,
-0.007371218875050545,
-0.008749929256737232,
0.016761034727096558,
0.03360306844115257,
-0.08728758990764618,
0.008501977659761906,
-0.03541824594140053,
-0.008844121359288692,
0.03133634477853775,
0.009985591284930706,
-0.04775169864296913,
-0.05569535493850708,
0.002343488624319434,
-0.011042306199669838,
-0.025633972138166428,
-0.013420823961496353,
0.033388957381248474,
-0.015863938257098198,
0.0142581881955266,
0.018669964745640755,
-0.0036482983268797398,
0.05622534081339836,
0.019287273287773132,
0.03049604594707489,
0.005176893901079893,
0.061686448752880096,
0.023635750636458397,
-0.0019120239885523915,
-0.017727870494127274,
-0.007933024317026138,
-0.004575362894684076,
0.026254871860146523,
0.03650182485580444,
0.04124152660369873,
-0.01560546737164259,
-0.0278460755944252,
-0.01341569609940052,
-0.026453353464603424,
-0.02413838729262352,
0.02379566617310047,
-0.027916308492422104,
0.029366016387939453,
-0.028186099603772163,
-0.012757017277181149,
0.046221837401390076,
-0.011813538148999214,
0.02095464989542961,
-0.05592988431453705,
-0.01067525614053011,
0.09706711769104004,
-0.015465741977095604,
-0.005127940326929092,
-0.0025232702028006315,
0.007626722101122141,
0.032390955835580826,
0.03161356970667839,
0.0026181191205978394,
-0.02643076702952385,
0.02388768643140793,
0.015738733112812042,
0.0069509269669651985,
0.06325989961624146,
0.009074116125702858,
-0.04292912036180496,
0.0011541979620233178,
0.016865313053131104,
-0.009096682071685791,
-0.052609432488679886,
0.02253413200378418,
0.008547716774046421,
-0.034782372415065765,
-0.011446109041571617,
0.01048195082694292,
-0.005230707582086325,
0.027639849111437798,
0.051652297377586365,
0.024004369974136353,
-0.0766955316066742,
-0.015532327815890312,
-0.032909590750932693,
0.0273964311927557,
-0.09891735017299652,
0.006492109037935734,
-0.03309956192970276,
-0.05193068087100983,
-0.030124738812446594,
-0.022117188200354576,
-0.015461175702512264,
0.00312603241764009,
-0.029408041387796402,
0.051677215844392776,
-0.0004867765528615564,
0.015019090846180916,
-0.029501717537641525,
0.008304355666041374,
0.006889207288622856,
0.040259771049022675,
-0.002247493714094162,
-0.03329632058739662,
-0.008334946818649769,
0.04538588598370552,
0.03865458071231842,
-0.009395015425980091,
0.008043091744184494,
-0.013229417614638805,
0.0015444305026903749,
0.02837555855512619,
0.024322614073753357,
-0.006520176772028208,
0.025333603844046593,
0.01820673607289791,
-0.042294926941394806,
0.03732398524880409,
-0.002280210144817829,
0.017125975340604782,
-0.005150387063622475,
-0.024181170389056206,
-0.021647963672876358,
0.01466981042176485,
0.04685184732079506,
-0.03308466449379921,
-0.045083340257406235,
-0.037858519703149796,
-0.07078211009502411,
0.01344899833202362,
-0.011799651198089123,
-0.012001851573586464,
-0.033555760979652405,
-0.02543765865266323,
0.0034614417236298323,
-0.008372821845114231,
-0.006765225902199745,
0.010365229099988937,
0.022235048934817314,
0.013795590028166771,
0.02428695186972618,
0.08510583639144897,
-0.005504364613443613,
0.019992444664239883,
0.05490051209926605,
0.05639708787202835,
0.05166109651327133,
-0.01608864963054657,
0.012960785999894142,
0.04467134550213814,
0.017136961221694946,
0.02103392779827118,
-0.028851864859461784,
0.024178821593523026,
0.023103905841708183,
-0.048522286117076874,
0.011537645012140274,
-0.02494509145617485,
0.016813842579722404,
-0.0010098767234012485,
0.061303891241550446,
-0.027122672647237778,
0.038812506943941116,
-0.0029486441053450108,
-0.0011185093317180872,
-0.03760671243071556,
-0.004770578350871801,
0.017460897564888,
0.0257626511156559,
0.007365950383245945,
-0.050022561103105545,
0.013231909833848476,
0.025445682927966118,
0.03234703838825226,
-0.0860050842165947,
-0.04488079622387886,
-0.03495507314801216,
0.008001095615327358,
0.02163778617978096,
0.010535978712141514,
0.005773871671408415,
0.000059960402722936124,
0.01942739635705948,
0.018003111705183983,
0.011696450412273407,
-0.060634151101112366,
0.00985498446971178,
-0.03882276639342308,
0.03258228674530983,
0.02376585453748703,
0.0031904191710054874,
-0.013049709610641003,
-0.006545850541442633,
-0.006302713416516781,
-0.05632309243083,
-0.023808950558304787,
0.015436968766152859,
0.03309784084558487,
0.048140138387680054,
0.004859802778810263,
-0.030382364988327026,
0.01915188692510128,
-0.03650498762726784,
-0.006227494217455387,
-0.010670778341591358,
0.09029174596071243,
-0.02445322647690773,
0.015169723890721798,
-0.03028300404548645,
0.002224096329882741,
-0.008147217333316803,
0.012774412520229816,
0.017112409695982933,
-0.024867022410035133,
-0.0012036878615617752,
-0.018137646839022636,
-0.01698319800198078,
0.04244416207075119,
0.022083893418312073,
-0.0187721848487854,
0.0321674682199955,
-0.009936909191310406,
0.022145286202430725,
-0.0020782339852303267,
0.011141196824610233,
0.0033017511013895273,
-0.02437177300453186,
-0.016683978959918022,
0.014638680033385754,
-0.00999273918569088,
0.04549899697303772,
-0.02181357331573963,
-0.030078314244747162,
0.017113713547587395,
0.026667898520827293,
0.06442507356405258,
0.013736842200160027,
-0.037203483283519745,
0.041299473494291306,
-0.0007467959658242762,
-0.006932737305760384,
-0.007601555436849594,
-0.0344560369849205,
0.006415700074285269,
-0.036769330501556396,
-0.016407575458288193,
-0.02325293980538845,
-0.007584890816360712,
-0.016687218099832535,
-0.016206039115786552,
0.03896753862500191,
-0.0174986831843853,
0.027177026495337486,
-0.03361567482352257,
0.019662657752633095,
-0.03618908300995827,
0.022455060854554176,
-0.15500573813915253,
0.013798446394503117,
0.027799172326922417,
-0.03161045163869858,
-0.055246662348508835,
0.017360206693410873,
-0.054232846945524216,
-0.03723471611738205,
-0.03101242147386074,
0.00525662349537015,
-0.021975437179207802,
0.02108420431613922,
-0.03361599147319794,
-0.017371168360114098,
-0.10082467645406723,
0.024603549391031265,
-0.008837359957396984,
-0.027175424620509148,
-0.04752759635448456,
-0.004681823775172234,
-0.011292877607047558,
-0.008743193000555038,
-0.028499962761998177,
-0.00784912146627903,
-0.018079029396176338,
-0.006636866834014654,
0.008765078149735928,
-0.044954437762498856,
-0.029546890407800674,
-0.03262671083211899,
-0.009822183288633823,
-0.021975647658109665,
0.000861103821080178,
0.04717746004462242,
-0.02742169238626957,
-0.007450422737747431,
0.0305276270955801,
-0.010582856833934784,
-0.011681761592626572,
-0.02330147475004196,
-0.027029698714613914,
0.019142556935548782,
-0.051331210881471634,
-0.015928881242871284,
0.045039962977170944,
-0.00747901713475585,
-0.010436279699206352,
0.012480093166232109,
-0.05743473768234253,
-0.04583163559436798,
-0.021524060517549515,
0.02440951019525528,
-0.024380221962928772,
0.0250303503125906,
-0.002260181587189436,
0.017208117991685867,
-0.05595092847943306,
-0.0004413662536535412,
-0.03919169306755066,
0.04645882546901703,
0.0027149058878421783,
0.023893501609563828,
-0.02928619459271431,
0.0021292399615049362,
-0.000559059320949018,
-0.008030794560909271,
-0.02983691170811653,
-0.00655733747407794,
0.0044484818354249,
-0.010785144753754139,
-0.008225546218454838,
-0.012978244572877884,
0.015614141710102558,
0.022537630051374435,
-0.005237790290266275,
0.00724935345351696,
-0.018382010981440544,
-0.0163502786308527,
-0.005470407195389271,
-0.015821993350982666,
-0.031217113137245178,
0.013137218542397022,
-0.016653189435601234,
0.01292227953672409,
-0.008213414810597897,
0.031474992632865906,
-0.000756100460421294,
-0.010970155708491802,
-0.0003716557694133371,
-0.009470649994909763,
-0.0856194943189621,
-0.00495077995583415,
-0.0039091878570616245,
0.04706127941608429,
0.0097430981695652,
0.036651864647865295,
-0.023003941401839256,
0.011767239309847355,
-0.02851150929927826,
-0.008737657219171524,
0.0066937850788235664,
0.002530907979235053,
-0.003680767957121134,
-0.010827536694705486,
-0.025494791567325592,
0.04792500287294388,
0.0051639499142766,
-0.023406043648719788,
0.03475820645689964,
0.0002047909511020407,
0.013531220145523548,
-0.007740465924143791,
-0.01637188345193863,
-0.027969030663371086,
-0.03226526826620102,
0.0012577592860907316,
-0.03872050344944,
0.014942134730517864,
-0.025851314887404442,
-0.002729652216657996,
0.03310876339673996,
-0.007855163887143135,
0.012481803074479103,
-0.015759892761707306,
-0.008906731382012367,
0.02281695418059826,
0.04746836796402931,
-0.00576433539390564,
0.044361334294080734,
-0.004400619305670261,
0.022288663312792778,
-0.010781662538647652,
0.020061086863279343,
0.001124963746406138,
-0.0038649842608720064,
0.024150975048542023,
0.013480334542691708,
0.0060323853977024555,
-0.03333546221256256,
-0.02992858551442623,
0.022917285561561584,
-0.014458113349974155,
0.012421372346580029,
-0.017153466120362282,
-0.04013805091381073,
0.015135427936911583,
0.0376158244907856,
-0.0117338290438056,
-0.04285862669348717,
-0.02811022475361824,
0.022291678935289383,
0.02417728491127491,
0.03810909390449524,
0.05434253811836243,
0.055108923465013504,
0.0005122554139234126,
0.02599618397653103,
-0.007167397066950798,
0.03154638409614563,
0.060753654688596725,
-0.0211069006472826,
-0.041965000331401825,
0.014003787189722061,
-0.026624662801623344,
-0.0189050305634737,
0.03150654956698418,
-0.024088095873594284,
0.01149743515998125,
-0.01845833845436573,
0.006835347972810268,
0.010121414437890053,
-0.003917722962796688,
-0.006853095255792141,
-0.02415846846997738,
0.035426631569862366,
0.008090820163488388,
-0.01308636274188757,
-0.04986729472875595,
0.06704404950141907,
-0.015893472358584404,
0.037802550941705704,
0.010241474956274033,
0.03206760436296463,
0.002782614668831229,
-0.01802968606352806,
0.05988624691963196,
-0.005419475492089987,
0.0029152671340852976,
0.013154308311641216,
-0.006915016565471888,
0.01850803755223751,
-0.010489273816347122,
0.028534729033708572,
-0.010803579352796078,
0.038692407310009,
-0.007597629446536303,
-0.040898509323596954,
0.03176518529653549,
-0.010122300125658512,
-0.010778037831187248,
0.027553657069802284,
-0.015945609658956528,
-0.028689784929156303,
-0.029137244448065758,
0.00403981376439333,
-0.004598499275743961,
0.027199333533644676,
-0.059510864317417145,
-0.03291470929980278,
0.0377500019967556,
-0.022639187052845955,
-0.0016763746971264482,
-0.014119796454906464,
-0.006017166189849377,
-0.012258549220860004,
0.010144609026610851,
0.014433179050683975,
-0.016231143847107887,
0.009551011957228184,
-0.014665494672954082,
0.03531819209456444,
0.060413558036088943,
-0.027441151440143585,
-0.02037729322910309,
0.015442066825926304,
0.0008063310524448752,
-0.0851130560040474,
0.023884611204266548,
-0.010696292854845524,
-0.011891788803040981,
-0.06265176832675934,
-0.00499002356082201,
-0.01527298241853714,
0.03447127714753151,
0.02322705276310444,
-0.009889460168778896,
-0.045183245092630386,
-0.033047351986169815,
-0.053304217755794525,
0.0046907756477594376,
-0.01305670291185379,
-0.003731090808287263,
0.021142497658729553,
0.017343226820230484
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:27
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
306. I was at a loss as to how to deal with situation.
148Although I accept the defendants evidence but given the lack of evidence about the effect on the defendant I am not satisfied it constitutes an assault. I note the cross examination of the defendant in these terms:
At T260.40 is this question and answer:
Q: But in respect of what is asserted there in paragraph 304 there was no threat made by Mr Cooper at that time was there?
A: At that particular juncture, no
10. Alleged assault in mid 2007 (threat to shoot)
149The evidence given was as follows at T319-320:
Q I will put my question to you again: are you able to identify by approximate date any other instance similar which involved the mention of rifles?
A. Yes.
Q. When was that?
A. That was in it -- -- I can't give you an exact date but it was March or April 2007.
Q. Where did it occur?
A. At Harwood, at our home in Harwood.
Q. In what context?
A. Bob and I had -- Bob was working at the phone shops and he was complaining about the staff and about the area. Things were pretty bad. And he continually said things like "I am a big fish in a little pond" and I turned around to him and said "We are only shop keepers after all", which I regretted, straight away.
And he said -- he just flew off. I can't recall other things he said but he was yelling at me, walking in and out, yelling. And he said once again "This is frustrating that shit out of me. I really should get rid of the rifles. I will either shoot myself, because I am going nuts, or shoot you."
Q. What effect did that have on you and your recollection?
A. It is a terrifying thing to hear. There were other instances that he said similar things.
150This alleged incident was first referred to at the trial when further evidence was given following an almost completed cross-examination of the defendant. It was never referred to in consultation with doctors. Plainly it was only recalled as a result of further questioning about paragraph 310 of her affidavit. That said, it has the ring of truth about it.
151I accept her evidence and it must have been very surprising given that there had been no instances of serious abuse for some seven years. I can accept that it may have terrified her. I am satisfied there was an assault.
Effect of assaults
152I turn to the question of what effect the assaults may have in the adjustment process. Plainly events after separation are not relevant and on this aspect of the case questions of the Limitation Act 1969 do not arise.
The defendant relied on inter alia two cases under the Family Law Act 1975, Doherty v Doherty (1996) FLC 92-652 and Marando v Marando (1997) FLC 92-754. In the first of these cases the Full Court said at page 82,683:-
"On page 26 the trial Judge made reference to the appellant's drinking habits and to domestic violence and aggression, which he exhibited towards the respondent and the children, particularly to S. Although the trial Judge did no more than record these events, it is clear from his findings that the wife's contribution as homemaker and parent may have been increased as a result thereof.
Although the domestic violence complained of related to a relatively small period of time at the end of the marriage, nevertheless, his Honour would, in my opinion, have been entitled to have found that because of the appellant's conduct,
the respondent's contribution diminished as a consequence, leading to the overall weighting based upon contribution in favour of the wife being increased, albeit only slightly, having regard to the facts of this case."
153Of interest is the reference to such conduct either increasing one party's contribution or diminishing the other party's contribution.
154In Marando v Marando at 84,168-9 Gee J had the following to say about the issue of domestic violence.
|
[
-0.021280650049448013,
0.03485782444477081,
-0.06192688271403313,
0.011574449017643929,
0.029656628146767616,
-0.045388657599687576,
0.011828567832708359,
0.06736800074577332,
-0.005857962183654308,
0.011927837505936623,
-0.014395017176866531,
0.06051504239439964,
-0.05121887847781181,
0.004094517789781094,
-0.011144776828587055,
0.006590722128748894,
0.025630241259932518,
-0.03368803858757019,
-0.014413341879844666,
-0.03831733018159866,
-0.03688531741499901,
0.0184000413864851,
0.028948919847607613,
0.020175665616989136,
-0.0057043167762458324,
0.019761737436056137,
-0.020806442946195602,
-0.007038668729364872,
-0.019016236066818237,
0.02660941332578659,
-0.011602010577917099,
-0.020713962614536285,
0.029672063887119293,
-0.005502783693373203,
-0.032134298235177994,
-0.000829013588372618,
-0.0009822722058743238,
-0.03497249260544777,
-0.01817077025771141,
0.024063175544142723,
-0.004278316628187895,
0.022175855934619904,
-0.0039031882770359516,
-0.03216854855418205,
0.012961708009243011,
-0.024689817801117897,
-0.005499959923326969,
-0.02949777990579605,
-0.013618376106023788,
0.010612125508487225,
0.011582138948142529,
-0.02014549821615219,
0.03981475532054901,
0.0038179249968379736,
0.00032123661367222667,
0.0751996636390686,
0.0015830034390091896,
0.00322432117536664,
-0.03327671065926552,
-0.028921160846948624,
-0.049620505422353745,
-0.03579459711909294,
-0.0011333568254485726,
-0.024112192913889885,
-0.016830697655677795,
0.08395542204380035,
-0.01125047542154789,
-0.0236611720174551,
-0.012624163180589676,
-0.040530987083911896,
0.017862267792224884,
-0.014184772968292236,
-0.0020600357092916965,
-0.02231735736131668,
-0.090728759765625,
0.009116219356656075,
0.009203123860061169,
0.014445440843701363,
-0.023916438221931458,
0.018629081547260284,
0.04267216473817825,
0.02435440383851528,
0.026373978704214096,
-0.0013008901150897145,
-0.0037526716478168964,
0.005646187346428633,
-0.02861211821436882,
-0.008646761067211628,
0.0196249857544899,
-0.014427314512431622,
-0.0024664727970957756,
0.00914197601377964,
0.020537540316581726,
-0.027932358905673027,
-0.023320158943533897,
0.015545008704066277,
-0.04596317932009697,
0.010649931617081165,
-0.030665097758173943,
0.002436949172988534,
-0.01133274007588625,
0.019988464191555977,
0.0008232812397181988,
-0.06106314808130264,
0.03192420303821564,
0.0034356804098933935,
0.04788186773657799,
0.037410758435726166,
0.027234777808189392,
0.0008490682230331004,
-0.003842904232442379,
0.01506789866834879,
0.006158745381981134,
0.027538562193512917,
-0.010017619468271732,
-0.0034711973275989294,
0.016581445932388306,
-0.040443193167448044,
-0.0003531825786922127,
-0.02199731580913067,
0.06009130924940109,
0.025691067799925804,
0.04587231203913689,
-0.027613015845417976,
-0.04156375303864479,
0.03510427102446556,
-0.003644953016191721,
0.0028103895019739866,
-0.027388228103518486,
0.03199908137321472,
-0.00577450031414628,
-0.01279020868241787,
-0.03092939592897892,
-0.07592284679412842,
0.002346571534872055,
-0.012566441670060158,
0.05154038965702057,
0.03213284909725189,
0.03942752256989479,
-0.017101556062698364,
0.04147029668092728,
-0.0019680270925164223,
0.021130342036485672,
0.0028884976636618376,
0.009474396705627441,
-0.02638345956802368,
0.029641631990671158,
-0.03483099490404129,
0.013958873227238655,
-0.005805866792798042,
-0.044147610664367676,
0.007943714037537575,
0.036363374441862106,
-0.020408116281032562,
0.030563320964574814,
-0.033579349517822266,
0.05365033447742462,
0.0031622035894542933,
0.0045316508039832115,
-0.0267197135835886,
0.003317897906526923,
-0.03166297450661659,
-0.03385847061872482,
0.0037447612266987562,
0.0344434417784214,
-0.0013198573142290115,
-0.0032150321640074253,
0.018115129321813583,
-0.011125755496323109,
-0.028060829266905785,
0.0347721129655838,
-0.020654086023569107,
-0.013645083643496037,
-0.011723630130290985,
0.022433407604694366,
0.018174344673752785,
0.03598039969801903,
0.008246775716543198,
0.004698364529758692,
-0.017628466710448265,
-0.03491761162877083,
0.023666154593229294,
0.0011814741883426905,
-0.0021588525269180536,
0.0015557324513792992,
0.011261234991252422,
-0.03761359304189682,
-0.03694133833050728,
0.023352576419711113,
-0.002250846941024065,
-0.02213737741112709,
-0.024812588468194008,
0.012976349331438541,
0.05560281127691269,
0.02015777677297592,
-0.036077987402677536,
0.0232913326472044,
-0.021907422691583633,
0.026436971500515938,
0.007320111617445946,
0.014002388343214989,
0.06684423983097076,
0.037159621715545654,
-0.0013295866083353758,
-0.05395852029323578,
-0.00010475426824996248,
-0.05647417902946472,
-0.004112293012440205,
-0.0014010375598445535,
-0.07303518801927567,
0.02574625425040722,
0.050409335643053055,
0.03186009079217911,
0.052503012120723724,
-0.009156200103461742,
0.02390952967107296,
0.0027107594069093466,
-0.025005456060171127,
0.003422401612624526,
-0.02551274560391903,
-0.0023247343488037586,
-0.0037062671035528183,
0.004396865610033274,
-0.02134690247476101,
-0.0008603864698670805,
0.02001282200217247,
-0.04002831131219864,
0.016535231843590736,
0.011548830196261406,
-0.04208359494805336,
0.05916775390505791,
-0.0070753456093370914,
0.001197619130834937,
-0.01834387518465519,
0.0007771332166157663,
-0.017611633986234665,
0.0024142079055309296,
0.0283485259860754,
0.0370137020945549,
-0.03968895971775055,
0.03319370001554489,
-0.02070925384759903,
0.012914319522678852,
-0.03150910139083862,
0.003734102239832282,
-0.04181205481290817,
0.0010465180967003107,
-0.0013665846781805158,
0.028812145814299583,
-0.00555460574105382,
-0.001249596942216158,
-0.027034223079681396,
-0.016095371916890144,
-0.013564461842179298,
0.03025132417678833,
0.005030838772654533,
0.02148275263607502,
0.0011341762728989124,
0.03288865089416504,
-0.022825093939900398,
-0.0012772235786542296,
0.012562471441924572,
0.021805142983794212,
-0.0010762796737253666,
0.02370215393602848,
-0.018558040261268616,
-0.008732614107429981,
-0.025582458823919296,
-0.03650733083486557,
-0.004341881722211838,
0.02835814654827118,
-0.05881623178720474,
-0.028285209089517593,
-0.030284473672509193,
-0.0002488041063770652,
0.043433185666799545,
0.01254519447684288,
-0.03740592673420906,
0.0065451269038021564,
-0.005305698607116938,
0.035908784717321396,
-0.02241385541856289,
0.026562929153442383,
-0.00525678601115942,
0.0005916014779359102,
-0.01776050589978695,
0.015548604540526867,
-0.06618969142436981,
0.02734844759106636,
-0.0333927683532238,
0.031489282846450806,
-0.006206773221492767,
0.06080951914191246,
-0.016024304553866386,
-0.05676380172371864,
-0.031926192343235016,
-0.006106302607804537,
-0.1471920758485794,
0.02953198179602623,
0.006222001276910305,
0.0033936421386897564,
0.024230076000094414,
0.03384757786989212,
-0.011819795705378056,
0.015347253531217575,
-0.013436871580779552,
-0.00035174854565411806,
-0.009986137971282005,
-0.06148597598075867,
-0.01769312471151352,
0.0051798271015286446,
0.0011726872762665153,
-0.022119037806987762,
-0.016389241442084312,
-0.006762155331671238,
0.054605934768915176,
-0.022256357595324516,
0.03804142773151398,
-0.009993838146328926,
0.02126041054725647,
-0.025203997269272804,
0.001804605359211564,
0.044303882867097855,
0.040078166872262955,
-0.003130891127511859,
-0.014474581927061081,
-0.018576065078377724,
-0.05542312189936638,
-0.05581528693437576,
-0.016581950709223747,
0.06147196143865585,
0.0026330749969929457,
0.07764533162117004,
0.002180455718189478,
-0.06223442777991295,
0.0033165719360113144,
-0.008664089255034924,
0.04924089461565018,
0.012402269057929516,
-0.021336453035473824,
0.006902306340634823,
0.019368333742022514,
-0.08783820271492004,
0.013582764193415642,
-0.02885425090789795,
-0.055241815745830536,
0.034858379513025284,
-0.04641490802168846,
-0.015053599141538143,
-0.05371086299419403,
0.016323614865541458,
-0.0025223272386938334,
-0.004382037092000246,
0.023837463930249214,
0.026509329676628113,
-0.031549520790576935,
0.018238503485918045,
-0.001703754416666925,
-0.07322557270526886,
0.012635418213903904,
0.04452229291200638,
-0.02425377629697323,
-0.02046901360154152,
0.010441857390105724,
0.0229610837996006,
-0.016263574361801147,
-0.01422616746276617,
0.03563143312931061,
-0.06169360876083374,
0.014856583438813686,
0.009276834316551685,
0.03470649570226669,
0.028763944283127785,
0.015632035210728645,
-0.04705719277262688,
0.003738957457244396,
-0.11564838141202927,
0.010037695989012718,
-0.00376494531519711,
-0.01374598778784275,
-0.01368066668510437,
-0.026469441130757332,
0.03688501939177513,
0.026417922228574753,
-0.03416949138045311,
0.021198637783527374,
0.2463138997554779,
0.03425998240709305,
-0.03185136988759041,
0.015195552259683609,
-0.009059462696313858,
0.010898180305957794,
0.051259785890579224,
0.006102423649281263,
0.03979480639100075,
-0.025330759584903717,
-0.018265897408127785,
0.05447802320122719,
-0.01341381948441267,
0.020759182050824165,
-0.05463770031929016,
0.02555706351995468,
-0.04468633607029915,
-0.04430684447288513,
0.05583786591887474,
0.05298375338315964,
0.03512497618794441,
-0.026014016941189766,
0.030202705413103104,
0.011725086718797684,
-0.06674730032682419,
-0.030044641345739365,
-0.0001825477520469576,
0.05222379043698311,
0.02343607135117054,
0.02675357647240162,
-0.05220841243863106,
-0.0053704287856817245,
0.021290190517902374,
-0.026129940524697304,
0.03594861552119255,
0.014372660778462887,
-0.002605915069580078,
-0.017911970615386963,
-0.07451867312192917,
0.01602868176996708,
-0.03176189959049225,
-0.04140179231762886,
-0.035489145666360855,
-0.03506983444094658,
0.00641637435182929,
-0.008703283034265041,
0.005990795325487852,
-0.021090198308229446,
-0.0759403184056282,
0.022128956392407417,
0.030093727633357048,
0.017339851707220078,
-0.004520833026617765,
-0.008463381789624691,
-0.08042781800031662,
0.016290247440338135,
0.0006307553849183023,
-0.0028612713795155287,
-0.036568816751241684,
0.036222729831933975,
0.0038380157202482224,
0.013923784717917442,
-0.0406392440199852,
0.03192908316850662,
-0.003082446288317442,
0.013599010184407234,
-0.026194289326667786,
-0.0024342841934412718,
0.07509047538042068,
-0.008444218896329403,
0.012912246398627758,
0.009204881265759468,
0.005739288404583931,
0.04414035379886627,
0.03507189452648163,
-0.027319757267832756,
-0.008424162864685059,
0.0015087443171069026,
0.012608150020241737,
0.021751614287495613,
-0.04469479247927666,
-0.013507453724741936,
-0.0000685805716784671,
-0.0027133976109325886,
-0.002126693492755294,
0.01723751239478588,
-0.001661307062022388,
0.05276322737336159,
0.012882544659078121,
0.021345531567931175,
-0.002551799174398184,
-0.0032415171153843403,
-0.03693518415093422,
0.009008229710161686,
0.03293180465698242,
-0.01056548673659563,
0.026374178007245064,
0.01019059307873249,
0.0102045563980937,
-0.021393055096268654,
-0.011781261302530766,
0.008585983887314796,
0.06670308113098145,
-0.023838398978114128,
0.007832111790776253,
-0.04712258279323578,
-0.03357880190014839,
-0.02177191525697708,
-0.01326046884059906,
-0.032447610050439835,
-0.03878533095121384,
0.021133629605174065,
-0.008043873123824596,
-0.05497121065855026,
0.05867528170347214,
0.1019672080874443,
-0.04566992446780205,
0.04500514641404152,
0.04358739033341408,
0.013948954641819,
-0.03334621712565422,
0.013586551882326603,
-0.014704403467476368,
0.045703988522291183,
-0.014978326857089996,
0.002973192371428013,
-0.019502293318510056,
-0.022305630147457123,
0.016547895967960358,
0.020877059549093246,
-0.017131619155406952,
-0.032669130712747574,
-0.06213848665356636,
0.0033127134665846825,
0.033414289355278015,
-0.003164606634527445,
0.04879077151417732,
0.0007611887413077056,
-0.0010771551169455051,
-0.013737049885094166,
-0.011616495437920094,
0.017056887969374657,
-0.03407207131385803,
0.005160497035831213,
0.002853226847946644,
0.061776820570230484,
-0.05610550194978714,
-0.01689627580344677,
-0.07595590502023697,
-0.026703916490077972,
0.05421043559908867,
-0.0003010840155184269,
0.0019175945781171322,
-0.030437057837843895,
0.016003966331481934,
-0.019203035160899162,
0.021687699481844902,
-0.003748144954442978,
0.016777658835053444,
-0.021354909986257553,
0.004253860097378492,
-0.022531989961862564,
-0.037225980311632156,
0.03472663089632988,
0.021822046488523483,
0.04496566206216812,
-0.000053820454922970384,
0.05393143743276596,
-0.00853004027158022,
0.006748895160853863,
-0.04701884090900421,
-0.0431896410882473,
-0.028871610760688782,
-0.02373519539833069,
-0.0008533633081242442,
0.006860692054033279,
-0.030209584161639214,
-0.007785735186189413,
0.001617082511074841,
0.0005206099012866616,
0.0036637031007558107,
0.03300807997584343,
0.0014905959833413363,
0.0403970330953598,
-0.029204942286014557,
0.007862217724323273,
0.05441446229815483,
-0.011250548996031284,
0.006758532486855984,
-0.012992343865334988,
0.0006195005844347179,
0.09081326425075531,
-0.017314661294221878,
-0.000647728971671313,
-0.0013002828927710652,
0.00385318067856133,
0.019503122195601463,
0.07234478741884232,
-0.008347077295184135,
-0.03030700795352459,
-0.00962283369153738,
0.0218204278498888,
0.007087268866598606,
0.0021457038819789886,
-0.0027941728476434946,
0.008024526759982109,
0.0173325352370739,
0.030421452596783638,
-0.0342768132686615,
-0.03230557218194008,
-0.0015070918016135693,
-0.01926550082862377,
-0.03947742283344269,
-0.00824573915451765,
-0.0064447615295648575,
-0.0067764571867883205,
0.048617616295814514,
0.012759990990161896,
-0.012230158783495426,
-0.033550143241882324,
0.005032543558627367,
-0.016660679131746292,
0.02824670448899269,
-0.05930225923657417,
-0.020980242639780045,
-0.007869590073823929,
-0.011017372831702232,
-0.03340849652886391,
-0.00645757419988513,
-0.015136106871068478,
0.004289835225790739,
-0.05988342687487602,
0.016638433560729027,
-0.011568992398679256,
0.006464477628469467,
-0.00035868730628862977,
-0.0031262189149856567,
-0.004695584066212177,
0.022983264178037643,
-0.0393751859664917,
0.0249446053057909,
-0.008589331991970539,
-0.02125539630651474,
0.04052918404340744,
-0.04936959967017174,
-0.0003256190102547407,
-0.024881307035684586,
-0.02354337088763714,
0.01290950458496809,
0.04083709418773651,
0.020652281120419502,
0.020030763000249863,
0.007884577848017216,
-0.026942988857626915,
0.006573485676199198,
0.05370881408452988,
0.03225867822766304,
-0.010944797657430172,
-0.048211470246315,
-0.033863365650177,
0.03792975842952728,
0.02335946448147297,
-0.018327035009860992,
-0.016514839604496956,
-0.04975550249218941,
-0.04449774697422981,
0.025186585262417793,
-0.025913653895258904,
-0.020296482369303703,
-0.030719991773366928,
0.0337369367480278,
0.014085071161389351,
-0.02960139513015747,
-0.015874823555350304,
0.0013744896277785301,
0.009242838248610497,
-0.053199950605630875,
0.00416483823210001,
0.05463172495365143,
-0.0161130353808403,
-0.0036227379459887743,
0.034400176256895065,
0.010470608249306679,
0.0636056661605835,
0.010839559137821198,
0.01717659831047058,
0.04234030470252037,
0.022311897948384285,
0.011923487298190594,
-0.03129080310463905,
0.04165073484182358,
-0.007838315330445766,
-0.042980633676052094,
0.0014028687728568912,
0.004289707168936729,
-0.01308286190032959,
-0.017242835834622383,
0.08485892415046692,
-0.025720063596963882,
0.0458872951567173,
-0.009402955882251263,
0.012324945069849491,
-0.04698051139712334,
0.00021500859293155372,
-0.007569918408989906,
0.024655040353536606,
-0.0014279141323640943,
-0.025687526911497116,
-0.016019800677895546,
0.0022764508612453938,
0.04130624607205391,
-0.0747203677892685,
0.0006568923126906157,
-0.048729561269283295,
-0.006897590588778257,
0.008781557902693748,
0.008713644929230213,
-0.013223882764577866,
0.001999017782509327,
-0.002645952859893441,
0.004722920712083578,
-0.024943996220827103,
-0.02746937982738018,
0.016249990090727806,
-0.06887348741292953,
0.03578608110547066,
-0.013202404603362083,
-0.0024295661132782698,
0.0006311137694865465,
0.00032994302455335855,
-0.026631029322743416,
-0.02752705104649067,
-0.02442130446434021,
0.008798409253358841,
0.042791787534952164,
0.016804419457912445,
-0.004551379010081291,
-0.05900898203253746,
0.03010900691151619,
-0.004251767881214619,
-0.04396604374051094,
-0.011112977750599384,
0.09011589735746384,
0.008095476776361465,
-0.01607244461774826,
-0.011270481161773205,
-0.013566063717007637,
0.005330079235136509,
-0.0023598428815603256,
0.03310387581586838,
-0.05264497920870781,
-0.011784067377448082,
-0.07468875497579575,
-0.003192716045305133,
0.051443636417388916,
0.017354222014546394,
-0.013286782428622246,
0.01570267789065838,
0.02152254618704319,
-0.018044890835881233,
-0.0007238700636662543,
0.02297636680305004,
0.0008410168811678886,
-0.0177195742726326,
-0.004360695835202932,
-0.0004885091329924762,
0.0034562794025987387,
0.01235728058964014,
0.016557147726416588,
0.047413937747478485,
0.03549913689494133,
0.017499318346381187,
0.012915602885186672,
0.015363936312496662,
-0.039338670670986176,
0.01634114980697632,
-0.0018897629342973232,
0.017968345433473587,
-0.004726806189864874,
-0.026360735297203064,
-0.015979718416929245,
-0.03859172388911247,
-0.02184380404651165,
-0.011530120857059956,
0.0006386798340827227,
0.023226164281368256,
-0.02424025908112526,
0.020439613610506058,
-0.00692063570022583,
0.04612956941127777,
-0.01635695807635784,
0.0575910247862339,
-0.024838335812091827,
0.057635918259620667,
-0.15217140316963196,
0.023670269176363945,
0.009526428766548634,
-0.0017809135606512427,
-0.05989763140678406,
-0.00882427953183651,
-0.03820564225316048,
0.007897521369159222,
-0.025990985333919525,
0.028450245037674904,
0.030055196955800056,
-0.018489744514226913,
-0.012518946081399918,
-0.017509300261735916,
-0.09094309061765671,
0.03491874039173126,
0.026790283620357513,
-0.019053990021348,
-0.0409882478415966,
0.04901191219687462,
0.014257746748626232,
-0.00387620460242033,
0.02782317064702511,
0.012625021860003471,
0.008103002794086933,
-0.027700770646333694,
-0.024650368839502335,
0.007680521812289953,
-0.04305076599121094,
-0.020935092121362686,
-0.0240690428763628,
-0.04590717330574989,
0.031719036400318146,
0.01023028139024973,
-0.008198398165404797,
-0.00766840809956193,
0.018351009115576744,
-0.029355734586715698,
0.0005351030267775059,
-0.00211630598641932,
0.012290545739233494,
0.024655602872371674,
-0.025800608098506927,
-0.01443308126181364,
0.005226839333772659,
0.03758925572037697,
0.0030828448943793774,
0.006566271185874939,
-0.038562748581171036,
-0.05770053341984749,
-0.0052094897255301476,
0.005518448539078236,
-0.02286323718726635,
0.061989493668079376,
0.015336251817643642,
0.0005872690817341208,
-0.04089098423719406,
-0.014468918554484844,
0.009422678500413895,
0.04708819463849068,
0.01932918094098568,
0.006415023468434811,
-0.029696589335799217,
-0.01105835847556591,
0.030533690005540848,
0.022344930097460747,
-0.0363619364798069,
0.003532272996380925,
-0.03851042315363884,
-0.018832949921488762,
-0.025480983778834343,
-0.019638989120721817,
0.020851943641901016,
0.0036896560341119766,
0.010555685497820377,
0.04377589374780655,
0.006363238673657179,
-0.0028954502195119858,
0.011597288772463799,
-0.0014643619069829583,
-0.006171307992190123,
0.01781654544174671,
-0.011488186195492744,
-0.03520159050822258,
-0.0019678776152431965,
0.019535554572939873,
0.013888110406696796,
-0.024483660236001015,
0.014864765107631683,
-0.006019814871251583,
-0.08311765640974045,
-0.00014505429135169834,
-0.020163826644420624,
0.05706636980175972,
0.009755425155162811,
0.03617403656244278,
-0.023652780801057816,
-0.011651049368083477,
-0.01807229220867157,
0.0256123635917902,
-0.010187823325395584,
-0.03491045907139778,
-0.00024208480317611247,
0.01729987934231758,
-0.018487803637981415,
0.01493727695196867,
-0.007686659228056669,
-0.0021968726068735123,
0.01287162397056818,
-0.03259040787816048,
0.019597485661506653,
-0.019427891820669174,
-0.04939800873398781,
-0.012533473782241344,
-0.037915028631687164,
0.027678443118929863,
0.02997247315943241,
0.03603270277380943,
-0.004291279707103968,
-0.004635009448975325,
0.022776328027248383,
-0.023955846205353737,
0.01733511872589588,
-0.015170152299106121,
-0.033040352165699005,
0.005612063221633434,
0.029823502525687218,
0.02179333195090294,
0.012708324939012527,
-0.012515496462583542,
0.04079653322696686,
-0.008907928131520748,
0.02553117461502552,
0.06690068542957306,
-0.0010651465272530913,
0.0108204809948802,
-0.012244937941432,
-0.004325453191995621,
-0.026595361530780792,
-0.029816551133990288,
0.017346730455756187,
-0.006109484005719423,
0.02051798813045025,
-0.04879820719361305,
-0.03127426654100418,
0.017007211223244667,
-0.0012863854644820094,
0.014240395277738571,
-0.03767523914575577,
-0.006289166398346424,
-0.03347126021981239,
0.015285326167941093,
0.01752149686217308,
0.08304097503423691,
0.002179737202823162,
-0.015888243913650513,
0.0338238887488842,
-0.012295100837945938,
0.010452658869326115,
0.05388735234737396,
0.01375431939959526,
-0.03876125067472458,
-0.023892026394605637,
-0.03293410688638687,
-0.06722857058048248,
0.03284977003931999,
0.0033282143995165825,
-0.02134413830935955,
-0.04236293211579323,
0.01408570446074009,
-0.01977606862783432,
0.011781465262174606,
0.0019647397566586733,
-0.004317408427596092,
0.015835048630833626,
-0.037596963346004486,
-0.012384166941046715,
-0.001112255034968257,
0.02201732061803341,
-0.02919328212738037,
0.03254134953022003,
0.06323292851448059,
0.007402022834867239,
0.015750592574477196,
0.018599500879645348,
0.07082506269216537,
0.01094254944473505,
-0.003478969680145383,
-0.028372252359986305,
0.01477693673223257,
0.0033613620325922966,
-0.021534446626901627,
0.03010737895965576,
-0.024722523987293243,
0.02802259847521782,
0.014159691520035267,
-0.03977810963988304,
0.037398021668195724,
-0.004914821591228247,
0.02341948263347149,
0.04360392689704895,
-0.012011012993752956,
-0.06206795200705528,
-0.013865908607840538,
-0.004853646736592054,
-0.039792515337467194,
0.018082935363054276,
-0.06645280122756958,
-0.023514900356531143,
0.03866353631019592,
-0.04443526640534401,
0.014662278816103935,
0.0002793034946080297,
0.059354133903980255,
0.013773289509117603,
0.018228797242045403,
0.00015470272046513855,
-0.004090031608939171,
0.0322599820792675,
0.012597124092280865,
0.04957538843154907,
0.04782497137784958,
-0.014203852042555809,
-0.04979162663221359,
-0.016390813514590263,
0.0037798553239554167,
-0.013028588145971298,
0.018528321757912636,
0.020829064771533012,
0.0037807468324899673,
-0.0297138299793005,
0.00022023875499144197,
0.014898700639605522,
0.035162441432476044,
0.043202709406614304,
-0.013230249285697937,
-0.005906764417886734,
-0.02050136588513851,
-0.048519477248191833,
0.039076175540685654,
0.001335326349362731,
-0.012550005689263344,
0.022610241547226906,
0.012749687768518925
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:10
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
* Part of farm $288,000 approx. in 2007
53Such figures take no account of borrowings or expenses but at least illustrate a source of continuing funds to support the parties.
Non-financial contributions to the relationship
54Before I consider the nature of the homemaker contributions in this matter I will first deal with the various assaults alleged in this case.
55In summary the various alleged assaults appear to be the following:
* Use of abusive language from 1993 in these terms (in Paras 117 & 211 of the defendant's affidavit)
"All you Mulcahys are selfish. You've got no idea how to fucking live or behave" and
"You're a private school overeducated cunt"
"You've all got a holier than thou attitude. The holy fucking Mulcahy trinity need a fucking smack in the fucking mouth".
He would also say to me on hundreds of occasions "If you were a bloke I'd fucking knock your head in". He would also say to me on many occasions "Someone should give you a fucking smack in the mouth". On other occasions he would say to me "I should smack your fucking head in" or "I should give you a fucking smack in the mouth".
* Arguments in 1993 about the parties relationships with their children (in paras 126 and 127) including abuse in these terms:
including "you're a miserable, selfish bitch. You have your children. What about giving me time and space with mine."
* In June 1995 the plaintiff, after the defendant asked when a shed in the back yard was going to be completed, grabbed her by the arm, dragged her down the back stairs to the yard where the unassembled shed lay and abused her in these terms (in para 206):
Bob: "What the fuck to do you call that? [indicating towards the disassembled shed]
Me: The shed's not for me or Station Ave, it's purely for Wetcheck's storage.
Bob: I can't fuckin' stand the sound of your fuckin' voice or the fuckin' sight of you. Get out of my fuckin' sight. Disappear. If you don't, I'll fuckin' kill you. I'm fuckin' out of here. I'm going to pack my stuff and find somewhere else to live. Don't come back till I'm gone. I promise you I'll fuckin' kill you."
* In late 1996 in a burst of anger ordered the defendant out of the property at Maroochydore in these terms (in para 237):
"Get out of my fucking place. I'll get a fucking flat bed truck and pitch your fucking gear over the fucking balcony".
* In late 1996 ordered the defendant out of the bed and took her back to her house at Gaythorne. (Para 238)
* In late December 2000 after a discussion about helping the plaintiff's son Trevor buy a property, which the defendant resisted, the plaintiff threatened to shoot either himself or the defendant. He became very angry and tipped a beer over the defendant. (Para 312 tx 319). During it he said:
"This is driving me fucking nuts, I really should get rid of the rifles. I am either going to shoot you or shoot myself or both of us."
* A few days after Christmas 2000 he complained to the defendant in these terms: (304)
"I've had to move furniture downstairs at Gaythorne and pack up the tool room, and I had to get Shane to help me - it's not my responsibility to do this shit. I've also left the key with the tenant. The fucking Mulcahys all fucking need a fucking smack in the fucking mouth".
* The threat to shoot was repeated in mid 2007
* On 18 February 2008 during an attempt at reconciliation the plaintiff suddenly burst out with (at para 582):
"All our successes have been due to me. All our failures are due to the fucking miserable Mulcahys ... Your bloody boys in particular.
I could easily destroy David's business. All it would take is one phone call.
I could easily get that general manager's position Wade is applying for at Dimension Data. I could get that job over Wade without doubt ... piece of piss!
I could destroy them. I know people who could seriously hurt them, the fucking miserable arrogant bastards.
|
[
-0.038411881774663925,
0.04748588427901268,
-0.023554202169179916,
0.013926377519965172,
-0.009322542697191238,
-0.03456798568367958,
0.04489810764789581,
0.023454740643501282,
-0.0007817941368557513,
0.009376518428325653,
-0.014111202210187912,
0.06271364539861679,
-0.04918769374489784,
-0.011542435735464096,
0.017642660066485405,
-0.059084486216306686,
0.019300552085042,
-0.04169953614473343,
0.001427939860150218,
-0.033768221735954285,
-0.02806304767727852,
-0.013025850057601929,
0.018378091976046562,
-0.012720487080514431,
0.018009062856435776,
0.012897223234176636,
-0.03288975730538368,
-0.019240645691752434,
-0.006859494838863611,
0.027896003797650337,
0.026955293491482735,
0.04519002139568329,
0.03771468251943588,
-0.030193613842129707,
-0.037398602813482285,
0.010835512541234493,
-0.001269556232728064,
-0.009830527938902378,
-0.04774979129433632,
0.0007507293485105038,
0.0030391442123800516,
0.06346730887889862,
-0.012579791247844696,
-0.02628958225250244,
0.015116901136934757,
-0.04699188470840454,
-0.004963248502463102,
-0.024716611951589584,
-0.025620704516768456,
0.027959464117884636,
-0.03226258605718613,
-0.028889570385217667,
0.05473572760820389,
0.015444123186171055,
-0.009411836974322796,
0.017121033743023872,
-0.0037206276319921017,
0.0357089526951313,
-0.07750202715396881,
0.010540895164012909,
-0.00942140817642212,
-0.0413270965218544,
-0.016417820006608963,
-0.015592888928949833,
0.015413210727274418,
0.09352517127990723,
-0.029386764392256737,
-0.025792401283979416,
-0.008379305712878704,
-0.007193113677203655,
0.00912566389888525,
-0.02009171061217785,
-0.00791183952242136,
-0.0017527122981846333,
-0.07584652304649353,
0.03493496775627136,
0.017007814720273018,
0.027013037353754044,
-0.017105255275964737,
0.03562292084097862,
0.06407532095909119,
0.009987267665565014,
0.02018112689256668,
0.03565892577171326,
-0.04205213114619255,
0.045645687729120255,
-0.018141601234674454,
0.020332882180809975,
0.018579384312033653,
-0.0319671593606472,
-0.013763879425823689,
0.009460126981139183,
0.042433805763721466,
-0.041557833552360535,
-0.011372569017112255,
0.00019854686979670078,
-0.055584028363227844,
0.02517556957900524,
0.012054073624312878,
0.00930863805115223,
0.020098183304071426,
-0.031058181077241898,
-0.027713563293218613,
-0.014762302860617638,
0.005527032073587179,
0.025912372395396233,
0.025939064100384712,
0.04841050133109093,
0.03497359901666641,
0.00023854106257203966,
0.022316843271255493,
0.020573383197188377,
0.006216269917786121,
-0.01040055975317955,
-0.02329574152827263,
-0.005905940197408199,
0.030791139230132103,
-0.0481918640434742,
0.03280850499868393,
0.007468945812433958,
0.025411456823349,
0.016558097675442696,
0.01982293836772442,
-0.016868246719241142,
-0.04971211031079292,
0.04821564257144928,
0.0069101243279874325,
0.02334887906908989,
-0.0075050657615065575,
0.03820599243044853,
-0.05158057063817978,
-0.003920418210327625,
-0.028736187145113945,
-0.04606963321566582,
-0.047895632684230804,
-0.00835860799998045,
0.05554237589240074,
0.03218803554773331,
0.0167233906686306,
-0.012191945686936378,
0.066119484603405,
0.02354469522833824,
0.031846363097429276,
-0.02038564905524254,
0.024846276268363,
-0.053081948310136795,
-0.018878787755966187,
-0.07899575680494308,
-0.021299200132489204,
-0.010263821110129356,
-0.004980917554348707,
0.001382161513902247,
0.044624511152505875,
-0.041378725320100784,
0.0004745112091768533,
-0.04206825792789459,
-0.000050563772674649954,
-0.031096236780285835,
0.03883366286754608,
-0.00004097019700566307,
0.01620132476091385,
0.011615915223956108,
-0.046531062573194504,
-0.0473380871117115,
0.05996435135602951,
-0.03277462348341942,
-0.016412248834967613,
0.03405741974711418,
-0.034455474466085434,
-0.029340676963329315,
0.05967339128255844,
-0.04087868705391884,
0.034165624529123306,
-0.0254355575889349,
0.032830335199832916,
0.018974894657731056,
0.02389593981206417,
0.01806260086596012,
-0.0026509244926273823,
-0.03198523074388504,
-0.04571850225329399,
0.016043255105614662,
-0.02399967797100544,
-0.027015620842576027,
-0.017824333161115646,
0.012540842406451702,
-0.022710498422384262,
-0.01836700178682804,
0.01234514731913805,
0.02341904491186142,
-0.030030319467186928,
-0.018795134499669075,
0.05285562947392464,
0.03328544646501541,
0.030376490205526352,
-0.028157731518149376,
0.017059052363038063,
-0.020399799570441246,
0.021616969257593155,
0.00195947103202343,
-0.0007604786078445613,
0.04648447036743164,
0.051604002714157104,
-0.03831646591424942,
-0.04065502807497978,
-0.008332330733537674,
-0.02321961335837841,
0.002882958622649312,
-0.011624029837548733,
-0.05066258832812309,
0.02432815171778202,
0.012129072099924088,
0.013526750728487968,
-0.018850035965442657,
0.003178540151566267,
-0.002169643295928836,
0.0091661736369133,
-0.016351118683815002,
0.005432173144072294,
0.023330986499786377,
-0.01392482127994299,
0.00048187607899308205,
0.022684723138809204,
0.04303918406367302,
0.009642703458666801,
-0.005882994271814823,
-0.010462123900651932,
0.006535268388688564,
0.020009852945804596,
-0.024615129455924034,
0.08036752790212631,
0.021258190274238586,
0.031071564182639122,
-0.008213687688112259,
0.02547479048371315,
0.014332025311887264,
0.020677706226706505,
0.00629439577460289,
0.005104921292513609,
0.014435149729251862,
-0.009461582638323307,
-0.0073930565267801285,
-0.03270112723112106,
-0.007080915383994579,
-0.008410677313804626,
0.002440106123685837,
0.02640991099178791,
0.03715892881155014,
0.012785069644451141,
-0.03389129415154457,
-0.001240466139279306,
-0.03304053470492363,
-0.016423318535089493,
-0.02489381842315197,
0.011096606031060219,
0.03144485875964165,
0.01391696184873581,
-0.003862083423882723,
0.01374118309468031,
0.0050811925902962685,
0.00421740859746933,
0.03018816187977791,
0.04107555374503136,
0.013502344489097595,
-0.0030370757449418306,
-0.006789765786379576,
-0.0324530191719532,
-0.06794939935207367,
0.002468268619850278,
0.011113294400274754,
0.018284998834133148,
-0.01296220812946558,
-0.0025889500975608826,
-0.00920411292463541,
0.002034604549407959,
-0.00391766894608736,
0.0050894697196781635,
-0.05658658966422081,
-0.0004372377006802708,
-0.016458993777632713,
0.02737417258322239,
0.032171834260225296,
-0.02490108273923397,
-0.012415995821356773,
0.00047210828051902354,
0.07610675692558289,
-0.020097482949495316,
-0.04698339104652405,
0.02230909653007984,
-0.05017395690083504,
0.0413273386657238,
-0.011309998109936714,
0.06557752192020416,
-0.006608031690120697,
-0.0680428072810173,
-0.031224029138684273,
-0.00742439366877079,
-0.1783875972032547,
0.03073299117386341,
-0.013647003099322319,
0.014675376005470753,
0.01563018560409546,
0.006394946947693825,
-0.00907774455845356,
-0.004324663430452347,
-0.008077363483607769,
0.027209103107452393,
0.032617129385471344,
-0.057399287819862366,
-0.016554391011595726,
0.005304795224219561,
-0.013391751796007156,
-0.040363017469644547,
0.01100670825690031,
0.007721226196736097,
0.012716063298285007,
-0.035032421350479126,
0.021020282059907913,
0.007264737039804459,
-0.01877644844353199,
-0.005076550878584385,
-0.04933319613337517,
0.023370904847979546,
0.05538792908191681,
-0.02724662981927395,
-0.011839107610285282,
-0.0008223506156355143,
-0.05795909836888313,
0.020362967625260353,
-0.0201509241014719,
0.01359507068991661,
-0.011325404979288578,
0.057831939309835434,
0.0067681679502129555,
-0.10374952107667923,
-0.02953106164932251,
-0.03330419957637787,
0.020742245018482208,
0.01985134743154049,
-0.02454931102693081,
0.03153451159596443,
0.030384307727217674,
-0.10114875435829163,
-0.004372908268123865,
-0.024084612727165222,
-0.03802379220724106,
0.032819218933582306,
0.011267244815826416,
0.03951489180326462,
-0.04102465510368347,
-0.024649182334542274,
-0.020832477137446404,
-0.0144223403185606,
-0.017647137865424156,
0.05333076789975166,
-0.01181833352893591,
0.008585619740188122,
0.022613907232880592,
-0.05125950276851654,
0.07885297387838364,
-0.000330096110701561,
-0.02743166871368885,
-0.0369110181927681,
0.010776243172585964,
-0.02821812778711319,
-0.006041381508111954,
-0.011600809171795845,
0.023597396910190582,
-0.050454553216695786,
0.014163290150463581,
-0.014080053195357323,
0.0325779914855957,
0.04227469488978386,
0.0018643158255144954,
-0.016472429037094116,
0.0028348020277917385,
-0.10320572555065155,
0.02862069569528103,
0.0457652248442173,
0.012345741502940655,
0.05490622669458389,
0.016055574640631676,
-0.024121515452861786,
0.01893865130841732,
-0.012842852622270584,
0.032712362706661224,
0.23106515407562256,
0.012014198116958141,
-0.0027305306866765022,
0.027295755222439766,
0.0216426569968462,
-0.0013096575858071446,
-0.004874221049249172,
0.05846568942070007,
0.03862579166889191,
-0.028875647112727165,
-0.02235761657357216,
0.02935786172747612,
0.038596585392951965,
0.0008635306148789823,
-0.01900235377252102,
0.010914655402302742,
-0.04472585394978523,
-0.033555302768945694,
0.05773412808775902,
0.03772905468940735,
0.038855765014886856,
-0.06400484591722488,
0.04023369401693344,
-0.0157134011387825,
-0.06619539856910706,
-0.03863652050495148,
-0.01308175828307867,
0.06314033269882202,
-0.02545863389968872,
0.002430954482406378,
-0.04144877567887306,
-0.013253041543066502,
0.006069527473300695,
0.018451612442731857,
0.027719758450984955,
-0.007098653353750706,
-0.015102478675544262,
-0.030424397438764572,
-0.0307333804666996,
0.033982183784246445,
-0.017516624182462692,
-0.02190016396343708,
-0.028293119743466377,
-0.05025639757514,
-0.032718196511268616,
-0.014917995780706406,
-0.002628135960549116,
-0.01302584633231163,
-0.05064952000975609,
0.0167225431650877,
-0.02724541164934635,
0.012833789922297001,
-0.002582325367256999,
0.02639409527182579,
-0.06715077906847,
-0.04621787741780281,
0.03287048637866974,
0.03830733522772789,
-0.01203744113445282,
0.046753138303756714,
0.007905219681560993,
0.04075499624013901,
-0.03999487683176994,
0.03510947898030281,
-0.013629310764372349,
-0.004061547107994556,
-0.026817141100764275,
-0.029181117191910744,
0.034472908824682236,
0.0009191349381580949,
0.043078649789094925,
0.004007759504020214,
-0.007810890208929777,
0.0216076597571373,
0.05506058782339096,
-0.022479252889752388,
-0.028403356671333313,
0.011629889719188213,
0.02247905544936657,
0.04604450985789299,
-0.05206020548939705,
-0.01664438657462597,
0.003946297336369753,
0.005328398197889328,
0.018520453944802284,
-0.010732809081673622,
-0.013415292836725712,
0.009709536097943783,
-0.012181960046291351,
-0.001578967203386128,
-0.017501285299658775,
-0.0067563606426119804,
-0.005422476213425398,
-0.01075664907693863,
0.0037287890445441008,
-0.018690230324864388,
0.0006098824669606984,
0.05099423974752426,
-0.010602947324514389,
-0.07410967350006104,
-0.001140365726314485,
0.0023349930997937918,
0.00434699933975935,
-0.016310036182403564,
0.03355342894792557,
0.016114063560962677,
-0.018353745341300964,
0.013232375495135784,
-0.026343753561377525,
0.0019246574956923723,
-0.015549274161458015,
0.008511463180184364,
0.03053548000752926,
-0.0036491670180112123,
-0.013739997521042824,
0.027675895020365715,
-0.026709649711847305,
-0.012287680990993977,
0.04574024677276611,
0.019605528563261032,
-0.0032613601069897413,
-0.04446955397725105,
-0.022090228274464607,
-0.01936577819287777,
0.01833457499742508,
-0.012726657092571259,
-0.03648016229271889,
0.013538195751607418,
-0.004641042556613684,
0.04657350480556488,
0.017068617045879364,
-0.03537715598940849,
-0.02933470718562603,
0.015017766505479813,
0.03646533191204071,
0.00025046782684512436,
0.03690645098686218,
-0.011322465725243092,
-0.01996856927871704,
0.05204835534095764,
0.0003355345397721976,
-0.004451397340744734,
-0.0003834299568552524,
0.02650010772049427,
0.003798252437263727,
-0.007004291284829378,
-0.10912729054689407,
0.026649879291653633,
0.005577097646892071,
0.014031337574124336,
0.003862277138978243,
-0.0026513535995036364,
-0.027664674445986748,
-0.019651053473353386,
0.008472845889627934,
0.0027817548252642155,
-0.0115106962621212,
0.013365449383854866,
0.025712167844176292,
-0.029115470126271248,
-0.0024992770049721003,
-0.007271306589245796,
0.017816361039876938,
0.032226111739873886,
0.03253478184342384,
0.059216465801000595,
-0.013018647208809853,
0.00018483861640561372,
-0.035833071917295456,
-0.0037640617229044437,
-0.006648119073361158,
-0.004618457984179258,
-0.015315511263906956,
0.019420454278588295,
0.05968358367681503,
-0.0036904816515743732,
-0.03513795882463455,
0.021299879997968674,
0.005345116835087538,
0.025433022528886795,
0.019416524097323418,
0.04704088345170021,
-0.05605261027812958,
0.0485859252512455,
-0.02109052613377571,
-0.020030343905091286,
0.020512443035840988,
-0.0029826245736330748,
0.016438834369182587,
-0.026419736444950104,
0.006158024538308382,
0.0835670530796051,
0.005380440037697554,
-0.007551482412964106,
0.01662038080394268,
-0.0012782972771674395,
0.008231627754867077,
0.0317140594124794,
0.012717130593955517,
-0.018014345318078995,
-0.012980148196220398,
0.021157652139663696,
0.00596887432038784,
0.030024008825421333,
0.045709457248449326,
-0.004923433996737003,
0.036389075219631195,
0.01781380921602249,
-0.027539577335119247,
-0.06422878801822662,
0.04487960785627365,
0.01588352397084236,
-0.0200965479016304,
-0.02038319781422615,
0.003154437756165862,
-0.04277404025197029,
0.03069334477186203,
0.038235053420066833,
-0.02599644847214222,
-0.03656424209475517,
-0.0036454107612371445,
-0.01499929279088974,
0.029471250250935555,
-0.07980090379714966,
0.003250611713156104,
0.001050747581757605,
0.016754619777202606,
-0.020380130037665367,
-0.01453610509634018,
-0.01390121504664421,
0.0073540834710001945,
-0.051653098315000534,
0.06445103138685226,
0.004404377192258835,
0.002588209230452776,
0.007724503520876169,
0.026959797367453575,
0.0005574919632636011,
0.033565327525138855,
-0.03451318293809891,
0.01547058392316103,
-0.037208281457424164,
0.013764717616140842,
0.04366996884346008,
-0.0014040326932445168,
-0.020862804725766182,
0.011180000379681587,
0.027442893013358116,
-0.005632935557514429,
0.04015246033668518,
-0.0041288575157523155,
-0.033449023962020874,
0.002174768131226301,
-0.0074578262865543365,
0.0041462271474301815,
0.022983526811003685,
0.03399142995476723,
-0.008311795070767403,
-0.06598112732172012,
-0.017019156366586685,
0.01659603789448738,
0.0026973800268024206,
-0.033229514956474304,
-0.017772700637578964,
-0.03535864129662514,
-0.05220743641257286,
0.00781425554305315,
-0.0028773904778063297,
-0.03134450316429138,
-0.036729585379362106,
0.016579419374465942,
-0.009331834502518177,
-0.0526418574154377,
0.015122835524380207,
0.04575926810503006,
-0.012398291379213333,
-0.03350263088941574,
0.0019319626735523343,
0.052659694105386734,
0.02474571019411087,
0.0155904870480299,
0.028601357713341713,
0.037679996341466904,
0.05632853880524635,
0.0018712240271270275,
-0.006098038516938686,
0.02551485411822796,
0.0064616440795362,
0.017796015366911888,
-0.0074316710233688354,
0.06667386740446091,
-0.00870554056018591,
-0.03936975449323654,
0.04423787072300911,
-0.01181371882557869,
0.002921176142990589,
0.0063256509602069855,
0.036055028438568115,
-0.014107131399214268,
0.01773361675441265,
-0.044279634952545166,
0.033738888800144196,
-0.01102393213659525,
-0.009050467051565647,
0.00018546407227404416,
0.005918305367231369,
0.033225927501916885,
-0.05611089617013931,
-0.01648818328976631,
-0.015414535999298096,
-0.0014213562244549394,
-0.05536410212516785,
-0.02009684406220913,
-0.00203323015011847,
0.03056446835398674,
0.039504971355199814,
0.01509732287377119,
0.007568010129034519,
0.0014306762022897601,
0.015853308141231537,
-0.004070499911904335,
0.03910775110125542,
-0.029226265847682953,
-0.0003546909720171243,
-0.0340837799012661,
0.03967466205358505,
0.050410423427820206,
-0.01392284594476223,
-0.03204936906695366,
-0.00034758049878291786,
-0.032937876880168915,
-0.03833018243312836,
-0.01251472719013691,
0.017190013080835342,
0.09013576060533524,
-0.004540460184216499,
0.032699599862098694,
-0.018535614013671875,
0.03519346937537193,
-0.003673106897622347,
-0.028232239186763763,
-0.043038807809352875,
0.07033302634954453,
0.0013553638709709048,
-0.011102698743343353,
-0.016365785151720047,
0.01136896200478077,
0.008806347846984863,
0.0024361084215343,
-0.003718584543094039,
-0.0144574623554945,
0.00882525835186243,
-0.005939217749983072,
-0.014766618609428406,
0.0496320016682148,
0.0022652652114629745,
0.023842105641961098,
0.010672017000615597,
0.021275486797094345,
0.017350953072309494,
-0.01877274177968502,
0.04835474491119385,
0.002180761657655239,
-0.008918311446905136,
-0.003038644092157483,
0.012041380628943443,
0.007067544385790825,
0.03842373192310333,
-0.014664269052445889,
0.019784165546298027,
0.025588063523173332,
-0.02313382364809513,
0.011567119508981705,
0.009359141811728477,
-0.023294612765312195,
0.01992950774729252,
-0.0029437290504574776,
0.014981944113969803,
0.023622455075383186,
-0.002651250222697854,
-0.023769769817590714,
-0.04007068648934364,
-0.037011828273534775,
0.002191477920860052,
0.03596344590187073,
0.02070346288383007,
0.012293299660086632,
0.024868862703442574,
0.014709889888763428,
0.06930874288082123,
-0.024718865752220154,
0.034955840557813644,
-0.03228360414505005,
0.02491944655776024,
-0.16731922328472137,
0.020912155508995056,
0.040446385741233826,
-0.045407671481370926,
-0.031664155423641205,
-0.03857960179448128,
-0.016406575217843056,
0.01805197447538376,
-0.023392338305711746,
0.01886974275112152,
0.0010675702942535281,
0.02192048355937004,
0.03608080372214317,
-0.025509698316454887,
-0.07556940615177155,
0.04165593162178993,
0.0006162431673146784,
-0.007473768666386604,
-0.032230444252491,
0.016300581395626068,
-0.012911238707602024,
-0.00010999466030625626,
-0.021463623270392418,
-0.01954086683690548,
0.006782027892768383,
-0.0036950400099158287,
-0.014418714679777622,
-0.012035413645207882,
-0.039587609469890594,
0.024860084056854248,
-0.0078770462423563,
-0.02877487987279892,
-0.008805103600025177,
0.008495052345097065,
-0.00008238130976678804,
0.013639891520142555,
0.010720214806497097,
-0.009423194453120232,
-0.023278189823031425,
-0.004458113573491573,
-0.011863754130899906,
0.02306962013244629,
-0.01035202294588089,
-0.05225033313035965,
0.01861535757780075,
0.03922281041741371,
0.0033827205188572407,
0.004776286892592907,
-0.030603932216763496,
-0.01030480582267046,
-0.01172691397368908,
0.03365601226687431,
-0.028652407228946686,
0.05678017437458038,
-0.01523556001484394,
-0.007075476460158825,
-0.02494235709309578,
-0.03812497481703758,
-0.04906420782208443,
0.04422156512737274,
-0.01940053701400757,
-0.0020641940645873547,
-0.002567752730101347,
-0.004218755755573511,
0.03687159717082977,
0.0009816240053623915,
-0.03884397819638252,
-0.027405226603150368,
-0.0252243559807539,
-0.008018799126148224,
0.024685241281986237,
-0.05208572745323181,
0.03466044366359711,
-0.04754418507218361,
0.014921017922461033,
-0.025618942454457283,
-0.03167792409658432,
0.01678168773651123,
-0.037758808583021164,
-0.007898756302893162,
-0.03992437571287155,
0.0038185480516403913,
-0.017262866720557213,
-0.030835667625069618,
0.022427059710025787,
0.007095263805240393,
0.0001447264658054337,
0.005121898837387562,
0.008823740296065807,
-0.000007390548489638604,
-0.027836395427584648,
0.0003605735255405307,
-0.013208764605224133,
0.02142423391342163,
0.008648931048810482,
0.0235173050314188,
-0.007377313449978828,
-0.00701528787612915,
-0.04970598593354225,
0.01705234684050083,
0.008749711327254772,
-0.0408395417034626,
-0.009735697880387306,
0.04701998457312584,
-0.04575178399682045,
0.056781016290187836,
-0.007088701240718365,
-0.032075416296720505,
-0.03568722680211067,
-0.016522636637091637,
0.004397976212203503,
-0.014942151494324207,
-0.07285042107105255,
-0.014606276527047157,
-0.04767199978232384,
0.04419321194291115,
0.033436261117458344,
0.053682275116443634,
-0.04337509721517563,
-0.018085362389683723,
0.02660655789077282,
0.027189036831259727,
0.021528374403715134,
-0.04278042912483215,
0.0014414641773328185,
0.0031822866294533014,
0.03327076509594917,
-0.007880687713623047,
0.008078400045633316,
-0.03105177916586399,
-0.020974403247237206,
-0.01690271869301796,
0.026294702664017677,
0.02181953936815262,
0.005950021091848612,
0.009647619910538197,
-0.03354578837752342,
0.013785133138298988,
-0.027112135663628578,
-0.030320513993501663,
-0.00832884106785059,
-0.02511555328965187,
-0.0204056017100811,
-0.010517135262489319,
-0.01568312756717205,
0.011063704267144203,
0.025882422924041748,
-0.012980295345187187,
0.0038361058104783297,
-0.004903249442577362,
-0.01907275803387165,
0.029429113492369652,
-0.005326285492628813,
0.03263462707400322,
0.022651590406894684,
0.01605905592441559,
0.02591235190629959,
-0.017044086009263992,
0.019336268305778503,
0.024988986551761627,
-0.012998648919165134,
-0.059158336371183395,
-0.002596927573904395,
-0.012323115020990372,
-0.05273439362645149,
-0.014436027966439724,
0.015532907098531723,
0.007985477335751057,
-0.05282409116625786,
-0.016474492847919464,
-0.00526569364592433,
-0.018745336681604385,
-0.006684888619929552,
0.010728423483669758,
-0.0012641100911423564,
-0.0352984219789505,
-0.006294265855103731,
-0.024600498378276825,
0.0661061555147171,
0.003805165644735098,
0.0428667776286602,
0.005946794059127569,
0.02191399782896042,
0.005098781548440456,
0.03961334004998207,
0.05283898860216141,
0.005136201158165932,
0.005017820745706558,
-0.00001095405241358094,
-0.01916525512933731,
-0.006914736237376928,
-0.03601907193660736,
0.007778698578476906,
-0.005105937365442514,
0.027045900002121925,
0.008496545255184174,
-0.02597932703793049,
0.04528946056962013,
-0.00916889775544405,
-0.0038631439674645662,
0.012435543350875378,
-0.03869521990418434,
-0.05688660219311714,
-0.04287255182862282,
-0.05789655074477196,
-0.03133794665336609,
-0.023475758731365204,
-0.03892941400408745,
-0.0051416982896625996,
0.05329851806163788,
-0.05491144582629204,
-0.02032199315726757,
0.028580473735928535,
0.011868459172546864,
-0.030624160543084145,
0.03987186402082443,
-0.001463117660023272,
0.0014944977592676878,
-0.025875752791762352,
0.0024091918021440506,
0.028689974918961525,
0.019927605986595154,
0.011532057076692581,
-0.05915170535445213,
0.033543821424245834,
-0.0015446015167981386,
-0.019604908302426338,
0.004063662141561508,
-0.0038995963986963034,
-0.049564559012651443,
-0.051338355988264084,
-0.01434930507093668,
-0.012261886149644852,
0.030460907146334648,
0.03706861287355423,
-0.002931122202426195,
-0.028074951842427254,
-0.02160920388996601,
-0.009067244827747345,
0.051321662962436676,
0.012507989071309566,
-0.01892027072608471,
-0.0037378575652837753,
0.01927417516708374
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:49
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
"ln summary, there is nothing in the further documentation by Dr. Fisher to justify any change in my opinion, I do not believe Ms, Mulahy is suffering from a disability under the relevant Section, 1 do not believe she is, or has been, suffering from a major psychiatric disorder but may have suffered from a recurrent adjustment disorder.
The terms "battered woman" and '"battered wife syndrome" are, in my view, not appropriately applied to Ms. Mulcahy given that there is a connotation of severe psychiatric illness."
263There was also criticism of the use by Dr Fischer of the terms "Mixed Anxiety Depressive syndrome". His explanation which I find acceptable was as follows:
""Q. In that report Dr Klug seeks to criticise your diagnosis by stating that mixed anxiety depressive syndrome is not to be found in DSM-IV. What is your comment on that statement?
A. Strictly speaking, he is correct, it isn't found in the diagnostic entity in DSM-IV. It is found in the preliminary drafts of DSM-V, which is the successor of DSM-IV. In reality people have argued very strongly that this is a useful way of characterising the sort of disorder I believe Mrs Mulcahy suffered from because there is a such a mixture of anxiety and depression which describes
where the patient is experiencing. Furthermore, may have etiological implications. In other words, often enough severe depression is preceded by being very stressed and anxious. One of the aims of the DSM system is to try and put things into categories can be tested and can end up understanding
causes by virtue of that classification or we find out what we classify as separate entities are the same entity. There is some scientific and logical basis to this approach. So in summary the term mixed anxiety depression is something many many people work in psychiatry would use as diagnosis and is about to become a official diagnosis in DSM-V and Dr Klug is correct it is not
in the current literature. He is correct in that. I think the point I am making qualifies why I am putting it in.
264Some things about the parties' relationship raise doubts about whether Dr Fischer's conclusions may be correct. Obvious ones are the fact that the defendant was a relatively high functioning individual throughout the relationship and another is the long periods of time between the assaults. In the plaintiff's submissions in reply he makes the following points:
"7.6 The point made at paragraph 154 of the earlier submissions which goes totally unremarked upon in the Defendant's submissions that a period of more than six years passes between the allegation at item 9 of the schedule of alleged assaults occurring in the Christmas/New Year period of 2000/2001 and the next chronological allegation which is item 3 occurring in March/April 2007.
This fact comprehensively debunks the repeated suggestions of the Defendant's submissions that there is some "continuum" of abuse.
7.7 The impressive list of examples of conduct of the Defendant which demonstrate a lack of fear or intimidation including (in addition to the matters mentioned above):
7.7.1 Camping in seemingly remote places; T354.28
7.7.2 Choosing to live in the isolated location at South Bank Road. It is instructive to consider just some of the evidence on this aspect. The evidence of the Defendant herself starting at T215.04 that, at least at the time of the purchase of 290 South Bank Road in late 1999 and the farm in late 2003:
(a) she had no concerns about living there with the Plaintiff;
(b) this in circumstances where she was dependent on him to drive her anywhere away from the property; and
(c) and, at T217.11, at the time the parties were looking to purchase 290 South Bank property (in late 1999), she had no concerns about her personal safety or physical situation;
7.7.3 Pressing the Plaintiff to live at South Bank Road despite his initial lack of interest in purchasing that property;
|
[
-0.019420137628912926,
-0.013540309853851795,
-0.055733323097229004,
-0.015452191233634949,
0.009171313606202602,
-0.006876627914607525,
0.03735335171222687,
0.006882216781377792,
0.04473324865102768,
0.004779075738042593,
0.0011018506484106183,
0.07218240946531296,
-0.018082546070218086,
0.0038068511057645082,
0.009890262968838215,
-0.04705602675676346,
0.022864291444420815,
-0.033640675246715546,
-0.012803277000784874,
-0.028460517525672913,
-0.03732169792056084,
-0.007007724139839411,
0.020708484575152397,
0.026054322719573975,
-0.009819312021136284,
0.05989386513829231,
0.015571950934827328,
-0.008323346264660358,
-0.01865265890955925,
0.05275825783610344,
-0.022531114518642426,
-0.03418530523777008,
0.040909118950366974,
-0.030765525996685028,
0.017102960497140884,
-0.005895903799682856,
-0.012539001181721687,
0.021996108815073967,
-0.04088744521141052,
0.01644512638449669,
0.015304244123399258,
0.014587603509426117,
0.022081533446907997,
-0.03358316794037819,
0.03586367145180702,
-0.06212819740176201,
0.001113855978474021,
-0.03598310798406601,
-0.003559545148164034,
-0.0003023440658580512,
-0.005316063296049833,
-0.06217270344495773,
0.03993258625268936,
-0.022329065948724747,
-0.008132821880280972,
-0.00030010551563464105,
-0.012874439358711243,
0.014040086418390274,
-0.024249983951449394,
0.01263691857457161,
-0.02270405925810337,
-0.012812660075724125,
-0.012866600416600704,
-0.03248152509331703,
0.016161544248461723,
0.06141478940844536,
-0.003131106263026595,
-0.0126466304063797,
0.008806953206658363,
-0.01994447596371174,
-0.016695799306035042,
-0.02400279976427555,
0.008156617172062397,
-0.015147757716476917,
-0.07895909994840622,
-0.00595980416983366,
0.017088113352656364,
0.00481799291446805,
-0.016105053946375847,
0.06744313985109329,
0.02978532388806343,
0.01749984733760357,
0.03891512006521225,
0.046670541167259216,
-0.02392941527068615,
0.04193630442023277,
-0.03974124789237976,
0.014660409651696682,
0.009895715862512589,
-0.04768398776650429,
-0.014874058775603771,
0.010187397710978985,
0.02555629424750805,
-0.019902480766177177,
-0.02090202271938324,
-0.011294983327388763,
-0.035745829343795776,
0.037970881909132004,
0.0007572477916255593,
-0.0038390865083783865,
0.004831589758396149,
0.021422291174530983,
-0.007572800386697054,
-0.05404568836092949,
-0.019044864922761917,
0.0016757136909291148,
0.02555122599005699,
0.05648330599069595,
0.030982404947280884,
0.008494795300066471,
0.008835148997604847,
0.002888380317017436,
0.018446272239089012,
0.043398838490247726,
-0.03442562371492386,
-0.00623253732919693,
-0.006142284721136093,
-0.07672636955976486,
0.02890300564467907,
-0.019577359780669212,
0.037211351096630096,
0.04587002098560333,
0.029954763129353523,
-0.04467016085982323,
-0.039482828229665756,
0.04690447449684143,
-0.03000251203775406,
0.014471391215920448,
-0.02754477597773075,
0.028311677277088165,
-0.01635487750172615,
-0.029129942879080772,
-0.01929919421672821,
-0.06957495957612991,
-0.006170268636196852,
-0.026796219870448112,
0.06596281379461288,
0.01096801832318306,
0.0035281169693917036,
-0.020177440717816353,
0.03319542482495308,
-0.008845570497214794,
0.03321518748998642,
-0.02826148085296154,
0.01819930598139763,
0.0015458931447938085,
-0.005985962692648172,
-0.01172222476452589,
0.003191653871908784,
0.017916517332196236,
0.011902562342584133,
-0.017361866310238838,
0.008024085313081741,
-0.006044026929885149,
0.0156242148950696,
-0.0013105759862810373,
0.02636973187327385,
0.01187040749937296,
0.005009260959923267,
-0.021971754729747772,
0.011179663240909576,
0.02972627989947796,
-0.024846019223332405,
0.0047897351905703545,
0.023607682436704636,
0.008645841851830482,
0.0455477200448513,
0.07800404727458954,
-0.0030909976921975613,
-0.028737835586071014,
0.012410599738359451,
-0.026167280972003937,
0.05529412999749184,
0.007680598180741072,
0.027661560103297234,
0.020040474832057953,
0.045711126178503036,
0.0023152721114456654,
-0.016247160732746124,
-0.03000863827764988,
-0.023221289739012718,
0.04265090078115463,
0.0034286370500922203,
0.0018270578002557158,
0.0007901361677795649,
-0.026264607906341553,
-0.03668088838458061,
-0.04552731662988663,
0.01830366626381874,
0.002189962426200509,
-0.04269305244088173,
-0.025566179305315018,
0.02781415544450283,
0.05255216732621193,
0.08623319119215012,
-0.025517601519823074,
0.0020502570550888777,
0.00394107261672616,
0.03287249058485031,
0.00035601266426965594,
-0.011826269328594208,
0.06373322010040283,
0.04880203679203987,
-0.013218797743320465,
-0.029416199773550034,
-0.0017459405353292823,
-0.05704076215624809,
-0.038699761033058167,
0.0040776655077934265,
-0.04349836707115173,
0.021673938259482384,
0.04152609035372734,
-0.013884277082979679,
-0.03507378324866295,
0.012796523049473763,
-0.05169963464140892,
0.0009570730617269874,
0.008629485964775085,
0.009362024255096912,
-0.015607229433953762,
0.01522770430892706,
-0.005652830004692078,
0.0010247984901070595,
-0.015661701560020447,
0.01522847916930914,
0.008312420919537544,
-0.011753971688449383,
0.040119390934705734,
0.01893571950495243,
-0.05584161728620529,
0.044836465269327164,
0.03222080320119858,
-0.043772365897893906,
-0.00011078608076786622,
0.032234206795692444,
0.012098745442926884,
0.04530014842748642,
0.02832595445215702,
0.03930584713816643,
0.0005778015474788845,
0.008882598951458931,
0.03437994420528412,
0.007754369638860226,
-0.02607976272702217,
-0.03604814410209656,
-0.004498790018260479,
0.05394405126571655,
0.03319351375102997,
0.015190508216619492,
0.014070536941289902,
0.004152194131165743,
0.013267137110233307,
-0.01202296931296587,
-0.012316999025642872,
0.05347689613699913,
0.035080745816230774,
0.02196824923157692,
0.005625918973237276,
0.04325217008590698,
-0.027031484991312027,
-0.012759863398969173,
0.0449138879776001,
0.031699471175670624,
0.002100105630233884,
-0.016449688002467155,
-0.043517544865608215,
-0.02328321523964405,
-0.008428415283560753,
0.021244261413812637,
0.007786422967910767,
0.011415380984544754,
-0.014973076060414314,
-0.005305691156536341,
0.015427997335791588,
0.017970217391848564,
0.008047809824347496,
0.01724010519683361,
-0.047863755375146866,
0.039315592497587204,
0.004885065369307995,
0.015732331201434135,
0.01929813250899315,
-0.0069990698248147964,
0.0270945206284523,
-0.018203753978013992,
0.01240068580955267,
0.0032665005419403315,
-0.01203889586031437,
-0.005401569418609142,
-0.0790768638253212,
0.02446042001247406,
-0.009209823794662952,
0.059749264270067215,
-0.018241552636027336,
-0.06588507443666458,
-0.023953374475240707,
-0.01787601225078106,
-0.16046348214149475,
-0.03058241307735443,
0.04162340611219406,
0.04822546988725662,
0.02207702398300171,
0.00522616459056735,
-0.0008723110659047961,
-0.011508031748235226,
-0.007551582995802164,
-0.026985540986061096,
0.012939861044287682,
-0.06200513243675232,
-0.022828349843621254,
0.03817741572856903,
0.01582963392138481,
0.021434368565678596,
0.00164443114772439,
-0.0018670286517590284,
-0.0034335670061409473,
-0.05947035923600197,
-0.012527098879218102,
0.003417119849473238,
0.002699545118957758,
-0.022828062996268272,
0.011943401768803596,
0.04350439831614494,
0.05160335451364517,
-0.0027338939253240824,
-0.0562351793050766,
-0.05326066166162491,
-0.02811613492667675,
0.004306298680603504,
-0.01470887940376997,
0.04572911188006401,
0.010423362255096436,
-0.0011032174807041883,
0.027519017457962036,
-0.04869379475712776,
-0.014077655971050262,
-0.06408635526895523,
0.01890825293958187,
0.03585266321897507,
0.008231207728385925,
0.029798513278365135,
-0.016605639830231667,
-0.03143785148859024,
0.04906276986002922,
-0.040316712111234665,
-0.022926943376660347,
0.002875465666875243,
-0.009060974232852459,
0.024497346952557564,
-0.04292861372232437,
-0.019571363925933838,
-0.012251853942871094,
-0.030345885083079338,
0.020732734352350235,
0.051486700773239136,
-0.0027985151391476393,
-0.04143685847520828,
0.03179219365119934,
-0.052854880690574646,
0.02042391337454319,
0.017210273072123528,
-0.03466818854212761,
-0.020069902762770653,
0.009184228256344795,
0.005536678247153759,
0.0010695878881961107,
0.008839970454573631,
0.0009626649552956223,
-0.033465128391981125,
-0.03572531417012215,
0.012247712351381779,
-0.002459013368934393,
0.03594228997826576,
0.026537306606769562,
-0.01703464984893799,
-0.016850998625159264,
-0.09668829292058945,
-0.01607503555715084,
0.026538772508502007,
0.015659337863326073,
0.024082565680146217,
-0.014436222612857819,
-0.03439973294734955,
0.0450533851981163,
-0.018743304535746574,
0.013138039968907833,
0.2646534740924835,
0.0344398096203804,
-0.031086290255188942,
0.009870936162769794,
0.02154875174164772,
0.013622051104903221,
0.024413608014583588,
0.009628822095692158,
-0.003883830038830638,
-0.034780535846948624,
-0.03867645934224129,
-0.00317162717692554,
0.028187142685055733,
0.015863541513681412,
-0.05051102116703987,
0.05574067309498787,
-0.08378028124570847,
-0.04274606704711914,
0.07560372352600098,
0.02724556252360344,
0.017398538067936897,
-0.06246462091803551,
0.05816671624779701,
0.038387447595596313,
-0.029748519882559776,
-0.018321065232157707,
-0.0035709450021386147,
0.021457025781273842,
-0.005435630679130554,
-0.017621969804167747,
-0.03324401378631592,
-0.022187991067767143,
0.051603641360998154,
-0.04279160127043724,
0.0078730508685112,
-0.009815306402742863,
0.002575083402916789,
-0.0047377306036651134,
-0.07908576726913452,
0.09188266098499298,
0.02477685920894146,
-0.0255871694535017,
-0.04280674457550049,
-0.011778479442000389,
0.02037833444774151,
0.00785303395241499,
-0.0013162372633814812,
-0.006317766383290291,
0.0053232330828905106,
0.021991953253746033,
-0.020448848605155945,
-0.021894052624702454,
0.002427207538858056,
0.0028759764973074198,
-0.02692270465195179,
0.004013900179415941,
-0.006809018552303314,
-0.007357265334576368,
-0.020735204219818115,
0.05684896931052208,
0.0027555562555789948,
0.012889683246612549,
-0.0725536197423935,
0.015181044116616249,
0.012480033561587334,
-0.001946828211657703,
-0.013620976358652115,
-0.013235912658274174,
0.024264561012387276,
-0.002155361697077751,
0.044513024389743805,
0.020226167514920235,
0.026414373889565468,
0.004972641821950674,
0.053945813328027725,
0.0017592740477994084,
0.0009508655057288706,
-0.0016761076403781772,
0.040780019015073776,
0.026462452486157417,
-0.03864634782075882,
-0.04444154351949692,
-0.015571626834571362,
-0.04414404556155205,
0.03158077597618103,
0.005956104025244713,
-0.005970996338874102,
0.016466422006487846,
0.020436124876141548,
-0.014007244259119034,
-0.007822761312127113,
-0.02222980372607708,
-0.021786507219076157,
0.04471142962574959,
-0.012087525799870491,
-0.009220193140208721,
0.011572715826332569,
0.015183957293629646,
0.007935617119073868,
-0.06581596285104752,
-0.0218074768781662,
-0.024452319368720055,
-0.023615306243300438,
0.0015982880722731352,
-0.0290523711591959,
-0.007689424324780703,
-0.01595558412373066,
-0.019177811220288277,
-0.010013269260525703,
-0.006935905199497938,
-0.00972329918295145,
0.001201098202727735,
-0.0005774800665676594,
0.004835654050111771,
-0.005901653319597244,
-0.009008541703224182,
-0.08099020272493362,
-0.0020555746741592884,
0.042483046650886536,
0.011542940512299538,
0.02203957363963127,
-0.003746297676116228,
-0.06343241780996323,
-0.012908789329230785,
-0.017985885962843895,
0.0052579594776034355,
0.00260550226084888,
-0.04769740253686905,
-0.026517005637288094,
0.011433033272624016,
0.017148667946457863,
-0.03902171179652214,
-0.04473421722650528,
-0.015124999918043613,
0.04126798361539841,
-0.00843031145632267,
0.010264282114803791,
0.02999514900147915,
0.011717055924236774,
-0.004671250469982624,
-0.03081110678613186,
-0.01546943373978138,
-0.007763667963445187,
0.03189472481608391,
0.015986822545528412,
0.01718803308904171,
-0.07102389633655548,
0.03826141357421875,
-0.025680359452962875,
-0.00008518173126503825,
0.02283427119255066,
-0.0024424835573881865,
-0.015026938170194626,
-0.02575034834444523,
-0.011401758529245853,
0.0003553240094333887,
-0.02633598819375038,
0.005157281178981066,
0.0904780775308609,
-0.013792910613119602,
-0.022472895681858063,
-0.002927968045696616,
-0.043236538767814636,
0.04413149505853653,
0.006521274801343679,
0.047429077327251434,
0.002166988793760538,
0.05511394143104553,
-0.003720778040587902,
-0.0017748522805050015,
0.039506375789642334,
-0.017233144491910934,
-0.04976216331124306,
0.026571381837129593,
0.03328252211213112,
0.02047034353017807,
-0.013592293485999107,
-0.003630960127338767,
0.00933102983981371,
0.0038685279432684183,
0.006091904826462269,
-0.010255525819957256,
-0.024589775130152702,
0.06018735095858574,
0.004072417039424181,
0.028792917728424072,
0.057860810309648514,
-0.008026925846934319,
0.017745794728398323,
-0.027672037482261658,
-0.017337223514914513,
0.0889807865023613,
-0.004403097555041313,
-0.0007583871483802795,
0.0025039175525307655,
0.030750861391425133,
0.022785313427448273,
0.027707215398550034,
0.025941947475075722,
-0.03450837731361389,
0.03656259924173355,
-0.01671437732875347,
-0.0086212744936347,
0.03899721801280975,
0.032601047307252884,
0.003563219914212823,
0.03282490745186806,
0.01680031791329384,
-0.01909050904214382,
-0.021989405155181885,
0.03582873195409775,
0.016808930784463882,
-0.04357094317674637,
-0.0002805978583637625,
-0.03963292017579079,
0.0034198572393506765,
-0.013825628906488419,
0.025615647435188293,
-0.03406519070267677,
-0.020439283922314644,
-0.025708574801683426,
-0.021408431231975555,
0.03115823119878769,
-0.07584679871797562,
-0.009047451429069042,
-0.014840321615338326,
-0.018815476447343826,
-0.02173740044236183,
-0.02510947547852993,
0.005003949627280235,
0.0064307874999940395,
-0.045254286378622055,
0.02664174512028694,
-0.01585538499057293,
0.008037527091801167,
-0.023735668510198593,
0.019141584634780884,
0.023018600419163704,
0.030472388491034508,
-0.006325129885226488,
0.037318553775548935,
-0.030284492298960686,
0.0016347854398190975,
0.02333565056324005,
-0.052538469433784485,
-0.03186191990971565,
-0.05355922132730484,
-0.0503230020403862,
0.03455307334661484,
0.05317825451493263,
-0.0317334420979023,
-0.004626194480806589,
0.014423467218875885,
-0.022531624883413315,
0.00001973148391698487,
0.023487962782382965,
0.014701495878398418,
-0.001108864089474082,
-0.01439416129142046,
-0.01466604508459568,
-0.01786118932068348,
0.0364517979323864,
0.01584179513156414,
-0.010331501252949238,
-0.07475890219211578,
-0.031989581882953644,
0.0012405054876580834,
0.027465837076306343,
-0.02144007943570614,
-0.03204493969678879,
-0.00852762907743454,
0.004604711662977934,
-0.055747006088495255,
-0.008338544517755508,
-0.03789438307285309,
0.017896801233291626,
-0.050287436693906784,
0.053358178585767746,
0.02395191788673401,
0.020127596333622932,
0.02272665500640869,
0.025469651445746422,
0.034818608313798904,
0.04431937634944916,
-0.031778089702129364,
0.03588882461190224,
0.06451281905174255,
0.027676884084939957,
0.007649472914636135,
-0.03345543518662453,
0.013626846484839916,
-0.0024488677736371756,
-0.040027718991041183,
0.04011363536119461,
-0.028419727459549904,
0.006245603319257498,
-0.010233189910650253,
0.0840902179479599,
-0.012044752016663551,
0.03434455022215843,
-0.019701210781931877,
0.0027920203283429146,
-0.013963891193270683,
0.025774991139769554,
0.00503880251199007,
-0.010134182870388031,
0.026595689356327057,
-0.07098514586687088,
-0.005696470849215984,
0.012317081913352013,
-0.023115169256925583,
-0.0030397744849324226,
-0.018996214494109154,
-0.037800319492816925,
0.003748745657503605,
0.015966687351465225,
0.013199795968830585,
-0.0021108754444867373,
-0.018777482211589813,
0.06638652086257935,
-0.012249727733433247,
0.03502611443400383,
-0.06461271643638611,
0.004073260817676783,
-0.026356611400842667,
0.018907666206359863,
-0.012074679136276245,
-0.044783201068639755,
-0.03966805711388588,
0.01432929839938879,
-0.043165091425180435,
-0.011476906016469002,
-0.01651832088828087,
0.011480579152703285,
0.041504744440317154,
0.04361133277416229,
-0.006018077954649925,
-0.02894352562725544,
0.04722914099693298,
-0.017943909391760826,
-0.00004309062933316454,
-0.03087511844933033,
0.05190989747643471,
-0.030625050887465477,
-0.008514493703842163,
0.033174727112054825,
0.029118897393345833,
0.0005368159618228674,
-0.012249933555722237,
0.02775649167597294,
-0.0003447323106229305,
-0.002012693090364337,
-0.009474529884755611,
-0.035478174686431885,
0.06097601726651192,
0.006524261087179184,
0.016844354569911957,
0.05365798622369766,
0.028720851987600327,
-0.0025068458635360003,
-0.021082324907183647,
0.015668649226427078,
0.002679196884855628,
-0.0005351055879145861,
0.017545893788337708,
0.007832747884094715,
-0.004635305609554052,
-0.023623628541827202,
-0.008377091027796268,
0.04056858643889427,
0.04334570840001106,
0.0136002441868186,
0.01109078899025917,
-0.013466055504977703,
-0.0664680078625679,
0.009644994512200356,
-0.024302195757627487,
0.007458824664354324,
-0.05214844271540642,
0.020100291818380356,
-0.010026494041085243,
-0.02985561452805996,
-0.038328319787979126,
-0.029383523389697075,
0.007164251524955034,
0.006030282936990261,
0.00794094055891037,
0.01753622107207775,
0.020719490945339203,
0.010211610235273838,
-0.0194581039249897,
0.035423871129751205,
-0.029932882636785507,
-0.007766021881252527,
-0.14486314356327057,
0.010925707407295704,
-0.007937989197671413,
-0.04324357956647873,
-0.08882344514131546,
0.011165243573486805,
-0.023773780092597008,
-0.01015380583703518,
-0.047387924045324326,
-0.016128212213516235,
-0.041737139225006104,
-0.005999359767884016,
0.013388395309448242,
-0.012087917886674404,
-0.08109094947576523,
0.03816105052828789,
0.014179444871842861,
-0.03393837809562683,
-0.023335494101047516,
0.02407107688486576,
0.02560380846261978,
-0.004972133319824934,
0.03367798030376434,
-0.0011246193898841739,
-0.04091755673289299,
-0.008726234547793865,
-0.07033760845661163,
-0.04963310435414314,
-0.024656537920236588,
-0.035592321306467056,
-0.04309447109699249,
-0.005888137500733137,
-0.006161825265735388,
0.01582259312272072,
0.004333659075200558,
-0.027664948254823685,
0.005512813106179237,
-0.012822835706174374,
-0.03291173651814461,
-0.010058296844363213,
-0.0056191603653132915,
0.03139287605881691,
0.0040046293288469315,
-0.027535337954759598,
0.004646981600672007,
0.04019058868288994,
0.003993786405771971,
0.008845406584441662,
-0.023893654346466064,
-0.015919528901576996,
-0.021108584478497505,
0.015810389071702957,
-0.006936275400221348,
0.0035656269174069166,
-0.008795005269348621,
-0.026522433385252953,
0.02600426785647869,
-0.024251531809568405,
0.005050724372267723,
0.05193464830517769,
0.013491055928170681,
-0.020479554310441017,
-0.048145197331905365,
-0.006554523017257452,
-0.01634931191802025,
0.018225276842713356,
-0.0552007332444191,
0.004171932116150856,
-0.027558600530028343,
0.012612851336598396,
-0.011416587978601456,
-0.06389454752206802,
0.0208827406167984,
-0.020408697426319122,
-0.005811988841742277,
-0.004105546046048403,
0.008129581809043884,
-0.02758410945534706,
0.01529692392796278,
-0.009294217452406883,
-0.008144021965563297,
0.0280179213732481,
0.03232976421713829,
-0.06133807823061943,
0.026019148528575897,
-0.005174330435693264,
0.0007120926165953279,
-0.0032910390291363,
0.019023213535547256,
0.002335886936634779,
-0.03912561386823654,
-0.009207958355545998,
-0.008168581873178482,
-0.017747730016708374,
-0.045310087502002716,
0.05343873053789139,
-0.00565947825089097,
-0.029400106519460678,
-0.030083350837230682,
0.01252816617488861,
0.0158101636916399,
-0.008294974453747272,
0.010352909564971924,
-0.0032590427435934544,
-0.047111596912145615,
0.013252547942101955,
-0.0112743666395545,
-0.013589068315923214,
-0.004000677261501551,
0.005087542813271284,
-0.018021903932094574,
-0.00033333132159896195,
-0.04048031568527222,
0.016798702999949455,
-0.03504543751478195,
0.025010671466588974,
-0.005277989897876978,
0.03891948238015175,
-0.019085295498371124,
0.012786949053406715,
0.025022275745868683,
0.019708342850208282,
0.051348619163036346,
-0.025041311979293823,
0.007609436754137278,
0.030408283695578575,
0.03429555147886276,
0.012216144241392612,
-0.007272328715771437,
-0.04235653951764107,
0.04639319330453873,
-0.01306414045393467,
0.015248593874275684,
0.006775038782507181,
0.018950652331113815,
0.034909553825855255,
-0.03394905477762222,
0.006644642446190119,
-0.01762099377810955,
-0.0024855402298271656,
0.008101025596261024,
-0.03375367447733879,
-0.006188732571899891,
-0.019017662853002548,
-0.019059086218476295,
-0.005535351578146219,
0.014461381360888481,
0.018307482823729515,
-0.06552872806787491,
-0.0007927710539661348,
-0.007039242424070835,
-0.0013123381650075316,
0.010969084687530994,
0.0622229129076004,
0.05683481693267822,
0.017676763236522675,
0.005087746772915125,
0.021076716482639313,
0.015463470481336117,
0.03354382887482643,
0.026522303000092506,
-0.024438319727778435,
-0.02516520395874977,
-0.004940522834658623,
-0.05274617299437523,
0.04880465567111969,
0.008841563016176224,
-0.003558458760380745,
-0.04060903936624527,
0.013157058507204056,
0.015554065816104412,
-0.021355075761675835,
0.015793319791555405,
0.020384514704346657,
0.03339964896440506,
-0.048954661935567856,
0.012242660857737064,
-0.008876858279109001,
-0.003259043674916029,
0.005176355596631765,
0.02390613965690136,
-0.006373271811753511,
0.005888943560421467,
0.011506359092891216,
-0.009103633463382721,
-0.005040674936026335,
0.012622724287211895,
0.011780203320086002,
-0.004174364265054464,
-0.017838474363088608,
0.015575234778225422,
-0.03468773886561394,
0.037599705159664154,
-0.0016851845430210233,
0.06367269903421402,
-0.014112565666437149,
-0.02468493953347206,
-0.030312059447169304,
-0.018247436732053757,
-0.020884361118078232,
-0.002256587613373995,
-0.050972890108823776,
0.009571491740643978,
-0.01751895435154438,
0.011746860109269619,
0.024516217410564423,
-0.021752139553427696,
-0.04351698234677315,
-0.00444152532145381,
0.05161236599087715,
-0.028817491605877876,
-0.0019182601245120168,
0.02210352197289467,
-0.0009045286569744349,
-0.007844031788408756,
0.04209046810865402,
-0.03953445702791214,
0.012890617363154888,
-0.018364328891038895,
-0.00501643680036068,
0.07171112298965454,
0.03953823447227478,
0.00451589934527874,
-0.06501351296901703,
0.013011963106691837,
-0.0028581623919308186,
-0.004969378467649221,
0.015636080875992775,
0.01554204523563385,
-0.03415491431951523,
-0.035718247294425964,
-0.014353988692164421,
0.003933607134968042,
0.04424251988530159,
0.024755306541919708,
0.024616621434688568,
-0.028709223493933678,
-0.0389845184981823,
0.009612261317670345,
-0.0088416188955307,
0.04147748649120331,
0.004233070183545351,
-0.036067306995391846,
-0.01702379807829857
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:28
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
In my opinion however, the wife over the very long period of cohabitation made a much greater contribution than the husband to the welfare of the family, particularly as homemaker and parent. I am satisfied on the evidence that in her homemaker and parenting role the wife in that role and by way of general contribution to the family's welfare carried out responsibilities well beyond the norm.
She had the responsibility of the home and the children almost entirely without the husband's assistance for a very long period of time. Amongst other things, she thereby enabled him to work and earn income over and above his full time work as well as his full time work.
In this family she was the uniting force and the one who provided the support, love and affection necessary to maintain this particular family unit over a long time.
This was made especially hard by the husband's abuse and denigration of her and the children in the ways described by them in their evidence, which I largely accept on this issue,
as well as by his attitude to `women's work' and by his drinking which necessitated the wife working especially hard and harder than would be usual in normal situations as homemaker, parent and as the prime navigator of the welfare of this family through the many seas of problems and difficulties which confronted them over the years.
These are special factors of the kind to which the Full Court drew attention in Ferraro v Ferraro 16 Fam LR 1, especially at pages 38, 39 and 47, that being a decision affirmed in McLay v McLay 20 Fam LR 239 at pages 248 to 249, and is no doubt what Baker J had in mind when speaking for the Full Court in Doherty v Doherty 20 Fam LR 137 at page 141.
His Honour's remarks, although, in my respectful opinion, obiter and given in an extempore judgment, are entitled to great respect. They do not represent new law. It has been suggested in some quarters since that judgment was delivered that they have, but I disagree with that suggestion.
The remarks of Baker J in Doherty's case were simply an expression, in the context of domestic violence, of the passages in Ferraro's case cited above. Neither Ferraro's case nor Doherty's case purported to overrule Soblusky (1976) 2 Fam LR 1, nor Ferguson (1978) 4 Fam LR 312, where investigation of fault or misconduct per se was deprecated.
Any intention to overrule Ferguson was deprecated in Ferraro's case at page 39, and I am, with respect, unable to accept that either Fogarty J or Baker J, who were members of the Full Court in both Ferraro and Doherty, would have intended such decisions to be overruled without expressly saying so.
155In Green v Robinson (1995) 36 NSWLR 96 Cole J at 119 after discussing the dictionary definitions of "homemaker" adopted the definition as "one who creates and maintains a comfortable and welcoming ambience for the members of their household". He went on to say at page 119:-
"However, even such a second meaning is inadequate if it is intended to convey that only one person in a household may be responsible for the creation or maintenance of such a welcoming ambience for it is clear, in my view, that each party to a relationship, be it of marriage or of a de facto relationship, may contribute to the homemaking in which that relationship subsists.
Parties to the relationship may, depending upon their various capacities, skills, inclinations, interests, available time and other factors, contribute significantly to the making of a home. The concept of " homemaker" or "making of a home" has a different and wider connotation than housekeeping or maintaining a house. It involves the creation of an emotional ambience of stability.
To take but three examples. A person, not infrequently the male in the relationship, may have skills related to home improvements which are exercised for the mutual advantage of the parties in the relationship. That is an aspect of homemaking for it permits the more pleasant enjoyment of the domestic relationship.
|
[
-0.014250542968511581,
0.007596943993121386,
-0.07122562825679779,
0.032167669385671616,
0.014357337728142738,
-0.022949492558836937,
0.010218036361038685,
0.04029201343655586,
0.01630212925374508,
-0.01278417743742466,
-0.004518529400229454,
0.07063349336385727,
-0.054644979536533356,
-0.023418553173542023,
-0.039591144770383835,
-0.027492795139551163,
0.023824144154787064,
-0.0679958239197731,
-0.03758050873875618,
0.0021764941047877073,
-0.020931271836161613,
-0.014879736118018627,
0.032700762152671814,
-0.0029749779496341944,
-0.006793054286390543,
0.01832621358335018,
0.01976526342332363,
-0.0006272286991588771,
-0.007902778685092926,
-0.015511895529925823,
0.008547380566596985,
-0.021034738048911095,
-0.0016602418618276715,
0.0098400404676795,
0.0035112611949443817,
-0.010512124747037888,
-0.034083861857652664,
-0.022784631699323654,
-0.016291720792651176,
0.031172527000308037,
-0.005752022843807936,
-0.005480483639985323,
-0.01541329175233841,
-0.06670982390642166,
0.049178726971149445,
-0.017837341874837875,
-0.049907561391592026,
-0.005929183680564165,
-0.03418917953968048,
-0.042046528309583664,
-0.04295216128230095,
-0.0349813811480999,
0.06167248263955116,
-0.021775290369987488,
0.00410116370767355,
0.061120063066482544,
-0.021036667749285698,
0.008863752707839012,
-0.035391680896282196,
0.00037960492772981524,
-0.01951594278216362,
-0.005875179078429937,
-0.024460898712277412,
-0.012391466647386551,
0.0007096441695466638,
0.04051840677857399,
0.00029462348902598023,
0.026871858164668083,
-0.006986337713897228,
-0.04419887810945511,
0.026175346225500107,
-0.012149211019277573,
-0.006857701577246189,
-0.010747579857707024,
-0.05847344920039177,
0.030422354117035866,
-0.024971112608909607,
0.038081925362348557,
-0.04546327516436577,
0.040016207844018936,
0.016295190900564194,
-0.021068548783659935,
0.022602124139666557,
0.03246789053082466,
-0.05704893544316292,
-0.014154216274619102,
-0.023304542526602745,
0.012998088262975216,
0.025202078744769096,
-0.03745216131210327,
-0.045112814754247665,
0.010979300364851952,
0.027753932401537895,
-0.00006970121467020363,
-0.029368819668889046,
0.04482179135084152,
-0.06421147286891937,
-0.012018262408673763,
0.009408066049218178,
-0.00169843970797956,
0.008906270377337933,
0.01363519299775362,
0.027007384225726128,
-0.030271261930465698,
-0.007905478589236736,
-0.025134531781077385,
0.009904779493808746,
0.006608608178794384,
0.04217558726668358,
0.027027374133467674,
0.02407700940966606,
0.008033940568566322,
0.042574867606163025,
0.046418145298957825,
-0.027322091162204742,
-0.007507687900215387,
0.04766405373811722,
-0.0418950654566288,
-0.012237804010510445,
0.014465298503637314,
-0.010431370697915554,
0.06547963619232178,
0.05749153718352318,
-0.04050973802804947,
-0.058894213289022446,
0.025749579071998596,
-0.013611799106001854,
0.0005879363161511719,
-0.05955498665571213,
0.027642248198390007,
0.012640240602195263,
-0.0015386908780783415,
-0.0036378814838826656,
-0.03936316445469856,
-0.004684308543801308,
0.008342952467501163,
0.034385208040475845,
-0.02316850982606411,
-0.015021544881165028,
0.016261190176010132,
0.032743729650974274,
0.028709648177027702,
0.0008494863286614418,
-0.0012942523462697864,
-0.005968295969069004,
-0.016532648354768753,
0.000049210848374059424,
-0.06082509085536003,
0.0034923201892524958,
-0.026411011815071106,
-0.018815066665410995,
0.020244920626282692,
0.03725583478808403,
-0.026335880160331726,
0.06989652663469315,
-0.036481231451034546,
0.01303474698215723,
0.04831131175160408,
-0.037688229233026505,
0.010673768818378448,
0.027843929827213287,
0.029564807191491127,
0.019769225269556046,
-0.00514706876128912,
-0.023269422352313995,
-0.023563327267766,
-0.018098508939146996,
0.033061832189559937,
-0.028434958308935165,
-0.010834979824721813,
0.018901577219367027,
-0.0310403760522604,
-0.000018680615539778955,
-0.010898886248469353,
0.039323851466178894,
0.019882068037986755,
0.035832539200782776,
0.021364498883485794,
0.004105479456484318,
-0.035796649754047394,
-0.0063461801037192345,
-0.01862204074859619,
0.004295827820897102,
0.005081181414425373,
-0.027173124253749847,
0.007463672198355198,
-0.0021305333357304335,
-0.050300728529691696,
0.03284713625907898,
-0.01907714642584324,
-0.052446942776441574,
-0.05998764932155609,
0.03929825499653816,
0.020763356238603592,
0.050090301781892776,
-0.02779759094119072,
-0.00440365681424737,
-0.007569780107587576,
0.03519362583756447,
-0.019683120772242546,
0.001473727053962648,
0.041287075728178024,
0.03468184545636177,
0.02722819708287716,
-0.04054088518023491,
-0.010216228663921356,
-0.06798218935728073,
-0.02882462367415428,
0.016040107235312462,
-0.018187997862696648,
-0.004399206023663282,
0.03686262294650078,
0.013495742343366146,
-0.00235822144895792,
-0.020201316103339195,
-0.011913849040865898,
0.0007121045491658151,
-0.01128636859357357,
0.029171960428357124,
-0.00028734267107211053,
-0.019379155710339546,
0.013512968085706234,
0.04521865025162697,
-0.020343948155641556,
0.00513265747576952,
0.01280204113572836,
0.007797291502356529,
0.004684580955654383,
0.04226062819361687,
-0.007210679817944765,
0.0330733023583889,
-0.0007063818629831076,
-0.024327054619789124,
-0.003971861209720373,
-0.03148064762353897,
-0.017413122579455376,
0.0030775212217122316,
0.022242777049541473,
-0.003407846437767148,
-0.02347482368350029,
0.021920708939433098,
0.005711693316698074,
0.03261163830757141,
-0.07395224273204803,
-0.002273971913382411,
-0.002740885829553008,
0.017442643642425537,
0.01741141639649868,
0.010113740339875221,
-0.012182826176285744,
0.03913378715515137,
-0.01089462824165821,
0.002475539455190301,
0.0005286414525471628,
0.04579992592334747,
0.037607286125421524,
0.018972011283040047,
-0.021264320239424706,
0.03618895635008812,
-0.0231330469250679,
0.015031212009489536,
0.006769849918782711,
0.0332769975066185,
-0.0035222466103732586,
0.005277598742395639,
-0.041303444653749466,
-0.043351102620363235,
-0.02543490007519722,
-0.0004955008625984192,
0.03184669092297554,
0.025028450414538383,
-0.040090303868055344,
0.012363622896373272,
-0.030736420303583145,
0.0028120323549956083,
0.02686060406267643,
0.023164691403508186,
-0.02937278524041176,
0.04479721188545227,
-0.016399096697568893,
0.04455982521176338,
0.025125905871391296,
0.019285518676042557,
-0.027587635442614555,
0.012849552556872368,
0.02371964231133461,
0.006240754388272762,
-0.03948178514838219,
0.02720542624592781,
-0.06321544200181961,
0.0739831030368805,
-0.0160683523863554,
0.08410059660673141,
-0.006507954094558954,
-0.10799640417098999,
0.004476030357182026,
0.021273169666528702,
-0.15471412241458893,
0.026035955175757408,
0.037479862570762634,
0.0218725074082613,
0.010768274776637554,
0.029606474563479424,
0.004335756413638592,
0.024147430434823036,
0.026126541197299957,
-0.006530804559588432,
-0.006695446092635393,
-0.0662408322095871,
-0.018219610676169395,
0.006626347079873085,
-0.030850600451231003,
-0.01173319946974516,
-0.01743423193693161,
0.01606353186070919,
-0.029837986454367638,
-0.03627674654126167,
-0.0019000923493877053,
-0.023698173463344574,
0.031581051647663116,
0.0031871178653091192,
-0.004623703192919493,
0.03308345377445221,
0.009612900204956532,
0.012649000622332096,
-0.02189396135509014,
-0.01890805922448635,
-0.019908979535102844,
0.0003398059925530106,
-0.00230046221986413,
0.01383924763649702,
-0.006367036607116461,
0.013581587933003902,
0.006535481661558151,
-0.08216918259859085,
-0.0009171530837193131,
0.009122260846197605,
-0.005412290338426828,
-0.0000572054268559441,
0.016746429726481438,
0.0009608253603801131,
0.0006399230333045125,
-0.06445976346731186,
0.012805026955902576,
-0.012743242084980011,
-0.03760402649641037,
0.024038776755332947,
-0.03128383681178093,
0.004424888640642166,
-0.043510135263204575,
0.0242304764688015,
-0.04483475163578987,
-0.03544754162430763,
-0.01279287226498127,
0.025681139901280403,
0.03042575716972351,
0.029434436932206154,
-0.03424575552344322,
-0.010761368088424206,
0.05044540762901306,
0.003173856297507882,
-0.03848449885845184,
0.030990052968263626,
-0.035829249769449234,
0.048786599189043045,
0.01203659176826477,
0.003095682244747877,
0.007663269527256489,
-0.0566156841814518,
0.021094264462590218,
-0.002998646115884185,
0.00533763412386179,
0.004501215647906065,
0.02014630287885666,
-0.018412062898278236,
-0.009165634401142597,
-0.06295501440763474,
0.028101934120059013,
-0.0015632561407983303,
-0.01051349937915802,
0.043615177273750305,
-0.005436085630208254,
-0.005500222090631723,
-0.0019873178098350763,
0.02353079244494438,
0.053478676825761795,
0.25223466753959656,
0.059584781527519226,
0.0559186115860939,
-0.029241077601909637,
0.006854192353785038,
0.004316252656280994,
0.0465855747461319,
0.01713930070400238,
0.020857812836766243,
-0.05748644098639488,
-0.06640714406967163,
0.022577285766601562,
0.02333822287619114,
0.01731126196682453,
-0.03479862958192825,
0.03751932829618454,
-0.016543401405215263,
0.008266175165772438,
0.0744580626487732,
-0.004239559173583984,
0.01502304244786501,
-0.018288597464561462,
0.019057851284742355,
0.0014977839309722185,
-0.031187796965241432,
-0.031123392283916473,
0.00540239317342639,
-0.008396688848733902,
0.0023007793352007866,
0.0037261787801980972,
-0.04667094349861145,
-0.04361594840884209,
0.0699206218123436,
-0.03978008031845093,
0.03762116655707359,
-0.0022052484564483166,
0.004897856153547764,
-0.0446903295814991,
-0.05053114891052246,
0.05249788984656334,
0.012310761958360672,
-0.027233272790908813,
-0.04799104109406471,
-0.04903256148099899,
-0.020314380526542664,
-0.0021248047705739737,
0.0030197612941265106,
-0.004934778902679682,
-0.016312694177031517,
0.004286596085876226,
-0.030648214742541313,
0.023600857704877853,
-0.017369244247674942,
0.03110608458518982,
-0.024873943999409676,
0.01721802167594433,
-0.006991398986428976,
0.01989266648888588,
0.002500508213415742,
0.06251528859138489,
0.044700440019369125,
0.009943303652107716,
-0.00538653414696455,
-0.03170064836740494,
0.03263800963759422,
0.04827863350510597,
-0.035488858819007874,
-0.04345264285802841,
0.03934493288397789,
0.023226909339427948,
0.0039386870339512825,
0.01748688891530037,
0.06133509427309036,
0.05062905326485634,
0.015951724722981453,
-0.028232654556632042,
0.058648597449064255,
0.01747080497443676,
0.036813437938690186,
0.0411338247358799,
-0.07227757573127747,
-0.03605940565466881,
0.029481125995516777,
-0.030547717586159706,
0.006747667212039232,
-0.004624361637979746,
-0.03150968998670578,
0.05314485356211662,
0.024163512513041496,
-0.010490207932889462,
-0.034418899565935135,
-0.008575803600251675,
-0.02000909484922886,
-0.002021648222580552,
-0.05918525904417038,
-0.022008847445249557,
-0.005977389868348837,
-0.012001789174973965,
0.0015548837836831808,
-0.04735720530152321,
-0.030253557488322258,
0.008478768169879913,
0.01416107453405857,
0.0008544581360183656,
-0.008518158458173275,
-0.008609257638454437,
-0.04667128622531891,
-0.00006025396578479558,
-0.007010411471128464,
0.016168760135769844,
-0.011304452084004879,
-0.018278399482369423,
-0.026700381189584732,
-0.013335276395082474,
0.0428733192384243,
0.042269766330718994,
-0.03110012225806713,
-0.011003642342984676,
0.037582989782094955,
-0.0028578287456184626,
-0.01634473167359829,
0.02235894836485386,
0.002560647204518318,
-0.005200238898396492,
-0.01628420501947403,
0.00563992653042078,
-0.029204143211245537,
-0.01591450162231922,
0.005093226209282875,
0.009199987165629864,
0.021692421287298203,
-0.049797650426626205,
-0.04414580389857292,
0.04241471737623215,
0.026387130841612816,
0.014836113899946213,
0.03706645593047142,
-0.023828011006116867,
-0.0573401004076004,
0.019074078649282455,
-0.05760134011507034,
-0.038105547428131104,
-0.033415429294109344,
0.02260470576584339,
0.010270752012729645,
0.021507225930690765,
-0.0651412084698677,
0.009113598614931107,
-0.002552069490775466,
-0.003799219848588109,
0.01906520314514637,
-0.004745205398648977,
-0.019363675266504288,
-0.00148188101593405,
0.014906068332493305,
0.04079437628388405,
-0.0000608899790677242,
-0.04590914025902748,
0.059233393520116806,
-0.03455810993909836,
-0.010060084983706474,
-0.009829011745750904,
-0.018791548907756805,
0.06140480190515518,
0.040916942059993744,
0.06288732588291168,
0.03174181655049324,
0.014831118285655975,
-0.004164486192166805,
-0.050929684191942215,
-0.02019827626645565,
-0.061655912548303604,
-0.02175462432205677,
-0.004764670040458441,
0.03377019986510277,
0.029577840119600296,
-0.011474068276584148,
0.05551648512482643,
0.038995467126369476,
-0.0253203883767128,
0.00988271925598383,
0.03304451331496239,
-0.02140755206346512,
0.01664968952536583,
-0.00899980403482914,
0.012118717655539513,
0.08299461752176285,
-0.008115571923553944,
0.029486034065485,
-0.0523662269115448,
0.007721093483269215,
0.09625058621168137,
-0.0225510336458683,
0.002506610006093979,
-0.02719859592616558,
0.023125803098082542,
0.01629525050520897,
0.028553400188684464,
0.005053762346506119,
-0.03212374821305275,
-0.022731874138116837,
0.042786840349435806,
0.019397113472223282,
0.014842156320810318,
0.026497673243284225,
-0.03165892884135246,
0.006708982866257429,
0.028161171823740005,
-0.024678196758031845,
-0.002885245019569993,
0.009845553897321224,
0.002360690850764513,
-0.02727067656815052,
0.005668628495186567,
-0.04741491377353668,
-0.004878941457718611,
0.008566702716052532,
0.03232749179005623,
0.01868779957294464,
-0.02189801260828972,
0.004944159649312496,
-0.031002597883343697,
0.002319830935448408,
-0.050031449645757675,
-0.042088188230991364,
-0.00036273381556384265,
-0.01458518672734499,
0.006764033809304237,
-0.012210769578814507,
-0.0075619518756866455,
0.007682593539357185,
-0.0761490911245346,
0.03439474105834961,
0.00011623798491200432,
-0.010091827251017094,
-0.030446732416749,
0.005936691537499428,
0.016250500455498695,
-0.0265033058822155,
-0.014822650700807571,
-0.006937467958778143,
-0.005923775490373373,
0.020991582423448563,
0.0840832069516182,
-0.0012812023051083088,
-0.046643417328596115,
-0.029506975784897804,
0.010987025685608387,
0.01867612451314926,
0.061680592596530914,
-0.035119637846946716,
0.013832182623445988,
-0.030397413298487663,
-0.0070074256509542465,
0.012047612108290195,
-0.020853042602539062,
-0.018184678629040718,
0.05437341704964638,
-0.027460401877760887,
-0.03656024485826492,
0.06168987974524498,
0.06975539028644562,
0.012528588995337486,
-0.02808089181780815,
-0.06096285954117775,
-0.028955060988664627,
0.00406383303925395,
-0.023677870631217957,
-0.006664464250206947,
-0.029728425666689873,
-0.0018074677791446447,
0.00406835088506341,
0.0056536211632192135,
-0.006560437846928835,
0.019406480714678764,
0.009148729033768177,
-0.022247672080993652,
-0.0019500580383464694,
0.006992470473051071,
0.027206774801015854,
0.04645141586661339,
0.03033343143761158,
0.008134202100336552,
0.056740954518318176,
0.021485649049282074,
0.0005354105960577726,
0.041091807186603546,
0.016925670206546783,
0.02513960190117359,
-0.007479537278413773,
0.03345917910337448,
0.00789799727499485,
-0.0018508266657590866,
0.018488269299268723,
0.03611532971262932,
0.04348644241690636,
0.008117548190057278,
0.004751541186124086,
-0.014946871437132359,
0.010303230956196785,
-0.021807145327329636,
-0.008488263934850693,
-0.0003124080249108374,
-0.001872373977676034,
-0.003025694051757455,
0.042937763035297394,
0.05139174312353134,
-0.05257587134838104,
0.0011567100882530212,
0.015966622158885002,
-0.039045482873916626,
-0.06607480347156525,
0.019937824457883835,
-0.026606129482388496,
0.03785872459411621,
0.044682808220386505,
0.022461609914898872,
-0.0376138836145401,
0.00024391087936237454,
0.026098519563674927,
0.029779164120554924,
-0.003773550735786557,
-0.04257747530937195,
-0.025910241529345512,
-0.02752617746591568,
0.03156382218003273,
0.012714178301393986,
-0.05453392490744591,
-0.025275031104683876,
0.02643660083413124,
-0.03113585151731968,
-0.01907924748957157,
-0.034693989902734756,
-0.0027164521161466837,
0.027140557765960693,
-0.019214075058698654,
0.016880204901099205,
-0.00259365513920784,
0.07243522256612778,
-0.016484109684824944,
-0.011980187147855759,
-0.03956064581871033,
0.08285540342330933,
-0.015975870192050934,
0.03447694703936577,
0.026713240891695023,
-0.011580918915569782,
-0.0019913436844944954,
0.038385242223739624,
-0.011788266710937023,
-0.0157071053981781,
-0.0015058816643431783,
-0.05153845623135567,
-0.030222134664654732,
0.0521656833589077,
-0.003082118695601821,
0.019041042774915695,
-0.022402742877602577,
0.03530948981642723,
-0.020061295479536057,
0.02401174232363701,
-0.02920340560376644,
0.007484860252588987,
-0.005598790943622589,
-0.019858449697494507,
-0.02447454258799553,
-0.04296157881617546,
-0.030958151444792747,
0.004067984875291586,
-0.0044273738749325275,
0.018265625461935997,
0.007399915251880884,
0.03429635986685753,
-0.014940458349883556,
-0.03907863050699234,
-0.02411220595240593,
0.0006237255875021219,
0.006886611692607403,
0.0072819143533706665,
0.026620954275131226,
-0.006824629846960306,
-0.05116639658808708,
0.008153177797794342,
0.02298809215426445,
-0.006205016281455755,
0.005162226501852274,
0.04094121977686882,
0.015294065698981285,
-0.010545246303081512,
0.011125419288873672,
0.005760605446994305,
0.05770697817206383,
-0.011044017039239407,
0.0027938990388065577,
-0.13930758833885193,
0.03680561110377312,
-0.025340132415294647,
0.024779388681054115,
-0.062333714216947556,
-0.010667992755770683,
-0.03759308159351349,
-0.00588711304590106,
-0.023487750440835953,
0.005321646109223366,
0.022403744980692863,
-0.03003411553800106,
0.007713963743299246,
-0.03507072851061821,
-0.048922158777713776,
0.009011107496917248,
-0.03385308384895325,
-0.048355381935834885,
-0.02013120986521244,
0.042802512645721436,
-0.009740658104419708,
-0.009073811583220959,
-0.018557578325271606,
0.006980016827583313,
-0.013227059505879879,
-0.019462058320641518,
-0.034747958183288574,
-0.03309484198689461,
-0.0558452270925045,
0.01936037838459015,
-0.023901494219899178,
-0.041544247418642044,
0.01553245261311531,
0.000638147525023669,
-0.028611965477466583,
-0.006416916381567717,
-0.005424594506621361,
0.012742188759148121,
-0.03365703299641609,
0.03696403652429581,
-0.01123509556055069,
0.017183123156428337,
-0.0188260730355978,
-0.01442981418222189,
0.021254491060972214,
0.03714558482170105,
0.01930440589785576,
0.0014886236749589443,
-0.019234495237469673,
-0.016965478658676147,
-0.03401060029864311,
-0.0048699271865189075,
0.05011414363980293,
0.027937309816479683,
0.0017258590087294579,
-0.01594380848109722,
-0.002760955598205328,
-0.0550876185297966,
-0.0028117417823523283,
0.04423557221889496,
0.018681665882468224,
-0.03054014779627323,
-0.019290225580334663,
-0.03282627835869789,
0.022058112546801567,
-0.008857275359332561,
-0.024215372279286385,
0.031976472586393356,
-0.03542351350188255,
0.020817207172513008,
0.008152593858540058,
-0.03781874477863312,
-0.007675774861127138,
0.0036759995855391026,
-0.012346997857093811,
0.005736099556088448,
0.01138988882303238,
0.009760168381035328,
-0.004840396810323,
0.014040175825357437,
-0.022503787651658058,
0.0066081322729587555,
-0.006491249892860651,
0.008401690982282162,
0.007039137650281191,
0.02949593774974346,
-0.0035153375938534737,
-0.03674807772040367,
-0.007269633933901787,
-0.003957598935812712,
-0.021842319518327713,
-0.0008389435242861509,
-0.022742142900824547,
0.010327396914362907,
0.017752481624484062,
0.045453447848558426,
-0.024686340242624283,
-0.0055539594031870365,
-0.047630444169044495,
-0.011787978000938892,
-0.03372132405638695,
-0.033263515681028366,
0.006042356602847576,
-0.007479664403945208,
-0.02662103809416294,
0.03736591339111328,
-0.03967073932290077,
-0.0006710492307320237,
0.034009210765361786,
-0.0003070657839998603,
0.0081338407471776,
-0.006653479300439358,
-0.023850372061133385,
-0.03374052792787552,
0.0034653330221772194,
0.02409469522535801,
0.01126868650317192,
0.03867679834365845,
0.012433740310370922,
0.00105112767778337,
0.004474974237382412,
-0.044584568589925766,
-0.007194444537162781,
-0.00995531864464283,
-0.02500852197408676,
-0.0009816285455599427,
0.03109605237841606,
0.0014325198717415333,
0.04147389158606529,
-0.022114822641015053,
0.06340622156858444,
-0.08602780848741531,
0.018183395266532898,
0.038444582372903824,
0.03249339386820793,
0.02134227193892002,
-0.02808166667819023,
0.00530585739761591,
-0.02835952304303646,
-0.014733156189322472,
0.0006870167562738061,
0.000617468380369246,
0.010385304689407349,
-0.026000885292887688,
-0.029680399224162102,
-0.013159006834030151,
-0.016929859295487404,
0.009664410725235939,
-0.046464815735816956,
0.0028765727765858173,
-0.005119475070387125,
-0.03710748627781868,
0.02538636326789856,
0.062441952526569366,
0.04447918012738228,
0.01288602501153946,
0.01726522110402584,
0.01546838041394949,
-0.0010207860032096505,
0.06220843642950058,
0.016183258965611458,
-0.023591667413711548,
-0.02077833004295826,
-0.023728393018245697,
-0.03021899238228798,
0.06246902421116829,
0.016296178102493286,
-0.028507614508271217,
-0.04291488602757454,
-0.034168168902397156,
0.03083682246506214,
0.00840208400040865,
0.009060810320079327,
-0.001561746234074235,
0.010109620168805122,
-0.06921660900115967,
-0.00013439655594993383,
0.023472648113965988,
0.024152269586920738,
0.0032626993488520384,
0.020546482875943184,
0.008999085985124111,
-0.007359068840742111,
0.01057429425418377,
0.015606623142957687,
0.056521009653806686,
0.018751075491309166,
-0.010066583752632141,
0.012607607990503311,
-0.04620622843503952,
-0.01576206646859646,
-0.026774153113365173,
0.05906589329242706,
-0.0060683609917759895,
0.016745328903198242,
0.0260408166795969,
-0.01793578825891018,
0.022602206096053123,
-0.0027847259771078825,
0.0023443077225238085,
0.025726458057761192,
0.00406476017087698,
-0.021251235157251358,
-0.003288557752966881,
-0.021243372932076454,
-0.06257806718349457,
-0.031598735600709915,
-0.028665583580732346,
-0.03203771263360977,
-0.0005457759252749383,
-0.03773635998368263,
-0.0001591510808793828,
-0.007654580287635326,
0.037267331033945084,
0.017339544370770454,
0.014223085716366768,
0.010640371590852737,
-0.014159651473164558,
0.005377266090363264,
-0.0033443267457187176,
0.020395290106534958,
0.048397939652204514,
-0.0072359349578619,
-0.09805433452129364,
0.01889592409133911,
0.027717655524611473,
-0.029609104618430138,
-0.0455850251019001,
-0.011152563616633415,
-0.03123646415770054,
-0.01662398874759674,
-0.012785688042640686,
0.01756075583398342,
0.029503511264920235,
0.04162512347102165,
-0.002707136794924736,
0.0015101877506822348,
-0.03226814791560173,
-0.016074422746896744,
-0.0033309252467006445,
0.03165971115231514,
0.004471510648727417,
-0.015079048462212086,
-0.009167864918708801
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:51
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
Why not? To try and understand why not is part of the psychology of the whole situation. Why did she not do the sensible thing?
Q. And there is an answer to this. That is she has exaggerated or taken out of context matters that have happened in her relationship for financial gain?
A. Well, the things she reports to me that were said to her and done strike me as being beyond the normal, beyond the healthy. As I tried to allude to previously, she didn't seem to me to take the opportunity to grossly exaggerate things when she could have."
267These responses seem to me to quite reasonable. It should not be forgotten that a lot of the abuse is said to be continuous, see the evidence in respect of the abusive language in 1993. Exhibit P in the proceedings is a collection of emails between the parties after separation.
They contain many emails from the defendant using expletives and direct sexual references which made Dr Fischer blush. This is put forward to play down the effect of the language used by the plaintiff. However it seems to me that they are in a limited time frame and probably said in the protective environment of emails and distance between the parties.
268But what of the contrary opinion of Dr Klug? His interview with the defendant was made difficult in that she continually referred him to her affidavit instead of answering his enquiries about any assaults. He described the results in these terms:
"On specific and persistent enquiry about the history of assaults in the relationship, despite describing difficulties in the relationship and verbal abuse from Mr. Cooper, she said he had never physically assaulted her. There is one episode when she said she was "dragged" when he grabbed her by the arm and marched her down a set of stairs.
Specifically however, there were no other incidents of physical aggression, according to Ms. Mulcahy's history at interview. There is also no history of sexual violence. When I persisted further along this line of enquiry she simply stated that she found it very difficult to talk about the situation and could not give me an answer. She referred me to her affidavit."
269It seems that Dr Klug has proceeded on the basis that although he has read the affidavit he places no great reliance on it in contrast to what little he elicited in the interview. For example there is no reference in his report to the threats to shoot or maim.
There could be several reasons for her attitude. She may have wished to be non-cooperative or she may have had a real difficulty in reliving the events again in the telling process. I think the latter is more likely.
270Having regard to these matters and the other matters appearing in the cross examination I prefer the evidence of Dr Fischer to that of Dr Klug on this aspect. There is an unresolved question as to when the disability commenced to have an effect upon her.
Dr Fischer suggests that she experienced an insidious deterioration in her capacity to assert herself in the relationship and that the disability occurred "from the earliest time in the relationship". Dr Kraushaar expresses some views on its commencement date but I will not have regard to them for the reasons already expressed.
271In my view the disability would have commenced after the events in 1993 and continued until a time shortly after the commencement of the proceedings in the Statement of Claim, August 2008, when she started to respond to the claim.
The limitation period is therefore suspended, by reason of her disability, until this time. Applying the three-year limitation period, she brought the proceedings within time.
272The updated table would appear as follows (updated areas in bold):
No. Incident Date of incident Applicable legislation and limitation period Date limitation period expired Date at which action "brought"
1. Argument (assault) May 1993 s 18A May 1996 27 August 2008
|
[
-0.05739207938313484,
0.008183954283595085,
-0.01180066354572773,
-0.014054466038942337,
-0.021581504493951797,
0.008810466155409813,
0.007745260838419199,
-0.0065453872084617615,
0.020580796524882317,
-0.015615440905094147,
0.02690664678812027,
0.07708209753036499,
-0.025850581005215645,
0.0112770339474082,
0.044610582292079926,
0.0016120014479383826,
0.04049968719482422,
-0.01996626704931259,
-0.009161029011011124,
-0.0072590671479702,
-0.01234361995011568,
-0.0164084080606699,
0.05720514431595802,
0.023802651092410088,
-0.00803686585277319,
0.04147850722074509,
-0.02206650748848915,
-0.029644299298524857,
0.00805843435227871,
0.03338109329342842,
0.009947818703949451,
-0.016903627663850784,
0.040644172579050064,
-0.008502771146595478,
-0.00755209568887949,
-0.012607351876795292,
0.001194084296002984,
-0.019944999366998672,
-0.028647810220718384,
0.018532689660787582,
-0.02968149073421955,
0.014930539764463902,
-0.00368688371963799,
-0.006176235619932413,
0.03837786987423897,
-0.037680044770240784,
0.02422439493238926,
-0.030234746634960175,
-0.002922915853559971,
-0.01967286691069603,
-0.02301630564033985,
-0.025131674483418465,
0.05929889529943466,
-0.012559730559587479,
0.04304292052984238,
0.019376136362552643,
0.0029899422079324722,
-0.02466982789337635,
-0.04780227690935135,
0.011908920481801033,
-0.0332520492374897,
-0.020308522507548332,
-0.0010686328168958426,
-0.010091920383274555,
0.0023671812377870083,
0.08509855717420578,
-0.02697434090077877,
-0.03705572709441185,
0.002844834001734853,
-0.050195641815662384,
0.0052194977179169655,
0.01756872609257698,
0.01186799630522728,
-0.020209014415740967,
-0.08333694934844971,
0.011541004292666912,
0.04136558249592781,
0.048551253974437714,
0.005465610418468714,
0.06624224036931992,
0.020564358681440353,
0.018611252307891846,
0.044513970613479614,
0.02890971675515175,
-0.02646115981042385,
0.01593106798827648,
-0.05454017221927643,
0.006435939110815525,
0.02591228485107422,
-0.03429798409342766,
-0.033684346824884415,
0.0056485082022845745,
-0.001166866859421134,
-0.05121683329343796,
-0.016925297677516937,
0.008201748132705688,
-0.04374631494283676,
-0.02437877468764782,
-0.010645145550370216,
0.011513653211295605,
0.01386187318712473,
0.009792030788958073,
0.0035668867640197277,
-0.02780773490667343,
0.002442119177430868,
-0.002642806386575103,
0.024990634992718697,
0.06422954052686691,
0.028309961780905724,
-0.01806924305856228,
0.01569562964141369,
0.028287705034017563,
0.02511562965810299,
0.006419649813324213,
-0.024967780336737633,
0.01678500883281231,
-0.002597386483103037,
-0.02430877834558487,
0.006447827909141779,
-0.023164791986346245,
0.05567789450287819,
0.012981701642274857,
0.048439037054777145,
-0.009360711090266705,
-0.0529872290790081,
0.03743615001440048,
-0.022151878103613853,
0.005912773311138153,
-0.056953053921461105,
0.04107518121600151,
0.0019444789504632354,
0.006408117711544037,
-0.03743819519877434,
-0.07125133275985718,
-0.009640167467296124,
-0.03396524116396904,
0.053246743977069855,
0.04644527658820152,
0.024814428761601448,
-0.015688836574554443,
0.044507261365652084,
-0.009258653037250042,
0.03522869572043419,
-0.03742252290248871,
0.026785235852003098,
-0.026139216497540474,
0.006627176888287067,
-0.009649282321333885,
0.029523754492402077,
-0.008138656616210938,
0.004017241299152374,
-0.0026341029442846775,
0.031140310689806938,
-0.0040578036569058895,
0.011487645097076893,
-0.0311674103140831,
0.0074949441477656364,
0.001268019201233983,
0.023140843957662582,
0.01608792319893837,
0.005114764906466007,
0.026072097942233086,
-0.04879724979400635,
-0.040032848715782166,
0.0343952439725399,
0.01681433990597725,
0.01650586724281311,
0.026222502812743187,
-0.03304986655712128,
-0.03499658405780792,
0.027878154069185257,
-0.027590202167630196,
0.04010828584432602,
-0.03604111075401306,
0.0226704441010952,
0.006527342367917299,
0.0037963686045259237,
0.004783191252499819,
0.029149120673537254,
-0.0021978674922138453,
-0.05382860451936722,
0.013510939665138721,
0.017467502504587173,
-0.011775064282119274,
-0.017011431977152824,
-0.004716579802334309,
-0.03571709617972374,
-0.05835415795445442,
0.019931752234697342,
0.009260419756174088,
-0.026844162493944168,
-0.05284995213150978,
0.009171782061457634,
0.025738868862390518,
0.018045326694846153,
-0.0436025932431221,
0.00883729849010706,
-0.021991973742842674,
-0.015552804805338383,
-0.061476048082113266,
-0.022099558264017105,
0.03901457414031029,
0.032897088676691055,
-0.0167675893753767,
-0.018961114808917046,
-0.026163598522543907,
-0.036711931228637695,
-0.015468945726752281,
0.014287171885371208,
-0.06102350354194641,
0.005423569120466709,
0.055156778544187546,
-0.013278238475322723,
0.030401941388845444,
-0.0006065071793273091,
0.0011686207726597786,
0.03148820996284485,
0.0024068672209978104,
0.032452624291181564,
-0.021430186927318573,
-0.024041160941123962,
0.018914993852376938,
-0.008402080275118351,
-0.020044071599841118,
-0.008835907094180584,
0.030407074838876724,
-0.020512592047452927,
0.00982113927602768,
0.008279446512460709,
-0.03869136422872543,
0.08823362737894058,
0.04370836168527603,
0.0380813404917717,
-0.002466436242684722,
0.019538553431630135,
-0.00040434469701722264,
0.047263890504837036,
0.01456417702138424,
0.04199992120265961,
0.018563823774456978,
-0.013273549266159534,
-0.021464573219418526,
0.027383923530578613,
-0.006546865217387676,
0.002608102047815919,
-0.036433275789022446,
0.04390230402350426,
0.005935142282396555,
-0.010302773676812649,
0.0079580033197999,
-0.007911210879683495,
0.0077805244363844395,
-0.004261817783117294,
-0.025769904255867004,
0.03906373679637909,
0.025760669261217117,
0.025295117869973183,
0.00043629889842122793,
0.021625597029924393,
0.009063768200576305,
0.007324395701289177,
-0.019385075196623802,
0.011228054761886597,
0.007688179146498442,
-0.009652450680732727,
-0.036870814859867096,
-0.019557366147637367,
-0.008507261984050274,
-0.005217554979026318,
0.025642214342951775,
0.014839167706668377,
-0.019855482503771782,
-0.04081270471215248,
-0.021926650777459145,
0.02360229566693306,
0.059022486209869385,
0.023569289594888687,
-0.02149209752678871,
0.023246992379426956,
-0.00435977429151535,
0.02808520570397377,
0.01177870575338602,
0.025841496884822845,
-0.03154006227850914,
0.004250130616128445,
0.0051391045562922955,
-0.0066059245727956295,
-0.016054807230830193,
-0.00965490099042654,
-0.03176283836364746,
0.03406034782528877,
0.021113090217113495,
0.062364161014556885,
-0.017215555533766747,
-0.041876170784235,
-0.0056062862277030945,
-0.032267939299345016,
-0.1552431583404541,
-0.0003467245842330158,
0.011314263567328453,
0.020501600578427315,
0.012091266922652721,
0.033544816076755524,
-0.006148369982838631,
0.00899090152233839,
-0.031783562153577805,
-0.010034934617578983,
0.011349711567163467,
-0.05995090305805206,
-0.003933291416615248,
-0.02301841415464878,
0.020811066031455994,
0.009459019638597965,
-0.018196841701865196,
-0.021263737231492996,
0.002795988926663995,
-0.03737517446279526,
0.0022606272250413895,
-0.00009903021418722346,
-0.014703234657645226,
-0.006035769358277321,
0.01708057150244713,
-0.019096994772553444,
-0.004963042214512825,
-0.0014319241745397449,
-0.04162949323654175,
-0.028298430144786835,
-0.05717300996184349,
0.0015256254700943828,
-0.01352526806294918,
0.03189105913043022,
-0.013939875178039074,
0.04431714490056038,
0.00668100081384182,
-0.0980139747262001,
-0.04427149146795273,
-0.014765376225113869,
0.005466530565172434,
0.03323465585708618,
0.012759963050484657,
0.03627690672874451,
-0.007351551670581102,
-0.05400729551911354,
0.042383138090372086,
-0.01840624213218689,
-0.045456308871507645,
-0.033159077167510986,
-0.06398944556713104,
0.030651986598968506,
-0.003747482318431139,
-0.012311463244259357,
-0.02138470858335495,
-0.04919637739658356,
0.025369156152009964,
0.04019087553024292,
-0.005003675352782011,
-0.018657861277461052,
0.0415949746966362,
-0.05928044393658638,
0.006396819371730089,
0.009099678136408329,
-0.041154421865940094,
0.03033723123371601,
0.017171088606119156,
0.001198472804389894,
0.0030335381161421537,
0.003966189455240965,
0.02083791047334671,
-0.038837824016809464,
0.026753362268209457,
0.022793138399720192,
-0.00810746755450964,
0.06693463772535324,
0.01640443690121174,
0.00043007629574276507,
-0.006899274419993162,
-0.08887474238872528,
-0.0010486859828233719,
0.017885887995362282,
-0.000763913441915065,
0.03619210794568062,
-0.021129384636878967,
-0.00665817828848958,
0.06059034913778305,
0.013399353250861168,
0.027430394664406776,
0.21937939524650574,
0.026403725147247314,
-0.01829995959997177,
0.01766444370150566,
0.0005909319734200835,
0.024713370949029922,
0.04529397189617157,
0.020786263048648834,
-0.005974338389933109,
-0.04226059466600418,
-0.008256715722382069,
0.011046137660741806,
-0.005451580043882132,
-0.004984450526535511,
-0.01433213334530592,
0.010003342293202877,
-0.010039248503744602,
-0.034286659210920334,
0.08009668439626694,
0.02338174730539322,
0.01269370038062334,
0.011463250033557415,
0.0378347709774971,
0.0461403913795948,
-0.05986924096941948,
-0.015576529316604137,
-0.015753870829939842,
0.024509485810995102,
-0.00609228340908885,
0.029904181137681007,
-0.01720537804067135,
-0.02493130788207054,
0.0332975834608078,
0.0021042809821665287,
0.025603273883461952,
0.016096970066428185,
0.01604553312063217,
-0.010609319433569908,
-0.09139810502529144,
0.07167956233024597,
0.05842478200793266,
-0.023576252162456512,
-0.04144744575023651,
-0.025428300723433495,
-0.00036668666871264577,
0.0011696240399032831,
-0.04504319652915001,
0.03454872593283653,
-0.054483287036418915,
0.026449792087078094,
0.025431476533412933,
0.007631619460880756,
-0.007425591349601746,
-0.014317036606371403,
-0.014337798580527306,
-0.020504863932728767,
0.014006218872964382,
0.015964819118380547,
-0.03669309616088867,
0.10412634909152985,
-0.01704249158501625,
0.02251352183520794,
-0.0324755422770977,
0.058491434901952744,
-0.02476777881383896,
0.01959497295320034,
-0.009248960763216019,
-0.03140654414892197,
0.044357601553201675,
0.001972103025764227,
0.0279427208006382,
0.056070733815431595,
0.011866031214594841,
-0.02140914835035801,
0.0360969603061676,
-0.012906679883599281,
-0.023684846237301826,
0.03466329723596573,
0.06394588202238083,
0.03716101497411728,
-0.01756102405488491,
-0.02430441603064537,
-0.031944382935762405,
-0.03481322526931763,
0.015328695997595787,
-0.0013287939364090562,
-0.016481241211295128,
0.04368888959288597,
0.012995085678994656,
0.0128544382750988,
-0.02625351957976818,
-0.018034713342785835,
-0.04861753061413765,
0.005370049271732569,
-0.028049373999238014,
0.0030627823434770107,
0.003983825910836458,
-0.01571248285472393,
-0.011622557416558266,
-0.06899651139974594,
-0.03847343102097511,
-0.008167162537574768,
0.008383483625948429,
-0.03692702203989029,
0.021381869912147522,
-0.04243561625480652,
-0.01806046813726425,
-0.0174582377076149,
-0.033833906054496765,
0.011510036885738373,
-0.007797111291438341,
-0.007283317856490612,
0.01030889805406332,
-0.02695007622241974,
0.0113760344684124,
0.04825529828667641,
-0.015497056767344475,
0.009409638121724129,
0.057048499584198,
0.07458528876304626,
-0.008931178599596024,
-0.02569538913667202,
-0.047720134258270264,
0.01053469069302082,
-0.0017576082609593868,
-0.03743130713701248,
0.013692307285964489,
-0.049271486699581146,
-0.0374998040497303,
0.006517983041703701,
0.0009863771265372634,
-0.012897648848593235,
-0.03652164340019226,
-0.023855913430452347,
0.046994615346193314,
-0.002797155873849988,
0.018346354365348816,
0.022181188687682152,
0.002438540104776621,
0.0140449870377779,
0.00933748111128807,
-0.033238478004932404,
-0.024110687896609306,
0.0288829505443573,
0.019411394372582436,
-0.030604775995016098,
-0.08873298764228821,
-0.0033611664548516273,
-0.011097720824182034,
-0.0022999243810772896,
0.03997134417295456,
0.011687667109072208,
-0.033109184354543686,
-0.03653477877378464,
-0.014625666663050652,
-0.014365343376994133,
-0.005925219971686602,
0.018037589266896248,
-0.0015237475745379925,
-0.02950781211256981,
-0.04122596234083176,
0.023297587409615517,
-0.0400131531059742,
0.0446833111345768,
0.002906827023252845,
0.0330413281917572,
0.016841944307088852,
0.050740886479616165,
0.0037068307865411043,
-0.01546158641576767,
0.030921103432774544,
-0.003179245162755251,
-0.03739480301737785,
0.018114974722266197,
0.007298631593585014,
0.021160975098609924,
-0.0504789724946022,
0.025459049269557,
-0.0018750353483483195,
-0.016796937212347984,
0.006196476053446531,
0.010991133749485016,
-0.026570379734039307,
0.03462847322225571,
0.005664078053086996,
0.011310760863125324,
0.05154787749052048,
-0.01719031296670437,
0.004342938773334026,
-0.04373501241207123,
0.010706889443099499,
0.11019579321146011,
0.012371938675642014,
-0.008455422706902027,
0.026247357949614525,
-0.019315356388688087,
0.04244256764650345,
0.0641833245754242,
0.024477658793330193,
-0.03059960901737213,
0.029406657442450523,
0.053526751697063446,
-0.018688403069972992,
0.07763344049453735,
0.001020459458231926,
0.001157952705398202,
0.020787369459867477,
0.012737900018692017,
-0.01956247165799141,
-0.040602389723062515,
-0.010622155852615833,
0.02488364465534687,
-0.055300407111644745,
-0.016986513510346413,
-0.036639682948589325,
-0.0028291831258684397,
-0.015363210812211037,
0.016785766929388046,
0.022101163864135742,
-0.02528523840010166,
-0.018005548045039177,
-0.027796166017651558,
0.04713904485106468,
-0.07058337330818176,
0.022653141990303993,
-0.018590420484542847,
-0.0012012876104563475,
-0.0090482197701931,
-0.03877786919474602,
-0.01602010428905487,
0.0011237969156354666,
-0.042506538331508636,
0.0017401081277057528,
-0.025646965950727463,
0.004018060863018036,
0.020298916846513748,
0.030204977840185165,
0.03188661113381386,
-0.01021874975413084,
-0.02557416446506977,
-0.03172912448644638,
0.010293284431099892,
0.019013598561286926,
0.025022901594638824,
-0.027653364464640617,
-0.00511409854516387,
0.007605137303471565,
-0.02645212784409523,
0.020618384703993797,
0.0754036158323288,
0.014262605458498001,
0.040046270936727524,
0.021612631157040596,
-0.02810807153582573,
-0.004334970843046904,
0.047756895422935486,
0.012450702488422394,
0.013393532484769821,
-0.032582223415374756,
-0.02571331523358822,
-0.0060461643151938915,
0.038201771676540375,
-0.0017736830050125718,
-0.017299149185419083,
-0.08085542917251587,
-0.020429221913218498,
-0.008875182829797268,
0.0248318649828434,
-0.019183848053216934,
-0.06412558257579803,
0.022375574335455894,
0.0334625281393528,
-0.0315307080745697,
-0.00546079408377409,
-0.02001848816871643,
-0.018899155780673027,
-0.045398347079753876,
0.037760116159915924,
0.06303725391626358,
0.033246107399463654,
0.01586863584816456,
0.04111739248037338,
0.07641000300645828,
0.032389089465141296,
-0.012517123483121395,
0.013062410987913609,
0.018962496891617775,
0.01747952029109001,
0.03520536795258522,
-0.029661646112799644,
0.031071022152900696,
-0.024886153638362885,
-0.04863881319761276,
0.026758400723338127,
0.004514141473919153,
-0.0074782418087124825,
-0.006143221165984869,
0.07472515106201172,
-0.023211555555462837,
0.006587095558643341,
-0.02213861420750618,
0.02874731458723545,
-0.019233698025345802,
-0.02041364461183548,
-0.04264502599835396,
0.01533499639481306,
0.001592150772921741,
-0.036198586225509644,
0.005563007201999426,
-0.000005382875315262936,
0.0030613555572927,
-0.05489116907119751,
0.003591652028262615,
-0.03815952688455582,
0.01630977727472782,
0.019159436225891113,
0.002946116030216217,
-0.016902020201086998,
-0.01355824712663889,
0.041372645646333694,
0.011554128490388393,
-0.0010662435088306665,
-0.04787364974617958,
0.030169719830155373,
-0.04540649428963661,
0.04500231519341469,
0.02680494263768196,
-0.04194992035627365,
-0.038625333458185196,
-0.002666100859642029,
-0.04476647078990936,
-0.038941800594329834,
-0.020294807851314545,
0.011629249900579453,
0.07110834866762161,
0.021832387894392014,
0.008525201119482517,
-0.0287379901856184,
0.02454747073352337,
-0.01571495831012726,
-0.019823703914880753,
-0.028074342757463455,
0.034855473786592484,
-0.010495603084564209,
-0.0036586597561836243,
0.0010357133578509092,
0.012988793663680553,
-0.006644901819527149,
0.002286492148414254,
-0.020481523126363754,
-0.005942452233284712,
0.003527402877807617,
-0.02117864601314068,
-0.03595448657870293,
0.03355763480067253,
0.03123658336699009,
0.013493589125573635,
0.046243853867053986,
0.024856500327587128,
0.024899767711758614,
-0.003404619637876749,
0.012383769266307354,
0.020164139568805695,
0.013649370521306992,
0.01615266129374504,
-0.0007192420307546854,
-0.0026208902709186077,
-0.013485021889209747,
-0.02408398874104023,
-0.01845225878059864,
0.017436780035495758,
0.016894951462745667,
0.027267280966043472,
0.002203787211328745,
-0.05142920836806297,
0.016023479402065277,
-0.0162037406116724,
-0.014745011925697327,
-0.010366255417466164,
0.0034804800525307655,
-0.026911605149507523,
-0.04521051421761513,
-0.02234290912747383,
-0.008842041715979576,
0.007283244747668505,
0.04278548061847687,
-0.007358253933489323,
-0.002038667444139719,
0.003791339462623,
0.014602217823266983,
0.0007829347159713507,
0.03134666383266449,
-0.06055053696036339,
0.0022741055581718683,
-0.15088336169719696,
0.02694092132151127,
0.00748660322278738,
-0.01660984382033348,
-0.052456796169281006,
-0.023545287549495697,
-0.035455916076898575,
0.0197697002440691,
-0.025860697031021118,
-0.024166300892829895,
-0.0007739397115074098,
-0.04796302318572998,
-0.033705320209264755,
-0.021053874865174294,
-0.0767260417342186,
0.04833715781569481,
0.00005499153121490963,
-0.02441372163593769,
-0.012180017307400703,
-0.01277952641248703,
-0.0015960870077833533,
0.005907726474106312,
-0.005346711724996567,
-0.012524661608040333,
-0.006182242184877396,
0.00323638878762722,
-0.032903749495744705,
0.008665456436574459,
-0.03395920246839523,
-0.05228486284613609,
-0.017566794529557228,
-0.052952688187360764,
-0.01259455643594265,
0.03268244490027428,
0.01745493896305561,
-0.018632926046848297,
-0.013995127752423286,
-0.040810726583004,
-0.043231748044490814,
-0.024771004915237427,
-0.04499267041683197,
0.021738719195127487,
0.0052444045431911945,
-0.031681858003139496,
0.002807808108627796,
0.037472210824489594,
-0.0015256416518241167,
0.020415397360920906,
-0.05018327385187149,
-0.014255505986511707,
-0.04603654146194458,
0.04269828274846077,
0.0017592004733160138,
0.00671735405921936,
-0.012588811106979847,
0.014949241653084755,
-0.012448173016309738,
0.011972549371421337,
-0.02256910316646099,
0.0653538778424263,
-0.0007562953978776932,
-0.03251122310757637,
-0.04228668287396431,
0.008417696692049503,
-0.0034215336199849844,
0.017736537382006645,
-0.05978866294026375,
0.024013923481106758,
-0.03070220537483692,
0.015917029231786728,
-0.01825517788529396,
-0.02723884768784046,
0.005258968099951744,
-0.03716515377163887,
-0.013006291352212429,
0.02432115189731121,
0.01093983557075262,
0.006325334310531616,
-0.013716371729969978,
-0.009191586636006832,
0.021887393668293953,
-0.021083736792206764,
-0.028621608391404152,
-0.032912321388721466,
0.06180263310670853,
0.04261638969182968,
0.0032550720497965813,
0.024872202426195145,
0.018809132277965546,
-0.001187243266031146,
-0.06255175173282623,
0.016952985897660255,
-0.04900360479950905,
0.0048385970294475555,
-0.011021492071449757,
0.02675997093319893,
-0.02307264134287834,
-0.01576162688434124,
-0.026271428912878036,
-0.033943746238946915,
0.014363642781972885,
-0.027242155745625496,
0.0111587755382061,
0.011461162008345127,
-0.05674762651324272,
0.06588886678218842,
0.01892833597958088,
-0.022799724712967873,
-0.012362581677734852,
0.01404429692775011,
-0.014501682482659817,
-0.015736835077404976,
-0.062067124992609024,
-0.03280699998140335,
-0.049179792404174805,
0.004265183117240667,
-0.008529407903552055,
0.03644081950187683,
-0.006332905497401953,
0.022770600393414497,
-0.01444730069488287,
-0.03732514753937721,
0.025425560772418976,
-0.029332704842090607,
-0.019426491111516953,
0.027831347659230232,
0.06471499055624008,
0.012966034933924675,
-0.011535060591995716,
-0.018409837037324905,
0.04029783234000206,
0.02300255559384823,
0.020585717633366585,
0.021101944148540497,
0.03272533044219017,
0.03478628396987915,
0.002989638363942504,
0.014301642775535583,
-0.008375173434615135,
0.008884645067155361,
-0.02271825261414051,
-0.0177094005048275,
-0.009631023742258549,
-0.03341774269938469,
-0.048414453864097595,
-0.01024486031383276,
0.03934228792786598,
0.021731028333306313,
-0.05188978463411331,
-0.019339652732014656,
-0.025007808580994606,
0.0022555396426469088,
0.027257591485977173,
0.0797121524810791,
0.004486040212213993,
0.0010835579596459866,
0.017736157402396202,
0.009995699860155582,
0.02162664756178856,
0.044321637600660324,
0.005457898136228323,
-0.06142355874180794,
-0.01849915087223053,
-0.0269386637955904,
-0.054695796221494675,
0.06260041892528534,
0.0178559347987175,
-0.010192293673753738,
-0.047866977751255035,
0.000252454454312101,
-0.0023920738603919744,
-0.0005602659657597542,
-0.01601652428507805,
0.027530895546078682,
0.01307632401585579,
-0.028615597635507584,
0.011602911166846752,
-0.024473071098327637,
0.020337359979748726,
-0.017199255526065826,
0.03923634812235832,
-0.02541848085820675,
0.008949005044996738,
0.022986503317952156,
-0.03902793303132057,
0.02456226944923401,
-0.021083591505885124,
0.023316171020269394,
0.001518527395091951,
-0.008903611451387405,
-0.017976384609937668,
-0.058134131133556366,
0.037587929517030716,
-0.01851879060268402,
0.03218774497509003,
-0.007857145741581917,
-0.020490825176239014,
-0.008994605392217636,
0.017061274498701096,
0.006383627653121948,
0.01167655736207962,
0.009636745788156986,
-0.012001791037619114,
-0.0234496109187603,
-0.019845999777317047,
0.005685409996658564,
-0.012185880914330482,
-0.054169632494449615,
-0.021353449672460556,
0.06819280982017517,
-0.033356908708810806,
-0.008664402179419994,
0.03486558794975281,
0.020005472004413605,
0.007400533650070429,
0.03644789755344391,
0.0011255175340920687,
-0.022067740559577942,
0.007393652573227882,
-0.01939554326236248,
0.06104133278131485,
0.03149303048849106,
0.03907967358827591,
-0.04947105795145035,
-0.00045060142292641103,
0.0036795444320887327,
-0.02139323018491268,
0.04771958664059639,
0.011226859875023365,
0.013872506096959114,
-0.024212215095758438,
-0.02048397995531559,
-0.01377084106206894,
0.062235020101070404,
-0.007682913914322853,
0.005779403727501631,
0.0036282779183238745,
-0.01590811088681221,
-0.040443118661642075,
0.008935815654695034,
0.02880631387233734,
-0.0013202859554439783,
0.00006417941040126607,
-0.01184167806059122
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:7
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
The plaintiff relies on the views expressed by Mahoney JA and which were approved by the five-member bench in Evans v Marmont. The plaintiff notes that the paragraph that followed the above passage of Mahoney JA's judgment includes the following:
"This does not mean that the fact that a woman when the order comes to be made is richer rather than poorer cannot affect the order to be made. In some cases it may. Thus one party may deserve to have an order but no order can be made because the other party has no property which can be adjusted to provide it. The Court may determine not to do what may be futile".
38The plaintiff submitted that what was being said by Mahoney JA in these passages was that an adjustment that might be made to other assets of the parties as a result of a windfall gain would only occur if the non winning party had made relevant contributions to the other assets to such an extent as to justify such an order.
39The defendant acknowledged in its submissions the authoritative nature of the pronouncement of Mahoney JA in Wallace v Stanford (1995) 35 NSWLR 1 that a party is not entitled to have or to have value from inherited property (a fortiori proceeds of a lottery win) merely because the other party has acquired it and,
it further conceded, congruent with the judgment of Mahoney JA, that an adjustment may be made to the division of the asset pool (not including lottery winnings) that might or would not otherwise have been made but for the enrichment of one of the parties by that "windfall".
40The defendant joined issue with the plaintiff's conclusions. It submitted that this proposition ignores for example, consideration of homemaker contributions and conduct rendering such contributions arduous of provision by the maltreated spouse. It also was submitted that it ignores individual or peculiar facts of each case:
"In this present case for example the desire of each party, especially Ms Mulcahy to build assets to provide homes for their respective children which drove her endeavours and from which Cooper benefited - all his aspirations of this type are met by windfall, whilst Ms Mulcahy's are thwarted to such extent that her children must now support her."
41It is important in considering this matter to remember what was said by Gleeson CJ and McLelland CJ in Eq in Evans v Marmont at 70F through to 80A is the following:
"There is nothing in Section 20 of the Act of the kind found in Section 75(2)(o) of the Family Law Act which requires or entitles the Court to take into account as a factor alongside those referred to in par (a) and par (b) any fact or circumstance which in the opinion of the Court the justice of the case requires to be taken into account.
Most importantly Section 20 specifies in par (a) and par (b) the matters to which the Court is to have regard.
As I have pointed out above, those matters would ordinarily have to be considered and a judgement as to what is just and equitable having regard to those matters will ordinarily have to be made, in a context, and that context may well include factors of the kind referred to by Hodgson J at first instance in Dwyer v Kaljo.
However par (a) and par (b) prescribe the focal points by reference to which the discretionary judgment as to what seems just and equitable must be made. They are not merely two matters, or groups of matters which take their place amongst any relevant considerations. It is by having regard to those matters that the Court may adjust property interest in a just and equitable manner".
42I also note the useful discussion by Bryson JA in Chanter v Catts 64 NSWLR 366, [2005] NSWCA 411 where he said the following at [65-67]:
65] The discretion while wide is not unlimited; the perception of what is just and equitable relates to the contributions referred to in paras (a) and (b) and not to some other or wider view of just and equitable adjustment of interests in property: see Evans v Marmont (1997) 42 NSWLR 70 ;
|
[
-0.007661035750061274,
0.05342085659503937,
-0.01819649338722229,
0.019539620727300644,
-0.01511854212731123,
-0.021311704069375992,
0.03140803426504135,
-0.0027734229806810617,
0.0133042111992836,
0.008306212723255157,
0.004535243846476078,
0.048647381365299225,
-0.0556349903345108,
0.00020857714116573334,
-0.01981671154499054,
-0.04932183772325516,
0.022668642923235893,
0.0010222077835351229,
-0.06283408403396606,
-0.015506617724895477,
-0.039615198969841,
0.00711010443046689,
0.033247847110033035,
0.02865639328956604,
0.02009647525846958,
0.01993553340435028,
-0.04472379386425018,
-0.0011408340651541948,
0.03204038739204407,
0.021801667287945747,
-0.045799024403095245,
0.048647038638591766,
0.024815808981657028,
-0.04227055236697197,
-0.0017021190142259002,
-0.04467247799038887,
-0.03194538503885269,
0.00523449806496501,
-0.002723866840824485,
0.005795074161142111,
-0.01169417891651392,
0.024181565269827843,
-0.02146054431796074,
-0.06643150001764297,
0.03234570473432541,
-0.012462851591408253,
-0.03333347290754318,
-0.02944514900445938,
-0.01377269346266985,
-0.016262009739875793,
-0.07137387245893478,
0.029390916228294373,
0.0771012157201767,
0.0065785921178758144,
0.010208697989583015,
0.012189648114144802,
0.00947656575590372,
0.009190352633595467,
-0.0495571531355381,
0.011731927283108234,
-0.006856345105916262,
-0.029505014419555664,
-0.04408562555909157,
-0.018127931281924248,
0.021929189562797546,
0.028687575832009315,
-0.021552952006459236,
-0.00858486257493496,
-0.013379387557506561,
0.0038166935555636883,
-0.01895626075565815,
-0.008627699688076973,
0.02102338708937168,
-0.008589341305196285,
-0.06645824015140533,
0.019764628261327744,
0.029362328350543976,
0.005658755078911781,
-0.03595491498708725,
-0.0043585095554590225,
0.024105604737997055,
-0.024240616708993912,
0.0068811168894171715,
0.023292912170290947,
-0.021545350551605225,
0.004573388956487179,
-0.019767427816987038,
0.029369603842496872,
0.04363151639699936,
-0.015322946943342686,
-0.022675862535834312,
0.009240817278623581,
0.023351097479462624,
-0.05983346328139305,
0.0027441743295639753,
0.02692018263041973,
-0.057357821613550186,
-0.008143346756696701,
0.03142624348402023,
0.004025573842227459,
0.01397587452083826,
0.01563936471939087,
0.002825722796842456,
-0.012263624928891659,
0.019548891112208366,
-0.004952203948050737,
-0.007390167564153671,
0.02343391627073288,
0.03419874981045723,
0.015523429960012436,
0.012549925595521927,
0.03893570974469185,
0.03734062612056732,
0.02377200685441494,
-0.03479037433862686,
-0.011028427630662918,
0.009401061572134495,
-0.02981438860297203,
-0.007533934433013201,
0.02410922572016716,
0.02363738603889942,
0.0035403717774897814,
0.056349366903305054,
-0.010337743908166885,
-0.06178443506360054,
-0.0008562742732465267,
-0.06397300213575363,
0.018874067813158035,
-0.05134082958102226,
0.025178901851177216,
0.0010056536411866546,
-0.04725570231676102,
-0.008274135179817677,
0.004771454259753227,
-0.014484073035418987,
0.023065466433763504,
0.059105172753334045,
0.03246494010090828,
-0.011243116110563278,
-0.055515315383672714,
0.05300053209066391,
0.010963997803628445,
0.007652910891920328,
-0.015504507347941399,
0.045126497745513916,
0.008269749581813812,
0.05078643560409546,
-0.02298523671925068,
-0.03160201758146286,
-0.01523133460432291,
-0.00209796242415905,
0.0013378218282014132,
0.019366666674613953,
-0.045007143169641495,
0.05032477527856827,
-0.04232201725244522,
0.035948824137449265,
0.048087526112794876,
-0.016994860023260117,
0.008712527342140675,
-0.040742382407188416,
0.0281072948127985,
-0.040483105927705765,
-0.04143836349248886,
-0.011371218599379063,
0.004047715105116367,
-0.01978980004787445,
0.04832802712917328,
-0.02381097339093685,
-0.055562861263751984,
0.019198836758732796,
0.010210384614765644,
-0.011001203209161758,
-0.02949358895421028,
0.017053496092557907,
0.004637799691408873,
0.043878503143787384,
-0.003295258851721883,
-0.035727012902498245,
-0.020470554009079933,
-0.02028859220445156,
-0.004476342350244522,
0.0005197636783123016,
-0.022179119288921356,
-0.027510544285178185,
0.029722370207309723,
-0.021825037896633148,
-0.018744878470897675,
0.04439358040690422,
-0.006740705110132694,
-0.05458097532391548,
-0.025263618677854538,
0.03662419319152832,
0.013349172659218311,
0.03720971196889877,
-0.06322404742240906,
0.012798387557268143,
-0.008734267204999924,
0.05059897527098656,
0.02846553921699524,
-0.018296705558896065,
0.015621618367731571,
0.008121270686388016,
0.0038641635328531265,
-0.017294077202677727,
0.0020020026713609695,
-0.0558663010597229,
-0.04830150306224823,
0.03349359706044197,
-0.018749894574284554,
0.035289086401462555,
0.03331618756055832,
0.034183844923973083,
0.021173087880015373,
-0.007227599620819092,
0.001601118710823357,
0.0016471005510538816,
-0.019616898149251938,
0.028737042099237442,
0.025466565042734146,
-0.011713284067809582,
-0.005803736392408609,
0.03151373565196991,
0.0181416142731905,
0.03700212389230728,
0.02790777198970318,
-0.043557099997997284,
0.0012015380198135972,
0.025392446666955948,
-0.02729453332722187,
0.038520101457834244,
0.026534853503108025,
0.023531479761004448,
-0.023480048403143883,
0.015956297516822815,
-0.018085673451423645,
-0.00544166611507535,
0.044369325041770935,
0.03633813560009003,
-0.009318246506154537,
0.002834203653037548,
-0.014005404897034168,
0.029136897996068,
-0.021645016968250275,
-0.009908408857882023,
-0.02037106826901436,
-0.006257663480937481,
-0.03427604213356972,
0.03131239116191864,
-0.029472192749381065,
0.021177619695663452,
-0.0037306970916688442,
0.015890656039118767,
-0.010828418657183647,
0.014927683398127556,
0.04395175352692604,
0.01968870870769024,
-0.02086009457707405,
0.02812633104622364,
-0.03649401292204857,
0.003697807202115655,
0.02623247727751732,
0.014086179435253143,
0.0033955650869756937,
0.02001488208770752,
-0.03775886818766594,
0.010039791464805603,
0.016184305772185326,
0.027170855551958084,
-0.008353563025593758,
0.011283455416560173,
0.009512280113995075,
0.032428570091724396,
-0.025384102016687393,
0.02557910792529583,
0.06983458995819092,
0.022900698706507683,
-0.03702046349644661,
0.031156061217188835,
-0.0293692909181118,
0.00019985882681794465,
0.03418397158384323,
0.02388916350901127,
-0.03029477968811989,
0.027500897645950317,
0.023020252585411072,
-0.001207609660923481,
-0.03033543936908245,
0.006790860090404749,
-0.04031671583652496,
0.052304890006780624,
-0.004757537506520748,
0.08267852663993835,
-0.025740183889865875,
-0.07992012798786163,
-0.009479675441980362,
-0.000095080875325948,
-0.14807476103305817,
-0.03657800331711769,
0.03093455731868744,
-0.003542847465723753,
0.013578751124441624,
0.02831893414258957,
-0.06318504363298416,
0.0459393635392189,
0.002934463554993272,
0.00441948976367712,
0.024122118949890137,
-0.07640641927719116,
-0.0007133606704883277,
0.0344398207962513,
0.010382196865975857,
-0.015480340458452702,
-0.017170336097478867,
0.0013115429319441319,
0.022540243342518806,
-0.02279208041727543,
-0.0200298260897398,
-0.015118061564862728,
0.03958292305469513,
-0.016770537942647934,
-0.027051426470279694,
-0.0047981832176446915,
-0.004151272587478161,
-0.008025887422263622,
-0.02850761078298092,
-0.04099272936582565,
-0.02700863592326641,
0.0576028972864151,
-0.0016904511721804738,
0.008576435036957264,
-0.03323895111680031,
0.02029210329055786,
0.03606604412198067,
-0.09026013314723969,
-0.015872899442911148,
-0.03094472736120224,
0.00736028328537941,
0.01935400255024433,
-0.0002490139158908278,
0.023125551640987396,
-0.03681885451078415,
-0.06035313755273819,
-0.017277024686336517,
-0.02666393667459488,
-0.04479110613465309,
0.030942536890506744,
-0.04784237593412399,
0.02551610767841339,
-0.04506813734769821,
-0.0183198731392622,
-0.04494089633226395,
-0.020565791055560112,
0.003940576687455177,
0.004040840081870556,
0.009500512853264809,
0.010474378243088722,
-0.03633306547999382,
-0.0012414754601195455,
0.019728925079107285,
-0.011578441597521305,
-0.007897008210420609,
-0.00239470019005239,
0.029460636898875237,
0.005492115393280983,
0.08338623493909836,
-0.004682301077991724,
-0.009180949069559574,
-0.06796611845493317,
0.013681387528777122,
0.005507036577910185,
-0.007053337059915066,
0.02460968680679798,
0.043143291026353836,
-0.03742041066288948,
-0.023987701162695885,
-0.08528021723031998,
0.024081775918602943,
-0.010413610376417637,
0.0028244887944310904,
0.029030919075012207,
-0.027150271460413933,
0.011040379293262959,
0.022903786972165108,
0.019832415506243706,
0.05213385075330734,
0.239553764462471,
-0.01089678704738617,
0.0008491466287523508,
0.03914505988359451,
0.008315694518387318,
-0.0021623773500323296,
0.03969496488571167,
0.043673425912857056,
0.012803751043975353,
-0.0016612204490229487,
-0.020038019865751266,
-0.007550803944468498,
0.021672366186976433,
0.03344430401921272,
-0.026286641135811806,
0.02402539551258087,
-0.033331889659166336,
-0.02616114541888237,
0.07253818213939667,
-0.0071587455458939075,
0.03225613385438919,
-0.06052210181951523,
0.016828669235110283,
0.003839903511106968,
-0.037830136716365814,
-0.011643273755908012,
0.007336733862757683,
0.006609223783016205,
-0.019472526386380196,
0.032530467957258224,
-0.037854839116334915,
-0.03142423555254936,
0.02987973764538765,
0.04840448126196861,
0.024967478588223457,
-0.014414386823773384,
-0.017914125695824623,
0.03294738009572029,
-0.030137166380882263,
0.01862538605928421,
0.021136373281478882,
-0.02517605572938919,
-0.06517776101827621,
-0.03600401431322098,
0.05325884371995926,
0.0022702226415276527,
0.009711532853543758,
0.007866051979362965,
-0.030549705028533936,
0.03645280748605728,
-0.016607100144028664,
0.0023741277400404215,
-0.021252665668725967,
0.005335216876119375,
-0.04163758456707001,
-0.020209020003676414,
-0.02334781549870968,
0.03526788577437401,
-0.027442296966910362,
0.01935541443526745,
0.006416374817490578,
-0.013405530713498592,
0.011207928881049156,
-0.008976360782980919,
-0.010998865589499474,
0.017919892445206642,
-0.030653949826955795,
-0.026958411559462547,
0.04109729826450348,
0.0029526641592383385,
0.0027894596569240093,
-0.04128066450357437,
0.04560498520731926,
0.04440690949559212,
0.028390465304255486,
0.013315889984369278,
0.016504626721143723,
0.002165796235203743,
0.030641213059425354,
-0.030141092836856842,
-0.05851668491959572,
-0.035802703350782394,
-0.004817475564777851,
-0.02274894528090954,
-0.002191756619140506,
-0.01128573901951313,
-0.017678342759609222,
0.0454627200961113,
0.05654171481728554,
-0.01655467227101326,
-0.02344694174826145,
-0.040443699806928635,
-0.025968385860323906,
0.018067263066768646,
0.0004590960161294788,
-0.011221597902476788,
0.04856089502573013,
0.04431435465812683,
-0.005662414710968733,
-0.005025961901992559,
-0.015593349002301693,
-0.014541991986334324,
0.013682132586836815,
-0.049394506961107254,
0.03290148079395294,
-0.01944398693740368,
0.011291678063571453,
-0.0020681070163846016,
-0.04787489026784897,
-0.05478236451745033,
-0.011398366652429104,
0.0022506308741867542,
-0.0036642001941800117,
0.00196167454123497,
0.02125556394457817,
0.020954221487045288,
-0.024020859971642494,
0.03087913990020752,
0.0456707701086998,
0.022567100822925568,
-0.03217383474111557,
-0.007862968370318413,
0.011634745635092258,
-0.021400339901447296,
-0.022344091907143593,
-0.04719892889261246,
-0.015464971773326397,
-0.0015575671568512917,
0.04191499203443527,
0.015339048579335213,
-0.004053506534546614,
-0.0037832593079656363,
-0.05517759546637535,
-0.015104565769433975,
0.009330451488494873,
-0.007232406176626682,
-0.007373160682618618,
0.010491402819752693,
-0.018126802518963814,
0.019589830189943314,
-0.009913908317685127,
-0.0059938193298876286,
-0.013973947614431381,
-0.0018691413570195436,
0.024571886286139488,
0.023809274658560753,
-0.021643228828907013,
-0.004053032491356134,
-0.03206222131848335,
0.005212173331528902,
-0.01837213896214962,
0.011413420550525188,
-0.02408445253968239,
-0.02372833900153637,
-0.018000531941652298,
0.03371773287653923,
0.013469802215695381,
-0.02061016857624054,
0.05584941804409027,
-0.02003658004105091,
-0.013905398547649384,
0.017788346856832504,
-0.022239936515688896,
0.07930225878953934,
0.009420923888683319,
0.07488813251256943,
0.04350418224930763,
0.013435990549623966,
0.00934660155326128,
-0.04014698415994644,
-0.05674364045262337,
-0.029742982238531113,
-0.018448907881975174,
-0.02236938662827015,
0.06555505841970444,
0.07038935273885727,
0.010272277519106865,
0.033764541149139404,
0.01152744796127081,
-0.08445212990045547,
0.02712223120033741,
-0.0005361863877624273,
-0.006886027287691832,
-0.012199661694467068,
-0.02830451726913452,
-0.02723660320043564,
0.010898701846599579,
0.00026651774533092976,
0.04737109690904617,
-0.033366911113262177,
-0.006707415450364351,
0.09940996766090393,
-0.00016876675363164395,
-0.03781256452202797,
0.04748595505952835,
0.05036669597029686,
0.012334263883531094,
0.052116431295871735,
0.01370660588145256,
-0.05403588339686394,
-0.01656625233590603,
-0.030574936419725418,
-0.03575778752565384,
-0.005314395762979984,
0.059008121490478516,
0.002083448925986886,
-0.016231341287493706,
0.00027287882403470576,
-0.028621308505535126,
-0.08035977184772491,
0.005963530391454697,
-0.019593732431530952,
-0.06143883988261223,
-0.001356735941953957,
0.048239678144454956,
0.006484319921582937,
0.031980834901332855,
0.04128097742795944,
-0.008000925183296204,
-0.04126237705349922,
-0.006352909374982119,
0.0031086979433894157,
0.017492735758423805,
-0.08074410259723663,
-0.015299759805202484,
-0.0026987490709871054,
-0.007807586342096329,
-0.0038899618666619062,
0.013070126064121723,
-0.0525113083422184,
0.0025169618893414736,
-0.025415487587451935,
0.001087559969164431,
-0.0011249068193137646,
-0.02000696212053299,
-0.028621995821595192,
0.009729845449328423,
0.005225839093327522,
0.013102381490170956,
-0.014978913590312004,
0.034663125872612,
0.006350199691951275,
0.05344647169113159,
0.07886258512735367,
0.014403758570551872,
-0.012176616117358208,
0.010081649757921696,
-0.0007387414807453752,
0.03926301747560501,
0.04513733834028244,
0.0016679372638463974,
-0.006677295081317425,
-0.0008022013353183866,
-0.015369650907814503,
-0.006587267387658358,
-0.03572024032473564,
-0.0010315785184502602,
0.0022995767649263144,
-0.028294505551457405,
-0.04113966226577759,
0.020649677142500877,
0.03298376500606537,
-0.0015940539306029677,
-0.021377863362431526,
-0.04384535923600197,
-0.03938034921884537,
0.0381183959543705,
-0.03731895983219147,
-0.011129455640912056,
-0.04213838651776314,
0.007095592096447945,
0.009876487776637077,
-0.06475714594125748,
-0.043775103986263275,
0.008961874060332775,
0.004977398086339235,
0.0015400282572954893,
0.028873324394226074,
-0.006616194266825914,
-0.00817355141043663,
0.013885609805583954,
-0.022030992433428764,
-0.01993435248732567,
-0.00023475011403206736,
-0.002243808237835765,
0.010139815509319305,
0.03299344331026077,
0.0005051649641245604,
0.015553902834653854,
-0.019345151260495186,
0.03793208301067352,
0.021081803366541862,
0.004646122921258211,
0.06156604364514351,
0.003325841622427106,
0.02856949344277382,
0.02920869179069996,
-0.0007249071495607495,
0.010054395534098148,
0.051929038017988205,
-0.023293493315577507,
-0.008848348632454872,
-0.022347813472151756,
0.002115414245054126,
0.007355155888944864,
0.023418491706252098,
0.06700453162193298,
-0.05242512747645378,
-0.030983226373791695,
0.025934800505638123,
-0.011546378955245018,
-0.06772027909755707,
-0.01166610699146986,
-0.016549965366721153,
0.01266840472817421,
0.025038164108991623,
0.05515332147479057,
-0.002883465960621834,
0.020541785284876823,
0.023252202197909355,
0.012417175807058811,
0.011279294267296791,
-0.009650787338614464,
-0.006072285585105419,
-0.01022652629762888,
-0.012250160798430443,
-0.028308358043432236,
-0.042868323624134064,
-0.015666218474507332,
0.029802532866597176,
-0.05371197685599327,
0.004220019560307264,
0.0008849926525726914,
-0.011496171355247498,
0.039498861879110336,
0.011317220516502857,
0.005835765041410923,
-0.02095167711377144,
0.038412585854530334,
-0.03801565244793892,
-0.0045213960111141205,
-0.05065808817744255,
0.07547665387392044,
-0.006224383134394884,
0.04527737945318222,
0.005487537477165461,
-0.0021368612069636583,
0.017775120213627815,
0.030764125287532806,
0.0331992544233799,
-0.02538440376520157,
0.017137043178081512,
-0.0327172689139843,
-0.005131929647177458,
0.028256120160222054,
0.015432760119438171,
0.029986070469021797,
0.03261713311076164,
0.023821597918868065,
-0.034637223929166794,
-0.02232048101723194,
-0.02667270228266716,
0.03092369996011257,
-0.006226727738976479,
-0.02417023479938507,
0.00765601871535182,
-0.005647297482937574,
0.0014182456070557237,
0.004780632443726063,
0.016887564212083817,
0.010023723356425762,
-0.005566601175814867,
0.008679458871483803,
-0.0018947210628539324,
-0.016529064625501633,
0.00008835421613184735,
-0.007656016852706671,
-0.021800365298986435,
-0.009993532672524452,
-0.007914259098470211,
0.0016705194720998406,
-0.006022579036653042,
-0.030497465282678604,
-0.012613528408110142,
-0.020335113629698753,
-0.02695895917713642,
0.06783271580934525,
-0.01825694367289543,
-0.014668157324194908,
0.06112239509820938,
0.010896398685872555,
0.08518817275762558,
-0.03255019336938858,
-0.028460944071412086,
-0.1464027613401413,
0.007490457966923714,
0.01074851956218481,
0.04585444927215576,
-0.06651535630226135,
-0.0005200249142944813,
-0.018686918541789055,
0.013761423528194427,
-0.017338695004582405,
-0.01727268658578396,
-0.019187627360224724,
-0.0011915971990674734,
0.0002925405278801918,
-0.023671189323067665,
-0.03689919784665108,
0.018494078889489174,
-0.0025778901763260365,
-0.06269742548465729,
-0.026595350354909897,
0.050374072045087814,
-0.004241949878633022,
-0.008961318992078304,
-0.00009338391828350723,
0.012006516568362713,
0.008222956210374832,
-0.01966601051390171,
-0.057072848081588745,
-0.06822686642408371,
-0.060778677463531494,
-0.03936567157506943,
-0.016083084046840668,
0.015653617680072784,
0.02536950819194317,
-0.007180591579526663,
-0.02279057912528515,
-0.003816812764853239,
-0.0184620413929224,
0.00038586874143220484,
-0.02518933266401291,
-0.0015852381475269794,
-0.010127751156687737,
0.03195062652230263,
-0.033010825514793396,
-0.021789947524666786,
0.019377978518605232,
0.05373702570796013,
0.003189732786267996,
0.020167434588074684,
-0.03362761065363884,
-0.01749277301132679,
-0.0013446919620037079,
-0.01788881979882717,
0.0029351890552788973,
0.029566967859864235,
-0.017346275970339775,
-0.006008592434227467,
-0.0099509721621871,
-0.0003595971502363682,
0.006231084931641817,
0.06050581485033035,
0.021754836663603783,
0.00565670570358634,
-0.014909783378243446,
-0.0632360503077507,
0.008186042308807373,
0.002332185162231326,
-0.03701785206794739,
-0.028055187314748764,
-0.008716884069144726,
-0.019372573122382164,
0.023008663207292557,
0.014706977643072605,
-0.025401994585990906,
-0.05400145426392555,
-0.0010882202768698335,
0.0113739725202322,
-0.015724577009677887,
-0.004903194960206747,
0.02821102738380432,
-0.01923888735473156,
-0.028145622462034225,
-0.004538373555988073,
0.002942221937701106,
-0.034317392855882645,
0.037222106009721756,
0.018465524539351463,
-0.00033910415368154645,
-0.006055735982954502,
-0.039357248693704605,
-0.059227533638477325,
-0.038148365914821625,
-0.023086952045559883,
-0.0045380000956356525,
0.017452821135520935,
0.026407741010189056,
0.0596696101129055,
0.01118745282292366,
0.007520158775150776,
-0.03206757828593254,
0.010199388489127159,
-0.010919051244854927,
-0.023703517392277718,
0.06648465245962143,
0.0039638918824493885,
-0.05481742322444916,
0.01910891756415367,
-0.01402223203331232,
0.001371454680338502,
-0.007335756905376911,
-0.014520307071506977,
-0.0033925031311810017,
0.008847024291753769,
-0.03237591311335564,
0.0006180644268169999,
-0.0503484271466732,
0.03028613142669201,
-0.005267740227282047,
0.024250498041510582,
0.014127901755273342,
-0.018933597952127457,
0.0009979524184018373,
-0.038659628480672836,
0.04121919721364975,
-0.016918839886784554,
-0.017965806648135185,
0.02576283924281597,
0.05002106726169586,
0.016253110021352768,
0.02500300295650959,
-0.012218444608151913,
0.051985520869493484,
-0.007954384200274944,
0.03429741784930229,
0.005119164939969778,
0.03617096319794655,
0.028400979936122894,
-0.0433712936937809,
0.018027568235993385,
-0.023591425269842148,
-0.059341393411159515,
-0.0019614410120993853,
-0.04167790338397026,
0.02021745778620243,
-0.014668255113065243,
-0.04085145518183708,
-0.036841291934251785,
0.03793921694159508,
0.03693905845284462,
-0.021811330690979958,
-0.062271106988191605,
-0.007265868131071329,
-0.013975745067000389,
0.02105102129280567,
0.02286483347415924,
0.019837170839309692,
-0.00747272465378046,
0.003930055536329746,
-0.02170526422560215,
0.026871969923377037,
0.04997141286730766,
0.018474968150258064,
-0.011572110466659069,
0.01693839207291603,
-0.03490016609430313,
-0.02395680546760559,
0.03834160417318344,
0.005535923410207033,
-0.009319359436631203,
-0.001218275516293943,
0.003738589119166136,
-0.008238299749791622,
0.014349501579999924,
-0.0023087088484317064,
0.031713929027318954,
0.004879828076809645,
-0.029183607548475266,
0.0019895206205546856,
0.030965471640229225,
0.020773205906152725,
-0.04278023540973663,
0.011636274866759777,
0.02809954434633255,
0.052296992391347885,
-0.01735459454357624,
0.016505951061844826,
0.02145286649465561,
-0.012463630177080631,
0.027884481474757195,
-0.004222779534757137,
-0.06846700608730316,
-0.008853744715452194,
-0.02941681630909443,
0.05908294767141342,
-0.029408525675535202,
0.017697269096970558,
0.01202736422419548,
0.010177528485655785,
0.022464154288172722,
-0.023159870877861977,
0.035879891365766525,
0.033192407339811325,
0.00730940094217658,
-0.03820173442363739,
0.013408518396317959,
-0.03993658348917961,
-0.055603399872779846,
-0.006048733834177256,
0.024302560836076736,
-0.03704548999667168,
0.04452924802899361,
-0.05492231622338295,
0.007568301633000374,
-0.023682957515120506,
0.04320153221487999,
0.025259671732783318,
0.0066167390905320644,
0.0075713093392550945,
0.03937080129981041,
0.05771106109023094,
0.00676428247243166,
0.012286574579775333,
0.03806135803461075,
-0.021870724856853485,
-0.024171333760023117,
-0.032633088529109955,
0.021143319085240364,
-0.025034187361598015,
-0.03661229833960533,
-0.028569266200065613,
0.01830974780023098,
-0.04031950980424881,
-0.05713200569152832,
-0.005626004189252853,
0.01593829318881035,
0.011392866261303425,
0.007822077721357346,
0.0044277384877204895,
-0.02984549291431904,
-0.041652534157037735,
0.004454053472727537,
-0.00510038947686553,
-0.007682519499212503,
0.003368888283148408,
0.03575851768255234
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:34
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
Before the court can make that final determination, it is necessary to identify and value the property in respect of which it is open to the court to make an adjustment and to identify and value the contributions that are being taken into account: see Howlett v Neilson [2005] NSWCA 149 ;
DFC 95-321 at [25]; Saric v Steward [2006] NSWCA 260; (2007) DFC 95 at [61]; Chanter v Catts [2005] NSWCA 411; 64 NSWLR 441 at [22].
[38] The authorities recognise that notwithstanding that the court exercises a wide discretion under s 20, a mathematical calculation of the contribution of the parties is of assistance in finding and testing conclusions as to what is just and equitable and in promoting transparency and consistency in decision-making: see Howlett v Neilson per Hodgson JA at [39].
[39] The discretionary considerations that may influence and/or determine the ultimate order made depend upon the particular circumstances of the case. As Ipp JA observed in Bilous v Mudaliar [2006] NSWCA 38 ; 65 NSWLR 615 at [63]:
"Determinations as to what orders should be made under s 20 are to be made solely on the grounds of the justice and equity of the case.
The justice and equity of the case may derive from the fact that the party who owns the family home or other property was able to retain that property, while the market value increased, because 'of joint efforts of wage earning, homemaking and parenting, and mutual support'.
In some instances the non-financial contributions of one party may result in property of the kind in question not having to be sold. In other instances, the non-financial contributions of one partner may allow the other to advance his or her career and earn a high income that enables the property in question to be maintained and retained.
Thus, an increment in capital value may well result, indirectly, from 'joint efforts of wage earning, homemaking and parenting, and mutual support'."
190Mathematical calculations, whilst not determinative, cannot be ignored. In Manns v Kennedy [2007] NSWCA 217, Campbell JA (with whom Santow JA and Bryson AJA agreed) stated:
[64] However, the "holistic value judgment" is the final step in the process of arriving at an order, namely deciding what adjustment of property seems just and equitable having regard to the contributions identified in paragraphs (a) and (b).
Carrying out the task that section 20 sets requires, before that final step is carried out, an identification and (so far as possible) valuation of the contributions that are being taken into account and an identification and (so far as possible) valuation of the property concerning which it is open to the court to make an adjustment: Howlett v Neilson [2005] NSWCA 149 at [25];
(2005) 33 Fam LR 420 at 407; Saric v Steward [2006] NSWCA 260 at [61]; (2007) DFC 95,401 at 78,713; Chanter v Catts [2005] NSWCA 411 at [22]; (2005) 64 NSWLR 360 at 366.
[65] Further, even in carrying out that final step, "there is no warrant for ignoring the rigour that mathematics can provide": Ross v Elderfield (at [49] per Handley JA (with whom McColl JA and Hislop J agreed)). As Hodgson JA said in Howlett v Neilson (at [39]; 411):
"... while I do not think that these matters can be determined on such mathematical calculations, I think mathematical calculations are of some use in guiding and testing conclusions about what is just and equitable, and also in promoting transparency and consistency in decision-making."
191In this case I will adopt a global approach. This is particularly appropriate given that there is no property which stands apart from their joint endeavours except for Gaythorne.
This assett contributed by the defendant was the start of their investment in property which could not have occurred without it. It was owned by the defendant at the commencement of the relationship and was still retained 15 years later when the relatiionship finished.
|
[
0.003208225592970848,
0.044849686324596405,
-0.0061808740720152855,
0.04524220898747444,
-0.008721361868083477,
-0.0237722285091877,
0.017716793343424797,
-0.03047935478389263,
0.038328055292367935,
0.00912270974367857,
0.01588146761059761,
0.05465978756546974,
-0.027073783800005913,
-0.008390389382839203,
-0.006953736301511526,
-0.041569340974092484,
0.003457693848758936,
0.004014287609606981,
-0.006999083328992128,
-0.007300242781639099,
-0.02601643092930317,
0.02486698515713215,
0.028422217816114426,
0.00944853201508522,
0.017543207854032516,
0.0010342475725337863,
-0.033531129360198975,
0.015371402725577354,
0.05030706524848938,
0.0188247412443161,
-0.031365349888801575,
0.006130394991487265,
0.006505140569061041,
-0.04332902655005455,
-0.0007658082176931202,
-0.017798926681280136,
-0.012607280164957047,
-0.003885120153427124,
-0.025164226070046425,
0.03092343732714653,
-0.002081429585814476,
0.013991082087159157,
-0.01682840846478939,
-0.013588185422122478,
0.0655563622713089,
-0.01073518581688404,
-0.028559979051351547,
-0.039815712720155716,
-0.028733715415000916,
-0.026010781526565552,
-0.034119103103876114,
0.022415975108742714,
0.045720577239990234,
-0.039214152842760086,
0.016581861302256584,
0.029280245304107666,
-0.0372399240732193,
-0.015680165961384773,
-0.07814531773328781,
-0.015338383615016937,
0.004880622494965792,
0.001950823818333447,
-0.05529136583209038,
-0.02395671047270298,
0.004523755516856909,
0.03524218127131462,
0.0046554128639400005,
-0.0021539705339819193,
0.008503176271915436,
-0.007400499191135168,
-0.03101165033876896,
-0.016209954395890236,
-0.019276821985840797,
-0.017200876027345657,
-0.05009884387254715,
0.01606624573469162,
0.011755870655179024,
0.027789514511823654,
0.012975812889635563,
-0.0066824499517679214,
-0.0010872601997107267,
-0.03208669275045395,
-0.011600416153669357,
0.00230416189879179,
-0.03472553566098213,
0.04769117385149002,
-0.016490263864398003,
0.03376786783337593,
0.059120576828718185,
-0.0210832878947258,
-0.0233991090208292,
0.01764979213476181,
0.023827223107218742,
-0.019666409119963646,
0.01182593684643507,
-0.009498858824372292,
-0.07956686615943909,
0.02744310349225998,
-0.033524658530950546,
0.03606058657169342,
0.047602709382772446,
0.032128576189279556,
0.02531752549111843,
-0.013081827200949192,
0.00688057579100132,
0.013231268152594566,
0.011194145306944847,
0.03565145283937454,
0.05265514925122261,
-0.0039994684047997,
0.02788187377154827,
-0.014258853159844875,
0.006814723368734121,
0.024320418015122414,
-0.008016417734324932,
-0.014306380413472652,
0.0024949470534920692,
0.008078488521277905,
0.011545316316187382,
0.00677958969026804,
0.04429394751787186,
0.020874883979558945,
0.03931809961795807,
-0.02129765972495079,
-0.040483854711055756,
0.029205532744526863,
0.0035312173422425985,
0.05365888401865959,
-0.03854069113731384,
0.00017824974202085286,
-0.019383566454052925,
-0.008410199545323849,
-0.025480439886450768,
-0.02311517484486103,
0.0025755935348570347,
0.009581424295902252,
0.03322670981287956,
0.024285197257995605,
0.01380150392651558,
-0.07237611711025238,
0.032218772917985916,
0.018206199631094933,
0.009746545925736427,
-0.02585718035697937,
0.028924042358994484,
0.02828235737979412,
0.024072257801890373,
-0.03561350330710411,
-0.0177072174847126,
-0.013281854800879955,
0.026111649349331856,
0.046127062290906906,
-0.02011542208492756,
-0.002773243933916092,
0.03715410828590393,
-0.03804658353328705,
-0.0025062065105885267,
0.025139234960079193,
-0.01205907016992569,
0.026286302134394646,
0.006801713723689318,
-0.0028766575269401073,
-0.034594129770994186,
-0.007612849120050669,
0.0035827045794576406,
-0.0026452329475432634,
-0.012122354470193386,
0.05365682393312454,
-0.013300425373017788,
-0.03050302155315876,
-0.008017915301024914,
-0.06172436848282814,
-0.026983996853232384,
-0.019126659259200096,
0.03052418678998947,
0.018456047400832176,
0.08186666667461395,
0.013257788494229317,
-0.015606604516506195,
-0.02927982062101364,
-0.00003488513539195992,
-0.003036402864381671,
-0.0071578118950128555,
-0.023177344352006912,
-0.04770313575863838,
0.024396218359470367,
-0.026812894269824028,
-0.03551175817847252,
0.035892993211746216,
0.02004513517022133,
-0.018004074692726135,
-0.010693383403122425,
0.026397977024316788,
-0.012671620585024357,
0.035315729677677155,
-0.03875752538442612,
-0.012173915281891823,
-0.006775905378162861,
0.03540543466806412,
0.017062153667211533,
-0.04144556075334549,
0.015167394652962685,
0.027947204187512398,
0.011681666597723961,
-0.03595690056681633,
0.006396356970071793,
-0.02926567941904068,
-0.022876808419823647,
0.05975544452667236,
-0.0036503777373582125,
0.02800096571445465,
0.04578108340501785,
0.04127679392695427,
-0.0016105326358228922,
0.00547380605712533,
0.003237747820094228,
-0.018401043489575386,
-0.03153430297970772,
-0.012258998118340969,
-0.0033911766950041056,
0.003009924665093422,
0.022323254495859146,
0.027120796963572502,
0.05482080951333046,
0.004041648935526609,
0.014402179047465324,
-0.035199861973524094,
-0.024007456377148628,
0.06440139561891556,
-0.014568773098289967,
0.0243154838681221,
0.00671363202854991,
0.02365954965353012,
-0.03985811769962311,
-0.019150834530591965,
0.017388297244906425,
0.029156843200325966,
0.019587159156799316,
-0.02125370502471924,
0.006100962869822979,
-0.05458991602063179,
-0.01726546324789524,
0.017292995005846024,
-0.012427096255123615,
-0.020462796092033386,
0.005473616532981396,
-0.003892944660037756,
0.003202182939276099,
0.04514329880475998,
-0.023585613816976547,
0.021046647801995277,
0.0024087349884212017,
0.01423695869743824,
0.0343337208032608,
-0.014068247750401497,
0.021358031779527664,
0.01070136297494173,
-0.026047853752970695,
0.02816108614206314,
-0.046498581767082214,
-0.009612063877284527,
0.024026790633797646,
0.05658431351184845,
0.004780234303325415,
0.02559555135667324,
-0.015962479636073112,
-0.028480611741542816,
-0.016882430762052536,
0.036482073366642,
-0.013962581753730774,
-0.028703516349196434,
0.009045610204339027,
-0.021400243043899536,
-0.012588603422045708,
0.03307550773024559,
0.06338296085596085,
0.014865859411656857,
0.0014919344102963805,
0.05031141638755798,
-0.0028249791357666254,
-0.0013982789823785424,
0.05061356723308563,
0.007555067539215088,
-0.03652482107281685,
0.024286963045597076,
-0.003582276403903961,
-0.017597585916519165,
-0.044665977358818054,
0.021504942327737808,
-0.04835851863026619,
0.02805311605334282,
-0.011220477521419525,
0.08210261911153793,
0.007560280617326498,
-0.06144824996590614,
-0.03354090824723244,
-0.017420800402760506,
-0.13694413006305695,
-0.019652917981147766,
0.008347580209374428,
0.03330693393945694,
-0.0035974630154669285,
0.031715597957372665,
-0.03708985075354576,
0.007516829762607813,
0.006591739133000374,
0.05435151979327202,
0.007656918838620186,
-0.08111394941806793,
-0.019571829587221146,
0.030278196558356285,
0.0026605352759361267,
-0.03450567275285721,
0.010166006162762642,
0.0022049241233617067,
0.03784002363681793,
-0.01870747283101082,
-0.027346964925527573,
-0.04218072444200516,
0.001425796071998775,
-0.009672368876636028,
0.01646232418715954,
-0.0018383500864729285,
-0.01615593582391739,
0.03362468630075455,
-0.0319477841258049,
-0.051384828984737396,
-0.020979834720492363,
-0.0001298154820688069,
0.00020818111079279333,
0.00510900653898716,
-0.015012199059128761,
0.01768709160387516,
0.02697169966995716,
-0.05295649543404579,
0.029620785266160965,
-0.036243170499801636,
0.026289639994502068,
0.02986825443804264,
-0.03998774662613869,
0.026865795254707336,
-0.037039440125226974,
-0.04050246253609657,
0.01700776442885399,
0.026539301499724388,
-0.0014943873975425959,
0.06306848675012589,
-0.024941205978393555,
-0.005092136096209288,
-0.026437019929289818,
-0.008968163281679153,
-0.05190005525946617,
-0.0030709542334079742,
0.02445555478334427,
0.0700913593173027,
-0.029321148991584778,
0.03048277273774147,
-0.02570739947259426,
-0.03464803472161293,
0.006606430280953646,
0.008662335574626923,
-0.0108138183131814,
-0.00022474057914223522,
0.031042709946632385,
-0.019597938284277916,
0.047523122280836105,
-0.008729647845029831,
0.004846989177167416,
-0.06567461788654327,
-0.017611196264624596,
-0.004334303550422192,
-0.008083337917923927,
0.004674273077398539,
0.03764677420258522,
-0.03367336839437485,
0.001983384834602475,
-0.07607197761535645,
0.01772288605570793,
-0.009951680898666382,
0.007539903745055199,
0.05640048906207085,
-0.002693311544135213,
0.004088276065886021,
0.022876568138599396,
-0.02433524653315544,
0.031101908534765244,
0.24440570175647736,
0.006301139015704393,
0.025910185649991035,
0.009915259666740894,
0.017108561471104622,
0.016001714393496513,
0.02809235081076622,
0.04054306074976921,
0.0023261490277945995,
-0.03193899989128113,
0.005144903901964426,
0.021016061305999756,
0.014321630820631981,
0.025782350450754166,
-0.04630552977323532,
0.0366630032658577,
-0.06023354083299637,
-0.048068273812532425,
0.0725456103682518,
-0.03008969873189926,
0.025694498792290688,
-0.0668368861079216,
0.005991153884679079,
0.038118280470371246,
-0.048068851232528687,
-0.012370582669973373,
-0.019714761525392532,
0.03191958740353584,
-0.027852466329932213,
0.038817960768938065,
-0.023517513647675514,
-0.010338794440031052,
0.029918668791651726,
-0.022388970479369164,
0.0025951419956982136,
0.0000034320721624681028,
-0.011706757359206676,
0.00871534738689661,
0.005218734033405781,
0.0171201191842556,
0.01635768637061119,
-0.015770912170410156,
-0.02647915482521057,
-0.030101140961050987,
0.03866424039006233,
0.004072802606970072,
0.006325596943497658,
0.0020075838547199965,
-0.004527219571173191,
0.033336516469717026,
-0.013759765774011612,
0.002247902099043131,
-0.03020251914858818,
-0.023641174659132957,
-0.012130143120884895,
0.009775005280971527,
0.017933165654540062,
0.048997633159160614,
-0.03945635259151459,
-0.0051435437053442,
0.0005892206099815667,
-0.004515388049185276,
-0.01000517513602972,
-0.025552116334438324,
-0.004238959401845932,
0.011863445863127708,
-0.011711914092302322,
-0.038702722638845444,
0.027525749057531357,
0.02470814436674118,
0.018164224922657013,
0.014844154939055443,
-0.02396995574235916,
0.033084746450185776,
0.048439767211675644,
-0.004695592913776636,
-0.010591106489300728,
0.03084736317396164,
0.024125274270772934,
-0.02579367905855179,
-0.031187424436211586,
-0.028675103560090065,
0.007155916187912226,
-0.0026745987124741077,
-0.006058696657419205,
-0.020788811147212982,
-0.05003872886300087,
0.057013846933841705,
0.011968596838414669,
-0.003766835667192936,
-0.03871086612343788,
-0.0368197001516819,
-0.014759855344891548,
-0.00827200897037983,
0.018556971102952957,
-0.01651463843882084,
0.058095015585422516,
0.0004973962786607444,
-0.021597880870103836,
-0.023420438170433044,
0.019338276237249374,
0.038054533302783966,
0.015122783370316029,
-0.036806270480155945,
0.04579080641269684,
-0.07205244898796082,
-0.011942939832806587,
0.014154699631035328,
-0.04336506873369217,
-0.016377748921513557,
-0.02812357060611248,
0.01357548963278532,
-0.018326042219996452,
0.017420873045921326,
0.03884357213973999,
0.02740689180791378,
-0.006109560374170542,
0.021407753229141235,
0.024813026189804077,
0.03535665199160576,
0.011796509847044945,
0.02083362080156803,
0.0188081543892622,
-0.04850862920284271,
-0.030207473784685135,
-0.02381294034421444,
-0.034852638840675354,
-0.0374041311442852,
0.009538202546536922,
-0.010314040817320347,
0.013250965625047684,
-0.02244414947926998,
-0.045234061777591705,
0.010595288127660751,
0.02203568071126938,
-0.002949248068034649,
0.015629250556230545,
0.0021136573050171137,
-0.025702260434627533,
0.052387677133083344,
-0.05405111610889435,
-0.052852265536785126,
-0.008468028157949448,
0.0029111437033861876,
0.00925353728234768,
0.02868068590760231,
0.003230365691706538,
-0.03202909976243973,
-0.05215039849281311,
0.008488182909786701,
-0.008893338963389397,
0.011197475716471672,
0.01647275872528553,
-0.06419343501329422,
-0.017586493864655495,
0.023952415212988853,
0.008774003945291042,
-0.006769012194126844,
0.01844901032745838,
-0.011872109957039356,
-0.015425259247422218,
0.022424690425395966,
0.00793165247887373,
0.01975681260228157,
0.005905066151171923,
0.04847177863121033,
0.01107704546302557,
0.027024708688259125,
0.01821925863623619,
-0.03881128877401352,
-0.01564604602754116,
-0.051226239651441574,
-0.023883245885372162,
0.026578787714242935,
0.02762862853705883,
-0.017342980951070786,
-0.015116443857550621,
0.016003312543034554,
0.03977781906723976,
-0.07424559444189072,
0.03677663207054138,
0.009713159874081612,
-0.06758098304271698,
0.01563098095357418,
-0.013955142349004745,
-0.04350839555263519,
-0.02768537774682045,
0.0016553261084482074,
0.08171474933624268,
-0.051306042820215225,
-0.009426688775420189,
0.09287498891353607,
0.007512274198234081,
-0.034608080983161926,
0.01569235883653164,
0.028018642216920853,
-0.006713305599987507,
0.042817458510398865,
0.027269933372735977,
-0.032708827406167984,
-0.029187679290771484,
0.009137916378676891,
-0.03216325864195824,
-0.023569395765662193,
0.07440531998872757,
0.004268804099410772,
-0.026215825229883194,
0.0013336514821276069,
-0.0049135200679302216,
-0.015228967182338238,
0.0008954267832450569,
-0.005548844579607248,
-0.05866938456892967,
0.010664346627891064,
0.017926329746842384,
-0.00019067406537942588,
0.020467767491936684,
0.04601152241230011,
0.004639790393412113,
-0.038898397237062454,
-0.024657610803842545,
-0.028771698474884033,
-0.013630160130560398,
-0.08915617316961288,
-0.04235965013504028,
0.011651288717985153,
0.01138151716440916,
0.008408411405980587,
-0.0007181517430581152,
-0.05143698304891586,
0.006794553715735674,
-0.06737285107374191,
0.03139253705739975,
0.008315607905387878,
-0.037932220846414566,
-0.015448941849172115,
0.012038104236125946,
-0.0014704697532579303,
0.03712986409664154,
-0.019163846969604492,
-0.007408003322780132,
0.02339310571551323,
0.03672582283616066,
0.04943152517080307,
0.015798548236489296,
-0.03552419692277908,
-0.0038234395906329155,
-0.006315890699625015,
0.026662835851311684,
0.05039017274975777,
-0.018001023679971695,
-0.04030870273709297,
-0.0007773437537252903,
-0.014500688761472702,
0.021533790975809097,
0.0017808667616918683,
-0.016565073281526566,
-0.0016944844974204898,
-0.06339720636606216,
-0.03845835477113724,
0.012569614686071873,
0.005517434794455767,
0.01940217986702919,
-0.02353866584599018,
-0.03821903094649315,
-0.0518290214240551,
0.0209860410541296,
-0.027374474331736565,
-0.009100125171244144,
-0.03213299810886383,
0.011573788709938526,
0.018347423523664474,
-0.04795151576399803,
-0.053987108170986176,
-0.000026866753614740446,
0.004805645439773798,
0.010706594213843346,
0.012415697798132896,
0.014836957678198814,
0.009502208791673183,
0.022491203621029854,
0.012316610664129257,
-0.0006264063995331526,
0.04037630930542946,
-0.04209800064563751,
-0.0032204960007220507,
0.011683885008096695,
0.024877093732357025,
0.022723058238625526,
-0.04102497920393944,
-0.0026096240617334843,
0.007469496224075556,
0.00833286065608263,
0.050683990120887756,
0.016289900988340378,
0.008660530671477318,
0.028544137254357338,
-0.018681690096855164,
-0.0030500502325594425,
0.020115522667765617,
-0.050634562969207764,
-0.03843428194522858,
-0.01464590709656477,
-0.04717634245753288,
0.022720659151673317,
0.03555459901690483,
0.0313703827559948,
-0.04579947888851166,
-0.021188853308558464,
0.010708232410252094,
-0.025640012696385384,
-0.08938033133745193,
0.018147045746445656,
0.02529955469071865,
0.02611364796757698,
0.011599964462220669,
0.030687103047966957,
0.01842900924384594,
-0.017771754413843155,
0.04485590383410454,
0.00663601653650403,
-0.023392263799905777,
-0.03335972875356674,
-0.057096343487501144,
-0.02153882011771202,
-0.019166061654686928,
0.02779202349483967,
-0.021460890769958496,
-0.012839036993682384,
0.03203067556023598,
-0.047486815601587296,
0.008313581347465515,
0.001463859574869275,
0.0023008461575955153,
-0.006706815212965012,
0.0019601734820753336,
-0.004196598194539547,
-0.03001326322555542,
0.07704204320907593,
-0.02908528409898281,
-0.02225741557776928,
-0.0668947845697403,
0.08648397028446198,
-0.008867522701621056,
-0.013226591050624847,
-0.025323206558823586,
-0.007862930186092854,
-0.02350674569606781,
0.0034500081092119217,
0.00934541691094637,
0.0057067545130848885,
0.01794285513460636,
-0.02133854478597641,
-0.008661805652081966,
0.016682103276252747,
0.02249683439731598,
0.050731319934129715,
-0.005954543594270945,
-0.007478953339159489,
-0.018841765820980072,
-0.03089321218430996,
-0.019309580326080322,
0.030967192724347115,
-0.01505041029304266,
0.02528979629278183,
0.014855355024337769,
0.017022421583533287,
-0.01388577651232481,
0.005247157532721758,
-0.007219826336950064,
0.06693701446056366,
-0.029978759586811066,
-0.001289533800445497,
0.021993104368448257,
-0.04147285968065262,
-0.004321049898862839,
0.007348289247602224,
-0.0037742466665804386,
0.00892297551035881,
-0.0011172180529683828,
0.01364800427109003,
-0.01371641457080841,
-0.06674260646104813,
-0.011529202573001385,
-0.015904825180768967,
-0.007849889807403088,
0.029810532927513123,
-0.009468518197536469,
-0.00859870482236147,
0.024184392765164375,
0.016672642901539803,
0.09800208359956741,
-0.02397991716861725,
-0.026679184287786484,
-0.1402217596769333,
0.009454971179366112,
0.023473376408219337,
0.0483875647187233,
-0.06571453809738159,
-0.0003403812588658184,
-0.03585248813033104,
0.025129057466983795,
-0.009668002836406231,
-0.006882357876747847,
-0.02515292912721634,
0.003268583444878459,
0.0017078828532248735,
-0.0037884770426899195,
0.0013338413555175066,
0.01137219462543726,
-0.01037850696593523,
-0.06336600333452225,
-0.05804307758808136,
0.020790189504623413,
-0.013670307584106922,
-0.009455264545977116,
-0.028430256992578506,
0.008545685559511185,
0.048378173261880875,
-0.041838400065898895,
-0.039405301213264465,
-0.04808744415640831,
-0.04820053651928902,
-0.09541534632444382,
-0.05247107893228531,
-0.013124744407832623,
0.0008986979373730719,
0.009566162712872028,
-0.04171472042798996,
-0.010145721957087517,
-0.016972020268440247,
0.010241531766951084,
-0.07593969255685806,
-0.024829231202602386,
0.0006482262397184968,
0.05504484102129936,
-0.009662511758506298,
0.010302707552909851,
-0.011419422924518585,
0.05760592967271805,
0.00839805044233799,
-0.020663775503635406,
-0.04163513705134392,
-0.040610019117593765,
-0.03360450267791748,
0.045022252947092056,
0.0375412218272686,
0.036626365035772324,
-0.010980394668877125,
0.020279811695218086,
-0.008400827646255493,
-0.02516232430934906,
0.022997001186013222,
0.04661743715405464,
0.04183436930179596,
0.0008113687508739531,
-0.011181961745023727,
-0.04828665405511856,
-0.0149834668263793,
0.013967134058475494,
-0.0246457327157259,
-0.0172808188945055,
0.006053614895790815,
-0.003464014269411564,
-0.006656403187662363,
0.05050346627831459,
0.0224290918558836,
-0.03081153705716133,
0.010328857228159904,
-0.005665212403982878,
-0.010893501341342926,
-0.004787456709891558,
0.006549540441483259,
0.029135331511497498,
-0.03963955119252205,
-0.005317822098731995,
-0.019688406959176064,
-0.008998443372547626,
0.06438615173101425,
0.015209472738206387,
0.020985683426260948,
0.0040617771446704865,
-0.030876148492097855,
-0.0402848906815052,
-0.03771200403571129,
-0.009937291033565998,
-0.010972416959702969,
-0.01871686801314354,
-0.022985175251960754,
0.023025892674922943,
-0.008226968348026276,
0.013769879937171936,
-0.03796904534101486,
-0.03629940748214722,
0.018633956089615822,
-0.03918609768152237,
0.02001388929784298,
-0.009548272006213665,
-0.06694965064525604,
0.036695268005132675,
0.04248025268316269,
-0.009792176075279713,
0.03965993598103523,
0.006353926844894886,
0.0034587285481393337,
-0.0028655054047703743,
-0.013439210131764412,
0.025395400822162628,
0.002039248589426279,
0.034395940601825714,
0.003443019464612007,
0.030207660049200058,
0.026366323232650757,
-0.01608089543879032,
0.013293643482029438,
0.00696673896163702,
-0.006662554573267698,
-0.020637858659029007,
-0.0225836131721735,
0.02977799065411091,
0.07371413707733154,
0.017012011259794235,
0.054301917552948,
-0.0376259945333004,
0.03385612368583679,
-0.049699753522872925,
0.011121895164251328,
0.015685921534895897,
0.04258527606725693,
0.01759660802781582,
-0.021968692541122437,
0.025630682706832886,
-0.011959033086895943,
-0.055263739079236984,
-0.0042450749315321445,
-0.023350104689598083,
0.026721570640802383,
0.014431807212531567,
-0.015477243810892105,
-0.02688421495258808,
-0.0007168280426412821,
0.044892314821481705,
-0.016308898106217384,
-0.04340561479330063,
-0.0027953782118856907,
-0.013508355244994164,
0.009585535153746605,
0.06813592463731766,
-0.014814415946602821,
-0.027003098279237747,
-0.01187306921929121,
0.0030546914786100388,
0.014971725642681122,
0.048056814819574356,
0.03326224908232689,
-0.011814706027507782,
-0.012253588996827602,
-0.01819983683526516,
-0.04586232081055641,
0.03747792914509773,
-0.016286421567201614,
0.03224369138479233,
-0.001979886321350932,
0.019057197496294975,
0.05300856754183769,
0.019152294844388962,
-0.018058080226182938,
-0.008367384783923626,
0.010606947354972363,
-0.000017228951037395746,
0.009401888586580753,
0.03547825291752815,
0.03012293390929699,
-0.030393140390515327,
0.03158614784479141,
0.021526901051402092,
0.05893245339393616,
-0.003747784998267889,
0.014180481433868408,
0.010509904474020004,
-0.03173470497131348,
0.014927116222679615,
0.02880209870636463,
-0.0333864726126194,
-0.0304748322814703,
0.020714113488793373,
0.04376611113548279,
-0.05575934052467346,
0.04363599419593811,
0.05757634714245796,
-0.006464149337261915,
0.014651990495622158,
0.019949879497289658,
0.022335097193717957,
0.018619704991579056,
-0.002807807642966509,
-0.048170074820518494,
0.010073540732264519,
-0.024988966062664986,
-0.035614944994449615,
-0.010544409044086933,
-0.021853912621736526,
-0.04010873660445213,
0.04144616425037384,
-0.03879452869296074,
0.008425015024840832,
-0.033703725785017014,
0.03408750519156456,
0.008590522222220898,
0.002169624902307987,
0.05733742564916611,
0.007856460288167,
0.02865775302052498,
-0.027912316843867302,
0.018396157771348953,
0.039729077368974686,
-0.047090914100408554,
-0.04203285649418831,
0.001533567439764738,
0.03387085720896721,
-0.013992526568472385,
-0.03687504306435585,
-0.0217455867677927,
0.014706929214298725,
-0.0512947253882885,
-0.03768666833639145,
0.018004918470978737,
0.036873556673526764,
-0.012715209275484085,
-0.03798345848917961,
0.013756344094872475,
-0.03167042136192322,
-0.03778479993343353,
-0.015201776288449764,
-0.014799452386796474,
-0.031522441655397415,
-0.009007998742163181,
0.03671909496188164
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:48
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
Did the condition, or conditions, in particular render her incapable of, or substantially impeded, the management of her affairs, in relation to each of the assaults and batteries inflicted upon her?
I believe, on the balance of probability, that she was caught up in a particular frame of mind, desperately hoping that the relationship would be salvageable and that the once-charming and considerate de facto husband would once again display such apparent loving and considerate behaviour.
The fact that, during her time with him, she experienced a degree of intermittent reinforcement of the idea that he was a suitable companion, by demonstrating care and expressing a wish to re-engage with her, even after the various periods of separation, that she was caught up emotionally in the hope that such a meaningful resumption of the original style of relationship would occur.
8. You ask -
Is it reasonable, having regard to her then condition, that Mrs Mulcahy was incapacitated, as set forth under Paragraph 6 (a)(1) of the Amended Statement of Cross-Claim Past Economic Loss?
I believe that it is reasonable, having regard to her then condition, that Mrs Mulcahy was incapacitated, as set forth.
9. You ask -
Similarly, would Mrs Mulcahy likely have been unable to carry out the work described in Paragraph 6 (a) (Hi) of the Amended Statement of Cross-Claim?
I believe that this is, on the balance of probability, likely to be true.
10.You ask-
Would I further provide my opinion, again, on the balance of probabilities only, as to whether it is likely that Mrs Mulcahy's current incapacity for work will continue into the future and, if so, is this probably the case on an indefinite basis?
I do not believe that it is likely that Mrs Mulcahy's current incapacity for work will continue into the future, if she engages in appropriate psychopharmacological and psychotherapeutic management of her Mixed Anxiety Depressive condition, and particularly if there is a favourable outcome to her Cross-Claim.
In the event that she fails to be successful in her Cross-Claim, I believe it will be tantamount to driving the final nail into the coffin of her self-confidence and her sense of fairness, in the face of the abuse to which she has allegedly been subjected to by Mr Cooper.
11.You ask-
What are the prospects, if any, of her returning, during the remainder of her prospective working life, to any gainful employment and, if so, in what measure?
As I have indicated above, I believe that with the correct intervention and with what is perceived as a fair outcome of the legal proceedings, she could return to gainful employment, subject to her successful response to treatment. The latter of course is yet to occur and is beyond definite prognostication at this stage.
261As noted above Dr Klug says:
"My opinion is that Ms. Mulcahy is not suffering from any severe psychiatric condition. She certainly has not been suffering from a chronic post-traumatic stress disorder or a major depressive disorder. She has probably suffered, at times, from an adjustment disorder.
An adjustment disorder is not a major mood disturbance but is nevertheless a significant psychiatric entity characterized by excessive distress and/or dysfunction in response to a specific stressor or stressors.
If Ms. Mulcahy has suffered from an adjustment disorder (chronic or intermittent) it would need to be specified what the stressors were that induced this condition. To my knowledge, and from the history Ms.
Mulcahy provided at interview, there has been no exposure to traumatic stressors. I note she is being medicated with an antidepressant and a minor tranquillizer and this is compatible with the diagnosis of an adjustment disorder. "
262In response to Dr Fischer's report he says:
|
[
-0.012678355909883976,
0.022788550704717636,
-0.052291907370090485,
-0.030040688812732697,
0.002561271656304598,
-0.009835924953222275,
0.04306066781282425,
0.013266008347272873,
0.02803081087768078,
-0.01697964034974575,
-0.024458829313516617,
0.04768485203385353,
-0.0004519689828157425,
0.01908804662525654,
0.013334060087800026,
-0.05477980896830559,
0.030544742941856384,
-0.007300152443349361,
-0.03841324523091316,
-0.020409507676959038,
-0.027755102142691612,
0.004470302257686853,
0.05668838322162628,
0.01606879010796547,
-0.021134153008461,
0.05402987450361252,
-0.0380588099360466,
0.01050877571105957,
-0.02853117510676384,
0.025990108028054237,
0.002644054125994444,
-0.032429903745651245,
0.027817970141768456,
-0.023799756541848183,
0.07638552039861679,
-0.012284250929951668,
-0.014208052307367325,
-0.02965344302356243,
-0.02188866026699543,
0.02996554784476757,
0.01666584424674511,
-0.013130998238921165,
0.009126460179686546,
-0.023251311853528023,
0.01186139602214098,
-0.05065958946943283,
0.000029063703550491482,
-0.02173212729394436,
-0.0035767618101090193,
-0.036063581705093384,
-0.036139409989118576,
-0.030081896111369133,
0.03451670706272125,
0.013952964916825294,
0.01124101784080267,
0.007772357203066349,
-0.00616199616342783,
-0.014026842080056667,
-0.024807078763842583,
-0.012477540411055088,
-0.05097084492444992,
-0.008449426852166653,
0.01681717112660408,
-0.02186112478375435,
-0.025156240910291672,
0.07258230447769165,
-0.0133393295109272,
-0.031770139932632446,
0.017425766214728355,
-0.05848894268274307,
-0.012043255381286144,
0.020131871104240417,
-0.014656184241175652,
-0.025677921250462532,
-0.08496933430433273,
0.007586311548948288,
-0.003971653990447521,
0.006173725705593824,
0.018089430406689644,
0.04505293443799019,
0.002105914754793048,
0.036628082394599915,
0.034213315695524216,
0.042158495634794235,
-0.02785618230700493,
0.007622437085956335,
-0.01756463199853897,
-0.0016797577263787389,
-0.013048261404037476,
-0.047445207834243774,
-0.020518722012639046,
0.00007301368896150962,
-0.016252372413873672,
-0.05636739358305931,
-0.04704599827528,
0.001844929065555334,
-0.041565343737602234,
0.023045985028147697,
0.031570520251989365,
0.03710641339421272,
-0.00718756252899766,
0.0200328528881073,
-0.0030357050709426403,
-0.028796864673495293,
-0.03994932770729065,
-0.0005818440113216639,
-0.002115932758897543,
0.06741337478160858,
0.035094004124403,
-0.001024833763949573,
0.008557111024856567,
-0.015993677079677582,
0.026781756430864334,
0.03352632746100426,
-0.023499954491853714,
0.00864399503916502,
0.015642067417502403,
-0.05209076777100563,
0.025468116626143456,
-0.03396492823958397,
0.0038126884028315544,
0.04474985972046852,
0.012432864867150784,
0.00911641214042902,
-0.04240255057811737,
0.022141389548778534,
-0.006112527567893267,
0.004721726756542921,
-0.02036929503083229,
0.04438691586256027,
-0.008183378726243973,
-0.004024232737720013,
-0.02291402965784073,
-0.05865263566374779,
-0.017904268577694893,
-0.022443804889917374,
0.04948703199625015,
0.01596478745341301,
-0.022446630522608757,
-0.017709476873278618,
0.030157344415783882,
0.01838606223464012,
0.04930984973907471,
-0.019239531829953194,
0.009885186329483986,
-0.03949500247836113,
0.06530553102493286,
-0.018180696293711662,
0.011954877525568008,
-0.028760766610503197,
0.028341026976704597,
-0.03294239193201065,
0.026929333806037903,
-0.02920207567512989,
0.04930439218878746,
-0.008006173186004162,
0.00511585408821702,
0.008883830159902573,
0.029170991852879524,
-0.029883159324526787,
-0.022691108286380768,
0.07150343060493469,
-0.03704613819718361,
-0.0034833624958992004,
0.027425270527601242,
-0.0017944729188457131,
-0.008033554069697857,
0.05651809647679329,
-0.020618870854377747,
-0.034835122525691986,
-0.004353544674813747,
-0.02233651652932167,
0.04189971461892128,
0.010457698255777359,
0.014978400431573391,
0.02416023425757885,
0.08999481797218323,
0.014508419670164585,
0.02271140180528164,
-0.03540157899260521,
-0.03544854372739792,
0.050061073154211044,
0.02634849213063717,
-0.05650002509355545,
0.009868609718978405,
-0.003400938119739294,
-0.012560876086354256,
-0.06158195808529854,
0.01957051455974579,
0.004845381714403629,
-0.027557622641324997,
-0.03633120656013489,
0.025011399760842323,
0.03568771108984947,
0.10360319912433624,
-0.023297753185033798,
0.0005827101413160563,
-0.02984040230512619,
0.021989041939377785,
-0.04685655236244202,
0.00932412687689066,
0.0346321165561676,
0.02087550051510334,
0.024764353409409523,
-0.015026748180389404,
0.007803306449204683,
-0.04421074688434601,
-0.016706502065062523,
-0.01790843904018402,
-0.02944175712764263,
0.007166275754570961,
0.03543372452259064,
-0.010422665625810623,
0.020030595362186432,
0.008379464969038963,
-0.00002490605584171135,
-0.0033529994543641806,
-0.013608447276055813,
-0.008280056528747082,
-0.012342709116637707,
0.023345913738012314,
0.003710688091814518,
0.013448817655444145,
-0.030070530250668526,
0.004270203877240419,
0.03681281954050064,
0.002392852446064353,
0.03387981653213501,
0.027188139036297798,
-0.03907107189297676,
0.0819404199719429,
0.017265690490603447,
0.005630576983094215,
0.004128234460949898,
0.01447194442152977,
0.032487232238054276,
0.030335623770952225,
0.015769783407449722,
0.024535220116376877,
-0.0017975509399548173,
-0.020991787314414978,
-0.023564349859952927,
0.04520474001765251,
-0.024543169885873795,
-0.008275866508483887,
0.016813889145851135,
0.021431993693113327,
0.013771459460258484,
0.004765309393405914,
0.0321616530418396,
0.0293791014701128,
0.025990348309278488,
0.005752217955887318,
-0.019541887566447258,
0.06816720217466354,
0.03301480412483215,
0.011366157792508602,
0.0026690573431551456,
0.00018566871585790068,
-0.04345326125621796,
-0.023643050342798233,
0.05055474862456322,
0.010140595957636833,
-0.02140396274626255,
-0.024549437686800957,
-0.021839240565896034,
0.0009913869434967637,
-0.018171923235058784,
-0.019844690337777138,
-0.004662916995584965,
0.0075584109872579575,
-0.0443950891494751,
-0.026597781106829643,
-0.017580470070242882,
0.020445220172405243,
0.003138937521725893,
0.023777969181537628,
-0.04109399765729904,
0.05054735764861107,
0.005875880364328623,
0.037883199751377106,
0.010181611403822899,
0.013992607593536377,
-0.001687646028585732,
-0.02006949484348297,
0.0188992228358984,
-0.02522888034582138,
-0.02324405498802662,
-0.007950306870043278,
-0.05842181295156479,
0.02454904094338417,
0.01247034315019846,
0.07891348749399185,
0.005205188877880573,
-0.03399989753961563,
0.02963101677596569,
0.002664315514266491,
-0.14806054532527924,
-0.04642830044031143,
0.01813690736889839,
0.013526519760489464,
0.011212623678147793,
0.027457863092422485,
0.008445492945611477,
-0.0018739799270406365,
-0.047844547778367996,
-0.010366056114435196,
0.039307668805122375,
-0.051656752824783325,
0.009368490427732468,
0.016383010894060135,
0.0088431341573596,
0.02864847332239151,
-0.003576359711587429,
0.011111505329608917,
-0.008183985948562622,
-0.05236669257283211,
-0.00610829284414649,
0.0063457489013671875,
0.04370637238025665,
-0.021999740973114967,
0.014736020006239414,
0.03213727846741676,
0.06238666549324989,
-0.029982194304466248,
-0.047652069479227066,
-0.032847244292497635,
-0.027561374008655548,
0.0039536431431770325,
-0.010195034556090832,
0.03186197578907013,
-0.025278208777308464,
0.00029731635004282,
0.01977783627808094,
-0.05136905238032341,
-0.0022208215668797493,
-0.053364839404821396,
0.025834688916802406,
0.015143253840506077,
0.017989343032240868,
0.055036671459674835,
-0.030927885323762894,
-0.05196034163236618,
0.03420945256948471,
-0.024231797084212303,
-0.03362424671649933,
-0.011567505076527596,
-0.04265971481800079,
0.018697110936045647,
-0.04806944355368614,
-0.001070070662535727,
-0.027909431606531143,
-0.029118118807673454,
0.03544340282678604,
0.04821934551000595,
-0.004551257472485304,
-0.020514849573373795,
0.03214022517204285,
-0.073702372610569,
0.014188388362526894,
-0.011011781170964241,
-0.02919810451567173,
-0.00026230703224428,
-0.0381857305765152,
0.03661308065056801,
0.01002933457493782,
0.005702801048755646,
-0.003009509528055787,
-0.01865733228623867,
-0.02084408886730671,
0.0001716650149319321,
-0.006468837149441242,
0.05415673181414604,
0.029019588604569435,
0.0022406543139368296,
-0.02525879256427288,
-0.08897426724433899,
0.00890425592660904,
0.01538802869617939,
0.0033602912444621325,
0.025507597252726555,
-0.016331862658262253,
-0.02040930651128292,
0.043400563299655914,
0.02453242801129818,
0.02295604720711708,
0.23812389373779297,
0.03416091576218605,
0.010010910220444202,
0.0007238411344587803,
0.010800815187394619,
-0.009197305887937546,
0.02058621682226658,
-0.0036698367912322283,
0.01608043536543846,
-0.020982276648283005,
-0.03381616994738579,
-0.020518479868769646,
-0.003196408972144127,
0.03260992094874382,
-0.034852877259254456,
0.017191637307405472,
-0.0696413591504097,
-0.05756869167089462,
0.07212483137845993,
-0.0012193770380690694,
0.02364910952746868,
-0.050925325602293015,
0.02697240188717842,
0.018883323296904564,
-0.048809148371219635,
0.01237894780933857,
0.006751072593033314,
0.042538803070783615,
-0.013240511529147625,
-0.015076021663844585,
-0.03543195128440857,
-0.022896092385053635,
0.06494216620922089,
-0.0355052687227726,
0.012867441400885582,
0.0027832842897623777,
-0.00892176665365696,
0.0020775252487510443,
-0.06802810728549957,
0.05941874533891678,
0.02454005926847458,
-0.01499965414404869,
-0.02938353642821312,
-0.04008416831493378,
0.020180780440568924,
0.004433567635715008,
-0.01356720644980669,
0.03572559356689453,
-0.004945979919284582,
0.04040447995066643,
-0.0029601489659398794,
-0.016261180862784386,
0.007128181867301464,
0.006267312448471785,
-0.02095259167253971,
-0.0027837827801704407,
-0.024989016354084015,
0.01337510347366333,
-0.02847454696893692,
0.052368905395269394,
-0.017708342522382736,
0.025237897410988808,
-0.07499369978904724,
0.034043919295072556,
-0.02896660380065441,
0.043962299823760986,
-0.053117457777261734,
-0.039529185742139816,
0.0383182093501091,
-0.00029145952430553734,
0.017944753170013428,
0.03692194074392319,
0.026004571467638016,
-0.016863541677594185,
0.02938518300652504,
-0.008742994628846645,
-0.010407034307718277,
0.052330002188682556,
0.03315027058124542,
0.05203741416335106,
-0.06033046916127205,
-0.04990838095545769,
-0.050085049122571945,
-0.03169339895248413,
0.00623342115432024,
0.004532675724476576,
-0.05304708331823349,
0.049223773181438446,
0.02449597232043743,
0.005659367423504591,
-0.01074785366654396,
-0.03573320060968399,
-0.021952351555228233,
0.021198363974690437,
-0.03221665322780609,
-0.008007087744772434,
0.009866329841315746,
-0.012531009502708912,
-0.011586267501115799,
-0.038922663778066635,
-0.02272847294807434,
-0.021135743707418442,
-0.014758720062673092,
-0.006354674231261015,
0.01988358050584793,
0.007815944962203503,
-0.008649882860481739,
-0.005084076430648565,
-0.01926705427467823,
0.010666855610907078,
-0.033166565001010895,
-0.008377612568438053,
-0.013738324865698814,
-0.005075537133961916,
0.01946449466049671,
0.005507601425051689,
-0.026903744786977768,
0.03067796304821968,
0.06734529137611389,
0.022075409069657326,
-0.007764097768813372,
0.0021271342411637306,
-0.06575644016265869,
-0.026943735778331757,
-0.004379452671855688,
-0.037095461040735245,
0.021289797499775887,
-0.04515882208943367,
0.0008324926602654159,
0.013219311833381653,
0.002001055981963873,
-0.008427891880273819,
-0.03401263803243637,
-0.02403612807393074,
0.026563668623566628,
-0.038285184651613235,
0.02805720455944538,
-0.0040880367159843445,
0.007352971006184816,
0.04525788500905037,
-0.027641190215945244,
-0.039932843297719955,
-0.03967427834868431,
0.011845107190310955,
0.023259766399860382,
-0.012801616452634335,
-0.05631449818611145,
0.03808929771184921,
-0.020764851942658424,
-0.0018709542928263545,
0.015663892030715942,
0.006974221672862768,
-0.008670132607221603,
-0.04590617120265961,
-0.004946182947605848,
-0.02169189043343067,
-0.015921153128147125,
-0.05946942791342735,
0.03965470567345619,
-0.008948280476033688,
-0.035567667335271835,
0.015368121676146984,
-0.058535147458314896,
0.05263620242476463,
0.002697455231100321,
0.04353222995996475,
0.03925296291708946,
0.06354748457670212,
0.034027568995952606,
-0.008257647044956684,
0.021395059302449226,
-0.02703833021223545,
-0.03283252194523811,
-0.024520738050341606,
0.040582600980997086,
0.03729967027902603,
0.00012079466978320852,
0.03688710927963257,
-0.02191348373889923,
-0.023483259603381157,
0.024295397102832794,
0.01744731143116951,
-0.030348114669322968,
0.030526330694556236,
-0.0037801305297762156,
-0.00807230081409216,
0.02807396650314331,
-0.0007972554303705692,
0.008716640062630177,
-0.047758493572473526,
-0.027068721130490303,
0.07739841192960739,
0.003944911062717438,
-0.02165226638317108,
-0.003747241571545601,
0.016682002693414688,
0.04521913081407547,
0.020014729350805283,
0.017510879784822464,
-0.07395631819963455,
-0.0027521324809640646,
0.017163490876555443,
-0.008744388818740845,
0.061507921665906906,
0.030420221388339996,
-0.008860040456056595,
0.023494787514209747,
-0.00855796318501234,
-0.029409920796751976,
0.001586601254530251,
0.007349494844675064,
0.04136781021952629,
-0.05338768661022186,
-0.013593580573797226,
-0.009439683519303799,
-0.011094454675912857,
0.04499056935310364,
0.0034209219738841057,
-0.01066440436989069,
-0.0556330606341362,
0.00990847498178482,
-0.0008540012640878558,
0.018149320036172867,
-0.07462914288043976,
-0.019602781161665916,
0.019716722890734673,
-0.017176181077957153,
-0.027145713567733765,
-0.026363449171185493,
-0.019019201397895813,
0.001742864609695971,
-0.04346674308180809,
0.03607429936528206,
-0.011181442067027092,
0.008057787083089352,
-0.0009433681261725724,
0.03137167915701866,
0.03460637107491493,
-0.0054114386439323425,
0.008576620370149612,
0.023009397089481354,
-0.029163401573896408,
0.02209530770778656,
0.05793727934360504,
-0.02002551779150963,
-0.026704637333750725,
-0.01759665086865425,
-0.012898190878331661,
0.033808380365371704,
0.026684174314141273,
0.020914973691105843,
0.026976201683282852,
0.0016609729500487447,
-0.010841438546776772,
0.005241783801466227,
0.010213710367679596,
-0.012310035526752472,
0.02480495534837246,
-0.020957348868250847,
-0.020888634026050568,
-0.0062463367357850075,
0.03219154104590416,
0.0210628192871809,
0.000913114461582154,
-0.05469552055001259,
-0.043768495321273804,
0.007280928548425436,
0.03857544809579849,
-0.024321909993886948,
-0.05571078136563301,
-0.0182994045317173,
0.007855908945202827,
-0.0430738665163517,
0.032814688980579376,
-0.026460135355591774,
0.0021403422579169273,
-0.01022987812757492,
0.027609920129179955,
0.0032445278484374285,
-0.010658030398190022,
0.01083790697157383,
0.0346686914563179,
0.02169358730316162,
0.01776394620537758,
-0.003811218775808811,
0.011330543085932732,
0.06510042399168015,
-0.006246770266443491,
0.010282290168106556,
0.0006838034023530781,
0.06001652404665947,
0.019849717617034912,
-0.027680594474077225,
0.04870225489139557,
-0.04815320670604706,
0.022419193759560585,
0.003657086519524455,
0.07928930968046188,
-0.025101713836193085,
0.024891352280974388,
-0.013711163774132729,
0.03566659614443779,
-0.04573093354701996,
0.009061099030077457,
-0.046881303191185,
0.013719004578888416,
0.038938917219638824,
-0.040439289063215256,
0.01298695057630539,
0.012805665843188763,
-0.011045784689486027,
-0.05846206098794937,
-0.01457598339766264,
0.0044473921880126,
0.022800415754318237,
0.0025121348444372416,
0.014771390706300735,
-0.008124285377562046,
-0.00357373827137053,
0.050201572477817535,
0.002070012269541621,
0.01626141369342804,
-0.04046713188290596,
-0.003016700502485037,
-0.04334152489900589,
0.04003262519836426,
-0.010044507682323456,
-0.05020340904593468,
-0.0557379275560379,
-0.024009419605135918,
-0.03212355822324753,
-0.029216518625617027,
-0.006377057172358036,
-0.03905293345451355,
0.05207812041044235,
-0.012010777369141579,
-0.006646301597356796,
-0.03693484142422676,
0.05618337169289589,
-0.02007206715643406,
0.009168535470962524,
-0.052184220403432846,
0.0491289421916008,
-0.008266654796898365,
0.002279010135680437,
0.022884640842676163,
-0.005281348247081041,
-0.014295234344899654,
0.00015390724001917988,
0.006999961566179991,
0.006021497305482626,
-0.005250750109553337,
0.00449717603623867,
-0.036263853311538696,
0.06016654893755913,
-0.01923728920519352,
0.05143772065639496,
0.046814486384391785,
0.017551977187395096,
0.014401630498468876,
-0.028095107525587082,
0.02537548542022705,
0.06251100450754166,
-0.03949851915240288,
-0.0012292562751099467,
0.0044408864341676235,
0.005190279800444841,
-0.022276373580098152,
0.015077671967446804,
0.007411843165755272,
0.02633012644946575,
-0.015776118263602257,
0.03591850399971008,
-0.009255386888980865,
-0.05989871174097061,
0.025564538314938545,
-0.02572294883430004,
0.013035224750638008,
-0.04134640097618103,
-0.01589508354663849,
-0.006727487780153751,
-0.035251230001449585,
0.02904508449137211,
-0.008321038447320461,
-0.013522383756935596,
-0.013736212626099586,
-0.013046142645180225,
0.022103114053606987,
-0.02627350203692913,
0.02248886413872242,
-0.008193925954401493,
0.0009071881067939103,
-0.04451549053192139,
-0.014268722385168076,
-0.1415376365184784,
0.009629477746784687,
0.020135069265961647,
-0.03323071822524071,
-0.07110914587974548,
0.001999660162255168,
-0.047181013971567154,
0.006080491468310356,
-0.018137896433472633,
-0.017881182953715324,
-0.03580616042017937,
-0.030296646058559418,
-0.01634247414767742,
-0.01524081639945507,
-0.04972623661160469,
0.05072716996073723,
0.003346453420817852,
-0.058394063264131546,
0.03442775830626488,
0.032665856182575226,
-0.005986838601529598,
-0.01331339217722416,
0.014255642890930176,
-0.02070005238056183,
-0.03260678052902222,
0.036849796772003174,
-0.05548785999417305,
0.00830758735537529,
-0.04047588258981705,
-0.01918635331094265,
-0.006204595789313316,
-0.007472556550055742,
0.013912661001086235,
-0.012604635208845139,
0.0022776431869715452,
-0.018972469493746758,
0.0024914040695875883,
0.015081913210451603,
-0.042811069637537,
-0.029558423906564713,
0.0002801455557346344,
0.020415998995304108,
-0.006661284249275923,
-0.0073890695348382,
0.009660019539296627,
0.04280395060777664,
-0.001135057071223855,
-0.013498052954673767,
-0.03855137526988983,
-0.012101859785616398,
-0.027092913165688515,
-0.0010524372337386012,
-0.041415683925151825,
0.023582056164741516,
-0.001986147603020072,
-0.0015069618821144104,
-0.029329152777791023,
-0.0035475774202495813,
-0.0032471290323883295,
0.04248630627989769,
-0.0036390821915119886,
0.008921979926526546,
-0.050490036606788635,
-0.0056424872018396854,
-0.013023003935813904,
-0.024980587884783745,
-0.05949133262038231,
0.03583709895610809,
-0.014961459673941135,
-0.0030353039037436247,
0.016600392758846283,
-0.04777872562408447,
0.046815820038318634,
-0.022870605811476707,
-0.008000458590686321,
0.005296844057738781,
0.022427763789892197,
-0.008620809763669968,
-0.040595460683107376,
-0.004896554164588451,
-0.02430136688053608,
0.010439190082252026,
-0.01627478376030922,
-0.044231586158275604,
0.043404847383499146,
-0.008068612776696682,
0.009968609549105167,
-0.028277603909373283,
0.03942315652966499,
-0.003063131822273135,
-0.0671510249376297,
0.0011999733978882432,
-0.004547870252281427,
-0.03361346200108528,
-0.03439449518918991,
0.05779581516981125,
0.01716822013258934,
-0.0019897378515452147,
-0.002856063423678279,
-0.010765761137008667,
0.01091611199080944,
-0.04969017207622528,
0.027561377733945847,
-0.00015970604727044702,
-0.017799939960241318,
0.041937291622161865,
0.0052747903391718864,
-0.015101682394742966,
0.016294332221150398,
0.018000934273004532,
-0.019504709169268608,
0.005334217566996813,
-0.04799415171146393,
-0.006076218094676733,
-0.023717796429991722,
0.04493636265397072,
-0.005834600422531366,
0.02895059436559677,
0.040213990956544876,
0.010554734617471695,
-0.0075751966796815395,
-0.024970192462205887,
0.019145334139466286,
-0.027874799445271492,
0.012672660872340202,
0.03900362178683281,
0.03319098427891731,
0.02463066391646862,
0.005282427649945021,
0.001110985060222447,
0.058184556663036346,
-0.01802859827876091,
-0.02455146797001362,
0.018704190850257874,
-0.0026584919542074203,
0.08073441684246063,
-0.021704083308577538,
0.0028052048292011023,
-0.00999622605741024,
0.012792348861694336,
-0.017292257398366928,
-0.022997476160526276,
-0.015647094696760178,
-0.039915747940540314,
-0.03487332537770271,
0.0014610829530283809,
0.025353049859404564,
0.036953844130039215,
-0.059823498129844666,
-0.0188358835875988,
0.015672268345952034,
0.00996434036642313,
0.03870878368616104,
0.05422814190387726,
0.030360687524080276,
0.002586629241704941,
-0.027039069682359695,
0.0049581378698349,
0.01955571398139,
0.07957769185304642,
0.05087660625576973,
-0.01614430546760559,
-0.041730768978595734,
-0.0110031608492136,
-0.04172655567526817,
0.04544498771429062,
0.005926733370870352,
-0.004223368130624294,
-0.019557133316993713,
-0.006923099514096975,
0.031734153628349304,
0.009160821326076984,
-0.012082966044545174,
-0.00016180639795493335,
0.06011967360973358,
-0.017043516039848328,
0.00889190100133419,
-0.0024291768204420805,
-0.010151983238756657,
0.01070397812873125,
0.04953153431415558,
0.002599327126517892,
0.0007984102121554315,
0.02952343411743641,
-0.020111100748181343,
-0.0020054501947015524,
-0.014827786013484001,
-0.00043018360156565905,
0.018253285437822342,
-0.024956056848168373,
-0.0031632084865123034,
-0.030045878142118454,
0.07664414495229721,
-0.03561744466423988,
0.06271130591630936,
-0.017117779701948166,
-0.026997379958629608,
-0.019525498151779175,
-0.016481658443808556,
-0.00204945495352149,
-0.0051746247336268425,
-0.030879294499754906,
0.017312532290816307,
-0.0033871689811348915,
-0.0077025191858410835,
-0.02160227671265602,
-0.0014117441605776548,
-0.01803709752857685,
-0.004790809936821461,
0.02251548133790493,
-0.012571508064866066,
-0.0034084750805050135,
0.03300541639328003,
-0.014008359052240849,
-0.017528042197227478,
0.006873406004160643,
-0.011134102940559387,
0.006720708683133125,
0.012119853869080544,
0.009145975112915039,
0.022967521101236343,
0.029713300988078117,
0.007030786946415901,
-0.037905216217041016,
0.0037854674737900496,
-0.027116360142827034,
-0.02168707177042961,
0.03232499212026596,
0.02480551041662693,
0.005951971281319857,
-0.04160952568054199,
-0.010668653063476086,
0.0006409524357877672,
0.05077681690454483,
-0.0004522654344327748,
0.02093464694917202,
-0.042715828865766525,
-0.012119073420763016,
-0.03863447159528732,
0.015883129090070724,
0.026225067675113678,
-0.00016223624697886407,
0.00863680150359869,
0.0030559541191905737
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:11
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
That fucking David should have his fucking lips cut off, with that fucking arrogant smirk.
I ought to break both their legs.
It just takes one phone call to destroy their prospects. Cunts!
I've had many conversations with David's staff. I know what they really think of him.
David and Wade are only using you. Once they've got what they want from you, they'll ditch you.
The reason we're in this fucking mess is because of your fucking kids."
* On 6 may 2008 the plaintiff to the knowledge of the defendant was to receive the results of medical tests. The defendant did not ring up to enquire about the results so the plaintiff rang and said repeatedly (in para 597):
"Cunt....cunt... cunt... you miserable selfish fucking cunt"
56I will deal with the factual disputes in respect of the alleged assaults first and then turn to the effect on the defendant of those assaults. In general I note that the defendant gave extensive evidence on the effect of the incidents upon her.
It will then be necessary to consider the application of the medical evidence in respect of the running of any time bar pursuant to the Limitation Act 1969 so far as it concerns the defendant's cross claim for assault.
57This requires a consideration of issues of credit in respect of each party and assumes critical importance in this case because the assaults, which happened at home, were not witnessed by any outsider.
Credibility of the plaintiff
58The plaintiff like many witnesses was not always good with dates. Two examples from the defendant's submissions are appropriate.
At T658, line 25 Cooper was asked questions about the period he was in Melbourne and at line 27 said he believed he said it was 1995 when he went there.
An examination of Cooper's 1993/94 and 1994/95 Tax Returns reveal that he was clearly running Wetcheck Roof Restorers business in Enoggera in Queensland and demonstrates that the evidence of Ms Mulcahy as to when he went to Melbourne, namely 1993, is correct.
Cooper is clearly incorrect in his recollection of dates. Again at T658, line 27 in reference to when he went to Melbourne he said:-
I believe I said it was '95 I went there.
whereas in his affidavit of 22 September 2009, paragraph 12 he said in "about 1992" he moved from Brisbane to Melbourne and stayed for about a year.
59Another example was as follows:
At T725, line 40 Cooper was asked when he first met Peter George and answered "in the early 2000's I believe" and then said "the early 2000's 1 2 3 something like that" however when suggested as follows, line 45:-
Question: You see may I suggest to you that it was 2005?
Answer: Yes it could be yes.
This exchange demonstrates that Cooper's memory is consistently faulty and he would seemingly say anything to get to the next question if he suspected there was proof of the proposition being put.
60At times he could be argumentative. An example appears at T749 when the plaintiff was cross-examined about the beer incident. The following is seen at line 43:
Question: Following those events you drove away for the day did you not?
Answer: Drove away.
Question: I suppose you deny that?
Answer: No hang on I drove away for the day. Well hang on this is supposed to happen in the afternoon or the evening. Not only that I've allegedly been drinking and yet I get in a car and drive away. Ask anybody around. I do not drink during the day.
I certainly do not drink when I'm driving and I certainly do not drink when I'm working in the shed or on the farm because if I got injured Ms Mulcahy could not drive me to hospital. She cannot drive so in terms of me drinking while I'm working it doesn't happen.
61It was submitted that this was an example of Cooper's editorialising - said to be one of the signal stigmata of the unsatisfactory witness.
62At T750 line 9 the plaintiff was directed to the opening words of paragraph 318 of Ms Mulcahy's affidavit,:-
|
[
-0.04211362823843956,
0.02402631565928459,
-0.02396564744412899,
-0.012009347788989544,
-0.021501699462532997,
-0.02332945354282856,
-0.012027686461806297,
-0.009894256480038166,
-0.00661334628239274,
0.02366105653345585,
-0.016003720462322235,
0.04169206693768501,
-0.020580418407917023,
0.0013142343377694488,
0.027788853272795677,
-0.03454376012086868,
0.02675657719373703,
-0.01430737879127264,
-0.017433030530810356,
-0.04424068331718445,
-0.006445109378546476,
-0.03323794901371002,
0.03985954448580742,
0.006865518633276224,
-0.007627577055245638,
0.04962776228785515,
-0.03800864890217781,
-0.019217217341065407,
0.02870100550353527,
0.013482354581356049,
-0.0038852174766361713,
-0.030970374122262,
0.06429728865623474,
0.008010324090719223,
0.00809449888765812,
-0.02369965985417366,
0.005462137516587973,
-0.021698608994483948,
-0.02056553214788437,
-0.017532598227262497,
0.006901721935719252,
0.01187332347035408,
0.008381197229027748,
-0.02820780500769615,
-0.01188670378178358,
-0.018790923058986664,
-0.012630057521164417,
-0.031135808676481247,
-0.005108503624796867,
0.02097269706428051,
-0.038844212889671326,
0.021856321021914482,
0.07329512387514114,
-0.004506062250584364,
0.0001136799473897554,
0.04114289954304695,
0.01670105941593647,
0.001974540762603283,
-0.0617828331887722,
0.01147624384611845,
-0.0034994997549802065,
-0.03153206408023834,
-0.00019777625857386738,
-0.028861956670880318,
-0.004749498795717955,
0.10436858981847763,
-0.02308366820216179,
-0.028145601972937584,
-0.003164618508890271,
-0.04773963242769241,
-0.00878235138952732,
0.02790425531566143,
0.013391464948654175,
-0.023051680997014046,
-0.08120832592248917,
-0.020057380199432373,
0.03431941941380501,
0.02902204357087612,
-0.013972838409245014,
0.04482710361480713,
0.05192415416240692,
0.021597959101200104,
0.014849402941763401,
0.0028816123958677053,
-0.036783523857593536,
0.015046815387904644,
-0.03813786432147026,
0.009524542838335037,
0.016219323500990868,
0.013759980909526348,
-0.023754369467496872,
-0.02689484693109989,
-0.002324555069208145,
-0.05149368569254875,
-0.026295380666851997,
0.0022968770936131477,
-0.05245155096054077,
0.010086821392178535,
0.01828092522919178,
0.03626906871795654,
0.027870675548911095,
0.015934528782963753,
-0.003465557238087058,
-0.046072524040937424,
-0.010909223929047585,
-0.0004564390401355922,
0.08197067677974701,
0.07715686410665512,
0.0189967043697834,
-0.009083547629415989,
0.04021153971552849,
0.025836367160081863,
-0.019769415259361267,
-0.008058572188019753,
-0.0022057786118239164,
0.03619343787431717,
-0.0014650654047727585,
-0.020480509847402573,
-0.007341006770730019,
-0.014340163208544254,
0.039671193808317184,
0.011480296030640602,
0.014723563566803932,
-0.025295376777648926,
-0.059826262295246124,
0.050696056336164474,
-0.004734877031296492,
0.011632256209850311,
-0.017561744898557663,
0.013785256072878838,
-0.03240819647908211,
0.008230151608586311,
-0.03416278958320618,
-0.050366975367069244,
-0.01255773939192295,
-0.02858353592455387,
0.05080211162567139,
0.023930788040161133,
-0.015626071020960808,
-0.051054973155260086,
0.06307611614465714,
-0.010211419314146042,
0.003704774659126997,
-0.01904064603149891,
0.02316521480679512,
-0.031821999698877335,
0.006700253114104271,
-0.014725987799465656,
0.01173392590135336,
-0.043621618300676346,
0.01326930895447731,
0.018696369603276253,
0.019337229430675507,
-0.019346602261066437,
0.03754201531410217,
-0.03164970502257347,
0.013069319538772106,
-0.01248969603329897,
0.004962627310305834,
-0.003254423150792718,
0.002839472144842148,
0.022135093808174133,
-0.04256189987063408,
-0.009958318434655666,
0.018478380516171455,
0.01577894575893879,
-0.005038782022893429,
0.016159923747181892,
-0.04944832995533943,
-0.013191872276365757,
0.034482941031455994,
-0.02803841605782509,
0.020585225895047188,
-0.0112724918872118,
0.02493583969771862,
0.014019559137523174,
0.053011324256658554,
0.006468649487942457,
-0.006806753575801849,
-0.03790871053934097,
-0.03269395977258682,
0.03671543300151825,
0.004125949461013079,
-0.011312511749565601,
-0.031647998839616776,
-0.011114988476037979,
-0.02369442768394947,
-0.022219613194465637,
0.014483409002423286,
0.012125885114073753,
-0.05161275714635849,
-0.028961319476366043,
0.040572114288806915,
0.04653056338429451,
0.03278900682926178,
-0.012981703504920006,
0.03859773650765419,
-0.02956414222717285,
-0.005336840637028217,
-0.017005078494548798,
-0.005019005388021469,
0.052522119134664536,
0.0491853766143322,
-0.06377821415662766,
-0.025257423520088196,
-0.00450755562633276,
-0.027758821845054626,
-0.021628879010677338,
-0.0022985797841101885,
-0.07033318281173706,
0.011320514604449272,
-0.03740452975034714,
0.005913012661039829,
0.0357830747961998,
-0.020349109545350075,
0.013613544404506683,
0.03711087256669998,
-0.025402212515473366,
0.030660480260849,
-0.0010674865916371346,
-0.00045608432264998555,
0.006292144302278757,
0.001298511982895434,
-0.03191583231091499,
0.013477986678481102,
0.0037070896942168474,
-0.02042469009757042,
0.06580887734889984,
0.0009942557662725449,
-0.03385782986879349,
0.07471665740013123,
0.0021314630284905434,
-0.006167449988424778,
-0.01327476929873228,
0.009056017734110355,
0.025821879506111145,
0.027678679674863815,
0.03161076456308365,
0.010591045953333378,
0.044973768293857574,
0.0010964503744617105,
-0.0063569024205207825,
0.049880772829055786,
-0.00752972811460495,
0.021637029945850372,
-0.013493213802576065,
0.0817379578948021,
0.01520733442157507,
0.013501632027328014,
0.001274608075618744,
-0.014330877922475338,
-0.029559532180428505,
-0.025693519040942192,
-0.02436921000480652,
-0.0068491604179143906,
0.042516257613897324,
0.01700681447982788,
0.016810055822134018,
0.015961425378918648,
-0.003988212905824184,
-0.01015512365847826,
0.029912017285823822,
0.005850538145750761,
0.0053987158462405205,
-0.025554416701197624,
-0.016946978867053986,
-0.008088908158242702,
-0.021124687045812607,
0.004622874315828085,
0.018807753920555115,
0.023660337552428246,
0.0028244012501090765,
-0.007064393721520901,
-0.014141806401312351,
0.009226762689650059,
0.04706987366080284,
0.005040156189352274,
-0.03439247980713844,
0.011443469673395157,
-0.015972567722201347,
0.03558560460805893,
0.017505068331956863,
0.0027786269783973694,
-0.021571002900600433,
-0.004673060495406389,
0.01943068578839302,
-0.012144376523792744,
-0.03424365818500519,
0.012510495260357857,
-0.04045049101114273,
0.030649758875370026,
0.027443967759609222,
0.06585925817489624,
-0.0008471417822875082,
-0.032844435423612595,
-0.022355321794748306,
0.012060936540365219,
-0.16246573626995087,
-0.024347292259335518,
0.006638163700699806,
0.03126681596040726,
0.008856086060404778,
-0.00351695716381073,
-0.020788375288248062,
0.005401930771768093,
-0.04500100016593933,
-0.015330560505390167,
0.027022473514080048,
-0.0535932295024395,
-0.018795480951666832,
-0.02038017101585865,
-0.005310553126037121,
-0.015933919697999954,
-0.0022118522319942713,
-0.017582301050424576,
0.0034631143789738417,
-0.04600825533270836,
0.02338191494345665,
0.01965521089732647,
0.038703128695487976,
-0.02290303446352482,
0.013871495611965656,
0.01424064114689827,
0.036069355905056,
0.004517545457929373,
-0.028004135936498642,
0.017381297424435616,
-0.011880283243954182,
-0.011815384961664677,
-0.010858241468667984,
0.030654797330498695,
0.0004614866047631949,
0.026809165254235268,
0.0322745218873024,
-0.09577295184135437,
-0.056518252938985825,
-0.0031562529038637877,
0.010091900825500488,
0.09015972167253494,
-0.010260063223540783,
0.041563887149095535,
0.016899412497878075,
-0.04876501485705376,
-0.008454793132841587,
-0.004034867975860834,
-0.06310727447271347,
-0.024878788739442825,
-0.00037981438799761236,
-0.0172217208892107,
-0.019496824592351913,
-0.0004332826065365225,
-0.007928851060569286,
-0.016809673979878426,
0.025335747748613358,
0.047560226172208786,
-0.01978422701358795,
-0.0014772432623431087,
-0.0046105463989079,
-0.06747198104858398,
0.04830532893538475,
0.03329361602663994,
-0.03391548991203308,
-0.029894253239035606,
0.003039895324036479,
-0.009488125331699848,
-0.0005026177386753261,
0.0005098716355860233,
0.012189776636660099,
-0.03893975540995598,
-0.002980270888656378,
0.021915443241596222,
0.0413876511156559,
0.0278914887458086,
-0.03571990132331848,
-0.004181009251624346,
-0.013087889179587364,
-0.10739947110414505,
0.015438882634043694,
0.03403318300843239,
0.005427517928183079,
0.01955464668571949,
0.013436373323202133,
-0.03885304182767868,
-0.010711191222071648,
0.009002546779811382,
0.014377008192241192,
0.23373554646968842,
0.01481300126761198,
-0.03224566951394081,
-0.03239796683192253,
0.020819202065467834,
-0.0001346760691376403,
0.01431588176637888,
0.04003911092877388,
0.00045967550249770284,
-0.04838572070002556,
-0.009327464736998081,
-0.010035576298832893,
-0.018423503264784813,
-0.026294901967048645,
-0.05678272992372513,
0.009183169342577457,
-0.020746491849422455,
-0.046842508018016815,
0.07625554502010345,
-0.006023409776389599,
0.0239226296544075,
-0.028927385807037354,
0.03817925974726677,
0.02610926143825054,
-0.044807981699705124,
-0.01682303473353386,
0.011253495700657368,
0.051073454320430756,
-0.029575590044260025,
0.021219169721007347,
-0.058507464826107025,
0.008862371556460857,
0.02309289015829563,
0.012265539728105068,
0.0314386785030365,
0.008018556982278824,
0.006574219558387995,
0.0053498949855566025,
-0.05673788860440254,
0.0456891693174839,
0.008194394409656525,
-0.013574710115790367,
-0.020026516169309616,
-0.06747142225503922,
0.011046811006963253,
-0.003076238092035055,
-0.0019000438041985035,
0.023222994059324265,
-0.04785546287894249,
0.02405695617198944,
0.010392534546554089,
0.039518553763628006,
0.01932014897465706,
0.028559595346450806,
-0.005070861894637346,
-0.01841859519481659,
-0.006724479142576456,
0.013652859255671501,
-0.04099870100617409,
0.06172466650605202,
-0.013744409196078777,
0.0378369577229023,
-0.030855579301714897,
0.09035706520080566,
-0.012927576899528503,
0.005153600126504898,
-0.03966861590743065,
-0.003078985493630171,
0.043568722903728485,
-0.014957301318645477,
0.05764766409993172,
0.032960984855890274,
0.03952567279338837,
-0.0032217565458267927,
0.06110140308737755,
-0.03431864455342293,
-0.024298997595906258,
0.01288170088082552,
0.025925295427441597,
0.04378393664956093,
-0.01207965798676014,
-0.02526988834142685,
0.0018375368090346456,
0.02341797761619091,
0.01392842922359705,
-0.012324064038693905,
-0.030141474679112434,
0.058986153453588486,
0.013229521922767162,
0.012540748342871666,
-0.0013901782222092152,
-0.021932030096650124,
-0.051955025643110275,
-0.01704876869916916,
0.010614348575472832,
-0.018006468191742897,
-0.02372455783188343,
0.0034206360578536987,
-0.01725860685110092,
-0.06117209047079086,
-0.018610484898090363,
-0.00417165644466877,
0.007145305629819632,
-0.014751057140529156,
0.07180517911911011,
0.0005401602247729897,
0.0074639213271439075,
-0.0019196238135918975,
-0.022693684324622154,
0.008411657065153122,
-0.0015659251948818564,
0.023659270256757736,
-0.016491705551743507,
0.007065202109515667,
-0.014344911091029644,
0.03448557108640671,
-0.020918037742376328,
0.019227927550673485,
0.02715553157031536,
0.056454598903656006,
-0.02800086699426174,
-0.0019674289505928755,
-0.035508763045072556,
-0.0022711502388119698,
-0.01948397047817707,
0.010517106391489506,
-0.026346534490585327,
-0.02601020224392414,
-0.04806840047240257,
0.03625927120447159,
-0.019426802173256874,
-0.024105051532387733,
-0.06989309191703796,
-0.02773275226354599,
0.03794873505830765,
0.0023570340126752853,
0.029983840882778168,
0.02264503389596939,
-0.025523396208882332,
0.045237381011247635,
0.013071112334728241,
0.012514669448137283,
-0.019690075889229774,
-0.00035967296571470797,
0.022399138659238815,
-0.0002773196902126074,
-0.0939359962940216,
-0.005544705782085657,
-0.028388304635882378,
-0.014261586591601372,
0.03460807353258133,
0.008854953572154045,
-0.053506769239902496,
-0.04847841337323189,
0.027034278959035873,
-0.012529010884463787,
-0.015467287041246891,
0.015368195250630379,
-0.0058676376938819885,
-0.026848532259464264,
-0.0005580945871770382,
0.04599115625023842,
0.02143898606300354,
0.04836605116724968,
0.027619943022727966,
0.0388631597161293,
0.006051107309758663,
0.02708834782242775,
0.020590825006365776,
0.0417899526655674,
0.01189766637980938,
0.030766630545258522,
-0.025563742965459824,
0.036351222544908524,
0.038366325199604034,
0.010929959826171398,
-0.0426861047744751,
-0.004190528765320778,
0.004282053560018539,
0.008137909695506096,
-0.037455376237630844,
0.02759667858481407,
0.007556343451142311,
0.057569533586502075,
-0.0217753779143095,
0.03552381321787834,
0.03264140710234642,
-0.012090631760656834,
0.01128846313804388,
-0.02853054739534855,
-0.012161650694906712,
0.11427010595798492,
-0.02014969289302826,
-0.012252841144800186,
0.014966288581490517,
0.00868435949087143,
0.02256075292825699,
0.0510411374270916,
-0.00006191627471707761,
-0.013728884048759937,
0.011261265724897385,
0.036889832466840744,
-0.01867707446217537,
0.033511124551296234,
0.005004758946597576,
-0.0018942005699500442,
0.019033612683415413,
0.03653786703944206,
-0.03482520580291748,
-0.037596870213747025,
0.018815768882632256,
0.022076871246099472,
-0.05057072639465332,
-0.03259309381246567,
-0.023346086964011192,
-0.021855555474758148,
0.034358907490968704,
0.015611805953085423,
-0.000922334031201899,
-0.0657930076122284,
-0.030658742412924767,
-0.028949862346053123,
0.04741094261407852,
-0.0844883918762207,
-0.012744092382490635,
0.0009769981261342764,
-0.0267333984375,
-0.025785084813833237,
-0.015364262275397778,
-0.023136261850595474,
-0.001478496240451932,
-0.030410779640078545,
0.006627638358622789,
0.009022164158523083,
-0.0006528652738779783,
0.013394417241215706,
-0.0030085809994488955,
0.008811457082629204,
0.007961281575262547,
-0.00754444720223546,
0.005279977805912495,
-0.016212020069360733,
0.029065866023302078,
0.029004249721765518,
-0.008488655090332031,
0.012254653498530388,
0.015091153793036938,
-0.007471428718417883,
0.013392948545515537,
0.04488671198487282,
0.024325676262378693,
0.030665956437587738,
-0.015245107002556324,
-0.0245197843760252,
0.04367790371179581,
0.06606483459472656,
0.030488325282931328,
0.01097939908504486,
-0.041984349489212036,
-0.009712932631373405,
0.025293314829468727,
0.018743524327874184,
-0.010732538998126984,
-0.017683912068605423,
-0.04569792374968529,
-0.04759376868605614,
0.02785491570830345,
-0.025324387475848198,
-0.027557380497455597,
-0.052959881722927094,
-0.01194646954536438,
0.029804004356265068,
-0.05634516105055809,
-0.013988817110657692,
-0.013613958843052387,
0.0007142146350815892,
-0.038090091198682785,
0.03463525325059891,
0.022338991984725,
0.03420116379857063,
0.014453601092100143,
0.060016438364982605,
0.03582338988780975,
0.014328747056424618,
-0.008915035985410213,
0.023193299770355225,
0.01069942582398653,
-0.0036536825355142355,
0.015669582411646843,
-0.02732420712709427,
0.04505632072687149,
-0.0019031426636502147,
-0.029788244515657425,
0.05747747793793678,
-0.008064965717494488,
0.002545533236116171,
0.0012870818609371781,
0.05428195372223854,
-0.022543659433722496,
0.05215677618980408,
-0.010837450623512268,
0.03657442703843117,
-0.03656170144677162,
-0.003653852501884103,
-0.008885068818926811,
0.022103436291217804,
-0.0005417151842266321,
-0.03929390385746956,
0.05799287185072899,
-0.0009691959712654352,
0.014371918514370918,
-0.09852296113967896,
-0.02537735551595688,
-0.011968692764639854,
0.003616665955632925,
0.01668950915336609,
0.008355563506484032,
-0.0037839950527995825,
0.005124648101627827,
-0.007242443505674601,
-0.015833161771297455,
0.024567650631070137,
-0.05916028097271919,
0.01857767254114151,
-0.07287859916687012,
0.047847263514995575,
-0.0014429714065045118,
-0.01790120266377926,
-0.013423540629446507,
-0.0005508793983608484,
-0.04822592809796333,
-0.04701464995741844,
-0.010367395356297493,
-0.02662784792482853,
0.06419740617275238,
0.0009137431625276804,
0.00427641998976469,
-0.02178865484893322,
0.02788044698536396,
-0.018567455932497978,
-0.009163344278931618,
-0.03042757511138916,
0.07134303450584412,
0.016053203493356705,
-0.008536610752344131,
-0.009969759732484818,
-0.005459071137011051,
-0.023887131363153458,
0.016233546659350395,
0.02164200320839882,
-0.038063034415245056,
0.01711777225136757,
-0.005954450462013483,
-0.03119049035012722,
0.05962982028722763,
0.0337647870182991,
-0.006759241688996553,
0.028017394244670868,
0.046618763357400894,
0.04853583872318268,
-0.014809171669185162,
0.01975574903190136,
-0.018397945910692215,
0.00007717945845797658,
-0.013686277903616428,
0.0006961792823858559,
-0.008424093015491962,
0.03206571936607361,
-0.005230381619185209,
0.01320988591760397,
0.011780750937759876,
0.03131566941738129,
0.024437230080366135,
0.0033717756159603596,
-0.033324234187603,
0.05089462548494339,
0.01449507288634777,
0.017026450484991074,
-0.015279289335012436,
-0.038274217396974564,
-0.014837837778031826,
-0.039803534746170044,
-0.00718203280121088,
0.006190802436321974,
-0.02012713998556137,
-0.01462471205741167,
-0.004408585373312235,
0.06500427424907684,
-0.02979574352502823,
0.03639576584100723,
-0.005593707785010338,
0.010160185396671295,
-0.041112545877695084,
0.041049521416425705,
-0.1557556837797165,
0.04538402333855629,
0.04630734771490097,
-0.040903400629758835,
-0.0762585699558258,
-0.01776234433054924,
-0.05042772740125656,
-0.011699260212481022,
-0.007327628321945667,
-0.02643771469593048,
0.02774270437657833,
-0.028653763234615326,
-0.007012913003563881,
-0.018261848017573357,
-0.07029146701097488,
0.05093981325626373,
-0.011477957479655743,
-0.05798887461423874,
-0.020459124818444252,
0.009997534565627575,
0.020714089274406433,
0.018081991001963615,
0.017111647874116898,
-0.010344410315155983,
-0.027111085131764412,
-0.01097017526626587,
-0.04031439498066902,
-0.010885925032198429,
-0.031189706176519394,
0.007840888574719429,
0.02645263448357582,
-0.03925405070185661,
-0.019356463104486465,
0.00014867045683786273,
0.022493485361337662,
0.001984749222174287,
0.019247476011514664,
-0.0006456676637753844,
-0.027582040056586266,
-0.027674145996570587,
-0.013028803281486034,
-0.0055539836175739765,
-0.013765844516456127,
-0.00547186192125082,
0.019453978165984154,
-0.0016036138404160738,
-0.03350547328591347,
0.03459782898426056,
-0.06354024261236191,
-0.018634120002388954,
-0.022242585197091103,
0.03999445214867592,
-0.0394805483520031,
0.022478599101305008,
0.004258418921381235,
-0.011933750472962856,
-0.04183237999677658,
-0.009429353289306164,
-0.04342447221279144,
0.0293886736035347,
0.000018136342987418175,
-0.011198312975466251,
-0.022678382694721222,
-0.0037272130139172077,
-0.008386884815990925,
0.0009189518168568611,
-0.011445767246186733,
-0.017520882189273834,
-0.006786783691495657,
-0.028126860037446022,
-0.02263866364955902,
-0.0584874264895916,
0.021895965561270714,
-0.012649034149944782,
-0.039562374353408813,
-0.020465349778532982,
0.00843382440507412,
-0.023926088586449623,
0.0030715034808963537,
-0.017766909673810005,
-0.044919248670339584,
0.020311938598752022,
-0.014642130583524704,
0.016872940585017204,
0.03731326758861542,
0.027856403961777687,
0.00984985288232565,
-0.010304327122867107,
0.025051316246390343,
-0.02438872680068016,
-0.04383695498108864,
0.008875700645148754,
-0.03396229445934296,
0.032756257802248,
0.00934233795851469,
0.011234958656132221,
-0.010314486920833588,
-0.022053582593798637,
-0.02276506833732128,
-0.0031463929917663336,
0.010434769093990326,
-0.019999371841549873,
0.01432529091835022,
0.03298486769199371,
-0.0200344305485487,
0.014549183659255505,
0.022152557969093323,
-0.03252921998500824,
-0.031986434012651443,
0.016193076968193054,
0.01480245590209961,
-0.02276531048119068,
-0.07023504376411438,
-0.012232307344675064,
-0.04377369582653046,
0.020205363631248474,
-0.00725962920114398,
0.015227802097797394,
-0.003993504215031862,
0.027337659150362015,
0.039003342390060425,
0.012410042807459831,
0.009610657580196857,
-0.037269238382577896,
-0.006516610272228718,
0.04401824623346329,
0.05516493692994118,
-0.013943564146757126,
-0.009026373736560345,
-0.009166032075881958,
0.017158005386590958,
0.010007708333432674,
-0.004130245186388493,
0.015295383520424366,
0.011168140918016434,
0.04178370535373688,
0.03443818539381027,
0.012424377724528313,
-0.026086386293172836,
-0.013475057668983936,
-0.010703233070671558,
0.00900627113878727,
-0.025111030787229538,
-0.010479670017957687,
-0.01674324832856655,
0.0014423433458432555,
0.03032764419913292,
0.000487790210172534,
-0.039547696709632874,
-0.011028960347175598,
0.0136873172596097,
-0.0037729914765805006,
-0.0036189653910696507,
0.05034935846924782,
-0.0033266101963818073,
-0.018911894410848618,
0.04593542218208313,
-0.0012745388085022569,
0.01963341049849987,
0.03558818995952606,
0.0022540926001966,
-0.025908753275871277,
-0.01969299092888832,
-0.03822265565395355,
-0.050948794931173325,
0.013289744034409523,
-0.011103435419499874,
-0.014342579990625381,
0.0009976059664040804,
-0.005873252172023058,
-0.015413036569952965,
-0.012188615277409554,
0.009932189248502254,
0.031573694199323654,
0.007214330602437258,
0.014286679215729237,
-0.0022566732950508595,
-0.030285926535725594,
0.04864807054400444,
-0.03970031812787056,
0.04013794660568237,
0.011934640817344189,
-0.0024468442425131798,
0.010542758740484715,
0.0014860015362501144,
0.024278607219457626,
-0.030346890911459923,
-0.017928842455148697,
0.004065839108079672,
0.011078925803303719,
-0.010199777781963348,
-0.0067896414548158646,
-0.0014379548374563456,
0.0015529001830145717,
0.031309377402067184,
-0.03196980431675911,
-0.042702917009592056,
0.05803738534450531,
0.007235289551317692,
0.008443258702754974,
0.06055624783039093,
-0.030636830255389214,
-0.049520641565322876,
-0.023267535492777824,
-0.016168400645256042,
-0.008993315510451794,
0.003333457512781024,
-0.06803613901138306,
-0.025526659563183784,
0.042786478996276855,
-0.027562124654650688,
-0.0459759421646595,
0.009337385185062885,
0.03941061347723007,
0.016291337087750435,
-0.005764748435467482,
-0.03404497727751732,
-0.009885508567094803,
0.010877087712287903,
0.017679620534181595,
0.03682680055499077,
0.029405703768134117,
-0.06972678005695343,
-0.029943348839879036,
0.031786516308784485,
0.01094132475554943,
-0.04479021579027176,
-0.0038805778604000807,
-0.009089615195989609,
-0.07220472395420074,
-0.01799536868929863,
-0.007896141149103642,
0.004455619025975466,
0.046099644154310226,
-0.013953957706689835,
-0.03519853577017784,
0.010734348557889462,
-0.01465772744268179,
-0.03558078408241272,
0.015371197834610939,
-0.0018079332076013088,
-0.01654043234884739,
0.02909460850059986,
0.02875208668410778
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:50
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
7.7.4 The fact that she went shooting with the Plaintiff with a spotlight; T341.19
7.7.5 The dealings with Gaythorne and the purchase by the MFT of the Mitchelton property to assist David's wife buy a different house;
7.7.6 The pay out of the River Road loan after the Plaintiff had expressly declined to sign the documents required to be signed in this regard (see par 50.9 of the earlier submissions, par 502 of the Defendant's Affidavit of 29 June 2011 and T183.4);
7.7.7 The secret rental receipts from River Road and related CBA accounts;
7.7.8 The trip to Vanuatu in late 2007 post the date the Defendant alleges was separation;
7.7.9. The trip to Bribie Island;
7.7.10. Her control of the $55,000 loan to Wade (David Mulcahy's evidence was that he was not involved with this loan (T437.17 to 21) nor knew the details of the rent receipts of River Road (T417.47 to 418.09 and 427.
18 to 36) and Wade Mulcahy's evidence was also that he did not know the details of the rent receipts of River Road (T113.22 to 31), which evidences the degree of involvement in these matters of the Defendant;
7.7.11 Her control and separateness in keeping the inheritance account. It should be noted that the inheritance was a modest amount of some $16,000, so that there is no credence in the suggestion by the Defendant that there is a basis for the separateness of these monies."
265Interestingly on the long time between the assaults Dr Fischer said:
"Q. And in terms of the third category, those incidents would need to be constant, I think, is the word you used in the report. That is, there's this constant apprehension of being killed, maimed, or persons close to them being killed or maimed. Is that so?
A. Yes, it is.
Q. And if there were periods of many years without these incidents, that would be relevant to your assessment of the illness if there were periods of time where there were normal behaviour?
A. Well, interestingly, it actually generally works in the obverse way to that because what we know is that intermittent reinforcement in behaviour therapy is the most powerful way of reinforcing an idea or a feeling. So if indeed the acts - the actual acts of violence are unpredictable but do occur intermittently,
then that is more likely to engender fear and a sense of impotence in the face of the ongoing situation than where there are mild degrees of assault happening very regularly and predictably."
266So far as the defendant's high functionality is concerned, he said:
"Q. Sorry, doctor, there is a matter Mr Priestley has reminded me. In respect of managing her affairs, that is Mrs Mulcahy's affairs, in terms of the history where she was involved with real estate and with various businesses of the parties during the relationship, and continued to do so up until separation; that is able to deal with banks on her own behalf or whatever.
She, in those circumstances, can I suggest to you, appear to have any disability in reporting matters or making complaint in respect of what she now complains of in affidavits as to how she was abused. What I am suggesting to you is, she, throughout the time of the relationship, was able to hold her own and appear to operate as a normal person would in a relationship with its normal ups and
downs. That's not your understanding?
A. Well, I think clearly to make it simplistic or we can try and tease out the various factors that have contributed to this complex situation. I guess the most important thing in my mind is, where it came to doing things that involved strongly asserting herself against a man who she felt ambivalent about did she make a sensible decision, such as taking out an AVO; no, she didn't as far as I know.
Did not make that sensible decision, despite being advised to do so. So, the concept of being in thrall to someone implies that when it comes to matters that have to do with either saying things or doing things that could harm the other, which logically she should have done on the basis of what she is telling us she didn't do it.
|
[
-0.01842944137752056,
0.044770993292331696,
-0.0305503997951746,
-0.025393016636371613,
-0.006462746299803257,
-0.03146928548812866,
0.052825361490249634,
0.013174534775316715,
0.010834726504981518,
0.016919685527682304,
0.0036771923769265413,
0.0282337237149477,
-0.039211999624967575,
0.009022636339068413,
0.02460000477731228,
-0.008395547978579998,
0.018324878066778183,
-0.019466033205389977,
-0.004176268354058266,
-0.05020929127931595,
-0.015286574140191078,
0.0171003770083189,
0.012545542791485786,
0.018574746325612068,
-0.016789056360721588,
0.0477815605700016,
-0.02294214628636837,
-0.019259031862020493,
-0.004446472506970167,
0.057239826768636703,
0.006193500943481922,
0.002580090891569853,
0.02062416635453701,
-0.011099476367235184,
0.01279060821980238,
-0.00009787877934286371,
-0.028087874874472618,
0.025339275598526,
-0.03429520130157471,
0.024245735257864,
0.008658047765493393,
-0.0001711664372123778,
0.008246749639511108,
0.00812178011983633,
0.04950346797704697,
-0.06359688937664032,
0.0012797225499525666,
-0.022412165999412537,
-0.007508185226470232,
-0.010499449446797371,
-0.051878515630960464,
-0.013658612035214901,
0.037804000079631805,
-0.0008509843610227108,
-0.01313474029302597,
0.0021112298127263784,
0.004412251990288496,
-0.019339555874466896,
-0.01769474893808365,
-0.0021161509212106466,
0.009909529238939285,
-0.013176490552723408,
-0.004272147547453642,
-0.025587929412722588,
0.006882113870233297,
0.08913673460483551,
-0.029275933280587196,
-0.03735028952360153,
0.009410182945430279,
-0.012798505835235119,
0.0013451448176056147,
-0.01361126359552145,
0.032126545906066895,
-0.026820754632353783,
-0.07533986121416092,
0.026436230167746544,
-0.01658838614821434,
0.02503153309226036,
-0.008196123875677586,
0.02987714111804962,
0.028959015384316444,
0.03688845410943031,
-0.016410334035754204,
0.04290669038891792,
-0.041739266365766525,
0.026680216193199158,
-0.023773686960339546,
0.03393646702170372,
0.0271000973880291,
-0.03150301054120064,
-0.01892850361764431,
-0.0073438300751149654,
0.016155218705534935,
-0.03713029995560646,
0.009173464961349964,
-0.028679687529802322,
-0.03017943724989891,
0.06273791939020157,
-0.026013890281319618,
0.022259937599301338,
0.03151314705610275,
-0.006277646403759718,
-0.007358428090810776,
-0.02032778412103653,
0.007964888587594032,
0.0038612280040979385,
0.034912046045064926,
0.05713904649019241,
0.018952688202261925,
0.012520960532128811,
0.010495529510080814,
-0.058476705104112625,
-0.00282434094697237,
0.023385053500533104,
-0.007727029267698526,
-0.006930128671228886,
0.019866131246089935,
-0.013658108189702034,
0.0018769681919366121,
-0.011816468089818954,
0.0482349619269371,
0.03559216484427452,
0.010384684428572655,
-0.021184567362070084,
-0.027364065870642662,
0.024404020980000496,
0.0066853296011686325,
0.022174237295985222,
-0.0254630446434021,
0.025483954697847366,
-0.012582443654537201,
-0.04595225676894188,
-0.009982802905142307,
-0.04657065495848656,
-0.02979360893368721,
-0.0022384810727089643,
0.050021570175886154,
0.004209624137729406,
-0.01470839325338602,
-0.027436278760433197,
0.0663473978638649,
0.055279046297073364,
0.0030285953544080257,
-0.025088051334023476,
0.019389817491173744,
-0.02217334322631359,
-0.005982305388897657,
-0.027157876640558243,
-0.005754845682531595,
0.016397111117839813,
-0.015703771263360977,
-0.012402821332216263,
0.02754266746342182,
-0.008806337602436543,
0.010498656891286373,
-0.046435847878456116,
0.019751928746700287,
-0.018010176718235016,
0.012650778517127037,
0.007899794727563858,
0.03804429993033409,
0.016342611983418465,
-0.04542751982808113,
-0.04394502937793732,
0.019986677914857864,
0.012739394791424274,
-0.003766070120036602,
0.018960556015372276,
0.009294475428760052,
0.000029837598049198277,
0.016005540266633034,
-0.053418759256601334,
0.06252729147672653,
-0.013835795223712921,
0.04128604382276535,
0.01605387032032013,
0.0687219426035881,
0.004425589460879564,
-0.0008302563219331205,
-0.03776584938168526,
-0.03962023928761482,
0.008949477225542068,
-0.0032221474684774876,
-0.019408095628023148,
0.016954153776168823,
0.0023600950371474028,
0.016321934759616852,
-0.02857942134141922,
0.029866540804505348,
0.017119020223617554,
-0.030163969844579697,
-0.013113739900290966,
0.04671374708414078,
0.046785756945610046,
0.07344190031290054,
-0.029463382437825203,
0.019359031692147255,
0.010949618183076382,
0.025671368464827538,
-0.010274911299347878,
0.004948756657540798,
0.040268536657094955,
0.035680439323186874,
-0.007943443022668362,
-0.03626019135117531,
0.011980109848082066,
-0.06875159591436386,
0.008031714707612991,
0.03243443742394447,
-0.04372389242053032,
-0.004304899368435144,
0.014697804115712643,
0.007040590047836304,
-0.03242779150605202,
-0.00009329848398920149,
0.016473770141601562,
0.019080903381109238,
-0.008732522837817669,
0.008413705043494701,
0.014781109057366848,
-0.014427362009882927,
0.021472366526722908,
-0.005930035840719938,
-0.012064972892403603,
0.0030578887090086937,
0.03783772513270378,
-0.036140598356723785,
0.04728689417243004,
-0.0011718395398929715,
-0.041066382080316544,
0.06346950680017471,
0.036315616220235825,
0.005526416935026646,
-0.012288099154829979,
0.016094941645860672,
0.00693502277135849,
0.031828753650188446,
0.017571406438946724,
0.0174468532204628,
-0.005481566768139601,
-0.013154500164091587,
0.010305440984666348,
0.009177177213132381,
-0.011943546123802662,
0.018057461827993393,
0.004679146688431501,
-0.016676606610417366,
0.017992449924349785,
0.004261399619281292,
-0.03831508010625839,
0.016659840941429138,
-0.0015662297373637557,
-0.004534546751528978,
-0.013431180268526077,
-0.0264362171292305,
0.027609089389443398,
0.024722952395677567,
-0.01052139699459076,
0.004221194889396429,
-0.011430074460804462,
0.015114651061594486,
0.04366208240389824,
0.04017528146505356,
0.010805840604007244,
-0.03886343538761139,
-0.030333325266838074,
-0.02447608672082424,
-0.029894519597291946,
0.0005671075778082013,
0.0050598932430148125,
0.022494344040751457,
0.0001692625810392201,
-0.009640134871006012,
-0.010792150162160397,
0.010303479619324207,
0.009934036061167717,
0.018695304170250893,
-0.038658272475004196,
0.020774830132722855,
0.0026463305111974478,
0.006570644676685333,
0.0001361692848149687,
-0.017126958817243576,
0.007302450947463512,
-0.015474104322493076,
0.019787926226854324,
-0.019210334867239,
-0.03921634331345558,
0.016121402382850647,
-0.033482637256383896,
0.029949963092803955,
0.00922256987541914,
0.07420314848423004,
0.0020456782076507807,
-0.040963064879179,
-0.019162068143486977,
-0.008216364309191704,
-0.1592378467321396,
-0.01072009839117527,
0.025135250762104988,
0.038870178163051605,
0.010003218427300453,
0.008250387385487556,
-0.01447934377938509,
0.003992128651589155,
-0.009306732565164566,
0.02729114145040512,
0.0372794084250927,
-0.05587385222315788,
-0.014565234072506428,
0.03592631220817566,
0.010448353365063667,
-0.040259525179862976,
0.016426775604486465,
0.01947380229830742,
0.010273579508066177,
-0.03760610148310661,
0.006881257053464651,
-0.0036398028023540974,
0.03043367899954319,
0.003255703952163458,
0.003673994680866599,
0.019478753209114075,
0.036127958446741104,
0.015549218282103539,
-0.027974039316177368,
-0.04039397090673447,
-0.03266994282603264,
0.008760392665863037,
-0.019216263666749,
0.048387426882982254,
-0.01022767648100853,
0.023726893588900566,
0.03937602415680885,
-0.058728400617837906,
-0.028996093198657036,
-0.05334979295730591,
-0.0009322960395365953,
0.024083087220788002,
-0.02927546203136444,
0.022856755182147026,
-0.023150792345404625,
-0.044357556849718094,
-0.0010850646067410707,
-0.03745617717504501,
-0.03009323589503765,
0.005227506626397371,
-0.006485543679445982,
0.002242044545710087,
-0.04857267811894417,
-0.02502863109111786,
-0.037201642990112305,
-0.03564184531569481,
0.048588816076517105,
0.057179760187864304,
-0.012977074831724167,
0.009050178341567516,
0.006384050473570824,
-0.07122864574193954,
0.0464145764708519,
-0.012893172912299633,
-0.01914398930966854,
-0.03635963425040245,
0.03651309013366699,
-0.01210879534482956,
-0.0009002569131553173,
0.002498370362445712,
-0.011427361518144608,
-0.055384375154972076,
-0.020753731951117516,
-0.007363575976341963,
-0.00406021811068058,
0.031117038801312447,
-0.00504304701462388,
0.01586548052728176,
0.006230647210031748,
-0.09498073160648346,
0.002120974939316511,
0.02457244135439396,
-0.010848013684153557,
0.03684837371110916,
0.006851546466350555,
-0.01041217241436243,
0.026400059461593628,
-0.013277239166200161,
0.022279512137174606,
0.2452211230993271,
0.005818617530167103,
-0.00483626127243042,
0.04070354998111725,
0.0016134321922436357,
0.007625785656273365,
0.04020081087946892,
0.07798246294260025,
-0.003085133619606495,
-0.03690734878182411,
-0.006006140261888504,
0.023792648687958717,
0.004789723549038172,
-0.008361037820577621,
-0.04591666907072067,
0.07861857116222382,
-0.025241883471608162,
-0.033535659313201904,
0.06526032090187073,
0.01022251881659031,
0.02226138859987259,
-0.031014373525977135,
0.01499999687075615,
0.07065854221582413,
-0.0631246417760849,
-0.013100781477987766,
-0.015117491595447063,
0.023986633867025375,
0.019682973623275757,
-0.010101846419274807,
-0.03253266587853432,
-0.003197788493707776,
0.040182627737522125,
-0.005420193076133728,
0.009355094283819199,
0.020643437281250954,
-0.00660385936498642,
-0.002882210072129965,
-0.05682920292019844,
0.07570584863424301,
-0.005833417177200317,
-0.028658458963036537,
-0.018157673999667168,
-0.05221526324748993,
0.01411348581314087,
0.011333076283335686,
0.008424513041973114,
0.01089154276996851,
-0.027085326611995697,
0.02406689152121544,
-0.01018490269780159,
0.00902005098760128,
-0.0053244419395923615,
0.02884928695857525,
-0.010566369630396366,
-0.001587658072821796,
-0.013431555591523647,
0.05277596041560173,
-0.0427229180932045,
0.054593946784734726,
-0.009071649052202702,
0.012670719996094704,
-0.08613239228725433,
-0.0036427879240363836,
0.0026869026478379965,
0.001865982892923057,
-0.07744041830301285,
-0.028623631224036217,
0.08629210293292999,
0.012636917643249035,
0.024132736027240753,
0.020184751600027084,
0.022984661161899567,
0.003976631443947554,
0.030698200687766075,
0.02573978714644909,
-0.021388592198491096,
0.013719674199819565,
0.02822999842464924,
-0.03703195974230766,
-0.01053605880588293,
-0.03773830458521843,
-0.0025749425403773785,
0.01787751168012619,
0.04986298084259033,
-0.010693925432860851,
-0.05159663036465645,
0.06508583575487137,
0.01763063110411167,
0.013820544816553593,
0.000750175619032234,
0.004884782247245312,
-0.04962360858917236,
-0.021586138755083084,
-0.0019351867958903313,
-0.0028588655404746532,
-0.015518886037170887,
-0.03449656069278717,
-0.03755195811390877,
-0.07249864935874939,
-0.005303649231791496,
-0.016642073169350624,
0.03673300892114639,
-0.03963491693139076,
-0.012987480498850346,
-0.0458868145942688,
0.017810577526688576,
0.0033722412772476673,
-0.052735645323991776,
0.0009888455970212817,
-0.02086716704070568,
-0.015862885862588882,
0.009223651140928268,
0.011517122387886047,
0.03268074616789818,
0.039411760866642,
-0.02566704712808132,
0.031524479389190674,
0.035026248544454575,
0.019825952127575874,
0.03619834780693054,
-0.03689756244421005,
-0.008963554166257381,
0.023592740297317505,
-0.030146939679980278,
0.022193772718310356,
-0.04109008610248566,
-0.00039729333366267383,
-0.003434565383940935,
0.012548916041851044,
0.004692181013524532,
-0.03719022125005722,
-0.04226848855614662,
-0.03073164075613022,
0.06700486689805984,
0.017687924206256866,
0.0102324727922678,
-0.04426528140902519,
-0.0075795529410243034,
0.005196202080696821,
-0.0338406004011631,
0.014786259271204472,
-0.0383102186024189,
0.0002605994523037225,
0.024446988478302956,
0.02882433496415615,
-0.07048220187425613,
0.030131231993436813,
-0.01612401381134987,
-0.017381014302372932,
0.017375890165567398,
0.0214491318911314,
-0.020955516025424004,
-0.021667638793587685,
0.044522520154714584,
-0.005826146341860294,
-0.011667865328490734,
-0.019146861508488655,
-0.0002421562239760533,
-0.021368203684687614,
0.0022630204912275076,
0.0021321226377040148,
-0.06117967888712883,
0.05301172658801079,
0.012356634251773357,
0.0671912431716919,
0.005504723638296127,
0.0021677552722394466,
0.015738843008875847,
0.014140277169644833,
-0.012974077835679054,
-0.015945103019475937,
-0.03894594684243202,
0.005900474730879068,
0.060090940445661545,
0.009183877147734165,
-0.013502540066838264,
0.001033635577186942,
-0.02644992433488369,
-0.04891904070973396,
0.008084062486886978,
0.019660064950585365,
-0.023265954107046127,
0.028040409088134766,
0.0039119175635278225,
-0.02108689397573471,
0.040604136884212494,
-0.018207667395472527,
-0.00768281752243638,
-0.055415112525224686,
-0.0036184482742100954,
0.10751311480998993,
-0.003466663183644414,
-0.021450374275445938,
0.003199217841029167,
0.020566942170262337,
0.0013317023403942585,
0.052597254514694214,
-0.013242088258266449,
-0.031521741300821304,
-0.002140015596523881,
0.033403001725673676,
0.0035072846803814173,
0.054462119936943054,
0.06943987309932709,
0.020088374614715576,
0.01853548362851143,
0.024457162246108055,
-0.0076035019010305405,
-0.05599553883075714,
0.05061468482017517,
0.03307642415165901,
-0.031169340014457703,
-0.010126582346856594,
-0.029184777289628983,
-0.04276132211089134,
0.009403036907315254,
0.0401262603700161,
0.024972517043352127,
-0.0871175229549408,
0.0011636094423010945,
-0.010110567323863506,
-0.00010067663242807612,
-0.10151985287666321,
-0.01683831959962845,
-0.010813442058861256,
-0.00683517986908555,
-0.01918724924325943,
-0.012310937978327274,
-0.011615986004471779,
0.001013874658383429,
-0.0402655303478241,
0.047760993242263794,
0.0236954428255558,
-0.0014608226483687758,
-0.04391615092754364,
0.03930029273033142,
0.01936739683151245,
0.009807111695408821,
-0.006417811382561922,
0.03207072243094444,
-0.03589573875069618,
0.012264005839824677,
0.012647215276956558,
-0.019000988453626633,
-0.01379218976944685,
0.0030726264230906963,
-0.0231009591370821,
0.01814541220664978,
0.058419182896614075,
0.039982572197914124,
-0.016030676662921906,
0.005723355803638697,
-0.015891671180725098,
0.0031566175166517496,
0.018642520532011986,
-0.0020079677924513817,
-0.01825229451060295,
-0.036644142121076584,
-0.05466156825423241,
-0.007927456870675087,
0.040704116225242615,
-0.005501981824636459,
-0.019590701907873154,
-0.06053168326616287,
-0.03821868449449539,
0.024677062407135963,
0.013632865622639656,
-0.013147725723683834,
-0.10156761109828949,
0.00981335248798132,
0.010474867187440395,
-0.023834779858589172,
0.010850219987332821,
-0.00621727854013443,
-0.0056863706558942795,
-0.02665749005973339,
0.058903858065605164,
0.020004967227578163,
-0.009325983002781868,
0.0224108025431633,
0.03127221018075943,
0.04617096111178398,
0.02888144738972187,
-0.04155746102333069,
0.011945278383791447,
0.037514153867959976,
0.014636605978012085,
0.020935481414198875,
-0.01820729300379753,
0.060202427208423615,
-0.00947529636323452,
-0.028976717963814735,
0.02873075008392334,
0.001472852542065084,
0.0011983333388343453,
-0.029637020081281662,
0.04726209491491318,
-0.02459607645869255,
0.004284264985471964,
-0.011606298387050629,
0.02114095538854599,
-0.010528738610446453,
-0.06254071742296219,
-0.004773121792823076,
-0.024387964978814125,
-0.009582792408764362,
-0.03574444726109505,
-0.008278975263237953,
0.022803407162427902,
0.014428667724132538,
-0.07837555557489395,
-0.010480050928890705,
-0.0006530600949190557,
0.0171495471149683,
0.016808196902275085,
-0.010670059360563755,
0.00895100086927414,
0.01351929735392332,
0.023613855242729187,
-0.038869988173246384,
0.0249226912856102,
-0.039407722651958466,
-0.005839756224304438,
-0.06750576198101044,
0.025897743180394173,
-0.008260403759777546,
-0.026429645717144012,
-0.033619821071624756,
-0.0031727117020636797,
-0.0605284757912159,
-0.030256936326622963,
-0.004858792759478092,
-0.004976943600922823,
0.03195886313915253,
0.044383563101291656,
-0.004823350813239813,
0.0032442437950521708,
0.03770635649561882,
-0.04863528907299042,
-0.013594698160886765,
-0.03455590456724167,
0.06616215407848358,
0.0016350029036402702,
0.014678708277642727,
-0.029174236580729485,
-0.007113250903785229,
0.004724876955151558,
-0.0019216140499338508,
0.029175857082009315,
-0.027589555829763412,
0.026094920933246613,
-0.017534755170345306,
-0.06124800071120262,
0.03069467283785343,
-0.006260789930820465,
0.00009409415361005813,
0.028490951284766197,
0.029135175049304962,
0.03335979953408241,
-0.019932888448238373,
0.06568403542041779,
0.027384955435991287,
-0.06276555359363556,
-0.009313940070569515,
0.014520003460347652,
0.04211047291755676,
0.012977227568626404,
-0.0250532403588295,
0.044213030487298965,
0.014893289655447006,
0.0022710231132805347,
-0.015111087821424007,
-0.012984366156160831,
-0.03172159567475319,
-0.009853210300207138,
0.015084763057529926,
-0.005352585110813379,
-0.013010796159505844,
0.012420334853231907,
-0.027529360726475716,
-0.019915975630283356,
-0.03276524320244789,
0.011018546298146248,
0.031337372958660126,
-0.036003462970256805,
-0.0030401013791561127,
0.020752614364027977,
-0.006698190234601498,
0.024054234847426414,
-0.02281271666288376,
0.034486252814531326,
-0.05468873679637909,
0.010114745236933231,
-0.1512165069580078,
0.03303247690200806,
0.025513680651783943,
-0.03327975049614906,
-0.07632297277450562,
-0.007284775376319885,
-0.023402586579322815,
-0.007468952797353268,
-0.05201375111937523,
-0.0016585233388468623,
-0.02058405801653862,
-0.0033812434412539005,
-0.01113464217633009,
-0.02665284462273121,
-0.03988651558756828,
0.04404648765921593,
0.02884320355951786,
-0.029452985152602196,
-0.03162140026688576,
0.05102550983428955,
-0.026085423305630684,
-0.024665458127856255,
0.0262908972799778,
-0.015743454918265343,
-0.010666419751942158,
-0.005220390856266022,
-0.047196242958307266,
-0.03705970570445061,
-0.03224498778581619,
0.0017614752287045121,
-0.04495881870388985,
-0.04960709065198898,
0.013092631474137306,
0.038683220744132996,
0.010278230533003807,
0.010155925527215004,
0.012913333252072334,
-0.013026668690145016,
-0.014070411212742329,
-0.03972991183400154,
-0.01889495737850666,
0.02444193698465824,
-0.024463986977934837,
-0.04000202938914299,
0.015777334570884705,
0.0437399297952652,
-0.001103437040001154,
0.014069945551455021,
-0.02103348821401596,
-0.03280115872621536,
-0.03157376870512962,
0.07463054358959198,
-0.0026654587127268314,
0.01296701468527317,
-0.0000057479264796711504,
0.025257553905248642,
-0.021871240809559822,
-0.032826222479343414,
-0.04560374468564987,
0.0324527733027935,
0.00035901207593269646,
-0.033877719193696976,
-0.03767959773540497,
-0.006575142033398151,
0.002799153793603182,
0.013529256917536259,
-0.050201449543237686,
-0.008254910819232464,
-0.007702963426709175,
-0.054056357592344284,
0.02296575717628002,
-0.03979647904634476,
0.011845606379210949,
-0.004435769747942686,
0.0029659948777407408,
0.003941898699849844,
-0.010289889760315418,
0.038964565843343735,
-0.04447183758020401,
0.001653613755479455,
-0.03224761411547661,
0.014655228704214096,
-0.00048499819240532815,
-0.044492918998003006,
0.012882414273917675,
0.04081892594695091,
0.011940077878534794,
-0.012207156978547573,
0.007678724825382233,
-0.023106424137949944,
-0.08467648178339005,
0.0006631870055571198,
0.02105826511979103,
0.009318027645349503,
-0.016804441809654236,
0.038715723901987076,
-0.02876529097557068,
0.011902726255357265,
-0.016860231757164,
0.024377670139074326,
0.0015688453568145633,
-0.048393476754426956,
-0.0001731495576677844,
-0.00464293546974659,
-0.075395368039608,
0.03768186271190643,
0.01510479673743248,
0.008651540614664555,
-0.008111245930194855,
-0.004102335777133703,
-0.01808137074112892,
-0.006983084604144096,
-0.06561152637004852,
0.012924395501613617,
-0.01719929277896881,
0.021687932312488556,
-0.015012852847576141,
0.024522356688976288,
-0.017511827871203423,
-0.0013348439242690802,
0.01270970143377781,
0.01597157120704651,
0.027571767568588257,
-0.03731643036007881,
-0.01031474769115448,
0.013024420477449894,
0.07203495502471924,
0.01895572431385517,
-0.015245938673615456,
-0.025742756202816963,
0.048091597855091095,
-0.021571185439825058,
-0.001186214154586196,
0.020930256694555283,
0.015168783254921436,
0.04245814308524132,
-0.009260320104658604,
0.02014254592359066,
-0.00830002874135971,
-0.03081531636416912,
0.03518831729888916,
-0.027954699471592903,
0.005494158715009689,
-0.007831367664039135,
-0.02769617736339569,
-0.015941310673952103,
0.06105692684650421,
0.010873132385313511,
-0.0396450012922287,
-0.0007685435120947659,
-0.009393534623086452,
0.0025464841164648533,
-0.01399796549230814,
0.060371845960617065,
0.06516234576702118,
-0.0010899733752012253,
0.03629164397716522,
-0.01563403755426407,
0.032162413001060486,
0.02387862280011177,
0.007693496532738209,
-0.03957325592637062,
-0.008348709903657436,
-0.01035830844193697,
-0.05590943992137909,
0.006144387181848288,
-0.004002879839390516,
0.014490277506411076,
-0.016060931608080864,
0.012845010496675968,
-0.005214697681367397,
0.039469536393880844,
-0.014520453289151192,
-0.015213117003440857,
0.007762583903968334,
-0.007462191395461559,
0.0019564004614949226,
-0.016351591795682907,
0.018454626202583313,
0.010328958742320538,
0.04294128343462944,
0.007788845803588629,
-0.013351021334528923,
0.025772999972105026,
0.008880349807441235,
0.028309723362326622,
-0.001386720803566277,
-0.005923583172261715,
-0.001027789548970759,
-0.018830642104148865,
0.03180854767560959,
-0.02537187747657299,
0.02063998393714428,
-0.043658625334501266,
0.043321773409843445,
0.019941626116633415,
-0.04253072664141655,
0.03794156759977341,
-0.03344428911805153,
-0.01459271926432848,
0.012722522020339966,
-0.01728464663028717,
-0.016616040840744972,
-0.010614389553666115,
-0.030446456745266914,
0.0027388569433242083,
0.004622795153409243,
-0.03155604004859924,
-0.001507867593318224,
0.052937913686037064,
-0.037438977509737015,
-0.0092585738748312,
-0.0178360678255558,
0.020139873027801514,
-0.03120480850338936,
0.016051502898335457,
0.02722316049039364,
-0.014241239987313747,
0.036938589066267014,
-0.012556597590446472,
0.04336845502257347,
0.07202766090631485,
0.001560386037454009,
-0.03366247937083244,
-0.011320616118609905,
-0.008601817302405834,
-0.02354520931839943,
-0.004006217699497938,
-0.015875060111284256,
0.0005425590788945556,
-0.06298262625932693,
0.005474430974572897,
-0.0009426017059013247,
0.0255193579941988,
0.0032239239662885666,
-0.0161273293197155,
-0.04984835162758827,
-0.023894650861620903,
-0.00410386873409152,
0.03082418255507946,
0.006277557462453842,
-0.025247443467378616,
-0.0028598459903150797,
-0.0009330729371868074
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:46
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
while the person is under the age of 18 years, or
while the person is, for a continuous period of 28 days or upwards, incapable of, or substantially impeded in, the management of his or her affairs, in relation to the cause of action in respect of the limitation period in which the question arises, by reason of:
(i) Any disease or any impairment of her physical or mental condition.
This definition of disability requires that, if the Section 52 exception is to apply, Mrs Mulcahy must have suffered from an incapacity or a substantial impediment in the management of her affairs, because of a disease or an impairment of her mental condition.
The disability that is relevant is one that renders Mrs Mulcahy incapable of, or substantially impeded in, the management of her affairs, including instituting legal proceedings for assault and battery.
You tell told me that "Court of Appeal of New South Wales has concluded that the inquiries made under Sub-Section ll(3)(b) is directed to determining whether a person is able to reason normally about the matters relevant to a potential course of action,
to understand and consider advice and to give instructions about any action that a fundamental aspect of bringing a claim was that it required the exercise of willpower to initiate the claim, and to continue with the claim (State of New South Wales v Harlum [2007] NSWCA120)".
Furthermore, you say "Section ll(3)(b) has also been held to be concerned with different classes of persons - those who were "incapable" (which conveys the concept of total incapacity), and those who were "substantially impeded in the management of his affairs in relation to the cause of action by reason of disease or impairment of physical or mental condition".
You go on to say that "mental condition" covers the mind's activities in all its aspects, including the ability to form a rational judgement, or to exercise willpower to control physical acts in accordance with rational judgement.
It is a relevant matter, in the consideration of the question, to have regard to how a reasonable person, without any impairment, would conduct him or herself in the management of his or her affairs (KOTULSKI v ATTARD [1981], NSWLR115).
1.
It is my view, that, to a significant extent, Mrs Mulcahy was in "thrall" to Mr Cooper, whom she had found charming and good company and pleasant initially to her children and initially a good sexual partner,
but who, over a passage of months from the beginning of their relationship, demonstrated himself to be jealous of her relationship with her two sons, extremely needy of attention, irascible and then increasingly,
with the passage of time, was allegedly verbally abusive in the extreme, prone to using the worst of expletives in the English lexicon and threatening her with physical violence and, again, allegedly', as pointed out in her affidavit, subjecting her to physical violence at times and, in the context of owning two rifles, engendering in her a realistically-based fear of a potential threat to her life.
The individual's own view of their relationship, their own observations of their family of origin relationships, their experiences of earlier relationships, particularly sexualised relationships as they go through their various developmental phases and stages, the chemistry of the relationship and the phenomenon of cognitive dissonance all have their part to play.
Often enough, the "battered woman", if indeed that is the victim, will state that the abuser is so remorseful after it has happened, there are explanations in the abuser's childhood for them having poor temper control, having been abused themselves,
or how much they feel their abuser needs them, the desire to keep an integrated marriage or family and the investment of time and emotion that has been made by the abused in the relationship, are cited as rationalisations for staying in the relationship.
|
[
0.019484931603074074,
0.04523039609193802,
-0.0012488553766161203,
-0.0399869941174984,
-0.00971001386642456,
-0.025357786566019058,
0.018156690523028374,
-0.007994871586561203,
0.030309293419122696,
0.0028142735827714205,
0.0028194913174957037,
0.03927995264530182,
-0.013375691138207912,
0.0003202873922418803,
0.017073893919587135,
-0.022654742002487183,
-0.002566669834777713,
-0.011038458906114101,
-0.027996283024549484,
-0.007252218201756477,
-0.007860245183110237,
-0.0020891325548291206,
0.04343393072485924,
0.02304207719862461,
-0.005983306560665369,
0.035914674401283264,
0.003539237193763256,
-0.008257952518761158,
-0.0031417948193848133,
0.029101932421326637,
-0.0138838617131114,
-0.05320274457335472,
0.04061546549201012,
-0.03955351933836937,
0.03215951472520828,
0.0049247052520513535,
-0.008077651262283325,
-0.0002815688494592905,
-0.02797224558889866,
0.01645687222480774,
-0.03335466980934143,
-0.00718045886605978,
0.027693498879671097,
-0.0002143772435374558,
0.03178614750504494,
-0.03509199991822243,
-0.014622117392718792,
-0.022848904132843018,
-0.025486143305897713,
-0.027877265587449074,
-0.03150647506117821,
-0.008793193846940994,
0.06037140265107155,
-0.024383531883358955,
0.01126148272305727,
0.04174795001745224,
0.007466849405318499,
-0.023803982883691788,
-0.04309218376874924,
0.022006932646036148,
-0.00611586170271039,
-0.00680789677426219,
-0.014763124287128448,
-0.026339709758758545,
-0.018895262852311134,
0.047684866935014725,
-0.005892939865589142,
-0.01661221869289875,
0.0035490335430949926,
-0.061596497893333435,
-0.0009366274462081492,
0.03688148036599159,
0.0045504798181355,
-0.039097730070352554,
-0.08466627448797226,
0.017318245023489,
0.007992777973413467,
0.017554258927702904,
0.01453937217593193,
0.03914839029312134,
0.016155414283275604,
0.033854890614748,
-0.0012827394530177116,
0.03192061930894852,
-0.03464466333389282,
-0.0037293191999197006,
-0.0249651949852705,
0.012618009932339191,
0.03764228895306587,
-0.03241186589002609,
0.014134223572909832,
-0.0007152322214096785,
0.005996405612677336,
-0.03258364647626877,
-0.0010067304829135537,
0.024595702067017555,
-0.030732301995158195,
-0.04362567514181137,
0.039340659976005554,
0.023107774555683136,
-0.022854482755064964,
0.0287050511687994,
-0.021970786154270172,
-0.009189347736537457,
-0.028763119131326675,
0.015469030477106571,
0.017998814582824707,
0.046648841351270676,
0.04056897759437561,
0.005908761639147997,
0.027733149006962776,
-0.013605872169137001,
0.021512992680072784,
0.014972773380577564,
-0.018599525094032288,
0.04308609664440155,
0.023932449519634247,
-0.029510416090488434,
-0.020471876487135887,
-0.002752527827396989,
-0.020056454464793205,
0.029120992869138718,
0.008107312023639679,
-0.03568846732378006,
-0.06734739243984222,
0.03239301219582558,
0.022830011323094368,
0.01754220575094223,
-0.042894646525382996,
0.023560794070363045,
0.012466119602322578,
-0.016952063888311386,
-0.032763928174972534,
-0.04336526617407799,
0.0017387830885127187,
0.005514277145266533,
0.06191219389438629,
0.057232800871133804,
-0.007270711474120617,
0.01160007156431675,
0.06154247745871544,
0.016822723671793938,
0.03464071825146675,
-0.0244099460542202,
0.011889543384313583,
-0.01322306226938963,
0.013315713964402676,
-0.038922905921936035,
0.01327536255121231,
-0.0004674365045502782,
0.011660637333989143,
-0.017749544233083725,
0.05702871084213257,
-0.042654938995838165,
0.026201125234365463,
-0.05412134528160095,
-0.008294288069009781,
0.035343535244464874,
0.0571882501244545,
-0.03697121888399124,
-0.0011533237993717194,
0.01876460574567318,
-0.03198276460170746,
0.01680290326476097,
0.03717812895774841,
0.023210102692246437,
0.019106870517134666,
0.05722268298268318,
-0.035267423838377,
-0.0270865298807621,
0.008558313362300396,
-0.02162814326584339,
0.03346594423055649,
-0.03857312723994255,
0.00418620090931654,
0.023424074053764343,
0.025359226390719414,
0.008937923237681389,
-0.002887340961024165,
-0.013186034746468067,
-0.030405590310692787,
0.018716955557465553,
0.01017140131443739,
-0.022486677393317223,
0.002979196608066559,
0.020071901381015778,
0.011724846437573433,
-0.026923367753624916,
0.036604899913072586,
0.007689898833632469,
-0.04307909682393074,
-0.04267863556742668,
-0.010320154018700123,
0.03942495957016945,
0.02641761675477028,
-0.04481456056237221,
-0.018497060984373093,
0.019104521721601486,
0.00935900118201971,
-0.01703682914376259,
0.00719569344073534,
0.04539255425333977,
0.02384277619421482,
-0.02532508224248886,
0.003728289622813463,
-0.016497328877449036,
-0.05702754482626915,
0.03003888763487339,
0.01494638528674841,
0.0010619417298585176,
0.036318156868219376,
0.008556981571018696,
-0.0039354111067950726,
-0.009250699542462826,
-0.026698144152760506,
-0.031404126435518265,
-0.011860469356179237,
0.0005314698209986091,
0.008505097590386868,
0.014848364517092705,
-0.003617564681917429,
0.03314805030822754,
0.005850543268024921,
0.009278643876314163,
0.00741160660982132,
0.017975056543946266,
-0.0260823555290699,
0.01704317331314087,
0.030606960877776146,
-0.0038605760782957077,
0.05728580430150032,
0.01741776615381241,
0.024957511574029922,
0.024878112599253654,
0.023617247119545937,
0.012451175600290298,
0.022883810102939606,
-0.023438481613993645,
0.03430081903934479,
0.0007019288023002446,
-0.013637176714837551,
-0.044823262840509415,
0.06630576401948929,
-0.0466303676366806,
-0.0037503300700336695,
-0.006125296000391245,
0.032490551471710205,
0.011260509490966797,
-0.022773409262299538,
-0.01123135443776846,
0.015816351398825645,
0.03079024702310562,
-0.009649813175201416,
-0.018585825338959694,
0.0023955791257321835,
0.004283668007701635,
0.024111177772283554,
0.01120960433036089,
-0.001431419630534947,
-0.011149191297590733,
-0.013560156337916851,
0.00009686326666269451,
0.04420211538672447,
-0.016456754878163338,
0.00813840702176094,
-0.020296955481171608,
-0.01393134891986847,
0.0012863082811236382,
-0.011071148328483105,
0.022588588297367096,
-0.005638996604830027,
-0.027078337967395782,
-0.027309125289320946,
-0.00652166036888957,
-0.00620617950335145,
0.007857785560190678,
0.03123740293085575,
-0.007501994259655476,
-0.003675882238894701,
0.0007100458024069667,
0.004070804920047522,
0.0279613696038723,
0.0034248291049152613,
-0.0026996638625860214,
-0.0072519490495324135,
0.03859400749206543,
-0.04329941049218178,
-0.04774271324276924,
-0.002129523316398263,
-0.05078534409403801,
0.05128798633813858,
0.02373431622982025,
0.06737793982028961,
-0.024612130597233772,
-0.04671220853924751,
0.02475365623831749,
0.005078466609120369,
-0.16126090288162231,
0.009908673353493214,
0.01494058407843113,
0.04786171391606331,
0.0078072091564536095,
0.031007951125502586,
-0.008235238492488861,
-0.0030311390291899443,
-0.0372430682182312,
0.015137476846575737,
0.05599718540906906,
-0.061418235301971436,
0.012691029347479343,
0.009187606163322926,
0.009049088694155216,
-0.01606227084994316,
0.00016655800573062152,
0.00005780789433629252,
-0.026500366628170013,
-0.0349486880004406,
-0.007878853939473629,
-0.0014635695843026042,
0.0076612369157373905,
-0.025956926867365837,
0.015082151629030704,
0.002917882055044174,
0.014422467909753323,
-0.0033851691987365484,
-0.031753841787576675,
-0.04012436792254448,
-0.06814073771238327,
-0.0010415695142000914,
-0.010360479354858398,
0.015533839352428913,
-0.03447370231151581,
0.0024171217810362577,
0.04508178308606148,
-0.05422826111316681,
-0.0020741685293614864,
-0.03154792636632919,
0.009832083247601986,
0.005513587035238743,
0.016856757923960686,
0.03438263386487961,
-0.017395837232470512,
-0.046110909432172775,
0.017602726817131042,
-0.007060912903398275,
-0.06555400788784027,
-0.019899047911167145,
-0.04104812443256378,
0.012915058061480522,
-0.04234074428677559,
-0.00047903595259413123,
-0.022884853184223175,
-0.046923305839300156,
0.05522117391228676,
0.03390369564294815,
-0.014718721620738506,
-0.008006297051906586,
-0.012044397182762623,
-0.05126061663031578,
0.03892124071717262,
-0.02044028230011463,
-0.02644013799726963,
-0.003838695352897048,
-0.004416188690811396,
0.018581049516797066,
-0.020967604592442513,
-0.003529034089297056,
-0.002807149663567543,
-0.04457221180200577,
-0.0013273963704705238,
0.001057041808962822,
0.019292160868644714,
0.005731853190809488,
0.029872922226786613,
0.020145274698734283,
-0.024403877556324005,
-0.06792888045310974,
0.004810638260096312,
0.046698156744241714,
-0.009230295196175575,
0.027576595544815063,
0.014247196726500988,
-0.05091684311628342,
0.048904962837696075,
0.005059351678937674,
0.025156170129776,
0.22931785881519318,
0.008813593536615372,
-0.027388088405132294,
-0.008556944318115711,
0.04734570160508156,
-0.0078112054616212845,
0.027528101578354836,
0.05859794095158577,
-0.010828137397766113,
-0.02718510664999485,
-0.00533587159588933,
-0.014820456504821777,
0.02169218845665455,
0.01880233734846115,
-0.03963211178779602,
0.01259919349104166,
-0.027882670983672142,
-0.058860134333372116,
0.06578803807497025,
0.007230085786432028,
0.025642750784754753,
-0.03625314682722092,
0.053034208714962006,
0.025213776156306267,
-0.036647383123636246,
0.00967933889478445,
-0.006092689465731382,
0.014513577334582806,
-0.014018227346241474,
-0.03667033836245537,
-0.06431671231985092,
-0.048356007784605026,
0.05538470298051834,
-0.047789230942726135,
0.03220963478088379,
0.02121410146355629,
-0.015511351637542248,
-0.03304043039679527,
-0.0930367261171341,
0.06571808457374573,
0.05908104032278061,
-0.016972582787275314,
-0.040776319801807404,
-0.04449769854545593,
0.04005010426044464,
0.02855551242828369,
-0.020350566133856773,
0.05110456049442291,
-0.012454669922590256,
0.01662403717637062,
-0.014657051302492619,
-0.010597066022455692,
-0.0104224169626832,
0.010820122435688972,
-0.01992759108543396,
-0.0314788743853569,
-0.000731030129827559,
0.024656308814883232,
-0.04823359102010727,
0.04093801975250244,
0.012407011352479458,
0.016383910551667213,
-0.07572983205318451,
0.05161527544260025,
0.003172795521095395,
0.04678678140044212,
-0.058081913739442825,
-0.05924020707607269,
0.05521576106548309,
0.008147239685058594,
0.04389658197760582,
0.014761976897716522,
0.00433158315718174,
0.021030547097325325,
0.04731767997145653,
-0.0009924494661390781,
-0.029985330998897552,
-0.010463246144354343,
0.06064900755882263,
-0.004924341104924679,
-0.020683851093053818,
-0.03962692245841026,
-0.022313440218567848,
-0.0440649576485157,
0.023868625983595848,
-0.011170942336320877,
-0.0060036624781787395,
0.04394971951842308,
0.02858414687216282,
-0.012526264414191246,
-0.00037451443495228887,
-0.025612203404307365,
-0.04744575917720795,
0.015107204206287861,
-0.04537009820342064,
-0.0061822389252483845,
0.037721503525972366,
-0.0412818007171154,
-0.04434610530734062,
-0.05527801811695099,
-0.028987310826778412,
-0.0280743520706892,
-0.006136592011898756,
-0.03207888826727867,
-0.0009623464429751039,
-0.02907676436007023,
-0.00664337445050478,
0.021717073395848274,
-0.04664570093154907,
-0.0005604944890365005,
-0.0032406833488494158,
-0.012883584015071392,
-0.02423769235610962,
0.01252032071352005,
-0.009821627289056778,
0.031104756519198418,
0.0011224892223253846,
0.025064917281270027,
0.05387162044644356,
0.023282917216420174,
0.002203592099249363,
0.028810037299990654,
-0.04628641530871391,
-0.022643625736236572,
0.0017032531322911382,
-0.028151048347353935,
-0.018162216991186142,
-0.03356187790632248,
0.0036858348175883293,
0.036051906645298004,
0.022535253316164017,
-0.019158750772476196,
-0.0565413236618042,
-0.005493304692208767,
0.04333893954753876,
-0.02080703340470791,
0.01836657151579857,
0.013072928413748741,
-0.0028482810594141483,
0.06370718777179718,
-0.01152597926557064,
-0.04280013218522072,
-0.015190983191132545,
0.0006035264814272523,
0.017066877335309982,
0.015461811795830727,
-0.08961332589387894,
0.01970834843814373,
-0.019035685807466507,
-0.01961113139986992,
0.00938280951231718,
0.004128093831241131,
-0.028826484456658363,
-0.04713711887598038,
0.017586486414074898,
-0.005166266113519669,
-0.01746314950287342,
-0.023814251646399498,
0.027179919183254242,
-0.03694595396518707,
-0.0269376989454031,
0.035703834146261215,
-0.026053810492157936,
0.07684115320444107,
0.050687894225120544,
0.06061887741088867,
0.03439026698470116,
0.04600559175014496,
0.007637296337634325,
0.015587389469146729,
0.023464759811758995,
-0.03671041503548622,
-0.04040483385324478,
-0.036100175231695175,
0.029980016872286797,
0.028039343655109406,
-0.03267993777990341,
0.026387950405478477,
-0.05478909611701965,
-0.02140384539961815,
0.019617971032857895,
0.005719809792935848,
-0.0075228530913591385,
0.04557365924119949,
0.01643495075404644,
-0.026703549548983574,
0.07082419842481613,
-0.03221604600548744,
-0.0032952141482383013,
-0.03432413935661316,
-0.008705643005669117,
0.09619303792715073,
0.009638845920562744,
-0.030751056969165802,
0.013342469930648804,
0.018757864832878113,
0.004957310855388641,
0.07045020163059235,
0.04298456385731697,
0.001233587390743196,
0.021351609379053116,
0.008223863318562508,
-0.007667586673051119,
0.0023223538883030415,
0.030367935076355934,
-0.013661577366292477,
0.019888564944267273,
0.014071725308895111,
-0.014540959149599075,
0.014198364689946175,
0.020057477056980133,
0.03933889791369438,
-0.05374637991189957,
-0.002362340223044157,
-0.06024255231022835,
0.011452458798885345,
0.010930003598332405,
0.05568036437034607,
0.02098034881055355,
-0.04241819679737091,
-0.02565356157720089,
-0.017025398090481758,
0.007608461193740368,
-0.07410021126270294,
0.004199828486889601,
0.001144030480645597,
0.03082239255309105,
-0.025340145453810692,
0.005808246321976185,
-0.004000919871032238,
0.0037149526178836823,
-0.04655436426401138,
0.02347465232014656,
0.004572874400764704,
-0.011601066216826439,
-0.0057531679049134254,
0.0564308725297451,
0.009687317535281181,
-0.016295546665787697,
-0.011913630180060863,
0.013322658836841583,
0.002112190006300807,
0.012709325179457664,
0.025110619142651558,
-0.00962584838271141,
-0.017125681042671204,
0.004525200929492712,
0.017970319837331772,
0.04462189972400665,
0.05785829946398735,
0.016059372574090958,
0.01356722041964531,
0.034519024193286896,
-0.034794487059116364,
0.01770160347223282,
0.02798059955239296,
-0.029242077842354774,
0.0016858172602951527,
-0.024893516674637794,
-0.041311077773571014,
-0.005865071434527636,
0.0031013202387839556,
0.007338379975408316,
-0.04267311841249466,
-0.04162076488137245,
-0.06057647615671158,
0.0028146931435912848,
0.01568465493619442,
-0.024306561797857285,
-0.05743219703435898,
-0.0048054237850010395,
0.027434945106506348,
-0.022853750735521317,
0.018394865095615387,
-0.021639740094542503,
-0.004664267413318157,
-0.04552997648715973,
0.03818603977560997,
0.0224897600710392,
-0.005513113457709551,
-0.005429928656667471,
0.030354434624314308,
0.04535797983407974,
0.05366632714867592,
0.012899793684482574,
-0.0009815475204959512,
0.03804896026849747,
0.00039014508365653455,
0.01675684191286564,
-0.006899806205183268,
0.04254164174199104,
-0.0020938455127179623,
-0.03188401460647583,
0.026915760710835457,
-0.017580857500433922,
0.039636559784412384,
-0.0016472885617986321,
0.011591398157179356,
-0.028839971870183945,
0.021988019347190857,
-0.009646574035286903,
0.0026505310088396072,
-0.022916123270988464,
-0.008107556030154228,
0.013719363138079643,
0.009864128194749355,
0.015454554930329323,
-0.0657363310456276,
-0.027597777545452118,
0.00986207090318203,
0.012167530134320259,
-0.06785974651575089,
-0.02976180985569954,
0.003355825087055564,
0.020173732191324234,
0.0040178545750677586,
0.0011498834937810898,
-0.010944373905658722,
0.013374620117247105,
0.030483480542898178,
0.009035049937665462,
0.03137240931391716,
-0.03787640854716301,
0.00044698428246192634,
-0.0579998642206192,
0.03884764388203621,
-0.007997716777026653,
-0.0709196925163269,
-0.05018178001046181,
-0.0021881761495023966,
-0.04176823049783707,
-0.018601160496473312,
-0.010639967396855354,
-0.007133826147764921,
0.019490083679556847,
0.025440437719225883,
0.010148253291845322,
-0.05951918661594391,
0.065803162753582,
-0.030942706391215324,
0.009941409341990948,
-0.0800032690167427,
0.0640157014131546,
-0.013759124092757702,
0.022141050547361374,
-0.003678159322589636,
0.0065935635939240456,
0.02391764521598816,
0.011811533942818642,
-0.014221424236893654,
0.004752445500344038,
0.00822864193469286,
0.01118415780365467,
-0.03345772624015808,
0.06588800996541977,
0.006094483193010092,
0.05385182425379753,
0.05774237960577011,
0.020662151277065277,
0.011655012145638466,
-0.012544219382107258,
0.009516071528196335,
0.05436359718441963,
-0.015918971970677376,
0.022173436358571053,
-0.006360307801514864,
-0.01052743662148714,
-0.06308088451623917,
0.026138044893741608,
0.027772849425673485,
0.02436676248908043,
-0.03808974847197533,
0.01665177382528782,
0.011984027922153473,
-0.03387557715177536,
0.02792932465672493,
-0.0169509407132864,
-0.008636224083602428,
-0.03010428324341774,
0.0005348268314264715,
-0.015423900447785854,
-0.03133310750126839,
0.013404713943600655,
0.011730557307600975,
-0.02124173566699028,
-0.011855660937726498,
-0.006754843983799219,
0.02516806125640869,
-0.012327739968895912,
-0.0033217440359294415,
0.009232409298419952,
0.026019088923931122,
-0.06773045659065247,
-0.006808842997997999,
-0.13997817039489746,
0.013203214854001999,
0.03772638365626335,
-0.01678970828652382,
-0.0666915774345398,
0.003632425097748637,
-0.055416230112314224,
0.015595074743032455,
-0.04922113195061684,
-0.021736035123467445,
-0.01293671689927578,
-0.044413018971681595,
-0.006197690032422543,
-0.022521542385220528,
-0.03401362523436546,
0.05182117968797684,
-0.023679545149207115,
-0.051089707762002945,
-0.02795243449509144,
0.0452752411365509,
-0.015866417437791824,
0.025224123150110245,
0.012767046689987183,
-0.009195894934237003,
-0.03341741859912872,
0.016146456822752953,
-0.054049812257289886,
-0.01741783507168293,
-0.05794042348861694,
-0.007904541678726673,
-0.011308503337204456,
-0.04930057004094124,
0.004670571535825729,
0.02102055773139,
0.00907136406749487,
-0.030779918655753136,
0.0024955039843916893,
-0.03911985829472542,
-0.033540330827236176,
-0.019413551315665245,
0.0030355656053870916,
0.007373800966888666,
-0.006202162243425846,
-0.004096070770174265,
-0.00830815453082323,
0.03132014721632004,
-0.0003439492138568312,
0.006528093013912439,
-0.06026862934231758,
-0.02917560189962387,
-0.04708118736743927,
0.04418310150504112,
-0.0178314708173275,
0.02991628833115101,
0.008262626826763153,
0.011252151802182198,
-0.0034807801712304354,
0.0013314145617187023,
-0.020936667919158936,
0.051563963294029236,
0.0006133903516456485,
-0.014601798728108406,
-0.01651754230260849,
0.009039112366735935,
-0.0029616199899464846,
0.0076536089181900024,
-0.04788397625088692,
0.026174109429121017,
-0.03227318450808525,
0.0077149230055511,
0.0052312882617115974,
-0.04786526784300804,
0.0010947869159281254,
0.0036389732267707586,
-0.015547472983598709,
0.033329077064991,
0.01641632802784443,
0.019209204241633415,
-0.004510452505201101,
0.012748501263558865,
0.0011160699650645256,
-0.014402462169528008,
0.0036174715496599674,
-0.012510381639003754,
0.04575689509510994,
0.029751047492027283,
-0.003263595048338175,
0.0038606449961662292,
0.03147013112902641,
-0.0030582984909415245,
-0.09416363388299942,
-0.0075739589519798756,
-0.013504702597856522,
-0.015441300347447395,
-0.023472225293517113,
0.0514858141541481,
0.0053268903866410255,
0.008062532171607018,
-0.030854512006044388,
0.0077065713703632355,
-0.017425687983632088,
-0.047196000814437866,
0.03289399296045303,
-0.023528186604380608,
-0.03289353474974632,
0.07731752097606659,
-0.031068237498402596,
-0.004202025476843119,
0.01136995293200016,
-0.015671417117118835,
0.015008501708507538,
-0.008472821675240993,
-0.06794179975986481,
-0.006775496061891317,
-0.028381450101733208,
0.02636026218533516,
-0.025768456980586052,
0.033973585814237595,
0.0157989040017128,
0.010664569213986397,
0.01710599847137928,
-0.01872226968407631,
0.037636008113622665,
-0.019775278866291046,
-0.006119200028479099,
0.030388416722416878,
0.05469685420393944,
0.01538678165525198,
-0.010120543651282787,
-0.02868546172976494,
0.04548614099621773,
-0.03925394266843796,
-0.011936786584556103,
0.023486513644456863,
0.00922424253076315,
0.02055547945201397,
0.02176467329263687,
0.01998399756848812,
-0.037641990929841995,
-0.01851288042962551,
0.006963275372982025,
-0.0056129018776118755,
-0.01617761142551899,
-0.010320276021957397,
-0.03727889060974121,
-0.022522328421473503,
0.014948438853025436,
0.009307176806032658,
-0.059881437569856644,
-0.03856765478849411,
-0.009293769486248493,
-0.010305617935955524,
0.04596852511167526,
0.03730017691850662,
0.045584362000226974,
-0.02252376265823841,
-0.008230099454522133,
0.036625318229198456,
0.017776677384972572,
0.05063427984714508,
0.018035318702459335,
-0.03633340448141098,
-0.04807468131184578,
-0.023943597450852394,
-0.06169134005904198,
0.06296560168266296,
-0.0010793850524351,
0.001051159924827516,
-0.018152382224798203,
-0.012862143106758595,
0.00473845936357975,
0.010066119953989983,
-0.019149579107761383,
0.030557697638869286,
0.03947240859270096,
-0.027477046474814415,
-0.008665702305734158,
0.02784288302063942,
-0.027991240844130516,
-0.0009565831860527396,
0.03270372748374939,
-0.00026821557548828423,
-0.00859074480831623,
0.02992718107998371,
-0.03762231394648552,
0.006757827941328287,
-0.016730815172195435,
-0.0009971163235604763,
0.00913915317505598,
-0.04562711715698242,
-0.002413227455690503,
-0.03810713067650795,
0.06024041771888733,
-0.010209590196609497,
0.02189038321375847,
0.012319311499595642,
-0.02702406607568264,
0.03600123152136803,
0.006777908653020859,
-0.0029487262945622206,
0.007277671713382006,
-0.031408727169036865,
0.009448998607695103,
-0.020028088241815567,
-0.04168834537267685,
-0.015821225941181183,
-0.006687083747237921,
-0.03610028326511383,
-0.006720400881022215,
0.040837399661540985,
-0.033826228231191635,
-0.03803175315260887,
0.04413566738367081,
0.02246071770787239,
0.026667868718504906,
-0.002187612932175398,
-0.0047250771895051,
0.01047553215175867,
0.003686027368530631,
-0.011435899883508682,
0.05915524438023567,
0.011351373046636581,
-0.007198359351605177,
-0.045857544988393784,
-0.010259823873639107,
-0.022558948025107384,
0.0036972668021917343,
0.03634136542677879,
0.010107649490237236,
0.0012538247974589467,
-0.03506360575556755,
-0.017810652032494545,
-0.012652674689888954,
0.034103862941265106,
0.00933841709047556,
-0.012404175475239754,
-0.014127691276371479,
-0.017144037410616875,
-0.0258957426995039,
0.04181564226746559,
0.07952643185853958,
-0.0011874563060700893,
0.022805500775575638,
-0.012397798709571362
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:40
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
..) I am of opinion that it is a relevant matter, in the consideration of the question raised by the notice of motion, to have regard to how a reasonable person without any impairment would conduct himself in the management of his affairs.
A reasonable person without impairment would be able to reason normally about the matters relevant to a potential cause of action, to understand and consider advice and to give instructions about any action."
221The above comments were approved by the Court of Appeal in Olive v Johnstone [2006] NSWCA 21 at [61] and in New South Wales v Harlum [2007] NSWCA 120 at [61].
222In Kotulski v Attard, Slattery J found that a plaintiff suffering from a "depressive state with some hysterical features (...) that impaired her volition and judgment" was suffering from a "disability" for the purposes of suspending the limitation period.
223In Saunders v Jackson [2009] NSWCA 192, Hoeben J (with whom Ipp and Macfarlan JJA agreed) said that "a consideration of this question [whether a person is substantially impeded in the management of the cause of action] must have regard to the nature of the particular cause of action".
His Honour said that a decision to commence an action after an industrial accident or a motor vehicle accident would be relatively straightforward, in contrast to the case before him, being an allegation of sexual assault within a family. In this case, the decision to bring an action in the context of domestic violence, against a de facto partner, could not be said to be "relatively straightforward".
224In New South Wales v Harlum Beazley JA (with whom Tobias JA agreed) emphasised the affect that a person's mental condition might have on the willpower to commence proceedings, at [94] - [95]:
"[94] The State's approach also fails to deal with another of the other fundamental aspects of bringing a claim, namely that it requires the exercise of willpower to initiate the claim: see Kotulski at 118. In this regard, I consider that it is important to understand that it is not only a question of having the willpower to engage in the task of commencing proceedings.
Such an approach takes a far too simplistic view of what is involved in the commencement of an action. In making a decision to commence an action, the person is also making a decision to continue with the claim.
[95] Even if a person is able to fulfil each of the requirements contained in the State's approach, including the making of a decision to instruct a lawyer and to provide instructions, the person may not have the willpower to engage in all that is required to commence an action because of that person's mental condition."
225In this case the defendant alleges that because of her pleaded injuries she has been under a disability from 1993 through to the last of the pleaded assaults and continuing. The pleaded injuries are post traumatic stress disorder, adjustment disorder and/or mixed anxiety depressive syndrome.
Whether the defendant suffers from a disability (medical evidence)
226This requires a consideration of the medical evidence to determine the effect of not only the assaults but also the statements on other occasions which although not constituting in themselves an assault, may be relevant to a medical opinion about the defendant's disability.
227The defendant initially sought to lead evidence from Dr Godsall a consultant psychiatrist. Five of his initial reports were not admitted into evidence but his report of 26 July 2011 was admitted and in that report he diagnosed the defendant in these terms:
" I diagnosed that Ms Mulcahy is suffering from PTSD as a result of exposure to chronic situational stress, bullying, threatened violence, verbal violence and derogatory, demeaning and trivialising comments and, along with the foregoing history, symptoms and signs consistent with a significant emotional reaction of great intensity if the situation in which she found herself was traumatic for her."
|
[
0.019611617550253868,
0.03179662674665451,
0.001957851927727461,
-0.021857161074876785,
-0.010805334895849228,
0.0065463874489068985,
0.02972826361656189,
-0.001549956970848143,
0.006407201290130615,
0.006397752556949854,
0.013721795752644539,
0.013932975940406322,
-0.027043618261814117,
-0.015193946659564972,
0.019979998469352722,
-0.02848161943256855,
-0.007775189355015755,
0.009041711688041687,
-0.022677931934595108,
0.002168024657294154,
-0.013982429169118404,
0.001367243705317378,
0.012724122032523155,
0.026718109846115112,
-0.004441134165972471,
0.03815356642007828,
-0.010775997303426266,
-0.0015815059887245297,
-0.001474110409617424,
0.010649059899151325,
-0.014424576424062252,
0.0038957614451646805,
0.009725412353873253,
-0.03524119034409523,
0.009206213057041168,
-0.009143120609223843,
-0.025556838139891624,
-0.010516324080526829,
-0.018942834809422493,
-0.013753702864050865,
-0.02639804221689701,
-0.00928905326873064,
0.025271210819482803,
0.015134225599467754,
0.04721955582499504,
-0.040481362491846085,
-0.015100759454071522,
0.0010610651224851608,
0.017791137099266052,
-0.04067523032426834,
-0.048358213156461716,
-0.0016786700580269098,
0.05583576112985611,
-0.049306660890579224,
-0.03720685467123985,
0.005276391748338938,
-0.021562503650784492,
-0.034032806754112244,
-0.08317579329013824,
0.0006994910072535276,
-0.025467781350016594,
0.009886572137475014,
-0.010527844540774822,
-0.028660092502832413,
-0.00715381745249033,
0.08141995966434479,
-0.0033417525701224804,
-0.025405429303646088,
0.0124429389834404,
-0.03420347720384598,
-0.002275231294333935,
0.0132469916716218,
-0.011708890087902546,
0.005109770689159632,
-0.04903718829154968,
0.015135935507714748,
0.020088303834199905,
0.00008589339267928153,
0.026278026401996613,
0.03456191346049309,
-0.00945630669593811,
0.030625293031334877,
-0.00012794403301086277,
0.034516580402851105,
-0.005845366511493921,
0.006979038473218679,
-0.013823829591274261,
0.017685487866401672,
0.03573153167963028,
-0.025501972064375877,
0.009045572951436043,
-0.00770751154050231,
-0.0004606570000760257,
-0.02174893207848072,
0.029033325612545013,
-0.00016097695333883166,
-0.028076335787773132,
-0.007089077960699797,
-0.008051751181483269,
0.04261136054992676,
0.019030675292015076,
0.012738648802042007,
-0.015758348628878593,
-0.009461667388677597,
0.006395402364432812,
0.0033629604149609804,
0.0222284235060215,
0.014709612354636192,
0.006246145348995924,
0.02090432494878769,
0.009195410646498203,
-0.004289731383323669,
0.06100410968065262,
0.015529115684330463,
-0.009438211098313332,
0.00781647302210331,
0.03787526860833168,
-0.020321229472756386,
-0.002893019700422883,
-0.013405336998403072,
0.017925549298524857,
0.018794819712638855,
0.02272946573793888,
-0.016941029578447342,
-0.031936123967170715,
0.02864721044898033,
0.024190474301576614,
0.022404128685593605,
-0.050834979861974716,
0.04690691456198692,
0.021680036559700966,
0.0004511948209255934,
-0.01888028159737587,
-0.0359729565680027,
0.010286950506269932,
-0.015995563939213753,
0.045215461403131485,
0.07120759785175323,
-0.012384302914142609,
-0.021533312276005745,
0.02385048381984234,
0.039061110466718674,
0.04010719433426857,
-0.05281759053468704,
0.008563434705138206,
-0.04518594592809677,
0.03717489168047905,
-0.03443077951669693,
0.012957549653947353,
-0.026904994621872902,
-0.007546946406364441,
-0.00338964955881238,
0.02382930926978588,
-0.039471134543418884,
0.029779119417071342,
-0.03127650171518326,
0.004704500548541546,
0.038566190749406815,
0.02229304239153862,
-0.003389677032828331,
-0.012764060869812965,
-0.013986850157380104,
-0.06036078929901123,
0.009575027041137218,
0.011847584508359432,
0.00369168259203434,
0.008415917865931988,
0.012912625446915627,
-0.026280852034687996,
-0.014313453808426857,
0.031381845474243164,
-0.020683495327830315,
0.023730112239718437,
0.018638212233781815,
0.017532501369714737,
0.017106568440794945,
0.054435696452856064,
0.018312852829694748,
-0.020361799746751785,
-0.013640506193041801,
-0.011064381338655949,
0.037868253886699677,
0.02720187045633793,
-0.021193599328398705,
-0.012155447155237198,
0.009045993909239769,
-0.025183428078889847,
-0.02881205826997757,
0.03279263153672218,
0.02555478736758232,
-0.027925632894039154,
-0.019456859678030014,
0.0150552187114954,
0.03821777179837227,
0.04915846884250641,
-0.04781171679496765,
-0.013473767787218094,
0.00348097737878561,
0.009583807550370693,
-0.0031206028070300817,
0.005271364469081163,
0.03927556052803993,
0.020219704136252403,
-0.0416000597178936,
-0.025880413129925728,
-0.017474090680480003,
-0.07895425707101822,
0.02417508140206337,
0.029477374628186226,
-0.021282514557242393,
0.021533509716391563,
0.054041650146245956,
0.0020343626383692026,
-0.02148543857038021,
-0.018510863184928894,
0.019978011026978493,
-0.01980559527873993,
-0.02378143183887005,
-0.023009108379483223,
-0.010644597932696342,
-0.007785520516335964,
0.033992916345596313,
0.0053510465659201145,
0.0036285342648625374,
-0.012358888983726501,
0.038826894015073776,
-0.028097927570343018,
0.011075574904680252,
0.04294174909591675,
-0.016445692628622055,
0.046648550778627396,
0.012448830530047417,
-0.00472016679123044,
-0.017579209059476852,
0.012517428956925869,
0.030706757679581642,
-0.01218377985060215,
0.004374505952000618,
0.023363715037703514,
-0.0029061012901365757,
-0.008855033665895462,
-0.030107058584690094,
0.03460085391998291,
-0.039385393261909485,
-0.00894476380199194,
-0.03698495402932167,
0.04393269121646881,
0.017147528007626534,
0.03840618580579758,
-0.017439864575862885,
0.04196704924106598,
0.039489902555942535,
-0.0169513039290905,
-0.0016560291405767202,
-0.036092810332775116,
0.005356991663575172,
0.04403636232018471,
0.017560161650180817,
-0.008119151927530766,
-0.039020147174596786,
-0.006523265969008207,
0.028300942853093147,
0.06528743356466293,
-0.019435398280620575,
-0.00015300227096304297,
-0.04593253508210182,
-0.06694445759057999,
-0.011019816622138023,
-0.007059426512569189,
-0.0034747852478176355,
0.005888264626264572,
-0.02769552171230316,
-0.018923643976449966,
0.004105929285287857,
-0.006366280373185873,
0.01432862039655447,
0.03376774489879608,
0.0086085619404912,
-0.01863374188542366,
-0.0020436907652765512,
0.01948166824877262,
0.029690561816096306,
0.02954966016113758,
-0.015471790917217731,
-0.015828702598810196,
0.0007102400995790958,
-0.011692444793879986,
-0.05984378233551979,
-0.005633032880723476,
-0.04335470497608185,
0.06213676184415817,
0.036855198442935944,
0.07570790499448776,
-0.04217877611517906,
-0.04069609194993973,
0.016311265528202057,
-0.007481541484594345,
-0.15722590684890747,
-0.0257799681276083,
0.021760642528533936,
0.029846178367733955,
-0.0014435906196013093,
0.015397786162793636,
-0.042862314730882645,
0.02125520445406437,
-0.026639914140105247,
0.02358827367424965,
0.07121873646974564,
-0.06625434011220932,
-0.0008661735337227583,
0.03541719913482666,
0.017036352306604385,
-0.004102597013115883,
0.02949151024222374,
-0.006716386880725622,
-0.001646592398174107,
-0.04567638412117958,
-0.01917063631117344,
-0.0011171805672347546,
0.023601507768034935,
-0.03284123167395592,
0.027108963578939438,
0.03156113997101784,
0.027095425873994827,
-0.010429047048091888,
-0.01780296303331852,
-0.04588595777750015,
-0.05205268785357475,
0.00997332762926817,
-0.011399936862289906,
0.04429386183619499,
-0.026926908642053604,
-0.0028404463082551956,
0.036693718284368515,
-0.07876961678266525,
-0.018773391842842102,
-0.018841110169887543,
0.01758516952395439,
0.038533810526132584,
0.01727200299501419,
0.019496669992804527,
-0.017640573903918266,
-0.02564951777458191,
-0.025740470737218857,
-0.008916113525629044,
-0.03327649459242821,
-0.01683722250163555,
-0.0273695457726717,
-0.03144200146198273,
-0.04472818970680237,
-0.014217591844499111,
-0.029829854145646095,
-0.0740065947175026,
0.04612553119659424,
0.030353721231222153,
0.003921919502317905,
-0.015194390900433064,
-0.030642101541161537,
-0.050556156784296036,
0.028397604823112488,
-0.007962755858898163,
-0.0028875686693936586,
0.015590650960803032,
0.005905382335186005,
0.012911736033856869,
-0.005872857756912708,
-0.011021826416254044,
-0.013661210425198078,
-0.04729922488331795,
-0.0301902387291193,
-0.004135988652706146,
0.021783800795674324,
-0.010111318901181221,
0.034543029963970184,
0.005243388004601002,
-0.01073384191840887,
-0.05555310845375061,
0.017550427466630936,
0.029050741344690323,
-0.009771451354026794,
0.04210115224123001,
-0.014098710380494595,
-0.01056815404444933,
0.04902820661664009,
0.025503478944301605,
0.04661531746387482,
0.2353418618440628,
0.012919299304485321,
-0.014230798929929733,
-0.006541212555021048,
0.01862020045518875,
-0.0035253760870546103,
0.01982683129608631,
0.02787105366587639,
0.00727121764793992,
-0.012365906499326229,
-0.028133010491728783,
0.008279136382043362,
0.004242908675223589,
0.030676495283842087,
-0.020964106544852257,
0.00218299706466496,
-0.03930060938000679,
-0.06692574918270111,
0.0880737379193306,
-0.006354202516376972,
0.06454363465309143,
-0.044659268110990524,
0.04444611817598343,
0.012073871679604053,
-0.033851705491542816,
-0.0015370621113106608,
-0.00575790461152792,
0.03779126703739166,
0.002827761694788933,
-0.02913091890513897,
-0.04854830354452133,
-0.011675087735056877,
0.04136055335402489,
-0.027742883190512657,
0.016789140179753304,
0.00304099777713418,
-0.031726282089948654,
-0.027905944734811783,
-0.06674498319625854,
0.0361105315387249,
0.05318364128470421,
-0.0326552540063858,
-0.04950409755110741,
-0.05087903514504433,
0.04621941223740578,
0.010939134284853935,
-0.020281054079532623,
0.026352785527706146,
-0.03408146649599075,
0.014361293986439705,
0.008494558744132519,
0.01135304756462574,
-0.012216385453939438,
-0.005853163078427315,
-0.028384454548358917,
0.008298010565340519,
-0.006389904767274857,
-0.004598701372742653,
-0.028591828420758247,
0.017859386280179024,
0.030759016051888466,
0.010439237579703331,
-0.08889307081699371,
0.015453645028173923,
-0.02888425998389721,
0.0570349283516407,
-0.027767101302742958,
-0.015258554369211197,
0.03232339397072792,
-0.016346093267202377,
0.044370707124471664,
0.003194895340129733,
0.001040516421198845,
0.048841193318367004,
0.02548031136393547,
-0.007315782830119133,
0.01746233180165291,
0.04957583546638489,
0.04320596903562546,
0.002326966729015112,
-0.025409149006009102,
-0.011694058775901794,
-0.001827745814807713,
-0.03856416419148445,
0.020021656528115273,
0.01364001352339983,
-0.014368935488164425,
0.04234286770224571,
0.040360353887081146,
-0.006405212916433811,
-0.016356155276298523,
-0.008542307652533054,
-0.04984123632311821,
0.029419656842947006,
-0.010276677086949348,
0.01460291538387537,
0.07953935861587524,
-0.018772048875689507,
-0.014590032398700714,
-0.04470626637339592,
0.013887911103665829,
-0.009102231822907925,
0.002455208683386445,
-0.04075269028544426,
-0.00630417512729764,
-0.025060230866074562,
-0.006338997278362513,
0.03297733888030052,
-0.02348325401544571,
-0.0023097649682313204,
-0.03905574977397919,
-0.020481359213590622,
-0.007422335911542177,
0.012114057317376137,
0.01990581303834915,
0.0526442788541317,
-0.025383630767464638,
0.01722690835595131,
0.06668513268232346,
0.052939947694540024,
-0.015364352613687515,
0.0407710075378418,
-0.045120205730199814,
0.028425686061382294,
-0.019709128886461258,
-0.017861245200037956,
-0.012622770853340626,
-0.04287261888384819,
0.013313014060258865,
0.00837705284357071,
0.02003595046699047,
-0.019787011668086052,
-0.04322453960776329,
-0.02888435311615467,
0.05757829174399376,
-0.029013702645897865,
0.04259152710437775,
0.02244870364665985,
0.014923011884093285,
0.0451996736228466,
-0.021597890183329582,
-0.015932871028780937,
-0.02215520478785038,
0.02032400667667389,
0.026064971461892128,
0.0034327469766139984,
-0.07744293659925461,
-0.0010857933666557074,
-0.07381609082221985,
0.012131779454648495,
0.042139243334531784,
0.017132770270109177,
-0.0244124885648489,
-0.048178914934396744,
-0.00747100543230772,
-0.009518596343696117,
-0.01179385557770729,
0.013642555102705956,
0.027903122827410698,
-0.03366371989250183,
-0.016517864540219307,
0.0479818657040596,
0.00320651032961905,
0.05420022830367088,
0.013692257925868034,
0.05622250586748123,
-0.010356996208429337,
-0.0006567692034877837,
0.00872008316218853,
0.02200235240161419,
-0.02447069063782692,
-0.05728757753968239,
-0.03429395705461502,
0.00000189836748631933,
0.05763193964958191,
0.043693941086530685,
-0.056791264563798904,
0.046857550740242004,
-0.003423703135922551,
-0.03369520977139473,
0.02462974190711975,
-0.019442453980445862,
-0.03254543989896774,
0.041010987013578415,
-0.00023596083337906748,
-0.013647413812577724,
0.018525321036577225,
-0.02260134369134903,
-0.002554256934672594,
-0.03559519350528717,
-0.04310654103755951,
0.10125143080949783,
0.012302848510444164,
-0.0070389918982982635,
0.0538005456328392,
0.013746295124292374,
0.028482304885983467,
0.03839347884058952,
0.03791113570332527,
0.0028356225229799747,
0.02522268332540989,
-0.024100756272673607,
-0.011148391291499138,
-0.002687038155272603,
0.05522671341896057,
-0.011990024708211422,
0.008863028138875961,
0.01520599890500307,
-0.018504193052649498,
-0.008168580941855907,
0.0413239449262619,
-0.0013642475241795182,
-0.04853425174951553,
0.0031087794341146946,
-0.014136048033833504,
0.011849358677864075,
0.011069320142269135,
0.07083586603403091,
0.00023178241099230945,
-0.022122716531157494,
0.009367592632770538,
-0.018827388063073158,
-0.0015200348570942879,
-0.09973626583814621,
-0.002575033577159047,
0.03147756680846214,
0.019103383645415306,
-0.03552374243736267,
0.03403529152274132,
-0.0015573407290503383,
0.00349472276866436,
-0.05826090648770332,
0.015173712745308876,
0.020584749057888985,
-0.000004755370355269406,
0.02644362673163414,
0.042598068714141846,
-0.013195577077567577,
0.001328120706602931,
-0.01038314774632454,
0.010002372786402702,
-0.0159405916929245,
0.03513399139046669,
0.001061854651197791,
-0.011671592481434345,
-0.05162116885185242,
0.023727556690573692,
-0.004237756598740816,
-0.0020000438671559095,
0.03282555937767029,
0.009709611535072327,
-0.0026547873858362436,
-0.010558546520769596,
-0.043551456183195114,
0.037029482424259186,
0.0427386537194252,
0.001974764745682478,
-0.003151568118482828,
-0.028206180781126022,
-0.03272610530257225,
0.003233191557228565,
0.019090283662080765,
0.0075438120402395725,
-0.03756313771009445,
-0.040628910064697266,
-0.06186540424823761,
0.019063230603933334,
-0.007816308178007603,
-0.026856843382120132,
-0.0618358850479126,
0.005076921079307795,
0.010139376856386662,
-0.037457190454006195,
-0.04182510823011398,
-0.012358094565570354,
-0.007064126431941986,
-0.032049912959337234,
0.029050525277853012,
0.022488342598080635,
-0.04861243814229965,
0.00008297406748170033,
-0.000177913490915671,
0.020926877856254578,
0.044966645538806915,
0.0202486515045166,
0.027668926864862442,
0.046576015651226044,
0.0038445640821009874,
0.020569678395986557,
-0.009721878916025162,
0.030985485762357712,
0.018458636477589607,
-0.03776272013783455,
0.05028917267918587,
0.004426112864166498,
0.023035505786538124,
-0.0038587143644690514,
0.02003001980483532,
-0.02610241435468197,
0.04262208938598633,
-0.03685157746076584,
0.011151335202157497,
-0.014309695921838284,
-0.031190041452646255,
-0.008963328786194324,
0.005119458772242069,
0.008511243388056755,
-0.03370290249586105,
-0.01535061001777649,
0.006555262021720409,
-0.010981235653162003,
-0.08239535987377167,
-0.017283855006098747,
0.0056377798318862915,
0.01842753030359745,
0.007719825021922588,
-0.005935273133218288,
-0.021580679342150688,
0.02634798176586628,
0.04292413592338562,
0.027885425835847855,
0.023301023989915848,
-0.017449939623475075,
-0.0013941798824816942,
-0.05811777710914612,
0.029604893177747726,
-0.030290665104985237,
-0.0415334478020668,
-0.006926504895091057,
-0.017811527475714684,
-0.04241717606782913,
0.020538603886961937,
0.012245852500200272,
-0.02388903871178627,
0.00324314390309155,
0.004548468627035618,
0.011741962283849716,
-0.012586472555994987,
0.062405284494161606,
-0.020488815382122993,
0.020106522366404533,
-0.1119060292840004,
0.0735401138663292,
0.0018086510244756937,
0.017787540331482887,
0.00749796349555254,
0.0033780585508793592,
0.012773631140589714,
0.02640676312148571,
0.03444691747426987,
0.0036025773733854294,
0.0042611681856215,
-0.01574430800974369,
-0.017236435785889626,
0.034509479999542236,
0.011296982876956463,
0.04723332077264786,
0.037426240742206573,
0.04543076083064079,
0.017970850691199303,
-0.0014746099477633834,
0.014043503440916538,
0.029895098879933357,
-0.0029900858644396067,
0.011283059604465961,
0.01345960982143879,
0.039466191083192825,
-0.0360843762755394,
0.04250101372599602,
0.024498363956809044,
0.046216223388910294,
-0.005926693323999643,
0.0020004657562822104,
0.008516840636730194,
-0.021559974178671837,
0.005218650214374065,
0.032060906291007996,
0.005558905191719532,
-0.028576936572790146,
0.015582330524921417,
-0.006519672926515341,
-0.03681245446205139,
-0.03262794390320778,
0.008795616216957569,
0.018040303140878677,
-0.020916946232318878,
0.009966014884412289,
0.0015123701887205243,
0.014503153041005135,
0.006268233060836792,
-0.022113056853413582,
0.02054186724126339,
-0.049457501620054245,
0.013311333954334259,
-0.14497575163841248,
-0.036281947046518326,
0.011068091727793217,
0.003380086272954941,
-0.0724218562245369,
-0.013545684516429901,
-0.06954870373010635,
0.011278336867690086,
-0.0175822414457798,
-0.02117486298084259,
-0.0033179332967847586,
-0.011850330047309399,
0.015907468274235725,
-0.03313509747385979,
-0.05726755037903786,
0.03719593212008476,
0.0007441363413818181,
-0.04677708074450493,
-0.03529469668865204,
0.057737868279218674,
-0.030978254973888397,
0.009128949604928493,
0.018611827865242958,
-0.007980536669492722,
-0.06184341385960579,
-0.03551216423511505,
-0.07743247598409653,
-0.026550956070423126,
-0.042459502816200256,
-0.01265756506472826,
-0.0002599444705992937,
-0.06608343124389648,
0.013786928728222847,
0.03496867045760155,
0.004416662734001875,
-0.03585962951183319,
-0.007101733703166246,
0.00013452782877720892,
-0.032157063484191895,
0.006843555718660355,
-0.004153487738221884,
0.03484785929322243,
-0.012339026667177677,
-0.01250381674617529,
-0.0026367877144366503,
0.04662467539310455,
-0.023205989971756935,
0.01572120562195778,
-0.026254503056406975,
-0.03348178043961525,
-0.023111354559659958,
0.045279134064912796,
-0.020743591710925102,
0.044598065316677094,
-0.0071131582371890545,
0.034905508160591125,
-0.00834997370839119,
-0.03684747591614723,
-0.009717659093439579,
0.05222930386662483,
-0.006000836379826069,
-0.027286602184176445,
-0.05263293907046318,
-0.024329574778676033,
0.0126644317060709,
0.011789918877184391,
-0.03762172535061836,
0.0314568430185318,
-0.0033609599340707064,
0.002909882925450802,
-0.03185831755399704,
-0.03484640270471573,
0.02252073585987091,
0.011982861906290054,
-0.001367146149277687,
0.048530131578445435,
-0.01022450439631939,
0.015229054726660252,
-0.008610047399997711,
0.013790580444037914,
-0.01970819942653179,
0.01599585823714733,
-0.04089697077870369,
-0.006730004213750362,
0.03946303203701973,
0.01167756225913763,
0.015307025983929634,
-0.007824714295566082,
0.025449927896261215,
-0.02463463880121708,
-0.07571355998516083,
-0.01844066195189953,
-0.023456014692783356,
0.01050810981541872,
-0.019073279574513435,
0.018936768174171448,
-0.006886267568916082,
-0.02088899537920952,
-0.028937362134456635,
-0.01824575662612915,
-0.010882008820772171,
-0.020970134064555168,
0.06038254499435425,
-0.027498628944158554,
-0.03420977666974068,
0.0361362062394619,
0.0037781349383294582,
-0.007480534724891186,
0.007673979736864567,
0.01782352477312088,
-0.013140219263732433,
-0.021119803190231323,
-0.06844610720872879,
-0.017904674634337425,
-0.003020503558218479,
0.03952429071068764,
0.009935017675161362,
0.023468172177672386,
0.019952353090047836,
0.030715269967913628,
-0.01467613223940134,
-0.04339217767119408,
0.03686753660440445,
-0.02606126293540001,
-0.04392191022634506,
0.04345151409506798,
0.05756846070289612,
-0.026285594329237938,
0.004371114540845156,
-0.01530028972774744,
0.025218550115823746,
-0.027299921959638596,
-0.007453249767422676,
0.013019409030675888,
-0.012695709243416786,
0.02439558319747448,
-0.03241131454706192,
0.019439492374658585,
-0.005770884454250336,
-0.037547480314970016,
0.007523020729422569,
-0.04921538382768631,
-0.0016464749351143837,
-0.012709615752100945,
-0.034170184284448624,
0.00015731067105662078,
0.028750361874699593,
0.011578688398003578,
-0.034538302570581436,
-0.024835661053657532,
-0.04655202478170395,
0.00607665441930294,
0.0330049991607666,
0.053786151111125946,
0.024420814588665962,
-0.06029467284679413,
0.005764339584857225,
0.02356996014714241,
0.03653397411108017,
0.05760793387889862,
0.02621048130095005,
-0.04835169017314911,
-0.04927656054496765,
-0.02797282300889492,
-0.05801280215382576,
0.04424690827727318,
0.008280811831355095,
0.012002910487353802,
-0.050937291234731674,
0.0004067464906256646,
0.004030246753245592,
-0.028652241453528404,
-0.033638160675764084,
-0.02546885423362255,
-0.012238029390573502,
-0.041857585310935974,
-0.002625439316034317,
-0.0032634136732667685,
-0.0052116625010967255,
-0.04888416826725006,
0.0298981461673975,
0.007666098885238171,
0.006551850121468306,
0.017727667465806007,
0.009129159152507782,
0.04423021897673607,
0.03426586464047432,
-0.01476193591952324,
-0.003176406491547823,
-0.03832003474235535,
-0.023688096553087234,
-0.02868645265698433,
0.01699773408472538,
-0.0480126328766346,
0.04214771091938019,
-0.0286752600222826,
-0.030365191400051117,
-0.01658916473388672,
0.01584172435104847,
0.023163702338933945,
0.014903491362929344,
0.0033329373691231012,
-0.015260690823197365,
-0.013344570994377136,
-0.04566270112991333,
0.00412875646725297,
0.008640595711767673,
-0.03277091681957245,
0.0038083097897469997,
0.0684138610959053,
-0.010815427638590336,
-0.038979776203632355,
0.01999458111822605,
0.022891195490956306,
-0.0007284223684109747,
0.00615136232227087,
-0.0036980812437832355,
0.014869345352053642,
-0.005045120604336262,
-0.015609451569616795,
0.054421208798885345,
0.059951625764369965,
-0.016391990706324577,
-0.055693719536066055,
-0.0015465255128219724,
0.0035668369382619858,
0.0027874973602592945,
0.02487882971763611,
-0.009682007133960724,
0.021256035193800926,
-0.0016670487821102142,
-0.003967763390392065,
-0.021049823611974716,
0.017239123582839966,
0.009393337182700634,
-0.03511884808540344,
-0.02489784173667431,
-0.023554602637887,
-0.051613226532936096,
0.014654824510216713,
0.0565401129424572,
-0.02116774581372738,
0.006196725182235241,
-0.018705641850829124
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:13
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
So it was economic stress, the fear of bankruptcy?
Answer:
Absolutely.
71The transcript at T687 illustrates the $30 million lottery win was 10/11 August 2010. The plaintiff's current wife, Ms Borrett, had her last day at Janmel on 19 August 2010. On 31 August 2010 the plaintiff's solicitor was no longer acting (lines 1 - 10) and after 27 August 2010 the plaintiff was self represented.
72On 30 September 2010 the plaintiff sent an email to Marco Williams of AR Conolly & Company, the defendant's solicitors. T689 shows the 30 September email was sent "around a week maybe less than or maybe more than the days on which Shane and Trevor's contracts for their new homes were accepted" - line 5. The plaintiff agreed he said in this 30 September email to AR Conolly:-
I do not have the funds or the borrowing capacity to meet those obligations and therefore the bank would take possession of the house at ............... which they would hold as security to cover their money.
If I can be so bold as to say I believe the tactics of your client was to beat me into submission by running me out of money through these proceedings. Well it now appears that your client's tactics have been successful. Perhaps a little too successful for her own good.
T689, line 47:-
That's what I wrote yes.
73At T690, lines 5 - 10 the plaintiff denied that he was pretending to go bankrupt or that he set out to deceive the opposing lawyers by pretending that he could not afford a lawyer and was about to go into bankruptcy.
At T692, line 7:-
Question: Mr Cooper I take it that you hotly deny any proposition at all that you were anxious about the other side finding out about your spouse's lotto win. You deny any anxiety about that do you?
Answer: Of course I do not deny that.
74It was submitted in light of the plaintiff's admission that he is entitled to half of the $30 million lottery proceeds, that it is an available finding, and the Court would come to the conclusion,
that the purpose of approaching AR Conolly and suggesting he was going bankrupt was to disguise the fact that he had funds available to him and that the matters set out in the email were no more than a pretence and set out to deceive.
75The plaintiff referred to his evidence at T691:
Q. That it was her proposal that it be only in her name?
A. Mr Williams, the house--
Q. Is that what you tell his Honour?
A. I'm telling you the house at Coffs Harbour was bought by Miss Borrett with her money because, when she won the Lotto, she refused to - after a couple of days - this didn't happen on the first day - after a couple of days the realisation came to her that I was in a fair sort of a mess with this case.
It looked very much like I was going to run out of funds before it even looked like coming to a conclusion.
Q. Yes?
A. She had been harassed and intimidated by the defendant's son at our
home. She felt that if the knowledge of $30 million and that she was still living there - she wanted to get away. She wanted to go to Coffs Harbour. So, she went down there. I helped her in looking for the properties, or at properties. She bought a home in her own name and she said to me:
"I'm sorry, until you get through this mess, we are not going to be in
a de facto relationship, because this woman will do anything to get
her hands on this money."
76At 692 the following occurred:
Q. Mr Cooper, I take it that you hotly deny any proposition at all that you were anxious about the other side finding out about your spouse's Lotto win. You deny any anxiety about that, do you?
A. Of course I do not deny that. What I am saying to you is my greater anxiety was the fact that I was up to my armpits in trying to deal with this mess.
My then partner, who had $30 million - and we both read the pre-nup agreement and it seemed to us that money didn't come into play; it was to do with joint accounts and property. And I'm saying to myself: Well, this is handy. I can't even fund the case I'm in.
|
[
-0.04564462974667549,
0.02972523681819439,
-0.03600557520985603,
-0.027108440175652504,
-0.0021582376211881638,
-0.029754361137747765,
-0.011552843265235424,
0.00011893942428287119,
0.016140401363372803,
-0.04140341654419899,
0.0086650550365448,
0.07782700657844543,
-0.038643352687358856,
-0.04013543576002121,
-0.03545287624001503,
0.03484233841300011,
0.027463093400001526,
-0.03202909976243973,
-0.036118607968091965,
-0.020370570942759514,
-0.04517655447125435,
-0.030698195099830627,
0.03714732825756073,
-0.007915990427136421,
-0.01954912580549717,
0.04875057563185692,
-0.03945950046181679,
0.039023056626319885,
0.010499658063054085,
0.01829751394689083,
-0.0030485927127301693,
0.01499057374894619,
0.005658281035721302,
-0.025302382186055183,
-0.004498274996876717,
0.004090720321983099,
0.016956349834799767,
0.016663558781147003,
-0.02620176412165165,
0.03414253145456314,
0.014653260819613934,
0.008470428176224232,
0.013162173330783844,
-0.04059813916683197,
0.054321400821208954,
-0.019692283123731613,
-0.012411580421030521,
-0.006867250893265009,
0.005432078614830971,
0.014139984734356403,
-0.002632117597386241,
-0.007009256165474653,
0.03381220996379852,
0.012786583974957466,
0.013846447691321373,
0.03493393957614899,
-0.005303387530148029,
-0.007917181588709354,
-0.023808786645531654,
-0.009657320566475391,
-0.0016359856817871332,
-0.04687758535146713,
-0.00936497189104557,
-0.020823512226343155,
0.013126975856721401,
0.11555545777082443,
-0.003917823079973459,
-0.004427414853125811,
-0.006461984943598509,
-0.007550206501036882,
-0.020543741062283516,
0.001968302996829152,
-0.010077884420752525,
-0.027133269235491753,
-0.1195395439863205,
0.009450332261621952,
0.04153507947921753,
0.021872112527489662,
-0.013637306168675423,
0.056395161896944046,
0.05122876167297363,
-0.004609463736414909,
0.016429508104920387,
0.05051468312740326,
-0.009932936169207096,
0.00630503473803401,
-0.024762015789747238,
-0.0062436871230602264,
-0.02593839168548584,
-0.01832108199596405,
-0.05264835059642792,
-0.009494414553046227,
0.03454296290874481,
-0.06109628081321716,
-0.025543170049786568,
-0.04252146929502487,
-0.0669705793261528,
-0.03180786594748497,
0.0020202072337269783,
0.012506823055446148,
0.04471760243177414,
0.026373999193310738,
0.020611699670553207,
-0.008019858039915562,
-0.01623273454606533,
-0.0017086146399378777,
0.04125857353210449,
0.03927168995141983,
0.04103349149227142,
0.01321850623935461,
0.021794483065605164,
0.02307807095348835,
0.029323533177375793,
0.03895208612084389,
-0.012399427592754364,
-0.009666439145803452,
0.006210357416421175,
-0.010177561081945896,
-0.0035464726388454437,
-0.0021097036078572273,
-0.0007460898486897349,
0.0413970947265625,
0.02090616524219513,
0.014433574862778187,
-0.040170855820178986,
0.028716782107949257,
-0.04980102553963661,
0.000798961496911943,
-0.032440029084682465,
0.020093465223908424,
0.012541274540126324,
-0.013557887636125088,
-0.0014254078269004822,
-0.05131959170103073,
-0.014358701184391975,
0.01637515239417553,
0.06671802699565887,
0.026212530210614204,
0.040676698088645935,
-0.0008789401035755873,
0.03033299185335636,
0.017946487292647362,
-0.018031340092420578,
-0.012900692410767078,
0.033988699316978455,
-0.04298511520028114,
0.028197316452860832,
0.007214061915874481,
-0.02203855849802494,
-0.008214599452912807,
0.0038665488827973604,
-0.005641158204525709,
-0.007180926389992237,
-0.0049521890468895435,
0.03173906356096268,
-0.02242368459701538,
0.022456495091319084,
-0.028097879141569138,
0.0038187578320503235,
0.03529489412903786,
0.001252267393283546,
-0.01399553008377552,
-0.04761751368641853,
-0.026094360277056694,
-0.028310444205999374,
0.012324163690209389,
-0.0013058921322226524,
0.027842041105031967,
-0.014015763998031616,
0.012267271988093853,
0.013457131572067738,
-0.06614653021097183,
0.025725774466991425,
-0.04095502197742462,
0.02495848946273327,
0.038896020501852036,
0.08325497806072235,
0.011284739710390568,
0.012783837504684925,
-0.06094830110669136,
-0.024211127310991287,
0.03857580944895744,
0.0041319685988128185,
-0.027185197919607162,
-0.009954241104424,
0.020690113306045532,
-0.025392815470695496,
-0.053963180631399155,
0.04863359406590462,
-0.002149815671145916,
-0.029527168720960617,
-0.02662692219018936,
0.021180955693125725,
-0.01853015087544918,
0.06271940469741821,
-0.04229256138205528,
-0.02270643413066864,
-0.06005174666643143,
-0.015619076788425446,
-0.006717958487570286,
-0.035620830953121185,
0.0200516190379858,
0.027961822226643562,
0.022595982998609543,
-0.04022366553544998,
0.017098447307944298,
-0.05708923563361168,
-0.019191769883036613,
0.018925808370113373,
-0.037522703409194946,
0.004802958574146032,
0.016665153205394745,
0.013192562386393547,
0.018089458346366882,
0.0025940174236893654,
-0.02075936086475849,
0.005417337641119957,
-0.011883527040481567,
0.02697145566344261,
-0.0221147071570158,
-0.008775345981121063,
0.021993113681674004,
-0.0004317191487643868,
-0.013469568453729153,
0.05943058058619499,
0.033633146435022354,
-0.00835499819368124,
0.04475131630897522,
-0.019291257485747337,
-0.051575012505054474,
0.019110482186079025,
-0.005107116419821978,
-0.003532682079821825,
-0.02077203243970871,
0.03496868908405304,
-0.017003096640110016,
0.0035568750463426113,
0.0068877809680998325,
0.013561946339905262,
0.010091321542859077,
-0.008971179835498333,
-0.00987932924181223,
0.01668698899447918,
0.004846061579883099,
-0.012898898683488369,
0.009886648505926132,
0.03185679763555527,
-0.002651020186021924,
0.007661575451493263,
0.00005409072036854923,
-0.016006048768758774,
-0.011248396709561348,
0.029182566329836845,
-0.0035389927215874195,
-0.0045492141507565975,
0.01917514018714428,
-0.0214756578207016,
-0.006448301952332258,
0.05825500562787056,
0.01180165447294712,
0.04803435876965523,
0.023921538144350052,
0.030338818207383156,
0.0020891637541353703,
-0.007826196029782295,
-0.0231182798743248,
-0.04543021693825722,
-0.016396740451455116,
0.01369546726346016,
0.04453529790043831,
0.015604685992002487,
-0.03802086040377617,
0.023533493280410767,
-0.037474293261766434,
0.009417515248060226,
0.008864359930157661,
-0.00042639317689463496,
-0.0420723557472229,
-0.008854194544255733,
-0.020665040239691734,
0.037501346319913864,
-0.00587806710973382,
-0.01723150536417961,
0.010478096082806587,
0.03863975405693054,
0.02580949105322361,
0.031097549945116043,
0.02650778368115425,
0.02521486207842827,
-0.05543957278132439,
-0.015998026356101036,
-0.04580404981970787,
0.0656697228550911,
-0.011419922113418579,
-0.047538433223962784,
-0.03979898616671562,
-0.007743638474494219,
-0.16993962228298187,
-0.0025358619168400764,
0.026867564767599106,
0.004509728867560625,
0.0007204886642284691,
0.055184490978717804,
-0.03155232220888138,
0.02212446928024292,
-0.008579520508646965,
0.014668386429548264,
0.03614375367760658,
-0.05668387934565544,
0.03718416765332222,
0.055758778005838394,
-0.027703452855348587,
-0.011447105556726456,
-0.000855923630297184,
0.0011765066301450133,
0.0059538003988564014,
-0.022779196500778198,
0.007481738924980164,
-0.014779198914766312,
0.03217879310250282,
-0.027358053252100945,
0.010604080744087696,
0.005757420789450407,
0.008722522296011448,
-0.02026613987982273,
-0.03463248535990715,
0.018533950671553612,
0.03057614341378212,
0.017721308395266533,
-0.012106632813811302,
0.016347840428352356,
0.0016302597941830754,
0.030299274250864983,
0.03342169523239136,
-0.03724457323551178,
-0.005654177162796259,
-0.05461020767688751,
0.023625846952199936,
0.005303849000483751,
-0.04483679309487343,
0.007299747318029404,
0.019612407311797142,
-0.09100869297981262,
-0.0063188159838318825,
-0.01089159119874239,
-0.02256685495376587,
0.006248072255402803,
-0.0602412112057209,
-0.01677762344479561,
-0.032840125262737274,
-0.013620310463011265,
-0.0034626410342752934,
0.004384813364595175,
0.021008364856243134,
0.05789453536272049,
-0.03763758763670921,
-0.004923093598335981,
-0.03845497593283653,
-0.056113388389348984,
0.02927597239613533,
0.021212201565504074,
-0.005868202541023493,
0.016151882708072662,
-0.02542010508477688,
0.01747024618089199,
0.008418617770075798,
0.0211159810423851,
0.022982250899076462,
-0.02138548344373703,
0.035644907504320145,
-0.003957872744649649,
-0.008225168101489544,
0.053735386580228806,
-0.006456976290792227,
0.019538680091500282,
0.013364939019083977,
-0.11507285386323929,
0.0003293416812084615,
0.001136964070610702,
0.00957317091524601,
0.02277132123708725,
-0.012557027861475945,
0.010302156209945679,
0.027152512222528458,
-0.004036236554384232,
0.014445739798247814,
0.21554015576839447,
0.04425511881709099,
-0.0063242739997804165,
0.04659103602170944,
0.023309729993343353,
-0.0009501440217718482,
0.02520810440182686,
0.017437484115362167,
0.009229599498212337,
-0.03920947387814522,
-0.021127969026565552,
0.053940411657094955,
0.013110938481986523,
0.020107094198465347,
-0.06808453798294067,
0.036224402487277985,
-0.052269112318754196,
-0.0006366550805978477,
0.05143749341368675,
0.012695597484707832,
0.009620137512683868,
-0.010835355147719383,
0.023948844522237778,
0.017379995435476303,
-0.046006105840206146,
-0.05906642973423004,
0.02272808365523815,
0.05980108678340912,
-0.013341107405722141,
0.05570374056696892,
-0.04312805086374283,
0.001619216869585216,
0.017472511157393456,
0.0058634327724576,
0.03033965267241001,
0.01337353140115738,
0.0026840302161872387,
-0.0019505869131535292,
-0.09076827764511108,
0.027575140818953514,
0.008254129439592361,
-0.013086771592497826,
-0.03935127705335617,
-0.0317511223256588,
-0.035972148180007935,
0.01698492094874382,
0.002033793367445469,
0.0546327568590641,
-0.0435553714632988,
0.009071431122720242,
0.0032496487256139517,
0.010571626015007496,
-0.054740119725465775,
0.007956926710903645,
-0.01759505458176136,
0.03328711912035942,
0.034901101142168045,
0.016376912593841553,
0.0018628198886290193,
0.0680873766541481,
-0.0018370968755334616,
0.05188242346048355,
-0.05274657905101776,
-0.02050172910094261,
-0.0091151874512434,
-0.0027542493771761656,
-0.023440903052687645,
-0.028557121753692627,
0.03155488148331642,
-0.00010414086136734113,
0.03367387875914574,
-0.006978979334235191,
0.0025433532427996397,
0.025201307609677315,
-0.019155941903591156,
-0.009720399044454098,
-0.006634917110204697,
0.027449963614344597,
0.00684475339949131,
0.022705495357513428,
0.02525520510971546,
-0.018825769424438477,
-0.00752205541357398,
0.03752271831035614,
0.017901362851262093,
0.005767849739640951,
-0.009457064792513847,
0.0647386983036995,
0.018484031781554222,
-0.005536671727895737,
-0.02213197574019432,
-0.023070381954312325,
-0.035134848207235336,
-0.002786151133477688,
0.018849719315767288,
-0.037277448922395706,
0.0300225131213665,
-0.02786371111869812,
0.01749160885810852,
-0.019591733813285828,
0.015610966831445694,
0.007509000599384308,
0.029806671664118767,
-0.04294189438223839,
0.036008067429065704,
0.007061141077429056,
-0.020617719739675522,
-0.039131879806518555,
-0.050418492406606674,
-0.020785300061106682,
-0.029022131115198135,
-0.003033301793038845,
0.015720756724476814,
-0.009470638819038868,
0.030442245304584503,
0.0547976940870285,
-0.07117956876754761,
0.05292182415723801,
0.05473656207323074,
0.020883454009890556,
-0.008597946725785732,
-0.03967583552002907,
-0.022837605327367783,
-0.012972303666174412,
-0.022275887429714203,
-0.017084550112485886,
0.051510680466890335,
-0.009588218294084072,
0.0004770990926772356,
-0.009500901214778423,
-0.058658238500356674,
-0.0021762812975794077,
-0.01799948140978813,
-0.03524572029709816,
0.03303905576467514,
0.002509291050955653,
0.02522442862391472,
0.04515876993536949,
-0.0430334098637104,
-0.0045611560344696045,
0.02751697041094303,
-0.006651970092207193,
-0.0005972976796329021,
0.016356639564037323,
0.00406715739518404,
0.02698805369436741,
-0.07400340586900711,
-0.001352364313788712,
-0.018467094749212265,
0.024990791454911232,
0.030415663495659828,
-0.007535761222243309,
-0.023542972281575203,
-0.009684039279818535,
0.048761021345853806,
-0.014974101446568966,
-0.007815053686499596,
0.012483666650950909,
-0.009740229696035385,
-0.02654073014855385,
0.03040900081396103,
0.03150706738233566,
-0.018046606332063675,
0.08297549933195114,
0.01112543698400259,
-0.012225735001266003,
0.013166282325983047,
0.02894657477736473,
0.03362935408949852,
-0.03105193004012108,
-0.03809701278805733,
-0.030098138377070427,
-0.022824326530098915,
-0.00586727587506175,
0.04142586886882782,
0.025682982057332993,
0.020571207627654076,
0.019682003185153008,
-0.03791689872741699,
-0.04945129156112671,
0.005551529116928577,
0.03419094532728195,
-0.0441000871360302,
0.057702843099832535,
-0.018697412684559822,
-0.01867937296628952,
0.054908085614442825,
-0.0003459503932390362,
-0.0033164313063025475,
-0.03959568962454796,
-0.02292822301387787,
0.08147971332073212,
-0.008025758899748325,
-0.006192981731146574,
0.01673547364771366,
0.05115596950054169,
-0.03523997217416763,
0.05267396941781044,
-0.00038952656905166805,
-0.013597862794995308,
0.030714528635144234,
0.02578117698431015,
0.013526428490877151,
0.06655177474021912,
-0.007170362863689661,
-0.06587956845760345,
-0.03224053978919983,
0.029964499175548553,
-0.012970207259058952,
-0.03913766145706177,
-0.015043037943542004,
0.0077808150090277195,
-0.009933301247656345,
-0.00436505489051342,
0.005774251651018858,
0.00046755350194871426,
0.024372434243559837,
0.0003967332886531949,
-0.02015184424817562,
-0.031356774270534515,
0.0037417409475892782,
-0.018062276765704155,
0.014484954997897148,
-0.07664434611797333,
-0.026720363646745682,
-0.009263236075639725,
-0.06561443954706192,
-0.06674271821975708,
-0.026053763926029205,
-0.006044216454029083,
0.002694091759622097,
-0.048771996051073074,
0.011487572453916073,
-0.007228350266814232,
-0.011975306086242199,
0.00914223026484251,
0.014725200831890106,
0.03537667170166969,
-0.003936690278351307,
0.027601221576333046,
0.009645242244005203,
-0.037006646394729614,
0.06415069103240967,
0.04696373641490936,
-0.029206179082393646,
0.02705971710383892,
-0.038488902151584625,
-0.05046139657497406,
0.014717096462845802,
0.037228748202323914,
-0.0005410081357695162,
0.03729359433054924,
0.03577732294797897,
0.006152348127216101,
-0.003020669799298048,
0.022379349917173386,
0.019179191440343857,
0.026156893000006676,
0.010969971306622028,
-0.018529776483774185,
0.031055517494678497,
0.019759194925427437,
-0.00629849499091506,
-0.029345782473683357,
-0.030536126345396042,
-0.059430260211229324,
0.028458930552005768,
0.022348817437887192,
-0.027962297201156616,
-0.040047794580459595,
-0.025127774104475975,
-0.01997591182589531,
-0.03990544006228447,
-0.010460326448082924,
0.014855450950562954,
0.011392581276595592,
-0.0174013189971447,
0.021715523675084114,
0.018652603030204773,
0.00672386446967721,
0.00276376586407423,
0.011418195441365242,
-0.009299898520112038,
0.022491494193673134,
0.001688192249275744,
0.027812534943223,
0.06393177062273026,
-0.019395915791392326,
-0.014061127789318562,
-0.009455641731619835,
0.011698207817971706,
-0.003289182437583804,
-0.027479641139507294,
0.017442215234041214,
0.007284337654709816,
-0.012087654322385788,
-0.00843774899840355,
0.08782266825437546,
-0.007028127554804087,
0.02846638485789299,
-0.010062898509204388,
0.018046315759420395,
-0.041440028697252274,
-0.007845519110560417,
-0.03381297364830971,
0.016199477016925812,
0.007854009978473186,
0.004952828865498304,
-0.024206506088376045,
0.006202834192663431,
0.017886200919747353,
-0.09082242101430893,
-0.006907545030117035,
-0.024392785504460335,
-0.010947183705866337,
-0.007415644824504852,
0.07478328794240952,
0.025717241689562798,
0.007611617911607027,
-0.015570522285997868,
0.04460391029715538,
0.015315725468099117,
-0.05772506818175316,
-0.0417676642537117,
-0.047209858894348145,
0.015417445451021194,
-0.025185951963067055,
-0.040612876415252686,
-0.01969953067600727,
-0.019222505390644073,
-0.04474445432424545,
-0.012411605566740036,
-0.01204739511013031,
0.014718789607286453,
-0.012129688635468483,
0.015923157334327698,
0.013586180284619331,
-0.006958281621336937,
0.027735821902751923,
-0.05499867722392082,
0.0010856250301003456,
-0.03473091498017311,
0.05312307924032211,
-0.02576441504061222,
0.003715161932632327,
0.018148386850953102,
-0.012276914902031422,
-0.009755482897162437,
0.0011865419801324606,
-0.0022822879254817963,
0.008414098992943764,
0.0037915806751698256,
-0.039399199187755585,
-0.05425552278757095,
0.0778127908706665,
0.019172387197613716,
0.02928883209824562,
-0.004762071650475264,
0.010566430166363716,
-0.00864870660007,
-0.017903750762343407,
0.022944476455450058,
0.025768233463168144,
-0.03907472640275955,
-0.005090188700705767,
0.034590065479278564,
-0.032534096390008926,
0.04973481595516205,
0.003447914030402899,
-0.02899111621081829,
-0.0014242914039641619,
0.005126264411956072,
0.024580787867307663,
0.019280094653367996,
-0.015412046574056149,
0.04947711527347565,
0.006064109969884157,
-0.004263940267264843,
0.002610786585137248,
-0.06138237938284874,
-0.012640606611967087,
-0.006343392189592123,
-0.022852979600429535,
0.006721977610141039,
0.02748892270028591,
-0.004339942708611488,
-0.007369642145931721,
0.025458335876464844,
0.023819921538233757,
0.024593954905867577,
-0.009935998357832432,
-0.012802503071725368,
-0.03316733241081238,
-0.023325858637690544,
-0.13868513703346252,
-0.005337556824088097,
-0.012377940118312836,
0.023219773545861244,
-0.043878789991140366,
0.012972438707947731,
-0.01652274653315544,
-0.0048597888089716434,
-0.025922242552042007,
0.02708813175559044,
-0.0042229690589010715,
-0.014035874046385288,
-0.03761060908436775,
-0.029511062428355217,
0.0010185650316998363,
0.03607124462723732,
0.002201091032475233,
-0.01998385787010193,
-0.042455799877643585,
-0.0001348327932646498,
-0.02141759917140007,
0.017804965376853943,
-0.05740974470973015,
0.0363689623773098,
0.016018295660614967,
-0.03511947765946388,
-0.02254919335246086,
0.009215361438691616,
-0.03741072863340378,
0.00048009006422944367,
-0.02101784572005272,
-0.049718230962753296,
0.013366201892495155,
0.002444701734930277,
0.006988380569964647,
-0.014596028253436089,
-0.015223318710923195,
-0.017130013555288315,
-0.05246945843100548,
-0.040096260607242584,
-0.039492227137088776,
0.0364556685090065,
-0.04027650132775307,
-0.01987629197537899,
0.029449909925460815,
0.006155628245323896,
-0.006516947411000729,
0.0023817052133381367,
-0.04912223294377327,
-0.03025921806693077,
-0.01740245148539543,
0.022260934114456177,
0.009616253897547722,
0.01930863782763481,
-0.01489995140582323,
-0.024263925850391388,
-0.012326034717261791,
0.000690220040269196,
0.03572148084640503,
0.03604581579566002,
-0.015759168192744255,
-0.01841704174876213,
-0.011264903470873833,
-0.005473071709275246,
-0.0022041669581085443,
-0.004323075991123915,
-0.020863238722085953,
-0.027768081054091454,
-0.022486364468932152,
0.013047087006270885,
-0.0032732828985899687,
0.004000561311841011,
0.0434500053524971,
-0.00393947958946228,
-0.0034375316463410854,
-0.01167990081012249,
0.003662622068077326,
-0.04028979316353798,
-0.05208763852715492,
-0.026112601161003113,
-0.05469212308526039,
0.014965998008847237,
-0.010402869433164597,
-0.007028587628155947,
0.010467604734003544,
0.03240576386451721,
0.00850732997059822,
0.018969468772411346,
-0.01971527934074402,
-0.042753539979457855,
-0.060163576155900955,
0.0038967153523117304,
-0.011524771340191364,
0.03074057772755623,
-0.005393378436565399,
0.05225061997771263,
-0.026777246966958046,
-0.010519273579120636,
-0.04137137159705162,
-0.012099824845790863,
0.006593639496713877,
-0.021388981491327286,
0.01219265628606081,
-0.04635174199938774,
-0.01295863464474678,
0.009075299836695194,
0.055709294974803925,
-0.02923358604311943,
-0.004949123132973909,
0.024300264194607735,
0.006329274270683527,
0.004397760145366192,
-0.041825782507658005,
-0.018940797075629234,
-0.010872400365769863,
-0.005384988151490688,
0.0030361067038029432,
0.0390872061252594,
0.019391218200325966,
-0.0008636695565655828,
0.003032151609659195,
-0.025424154475331306,
0.003918766044080257,
0.00060052186017856,
-0.0025980703067034483,
0.0012897655833512545,
0.051134318113327026,
0.015062328428030014,
0.04726247861981392,
-0.016803937032818794,
0.06538815796375275,
-0.006949710659682751,
0.054065510630607605,
0.018718961626291275,
0.022932561114430428,
0.015135759487748146,
0.025129852816462517,
0.015869399532675743,
-0.01818149723112583,
-0.02249833010137081,
0.0367208831012249,
-0.016098039224743843,
0.02304026484489441,
-0.013242981396615505,
-0.06459241360425949,
0.0547347329556942,
0.025170795619487762,
-0.03634437173604965,
-0.04350120946764946,
-0.005285895429551601,
-0.006454347632825375,
0.0068118697963654995,
0.02869340032339096,
0.035631220787763596,
0.0400078259408474,
-0.0045075127854943275,
0.022912437096238136,
-0.06737963855266571,
0.03323528915643692,
0.04257507249712944,
-0.002793052699416876,
-0.029521722346544266,
0.011574395932257175,
-0.044244494289159775,
-0.025638721883296967,
0.03187099099159241,
-0.050675224512815475,
0.013652920722961426,
-0.027065150439739227,
-0.011363294906914234,
-0.036415837705135345,
-0.014509135857224464,
-0.011247728951275349,
0.02323887124657631,
0.012222515419125557,
-0.027342069894075394,
0.024838224053382874,
0.019190698862075806,
0.03328755870461464,
-0.01156170479953289,
0.034060318022966385,
0.019068440422415733,
0.04600241035223007,
-0.0010856257285922766,
-0.002306082984432578,
0.05884690582752228,
0.0563909187912941,
-0.006814179942011833,
-0.03048086352646351,
-0.010162541642785072,
-0.03611915558576584,
-0.027991438284516335,
0.029126491397619247,
-0.0015726430574432015,
0.07566089183092117,
0.0012224677484482527,
-0.016918247565627098,
0.0009401671122759581,
0.026753537356853485,
0.01848427578806877,
0.008737176656723022,
-0.03307276591658592,
-0.044333040714263916,
-0.003563100704923272,
0.012679400853812695,
0.011900524608790874,
0.020216410979628563,
-0.06863024830818176,
-0.024758355692029,
0.05165034532546997,
-0.024472050368785858,
0.036070842295885086,
0.020776011049747467,
-0.007122197654098272,
-0.03176458179950714,
0.02131609432399273,
0.016835268586874008,
-0.026123590767383575,
0.036779582500457764,
-0.016827672719955444,
-0.003340404247865081,
0.028188619762659073,
-0.02869243733584881,
-0.015089074149727821,
0.01864112913608551,
0.019529975950717926,
-0.015817606821656227,
-0.017584217712283134,
-0.012805643491446972,
-0.026365656405687332,
-0.04109971597790718,
-0.02366781048476696,
0.018368050456047058,
0.0664685070514679,
0.007189927157014608,
-0.03988341614603996,
-0.031344179064035416,
-0.010665951296687126,
-0.04034370929002762,
-0.010446795262396336,
-0.012000692076981068,
-0.013298813253641129,
-0.0061739063821733,
-0.053501442074775696
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:36
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
195However, his Honour propounded his agreement with Hodgson JA in Howlett v Neilson in relation to the notions which underline the "erosion principle":
"[48] The initial contributions made by parties to a de facto relationship may often take the form of a family home or other assets in the form of immovable property. During the course of the relationship, property may be acquired and registered in the name of one of the parties, alone.
The duration of the relationship and the significance of the respective contributions of the parties may lead to a court adjusting the parties' interests in such a way that the party who provides such property (or the party who is the registered owner) receives substantially less than the full value of that property when the relationship is terminated.
[49] The adjusting order may require the party making the initial contribution (or the party who is the registered owner) to pay the other party a sum of money that represents a proportion of the increase in the capital value of the property concerned or, indeed, its overall value.
Hodgson JA emphasised the latter possibility in Howlett v Neilson when he said (at 410 [35]): "[I]t is plainly not the case that the contributions of the parties should be considered as making it just and equitable that there be an order only concerning increases in the value of assets over and above initial contributions". (Emphasis added)
196The erosion principle has been discussed in a number of recent cases. In Wendt v Wood [2011] NSWSC 781 Slattery said:
"[98] In the course of final submissions, counsel...referred me to the so-called " erosion principle".
Indeed, it is not a principle of law at all but really a short hand description of the approach to the evaluation of contributions which recognises that initial contributions do not carry forward full weight but diminish in significance by reason of the other subsequent contributions made by both parties during the relationship: Sharpless v McKibbin [2007] NSWSC 1498 at [78] per Brereton J.
It is not really a question of erosion but of what weight is to be attached in all the circumstances to the initial contributions, in the context of all the contributions."
197In this case given the use by the parties of the Gaythorne property for borrowing and the benefit of successful joint property investments that flowed from that use I do not see that there is any real reason why the value of that contribution should be diminished.
198The major contribution to the assets of the parties has been their successful property developments. There were joint projects to which they both contributed to different extents as outlined above. Overall the non-financial contributions favour the plaintiff.
199Giving due weight to the contributions of Gaythorne by the defendant, I think an appropriate division is 40% to the plaintiff and 60% to the defendant. The property of the parties, with add backs is $1,605,782.
After division of this amount into these proportions and subtracting the applicable add backs, the plaintiff receives $342,313 ($642,313 less $300,000) and the defendant $542,469 ($963,469 less $421,000).
200Thereafter account should be taken of what other assets have been taken or should be retained by them. These are:
Plaintiff Defendant
Household contents $5,000 50% interest in River Road $67,500
Glassware $12,500 Art works $15,000
Janmell $236,196 Mower $3,000
Superannuation $17,000 Glassware $12,500
Total $270,696 Total $98,000
201Deducting these from each party's entitlements referred to above gives the plaintiff $71,617 ($342,313 less $270,696) and the defendant $444,469 ($542,469 less $163,000) of the remaining assets of the parties.
202The balance of the assets of the parties should be sold, debts paid and the resulting sum distributed to the parties in the proportion set out in the preceding paragraph.
|
[
-0.010695709846913815,
0.058094192296266556,
0.00616279523819685,
0.03824537247419357,
0.006899320986121893,
-0.044568467885255814,
0.027854856103658676,
0.004225265234708786,
0.01519598439335823,
-0.01488526538014412,
-0.008692401461303234,
0.01675667241215706,
-0.047452349215745926,
-0.01686899922788143,
0.016944384202361107,
0.015573396347463131,
0.004845330957323313,
-0.02737959288060665,
-0.009512328542768955,
-0.006212992127984762,
-0.019804172217845917,
0.027121899649500847,
0.039013613015413284,
0.034197937697172165,
0.021822884678840637,
0.022832734510302544,
-0.03033413365483284,
0.012053935788571835,
0.029093168675899506,
0.004712354391813278,
-0.020089223980903625,
0.015847234055399895,
0.006670794449746609,
-0.04075661301612854,
-0.00938780140131712,
-0.0005918436800129712,
0.02293371595442295,
-0.017298776656389236,
-0.01725834049284458,
0.04050322622060776,
-0.012051473371684551,
-0.013586829416453838,
-0.023758482187986374,
-0.0065333847887814045,
0.05260720103979111,
-0.010563857853412628,
-0.02643793448805809,
-0.03300248458981514,
-0.04706070199608803,
-0.024918636307120323,
-0.04958885535597801,
0.016491305083036423,
0.045711006969213486,
-0.03466339781880379,
0.026603808626532555,
0.008920220658183098,
-0.04644186049699783,
-0.016274133697152138,
-0.059456661343574524,
-0.005331750959157944,
0.009272705763578415,
0.016871975734829903,
-0.052979882806539536,
-0.04152480512857437,
-0.0030682741198688745,
0.06527835130691528,
-0.049579065293073654,
-0.007184447254985571,
-0.0154209453612566,
0.0037627494893968105,
-0.020690124481916428,
-0.01477685198187828,
0.014126480557024479,
-0.003040800802409649,
-0.060595881193876266,
0.0306607186794281,
0.000018646614989847876,
0.0419311486184597,
-0.0018030061619356275,
-0.0006615645252168179,
0.014486578293144703,
-0.03058045357465744,
-0.015070506371557713,
0.00555534940212965,
-0.07677535712718964,
0.0640575960278511,
-0.008391591720283031,
0.03013448230922222,
0.04154541715979576,
-0.03727690130472183,
-0.011231983080506325,
-0.0028120155911892653,
0.03115258552134037,
-0.03485290706157684,
0.02363968826830387,
0.03282483294606209,
-0.05647331476211548,
0.033583518117666245,
0.011644416488707066,
0.005786329973489046,
0.0034805757459253073,
-0.00827282015234232,
0.03783933073282242,
-0.03512782230973244,
0.028336934745311737,
0.00853725429624319,
0.04795869439840317,
0.026950033381581306,
0.02517637424170971,
0.0026087299920618534,
0.005865178070962429,
-0.034261539578437805,
0.024487106129527092,
0.020841827616095543,
-0.006952300202101469,
0.018703699111938477,
-0.002462162636220455,
-0.012528124265372753,
0.0011414712062105536,
-0.006329141557216644,
0.04500485956668854,
0.012448201887309551,
0.08966470509767532,
0.005558336619287729,
-0.016104262322187424,
0.0037340836133807898,
-0.023868927732110023,
0.041573479771614075,
-0.014546333812177181,
0.018205583095550537,
-0.005682460498064756,
-0.039648354053497314,
-0.016186930239200592,
-0.027434267103672028,
-0.014712680131196976,
0.027371183037757874,
0.06674767285585403,
0.007131543941795826,
0.012670770287513733,
-0.025380834937095642,
0.03005288355052471,
0.04182199388742447,
0.007646627724170685,
-0.026341376826167107,
0.03169358894228935,
0.011862089857459068,
0.0057185436598956585,
-0.019319672137498856,
0.0028058511670678854,
-0.006979208905249834,
0.011356559582054615,
0.010996222496032715,
0.02002142369747162,
-0.025130892172455788,
0.006490188650786877,
-0.048667993396520615,
0.03459244593977928,
-0.011539285071194172,
0.0015603047795593739,
0.029793981462717056,
-0.004666019231081009,
0.047511037439107895,
-0.07210652530193329,
-0.03382847458124161,
-0.0013881833292543888,
0.03479843586683273,
0.026654763147234917,
0.02411746047437191,
0.002293586963787675,
0.006663579028099775,
0.041555099189281464,
-0.016916824504733086,
0.019967328757047653,
-0.038698215037584305,
0.023584363982081413,
0.02005879580974579,
0.07293490320444107,
0.006376373581588268,
-0.0459052175283432,
-0.013021048158407211,
-0.0006826778408139944,
0.04054274037480354,
0.01945427618920803,
-0.029248923063278198,
-0.02478708326816559,
0.038301922380924225,
0.026936443522572517,
-0.02065705507993698,
0.042429499328136444,
0.019360052421689034,
-0.018991587683558464,
-0.029850559309124947,
-0.011284121312201023,
-0.001921052229590714,
0.046740371733903885,
-0.05064229294657707,
-0.0024816086515784264,
-0.014782682061195374,
0.042867209762334824,
0.00799553468823433,
-0.05645144358277321,
0.012740406207740307,
0.025933675467967987,
0.028157999739050865,
-0.04630086570978165,
0.009345648810267448,
-0.06732267141342163,
0.018542766571044922,
0.052970949560403824,
-0.023130495101213455,
0.011879543773829937,
-0.003341135336086154,
0.03855235502123833,
-0.013930763117969036,
0.013225427828729153,
0.011673565953969955,
0.03336559236049652,
-0.037592481821775436,
0.00974156055599451,
0.009646046906709671,
-0.0137207405641675,
-0.01544874720275402,
0.011356827802956104,
0.033584821969270706,
-0.001597212627530098,
0.017418568953871727,
-0.03307050094008446,
0.0006511625251732767,
0.06132625415921211,
-0.0264468751847744,
0.011472956277430058,
0.004558274056762457,
0.04835880175232887,
-0.043933626264333725,
0.04102054610848427,
-0.011964906938374043,
0.023237252607941628,
0.019619030877947807,
-0.013460610061883926,
0.0006833052029833198,
-0.01938517577946186,
-0.015861760824918747,
-0.022267166525125504,
-0.012032403610646725,
-0.003331246552988887,
-0.042171720415353775,
0.01243999321013689,
0.004199195187538862,
0.022034313529729843,
-0.026853671297430992,
0.00583607517182827,
-0.013148508034646511,
0.03608018904924393,
0.011079425923526287,
-0.00922697689384222,
0.01994205266237259,
0.013112999498844147,
-0.013615641742944717,
0.02963228151202202,
-0.05113019421696663,
0.02180180884897709,
0.009817431680858135,
0.02912367694079876,
0.012462521903216839,
0.02700614742934704,
-0.008613686077296734,
-0.03125116229057312,
-0.004467627964913845,
-0.006402797065675259,
0.026805231347680092,
0.0354139618575573,
0.007202777545899153,
0.03371722623705864,
-0.03927009180188179,
0.03958214446902275,
0.04785701259970665,
0.006893051788210869,
-0.005655176471918821,
0.005476991645991802,
-0.018023688346147537,
0.009824421256780624,
0.005708795040845871,
0.022514168173074722,
-0.016774702817201614,
-0.019519289955496788,
0.010135771706700325,
-0.009498700499534607,
-0.029500287026166916,
0.015724923461675644,
-0.03961027413606644,
0.036674853414297104,
-0.027148902416229248,
0.07673138380050659,
0.021113840863108635,
-0.11728289723396301,
-0.022643277421593666,
-0.020268207415938377,
-0.13524164259433746,
-0.0004898408078588545,
0.003003788413479924,
0.04480564594268799,
0.013399047777056694,
0.035940855741500854,
-0.06637538969516754,
0.04249001294374466,
0.010670451447367668,
0.01639053411781788,
-0.0358780175447464,
-0.07367713749408722,
-0.018268270418047905,
0.006388552952557802,
-0.017566584050655365,
-0.011126640252768993,
-0.002831768011674285,
0.0037734033539891243,
0.043065235018730164,
-0.008429543115198612,
-0.001507562818005681,
-0.024790238589048386,
0.021699000149965286,
0.017452914267778397,
0.004173900466412306,
0.030434658750891685,
0.0007901868084445596,
0.0330120287835598,
-0.015944408252835274,
-0.04987631365656853,
-0.08121074736118317,
0.007714683189988136,
-0.009660241194069386,
0.0057181851007044315,
-0.032128505408763885,
0.04428510740399361,
0.039066676050424576,
-0.07375424355268478,
-0.012982443906366825,
-0.013365235179662704,
0.0331103578209877,
0.04088573902845383,
-0.024304626509547234,
-0.010968605056405067,
-0.016192013397812843,
-0.055163200944662094,
-0.026335380971431732,
0.01335610169917345,
-0.008521834388375282,
0.05856797844171524,
-0.00810997374355793,
0.005889026913791895,
-0.05336117744445801,
-0.022579370066523552,
-0.0378151535987854,
0.0034550027921795845,
0.051132284104824066,
0.07168425619602203,
0.0031540272757411003,
0.019095974043011665,
-0.017569515854120255,
-0.016589181497693062,
0.03175053745508194,
0.01582786813378334,
-0.017894713208079338,
-0.04037003591656685,
0.01092526689171791,
-0.019062606617808342,
0.028833821415901184,
-0.028275277465581894,
0.007743821479380131,
-0.02045021578669548,
0.011935262009501457,
0.0011423883261159062,
-0.00948062352836132,
0.006942252162843943,
0.01714988611638546,
-0.028941063210368156,
0.0010098264319822192,
-0.10318918526172638,
0.019648371264338493,
-0.008804027922451496,
-0.0018232768634334207,
0.049974408000707626,
-0.01638496294617653,
0.030903704464435577,
0.04084154963493347,
-0.0011734138242900372,
0.05536893755197525,
0.23114699125289917,
-0.0024919065181165934,
0.0414266474545002,
0.05613948032259941,
-0.005260034464299679,
-0.03825489059090614,
0.0565103255212307,
0.029505116865038872,
0.003115986241027713,
-0.04693283885717392,
-0.043681465089321136,
0.05335496366024017,
0.03967401385307312,
0.02400580421090126,
-0.048683393746614456,
0.04226277023553848,
-0.03545459359884262,
-0.029538944363594055,
0.05824178829789162,
-0.013754378072917461,
0.02471240796148777,
-0.02885235846042633,
0.011574708856642246,
0.018990328535437584,
-0.05112911015748978,
0.006298008840531111,
0.014749131165444851,
0.06051306426525116,
-0.014667053706943989,
0.013958108611404896,
0.003897466929629445,
-0.011364813894033432,
0.042542118579149246,
0.02506936900317669,
0.02771736867725849,
-0.0018267068080604076,
-0.03967716917395592,
0.019666781648993492,
-0.0010412440169602633,
0.022260665893554688,
0.03526384383440018,
-0.003616929519921541,
-0.002112853806465864,
-0.03645060211420059,
0.008802816271781921,
-0.028874816372990608,
-0.00014231381646823138,
-0.01882392168045044,
-0.007529313210397959,
0.05491821840405464,
-0.05946223437786102,
0.03510559722781181,
-0.008318229578435421,
-0.0003516788419801742,
-0.040961626917123795,
0.002794858068227768,
-0.0018703013192862272,
0.050642747431993484,
-0.021664820611476898,
0.016903188079595566,
-0.0017339390469715,
-0.004630119074136019,
-0.016988229006528854,
-0.033851370215415955,
-0.006038907915353775,
-0.006448015104979277,
-0.03143327683210373,
-0.015850730240345,
0.020703837275505066,
0.009529199451208115,
-0.006035271566361189,
0.0033461994025856256,
-0.024154528975486755,
0.05942385271191597,
0.05018394812941551,
-0.006715971045196056,
-0.032568130642175674,
0.014523912221193314,
-0.012373281642794609,
-0.018293680623173714,
-0.03490251675248146,
-0.04965808615088463,
-0.000624831416644156,
-0.008545604534447193,
0.020738231018185616,
0.0004040090716443956,
-0.042370785027742386,
0.01336896512657404,
0.01432874146848917,
-0.017418913543224335,
-0.008303788490593433,
-0.049259405583143234,
-0.008700530044734478,
0.03413970768451691,
-0.004049337934702635,
0.006984492298215628,
0.03513195738196373,
0.004622176755219698,
-0.05226334184408188,
-0.0016978654311969876,
-0.015605006366968155,
0.01800449751317501,
0.028663458302617073,
-0.060341961681842804,
0.012850305996835232,
-0.04086187854409218,
-0.012600461952388287,
-0.009507179260253906,
-0.0736178308725357,
-0.04927024245262146,
0.0034858740400522947,
0.03422996401786804,
-0.002810560166835785,
0.01950441300868988,
0.04663825035095215,
0.05449258163571358,
0.005267217755317688,
0.03650391474366188,
0.029258687049150467,
0.0019185226410627365,
-0.008585437200963497,
0.027234625071287155,
-0.006822280585765839,
-0.019477691501379013,
-0.009845377877354622,
0.01270383968949318,
-0.02451200783252716,
-0.020446205511689186,
0.013104937970638275,
0.006188502069562674,
-0.001524043153040111,
-0.03763636201620102,
-0.042997587472200394,
0.005769660230726004,
0.03451023995876312,
0.00034494014107622206,
0.033808305859565735,
-0.022511525079607964,
-0.04750818386673927,
0.03595820441842079,
-0.022688284516334534,
-0.05205279588699341,
0.001175345852971077,
0.02724471129477024,
0.009027859196066856,
0.023002788424491882,
0.0013385004131123424,
-0.012153537943959236,
-0.07113952189683914,
-0.014878933317959309,
-0.01403536181896925,
0.022997552528977394,
-0.015235940925776958,
-0.02408919483423233,
0.007947612553834915,
-0.013456188142299652,
-0.010125820524990559,
-0.011145027354359627,
0.008193997666239738,
-0.013163316994905472,
0.01560225524008274,
0.007589953951537609,
-0.006184585392475128,
0.05257992818951607,
0.03924071416258812,
0.07618329674005508,
-0.013806349597871304,
-0.0087958462536335,
-0.009473826736211777,
-0.03728816658258438,
-0.011772571131587029,
-0.03666604310274124,
-0.03146462142467499,
0.0013861247571185231,
0.01112399809062481,
-0.002129637636244297,
0.01713690161705017,
0.03152257949113846,
0.02098260447382927,
-0.07144389301538467,
0.0018289318541064858,
0.00319836032576859,
-0.02563200145959854,
0.026262694969773293,
0.021878020837903023,
-0.04081384465098381,
-0.014760123565793037,
-0.014025537297129631,
0.025536250323057175,
-0.05052781105041504,
-0.01684487611055374,
0.08969850838184357,
-0.0004580663808155805,
-0.0491519495844841,
0.05223703384399414,
-0.02056032605469227,
-0.041060879826545715,
0.032901134341955185,
0.00614030659198761,
-0.02239324524998665,
-0.03246287629008293,
0.032898709177970886,
0.03519327938556671,
0.027082044631242752,
0.0407404787838459,
-0.006235817912966013,
-0.02003597281873226,
-0.0023756236769258976,
-0.028776559978723526,
-0.03859011456370354,
0.009549370035529137,
-0.009649675339460373,
-0.05980057269334793,
0.003894014982506633,
0.046582650393247604,
-0.01719510741531849,
0.010083846747875214,
0.02243983931839466,
-0.035739656537771225,
-0.046354055404663086,
0.03879991173744202,
-0.018361737951636314,
-0.02786414697766304,
-0.05572190135717392,
-0.026021795347332954,
-0.00982243474572897,
0.0032324939966201782,
0.020543457940220833,
0.005301887635141611,
-0.010232171975076199,
0.00017153438238892704,
-0.056835804134607315,
-0.0023838449269533157,
-0.017953557893633842,
-0.01740032434463501,
-0.039750970900058746,
0.012761524878442287,
0.005585200618952513,
0.018874680623412132,
0.004806823097169399,
0.016587143763899803,
-0.02128385752439499,
0.033049967139959335,
0.016597650945186615,
0.013236341066658497,
-0.03281901404261589,
0.009631491266191006,
0.010382908396422863,
0.04142841696739197,
0.0305753406137228,
0.0221854355186224,
-0.022943271324038506,
0.0014164116000756621,
-0.03207018971443176,
-0.002553697442635894,
0.019989987835288048,
-0.004146987106651068,
-0.003945778589695692,
-0.05455831065773964,
-0.0830644890666008,
0.006088860332965851,
0.028979288414120674,
-0.00777314743027091,
-0.014815947972238064,
-0.062204428017139435,
-0.07158362865447998,
0.0073209707625210285,
-0.012820963747799397,
-0.009313534013926983,
0.00032212177757173777,
0.01498408429324627,
0.012445331551134586,
-0.041425254195928574,
-0.04597426950931549,
-0.015666425228118896,
-0.00102737988345325,
0.016570869833230972,
-0.020826123654842377,
0.05732087045907974,
-0.021771449595689774,
0.004846005234867334,
-0.00380740431137383,
-0.00860564038157463,
0.020518148317933083,
-0.04397299140691757,
-0.023480115458369255,
0.021449757739901543,
0.014075282961130142,
0.021670078858733177,
-0.043043315410614014,
0.05019617825746536,
0.02152765728533268,
-0.016205070540308952,
0.028376979753375053,
0.03133665397763252,
0.014949447475373745,
0.028571367263793945,
-0.002591681433841586,
0.002346210414543748,
0.0052887615747749805,
-0.013355308212339878,
-0.00532376067712903,
-0.010136624798178673,
-0.03425285220146179,
0.004872033838182688,
-0.006678881123661995,
0.02784319594502449,
-0.06424494087696075,
-0.001394108054228127,
0.001233610208146274,
0.011229473166167736,
-0.0799662321805954,
0.0032871845178306103,
-0.010202944278717041,
0.04537117853760719,
0.01971919648349285,
0.019731365144252777,
-0.017410660162568092,
0.00765735050663352,
0.004448826424777508,
0.02922465279698372,
-0.011635738424956799,
-0.031043831259012222,
-0.024725962430238724,
-0.04598240181803703,
-0.03277445212006569,
0.045945048332214355,
-0.016129398718476295,
-0.023965762928128242,
0.02070820890367031,
-0.03588050231337547,
0.017903845757246017,
-0.005427354946732521,
-0.02610364556312561,
0.0413096658885479,
-0.012209884822368622,
-0.007763041649013758,
-0.02474921941757202,
0.052193887531757355,
-0.030435753986239433,
-0.050454720854759216,
-0.04239679500460625,
0.10764506459236145,
-0.002172703854739666,
0.0017558862455189228,
-0.0008374265744350851,
-0.025594592094421387,
-0.002347281202673912,
0.005401233676820993,
0.019314071163535118,
0.006544966250658035,
0.02690008655190468,
-0.041067738085985184,
-0.0342184342443943,
-0.009768865071237087,
-0.035169512033462524,
0.03576512634754181,
-0.028551319614052773,
0.007521065883338451,
-0.049955859780311584,
-0.020831109955906868,
-0.021373150870203972,
0.015583381056785583,
0.0037902402691543102,
0.014111882075667381,
0.021745361387729645,
-0.005353659391403198,
-0.011150727048516273,
0.007216142490506172,
-0.01248759962618351,
0.03570860996842384,
-0.033052198588848114,
0.008437520824372768,
-0.0072035398334264755,
-0.05103977024555206,
-0.02058498188853264,
0.005319884978234768,
-0.0019111997680738568,
0.001612099353224039,
0.0065094176679849625,
-0.0037766536697745323,
-0.04195200279355049,
-0.06614170968532562,
-0.006580384448170662,
-0.0016383504262194037,
0.0023926259018480778,
0.0074753547087311745,
0.01370883546769619,
0.026080777868628502,
0.05291252210736275,
-0.033770497888326645,
0.07291318476200104,
-0.03169264271855354,
-0.0019041303312405944,
-0.13659672439098358,
0.009626355022192001,
0.02459677867591381,
0.026981759816408157,
-0.07047861814498901,
0.005793807562440634,
-0.025981605052947998,
0.010862677358090878,
-0.018342388793826103,
-0.009179184213280678,
0.0025750489439815283,
0.009749084711074829,
-0.009493512101471424,
-0.01969960145652294,
-0.03631863370537758,
0.04615824297070503,
-0.027136724442243576,
-0.06137913092970848,
-0.07869451493024826,
0.01602204330265522,
-0.015281639993190765,
-0.013004902750253677,
-0.028653163462877274,
-0.0008924593566916883,
0.036796584725379944,
0.003131836885586381,
-0.007708480581641197,
-0.06745502352714539,
-0.03164985403418541,
-0.01700947806239128,
-0.028062729164958,
-0.007492733187973499,
-0.007421461399644613,
0.007446771953254938,
-0.03007817640900612,
0.028522439301013947,
-0.010698225349187851,
-0.05184974521398544,
-0.015437479130923748,
0.018108714371919632,
-0.01548528578132391,
0.021337082609534264,
-0.03495487570762634,
0.006845616269856691,
0.03151209279894829,
0.042327892035245895,
-0.021730290725827217,
-0.026516854763031006,
-0.05989748612046242,
-0.048339396715164185,
-0.04155672714114189,
0.02801898866891861,
0.04526232182979584,
0.018406031653285027,
-0.00037236115895211697,
0.03534562513232231,
-0.02975793369114399,
-0.016712380573153496,
0.008523424156010151,
0.020617052912712097,
-0.006565751042217016,
0.021304365247488022,
-0.021147744730114937,
-0.05951201915740967,
-0.017341846600174904,
-0.0006734133930876851,
-0.00030965343466959894,
-0.023091409355401993,
-0.0005617344286292791,
-0.016969995573163033,
0.0075635905377566814,
0.024764439091086388,
0.025830794125795364,
-0.012607409618794918,
0.017160089686512947,
0.028585027903318405,
-0.04159313812851906,
0.025807645171880722,
-0.04669589176774025,
0.008349268697202206,
0.022962989285588264,
-0.0006375415832735598,
0.007656478323042393,
-0.0303721372038126,
0.055838342756032944,
0.048089344054460526,
-0.03206959739327431,
0.004157077521085739,
0.006916860584169626,
-0.027837850153446198,
-0.043621718883514404,
-0.009403889067471027,
-0.01648453250527382,
-0.0061018578708171844,
-0.0012301885290071368,
0.021660935133695602,
-0.0005391326267272234,
0.03875471651554108,
-0.023967163637280464,
-0.01452233549207449,
-0.0036377219948917627,
-0.03254683315753937,
0.020313682034611702,
-0.020173711702227592,
-0.05027126520872116,
0.0365632139146328,
-0.05046222358942032,
-0.010462936013936996,
0.028093921020627022,
-0.014848901890218258,
-0.009252297692000866,
-0.029976829886436462,
-0.021876193583011627,
0.0029860236681997776,
-0.008785974234342575,
0.036667533218860626,
-0.015425246208906174,
-0.0006962430197745562,
0.003677806816995144,
0.018511120229959488,
0.013089612126350403,
-0.031030144542455673,
0.014573662541806698,
-0.012947054579854012,
-0.001929455786012113,
0.007909335196018219,
0.07205385714769363,
0.0165106188505888,
0.0703975185751915,
-0.012893990613520145,
0.04654572531580925,
-0.025372745469212532,
0.0021135383285582066,
0.0005250137764960527,
0.03308996185660362,
0.023337334394454956,
-0.008769823238253593,
0.02658170275390148,
-0.02340937778353691,
-0.04741235822439194,
0.01561345811933279,
-0.012478400021791458,
0.04033501818776131,
-0.003429407486692071,
-0.017705686390399933,
-0.025764422491192818,
0.003098671091720462,
0.003156972350552678,
0.007216514088213444,
-0.06914782524108887,
-0.03291282802820206,
0.019272712990641594,
0.003962361253798008,
0.08599358797073364,
-0.00022366069606505334,
-0.001810687594115734,
0.046772681176662445,
-0.02289567142724991,
0.0407041572034359,
0.030912283807992935,
0.003085455857217312,
-0.038721464574337006,
-0.02115694433450699,
0.006822157185524702,
-0.04818093404173851,
0.01393252145498991,
-0.014702779240906239,
0.03375948965549469,
-0.03212866559624672,
-0.0015520931920036674,
-0.016084108501672745,
0.002419442404061556,
-0.007017178926616907,
-0.07154668122529984,
0.008388823829591274,
0.01284831389784813,
0.005828010383993387,
0.005369925871491432,
0.04308198392391205,
-0.04186488315463066,
0.0188569538295269,
0.056344080716371536,
0.045075222849845886,
-0.0038367616944015026,
0.020740823820233345,
0.06817581504583359,
-0.002422960940748453,
0.03553839772939682,
0.0008898698724806309,
-0.034126102924346924,
-0.019334619864821434,
0.003795923897996545,
0.04368596151471138,
-0.032712534070014954,
0.012434331700205803,
0.03302350640296936,
0.011609896086156368,
0.021022018045186996,
0.02480805478990078,
0.026092324405908585,
0.03385526314377785,
0.00220384169369936,
-0.027019526809453964,
0.020828137174248695,
-0.057195648550987244,
-0.027370667085051537,
-0.0032098900992423296,
0.007897821255028248,
-0.048096027225255966,
0.05147089064121246,
-0.03547866269946098,
0.001663966802880168,
-0.001492995535954833,
0.054770153015851974,
-0.0030130608938634396,
0.03170471265912056,
0.05303411930799484,
0.006954836659133434,
0.01097591407597065,
-0.026555674150586128,
0.03246169537305832,
0.03774774819612503,
-0.020090073347091675,
-0.028208479285240173,
0.006349228788167238,
-0.00481949420645833,
0.016351623460650444,
-0.03987325727939606,
-0.04132349044084549,
0.006827957462519407,
-0.025237025693058968,
-0.04006173834204674,
-0.009629175066947937,
0.04134662076830864,
0.013557625003159046,
-0.0168189387768507,
0.00017288060917053372,
-0.017792563885450363,
0.006566881202161312,
0.0019191912142559886,
-0.018926654011011124,
0.004549139644950628,
-0.027466414496302605,
0.013283945620059967
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:16
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
In approximately June or July 2008 Bob and I talked about this and other incidents. Bob had said to me on other occasions in the past words to the effect of "If you were a bloke I'd knock your fucking head in and I forget you're a sheila and not a bloke". Bob and I talked about this and other incidents after Bob showed me an article given to him by David Bourke about head chatter.
Bob told me ..."
Is this coming back to you at all?
Answer: It is now yes.
At line 47:-
Question: Bob told me "I virtually lose my mind at times and I don't recall what I have said. You know I would never hurt you. I said to him "Remember when you dragged me down the stairs and threatened to kill me?" He said "I honestly and truly don't remember that. I didn't hurt you did I? I know I honestly would never hurt you."
I did not tell him I'm scared of him. I'm scared he will harm me and my sons in some way. I'm afraid of him. I'm deeply afraid of him. I'm deeply increasingly disturbed by his behaviour.
Now do you remember the context now?
Answer: Yes I do.
At T653, line 10:-
Question: Do you remember on your oath point blank denying that entire evidence that I've read out to you?
Answer: I don't know whether I point blank but I'm sure I denied it because I was denying the whole sequence of events that had been portrayed, yes.
89The defendant submits that these questions and answers reveal that Cooper's failure to remember anything about the article dealing with head chatter in evidence (T652, lines 20 - 25) demonstrates that, whether he remembered or not,
he was prepared to deny any suggestion put to him either from the defendant's evidence or affidavits or in cross-examination that was adverse to his interests, unless and until confronted with no other alternative.
90At T720, line 11 while being cross-examined about paragraph 587 of the defendant's affidavit the plaintiff was asked:-
Question: I want to ask you this. Do you absolutely deny ever having said words to the effect "I virtually lose my mind at times and I don't recall what I've said". Do you absolutely reject you ever said anything to that effect?
Answer: I can't answer that yes or no, would you allow me to tell the one time I did say something?
Question: Mr Cooper ... your counsel has a right to re-examine you.
Answer: OK well the answer's no, not those words in that context.
Question: I asked you whether you would deny ever having said words to that effect "I virtually lose my mind at times and I don't recall what I've said." Now will you on oath say you have never said to her words to that effect?
Answer: I will deny it.
91The defendant submits that analysis of the answers given support the submission that the plaintiff was consistently evasive. The contrast between an answer "well the answer is no, not those words in that context" and an absolute denial that he had ever said to her words to that effect, it was submitted does not stand up.
92The subject matter namely losing his mind and not recalling what he has said are very important given that the assaults invariably may have occurred when the plaintiff was very angry and violent. Further cross-examination on the note left before the trip to Melbourne illustrates the point.
At T603, line 12:-
We had quite a strong argument ... ... it was getting very angry very frustrating for me, so it blew up
T603, line 50:-
It was a heated argument.
T604, line 8:-
Question: Were you angry?
Answer: Yes.
T604, line 41:-
Question: So what do you say had provoked the argument?
Answer: I don't remember.
Question: Having left that note you do not remember what the argument was about?
Answer: No I don't.
93If he cannot remember what provoked the arguments he may not even remember what he said.
94At T692 the plaintiff was asked:-
Question: Have you said in your affidavits you've only once lost your temper with Ms Mulcahy?
Answer: I'm not losing my temper.
Question: I wonder if you'd answer my question.
Answer: What was the question?
|
[
0.0009534735581837595,
0.03089326061308384,
0.006305281538516283,
0.009525598958134651,
-0.016039486974477768,
-0.06337658315896988,
0.0503154881298542,
0.012202641926705837,
0.059769462794065475,
-0.027741428464651108,
0.03388581797480583,
0.02566220425069332,
-0.04602835699915886,
0.00682509271427989,
0.014884685166180134,
-0.02986508421599865,
0.01644439436495304,
-0.026730628684163094,
-0.012897470965981483,
-0.017586996778845787,
-0.031101541593670845,
-0.03534168750047684,
0.002671667840331793,
0.00013364684127736837,
-0.009830287657678127,
0.01601516641676426,
-0.0156717449426651,
-0.030461087822914124,
-0.00884696189314127,
0.01880422607064247,
0.018354520201683044,
-0.01839955896139145,
0.026164647191762924,
-0.03470577299594879,
0.029205942526459694,
-0.012978274375200272,
0.010422246530652046,
0.002935675671324134,
-0.017148979008197784,
0.006772864609956741,
0.03445577993988991,
0.022452494129538536,
0.019958384335041046,
-0.015664223581552505,
0.022830763831734657,
-0.012977494858205318,
-0.008112557232379913,
-0.004965641535818577,
0.0324147529900074,
-0.009601989760994911,
-0.023118186742067337,
-0.006045147310942411,
0.022077377885580063,
0.003817119402810931,
-0.011650601401925087,
0.037087246775627136,
-0.016713084653019905,
0.00852979440242052,
-0.053898151963949203,
0.008737505413591862,
-0.0022441211622208357,
-0.058239832520484924,
0.020719489082694054,
0.026799524202942848,
-0.02413766458630562,
0.09989213943481445,
-0.012066756375133991,
-0.03482621908187866,
-0.002437646733596921,
-0.01874666102230549,
-0.02377025969326496,
-0.016191119328141212,
0.0071557313203811646,
-0.02974647469818592,
-0.08334600180387497,
0.0348808579146862,
0.05415012314915657,
0.016189010813832283,
-0.0035085384733974934,
0.034457169473171234,
0.0625973716378212,
-0.006897634360939264,
-0.0006852332735434175,
0.023458875715732574,
-0.03636176884174347,
0.0310512725263834,
-0.02155211567878723,
0.018043937161564827,
-0.015066861175000668,
-0.025488289073109627,
-0.010256490670144558,
0.01316238846629858,
-0.004407842643558979,
-0.06707615405321121,
-0.025637971237301826,
-0.002984337043017149,
-0.019152183085680008,
-0.01122278906404972,
-0.04717112332582474,
0.031452883034944534,
0.015152987092733383,
0.0005078017711639404,
-0.001136784558184445,
-0.048649370670318604,
0.02232888527214527,
0.007339578587561846,
0.02790563553571701,
0.03279731795191765,
0.04886699840426445,
-0.0028521581552922726,
0.03825491666793823,
0.0007698065601289272,
-0.03711438924074173,
0.007383302319794893,
0.008768285624682903,
-0.012096371501684189,
-0.008004164323210716,
-0.014686507172882557,
0.008595080114901066,
-0.023492008447647095,
0.02700280025601387,
0.027771150693297386,
0.01163690909743309,
-0.014591335318982601,
-0.03871940076351166,
0.035294149070978165,
-0.035635728389024734,
0.009286969900131226,
0.008595827966928482,
0.0340237133204937,
-0.029987022280693054,
-0.009372854605317116,
-0.0158152524381876,
-0.051253676414489746,
-0.04891391098499298,
-0.006818675901740789,
0.0034622084349393845,
0.035673677921295166,
-0.013540751300752163,
-0.025206029415130615,
0.06917698681354523,
0.032992299646139145,
0.024511490017175674,
-0.05462190881371498,
-0.019476693123579025,
0.007573834620416164,
0.05351735278964043,
0.007912070490419865,
0.0006407664041034877,
0.025531645864248276,
-0.010555990971624851,
-0.022126516327261925,
0.036111120134592056,
-0.006212717853486538,
0.05890990048646927,
-0.08967030793428421,
0.012315718457102776,
0.003419900080189109,
-0.02462085522711277,
0.05252448096871376,
-0.015140866860747337,
-0.011910118162631989,
-0.051917217671871185,
-0.004780530463904142,
0.021221745759248734,
0.03459533676505089,
0.009049203246831894,
0.007870390079915524,
0.0009221045183949172,
-0.011190267279744148,
0.02134733460843563,
-0.039123788475990295,
0.018872929736971855,
0.00593676557764411,
0.04620839282870293,
0.034247443079948425,
0.01793285645544529,
0.010844077914953232,
-0.003450786927714944,
-0.06156906113028526,
0.017574436962604523,
0.006797668058425188,
0.011063888669013977,
-0.0060388813726603985,
-0.047139402478933334,
0.03444729372859001,
-0.06021669879555702,
-0.016230208799242973,
0.01712867058813572,
0.045258212834596634,
-0.045814987272024155,
-0.020679179579019547,
0.007219456601887941,
0.03780210018157959,
0.03533925861120224,
0.00015897273260634392,
0.026029866188764572,
-0.025222105905413628,
0.0012487105559557676,
-0.006430612411350012,
-0.0011070353211835027,
0.082365982234478,
-0.0005002598627470434,
-0.02340947650372982,
-0.00971932988613844,
-0.005225283559411764,
-0.046295225620269775,
-0.005396207794547081,
0.012144237756729126,
-0.0742216631770134,
0.015269296243786812,
0.0005389825091697276,
0.008067771792411804,
0.05036396160721779,
-0.022806361317634583,
-0.013933057896792889,
-0.00857040286064148,
-0.010353954508900642,
-0.00038408322143368423,
-0.014417908154428005,
0.011279965750873089,
0.009832656010985374,
-0.01018790528178215,
-0.021237820386886597,
0.005165712907910347,
0.017659848555922508,
-0.0006027366034686565,
0.03604947403073311,
0.009134985506534576,
-0.005823529791086912,
0.039622243493795395,
0.01940879225730896,
0.010077833198010921,
0.021183611825108528,
0.0167873352766037,
-0.0021164361387491226,
-0.04856472834944725,
0.00933501124382019,
0.06006139889359474,
-0.014800495468080044,
-0.027325991541147232,
-0.018849242478609085,
0.04894205927848816,
-0.01797250099480152,
-0.021732192486524582,
-0.00732567859813571,
0.018613161519169807,
0.007129556033760309,
0.042272720485925674,
0.01442909799516201,
-0.01092261541634798,
0.016967667266726494,
0.004549018107354641,
-0.055776264518499374,
0.048463042825460434,
-0.0020584622398018837,
-0.013806247152388096,
0.010585503652691841,
-0.0004118519718758762,
0.01614231802523136,
0.029149087145924568,
0.004715850576758385,
0.016905758529901505,
0.004473881796002388,
-0.013413313776254654,
-0.005428762640804052,
-0.04197448119521141,
-0.0491681843996048,
-0.013605366460978985,
-0.0032589882612228394,
0.014666875824332237,
0.008906671777367592,
0.004063088912516832,
-0.047920700162649155,
-0.02115803211927414,
0.05429787561297417,
-0.01263844221830368,
0.008424113504588604,
0.0024266086984425783,
0.02563854306936264,
0.013122190721333027,
0.006328010931611061,
-0.0162053219974041,
-0.00700314249843359,
-0.02108301967382431,
0.03279460594058037,
-0.011102166026830673,
-0.05718658119440079,
-0.008456699550151825,
-0.02714030258357525,
-0.008114715106785297,
-0.0024424875155091286,
0.06981168687343597,
0.0015749750891700387,
-0.06237557902932167,
0.016332607716321945,
0.001068419311195612,
-0.14243653416633606,
-0.0446636863052845,
0.0146793769672513,
-0.01609949581325054,
0.029966775327920914,
-0.009585155174136162,
-0.014155620709061623,
-0.02100958488881588,
-0.03046264499425888,
0.0086121940985322,
0.06158258393406868,
-0.040408503264188766,
-0.015068290755152702,
0.022912219166755676,
0.052630163729190826,
-0.021007951349020004,
-0.01849132962524891,
-0.009002779610455036,
0.03421390801668167,
-0.0511913001537323,
0.05288585275411606,
-0.027472898364067078,
0.04897454380989075,
-0.023557117208838463,
-0.007984207943081856,
0.021242497488856316,
0.03396666422486305,
-0.004263441078364849,
-0.041592005640268326,
-0.022152481600642204,
-0.030707068741321564,
-0.024558523669838905,
-0.019466467201709747,
0.04027470573782921,
0.00407163193449378,
0.06015993654727936,
0.011800325475633144,
-0.0426984541118145,
-0.02256138250231743,
-0.024923397228121758,
0.015346910804510117,
0.06280467659235,
-0.04902280122041702,
0.03193855658173561,
0.011867365799844265,
-0.040622591972351074,
0.018658073619008064,
0.037938348948955536,
-0.05848752707242966,
0.036286111921072006,
-0.03613162040710449,
-0.015377450734376907,
-0.02238045446574688,
-0.012807684019207954,
-0.0042601111344993114,
0.0010422701016068459,
0.017753619700670242,
0.05215588957071304,
-0.029622595757246017,
-0.013085576705634594,
0.027604876086115837,
-0.060277875512838364,
-0.012775585055351257,
0.054245125502347946,
-0.04940349608659744,
0.006631455384194851,
0.004421954974532127,
-0.05317767709493637,
-0.03142489865422249,
0.008214964531362057,
0.02466404251754284,
-0.04605858400464058,
0.009520770981907845,
-0.005493220407515764,
0.0017915676580742002,
0.019942373037338257,
-0.017001090571284294,
-0.030372150242328644,
-0.0006718047661706805,
-0.11533230543136597,
0.046363621950149536,
0.015320241451263428,
0.0026572926435619593,
0.010914705693721771,
0.00047278092824853957,
0.011572706513106823,
0.02137215994298458,
-0.0034286321606487036,
0.01024110708385706,
0.1984691023826599,
0.028515897691249847,
-0.03891017287969589,
0.002363571897149086,
-0.02587936818599701,
0.03467685729265213,
0.033682629466056824,
0.06753954291343689,
0.032203637063503265,
-0.041268836706876755,
-0.03711315989494324,
0.02557910792529583,
-0.0011225709458813071,
0.019667593762278557,
-0.05031231790781021,
-0.0035192230716347694,
-0.026637094095349312,
-0.00779184652492404,
0.077462337911129,
0.011305107735097408,
0.03381073474884033,
0.021407505497336388,
0.08794477581977844,
0.01549310889095068,
-0.02718978188931942,
-0.02848154865205288,
-0.017300745472311974,
0.04384731501340866,
-0.04000362008810043,
0.012857869267463684,
-0.047372154891490936,
0.018230015411973,
0.02217653952538967,
-0.0065187932923436165,
0.029035383835434914,
0.001393343904055655,
-0.016514405608177185,
-0.029870793223381042,
-0.02188742533326149,
0.0422399565577507,
0.0027560070157051086,
-0.019978513941168785,
0.002989682136103511,
-0.04907456040382385,
-0.03624364361166954,
-0.00974600575864315,
-0.01508434396237135,
0.014457962475717068,
-0.06415126472711563,
0.03373192995786667,
-0.00845411792397499,
0.051191676408052444,
-0.018960298970341682,
0.017293833196163177,
-0.033130306750535965,
0.015417472459375858,
-0.016730941832065582,
-0.015440192073583603,
-0.0769277811050415,
0.07478895783424377,
-0.00778579106554389,
0.04406845197081566,
-0.04304992035031319,
0.051773473620414734,
0.01004705298691988,
0.046911876648664474,
0.015431619249284267,
-0.019779009744524956,
0.06690579652786255,
0.02565809339284897,
0.06658471375703812,
0.03586101904511452,
0.017155146226286888,
-0.0048677329905331135,
0.020947061479091644,
-0.04769393429160118,
-0.01725493185222149,
0.03530263155698776,
0.03445076197385788,
0.024101704359054565,
0.013569188304245472,
-0.027480175718665123,
-0.04993659257888794,
0.019761793315410614,
0.05271026864647865,
0.003400850109755993,
-0.008461334742605686,
0.03184948116540909,
-0.002078989753499627,
0.03974821791052818,
-0.0015288861468434334,
-0.013142809271812439,
-0.0061036525294184685,
-0.001171213574707508,
0.011487268842756748,
0.022814637050032616,
0.01059785671532154,
0.001883552991785109,
0.006271149031817913,
-0.0456765741109848,
-0.017323531210422516,
-0.02122352086007595,
0.04937991872429848,
0.003744753310456872,
0.03922956809401512,
-0.03411280736327171,
-0.0054930103942751884,
0.0034590100403875113,
-0.040927328169345856,
-0.022358020767569542,
-0.005311001557856798,
0.01442040503025055,
-0.021364104002714157,
0.0007156826322898269,
0.02806917019188404,
0.04252924397587776,
-0.024697791785001755,
0.022224104031920433,
0.01772112026810646,
0.055274996906518936,
-0.019245892763137817,
0.014052856713533401,
-0.032383088022470474,
0.05121801793575287,
0.0223008394241333,
0.006783213000744581,
-0.022218555212020874,
0.00044721440644934773,
-0.03774833679199219,
0.025771785527467728,
0.011766440235078335,
-0.0069697038270533085,
-0.036507681012153625,
0.009171703830361366,
0.04653629660606384,
0.0028158051427453756,
-0.031082231551408768,
-0.019546031951904297,
-0.025637982413172722,
0.03149084001779556,
0.02893618308007717,
0.01464550569653511,
0.009630149230360985,
0.0023609010968357325,
0.005751684308052063,
0.013562934473156929,
-0.06310469657182693,
-0.0067239319905638695,
-0.06609285622835159,
-0.019393406808376312,
0.045747991651296616,
0.02262968011200428,
-0.035792525857686996,
-0.04200897738337517,
0.003643516916781664,
-0.03250982239842415,
-0.014043675735592842,
0.00899085309356451,
0.016488274559378624,
-0.026221860200166702,
0.002612907439470291,
0.010903437621891499,
-0.016249632462859154,
0.0374595932662487,
-0.009748957119882107,
0.048357654362916946,
0.017199011519551277,
0.036544159054756165,
-0.010285429656505585,
0.036310236901044846,
-0.05158637464046478,
-0.03425051271915436,
-0.005741244647651911,
0.008334172889590263,
0.01434428058564663,
0.0295689906924963,
0.0033248194959014654,
0.016607925295829773,
-0.0006651579169556499,
-0.011586886830627918,
0.010131226852536201,
0.01626899093389511,
0.0010967708658427,
0.07795554399490356,
-0.021926090121269226,
-0.011824562214314938,
0.0328507237136364,
-0.0021698351483792067,
-0.003611805848777294,
-0.023639338091015816,
-0.04885554686188698,
0.09096495062112808,
0.01063093077391386,
-0.028197648003697395,
0.017245830968022346,
0.028737040236592293,
0.04546916112303734,
0.03494785353541374,
-0.0034585820976644754,
-0.03772430494427681,
-0.03925048187375069,
0.02720477804541588,
-0.01655254140496254,
0.023972896859049797,
0.0009501882595941424,
0.010321417823433876,
0.011116262525320053,
0.030531151220202446,
-0.009735971689224243,
-0.03249741718173027,
0.032449714839458466,
-0.0014017480425536633,
-0.05065525695681572,
-0.013321156613528728,
-0.05001034960150719,
0.010642573237419128,
0.013588381931185722,
0.033108677715063095,
0.02726520225405693,
-0.021016938611865044,
0.006606754381209612,
-0.03920883685350418,
0.06313242018222809,
-0.0788181722164154,
-0.0506579726934433,
-0.033250659704208374,
-0.02479586750268936,
-0.055844858288764954,
-0.020586134865880013,
-0.02885863184928894,
-0.001572666224092245,
-0.051932379603385925,
-0.007762421388179064,
0.017069406807422638,
0.010393836535513401,
0.005249626003205776,
-0.027612149715423584,
0.004444668535143137,
0.014467048458755016,
-0.026658451184630394,
0.018176402896642685,
0.005050939507782459,
0.03227917477488518,
0.07967811822891235,
-0.025838490575551987,
-0.009920720010995865,
0.0031395643018186092,
-0.028222786262631416,
-0.00885708723217249,
0.029133547097444534,
0.02543993666768074,
0.009920983575284481,
0.012329929508268833,
-0.03606399521231651,
-0.002084864769130945,
0.009393616579473019,
0.05180498585104942,
-0.011651438660919666,
-0.05094359442591667,
-0.028898043558001518,
-0.020825441926717758,
0.018048202618956566,
0.0019248134922236204,
-0.011727455072104931,
-0.07712026685476303,
-0.0367140918970108,
0.03642267361283302,
0.01712573878467083,
-0.00895310752093792,
-0.07110022753477097,
0.012794382870197296,
-0.0031926254741847515,
-0.006105486769229174,
-0.019696829840540886,
0.0033070307690650225,
0.017238665372133255,
-0.03761640191078186,
0.0006275884807109833,
0.037305522710084915,
-0.01431212481111288,
0.03137747570872307,
0.054989904165267944,
0.05635529384016991,
0.05113884434103966,
-0.016270792111754417,
0.002647276036441326,
0.03966894373297691,
0.04437058046460152,
0.025437090545892715,
-0.018986783921718597,
0.04336719959974289,
-0.015257650054991245,
-0.03195029869675636,
0.02476007677614689,
-0.030248239636421204,
-0.0010647830786183476,
0.027609070762991905,
0.013211559504270554,
0.002094489987939596,
0.040132787078619,
0.006859300192445517,
0.05522845685482025,
-0.03144009783864021,
0.01199665293097496,
-0.031931400299072266,
0.0021884648595005274,
-0.003812150564044714,
-0.044236212968826294,
0.03981613367795944,
0.04530943185091019,
0.0503794327378273,
-0.06214690953493118,
-0.03817928954958916,
-0.037834666669368744,
-0.010950610972940922,
0.009112863801419735,
0.06217527016997337,
-0.013150742277503014,
0.0013113318709656596,
-0.009999319911003113,
-0.03343326225876808,
-0.018611760810017586,
-0.04947960749268532,
0.01173036266118288,
-0.06644615530967712,
0.05511922761797905,
0.014001458883285522,
-0.06051678955554962,
-0.02176746539771557,
-0.028330715373158455,
-0.029937295243144035,
-0.030458271503448486,
0.03209444507956505,
0.022994941100478172,
0.006526186130940914,
0.012459454126656055,
0.024264367297291756,
-0.007759387604892254,
0.004126833751797676,
-0.06487424671649933,
0.015737351030111313,
-0.04125010594725609,
0.09179205447435379,
-0.018455691635608673,
-0.007102240342646837,
0.00725967762991786,
0.02495608478784561,
-0.00417438056319952,
0.025352027267217636,
0.009795596823096275,
-0.022908205166459084,
0.009402268566191196,
-0.04486775025725365,
-0.03665885701775551,
0.05055798962712288,
0.02401008829474449,
-0.001431482145562768,
0.005179222207516432,
0.031880613416433334,
-0.0005659700254909694,
-0.0014705448411405087,
0.01214396208524704,
0.0039042518474161625,
-0.01994391717016697,
0.0026474788319319487,
0.004715322982519865,
-0.01116357371211052,
0.0011389683932065964,
-0.009188305586576462,
-0.006789501290768385,
-0.014093630015850067,
0.025508690625429153,
-0.01325976848602295,
-0.00523888086900115,
-0.03805561736226082,
0.036767203360795975,
0.0168599933385849,
-0.013889309950172901,
0.0076328180730342865,
-0.004180106800049543,
-0.017659777775406837,
-0.017627831548452377,
0.010192526504397392,
-0.03769122064113617,
0.035761758685112,
-0.03844819217920303,
-0.05280356481671333,
0.030843915417790413,
-0.014875782653689384,
0.04285312443971634,
-0.009121296927332878,
-0.011090390384197235,
-0.05776031315326691,
0.04336002096533775,
-0.1427001953125,
0.03447958081960678,
0.030256932601332664,
-0.017646213993430138,
-0.03663609176874161,
-0.008117166347801685,
-0.06288895756006241,
-0.01531216874718666,
-0.011885286308825016,
0.005031909793615341,
-0.01461197528988123,
-0.010230153799057007,
-0.041771624237298965,
-0.02481335960328579,
-0.07504391670227051,
0.04587746784090996,
0.03494340553879738,
-0.013674839399755001,
-0.04062538966536522,
-0.020882777869701385,
-0.0033833226189017296,
-0.022532420232892036,
0.0323161855340004,
-0.02639736607670784,
-0.02113036997616291,
-0.019358409568667412,
-0.014841312542557716,
0.010058902204036713,
-0.03568398952484131,
-0.014827026054263115,
-0.00494026392698288,
-0.019983910024166107,
-0.014731171540915966,
0.01029342133551836,
-0.0018903902964666486,
0.011623605154454708,
0.03675958886742592,
-0.012460898607969284,
0.024311672896146774,
-0.03262978792190552,
-0.024739457294344902,
-0.01480440516024828,
-0.007034203037619591,
-0.02608310617506504,
0.01386974100023508,
0.0037205175030976534,
-0.04373030364513397,
0.031960539519786835,
-0.021510951220989227,
-0.0165653508156538,
-0.024081896990537643,
0.018011799082159996,
-0.01929931528866291,
0.008544412441551685,
0.017303014174103737,
-0.021120525896549225,
-0.02559971995651722,
0.024921851232647896,
0.010376629419624805,
0.033949267119169235,
-0.007525759749114513,
-0.027775686234235764,
-0.042561911046504974,
0.03428195044398308,
-0.007308403495699167,
-0.013448800891637802,
-0.02287287265062332,
0.015995526686310768,
-0.026927407830953598,
0.011981653049588203,
-0.037123989313840866,
-0.006038374733179808,
0.011442362330853939,
0.017271362245082855,
0.03581053391098976,
-0.007936186157166958,
0.00915500894188881,
0.007318221963942051,
0.013005314394831657,
-0.0056472523137927055,
-0.02437650039792061,
-0.015304675325751305,
-0.05922515317797661,
-0.021554727107286453,
-0.012719626538455486,
0.027985455468297005,
-0.013962756842374802,
-0.009049932472407818,
0.027611594647169113,
-0.019920462742447853,
-0.06463009864091873,
-0.0007674885564483702,
-0.029990477487444878,
0.03022918477654457,
-0.019847411662340164,
0.035428959876298904,
-0.007284531835466623,
-0.02926653064787388,
0.017516594380140305,
-0.024644440039992332,
-0.025891639292240143,
-0.03951799497008324,
0.021611366420984268,
0.018362876027822495,
-0.016696210950613022,
0.03661798685789108,
0.039186373353004456,
-0.022417448461055756,
0.011132619343698025,
0.02278466895222664,
0.01390524860471487,
-0.019455600529909134,
-0.050530269742012024,
-0.021667424589395523,
-0.027064688503742218,
0.015613853931427002,
-0.02216275781393051,
0.04546688124537468,
0.00396601902320981,
0.014407912269234657,
-0.0100752217695117,
0.029465800151228905,
-0.03580699488520622,
-0.01789097487926483,
-0.01411611121147871,
0.033276405185461044,
0.045028455555438995,
-0.022917285561561584,
-0.00522995600476861,
0.016431646421551704,
0.024287084117531776,
-0.012753837741911411,
0.008922331966459751,
0.027596699073910713,
-0.0073076533153653145,
0.01723349094390869,
-0.01131532434374094,
0.014359764754772186,
-0.0409952774643898,
-0.02181589975953102,
0.009910665452480316,
-0.0023303127381950617,
-0.018214277923107147,
-0.014665168710052967,
-0.03087671473622322,
0.020963193848729134,
0.009024553000926971,
0.022334078326821327,
-0.09226739406585693,
-0.01067547407001257,
0.019207118079066277,
0.020293569192290306,
-0.0009883319726213813,
0.03518793359398842,
-0.00888617243617773,
0.024830114096403122,
0.012362153269350529,
0.015039266087114811,
0.02228487655520439,
0.052810266613960266,
-0.012265285477042198,
-0.040452953428030014,
-0.02212742157280445,
-0.018521007150411606,
0.008631565608084202,
0.027894416823983192,
0.002503418829292059,
0.02055441588163376,
-0.06419926136732101,
0.011585026048123837,
-0.04816054552793503,
0.0014350063866004348,
-0.0007629849133081734,
0.01082895789295435,
0.013823691755533218,
-0.001577209448441863,
0.020986413583159447,
-0.0574524961411953,
0.029740139842033386,
-0.007641534321010113,
0.03596557304263115,
0.006060165353119373,
-0.024220291525125504,
-0.026490576565265656,
0.03770962730050087,
0.0541251003742218,
0.02202647738158703,
0.011838669888675213,
-0.029886821284890175,
0.0018084755865857005,
-0.0038209445774555206,
-0.002370669739320874,
0.06808352470397949,
-0.014772715978324413,
0.012209830805659294,
0.020402982831001282,
-0.038284096866846085,
0.04699380695819855,
0.008153019472956657,
0.025426384061574936,
0.039520520716905594,
-0.014229490421712399,
-0.04103090986609459,
-0.0387447364628315,
-0.054481517523527145,
0.030601881444454193,
-0.011107957921922207,
-0.05856875702738762,
-0.031818583607673645,
0.07168024778366089,
-0.0013307419139891863,
-0.0008740914054214954,
-0.058264195919036865,
0.01639600284397602,
-0.008233694359660149,
0.010451051406562328,
-0.03769463300704956,
0.027576250955462456,
0.03393290564417839,
-0.001332401530817151,
0.028808465227484703,
0.02585182897746563,
-0.03735095262527466,
-0.04700550436973572,
-0.015652377158403397,
-0.010997292585670948,
-0.01402110792696476,
0.03846421465277672,
-0.0006197250331752002,
-0.004038967192173004,
-0.03788859024643898,
-0.013405315577983856,
0.004450224805623293,
0.028650017455220222,
-0.005191956181079149,
-0.026277124881744385,
-0.034199949353933334,
-0.011400957591831684,
-0.05527669936418533,
0.00342852552421391,
-0.023121682927012444,
-0.01855928637087345,
0.003408556105569005,
-0.02117391861975193
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:8
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
21 Fam LR 760 per Gleeson CJ and McLelland CJ in Eq, approving views of Mahoney JA in the majority in Wallace v Stanford (1995) 37 NSWLR 1 ; 19 Fam LR 430 and in the minority in Dwyer v Kaljo (1992) 27 NSWLR 728 ; 15 Fam LR 645 and in turn substantially approving the views of Hodgson J at first instance in Dwyer v Kaljo (1987) 11 Fam LR 785 at 793.
It should I think be understood that in Evans v Marmont Meagher JA, at NSWLR 98; Fam LR 786-7, agreed with this part of the judgment of Gleeson CJ and McLelland CJ in Eq.
[66] What I understand to be established by the majority view in Evans v Marmont is to this effect:
(a) The factors referred to in paras (a) and (b) of s 21 are fundamental factors influencing the judgment of the court.
(b) Considering contributions and nothing else cannot lead to any view on what is just and equitable in the circumstances.
(c) Factors other than contributions can have no independent bearing on what is just and equitable: they have only such relevance as they may have to the question: what is just and equitable having regard to the contributions of the parties?
(d) Factors other than contributions mentioned in s 20(1)(a) and (b) may be relevant to answer the question whether the contributions of one party have been sufficiently compensated.
(e) The financial circumstances of the parties are relevant to ascertain the property of the parties at the time of the hearing, to which any adjustments of interest are to be made.
(f) The needs and means of the parties have general relevance as subsidiary factors to the question of what is just and equitable having regard to the contributions of parties; but otherwise the needs and means of the parties have no relevance, and a disproportion in their assets is not a reason why it is just and equitable to make an adjustment.
(g) It would be unrealistic to attempt to evaluate contributions of the kinds referred to in s 20(1)(a) and (b) for the purpose of determining what is just and equitable having regard to those contributions in isolation from the nature and incidents of the relationship as a whole.
(h) Often it may be found that contributions of the kind referred to in s 20(1)(b) would involve shared activities or reciprocal benefits which do not give rise to any disproportionate burden which it would be just and equitable to satisfy by an adjustment of interests in property.
[67] Notwithstanding the strength of the dissenting judgments of Mason P and Priestley JA in Evans v Marmont, the course of judicial opinion leading to Evans v Marmont means, in my view, that earlier judicial consideration, including consideration in the Court of Appeal, of the significance of contributions in s 20(1) should not be treated as authoritative;
this observation extends not only to Dwyer v Kaljo but also to Green v Robinson (1995) 36 NSWLR 96 ; 18 Fam LR 594 and Theodoropoulos v Theodosiou (1995) 38 NSWLR 424 ; 19 Fam LR 632.
The history of diversity of opinion, two refusals of special leave to appeal to the High Court and convening a Court of Appeal of five members gives the majority decision in Evans v Marmont a special claim to authority. In particular, expressions of opinion in Green v Robinson no longer govern the application of s 20(1). I do not find any clear majority expression of view in Green v Robinson.
43There are many other cases on lottery wins a number of which I have collected in Senno v Bailey [2011] NSWSC 679. The asset in this case only came into existence three years after the conclusion of the relationship and had nothing to do with the defendant. The defendant made no contributions to it and in my view it is not appropriate to take account of it in the adjustment process.
Financial contributions to the relationship
44The evidence of the plaintiff's earnings as disclosed in his tax returns is:
* 1991/92 - taxable income $17,118, tax $2,691 - $270 net per week.
* 1992/93 - taxable income $23,365, tax $6,441 - $326 net per week.
* 1993/94 - taxable income $3,614, tax nil - $70 net per week.
|
[
-0.01533511932939291,
0.06281694024801254,
-0.01720999740064144,
0.01024832483381033,
-0.028538037091493607,
-0.03229657933115959,
-0.006484478712081909,
-0.01206776313483715,
0.026011846959590912,
0.011574161238968372,
0.011340616270899773,
0.050581514835357666,
-0.0788995772600174,
-0.0023413398303091526,
-0.05499117821455002,
-0.0424504429101944,
0.016420362517237663,
-0.005406215321272612,
-0.06369785964488983,
-0.010771066881716251,
-0.017555948346853256,
0.009610551409423351,
0.021131163462996483,
0.01683824136853218,
0.04230593517422676,
0.0262778140604496,
-0.05153593793511391,
-0.02027578465640545,
0.02975299209356308,
0.05026232823729515,
-0.031783442944288254,
0.016082262620329857,
-0.008011839352548122,
-0.04350809380412102,
-0.012673607096076012,
-0.022838778793811798,
-0.026872362941503525,
0.031100569292902946,
-0.025268536061048508,
0.004778838716447353,
-0.012788733467459679,
0.015911994501948357,
-0.01433257944881916,
-0.027194280177354813,
0.045855842530727386,
-0.01855579763650894,
-0.024095989763736725,
-0.027612121775746346,
0.0015343736158683896,
0.009433403611183167,
-0.05512585490942001,
0.03630154952406883,
0.05474171042442322,
-0.007464898284524679,
-0.0029984316788613796,
0.009553615003824234,
-0.035783551633358,
-0.026561100035905838,
-0.03338445723056793,
0.002745741745457053,
0.001354298321530223,
0.00013203980051912367,
-0.06932716071605682,
-0.038626473397016525,
0.0104683768004179,
0.05834919586777687,
-0.02539094164967537,
0.0011877112556248903,
-0.011415582150220871,
-0.012126754969358444,
-0.019877398386597633,
-0.035140227526426315,
-0.004558836575597525,
-0.03303467482328415,
-0.06632938981056213,
-0.004113243892788887,
0.028077056631445885,
0.018845373764634132,
-0.013176362961530685,
-0.01351220440119505,
0.02550608478486538,
-0.005790251307189465,
0.004256017506122589,
-0.0002540402056183666,
-0.06589426845312119,
0.03366462513804436,
0.01401190273463726,
0.024331560358405113,
0.019335277378559113,
-0.026420725509524345,
-0.05872507020831108,
0.008225465193390846,
0.02519264444708824,
-0.03067384660243988,
0.015168299898505211,
-0.009294284507632256,
-0.08384381234645844,
0.04196995496749878,
0.019630281254649162,
-0.0031474148854613304,
0.02673255279660225,
0.02771914377808571,
0.0021382332779467106,
-0.00466704647988081,
-0.009903724305331707,
0.02363385073840618,
0.020317036658525467,
0.010152035392820835,
0.021472366526722908,
0.01607568748295307,
-0.007547690533101559,
0.021902713924646378,
-0.004641309380531311,
0.012279771268367767,
-0.02720952220261097,
0.0007240633713081479,
0.0012415744131430984,
-0.024838699027895927,
-0.013993295840919018,
0.02662409283220768,
0.0774984210729599,
0.02070588618516922,
0.06341090053319931,
-0.02695947326719761,
-0.07091036438941956,
0.03686753287911415,
-0.008778585121035576,
0.04550334811210632,
-0.04625000059604645,
0.025642968714237213,
-0.0077454387210309505,
-0.021355371922254562,
-0.028943318873643875,
-0.02017253264784813,
-0.009494821541011333,
0.014111383818089962,
0.051632072776556015,
0.02592002972960472,
0.029824785888195038,
-0.05437776818871498,
0.02342606708407402,
0.03775925561785698,
-0.011590017937123775,
-0.030982783064246178,
0.030967706814408302,
0.018740730360150337,
0.019617969170212746,
0.02800464630126953,
-0.015377088449895382,
-0.007964774034917355,
0.015153251588344574,
-0.012166503816843033,
0.035312291234731674,
-0.011316358111798763,
0.052609819918870926,
-0.06462395191192627,
0.03266112133860588,
0.05055393651127815,
-0.029240842908620834,
0.02317974343895912,
0.006039233412593603,
0.02144067920744419,
-0.014854415319859982,
-0.022278636693954468,
0.002938894322142005,
0.04273827373981476,
0.012608019635081291,
0.06971575319766998,
-0.02273380570113659,
-0.03950962796807289,
-0.0029984659049659967,
-0.008120015263557434,
-0.006959073711186647,
-0.024908890947699547,
0.00213885516859591,
0.006705936510115862,
0.07185476273298264,
0.0031340548302978277,
-0.02554059959948063,
-0.04232256859540939,
-0.027906980365514755,
0.009596824645996094,
0.01673852652311325,
-0.012407872825860977,
-0.029117608442902565,
0.011034678667783737,
-0.03489653021097183,
-0.02939935214817524,
0.03750954568386078,
-0.014476257376372814,
-0.015310117043554783,
-0.0061533791013062,
0.027489183470606804,
0.03840557113289833,
0.022513853386044502,
-0.045681942254304886,
0.015504448674619198,
-0.009857838973402977,
0.023242855444550514,
0.01947261206805706,
-0.03879394009709358,
-0.011601322330534458,
0.00015231544966809452,
0.022207072004675865,
-0.023385589942336082,
-0.008473515510559082,
-0.05459858104586601,
-0.02861352451145649,
0.029728591442108154,
0.004148769658058882,
0.020741911605000496,
0.017221547663211823,
0.015736771747469902,
0.014030179008841515,
0.01950429566204548,
0.02590090036392212,
0.0055443355813622475,
0.00403842655941844,
0.043264519423246384,
0.04707895591855049,
0.016536956652998924,
0.022500349208712578,
0.023092120885849,
0.04964105039834976,
0.04263375699520111,
0.009312983602285385,
-0.04018530622124672,
-0.0014466404682025313,
0.045496679842472076,
-0.03273671120405197,
0.03411193937063217,
-0.00035899324575439095,
0.010616878978908062,
-0.015008695423603058,
0.014798332937061787,
-0.007010667119175196,
0.004210208542644978,
0.03135456144809723,
0.023323815315961838,
0.026012271642684937,
-0.01628102920949459,
-0.014896067790687084,
0.021272681653499603,
0.009830111637711525,
0.01679893583059311,
-0.011055178940296173,
0.015354372560977936,
-0.010824115946888924,
0.005235366057604551,
-0.050585050135850906,
0.0032370653934776783,
-0.008548034355044365,
-0.00595325231552124,
-0.035640303045511246,
0.020224131643772125,
0.049531254917383194,
0.017213210463523865,
-0.021390626206994057,
0.031176188960671425,
-0.0462612621486187,
0.006069864146411419,
0.02234974503517151,
0.044639430940151215,
0.013710168190300465,
-0.008351976983249187,
-0.024638403207063675,
0.016292192041873932,
-0.008944851346313953,
0.025807637721300125,
0.017716215923428535,
-0.0017474754713475704,
-0.024173147976398468,
0.00020365578529890627,
-0.007298276759684086,
0.012036442756652832,
0.05576417222619057,
0.018013572320342064,
-0.03521984443068504,
0.03478352352976799,
-0.03165159001946449,
0.008773977868258953,
0.05307760089635849,
0.017026914283633232,
-0.04606315493583679,
0.02000230923295021,
-0.012322301045060158,
0.01622423715889454,
-0.053938888013362885,
0.016135327517986298,
-0.0170343816280365,
0.030743205919861794,
-0.0230458565056324,
0.08997432142496109,
-0.01773090288043022,
-0.0879688709974289,
-0.006446477957069874,
-0.015758726745843887,
-0.14644376933574677,
-0.009107803925871849,
0.02456503175199032,
0.000901468563824892,
0.016615498811006546,
0.03659280017018318,
-0.04240134358406067,
0.023409247398376465,
-0.007942219264805317,
0.03162989020347595,
0.005811749026179314,
-0.07663648575544357,
-0.039506375789642334,
0.009442254900932312,
-0.0008955012890510261,
-0.0161464661359787,
-0.02643612027168274,
-0.012839081697165966,
0.036810144782066345,
-0.02219129540026188,
-0.035129133611917496,
-0.031646110117435455,
0.020823586732149124,
0.006252238526940346,
0.0051253619603812695,
0.013756372965872288,
-0.0019714366644620895,
0.030334405601024628,
-0.02764585055410862,
-0.036443017423152924,
-0.04261205345392227,
0.06289707869291306,
-0.004759589675813913,
0.020160919055342674,
-0.0319785475730896,
0.019174156710505486,
0.04702683910727501,
-0.0747012346982956,
-0.018379710614681244,
-0.009713235311210155,
0.011391965672373772,
0.03251669928431511,
-0.0061050476506352425,
0.005082250107079744,
-0.03198469430208206,
-0.08037487417459488,
0.012080350890755653,
-0.019831068813800812,
-0.008772529661655426,
0.03649389371275902,
-0.04482654109597206,
-0.001097790664061904,
-0.02621631510555744,
-0.0019251704216003418,
-0.044611405581235886,
-0.0052987998351454735,
-0.004637768492102623,
0.00693456269800663,
0.01818106509745121,
0.001400067936629057,
-0.03916424885392189,
-0.04818469658493996,
0.045353855937719345,
-0.0023500840179622173,
-0.017580067738890648,
0.0038637120742350817,
0.028203610330820084,
0.024382052943110466,
0.058732885867357254,
-0.01891317032277584,
0.011866222135722637,
-0.03644941374659538,
0.01423786859959364,
0.004500733222812414,
0.00945377815514803,
0.027301393449306488,
0.05383327603340149,
-0.047596629709005356,
0.0023809445556253195,
-0.05019897222518921,
-0.0011679112212732434,
0.0180314052850008,
-0.0036967583000659943,
0.05299915373325348,
-0.0006192937726154923,
0.008644990622997284,
0.03014104813337326,
0.0074552143923938274,
0.06480257213115692,
0.23877382278442383,
0.026085540652275085,
-0.003083740593865514,
0.008468282409012318,
0.0055083706974983215,
-0.010150772519409657,
0.06011442467570305,
0.02586742863059044,
0.00033540077856741846,
-0.0037394945975393057,
-0.02033725567162037,
0.0028303011786192656,
-0.014880281873047352,
0.007698454428464174,
-0.007705667056143284,
0.04927195608615875,
-0.041389741003513336,
-0.04432640224695206,
0.07641695439815521,
-0.04033774510025978,
0.04268407076597214,
-0.0646076500415802,
0.005924860015511513,
0.003518229117617011,
-0.05404842644929886,
-0.038123469799757004,
-0.009256521239876747,
0.009533224627375603,
0.011112814769148827,
0.021513916552066803,
-0.03513185307383537,
-0.012333872728049755,
0.027939701452851295,
0.037720970809459686,
0.05783623456954956,
-0.01737258769571781,
-0.01202155277132988,
0.035197239369153976,
0.011130627244710922,
0.0328994020819664,
0.04204978048801422,
-0.030705638229846954,
-0.023026881739497185,
-0.0151066230610013,
0.035176970064640045,
0.019172200933098793,
-0.005369140300899744,
0.016708876937627792,
-0.022933725267648697,
0.0465627983212471,
-0.05253744497895241,
0.00296163372695446,
-0.000367853936040774,
0.015550809912383556,
-0.041121721267700195,
-0.01283931266516447,
-0.01850910484790802,
0.0075333090499043465,
-0.03391968831419945,
0.021185854449868202,
-0.004772036336362362,
0.0013281882274895906,
-0.01590755395591259,
-0.0018934861291199923,
0.016634909436106682,
0.008068385533988476,
-0.047779008746147156,
-0.040321897715330124,
0.06155659258365631,
0.02212090790271759,
0.007270623929798603,
0.0065720113925635815,
0.019250890240073204,
0.017799012362957,
0.013534924015402794,
0.03433440625667572,
0.012655450962483883,
-0.0017941782716661692,
0.009902284480631351,
-0.025384346023201942,
-0.06687092036008835,
-0.027590729296207428,
-0.012765641324222088,
-0.010789466090500355,
0.0032645578030496836,
0.009609907865524292,
-0.011600686237215996,
0.022265475243330002,
0.06638936698436737,
-0.04830849543213844,
-0.03947371244430542,
-0.04299378767609596,
-0.05018717050552368,
0.0029262711759656668,
-0.029876098036766052,
0.03373080864548683,
0.01448733452707529,
0.04960779473185539,
-0.01872001588344574,
0.005843259394168854,
0.01528969220817089,
0.025622176006436348,
0.029017440974712372,
-0.05391393229365349,
0.017888246104121208,
-0.06060606241226196,
0.010706458240747452,
-0.011250443756580353,
-0.05598703399300575,
-0.040693532675504684,
-0.02448360249400139,
0.0023383288644254208,
0.005233736243098974,
0.002296192804351449,
0.009479633532464504,
0.034523893147706985,
0.018176058307290077,
0.0075944047421216965,
0.039459068328142166,
0.034173399209976196,
0.0064042373560369015,
0.026160746812820435,
0.016772791743278503,
-0.017381155863404274,
-0.0064628841355443,
-0.02597079984843731,
-0.02499546855688095,
-0.03832503780722618,
0.027358917519450188,
-0.004059650003910065,
0.006029561161994934,
-0.025392992421984673,
-0.04330072179436684,
-0.0010053501464426517,
-0.006506877951323986,
-0.02752865105867386,
0.013181361369788647,
-0.002660078927874565,
-0.02344355545938015,
0.03286268934607506,
-0.02091286890208721,
-0.024456605315208435,
0.0071462104097008705,
-0.019179435446858406,
0.024363873526453972,
-0.014225365594029427,
0.006965641863644123,
-0.023563377559185028,
-0.0414842888712883,
0.020778922364115715,
0.00600343756377697,
0.012027306482195854,
0.009327703155577183,
-0.022761326283216476,
-0.023256123065948486,
0.055158719420433044,
0.005392896011471748,
-0.0616283155977726,
0.048327550292015076,
-0.020182209089398384,
-0.03169403597712517,
0.019753122702240944,
0.0007245171582326293,
0.07347399741411209,
-0.016332507133483887,
0.08880533277988434,
0.03835740312933922,
0.004759015049785376,
0.0030788376461714506,
-0.05593164637684822,
-0.052815031260252,
-0.025983206927776337,
-0.014250773005187511,
-0.029956646263599396,
0.013144762255251408,
0.0521182082593441,
0.014029199257493019,
0.042026735842227936,
0.0000017111424313043244,
-0.07887686789035797,
0.031565386801958084,
-0.003227889770641923,
-0.007651187013834715,
-0.0016467829700559378,
-0.028240857645869255,
0.007347573526203632,
0.005574776325374842,
-0.012931456789374352,
0.061658430844545364,
-0.03920884057879448,
-0.010959473438560963,
0.10378552973270416,
0.03843460604548454,
-0.026616839691996574,
0.02289087325334549,
0.027677685022354126,
-0.013837822712957859,
0.03675781562924385,
0.018913930281996727,
-0.047162026166915894,
-0.027419228106737137,
-0.012107426300644875,
-0.0290325116366148,
-0.017938559874892235,
0.06017965450882912,
0.005170747637748718,
-0.00517842685803771,
-0.00047267175978049636,
-0.025606054812669754,
-0.05745236948132515,
0.028318386524915695,
-0.004905698820948601,
-0.04740922898054123,
0.004040262196213007,
0.027170589193701744,
0.02121204510331154,
0.019507596269249916,
0.015243276953697205,
0.0009226618567481637,
-0.03504259139299393,
-0.012291098944842815,
-0.050734955817461014,
0.004406607709825039,
-0.07216386497020721,
0.0026653409004211426,
0.006571280304342508,
-0.017810797318816185,
0.031231718137860298,
0.029856659471988678,
-0.030004488304257393,
0.0070775654166936874,
-0.06392393261194229,
0.010490902699530125,
-0.023267647251486778,
-0.036802832037210464,
-0.0019201849354431033,
0.025297783315181732,
0.003197191981598735,
0.004364469554275274,
-0.006010548211634159,
0.02329188771545887,
-0.013162841089069843,
0.034152429550886154,
0.07394775748252869,
0.01589028351008892,
-0.04178566858172417,
-0.0033197428565472364,
0.017578471451997757,
0.0005520633421838284,
0.06387989223003387,
0.010886359959840775,
0.02243891917169094,
-0.010154309682548046,
-0.026511456817388535,
-0.009580094367265701,
0.0036482203286141157,
-0.02867795154452324,
0.010648042894899845,
-0.04148450866341591,
-0.0633331760764122,
0.0017021794337779284,
0.02762908861041069,
0.015598710626363754,
-0.021372979506850243,
-0.026852501556277275,
-0.05422394722700119,
0.032885558903217316,
-0.03926195949316025,
-0.002067434834316373,
0.003560615936294198,
-0.008480120450258255,
0.012313277460634708,
-0.04372294247150421,
-0.04516347870230675,
0.019135816022753716,
0.006014821585267782,
-0.008924185298383236,
0.004542114678770304,
0.018451252952218056,
0.007991273887455463,
0.03505091741681099,
0.0006534301792271435,
-0.0291680209338665,
0.013503672555088997,
-0.021555760875344276,
0.0011280982289463282,
0.036197811365127563,
-0.00724034383893013,
0.012464026920497417,
-0.018056178465485573,
0.01617773249745369,
0.0013902278151363134,
-0.0008295234874822199,
0.05124228447675705,
0.010901183821260929,
0.019999023526906967,
0.005010404158383608,
0.0039046050515025854,
-0.005787513218820095,
0.02661432884633541,
-0.03016795590519905,
-0.011439123190939426,
-0.0010409870883449912,
-0.023390045389533043,
-0.017075270414352417,
0.022791622206568718,
0.04950561001896858,
-0.05360301211476326,
-0.04839961230754852,
0.019978202879428864,
-0.037131424993276596,
-0.03150135278701782,
0.008267486467957497,
-0.005649628583341837,
-0.018718646839261055,
0.02174208126962185,
0.026418397203087807,
-0.007468827534466982,
-0.004227860365062952,
0.021573234349489212,
-0.008145025931298733,
0.013552057556807995,
-0.024929838255047798,
-0.005887923762202263,
-0.028831807896494865,
-0.009950798936188221,
0.027303293347358704,
-0.03983520716428757,
-0.02899504452943802,
0.0026170769706368446,
-0.06051493063569069,
0.0008819731301628053,
0.0029181945137679577,
-0.017885975539684296,
0.033019062131643295,
-0.0005382775561884046,
0.0042577702552080154,
-0.012929861433804035,
0.035100776702165604,
-0.03457740694284439,
-0.005217134486883879,
-0.07249613851308823,
0.09615004807710648,
-0.0004924881504848599,
0.006858415901660919,
0.031492479145526886,
0.0004235137312207371,
0.00017263262998312712,
0.04235420748591423,
0.016651883721351624,
-0.05462706834077835,
0.058339331299066544,
-0.029498184099793434,
-0.00043498139712028205,
0.009763483889400959,
0.019677169620990753,
0.01963411085307598,
0.014550677500665188,
0.01303912978619337,
-0.02675352618098259,
-0.008625073358416557,
-0.012512489221990108,
0.0073117949068546295,
-0.008223915472626686,
-0.00925159826874733,
0.007261434569954872,
0.0037258693482726812,
0.014086342416703701,
0.013749197125434875,
0.018417514860630035,
0.012629825621843338,
0.031273484230041504,
-0.003072696039453149,
0.011089109815657139,
-0.03598875179886818,
-0.0204220712184906,
-0.013874610885977745,
-0.018484488129615784,
-0.014855565503239632,
0.01239350438117981,
0.008713755756616592,
-0.03984612971544266,
-0.043986331671476364,
-0.006961039733141661,
-0.0229305699467659,
0.015602272003889084,
0.0553264245390892,
0.008233366534113884,
0.01819983310997486,
0.04464040324091911,
-0.012955819256603718,
0.08457475155591965,
-0.04840276762843132,
-0.03107629157602787,
-0.15298201143741608,
0.006867488846182823,
0.00788321252912283,
0.03393081948161125,
-0.043328337371349335,
-0.01646244153380394,
-0.022123489528894424,
0.020862283185124397,
-0.021229567006230354,
-0.03485964611172676,
0.01568313129246235,
0.01012388151139021,
0.00025200616801157594,
-0.014620679430663586,
-0.053024351596832275,
-0.019097905606031418,
0.006283763330429792,
-0.06297000497579575,
-0.005884400103241205,
0.023573577404022217,
-0.022213920950889587,
0.0019924843218177557,
-0.04294832795858383,
0.006856651045382023,
0.023720256984233856,
-0.0053239790722727776,
-0.042722541838884354,
-0.055966660380363464,
-0.06084199622273445,
0.004289101343601942,
-0.032629676163196564,
0.008645523339509964,
0.02384752780199051,
-0.005244024097919464,
-0.033994320780038834,
-0.000178140340722166,
-0.021754540503025055,
0.022252393886446953,
-0.04767747223377228,
-0.0009805287700146437,
-0.01154855266213417,
0.028175974264740944,
-0.024380458518862724,
-0.017367983236908913,
0.01902216300368309,
0.05331798642873764,
0.006128998473286629,
-0.01752684824168682,
-0.014953295700252056,
-0.011913151480257511,
-0.04135120287537575,
0.007644051685929298,
0.00931655615568161,
0.023541858419775963,
-0.001517763826996088,
-0.008894961327314377,
-0.015702126547694206,
-0.006680162623524666,
0.04285575821995735,
0.07601919770240784,
0.024074818938970566,
0.019064702093601227,
-0.0025129809509962797,
-0.06241763010621071,
-0.0009769119787961245,
0.003136000595986843,
-0.049230314791202545,
-0.02605956420302391,
-0.026965606957674026,
-0.017208972945809364,
-0.00385922659188509,
0.006554208695888519,
-0.013304847292602062,
-0.06384073197841644,
0.002046727342531085,
0.007232653442770243,
-0.010881667025387287,
0.0009213691228069365,
-0.02259114384651184,
0.012547747232019901,
-0.013453977182507515,
0.017087314277887344,
-0.010568853467702866,
-0.01378844864666462,
0.05404080078005791,
0.016451653093099594,
-0.020269552245736122,
-0.034514639526605606,
-0.004745301324874163,
-0.0378691628575325,
-0.041136980056762695,
-0.0004075450706295669,
-0.022687356919050217,
0.022374756634235382,
0.008354860357940197,
0.03532745689153671,
-0.03498539328575134,
0.014874097891151905,
-0.01581820845603943,
-0.019305380061268806,
-0.01608695276081562,
-0.043817419558763504,
0.05176810920238495,
-0.005723136477172375,
-0.017193591222167015,
0.0028055806178599596,
0.004933581221848726,
0.0005589903448708355,
0.025168053805828094,
-0.0028929458931088448,
0.024245359003543854,
-0.008232399821281433,
-0.016780119389295578,
0.015529313124716282,
-0.05176433175802231,
0.02299928292632103,
-0.0012451200745999813,
0.020004959776997566,
0.03246697410941124,
-0.006983412895351648,
0.0033860020339488983,
-0.0564066581428051,
0.02605290152132511,
-0.014484018087387085,
0.018193446099758148,
0.007797921542078257,
0.04451178386807442,
-0.0012353844940662384,
0.040573038160800934,
-0.04009918123483658,
0.033967819064855576,
-0.01015816442668438,
0.003941085189580917,
0.016405388712882996,
0.051716532558202744,
0.06069318205118179,
-0.028735632076859474,
0.024764489382505417,
-0.03354876860976219,
-0.06869921088218689,
0.0010742724407464266,
-0.01597283035516739,
-0.004842960741370916,
0.003474373836070299,
-0.033611223101615906,
-0.017097031697630882,
0.038961343467235565,
0.020875386893749237,
-0.03693103417754173,
-0.06828448176383972,
-0.02293780818581581,
0.004319471772760153,
0.019955405965447426,
0.06519056111574173,
0.013457702472805977,
-0.02986527606844902,
0.010130477137863636,
-0.02594858966767788,
0.031398672610521317,
0.05963854119181633,
0.04107484593987465,
-0.002200118266046047,
-0.003160609398037195,
-0.012026913464069366,
-0.05725909397006035,
0.0463608056306839,
-0.012092114426195621,
-0.011627367697656155,
0.01261937152594328,
0.006567435804754496,
0.0012279797811061144,
0.03279934450984001,
-0.017860673367977142,
0.013197731226682663,
0.029109222814440727,
-0.029384370893239975,
0.002233323408290744,
0.008905178867280483,
0.01192522794008255,
-0.05581013113260269,
0.006932184100151062,
0.04620328173041344,
0.03446052223443985,
-0.005550883244723082,
-0.004987963009625673,
0.047908954322338104,
-0.02101946249604225,
0.0027664632070809603,
0.022392798215150833,
-0.03925296664237976,
-0.006591326557099819,
-0.018593475222587585,
0.03878146409988403,
0.008498390205204487,
0.01601523347198963,
0.04184751957654953,
-0.0020980092231184244,
-0.00008224065095419064,
-0.021755674853920937,
0.024540502578020096,
0.014262628741562366,
-0.006180025637149811,
-0.024503666907548904,
0.010447134263813496,
-0.027987316250801086,
-0.0390620082616806,
0.009391670115292072,
-0.0070261419750750065,
-0.05025753378868103,
0.04810880869626999,
-0.04071129485964775,
-0.019471706822514534,
-0.04712110385298729,
0.06751935184001923,
-0.005189515650272369,
0.022386079654097557,
0.027314206585288048,
0.013889837078750134,
0.04098911210894585,
-0.028959864750504494,
0.014381769113242626,
0.02528640255331993,
0.0002543820592109114,
-0.030192608013749123,
-0.007244980428367853,
0.01694796234369278,
-0.02852817066013813,
-0.03536593168973923,
-0.01561745721846819,
0.021932220086455345,
-0.024689029902219772,
-0.035474348813295364,
-0.013699241913855076,
-0.007797994650900364,
0.010896866209805012,
0.005557363852858543,
-0.013404038734734058,
-0.0160873681306839,
-0.00912062544375658,
-0.015371713787317276,
-0.011786910705268383,
0.0036980295553803444,
-0.012451224960386753,
0.012543471530079842
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:18
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
102The second matter was that it only emerged during the hearing in cross-examination that the rental from the River Road property was received in a CBA account operated by the defendant's son on her behalf. It will be recalled that the defendant owned a 50% interest in that property.
103Both these matters are serious matters that affect the credit of the defendant.
104It was suggested by the plaintiff that the defendant was prone to exaggeration and reference was made to the change in paragraph 211 of her affidavit where the words, "hundreds" in one place was changed to "many".
This was in reference to the occasions when the defendant alleged the plaintiff said, "Someone should give you a fucking smack in the mouth". This to my mind does not illustrate a general tendency to exaggerate her evidence.
105What is of more concern is her failure to answer questions. On numerous occasions the defendant commenced an answer to a question, "Oh my goodness" or "goodness". Very often what followed on these occasions was either a lack of recall or a suggestion that someone else be asked about it or even more frankly, on one occasion, "Oh my goodness, I do not know how to answer that question".
106On another occasion, "Oh goodness. I - I don't - I don't recall specifically, no".
107On one occasion when she was asked what her current medication was she said, "Goodness, I think you will have to ask the doctors/I think it is - ".
108Although there are some matters which indicate that the defendant has not put her case forward to the Court honestly in that she has not given all necessary financial information I did not get the impression that she was prone to exaggeration. She did appear, however, to evade answering some questions. Accordingly, her evidence has to be treated with caution.
The individual assaults
109I note that an assault consists of:
"Intentionally creating in another person an apprehension of imminent harmful or offensive contact. If the threat is actually carried out, the whole incident is properly described as an 'assault and battery'. Usually both offences occur in rapid succession, and in common parlance the word 'assault' is frequently used as including a battery.
But the one offence may be committed without the other. A battery may be inflicted on a victim who does not expect it and therefore cannot complain of an assault, as where the victim is struck from behind without warning. Conversely there may be an assault without battery if the threat to inflict lawful force is not in fact carried out.
Assault allows redress for the creation of an undesired emotional state unaccompanied by external injury. This is unusual for tort law, but it was decided at an early stage that assault warranted legal redress, partly as an aid to punishing offenders who had attempted to commit the crime of battery, partly because it minimised the temptation to retaliate.
Since the gist of assault lies in the apprehension of impending contact, the effect on the victim's mind created by the threat is the crux, not whether the defendant actually had the intention to follow it up.
The intent required for the tort of assault is the desire to arouse apprehension of physical contact, not necessarily to inflict actual harm. Hence it is actionable to point a pistol for the mere purpose of frightening.
It is sufficient if the threat would have aroused an expectation of physical aggression in the mind of a reasonable person not afflicted with exaggerated fears or peculiar and abnormal timidity. But the plaintiff need not have been actually frightened: apprehension is not the same as fear, and one too courageous to be intimidated is nonetheless entitled to redress.
There must, however, be an apparent ability to carry out the threat immediately. Lunging at someone who is obviously out of range does not count as assault, unless the intended victim had reasonable grounds for fearing that the defendant would immediately have come within range and landed a blow.
|
[
0.01711815968155861,
0.022758089005947113,
-0.04943518340587616,
-0.00876966305077076,
-0.02800111100077629,
-0.04319395124912262,
0.041074275970458984,
0.03498636186122894,
0.015966234728693962,
-0.019273407757282257,
-0.0025358563289046288,
0.05529344454407692,
-0.06150369718670845,
-0.018915409222245216,
0.010790275409817696,
0.005558972246944904,
0.02956128679215908,
0.0002910358307417482,
-0.04294353723526001,
-0.034017011523246765,
-0.008175118826329708,
0.0033982896711677313,
-0.013044478371739388,
0.036352649331092834,
-0.024600202217698097,
0.017031237483024597,
-0.03650876134634018,
-0.02094757929444313,
-0.01957189105451107,
0.003928052261471748,
0.005849016364663839,
0.0059530483558773994,
0.03625606745481491,
-0.0062990025617182255,
-0.005132391583174467,
-0.01216653361916542,
-0.04107273370027542,
-0.021349119022488594,
-0.007477549836039543,
0.009787785820662975,
0.014954633079469204,
0.004683778155595064,
-0.004572421312332153,
-0.022143369540572166,
0.026454130187630653,
-0.032172270119190216,
-0.0017957286909222603,
-0.043501630425453186,
0.0051623000763356686,
-0.0240192674100399,
-0.009114926680922508,
0.022914689034223557,
0.027578219771385193,
-0.030604245141148567,
0.0004898151964880526,
-0.0018948778742924333,
0.037497494369745255,
0.021803369745612144,
-0.041853614151477814,
-0.0008194396505132318,
-0.020393921062350273,
-0.04930383712053299,
-0.046441927552223206,
-0.03836436942219734,
-0.020610768347978592,
0.06645698100328445,
-0.018191222101449966,
-0.009756338782608509,
-0.010010643862187862,
-0.030436387285590172,
0.008569233119487762,
-0.003845969680696726,
-0.03863444924354553,
-0.0034004671033471823,
-0.06899530440568924,
0.020865503698587418,
0.05054226145148277,
0.004794001579284668,
-0.018815388903021812,
0.021834179759025574,
0.02695472165942192,
0.01770808733999729,
-0.012043753638863564,
0.016554808244109154,
-0.00019568718562368304,
0.02241680398583412,
-0.02467108704149723,
-0.045651745051145554,
0.03029492497444153,
-0.010667056776583195,
-0.006448823027312756,
0.0387919545173645,
0.023478610441088676,
-0.04916064068675041,
-0.007803544867783785,
0.002590051619336009,
-0.04236892610788345,
-0.006832533981651068,
-0.015751751139760017,
0.01057079154998064,
0.02457438036799431,
0.03343385457992554,
0.004192583728581667,
-0.04960855841636658,
0.0038052788004279137,
0.011130218394100666,
0.03086973913013935,
0.024250276386737823,
0.049729060381650925,
-0.002136095892637968,
0.006691677495837212,
0.035556573420763016,
0.003717113519087434,
-0.01240200363099575,
0.0034233126789331436,
-0.0005289108376018703,
0.005632856395095587,
-0.009821944870054722,
0.022142833098769188,
0.01795002445578575,
0.016212178394198418,
0.05516377463936806,
0.07834921777248383,
-0.02045990526676178,
-0.024542173370718956,
0.016458038240671158,
-0.03854617103934288,
0.0009647816768847406,
-0.034863390028476715,
0.04791359603404999,
0.03543940559029579,
-0.02540060132741928,
-0.049318116158246994,
-0.042395468801259995,
-0.022457363083958626,
-0.010043799877166748,
0.018285922706127167,
0.03516937047243118,
0.010623540729284286,
-0.037758342921733856,
0.050767458975315094,
0.04023627191781998,
0.02402365580201149,
-0.019048644229769707,
0.00026169835473410785,
-0.024518176913261414,
0.043555743992328644,
-0.038127124309539795,
-0.010304209776222706,
-0.015631619840860367,
-0.00034168854472227395,
-0.009279437363147736,
0.05048287659883499,
-0.03661525994539261,
0.035004813224077225,
-0.041197698563337326,
0.020757028833031654,
-0.021573493257164955,
0.03107590600848198,
0.010432019829750061,
0.05999375134706497,
-0.0011594818206503987,
-0.014513799920678139,
-0.026224622502923012,
0.012830238789319992,
0.028373103588819504,
-0.016100315377116203,
0.033297643065452576,
-0.03749622404575348,
-0.004908885806798935,
0.058426760137081146,
-0.003701493376865983,
0.03336724638938904,
-0.02857050485908985,
0.024504564702510834,
0.013823596760630608,
0.05177147313952446,
0.00731209060177207,
-0.01087172981351614,
-0.040700387209653854,
-0.0009455980034545064,
0.01350138895213604,
0.009224704466760159,
-0.006833638995885849,
-0.015106389299035072,
-0.00279233162291348,
-0.050099294632673264,
-0.0010439592879265547,
0.02480371855199337,
0.04083871841430664,
-0.02476450800895691,
-0.034853365272283554,
0.0345587283372879,
0.003891643602401018,
0.0603514164686203,
-0.04717729240655899,
0.021428601816296577,
-0.017540665343403816,
0.042696066200733185,
-0.017100349068641663,
0.0051599168218672276,
0.027501888573169708,
0.048417963087558746,
0.011764183640480042,
-0.032720111310482025,
0.011455816216766834,
-0.11840365827083588,
0.024561012163758278,
0.01964155025780201,
-0.07836121320724487,
0.0068005165085196495,
0.030446602031588554,
0.05665497109293938,
0.01195948850363493,
-0.030475398525595665,
-0.015623870305716991,
0.027270380407571793,
-0.005284685175865889,
-0.008522900752723217,
0.0023633118253201246,
-0.006858694367110729,
-0.0014425728004425764,
-0.01524722296744585,
-0.009417676366865635,
0.013189113698899746,
0.03139767050743103,
-0.02425449527800083,
0.014305821619927883,
-0.013053731061518192,
0.0019226535223424435,
0.014040270820260048,
0.04164007306098938,
0.005288796033710241,
-0.03391476348042488,
0.023132041096687317,
0.011731265112757683,
0.012413125485181808,
-0.0006787303718738258,
0.021884484216570854,
0.005979352165013552,
0.01957727037370205,
-0.04071171209216118,
0.025112593546509743,
0.01130074355751276,
-0.007532315328717232,
-0.05542304366827011,
-0.0017835779581218958,
0.038104843348264694,
0.00921703316271305,
-0.009768434800207615,
-0.005086383782327175,
-0.024893339723348618,
0.005223861895501614,
-0.03443791717290878,
0.024151982739567757,
0.01895131543278694,
-0.0036674528382718563,
0.004797954577952623,
0.0183478444814682,
0.011584963649511337,
-0.009456810541450977,
0.02190735563635826,
0.056401800364255905,
0.018727172166109085,
-0.006520104128867388,
-0.024158667773008347,
-0.04061892628669739,
-0.019624952226877213,
-0.0017770023550838232,
-0.003196193603798747,
-0.0010149097070097923,
-0.04404672235250473,
0.0022800974547863007,
-0.023335019126534462,
0.020953776314854622,
0.0677972361445427,
0.015030838549137115,
-0.018281511962413788,
0.03660111501812935,
0.023547900840640068,
0.018268315121531487,
-0.035266630351543427,
0.00038885543472133577,
-0.012137319892644882,
0.02847319468855858,
0.033063068985939026,
-0.002314438810572028,
-0.07450556755065918,
0.0319112166762352,
-0.03955310955643654,
0.020050136372447014,
-0.05107913166284561,
0.06398842483758926,
-0.01312605943530798,
-0.05867457017302513,
-0.05060432478785515,
-0.026137549430131912,
-0.15423649549484253,
-0.019404476508498192,
0.026800936087965965,
0.03587550297379494,
0.006054323632270098,
0.04327584430575371,
-0.026038803160190582,
0.006924494169652462,
0.03219436854124069,
0.022283434867858887,
0.0012148839887231588,
-0.05716187506914139,
-0.00010708143236115575,
0.013137506321072578,
0.0453503355383873,
-0.024565793573856354,
-0.034074753522872925,
0.039462681859731674,
0.04448733478784561,
0.00005403567774919793,
0.005522029008716345,
-0.03822854906320572,
-0.006939363200217485,
-0.002216990338638425,
-0.032935187220573425,
0.04914219677448273,
0.036456409841775894,
0.016381632536649704,
-0.03146614134311676,
-0.019746581092476845,
-0.08343399316072464,
-0.004901588894426823,
-0.013930500485002995,
0.030567090958356857,
-0.009600337594747543,
0.06624229997396469,
0.0003518915909808129,
-0.013047337532043457,
-0.019503086805343628,
-0.013377971015870571,
0.038179486989974976,
0.06325944513082504,
-0.02236339822411537,
0.011206184513866901,
0.0070769302546978,
-0.0688483715057373,
-0.026085492223501205,
-0.008757567033171654,
-0.05711318552494049,
0.019798843190073967,
-0.022840814664959908,
0.009522035717964172,
-0.040336936712265015,
-0.006891954690217972,
-0.03175800293684006,
-0.03558396175503731,
0.053734492510557175,
0.050530292093753815,
-0.012002541683614254,
-0.0018245915416628122,
-0.006317966151982546,
-0.0354757159948349,
-0.0065007624216377735,
0.005666426382958889,
-0.04033847898244858,
-0.02678884193301201,
0.047320593148469925,
0.010561371222138405,
0.010786162689328194,
-0.010494065470993519,
0.039038557559251785,
-0.05737568438053131,
-0.005335518624633551,
0.023688772693276405,
-0.016359657049179077,
0.044619858264923096,
-0.0024037547409534454,
-0.005895711947232485,
-0.04021842032670975,
-0.11019740998744965,
0.03180185705423355,
0.023590141907334328,
0.0007840326288715005,
0.0334576852619648,
0.012245493941009045,
-0.019705088809132576,
0.025255823507905006,
-0.01451339665800333,
0.04490630328655243,
0.25726011395454407,
0.01586797460913658,
-0.013108211569488049,
0.024875428527593613,
-0.02359035052359104,
0.0014511399203911424,
0.005062949378043413,
0.031392812728881836,
0.010716631077229977,
-0.04382588714361191,
-0.015718618407845497,
0.03689643368124962,
-0.00706462562084198,
0.020942185074090958,
-0.038207173347473145,
0.04487005993723869,
-0.07255396991968155,
-0.015246756374835968,
0.06934211403131485,
0.003140913788229227,
0.01333802379667759,
-0.02077847719192505,
0.03252774477005005,
-0.0020579653792083263,
-0.05443846061825752,
-0.03886603191494942,
-0.00733909709379077,
0.0376012921333313,
0.01388399675488472,
0.020227033644914627,
-0.047506555914878845,
-0.0016554767498746514,
0.02608238160610199,
-0.010810280218720436,
0.00241899979300797,
-0.004911740310490131,
-0.010711165145039558,
-0.0014785976381972432,
-0.09962515532970428,
0.03201647475361824,
0.007699796464294195,
-0.0439889095723629,
-0.03202717751264572,
-0.03228019177913666,
-0.017107544466853142,
0.012889980338513851,
-0.013726671226322651,
0.030852224677801132,
-0.028271321207284927,
0.019743921235203743,
-0.012466591782867908,
-0.0032933331094682217,
-0.020345548167824745,
0.04199749603867531,
-0.03681417554616928,
-0.015980787575244904,
0.003116497304290533,
0.04403768479824066,
-0.0015577210579067469,
0.06217101961374283,
0.006527767051011324,
0.027402954176068306,
-0.06756724417209625,
0.026751559227705002,
-0.0008723658975213766,
-0.0008623585454188287,
-0.02104506641626358,
-0.04557574912905693,
0.03552000969648361,
0.008840059861540794,
0.029180554673075676,
0.010009054094552994,
-0.015241742134094238,
0.01817421242594719,
0.030021801590919495,
0.0038475021719932556,
-0.009379052557051182,
0.0055292570032179356,
0.003636898472905159,
-0.005764836445450783,
-0.015786580741405487,
-0.03709971159696579,
0.002408217638731003,
-0.021565156057476997,
0.014588577672839165,
0.012912851758301258,
-0.0013436893932521343,
0.044364165514707565,
0.03771030902862549,
-0.01183279138058424,
-0.012730016373097897,
-0.01981312967836857,
-0.03042958304286003,
-0.020092429593205452,
0.04414893686771393,
0.021930629387497902,
0.028850018978118896,
-0.026718242093920708,
-0.01700255274772644,
-0.026062021031975746,
0.0015440976712852716,
0.0014529721811413765,
0.05169673264026642,
0.0014696570578962564,
0.03778471425175667,
-0.06354957818984985,
0.004293315578252077,
0.011851136572659016,
-0.04765332117676735,
-0.02514490857720375,
-0.009392020292580128,
0.003375357249751687,
-0.0045518274419009686,
-0.005461829248815775,
0.020724888890981674,
0.03892933204770088,
-0.061443548649549484,
0.004408619832247496,
0.053542256355285645,
0.060897406190633774,
-0.007094081025570631,
0.0006095386925153434,
-0.0005534102092497051,
0.00935003999620676,
-0.021748820319771767,
-0.03348285332322121,
-0.00698676984757185,
0.01764395646750927,
-0.00698441406711936,
0.018450874835252762,
-0.010741818696260452,
-0.02864975854754448,
-0.0628046914935112,
0.02621479704976082,
0.06018111854791641,
-0.026568908244371414,
0.005454879719763994,
0.0061834221705794334,
-0.0427427738904953,
0.008190610446035862,
0.005949221085757017,
0.02263658493757248,
-0.05929037183523178,
0.02545991539955139,
0.009135760366916656,
0.0334392786026001,
-0.08507668226957321,
0.02523830160498619,
-0.042557306587696075,
-0.0069219502620399,
0.03627951443195343,
-0.0001756064302753657,
-0.016684165224432945,
-0.04975655674934387,
0.012964748777449131,
0.0021473653614521027,
0.0036323589738458395,
-0.006385984364897013,
0.025586921721696854,
-0.04234425351023674,
0.013363275676965714,
-0.012275761924684048,
-0.06641533970832825,
0.054739441722631454,
0.04434262588620186,
0.057017769664525986,
0.00744915334507823,
0.06984072923660278,
-0.01021338626742363,
-0.013276633806526661,
-0.0063975779339671135,
-0.035294778645038605,
-0.023076308891177177,
0.002025117166340351,
0.02206617221236229,
-0.019491661339998245,
-0.020570699125528336,
0.008690408430993557,
0.01549042109400034,
-0.013060840778052807,
0.03976793959736824,
-0.0021343501284718513,
-0.029665593057870865,
0.058097340166568756,
-0.0051740240305662155,
-0.00008301038906211033,
0.04207352176308632,
-0.010660296306014061,
0.017968731001019478,
-0.029096947982907295,
0.0022599450312554836,
0.09072490781545639,
-0.02343224734067917,
0.0002873192715924233,
0.037552397698163986,
0.020553525537252426,
0.05230308696627617,
0.03713042661547661,
0.0017712184926494956,
-0.011181075125932693,
-0.0031350194476544857,
-0.016375523060560226,
-0.006864134222269058,
0.03184789791703224,
0.03645102307200432,
0.001254378934390843,
-0.004608831834048033,
0.014327626675367355,
-0.021187542006373405,
-0.02439720742404461,
0.02693977765738964,
0.03639039024710655,
-0.011479610577225685,
-0.047077879309654236,
0.0021656802855432034,
0.0033022540155798197,
-0.00724254222586751,
0.015461089089512825,
-0.03432794660329819,
-0.01535833440721035,
0.004618861712515354,
-0.047335922718048096,
0.045566000044345856,
-0.06671945750713348,
-0.009825392626225948,
-0.00500528234988451,
-0.021003413945436478,
-0.0018453444354236126,
-0.024728044867515564,
-0.011787481606006622,
-0.00482981838285923,
-0.025751281529664993,
0.01023564487695694,
-0.004525991156697273,
0.010701627470552921,
0.0001698158885119483,
0.02359170652925968,
0.00705684395506978,
-0.015449686907231808,
-0.031433094292879105,
-0.016996202990412712,
0.026748763397336006,
0.030540259554982185,
0.020574823021888733,
-0.007245020009577274,
-0.013666315004229546,
-0.05557582154870033,
-0.021098950877785683,
0.01760639250278473,
0.012391860596835613,
-0.010614369995892048,
-0.034111928194761276,
0.01993829384446144,
-0.04270178824663162,
0.01211418304592371,
0.04178248345851898,
0.01915467530488968,
0.01369466632604599,
-0.06267230957746506,
-0.0010515659814700484,
0.009595534764230251,
0.021048784255981445,
0.011581124737858772,
-0.018837569281458855,
-0.05343572795391083,
-0.06492006778717041,
0.005946800112724304,
-0.02547421120107174,
-0.0191040001809597,
-0.08029968291521072,
-0.009930729866027832,
-0.007978643290698528,
-0.031334683299064636,
-0.008588945493102074,
0.002687619999051094,
-0.04416825249791145,
-0.04865361005067825,
0.04777713119983673,
0.04609121009707451,
-0.028952831402420998,
0.00992653053253889,
-0.005683883558958769,
0.010413958691060543,
0.05121086165308952,
-0.0061086686328053474,
-0.0139473183080554,
0.054327163845300674,
-0.0021105760242789984,
0.004085668828338385,
-0.010489691980183125,
0.03719262033700943,
-0.019702481105923653,
-0.030123330652713776,
0.009789299219846725,
0.012526826933026314,
0.003223347244784236,
0.009458547458052635,
0.06803382188081741,
-0.0003423568850848824,
0.012206420302391052,
-0.007407223340123892,
-0.011977072805166245,
-0.020372722297906876,
-0.029828881844878197,
-0.025138631463050842,
-0.01113370805978775,
-0.03380782529711723,
-0.026056820526719093,
-0.004703051410615444,
-0.005197965539991856,
0.015943773090839386,
-0.06917325407266617,
0.012417539022862911,
-0.056509438902139664,
0.026252731680870056,
-0.00535433879122138,
0.005320728290826082,
-0.03666107356548309,
0.03851323947310448,
0.024760983884334564,
0.02063027396798134,
-0.017614297568798065,
-0.02699822559952736,
0.0258623119443655,
-0.050797753036022186,
0.016508379951119423,
-0.018663380295038223,
-0.02905469387769699,
0.009911942295730114,
0.02211657166481018,
-0.00887139979749918,
-0.0025701774284243584,
-0.026385491713881493,
-0.009897671639919281,
0.03726090118288994,
0.025766707956790924,
0.002141704550012946,
-0.020018652081489563,
0.0261229295283556,
-0.024587398394942284,
-0.01574750617146492,
-0.005284463055431843,
0.07238788902759552,
-0.0006655841134488583,
-0.027606358751654625,
-0.038981325924396515,
-0.007807491812855005,
0.017158688977360725,
-0.0018023266457021236,
0.034236326813697815,
0.016054389998316765,
0.002440888900309801,
-0.039786212146282196,
-0.06043114885687828,
0.04030551016330719,
-0.02997785247862339,
-0.021189771592617035,
-0.008626054041087627,
0.058924056589603424,
0.00954623892903328,
-0.029383577406406403,
0.036922089755535126,
0.013634659349918365,
-0.05592947453260422,
0.000731967797037214,
-0.006302505265921354,
-0.004524013493210077,
0.012793083675205708,
-0.017996855080127716,
-0.005094319116324186,
0.010084973648190498,
0.003291965462267399,
-0.012234157882630825,
0.018337346613407135,
-0.03276804834604263,
0.03491503372788429,
0.04086229205131531,
-0.018057983368635178,
0.003987776581197977,
-0.014313113875687122,
-0.01570415310561657,
-0.04238429665565491,
-0.03899555653333664,
-0.011054230853915215,
0.014440212398767471,
-0.011344526894390583,
-0.037677496671676636,
0.01081273052841425,
0.013516192324459553,
0.01644604653120041,
-0.04046046361327171,
0.03154471889138222,
-0.022794846445322037,
0.0074773626402020454,
-0.1484094262123108,
0.01607642136514187,
0.006044057663530111,
-0.017523514106869698,
-0.031123366206884384,
-0.013896215707063675,
-0.0356362983584404,
0.007766869384795427,
-0.03157642483711243,
0.027474461123347282,
0.0012073094258084893,
0.03693794459104538,
0.02674221247434616,
-0.008683978579938412,
-0.0468367338180542,
0.05028117075562477,
-0.031570758670568466,
-0.004079124424606562,
-0.03184633329510689,
0.07040572911500931,
-0.0009362563141621649,
-0.02663339301943779,
0.03037753701210022,
-0.012488869950175285,
0.010926080867648125,
-0.003969797398895025,
-0.08141201734542847,
-0.033170852810144424,
-0.03147145360708237,
0.008339759893715382,
-0.00009094909182749689,
-0.004611892160028219,
0.026668114587664604,
0.02400633879005909,
0.01951787807047367,
0.00235181488096714,
0.00704516377300024,
0.0047001042403280735,
-0.010423023253679276,
-0.04115556925535202,
-0.03659128397703171,
0.020254328846931458,
0.0024209453258663416,
-0.02983991615474224,
0.02954898774623871,
0.0522715263068676,
-0.016580840572714806,
0.024955743923783302,
-0.03552459925413132,
-0.010153996758162975,
-0.0499131940305233,
0.04932110011577606,
-0.017283430323004723,
-0.0038716753479093313,
-0.009068727493286133,
0.009528637863695621,
-0.037342220544815063,
-0.040082234889268875,
0.004169771913439035,
0.06591172516345978,
-0.03221752122044563,
0.012442751787602901,
-0.028402622789144516,
0.003923774231225252,
0.02969854138791561,
0.04197006672620773,
-0.04140667989850044,
-0.023664284497499466,
0.0004920732462778687,
-0.028156500309705734,
-0.010280178859829903,
-0.0342232808470726,
0.04751107469201088,
-0.009983362630009651,
0.024786828085780144,
0.019296061247587204,
-0.01102036889642477,
0.02066916972398758,
-0.038932979106903076,
-0.04358004033565521,
0.0007806594367139041,
-0.010019916109740734,
-0.004567660391330719,
-0.017526913434267044,
0.0006231637671589851,
0.023137155920267105,
-0.00952522549778223,
0.007051973138004541,
0.038491249084472656,
-0.02072666771709919,
-0.04768751934170723,
0.0007864164654165506,
-0.016113493591547012,
0.031623274087905884,
0.01403307169675827,
0.03807542100548744,
-0.011144000105559826,
-0.013577660545706749,
-0.017315354198217392,
-0.00466329837217927,
-0.0041244737803936005,
-0.022448664531111717,
0.029066631570458412,
-0.013448243029415607,
-0.06091596186161041,
0.017226608470082283,
0.016794167459011078,
-0.00808997917920351,
-0.0010747283231467009,
0.016301531344652176,
-0.0013110649306327105,
-0.05500216409564018,
-0.02938270755112171,
0.018079111352562904,
-0.06273628026247025,
0.029223890975117683,
-0.004663444589823484,
0.035317447036504745,
-0.02425675466656685,
0.06566603481769562,
0.03690323978662491,
-0.0026477850042283535,
0.021655909717082977,
-0.028307469561696053,
-0.012845350429415703,
0.008191382512450218,
0.08268602192401886,
0.009425800293684006,
0.00920921005308628,
-0.011650476604700089,
0.010201536118984222,
-0.03080044873058796,
-0.0069025238044559956,
0.03143796697258949,
-0.017132826149463654,
0.04529160261154175,
-0.01754356548190117,
0.007362601812928915,
-0.04049737751483917,
-0.03069237805902958,
0.038408923894166946,
-0.03563501685857773,
0.010262916795909405,
-0.0006343171698972583,
-0.02980107069015503,
0.013175868429243565,
0.005051254294812679,
0.05599946528673172,
-0.029703009873628616,
-0.01846778579056263,
-0.018184108659625053,
0.007918622344732285,
0.024809306487441063,
0.05805094167590141,
0.001935236738063395,
0.010625617578625679,
0.02552332729101181,
0.010400895029306412,
-0.015052150934934616,
0.05370118468999863,
0.027351152151823044,
0.016157161444425583,
-0.027327561751008034,
-0.008705624379217625,
-0.009318833239376545,
0.03704158961772919,
-0.0058714402839541435,
0.012256664223968983,
-0.038673464208841324,
0.02684091031551361,
0.0063599226996302605,
0.001285299425944686,
-0.013879395090043545,
-0.016735076904296875,
0.01589892990887165,
-0.008213299326598644,
0.03113226778805256,
-0.01684257760643959,
0.009291138499975204,
-0.0022896688897162676,
0.021980348974466324,
0.008671866729855537,
-0.035613227635622025,
-0.01926981471478939,
-0.011013753712177277,
0.01552499458193779,
0.03222960606217384,
0.03239113837480545,
-0.00919936690479517,
-0.030037865042686462,
0.023937983438372612,
-0.04680845886468887,
0.019388509914278984,
-0.012928028590977192,
0.05171053856611252,
0.031648799777030945,
-0.006156252231448889,
-0.004989919252693653,
-0.0030106131453067064,
0.012164468877017498,
0.0373619981110096,
0.009668207727372646,
0.01816578581929207,
0.016022343188524246,
-0.021264685317873955,
0.006156875751912594,
0.013266314752399921,
-0.018642302602529526,
-0.01172521710395813,
0.042038444429636,
-0.013890556059777737,
-0.008008458651602268,
-0.013207611627876759,
-0.0029805570375174284,
-0.02463543601334095,
0.005164308939129114,
0.04446180909872055,
0.012543016113340855,
-0.00585869001224637,
-0.017348093912005424,
0.04526340961456299,
0.07916419208049774,
-0.008584736846387386,
-0.04071083664894104,
0.01576194539666176,
0.015795225277543068,
-0.03654567152261734,
0.04403410479426384,
-0.02585086040198803,
-0.004446315113455057,
-0.06008150056004524,
-0.03275597468018532,
-0.008064170368015766,
0.05342211574316025,
0.013614042662084103,
-0.049246519804000854,
-0.03023334965109825,
-0.015191336162388325,
-0.023500654846429825,
0.002058260841295123,
-0.0003201016515959054,
-0.009975092485547066,
-0.010723714716732502,
-0.009531696327030659
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:33
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
188In Bilous v Mudaliar [2006] NSWCA 38 ; 65 NSWLR 615, Ipp JA outlined the general approach that should be taken in the evaluation of the parties' contributions in the following terms:
[41] In Davey v Lee (1990) 13 Fam LR 668, McLelland J said at 689:
"[T]he Court is not required under s 20 to undertake a reductionist process analogous to the taking of partnership accounts (notoriously one of the most time-consuming and expensive of litigious exercises) by examining every alleged 'contribution' of the kinds described in the section with a view to putting a monetary value on it in order to reach an accounting balance one way or the other,
which is to be then eliminated by the requisite financial adjustment.
Rather the Court is required to make a holistic value judgment in the exercise of a discretionary power of a very general kind."
I would endorse this approach as well as his Honour's further observation that, while the parties may value non-material contributions to the welfare of the family more highly than material contributions, these are not matters that lend themselves to detailed examination and analysis by a Court.
[42] Generally, the Court has a broad discretion in determining the approach to adopt in considering what order to make under s 20(1). As Brereton J (with whom Basten JA and Hunt AJA agreed) said in Kardos v Sarbutt at [51] (relying on Norbis v Norbis [1986] HCA 17; (1986) 161 CLR 513):
"Although in the majority of cases, the global approach is likely to be more convenient than an asset-by-asset approach, the application of the asset-by-asset approach does not of itself amount to an error of law."
Brereton J at [54] observed that:
"As [ Lenehan v Lenehan [1987] FamCA 8;
(1987) 11 Fam LR 615] shows, the principal indicator for an 'asset-by-asset' analysis is discrepant identifiable contributions of the parties to different assets: in that case, the proportionate contribution of the parties to the acquisition, conservation and improvement of the matrimonial home on the one hand, and to the business assets on the other, were quite different.
Such an approach will often be contra-indicated where, as here, there has been a pooling of income."
[43] If a global approach is adopted, regard must still be had to the origin and nature of the different assets. If an asset-by-asset approach is adopted, care must be taken to avoid the risk of undervaluing domestic and non-financial contributions and regard must be had to the overall result: Kardos v Sarbutt at [51] and [54].
Some situations do not lend themselves either to a pure global approach or to a pure asset-by-asset approach. In some cases the judge may decide to have regard to the particular contributions made to individual assets, weigh up the overall respective contributions to the parties and make differing apportionments in relation to the interests of the parties in different assets.
189In Separovich v Ferrao [2011] NSWCA 180, Beazley JA (with whom McColl and MacFarlan JJA agreed) stated:
[36] There are, as might be expected, a plethora of authorities as to how the Court should approach an adjustment of property under s 20. It is sufficient for the purposes of this case to refer to the following.
In Manns v Kennedy [2007] NSWCA 217 ; DFC 95-406 Campbell JA (Santow JA and Bryson AJA agreeing) observed, at [62], that under s 20, the Court was required to make a holistic value judgment in the exercise of a discretionary power of a very general kind: see Davey v Lee (1990) 13 Fam LR 688 at 689;
Ross v Elderfield [2006] NSWCA 129 ; DFC 95-338 at [35]; Kardos v Sarbutt [2006] NSWCA 111 ; DFC 95-332 at [36].
[37] However, that " holistic value judgment" is the final step in the process of arriving at an order, being the just and equitable adjustment of property, having regard to the contributions identified in s 20.
|
[
0.021348372101783752,
0.019996892660856247,
-0.045759640634059906,
0.03093365766108036,
0.012410258874297142,
-0.009161612950265408,
0.021476466208696365,
-0.02880115620791912,
0.003704501548781991,
0.0020307269878685474,
-0.011533248238265514,
0.04757077991962433,
-0.028423896059393883,
0.0275092963129282,
0.010444733314216137,
-0.010990760289132595,
0.02347078174352646,
0.027227405458688736,
-0.02536541223526001,
0.012298116460442543,
-0.04759907349944115,
0.010230116546154022,
-0.006294155027717352,
-0.05411039665341377,
-0.011495545506477356,
-0.0018884665332734585,
-0.028972042724490166,
-0.011901745572686195,
0.03336050733923912,
0.028698595240712166,
-0.033522769808769226,
0.017309430986642838,
0.01973196305334568,
-0.018312012776732445,
0.009855881333351135,
-0.025746123865246773,
-0.00700143538415432,
-0.0018854595255106688,
-0.027290863916277885,
0.015569593757390976,
-0.025572344660758972,
0.013409238308668137,
-0.009010188281536102,
-0.04497876763343811,
0.05965148285031319,
-0.0052437856793403625,
-0.019543366506695747,
-0.04751095920801163,
-0.0465044267475605,
-0.025449007749557495,
-0.046554405242204666,
0.029056133702397346,
0.04230876266956329,
-0.026608318090438843,
0.005104802083224058,
0.022615984082221985,
-0.0012737881625071168,
-0.0074143786914646626,
-0.06099816411733627,
-0.034367144107818604,
0.007715027313679457,
0.001921038026921451,
-0.05079135671257973,
-0.008043775334954262,
0.006733017973601818,
0.007486189715564251,
0.0002627332869451493,
-0.013555162586271763,
-0.013072720728814602,
0.007824559696018696,
-0.02648031711578369,
-0.02105388417840004,
-0.038062456995248795,
0.005866223946213722,
-0.05521193891763687,
0.016499079763889313,
0.010410514660179615,
0.013725060038268566,
0.004633776377886534,
-0.01871788129210472,
0.000007025226750556612,
-0.021658314391970634,
-0.011528940871357918,
0.01011260598897934,
-0.028307631611824036,
-0.0016114059835672379,
0.003773059695959091,
0.0001531789603177458,
0.04375850036740303,
0.046563949435949326,
-0.014364735223352909,
-0.022329039871692657,
0.024230869486927986,
-0.017154483124613762,
0.0035490456502884626,
0.010350065305829048,
-0.1022227481007576,
0.030883392319083214,
-0.012824146077036858,
0.017217881977558136,
0.019082549959421158,
0.016262538731098175,
0.023539453744888306,
-0.0195176862180233,
0.029068242758512497,
0.01925765909254551,
0.032809823751449585,
0.044303786009550095,
0.045621078461408615,
0.00487971818074584,
-0.012397397309541702,
-0.021205807104706764,
0.004620326682925224,
0.018949799239635468,
-0.02610504999756813,
-0.019094420596957207,
-0.019861046224832535,
-0.008544178679585457,
-0.003398055210709572,
-0.004487421829253435,
-0.004357648082077503,
0.03309200331568718,
0.042200516909360886,
-0.00996817834675312,
-0.00557309202849865,
0.04568703472614288,
-0.009612027555704117,
0.026728816330432892,
-0.06970719248056412,
-0.00742125790566206,
-0.017824485898017883,
0.013640861958265305,
-0.027630193158984184,
-0.018020788207650185,
0.009319855831563473,
0.000598135928157717,
0.03779435530304909,
0.053153954446315765,
-0.023383989930152893,
-0.07069641351699829,
0.047338150441646576,
0.021411456167697906,
-0.004371777176856995,
-0.006498650182038546,
0.028990615159273148,
0.020946292206645012,
0.041329678148031235,
-0.010712589137256145,
-0.05664989724755287,
-0.042757339775562286,
0.009536266326904297,
0.04443536326289177,
0.019165974110364914,
-0.025316065177321434,
0.07579988986253738,
-0.038405850529670715,
-0.009541690349578857,
0.006813999731093645,
0.01804790087044239,
0.0403439961373806,
0.008854539133608341,
0.051720574498176575,
-0.030033959075808525,
0.0006693251780234277,
-0.0252325851470232,
0.006727566011250019,
0.0271222572773695,
0.01337170135229826,
0.020871106535196304,
-0.005721265450119972,
0.026385778561234474,
-0.026274358853697777,
0.01231302972882986,
-0.022957196459174156,
0.009938139468431473,
0.02322828769683838,
0.06116998940706253,
0.03340559080243111,
-0.02679423801600933,
-0.020424511283636093,
-0.010067797265946865,
0.015198110602796078,
-0.011862271465361118,
-0.025867654010653496,
-0.05578670650720596,
0.015759220346808434,
-0.02098282054066658,
-0.02028430625796318,
0.04886788874864578,
-0.0015428857877850533,
-0.028988845646381378,
-0.014074712060391903,
0.043892841786146164,
0.005769315175712109,
0.0069263046607375145,
-0.023541061207652092,
0.014305644668638706,
0.024007348343729973,
0.0052657057531178,
-0.01601559855043888,
-0.02353210747241974,
0.022375883534550667,
0.026844780892133713,
0.027475936338305473,
-0.01883893832564354,
-0.0017233033431693912,
-0.06051143258810043,
-0.013277838006615639,
0.059386637061834335,
-0.0017124720616266131,
0.045483339577913284,
0.0402500256896019,
0.02953801490366459,
0.026422470808029175,
-0.05431855097413063,
-0.010250844061374664,
-0.008409577421844006,
-0.05183739587664604,
-0.020422371104359627,
0.011307727545499802,
0.005840441677719355,
0.008721272461116314,
0.017783943563699722,
0.02172211743891239,
0.016832765191793442,
-0.0040473295375704765,
-0.05671721324324608,
-0.011314584873616695,
0.07325226813554764,
-0.01342826522886753,
0.05665825679898262,
-0.000008887086551112588,
-0.014317956753075123,
-0.0379994660615921,
0.007528772111982107,
0.006318665109574795,
0.05957570672035217,
0.01583237759768963,
-0.0006720963283441961,
-0.0009461225708946586,
-0.029081767424941063,
-0.018761971965432167,
-0.0019159551011398435,
-0.012343792244791985,
-0.04524097964167595,
-0.018526490777730942,
-0.003204898675903678,
0.027229521423578262,
0.026022931560873985,
-0.04694191366434097,
0.03205888718366623,
-0.0035931160673499107,
0.013969328254461288,
0.02228764072060585,
-0.014132024720311165,
0.00800035148859024,
-0.003868425264954567,
0.00355529529042542,
0.02703489363193512,
-0.048307616263628006,
0.009939099662005901,
0.024892563000321388,
0.04050053283572197,
0.02326253615319729,
0.019608434289693832,
-0.026502007618546486,
-0.035033389925956726,
0.004306836053729057,
0.008544255048036575,
0.021610166877508163,
-0.023797130212187767,
0.03664582967758179,
-0.006164776161313057,
0.0033527230843901634,
0.005052220541983843,
0.04020359367132187,
0.023724492639303207,
-0.03434343263506889,
0.05564876273274422,
-0.0026446166448295116,
-0.0460299514234066,
0.018081793561577797,
0.009816727600991726,
-0.01711845025420189,
-0.017343755811452866,
-0.010652674362063408,
-0.030362870544195175,
-0.035686541348695755,
0.01719251088798046,
-0.05534089356660843,
0.09052574634552002,
-0.0038032270967960358,
0.08068948239088058,
-0.012925418093800545,
-0.044175878167152405,
-0.0416480116546154,
-0.009064528159797192,
-0.133968323469162,
0.018109800294041634,
0.02453690581023693,
0.012801527045667171,
0.001594281056895852,
0.048182301223278046,
-0.03590541332960129,
0.0004548724100459367,
-0.0005904916324652731,
0.011255964636802673,
0.01034601591527462,
-0.06572062522172928,
-0.017877282574772835,
0.011411136947572231,
0.010456467978656292,
-0.03205029293894768,
0.01902647130191326,
0.015654390677809715,
0.02400333620607853,
-0.009785173460841179,
-0.007401950657367706,
-0.008078539744019508,
-0.02544243633747101,
-0.010619918815791607,
0.024926358833909035,
-0.020507125183939934,
-0.010821051895618439,
0.05325808748602867,
-0.01003256719559431,
-0.02527216635644436,
-0.03261487931013107,
-0.022752361372113228,
0.00413826759904623,
0.0248950757086277,
-0.02791525609791279,
0.024788619950413704,
0.014831841923296452,
-0.05981701612472534,
0.020914070308208466,
-0.0383441187441349,
0.05762890353798866,
0.042348712682724,
-0.02633519284427166,
0.009519286453723907,
-0.03093189187347889,
-0.04155776649713516,
0.02880697324872017,
-0.014759017154574394,
-0.0328146368265152,
0.06403979659080505,
-0.006728221196681261,
0.01478537730872631,
-0.031242795288562775,
0.002948130015283823,
-0.03463082015514374,
-0.020359722897410393,
0.041249778121709824,
0.07462359219789505,
0.013590551912784576,
-0.042631298303604126,
-0.030547743663191795,
0.00276074162684381,
0.003937524743378162,
-0.013380182906985283,
-0.030755415558815002,
-0.005398707929998636,
0.035073909908533096,
-0.01831827312707901,
0.04657634720206261,
-0.03877248987555504,
-0.007623847108334303,
-0.053505539894104004,
0.019040362909436226,
-0.00858231633901596,
-0.008916143327951431,
-0.004584319423884153,
0.051183559000492096,
-0.03347465768456459,
0.012649454176425934,
-0.07311755418777466,
0.05549612268805504,
-0.026222433894872665,
0.022481970489025116,
0.04293296858668327,
-0.013069599866867065,
-0.010326916351914406,
0.012189722619950771,
-0.016783587634563446,
0.026115799322724342,
0.24575674533843994,
0.0016376292333006859,
0.04109823703765869,
0.020831862464547157,
0.050122275948524475,
-0.01144038699567318,
0.037211570888757706,
0.03927064687013626,
0.009515419602394104,
-0.035002224147319794,
-0.03554120659828186,
0.0447482094168663,
0.011010916903614998,
0.026131201535463333,
-0.05798519030213356,
0.030476784333586693,
-0.04305972531437874,
-0.03139259293675423,
0.08111541718244553,
-0.0014213882386684418,
0.05460919812321663,
-0.03746243193745613,
0.032745394855737686,
0.038539331406354904,
-0.06595068424940109,
-0.012077267281711102,
0.005801134742796421,
0.04684654250741005,
-0.03042452223598957,
0.04397941008210182,
-0.032225485891103745,
-0.018254276365041733,
0.021767446771264076,
-0.012360570020973682,
-0.007654298562556505,
-0.0009042933816090226,
-0.003611224237829447,
0.021148664876818657,
0.020380621775984764,
0.05513825640082359,
0.004430343862622976,
-0.02479817532002926,
-0.03346002846956253,
-0.029735293239355087,
0.02870885841548443,
0.009585106745362282,
-0.011391343548893929,
-0.006383884232491255,
-0.017487693578004837,
0.03281664103269577,
-0.036213550716638565,
-0.012151390314102173,
-0.029872214421629906,
0.023527951911091805,
-0.02239055186510086,
0.02504112757742405,
0.005811456590890884,
0.022146102041006088,
-0.01684754528105259,
-0.014017734676599503,
-0.0011521270498633385,
0.001666177879087627,
0.003384009003639221,
-0.02975430339574814,
-0.01647154614329338,
0.010189173743128777,
-0.032032400369644165,
-0.02534520998597145,
0.00810876302421093,
-0.0025910409167408943,
0.032061778008937836,
-0.012523992918431759,
0.004856526851654053,
0.028685124590992928,
0.034650806337594986,
0.006908072158694267,
0.018499931320548058,
-0.010825210250914097,
0.005883332807570696,
-0.0367204025387764,
-0.05058690160512924,
-0.01137575414031744,
-0.0027017355896532536,
-0.012618174776434898,
0.00441593024879694,
-0.00012957437138538808,
-0.06121579930186272,
0.027435271069407463,
-0.008764749392867088,
-0.018799997866153717,
-0.03955370932817459,
-0.03842822089791298,
0.015299375168979168,
0.023033129051327705,
0.008884737268090248,
0.008904335089027882,
0.07118289172649384,
-0.008601297624409199,
-0.022197723388671875,
-0.018187472596764565,
-0.01767529547214508,
0.06705427169799805,
-0.004284059628844261,
-0.026251181960105896,
0.044326215982437134,
-0.06286062300205231,
0.005954177118837833,
-0.007780443411320448,
-0.0511888787150383,
-0.01312573254108429,
-0.03858799859881401,
0.02413157932460308,
0.010499260388314724,
0.04714991897344589,
0.009176447987556458,
0.06720484048128128,
-0.022130485624074936,
0.027768133208155632,
0.04313235357403755,
0.028974883258342743,
0.00017848567222245038,
-0.004969235975295305,
-0.0028811038937419653,
-0.04011102393269539,
0.00035576079972088337,
0.0033197675365954638,
-0.02611539326608181,
-0.00974468607455492,
0.014656681567430496,
0.042278971523046494,
0.02677168697118759,
-0.00860050693154335,
-0.04221568629145622,
-0.011193615384399891,
-0.014536892995238304,
-0.016324128955602646,
-0.032207682728767395,
0.023993946611881256,
-0.04746703431010246,
0.03166911005973816,
-0.04491841048002243,
-0.018511349335312843,
-0.001975803868845105,
0.0016208440065383911,
0.015254209749400616,
0.025847557932138443,
0.0005756052560172975,
-0.010664587840437889,
-0.021020079031586647,
0.014512465335428715,
0.016193900257349014,
0.014894452877342701,
-0.039791107177734375,
-0.045515310019254684,
-0.022343900054693222,
-0.018201056867837906,
0.0003424314199946821,
-0.009809229522943497,
0.029665352776646614,
-0.01236877404153347,
-0.01675630360841751,
0.0006387211615219712,
-0.0038792178966104984,
0.04692836105823517,
0.010308158583939075,
0.10122916847467422,
0.002977801952511072,
0.023087646812200546,
0.0371035598218441,
-0.038510795682668686,
-0.037793878465890884,
-0.045640770345926285,
-0.0434589609503746,
-0.02585836499929428,
0.04479534924030304,
0.021065684035420418,
-0.028763072565197945,
0.043835971504449844,
0.03597414493560791,
-0.06077543646097183,
0.03392920643091202,
0.01994050294160843,
-0.029285257682204247,
0.012321730144321918,
-0.0023888018913567066,
0.005513038486242294,
0.011369350366294384,
-0.029714584350585938,
0.012677531689405441,
-0.03466194123029709,
-0.026046255603432655,
0.09517566859722137,
-0.012620224617421627,
-0.06270668655633926,
0.03317747637629509,
0.0290998425334692,
0.00040660164086148143,
0.0469055138528347,
0.014962471090257168,
-0.04082796350121498,
-0.03407103568315506,
-0.006432181689888239,
0.016723530367016792,
-0.057857997715473175,
0.044322334229946136,
0.021445248275995255,
-0.022272737696766853,
0.003328139428049326,
0.0009617356699891388,
0.01195850595831871,
0.01419678796082735,
0.018822085112333298,
-0.015044949017465115,
0.0014091359917074442,
0.025855036452412605,
0.009548661299049854,
0.05252630263566971,
0.04504895955324173,
0.001073644496500492,
-0.039687786251306534,
-0.009567881934344769,
-0.019624292850494385,
-0.009282777085900307,
-0.07342363893985748,
0.015243140049278736,
0.03539743274450302,
-0.015761930495500565,
0.005612847860902548,
-0.009395606815814972,
-0.033534057438373566,
0.007875925861299038,
-0.03701559081673622,
0.02305656671524048,
0.019906261935830116,
-0.02656916342675686,
-0.014918309636414051,
0.025593360885977745,
0.008649333380162716,
0.04845369979739189,
-0.00954592227935791,
0.011958472430706024,
-0.01711946167051792,
0.033480603247880936,
0.02761363610625267,
-0.02283496782183647,
-0.05463583394885063,
0.018152832984924316,
-0.0075382147915661335,
0.019039595499634743,
0.014493098482489586,
-0.027824485674500465,
-0.03029809519648552,
0.0029659767169505358,
-0.039402998983860016,
0.01777011528611183,
-0.0065346998162567616,
-0.030889663845300674,
0.022700361907482147,
-0.07323505729436874,
-0.05031059682369232,
0.012936854735016823,
0.017983311787247658,
-0.0007971514714881778,
-0.037048064172267914,
-0.04600534960627556,
-0.060704395174980164,
0.024826407432556152,
-0.014350456185638905,
-0.0029510303866118193,
-0.045814938843250275,
-0.021381141617894173,
0.01753842830657959,
-0.042886946350336075,
-0.06582347303628922,
0.009015219286084175,
0.017723340541124344,
-0.010382993146777153,
-0.015952153131365776,
0.016357025131583214,
0.010008182376623154,
0.02133147418498993,
0.017189878970384598,
0.0008481114637106657,
0.05957258492708206,
-0.032097578048706055,
-0.003997971769422293,
0.03264576196670532,
0.026038305833935738,
0.007770712953060865,
-0.02367899753153324,
0.03667178377509117,
0.028861187398433685,
0.004077932797372341,
0.040979716926813126,
-0.0040860362350940704,
0.004406226798892021,
0.03721572831273079,
0.009155308827757835,
0.004058823920786381,
0.012203103862702847,
-0.05981513112783432,
-0.0110696479678154,
-0.0031006650533527136,
-0.021872220560908318,
0.02175469510257244,
0.03533530607819557,
0.030428998172283173,
-0.04164429381489754,
-0.02799256145954132,
-0.008383885957300663,
-0.016178445890545845,
-0.056108005344867706,
0.02727385237812996,
-0.009427429176867008,
0.0019035768928006291,
0.011906801722943783,
0.03671346604824066,
-0.01150035485625267,
-0.007429967168718576,
0.03205134719610214,
0.014274952001869678,
-0.024716738611459732,
-0.023528119549155235,
-0.03051208145916462,
-0.040353477001190186,
-0.032025162130594254,
0.02971440739929676,
-0.037449270486831665,
-0.014304815791547298,
0.023302597925066948,
-0.05050240457057953,
-0.0020192123483866453,
-0.017030425369739532,
0.01398131437599659,
0.030713409185409546,
0.030447455123066902,
-0.0020691414829343557,
-0.04479408636689186,
0.0894196480512619,
-0.02150683104991913,
-0.0245877243578434,
-0.06690594553947449,
0.08958674967288971,
-0.02205411158502102,
-0.0007133501931093633,
-0.0017129381885752082,
0.01978755183517933,
-0.022777142003178596,
0.004238855093717575,
0.01780586689710617,
-0.011546441353857517,
0.008568000048398972,
-0.02233639359474182,
-0.017768261954188347,
0.009556961245834827,
-0.021222587674856186,
0.005967563949525356,
0.05601270869374275,
0.04427262395620346,
-0.05488855019211769,
-0.018215039744973183,
-0.0142525564879179,
0.0295637808740139,
-0.0334143303334713,
0.024964695796370506,
0.0072387950494885445,
0.007881716825067997,
-0.018046202138066292,
-0.0061257462948560715,
0.019386816769838333,
0.047563400119543076,
-0.012353874742984772,
0.0048272935673594475,
-0.008113003335893154,
-0.03956844285130501,
-0.02094908244907856,
0.02349153161048889,
0.00047908927081152797,
-0.0028383187018334866,
0.004253341816365719,
0.017312003299593925,
-0.05263621360063553,
-0.0686122328042984,
0.0033050822094082832,
-0.0011671180836856365,
-0.025623271241784096,
0.011202769353985786,
-0.02090875618159771,
0.002753065899014473,
0.0019714892841875553,
0.0025249056052416563,
0.07941791415214539,
-0.015007894486188889,
-0.02220398187637329,
-0.1357378512620926,
0.0047934893518686295,
0.011129546910524368,
0.024541392922401428,
-0.07100887596607208,
-0.017598599195480347,
-0.037364643067121506,
0.009862283244729042,
-0.026387924328446388,
-0.0014863248215988278,
-0.032049793750047684,
0.01894829049706459,
-0.042935825884342194,
0.0038088164292275906,
-0.030112827196717262,
-0.020010419189929962,
0.004784213844686747,
-0.03502360358834267,
-0.041571542620658875,
0.05059724301099777,
-0.0049506183713674545,
0.007316788658499718,
0.002167141530662775,
-0.021959684789180756,
0.004700971767306328,
-0.03128471225500107,
-0.04484592005610466,
-0.028011297807097435,
-0.04651448875665665,
-0.07480383664369583,
-0.022188978269696236,
-0.007100989576429129,
0.035261016339063644,
0.00647747004404664,
-0.005068582016974688,
-0.032753825187683105,
-0.009773235768079758,
0.022008497267961502,
-0.033543363213539124,
0.012883561663329601,
0.01797984540462494,
0.045093290507793427,
-0.003252028487622738,
0.014454789459705353,
-0.014255073852837086,
0.05999346449971199,
0.03434988856315613,
-0.028721939772367477,
-0.011637105606496334,
-0.04157063364982605,
-0.0767131969332695,
0.023453764617443085,
0.034334417432546616,
0.014170852489769459,
0.024463893845677376,
-0.028955159708857536,
-0.011889473535120487,
-0.022392522543668747,
0.0057000466622412205,
0.03690831735730171,
0.033150795847177505,
0.02386544458568096,
-0.007677166722714901,
-0.046043843030929565,
-0.02367474138736725,
0.03857665881514549,
-0.04878845810890198,
-0.01598387025296688,
-0.02980031818151474,
0.013131670653820038,
-0.0037996373139321804,
0.03367245942354202,
-0.012745840474963188,
-0.0005670044338330626,
-0.0003832121437881142,
0.01925918459892273,
-0.0038131738547235727,
0.008004680275917053,
-0.006991886999458075,
0.04175890237092972,
-0.025872157886624336,
-0.030418800190091133,
-0.03895121067762375,
-0.04645448550581932,
0.0432930514216423,
0.012396201491355896,
0.0003536837757565081,
-0.020224060863256454,
-0.017895592376589775,
-0.05801258608698845,
-0.05076839029788971,
-0.04526367038488388,
-0.04590601846575737,
-0.014979234896600246,
-0.00624285452067852,
0.022907020524144173,
0.0018600851763039827,
-0.013733577914536,
-0.005516332574188709,
0.005429164040833712,
-0.02392321638762951,
-0.046743810176849365,
0.027839144691824913,
-0.014887623488903046,
-0.019056523218750954,
0.013460182584822178,
-0.011564881540834904,
-0.005328269675374031,
0.03094192035496235,
0.0024216535966843367,
-0.0356537289917469,
0.012780655175447464,
-0.03216129168868065,
0.02132846601307392,
-0.02720537595450878,
0.02641100063920021,
-0.024801794439554214,
0.02003621868789196,
-0.007833669893443584,
-0.015872042626142502,
0.015612353570759296,
-0.012283612973988056,
0.0055917310528457165,
-0.007655140478163958,
-0.022804133594036102,
0.03205375000834465,
0.024512069299817085,
0.02351369522511959,
0.012947430834174156,
-0.04491255804896355,
0.07525169849395752,
-0.04408068582415581,
-0.009752670302987099,
0.0049522616900503635,
0.01584593579173088,
0.03144747391343117,
-0.024787774309515953,
0.015977663919329643,
-0.04773787036538124,
-0.053282637149095535,
0.01433095708489418,
-0.01240246370434761,
0.038150351494550705,
0.0013525678077712655,
-0.023168988525867462,
-0.01137249730527401,
0.0063490052707493305,
0.05191371217370033,
-0.029865825548768044,
-0.0460921972990036,
0.0006539198802784085,
-0.013995478861033916,
-0.01589127443730831,
0.07950656116008759,
0.021265435963869095,
-0.035386279225349426,
-0.00849835854023695,
0.009466703981161118,
0.0040214709006249905,
0.07411997765302658,
0.0563652440905571,
-0.012744294479489326,
0.009179326705634594,
-0.029974712058901787,
-0.012996155768632889,
0.01961524970829487,
-0.03444518521428108,
0.011433659121394157,
-0.022534949705004692,
0.0181331317871809,
0.03816983476281166,
0.0337948203086853,
-0.020402640104293823,
0.004736631643027067,
0.024868754670023918,
-0.023728545755147934,
-0.024624092504382133,
0.035423342138528824,
0.006323674693703651,
-0.014101606793701649,
0.013868304900825024,
0.02360871620476246,
0.041120853275060654,
0.007975921966135502,
-0.000423296180088073,
0.020978953689336777,
-0.020401233807206154,
0.008490748703479767,
0.03408382087945938,
-0.05055028945207596,
-0.02613774500787258,
0.012701812200248241,
0.05207850784063339,
-0.039121486246585846,
0.02963067777454853,
0.0601833276450634,
0.010774388909339905,
0.011691716499626637,
0.005606950260698795,
0.038876257836818695,
0.027026904746890068,
-0.02115653082728386,
-0.06295530498027802,
-0.00750027084723115,
-0.03355007246136665,
-0.01716914400458336,
-0.014399485662579536,
0.006250249687582254,
-0.005605827551335096,
0.030959252268075943,
-0.010035041719675064,
-0.0072845895774662495,
-0.020749716088175774,
0.07635308057069778,
0.0003599621122702956,
0.02350097894668579,
0.005328914150595665,
0.03897562623023987,
0.01195567287504673,
-0.03733998164534569,
0.0044944495894014835,
0.03944249451160431,
-0.010397764854133129,
-0.021093713119626045,
0.0013077057665213943,
0.029335910454392433,
-0.014765134081244469,
-0.008845576085150242,
0.0011689820094034076,
0.0031211129389703274,
-0.0300560612231493,
-0.028066731989383698,
0.019209759309887886,
0.03522270917892456,
0.030522579327225685,
-0.015620910562574863,
-0.015084095299243927,
0.010142031125724316,
-0.03474459797143936,
0.007276326417922974,
0.013881050981581211,
-0.0019963786471635103,
-0.006947685033082962,
0.02520802430808544
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:19
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
It is an assault to point a pistol at another in such a way as to induce the belief that the plaintiff is about to be shot even if, unknown to the plaintiff, the pistol is unloaded. But a threatened coup d'etat did not constitute an assault where no one capable of carrying out violent attacks had yet arrived in the relevant country.
See Carolyn Sappideen et al, Fleming's The Law of Torts, 10th ed (2011) Thomson Reuters at 2.70.
110I will first deal with those assaults where there are some suggestions of corroborative material. As I have already mentioned there were no witnesses to any of the assaults.
1. Alleged assault in May 1993 (threat in note)
111The relevant evidence given by the defendant was as follows:
126. In the meantime, before he left for Melbourne, Bob and I planned to take a short holiday in Yamba, where we had moved the caravan. We were going to have all our children with us, but before that happened Bob said to me
Bob: "Why do bloody Wade and David need to come? I really want to spend time with my kids - I see yours every day. "
Me: "Both you and your kids have been welcome to stay at Station Avenue whenever you wanted, over the past couple of years, and we have all made you more than welcome."
Bob: "I'm a bloody absentee father - you wouldn't fucking remotely know what that feels like."
He was to repeat this last comment to me often, for many years.
127. The conversation continued for an hour and Bob shouted at me and repeated words including "you're a miserable, selfish bitch. You have your children. What about giving me time and space with mine."
I said: "It would be good if they were all together with us on this occasion. I don't understand you with Dave and Wade. They were so good to you when you were down and out. Have you forgotten?".
Bob said: " Fancy remembering those things. How petty. That's poison you've got stored up saying that to me. You've got a memory like an elephant."
Bob shouted at me and stood over me looking down at me, close to my face Finally, I left the room. I went into the lounge room and sat down. I felt intimidated and shaken. I could hear Bob moving about in the bedroom. That evening I did not see him again. After a while I heard his car start. I went into the kitchen and I found a written note by Bob which said:
"I'll be back after I get back from Melbourne to get the rest of my stuff. I'd strongly advise you not to be here so I'll ring first. PS. I can't believe the poison you've stored going back so far. FUCK YOU!!!!!"
128. We did not take the holiday as planned.
129. To my knowledge, Bob spent a week or two with his children at Noosa and then went to Melbourne to take over the Roof Shield business.
112A copy of the note left by the plaintiff is in evidence as exhibit 8. It can be recalled from previous evidence that I have quoted above that the defendant concedes that he wrote the note, that it was preceded by an argument which occurred before a trip by him to Melbourne.
The defendant could not recall what the argument was about. Notwithstanding this he denied the conversations alleged by the defendant.
113The reference to her sons being good to him was an occasion when the plaintiff first came to live with the defendant when he wanted to borrow $7,000 to buy a car. He could not borrow it and he used her sons credit worthiness to borrow the money. Given the matters that support the defendant's version of events I will accept her evidence of the conversations.
114She has spoken in her evidence of fear and the threat in the note is sufficient to establish the circumstances as an assault.
2. Alleged assault on 18 February 2008 (verbal attack)
115The defendants evidence was as follows:
582. On 18 February 2008 as part of our efforts at reconciliation, Bob and I were having dinner together on the deck at Mitchelton when Bob suddenly and unexpectedly started screaming at me:
|
[
0.039354629814624786,
0.028361031785607338,
-0.02765621244907379,
0.02661716192960739,
-0.014502877369523048,
-0.07277631759643555,
0.08353137969970703,
0.02648080326616764,
0.018832506611943245,
0.012285112403333187,
0.020603712648153305,
0.05069052800536156,
-0.04452309012413025,
-0.03284666687250137,
0.009106767363846302,
0.005682396702468395,
0.027235418558120728,
-0.026747947558760643,
-0.01518888957798481,
-0.018927404657006264,
-0.06267782300710678,
0.010489292442798615,
0.007769010495394468,
0.013100317679345608,
-0.026745924726128578,
0.006847138050943613,
-0.011242245323956013,
-0.027016060426831245,
-0.03719806671142578,
0.015394987538456917,
0.00990273430943489,
-0.010678360238671303,
0.02560940384864807,
0.02418583817780018,
-0.017634104937314987,
-0.004433334339410067,
-0.008908839896321297,
-0.02060050703585148,
-0.018481871113181114,
0.030956946313381195,
-0.01945466548204422,
0.0007946031400933862,
-0.03110293298959732,
0.016651421785354614,
0.002782051917165518,
-0.03703387826681137,
-0.02739887125790119,
-0.009516655467450619,
0.01722593605518341,
-0.0008473884663544595,
-0.043018653988838196,
0.02386101707816124,
0.020484423264861107,
-0.002329761628061533,
-0.01682688668370247,
-0.0004699146666098386,
0.03697992488741875,
0.0031777340918779373,
-0.060246240347623825,
-0.034173768013715744,
0.002859345870092511,
-0.05354190245270729,
-0.020285923033952713,
-0.0211291816085577,
-0.01146814227104187,
0.11387486755847931,
-0.030459962785243988,
-0.028128767386078835,
-0.00155166897457093,
-0.028557630255818367,
0.008489672094583511,
0.016377659514546394,
-0.01853717491030693,
-0.025112487375736237,
-0.06607738882303238,
0.011905815452337265,
0.03151262551546097,
0.0029787675011903048,
-0.032547444105148315,
0.01995205506682396,
0.05390472710132599,
0.005836171563714743,
0.012400303035974503,
0.04400032386183739,
-0.0019900731276720762,
0.02439534291625023,
-0.027735287323594093,
0.007378450129181147,
0.0030103656463325024,
0.011760435067117214,
0.0012100397143512964,
0.008428446017205715,
0.05158800631761551,
-0.061848677694797516,
-0.014700910076498985,
-0.0024546803906559944,
-0.03932128846645355,
0.009206045418977737,
-0.035089846700429916,
-0.008884988725185394,
0.018480421975255013,
0.01602877676486969,
-0.03503542020916939,
-0.023197900503873825,
0.05057757720351219,
0.047130320221185684,
0.08597645908594131,
0.045408282428979874,
0.03048262558877468,
0.0038793704006820917,
0.03939468786120415,
0.03960084542632103,
-0.01921205408871174,
-0.04101625829935074,
-0.00039079104317352176,
0.016856320202350616,
0.01671499013900757,
-0.02036266215145588,
-0.02284552901983261,
-0.017769785597920418,
-0.018667355179786682,
0.04503082484006882,
0.015694767236709595,
-0.03397282958030701,
-0.028793251141905785,
0.012710882350802422,
-0.02003970742225647,
0.0019299726700410247,
-0.013259637169539928,
0.02206011302769184,
-0.008958621881902218,
-0.033706508576869965,
-0.03212880715727806,
-0.049255285412073135,
-0.009480113163590431,
0.007575458846986294,
0.008552202954888344,
0.05894259735941887,
0.03334344923496246,
-0.04076850786805153,
0.031228331848978996,
-0.024867014959454536,
-0.004025086760520935,
-0.012582414783537388,
0.03658099099993706,
-0.0011086486047133803,
0.026688693091273308,
-0.023997878655791283,
0.0034562498331069946,
0.007091649807989597,
-0.013394312001764774,
0.022485539317131042,
-0.018571479246020317,
0.004325288347899914,
0.03135860338807106,
-0.05583510175347328,
0.018642503768205643,
0.0011525729205459356,
-0.02039516158401966,
0.008300414308905602,
0.02030717208981514,
-0.004774003755301237,
-0.06626155972480774,
-0.005161208100616932,
0.01918913796544075,
0.014076679944992065,
-0.024562576785683632,
0.024444660171866417,
-0.025258300825953484,
-0.025853576138615608,
0.04739341139793396,
-0.006436965428292751,
0.010799286887049675,
-0.003279047319665551,
0.013697762973606586,
0.0276060551404953,
0.041146885603666306,
0.025209655985236168,
-0.019351642578840256,
-0.04977825656533241,
0.0024046043399721384,
0.039561428129673004,
-0.005262336228042841,
-0.06274089217185974,
-0.0046114264987409115,
0.020033173263072968,
-0.014745478518307209,
0.0005448661395348608,
0.010328943841159344,
-0.0012268468271940947,
-0.052117832005023956,
-0.043324559926986694,
0.040530454367399216,
0.00009604602382751182,
0.05931440740823746,
-0.03987804800271988,
0.037693094462156296,
-0.04381672292947769,
-0.010177136398851871,
-0.03135623782873154,
-0.020558200776576996,
0.04022525995969772,
0.06541421264410019,
-0.029630199074745178,
-0.030132349580526352,
-0.022243479266762733,
-0.0539313368499279,
0.000151670872583054,
0.02810540981590748,
-0.10703128576278687,
-0.0008783733937889338,
0.030249062925577164,
0.021013112738728523,
0.004361444152891636,
-0.01617584563791752,
-0.006540458649396896,
0.0013023674255236983,
-0.0009492062963545322,
0.006020891014486551,
0.037267304956912994,
0.008722813799977303,
-0.006824928801506758,
-0.038922443985939026,
-0.02072896808385849,
0.03158264979720116,
0.04425555095076561,
-0.010706888511776924,
0.005907187703996897,
0.02473250776529312,
-0.010485265403985977,
0.05368465930223465,
-0.009079575538635254,
0.011212239973247051,
0.017230596393346786,
0.023105720058083534,
-0.004264213144779205,
-0.02574264444410801,
0.032155875116586685,
0.055939171463251114,
-0.00875238236039877,
0.017412973567843437,
-0.010363606736063957,
0.008581436239182949,
-0.023790962994098663,
-0.03107154183089733,
-0.03480086848139763,
0.017823150381445885,
-0.005538381636142731,
0.028917444869875908,
0.006421803496778011,
-0.006116918288171291,
-0.02231866493821144,
-0.02927326038479805,
-0.0213294867426157,
-0.010079758241772652,
0.00923549011349678,
0.03693682327866554,
0.013274732045829296,
0.024749116972088814,
0.0002399094373686239,
-0.008053476922214031,
0.018323229625821114,
0.047074094414711,
0.012099198065698147,
0.009641858749091625,
-0.01613811030983925,
-0.024369526654481888,
-0.04369930922985077,
-0.012451839633286,
-0.0007810848182998598,
0.018813423812389374,
-0.026668064296245575,
-0.006830030586570501,
-0.062387898564338684,
-0.002598434453830123,
0.027681292966008186,
-0.007239873055368662,
-0.03926362469792366,
-0.008919906802475452,
-0.018543167039752007,
0.01896725967526436,
-0.0574348121881485,
-0.002162544522434473,
0.0010316477855667472,
-0.002901315689086914,
0.05465599521994591,
0.013870401307940483,
-0.05540378391742706,
0.02252833917737007,
-0.03617684915661812,
0.03827160969376564,
-0.010432692244648933,
0.057845547795295715,
-0.022777853533625603,
-0.03163696452975273,
-0.019861698150634766,
-0.001243039732798934,
-0.17108801007270813,
0.022393733263015747,
0.0165487602353096,
0.018632810562849045,
0.018451234325766563,
0.02703009732067585,
-0.04977032542228699,
-0.016041014343500137,
0.013287228532135487,
-0.005229648668318987,
0.015226333402097225,
-0.03596970811486244,
-0.019336670637130737,
0.00873007345944643,
0.04117804393172264,
-0.03354547172784805,
0.010927942581474781,
-0.0004499313945416361,
0.036285609006881714,
-0.040830593556165695,
0.04681022837758064,
-0.05443830043077469,
0.021784910932183266,
-0.0036706901155412197,
-0.013215583749115467,
0.011522173881530762,
0.054118722677230835,
0.007179971318691969,
-0.02016551047563553,
0.0024395729415118694,
-0.02969120442867279,
-0.024960052222013474,
-0.01930488832294941,
0.03765831142663956,
-0.005047982558608055,
0.033456869423389435,
0.02898925170302391,
-0.04335469380021095,
0.029720401391386986,
-0.018691502511501312,
0.03289684280753136,
0.059822507202625275,
-0.012820599600672722,
-0.002197753870859742,
-0.0016959580825641751,
-0.0797102078795433,
-0.01696259155869484,
0.02922380343079567,
-0.03653962165117264,
0.01678902842104435,
-0.021755045279860497,
-0.008200783282518387,
-0.06517527252435684,
-0.01959322765469551,
-0.013839419931173325,
0.004664956126362085,
0.05869085341691971,
0.006654387339949608,
-0.03642066940665245,
0.007905049249529839,
-0.009539186954498291,
-0.04607308283448219,
0.0021320870146155357,
0.021085551008582115,
-0.01734832674264908,
0.005414143204689026,
0.039780739694833755,
0.024781405925750732,
0.005892145447432995,
0.0063123381696641445,
0.03904484957456589,
-0.08283530920743942,
0.02931893989443779,
0.02117941528558731,
0.05198332294821739,
0.034933753311634064,
-0.03046959638595581,
0.009807858616113663,
-0.020582225173711777,
-0.09240571409463882,
-0.003737751394510269,
0.004552705213427544,
0.01846248283982277,
-0.0008537551620975137,
0.004882615990936756,
0.006654251366853714,
0.02081565372645855,
-0.009515372104942799,
0.04938480257987976,
0.2520553171634674,
0.01944047398865223,
-0.00807870365679264,
-0.010151367634534836,
-0.013113192282617092,
0.0020497064106166363,
0.0016062528593465686,
0.030082881450653076,
0.0358189158141613,
-0.03941743075847626,
-0.027866683900356293,
-0.005928284488618374,
-0.005527224391698837,
0.0015920069999992847,
-0.037834130227565765,
0.010513601824641228,
-0.045789264142513275,
-0.006269040051847696,
0.058680761605501175,
0.004423796199262142,
0.019504360854625702,
-0.024355478584766388,
0.061087340116500854,
0.024328893050551414,
-0.0399085134267807,
-0.02223188988864422,
-0.023757871240377426,
0.05806275084614754,
0.027360644191503525,
0.012160793878138065,
-0.054847005754709244,
-0.013130363076925278,
0.016839884221553802,
0.03759817034006119,
0.02364862896502018,
-0.0016320727299898863,
-0.04642361029982567,
-0.029795654118061066,
-0.05024522542953491,
0.03668314963579178,
-0.019140619784593582,
-0.0184200257062912,
0.022112401202321053,
-0.05617701634764671,
-0.0043975068256258965,
0.048543766140937805,
-0.052735403180122375,
0.02534407190978527,
-0.04690336808562279,
0.004993667360395193,
0.008344408124685287,
-0.005830754060298204,
-0.0030565124470740557,
0.032600902020931244,
-0.03644083812832832,
0.01240206602960825,
0.010226168669760227,
0.0029543533455580473,
-0.028835343196988106,
0.03766751289367676,
0.03679339587688446,
0.03928494080901146,
-0.0315670482814312,
0.04447542130947113,
0.0025500354822725058,
0.0056547545827925205,
-0.019666235893964767,
-0.0418759360909462,
0.027989419177174568,
0.023435130715370178,
0.042814116925001144,
0.015406923368573189,
-0.015355577692389488,
0.04211897403001785,
0.04610946401953697,
-0.014178243465721607,
-0.02103349380195141,
0.0033890113700181246,
0.03290003910660744,
-0.010388076305389404,
-0.01301832590252161,
-0.027592752128839493,
0.010515863075852394,
-0.007447421550750732,
0.015725864097476006,
-0.009598799981176853,
0.01103853341192007,
0.043833326548337936,
0.0526011660695076,
0.02689264714717865,
-0.00343987881205976,
0.0040395986288785934,
-0.06326861679553986,
-0.0198409054428339,
0.036147426813840866,
-0.02289396896958351,
0.009602521546185017,
-0.0028997352346777916,
0.0033192129340022802,
-0.009481585584580898,
0.015915753319859505,
-0.025180449709296227,
0.07069747149944305,
0.013314438052475452,
0.0076524545438587666,
-0.02323921024799347,
-0.03039737604558468,
0.009817712008953094,
-0.010401756502687931,
-0.026016296818852425,
-0.025074172765016556,
0.023870447650551796,
0.019804323092103004,
-0.02134917676448822,
0.05625629797577858,
0.03236575797200203,
-0.031655196100473404,
-0.0003330808540340513,
0.04056375101208687,
0.006384642329066992,
0.001442514592781663,
-0.004241625312715769,
-0.023110071197152138,
0.04890604689717293,
-0.02902895212173462,
0.01794365979731083,
-0.0030462623108178377,
0.021072296425700188,
0.00041891427827067673,
0.030510755255818367,
-0.02002890221774578,
-0.031557708978652954,
-0.02861674316227436,
0.00838917214423418,
0.04459979757666588,
0.0021585344802588224,
0.015351062640547752,
-0.0033544497564435005,
-0.03408270329236984,
0.01981651596724987,
0.02334076538681984,
0.011998409405350685,
-0.018926678225398064,
-0.0027818200178444386,
0.00791409332305193,
0.031957656145095825,
-0.07536561042070389,
0.005911840591579676,
-0.0632563903927803,
-0.011127589270472527,
0.043633196502923965,
0.004566696472465992,
-0.014369827695190907,
-0.015928346663713455,
0.02246100828051567,
-0.014415428973734379,
0.0009067704668268561,
0.03524692356586456,
0.013097185641527176,
-0.027714457362890244,
0.012415638193488121,
0.021842168644070625,
-0.013462966307997704,
0.03463929146528244,
0.023973485454916954,
0.07201164215803146,
-0.033527061343193054,
-0.01156244520097971,
-0.02552485466003418,
0.012035754509270191,
-0.01784881204366684,
-0.024363504722714424,
-0.02747456356883049,
0.004260566551238298,
0.04773601517081261,
-0.034005872905254364,
-0.030789189040660858,
-0.040795329958200455,
0.014066769741475582,
-0.023552116006612778,
-0.01714770309627056,
0.026149015873670578,
-0.03718185797333717,
0.07841362059116364,
0.011038337834179401,
-0.018896684050559998,
0.045481301844120026,
0.005925149656832218,
-0.0021986914798617363,
-0.02501801773905754,
-0.04356779903173447,
0.10404057800769806,
-0.03065837360918522,
-0.014133693650364876,
0.049100957810878754,
0.015013723634183407,
0.05588318780064583,
0.025416754186153412,
-0.006204798351973295,
-0.03565371036529541,
0.002139056334272027,
-0.010272807441651821,
0.001014828565530479,
0.0015153739368543029,
0.034383926540613174,
0.034052878618240356,
-0.017543716356158257,
0.023799486458301544,
-0.011553319171071053,
-0.00012430820788722485,
0.011926490813493729,
-0.003710306016728282,
-0.024574091657996178,
-0.03504107519984245,
-0.015344802290201187,
-0.023391133174300194,
0.04202500358223915,
0.03540722653269768,
-0.035660192370414734,
-0.012814742513000965,
-0.0013121094089001417,
-0.010876772925257683,
0.04765426367521286,
-0.07237932085990906,
-0.0368274450302124,
0.016693245619535446,
-0.02021980658173561,
-0.04589531570672989,
-0.0267866849899292,
-0.015880173072218895,
0.0052060880698263645,
-0.043802350759506226,
0.03662524372339249,
0.010065816342830658,
0.012893875129520893,
0.05535312369465828,
0.01593165099620819,
-0.01752125285565853,
0.022737601771950722,
-0.010085172019898891,
0.0006247218698263168,
0.022441726177930832,
0.010593115352094173,
0.017166106030344963,
-0.020462000742554665,
0.004481859505176544,
-0.02686895802617073,
-0.03621280565857887,
0.009247343055903912,
0.03108757734298706,
0.005948440637439489,
-0.026706302538514137,
0.009729462675750256,
-0.04526367783546448,
-0.0019828772637993097,
0.018261529505252838,
0.020287398248910904,
-0.0027566791977733374,
-0.05322329327464104,
-0.0086468905210495,
0.007019477430731058,
-0.008395378477871418,
-0.029218440875411034,
-0.019778544083237648,
-0.017932506278157234,
-0.05934670567512512,
0.0043653808534145355,
-0.011828414164483547,
-0.009732076898217201,
-0.07034772634506226,
-0.011367554776370525,
-0.012691425159573555,
-0.047197550535202026,
-0.03287805989384651,
0.0014906693249940872,
0.008957963436841965,
-0.0310166347771883,
0.02364422380924225,
0.04553206264972687,
0.02575627528131008,
0.02805626019835472,
0.004312875214964151,
0.005159279331564903,
0.06197842210531235,
0.012794993817806244,
0.02609073929488659,
0.019958507269620895,
0.02576894871890545,
0.014960402622818947,
-0.0043511842377483845,
0.029542630538344383,
0.02525359019637108,
-0.008314967155456543,
0.007162264548242092,
0.013320790603756905,
-0.002410255139693618,
-0.013406314887106419,
0.04642747342586517,
-0.0018877858528867364,
0.02771148830652237,
-0.02281486801803112,
0.034364499151706696,
-0.028652623295783997,
-0.01499888300895691,
-0.019137447699904442,
0.003504588734358549,
-0.002286131726577878,
-0.04075833410024643,
0.012495366856455803,
-0.011410926468670368,
0.02475600130856037,
-0.07880120724439621,
-0.02155349776148796,
-0.03366260230541229,
0.00005826471169712022,
-0.007833403535187244,
0.02550979144871235,
0.0015323502011597157,
0.05538114905357361,
-0.024935955181717873,
-0.00029964305576868355,
0.043098125606775284,
-0.023500120267271996,
0.03473697230219841,
-0.04604604095220566,
0.011238526552915573,
-0.027360539883375168,
-0.04959360137581825,
0.019746482372283936,
-0.005076469387859106,
-0.008952238596975803,
0.011315359733998775,
-0.02019769325852394,
0.047997795045375824,
0.02739689126610756,
0.03693728148937225,
0.00795504916459322,
-0.008566751144826412,
0.0030112997628748417,
-0.03206189349293709,
-0.004322279244661331,
-0.0173320434987545,
0.06821472197771072,
0.0015042504528537393,
-0.00797565933316946,
-0.0447596050798893,
0.009082656353712082,
0.0004889874835498631,
0.028919890522956848,
0.008970268070697784,
-0.009445460513234138,
-0.01036478765308857,
-0.022485146299004555,
-0.03477087616920471,
0.0370987206697464,
0.028497599065303802,
-0.0398271419107914,
0.011454257182776928,
0.05131865665316582,
-0.006965075619518757,
-0.015871141105890274,
0.0337434858083725,
-0.0018029704224318266,
-0.022940898314118385,
-0.0035126921720802784,
0.044888999313116074,
0.024529308080673218,
-0.00766422413289547,
-0.000466238270746544,
-0.005952490493655205,
0.00741860456764698,
0.06874193996191025,
0.011589321307837963,
0.007446604315191507,
-0.025234730914235115,
0.00813983753323555,
0.028375092893838882,
-0.033720117062330246,
0.018514730036258698,
-0.025550635531544685,
-0.028048457577824593,
-0.0708230584859848,
-0.05815146490931511,
-0.00635085254907608,
0.01808067224919796,
-0.014581325463950634,
-0.007290721405297518,
0.004666873253881931,
-0.026414819061756134,
0.029026860371232033,
-0.04263985529541969,
-0.008490501902997494,
-0.035947952419519424,
0.038130927830934525,
-0.15378239750862122,
0.022225340828299522,
0.019509993493556976,
-0.006395742297172546,
-0.0846569836139679,
-0.037609707564115524,
-0.0525897778570652,
0.01671023480594158,
-0.01406756043434143,
0.01210852526128292,
0.012360398657619953,
0.0308559387922287,
0.012492768466472626,
-0.02329011633992195,
-0.04644250124692917,
0.06251151114702225,
0.003882467746734619,
0.0025447988882660866,
-0.023544292896986008,
0.012119820341467857,
0.001689039170742035,
-0.031196098774671555,
0.04903893172740936,
-0.013256629928946495,
-0.021602170541882515,
-0.0271300096064806,
-0.018154429271817207,
-0.007518006023019552,
-0.029457496479153633,
-0.037276722490787506,
0.02781497873365879,
-0.055516112595796585,
0.004584452137351036,
0.019849300384521484,
0.004703642800450325,
0.03507855162024498,
0.021513473242521286,
-0.013541472144424915,
0.022983435541391373,
-0.016979368403553963,
-0.04579566419124603,
0.0040605743415653706,
-0.035132572054862976,
-0.033782731741666794,
0.011936028487980366,
0.03219752386212349,
-0.03525656834244728,
0.007560975383967161,
-0.050840213894844055,
-0.025633176788687706,
-0.048702891916036606,
0.05550019443035126,
0.00015198993787635118,
0.00367193715646863,
0.01608508639037609,
-0.0024714891333132982,
-0.016898076981306076,
-0.013001993298530579,
0.006462564691901207,
0.005848952103406191,
0.0023423293605446815,
-0.030507070943713188,
-0.02331671305000782,
-0.006880848202854395,
0.042440518736839294,
-0.0024043372832238674,
0.02087552659213543,
-0.023269250988960266,
-0.006696616765111685,
-0.016579212620854378,
-0.01255610678344965,
-0.045698389410972595,
-0.003312751417979598,
-0.005515607073903084,
0.006729550659656525,
0.015776289626955986,
0.0373435914516449,
0.005012436304241419,
0.00046958253369666636,
-0.007963993586599827,
-0.0009440595167689025,
-0.032148994505405426,
-0.01021659653633833,
-0.07328665256500244,
-0.01662294566631317,
0.0303631741553545,
0.006384709849953651,
-0.029570426791906357,
0.016328707337379456,
-0.05112014710903168,
-0.03520304709672928,
-0.0032684991601854563,
-0.031237630173563957,
0.08385880291461945,
-0.00006580429908353835,
0.035002414137125015,
-0.01703198254108429,
-0.03214871883392334,
-0.03144266456365585,
-0.013548002578318119,
-0.024523919448256493,
-0.04507505148649216,
0.01259679812937975,
0.016160929575562477,
-0.055060673505067825,
-0.004477925598621368,
-0.0006167742540128529,
-0.022112712264060974,
-0.009775909595191479,
0.014872231520712376,
0.04221025109291077,
-0.028088178485631943,
-0.057017918676137924,
0.000500429596286267,
-0.05318322032690048,
0.03239051625132561,
-0.012630102224647999,
0.0497753880918026,
0.019097892567515373,
0.00322127528488636,
0.006469967309385538,
0.018038921058177948,
-0.006844726391136646,
-0.021013440564274788,
-0.01180359534919262,
0.008599000051617622,
0.057521577924489975,
-0.007925352081656456,
0.01744542270898819,
-0.02667761966586113,
0.014009113423526287,
-0.000003960602498409571,
0.025956790894269943,
0.037374310195446014,
0.0058034323155879974,
0.039444103837013245,
-0.0050044674426317215,
0.01200932264328003,
-0.01960715651512146,
-0.02937455289065838,
0.04078063741326332,
-0.048644259572029114,
-0.002390535781159997,
-0.03019600361585617,
-0.03086715005338192,
0.025623826310038567,
0.0018791531911119819,
0.014033251442015171,
-0.02350466139614582,
-0.005180209409445524,
0.02710438147187233,
0.026535671204328537,
-0.016646001487970352,
0.04276169836521149,
-0.02392197586596012,
0.04595131799578667,
0.010412446223199368,
0.0029171223286539316,
0.02316332794725895,
0.04530102387070656,
-0.0002086559688905254,
-0.03108213283121586,
-0.010498571209609509,
-0.01668431982398033,
-0.0038656473625451326,
0.053678322583436966,
-0.0029440615326166153,
0.019351689144968987,
-0.030308326706290245,
0.02354544773697853,
0.001244981656782329,
0.00038090607267804444,
-0.0020804216619580984,
-0.004630476702004671,
0.011088648810982704,
-0.006548046600073576,
0.009479262866079807,
-0.026728330180048943,
0.025510098785161972,
-0.013297765515744686,
0.025106169283390045,
0.010278206318616867,
0.017643092200160027,
0.014002153649926186,
0.025052417069673538,
0.05726022273302078,
0.022379690781235695,
-0.01065756008028984,
-0.034679755568504333,
-0.032064393162727356,
0.023384151980280876,
-0.010167231783270836,
0.040502097457647324,
-0.003516358556225896,
0.01627584546804428,
0.008948341012001038,
-0.009371578693389893,
0.048112135380506516,
0.03533231467008591,
0.04728519916534424,
0.02477605640888214,
-0.014401860535144806,
-0.030687514692544937,
-0.03604177013039589,
-0.05663520470261574,
0.009630367159843445,
0.0069036539644002914,
-0.04366670176386833,
-0.03640485927462578,
0.059786781668663025,
-0.05786789953708649,
-0.024222906678915024,
-0.015943313017487526,
0.040771014988422394,
-0.013640904799103737,
-0.029512111097574234,
-0.03842286765575409,
-0.012369316071271896,
0.0057535115629434586,
-0.005270830355584621,
0.017145883291959763,
0.03514927253127098,
-0.03346525877714157,
-0.013615219853818417,
0.004111948423087597,
0.01299266330897808,
-0.010129116475582123,
0.005239739082753658,
-0.010876012966036797,
-0.04100412130355835,
-0.0005748422117903829,
-0.020269859582185745,
-0.007592339068651199,
0.06721821427345276,
0.005656605586409569,
-0.057334575802087784,
-0.010800762102007866,
0.01468582171946764,
-0.02842637710273266,
0.006526377517729998,
-0.03075288236141205,
-0.011778183281421661,
-0.0065684691071510315,
-0.01833347976207733
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:37
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
203The defendant made a submission that due to her difficult financial situation she should be paid in cash with the defendant to retain the assets. Given that she will be entitled to her award of damages, which is substantial, this will relieve her financial situation. It is preferable that both parties have an incentive to attend properly to the realisation of their assets.
The defendant's cross claim for assault
204I have found that the following assaults have been proved:
1.The argument in May 1993 (assault);
2.The threat to kill and battery in 1995 (assault and battery);
3.One occasion of ordering the defendant out of the house in 1996 (assault);
4.The beer incident and threat to shoot in December 2000 (assault and battery);
5.Threat to shoot in 2007 (assault).
205The defendant claims damages, aggravated and exemplary damages. However, before considering her claim I must ascertain whether or not her causes of action in relation to each occasion of assault and/or battery are statute barred.
The applicable limitation period
206In relation to all of the incidents except the last incident in 2007, the relevant section in the Limitation Act 1969 is section 18A, which relevantly reads:
"18A Personal injury
(1) This section applies to a cause of action, founded on negligence, nuisance or breach of duty, for damages for personal injury, but does not apply to:
(a) ...
(b) ...
(c) a cause of action to which Division 6 applies.
Note. Division 6 provides for the limitation period for non-motor accident actions for death or personal injury resulting from an incident that occurs on or after the commencement of that Division.
(2) An action on a cause of action to which this section applies is not maintainable if brought after the expiration of a limitation period of 3 years running from the date on which the cause of action first accrues to the plaintiff or to a person through whom the plaintiff claims."
207Campbell J in O'Neill v Foster (2004) 61 NSWLR 499 at [44] confirmed that s 18A is the correct section to apply in a cause of action for assault given the extended definition in s 11 of the Limitation Act 1969 of "breach of duty", which includes trespass to the person. By analogy s 18A also governs a cause of action for battery.
208In relation to the 2007 incident, section 18A does not apply. Since the "act or omission alleged to have resulted in the injury... with which a claim is concerned" occurred on or after the commencement of Part 2, Division 6 of the Limitation Act 1969, being 6 December 2002, Division 6 governs the cause of action (see s 18A (1)(c) and 50A).
209Therefore section 50C applies to the cause of action for the assault in 2007. Section 50C is the crucial section in Division 6 for the purposes of these proceedings. The section reads:
"50C Limitation period for personal injury actions
(1) An action on a cause of action to which this Division applies is not maintainable if brought after the expiration of a limitation period of whichever of the following periods is the first to expire:
(a) the 3 year post discoverability limitation period, which is the period of 3 years running from and including the date on which the cause of action is discoverable by the plaintiff,
(b) the 12 year long-stop limitation period, which is the period of 12 years running from the time of the act or omission alleged to have resulted in the injury or death with which the claim is concerned..."
210Section 50D defines the 'date on which a cause of action is discoverable':
"50D Date cause of action is discoverable
(1) For the purposes of this Division, a cause of action is discoverable by a person on the first date that the person knows or ought to know of each of the following facts:
(a) the fact that the injury or death concerned has occurred,
(b) the fact that the injury or death was caused by the fault of the defendant,
|
[
0.017645252868533134,
0.061580780893564224,
-0.012833577580749989,
0.0050171008333563805,
-0.028600631281733513,
-0.06576532125473022,
0.0354427769780159,
0.033674709498882294,
-0.003465300891548395,
0.0012612068094313145,
0.012383089400827885,
0.06473932415246964,
-0.0437607541680336,
0.019809016957879066,
0.0029746596701443195,
-0.004405996296554804,
0.026362022385001183,
0.007352530024945736,
-0.02695065550506115,
-0.022487886250019073,
-0.0044860271736979485,
-0.010138658806681633,
-0.008994245901703835,
0.017559770494699478,
-0.040115587413311005,
0.0022968612611293793,
-0.04634235426783562,
-0.021869737654924393,
-0.010035417973995209,
0.04593402147293091,
-0.021318430081009865,
-0.013126032426953316,
0.014515955932438374,
-0.023459313437342644,
0.008966755121946335,
-0.032381024211645126,
-0.009535999968647957,
-0.01570340059697628,
-0.051515430212020874,
0.03600859269499779,
0.014016155153512955,
0.008532393723726273,
0.01988654024899006,
0.018539132550358772,
0.039586927741765976,
-0.014484918676316738,
-0.005207815207540989,
-0.0494588203728199,
-0.03270865976810455,
-0.030359193682670593,
-0.0026955099310725927,
-0.011074275709688663,
0.033996812999248505,
-0.020789189264178276,
0.03606641665101051,
0.048387374728918076,
-0.01775958761572838,
-0.04187270998954773,
-0.03570380061864853,
-0.0009206077083945274,
-0.032156940549612045,
-0.02350739948451519,
-0.06063651666045189,
-0.014457691460847855,
0.01132361963391304,
0.01801818236708641,
-0.0043892646208405495,
-0.018951617181301117,
-0.000844329537358135,
-0.026814088225364685,
0.010276738554239273,
0.015819258987903595,
0.0035626778844743967,
-0.01823468692600727,
-0.06113100051879883,
0.011103756725788116,
0.06339187175035477,
-0.004302297253161669,
0.01525496132671833,
0.010540323331952095,
-0.003241440514102578,
0.022480618208646774,
0.02095324732363224,
0.03199749067425728,
-0.0012008005287498236,
0.0438806414604187,
-0.05119388550519943,
-0.03972281143069267,
0.03534572571516037,
-0.012762580066919327,
0.00568681675940752,
0.00296200392767787,
-0.006148716900497675,
-0.0036545549519360065,
-0.0075030867010355,
-0.003377337707206607,
-0.055422909557819366,
-0.0235627219080925,
0.023380190134048462,
0.011783679947257042,
0.03037887252867222,
0.031426187604665756,
0.03981143608689308,
-0.020393047481775284,
0.003572119167074561,
-0.0034098343458026648,
0.06436176598072052,
0.04828638210892677,
0.044423606246709824,
-0.006366940680891275,
0.0130652179941535,
0.03168300911784172,
0.012595213018357754,
0.01817348226904869,
0.004927272442728281,
0.0019382929895073175,
0.015087499283254147,
-0.05402125418186188,
-0.015098017640411854,
-0.027718082070350647,
0.0277765691280365,
0.028272800147533417,
0.07191655039787292,
-0.05629799887537956,
-0.02487597055733204,
0.02700020559132099,
0.028491342440247536,
0.01146620698273182,
-0.02800017036497593,
0.04936765134334564,
0.014172835275530815,
-0.02152622491121292,
-0.02643916942179203,
-0.02862715534865856,
-0.037129245698451996,
-0.004723214544355869,
0.040018822997808456,
0.04566444456577301,
0.04770569130778313,
-0.04898913949728012,
0.02704748511314392,
0.002085820073261857,
-0.006661840248852968,
-0.025160348042845726,
0.045650288462638855,
-0.03040018118917942,
0.00626247888430953,
-0.021478498354554176,
0.03465431183576584,
0.009802399203181267,
0.010087325237691402,
-0.00992252491414547,
0.05209464207291603,
-0.058775752782821655,
-0.009079858660697937,
-0.055089011788368225,
0.001622451702132821,
-0.028893928974866867,
0.050668928772211075,
-0.027327045798301697,
0.03195895254611969,
-0.013258235529065132,
-0.03363988548517227,
0.011332063004374504,
0.021213458850979805,
0.06524356454610825,
0.005417386535555124,
0.024654163047671318,
-0.05242258682847023,
0.015498621389269829,
0.06085735931992531,
-0.03491600975394249,
-0.0013150586746633053,
-0.03631962463259697,
0.03191104158759117,
0.020447636023163795,
0.006987379398196936,
0.021199557930231094,
-0.05163269490003586,
-0.008423698134720325,
-0.038213059306144714,
0.026210013777017593,
-0.001127417664974928,
0.021520337089896202,
-0.024323595687747,
0.03382685035467148,
-0.050927821546792984,
0.00025858712615445256,
0.013756864704191685,
0.03278942406177521,
-0.01718246378004551,
-0.039359502494335175,
-0.022562695667147636,
0.038943856954574585,
0.021702969446778297,
-0.06570978462696075,
0.03679535165429115,
-0.057271841913461685,
0.014846081845462322,
-0.0043674674816429615,
-0.017085181549191475,
0.053103309124708176,
0.0631398856639862,
-0.010564328171312809,
-0.023235078901052475,
0.019307861104607582,
-0.041047465056180954,
0.02422565221786499,
0.027770882472395897,
-0.06810753047466278,
0.0002707413223106414,
0.018880188465118408,
0.010281579568982124,
0.012973503209650517,
-0.04022539407014847,
-0.03279775008559227,
0.028394723311066628,
-0.019296947866678238,
0.010477857664227486,
-0.003581967670470476,
0.00736002204939723,
0.023693833500146866,
-0.04830646142363548,
-0.007954424247145653,
0.020885812118649483,
-0.002169246319681406,
-0.03184695541858673,
0.018202215433120728,
0.01355541218072176,
-0.04390493035316467,
0.02965778112411499,
0.015459209680557251,
0.003102109534665942,
-0.018280070275068283,
0.029835950583219528,
-0.010005274787545204,
0.047963742166757584,
0.020793357864022255,
0.013411683961749077,
-0.0024402074050158262,
0.02367572672665119,
-0.05879877135157585,
0.007612229790538549,
0.002419186057522893,
0.0006586906383745372,
-0.021253913640975952,
0.04446481540799141,
0.04209613800048828,
-0.014502059668302536,
-0.013916965574026108,
-0.0127360625192523,
-0.032964590936899185,
0.00018783453560899943,
-0.00639922171831131,
-0.015778006985783577,
0.02468150295317173,
-0.023719824850559235,
0.0004393150156829506,
0.037930678576231,
0.0076671442948281765,
-0.03088541515171528,
0.007661096751689911,
0.04779171943664551,
0.01185133308172226,
-0.002989858388900757,
-0.011167017742991447,
-0.00972925778478384,
-0.03284366801381111,
-0.0013670643093064427,
-0.004487206693738699,
-0.0135337607935071,
-0.013808724470436573,
-0.01570257730782032,
-0.04043833166360855,
0.018841644749045372,
0.046093910932540894,
0.051033005118370056,
-0.0034824300091713667,
-0.000566906004678458,
0.018804289400577545,
0.02421058900654316,
0.010554378852248192,
0.042869556695222855,
-0.01212239172309637,
0.045476000756025314,
0.020231347531080246,
-0.03213571012020111,
-0.03588027134537697,
0.020485173910856247,
-0.029314663261175156,
0.02188136614859104,
-0.011734466068446636,
0.07252634316682816,
-0.04850657656788826,
-0.05177486687898636,
0.010345670394599438,
-0.006934445817023516,
-0.14435511827468872,
-0.011298857629299164,
-0.013882484287023544,
0.06624293327331543,
0.02153412252664566,
0.019362274557352066,
-0.02060016430914402,
-0.005117304623126984,
-0.03680963069200516,
0.050151433795690536,
0.019115841016173363,
-0.06937047094106674,
0.001760185812599957,
0.027231749147176743,
0.014589543454349041,
-0.0016776639968156815,
-0.016768597066402435,
0.0026903911493718624,
0.01023221854120493,
-0.02700204774737358,
-0.05330239236354828,
0.032832615077495575,
0.005973423831164837,
-0.02313479408621788,
0.019866541028022766,
0.05072438716888428,
0.019761964678764343,
0.03280368447303772,
-0.027992606163024902,
0.0032427506521344185,
-0.07341960072517395,
-0.02073970064520836,
-0.007517182733863592,
0.039936430752277374,
0.01109970360994339,
0.0444917269051075,
-0.013731715269386768,
-0.045112188905477524,
0.0039258673787117004,
-0.003091819118708372,
0.01818862557411194,
0.05733788013458252,
0.012628098949790001,
-0.0010443401988595724,
0.02311578020453453,
-0.08423744887113571,
-0.042778030037879944,
0.016806358471512794,
-0.041073836386203766,
-0.005809865426272154,
-0.05156974494457245,
0.017818061634898186,
-0.035222094506025314,
-0.03135314956307411,
-0.01680242083966732,
-0.011579352430999279,
0.0707169622182846,
0.04349718615412712,
-0.02111155167222023,
0.011325824074447155,
0.03613385930657387,
-0.06088240072131157,
-0.00480220653116703,
-0.004976974334567785,
-0.012598478235304356,
0.00042676817975007,
0.01997172273695469,
0.0033742378000169992,
0.00836009532213211,
-0.0501318983733654,
0.02741982601583004,
-0.10229658335447311,
0.02091905102133751,
0.011575308628380299,
-0.013361729681491852,
0.013628615066409111,
0.03213160112500191,
-0.0351276695728302,
-0.035880234092473984,
-0.11899146437644958,
-0.0066960952244699,
0.03229976072907448,
-0.009007187560200691,
0.04576008394360542,
0.0011808749986812472,
-0.03075077198445797,
0.047819457948207855,
-0.01447537075728178,
-0.0008586071780882776,
0.21504400670528412,
-0.00510222977027297,
-0.0213931892067194,
0.042880646884441376,
0.01455334760248661,
0.0017481392715126276,
-0.0013842014595866203,
-0.008313552476465702,
-0.010357058607041836,
-0.04717366397380829,
-0.016320299357175827,
0.04127645120024681,
0.010186810977756977,
-0.004941623657941818,
-0.03614728897809982,
0.008783182129263878,
-0.01357736624777317,
-0.008748168125748634,
0.08513994514942169,
0.013732600957155228,
0.023663783445954323,
-0.04222482442855835,
0.023039229214191437,
0.050752632319927216,
-0.04216231778264046,
-0.042910173535346985,
0.01352800615131855,
0.06089441105723381,
-0.02377350628376007,
0.050630394369363785,
-0.04321024939417839,
-0.03312127664685249,
0.037381041795015335,
-0.027728062123060226,
-0.009626001119613647,
0.0031421477906405926,
0.009835748001933098,
0.005905916914343834,
-0.03472978249192238,
0.026863306760787964,
0.0008194604888558388,
-0.016349192708730698,
-0.04079620540142059,
-0.017433064058423042,
0.03524838760495186,
0.015942752361297607,
-0.003042232245206833,
0.04356859624385834,
-0.0019741198047995567,
0.03011646494269371,
0.025660568848252296,
0.029424333944916725,
-0.0018564347410574555,
0.012996559962630272,
-0.06997963041067123,
-0.03152335062623024,
0.011215806938707829,
-0.011388275772333145,
-0.0049556647427380085,
-0.007057627663016319,
0.00022775014804210514,
0.009000161662697792,
-0.05840582773089409,
0.03369281440973282,
0.00459665060043335,
-0.011934150010347366,
-0.052142105996608734,
-0.0048026773147284985,
0.007960954681038857,
-0.03326119855046272,
0.005233915522694588,
0.025928501039743423,
-0.010545681230723858,
0.035834379494190216,
0.036924805492162704,
-0.003255056217312813,
-0.022354362532496452,
0.014650157652795315,
0.027341846376657486,
0.0012446792097762227,
-0.04639393463730812,
-0.06542248278856277,
-0.006729442160576582,
0.0050490074791014194,
0.008799975737929344,
-0.0005663822521455586,
-0.01847263053059578,
0.048544853925704956,
0.014089707285165787,
-0.01541516836732626,
-0.01903657242655754,
-0.02411983348429203,
-0.015258357860147953,
0.0032474936451762915,
0.013366477563977242,
0.01980329304933548,
0.04796820878982544,
0.013108859769999981,
-0.04180021956562996,
-0.018227942287921906,
0.0055050328373909,
-0.019300982356071472,
0.03984643518924713,
-0.018045401200652122,
0.008571630343794823,
-0.004191352520138025,
-0.01117164921015501,
0.0023360117338597775,
-0.03193075954914093,
-0.0791059136390686,
-0.015098818577826023,
0.03369703143835068,
-0.013327965512871742,
-0.014254092238843441,
0.01997227594256401,
0.06900443136692047,
-0.04615309461951256,
0.029553290456533432,
0.03409208729863167,
0.020520951598882675,
-0.00951936561614275,
0.017400721088051796,
-0.0025732610374689102,
0.01640498824417591,
-0.020710909739136696,
-0.03409182280302048,
-0.008363633416593075,
-0.024989601224660873,
0.012373922392725945,
0.03338102623820305,
-0.05294887721538544,
-0.005233948118984699,
-0.01921524479985237,
-0.005066159646958113,
0.04333820566534996,
-0.005895651411265135,
0.01709751784801483,
0.03159065544605255,
-0.020115235820412636,
-0.02547631971538067,
0.04162951186299324,
-0.009095548652112484,
-0.04953811690211296,
0.026107240468263626,
-0.02281951531767845,
0.039138633757829666,
-0.035870715975761414,
0.007643239572644234,
-0.06597737967967987,
0.006457530427724123,
0.025127317756414413,
0.0020190817303955555,
0.002312118886038661,
-0.04698137938976288,
-0.0221388041973114,
-0.044218022376298904,
0.00891694612801075,
0.04789542406797409,
-0.018869638442993164,
-0.027507580816745758,
-0.030896635726094246,
-0.040011368691921234,
-0.029067115858197212,
0.019279232248663902,
0.03268514946103096,
0.05071863532066345,
0.033263351768255234,
0.05008254200220108,
0.007516360376030207,
-0.002636142075061798,
0.007255684118717909,
-0.005874572321772575,
-0.023829063400626183,
0.019222961738705635,
0.004351529758423567,
0.020822400227189064,
-0.04021770507097244,
0.040540605783462524,
-0.04537780582904816,
0.00016437405429314822,
0.03418206796050072,
0.03189051151275635,
-0.018721934407949448,
0.06051599979400635,
0.002678871853277087,
-0.011663911864161491,
0.0459393635392189,
-0.018596837297081947,
0.029205162078142166,
-0.021920662373304367,
-0.02670637145638466,
0.08962078392505646,
0.009654858149588108,
-0.004952540155500174,
-0.0021653324365615845,
-0.011074228212237358,
0.042724739760160446,
0.05037800595164299,
0.050349410623311996,
0.0007748672505840659,
-0.035205867141485214,
0.008172690868377686,
0.006549882236868143,
-0.015065828338265419,
0.019501453265547752,
-0.019613437354564667,
0.025789042934775352,
0.033307094126939774,
-0.015219134278595448,
0.016535496339201927,
0.016558781266212463,
0.04217850789427757,
-0.02862401306629181,
-0.01346959825605154,
-0.034190788865089417,
0.016827045008540154,
0.001064618700183928,
0.01290129590779543,
0.00013669430336449295,
-0.0285955723375082,
-0.04011077433824539,
-0.021097375079989433,
0.025986403226852417,
-0.0419745147228241,
0.007199620362371206,
0.0017556424718350172,
-0.003731743199750781,
-0.06608197093009949,
-0.026648221537470818,
-0.020916568115353584,
0.003337169997394085,
-0.061172645539045334,
0.0027174223214387894,
-0.008064113557338715,
-0.012917323969304562,
0.002261323155835271,
0.023412827402353287,
0.0004637578094843775,
0.041690390557050705,
-0.04123338311910629,
-0.013586108572781086,
0.01350372564047575,
-0.006649347022175789,
0.031034749001264572,
-0.024775894358754158,
0.02004278637468815,
-0.012857617810368538,
-0.018641222268342972,
0.04103197529911995,
0.020157525315880775,
0.011856527999043465,
-0.0285015981644392,
0.023659054189920425,
-0.03522515296936035,
0.036771260201931,
0.01726638339459896,
-0.0016826641513034701,
0.016993416473269463,
-0.06561889499425888,
-0.032489191740751266,
0.006590200588107109,
0.014799223281443119,
-0.0068822898901999,
-0.023086324334144592,
-0.04378717020153999,
-0.05640462413430214,
-0.018921079114079475,
-0.016614548861980438,
-0.020028013736009598,
-0.053458765149116516,
0.03108292818069458,
0.019375696778297424,
-0.0066145178861916065,
-0.027421066537499428,
0.006673615891486406,
-0.023749837651848793,
-0.04101996868848801,
0.030407235026359558,
0.05239136517047882,
-0.018890809267759323,
-0.014761015772819519,
0.010750824585556984,
0.061672989279031754,
0.04338846728205681,
0.02282838709652424,
-0.017190173268318176,
0.018711302429437637,
0.005731076933443546,
0.017261868342757225,
-0.023196732625365257,
0.023658962920308113,
-0.013358846306800842,
-0.062011707574129105,
0.022092506289482117,
-0.008477097377181053,
-0.01475417148321867,
-0.010434542782604694,
0.031229428946971893,
-0.025358404964208603,
0.010810863226652145,
0.0011816330952569842,
-0.0017633303068578243,
-0.03855518996715546,
-0.04493960738182068,
-0.0010330149671062827,
-0.028792669996619225,
0.002503206254914403,
-0.03098790906369686,
-0.033130399882793427,
0.01049844827502966,
-0.014018415473401546,
-0.07039076834917068,
0.016885092481970787,
-0.04118918627500534,
-0.006468645296990871,
-0.0272440854460001,
-0.017033595591783524,
-0.012105035595595837,
0.044414978474378586,
0.01041136123239994,
0.027760805562138557,
-0.015744008123874664,
-0.025290289893746376,
0.028805328533053398,
-0.08368291705846786,
0.024405740201473236,
0.00010116679914062843,
-0.0512351356446743,
-0.017813129350543022,
0.016293182969093323,
-0.04229557141661644,
-0.009972522966563702,
-0.02144058607518673,
0.015933312475681305,
0.05161512643098831,
0.054174888879060745,
0.011470703408122063,
-0.027553798630833626,
0.05659833177924156,
-0.04477107897400856,
-0.01439698413014412,
-0.042331621050834656,
0.05999183654785156,
0.014693857170641422,
-0.03606545552611351,
-0.01702021434903145,
0.011147643439471722,
-0.018047932535409927,
0.010610156692564487,
0.01935175247490406,
-0.012427816167473793,
0.002570081502199173,
-0.010026516392827034,
-0.04006299749016762,
0.0522380955517292,
0.019039781764149666,
-0.00041294656693935394,
0.054812002927064896,
0.029459476470947266,
0.00581450667232275,
-0.013440084643661976,
0.03768444433808327,
0.017096679657697678,
0.004450211767107248,
-0.004715531133115292,
0.019956346601247787,
-0.00003895774352713488,
0.003401240799576044,
0.021687977015972137,
-0.01147129014134407,
0.029572738334536552,
-0.03533656895160675,
0.013321103528141975,
-0.007770128082484007,
-0.03190574049949646,
0.024834956973791122,
0.006162178702652454,
-0.03793187439441681,
0.02825205959379673,
-0.017284072935581207,
-0.04345805570483208,
-0.03007362224161625,
-0.03762060031294823,
0.006673024967312813,
0.017944592982530594,
-0.010274349711835384,
-0.01891789585351944,
0.030198249965906143,
0.0059080570936203,
0.044026315212249756,
-0.00024545693304389715,
0.04343821853399277,
-0.051428306847810745,
0.018031461164355278,
-0.15537694096565247,
-0.0031662334222346544,
0.0021434989757835865,
-0.012927102856338024,
-0.041028816252946854,
0.008279542438685894,
-0.0481993742287159,
0.038702886551618576,
-0.02941306307911873,
-0.0008901870460249484,
0.014576885849237442,
-0.03147098422050476,
0.0560622476041317,
-0.0005365044926293194,
-0.01767428033053875,
0.036036379635334015,
-0.021595358848571777,
-0.006311860866844654,
-0.018842710182070732,
0.027523944154381752,
0.007740546949207783,
0.0034504292998462915,
-0.01992897316813469,
-0.04686841741204262,
-0.020412662997841835,
0.0016740963328629732,
-0.04968098923563957,
-0.020384961739182472,
-0.030927659943699837,
-0.02725166082382202,
0.008726309053599834,
-0.03341667354106903,
-0.0025309857446700335,
0.031046627089381218,
0.04971415549516678,
0.005149854347109795,
0.00318021303974092,
-0.02642405405640602,
-0.0016191067406907678,
-0.021760696545243263,
-0.02713741548359394,
0.0032535335049033165,
-0.03687169402837753,
-0.023427367210388184,
0.05248255282640457,
0.03479450196027756,
-0.013135244138538837,
0.000516885076649487,
-0.07889227569103241,
0.002547602402046323,
-0.016619501635432243,
0.025097979232668877,
0.02011837810277939,
0.023494858294725418,
0.002106762956827879,
0.021746328100562096,
-0.015365852043032646,
-0.037083949893713,
-0.0021976602729409933,
-0.0005505746812559664,
-0.02172384224832058,
0.015600359998643398,
-0.03694014251232147,
-0.0011902692494913936,
0.06620043516159058,
0.05583985149860382,
-0.053629133850336075,
-0.005404985044151545,
0.00038784617208875716,
-0.03514941409230232,
-0.015117202885448933,
-0.02288362942636013,
-0.0052766562439501286,
-0.009404479525983334,
-0.0035236466210335493,
0.036839649081230164,
0.00606163963675499,
0.0007986908312886953,
0.0019370733061805367,
0.010452174581587315,
0.006985736079514027,
0.0004992537433281541,
-0.006623758468776941,
-0.013328511267900467,
0.05747366324067116,
-0.02086099609732628,
0.007168028969317675,
-0.0049469927325844765,
0.018889877945184708,
-0.023374460637569427,
-0.05288996919989586,
-0.004396332893520594,
-0.006684750318527222,
0.016518408432602882,
-0.008732710033655167,
0.033223580569028854,
-0.012477164156734943,
-0.029420921579003334,
-0.02091391384601593,
-0.000836492923554033,
0.005522397346794605,
-0.027985064312815666,
0.040643125772476196,
-0.012502782978117466,
-0.04519190639257431,
0.027551984414458275,
0.03560236096382141,
0.0068807960487902164,
-0.031918708235025406,
0.009898507967591286,
-0.022347930818796158,
-0.0341055765748024,
-0.0678136795759201,
-0.012373062781989574,
-0.04890129715204239,
-0.029830340296030045,
-0.0015117257134988904,
0.01620524376630783,
-0.021643808111548424,
0.023963572457432747,
0.0002198599831899628,
0.0037593229208141565,
0.006869161501526833,
-0.04118410870432854,
-0.025865335017442703,
-0.0027755030896514654,
0.04457765072584152,
0.019953260198235512,
0.035608019679784775,
-0.008027254603803158,
0.05609438568353653,
-0.018940482288599014,
0.0014947415329515934,
0.026979822665452957,
-0.01661546714603901,
0.005884505342692137,
-0.0030735977925360203,
0.02254035510122776,
-0.025199050083756447,
-0.03420092910528183,
0.002476274501532316,
0.001945739146322012,
-0.01523377001285553,
-0.019132137298583984,
-0.020313169807195663,
-0.01227494701743126,
0.039564311504364014,
0.012986589223146439,
-0.02198105677962303,
-0.011760738678276539,
-0.051035456359386444,
0.03411811217665672,
0.033665161579847336,
0.0654035359621048,
0.004113410599529743,
-0.01465290505439043,
0.013831496238708496,
0.006182575598359108,
-0.0009082422475330532,
0.04106986150145531,
-0.006720792036503553,
-0.03108949027955532,
-0.01676378771662712,
-0.03434973582625389,
-0.009955416433513165,
0.04709243029356003,
-0.03087814338505268,
0.011246315203607082,
-0.0554770864546299,
-0.0012012124061584473,
-0.003978355787694454,
-0.00618957681581378,
0.005319422110915184,
0.05701342597603798,
-0.034170858561992645,
0.0017645311309024692,
-0.005579374730587006,
0.012420072220265865,
0.008719253353774548,
-0.019605044275522232,
0.020174017176032066,
0.019921280443668365,
-0.0034433393739163876,
0.009501601569354534,
0.02126317471265793,
0.020772118121385574,
0.03669096902012825,
0.007554476615041494,
-0.0004990098532289267,
-0.04511435702443123,
0.017919637262821198,
-0.015404940582811832,
-0.029469799250364304,
-0.01713266409933567,
0.04606242477893829,
0.0077221752144396305,
-0.008708784356713295,
0.020709898322820663,
0.028515497222542763,
0.028011446818709373,
0.07022642344236374,
-0.005053980275988579,
-0.012113507837057114,
0.004628398455679417,
-0.013463899493217468,
-0.01642625220119953,
-0.013973252847790718,
-0.03170124068856239,
-0.049594178795814514,
0.026928454637527466,
-0.012118687853217125,
0.0016550797736272216,
0.026670606806874275,
0.04163825511932373,
0.031156908720731735,
0.008023825474083424,
0.020225347951054573,
0.030019164085388184,
-0.01066083088517189,
-0.02214599773287773,
0.05244608223438263,
0.0450485534965992,
-0.012385586276650429,
-0.05209073796868324,
0.011267886497080326,
-0.009001048281788826,
-0.04802557826042175,
0.033835675567388535,
0.004467940889298916,
-0.013433479703962803,
0.00016989670984912664,
-0.049595825374126434,
0.025810392573475838,
0.05132513493299484,
0.04062648490071297,
-0.03542749211192131,
-0.030082566663622856,
-0.04421886429190636,
-0.011734426021575928,
0.01161025371402502,
0.06288927048444748,
0.021989138796925545,
-0.012049230746924877,
0.00855428259819746
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e:5
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d977e
|
Honda push mower, Cox ride-on mower, whipper snippers etc removed from the former home by the Defendant (E) Joint $3,000
Leftover stock from Ace High Hats (hats) & Techni 2000 (welding rods) - stored at River Road, now in Defendant's possession (E) Joint (6) $9,000
Glassware - already distributed between the parties (E) Joint $25,000
Farm machinery & equipment (E) Joint $20,000
Janmel - 50% (as per agreed value) Joint $236,196
Superannuation Plaintiff $17,000
Total assets $1,938,231
Liabilities
ANZ equity manager account Joint $145,299
Re 282 SBR Joint $347,150
50% share of mortgage on River Road ($130,000) Joint $65,000
Total joint liabilities $557,449
Net joint assets $1,380,782
28The defendant's position throws up the following differences between the parties.
(1)The add back for Gaythorne which I determine at $421,000.
(2)Operating account. Plaintiff $24,255 defendant $26,064. In the absence of any proper explanation for the difference between the parties as to the ANZ joint operating account, I will adopt the lower figure of $24,255.
(3)Netsaver account. The parties are agreed as to the present balance of $10,280. There is no agreement as to whether recent reductions were for joint expenses or simply personal payments for the plaintiff.
The amount in the Netsaver bank account as at 1 July 2011 was $78,230. Given the agreement as to the present balance of $10,280 I will use that figure in the absence of evidence as to the purposes of the reduction.
(4)Janmell loan. Plaintiff Nil defendant $73,692 plus interest of $17,153.07. Having regard to the affidavit evidence of the plaintiff I will adopt his figures for the Janmell loans and monies owed for use of joint funds.
(5)Monies owed by plaintiff for use of joint funds. Plaintiff $4,700 defendant $165,612.81. Having regard to the affidavit evidence of the plaintiff I will adopt his figures for the Janmell loans and monies owed for use of joint funds.
(6)Ace High Hats. Plaintiff $9,000, defendant nil. Given the passage of time I will adopt the defendant's value of the Ace High Hats.
(7)Add back by Plaintiff for $250,000 and $50,000.
(8)Mortgage on River road. This was paid out by the Mulchay family trust on 17 January 2008.
29Given that the defendant does not give a credit for interest on her add back it is inappropriate to require the plaintiff to give a credit for interest on his add back.
30The plaintiff filed a detailed affidavit dated 2 September 2011 as a result of a direction made by the Court on 10 August 2011 to explain the situation with respect to bank accounts and use of funds. There has been no response or cross-examination on this material and the differences claimed by the defendant, to which I have referred, are not explained in her submissions.
|
[
-0.004074735566973686,
-0.021589970216155052,
-0.041196685284376144,
0.023686330765485764,
0.0035161771811544895,
-0.046443596482276917,
0.024045100435614586,
0.0334211066365242,
-0.014293846674263477,
-0.008815065957605839,
-0.005958283320069313,
0.03983721137046814,
-0.06266472488641739,
-0.010065932758152485,
0.011886954307556152,
-0.02186756581068039,
0.002966091735288501,
-0.013027429580688477,
-0.004204012919217348,
-0.03881377726793289,
0.008237217552959919,
-0.0014707371592521667,
0.03520453721284866,
0.03509778901934624,
0.03026280552148819,
0.042972318828105927,
-0.07768897712230682,
0.007596198935061693,
0.06068072095513344,
0.034952156245708466,
-0.04588514193892479,
0.01438915729522705,
0.02203998528420925,
-0.026556149125099182,
-0.035169024020433426,
-0.028227372094988823,
-0.00817360170185566,
0.01324427779763937,
-0.03243603929877281,
0.026056062430143356,
0.002790812635794282,
-0.013775816187262535,
-0.010601982474327087,
-0.0037284833379089832,
0.06713858991861343,
-0.008805249817669392,
-0.010560529306530952,
-0.019145341590046883,
-0.045019470155239105,
0.005892927758395672,
-0.02629624865949154,
-0.03397440165281296,
0.0693865567445755,
0.0024089564103633165,
0.0070441835559904575,
-0.013556662946939468,
-0.008786717429757118,
-0.008962685242295265,
-0.036788128316402435,
0.007776015438139439,
0.008351574651896954,
0.0016858825692906976,
-0.03969253972172737,
-0.007334345951676369,
0.010812690481543541,
0.11159421503543854,
-0.05738256871700287,
0.01164262369275093,
-0.010406970977783203,
-0.022353900596499443,
-0.006187731865793467,
-0.02905992977321148,
0.04096861928701401,
0.012442980892956257,
-0.07945054769515991,
0.014410587027668953,
0.05141608789563179,
0.008755702525377274,
0.008011192083358765,
-0.01684786193072796,
0.05130450055003166,
-0.03003564104437828,
0.02085883915424347,
0.04872952401638031,
-0.08679110556840897,
0.03846395015716553,
-0.013380168937146664,
0.04523080587387085,
-0.033669471740722656,
-0.003123081987723708,
-0.013333373703062534,
-0.00006727095751557499,
0.016398785635828972,
-0.04600220173597336,
0.01639462634921074,
0.04062490537762642,
-0.07254881411790848,
0.03488316386938095,
0.019080298021435738,
0.01033861469477415,
0.014903922565281391,
-0.0069699957966804504,
0.013568302616477013,
-0.03420465812087059,
-0.0005771219730377197,
-0.011763698421418667,
0.024013355374336243,
0.013446339406073093,
0.00525402557104826,
-0.027187412604689598,
0.0029246301855891943,
0.008287644945085049,
0.015586772933602333,
0.03248513862490654,
-0.0005875030183233321,
-0.0015226044924929738,
0.013799004256725311,
-0.013507571071386337,
0.04638431966304779,
0.018910175189375877,
0.053634241223335266,
0.015243543311953545,
0.04542500153183937,
-0.021862920373678207,
-0.01792086847126484,
0.00916915200650692,
-0.02227124758064747,
-0.003023276338353753,
-0.004623421002179384,
0.028583673760294914,
-0.0038355966098606586,
-0.03222503513097763,
-0.028211966156959534,
-0.031094199046492577,
-0.02814718335866928,
-0.044401902705430984,
0.06963260471820831,
0.008912603370845318,
0.026712890714406967,
-0.03674641624093056,
0.056604620069265366,
0.036362357437610626,
-0.019678805023431778,
-0.000609777111094445,
0.06165733560919762,
-0.026434659957885742,
0.00820990465581417,
-0.013546452857553959,
-0.012328648008406162,
-0.029726145789027214,
0.002514243358746171,
0.006807432975620031,
0.007362013682723045,
-0.01199977658689022,
0.026493949815630913,
-0.022653304040431976,
0.03768326714634895,
-0.014253431931138039,
-0.002054003067314625,
0.0343487411737442,
-0.006623816676437855,
-0.0004138521908316761,
-0.017587093636393547,
-0.07215128093957901,
-0.004159384872764349,
0.01703713648021221,
0.0005214939010329545,
0.02290286123752594,
0.00536100659519434,
-0.003831112990155816,
0.05259473994374275,
-0.01943351700901985,
0.035558320581912994,
-0.02874167077243328,
0.02550271525979042,
0.0042913975194096565,
0.045347075909376144,
-0.014429374597966671,
0.018302150070667267,
-0.03504006937146187,
-0.03206678479909897,
0.03239792585372925,
0.009262320585548878,
-0.021188359707593918,
-0.010566079057753086,
0.02894824743270874,
0.029753729701042175,
-0.04381827637553215,
0.032222189009189606,
0.00822748988866806,
-0.04352836310863495,
-0.01844298653304577,
0.019598957151174545,
-0.014946583658456802,
0.022306345403194427,
-0.032977886497974396,
-0.009667536243796349,
-0.04814794659614563,
0.03468776494264603,
-0.0312797874212265,
-0.02198067121207714,
0.008130421862006187,
0.026672042906284332,
0.03815841302275658,
-0.04232942685484886,
0.017026446759700775,
-0.05627678707242012,
0.014459137804806232,
0.00016444995708297938,
-0.053265850991010666,
0.003469885094091296,
0.03577307611703873,
0.03688701242208481,
0.042537935078144073,
0.05552294850349426,
-0.02678253874182701,
0.05619939789175987,
-0.02630816213786602,
0.028321359306573868,
-0.01078340969979763,
-0.07940302044153214,
0.01698072999715805,
-0.013242270797491074,
0.08988587558269501,
-0.017083704471588135,
0.029031075537204742,
-0.027776675298810005,
-0.003674879902973771,
0.043400995433330536,
-0.050512876361608505,
0.0005657599540427327,
0.01661911979317665,
0.06730788201093674,
-0.040178194642066956,
0.03745495527982712,
0.02284054458141327,
0.021854223683476448,
-0.005356706213206053,
-0.02606886252760887,
0.02303244359791279,
-0.04109703004360199,
0.015354030765593052,
-0.01633710041642189,
-0.015997616574168205,
0.0021754123736172915,
0.014845986850559711,
0.004628551192581654,
0.00033142627216875553,
0.02141089364886284,
-0.014127898029983044,
-0.024933671578764915,
-0.028441695496439934,
0.001461964682675898,
-0.0071547022089362144,
-0.007271484937518835,
0.03699003905057907,
0.023608673363924026,
-0.013762079179286957,
0.048029277473688126,
-0.02208983711898327,
0.018083913251757622,
0.03753075748682022,
0.032457392662763596,
0.013581999577581882,
-0.033400945365428925,
-0.007052615284919739,
-0.04882245883345604,
-0.009987701661884785,
0.0041539049707353115,
-0.008382297120988369,
0.025336969643831253,
0.005368940997868776,
-0.036530811339616776,
-0.034980352967977524,
0.04115239903330803,
0.029056571424007416,
0.025217629969120026,
-0.03860419988632202,
-0.002716920804232359,
-0.019625574350357056,
0.0377301461994648,
-0.010323787108063698,
-0.0011590220965445042,
-0.02592909149825573,
0.022288644686341286,
0.02915453165769577,
0.0011362663935869932,
-0.003272546688094735,
-0.00586030213162303,
-0.05074077099561691,
0.01322644017636776,
-0.01388836745172739,
0.06503088027238846,
0.001428037416189909,
-0.0677037239074707,
-0.025728490203619003,
-0.01206272467970848,
-0.15950757265090942,
0.0007702186121605337,
0.014140510000288486,
-0.0039724139496684074,
0.0056390585377812386,
0.0179227814078331,
-0.054067421704530716,
0.04322512820363045,
0.01576690934598446,
0.04359503090381622,
-0.023380989208817482,
-0.08340328931808472,
0.0013315841788426042,
0.03826851025223732,
-0.016030145809054375,
-0.020732345059514046,
0.019567428156733513,
-0.002874939702451229,
0.0015896880067884922,
-0.013120139949023724,
-0.03922509029507637,
-0.02127421833574772,
0.0202325526624918,
0.00005223642074270174,
-0.020604733377695084,
0.02793574146926403,
-0.003285540733486414,
-0.017713937908411026,
-0.0007845884538255632,
-0.03767869994044304,
-0.020573141053318977,
0.020136002451181412,
0.0013507154071703553,
0.017259372398257256,
-0.029326511546969414,
0.03179287165403366,
0.05299751088023186,
-0.0479528047144413,
-0.02940423972904682,
-0.04900084808468819,
0.02580132894217968,
0.009361096657812595,
-0.008794818073511124,
0.014670107513666153,
0.0053429682739079,
-0.018358686938881874,
-0.00960941705852747,
0.011473065242171288,
-0.0120779350399971,
0.04780413955450058,
-0.035847585648298264,
0.013998035341501236,
-0.023587634786963463,
-0.005015833303332329,
-0.017469128593802452,
-0.015628483146429062,
0.033455342054367065,
0.07481008768081665,
-0.0012374598300084472,
0.009308278560638428,
-0.0199436042457819,
-0.024912817403674126,
0.02141581103205681,
0.038559895008802414,
-0.02081027813255787,
-0.010753952898085117,
-0.013341235928237438,
-0.04972532391548157,
0.01165104005485773,
-0.042974937707185745,
0.01575002633035183,
-0.016591619700193405,
-0.010277990251779556,
-0.018914202228188515,
-0.035855356603860855,
0.030848179012537003,
0.02138439007103443,
-0.02318311296403408,
0.0034373572561889887,
-0.12585410475730896,
-0.0009544787462800741,
0.0313277542591095,
-0.018272116780281067,
0.047104477882385254,
-0.0043295337818562984,
-0.004923186730593443,
0.011387323960661888,
0.0033948770724236965,
0.017064113169908524,
0.2330886870622635,
-0.00023002453963272274,
0.03337603807449341,
0.043799325823783875,
-0.020977960899472237,
-0.026224203407764435,
0.03201577067375183,
0.03644753620028496,
0.025504833087325096,
-0.038601573556661606,
-0.020602194592356682,
0.07443533837795258,
0.024365533143281937,
-0.003726575057953596,
0.0053594522178173065,
0.024165738373994827,
-0.04080498218536377,
-0.036048464477062225,
0.06418316066265106,
-0.002607224974781275,
0.04774102196097374,
-0.038929276168346405,
-0.031584396958351135,
0.028757937252521515,
-0.05388328433036804,
-0.030909383669495583,
0.024716978892683983,
0.06662425398826599,
-0.027998624369502068,
0.0764097049832344,
-0.01638881117105484,
-0.0031952583231031895,
0.0000994538568193093,
0.014919716864824295,
0.024791762232780457,
-0.0070115248672664165,
0.0035313121043145657,
0.0034146015532314777,
-0.014270186424255371,
0.06189968064427376,
0.01011671219021082,
-0.048340171575546265,
-0.05226203054189682,
-0.004254271741956472,
0.006368751171976328,
-0.018878627568483353,
0.020964592695236206,
0.0351683534681797,
0.008869574405252934,
0.02788808010518551,
-0.020844584330916405,
0.014301212504506111,
-0.008105273358523846,
0.007331318687647581,
-0.04618144780397415,
-0.011415713466703892,
0.023524127900600433,
0.015082229860126972,
-0.02468184567987919,
0.01719520427286625,
-0.019829392433166504,
-0.00913931056857109,
-0.050963737070560455,
-0.011669095605611801,
-0.020654581487178802,
-0.048272036015987396,
-0.005155462771654129,
-0.03724098578095436,
0.030258584767580032,
-0.015226013958454132,
0.04288386180996895,
0.02813376486301422,
0.0035933833569288254,
0.03595246374607086,
0.06303548812866211,
0.02088288776576519,
-0.017350848764181137,
-0.0011179436696693301,
-0.01261490024626255,
-0.008070733398199081,
-0.045935191214084625,
-0.017890049144625664,
-0.03125574812293053,
0.028911860659718513,
0.009728075005114079,
-0.007240060716867447,
-0.020962687209248543,
0.026279671117663383,
0.01614026539027691,
-0.022964945062994957,
-0.05311862379312515,
-0.01386125199496746,
-0.004149445332586765,
0.010376512072980404,
0.007969982922077179,
0.009104500524699688,
0.0015593997668474913,
0.0351637527346611,
-0.019228389486670494,
-0.04301496967673302,
0.027910856530070305,
0.003954216372221708,
0.032413359731435776,
-0.04584698751568794,
0.03098827600479126,
0.027626343071460724,
0.004011979792267084,
-0.010991963557898998,
-0.07062148302793503,
-0.027798088267445564,
-0.019162617623806,
0.0074242521077394485,
0.004687327425926924,
-0.0012308284640312195,
0.054064471274614334,
0.01714484952390194,
0.05293472483754158,
0.04995777830481529,
0.009913940913975239,
0.032059576362371445,
0.016312040388584137,
-0.057783566415309906,
-0.04986051842570305,
-0.033172883093357086,
0.005250376183539629,
-0.05412616953253746,
-0.012703007087111473,
-0.00570512842386961,
-0.0020040003582835197,
0.028345052152872086,
-0.012081927619874477,
-0.03621997684240341,
-0.03943421691656113,
-0.013103260658681393,
-0.0009660130017437041,
0.043887101113796234,
0.0006645318353548646,
-0.00724657392129302,
-0.03235706314444542,
0.0020978099200874567,
-0.047217514365911484,
-0.024391066282987595,
-0.01390452217310667,
0.020438728854060173,
-0.008417664095759392,
0.0028835234697908163,
-0.02502138912677765,
0.015815895050764084,
-0.04334628954529762,
0.014741755090653896,
-0.011317222379148006,
0.03406666964292526,
-0.028936460614204407,
-0.07156487554311752,
-0.034410424530506134,
-0.037296123802661896,
0.02686113677918911,
-0.0023052669130265713,
0.027469944208860397,
-0.026828346773982048,
0.0040135313756763935,
-0.03144126385450363,
-0.012239169329404831,
0.030198505148291588,
0.018632492050528526,
0.06230730563402176,
-0.014785289764404297,
0.011508584953844547,
0.029554372653365135,
-0.007211189717054367,
0.00803691241890192,
-0.045939359813928604,
-0.007000435143709183,
0.012914903461933136,
0.05114777386188507,
0.006876878906041384,
0.019858071580529213,
0.02074028179049492,
0.02596295438706875,
-0.02716626226902008,
0.011395999230444431,
0.03301515802741051,
-0.015469473786652088,
-0.013489652425050735,
0.0172720979899168,
-0.020560428500175476,
-0.02923898585140705,
-0.023462515324354172,
0.02612851746380329,
-0.05717562511563301,
0.015019753947854042,
0.08115991204977036,
0.014420166611671448,
-0.023256486281752586,
0.0146289998665452,
0.003345201490446925,
-0.013026720844209194,
0.02216310240328312,
-0.0019722713623195887,
0.001787309069186449,
-0.018759900704026222,
0.01204041950404644,
0.03895935043692589,
0.02571321465075016,
0.03361141309142113,
-0.018132731318473816,
-0.007673284038901329,
0.009824673645198345,
-0.03336942195892334,
-0.06821118295192719,
0.0017792097060009837,
0.0049217017367482185,
0.02613440901041031,
0.01650061644613743,
0.031213093549013138,
-0.0022167374845594168,
0.04093034565448761,
0.016831491142511368,
-0.02647702768445015,
-0.0559253990650177,
-0.012439502403140068,
-0.02046341262757778,
0.02834848128259182,
-0.08331470191478729,
0.021300023421645164,
0.03754398971796036,
-0.028227556496858597,
0.009380827657878399,
-0.009190915152430534,
0.010922256857156754,
0.008637303486466408,
-0.00032047348213382065,
0.07735399156808853,
-0.010624927468597889,
0.003652984043583274,
-0.04195934534072876,
0.005200178828090429,
0.011252821423113346,
0.0012734701158478856,
-0.01587684638798237,
0.02712995931506157,
-0.007983810268342495,
0.03655083104968071,
0.03436700254678726,
0.024964312091469765,
-0.02123475819826126,
-0.009745157323777676,
-0.024917876347899437,
0.008240372873842716,
0.029078714549541473,
0.0015432945219799876,
-0.0068876431323587894,
-0.004040337633341551,
-0.014021718874573708,
-0.008330360986292362,
0.012709124013781548,
0.007894590497016907,
0.005566398147493601,
-0.04694861173629761,
-0.05883301794528961,
-0.007453299593180418,
0.0145283043384552,
-0.02335749752819538,
-0.002618957543745637,
-0.03166603296995163,
-0.06032499298453331,
0.023144634440541267,
-0.037829428911209106,
-0.011783723719418049,
-0.01704416610300541,
-0.010768032632768154,
-0.037165600806474686,
-0.009309284389019012,
-0.044974423944950104,
-0.011079303920269012,
-0.009004310704767704,
0.024851638823747635,
-0.0014351955614984035,
0.028432216495275497,
0.0220171008259058,
0.011322815902531147,
-0.028203869238495827,
0.03563617914915085,
0.017380615696310997,
-0.0645204558968544,
-0.005191293079406023,
0.04441751167178154,
0.004831906873732805,
0.0160105861723423,
-0.014091111719608307,
0.001106016687117517,
-0.01100901048630476,
-0.02372165583074093,
0.014886429533362389,
-0.03498269245028496,
0.006590159609913826,
0.00763884000480175,
-0.01854640431702137,
-0.021623095497488976,
-0.02414863184094429,
-0.019449317827820778,
-0.011242680251598358,
-0.0164853073656559,
-0.0673462525010109,
-0.03125973045825958,
-0.0038730097003281116,
0.010871551930904388,
-0.018037838861346245,
-0.040887027978897095,
-0.003109880955889821,
-0.0038614862132817507,
-0.04325258731842041,
0.008253989741206169,
-0.019883859902620316,
0.026083430275321007,
0.03044082410633564,
0.018591750413179398,
0.002098062541335821,
0.016056634485721588,
0.01336339209228754,
0.009843572042882442,
0.03686869889497757,
-0.05398474633693695,
-0.00960304494947195,
-0.018763327971100807,
0.03333577141165733,
-0.004970254376530647,
-0.01056712120771408,
-0.005419517867267132,
-0.011891902424395084,
-0.00009315388888353482,
-0.013318818062543869,
-0.03796125948429108,
-0.00817286316305399,
0.050643354654312134,
0.011762255802750587,
0.03296564891934395,
-0.012559621594846249,
0.011453818529844284,
-0.020123250782489777,
-0.0729488953948021,
-0.023015130311250687,
0.07022574543952942,
0.02205425128340721,
-0.018891654908657074,
-0.04401193931698799,
0.016569361090660095,
0.0100852744653821,
0.022051982581615448,
0.020373668521642685,
0.015670785680413246,
0.004982145968824625,
-0.033870674669742584,
-0.058242879807949066,
0.02584262378513813,
-0.01863601990044117,
-0.022086553275585175,
0.0008013643091544509,
0.01577427238225937,
0.006650225725024939,
-0.052597545087337494,
0.013492579571902752,
0.0525725856423378,
-0.008001450449228287,
0.00020442109962459654,
0.008688647300004959,
-0.005626597907394171,
0.02879587560892105,
-0.03513454645872116,
-0.012830354273319244,
0.021947674453258514,
-0.04612940177321434,
-0.023410433903336525,
0.007385557517409325,
-0.01624707132577896,
0.013102058321237564,
0.022883867844939232,
-0.016711687669157982,
-0.02029051072895527,
0.0013424737844616175,
-0.016817856580018997,
-0.031237561255693436,
-0.03337742015719414,
0.013462468050420284,
-0.01483885943889618,
0.014386530965566635,
0.008892984129488468,
0.003455543890595436,
0.03235149011015892,
0.04427189379930496,
-0.028765935450792313,
0.031143024563789368,
-0.02318902686238289,
0.014312190935015678,
-0.15452517569065094,
0.0384715273976326,
-0.005120863672345877,
-0.023420479148626328,
-0.029006613418459892,
0.015480718575417995,
-0.0045662191696465015,
0.01909242756664753,
-0.02947106957435608,
0.004052967764437199,
-0.03295411914587021,
0.005236566998064518,
0.03207961842417717,
-0.0015537255676463246,
-0.045783523470163345,
0.07113482803106308,
-0.0032754603307694197,
-0.07059857249259949,
-0.02170637995004654,
0.012415017001330853,
-0.0023135219234973192,
0.010965046472847462,
-0.006447228137403727,
-0.00858317781239748,
0.013673876412212849,
-0.017534054815769196,
-0.04686475545167923,
-0.006166177336126566,
-0.03222965821623802,
0.024620164185762405,
-0.030308624729514122,
-0.02500190958380699,
0.002282177796587348,
0.0378713384270668,
-0.008533935993909836,
0.046292100101709366,
0.006275046616792679,
-0.017682557925581932,
-0.008993824012577534,
-0.0028633717447519302,
-0.02690010890364647,
0.016033770516514778,
-0.04060661420226097,
-0.01648157835006714,
0.05182374641299248,
0.022109970450401306,
-0.033334698528051376,
0.015896856784820557,
-0.05694954842329025,
-0.02788594551384449,
-0.0028333463706076145,
0.01993078738451004,
0.0068271588534116745,
0.007400511298328638,
-0.005523038562387228,
0.006375775672495365,
-0.006029176991432905,
-0.015786098316311836,
-0.03458910435438156,
0.05021505802869797,
-0.024039508774876595,
0.011769434437155724,
-0.04828135669231415,
-0.026196414604783058,
0.02224660851061344,
0.01999174803495407,
-0.04034775495529175,
-0.029574960470199585,
0.034860603511333466,
-0.03207997605204582,
0.032693080604076385,
-0.008057716302573681,
0.06011579930782318,
-0.009766577742993832,
0.013425087556242943,
-0.012257078662514687,
0.014084875583648682,
0.0100071020424366,
-0.04076223447918892,
-0.002703683916479349,
-0.009873488917946815,
0.03324510529637337,
0.007920295000076294,
-0.060640331357717514,
0.037781570106744766,
0.0440128855407238,
-0.04209895431995392,
0.007669818587601185,
0.017959976568818092,
0.0076661366038024426,
-0.05071650445461273,
-0.014483683742582798,
0.009027848951518536,
-0.02556653320789337,
0.03486774489283562,
0.022072214633226395,
-0.0016279375413432717,
-0.00232754391618073,
-0.018684690818190575,
-0.005427954718470573,
-0.026668142527341843,
-0.022781016305088997,
0.018214194104075432,
0.012403061613440514,
-0.007829481735825539,
0.02795354463160038,
-0.03447757661342621,
-0.04964491352438927,
0.02526552602648735,
0.015425264835357666,
0.00528127234429121,
-0.008471430279314518,
-0.036283090710639954,
0.005325300619006157,
-0.05023694410920143,
0.004195925779640675,
0.03856784850358963,
0.00854456890374422,
-0.029193513095378876,
0.01777321845293045,
0.04977746307849884,
-0.004295843653380871,
0.04498763009905815,
-0.018187394365668297,
-0.0183599554002285,
0.005939609371125698,
0.060160938650369644,
0.010238352231681347,
0.047475580126047134,
0.017980942502617836,
-0.0024052683729678392,
-0.0033375860657542944,
0.0023346152156591415,
0.013307422399520874,
0.005266179796308279,
0.02791331522166729,
-0.0260185357183218,
0.057845935225486755,
-0.043872199952602386,
-0.02719571255147457,
0.02514508366584778,
0.03025142289698124,
-0.022035887464880943,
0.025701947510242462,
-0.07057065516710281,
-0.022241460159420967,
0.03204018622636795,
-0.010184190236032009,
-0.009128587320446968,
-0.028755510225892067,
-0.02439415454864502,
-0.00442607793956995,
-0.007372959516942501,
0.07060475647449493,
-0.0010627694427967072,
-0.018590232357382774,
0.04434828460216522,
-0.020598767325282097,
0.00463899364694953,
0.05304260924458504,
0.009227987378835678,
-0.04686592519283295,
-0.03321733698248863,
-0.027000872418284416,
-0.03822646290063858,
0.02997180074453354,
-0.02085036225616932,
0.024087654426693916,
-0.052459318190813065,
-0.011240535415709019,
-0.031148208305239677,
-0.036114539951086044,
-0.026554066687822342,
0.018271449953317642,
-0.004375551827251911,
0.023458776995539665,
0.002792761428281665,
0.01241002045571804,
0.032083820551633835,
-0.026068074628710747,
0.026503916829824448,
0.03167084604501724,
0.051674239337444305,
0.025564054027199745,
0.018438102677464485,
0.06974315643310547,
-0.004111049231141806,
0.026678839698433876,
-0.0002480039547663182,
-0.015125316567718983,
-0.040125250816345215,
-0.01603684388101101,
-0.03825513646006584,
-0.008356613107025623,
0.04734219238162041,
0.028401067480444908,
-0.0059392135590314865,
0.011229491792619228,
0.026953255757689476,
0.05328082665801048,
0.03766564652323723,
-0.008669940754771233,
-0.03672618046402931,
0.01875186339020729,
-0.008384829387068748,
-0.014105729758739471,
0.01819191873073578,
-0.008091100491583347,
-0.057820774614810944,
0.05758827179670334,
-0.02289390191435814,
-0.012606465257704258,
0.023664399981498718,
0.01619800180196762,
-0.010921978391706944,
0.038968998938798904,
-0.002311475109308958,
0.0014846347039565444,
-0.008441723883152008,
0.008181925863027573,
0.036644890904426575,
0.05061575770378113,
-0.015067139640450478,
-0.024486353620886803,
0.03385784849524498,
-0.00727285910397768,
0.01883952133357525,
-0.011121464893221855,
-0.024804148823022842,
-0.024273889139294624,
-0.04094194993376732,
-0.0011375009780749679,
-0.001226561376824975,
0.05470645800232887,
-0.029463613405823708,
-0.03602634742856026,
-0.0409252867102623,
0.018637757748365402,
-0.0006840831483714283,
0.015735415741801262,
-0.04025209695100784,
0.020634248852729797,
-0.023764317855238914,
0.015643421560525894
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:0
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd [2012] NSWSC 377
Hearing dates: 20, 21 and 22 March 2012
Decision date: 20 April 2012
Jurisdiction: Common Law
Before: Beech-Jones J
Decision: 1. Stand over the proceedings to 9 May 2012 at 9.30am before Beech-Jones J;
2. Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant confer as to the appropriate form of orders to reflect this judgment (including as to costs);
3. Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant to, on or before 4 May 2012, file and serve either an form of order that it is agreed reflects this judgment or, failing agreement, their own forms of order reflecting this judgment (including as to costs);
4. There be liberty to apply.
Catchwords: INSURANCE - double insurance - contribution - whether sufficient to only show reasonable compromise - whether common insured an "owner" of vehicle - whether "injury" established - whether compromise reasonable so as to entitle Plaintiff to contribution - recoupment.
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002
Evidence Act 1995
Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999
Workers Compensation Act 1987
Cases Cited: Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1969) 121 CLR 342
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v GSF Australia Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] HCA 26; (2005) 221 CLR 568
AJW & 2 Ors v State of New South Wales [2003] NSWSC 803
AMP Workers Compensation Services (NSW) Ltd v QBE Insurance Ltd [2001] NSWCA 267; (2001) 53 NSWLR 35
Distillers Co Bio Chemicals (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1
Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR (NSW) 88)
Enterprise Oil Ltd v Strand Insurance Co Ltd [2007] Lloyd's Rep IR 186
Friend v Brooker [2009] HCA 21; (2009) 239 CLR 129
Harmer v Hare [2011] NSWCA 229
Havas v Standard Knitting Mills Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 295; (2001) 52 NSWLR 293
Limit (No 3) Ltd v ACE Insurance Ltd [2009] NSWSC 514
Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co v Bovis Lend Lease Ltd [2005] Lloyd's Rep IR 74
McDonnell Information Systems Ltd v Swinbank & Ors [1999] Lloyd's Rep IR 98
Minister for Environmental Planning v San Sebastian [1983] 2 NSWLR 268
Nye v New South Wales & Ors [2002] NSWSC 1268; (2002) 134 A Crim R 245
Piening v Wanless [1968] HCA 7; (1968) 117 CLR 498
R v Rondo [2001] NSWCCA 540; (2001) 126 A Crim R 562
Thomas v State of New South Wales [2008] NSWCA 316; (2008) 74 NSWLR 34
Zotti v Australian Associated Motor Insurers Ltd [2009] NSWCA 323
Zurich Australia Insurance Ltd v CSR Ltd [2001] NSWCA 261; (2001) 52 NSWLR 193
Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v GIO General Ltd [2011] NSWCA 47
Texts Cited: Goff and Jones, The Law of Restitution (6th ed), Sweet & Maxwell
Category: Principal judgment
Parties: QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd (Plaintiff)
CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd (Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
Mr R A Cavanagh SC, Mr S E McCarthy (Plaintiff)
Mr S G Campbell SC, Mr P N Khandhar (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Curwoods Lawyers (Plaintiff)
TurksLegal (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2010/140098
Judgment
1The plaintiff, QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd ("QBE"), seeks contribution from the defendant, CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd ("CGU") alleging that they both insured Megbuy Pty Ltd ("Megbuy") in respect of the same loss (see Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office of New South Wales (1969) 121 CLR 342).
|
[
-0.03889351710677147,
0.016600508242845535,
-0.010679550468921661,
-0.017512502148747444,
-0.01527238730341196,
-0.04627692699432373,
0.010903645306825638,
-0.026310762390494347,
0.011071763001382351,
0.06156769394874573,
0.03511806204915047,
0.021555615589022636,
0.009294274263083935,
-0.0023845406249165535,
-0.0025640535168349743,
-0.014198411256074905,
-0.025696003809571266,
0.02689516916871071,
-0.058677274733781815,
-0.04017210751771927,
-0.016519319266080856,
-0.018826987594366074,
-0.003585637314245105,
0.035804588347673416,
0.048067815601825714,
0.01337805762887001,
-0.01793581433594227,
0.02220955491065979,
0.027853913605213165,
0.03794119507074356,
-0.025808818638324738,
-0.0015690422151237726,
0.006780677475035191,
0.0009498065337538719,
0.0013013718416914344,
-0.03205250948667526,
-0.042902108281850815,
0.02502206712961197,
-0.04507879912853241,
0.0018176494631916285,
-0.01037502009421587,
-0.025457780808210373,
0.03447863459587097,
-0.021724196150898933,
0.04964604601264,
-0.014034628868103027,
-0.014014668762683868,
-0.024806490167975426,
0.026240302249789238,
-0.023256661370396614,
-0.05468504875898361,
0.01533240731805563,
0.09002518653869629,
-0.03949778527021408,
0.008793294429779053,
0.008879203349351883,
-0.000012108520422771107,
-0.0350503996014595,
-0.07178930193185806,
-0.02571229077875614,
-0.023452773690223694,
0.012010897509753704,
-0.003358288435265422,
0.025252578780055046,
0.04265085607767105,
0.07456435263156891,
-0.018171511590480804,
-0.019133437424898148,
-0.005742101930081844,
-0.011708313599228859,
0.0014664609916508198,
0.0004989600274711847,
-0.0060486337170004845,
0.01632722280919552,
-0.07929498702287674,
-0.005341666284948587,
0.023113833740353584,
-0.011767648160457611,
0.023757973685860634,
-0.001285672653466463,
0.014896619133651257,
0.02482302486896515,
-0.04235429689288139,
0.009720390662550926,
-0.05378776043653488,
0.012506573460996151,
-0.0017849650466814637,
0.02034050039947033,
-0.028461622074246407,
-0.007444247603416443,
-0.017738059163093567,
-0.018068095669150352,
-0.005078556016087532,
-0.011982538737356663,
0.01755325123667717,
-0.04260493442416191,
-0.05009451508522034,
0.04528650641441345,
-0.007347773760557175,
0.03751237690448761,
-0.014513036236166954,
-0.00989606138318777,
0.03939848393201828,
-0.023468824103474617,
0.01791558414697647,
0.02655976638197899,
0.037658095359802246,
0.030262507498264313,
0.0011247503571212292,
-0.00045589471119455993,
-0.006620747037231922,
0.01927281729876995,
-0.0036420244723558426,
0.031727224588394165,
-0.010458877310156822,
-0.009025518782436848,
0.00597713328897953,
-0.013331670314073563,
-0.0005507270689122379,
-0.022989125922322273,
0.02876194939017296,
0.022189605981111526,
0.039750222116708755,
-0.015421814285218716,
-0.033127982169389725,
0.0027603053022176027,
0.05209367722272873,
0.005275968927890062,
0.004951878450810909,
-0.026369774714112282,
-0.0069285230711102486,
-0.004000045824795961,
-0.011329001747071743,
-0.05250125005841255,
-0.026035191491246223,
-0.04705200716853142,
0.08788136392831802,
-0.009164819493889809,
0.009046478196978569,
-0.03542754799127579,
0.025641797110438347,
0.006414314731955528,
-0.0059061250649392605,
-0.020948797464370728,
-0.0011127962497994304,
-0.02561544068157673,
0.04675048589706421,
-0.04267556220293045,
0.017705416306853294,
0.0008434833725914359,
0.028897825628519058,
0.012391830794513226,
0.0013464081566780806,
-0.05407783016562462,
0.08795648068189621,
-0.02577945776283741,
0.0034984068479388952,
-0.01363909337669611,
-0.017247024923563004,
-0.00849148165434599,
0.007105992175638676,
0.034938789904117584,
-0.03432915732264519,
-0.006530874874442816,
0.01607181504368782,
-0.002468001563102007,
0.031137684360146523,
0.033498022705316544,
-0.023310646414756775,
0.00855813268572092,
0.02261766605079174,
-0.011409642174839973,
-0.0004861634224653244,
-0.02868359349668026,
0.032175976783037186,
0.006614338606595993,
0.03860859572887421,
0.018047673627734184,
-0.04581021890044212,
-0.02721458487212658,
-0.023794550448656082,
0.027149200439453125,
-0.017510177567601204,
-0.010266421362757683,
-0.01743578538298607,
0.019390136003494263,
-0.04834010824561119,
-0.06308456510305405,
0.04131058230996132,
0.03905268386006355,
-0.0005412456230260432,
-0.0006804971490055323,
0.003243789542466402,
-0.025105049833655357,
0.007614011876285076,
-0.010688711889088154,
0.030580198392271996,
-0.02860960178077221,
0.04708500951528549,
-0.00851500779390335,
-0.05908256769180298,
0.01651930622756481,
0.03574475646018982,
-0.03486377373337746,
-0.04310207813978195,
-0.022043148055672646,
-0.016737060621380806,
0.059281546622514725,
-0.012625548988580704,
-0.02399240806698799,
-0.006221340503543615,
-0.002957628108561039,
0.020543836057186127,
0.04397490248084068,
-0.06185321882367134,
-0.015299378894269466,
0.019109651446342468,
-0.014616400003433228,
0.021788232028484344,
0.05728556215763092,
-0.04168768227100372,
0.0024387624580413103,
-0.011915141716599464,
0.008394738659262657,
0.06989339739084244,
-0.008273354731500149,
-0.01724015548825264,
0.034065354615449905,
0.058249279856681824,
-0.01958828791975975,
0.00016236017108894885,
0.013684555888175964,
0.030089447274804115,
-0.037094324827194214,
0.03321462497115135,
0.00411628233268857,
0.011491515673696995,
0.03191213682293892,
0.008023430593311787,
0.023533644154667854,
-0.0409034825861454,
-0.051936227828264236,
0.030750056728720665,
-0.03256512060761452,
-0.0430334247648716,
-0.019883211702108383,
0.012852289713919163,
-0.018367113545536995,
0.022969700396060944,
-0.005712615791708231,
0.00698496401309967,
-0.0022115055471658707,
-0.04381946846842766,
0.010461541824042797,
-0.026678690686821938,
0.024106644093990326,
0.016861850395798683,
-0.01839229092001915,
0.03601918742060661,
-0.011319207958877087,
0.016051413491368294,
0.0068711102940142155,
0.05254233255982399,
0.00870362389832735,
-0.02284948341548443,
-0.021907858550548553,
-0.023378217592835426,
-0.010919580236077309,
-0.0405832901597023,
-0.03251544386148453,
0.003776857163757086,
0.007333847694098949,
0.004084233194589615,
-0.027990302070975304,
-0.004087704699486494,
0.04649088531732559,
0.009163258597254753,
-0.03358674794435501,
0.008673157542943954,
-0.0008991268696263433,
0.05082619935274124,
0.029699474573135376,
-0.026150599122047424,
-0.04281771555542946,
0.011065594851970673,
-0.025319693610072136,
0.01716548390686512,
-0.0708698257803917,
-0.026862572878599167,
-0.06213183328509331,
0.019198734313249588,
-0.030587444081902504,
0.06857111304998398,
-0.005870242603123188,
-0.010582677088677883,
0.04505970701575279,
-0.004681755788624287,
-0.16722780466079712,
-0.0016477516619488597,
0.027063168585300446,
-0.018814682960510254,
-0.0024855881929397583,
0.029527384787797928,
-0.061169859021902084,
-0.02156863361597061,
-0.0018792254850268364,
0.002723224461078644,
0.021986618638038635,
-0.06707795709371567,
-0.03306609019637108,
0.041704438626766205,
0.014140058308839798,
-0.03366111218929291,
-0.017576657235622406,
0.011005222797393799,
0.058537550270557404,
-0.0276651494204998,
-0.03334249183535576,
-0.014589173719286919,
-0.014014272950589657,
-0.010251391679048538,
0.022134117782115936,
-0.054045215249061584,
0.004345146473497152,
0.004611995071172714,
-0.027852080762386322,
-0.012507807463407516,
-0.04222884774208069,
-0.008634784258902073,
-0.001913333428092301,
0.02323492057621479,
0.02464056760072708,
0.01192119438201189,
0.03450944274663925,
-0.0881347730755806,
0.008948550559580326,
-0.00990990363061428,
0.014108032919466496,
0.08094248175621033,
-0.024244947358965874,
0.013724160380661488,
-0.009714344516396523,
-0.047795508056879044,
0.016878994181752205,
-0.003356341505423188,
-0.03694115951657295,
0.04078897088766098,
-0.01842663437128067,
-0.036032721400260925,
-0.017807429656386375,
0.009902724996209145,
-0.021991677582263947,
-0.016921360045671463,
0.029330650344491005,
0.0872097834944725,
-0.001953442580997944,
-0.0036597212310880423,
-0.0567244291305542,
-0.008575514890253544,
-0.0034863229375332594,
-0.008143977262079716,
-0.0658474937081337,
0.007235735189169645,
0.013129057362675667,
-0.04325338825583458,
0.07322949916124344,
0.0019842078909277916,
0.0020487012807279825,
-0.00035107159055769444,
0.020060256123542786,
-0.018795689567923546,
0.008549503050744534,
0.004419176373630762,
0.0019067024113610387,
-0.02629590593278408,
0.007563948165625334,
-0.08099153637886047,
0.026880817487835884,
0.04296652227640152,
0.0050781359896063805,
0.04261116310954094,
0.0050728898495435715,
0.012573684565722942,
-0.025472383946180344,
0.0069267041981220245,
0.009137089364230633,
0.21358992159366608,
0.05519625544548035,
-0.02594755031168461,
0.0005730059347115457,
0.03200346231460571,
-0.03424572944641113,
0.027133408933877945,
0.041996125131845474,
0.03364185988903046,
-0.024194292724132538,
-0.06884507834911346,
-0.011286277323961258,
0.022465674206614494,
0.0034306710585951805,
-0.01427621953189373,
-0.014282355085015297,
-0.0228889063000679,
-0.005518404766917229,
0.09931951761245728,
-0.009885256178677082,
0.03077751398086548,
-0.0348808728158474,
-0.020075984299182892,
0.0343368761241436,
-0.04189044609665871,
-0.008699577301740646,
-0.0016287473263218999,
0.023998020216822624,
-0.03289981558918953,
0.050577662885189056,
-0.03706057742238045,
-0.0029708221554756165,
0.006915138103067875,
0.0031833092216402292,
-0.030252685770392418,
-0.03170696645975113,
-0.021293161436915398,
0.008894889615476131,
0.016224674880504608,
0.04655696079134941,
0.0021090807858854532,
-0.029763538390398026,
0.04073202237486839,
0.021099677309393883,
0.0527435727417469,
-0.010088657028973103,
0.00931730680167675,
0.000657710013911128,
-0.0249127559363842,
0.03252091258764267,
-0.056899543851614,
-0.007867643609642982,
-0.047596387565135956,
0.01405857689678669,
-0.014173546805977821,
-0.015595141798257828,
0.009766253642737865,
-0.02982213906943798,
-0.023400025442242622,
0.005680951755493879,
0.006172040477395058,
0.004172972869127989,
-0.07044744491577148,
0.008461249060928822,
0.01178502757102251,
0.0019311921205371618,
-0.03421008214354515,
0.005303551442921162,
0.05640691518783569,
0.02015550248324871,
0.035632867366075516,
0.07337400317192078,
0.010899988003075123,
0.023156968876719475,
0.027236927300691605,
0.04291339963674545,
0.016250647604465485,
0.04393695294857025,
-0.03827416151762009,
-0.01422947645187378,
-0.009796327911317348,
0.03443736582994461,
-0.0003917549620382488,
-0.018520524725317955,
-0.003528923261910677,
-0.01766657643020153,
-0.028770828619599342,
0.0105458814650774,
0.06738492846488953,
0.00014518816897179931,
-0.03979804366827011,
-0.058330219238996506,
-0.02158845216035843,
0.022408468648791313,
-0.016306282952427864,
0.019364114850759506,
0.05294563248753548,
0.014961312524974346,
-0.02151610143482685,
-0.0216669924557209,
-0.0023083770647644997,
0.00453529879450798,
0.01868552155792713,
-0.03350061923265457,
-0.0005039971438236535,
0.001849104999564588,
-0.004548062104731798,
-0.02862492762506008,
-0.04757554456591606,
-0.00992056354880333,
-0.0037709821481257677,
0.01752370223402977,
-0.011692683212459087,
0.028516458347439766,
-0.010355842299759388,
0.028029585257172585,
-0.006984540726989508,
0.0319964699447155,
0.03669873625040054,
-0.005583283491432667,
-0.01968228816986084,
0.021314939484000206,
-0.013889051973819733,
0.0042001898400485516,
0.0004498455673456192,
-0.0001628072641324252,
-0.03803137689828873,
-0.02971833012998104,
-0.004289747681468725,
0.039272740483284,
-0.0254350733011961,
-0.011920228600502014,
-0.024647165089845657,
-0.02643384411931038,
0.020248735323548317,
0.0011703253258019686,
0.03111211396753788,
0.07633396238088608,
0.011162984184920788,
-0.012080715969204903,
-0.010239741764962673,
-0.008953159675002098,
-0.015042908489704132,
-0.04058355093002319,
0.007201060187071562,
-0.03756534680724144,
0.04566412419080734,
0.00729288998991251,
-0.08403502404689789,
0.0068993340246379375,
-0.019361082464456558,
0.040364231914281845,
-0.01631930284202099,
-0.02745121531188488,
-0.03264239802956581,
0.01688476651906967,
0.02281997539103031,
0.0035044837277382612,
0.02601400576531887,
-0.03540734574198723,
0.0103457598015666,
-0.014623821713030338,
0.0241028293967247,
0.08044708520174026,
0.021028099581599236,
0.037581272423267365,
-0.020846759900450706,
0.05648191273212433,
0.04152006283402443,
-0.002682264195755124,
-0.014403884299099445,
-0.006167457904666662,
-0.03135194629430771,
0.0466829352080822,
0.07489281892776489,
0.022816834971308708,
0.006868540309369564,
0.008529594168066978,
0.006376033183187246,
-0.06601401418447495,
0.01270372699946165,
0.022694608196616173,
-0.014357272535562515,
0.013683098368346691,
-0.006580197252333164,
-0.0002736054011620581,
0.025847120210528374,
-0.027224121615290642,
0.041691653430461884,
0.012125777080655098,
-0.0031642711255699396,
0.08757811784744263,
0.01563173532485962,
-0.01581563986837864,
0.029004130512475967,
0.019812477752566338,
0.006766661535948515,
0.013983113691210747,
0.018551938235759735,
-0.036686837673187256,
-0.02649402618408203,
0.029920555651187897,
0.02725379914045334,
-0.025845764204859734,
0.054088376462459564,
-0.0051570157520473,
0.01420100498944521,
0.003911765292286873,
-0.05726940929889679,
0.009778880514204502,
0.023783555254340172,
-0.029187509790062904,
-0.003463092725723982,
0.026543304324150085,
0.00284165539778769,
0.020065877586603165,
-0.010008146986365318,
0.05261947959661484,
0.005639153532683849,
-0.0520520843565464,
-0.024633711203932762,
-0.010641827248036861,
0.07106703519821167,
-0.07760164141654968,
0.008100572973489761,
0.03466999530792236,
0.0025699937250465155,
-0.014975128695368767,
0.04598791152238846,
-0.013855177909135818,
0.007420785259455442,
-0.027766793966293335,
-0.004533036146312952,
-0.010069605894386768,
-0.02694825641810894,
0.05322157219052315,
0.047285035252571106,
0.01935003511607647,
0.024526549503207207,
-0.019127273932099342,
0.0045352536253631115,
0.03447001799941063,
0.0012897729175165296,
0.047740764915943146,
0.000834032311104238,
0.008936579339206219,
-0.04226582497358322,
0.011904621496796608,
0.04951389133930206,
0.03159613907337189,
0.007518184836953878,
0.010914799757301807,
0.026166528463363647,
-0.047800321131944656,
-0.005462076049298048,
-0.00493058143183589,
0.003070797538384795,
0.020811159163713455,
-0.03591204807162285,
-0.03098095767199993,
-0.011543123982846737,
0.005885730963200331,
0.0031236009672284126,
-0.047526512295007706,
0.007608381099998951,
-0.07372599095106125,
0.04483605548739433,
0.0052172220312058926,
-0.015489880926907063,
-0.0034846963826566935,
0.006273083388805389,
-0.010082615539431572,
-0.05250278115272522,
-0.05447389557957649,
-0.02508411556482315,
0.026307206600904465,
-0.006684250198304653,
0.03141190856695175,
0.058838777244091034,
-0.002673310460522771,
0.0450594387948513,
-0.02766340784728527,
0.0022511794231832027,
0.04429028555750847,
-0.02372412197291851,
0.027516111731529236,
0.04148603975772858,
0.005540203303098679,
-0.0020050769671797752,
0.0003126415249425918,
0.002386236796155572,
-0.021904077380895615,
-0.02392352931201458,
0.03720072656869888,
0.011721073649823666,
-0.021831141784787178,
0.010706647299230099,
0.025553906336426735,
-0.017203565686941147,
-0.01010473445057869,
-0.018010945990681648,
0.024839527904987335,
-0.018784942105412483,
-0.04312622919678688,
-0.01255660317838192,
0.025172296911478043,
0.02280818670988083,
-0.024255800992250443,
0.01533828116953373,
-0.002640426391735673,
-0.028663381934165955,
-0.04376663267612457,
-0.009530466981232166,
-0.026943622156977654,
-0.010457721538841724,
0.012365848757326603,
-0.008741130121052265,
-0.018976468592882156,
-0.0059775738045573235,
0.002981283236294985,
0.03731905296444893,
-0.019832078367471695,
-0.0418376550078392,
0.007323310244828463,
-0.023951930925250053,
0.01608935557305813,
0.002851780503988266,
-0.008847566321492195,
-0.025175731629133224,
0.009341659024357796,
-0.03023286536335945,
-0.03540875390172005,
-0.011755697429180145,
-0.0015390070620924234,
0.03610113263130188,
0.003427432617172599,
-0.0007212201016955078,
-0.025749007239937782,
0.01869901269674301,
-0.027647018432617188,
-0.029303137212991714,
-0.03733282536268234,
0.07840216159820557,
-0.005046619102358818,
0.0017889236332848668,
-0.006043769419193268,
0.01825040392577648,
0.02600928395986557,
-0.0022055944427847862,
0.013655651360750198,
0.0024895158130675554,
0.006431123707443476,
-0.017471550032496452,
-0.042366791516542435,
0.04258918762207031,
0.024945436045527458,
-0.03499534726142883,
0.01149564329534769,
-0.0011197262210771441,
-0.006647088564932346,
-0.05161011964082718,
-0.008870990946888924,
-0.051089152693748474,
-0.007419012486934662,
0.04633692279458046,
0.015409141778945923,
0.0014863968826830387,
0.008138231933116913,
-0.004027382470667362,
-0.02171829156577587,
0.011978646740317345,
0.04350991174578667,
0.0178321972489357,
0.012580806389451027,
-0.003472968703135848,
-0.0003792403731495142,
0.02041591703891754,
0.0109095498919487,
-0.04013029485940933,
-0.02389601059257984,
-0.00156593625433743,
-0.010867868550121784,
-0.05349944159388542,
0.0027685542590916157,
0.037365466356277466,
0.0010369064984843135,
-0.041320934891700745,
0.01994406245648861,
0.000010623089110595174,
0.05507364124059677,
-0.037198178470134735,
0.0448683463037014,
-0.04275310039520264,
0.006667002569884062,
-0.13701264560222626,
-0.003276196541264653,
0.0049902633763849735,
0.010643702931702137,
-0.06889135390520096,
0.0058283996768295765,
-0.028276827186346054,
0.043079935014247894,
-0.014784048311412334,
-0.03907313197851181,
-0.048261914402246475,
-0.045734889805316925,
0.0634598508477211,
-0.007976209744811058,
0.005018537864089012,
-0.01971728354692459,
-0.0010045381495729089,
-0.039446305483579636,
-0.022778354585170746,
0.06489735096693039,
0.012841149233281612,
0.024874702095985413,
0.0037998391781002283,
-0.0028050111141055822,
-0.018450038507580757,
-0.040157005190849304,
-0.017972690984606743,
-0.00774485245347023,
-0.040073588490486145,
0.004271497949957848,
0.00005635711568174884,
-0.024958448484539986,
0.023821361362934113,
0.044074103236198425,
-0.016162149608135223,
0.05356243625283241,
0.0139906145632267,
0.003712000558152795,
-0.044211093336343765,
-0.027586111798882484,
0.0037880504969507456,
0.015754736959934235,
-0.015420790761709213,
-0.015842394903302193,
0.029248148202896118,
0.009232711978256702,
-0.03248152881860733,
0.005741373635828495,
0.0031772684305906296,
-0.03478740155696869,
0.0008748885011300445,
0.015716632828116417,
-0.0033289322163909674,
-0.01968330331146717,
-0.005051354877650738,
-0.006775755900889635,
0.013892027549445629,
-0.00835364032536745,
0.01806870475411415,
0.0585547499358654,
-0.02610604092478752,
-0.006368124857544899,
-0.022656481713056564,
-0.05446651950478554,
0.01598210074007511,
0.01147451065480709,
-0.009769164025783539,
-0.010787778533995152,
0.01312027033418417,
0.04223658889532089,
-0.01293532270938158,
-0.029345232993364334,
0.005797759164124727,
-0.03060074709355831,
0.0017563431756570935,
-0.016418367624282837,
-0.003678416134789586,
-0.00033467262983322144,
-0.017579523846507072,
0.01833147555589676,
0.0005010035238228738,
0.013077588751912117,
-0.008981104008853436,
0.014167716726660728,
0.03626193851232529,
-0.0062841749750077724,
-0.005769010633230209,
-0.027326593175530434,
0.05469803139567375,
-0.014684547670185566,
-0.06116964668035507,
-0.01912395842373371,
-0.06733597069978714,
0.06304001808166504,
-0.016830729320645332,
0.02210061252117157,
0.006341953296214342,
-0.017037589102983475,
-0.03386275842785835,
-0.06871097534894943,
-0.029874036088585854,
-0.030029315501451492,
-0.02378440462052822,
-0.042075227946043015,
0.005912463180720806,
0.013695310801267624,
0.0033740790095180273,
-0.03423712030053139,
0.014101304113864899,
-0.014459449797868729,
0.02154974825680256,
-0.020334461703896523,
-0.03552732616662979,
0.01206024270504713,
-0.052480317652225494,
0.040101464837789536,
-0.013730727136135101,
0.022779472172260284,
-0.014216062612831593,
0.011869261972606182,
-0.009350302629172802,
-0.02540307492017746,
-0.004895951598882675,
-0.011478425934910774,
0.037412069737911224,
0.009043444879353046,
0.04632018133997917,
-0.0185222327709198,
0.007616890594363213,
-0.01307586207985878,
0.0008904398418962955,
0.022120434790849686,
0.0073154037818312645,
-0.014826757833361626,
0.015010757371783257,
0.015525838360190392,
-0.03693755343556404,
0.008393949829041958,
-0.02894057147204876,
-0.049737267196178436,
0.03667181357741356,
0.001680591725744307,
-0.0340639166533947,
-0.006655517965555191,
-0.017584698274731636,
-0.06005154177546501,
0.02030530944466591,
-0.03246794641017914,
0.00047680240822955966,
-0.041789621114730835,
-0.009862100705504417,
0.008925620466470718,
-0.017900243401527405,
0.08927232772111893,
0.03721444681286812,
-0.024886982515454292,
0.02775821089744568,
-0.006484516430646181,
-0.004812618717551231,
0.047788508236408234,
0.022807732224464417,
-0.0030861194245517254,
-0.014917158521711826,
-0.029084108769893646,
-0.03923377767205238,
0.05511006712913513,
-0.00690152682363987,
0.00963534601032734,
-0.02707551419734955,
0.026636997237801552,
-0.017716001719236374,
0.01479009073227644,
-0.027315059676766396,
-0.012103005312383175,
0.021060282364487648,
0.02630617469549179,
-0.027217473834753036,
-0.01787174493074417,
0.04749251529574394,
-0.0071858856827020645,
0.029574792832136154,
0.06228221207857132,
0.00926569290459156,
0.04222662001848221,
-0.010228612460196018,
0.021891478449106216,
0.005808625835925341,
-0.028857532888650894,
0.00339980935677886,
-0.053363312035799026,
0.02546309493482113,
0.013432386331260204,
-0.006638798862695694,
-0.0330321229994297,
0.07508745044469833,
0.023514680564403534,
-0.010682432912290096,
0.01569194532930851,
0.034439217299222946,
0.03396992385387421,
-0.003989644348621368,
-0.011987532489001751,
-0.024816587567329407,
-0.023479381576180458,
-0.05924692004919052,
-0.0467035137116909,
0.004429812077432871,
-0.019029760733246803,
-0.025523360818624496,
0.0524502769112587,
0.0003628574777394533,
-0.012599391862750053,
-0.0221491027623415,
0.048899561166763306,
-0.0463084802031517,
0.02393517643213272,
-0.03455965593457222,
-0.019345326349139214,
0.04934103786945343,
-0.03889746218919754,
0.06685323268175125,
0.05171971768140793,
-0.02826394885778427,
-0.03119286336004734,
0.045411184430122375,
0.0022707264870405197,
-0.01680242456495762,
-0.028801769018173218,
0.030272850766777992,
-0.0301019586622715,
0.018682563677430153,
-0.006592953111976385,
-0.002289970638230443,
0.029504476115107536,
0.002066256944090128,
-0.0371294766664505,
-0.035194508731365204,
-0.03170013427734375,
-0.02033933624625206,
-0.012974652461707592,
0.015427082777023315,
0.013160813599824905,
0.03427235409617424,
-0.025410274043679237
] |
What is the basis for QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd's claim for contribution from CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd?
|
[
-0.044456757605075836,
0.002508128760382533,
-0.012594552710652351,
-0.03283628076314926,
0.010284585878252983,
-0.02173209749162197,
0.0357731357216835,
-0.006148258689790964,
0.011291425675153732,
0.024967141449451447,
0.04704714193940163,
-0.004008579067885876,
0.015302062034606934,
-0.0037017399445176125,
0.030234605073928833,
-0.004890785086899996,
0.0059013632126152515,
-0.019635286182165146,
-0.08467815071344376,
-0.06438519805669785,
0.023418966680765152,
-0.013521770015358925,
0.0013710658531636,
0.05357394367456436,
0.042968299239873886,
0.012482943013310432,
-0.008818183094263077,
0.002787234028801322,
-0.003980576526373625,
-0.014029466547071934,
-0.035244688391685486,
-0.0018816861556842923,
-0.024370141327381134,
-0.0035314210690557957,
-0.012414021417498589,
-0.03429684415459633,
-0.015866663306951523,
0.00905709620565176,
-0.05567562207579613,
-0.025525763630867004,
-0.01513287890702486,
-0.035495657473802567,
0.06098264828324318,
-0.0009241433581337333,
0.05491289868950844,
-0.020622113719582558,
-0.029831301420927048,
-0.012038873508572578,
-0.02737465128302574,
-0.0014880417147651315,
-0.015536502003669739,
-0.0014323457144200802,
0.03972291946411133,
-0.03127271309494972,
0.030169140547513962,
0.010581850074231625,
-0.013422810472548008,
-0.03970451280474663,
-0.05370378866791725,
-0.03246745839715004,
-0.01842644438147545,
-0.0033114647958427668,
0.008144783787429333,
0.02213439904153347,
0.03522093966603279,
0.04095242917537689,
0.0060195233672857285,
-0.01661602407693863,
-0.0073606339283287525,
0.005208331625908613,
0.0000884366818354465,
0.008795502595603466,
-0.011906650848686695,
-0.016739681363105774,
-0.06889045983552933,
-0.005118145141750574,
0.004635247867554426,
-0.024137264117598534,
0.016675233840942383,
0.02546251006424427,
0.008118187077343464,
0.05339385196566582,
-0.02986636757850647,
0.012742020189762115,
-0.04963087663054466,
-0.007272104267030954,
0.0299149751663208,
-0.01758425682783127,
-0.026716921478509903,
-0.03137550503015518,
-0.03295272961258888,
-0.024268751963973045,
0.03394562751054764,
-0.028292490169405937,
-0.026903096586465836,
-0.03298405557870865,
-0.04036717489361763,
0.06410201638936996,
0.01618289202451706,
0.026756154373288155,
0.016882406547665596,
0.02832278609275818,
0.0607357919216156,
-0.04184350371360779,
0.01314359437674284,
-0.029534585773944855,
0.040346913039684296,
0.021072354167699814,
-0.024812009185552597,
0.01079716719686985,
-0.01647636480629444,
0.028888078406453133,
0.009383577853441238,
0.029267199337482452,
-0.00947551615536213,
0.01743035390973091,
-0.023253021761775017,
-0.009766080416738987,
-0.02524590864777565,
-0.013468710705637932,
0.04372792690992355,
-0.04052877053618431,
0.011374091729521751,
-0.010495990514755249,
0.013039120472967625,
-0.043911587446928024,
0.05439388379454613,
-0.016681628301739693,
0.005396121181547642,
-0.027072321623563766,
-0.022180330008268356,
0.016123084351420403,
0.0028486140072345734,
-0.05324125289916992,
-0.0459291934967041,
-0.03072301857173443,
0.07206058502197266,
0.0021559172309935093,
-0.002540485467761755,
-0.021779727190732956,
-0.0009340684046037495,
0.006688104476779699,
0.022789979353547096,
-0.01702817529439926,
-0.022544771432876587,
-0.003622171003371477,
0.02770921401679516,
-0.033000532537698746,
0.012326770462095737,
0.0352347157895565,
0.004688049200922251,
-0.00940227322280407,
-0.06480832397937775,
-0.03305424377322197,
0.04493838548660278,
-0.01727774366736412,
0.014504965394735336,
-0.02529420517385006,
-0.005734392441809177,
0.0007845853106118739,
0.018414365127682686,
0.014170526526868343,
-0.017902705818414688,
-0.020167414098978043,
0.0258864164352417,
0.05326859652996063,
0.032378070056438446,
0.032128315418958664,
-0.03367917239665985,
0.0430091992020607,
-0.0024611612316221,
0.008585424162447453,
-0.005428841803222895,
-0.012608828023076057,
0.06089234724640846,
0.0179330762475729,
0.039816856384277344,
0.021081916987895966,
-0.004439855460077524,
-0.026290200650691986,
0.006427492946386337,
-0.0026272202376276255,
0.004136721137911081,
-0.0654398500919342,
0.02295081876218319,
0.015569809824228287,
0.009001840837299824,
-0.04649796709418297,
0.050758395344018936,
0.02622821368277073,
0.002951662288978696,
0.014297740533947945,
-0.001289837877266109,
-0.026293562725186348,
0.010185752995312214,
-0.025722507387399673,
0.027251655235886574,
-0.012617457658052444,
0.01680695451796055,
-0.013477765955030918,
-0.09241187572479248,
0.015876291319727898,
0.010507648810744286,
0.0055221752263605595,
-0.03562982380390167,
-0.008835035376250744,
-0.03548965975642204,
0.07902596145868301,
0.010880663059651852,
-0.013425121083855629,
0.00852995179593563,
-0.024803008884191513,
0.035305194556713104,
0.04536827653646469,
-0.03301796689629555,
-0.025540504604578018,
-0.021031904965639114,
0.0077583277598023415,
0.028019895777106285,
0.0308774933218956,
-0.01764959655702114,
0.0032516212668269873,
-0.008655689656734467,
0.02544877864420414,
0.104428231716156,
-0.013660918921232224,
0.006652947049587965,
0.028532233089208603,
0.03667476400732994,
-0.029747338965535164,
0.013324414379894733,
-0.01685984805226326,
-0.03392348065972328,
-0.06093381717801094,
0.015334534458816051,
0.06443245708942413,
0.015147279016673565,
0.013668756000697613,
0.022656815126538277,
0.014154708944261074,
-0.009670816361904144,
-0.03415239602327347,
0.010363456793129444,
0.003196470206603408,
-0.03543661907315254,
-0.001104162074625492,
0.022311463952064514,
0.043233297765254974,
0.01917831227183342,
-0.002586592687293887,
0.01783576048910618,
-0.007012603804469109,
-0.06316209584474564,
-0.051282014697790146,
-0.001666617812588811,
0.030326958745718002,
0.018011508509516716,
-0.0170834269374609,
0.05771777778863907,
-0.010855574160814285,
0.0010869271354749799,
0.001363048329949379,
0.036471519619226456,
-0.01187837589532137,
0.0319804847240448,
0.008112535811960697,
-0.03382716327905655,
0.0025791556108742952,
-0.02260342426598072,
0.01230814028531313,
-0.024306410923600197,
0.024735117331147194,
-0.022684793919324875,
0.02328282594680786,
-0.0015045476611703634,
0.03654007241129875,
-0.03367873653769493,
-0.03852147236466408,
-0.016208892688155174,
-0.004181449301540852,
0.04390271008014679,
0.057001832872629166,
-0.05325595661997795,
0.013038004748523235,
0.0023745207581669092,
-0.060051482170820236,
0.02115052565932274,
-0.047376517206430435,
-0.038490455597639084,
-0.06863878667354584,
0.022888969630002975,
-0.038140758872032166,
0.06338586658239365,
-0.04421400651335716,
-0.021437304094433784,
0.02335403673350811,
-0.018026819452643394,
-0.12032219022512436,
-0.03439752757549286,
0.01310200896114111,
0.011145224794745445,
-0.0038045006804168224,
0.015252118930220604,
-0.031514257192611694,
-0.0392010360956192,
0.004200149793177843,
-0.05844050645828247,
-0.003115916159003973,
-0.07698921859264374,
-0.04217846691608429,
0.05070161074399948,
-0.010378047823905945,
-0.029165616258978844,
-0.014477640390396118,
-0.02213272452354431,
0.03807700052857399,
-0.0047806622460484505,
-0.05126359313726425,
-0.000505105999764055,
-0.022464079782366753,
0.03405317664146423,
0.0018388800090178847,
-0.023146938532590866,
0.029236800968647003,
-0.016727406531572342,
0.007554831448942423,
-0.0015588677488267422,
-0.03353159502148628,
-0.049632757902145386,
0.0075379060581326485,
0.029929576441645622,
0.018492110073566437,
0.00645223306491971,
0.0031238319352269173,
-0.050426896661520004,
0.007842064835131168,
0.03159775212407112,
-0.003944915719330311,
0.06884074211120605,
0.022279011085629463,
0.016530688852071762,
0.01881410926580429,
-0.025623636320233345,
0.037433724850416183,
-0.009768141433596611,
-0.055199217051267624,
0.00549687584862113,
0.00456983270123601,
0.007835379801690578,
-0.010511143133044243,
-0.0034495966974645853,
-0.02993732877075672,
-0.020769521594047546,
0.004623699933290482,
0.06363702565431595,
-0.014835427515208721,
-0.008170057088136673,
-0.01846315711736679,
-0.0009309580200351775,
-0.011920349672436714,
0.03246517479419708,
-0.017368197441101074,
0.013592444360256195,
-0.00003628508420661092,
-0.004383400082588196,
0.021752234548330307,
-0.0052228146232664585,
-0.014447662979364395,
0.023655425757169724,
-0.007154593709856272,
-0.029993796721100807,
-0.031517937779426575,
0.012393854558467865,
-0.005957682151347399,
0.0011950446059927344,
0.0008113398216664791,
-0.07978858798742294,
0.032197512686252594,
0.025370711460709572,
0.07670191675424576,
0.01831701211631298,
0.0012548179365694523,
0.02298789657652378,
-0.0005123173468746245,
0.02067417837679386,
0.03359808400273323,
0.17725248634815216,
0.0202490147203207,
-0.01528810616582632,
-0.007084245327860117,
0.02866489626467228,
-0.03579983487725258,
-0.003753029042854905,
-0.00022870920656714588,
0.026889745146036148,
-0.04050776734948158,
-0.05558701604604721,
-0.018155809491872787,
0.013878661207854748,
-0.0018767614383250475,
0.0010819629533216357,
-0.012128841131925583,
-0.04601993411779404,
-0.013407559134066105,
0.09720266610383987,
-0.045225128531455994,
0.009823564440011978,
-0.022302823141217232,
-0.014093161560595036,
0.02295779250562191,
0.012089964933693409,
-0.006638914812356234,
-0.002095271134749055,
0.02674008719623089,
0.022464022040367126,
0.03321017324924469,
-0.022374100983142853,
0.028750034049153328,
-0.02270088531076908,
0.010657094419002533,
-0.038955219089984894,
-0.039870284497737885,
-0.018354084342718124,
0.0428658127784729,
0.031185271218419075,
0.032854340970516205,
0.03146551176905632,
-0.047997843474149704,
0.03527028113603592,
0.01999993436038494,
0.03701884672045708,
-0.05369607359170914,
-0.019226539880037308,
-0.007154156919568777,
-0.006756522227078676,
0.015711989253759384,
-0.06984847784042358,
0.007202251814305782,
-0.057274699211120605,
0.006519337184727192,
-0.01146791409701109,
-0.016133155673742294,
0.014608713798224926,
-0.011454680003225803,
0.004037291277199984,
-0.0025080747436732054,
0.017948558554053307,
-0.021250901743769646,
-0.056857045739889145,
0.002624809741973877,
-0.009982455521821976,
0.019329354166984558,
-0.05681406334042549,
-0.030013492330908775,
0.07729179412126541,
-0.023821266368031502,
0.024017607793211937,
0.04544050619006157,
0.03057795949280262,
0.04142484813928604,
0.06980357319116592,
0.05057048797607422,
0.02619592659175396,
0.015412104316055775,
-0.002620847662910819,
-0.01721532829105854,
-0.004844993818551302,
0.0022736936807632446,
0.005756742786616087,
0.0055328477174043655,
0.00023374933516606688,
0.0026386852841824293,
-0.06066294014453888,
0.020572511479258537,
0.065264031291008,
-0.04040418937802315,
0.0009782719425857067,
-0.01765606738626957,
-0.007368918042629957,
0.030712511390447617,
0.0203580092638731,
0.005510591436177492,
0.02524591237306595,
0.01847849041223526,
-0.0344252735376358,
-0.037874702364206314,
-0.041774820536375046,
-0.022817503660917282,
0.015006247907876968,
-0.007657329551875591,
-0.0035621521528810263,
0.04411868005990982,
0.03263779729604721,
-0.021280866116285324,
-0.01657629758119583,
-0.004062353167682886,
0.03049403429031372,
0.010039826855063438,
0.001533366390503943,
0.02289285883307457,
0.03559454530477524,
0.023098468780517578,
-0.014119848608970642,
0.014214894734323025,
0.05394112691283226,
0.007532710675150156,
-0.03324681147933006,
-0.03318027779459953,
-0.0037428014911711216,
0.017377642914652824,
-0.041478853672742844,
0.003907299600541592,
-0.02866290882229805,
-0.04328889399766922,
-0.022488323971629143,
0.002630852861329913,
-0.0002574750396888703,
0.015752319246530533,
0.02098485454916954,
-0.009250753559172153,
0.04160965606570244,
-0.033356279134750366,
0.023621192201972008,
0.06834147870540619,
-0.01865490898489952,
0.025463223457336426,
0.009702606126666069,
0.0005959500558674335,
-0.009660481475293636,
-0.008190982975065708,
0.015185524709522724,
-0.05264662206172943,
0.05871102213859558,
0.04710263013839722,
-0.04659932106733322,
-0.04342913627624512,
-0.03155859187245369,
0.04478220269083977,
-0.049516744911670685,
0.012530364096164703,
0.0034552598372101784,
0.04113684594631195,
0.021001644432544708,
0.01524929329752922,
0.02720404416322708,
-0.020937275141477585,
-0.017980119213461876,
-0.007005291525274515,
0.04487068951129913,
0.07445613294839859,
-0.014942790381610394,
0.003588031977415085,
-0.02362683229148388,
0.024281322956085205,
0.044383954256772995,
-0.017129234969615936,
-0.006354562472552061,
0.006555346772074699,
-0.005381543654948473,
0.08302221447229385,
0.06767869740724564,
0.0563824325799942,
-0.015695562586188316,
0.003764133434742689,
0.009308994747698307,
-0.03022467903792858,
0.009986446239054203,
0.00133669120259583,
-0.03788024187088013,
-0.01123996451497078,
-0.013525713235139847,
0.032960813492536545,
0.025890303775668144,
-0.05688739940524101,
0.001015208661556244,
0.046404752880334854,
-0.027272533625364304,
0.06754805892705917,
-0.012832232750952244,
0.0018249740824103355,
0.03498365357518196,
0.018401827663183212,
-0.06323409080505371,
0.014385723508894444,
-0.01606684736907482,
0.0060003940016031265,
-0.00040940000326372683,
-0.004248855635523796,
0.02334686927497387,
-0.03564723953604698,
0.04505329579114914,
-0.03544436767697334,
0.02620154619216919,
0.012800004333257675,
-0.007216784171760082,
-0.038753941655159,
0.021121172234416008,
-0.01789204590022564,
-0.012691456824541092,
-0.0010858578607439995,
0.026385953649878502,
0.03489001467823982,
-0.036226123571395874,
0.030634963884949684,
-0.004686425905674696,
-0.07194177061319351,
-0.0168564822524786,
0.03198087960481644,
0.04043630138039589,
-0.06533481925725937,
0.00275242468342185,
0.0017634298419579864,
-0.019248563796281815,
-0.03403688967227936,
0.05170666426420212,
-0.015097913332283497,
0.014635820873081684,
-0.012903193011879921,
-0.04767952486872673,
-0.02772529050707817,
-0.009514293633401394,
0.01743006333708763,
0.027380499988794327,
-0.005705392919480801,
-0.006056357640773058,
-0.023020541295409203,
-0.008846672251820564,
0.008641041815280914,
-0.013483685441315174,
0.05559033155441284,
-0.004803256131708622,
-0.016518035903573036,
-0.010635687969624996,
0.05031316727399826,
0.052317213267087936,
-0.022104205563664436,
0.017517611384391785,
0.006175763439387083,
0.06035728007555008,
-0.05873469263315201,
-0.030639423057436943,
-0.0219721719622612,
-0.006917912047356367,
0.015087530016899109,
-0.03691324591636658,
-0.02969544194638729,
0.00265245302580297,
-0.0017469016602262855,
-0.0052588083781301975,
-0.0729152113199234,
-0.0050064316019415855,
-0.020054908469319344,
0.033598773181438446,
-0.007978823035955429,
-0.016293412074446678,
0.0353129617869854,
0.019981982186436653,
-0.025728829205036163,
-0.08462351560592651,
-0.06368154287338257,
-0.016665495932102203,
0.01140553504228592,
-0.028718413785099983,
0.0016149120638146996,
0.05034225061535835,
-0.015826327726244926,
0.0402342714369297,
0.012369533069431782,
-0.026257313787937164,
0.028126776218414307,
0.014065087772905827,
0.0533248633146286,
0.04770999029278755,
0.0034470022656023502,
-0.020242944359779358,
0.022040054202079773,
-0.00876570027321577,
-0.013231527991592884,
-0.022610094398260117,
-0.017600491642951965,
-0.008347551338374615,
-0.007151974365115166,
0.010090823285281658,
0.029755311086773872,
-0.03549597039818764,
0.006950524169951677,
0.0006792303174734116,
0.024072542786598206,
-0.032991573214530945,
-0.03573545068502426,
-0.01615159399807453,
-0.004670089576393366,
0.011106978170573711,
-0.055094752460718155,
0.0031768567860126495,
0.010304434224963188,
-0.020473888143897057,
0.0193560179322958,
0.014187255874276161,
-0.017700519412755966,
-0.0538782998919487,
0.019444409757852554,
0.017202766612172127,
-0.005469880532473326,
0.009661941789090633,
0.0058257095515728,
0.005181486252695322,
0.010396800935268402,
-0.047116558998823166,
0.013975213281810284,
-0.042862433940172195,
-0.0016498274635523558,
0.05514984205365181,
0.04523121565580368,
-0.007836136035621166,
0.03922772780060768,
-0.02116149477660656,
-0.014628265053033829,
0.012314985506236553,
0.007380358409136534,
0.032946132123470306,
-0.00930046010762453,
-0.023136746138334274,
-0.03701134771108627,
0.031296756118535995,
0.016530945897102356,
-0.029292317107319832,
-0.07020346075296402,
0.04174553602933884,
-0.02591858059167862,
0.007423967123031616,
-0.004180181305855513,
0.0005652070976793766,
0.04492223635315895,
0.008163654245436192,
0.005277309101074934,
0.005460488144308329,
0.04761847108602524,
0.021738003939390182,
-0.042905133217573166,
0.01615322381258011,
0.017268355935811996,
-0.005554098170250654,
0.011460941284894943,
-0.016742486506700516,
0.008851449936628342,
0.009189375676214695,
-0.005900799296796322,
-0.039255689829587936,
0.028911316767334938,
0.04465718939900398,
0.0056263841688632965,
0.004887109622359276,
0.06464509665966034,
-0.015806907787919044,
-0.04222356528043747,
-0.03128080070018768,
-0.007730991579592228,
-0.0019861215259879827,
-0.017215630039572716,
-0.03103361837565899,
-0.02887725830078125,
-0.00434246426448226,
0.012617616914212704,
-0.0443878136575222,
-0.0038804523646831512,
0.004682788625359535,
0.012417915277183056,
-0.028296470642089844,
-0.005296711809933186,
0.058142416179180145,
0.03571530431509018,
-0.012721192091703415,
-0.009309268556535244,
0.038594380021095276,
-0.015067045576870441,
-0.008845062926411629,
0.017655733972787857,
-0.03588400036096573,
0.0038838335312902927,
-0.10155793279409409,
-0.011184213683009148,
0.018953293561935425,
0.02206677757203579,
-0.09694173187017441,
-0.005393663886934519,
-0.03709162771701813,
0.04566735029220581,
0.02160770818591118,
-0.04525227099657059,
-0.0354841947555542,
0.0027520358562469482,
0.04432128742337227,
0.026080435141921043,
-0.008671053685247898,
-0.038516074419021606,
-0.019756220281124115,
-0.03611840680241585,
-0.019134316593408585,
-0.0033090657088905573,
0.0009642626973800361,
0.011255365796387196,
0.007728564087301493,
0.011789614334702492,
-0.023628292605280876,
-0.022511256858706474,
-0.035489704459905624,
-0.0004601007385645062,
-0.03710146248340607,
0.03194544091820717,
-0.0016065767267718911,
-0.02110457606613636,
0.0295233316719532,
-0.011905449442565441,
-0.02032124437391758,
0.018627895042300224,
-0.018390079960227013,
-0.020093213766813278,
-0.0264325812458992,
-0.03240776062011719,
-0.02398386038839817,
0.01948000118136406,
-0.018991386517882347,
0.01498583983629942,
0.06330311298370361,
-0.01594093255698681,
-0.020326312631368637,
0.014930800534784794,
-0.021360978484153748,
-0.007560477592051029,
-0.004530360456556082,
-0.0231770109385252,
0.004747692961245775,
-0.03760550916194916,
0.014835034497082233,
-0.02846779301762581,
0.02447277307510376,
0.01998777501285076,
0.021678071469068527,
0.05733231455087662,
0.020128920674324036,
-0.015606178902089596,
0.0009241333464160562,
-0.03952935338020325,
0.02239598147571087,
-0.032734014093875885,
-0.007189193740487099,
-0.007631413638591766,
0.032035764306783676,
0.019305530935525894,
-0.010136443190276623,
0.005912480875849724,
0.026665478944778442,
-0.037797711789608,
-0.005066205281764269,
-0.016528215259313583,
0.01938418298959732,
0.023950764909386635,
-0.008485705591738224,
0.022819923236966133,
-0.0018789948662742972,
0.0069250981323421,
-0.030160684138536453,
-0.028248902410268784,
0.041916053742170334,
-0.0062192571349442005,
0.03334277495741844,
-0.028103502467274666,
0.0666191428899765,
-0.0147312106564641,
-0.08193933963775635,
0.0040628123097121716,
-0.030833277851343155,
0.018942253664135933,
-0.03554150089621544,
0.042945973575115204,
0.006396173499524593,
-0.0007959910435602069,
-0.00878957100212574,
-0.05644994229078293,
-0.04633450508117676,
0.014032012782990932,
0.006453535053879023,
0.015207813121378422,
-0.03454536199569702,
0.011912574991583824,
-0.017952851951122284,
-0.01608881540596485,
0.00733153847977519,
-0.008838290348649025,
-0.005876523442566395,
-0.018339943140745163,
-0.001892485423013568,
0.01232814695686102,
-0.0365009531378746,
0.04559612646698952,
-0.027438636869192123,
0.019388223066926003,
-0.03405646234750748,
0.05313315615057945,
0.005352933891117573,
-0.01992741785943508,
-0.03427001088857651,
0.0023173096124082804,
0.030644243583083153,
-0.006233639549463987,
0.01208682544529438,
0.003602672601118684,
0.02775225043296814,
-0.015054664574563503,
0.003663749201223254,
0.028771454468369484,
-0.03233286738395691,
-0.0030518476851284504,
0.011213183403015137,
0.017475593835115433,
0.042661115527153015,
0.025054296478629112,
-0.026453252881765366,
-0.04293323680758476,
0.019835948944091797,
0.008618641644716263,
-0.04573366791009903,
0.03957750275731087,
-0.022914474830031395,
-0.03363116458058357,
-0.018280765041708946,
-0.053569208830595016,
-0.019331540912389755,
-0.01800384186208248,
0.019100161269307137,
0.010769596323370934,
-0.03216586634516716,
0.10839436203241348,
0.005701244343072176,
-0.038784876465797424,
0.04434172809123993,
0.027926990762352943,
-0.023453693836927414,
0.02873915247619152,
0.017575889825820923,
-0.08178134262561798,
-0.011627176776528358,
-0.04157348349690437,
-0.0009372322238050401,
0.02825186401605606,
-0.038262832909822464,
0.007430818397551775,
0.011334888637065887,
0.017768247053027153,
-0.03662190958857536,
-0.0052486141212284565,
-0.033140648156404495,
0.01660638116300106,
0.05928744375705719,
0.028446942567825317,
-0.012620159424841404,
0.022315770387649536,
0.09087476134300232,
0.010796434246003628,
0.031404536217451096,
0.025062326341867447,
0.00828566774725914,
0.019462119787931442,
-0.022473452612757683,
0.01421786192804575,
-0.020876845344901085,
-0.04488418996334076,
0.013392946682870388,
-0.032297857105731964,
0.05947451665997505,
0.03539058566093445,
-0.01190160121768713,
-0.008002270944416523,
0.04178962484002113,
0.020137477666139603,
0.013256383128464222,
0.0006384072476066649,
-0.0293776523321867,
0.04906431585550308,
-0.012865845113992691,
-0.013767393305897713,
-0.0234322939068079,
-0.020493796095252037,
-0.03719127178192139,
-0.02075616829097271,
-0.051811154931783676,
-0.017737019807100296,
-0.009707805700600147,
-0.012265012599527836,
-0.021958181634545326,
-0.0008657592115923762,
-0.01621708646416664,
0.05329177528619766,
-0.06157776340842247,
-0.005431591533124447,
-0.03683572635054588,
-0.07567814737558365,
-0.01754801534116268,
-0.01407679170370102,
0.030613303184509277,
0.08705159276723862,
-0.014905761927366257,
-0.01350715383887291,
0.044356439262628555,
0.0005728665855713189,
0.010419313795864582,
-0.00836559385061264,
0.054916441440582275,
-0.01948711648583412,
0.054850783199071884,
-0.0237529668956995,
-0.01628437452018261,
0.02883116714656353,
0.017347043380141258,
-0.03357581049203873,
-0.03990636393427849,
-0.058579687029123306,
-0.024403970688581467,
-0.015202181413769722,
0.015210575424134731,
-0.007835045456886292,
0.011956693604588509,
-0.026651034131646156
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:17
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
"To me the forklift was faulty mechanically in its steering. It fish-tailed once you reached a certain speed. You had to overcorrect the steering. It was back wheel steering. I refer you to my other statement. It was maintained by mechanics at work." (emphasis added)
82I made a direction under s 136 of the Evidence Act in respect of the italicised portion of this paragraph restricting its use to only prove the fact that it was that a statement that was communicated to QBE as that was a matter relevant to an assessment by it of whether to compromise Mr Horwood's claim.
83The reference to "my other statement" I infer to be a reference to the unsigned statement, in particular, to paragraph 9 of that statement which was as follows:
"Prior to Peter's accident and when I was driving the forklift I noticed the following about it:
(a)The steering was very loose. You had to turn the steering anything up to 180 degrees to get the machine to turn.
(b)When turning the machine it could turn either very slowly or very sharply without warning. There was no consistency so I didn't know what the machine was going to do. I had to be very alert and very careful driving it.
(c)When the forklift got up to a certain speed, I'm not sure exactly what the speed was because there is no speedo, but it's when the machine was driven almost to its capacity, it would fishtail. The steering is on the rear wheels.
When it starts to fishtail the steering became almost useless because it was too loose and you couldn't correct it. If you were not very careful you could lose control. It was easy to over correct.
(d)The brakes were never very good. Driving the machine on the roads around Broken Hill the brakes would squeal and were very dull. The stopping distance was inordinately long.
(e)In my experience of driving this machine prior to Peter's accident, and this includes the weeks leading up to Peter's accident, I almost had a number of accident's [sic] myself.
(f)Because the maximum speed of the machine was still well less than the speed limit I tended to drive the machine towards the edge of the roadway. This did not impede traffic. At the edge of the roadway usually was where the camber of the road was more pronounced.
(g)On many occasions I almost hit parked cars or lost control of the machine because the machine would wander and I couldn't correct it quick enough with the steering.
(h)On a number of occasions where I was hurrying to get to places to use the forklift on roads, it would fishtail. The only thing I could do on those occasions was basically hope that by taking my foot off the accelerator that the machine would centre itself. On a number of occasions, more than two, I thought that the machine was going to turn over on me."
84At [12] Mr Oates states that on a number of occasions he complained to Terry Capper about the steering of the forklift and that this was in the "short period leading up to Peter's accident".
85I have outlined above the relevant part of the contents of the running log of the WorkCover investigation including the conversation with Mr Barry Gillett.
86QBE tendered two reports from a firm of investigators it retained, GCI Group. Attached to one of those reports was a statement from the police officer who attended at the scene of the accident, Constable Paul Thompson, given on 8 June 2007.
He recounts arriving at the scene of the accident and obtaining a brief statement from Mr Horwood, the effect of which I have set out above. He did not interview anyone at the scene of the accident and only spoke to Mr Horwood later at the hospital.
87One of the investigator's reports also included various file notes of discussions between the investigator and a number of witnesses. One of the witnesses spoken to was Mr Gillett. The interviewer's notes record that Mr Gillett stated that he was employed by Megbuy until 8 May 2005 and that he maintained the forklift until that time. He was recorded as stating, inter alia:
|
[
0.007057147100567818,
-0.008787074126303196,
-0.023145148530602455,
-0.020388392731547356,
0.028547540307044983,
-0.031222550198435783,
-0.021931931376457214,
0.058642953634262085,
0.005915065295994282,
0.017523769289255142,
0.0013415783178061247,
0.016436904668807983,
0.028855454176664352,
-0.02679535746574402,
0.007817828096449375,
-0.0677899718284607,
0.03612716495990753,
-0.017328619956970215,
-0.02122805267572403,
-0.06082015857100487,
0.026403022930026054,
-0.01296384446322918,
0.05321718752384186,
0.06959883123636246,
0.006606927141547203,
0.02501700632274151,
0.028977101668715477,
0.0034380494616925716,
0.008119309321045876,
-0.011779767461121082,
0.03571942076086998,
0.012515384703874588,
-0.019034849479794502,
0.002809894969686866,
-0.016494160518050194,
-0.026130426675081253,
0.008339712396264076,
-0.012979906983673573,
-0.018692802637815475,
0.0030161684844642878,
-0.010954931378364563,
-0.005090715363621712,
0.05433167144656181,
-0.008622798137366772,
0.023036036640405655,
-0.03454378619790077,
-0.0476076602935791,
-0.01596722938120365,
-0.0052470979280769825,
0.014401566237211227,
-0.009582317434251308,
-0.03286740556359291,
0.04586745426058769,
-0.021409999579191208,
0.0018149245297536254,
0.02994447760283947,
0.0013507221592590213,
0.003635401837527752,
-0.09082785248756409,
-0.0003184775123372674,
-0.006598731502890587,
-0.0009469307260587811,
-0.019731100648641586,
-0.02214842289686203,
-0.007654925342649221,
0.12958361208438873,
-0.0399593822658062,
0.018121251836419106,
-0.016291232779622078,
-0.024612776935100555,
0.0057484363205730915,
0.023742331191897392,
0.03344234079122543,
0.011535982601344585,
-0.04719829186797142,
0.031103653833270073,
0.015173092484474182,
0.034119490534067154,
0.017485860735177994,
0.04523899033665657,
0.04220733791589737,
0.012915065512061119,
0.005015513394027948,
0.010723816230893135,
0.004168996121734381,
-0.0014468968147411942,
-0.029967745766043663,
0.02139808051288128,
0.003797333687543869,
0.015388363972306252,
0.008793409913778305,
-0.006976352538913488,
0.03024679608643055,
-0.04327777400612831,
-0.022768741473555565,
-0.018430152907967567,
0.012325395829975605,
0.023458685725927353,
-0.0010213236091658473,
0.00021488232596311718,
-0.024245521053671837,
0.011282048188149929,
0.02023601531982422,
-0.04811028391122818,
0.02162073366343975,
-0.0024188244715332985,
0.036326173692941666,
0.016400234773755074,
0.02031734213232994,
0.004333140794187784,
0.060053300112485886,
0.023325800895690918,
-0.021117988973855972,
0.030166324228048325,
-0.003746634814888239,
-0.015667567029595375,
0.018143020570278168,
-0.025445550680160522,
0.014467967674136162,
-0.028284085914492607,
0.04800271987915039,
0.06545967608690262,
0.056458763778209686,
-0.03174472972750664,
-0.05444425716996193,
-0.006051159463822842,
-0.024337776005268097,
-0.06721679866313934,
-0.021043797954916954,
0.007027824874967337,
0.012492669746279716,
0.004426589235663414,
-0.017793375998735428,
-0.044247664511203766,
-0.062002040445804596,
-0.02861861139535904,
-0.002761813811957836,
-0.02533874101936817,
-0.03495742380619049,
-0.007740429136902094,
0.02607104554772377,
0.054789599031209946,
-0.0004006973758805543,
-0.008053514175117016,
0.04119756072759628,
-0.03269980847835541,
0.0265624038875103,
-0.037195004522800446,
0.012319092638790607,
-0.014464464038610458,
0.018798209726810455,
0.01580984704196453,
-0.003877745009958744,
-0.04586828127503395,
0.04332752153277397,
-0.05533316358923912,
0.021803664043545723,
0.004787949845194817,
-0.015316395089030266,
0.011186194606125355,
0.0036763667594641447,
0.05687813088297844,
-0.017024610191583633,
-0.022619646042585373,
0.022309277206659317,
0.019525839015841484,
0.026714324951171875,
0.026464466005563736,
-0.010485979728400707,
-0.03365177661180496,
0.010291951708495617,
-0.02669568359851837,
0.03042096272110939,
0.030938858166337013,
0.00942247174680233,
0.031025027856230736,
0.05830660089850426,
0.019510986283421516,
0.03562885895371437,
-0.035063471645116806,
-0.009633908979594707,
0.021649854257702827,
0.011463391594588757,
-0.003551773726940155,
-0.01862480118870735,
0.019485466182231903,
0.02433054894208908,
-0.036367230117321014,
0.013845042325556278,
-0.0014569952618330717,
-0.024806510657072067,
-0.02737235277891159,
0.06601843237876892,
0.034203317016363144,
0.03181012347340584,
-0.016576198861002922,
0.029108701273798943,
-0.02956795133650303,
0.03520767018198967,
-0.0072549558244645596,
0.01114718522876501,
0.03387368097901344,
0.063344806432724,
-0.06287900358438492,
-0.027110107243061066,
0.010690269060432911,
-0.011941416189074516,
0.006246093660593033,
0.024104002863168716,
-0.07309514284133911,
0.0062871696427464485,
-0.01743333600461483,
0.0077588208951056,
0.023285450413823128,
-0.02757309563457966,
0.02624579705297947,
-0.024062801152467728,
0.00038091634633019567,
-0.0076764291152358055,
-0.03274013102054596,
0.0008057812810875475,
-0.0063100093975663185,
-0.005555675830692053,
-0.009530431590974331,
0.032906390726566315,
0.009168369695544243,
-0.03958813101053238,
0.0339507982134819,
0.007549053989350796,
-0.059618864208459854,
0.043983206152915955,
0.0032558240927755833,
0.02459626831114292,
-0.02124018594622612,
0.022033868357539177,
0.02546658180654049,
0.0136167723685503,
0.010790154337882996,
0.01912914216518402,
0.045906681567430496,
0.01034120749682188,
-0.035089895129203796,
0.05251307785511017,
-0.03440086543560028,
-0.0026021813973784447,
-0.03475075587630272,
0.022468283772468567,
0.035645321011543274,
0.040978580713272095,
0.04273447394371033,
0.03558539226651192,
-0.0061084371991455555,
-0.011019008234143257,
-0.007610662374645472,
0.016374442726373672,
0.0460660420358181,
0.032565996050834656,
-0.017226720228791237,
0.007904453203082085,
-0.030310727655887604,
0.021860409528017044,
0.04184948652982712,
0.03207629919052124,
-0.021904030814766884,
-0.03386979550123215,
-0.012879588641226292,
-0.025789085775613785,
-0.061415862292051315,
-0.04556753858923912,
0.02282957173883915,
0.008415723219513893,
-0.006770292297005653,
0.006404409185051918,
0.01571180298924446,
0.02033761702477932,
0.04586731269955635,
-0.030346008017659187,
-0.008039960637688637,
0.04026074334979057,
0.003929364029318094,
0.07486902177333832,
-0.010690965689718723,
0.034719109535217285,
-0.01432984508574009,
0.038629673421382904,
-0.00568372430279851,
-0.04540841281414032,
-0.03392400965094566,
-0.017847338691353798,
-0.024754690006375313,
0.031672582030296326,
-0.007388009224087,
0.045993588864803314,
-0.023761296644806862,
-0.03087608516216278,
0.029760146513581276,
0.013135630637407303,
-0.14682602882385254,
0.023276619613170624,
0.03477340191602707,
0.00369048654101789,
0.007131012622267008,
0.038865573704242706,
-0.004393785260617733,
-0.01376799214631319,
-0.03442087024450302,
-0.0038040615618228912,
-0.01765488274395466,
-0.04374530538916588,
0.006228942424058914,
-0.012587862089276314,
-0.018366163596510887,
-0.020044822245836258,
0.0029562923591583967,
0.01838037744164467,
0.0028958874754607677,
-0.06489297747612,
0.020792502909898758,
-0.0018076293636113405,
0.022622983902692795,
-0.011335879564285278,
-0.013546057976782322,
-0.03684934601187706,
0.056524742394685745,
0.0020703738555312157,
-0.04164694622159004,
-0.05189046263694763,
-0.01417612936347723,
-0.01903267577290535,
-0.014281331561505795,
0.05890756472945213,
0.015039668418467045,
0.0159310232847929,
0.045644957572221756,
-0.07335039973258972,
-0.006783870980143547,
-0.00814858078956604,
0.03327455371618271,
0.06478440761566162,
-0.025907140225172043,
0.022210726514458656,
0.00788814015686512,
-0.08619910478591919,
0.021517891436815262,
0.01672847382724285,
-0.059465955942869186,
0.02486574277281761,
-0.0017025977140292525,
-0.02995939739048481,
0.005498501472175121,
0.014601359143853188,
0.009023782797157764,
-0.017752885818481445,
0.02951948717236519,
0.06433580070734024,
-0.04022564738988876,
0.003401605412364006,
0.018177222460508347,
-0.05481407418847084,
0.04095855727791786,
0.019507288932800293,
-0.037571217864751816,
0.006435157265514135,
-0.00009864064486464486,
-0.007274145260453224,
0.025392750278115273,
-0.008973962627351284,
-0.015341155230998993,
-0.06243255361914635,
0.03243646398186684,
0.021324221044778824,
0.03830805420875549,
0.015760453417897224,
-0.01673152483999729,
-0.0147037822753191,
0.0029833184089511633,
-0.08599875122308731,
-0.012464996427297592,
0.06483270227909088,
-0.009520553052425385,
0.005628178361803293,
-0.01928030513226986,
0.016498906537890434,
0.012359578162431717,
0.031829290091991425,
0.046842027455568314,
0.23893779516220093,
0.014590716920793056,
-0.027421431615948677,
-0.009251147508621216,
-0.0024705990217626095,
0.00010519692295929417,
0.0022732813376933336,
-0.005648531019687653,
0.020645594224333763,
-0.022314704954624176,
-0.025885241106152534,
0.01100081019103527,
0.033809781074523926,
0.032448481768369675,
-0.02622263692319393,
-0.006311685312539339,
-0.03238467872142792,
-0.05271786078810692,
0.04846334084868431,
0.00902122724801302,
0.033551573753356934,
0.016584161669015884,
0.04746968671679497,
0.031516388058662415,
-0.09112484008073807,
-0.02649243362247944,
-0.028629381209611893,
-0.030413132160902023,
0.01375244278460741,
0.015222103334963322,
-0.022908488288521767,
-0.015953686088323593,
0.040118660777807236,
0.011918839998543262,
-0.011290952563285828,
0.0002915567019954324,
-0.02796071209013462,
0.0015675234608352184,
-0.001401565968990326,
0.0016550328582525253,
0.01971188187599182,
0.011332744732499123,
-0.04597486928105354,
-0.028974464163184166,
-0.03397870436310768,
0.001881520845927298,
-0.00023774951114319265,
-0.009554058313369751,
-0.046253498643636703,
0.041569411754608154,
-0.014661626890301704,
0.05001308396458626,
-0.03602854534983635,
-0.019684849306941032,
-0.011189021170139313,
0.02256651408970356,
0.012429514899849892,
0.004791633225977421,
0.007879680953919888,
0.037781983613967896,
0.024281663820147514,
0.029030825942754745,
-0.030770039185881615,
0.03131149709224701,
-0.003845946164801717,
0.004202254116535187,
-0.02719520777463913,
-0.019922027364373207,
0.0429677814245224,
-0.008344726637005806,
0.007021707482635975,
0.033048104494810104,
0.011265847831964493,
0.047669608145952225,
0.014853348024189472,
-0.017535865306854248,
0.01687927357852459,
0.04199095070362091,
-0.031865742057561874,
0.02641417644917965,
-0.028334876522421837,
-0.036192163825035095,
-0.007673810701817274,
0.013113788329064846,
0.004275006242096424,
-0.018280325457453728,
-0.0031656103674322367,
0.06417039036750793,
0.03045865334570408,
0.005903684534132481,
-0.04780026152729988,
-0.03120436705648899,
-0.01008633803576231,
0.011309965513646603,
-0.05050770193338394,
0.013690713793039322,
0.014640826731920242,
0.0024493704549968243,
0.002260992769151926,
-0.053588155657052994,
-0.028506219387054443,
0.009603241458535194,
0.002154513029381633,
0.01395530253648758,
0.006526337005198002,
-0.04578379914164543,
-0.02446615695953369,
0.021374283358454704,
-0.012783952988684177,
-0.012096904218196869,
-0.0160017479211092,
0.016741540282964706,
0.0045349919237196445,
-0.032945889979600906,
0.016477476805448532,
0.02106720581650734,
-0.03108667954802513,
0.07967119663953781,
-0.0018367440206930041,
0.03409513458609581,
-0.030261235311627388,
0.0031847667414695024,
-0.026355288922786713,
-0.01818637177348137,
-0.02477753534913063,
-0.020439419895410538,
-0.04171155393123627,
-0.04938632249832153,
-0.03519601374864578,
0.023295534774661064,
0.0003238089266233146,
0.006673745810985565,
-0.05891020968556404,
0.025330927222967148,
0.06468436121940613,
-0.0032807046081870794,
-0.01353218499571085,
0.019858818501234055,
-0.031044622883200645,
-0.007537101395428181,
-0.04099541902542114,
0.009232140146195889,
-0.045582763850688934,
-0.06253061443567276,
0.014314169995486736,
-0.008102304302155972,
-0.03683071956038475,
0.02011796087026596,
-0.07574785500764847,
-0.05232315510511398,
0.029233193024992943,
0.025241799652576447,
-0.05812980607151985,
-0.017915882170200348,
0.0025767418555915356,
0.015163491480052471,
0.004655439406633377,
-0.026079917326569557,
-0.004693825729191303,
-0.02734069712460041,
0.004364201333373785,
-0.02008301392197609,
-0.029038148000836372,
0.04418681934475899,
-0.013032919727265835,
0.025099696591496468,
0.045880284160375595,
0.03212472423911095,
0.0631866380572319,
-0.005596507340669632,
-0.0011522199492901564,
-0.035442184656858444,
0.011755439452826977,
0.054815810173749924,
0.023826394230127335,
0.04817134141921997,
-0.047216497361660004,
0.013985993340611458,
-0.008968271315097809,
-0.026306169107556343,
0.008371487259864807,
0.023016344755887985,
-0.009425966069102287,
-0.006460750941187143,
-0.018938098102808,
-0.03250492736697197,
0.03530079126358032,
-0.022917160764336586,
-0.006904704961925745,
-0.020102281123399734,
-0.012438477948307991,
0.10057996213436127,
-0.04333075135946274,
-0.01569903828203678,
-0.011712862178683281,
0.006946159992367029,
0.0016384869813919067,
0.010089097544550896,
-0.0010471581481397152,
-0.06270656734704971,
-0.058057866990566254,
0.012135145254433155,
0.0053867497481405735,
0.04141213744878769,
0.03156885504722595,
0.004347986076027155,
-0.05433765798807144,
0.012783345766365528,
-0.039226241409778595,
-0.012018919922411442,
-0.004960724152624607,
0.0023765251971781254,
-0.056972015649080276,
-0.023943249136209488,
-0.009029482491314411,
-0.007453304249793291,
0.0541764535009861,
0.06294511258602142,
0.0003744054993148893,
-0.018130183219909668,
-0.048948463052511215,
0.009624497033655643,
0.04682079702615738,
-0.06189809367060661,
-0.06622446328401566,
0.02464945800602436,
-0.020899776369333267,
-0.0601004995405674,
0.03341756761074066,
-0.01148598175495863,
0.0019783175084739923,
-0.043941132724285126,
0.014810224063694477,
-0.010942798107862473,
0.025492023676633835,
-0.0029994864016771317,
0.02749130316078663,
0.03615650534629822,
0.009391509927809238,
-0.04207681864500046,
0.032962437719106674,
-0.03418828547000885,
0.018626069650053978,
0.069907546043396,
-0.017866099253296852,
-0.05772419273853302,
0.00043882132740691304,
-0.06986905634403229,
-0.010118088684976101,
0.01216599065810442,
0.02697943150997162,
0.02690075896680355,
0.0079762302339077,
-0.02684098668396473,
-0.012625468894839287,
0.011190592311322689,
0.006011040881276131,
-0.007555664516985416,
-0.02139449305832386,
-0.014842291362583637,
0.010790223255753517,
0.012632669880986214,
0.011247330345213413,
-0.027372481301426888,
-0.007537495344877243,
-0.033301010727882385,
0.013806158676743507,
0.03290053829550743,
-0.042609453201293945,
-0.0584634467959404,
-0.023144353181123734,
-0.018186459317803383,
-0.0444943942129612,
-0.04744651913642883,
-0.017484022304415703,
0.018249820917844772,
-0.010083958506584167,
-0.01218648161739111,
-0.01312928181141615,
-0.05527976155281067,
0.016843801364302635,
-0.030821120366454124,
-0.033042699098587036,
0.0700594112277031,
0.005962831433862448,
0.06269890069961548,
0.04440964758396149,
0.003345978446304798,
0.00469610933214426,
-0.015738829970359802,
0.048719264566898346,
0.007852933369576931,
-0.01647951640188694,
-0.014077236875891685,
-0.028846539556980133,
0.004910788033157587,
-0.022730160504579544,
0.06988117843866348,
-0.027397705242037773,
0.008105047978460789,
0.004377175122499466,
0.03356455639004707,
-0.04220009595155716,
-0.014315813779830933,
0.009377874433994293,
0.007271949667483568,
-0.017669623717665672,
-0.040586404502391815,
0.0033874388318508863,
-0.008271749131381512,
0.016523070633411407,
-0.05455191805958748,
0.0003247093118261546,
-0.003076951950788498,
-0.02316809818148613,
-0.0005792835727334023,
-0.0047475071623921394,
0.00028724418370984495,
0.0007507219561375678,
0.0359613373875618,
0.014175858348608017,
0.010379907675087452,
-0.04369865730404854,
-0.03721362724900246,
-0.0835813358426094,
0.012741331942379475,
-0.04528447985649109,
0.003723087953403592,
-0.012912114150822163,
-0.03209613263607025,
-0.02771514467895031,
0.012571420520544052,
-0.02334621548652649,
0.019003011286258698,
0.08394404500722885,
-0.026791350916028023,
-0.00022499282204080373,
-0.03691503405570984,
0.04229233041405678,
-0.045812852680683136,
0.014385472051799297,
-0.022809596732258797,
0.0482814684510231,
-0.004041928332298994,
0.03305557370185852,
0.014896268025040627,
-0.006253268104046583,
-0.0006024634931236506,
0.03268960490822792,
0.04185754805803299,
-0.018030209466814995,
0.04620993137359619,
-0.01220454927533865,
-0.028700435534119606,
0.002693381393328309,
0.006725667510181665,
-0.001385293435305357,
-0.012995319440960884,
0.03904328495264053,
-0.013637806288897991,
0.0019520942587405443,
0.011969638988375664,
-0.03063158504664898,
-0.025926435366272926,
-0.004426412750035524,
-0.0026024829130619764,
0.015293935313820839,
-0.024405233561992645,
-0.026510905474424362,
0.005495538469403982,
-0.02352873608469963,
-0.012850825674831867,
0.04674559459090233,
-0.006783384829759598,
-0.039759561419487,
0.026120169088244438,
0.012296564877033234,
0.00013921984646003693,
-0.010123143903911114,
-0.017508942633867264,
-0.020140958949923515,
-0.042667239904403687,
-0.029953256249427795,
0.0005831792950630188,
0.021469945088028908,
-0.019542865455150604,
-0.03209560737013817,
0.03979109600186348,
-0.032140593975782394,
0.04415452480316162,
-0.011559709906578064,
0.036377403885126114,
-0.054886698722839355,
0.010513820685446262,
-0.1253224015235901,
0.011689324863255024,
-0.004033607430756092,
-0.025693165138363838,
-0.046368200331926346,
-0.004522417671978474,
-0.009985528886318207,
-0.004783004056662321,
-0.035059768706560135,
0.0026975979562848806,
0.019939441233873367,
-0.01324320025742054,
0.04106255620718002,
-0.0037096336018294096,
-0.023775987327098846,
0.039336785674095154,
-0.059185780584812164,
-0.00978658627718687,
-0.03464427590370178,
0.0342489629983902,
0.03994255140423775,
0.01998968794941902,
0.007650268729776144,
-0.005106552969664335,
-0.025483351200819016,
0.010270042344927788,
-0.015995176509022713,
-0.008615192025899887,
-0.011937527917325497,
-0.001919057802297175,
-0.049768008291721344,
-0.06382306665182114,
0.008301980793476105,
0.059674810618162155,
0.004216114990413189,
0.016534121707081795,
0.015109790489077568,
0.015870099887251854,
-0.03462255746126175,
-0.026837090030312538,
-0.04445580020546913,
0.018205048516392708,
-0.03570937365293503,
-0.03717868775129318,
-0.03600839897990227,
0.03798175975680351,
-0.02789735235273838,
0.008683945052325726,
-0.0007340080919675529,
-0.03872906416654587,
-0.020794561132788658,
0.011710059829056263,
-0.003418778069317341,
0.06618569046258926,
0.033037152141332626,
0.03408455476164818,
-0.016488317400217056,
-0.028248926624655724,
0.0011847401037812233,
0.072282575070858,
0.00414133770391345,
0.0017153859371319413,
-0.028560811653733253,
-0.013942844234406948,
-0.006576401647180319,
0.007824556902050972,
-0.01965572126209736,
0.006241093389689922,
0.03542261943221092,
-0.03834003955125809,
-0.020766980946063995,
-0.020615506917238235,
0.03633679077029228,
-0.01816638559103012,
-0.011543411761522293,
-0.02378184348344803,
0.021058401092886925,
-0.050174254924058914,
0.026383379474282265,
-0.00641636410728097,
-0.015800796449184418,
0.0007030857959762216,
-0.050655022263526917,
0.005296447314321995,
0.03542754426598549,
0.05085572972893715,
-0.01530284620821476,
-0.03281695023179054,
0.019745560362935066,
-0.060518473386764526,
-0.03800052031874657,
0.016066566109657288,
-0.0021401785779744387,
0.010412479750812054,
-0.037283528596162796,
0.04654664918780327,
-0.004517081193625927,
-0.026302965357899666,
-0.02443435974419117,
-0.015729127451777458,
-0.013754243962466717,
-0.017640231177210808,
0.003490365343168378,
0.01915273442864418,
-0.005685638170689344,
0.006462656892836094,
0.03664151579141617,
0.010421295650303364,
0.017140908166766167,
-0.04176992550492287,
-0.024212006479501724,
-0.049603164196014404,
-0.061564456671476364,
-0.017267238348722458,
-0.01025293581187725,
0.055941417813301086,
0.012702259235084057,
-0.017259100452065468,
-0.010935625992715359,
0.029859060421586037,
0.018781457096338272,
-0.018768755719065666,
0.015887638553977013,
-0.013265350833535194,
-0.035477250814437866,
0.02152504399418831,
0.030411509796977043,
0.0011743356008082628,
0.00421188585460186,
0.009156529791653156,
0.008475256152451038,
-0.009390821680426598,
-0.000016961594155873172,
0.021373072639107704,
-0.00880745705217123,
0.0030308447312563658,
-0.010422589257359505,
-0.007592357229441404,
-0.001063730102032423,
-0.044809941202402115,
0.012497075833380222,
0.007793101016432047,
-0.01408305112272501,
-0.03787097707390785,
-0.013581709004938602,
-0.013281998224556446,
0.036458395421504974,
0.012952209450304508,
-0.022298719733953476,
0.0014911254402250051,
-0.0051839291118085384,
0.03696808964014053,
-0.013104395009577274,
0.047557052224874496,
0.00785171426832676,
-0.010024778544902802,
0.037941474467515945,
0.046402644366025925,
0.02483939751982689,
0.03908568248152733,
0.05040767416357994,
-0.03930896520614624,
-0.010265487246215343,
-0.021454811096191406,
-0.007281784433871508,
0.03270731121301651,
0.009798295795917511,
-0.03371373191475868,
-0.01592416502535343,
-0.008674440905451775,
0.037995126098394394,
0.034285660833120346,
-0.026493016630411148,
0.009700109250843525,
0.028903983533382416,
-0.07194313406944275,
-0.005402880720794201,
-0.03593819960951805,
0.046200964599847794,
-0.0035063743125647306,
0.03283337503671646,
0.03266642242670059,
0.01468562614172697,
0.024879876524209976,
-0.01565595529973507,
0.01480141282081604,
-0.010543693788349628,
0.0037566539831459522,
-0.04315599799156189,
0.008733024820685387,
0.000545566319487989,
0.018924906849861145,
-0.005557163618505001,
-0.03509195148944855,
0.03845947980880737,
-0.013830652460455894,
-0.007915911264717579,
0.03989943116903305,
0.010823208838701248,
0.015410692431032658,
0.018967360258102417,
-0.009870047681033611,
-0.011833160184323788,
-0.038165319710969925,
-0.034514546394348145,
-0.005654644686728716,
0.015730496495962143,
-0.02899918332695961,
-0.016778144985437393,
0.03709384799003601,
-0.031009774655103683,
-0.005768124014139175,
0.012395416386425495,
0.02140209637582302,
-0.023057499900460243,
0.013861247338354588,
0.032192181795835495,
0.013452406041324139,
0.020638996735215187,
-0.013307438232004642,
0.03818494454026222,
0.02991204336285591,
-0.005945207085460424,
-0.046464186161756516,
-0.006794176530092955,
0.004724579397588968,
0.011352501809597015,
-0.0015893650706857443,
-0.00574447400867939,
0.0023241254966706038,
-0.013789855875074863,
0.0016985053662210703,
0.019879918545484543,
0.04472566395998001,
-0.004085511434823275,
0.0025036102160811424,
-0.02730405516922474,
-0.0367758683860302,
-0.004309157375246286,
-0.008898249827325344,
0.057017628103494644,
-0.012849661521613598,
-0.007762367371469736,
0.008174916729331017
] |
What did Mr Oates state about the forklift's steering in the period leading up to Peter's accident?
|
[
0.0011028689332306385,
0.0015301252715289593,
-0.0357324592769146,
-0.013728806748986244,
0.030289627611637115,
-0.03613158315420151,
-0.006993317045271397,
0.03197677060961723,
0.017173394560813904,
0.007379493676126003,
-0.013304282911121845,
0.05655108019709587,
0.05207731947302818,
-0.008531389757990837,
0.04140305891633034,
-0.04757889360189438,
0.05460992828011513,
-0.021494142711162567,
0.012735342606902122,
-0.050968751311302185,
0.007222547195851803,
-0.020951438695192337,
-0.0407705157995224,
0.07223021984100342,
0.009347507730126381,
0.005291854962706566,
0.03742273524403572,
-0.0029052181635051966,
-0.011053758673369884,
0.0066926744766533375,
0.030527284368872643,
0.0032871856819838285,
-0.009490983560681343,
0.03404567018151283,
-0.00266561028547585,
-0.03281380236148834,
0.0384441614151001,
0.021275995299220085,
-0.028893154114484787,
-0.015752824023365974,
-0.02161400392651558,
-0.02648591808974743,
0.05701347813010216,
0.020809117704629898,
-0.00810333527624607,
-0.03687049075961113,
-0.03379616513848305,
-0.02027425356209278,
0.0201516542583704,
0.01656194031238556,
-0.021407149732112885,
-0.01641123555600643,
0.01775667816400528,
-0.016385454684495926,
0.027648253366351128,
0.025142492726445198,
0.007384882308542728,
0.025916818529367447,
-0.05389518663287163,
0.01616884209215641,
0.015175744891166687,
-0.04224754497408867,
0.013997995294630527,
-0.01927763782441616,
-0.0019514600280672312,
0.09472674876451492,
-0.03397031128406525,
-0.01271953247487545,
-0.00810967106372118,
-0.0012380240950733423,
-0.026813659816980362,
0.03886927664279938,
0.06655939668416977,
-0.00875746551901102,
-0.018285393714904785,
0.001056167995557189,
-0.012847399339079857,
0.006776758935302496,
0.002119275275617838,
0.06672263145446777,
0.05289124697446823,
0.031131740659475327,
-0.000816279265563935,
0.016249671578407288,
0.034020356833934784,
0.05381520837545395,
-0.050865866243839264,
0.008856034837663174,
0.03160148113965988,
0.009467399679124355,
0.003591828281059861,
-0.02100139856338501,
0.027368908748030663,
-0.02700377255678177,
-0.06652647256851196,
-0.042495738714933395,
0.018483662977814674,
0.013959337957203388,
0.016154654324054718,
-0.014683213084936142,
0.01989893428981304,
-0.01637876220047474,
-0.015180014073848724,
-0.03856994956731796,
0.041825681924819946,
-0.04361281916499138,
0.03952281177043915,
0.02031978778541088,
0.013088434003293514,
0.003553189104422927,
0.05854327604174614,
0.06269682198762894,
0.03404568135738373,
-0.009450249373912811,
-0.027004815638065338,
0.005724586080759764,
0.02524639293551445,
-0.013020601123571396,
-0.002240309026092291,
-0.0038921888917684555,
0.06291680037975311,
0.046822741627693176,
0.06589192152023315,
-0.029934300109744072,
0.0016310650389641523,
-0.0025467604864388704,
-0.0321277491748333,
-0.055819712579250336,
0.04337461292743683,
0.009625648148357868,
-0.005715771112591028,
-0.006583117879927158,
-0.03362807258963585,
-0.030596064403653145,
-0.0731295794248581,
-0.030462931841611862,
0.010381268337368965,
0.0021122244652360678,
-0.009895216673612595,
-0.02493332326412201,
0.035676296800374985,
0.06805979460477829,
0.0053620836697518826,
-0.014874445274472237,
0.028785649687051773,
-0.04971986636519432,
0.01726340502500534,
0.004189357627183199,
0.009589726105332375,
0.003989687189459801,
-0.013543379493057728,
-0.005151976831257343,
0.008049290627241135,
-0.0035929435398429632,
0.058346763253211975,
-0.025537073612213135,
0.004530380014330149,
0.0379306934773922,
-0.03234509751200676,
0.005650553852319717,
0.03510425612330437,
0.006202880293130875,
-0.009296185337007046,
-0.03654973953962326,
-0.004938621073961258,
0.030640484765172005,
0.01581062190234661,
0.0012799950782209635,
-0.027417104691267014,
0.024399304762482643,
-0.019270380958914757,
-0.024559199810028076,
0.009194388054311275,
0.018849048763513565,
0.024238616228103638,
0.007562669925391674,
0.047005727887153625,
0.007616787683218718,
0.05699962377548218,
-0.04650885611772537,
-0.01499287597835064,
0.03997378423810005,
0.035025857388973236,
-0.014953169040381908,
0.03058200515806675,
0.0197911337018013,
0.027333112433552742,
-0.04456780478358269,
0.013160506263375282,
-0.015431975945830345,
-0.032490815967321396,
-0.03835102915763855,
0.06231852248311043,
0.02373083308339119,
0.03253217041492462,
0.010228822939097881,
0.004392723087221384,
-0.04069902375340462,
-0.013270455412566662,
0.0235237255692482,
0.0224935170263052,
0.03689466416835785,
0.0388103611767292,
-0.039508119225502014,
0.003959794994443655,
-0.023513002321124077,
-0.007898334413766861,
-0.017728272825479507,
-0.009768832474946976,
-0.04474985599517822,
-0.009708123281598091,
-0.04015382379293442,
0.009241481311619282,
-0.025961298495531082,
-0.030445577576756477,
0.026214055716991425,
-0.013619787059724331,
0.014726446010172367,
-0.045560531318187714,
-0.03757436200976372,
0.02842850424349308,
-0.026849428191781044,
0.03946039453148842,
-0.049597252160310745,
0.01974366419017315,
0.03388228639960289,
-0.011897885240614414,
-0.0014256034046411514,
-0.033627044409513474,
-0.051972027868032455,
0.007023611571639776,
0.01255179662257433,
-0.006110482383519411,
-0.0009578155586495996,
0.04013356566429138,
0.040316712111234665,
0.06763114780187607,
0.028898369520902634,
0.025118758901953697,
0.03431794047355652,
0.0015306791756302118,
-0.012506472878158092,
0.011836294084787369,
0.013904334977269173,
0.015275942161679268,
-0.010370627045631409,
0.006133825983852148,
0.019750915467739105,
0.0308817308396101,
0.05336372181773186,
0.06160987168550491,
-0.0061951130628585815,
-0.05093488469719887,
0.02435505948960781,
0.008655757643282413,
0.043722230941057205,
0.02960335463285446,
-0.05390145629644394,
-0.02618088200688362,
-0.06469882279634476,
0.005350134335458279,
0.06058550998568535,
-0.019107472151517868,
0.0005814615869894624,
-0.03950629383325577,
-0.011130869388580322,
-0.0489213690161705,
-0.04224741831421852,
-0.027572575956583023,
0.03593621402978897,
-0.035306867212057114,
0.0035232233349233866,
0.006509289611130953,
-0.0013947979314252734,
0.017488641664385796,
0.03368334472179413,
-0.05058211833238602,
0.023846525698900223,
-0.016457127407193184,
0.022322842851281166,
0.0413781963288784,
-0.021961895748972893,
0.01712876558303833,
0.020334234461188316,
-0.006634989753365517,
-0.004954850301146507,
-0.02976185455918312,
-0.0020166991744190454,
-0.06690070778131485,
-0.07667864859104156,
0.019440289586782455,
-0.026413172483444214,
0.062285713851451874,
0.007786245085299015,
0.00845266692340374,
0.06302668154239655,
0.0000425722319050692,
-0.13247203826904297,
-0.0008686732035130262,
0.019566066563129425,
0.004759575240314007,
0.012562003917992115,
0.012878776527941227,
-0.0042534274980425835,
-0.03005681186914444,
-0.029025306925177574,
0.0048474641516804695,
0.02431417815387249,
-0.032804250717163086,
0.0042437403462827206,
-0.0183881726115942,
-0.03409343957901001,
-0.03590843826532364,
0.03244716301560402,
0.006691368762403727,
0.02473703771829605,
-0.05537796393036842,
0.015122933313250542,
0.027714893221855164,
0.008916553109884262,
-0.01670377515256405,
0.00628314446657896,
-0.03819555789232254,
0.024547550827264786,
0.0310166347771883,
-0.044139500707387924,
-0.011072058230638504,
-0.0013481959467753768,
-0.020537368953227997,
-0.005288969725370407,
0.06645956635475159,
-0.02164331078529358,
-0.029992546886205673,
0.06522765755653381,
-0.03234275057911873,
-0.003179890802130103,
0.002279154025018215,
-0.001982008572667837,
0.026408011093735695,
-0.036035455763339996,
-0.01506487000733614,
0.025368748232722282,
-0.10505332797765732,
-0.04463450238108635,
0.019059693440794945,
-0.011245720088481903,
-0.006878519430756569,
0.0026631527580320835,
-0.009730135090649128,
-0.00477214390411973,
0.008591307327151299,
-0.0028015889693051577,
-0.018000738695263863,
0.00393338967114687,
0.03889879584312439,
-0.03286904841661453,
0.027164457365870476,
-0.006427373271435499,
-0.02425881288945675,
0.025224415585398674,
0.012828303501009941,
-0.02601088210940361,
0.0012240912765264511,
-0.020425323396921158,
0.017945177853107452,
0.027509501203894615,
0.0029174580704420805,
-0.0382208488881588,
-0.042405739426612854,
0.027119452133774757,
-0.006159847602248192,
-0.004343531094491482,
0.021761290729045868,
-0.034998778253793716,
-0.05070491507649422,
0.00810872483998537,
-0.04960086569190025,
-0.002022468252107501,
0.0803920179605484,
0.01730179972946644,
0.014013200998306274,
-0.011074932292103767,
-0.013634711503982544,
0.029229115694761276,
0.039614398032426834,
0.016557304188609123,
0.20474541187286377,
-0.02522183023393154,
-0.034444987773895264,
0.013113854452967644,
0.005882067605853081,
0.011004364117980003,
-0.00656408304348588,
-0.03741941973567009,
0.017482666298747063,
-0.03335077315568924,
-0.008040281012654305,
-0.001967156073078513,
0.047108471393585205,
0.005410190671682358,
-0.022623948752880096,
-0.008645627647638321,
-0.02984185330569744,
-0.08339713513851166,
0.05498308315873146,
-0.02398863434791565,
0.03558018058538437,
0.05268283933401108,
-0.015289380215108395,
-0.02755359560251236,
-0.05393447354435921,
-0.052386973053216934,
-0.005119762383401394,
-0.006542224902659655,
0.012437602505087852,
-0.028103185817599297,
-0.038063034415245056,
-0.0006066004280000925,
0.01179357897490263,
0.048456914722919464,
-0.02462150901556015,
0.024757858365774155,
-0.0504230298101902,
-0.010764140635728836,
0.04216109216213226,
-0.027342183515429497,
-0.020681051537394524,
-0.008511790074408054,
-0.010299674235284328,
-0.05706119164824486,
-0.01965504139661789,
-0.027279438450932503,
-0.0029406410176306963,
0.00192893180064857,
-0.07630184292793274,
0.06588166952133179,
-0.008373367600142956,
0.05710319057106972,
-0.05332612246274948,
-0.006984278559684753,
0.015060889534652233,
0.00870460644364357,
0.011337503790855408,
0.02986578457057476,
-0.009301184676587582,
-0.02224413864314556,
0.01846691407263279,
-0.00211404450237751,
-0.012243776582181454,
-0.0047440058551728725,
0.0018273426685482264,
0.007319919764995575,
-0.01908254064619541,
0.009070494212210178,
-0.019468508660793304,
0.011830668896436691,
0.0024558824952691793,
-0.02365422435104847,
-0.02797834202647209,
0.03885262459516525,
0.02144821546971798,
0.03245958313345909,
-0.015486790798604488,
0.0636240690946579,
-0.007388812955468893,
0.023900048807263374,
-0.005563453771173954,
-0.02066490799188614,
-0.01733778975903988,
-0.030344778671860695,
0.0059828623197972775,
-0.059523969888687134,
-0.013242692686617374,
0.016843894496560097,
0.03235240280628204,
-0.006151657551527023,
-0.019384590908885002,
0.007943428121507168,
0.03229644149541855,
-0.011877119541168213,
-0.06106850132346153,
-0.045220520347356796,
0.05953248590230942,
0.023412594571709633,
-0.003499796846881509,
-0.029612012207508087,
-0.0443386435508728,
0.0012281585950404406,
0.0036613959819078445,
-0.0017021632520481944,
0.014256471768021584,
-0.01900048926472664,
-0.04858423396945,
0.01546921394765377,
0.004097272641956806,
-0.028445299714803696,
0.01669907569885254,
0.003313009859994054,
0.03283875063061714,
0.014407048933207989,
0.010413739830255508,
-0.009559620171785355,
-0.02060536853969097,
0.0589011088013649,
-0.04591134935617447,
0.03336269408464432,
-0.04524562880396843,
0.0035199346020817757,
0.005777411162853241,
0.0018252157606184483,
-0.0539436973631382,
-0.022736309096217155,
-0.0761130079627037,
-0.07742489874362946,
-0.06736384332180023,
-0.0021801083348691463,
-0.025966694578528404,
0.017920320853590965,
-0.040535133332014084,
0.03234052285552025,
0.07725316286087036,
-0.016394291073083878,
-0.009015805087983608,
0.012580391950905323,
-0.011064755730330944,
0.017519421875476837,
-0.03502695634961128,
-0.010763691738247871,
-0.06180734559893608,
-0.04858733341097832,
-0.01134862843900919,
-0.050717733800411224,
-0.06218932941555977,
0.003337093163281679,
-0.05643441528081894,
-0.00012287784193176776,
-0.008583450689911842,
0.026768842712044716,
-0.024854479357600212,
0.02251294255256653,
0.04158177971839905,
0.025298863649368286,
-0.004798918031156063,
-0.001198473502881825,
-0.0282448623329401,
-0.014627572149038315,
0.031137406826019287,
0.027574138715863228,
0.011838715523481369,
0.0458151251077652,
0.011992874555289745,
0.014601564034819603,
0.010102706030011177,
0.0374116525053978,
0.053863413631916046,
0.004685261286795139,
0.01810225285589695,
0.024986300617456436,
-0.004326147027313709,
0.053827229887247086,
0.051640480756759644,
0.010677766986191273,
-0.028277063742280006,
0.023678559809923172,
-0.033547136932611465,
0.027419306337833405,
0.0021258494816720486,
0.029895247891545296,
-0.0013074787566438317,
0.003924715798348188,
-0.05047764629125595,
-0.02393391914665699,
0.02173108421266079,
-0.009316331706941128,
-0.047817572951316833,
-0.0033640749752521515,
-0.01684306189417839,
0.08774946630001068,
-0.03315170481801033,
-0.002540535293519497,
-0.009276073426008224,
0.0027727563865482807,
0.012749913148581982,
0.008540360257029533,
0.02150747925043106,
-0.007526827976107597,
-0.051300179213285446,
-0.012493676505982876,
0.0029566646553575993,
0.013365850783884525,
0.011679570190608501,
0.03425215929746628,
-0.10600975900888443,
0.0198797807097435,
0.002637580968439579,
-0.024871444329619408,
0.025038480758666992,
-0.009653382003307343,
-0.008298898115754128,
-0.020398877561092377,
0.017928896471858025,
0.016408685594797134,
0.024745821952819824,
0.06526486575603485,
-0.00462733581662178,
-0.02390601858496666,
-0.02345578558743,
0.0032327743247151375,
-0.002916005440056324,
-0.03452964127063751,
-0.05724901333451271,
0.022219887003302574,
-0.010617988184094429,
-0.05602299049496651,
0.04606768861413002,
0.01656688004732132,
0.00893261656165123,
-0.019555525854229927,
-0.041228506714105606,
-0.014580613933503628,
0.02651507779955864,
0.023102514445781708,
0.029908714815974236,
0.02601657435297966,
0.028570378199219704,
-0.012263595126569271,
0.019258012995123863,
-0.07087519019842148,
-0.014400217682123184,
0.04710698872804642,
0.008544505573809147,
-0.08353673666715622,
0.011574882082641125,
-0.05011019855737686,
-0.03108230233192444,
0.051502835005521774,
0.0431402288377285,
0.033095043152570724,
0.013556886464357376,
-0.032023992389440536,
-0.019844355061650276,
-0.02015797793865204,
0.0024853390641510487,
-0.025378447026014328,
-0.029139278456568718,
-0.03984883055090904,
-0.022412486374378204,
-0.0017096939263865352,
0.003149043070152402,
-0.031725309789180756,
-0.03709455579519272,
-0.014228050597012043,
0.006249632220715284,
0.01722799241542816,
-0.03503065183758736,
-0.05771268159151077,
-0.014070714823901653,
0.0032164345029741526,
-0.057929858565330505,
-0.047349438071250916,
0.002212187275290489,
0.02422923594713211,
-0.011508950032293797,
0.0005342444637790322,
-0.008013278245925903,
-0.011760695837438107,
0.03701458126306534,
0.0017548393225297332,
-0.0046196598559618,
0.02977863699197769,
0.016901543363928795,
0.045430105179548264,
0.02394157275557518,
-0.010749860666692257,
0.010216325521469116,
0.017671700567007065,
0.06706201285123825,
0.010608554817736149,
0.03527311235666275,
0.01170793455094099,
-0.037002336233854294,
0.015787184238433838,
0.004281966481357813,
-0.0004064419190399349,
-0.06224752590060234,
0.015693509951233864,
-0.025361698120832443,
0.03260486572980881,
-0.05676841363310814,
0.00857132114470005,
-0.0015135741559788585,
0.009303904138505459,
0.009666209109127522,
-0.06978973001241684,
0.009547448717057705,
0.004255129490047693,
0.000519059831276536,
-0.029956916347146034,
0.014713790267705917,
0.017484040930867195,
-0.002437717979773879,
0.0014704802306368947,
-0.005951414816081524,
0.013901995494961739,
-0.025050567463040352,
0.01416709553450346,
0.03821905329823494,
0.05135146901011467,
-0.014921225607395172,
-0.041773002594709396,
-0.060648322105407715,
0.00987323373556137,
-0.011493715457618237,
0.044270001351833344,
-0.007593379821628332,
-0.0010048500262200832,
-0.007748874370008707,
0.0054257591255009174,
-0.03658004850149155,
0.03565049543976784,
0.056500326842069626,
-0.02955794334411621,
-0.012515504844486713,
-0.0019243364222347736,
0.05730922892689705,
-0.03887561708688736,
0.0460476353764534,
-0.004354824312031269,
0.03542419523000717,
-0.006167330779135227,
0.03345600515604019,
-0.0023823417723178864,
-0.055412597954273224,
-0.0002998250420205295,
0.05110609531402588,
0.027203133329749107,
-0.017462624236941338,
0.043279413133859634,
0.038585830479860306,
-0.041215479373931885,
0.003723092842847109,
0.014975452795624733,
0.0012200959026813507,
-0.029950885102152824,
0.0042107985354959965,
0.0018319073133170605,
0.025962989777326584,
-0.002066202461719513,
-0.016614269465208054,
-0.033788569271564484,
0.004852990619838238,
0.0193388219922781,
-0.004874417558312416,
-0.0245804600417614,
0.030089624226093292,
0.002673221519216895,
-0.002721179276704788,
-0.02315509505569935,
-0.006257618777453899,
0.013783611357212067,
-0.022887125611305237,
0.02197512798011303,
0.02958819456398487,
-0.0034428176004439592,
0.05259794369339943,
-0.024952877312898636,
-0.006158786825835705,
-0.027634795755147934,
-0.021090781316161156,
0.0008983972948044538,
0.025720054283738136,
-0.08280761539936066,
-0.02757900394499302,
0.02199748158454895,
0.0002482547424733639,
0.012977113015949726,
-0.011050018481910229,
0.02085849456489086,
-0.03512447699904442,
-0.015181229449808598,
-0.1098875179886818,
0.026268547400832176,
0.03419727087020874,
-0.008241318166255951,
-0.0591902956366539,
-0.010711201466619968,
-0.004412687383592129,
-0.021823130548000336,
-0.0068038515746593475,
0.002070997143164277,
0.02852408029139042,
-0.010708818212151527,
-0.022655732929706573,
0.00037329987389966846,
0.007557659409940243,
0.05079780891537666,
-0.022804386913776398,
-0.008620033040642738,
-0.03181176260113716,
-0.0011498930398374796,
-0.010268296115100384,
0.006331554614007473,
-0.023342875763773918,
-0.017528511583805084,
-0.034480877220630646,
-0.009838737547397614,
-0.026600930839776993,
-0.009513475932180882,
-0.017036475241184235,
-0.04134184867143631,
-0.012282786890864372,
-0.024447448551654816,
0.031514186412096024,
0.07508403807878494,
0.01116279698908329,
-0.007356885354965925,
0.0003827048058155924,
0.019419608637690544,
0.0006940613966435194,
-0.05569164827466011,
-0.01853928342461586,
0.016657225787639618,
-0.04649326205253601,
-0.02524525113403797,
-0.018974842503666878,
0.026432720944285393,
-0.02944553643465042,
0.0362742654979229,
-0.010814953595399857,
-0.03590233251452446,
-0.013227186165750027,
0.013053033500909805,
0.0128457210958004,
0.06157037243247032,
0.011609900742769241,
0.037224117666482925,
-0.04193932190537453,
-0.005173086654394865,
0.02369244024157524,
0.05144372209906578,
0.018592122942209244,
0.016024086624383926,
-0.015002885833382607,
-0.008678273297846317,
-0.009039908647537231,
-0.012901391834020615,
-0.024026911705732346,
0.004260607063770294,
0.03735385462641716,
-0.022354958578944206,
-0.04094988852739334,
-0.025459231808781624,
-0.0019389097578823566,
0.032509997487068176,
0.0020244992338120937,
-0.04376242682337761,
0.01838344894349575,
-0.014833536930382252,
0.03707331046462059,
0.01176824327558279,
-0.036151353269815445,
0.002628598129376769,
-0.05504043772816658,
0.016664551571011543,
0.014073170721530914,
0.03228560462594032,
0.0005517441895790398,
-0.03720058128237724,
0.001161235268227756,
-0.06107804924249649,
0.004646191373467445,
0.010512410663068295,
0.0003058803849853575,
0.004455399699509144,
0.01226005144417286,
0.02800443209707737,
-0.013865478336811066,
-0.01979745924472809,
-0.03460013493895531,
-0.006461027543991804,
-0.03866131231188774,
-0.015523373149335384,
-0.0018792280461639166,
0.008844978176057339,
-0.013625901192426682,
0.02854127623140812,
0.04025217145681381,
0.00014655140694230795,
-0.017527328804135323,
-0.017117058858275414,
0.0037338905967772007,
-0.03235172480344772,
-0.03301579877734184,
-0.02304825559258461,
0.03168390691280365,
0.00624237721785903,
0.0029925371054559946,
-0.031050605699419975,
-0.01976081356406212,
0.05687684938311577,
0.002024624962359667,
0.015307878144085407,
-0.005948804318904877,
-0.046793289482593536,
-0.04850979894399643,
0.032201290130615234,
-0.013429241254925728,
-0.03729245066642761,
-0.003409575205296278,
-0.001689285272732377,
0.014161676168441772,
-0.03639428690075874,
0.013249717652797699,
-0.0042821369133889675,
-0.0038202558644115925,
-0.01688235066831112,
0.01953006349503994,
0.008245098404586315,
-0.0208673607558012,
-0.06645464897155762,
-0.002113977912813425,
0.03579174354672432,
-0.01766207627952099,
-0.013469450175762177,
0.0017259650630876422,
-0.018447861075401306,
0.026582518592476845,
0.034854888916015625,
-0.009782228618860245,
0.026976317167282104,
0.008877621032297611,
0.011180437169969082,
0.010109677910804749,
0.007265872787684202,
0.011334498412907124,
-0.0113011309877038,
0.033704522997140884,
0.049224626272916794,
0.022565212100744247,
-0.05084182694554329,
0.05945347249507904,
-0.048153042793273926,
-0.01316858734935522,
0.0013664765283465385,
0.011792277917265892,
-0.006423131097108126,
0.01044402550905943,
0.02287716045975685,
-0.014003033749759197,
-0.005926812533289194,
-0.002483992837369442,
-0.002546692034229636,
-0.017194325104355812,
0.01830831915140152,
-0.009531504474580288,
-0.017912622541189194,
0.03237239643931389,
-0.014317482709884644,
0.049754977226257324,
-0.01144505850970745,
0.007533559575676918,
-0.0063951327465474606,
0.06961102783679962,
0.014432902447879314,
-0.019400104880332947,
0.0008186810882762074,
0.02127251774072647,
-0.009006484411656857,
-0.08091168850660324,
0.023899560794234276,
-0.019818667322397232,
0.017461590468883514,
0.00203999737277627,
-0.05876618251204491,
0.02909001149237156,
-0.02645455114543438,
0.01879791170358658,
0.024095037952065468,
0.011281423270702362,
0.022321967408061028,
-0.040320076048374176,
-0.02435447834432125,
-0.01375078596174717,
-0.03293253481388092,
-0.002841910347342491,
0.01915716752409935,
0.0012409494956955314,
-0.061327870935201645,
-0.03799750655889511,
0.00530686741694808,
-0.009848502464592457,
-0.02091040462255478,
0.028040701523423195,
0.008095016703009605,
-0.003266888903453946,
0.021150771528482437,
0.05788858234882355,
0.012709802016615868,
0.031067347154021263,
-0.037890199571847916,
0.03040149062871933,
-0.0025178836658596992,
0.004070755559951067,
-0.015427730046212673,
0.05429986119270325,
0.010268726386129856,
-0.008687261492013931,
-0.04253602772951126,
-0.035491567105054855,
-0.015312327072024345,
0.00877362210303545,
-0.013827095739543438,
0.010233200155198574,
0.061374034732580185,
0.026262827217578888,
0.011125247925519943,
0.016967829316854477,
-0.005104243755340576,
0.0370483472943306,
-0.03721236810088158,
0.04494955763220787,
-0.02076895348727703,
-0.019909599795937538,
-0.016461238265037537
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:11
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
At first he stated he could not recall when Mr McMasters was employed but eventually agreed it was at least later than 2005. Apparently Mr McMasters was also injured in his employment. On 1 May 2007 Mr Capper wrote to WorkCover on Levira letterhead setting out his wages for the period 3 July 2006 to 2 April 2007.
Mr Capper agreed that Mr McMasters had been injured using a forklift owned by a bakery while delivering bread. However he denied that Levira was a party to the contract with the bakery company. He claimed that Mr McMaster was undertaking "a job for Megbuy".
Mr Capper agreed that Mr McMasters had worked at 86 Pinnacles Street, Broken Hill while employed by Levira. Mr Capper denied that Mr McMasters ever used the forklift the subject of the proceedings or that he used the truck registered to Levira. Mr Capper maintained that this truck was also used in the business of Megbuy.
48There was tendered a Deed of Company Arrangement which had been signed by each of Levira, Megbuy and two other companies of which Mr Capper was the principal (Katam Pty Ltd and Samphire Pty Ltd). It was executed in October 2005. It recorded the appointment of an administrator to all of the companies on or about 9 September 2005.
Mr Capper denied that all of these companies were trading up to the date the Deed of Company Arrangement was signed. It was suggested to Mr Capper that the Deed was the result of the issue of a statutory demand by the Australian Taxation Office. Mr Capper queried with the questioner when this occurred. He was asked, and answered as follows:
"Q: That [the statutory demand] was the start of the trouble?
A: The trouble had started before 2005."
49Three further matters should be noted about the evidence given by Mr Capper concerning the ownership of the vehicle.
50First, the forklift was kept at 86 Pinnacles Street Broken Hill from at least the point in time that Mr Capper said Megbuy assumed the conduct of Levira's business. Mr Capper explained that this property was owned by him and his wife and that there were no lease arrangements between them and any of the four companies that I have referred to above.
51Second, insofar as various costs and expenses associated with the businesses were paid for, Mr Capper explained that they were all paid out of one common bank account and then dispersed to meet those expenses.
I infer that this included the payment of the green slip for the forklift truck. Mr Capper could not recall the entity that owned this bank account. The effect of his evidence was that this expense was ultimately borne by Megbuy.
52Third, although Mr Capper accepted that Mr McMasters continued to drive a truck owned by Levira, he did not accept that any employee of Levira after 2006 ever drove the forklift. He maintained that it was driven and maintained by employees of Megbuy.
53Mr Capper's certainty as to the lack of activity involving Levira from 2005 was clearly undermined by the material shown to him concerning Mr McMasters. Further, his record keeping for all the companies appear to have been generally shambolic so that an assessment of the steps taken with these companies is largely dependent upon his imperfect recollection.
While I have significant misgivings about his evidence on the state of repair of the forklift (see [95]), I nevertheless accept the thrust of his evidence that, at some time prior to 2005, Levira had substantially ceased trading activity and the business of Robertson Carriers was assumed and conducted by Megbuy.
There was no apparent reason for Mr Capper to seek to overstate the role of Megbuy and understate that of Levira in his evidence. I formed the impression that he had adopted a simple "strategy" to conduct his businesses via Megbuy and not via Levira because of some difficulty with the ATO (which was not developed in the evidence).
|
[
0.022153720259666443,
-0.027683604508638382,
-0.012908169068396091,
0.0062705702148377895,
-0.0027433615177869797,
0.013969061896204948,
0.0011536255478858948,
0.06764306128025055,
0.0016483727376908064,
0.009959951043128967,
0.01254663523286581,
0.025874102488160133,
-0.0047948164865374565,
-0.013563076965510845,
-0.02435801550745964,
-0.04106149449944496,
0.05472628399729729,
0.005610641557723284,
-0.030990634113550186,
-0.042159225791692734,
0.026063835248351097,
-0.04438850283622742,
0.07002894580364227,
0.048650700598955154,
0.013565403409302235,
0.017431320622563362,
-0.011463167145848274,
-0.009935269132256508,
-0.008162016980350018,
-0.016988877207040787,
-0.023640505969524384,
-0.027941791340708733,
0.007030942011624575,
0.002896979684010148,
0.011517565697431564,
-0.05417367070913315,
0.03304110839962959,
0.004055181052535772,
-0.0230795219540596,
0.01476889569312334,
0.001873549772426486,
0.014339224435389042,
-0.0046906620264053345,
-0.01821761578321457,
0.004823677707463503,
-0.013679842464625835,
-0.026050539687275887,
-0.023518342524766922,
-0.0013384375488385558,
-0.023131899535655975,
-0.05118827894330025,
-0.00032549354364164174,
0.06563165783882141,
-0.03668723255395889,
-0.012176796793937683,
0.003891488304361701,
-0.005285716149955988,
-0.011709965765476227,
-0.04292239621281624,
0.017416197806596756,
-0.0006569903343915939,
-0.00033031561179086566,
-0.006667907815426588,
-0.023279843851923943,
0.005725555587559938,
0.08776596933603287,
-0.022286003455519676,
-0.03702883422374725,
-0.012711450457572937,
-0.07237795740365982,
-0.005463838577270508,
-0.007885619066655636,
0.024303916841745377,
0.007640163414180279,
-0.05733214691281319,
0.005764537025243044,
0.016249464824795723,
0.013114608824253082,
-0.0027035323437303305,
0.009225713089108467,
0.03913050889968872,
0.008994936011731625,
-0.0062051210552453995,
0.02750004641711712,
0.011425456963479519,
-0.008149339817464352,
-0.05433104932308197,
-0.0009383636061102152,
-0.02690640278160572,
0.03724195435643196,
0.018887296319007874,
-0.015668241307139397,
-0.04345356673002243,
-0.01727525144815445,
-0.005751974880695343,
0.0037803759332746267,
-0.029492860659956932,
0.024171629920601845,
0.060194846242666245,
0.011686134152114391,
0.01787281036376953,
0.04024019092321396,
0.012737109325826168,
-0.04884357750415802,
0.010717002674937248,
-0.016872107982635498,
0.003391934558749199,
0.043162938207387924,
0.03169571980834007,
-0.013535174541175365,
0.04368803650140762,
-0.02259320765733719,
-0.030042700469493866,
0.023263834416866302,
0.004181134048849344,
0.0075952522456645966,
0.021442681550979614,
-0.053674034774303436,
0.0390646755695343,
-0.0022808725479990244,
0.05428415536880493,
0.049582112580537796,
0.07757361978292465,
-0.04579728841781616,
-0.09191282093524933,
0.014239332638680935,
0.020425867289304733,
-0.026949962601065636,
-0.021075885742902756,
0.042132582515478134,
-0.009857256896793842,
0.008302988484501839,
-0.02937220223248005,
-0.06648772209882736,
-0.02511177584528923,
-0.026331817731261253,
0.01761382631957531,
-0.02489728480577469,
-0.013007842935621738,
-0.0364958792924881,
0.036208029836416245,
0.05479614436626434,
-0.040710385888814926,
-0.028729641810059547,
0.021151110529899597,
-0.01471064891666174,
0.002883609151467681,
0.006652875803411007,
0.013952817767858505,
-0.0248569343239069,
-0.016501637175679207,
0.00914982333779335,
0.006328510120511055,
-0.026237115263938904,
0.03421566262841225,
-0.0289224274456501,
0.003416621359065175,
-0.020665902644395828,
0.010476452298462391,
0.02616630308330059,
0.06078723445534706,
0.07024623453617096,
-0.01889021508395672,
-0.022627083584666252,
0.01182567048817873,
-0.0019175404449924827,
-0.013662241399288177,
0.03777947649359703,
-0.011188575997948647,
0.014068000949919224,
0.017571041360497475,
-0.022537685930728912,
0.05061976984143257,
-0.006089319474995136,
0.010468453168869019,
0.038450099527835846,
0.10669956356287003,
0.004476564936339855,
0.017072254791855812,
-0.07585833221673965,
-0.04365195706486702,
-0.0005001846584491432,
0.008495481684803963,
-0.01710527390241623,
-0.038401711732149124,
-0.00619225949048996,
0.003739745821803808,
-0.05273069441318512,
0.023659206926822662,
0.026561621576547623,
-0.023984374478459358,
-0.019210604950785637,
0.018634332343935966,
-0.022456498816609383,
0.014208756387233734,
-0.012884316965937614,
0.011860566213726997,
0.019741984084248543,
0.01869778521358967,
-0.038825873285532,
-0.013326776213943958,
0.04700146242976189,
0.0715826079249382,
-0.001978027168661356,
-0.039675261825323105,
0.0287344828248024,
-0.016759270802140236,
0.02307032234966755,
-0.006365825422108173,
-0.09018608182668686,
0.001926718046888709,
-0.01925233006477356,
0.0019467348465695977,
0.04578316584229469,
0.017710568383336067,
-0.04321878030896187,
0.012014089152216911,
-0.003895837115123868,
0.040641218423843384,
-0.023310137912631035,
-0.005076675675809383,
0.008888454176485538,
-0.016564125195145607,
0.0002538530679885298,
0.00304385251365602,
0.002427126979455352,
-0.01730252243578434,
0.055035438388586044,
-0.004069569054991007,
-0.05038017779588699,
0.042818304151296616,
0.00029417555197142065,
-0.019355297088623047,
-0.00934728141874075,
0.029671963304281235,
0.006027281749993563,
0.05067921429872513,
0.02531011588871479,
0.02434465102851391,
0.014514826238155365,
0.010812516324222088,
-0.01949676312506199,
0.0010778597788885236,
-0.02062196657061577,
0.018663302063941956,
0.007248547859489918,
0.025407442823052406,
0.024646757170557976,
0.01128288172185421,
0.02349204383790493,
0.018562626093626022,
-0.020860355347394943,
-0.009542428888380527,
0.005499367136508226,
-0.020265672355890274,
0.03145381063222885,
-0.023294435814023018,
-0.0005715888109989464,
0.03211401402950287,
-0.003307262435555458,
0.0005124323652125895,
0.010578812099993229,
-0.0010860356269404292,
-0.006437843665480614,
-0.04181511327624321,
0.0044442336075007915,
-0.03582831472158432,
-0.06227685138583183,
-0.029654091224074364,
0.047185126692056656,
-0.0018874190282076597,
-0.026105379685759544,
0.004923099651932716,
0.003933230880647898,
0.028247233480215073,
0.03563357889652252,
0.01607167348265648,
-0.006196060683578253,
0.03207027167081833,
0.019696518778800964,
0.04842621088027954,
0.0018763185944408178,
0.05401022359728813,
-0.031799424439668655,
0.02785453200340271,
-0.0018550121458247304,
-0.006441232282668352,
-0.031368330121040344,
-0.015433251857757568,
-0.039479341357946396,
0.017150413244962692,
0.02041276916861534,
0.05710861086845398,
0.00317830010317266,
-0.046692267060279846,
-0.0020737089216709137,
0.035198111087083817,
-0.1577056348323822,
-0.03160914406180382,
-0.02908986434340477,
0.002693697577342391,
-0.006626690737903118,
0.0024617931339889765,
-0.0028215935453772545,
-0.006889447569847107,
-0.054657626897096634,
0.01527139637619257,
0.011990121565759182,
-0.03975063934922218,
-0.024440238252282143,
-0.0018775739008560777,
-0.008867708034813404,
-0.03666737675666809,
0.0039049366023391485,
-0.00807651411741972,
0.02017691172659397,
-0.03826458752155304,
-0.0005078843096271157,
-0.013999649323523045,
0.024086518213152885,
-0.015397832728922367,
0.01451435312628746,
-0.004649383947253227,
0.024822169914841652,
-0.010267413221299648,
-0.05403671786189079,
-0.007222466636449099,
0.024287564679980278,
0.02280454896390438,
-0.0023435535840690136,
0.020225750282406807,
-0.001359944581054151,
0.04850483313202858,
0.05487198382616043,
-0.06107494235038757,
-0.013296843506395817,
0.008329909294843674,
-0.00213524978607893,
0.10066103935241699,
-0.0031520952470600605,
-0.0003067399375140667,
0.018815714865922928,
-0.05900343880057335,
0.007701789494603872,
-0.005561125930398703,
-0.04991840943694115,
-0.00530500803142786,
-0.00235538138076663,
-0.005061289295554161,
-0.03512891009449959,
-0.003258493496105075,
-0.004564864095300436,
-0.026532504707574844,
0.029778825119137764,
0.027928758412599564,
-0.0441567562520504,
0.03571230545639992,
0.007866909727454185,
-0.07108622044324875,
0.03929861634969711,
0.030210012570023537,
-0.03175486624240875,
0.04123272746801376,
-0.026463817805051804,
0.0025803635362535715,
0.01072588749229908,
-0.00338691845536232,
-0.003229564055800438,
-0.05246170982718468,
0.008315123617649078,
0.013370480388402939,
0.025426113978028297,
0.034973349422216415,
-0.017956849187612534,
-0.013745545409619808,
0.010870026424527168,
-0.0865236446261406,
-0.006512160412967205,
0.02149529568850994,
-0.010259817354381084,
0.030415629968047142,
0.003516876371577382,
0.039414890110492706,
-0.0015532136894762516,
0.01618153229355812,
0.0509880967438221,
0.22146710753440857,
-0.019949492067098618,
-0.014700070023536682,
0.003593789879232645,
0.03652244061231613,
0.00200951611623168,
0.031593188643455505,
0.015896940603852272,
0.013406645506620407,
-0.04958091676235199,
0.016291575506329536,
0.006290290504693985,
0.019099777564406395,
0.023522231727838516,
-0.015872154384851456,
-0.04631828889250755,
-0.0019836206920444965,
-0.03746594861149788,
0.08410090953111649,
0.008151068352162838,
0.042092785239219666,
-0.016699712723493576,
0.02532753348350525,
0.0029000903014093637,
-0.08747173845767975,
-0.046674299985170364,
-0.0042718141339719296,
0.03129175677895546,
-0.013501386158168316,
0.05142119899392128,
-0.030045833438634872,
-0.014879497699439526,
0.018756723031401634,
-0.02587272785604,
0.022228512912988663,
0.012987460941076279,
0.0033518262207508087,
-0.0015107323415577412,
0.012623033486306667,
0.06728015840053558,
0.01541991624981165,
-0.014676169492304325,
-0.006348530761897564,
-0.05070275440812111,
-0.04160409793257713,
-0.00037851123488508165,
0.011634946800768375,
0.09045442193746567,
-0.031059041619300842,
0.0021523048635572195,
-0.03117690421640873,
0.005011379718780518,
-0.00918624922633171,
0.015930483117699623,
-0.059089019894599915,
0.004977005068212748,
0.01065638568252325,
0.004918431397527456,
0.00775537732988596,
0.05483010411262512,
0.018950514495372772,
0.022682085633277893,
0.00800255499780178,
0.04357779398560524,
-0.03347265347838402,
-0.01898658648133278,
-0.03691866248846054,
0.0004975578631274402,
0.03193826228380203,
-0.02612895332276821,
0.0017803027294576168,
0.036525528877973557,
0.04655403271317482,
-0.007024848368018866,
0.04774843156337738,
0.005591819994151592,
0.01659415476024151,
0.06663060933351517,
0.009270548820495605,
0.02107367478311062,
-0.031345389783382416,
0.03075682371854782,
-0.004764516372233629,
0.04319210723042488,
0.008346646092832088,
-0.014031478203833103,
-0.0325244665145874,
0.0673365369439125,
0.023350374773144722,
-0.02032439038157463,
-0.02767021209001541,
-0.021406954154372215,
0.00405552051961422,
-0.010314893908798695,
-0.02147698402404785,
-0.017513494938611984,
0.0100499726831913,
-0.025619754567742348,
0.010514943860471249,
-0.03721172362565994,
-0.019273750483989716,
0.019716333597898483,
-0.020591730251908302,
0.0059952205047011375,
-0.0036407806910574436,
-0.028300296515226364,
0.010005968622863293,
0.019886573776602745,
-0.061246633529663086,
0.010335145518183708,
0.05014966428279877,
0.013797740451991558,
-0.0641789585351944,
-0.014587962068617344,
0.006422001868486404,
0.03318393975496292,
-0.04007133096456528,
0.03156347572803497,
0.04408245533704758,
0.0400407537817955,
0.0032691145315766335,
-0.03589586913585663,
-0.022507481276988983,
-0.0018239716300740838,
0.009920954704284668,
-0.03448439761996269,
-0.032974760979413986,
-0.05181923881173134,
-0.007765389513224363,
0.02482103928923607,
0.004065216984599829,
-0.025499634444713593,
-0.006486227735877037,
-0.01907397247850895,
0.030906805768609047,
-0.0009344193385913968,
-0.05086885765194893,
0.012775284238159657,
-0.04298897087574005,
0.016706129536032677,
-0.02660262957215309,
-0.0082864323630929,
-0.05269419029355049,
-0.0016559294890612364,
0.02636099047958851,
-0.0029291457030922174,
-0.041586413979530334,
0.0195949524641037,
-0.012190579436719418,
-0.005038342904299498,
0.03771958500146866,
0.025668466463685036,
-0.01859382353723049,
-0.02586991898715496,
-0.003803769825026393,
-0.0004785447963513434,
0.012821140699088573,
0.03250426426529884,
0.036003246903419495,
-0.04319929704070091,
-0.0028411750681698322,
-0.032644424587488174,
0.023811308667063713,
0.0295054093003273,
-0.011959005147218704,
0.06166611239314079,
0.0023162374272942543,
0.06594979763031006,
0.027468739077448845,
0.005719637963920832,
0.004014918580651283,
-0.060556236654520035,
-0.01726165972650051,
0.022623030468821526,
0.04883907362818718,
0.03856382891535759,
-0.033397022634744644,
0.034999482333660126,
-0.009394028224050999,
-0.016366705298423767,
0.007771119941025972,
0.021769199520349503,
-0.061760276556015015,
0.009739232249557972,
-0.020326701924204826,
0.012672965414822102,
0.010940843261778355,
-0.011367416940629482,
0.0022286230232566595,
-0.017503617331385612,
0.01823229342699051,
0.09073562175035477,
0.008806003257632256,
-0.019474633038043976,
-0.008180406875908375,
0.015487811528146267,
-0.0011644649785012007,
-0.00556808989495039,
0.008536562323570251,
-0.05652051046490669,
-0.021778985857963562,
0.021288694813847542,
0.011903098784387112,
-0.00938462931662798,
0.03736488148570061,
-0.0037515670992434025,
-0.006703076884150505,
0.020552324131131172,
-0.01489541307091713,
-0.015544334426522255,
0.04125237092375755,
0.06625456362962723,
-0.005316534545272589,
-0.01137180719524622,
-0.016764353960752487,
0.02639191783964634,
0.039896219968795776,
0.03338053822517395,
-0.006666846107691526,
-0.07829225063323975,
-0.04190842807292938,
-0.016873594373464584,
0.005278917960822582,
-0.026708243414759636,
-0.03591575101017952,
-0.003973611630499363,
-0.00013950893480796367,
-0.009803774766623974,
0.012057578191161156,
-0.015598835423588753,
0.0026050028391182423,
-0.002205244731158018,
0.020875422284007072,
-0.016537340357899666,
0.00823530089110136,
-0.029540834948420525,
0.015651807188987732,
0.007819518446922302,
-0.0028036010917276144,
0.02276189811527729,
0.04639875516295433,
-0.03068791888654232,
-0.012128952890634537,
0.055280912667512894,
-0.01230296678841114,
-0.007943698205053806,
-0.009287822991609573,
0.0008025694405660033,
0.025727974250912666,
0.01686817780137062,
-0.0272985827177763,
0.017113326117396355,
0.0155407739803195,
-0.02491552196443081,
0.007266832981258631,
0.004484404344111681,
0.0025984211824834347,
-0.03028061054646969,
-0.07065194845199585,
-0.03177720680832863,
-0.02836480736732483,
0.05788209289312363,
0.0014896650100126863,
-0.0009409054764546454,
0.003932564053684473,
-0.057853516191244125,
0.033297475427389145,
-0.04345846176147461,
-0.004600171931087971,
-0.03040456399321556,
0.007941457442939281,
0.026867913082242012,
-0.058940157294273376,
-0.05326244607567787,
-0.026682645082473755,
0.014710264280438423,
-0.008856957778334618,
-0.0029307964723557234,
0.0413588285446167,
0.015867944806814194,
0.05586780980229378,
0.010291694663465023,
-0.008993689902126789,
0.03506430238485336,
0.009963667951524258,
0.004901626612991095,
0.002299844054505229,
0.023917892947793007,
0.01757911592721939,
0.01094179879873991,
0.006381583400070667,
0.04519090801477432,
-0.008424222469329834,
0.04904031381011009,
-0.04471404105424881,
-0.006932748015969992,
-0.02142934314906597,
0.08246379345655441,
-0.03876494616270065,
0.005965378135442734,
-0.010530064813792706,
0.014407742768526077,
-0.044314850121736526,
-0.04641544818878174,
-0.02837062068283558,
-0.017351120710372925,
0.019956834614276886,
-0.040894970297813416,
-0.030914798378944397,
-0.00017903096158988774,
0.03397339954972267,
-0.06498485058546066,
-0.015423454344272614,
-0.0005947460886090994,
0.00513254152610898,
0.0019983926322311163,
0.006274037063121796,
0.012866607867181301,
0.0036443285644054413,
0.012981556355953217,
-0.014497721567749977,
0.05360323190689087,
-0.027283983305096626,
-0.0010533813619986176,
-0.08425503969192505,
0.04680022969841957,
-0.012123794294893742,
-0.006924424320459366,
-0.006435165647417307,
-0.013482717797160149,
-0.0269574373960495,
0.005214378237724304,
-0.02605566568672657,
0.017741715535521507,
0.07941530644893646,
-0.005079928785562515,
0.0025128338020294905,
-0.02486344799399376,
0.035167232155799866,
-0.07817631959915161,
-0.035091694444417953,
-0.0507027767598629,
0.023441515862941742,
0.02059381641447544,
0.00254472391679883,
0.009191973134875298,
0.03245257958769798,
0.009684903547167778,
0.03283911198377609,
-0.004950566682964563,
-0.012544986791908741,
0.018887143582105637,
-0.005191785749047995,
-0.05157271400094032,
0.025855913758277893,
0.004828444216400385,
0.01725389063358307,
-0.009760410524904728,
0.0017701230244711041,
0.012310685589909554,
-0.010797389782965183,
0.02822265960276127,
-0.0009895849507302046,
-0.01620340161025524,
-0.014120071195065975,
0.010976321063935757,
-0.001269566360861063,
-0.008050285279750824,
-0.023509083315730095,
-0.0021261030342429876,
0.032878462225198746,
-0.06029528006911278,
0.027104733511805534,
-0.010405639186501503,
-0.00725299259647727,
0.026414798572659492,
0.006796522065997124,
-0.017543578520417213,
0.0007583082187920809,
-0.0003855560498777777,
-0.02573748677968979,
-0.02158430963754654,
0.015292095951735973,
-0.0202778410166502,
0.007745881099253893,
-0.02693895250558853,
-0.013812060467898846,
0.03416835144162178,
-0.016139749437570572,
0.004506281577050686,
0.003623032011091709,
0.038045793771743774,
-0.053458038717508316,
0.02737247385084629,
-0.14125095307826996,
0.014034233056008816,
-0.002214455045759678,
-0.02680533565580845,
-0.05497683212161064,
-0.01576758362352848,
0.009877347387373447,
0.025999007746577263,
-0.025180358439683914,
0.0157445278018713,
0.015878913924098015,
0.014328368939459324,
0.04522679001092911,
-0.016435828059911728,
-0.048287879675626755,
0.03374859318137169,
-0.020348161458969116,
-0.007364210207015276,
-0.03511732071638107,
0.02941148541867733,
0.029808830469846725,
0.002596553647890687,
0.00797652080655098,
-0.006776001304388046,
-0.005478110164403915,
0.05247785896062851,
-0.03379514440894127,
-0.04191989451646805,
-0.04295731708407402,
-0.015650663524866104,
-0.06100650504231453,
-0.03650836646556854,
0.001524771680124104,
0.045606955885887146,
0.012105864472687244,
0.009125233627855778,
0.03569354489445686,
-0.07053561508655548,
-0.04800863191485405,
-0.009906639344990253,
-0.02182924374938011,
0.014480283483862877,
-0.026177627965807915,
-0.0281011164188385,
0.008590392768383026,
-0.014567757956683636,
-0.009797838516533375,
-0.007450887002050877,
-0.0514664463698864,
-0.022638214752078056,
-0.07633921504020691,
0.019713951274752617,
-0.016125328838825226,
0.011162355542182922,
0.036712877452373505,
0.02355245314538479,
-0.04685724899172783,
-0.0425693616271019,
0.008432123810052872,
0.0399688258767128,
-0.017615556716918945,
0.00849832221865654,
-0.04002032428979874,
-0.01430370844900608,
0.04227358475327492,
-0.012702904641628265,
0.023545751348137856,
0.002471218816936016,
0.02827763371169567,
-0.007612368557602167,
0.010395007207989693,
-0.06026216223835945,
0.020989805459976196,
-0.04372379928827286,
-0.02048620581626892,
-0.002063335618004203,
0.010147204622626305,
0.025389673188328743,
-0.00610377686098218,
0.007890408858656883,
-0.01048689242452383,
0.04250068962574005,
-0.045255135744810104,
-0.007517112419009209,
0.08456068485975266,
0.02963259443640709,
-0.031906984746456146,
-0.05056145042181015,
0.04065714403986931,
-0.03167181462049484,
-0.056207966059446335,
0.025822972878813744,
-0.02178775519132614,
-0.0019667043816298246,
-0.0024775685742497444,
0.05991927906870842,
0.0068201026879251,
-0.0061651780270040035,
-0.04161718487739563,
0.002965001156553626,
-0.01341389212757349,
-0.05311663821339607,
-0.010276921093463898,
-0.006278578191995621,
-0.002340593608096242,
0.009427644312381744,
0.01958780735731125,
-0.01652122475206852,
-0.007551145739853382,
0.00817885808646679,
-0.01110051665455103,
-0.010963179171085358,
-0.02714780904352665,
-0.0361047089099884,
-0.05264604464173317,
-0.014828411862254143,
0.01315414160490036,
-0.012356368824839592,
-0.03809265047311783,
0.01672344096004963,
0.0340876504778862,
-0.013710982166230679,
-0.004599043633788824,
-0.018270457163453102,
0.010265731252729893,
0.021883884444832802,
0.0449654757976532,
-0.03436661511659622,
-0.002274085534736514,
-0.018570108339190483,
0.05140160396695137,
-0.005524065811187029,
-0.003942531067878008,
-0.004170552361756563,
-0.03383573517203331,
0.023674778640270233,
0.0007455985178239644,
0.02297913283109665,
-0.019303595647215843,
-0.02996598370373249,
-0.030820567160844803,
0.002843716414645314,
-0.022205470129847527,
-0.01652565971016884,
-0.011105746030807495,
-0.01061245333403349,
0.006198015995323658,
0.004235123284161091,
-0.020897697657346725,
-0.023174770176410675,
-0.035818587988615036,
0.0016575310146436095,
-0.010783365927636623,
0.05117694288492203,
0.02902883291244507,
0.009377880021929741,
0.03236592188477516,
-0.009693080559372902,
0.01205619890242815,
0.01697366125881672,
0.03851863741874695,
-0.03339521214365959,
-0.0016984285321086645,
-0.019927483052015305,
-0.01249637734144926,
0.051878422498703,
-0.007880563847720623,
0.015535294078290462,
0.013162050396203995,
-0.003509789239615202,
-0.010075739584863186,
0.02931572124361992,
-0.009777012281119823,
-0.02271370030939579,
0.01913372054696083,
-0.03632422909140587,
-0.012313472107052803,
-0.025035163387656212,
0.02265648916363716,
-0.01998632214963436,
0.06509015709161758,
0.0308475811034441,
-0.0031815501861274242,
-0.01793803460896015,
0.041064538061618805,
0.033705100417137146,
0.01590193249285221,
-0.015316221863031387,
-0.012148496694862843,
-0.016106272116303444,
0.007238747552037239,
0.026083627715706825,
-0.02091503143310547,
-0.0032586511224508286,
0.06100223585963249,
-0.04534590244293213,
-0.03191087767481804,
0.029983695596456528,
-0.013595120050013065,
0.04514366015791893,
0.030399687588214874,
-0.03441005200147629,
-0.05222907289862633,
-0.020359795540571213,
-0.0350397452712059,
0.014769717119634151,
0.038280270993709564,
-0.0632585808634758,
0.001969530014321208,
0.02825012616813183,
-0.012994067743420601,
-0.008551333099603653,
0.0030066820327192545,
0.010924996808171272,
-0.007220406085252762,
-0.03470522165298462,
-0.017425041645765305,
0.016884945333003998,
0.016947166994214058,
0.001665765536017716,
-0.016021613031625748,
0.03666415810585022,
-0.05598289519548416,
-0.03364646062254906,
0.014996924437582493,
0.016363361850380898,
-0.0074341935105621815,
-0.02591359056532383,
0.04577130451798439,
-0.02872614748775959,
-0.033497702330350876,
-0.011895377188920975,
-0.004777670372277498,
0.08814388513565063,
0.005801733583211899,
-0.0026214944664388895,
-0.041315656155347824,
-0.03748852759599686,
-0.022991809993982315,
-0.03944004327058792,
0.05248138681054115,
-0.000443621160229668,
-0.017982224002480507,
0.00448467954993248
] |
What was the relationship between Levira and Megbuy, according to Mr Capper's evidence in QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd v CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd [2012] NSWSC 377?
|
[
-0.026179008185863495,
-0.02862442471086979,
0.00872898194938898,
-0.04199538752436638,
0.005174233112484217,
-0.010295632295310497,
0.003987184725701809,
-0.0027507785707712173,
-0.0032458368223160505,
0.04650837182998657,
0.01697457768023014,
0.026480916887521744,
0.004136424977332354,
-0.004135145805776119,
-0.016235586255788803,
-0.02813160978257656,
-0.0027639316394925117,
-0.010008254088461399,
-0.05477146431803703,
-0.059604354202747345,
0.013038448989391327,
-0.04950090870261192,
-0.03848203271627426,
0.04494393616914749,
0.04442889615893364,
0.008234109729528427,
0.015615470707416534,
0.0052039483562111855,
-0.02998010814189911,
0.0009589148685336113,
-0.030547650530934334,
0.013300186023116112,
0.0016892781713977456,
-0.01723438687622547,
0.033150576055049896,
-0.05845734104514122,
0.03184247389435768,
-0.005959541071206331,
-0.04165941849350929,
-0.015999410301446915,
-0.022674579173326492,
-0.030238566920161247,
0.02012302726507187,
0.0009643023367971182,
0.029775990173220634,
-0.008737171068787575,
-0.01200184877961874,
-0.022146960720419884,
0.0154540054500103,
-0.032227836549282074,
-0.033020831644535065,
0.004480731673538685,
0.049385566264390945,
-0.03399232029914856,
0.0281803160905838,
0.015176666900515556,
0.012340705841779709,
-0.041863154619932175,
-0.03936575725674629,
-0.008912516757845879,
0.001523778890259564,
0.014156126417219639,
0.011780453845858574,
0.015298987738788128,
0.0016083645168691874,
0.07654700428247452,
-0.002448909217491746,
-0.01581711880862713,
-0.013418872840702534,
-0.047162070870399475,
0.022783836349844933,
0.0025947336107492447,
0.01810516230762005,
0.010269438847899437,
-0.05920105427503586,
-0.009157444350421429,
0.017281901091337204,
-0.021239757537841797,
-0.025950035080313683,
0.0036788061261177063,
0.04329116269946098,
0.05872920900583267,
-0.03491754084825516,
0.019332945346832275,
-0.04734627902507782,
-0.016769327223300934,
0.004060614854097366,
-0.03548184782266617,
-0.02694801241159439,
0.018601391464471817,
0.01639747992157936,
-0.011298547498881817,
-0.011902079917490482,
-0.044519003480672836,
-0.004116194322705269,
-0.018569806590676308,
-0.03756912052631378,
0.0201908890157938,
0.05889333039522171,
0.013739785179495811,
-0.016079355031251907,
0.010726163163781166,
0.04972204193472862,
-0.03708785027265549,
0.035631608217954636,
-0.03157665207982063,
0.0021011705975979567,
0.06299728900194168,
-0.022505922242999077,
0.01562897302210331,
-0.0033153167460113764,
0.008847863413393497,
-0.009787673130631447,
-0.01111469604074955,
-0.01702226884663105,
0.0038448793347924948,
-0.02720511518418789,
-0.029757868498563766,
0.010231670923531055,
-0.011404394172132015,
0.043968815356492996,
0.025961710140109062,
0.019667737185955048,
-0.01474329736083746,
-0.046701762825250626,
-0.00783733744174242,
0.05948478356003761,
-0.013774222694337368,
-0.022825293242931366,
-0.0030025658197700977,
-0.03382100537419319,
-0.004276704043149948,
-0.009347916580736637,
-0.07392127066850662,
-0.01286328211426735,
-0.05436860769987106,
0.04922948405146599,
-0.008339963853359222,
-0.03856001794338226,
-0.05592996999621391,
-0.02109329216182232,
0.04082084074616432,
0.017273562029004097,
-0.03708437830209732,
-0.03427441418170929,
-0.02304418757557869,
0.010623821057379246,
-0.007936748676002026,
0.010614902712404728,
0.011599963530898094,
0.01195173617452383,
-0.015051636844873428,
-0.00991183053702116,
0.015422574244439602,
0.05619789659976959,
-0.010381031781435013,
0.009097130037844181,
-0.017174173146486282,
0.03319636732339859,
0.01984287239611149,
0.01754574291408062,
-0.010099461302161217,
0.0028891856782138348,
-0.04204553738236427,
0.04742646589875221,
0.03562391176819801,
0.00037632492603734136,
0.041551362723112106,
-0.002388597931712866,
0.01076729316264391,
-0.01928652636706829,
0.003795322496443987,
0.021471073850989342,
0.00041767480433918536,
0.05313164368271828,
0.022289220243692398,
0.07687350362539291,
0.015224401839077473,
-0.009864090010523796,
-0.05340183153748512,
-0.009471752680838108,
0.02444741129875183,
-0.0004029025149066001,
-0.052233193069696426,
-0.03042045421898365,
-0.01080736517906189,
0.017056260257959366,
-0.06096386909484863,
0.033746350556612015,
0.034154366701841354,
0.007151520345360041,
-0.0024080427829176188,
0.023379389196634293,
-0.05679776147007942,
0.01158197596669197,
0.011933309957385063,
0.0020066937431693077,
0.010124039836227894,
0.04201915115118027,
-0.043564267456531525,
-0.03354182466864586,
0.006484668701887131,
0.0362209789454937,
0.03593183308839798,
-0.015418408438563347,
-0.011637110263109207,
-0.037323810160160065,
0.07341405004262924,
0.008205330930650234,
-0.05471789836883545,
0.0018576676957309246,
0.002556720981374383,
0.04708782956004143,
0.03939984738826752,
-0.04125981405377388,
-0.030099552124738693,
0.013934873975813389,
-0.000020015504560433328,
0.023767780512571335,
0.017249174416065216,
-0.029242848977446556,
0.012297498062252998,
-0.011519824154675007,
0.013971645385026932,
0.0492168590426445,
-0.0135598573833704,
-0.01012551411986351,
0.07846052944660187,
0.010180938988924026,
-0.024302922189235687,
0.04061194881796837,
-0.015240647830069065,
0.006321164313703775,
-0.024284448474645615,
0.008308183401823044,
0.01614120788872242,
0.024065379053354263,
0.059324488043785095,
0.034058667719364166,
-0.01984490640461445,
0.018807649612426758,
-0.013530602678656578,
-0.0009001695434562862,
-0.034678176045417786,
-0.0009341247496195138,
-0.02130044251680374,
0.020006585866212845,
0.034128669649362564,
0.024569235742092133,
0.018357092514634132,
0.02877434529364109,
-0.021236073225736618,
-0.06537821143865585,
-0.025916973128914833,
-0.017443975433707237,
0.013811466284096241,
0.005894697271287441,
-0.005951529368758202,
0.05997253209352493,
-0.0005903610144741833,
0.009376189671456814,
-0.01742013357579708,
0.031523458659648895,
0.0016288189217448235,
-0.007846450433135033,
-0.017545362934470177,
-0.03565487638115883,
-0.018458489328622818,
-0.020580068230628967,
0.024805400520563126,
-0.02146153524518013,
0.0033497000113129616,
0.003223428037017584,
0.012565490789711475,
-0.005547243170440197,
0.03793780133128166,
-0.007201232481747866,
-0.02705635316669941,
-0.006800671108067036,
0.03551667183637619,
0.05392487347126007,
0.024672091007232666,
-0.005497178062796593,
-0.003468159819021821,
-0.007418972905725241,
-0.05001732334494591,
-0.024217789992690086,
-0.03056676872074604,
-0.061290957033634186,
-0.0557095967233181,
0.05968404933810234,
0.030509278178215027,
0.06739252060651779,
0.014453413896262646,
-0.007628548424690962,
0.021779704838991165,
0.007644179742783308,
-0.14631076157093048,
-0.029410528019070625,
-0.009798960760235786,
0.010273967869579792,
-0.021935714408755302,
0.006995477247983217,
-0.033055853098630905,
-0.012281972914934158,
-0.0268170814961195,
-0.014227394014596939,
-0.016281647607684135,
-0.05087880417704582,
-0.02050066739320755,
0.009113061241805553,
-0.03154907748103142,
-0.0003322661214042455,
0.007969976402819157,
-0.009111384861171246,
0.03363484889268875,
-0.017749406397342682,
-0.033454012125730515,
-0.026589324697852135,
0.019378863275051117,
0.012820672243833542,
0.05696723237633705,
-0.019690925255417824,
0.0006398537661880255,
-0.019350169226527214,
-0.018687590956687927,
-0.01510651595890522,
0.004897007718682289,
-0.0016178508521988988,
-0.006097197066992521,
0.007867204025387764,
-0.01811973936855793,
0.03231046348810196,
-0.005332190077751875,
-0.05884336680173874,
0.0005906719597987831,
0.01664874143898487,
0.007325612008571625,
0.09572957456111908,
-0.009056196548044682,
0.021889446303248405,
0.007329563610255718,
-0.023899024352431297,
0.013866466470062733,
-0.01583912968635559,
-0.04129095375537872,
-0.009476848877966404,
-0.007785425987094641,
0.03354139253497124,
-0.01437340397387743,
-0.00562468683347106,
-0.032057419419288635,
-0.0029625697061419487,
0.039395708590745926,
0.09116251766681671,
0.0094033507630229,
0.007123860064893961,
-0.031605761498212814,
-0.01582527719438076,
0.024005226790905,
0.03663574531674385,
-0.05473863333463669,
0.009942008182406425,
0.010930249467492104,
-0.0019297758117318153,
0.02995206229388714,
0.010622524656355381,
-0.0070190466940402985,
0.012969965115189552,
0.02719731815159321,
-0.016872862353920937,
0.03214821591973305,
0.03090604394674301,
-0.0028078975155949593,
-0.02531605213880539,
0.03616902604699135,
-0.04596485197544098,
0.026930173859000206,
0.05019647628068924,
0.018933553248643875,
0.03770102933049202,
-0.0014871996827423573,
0.04411931335926056,
-0.021688690409064293,
0.03986071050167084,
0.063494972884655,
0.16436037421226501,
0.010236471891403198,
-0.002846787916496396,
-0.0013859746977686882,
-0.005429611541330814,
-0.006552409380674362,
0.05091655254364014,
0.0442863367497921,
0.035664454102516174,
-0.02491035871207714,
-0.020712045952677727,
-0.047481924295425415,
0.016199495643377304,
0.017013462260365486,
0.026509832590818405,
-0.00665096752345562,
-0.02100984938442707,
-0.04502575844526291,
0.08744411915540695,
-0.00955907255411148,
0.01547839492559433,
0.019497426226735115,
-0.021724319085478783,
0.02520960383117199,
-0.05883270874619484,
-0.04664447903633118,
0.021101024001836777,
0.02360144816339016,
0.026685116812586784,
0.03163855895400047,
-0.010827632620930672,
0.0023806162644177675,
-0.05299296975135803,
0.005954440217465162,
0.009794282726943493,
-0.008660347200930119,
-0.02087557688355446,
0.011751843616366386,
0.011815662495791912,
0.10412848740816116,
-0.011279311031103134,
-0.029068224132061005,
0.05064467713236809,
-0.00502624548971653,
0.011776572093367577,
-0.04398220777511597,
-0.00785218458622694,
0.040759891271591187,
-0.018820105120539665,
-0.005967306438833475,
-0.07734072953462601,
-0.00091464479919523,
-0.028775468468666077,
0.03726840391755104,
-0.03155259042978287,
0.0014588667545467615,
0.008808969520032406,
0.017501430585980415,
0.0033049434423446655,
0.025643544271588326,
0.03797720745205879,
0.009063860401511192,
0.0013864277862012386,
0.018762126564979553,
-0.021654613316059113,
0.017338082194328308,
-0.04933970794081688,
-0.012499780394136906,
0.035434920340776443,
0.003839308861643076,
0.017440807074308395,
0.06595116853713989,
0.0373903252184391,
0.012077849358320236,
0.05764400213956833,
0.04675750061869621,
0.04164076969027519,
0.030359014868736267,
0.026424413546919823,
0.0010102825472131371,
0.011187558062374592,
0.06142958998680115,
0.004480536095798016,
0.0274795014411211,
0.009272639639675617,
-0.022878725081682205,
-0.02924744226038456,
0.06578710675239563,
0.020133983343839645,
-0.02812121994793415,
-0.016292186453938484,
-0.015584695152938366,
-0.06784123182296753,
-0.008547681383788586,
-0.05846333131194115,
0.027862923219799995,
0.011723469942808151,
-0.001039244350977242,
-0.0095879090949893,
-0.03782300278544426,
-0.049631841480731964,
0.010330402292311192,
-0.0011279600439593196,
0.0008373900782316923,
-0.02470705285668373,
0.000182794698048383,
0.034169577062129974,
-0.03110259212553501,
-0.034961629658937454,
-0.017411919310688972,
0.027436988428235054,
0.009179324842989445,
-0.06475052982568741,
-0.006970908027142286,
0.023999705910682678,
0.014659163542091846,
-0.025079796090722084,
-0.0019108362030237913,
0.04645110294222832,
0.03633035719394684,
0.011884056963026524,
-0.02105407975614071,
-0.027401143684983253,
-0.015320852398872375,
-0.021571315824985504,
-0.017457423731684685,
-0.02699207328259945,
-0.011460177600383759,
-0.019549869000911713,
0.013770080171525478,
-0.01579110138118267,
-0.01041117962449789,
0.0461900494992733,
-0.015191669575870037,
0.009342219680547714,
0.012248772196471691,
-0.014219284057617188,
0.04756995290517807,
-0.027424832805991173,
0.011935935355722904,
-0.006225242279469967,
-0.019971970468759537,
-0.03403386473655701,
0.014891163446009159,
0.03031601756811142,
-0.03998960554599762,
0.0005697993328794837,
0.04415472596883774,
-0.015949176624417305,
-0.03536912798881531,
-0.022593818604946136,
0.03682095557451248,
-0.0468464158475399,
-0.0050777290016412735,
-0.03312118723988533,
0.023413265123963356,
0.024294385686516762,
0.03378850221633911,
0.013358039781451225,
-0.022981766611337662,
0.024465078487992287,
-0.04603918641805649,
0.033320799469947815,
0.046518925577402115,
-0.02858728915452957,
0.05576576665043831,
-0.04051732271909714,
0.042963918298482895,
0.047878433018922806,
0.011584843508899212,
-0.022290904074907303,
0.007493729703128338,
-0.021735837683081627,
0.03983071446418762,
0.06550613045692444,
0.04855090752243996,
-0.00657553831115365,
0.008077885955572128,
-0.013436217792332172,
-0.032269660383462906,
-0.01210890430957079,
0.00897485576570034,
-0.013053075410425663,
0.02382277138531208,
-0.0397375263273716,
0.0590849295258522,
0.0449901707470417,
-0.034929484128952026,
-0.03868015110492706,
0.01867111772298813,
-0.0036722382064908743,
0.06986821442842484,
0.008188646286725998,
-0.017440680414438248,
0.006537833251059055,
0.015085550956428051,
-0.057386890053749084,
0.007070824038237333,
0.014467853121459484,
-0.010466879233717918,
-0.017551889643073082,
0.039515916258096695,
0.03429252654314041,
-0.03542809933423996,
0.024617783725261688,
-0.00790348369628191,
0.011146476492285728,
0.022910352796316147,
-0.023266887292265892,
-0.024278923869132996,
0.0018175903242081404,
0.031409770250320435,
-0.001886946614831686,
-0.009431833401322365,
0.03875872492790222,
0.017298240214586258,
-0.01657204143702984,
0.03141535818576813,
-0.01350204087793827,
-0.07240402698516846,
-0.01646943762898445,
-0.015089450404047966,
0.019032306969165802,
-0.06647282838821411,
-0.005178958177566528,
-0.006767972372472286,
0.006215963512659073,
-0.02034151367843151,
0.037753041833639145,
0.00805314164608717,
0.007462247274816036,
0.00009917710849549621,
-0.03277270495891571,
-0.037634968757629395,
-0.01341921929270029,
0.002137377392500639,
0.016848459839820862,
-0.007118715904653072,
-0.04308971017599106,
0.05391323193907738,
-0.024722162634134293,
0.0021000602282583714,
-0.039312899112701416,
0.07695572078227997,
0.009920094162225723,
-0.024688446894288063,
-0.006478745490312576,
0.027002928778529167,
0.04686391353607178,
-0.015033556148409843,
0.016461562365293503,
0.03103417158126831,
0.012016838416457176,
-0.047144580632448196,
-0.04038959741592407,
-0.0344470851123333,
0.03135383501648903,
-0.010752767324447632,
-0.06385134160518646,
-0.059952229261398315,
-0.016195256263017654,
0.01594674587249756,
-0.00045526347821578383,
-0.05526447668671608,
0.000499376910738647,
-0.017351308837532997,
0.050215594470500946,
-0.0166179109364748,
-0.011841226369142532,
-0.012619167566299438,
0.013045377098023891,
-0.011344503611326218,
-0.08080457150936127,
-0.06088799610733986,
-0.030215643346309662,
0.017573442310094833,
-0.03792353346943855,
0.004456851631402969,
0.06159045919775963,
0.036992382258176804,
0.0652509555220604,
0.046596236526966095,
-0.03182622790336609,
0.018304290249943733,
0.024570036679506302,
0.013991440646350384,
0.02060433104634285,
0.03976942226290703,
-0.0020706115756183863,
0.001151739852502942,
0.017715975642204285,
0.025737615302205086,
-0.009801331907510757,
0.014492246322333813,
-0.025976262986660004,
0.0026491188909858465,
0.011219831183552742,
0.09364289790391922,
-0.05209551006555557,
0.007988618686795235,
-0.010972214862704277,
0.039041027426719666,
-0.018815936520695686,
-0.04056612774729729,
-0.043879106640815735,
-0.0068305921740829945,
-0.006244838237762451,
-0.047662314027547836,
0.01244454737752676,
0.0160662978887558,
0.010789984837174416,
-0.009823402389883995,
-0.015118065290153027,
-0.02739349752664566,
-0.06424704194068909,
0.003753481898456812,
-0.013354869559407234,
0.022452853620052338,
0.021697189658880234,
-0.04707643389701843,
-8.075106734395376e-7,
0.05420195311307907,
-0.017699090763926506,
0.017465248703956604,
-0.05300081893801689,
0.00987059623003006,
0.04344411939382553,
-0.0008091629133559763,
-0.019119305536150932,
0.029462095350027084,
-0.016275981441140175,
-0.02294720895588398,
-0.03710966557264328,
0.005592353641986847,
0.02762436494231224,
0.030929679051041603,
-0.03592277690768242,
-0.005664234049618244,
0.030124090611934662,
0.0015619491459801793,
-0.03055504895746708,
-0.031023066490888596,
0.011600768193602562,
-0.016883185133337975,
0.0019693844951689243,
0.006788347382098436,
0.011419197544455528,
0.03363446891307831,
-0.00009807105379877612,
-0.011261659674346447,
0.012904894538223743,
0.04714549705386162,
0.01768476888537407,
-0.06591466069221497,
-0.002434938447549939,
0.011850026436150074,
-0.023349661380052567,
-0.003713502548635006,
-0.002756864298135042,
0.019314207136631012,
0.014273998327553272,
0.008027798496186733,
-0.052759941667318344,
-0.003165797097608447,
0.0338248535990715,
0.014831357635557652,
-0.019672511145472527,
0.027019120752811432,
-0.047180019319057465,
-0.042145632207393646,
0.018049126490950584,
-0.023369764909148216,
0.005642333999276161,
-0.010392018593847752,
-0.04425789788365364,
-0.00035865732934325933,
0.004319018218666315,
-0.026216736063361168,
-0.054417505860328674,
0.032353732734918594,
0.008812702260911465,
0.01517860684543848,
0.012096816673874855,
-0.018594011664390564,
0.011228720657527447,
-0.019057493656873703,
-0.008308027870953083,
-0.03160526975989342,
0.002019355073571205,
0.00033838831586763263,
0.01466766931116581,
0.025987528264522552,
-0.03344137594103813,
0.037543170154094696,
-0.10166354477405548,
0.011877794750034809,
0.015431055799126625,
0.03375473618507385,
-0.0487884059548378,
-0.024691671133041382,
0.006163421086966991,
0.030472593382000923,
0.005506964400410652,
-0.005721411667764187,
-0.04091687500476837,
-0.03819260373711586,
0.008563186042010784,
-0.0013196771033108234,
-0.030013885349035263,
-0.023342294618487358,
0.004779600538313389,
-0.07594957202672958,
-0.013843326829373837,
0.022442637011408806,
0.03784260153770447,
0.0032467583660036325,
0.021976320073008537,
0.01166054792702198,
-0.006259402725845575,
0.007437668275088072,
-0.04129564017057419,
-0.02329242043197155,
-0.05373147502541542,
-0.011251487769186497,
-0.046974413096904755,
-0.0009964833734557033,
0.032708194106817245,
0.016954045742750168,
-0.0008961773128248751,
0.011408020742237568,
0.03333165496587753,
-0.059353385120630264,
-0.03138914331793785,
-0.008478554897010326,
-0.02029317244887352,
0.0056275008246302605,
-0.013075673952698708,
0.009438032284379005,
0.024395078420639038,
-0.04493969306349754,
-0.03138212859630585,
-0.008598743006587029,
-0.005172582808881998,
-0.0036979923024773598,
-0.01786360703408718,
0.004827106837183237,
-0.00004339914448792115,
-0.021286694332957268,
0.039879895746707916,
-0.0059969197027385235,
-0.015641778707504272,
-0.02393803372979164,
0.022804317995905876,
0.06889041513204575,
-0.0006220471695996821,
-0.022040506824851036,
-0.0036749443970620632,
-0.023753492161631584,
0.04882032424211502,
-0.05381430312991142,
0.031482845544815063,
0.0029405246023088694,
0.014231476932764053,
0.027208121493458748,
0.002489903010427952,
-0.06448646634817123,
0.016639195382595062,
-0.019405286759138107,
0.0004187489685136825,
-0.025201477110385895,
-0.0024234282318502665,
0.05026910454034805,
0.019050443544983864,
0.015284601598978043,
-0.023197436705231667,
0.025953924283385277,
0.0032143867574632168,
-0.00874380674213171,
0.06043301150202751,
0.028941834345459938,
-0.005804076790809631,
-0.02530762180685997,
0.04509837552905083,
-0.015817565843462944,
-0.0785418227314949,
-0.002862087916582823,
-0.033776719123125076,
0.03577981889247894,
-0.02395675703883171,
0.06544788181781769,
-0.003470968920737505,
-0.015588267706334591,
-0.039967454969882965,
-0.01742669753730297,
-0.07626418769359589,
-0.02462477795779705,
-0.0180788803845644,
0.0016336716944351792,
-0.004312058445066214,
0.012881504371762276,
0.051590997725725174,
-0.02717403694987297,
0.0047674220986664295,
-0.00012478204735089093,
-0.0029707136563956738,
-0.010760440491139889,
0.01190909929573536,
-0.022837866097688675,
-0.05722969025373459,
0.02538871578872204,
-0.027288636192679405,
0.028730452060699463,
-0.05815577879548073,
0.04036232829093933,
0.013793930411338806,
-0.013817941769957542,
-0.011358366347849369,
-0.027011817321181297,
0.011850336566567421,
-0.010654895566403866,
0.02934577688574791,
0.001726579386740923,
-0.01032019592821598,
-0.016944359987974167,
0.016613641753792763,
0.024635013192892075,
-0.06214544177055359,
-0.028016362339258194,
0.03146946057677269,
0.027930663898587227,
0.005818120203912258,
0.034875936806201935,
-0.022182466462254524,
-0.026073280721902847,
-0.007442113943397999,
-0.011013632640242577,
-0.04133414477109909,
0.03244050592184067,
-0.0021479378920048475,
-0.0088390177115798,
0.0007635352085344493,
-0.02450094372034073,
-0.03911733627319336,
-0.025634774938225746,
0.0007835946744307876,
-0.008014974184334278,
-0.02842099592089653,
0.06631755828857422,
0.028363773599267006,
0.004679798148572445,
0.05814386531710625,
-0.028240583837032318,
-0.04796120524406433,
0.05093610659241676,
-0.00521971145644784,
-0.060740359127521515,
-0.021366529166698456,
-0.029494168236851692,
-0.02924247831106186,
0.02109603025019169,
0.008277921006083488,
0.0021685354877263308,
0.0011662382166832685,
0.0023983668070286512,
-0.01585683412849903,
-0.0058265021070837975,
-0.034262027591466904,
-0.02554916962981224,
0.04114291071891785,
0.022848274558782578,
-0.02227645553648472,
0.0166231207549572,
0.05931927636265755,
0.03159211203455925,
0.044944316148757935,
0.025268714874982834,
-0.021809106692671776,
0.013704069890081882,
-0.0006248425925150514,
0.05304480716586113,
0.021190764382481575,
-0.08527097851037979,
-0.008050494827330112,
-0.0043699913658201694,
0.03365449234843254,
0.003100330475717783,
-0.006443343125283718,
-0.0325581319630146,
0.051199980080127716,
0.015173029154539108,
-0.020354758948087692,
0.03480064496397972,
-0.026965461671352386,
0.0387599915266037,
-0.042743947356939316,
-0.021529605612158775,
-0.017877278849482536,
-0.0281832255423069,
-0.06957540661096573,
-0.029242509976029396,
0.00045400747330859303,
-0.04744276776909828,
0.017507513985037804,
0.004110031295567751,
0.0037656812928617,
-0.015418289229273796,
-0.035416580736637115,
0.01530882716178894,
-0.013929030857980251,
-0.0032473064493387938,
-0.07457972317934036,
-0.05767534673213959,
-0.013427253812551498,
0.02243194729089737,
0.026179634034633636,
0.07310474663972855,
-0.04610777273774147,
-0.013084964826703072,
0.011233542114496231,
0.0012237358605489135,
-0.026339592412114143,
-0.017305120825767517,
0.06738615036010742,
-0.04957127571105957,
-0.004897457081824541,
-0.011548763141036034,
-0.046843353658914566,
0.0396079495549202,
0.007765935733914375,
0.011434845626354218,
-0.028846412897109985,
-0.03184317424893379,
-0.01789931207895279,
-0.04052206873893738,
0.035531770437955856,
0.013241242617368698,
-0.000524847477208823,
0.011119319126009941
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:2
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
This extension was not directly relevant to this matter as this part of QBE's case involved an alleged liability of an alleged "common insured", namely Megbuy.
11AMP v QBE also confirmed that the time at which questions of double insurance are to be determined are "the time of the casualty" (at [17] per Handley JA). Subject to certain qualifications which are presently immaterial, this aspect of AMP v QBE was followed in QBE Insurance (Aust) Ltd v Lumley General Insurance Ltd [2009] VSCA 124; (2009) 24 VR 326.
Both parties conducted this matter on the basis that the relevant date for ascertaining the existence of the alleged common obligation to insure Megbuy for the alleged identical loss was the date of Mr Horwood's accident, namely 7 November 2005.
12The starting point for considering QBE's claim is to identify the scope of cover of the policies provided by each of CGU and QBE bearing in mind that there needs to be a "contract of indemnity", "covering the identical loss" for the "identical insured".
13The scope of the CTP policy provided by QBE as at 7 November 2005 was set out in section 10 of the MAC Act which relevantly provided:
"10 Third-party policies
A third-party policy under this Act is a policy that is in the following terms:
Third-party Policy
The insurer insures the owner of the motor vehicle and any other person who at any time drives the vehicle (whether or not with the consent of the owner) against liability in respect of the death of or injury to a person caused by the fault of the owner or driver of the vehicle:
(a) if the motor vehicle is not one to which paragraph (b) applies-in the use or operation of the vehicle in any part of the Commonwealth (whether or not on a road), or
(b) if the motor vehicle is subject to an unregistered vehicle permit under the Road Transport (Vehicle Registration) Act 1997-in the use or operation of the vehicle on any road in any part of the Commonwealth.
In this policy, words and expressions have the same meanings as in the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999." (emphasis added)
14The definition of "owner" is set out at [41] below. Further there is a definition of "injury" in s 3 which repeats the reference to "fault" in s 10 but introduced further causation tests which are discussed below at [116] to [131]. It provided:
"injury:
(a) means personal or bodily injury caused by the fault of the owner or driver of a motor vehicle in the use or operation of the vehicle if, and only if, the injury is a result of and is caused during:
(i) the driving of the vehicle, or
(ii) a collision, or action taken to avoid a collision, with the vehicle, or
(iii) the vehicle's running out of control, or
(iv) such use or operation by a defect in the vehicle, and
(b) includes:
(i) pre-natal injury, and
(ii) psychological or psychiatric injury, and
(iii) damage to artificial members, eyes or teeth, crutches or other aids or spectacle glasses,
and injured person means a person who suffers such an injury."
15It is necessary to note one feature of the MAC Act which QBE emphasised in its submissions. Part 4.3 of the MAC Act imposes various duties upon insurers, claimants and the insured in respect of compensations claims. Sub section 80(1) imposes a duty on an insurer to "endeavour to resolve a claim, by settlement or otherwise, as justly and as expeditiously as possible".
Sub section 81(1) imposes a duty upon an insurer to give "written notice to the claimant as expeditiously as possible whether the insurer admits or denies liability for the claim, but in any event within three months after the claimant gave notice of the claim under section 72".
Sub section 82(1) imposes a duty upon an insurer to make "a reasonable offer of settlement" to a claimant within certain specified time periods. Three matters should be noted about these provisions. First, as was submitted on behalf of CGU, these provisions do not have the effect of imposing a liability upon an insurer such as QBE that does not exist.
|
[
0.01167682372033596,
0.0003799406113103032,
-0.02246425673365593,
-0.003067326731979847,
-0.0037508434616029263,
-0.02751769870519638,
0.016773048788309097,
0.0160304456949234,
-0.009745676070451736,
0.03208544850349426,
0.0009140274487435818,
-0.015415051952004433,
0.007225985638797283,
0.009527753107249737,
-0.0029424529056996107,
-0.018540196120738983,
0.019317539408802986,
-0.00690792640671134,
-0.06323692947626114,
-0.051175087690353394,
-0.00511140888556838,
-0.005048695486038923,
0.004001718945801258,
0.012188585475087166,
0.016501305624842644,
0.01510478276759386,
-0.023417817428708076,
0.010856831446290016,
0.0031394362449645996,
0.011674267239868641,
-0.03231336921453476,
-0.018442515283823013,
-0.035877496004104614,
-0.04613673686981201,
-0.010893662460148335,
-0.016655277460813522,
-0.043006960302591324,
0.021971862763166428,
-0.02398727647960186,
-0.016092702746391296,
-0.012304873205721378,
-0.041786741465330124,
0.007926655001938343,
0.013474272564053535,
0.04805196449160576,
-0.040090762078762054,
0.002343615982681513,
-0.02317451499402523,
-0.011603573337197304,
-0.04155507683753967,
-0.07142654806375504,
-0.023851072415709496,
0.052509989589452744,
-0.03669266402721405,
0.004928430076688528,
0.03411027044057846,
-0.02802121266722679,
-0.052038248628377914,
-0.04225116968154907,
-0.021161329001188278,
-0.042099729180336,
-0.02921191044151783,
0.006122951861470938,
0.03567303344607353,
0.0021786687429994345,
0.0595063790678978,
-0.02075800485908985,
-0.03035123087465763,
-0.019649682566523552,
-0.02402586117386818,
0.0004282620793674141,
0.014440585859119892,
-0.0386958085000515,
-0.0013209375320002437,
-0.06899001449346542,
-0.00284021720290184,
0.01776655577123165,
0.0023114706855267286,
-0.008955036289989948,
0.012872018851339817,
-0.0014383256202563643,
-0.000026180958229815587,
-0.014660987071692944,
0.02443072758615017,
-0.014265241101384163,
-0.02344561368227005,
-0.016635334119200706,
-0.017408238723874092,
0.002614129800349474,
-0.010873538441956043,
-0.002502596937119961,
0.004516493529081345,
0.03851501643657684,
0.0019511852879077196,
0.019401153549551964,
-0.04088357090950012,
-0.058012913912534714,
0.028193114325404167,
-0.00007776399434078485,
0.005453249905258417,
0.0022489542607218027,
-0.013851618394255638,
0.0538686104118824,
-0.04788044095039368,
-0.017852449789643288,
0.007207333110272884,
0.04474329203367233,
0.022066708654165268,
0.009686000645160675,
0.0026809442788362503,
0.002774629509076476,
0.020029377192258835,
0.0006171239074319601,
0.02335727959871292,
-0.009674831293523312,
0.009969301521778107,
0.009189796634018421,
-0.022389104589819908,
-0.006848490331321955,
0.01015249453485012,
0.022000068798661232,
0.056456610560417175,
0.033907923847436905,
0.0032152682542800903,
-0.051766473799943924,
0.0011764424853026867,
-0.0027936261612921953,
0.010313362814486027,
-0.021175632253289223,
-0.03667775169014931,
0.012411467730998993,
-0.012845945544540882,
-0.00761781819164753,
-0.028792180120944977,
-0.033890508115291595,
-0.03631444275379181,
0.04914957657456398,
0.007999696768820286,
-0.03872305899858475,
-0.038795508444309235,
0.028041213750839233,
0.022223008796572685,
-0.0012915246188640594,
-0.015162436291575432,
0.02921370230615139,
0.002459893934428692,
0.051124200224876404,
-0.0445123165845871,
0.0034954033326357603,
0.0014028857694938779,
0.013035086914896965,
0.013278966769576073,
0.009115513414144516,
-0.05954136699438095,
-0.011610227636992931,
-0.027796046808362007,
-0.014183354564011097,
-0.02868238463997841,
0.027157125994563103,
0.0014796890318393707,
-0.01001314353197813,
0.04956696555018425,
-0.006279879715293646,
-0.023598216474056244,
0.006106086075305939,
-0.0049753617495298386,
-0.01988447830080986,
0.03774535283446312,
-0.03177707642316818,
-0.010022865608334541,
0.018851546570658684,
0.02383529767394066,
-0.015947192907333374,
-0.003754646750167012,
0.033882420510053635,
0.03863245248794556,
0.0569671131670475,
0.021177230402827263,
-0.006982104387134314,
-0.019539060071110725,
0.009377064183354378,
0.004034946206957102,
0.0065880436450243,
-0.03403349220752716,
0.014663893729448318,
0.03784060850739479,
-0.018344897776842117,
-0.01947704888880253,
0.037143874913454056,
0.01936446502804756,
-0.010123820044100285,
-0.020776649937033653,
0.010662274435162544,
0.019298406317830086,
-0.012813297100365162,
-0.05682282894849777,
0.052043426781892776,
0.004893904086202383,
0.023610897362232208,
-0.036792684346437454,
-0.03447519242763519,
-0.0017486948054283857,
0.0804562121629715,
-0.02080761454999447,
0.0003143568756058812,
-0.03312743082642555,
-0.07455692440271378,
0.03853122889995575,
0.030703570693731308,
-0.058304522186517715,
0.007866578176617622,
-0.007440786808729172,
0.03328029438853264,
-0.0016449877293780446,
-0.058347608894109726,
-0.034151267260313034,
0.015108736231923103,
0.03672630339860916,
0.03428162634372711,
0.037646401673555374,
-0.02812611684203148,
0.013944328762590885,
-0.003524967236444354,
0.022921564057469368,
0.04662061855196953,
-0.008504618890583515,
-0.0013937532203271985,
0.035038627684116364,
0.0014970966149121523,
-0.009168787859380245,
0.027072977274656296,
0.0329807847738266,
0.008588377386331558,
-0.04395458102226257,
0.029849519953131676,
0.014537184499204159,
0.0263203214854002,
-0.007196363527327776,
0.03723286837339401,
-0.007123203482478857,
0.013008340261876583,
-0.03597620874643326,
0.03438808023929596,
-0.02214309573173523,
0.020159203559160233,
-0.02794097550213337,
-0.012041473761200905,
0.02488730661571026,
0.006511840503662825,
-0.014896220527589321,
-0.016412897035479546,
-0.01573384553194046,
-0.0019655958749353886,
-0.011668114922940731,
0.0036504874005913734,
0.0325295589864254,
0.011075668036937714,
-0.0006840359419584274,
0.03247631713747978,
-0.027302611619234085,
-0.005707928445190191,
0.05309591814875603,
0.056153979152441025,
-0.003666203236207366,
-0.029648784548044205,
-0.03235534578561783,
-0.01232282817363739,
-0.028509603813290596,
-0.023345112800598145,
0.01812007650732994,
0.009201694279909134,
-0.014515523798763752,
0.023282788693904877,
0.008092228323221207,
0.01654856465756893,
0.040756624191999435,
0.015593349933624268,
-0.023534368723630905,
0.01413358747959137,
0.014866488985717297,
0.04232672601938248,
0.024902448058128357,
-0.013684496283531189,
-0.015167192555963993,
0.027473580092191696,
-0.023936515673995018,
-0.01551246177405119,
-0.04921757057309151,
-0.02642863243818283,
-0.03436592221260071,
0.04274783283472061,
-0.003554021706804633,
0.06692937016487122,
-0.027871092781424522,
-0.041397854685783386,
0.03173608332872391,
0.01962157152593136,
-0.15314248204231262,
-0.03028539940714836,
0.015827601775527,
0.015593483112752438,
-0.000024200886400649324,
0.041572850197553635,
-0.02650207094848156,
-0.014715558849275112,
0.018451431766152382,
0.06256607919931412,
-0.002333106705918908,
-0.062032222747802734,
-0.03355030342936516,
0.008419415913522243,
0.054816633462905884,
-0.04457629844546318,
-0.024753309786319733,
0.023328382521867752,
-0.0018137037986889482,
-0.024244941771030426,
-0.05016716197133064,
-0.005852912086993456,
-0.006853831000626087,
-0.020143544301390648,
0.02329382300376892,
-0.03491804376244545,
0.02426886558532715,
0.006646249908953905,
-0.05099537596106529,
0.020623773336410522,
-0.06526250392198563,
-0.009483997710049152,
-0.018089838325977325,
0.031795747578144073,
0.036071792244911194,
-0.03136008605360985,
0.057600680738687515,
-0.024563249200582504,
0.01996920257806778,
-0.018742412328720093,
0.03370388597249985,
0.10182701796293259,
0.016095122322440147,
0.002265940885990858,
-0.0016392107354477048,
-0.06028202176094055,
0.00776553014293313,
-0.012651314958930016,
-0.0641668438911438,
0.027335112914443016,
-0.019660864025354385,
-0.020006507635116577,
-0.006693893112242222,
0.01817493885755539,
-0.02845039963722229,
-0.03253425285220146,
0.04348064586520195,
0.05876011773943901,
-0.005453026387840509,
-0.007497081998735666,
-0.04315395653247833,
-0.0008489977917633951,
0.0017354846931993961,
0.017140984535217285,
-0.030455010011792183,
0.018578192219138145,
0.013421165756881237,
0.0036468193866312504,
0.020164649933576584,
-0.014587311074137688,
0.002966583939269185,
-0.047485798597335815,
0.01631873846054077,
-0.010458562523126602,
-0.026488926261663437,
-0.016877956688404083,
0.026729224249720573,
-0.005167076364159584,
-0.023371834307909012,
-0.07483728229999542,
-0.003958113491535187,
0.004143774043768644,
0.017301499843597412,
0.010855866596102715,
0.004415097180753946,
-0.03252806141972542,
0.020004937425255775,
0.003407434094697237,
0.0401763841509819,
0.24784953892230988,
0.02394462376832962,
-0.06198728084564209,
-0.005715909413993359,
0.02479987032711506,
-0.01120518147945404,
0.018925374373793602,
0.040162261575460434,
-0.0038324666675180197,
-0.027101073414087296,
-0.06564284861087799,
0.009177548810839653,
0.035562045872211456,
0.006565413903445005,
-0.017582200467586517,
-0.04156723991036415,
-0.045723479241132736,
-0.007683570962399244,
0.062113869935274124,
-0.03146739676594734,
0.03621084615588188,
-0.008685370907187462,
0.04254147410392761,
0.0160532183945179,
-0.05912967026233673,
-0.06167866662144661,
-0.006641537416726351,
-0.0027449384797364473,
-0.0223704781383276,
0.025126757100224495,
-0.04215577617287636,
-0.02409871481359005,
0.042038436979055405,
-0.004299718886613846,
-0.008760309778153896,
-0.010616759769618511,
-0.03727167099714279,
-0.004439313430339098,
0.0006251070299185812,
0.050560902804136276,
0.05253424495458603,
-0.02267899177968502,
0.014735035598278046,
0.0004588895826600492,
0.037663303315639496,
0.020815037190914154,
-0.015250284224748611,
0.003408525139093399,
-0.00941432174295187,
0.016945548355579376,
-0.03636204078793526,
-0.003606150159612298,
-0.006870174314826727,
0.041380397975444794,
-0.0174587182700634,
0.029680168256163597,
0.015477349981665611,
0.017707783728837967,
-0.002060647588223219,
-0.035395968705415726,
0.03939571604132652,
-0.005715963430702686,
-0.042766083031892776,
0.02004912681877613,
0.012004612945020199,
-0.007998504675924778,
-0.02880673110485077,
0.02016603946685791,
0.04891952499747276,
0.025930367410182953,
0.026157531887292862,
0.06078312173485756,
0.04291472211480141,
0.038589004427194595,
0.041296862065792084,
0.031853485852479935,
0.04434923455119133,
-0.006858133245259523,
-0.0030484681483358145,
-0.017330190166831017,
-0.030630292370915413,
-0.007150492165237665,
0.019088614732027054,
-0.013694635592401028,
0.036718711256980896,
-0.01961914449930191,
-0.03888985142111778,
0.04262793809175491,
0.06671316176652908,
-0.028565075248479843,
-0.03248725086450577,
-0.03366760164499283,
0.01764860935509205,
0.057938750833272934,
-0.026399174705147743,
0.012217864394187927,
0.05834890156984329,
-0.006901314947754145,
-0.03681079298257828,
-0.03323294594883919,
0.023551298305392265,
-0.029931318014860153,
-0.001944660791195929,
0.019527580589056015,
-0.009686858393251896,
0.015476896427571774,
0.011862813495099545,
0.008010310120880604,
-0.04738227650523186,
-0.008923405781388283,
-0.0008416780037805438,
0.012768632732331753,
-0.01747020334005356,
0.007528188172727823,
-0.0048047760501503944,
0.029707476496696472,
-0.045005057007074356,
0.03996352106332779,
0.039754468947649,
0.024426626041531563,
-0.014195802621543407,
0.04582628607749939,
-0.018074145540595055,
0.003301824675872922,
-0.020170943811535835,
-0.031307827681303024,
-0.030528321862220764,
-0.004540884867310524,
-0.017152827233076096,
0.026223165914416313,
-0.00622094189748168,
-0.00917948316782713,
-0.030494486913084984,
-0.003550154622644186,
0.047011665999889374,
-0.008306966163218021,
-0.0318293534219265,
0.029893936589360237,
0.006407048087567091,
0.0026162019930779934,
-0.03956232964992523,
0.002013186691328883,
-0.04760169982910156,
0.0020219336729496717,
0.020697537809610367,
0.00007988155266502872,
-0.014417356811463833,
0.026911549270153046,
-0.073818139731884,
0.0025932425633072853,
-0.025503771379590034,
-0.00043084879871457815,
-0.021539956331253052,
-0.03419121354818344,
-0.024061966687440872,
0.0026644370518624783,
0.025209778919816017,
0.009319008328020573,
0.011267904192209244,
-0.028264416381716728,
-0.013573328033089638,
-0.0491497628390789,
-0.020575346425175667,
0.06275307387113571,
0.011778655461966991,
0.04109397530555725,
0.013966824859380722,
0.019839929416775703,
0.029592325910925865,
0.018305707722902298,
0.010906191542744637,
-0.03879142552614212,
-0.008744814433157444,
0.035585932433605194,
0.05745864659547806,
0.06586021184921265,
-0.001969271805137396,
-0.010331817902624607,
0.01733674854040146,
-0.0247956532984972,
-0.02206026390194893,
0.040474776178598404,
-0.0179941076785326,
0.04146910458803177,
-0.014055436477065086,
0.006642478518188,
0.042493343353271484,
-0.03948269039392471,
0.007645653560757637,
0.0038452697917819023,
-0.008328380063176155,
0.10245614498853683,
-0.03461415320634842,
-0.004959970712661743,
0.019762074574828148,
0.023566655814647675,
-0.014645439572632313,
-0.021088982000947,
-0.0057198526337742805,
-0.028224367648363113,
0.03846883028745651,
0.029186366125941277,
0.00699612358585,
0.030800893902778625,
0.047592438757419586,
-0.032275255769491196,
-0.00203028810210526,
-0.016210393980145454,
-0.03562738746404648,
0.0017895165365189314,
0.01967325247824192,
0.0018598391907289624,
-0.02448453940451145,
0.009856389835476875,
-0.042324986308813095,
0.019918330013751984,
0.030969450250267982,
0.04400220140814781,
-0.0025981110520660877,
-0.050465479493141174,
-0.028184615075588226,
-0.002207692712545395,
0.06335978209972382,
-0.0520508773624897,
0.00833465252071619,
0.05456567928195,
-0.009912575595080853,
-0.04417317733168602,
0.004034057259559631,
0.0019015969010069966,
0.01258859597146511,
-0.056220170110464096,
-0.009405591525137424,
-0.005431055556982756,
-0.011764122173190117,
-0.012070953845977783,
0.02621159330010414,
0.011822864413261414,
0.03920502960681915,
-0.012412709183990955,
0.01633911021053791,
0.05431376397609711,
-0.012707275338470936,
0.07754646241664886,
0.018071206286549568,
-0.004421156365424395,
-0.042486704885959625,
-0.03827809542417526,
0.05842895433306694,
0.018875721842050552,
-0.004246651194989681,
0.029936354607343674,
0.08534082770347595,
-0.06020309776067734,
0.007267479319125414,
0.006321944762021303,
0.032862093299627304,
0.03303512558341026,
-0.055951740592718124,
-0.007218200247734785,
0.037751007825136185,
0.028279148042201996,
-0.003565190825611353,
-0.06685560941696167,
0.003953736741095781,
-0.0468151681125164,
0.02718491107225418,
-0.0012109184172004461,
-0.03551822528243065,
-0.012639325112104416,
-0.039311863481998444,
-0.009495900012552738,
-0.03328549116849899,
-0.04547785967588425,
-0.0512012243270874,
-0.007657827343791723,
-0.0426776222884655,
0.011600557714700699,
0.046074338257312775,
-0.0164450965821743,
0.02590549923479557,
0.0024695454631000757,
0.014874439686536789,
0.013166126795113087,
-0.016663335263729095,
0.0005949424230493605,
0.03449143469333649,
-0.0009235414327122271,
-0.0023670063819736242,
-0.035835057497024536,
-0.027004841715097427,
0.01219240017235279,
-0.02158818580210209,
-0.00598121015354991,
0.006683223880827427,
0.009323756210505962,
-0.04425230249762535,
0.058904990553855896,
-0.021108487620949745,
-0.0012736240169033408,
-0.01449328102171421,
0.004657558165490627,
-0.043439097702503204,
-0.03519168496131897,
0.010155908763408661,
-0.010517999529838562,
0.00748797319829464,
-0.04862053692340851,
0.009272498078644276,
-0.0032073971815407276,
-0.023125886917114258,
-0.027679556980729103,
0.0060823881067335606,
-0.03610599786043167,
-0.04427126422524452,
0.018167342990636826,
0.015344013459980488,
-0.020093917846679688,
0.027536075562238693,
-0.028584647923707962,
0.04164525121450424,
0.0035569837782531977,
-0.0469973050057888,
-0.0442730113863945,
-0.05373995378613472,
-0.0019378926372155547,
-0.008936519734561443,
-0.02640420012176037,
-0.036680787801742554,
0.01700315624475479,
-0.035634227097034454,
0.001103662420064211,
-0.017488274723291397,
0.002971144625917077,
0.01486184448003769,
0.01734815165400505,
-0.039476409554481506,
-0.054818104952573776,
0.032555799931287766,
-0.007680798415094614,
-0.014032375998795033,
-0.058502599596977234,
0.05450160801410675,
-0.011187201365828514,
0.004117106087505817,
-0.019473694264888763,
0.03421656787395477,
0.03263386711478233,
-0.0016892078565433621,
0.022246433421969414,
-0.0022627576254308224,
-0.014106771908700466,
-0.025251302868127823,
-0.03195706754922867,
0.015927739441394806,
0.00813701655715704,
0.00880070123821497,
0.008330835960805416,
0.03243020176887512,
0.02510102093219757,
-0.02365144155919552,
0.05155430734157562,
-0.022877592593431473,
0.018210958689451218,
0.03480237349867821,
0.0048360321670770645,
-0.0022853577975183725,
0.016007455065846443,
-0.003087208606302738,
-0.03151785582304001,
0.002690899418666959,
0.02202019840478897,
0.0036759416107088327,
0.03803503140807152,
0.009067135863006115,
-0.0363345742225647,
0.009760110639035702,
-0.01412234827876091,
-0.042692631483078,
-0.016315095126628876,
-0.03409772738814354,
-0.02646481618285179,
-0.06315809488296509,
-0.008994444273412228,
0.024923278018832207,
-0.00448166998103261,
0.004047457128763199,
0.0013989490689709783,
-0.03756970912218094,
0.03190534561872482,
-0.019920041784644127,
0.04483882710337639,
-0.02091122791171074,
0.008105676621198654,
-0.11835554242134094,
-0.015492340549826622,
-0.015372328460216522,
0.017183061689138412,
-0.08440862596035004,
0.019419962540268898,
-0.014888888224959373,
0.024112535640597343,
0.004453821107745171,
-0.014345523901283741,
-0.027807407081127167,
-0.03584403172135353,
0.0990714356303215,
-0.019342422485351562,
0.0003430554934311658,
0.014118132181465626,
-0.007006708532571793,
-0.037775855511426926,
-0.008145922794938087,
0.033815812319517136,
-0.005164321046322584,
0.05129295215010643,
0.019038792699575424,
-0.025959648191928864,
0.022883441299200058,
-0.028085976839065552,
-0.03488878533244133,
-0.015722330659627914,
-0.01834183745086193,
0.04167758673429489,
-0.0009826717432588339,
-0.022435685619711876,
0.010168219916522503,
0.02743927389383316,
0.012148048728704453,
0.031441450119018555,
0.020885203033685684,
-0.0003150109259877354,
-0.06142522022128105,
-0.027364883571863174,
-0.02642853744328022,
0.015926558524370193,
-0.022294502705335617,
-0.020534759387373924,
0.009307916276156902,
0.018044279888272285,
-0.025859620422124863,
0.009970933198928833,
-0.003228458808735013,
-0.033533915877342224,
-0.030496738851070404,
0.009367008693516254,
-0.020516948774456978,
-0.005486646201461554,
0.009765506722033024,
0.013014036230742931,
0.017518918961286545,
-0.009811459109187126,
-0.002776743145659566,
0.05669907107949257,
-0.0021138405427336693,
-0.008118587546050549,
-0.012274611741304398,
0.009782210923731327,
0.06897329539060593,
0.023112187162041664,
-0.013954970985651016,
0.008197055198252201,
0.02235838770866394,
0.032716054469347,
0.030668625608086586,
-0.03535468131303787,
0.023960381746292114,
-0.037946611642837524,
-0.009678725153207779,
-0.0018287504790350795,
0.015749873593449593,
0.022617371752858162,
0.002800263464450836,
-0.0073364730924367905,
-0.01583332195878029,
-0.003240287071093917,
0.002987148240208626,
0.019019227474927902,
0.024171769618988037,
0.017787223681807518,
0.002982322359457612,
-0.04093356058001518,
0.08129207789897919,
-0.06385433673858643,
-0.07869912683963776,
-0.013910544104874134,
0.00901360809803009,
0.03540724515914917,
-0.02938583306968212,
0.06885392963886261,
-0.008139673620462418,
-0.028099272400140762,
-0.014550742693245411,
-0.018596699461340904,
-0.011784803122282028,
-0.04961313307285309,
0.04258043318986893,
0.005982952658087015,
-0.054443325847387314,
0.048118479549884796,
-0.03330074995756149,
0.0031173659954220057,
-0.015550539828836918,
-0.0135567095130682,
-0.012903601862490177,
-0.0502651073038578,
-0.00690457783639431,
0.0199370589107275,
-0.04232559725642204,
-0.012526964768767357,
-0.007538370322436094,
0.03414449468255043,
-0.03804280236363411,
0.039510298520326614,
0.015706222504377365,
-0.030773432925343513,
0.014079476706683636,
-0.00567649258300662,
0.019074993208050728,
0.0639309212565422,
0.010934717021882534,
-0.01429431140422821,
0.06384722143411636,
-0.0442168302834034,
0.03889961168169975,
-0.00940330047160387,
-0.008581580594182014,
0.009143618866801262,
-0.007104784715920687,
0.043037910014390945,
-0.012506036087870598,
0.014029547572135925,
-0.005457379389554262,
-0.04914003238081932,
0.02004947140812874,
-0.02328416518867016,
-0.012265758588910103,
-0.006925160065293312,
-0.03952454403042793,
-0.022236274555325508,
-0.015161805786192417,
-0.007630379404872656,
-0.013842812739312649,
-0.057648707181215286,
-0.008545447140932083,
-0.022637546062469482,
-0.01511096116155386,
0.07597989588975906,
0.013683740049600601,
-0.009418414905667305,
0.026065824553370476,
0.03851255029439926,
0.005710724741220474,
0.06539972126483917,
0.010372183285653591,
-0.03979644179344177,
-0.033039528876543045,
-0.07401467114686966,
-0.011561869643628597,
0.03957880288362503,
-0.040998682379722595,
-0.0036982414312660694,
-0.002823664341121912,
-0.001314483000896871,
-0.023042410612106323,
-0.004025345668196678,
-0.020387176424264908,
0.026676518842577934,
0.015010282397270203,
0.01036872249096632,
-0.0323798842728138,
0.010932885110378265,
0.05337238311767578,
-0.009573609568178654,
0.03807055577635765,
0.06577610224485397,
0.02085191011428833,
0.02055526152253151,
-0.017139269039034843,
0.002808444667607546,
-0.01878240518271923,
0.002205893164500594,
-0.0028343640733510256,
-0.044444095343351364,
-0.004263765644282103,
-0.00987930502742529,
0.031934816390275955,
-0.0021936597768217325,
0.05051346495747566,
0.010252000764012337,
-0.003636918729171157,
0.017736762762069702,
0.001519199344329536,
0.04649629443883896,
0.006424719467759132,
-0.017821092158555984,
-0.030024930834770203,
-0.0079311802983284,
-0.03612585738301277,
-0.022793028503656387,
0.006443566642701626,
-0.003568534040823579,
0.006326650734990835,
0.062453966587781906,
-0.030176842585206032,
-0.02755940705537796,
-0.0237704087048769,
0.07873097062110901,
-0.023150892928242683,
0.03410235047340393,
-0.005489511881023645,
0.01275645475834608,
-0.003606625832617283,
0.009736177511513233,
0.0460602343082428,
0.06356638669967651,
-0.025470247492194176,
-0.05561617761850357,
-0.00131461292039603,
0.033621493726968765,
-0.009203867055475712,
-0.0014344884548336267,
0.03005804307758808,
-0.020913351327180862,
-0.003552973736077547,
-0.0013045925879850984,
-0.020053161308169365,
0.015154425986111164,
0.02045133337378502,
-0.011376607231795788,
-0.011039478704333305,
-0.025311939418315887,
-0.01585790514945984,
-0.02414700761437416,
0.07224330306053162,
-0.006330426782369614,
0.019931113347411156,
-0.06567519903182983
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:7
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
The liability of the 'first insurer's insured" or "common insured", ie Caringbah, under the MAC Act was admitted and the subject of consent orders reflecting that admission.
The only judicial determination that occurred in Zurich v GIO was a matter affecting the quantum of that liability. In this case the liability of Megbuy under the MAC Act was admitted in November 2009 and then the subject of consent orders in December 2009.
35In submitting that the reference to "reasonable compromise" in Zurich at [57] was incorrect Mr Campbell SC referred to three decisions noted at the commencement of [58], ie GIO v Royal Exchange, C E Heath v SGIC and Drayton v Martin.
He submitted that none of those authorities suggested that a reasonable compromise sufficed to establish the liability of the "common insured". I agree that none of the passages cited in those three cases suggests that.
However, my reading of [58] is that Giles JA was not suggesting that those cases supported the proposition that reasonable compromise was sufficient to entitle a party to a double insurance contribution. I read his Honour as relying on those cases to support the reference to "judicially determined" in [57]. The reasoning supporting the reference to "compromise" in [57] is the balance of [58].
36If the matter was open for me to decide then I would have thought that Mr Campbell SC might be on surer ground in relation to his argument concerning the balance of [58]. The general position is that an insured under a liability policy can only recover against their insurer if they were actually under a liability to a third party on a proper analysis of the law and facts.
A settlement does not suffice. The insured must demonstrate that it was or would have been liable (Enterprise Oil Ltd v Strand Insurance Co Ltd [2007] Lloyd's Rep IR 186 at [27] and [72] citing McDonnell Information Systems Ltd v Swinbank & Ors [1999] Lloyd's Rep IR 98).
A reasonable settlement will normally be sufficient to establish the amount of the insured's liability but not the liability itself (Lumbermen's Mutual Casualty Co v Bovis Lend Lease Ltd [2005] Lloyd's Rep IR 74, 84).
As noted in Zurich v GIO at [58] where there is conduct amounting to a repudiation of the insurance contract, especially conduct in which the insurer breaches the contract by denying liability and refusing to defend or settle,
it may be sufficient if the insured can prove that the settlement with the injured person was reasonable (see Distillers Co Bio Chemicals (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1 at 9, per Menzies J;
and Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR (NSW) 88)).
However the conduct must amount to a repudiation of the policy. In Distillers the insurer forced the insured to defend the claims made against it. It did not assume carriage of the claims on its behalf. Given the wording of the policy that did not amount to a repudiation by the insurer (Distillers at 10, per Menzies J).
It is understandable how the principles concerning the position between an insured and repudiating insurer can translate to a claim for equitable contribution from a non-repudiating insurer against a repudiating insurer.
However it is not clear how the cases dealing with a repudiation support the "reasonable settlement" limb of the principle formulated by Giles JA in Zurich v GIO at [57].
It does not appear that the form of policy created by Division 1 of Part 7 of the WC Act is of such a nature that the refusal of an insurer such as CGU in this case (or GIO in that case) to meet or participate in the defence of the claim against the employer amounts to a repudiation.
I say "appears" because no argument before me was directed towards this aspect of [58] of Giles JA's judgment in Zurich v GIO.
|
[
-0.00778759503737092,
0.018414074555039406,
-0.029023684561252594,
-0.03374071419239044,
0.0015318819787353277,
-0.043914470821619034,
0.004587088245898485,
0.006514030043035746,
-0.00008437741780653596,
0.05889305844902992,
-0.0010352319804951549,
-0.03247848525643349,
-0.009553911164402962,
0.02125629037618637,
-0.00938091054558754,
0.004774949047714472,
0.010254807770252228,
0.010340015403926373,
-0.0655551627278328,
-0.0050672064535319805,
-0.0014413893222808838,
-0.005548373330384493,
0.020591264590620995,
-0.003383312840014696,
0.011701690964400768,
0.03752175718545914,
-0.032618824392557144,
-0.0020894273184239864,
0.006349616218358278,
0.018519800156354904,
-0.024773044511675835,
0.018070567399263382,
0.006412735674530268,
-0.030021509155631065,
0.020615320652723312,
-0.011661211960017681,
-0.034771330654621124,
0.009772704914212227,
-0.012483179569244385,
-0.009276414290070534,
0.01854659989476204,
-0.002041454194113612,
0.012875554151833057,
-0.022376852110028267,
0.04860193282365799,
-0.0379999615252018,
0.0022439949680119753,
-0.01095799170434475,
0.0006515842396765947,
-0.0309041328728199,
-0.06275589764118195,
0.031152939423918724,
0.10012247413396835,
-0.04144957289099693,
-0.018321242183446884,
0.054130230098962784,
0.014080040156841278,
-0.052319739013910294,
-0.018574463203549385,
-0.028555557131767273,
-0.03157707303762436,
-0.015452856197953224,
-0.030688270926475525,
-0.0025391769595444202,
0.01893579587340355,
0.0368732325732708,
-0.01975199207663536,
-0.022144639864563942,
-0.04077660292387009,
-0.04304646700620651,
-0.01136869378387928,
0.029338860884308815,
-0.044197868555784225,
0.0396256186068058,
-0.042046189308166504,
-0.007988987490534782,
0.07014773041009903,
0.003842639271169901,
0.014238420873880386,
-0.024623766541481018,
0.012481358833611012,
-0.008181055076420307,
-0.030378973111510277,
0.007836543023586273,
-0.0446198433637619,
0.025459978729486465,
-0.02046848088502884,
-0.009473512880504131,
-0.012783109210431576,
-0.0217927023768425,
0.0072431545704603195,
-0.021921733394265175,
-0.02394002117216587,
0.004732901230454445,
0.018194530159235,
0.016680723056197166,
-0.07474761456251144,
0.016572674736380577,
0.028977731242775917,
0.04354085773229599,
0.01251198910176754,
-0.013743404299020767,
0.01227478962391615,
-0.030471503734588623,
0.00581153342500329,
0.02235517092049122,
-0.017690833657979965,
0.06980029493570328,
-0.0025691220071166754,
-0.008092972449958324,
-0.02466675452888012,
0.0030181962065398693,
0.009375892579555511,
0.03445703163743019,
-0.00031074011349119246,
-0.02864542230963707,
-0.00574685912579298,
-0.013250326737761497,
0.005896391347050667,
-0.022378450259566307,
0.006352448370307684,
0.041756317019462585,
0.035717569291591644,
-0.014167208224534988,
-0.02420671097934246,
-0.01524550374597311,
-0.004566425923258066,
0.007881639525294304,
-0.012045269832015038,
0.018949441611766815,
0.006553768180310726,
0.010165232233703136,
-0.015943707898259163,
-0.03603638708591461,
-0.002794475993141532,
-0.036368511617183685,
0.04545697942376137,
-0.026364093646407127,
-0.014930110424757004,
-0.07169792056083679,
0.02847454696893692,
0.04832535982131958,
0.007326049730181694,
-0.022517062723636627,
0.024509893730282784,
-0.05146146938204765,
0.036866795271635056,
0.0011540764244273305,
0.006019514054059982,
0.004419330973178148,
0.002318946411833167,
0.013793627731502056,
0.018886402249336243,
-0.032929424196481705,
0.03177677094936371,
-0.020819339901208878,
-0.008074391633272171,
-0.005013222806155682,
0.06204984709620476,
0.02891596034169197,
-0.020244255661964417,
0.04692579805850983,
-0.053029973059892654,
-0.009077847003936768,
-0.02407551370561123,
-0.015574024058878422,
-0.012635240331292152,
0.05214672535657883,
-0.02483973652124405,
-0.042880527675151825,
0.04027242586016655,
0.025649908930063248,
0.023689808323979378,
-0.03770216554403305,
0.00042871132609434426,
0.02903333678841591,
0.035674940794706345,
0.017919259145855904,
0.02254333160817623,
-0.022771893069148064,
-0.027898317202925682,
-0.010970830917358398,
0.01456422545015812,
-0.03043045476078987,
-0.011588847264647484,
0.011633938178420067,
0.0021480333525687456,
-0.05792595446109772,
0.036539655178785324,
0.04223677143454552,
0.023527204990386963,
-0.03501691296696663,
-0.03589092195034027,
-0.01113048568367958,
-0.013744303956627846,
0.000012979854545847047,
0.03364888206124306,
-0.009901381097733974,
0.03685039281845093,
-0.01495839562267065,
-0.02726772427558899,
0.025348739698529243,
0.04583156108856201,
0.01760856620967388,
-0.029485832899808884,
0.0003167990653309971,
-0.08014866709709167,
0.012400006875395775,
0.03876928985118866,
-0.03531667962670326,
0.006329326890408993,
-0.014478280209004879,
0.020825540646910667,
0.03626333177089691,
-0.05870279297232628,
-0.01584230363368988,
0.03921419009566307,
0.00701533118262887,
0.05545029789209366,
0.027272000908851624,
-0.009305085986852646,
0.01634311117231846,
-0.018487298861145973,
0.043826356530189514,
0.036273710429668427,
0.0028276126831769943,
-0.04773911088705063,
0.04056309163570404,
0.023983588442206383,
-0.008420913480222225,
0.009575538337230682,
0.02161255106329918,
0.010687577538192272,
-0.04052913188934326,
0.015678400173783302,
0.028906947001814842,
0.02640841156244278,
0.014063169248402119,
0.0159857589751482,
-0.0068677738308906555,
-0.0289904922246933,
-0.01798628270626068,
0.06304408609867096,
-0.014053423888981342,
-0.011575153097510338,
-0.020742718130350113,
-0.003609363455325365,
0.021840734407305717,
0.01316745299845934,
-0.018692484125494957,
-0.027116257697343826,
-0.019426019862294197,
-0.01631956361234188,
0.006831421982496977,
0.017031868919730186,
0.012594053521752357,
0.002246866235509515,
0.0009805891895666718,
0.059221189469099045,
-0.01159321516752243,
0.0182717926800251,
0.008338307030498981,
0.022123947739601135,
0.004488023463636637,
-0.019974062219262123,
-0.030387550592422485,
-0.05617544800043106,
0.01828066259622574,
-0.013497386127710342,
-0.023829542100429535,
-0.0031102958600968122,
0.018536295741796494,
-0.019938159734010696,
-0.0005278358585201204,
0.045459091663360596,
0.013687136583030224,
0.03720814362168312,
-0.022785324603319168,
0.024640927091240883,
0.0030427766032516956,
0.008185196667909622,
0.007588499691337347,
0.02968795970082283,
-0.05168326199054718,
0.017605839297175407,
-0.020321981981396675,
-0.01265593059360981,
-0.01574276015162468,
-0.005425294395536184,
-0.06946908682584763,
0.03585284203290939,
0.0075518544763326645,
0.07489543408155441,
-0.013004344888031483,
-0.07335717976093292,
-0.012322964146733284,
0.02019578032195568,
-0.14784985780715942,
-0.012077085673809052,
0.022878967225551605,
0.003937195520848036,
-0.011830777861177921,
0.04169703647494316,
-0.0413631908595562,
0.009504138492047787,
0.006525619886815548,
0.005397571716457605,
-0.0044358354061841965,
-0.06378553062677383,
0.0011063823476433754,
0.018630610778927803,
0.019641611725091934,
-0.014066703617572784,
-0.050964441150426865,
0.01543098408728838,
0.018056068569421768,
-0.02978682331740856,
-0.009264989756047726,
-0.02249726839363575,
-0.008276780135929585,
0.005857428070157766,
0.02409980446100235,
-0.00453770300373435,
0.026485295966267586,
0.029736319556832314,
-0.06334861367940903,
0.005260108038783073,
-0.0675993487238884,
0.0011094599030911922,
-0.014422188512980938,
0.042509857565164566,
0.022925162687897682,
0.007314520888030529,
0.039184655994176865,
-0.0473010279238224,
-0.008612322621047497,
-0.01271725818514824,
0.03698170930147171,
0.06518195569515228,
0.012019849382340908,
0.0160024743527174,
-0.030371883884072304,
-0.02710641734302044,
0.0038829054683446884,
-0.01126613188534975,
-0.005504980217665434,
0.022052250802516937,
0.013203510083258152,
-0.034130558371543884,
-0.03942602872848511,
0.017962858080863953,
-0.01842040754854679,
-0.02022140845656395,
0.03860820084810257,
0.03906818851828575,
0.016470586881041527,
0.006888960022479296,
-0.05551638454198837,
-0.013933134265244007,
0.016123155131936073,
0.030501188710331917,
-0.034286875277757645,
0.01940188743174076,
0.009364507161080837,
-0.001617655623704195,
0.059844229370355606,
-0.01129856240004301,
-0.017793001607060432,
-0.01332380436360836,
0.0171593576669693,
-0.012964481487870216,
-0.04275337606668472,
0.016366416588425636,
0.03492003306746483,
-0.01181232463568449,
-0.017583321779966354,
-0.05638482794165611,
0.039845794439315796,
-0.017401762306690216,
0.026074189692735672,
0.05127030983567238,
-0.004178902134299278,
0.012345878407359123,
-0.0053316159173846245,
0.018033744767308235,
-0.009656241163611412,
0.22186978161334991,
0.03820706903934479,
0.020055819302797318,
0.0031646203715354204,
0.025811150670051575,
-0.012387629598379135,
0.03599157556891441,
0.04233848676085472,
0.005576495546847582,
-0.0316300168633461,
-0.05491902306675911,
0.012673163786530495,
0.03534466773271561,
0.01271780300885439,
-0.01421759556978941,
-0.031036553904414177,
-0.046482667326927185,
-0.02433140203356743,
0.09912382066249847,
-0.0316210612654686,
0.05666442587971687,
0.006371674593538046,
0.04315883666276932,
0.04084811359643936,
-0.04905558377504349,
-0.041275881230831146,
0.020307620987296104,
0.018121467903256416,
0.010807663202285767,
0.003004916710779071,
-0.03958789259195328,
-0.004774053581058979,
0.02593650296330452,
0.004835486877709627,
0.0034579739440232515,
0.03024984896183014,
0.013098258525133133,
-0.0006537736626341939,
0.01262096967548132,
0.04733727127313614,
0.05031195655465126,
-0.029913604259490967,
0.009074488654732704,
-0.025577696040272713,
0.0623181127011776,
-0.030630607157945633,
0.004511124920099974,
0.0021195781882852316,
-0.01157123502343893,
0.019198523834347725,
-0.06599785387516022,
0.014178796671330929,
-0.016327807679772377,
0.017398027703166008,
-0.06201372295618057,
0.0364999957382679,
-0.0305143054574728,
0.0184335820376873,
-0.007816730067133904,
0.02186160907149315,
0.01776745542883873,
0.02036176808178425,
-0.041488442569971085,
0.03850356116890907,
-0.00743118254467845,
0.012360001914203167,
-0.07021857053041458,
0.009422111324965954,
0.06113654747605324,
0.04360853135585785,
-0.008765123784542084,
0.026401739567518234,
-0.001579447416588664,
0.0016491434071213007,
0.03940339758992195,
0.04861947149038315,
0.042287398129701614,
0.01994047872722149,
-0.02506490796804428,
-0.032978784292936325,
-0.08712407946586609,
0.0041785044595599174,
0.019491100683808327,
0.008085912093520164,
-0.0002811330487020314,
-0.0009939894080162048,
-0.0410718098282814,
0.06642787158489227,
0.01741858199238777,
-0.048255570232868195,
-0.001769582275301218,
-0.0052026244811713696,
-0.015218713320791721,
0.021398212760686874,
0.009901121258735657,
0.004546699114143848,
0.02095404639840126,
-0.013531245291233063,
-0.013976311311125755,
0.005410502664744854,
0.026506276801228523,
-0.0037328556645661592,
0.01443785335868597,
-0.008905289694666862,
0.031922198832035065,
0.04591716080904007,
0.04145219549536705,
0.006677245255559683,
-0.04556404799222946,
-0.01975392736494541,
-0.0029417325276881456,
0.032270923256874084,
-0.0044653587974607944,
0.006722678896039724,
0.01578071154654026,
0.03703545778989792,
-0.025055788457393646,
0.033412665128707886,
0.05770305544137955,
0.06082819029688835,
-0.000009462547495786566,
-0.007043825462460518,
-0.03997858241200447,
0.007514581084251404,
0.008446762338280678,
0.029142189770936966,
-0.025950796902179718,
-0.043815724551677704,
0.02687254175543785,
-0.009258701466023922,
0.025691555812954903,
0.007571123540401459,
-0.019637444987893105,
-0.02394682727754116,
0.06890715658664703,
-0.0000908059228095226,
-0.009365187957882881,
0.030633805319666862,
0.026166697964072227,
-0.01885119266808033,
-0.01750965230166912,
0.009933552704751492,
-0.03714670613408089,
-0.03512832522392273,
0.0006577598978765309,
-0.02549375407397747,
-0.029316069558262825,
-0.018288936465978622,
-0.04630175977945328,
0.02396578900516033,
-0.01048777624964714,
-0.016461562365293503,
-0.04924076795578003,
-0.023489726707339287,
-0.03383282199501991,
-0.017435332760214806,
-0.013249510899186134,
0.019211696460843086,
0.03656170889735222,
-0.024094590917229652,
-0.0019258912652730942,
-0.047044750303030014,
0.012119699269533157,
0.033223964273929596,
0.030334288254380226,
0.04981432110071182,
0.008867936208844185,
0.09468311816453934,
0.07559480518102646,
-0.030659876763820648,
0.020028216764330864,
-0.021984294056892395,
-0.02360767126083374,
0.010758154094219208,
0.057486243546009064,
0.044858887791633606,
0.0027024182491004467,
0.014262937940657139,
0.04581684619188309,
-0.015219450928270817,
0.008232002146542072,
0.008893364109098911,
0.00021917515550740063,
0.047323185950517654,
0.0003872188099194318,
0.018208859488368034,
0.00420389324426651,
-0.016697179526090622,
0.049661822617053986,
-0.02459023706614971,
-0.01879776641726494,
0.0834391787648201,
-0.010237086564302444,
-0.005074454005807638,
-0.004227898549288511,
0.004284451249986887,
-0.011882808990776539,
0.009395172819495201,
-0.022505145519971848,
-0.03306979313492775,
0.0032282122410833836,
-0.011001167818903923,
0.02065121941268444,
-0.005853812210261822,
0.031347256153821945,
0.006049707531929016,
-0.008551079779863358,
-0.02146148681640625,
-0.04327133670449257,
0.02491009421646595,
-0.003485070075839758,
0.023476580157876015,
-0.037100207060575485,
-0.0039795259945094585,
0.002404966624453664,
0.015547974966466427,
0.0002330002753296867,
0.011195207014679909,
0.0127217136323452,
-0.060903679579496384,
-0.005957289133220911,
-0.032255541533231735,
0.06525981426239014,
-0.08460935205221176,
-0.0030352177564054728,
0.07881356030702591,
-0.01474226638674736,
-0.02678322046995163,
0.0009987350786104798,
-0.006162653211504221,
0.010823853313922882,
-0.03419824689626694,
0.02957228757441044,
-0.0059046498499810696,
0.007528088986873627,
0.010997012257575989,
0.020214660093188286,
-0.0007749926880933344,
0.05055471137166023,
0.022106122225522995,
0.01992509886622429,
0.005088680423796177,
-0.014041118323802948,
0.022178569808602333,
-0.002104432787746191,
-0.003965736832469702,
-0.011547811329364777,
-0.019460640847682953,
0.04190295189619064,
-0.022199830040335655,
-0.029626937583088875,
0.024982646107673645,
-0.0037854553665965796,
-0.026809293776750565,
0.012459646910429,
-0.011544235050678253,
0.01086665689945221,
-0.018729588016867638,
-0.06540525704622269,
-0.010267402045428753,
0.004283978138118982,
0.023004762828350067,
-0.0011941647389903665,
-0.04946070909500122,
-0.002773556625470519,
-0.048481062054634094,
0.0442088283598423,
-0.031800463795661926,
-0.02129111997783184,
-0.0176340751349926,
-0.02832832746207714,
-0.02658761478960514,
-0.03489154204726219,
-0.05336720496416092,
-0.02893284149467945,
-0.005141225643455982,
-0.04017375782132149,
0.005483579356223345,
0.025786785408854485,
0.005139795131981373,
0.005043969489634037,
0.005723627749830484,
-0.0030402219854295254,
0.025269098579883575,
-0.04327091947197914,
-0.003999646753072739,
0.032223090529441833,
0.02190374955534935,
0.004039583262056112,
-0.01799747720360756,
-0.02814471162855625,
0.02953190915286541,
-0.022389404475688934,
-0.006174284964799881,
0.016347412019968033,
-0.0027485890313982964,
-0.0238555409014225,
0.06449732184410095,
-0.023357056081295013,
0.02966912090778351,
-0.004304666072130203,
-0.009042280726134777,
-0.03511260822415352,
-0.021315433084964752,
-0.016920357942581177,
0.01099893357604742,
0.011257963255047798,
-0.013972059823572636,
0.026838796213269234,
0.00625868933275342,
0.0049703773111104965,
-0.09023209661245346,
0.013015180826187134,
-0.03314782306551933,
-0.007839525118470192,
0.02420567162334919,
-0.0024437366519123316,
-0.026454662904143333,
0.013470008969306946,
-0.011855746619403362,
-0.0009473797399550676,
-0.03516043350100517,
-0.0481535904109478,
-0.0030563820619136095,
-0.056616052985191345,
0.016375504434108734,
-0.01067918911576271,
-0.010985516011714935,
-0.03186694160103798,
0.0026559624820947647,
-0.0460253469645977,
-0.03727295249700546,
-0.00925404578447342,
-0.005411158781498671,
0.04754895716905594,
0.011412388645112514,
-0.07986975461244583,
-0.040689218789339066,
0.020631389692425728,
0.0055024572648108006,
0.022097643464803696,
-0.0705956518650055,
0.049964722245931625,
0.012707545422017574,
0.0007128969300538301,
-0.01886252872645855,
-0.005078956019133329,
0.02964092046022415,
-0.02005305513739586,
0.0026271746028214693,
0.009231023490428925,
-0.0172306839376688,
-0.01551186852157116,
-0.024039076641201973,
0.009080185554921627,
-0.008424838073551655,
0.00511415209621191,
0.019937118515372276,
0.011260227300226688,
-0.024394424632191658,
-0.03981126472353935,
0.020033644512295723,
-0.025393931195139885,
0.003684286493808031,
0.019849173724651337,
0.014648519456386566,
-0.0019112396985292435,
-0.02267848141491413,
0.015534820035099983,
-0.03212648630142212,
0.03504819795489311,
0.03958601877093315,
0.0023195059038698673,
0.009916231967508793,
-0.022700464352965355,
0.025021245703101158,
0.012732238508760929,
-0.004545155912637711,
-0.03940809890627861,
-0.012192134745419025,
-0.012278133071959019,
-0.07840365171432495,
-0.03953889384865761,
-0.0019773582462221384,
-0.002127442741766572,
-0.032646846026182175,
0.0014878386864438653,
0.0032808727119117975,
-0.04011008143424988,
0.02166217379271984,
-0.009562881663441658,
0.03672196343541145,
-0.02307167463004589,
-0.014248592779040337,
-0.131697878241539,
-0.013700350187718868,
0.004340879153460264,
0.010026994161307812,
-0.031813547015190125,
-0.02143985591828823,
-0.00806224811822176,
-0.010231534950435162,
-0.0025013580452650785,
-0.0399201437830925,
-0.03326075151562691,
-0.005236195400357246,
0.06968077272176743,
-0.014412980526685715,
-0.050244301557540894,
0.008025426417589188,
-0.03400679677724838,
-0.04221940413117409,
-0.02775987796485424,
0.0038860721979290247,
0.01950255036354065,
0.04042894020676613,
0.012942211702466011,
-0.03457871079444885,
-0.011620975099503994,
-0.036840204149484634,
-0.058017414063215256,
-0.027214229106903076,
-0.05121826007962227,
-0.03915578871965408,
0.0007658654358237982,
0.00809699110686779,
-0.00911414623260498,
0.011815184727311134,
-0.007845461368560791,
0.015726150944828987,
0.0032040278892964125,
0.0021139562595635653,
-0.03761402890086174,
-0.016508815810084343,
-0.0008005534182302654,
0.03503457456827164,
-0.004333498887717724,
-0.0029311629477888346,
0.004304710775613785,
0.050639472901821136,
-0.02540704794228077,
0.005996832624077797,
-0.05494679883122444,
-0.018054943531751633,
-0.0362449511885643,
0.012405752204358578,
-0.019048543646931648,
0.03399454057216644,
0.007857381366193295,
0.008200103417038918,
-0.02832847461104393,
-0.018736395984888077,
0.015629135072231293,
0.0824221670627594,
0.00968236941844225,
-0.031119730323553085,
-0.05728219076991081,
-0.023656615987420082,
0.06468648463487625,
0.041337430477142334,
-0.02624513767659664,
-0.014009629376232624,
0.0029071499593555927,
0.006805042270570993,
0.039377328008413315,
-0.00992542877793312,
-0.01565299741923809,
-0.06454527378082275,
0.017249880358576775,
-0.017919307574629784,
-0.028907982632517815,
-0.0093626007437706,
-0.01722599007189274,
-0.00873127207159996,
0.029414702206850052,
-0.02675611898303032,
-0.028489699587225914,
-0.03819665312767029,
0.046772874891757965,
0.013328204862773418,
-0.02040191739797592,
0.004675866570323706,
0.10136410593986511,
-0.03989463299512863,
-0.05234234780073166,
-0.004814233165234327,
-0.02103564143180847,
0.016129307448863983,
-0.03390092775225639,
0.050395481288433075,
0.02209569327533245,
-0.015752220526337624,
-0.020014509558677673,
-0.008912956342101097,
-0.037272270768880844,
-0.054749928414821625,
0.02249566838145256,
-0.02382672019302845,
-0.03904030844569206,
0.005653054919093847,
-0.03730473294854164,
0.024013377726078033,
0.013326166197657585,
0.015654558315873146,
-0.030510317534208298,
-0.027962245047092438,
0.01800263673067093,
0.0037786660250276327,
-0.05796922370791435,
-0.006898096762597561,
-0.005925539880990982,
0.052296191453933716,
-0.005636231973767281,
0.0066042146645486355,
0.015377955511212349,
-0.021032391116023064,
0.01832134835422039,
-0.01035945862531662,
0.00467050913721323,
-0.012298163026571274,
0.022359447553753853,
-0.004914039745926857,
0.03781701251864433,
-0.04000573977828026,
0.011034131981432438,
-0.0075257038697600365,
-0.02273831143975258,
0.02748185582458973,
0.02136676199734211,
0.051538966596126556,
-0.04661352559924126,
-0.009559396654367447,
0.0021655112504959106,
-0.021528571844100952,
0.015318703837692738,
-0.014270883053541183,
-0.010077751241624355,
0.02363337203860283,
-0.04118834063410759,
-0.007518597412854433,
-0.0016132212476804852,
0.0029911512974649668,
-0.06196029484272003,
-0.02563868835568428,
-0.05607904866337776,
0.013155380263924599,
-0.0026542088016867638,
0.07507003098726273,
0.03660661727190018,
-0.0328892357647419,
0.0141697833314538,
-0.0033324493560940027,
0.026035115122795105,
0.10122720897197723,
0.03682399541139603,
-0.0027308999560773373,
-0.04382583498954773,
-0.06187911704182625,
-0.03855851665139198,
0.04566812142729759,
-0.012834648601710796,
-0.000021496443878277205,
-0.000863350578583777,
-0.0008174704853445292,
0.03164830803871155,
0.02289123274385929,
-0.021742576733231544,
0.0172174833714962,
-0.01834438368678093,
-0.010692485608160496,
-0.02450551465153694,
-0.020156264305114746,
-0.004714291542768478,
0.010623788461089134,
0.039070114493370056,
0.03376389667391777,
0.03240508213639259,
0.024754028767347336,
0.022780470550060272,
0.03365209326148033,
0.039327025413513184,
-0.007929709739983082,
-0.0019311773357912898,
-0.02730085887014866,
-0.013932233676314354,
-0.03259603679180145,
0.006275189574807882,
-0.02358384057879448,
0.07635746896266937,
-0.0001565236016176641,
-0.01777392067015171,
0.0246276818215847,
0.02522403374314308,
0.04562472179532051,
-0.009686821140348911,
-0.07088343799114227,
-0.016073506325483322,
-0.003297853283584118,
-0.03824786841869354,
-0.06444153189659119,
0.012519750744104385,
-0.02129186876118183,
-0.034714456647634506,
0.0523165687918663,
0.024321885779500008,
0.005632575135678053,
-0.00286659924313426,
0.0640735849738121,
-0.02707047574222088,
0.004162466619163752,
0.006039561238139868,
-0.014127193950116634,
0.019369162619113922,
-0.026694906875491142,
-0.0018317721551284194,
0.0884416401386261,
-0.028991971164941788,
-0.03612106665968895,
0.0072687710635364056,
0.019726015627384186,
-0.016344139352440834,
-0.005352888256311417,
0.06181304529309273,
-0.013224753551185131,
-0.02259620651602745,
0.02576247788965702,
-0.010437679477036,
0.03140892833471298,
0.004653539042919874,
0.012857658788561821,
-0.031699441373348236,
-0.020247669890522957,
-0.013462476432323456,
-0.0063339658081531525,
0.0425175242125988,
0.0033797763753682375,
0.020736217498779297,
0.018398649990558624
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:24
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
118Mr Campbell SC contended that, even if QBE had demonstrated to the relevant standard a "liability" of Megbuy arising from its failure to maintain the forklift or allowing it to be used, the definition of injury was not satisfied, or even capable of satisfaction.
Mr Campbell SC contended that, insofar as QBE relied upon (a)(iv) of the definition of injury, the reference to "such use or operation" was a reference to the "use or operation" referred to in the opening words of the definition of "injury", which in this case was maintenance.
He contended that, even if the injury could be seen "as a result of such use or operation", it could not have said to have been caused "during" such use of operation.
Further, in relation to sub paragraphs (a)(i) to (iii) Mr Campbell SC contended that, while the physical injury to Mr Horwood might have been caused during one of those activities, it was not "as a result" of any those activities.
Mr Campbell SC referred me to the decisions in Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v GSF Australia Pty Ltd & Anor [2005] HCA 26; (2005) 221 CLR 568 ("Allianz v GSF""), Zurich Australia Insurance Ltd v CSR Ltd [2001] NSWC Act 261; (2001) 52 NSWLR 193 ("Zurich v CSR") and Zotti v Australian Associated Motor Insurers Ltd [2009] NSWCA 323 ("Zotti").
119If accepted, Mr Campbell SC's submission would have the consequence that CTP insurers do not provide cover in the event that an owner does not maintain a vehicle resulting in a defect which is causative of harm suffered to a person who is driving the vehicle or collides with the vehicle.
This strikes me as counter intuitive to say the least but that does not mean it is not correct. To address it I will refer to the three cases that Mr Campbell SC referred to in chronological order.
120In Zurich v CSR Spigelman CJ construed the reference to "such use or operation" in (a)(iv) of the definition of "injury" in the MAC Act as a reference to the "use" or "operation" referred to in the opening words of the definition of "injury" and not to the forms of use referred to in sub paragraphs (a)(i) to (a)(iii) (driving collision etc) (at [31] to [32]):
"The second submission was that the word "such" in (a)(iv) did not refer to the words "use or operation" in the opening words of par (a), but referred to the "use or operation" comprised in (i), (ii) and (iii), that is "driving", "collision" and "running out of control". This construction would deprive (iv) of all content.
Paragraph (a)(i) applies to any injury "caused during ... driving". That encompasses every injury "caused during ... driving ... by a defect in the vehicle". The same is true of pars (ii) and (iii). The construction advanced by the Appellant would leave (iv) with no work to do.
The word "such" in (iv) is, in my opinion, a reference to the preceding use of the precise words which immediately follow it, i.e. "use and operation". The repetition of this phrase in (iv) was necessitated by the fact that the sub-paragraphs are all qualified by the word "during".
It makes sense to speak of something occurring "during" driving, a collision or running out of control. It makes no sense to speak of something occurring "during" a defect. The words are repeated to identify a time dimension for (iv)." (emphasis added)
121Zurich v CSR concerned a defect in a truck which was said to be the absence of any form of hydraulic or mechanical assistance for lifting a ramp at its rear (at [68]). The claimant had been injured in the course of his employment while lifting the ramp (at [1]).
If the phrase "such use or operation" in (a)(iv) was only referrable to the forms of use referred to in (a)(i) to (iii) then the injury would not be capable of being covered by the MAC Act because it would not have occurred during any of those forms of use.
|
[
0.023646293208003044,
0.02009483613073826,
-0.026970913633704185,
-0.014893488958477974,
0.006065779831260443,
-0.0012579836184158921,
0.018940603360533714,
0.03386130928993225,
-0.011391897685825825,
0.01548872608691454,
0.011320977471768856,
0.000405818282160908,
0.010517938993871212,
-0.0001562028774060309,
0.005855843424797058,
-0.050640907138586044,
0.0320957787334919,
0.01343457866460085,
-0.026396479457616806,
-0.03339110314846039,
0.05168693885207176,
0.009575662203133106,
0.031831465661525726,
0.03519477695226669,
-0.02279786579310894,
0.03476310148835182,
-0.03070402704179287,
0.019610246643424034,
0.011711404658854008,
0.00516910757869482,
-0.024424128234386444,
0.012288752011954784,
-0.009997704066336155,
-0.031599316745996475,
0.013116625137627125,
-0.03182261437177658,
-0.04040288180112839,
0.007611221633851528,
-0.018186474218964577,
0.02188999578356743,
-0.038133956491947174,
-0.019117994233965874,
0.02377784438431263,
-0.015305696055293083,
0.06108778342604637,
-0.02783161588013172,
-0.006826350465416908,
-0.03431137651205063,
0.010708673857152462,
-0.027891553938388824,
-0.06798996776342392,
-0.016906453296542168,
0.06584784388542175,
-0.042522359639406204,
0.031324584037065506,
0.0400695875287056,
-0.023646794259548187,
-0.056576915085315704,
-0.06710205227136612,
-0.02882966212928295,
-0.02995629981160164,
-0.03413911536335945,
0.01248571090400219,
0.00910907331854105,
-0.02685490995645523,
0.07662588357925415,
0.006073709577322006,
-0.04622458666563034,
-0.011275851167738438,
-0.050432849675416946,
0.013830184005200863,
0.023871028795838356,
-0.0143083855509758,
-0.018433652818202972,
-0.06621791422367096,
0.00363184604793787,
0.016766415908932686,
0.007881075143814087,
0.0004632257914636284,
0.03590935468673706,
0.015496955253183842,
0.011517510749399662,
-0.021396426483988762,
0.013636213727295399,
-0.014659957028925419,
-0.016518300399184227,
-0.05941295996308327,
0.02028215304017067,
-0.016746249049901962,
0.02341500110924244,
0.061671141535043716,
-0.025999179109930992,
0.013512604869902134,
-0.0058051710948348045,
0.022631999105215073,
0.0025133888702839613,
-0.06058716028928757,
0.02644437737762928,
-0.030189108103513718,
0.036952171474695206,
0.011080029420554638,
0.0006683841347694397,
0.00951250921934843,
-0.045332930982112885,
0.007675834931433201,
-0.023556673899292946,
0.014678824692964554,
0.027468029409646988,
-0.006168604362756014,
0.0051466235890984535,
0.0107338335365057,
0.03267068415880203,
-0.0023359248880296946,
0.021176669746637344,
-0.004539135843515396,
0.000734305998776108,
-0.006189032457768917,
-0.0501888245344162,
0.04689928516745567,
-0.02014673687517643,
0.027765488252043724,
0.049367506057024,
0.05791009962558746,
-0.013908111490309238,
-0.04960060119628906,
-0.0016057161847129464,
-0.0032380465418100357,
0.003758769715204835,
-0.017257921397686005,
0.006788457278162241,
0.00629316084086895,
0.024535154923796654,
-0.013382340781390667,
-0.03641527518630028,
-0.04529648646712303,
-0.01866789534687996,
0.05620066449046135,
0.0047077396884560585,
-0.02128608152270317,
-0.05142979696393013,
0.049543656408786774,
0.004159647040069103,
0.04149021953344345,
-0.022608008235692978,
0.028867030516266823,
-0.029847178608179092,
0.04292406886816025,
-0.021803241223096848,
0.01946447044610977,
-0.0028849784284830093,
0.001578457304276526,
0.00007870357512729242,
-0.009880997240543365,
-0.07260596752166748,
0.02168509177863598,
-0.02107643336057663,
-0.030656883493065834,
-0.006332349963486195,
-0.008760115131735802,
0.012904862873256207,
0.017418034374713898,
0.06682060658931732,
-0.03765967860817909,
-0.028696155175566673,
0.04187268391251564,
-0.0027110883966088295,
0.008770079351961613,
0.04137752205133438,
-0.04381689429283142,
-0.0061009046621620655,
0.0056063588708639145,
-0.012678022496402264,
0.0425742045044899,
-0.02957371063530445,
0.047397758811712265,
0.041435107588768005,
0.05146216228604317,
0.019683759659528732,
0.0021289268042892218,
-0.03933996334671974,
0.006269919686019421,
-0.00180439418181777,
0.01312421914190054,
-0.02266741171479225,
-0.025922339409589767,
-0.01966908387839794,
0.01170338038355112,
-0.03638646751642227,
0.02446695975959301,
0.005871124099940062,
-0.005478454288095236,
-0.04817552864551544,
-0.0038625092711299658,
0.02734273672103882,
0.025149047374725342,
-0.007955742999911308,
0.04030315950512886,
0.007748901844024658,
0.03784788399934769,
-0.0357942096889019,
0.033071111887693405,
0.013462408445775509,
0.0437542125582695,
-0.050464555621147156,
-0.05231913551688194,
-0.02253972552716732,
-0.03849468752741814,
0.04530375078320503,
-0.00006692273746011779,
-0.058773137629032135,
0.05620615929365158,
-0.03243762627243996,
0.033314310014247894,
0.0221174918115139,
-0.026485217735171318,
-0.0016862757038325071,
-0.014356267638504505,
-0.002939997473731637,
0.00782800279557705,
0.0020033838227391243,
-0.0101771866902709,
-0.023827381432056427,
-0.02994924783706665,
0.02505195327103138,
0.035899464040994644,
0.0073448671028018,
-0.011287122964859009,
0.04882079362869263,
-0.0058768270537257195,
0.013128109276294708,
0.02807139791548252,
0.006795286666601896,
0.03608303144574165,
-0.0350879542529583,
0.05173690989613533,
0.01539461687207222,
0.054510802030563354,
0.007242303807288408,
0.01432378776371479,
0.0007484260713681579,
-0.010294021107256413,
-0.060919295996427536,
0.06030062958598137,
-0.03729122504591942,
-0.029933838173747063,
-0.007107023615390062,
0.013546469621360302,
0.007381059229373932,
0.008918036706745625,
0.009030557237565517,
0.052816178649663925,
-0.010541821829974651,
-0.02216303162276745,
-0.013925435952842236,
0.018710218369960785,
0.01341606117784977,
0.0324682779610157,
-0.005414060782641172,
0.0010672489879652858,
-0.02404988557100296,
-0.0056226723827421665,
0.05324454978108406,
0.027719253674149513,
-0.011992783285677433,
-0.0038869946729391813,
-0.05588782951235771,
-0.010934822261333466,
-0.011486813426017761,
-0.058556921780109406,
0.003100658766925335,
0.019152283668518066,
-0.0008805139223113656,
-0.02402437850832939,
-0.0003443720634095371,
-0.0062517221085727215,
0.0298443753272295,
0.01419752649962902,
-0.02919749915599823,
0.041423164308071136,
0.0214011799544096,
0.040258005261421204,
0.01297034602612257,
0.0009253680473193526,
-0.0713590756058693,
0.02999800816178322,
-0.012117283418774605,
0.010557286441326141,
-0.04826200380921364,
-0.010098169557750225,
-0.06605155766010284,
0.03313600644469261,
-0.018771128728985786,
0.06495313346385956,
-0.02615739218890667,
-0.053586412221193314,
0.006363520398736,
-0.005392011255025864,
-0.15336720645427704,
-0.016456924378871918,
0.028294967487454414,
0.03193793445825577,
0.00915400218218565,
0.017702840268611908,
-0.028475172817707062,
-0.006221705581992865,
-0.021956615149974823,
0.012349463067948818,
0.009673277847468853,
-0.06215779483318329,
-0.040056582540273666,
0.01672137901186943,
0.02779684029519558,
-0.03135642409324646,
-0.0401214174926281,
-0.003670872887596488,
-0.0031762244179844856,
-0.018810633569955826,
0.01567511074244976,
0.008009519428014755,
-0.006776592694222927,
-0.0020805541425943375,
-0.01631631888449192,
-0.013191977515816689,
0.04060627520084381,
0.011447577737271786,
-0.0456632561981678,
-0.02367389015853405,
-0.04613802582025528,
-0.016490692272782326,
-0.02366754785180092,
0.03745594993233681,
0.04417072981595993,
0.03251488134264946,
0.04458579421043396,
-0.07615207880735397,
-0.01917312480509281,
0.003696118714287877,
0.020267179235816002,
0.0986952930688858,
0.00027800994575954974,
0.030492251738905907,
0.0014603124000132084,
-0.06823433190584183,
0.015329861082136631,
-0.00025748182088136673,
-0.013447512872517109,
-0.0019568665884435177,
-0.030178215354681015,
-0.03689287602901459,
-0.001704907976090908,
-0.002533006714656949,
-0.007191801443696022,
-0.02228788286447525,
0.03966602310538292,
0.04921705275774002,
0.004023291636258364,
0.03233376145362854,
-0.0008892362238839269,
-0.03201107308268547,
-0.0042587206698954105,
0.004929148592054844,
-0.061725981533527374,
0.012024478986859322,
-0.005962406285107136,
0.006954571697860956,
0.06351469457149506,
-0.03642057999968529,
-0.019164497032761574,
-0.020744377747178078,
0.016291726380586624,
-0.008753378875553608,
-0.02357214130461216,
-0.010615931823849678,
0.0005117307300679386,
0.008748776279389858,
-0.012033810839056969,
-0.0800485759973526,
-0.013907024636864662,
0.006759799085557461,
0.01283522229641676,
0.02164069190621376,
-0.015003237873315811,
0.03329699486494064,
0.02330910414457321,
0.02157558500766754,
-0.005668364465236664,
0.227714404463768,
0.014634882099926472,
-0.027015624567866325,
-0.018476588651537895,
0.009012154303491116,
-0.004456807859241962,
0.028484607115387917,
0.008756961673498154,
0.011874550022184849,
-0.04532107710838318,
-0.048169925808906555,
0.0004393477865960449,
-0.007684650830924511,
0.0315348356962204,
-0.028147052973508835,
-0.05084127187728882,
-0.03884400427341461,
-0.05096105858683586,
0.07812099158763885,
-0.023835835978388786,
0.03664221614599228,
0.008277924731373787,
0.04141147807240486,
0.003222688799723983,
-0.06749413907527924,
-0.025408949702978134,
-0.019837573170661926,
-0.018850775435566902,
-0.02124541997909546,
0.02750886045396328,
-0.030907606706023216,
-0.01721569336950779,
0.02128361538052559,
-0.016794856637716293,
-0.03736371546983719,
-0.019144654273986816,
-0.034633226692676544,
-0.0008712081471458077,
-0.06119028851389885,
0.03401760384440422,
0.025272885337471962,
-0.005582374986261129,
-0.012879890389740467,
0.010753334499895573,
0.013913114555180073,
-0.00709430081769824,
-0.001674349419772625,
-0.011505717411637306,
0.014223093166947365,
0.012245035730302334,
-0.0407898910343647,
0.02923770062625408,
-0.019593117758631706,
0.020544448867440224,
-0.030647072941064835,
0.002180288312956691,
-0.01625257357954979,
0.014890339225530624,
0.008856113068759441,
0.008847714401781559,
0.02717418596148491,
0.018556173890829086,
-0.01993933692574501,
0.04642276465892792,
-0.007452951744198799,
0.032452668994665146,
-0.008303241804242134,
-0.013458392582833767,
0.03174220398068428,
-0.014308927580714226,
0.004728812258690596,
0.026427138596773148,
0.03289361670613289,
0.016746297478675842,
0.04587266966700554,
0.006246638484299183,
0.008338703773915768,
0.014926762320101261,
-0.015509971417486668,
0.016030974686145782,
-0.041920386254787445,
-0.03129550442099571,
-0.011752108111977577,
-0.05175798013806343,
0.020605871453881264,
-0.009642811492085457,
-0.033446621149778366,
0.06014726310968399,
0.04764527082443237,
-0.020816626027226448,
-0.03357953950762749,
-0.03148829936981201,
0.005568141117691994,
0.005273128859698772,
-0.055950526148080826,
0.027325298637151718,
0.01813616044819355,
0.012377995997667313,
-0.021125666797161102,
-0.05930853635072708,
-0.01871105469763279,
-0.008893928490579128,
-0.017349736765027046,
0.008891589939594269,
0.01918579638004303,
0.006315461825579405,
0.01374885905534029,
-0.014621161855757236,
-0.03922462835907936,
0.0010784617625176907,
0.006829654332250357,
0.02523505501449108,
-0.02369127981364727,
0.009527082554996014,
0.013253811746835709,
0.014567717909812927,
-0.041091859340667725,
0.07051284611225128,
0.04057237505912781,
0.06851571053266525,
-0.04830954968929291,
0.010704882442951202,
-0.023929158225655556,
0.0007944952812977135,
-0.021131541579961777,
-0.00548080587759614,
-0.05455921217799187,
-0.03771541267633438,
-0.020523739978671074,
0.04149462282657623,
0.005700598005205393,
-0.010241016745567322,
-0.04418328031897545,
0.006837182212620974,
0.05685977637767792,
-0.03233742341399193,
-0.024000093340873718,
0.05557246133685112,
-0.0018415615195408463,
0.009926394559442997,
-0.01490043941885233,
-0.007520885206758976,
-0.0424550324678421,
0.03912508115172386,
0.0040770103223621845,
-0.008899347856640816,
-0.03011389449238777,
-0.004930880386382341,
-0.037404295057058334,
-0.018389545381069183,
0.0323890782892704,
0.0014897906221449375,
-0.019413376227021217,
-0.04578700289130211,
-0.0059056212194263935,
-0.025141408666968346,
-0.0008342263754457235,
0.02864023670554161,
0.010499328374862671,
-0.03932476043701172,
-0.019347762688994408,
-0.03265354782342911,
-0.00781850516796112,
0.04180087894201279,
0.025189261883497238,
0.004452835768461227,
0.00349607621319592,
0.042763181030750275,
0.01734069362282753,
0.013609340414404869,
-0.01075336616486311,
-0.049071066081523895,
-0.014457368291914463,
0.050863541662693024,
0.04260646179318428,
0.05817990005016327,
0.004216396249830723,
-0.00473877415060997,
-0.010519707575440407,
-0.0004288738709874451,
-0.024778516963124275,
0.01553297322243452,
0.0012672983575612307,
0.007314995862543583,
-0.05938291922211647,
0.030525851994752884,
0.05487101152539253,
-0.019321244210004807,
-0.008419506251811981,
-0.02439504861831665,
-0.01655968278646469,
0.09138467162847519,
-0.026023097336292267,
-0.004657524637877941,
0.029964828863739967,
0.004635997582226992,
0.02879718877375126,
-0.008589101955294609,
-0.014923407696187496,
-0.05212685838341713,
-0.016457574442029,
0.023185530677437782,
-0.010406342335045338,
0.03422544151544571,
0.021269185468554497,
-0.036592207849025726,
0.018885893747210503,
0.012355724349617958,
-0.010020389221608639,
-0.021159013733267784,
0.008215458132326603,
-0.010579977184534073,
-0.040302254259586334,
0.011364374309778214,
-0.043095413595438004,
0.003459961386397481,
0.027262156829237938,
0.055356141179800034,
0.015871811658143997,
-0.042078085243701935,
-0.029188185930252075,
-0.007190903183072805,
0.062228113412857056,
-0.07095856219530106,
0.004128489643335342,
0.050794173032045364,
0.04577459394931793,
-0.04379858076572418,
0.008870727382600307,
-0.011651268228888512,
0.004283069632947445,
-0.018277917057275772,
0.001449534553103149,
-0.0033666957169771194,
0.016002388671040535,
0.0023067635484039783,
0.03456158563494682,
0.009429356083273888,
0.04658622294664383,
-0.01634206995368004,
0.04650530964136124,
-0.0024576648138463497,
0.01609741896390915,
0.061381347477436066,
-0.02967997081577778,
-0.009455380029976368,
-0.02097044140100479,
-0.00458027608692646,
0.03613320365548134,
0.033485278487205505,
-0.012714767828583717,
0.04701464995741844,
0.03686436265707016,
-0.033992666751146317,
-0.03383370116353035,
-0.015592577867209911,
-0.00953653734177351,
0.015798743814229965,
-0.06347085535526276,
-0.023621106520295143,
-0.012484663166105747,
0.030287278816103935,
-0.003934926353394985,
-0.02339274436235428,
0.015949618071317673,
-0.061911601573228836,
0.00846807286143303,
0.008044722490012646,
-0.025094324722886086,
-0.006495526526123285,
-0.034382641315460205,
0.020005734637379646,
-0.04247066006064415,
-0.03616492450237274,
-0.037586476653814316,
0.006986836902797222,
-0.02604299783706665,
0.01788601651787758,
0.033466141670942307,
-0.0024338604416698217,
0.02712932787835598,
0.006054094526916742,
0.00740036740899086,
0.044239141047000885,
0.0018734649056568742,
0.04687918350100517,
0.01510563213378191,
-0.0006581911002285779,
0.02835308574140072,
-0.033243630081415176,
0.029122039675712585,
0.0072928741574287415,
-0.010757475160062313,
-0.014132389798760414,
-0.034805797040462494,
0.00948800053447485,
0.01139019150286913,
0.0725812017917633,
-0.016797862946987152,
0.009466061368584633,
-0.0009058506111614406,
0.021743785589933395,
-0.04175543412566185,
-0.05468624085187912,
0.0023927930742502213,
0.0006965771899558604,
0.01758204959332943,
-0.04598872363567352,
0.029926205053925514,
0.0008977179531939328,
0.00554546806961298,
-0.02350967563688755,
-0.0065148682333528996,
-0.021419208496809006,
0.0041260067373514175,
0.01816161349415779,
-0.01941601000726223,
-0.00746218953281641,
0.02239956147968769,
0.0371856689453125,
-0.022522974759340286,
-0.0002707697858568281,
-0.06033744290471077,
0.00029943836852908134,
-0.06570964306592941,
-0.00160113419406116,
-0.005982653703540564,
-0.02492421865463257,
-0.045090507715940475,
-0.0046227192506194115,
-0.02677694708108902,
-0.0130100566893816,
0.005395724903792143,
0.0058656977489590645,
0.07050849497318268,
0.002742481417953968,
-0.047011878341436386,
-0.05554879084229469,
0.027713553979992867,
-0.018889781087636948,
0.049709465354681015,
-0.0783608928322792,
0.0733601450920105,
-0.023897187784314156,
0.012181932106614113,
0.007447206415235996,
-0.0008693102863617241,
0.01808871328830719,
0.018255161121487617,
0.02758844941854477,
0.0041851457208395,
0.008342646062374115,
-0.01992659457027912,
-0.012667187489569187,
0.02868538163602352,
0.03355886787176132,
-0.014913994818925858,
0.021388063207268715,
-0.00440319674089551,
-0.024888429790735245,
-0.04525269567966461,
0.04197844862937927,
-0.02164633758366108,
0.030496440827846527,
0.026078999042510986,
-0.009955144487321377,
-0.014381821267306805,
0.02410922199487686,
0.020144926384091377,
-0.021825434640049934,
0.004173021297901869,
-0.03189299255609512,
0.01959523931145668,
-0.0037771330680698156,
-0.0002812661696225405,
-0.009192809462547302,
0.034186139702796936,
0.02104661427438259,
-0.02272152528166771,
-0.009037774987518787,
-0.03545590117573738,
-0.04551303759217262,
-0.0456937775015831,
0.010536031797528267,
-0.011983862146735191,
-0.011426803655922413,
-0.035324133932590485,
-0.009845772758126259,
-0.03722290322184563,
0.04122352972626686,
-0.019907036796212196,
0.0584355890750885,
-0.022181013599038124,
0.03401528298854828,
-0.13534004986286163,
0.026735790073871613,
0.0016933548031374812,
0.0009258189238607883,
-0.06306188553571701,
0.005737225525081158,
-0.012089691124856472,
0.009506121277809143,
-0.017796996980905533,
-0.03132385388016701,
0.0024036578834056854,
-0.012010707519948483,
0.07518769800662994,
-0.0009535098215565085,
-0.05123274028301239,
0.03068099170923233,
-0.042028285562992096,
-0.051133207976818085,
-0.03959693759679794,
0.017182618379592896,
0.013971752487123013,
0.023776229470968246,
0.02503632754087448,
-0.010560301132500172,
-0.010771254077553749,
-0.02528049238026142,
-0.05882512778043747,
-0.009316894225776196,
-0.031377390027046204,
0.020650353282690048,
0.012052986770868301,
-0.04687076061964035,
0.017136365175247192,
0.0367649681866169,
-0.008126877248287201,
0.034863997250795364,
-0.001688902615569532,
-0.016397986561059952,
-0.05541575700044632,
-0.014474866911768913,
-0.011982293799519539,
-0.008611203171312809,
-0.0175595972687006,
-0.0019170971354469657,
0.011713089421391487,
0.004585361573845148,
0.0008767044055275619,
-0.013560561463236809,
-0.008488472551107407,
-0.011976032517850399,
-0.04829646646976471,
0.009505578316748142,
-0.03252066299319267,
0.00717950938269496,
-0.0028383289463818073,
0.029596945270895958,
-0.03129199892282486,
-0.023452572524547577,
-0.03328913077712059,
0.049419667571783066,
0.005042416509240866,
0.010396531783044338,
-0.04180304706096649,
-0.033625878393650055,
0.0521184466779232,
0.001389139797538519,
-0.007124361116439104,
0.00958500150591135,
0.022730393335223198,
0.029184706509113312,
0.009995277971029282,
-0.00893548596650362,
-0.0001507231645518914,
-0.0018932574894279242,
-0.022949224337935448,
0.013002893887460232,
0.01732432097196579,
-0.01297819521278143,
0.04200613871216774,
0.028196802362799644,
0.018866870552301407,
-0.01960153691470623,
-0.014555473811924458,
0.02634238637983799,
0.04292638599872589,
0.008946165442466736,
0.012517341412603855,
-0.027696777135133743,
0.06374114751815796,
-0.04745735228061676,
-0.0657304897904396,
0.01577708125114441,
-0.02581619657576084,
0.07234079390764236,
-0.020687108859419823,
0.06547265499830246,
0.0074257031083106995,
-0.002481097588315606,
-0.01127399317920208,
-0.038324110209941864,
0.01757645793259144,
0.025431113317608833,
0.01987151987850666,
0.0005483560380525887,
-0.011597859673202038,
0.02536691538989544,
-0.02988750860095024,
0.0028279004618525505,
0.021010519936680794,
-0.0015992079861462116,
-0.03727889433503151,
-0.04847392439842224,
-0.03565119206905365,
-0.01806112751364708,
-0.03731982037425041,
0.01009192131459713,
-0.01999407634139061,
0.02755449153482914,
-0.026323633268475533,
0.004175469744950533,
0.03318796679377556,
-0.061637092381715775,
0.033010177314281464,
-0.015896987169981003,
0.013444368727505207,
0.05556792393326759,
0.04912734404206276,
0.004798291716724634,
-0.005554152652621269,
-0.03019036538898945,
0.04571271687746048,
0.00467338552698493,
-0.023638352751731873,
0.013945119455456734,
-0.02783219702541828,
0.03971169888973236,
-0.0022436585277318954,
-0.004083176143467426,
-0.021387185901403427,
-0.01114571001380682,
0.004612476099282503,
-0.002751509891822934,
0.0041967169381678104,
-0.023837780579924583,
-0.030592769384384155,
-0.026225842535495758,
-0.012559513561427593,
0.001140298438258469,
-0.006399385631084442,
-0.030003584921360016,
-0.008215682581067085,
0.013542276807129383,
0.014192981645464897,
0.08870553225278854,
0.003241795813664794,
-0.04032713547348976,
0.020309560000896454,
0.0388406440615654,
-0.014699246734380722,
0.0511675663292408,
0.05769838020205498,
-0.005033039953559637,
-0.028996562585234642,
-0.043392665684223175,
0.003956783562898636,
0.032219212502241135,
0.007019231095910072,
0.004655720200389624,
-0.0006425345200113952,
-0.003917577676475048,
-0.007659403141587973,
-0.011895311996340752,
-0.016816165298223495,
-0.0016180158127099276,
0.03627082705497742,
-0.054472994059324265,
-0.017962360754609108,
0.0351715050637722,
0.01601571775972843,
-0.019757861271500587,
0.033327970653772354,
0.0297752283513546,
0.03827594593167305,
0.021661847829818726,
0.006196062080562115,
0.016018329188227654,
0.00276304897852242,
-0.010931408032774925,
-0.011578078381717205,
-0.03318219259381294,
0.0050702220760285854,
-0.0017563457367941737,
0.02856707014143467,
-0.04388388618826866,
0.05335640162229538,
0.02424607239663601,
-0.01789514347910881,
0.032235704362392426,
0.007031954359263182,
0.031326815485954285,
0.0067949858494102955,
-0.013358892872929573,
0.0016201466787606478,
-0.023194629698991776,
-0.043295055627822876,
-0.01196328829973936,
-0.0140671506524086,
-0.02198408916592598,
-0.03360416367650032,
0.06889420002698898,
0.0008808410493656993,
-0.011095077730715275,
-0.0006810587365180254,
0.052212588489055634,
-0.0380995012819767,
0.001742761698551476,
-0.029294803738594055,
-0.004745325073599815,
-0.006276281550526619,
0.0353781133890152,
0.028463365510106087,
0.050552673637866974,
0.016032524406909943,
-0.05258333310484886,
0.01606334187090397,
0.02101750858128071,
-0.028606517240405083,
0.004911046475172043,
0.022926002740859985,
-0.01578330807387829,
0.017014270648360252,
-0.029639380052685738,
-0.02005673758685589,
0.06220840662717819,
0.03972990810871124,
-0.03087286464869976,
-0.013738281093537807,
-0.014596717432141304,
-0.0021246038377285004,
-0.03771783038973808,
0.08776445686817169,
-0.007796107325702906,
0.027106892317533493,
-0.00208092387765646
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:15
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
It also included s 93 which enabled the issue of prohibition notices prohibiting the carrying out of any activity which in the opinion of an investigator was said to involve an immediate risk to health or safety of a person at a place of work.
The OHS Act contemplated that the investigation of workplace accidents might lead to criminal prosecutions, lesser forms of enforcement action or to no enforcement action being taken.
69The WorkCover log records that an investigation commenced in November 2005 and in the early part of 2006 various improvement notices were issued. The conversation with Mr Gillett referred to above occurred on 7 June 2006.
The log contains an entry for 13 June 2006 recording the opinion of a Workcover officer that "the incident requires full investigation and that it was upgraded to Category B". The entries for 15 August 2006, 14 September 2006 and 11 October 2006 record consideration being given to whether a prosecution would be commenced. In the end result no such prosecution occurred.
70It seems that by the time of the representation made by Mr Gillett to a WorkCover officer on 7 June 2006 the only matter to be considered by WorkCover was whether a prosecution would be commenced or not. In my view this is more than sufficient to result in s 69(3)(b) being engaged. The representations were clearly made "in connection with" an investigation.
By at least 7 June 2006 the investigation was clearly one "relating to ... a criminal proceeding" even if one did not eventuate. The evidentiary status of a representation under s 69 of the Evidence Act is not altered by a decision made after the time that it is made not to commence a prosecution.
71The second document which was the subject of an objection that I reserved upon was a signed statement of Mr Oates bearing the date 25 June 2007. Mr Oates was not made available for cross examination. Mr Cavanagh SC sought to tender the statement in accordance with ss 63(1) of the Evidence Act.
It was said that Mr Oates was "unavailable" to give evidence and, in particular, that "all reasonable steps have been taken, by [QBE], to find [Mr Oates] or secure his ... attendance, but without success" (see ss 4(1)(f) of Part 2 of the Dictionary to the Evidence Act).
72The evidence said to establish that Mr Oates was unavailable was set out in an affidavit from QBE's solicitor. On 19 December 2011 he retained a private investigator to locate Mr Oates. He provided him with Mr Oates' last known residential address in Broken Hill and last known contact telephone numbers. The investigator worked through the holiday period.
On 6 January 2012 he reported that he had identified a "Facebook" account for Mr Oates, contact details for a number of "key relatives" and a "possible suspect residential address". He reported that he had spoken to someone who answered the phone number that he had obtained for the "key relatives" but that this person had seemed "evasive and protective of [Mr Oates] and his whereabouts".
73On 10 January 2012 the private investigator reported that he was unable to locate the current whereabouts of Mr Oates. He stated that he had been able to locate an "active Facebook account" for Mr Oates. Mr Oates' "Facebook wall" recorded that his current city was Broken Hill and that his listed work was said to be the "Sturt Club".
The investigator contacted the Sturt Club which advised that Mr Oates was a member and not an employee and that, to the best of their knowledge, he was "working in Queensland in mining; most likely Townsville".
They advised that he flew in and out of Broken Hill. The investigator also reported that inquiries had been made of a neighbour of a relative of Mr Oates. The neighbour confirmed that the relative was Mr Oates' brother, that Mr Oates did not live with his brother and was not known to the neighbour.
|
[
-0.0249941423535347,
0.033056121319532394,
-0.043173082172870636,
-0.006060200743377209,
0.0010510755237191916,
-0.00795462355017662,
-0.01463309582322836,
0.01132935844361782,
0.02927357517182827,
0.005903004202991724,
0.0135261295363307,
0.01894395239651203,
-0.007422635331749916,
-0.018150102347135544,
0.04512583091855049,
-0.009908563457429409,
0.04206690192222595,
-0.028469230979681015,
-0.018327094614505768,
-0.01597473956644535,
-0.02414022386074066,
-0.024620123207569122,
0.030544007197022438,
0.04480360448360443,
-0.008234639652073383,
0.024749059230089188,
-0.008415541611611843,
-0.03140490874648094,
-0.011748810298740864,
-0.01838965341448784,
0.025831313803792,
-0.021374743431806564,
0.017396746203303337,
0.010473323054611683,
-0.006876826751977205,
-0.019372815266251564,
0.016240041702985764,
0.01810017041862011,
-0.04044303670525551,
-0.008961108513176441,
-0.01976819522678852,
0.022395217791199684,
0.04412350803613663,
-0.034619733691215515,
0.0007246239692904055,
-0.05716400220990181,
-0.012336106039583683,
0.0018340275855734944,
-0.0011830813018605113,
0.0023940270766615868,
-0.01999165117740631,
0.0037292889319360256,
0.02441873960196972,
-0.04033569619059563,
-0.007611660286784172,
-0.032365210354328156,
0.0065963780507445335,
-0.019746020436286926,
-0.08433909714221954,
-0.03612504526972771,
0.010366982780396938,
-0.035582344979047775,
-0.044625505805015564,
-0.019545461982488632,
0.01979166641831398,
0.06684692203998566,
-0.01131374854594469,
-0.012289192527532578,
-0.007086341734975576,
-0.012774721719324589,
-0.0019238187232986093,
-0.007617729716002941,
-0.007786647416651249,
-0.003056915942579508,
-0.027882665395736694,
-0.01179641392081976,
0.013676449656486511,
-0.013546121306717396,
0.01318021398037672,
0.039104510098695755,
0.02051478810608387,
0.041661158204078674,
0.033387765288352966,
0.029406465590000153,
-0.025791311636567116,
0.017345834523439407,
0.0015257640043273568,
0.02799629420042038,
0.020226430147886276,
-0.04993755370378494,
-0.012151911854743958,
0.006616619415581226,
0.030956381931900978,
-0.0345001295208931,
-0.03304535895586014,
0.006030417513102293,
0.013077513314783573,
-0.009935627691447735,
-0.007359185256063938,
0.023423796519637108,
-0.008926711045205593,
0.02224554494023323,
-0.0007657727692276239,
-0.02438478171825409,
-0.006507236044853926,
0.02630254626274109,
0.017937475815415382,
0.07302355021238327,
0.020937224850058556,
-0.0058951061218976974,
-0.0011969564948230982,
-0.015171915292739868,
-0.01423170231282711,
0.03209877759218216,
-0.0048593501560389996,
0.011109068989753723,
0.041646815836429596,
-0.0011260199826210737,
-0.04883915185928345,
-0.004221262875944376,
0.04474229738116264,
0.012197580188512802,
0.06156112253665924,
-0.049851346760988235,
-0.026942066848278046,
-0.023968679830431938,
0.013729671947658062,
-0.025759881362318993,
0.0006614777958020568,
0.009434284642338753,
-0.011614774353802204,
-0.021370265632867813,
-0.03597100079059601,
-0.06910262256860733,
-0.03977420926094055,
-0.033322107046842575,
0.009054986760020256,
0.007807772606611252,
0.017727093771100044,
0.0065077184699475765,
0.05938832461833954,
0.032470859587192535,
-0.01529155857861042,
-0.006381019949913025,
0.017733018845319748,
-0.04319758340716362,
-0.0012424369342625141,
0.007515495177358389,
0.04537104442715645,
-0.04124382510781288,
0.023121334612369537,
0.008590597659349442,
0.016411522403359413,
0.0002262709167553112,
0.026390451937913895,
-0.03717634454369545,
0.008141432888805866,
-0.024595795199275017,
0.00781235471367836,
-0.0022981970105320215,
-0.0009333381312899292,
0.04151073470711708,
-0.0430632084608078,
-0.018248362466692924,
0.04857470467686653,
-0.009167204611003399,
0.0022847591899335384,
0.008264264091849327,
-0.02591283619403839,
-0.013007836416363716,
0.010030054487287998,
-0.03650409355759621,
0.016458677127957344,
-0.03775396570563316,
0.03760657459497452,
0.010570969432592392,
0.05287456139922142,
0.029385607689619064,
0.010588152334094048,
-0.048123300075531006,
-0.02185680903494358,
0.04103891924023628,
0.004024777095764875,
0.013574068434536457,
0.006352494470775127,
0.004877173807471991,
-0.016137301921844482,
-0.014669534750282764,
0.031640660017728806,
0.019205396994948387,
-0.013256130740046501,
-0.04239563271403313,
0.03430290147662163,
0.014665872789919376,
0.010496648028492928,
-0.018897414207458496,
-0.006156807765364647,
-0.027378393337130547,
-0.02045437879860401,
0.0031894510611891747,
-0.03620852157473564,
0.03704346343874931,
0.06894947588443756,
-0.043655432760715485,
-0.058411769568920135,
0.02312297746539116,
0.010712115094065666,
-0.003976691979914904,
0.024501323699951172,
-0.09645728021860123,
-0.016710974276065826,
0.05787457153201103,
-0.005831511691212654,
0.03520932048559189,
-0.024276234209537506,
-0.020596904680132866,
0.0011053443886339664,
-0.016132548451423645,
-0.034080494195222855,
-0.018829967826604843,
-0.02610139548778534,
-0.015048515982925892,
0.00926709920167923,
-0.03401698172092438,
0.06928092241287231,
0.04890761896967888,
-0.002184968674555421,
0.031151603907346725,
0.01803644374012947,
-0.03209516033530235,
0.03316576033830643,
0.0036289968993514776,
0.02365441434085369,
-0.026043931022286415,
0.005303922574967146,
0.00026313247508369386,
-0.004343793727457523,
0.02461584471166134,
0.026940856128931046,
0.043007101863622665,
0.01592126488685608,
-0.006125519517809153,
0.048338789492845535,
-0.026523731648921967,
-0.009293950162827969,
-0.004676168784499168,
0.0005146865732967854,
0.04141221567988396,
0.0390532985329628,
0.003703430760651827,
0.021248625591397285,
0.01062011532485485,
-0.03233683854341507,
-0.0018152797129005194,
0.032901376485824585,
0.009131480939686298,
0.010403490625321865,
-0.01786705106496811,
0.004858920816332102,
-0.007952949032187462,
0.015045094303786755,
0.021338671445846558,
-0.001576224691234529,
-0.008149628527462482,
0.008444675244390965,
-0.03172142058610916,
-0.027518989518284798,
-0.059117939323186874,
-0.0013665447477251291,
-0.0039893812499940395,
0.018103286623954773,
0.013739465735852718,
-0.017696689814329147,
-0.0045485650189220905,
0.01856287196278572,
-0.053540173918008804,
-0.008072204887866974,
-0.003670147620141506,
0.00010979657236021012,
0.0025435120332986116,
0.0011314660077914596,
0.012554082088172436,
0.02173970453441143,
0.017576079815626144,
0.004398979712277651,
0.00239747972227633,
0.024570392444729805,
-0.013599326834082603,
-0.008968641050159931,
-0.05040351301431656,
0.024213479831814766,
0.012304247356951237,
0.08162499219179153,
-0.010355900041759014,
-0.04066071659326553,
-0.005467061419039965,
-0.018570173531770706,
-0.14282992482185364,
-0.02263723313808441,
0.017150094732642174,
0.04538073390722275,
0.0254900511354208,
0.024354159832000732,
0.003034755354747176,
0.014383535832166672,
-0.02950277365744114,
0.0005529040354304016,
0.004841422662138939,
-0.07269440591335297,
-0.03207530081272125,
0.00663407426327467,
-0.02299468033015728,
-0.011275716125965118,
-0.014172187075018883,
0.012649573385715485,
0.02287597395479679,
-0.05846335366368294,
0.0037411884404718876,
-0.040954504162073135,
0.03673531487584114,
0.05071692541241646,
0.020292477682232857,
-0.0024902084842324257,
0.07339679449796677,
0.025548797100782394,
-0.04179620370268822,
-0.019840195775032043,
-0.009984223172068596,
-0.018612951040267944,
0.005106951575726271,
0.034648291766643524,
0.013023861683905125,
0.021159399300813675,
0.01024621818214655,
-0.09240711480379105,
-0.0071562789380550385,
-0.008905659429728985,
0.028445780277252197,
0.045168258249759674,
-0.008912494406104088,
0.03359339386224747,
0.046780847012996674,
-0.08807913959026337,
0.009728167206048965,
-0.003499684389680624,
-0.0788290724158287,
-0.0044098361395299435,
-0.040490712970495224,
0.005765336100012064,
-0.023396626114845276,
-0.04381042718887329,
0.004806271754205227,
-0.023041920736432076,
0.03362525627017021,
0.016175419092178345,
-0.0592399537563324,
0.010572918690741062,
0.023775311186909676,
-0.07543051987886429,
0.04512440785765648,
0.01281155738979578,
0.0005416709464043379,
0.013113867491483688,
-0.046225517988204956,
-0.011201389133930206,
0.01959644816815853,
0.017041726037859917,
0.003929621540009975,
-0.07390322536230087,
-0.01194731704890728,
0.02162342332303524,
0.00714205764234066,
0.01777644082903862,
-0.011690126731991768,
0.00004078312122146599,
0.0036707620602101088,
-0.11200067400932312,
-0.025009967386722565,
0.040906019508838654,
0.007671935949474573,
0.055091824382543564,
0.008180973120033741,
0.02248239889740944,
0.0457039475440979,
0.04479921981692314,
0.04360024631023407,
0.22835449874401093,
0.030141089111566544,
-0.024168996140360832,
-0.012127951718866825,
0.0010313412640243769,
0.003878713818266988,
0.003702206537127495,
0.0326789952814579,
0.005790284834802151,
-0.04337047040462494,
-0.045299626886844635,
-0.013963861390948296,
0.05934276804327965,
0.0016503740334883332,
0.0030747109558433294,
-0.0017061976250261068,
-0.030178790912032127,
-0.01668720692396164,
0.07280831784009933,
-0.018291659653186798,
0.04039599001407623,
-0.009952268563210964,
0.04687299579381943,
0.05329374223947525,
-0.03418227285146713,
-0.006678162608295679,
-0.046546973288059235,
0.03817747160792351,
0.014578503556549549,
0.019282346591353416,
0.010707010515034199,
0.014885468408465385,
0.004106630105525255,
-0.012649698182940483,
-0.025331545621156693,
0.03903045877814293,
-0.0494534894824028,
-0.02432192862033844,
0.005838988348841667,
0.05332468822598457,
-0.04323985055088997,
-0.0007037239847704768,
-0.0274472925812006,
-0.03747498244047165,
0.021284732967615128,
0.005079517140984535,
0.00236100354231894,
0.04132535681128502,
-0.022307369858026505,
0.01216078083962202,
-0.027500366792082787,
-0.00012714524928014725,
-0.02846028096973896,
-0.008573751896619797,
-0.020212315022945404,
0.01157428976148367,
-0.002622064668685198,
-0.023881487548351288,
-0.033243682235479355,
0.02961783856153488,
0.027052033692598343,
0.028693776577711105,
-0.022404534742236137,
0.04185707867145538,
0.004199456423521042,
0.021179022267460823,
-0.03323834761977196,
-0.03169878572225571,
0.028687844052910805,
-0.006699278950691223,
0.006919495295733213,
0.03351897746324539,
-0.006405442021787167,
0.03653056174516678,
0.043043822050094604,
0.031845591962337494,
-0.004865553695708513,
0.08877051621675491,
0.014825256541371346,
0.006396078504621983,
-0.01897410862147808,
-0.021164795383810997,
0.017890045419335365,
0.018915768712759018,
0.010887914337217808,
0.0024183911737054586,
-0.004403162747621536,
0.05977986380457878,
0.014055171981453896,
0.0043932474218308926,
0.001038815244100988,
-0.03473841771483421,
-0.013621224090456963,
-0.022692475467920303,
-0.012849736027419567,
0.023678496479988098,
0.014173032715916634,
0.005741668399423361,
0.013954415917396545,
-0.06752917170524597,
-0.0025072500575333834,
-0.010039648041129112,
0.007079973351210356,
-0.01981155201792717,
0.029200922697782516,
0.015036061406135559,
-0.04685740917921066,
-0.007588519249111414,
0.026762915775179863,
-0.045387737452983856,
-0.01196347177028656,
0.002663413528352976,
0.035212498158216476,
-0.031111888587474823,
0.024728326126933098,
0.04981667175889015,
-0.029278764501214027,
0.05505196750164032,
0.001214449293911457,
0.037083178758621216,
-0.030663246288895607,
0.005137952044606209,
-0.03354005143046379,
0.021892812103033066,
-0.014832873828709126,
-0.007162182126194239,
-0.022763671353459358,
-0.07535351067781448,
-0.03669240325689316,
0.004613141529262066,
-0.021466031670570374,
-0.02112661302089691,
-0.046901777386665344,
0.004740594420582056,
0.034577835351228714,
-0.031784579157829285,
0.03822663426399231,
0.0360095240175724,
0.006654325872659683,
0.014595575630664825,
-0.020462866872549057,
0.017331311479210854,
-0.005875959061086178,
-0.02725883573293686,
-0.025411181151866913,
0.008023396134376526,
-0.0908181294798851,
-0.014343338087201118,
-0.036790069192647934,
0.006004685070365667,
0.05926716700196266,
0.02525906451046467,
-0.037592194974422455,
-0.03789054602384567,
0.03322381526231766,
0.019456839188933372,
-0.0010468258988112211,
0.016138773411512375,
0.020854292437434196,
-0.03752727434039116,
-0.008876756764948368,
0.0067613753490149975,
-0.030400684103369713,
0.028921393677592278,
-0.018867172300815582,
0.03711364045739174,
-0.00107015750836581,
0.021442482247948647,
0.025905966758728027,
-0.03937973827123642,
0.0460345521569252,
-0.0548543818295002,
-0.04552032798528671,
0.041845887899398804,
0.0244644396007061,
0.05132805556058884,
-0.04997550696134567,
0.010540695860981941,
0.020247090607881546,
-0.0023780029732733965,
0.03951416164636612,
-0.0067290510050952435,
-0.026373060420155525,
0.012332276441156864,
0.033451274037361145,
0.03597016632556915,
-0.0015113704139366746,
-0.0103590814396739,
0.039794307202100754,
-0.03562337905168533,
-0.05381006374955177,
0.0719514787197113,
-0.009438464418053627,
-0.006002443842589855,
0.0059625511057674885,
-0.003478404600173235,
0.03717002272605896,
0.019869184121489525,
0.022587865591049194,
-0.030456667765975,
-0.041403643786907196,
0.03062443807721138,
0.03343543782830238,
0.015175811015069485,
0.06341171264648438,
0.005293747875839472,
-0.01718737557530403,
-0.00046107001253403723,
-0.03069683350622654,
-0.02736026793718338,
0.04561435431241989,
-0.004085947759449482,
-0.049674782902002335,
-0.015378090552985668,
-0.021147051826119423,
-0.029631558805704117,
0.0319998674094677,
0.049488600343465805,
-0.012029963545501232,
-0.05309054255485535,
0.0013992044841870666,
-0.0024086390621960163,
0.06557904183864594,
-0.08614952117204666,
-0.049440279603004456,
-0.013533094897866249,
-0.027614081278443336,
-0.04063747450709343,
0.029629886150360107,
0.0007727353950031102,
0.011847148649394512,
-0.039261430501937866,
0.0317113995552063,
-0.03587352856993675,
-0.021850431337952614,
0.029183976352214813,
0.016810797154903412,
0.0005984249874018133,
0.0005647275829687715,
-0.05138574168086052,
0.029588375240564346,
-0.01618177257478237,
0.03157169744372368,
0.023544877767562866,
-0.005725345574319363,
-0.019666315987706184,
0.019092334434390068,
-0.007207667455077171,
0.020777592435479164,
0.03027072362601757,
-0.013763035647571087,
-0.009114522486925125,
0.005571718327701092,
-0.050345323979854584,
0.0074113658629357815,
0.04453739523887634,
0.039655767381191254,
-0.026137806475162506,
-0.014115305617451668,
0.0014005014672875404,
-0.005113512743264437,
0.021510915830731392,
-0.00571124954149127,
-0.04334596171975136,
-0.029228027909994125,
-0.06737854331731796,
0.016291625797748566,
0.02382972091436386,
-0.012074213474988937,
-0.0590035654604435,
0.021637005731463432,
0.010120161809027195,
-0.038829050958156586,
-0.03271239995956421,
-0.035893943160772324,
0.01557093020528555,
-0.06804461777210236,
0.017454015091061592,
0.02194581925868988,
-0.04074019938707352,
0.03065895102918148,
0.0016857906011864543,
0.003695111256092787,
0.042289700359106064,
-0.026287827640771866,
0.030726995319128036,
-0.0025415574200451374,
0.029062995687127113,
0.007230526302009821,
-0.017309116199612617,
0.038556430488824844,
0.007119525223970413,
-0.002912839176133275,
-0.006269670091569424,
-0.0036191160324960947,
0.001499679870903492,
-0.028683511540293694,
0.04332152381539345,
-0.03863648697733879,
0.029159024357795715,
-0.009998819790780544,
0.03649742156267166,
-0.026274600997567177,
-0.05392881855368614,
-0.0030541718006134033,
-0.019810840487480164,
0.0022872916888445616,
-0.06393387168645859,
-0.0152377774938941,
0.0028303696308285,
-0.018279604613780975,
-0.07365193963050842,
-0.01951783150434494,
-0.04408768191933632,
0.01097559928894043,
0.0585072785615921,
0.024169381707906723,
-0.017720622941851616,
-0.035162221640348434,
0.013097995892167091,
-0.00535605987533927,
0.025806523859500885,
-0.04580487683415413,
-0.005396456923335791,
-0.05540929734706879,
0.017872842028737068,
-0.03650396317243576,
-0.030042331665754318,
-0.020296748727560043,
0.01231975108385086,
-0.0394841693341732,
-0.04427734762430191,
-0.004349058493971825,
-0.000143063924042508,
0.06022253632545471,
-0.012813067995011806,
-0.020493896678090096,
-0.02383681759238243,
0.04314785078167915,
-0.03193618729710579,
-0.0096895145252347,
-0.020700782537460327,
0.06614484637975693,
0.02072686143219471,
0.010465113446116447,
-0.014516624622046947,
0.0064996276050806046,
-0.03391118347644806,
0.04142442345619202,
0.0012433665106073022,
0.004809150937944651,
0.01568029262125492,
-0.013781935907900333,
-0.05227852612733841,
0.06013185903429985,
0.04523174837231636,
0.005824113264679909,
-0.027734093368053436,
0.027546927332878113,
0.028332965448498726,
0.009002863429486752,
0.03857680410146713,
-0.020722460001707077,
-0.02420083060860634,
0.012554493732750416,
0.026614654809236526,
0.018494924530386925,
-0.01195561233907938,
0.01914585940539837,
-0.0036852757912129164,
0.0046909223310649395,
-0.014142239466309547,
0.03414257988333702,
-0.004299427382647991,
-0.03240213170647621,
0.02174539677798748,
-0.010427757166326046,
-0.013633765280246735,
-0.00711181852966547,
-0.009539362043142319,
-0.013945236802101135,
-0.016757313162088394,
-0.030786534771323204,
0.006685386411845684,
-0.030845502391457558,
0.0058872937224805355,
-0.0036741013173013926,
0.06219775229692459,
0.01141023077070713,
-0.006586732342839241,
-0.019018715247511864,
0.027340847998857498,
-0.027389394119381905,
0.02382161282002926,
-0.14986082911491394,
0.010930543765425682,
-0.013368482701480389,
-0.03659314662218094,
-0.07228171080350876,
0.006459399126470089,
-0.03991442173719406,
0.006272582802921534,
-0.016102157533168793,
0.00786166824400425,
0.023977160453796387,
-0.05613157898187637,
0.03597785532474518,
-0.002063574967905879,
-0.04144790396094322,
0.04358985275030136,
0.016143757849931717,
-0.004128568340092897,
-0.022572049871087074,
0.01867198571562767,
-0.00811731070280075,
0.0054782782681286335,
0.008688741363584995,
-0.009062560275197029,
-0.03574297949671745,
-0.01813502609729767,
-0.04886404052376747,
-0.04350067302584648,
-0.028846826404333115,
-0.01570030115544796,
-0.020930659025907516,
-0.035476021468639374,
-0.015771960839629173,
0.0492362454533577,
0.02269171178340912,
0.009096154943108559,
0.018528802320361137,
-0.023827029392123222,
-0.0366225391626358,
-0.031165551394224167,
-0.039584770798683167,
0.00231437711045146,
-0.03475587069988251,
0.0021542601753026247,
0.025128846988081932,
-0.02705957740545273,
0.03910982236266136,
0.011977448128163815,
-0.033717431128025055,
-0.011014358140528202,
0.02888900600373745,
0.046989165246486664,
-0.030284622684121132,
0.0548127181828022,
0.0008886727155186236,
0.02458270452916622,
0.01862727478146553,
-0.04519546031951904,
-0.05931345000863075,
0.05282926559448242,
0.022698720917105675,
-0.004136689938604832,
-0.0361429788172245,
-0.007044605445116758,
-0.03640657290816307,
0.007006301078945398,
-0.01278446614742279,
-0.024952976033091545,
-0.06460174173116684,
-0.01462422963231802,
-0.0067374370992183685,
-0.02263895981013775,
0.01126235444098711,
-0.015293598175048828,
0.009192771278321743,
-0.020038966089487076,
0.0036232767160981894,
0.004240764770656824,
0.003086016746237874,
-0.01365386601537466,
-0.014970746822655201,
0.006332087330520153,
-0.01566205359995365,
0.00031429791124537587,
0.02068318799138069,
-0.004117198288440704,
0.00783077348023653,
-0.0025272173807024956,
-0.016894523054361343,
0.007834688760340214,
-0.04864519461989403,
0.009406807832419872,
0.002116661285981536,
0.031012631952762604,
-0.0013604784617200494,
0.03838737681508064,
-0.011215347796678543,
0.0021532117389142513,
-0.018550867214798927,
-0.016422992572188377,
-0.024183521047234535,
-0.02890978939831257,
0.011174802668392658,
0.034939687699079514,
-0.044601403176784515,
0.023831693455576897,
0.021807556971907616,
-0.037275806069374084,
0.015959687530994415,
-0.02007557451725006,
-0.004528798628598452,
-0.04136975482106209,
-0.06632149964570999,
0.015647968277335167,
-0.027802351862192154,
0.02201509289443493,
0.023627329617738724,
0.012982663698494434,
-0.004668591544032097,
0.02654818817973137,
0.018556972965598106,
-0.00361210317350924,
0.00849386677145958,
-0.03845318406820297,
-0.01365408394485712,
0.018242010846734047,
0.10052621364593506,
0.011748564429581165,
0.03388896957039833,
-0.04274291545152664,
0.03771866112947464,
-0.027501853182911873,
-0.007413637358695269,
0.015124965459108353,
0.012687667272984982,
0.009979775175452232,
0.010771213099360466,
0.027230827137827873,
-0.014163479208946228,
-0.04996650665998459,
-0.011167426593601704,
0.005155481863766909,
0.010209904983639717,
-0.015494263730943203,
0.004282564856112003,
-0.05880145728588104,
0.05337733030319214,
-0.021829266101121902,
-0.03519875556230545,
-0.03436825051903725,
0.029017336666584015,
0.01747925765812397,
0.0026652722153812647,
0.051760777831077576,
0.04044526442885399,
0.0054510291665792465,
0.028742872178554535,
0.04894253611564636,
0.009825905784964561,
0.08323996514081955,
-0.01960812322795391,
-0.04650481417775154,
-0.030791010707616806,
-0.02318512089550495,
-0.04457961022853851,
0.021315595135092735,
-0.005614145193248987,
-0.009020257741212845,
-0.03343026712536812,
0.014597387984395027,
-0.005401490721851587,
0.009062213823199272,
-0.010666249319911003,
-0.01665969379246235,
0.02699076198041439,
-0.0034581292420625687,
0.027330486103892326,
0.007720095105469227,
0.09463459253311157,
-0.05584193393588066,
0.026844704523682594,
0.012888197787106037,
0.012225075624883175,
0.015404684469103813,
-0.016230402514338493,
0.005062529817223549,
-0.028668556362390518,
0.02875174582004547,
-0.024144243448972702,
0.005349203944206238,
0.02558733895421028,
-0.010216816328465939,
0.006922369357198477,
-0.04184998571872711,
0.04706234484910965,
0.005422267597168684,
-0.014313334599137306,
0.021720675751566887,
0.01797639951109886,
0.0441926084458828,
-0.022262392565608025,
0.0112112732604146,
-0.01687806099653244,
-0.02220301702618599,
-0.01900508627295494,
0.016359632834792137,
-0.006086115259677172,
-0.05848280340433121,
-0.029328618198633194,
0.02210325188934803,
-0.03845911845564842,
-0.032120976597070694,
0.034668587148189545,
0.0031887758523225784,
0.013175513595342636,
0.010571995750069618,
-0.003991049248725176,
0.009921981953084469,
-0.000723233912140131,
-0.018701769411563873,
0.05580568313598633,
0.04624054208397865,
-0.004801182541996241,
-0.010451553389430046,
-0.02653406746685505,
0.006965302862226963,
0.005079340189695358,
0.017626363784074783,
0.04398919641971588,
0.006103184074163437,
-0.017206672579050064,
0.0187530554831028,
0.0199858620762825,
0.057127248495817184,
0.017315994948148727,
-0.0027021318674087524,
-0.020717989653348923,
-0.05268028378486633,
-0.0454140342772007,
0.01846419647336006,
0.002605454996228218,
0.043887026607990265,
0.0061699403449893,
-0.004450008273124695
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:29
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
In that result QBE would have been seeking recovery in respect of a payment that was not made by it pursuant to any legal obligation or under the threat of the enforcement of a legal obligation but only under a bona fide belief as to the existence of such an obligation.
The obstacles in the face of recovery in those circumstances are considerable. None of the cases discussed by Rein J in Limit v Ace address that situation. The discussion in the plurality judgment in Friend v Brooker [2009] HCA 21; (2009) 239 CLR 129 at [45] to [48] would not appear to accommodate recovery in such circumstances (see Zurich v GIO at [77]).
138Second, if QBE had only failed in its double insurance claim because it was found that Megbuy was not the owner then it might still have been arguable that the payment that was made by it was "compellable" under law because QBE was still obliged to indemnify the other potential owner, Levira.
However once that scenario is contemplated one needs to consider the potential liability of Megbuy as the employer so as to apply the statutory regime in s 151Z of the WC Act. The task of speculating about whether there is any room for the operation of the principle of recoupment in the context of those provisions based on scenarios that are not reflected in my findings would be a futile exercise.
Orders
139The Court makes the following orders:
(1)Stand over the proceedings to 9 May 2012 at 9.30am before Beech-Jones J;
(2)Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant confer as to the appropriate form of orders to reflect this judgment (including as to costs);
(3)Direct the Plaintiff and the Defendant to, on or before 4 May 2012, file and serve either a form of order that it is agreed reflects this judgment or, failing agreement, their own forms of order reflecting this judgment (including as to costs);
(4)There be liberty to apply.
Amendments
10 May 2013 - Amend date in quote to read "[7] November 2005"
Amended paragraphs: 79
10 May 2013 - Replace "underlined" with "italicised".
Amended paragraphs: 63, 82, 89
10 May 2013 - Insert italicised emphasis (underlined emphasis was not imported by Caselaw).
Amended paragraphs: 13, 17, 30, 63, 81, 89, 120, 125, 126
DISCLAIMER - Every effort has been made to comply with suppression orders or statutory provisions prohibiting publication that may apply to this judgment or decision.
The onus remains on any person using material in the judgment or decision to ensure that the intended use of that material does not breach any such order or provision. Further enquiries may be directed to the Registry of the Court or Tribunal in which it was generated.
Decision last updated: 10 May 2013
|
[
-0.00758438091725111,
0.03186611086130142,
-0.012263202108442783,
0.01092479471117258,
-0.04432911425828934,
0.014659581705927849,
0.037466347217559814,
-0.0031260724645107985,
-0.0075567238964140415,
0.017933763563632965,
0.011920622549951077,
0.011153356172144413,
-0.02026008442044258,
0.01249074935913086,
-0.03625478595495224,
-0.022346511483192444,
0.011302145197987556,
0.035323113203048706,
-0.054805777966976166,
-0.03053264319896698,
-0.019263023510575294,
-0.014164377003908157,
-0.0037438757717609406,
0.02817714773118496,
0.028454212471842766,
0.007144348230212927,
-0.02156934142112732,
0.0010441699996590614,
0.01424466259777546,
0.04099568352103233,
-0.0016313338419422507,
0.02530689910054207,
0.014273551292717457,
-0.024162229150533676,
0.015743965283036232,
-0.03841054439544678,
-0.03657297417521477,
0.009029502980411053,
-0.02819073013961315,
-0.015058906748890877,
-0.0008223909535445273,
0.02838287502527237,
-0.00486008869484067,
-0.012343687005341053,
0.034218378365039825,
-0.028633153066039085,
-0.0020485203713178635,
-0.013515755534172058,
-0.013789545744657516,
-0.037244319915771484,
-0.08230345696210861,
-0.00504120159894228,
0.09533955156803131,
-0.030664239078760147,
-0.014810837805271149,
0.022488513961434364,
0.024217160418629646,
-0.0158508513122797,
-0.04718467593193054,
-0.03960698843002319,
-0.022403893992304802,
-0.015040277503430843,
-0.0613638237118721,
0.014514751732349396,
-0.0004547476419247687,
0.0674516037106514,
-0.009207397699356079,
0.014266958460211754,
0.009077087976038456,
-0.03376394882798195,
0.018823042511940002,
0.0032902020029723644,
0.028253797441720963,
0.004827015567570925,
-0.09345246851444244,
0.014224966056644917,
0.008435754105448723,
-0.03516313061118126,
-0.004276202991604805,
-0.008990742266178131,
0.0009339746902696788,
0.0173859391361475,
-0.01697923056781292,
0.03271927684545517,
-0.0050505222752690315,
0.015218334272503853,
-0.0009897894924506545,
-0.03688574954867363,
0.0010232824133709073,
0.010449744760990143,
-0.014923031441867352,
0.0016339410794898868,
-0.013183390721678734,
-0.0381929986178875,
0.027431270107626915,
-0.012431256473064423,
-0.06061432138085365,
-0.010625826194882393,
0.024328434839844704,
0.025534437969326973,
0.01621311716735363,
0.004730572458356619,
0.04313488304615021,
-0.055888641625642776,
0.028701798990368843,
-0.0003966388467233628,
0.031109387055039406,
0.058748554438352585,
0.006837908178567886,
0.0204011183232069,
-0.015869401395320892,
0.017300309613347054,
0.0071125151589512825,
0.010992669500410557,
0.003050523577257991,
-0.025746796280145645,
0.02493455447256565,
-0.029081333428621292,
0.03165698051452637,
-0.029184261336922646,
0.014780296944081783,
0.0297763142734766,
0.034846045076847076,
-0.018170267343521118,
-0.08321911841630936,
0.015586315654218197,
0.014324250631034374,
-0.024940896779298782,
-0.026748083531856537,
-0.0014342336216941476,
0.0006174340378493071,
-0.0016671670600771904,
-0.01800002157688141,
-0.03537755459547043,
-0.058730971068143845,
-0.0352751724421978,
0.035401273518800735,
0.011034353636205196,
-0.05820547789335251,
-0.04685031995177269,
0.005727001931518316,
0.02369081787765026,
0.0187964029610157,
-0.016841785982251167,
-0.00114902900531888,
0.004959240555763245,
0.0547533743083477,
-0.04119986295700073,
0.022835135459899902,
-0.026494771242141724,
0.014466479420661926,
-0.023761659860610962,
0.04443739727139473,
-0.01845148578286171,
0.04427389055490494,
-0.0947176069021225,
-0.015467260032892227,
0.006041659042239189,
-0.017908522859215736,
0.012348063290119171,
-0.0014712561387568712,
0.028649823740124702,
-0.0061052655801177025,
-0.02645067311823368,
-0.018897460773587227,
-0.02146468497812748,
-0.02173743024468422,
0.026493972167372704,
-0.011901193298399448,
0.008338737301528454,
0.02106945402920246,
0.002894425531849265,
0.020357586443424225,
-0.05407731980085373,
0.009763059206306934,
0.0184975303709507,
0.020094148814678192,
0.023110467940568924,
-0.006854120641946793,
-0.04308554530143738,
-0.0509563609957695,
0.016695106402039528,
0.006189778447151184,
-0.019342707470059395,
-0.004613569937646389,
0.013836149126291275,
-0.05227857455611229,
-0.06212646886706352,
0.025673462077975273,
0.007558600511401892,
-0.005136311985552311,
0.011372077278792858,
0.02652090974152088,
0.003982915077358484,
-0.01678299345076084,
-0.040168046951293945,
0.02349303849041462,
-0.0012516322312876582,
0.031013885512948036,
-0.026702458038926125,
-0.03792732208967209,
0.004765509162098169,
0.0400598980486393,
0.014405007474124432,
-0.025322701781988144,
-0.010134203359484673,
-0.028254082426428795,
0.019516263157129288,
0.037614304572343826,
-0.07342850416898727,
-0.014550096355378628,
-0.004551427438855171,
-0.0072455634362995625,
0.0408589243888855,
-0.05984015390276909,
-0.024744227528572083,
0.007984265685081482,
-0.01764615811407566,
0.029187791049480438,
0.03592832759022713,
-0.03595768287777901,
0.006625806447118521,
0.001176960184238851,
-0.0044443621300160885,
0.028760410845279694,
-0.0014981175772845745,
-0.0206599123775959,
0.04103276878595352,
0.021997498348355293,
-0.009140782058238983,
0.017279502004384995,
-0.0025559221394360065,
0.013558244332671165,
-0.019629240036010742,
0.042786575853824615,
-0.010744179598987103,
0.027948623523116112,
0.053745631128549576,
0.03270012512803078,
-0.015302902087569237,
-0.0002815744956023991,
-0.025122983381152153,
0.047848112881183624,
-0.011959522031247616,
-0.003227072535082698,
-0.02351432666182518,
-0.030510123819112778,
0.0314842090010643,
0.03856771066784859,
0.01901674084365368,
0.006434170994907618,
-0.02700818143785,
-0.04803646355867386,
-0.03553382307291031,
0.005130801349878311,
0.030967935919761658,
0.00687247421592474,
-0.03716566041111946,
0.00919349305331707,
0.005985287483781576,
0.038312703371047974,
-0.014343781396746635,
0.005337621085345745,
0.0018331577302888036,
-0.016911018639802933,
-0.07144646346569061,
-0.029802769422531128,
-0.022348999977111816,
-0.02166098728775978,
-0.037837207317352295,
-0.009630493819713593,
-0.005301178898662329,
0.0008511458290740848,
0.015655769035220146,
0.033566005527973175,
0.07091270387172699,
0.01949192024767399,
-0.04136717692017555,
0.03026091679930687,
0.014986641705036163,
0.06800752878189087,
0.05392733961343765,
0.004629961680620909,
-0.06195157766342163,
0.035526204854249954,
-0.004368655849248171,
-0.013124859891831875,
-0.058271005749702454,
-0.02140798419713974,
-0.06020765379071236,
0.02351999282836914,
0.012780817225575447,
0.07871979475021362,
0.02143319509923458,
-0.03617030009627342,
0.014638925902545452,
-0.006444788537919521,
-0.1667596995830536,
-0.022664736956357956,
0.02380588836967945,
-0.022024285048246384,
-0.005155118647962809,
0.018357230350375175,
-0.023672262206673622,
-0.004077116493135691,
0.02113550715148449,
0.011348279193043709,
-0.030873920768499374,
-0.06509479135274887,
-0.0048941560089588165,
0.04962371289730072,
0.05196100473403931,
-0.00363382650539279,
-0.024179216474294662,
-0.013034617528319359,
0.03790351375937462,
-0.03672335296869278,
-0.045586805790662766,
-0.044454336166381836,
0.014706297777593136,
-0.02324395440518856,
0.02242370881140232,
-0.036698758602142334,
-0.0006526924553327262,
-0.008688903413712978,
-0.05887948349118233,
0.011565119959414005,
-0.04485779255628586,
0.027371130883693695,
-0.00464513199403882,
0.01538274809718132,
0.011801748536527157,
0.028340285643935204,
0.04983183741569519,
-0.037889596074819565,
0.014814486727118492,
0.010388017632067204,
0.03213430568575859,
0.04760773107409477,
-0.005305703729391098,
0.020460745319724083,
-0.008076111786067486,
-0.05197929963469505,
-0.015019956044852734,
-0.0077789113856852055,
-0.06730009615421295,
0.03785724192857742,
-0.02442573383450508,
-0.002835554303601384,
-0.021830733865499496,
0.006399910897016525,
-0.033519402146339417,
-0.022846559062600136,
0.02509317174553871,
0.06536620110273361,
-0.036396317183971405,
0.04155634716153145,
-0.024095481261610985,
-0.023154525086283684,
0.009838961996138096,
0.012138829566538334,
-0.06274717301130295,
0.026644419878721237,
0.018870389088988304,
-0.02778465300798416,
0.053724583238363266,
-0.007394693326205015,
0.003684703027829528,
-0.01757434941828251,
0.004603264853358269,
-0.005350104998797178,
-0.02741675078868866,
0.0321074053645134,
-0.002588150557130575,
-0.021916968747973442,
-0.005963025614619255,
-0.0869109183549881,
-0.0003636227920651436,
0.007652513682842255,
-0.025977741926908493,
0.0260970126837492,
0.010411037132143974,
0.0006172402063384652,
0.00019551749574020505,
0.0705389454960823,
0.021535497158765793,
0.21387110650539398,
0.012322135269641876,
0.017204172909259796,
0.011654025875031948,
-0.002250419929623604,
0.03105241246521473,
0.03774246945977211,
0.06826354563236237,
0.00438737915828824,
-0.030674446374177933,
-0.02916974015533924,
0.011220970191061497,
0.030116381123661995,
0.02832270972430706,
-0.0025572297163307667,
-0.020132478326559067,
-0.02940545789897442,
0.004752127919346094,
0.10598210245370865,
-0.01350889541208744,
0.008604662492871284,
-0.015627063810825348,
-0.0167972594499588,
0.028808239847421646,
-0.06064590811729431,
-0.04736355319619179,
0.018504168838262558,
0.0005611914675682783,
0.005877687595784664,
0.031033338978886604,
-0.046309880912303925,
-0.02908971533179283,
0.039165038615465164,
-0.015296988189220428,
-0.026679720729589462,
-0.018751688301563263,
0.01952405273914337,
0.01255739200860262,
-0.032733313739299774,
0.0566064678132534,
0.00760332215577364,
-0.02984892576932907,
0.010534259490668774,
-0.008278279565274715,
0.006310306955128908,
0.011723165400326252,
-0.023111646994948387,
0.0007237835670821369,
-0.007839436642825603,
0.042435333132743835,
-0.02582411840558052,
-0.020136501640081406,
-0.01007559709250927,
0.04385898634791374,
-0.05912323668599129,
0.019087808206677437,
-0.046570587903261185,
0.013913445174694061,
-0.008001462556421757,
0.015051908791065216,
-0.008801138028502464,
0.011027141474187374,
-0.044241491705179214,
0.020784666761755943,
-0.004588915966451168,
0.024250781163573265,
-0.03031856007874012,
0.018092269077897072,
0.0759584903717041,
0.01970442198216915,
-0.003948408644646406,
0.03841882944107056,
0.025766972452402115,
-0.005446027498692274,
0.061791446059942245,
0.009104474447667599,
0.029506878927350044,
0.06411311775445938,
-0.052816521376371384,
-0.011812863871455193,
0.005803484003990889,
0.010181265883147717,
-0.007588857319205999,
-0.004615175537765026,
0.006745361257344484,
-0.04788817837834358,
-0.023676203563809395,
0.06261561065912247,
0.0393703356385231,
-0.0534680150449276,
-0.03335772827267647,
-0.02172846905887127,
-0.0157718937844038,
0.00192862784024328,
-0.007985522039234638,
0.023559989407658577,
0.027540601789951324,
0.025449372828006744,
-0.017819995060563087,
-0.02316456101834774,
-0.056160952895879745,
-0.012329764664173126,
0.029096338897943497,
-0.04857398942112923,
-0.010219704359769821,
-0.009363609366118908,
0.0016124837566167116,
-0.044520050287246704,
-0.02543582022190094,
0.010790427215397358,
0.017022842541337013,
0.017045002430677414,
-0.024658560752868652,
-0.01474380400031805,
0.020582299679517746,
0.032304637134075165,
-0.042593177407979965,
0.03559614717960358,
0.045965418219566345,
0.04352319985628128,
-0.005701737944036722,
0.03329416364431381,
-0.01783180609345436,
0.03605950251221657,
0.011248637922108173,
-0.01950649358332157,
0.004253610968589783,
-0.014108010567724705,
0.021305015310645103,
-0.00034587905975058675,
-0.030779704451560974,
-0.0001838058524299413,
-0.031811509281396866,
-0.017912790179252625,
0.011212910525500774,
-0.0073261442594230175,
-0.024419043213129044,
-0.0009281818056479096,
0.020998641848564148,
0.007160249166190624,
-0.009537715464830399,
0.004146963357925415,
-0.06240103021264076,
0.017390934750437737,
0.015187369659543037,
-0.00757679995149374,
-0.0062857018783688545,
0.0026498970109969378,
-0.06526871770620346,
0.012651666067540646,
-0.008050414733588696,
0.04028796777129173,
-0.02814224734902382,
-0.005808419547975063,
-0.0216242503374815,
0.006967697758227587,
0.015233205631375313,
0.0008261233451776206,
0.005484652705490589,
-0.04810882732272148,
-0.006768141873180866,
-0.013086104765534401,
-0.0041025662794709206,
0.056337691843509674,
0.008961515501141548,
0.05368397384881973,
-0.02523905038833618,
0.030815795063972473,
0.037051621824502945,
-0.003345050383359194,
-0.004861271008849144,
-0.02111608162522316,
-0.014570815488696098,
0.030746564269065857,
0.04961193725466728,
0.007370240055024624,
0.002716206246986985,
0.009355640038847923,
0.044539447873830795,
-0.06450781226158142,
-0.005990692880004644,
0.011185256764292717,
-0.050398264080286026,
-0.00530965905636549,
-0.012618348933756351,
0.0005262743216007948,
-0.02232479117810726,
-0.02491089701652527,
0.07652286440134048,
-0.02207418717443943,
-0.011613905429840088,
0.09622512757778168,
0.03547414019703865,
-0.018014412373304367,
0.0030829107854515314,
0.05916644632816315,
0.009706933051347733,
-0.01571911759674549,
0.018592078238725662,
-0.03932999074459076,
0.00245648343116045,
-0.01027634646743536,
0.018228458240628242,
-0.013633085414767265,
0.02060435712337494,
-0.002057804260402918,
0.011282985098659992,
0.017592793330550194,
-0.025436287745833397,
0.030932359397411346,
-0.01726227067410946,
0.027716608718037605,
-0.0021868108306080103,
0.012104230001568794,
0.02990456484258175,
0.010917509905993938,
-0.012781493365764618,
0.05891465023159981,
0.02513514831662178,
-0.026673199608922005,
-0.009899213910102844,
0.003615304594859481,
0.05892375111579895,
-0.0580630749464035,
0.017221389338374138,
0.047830794006586075,
-0.0071850125677883625,
-0.01273241639137268,
0.029972946271300316,
0.009901631623506546,
0.006835354957729578,
-0.008252688683569431,
-0.009777802973985672,
0.0007571633323095739,
-0.012158682569861412,
0.004987990949302912,
0.022224759683012962,
0.016263240948319435,
-0.0017654187977313995,
0.008318944834172726,
0.00967033114284277,
0.004612859338521957,
-0.008218429051339626,
0.08430534601211548,
-0.01261042058467865,
0.0054792421869933605,
-0.032206982374191284,
-0.030139904469251633,
0.06005856394767761,
0.003916660323739052,
-0.011724865064024925,
0.013958897441625595,
0.028504235669970512,
-0.033273544162511826,
0.028914552181959152,
0.0017553343204781413,
0.0011593971867114305,
0.0023278866428881884,
-0.05064912885427475,
-0.03549712523818016,
0.028333362191915512,
0.013348827138543129,
0.00747088436037302,
-0.06038413569331169,
0.01493882853537798,
-0.05486779287457466,
0.03231044486165047,
-0.008496497757732868,
-0.012085427530109882,
0.007466423325240612,
0.01157859992235899,
0.01892111450433731,
-0.03020348772406578,
-0.03474566340446472,
-0.039638813585042953,
-0.00283645698800683,
0.013052089139819145,
0.027897827327251434,
0.04807766154408455,
-0.02450411766767502,
0.050775185227394104,
0.003086918266490102,
-0.010846368968486786,
0.02278839237987995,
-0.005886714905500412,
0.0018888862105086446,
0.061034008860588074,
0.025771843269467354,
-0.014568611979484558,
-0.016834160313010216,
0.014507404528558254,
0.003039136528968811,
-0.028384530916810036,
0.0005740203196182847,
-0.010535400360822678,
-0.03768740966916084,
0.006003998685628176,
0.06183340772986412,
-0.035859931260347366,
-0.009799197316169739,
-0.026271017268300056,
0.006552620325237513,
-0.0242480356246233,
-0.048442743718624115,
-0.0224621519446373,
0.012946834787726402,
0.017731690779328346,
0.005103874485939741,
0.04567372426390648,
0.04810158163309097,
0.02920810878276825,
-0.055953800678253174,
-0.02039126679301262,
-0.04354255646467209,
-0.02361077442765236,
0.004150261636823416,
0.039102986454963684,
-0.023020779713988304,
0.019128920510411263,
-0.03301994875073433,
0.046279434114694595,
0.01810404285788536,
-0.014176766388118267,
-0.0071503049694001675,
-0.02062525786459446,
0.029483802616596222,
-0.001877805101685226,
-0.01117322500795126,
-0.034631550312042236,
-0.014120729640126228,
-0.04356176033616066,
-0.028718309476971626,
-0.024861060082912445,
0.012505869381129742,
0.05107511579990387,
0.006502513308078051,
-0.006011250428855419,
0.012699522078037262,
0.026743141934275627,
0.0035510037560015917,
0.012581959366798401,
-0.06827880442142487,
0.047780729830265045,
-0.01383669301867485,
0.0021791732870042324,
0.024390578269958496,
0.0025845735799521208,
0.011084734462201595,
-0.010315222665667534,
-0.018913015723228455,
0.0223491583019495,
0.005265610292553902,
-0.028869323432445526,
-0.03777886927127838,
0.010275664739310741,
0.021027417853474617,
-0.0037443519104272127,
0.049486856907606125,
0.034648261964321136,
0.07863862812519073,
-0.027297038584947586,
0.04829102382063866,
-0.04281821846961975,
-0.0027748909778892994,
0.00899428129196167,
0.012019401416182518,
0.0012676327023655176,
0.032016169279813766,
-0.023505041375756264,
-0.02589607797563076,
-0.013070549815893173,
-0.03206327185034752,
0.040425773710012436,
-0.011536157689988613,
-0.011788043193519115,
0.007816042751073837,
0.017282800748944283,
0.008117124438285828,
-0.018570493906736374,
-0.03711136057972908,
-0.0047455220483243465,
-0.025952666997909546,
-0.007949220016598701,
0.006960258819162846,
0.0034143307711929083,
0.0066726249642670155,
0.004396868869662285,
-0.006501405965536833,
-0.026448549702763557,
0.02871725708246231,
-0.04975097253918648,
0.03285307437181473,
-0.03573644533753395,
0.029091982170939445,
-0.15685676038265228,
0.006372037343680859,
-0.023462669923901558,
0.049958471208810806,
-0.051870740950107574,
0.0009192193392664194,
-0.04105672985315323,
0.010577511042356491,
-0.0411192923784256,
0.008333804085850716,
-0.030665341764688492,
-0.049625810235738754,
0.07331245392560959,
-0.01908264495432377,
-0.0329645499587059,
0.05275030434131622,
0.025490406900644302,
-0.035034116357564926,
0.016985872760415077,
0.05086186155676842,
0.021185247227549553,
0.01389909815043211,
-0.0013209098251536489,
-0.02249576337635517,
-0.008501066826283932,
-0.016209980472922325,
-0.01068395096808672,
-0.0002015772188315168,
-0.049057137221097946,
-0.01037775818258524,
0.01560527179390192,
0.0077033936977386475,
0.009503880515694618,
0.0422900915145874,
-0.007684011477977037,
0.021465133875608444,
0.02211781032383442,
0.006861651316285133,
-0.01925119385123253,
-0.07035746425390244,
0.012111512944102287,
0.009199830703437328,
0.0028202866669744253,
-0.0404345728456974,
0.029759397730231285,
-0.003939109388738871,
-0.008953233249485493,
0.014148332178592682,
0.0013879286125302315,
-0.04785909131169319,
-0.03222477063536644,
0.004391377791762352,
-0.011587303131818771,
-0.031847283244132996,
0.02096373774111271,
-0.00017415880574844778,
0.0008606226183474064,
-0.03199775516986847,
-0.0073279100470244884,
0.0832161158323288,
-0.0002799113281071186,
-0.014102362096309662,
-0.03654234856367111,
-0.030287208035588264,
0.029515519738197327,
-0.000615580240264535,
-0.024377286434173584,
0.005763206630945206,
-0.02172950468957424,
0.01912340708076954,
0.007263891864567995,
-0.02778712287545204,
0.018690871074795723,
-0.03488718345761299,
0.005872157867997885,
0.012047406286001205,
0.0017439941875636578,
0.0176637452095747,
0.030402271077036858,
-0.018727140501141548,
-0.00619469303637743,
0.016887875273823738,
-0.03024524450302124,
-0.01823086105287075,
0.028266822919249535,
0.0070335897617042065,
-0.06562753021717072,
-0.002158150775358081,
0.00703577371314168,
-0.03179110586643219,
-0.059009257704019547,
-0.0003176970931235701,
-0.03887711837887764,
0.033691082149744034,
-0.006597332656383514,
0.023618729785084724,
-0.02244141511619091,
-0.009315905161201954,
-0.01759873330593109,
-0.023400453850626945,
-0.02354738675057888,
-0.03902783244848251,
0.024067634716629982,
-0.01625693030655384,
-0.00038557910011149943,
0.05487567186355591,
-0.008263751864433289,
0.004693951923400164,
-0.01723969355225563,
-0.008670465089380741,
-0.014929280616343021,
-0.052849169820547104,
-0.050326813012361526,
0.0029489388689398766,
-0.07261377573013306,
0.028200654312968254,
0.0019091533031314611,
0.0481148436665535,
-0.00996103510260582,
0.02119537815451622,
0.005185161717236042,
-0.0695701614022255,
0.023649651557207108,
-0.019012538716197014,
0.03288072347640991,
0.03283634036779404,
0.024253664538264275,
0.012545639649033546,
0.03487701714038849,
-0.0003222482337150723,
0.03855324909090996,
-0.01346299983561039,
-0.02450498379766941,
0.012984339147806168,
-0.010884098708629608,
0.02935524471104145,
-0.021009139716625214,
0.008859905414283276,
0.013655745424330235,
-0.03692490607500076,
-0.0003916771966032684,
-0.039925120770931244,
-0.021197199821472168,
0.003027196042239666,
-0.050696615129709244,
-0.05806133896112442,
0.009808489121496677,
-0.0032881388906389475,
-0.02160024084150791,
-0.07895220816135406,
-0.005573497153818607,
0.007736892905086279,
0.010773682035505772,
0.053251441568136215,
0.02662539854645729,
-0.024062391370534897,
0.044983651489019394,
-0.017609279602766037,
-0.036812711507081985,
0.07359345257282257,
0.018804427236318588,
-0.0047213309444487095,
-0.028064532205462456,
0.006402977742254734,
-0.03158451244235039,
0.042108915746212006,
-0.016908321529626846,
-0.014587227255105972,
-0.03126879036426544,
0.02791566587984562,
-0.006515654269605875,
0.02400926873087883,
-0.029861271381378174,
-0.009521366097033024,
0.022391686215996742,
-0.04749039188027382,
-0.017472047358751297,
-0.005178127903491259,
0.05969928577542305,
-0.0503779761493206,
0.04674611985683441,
0.03448791429400444,
-0.014484629966318607,
0.011836441233754158,
0.006504134740680456,
0.027149684727191925,
-0.0032486901618540287,
0.0016775703988969326,
0.00153250596486032,
-0.016820980235934258,
0.014226337894797325,
-0.009541196748614311,
-0.023380625993013382,
0.006942386738955975,
0.06798775494098663,
0.053265709429979324,
0.011211411096155643,
0.051003240048885345,
0.0007700484129600227,
-0.005600077100098133,
0.008479224517941475,
0.018550865352153778,
-0.027477478608489037,
0.02138911746442318,
-0.042066458612680435,
-0.02419835329055786,
0.04566230624914169,
-0.01038134191185236,
-0.033309970051050186,
0.06476620584726334,
-0.017197836190462112,
-0.003086839569732547,
-0.04667474702000618,
0.022722894325852394,
-0.009759818203747272,
0.027098560705780983,
0.005283694714307785,
-0.03570755943655968,
0.03758116438984871,
-0.021059025079011917,
0.028555992990732193,
0.05827322602272034,
-0.017145799472928047,
-0.03940879553556442,
-0.011561947874724865,
-0.0010095658944919705,
-0.020680798217654228,
-0.013324080035090446,
0.02283799648284912,
0.009885497391223907,
-0.007379676681011915,
0.029211994260549545,
-0.01454822439700365,
0.008965031243860722,
-0.024885864928364754,
-0.026582088321447372,
-0.009630011394619942,
-0.02032993547618389,
-0.0366273932158947,
-0.010604762472212315,
0.028631359338760376,
-0.009241857565939426,
0.024928752332925797,
0.0008636410930193961
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:4
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
At least one way of construing an admission that a settlement sum represented a "reasonable amount in the circumstances" is that it is an admission that the sum agreed represents a reasonable compromise having regard to the likelihood of liability under the MAC Act being established and the likely range of damages.
If that is what the pleading meant then it would cut across so much of the denial of the satisfaction of "injury" as it involves a denial of at least "fault" on the part of the owner.
22At the hearing Mr Campbell SC who appeared with Mr McCarthy for CGU explained that his client's admission in [A8] only meant that it accepted that the settlement figure represented a reasonable assessment of the quantum of Mr Horwood's claim but that CGU denied that there was any "fault" of Megbuy and, even if there was, it was not a fault that fell within the statutory phrase "injury".
Mr Cavanagh SC who appeared with Mr Khandhar for QBE submitted that this position was not open on the pleadings.
He contended that the only issue that CGU could agitate was the ownership of the forklift, although he sought to meet all of CGU's contentions if that submission was not accepted.
Mr Campbell SC pointed to a letter sent by CGU's solicitors dated 2 March 2010 to QBE's solicitors in which it complained that it was not aware of the basis for QBE's admission of a breach of duty by Megbuy and the basis upon which Mr Horwood's claim fell within the definition of "injury".
23With some reluctance I accept Mr Campbell SC's submission as to the effect of the pleadings. Without any limitation on what the phrase "reasonable in the circumstances" in [A8] of CGU's pleading means I do not consider that QBE can use it to cut across [A7].
The phrase could be a reference to the circumstance that the settlement figure was negotiated with Mr Horwood after QBE and Megbuy had already admitted ownership and liability (as that had occurred prior to agreement over the settlement sum being reached).
However, the admission in [A7] operates to prevent CGU from arguing any point concerning the failure of QBE to discount Mr Horwood's claim on account of any contributory negligence on the part of Mr Horwood. This allegation was still on foot at the time of the settlement in December 2009 and not specifically traversed in CGU's pleadings.
It clearly was a "circumstance" prevailing at the time the settlement was reached. Mr Campbell SC did not specifically submit that the settlement was unreasonable on account of any failure to address whether there was contributory negligence on the part of Mr Horwood, although he did submit that Mr Horwood's error was the cause of the accident.
THE DECISION IN ZURICH V GIO
24The parties were not only in dispute about what was in dispute they were also in dispute about the evidentiary framework that should be adopted to resolve what was in dispute.
25QBE submitted that any issue concerning Megbuy's liability to Mr Horwood under the MAC Act, whether Megbuy is the "owner" of the forklift or whether there the definition of "injury" was satisfied should be determined by considering only whether the settlement that it reached on behalf Megbuy represented a "reasonable compromise" respecting those issues.
CGU submitted that those matters needed to be re-litigated afresh in this Court. QBE also postulated an alternative position concerning the definition of "injury" which I address below at [40].
26QBE relied upon the Court of Appeal's judgement in Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd v GIO General Ltd [2011] NSWCA 47 ("Zurich v GIO"). Given its significance to these proceedings I will address it in some detail.
27In Zurich v GIO, a family bus and coach business was operated through two companies, Caringbah Bus Services Pty Ltd ("Caringbah") and Tiger Tours Pty Ltd ("Tiger"). Zurich was the third party insurer of a coach registered in the name of Caringbah. GIO was the workers compensation insurer of Tiger.
|
[
0.021589919924736023,
-0.0067758276127278805,
-0.016568459570407867,
-0.029398225247859955,
0.014850346371531487,
-0.03112133778631687,
0.0129122044891119,
0.008466127328574657,
0.015086057595908642,
0.0077456822618842125,
0.007830812595784664,
0.003212330164387822,
0.007938718423247337,
0.008926762267947197,
0.026342038065195084,
-0.010258317925035954,
0.023352377116680145,
-0.004609216935932636,
-0.0344231054186821,
-0.033501140773296356,
0.0008327564573846757,
-0.018454259261488914,
0.03130533546209335,
0.02999039925634861,
0.01419560331851244,
0.02523912861943245,
-0.013278394006192684,
0.00971435010433197,
0.0027667591348290443,
0.0038780365139245987,
-0.007558292709290981,
0.013752357102930546,
0.017809392884373665,
-0.013822105713188648,
0.01720045693218708,
-0.04115478694438934,
-0.013557781465351582,
0.014949732460081577,
-0.02685696817934513,
0.019704818725585938,
-0.01036999374628067,
-0.010367817245423794,
0.017012381926178932,
-0.04522585868835449,
0.05263660475611687,
-0.03859570249915123,
-0.013851350173354149,
-0.02609376050531864,
-0.02638443186879158,
-0.020121265202760696,
-0.06506089121103287,
-0.001930348458699882,
0.056731510907411575,
-0.03341476619243622,
-0.024122416973114014,
0.007957750000059605,
-0.0016940961359068751,
-0.04493698105216026,
-0.04395389184355736,
-0.04223540797829628,
-0.06403110921382904,
-0.026995139196515083,
-0.02356889471411705,
0.011563153006136417,
0.031647130846977234,
0.07141391932964325,
-0.015286989510059357,
-0.022633103653788567,
-0.022315874695777893,
-0.05671040713787079,
0.011266116984188557,
0.009393949992954731,
-0.02982346899807453,
0.010092155076563358,
-0.04720878601074219,
0.026087405160069466,
0.03294956311583519,
0.04296177253127098,
-0.005985559429973364,
0.030694281682372093,
0.011020767502486706,
0.0005384929245337844,
-0.03495904058218002,
0.007189340423792601,
-0.04822437837719917,
0.017657410353422165,
-0.02485482394695282,
-0.009485973976552486,
-0.03369854390621185,
0.022218650206923485,
0.006129669491201639,
-0.012781119905412197,
-0.017699677497148514,
-0.021803883835673332,
-0.003663553623482585,
0.006325231399387121,
-0.07203534245491028,
0.030317630618810654,
-0.016782905906438828,
0.0016321054426953197,
0.022128889337182045,
-0.006552168633788824,
0.03866160288453102,
-0.028903674334287643,
0.0021315966732800007,
-0.003718616208061576,
0.042173661291599274,
0.07115253061056137,
-0.02266533486545086,
0.007937975227832794,
0.0056083425879478455,
0.030386745929718018,
-0.008833125233650208,
0.022863777354359627,
-0.00804173108190298,
-0.020273536443710327,
0.009041747078299522,
-0.02388564869761467,
0.029632989317178726,
-0.035118650645017624,
0.032638974487781525,
0.05503775551915169,
0.017739875242114067,
-0.019704658538103104,
-0.053835172206163406,
-0.013650168664753437,
0.01822488196194172,
-0.008697926066815853,
-0.015426733531057835,
-0.023805666714906693,
0.00754728214815259,
-0.0005292663699947298,
-0.0243608970195055,
-0.05668165162205696,
-0.022341663017868996,
-0.036232031881809235,
0.08773012459278107,
-0.007190871052443981,
-0.03497953712940216,
-0.07818102091550827,
0.02048439159989357,
0.03018275834619999,
-0.007693672552704811,
-0.02127058617770672,
0.04839594289660454,
-0.04166393354535103,
0.057099901139736176,
-0.027308421209454536,
0.028559431433677673,
-0.006995666306465864,
0.004816811066120863,
0.022152133285999298,
-0.021365253254771233,
-0.061620213091373444,
0.005079830531030893,
-0.03550109267234802,
-0.013551970943808556,
-0.013796895742416382,
-0.001960400026291609,
0.04770732298493385,
0.009254236705601215,
0.061938270926475525,
-0.03594931960105896,
-0.04900098219513893,
-0.008584880270063877,
-0.019907627254724503,
-0.02195628732442856,
0.0582338310778141,
-0.025651849806308746,
-0.009719733148813248,
0.02692313864827156,
0.009409960359334946,
0.02556590735912323,
0.0060171326622366905,
0.031248990446329117,
0.029966065660119057,
0.045174047350883484,
0.028802359476685524,
0.03450189530849457,
-0.04488217085599899,
-0.009761007502675056,
-0.007975330576300621,
0.023601694032549858,
-0.02811061218380928,
-0.009154075756669044,
0.04098224267363548,
0.0019114434253424406,
-0.043347857892513275,
0.01858275756239891,
0.002495684428140521,
0.023004094138741493,
-0.02983149141073227,
0.013973651453852654,
-0.028370589017868042,
0.02064395509660244,
0.01107060443609953,
0.063748799264431,
-0.010399682447314262,
0.013566440902650356,
-0.058873072266578674,
-0.032717518508434296,
0.03553174436092377,
0.04093772545456886,
-0.017709266394376755,
-0.047705475240945816,
-0.0020371314603835344,
-0.07934606820344925,
0.03429832309484482,
0.014990965835750103,
-0.07681156694889069,
0.0025927461683750153,
0.00019941903883591294,
0.023862114176154137,
-0.0008210522937588394,
-0.032530978322029114,
-0.010320368222892284,
0.03263619542121887,
-0.011451782658696175,
0.027426281943917274,
0.007887335494160652,
0.0001528285356471315,
0.0002959163684863597,
-0.010763473808765411,
0.06799852102994919,
0.007002983242273331,
0.020343339070677757,
-0.018403587862849236,
0.05580230802297592,
0.016092540696263313,
-0.02215644344687462,
0.020615145564079285,
0.0022286309394985437,
0.0060134269297122955,
-0.05485183373093605,
0.0377868115901947,
0.022258669137954712,
0.06375857442617416,
0.0064145652577281,
0.017534194514155388,
0.012466618791222572,
-0.05929585546255112,
0.008565809577703476,
0.07053723931312561,
-0.026598265394568443,
-0.03549925610423088,
-0.03421694412827492,
0.0010450702393427491,
0.03242088854312897,
0.006019792053848505,
-0.017522361129522324,
0.0299873985350132,
-0.05592905357480049,
-0.042968522757291794,
-0.01707836613059044,
0.011787462048232555,
0.03126218914985657,
0.0151221277192235,
-0.0078082624822855,
0.04138604551553726,
0.017412353307008743,
0.029073912650346756,
-0.01861473359167576,
0.0252453051507473,
0.013513251207768917,
0.017446696758270264,
-0.044089484959840775,
-0.05150900036096573,
0.00045932186185382307,
-0.03222095966339111,
0.016295386478304863,
-0.002910048235207796,
0.030827701091766357,
-0.04188982769846916,
0.0026442294474691153,
0.023777173832058907,
0.029071426019072533,
-0.012207570485770702,
-0.038495246320962906,
0.0031331381760537624,
0.008078327402472496,
0.03934808075428009,
-0.02057158760726452,
0.008238018490374088,
-0.048920340836048126,
0.016735130921006203,
-0.004689070861786604,
-0.020650777965784073,
-0.04515320435166359,
-0.008416987024247646,
-0.08159888535737991,
0.030487021431326866,
-0.02962610498070717,
0.0747753232717514,
-0.007518211379647255,
-0.0414254255592823,
-0.02336045540869236,
0.01940413936972618,
-0.15333670377731323,
-0.04127925634384155,
0.01591889001429081,
0.03579900413751602,
-0.006072294432669878,
0.01742391847074032,
-0.019664181396365166,
0.004757727030664682,
0.021744927391409874,
0.03935007378458977,
0.031698115170001984,
-0.06257731467485428,
0.011790391989052296,
0.026171822100877762,
0.020561806857585907,
-0.016806047409772873,
-0.028435837477445602,
0.00472246203571558,
0.029443031176924706,
-0.02688346803188324,
-0.0008418870274908841,
0.004756510723382235,
0.0014899440575391054,
-0.007022492121905088,
0.032424453645944595,
0.0045833648182451725,
0.01646609418094158,
0.02471943013370037,
-0.0370657704770565,
-0.0036963478196412325,
-0.06654877960681915,
-0.03163498267531395,
-0.016911547631025314,
0.06172100454568863,
0.024555351585149765,
0.024923082441091537,
0.024539237841963768,
-0.060877494513988495,
-0.01236728485673666,
0.0007146275602281094,
0.025527454912662506,
0.09170026332139969,
0.01183290034532547,
0.00215642130933702,
-0.02240448258817196,
-0.04114347696304321,
0.017479993402957916,
-0.018578380346298218,
-0.01951471157371998,
-0.006621026899665594,
0.002999258227646351,
-0.022541845217347145,
-0.011479109525680542,
0.019698329269886017,
-0.011541458778083324,
-0.01385208498686552,
0.04635032266378403,
0.06319819390773773,
0.010689645074307919,
0.01958652026951313,
-0.011523431167006493,
-0.036068473011255264,
0.015177230350673199,
0.004804814700037241,
-0.049701884388923645,
0.01806412823498249,
0.015574963763356209,
0.015618105418980122,
0.05926588550209999,
-0.00462988531216979,
-0.02233709581196308,
-0.02341185137629509,
0.0002887591253966093,
-0.011174550279974937,
-0.011056221090257168,
0.015676524490118027,
0.02950902283191681,
0.0018516290001571178,
-0.004161729943007231,
-0.057216618210077286,
0.02306019701063633,
0.014179158955812454,
0.025898724794387817,
0.034806665033102036,
0.0011412505991756916,
0.02603810466825962,
0.021018261089920998,
0.027536004781723022,
0.008160588331520557,
0.20932163298130035,
0.011709736660122871,
0.02243688702583313,
0.011424615047872066,
0.010254602879285812,
0.0018292649183422327,
0.024504683911800385,
0.031017715111374855,
0.0035764025524258614,
-0.04827786982059479,
-0.04423440247774124,
0.0165235698223114,
0.01746642217040062,
0.02984156273305416,
-0.00987426470965147,
-0.014959466643631458,
-0.05657569319009781,
-0.05654406547546387,
0.07369302958250046,
-0.02811454050242901,
0.03191034123301506,
-0.012431776151061058,
0.011985483579337597,
-0.0039538173004984856,
-0.060962360352277756,
-0.043045125901699066,
0.0029652523808181286,
0.028477884829044342,
0.007890420034527779,
0.014890008606016636,
-0.021234463900327682,
0.0129458699375391,
0.004878386855125427,
-0.0016324934549629688,
-0.009457520209252834,
-0.0049397898837924,
-0.028354154899716377,
0.016162103042006493,
-0.016291435807943344,
0.05354605242609978,
0.05448264256119728,
-0.01689552702009678,
-0.016482515260577202,
-0.0028353941161185503,
-0.009063448756933212,
-0.010179661214351654,
0.0009336995426565409,
0.016250863671302795,
-0.031979117542505264,
0.05099700763821602,
-0.10957954078912735,
0.011030447669327259,
-0.04422648996114731,
0.017246419563889503,
-0.030443109571933746,
0.027062026783823967,
-0.008445748127996922,
0.03824175149202347,
0.009611488319933414,
0.019770318642258644,
0.03421519696712494,
0.017388688400387764,
-0.027423035353422165,
0.005879985634237528,
-0.01022281777113676,
0.03373265638947487,
-0.07132846862077713,
-0.005451229400932789,
0.05591137707233429,
0.00608915276825428,
-0.012868508696556091,
0.04453375190496445,
0.010619176551699638,
0.025597821921110153,
0.047755785286426544,
0.025379493832588196,
0.011921734549105167,
0.01778465509414673,
0.00695034209638834,
-0.03065064549446106,
-0.03201528266072273,
-0.022899789735674858,
-0.002925282344222069,
0.015804922208189964,
0.021430417895317078,
0.004658261314034462,
-0.027805931866168976,
0.04328133910894394,
0.05120224878191948,
-0.03632960468530655,
-0.031835220754146576,
-0.029012933373451233,
-0.0037523815408349037,
0.003262148005887866,
-0.01588400825858116,
0.033750154078006744,
0.020552512258291245,
0.005015216302126646,
-0.012041942216455936,
-0.05350106582045555,
-0.03360633924603462,
-0.008968659676611423,
-0.00031588421552442014,
-0.015670781955122948,
-0.0016011408297345042,
0.0011538492981344461,
0.036229077726602554,
-0.006261053495109081,
-0.05887468904256821,
-0.011914413422346115,
0.028254888951778412,
-0.00126651709433645,
-0.015093819238245487,
0.029401909559965134,
0.009149978868663311,
0.03429000824689865,
-0.03679676726460457,
0.03265056386590004,
0.05779644474387169,
0.05013645440340042,
-0.0032044181134551764,
-0.00045207704533822834,
-0.008952454663813114,
0.04763662815093994,
0.026389354839920998,
0.004056919366121292,
-0.02187488228082657,
-0.037296511232852936,
-0.00034260653774254024,
0.025995733216404915,
0.02843513712286949,
-0.0014772138092666864,
-0.0300093125551939,
-0.017304345965385437,
0.058616288006305695,
-0.003180191619321704,
-0.03306233137845993,
0.03851399943232536,
-0.013760911300778389,
0.004775299225002527,
-0.030765963718295097,
0.01130974292755127,
-0.03911904618144035,
0.009800578467547894,
-0.005271961446851492,
-0.01719667762517929,
-0.042833831161260605,
0.03456646949052811,
-0.06586794555187225,
-0.015215949155390263,
0.009032318368554115,
0.019345538690686226,
-0.03230224549770355,
-0.01603594422340393,
-0.026259077712893486,
0.016563711687922478,
0.005238779820501804,
0.016997337341308594,
0.0132874995470047,
-0.023492060601711273,
-0.02138586714863777,
-0.01085781678557396,
0.000504281313624233,
0.04864361137151718,
-0.009393670596182346,
0.05411472171545029,
0.01340574026107788,
0.060642365366220474,
0.03600198030471802,
-0.033496588468551636,
-0.0070056370459496975,
-0.024167431518435478,
-0.01858505979180336,
0.0515688955783844,
0.04390991851687431,
0.0657290667295456,
0.034833136945962906,
0.009854077361524105,
0.024790123105049133,
-0.007519072853028774,
0.0010525942780077457,
0.012493160553276539,
-0.026780420914292336,
0.01575164869427681,
-0.05711802467703819,
0.025120586156845093,
0.0395435132086277,
-0.024625610560178757,
0.010163342580199242,
-0.009785255417227745,
-0.04052792862057686,
0.09728696197271347,
-0.03829489275813103,
-0.01593707501888275,
0.024772532284259796,
0.013176754117012024,
-0.012085817754268646,
0.014571561478078365,
-0.01896575093269348,
-0.042263440787792206,
-0.029787519946694374,
0.015481368638575077,
-0.006052249576896429,
0.008661641739308834,
0.05597999691963196,
-0.0015547734219580889,
0.015723329037427902,
0.016782116144895554,
-0.018186055123806,
-0.005269923247396946,
0.019809776917099953,
0.00978972390294075,
-0.019743384793400764,
0.0005314123700372875,
-0.01020493358373642,
0.012555629946291447,
0.017349060624837875,
0.06431861221790314,
-0.018878458067774773,
-0.07987556606531143,
-0.02312679961323738,
-0.02277868054807186,
0.03758319839835167,
-0.07987382262945175,
-0.01733594760298729,
0.0666196346282959,
0.005324512254446745,
0.0070405746810138226,
0.004163798410445452,
0.0023152362555265427,
0.0077450633980333805,
-0.010723968036472797,
-0.01361939124763012,
-0.02869410067796707,
-0.008974846452474594,
-0.008993301540613174,
0.03339540585875511,
-0.006510085891932249,
0.029854653403162956,
0.01080641895532608,
0.04367966204881668,
-0.019907064735889435,
-0.005990197882056236,
0.08008264750242233,
-0.018786722794175148,
-0.003875188995152712,
-0.002151643158867955,
-0.03839637339115143,
0.025854194536805153,
-0.005582593847066164,
-0.01329128909856081,
0.017540138214826584,
0.014785350300371647,
-0.030056975781917572,
-0.01125972718000412,
-0.026797698810696602,
0.021397128701210022,
0.018818391487002373,
-0.051993049681186676,
-0.0361810177564621,
0.020764684304594994,
0.03788873553276062,
-0.012060806155204773,
-0.022828349843621254,
0.02512652985751629,
-0.06755447387695312,
0.011916302144527435,
-0.04227641969919205,
-0.031984858214855194,
-0.021496370434761047,
-0.021488741040229797,
-0.005656370893120766,
-0.0577368326485157,
-0.036354176700115204,
-0.034410811960697174,
0.004436515271663666,
-0.0595853291451931,
0.05362224578857422,
0.03998526185750961,
0.016980402171611786,
0.01251645851880312,
-0.016819272190332413,
-0.016166239976882935,
0.0473543182015419,
-0.04218246415257454,
0.028781119734048843,
-0.002117446856573224,
-0.003086137119680643,
0.023798702284693718,
-0.03647219389677048,
0.012246201746165752,
0.03921741992235184,
-0.02123573049902916,
0.01330378744751215,
-0.022215241566300392,
0.006866334471851587,
-0.02330496348440647,
0.061944905668497086,
-0.020966799929738045,
0.016419056802988052,
-0.00044340704334899783,
-0.036941997706890106,
-0.04330774024128914,
-0.021967127919197083,
-0.01502107735723257,
-0.011152571067214012,
0.01937182806432247,
-0.032939374446868896,
-0.010073816403746605,
0.005282863974571228,
-0.009778175503015518,
-0.06023406237363815,
-0.022890621796250343,
-0.02402801252901554,
-0.0006394608062691987,
0.019613998010754585,
0.00208531622774899,
-0.009970322251319885,
0.02495267055928707,
0.04032086953520775,
0.015233958140015602,
-0.02299276925623417,
-0.03297213464975357,
-0.008771450258791447,
-0.048509631305933,
0.009858653880655766,
0.03135932609438896,
-0.02447189949452877,
-0.0351099818944931,
0.016557220369577408,
-0.03573992848396301,
-0.004679272882640362,
-0.022348226979374886,
0.007128380239009857,
0.07145938277244568,
0.0036109411157667637,
-0.03702043369412422,
-0.010677755810320377,
0.023189371451735497,
0.023320134729146957,
0.003890024498105049,
-0.060228150337934494,
0.07035617530345917,
-0.013394041918218136,
-0.002450960921123624,
0.01571519486606121,
-0.0032507642172276974,
0.005733617581427097,
0.010830218903720379,
0.025600166991353035,
0.007788072340190411,
-0.007186921779066324,
-0.017033524811267853,
-0.028624095022678375,
0.00018958887085318565,
0.02085174061357975,
-0.003583210986107588,
0.026669245213270187,
0.0053420234471559525,
-0.011140584014356136,
-0.04154004529118538,
0.03083859384059906,
0.0006666699191555381,
0.010639440268278122,
0.01437449362128973,
0.019061557948589325,
-0.012053013779222965,
0.03237098827958107,
0.0384233221411705,
-0.028607705608010292,
0.008878576569259167,
-0.0064582666382193565,
-0.00782602559775114,
-0.014464587904512882,
0.010060341097414494,
-0.012333627790212631,
0.020215267315506935,
-0.009350413456559181,
-0.0306042842566967,
-0.05180817469954491,
-0.013381704688072205,
-0.08181233704090118,
-0.05449657887220383,
0.006898288615047932,
0.02975514717400074,
-0.024975929409265518,
0.012148655019700527,
-0.005546938627958298,
-0.00398182263597846,
0.001539854216389358,
-0.0075144958682358265,
0.03689425438642502,
-0.04931008815765381,
0.001527034561149776,
-0.13720044493675232,
0.021456776186823845,
-0.005686882883310318,
0.024928387254476547,
-0.05686964839696884,
-0.009807090274989605,
-0.04931769147515297,
0.00398672791197896,
0.010458510369062424,
-0.04230310395359993,
-0.018587671220302582,
0.004215196706354618,
0.06726324558258057,
-0.00046730812755413353,
-0.0392213873565197,
0.029205292463302612,
-0.04679752513766289,
-0.03310592100024223,
-0.02536132000386715,
0.02316954731941223,
0.006167723331600428,
0.028132658451795578,
0.009372863918542862,
-0.026034481823444366,
-0.02618248574435711,
-0.030798569321632385,
-0.039885953068733215,
-0.06077727675437927,
-0.04450192674994469,
-0.004027926363050938,
-0.032910048961639404,
-0.0389588437974453,
0.011400450952351093,
0.003429117612540722,
0.018538327887654305,
0.030668986961245537,
0.011363625526428223,
-0.001855711918324232,
-0.022770622745156288,
-0.007381636183708906,
-0.0012446311302483082,
0.015000522136688232,
-0.010256050154566765,
-0.004623631946742535,
-0.015517900697886944,
0.03515606373548508,
0.02471339888870716,
-0.003660933580249548,
-0.04061564430594444,
-0.02980799786746502,
-0.04387360438704491,
0.009812668897211552,
-0.033284563571214676,
0.022647805511951447,
0.024431299418210983,
0.011852984316647053,
-0.00828470941632986,
-0.03562315180897713,
0.003412415273487568,
0.07941664010286331,
0.02950143627822399,
-0.03317295014858246,
-0.029706276953220367,
-0.01710740104317665,
0.04597942531108856,
0.011374948546290398,
0.0028184670954942703,
0.012984138913452625,
0.026057373732328415,
0.004851297475397587,
0.011135479435324669,
-0.007043211720883846,
-0.012257011607289314,
-0.027364252135157585,
0.0182639230042696,
-0.021414736285805702,
0.015312232077121735,
-0.004911343567073345,
-0.032979194074869156,
0.019680503755807877,
0.03568476811051369,
-0.0035280606243759394,
-0.03690434247255325,
-0.04937056079506874,
0.024616513401269913,
0.007523335050791502,
-0.010670204646885395,
-0.02683364972472191,
0.06129578500986099,
-0.08176500350236893,
-0.06071384996175766,
0.00882536917924881,
-0.005277983844280243,
0.007793629541993141,
-0.05314561724662781,
0.034159980714321136,
0.025018002837896347,
-0.014105021953582764,
-0.017872216179966927,
-0.028522416949272156,
-0.014158434234559536,
-0.04030166193842888,
0.026428787037730217,
0.007642812095582485,
-0.019259504973888397,
0.034192487597465515,
-0.004547324497252703,
0.01979559287428856,
0.010286650620400906,
0.011558229103684425,
-0.04003284126520157,
-0.048245299607515335,
-0.03349992632865906,
-0.02364538237452507,
-0.04628763347864151,
-0.0002999364514835179,
-0.02799496240913868,
0.026259582489728928,
-0.01803797483444214,
0.031715020537376404,
0.010323085822165012,
-0.02906768023967743,
0.03219416365027428,
-0.0073746852576732635,
0.0019199511734768748,
0.023311220109462738,
0.07931962609291077,
0.0057022967375814915,
0.022375771775841713,
-0.016131971031427383,
0.031040038913488388,
-0.019174380227923393,
0.0011799237690865993,
0.029414068907499313,
0.0034077989403158426,
0.060683999210596085,
-0.013454879634082317,
-0.0042915353551507,
-0.024043450132012367,
-0.03624168783426285,
0.02013968490064144,
-0.03340425714850426,
-0.009296968579292297,
0.009856189601123333,
-0.047554899007081985,
0.002037425059825182,
0.00526052713394165,
-0.010996629483997822,
-0.029282566159963608,
-0.0381322056055069,
-0.016982411965727806,
0.011721418239176273,
-0.008775142021477222,
0.08967456966638565,
0.012936057522892952,
-0.04478143900632858,
-0.007540671154856682,
0.01220654509961605,
0.010667070746421814,
0.0412016324698925,
0.039125896990299225,
-0.00871050450950861,
-0.010383573360741138,
0.009944836609065533,
-0.004749764688313007,
0.023880193009972572,
-0.011350654065608978,
0.009050981141626835,
-0.028498683124780655,
-0.023508494719862938,
0.02820347435772419,
-0.01839715614914894,
-0.028765631839632988,
0.028400318697094917,
0.04131552577018738,
-0.0221282709389925,
-0.007038427516818047,
-0.007080464623868465,
0.025763284415006638,
-0.003308915765956044,
0.03122793138027191,
0.014633995480835438,
0.011107612401247025,
0.01970924250781536,
0.025072047486901283,
0.019769864156842232,
0.03315414488315582,
0.02455964870750904,
-0.008397412486374378,
-0.008482921868562698,
-0.032625194638967514,
-0.029861722141504288,
0.013398301787674427,
-0.015182724222540855,
0.039743103086948395,
0.01913294568657875,
0.011447385884821415,
0.005993946455419064,
0.006713608745485544,
0.0358402319252491,
0.017702318727970123,
-0.02885270118713379,
-0.004765703808516264,
-0.011389477178454399,
-0.0491773821413517,
-0.012950828298926353,
-0.003946756012737751,
-0.015101948752999306,
-0.03210495784878731,
0.040790461003780365,
-0.008119963109493256,
-0.004795160610228777,
-0.0016644085990265012,
0.06919824331998825,
-0.05456574633717537,
0.01705659180879593,
-0.02503027208149433,
-0.026892658323049545,
0.025309331715106964,
-0.023910224437713623,
0.007918834686279297,
0.07456430047750473,
-0.0037581613287329674,
-0.05066322162747383,
0.017122847959399223,
0.019953440874814987,
-0.01887347735464573,
0.016728490591049194,
0.03941737115383148,
-0.025006933137774467,
-0.020922675728797913,
-0.027878930792212486,
-0.004025627393275499,
0.03833744674921036,
0.032602857798337936,
-0.012445114552974701,
0.0221763476729393,
-0.019735442474484444,
-0.0010455322917550802,
-0.030362838879227638,
0.08578911423683167,
-0.005319404881447554,
0.025438619777560234,
-0.021407971158623695
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:16
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
The private investigator also reported that Mr Oates was recorded on the electoral roll at an address in Broken Hill but he was not recorded as owning real estate in New South Wales or Queensland. Although his mobile account was still "live" he never answered or returned calls.
74The end result of the inquiries was that there was no address for Mr Oates and his "Facebook wall" did not contain an accurate statement of where he worked. To the best of the investigator's knowledge he was working in the mining industry in Queensland. There was no form of electronic search that could assist in further refining the search in Queensland.
75In AJW & 2 Ors v State of New South Wales [2003] NSWSC 803 Bell J concluded at [15] to [16] that "all reasonable steps" have been taken to find a witness in circumstances where the plaintiffs had retained an experienced investigator to locate the witness.
Her Honour inferred that the investigator had carried out the enquiries that "might reasonably be expected to have been undertaken by a competent investigator". I am similarly satisfied here. QBE satisfied me that Mr Oates was "unavailable" and his signed statement was admissible under s 63 of the Evidence Act. The status of his unsigned statement is addressed below.
MEGBUY'S ALLEGED LIABILITY TO MR HORWOOD
76The photos of Mr Horwood's accident depict a forklift turned over on its left side in the middle of the street. In the foreground of the pictures is a motor vehicle parked adjacent to the kerb on the left hand side of the road. Immediately adjacent to the rear of the motor vehicle on the right hand side are are some tyre marks which veer to the right to the point where the forklift was tipped over.
A police sketch indicates that at the rear of the vehicle the tyre marks were 24cm from the side of the vehicle and that the point the forklift turned over is 8.2 metres from that location. The sketch and the photos suggest that the forklift was driven close to the car. The brakes were applied. It swung to the right and, being top-heavy, turned on its left side.
77CGU tendered a series of documents which record the accounts Mr Horwood gave of the incident to the police, WorkCover inspectors, QBE and doctors. On the day of the accident he told a police officer that he was " ... travelling along Talc Street on to my next job. I lost control of the forklift and the next thing I know is it fell over.
" On 16 December 2005 a WorkCover inspector recorded that he stated that: "I was going from job to job on the forklift. Stated he was not speeding and was taking his time. The incident happened pretty quick - said that the camber of the road is pretty sharp, off to the gutter. He said that a wheel may have got caught in road surface. He said that he didn't really know what happened."
78On 2 May 2006 Mr Horwood advised QBE in his claim form that: "I was driving a forklift in Talc Street towards Galena Street, next thing that I remember of the accident was that it rolled on its left side. I believe the steep camber of the road caused the forklift to become unbalanced."
79On 21 February 2007 Dr Michael Long recorded the following history after having consulted with Mr Horwood on the previous day: "This occurred on [7] November 2005 when he was driving a forklift in the streets of Broken Hill en route to another point where he was delivering palettes.
Evidently the forklift he was driving tipped over. However he does not recall the actual event or reason for it. The loss of consciousness he described as being instantaneous."
80To the extent that these histories recount that the "camber" of Talc Street falls away steeply off to the gutter it is not borne out by the photographs. Generally, the histories given by Mr Horwood rise no higher than him having no real recollection of what occurred immediately prior to the accident other than a recollection that he lost control.
81I have described the debate over the tender of both the unsigned statement of Mr Oates and the signed statement above. In paragraph [22] of his signed statement Mr Oates states:
|
[
0.0006383816944435239,
0.027289433404803276,
-0.019361888989806175,
-0.02323872037231922,
0.020400451496243477,
-0.0071111260913312435,
-0.008583015762269497,
-0.0063119190745055676,
0.010918623767793179,
0.029978899285197258,
0.01805131323635578,
0.02204136550426483,
0.03360835835337639,
-0.020003166049718857,
0.029617343097925186,
-0.0198792964220047,
0.025617828592658043,
-0.03134160488843918,
-0.034972235560417175,
-0.04849190264940262,
-0.00952798593789339,
-0.016931144520640373,
0.02351534739136696,
0.0025476119481027126,
0.008324263617396355,
0.011538789607584476,
0.019914673641324043,
-0.005018226336687803,
-0.020108070224523544,
-0.022255226969718933,
0.016705552116036415,
-0.04095425084233284,
0.00444031273946166,
-0.0079603036865592,
-0.05892310291528702,
-0.010148231871426105,
0.007108462508767843,
-0.008389907889068127,
-0.0326714813709259,
-0.008504882454872131,
0.014863639138638973,
0.03630294278264046,
0.014804805628955364,
-0.031246285885572433,
0.009504753164947033,
-0.03947746381163597,
-0.024838358163833618,
0.0012175369774922729,
0.05047808960080147,
0.0029126685112714767,
-0.014941110275685787,
-0.0032832412980496883,
0.03893619030714035,
0.003548086155205965,
0.0048721665516495705,
0.01446473691612482,
-0.028069568797945976,
-0.03250887989997864,
-0.0752042606472969,
-0.011971496045589447,
0.027071787044405937,
-0.008619840256869793,
-0.014415574260056019,
-0.012206937186419964,
-0.008411189541220665,
0.13747863471508026,
-0.038624320179224014,
-0.022903304547071457,
-0.02388925664126873,
-0.019958054646849632,
0.014335088431835175,
0.0003363500873092562,
-0.014419090934097767,
-0.024231616407632828,
-0.036465998739004135,
0.00018029862258117646,
0.021015433594584465,
0.01825629360973835,
0.027352776378393173,
0.055217090994119644,
0.04198131710290909,
0.014917967841029167,
0.007664258126169443,
0.030305255204439163,
0.002640823135152459,
0.014763744547963142,
-0.021653365343809128,
0.0353168286383152,
0.015910528600215912,
-0.03148481994867325,
-0.008299129083752632,
0.01787189207971096,
0.034493882209062576,
-0.04674767702817917,
-0.02226843684911728,
-0.022711999714374542,
-0.0030889578629285097,
-0.021910713985562325,
-0.015888169407844543,
0.011582870967686176,
-0.030811423435807228,
0.01985142007470131,
0.04164121299982071,
-0.015274126082658768,
-0.009773176163434982,
0.032993026077747345,
0.015096881426870823,
0.04058430343866348,
0.03036857582628727,
0.0008533481159247458,
0.026299864053726196,
-0.004919175989925861,
-0.016370322555303574,
0.01758626475930214,
-0.03941972926259041,
0.023624379187822342,
-0.001134376390837133,
0.006705543026328087,
-0.04542574658989906,
0.008821629919111729,
0.07928989082574844,
0.04059486463665962,
0.06851599365472794,
-0.04613383859395981,
-0.028064163401722908,
-0.0235451627522707,
-0.01125666219741106,
-0.029509298503398895,
0.000718102790415287,
-0.0043952506966888905,
-0.004392452072352171,
-0.01832113228738308,
-0.020030606538057327,
-0.04235602170228958,
-0.06341565400362015,
-0.027064628899097443,
0.036108724772930145,
0.030389010906219482,
-0.006211657542735338,
-0.030039098113775253,
0.06692689657211304,
0.03930463641881943,
-0.010374011471867561,
-0.021017229184508324,
0.051825519651174545,
-0.004943558480590582,
0.013416189700365067,
-0.01733538694679737,
0.026005877181887627,
-0.03521628677845001,
0.015163867734372616,
-0.014144660905003548,
-0.0025481050834059715,
-0.018703026697039604,
0.011113792657852173,
-0.04625163599848747,
0.01266313623636961,
-0.013483940623700619,
-0.025067174807190895,
0.020444924011826515,
0.027398616075515747,
0.05488380417227745,
-0.06832417845726013,
-0.02177164889872074,
0.024362731724977493,
0.0008399883517995477,
0.024995656684041023,
0.008056585676968098,
-0.0010392202530056238,
0.0008443467668257654,
0.009707770310342312,
-0.029542261734604836,
0.007716368418186903,
-0.027249185368418694,
0.03924701735377312,
0.023660972714424133,
0.08224998414516449,
0.009465917013585567,
0.029590286314487457,
-0.047343336045742035,
-0.0032936218194663525,
0.012072206474840641,
0.02023738995194435,
0.004880919586867094,
0.01270851120352745,
0.02592848800122738,
-0.03281119093298912,
-0.04467242956161499,
0.01399941649287939,
0.011102533899247646,
-0.034448232501745224,
-0.006406831555068493,
0.02993094176054001,
0.036067117005586624,
0.029725585132837296,
0.0008173244423232973,
-0.003169848583638668,
-0.008485286496579647,
0.0007514096214435995,
-0.00014248292427510023,
-0.02768041007220745,
0.04212874546647072,
0.0693342536687851,
-0.07721688598394394,
-0.03838877007365227,
-0.014432722702622414,
-0.0007834528805688024,
-0.00028284575091674924,
0.015277904458343983,
-0.09605532884597778,
0.051494281738996506,
0.009011249989271164,
0.006579749286174774,
0.021267514675855637,
-0.003061665454879403,
0.019527554512023926,
0.008155657909810543,
0.0016181376995518804,
-0.010137166827917099,
0.004955929704010487,
-0.018600711598992348,
-0.026918204501271248,
0.02799265645444393,
-0.011598067358136177,
0.060728948563337326,
0.048340581357479095,
-0.03508790209889412,
0.03898585960268974,
0.024551542475819588,
-0.07407558709383011,
0.05028863623738289,
-0.0005744274239987135,
0.015384301543235779,
-0.04079986363649368,
0.04466784745454788,
0.008329775184392929,
0.003938621375709772,
0.002215328626334667,
0.03814735636115074,
0.030846698209643364,
-0.007751936092972755,
-0.0016581787494942546,
0.03392699360847473,
-0.020633403211832047,
-0.02176387421786785,
0.002915180753916502,
-0.006632591597735882,
0.036014873534440994,
0.0048850835300982,
0.028270086273550987,
0.03034457564353943,
-0.0007897816249169409,
-0.018095793202519417,
0.0052235182374715805,
0.016062699258327484,
0.04512041062116623,
0.016054503619670868,
-0.02174166589975357,
-0.0102927815169096,
-0.035122349858284,
0.03276247903704643,
0.032111987471580505,
-0.00413548992946744,
-0.0018230370478704572,
-0.027550235390663147,
0.017397696152329445,
-0.01827923394739628,
-0.03036925569176674,
-0.007875276729464531,
-0.01476369146257639,
0.00003206132896593772,
0.005526931025087833,
-0.018523482605814934,
-0.01018546987324953,
0.012133489362895489,
0.006339729763567448,
-0.010578306391835213,
-0.007744168862700462,
-0.003921747673302889,
-0.00171016959939152,
0.035578206181526184,
-0.003906360361725092,
0.039884816855192184,
0.0040774280205369,
-0.00674139941111207,
0.014282864518463612,
0.013470245525240898,
-0.0051382011733949184,
-0.004812526982277632,
-0.04323842003941536,
0.029600316658616066,
-0.00712602399289608,
0.05335639417171478,
0.004122332204133272,
-0.02624269388616085,
-0.0008639319567009807,
-0.008654268458485603,
-0.15767860412597656,
-0.04569980129599571,
0.018569961190223694,
-0.006920248735696077,
0.025858253240585327,
0.005620148964226246,
-0.0059638977982103825,
-0.004882950335741043,
-0.0234470646828413,
0.006837061606347561,
0.014031857252120972,
-0.05256884917616844,
-0.037124235183000565,
-0.013673624955117702,
-0.029215378686785698,
-0.0336214080452919,
0.02011432871222496,
0.028207948431372643,
0.04062991589307785,
-0.06200430542230606,
-0.01228358969092369,
0.008392988704144955,
0.02297559380531311,
0.03128344193100929,
0.006343249697238207,
-0.02184726670384407,
0.05901581794023514,
-0.011931860819458961,
-0.01322230789810419,
-0.02318250760436058,
0.01504466962069273,
-0.03970413655042648,
-0.00436566723510623,
0.042163293808698654,
0.004181841388344765,
0.03485473617911339,
0.047072917222976685,
-0.057062726467847824,
-0.017648225650191307,
-0.025784004479646683,
0.02430897206068039,
0.06758453696966171,
-0.02477162703871727,
0.032087184488773346,
0.008824765682220459,
-0.05709725245833397,
0.044231120496988297,
-0.024701150134205818,
-0.049398984760046005,
-0.007651354651898146,
-0.00787239521741867,
-0.005824098829180002,
-0.024915151298046112,
0.0004759008879773319,
0.01954871416091919,
0.005215368699282408,
0.04410663992166519,
0.05475554242730141,
-0.055234506726264954,
0.0140781095251441,
-0.024197855964303017,
-0.04315495118498802,
0.026948517188429832,
0.027191635221242905,
0.017200123518705368,
0.022015588358044624,
-0.01931334100663662,
-0.01098965760320425,
-0.013287266716361046,
-0.008883459493517876,
0.016629688441753387,
-0.032031070441007614,
0.032754965126514435,
0.016788803040981293,
0.010753512382507324,
0.014010973274707794,
-0.0314113087952137,
-0.01829901710152626,
0.018868759274482727,
-0.09314209222793579,
-0.016330556944012642,
0.032419029623270035,
0.004185172263532877,
0.010072183795273304,
-0.0034965979866683483,
0.01781672239303589,
0.028751859441399574,
0.01645565591752529,
0.04027431085705757,
0.246612086892128,
0.018157612532377243,
-0.06378082185983658,
-0.027874203398823738,
0.007373054511845112,
-0.0019800157751888037,
0.039825595915317535,
0.03338749334216118,
0.03493301942944527,
-0.039204079657793045,
-0.03636964038014412,
0.014225163497030735,
0.020344644784927368,
0.01971040852367878,
-0.01382499560713768,
0.0030652384739369154,
-0.02049858495593071,
-0.041101738810539246,
0.0644974336028099,
0.01735023967921734,
0.061806630343198776,
-0.023592602461576462,
0.04784613102674484,
0.025745047256350517,
-0.08627325296401978,
-0.02081144228577614,
-0.011909249238669872,
0.049742452800273895,
-0.012217378243803978,
-0.006735955830663443,
-0.01575940102338791,
-0.011898905970156193,
0.02604048140347004,
-0.008510228246450424,
-0.018835751339793205,
0.06227455660700798,
-0.014688542112708092,
-0.019866863265633583,
0.01350484974682331,
0.02224012091755867,
-0.009339654818177223,
-0.012745986692607403,
-0.02734869346022606,
-0.033145722001791,
0.01652832143008709,
0.014091093093156815,
0.009065031073987484,
0.01668696291744709,
-0.0446590930223465,
0.06274287402629852,
-0.0359419547021389,
0.03599194809794426,
-0.034732092171907425,
-0.020249757915735245,
-0.025077572092413902,
0.0016646740259602666,
0.01878792978823185,
-0.002449663821607828,
-0.02044823206961155,
0.03656258061528206,
0.039531536400318146,
0.02832803688943386,
-0.052411507815122604,
0.015572288073599339,
-0.020538507029414177,
0.0042343102395534515,
-0.015788517892360687,
-0.024762824177742004,
0.03551210090517998,
0.03816225752234459,
0.011819415725767612,
0.019450034946203232,
0.02500525303184986,
0.05182262510061264,
0.05339336022734642,
0.022394103929400444,
0.020956899970769882,
0.057903580367565155,
-0.0032593884970992804,
-0.009691939689218998,
-0.022033732384443283,
-0.020108498632907867,
-0.010285615921020508,
0.041184116154909134,
0.004982339218258858,
-0.019840555265545845,
0.0005230870447121561,
0.0725071057677269,
0.011588864959776402,
-0.01590532809495926,
0.0025842001195997,
-0.021994508802890778,
-0.020327910780906677,
0.016398586332798004,
-0.013092088513076305,
0.0030134504195302725,
0.03296010568737984,
-0.0031329162884503603,
0.023280255496501923,
-0.05019202455878258,
0.0012668486451730132,
0.0019656179938465357,
-0.02401597611606121,
-0.007765461690723896,
0.017468303442001343,
-0.02051258459687233,
0.006326745729893446,
0.01573519967496395,
-0.02804844081401825,
-0.030998047441244125,
-0.014850834384560585,
-0.006270982325077057,
0.02082734927535057,
-0.014720657840371132,
0.015139520168304443,
0.022618720307946205,
-0.052819885313510895,
0.05117719620466232,
-0.014596029184758663,
0.047738734632730484,
-0.03433037921786308,
-0.04695812612771988,
-0.04791823774576187,
-0.039595820009708405,
-0.0405944399535656,
-0.022157639265060425,
-0.04638140648603439,
-0.03770942986011505,
-0.04028961807489395,
0.03952975943684578,
-0.004638156853616238,
-0.010162346065044403,
-0.04430686682462692,
-0.008804614655673504,
0.0712723657488823,
-0.006753893103450537,
0.01462201401591301,
0.014424433000385761,
-0.03876263648271561,
0.015465234406292439,
-0.036643024533987045,
0.04617065191268921,
-0.02481466718018055,
-0.038057200610637665,
-0.010125521570444107,
-0.014703752472996712,
-0.04518939182162285,
0.01663944497704506,
-0.04158616065979004,
-0.020316483452916145,
0.009345237165689468,
0.004725009202957153,
-0.05285254120826721,
-0.01818733848631382,
0.02479252591729164,
0.058083873242139816,
-0.003591642715036869,
-0.01852007582783699,
0.037832457572221756,
-0.0611654557287693,
-0.03173922002315521,
0.00808136910200119,
-0.015124144032597542,
0.08486973494291306,
-0.007576251868158579,
0.022157056257128716,
0.01137175876647234,
0.02909601293504238,
0.038168806582689285,
-0.033273518085479736,
0.008130902424454689,
-0.04541988670825958,
-0.01970691978931427,
0.05748169124126434,
0.04788105934858322,
0.09446392208337784,
-0.013192151673138142,
-0.00072463508695364,
-0.008730011060833931,
-0.03675621375441551,
0.006975564640015364,
0.013847900554537773,
-0.02873018942773342,
-0.01928233727812767,
0.022853123024106026,
0.009967947378754616,
0.006189109291881323,
-0.011270350776612759,
0.0353802889585495,
0.00008566107862861827,
0.00558825908228755,
0.09367398172616959,
0.0043841213919222355,
-0.012009071186184883,
0.01665215566754341,
0.0068192677572369576,
0.03796644136309624,
0.03552442789077759,
0.02597326971590519,
-0.05110181123018265,
-0.04190923273563385,
-0.008305622264742851,
-0.00872015580534935,
0.006496957503259182,
0.05685091018676758,
0.009336113929748535,
0.00698506087064743,
0.026324471458792686,
-0.02766868844628334,
-0.024572454392910004,
0.06411746889352798,
-0.0015268826391547918,
-0.02681264840066433,
-0.03594157099723816,
-0.01299282070249319,
-0.015693826600909233,
0.0545356459915638,
0.04922788217663765,
-0.031080588698387146,
-0.07140471041202545,
-0.042217567563056946,
-0.0033628949895501137,
0.033654194325208664,
-0.03017333336174488,
-0.06668456643819809,
0.009573061019182205,
-0.015956414863467216,
-0.03975434973835945,
0.014519874006509781,
0.007457610685378313,
0.007026407867670059,
-0.04128829389810562,
0.02562875486910343,
-0.044695205986499786,
-0.018080443143844604,
0.004623811691999435,
0.02056368812918663,
0.018831616267561913,
0.0036063643638044596,
-0.05116770789027214,
0.044878099113702774,
-0.03270241990685463,
0.014776622876524925,
0.03920738026499748,
-0.002978795673698187,
0.006563798990100622,
-0.01123348530381918,
-0.027174346148967743,
-0.007726625539362431,
0.02551303803920746,
0.032569508999586105,
0.0037332300562411547,
0.003647688776254654,
-0.039322126656770706,
0.02697828784584999,
0.029430778697133064,
-0.011185203678905964,
-0.021801559254527092,
-0.03840872645378113,
-0.0066911266185343266,
-0.006441734731197357,
0.013893735595047474,
0.010376823134720325,
-0.033389315009117126,
-0.0024219579063355923,
-0.0775819793343544,
0.007379902061074972,
0.006471280939877033,
-0.013654340989887714,
-0.06835141777992249,
-0.03878769278526306,
-0.004554091952741146,
-0.050491057336330414,
-0.06425058096647263,
-0.05973205715417862,
0.013819714076817036,
-0.045426759868860245,
-0.01539613027125597,
0.024879811331629753,
-0.028267988935112953,
0.04056355729699135,
-0.000909363036043942,
-0.02509581297636032,
0.05037004500627518,
-0.04935678839683533,
0.04750179871916771,
0.038389481604099274,
0.017337951809167862,
-0.01933981105685234,
-0.02214732952415943,
0.05386782065033913,
0.0018633038271218538,
0.013448862358927727,
0.045485708862543106,
-0.03118150308728218,
0.009430063888430595,
-0.03375445678830147,
0.032468996942043304,
-0.04790670797228813,
0.009357837960124016,
-0.01113670039921999,
0.012320526875555515,
-0.033879514783620834,
-0.021122833713889122,
-0.018750745803117752,
-0.0026335581205785275,
0.004910948686301708,
-0.04987712576985359,
-0.011295518837869167,
-0.0049858177080750465,
-0.013485807925462723,
-0.0328400582075119,
-0.021532423794269562,
0.015424498356878757,
-0.003994588274508715,
0.01312084961682558,
0.011590281501412392,
0.02378915250301361,
-0.017820728942751884,
0.004778627306222916,
-0.006955855060368776,
0.035419631749391556,
-0.06057015061378479,
-0.031253013759851456,
-0.05945083126425743,
0.005626167636364698,
-0.02423303946852684,
0.0009701742674224079,
-0.024764131754636765,
0.01385111641138792,
-0.04431060701608658,
-0.0198915284126997,
-0.013788612559437752,
0.0030846057925373316,
0.04447691887617111,
-0.029667114838957787,
-0.015526968985795975,
-0.037058133631944656,
0.01826396770775318,
-0.0385306142270565,
0.00548288831487298,
-0.031356051564216614,
0.0651024654507637,
-0.0010232912609353662,
0.012853248044848442,
0.01834249496459961,
0.002730193082243204,
-0.017144976183772087,
0.03399811312556267,
0.03160769119858742,
0.020054606720805168,
0.032922614365816116,
-0.006450075656175613,
-0.01141980942338705,
0.0320739783346653,
0.02281476929783821,
-0.0007101913797669113,
-0.0247284434735775,
0.006255707703530788,
0.030367810279130936,
0.0031062732450664043,
0.04144837707281113,
-0.010508570820093155,
-0.03056953102350235,
0.022881541401147842,
0.02009119652211666,
0.010574031621217728,
-0.01127693708986044,
0.012025529518723488,
-0.022249659523367882,
-0.031236767768859863,
-0.017993764951825142,
0.04128539189696312,
0.022548194974660873,
-0.012038178741931915,
0.021309608593583107,
-0.011282140389084816,
0.006462267599999905,
0.004212603438645601,
-0.012697180733084679,
-0.015303422696888447,
-0.039336834102869034,
-0.015511516481637955,
0.0013370518572628498,
0.010604813694953918,
0.016872823238372803,
-0.0248485766351223,
0.05946553125977516,
-0.02219749614596367,
0.01273637916892767,
-0.030424196273088455,
0.03686407953500748,
-0.03183897212147713,
0.010477963835000992,
-0.14136402308940887,
0.026828652247786522,
0.007929875515401363,
-0.0015220497734844685,
-0.07963429391384125,
0.016981933265924454,
-0.01846020296216011,
-0.0296322088688612,
0.005588822532445192,
0.014877409674227238,
-0.013717517256736755,
-0.028878146782517433,
-0.0024288087151944637,
0.0033955234102904797,
-0.0294960830360651,
0.014707590453326702,
0.004764338489621878,
-0.0431726910173893,
-0.039729148149490356,
0.045179080218076706,
0.009411259554326534,
0.0006498457514680922,
0.009274931624531746,
-0.020247003063559532,
-0.0054734437726438046,
-0.020333580672740936,
-0.0584421344101429,
-0.016876721754670143,
-0.03325564041733742,
-0.004215841647237539,
-0.048436690121889114,
-0.012858988717198372,
0.0046738130040466785,
0.05314309149980545,
-0.0036875316873192787,
0.007544787600636482,
0.03245300427079201,
-0.02681126445531845,
-0.05487805977463722,
-0.05140363425016403,
-0.04976176470518112,
0.03313722088932991,
-0.02422931417822838,
0.01074619684368372,
0.0330980084836483,
0.010276062414050102,
-0.016667835414409637,
0.002014298690482974,
-0.04804574325680733,
-0.0468825027346611,
0.006419289391487837,
0.023608053103089333,
-0.025069471448659897,
0.05290646478533745,
0.026504257693886757,
0.012480659410357475,
-0.024257449433207512,
-0.01526780053973198,
-0.03187660872936249,
0.04038584604859352,
-0.003265692852437496,
0.009268004447221756,
-0.03284449130296707,
-0.02861139364540577,
-0.02775014191865921,
-0.012017729692161083,
0.03506748378276825,
-0.03288945555686951,
0.005696071777492762,
-0.015453053638339043,
-0.022734908387064934,
-0.02795054391026497,
0.040032777935266495,
-0.0094751613214612,
-0.0166593287140131,
-0.021765602752566338,
-0.0068366616033017635,
-0.018693620339035988,
0.005590178072452545,
-0.011798781342804432,
-0.026825379580259323,
0.00007524174725404009,
-0.05485648661851883,
0.03335901349782944,
0.01667925901710987,
0.01053338311612606,
0.022394463419914246,
-0.0368010587990284,
0.020482413470745087,
-0.02306448295712471,
-0.04107825458049774,
0.006582924164831638,
-0.005294436123222113,
0.03840594366192818,
-0.00278878235258162,
0.010549704544246197,
-0.010007266886532307,
-0.003551201429218054,
-0.019946247339248657,
-0.021945402026176453,
-0.010762703604996204,
-0.014412258751690388,
0.0142654525116086,
-0.007268124260008335,
-0.04438258334994316,
0.007975545711815357,
0.040612250566482544,
0.023381216451525688,
-0.0018818839453160763,
-0.004390783607959747,
-0.0036369601730257273,
-0.03882967308163643,
-0.0457674041390419,
0.02008245326578617,
0.011790230870246887,
0.030734490603208542,
0.009137744084000587,
-0.0023727756924927235,
-0.024305852130055428,
0.03012610599398613,
0.021903667598962784,
0.005367521196603775,
0.02767939120531082,
-0.03480736166238785,
-0.01695425994694233,
0.04020589590072632,
0.05216621980071068,
-0.011897826567292213,
0.015157915651798248,
-0.017478443682193756,
0.028342803940176964,
-0.023525375872850418,
0.010501164942979813,
0.008805487304925919,
0.007931940257549286,
0.009757244028151035,
-0.009307307191193104,
-0.00975445844233036,
-0.026805078610777855,
-0.0774669498205185,
-0.011716966517269611,
-0.01591286063194275,
-0.011321338824927807,
-0.02378435619175434,
-0.03100641816854477,
0.003679311601445079,
0.016568757593631744,
-0.006339635234326124,
-0.006519014947116375,
-0.04317446053028107,
-0.00012084435002179816,
-0.0014029733138158917,
-0.01874624378979206,
0.06259825825691223,
0.010337685234844685,
-0.016575584188103676,
0.05006984621286392,
0.046765536069869995,
0.021631035953760147,
0.037468455731868744,
0.01962374523282051,
-0.003028996055945754,
-0.03518436849117279,
-0.028004221618175507,
-0.030924290418624878,
0.02072809636592865,
-0.016914237290620804,
0.014047853648662567,
-0.0034349020570516586,
-0.006926114205271006,
0.007059793453663588,
0.029895110055804253,
-0.0133581031113863,
-0.019994305446743965,
0.03835873678326607,
-0.027897218242287636,
0.016337508335709572,
0.01454516313970089,
0.07703910022974014,
-0.011894605122506618,
0.024157796055078506,
0.06004388630390167,
-0.004119361750781536,
0.04313948005437851,
-0.03777769207954407,
-0.007857187651097775,
-0.02014634758234024,
0.020619360730051994,
-0.01793881691992283,
-0.007342732977122068,
0.008418652229011059,
0.004006539937108755,
-0.014841130003333092,
-0.03743292763829231,
0.05799933150410652,
0.0213821679353714,
-0.02769065648317337,
0.018395859748125076,
0.006249858066439629,
0.06563924998044968,
0.013190965168178082,
0.009283537976443768,
-0.0816195011138916,
-0.03194097429513931,
-0.001531051704660058,
0.029491301625967026,
0.0058700088411569595,
0.0017474492779001594,
-0.04207824170589447,
0.028888486325740814,
-0.031072374433279037,
-0.01808367483317852,
0.005029859486967325,
0.019465282559394836,
-0.010473353788256645,
0.00727169681340456,
-0.008873596787452698,
-0.061215102672576904,
0.0228675976395607,
-0.006397090386599302,
-0.001200932776555419,
0.056914322078228,
-0.03318982198834419,
-0.020534751936793327,
0.014767111279070377,
0.021382194012403488,
0.020457355305552483,
0.008974523283541203,
0.011084129102528095,
0.001977564301341772,
0.0059667667374014854,
-0.013026081025600433,
0.02306043915450573,
0.028999088332057,
-0.024204999208450317,
0.006890156771987677,
-0.029251929372549057,
-0.05978040769696236,
-0.04285356402397156,
0.020286649465560913,
0.009911063127219677,
0.01032395102083683,
-0.0016047273529693484,
-0.0176682285964489
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:13
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
From early 2005 its business was limited to no more than the engagement of Mr McMasters and it is not clear whether that was undertaken prior to or as at 7 November 2005. He had nothing to do with the forklift.
58In his written submissions Mr Campbell SC submitted that the suggestion that Levira had ceased to have possession of the forklift was not made good because it was premised upon a contention about the cessation of its operations.
He submitted that the premise was flawed because of the doubt surrounding Mr Capper's evidence by reason of the engagement of Mr McMasters. That is addressed by the above findings.
59Mr Campbell SC also contended that QBE had not negatived the operation of s 4(2) of the MAC Act. It is not necessary for me to dwell on the question as to which party bears the onus in relation to the application of s 4(2) as the findings I have made discharge any onus that may have been imposed on QBE. My findings reach back to the beginning of 2005.
If the arrangements by which Megbuy came to use the forklift could be described as a "lending" for the purposes of s 4(2)(a) of the MAC Act then, on my findings, they were a "lending" for a period that exceeded 3 months (see Havas at [12]).
Further, the circumstances in which Megbuy came into the possession of the vehicle mean that it was repaired, maintained and used by it for its own benefit and not that of Levira. Thus s 4(2)(b) does not operate to qualify the satisfaction of s 4(1)(a)(iii) either.
60Accordingly, I am satisfied that as at 7 November 2005 Megbuy was the "owner" of the forklift. I have reached that standard of satisfaction by considering the matter myself de novo. If, contrary to the view I have expressed in [39], this analysis should be undertaken by only determining whether it was reasonable for QBE to compromise the question of ownership, then I am satisfied that it was.
The only real difference between the evidence before me and the material that was before QBE is that which emerged in cross-examination of Mr Capper concerning the engagement of Mr McMasters. The information QBE had available to it during Mr Horwood's proceedings clearly demonstrated that Megbuy was the "owner" of the forklift.
OUTSTANDING OBJECTIONS
61I have described at [32] to [34] above the debate that occurred at the point QBE sought to tender the letter from Mr Horwood's solicitors to Mr Oates with the enclosed unsigned statement.
After my ruling Mr Cavanagh SC tendered further material in an effort to demonstrate both that there was a "reasonable compromise" of Megbuy's alleged liability and, in the event that contrary to my ruling noted at [33], it was ultimately found that QBE is required to demonstrate Megbuy's liability de novo, that it was so liable.
62With some of that material I allowed the tender but made directions under s 136 of the Evidence Act restricting the use that could be made of the evidence so that it could only be relied on as demonstrating that the compromise was reasonable (see [63], [82] and [89] below).
With two items of evidence Mr Campbell SC accepted that the material was admissible in light of the ruling noted at [33], did not seek a direction under s 136 but did make an objection to its tender which he contended would be necessary to decide in the event that ultimately I (or a higher Court) reached a different view to that stated in Zurich v GIO at [57].
I heard argument on the objections and indicated I would rule on them in my final judgment. However, I have doubts about this approach. In my view the appropriate manner in which to proceed was to seek a direction under s 136 at the time of tender.
In any event what follows are my reasons for upholding one and rejecting another of Mr Campbell SC's "contingent objections" to the tender of these two items of evidence. The second item of evidence is considered below, when I address Megbuy's liability on the basis that, contrary to my finding at [37], I am required to consider the question of liability de novo.
|
[
0.02439161017537117,
-0.012881392613053322,
-0.025951994583010674,
0.008767144754529,
0.01780560053884983,
0.0009209185373038054,
0.014405767433345318,
0.03833463415503502,
0.008539466187357903,
0.03668084368109703,
-0.005707988981157541,
-0.00023148114269133657,
-0.01880449429154396,
0.018151840195059776,
-0.031235208734869957,
-0.03679199889302254,
0.0442780926823616,
0.001002090168185532,
-0.04621901363134384,
-0.027739187702536583,
-0.011697929352521896,
-0.05160451680421829,
0.040731534361839294,
0.051040053367614746,
0.04169433191418648,
0.014697495847940445,
0.0007937303744256496,
-0.011285562068223953,
0.0062095606699585915,
0.018056534230709076,
-0.01884308084845543,
-0.00333806243725121,
-0.004621594678610563,
-0.000047011100832605734,
0.015220453031361103,
-0.052379533648490906,
-0.011553624644875526,
0.009654278866946697,
-0.02864992618560791,
-0.00033906911266967654,
-0.013661530800163746,
-0.01577795296907425,
-0.0031640043016523123,
-0.04953893646597862,
0.03818750008940697,
-0.025102859362959862,
-0.0018606474623084068,
-0.02634393982589245,
-0.001884508179500699,
-0.006171992048621178,
-0.06768599897623062,
-0.011595341376960278,
0.06209349259734154,
-0.02991865947842598,
0.00033081622677855194,
0.011996179819107056,
0.009451687335968018,
-0.021808462217450142,
-0.0595887117087841,
-0.02342967316508293,
-0.025193648412823677,
-0.02984725683927536,
0.0012262997915968299,
0.0020375687163323164,
0.02656567096710205,
0.05923532694578171,
-0.019221454858779907,
0.002318501705303788,
-0.010561351664364338,
-0.056443896144628525,
0.007628598250448704,
0.012317013926804066,
-0.012356235645711422,
0.022961903363466263,
-0.06828293204307556,
0.003103724680840969,
0.005916379392147064,
0.014181846752762794,
0.015056370757520199,
0.013620072044432163,
0.017564138397574425,
0.022185929119586945,
-0.026242904365062714,
0.020769070833921432,
0.01098712906241417,
-0.03361702337861061,
-0.02603430300951004,
-0.011419568210840225,
-0.012985196895897388,
0.03004509024322033,
-0.009855822660028934,
-0.007886308245360851,
-0.005029245745390654,
-0.04814473167061806,
-0.005011341068893671,
0.006169457454234362,
-0.06443306803703308,
0.021963395178318024,
0.027350937947630882,
0.018942637369036674,
-0.011366366408765316,
0.027905665338039398,
0.016715943813323975,
-0.04001234844326973,
0.0034387519117444754,
-0.017136817798018456,
-0.004248255398124456,
0.049621060490608215,
-0.00144676910713315,
0.0023934233468025923,
0.008510441519320011,
0.012137115933001041,
-0.006744553800672293,
0.021996475756168365,
-0.0008398887002840638,
-0.027659697458148003,
0.013361865654587746,
-0.024727247655391693,
0.017914723604917526,
-0.025624873116612434,
0.04981059581041336,
0.04758908599615097,
0.058459147810935974,
-0.021702667698264122,
-0.05201650410890579,
-0.002666198182851076,
0.008500427938997746,
-0.04429464414715767,
-0.055291566997766495,
0.015093250200152397,
0.0007042043725959957,
-0.02621985785663128,
-0.013149605132639408,
-0.0867229700088501,
-0.03747473284602165,
-0.028138503432273865,
0.014121940359473228,
0.024202421307563782,
-0.032867882400751114,
-0.02988601103425026,
0.07429586350917816,
0.03971979022026062,
-0.003648397047072649,
-0.018545325845479965,
0.036869145929813385,
-0.02105403132736683,
0.051133155822753906,
-0.04131130874156952,
0.00044400227488949895,
-0.03495445474982262,
0.002874525962397456,
0.017916444689035416,
-0.019923541694879532,
-0.02899005264043808,
0.03388239070773125,
-0.042173128575086594,
0.021015657112002373,
0.018272114917635918,
-0.009839885868132114,
0.06955722719430923,
0.011489459313452244,
0.030992837622761726,
-0.02929805777966976,
-0.018387971445918083,
-0.011168926022946835,
0.005407793913036585,
-0.0007778431754559278,
0.026289978995919228,
-0.0024187618400901556,
-0.020539943128824234,
0.032752130180597305,
-0.0011530540650710464,
0.03851442411541939,
-0.005205506458878517,
0.020412538200616837,
0.03534520044922829,
0.0493527315557003,
0.02459815703332424,
0.004845387768000364,
-0.06337805837392807,
-0.012541431002318859,
0.017078720033168793,
0.005704878829419613,
-0.03189718723297119,
-0.03775830939412117,
0.005491307005286217,
0.014468550682067871,
-0.057080935686826706,
0.024752968922257423,
0.00757773919031024,
-0.00577126769348979,
-0.019250163808465004,
0.019240137189626694,
-0.0016884006327018142,
-0.0007971881423145533,
-0.005096361506730318,
-0.0025220431853085756,
0.022437814623117447,
0.021225515753030777,
-0.04430548474192619,
-0.0386674702167511,
0.014452162198722363,
0.062358856201171875,
-0.02708194963634014,
-0.04267648607492447,
0.0069962600246071815,
-0.04431900382041931,
0.02691640891134739,
0.018993007019162178,
-0.08933014422655106,
0.00036485897726379335,
0.02978774718940258,
0.03101583942770958,
0.025844089686870575,
-0.014042767696082592,
-0.03237326815724373,
-0.0013986688572913408,
-0.006927967071533203,
0.02863931842148304,
-0.014699525199830532,
0.005749143660068512,
0.020641570910811424,
0.011247111484408379,
0.022600803524255753,
-0.010914157144725323,
0.001161386026069522,
-0.055691227316856384,
0.05908162519335747,
0.010598701424896717,
-0.019693782553076744,
0.07567539811134338,
0.0003149627009406686,
0.0011303172213956714,
-0.022486422210931778,
0.019949400797486305,
-0.0012834707740694284,
0.023568423464894295,
0.01689300499856472,
0.030263157561421394,
0.018479524180293083,
-0.010888011194765568,
-0.030913149937987328,
0.03175920993089676,
-0.02158282697200775,
0.022126344963908195,
-0.0006869604112580419,
0.0017603811575099826,
0.04415003955364227,
0.03492987900972366,
0.014590432867407799,
0.01320307794958353,
-0.008224818855524063,
-0.0023303006310015917,
0.0024152870755642653,
0.01126625295728445,
0.038442280143499374,
-0.0006530280807055533,
-0.016789143905043602,
0.03802163898944855,
-0.0006076068384572864,
0.03714793920516968,
0.029299059882760048,
0.03405486047267914,
0.000969103304669261,
-0.023343242704868317,
-0.038556382060050964,
-0.026527438312768936,
-0.009615135379135609,
-0.011950847692787647,
0.024687083438038826,
0.013415311463177204,
0.011316447518765926,
-0.024795982986688614,
0.03539721295237541,
0.029632586985826492,
0.03647054359316826,
0.01378338597714901,
-0.03701906278729439,
0.031331468373537064,
0.020693855360150337,
0.024319054558873177,
0.027836237102746964,
0.03790578991174698,
-0.038361191749572754,
0.025951605290174484,
-0.011080991476774216,
-0.022816313430666924,
-0.01628432795405388,
-0.04398118332028389,
-0.06500234454870224,
0.007131209131330252,
0.041969120502471924,
0.059387411922216415,
-0.0025523959193378687,
-0.051446814090013504,
-0.009091387502849102,
0.013405068777501583,
-0.1583811342716217,
-0.017263777554035187,
0.015166808851063251,
0.006361857987940311,
-0.013253184966742992,
0.018993834033608437,
-0.006193369626998901,
-0.0040447344072163105,
-0.004035403486341238,
0.004964966792613268,
-0.003811354748904705,
-0.059388417750597,
-0.03025023266673088,
0.020262792706489563,
-0.003225912107154727,
-0.01761752739548683,
-0.002787001198157668,
-0.025829413905739784,
0.032384682446718216,
-0.02973860874772072,
-0.0033420880790799856,
-0.030978061258792877,
0.03185831010341644,
0.007178855128586292,
0.05595953390002251,
-0.0467965304851532,
0.010772441513836384,
-0.00047289245412684977,
-0.035215917974710464,
-0.017601730301976204,
-0.020221656188368797,
-0.0008207655628211796,
-0.0040808808989822865,
0.019862009212374687,
0.004415317438542843,
0.02555093541741371,
0.06843771785497665,
-0.07591859251260757,
-0.03130407631397247,
0.01895933598279953,
0.04300656169652939,
0.07344482839107513,
-0.017800381407141685,
-0.018417103216052055,
0.014532146044075489,
-0.0773681104183197,
0.02185220643877983,
0.0007667952449992299,
-0.05766093730926514,
0.005066862795501947,
0.0008465523133054376,
-0.00026679178699851036,
0.00569986691698432,
0.008124537765979767,
-0.011483356356620789,
-0.04039743170142174,
0.03566195070743561,
0.05250507965683937,
-0.029174722731113434,
0.0009764980641193688,
0.021019693464040756,
-0.08711081743240356,
0.06365114450454712,
0.001015445333905518,
-0.05846666172146797,
0.009406758472323418,
-0.026567615568637848,
-0.009778023697435856,
0.02597016841173172,
-0.011918524280190468,
-0.014787236228585243,
-0.034698810428380966,
0.025722051039338112,
0.010562367737293243,
-0.018176866695284843,
0.03468737006187439,
-0.005053125321865082,
-0.028834758326411247,
0.004193529486656189,
-0.0754862129688263,
0.015250573866069317,
0.0053640082478523254,
-0.015904974192380905,
0.013893290422856808,
-0.0007868155371397734,
0.03298017755150795,
0.013817772269248962,
0.023481575772166252,
0.0663175955414772,
0.23643989861011505,
0.0060342419892549515,
0.00570986233651638,
-0.012491950765252113,
0.018633922562003136,
0.029326017946004868,
0.020441662520170212,
0.05919341370463371,
-0.002030041068792343,
-0.020642679184675217,
-0.034698642790317535,
-0.009817737154662609,
0.03729137405753136,
0.009501545690000057,
-0.03098161704838276,
-0.042300816625356674,
-0.0379224456846714,
-0.046430554240942,
0.08811251074075699,
0.007771288510411978,
0.04283404350280762,
-0.004517145920544863,
0.0023025614209473133,
0.030298180878162384,
-0.07077256590127945,
-0.031926531344652176,
0.028497178107500076,
0.028574557974934578,
-0.0002094558731187135,
0.032419394701719284,
-0.00085358606884256,
0.004276429768651724,
0.015451636165380478,
-0.026401648297905922,
0.018199801445007324,
0.013296653516590595,
-0.009716030210256577,
0.012191754765808582,
-0.016837717965245247,
0.052501775324344635,
0.009008732624351978,
-0.00974804162979126,
-0.03793947771191597,
-0.033649805933237076,
-0.017444008961319923,
0.01566438376903534,
0.0015942525351420045,
0.05965011939406395,
-0.014829487539827824,
0.018742699176073074,
-0.06949049234390259,
-0.028327880427241325,
-0.026211176067590714,
0.014122994616627693,
-0.014344376511871815,
0.02426012046635151,
-0.03712816163897514,
0.035542670637369156,
-0.002591499825939536,
0.054387446492910385,
0.01556900329887867,
0.025903498753905296,
-0.024182191118597984,
0.03680538758635521,
-0.0012077559949830174,
-0.0045733521692454815,
-0.057026494294404984,
-0.006809935439378023,
0.06520473212003708,
-0.016598662361502647,
0.022246867418289185,
0.042591121047735214,
0.017657332122325897,
0.024960186332464218,
0.032946184277534485,
0.026217449456453323,
0.007791183888912201,
0.038410477340221405,
0.01307943370193243,
0.02255908027291298,
-0.013066296465694904,
0.006563355214893818,
0.006592434365302324,
0.02611091174185276,
0.017247840762138367,
-0.020605366677045822,
-0.0035822924692183733,
0.0443638451397419,
-0.00019289657939225435,
-0.027990231290459633,
-0.05595874413847923,
-0.029151925817131996,
-0.012284405529499054,
0.011732752434909344,
-0.029546108096837997,
0.0007887326064519584,
0.006320321466773748,
0.0076805585995316505,
0.00236710999161005,
-0.006205207202583551,
-0.03267911821603775,
0.021965395659208298,
0.0193841140717268,
-0.0052262539975345135,
-0.00956130214035511,
-0.031147588044404984,
-0.006511033978313208,
-0.00001532459464215208,
-0.027876831591129303,
0.007687686011195183,
0.026454612612724304,
0.023653702810406685,
-0.05189787223935127,
-0.012166290543973446,
0.013005050830543041,
0.025897836312651634,
-0.07419464737176895,
0.0455225333571434,
0.014475710690021515,
0.03896879404783249,
0.020792821422219276,
-0.0078629394993186,
-0.02111743949353695,
-0.0018229159759357572,
-0.0026557662058621645,
-0.04609108343720436,
-0.05641356483101845,
-0.02739807777106762,
0.00033436986268498003,
0.02896173670887947,
0.03973696380853653,
-0.008071452379226685,
-0.033347342163324356,
-0.01628730818629265,
0.02631249651312828,
-0.0024653126019984484,
-0.030564533546566963,
0.028594840317964554,
-0.052266620099544525,
0.010503938421607018,
-0.03720296174287796,
-0.03095943294465542,
-0.04194127023220062,
0.006690010894089937,
-0.0009995613945648074,
-0.033126648515462875,
-0.04714019224047661,
0.030807925388216972,
-0.022043900564312935,
-0.027510052546858788,
-0.0035185725428164005,
0.01901945099234581,
-0.018465891480445862,
-0.03583251312375069,
-0.017361987382173538,
0.017104629427194595,
0.009183564223349094,
0.018869338557124138,
0.009930242784321308,
-0.03888806328177452,
-0.004157822113484144,
-0.03170715644955635,
0.00867443811148405,
0.047133397310972214,
-0.007039057556539774,
0.06180907413363457,
-0.013284155167639256,
0.06779379397630692,
0.054802943021059036,
-0.007127030286937952,
-0.030387822538614273,
-0.02488158643245697,
0.008624917827546597,
0.02886703982949257,
0.05463400110602379,
0.06182731315493584,
-0.004957409575581551,
0.050524841994047165,
-0.014967786148190498,
-0.019800318405032158,
0.014906113035976887,
0.02326691523194313,
-0.04303763061761856,
-0.013396511785686016,
-0.021460043266415596,
-0.0058648367412388325,
0.014435786753892899,
-0.026531247422099113,
0.042518291622400284,
-0.021936221048235893,
-0.018457412719726562,
0.09472566843032837,
-0.020435132086277008,
-0.02643708512187004,
0.014234681613743305,
0.03452293202280998,
0.003968443255871534,
-0.002314395271241665,
0.008534635417163372,
-0.06653102487325668,
-0.0056981733068823814,
0.033787716180086136,
0.01167757622897625,
-0.022537264972925186,
0.02938261814415455,
-0.005383514799177647,
0.015687765553593636,
0.027178814634680748,
-0.002792778890579939,
-0.021374767646193504,
0.02531524747610092,
0.04053338244557381,
-0.009021428413689137,
0.0018101909663528204,
-0.012535088695585728,
0.029520217329263687,
0.032563336193561554,
0.05322027578949928,
-0.008861876092851162,
-0.045901622623205185,
0.0024018522817641497,
-0.021964019164443016,
0.008983449079096317,
-0.06751560419797897,
-0.03262358903884888,
0.027068430557847023,
0.004440207965672016,
-0.01014409214258194,
0.02455257438123226,
-0.0053438651375472546,
0.009660652838647366,
-0.017809517681598663,
0.015885990113019943,
-0.01110290177166462,
0.010094801895320415,
-0.017480812966823578,
0.03249752148985863,
0.009599456563591957,
-0.016105150803923607,
0.004455165471881628,
0.039703451097011566,
-0.017063993960618973,
0.010959041304886341,
0.0706171840429306,
-0.02500092424452305,
-0.030760930851101875,
-0.010229435749351978,
-0.012935263104736805,
0.011382082477211952,
0.011312155984342098,
-0.02660212107002735,
0.0025048216339200735,
0.010302065871655941,
-0.013763083145022392,
0.010334290564060211,
-0.009984893724322319,
0.0016975031467154622,
-0.01732301153242588,
-0.10988787561655045,
-0.03860842436552048,
0.014025554060935974,
0.02011822536587715,
-0.0016959176864475012,
-0.014346119947731495,
0.012136644683778286,
-0.06887062638998032,
0.021885283291339874,
-0.040059059858322144,
-0.007102527655661106,
-0.03402291610836983,
-0.013849555514752865,
0.01466126088052988,
-0.0464169979095459,
-0.07130254060029984,
-0.018716702237725258,
0.01827910542488098,
-0.010697383433580399,
0.0002905502333305776,
0.0027042569126933813,
0.0019261426059529185,
0.029011540114879608,
0.021055446937680244,
0.006821544840931892,
0.018749110400676727,
-0.009837482124567032,
0.0008029253222048283,
0.012335451319813728,
0.021033506840467453,
0.011482615023851395,
-0.023492107167840004,
0.014331748709082603,
0.03616104647517204,
-0.009438799694180489,
0.020524227991700172,
-0.02109391987323761,
-0.008352303877472878,
0.001054464839398861,
0.05606706440448761,
-0.03168870136141777,
0.02261088788509369,
-0.01456438284367323,
-0.00075712357647717,
-0.04160134494304657,
-0.04508914053440094,
-0.04589550569653511,
-0.023952383548021317,
0.023609330877661705,
-0.018963603302836418,
-0.011433819308876991,
0.03597436472773552,
0.02195156365633011,
-0.06487573683261871,
-0.0445052795112133,
-0.03567574545741081,
-0.012356995604932308,
0.012960022315382957,
0.01269486453384161,
-0.01023929100483656,
-0.01214794721454382,
-0.0008456446812488139,
0.0016199923120439053,
0.012883775867521763,
-0.021930154412984848,
-0.005399317014962435,
-0.08122262358665466,
0.029408585280179977,
0.015357213094830513,
-0.0031376045662909746,
-0.015763891860842705,
-0.006908759009093046,
-0.007828060537576675,
-0.002123746555298567,
-0.011769573204219341,
0.01471887156367302,
0.08605040609836578,
0.03501489385962486,
-0.03582742065191269,
-0.016091348603367805,
0.062308140099048615,
-0.02998191863298416,
-0.014945214614272118,
-0.06332706660032272,
0.06086578592658043,
-0.01627599447965622,
0.01839401200413704,
-0.0016606501303613186,
-0.0003869413339998573,
0.008517579175531864,
0.01475844532251358,
0.030308902263641357,
-0.010065209120512009,
-0.003770278999581933,
-0.01041517872363329,
-0.04727741330862045,
0.023203091695904732,
0.027511250227689743,
0.006297441199421883,
0.029734371230006218,
0.04369250684976578,
-0.007144755683839321,
-0.02771739475429058,
0.03789316862821579,
-0.016049375757575035,
-0.03279596194624901,
-0.008774969726800919,
-0.0035568787716329098,
0.006575538776814938,
0.0208235252648592,
-0.009262275882065296,
-0.0033393497578799725,
0.03710485249757767,
-0.045190490782260895,
0.03334248811006546,
-0.014909854158759117,
-0.01724587380886078,
-0.003898827126249671,
-0.000892843003384769,
-0.019791176542639732,
-0.04102868214249611,
0.019434913992881775,
-0.0060162171721458435,
-0.06260760128498077,
-0.008821479044854641,
-0.009944308549165726,
0.042837709188461304,
-0.01104766596108675,
-0.006117339711636305,
0.019290106371045113,
-0.036098677664995193,
0.016363946720957756,
0.008770110085606575,
0.07164032757282257,
-0.051079168915748596,
0.039847396314144135,
-0.13963334262371063,
0.021538501605391502,
-0.01242635678499937,
0.003213289426639676,
-0.040946587920188904,
-0.009390209801495075,
0.006078221369534731,
0.013590130023658276,
-0.021327603608369827,
-0.00325674656778574,
-0.03948644548654556,
-0.02728140726685524,
0.04295028746128082,
-0.01404130645096302,
-0.037560224533081055,
0.04828424006700516,
-0.009896727278828621,
-0.043603554368019104,
-0.03469507768750191,
0.05315389111638069,
0.021011676639318466,
0.0040356675162911415,
0.011515227146446705,
-0.02810048498213291,
-0.03873409330844879,
0.012108744122087955,
-0.02711724489927292,
-0.02281891368329525,
-0.025840945541858673,
-0.005278675351291895,
-0.025991130620241165,
-0.02602265402674675,
0.012888352386653423,
0.04949658364057541,
0.00910736434161663,
0.006497261114418507,
0.03578619658946991,
-0.046781864017248154,
-0.03578381985425949,
-0.017936600372195244,
-0.0015911374939605594,
0.017906110733747482,
0.012068478390574455,
-0.025159740820527077,
-0.004550416953861713,
-0.003046792233362794,
0.028329625725746155,
0.002944524399936199,
-0.053371235728263855,
-0.030603686347603798,
-0.0483238585293293,
0.015105599537491798,
-0.02184726856648922,
0.041223522275686264,
0.03049015998840332,
-0.006473898887634277,
-0.020905673503875732,
-0.04228617623448372,
-0.044793177396059036,
0.06625404953956604,
0.0009332739282399416,
0.010014793835580349,
-0.022410152480006218,
-0.04731541872024536,
0.010241847485303879,
-0.008886374533176422,
-0.020946091040968895,
0.015415345318615437,
0.013864069245755672,
0.008687954396009445,
0.0049309623427689075,
-0.02355780079960823,
0.0061204684898257256,
-0.009464623406529427,
-0.0167851485311985,
-0.0036081532016396523,
0.005286727100610733,
0.036835942417383194,
0.0016885678051039577,
0.006746203172951937,
-0.017341352999210358,
-0.012990448623895645,
-0.054167553782463074,
-0.033523235470056534,
0.07811953872442245,
0.019127216190099716,
-0.0331093966960907,
-0.05517293140292168,
0.06276588141918182,
-0.041262805461883545,
-0.05013154819607735,
-0.008207428269088268,
-0.015886839479207993,
0.03081692010164261,
-0.02496342733502388,
0.06569018959999084,
-0.011376193724572659,
-0.004834685940295458,
-0.013098791241645813,
0.0007159850792959332,
-0.04576088488101959,
-0.03651309385895729,
0.0034728352911770344,
-0.014640606008470058,
0.004407277796417475,
0.03692418336868286,
-0.00036183561314828694,
0.001841677469201386,
-0.0008542545838281512,
0.021237948909401894,
-0.03696713596582413,
-0.025800133123993874,
-0.01657314971089363,
-0.0020368648692965508,
-0.050514791160821915,
0.019519109278917313,
-0.007055406458675861,
0.0007608291343785822,
-0.04697422310709953,
0.0006020868313498795,
0.048576969653367996,
-0.03388921916484833,
0.0049726702272892,
-0.01940222457051277,
-0.001975251827389002,
0.04637708514928818,
0.035957708954811096,
-0.020208632573485374,
0.01625913381576538,
0.016966266557574272,
0.04659254103899002,
0.015348357148468494,
-0.0218036025762558,
0.027180451899766922,
-0.003320119110867381,
0.011424874886870384,
-0.02409960702061653,
0.01232990063726902,
-0.027037784457206726,
-0.057358771562576294,
-0.022788627073168755,
-0.033263660967350006,
-0.016218557953834534,
-0.0015337580116465688,
-0.01987796276807785,
0.002068418078124523,
0.02520640753209591,
0.041027504950761795,
-0.02505425177514553,
-0.05657137557864189,
-0.01753607764840126,
-0.04080832004547119,
-0.0064300596714019775,
0.05398474633693695,
0.006321500986814499,
0.004346010275185108,
0.04279908910393715,
-0.03175592049956322,
-0.025306809693574905,
0.02971901185810566,
0.05506320297718048,
-0.014533772133290768,
-0.020079856738448143,
-0.023718127980828285,
-0.021957337856292725,
0.069354347884655,
0.007516663055866957,
0.0034934866707772017,
-0.02826477773487568,
-0.0041936784982681274,
-0.0006162652862258255,
0.05123380199074745,
-0.0016265733866021037,
0.022538240998983383,
0.03936545178294182,
-0.07763060927391052,
-0.023702114820480347,
0.004998447839170694,
0.056348059326410294,
-0.004041296895593405,
0.06253400444984436,
0.0228979904204607,
-0.009010542184114456,
0.027825094759464264,
0.0374053418636322,
0.05128281190991402,
-0.006459165830165148,
-0.012546230107545853,
0.001281574135646224,
-0.015494538471102715,
0.014437910169363022,
-0.008720723912119865,
-0.010586322285234928,
-0.023294560611248016,
0.04451405256986618,
0.02508658356964588,
-0.012650256045162678,
0.03515425696969032,
-0.035674065351486206,
0.021722864359617233,
0.02117016911506653,
0.013240499421954155,
-0.032364118844270706,
-0.010231615975499153,
-0.04401952028274536,
-0.034875672310590744,
0.03331448510289192,
-0.0292238537222147,
-0.004396610427647829,
0.020138492807745934,
-0.053503893315792084,
0.014373497106134892,
-0.014118611812591553,
0.030926864594221115,
-0.003872349625453353,
-0.004819218069314957,
-0.0026438352651894093,
-0.007208081893622875,
0.004721543751657009,
0.03606480732560158,
0.01651904545724392,
0.057147979736328125,
-0.033885881304740906,
-0.019808737561106682,
0.0007932941080071032,
0.003193231299519539,
-0.027955571189522743,
-0.008809655904769897,
0.029093455523252487,
-0.0062299976125359535,
-0.04896369203925133,
0.007721289526671171,
0.004696464631706476,
0.02616538107395172,
0.009840949438512325,
-0.0248679518699646,
-0.031775496900081635,
-0.05033102259039879,
-0.01648763008415699,
-0.023843873292207718,
0.06072448939085007,
0.006345639005303383,
0.015006175264716148,
0.021498043090105057
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:18
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
"The steering was not dangerous. There was a reasonable level of wear in the steering so that sometimes it could react very quickly and sharply and turn and other times one could turn the wheel and nothing happened. Then, you turned it a little bit more and there was sharp movement. Overall he states there was 'a lot of playing in the steering'.
Gus Gillett got quotes for repairs and parts to repair the steering, but Terry Capper always refused to have this work done. He does not know why, but assumed that Terry Capper did not want to spend the money.
The forklift could have 'speed wobbles'. He admitted that this is a common problem when forklifts are driven on a road."
88The investigator's report records that Mr Gillett also advised the investigator that by chance he was working near the accident and attended at the scene about 10-15 minutes after it occurred. He is recorded by the investigator as "speculat [ing] that the loose steering, and slope of the road where the accident happened may have combined to contribute to the accident".
89The investigator's log also included a file note of an interview with Kim Sanderson who had worked with Mr Capper since 1999. The log records Mr Sanderson being of the view that the forklift was "unroadworthy" but that "he never thought it was dangerous". The interview notes further record that Mr Sanderson advised the investigator that:
"... he was aware that the steering was 'a bit loose'. He concluded this due to his experience driving the forklift and finding that if he drove over a bump on a public road the machine could unexpectedly jump to the right.
He also noted the driver needed to turn the steering wheel continuously to the left and to the right to keep the machine heading in a straight direction. The steering mechanisms are located at the rear of the forklift and this can add to the difficulties with driving.
.......
Kim Sanderson stated that it was his experience with [the forklift] that the steering suddenly jerking to the right was enough to cause the forklift to go out of control and tip over.
Kim Sanderson noted this was a common "failing" of forklifts and not just QBU 771. He speculated that there might be a manufacturing defect in all forklifts to cause them to behave as he described." (emphasis added)
I made a direction under s 136 of the Evidence Act in relation to the italicised portion of this extract to the same effect as that described in [82] above.
90The investigator's notes also record that they contacted Ty Ralph who was the Megbuy employee who took over the responsibility for the repair and maintenance of the forklift after May 2005.
Again, it was common ground that Mr Ralph was not a qualified mechanic. The investigator's notes record that they spoke to Mr Ralph about the forklift but "surprisingly, he denied any knowledge of its mechanics".
91The investigator's notes also contain a note of discussion with a mechanic, Les Gers. He did not inspect the forklift prior to the accident. He recalled "some weeks/months" after the accident he had received a telephone call from Mr Ralph who had asked him to prepare an independent report for WorkCover. Mr Gers agreed to look at the forklift and gave Mr Ralph a verbal list of repairs.
The work was carried out and he inspected the forklift. He did not recall the list but could recall the handbrake and headlights needed adjusting. This led to Mr Gers preparing a note for WorkCover stating the condition of the forklift complied with requirements. The document was tendered by CGU. It bore the date 12 October 2006.
92Mr Capper signed a statement dated 25 June 2007 which was provided to QBE. It relevantly stated:
"It [the forklift] was serviced and maintained internally at 86 Pinnacles Place Broken Hill. There are no records of the servicing and maintenance held. The driver checks the machine each day morning - oil and water levels. They run on LPG. There was nothing wrong with the forklift.
I have a defect book at 86 Pinnacles Place and there is no entry by Peter Horwood that there was anything wrong with the forklift.
|
[
-0.011390319094061852,
-0.011106233112514019,
-0.029431577771902084,
-0.02462190017104149,
0.024105068296194077,
-0.01944524422287941,
-0.026709308847784996,
0.025900060310959816,
0.04906807467341423,
0.0315578393638134,
0.013797206804156303,
0.038111019879579544,
0.013316606171429157,
-0.02940019592642784,
0.03211459144949913,
-0.024465437978506088,
0.008863845840096474,
-0.039217811077833176,
-0.03267035260796547,
-0.04134780168533325,
-0.0007066777325235307,
-0.0046965754590928555,
0.043624069541692734,
0.03596464544534683,
-0.005358963273465633,
0.036666374653577805,
-0.0038279730360955,
0.011198981665074825,
-0.010190523229539394,
-0.04216820001602173,
-0.026650825515389442,
0.0013214914361014962,
0.000748521473724395,
-0.005771115887910128,
-0.007542446721345186,
-0.07822874933481216,
0.02237050049006939,
-0.015475966967642307,
-0.02549959346652031,
-0.004809934180229902,
-0.009661263786256313,
-0.013786486349999905,
0.07485860586166382,
-0.03566891700029373,
0.03707023337483406,
-0.022809147834777832,
-0.04086317494511604,
-0.025852536782622337,
0.03851199150085449,
-0.005395089741796255,
-0.00645038764923811,
-0.009177125059068203,
0.014554912224411964,
-0.038901858031749725,
0.033634450286626816,
-0.0027747773565351963,
-0.013871017843484879,
-0.024593451991677284,
-0.05681249871850014,
0.023973306640982628,
-0.027034012600779533,
-0.012636368162930012,
0.024601316079497337,
-0.018193554133176804,
0.005752803757786751,
0.10505086928606033,
-0.04983329400420189,
-0.02397807314991951,
-0.007617234718054533,
-0.010087274014949799,
-0.010645315982401371,
-0.005928792990744114,
0.012302574701607227,
0.02111630327999592,
-0.03518602252006531,
0.05521026998758316,
0.03305184096097946,
0.004140547942370176,
0.025219008326530457,
0.03639648109674454,
0.040776435285806656,
0.030838618054986,
0.0002795094042085111,
0.016228128224611282,
0.013663902878761292,
0.02181427553296089,
-0.03654857724905014,
0.044407643377780914,
0.0011451890459284186,
-0.016575949266552925,
-0.008956113830208778,
0.01047166995704174,
0.0181617122143507,
-0.002082381397485733,
-0.045715440064668655,
0.018909472972154617,
-0.005111389793455601,
0.054650913923978806,
0.0022494273725897074,
-0.009842447005212307,
-0.009863307699561119,
-0.02088194340467453,
0.027203604578971863,
-0.03850933536887169,
0.04148811101913452,
-0.025063227862119675,
0.025260930880904198,
0.05455353856086731,
0.04162047803401947,
-0.021983781829476357,
0.028924819082021713,
-0.01447086501866579,
-0.008931510150432587,
0.011571609415113926,
-0.04159380495548248,
-0.009091910906136036,
0.03166615962982178,
-0.04350440576672554,
0.023437660187482834,
-0.0034622156526893377,
0.04062956944108009,
0.029966574162244797,
0.06193951889872551,
-0.02431063912808895,
-0.028008129447698593,
-0.025681715458631516,
-0.02496895007789135,
-0.03260016441345215,
-0.014704580418765545,
0.02028966322541237,
-0.0042889793403446674,
0.020147940143942833,
-0.022747080773115158,
-0.03664248809218407,
-0.04949934035539627,
-0.0354701466858387,
0.011574818752706051,
0.029658053070306778,
-0.027311254292726517,
-0.00511386850848794,
0.026062125340104103,
0.09196019172668457,
0.025726845487952232,
-0.017347261309623718,
0.02432718500494957,
0.01594906486570835,
0.0009917371207848191,
-0.0036311212461441755,
-0.005985049530863762,
-0.0032386062666773796,
0.027588242664933205,
-0.030422775074839592,
-0.00898212380707264,
0.002143555087968707,
0.04216363653540611,
-0.033434730023145676,
-0.011938844807446003,
0.003083484247326851,
-0.01998046226799488,
0.011563867330551147,
0.01828521117568016,
0.05528280884027481,
0.004840581677854061,
-0.038925305008888245,
0.055980004370212555,
-0.011801319196820259,
0.022551069036126137,
-0.02556002326309681,
-0.026151025667786598,
-0.03831014037132263,
0.0000029930611162853893,
-0.010394252836704254,
0.018215307965874672,
0.01721728779375553,
0.02144225500524044,
0.03862833231687546,
0.05807516723871231,
0.011141031980514526,
0.06290515512228012,
-0.036822110414505005,
0.0002146515907952562,
0.025708410888910294,
0.022280985489487648,
0.036855898797512054,
-0.00830097496509552,
0.04858570918440819,
0.028712064027786255,
-0.013209076598286629,
0.026226896792650223,
0.021707363426685333,
-0.01271812990307808,
-0.02312137745320797,
0.015085343271493912,
0.02661762945353985,
0.035490818321704865,
0.002298861276358366,
0.03721842169761658,
-0.014396345242857933,
0.03379558399319649,
-0.009054391644895077,
-0.0024375703651458025,
0.045747868716716766,
0.06588446348905563,
-0.002054203301668167,
-0.018723366782069206,
-0.007164028938859701,
-0.04733027145266533,
0.007411023136228323,
0.013463272713124752,
-0.06734993308782578,
0.026867317035794258,
-0.005571581423282623,
0.003520887577906251,
0.05197566747665405,
-0.006660920567810535,
0.01927797496318817,
0.007896309718489647,
0.01055180188268423,
0.021704336628317833,
-0.014786339364945889,
-0.01963416300714016,
0.010389289818704128,
-0.011509674601256847,
-0.03521345928311348,
0.013527117669582367,
0.04468764364719391,
-0.036481019109487534,
0.025895049795508385,
0.01885819248855114,
-0.05067029967904091,
0.05401584506034851,
0.006640261970460415,
0.009432381018996239,
-0.006815202068537474,
0.012868175283074379,
-0.0027396478690207005,
0.04028739780187607,
-0.015042617917060852,
0.056381966918706894,
0.04193983972072601,
-0.003060964634642005,
-0.0081007806584239,
0.037103425711393356,
0.00007274216477526352,
-0.018206080421805382,
-0.008198102936148643,
0.02664664387702942,
0.023009123280644417,
0.014160730876028538,
0.021345458924770355,
0.057378750294446945,
-0.0007216882659122348,
-0.013180815614759922,
-0.0013354177353903651,
0.015894973650574684,
0.037782859057188034,
0.03313928470015526,
-0.02015649899840355,
-0.008389027789235115,
-0.018289802595973015,
0.005745589267462492,
0.02875000610947609,
0.01391947828233242,
0.00027459306875243783,
-0.024779746308922768,
0.002711998764425516,
-0.027170328423380852,
-0.09752557426691055,
-0.03218851238489151,
0.005610531661659479,
-0.008036051876842976,
0.0011570773785933852,
0.0037907036021351814,
-0.019095130264759064,
-0.000903054082300514,
0.021948406472802162,
-0.029331626370549202,
0.006676402874290943,
0.0439659021794796,
-0.025235017761588097,
0.05036744847893715,
-0.0284890066832304,
0.019846513867378235,
-0.004316932521760464,
0.03373418375849724,
-0.010290236212313175,
-0.022845199331641197,
-0.06523708254098892,
-0.0218157060444355,
-0.04289420321583748,
0.02418481558561325,
-0.05326635390520096,
0.05960303172469139,
-0.0198605265468359,
-0.024385124444961548,
0.01581719145178795,
0.006782239302992821,
-0.14493614435195923,
0.02784554846584797,
0.019727550446987152,
-0.009291552938520908,
0.011956424452364445,
0.014784175902605057,
-0.012763548642396927,
-0.0025827952194958925,
-0.06892146915197372,
-0.020841682329773903,
0.033065758645534515,
-0.026927663013339043,
-0.01927327737212181,
0.007894662208855152,
-0.015173478983342648,
-0.03792063519358635,
-0.003465748857706785,
0.01934869959950447,
0.003142699133604765,
-0.042231447994709015,
0.013145554810762405,
-0.018736178055405617,
0.07379482686519623,
0.012109105475246906,
-0.04139716923236847,
-0.021382056176662445,
0.04591026529669762,
0.016373632475733757,
-0.02209172584116459,
-0.026144683361053467,
-0.006785271223634481,
-0.011046904139220715,
-0.011286385357379913,
0.06331247836351395,
0.015773413702845573,
0.009363186545670033,
0.03937411308288574,
-0.08718526363372803,
0.003305623773485422,
0.00614137900993228,
0.00636528292670846,
0.114243283867836,
-0.03013600781559944,
0.018134450539946556,
0.02586270682513714,
-0.08465323597192764,
0.047416456043720245,
-0.01847101002931595,
-0.07389166951179504,
0.03722069412469864,
-0.007995924912393093,
-0.026792827993631363,
-0.03267358988523483,
0.009496018290519714,
-0.01645682565867901,
0.01445876993238926,
0.017588673159480095,
0.010720660910010338,
-0.02207762934267521,
0.005779589526355267,
-0.03450920805335045,
-0.07845555245876312,
-0.0008563426672481,
0.062286779284477234,
-0.026811446994543076,
0.02044019103050232,
0.00885835662484169,
-0.033589769154787064,
0.02601383998990059,
0.011548916809260845,
-0.04239986836910248,
-0.0727258175611496,
0.03428277745842934,
0.001342564937658608,
0.029564129188656807,
0.031074220314621925,
-0.012372772209346294,
-0.0005095054511912167,
0.029963187873363495,
-0.09676700085401535,
0.005570795852690935,
0.02910485491156578,
0.003022188786417246,
-0.009141676127910614,
-0.001918793423101306,
0.052481479942798615,
0.01002610195428133,
0.04904015362262726,
0.05033925175666809,
0.2647244930267334,
-0.01435224898159504,
-0.05110827088356018,
0.012344196438789368,
0.006558463908731937,
0.028962770476937294,
0.032166581600904465,
-0.006817142944782972,
0.02592066116631031,
-0.02066107653081417,
-0.051480453461408615,
0.009905110113322735,
0.026020472869277,
0.02484433725476265,
0.000010853813364519738,
0.008437367156147957,
-0.029762649908661842,
-0.04369166120886803,
0.0678718239068985,
-0.012816952541470528,
0.05983258783817291,
0.020556651055812836,
0.044555820524692535,
-0.012963473796844482,
-0.08028827607631683,
-0.013898445293307304,
-0.005242583807557821,
0.0022464313078671694,
0.014561029151082039,
0.02394179068505764,
-0.011946181766688824,
-0.010589776560664177,
0.032943014055490494,
-0.01685590296983719,
-0.022197652608156204,
0.016062460839748383,
0.012599529698491096,
-0.012469494715332985,
0.025905558839440346,
0.02590116485953331,
0.037090763449668884,
-0.012366903945803642,
-0.013425071723759174,
-0.027682332322001457,
-0.041311223059892654,
-0.018231235444545746,
0.007142673246562481,
-0.0025013554841279984,
-0.022816089913249016,
0.02897658385336399,
-0.04478663206100464,
0.034879330545663834,
-0.00658451858907938,
-0.023764237761497498,
-0.03158513084053993,
0.01916453056037426,
0.008595353923738003,
-0.0024274373427033424,
-0.008665340021252632,
0.0478547178208828,
0.028315626084804535,
0.02708345092833042,
-0.015853866934776306,
0.037179578095674515,
-0.007964911870658398,
0.006651811767369509,
-0.006445946637541056,
-0.03364907205104828,
0.033953506499528885,
-0.016048489138484,
-0.013884763233363628,
0.02078002132475376,
-0.004302455112338066,
0.05118398368358612,
0.031238768249750137,
-0.0005401356611400843,
0.0305626317858696,
0.062341440469026566,
-0.022776836529374123,
0.00015285241534002125,
-0.037909094244241714,
-0.031228691339492798,
0.009291301481425762,
0.014539802446961403,
-0.0021048812195658684,
0.01582827977836132,
-0.025879206135869026,
0.06036963313817978,
0.011145156808197498,
0.024163300171494484,
0.0008721099002286792,
-0.0399760976433754,
0.007324711885303259,
0.003777881618589163,
-0.0512874573469162,
-0.019610468298196793,
0.00941343605518341,
-0.028393687680363655,
0.006882774643599987,
-0.050608452409505844,
-0.028393320739269257,
-0.013807161711156368,
-0.01857023313641548,
0.014049707911908627,
-0.008098975755274296,
-0.01179726142436266,
0.014363683760166168,
-0.01417826022952795,
0.005066297482699156,
-0.008023899979889393,
-0.022174054756760597,
0.011351342312991619,
-0.045572880655527115,
-0.0297995712608099,
0.01743474043905735,
-0.0025098274927586317,
-0.019732942804694176,
0.04897794499993324,
0.004977046512067318,
0.03328528627753258,
-0.02473129890859127,
-0.021786171942949295,
-0.002534079598262906,
0.003956868778914213,
-0.037293653935194016,
-0.008840221911668777,
-0.06492343544960022,
-0.08035031706094742,
-0.02623797580599785,
0.02145974338054657,
0.03198663145303726,
-0.005896672606468201,
-0.024461131542921066,
-0.007521863095462322,
0.06768902391195297,
-0.018714584410190582,
-0.01947825402021408,
-0.0057310606352984905,
-0.003590106498450041,
0.0038779834285378456,
-0.027204755693674088,
0.014983991160988808,
-0.03897172212600708,
-0.02031395025551319,
0.012332637794315815,
0.003245818894356489,
-0.012815539725124836,
-0.00034028530353680253,
-0.05266151204705238,
-0.002676992444321513,
0.0004848481621593237,
0.0272640660405159,
-0.012706129811704159,
0.011812057346105576,
0.0007983334944583476,
0.02767707034945488,
-0.014421616680920124,
-0.003102700924500823,
0.040697358548641205,
-0.031744133681058884,
0.014614975079894066,
-0.029262779280543327,
0.03562786430120468,
0.04945896938443184,
0.040702879428863525,
0.032625630497932434,
0.04311113432049751,
0.03015347197651863,
0.04647240787744522,
-0.013712712563574314,
-0.006920688319951296,
-0.017346417531371117,
-0.0006539566675201058,
0.013535928912460804,
0.01083128247410059,
0.06113583967089653,
-0.05430212616920471,
0.0415254607796669,
-0.043942030519247055,
-0.04097609594464302,
-0.004173785913735628,
0.018232906237244606,
-0.02349725551903248,
-0.00945066288113594,
-0.022917650640010834,
-0.025797372683882713,
0.016876529902219772,
0.0004257170658092946,
0.010414780117571354,
-0.0026616572868078947,
-0.0010371061507612467,
0.07848434150218964,
-0.01597691886126995,
-0.010978634469211102,
-0.0006566793890669942,
0.006993807852268219,
0.02903807908296585,
-0.014656663872301579,
0.010229954496026039,
-0.05692154914140701,
-0.049570005387067795,
0.031847503036260605,
0.007367567624896765,
0.020982973277568817,
0.02806260623037815,
0.018499381840229034,
-0.04039999842643738,
0.035320449620485306,
-0.01867610774934292,
-0.017580710351467133,
0.013043893501162529,
0.0008108313195407391,
-0.028054745867848396,
-0.003774243639782071,
-0.014842693693935871,
-0.01033114455640316,
0.03100639395415783,
0.058125462383031845,
-0.005907576065510511,
-0.05659335106611252,
-0.021699734032154083,
0.016356607899069786,
0.056797392666339874,
-0.028638692572712898,
-0.03497447073459625,
-0.009342058561742306,
0.0012388525065034628,
-0.044490426778793335,
0.011446942575275898,
0.0005257871234789491,
0.0002727845567278564,
-0.03171972557902336,
0.008535154163837433,
-0.012244066223502159,
0.017886431887745857,
-0.00622378196567297,
0.02678908035159111,
0.038783326745033264,
0.013958713039755821,
-0.03367378190159798,
0.0327223464846611,
-0.08117691427469254,
-0.014633046463131905,
0.04020519554615021,
-0.030916083604097366,
-0.04883408546447754,
-0.004040936939418316,
-0.04816301912069321,
-0.03331570699810982,
0.026373952627182007,
0.011872181668877602,
0.04876966401934624,
0.01911451853811741,
-0.012318967841565609,
-0.05600458011031151,
0.0018633618019521236,
0.02515130490064621,
-0.03447701781988144,
-0.03322698920965195,
0.006120017729699612,
-0.03400720655918121,
0.046593621373176575,
0.0116330087184906,
0.0035143059212714434,
-0.022080151364207268,
-0.014097443781793118,
0.012210145592689514,
0.02483111433684826,
-0.03253946453332901,
-0.07479090988636017,
-0.031228087842464447,
-0.010636148042976856,
-0.0671117901802063,
-0.032553061842918396,
-0.050253432244062424,
0.014311699196696281,
-0.008642429485917091,
-0.005295594222843647,
-0.0037751933559775352,
-0.043107468634843826,
0.03911596164107323,
-0.006565004587173462,
-0.033483169972896576,
0.05093681439757347,
0.004031982738524675,
0.04199615865945816,
0.020438281819224358,
-0.0255722776055336,
-0.006482468917965889,
0.004276385996490717,
0.04271518439054489,
0.006792310159653425,
0.02016236074268818,
0.03857932612299919,
-0.015641359612345695,
-0.00018794443167280406,
-0.03880025073885918,
0.09901177138090134,
-0.020200461149215698,
0.012817437760531902,
0.0014916975051164627,
0.02660134620964527,
-0.05334587022662163,
-0.035410016775131226,
-0.022159269079566002,
-0.0006578781176358461,
-0.023846784606575966,
-0.028977198526263237,
-0.0403863787651062,
-0.020878132432699203,
0.039515454322099686,
-0.027321817353367805,
0.019627027213573456,
0.016253821551799774,
0.0036674763541668653,
0.01491525862365961,
-0.022734863683581352,
-0.005043521989136934,
0.008825044147670269,
0.053197555243968964,
0.002345824148505926,
0.00040988082764670253,
-0.05652182549238205,
-0.01772836036980152,
-0.09006668627262115,
0.02439030446112156,
-0.04447929561138153,
0.010878143832087517,
-0.016086114570498466,
-0.009659872390329838,
-0.031515590846538544,
-0.004781945608556271,
-0.002233220264315605,
0.008929598145186901,
0.07745030522346497,
0.001006860751658678,
0.03037439100444317,
-0.005720153916627169,
0.054869700223207474,
-0.052449699491262436,
-0.002673889510333538,
-0.037700578570365906,
0.03174534812569618,
-0.004742687102407217,
0.011040344834327698,
0.021711943671107292,
0.008030936121940613,
-0.017617756500840187,
0.0068220277316868305,
0.009744553826749325,
-0.03117128275334835,
-0.003481840016320348,
-0.0193769671022892,
-0.04267730191349983,
-0.00204760511405766,
-0.005592194851487875,
-0.011826355010271072,
-0.026370983570814133,
-0.000294816039968282,
-0.0173041932284832,
0.027539663016796112,
0.02061671018600464,
-0.013725083321332932,
-0.03955967351794243,
0.00364427687600255,
0.028338680043816566,
0.012244794517755508,
-0.037000447511672974,
0.0012547984952107072,
-0.003914822358638048,
-0.024338632822036743,
-0.009293513372540474,
0.04124903306365013,
-0.012392780743539333,
-0.011476004496216774,
0.029903972521424294,
-0.007650517858564854,
-0.014761007390916348,
-0.0017857105704024434,
-0.008248507045209408,
-0.016276979818940163,
-0.0457867793738842,
-0.028356295078992844,
-0.015160100534558296,
0.026011696085333824,
0.002344717038795352,
-0.04973507300019264,
0.028970949351787567,
0.01687106117606163,
0.003573608584702015,
-0.024652451276779175,
0.011000307276844978,
-0.05061668902635574,
0.006724580656737089,
-0.1330842822790146,
0.02552642859518528,
-0.011223400942981243,
-0.028605500236153603,
-0.03842921555042267,
-0.03351648896932602,
-0.008043991401791573,
0.021836018189787865,
-0.025812074542045593,
-0.028490353375673294,
0.052515432238578796,
-0.00597624946385622,
0.022446440532803535,
0.033687617629766464,
-0.018849866464734077,
0.01830477826297283,
-0.018166417255997658,
-0.024037521332502365,
-0.019061265513300896,
0.011026973836123943,
0.02721894346177578,
-0.007346329279243946,
0.012299573980271816,
-0.0061035677790641785,
-0.033486343920230865,
0.006421482190489769,
-0.01143859513103962,
-0.0174225103110075,
-0.03374151140451431,
0.0031660792883485556,
-0.07141464948654175,
-0.059404317289590836,
0.0004529860452748835,
0.06995262950658798,
-0.0006234605680219829,
0.019550198689103127,
0.043405625969171524,
0.0058645764365792274,
-0.03504057973623276,
-0.026580359786748886,
-0.024314140900969505,
0.0073679303750395775,
-0.04037701338529587,
-0.01696738973259926,
-0.007642346899956465,
0.040195487439632416,
-0.004597368184477091,
0.002917315810918808,
-0.016250574961304665,
-0.011293458752334118,
-0.005128508433699608,
0.01644514501094818,
-0.02871006727218628,
0.010481839068233967,
0.008278479799628258,
0.04280051589012146,
-0.017878282815217972,
-0.012536308728158474,
-0.004829279147088528,
0.0528741218149662,
0.0027188356034457684,
0.00219407444819808,
-0.0459132120013237,
-0.021907417103648186,
-0.006077045574784279,
0.0036147325299680233,
0.010273096151649952,
-0.008290042169392109,
0.03688516095280647,
-0.017939576879143715,
-0.00965200737118721,
-0.0337749719619751,
0.024284301325678825,
-0.014131825417280197,
0.012560703791677952,
-0.020793994888663292,
-0.005236660595983267,
-0.004250891972333193,
0.03573544695973396,
-0.0006384396110661328,
0.011569793336093426,
0.008344344794750214,
-0.05470024049282074,
0.020238589495420456,
0.04358762875199318,
0.024864505976438522,
-0.021166400983929634,
-0.04641815647482872,
0.042599257081747055,
-0.04815569519996643,
-0.04724771901965141,
0.020223429426550865,
-0.01992436870932579,
-0.011886334978044033,
-0.028343433514237404,
0.04768583923578262,
0.0018706675618886948,
-0.027859266847372055,
-0.04945455864071846,
-0.015975594520568848,
-0.016958950087428093,
-0.0532350167632103,
0.008196030743420124,
-0.000012509402040450368,
-0.018734700977802277,
-0.010987183079123497,
0.03659510985016823,
-0.0151504622772336,
0.004030922893434763,
-0.008184202015399933,
0.005989032797515392,
-0.04835739731788635,
-0.03486274182796478,
-0.05788171663880348,
-0.019899295642971992,
0.03185706585645676,
-0.00027936603873968124,
-0.027761658653616905,
-0.009929565712809563,
0.007103216368705034,
0.013170864433050156,
-0.03030741587281227,
-0.01504781749099493,
-0.012491824105381966,
-0.041602279990911484,
0.026977958157658577,
0.04629776254296303,
0.000910286616999656,
0.01860191859304905,
-0.0022763435263186693,
0.016401002183556557,
-0.0016074904706329107,
0.005198048427700996,
-0.005107425153255463,
0.0056892214342951775,
0.009136149659752846,
-0.017368974164128304,
0.002968228654935956,
-0.023961162194609642,
-0.049747806042432785,
0.029488231986761093,
0.002747755963355303,
-0.013599122874438763,
-0.05617254972457886,
0.010151012800633907,
-0.025054404512047768,
0.026366516947746277,
-0.008511113934218884,
-0.007617708295583725,
-0.03373017907142639,
-0.0074430606327950954,
0.012245642021298409,
-0.01497146487236023,
0.05704225227236748,
0.028496544808149338,
0.009068009443581104,
0.03943617269396782,
0.039171453565359116,
0.030362961813807487,
0.04011905938386917,
0.03389282897114754,
-0.027277573943138123,
-0.024861382320523262,
-0.027756281197071075,
-0.005357370246201754,
0.027352532371878624,
0.01868973858654499,
0.0051787542179226875,
0.0007575260824523866,
-0.037306420505046844,
-0.012721586972475052,
0.05496726557612419,
-0.0012047926429659128,
0.0018595028668642044,
0.00039591811946593225,
-0.04036952555179596,
0.03779201954603195,
-0.033555351197719574,
0.024141788482666016,
-0.015168414451181889,
0.03107750602066517,
0.042643893510103226,
-0.004848584067076445,
0.028890293091535568,
0.003755417186766863,
-0.0019094255985692143,
-0.027532177045941353,
0.002366401255130768,
-0.035980090498924255,
0.014946977607905865,
0.004977859556674957,
0.003197848331183195,
0.0022418603766709566,
-0.0460488498210907,
0.03363501653075218,
-0.020860755816102028,
-0.03841450810432434,
-0.013147581368684769,
0.012797855772078037,
0.018822792917490005,
0.017301851883530617,
-0.013406931422650814,
-0.03380599245429039,
-0.05296095460653305,
-0.02172047831118107,
0.0010038093896582723,
-0.0017503174021840096,
-0.05192483961582184,
-0.02138829044997692,
0.016918351873755455,
-0.03021538257598877,
0.01328588929027319,
0.009102724492549896,
0.02802085131406784,
-0.0325508713722229,
0.004225275944918394,
-0.011979912407696247,
0.03366728127002716,
0.012026790529489517,
-0.00585667509585619,
0.00744664017111063,
0.029034286737442017,
-0.004766617901623249,
-0.04200959578156471,
0.023146260529756546,
0.02486017346382141,
0.017454924061894417,
-0.03861088305711746,
0.004666084423661232,
0.006225795019418001,
-0.03781520947813988,
-0.02674766816198826,
-0.017465999349951744,
0.04438050836324692,
0.02584468200802803,
0.010851802304387093,
-0.040673065930604935,
-0.016070611774921417,
-0.0371578186750412,
0.011731547303497791,
0.02010870911180973,
0.014460677281022072,
0.01994967646896839,
0.021242696791887283
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:10
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
43The principal of Megbuy and Levira was and is Mr Terry Capper. On or about 25 June 2007 he signed a statement that was provided to QBE. It confirmed the details of Mr Horwood's employment by Megbuy. In paragraphs [5] to[11] he stated:
"5. Levira Pty Ltd is a private company. It does not trade. It was created several years ago to operate a transport business. That business is now operated by Megbuy Pty Ltd. There was a problem with money a few years ago and so I decided to use Megbuy to operate the trucking business.
6.I am a sole director of Levira Pty Ltd. I am the sole director of Megbuy Pty Ltd.
7.Their operating addresses is 86 Pinnacles Place Broken Hill and the registered business address is 43 Edward Street Norwood SA. NRA Johnson is the company accountant and it is at that address.
8.Levira Pty Ltd bought a forklift about 10 years ago (about 1997). It was second hand. Levira Pty Ltd had held the registration and the insurance since. I did not change the ownership to Megbuy Pty Ltd as there was no need.
9.Although Levira Pty Ltd is not operating it has not been dissolved or wound up. Levira Pty Ltd also owns a truck. The truck had nothing to do with the accident.
10.The forklift was registered as QBU 771. The rego was NSW.
11.It was serviced and maintained internally at 86 Pinnacles Place Broken Hill ... ".
44Mr Capper gave oral evidence addressing two topics. First, he was examined and cross-examined on the question of whether or not Megbuy answered the statutory definition of "owner" of the forklift as at 7 November 2007.
Second, he was cross-examined by Mr Campbell SC in an effort to rebut any suggestion that there was some defect with the forklift in an endeavour to demonstrate that there was no liability on the part of Megbuy to Mr Horwood.
At the conclusion of the cross-examination by Mr Campbell SC, Mr Cavanagh SC applied for, and was granted leave, under s 38 of the Evidence Act 1995 to cross-examine Mr Capper on the second topic.
I agreed to that course because his evidence on this issue was "unfavourable" to the interests of CGU assuming that it was incumbent upon me to determine the liability of Megbuy to Mr Horwood de novo. The following concerns the evidence that Mr Capper gave on the first topic. His evidence on the second topic is discussed at [92] to [95].
45Mr Capper explained that some time in the 1990s Levira purchased the transport business known as "Robertson Carriers" and Megbuy purchased the business known as "Johnston Transport". At the time of that purchase he was not a director of Levira or Megbuy, however he was a shareholder. Later he became the sole director of both companies.
He explained that initially Megbuy, trading as Johnson Transport, operated its business from 86 Pinnacles Place Broken Hill and that Levira, trading as Robertson Carriers, operated its business "out of the rail yard in Broken Hill". Prior to 2000, the two businesses were conducted independently of each other.
One set of employees was devoted to undertaking deliveries on behalf of Robertson carriers and another set undertook deliveries for Johnston Transport. At some later point both businesses were operated from 86 Pinnacles Place, Broken Hill.
46Mr Capper stated that, "sometime in the 2000s" but before 2005 Levira ceased trading and the two businesses were then operated by Megbuy. It employed staff and paid bills. Megbuy staff serviced all the equipment including the forklift. Megbuy paid for all expenses associated with the forklift including insurance.
He stated that the forklift was available for use by employees of Megbuy at all times (including Mr Horwood). He also stated that, after Megbuy assumed the conduct of both businesses, Levira did not trade, employ staff or operate accounts ("it just sat there basically").
47The picture presented of complete non-activity on the part of Levira after the merger of the two businesses was qualified under cross-examination. Mr Capper agreed that Levira engaged at least one employee, Gordon McMasters.
|
[
-0.006130353547632694,
-0.022850103676319122,
0.008139711804687977,
-0.02156878635287285,
0.0032452645245939493,
0.0036252336576581,
-0.0310836024582386,
0.03855809196829796,
0.001322574564255774,
0.024690410122275352,
0.008231534622609615,
0.025143617764115334,
-0.011304923333227634,
0.012708212248980999,
-0.02082150988280773,
-0.05458145961165428,
0.03608788922429085,
0.009695712476968765,
-0.0353146493434906,
-0.040774423629045486,
0.01261774729937315,
-0.05107331648468971,
0.03782256320118904,
0.053004391491413116,
0.0339127779006958,
0.024455847218632698,
0.026003843173384666,
0.013465659692883492,
-0.009442165493965149,
-0.010922837071120739,
-0.029633356258273125,
-0.007146643474698067,
-0.012204683385789394,
-0.014542371034622192,
0.02281595580279827,
-0.07161058485507965,
0.03074948489665985,
0.0018134727142751217,
-0.029556792229413986,
-0.008973040618002415,
-0.010141246020793915,
0.023408204317092896,
-0.00619261059910059,
-0.019086772575974464,
0.019678499549627304,
-0.021320901811122894,
-0.006380188278853893,
-0.018370000645518303,
0.006327150855213404,
-0.00492699583992362,
-0.04392518475651741,
-0.005740953143686056,
0.07629960775375366,
-0.023240655660629272,
0.020162440836429596,
0.007072120439261198,
0.0012257752241566777,
-0.023067420348525047,
-0.015926610678434372,
0.022508908063173294,
-0.027022838592529297,
0.005365059245377779,
0.027498992159962654,
0.0018609679536893964,
0.015296759083867073,
0.0900416299700737,
-0.044589824974536896,
-0.013389798812568188,
0.0030501754954457283,
-0.03909546881914139,
-0.011442096903920174,
-0.012174611911177635,
0.008962443098425865,
0.002677930984646082,
-0.07079345732927322,
0.03932080417871475,
0.01735769771039486,
0.00010199331882176921,
-0.011499447748064995,
-0.0028181560337543488,
0.032685138285160065,
0.023571500554680824,
-0.028385985642671585,
0.006898025516420603,
-0.0014197531854733825,
-0.010941622778773308,
-0.037536781281232834,
0.005346691235899925,
-0.027972480282187462,
0.014133771881461143,
-0.009468957781791687,
-0.0058541567996144295,
-0.016497407108545303,
-0.03139345720410347,
-0.018877390772104263,
-0.009256898425519466,
-0.011650425381958485,
0.01664237678050995,
0.028402170166373253,
0.006148567423224449,
-0.025339484214782715,
0.020805593580007553,
0.02114567719399929,
-0.04229032248258591,
0.002171541331335902,
-0.0026223082095384598,
0.008846023119986057,
0.04377768561244011,
-0.0024865721352398396,
-0.0037803843151777983,
0.021214492619037628,
-0.008572557009756565,
0.005446631461381912,
0.02094285935163498,
-0.016037724912166595,
-0.028829380869865417,
0.01599862612783909,
-0.036749888211488724,
0.02843676507472992,
-0.014073810540139675,
0.050992123782634735,
0.06563474237918854,
0.04380328580737114,
-0.05350317433476448,
-0.05689256638288498,
-0.015892306342720985,
0.03205413371324539,
-0.02078292891383171,
-0.016625357791781425,
0.0257965549826622,
-0.03364749997854233,
0.0085139824077487,
-0.01239017304033041,
-0.06911294907331467,
-0.03627988323569298,
-0.053179483860731125,
0.03190559893846512,
-0.00789223425090313,
-0.035510145127773285,
-0.03248457983136177,
0.05240076780319214,
0.09351669251918793,
0.009602845646440983,
-0.02547827921807766,
0.009523735381662846,
-0.03955208510160446,
0.03748606517910957,
0.020504122599959373,
0.011088927276432514,
-0.010890579782426357,
-0.009981038048863411,
0.004544747062027454,
0.010283136740326881,
-0.0014642318710684776,
-0.011669839732348919,
-0.020322399213910103,
0.010789178311824799,
-0.023824194446206093,
0.008030443452298641,
0.04647163674235344,
0.019063295796513557,
0.06278418004512787,
0.021356508135795593,
-0.04388628527522087,
0.03208605572581291,
0.019455520436167717,
-0.012778829783201218,
0.01909749209880829,
0.0013598824152722955,
0.010060667060315609,
0.029299411922693253,
-0.011283794417977333,
0.04775218665599823,
-0.00457219360396266,
0.013321762904524803,
0.03384311497211456,
0.0858859121799469,
-0.0008569766650907695,
-0.0018527924548834562,
-0.035381875932216644,
-0.019183125346899033,
0.010604189708828926,
0.004687112756073475,
0.00025167581043206155,
-0.0501449778676033,
-0.006338023580610752,
0.033311765640974045,
-0.03375015780329704,
0.025678159669041634,
0.020577194169163704,
-0.004311118274927139,
-0.00046935825957916677,
0.011603436432778835,
-0.012513761408627033,
0.022327184677124023,
0.021522454917430878,
0.0021284425165504217,
-0.017861610278487206,
0.0273031797260046,
-0.04469682276248932,
-0.025318719446659088,
0.039839405566453934,
0.0758025273680687,
0.010815855115652084,
-0.026008348912000656,
0.010105134919285774,
-0.036637112498283386,
0.003141032764688134,
-0.012045240961015224,
-0.06481578946113586,
0.029514040797948837,
-0.02726730704307556,
0.03373804688453674,
0.04338284209370613,
-0.001907678204588592,
-0.03147280588746071,
0.03908032923936844,
-0.015805130824446678,
0.05519144982099533,
-0.020132102072238922,
0.008348487317562103,
0.017388731241226196,
-0.02583664283156395,
0.02253667265176773,
0.027910426259040833,
0.025727564468979836,
-0.02172478847205639,
0.07900691032409668,
-0.017426561564207077,
-0.024496179074048996,
0.03162848576903343,
0.003473494900390506,
0.0048397621139883995,
-0.030559338629245758,
0.015019920654594898,
0.02513984404504299,
0.02410910464823246,
0.0528445690870285,
0.04417720064520836,
0.025543352589011192,
0.0277573149651289,
-0.012829788029193878,
0.03606068715453148,
-0.05450265109539032,
0.026543540880084038,
-0.0333993025124073,
0.04285357892513275,
0.042861148715019226,
0.02345411293208599,
0.015686461701989174,
0.035991936922073364,
-0.0013782888418063521,
0.003478042082861066,
-0.0138482004404068,
-0.019703712314367294,
0.046590372920036316,
0.00521421292796731,
-0.0027435545343905687,
0.022375481203198433,
-0.012649460695683956,
0.02264314331114292,
0.00043429184006527066,
0.033445775508880615,
-0.009449958801269531,
-0.051970675587654114,
0.00705074705183506,
-0.025799347087740898,
-0.04304862767457962,
-0.014547916129231453,
0.033435624092817307,
-0.035299692302942276,
-0.00029595798696391284,
0.01671382412314415,
0.009621692821383476,
0.013768961653113365,
0.04601084068417549,
0.02458999864757061,
-0.0091902120038867,
0.01721402443945408,
0.00132808368653059,
0.03802790492773056,
-0.015089614316821098,
0.034100379794836044,
-0.01486335601657629,
0.029660705476999283,
0.016357138752937317,
-0.018499601632356644,
-0.007086825557053089,
-0.029974905773997307,
-0.03549961745738983,
0.03331143781542778,
0.020512301474809647,
0.05514466017484665,
0.02434396557509899,
-0.02215546742081642,
0.011865234933793545,
0.02639775350689888,
-0.17674924433231354,
0.0039052870124578476,
-0.013764017261564732,
-0.024070367217063904,
0.004177633207291365,
0.005748435389250517,
-0.019981935620307922,
-0.014936398714780807,
-0.025949956849217415,
0.004818779416382313,
0.023035114631056786,
-0.031930092722177505,
-0.04935791715979576,
-0.009454663842916489,
-0.0011606812477111816,
-0.0030239983461797237,
0.01866435445845127,
-0.008857695385813713,
0.02508481964468956,
-0.025231709703803062,
-0.008842662908136845,
-0.02156010828912258,
0.02473682537674904,
-0.011879914440214634,
0.023833708837628365,
-0.00953893456608057,
0.03490741550922394,
-0.008443684317171574,
-0.05061586946249008,
-0.023187117651104927,
0.04334336519241333,
0.032604388892650604,
-0.011674925684928894,
0.02527610771358013,
0.0018769757589325309,
0.026492571458220482,
0.06471879035234451,
-0.05375567823648453,
-0.004875706508755684,
0.017388174310326576,
0.00010154007031815127,
0.1187857985496521,
-0.015658657997846603,
0.009153787977993488,
0.019522374495863914,
-0.056304603815078735,
0.02635515294969082,
-0.038642510771751404,
-0.04366866871714592,
0.010935981757938862,
-0.031035827472805977,
0.013157890178263187,
-0.02960233949124813,
0.022466091439127922,
-0.009069079533219337,
-0.0056903427466750145,
0.04589572548866272,
0.03189289569854736,
-0.05250634253025055,
0.02049160748720169,
-0.010919095017015934,
-0.05809153988957405,
0.03963794559240341,
0.03489120304584503,
-0.04915207624435425,
0.044462382793426514,
-0.008898423053324223,
-0.0011601204751059413,
0.013157269917428493,
0.001805817591957748,
-0.025240102782845497,
-0.07407961785793304,
-0.0035691973753273487,
-0.021588999778032303,
0.005221162922680378,
0.02366398461163044,
-0.008372065611183643,
-0.0022860991302877665,
-0.00016379561566282064,
-0.09441675990819931,
0.016054416075348854,
0.013500206172466278,
-0.01758982241153717,
0.023188728839159012,
-0.004914864432066679,
0.0244764294475317,
0.020082473754882812,
0.04258676618337631,
0.09286484122276306,
0.2553030848503113,
-0.02972174808382988,
-0.05878884345293045,
0.006334950681775808,
-0.008584649302065372,
0.0018233773298561573,
0.02706204541027546,
0.03660697862505913,
0.014772286638617516,
-0.0401894710958004,
0.011690703220665455,
0.02040001004934311,
0.01200427021831274,
0.02399098500609398,
0.005671993363648653,
-0.01844833604991436,
-0.001065440708771348,
-0.05013562738895416,
0.054762281477451324,
0.0023450800217688084,
0.04557926580309868,
-0.005303237121552229,
0.025382937863469124,
0.01475034561008215,
-0.0709444060921669,
-0.050932627171278,
0.013164474628865719,
0.03234468400478363,
-0.0022527386900037527,
0.042838115245103836,
-0.020823506638407707,
-0.031226232647895813,
-0.020687663927674294,
-0.013722443021833897,
0.011484172195196152,
0.011699107475578785,
0.02223730832338333,
-0.006838842760771513,
0.02169777639210224,
0.06832525879144669,
-0.020232100039720535,
-0.019325437024235725,
0.001796418335288763,
-0.04278578609228134,
-0.023794271051883698,
-0.006294582970440388,
0.008195381611585617,
0.0721360594034195,
-0.016445854678750038,
0.02131463773548603,
-0.027837036177515984,
-0.0016158579383045435,
-0.011824877001345158,
0.011081427335739136,
-0.04407230392098427,
0.01882125996053219,
-0.005664479918777943,
0.020718533545732498,
0.02520284615457058,
0.044400397688150406,
0.019921332597732544,
0.019501090049743652,
-0.006209412589669228,
0.0245067086070776,
-0.015460544265806675,
-0.022498691454529762,
-0.03209466114640236,
0.014762653037905693,
0.03130057826638222,
-0.01678161323070526,
0.012517130002379417,
0.03179416432976723,
0.04590582102537155,
-0.015676522627472878,
0.07942746579647064,
0.003982263617217541,
0.02514859288930893,
0.03728833049535751,
0.007114992942661047,
0.005310951732099056,
-0.02495705522596836,
0.02489389292895794,
0.011970260180532932,
0.055182430893182755,
0.018967876210808754,
-0.010927494615316391,
0.017456503584980965,
0.08137340098619461,
-0.001321862218901515,
-0.016455180943012238,
-0.020851584151387215,
-0.02877311035990715,
-0.03885667398571968,
0.02801666595041752,
-0.05005742609500885,
-0.011096194386482239,
-0.0018749305745586753,
-0.01644861325621605,
-0.011373991146683693,
-0.011212366633117199,
-0.0066961729899048805,
0.04356198012828827,
-0.013480793684720993,
0.022111427038908005,
-0.020535985007882118,
-0.05613107234239578,
0.028746988624334335,
0.0165764968842268,
-0.036814190447330475,
0.011202310211956501,
0.022614281624555588,
0.023671424016356468,
-0.053191523998975754,
-0.017022643238306046,
0.011762820184230804,
-0.01754254661500454,
-0.05027474835515022,
0.021447142586112022,
0.035813506692647934,
0.05883070454001427,
0.01724073477089405,
-0.03429855406284332,
-0.04670792818069458,
0.000422741228248924,
-0.0242499727755785,
-0.03421765938401222,
-0.033078648149967194,
-0.02664102613925934,
-0.010220923461019993,
0.033299654722213745,
0.0028993720188736916,
-0.022046610713005066,
-0.017557667568325996,
-0.023519419133663177,
0.015857305377721786,
0.010720465332269669,
-0.05678222328424454,
0.00307314726524055,
-0.03591039404273033,
-0.0036250802222639322,
-0.06992088258266449,
-0.004831927362829447,
-0.05760011449456215,
0.0003289888263680041,
0.028012461960315704,
-0.012001106515526772,
-0.0329865925014019,
0.019923850893974304,
-0.02322058379650116,
-0.02828855626285076,
0.018102826550602913,
0.03061497025191784,
-0.02651248872280121,
-0.014207345433533192,
-0.03441790118813515,
-0.007604348473250866,
0.0016571388114243746,
-0.005452563986182213,
0.035224199295043945,
-0.02576501853764057,
-0.0009027532069012523,
-0.025707783177495003,
0.032274313271045685,
0.0572606585919857,
-0.03570793569087982,
0.06213247776031494,
-0.00273696705698967,
0.03752177953720093,
0.03216869384050369,
0.0042927502654492855,
-0.0034952342975884676,
-0.07785751670598984,
0.007135862018913031,
0.017439426854252815,
0.06047621741890907,
0.06857593357563019,
-0.018318211659789085,
0.011008279398083687,
-0.036902669817209244,
-0.04284391552209854,
0.011541207320988178,
0.03681524097919464,
-0.03588017821311951,
-0.0066907876171171665,
-0.014373929239809513,
-0.006181183271110058,
0.016935300081968307,
-0.014700467698276043,
-0.023981653153896332,
-0.002135035116225481,
0.008862176910042763,
0.07526145130395889,
0.031447116285562515,
-0.008554697036743164,
0.00279490789398551,
0.043834127485752106,
-0.01189734973013401,
-0.022761186584830284,
-0.009662075899541378,
-0.020542845129966736,
-0.03808703273534775,
0.04291980713605881,
0.00907193124294281,
-0.02773200534284115,
0.025829775258898735,
0.005496499594300985,
-0.01084241084754467,
0.022513465955853462,
-0.007886110804975033,
-0.023669563233852386,
0.026786677539348602,
0.026537030935287476,
-0.013108623214066029,
-0.0044212075881659985,
-0.0014319807523861527,
0.012579631991684437,
0.04125264286994934,
0.046796418726444244,
-0.025111699476838112,
-0.09347766637802124,
-0.02881997637450695,
-0.019030889496207237,
0.025381023064255714,
-0.040647417306900024,
-0.03879164159297943,
0.0010074542369693518,
0.035247161984443665,
0.011859122663736343,
0.021730685606598854,
0.015714915469288826,
0.007188369985669851,
0.0018284573452547193,
-0.006830853875726461,
-0.05564247444272041,
0.013920442201197147,
-0.018868152052164078,
0.018610384315252304,
0.010985528118908405,
-0.017641598358750343,
0.00027713377494364977,
0.03152821585536003,
-0.019093476235866547,
0.008931196294724941,
0.05627460032701492,
0.023808099329471588,
0.01288490928709507,
-0.033358119428157806,
-0.014395199716091156,
0.042547713965177536,
0.058843884617090225,
0.019023748114705086,
0.024982795119285583,
-0.01315127220004797,
-0.0511348657310009,
-0.024333633482456207,
-0.0027162921614944935,
0.01517004519701004,
-0.028491821140050888,
-0.06374950706958771,
-0.018305329605937004,
-0.04337732493877411,
0.031887155026197433,
-0.010380299761891365,
-0.014625389128923416,
-0.002505000215023756,
-0.06276126205921173,
0.04868737608194351,
-0.03747178614139557,
-0.014777777716517448,
-0.03720879927277565,
-0.005300938151776791,
0.023081468418240547,
-0.04624436795711517,
-0.019686775282025337,
-0.05280496925115585,
0.012578235007822514,
-0.033177442848682404,
-0.01612657681107521,
0.0108839962631464,
0.013201490044593811,
0.03993169590830803,
-0.021058108657598495,
0.002234162064269185,
0.05713904649019241,
0.003105713753029704,
0.00684650894254446,
0.02849568799138069,
0.07062741369009018,
-0.013996055349707603,
0.021896660327911377,
0.0360553152859211,
0.05515989288687706,
0.009406933560967445,
0.05541306734085083,
-0.04099106043577194,
-0.028114590793848038,
0.009409933350980282,
0.0828164666891098,
-0.030344339087605476,
0.015171321108937263,
-0.012728412635624409,
0.02238578535616398,
-0.02055479772388935,
-0.018054919317364693,
-0.04360268637537956,
-0.010370849631726742,
0.0003820785495918244,
-0.030187690630555153,
-0.017955519258975983,
0.006285877898335457,
0.022399814799427986,
-0.06525471061468124,
-0.0013285278109833598,
-0.007242399733513594,
-0.030372928828001022,
0.008968928828835487,
-0.0035862012300640345,
0.01098578330129385,
-0.007856646552681923,
-0.004708409309387207,
-0.048122256994247437,
0.03399524465203285,
-0.013626963831484318,
0.005128232296556234,
-0.07975082844495773,
0.043931834399700165,
0.018982945010066032,
0.011062774807214737,
-0.0215647853910923,
-0.00596430292353034,
-0.028180617839097977,
-0.022842347621917725,
-0.03053421899676323,
0.026347510516643524,
0.05156245455145836,
0.014285934157669544,
-0.01849834807217121,
-0.035230353474617004,
0.026275666430592537,
-0.043666016310453415,
-0.02767113596200943,
-0.04702415317296982,
-0.00015437195543199778,
0.00863737240433693,
0.024616988375782967,
0.0024480847641825676,
0.000844449270516634,
0.01293021161109209,
0.005571496207267046,
0.003752226708456874,
-0.02155439369380474,
0.050485920161008835,
-0.00927997287362814,
-0.03472953289747238,
0.019574904814362526,
0.011574270203709602,
0.0020861176308244467,
-0.011028471402823925,
0.01776658184826374,
0.007250627502799034,
-0.02279065176844597,
-0.001224841340444982,
-0.01322966255247593,
-0.04320235177874565,
-0.00012050190707668662,
0.005856276489794254,
0.00039178639417514205,
0.0049106646329164505,
-0.04281981289386749,
0.004444944206625223,
0.0011941000120714307,
-0.05663313344120979,
0.006543644238263369,
-0.007287607528269291,
-0.004986744839698076,
0.02691621705889702,
-0.016459468752145767,
-0.015215308405458927,
-0.00999508984386921,
0.0024100805167108774,
-0.019638272002339363,
0.005567455198615789,
0.00633883336558938,
-0.014514070004224777,
-0.00594021612778306,
-0.024474678561091423,
-0.016637364402413368,
-0.005923445336520672,
0.016124220564961433,
-0.0016449278919026256,
0.01208050549030304,
0.023405771702528,
-0.0533955954015255,
0.029890524223446846,
-0.13205364346504211,
-0.0032224240712821484,
0.0036639608442783356,
-0.013739447109401226,
-0.05822301656007767,
-0.026538588106632233,
0.02862103283405304,
0.014500628225505352,
-0.02028745599091053,
0.0038042408414185047,
-0.02711109258234501,
-0.0016473777359351516,
0.018365655094385147,
-0.012237286195158958,
-0.021069277077913284,
0.029338428750634193,
-0.031466227024793625,
-0.0049059283919632435,
-0.011007201857864857,
0.03323659673333168,
0.009407836943864822,
-0.00814695656299591,
0.0010083786910399795,
0.011956553906202316,
0.008482949808239937,
0.02648724801838398,
-0.05393446236848831,
-0.02246072329580784,
-0.045712392777204514,
-0.02264794148504734,
-0.0615973174571991,
-0.035564109683036804,
0.017778975889086723,
0.04482738673686981,
-0.018312353640794754,
0.015310178510844707,
0.04216316342353821,
-0.06405341625213623,
-0.011450833640992641,
-0.020076081156730652,
-0.020863736048340797,
0.011701148003339767,
-0.019773822277784348,
-0.027242053300142288,
0.014270586892962456,
-0.03725217282772064,
0.01628030277788639,
-0.00722583057358861,
-0.04190151393413544,
-0.02917490154504776,
-0.04330793023109436,
0.03342686966061592,
-0.02560856193304062,
0.006306289695203304,
0.024909857660531998,
0.0007659997208975255,
-0.05003383010625839,
-0.03775394335389137,
-0.0400787889957428,
0.05137844756245613,
-0.0303080752491951,
0.001960993744432926,
-0.03610888496041298,
-0.013017515651881695,
0.03208174556493759,
-0.015241889283061028,
0.007000759709626436,
0.0017832902958616614,
0.007519321516156197,
-0.0016844249330461025,
0.014196900650858879,
-0.07934588938951492,
-0.0072203935123980045,
-0.008969496004283428,
-0.014106555841863155,
-0.015289800241589546,
0.00741494121029973,
-0.0045098490081727505,
0.013740749098360538,
0.0038395007140934467,
-0.02112913876771927,
0.02419487200677395,
-0.03170398622751236,
0.04571859911084175,
0.056250981986522675,
0.030783120542764664,
-0.0085637541487813,
-0.04006310924887657,
0.02777828276157379,
-0.03515898808836937,
-0.05704730376601219,
0.000017124299120041542,
-0.010765664279460907,
0.02599485032260418,
-0.021164001896977425,
0.06439278274774551,
0.00317323743365705,
-0.015670165419578552,
-0.03303944319486618,
0.022503279149532318,
-0.029059570282697678,
-0.020071325823664665,
0.01324636209756136,
0.025700537487864494,
0.0048104217275977135,
-0.024218538776040077,
0.009802338667213917,
-0.00803752988576889,
-0.009732145816087723,
0.0005794143071398139,
-0.027922967448830605,
-0.01821293868124485,
-0.01677563600242138,
-0.025978446006774902,
-0.04833647981286049,
0.02132554166018963,
-0.0045141554437577724,
-0.022122344002127647,
-0.04146888107061386,
0.04149533435702324,
0.02985735796391964,
-0.013459627516567707,
-0.020013239234685898,
-0.010616280138492584,
-0.01450197584927082,
0.005799946375191212,
0.05031607300043106,
-0.016046566888689995,
-0.006923072040081024,
-0.011157378554344177,
0.04462512210011482,
-0.001838710275478661,
-0.001653686398640275,
-0.01361924596130848,
-0.012148944661021233,
0.017273543402552605,
-0.03274546563625336,
0.016301797702908516,
-0.017949355766177177,
-0.03521999716758728,
-0.03191191703081131,
-0.02024579979479313,
-0.023370176553726196,
-0.016199897974729538,
-0.009455299936234951,
-0.013884329237043858,
0.022124705836176872,
0.011794818565249443,
-0.0376989021897316,
-0.05463332310318947,
-0.021746844053268433,
-0.023358814418315887,
-0.03445933759212494,
0.07193240523338318,
0.022194353863596916,
-0.005237095057964325,
0.052817706018686295,
-0.017144825309515,
-0.004632124677300453,
0.003229542402550578,
0.020869402214884758,
-0.03072613663971424,
-0.02292240783572197,
-0.03829579800367355,
-0.039462748914957047,
0.019725549966096878,
-0.006133456248790026,
0.0029164545703679323,
-0.0006610573036596179,
-0.006340167950838804,
-0.022579031065106392,
0.029983049258589745,
-0.01908007636666298,
-0.01492888480424881,
0.04665084183216095,
-0.01794350892305374,
-0.01813342049717903,
-0.02884730137884617,
0.04293427616357803,
-0.017217526212334633,
0.05317128077149391,
0.03513788431882858,
-0.006815427448600531,
-0.013812841847538948,
0.009230556897819042,
0.022506268694996834,
-0.024202605709433556,
-0.024042684584856033,
-0.0030763759277760983,
0.0015132131520658731,
-0.001636233413591981,
0.021758029237389565,
-0.013039627112448215,
-0.016304485499858856,
0.037022899836301804,
-0.02063484489917755,
-0.007771780248731375,
0.04353145882487297,
-0.012238264083862305,
0.04218035936355591,
0.021634986624121666,
-0.009604413993656635,
-0.047526244074106216,
-0.03351181745529175,
-0.054926853626966476,
0.01451429259032011,
0.03754979744553566,
-0.047089800238609314,
-0.007637712638825178,
0.05510043352842331,
-0.03950648754835129,
-0.0005669977981597185,
-0.007206371054053307,
0.02208651788532734,
-0.0034855101257562637,
-0.016683002933859825,
-0.003660164773464203,
0.021795857697725296,
0.0169691052287817,
-0.009202525019645691,
0.0019732399377971888,
0.06297921389341354,
-0.022237395867705345,
-0.021563196554780006,
-0.0008755918242968619,
-0.015464221127331257,
0.003034224733710289,
-0.02575679123401642,
0.03208127245306969,
-0.03325839340686798,
-0.00759779941290617,
0.009440145455300808,
-0.004979873541742563,
0.04682540148496628,
-0.0013004023348912597,
-0.001228858600370586,
-0.016323259100317955,
-0.05318731442093849,
-0.02015010453760624,
-0.04840494319796562,
0.034739814698696136,
0.0017004143446683884,
0.0004125645791646093,
0.01284816488623619
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:12
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
At two points in his evidence he clearly stated that Megbuy had assumed the conduct of Levira's business prior to 2005. I do not see that as inconsistent with the issue of a statutory demand at some unspecified point and the entry into of a Deed of Company Arrangement in October 2005.
54I accept and find that Levira did not utilise the forklift in connection with any activity that it was carrying on as at 7 November 2005 and had not done so since the beginning of 2005. I find that as at November 2005 and since the beginning of 2005 it was being maintained and used as needed by employees of Megbuy from the usual place of business conducted by Megbuy, namely 86 Pinnacles Street.
To the extent that in 2005 and 2006 Levira was conducting business, it was only the activity of employing Mr McMasters who was undertaking deliveries in fulfilment of Megbuy's contract. He did not use the forklift or the truck owned by Levira.
55The parties referred me to the Court of Appeal's decision in Havas v Standard Knitting Mills Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 295; (2001) 52 NSWLR 293. It addressed the definition of "owner" in s 3 of the Motor Accidents Act 1988 as in force as at 14 June 1995. Subsections 3(a)(ii) and 3(4) of that definition were not relevantly different to ss 4(1) and 4(2) of the MAC Act as applicable to this case.
The registered owner of the vehicle in question (Universal) was in the same group of companies as the respondent to the appeal (Standard) who was found to be an "owner" of the vehicle by virtue of its entitlement to immediate possession.
In addition to the link between the companies, the facts which gave rise to the finding that Universal ceased to have possession and Standard was entitled to immediate possession were recorded in the judgment of Hodgson JA as follows (at [9]):
"After the purchase, the forklift went to the [Standard's] premises (which were distinct from Universal's premises) where it was used and permanently garaged. From this time, the respondent and his employees had physical possession of the vehicle and its keys and exclusive use of the vehicle, and the vehicle was used in the respondent's commercial operations.
Invoices for maintenance of the vehicle were marked with initials identifying the respondent, and according to a past employee of the respondent called at the hearing by the appellant, this meant (at least during the time of her employment from 27 January 1997 to 21 January 2000) the cost of those services was borne by the respondent."
56In addition at [15] - [19] Hodgson JA (with whom Steyn and Heydon JJA agreed) rejected a contention that the entitlement to immediate possession in the former s 3(3)(a)(ii) (current s 4(1)(a)(iii)) was one that had to be maintainable against not only third parties but the registered owner.
Further, against the contingency that that conclusion was wrong,
Hodgson JA found that the circumstances gave rise to an inference that Standard had an immediate right to possession against Universal as Universal could not disrupt Standard's operations by taking the forklift without notice (at [24] see also Heydon JA at [2] who based the entitlement of Standard to resist a claim for immediate possession on an implied contractual term).
57I am satisfied that as at 7 November 2005 Levira had ceased to possess the forklift and Megbuy had an entitlement to immediate possession of it. Since at least the beginning of 2005 the forklift been used by employees of Megbuy. It had been serviced by Megbuy.
The cost of its repairs and insurance had been borne by Megbuy via the mechanism I have described above. There is nothing to suggest that any other entity had anything to do with the forklift from early 2005. In that sense Megbuy's use was "exclusive".
Unlike Havas, the premises that the forklift was garaged at, namely 86 Pinnacles Street Broken Hill, were not distinct from the premises of Levira. However, to say that 86 Pinnacles Street was Levira's business premises only invites an inquiry as to what business it conducted there.
|
[
0.005633690860122442,
0.005031122826039791,
-0.013573979958891869,
-0.0015090072993189096,
-0.011871235445141792,
-0.0015239057829603553,
-0.025714559480547905,
0.033834028989076614,
0.020069988444447517,
0.021494213491678238,
-0.023085162043571472,
0.03639378026127815,
0.007406668737530708,
-0.01602690853178501,
-0.01339770294725895,
-0.057593829929828644,
0.01757328025996685,
0.012675449252128601,
-0.042415276169776917,
-0.04777206853032112,
-0.006636497564613819,
-0.02158132940530777,
0.04793102294206619,
0.034173447638750076,
0.018580418080091476,
0.002478300593793392,
0.018829910084605217,
0.004697926342487335,
0.027091197669506073,
-0.004103959072381258,
-0.020912332460284233,
-0.002301286207512021,
0.0023579024709761143,
-0.012465093284845352,
0.000520596222486347,
-0.05448064208030701,
-0.0032092330511659384,
0.03797422721982002,
-0.03318822756409645,
-0.0021684388630092144,
-0.020309891551733017,
0.0024123534094542265,
-0.022008294239640236,
-0.017875852063298225,
0.01031943503767252,
-0.02348104491829872,
-0.014774106442928314,
-0.023695094510912895,
-0.029016125947237015,
-0.04051836580038071,
-0.027760274708271027,
-0.006087404675781727,
0.08664017915725708,
0.005638857837766409,
0.0411374606192112,
0.005174864549189806,
-0.0065660299733281136,
-0.024335090070962906,
-0.015864016488194466,
0.0024072700180113316,
-0.019450590014457703,
0.018043531104922295,
-0.03812851756811142,
0.003607801627367735,
0.024303268641233444,
0.0372902974486351,
-0.03758750483393669,
-0.04317818582057953,
-0.025172248482704163,
-0.05001869425177574,
-0.020480552688241005,
-0.0002754371671471745,
-0.003427666611969471,
0.06428483873605728,
-0.056972019374370575,
0.012414793483912945,
0.04201211407780647,
0.03162754327058792,
0.01548067294061184,
-0.020765746012330055,
0.031965989619493484,
0.009547264315187931,
-0.022864293307065964,
0.003563513280823827,
0.004952493589371443,
0.029655711725354195,
-0.057068005204200745,
0.0017961527919396758,
0.018198426812887192,
0.000005749001957155997,
0.014181563630700111,
-0.01452910527586937,
-0.01361200399696827,
-0.029167676344513893,
-0.023521294817328453,
0.031897179782390594,
-0.03679769113659859,
0.015268935821950436,
0.027704469859600067,
0.010954347439110279,
0.0008654620032757521,
0.018696913495659828,
0.017239609733223915,
-0.05703382194042206,
0.0033037709072232246,
0.00813803169876337,
0.037937652319669724,
0.03844090923666954,
0.0067155989818274975,
-0.002078104065731168,
0.0003168026451021433,
-0.007265480700880289,
-0.0047132051549851894,
-0.022703150287270546,
-0.020892517641186714,
-0.01617339439690113,
0.005028783343732357,
-0.051942359656095505,
0.0724351778626442,
-0.017564082518219948,
0.0295890923589468,
0.034429676830768585,
0.05910421907901764,
-0.0460888035595417,
-0.046813685446977615,
0.03356045112013817,
0.009165488183498383,
-0.048691168427467346,
-0.024477321654558182,
0.03049428015947342,
-0.03459284082055092,
-0.007192652206867933,
-0.012187416665256023,
-0.05108126625418663,
-0.02310243248939514,
-0.037757083773612976,
0.038245055824518204,
0.007175991777330637,
-0.05255040153861046,
-0.03580400347709656,
0.07682500779628754,
0.06272432953119278,
0.00866637285798788,
-0.011373519897460938,
-0.001704178168438375,
-0.011268123053014278,
0.04513593763113022,
-0.01658136397600174,
0.007429569028317928,
-0.05141448229551315,
-0.02762690931558609,
0.02059893123805523,
0.0015596182784065604,
-0.027522476390004158,
0.014988833107054234,
0.0024184049107134342,
-0.015577349811792374,
0.005968823097646236,
0.010586750693619251,
0.03245949372649193,
0.02231629192829132,
0.04007580131292343,
0.006250548642128706,
-0.006074805278331041,
-0.007708917371928692,
-0.0018055636901408434,
0.000699370342772454,
0.03418368101119995,
0.0018155585275962949,
0.010243656113743782,
0.023390663787722588,
-0.006941299419850111,
0.05482739210128784,
-0.015153679996728897,
0.014133160002529621,
0.022160394117236137,
0.056263115257024765,
0.009447041898965836,
0.011454039253294468,
-0.0470174141228199,
-0.037323564291000366,
0.032189927995204926,
0.026436209678649902,
0.013763532973825932,
-0.059236787259578705,
0.00823131762444973,
0.010357445105910301,
-0.04497150331735611,
0.024901296943426132,
0.06070222333073616,
-0.008958532474935055,
-0.0011760484194383025,
0.025748219341039658,
0.0012503931066021323,
0.017469497397542,
-0.03979507088661194,
0.00852765142917633,
-0.009308256208896637,
0.04740002378821373,
-0.021534772589802742,
-0.037202514708042145,
0.016785865649580956,
0.046885907649993896,
-0.04750433564186096,
-0.04417158663272858,
-0.020435940474271774,
-0.02931872569024563,
0.02704097516834736,
-0.0032265614718198776,
-0.02496335096657276,
-0.020936263725161552,
-0.012368964031338692,
0.01731032319366932,
-0.00019184155098628253,
-0.00634031742811203,
-0.004172278102487326,
0.0165423471480608,
0.009859073907136917,
0.019061993807554245,
0.0002076811360893771,
0.003845144296064973,
0.013153648003935814,
0.003095341147854924,
0.0024883984588086605,
-0.02521599270403385,
0.013113749213516712,
-0.014113430865108967,
0.0435246005654335,
-0.0030060550197958946,
-0.004537730012089014,
0.03215745463967323,
0.015574916265904903,
0.018943030387163162,
-0.02710884064435959,
0.020732572302222252,
0.021390805020928383,
0.048008281737565994,
0.03678712248802185,
0.042351268231868744,
0.051343049854040146,
-0.0261529628187418,
-0.009365787729620934,
0.009013001807034016,
-0.017826560884714127,
0.00980053935199976,
-0.010351364500820637,
0.00999942235648632,
-0.00624100910499692,
0.02015446498990059,
0.0035101776011288166,
0.01754872128367424,
0.013716277666389942,
-0.013062718324363232,
0.01965438388288021,
-0.0459822379052639,
0.022503184154629707,
-0.013782655820250511,
-0.01902933605015278,
-0.011388059705495834,
-0.01092133205384016,
0.03243287652730942,
0.025415783748030663,
0.024305962026119232,
0.016018981114029884,
-0.04825461655855179,
-0.027893049642443657,
-0.004027087707072496,
-0.009673332795500755,
-0.015086864121258259,
0.017961598932743073,
-0.006791101302951574,
0.006886250339448452,
-0.0027962380554527044,
0.03813080117106438,
0.04787047952413559,
0.041090574115514755,
0.038786012679338455,
-0.01163544412702322,
-0.014107953757047653,
0.014414156787097454,
-0.007157360203564167,
-0.0295516736805439,
0.041343893855810165,
-0.04703020304441452,
0.040346961468458176,
-0.005967294331640005,
-0.019468318670988083,
-0.044464752078056335,
-0.018247703090310097,
-0.07327268272638321,
0.02189869061112404,
0.0339069589972496,
0.05191902816295624,
0.018791930750012398,
-0.027864135801792145,
-0.0072838785126805305,
0.013910096138715744,
-0.16269010305404663,
0.00497494637966156,
-0.0029264679178595543,
-0.0007956752087920904,
-0.01268266886472702,
0.0022907343227416277,
-0.03003656677901745,
-0.026717988774180412,
0.0014917678199708462,
0.03591027110815048,
0.02978152595460415,
-0.04544871300458908,
-0.04461483657360077,
0.005222233943641186,
0.027584102004766464,
-0.0069755795411765575,
0.024853073060512543,
-0.027914851903915405,
0.07277733832597733,
-0.03754878789186478,
0.005581593606621027,
-0.015116890892386436,
0.02261856012046337,
-0.002818262903019786,
0.001875555026344955,
-0.003771458752453327,
0.021192478016018867,
-0.0003839101700577885,
-0.05789698287844658,
-0.03181533142924309,
-0.004688304383307695,
0.006399181205779314,
-0.019400645047426224,
0.053311336785554886,
-0.0019896512385457754,
0.01628652773797512,
0.08867514133453369,
-0.08377448469400406,
-0.024258801713585854,
0.00914961751550436,
0.024332785978913307,
0.09146672487258911,
-0.03797074407339096,
-0.006361743900924921,
-0.00447015929967165,
-0.05769098177552223,
-0.0016884093638509512,
-0.03438214957714081,
-0.04747677966952324,
0.025701142847537994,
-0.013343963772058487,
-0.006658026482909918,
-0.013200391083955765,
0.008858160115778446,
0.0036106237675994635,
-0.005474541336297989,
0.030607223510742188,
0.05927702412009239,
-0.04134892299771309,
0.014428647235035896,
-0.016329070553183556,
-0.07063674181699753,
0.04347973316907883,
0.0009261071681976318,
-0.061373356729745865,
0.011163277551531792,
-0.015295793302357197,
-0.005990586709231138,
0.014844386838376522,
-0.04943638667464256,
-0.027724560350179672,
-0.050136033445596695,
-0.003306260099634528,
0.0037568819243460894,
-0.016988450661301613,
0.005658047739416361,
0.010501453652977943,
-0.01653827540576458,
-0.004702670034021139,
-0.09750134497880936,
0.014424676075577736,
0.006750999018549919,
-0.014161807484924793,
0.015471401624381542,
0.0015186058590188622,
0.04712744802236557,
0.000274394522421062,
0.018704278394579887,
0.06326357275247574,
0.2216149866580963,
-0.016570227220654488,
-0.0012949141673743725,
0.0265953466296196,
0.005088733043521643,
-0.0036124608013778925,
-0.0022876025177538395,
-0.009463058784604073,
0.009473275393247604,
-0.042592182755470276,
-0.0017776895547285676,
0.00046706307330168784,
0.03349623084068298,
0.019883781671524048,
-0.02044711448252201,
-0.03908718004822731,
0.0013722351286560297,
-0.06299567967653275,
0.08082497864961624,
-0.026288174092769623,
0.02278066612780094,
0.017978733405470848,
0.0017509552417322993,
0.023410120978951454,
-0.08030644804239273,
-0.037255123257637024,
0.002557255793362856,
0.02791302092373371,
-0.020578891038894653,
0.03483886644244194,
-0.006247377023100853,
-0.02432810328900814,
0.021611997857689857,
0.009756234474480152,
0.008989663794636726,
0.025441177189350128,
-0.018704377114772797,
0.0047289044596254826,
-0.027073446661233902,
0.05393233522772789,
0.0075244419276714325,
-0.003778604557737708,
-0.02124750055372715,
-0.014941093511879444,
0.007840937003493309,
-0.004794548265635967,
-0.003486101282760501,
0.0773698017001152,
0.011140325106680393,
0.043661899864673615,
-0.052008192986249924,
-0.013562384992837906,
-0.053802214562892914,
0.02214064635336399,
-0.08802968263626099,
0.018660588189959526,
-0.011905119754374027,
0.0031533250585198402,
0.020730700343847275,
0.05624059587717056,
0.021465130150318146,
0.01873241364955902,
-0.02633388340473175,
-0.007289770059287548,
0.006973301526159048,
-0.024716738611459732,
-0.015472392551600933,
0.00665035005658865,
0.01702450029551983,
-0.023131506517529488,
0.03183598071336746,
0.037468474358320236,
-0.005418345332145691,
0.008146385662257671,
0.05894995108246803,
0.010402326472103596,
-0.0046878233551979065,
0.04569179564714432,
0.016774335876107216,
0.01342545822262764,
-0.004854956641793251,
0.01802317425608635,
-0.0020128560718148947,
0.024090267717838287,
0.022173620760440826,
-0.004125726409256458,
-0.004437336698174477,
0.05632231384515762,
0.0201050266623497,
-0.018091635778546333,
-0.019404366612434387,
-0.034367479383945465,
-0.001748366979882121,
0.05057796463370323,
-0.030543038621544838,
-0.0304269976913929,
-0.0007766595226712525,
-0.0029053741600364447,
0.004663402214646339,
-0.007634839974343777,
0.00015526627248618752,
0.043931618332862854,
-0.028925901278853416,
0.00696047255769372,
0.006330418866127729,
-0.058152616024017334,
0.012058727443218231,
0.01892467960715294,
-0.043446823954582214,
-0.00946983601897955,
0.016037046909332275,
0.014093488454818726,
-0.044604647904634476,
-0.020430155098438263,
0.006493619177490473,
-0.0112794553861022,
-0.02567603811621666,
0.0224546380341053,
0.032362163066864014,
0.034361377358436584,
0.022950507700443268,
-0.021545423194766045,
-0.04760318621993065,
-0.02331484481692314,
-0.009254544973373413,
-0.011750915087759495,
-0.05941354110836983,
-0.056927088648080826,
0.00962004903703928,
0.028174884617328644,
-0.007918753661215305,
-0.01598643884062767,
-0.03168502449989319,
-0.007454149890691042,
0.06325849145650864,
-0.000036010889743920416,
-0.0442107655107975,
0.015956228598952293,
-0.06293503940105438,
-0.0037858744617551565,
-0.024228185415267944,
-0.025499241426587105,
-0.015213089063763618,
-0.0007438616594299674,
0.043804626911878586,
-0.026398388668894768,
-0.014598221518099308,
0.03316132351756096,
-0.005457264371216297,
0.01255213376134634,
-0.019109806045889854,
0.013182430528104305,
-0.03947826847434044,
-0.0026892235036939383,
-0.03354815021157265,
-0.013156567700207233,
0.017849769443273544,
0.0013650718610733747,
0.014530964195728302,
-0.04957554489374161,
0.006478873081505299,
-0.03867897391319275,
0.008053852245211601,
0.06097407266497612,
-0.0025100233033299446,
0.049553968012332916,
0.009893937036395073,
0.07428718358278275,
-0.007604374550282955,
-0.00021473504602909088,
-0.010477813892066479,
-0.0700976774096489,
-0.02321443520486355,
-0.003385439282283187,
0.05565289407968521,
0.03128499537706375,
-0.04081344231963158,
0.011729445308446884,
-0.00883867871016264,
-0.021458955481648445,
0.021359741687774658,
0.02526850625872612,
-0.021401043981313705,
-0.034938812255859375,
0.005796149373054504,
0.012116971425712109,
0.05591283366084099,
-0.006149408407509327,
0.011302115395665169,
-0.03129899501800537,
-0.003566138679161668,
0.08785078674554825,
0.026908086612820625,
-0.0021664975211024284,
-0.0005629879306070507,
-0.00726409861817956,
-0.020316405221819878,
-0.011069824919104576,
0.02862708270549774,
-0.06505267322063446,
-0.022843051701784134,
0.014037310145795345,
0.014295226894319057,
-0.013782784342765808,
0.0650327280163765,
-0.01381508819758892,
0.0019114463357254863,
0.02174494042992592,
0.018323464319109917,
-0.013817496597766876,
0.022768409922719002,
0.04373902082443237,
-0.027109423652291298,
0.026661600917577744,
0.008792252279818058,
0.003724439535290003,
0.03197012096643448,
0.08851195126771927,
-0.007484962698072195,
-0.062038078904151917,
0.014966381713747978,
-0.020236346870660782,
0.0388355627655983,
-0.051278505474328995,
0.009811525233089924,
0.056904036551713943,
0.05116385966539383,
0.0040374803356826305,
0.007157334592193365,
0.010311114601790905,
0.0025019089225679636,
0.020679345354437828,
0.0038850230630487204,
0.004969098139554262,
0.018546734005212784,
-0.009096802212297916,
0.025065451860427856,
0.005435967817902565,
0.01684376411139965,
0.013564739376306534,
0.02442595735192299,
-0.00782698392868042,
0.023096125572919846,
0.024239594116806984,
-0.013935168273746967,
-0.0072507355362176895,
0.0019807014614343643,
-0.004710674285888672,
0.016262434422969818,
0.04658913239836693,
-0.019561532884836197,
0.031505078077316284,
0.015961235389113426,
-0.043023481965065,
-0.007608375046402216,
0.00640739593654871,
0.022294344380497932,
-0.03198034316301346,
-0.07724657654762268,
-0.05228741839528084,
-0.0013458055909723043,
0.04029226303100586,
-0.009951393119990826,
0.011340493336319923,
-0.0007714234525337815,
-0.0669434443116188,
0.029335251078009605,
-0.041676804423332214,
0.0008806994301266968,
-0.02183123491704464,
0.0059521496295928955,
0.021137189120054245,
-0.036903612315654755,
-0.042320139706134796,
-0.01415610034018755,
0.019693607464432716,
-0.01875368319451809,
0.002736578229814768,
0.02567293494939804,
-0.007742358837276697,
0.034463729709386826,
-0.008789962157607079,
-0.008964870125055313,
0.04625727981328964,
-0.017822332680225372,
0.007280218414962292,
0.007852933369576931,
0.03107660450041294,
-0.003100514877587557,
-0.0020146628376096487,
0.016227319836616516,
0.04945044219493866,
0.008422047831118107,
0.057707369327545166,
-0.033484648913145065,
0.02409442886710167,
-0.011312156915664673,
0.01877427101135254,
-0.025975247845053673,
0.018072884529829025,
-0.016803858801722527,
0.008683021180331707,
-0.028632964938879013,
-0.021288219839334488,
-0.031595222651958466,
-0.007023689337074757,
0.01603163219988346,
-0.06116506829857826,
0.007637339644134045,
0.01368666347116232,
0.00779122905805707,
-0.055681683123111725,
0.007030177395790815,
-0.0012648244155570865,
-0.003515527117997408,
0.021047169342637062,
-0.0033760028891265392,
-0.00027177599258720875,
-0.004338910803198814,
-0.012200184166431427,
0.0024587383959442377,
0.06852167099714279,
-0.014797009527683258,
0.007086563855409622,
-0.060786355286836624,
0.04540339484810829,
-0.013692980632185936,
-0.017809534445405006,
-0.01253408845514059,
-0.008630742318928242,
-0.03105827420949936,
-0.002890277188271284,
-0.031183674931526184,
0.017565786838531494,
0.07043309509754181,
0.014275604858994484,
-0.048482660204172134,
-0.027182327583432198,
0.03706390783190727,
-0.04117438197135925,
-0.03547975793480873,
-0.03727130591869354,
0.03677430376410484,
0.017585184425115585,
0.00974918995052576,
0.0213322751224041,
0.01761242188513279,
0.01885301247239113,
0.024654794484376907,
0.0031749180052429438,
-0.007310783956199884,
0.010920865461230278,
-0.017321284860372543,
-0.044848375022411346,
0.028885500505566597,
-0.0006969754467718303,
0.0009884871542453766,
0.02407277189195156,
0.02153116464614868,
-0.00010445094085298479,
-0.041373539716005325,
0.03139183670282364,
-0.039541251957416534,
0.015142615884542465,
0.0024434959050267935,
0.030656304210424423,
0.015120244584977627,
0.023097889497876167,
-0.009322430938482285,
-0.010247825644910336,
0.03993155062198639,
-0.06301875412464142,
0.019375620409846306,
-0.00455134455114603,
-0.01530369184911251,
0.03176211938261986,
-0.002147815888747573,
-0.04773537814617157,
-0.012913255020976067,
0.0006433288799598813,
-0.014281573705375195,
-0.07359670847654343,
0.013020449317991734,
0.0005943970754742622,
0.027149474248290062,
0.01082147192209959,
-0.0059553454630076885,
-0.014128174632787704,
-0.03779478371143341,
0.0016934218583628535,
-0.011532039381563663,
0.052245527505874634,
-0.02906176634132862,
0.030497819185256958,
-0.12734343111515045,
-0.006445337552577257,
-0.009270897135138512,
0.00964744295924902,
-0.058685656636953354,
-0.0109173022210598,
0.018114902079105377,
0.03451623395085335,
-0.01364272739738226,
0.005552178714424372,
-0.00044139818055555224,
-0.005299881100654602,
-0.0005771385622210801,
-0.008354187943041325,
-0.04510752856731415,
0.05346660688519478,
-0.05093856528401375,
-0.0364859402179718,
-0.03383554518222809,
0.021009482443332672,
0.004007132723927498,
-0.017074506729841232,
0.005268323700875044,
-0.0011831239098683,
0.014577575959265232,
0.03782248497009277,
-0.06697265058755875,
-0.038839008659124374,
-0.03453584015369415,
-0.034377142786979675,
-0.05597618222236633,
-0.04210856184363365,
0.00488967914134264,
0.06048011779785156,
-0.012190574780106544,
0.03142169862985611,
0.05173497274518013,
-0.04494946822524071,
-0.03801356256008148,
0.02110830880701542,
-0.025839312002062798,
0.016896069049835205,
-0.04634816572070122,
-0.04853687062859535,
-0.02351510338485241,
0.0013892208226025105,
0.01685521751642227,
-0.010699639096856117,
-0.041472792625427246,
-0.02700711600482464,
-0.0353916771709919,
0.009808453731238842,
-0.054458409547805786,
0.028953393921256065,
0.04674186185002327,
0.015462931245565414,
-0.029061531648039818,
-0.027847059071063995,
-0.08991169184446335,
0.05900071561336517,
0.008478324860334396,
0.01234481856226921,
-0.02957882545888424,
-0.04955541342496872,
0.02839660830795765,
0.002885836409404874,
-0.0010065615642815828,
-0.022531192749738693,
0.012451057322323322,
0.011295726522803307,
0.012247205711901188,
-0.031236041337251663,
-0.016267403960227966,
-0.025395309552550316,
-0.003455904545262456,
-0.02112552337348461,
0.012322170659899712,
0.014455669559538364,
-0.01004763226956129,
0.020419156178832054,
-0.018704133108258247,
-0.00008090357732726261,
-0.013914811424911022,
-0.013174873776733875,
0.08607561141252518,
0.033260416239500046,
-0.03697942942380905,
-0.026464391499757767,
0.046880092471838,
-0.027020979672670364,
-0.054003503173589706,
0.0027971500530838966,
-0.024353360757231712,
0.05575896054506302,
-0.004420410841703415,
0.03144614398479462,
-0.019067689776420593,
-0.03066283091902733,
-0.03983739763498306,
0.013040337711572647,
-0.01637614332139492,
-0.031082838773727417,
0.04274442046880722,
0.001918660826049745,
-0.024412838742136955,
-0.014776777476072311,
-0.004970632027834654,
0.006792997010052204,
-0.03883575648069382,
0.010024601593613625,
-0.04164651408791542,
-0.024616844952106476,
-0.02980032190680504,
-0.011421892791986465,
-0.01007692702114582,
0.019189942628145218,
-0.015028734691441059,
-0.029697639867663383,
-0.03258644416928291,
0.009923993609845638,
0.03549370914697647,
-0.006567172706127167,
0.014288168400526047,
-0.02549033798277378,
-0.0042389375157654285,
0.016721682623028755,
0.03806208074092865,
-0.02108387090265751,
0.01194001641124487,
-0.012624149210751057,
0.047833893448114395,
0.019485749304294586,
-0.026065072044730186,
0.023361897096037865,
-0.0075070541352033615,
-0.014987021684646606,
-0.027782931923866272,
0.011272421106696129,
-0.026176782324910164,
-0.0682828426361084,
-0.008746467530727386,
-0.013735346496105194,
-0.007317217532545328,
-0.023754971101880074,
-0.015478638000786304,
0.00843817088752985,
0.0331842303276062,
0.03350885212421417,
-0.027790997177362442,
-0.06970155239105225,
-0.03260809928178787,
-0.007140800356864929,
-0.040216002613306046,
0.079482801258564,
0.021860450506210327,
-0.0378258116543293,
0.061842042952775955,
0.00023620744468644261,
-0.002169704297557473,
0.009863326326012611,
0.02740427665412426,
-0.009665906429290771,
-0.023068591952323914,
-0.055537499487400055,
-0.005763515830039978,
0.031098144128918648,
0.010068638250231743,
0.006407237611711025,
0.0008320072083733976,
-0.004505868535488844,
0.02126198448240757,
0.040505699813365936,
-0.04006100445985794,
-0.005960752256214619,
0.00888407975435257,
-0.03629310429096222,
-0.029010143131017685,
0.002871206495910883,
0.005307036451995373,
-0.03752203658223152,
0.0393194779753685,
0.07098390907049179,
0.01896895281970501,
-0.012518336065113544,
0.001056505716405809,
0.02755800075829029,
0.017649032175540924,
-0.010785414837300777,
-0.006629543844610453,
-0.048492610454559326,
0.0041529168374836445,
0.024515585973858833,
-0.03777144476771355,
-0.025638282299041748,
0.03908395767211914,
-0.05113190785050392,
0.00114785588812083,
0.05222391337156296,
-0.004320885986089706,
0.05680633708834648,
0.03460073471069336,
0.007552014198154211,
-0.04452289640903473,
-0.01527422945946455,
-0.042909346520900726,
-0.004096230957657099,
0.03683670982718468,
-0.04350894317030907,
0.0002930309565272182,
0.04202605038881302,
-0.01689862459897995,
-0.012029648758471012,
0.009812078438699245,
0.046084851026535034,
-0.02279408648610115,
-0.0002800324291456491,
0.019261758774518967,
0.02734958566725254,
0.0007191055337898433,
0.00808725692331791,
0.013118459843099117,
0.017281020060181618,
-0.05336626619100571,
-0.00874396599829197,
-0.015996452420949936,
-0.00022408513177651912,
0.02342427335679531,
-0.044535961002111435,
0.01716979220509529,
-0.0022924465592950583,
-0.013717267662286758,
0.017935097217559814,
0.004769008141011,
0.080240398645401,
0.0016419021412730217,
-0.02573874033987522,
-0.042506393045186996,
-0.02021055668592453,
0.01675482653081417,
-0.02834058180451393,
0.05526955798268318,
-0.01320779137313366,
-0.009430392645299435,
0.027329422533512115
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:26
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
.. such use or operation by the defect in the vehicle" (at [23]). In addressing that, McHugh JA agreed with the Court of Appeal in Zurich v CSR that the phrase "such" in sub paragraph (a)(iv) of the definition refers to the opening words of the paragraph and not sub paragraphs (i) to (iii).
McHugh J accepted a finding in the Court of Appeal that the loading or unloading of a vehicle was such use or operation (at [27]).
The third aspect of causation was said to be whether the physical injury was sustained "as a result of and is caused by a defect in the vehicle" (at [31]).
McHugh J found that there was a "defect in the vehicle" but that the injury was not caused by the defect but the employer's direction to convey the containers manually to the rear of the truck. It was the direction that was the proximate cause of the injury. In so finding McHugh J stated (at [57]):
"In my opinion, however, the second and third requirements of the causal inquiry (whether the injury was "a result of and ... caused during ... such use ... by a defect in the vehicle") was not satisfied. Mr Oliver's injury was no doubt as a result of the defect. But it does not follow that, for the purpose of the Act, the injury was caused by the defect in the vehicle.
Where the injury is sustained as a consequence of a defect in the vehicle and does not fall within sub paragraph (i)(ii) or (iii) it would not be "caused by" the defect unless the connection between the defect and the injury is more than a "result of" the defect, When the case falls within sub paragraph (iv), the definition applies only where "the injury is a result of and is caused .
.. by a defect". (emphasis added)
126Callinan J reached the same result. His Honour agreed that the operative cause of the injury was not any defect in the vehicle but the negligent and dangerous direction by the employer given as to the movement of containers (at [129]).
However Callinan J did not accept the starting point of the other judgments concerning the correctness of the construction of sub paragraph (a)(iv) enunciated in Zurich v CSR. His Honour found (at [133]):
"I am unable to agree. The expression "use or operation" is explained, qualified and further refined by sub-pars (i), (ii) and (iii). The word "such" is a reference to that expression as so refined or qualified. Sub-paragraph (iv) does have work to do. It is important to note that the introductory words of the definition speak of the fault of the owner or driver of a motor vehicle.
An owner who is not driving the vehicle would not ordinarily be at fault and responsible for an injury within sub-paragraphs (i) and (ii). An owner although he or she could conceivably be at fault when the vehicle ran out of control as contemplated by sub-par (iii), would generally be unlikely to be so.
More probably such an event would result from a failure of the last driver to secure the vehicle properly after driving it, or to control it properly when driving it.
A running out of control could also be of course a result of a failure by the owner to rectify a defect such as a malfunctioning brake or gearbox. On the other hand the "fault" of an owner would be more likely to be the failure say, of that owner to service the vehicle regularly in order to discover some defect in it, or to rectify a defect in it of which he or she should be aware.
In other words the purpose of sub-paragraph (iv) is to sheet home liability for an injury caused by the fault of the owner, if the injury is a result of a defect causing it, during such use or operation, that is, whilst it is being driven as contemplated by sub-pars (i) and (ii) or running out of control as contemplated by sub-par (iii) in circumstances in which the driver has not been at fault.
" (emphasis added)
127In Zotti the appellant had an accident when he lost control of his bicycle at an intersection. Less than two hours previously there had been a motor vehicle collision at the intersection which had led to an oil slick remaining on the road.
|
[
-0.010133765637874603,
-0.010041061788797379,
-0.03972925245761871,
0.003116168547421694,
-0.02389211393892765,
0.017228972166776657,
0.007815991528332233,
0.03207474946975708,
0.0006017077248543501,
-0.028600243851542473,
-0.031001964583992958,
0.010198167525231838,
0.002910440554842353,
-0.022415492683649063,
-0.029155628755688667,
-0.05157714709639549,
0.04467029869556427,
0.017210835590958595,
-0.009581383317708969,
-0.00785330031067133,
0.026178250089287758,
-0.014138676226139069,
0.03397057577967644,
0.03636743873357773,
-0.025477321818470955,
0.031112762168049812,
0.018756767734885216,
-0.008715151809155941,
-0.018526611849665642,
0.004487831611186266,
0.0031651905737817287,
-0.023365743458271027,
-0.030995842069387436,
-0.021672401577234268,
0.011957364156842232,
-0.010241654701530933,
-0.04303852841258049,
-0.0035745392087846994,
-0.012600656598806381,
0.01681746356189251,
-0.027524318546056747,
-0.010120709426701069,
0.016398489475250244,
-0.051985569298267365,
0.008281989023089409,
-0.00892910361289978,
-0.009420743212103844,
-0.026173757389187813,
0.004535455256700516,
-0.01692260429263115,
-0.05432210490107536,
-0.0028831057716161013,
0.10135625302791595,
-0.05079152435064316,
0.02111184038221836,
0.014110337011516094,
-0.010205461643636227,
-0.057882484048604965,
-0.034280937165021896,
0.018318550661206245,
-0.030103454366326332,
-0.028693925589323044,
-0.03509609401226044,
-0.009178933687508106,
0.003398854285478592,
0.06294060498476028,
-0.02020386978983879,
-0.04486456140875816,
-0.009620966389775276,
-0.04384796693921089,
0.0074737961404025555,
0.00886014848947525,
-0.010615307837724686,
-0.02514699473977089,
-0.04406466707587242,
0.011399822309613228,
0.04291656240820885,
-0.0014843815006315708,
-0.020253129303455353,
0.03597254678606987,
0.0017342554638162255,
-0.02489190734922886,
-0.0188391525298357,
0.02353045344352722,
0.0075570037588477135,
0.009495771490037441,
-0.0513046570122242,
0.020927438512444496,
0.0007476392202079296,
-0.006137549411505461,
0.027425741776823997,
-0.0209280326962471,
0.018909873440861702,
-0.0020654562395066023,
0.027383022010326385,
0.03247423470020294,
-0.08488257229328156,
0.039817653596401215,
-0.010332617908716202,
0.02562115527689457,
0.02531364932656288,
0.0021352057810872793,
-0.014753508381545544,
-0.08748327940702438,
0.013943638652563095,
-0.007090558763593435,
0.01802074909210205,
0.023011988028883934,
0.011288913898169994,
0.002184016164392233,
0.03564740717411041,
0.013762355782091618,
0.015623267740011215,
0.0052362121641635895,
-0.024368371814489365,
0.01323567982763052,
-0.007150039542466402,
-0.03791586309671402,
0.03413224220275879,
-0.022955982014536858,
-0.0010864912765100598,
0.04303799942135811,
0.06368457525968552,
-0.01151820458471775,
-0.019351208582520485,
0.016618451103568077,
-0.00671067088842392,
0.03137069568037987,
-0.00022157016792334616,
0.03352184593677521,
-0.0023652645759284496,
0.01770014502108097,
-0.031036192551255226,
0.015869684517383575,
-0.022885018959641457,
0.006832610350102186,
0.053161829710006714,
0.008788078092038631,
-0.041426993906497955,
-0.03447683900594711,
0.05328739434480667,
0.027706263586878777,
0.025885874405503273,
-0.04446781426668167,
0.02830519899725914,
-0.011441508308053017,
0.047113027423620224,
-0.004975640680640936,
0.02263796702027321,
-0.0024006571620702744,
0.00842900201678276,
-0.00853642262518406,
0.03714799880981445,
-0.04739810898900032,
0.04784317687153816,
-0.027728576213121414,
-0.00876311119645834,
0.009006926789879799,
0.007033890578895807,
-0.008938536047935486,
0.022970028221607208,
0.07949884980916977,
0.01085038110613823,
-0.026773596182465553,
0.01494524534791708,
-0.00845272932201624,
0.0137846814468503,
0.030536280944943428,
-0.03014838509261608,
-0.03967937454581261,
0.021517788991332054,
-0.013563374988734722,
0.022705228999257088,
-0.029941793531179428,
0.03125997632741928,
0.04018488898873329,
0.04578876495361328,
0.008102728053927422,
-0.0312703400850296,
-0.029686346650123596,
0.030999379232525826,
-0.005252561066299677,
0.00584828108549118,
-0.021406667307019234,
-0.0399230532348156,
-0.01615125872194767,
0.02520935982465744,
-0.022542454302310944,
0.021758314222097397,
-0.0015597548335790634,
-0.04638923332095146,
-0.07051996886730194,
0.04002924636006355,
0.01782848872244358,
0.006843140814453363,
-0.007174580357968807,
0.04024332016706467,
-0.0180516354739666,
0.029135780408978462,
-0.027427582070231438,
0.025534119457006454,
0.03835896775126457,
0.05056476965546608,
-0.045072853565216064,
-0.025714389979839325,
-0.01306939497590065,
-0.0431460365653038,
-0.01188113633543253,
0.01785960979759693,
-0.05511020869016647,
0.026357941329479218,
-0.052697598934173584,
-0.023703619837760925,
-0.01105506345629692,
-0.04381999000906944,
-0.016063693910837173,
0.01369999535381794,
-0.058733709156513214,
0.007830525748431683,
-0.01312235463410616,
-0.023704681545495987,
-0.0042594620026648045,
-0.04517044126987457,
0.0005361614748835564,
0.022400354966521263,
-0.01787235587835312,
0.016824975609779358,
0.009560450911521912,
0.01798321306705475,
0.0007010520785115659,
0.03668653964996338,
0.01891343481838703,
0.011153992265462875,
-0.014659133739769459,
0.03930463641881943,
0.006966390646994114,
0.028033223003149033,
0.04770630970597267,
0.02195386216044426,
-0.003760129678994417,
0.02290617860853672,
-0.052564941346645355,
0.04289018362760544,
-0.04766298457980156,
-0.038352444767951965,
-0.04194709286093712,
0.026279743760824203,
0.03386485204100609,
-0.017851781100034714,
0.004692002199590206,
0.029730139300227165,
0.008495118468999863,
0.023883137851953506,
0.010091694071888924,
0.029724329710006714,
0.017685335129499435,
0.025194387882947922,
-0.008289407938718796,
-0.016987955197691917,
-0.038164809346199036,
-0.015790149569511414,
0.035113658756017685,
0.022280946373939514,
-0.0156865231692791,
-0.001135968486778438,
-0.05662073194980621,
-0.019081247970461845,
-0.005933660548180342,
-0.061253707855939865,
-0.013107896782457829,
0.02486363798379898,
0.024179069325327873,
-0.026109473779797554,
-0.0020208735950291157,
-0.0034986527170985937,
0.030811859294772148,
0.01093002688139677,
-0.020550863817334175,
0.07348830252885818,
0.027314597740769386,
0.04571814462542534,
0.009146040305495262,
0.04727969691157341,
-0.019416561350226402,
0.048047713935375214,
0.02538279816508293,
-0.008817358873784542,
-0.02859167568385601,
0.0005400779191404581,
-0.03275340050458908,
0.03243229538202286,
-0.03827810660004616,
0.06995843350887299,
-0.024966837838292122,
-0.07519712299108505,
-0.002388137159869075,
-0.01481211744248867,
-0.16919371485710144,
-0.02278277277946472,
0.04148083180189133,
0.02035500667989254,
0.01974891871213913,
0.023403335362672806,
-0.06022615730762482,
-0.021097688004374504,
-0.028863774612545967,
-0.02114356867969036,
-0.016562193632125854,
-0.0625838115811348,
-0.008402024395763874,
-0.013369979336857796,
0.004671814385801554,
-0.038097839802503586,
-0.03698178008198738,
0.011317440308630466,
0.010704261250793934,
-0.027049867436289787,
0.008413981646299362,
0.005396051332354546,
-0.009344806894659996,
-0.040716078132390976,
-0.0018595457077026367,
-0.006613871082663536,
0.02674969658255577,
0.025455668568611145,
-0.04990514740347862,
-0.004963989369571209,
-0.03408487141132355,
-0.0013510601129382849,
-0.020336532965302467,
0.042896613478660583,
0.012896515429019928,
0.0026223084423691034,
0.037526246160268784,
-0.07828458398580551,
-0.009934219531714916,
0.008581249974668026,
0.030426375567913055,
0.061216652393341064,
-0.005203998181968927,
0.014600589871406555,
-0.014349848963320255,
-0.07936511933803558,
-0.0020612336229532957,
0.007850547321140766,
-0.00775983277708292,
0.014049844816327095,
-0.011542299762368202,
-0.007208678405731916,
-0.024416062980890274,
-0.04037999361753464,
-0.007039457093924284,
-0.025355223566293716,
0.048527926206588745,
0.03560345992445946,
0.009956779889762402,
0.04449550062417984,
0.012858172878623009,
-0.017482373863458633,
0.015090672299265862,
-0.032585978507995605,
-0.056477293372154236,
0.005463937297463417,
0.015001650899648666,
0.011513466946780682,
0.06582174450159073,
-0.04009784758090973,
-0.021120993420481682,
-0.059603121131658554,
0.022869108244776726,
0.016774749383330345,
-0.014238076284527779,
-0.01100282371044159,
0.003331476356834173,
0.020939303562045097,
0.008447105996310711,
-0.08405381441116333,
0.035552263259887695,
0.006916307844221592,
0.020944194868206978,
0.02240380086004734,
-0.013244877569377422,
0.006845882628113031,
0.04320002347230911,
0.010002209804952145,
0.02300904504954815,
0.22592416405677795,
0.018121959641575813,
-0.0006900582229718566,
-0.007215145044028759,
0.007625914178788662,
-0.03478015959262848,
0.006219038274139166,
-0.013680502772331238,
-0.0204234030097723,
-0.035080838948488235,
-0.02427278459072113,
0.01582372933626175,
0.020227491855621338,
0.02583444118499756,
-0.02141323871910572,
-0.019488152116537094,
-0.026034479960799217,
-0.026499483734369278,
0.09263288229703903,
-0.0017138886032626033,
0.05369576811790466,
-0.024439150467514992,
0.06959743052721024,
0.04051478952169418,
-0.04257333278656006,
-0.015758970752358437,
-0.009359425865113735,
-0.028881743550300598,
-0.024152562022209167,
-0.02185848541557789,
-0.03858087211847305,
-0.024410242214798927,
0.05165337026119232,
-0.0013199117965996265,
-0.05222124606370926,
0.002529079793021083,
-0.014388524927198887,
0.005124183837324381,
-0.0422048345208168,
0.019289303570985794,
0.02031487226486206,
-0.025132576003670692,
-0.03523750230669975,
-0.0037888619117438793,
0.05286593362689018,
0.015845714136958122,
-0.006470771972090006,
-0.006867474410682917,
-0.00450895493850112,
0.033625297248363495,
0.015513334423303604,
0.011422009207308292,
-0.024043774232268333,
0.018716178834438324,
-0.0404331348836422,
-0.008376293815672398,
-0.017171747982501984,
0.018552321940660477,
0.006271414924412966,
-0.004177491180598736,
0.04351774975657463,
0.002273524645715952,
-0.014099075458943844,
0.019909067079424858,
0.03151070326566696,
0.02973988838493824,
0.013134442269802094,
-0.030887125059962273,
0.024869807064533234,
0.025074435397982597,
0.00620943121612072,
0.0032651633955538273,
0.03707456961274147,
0.025461358949542046,
0.05579264089465141,
-0.005224030464887619,
0.017909344285726547,
0.02255227416753769,
0.012814022600650787,
0.039826106280088425,
-0.04576514661312103,
-0.05390497297048569,
-0.008481018245220184,
-0.04156435281038284,
0.021001121029257774,
-0.012294471263885498,
-0.032005470246076584,
0.05789770558476448,
0.023552756756544113,
0.003656647866591811,
-0.00628335727378726,
-0.034807659685611725,
0.004760805517435074,
0.05153609812259674,
-0.028792547062039375,
0.018573002889752388,
0.03307254984974861,
0.014161263592541218,
-0.028296656906604767,
-0.020408477634191513,
-0.011480849236249924,
-0.02030705101788044,
0.004461655858904123,
0.02018769085407257,
0.05896562337875366,
-0.00806053914129734,
-0.0290834940969944,
0.01673196814954281,
-0.005629471968859434,
0.024859685450792313,
0.029438355937600136,
0.031774576753377914,
-0.006432273890823126,
0.004360060673207045,
0.0033158313017338514,
0.019973652437329292,
-0.030053365975618362,
0.044532328844070435,
0.03120233118534088,
0.0713566318154335,
-0.04910102114081383,
0.0010021094931289554,
-0.021364187821745872,
0.027757970616221428,
-0.019523179158568382,
-0.014726342633366585,
-0.026054907590150833,
-0.03218274191021919,
-0.031834814697504044,
0.021658439189195633,
0.001544786267913878,
-0.008060336112976074,
-0.04555023834109306,
0.004272937774658203,
0.060057807713747025,
-0.0190450306981802,
-0.0599282905459404,
0.03895903006196022,
-0.020324118435382843,
-0.0001874448062153533,
-0.00021624821238219738,
0.017098400741815567,
-0.024625161662697792,
0.003063454292714596,
-0.0065459744073450565,
-0.006118267774581909,
-0.044490549713373184,
0.021020103245973587,
-0.05034373328089714,
0.0036912825889885426,
0.01950794644653797,
0.0025168161373585463,
-0.008191009052097797,
-0.043724797666072845,
-0.0037010912783443928,
-0.041740782558918,
-0.002049403265118599,
-0.03633657097816467,
-0.0015089495573192835,
-0.015284975990653038,
-0.008763913065195084,
-0.006637705024331808,
-0.023221267387270927,
0.006923953536897898,
0.026792172342538834,
0.020183315500617027,
0.05408596247434616,
0.020571909844875336,
-0.011862878687679768,
0.0031432064715772867,
0.030974484980106354,
-0.05328875780105591,
-0.00037533120485022664,
0.029303163290023804,
0.010196365416049957,
0.08031351864337921,
-0.03734142333269119,
0.009449881501495838,
-0.012218272313475609,
-0.016315853223204613,
-0.0011305122170597315,
0.008676743134856224,
0.029765238985419273,
0.021995989605784416,
-0.047159142792224884,
-0.015052830800414085,
0.05389948561787605,
-0.0050735785625875,
-0.023086171597242355,
-0.024693112820386887,
-0.005726180505007505,
0.09205041080713272,
-0.006790515035390854,
-0.011780395172536373,
0.04785429686307907,
-0.00449849758297205,
0.024611033499240875,
-0.01494697667658329,
-0.023423468694090843,
-0.026683522388339043,
0.009155669249594212,
-0.012814742513000965,
0.01811566948890686,
0.048094138503074646,
0.028159024193882942,
-0.03688925504684448,
-0.018061373382806778,
0.008111474104225636,
-0.010711959563195705,
-0.002827666001394391,
0.018398452550172806,
0.011534900404512882,
-0.03868818283081055,
0.008269772864878178,
-0.04265676438808441,
-0.0021330309100449085,
0.0287766233086586,
0.04810437187552452,
0.024667829275131226,
-0.037491604685783386,
-0.015906648710370064,
-0.01711084321141243,
0.033623892813920975,
-0.060158174484968185,
0.013225843198597431,
0.03028647042810917,
0.017305413261055946,
-0.035849351435899734,
-0.01060452964156866,
-0.022166278213262558,
-0.004854446277022362,
-0.016295919194817543,
0.009007789194583893,
-0.0019063613144680858,
0.029537133872509003,
0.02882527932524681,
0.0017606004839763045,
0.022731013596057892,
0.0767766535282135,
-0.0038679686840623617,
0.04826441779732704,
0.0020442442037165165,
0.04227491095662117,
0.0280031468719244,
-0.024271149188280106,
-0.00442888168618083,
-0.022337548434734344,
-0.03354713320732117,
0.037453051656484604,
0.05685252323746681,
-0.01685161143541336,
0.04149268940091133,
0.03491220623254776,
-0.03465582802891731,
-0.03647598251700401,
0.007340929936617613,
-0.008854029700160027,
0.051071301102638245,
-0.06573114544153214,
-0.015818187966942787,
-0.016360890120267868,
0.032297346740961075,
0.013506794348359108,
-0.0020033700857311487,
0.016768928617239,
-0.06853128224611282,
0.030722541734576225,
0.020649679005146027,
-0.031936369836330414,
-0.03736594319343567,
-0.05666503682732582,
0.03638850152492523,
-0.027050277218222618,
-0.042412519454956055,
0.0012622025096789002,
-0.022469203919172287,
-0.03977010399103165,
-0.012201705947518349,
0.01847556047141552,
0.003350755199790001,
-0.019365334883332253,
0.002372946124523878,
-0.006164483726024628,
0.03871142119169235,
0.026263369247317314,
0.009108666330575943,
0.03258907422423363,
-0.006638532504439354,
0.025946997106075287,
-0.03447457402944565,
0.05277009680867195,
-0.01770857535302639,
-0.004511686507612467,
-0.007421543821692467,
-0.03265180066227913,
0.008209021762013435,
0.0055543603375554085,
0.041530124843120575,
0.012842070311307907,
0.013905970379710197,
-0.02259724959731102,
0.02829793281853199,
-0.02205241285264492,
-0.03270723670721054,
0.009192322380840778,
0.004019462503492832,
0.03377014026045799,
-0.02594366855919361,
-0.008929983712732792,
0.026248836889863014,
0.0008519650436937809,
-0.10096130520105362,
0.008725163526833057,
-0.018617626279592514,
0.035633306950330734,
0.02703685872256756,
0.02459557168185711,
-0.002249083248898387,
0.02249191701412201,
0.04933864250779152,
-0.023841332644224167,
0.0010405346984043717,
-0.024986520409584045,
0.01765395514667034,
-0.07261014729738235,
-0.007330704480409622,
0.03359769284725189,
-0.02215593121945858,
-0.039250437170267105,
-0.02712305076420307,
-0.03525443747639656,
-0.012475665658712387,
0.003340049646794796,
0.010601654648780823,
0.049541108310222626,
-0.0052286856807768345,
-0.026865139603614807,
-0.03310936316847801,
0.026165569201111794,
-0.01419246569275856,
0.02840486913919449,
-0.05245544761419296,
0.0803094431757927,
0.008560121059417725,
-0.004389795940369368,
-0.01701243966817856,
0.0009883134625852108,
0.002198927104473114,
0.046504195779561996,
0.0172302033752203,
-0.023361677303910255,
-0.010255907662212849,
-0.008964463137090206,
-0.031775470823049545,
-0.0007805017521604896,
0.0480150505900383,
0.0021747713908553123,
0.010587834753096104,
0.017386198043823242,
-0.03848163038492203,
-0.01755547896027565,
0.04002145677804947,
0.0013415352441370487,
0.049208495765924454,
0.02187897451221943,
0.01555156335234642,
-0.003211150411516428,
-0.040982216596603394,
0.03746049478650093,
0.00531001714989543,
0.02032773569226265,
-0.037974096834659576,
0.013413866050541401,
-0.041782863438129425,
0.00492359371855855,
-0.017218368127942085,
-0.0037754997611045837,
0.015289000235497952,
-0.010627487674355507,
-0.0064306315034627914,
-0.031234322115778923,
-0.051855795085430145,
-0.055469222366809845,
0.019405465573072433,
-0.028918219730257988,
-0.03161595016717911,
-0.011572296731173992,
0.00787206832319498,
-0.00830208882689476,
0.035227905958890915,
-0.008173920214176178,
0.048810288310050964,
-0.027277357876300812,
-0.020154347643256187,
-0.13604842126369476,
0.019809028133749962,
0.010350404307246208,
-0.0008960681734606624,
-0.05670518800616264,
-0.007233681622892618,
-0.004864110611379147,
0.025220606476068497,
-0.02365514263510704,
-0.04550255089998245,
0.007703749462962151,
0.0010920281056314707,
0.02198933996260166,
-0.021923251450061798,
-0.018816227093338966,
0.040240898728370667,
-0.03612964600324631,
-0.0669870600104332,
-0.03801318258047104,
0.014690744690597057,
-0.02136426791548729,
0.01690179854631424,
0.00757840508595109,
-0.040929801762104034,
-0.03423250466585159,
-0.005856124218553305,
-0.07555798441171646,
-0.029683688655495644,
-0.03750843182206154,
-0.01752503216266632,
0.02916930429637432,
-0.025677135214209557,
-0.006616223603487015,
-0.0012968597002327442,
-0.008217724971473217,
0.004330347292125225,
-0.007273619994521141,
-0.0042496477253735065,
-0.033020853996276855,
0.00906448159366846,
0.000082530161307659,
-0.0018509194487705827,
-0.006821046583354473,
-0.011483264155685902,
0.04220161959528923,
0.03170226141810417,
-0.010033156722784042,
0.014649012126028538,
-0.01934133470058441,
-0.007203829009085894,
-0.04201744496822357,
0.00903325155377388,
0.01254518236964941,
0.006680318154394627,
0.0007021541241556406,
0.04004676267504692,
-0.03334370255470276,
-0.014395912177860737,
-0.05560607463121414,
0.051752056926488876,
-0.05051834508776665,
-0.012387669645249844,
-0.04289012774825096,
0.004359629936516285,
0.04012342542409897,
0.02884349226951599,
-0.017484717071056366,
0.019670747220516205,
0.03118228167295456,
0.03505072370171547,
0.007723814807832241,
-0.008377809077501297,
0.006019181106239557,
-0.014678619801998138,
-0.007091960869729519,
0.02868671342730522,
0.0460725836455822,
-0.01618880406022072,
-0.0019750562496483326,
0.009002599865198135,
-0.012691367417573929,
-0.010928504168987274,
-0.026829663664102554,
0.04733435437083244,
0.05114053934812546,
0.011547356843948364,
0.010111037641763687,
-0.028571030125021935,
-0.012763427570462227,
-0.10892839729785919,
-0.04188854619860649,
0.013672804459929466,
-0.025028781965374947,
0.0463627427816391,
-0.000885116751305759,
0.039717428386211395,
0.043027859181165695,
-0.005669035948812962,
-0.023715468123555183,
-0.029127808287739754,
0.012376692146062851,
-0.012245367281138897,
0.03748193010687828,
-0.004814253654330969,
-0.024700598791241646,
0.011394038796424866,
-0.02535051479935646,
-0.0075673554092645645,
-0.01589536853134632,
0.013869360089302063,
-0.03260838985443115,
-0.03165715932846069,
-0.04758325219154358,
-0.025425180792808533,
-0.016371071338653564,
0.0033282681833952665,
-0.029096946120262146,
0.011849954724311829,
-0.018883109092712402,
0.01945207081735134,
0.035109974443912506,
-0.05545775219798088,
0.06432733684778214,
-0.029628822579979897,
0.010049705393612385,
0.026580138131976128,
0.06516502797603607,
0.003644886426627636,
-0.01438687089830637,
-0.015512936748564243,
0.021192127838730812,
-0.03448379784822464,
0.011157295666635036,
0.012413428165018559,
-0.027904339134693146,
0.0313679464161396,
-0.010189787484705448,
0.002966987667605281,
-0.03783462569117546,
0.0023580119013786316,
-0.007224319037050009,
0.0005003614933229983,
0.024862078949809074,
-0.04025894030928612,
-0.04267216473817825,
-0.0125445406883955,
0.017689717933535576,
0.012282547540962696,
-0.035885848104953766,
-0.03267199173569679,
-0.012739187106490135,
0.019893109798431396,
0.015155786648392677,
0.09371498227119446,
0.0045265499502420425,
-0.002760276198387146,
-0.008056867867708206,
0.03602054342627525,
-0.013225128874182701,
0.04451354593038559,
0.03887246921658516,
-0.011659770272672176,
-0.014542157761752605,
-0.07004494220018387,
0.0011950863990932703,
0.023084497079253197,
0.01455910224467516,
0.016524702310562134,
-0.011313625611364841,
-0.010134483687579632,
-0.023902924731373787,
-0.022104263305664062,
0.0036080521531403065,
0.007947144098579884,
-0.024800948798656464,
-0.03713817521929741,
-0.011455136351287365,
-0.016064321622252464,
0.02295287884771824,
-0.05064454302191734,
0.03168167546391487,
0.0005287404055707157,
0.016663268208503723,
-0.021456070244312286,
0.03130878880620003,
0.009911488741636276,
0.03014908730983734,
0.012890777550637722,
0.00765231205150485,
-0.04478392004966736,
0.006496870890259743,
-0.021355681121349335,
0.01704874075949192,
-0.03936230391263962,
0.018051056191325188,
0.002785854274407029,
-0.004088146146386862,
0.022713245823979378,
0.025769485160708427,
0.023083774372935295,
0.01440057996660471,
0.005077735520899296,
-0.019511891528964043,
-0.011871260590851307,
-0.050705667585134506,
-0.03639134392142296,
-0.021498477086424828,
-0.012528789229691029,
-0.046598710119724274,
0.07925352454185486,
0.008445711806416512,
-0.016836265102028847,
0.030515119433403015,
0.0393713042140007,
-0.021600758656859398,
-0.02355341985821724,
0.00857368391007185,
0.035693876445293427,
0.023907743394374847,
0.007556782569736242,
0.04264478385448456,
0.06352528929710388,
0.03261714428663254,
-0.05039152130484581,
0.019565580412745476,
0.003078391309827566,
-0.03787358105182648,
0.006974411197006702,
0.009746406227350235,
-0.0011183263268321753,
0.0021540895104408264,
-0.039544664323329926,
-0.005823183339089155,
0.07253073155879974,
0.001272466266527772,
0.0021262429654598236,
-0.018990131095051765,
0.006283863447606564,
-0.006773943081498146,
-0.008217758499085903,
0.03900228440761566,
0.014885389246046543,
-0.006512297783046961,
0.003699127584695816
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:20
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
They noted that Mr Gillett had agreed that the steering was unpredictable and added that in their view "that would constitute a defect within the meaning of the [MAC] Act". They indicated they would like to obtain a statement from Mr Anderson but even without evidence from him "our belief is the breach of duty of care will be established".
They then addressed the possibility of a reduction for contributory negligence which they at that time considered would be in the range 0% - 20%. The letter advised of a range of likely damages that would be awarded of $563,700.00 to $1,092,200.00 (inclusive of costs).
98In November 2008 Mr Horwood filed his statement of claim against Megbuy. The statement of claim pleaded that Megbuy was not only his employer, it was the owner of the forklift.
It particularised Megbuy's negligence in terms that reflected the apprehension of QBE's solicitors, that is, it alleged a failure on the part of Megbuy to maintain the forklift and allowing the forklift to be driven whilst steering was excessively loose and erratic and might "fish-tail due to loose steering".
The statement of claim alleged that Megbuy was liable because [it] was the owner of the vehicle, the vehicle was in use at the time of the accident and the vehicle was defective".
99QBE also tendered a letter from its solicitors to one of its claims managers dated 13 July 2009. This was well after proceedings had commenced. The letter summarised the effect of advice that had been obtained from counsel (Mr Cavanagh SC).
It was said that counsel had noted the difficulty in reconciling Mr Capper's evidence with that of Messr Sanderson, Oates and Gillett. He noted the "critical evidence" from Mr Gillett which suggested that there had been "deficiencies in the steering of the forklift for some time prior to the accident". The letter extracted the following from counsel's advice:
"It is surprising that both [Gillett and Oates] would be so adamant and specific as to the deficiencies in the steering mechanism if there was absolutely no substance to such suggestion. It seems that these former employees will give evidence in the proceedings.
It is highly unlikely that the Court would reject their evidence as being fabricated or speculative. They may not be able to offer an opinion as to the cause of the accident but they may be able to give sufficient evidence to provide a basis for the Court to make the appropriate findings".
100QBE's solicitors then added:
"We agree with counsel's conclusion that the defendant is at significant risk. The plaintiff sustained a serious injury. The Court will be loathe to conclude that this did not occur through the negligence of the defendant as owner of the registered forklift.
You could procure expert evidence to analyse in greater detail the mechanics of the accident but our view is that this is unlikely to alter the final outcome and that liability should, in fact, be admitted in due course to contain costs."
101The letter referred to advice that had been provided in April 2009 that the most likely damages to be sought by Mr Horwood, or ordered by the Court, and costs would be "just over $1.2 million".
102Consistent with this letter on 26 August 2009 QBE's solicitor advised Mr Horwood's solicitor that they were instructed to admit liability "subject to preservation of the defence of contributory negligence." The chronology of events leading to the entry of the consent orders has been set out above.
To that chronology I add that on 24 November 2009 QBE was advised by its solicitors of a revised range of damages of $824,750.00 to $1,615,000.00 (inclusive of costs) with a "most likely" figure of $1,249,000.00.
103The material obtained by QBE concerning the forklift revealed that it was old and, to the extent that it had been serviced, the persons who undertook that were not qualified mechanics (Messrs Gillett and Ralph). There were no records of it being serviced and maintained prior to Mr Horwood's accident.
|
[
0.011226353235542774,
-0.0068917106837034225,
-0.015167264267802238,
-0.01143935602158308,
0.03416014462709427,
-0.010394157841801643,
-0.00973594281822443,
0.012953272089362144,
0.02244529500603676,
0.01476331427693367,
0.009409137070178986,
0.00014249155356083065,
-0.009439378045499325,
0.00040164528763853014,
-0.012095531448721886,
-0.03692786023020744,
0.01515619084239006,
-0.018511785194277763,
-0.04305272176861763,
-0.024850239977240562,
0.013537909835577011,
0.0035669696517288685,
0.06444522738456726,
0.023091599345207214,
0.028627103194594383,
0.033196043223142624,
-0.030618224292993546,
0.005182836204767227,
0.033824559301137924,
-0.020646637305617332,
-0.02414264902472496,
-0.020478159189224243,
0.02446928434073925,
0.012016505002975464,
0.024406306445598602,
-0.06846839189529419,
-0.010444164276123047,
0.016887400299310684,
-0.0204909797757864,
0.0028255595825612545,
0.00958747323602438,
-0.014593061059713364,
0.029373737052083015,
-0.03545761480927467,
0.02688451297581196,
-0.02862774208188057,
-0.00932308565825224,
-0.012157820165157318,
0.004731346853077412,
-0.02536091022193432,
-0.018388520926237106,
-0.02940830960869789,
0.06629130244255066,
-0.018575351685285568,
0.00042632283293642104,
0.008909911848604679,
0.02071513794362545,
-0.01336878351867199,
-0.06825770437717438,
-0.005007087253034115,
-0.023217948153614998,
-0.04476111754775047,
-0.01568763516843319,
-0.002651070710271597,
0.018018895760178566,
0.09514480084180832,
-0.032752007246017456,
0.0005530107882805169,
-0.008295002393424511,
-0.01858876459300518,
-0.010573098435997963,
0.013150738552212715,
0.01786775141954422,
0.0253602247685194,
-0.06523952633142471,
0.028496112674474716,
0.0002740367199294269,
0.038412850350141525,
-0.004858012311160564,
0.024592570960521698,
0.00804805289953947,
0.007376323454082012,
-0.01616961508989334,
0.028133079409599304,
-0.0400644987821579,
0.009650222957134247,
-0.00029056656057946384,
0.008339468389749527,
-0.004123697988688946,
0.00579429417848587,
-0.012422282248735428,
0.01060648076236248,
0.015645811334252357,
-0.022882048040628433,
-0.006563883274793625,
-0.02493121847510338,
-0.05988951399922371,
0.0411323718726635,
0.010965298861265182,
-0.004793383181095123,
-0.007610186468809843,
0.018488552421331406,
0.04241825267672539,
-0.047280751168727875,
0.027686510235071182,
-0.009701196104288101,
0.001218541176058352,
0.03640173375606537,
0.028736013919115067,
0.003011331893503666,
-0.015386447310447693,
0.0033682072535157204,
-0.019898345693945885,
0.01808950863778591,
-0.0005077472305856645,
0.00008476735820295289,
0.030323822051286697,
-0.03647651523351669,
0.002262141788378358,
-0.045729219913482666,
0.05632202699780464,
0.04564615339040756,
0.05332621559500694,
-0.013361938297748566,
-0.03260417655110359,
-0.013328426517546177,
0.00007578341319458559,
-0.05238206312060356,
-0.017551599070429802,
0.004865976516157389,
0.0047334362752735615,
0.0035979158710688353,
-0.01025922317057848,
-0.049767643213272095,
-0.05113770440220833,
-0.02961248904466629,
0.04723012074828148,
0.012032035738229752,
-0.02673797309398651,
-0.016638988628983498,
0.04530360922217369,
0.04199552536010742,
-0.006814890541136265,
0.005978730507194996,
0.045001886785030365,
-0.005899809300899506,
0.0243513286113739,
-0.03342496603727341,
0.01818881742656231,
-0.0004289452626835555,
0.038345422595739365,
-0.010647662915289402,
-0.0006623318186029792,
-0.04205251485109329,
0.022836273536086082,
-0.05565271154046059,
0.033563319593667984,
-0.027925876900553703,
-0.012836800888180733,
0.01815567910671234,
-0.005231430288404226,
0.07396115362644196,
-0.036294128745794296,
-0.04209029674530029,
0.003125465475022793,
0.010892820544540882,
0.028831329196691513,
0.030100803822278976,
-0.02271389029920101,
-0.025766927748918533,
0.014109237119555473,
-0.009847034700214863,
0.007996562868356705,
-0.0071832905523478985,
0.02967558428645134,
0.02779664658010006,
0.05733097717165947,
0.015677861869335175,
0.022267498075962067,
-0.05559707060456276,
0.015551183372735977,
0.007343607023358345,
0.017654845491051674,
-0.027840828523039818,
-0.007219982799142599,
0.05230998247861862,
0.003077942645177245,
-0.038815051317214966,
0.006132199894636869,
-0.00390536617487669,
0.0003084213240072131,
-0.018129220232367516,
0.013029058463871479,
-0.014202848076820374,
0.01650966890156269,
0.0022919264156371355,
0.030296146869659424,
-0.02604489214718342,
0.02471940591931343,
-0.046961236745119095,
-0.03392326459288597,
0.03400251269340515,
0.023471370339393616,
-0.013202673755586147,
-0.047306835651397705,
0.018013235181570053,
-0.03787325322628021,
-0.0035701605957001448,
0.013733836822211742,
-0.061147887259721756,
0.006641759071499109,
0.008792612701654434,
0.04653723165392876,
0.0087622394785285,
-0.021546173840761185,
-0.007890908047556877,
0.011452920734882355,
-0.01473503839224577,
0.02452007867395878,
-0.019211772829294205,
-0.05715194717049599,
-0.008021223358809948,
0.006497456692159176,
0.0035711994860321283,
0.024287914857268333,
0.026162656024098396,
-0.031951479613780975,
0.018023470416665077,
0.012365489266812801,
-0.04396975412964821,
0.041146695613861084,
0.005334649235010147,
0.023153645917773247,
-0.034869641065597534,
0.02611265517771244,
0.02088618092238903,
0.013708160258829594,
0.01911149173974991,
0.028767738491296768,
0.04297705367207527,
-0.029133634641766548,
0.0020444674883037806,
0.04278932511806488,
-0.027753282338380814,
-0.01762506179511547,
-0.013691320084035397,
0.009759622626006603,
0.057205528020858765,
0.06259696185588837,
0.02502506785094738,
0.01921134814620018,
-0.013646580278873444,
-0.031587667763233185,
-0.009559114463627338,
0.011820698156952858,
0.0446234755218029,
0.01868792623281479,
-0.021968945860862732,
0.024082152172923088,
-0.026015734300017357,
-0.007301084231585264,
0.004526243545114994,
0.03571092337369919,
0.0011900251265615225,
-0.02945014275610447,
-0.02601088024675846,
-0.007515138480812311,
-0.05312841385602951,
-0.028856363147497177,
-0.00699967984110117,
0.025096334517002106,
0.01774996891617775,
-0.008713974617421627,
0.002377525670453906,
0.011820277199149132,
0.020986471325159073,
-0.0130451750010252,
-0.02993554249405861,
0.013678466901183128,
-0.03869735077023506,
0.0703284814953804,
0.029990537092089653,
0.028191527351737022,
-0.017619043588638306,
0.015773599967360497,
0.013167819008231163,
-0.03770773112773895,
-0.07265380769968033,
-0.028965283185243607,
-0.052748702466487885,
0.01324713695794344,
-0.02815837785601616,
0.06824608147144318,
0.006183145102113485,
-0.049453042447566986,
0.030350320041179657,
-0.0025776447728276253,
-0.1473560780286789,
0.009441420435905457,
0.012457267381250858,
0.060043815523386,
0.003234656061977148,
0.03197670727968216,
0.00011360088683431968,
0.0007582590915262699,
-0.021744797006249428,
0.015522994101047516,
0.029751934111118317,
-0.060415640473365784,
-0.0037640496157109737,
0.011613354086875916,
0.00975106656551361,
-0.01550052035599947,
0.023579467087984085,
0.0067264121025800705,
0.024494053795933723,
-0.023857176303863525,
-0.014706214889883995,
-0.03201383352279663,
0.01294176746159792,
0.004877939820289612,
-0.010546940378844738,
-0.013337096199393272,
0.046252958476543427,
0.024387402459979057,
-0.0047823055647313595,
-0.03905919939279556,
-0.03653997555375099,
0.010874241590499878,
-0.007127952296286821,
0.042203761637210846,
-0.008116679266095161,
0.006824844982475042,
0.0846339762210846,
-0.08511459827423096,
0.005268111824989319,
-0.0003014424000866711,
0.03890613093972206,
0.08832836151123047,
0.000331599498167634,
-0.015156676061451435,
-0.005116172134876251,
-0.07817770540714264,
0.020338375121355057,
0.0173883568495512,
-0.0475434772670269,
0.031774215400218964,
-0.02250642329454422,
-0.00979562196880579,
0.013702791184186935,
0.012076348066329956,
-0.019295720383524895,
-0.027674280107021332,
0.03647727891802788,
0.06262217462062836,
-0.03066623955965042,
0.008666040375828743,
-0.02625318057835102,
-0.0775933787226677,
0.03976299613714218,
0.04273638501763344,
-0.031894974410533905,
0.00017029036825988442,
0.002313349163159728,
-0.029979899525642395,
0.03317372500896454,
0.0009581621852703393,
-0.03400377184152603,
-0.04687381535768509,
0.058833591639995575,
-0.026360388845205307,
0.03835627809166908,
0.01856115646660328,
-0.003198880236595869,
-0.016099849715828896,
-0.002916342345997691,
-0.0830308198928833,
-0.0013740552822127938,
0.0529126413166523,
-0.02484939619898796,
0.028385082259774208,
-0.01767532341182232,
0.030648237094283104,
0.025320356711745262,
0.04440648481249809,
0.0498172827064991,
0.2584556043148041,
-0.04566849768161774,
-0.0022325683385133743,
0.021493826061487198,
0.01975187472999096,
0.04338724538683891,
0.0036461169365793467,
0.032498329877853394,
0.022239210084080696,
-0.012216951698064804,
-0.0382126085460186,
-0.027267565950751305,
0.002895534737035632,
0.018973080441355705,
-0.027501337230205536,
-0.010752011090517044,
-0.030459629371762276,
-0.04305557906627655,
0.06198374927043915,
-0.0198446586728096,
0.05620793625712395,
-0.002956555923447013,
0.04167653247714043,
0.006328473333269358,
-0.11095813661813736,
-0.044431172311306,
0.004964033607393503,
0.028400518000125885,
0.005066736601293087,
0.021995259448885918,
-0.02996506541967392,
-0.01769142597913742,
0.010801815427839756,
0.0046131908893585205,
-0.006825408898293972,
-0.014959795400500298,
0.00044830681872554123,
-0.013643864542245865,
0.007831806316971779,
0.01235202793031931,
0.0514429472386837,
-0.004382618702948093,
-0.02984151616692543,
-0.015995115041732788,
-0.01978268474340439,
0.010247530415654182,
0.012629921548068523,
0.006079293321818113,
-0.00955155584961176,
0.027561860159039497,
-0.04389358311891556,
0.00914040207862854,
-0.036063745617866516,
-0.00653846375644207,
-0.02623557299375534,
0.012003686279058456,
-0.009184617549180984,
0.015184025280177593,
0.007224115543067455,
0.008876267820596695,
0.01857190765440464,
0.014505275525152683,
-0.016173118725419044,
0.019805049523711205,
-0.005110642407089472,
-0.0021847498137503862,
-0.0602504163980484,
0.007300780154764652,
0.03205821290612221,
-0.003302561119198799,
0.003265829524025321,
0.02034236304461956,
0.0007361604366451502,
0.0374293252825737,
0.035360727459192276,
0.022621195763349533,
-0.00015134172281250358,
0.05421185865998268,
-0.0031918457243591547,
0.005500701256096363,
-0.030098525807261467,
-0.0267092976719141,
0.0047759683802723885,
-0.00109535688534379,
-0.0015350602334365249,
-0.03184732794761658,
-0.04494359344244003,
0.04111107438802719,
0.02099113166332245,
-0.015585515648126602,
-0.03205627575516701,
-0.030432237312197685,
-0.010736417025327682,
0.014301612973213196,
-0.03199543058872223,
0.01478884182870388,
0.07107993215322495,
0.008599621243774891,
-0.008404871448874474,
-0.05305272713303566,
-0.025053439661860466,
0.0016954619204625487,
-0.010291030630469322,
-0.03857787698507309,
-0.022824229672551155,
-0.018016546964645386,
0.010739623568952084,
-0.014898222871124744,
-0.0516171008348465,
-0.012992904521524906,
-0.012881671078503132,
-0.002684550592675805,
-0.01736263558268547,
-0.014434662647545338,
0.014014271087944508,
0.036104071885347366,
0.0051326509565114975,
0.04035278409719467,
-0.007840770296752453,
0.016503632068634033,
-0.029531074687838554,
-0.00561853963881731,
-0.03668268769979477,
0.03243667259812355,
-0.0004936117911711335,
0.022079894319176674,
-0.03530244529247284,
-0.03102254495024681,
-0.006277377717196941,
0.013904326595366001,
-0.003778251353651285,
-0.018143998458981514,
-0.02059514820575714,
-0.02829309180378914,
0.04920269176363945,
0.012501443736255169,
-0.00501870596781373,
0.02481967955827713,
0.005129113793373108,
0.00715964799746871,
-0.026744570583105087,
-0.014001882635056973,
-0.04863595589995384,
-0.04677532613277435,
0.017717691138386726,
-0.0006256068591028452,
-0.022384028881788254,
0.03435960039496422,
-0.05573144182562828,
-0.007833166047930717,
-0.002099050674587488,
0.03248627856373787,
-0.021062714979052544,
-0.00703852716833353,
-0.005067023914307356,
0.03382422402501106,
0.03278777003288269,
-0.000006998689968895633,
0.014873281121253967,
-0.04145943373441696,
-0.006062863860279322,
-0.008953889831900597,
0.017969302833080292,
0.051896557211875916,
0.01451792661100626,
0.03698574751615524,
0.011760169640183449,
0.0362723283469677,
0.05119352042675018,
0.011124949902296066,
0.0005912076449021697,
0.0034388655330985785,
0.0047904690727591515,
0.06687499582767487,
0.034771330654621124,
0.0574602335691452,
-0.028460994362831116,
0.018954478204250336,
0.057017914950847626,
-0.03755176439881325,
0.01219934318214655,
0.0378701277077198,
-0.03699497878551483,
0.004525747150182724,
-0.01596541702747345,
-0.024452345445752144,
0.010988833382725716,
-0.04006268084049225,
0.0266413651406765,
-0.027175161987543106,
-0.03844304010272026,
0.0876423567533493,
-0.0294700525701046,
-0.031068721786141396,
-0.0041929068975150585,
0.015963857993483543,
0.003995050210505724,
0.03142371028661728,
0.001388360164128244,
-0.020103896036744118,
-0.028301911428570747,
0.02823432721197605,
0.022188525646924973,
-0.0036642998456954956,
0.04665122926235199,
0.016203807666897774,
-0.016573425382375717,
0.029586005955934525,
-0.032672420144081116,
0.009557942859828472,
0.028627529740333557,
0.016556456685066223,
-0.018876636400818825,
0.0034669404849410057,
-0.016791507601737976,
-0.005407171789556742,
0.019207673147320747,
0.05618051066994667,
-0.04624348506331444,
-0.04559628665447235,
-0.033937007188797,
-0.003129290882498026,
0.029689103364944458,
-0.06087101250886917,
-0.022138861939311028,
0.03236689046025276,
-0.02490229159593582,
-0.029162073507905006,
0.011384120211005211,
-0.0005311869899742305,
0.011712516658008099,
-0.046818651258945465,
0.004209162667393684,
-0.027635563164949417,
0.005109808407723904,
0.003768947906792164,
0.04859255626797676,
0.018555333837866783,
-0.0019238527165725827,
-0.006454714108258486,
0.032963480800390244,
-0.004028670489788055,
-0.00040016433922573924,
0.06730883568525314,
-0.01632053032517433,
-0.012896458618342876,
0.004032749682664871,
-0.04637964814901352,
-0.014698619954288006,
0.016398968175053596,
0.03558851033449173,
0.007641751319169998,
0.011983518488705158,
-0.030935371294617653,
0.001968416851013899,
-0.03563164919614792,
-0.013996749185025692,
0.0002539123815950006,
-0.04370223358273506,
-0.02599540911614895,
-0.007461563218384981,
0.04914918541908264,
0.00019230658654123545,
-0.027936773374676704,
0.019247235730290413,
-0.0486706905066967,
0.0002721870841924101,
-0.0069660041481256485,
-0.016878852620720863,
-0.025447936728596687,
0.02109316736459732,
-0.019014066085219383,
-0.07608344405889511,
-0.08967754244804382,
-0.035998228937387466,
0.027489546686410904,
-0.047129590064287186,
-0.015122856013476849,
0.013535769656300545,
-0.07563313096761703,
0.048057109117507935,
-0.04490010812878609,
0.006935843266546726,
0.011511354707181454,
-0.006168872117996216,
0.03666897863149643,
0.019196394830942154,
-0.0012668047565966845,
0.0014518967363983393,
-0.013605104759335518,
0.03130018711090088,
0.034489307552576065,
-0.02164972573518753,
0.01579969748854637,
-0.01960279420018196,
0.003184403060004115,
-0.012819966301321983,
0.07012555003166199,
-0.04240386560559273,
0.006726318504661322,
-0.02223341353237629,
-0.00821530818939209,
-0.030133286491036415,
-0.03256182000041008,
0.008847164921462536,
-0.00928427278995514,
0.0197017639875412,
-0.0441603809595108,
-0.034609369933605194,
0.03140399977564812,
0.010220091789960861,
-0.054782260209321976,
-0.01424389984458685,
-0.03200250491499901,
-0.0025506331585347652,
0.01663501374423504,
0.0133652463555336,
0.003543134545907378,
0.02712060697376728,
0.030811039730906487,
0.039689283818006516,
-0.015558949671685696,
-0.046276483684778214,
-0.020417561754584312,
-0.08576923608779907,
0.00034943321952596307,
0.024211568757891655,
0.010743838734924793,
-0.029389558359980583,
-0.02667979709804058,
-0.02351973205804825,
-0.0076921056024730206,
-0.02672918699681759,
-0.013953864574432373,
0.07489798218011856,
0.017932502552866936,
0.005204987712204456,
-0.008368912152945995,
0.06427572667598724,
-0.03739834949374199,
-0.01540136244148016,
-0.05704108253121376,
0.06711362302303314,
-0.012533677741885185,
-0.006850417237728834,
0.006917130202054977,
0.0003986263182014227,
-0.012451875023543835,
0.024225881323218346,
0.04295504093170166,
0.016746824607253075,
0.01508434396237135,
-0.026274848729372025,
-0.054885976016521454,
0.0027421361301094294,
0.02506415732204914,
0.0034765040036290884,
-0.0017459276132285595,
0.023511748760938644,
-0.013082335703074932,
-0.020468974485993385,
0.03168104961514473,
-0.000977840623818338,
-0.023277774453163147,
0.019541645422577858,
0.02060212939977646,
-0.012768419459462166,
0.01468435488641262,
-0.01621820032596588,
-0.012285677716135979,
0.0033033080399036407,
-0.013636153191328049,
0.013518155552446842,
-0.0013487112009897828,
0.008222862146794796,
0.017030613496899605,
0.026825109496712685,
0.01474708877503872,
0.0130138099193573,
-0.034942321479320526,
-0.028599776327610016,
-0.054283507168293,
-0.06089930981397629,
-0.005948005709797144,
0.03217572718858719,
0.027853110805153847,
-0.04427633807063103,
0.020874856039881706,
-0.021496538072824478,
0.045116446912288666,
-0.010115721262991428,
0.034123826771974564,
-0.05647791549563408,
0.021999893710017204,
-0.14232903718948364,
0.017259959131479263,
-0.0035882580559700727,
-0.0037828453350812197,
-0.07812230288982391,
-0.005334310233592987,
-0.021154286339879036,
0.0015382174169644713,
-0.013622874394059181,
-0.023869158700108528,
-0.007153748068958521,
0.015081709250807762,
0.05848127603530884,
0.010695052333176136,
-0.018545422703027725,
0.07124263793230057,
-0.00493591045960784,
-0.04723791778087616,
-0.03079848363995552,
0.04291180148720741,
0.02335706353187561,
0.013981410302221775,
-0.006005206145346165,
-0.009822488762438297,
-0.04724971950054169,
-0.010157494805753231,
-0.030193574726581573,
-0.030411778017878532,
-0.018426479771733284,
-0.001627218327485025,
-0.06905324012041092,
-0.006431463174521923,
0.014614855870604515,
0.030021632090210915,
-0.020350802689790726,
0.023901667445898056,
0.009981314651668072,
-0.007825637236237526,
-0.046107497066259384,
-0.0174998939037323,
-0.010843301191926003,
0.019983163103461266,
-0.05599803104996681,
0.007546382490545511,
-0.00409181322902441,
0.044238168746232986,
-0.03772122040390968,
-0.002553148427978158,
-0.0032450754661113024,
-0.03956206515431404,
-0.037523530423641205,
0.027727851644158363,
-0.020338144153356552,
0.0015359146054834127,
0.007611061446368694,
0.037211935967206955,
0.0069780172780156136,
-0.04441037029027939,
-0.006533668842166662,
0.058765094727277756,
-0.008433280512690544,
0.012316850945353508,
-0.04592892527580261,
-0.03359459340572357,
0.030533278360962868,
-0.00370801636017859,
0.013001793064177036,
0.009404746815562248,
-0.014354185201227665,
0.00032861990621313453,
-0.002464494900777936,
-0.02262231707572937,
0.046795934438705444,
-0.031529750674963,
0.027335934340953827,
-0.018973657861351967,
0.012838724069297314,
0.0005611942615360022,
0.012521116994321346,
-0.003767663612961769,
-0.00492442911490798,
-0.002818445209413767,
-0.06905391812324524,
-0.01416010968387127,
0.038158539682626724,
0.030704500153660774,
-0.022556103765964508,
-0.04320598393678665,
0.043486837297677994,
-0.05184074491262436,
-0.0751747190952301,
0.00021378153178375214,
0.033351294696331024,
-0.008061330765485764,
-0.030565982684493065,
0.03594685345888138,
0.009058882482349873,
-0.02270698919892311,
-0.031092660501599312,
-0.06502170860767365,
-0.018963007256388664,
-0.04393146559596062,
0.018718115985393524,
-0.004019387532025576,
-0.013437728397548199,
0.05203249678015709,
-0.02880694344639778,
0.007409759797155857,
-0.0120640704408288,
-0.0009364364668726921,
-0.01676720567047596,
-0.05265587568283081,
-0.038549087941646576,
-0.032247282564640045,
-0.023075465112924576,
0.049537643790245056,
0.005211327690631151,
0.00908985547721386,
-0.021162496879696846,
0.007478062994778156,
0.036322567611932755,
-0.03219842538237572,
0.02038326859474182,
-0.018393492326140404,
0.0000373621478502173,
0.046235814690589905,
0.05296538770198822,
0.02910769358277321,
0.02050367183983326,
-0.02222083881497383,
0.04328363016247749,
-0.018209507688879967,
-0.009565162472426891,
-0.008784077130258083,
0.02005121111869812,
0.02419539913535118,
-0.0398678183555603,
0.00495846988633275,
-0.0005915029905736446,
-0.05443257465958595,
0.012199994176626205,
0.004326071590185165,
-0.012901732698082924,
-0.012123682536184788,
-0.028957979753613472,
-0.0031985770910978317,
0.03564271703362465,
-0.02422301471233368,
0.006857014261186123,
-0.030278241261839867,
-0.02820533886551857,
0.01095938216894865,
0.0000556124905415345,
0.07782229036092758,
0.02772732824087143,
-0.023308033123612404,
0.04276065528392792,
0.022253312170505524,
0.008192814886569977,
0.04628210887312889,
0.03791625425219536,
-0.03571713715791702,
-0.03090932033956051,
-0.002279482549056411,
-0.030257858335971832,
0.018510278314352036,
-0.012522471137344837,
0.0013296782271936536,
-0.025017110630869865,
-0.006951328832656145,
0.014625202864408493,
-0.019739076495170593,
-0.03633700683712959,
-0.008416751399636269,
0.03747767210006714,
-0.039704933762550354,
0.006871853023767471,
-0.027203673496842384,
0.06848064064979553,
-0.005776987876743078,
0.05464247614145279,
0.03788531571626663,
0.028514888137578964,
0.014657648280262947,
0.015938526019454002,
0.02997591905295849,
-0.00331084500066936,
-0.0002869280579034239,
-0.05008530989289284,
-0.0037622733507305384,
-0.009748933836817741,
0.004713177215307951,
-0.010009380988776684,
-0.03425560146570206,
0.02790900692343712,
0.01240373495966196,
-0.007767681963741779,
0.037265628576278687,
0.01970660872757435,
0.021857108920812607,
0.003399911569431424,
-0.02403656579554081,
0.0007767603383399546,
-0.018722154200077057,
-0.020260320976376534,
-0.0020636250264942646,
0.01939520239830017,
-0.030726799741387367,
-0.05779140070080757,
-0.0016821245662868023,
-0.04667344689369202,
0.008477496914565563,
0.02812233194708824,
0.047409120947122574,
-0.03215460479259491,
0.01845972239971161,
-0.0006020637811161578,
-0.01407849881798029,
0.02417992614209652,
-0.009340864606201649,
0.011035190895199776,
0.040129393339157104,
-0.00781430397182703,
-0.03370101377367973,
0.02081836573779583,
0.010974916629493237,
0.033190999180078506,
-0.03054196387529373,
0.020564373582601547,
0.0028590664733201265,
-0.011081716977059841,
-0.012472228147089481,
0.015285558998584747,
0.024819986894726753,
0.005124091636389494,
-0.030146967619657516,
-0.023314913734793663,
-0.0436880961060524,
-0.01165605429559946,
-0.009554357267916203,
0.05974213033914566,
0.005305549595504999,
-0.0008311492274515331,
0.017849961295723915
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:6
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
That it was reasonable for Caringbah (and Zurich acting in its interests) effectively to admit that it was owner of the coach is established by GIO's concurrence in it doing so.
The concurrence was not that Caringbah might admit liability and "defect" if it saw fit, with GIO reserving its position, but that it was appropriate that liability and "defect" be admitted. That it was reasonable for Caringbah to compromise the damages at $352,000 is similarly established by GIO's concurrence.
................
63.Zurich was only obliged to indemnify Caringbah if Caringbah was "owner" of the coach, within the Zurich statutory policy. Presumably Caringbah invoked the Zurich policy, and there is no reason to conclude other than that Zurich thought at the time that Caringbah was the or an owner of the coach: the only question in the District Court proceedings was whether Tiger was also owner of the coach.
That Zurich reasonably thought that Caringbah was the or an owner of the coach, and so was entitled to indemnity in respect of any liability to Mr McLellan, is established by GIO's concurrence in effective admission of Caringbah's ownership.
64.There is the equivalent of a reasonable settlement with Caringbah.
It would not be consistent with the natural justice and general principles of justice on which contribution on the basis of double insurance rests that, having concurred in Zurich shouldering the burden of indemnifying Caringbah as owner of the coach, including "owner" within Zurich's statutory policy, GIO should not have to share the burden. " (emphasis added)
Allsop P (at [1]) and Young JA (at [82]) agreed with Giles JA.
31The parties debated the correctness and scope of the statement of Giles JA in [57] of Zurich v QBE that where the liability of the first insurer's insured has "been the subject of a reasonable compromise" the "second insurer cannot put in issue in contribution proceedings the liability of the common insured".
32On the first day of the hearing Mr Campbell SC objected to the tender by QBE of a letter from Mr Horwood's solicitors to a Mr Oates enclosing an unsigned statement of Mr Oates. Mr Oates was another employee who worked for Megbuy and the statement referred to the poor state of the driving mechanism on the forklift (see below at [83]).
The tender was undertaken to establish that there had been a reasonable compromise of the claim against Megbuy in that the statement represented evidence that was likely to be available at any hearing of Mr Horwood's claim and it was material known to both sides of the litigation.
In objecting to the tender Mr Campbell SC accepted that, at the very least, the effect of [57] of Giles JA's judgement enabled the "liability" of Megbuy to be established by demonstrating a reasonable compromise (although he took issue with the scope of that principle as asserted by the QBE).
However, Mr Campbell SC contended that the statement was obiter dicta and, respectfully, submitted that it was incorrect.
33I allowed the tender of the material. I was not asked and did not place any restriction on the use to which it might be put. In allowing the tender I was not prepared to determine at that point in the trial that the Court of Appeal's statement was incorrect and should not be followed.
In announcing my ruling I indicated that Mr Campbell SC was not precluded from repeating the submission in final address. I also stated QBE were on notice of CGU's contention and had to make the appropriate forensic choices in running their case against the contingency that Mr Campbell SC's point was ultimately accepted.
34Mr Campbell SC submitted that the passage in Zurich v GIO at [57] "was obiter because in that case the liability of the plaintiff had been established by a judgement in the District Court.
" On reflection I do not think that is quite correct. The only judicial determination on the merits in Zurich v GIO was the determination by the District Court that Tiger was the owner of the coach in addition to Caringbah.
|
[
-0.016262894496321678,
-0.003173573175445199,
-0.022362705320119858,
-0.0015197463799268007,
0.015257209539413452,
-0.011389472521841526,
-0.0016533660236746073,
0.020517751574516296,
0.004472106229513884,
0.01645553484559059,
-0.004366307985037565,
-0.005843461491167545,
-0.019833190366625786,
0.019045459106564522,
0.004165058955550194,
-0.006227079778909683,
0.05123624950647354,
0.006388545967638493,
-0.06215197220444679,
-0.033481817692518234,
0.009285977110266685,
-0.03204134851694107,
0.07639565318822861,
0.020662276074290276,
0.007361405063420534,
0.040968216955661774,
0.004637529607862234,
0.013690834864974022,
-0.003944923635572195,
-0.0166596919298172,
-0.022980915382504463,
0.04775480553507805,
0.0036844657734036446,
-0.010788320563733578,
0.007076903246343136,
-0.04488438740372658,
0.008538504131138325,
-0.0022875145077705383,
-0.013029397465288639,
-0.002659892663359642,
-0.019185746088624,
-0.026464054360985756,
0.02084280736744404,
-0.05776679515838623,
0.02329719252884388,
-0.011385326273739338,
-0.011707771569490433,
-0.027574613690376282,
-0.013499976135790348,
-0.013401826843619347,
-0.0576322004199028,
0.0050882906652987,
0.0724613294005394,
-0.022470269352197647,
-0.004627303685992956,
0.04808492213487625,
0.03952037915587425,
-0.046724993735551834,
-0.04969584196805954,
-0.02160174958407879,
-0.04331105947494507,
-0.06736228615045547,
0.004476981703191996,
-0.0017240939196199179,
0.015718109905719757,
0.07079865038394928,
0.02143368311226368,
-0.010965033434331417,
-0.015265347436070442,
-0.05238666012883186,
-0.02983800880610943,
0.02156064845621586,
-0.021418415009975433,
0.005384939722716808,
-0.05517644062638283,
0.010167465545237064,
0.01252325251698494,
-0.0017700172029435635,
0.026979081332683563,
0.002657476346939802,
0.023961437866091728,
-0.021082261577248573,
-0.0007040093769319355,
0.01446476113051176,
-0.044312845915555954,
-0.00972301047295332,
-0.03558829054236412,
0.02458927035331726,
-0.020231690257787704,
0.019922930747270584,
-0.01128278486430645,
-0.05553998798131943,
-0.00921666156500578,
-0.02931191958487034,
0.01990065909922123,
-0.004555893130600452,
-0.06468920409679413,
0.006684410851448774,
0.015705347061157227,
0.007266688160598278,
0.02523931860923767,
-0.012831566855311394,
0.0011652314569801092,
-0.02785709872841835,
0.004299242980778217,
-0.010693306103348732,
-0.008426222018897533,
0.054351650178432465,
-0.007087041158229113,
0.007668305188417435,
0.009958483278751373,
0.03989711031317711,
0.013338391669094563,
0.048154838383197784,
-0.016267457976937294,
-0.04016624391078949,
0.0070758662186563015,
0.013542775996029377,
0.02650856040418148,
-0.024522952735424042,
0.0356246680021286,
0.048535190522670746,
0.027561914175748825,
-0.012859408743679523,
-0.035702694207429886,
-0.0496639646589756,
-0.01268397830426693,
-0.015040378086268902,
-0.04634767025709152,
-0.004405618645250797,
0.013737927190959454,
0.019422708079218864,
0.01208180096000433,
-0.06204579398036003,
-0.03220348805189133,
-0.037838567048311234,
0.01598617061972618,
-0.0008692782721482217,
-0.038304027169942856,
-0.06474067270755768,
0.046687982976436615,
0.050275109708309174,
0.015618680976331234,
-0.030966883525252342,
0.034243762493133545,
-0.0016770422225818038,
0.029220100492239,
-0.0053969318978488445,
-0.006793694570660591,
-0.0007308415952138603,
0.023903299123048782,
0.012391793541610241,
-0.007416490465402603,
-0.032843828201293945,
0.004197339527308941,
-0.02186226099729538,
0.021594179794192314,
-0.010546151548624039,
-0.008370080962777138,
0.02947191894054413,
0.012506124563515186,
0.06512771546840668,
0.028508901596069336,
-0.02372373640537262,
-0.011387065052986145,
0.0043505593203008175,
-0.03115900792181492,
0.045681729912757874,
-0.007100079208612442,
-0.024830954149365425,
-0.001635551336221397,
0.04317236691713333,
0.014300049282610416,
-0.0035208137705922127,
0.010827208869159222,
0.02653055638074875,
0.02194915898144245,
0.015173731371760368,
0.021118324249982834,
-0.03858153149485588,
-0.00827899668365717,
-0.010961233638226986,
0.004139398690313101,
-0.03708573430776596,
-0.028331737965345383,
0.021852262318134308,
0.0272942166775465,
-0.054526831954717636,
0.026163049042224884,
0.011602670885622501,
-0.007283460348844528,
-0.027289053425192833,
0.013745341449975967,
-0.01557962317019701,
-0.00364513392560184,
0.018056076020002365,
0.036925118416547775,
-0.0055603766813874245,
0.034455783665180206,
-0.06743073463439941,
-0.007903805933892727,
0.0376337431371212,
0.06806961447000504,
0.025806676596403122,
-0.03984929993748665,
0.009419752284884453,
-0.0543803907930851,
0.02336626872420311,
0.041655272245407104,
-0.0946233943104744,
-0.0018460253486409783,
-0.060312170535326004,
-0.0053295292891561985,
0.03213249519467354,
-0.037444520741701126,
-0.02536631189286709,
0.03252134099602699,
-0.014426451176404953,
0.030113596469163895,
-0.012025480158627033,
0.001696494990028441,
0.020862741395831108,
0.018769772723317146,
0.05927909165620804,
0.028460949659347534,
0.02671782486140728,
-0.005817065015435219,
0.038828469812870026,
-0.00308702839538455,
-0.027476683259010315,
0.029621750116348267,
0.02824418991804123,
-0.004322956781834364,
-0.049973223358392715,
0.017725685611367226,
0.028797060251235962,
0.000581785396207124,
0.0023084748536348343,
0.01790977641940117,
0.008358744904398918,
-0.02806122787296772,
0.002111080102622509,
0.08072386682033539,
-0.034518346190452576,
-0.014995621517300606,
-0.026116738095879555,
0.015959959477186203,
0.021701298654079437,
-0.001822806429117918,
-0.011191886849701405,
0.021055154502391815,
-0.009838314726948738,
-0.01897728070616722,
-0.029909012839198112,
0.032285407185554504,
0.016900446265935898,
0.021815765649080276,
-0.016926662996411324,
0.03555906191468239,
0.018569424748420715,
0.048924777656793594,
-0.03332589939236641,
-0.0063595944084227085,
0.02022995613515377,
-0.008478227071464062,
-0.05061207339167595,
-0.04096456617116928,
-0.012697465717792511,
-0.04957069084048271,
-0.018737953156232834,
-0.020020071417093277,
0.01987416483461857,
-0.05800702050328255,
0.023541714996099472,
0.022596638649702072,
0.04291725158691406,
0.04891987517476082,
-0.037505365908145905,
-0.008379528298974037,
0.010515241883695126,
0.02542162500321865,
0.006303637288510799,
0.015462454408407211,
0.00746703939512372,
0.016475504264235497,
0.003736330196261406,
-0.012155390344560146,
-0.000709173793438822,
0.005520543549209833,
-0.05058243125677109,
-0.010836154222488403,
0.039334896951913834,
0.08799102902412415,
-0.008635655976831913,
-0.052563585340976715,
-0.019217848777770996,
0.0006364941946230829,
-0.16660496592521667,
0.0072081186808645725,
0.015578958205878735,
0.03390106186270714,
-0.029880084097385406,
0.025696521624922752,
-0.007743074558675289,
0.001200518338009715,
0.02206169255077839,
-0.002774900523945689,
0.02825106680393219,
-0.05780736729502678,
0.007520965300500393,
0.01993548311293125,
0.004993599373847246,
-0.01772499457001686,
-0.013825762085616589,
-0.015406932681798935,
0.03645121306180954,
-0.027602750808000565,
0.02343573607504368,
-0.013771211728453636,
-0.0016898636240512133,
-0.0006627931143157184,
0.02019576169550419,
-0.010509837418794632,
0.005323243327438831,
-0.00041254484676755965,
-0.05532652139663696,
-0.016800925135612488,
-0.01828516460955143,
-0.008595794439315796,
-0.010795403271913528,
0.02472875267267227,
0.017682986333966255,
0.016030678525567055,
0.06178330257534981,
-0.041186682879924774,
-0.011821329593658447,
-0.017510026693344116,
0.028826510533690453,
0.0663759708404541,
-0.04169749841094017,
0.022973867133259773,
-0.02436457946896553,
-0.018331097438931465,
0.024135343730449677,
-0.00923234410583973,
-0.03621413931250572,
0.017708083614706993,
0.03301229327917099,
-0.031114637851715088,
0.01290932297706604,
-0.012373769655823708,
-0.01656525209546089,
-0.02510620653629303,
0.02637268416583538,
0.04388873279094696,
0.030281808227300644,
0.008384824730455875,
-0.045223645865917206,
-0.045113254338502884,
0.0010669942712411284,
0.02135845646262169,
-0.04982064664363861,
0.048146285116672516,
-0.01005054172128439,
0.005940320435911417,
0.04113510996103287,
0.013399134390056133,
-0.02074667066335678,
-0.01772364228963852,
0.04830306023359299,
-0.016630370169878006,
-0.022759994491934776,
0.0118363406509161,
0.008298082277178764,
-0.019652647897601128,
-0.011893995106220245,
-0.06985455006361008,
0.06155935302376747,
-0.005264322739094496,
0.009340165182948112,
0.026993941515684128,
-0.005135217681527138,
0.023704130202531815,
0.036458030343055725,
0.04054636508226395,
-0.0008577727130614221,
0.24430334568023682,
-0.014054213650524616,
-0.010625583119690418,
0.008546898141503334,
0.00931596476584673,
-0.009552549570798874,
0.008197110146284103,
0.05803845450282097,
0.0025749895721673965,
-0.02413812465965748,
-0.06475049257278442,
0.018726278096437454,
0.023755621165037155,
0.00281310616992414,
-0.007803491782397032,
-0.044460151344537735,
-0.015113982371985912,
-0.04575898125767708,
0.05230359360575676,
-0.03700346499681473,
0.06754161417484283,
-0.020172201097011566,
0.04910654574632645,
0.0032788775861263275,
-0.057228345423936844,
-0.06523145735263824,
0.008603007532656193,
-0.004706663079559803,
0.02111922763288021,
0.039083532989025116,
-0.05671272799372673,
0.0041907476261258125,
0.012607519514858723,
-0.0010585109703242779,
-0.009250386618077755,
0.014885311014950275,
-0.0040563540533185005,
0.01814430020749569,
0.0004787635407410562,
0.050339482724666595,
0.009610532782971859,
-0.020619403570890427,
0.0007391769322566688,
-0.018389077857136726,
0.023314733058214188,
-0.007627997547388077,
-0.0021095226984471083,
0.032271288335323334,
-0.03791432827711105,
0.015365955419838428,
-0.08397234231233597,
0.009962458163499832,
-0.033777229487895966,
0.007090161554515362,
-0.021058302372694016,
0.04047508165240288,
0.0014092120109125972,
0.010924622416496277,
-0.017824485898017883,
0.04946758598089218,
0.0019501685164868832,
0.020942389965057373,
-0.02347836084663868,
0.012645561248064041,
-0.013694414868950844,
0.026341857388615608,
-0.07391519099473953,
-0.012000815011560917,
0.050652842968702316,
-0.0035474183969199657,
0.0541166290640831,
0.02832508273422718,
0.017106961458921432,
0.026278097182512283,
0.04297769442200661,
0.011058923788368702,
0.002355970209464431,
0.046350330114364624,
0.03483361005783081,
-0.01866905950009823,
-0.07449603825807571,
-0.0209974218159914,
-0.027472272515296936,
0.020638594403862953,
0.015618724748492241,
-0.01461820024996996,
-0.0086818253621459,
0.046553414314985275,
0.004748520907014608,
-0.048796530812978745,
0.005537222605198622,
0.010231995023787022,
-0.00842307135462761,
0.017643604427576065,
-0.012620633468031883,
0.011895914562046528,
0.02350994385778904,
0.009182184003293514,
0.0007385690696537495,
-0.025504976511001587,
0.01822737790644169,
-0.004845800809562206,
-0.02331201359629631,
-0.00802584271878004,
0.055850714445114136,
0.027094870805740356,
0.037583477795124054,
-0.01619541272521019,
-0.04291439428925514,
-0.011633730493485928,
0.039034321904182434,
0.0180409736931324,
-0.04782172292470932,
-0.006576217245310545,
0.041054051369428635,
0.017131559550762177,
-0.046260785311460495,
0.002456905320286751,
0.02713618054986,
0.043887559324502945,
0.004103564191609621,
0.00453463289886713,
-0.04165502265095711,
0.025922900065779686,
0.007682621944695711,
-0.009335744194686413,
-0.02219417504966259,
-0.0394505076110363,
-0.008006948977708817,
-0.02225351706147194,
0.027182195335626602,
-0.009735637344419956,
-0.015518699772655964,
0.0031937032472342253,
0.022715259343385696,
-0.023957349359989166,
-0.042897120118141174,
-0.000684893224388361,
0.013188082724809647,
0.006738588679581881,
-0.014644913375377655,
0.007323774974793196,
-0.051136188209056854,
-0.004853215534240007,
0.0006315464270301163,
0.01495831087231636,
-0.015314522199332714,
0.031621262431144714,
-0.022716153413057327,
0.018450625240802765,
0.004958202596753836,
0.02302415668964386,
-0.03533563390374184,
-0.038096457719802856,
0.0023681188467890024,
-0.010819918476045132,
0.027301285415887833,
-0.003928948659449816,
0.03284841030836105,
-0.04264680668711662,
-0.008096715435385704,
-0.022520001977682114,
0.0077441176399588585,
0.024558240547776222,
0.007989350706338882,
0.06395960599184036,
-0.007572928909212351,
0.07969240099191666,
0.04464598372578621,
-0.03062407672405243,
0.04015545919537544,
-0.01834564283490181,
-0.01633559539914131,
0.028483759611845016,
0.06277401745319366,
0.07941675931215286,
0.02450890652835369,
0.03979374095797539,
0.023764504119753838,
-0.02774939499795437,
-0.006328472401946783,
0.018997997045516968,
-0.06701674312353134,
0.03347894921898842,
-0.026477230712771416,
-0.04034402593970299,
0.0006635285099036992,
-0.01797151379287243,
0.0185039434581995,
-0.014300503768026829,
-0.01841292344033718,
0.06485047936439514,
-0.037835460156202316,
-0.01727055385708809,
0.028067631646990776,
0.044867075979709625,
-0.049384329468011856,
-0.010387496091425419,
0.0020258582662791014,
-0.041897352784872055,
-0.0329684279859066,
-0.0386895053088665,
0.015050606802105904,
-0.014223304577171803,
0.049093097448349,
0.008275792002677917,
-0.023834768682718277,
0.014893384650349617,
-0.028042586520314217,
0.00009924035839503631,
0.014787977561354637,
0.01943986304104328,
-0.04096779599785805,
-0.019028468057513237,
-0.009499658830463886,
-0.008206450380384922,
0.041513074189424515,
0.0010835881112143397,
0.008519796654582024,
-0.049419600516557693,
0.007299941498786211,
0.004528980236500502,
0.017207389697432518,
-0.08587713539600372,
0.01512659527361393,
0.03474578261375427,
0.007122963201254606,
-0.012241154909133911,
0.04605682194232941,
-0.026125818490982056,
0.011997495777904987,
-0.016186119988560677,
-0.004695965442806482,
-0.027717076241970062,
-0.01831565797328949,
-0.019294004887342453,
0.028462158516049385,
0.018446048721671104,
0.04030026122927666,
0.005622532684355974,
0.06455797702074051,
-0.005180984269827604,
-0.008717630058526993,
0.049175627529621124,
0.0032718253787606955,
-0.016063077375292778,
-0.00618894025683403,
-0.030223505571484566,
0.023508552461862564,
0.013009070418775082,
-0.00004535485277301632,
0.0358748622238636,
-0.0007753134123049676,
-0.03034505806863308,
-0.018607713282108307,
-0.02832014299929142,
0.008638481609523296,
-0.000282266759313643,
-0.06905139237642288,
0.006326423026621342,
0.019864313304424286,
0.024312276393175125,
0.005869595799595118,
-0.02900402620434761,
0.025207743048667908,
-0.038496848195791245,
0.022244561463594437,
0.0014450158923864365,
-0.015647904947400093,
-0.027342870831489563,
-0.023325158283114433,
0.039004988968372345,
-0.062419429421424866,
-0.07342585921287537,
-0.02611178159713745,
0.01348112616688013,
-0.04381585121154785,
-0.00854798499494791,
0.030211230739951134,
0.010902064852416515,
0.03272803872823715,
-0.006023460999131203,
-0.028140131384134293,
0.06090017408132553,
-0.022899525240063667,
0.03573782742023468,
0.014454375952482224,
0.019407430663704872,
-0.007105144672095776,
-0.043917492032051086,
0.02471044287085533,
0.03737136721611023,
-0.016534851863980293,
0.0001479138882132247,
-0.003409776370972395,
-0.019454237073659897,
-0.02687186375260353,
0.046287901699543,
-0.04795881360769272,
0.020323438569903374,
-0.029971925541758537,
0.008339246734976768,
-0.04611584544181824,
-0.03453341871500015,
-0.025060147047042847,
-0.011120418086647987,
0.020593566820025444,
0.0002214052074123174,
-0.012612294405698776,
0.03455369547009468,
-0.013296561315655708,
-0.05770420655608177,
-0.034118734300136566,
-0.048639796674251556,
-0.005678129382431507,
0.030855562537908554,
0.014691820368170738,
-0.017091864719986916,
0.0072777606546878815,
0.005347739905118942,
-0.002759745344519615,
-0.03629712387919426,
-0.03029790148139,
-0.009213166311383247,
-0.045113611966371536,
-0.009317584335803986,
0.018533457070589066,
-0.014921004883944988,
-0.053966622799634933,
0.018741659820079803,
-0.04823676124215126,
-0.017799923196434975,
-0.008669693022966385,
0.0072672320529818535,
0.08049933612346649,
-0.030438095331192017,
-0.04552800580859184,
-0.005136960186064243,
0.007554154843091965,
-0.0006792339263483882,
0.000042550349462544546,
-0.050902970135211945,
0.08376255631446838,
0.006196215748786926,
0.03237422555685043,
-0.0016389730153605342,
0.0051062158308923244,
0.024147216230630875,
-0.012654993683099747,
0.018857857212424278,
-0.004210687708109617,
0.0007295694667845964,
-0.023251047357916832,
-0.008102543652057648,
-0.0248279832303524,
0.0219736211001873,
0.0047340840101242065,
0.03687048703432083,
0.010920668952167034,
-0.03383322432637215,
-0.056227829307317734,
0.027289770543575287,
-0.024212749674916267,
0.018696021288633347,
0.015650024637579918,
0.005725827533751726,
-0.016248192638158798,
-0.003323378972709179,
0.006352068856358528,
-0.0024877991527318954,
0.040884099900722504,
-0.021716827526688576,
0.014137610793113708,
-0.030919626355171204,
0.03633062168955803,
0.0009504941408522427,
0.02356705069541931,
-0.0029619475826621056,
-0.02429959550499916,
-0.036272112280130386,
-0.016176901757717133,
-0.056685060262680054,
-0.05347083508968353,
0.013116073794662952,
0.016584565863013268,
-0.06310867518186569,
-0.02426355704665184,
-0.0068639107048511505,
0.021646905690431595,
-0.0025969583075493574,
0.011072023771703243,
0.03630867972970009,
-0.044421952217817307,
-0.018761789426207542,
-0.13598397374153137,
0.020761214196681976,
-0.016721997410058975,
0.007658382412046194,
-0.062244098633527756,
-0.017716865986585617,
-0.01683070883154869,
0.005158086773008108,
-0.017174270004034042,
-0.03588218241930008,
-0.031684573739767075,
-0.007719692774116993,
0.08564373850822449,
-0.0035534657072275877,
-0.010138945654034615,
0.04010790213942528,
-0.034293293952941895,
-0.030512014403939247,
-0.03788842260837555,
0.005158371292054653,
-0.0028543558437377214,
0.01393349189311266,
0.01093685906380415,
0.0048102340660989285,
-0.018359161913394928,
-0.043246276676654816,
-0.0376347191631794,
-0.019470104947686195,
-0.04046562686562538,
-0.03269211947917938,
-0.01142859272658825,
0.014691171236336231,
0.016410933807492256,
0.040902938693761826,
-0.009017692878842354,
0.018385177478194237,
-0.0024894934613257647,
-0.015411208383738995,
-0.0252356119453907,
-0.02195652201771736,
0.009530563838779926,
0.01169110182672739,
-0.00271320017054677,
-0.001872787601314485,
0.014514821581542492,
0.026726054027676582,
0.02021794021129608,
-0.016806846484541893,
-0.06040395051240921,
-0.05471285060048103,
-0.04526573419570923,
0.008494739420711994,
-0.02465951256453991,
0.05014556646347046,
0.010928953997790813,
-0.001393878017552197,
-0.016909049823880196,
-0.02064618095755577,
-0.015731055289506912,
0.06549089401960373,
0.004137756768614054,
0.006428644992411137,
-0.042299095541238785,
-0.025101343169808388,
0.03770370036363602,
0.017296962440013885,
-0.010819883085787296,
0.0027183061465620995,
-0.024952566251158714,
0.029064781963825226,
0.017020734027028084,
-0.000025060233383555897,
0.007308449596166611,
-0.032542817294597626,
0.0017213433748111129,
-0.011369545944035053,
0.0036079564597457647,
0.0038774588610976934,
-0.016657689586281776,
-0.009092637337744236,
0.013270760886371136,
0.015910621732473373,
-0.015732429921627045,
-0.03428459167480469,
0.03460603952407837,
0.04145636036992073,
-0.007740260101854801,
-0.019627606496214867,
0.051486365497112274,
-0.0697888657450676,
-0.05354306846857071,
0.012318860739469528,
0.0019080317579209805,
0.02302282303571701,
-0.03723251074552536,
0.04004344344139099,
0.03660239279270172,
0.009802487678825855,
-0.024211779236793518,
-0.028962215408682823,
-0.0313396118581295,
-0.07114223390817642,
0.013753361068665981,
0.003497422207146883,
-0.042559605091810226,
0.01503242738544941,
-0.003859098767861724,
0.03931015729904175,
0.0022197572980076075,
0.021783551201224327,
-0.04244563356041908,
-0.029463760554790497,
-0.01610395684838295,
-0.051418524235486984,
-0.04883259907364845,
0.008306137286126614,
0.009310909546911716,
0.023702025413513184,
-0.02193734049797058,
0.026944976300001144,
0.0033539251890033484,
-0.013997877016663551,
0.054447323083877563,
-0.017657656222581863,
-0.024465540423989296,
0.010304692201316357,
0.06267037987709045,
0.0036069240886718035,
0.03136490657925606,
-0.010649007745087147,
0.034673962742090225,
-0.01878884993493557,
-0.008402577601373196,
0.029700307175517082,
-0.002066720277070999,
0.01204451359808445,
-0.03681815043091774,
0.004558165557682514,
-0.01125835720449686,
-0.037908926606178284,
-0.009796983562409878,
0.012759883888065815,
-0.008597874082624912,
-0.009227488189935684,
-0.04413227364420891,
-0.0019334282260388136,
0.006295203231275082,
0.012060634791851044,
-0.025238636881113052,
-0.03218298777937889,
-0.012152536772191525,
-0.006591569632291794,
0.015924153849482536,
0.08175889402627945,
0.022499075159430504,
-0.03364970162510872,
0.023418065160512924,
0.0009591730195097625,
-0.00806252472102642,
0.06287374347448349,
0.04492933675646782,
-0.02723516710102558,
-0.04902961105108261,
-0.016364427283406258,
-0.01845577359199524,
0.03127356618642807,
0.005663455929607153,
0.0008238576119765639,
-0.02695591188967228,
0.0009844560408964753,
0.015976902097463608,
0.012490545399487019,
-0.022486133500933647,
0.027020113542675972,
0.0085825864225626,
-0.05010142922401428,
0.025946639478206635,
0.021707098931074142,
0.051534686237573624,
-0.005132368765771389,
0.03772040829062462,
0.035658713430166245,
0.01967923529446125,
0.021331537514925003,
0.010658723302185535,
0.015115045011043549,
0.0009724018163979053,
0.013062771409749985,
-0.0038523608818650246,
-0.022237049415707588,
-0.011580453254282475,
-0.016561968252062798,
0.004079838283360004,
-0.023136168718338013,
0.04557100683450699,
0.013282307423651218,
-0.017864329740405083,
0.017342183738946915,
0.007816477678716183,
0.017222562804818153,
0.014187836088240147,
-0.016550777480006218,
-0.03662274032831192,
-0.009490564465522766,
-0.012650596909224987,
-0.01793786883354187,
-0.023252641782164574,
-0.03113115020096302,
-0.056258998811244965,
0.026217110455036163,
-0.019553527235984802,
0.004929559770971537,
0.007674767170101404,
0.04068150371313095,
-0.020846018567681313,
-0.01467872317880392,
0.012813394889235497,
-0.02610698901116848,
0.01771824061870575,
-0.009768027812242508,
0.019315792247653008,
0.08932862430810928,
-0.0342705212533474,
-0.043130841106176376,
0.01346179936081171,
0.015640366822481155,
-0.029536213725805283,
0.03889498487114906,
0.02481698989868164,
0.0052195522002875805,
0.014271741732954979,
-0.03862029314041138,
-0.006225505843758583,
0.02545311115682125,
-0.006422663573175669,
0.013455300591886044,
0.08186674863100052,
-0.0201476588845253,
-0.021833378821611404,
-0.025505825877189636,
0.0736175924539566,
-0.002232627710327506,
0.03218436241149902,
-0.0015012947842478752
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:1
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
In the alternative QBE seeks recovery from CGU by invoking the concept of "recoupment" discussed by Rein J in Limit (No 3) Ltd v ACE Insurance Ltd [2009] NSWSC 514 ("Limit v Ace").
BACKGROUND
2On 7 November 2005 Mr Peter Horwood was a driving a forklift along Talc Street Broken Hill. The forklift toppled onto its left side. Mr Horwood suffered significant injuries. His left hand was amputated.
3QBE provided compulsory third party insurance ("CTP") for the forklift in accordance with the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (the "MAC Act"). The forklift was registered in the name of Levira Pty Ltd ("Levira"), a company connected with Megbuy in the manner explained below.
4Mr Horwood was employed by Megbuy. He was driving the forklift in the course of his employment. In accordance with its obligation under s 155(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the "WC Act") Megbuy obtained a policy of insurance from CGU concerning its employees, including Mr Horwood.
5It was admitted on the pleadings that in January 2008 Mr Horwood commenced proceedings in the District Court. A statement of claim bearing the date November 2008 reveals that he sued only Megbuy. He pleaded that Megbuy was both his employer and the "owner" of the vehicle. He asserted that Megbuy's liability to him was governed by the MAC Act.
6QBE assumed the carriage of the proceedings on behalf of Megbuy. In late November 2008 a defence was filed admitting ownership of the forklift but denying liability and alleging contributory negligence on the part of Mr Horwood.
Particulars of the allegation of contributory negligence were provided in July 2009. In November 2009 an amended defence was filed admitting liability. The allegation of contributory negligence remained.
7On 7 December 2009 "Heads of Agreement" were entered into between Mr Horwood, QBE and CGU. It records an agreement to settle the claim for $1,500,000.00 inclusive of costs and agreement on an amount to be repaid to CGU in partial repayment of the workers compensation payments that Mr Horwood had received to that time.
8Consent orders between Mr Horwood and QBE were prepared and signed. They bear the date 8 December 2009. It was admitted on the pleadings that the proceedings were settled on 10 December 2009. I infer that the consent orders were made by the District Court around that date.
Cases do not usually settle without a court making some orders finally disposing of them. The orders provided for a verdict in favour of Mr Horwood for $1,500,000.00. QBE paid that sum shortly afterwards.
9Even though it was a party to the Heads of Agreement, neither in that document nor at any other time did CGU agree to or acquiesce in Megbuy's admission of ownership of the forklift. The admission of ownership of the forklift by Megbuy was not a matter that significantly affected QBE's exposure to a claim from Mr Horwood.
It was the insurer of whatever entity owned the forklift. Presumably Mr Horwood would have sought to join Levira if Megbuy's ownership of the forklift was seriously contested. However whether or not Megbuy was the owner of the forklift was of great significance to CGU. It only insured Megbuy. It did not insure Levira.
SCOPE OF THE POLICIES AND ISSUES IN DISPUTE
10In describing claims for contribution between insurers in the case of double insurance in Albion Kitto J stated (at 352) that: "What attracts the right of contribution between insurers ... is simply the fact that that each contract is a contract of indemnity and covers the identical loss that the identical insured has sustained.
" In AMP Workers Compensation Services (NSW) Ltd v QBE Insurance Ltd [2001] NSWCA 267; (2001) 53 NSWLR 35 ("AMP v QBE"), the Court of Appeal extended the principle's operation to encompass some situations where the two insurers covered the same loss but did not indemnify the "identical insured" but only because of a choice exercised by the injured plaintiff as to which party to sue.
|
[
0.0012259718496352434,
0.017594201490283012,
-0.007484088186174631,
-0.027338998392224312,
0.014031080529093742,
-0.01258890051394701,
-0.00005641577081405558,
0.006902122404426336,
-0.006474980153143406,
0.030711745843291283,
-0.01062723807990551,
0.008543558418750763,
-0.019453464075922966,
-0.008447665721178055,
0.011848474852740765,
-0.039821453392505646,
0.018765335902571678,
-0.013219863176345825,
-0.05425699055194855,
-0.046012286096811295,
0.00852231215685606,
-0.002120181219652295,
0.009142991155385971,
0.05818430334329605,
0.03365056961774826,
0.020013932138681412,
0.008426561951637268,
0.018344849348068237,
0.00982766691595316,
0.007577252574265003,
-0.027643874287605286,
-0.02238319255411625,
-0.011606433428823948,
-0.025933129712939262,
-0.0023893469478935003,
-0.029605964198708534,
0.004390375223010778,
0.025418616831302643,
-0.030298613011837006,
-0.01882934384047985,
-0.015369430184364319,
0.0032779539469629526,
0.0429440476000309,
-0.018652942031621933,
0.022222569212317467,
-0.01567874662578106,
0.0028723229188472033,
-0.0035956597421318293,
0.009825245477259159,
-0.044388361275196075,
-0.0356176421046257,
0.011355164460837841,
0.08111735433340073,
-0.026252951472997665,
0.0018820192199200392,
0.031393878161907196,
-0.019632775336503983,
-0.02188260667026043,
-0.05616484209895134,
-0.02640412002801895,
-0.019581666216254234,
-0.008597217500209808,
-0.021751899272203445,
0.020431194454431534,
0.008087366819381714,
0.11595577001571655,
-0.023453619331121445,
-0.006872411351650953,
-0.015212240628898144,
-0.03907259553670883,
-0.011764838360249996,
0.023048702627420425,
-0.02555234171450138,
0.01806940883398056,
-0.07186178117990494,
0.012778566218912601,
0.040397513657808304,
0.015114138834178448,
0.016047818586230278,
0.02632547728717327,
0.01873098686337471,
0.01062987744808197,
-0.03493703156709671,
0.011096806265413761,
-0.031324490904808044,
-0.019764985889196396,
0.003824771847575903,
-0.004864678718149662,
-0.02840254083275795,
0.006986756809055805,
0.001486013876274228,
-0.001104535534977913,
-0.007533549796789885,
-0.02416338585317135,
0.005794322118163109,
-0.02046228013932705,
-0.05224744603037834,
-0.0028761764988303185,
0.018486935645341873,
0.032865602523088455,
0.022043194621801376,
0.01941448077559471,
0.07279476523399353,
-0.043119579553604126,
0.005806655623018742,
-0.0035354853607714176,
0.04130646213889122,
0.035155247896909714,
0.021623576059937477,
-0.00034337100805714726,
-0.0021328579168766737,
0.020112479105591774,
-0.012761455029249191,
0.02233201451599598,
-0.012815097346901894,
-0.011971601285040379,
0.012002663686871529,
-0.04404996335506439,
0.02873510867357254,
-0.01822427101433277,
0.047667067497968674,
0.04316828027367592,
0.03179461508989334,
-0.008007002994418144,
-0.03987126424908638,
-0.011259079910814762,
0.01769031584262848,
-0.028903428465127945,
0.006681562401354313,
-0.0301214512437582,
-0.0027830416802316904,
0.0068565914407372475,
-0.006591459270566702,
-0.04177607223391533,
-0.06152816861867905,
-0.06535305827856064,
0.037261661142110825,
-0.029237885028123856,
-0.013342109508812428,
-0.06173277646303177,
0.03477726876735687,
0.054371513426303864,
0.009788356721401215,
-0.014884170144796371,
0.005155100952833891,
-0.023452451452612877,
0.030130723491311073,
-0.030531086027622223,
0.033294424414634705,
0.0023664599284529686,
0.010919596999883652,
0.0058789923787117004,
-0.012256077490746975,
-0.05071546882390976,
0.033069755882024765,
-0.011551509611308575,
-0.015259480103850365,
-0.024271713569760323,
0.0000809666162240319,
0.023440692573785782,
-0.005849591922014952,
0.04648410528898239,
-0.03571813926100731,
-0.04768748953938484,
-0.00767406215891242,
-0.0021901805885136127,
0.01085637416690588,
0.047681886702775955,
0.004441644065082073,
-0.0020200368016958237,
0.03567389026284218,
0.025029579177498817,
0.021765906363725662,
-0.01928344927728176,
0.0018536486895754933,
0.037156734615564346,
0.04706896096467972,
-0.0038009292911738157,
0.03226318955421448,
-0.04909130558371544,
-0.021601783111691475,
0.008801547810435295,
0.026780959218740463,
-0.019235972315073013,
0.009417854249477386,
0.033073365688323975,
0.009619224816560745,
-0.021397555246949196,
0.024469904601573944,
0.029409637674689293,
0.012627917341887951,
-0.010545540601015091,
0.014642325229942799,
-0.009068825282156467,
0.026461487635970116,
-0.0023123756982386112,
0.01825827918946743,
-0.02462722547352314,
0.028844354674220085,
-0.04137026518583298,
-0.060400377959012985,
0.012055925093591213,
0.0640675351023674,
-0.026847461238503456,
-0.03646222874522209,
0.005353783257305622,
-0.05043890327215195,
0.06641437858343124,
0.01090945117175579,
-0.05759627744555473,
0.011367127299308777,
-0.016353074461221695,
0.036011163145303726,
0.06737005710601807,
-0.03968495875597,
-0.019137896597385406,
0.03202873095870018,
0.007792700082063675,
0.033525802195072174,
0.033364370465278625,
-0.053001485764980316,
-0.009012121707201004,
-0.011528980918228626,
-0.005497130099684,
0.04378135874867439,
0.012570669874548912,
0.002132902853190899,
0.0754113644361496,
-0.00022220105165615678,
-0.04208976775407791,
0.020013215020298958,
0.008402643725275993,
0.01615358516573906,
-0.06600533425807953,
0.06351031363010406,
0.049652643501758575,
0.04292120411992073,
0.010457565076649189,
0.04205987602472305,
0.017975714057683945,
0.005611170548945665,
-0.026914948597550392,
0.03127341344952583,
-0.025795718654990196,
0.004987312946468592,
-0.012041205540299416,
0.004147595725953579,
0.042970385402441025,
0.030060160905122757,
-0.010568705387413502,
-0.00973212718963623,
-0.027579860761761665,
-0.03374788165092468,
-0.004862681496888399,
-0.014951623976230621,
0.049858640879392624,
0.01146728452295065,
-0.02211696095764637,
0.030116409063339233,
-0.00046756453230045736,
0.00001299186533287866,
0.025938786566257477,
0.03548721969127655,
-0.009111338295042515,
-0.039762187749147415,
0.0013375944690778852,
-0.021584725007414818,
-0.020391590893268585,
-0.021190432831645012,
0.008060953579843044,
-0.0002976188261527568,
0.014352229423820972,
-0.007984190247952938,
-0.0040653180330991745,
0.03736039996147156,
0.020801447331905365,
0.01646655984222889,
-0.055263034999370575,
-0.007094255648553371,
-0.0035440362989902496,
0.06269077956676483,
0.021064331755042076,
0.020077642053365707,
-0.0292481929063797,
0.00817383173853159,
0.002219187328591943,
-0.012648110277950764,
-0.04980837181210518,
-0.05005199834704399,
-0.05842329561710358,
0.0239803995937109,
-0.020835131406784058,
0.0547177828848362,
-0.00013254591613076627,
-0.039443496614694595,
0.04933454096317291,
0.03240963816642761,
-0.14892102777957916,
-0.0103805186226964,
0.010782216675579548,
0.02150476910173893,
-0.004181659314781427,
0.023478571325540543,
0.003095452208071947,
0.02602005936205387,
0.0043393829837441444,
0.018045639619231224,
-0.01618233695626259,
-0.059449486434459686,
-0.007755143567919731,
0.03654400631785393,
0.023316092789173126,
-0.022980835288763046,
-0.013610362075269222,
-0.014912685379385948,
0.03629153221845627,
-0.033530738204717636,
-0.034229692071676254,
-0.022881118580698967,
0.012111769989132881,
-0.019571278244256973,
0.04260221868753433,
-0.013093245215713978,
0.027585329487919807,
-0.031919654458761215,
-0.0251021571457386,
-0.02250387892127037,
-0.05303710326552391,
-0.024101365357637405,
-0.009359946474432945,
0.03290846198797226,
0.028808144852519035,
0.012457274831831455,
0.017391400411725044,
-0.060663022100925446,
-0.028871120885014534,
-0.003409833647310734,
0.04023901745676994,
0.08187808841466904,
0.012001477181911469,
-0.00403464725241065,
0.014584772288799286,
-0.05851389840245247,
0.01905117556452751,
0.007847934029996395,
-0.06997079402208328,
0.04490668326616287,
-0.035034794360399246,
-0.007220037747174501,
-0.015304012224078178,
0.01790076494216919,
0.01561737060546875,
-0.009605664759874344,
0.06524322926998138,
0.04189477115869522,
-0.0091862166300416,
0.037769969552755356,
-0.01078240480273962,
-0.03119489550590515,
0.0326334685087204,
0.02743310108780861,
-0.047595225274562836,
0.01411309652030468,
0.0073419660329818726,
0.011428110301494598,
0.021227871999144554,
-0.012429033406078815,
-0.00978099275380373,
-0.04370517283678055,
0.033005278557538986,
-0.015624906867742538,
-0.006856998894363642,
0.026899440214037895,
0.009706360287964344,
-0.016854403540492058,
0.012936165556311607,
-0.09773202240467072,
0.014528796076774597,
0.015014196746051311,
-0.003920904826372862,
0.026838745921850204,
-0.0006318793748505414,
0.02457866258919239,
0.006435320246964693,
0.029376491904258728,
0.0545097179710865,
0.2324165403842926,
0.0035588310565799475,
-0.016506867483258247,
0.008588479831814766,
-0.007365497760474682,
-0.007916809059679508,
0.026349743828177452,
0.01988060772418976,
0.02819191850721836,
-0.026012543588876724,
-0.007450254168361425,
0.011987721547484398,
0.015767550095915794,
0.028926236554980278,
-0.008613483980298042,
-0.02906625159084797,
-0.04847816377878189,
-0.03160668909549713,
0.060820072889328,
-0.019077645614743233,
0.029400091618299484,
0.008066692389547825,
0.0180562324821949,
0.008705249056220055,
-0.058626092970371246,
-0.05528951436281204,
0.016126837581396103,
0.03867883235216141,
0.0018044153694063425,
0.031938228756189346,
-0.01801271177828312,
-0.0215411726385355,
0.004425210412591696,
0.014463970437645912,
-0.021998105570673943,
-0.009720183908939362,
-0.03172779828310013,
-0.002136093797162175,
-0.0053374855779111385,
0.04251934587955475,
0.044903382658958435,
-0.03178592026233673,
-0.011448776349425316,
0.010827405378222466,
0.02329913154244423,
-0.017473220825195312,
0.002067292109131813,
0.03143441304564476,
0.0008974375086836517,
0.03210145980119705,
-0.059290990233421326,
0.004321563523262739,
-0.024487940594553947,
0.004268565680831671,
-0.03077293001115322,
0.02505241334438324,
-0.011852631345391273,
0.009266907349228859,
-0.006114691961556673,
-0.0026582160498946905,
-0.004621382802724838,
0.012713064439594746,
-0.05944880098104477,
0.018096430227160454,
-0.013229514472186565,
-0.008582389913499355,
-0.02666795253753662,
0.048469673842191696,
0.0562685951590538,
0.014464952982962132,
0.01326112449169159,
0.03342023864388466,
0.043631698936223984,
0.038574669510126114,
0.055471617728471756,
0.03679327294230461,
0.020703939720988274,
0.03008214756846428,
-0.040019553154706955,
-0.02040718123316765,
-0.006143265403807163,
-0.02090446837246418,
0.024298999458551407,
-0.015675680711865425,
-0.005275467410683632,
-0.035174574702978134,
-0.03910335525870323,
0.05981238931417465,
0.04581232741475105,
-0.04823191091418266,
-0.036542218178510666,
-0.023272931575775146,
-0.01451121736317873,
0.043215882033109665,
-0.03859448805451393,
0.005159253254532814,
0.04347732663154602,
0.005767784547060728,
-0.005290652625262737,
-0.035143375396728516,
-0.04048113152384758,
0.009945159777998924,
-0.01924104243516922,
-0.01545351929962635,
-0.031263671815395355,
-0.0429871641099453,
0.019445735961198807,
-0.008480893447995186,
-0.07793636620044708,
0.003723138477653265,
0.03981959447264671,
0.02696964144706726,
-0.031082507222890854,
0.00539607647806406,
0.011032940819859505,
0.022109316661953926,
-0.012454838491976261,
0.03804498910903931,
0.031783346086740494,
0.020423084497451782,
-0.03396961838006973,
0.0020067032892256975,
-0.049902547150850296,
0.04558538645505905,
-0.000757690635509789,
-0.015273191966116428,
-0.038325365632772446,
-0.03387818485498428,
-0.028726927936077118,
0.025457406416535378,
-0.034431423991918564,
0.011819127015769482,
0.0008307170355692506,
-0.018557799980044365,
0.039734721183776855,
-0.020696988329291344,
-0.019650297239422798,
0.039345353841781616,
-0.014199994504451752,
-0.01400751993060112,
-0.03057785890996456,
0.0046927910298109055,
-0.056894700974226,
-0.0351937972009182,
0.021208686754107475,
-0.03879665210843086,
-0.002997086849063635,
0.027418339625000954,
-0.05967145785689354,
-0.024861617013812065,
-0.006321645341813564,
0.03799641877412796,
-0.03587261214852333,
0.0086853988468647,
-0.02168123796582222,
0.014492069371044636,
0.021606646478176117,
-0.030059799551963806,
0.019213497638702393,
-0.049349091947078705,
-0.017459606751799583,
-0.029300179332494736,
0.008951880969107151,
0.055541373789310455,
0.001351995044387877,
0.04014967009425163,
-0.01059697475284338,
0.05489092320203781,
0.05976981669664383,
0.00017861241940408945,
-0.03579657897353172,
-0.048702649772167206,
0.0008841966628096998,
0.06404832005500793,
0.04790518060326576,
0.059772953391075134,
-0.007176022045314312,
-0.014267346821725368,
0.02080664038658142,
-0.033883899450302124,
-0.015453822910785675,
0.015431517735123634,
-0.05130106583237648,
0.004256351850926876,
0.015977054834365845,
-0.005678742658346891,
0.021209893748164177,
-0.0397830493748188,
0.00859608594328165,
0.0006682384409941733,
-0.01905440166592598,
0.11032001674175262,
-0.005142146721482277,
-0.013020453043282032,
0.004363730549812317,
0.02752869576215744,
-0.020962165668606758,
-0.005052016582340002,
0.0019446753431111574,
-0.0374116450548172,
-0.0355495810508728,
0.02460862323641777,
0.015527637675404549,
-0.02542218565940857,
0.052865784615278244,
-0.02378641441464424,
-0.010711777955293655,
-0.0027477273251861334,
-0.029221609234809875,
0.013190614990890026,
0.025917980819940567,
0.01415333990007639,
-0.032390885055065155,
0.006673880852758884,
0.019073612987995148,
0.012423370964825153,
0.017974724993109703,
0.06526386737823486,
-0.04164259135723114,
-0.05167070031166077,
-0.04904097318649292,
-0.00046526273945346475,
0.057547640055418015,
-0.07720961421728134,
0.006473081652075052,
0.025740735232830048,
-0.013197166845202446,
-0.034686148166656494,
0.01692638359963894,
-0.006250903941690922,
0.013369262218475342,
-0.03026721440255642,
0.0003268345317337662,
-0.025020286440849304,
-0.003174911020323634,
0.02269601635634899,
0.024100175127387047,
0.01596967875957489,
0.011484863236546516,
-0.01573658548295498,
0.022709669545292854,
-0.005391869693994522,
-0.015663154423236847,
0.07685448229312897,
0.0033163458574563265,
0.008263627998530865,
-0.010982613079249859,
-0.01053477730602026,
0.03849560767412186,
-0.0017167342593893409,
-0.008293818682432175,
0.031178446486592293,
0.039430540055036545,
-0.06037318706512451,
0.02550118789076805,
-0.019501348957419395,
-0.000728766608517617,
0.006833298597484827,
-0.03204459697008133,
-0.037926219403743744,
-0.009032473899424076,
0.02713409624993801,
0.01302267424762249,
-0.059324536472558975,
0.035696838051080704,
-0.053325045853853226,
0.03585880249738693,
-0.03057626634836197,
-0.018593627959489822,
-0.013058322481811047,
0.00500533590093255,
-0.0031709957402199507,
-0.05302177742123604,
-0.045436955988407135,
-0.02384607307612896,
0.018466558307409286,
-0.03638927638530731,
-0.0043844315223395824,
0.05615058168768883,
-0.03471991419792175,
0.03567449748516083,
-0.023703617975115776,
-0.00191014027222991,
0.04665499925613403,
-0.002319842344149947,
0.021307064220309258,
0.06022470071911812,
0.010699116624891758,
-0.03200756758451462,
-0.015024281106889248,
0.010048311203718185,
0.002461939351633191,
-0.013344989158213139,
-0.0012047963682562113,
-0.031168870627880096,
-0.02067263424396515,
-0.0027392569463700056,
0.0824318677186966,
-0.05391407385468483,
-0.01819799467921257,
-0.019405055791139603,
-0.0053669000044465065,
-0.03945256397128105,
-0.0496087446808815,
-0.004652000032365322,
0.0025592162273824215,
0.016948264092206955,
-0.04877613112330437,
-0.020458534359931946,
0.007496930658817291,
-0.004145742394030094,
-0.034589484333992004,
-0.016582205891609192,
-0.028510674834251404,
-0.03322013467550278,
0.01828332245349884,
0.003973226062953472,
-0.047273170202970505,
-0.011642156168818474,
-0.002822814742103219,
0.031124724075198174,
0.020948447287082672,
-0.039112817496061325,
-0.008056117221713066,
-0.04029624164104462,
0.009662316180765629,
0.004354571457952261,
0.006259694695472717,
-0.016002701595425606,
-0.00538783660158515,
-0.011438373476266861,
-0.015736902132630348,
-0.001826537074521184,
0.015276525169610977,
0.07845063507556915,
0.03133772313594818,
-0.015981551259756088,
-0.02433355525135994,
0.008221597410738468,
-0.02683117613196373,
-0.02976592630147934,
-0.06838978826999664,
0.0587909035384655,
-0.001456216792576015,
0.01004024501889944,
0.03944255784153938,
-0.0033700105268508196,
0.01648152619600296,
0.008888808079063892,
0.030073128640651703,
-0.0000579290026507806,
0.007036249153316021,
-0.030990317463874817,
-0.0245326217263937,
0.009376385249197483,
-0.004342995584011078,
0.02497112937271595,
0.012251756154000759,
0.015175831504166126,
0.0016034087166190147,
-0.018712887540459633,
0.01609264500439167,
-0.0019857522565871477,
-0.01706554740667343,
0.012824286706745625,
0.01894279196858406,
0.0030601248145103455,
0.03228107839822769,
-0.0052025108598172665,
-0.03965151682496071,
-0.006808902602642775,
-0.03609270974993706,
0.03278416767716408,
-0.007354389410465956,
-0.00905732624232769,
-0.0025616916827857494,
0.010820089839398861,
-0.009862683713436127,
-0.01271322276443243,
-0.03705647587776184,
-0.020897483453154564,
-0.03303392603993416,
-0.039475541561841965,
0.0017442589160054922,
0.01622871123254299,
0.048945311456918716,
-0.011189530603587627,
0.023660549893975258,
-0.048707012087106705,
0.02161264233291149,
-0.01253474596887827,
0.03151010721921921,
-0.030150774866342545,
0.02831103652715683,
-0.13148310780525208,
-0.017879102379083633,
-0.009289453737437725,
0.026867730543017387,
-0.08119871467351913,
0.008349588140845299,
-0.034784287214279175,
0.029139449819922447,
0.00674255657941103,
-0.01055466290563345,
-0.03062504157423973,
-0.017252836376428604,
0.06078435853123665,
0.011557348072528839,
-0.0009974372806027532,
0.023401569575071335,
-0.029858317226171494,
-0.04219590872526169,
-0.04317222908139229,
0.05202193930745125,
0.016249047592282295,
0.0067725758999586105,
-0.0018095625564455986,
-0.02121843956410885,
-0.019612012431025505,
0.010117138735949993,
-0.06753844022750854,
-0.023766204714775085,
-0.04123498499393463,
0.030721912160515785,
-0.0534241646528244,
-0.06315278261899948,
0.014731677249073982,
0.03603381663560867,
0.00905541330575943,
0.010281031019985676,
0.005630434025079012,
-0.010258030146360397,
-0.03121313266456127,
-0.05465548112988472,
-0.019850747659802437,
0.030203282833099365,
-0.023895390331745148,
-0.01800617389380932,
0.006841961294412613,
0.002313717268407345,
-0.0022253396455198526,
0.01577460579574108,
-0.007671847939491272,
-0.029194029048085213,
-0.029488010331988335,
-0.009753947146236897,
0.008805908262729645,
0.0018174198921769857,
0.0450376532971859,
0.025124188512563705,
-0.015313373878598213,
-0.021527448669075966,
-0.00865147728472948,
0.07265891879796982,
-0.018693165853619576,
-0.00010514221503399312,
-0.02653372287750244,
-0.01652763970196247,
0.05852286145091057,
-0.0010392771800979972,
0.024052882567048073,
0.017650801688432693,
0.01899557001888752,
0.003955178428441286,
0.030307341367006302,
-0.05368523299694061,
0.03573397547006607,
-0.027096407487988472,
-0.006596132647246122,
-0.008134554140269756,
-0.004696523770689964,
-0.003733862191438675,
-0.008883231319487095,
-0.0055108037777245045,
-0.009368523955345154,
-0.018613198772072792,
-0.032315172255039215,
0.008657863363623619,
0.04890677332878113,
0.018670689314603806,
-0.019788308069109917,
-0.030095288529992104,
0.06387980282306671,
-0.032587915658950806,
-0.05687378719449043,
-0.0003840540593955666,
-0.025197265669703484,
0.0043929461389780045,
-0.010608694516122341,
0.052379708737134933,
0.0021991918329149485,
-0.014450532384216785,
-0.017153380438685417,
-0.02636313997209072,
-0.04636058211326599,
-0.00807253923267126,
0.012922760099172592,
-0.011894676834344864,
-0.029826980084180832,
0.046964168548583984,
-0.01439981535077095,
-0.007709126453846693,
-0.017176764085888863,
-0.021222727373242378,
-0.035630352795124054,
-0.04260072112083435,
-0.009390692226588726,
0.002288537798449397,
-0.026739580556750298,
0.021166499704122543,
-0.0010944083333015442,
0.02459760382771492,
-0.024793466553092003,
0.05358710139989853,
0.03449046239256859,
-0.045422449707984924,
0.010013788007199764,
-0.01710336282849312,
0.022573120892047882,
0.019869016483426094,
0.03936335816979408,
0.017090870067477226,
0.03786630928516388,
0.004545167088508606,
0.0413663387298584,
-0.025288844481110573,
-0.029236216098070145,
0.0059536718763411045,
-0.005784415639936924,
0.016738658770918846,
-0.017461344599723816,
0.010976231656968594,
0.008532007224857807,
-0.05780922248959541,
0.010394314303994179,
-0.027267200872302055,
-0.024372026324272156,
-0.001288635190576315,
-0.047084782272577286,
-0.03571971505880356,
0.015668123960494995,
-0.013285443186759949,
-0.025446657091379166,
-0.042990900576114655,
-0.026233606040477753,
0.01199037954211235,
-0.012149273417890072,
0.09315775334835052,
0.004309714771807194,
-0.045309096574783325,
0.040406741201877594,
0.0021715660113841295,
-0.011719350703060627,
0.03943542763590813,
0.036145880818367004,
-0.020408596843481064,
-0.030222665518522263,
-0.01170502882450819,
-0.03157616779208183,
0.03011249378323555,
-0.03459326922893524,
-0.006122983526438475,
-0.014348804950714111,
0.013995817862451077,
-0.013556016609072685,
0.0007602351834066212,
-0.04327446594834328,
0.005936809815466404,
0.053171977400779724,
-0.01899104379117489,
-0.028430012986063957,
0.005810323171317577,
0.07580229640007019,
-0.021574566140770912,
0.04406141862273216,
0.0654132217168808,
0.013065331615507603,
0.02104470692574978,
-0.0089385025203228,
0.007438024040311575,
-0.008631624281406403,
-0.01181624736636877,
-0.03263318911194801,
-0.024670368060469627,
0.03168328106403351,
0.016245733946561813,
-0.004731400869786739,
-0.027626706287264824,
0.04825032502412796,
0.012457339093089104,
-0.018878767266869545,
0.012360206805169582,
-0.007708217483013868,
0.048688050359487534,
-0.008438460528850555,
-0.013007214292883873,
-0.011540141887962818,
-0.02481713518500328,
-0.02887532487511635,
0.0020109720062464476,
0.01801450550556183,
-0.02984130010008812,
-0.002814916195347905,
0.029301641508936882,
-0.010402780957520008,
-0.001441709348000586,
-0.022244824096560478,
0.048495106399059296,
-0.0002136765542672947,
0.031502626836299896,
-0.008012443780899048,
-0.03293780982494354,
0.010188993997871876,
-0.015033225528895855,
0.0115829361602664,
0.051324572414159775,
-0.028551358729600906,
-0.02668251469731331,
0.027658769860863686,
0.016565972939133644,
0.004184854682534933,
-0.027627553790807724,
0.044811416417360306,
-0.022369135171175003,
0.01226486824452877,
-0.014272580854594707,
-0.011554756201803684,
0.014013081789016724,
0.036591555923223495,
-0.055386364459991455,
-0.021002359688282013,
-0.05241762846708298,
-0.02802574262022972,
-0.03803223371505737,
0.03647663816809654,
0.01267036609351635,
0.03412811830639839,
0.013099170289933681
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:28
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
(iii)The combination of my findings as to ownership of the forklift by Megbuy and the liability of Megbuy meant that the definition of "injury" in s 3 of the MAC Act was satisfied ([131]).
133It follows that QBE has established an entitlement to recover contribution from CGU. Each contract of insurance was a contract of indemnity. It covered the identical "loss" (ie liability to Mr Horwood) that the "identical insured" (ie Megbuy) sustained.
134Subject to considering the claim for recoupment, it was not disputed that the appropriate apportionment of the settlement sum paid to Mr Horwood and CGU's costs of defending his proceedings would be 50% each. This follows from the statement of Kitto J in Albion at 350 that the burden is shared "pro rata".
Interest would also need to be added. Also, as I understand the position, a credit of $100,000 in favour of CGU would need to be allowed as provided for in clause 11 of the Heads of Agreement. I will direct the parties to confer as to the appropriate sum to be calculated and bring in appropriate forms of orders including as to costs.
RECOUPMENT
135In Limit (No 3) v ACE Insurance Ltd [2009] NSWSC 514 ("Limit v ACE"), the plaintiff was an excess of loss insurer to a joint venture. It became obliged to indemnify the joint venture only because the primary insurer, ACE, wrongly refused to meets it obligations to the joint venture.
The payments made by the plaintiff removed a burden otherwise imposed upon ACE (at [280] to [281]). Thus it was not a case involving "double insurance" in the sense discussed in Albion in that the insurers "were not jointly liable at the time of casualty" (at [286]). Rein J held that this propelled the claim "into one more akin to recoupment" (at [286]).
His Honour described the elements of a claim for recoupment as being firstly that the party seeking recovery was "compelled, or was compellable, by law to make the payment", secondly that the party "did not officiously expose himself to the liability to make the payment" and thirdly that "his payment discharged a liability" of the party from whom recovery was sought (at [289]).
His Honour cited Goff and Jones, The Law of Restitution (6th ed), Sweet & Maxwell at para 15.001 in support of that description and then reviewed a number of cases (at [292] to [315]) before concluding at ([316]) that it was "just and equitable to order recoupment of any liability of which ACE was relieved by Lloyd's payment".
136QBE's claim in recoupment was said by it to only arise in the event that its double insurance claim failed. In that event it claimed that it was entitled to recoup the entirety of the payment that was made to Mr Horwood. As the double insurance claim has succeeded it does not arise.
Further, given that I have found that both QBE and CGU fully insured Megbuy for the same loss, then any application of a principle of "recoupment" could not lead to any different result that an apportionment pro rata that arises on a contribution claim (see Albion at 350 per Kitto J). However in deference to some of the arguments I make two observations about the recoupment claim.
137First, if QBE had failed on its double insurance claim then that would have been either as a result of Megbuy not having been found to be the owner of the forklift or Mr Horwood's claim not having fallen with the definition of "injury" in s 3 of the MAC Act.
In either case it would have meant that QBE's obligation under the CTP policy created by s 10 of the MAC Act did not respond to the claim against Megbuy.
Subject to one matter discussed next and despite various submissions made by QBE to the contrary, that would have lead to the result that, unlike the plaintiff in Limit v ACE, QBE had not made a payment that it was "compelled, or was compellable, by law to make".
The duties imposed by ss 80 to 82 of the MAC Act do not impose any duty upon QBE to make a payment or offer of settlement in respect of a liability that is not covered by the CTP policy.
|
[
0.03514665365219116,
0.0027588035445660353,
-0.011474303901195526,
-0.02789790742099285,
0.022314608097076416,
-0.023891471326351166,
0.028225570917129517,
0.023373905569314957,
-0.01580510288476944,
0.0292530357837677,
-0.0037378096021711826,
0.003041973104700446,
-0.03851062059402466,
0.01837407611310482,
-0.015332570299506187,
-0.042137082666158676,
0.015935149043798447,
-0.017143167555332184,
-0.04849819093942642,
-0.037932731211185455,
0.002928755711764097,
0.016404952853918076,
0.008053770288825035,
0.03353343531489372,
0.021395327523350716,
0.020943861454725266,
-0.017777983099222183,
0.024178441613912582,
0.0030611427500844,
-0.0062321946024894714,
-0.010428751818835735,
0.00483871903270483,
0.001913074986077845,
-0.012211237102746964,
-0.0013631365727633238,
-0.027445180341601372,
-0.03697342053055763,
0.04213361442089081,
-0.016293667256832123,
0.004829978104680777,
-0.02413211576640606,
0.0009664219687692821,
0.016241174191236496,
-0.029354222118854523,
0.042083777487277985,
-0.022378521040081978,
-0.0046165683306753635,
-0.019363967701792717,
-0.0023710778914391994,
-0.013445182703435421,
-0.07113999873399734,
-0.001729995128698647,
0.06830014288425446,
-0.022082261741161346,
-0.0019304387969896197,
0.016831381246447563,
-0.014983214437961578,
-0.011685889214277267,
-0.05104130879044533,
-0.03252159431576729,
-0.03209332749247551,
-0.03035082295536995,
-0.03792937099933624,
0.02525935508310795,
0.005965352989733219,
0.09730807691812515,
-0.02401900105178356,
0.010284543968737125,
-0.009602094069123268,
-0.02562827244400978,
-0.007349837571382523,
0.0003813794464804232,
-0.03549554571509361,
-0.008563125506043434,
-0.0728885754942894,
0.009725064970552921,
0.017228038981556892,
0.025271199643611908,
0.021343359723687172,
0.012659333646297455,
0.015557801350951195,
-0.008540613576769829,
-0.01649569906294346,
0.027856096625328064,
-0.05349214747548103,
-0.010655646212399006,
0.007133252453058958,
-0.006243595387786627,
-0.01643923483788967,
-0.017132505774497986,
0.005087194498628378,
0.008588396944105625,
0.020877230912446976,
-0.022678226232528687,
0.0260488148778677,
-0.0011698694434016943,
-0.04309939220547676,
0.008075492456555367,
0.022317305207252502,
0.0007075453759171069,
0.011520905420184135,
0.004985959269106388,
0.06425148248672485,
-0.03317336365580559,
-0.003981107845902443,
0.006838445086032152,
0.024170489981770515,
0.04059508442878723,
0.01873152330517769,
-0.0033108305651694536,
-0.0089194905012846,
0.03988860547542572,
-0.03707277029752731,
0.022682836279273033,
-0.018125779926776886,
-0.005922962911427021,
0.014526676386594772,
-0.01808292046189308,
0.025601886212825775,
0.003604189259931445,
0.0416780486702919,
0.032468702644109726,
0.02961605228483677,
-0.004049618728458881,
-0.04766780138015747,
-0.01099513191729784,
0.0018389333272352815,
-0.003483976935967803,
-0.01003881823271513,
-0.030763285234570503,
0.014505543746054173,
0.009960254654288292,
-0.030889492481946945,
-0.039466582238674164,
-0.0402354933321476,
-0.05431365221738815,
0.06715148687362671,
0.0055372873321175575,
-0.03781011328101158,
-0.05543715879321098,
0.04979519173502922,
0.041671860963106155,
0.025750458240509033,
-0.006409869529306889,
0.019171899184584618,
-0.012575329281389713,
0.028803927823901176,
-0.030217550694942474,
0.01870114915072918,
-0.016175048425793648,
0.00577563839033246,
0.025597214698791504,
-0.0027400178369134665,
-0.05491587147116661,
0.04533016309142113,
-0.03910142183303833,
0.004223069176077843,
-0.010219947434961796,
0.009397156536579132,
0.040939245373010635,
-0.02564028464257717,
0.060647621750831604,
-0.03151506185531616,
-0.03933310508728027,
-0.018440796062350273,
-0.016265586018562317,
-0.011738328263163567,
0.03300069645047188,
-0.01455212477594614,
-0.009779809042811394,
0.04847178980708122,
0.010937988758087158,
0.010675809346139431,
-0.02139827236533165,
0.024157492443919182,
0.028147345408797264,
0.04933716729283333,
0.0061137499287724495,
0.011048588901758194,
-0.051973626017570496,
-0.018890684470534325,
0.003318530274555087,
0.01563018001616001,
-0.015641789883375168,
0.008928648196160793,
0.05137233808636665,
0.007093584630638361,
-0.0177154578268528,
0.025530826300382614,
0.03498523309826851,
-0.0045244647189974785,
-0.012550835497677326,
0.015268734656274319,
-0.02451133541762829,
0.0038372590206563473,
-0.035080865025520325,
0.025848550722002983,
-0.0072103505954146385,
0.03665165603160858,
-0.015255178324878216,
-0.03302328288555145,
-0.007526864763349295,
0.06729044020175934,
-0.026933232322335243,
-0.037203945219516754,
-0.009604759514331818,
-0.0718386322259903,
0.03078596666455269,
0.0071359495632350445,
-0.059854887425899506,
0.015893572941422462,
-0.019093841314315796,
0.049186255782842636,
0.05012794956564903,
-0.05166485160589218,
-0.03240899369120598,
0.038552213460206985,
0.008391222916543484,
0.04586447775363922,
0.023811737075448036,
-0.03488962724804878,
-0.025026794523000717,
0.01492745615541935,
0.031415220350027084,
0.0370335690677166,
0.03158808872103691,
-0.028712205588817596,
0.053779713809490204,
0.022798461839556694,
-0.05105161666870117,
0.008489697240293026,
0.022533975541591644,
0.0037312351632863283,
-0.03115878440439701,
0.04585811495780945,
0.012264690361917019,
0.05817075073719025,
0.023015335202217102,
0.023375125601887703,
0.003155854530632496,
-0.0009896449046209455,
-0.014716223813593388,
0.04256153106689453,
-0.025512391701340675,
-0.03227631375193596,
-0.018373295664787292,
-0.027291784062981606,
0.04253365099430084,
0.019257068634033203,
-0.005548113025724888,
-0.00862049125134945,
-0.05486669763922691,
-0.04668562859296799,
-0.008293857797980309,
0.003420855151489377,
0.04070903733372688,
-0.003796529257670045,
0.00039494154043495655,
0.05478794500231743,
-0.015555085614323616,
0.021317820996046066,
0.009480462409555912,
0.03322077915072441,
-0.006399963516741991,
-0.045765142887830734,
-0.032082341611385345,
-0.05190713703632355,
-0.020059995353221893,
-0.03959454223513603,
0.012950235046446323,
0.004670046269893646,
0.0049414318054914474,
-0.007676643785089254,
-0.002527943579480052,
0.05259029194712639,
0.047366175800561905,
0.034471772611141205,
-0.030593672767281532,
0.010583505034446716,
-0.02636874094605446,
0.04411502555012703,
0.041370369493961334,
0.006525758188217878,
-0.06602348387241364,
0.03400258719921112,
0.019781725481152534,
0.008787366561591625,
-0.06549721956253052,
-0.01368008740246296,
-0.06659898906946182,
0.021110285073518753,
-0.026231084018945694,
0.07254727184772491,
-0.009145356714725494,
-0.06430766731500626,
0.004576350562274456,
0.02896999567747116,
-0.14575418829917908,
-0.024101346731185913,
0.029244327917695045,
0.00179486651904881,
-0.0006244595861062407,
0.025978263467550278,
-0.008382756263017654,
0.010701335035264492,
0.024652814492583275,
0.030581500381231308,
-0.013362772762775421,
-0.0731482282280922,
-0.001976021798327565,
0.027039626613259315,
0.03750522434711456,
-0.031424131244421005,
-0.03199227899312973,
-0.0010813107946887612,
0.020181214436888695,
-0.015791036188602448,
-0.033763132989406586,
-0.019003180786967278,
-0.017624037340283394,
0.004127089399844408,
0.0016645606374368072,
0.016704261302947998,
0.009927038103342056,
-0.017332326620817184,
-0.039102230221033096,
-0.009564287029206753,
-0.08079218119382858,
-0.014208989217877388,
-0.01928175985813141,
0.021949782967567444,
0.019049959257245064,
0.011335533112287521,
0.04888111725449562,
-0.051221445202827454,
0.006898582447320223,
-0.0057236491702497005,
0.051863718777894974,
0.07949776947498322,
-0.020232221111655235,
0.008855795487761497,
-0.0065672434866428375,
-0.04790997877717018,
0.01355254277586937,
0.011605407111346722,
-0.05641307309269905,
0.027582526206970215,
-0.03160608187317848,
-0.008847272954881191,
-0.04028195142745972,
0.016547517850995064,
-0.004285942297428846,
0.007284080609679222,
0.05809773504734039,
0.031024429947137833,
-0.00016784058243501931,
0.05864117667078972,
-0.024026693776249886,
-0.039304088801145554,
0.03774143382906914,
0.039369914680719376,
-0.05571199581027031,
0.015623523853719234,
0.012432455085217953,
-0.014344176277518272,
0.03379356116056442,
-0.031162725761532784,
-0.010650989599525928,
-0.03490668535232544,
0.024965550750494003,
-0.012465723790228367,
-0.030867069959640503,
0.008273615501821041,
0.0012449690839275718,
-0.01647699438035488,
0.0030203312635421753,
-0.08622889220714569,
0.01493592094630003,
0.0018619803013280034,
0.004463901277631521,
0.027332274243235588,
0.0035577714443206787,
0.007055398542433977,
0.005726051051169634,
0.00735060079023242,
0.026842858642339706,
0.24264849722385406,
0.0023296114522963762,
-0.011378699913620949,
0.014330418780446053,
0.020304590463638306,
0.00859168078750372,
0.019122561439871788,
0.02787732146680355,
0.020354807376861572,
-0.013426808640360832,
-0.03781262785196304,
0.013114521279931068,
0.026167238131165504,
0.02535664476454258,
-0.026528622955083847,
-0.048976726830005646,
-0.04621007293462753,
-0.02704753540456295,
0.08029042184352875,
-0.005651906598359346,
0.027361439540982246,
-0.0173153318464756,
0.009109653532505035,
0.019496483728289604,
-0.07921997457742691,
-0.05924571305513382,
0.02502337656915188,
0.03171160817146301,
0.012450302951037884,
0.02026396431028843,
-0.03042576275765896,
-0.025566361844539642,
0.014169415459036827,
0.025997057557106018,
-0.007875300012528896,
-0.004366069566458464,
-0.03651455417275429,
0.004644276574254036,
-0.01387572381645441,
0.027955221012234688,
0.041904181241989136,
-0.014299806207418442,
-0.029511140659451485,
0.0008867136784829199,
0.010888641700148582,
0.0003702921967487782,
-0.002953916322439909,
0.030535442754626274,
-0.0015727857826277614,
0.03520800918340683,
-0.06598641723394394,
0.024391986429691315,
-0.013351120054721832,
0.019749809056520462,
-0.030081139877438545,
0.045518066734075546,
-0.009873083792626858,
0.029146134853363037,
-0.0270212534815073,
-0.02523508109152317,
0.02261962927877903,
0.014043966308236122,
-0.029821520671248436,
0.013494802638888359,
0.0048728203400969505,
-0.012558696791529655,
-0.05714697390794754,
0.023451045155525208,
0.057478535920381546,
0.002950652502477169,
0.0038597609382122755,
0.047093022614717484,
0.0059771123342216015,
0.039307400584220886,
0.044613562524318695,
0.034087516367435455,
0.0473005473613739,
0.02310153841972351,
-0.04168495163321495,
-0.06076584756374359,
-0.049313973635435104,
-0.037767380475997925,
0.011273953132331371,
-0.03437495604157448,
0.005448860581964254,
-0.024517185986042023,
-0.034281209111213684,
0.04724321514368057,
0.0482349693775177,
-0.060842275619506836,
-0.03700293228030205,
-0.02866106852889061,
0.0043336208909749985,
0.01885826513171196,
-0.008950716815888882,
0.013400743715465069,
0.0344303697347641,
-0.013635135255753994,
-0.0278055127710104,
-0.040029026567935944,
-0.026630360633134842,
0.0004522644157987088,
0.0057032182812690735,
-0.002459340961650014,
-0.024279121309518814,
0.015957333147525787,
0.022321948781609535,
-0.028512708842754364,
-0.07690224796533585,
-0.027180265635252,
0.005250036250799894,
0.01791451871395111,
-0.018774274736642838,
-0.005511503666639328,
0.037690334022045135,
0.025648577138781548,
-0.03314664214849472,
0.04175214469432831,
0.02942623756825924,
0.015612751245498657,
-0.027032330632209778,
0.005749505013227463,
-0.030358493328094482,
0.01496871467679739,
0.010623942129313946,
-0.024155965074896812,
-0.02761208638548851,
-0.026692207902669907,
-0.009313778020441532,
0.01714242622256279,
0.011134838685393333,
0.004590622149407864,
-0.02629835717380047,
-0.012094906531274319,
0.03232105076313019,
-0.01706368662416935,
-0.038768455386161804,
0.021704116836190224,
-0.008632109500467777,
-0.040276721119880676,
-0.04534238204360008,
0.01702410727739334,
-0.07311128079891205,
0.008773598819971085,
0.007225614041090012,
-0.017650512978434563,
-0.0024712986778467894,
0.03390831872820854,
-0.04967240244150162,
-0.0027503918390721083,
-0.017584126442670822,
0.02772262506186962,
-0.024125592783093452,
0.00047293552779592574,
-0.03184187412261963,
0.004285925533622503,
0.0332648903131485,
0.011119627393782139,
0.005950990132987499,
-0.0384632870554924,
-0.005288266111165285,
-0.01591886207461357,
-0.015085055492818356,
0.059429217129945755,
0.004400334320962429,
0.056165821850299835,
-0.004618359729647636,
0.05365578830242157,
0.06187625229358673,
-0.021892011165618896,
-0.020429670810699463,
-0.03361838683485985,
-0.0015216243918985128,
0.045241013169288635,
0.05434593930840492,
0.056814372539520264,
-0.008750860579311848,
0.010188417509198189,
0.04850725829601288,
-0.03059558942914009,
-0.022656140848994255,
0.0314607210457325,
-0.032941412180662155,
-0.006768174469470978,
-0.0014780131168663502,
-0.0032649761997163296,
0.019599299877882004,
-0.03929145634174347,
0.00007729433127678931,
-0.029642021283507347,
-0.000005534935098694405,
0.10701794177293777,
-0.015826785936951637,
-0.017030559480190277,
-0.006587841548025608,
0.033450961112976074,
-0.02517136186361313,
-0.015669802203774452,
-0.028489528223872185,
-0.024645861238241196,
-0.029489003121852875,
0.030726222321391106,
0.007581556215882301,
-0.007940172217786312,
0.043997686356306076,
-0.013091253116726875,
-0.002332337200641632,
-0.015991665422916412,
-0.03901108726859093,
-0.0025124738458544016,
-0.008408737368881702,
0.007032989524304867,
0.004658706486225128,
0.011502677574753761,
0.0033478494733572006,
-0.0027027272153645754,
0.014032392762601376,
0.032321490347385406,
-0.010331416502594948,
-0.038035646080970764,
-0.020692944526672363,
-0.004398596007376909,
0.04109491780400276,
-0.06305842846632004,
0.03412724658846855,
0.06760843098163605,
0.002350175753235817,
-0.04202093556523323,
0.01190247479826212,
-0.01361780147999525,
0.008169565349817276,
-0.026498157531023026,
0.0089335348457098,
-0.03051736392080784,
0.0014561597490683198,
-0.005929618142545223,
0.013017895631492138,
0.028129663318395615,
0.034861430525779724,
0.01072684582322836,
0.01698043942451477,
-0.004019944462925196,
-0.01929960586130619,
0.06152360513806343,
0.0132238594815135,
-0.004070311784744263,
-0.020098239183425903,
-0.02791222557425499,
0.04031876474618912,
-0.010679226368665695,
0.003266772488132119,
0.037289537489414215,
0.046142932027578354,
-0.04089752957224846,
0.02670055814087391,
-0.002031568670645356,
-0.003307830076664686,
0.004665462300181389,
-0.02592814527451992,
-0.028755856677889824,
0.01735447347164154,
0.03180602565407753,
-0.000993558787740767,
-0.04745491221547127,
0.01658346876502037,
-0.05959443002939224,
0.01829332299530506,
-0.015372763387858868,
-0.02939526177942753,
0.020725611597299576,
-0.0024530731607228518,
-0.02123522199690342,
-0.05502312630414963,
-0.06399427354335785,
-0.0019543517846614122,
0.002262193476781249,
-0.011759255081415176,
-0.004510541912168264,
0.04588967189192772,
-0.05847122520208359,
0.04439748823642731,
-0.04353909566998482,
0.005163622088730335,
0.047697048634290695,
-0.024390313774347305,
-0.003320809220895171,
0.05474722757935524,
0.007793711498379707,
-0.028125597164034843,
-0.018195396289229393,
-0.005539416801184416,
0.009047572501003742,
-0.01532164216041565,
0.01416956540197134,
-0.005728830583393574,
-0.0017272927798330784,
0.016577934846282005,
0.053470976650714874,
-0.03104933723807335,
-0.015429253689944744,
-0.01214034017175436,
-0.028264017775654793,
-0.055321116000413895,
-0.035331107676029205,
-0.008996262215077877,
-0.019521638751029968,
0.0369105190038681,
-0.011399626731872559,
0.0025131111033260822,
0.0008140930440276861,
0.00410459702834487,
-0.047207292169332504,
-0.029104117304086685,
-0.02992919459939003,
-0.019336989149451256,
0.018405731767416,
0.016696356236934662,
-0.011656682007014751,
0.022253641858696938,
-0.010671976953744888,
0.03814830631017685,
0.012561235576868057,
-0.0505080409348011,
-0.04323223978281021,
-0.02707528881728649,
0.003199520753696561,
-0.004781135357916355,
-0.008910034783184528,
-0.01904085837304592,
0.02017221599817276,
-0.01899711787700653,
-0.006392873823642731,
-0.02978111431002617,
0.015219333581626415,
0.07414408028125763,
0.029242517426609993,
-0.012272794730961323,
-0.0092943599447608,
0.02697916328907013,
0.012737659737467766,
-0.008946390822529793,
-0.04694805294275284,
0.09883669018745422,
-0.0013716951943933964,
0.0032288359943777323,
0.0031838396098464727,
0.017398018389940262,
0.02047860249876976,
-0.020807690918445587,
0.0036590085364878178,
0.02234414592385292,
0.003081770846620202,
-0.03034026175737381,
-0.04606560990214348,
-0.00289666629396379,
-0.05264808610081673,
0.010825063101947308,
0.009454179555177689,
0.024302469566464424,
0.018063288182020187,
-0.026656076312065125,
0.038652095943689346,
-0.012887513265013695,
-0.03094310499727726,
0.007813893258571625,
0.011662834323942661,
-0.0006816648528911173,
0.02480890415608883,
-0.005374746862798929,
-0.04999547451734543,
0.0033464846201241016,
-0.01601511798799038,
0.014580151997506618,
-0.004241604823619127,
0.007362491451203823,
-0.018492570146918297,
0.027482211589813232,
-0.002632160671055317,
-0.020474515855312347,
-0.028019726276397705,
-0.02101708948612213,
-0.05313654989004135,
-0.04647837206721306,
0.0058355252258479595,
0.0033896106760948896,
0.008051902987062931,
-0.017466209828853607,
0.008311254903674126,
-0.03336801752448082,
0.03496569022536278,
-0.02200952358543873,
0.033662348985672,
-0.032289985567331314,
0.01709560677409172,
-0.13194134831428528,
0.0053597441874444485,
-0.028960764408111572,
0.04041806235909462,
-0.06326810270547867,
0.009796188212931156,
-0.029287025332450867,
0.008648134768009186,
-0.0029507610015571117,
-0.004243964795023203,
-0.019939761608839035,
-0.030117066577076912,
0.08367304503917694,
-6.203497093792976e-8,
-0.025106461718678474,
0.027346359565854073,
-0.022721609100699425,
-0.04089738428592682,
-0.008088897913694382,
0.014211858622729778,
0.0267441738396883,
0.018063751980662346,
0.03808598965406418,
-0.02449479140341282,
-0.017508527263998985,
-0.007188481278717518,
-0.06260611861944199,
0.006026878487318754,
-0.024171270430088043,
0.030600184574723244,
-0.019098835065960884,
-0.03215533867478371,
0.006647601258009672,
0.022420218214392662,
0.00442759832367301,
0.03885921463370323,
0.013446160592138767,
0.0008524247095920146,
-0.005019970703870058,
-0.06077754497528076,
0.0012440687278285623,
0.021637525409460068,
-0.013462086208164692,
-0.025601515546441078,
0.0016616065986454487,
0.027756504714488983,
0.0036813276819884777,
0.01666366495192051,
-0.014476912096142769,
-0.04482347518205643,
-0.05010857805609703,
0.005487462040036917,
0.0023435659240931273,
0.02996554784476757,
0.019643213599920273,
-0.004371136426925659,
0.006055151112377644,
-0.03007609210908413,
-0.02179744467139244,
0.07468684762716293,
-0.01062024850398302,
-0.02247557044029236,
-0.03292446210980415,
-0.03323103114962578,
0.034292224794626236,
0.03166776895523071,
-0.0033645627554506063,
0.015595742501318455,
0.023856068029999733,
-0.013635268434882164,
0.02093081921339035,
-0.010310978628695011,
0.027878927066922188,
-0.04669298604130745,
-0.010799907147884369,
-0.0012353783240541816,
0.017122648656368256,
0.018612299114465714,
0.006855875253677368,
-0.007831230759620667,
0.014559534378349781,
-0.013408580794930458,
-0.00982290506362915,
-0.004037134815007448,
0.046934083104133606,
0.03011527843773365,
-0.031455881893634796,
-0.03292013704776764,
0.06224849075078964,
-0.036037348210811615,
-0.05854082852602005,
-0.022460298612713814,
-0.0041769715026021,
-0.002853103680536151,
-0.019993698224425316,
0.048998065292835236,
0.006911026313900948,
-0.013008464127779007,
0.0004485132230911404,
-0.025769516825675964,
-0.011754498817026615,
-0.034293998032808304,
0.03587286174297333,
-0.0018237639451399446,
-0.00464866915717721,
0.0610818937420845,
-0.026873694732785225,
0.016358399763703346,
0.013189186342060566,
-0.02691204473376274,
-0.03355266898870468,
-0.04636615887284279,
-0.011132422834634781,
0.007236714940518141,
-0.04332822561264038,
0.020983509719371796,
-0.0024107610806822777,
0.046635158360004425,
-0.040902029722929,
0.039289895445108414,
0.03816327080130577,
-0.0296640507876873,
0.012685843743383884,
0.0006391960196197033,
0.017081279307603836,
0.036675404757261276,
0.017136365175247192,
0.005691302474588156,
0.05082951486110687,
-0.013363382779061794,
0.03830459713935852,
-0.031722474843263626,
-0.03981819376349449,
0.005863669794052839,
-0.019417092204093933,
0.03678728640079498,
-0.039062052965164185,
0.014601078815758228,
-0.0019832372199743986,
-0.0448339506983757,
0.026086855679750443,
-0.03779396787285805,
0.00009423240408068523,
0.02446783147752285,
-0.040752481669187546,
-0.05446694418787956,
0.003980520647019148,
-0.012123854830861092,
-0.015644237399101257,
-0.05465824902057648,
-0.04051465541124344,
0.0158280897885561,
-0.01907321996986866,
0.09746833890676498,
0.018083224073052406,
-0.04197777807712555,
0.04251924902200699,
0.01663334295153618,
-0.014556667767465115,
0.05612810328602791,
0.0252098198980093,
-0.006191638298332691,
-0.019184892997145653,
-0.015264085493981838,
-0.015465700067579746,
0.009453319944441319,
-0.02083686925470829,
0.000058065987104782835,
-0.007077195681631565,
-0.005498657468706369,
-0.014294450171291828,
0.009041676297783852,
-0.027004443109035492,
0.01703069731593132,
0.03530503064393997,
-0.027756839990615845,
-0.018875325098633766,
-0.004378088749945164,
0.07640925794839859,
-0.02151959389448166,
0.04568592086434364,
0.049923915416002274,
0.0010395554127171636,
0.029217202216386795,
-0.015791457146406174,
0.015438328497111797,
-0.012389748357236385,
-0.015887849032878876,
-0.04534090310335159,
-0.0352291464805603,
-0.009595325216650963,
-0.018761105835437775,
0.00192464969586581,
-0.009731263853609562,
0.06694052368402481,
0.045238837599754333,
-0.002373523311689496,
-0.000342401210218668,
0.00696595711633563,
0.02732858993113041,
-0.007477612234652042,
-0.014066406525671482,
-0.031435709446668625,
-0.005814550910145044,
-0.03830520436167717,
-0.017122695222496986,
0.014874054118990898,
-0.0065323361195623875,
-0.04040469229221344,
0.04983232170343399,
-0.02177358604967594,
0.0015502013266086578,
-0.032514527440071106,
0.04478166624903679,
-0.015226094983518124,
0.01904068887233734,
-0.00038275300175882876,
-0.022380100563168526,
0.020072059705853462,
0.016368206590414047,
0.012175329960882664,
0.0635717511177063,
-0.02252820134162903,
-0.0317513570189476,
0.021642498672008514,
0.014242364093661308,
0.019246533513069153,
0.0100839389488101,
0.036210935562849045,
-0.010145108215510845,
0.014769523404538631,
-0.01355541031807661,
-0.006051450036466122,
0.02188478596508503,
0.018237577751278877,
-0.02599584311246872,
-0.005050004925578833,
-0.03880726546049118,
-0.018062347546219826,
-0.007596451789140701,
0.04682852700352669,
0.014477546326816082,
0.04440171271562576,
0.009689122438430786
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:21
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
The advice given to QBE by its solicitors and Counsel accepted the likelihood of the acceptance of the evidence from Messrs Gillett and Oates. I agree with that assessment having regard to the material available to them.
There was no apparent reason why their evidence would not be accepted. They had no interest in the outcome of the proceedings. Mr Capper's evidence was unlikely to be accepted.
Of all the witnesses he had the greatest reason to be considered partial given his responsibility for the maintenance and use of the forklift. Mr Sanderson's evidence was equivocal but tended to support Mr Horwood's claim. It was unlikely that he would be called by either side.
104If the evidence of Messrs Gillett and Oates was accepted then it would have established that:
(i)the forklift had long standing deficiencies including loose steering, poor braking and propensity to "fishtail" at some speeds;
(ii)the defects were known to its owner (Mr Capper); and
(iii)Mr Gillett presented quotes for repairs and parts to repair the steering but Mr Capper refused to have the work done.
105The advice from QBE's counsel and solicitors did not descend to considering either ss 5B or 5C of the Civil Liability Act 2002 which were applicable (s 3B(2)). However I have no doubt that a conclusion that there was a breach of a duty of care follows from an acceptance of Messrs Gillett and Oates evidence.
The existence of a duty of care owed by an owner of a motor vehicle to those who use it was not in dispute before me (see Harmer v Hare [2011] NSWCA 229 at [195] (per Whealy JA)).
The risk of harm flowing from a defect in the steering mechanism was clearly foreseeable and not insignificant (s 5B(1)(a) and (b)). There were two obvious precautions that could have been taken to avoid it, namely undertake such steps necessary to have it fixed, or failing that, direct that it not be used at least on a public road.
If those steps were not taken then the probability of harm resulting was reasonably likely and the likely seriousness of harm resulting from an accident of a forklift on a public road was significant (ss 5B(2)(a) and (b)).
106The evidence the investigator obtained from Messrs Gers and Gillett suggests that whatever defects the forklift had they were not expensive to repair. The undertaking of those repairs would clearly be precautions that a reasonable person would have undertaken in the circumstances.
Even if it was not possible to ascertain the likely cost of repairing the forklift to the requisite standard,
the magnitude of the risk posed by the forklift was such that I consider the burden of directing that the forklift not be driven on a public road and the social utility of the task that Mr Horwood was undertaking were strongly outweighed by the risks inherent in allowing a forklift with a defective steering mechanism to be driven (ss 5B(2)(c) and (d)).
Accordingly I consider that, even if for some reason the forklift could not have been repaired, a reasonable person in the position of Megbuy would have directed that the forklift not be driven on a public road.
I consider that a reasonable person in Megbuy's position would have taken the precaution, of either having the forklift repaired or, failing that, directed that it not be driven on a public road (s 5B(1)(c)).
107Neither of the tendered extracts from the advice of counsel to QBE or the advice from its solicitors specifically addressed causation. A pragmatic position appears to have been adopted.
They gauged that the District Court would strain to find liability established in the circumstances of a plaintiff with a serious injury and a body of evidence suggesting a persistent defect with the forklift's steering mechanism.
Mr Campbell SC contended that causation was not established on the material before QBE. He contended that the clear inference was that Mr Horwood braked heavily and swerved to avoid colliding with the parked car.
|
[
0.03449910134077072,
0.00004103493120055646,
-0.03682595491409302,
-0.03151926025748253,
0.027034297585487366,
-0.04190288856625557,
0.013385134749114513,
0.013705352321267128,
0.026258496567606926,
0.017533231526613235,
0.004680424463003874,
0.02878824807703495,
-0.006819202098995447,
-0.01757807284593582,
0.002230266574770212,
-0.02190770022571087,
0.018473437055945396,
-0.017835209146142006,
-0.07233364880084991,
-0.052916157990694046,
0.024015113711357117,
-0.009291746653616428,
0.01846362091600895,
0.043813079595565796,
-0.0077991485595703125,
0.0182554479688406,
-0.007059305906295776,
0.016929078847169876,
0.0031125880777835846,
-0.015605736523866653,
-0.02449987828731537,
-0.022389337420463562,
0.017481720075011253,
0.014578155241906643,
0.005061479285359383,
-0.0773259624838829,
-0.014530475251376629,
0.009156497195363045,
-0.013521604239940643,
-0.0121128149330616,
-0.02368912287056446,
0.0030904673039913177,
0.04638035222887993,
-0.04534550756216049,
0.02885458618402481,
-0.03898888826370239,
-0.030607230961322784,
-0.017298445105552673,
0.0031372110825031996,
0.014180350117385387,
-0.040259186178445816,
-0.007968779653310776,
0.028528176248073578,
-0.03506707400083542,
0.028032489120960236,
-0.00039063376607373357,
0.04431438818573952,
-0.033175766468048096,
-0.05767056718468666,
0.01585707999765873,
-0.02259775996208191,
-0.02327999658882618,
0.006665462162345648,
-0.021676653996109962,
0.021459434181451797,
0.07215678691864014,
-0.03850804641842842,
-0.001987031428143382,
-0.01431729830801487,
-0.023336337879300117,
-0.006182513199746609,
0.01166154257953167,
0.008461912162601948,
0.015435107983648777,
-0.05063635855913162,
0.016674576327204704,
0.00479526212438941,
0.024757687002420425,
-0.0027299236971884966,
0.0693313404917717,
0.01994391530752182,
0.023382442072033882,
0.01548224501311779,
0.03352782502770424,
-0.013165182434022427,
-0.0013231521006673574,
-0.04438360035419464,
0.016918940469622612,
0.0012036014813929796,
0.005957489367574453,
-0.013266650028526783,
0.0038423025980591774,
0.012399955652654171,
-0.019045598804950714,
-0.016386596485972404,
0.015714379027485847,
-0.035713836550712585,
0.018578972667455673,
0.019420476630330086,
0.014480932615697384,
-0.011875737458467484,
0.0012875410029664636,
0.014484433457255363,
-0.033178091049194336,
-0.0022456578444689512,
-0.031484100967645645,
-0.014588544145226479,
0.04051026329398155,
0.01997298374772072,
0.005779008846729994,
0.012641257606446743,
0.026812177151441574,
-0.011877785436809063,
0.009803272783756256,
-0.02308260090649128,
0.0006210616556927562,
0.04190541431307793,
-0.021090412512421608,
-0.020824067294597626,
-0.015047403052449226,
0.050149690359830856,
0.06166951730847359,
0.07447020709514618,
-0.041053593158721924,
-0.025060387328267097,
-0.005546548869460821,
0.012804217636585236,
-0.06233017146587372,
-0.02336122840642929,
-0.00601571798324585,
0.008927445858716965,
-0.016907429322600365,
-0.009488238021731377,
-0.061389315873384476,
-0.03396181762218475,
-0.014334633015096188,
0.0169978030025959,
0.018220774829387665,
-0.03480178490281105,
-0.01639469712972641,
0.024969538673758507,
0.06400071829557419,
0.03159506618976593,
0.006603892892599106,
0.036966174840927124,
-0.018688108772039413,
0.009089352563023567,
-0.008351702243089676,
0.03161938115954399,
-0.030516646802425385,
0.013644657097756863,
-0.003717778716236353,
0.011379004456102848,
-0.043632447719573975,
0.03440173715353012,
-0.052672192454338074,
0.027431262657046318,
-0.04007592052221298,
-0.0008472324698232114,
0.006199873052537441,
0.011865473352372646,
0.03503584489226341,
-0.009838702157139778,
-0.03292754292488098,
0.013582724146544933,
0.023692144080996513,
0.04512215778231621,
0.02413465641438961,
-0.027649907395243645,
-0.009021465666592121,
0.0032594066578894854,
-0.014451389200985432,
0.013019266538321972,
0.014486448839306831,
0.03314916044473648,
0.031922176480293274,
0.042231351137161255,
0.01930035464465618,
0.031998760998249054,
-0.05017581954598427,
0.028230944648385048,
-0.00959158968180418,
0.03374221548438072,
0.0035875276662409306,
-0.010212007910013199,
0.03199641779065132,
0.027026278898119926,
-0.05365714058279991,
0.031067004427313805,
0.02352951467037201,
-0.006278743036091328,
-0.042888280004262924,
0.039777323603630066,
0.014791685156524181,
0.013793780468404293,
-0.008068074472248554,
0.015353799797594547,
-0.02071307599544525,
0.04299008473753929,
-0.016183510422706604,
-0.014457414858043194,
0.023409739136695862,
0.05983241647481918,
-0.043105598539114,
-0.04225878790020943,
-0.00779066514223814,
-0.04871295765042305,
0.01054114755243063,
0.02917325496673584,
-0.07475722581148148,
0.013438649475574493,
-0.011810444295406342,
0.031125502660870552,
0.021912438794970512,
0.005151241086423397,
0.007217698264867067,
-0.007875708863139153,
-0.015306614339351654,
0.005040130112320185,
-0.011200332082808018,
-0.018712935969233513,
-0.016362417489290237,
0.006349778734147549,
-0.010034787468612194,
0.012040387839078903,
0.03453166410326958,
-0.02639443799853325,
0.017346244305372238,
0.01072857528924942,
-0.019727375358343124,
0.055777814239263535,
0.014675646089017391,
0.021794579923152924,
-0.024877440184354782,
0.045117899775505066,
0.011250678449869156,
-0.003375705098733306,
0.013894474133849144,
0.01206014584749937,
0.017608217895030975,
-0.03161816671490669,
-0.01708296686410904,
0.06214341148734093,
-0.04091934859752655,
-0.0028488708194345236,
-0.04306948930025101,
-0.01690186746418476,
0.01090127881616354,
0.0392950177192688,
0.029281649738550186,
0.03689812868833542,
0.008125890046358109,
-0.03079775907099247,
0.01004703901708126,
0.013835231773555279,
0.028424542397260666,
0.030345119535923004,
-0.016553955152630806,
0.01404985599219799,
-0.029725993052124977,
0.0033519722055643797,
0.045680414885282516,
0.03925669193267822,
0.0008906422881409526,
-0.04202248901128769,
-0.05161289870738983,
-0.03625260293483734,
-0.07020801305770874,
-0.05437828227877617,
-0.017305558547377586,
0.012758136726915836,
0.005825227592140436,
-0.015073923394083977,
0.022145280614495277,
0.028018338605761528,
0.0351044200360775,
-0.018556270748376846,
-0.0069283475168049335,
0.014200452715158463,
-0.014988868497312069,
0.03467028588056564,
0.024316543713212013,
0.032007161527872086,
-0.00550827756524086,
0.01476515457034111,
0.0011676663998514414,
-0.04197130724787712,
-0.05369633063673973,
-0.03906737640500069,
-0.06286259740591049,
0.05772547796368599,
0.02480889856815338,
0.06190876290202141,
-0.013566650450229645,
-0.05341947823762894,
0.02662179060280323,
0.0042211320251226425,
-0.15268707275390625,
0.01646311581134796,
0.04740714281797409,
0.006587714422494173,
-0.00352300307713449,
0.02036750316619873,
-0.02325824648141861,
-0.004487859550863504,
-0.026515483856201172,
-0.0053350129164755344,
0.02848273143172264,
-0.06451202929019928,
-0.017498623579740524,
0.014976062811911106,
-0.008343540132045746,
-0.030826125293970108,
0.016781290993094444,
0.003335935063660145,
0.015627015382051468,
-0.03903625160455704,
0.011095117777585983,
-0.01856091059744358,
0.050686486065387726,
0.017475934699177742,
-0.0037742445711046457,
-0.04643576964735985,
0.04439426586031914,
0.03440200537443161,
-0.030613083392381668,
-0.038164861500263214,
-0.01890508271753788,
0.008814961649477482,
-0.009396381676197052,
0.06553228199481964,
-0.030654622241854668,
0.0006970416870899498,
0.0720912292599678,
-0.07147103548049927,
-0.0005508271278813481,
0.009192016907036304,
0.02543906308710575,
0.09763114154338837,
-0.033860284835100174,
0.0066447751596570015,
0.011046744883060455,
-0.08013293147087097,
0.018636053428053856,
-0.004905123263597488,
-0.05781864747405052,
0.030743485316634178,
-0.001884234370663762,
-0.04205938056111336,
-0.003940060269087553,
-0.0024094588588923216,
-0.0372292697429657,
-0.022247685119509697,
0.022293271496891975,
0.05415679141879082,
-0.03722153604030609,
0.016106760129332542,
-0.024678805842995644,
-0.06922417879104614,
0.022848235443234444,
0.028506886214017868,
-0.05950608104467392,
0.00203316705301404,
-0.006231163628399372,
-0.029554899781942368,
0.032488077878952026,
-0.004546114709228277,
-0.05220607668161392,
-0.06775429099798203,
0.042913589626550674,
-0.021962376311421394,
0.005358089227229357,
0.016388587653636932,
0.019735494628548622,
-0.001517832395620644,
-0.022150374948978424,
-0.06839665025472641,
0.0006332503398880363,
0.037998016923666,
-0.005022231489419937,
0.01930696703493595,
0.0008557869005016983,
0.033138860017061234,
0.014189865440130234,
0.037899404764175415,
0.07751087099313736,
0.24635709822177887,
-0.04523076117038727,
-0.032941918820142746,
-0.015275832265615463,
0.007497204001992941,
0.02523598074913025,
0.03680043667554855,
0.022552859038114548,
0.022017857059836388,
-0.020614372566342354,
-0.06443822383880615,
-0.014401501975953579,
0.012976326048374176,
0.007831797003746033,
-0.04264821112155914,
-0.019360773265361786,
-0.014111055992543697,
-0.06414210051298141,
0.08455656468868256,
-0.031195323914289474,
0.028360674157738686,
0.011192438192665577,
0.02304343320429325,
0.017123112455010414,
-0.07568856328725815,
-0.004357234109193087,
0.0043784864246845245,
-0.012392645701766014,
0.016775749623775482,
-0.0038872193545103073,
-0.01750817522406578,
-0.004429352004081011,
0.05494775250554085,
-0.02708750031888485,
-0.0008584794122725725,
-0.005689174868166447,
-0.010218540206551552,
-0.015575666911900043,
0.012260820716619492,
0.04323496297001839,
0.053877394646406174,
-0.004551360383629799,
-0.050367262214422226,
-0.04299229755997658,
-0.026542561128735542,
0.004918406251817942,
-0.006557757966220379,
0.001118168467655778,
-0.02109272964298725,
0.04786611720919609,
-0.04954864829778671,
0.009844813495874405,
-0.04310348629951477,
-0.00979586597532034,
-0.03959958255290985,
0.05046091228723526,
0.012269492261111736,
-0.012415151111781597,
0.01879844069480896,
0.01761075295507908,
0.030628714710474014,
0.01591424085199833,
-0.016109665855765343,
0.01889760047197342,
-0.017084309831261635,
0.0022038393653929234,
-0.055295296013355255,
0.000532685371581465,
0.060685861855745316,
-0.022750062867999077,
-0.00964109506458044,
0.027902059257030487,
0.008293507620692253,
0.055516600608825684,
0.029194701462984085,
0.023752810433506966,
0.04602070897817612,
0.06800536811351776,
-0.0042200470343232155,
-0.006963670719414949,
-0.024768030270934105,
-0.02327476441860199,
-0.0026530802715569735,
0.01728341542184353,
0.011497491039335728,
-0.007572593167424202,
0.00007566554268123582,
0.057607252150774,
0.04218732565641403,
0.022515153512358665,
-0.01923203282058239,
-0.03585245832800865,
-0.00877461675554514,
0.02517162635922432,
-0.023248497396707535,
0.01763039641082287,
0.04156288877129555,
-0.017500082030892372,
-0.0039031628984957933,
-0.04914497584104538,
-0.026086172088980675,
-0.009468723088502884,
-0.016941865906119347,
-0.026352258399128914,
0.001143215806223452,
-0.01597011648118496,
0.004808829631656408,
-0.006303016096353531,
-0.036898281425237656,
-0.03398028016090393,
0.00768698938190937,
-0.0013871578266844153,
-0.012608267366886139,
-0.01994680054485798,
0.015219650231301785,
0.00542698847129941,
-0.027456630021333694,
0.04369380697607994,
0.02719578891992569,
0.05587609484791756,
-0.02313881926238537,
-0.0015117292059585452,
-0.042617544531822205,
0.01611912064254284,
-0.009615647606551647,
-0.0035557334776967764,
-0.059372495859861374,
-0.030726080760359764,
0.0020168593619018793,
0.03330831602215767,
0.03365502133965492,
-0.006090135313570499,
-0.05974910408258438,
-0.025414036586880684,
0.04074136167764664,
-0.015747912228107452,
0.004554979503154755,
0.0104666817933321,
-0.015567558817565441,
0.004470315761864185,
-0.0034742439165711403,
-0.009363558143377304,
-0.04746554419398308,
0.010182404890656471,
-0.0005144058959558606,
0.002068899106234312,
-0.0441913865506649,
0.017732994630932808,
-0.04439176246523857,
-0.037147730588912964,
0.012083121575415134,
0.011691494844853878,
-0.03862796351313591,
-0.012114036828279495,
-0.0001537937787361443,
0.04068206250667572,
0.005819954909384251,
-0.03041589818894863,
0.043180204927921295,
-0.03197149932384491,
-0.02563633769750595,
-0.017938395962119102,
-0.014997872523963451,
0.03541816025972366,
0.04285537451505661,
0.061589986085891724,
0.0155343571677804,
0.06513120979070663,
0.0714612677693367,
-0.027477450668811798,
0.011699597351253033,
-0.021531719714403152,
-0.004873696248978376,
0.04825633391737938,
0.0419163815677166,
0.06194373965263367,
-0.04321029409766197,
0.04886123165488243,
0.03872213512659073,
-0.016491364687681198,
0.008795978501439095,
0.03775074705481529,
-0.019423721358180046,
-0.0004606875008903444,
-0.037725817412137985,
-0.034181706607341766,
0.018439799547195435,
-0.023139966651797295,
0.031031813472509384,
-0.00538290198892355,
-0.003449131501838565,
0.0793185606598854,
-0.01773075759410858,
-0.013283634558320045,
0.029856424778699875,
0.028304677456617355,
0.026580169796943665,
0.01834077015519142,
-0.0014587502228096128,
-0.0806426852941513,
-0.019673824310302734,
-0.01745646819472313,
0.010418269783258438,
0.014187924563884735,
0.037509020417928696,
0.0037263534031808376,
-0.014990324154496193,
0.023813510313630104,
-0.02797887474298477,
-0.013543953187763691,
0.010464777238667011,
0.047574639320373535,
-0.012781213968992233,
-0.005549510009586811,
-0.0333428792655468,
0.011393391527235508,
0.02205844782292843,
0.054198890924453735,
-0.002803429262712598,
-0.04000682011246681,
-0.007761064916849136,
-0.007662273943424225,
0.027058839797973633,
-0.04997275397181511,
-0.025583263486623764,
0.014962075278162956,
0.0009312891052104533,
-0.028555743396282196,
0.018234187737107277,
0.020755676552653313,
0.009974580258131027,
-0.04015560820698738,
-0.00607652822509408,
-0.016706859692931175,
0.006699047051370144,
-0.011831128969788551,
0.03271228075027466,
0.024886377155780792,
0.011040613986551762,
0.004553980194032192,
0.026728803291916847,
-0.01681230589747429,
0.012751119211316109,
0.06149490922689438,
-0.016153903678059578,
-0.030418815091252327,
0.004756275564432144,
-0.0370359867811203,
-0.0221230611205101,
0.02362160198390484,
0.01037012878805399,
0.010055938735604286,
0.022785859182476997,
-0.03793150186538696,
0.016122395172715187,
-0.013421613723039627,
0.008830634877085686,
-0.00038526824209839106,
-0.05306402966380119,
0.008715352974832058,
0.00343871652148664,
0.04173854738473892,
0.00848387647420168,
-0.010753575712442398,
0.00553986057639122,
-0.0379331074655056,
-0.0014499243116006255,
0.013545394875109196,
-0.013909217901527882,
-0.03531554713845253,
0.0023302289191633463,
-0.004161037504673004,
-0.03157993406057358,
-0.09386438876390457,
-0.049348995089530945,
0.01878373697400093,
-0.03352006524801254,
0.02711356244981289,
0.0022608095314353704,
-0.04932623729109764,
0.04442700743675232,
-0.04855681210756302,
-0.011664524674415588,
0.03472549095749855,
0.015163397416472435,
0.03568064048886299,
0.04375075921416283,
0.0038401219062507153,
0.003930776845663786,
-0.01792886294424534,
0.02334274724125862,
0.041334059089422226,
-0.004677078686654568,
0.007154330611228943,
-0.007963890209794044,
0.02455720491707325,
-0.04317203536629677,
0.05639345198869705,
-0.017161639407277107,
0.025447789579629898,
-0.014100638218224049,
0.02403823286294937,
-0.04019201174378395,
-0.06047658249735832,
-0.022198786959052086,
-0.02068301849067211,
0.0034762700088322163,
-0.050044476985931396,
-0.012117083184421062,
0.0051670256070792675,
-0.01881181076169014,
-0.041533421725034714,
-0.01968790404498577,
-0.024015555158257484,
-0.004336120560765266,
0.010655595920979977,
-0.01573360338807106,
0.004131739027798176,
0.013967356644570827,
0.03178710862994194,
0.010286042466759682,
-0.012759193778038025,
-0.03914535790681839,
-0.01125838328152895,
-0.08594918996095657,
0.02103857323527336,
-0.004229092970490456,
0.016377437859773636,
-0.0066102719865739346,
-0.026902245357632637,
-0.05935361608862877,
0.017752664163708687,
-0.01862483099102974,
0.013646567240357399,
0.10271813720464706,
-0.008313575759530067,
0.009449032135307789,
-0.02851395681500435,
0.09612522274255753,
-0.0353335440158844,
-0.03783207759261131,
-0.03270197659730911,
0.07687617093324661,
-0.008286220021545887,
-0.001887094578705728,
-0.015727393329143524,
-0.017543861642479897,
-0.011478054337203503,
0.0327826589345932,
0.02249941974878311,
-0.001779096433892846,
0.019441787153482437,
-0.021033087745308876,
-0.06081518530845642,
-0.01164273265749216,
0.003292832989245653,
0.01095433160662651,
-0.01157434843480587,
0.024414343759417534,
-0.009101470932364464,
-0.014202219434082508,
0.0152155552059412,
-0.031015271320939064,
-0.012494878843426704,
0.022625291720032692,
0.008657322265207767,
-0.0054072788916528225,
-0.01712905988097191,
0.022942109033465385,
-0.018604449927806854,
-0.000505561416503042,
0.002763903932645917,
0.01551862433552742,
-0.02289087325334549,
-0.01545715518295765,
0.019209038466215134,
0.011759298853576183,
0.005317667964845896,
-0.014908607117831707,
-0.006729873828589916,
-0.021754847839474678,
-0.05490748584270477,
-0.028620712459087372,
-0.008182392455637455,
0.0160306915640831,
0.0016768104396760464,
-0.014164431020617485,
0.011827466078102589,
0.0016541293589398265,
0.01611822284758091,
-0.003975096624344587,
0.045378636568784714,
-0.04712577536702156,
0.02119222842156887,
-0.1271105706691742,
0.0187178086489439,
-0.003408590331673622,
0.011015729047358036,
-0.05454804375767708,
-0.01043631974607706,
-0.017091847956180573,
0.004682779777795076,
-0.04284593462944031,
-0.011328564025461674,
0.02227327972650528,
-0.020237304270267487,
0.058925677090883255,
0.00899864174425602,
-0.03533964976668358,
0.027067000046372414,
-0.016556618735194206,
-0.02558297850191593,
-0.01719309203326702,
0.043155502527952194,
0.013140433467924595,
0.015198097564280033,
0.005095509346574545,
-0.005942651070654392,
-0.0484582893550396,
-0.021732401102781296,
-0.05452292412519455,
-0.026496348902583122,
-0.013024264946579933,
0.0047838143073022366,
-0.03196129575371742,
-0.023522254079580307,
0.009096154943108559,
0.02616967260837555,
-0.0018157886806875467,
0.012307466939091682,
0.015224827453494072,
-0.026180153712630272,
-0.05230483412742615,
-0.006114158313721418,
-0.014421006664633751,
0.0025475495494902134,
-0.03828001394867897,
0.015884103253483772,
-0.04168666526675224,
0.028992123901844025,
-0.02695341221988201,
0.0020390311256051064,
-0.0441126823425293,
-0.009142656810581684,
-0.05047016218304634,
0.046770449727773666,
-0.044241778552532196,
0.008059977553784847,
0.02066606469452381,
0.0006600689375773072,
-0.014443203806877136,
-0.03786811977624893,
-0.008778215385973454,
0.05026574805378914,
-0.002104018349200487,
-0.0002001723478315398,
-0.02961873635649681,
-0.03441249579191208,
0.007224386092275381,
-0.006831691134721041,
-0.005688248667865992,
-0.010193892754614353,
0.014988708309829235,
-0.0029196608811616898,
-0.004311806056648493,
-0.0322740375995636,
0.04145940765738487,
-0.017989886924624443,
0.006348343566060066,
-0.038108617067337036,
0.009919079020619392,
-0.014840680174529552,
0.03322511538863182,
0.001542002079077065,
-0.01631471887230873,
0.01586572453379631,
-0.036146264523267746,
-0.00972131360322237,
0.05091924965381622,
0.031977329403162,
-0.01268222276121378,
-0.03313981369137764,
0.033501528203487396,
-0.048861391842365265,
-0.06376007944345474,
0.017015863209962845,
0.0060826074331998825,
0.008934982120990753,
-0.018993010744452477,
0.02771242894232273,
-0.0010455024894326925,
-0.023386025801301003,
-0.03220127522945404,
-0.02809784561395645,
-0.024082127958536148,
-0.032344721257686615,
0.01049304474145174,
-0.005467536859214306,
-0.003220614045858383,
0.008722797967493534,
-0.031782254576683044,
0.01222787145525217,
0.006009815260767937,
0.032481588423252106,
-0.024799903854727745,
-0.03481891378760338,
-0.03511462360620499,
-0.05010600760579109,
-0.00977581087499857,
0.03750918060541153,
-0.0095122205093503,
-0.03692946583032608,
-0.038131460547447205,
0.020739538595080376,
0.03317388892173767,
-0.013865167275071144,
0.025091327726840973,
-0.015487179160118103,
-0.03303305432200432,
0.01968640461564064,
0.043914128094911575,
0.012909604236483574,
0.018124401569366455,
-0.010894917882978916,
0.040634673088788986,
-0.026371493935585022,
-0.0034567583352327347,
0.0038246777839958668,
0.003888032166287303,
0.022843873128294945,
-0.011529584415256977,
0.010744104161858559,
-0.014384313486516476,
-0.04494132846593857,
0.014241771772503853,
-0.003627736819908023,
-0.0011953088687732816,
-0.02099592611193657,
-0.02971535176038742,
-0.0011993908556178212,
0.021481188014149666,
0.013734281063079834,
-0.01498863659799099,
-0.021109960973262787,
-0.013582438230514526,
-0.010418516583740711,
0.006068964023143053,
0.04118989780545235,
0.02766173705458641,
-0.030832776799798012,
0.04024730250239372,
0.03391558676958084,
0.002981932135298848,
0.04366614669561386,
0.06311468780040741,
-0.036555301398038864,
-0.0482182577252388,
-0.03584953397512436,
-0.03905389457941055,
0.07022500783205032,
0.00527166249230504,
-0.007660075556486845,
-0.002061959821730852,
-0.01595773734152317,
0.007303528022021055,
0.03628886118531227,
-0.010333294980227947,
-0.022044207900762558,
0.036293018609285355,
-0.05147816240787506,
0.0005476042279042304,
-0.012811535969376564,
0.030179178342223167,
-0.014264753088355064,
0.03475349396467209,
0.040913987904787064,
0.02514825388789177,
0.026827264577150345,
-0.0011415035696700215,
0.027338961139321327,
-0.013219987042248249,
0.007409743964672089,
-0.029915571212768555,
-0.008406683802604675,
-0.00648031709715724,
-0.010846355929970741,
-0.008806766010820866,
-0.047523077577352524,
0.015852781012654305,
-0.014601131901144981,
-0.010051470249891281,
0.028952347114682198,
0.009496859274804592,
0.0320313423871994,
0.03538133576512337,
0.001863713376224041,
-0.016392819583415985,
-0.032873377203941345,
-0.0009928005747497082,
-0.0035931982565671206,
0.01641414687037468,
-0.02776799537241459,
-0.0228263009339571,
0.036317337304353714,
-0.028966758400201797,
0.0012357295490801334,
0.016202453523874283,
0.06583648920059204,
-0.027506494894623756,
0.0016623493283987045,
-0.014088750816881657,
-0.0020886282436549664,
0.03890682011842728,
-0.023909425362944603,
0.0032478640787303448,
0.06107907369732857,
0.005895986221730709,
-0.06408765912055969,
0.03830981254577637,
0.035784900188446045,
0.023067018017172813,
-0.003236960619688034,
0.008654034696519375,
-0.01627139374613762,
0.00289072934538126,
0.005054035224020481,
0.0212105643004179,
0.04325849190354347,
0.000030838251404929906,
-0.003061795374378562,
-0.035595085471868515,
-0.02766740880906582,
-0.0212237685918808,
-0.0034420627634972334,
0.05020059272646904,
0.028642836958169937,
0.0030219319742172956,
0.017793094739317894
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:9
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
In my view that must be addressed afresh by me. I address it at [41] to [60] below. (I also address that issue on the basis that a reasonable compromise on that issue suffices: [60].)
40The more difficult matter concerns the approach to be adopted to the question of whether the circumstances of Mr Horwood's accident meant that the definition of "injury" in s 3 of the MAC Act was satisfied.
Again each of the admissions of liability in the defence, the heads of agreement and the consent orders all necessarily included an admission that the definition of "injury" was satisfied in relation to Mr Horwood's claim.
However they are also necessary components of QBE's obligation to provide cover under the MAC Act and critical to ascertaining whether CGU's was obliged to provide cover for a liability quantified in accordance with Chapter 5 of the MAC Act.
Given the manner in which [57] of Zurich v GIO is expressed I do not see how the question of "fault" of the owner can be re-litigated afresh if the Court is satisfied there was a reasonable compromise of "liability".
However, the remaining aspects of the definition of "injury" (other than the definition of owner) are all matters of characterisation of that liability. At the very least, a consideration of whether the (alleged) liability being compromised falls within the definition of "injury" must be a relevant component of whether the compromise was reasonable.
I consider that I should approach the matter by asking whether the alleged liability that was being compromised satisfied the definition of "injury". If it did not then the compromise would not be reasonable. If it did then that conclusion would inform but not determine any assessment of whether or not the compromise was reasonable. I address this aspect in [116] to [131] below.
WAS MEGBUY THE OWNER OF THE FORKLIFT AS AT 7 NOVEMBER 2005?
41As at 7 November 2005, section 4 of the MAC provided:
"4 Meaning of "owner" of motor vehicle
(1) For the purposes of this Act:
(a) in the case of a motor vehicle that is registered, the owner is:
(i) each registered operator of the vehicle within the meaning of the Road Transport (Vehicle Registration) Act 1997, unless the operator has sold or ceased to have possession of the vehicle, and
(ii) each person who, although not a registered operator of the vehicle, is a sole or joint owner of the vehicle, unless that person has sold or ceased to have possession of the vehicle, and
(iii) if any such registered operator or owner has sold or ceased to have possession of the vehicle-any person who solely or jointly or in common with any other person is entitled to the immediate possession of the vehicle, or
(b) in the case of a motor vehicle that is unregistered, the owner is any person who solely or jointly or in common with any other person is entitled to the immediate possession of the vehicle, or
(c) in the case of a motor vehicle to which a trader's plate is fixed, the owner is the trader to whom the trader's plate is issued.
(2) For the purposes of this section, a person is taken not to have ceased to have possession or, as the case may be, not to have acquired possession of a motor vehicle where a change of possession occurs by way of:
(a) any hiring (not being a hiring under a hire-purchase agreement) or lending of the vehicle for a period not exceeding 3 months, or
(b) the passing of the possession of the vehicle to a bailee for the purpose of sale or disposal or for the purpose of alteration, repair, renovation, garaging, storing or other like purpose not involving the use or operation of the motor vehicle for the benefit of the bailee."
42It was common ground that, as at 7 November 2005, Levira was the registered owner of the forklift. However, QBE contended that s 4(1)(a)(iiii) of the MAC Act was engaged in that, as at that date, Levira "ceased to have possession" of the forklift and Megbuy, either by itself or in common with others, was "entitled to immediate possession".
|
[
0.041654836386442184,
-0.014897140674293041,
-0.018803894519805908,
-0.016448693349957466,
0.019833926111459732,
-0.02422221563756466,
0.025667931884527206,
0.014692571945488453,
0.016415229067206383,
0.037226706743240356,
-0.010107048787176609,
-0.01605936884880066,
-0.009872685186564922,
0.009904761798679829,
-0.006476300302892923,
-0.04016749560832977,
0.018503976985812187,
-0.0007206226582638919,
-0.038212504237890244,
-0.05307364463806152,
0.02011771686375141,
-0.022670408710837364,
0.044462960213422775,
0.030792560428380966,
0.02100817859172821,
-0.0002933541836682707,
-0.010583941824734211,
0.00041907638660632074,
0.004526392091065645,
-0.019612036645412445,
-0.01766235940158367,
-0.017326027154922485,
-0.0473044291138649,
-0.022993680089712143,
-0.0014501221012324095,
-0.03414498642086983,
-0.021017950028181076,
0.026509488001465797,
-0.023348994553089142,
-0.007210958749055862,
-0.01126039121299982,
-0.021567771211266518,
-0.004522392060607672,
-0.043292634189128876,
0.033409930765628815,
-0.023570822551846504,
-0.004033661913126707,
-0.01975691318511963,
-0.015984205529093742,
-0.02665586583316326,
-0.05641256645321846,
-0.008273966610431671,
0.05238552391529083,
-0.005394239444285631,
-0.007366545964032412,
0.04021260514855385,
0.00030397422960959375,
-0.05834486708045006,
-0.042334459722042084,
-0.02284351736307144,
-0.04646219685673714,
0.003704276168718934,
-0.010239177383482456,
0.018089741468429565,
-0.024633146822452545,
0.0651383176445961,
-0.0443558506667614,
-0.04708974435925484,
-0.019990522414445877,
-0.026146788150072098,
-0.012396757490932941,
0.010092559270560741,
-0.045103445649147034,
0.024371378123760223,
-0.05398575961589813,
0.015760134905576706,
0.03762629255652428,
0.03856433928012848,
-0.001482656691223383,
0.015840433537960052,
0.020064808428287506,
0.007816816680133343,
-0.012279720976948738,
0.03123655542731285,
0.008193711750209332,
0.0034930685069411993,
-0.042908672243356705,
-0.02089361660182476,
-0.004950102884322405,
-0.012292140163481236,
0.004758377093821764,
0.0025810685474425554,
0.015155866742134094,
-0.011329754255712032,
-0.005402803421020508,
-0.0016620575916022062,
-0.046278294175863266,
0.0034695647191256285,
-0.01042927149683237,
-0.017843816429376602,
-0.008428070694208145,
0.02005964331328869,
0.07962258160114288,
-0.05993126332759857,
-0.021481677889823914,
0.026541510596871376,
0.022982079535722733,
0.04286091774702072,
-0.0038427456747740507,
-0.001934681786224246,
-0.0009459939901717007,
0.014748208224773407,
-0.028639590367674828,
-0.001862664707005024,
-0.0016604794654995203,
-0.026871860027313232,
0.00014641930465586483,
-0.054614901542663574,
-0.0020007009152323008,
-0.0377679318189621,
0.017372699454426765,
0.06035742908716202,
0.04131791368126869,
-0.03876823931932449,
-0.02862703986465931,
0.0034162402153015137,
0.02326745167374611,
-0.01368152815848589,
0.00763394171372056,
-0.0022812376264482737,
0.03350191190838814,
-0.004551232326775789,
-0.030244696885347366,
-0.04644712433218956,
-0.04122594743967056,
-0.018655313178896904,
0.04525090008974075,
0.021458949893712997,
-0.04714826121926308,
-0.023557957261800766,
0.047836244106292725,
0.05118748918175697,
0.011433292180299759,
-0.003246876411139965,
0.04989728331565857,
-0.010459054261446,
0.04720596224069595,
-0.04339580610394478,
0.0162146408110857,
-0.033680107444524765,
0.004319962579756975,
0.00981917791068554,
0.017559295520186424,
-0.06347263604402542,
0.03847857564687729,
-0.041641540825366974,
-0.008122028782963753,
-0.014351649209856987,
0.009249230846762657,
0.026516035199165344,
-0.0009702055831439793,
0.04860500246286392,
-0.012198383919894695,
-0.03519156947731972,
0.023508168756961823,
0.012238954193890095,
-0.0008099538972601295,
0.04536056891083717,
-0.01923624984920025,
-0.00524684926494956,
0.01361306942999363,
0.015232404693961143,
0.02390836365520954,
0.00262848986312747,
0.027365675196051598,
0.03637821227312088,
0.0431540347635746,
0.010817063972353935,
-0.002428004750981927,
-0.024601083248853683,
0.0031818344723433256,
-0.027026286348700523,
0.014153800904750824,
-0.012238159775733948,
0.01870608516037464,
0.021410852670669556,
0.026355870068073273,
-0.04907059669494629,
0.014421414583921432,
0.02392750233411789,
0.011617415584623814,
-0.012569223530590534,
-0.02448812685906887,
0.013095317408442497,
0.021697038784623146,
-0.021120518445968628,
0.03070676326751709,
0.002779430942609906,
0.05403920263051987,
-0.033559683710336685,
-0.028481492772698402,
-0.004948332440108061,
0.10272383689880371,
-0.021013792604207993,
-0.017057539895176888,
-0.021757856011390686,
-0.05249049887061119,
0.016646748408675194,
0.007587712723761797,
-0.06207549199461937,
0.017794394865632057,
0.015145466662943363,
0.053243283182382584,
-0.007344525307416916,
-0.034823596477508545,
-0.02309446781873703,
0.013452637009322643,
-0.006933106575161219,
0.050929855555295944,
-0.0012433405499905348,
-0.014009556733071804,
-0.004689576104283333,
0.003829716006293893,
0.042209282517433167,
0.024101857095956802,
0.002308788476511836,
-0.05338061600923538,
0.051969014108181,
0.006088356487452984,
-0.0003410254721529782,
0.04028619825839996,
0.023586060851812363,
0.004215355962514877,
-0.062058284878730774,
0.0372772291302681,
0.00572141632437706,
0.021842798218131065,
0.004143241327255964,
0.0072821686044335365,
0.005123046692460775,
-0.003278392134234309,
-0.05678819119930267,
0.058647315949201584,
-0.021962493658065796,
0.0033176415599882603,
-0.020734934136271477,
-0.039201099425554276,
0.03084922954440117,
0.004508335143327713,
0.012001922354102135,
0.012108154594898224,
-0.02240542136132717,
0.01802661456167698,
0.01908482424914837,
0.01923668570816517,
0.031878791749477386,
0.006262505427002907,
-0.00640634261071682,
-0.0062729716300964355,
-0.034600697457790375,
0.00887735839933157,
0.03742985799908638,
0.07309359312057495,
0.013521275483071804,
-0.029971975833177567,
-0.012133536860346794,
-0.005052048712968826,
-0.0157562755048275,
-0.04047929123044014,
0.006719515658915043,
0.006894416641443968,
-0.00903337076306343,
0.0001456710451748222,
0.0032507532741874456,
0.032299406826496124,
0.03470339626073837,
0.028056155890226364,
-0.02837264910340309,
0.03322698175907135,
0.014775102026760578,
0.026234110817313194,
0.01462384220212698,
0.03947410359978676,
-0.033605970442295074,
0.04294591397047043,
0.01528339833021164,
-0.03566531091928482,
-0.05273781716823578,
-0.02811579406261444,
-0.05895273759961128,
0.04430894926190376,
0.02732268162071705,
0.05443032085895538,
-0.023807896301150322,
-0.053005021065473557,
-0.016414809972047806,
0.021209321916103363,
-0.1435786634683609,
-0.03378935903310776,
0.01787174679338932,
0.004471638239920139,
-0.005682408344000578,
0.013265999034047127,
-0.0016667582094669342,
-0.005458552855998278,
-0.002712829736992717,
0.04748579114675522,
0.01224262174218893,
-0.04516586661338806,
-0.017605623230338097,
0.010008533485233784,
0.017050307244062424,
-0.031214643269777298,
0.001349511556327343,
0.014182095415890217,
0.004470312036573887,
-0.03502093255519867,
-0.007779968436807394,
-0.02108505368232727,
0.02508903108537197,
-0.01104537583887577,
0.0018072185339406133,
0.00824491772800684,
0.029849931597709656,
-0.014871833845973015,
-0.05196566879749298,
0.004038539249449968,
-0.06042126566171646,
-0.023782575502991676,
-0.00727800140157342,
0.03826519101858139,
0.009203028865158558,
0.018899766728281975,
0.0457206666469574,
-0.04757685959339142,
0.0024665198288857937,
0.011804699897766113,
0.035345882177352905,
0.080176442861557,
-0.021336881443858147,
0.02350175566971302,
-0.010297813452780247,
-0.067927286028862,
0.016240186989307404,
-0.013172316364943981,
-0.05544353276491165,
0.011319548822939396,
-0.019707635045051575,
0.0002181199670303613,
-0.012367649003863335,
0.007451039273291826,
-0.009059987962245941,
0.0074826618656516075,
0.06290992349386215,
0.045244697481393814,
-0.0009869907516986132,
0.01823536492884159,
-0.02307022549211979,
-0.05782544985413551,
0.053114257752895355,
0.0103624127805233,
-0.036168213933706284,
0.01536042895168066,
0.0012651296565309167,
-0.010211683809757233,
0.02146715670824051,
-0.01786012575030327,
-0.036039311438798904,
-0.05070653185248375,
0.041125353425741196,
-0.01151927188038826,
0.00042893181671388447,
-0.00043831844232045114,
0.02091998979449272,
-0.012328558601439,
-0.005637675989419222,
-0.06081096827983856,
-0.00806362647563219,
-0.007641557604074478,
0.003957411274313927,
0.03298385813832283,
0.006177890580147505,
0.041359346359968185,
0.015547657385468483,
0.02070116065442562,
0.026452163234353065,
0.23733264207839966,
0.04516453295946121,
-0.018461816012859344,
-0.004293509759008884,
0.018517030403017998,
0.0024591784458607435,
0.02407967858016491,
0.01624109596014023,
-0.0023324331268668175,
-0.015346967615187168,
-0.023163266479969025,
0.016880126670002937,
0.04839511215686798,
0.030592545866966248,
-0.04697387292981148,
-0.05623309314250946,
-0.03146178275346756,
-0.045117948204278946,
0.06575115770101547,
-0.023232100531458855,
0.019035540521144867,
-0.0003663947281893343,
0.032976701855659485,
0.021350039169192314,
-0.09219342470169067,
-0.023146281018853188,
0.002713200869038701,
-0.02385968342423439,
-0.02100035548210144,
0.00569255230948329,
-0.03410198912024498,
-0.027277158573269844,
0.024412332102656364,
-0.01611165516078472,
-0.01599126309156418,
0.032714612782001495,
0.01199742779135704,
0.0002826074487529695,
-0.028333893045783043,
0.03383959084749222,
0.03106650337576866,
0.0061979168094694614,
-0.024494215846061707,
-0.03157094866037369,
0.041570402681827545,
0.020515581592917442,
0.01458290871232748,
-0.0006092709372751415,
0.0014920945977792144,
0.03135146200656891,
-0.07861915975809097,
-0.0031817066483199596,
-0.02880057319998741,
0.008426826447248459,
-0.017544390633702278,
0.04057667776942253,
-0.012811103835701942,
0.03912343829870224,
0.018719373270869255,
0.0013660405529662967,
0.0403311550617218,
0.03466547280550003,
-0.02676169015467167,
0.016080014407634735,
-0.009586558677256107,
0.02693185769021511,
-0.01381592731922865,
-0.011702326126396656,
0.05461108684539795,
0.002351969014853239,
-0.014546115882694721,
0.033780287951231,
0.01383610162883997,
0.04376104474067688,
0.021756786853075027,
0.038967281579971313,
0.01416452880948782,
0.011489322409033775,
-0.01637427881360054,
-0.023182986304163933,
-0.04492683708667755,
-0.06012096256017685,
0.006291124038398266,
0.021493321284651756,
0.022211013361811638,
-0.0024086160119622946,
-0.00948339980095625,
0.06486079096794128,
0.025570977479219437,
-0.03577369078993797,
-0.020250769332051277,
-0.03728507459163666,
-0.017142662778496742,
0.030395491048693657,
-0.03828801214694977,
0.015274159610271454,
0.03528880700469017,
-0.012012636289000511,
-0.02928917668759823,
0.001941358670592308,
0.005678640678524971,
-0.0037940789479762316,
-0.013324889354407787,
0.018150335177779198,
-0.016382088884711266,
-0.02879396080970764,
0.0068475110456347466,
0.003560722805559635,
-0.05653868615627289,
-0.021576853469014168,
0.044541697949171066,
0.0010770111111924052,
-0.024164119735360146,
0.006566139869391918,
0.022013913840055466,
0.041081503033638,
-0.0479523204267025,
0.040658049285411835,
0.03230353072285652,
0.01762915961444378,
-0.021427100524306297,
0.019622744992375374,
-0.0173716451972723,
0.018886683508753777,
-0.03352363407611847,
-0.04424723982810974,
-0.03277464956045151,
-0.028226172551512718,
-0.0021316590718925,
0.031772539019584656,
0.009422045201063156,
0.004671030677855015,
-0.014680363237857819,
-0.0041231331415474415,
0.0722370520234108,
0.013674736022949219,
-0.0569378137588501,
0.028060436248779297,
0.004888466559350491,
-0.00030269738635979593,
-0.04829952493309975,
-0.003440963104367256,
-0.045026689767837524,
-0.0028712591156363487,
0.01833978481590748,
-0.003134965430945158,
-0.014922438189387321,
0.009265400469303131,
-0.07950064539909363,
-0.007819260470569134,
0.004789731465280056,
-0.02587396465241909,
-0.016366370022296906,
-0.031217902898788452,
-0.03594734147191048,
-0.009227379225194454,
0.028433319181203842,
0.0027297737542539835,
0.010977761819958687,
-0.04612412676215172,
-0.023053409531712532,
-0.042001064866781235,
-0.01333056204020977,
0.087593212723732,
-0.007546123582869768,
0.03907502070069313,
0.016016565263271332,
0.07678113877773285,
0.03171897679567337,
-0.0035572987981140614,
-0.009638677351176739,
-0.06614869087934494,
0.020569058135151863,
0.025836007669568062,
0.049018025398254395,
0.10016647726297379,
0.01898428611457348,
0.014839572831988335,
-0.007221500389277935,
-0.0026851773727685213,
-0.003811090951785445,
0.047221262007951736,
-0.02420683391392231,
-0.004933664575219154,
-0.020720018073916435,
-0.0058551267720758915,
0.0342191606760025,
-0.03434203937649727,
0.03787592053413391,
0.008900224231183529,
-0.005042938981205225,
0.08086821436882019,
-0.019186967983841896,
-0.019192088395357132,
0.03337625786662102,
0.009306971915066242,
0.006871742196381092,
-0.00338120199739933,
-0.007085548248142004,
-0.03502652421593666,
-0.02459535375237465,
-0.013056105002760887,
0.004809258505702019,
0.002541224006563425,
0.06662381440401077,
-0.024168293923139572,
0.0037496767472475767,
0.016378801316022873,
-0.04072029888629913,
0.01375945471227169,
0.0375710092484951,
0.019087916240096092,
-0.025560172274708748,
0.0035859388299286366,
-0.04576482996344566,
0.017189864069223404,
0.01929536461830139,
0.04295147955417633,
-0.030097248032689095,
-0.036549512296915054,
-0.01616082713007927,
-0.021174266934394836,
0.06109268218278885,
-0.07057646661996841,
0.0019239274552091956,
0.06684131175279617,
-0.016973325982689857,
-0.042636215686798096,
-0.018708836287260056,
0.01015604380518198,
0.005032820161432028,
-0.040097661316394806,
0.027085112407803535,
-0.013235879130661488,
0.02652946300804615,
-0.015766706317663193,
0.03716263920068741,
0.004697196651250124,
0.02774031274020672,
0.007975441403687,
0.034649115055799484,
0.002963607432320714,
0.009748362936079502,
0.06194111332297325,
-0.018901262432336807,
0.021622207015752792,
0.00921423640102148,
-0.036710988730192184,
0.023986320942640305,
-0.0033596630673855543,
-0.014716182835400105,
0.02691716141998768,
0.050213754177093506,
-0.028726724907755852,
-0.0011995953973382711,
-0.02514001540839672,
0.023368777707219124,
0.02346702665090561,
-0.0785326436161995,
-0.037583354860544205,
0.0115900207310915,
0.04219415783882141,
-0.00011655005073407665,
-0.03222508728504181,
0.019445884972810745,
-0.07452493906021118,
0.017344344407320023,
-0.024995911866426468,
-0.026301970705389977,
-0.019116336479783058,
-0.022236300632357597,
-0.01631215028464794,
-0.02861884795129299,
-0.03797367587685585,
-0.051657307893037796,
0.012093178927898407,
-0.040475212037563324,
0.02836090512573719,
0.02187541127204895,
-0.03566308692097664,
0.033931031823158264,
-0.019787967205047607,
0.01006629690527916,
0.03414062783122063,
-0.0011483742855489254,
-0.00013071206922177225,
0.023534484207630157,
-0.0005265854997560382,
0.004941702354699373,
-0.031477756798267365,
0.013341325335204601,
0.03126455843448639,
0.006849613972008228,
0.006543268915265799,
-0.024553339928388596,
0.02189602144062519,
-0.01774980127811432,
0.06229560449719429,
-0.03925739973783493,
0.009284064173698425,
-0.004901483189314604,
-0.014503585174679756,
-0.042892590165138245,
-0.022049153223633766,
0.0012577405432239175,
-0.031340472400188446,
0.013324259780347347,
-0.06326454132795334,
-0.009122729301452637,
0.05451662093400955,
-0.006480152253061533,
-0.045682985335588455,
-0.03118874691426754,
-0.01985778845846653,
-0.002782940398901701,
0.014157894067466259,
0.006634194403886795,
0.002629050984978676,
0.024566246196627617,
0.0034692890476435423,
0.016697870567440987,
0.0007153636543080211,
-0.0463455393910408,
-0.022788533940911293,
-0.06022960692644119,
0.018696609884500504,
0.017814336344599724,
-0.007057914976030588,
-0.01744728721678257,
-0.005646496079862118,
-0.01784014329314232,
-0.024301212280988693,
-0.01947159320116043,
0.010272313840687275,
0.06443159282207489,
0.016778666526079178,
-0.040919676423072815,
-0.04827366769313812,
0.0589764267206192,
-0.007140278350561857,
0.005892911925911903,
-0.05142022669315338,
0.08907022327184677,
-0.018138529732823372,
0.009427114389836788,
0.00018796954827848822,
0.004667419008910656,
0.012274333275854588,
-0.0015271799638867378,
0.05101709067821503,
-0.0012282180832698941,
-0.026063475757837296,
-0.028021564707159996,
-0.03258774057030678,
0.025395089760422707,
-0.008089575916528702,
-0.00824629794806242,
-0.0026774706784635782,
0.019618719816207886,
-0.023172810673713684,
-0.029323577880859375,
0.05621366202831268,
-0.025660675019025803,
-0.00137723155785352,
0.026825616136193275,
0.0030551624950021505,
-0.01048488449305296,
-0.0027451040223240852,
0.014180521480739117,
-0.01670168712735176,
0.012157087214291096,
-0.03332579508423805,
0.02231689728796482,
0.022491440176963806,
-0.017924461513757706,
-0.03344333916902542,
0.007085517048835754,
-0.037322018295526505,
-0.03669301047921181,
-0.03748023509979248,
-0.014985252171754837,
-0.07665523141622543,
-0.032132603228092194,
0.006241311319172382,
0.02066517062485218,
-0.001969576347619295,
0.007794369477778673,
0.02121216431260109,
-0.08430571854114532,
0.029108550399541855,
-0.017835985869169235,
0.05149862915277481,
-0.03397360444068909,
0.00283934292383492,
-0.13399344682693481,
0.007423392031341791,
-0.03468499705195427,
0.01440846174955368,
-0.06096285954117775,
-0.008792219683527946,
-0.030917063355445862,
-0.01081128977239132,
0.005316190421581268,
0.002925446955487132,
-0.022010235115885735,
-0.038295526057481766,
0.08008840680122375,
-0.007544530555605888,
-0.04293535649776459,
0.02749839797616005,
-0.027935251593589783,
-0.0608510859310627,
-0.011172971688210964,
0.015900779515504837,
-0.002705235965549946,
0.03388175368309021,
0.011729114688932896,
-0.03306438401341438,
-0.00982812512665987,
-0.00474076671525836,
-0.06518849730491638,
-0.020032858476042747,
-0.014221398159861565,
-0.0021835847292095423,
-0.051194511353969574,
-0.02235974557697773,
0.002223733812570572,
0.009473003447055817,
-0.020423859357833862,
0.012375925667583942,
0.008999996818602085,
-0.010123093612492085,
-0.05192629247903824,
0.00796116329729557,
-0.008181947283446789,
0.010820126160979271,
-0.017116239294409752,
0.008779183961451054,
-0.003833250841125846,
0.02650570310652256,
0.004791404120624065,
0.008493497036397457,
-0.05705970153212547,
-0.035018328577280045,
-0.017925908789038658,
0.011305427178740501,
-0.05972781404852867,
0.035145875066518784,
0.026557518169283867,
0.007310373242944479,
-0.0311092771589756,
-0.01715814135968685,
-0.047523774206638336,
0.06372376531362534,
-0.011443231254816055,
-0.030982032418251038,
-0.028820570558309555,
-0.022917835041880608,
0.0486413948237896,
0.009182835929095745,
-0.022359278053045273,
0.007650666404515505,
0.005040296819061041,
0.015366478823125362,
0.028842173516750336,
-0.048994019627571106,
0.03530072048306465,
-0.02448396198451519,
0.00045490922639146447,
0.0007369429222308099,
0.015864256769418716,
-0.01950610615313053,
-0.006375459022819996,
0.03284445405006409,
0.013195637613534927,
-0.009472581557929516,
-0.03426368162035942,
-0.007130941841751337,
0.0501934215426445,
0.04474325478076935,
-0.02320874109864235,
-0.04146861657500267,
0.08158870041370392,
-0.042751800268888474,
-0.0649145171046257,
-0.011873277835547924,
-0.013931873254477978,
0.04291749745607376,
-0.04072589799761772,
0.05416411533951759,
0.007521876599639654,
-0.03699704632163048,
-0.03217343986034393,
0.00238431291654706,
-0.013629799708724022,
-0.050109051167964935,
0.022765740752220154,
0.01945023611187935,
-0.017023811116814613,
0.01723283901810646,
-0.01845179870724678,
0.03533525764942169,
0.0012526224600151181,
-0.0077120340429246426,
-0.014630327001214027,
-0.02412155270576477,
-0.0020135475788265467,
-0.02295578643679619,
-0.019356567412614822,
-0.000004919088496535551,
-0.010322053916752338,
0.0043572960421442986,
-0.035314418375492096,
0.0385490283370018,
0.02761426381766796,
-0.01633283868432045,
0.042487166821956635,
-0.016274981200695038,
-0.017649583518505096,
0.06066184490919113,
0.050829824060201645,
-0.001266558188945055,
0.01436524000018835,
-0.020764779299497604,
0.043199338018894196,
-0.03027348779141903,
-0.01940041035413742,
0.019149936735630035,
-0.010593644343316555,
0.02684754505753517,
-0.011166539043188095,
0.010414602234959602,
-0.03275659307837486,
-0.05401144549250603,
0.03072994016110897,
-0.042853206396102905,
-0.0137534374371171,
0.01546345092356205,
-0.029634613543748856,
0.013918973505496979,
-0.004340129438787699,
0.0128262834623456,
-0.05479703098535538,
-0.04928308352828026,
-0.020733369514346123,
-0.0030333935283124447,
0.026607343927025795,
0.052417051047086716,
0.01453543733805418,
-0.03719022870063782,
0.02686564438045025,
0.012474325485527515,
-0.0010025841183960438,
0.039747901260852814,
0.02668130397796631,
-0.037016361951828,
-0.018580380827188492,
-0.023521050810813904,
-0.02109956182539463,
0.024102644994854927,
-0.016152214258909225,
-0.012770745903253555,
-0.00042957643745467067,
0.006778530310839415,
0.003800127888098359,
0.010117060504853725,
-0.025285571813583374,
0.02907407283782959,
0.00820193625986576,
-0.06308653950691223,
-0.0235989298671484,
0.030442001298069954,
0.034526556730270386,
-0.006799148861318827,
0.037326324731111526,
0.049740880727767944,
0.014970527030527592,
0.02016443759202957,
0.007970675826072693,
0.024851134046912193,
0.027393676340579987,
-0.001469051348976791,
0.004111436661332846,
-0.00999449659138918,
0.006454755086451769,
-0.0012142712948843837,
0.008797156624495983,
-0.01125886756926775,
0.04386945068836212,
0.007621726952493191,
-0.010058054700493813,
0.03713338077068329,
-0.0018269835272803903,
0.06008603423833847,
0.0448559932410717,
-0.013179979287087917,
-0.008301151916384697,
-0.014033769257366657,
-0.022884897887706757,
-0.022940609604120255,
0.0159914568066597,
-0.03038906864821911,
-0.004157515242695808,
0.028519317507743835,
-0.007615340873599052,
-0.027324942871928215,
-0.017811987549066544,
0.07065669447183609,
-0.03237380087375641,
0.021014174446463585,
0.017021778970956802,
-0.011287759989500046,
0.00840967521071434,
0.006799389608204365,
0.01697085238993168,
0.06205755099654198,
-0.02528749592602253,
-0.011139949783682823,
-0.017386427149176598,
-0.0032020669896155596,
-0.005671507678925991,
0.004751147236675024,
0.03824317827820778,
0.0024189085233956575,
-0.020172396674752235,
0.002026043366640806,
-0.013021465390920639,
0.009564108215272427,
0.012215901166200638,
-0.012416651472449303,
-0.011544301174581051,
-0.006965164095163345,
0.0006664723623543978,
-0.00004570904275169596,
0.05286325141787529,
0.025204939767718315,
-0.0009497472201474011,
0.004486046265810728
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:5
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
28A driver employed by Tiger sued Caringbah for an injury he suffered while working on the coach. He did not sue Tiger. It was agreed that, if he had only sued Tiger in its capacity as his employer, then he would not have exceeded the thresholds for recovery found in Division 3 of Part 5 of the WC Act (at [7]).
Caringbah admitted liability to pay damages under the MAC Act and the amount (at [9]). Implicit in that admission was an acceptance that it was the "owner" of the coach (at [9]). It seems that the only defence raised by Caringbah was that its liability should be reduced by reason of s 151Z(2)(c) of the WC Act.
It operated to reduce the injured driver's damages by the amount that Caringbah would have recovered by way of contribution from Tiger as a joint tortfeasor but could not as a result of the operation of Division 3 of Part 5 of the WC Act.
The injured driver countered this defence by contending that both Tiger and Caringbah were "owners" of the coach and thus there was no reduction because that meant that Tiger was liable under the MAC Act (as s 151E(2) rendered the restrictions in Division 3 of Part 5 of the WC Act inapplicable: see [17] above).
The District Court found that Tiger was also an "owner" and thus there was no reduction in the verdict against Caringbah (at [12]).
29Zurich's subsequent attempt at recovery from GIO involved an application of the extension of the double insurance principle discussed in AMP v QBE as Zurich and GIO did not insure the same insured. In the Court of Appeal, GIO resisted recovery on two bases. First it contended that Zurich was not obliged to indemnify Caringbah because it was not the, or even an, owner of the coach (at [50]).
Second it contended that Tiger's liability had not been proved between Zurich and GIO and it was not bound by the District Court's findings because neither Tiger nor GIO were party to the District Court proceedings (at [51]). This aspect of Zurich is not relevant to this case as it does not involve any equivalent of Tiger. The only "common insured" is Megbuy.
30In relation to GIO's first contention, Giles JA held:
"57.Since contribution involves sharing a common burden, the first insurer must establish the liability for which it must provide indemnity under its policy.
However, if the liability of the first insurer's insured has been judicially determined or has been the subject of a reasonable compromise, that suffices for contribution, and the second insurer cannot put in issue in contribution proceedings the liability of the common insured.
58.
That is implicit in, for example, Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v Royal Exchange Assurance of London (1965) 82 WN (NSW) Pt 1 468 at 474; C E Heath Underwriting Insurance (Aust) Pty Ltd v State Government Insurance Commission (1983) 34 SASR 1 at 7;
and Drayton v Martin (1996) 67 FLR 1 at 15, and as to compromise reflects the sensible and commercial reality that liability is commonly resolved by settlement and parties should not be required to litigate to a conclusion.
It is consistent with the position in cases such as Edwards v Insurance Office of Australia Ltd (1933) 34 SR (NSW) 88, the cases ultimately turning on the policy wording, under which it is sufficient for an insured claiming against one insurer which has wrongly repudiated its obligation to indemnify to prove that the settlement reached with the injured person was reasonable;
see also The Distillers Co Bio-Chemicals (Aust) Pty Ltd v Ajax Insurance Co Ltd (1974) 130 CLR 1 at 9-10 per Menzies J and 25-6 per Stephen J, and Costi v Rodwell (1985) VR 287 at 289.
Only as an illustration, in the AMP case the liability of Graupner to Mitchell was established by a settlement.
59.There is no reason why this should not be so where there are different insureds rather than a common insured. In the present case the liability of Caringbah to Mr McLellan, if Caringbah was owner of the coach, could not be doubted.
|
[
-0.024309415370225906,
-0.01701529324054718,
-0.02825203910470009,
-0.011971104890108109,
0.002933946903795004,
-0.030059214681386948,
0.006285201292484999,
0.03182297199964523,
-0.017953265458345413,
-0.010521195828914642,
-0.00456345546990633,
-0.024303697049617767,
-0.02351287566125393,
0.010116334073245525,
0.012139136902987957,
-0.022138480097055435,
0.009460230357944965,
0.006363140419125557,
-0.048311371356248856,
-0.01830032281577587,
-0.004670043475925922,
-0.0073777115903794765,
0.04473205655813217,
0.014072035439312458,
-0.0074576749466359615,
0.033505506813526154,
-0.021806731820106506,
-0.010611066594719887,
-0.021814510226249695,
-0.01208618562668562,
-0.016737446188926697,
0.01704745925962925,
-0.008175550028681755,
-0.015313608571887016,
-0.02605094388127327,
-0.03509186953306198,
0.00010634462523739785,
0.012584730982780457,
-0.014270376414060593,
-0.006096134427934885,
-0.01786705106496811,
0.00423736497759819,
0.018672320991754532,
-0.04953231289982796,
0.010008995421230793,
-0.014069772325456142,
-0.010661211796104908,
-0.02967180125415325,
0.009619279764592648,
-0.026033829897642136,
-0.04297926649451256,
0.012250235304236412,
0.058540310710668564,
-0.00629563070833683,
-0.01995011605322361,
0.05056467279791832,
0.048224497586488724,
-0.03734938055276871,
-0.009339428506791592,
-0.022203702479600906,
-0.03192167356610298,
-0.04507911205291748,
-0.014373589307069778,
0.008456717245280743,
0.012770861387252808,
0.05908278375864029,
-0.016036979854106903,
-0.03030812181532383,
-0.026700379326939583,
-0.048640213906764984,
-0.019142018631100655,
0.018929416313767433,
-0.025126086547970772,
0.00776981795206666,
-0.07062413543462753,
0.02297825738787651,
0.035373277962207794,
0.008956464007496834,
0.0045499615371227264,
-0.02272668108344078,
0.021841201931238174,
-0.015090749599039555,
0.008084198459982872,
0.0055106692016124725,
-0.04568595439195633,
0.00565436901524663,
-0.03140727058053017,
0.023918338119983673,
-0.01581481844186783,
-0.006499425042420626,
-0.019982049241662025,
-0.06116967275738716,
0.011097307316958904,
0.01576334610581398,
0.03055913746356964,
0.011655060574412346,
-0.08336925506591797,
-0.008720030076801777,
0.027372851967811584,
0.022041277959942818,
0.04043235257267952,
0.03235602378845215,
0.02324855700135231,
-0.029018107801675797,
-0.0010070644784718752,
-0.005679836496710777,
-0.003401347668841481,
0.07196462154388428,
-0.00047463789815083146,
-0.015996625646948814,
0.0023490500170737505,
0.03336925432085991,
0.016628654673695564,
0.047121353447437286,
-0.028202474117279053,
-0.022934651002287865,
-0.01097500417381525,
-0.032654836773872375,
0.0003500301972962916,
-0.023122400045394897,
0.01754486747086048,
0.03405729681253433,
0.047019731253385544,
-0.01525202952325344,
-0.033778734505176544,
-0.027818460017442703,
0.00523650785908103,
0.0035104313865303993,
-0.04166404902935028,
0.0032418882474303246,
-0.0017981280107051134,
0.018892118707299232,
-0.002382517559453845,
-0.045050472021102905,
0.009771612472832203,
-0.019212156534194946,
0.040245383977890015,
-0.03661993891000748,
-0.026498930528759956,
-0.044144824147224426,
0.010355329141020775,
0.03599744662642479,
0.01746102049946785,
-0.03903700038790703,
0.030393777415156364,
-0.0024081002920866013,
0.01831802912056446,
-0.004863257985562086,
-0.017522742971777916,
-0.0026263748295605183,
0.003814223688095808,
-0.0054511199705302715,
0.01868671365082264,
-0.04413614049553871,
0.03184162452816963,
-0.02728433534502983,
0.014316349290311337,
-0.01370915025472641,
0.015772921964526176,
0.03538540378212929,
-0.008898885920643806,
0.05833379179239273,
0.025057563558220863,
-0.015316921286284924,
0.008185495622456074,
-0.00502372719347477,
-0.03379721939563751,
0.04353092238306999,
-0.010286803357303143,
-0.02583010122179985,
-0.004419206641614437,
0.060283560305833817,
0.00260161398909986,
0.0124375494197011,
0.024351874366402626,
0.04192967340350151,
0.030765758827328682,
0.021850869059562683,
0.014779490418732166,
-0.03463496267795563,
-0.00855901651084423,
0.0133043322712183,
0.0042008208110928535,
-0.028010400012135506,
0.005651967599987984,
0.010983306914567947,
0.001391046098433435,
-0.05276475474238396,
0.04577469825744629,
0.004965066444128752,
-0.0009046278428286314,
-0.0346929095685482,
-0.01346376072615385,
-0.010817659087479115,
-0.0066581834107637405,
-0.005231921095401049,
0.033492207527160645,
-0.01984713040292263,
0.010376568883657455,
-0.011684520170092583,
-0.02790503203868866,
0.02309565246105194,
0.07430296391248703,
0.015221931040287018,
-0.040341198444366455,
0.009986274875700474,
-0.06390325725078583,
0.027532638981938362,
0.036869753152132034,
-0.06759922206401825,
-0.007126362528651953,
-0.03708542510867119,
-0.030576350167393684,
0.013505336828529835,
-0.015979181975126266,
-0.013970251195132732,
0.04678966477513313,
-0.005948568694293499,
0.06921675056219101,
-0.013410244137048721,
0.015696857124567032,
0.02766668051481247,
-0.006657053716480732,
0.054059404879808426,
0.05801907926797867,
-0.0050897845067083836,
-0.011455650441348553,
0.020112136378884315,
0.007561111822724342,
-0.041774798184633255,
0.0003149707627017051,
0.03109433688223362,
-0.031041838228702545,
-0.024259233847260475,
0.010525803081691265,
0.02319231815636158,
0.029915660619735718,
-0.020854996517300606,
0.016096416860818863,
0.0018169486429542303,
-0.01972205936908722,
0.003521348349750042,
0.06433094292879105,
-0.013644483871757984,
-0.026182526722550392,
-0.03360552713274956,
0.02255723439157009,
0.04297841712832451,
-0.010819182731211185,
-0.019120093435049057,
0.00705585815012455,
-0.0057319896295666695,
0.009967844001948833,
-0.005493598524481058,
0.00195141916628927,
0.022525962442159653,
0.033282455056905746,
-0.00876467116177082,
-0.0009425661992281675,
-0.014922205358743668,
0.02919135056436062,
0.0175976250320673,
0.03312047943472862,
0.009429516270756721,
-0.03527439385652542,
-0.028209351003170013,
-0.03758423402905464,
-0.04045132175087929,
-0.043914299458265305,
0.00182500877417624,
0.009415600448846817,
0.029466865584254265,
-0.04249552637338638,
-0.005651402752846479,
0.046585820615291595,
0.049989812076091766,
0.04313970357179642,
0.001140580396167934,
0.023858653381466866,
0.005451799836009741,
0.004696693737059832,
0.017300071194767952,
0.02166053280234337,
0.02752598375082016,
0.014928237535059452,
0.024123823270201683,
-0.01434575580060482,
0.009174280799925327,
-0.009233619086444378,
-0.04370899870991707,
0.013052965514361858,
-0.024502776563167572,
0.08609986305236816,
-0.03850754350423813,
-0.06327575445175171,
0.0028224876150488853,
0.013846093788743019,
-0.16579174995422363,
0.01692475751042366,
0.04401616007089615,
0.04406445100903511,
-0.01851743832230568,
0.04395448789000511,
-0.00981501117348671,
0.0011197987478226423,
0.007751598488539457,
-0.0027576256543397903,
0.009392458014190197,
-0.06572727113962173,
-0.01970120146870613,
0.042722009122371674,
-0.0008889013552106917,
-0.009268554858863354,
-0.03831223398447037,
-0.014065012335777283,
0.004203964956104755,
-0.014012211933732033,
0.02442869544029236,
-0.001775408978573978,
-0.029064469039440155,
-0.02416265197098255,
0.012058993801474571,
-0.013381725177168846,
0.035794325172901154,
0.007755615748465061,
-0.0410669669508934,
0.009700451977550983,
-0.053666818886995316,
0.007116456516087055,
-0.012417550198733807,
0.0344056561589241,
-0.02039836347103119,
-0.003506442764773965,
0.032744672149419785,
-0.005148731172084808,
0.008335750550031662,
-0.027852313593029976,
0.040192924439907074,
0.0667903795838356,
-0.020624296739697456,
0.022920189425349236,
-0.022918561473488808,
-0.03072422556579113,
-0.015559791587293148,
-0.02868049219250679,
-0.0412430465221405,
0.018472136929631233,
0.029210742563009262,
-0.036098018288612366,
-0.008987277746200562,
0.0012411242350935936,
-0.011225666850805283,
-0.02702905423939228,
0.013015002943575382,
0.03257162496447563,
0.03943191096186638,
-0.008668198250234127,
-0.036495957523584366,
-0.03208350017666817,
-0.0019534132443368435,
0.03381848335266113,
-0.03968694806098938,
0.05408855155110359,
-0.002662977436557412,
0.024522842839360237,
0.03552619740366936,
-0.019004950299859047,
-0.014441805891692638,
-0.06815250217914581,
0.03267525136470795,
-0.0062447236850857735,
-0.017885848879814148,
-0.0033079981803894043,
0.040571775287389755,
-0.01006691437214613,
-0.044001512229442596,
-0.09373310953378677,
0.013787871226668358,
-0.0030098925344645977,
0.04134099557995796,
0.0359826423227787,
0.002588290488347411,
0.015794701874256134,
0.02644277922809124,
0.030238069593906403,
0.01804482936859131,
0.25479060411453247,
0.009350613690912724,
-0.027717500925064087,
0.004051025025546551,
0.01701069436967373,
-0.02318689413368702,
0.016730252653360367,
0.035963814705610275,
0.0064903791062533855,
-0.02765960991382599,
-0.08830151706933975,
0.029051288962364197,
0.021828625351190567,
0.022089483216404915,
-0.021554043516516685,
-0.03355831280350685,
-0.024074118584394455,
-0.031464289873838425,
0.06338351219892502,
-0.03672024607658386,
0.059312500059604645,
-0.03796008601784706,
0.06206316500902176,
0.03348417207598686,
-0.05317714437842369,
-0.04496875777840614,
-0.017261842265725136,
0.0242446456104517,
0.0189219918102026,
0.01505983155220747,
-0.01736578904092312,
0.00946387741714716,
0.027184680104255676,
-0.022667933255434036,
-0.001522587612271309,
0.024904463440179825,
0.023393183946609497,
-0.0015633461298421025,
0.0005238855956122279,
0.052874933928251266,
0.013178016059100628,
-0.05265171453356743,
0.017766732722520828,
-0.014740961603820324,
0.05096958950161934,
-0.015225466340780258,
-0.013773215003311634,
0.011021388694643974,
-0.04621865227818489,
0.016862303018569946,
-0.059903115034103394,
0.001540972269140184,
-0.024096354842185974,
0.007752640172839165,
-0.041797809302806854,
0.032344747334718704,
0.001427746145054698,
0.010868596844375134,
-0.011291834525763988,
-0.010794694535434246,
-0.0029215675313025713,
-0.008913257159292698,
-0.03536777198314667,
0.01627538539469242,
-0.0010339790023863316,
0.029909802600741386,
-0.05752375349402428,
-0.01952137053012848,
0.0340459942817688,
-0.006548321805894375,
0.03240993991494179,
0.025250237435102463,
-0.0074539161287248135,
0.027777425944805145,
0.04139495640993118,
0.03235030174255371,
0.022009791806340218,
0.015366174280643463,
0.004041927866637707,
-0.01856105774641037,
-0.06939666718244553,
-0.03484427556395531,
0.0003965858486481011,
-0.009084376506507397,
0.0064473506063222885,
0.008662690408527851,
-0.015892140567302704,
0.04820609465241432,
0.03061078116297722,
-0.03834942728281021,
0.011869977228343487,
-0.014671065844595432,
0.00879791472107172,
0.02495870739221573,
0.00688210129737854,
-0.0018729738658294082,
0.006277603097259998,
0.01628141663968563,
-0.016240153461694717,
-0.018289992585778236,
0.04332367703318596,
-0.018045302480459213,
-0.017913218587636948,
-0.029616663232445717,
0.047347526997327805,
0.06368737667798996,
0.021534422412514687,
0.006338087841868401,
-0.03552395477890968,
-0.029650986194610596,
0.023437311872839928,
0.021609479561448097,
-0.001757209887728095,
-0.0043341778218746185,
0.02488773502409458,
0.030308548361063004,
-0.001742545166052878,
0.023370632901787758,
0.04098651185631752,
0.01491555105894804,
-0.01323676761239767,
-0.006352928001433611,
-0.03971490263938904,
0.0014889921294525266,
0.006394986994564533,
0.0033124079927802086,
-0.0008620259468443692,
-0.05367293581366539,
-0.0037931790575385094,
0.0005420015659183264,
0.021662425249814987,
0.013677140697836876,
-0.019705889746546745,
-0.00873761810362339,
0.04237236827611923,
-0.02286168746650219,
-0.010758196003735065,
0.026757407933473587,
0.045982133597135544,
-0.020836343988776207,
-0.016239648684859276,
0.02650751732289791,
-0.04009801149368286,
-0.0011113467626273632,
-0.002201875438913703,
0.017084280028939247,
-0.012356847524642944,
0.0357200987637043,
-0.017823703587055206,
0.01675712876021862,
-0.002786851255223155,
-0.02044513262808323,
-0.02040901966392994,
-0.022524433210492134,
-0.007182441186159849,
-0.02730696089565754,
0.007762000896036625,
-0.03295322135090828,
0.02304832823574543,
-0.026648154482245445,
-0.0125647047534585,
-0.035538945347070694,
0.020931055769324303,
0.03689877316355705,
0.048900213092565536,
0.07341360300779343,
0.010749079287052155,
0.05990615114569664,
0.03186408057808876,
-0.022162029519677162,
0.039526522159576416,
-0.024120314046740532,
-0.006304496433585882,
0.01808803714811802,
0.030276095494627953,
0.06331528723239899,
0.04114853963255882,
-0.0032720931340008974,
0.03982967510819435,
-0.00032515349448658526,
-0.008038574829697609,
0.02987910807132721,
-0.04912726581096649,
0.0670371875166893,
-0.008857565000653267,
-0.008415126241743565,
0.0034508826211094856,
-0.028286410495638847,
0.000781736453063786,
-0.022250952199101448,
-0.00814888533204794,
0.07665269821882248,
-0.004380007740110159,
-0.017005866393446922,
-0.03127828612923622,
0.02654111012816429,
-0.06580287218093872,
-0.005027724429965019,
0.014646441675722599,
-0.039972249418497086,
-0.025050412863492966,
-0.009854326024651527,
0.037662334740161896,
0.028916742652654648,
0.02605944499373436,
-0.011583415791392326,
-0.037381406873464584,
0.01793462224304676,
-0.04051019996404648,
0.005780580919235945,
0.020511381328105927,
-0.003666124539449811,
-0.044948358088731766,
-0.01985066384077072,
-0.03978561982512474,
0.019666502252221107,
0.0258826594799757,
0.026559025049209595,
0.01590256206691265,
-0.056322529911994934,
0.016704782843589783,
0.002111093606799841,
0.033709798008203506,
-0.07622813433408737,
0.029512163251638412,
0.057018864899873734,
-0.0381985679268837,
-0.04695725068449974,
0.005714062601327896,
-0.022205771878361702,
0.010547763668000698,
-0.020200330764055252,
0.0017873374745249748,
-0.011751823127269745,
0.0047451495192945,
-0.016945648938417435,
0.02343808487057686,
0.01607482321560383,
0.05158153548836708,
-0.006999367848038673,
0.058667052537202835,
0.01019427739083767,
-0.030395744368433952,
0.038723595440387726,
-0.007749697659164667,
-0.014691433869302273,
-0.01364485826343298,
-0.023899665102362633,
0.037529926747083664,
0.02971901372075081,
-0.033240798860788345,
0.024606911465525627,
0.023438094183802605,
-0.030930109322071075,
0.0002569369098637253,
0.0016607135767117143,
0.01100728940218687,
0.02334000915288925,
-0.0713629275560379,
-0.01860223524272442,
0.02961607463657856,
0.03683198243379593,
0.008670874871313572,
-0.06610550731420517,
0.00860083382576704,
-0.036772359162569046,
0.02082270383834839,
0.04555391147732735,
-0.024009238928556442,
-0.04224952682852745,
-0.01579243876039982,
0.020486608147621155,
-0.06078062579035759,
-0.05113152787089348,
-0.005992162972688675,
0.008644960820674896,
-0.014715995639562607,
-0.011268362402915955,
0.06273657828569412,
-0.008943334221839905,
0.026014043018221855,
-0.01220015063881874,
-0.027298303321003914,
0.041414011269807816,
-0.018197596073150635,
0.023202544078230858,
0.030556995421648026,
0.023529374971985817,
0.0008144115563482046,
-0.02878435328602791,
0.015861716121435165,
0.016282090917229652,
-0.03126728534698486,
0.017021257430315018,
-0.014433708041906357,
-0.019769301638007164,
-0.0016897963359951973,
0.0651092678308487,
-0.037266992032527924,
0.011169608682394028,
-0.015987303107976913,
0.02442886494100094,
-0.060572635382413864,
-0.04816581681370735,
-0.022625386714935303,
0.031150009483098984,
0.01499623991549015,
-0.027661273255944252,
-0.0034866780042648315,
0.0134275546297431,
-0.008647511713206768,
-0.04135880619287491,
0.013175707310438156,
-0.05655217915773392,
-0.01846950687468052,
0.020045241340994835,
0.016418997198343277,
-0.019773775711655617,
0.007080464158207178,
-0.016630176454782486,
-0.017976870760321617,
-0.02481120266020298,
-0.06118711084127426,
-0.019658051431179047,
-0.04597547650337219,
0.008953150361776352,
0.050157878547906876,
-0.019671784713864326,
-0.04462898522615433,
-0.006693325471132994,
-0.056535374373197556,
-0.0027929572388529778,
-0.007744932547211647,
-0.005487232003360987,
0.06125593185424805,
0.009174993261694908,
-0.03676990792155266,
-0.04403533786535263,
0.012530896812677383,
-0.017002373933792114,
0.011947554536163807,
-0.048950567841529846,
0.0956709086894989,
0.004115654621273279,
0.029334919527173042,
0.007269900292158127,
-0.00509291747584939,
0.0057952213101089,
-0.016599835827946663,
0.002696199342608452,
0.008634040132164955,
-0.007639539893716574,
-0.03847377002239227,
-0.02413407899439335,
0.01521934662014246,
0.006530693732202053,
0.0186370350420475,
0.0005948414909653366,
0.029008004814386368,
-0.008246036246418953,
-0.03878897801041603,
0.02704853005707264,
-0.02446587197482586,
0.0011437300126999617,
0.026738202199339867,
0.027302050963044167,
-0.02962144836783409,
-0.0032092828769236803,
-0.015511583536863327,
-0.01727435365319252,
0.03245598450303078,
0.017980121076107025,
-0.012981916777789593,
0.004148536827415228,
-0.006693341303616762,
0.018088113516569138,
0.007481338921934366,
0.006690597627311945,
-0.034232623875141144,
-0.012985517270863056,
-0.011607153341174126,
-0.04975428059697151,
-0.04827453941106796,
0.010670643299818039,
0.008910523727536201,
-0.05480162426829338,
-0.010909052565693855,
-0.006621470209211111,
0.007027206942439079,
0.005208646412938833,
-0.007668602745980024,
0.04632575437426567,
-0.05050932243466377,
-0.01460181549191475,
-0.12814320623874664,
-0.0025859251618385315,
-0.01294747181236744,
-0.01601596176624298,
-0.0580136738717556,
-0.01557124126702547,
-0.022162510082125664,
0.02997284196317196,
-0.024850163608789444,
-0.04918978735804558,
-0.00455104187130928,
-0.016517721116542816,
0.05182153731584549,
0.0055735548958182335,
-0.041309207677841187,
0.009102278389036655,
-0.027718285098671913,
-0.03282945230603218,
-0.026933053508400917,
-0.016192641109228134,
0.003135642036795616,
0.021439963951706886,
0.004083623643964529,
-0.017470143735408783,
-0.003736028680577874,
-0.02217831462621689,
-0.06816387176513672,
-0.02533954195678234,
-0.05360020324587822,
-0.01268727332353592,
-0.024370478466153145,
-0.00969828013330698,
-0.0022198704537004232,
0.01385769248008728,
-0.001988818636164069,
0.0058904970064759254,
-0.004451004788279533,
0.0040303063578903675,
-0.03678520768880844,
-0.01569325476884842,
0.013314909301698208,
0.02415573224425316,
-0.014710920862853527,
-0.003457902232185006,
0.02478172443807125,
0.023486776277422905,
-0.01790856197476387,
-0.005858392920345068,
-0.070558562874794,
-0.035386569797992706,
-0.03910224139690399,
-0.008701594546437263,
-0.019113918766379356,
0.03551401197910309,
0.007102223578840494,
0.0030833599157631397,
-0.025544000789523125,
0.0058858077973127365,
0.02140476554632187,
0.08946815878152847,
0.004730874206870794,
-0.008021024987101555,
-0.038775812834501266,
0.007055146619677544,
0.03552927076816559,
0.035433780401945114,
-0.037604235112667084,
0.004894436337053776,
-0.013903188519179821,
0.02003359980881214,
0.04378409683704376,
-0.03489261493086815,
0.0019066864624619484,
-0.03288652375340462,
-0.0010794044937938452,
0.028788631781935692,
0.008762074634432793,
0.0004907469265162945,
-0.032891061156988144,
-0.014158709906041622,
0.025046439841389656,
0.016292372718453407,
-0.017265528440475464,
-0.05594690889120102,
0.03579730540513992,
0.019163934513926506,
-0.0007546307751908898,
0.0053733764216303825,
0.07566074281930923,
-0.06492435932159424,
-0.04248567298054695,
0.01802690140902996,
-0.02302008680999279,
0.008555197156965733,
-0.04854875057935715,
0.04051470384001732,
0.051505934447050095,
-0.010748637840151787,
-0.01902221515774727,
-0.008270349353551865,
-0.0219621192663908,
-0.05513196066021919,
0.024203725159168243,
0.0092576052993536,
-0.03485362231731415,
0.01425111573189497,
-0.040402039885520935,
0.013181377202272415,
0.004704009275883436,
-0.012372140772640705,
-0.043290603905916214,
-0.02982429414987564,
0.007649618200957775,
-0.047921258956193924,
-0.062095288187265396,
-0.003356831381097436,
0.0317632257938385,
0.05052056908607483,
0.014483507722616196,
0.05089437961578369,
-0.022894153371453285,
-0.01792694441974163,
0.03863149508833885,
-0.009997786022722721,
-0.0016345485346391797,
-0.009623631834983826,
0.03796667605638504,
0.012560730800032616,
0.02422397769987583,
-0.027219148352742195,
0.022143244743347168,
-0.02522173710167408,
0.007882899604737759,
0.0251409150660038,
-0.006183090154081583,
0.0016764621250331402,
-0.01637420617043972,
0.013231739401817322,
-0.02357502281665802,
-0.02970840223133564,
0.025355106219649315,
0.018519042059779167,
-0.01087121106684208,
-0.017350129783153534,
-0.05989823490381241,
-0.015614056028425694,
0.001822365098632872,
0.019088806584477425,
-0.0362396240234375,
-0.04799309000372887,
-0.03813283145427704,
0.002194139640778303,
-0.0019575911574065685,
0.11095453798770905,
0.007574648130685091,
-0.03894266113638878,
0.04330059513449669,
-0.019938183948397636,
-0.0013037192402407527,
0.06725398451089859,
0.0196938868612051,
-0.057284560054540634,
-0.023923136293888092,
-0.06856583803892136,
-0.018140103667974472,
0.03570738434791565,
-0.019661473110318184,
0.0005167625495232642,
-0.0017347745597362518,
0.021151674911379814,
0.005027927923947573,
0.011521824635565281,
-0.028886711224913597,
0.024769147858023643,
0.015154884196817875,
-0.01387304998934269,
0.0089358389377594,
0.02157771587371826,
0.011324718594551086,
-0.003107745200395584,
0.04193085804581642,
0.04172958433628082,
0.04176211729645729,
0.020427703857421875,
0.011316254734992981,
0.0036911391653120518,
0.0043114908039569855,
0.006716989446431398,
-0.014206146821379662,
-0.03860388323664665,
-0.010052824392914772,
0.013038798235356808,
-0.0012249851133674383,
-0.016872474923729897,
0.057332828640937805,
-0.005606252700090408,
-0.004696990828961134,
0.023911261931061745,
0.026848094537854195,
0.04952883720397949,
0.028074247762560844,
-0.04273570328950882,
-0.04143715277314186,
0.001180781633593142,
-0.034210361540317535,
-0.035711869597435,
-0.0031944068614393473,
-0.02259148471057415,
-0.04252515360713005,
0.0485403910279274,
-0.00254659540951252,
-0.013429325073957443,
0.014118065126240253,
0.0713287889957428,
-0.057325415313243866,
0.013819883577525616,
0.0006117943557910621,
-0.00375294778496027,
-0.007640104275196791,
-0.013998212292790413,
0.027758700773119926,
0.079557403922081,
-0.005236688069999218,
-0.05531824007630348,
0.024614375084638596,
0.029101664200425148,
-0.00879279337823391,
0.018236590549349785,
0.0560951866209507,
-0.03394481539726257,
-0.008459496311843395,
0.009782720357179642,
-0.005644329357892275,
0.029824011027812958,
-0.0137668177485466,
0.01949811913073063,
0.04065067693591118,
-0.004815289750695229,
-0.0221859160810709,
-0.0031157294288277626,
0.05030413344502449,
0.030958333984017372,
0.025470789521932602,
0.013486729934811592
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:19
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
To the best of my knowledge there was no defect in the forklift on 7 November 2005. The forklift was fine. Peter Horwood did not contact me that day to make any complaints about the forklift. We operated it the next day.
I have driven the forklift myself many times. It is old but reliable and has no quirks or oddities in its workings. It works every day without incident.
...
The forklift did not need any repair or maintenance as a result of the accident."
93As noted, Mr Capper also gave oral evidence concerning the state of repair and serviceability of the forklift.
The substance of the evidence given by Mr Capper concerning the state of the repair of the forklift did not differ to any significant degree from that set out in his statement of 25 June 2007. He stated that at some time prior to the accident Mr Gillett was responsible for maintaining the forklift.
He said the system of maintenance involved the recording in a log book of any difficulties as noticed by drivers. He stated that there was no defect recorded in the log book concerning the forklift. He stated that after the accident the forklift was investigated by WorkCover and an Improvement Notice was issued.
94When cross-examined on this topic by Mr Cavanagh SC (see above), Mr Capper accepted that, at some point prior to the accident and after Mr Gillett had left the company, his nephew, Mr Ralph, undertook maintenance of the forklift.
He agreed that Mr Ralph was not a qualified mechanic. Further, while he asserted that maintenance records had been kept prior to the accident, he agreed that he had not been able to produce any such records at any time.
He agreed the report of 12 October 2006 was prepared in response to investigation by WorkCover. He denied the suggestion that was put to him that, in the immediate period after the accident involving Mr Horwood, his nephew and another person had arranged for repairs to be done to the forklift and those repairs are reflected in the document that bears the date 12 October 2006.
95I detected considerable sensitivity on the topic of the state of the forklift by Mr Capper in giving evidence. At this point I make two observations about his evidence.
First I consider that any insurer acting reasonably who was in possession of his statement and what it revealed about the qualifications of persons responsible for servicing the forklift and the absence of maintenance records would be distinctly unenthusiastic about defending a proceeding based on his evidence alone.
Second, I do not consider that any such insurer would have had that enthusiasm revived if they had the opportunity, as I did, to observe Mr Capper give evidence on this topic. I will return to this when I address the position at [112] on the basis that my conclusion at [37] was wrong and it was incumbent on me to determine Megbuy's liability de novo.
96CGU also tendered through Mr Capper some maintenance records for the forklift, all of which relate to the period from March 2006 onwards.
97There was also tendered a letter to QBE from its solicitors to its Claims Manager dated 3 August 2007. This preceded the commencement of proceedings. The letter recounted the salient points of the evidence that had been gathered to that time including the material from Mr Oates.
The authors commented that, if Mr Oates' allegations were accurate, then Mr Horwood was "likely to establish that he lost control of the forklift because of a mechanical defect" and that the defect was "well within the knowledge of the insured and its failure to rectify it constituted a breach of its duty of care".
They noted that to that point in time Mr Horwood had not claimed that the loss of control of the forklift had anything to do with the steering mechanism but they apprehended that such an allegation would be made if proceedings were commenced.
|
[
0.012044779025018215,
0.006180237513035536,
-0.015772772952914238,
-0.0264495350420475,
0.014757223427295685,
-0.030080562457442284,
-0.020348936319351196,
0.04165775328874588,
0.006220570299774408,
0.013531681150197983,
-0.0092411944642663,
0.015025168657302856,
0.0002432980400044471,
-0.0008286122465506196,
-0.005943408235907555,
-0.026875808835029602,
0.02515839785337448,
-0.023065686225891113,
-0.05264488235116005,
-0.05270044878125191,
0.010231973603367805,
-0.01413800660520792,
0.06900861859321594,
0.04647549241781235,
0.008553119376301765,
0.03140351176261902,
0.017838407307863235,
0.009960038587450981,
0.0193254966288805,
-0.013389131985604763,
-0.015027095563709736,
-0.014796186238527298,
-0.0065935468301177025,
0.01888038031756878,
0.00010984639811795205,
-0.07868912816047668,
0.013867126777768135,
0.005464594811201096,
-0.025207441300153732,
-0.01747942343354225,
-0.019722770899534225,
-0.02252879925072193,
0.02286585234105587,
-0.029654504731297493,
0.030992256477475166,
-0.04752839729189873,
-0.03305312246084213,
-0.014584111981093884,
0.006801370065659285,
0.006197374314069748,
-0.023119941353797913,
-0.03327180817723274,
0.02938319742679596,
-0.03244433179497719,
0.0011014094343408942,
0.013582760468125343,
0.011340736411511898,
-0.05361740291118622,
-0.053902868181467056,
-0.0145255783572793,
0.0025407408829778433,
-0.01170793641358614,
0.017661653459072113,
0.004710612818598747,
0.012836793437600136,
0.11224781721830368,
-0.030349696055054665,
-0.02614104561507702,
-0.01438822690397501,
-0.026012208312749863,
-0.0031862391624599695,
0.0065801250748336315,
-0.00003152807767037302,
0.009060473181307316,
-0.06470131129026413,
0.013168146833777428,
0.014285830780863762,
0.017409518361091614,
0.001430252566933632,
0.03717740252614021,
0.03045918047428131,
0.030438827350735664,
0.02059735357761383,
0.05286072939634323,
-0.020583316683769226,
-0.021254079416394234,
-0.014369657263159752,
0.03473098203539848,
0.0010235327063128352,
0.002713151276111603,
0.009003693237900734,
-0.017752105370163918,
0.011725551448762417,
-0.03548315912485123,
-0.025153810158371925,
0.012775380164384842,
-0.025690289214253426,
0.027361782267689705,
0.004592726938426495,
-0.0016989530995488167,
0.005672611761838198,
0.013509471900761127,
0.02171587571501732,
-0.017104139551520348,
0.022234631702303886,
-0.024093015119433403,
0.017714867368340492,
0.03733247146010399,
0.02063891291618347,
-0.004896532278507948,
0.017712976783514023,
0.034813981503248215,
-0.028020469471812248,
0.05448388680815697,
-0.0034890533424913883,
-0.003718519350513816,
0.03354386240243912,
-0.02436315454542637,
0.006509731523692608,
-0.018605822697281837,
0.04716429486870766,
0.056598443537950516,
0.05008798465132713,
-0.027930421754717827,
-0.06056218966841698,
-0.004721531178802252,
0.012433218769729137,
-0.06376387178897858,
-0.03543961048126221,
0.009706893004477024,
0.01557818241417408,
0.01695076934993267,
-0.027148792520165443,
-0.0761457085609436,
-0.032677557319402695,
-0.020220432430505753,
0.021602090448141098,
0.03816571086645126,
-0.028705406934022903,
-0.01912269927561283,
0.05170019716024399,
0.0664261057972908,
-0.004427424632012844,
-0.020408209413290024,
0.027922019362449646,
0.0034746720921248198,
0.008615447208285332,
-0.015371652320027351,
0.022299757227301598,
0.015363069251179695,
0.007032583002001047,
0.0019817231222987175,
-0.024652376770973206,
-0.044662956148386,
0.04867997020483017,
-0.03086700662970543,
0.005243061576038599,
-0.005951223894953728,
0.001562075805850327,
0.00450789462774992,
0.010141675360500813,
0.08112397789955139,
-0.020176507532596588,
-0.015532804653048515,
0.023669088259339333,
0.013286732137203217,
0.032985251396894455,
-0.02241385355591774,
-0.027925388887524605,
-0.015873009338974953,
0.016860589385032654,
-0.01696060225367546,
0.010145840235054493,
0.02194819040596485,
0.016149787232279778,
0.0326167494058609,
0.05738582834601402,
0.012731542810797691,
0.047253865748643875,
-0.05911881849169731,
0.000796051521319896,
0.014798413962125778,
0.022666826844215393,
0.005450102966278791,
-0.009382086805999279,
0.034402940422296524,
0.003119378350675106,
-0.02359026111662388,
0.02281101606786251,
0.003980075474828482,
-0.004837562795728445,
-0.030545130372047424,
0.030929751694202423,
0.004889746196568012,
0.015230618417263031,
0.00040261511458083987,
0.03281554579734802,
-0.000805308751296252,
0.010838107205927372,
-0.028195753693580627,
0.0020564210135489702,
0.043058402836322784,
0.06038769707083702,
-0.015580727718770504,
-0.03657643869519234,
0.009725046344101429,
-0.03195430710911751,
0.012724538333714008,
0.007214633282274008,
-0.10226970911026001,
0.016929207369685173,
-0.007769760675728321,
0.023268772289156914,
0.03369306027889252,
-0.0227988101541996,
-0.023728666827082634,
0.01667306199669838,
-0.0072004045359790325,
0.04292067885398865,
-0.033350296318531036,
-0.04204123467206955,
0.004390038549900055,
0.020828526467084885,
-0.010846482589840889,
0.034343112260103226,
0.016519349068403244,
-0.05207647755742073,
0.036654502153396606,
0.023682110011577606,
-0.035058096051216125,
0.062438249588012695,
0.015041027218103409,
0.014216787181794643,
-0.019544733688235283,
0.017780929803848267,
-0.01223044004291296,
0.033659130334854126,
0.02997010573744774,
0.027064302936196327,
0.03304052725434303,
-0.014849850907921791,
-0.007004925049841404,
0.04981241002678871,
-0.023425985127687454,
-0.006016551051288843,
-0.01515079103410244,
0.036165833473205566,
0.014252519235014915,
0.04604024440050125,
0.017292769625782967,
0.02781343273818493,
-0.028371740132570267,
-0.015063139609992504,
0.020786834880709648,
0.03423074260354042,
0.04088103771209717,
0.0366501584649086,
-0.024846864864230156,
0.001081780414097011,
-0.031878747045993805,
-0.006400055717676878,
0.022633731365203857,
0.02844683825969696,
0.0031712031923234463,
-0.04414595663547516,
-0.04048256576061249,
0.00034378733835183084,
-0.07285281270742416,
-0.029062209650874138,
0.012648266740143299,
0.024378105998039246,
-0.005453440826386213,
-0.009637446142733097,
0.02991958148777485,
-0.005488720256835222,
0.009430322796106339,
-0.001330324448645115,
-0.005389591213315725,
0.01962125301361084,
-0.0202479250729084,
0.04934939742088318,
0.01495368592441082,
0.0466146282851696,
-0.042841073125600815,
-0.0008253049454651773,
-0.007702887523919344,
-0.011057988740503788,
-0.03999339044094086,
-0.03548777848482132,
-0.05798527970910072,
0.028171541169285774,
0.027139972895383835,
0.060353659093379974,
0.0006730466266162694,
-0.04193689674139023,
0.01722147688269615,
0.02085915580391884,
-0.14756807684898376,
0.033125750720500946,
-0.007194535341113806,
0.012829963117837906,
0.006617295555770397,
0.024081917479634285,
-0.0005676716682501137,
0.016115637496113777,
-0.038186077028512955,
-0.0344003401696682,
0.026281189173460007,
-0.04973062872886658,
-0.03238915652036667,
-0.0005030702450312674,
-0.02626289427280426,
-0.01314424630254507,
-0.006105034612119198,
-0.0006271146121434867,
0.029699061065912247,
-0.03694251552224159,
-0.018140459433197975,
-0.004221636336296797,
0.022138623520731926,
-0.014924905262887478,
0.020232750102877617,
-0.023589475080370903,
0.041645970195531845,
0.0028108488768339157,
-0.03985545039176941,
-0.03458809852600098,
-0.020564164966344833,
-0.025931045413017273,
-0.005528673995286226,
0.039491645991802216,
-0.0023300056345760822,
-0.004076225683093071,
0.06216816604137421,
-0.09858021140098572,
-0.033173758536577225,
0.005706286057829857,
0.019099442288279533,
0.08864424377679825,
-0.014599188230931759,
0.0005742177600041032,
0.00198395736515522,
-0.07858594506978989,
0.028829246759414673,
-0.00048737836186774075,
-0.07126698642969131,
0.03601846098899841,
-0.018773945048451424,
0.006661156192421913,
-0.00028916203882545233,
0.010386243462562561,
-0.01934862695634365,
-0.03086148574948311,
0.0446309857070446,
0.028370345011353493,
-0.03157712146639824,
0.005546506028622389,
0.0009329239255748689,
-0.07501716166734695,
0.01916157454252243,
0.05927751213312149,
-0.024428872391581535,
0.01979784294962883,
-0.028553269803524017,
-0.028053907677531242,
-0.0035687729250639677,
0.007738609332591295,
-0.03490117937326431,
-0.04769366979598999,
0.04592213034629822,
0.0027130802627652884,
0.01782931387424469,
0.030286919325590134,
-0.003878186922520399,
0.005944377277046442,
-0.011331445537507534,
-0.08539393544197083,
-0.012980792671442032,
0.045258499681949615,
-0.00836594495922327,
0.022989025339484215,
-0.015198483131825924,
0.0485927052795887,
0.01932119019329548,
0.0452679768204689,
0.048348307609558105,
0.25076520442962646,
-0.038854505866765976,
-0.04496832937002182,
-0.004851446952670813,
0.02712731622159481,
0.01688835211098194,
0.03374866023659706,
0.013251305557787418,
0.016721513122320175,
-0.01711893640458584,
-0.029869521036744118,
-0.029963761568069458,
0.009381626732647419,
0.017922885715961456,
-0.007483742665499449,
-0.025969043374061584,
-0.03470704331994057,
-0.058113399893045425,
0.06855650246143341,
-0.010781346820294857,
0.06243818998336792,
-0.0158296599984169,
0.041224405169487,
-0.007169404532760382,
-0.08864320069551468,
-0.016713090240955353,
0.008944063447415829,
0.0068223970010876656,
0.014898944646120071,
0.01876586303114891,
-0.027168020606040955,
-0.0018849715124815702,
0.026277199387550354,
-0.007098592817783356,
-0.03038209117949009,
0.02441086247563362,
-0.014513412490487099,
-0.0006067536887712777,
0.003802906721830368,
0.018457934260368347,
0.022027481347322464,
-0.008824435994029045,
-0.007611625362187624,
-0.021466797217726707,
-0.017361914739012718,
0.0263558067381382,
0.0069049145095050335,
0.01679629646241665,
-0.02552754059433937,
0.02108536846935749,
-0.021770086139440536,
0.012176851741969585,
-0.03545774146914482,
0.003076107008382678,
-0.0004014895821455866,
0.005415756721049547,
-0.0113934725522995,
0.02477513812482357,
0.00529558677226305,
0.03012795001268387,
-0.0005527138710021973,
0.03199326619505882,
0.018605979159474373,
0.03715789318084717,
0.003338081995025277,
0.006360142026096582,
-0.02361251413822174,
-0.017435288056731224,
0.06490553170442581,
-0.011592830531299114,
0.001873238361440599,
0.02593463659286499,
0.003301602555438876,
0.049242809414863586,
0.035124700516462326,
-0.0029831829015165567,
0.027766015380620956,
0.062306489795446396,
-0.02746671810746193,
0.021628810092806816,
-0.0378488153219223,
-0.02904554456472397,
0.01365575846284628,
0.03421889990568161,
0.020810764282941818,
-0.002750427694991231,
-0.01764107309281826,
0.06444832682609558,
0.0228640865534544,
-0.022801252081990242,
-0.0019977872725576162,
-0.04207863658666611,
0.013206182047724724,
0.008851769380271435,
-0.011289278045296669,
-0.0028871179092675447,
0.03368813544511795,
-0.03915597125887871,
-0.00444084731861949,
-0.01980871893465519,
-0.006744998041540384,
-0.004858686123043299,
-0.024320298805832863,
0.022550975903868675,
-0.023097552359104156,
-0.01614164188504219,
0.0005396485794335604,
-0.007592060137540102,
-0.018940839916467667,
-0.015296376310288906,
0.02080099657177925,
0.02972503937780857,
-0.02730405516922474,
-0.009061885997653008,
0.018853511661291122,
0.00719230342656374,
-0.01931370422244072,
0.03439673036336899,
0.0024730011355131865,
0.040947075933218,
-0.027596771717071533,
0.0027419133111834526,
-0.022200623527169228,
-0.007748486008495092,
-0.013999855145812035,
-0.03295913711190224,
-0.05057694762945175,
-0.0832817330956459,
-0.04192497953772545,
0.021383317187428474,
0.0041557541117072105,
-0.01769379898905754,
-0.021087564527988434,
-0.013380885124206543,
0.028675446286797523,
-0.023415513336658478,
-0.005121689289808273,
0.027426034212112427,
-0.021005826070904732,
0.011733957566320896,
-0.028595346957445145,
0.006160301622003317,
-0.05389599874615669,
-0.03439078852534294,
0.008649961091578007,
-0.02652933821082115,
-0.027292082086205482,
0.04634677618741989,
-0.07941856980323792,
-0.016993412747979164,
0.02293277159333229,
0.04506519064307213,
-0.04995321109890938,
-0.020321235060691833,
-0.009256543591618538,
0.022160325199365616,
0.004154248628765345,
0.007303497288376093,
0.0180867500603199,
-0.03950732946395874,
-0.005398341920226812,
-0.010319186374545097,
0.027635905891656876,
0.0573858879506588,
0.019872011616826057,
0.016945017501711845,
0.0048033930361270905,
0.02820654585957527,
0.054142311215400696,
-0.003480717772617936,
0.014999921433627605,
-0.03817461058497429,
0.001537507283501327,
0.04982336238026619,
0.02453797683119774,
0.06451211869716644,
-0.045145224779844284,
0.05361271649599075,
-0.0008484074496664107,
-0.01863778568804264,
-0.004010975826531649,
0.03495257347822189,
-0.03467660769820213,
-0.017333175987005234,
-0.019138356670737267,
-0.0444023534655571,
0.015170575119554996,
-0.024075577035546303,
0.014011146500706673,
-0.0009603796643204987,
-0.030871447175741196,
0.0988508090376854,
-0.04091344773769379,
-0.021491795778274536,
0.029486844316124916,
0.02012932486832142,
0.0006488841609098017,
-0.003145205322653055,
0.021484481170773506,
-0.059773486107587814,
-0.03715863451361656,
0.020802373066544533,
0.01603100262582302,
0.01852782629430294,
0.03343890979886055,
0.020624419674277306,
-0.045522868633270264,
0.028986511752009392,
-0.02850261703133583,
-0.020035218447446823,
0.043652404099702835,
0.04021860286593437,
-0.02627391740679741,
-0.015314916148781776,
-0.04040765017271042,
0.0022684596478939056,
0.041804708540439606,
0.05672994256019592,
0.011572379618883133,
-0.058106400072574615,
-0.013344950042665005,
0.0008282243506982923,
0.02890283614397049,
-0.030531682074069977,
-0.016683144494891167,
0.04376711696386337,
0.0016454358119517565,
-0.02578357793390751,
0.010669870302081108,
-0.016700396314263344,
0.005163145717233419,
-0.03410353884100914,
-0.007489711046218872,
-0.036785632371902466,
0.01030235830694437,
-0.008745177648961544,
0.045295603573322296,
0.03346484154462814,
-0.0020836666226387024,
-0.006133842281997204,
0.03923917934298515,
-0.02680296264588833,
0.005782903637737036,
0.033778123557567596,
-0.0072409347631037235,
-0.00506120640784502,
-0.022941850125789642,
-0.05820317566394806,
-0.014284387230873108,
0.0072187515906989574,
-0.001019496121443808,
0.02447434887290001,
0.03235093131661415,
-0.02710486575961113,
-0.005707907024770975,
-0.0016601315001025796,
-0.006754240021109581,
-0.018747102469205856,
-0.04626966267824173,
-0.04060719162225723,
-0.000057222066971007735,
0.03927719220519066,
0.0027552112005650997,
-0.030364248901605606,
-0.019060082733631134,
-0.054878704249858856,
0.01830187626183033,
0.017195481806993484,
-0.009055248461663723,
-0.05103098973631859,
0.0023976482916623354,
-0.004419754724949598,
-0.06797438859939575,
-0.05184220150113106,
-0.060253165662288666,
0.025411566719412804,
-0.028173504397273064,
-0.01233617402613163,
0.0028828722424805164,
-0.019721655175089836,
0.06522718071937561,
-0.03482884541153908,
-0.0017583486624062061,
0.04376858472824097,
0.017138278111815453,
0.011947615072131157,
0.04400372505187988,
0.016804587095975876,
-0.005353335756808519,
-0.008068010210990906,
0.03926493600010872,
0.018876943737268448,
-0.014160005375742912,
0.026359453797340393,
-0.0073866453021764755,
-0.005213473457843065,
-0.03000597096979618,
0.08624940365552902,
-0.05852637439966202,
0.024270320311188698,
0.002495002234354615,
0.03496968373656273,
-0.028628183528780937,
-0.04752255603671074,
0.006984543986618519,
-0.021245121955871582,
0.02925526723265648,
-0.04172845929861069,
-0.03860948234796524,
-0.0028504510410130024,
0.021476350724697113,
-0.06508194655179977,
-0.004218376241624355,
0.008575032465159893,
0.013717119581997395,
0.042690210044384,
-0.018249716609716415,
-0.019872531294822693,
-0.00314917741343379,
0.038095228374004364,
0.012928619980812073,
-0.003208021866157651,
-0.06214813143014908,
-0.03617139533162117,
-0.08983683586120605,
0.018363190814852715,
-0.029320145025849342,
-0.008855928666889668,
-0.0038634883239865303,
-0.01638038642704487,
-0.012789268977940083,
-0.009280450642108917,
0.011227271519601345,
0.010689489543437958,
0.08007452636957169,
-0.00257176929153502,
0.00901212077587843,
-0.02998581901192665,
0.074820376932621,
-0.06440123915672302,
-0.029783112928271294,
-0.059873804450035095,
0.06248604133725166,
-0.026298202574253082,
0.017181312665343285,
-0.00016630583559162915,
0.013826140202581882,
-0.009525839239358902,
0.03569816052913666,
0.01617087982594967,
-0.022039514034986496,
0.0053053004667162895,
-0.009658549912273884,
-0.04490422457456589,
0.018730152398347855,
0.019602449610829353,
0.013761273585259914,
-0.004921274725347757,
0.03224940598011017,
-0.016182810068130493,
-0.004028037190437317,
0.028102099895477295,
-0.002262842608615756,
-0.00693476852029562,
0.026326199993491173,
-0.002077448880299926,
0.03180798515677452,
0.01079501211643219,
-0.018593328073620796,
0.006491784937679768,
0.004884672351181507,
-0.023378955200314522,
0.004280046094208956,
-0.03900232911109924,
-0.04234961047768593,
0.0005684532225131989,
-0.009524323977530003,
0.008050450123846531,
-0.024127919226884842,
-0.011905635707080364,
-0.018451543524861336,
-0.012365413829684258,
-0.02273937687277794,
0.001646813820116222,
0.008558236062526703,
-0.009148609824478626,
-0.04078354313969612,
0.06204738840460777,
-0.022526653483510017,
0.014270919375121593,
-0.021941738203167915,
0.011231393553316593,
-0.03658381849527359,
0.006819685455411673,
-0.13699115812778473,
0.005850843619555235,
-0.03026394546031952,
-0.00956109818071127,
-0.07284325361251831,
-0.0029270935337990522,
-0.001474570482969284,
0.01627902127802372,
-0.0185910165309906,
-0.014703284949064255,
0.021849261596798897,
-0.030695118010044098,
0.04240572080016136,
-0.0016643626149743795,
-0.03109065257012844,
0.03775382414460182,
-0.0230929646641016,
-0.041240718215703964,
-0.029155369848012924,
0.022996896877884865,
0.0044792150147259235,
0.01972476951777935,
-0.011020392179489136,
-0.031328894197940826,
-0.031052319332957268,
0.0094135208055377,
-0.039335690438747406,
-0.026007207110524178,
-0.016305357217788696,
0.016251705586910248,
-0.04046531394124031,
-0.016085539013147354,
-0.0073263682425022125,
0.03880510479211807,
-0.0005030892207287252,
0.014525280334055424,
0.01474232878535986,
-0.02794838696718216,
-0.034338172525167465,
-0.003329124301671982,
-0.04123813286423683,
0.003564819460734725,
-0.027269918471574783,
0.025092748925089836,
0.017405826598405838,
0.01362923625856638,
-0.0009321976103819907,
0.009298122487962246,
-0.030828898772597313,
-0.03610767796635628,
-0.024276413023471832,
0.01537308469414711,
-0.016880370676517487,
0.018176374956965446,
0.018777351826429367,
0.023552488535642624,
0.004127316176891327,
-0.025513868778944016,
-0.05269711837172508,
0.06888807564973831,
-0.021609371528029442,
-0.0019443059572950006,
-0.030302954837679863,
-0.03653060644865036,
0.0009587631793692708,
-0.002190300961956382,
0.008066008798778057,
0.013169706799089909,
0.005201711319386959,
0.006712552160024643,
0.0021665277890861034,
-0.05262196809053421,
0.0427495539188385,
-0.01558550912886858,
-0.00511025870218873,
-0.020993009209632874,
0.025003477931022644,
-0.002327363472431898,
0.021050438284873962,
0.0025786426849663258,
-0.009135967120528221,
0.014116518199443817,
-0.03735111653804779,
0.030308037996292114,
0.05844513699412346,
0.0052490923553705215,
0.007057061418890953,
-0.08266037702560425,
0.0360347144305706,
-0.014788730069994926,
-0.059394028037786484,
0.019143121317029,
0.014370365999639034,
0.02689831145107746,
-0.04655726999044418,
0.06153935566544533,
0.008593075908720493,
-0.011388950981199741,
-0.010952825658023357,
-0.01179251167923212,
-0.010934555903077126,
-0.04262213781476021,
0.00030654252623207867,
0.013772492296993732,
0.0032573421485722065,
0.03472021594643593,
-0.010619559325277805,
-0.018029289320111275,
-0.015764450654387474,
0.018664607778191566,
-0.023526418954133987,
-0.068776935338974,
-0.054404519498348236,
-0.029561977833509445,
-0.035054855048656464,
0.008595132268965244,
0.0065936860628426075,
0.0021442705765366554,
-0.010460750199854374,
0.005660760682076216,
0.037599727511405945,
-0.03837535157799721,
0.00800522230565548,
-0.014886599034070969,
-0.0027156274300068617,
0.034407611936330795,
0.049210596829652786,
-0.014955229125916958,
0.022677285596728325,
-0.029635949060320854,
0.05119079723954201,
-0.008730710484087467,
0.009458859451115131,
0.0022126371040940285,
0.014420434832572937,
0.018392648547887802,
-0.023561136797070503,
0.008617127314209938,
-0.0057673328556120396,
-0.04855389520525932,
0.00043081725016236305,
0.0028361801523715258,
-0.02376173995435238,
-0.016432952135801315,
-0.00375127955339849,
-0.03630933165550232,
0.02245800755918026,
0.0018603283679112792,
-0.016607418656349182,
-0.014381272718310356,
-0.018015915527939796,
0.011311730369925499,
0.0035703203175216913,
0.057938411831855774,
-0.010479070246219635,
0.019634125754237175,
0.0641121044754982,
0.01945495419204235,
-0.00654338113963604,
0.021566791459918022,
0.06721914559602737,
-0.014803200960159302,
-0.03371482715010643,
-0.0512467622756958,
-0.01911362074315548,
0.004856096114963293,
0.006039898376911879,
-0.0010680088307708502,
-0.040162693709135056,
-0.014206355437636375,
-0.01836175099015236,
-0.004521563649177551,
-0.0021117464639246464,
-0.008526206947863102,
0.04097415506839752,
-0.042606860399246216,
-0.004709215834736824,
-0.0576619878411293,
0.06077684089541435,
-0.014160916209220886,
0.03300280496478081,
0.04275533929467201,
0.028960425406694412,
0.017544172704219818,
0.005087032914161682,
0.0027797280345112085,
0.004163758829236031,
-0.003950878977775574,
-0.04636462777853012,
0.011417590081691742,
-0.0017305604415014386,
-0.004161358345299959,
0.0181731004267931,
-0.015775540843605995,
0.05097326263785362,
-0.024291083216667175,
-0.02864965610206127,
0.01905370131134987,
0.017688853666186333,
0.029933031648397446,
-0.012023110873997211,
-0.022463910281658173,
-0.027520224452018738,
-0.015756750479340553,
0.0012046225601807237,
0.01684272103011608,
0.009866694919764996,
-0.030772894620895386,
-0.010910703800618649,
0.011143551208078861,
-0.05017577111721039,
-0.0015535898273810744,
0.01888749748468399,
0.03490090370178223,
-0.002599970903247595,
-0.009692402556538582,
-0.022409653291106224,
-0.008392216637730598,
-0.00018321993411518633,
0.015686511993408203,
0.016471121460199356,
0.04816053807735443,
-0.03950715437531471,
-0.05630277469754219,
0.018636247143149376,
0.02881460078060627,
0.017498182132840157,
-0.013705626130104065,
0.01830374263226986,
0.02082863450050354,
0.0008339869091287255,
-0.008912556804716587,
0.005974178202450275,
0.02317294478416443,
0.026636198163032532,
-0.01657010242342949,
-0.04775330424308777,
-0.040812939405441284,
-0.032123465090990067,
-0.003704353468492627,
0.03763851523399353,
0.0118229566141963,
0.014950142242014408,
0.008578406646847725
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:23
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
On that basis the evidence that I am able to consider consists of the photos and sketch of the accident (see [76]), Mr Horwood's statements (see [77] to [79], Mr Capper's written statements and oral evidence (see [92] to [94]),
the signed statement of Mr Oates other than the material the subject of a direction under s 136 (see [81] and [82]) and the letter signed by Mr Gers dated 12 October 2006 ([91]).
It would also include the unsigned statement of Mr Oates because he has incorporated that by reference into his signed statement (see [83] above). It would not include the statement Mr Gillette made to the WorkCover inspector (see [63]) or the material from the Investigator's reports (see [86] to [91]).
113Considering that material alone there is still a sharp discrepancy between Mr Oates' evidence and that of Mr Capper. I find that, based on Mr Oates' statements, the forklift had persistent deficiencies including loose steering, poor braking and propensity to fishtail at some speeds. I reject the evidence from Mr Capper to the contrary.
I have referred above to the misgivings I have about this aspect of his evidence. On this issue the absence of any service or maintenance records for the forklift for the relevant period and his use of unqualified personnel to maintain the forklift reinforces the doubts I have from having observed his evidence on this topic.
Mr Oates' evidence was untested. However there is no reason apparent why he would provide a consistently false impression of the state of the forklift. The position is different for Mr Capper. His company, Megbuy, was ultimately responsible for the forklift.
From an early point in WorkCover's investigation he must have realised that there could be adverse ramifications for either him or Megbuy if the forklift was allowed to be driven on a public road with a persistent defect.
114QBE had material which suggested that the option of repairing the persistent defect in the vehicle was relatively inexpensive but nevertheless rejected by Mr Capper. The material that I am considering at this point of the analysis does not support such a finding other than perhaps the letter from Mr Gers dated 12 October 2006.
However the analysis at [105] to [106] above concluded that a breach of duty would still be established even if the cost of the repairs was not able to be ascertained because, in the absence of repair, it was incumbent on Megbuy not to allow the forklift to be driven, especially on a public road.
The balance of the reasoning at [108] is also applicable. I make the findings on causation that I concluded that the District Court would have been reasonably likely to have made (see [108]).
115Accordingly, to the extent that it was incumbent on me to determine de novo whether Megbuy was liable to Mr Horwood, then I am satisfied that it was. The question as to whether it was a liability that results in the definition of "injury" being satisfied is addressed next.
WAS THE DEFINITION OF INJURY SATISFIED?
116The remaining issue with the double insurance claim is whether the findings I have made concerning ownership and the existence of a liability owing from Megbuy to Mr Horwood meant that the definition of "injury" in section 3 of the MAC Act was satisfied. I have set out in [14] above that definition.
117Mr Horwood's statement of claim alleged that Megbuy was the "owner" of the vehicle, the vehicle was in use at the time of the accident and the vehicle was defective. He did not seek to confine himself to any of the limbs specified in (a)(i) to (iv) of the definition of "injury". As between QBE and CGU, Mr Cavanagh SC sought to rely on all four limbs.
He contended the liability of Megbuy to Mr Horwood that was compromised (or established) could be characterised as having been caused by the fault of the "owner" (i.e. Megbuy) in the use or operation of the vehicle (i.e. its maintenance or allowing it to be "used") in circumstances when the physical injury to Mr Horwood was both "as a result of" and was "caused" during any of (a)(i) to (iv).
|
[
0.0029330544639378786,
0.003673355560749769,
-0.018085196614265442,
-0.017487263306975365,
0.024357153102755547,
-0.017850376665592194,
0.003908440470695496,
0.02672506310045719,
0.010534275323152542,
0.03031790442764759,
-0.0073375459760427475,
0.011139065958559513,
-0.003682744223624468,
-0.005409180652350187,
-0.01062226202338934,
-0.032820966094732285,
0.030636336654424667,
-0.019297942519187927,
-0.04769519343972206,
-0.046977702528238297,
0.030440961942076683,
-0.0451682023704052,
0.053454238921403885,
0.0519268773496151,
0.016465814784169197,
0.03222842514514923,
0.018421368673443794,
0.0059443009085953236,
-0.013603316619992256,
0.007560308091342449,
-0.004842937923967838,
-0.023152001202106476,
0.0015213560545817018,
0.0023743531201034784,
0.020088745281100273,
-0.04617021232843399,
-0.009132885374128819,
0.030357902869582176,
-0.021807273849844933,
-0.00048403741675429046,
-0.020945657044649124,
0.006191789638251066,
0.0238640196621418,
-0.04802576079964638,
0.00921411719173193,
-0.047346390783786774,
0.007809267845004797,
-0.020923595875501633,
0.012623537331819534,
-0.004495819564908743,
-0.047038063406944275,
-0.012882809154689312,
0.053861405700445175,
-0.030487386509776115,
-0.0021878208499401808,
0.01860268972814083,
-0.014854127541184425,
-0.028037847951054573,
-0.07466814666986465,
-0.004719784948974848,
-0.014252220280468464,
-0.006471309810876846,
-0.014672285877168179,
0.011569876223802567,
0.014658669009804726,
0.09048371762037277,
-0.033537644892930984,
-0.007474892307072878,
0.003006596118211746,
-0.042818617075681686,
0.013425935059785843,
0.01118718832731247,
-0.033336341381073,
0.010785948485136032,
-0.0655030608177185,
-0.008172590285539627,
-0.0013798701111227274,
0.004685494117438793,
-0.003688110737130046,
0.0483296737074852,
0.023828156292438507,
0.020952938124537468,
-0.004984491504728794,
0.030043452978134155,
-0.026010578498244286,
0.012824549339711666,
-0.031049873679876328,
-0.008151616901159286,
0.00845845602452755,
0.003465883433818817,
0.007103691343218088,
-0.004905149340629578,
0.025339189916849136,
-0.02647542580962181,
0.01849074475467205,
-0.0045209345407783985,
-0.024805555120110512,
0.025239547714591026,
0.01811726950109005,
0.0019209175370633602,
0.0005286571104079485,
0.009187771007418633,
0.015726029872894287,
-0.03458038717508316,
-0.008693434298038483,
0.006545152515172958,
0.03297198563814163,
0.03297653794288635,
-0.004339980892837048,
0.0012827238533645868,
0.016416791826486588,
0.03847714513540268,
-0.03360355645418167,
0.028169896453619003,
-0.000699044787324965,
0.007600688841193914,
0.01185282040387392,
-0.033564142882823944,
-0.001099229441024363,
-0.0003692575264722109,
0.06543751806020737,
0.06270675361156464,
0.050665032118558884,
-0.04456159099936485,
-0.057421986013650894,
-0.003673661034554243,
0.009250915609300137,
-0.037031665444374084,
-0.04988400265574455,
-0.025219060480594635,
0.01517417561262846,
0.008165430277585983,
-0.022945038974285126,
-0.07897176593542099,
-0.03393765166401863,
-0.025150949135422707,
0.03888674080371857,
0.03597792983055115,
-0.02521997131407261,
-0.007253479678183794,
0.06773696839809418,
0.02501157857477665,
0.012255717068910599,
-0.009993623942136765,
0.026045406237244606,
-0.007645162288099527,
0.03891291096806526,
-0.028067024424672127,
0.044307250529527664,
-0.025014318525791168,
0.0329442024230957,
0.0033071369398385286,
0.0014816928887739778,
-0.04572059586644173,
0.03242997080087662,
-0.04994719848036766,
0.014324610121548176,
-0.034816280007362366,
0.015665264800190926,
-0.0049765086732804775,
-0.002851837081834674,
0.0861605703830719,
-0.0009888665517792106,
-0.030519140884280205,
0.004801373463124037,
0.02894187532365322,
-0.0047777327708899975,
0.021941209211945534,
-0.02445504628121853,
-0.04217122495174408,
0.023920578882098198,
-0.005240029189735651,
0.02865946665406227,
-0.0032429518178105354,
0.026980044320225716,
0.0267289187759161,
0.02592676691710949,
-0.0018455741228535771,
0.02777983620762825,
-0.04994402453303337,
-0.01811404339969158,
0.006370013114064932,
0.030020033940672874,
-0.007162971422076225,
0.01667650416493416,
0.020694013684988022,
-0.004549866542220116,
-0.03307698294520378,
0.02041483111679554,
0.02094774879515171,
-0.011134300380945206,
-0.03240776062011719,
0.006418531760573387,
-0.00044818216701969504,
0.012514919973909855,
-0.030038675293326378,
0.027414634823799133,
0.0106755830347538,
0.012245770543813705,
-0.031819503754377365,
-0.022920187562704086,
0.015654148533940315,
0.09005173295736313,
-0.04822120815515518,
-0.03328457474708557,
-0.02542639710009098,
-0.038473404943943024,
-0.00034801362198777497,
0.023628029972314835,
-0.10694803297519684,
0.009313230402767658,
-0.014070063829421997,
0.0076352572068572044,
0.03515768051147461,
-0.030183248221874237,
-0.019608505070209503,
0.0065401713363826275,
-0.010515805333852768,
0.047481004148721695,
-0.011357604525983334,
-0.020447440445423126,
-0.0036054158117622137,
0.004124309401959181,
0.017130963504314423,
0.019009286537766457,
0.0183862317353487,
-0.031132033094763756,
0.024554574862122536,
-0.007821392267942429,
-0.04523589089512825,
0.05208167806267738,
0.04499442130327225,
0.0050863525830209255,
-0.024327954277396202,
0.03633281961083412,
0.007751692086458206,
0.03949261084198952,
0.019066207110881805,
0.014653093181550503,
0.022863944992423058,
-0.011489356867969036,
-0.029527345672249794,
0.054747261106967926,
-0.01861180178821087,
-0.001363507122732699,
-0.01852404698729515,
0.0075667849741876125,
0.021161288022994995,
0.014188285917043686,
0.035149965435266495,
0.02265395224094391,
-0.012970096431672573,
-0.015433607622981071,
0.007973133586347103,
-0.00025252194609493017,
0.04405146464705467,
0.02882876805961132,
-0.002478770213201642,
0.02457818202674389,
-0.02523994818329811,
0.005240745842456818,
0.017248520627617836,
0.020073750987648964,
-0.0054056281223893166,
-0.018928397446870804,
-0.05382904037833214,
-0.022917121648788452,
-0.039406292140483856,
-0.04645155370235443,
0.01905820704996586,
0.019809657707810402,
-0.03255457431077957,
-0.014330480247735977,
-0.018873998895287514,
0.015902452170848846,
0.026482298970222473,
0.029500965029001236,
-0.006682463921606541,
0.0075890058651566505,
-0.013834286481142044,
0.07372289896011353,
0.007668175268918276,
0.019366644322872162,
-0.04090242460370064,
0.031979456543922424,
0.02598508633673191,
-0.02763715386390686,
-0.05409061536192894,
-0.025407515466213226,
-0.06694240868091583,
0.05638757720589638,
0.0026665094774216413,
0.05625533312559128,
-0.014145318418741226,
-0.04673480987548828,
0.02372313290834427,
0.023682845756411552,
-0.14041081070899963,
-0.00972031056880951,
0.03214099630713463,
0.019053921103477478,
-0.0059088971465826035,
0.01092127151787281,
-0.011016476899385452,
0.0013648421736434102,
-0.011396554298698902,
0.010978165082633495,
0.015992451459169388,
-0.06749874353408813,
-0.04294886812567711,
0.0017154294764623046,
0.017248021438717842,
-0.044865306466817856,
-0.004100735764950514,
0.018247956410050392,
0.021544214338064194,
-0.019876450300216675,
0.010456434451043606,
0.011116362176835537,
0.0031343111768364906,
-0.021957609802484512,
0.038686852902173996,
-0.009069773368537426,
0.025481685996055603,
0.013922704383730888,
-0.052284836769104004,
-0.02442212775349617,
-0.03063295967876911,
-0.003031092928722501,
-0.0066387648694217205,
0.038878727704286575,
-0.0119254719465971,
0.01967458240687847,
0.07007578015327454,
-0.0925871804356575,
-0.01690136268734932,
-0.006762341130524874,
0.030101537704467773,
0.08952692896127701,
-0.00605923542752862,
0.0006553260027430952,
0.004336795769631863,
-0.06929205358028412,
0.034843046218156815,
0.0023373395670205355,
-0.06010635197162628,
-0.001612948370166123,
-0.020840846002101898,
-0.012999085709452629,
0.0033408610615879297,
-0.006904892157763243,
-0.02093692496418953,
-0.020979633554816246,
0.040906503796577454,
0.04245220869779587,
-0.01651160418987274,
0.0064611369743943214,
-0.0026708380319178104,
-0.059234920889139175,
0.04135270416736603,
0.01894984394311905,
-0.04916033148765564,
0.010919932276010513,
0.008595181629061699,
-0.01797325536608696,
0.001567951519973576,
-0.006015576422214508,
-0.03720635175704956,
-0.05565929412841797,
0.05196342244744301,
-0.005067416932433844,
0.008072740398347378,
0.017410842701792717,
0.006581170484423637,
-0.008702904917299747,
-0.006815542466938496,
-0.061358869075775146,
0.02239963226020336,
0.036768730729818344,
-0.012466724030673504,
0.03543800115585327,
-0.009141771122813225,
0.024847036227583885,
0.034775260835886,
0.005716669838875532,
0.03539285808801651,
0.22415313124656677,
-0.027933988720178604,
-0.05862920731306076,
-0.028771359473466873,
0.0313747338950634,
0.006238000933080912,
0.049732472747564316,
0.03335871547460556,
-0.008522908203303814,
-0.01845029927790165,
-0.05504433810710907,
-0.02515021152794361,
0.05161536484956741,
0.01381703931838274,
-0.03968082740902901,
-0.027136685326695442,
-0.03371117264032364,
-0.06528628617525101,
0.07358755171298981,
0.0008618204738013446,
0.034835249185562134,
0.008018102496862411,
0.034382570534944534,
0.010088106617331505,
-0.08841823041439056,
-0.0426306277513504,
0.004001927562057972,
0.00047388856182806194,
0.0008565281750634313,
0.011262873187661171,
-0.027377596125006676,
-0.017992375418543816,
0.02823689766228199,
-0.01687641255557537,
-0.01359150093048811,
0.019322594627738,
-0.04513048380613327,
-0.02447405271232128,
-0.007088659331202507,
0.04789320379495621,
0.020481744781136513,
0.006193761248141527,
-0.009458447806537151,
-0.017789924517273903,
-0.002264259848743677,
0.02007356658577919,
0.039279770106077194,
0.02033582329750061,
-0.01963764615356922,
0.03395695611834526,
-0.04442698881030083,
-0.0082811014726758,
-0.03105056658387184,
0.005723551381379366,
-0.017531875520944595,
0.015465470030903816,
0.003067533951252699,
0.029034115374088287,
-0.00903212558478117,
0.029453802853822708,
0.021412087604403496,
0.018489433452486992,
-0.054315000772476196,
0.02990659512579441,
0.0014531994238495827,
0.020980199798941612,
-0.052284371107816696,
-0.02092798240482807,
0.042763058096170425,
-0.00006556333391927183,
0.019411971792578697,
0.04613875225186348,
0.010656788945198059,
0.033031899482011795,
0.042419351637363434,
0.024055026471614838,
0.03845120593905449,
0.052548497915267944,
0.006774248089641333,
0.011697791516780853,
-0.040112994611263275,
-0.023250583559274673,
-0.0018797843949869275,
0.01053028553724289,
0.021758191287517548,
-0.014641184359788895,
-0.00006874698010506108,
0.04700745269656181,
0.02811906300485134,
-0.02697174996137619,
-0.027936067432165146,
-0.02876736968755722,
0.019366441294550896,
0.02841862477362156,
-0.010113898664712906,
0.018946968019008636,
0.02198941633105278,
-0.0170823335647583,
0.005091106053441763,
-0.05138510838150978,
-0.023995717987418175,
0.012518101371824741,
-0.021928751841187477,
-0.01515013538300991,
-0.0038735063280910254,
-0.050977349281311035,
0.01236134022474289,
0.003981807269155979,
-0.04661107435822487,
-0.011067057959735394,
0.010087433271110058,
0.004220492672175169,
-0.03647284954786301,
0.00113844929728657,
0.0031152719166129827,
0.01646006479859352,
-0.0666685700416565,
0.03776656091213226,
0.008161441422998905,
0.05079840123653412,
-0.014304493553936481,
0.0043410006910562515,
-0.04439167305827141,
0.009651224128901958,
-0.023001665249466896,
-0.027616459876298904,
-0.05251888185739517,
-0.00867403019219637,
-0.029028357937932014,
0.005211457144469023,
-0.0021528007928282022,
-0.009207218885421753,
-0.05086270719766617,
-0.0052797324024140835,
0.06721492856740952,
-0.02491447515785694,
-0.010643841698765755,
0.03592970594763756,
-0.025958135724067688,
0.009686056524515152,
-0.04113348573446274,
0.00005520428385352716,
-0.051403481513261795,
-0.010475171729922295,
0.0014046675059944391,
-0.01922816038131714,
-0.0505041778087616,
0.03754352033138275,
-0.05744115635752678,
-0.02750423550605774,
0.028616532683372498,
0.006184084340929985,
-0.053008537739515305,
-0.033931661397218704,
0.014792312867939472,
0.016500679776072502,
0.008028962649405003,
0.023681223392486572,
0.0335765965282917,
-0.03616637364029884,
-0.017743436619639397,
-0.018969789147377014,
-0.009255297482013702,
0.05036737397313118,
0.013499376364052296,
0.022214289754629135,
0.000574908743146807,
0.04859519004821777,
0.027950292453169823,
0.0021492394153028727,
-0.001489866292104125,
-0.05637127533555031,
-0.020854508504271507,
0.05978486314415932,
0.008920575492084026,
0.06823493540287018,
-0.005939787719398737,
0.043060552328825,
0.02800995111465454,
-0.022146107628941536,
0.0028437727596610785,
0.03145253285765648,
-0.009316532872617245,
0.025470811873674393,
-0.011126648634672165,
-0.007140589877963066,
0.023461613804101944,
-0.03644362464547157,
0.017069686204195023,
-0.009167357347905636,
-0.013212607242166996,
0.08719168603420258,
-0.02328120730817318,
-0.01583264395594597,
0.01453686598688364,
0.03327494114637375,
0.011491858400404453,
0.009548441506922245,
0.022824695333838463,
-0.04362170025706291,
0.01120541151612997,
0.02705521322786808,
0.004200270865112543,
0.021239083260297775,
0.023346809670329094,
-0.0003055610868614167,
-0.012759995646774769,
0.014043520204722881,
-0.04345820099115372,
-0.0205924641340971,
0.020155195146799088,
0.022512992843985558,
-0.0035595432855188847,
-0.007305049803107977,
-0.05557234585285187,
0.026508258655667305,
0.02514038048684597,
0.03559112548828125,
0.017426718026399612,
-0.047615472227334976,
-0.03366579860448837,
-0.015021582134068012,
0.025346148759126663,
-0.04341787099838257,
0.0041056908667087555,
0.03653586283326149,
0.009122021496295929,
-0.03237203508615494,
0.01895182393491268,
-0.008619037456810474,
0.010168272070586681,
-0.046941112726926804,
-0.008471212349832058,
-0.03400742635130882,
-0.0013153718318790197,
0.0022597864735871553,
0.019511591643095016,
0.02884303219616413,
0.010346252471208572,
-0.004371205810457468,
0.04161575064063072,
-0.01077826227992773,
-0.008064528927206993,
0.06163192540407181,
-0.02046510949730873,
0.008308515883982182,
-0.028091678395867348,
-0.045367203652858734,
0.02665833570063114,
0.015547670423984528,
0.028199732303619385,
0.04898944869637489,
0.032097309827804565,
-0.040987733751535416,
0.013041346333920956,
0.0032296546269208193,
-0.023339418694376945,
0.008256427012383938,
-0.08155173808336258,
-0.035952601581811905,
-0.016748065128922462,
0.059285085648298264,
0.013085996732115746,
-0.03659653291106224,
0.02467249520123005,
-0.05531957745552063,
-0.0019472306594252586,
0.019149374216794968,
-0.017375076189637184,
-0.027037018910050392,
-0.04002026095986366,
0.019946040585637093,
-0.029906079173088074,
-0.07681381702423096,
-0.0471523180603981,
0.0253838449716568,
-0.041582923382520676,
0.007455878891050816,
0.020244622603058815,
-0.054705660790205,
0.05407273396849632,
-0.024769358336925507,
-0.014466647058725357,
0.048634521663188934,
0.014077430590987206,
0.010239035822451115,
0.03467724844813347,
0.03373817354440689,
0.01372222974896431,
-0.005673401523381472,
0.025319203734397888,
0.0349513404071331,
0.011974150314927101,
0.024000326171517372,
-0.00876226369291544,
0.009592946618795395,
-0.020698022097349167,
0.06949494779109955,
-0.031856976449489594,
0.014474951662123203,
-0.008847001940011978,
0.001638498972170055,
-0.045896515250205994,
-0.05167815089225769,
0.0030111155938357115,
-0.03721966594457626,
0.022776342928409576,
-0.031671226024627686,
-0.024416547268629074,
0.0019782474264502525,
-0.01357875857502222,
-0.03687705099582672,
-0.027532469481229782,
-0.012163934297859669,
-0.016451362520456314,
0.023681234568357468,
-0.008400741033256054,
-0.007908166386187077,
0.009343805722892284,
0.01071499940007925,
0.030761437490582466,
0.00017278920859098434,
-0.05212942883372307,
-0.03392711654305458,
-0.06788533180952072,
0.015874095261096954,
0.00496962433680892,
-0.008809787221252918,
-0.03504223749041557,
-0.0036134282127022743,
-0.03779641166329384,
-0.018535736948251724,
-0.04260580986738205,
0.018334753811359406,
0.08235467225313187,
-0.011530853807926178,
-0.01484393049031496,
-0.01782969757914543,
0.06451454013586044,
-0.02277209796011448,
-0.040053412318229675,
-0.051089294254779816,
0.06749820709228516,
-0.0005218011792749166,
0.0030450604390352964,
-0.0034511908888816833,
0.001202849787659943,
-0.00044878461631014943,
0.023557186126708984,
0.02228570729494095,
-0.0038228933699429035,
0.008428635075688362,
-0.005187373608350754,
-0.0645390972495079,
0.014520351774990559,
0.03090824745595455,
0.014164652675390244,
-0.0014906128635630012,
0.03919963166117668,
0.007232519332319498,
-0.0008624178590252995,
0.03135211765766144,
-0.0434318482875824,
-0.0255658607929945,
0.017701013013720512,
-0.008853544481098652,
0.002880701096728444,
0.004169995430856943,
-0.0009291890892200172,
0.0027145056519657373,
0.006058142054826021,
-0.031671591103076935,
0.021304916590452194,
-0.021255699917674065,
-0.021501652896404266,
-0.00661787623539567,
0.00023316644364967942,
-0.010474526323378086,
-0.013791307806968689,
0.010707386769354343,
-0.031114675104618073,
-0.030371399596333504,
-0.029048891738057137,
0.017077865079045296,
0.018415158614516258,
-0.0119561068713665,
-0.0061047133058309555,
0.03476738557219505,
-0.03139257803559303,
0.018929999321699142,
-0.011709930375218391,
0.06596650183200836,
-0.05249520763754845,
0.010717627592384815,
-0.13715122640132904,
0.008581711910665035,
-0.031268514692783356,
0.003552013309672475,
-0.06774096935987473,
0.006690742447972298,
-0.019608715549111366,
0.010316199623048306,
-0.038586802780628204,
0.004541425034403801,
-0.00018098874716088176,
-0.04422583803534508,
0.06666329503059387,
0.0031833667308092117,
-0.042988162487745285,
0.035417672246694565,
-0.007779392879456282,
-0.04332370683550835,
-0.0008150986395776272,
0.03984183818101883,
0.008097667247056961,
0.04651552438735962,
0.007108022924512625,
-0.03522363677620888,
-0.03119010291993618,
-0.0010608345037326217,
-0.06058158352971077,
-0.008202548138797283,
-0.003979831002652645,
0.0531163215637207,
-0.029766639694571495,
-0.023387841880321503,
0.0100408885627985,
0.047402285039424896,
0.044035304337739944,
0.03867324814200401,
0.016091736033558846,
-0.02825368009507656,
-0.06529112160205841,
-0.025792261585593224,
-0.026220420375466347,
0.013859567232429981,
-0.006201595067977905,
-0.007280160207301378,
0.033530112355947495,
0.0025736240204423666,
0.017586268484592438,
0.008270567283034325,
-0.008049661293625832,
-0.036512572318315506,
-0.04701073467731476,
0.019728215411305428,
-0.032239776104688644,
0.025733355432748795,
0.014851040206849575,
0.022930558770895004,
0.002578368876129389,
-0.05810963362455368,
-0.04401673004031181,
0.060157276690006256,
-0.027173936367034912,
-0.012708229944109917,
-0.031428173184394836,
-0.024061910808086395,
-0.0006420892314054072,
0.011590206064283848,
0.012804782018065453,
0.0007852745475247502,
0.01126383151859045,
-0.018127083778381348,
0.000700055796187371,
-0.046801820397377014,
0.05425034463405609,
-0.00467193778604269,
-0.0054387557320296764,
-0.018066881224513054,
0.03191296011209488,
0.008940034545958042,
0.018941810354590416,
0.008793894201517105,
-0.0025554753374308348,
0.008434240706264973,
-0.0348803885281086,
0.009248655289411545,
0.04798715561628342,
0.020967209711670876,
-0.0054079038091003895,
-0.04409566894173622,
0.056685518473386765,
-0.03763589262962341,
-0.06374511122703552,
0.013785206712782383,
-0.00015904840256553143,
0.019603105261921883,
-0.011536277830600739,
0.05445568263530731,
0.013397950679063797,
0.0038762735202908516,
-0.025309965014457703,
-0.030880799517035484,
0.008697878569364548,
-0.05175498500466347,
0.008526367135345936,
-0.01970731094479561,
-0.023291394114494324,
0.06571441143751144,
-0.043975234031677246,
0.021670181304216385,
0.0030232039280235767,
-0.005606667138636112,
-0.03330729156732559,
-0.05180106684565544,
-0.06253696978092194,
-0.022893177345395088,
-0.02949553355574608,
0.009638415649533272,
0.0072773355059325695,
0.015525675378739834,
-0.03661049157381058,
0.024066118523478508,
0.02776046097278595,
-0.022125540301203728,
0.04519227519631386,
-0.01866428181529045,
-0.023273851722478867,
0.03669612109661102,
0.049314334988594055,
-0.010969343595206738,
0.027389781549572945,
-0.009251270443201065,
0.04800165444612503,
-0.025998558849096298,
-0.024365395307540894,
-0.002078133635222912,
0.006607320159673691,
0.036035116761922836,
-0.03394516184926033,
0.010388593189418316,
-0.007703674025833607,
-0.04222911223769188,
0.011281756684184074,
-0.018192224204540253,
-0.0201109629124403,
-0.000031062401831150055,
-0.013243487104773521,
-0.028420431539416313,
0.022395312786102295,
-0.000030212040655897,
-0.030287601053714752,
-0.031097112223505974,
-0.025219887495040894,
-0.0064429547637701035,
0.0025284229777753353,
0.04797172546386719,
0.02611745148897171,
-0.030381323769688606,
0.06091645359992981,
0.014783723279833794,
-0.009236808866262436,
0.040822584182024,
0.04560885578393936,
-0.03119899518787861,
-0.041405122727155685,
-0.02949264645576477,
-0.040331222116947174,
0.0362616702914238,
0.01022285409271717,
-0.003775712801143527,
-0.01420779898762703,
0.00026703771436586976,
0.023921221494674683,
0.017893817275762558,
-0.014896218664944172,
-0.011179785244166851,
0.038621630519628525,
-0.028356434777379036,
0.0002865800342988223,
-0.034629423171281815,
0.07325953990221024,
-0.005062021315097809,
0.03543112054467201,
0.03793531283736229,
-0.009754345752298832,
0.027764085680246353,
-0.0265969205647707,
0.022363044321537018,
-0.0034271019976586103,
-0.005404215306043625,
-0.03741981089115143,
-0.03270426765084267,
-0.017813360318541527,
-0.0234303530305624,
-0.013338782824575901,
-0.020478812977671623,
0.05487562343478203,
-0.007116157561540604,
-0.012764579616487026,
0.034448932856321335,
0.008602575398981571,
0.008932869881391525,
0.0017513444181531668,
-0.007118691690266132,
-0.0001680119166849181,
-0.025776540860533714,
-0.03937400132417679,
-0.004248027689754963,
0.015848830342292786,
-0.003056620480492711,
-0.01170048862695694,
0.0501459501683712,
-0.03492315858602524,
-0.013585451059043407,
-0.006042413413524628,
0.04877660796046257,
-0.0012672310695052147,
0.0013316875556483865,
-0.0022521205246448517,
-0.011820018291473389,
0.02233140729367733,
0.0040784054435789585,
0.030891187489032745,
0.058479003608226776,
-0.04286249727010727,
-0.05321243032813072,
0.009024718776345253,
0.006357542704790831,
0.002137791132554412,
-0.0024357112124562263,
0.038922324776649475,
0.0020181844010949135,
0.0031660236418247223,
-0.014258158393204212,
0.01605285331606865,
0.018478386104106903,
0.02656056359410286,
-0.0041930219158530235,
-0.02034357562661171,
-0.02032657340168953,
-0.027448175475001335,
-0.01775837317109108,
0.043810851871967316,
0.016818206757307053,
0.011325894854962826,
-0.011538498103618622
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:8
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
37However I do not consider that it is open for me to take a contrary view to the proposition stated in [57] of Zurich v GIO concerning "reasonable compromise". The passage was affirmed by three judges of appeal. As I have stated Zurich v GIO was not a case where the liability of the common insured (ie Caringbah) was "judicially determined".
The manner in which Caringbah's liability to the coach driver and Zurich's obligation to indemnify Caringbah arose in Zurich v GIO was no different to that which Megbuy incurred to Mr Horwood here, namely a defence was filed admitting liability under the MAC Act followed by an agreed amount for damages that was reflected in a consent order.
The reference to "reasonable compromise" in the judgment of Giles JA at [57] was an essential step in the reasoning that led to the outcome in Zurich v GIO, and it forms part of the ratio of that case.
I am not free to depart from it although I can acknowledge any doubts I have as to its correctness (see Minister for Environmental Planning v San Sebastian [1983] 2 NSWLR 268 at 315). To the extent I have doubts I have stated them.
Accordingly I consider that the question that arises in relation to Megbuy's liability to Mr Horwood is whether the sum of $1.5M represented a reasonable compromise of any liability it had to Mr Horwood under the MAC. I address that issue below at [76] to [111]. Against the contingency that my conclusion is wrong I have also addressed the liability of Megbuy de novo (at [112] to [115]).
38The more difficult question for me concerns the scope of the statement in [57] of Zurich v GIO. Conceptually it is not difficult to differentiate between the matters affecting the liability of the common insured to the injured claimant and matters affecting the obligation of the first insurer to provide cover to the common insured.
However what if those matters overlap?
In stating that the second insurer, in this case CGU, cannot put in issue in contribution proceedings the liability of the "common insured" does that prevent the putting in issue of matters concerning the liability of the common insured to the injured claimant which are also necessary elements of the obligation of either the first or second insurer to indemnify the common insured for that liability?
39One such matter in this case is whether or not Megbuy was the "owner" of the vehicle. In this case, each of the admission of liability in the defence, the heads of agreement and the consent orders all necessarily involved an admission that Megbuy was the "owner" of the forklift within the meaning of s 4 of the MAC Act.
Its ownership was a necessary element of it being liable to pay damages to Mr Horwood calculated in accordance with the MAC Act, as it was for Caringbah in Zurich v CGU.
In Zurich v CGU the admission of ownership by Caringbah was concurred in by GIO. In this case CGU has continually resisted that assertion.
My reading of [59], [63] to [64] in Zurich v GIO when taken with [75] is that this issue was resolved adversely to GIO because of the reasonable belief on the part of Zurich that Caringbah was the owner which was concurred in by GIO through the course of the proceedings.
I read the reference in [64] to the concurrence being the "equivalent of a reasonable settlement" at suggesting that something equivalent to a reasonable compromise was necessary because a reasonable compromise on the part of Zurich that reflected an admission of ownership was considered necessary but not sufficient.
In the absence of that concurrence it seems to me that that GIO would have been entitled to put in issue Caringbah's ownership of the forklift as that was a matter that went directly to Zurich's obligation to provide cover.
In this case Megbuy's ownership of the forklift is a necessary component of QBE's obligation to provide cover and ascertaining the scope of cover provided by CGU. There was no concurrence in the admission of ownership by Megbuy and QBE on the part of CGU.
|
[
0.01071988046169281,
-0.009206729009747505,
-0.007657255511730909,
-0.03754354640841484,
0.016640836372971535,
-0.008014099672436714,
0.010014045983552933,
0.00020492116163950413,
-0.013643584214150906,
0.01826488971710205,
-0.000333368283463642,
-0.028581183403730392,
-0.012612525373697281,
0.012322142720222473,
-0.013528591953217983,
-0.017419325187802315,
0.0333431251347065,
0.01471276581287384,
-0.0887996032834053,
-0.011535325087606907,
0.019341319799423218,
-0.019716672599315643,
0.021088166162371635,
0.02412540838122368,
0.020358113572001457,
0.017987169325351715,
-0.010479149408638477,
-0.002037572441622615,
0.0040226527489721775,
-0.010980105958878994,
-0.0122067304328084,
0.016955284401774406,
0.013899551704525948,
-0.016621600836515427,
0.00401145638898015,
-0.052461326122283936,
-0.023428237065672874,
-0.000990811618976295,
-0.011715438216924667,
-0.016667282208800316,
0.0007458559121005237,
-0.015337629243731499,
0.011511863209307194,
-0.043852828443050385,
0.04133496433496475,
-0.02635255828499794,
-0.007760161533951759,
-0.01770133525133133,
-0.010483463294804096,
-0.03069430962204933,
-0.04479728639125824,
0.0032835465390235186,
0.08555983752012253,
-0.03406016156077385,
-0.016090206801891327,
0.0303749218583107,
0.02562198042869568,
-0.04955112561583519,
-0.030711425468325615,
-0.05936732515692711,
-0.05613087862730026,
-0.0318043977022171,
-0.004163751844316721,
0.0008729619439691305,
0.02102740667760372,
0.06622736155986786,
-0.01060011237859726,
-0.02432270348072052,
-0.02422403171658516,
-0.049788884818553925,
-0.023234650492668152,
0.007291546557098627,
-0.030355695635080338,
0.014677380211651325,
-0.04439496621489525,
0.0010721685830503702,
0.02930014580488205,
0.013198127038776875,
-0.001776577322743833,
0.016735387966036797,
0.01949404366314411,
0.010232406668365002,
-0.006976699456572533,
0.002179499017074704,
-0.03755069896578789,
0.013826688751578331,
-0.03662490099668503,
0.00410913722589612,
-0.012076822109520435,
-0.014238429255783558,
-0.0032309486996382475,
-0.029303504154086113,
-0.0008544456795789301,
-0.014763839542865753,
0.024730471894145012,
0.014541422948241234,
-0.0775470957159996,
0.005831201560795307,
0.014824122190475464,
0.0018632275750860572,
0.026500526815652847,
-0.0030202826019376516,
0.047149237245321274,
-0.02676025964319706,
-0.023411419242620468,
-0.005603056866675615,
0.0048593697138130665,
0.05138862878084183,
-0.01166821364313364,
-0.009963901713490486,
0.01290950644761324,
0.05028561130166054,
0.007122814655303955,
0.038618315011262894,
-0.010649320669472218,
-0.04268711805343628,
-0.0014348957920446992,
-0.016453497111797333,
0.021463947370648384,
-0.04083912447094917,
0.03973624110221863,
0.05708449333906174,
0.03794391453266144,
-0.018583491444587708,
-0.03799130767583847,
-0.024580618366599083,
0.015834199264645576,
-0.02182084135711193,
-0.008940361440181732,
-0.017216037958860397,
0.029306476935744286,
0.03128878399729729,
-0.011685377918183804,
-0.027898328378796577,
-0.025333205237984657,
-0.056718580424785614,
0.04201674833893776,
-0.01148009579628706,
-0.04612145200371742,
-0.06698271632194519,
0.05029799044132233,
0.03927348554134369,
0.006172295194119215,
-0.010894709266722202,
0.02963872440159321,
-0.005857640411704779,
0.04478273540735245,
-0.01577942818403244,
0.00787737313657999,
-0.022300325334072113,
0.025492267683148384,
0.011395159177482128,
-0.010252406820654869,
-0.037164829671382904,
0.012569142505526543,
-0.01829005964100361,
0.02035464346408844,
-0.017040599137544632,
0.009206660091876984,
0.043753769248723984,
0.015637323260307312,
0.04280133917927742,
-0.024608595296740532,
-0.03072686307132244,
-0.01538913231343031,
-0.015558334067463875,
0.00017392446170561016,
0.049790024757385254,
-0.028243020176887512,
-0.019305815920233727,
0.023500004783272743,
0.027587147429585457,
0.015984151512384415,
-0.009532650001347065,
0.02429378591477871,
0.029062319546937943,
0.03324151784181595,
0.027517803013324738,
0.027274969965219498,
-0.019268399104475975,
-0.013347134925425053,
-0.018875904381275177,
0.025162145495414734,
-0.02333851344883442,
-0.01795572228729725,
0.019321320578455925,
0.015379749238491058,
-0.06713490933179855,
0.01613662764430046,
0.037626612931489944,
0.01422631461173296,
-0.035501398146152496,
-0.022588878870010376,
-0.0232724417001009,
-0.002199868205934763,
0.029338013380765915,
0.036222949624061584,
-0.013016365468502045,
0.03675295040011406,
-0.0642552450299263,
-0.033243607729673386,
0.026681404560804367,
0.051776740700006485,
-0.002234812593087554,
-0.041718341410160065,
0.0027413032948970795,
-0.06403148919343948,
0.011588591150939465,
0.026478074491024017,
-0.07282707840204239,
0.013714945875108242,
-0.023089934140443802,
0.031032102182507515,
0.02444172278046608,
-0.07288869470357895,
-0.011094246990978718,
0.03811122477054596,
-0.032792940735816956,
0.045989323407411575,
0.004829999525099993,
-0.00004117278513149358,
-0.00792344193905592,
-0.0036367392167448997,
0.06315723806619644,
0.0174434632062912,
0.01813182607293129,
-0.06833313405513763,
0.05195315182209015,
-0.00219161668792367,
-0.02997397817671299,
0.02922072447836399,
0.032809581607580185,
0.010690470226109028,
-0.04507283866405487,
0.025171147659420967,
0.011986710131168365,
0.012857338413596153,
-0.0017619546269997954,
-0.003941710572689772,
0.02323431707918644,
-0.04146227985620499,
-0.010658815503120422,
0.10790170729160309,
-0.005600818432867527,
-0.02120888978242874,
-0.023443840444087982,
0.020583264529705048,
0.011518847197294235,
-0.0011955118970945477,
-0.018002495169639587,
-0.0052449069917202,
-0.030789202079176903,
-0.011777706444263458,
-0.0018240988720208406,
0.029497209936380386,
0.02276417426764965,
0.0069213309325277805,
-0.0038611688651144505,
0.058265723288059235,
0.00018865498714148998,
0.04066161438822746,
-0.015020940452814102,
0.0234820656478405,
0.010664447210729122,
-0.04134078696370125,
-0.04252513125538826,
-0.021428456529974937,
-0.0008064704015851021,
-0.034992069005966187,
-0.019107023254036903,
-0.0029200129210948944,
0.02453480288386345,
-0.024340946227312088,
0.007075685076415539,
0.02301691100001335,
0.0474921315908432,
0.0401337556540966,
-0.022039368748664856,
0.02496011182665825,
-0.0010122969979420304,
0.036163244396448135,
-0.00331131205894053,
0.039519112557172775,
-0.035529475659132004,
-0.005051001440733671,
-0.007871905341744423,
-0.031173937022686005,
-0.011694840155541897,
-0.014726787805557251,
-0.06103574484586716,
-0.00003629437924246304,
0.017789123579859734,
0.06595996767282486,
-0.0187812689691782,
-0.059139102697372437,
-0.038335852324962616,
0.023792261257767677,
-0.15323017537593842,
0.005154470447450876,
0.03157961368560791,
0.022440219298005104,
-0.018067248165607452,
0.03563620150089264,
-0.024016257375478745,
-0.004813609644770622,
0.017233725637197495,
0.0053200493566691875,
0.02295239455997944,
-0.04744905233383179,
-0.009839529171586037,
0.03479737788438797,
0.006885888986289501,
-0.022775400429964066,
-0.035354822874069214,
-0.021101748570799828,
0.01549854502081871,
-0.0339597687125206,
-0.00026437322958372533,
0.003697955049574375,
-0.003103172406554222,
0.004532109946012497,
0.03675191104412079,
0.01197891402989626,
0.015610756352543831,
-0.006150548346340656,
-0.03219924122095108,
-0.02964823506772518,
-0.04562949016690254,
-0.022845594212412834,
-0.016703596338629723,
0.03102630376815796,
0.01657513529062271,
0.001307687838561833,
0.03935685008764267,
-0.06304914504289627,
-0.016258539631962776,
0.004855137784034014,
0.02023474872112274,
0.09297770261764526,
-0.006566985975950956,
0.005832979455590248,
-0.03483572229743004,
-0.02629091963171959,
0.011043963953852654,
-0.015165779739618301,
-0.020905490964651108,
-0.0031254810746759176,
0.006620428059250116,
-0.01764407567679882,
-0.010635742917656898,
0.041593506932258606,
-0.018328934907913208,
-0.006735796108841896,
0.032794609665870667,
0.03580516204237938,
0.0278600063174963,
0.012735934928059578,
-0.05757095664739609,
-0.02755686454474926,
0.017910191789269447,
0.017889464274048805,
-0.05090060830116272,
0.036340244114398956,
0.00872709695249796,
0.014213544316589832,
0.04674060642719269,
-0.012412618845701218,
-0.015878951177001,
-0.03188026323914528,
0.03537261486053467,
-0.02940603345632553,
-0.054988741874694824,
-0.003909098915755749,
0.03072483092546463,
-0.015076383017003536,
-0.020277637988328934,
-0.04337317869067192,
0.04168333113193512,
-0.02131820283830166,
0.007260532584041357,
0.039921604096889496,
-0.015779176726937294,
0.023728925734758377,
0.019256582483649254,
0.04684888944029808,
0.0022131777368485928,
0.23510527610778809,
0.006839253008365631,
0.006195352878421545,
-0.004735265392810106,
0.02735610492527485,
0.0036230776458978653,
0.020989906042814255,
0.03606404364109039,
0.015001196414232254,
-0.035511091351509094,
-0.054691966623067856,
0.024790987372398376,
0.024171000346541405,
0.03393372520804405,
-0.005573616363108158,
-0.039980947971343994,
-0.018779246136546135,
-0.06246795505285263,
0.05854595825076103,
-0.03169429302215576,
0.03875704109668732,
-0.02073632925748825,
0.02263675630092621,
0.017990155145525932,
-0.07849635183811188,
-0.04796301946043968,
0.01766747049987316,
0.009066414088010788,
0.025727244094014168,
0.02543974295258522,
-0.055020809173583984,
0.0036792289465665817,
0.001509896363131702,
-0.003153676399961114,
-0.012092790566384792,
0.03675113990902901,
-0.015712542459368706,
-0.0150430453941226,
-0.0014403285458683968,
0.06997483223676682,
0.011330184526741505,
-0.015147578902542591,
-0.015485020354390144,
-0.013291778042912483,
0.046016816049814224,
-0.018541092053055763,
-0.005035400856286287,
0.014618275687098503,
-0.007329386193305254,
0.025851761922240257,
-0.09352729469537735,
0.011173833161592484,
-0.03619870916008949,
0.035855405032634735,
-0.03805498778820038,
0.04378257691860199,
-0.022882023826241493,
0.012099961750209332,
0.002040351741015911,
0.021124396473169327,
0.013950281776487827,
0.01970173791050911,
-0.0009048290085047483,
0.004030113108456135,
0.003808981040492654,
0.021468643099069595,
-0.054162077605724335,
0.003344528377056122,
0.05364575609564781,
0.013777843676507473,
0.0037764671724289656,
0.032747335731983185,
0.008072515949606895,
0.023561587557196617,
0.03550255298614502,
0.03383085876703262,
0.03184954449534416,
0.02912491373717785,
0.0012190388515591621,
-0.03448142111301422,
-0.07528325915336609,
-0.021550452336668968,
-0.005253227427601814,
0.02700156718492508,
0.00796979758888483,
-0.009550662711262703,
0.008172237314283848,
0.0648716390132904,
0.032260097563266754,
-0.04546944797039032,
-0.016047772020101547,
0.007376471534371376,
-0.008377373218536377,
0.008557243272662163,
0.0002005522110266611,
0.007171938195824623,
0.027118761092424393,
-0.004569867625832558,
-0.02513141743838787,
-0.014537984505295753,
0.005319136660546064,
-0.0029860236681997776,
-0.000859030638821423,
-0.015968535095453262,
0.017500312998890877,
0.04784253239631653,
0.032833024859428406,
0.008175283670425415,
-0.07355859875679016,
-0.029189584776759148,
0.03793925791978836,
0.010295301675796509,
-0.02864309586584568,
-0.0018218435579910874,
0.01718733459711075,
0.035714030265808105,
-0.028062887489795685,
0.02200484648346901,
0.05349689722061157,
0.04165155068039894,
0.0014421080704778433,
-0.011841010302305222,
-0.03763694688677788,
0.0068131363950669765,
0.019646691158413887,
0.0026919040828943253,
-0.03784852847456932,
-0.03185826167464256,
0.028229868039488792,
0.014146554283797741,
0.03706468269228935,
0.003642176976427436,
-0.0012783842394128442,
-0.0028082672506570816,
0.04456738010048866,
-0.013675500638782978,
-0.025445839390158653,
0.041231684386730194,
0.011539355851709843,
-0.0187020692974329,
-0.02866612747311592,
0.023600641638040543,
-0.0541079081594944,
-0.025871876627206802,
-0.0028696341905742884,
-0.012351739220321178,
-0.025783119723200798,
0.013920157216489315,
-0.04742021858692169,
-0.006148760672658682,
-0.006221395917236805,
0.013622590340673923,
-0.039494022727012634,
-0.02357482723891735,
-0.02387763001024723,
-0.019595913589000702,
0.020497266203165054,
0.004853086080402136,
0.029368983581662178,
-0.043350666761398315,
-0.02183752879500389,
-0.02640850469470024,
-0.0015744265401735902,
0.06302663683891296,
0.01808168739080429,
0.07246513664722443,
0.014647562056779861,
0.07026650756597519,
0.05266596004366875,
-0.003347821068018675,
0.009189687669277191,
-0.02990828827023506,
0.004120275378227234,
0.01496976800262928,
0.0645994171500206,
0.10169006139039993,
0.013269398361444473,
0.011244584806263447,
0.01284122932702303,
0.006961763370782137,
-0.0024273539893329144,
0.03198501840233803,
-0.028614291921257973,
0.010907950811088085,
-0.04329347983002663,
-0.0034946876112371683,
0.026937175542116165,
-0.03733978793025017,
0.031661175191402435,
-0.018095577135682106,
-0.008858931250870228,
0.07219173014163971,
-0.04192448407411575,
-0.007481359876692295,
0.041374415159225464,
0.00727941794320941,
-0.023690342903137207,
-0.01275691855698824,
-0.011161995120346546,
-0.02374269813299179,
-0.029551036655902863,
-0.024337492883205414,
-0.0008167016785591841,
-0.016372082754969597,
0.043118223547935486,
0.006643748376518488,
0.0028874066192656755,
0.004403098952025175,
-0.02803410217165947,
-0.00007967317651491612,
-0.01319066621363163,
0.030826015397906303,
-0.01813356764614582,
-0.004381651524454355,
-0.01660209335386753,
0.024694986641407013,
0.019062485545873642,
0.02744516357779503,
-0.0030162015464156866,
-0.0457286573946476,
0.013806300237774849,
-0.002126452513039112,
0.051289647817611694,
-0.057580992579460144,
-0.01097472570836544,
0.05619636923074722,
-0.0029006460681557655,
-0.017704330384731293,
0.013449110090732574,
-0.01752249337732792,
0.009383809752762318,
-0.014532918110489845,
0.007304828613996506,
-0.023628540337085724,
0.006555857136845589,
-0.009081020951271057,
0.025063922628760338,
0.023105379194021225,
0.04066742956638336,
0.0038558323867619038,
0.0635840892791748,
-0.01647251471877098,
-0.012885203585028648,
0.064125657081604,
0.019790630787611008,
-0.009421085938811302,
0.009895932860672474,
-0.023374343290925026,
0.03530539199709892,
0.0014857506612315774,
-0.009675505571067333,
0.016805043444037437,
0.0077267540618777275,
-0.016773303970694542,
0.0011076079681515694,
-0.01733243651688099,
0.001905294950120151,
0.03274714946746826,
-0.04840715229511261,
-0.027919048443436623,
0.005264317151159048,
0.033456023782491684,
-0.010019803419709206,
-0.018332017585635185,
0.019055504351854324,
-0.049080073833465576,
0.015915224328637123,
-0.018012937158346176,
-0.024250036105513573,
-0.011799481697380543,
-0.025778021663427353,
-0.0017027475405484438,
-0.05071573704481125,
-0.06253805011510849,
-0.035729046911001205,
0.004846191965043545,
-0.04955826699733734,
0.011315250769257545,
0.027813438326120377,
-0.009496117942035198,
0.03547209873795509,
-0.013863595202565193,
-0.008352319709956646,
0.04083278402686119,
-0.02058117464184761,
0.015457451343536377,
0.025546016171574593,
0.01024651899933815,
0.0061144097708165646,
-0.02070699632167816,
0.014317087829113007,
0.039382390677928925,
-0.018063606694340706,
0.02590298093855381,
-0.00661770673468709,
0.017546778544783592,
-0.027999676764011383,
0.062113504856824875,
-0.03979145735502243,
0.024176495149731636,
-0.005976750515401363,
-0.030422348529100418,
-0.05414275452494621,
-0.031755778938531876,
-0.012613792903721333,
-0.009212197735905647,
0.018730416893959045,
-0.023304982110857964,
-0.0016680957050994039,
0.013545333407819271,
-0.010475835762917995,
-0.08883871883153915,
-0.02526249550282955,
-0.054740265011787415,
-0.00563438655808568,
0.020746901631355286,
-0.005014731083065271,
-0.010689412243664265,
0.002594233490526676,
0.013043978251516819,
-0.0028778149280697107,
-0.018998729065060616,
-0.032551348209381104,
-0.011319203302264214,
-0.03462948277592659,
0.028873788192868233,
0.007192777935415506,
-0.018382882699370384,
-0.029371090233325958,
0.011815779842436314,
-0.030466049909591675,
-0.018487539142370224,
-0.009243054315447807,
-0.004466081969439983,
0.07832156121730804,
-0.0014147704932838678,
-0.05122009292244911,
-0.005073145031929016,
0.0242643803358078,
0.012591814622282982,
0.004123189020901918,
-0.04271364212036133,
0.0691726952791214,
-0.003611250314861536,
0.023976614698767662,
0.002592835109680891,
0.011865044943988323,
0.034730177372694016,
-0.007922036573290825,
0.03257511183619499,
0.007521400228142738,
-0.02015327475965023,
-0.03697441145777702,
-0.01640653982758522,
0.007460278924554586,
-0.010928654111921787,
-0.008768510073423386,
0.03392786905169487,
0.009609905071556568,
-0.0191180557012558,
-0.0453927218914032,
0.009072478860616684,
-0.011160974390804768,
0.014780467376112938,
0.014280791394412518,
-0.004995508119463921,
-0.03369249403476715,
-0.013416922651231289,
0.01081820297986269,
-0.03479914739727974,
0.02599945105612278,
0.010926465503871441,
-0.002470168983563781,
-0.014288399368524551,
0.006250618025660515,
0.007986427284777164,
0.010263740085065365,
-0.0204169824719429,
-0.027426259592175484,
-0.057985056191682816,
-0.013903308659791946,
-0.08296007663011551,
-0.0395527146756649,
0.01746264286339283,
0.0396236777305603,
-0.034077420830726624,
-0.007188490591943264,
-0.012767009437084198,
-0.03560658171772957,
0.014393100515007973,
-0.004265082534402609,
0.050112687051296234,
-0.02693238854408264,
-0.007136580999940634,
-0.13997270166873932,
0.026389671489596367,
0.0007831903058104217,
0.023752907291054726,
-0.04790955409407616,
-0.005384180694818497,
-0.01938924565911293,
0.0005586621700786054,
0.0024738528300076723,
-0.03761652112007141,
-0.013697518035769463,
-0.00897936150431633,
0.07233062386512756,
-0.009759501554071903,
-0.04207406938076019,
0.03049056977033615,
-0.029466070234775543,
-0.039004500955343246,
-0.027386972680687904,
0.015818096697330475,
0.0022481633350253105,
0.04640566557645798,
-0.011045537889003754,
-0.013872831128537655,
-0.003850301494821906,
-0.02177475020289421,
-0.05274888873100281,
-0.023720307275652885,
-0.04483472555875778,
-0.019324306398630142,
-0.031279031187295914,
-0.008605667389929295,
0.004675047472119331,
0.035963550209999084,
-0.010334975086152554,
0.014761221595108509,
0.019551927223801613,
-0.0004111325542908162,
-0.029488038271665573,
-0.01713288575410843,
-0.011242810636758804,
0.014115356840193272,
-0.009035046212375164,
-0.004222823306918144,
-0.01816621981561184,
0.023098452016711235,
0.01226783450692892,
-0.004479690920561552,
-0.053983423858881,
-0.021778807044029236,
-0.0528549961745739,
0.017786018550395966,
-0.04753918573260307,
0.04359252750873566,
0.018966825678944588,
0.004636744037270546,
-0.02373010851442814,
-0.012487390078604221,
-0.0009053598041646183,
0.09300345182418823,
0.004147134721279144,
-0.018748633563518524,
-0.05872637778520584,
-0.005588654428720474,
0.04718008264899254,
0.023999270051717758,
-0.01771405152976513,
-0.001317859161645174,
0.010171967558562756,
0.018962038680911064,
0.02108249068260193,
0.010327260009944439,
0.016442706808447838,
-0.0325675830245018,
0.003971765749156475,
-0.012628432363271713,
0.0016983244568109512,
-0.004920996259897947,
-0.015758801251649857,
0.010405047796666622,
0.038606658577919006,
-0.028570890426635742,
-0.026768678799271584,
-0.05561525747179985,
0.04657849296927452,
0.024842435494065285,
-0.012644275091588497,
-0.03856860101222992,
0.07963314652442932,
-0.07408296316862106,
-0.06039033830165863,
-0.0027253369335085154,
-0.032482489943504333,
0.012384507805109024,
-0.056229181587696075,
0.048559654504060745,
0.007257284130901098,
-0.000121735742141027,
-0.034411367028951645,
-0.024259833618998528,
-0.04291250556707382,
-0.049281708896160126,
0.006279138382524252,
0.009195667691528797,
-0.020506080240011215,
0.026762498542666435,
-0.0021904115565121174,
0.025404704734683037,
0.029363157227635384,
0.010524217039346695,
-0.028309032320976257,
-0.025159861892461777,
0.013236897997558117,
-0.028149046003818512,
-0.04280976578593254,
-0.015131675638258457,
-0.006527539808303118,
0.04292052984237671,
-0.01599699817597866,
0.0442483127117157,
0.010944807901978493,
-0.027558358386158943,
0.04722276329994202,
-0.0024304953403770924,
-0.006479348987340927,
-0.0028537604957818985,
0.058737847954034805,
-0.003673585131764412,
0.0427832156419754,
-0.028835436329245567,
0.030969703570008278,
-0.01852830871939659,
0.003089532256126404,
0.03659218177199364,
-0.023349668830633163,
0.041845619678497314,
-0.03295763209462166,
-0.013367099687457085,
-0.001601615222170949,
-0.04004587233066559,
-0.00853352714329958,
-0.005556707736104727,
-0.02053232304751873,
0.014733046293258667,
-0.05372461676597595,
0.007467716932296753,
0.006599274463951588,
0.018438799306750298,
-0.03877316042780876,
-0.037885889410972595,
-0.037425555288791656,
-0.01029661763459444,
0.005839124321937561,
0.10322734713554382,
0.0041046831756830215,
-0.0514347106218338,
0.023462854325771332,
-0.0005757804028689861,
0.005926111713051796,
0.052677448838949203,
0.0713241770863533,
-0.03547314554452896,
-0.038096413016319275,
-0.029964689165353775,
-0.030686914920806885,
0.05975068733096123,
-0.008563925512135029,
0.008729381486773491,
-0.018806656822562218,
0.020165957510471344,
0.011634740978479385,
0.005469988100230694,
-0.0276108980178833,
0.037294138222932816,
0.01748727448284626,
-0.056283462792634964,
-0.01146978884935379,
-0.021056819707155228,
0.02229626104235649,
0.00971986260265112,
0.030949873849749565,
0.02765697054564953,
0.017992068082094193,
0.021288001909852028,
0.0013375433627516031,
0.027007173746824265,
-0.0037349285557866096,
0.019998474046587944,
-0.014591224491596222,
-0.010459991171956062,
-0.03800208494067192,
-0.019981591030955315,
0.019866375252604485,
-0.024398110806941986,
0.05205265432596207,
0.01900964230298996,
-0.013556502759456635,
0.016114473342895508,
0.028823845088481903,
0.044383466243743896,
-0.0071542877703905106,
-0.04010477289557457,
-0.026956215500831604,
0.011315369047224522,
-0.023270361125469208,
-0.02940276265144348,
0.004856029059737921,
-0.027995435521006584,
-0.03023580275475979,
0.033653367310762405,
0.003216760465875268,
0.005810211878269911,
0.0006134843570180237,
0.06812196969985962,
-0.03748270124197006,
0.005064660217612982,
0.009166326373815536,
-0.0136052081361413,
0.040589720010757446,
-0.007457743864506483,
-0.0001745307818055153,
0.07054301351308823,
-0.0249453354626894,
-0.046650953590869904,
0.02108493633568287,
0.016891025006771088,
-0.023634199053049088,
0.01804478093981743,
0.03444407880306244,
-0.01768641546368599,
-0.014123605564236641,
-0.012760232202708721,
-0.011844413354992867,
0.021089620888233185,
-0.004718313459306955,
0.013037391006946564,
0.009488416835665703,
-0.014238618314266205,
-0.012910288758575916,
-0.01963297463953495,
0.06909826397895813,
0.006279082503169775,
0.026162395253777504,
0.008345283567905426
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:14
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
63The first of these two items was a running log of a WorkCover investigation into Mr Horwood's accident. The log includes a note of a conversation between the WorkCover investigator and Mr Barry Gillett.
Mr Gillett was employed by Megbuy until early 2005 and undertook work on the forklift. It was common ground that he was not a qualified mechanic. The log includes the following entry as made, I infer, by a member of staff at WorkCover:
"On 7 June 06 I have a phone discussion with Barry Gillett (an ex employee who was responsible for repairs and maintenance of plant used by other employees of Megbuy Pty Ltd). He stated that the Nissan forklift truck did have defects with the steering mechanism.
He was of the opinion that the steering defects could have been the cause of the accident. He left employment with Megbuy Pty Ltd approximately six months prior to the incident." (emphasis added)
I made a direction under s 136 of the Evidence Act in respect of the italicised portion of this paragraph restricting its use to only prove the fact that it was that a statement that was communicated to QBE.
64Mr Campbell SC objected to the tender on the basis that any representations in the document were not admissible as exceptions to the hearsay rule under s 69(2) of the Evidence Act because they were "made in connection with an investigation relating or leading to a criminal proceeding" (s 69(3)(b)).
It was common ground that no criminal proceeding resulted from WorkCover's investigation, however it was contended this did not preclude the operation of s 69(3)(b).
65In R v Rondo [2001] NSWCCA 540; (2001) 126 A Crim R 562 Smart AJ at [96] (with whom Spigelman CJ and Simpson J agreed) described the words "in connection with" in s 69(3)(b) as having "a wide import".
It was found that a "custody management record" recording various events that occurred while the appellant was in custody and the times when they occurred was not admissible as a business record because it fell within s 69(3)(b).
The precise connection between the representations in the record and a potential criminal prosecution is not made clear in the judgement beyond the fact that the document was sent to a justice in support of the issue of a "detention warrant" under former Part 10A of the Crimes Act 1900 authorising his ongoing detention prior to his being charged.
66In Nye v New South Wales & Ors [2002] NSWSC 1268; (2002) 134 A Crim R 245 O'Keefe J rejected a submission that transcripts of a Royal Commission were excluded under s 69(3)(b) (at [18]).
His Honour found that the connection between the conduct of a Royal Commission and the instituting of a prosecution was insufficient given that "[a]t most, the Royal Commissioner could make a recommendation that consideration be given to the prosecution of certain individuals" (at [18]).
At [17] O'Keefe J suggested that a narrow construction of s 69(3)(b) was to be preferred so as not to unduly to "curtail the admission of evidence that could rationally affect the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue."
67It does not appear that O'Keefe J was referred to the decision in Rondo. In Thomas v State of New South Wales [2008] NSWCA 316; (2008) 74 NSWLR 34 at [6] Hodgson JA agreed with O'Keefe J's conclusion in Nye but held that Royal Commission transcripts were excluded by s 69(3)(a) (at [7]; Campbell JA agreeing at [17] and Gyles AJA dissenting on this point at [87]).
Again no reference was made to Rondo but the discussion by Campbell JA of the width of the expression "in connection with" in Thomas at [19] to [21] was consistent with Rondo. It is the approach that I am bound to apply.
68As at 2005 and 2006 WorkCover investigations were governed by Part 5 of the Occupational Health and Safety Act 2000 ("OHS Act"). Prosecutions were governed by Part 7.
Section 86 mandated the reporting of certain workplace accidents to WorkCover. Part 6 included s 91 which made provision for the issue of "improvement notices" requiring the remedying of any contravention of the OHS Act or the regulations.
|
[
0.019356103613972664,
0.023635996505618095,
-0.013649147003889084,
-0.01189012173563242,
0.032077573239803314,
-0.035809941589832306,
-0.06684522330760956,
0.013813411816954613,
0.011895924806594849,
0.016007233411073685,
0.004773341119289398,
0.017764532938599586,
0.01945303939282894,
-0.005988037213683128,
0.013169351033866405,
-0.033763136714696884,
0.02960059978067875,
-0.004629077389836311,
-0.03144580498337746,
0.002064935164526105,
0.011957590468227863,
-0.013531764037907124,
0.031987883150577545,
0.04587867856025696,
0.033444248139858246,
0.009957118891179562,
0.018499676138162613,
-0.009816344827413559,
-0.009870289824903011,
-0.009144817478954792,
0.011747142300009727,
0.02455045096576214,
0.008483008481562138,
-0.002976854331791401,
-0.02008313685655594,
-0.04755992442369461,
0.01825031265616417,
0.014840858057141304,
-0.04822913929820061,
-0.03039916791021824,
-0.033486250787973404,
0.0017382067162543535,
0.04436725750565529,
-0.04497050493955612,
0.06210903450846672,
-0.03561397269368172,
-0.03753816708922386,
-0.025446690618991852,
0.0011159348068758845,
0.0233949925750494,
-0.03563396632671356,
0.021856369450688362,
0.03873462602496147,
-0.028565412387251854,
0.0018605407094582915,
0.008105472661554813,
-0.014997558668255806,
-0.0576816163957119,
-0.08383739739656448,
-0.014645980671048164,
0.003069394500926137,
-0.01829947903752327,
-0.013410288840532303,
0.008039060980081558,
0.019543902948498726,
0.1081094890832901,
-0.018051087856292725,
0.01322560291737318,
-0.011415502056479454,
-0.0337904654443264,
-0.021864619106054306,
0.001488758367486298,
0.004462097305804491,
0.014591879211366177,
-0.054918043315410614,
0.010674387216567993,
-0.000775015156250447,
0.03710324689745903,
-0.02821504883468151,
0.027304697781801224,
0.03476414456963539,
0.03428833559155464,
0.005407020915299654,
0.024798160418868065,
-0.007924647070467472,
0.003322158707305789,
-0.04157344996929169,
0.02440682426095009,
0.006134448107331991,
0.0023345525842159986,
-0.0002611432282719761,
-0.022922957316040993,
0.013603614643216133,
-0.021044444292783737,
-0.011785514652729034,
-0.0019058873876929283,
-0.043746720999479294,
0.023166339844465256,
-0.010948320850729942,
-0.007427637465298176,
-0.034014537930488586,
-0.011060039512813091,
0.027749713510274887,
-0.0262063629925251,
0.006157733965665102,
0.02590598538517952,
0.029717836529016495,
0.016872761771082878,
0.029746361076831818,
-0.010057900100946426,
0.006117640528827906,
0.014890642836689949,
0.006997750606387854,
0.04933181777596474,
-0.023001892492175102,
-0.025086795911192894,
0.014758667908608913,
-0.022888991981744766,
0.021117564290761948,
-0.027079327031970024,
0.041807424277067184,
0.03003997541964054,
0.06770117580890656,
-0.04761989787220955,
-0.06050809845328331,
-0.0611514151096344,
0.02313043735921383,
-0.018371909856796265,
-0.029952432960271835,
-0.004891767632216215,
-0.004858268890529871,
0.01854759268462658,
-0.02497263066470623,
-0.04076538607478142,
-0.04866347461938858,
-0.031931739300489426,
0.05273710563778877,
-0.0012872155057266355,
-0.017303643748164177,
-0.030390415340662003,
0.05072475224733353,
0.03202522546052933,
0.005307338200509548,
-0.026673782616853714,
0.02241441421210766,
-0.022447040304541588,
0.024646975100040436,
-0.02097933553159237,
0.015401655808091164,
-0.017090247943997383,
-0.0028611081652343273,
0.00176554499194026,
-0.020239925011992455,
-0.029498104006052017,
0.01097193080931902,
-0.05074933543801308,
0.02021510899066925,
0.005071895197033882,
0.004559255205094814,
0.01397653203457594,
0.011212926357984543,
0.07067719846963882,
-0.013825171627104282,
-0.027325285598635674,
0.02974233776330948,
-0.010121393948793411,
0.01086276862770319,
0.024187248200178146,
-0.022801881656050682,
-0.040931686758995056,
0.0022445048671215773,
-0.031391263008117676,
0.021436156705021858,
-0.020691879093647003,
0.05026160925626755,
0.027258234098553658,
0.06002392619848251,
0.023119039833545685,
0.00272540794685483,
-0.0411355085670948,
-0.010579174384474754,
0.03696652129292488,
0.03244553878903389,
0.010179686360061169,
-0.009419371373951435,
0.0009286181884817779,
-0.009156552143394947,
-0.03194738179445267,
0.02374732866883278,
-0.007161740679293871,
-0.026688292622566223,
-0.026306243613362312,
0.021826978772878647,
0.032441701740026474,
0.019993316382169724,
-0.0005482915439642966,
0.02840522490441799,
-0.023817358538508415,
0.018841678276658058,
0.0017124273581430316,
-0.032081566751003265,
0.025599634274840355,
0.0657886490225792,
-0.05891232565045357,
-0.06636588275432587,
-0.005632884334772825,
-0.027231687679886818,
-0.0040217735804617405,
0.029101183637976646,
-0.0670112669467926,
0.03601432591676712,
0.015536361373960972,
0.02754971571266651,
0.03306044265627861,
-0.051694177091121674,
0.0236569382250309,
-0.01736440137028694,
-0.027202045544981956,
0.01804995723068714,
-0.003463050816208124,
0.00473408866673708,
-0.006905257236212492,
0.012204143218696117,
-0.0005124133313074708,
0.041614457964897156,
0.010159107856452465,
-0.03725405037403107,
0.036585863679647446,
0.03499482572078705,
-0.04604044184088707,
0.04124341160058975,
0.0009363307617604733,
0.05275767669081688,
-0.029854705557227135,
0.012846226803958416,
-0.01234510075300932,
0.025870971381664276,
0.010543564334511757,
0.031149480491876602,
0.0549175888299942,
-0.021363765001296997,
-0.0334576852619648,
0.0551656074821949,
-0.03463716432452202,
0.0011850951705127954,
-0.02769644930958748,
0.032636817544698715,
0.0012736634816974401,
0.018205534666776657,
-0.00446788826957345,
0.036999981850385666,
-0.01810387708246708,
-0.014627966098487377,
-0.0034897809382528067,
0.022036029025912285,
0.04764741286635399,
0.04726819694042206,
-0.02446076087653637,
0.018158001825213432,
-0.014780405908823013,
0.011456177569925785,
0.0462854765355587,
0.03923017531633377,
-0.0028783781453967094,
-0.02286650612950325,
-0.006429774686694145,
-0.028058672323822975,
-0.03640960529446602,
-0.017580583691596985,
0.0010181711986660957,
-0.009190021082758904,
-0.010763222351670265,
-0.014234818518161774,
-0.022103874012827873,
0.02270760014653206,
0.005982583854347467,
-0.012574201449751854,
-0.005877187941223383,
0.011238470673561096,
-0.02278502658009529,
0.027670320123434067,
-0.004546517971903086,
0.027227118611335754,
-0.039651427417993546,
0.02634657546877861,
-0.0088660828769207,
-0.0018181402701884508,
-0.0505249910056591,
-0.030335955321788788,
-0.02881636470556259,
0.0499858595430851,
0.022594435140490532,
0.07271181046962738,
-0.011659549549221992,
-0.05031973123550415,
0.029394004493951797,
-0.019802391529083252,
-0.15625780820846558,
-0.0059820907190442085,
-0.004011303652077913,
0.020488807931542397,
0.0159304179251194,
0.04785647615790367,
0.024739781394600868,
-0.02329099364578724,
-0.03394559025764465,
0.026101605966687202,
0.025111688300967216,
-0.06180466338992119,
-0.04880227893590927,
0.006387390196323395,
-0.01519824843853712,
-0.009988753125071526,
-0.011428404599428177,
-0.0031440986786037683,
0.06075410917401314,
-0.04870349541306496,
-0.019023464992642403,
-0.014071790501475334,
0.02916014939546585,
0.01578877493739128,
0.0457431860268116,
-0.028709042817354202,
0.04771298170089722,
-0.005364264361560345,
-0.0053553227335214615,
-0.04872659593820572,
-0.013109476305544376,
-0.011569194495677948,
-0.0015647883992642164,
0.047422368079423904,
0.0029785598162561655,
0.03331032395362854,
0.05372602492570877,
-0.06110639125108719,
-0.05660400912165642,
-0.006209003273397684,
0.023105010390281677,
0.07707168906927109,
-0.014553009532392025,
0.006564178969711065,
0.01941445656120777,
-0.0778350904583931,
0.023059749975800514,
-0.0021906481124460697,
-0.07068205624818802,
0.01386123988777399,
-0.028083527460694313,
-0.022090042009949684,
-0.03144489973783493,
0.006633156444877386,
0.00005961869464954361,
-0.02641717903316021,
0.0515594407916069,
0.026841407641768456,
-0.018577268347144127,
0.027554335072636604,
0.0023390662390738726,
-0.05682215094566345,
0.046182237565517426,
0.0031695463694632053,
-0.017560208216309547,
0.010695473290979862,
-0.003344764467328787,
-0.003009866224601865,
0.014371862635016441,
-0.030750595033168793,
-0.012193530797958374,
-0.020755311474204063,
0.009692974388599396,
0.0025868897791951895,
0.010022478178143501,
0.006745617836713791,
-0.006376593839377165,
-0.024873578920960426,
-0.011154855601489544,
-0.08513917773962021,
-0.03318136930465698,
0.03363097459077835,
0.0032498412765562534,
-0.0013746279291808605,
-0.008862161077558994,
0.07843665778636932,
0.028709091246128082,
0.035143427550792694,
0.02615961618721485,
0.2400156855583191,
0.011808663606643677,
-0.04185953363776207,
-0.029947221279144287,
0.00428604893386364,
-0.0021299528889358044,
0.020548267289996147,
0.006033100187778473,
0.009412708692252636,
-0.030914466828107834,
-0.03336198627948761,
0.00022942772193346173,
0.03408101573586464,
-0.003715276950970292,
-0.012580924667418003,
0.007314723450690508,
-0.04390297457575798,
-0.03640664368867874,
0.07210717350244522,
-0.00218829489313066,
0.05296019837260246,
-0.001600082847289741,
0.028583016246557236,
0.025779299437999725,
-0.06173206493258476,
-0.011954383924603462,
-0.021300025284290314,
0.014004184864461422,
-0.01626356691122055,
0.019419964402914047,
0.0017766524106264114,
0.007644508965313435,
0.0016320376889780164,
0.0311224777251482,
0.0049491943791508675,
0.024625521153211594,
-0.018385009840130806,
0.000384834420401603,
-0.009198851883411407,
0.016187289729714394,
-0.008316289633512497,
-0.011705268174409866,
-0.02258249558508396,
-0.01329734455794096,
0.013160429894924164,
-0.002566783456131816,
0.015377999283373356,
0.012512939050793648,
-0.00835198350250721,
0.034234460443258286,
-0.05731866508722305,
-0.006212245207279921,
-0.030474644154310226,
-0.010651150718331337,
-0.02377908304333687,
0.03234820067882538,
-0.04033567011356354,
0.0008755578310228884,
0.0012956351274624467,
0.02764788083732128,
-0.007690766826272011,
0.00795599166303873,
-0.030543940141797066,
0.028228431940078735,
0.004295879043638706,
0.02007073350250721,
-0.04307977110147476,
-0.03947306424379349,
0.07029256224632263,
-0.02575065940618515,
-0.009892357513308525,
0.028285173699259758,
0.022812435403466225,
0.046403493732213974,
0.05466628074645996,
0.038401342928409576,
0.004137849435210228,
0.06410511583089828,
-0.020517434924840927,
-0.010218963958323002,
-0.02876327373087406,
-0.008912756107747555,
0.00534977437928319,
0.02412090077996254,
0.01027863472700119,
-0.017029302194714546,
0.023664340376853943,
0.07724231481552124,
0.03250794857740402,
0.021047649905085564,
-0.001947280252352357,
-0.03248090669512749,
-0.023606525734066963,
-0.007438823115080595,
-0.027780216187238693,
0.04015452414751053,
0.026688287034630775,
0.0015847485046833754,
0.0032796713057905436,
-0.03233053535223007,
-0.013049240224063396,
0.01698746718466282,
-0.01470605842769146,
-0.008597001433372498,
-0.03467755764722824,
-0.000489227706566453,
0.00949220173060894,
-0.03211095184087753,
0.004035354591906071,
-0.04205461964011192,
-0.04257526248693466,
-0.007585891056805849,
-0.01873890496790409,
-0.038044899702072144,
0.021880578249692917,
0.007242806721478701,
-0.03055981732904911,
0.03827286139130592,
0.000017011867385008372,
0.04793855920433998,
-0.016148516908288002,
-0.0012052352540194988,
-0.025451473891735077,
0.01442074403166771,
-0.02131602168083191,
-0.016124768182635307,
-0.05567360669374466,
-0.058204617351293564,
-0.006461556069552898,
0.048043083399534225,
0.021550770848989487,
-0.011467714793980122,
-0.02701239287853241,
0.006826448254287243,
0.024227263405919075,
-0.01402532123029232,
0.017895091325044632,
0.03411579132080078,
-0.015280110761523247,
0.011493664234876633,
-0.06406799703836441,
0.019601231440901756,
-0.03377293050289154,
-0.010345466434955597,
-0.01285792887210846,
-0.008631217293441296,
-0.022793501615524292,
0.02277577854692936,
-0.050171639770269394,
-0.021267205476760864,
-0.0016029676189646125,
0.026584025472402573,
-0.02587820589542389,
-0.02244100533425808,
0.016640735790133476,
0.010197707451879978,
0.02073802426457405,
0.011543480679392815,
0.0466919019818306,
-0.0244985930621624,
-0.006184838712215424,
0.0011469253804534674,
-0.0022883289493620396,
0.04481060802936554,
0.006357342004776001,
0.044341471046209335,
-0.0046976907178759575,
0.039775993674993515,
0.0764581710100174,
-0.02030564472079277,
-0.006033174693584442,
-0.08157691359519958,
-0.00890767015516758,
0.06986191123723984,
0.05610572546720505,
0.0773971751332283,
-0.03605731949210167,
0.01546857226639986,
-0.010859934613108635,
-0.03105812892317772,
-0.0013750356156378984,
0.021659471094608307,
-0.02354402281343937,
-0.013471515849232674,
-0.019877875223755836,
0.006673467345535755,
0.03862816467881203,
-0.031503308564424515,
-0.0014504186110571027,
-0.028147870674729347,
-0.03613659739494324,
0.08784765005111694,
-0.025457166135311127,
-0.0170846376568079,
0.02908357046544552,
-0.015516391023993492,
0.0004034317971672863,
0.00129240145906806,
-0.004226307850331068,
-0.050322823226451874,
-0.015963608399033546,
0.03470521792769432,
0.03355373069643974,
-0.01335801649838686,
0.057731352746486664,
0.00466089928522706,
-0.033384643495082855,
0.003548631677404046,
-0.0355016253888607,
-0.020501969382166862,
0.05963892862200737,
0.017005931586027145,
-0.043369945138692856,
-0.019457556307315826,
0.006551880389451981,
0.0007366667850874364,
0.058323923498392105,
0.07597694545984268,
-0.015497448854148388,
-0.06678406149148941,
-0.001425527618266642,
-0.018081236630678177,
0.04424025118350983,
-0.049539122730493546,
-0.026631737127900124,
0.021594785153865814,
-0.02288683131337166,
-0.04346374049782753,
0.044966183602809906,
0.012595568783581257,
0.011399478651583195,
-0.049099452793598175,
0.015487827360630035,
-0.04371500387787819,
-0.003773636417463422,
0.036082878708839417,
0.02000809647142887,
0.0007627225713804364,
0.0018134366255253553,
-0.051440924406051636,
0.042529068887233734,
-0.0014687477378174663,
0.03260359540581703,
0.062014028429985046,
-0.019921263679862022,
-0.03896370157599449,
0.02048022486269474,
-0.0020164467860013247,
0.01339512038975954,
0.02928987704217434,
0.010376323014497757,
0.0011264730710536242,
-0.003992307931184769,
-0.043313805013895035,
0.006715427152812481,
0.008598203770816326,
-0.00667802058160305,
0.018749775364995003,
-0.011255004443228245,
-0.024701328948140144,
0.007637789472937584,
0.01154171209782362,
-0.030648352578282356,
-0.04307123273611069,
0.01730435900390148,
-0.05120942369103432,
0.04508091136813164,
0.004049861803650856,
-0.011046030558645725,
-0.04186183214187622,
0.011325271800160408,
-0.00996567215770483,
-0.04526856914162636,
-0.032920416444540024,
-0.045880794525146484,
0.007896319031715393,
-0.024994822219014168,
0.0006364707951433957,
0.03129420429468155,
-0.022432025521993637,
0.048955149948596954,
-0.03649229183793068,
-0.02066303789615631,
0.0434909351170063,
0.004919479601085186,
0.04546456038951874,
0.006911578122526407,
0.006898588966578245,
0.0008300660992972553,
-0.039403725415468216,
0.031224986538290977,
0.026451950892806053,
0.0014522784622386098,
0.012310249730944633,
-0.00433264160528779,
-0.008815688081085682,
0.022481828927993774,
0.07440731674432755,
-0.05055631324648857,
0.026867574080824852,
-0.01323075033724308,
0.01936170645058155,
-0.02981983684003353,
-0.06678846478462219,
0.0037482331972569227,
-0.0038289271760731936,
0.004231690429151058,
-0.02949894405901432,
-0.027767058461904526,
0.003565911902114749,
0.016835853457450867,
-0.07377413660287857,
0.007107696030288935,
-0.037644125521183014,
-0.025929292663931847,
0.03319770470261574,
-0.013042571023106575,
-0.024919547140598297,
-0.007680212613195181,
0.017872801050543785,
0.02050704136490822,
0.012440335005521774,
-0.05398094281554222,
-0.02359575405716896,
-0.08431323617696762,
0.029109448194503784,
-0.012890740297734737,
0.015452319756150246,
-0.012159312143921852,
-0.026342028751969337,
-0.05090903863310814,
-0.03145047277212143,
0.0013677526731044054,
-0.009363077580928802,
0.0865912139415741,
-0.0053291781805455685,
-0.018760716542601585,
-0.021563366055488586,
0.06288246810436249,
-0.04834435135126114,
-0.019198190420866013,
-0.05967080965638161,
0.08026803284883499,
-0.008470464497804642,
0.03267432749271393,
-0.015989849343895912,
0.010251578874886036,
-0.015485186129808426,
0.040651995688676834,
0.017863629385828972,
0.003244725987315178,
0.03883562609553337,
-0.01969693973660469,
-0.03685427084565163,
0.005626479629427195,
0.03850601986050606,
0.018063602969050407,
0.012545367702841759,
0.005789817776530981,
-0.00958323199301958,
-0.0234090406447649,
0.02134336531162262,
-0.03617207705974579,
-0.016460947692394257,
0.02969745732843876,
0.012864282354712486,
0.012025220319628716,
0.02852449379861355,
-0.004810519050806761,
-0.004329034127295017,
-0.005359777715057135,
-0.011339266784489155,
0.01887969672679901,
-0.027746863663196564,
-0.020442534238100052,
-0.00868471059948206,
0.0075442115776240826,
0.0034609283320605755,
-0.04640139639377594,
0.01945793256163597,
-0.008553904481232166,
-0.06308242678642273,
-0.0045443810522556305,
0.0050544110126793385,
0.009087549522519112,
-0.0024457769468426704,
-0.026211032643914223,
0.02553102932870388,
-0.03140854835510254,
0.039970722049474716,
-0.024516209959983826,
0.0424928292632103,
-0.03618929162621498,
0.03989674150943756,
-0.1407501995563507,
-0.00011916885705431923,
-0.00009894657705444843,
0.010744818486273289,
-0.0833209976553917,
-0.024528231471776962,
0.011778918094933033,
0.031302377581596375,
-0.015284014865756035,
-0.009496205486357212,
0.0035325060598552227,
-0.04185839369893074,
0.051787447184324265,
-0.004400335717946291,
-0.05540093034505844,
0.020261703059077263,
-0.007631158456206322,
-0.02624668926000595,
-0.046214509755373,
0.022675590589642525,
0.020526088774204254,
0.025189513340592384,
0.025910310447216034,
-0.00766502320766449,
-0.027574315667152405,
0.0012363947462290525,
-0.0661807507276535,
-0.012559291906654835,
-0.03519172966480255,
-0.014206989668309689,
-0.04213270917534828,
-0.049441128969192505,
0.02148156613111496,
0.03785448893904686,
-0.012302152812480927,
0.009507172740995884,
0.010992636904120445,
-0.00853780284523964,
-0.010314319282770157,
-0.01926282048225403,
-0.02811817266047001,
0.013387791812419891,
-0.03008224256336689,
-0.006372050382196903,
0.0038972010370343924,
-0.005548899061977863,
-0.016989627853035927,
-0.007013734895735979,
-0.04254801571369171,
-0.014153808355331421,
-0.0015347222797572613,
0.017037764191627502,
-0.02262888289988041,
0.01962907798588276,
-0.003241542726755142,
0.022351037710905075,
0.0033184702042490244,
-0.03780239075422287,
-0.039067432284355164,
0.04701441526412964,
0.0016189402667805552,
-0.002302753971889615,
-0.03779779002070427,
-0.03520364314317703,
-0.0029292437247931957,
0.005334623157978058,
-0.00227067107334733,
0.009113172069191933,
-0.019526371732354164,
0.016140710562467575,
-0.020033398643136024,
-0.022687716409564018,
0.0034731272608041763,
-0.009784713387489319,
-0.026631921529769897,
-0.012659342959523201,
-0.006162273231893778,
0.00475292606279254,
0.03887614607810974,
0.027063407003879547,
-0.009608382359147072,
-0.0011877113720402122,
-0.037592776119709015,
0.018024899065494537,
0.028114749118685722,
0.01984287053346634,
0.015864554792642593,
-0.015473322942852974,
0.03209036588668823,
-0.033933695405721664,
-0.04929059371352196,
0.01204736065119505,
-0.03016597218811512,
0.044574636965990067,
-0.03870323672890663,
0.05525437742471695,
-0.017599523067474365,
0.00935959629714489,
-0.018593955785036087,
-0.007634754292666912,
-0.03343907371163368,
-0.022837843745946884,
0.008649324998259544,
0.006083302199840546,
-0.013693450950086117,
0.0044694263488054276,
0.014018755406141281,
-0.0011066705919802189,
0.018008023500442505,
0.0024215104058384895,
0.0037951660342514515,
-0.03009469248354435,
-0.012966245412826538,
-0.005934752523899078,
-0.04432138055562973,
0.04545474424958229,
0.016601979732513428,
-0.0055265421979129314,
-0.018726270645856857,
0.02978772670030594,
0.02404703013598919,
-0.02325083501636982,
0.006921574007719755,
-0.014028205536305904,
-0.03434629365801811,
0.03758885711431503,
0.04588276520371437,
-0.0011848282301798463,
0.02676263451576233,
0.00038408927503041923,
0.03015631064772606,
0.015337691642343998,
-0.012728133238852024,
0.02778695523738861,
-0.018954405561089516,
0.042418673634529114,
-0.041773878037929535,
0.011538254097104073,
-0.022169079631567,
-0.0501568466424942,
-0.011821196414530277,
-0.010841538198292255,
-0.008631626144051552,
-0.01203739084303379,
-0.016653209924697876,
-0.036148831248283386,
0.026989953592419624,
-0.029373187571763992,
-0.04120935499668121,
-0.031178288161754608,
-0.00024370088067371398,
0.03761247918009758,
0.0060952203348279,
0.047568947076797485,
0.016563380137085915,
-0.030741067603230476,
0.05118639022111893,
0.006612748373299837,
-0.01474335789680481,
0.03380853682756424,
0.03201831504702568,
-0.029119474813342094,
-0.029993994161486626,
-0.022075586020946503,
-0.050679758191108704,
0.04998786002397537,
-0.00744075421243906,
-0.007908519357442856,
-0.01667351834475994,
-0.0037550232373178005,
0.010111922398209572,
-0.0026346894446760416,
-0.02612399123609066,
-0.017229391261935234,
0.05256184563040733,
-0.03994646668434143,
-0.009862104430794716,
-0.022452132776379585,
0.06948300451040268,
-0.020855816081166267,
0.049475543200969696,
0.04978378117084503,
0.0321226604282856,
0.027298929169774055,
-0.02410678192973137,
0.04346439987421036,
-0.0023899569641798735,
-0.010710827074944973,
-0.039402078837156296,
-0.0056609949097037315,
0.01391234714537859,
0.019515622407197952,
0.011688309721648693,
-0.027449652552604675,
0.043398041278123856,
-0.00043351779459044337,
-0.02651403844356537,
0.009669005870819092,
0.01056880783289671,
0.045275021344423294,
0.0050574238412082195,
0.00018293278117198497,
-0.017775580286979675,
-0.027937864884734154,
-0.029846327379345894,
-0.008771942928433418,
0.011163398623466492,
-0.047493282705545425,
-0.0161028653383255,
0.05675780028104782,
-0.026395563036203384,
-0.029714103788137436,
-0.006502338219434023,
0.03226720541715622,
-0.028480753302574158,
0.013117979280650616,
0.00005852835238329135,
-0.01734958030283451,
-0.0026133425999432802,
-0.010385469533503056,
0.025682855397462845,
0.07113529741764069,
-0.009576410055160522,
-0.03080660104751587,
0.024048371240496635,
-0.0025260711554437876,
-0.003884446807205677,
0.006926913745701313,
0.02814587578177452,
0.002776368521153927,
0.0018938551656901836,
0.006177461706101894,
-0.02204587124288082,
0.027732616290450096,
0.02949238382279873,
0.006862931419163942,
-0.04105374962091446,
-0.023458393290638924,
-0.02991398796439171,
-0.01942479982972145,
0.038287583738565445,
0.0017012471798807383,
0.029858199879527092,
0.0027979006990790367
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:25
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
In the emphasised part of the above passage Spigelman CJ confirmed that, in a circumstance where a defect had "caused an accident" while the car was being driven, then that would be caught by (a)(i) of the definition. The defect "would be the cause" and the physical injuries that were occasioned would be both a "result of" and "caused during" the driving of the vehicle.
122In Allianz v GSF a truck was fitted with a mechanical unloading system which conveyed the containers to the rear of the truck where they were removed by a forklift. The mechanical unloading system became inoperative and an employee was directed by his employer to convey the containers manually to the rear of the truck. He was injured while doing so.
The employee sought to argue that he fell within sub-paragraph (a)(iv) of the definition of "injury". It was not open to the employee to contend that he fell within any of (a)(i) to (a)(iii) because the injury was not caused during the driving of the vehicle, a collision involving the vehicle or the vehicle running out of control.
123At [87] to [94] Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ addressed the proper construction of the definition of "injury". Their Honours proceeded upon an acceptance of the correctness of the construction of sub paragraph (a)(iv) adopted in Zurich v CSR at [88] to [89]. Their Honours construed the definition of "injury" in the context of (a)(iv) as follows, (at [93] to [94]):
"In argument, some suggestion was conveyed that the terms "result" and "cause" have different meanings and, in particular, that "cause" narrows "result". That is not so. The drafting in the second part of paragraph (a) of the definition seeks to accommodate two cumulative criteria and does so by telescoping them into a grammatical contortion.
One criterion is that the injury be sustained during certain events, including the driving of the vehicle or a collision with a vehicle or its running out of control. The other criterion is that the injury be sustained as a consequence of those events.
The phrase "a result of" is linked to the first or temporal criterion; the phrase "is caused by" is linked to the second criterion. In sub paragraph (iv), the temporal criterion is that the injury be as a result of the use or operation of the vehicle because it was sustained during that activity. The other criterion is by the injury being caused by a defect in the vehicle".
124Their Honours then addressed the second criterion identified in [94], namely whether the injury was "caused by a defect in the vehicle". On that issue, their Honours held that the phrase "if and only if ... directs attention to notions of predominance and immediacy rather than to more removed circumstances" (at [102]).
Their Honours found that it was the system of work and, in particular, the direction to the injured worker which had the relevant predominant quality of, and immediacy to, the plaintiff's injury. The defect in the unloading system was not a defect by which the accident was caused in the necessary statutory sense (at [103]).
125The judgment of McHugh J was to similar effect. His Honour considered that Zurich v CSR had correctly construed (a)(iv) of the definition of injury (at [25]).
McHugh J identified three aspects of causation that arise in a case under (a)(iv) of the definition of "injury". The first aspect of causation was that the accident be "caused by the fault of the owner in the use of the operation of the vehicle".
The "fault" of the owner in Allianz v GSF was satisfied by both the direction given by the employer to the injured employee as well as the failure by the owner to fix the defective unloading mechanism.
The fault was also found to be in the use of the operation of the truck as it was in the use of the transport of employer's goods (at [22]). The second aspect of causation as to whether there was a defect in the vehicle was that the injury must be "a result of and is caused during .
|
[
-0.017743226140737534,
0.013406340964138508,
-0.013918188400566578,
-0.019705690443515778,
-0.006935983430594206,
0.01727933995425701,
-0.022400373592972755,
0.029435520991683006,
0.027543408796191216,
-0.006620450410991907,
-0.006610882934182882,
0.013534733094274998,
-0.020075634121894836,
0.008497698232531548,
0.027436666190624237,
0.004111809190362692,
0.0442764014005661,
-0.019282514229416847,
-0.005851224064826965,
-0.037801723927259445,
0.02467932738363743,
-0.0014652723912149668,
0.04569345340132713,
0.05361252650618553,
0.004982356447726488,
0.03257365897297859,
-0.008565593510866165,
0.00587569922208786,
0.02118302322924137,
-0.00474864337593317,
-0.0036302118096500635,
-0.007752626668661833,
-0.014401094056665897,
-0.01063658855855465,
0.011882718652486801,
-0.00039473542710766196,
-0.018652237951755524,
-0.014500219374895096,
-0.020403314381837845,
0.035359956324100494,
-0.041066717356443405,
-0.02845083549618721,
-0.01423473097383976,
-0.05738885700702667,
0.05045059323310852,
-0.03914408013224602,
-0.009845713153481483,
-0.040170662105083466,
-0.020847143605351448,
-0.037879329174757004,
-0.07359559088945389,
-0.014925002120435238,
0.10204240679740906,
-0.031709082424640656,
0.008749702014029026,
0.009721633978188038,
-0.02913287654519081,
-0.03183257579803467,
-0.05459389463067055,
-0.020193984732031822,
-0.03735610842704773,
-0.025082018226385117,
-0.015179064124822617,
-0.014850289560854435,
0.005984725430607796,
0.04443000257015228,
-0.02010045200586319,
-0.03301373869180679,
-0.02192123420536518,
-0.05297548323869705,
0.015410290099680424,
-0.011143727228045464,
-0.0063234237022697926,
-0.012259094975888729,
-0.05621547996997833,
0.013856115750968456,
0.03921213746070862,
0.002821528585627675,
-0.0007422366179525852,
0.035780709236860275,
-0.013847104273736477,
-0.017504606395959854,
-0.03043537586927414,
0.011106795631349087,
-0.01238858513534069,
0.008308788761496544,
-0.043589998036623,
0.030001161620020866,
-0.0014536716043949127,
-0.030055759474635124,
0.020997680723667145,
-0.007828163914382458,
-0.010540198534727097,
-0.01804833672940731,
0.043304793536663055,
-0.022144213318824768,
-0.07180380076169968,
0.041038449853658676,
-0.005787473171949387,
0.04989629611372948,
0.016740135848522186,
0.028704090043902397,
0.0022591673769056797,
-0.040742188692092896,
-0.006454935763031244,
-0.01832624152302742,
0.05120816454291344,
0.04810677096247673,
-0.009972243569791317,
-0.011035013943910599,
0.0065018958412110806,
0.028368361294269562,
0.00664738891646266,
0.02627546712756157,
-0.014687838032841682,
0.015880949795246124,
0.00009287007560487837,
-0.060570355504751205,
0.0665423572063446,
-0.009564665146172047,
0.035551752895116806,
0.019073836505413055,
0.034888315945863724,
-0.0023160644341260195,
-0.04140544310212135,
0.026693783700466156,
-0.012642323039472103,
0.044434309005737305,
-0.03646830469369888,
0.010972714982926846,
0.005383159499615431,
0.06045211851596832,
-0.024334702640771866,
-0.03145332634449005,
-0.0036418652161955833,
-0.004927178844809532,
0.04893337935209274,
-0.010184123180806637,
-0.008088692091405392,
-0.02753359079360962,
0.054210346192121506,
0.01727631315588951,
0.025267932564020157,
-0.021633442491292953,
0.014957882463932037,
-0.007158644963055849,
0.03707403317093849,
0.008958677761256695,
0.013439318165183067,
-0.031483244150877,
0.008996527642011642,
0.0002981071302201599,
0.06517086923122406,
-0.07191799581050873,
0.046185556799173355,
-0.03056911565363407,
0.007518445607274771,
0.004279774148017168,
-0.018545344471931458,
0.011642144992947578,
0.00031798839336261153,
0.07608688622713089,
-0.0012960875174030662,
0.00807716604322195,
0.04001258686184883,
-0.0032083967234939337,
0.015556874684989452,
0.04815465956926346,
-0.07090813666582108,
-0.06727368384599686,
0.028568271547555923,
0.009149536490440369,
0.030460206791758537,
-0.011655881069600582,
0.029898427426815033,
0.04951127991080284,
0.06216198951005936,
0.004839447792619467,
-0.00033491887734271586,
-0.040570493787527084,
0.004341257736086845,
-0.018026050180196762,
0.033913712948560715,
-0.007610954809933901,
-0.024320321157574654,
-0.009104238823056221,
0.011789537034928799,
-0.012499736621975899,
0.018573680892586708,
-0.011771997436881065,
-0.03776306286454201,
-0.06485534459352493,
-0.0067765661515295506,
0.04196369647979736,
0.049414508044719696,
-0.01254481915384531,
0.05499854311347008,
0.012161454185843468,
0.03369960933923721,
-0.04292893037199974,
0.010667908936738968,
0.016373207792639732,
0.04504473879933357,
-0.009724540635943413,
-0.03702197223901749,
-0.016380392014980316,
-0.10413128137588501,
-0.006342918146401644,
0.018590113148093224,
-0.0466856025159359,
0.03835722431540489,
-0.03813791647553444,
-0.017338113859295845,
-0.026762580499053,
-0.0021984493359923363,
-0.0323767326772213,
0.0036548220086842775,
0.0066680945456027985,
0.011266840621829033,
-0.01420407835394144,
-0.018278172239661217,
-0.0028637012001127005,
-0.02331947162747383,
0.020027194172143936,
-0.0046403054147958755,
0.018158650025725365,
-0.014267832972109318,
0.007759915664792061,
-0.0016651090700179338,
0.0012720529921352863,
0.058962274342775345,
0.013503254391252995,
0.0059668635949492455,
-0.047723472118377686,
0.019828131422400475,
0.001124226488173008,
0.06309335678815842,
0.00784036424010992,
0.0385117270052433,
-0.010368799790740013,
-0.005114465486258268,
-0.05716189742088318,
0.037775326520204544,
-0.0265421811491251,
-0.03353574872016907,
-0.032274071127176285,
0.031176680698990822,
0.014918697066605091,
-0.017265653237700462,
0.011166820302605629,
0.06644954532384872,
0.02051999792456627,
0.02039283514022827,
-0.027224306017160416,
0.003708211239427328,
0.01580463908612728,
-0.007923628203570843,
-0.01383982878178358,
0.01685594953596592,
-0.02746906690299511,
0.007881936617195606,
0.04142138361930847,
0.019852671772241592,
-0.013325249776244164,
0.0309994388371706,
-0.06813274323940277,
-0.04474340006709099,
-0.03241995722055435,
-0.05139528959989548,
-0.021398358047008514,
0.03138743340969086,
0.003876657923683524,
-0.013070080429315567,
-0.01539709884673357,
0.024392075836658478,
0.033039867877960205,
0.01385437697172165,
-0.01363667007535696,
0.06973402947187424,
0.003193387296050787,
0.03557976335287094,
-0.049179647117853165,
0.027210231870412827,
-0.009416520595550537,
0.05086586996912956,
0.014742153696715832,
0.0028242249973118305,
-0.02004403807222843,
-0.0034881839528679848,
-0.00913430005311966,
0.0577937550842762,
-0.03464822098612785,
0.0529252365231514,
-0.03875703737139702,
-0.06702662259340286,
0.023866776376962662,
-0.0005676563596352935,
-0.15524551272392273,
-0.026205450296401978,
0.00649681780487299,
0.04129254072904587,
0.0009998215828090906,
0.00037269387394189835,
-0.05768842250108719,
-0.019992917776107788,
-0.03654897212982178,
0.021484049037098885,
-0.0018224046798422933,
-0.056412212550640106,
-0.022348560392856598,
-0.02705467864871025,
0.0077139837667346,
-0.013065095990896225,
-0.0457414835691452,
0.008488506078720093,
0.0090715903788805,
0.0018118711886927485,
0.023157015442848206,
-0.005847445223480463,
-0.04587707668542862,
-0.031668346375226974,
0.003946827258914709,
-0.019699878990650177,
0.007433912251144648,
0.04011644423007965,
-0.03368718549609184,
-0.010665586218237877,
-0.09716245532035828,
0.005388200748711824,
-0.01911011151969433,
0.044588133692741394,
0.015097021125257015,
0.0077084023505449295,
0.020109152421355247,
-0.10443444550037384,
0.01664981245994568,
0.030223604291677475,
0.013162992894649506,
0.06166530027985573,
-0.0038381728809326887,
0.009812586009502411,
0.0000551098637515679,
-0.048423413187265396,
0.03179403766989708,
-0.008328300900757313,
-0.02413107268512249,
0.011051503010094166,
-0.007135341409593821,
-0.015130490064620972,
-0.008582965470850468,
-0.0023174313828349113,
-0.014247373677790165,
-0.004517911933362484,
0.05193793773651123,
0.026610620319843292,
0.008831287734210491,
0.02359478361904621,
0.018098769709467888,
-0.033242806792259216,
-0.0031812984962016344,
0.006011024117469788,
-0.01031095627695322,
-0.03935253620147705,
0.007652457803487778,
-0.01357796136289835,
0.048737723380327225,
-0.03337255120277405,
-0.015517107211053371,
-0.05816134065389633,
0.026185374706983566,
-0.027450185269117355,
0.025153782218694687,
-0.015504325740039349,
0.0062299855053424835,
0.012053404934704304,
0.004475622903555632,
-0.05538906529545784,
0.00041972368489950895,
0.01481027901172638,
0.02940411865711212,
0.03211981803178787,
-0.00626020785421133,
0.027350930497050285,
0.028569700196385384,
-0.008947459049522877,
0.0031769073102623224,
0.21282221376895905,
0.012019054032862186,
0.0006662579253315926,
-0.013339409604668617,
0.025936150923371315,
-0.018117384985089302,
0.025179827585816383,
-0.022010987624526024,
-0.012837390415370464,
-0.048366349190473557,
-0.05168883502483368,
0.006637046113610268,
-0.012028527446091175,
0.04163379222154617,
-0.03375298157334328,
-0.029959607869386673,
-0.03127238154411316,
-0.02204168774187565,
0.08660861849784851,
-0.022201726213097572,
0.022508656606078148,
0.0023018240462988615,
0.06939254701137543,
0.013289254158735275,
-0.05451991409063339,
-0.03464766964316368,
-0.003603561082854867,
-0.03748021274805069,
0.007424074690788984,
-0.007371223531663418,
-0.05034979432821274,
-0.013765133917331696,
0.032020147889852524,
-0.005640816409140825,
-0.04075101017951965,
-0.0034662852995097637,
-0.038433365523815155,
-0.0057800388894975185,
-0.013564263470470905,
0.017943933606147766,
0.03541968762874603,
-0.002156676957383752,
-0.0053221192210912704,
-0.018573008477687836,
0.024169763550162315,
0.0017025952693074942,
-0.018044093623757362,
-0.000597974460106343,
-0.01265009120106697,
0.013665362261235714,
-0.028623830527067184,
0.014934651553630829,
-0.033032841980457306,
0.027553535997867584,
-0.0366838201880455,
0.013505171984434128,
0.005060579627752304,
0.04206144064664841,
0.014986125752329826,
-0.009199603460729122,
0.056500449776649475,
0.014150089584290981,
0.011779777705669403,
0.03892024978995323,
0.03196556493639946,
0.019057560712099075,
0.003971021622419357,
-0.032941438257694244,
0.008999088779091835,
0.0313715934753418,
-0.009069263003766537,
0.040349893271923065,
0.009714266285300255,
0.004832115955650806,
0.030994027853012085,
-0.014122470282018185,
0.0197349414229393,
0.04156002774834633,
0.029755545780062675,
0.043728865683078766,
-0.05862949416041374,
-0.059751540422439575,
-0.0036249044351279736,
-0.017912914976477623,
0.014272818341851234,
-0.008430970832705498,
-0.04435697942972183,
0.010028574615716934,
0.03382707014679909,
0.00196088501252234,
-0.01565706543624401,
-0.021377813071012497,
-0.011173274368047714,
0.014404521323740482,
-0.034276802092790604,
0.03754875063896179,
-0.010755633004009724,
0.0018363227136433125,
-0.05067581310868263,
-0.03211900591850281,
-0.009976490400731564,
-0.015750331804156303,
-0.0027529026847332716,
0.007622131146490574,
0.003345709992572665,
-0.007471764925867319,
-0.03301108628511429,
0.023880768567323685,
-0.027193468064069748,
0.015378858894109726,
0.02729274146258831,
0.019455011934041977,
-0.014204171486198902,
0.03467607498168945,
-0.016758212819695473,
0.02765117958188057,
-0.021290116012096405,
0.029248230159282684,
0.04731006175279617,
0.06542857736349106,
-0.03200799226760864,
0.04122522845864296,
-0.037717629224061966,
0.015074120834469795,
0.002138604177162051,
0.011866112239658833,
-0.0318530835211277,
-0.04555412754416466,
-0.0006569115212187171,
0.028483234345912933,
-0.0023821850772947073,
-0.0030615751165896654,
-0.03166879341006279,
-0.03771687299013138,
0.06765443831682205,
-0.006120217032730579,
-0.04315438121557236,
0.05350818857550621,
-0.0340777151286602,
-0.008106901310384274,
0.012445569038391113,
-0.019062913954257965,
-0.025033870711922646,
0.023297453299164772,
-0.006643152795732021,
0.01967223919928074,
-0.012606599368155003,
0.023872075602412224,
-0.05802864953875542,
-0.008233414962887764,
0.03260062634944916,
0.014122730121016502,
0.03663599491119385,
-0.053664762526750565,
0.00901276059448719,
-0.043506186455488205,
0.007786517031490803,
-0.013572372496128082,
-0.04546082392334938,
-0.025495408102869987,
-0.02350020222365856,
0.002084719017148018,
-0.0020210552029311657,
0.02275386080145836,
0.04320049658417702,
0.04406147450208664,
0.03244168683886528,
0.030891412869095802,
0.014517475850880146,
-0.011890149675309658,
-0.0178560521453619,
-0.0527336411178112,
-0.03272118419408798,
0.04407789185643196,
0.06342422217130661,
0.07154779136180878,
-0.018117062747478485,
0.011304960586130619,
-0.021062079817056656,
-0.0004260203568264842,
-0.015010429546236992,
-0.010674585588276386,
-0.026445217430591583,
0.05497434735298157,
-0.03633894398808479,
-0.003332665888592601,
0.023172520101070404,
-0.004838259425014257,
-0.011231030337512493,
-0.0388171449303627,
-0.04322230815887451,
0.09587784856557846,
-0.023240448907017708,
-0.005890375003218651,
0.019727934151887894,
0.002328980015590787,
0.01914445497095585,
-0.013097385875880718,
-0.002978212432935834,
-0.027141259983181953,
-0.004976293537765741,
0.00002485419827280566,
-0.002529917052015662,
0.05660143494606018,
0.01920674368739128,
-0.004200697410851717,
0.006313649471849203,
-0.005027666687965393,
-0.03824770450592041,
0.012358831241726875,
0.023384498432278633,
-0.02790232188999653,
-0.04155780375003815,
-0.014300900511443615,
-0.05290813371539116,
0.007566714193671942,
0.026978326961398125,
0.04001883044838905,
0.011040489189326763,
-0.030634166672825813,
-0.01225595735013485,
-0.01644650101661682,
0.03162126615643501,
-0.036645498126745224,
0.03493482992053032,
0.013236619532108307,
0.04292198270559311,
-0.0206399317830801,
-0.006195008754730225,
-0.01060712430626154,
0.00001867132777988445,
-0.04410175979137421,
-0.03157446160912514,
-0.019897479563951492,
0.020662127062678337,
0.03278794139623642,
0.02540718950331211,
0.0030715949833393097,
0.05820385366678238,
-0.007633132394403219,
0.03513439744710922,
-0.01063099130988121,
0.02676868997514248,
0.03481453284621239,
-0.019090672954916954,
-0.007741149980574846,
0.022167706862092018,
-0.06657174974679947,
0.024149090051651,
0.04508733004331589,
0.009246589615941048,
0.043607909232378006,
0.026871642097830772,
-0.04555673897266388,
-0.028248293325304985,
-0.01229475811123848,
-0.037236232310533524,
0.039448171854019165,
-0.04795027896761894,
-0.005649575963616371,
-0.021670034155249596,
0.05645501986145973,
-0.0016136578051373363,
-0.001720983418636024,
0.017647894099354744,
-0.06886563450098038,
0.008393747732043266,
-0.002019638428464532,
0.0005745470407418907,
-0.020086301490664482,
-0.019923001527786255,
0.006394471973180771,
-0.033341340720653534,
-0.043267738074064255,
-0.03276611492037773,
-0.01881641149520874,
-0.022013863548636436,
0.026623865589499474,
0.02732411026954651,
-0.01077007595449686,
-0.007837305776774883,
-0.011265330016613007,
-0.01991303823888302,
0.054515086114406586,
0.026508785784244537,
0.008845912292599678,
0.01840885728597641,
-0.020825054496526718,
0.0399073027074337,
-0.01519433781504631,
0.019564466550946236,
-0.009784041903913021,
-0.02195550501346588,
0.003038478549569845,
0.007524109911173582,
0.00010578965157037601,
-0.008067423477768898,
0.05492069572210312,
-0.005354647058993578,
-0.017881013453006744,
-0.029777612537145615,
0.020977862179279327,
-0.002961665391921997,
-0.037401117384433746,
0.029379673302173615,
0.00384830916300416,
0.004575960338115692,
-0.02151639759540558,
-0.020651083439588547,
0.03704081475734711,
-0.04812997579574585,
-0.08513076603412628,
-0.0009464395116083324,
-0.021977553144097328,
0.03279507905244827,
0.025707345455884933,
-0.010532171465456486,
-0.010005506686866283,
0.0021720845252275467,
0.07020291686058044,
0.004537598229944706,
0.00788755901157856,
-0.041586119681596756,
0.020869344472885132,
-0.0780538022518158,
0.008907832205295563,
-0.003988516516983509,
-0.036182649433612823,
-0.02108381874859333,
-0.016768019646406174,
-0.02040882036089897,
-0.01839369162917137,
0.0003696070925798267,
0.010019754059612751,
0.0234675332903862,
0.01318768598139286,
-0.03456238657236099,
-0.018591536208987236,
0.05072282627224922,
-0.03134914115071297,
0.03203458711504936,
-0.06081034988164902,
0.07810838520526886,
-0.018470970913767815,
-0.022543348371982574,
-0.027357593178749084,
-0.00826147198677063,
-0.0006433493108488619,
0.016154533252120018,
0.00629587285220623,
-0.01736411266028881,
0.00009267595305573195,
0.0010160296224057674,
-0.022124458104372025,
0.006262065377086401,
0.019557569175958633,
0.00571370730176568,
0.017874371260404587,
0.017741013318300247,
-0.009599034674465656,
-0.04731769114732742,
0.04282654821872711,
-0.014987503178417683,
0.013547693379223347,
0.030193733051419258,
0.0342317633330822,
0.002014610916376114,
-0.026728084310889244,
0.011363966390490532,
-0.004530113656073809,
0.04520194232463837,
-0.012683002278208733,
0.020929882302880287,
-0.04918336123228073,
-0.016917681321501732,
-0.014157935976982117,
0.027231106534600258,
0.025609491392970085,
0.0007796824793331325,
-0.001726760994642973,
-0.010091658681631088,
-0.0301196426153183,
-0.045877616852521896,
0.012780149467289448,
-0.03528456389904022,
-0.035176441073417664,
-0.01743154600262642,
0.020947441458702087,
-0.0029794119764119387,
0.04669267311692238,
-0.013604856096208096,
0.06753058731555939,
-0.044634077697992325,
-0.015465840697288513,
-0.11992724984884262,
0.026841282844543457,
0.001653206185437739,
0.011068630963563919,
-0.02665475569665432,
-0.010029613971710205,
-0.0033511959481984377,
0.030428927391767502,
-0.009858150035142899,
-0.07170699536800385,
0.03844528645277023,
-0.00019860615429934114,
0.04145258292555809,
-0.003872527275234461,
-0.03958957642316818,
0.007535544689744711,
-0.045127324759960175,
-0.047983769327402115,
-0.001999251078814268,
0.018003055825829506,
-0.0030087248887866735,
-0.0014075879007577896,
0.005331083200871944,
-0.03717811405658722,
-0.040953412652015686,
-0.010902699083089828,
-0.06820858269929886,
-0.017643092200160027,
-0.015948159620165825,
-0.0030563173349946737,
0.008532890118658543,
-0.0321902260184288,
-0.015277091413736343,
0.018461331725120544,
0.006322122178971767,
0.014758601784706116,
-0.015114570036530495,
0.022985147312283516,
-0.0015194222796708345,
-0.008382242172956467,
0.008705017156898975,
0.009780424647033215,
0.0086161307990551,
0.005040301010012627,
-0.005662404466420412,
0.06309107691049576,
0.005055334884673357,
-0.009940986521542072,
-0.002622042316943407,
-0.00446741096675396,
-0.054310526698827744,
0.03934762254357338,
0.009475836530327797,
0.0009942434262484312,
-0.014974753372371197,
0.05467381700873375,
0.005246169399470091,
-0.0590098574757576,
-0.03515835106372833,
0.017076876014471054,
-0.008339867927134037,
-0.01715201884508133,
-0.02173524536192417,
-0.06032311171293259,
0.03429413586854935,
0.019302891567349434,
-0.03815436735749245,
0.011718304827809334,
0.019373420625925064,
0.014672857709228992,
-0.012604598887264729,
0.017566440626978874,
-0.01072875689715147,
-0.024188533425331116,
0.006037731189280748,
0.04572274908423424,
0.051284946501255035,
0.017889603972434998,
-0.02058797888457775,
-0.0034825033508241177,
0.003910440020263195,
0.00042364763794466853,
-0.001331015140749514,
0.02726772427558899,
0.04343113675713539,
0.04493054375052452,
0.008224290795624256,
-0.010180916637182236,
0.028772922232747078,
-0.05196041241288185,
-0.03538241237401962,
0.02472872845828533,
-0.028985699638724327,
0.04060962423682213,
-0.01305338740348816,
0.03586982190608978,
0.02822270058095455,
-0.0037700009997934103,
-0.03386002406477928,
-0.03965006396174431,
0.030143776908516884,
-0.03768059238791466,
0.041273269802331924,
-0.013400174677371979,
-0.03642217814922333,
0.006203351076692343,
-0.00820874609053135,
0.02006581425666809,
0.028223035857081413,
0.0012014867970719934,
-0.012174665927886963,
-0.06664591282606125,
-0.04189116507768631,
-0.029324373230338097,
0.0058891260996460915,
0.011846872977912426,
-0.010458597913384438,
0.027885736897587776,
-0.00469327624887228,
0.025188757106661797,
0.02760918438434601,
-0.03468276187777519,
0.04125208780169487,
-0.025983482599258423,
0.001455042278394103,
0.03708280622959137,
0.05168351158499718,
-0.0018850879278033972,
0.006976838689297438,
-0.029175076633691788,
0.027834204956889153,
-0.06457656621932983,
-0.035307638347148895,
0.010899484157562256,
-0.005894937086850405,
0.057765666395425797,
-0.015871362760663033,
0.012813681736588478,
-0.055806394666433334,
-0.0035406339447945356,
0.03603250905871391,
-0.02255246788263321,
0.0032626360189169645,
-0.02199484407901764,
-0.03346698358654976,
-0.03741668164730072,
-0.005405455362051725,
0.002646435284987092,
-0.016775699332356453,
-0.044907111674547195,
-0.013530366122722626,
0.02803499437868595,
0.0047426652163267136,
0.08055181801319122,
0.05254453420639038,
-0.03397646173834801,
0.017733542248606682,
0.04140324890613556,
0.002654595300555229,
0.03797507286071777,
0.01858370006084442,
-0.011789708398282528,
-0.027203740552067757,
-0.023546593263745308,
-0.0013211655896157026,
0.040723931044340134,
0.004021196626126766,
0.01697271130979061,
0.0035639668349176645,
-0.014850020408630371,
0.007693095598369837,
-0.033810243010520935,
-0.023305619135499,
0.0008313762955367565,
-0.013865204527974129,
-0.02099038101732731,
-0.0006029467913322151,
0.023377811536192894,
-0.007891207002103329,
-0.026971232146024704,
0.023877540603280067,
-0.00046317020314745605,
0.006294303108006716,
-0.0032577109523117542,
0.01203105691820383,
-0.003140202723443508,
0.054798297584056854,
0.02118844725191593,
0.00869853887706995,
-0.06060587242245674,
-0.0030120620504021645,
0.009686215780675411,
0.03529030457139015,
-0.0065504517406225204,
0.049491651356220245,
0.007080167531967163,
-0.012221899814903736,
-0.01066619623452425,
0.010264642536640167,
0.018112704157829285,
0.011273692362010479,
-0.025830471888184547,
-0.03481059893965721,
-0.018460044637322426,
-0.050255246460437775,
-0.0011330177076160908,
-0.0349600687623024,
0.012816756032407284,
-0.032520461827516556,
0.046166177839040756,
0.001329436432570219,
-0.016797153279185295,
0.014960316009819508,
0.017278190702199936,
-0.032573264092206955,
-0.006312343757599592,
-0.016004469245672226,
0.020585566759109497,
0.004947450943291187,
-0.003209863556548953,
0.05013405159115791,
0.06691072136163712,
-0.014841004274785519,
-0.06519893556833267,
0.008240138180553913,
0.021073060110211372,
-0.015653854236006737,
-0.024548569694161415,
0.0354916974902153,
-0.0033848604653030634,
0.0006676057819277048,
-0.033913034945726395,
-0.0009947667131200433,
0.08152119815349579,
0.039131127297878265,
-0.015223037451505661,
-0.012274947948753834,
0.00006968015804886818,
-0.0224932748824358,
-0.032961420714855194,
0.02927120216190815,
0.013253540731966496,
-0.02305966429412365,
-0.022450311109423637
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:27
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
The claim did not fall within sub paragraph (a)(iv) as there was no suggestion of a defect in any vehicle. Instead, it was contended that it fell within sub paragraph (a)(ii) of the definition.
Having regard to the use of the word "sustained" at [94] in the judgment of Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ in Allianz v GSF (see above at [123]) the Court of Appeal felt constrained to treat the definition of "injury" as only enabling the recovery in a sub paragraph (a)(ii) case where the injury had been "sustained during a collision with the vehicle" (at [32],
per Spigelman CJ, at [47] per Allsop P, at [60] per Hodgson JA, at [66] per McColl JA, and at [109] to [111] per Campbell JA).
The Court then addressed whether or not the injury in that case could be held to have been sustained "during" the collision and rejected that contention.
128Both Allianz v GSF and Zurich v CSR involved cases where the injured employee was not injured either as a result of or during one of the activities specified in (a)(i) to (iii) of the definition of injury. In Zurich v CSR at [31], Spigelman CJ had expressly contemplated that sub paragraph (a)(i) "encompassed every injury 'caused' during .
.. driving ... by a defect in the vehicle" and stated that the same was true of sub paragraph (a)(ii) and (iii). His Honour envisaged sub paragraph (a)(iv) as expanding the scope for recovery to those whose injuries are caused by a defect in cases that do not involve any of the activities in sub paragraph (a)(i), (ii) and (iii).
McHugh J in Allianz v GSF at [57] also contemplated a circumstance where injury could be sustained "as a consequence of a defect in the vehicle" during an activity specified in sub paragraph (a)(i), (a)(ii) or (a)(iii) of the definition of "injury".
The judgment of Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ in Allianz v GSF accepted the correctness of Zurich v CSR. Their Honours appear to have to proceed upon the correctness of what Spigelman CJ contemplated in Zurich v CSR concerning sub paragraphs (a)(i) to (a)(iii). At the very least they did not disavow it.
129In Allianz v GSF Callinan J disagreed with the construction stated by Spigelman CJ in Zurich v CSR. His Honour confined the operation of sub paragraph (a)(iv), but nevertheless confirmed its application to the circumstance of a physical injury caused by a defect in the vehicle which is the fault of the owner and which is sustained during one of the activities specified in (a)(i), (ii) or (iii).
130Thus, one matter that is common to all the judgments in Allianz v GSF is an acceptance that the very scenario put forward by Mr Horwood falls within the definition of injury. It either falls within sub paras (a)(i) to (iii) in the view of McHugh J, or sub paragraph (a)(iv) according to Callihan J.
The judgment of Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ appear to accept the former. Accordingly I do not accept the submission of Mr Campbell SC that either Allianz v GSF or Zotti has the consequence that Mr Horwood's case could not fall within any of sub paragraphs (a)(i) to (a)(iv) of the definition of injury.
131It follows from this and my findings as to ownership that I consider that the "liability" of Megbuy that was compromised, or established before me (at [115]), is a liability that answers the description of "injury" in s 3 of the MAC Act.
CONCLUSION ON DOUBLE INSURANCE CLAIM
132In summary I have found that:
(i)As at 7 November 2005 Megbuy was the owner of the forklift with the meaning of s 4 of the MAC Act ([60]). If, contrary to the conclusion I reached in [39], I was only required to determine whether QBE acted reasonably in causing Megbuy to admit ownership then, I have found that it so acted (at [60]);
(ii)Subject to considering the definition of "injury", the settlement of Mr Horwood's claim against Megbuy represented a reasonable compromise of the liability alleged against Megbuy (at [110]). If, contrary, to my conclusion in [37], I was required to determine de novo whether Megbuy was liable to Mr Horwood then I am so satisfied ([115]); and
|
[
0.0029589622281491756,
0.017141612246632576,
-0.01715262420475483,
-0.01624368503689766,
0.015456749126315117,
0.011828497983515263,
0.011774050071835518,
0.009373672306537628,
0.021625349298119545,
-0.007197427097707987,
0.01391154807060957,
0.008153127506375313,
-0.01745380461215973,
0.0014180949656292796,
-0.014319670386612415,
-0.01699024625122547,
0.03754813224077225,
-0.021986598148941994,
-0.049406081438064575,
-0.07626743614673615,
0.0461951345205307,
0.002487472491338849,
0.05065210536122322,
0.058197394013404846,
-0.001928532961755991,
0.027215341106057167,
-0.022719983011484146,
0.03175884857773781,
0.02829277142882347,
0.010880745947360992,
0.00267468998208642,
0.020945683121681213,
-0.0027856798842549324,
-0.028078759089112282,
0.00894494354724884,
-0.034889597445726395,
-0.03517443314194679,
0.006869119126349688,
-0.009562425315380096,
0.013675509952008724,
-0.03904107213020325,
-0.020096419379115105,
0.014808961190283298,
-0.05496702715754509,
0.02613765187561512,
-0.04598120227456093,
-0.011658469215035439,
-0.026420684531331062,
-0.004231487866491079,
-0.008191078901290894,
-0.07293515652418137,
-0.020743297412991524,
0.10180450230836868,
0.0030447617173194885,
0.012398368678987026,
0.015170767903327942,
-0.01683598756790161,
-0.04018082097172737,
-0.05837855115532875,
-0.010182738304138184,
-0.03835142031311989,
-0.0009073377586901188,
-0.003257154021412134,
0.029496008530259132,
0.0007702296716161072,
0.07975484430789948,
-0.025298284366726875,
-0.03835958242416382,
-0.020438779145479202,
-0.048752449452877045,
0.0024273789022117853,
0.00222552171908319,
-0.03943511098623276,
0.007369696628302336,
-0.06632339954376221,
-0.001949007622897625,
0.01321811880916357,
0.018112024292349815,
0.0011568247573450208,
0.044661737978458405,
0.030592789873480797,
0.005251821596175432,
-0.030275600031018257,
0.014640655368566513,
-0.029342293739318848,
0.005428193137049675,
-0.019747499376535416,
0.009704879485070705,
-0.0037260449025779963,
0.009111486375331879,
0.03663194552063942,
-0.011862264014780521,
0.017174245789647102,
-0.027635470032691956,
0.0394083634018898,
-0.01343926228582859,
-0.0605524405837059,
0.03608943521976471,
0.003497905796393752,
0.034042876213788986,
0.012562813237309456,
0.007847622968256474,
0.020008260384202003,
-0.06312143057584763,
0.008697421289980412,
0.022632719948887825,
0.0413578562438488,
0.039480216801166534,
-0.021350305527448654,
0.0057348525151610374,
-0.0066899508237838745,
0.036181870847940445,
0.0062968432903289795,
0.03588031232357025,
-0.021583329886198044,
0.004935424774885178,
-0.006635657511651516,
-0.04717949032783508,
0.07016080617904663,
-0.038851454854011536,
0.04811790585517883,
0.02957361564040184,
0.03379227593541145,
-0.03632846102118492,
-0.05690858140587807,
0.011477011255919933,
-0.0036525996401906013,
0.005872420500963926,
-0.04051036760210991,
-0.014124789275228977,
0.007735422812402248,
0.01868659257888794,
-0.01603870280086994,
-0.04594888910651207,
-0.009963802993297577,
-0.02683212049305439,
0.05831687152385712,
0.0016625472344458103,
-0.037199608981609344,
-0.04259872809052467,
0.05967170372605324,
0.016907451674342155,
0.04851946607232094,
-0.02273084782063961,
0.02200291119515896,
-0.038807857781648636,
0.03100145421922207,
-0.02228245511651039,
0.033073704689741135,
-0.02837846800684929,
0.01025446504354477,
-0.006591693498194218,
0.009279643185436726,
-0.09191878885030746,
0.014538221061229706,
-0.040824610739946365,
0.0027413764037191868,
-0.0034952356945723295,
0.0022477558813989162,
0.004767280071973801,
0.007068543694913387,
0.06356369704008102,
-0.010774238966405392,
-0.030307712033391,
0.017449675127863884,
-0.0014526548329740763,
0.03782413527369499,
0.03487752005457878,
-0.029283955693244934,
-0.029480960220098495,
0.02070835791528225,
0.014771143905818462,
0.024739595130085945,
-0.029569566249847412,
0.03398064151406288,
0.036037787795066833,
0.05590953677892685,
0.013544036075472832,
-0.0036239048931747675,
-0.04732108861207962,
-0.01036420464515686,
-0.004148572217673063,
0.02990911342203617,
0.0037526125088334084,
-0.013256754726171494,
-0.003500972641631961,
0.001639258349314332,
-0.03730525076389313,
0.01189480908215046,
-0.01057813037186861,
-0.02680560015141964,
-0.04001209884881973,
-0.011999468319118023,
0.016871357336640358,
0.015202060341835022,
-0.006601253058761358,
0.06062448397278786,
-0.006149336230009794,
0.0340140275657177,
-0.043373577296733856,
-0.023264771327376366,
0.008591726422309875,
0.07531961798667908,
-0.032632604241371155,
-0.03908301517367363,
-0.014790957793593407,
-0.0403842069208622,
0.01359802670776844,
0.005651354789733887,
-0.04648947715759277,
0.026168348267674446,
-0.03208363428711891,
0.033282242715358734,
0.001788815250620246,
-0.020991705358028412,
-0.04781121388077736,
0.004711065907031298,
0.017034921795129776,
0.01951250247657299,
0.005090721417218447,
-0.023953570052981377,
-0.004414801020175219,
-0.02862623520195484,
0.026455916464328766,
0.015093216672539711,
0.001455734483897686,
-0.030940579250454903,
0.03614001348614693,
0.0032875591423362494,
-0.004642829764634371,
0.05648953840136528,
0.018799807876348495,
0.017899665981531143,
-0.0408688560128212,
0.04540936276316643,
-0.0018859951524063945,
0.04573261737823486,
0.02670998126268387,
0.03464893624186516,
0.008883053436875343,
-0.020376577973365784,
-0.050551947206258774,
0.06591452658176422,
-0.04011795297265053,
-0.011340350843966007,
-0.03288900479674339,
-0.006209457293152809,
0.004842082504183054,
0.01405347976833582,
0.0429711788892746,
0.07180289179086685,
-0.00046319045941345394,
0.024157730862498283,
-0.014546492137014866,
-0.016031887382268906,
0.02997787855565548,
0.006325944792479277,
-0.014720411971211433,
0.019857129082083702,
-0.014775006100535393,
0.009771239012479782,
0.03630629926919937,
0.03064836375415325,
-0.007237232755869627,
-0.006196627393364906,
-0.07547606527805328,
-0.03544369339942932,
-0.028236454352736473,
-0.06322475522756577,
-0.021652357652783394,
0.0035089650191366673,
0.002333425683900714,
-0.016286781057715416,
-0.010702414438128471,
0.028224898502230644,
0.008869007229804993,
0.0344587042927742,
-0.02313094213604927,
0.03248251602053642,
0.016040869057178497,
0.056407034397125244,
-0.0053529804572463036,
0.025657767429947853,
-0.05787353217601776,
0.03388518840074539,
0.01995847001671791,
0.0021409837063401937,
-0.038259949535131454,
-0.0029917412903159857,
-0.04657571390271187,
0.04326976463198662,
-0.010738308541476727,
0.03971787169575691,
-0.025053581222891808,
-0.05693948641419411,
0.012616612948477268,
-0.003044771496206522,
-0.15091288089752197,
-0.011336551047861576,
0.052265532314777374,
0.02802519127726555,
-0.008077599108219147,
0.0019355220720171928,
-0.017424635589122772,
-0.0003356648376211524,
-0.027418935671448708,
0.02546422742307186,
0.010177992284297943,
-0.052085015922784805,
-0.015067663975059986,
0.029367586597800255,
0.00812605768442154,
0.00536777637898922,
-0.017173778265714645,
-0.000999117735773325,
0.028227563947439194,
-0.015257827937602997,
0.015471280552446842,
-0.022244181483983994,
-0.008422943763434887,
-0.02367890439927578,
0.02480468526482582,
0.0013288739137351513,
0.022514456883072853,
-0.013431285507977009,
-0.05354270339012146,
-0.025770684704184532,
-0.07006609439849854,
0.009943587705492973,
-0.016692839562892914,
0.03505459427833557,
0.02147871069610119,
0.024744123220443726,
0.050719019025564194,
-0.09324377030134201,
-0.011994490399956703,
-0.001518799806945026,
0.045992739498615265,
0.06386592984199524,
-0.0036660146433860064,
-0.0034806213807314634,
-0.014048784039914608,
-0.0860835537314415,
0.016807928681373596,
-0.0008413162431679666,
-0.0034738120157271624,
0.011364003643393517,
-0.036113109439611435,
-0.013914207927882671,
0.010090311989188194,
0.00429213372990489,
-0.006572811398655176,
-0.004772235173732042,
0.08031929284334183,
0.058616820722818375,
0.01824406161904335,
-0.010202961973845959,
-0.00021229288540780544,
-0.021886605769395828,
0.010674877092242241,
0.02124227210879326,
-0.029013311490416527,
0.01046791858971119,
0.01659764163196087,
-0.008055203594267368,
0.05203345790505409,
-0.017095470800995827,
-0.027271445840597153,
-0.03147997707128525,
0.02502467855811119,
-0.03681812807917595,
-0.02566133812069893,
-0.002405904931947589,
0.021008137613534927,
-0.03233707323670387,
0.018566083163022995,
-0.07421138137578964,
0.019512992352247238,
-0.010653619654476643,
0.012103065848350525,
0.013865439221262932,
-0.021521657705307007,
0.05814196541905403,
0.021333131939172745,
0.008234110660851002,
0.01787613146007061,
0.2227664589881897,
0.021085185930132866,
-0.005138748791068792,
-0.014423391781747341,
0.00042800584924407303,
0.014160370454192162,
0.03580240532755852,
0.019759833812713623,
0.005721621681004763,
-0.037648919969797134,
-0.07799533754587173,
-0.015128465369343758,
-0.009274618700146675,
0.03165244311094284,
-0.007179235108196735,
-0.03157884627580643,
-0.03662814199924469,
-0.02761600911617279,
0.06951218843460083,
0.0047186375595629215,
0.03726750612258911,
0.007262863218784332,
0.02953612618148327,
0.004186464473605156,
-0.0849304348230362,
-0.05524887889623642,
0.005048042628914118,
-0.022712133824825287,
-0.012965441681444645,
-0.016162244603037834,
-0.0355648547410965,
-0.015823256224393845,
0.0056829252280294895,
-0.0008413324248977005,
-0.01844516210258007,
0.0006671611336059868,
-0.03968817740678787,
0.0031949870754033327,
-0.04983069747686386,
0.04203011468052864,
0.027879325672984123,
-0.0030978017020970583,
-0.031171098351478577,
-0.0037819703575223684,
0.026642872020602226,
0.012507499195635319,
0.01971741020679474,
-0.00817867647856474,
0.00686461478471756,
0.01065776590257883,
-0.03238058090209961,
0.011321025900542736,
-0.04054626077413559,
0.014329271391034126,
-0.0252933781594038,
0.024766873568296432,
-0.017758727073669434,
0.017337022349238396,
0.020188890397548676,
-0.008562728762626648,
0.013405289500951767,
0.024117005988955498,
-0.018126528710126877,
0.028455400839447975,
0.01875917986035347,
0.034706924110651016,
-0.027568433433771133,
0.012510781176388264,
0.026669137179851532,
0.009142111986875534,
0.004483194090425968,
0.0204980056732893,
0.01350569911301136,
0.011760871857404709,
0.04461326450109482,
0.030893314629793167,
0.007162652909755707,
0.02598263882100582,
-0.009397123008966446,
0.015010147355496883,
-0.049802880734205246,
-0.0428825281560421,
-0.02386743202805519,
-0.014954225160181522,
0.02891881763935089,
-0.022088520228862762,
-0.04306001588702202,
0.02896158955991268,
0.04509047046303749,
-0.028686314821243286,
-0.013016494922339916,
-0.02031235210597515,
0.014485668390989304,
0.028948871418833733,
-0.03855813294649124,
0.026217980310320854,
0.01676163077354431,
0.0016660711262375116,
-0.027921006083488464,
-0.030725449323654175,
-0.015527468174695969,
-0.011636709794402122,
-0.03795970603823662,
-0.005263490602374077,
-0.037307459861040115,
-0.017030131071805954,
0.0025348959024995565,
-0.0010778388241305947,
-0.04405056685209274,
0.00364084099419415,
0.018995247781276703,
-0.006129602435976267,
-0.031521912664175034,
0.019552573561668396,
-0.0017704516649246216,
0.029158858582377434,
-0.03934578597545624,
0.026962418109178543,
0.05635635554790497,
0.04846227914094925,
0.000767377729061991,
0.015370987355709076,
-0.05060262978076935,
0.003496937220916152,
-0.00336832064203918,
0.014399549923837185,
-0.031071646139025688,
-0.016210967674851418,
0.00545613095164299,
0.03297599032521248,
0.0056876009330153465,
-0.012906631454825401,
-0.035619333386421204,
0.00564280292019248,
0.056953396648168564,
-0.01779661886394024,
-0.03028978407382965,
0.04042118415236473,
-0.016015060245990753,
-0.019396288320422173,
-0.004516808316111565,
-0.02499917522072792,
-0.036537978798151016,
0.015396482311189175,
-0.013984172604978085,
0.0016989496070891619,
-0.021978840231895447,
0.0393412746489048,
-0.05346923694014549,
-0.03891284391283989,
0.005910056643188,
0.014360850676894188,
-0.014124290086328983,
-0.06036948412656784,
-0.012546446174383163,
-0.008727969601750374,
0.015849914401769638,
0.009895265102386475,
0.002192556159570813,
-0.05392460897564888,
-0.013722152449190617,
-0.033294130116701126,
-0.0078059774823486805,
0.044643860310316086,
0.009981943294405937,
0.026498127728700638,
-0.0009347857558168471,
0.04478229954838753,
0.02572018653154373,
0.003936260472983122,
-0.0032553996425122023,
-0.05458802357316017,
-0.023838074877858162,
0.03693241998553276,
0.04199792072176933,
0.0556078739464283,
0.0028515623416751623,
0.020603027194738388,
0.007267494220286608,
0.001193302683532238,
-0.006207667291164398,
0.019015897065401077,
-0.008234933018684387,
-0.009332191199064255,
-0.023787444457411766,
0.03202688694000244,
0.05712093785405159,
-0.021219315007328987,
0.019672363996505737,
-0.018519356846809387,
-0.024350633844733238,
0.08057434856891632,
-0.01673613116145134,
-0.001599325449205935,
0.03501113876700401,
0.009491939097642899,
-0.0033978905994445086,
-0.007364911958575249,
-0.022674569860100746,
-0.05563091114163399,
-0.018749024718999863,
0.0045196679420769215,
0.0072885300032794476,
0.02084926888346672,
0.057063113898038864,
-0.024644842371344566,
0.0016770272050052881,
0.0076254489831626415,
-0.03975424915552139,
0.012995042838156223,
0.0024529912043362856,
-0.0005725793307647109,
-0.031998563557863235,
0.009403766132891178,
-0.03181742876768112,
0.0161017756909132,
0.008711169473826885,
0.04310304671525955,
-0.009028099477291107,
-0.04316160827875137,
-0.013069447129964828,
-0.012242289260029793,
0.0569906160235405,
-0.05977806821465492,
0.056118957698345184,
0.03734298795461655,
0.022855062037706375,
-0.012711838819086552,
0.0030933977104723454,
0.008539076894521713,
0.007049535866826773,
-0.03517557308077812,
-0.013329786248505116,
-0.044326961040496826,
0.015533794648945332,
-0.00411798432469368,
0.021372942253947258,
0.01993689499795437,
0.05269289016723633,
-0.016250168904662132,
0.03634926304221153,
-0.033130209892988205,
0.005762047600001097,
0.04873279109597206,
-0.023754995316267014,
0.014512438327074051,
0.011696471832692623,
-0.049721430987119675,
0.04012666642665863,
0.021355709061026573,
0.017279503867030144,
0.04775676876306534,
0.040026936680078506,
-0.04652820900082588,
-0.02152440696954727,
-0.014568504877388477,
0.002146255923435092,
0.01536464225500822,
-0.05108005553483963,
-0.039599522948265076,
-0.013746311888098717,
0.07791613042354584,
-0.017436474561691284,
-0.023568646982312202,
0.044242020696401596,
-0.0654369592666626,
0.010339836589992046,
-0.01685432158410549,
-0.004117138683795929,
-0.01987290196120739,
-0.03982636332511902,
0.01521756500005722,
-0.027205629274249077,
-0.040147483348846436,
-0.03529621660709381,
0.005578147247433662,
-0.05812154337763786,
0.02736600488424301,
0.02157067507505417,
-0.04587133973836899,
0.006502375937998295,
-0.02351633831858635,
-0.01718679443001747,
0.04178295284509659,
-0.009777301922440529,
0.020768219605088234,
0.020558785647153854,
-0.00733426446095109,
0.016241377219557762,
-0.03267230466008186,
0.02531319484114647,
0.009927568957209587,
-0.0038006105460226536,
0.02867039106786251,
-0.017218388617038727,
0.022158969193696976,
0.01287880726158619,
0.05740475282073021,
-0.021824736148118973,
0.006359407212585211,
-0.010452785529196262,
0.032024431973695755,
-0.03418545424938202,
-0.06739480793476105,
-0.002069854876026511,
-0.0017444014083594084,
0.014733112417161465,
-0.02335050329566002,
-0.024069862440228462,
0.028429942205548286,
-0.016803214326500893,
-0.06704367697238922,
-0.001119933440349996,
-0.02503773756325245,
-0.020507896319031715,
0.015581497922539711,
-0.007991974242031574,
-0.007300743367522955,
0.004441393539309502,
0.05417758598923683,
0.007137833628803492,
-0.016903644427657127,
-0.07729392498731613,
-0.0020117969252169132,
-0.07468154281377792,
-0.022611843422055244,
-0.00466173468157649,
-0.024513592943549156,
-0.03643445298075676,
-0.01863233931362629,
-0.008136339485645294,
-0.005947960074990988,
-0.03190135210752487,
0.004894097335636616,
0.07074665278196335,
0.03267158940434456,
-0.030985159799456596,
-0.02990148961544037,
0.027900688350200653,
-0.0010818860027939081,
0.012386863119900227,
-0.05160447582602501,
0.09575338661670685,
-0.017779391258955002,
-0.02054862305521965,
0.0050800335593521595,
0.020538002252578735,
0.023727748543024063,
-0.019456174224615097,
0.017358291894197464,
0.025587379932403564,
-0.008911988697946072,
-0.031098710373044014,
-0.017262868583202362,
-0.004997794516384602,
0.011650468222796917,
-0.03813200071454048,
0.0017340899212285876,
0.02244712971150875,
-0.015651436522603035,
-0.046894099563360214,
0.030141836032271385,
-0.023993752896785736,
0.0019748995546251535,
0.03517327457666397,
0.02207627333700657,
-0.01820288598537445,
0.0027282326482236385,
0.028556451201438904,
0.014506853185594082,
0.01759728230535984,
-0.022942278534173965,
0.0372626818716526,
-0.02523799240589142,
-0.002031478565186262,
-0.023971635848283768,
0.04566684737801552,
-0.0031795939430594444,
-0.04555666074156761,
0.0052449628710746765,
-0.024878505617380142,
-0.05395806208252907,
-0.042591992765665054,
0.005223554093390703,
0.014697765931487083,
-0.0008285770891234279,
-0.012183659709990025,
-0.017632683739066124,
-0.023438209667801857,
0.048565417528152466,
-0.005523766856640577,
0.06406554579734802,
-0.010134078562259674,
0.017733348533511162,
-0.1283760368824005,
0.0235329270362854,
-0.018788982182741165,
0.018708061426877975,
-0.06143864989280701,
0.010652187280356884,
-0.01102218683809042,
0.031440410763025284,
-0.021431144326925278,
-0.02515232376754284,
-0.02482294850051403,
-0.018500469624996185,
0.05894757807254791,
-0.005687715020030737,
-0.023092003539204597,
0.007596169598400593,
-0.044229354709386826,
-0.0630606934428215,
-0.0189492329955101,
0.012604139745235443,
0.006520784460008144,
0.014525596983730793,
0.030765727162361145,
-0.046118151396512985,
-0.008504031226038933,
-0.01780996471643448,
-0.0984039381146431,
-0.0023192698135972023,
-0.01622324436903,
-0.0009099490707740188,
-0.002332990989089012,
-0.024416940286755562,
0.015291386283934116,
0.005982840899378061,
0.01603720895946026,
0.048433344811201096,
-0.004937710240483284,
-0.01226124633103609,
-0.022074468433856964,
-0.014864906668663025,
-0.017806831747293472,
0.02836361713707447,
-0.01650949753820896,
-0.009202019311487675,
0.027613665908575058,
0.02530231513082981,
0.011896735057234764,
-0.023311151191592216,
0.002401721430942416,
-0.021991942077875137,
-0.03406958281993866,
0.010541919618844986,
-0.03369486331939697,
0.012540075927972794,
-0.014811739325523376,
0.02912185527384281,
-0.023390939459204674,
-0.05532797798514366,
-0.04008546471595764,
0.07028354704380035,
0.011212600395083427,
-0.0010858960449695587,
-0.026676882058382034,
-0.04658560827374458,
0.011077958159148693,
0.03095163218677044,
-0.006853932980448008,
0.013586410321295261,
0.023157941177487373,
0.013411984778940678,
0.026902956888079643,
-0.00044570592581294477,
0.022698620334267616,
-0.0012381066335365176,
-0.021045943722128868,
0.030187439173460007,
0.004516668617725372,
0.008064416237175465,
0.0016226547304540873,
-0.0017880420200526714,
0.023808494210243225,
-0.002424984471872449,
-0.004086974076926708,
0.0041901362128555775,
0.04998099431395531,
0.039043884724378586,
-0.02339627780020237,
-0.02608826383948326,
0.06968436390161514,
-0.030964065343141556,
-0.05478735268115997,
0.02517680637538433,
-0.010921942070126534,
0.041371095925569534,
-0.025730228051543236,
0.02676467038691044,
0.015620985999703407,
-0.021134601905941963,
-0.02879035286605358,
-0.016898060217499733,
0.022006960585713387,
-0.03356683999300003,
0.05517394840717316,
-0.014509953558444977,
-0.016034593805670738,
-0.00030329194851219654,
-0.020241575315594673,
0.008686094544827938,
0.029113881289958954,
-0.014672622084617615,
-0.016689719632267952,
-0.060375139117240906,
-0.04072392359375954,
-0.028428519144654274,
-0.022328803315758705,
0.006629695184528828,
-0.022509517148137093,
0.02957194484770298,
-0.0097665311768651,
0.011364665813744068,
0.042598217725753784,
-0.029243404045701027,
0.07850996404886246,
-0.023893160745501518,
-0.0071258158423006535,
0.035660602152347565,
0.04568582400679588,
0.022395478561520576,
0.025157274678349495,
-0.008434204384684563,
0.04727248474955559,
-0.011841821484267712,
-0.03129042685031891,
0.014307049103081226,
-0.015590590424835682,
0.024629201740026474,
-0.014914050698280334,
-0.013246189802885056,
-0.039336398243904114,
-0.04254256933927536,
0.021814703941345215,
-0.02108757570385933,
-0.012376096099615097,
-0.016616644337773323,
-0.03888701647520065,
-0.06455439329147339,
-0.010299399495124817,
0.01022570114582777,
-0.01619592495262623,
-0.053129132837057114,
-0.00991638470441103,
0.00947082880884409,
0.02183179371058941,
0.06766282021999359,
0.051238469779491425,
-0.042981214821338654,
0.027500856667757034,
0.016259735450148582,
-0.020955348387360573,
0.03501030430197716,
0.032494500279426575,
-0.020341256633400917,
-0.028239458799362183,
-0.008452439680695534,
-0.005652408115565777,
0.03560212254524231,
0.009013569913804531,
-0.0028991696890443563,
-0.007438429165631533,
-0.00007576558709843084,
0.003954710438847542,
0.004916613455861807,
-0.03208363056182861,
0.008910616859793663,
0.028859158977866173,
-0.053290676325559616,
-0.017965812236070633,
-0.005504042841494083,
0.0033220588229596615,
-0.007317767944186926,
0.043387483805418015,
0.05308667942881584,
0.0038707852363586426,
0.005873805843293667,
-0.011198441497981548,
0.012771432287991047,
0.037207335233688354,
-0.003218993777409196,
-0.01956997439265251,
-0.05752462521195412,
-0.015010710805654526,
-0.013324454426765442,
0.008535691536962986,
-0.02789129503071308,
0.04322226718068123,
0.010938100516796112,
-0.011186773888766766,
-0.005539224948734045,
0.017025254666805267,
0.05305920168757439,
0.017327141016721725,
-0.01863883063197136,
0.0052957660518586636,
-0.0068466560915112495,
-0.012647729367017746,
0.012380431406199932,
0.00042728130938485265,
0.009748715907335281,
-0.008354758843779564,
0.05603065341711044,
-0.0005043549463152885,
-0.015755999833345413,
-0.016958024352788925,
0.06225600466132164,
-0.0213633980602026,
0.006351661402732134,
-0.009503084234893322,
-0.016787024214863777,
0.006571806035935879,
0.028970301151275635,
0.019065599888563156,
0.04808240383863449,
-0.026252374053001404,
-0.036734629422426224,
0.007906835526227951,
-0.004055357538163662,
-0.014337911270558834,
-0.024392616003751755,
0.01834326982498169,
-0.003660286543890834,
0.0005687961238436401,
-0.01290786825120449,
-0.007191890385001898,
0.06693074852228165,
0.03869074583053589,
-0.008551560342311859,
0.005954266060143709,
-0.013976315967738628,
-0.014275498688220978,
-0.03883177042007446,
0.057032570242881775,
0.025306889787316322,
0.0006560251931659877,
0.032316360622644424
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:22
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
108At any hearing the evidence on causation was likely to be the evidence of Mr Horwood, the photos of the accident, the sketch of the scene and the evidence suggesting that it had a persistent defect in the steering mechanism.
As noted, Mr Horwood had little recollection of the accident other than a recollection that he lost control. This recollection is at least consistent with the loose steering of the forklift being operative to cause the accident.
Mr Horwood had driven the forklift on a number of occasions including on a public street. Although the forklift appears to have moved close to the back of the car depicted in the photos of the accident, it was not so close that I would expect a reasonably experienced driver of the forklift to overreact by turning as sharply as depicted by the tyre marks and the final position of the forklift.
The more likely explanation for that having occurred is that at the point Mr Horwood sought to correct his course the defect in the steering exaggerated his correction. In my view it would have been reasonably open to the District Court to have found that factual causation was made out in relation to the failure of Megbuy to have the forklift repaired or removed from use on a public road (s.
5D(1)(a)). Further I consider that it is reasonably likely that it would have so found. If such a finding was made, a finding under s 5D(1)(b) of the Civil Liability Act would have followed.
109Mr Campell SC sought to characterise the agreement with Mr Horwood as a "complete capitulation near to the top of the range" rather than a settlement. He contended that QBE could not have reached any reasonable compromise on liability in the absence of expert evidence.
He contended that, in the absence of such evidence, "an inference of negligence is not available from something unexpected or untoward in the operation of the machine" and referred to the passage from the judgment of Barwick CJ in Piening v Wanless [1968] HCA 7; (1968) 117 CLR 498 at 507 - 508.
However this was not the factual scenario suggested by the evidence of Messrs Gillett and Oates. The defect in the steering mechanism that they described was not "unexpected" but was persistent although erratic. Expert evidence was not required to establish breach in this case.
110The test posed by Zurich v GIO requires me to determine whether QBE effected a reasonable compromise of Mr Horwood's allegation that it was liable to him for damages calculated in accordance with the MAC Act.
Having regard to the admission in CGU's pleading as discussed at [19] to [23] above, the question for me is whether QBE's conduct in causing Megbuy to admit liability was reasonable. Having regard to the findings that I have made, I am satisfied that it was. It is necessary to note one matter concerning QBE's obligations under ss 80 to 82 of the MAC Act.
In a different context, it might have been contended that overall the compromise that QBE effected was not reasonable because it admitted liability in August 2009 and only later negotiated over quantum and thus did so from a position of relative weakness.
However, given the obligations imposed by QBE under the MAC Act I do not consider that its admission of liability can be held against it in this way. Having gathered evidence and advice that it was very likely to be found liable, QBE was acting entirely consistently with its obligations when it admitted liability.
111Consistent with the discussion at [40] above, these conclusions do not end the inquiry as to whether the compromise was reasonable. There is the remaining issue as to whether the definition of "injury" in s 3 of the MAC Act is satisfied.
112Before addressing that, I will revisit the question of the liability of Megbuy on the basis that my conclusion in [37] is wrong and it was incumbent on me to determine whether it was liable to Mr Horwood.
|
[
0.03454388678073883,
-0.015753258019685745,
0.0037481666076928377,
-0.03549366816878319,
0.03573421388864517,
-0.018407486379146576,
0.014294980093836784,
0.006447772495448589,
0.026478102430701256,
0.02817430905997753,
-0.006466446444392204,
-0.014134658500552177,
-0.010402655228972435,
0.021445799618959427,
-0.01584327220916748,
-0.03912699595093727,
0.043226614594459534,
-0.003527980763465166,
-0.04808875545859337,
-0.03802788630127907,
0.029433561488986015,
-0.027300044894218445,
0.0555373914539814,
0.02061711996793747,
0.024384580552577972,
0.001909855636768043,
-0.023351166397333145,
0.003477232763543725,
-0.006580043584108353,
-0.029224662110209465,
-0.008721401914954185,
0.008867739699780941,
0.0032044618856161833,
-0.0022937848698347807,
0.006483669392764568,
-0.05921897664666176,
-0.028397468850016594,
0.001937136985361576,
-0.018234875053167343,
-0.0005768747068941593,
0.002464420162141323,
0.0028732947539538145,
0.026182904839515686,
-0.04342730715870857,
0.03548680618405342,
-0.031662534922361374,
-0.016520174220204353,
-0.01760382205247879,
-0.024013478308916092,
-0.011811095289885998,
-0.044957809150218964,
-0.011456441134214401,
0.04215841367840767,
-0.020395120605826378,
-0.005032747983932495,
-0.0014780857600271702,
0.0055439528077840805,
-0.03603297844529152,
-0.06196006387472153,
-0.02315574884414673,
-0.03663277626037598,
-0.016517605632543564,
-0.0074433316476643085,
0.02225630357861519,
0.022268399596214294,
0.07650946080684662,
-0.03177424520254135,
-0.016165392473340034,
-0.011311572976410389,
-0.014718424528837204,
0.009591808542609215,
0.016082489863038063,
-0.027445781975984573,
0.012631402350962162,
-0.05600079149007797,
0.030319251120090485,
0.0002804950054269284,
0.022387973964214325,
-0.009715041145682335,
0.0543719157576561,
0.026648035272955894,
0.0034599388018250465,
-0.008264699019491673,
-0.005041942466050386,
-0.011653379537165165,
-0.007816476747393608,
-0.02739948034286499,
0.0041713775135576725,
-0.004779832437634468,
-0.010148392990231514,
-0.017746347934007645,
0.005675457417964935,
-0.0006085102213546634,
-0.0205999668687582,
-0.010467623360455036,
-0.009223288856446743,
-0.04783039540052414,
0.011766466312110424,
-0.009105857461690903,
-0.011665590107440948,
-0.022040776908397675,
0.016152143478393555,
0.06657771021127701,
-0.035265158861875534,
-0.007283906918019056,
0.005502364598214626,
-0.003438760293647647,
0.04645630344748497,
0.025685690343379974,
0.018445299938321114,
0.009745662100613117,
0.0023502151016145945,
-0.007389635778963566,
0.028395015746355057,
-0.006418800447136164,
-0.020866932347416878,
0.01649516634643078,
-0.03763815015554428,
0.0012581004993990064,
-0.02354337088763714,
0.05011502653360367,
0.05678361654281616,
0.052290305495262146,
-0.02791653573513031,
-0.04715592786669731,
-0.023033382371068,
0.016082119196653366,
-0.040262311697006226,
-0.03888814523816109,
-0.01687377505004406,
0.015369940549135208,
-0.011459056288003922,
0.00673795398324728,
-0.049438878893852234,
-0.0348999947309494,
-0.044324520975351334,
0.041539255529642105,
0.012537377886474133,
-0.03378027305006981,
-0.04101688414812088,
0.03222852572798729,
0.01786159537732601,
0.014014175161719322,
0.0041150362230837345,
0.03593963012099266,
-0.02272464521229267,
0.021404650062322617,
-0.04808416962623596,
0.012822862714529037,
-0.017125273123383522,
0.018552925437688828,
0.0022008607629686594,
-0.006860767025500536,
-0.04970218986272812,
0.014131050556898117,
-0.03284705802798271,
0.023792888969182968,
-0.014314135536551476,
-0.021577827632427216,
0.03178606554865837,
-0.01839473471045494,
0.05253273621201515,
-0.03224178031086922,
-0.01882990263402462,
0.011294185183942318,
-0.0114442752674222,
0.012635424733161926,
0.01769576407968998,
-0.021614249795675278,
-0.03685074672102928,
0.03319267928600311,
0.0008814996108412743,
0.023311831057071686,
0.00039746437687426805,
0.05089114233851433,
0.03268277645111084,
0.058852843940258026,
0.016991177573800087,
0.03315408527851105,
-0.038948897272348404,
0.02373064123094082,
-0.014292352832853794,
0.019892584532499313,
0.001041960553266108,
-0.018153591081500053,
0.032185766845941544,
-0.010100681334733963,
-0.07360287010669708,
0.014981059357523918,
0.01072742696851492,
0.009092231281101704,
-0.011627408675849438,
0.0006863902672193944,
-0.009883067570626736,
0.012186603620648384,
-0.002376526826992631,
0.047977566719055176,
0.005285341292619705,
0.014989198185503483,
-0.039031196385622025,
-0.027205051854252815,
0.032463692128658295,
0.03875049203634262,
-0.02807844802737236,
-0.04311221465468407,
0.006075847428292036,
-0.06213463470339775,
0.006509819533675909,
0.0332285612821579,
-0.0427473746240139,
0.007038623560220003,
-0.00011602965969359502,
0.03736894205212593,
0.0019952792208641768,
-0.02314666658639908,
0.0043633547611534595,
0.007885332219302654,
-0.005912518594413996,
0.031683314591646194,
-0.02012203074991703,
-0.037669841200113297,
0.0014687970979139209,
0.022455208003520966,
0.016519492492079735,
0.008608178235590458,
0.004748930223286152,
-0.03551390394568443,
0.04997839406132698,
-0.003068564459681511,
-0.015518990345299244,
0.031748540699481964,
0.014499079436063766,
0.03412987291812897,
-0.046037983149290085,
0.02662617154419422,
0.015141288749873638,
0.006198173854500055,
0.008592281490564346,
0.04235554113984108,
0.03570983558893204,
-0.023847002536058426,
-0.007998119108378887,
0.06579678505659103,
-0.039848919957876205,
-0.004695134237408638,
-0.03951483592391014,
0.00949910469353199,
0.004948726389557123,
0.04477245733141899,
0.012066185474395752,
0.02087949961423874,
-0.017868759110569954,
-0.015969593077898026,
-0.0206323079764843,
0.030871760100126266,
0.044276244938373566,
0.025090476498007774,
-0.024384785443544388,
0.028141072019934654,
-0.004409424494951963,
0.03134305775165558,
0.008336048573255539,
0.060779016464948654,
-0.006553096696734428,
-0.027226826176047325,
-0.04164198413491249,
-0.007404971402138472,
-0.010890220291912556,
-0.04592231288552284,
-0.015217854641377926,
0.01237102597951889,
0.013241101987659931,
-0.009259541518986225,
0.02607000060379505,
0.014806220307946205,
0.02172793447971344,
-0.018213395029306412,
-0.01297500729560852,
0.00495678698644042,
0.0012261602096259594,
0.041518766433000565,
0.00842968188226223,
0.01120478194206953,
-0.04000949114561081,
0.02636137790977955,
0.007056132890284061,
-0.04104101285338402,
-0.042167335748672485,
-0.020098362118005753,
-0.05838928744196892,
0.0437261238694191,
0.0041999430395662785,
0.05552290007472038,
0.018416384235024452,
-0.057716868817806244,
0.00837612897157669,
0.026705339550971985,
-0.14966021478176117,
-0.028528288006782532,
0.025256695225834846,
0.009637084789574146,
-0.009870779700577259,
0.020406967028975487,
0.008691402152180672,
-0.015608372166752815,
0.014194306917488575,
0.015746327117085457,
0.015433460474014282,
-0.059754878282547,
-0.00693473732098937,
0.0011078155366703868,
-0.009574717842042446,
-0.027188962325453758,
0.015464894473552704,
0.0018898099660873413,
0.03296758979558945,
-0.03634267300367355,
0.0185659471899271,
-0.01877773180603981,
0.015887752175331116,
-0.0028390642255544662,
-0.002848492469638586,
-0.02388010546565056,
0.034414343535900116,
0.0250681322067976,
-0.004585837479680777,
-0.03592107445001602,
-0.052778445184230804,
-0.006417021621018648,
-0.015066961757838726,
0.05910656228661537,
0.001103064278140664,
-0.00027229025727137923,
0.0595879890024662,
-0.07107863575220108,
-0.010480961762368679,
0.012739788740873337,
0.025510426610708237,
0.10381724685430527,
-0.01584085449576378,
0.017554575577378273,
-0.013697483576834202,
-0.07383722066879272,
0.02246127463877201,
-0.015100551769137383,
-0.06965605169534683,
0.022520028054714203,
0.007411584258079529,
-0.040621813386678696,
0.007188794668763876,
0.01905396208167076,
-0.010277783498167992,
-0.01051697414368391,
0.044134896248579025,
0.0421898178756237,
-0.04653339833021164,
0.012919774278998375,
-0.02707233838737011,
-0.04288404434919357,
0.020225966349244118,
0.030054593458771706,
-0.05361560359597206,
0.014503725804388523,
-0.004420100245624781,
-0.020200371742248535,
0.020015893504023552,
-0.008419371210038662,
-0.03192657604813576,
-0.05422931909561157,
0.03263142332434654,
-0.010343550704419613,
0.004364784341305494,
0.02907886728644371,
0.008265083655714989,
-0.008149567991495132,
0.005616140551865101,
-0.04702730476856232,
-0.00791872013360262,
0.025108536705374718,
0.008664221502840519,
0.0206968542188406,
-0.014548111706972122,
0.04602427035570145,
0.02945990301668644,
0.022734178230166435,
0.03756776452064514,
0.24701961874961853,
-0.02770524099469185,
-0.009662743657827377,
-0.02146843634545803,
0.013232136145234108,
0.02156933769583702,
0.014637776650488377,
0.0276869498193264,
-0.0024763373658061028,
-0.011533469893038273,
-0.04809079319238663,
0.013708475977182388,
0.011372379027307034,
0.019626891240477562,
-0.013426107354462147,
-0.006926240865141153,
-0.03203560411930084,
-0.05653448402881622,
0.08250496536493301,
-0.025540290400385857,
0.027839306741952896,
0.0007387149962596595,
0.0437127985060215,
0.04026440903544426,
-0.06174181029200554,
-0.03311483561992645,
-0.012547937221825123,
0.0034240251407027245,
0.02899421565234661,
-0.00877489522099495,
-0.03397390618920326,
-0.014140313491225243,
0.028050091117620468,
-0.0010376748396083713,
-0.005110143218189478,
0.019664904102683067,
0.0029874492902308702,
0.006120314355939627,
0.0029034579638391733,
0.0107892956584692,
0.047617897391319275,
-0.0063872868195176125,
-0.03746193274855614,
0.0133681520819664,
0.0258218701928854,
0.005705457646399736,
0.006633067969232798,
-0.012765537016093731,
-0.015263907611370087,
0.049955226480960846,
-0.060721561312675476,
0.02381998300552368,
-0.019460903480648994,
-0.02251143380999565,
-0.030014121904969215,
0.03602433577179909,
-0.01253490149974823,
0.04943753033876419,
-0.006104013882577419,
0.01827841065824032,
0.03517245501279831,
0.0260637104511261,
-0.02366054616868496,
0.024069542065262794,
-0.006552876904606819,
0.015606635250151157,
-0.0711534321308136,
-0.013807808049023151,
0.05851114168763161,
-0.012128460220992565,
0.023152168840169907,
0.04379136487841606,
0.012971161864697933,
0.035119667649269104,
0.03842504695057869,
0.043472494930028915,
0.03558504581451416,
0.07023131847381592,
-0.005156658124178648,
-0.02856474183499813,
-0.03918624296784401,
-0.03985227644443512,
-0.011551800183951855,
0.018755391240119934,
-0.0052348230965435505,
0.001705474336631596,
-0.007197720929980278,
0.0619928278028965,
0.03346908837556839,
-0.01931655965745449,
-0.029501454904675484,
-0.021592603996396065,
-0.01704009436070919,
0.030051643028855324,
-0.010663137771189213,
0.016659563407301903,
0.04078176990151405,
-0.015774020925164223,
-0.01493191160261631,
-0.03076757863163948,
-0.03511430695652962,
-0.00430452823638916,
-0.007304139900952578,
-0.022472504526376724,
0.006658215541392565,
-0.02516159974038601,
0.016112273558974266,
0.01209636777639389,
-0.013925069011747837,
-0.0190396960824728,
-0.004380855243653059,
0.006488039158284664,
-0.013080230914056301,
-0.018540984019637108,
0.02448291890323162,
0.01601380854845047,
-0.026148976758122444,
0.04532727971673012,
0.018219774588942528,
0.04903668165206909,
-0.014712831936776638,
-0.00836205668747425,
-0.0286826491355896,
0.020328866317868233,
-0.021287040784955025,
-0.012063657864928246,
-0.053457651287317276,
-0.03951919078826904,
-0.001361883245408535,
0.014618945308029652,
0.029843153432011604,
0.001726014306768775,
-0.03437812626361847,
-0.0022368545178323984,
0.07044538855552673,
-0.019265079870820045,
-0.01537711638957262,
0.03273097053170204,
0.003604241879656911,
-0.008076581172645092,
-0.032594047486782074,
-0.0005639439914375544,
-0.05826447531580925,
-0.038039546459913254,
0.0024067778140306473,
-0.015059121884405613,
-0.03423082083463669,
0.030140556395053864,
-0.06078052520751953,
-0.04033661633729935,
0.013391628861427307,
0.038085490465164185,
-0.04054337367415428,
-0.02069929800927639,
-0.03798314929008484,
0.050047289580106735,
0.01418166235089302,
-0.010420503094792366,
0.009805968962609768,
-0.039120111614465714,
-0.03200909122824669,
-0.0162118561565876,
-0.00951576977968216,
0.05456739664077759,
0.030855726450681686,
0.04962883144617081,
0.02679814212024212,
0.052837129682302475,
0.07069428265094757,
-0.018247826024889946,
0.011624431237578392,
-0.0160425566136837,
0.009855711832642555,
0.05806947499513626,
0.030394114553928375,
0.10562766343355179,
-0.022536946460604668,
0.021172497421503067,
0.015637261793017387,
-0.0033174955751746893,
0.003244862426072359,
0.04085024446249008,
-0.02674565650522709,
0.0069165159948170185,
-0.03736228868365288,
-0.02275063283741474,
0.023902790620923042,
-0.03447968140244484,
0.025081230327486992,
-0.008766207844018936,
-0.0367056280374527,
0.08666214346885681,
-0.029223937541246414,
0.0013300462160259485,
0.03583315759897232,
0.010095213539898396,
-0.014675573445856571,
0.03257102519273758,
0.006157181691378355,
-0.07150701433420181,
-0.0035269169602543116,
-0.012153873220086098,
-0.0011411098530516028,
0.021788068115711212,
0.06491512805223465,
0.013000616803765297,
-0.0065352097153663635,
0.00935460813343525,
-0.018511923030018806,
-0.010375229641795158,
0.01281757466495037,
0.037553224712610245,
-0.03793086111545563,
-0.009214441291987896,
-0.02925221435725689,
0.008528784848749638,
0.03839148208498955,
0.06858010590076447,
-0.0016420880565419793,
-0.04200674220919609,
-0.010867845267057419,
-0.013580067083239555,
0.025784684345126152,
-0.05964731052517891,
-0.04570043087005615,
0.038087476044893265,
-0.005415753461420536,
-0.045391473919153214,
0.019736889749765396,
0.008592394180595875,
0.0072339861653745174,
-0.05365476757287979,
-0.00925683043897152,
-0.02716708369553089,
0.014337887987494469,
-0.0016851190011948347,
0.03982485458254814,
-0.001259773736819625,
0.02535090409219265,
-0.014535916969180107,
0.030406517907977104,
0.002488190308213234,
-0.0018110814271494746,
0.0641501322388649,
-0.010994459502398968,
0.004115078132599592,
0.010296535678207874,
-0.06442920118570328,
-0.0005732483114115894,
0.01976286992430687,
0.02555209957063198,
0.04214983433485031,
0.007722343318164349,
-0.03489289805293083,
0.008326547220349312,
-0.019283676519989967,
-0.011973892338573933,
0.011463522911071777,
-0.04531579092144966,
-0.0037126238457858562,
0.0017984575824812055,
0.03422313928604126,
-0.008217527531087399,
-0.008441527374088764,
-0.0059264544397592545,
-0.05337678641080856,
0.01499719638377428,
0.008813712745904922,
-0.02094702422618866,
-0.060540821403265,
-0.02200126275420189,
-0.01762291230261326,
-0.03581320121884346,
-0.057106226682662964,
-0.050269704312086105,
0.025271184742450714,
-0.053334545344114304,
0.004556004889309406,
-0.005940400529652834,
-0.04119531065225601,
0.02506359852850437,
-0.04410175979137421,
0.004982585087418556,
0.03349503502249718,
-0.005514118354767561,
0.029668675735592842,
0.051872678101062775,
-0.006331460550427437,
0.002664151368662715,
-0.017220303416252136,
0.03425776585936546,
0.05042191222310066,
0.0019079293124377728,
0.003703316440805793,
-0.004989273380488157,
0.03015485778450966,
-0.024301664903759956,
0.09010155498981476,
-0.03309498727321625,
0.00008818011701805517,
-0.006478482391685247,
-0.010117465630173683,
-0.04189598560333252,
-0.028679540380835533,
-0.01163498405367136,
-0.02808202989399433,
0.013815969228744507,
-0.02289404161274433,
0.011712028644979,
0.018243905156850815,
-0.008745909668505192,
-0.05978846177458763,
-0.022822285071015358,
-0.032175008207559586,
-0.015120448544621468,
0.012419025413691998,
-0.0020050890743732452,
-0.02962304838001728,
0.01596987061202526,
0.026719462126493454,
0.018230421468615532,
-0.01682312972843647,
-0.02602909505367279,
-0.021113716065883636,
-0.08269423991441727,
0.009158181957900524,
0.012953529134392738,
0.005691134370863438,
-0.01890428178012371,
-0.019725613296031952,
-0.036255352199077606,
0.00103354686871171,
-0.017822539433836937,
-0.004124875646084547,
0.1052965298295021,
0.006340355612337589,
-0.015354383736848831,
-0.019185958430171013,
0.06392353028059006,
-0.03731127828359604,
-0.021420525386929512,
-0.05359550938010216,
0.08398055285215378,
-0.02870240993797779,
-0.0036514413077384233,
0.0036345382686704397,
0.0001640991831663996,
-0.0009677043999545276,
0.020778195932507515,
0.052004117518663406,
0.009528662078082561,
0.004149990156292915,
-0.023832619190216064,
-0.04104010388255119,
-0.012556451372802258,
0.0071259899996221066,
0.0031626049894839525,
0.025138085708022118,
0.01338907890021801,
-0.0004197087255306542,
-0.003763691522181034,
0.048051685094833374,
-0.019140979275107384,
-0.00454218965023756,
0.008461653254926205,
0.010995355434715748,
0.012025885283946991,
0.02752455696463585,
-0.005552584771066904,
-0.025803258642554283,
-0.011309550143778324,
-0.011810586787760258,
0.02536742389202118,
-0.010309423319995403,
-0.01513727381825447,
-0.0027663027867674828,
-0.004338651895523071,
-0.006573447026312351,
-0.020741792395710945,
-0.020240316167473793,
-0.0364154651761055,
-0.0822301059961319,
-0.03911770135164261,
0.005034101195633411,
0.03982630372047424,
0.011617985554039478,
-0.01860646717250347,
0.004865806549787521,
-0.054485902190208435,
0.03278394788503647,
0.010344736278057098,
0.053362082690000534,
-0.05059317871928215,
0.023170186206698418,
-0.13027644157409668,
0.006432860624045134,
0.005147561896592379,
0.0020025072153657675,
-0.05286384001374245,
-0.005371543578803539,
-0.03923331946134567,
-0.004642131272703409,
-0.010288131423294544,
-0.029476318508386612,
-0.015045669861137867,
-0.01656351238489151,
0.045119550079107285,
0.00908654648810625,
-0.058748792856931686,
0.025110449641942978,
-0.02156992442905903,
-0.04271582514047623,
-0.018763918429613113,
0.026850303635001183,
0.02838105522096157,
0.02117506042122841,
0.015302966348826885,
-0.02790777198970318,
-0.03666281700134277,
-0.01748892106115818,
-0.0402829609811306,
-0.04932887852191925,
-0.020814135670661926,
-0.013565298169851303,
-0.06619814038276672,
-0.04318312555551529,
0.007520550396293402,
0.039039820432662964,
-0.00046027940697968006,
0.005433935672044754,
0.0019454514840617776,
-0.010700972750782967,
-0.03583739325404167,
-0.0037753754295408726,
-0.002135250251740217,
0.010783303529024124,
-0.018255185335874557,
0.00684767309576273,
-0.03839830681681633,
0.02375544048845768,
-0.01651132106781006,
0.0015707096317782998,
-0.03125504404306412,
-0.02983461692929268,
-0.04128891974687576,
0.04777853935956955,
-0.03426986187696457,
0.026920607313513756,
0.0146561274304986,
0.0021298262290656567,
-0.01500448863953352,
-0.016457656398415565,
-0.02555287815630436,
0.05759792402386665,
0.01614353433251381,
-0.013537132181227207,
-0.029808660969138145,
-0.03274267539381981,
0.034459471702575684,
-0.0024678539484739304,
-0.007928527891635895,
0.009785030968487263,
0.008318770676851273,
0.001527714659459889,
0.00040971863199956715,
-0.009835715405642986,
0.03541499003767967,
-0.026274001225829124,
-0.014925958588719368,
-0.025124773383140564,
0.019747095182538033,
-0.030183933675289154,
0.025173023343086243,
0.0014974756632000208,
-0.00853341817855835,
-0.013604797422885895,
-0.04875180125236511,
-0.02446584776043892,
0.04492715746164322,
-0.003377793822437525,
-0.03300517052412033,
-0.037424277514219284,
0.07073846459388733,
-0.07295647263526917,
-0.05798494070768356,
0.016244227066636086,
0.0008798615308478475,
-0.007930385880172253,
-0.057570695877075195,
0.03050815500319004,
0.002709762193262577,
-0.005153232254087925,
-0.03454960137605667,
-0.02663388103246689,
-0.02952495589852333,
-0.01598893105983734,
0.020748820155858994,
-0.001020146650262177,
-0.021603642031550407,
0.021076548844575882,
-0.013781244866549969,
0.0260179340839386,
0.01416261587291956,
0.012458836659789085,
-0.05014818161725998,
-0.05027638003230095,
-0.025383619591593742,
-0.031559139490127563,
0.006135447416454554,
0.06069101020693779,
-0.019093964248895645,
0.014966635964810848,
-0.007888398133218288,
0.034964025020599365,
0.03154370188713074,
-0.06452822685241699,
0.04591682180762291,
-0.002693326910957694,
-0.03429432213306427,
0.03673157840967178,
0.04471474513411522,
0.018874377012252808,
0.0018932870589196682,
-0.0035578946117311716,
0.04796067625284195,
-0.03336483612656593,
-0.019571268931031227,
0.0420667827129364,
-0.0003580672782845795,
0.03350784257054329,
-0.024959146976470947,
-0.011299779638648033,
0.011738093569874763,
-0.06712595373392105,
-0.003872461151331663,
-0.025060802698135376,
-0.003689949633553624,
-0.0032727262005209923,
-0.028520917519927025,
-0.006353790406137705,
0.023639127612113953,
0.0032978467643260956,
-0.021839698776602745,
-0.02959706075489521,
-0.008096515201032162,
-0.010034644044935703,
0.005762787535786629,
0.07277975231409073,
0.030563555657863617,
-0.03148939087986946,
0.028200479224324226,
0.022064855322241783,
-0.01113108266144991,
0.055390190333127975,
0.038284990936517715,
-0.007714360486716032,
-0.03902880847454071,
0.0020489573944360018,
-0.034019410610198975,
0.049109697341918945,
0.008646476082503796,
-0.005472502671182156,
-0.013583905063569546,
-0.009762100875377655,
0.032803259789943695,
0.025399647653102875,
-0.0235611479729414,
0.021811407059431076,
0.03711795061826706,
-0.07379195839166641,
0.011460848152637482,
-0.003852277062833309,
0.041971977800130844,
-0.00674146693199873,
0.0312382560223341,
0.04348532482981682,
0.013830241747200489,
0.0478786863386631,
0.018809912726283073,
0.019033284857869148,
-0.003552002366632223,
0.0019115348113700747,
-0.036166608333587646,
-0.009648886509239674,
-0.011350911110639572,
-0.008112717419862747,
-0.0028683687560260296,
-0.03741496056318283,
0.029834788292646408,
0.012708744965493679,
-0.011447916738688946,
0.01288120448589325,
0.004676877520978451,
0.03237567096948624,
0.02046138606965542,
-0.011032476089894772,
-0.017645997926592827,
-0.03454679250717163,
-0.017633698880672455,
-0.015612435527145863,
0.009391726925969124,
-0.020368317142128944,
-0.025060953572392464,
0.02249339036643505,
-0.011557014659047127,
-0.01531777810305357,
-0.002123583108186722,
0.07212700694799423,
-0.03539133816957474,
0.015468401834368706,
-0.00654491875320673,
-0.016507355496287346,
0.05307585373520851,
-0.004217204637825489,
-0.005757382605224848,
0.061470698565244675,
0.013077138923108578,
-0.046813614666461945,
0.00697738490998745,
0.03163836523890495,
0.010417662560939789,
0.002871748758479953,
0.006243770942091942,
0.0037273368798196316,
-0.028797989711165428,
0.00391036132350564,
-0.004105028230696917,
0.006902730092406273,
0.013079368509352207,
-0.005315410904586315,
-0.01484201941639185,
-0.017445998266339302,
-0.013847658410668373,
-0.023169057443737984,
0.07541873306035995,
0.00685777235776186,
0.014586089178919792,
0.04246796667575836
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e:3
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d978e
|
They do not require it to either admit liability or make an offer of settlement of payment of a sum in circumstances where the insured is not liable. Second, these provisions do not convert the cover that is provided by s 10 into some form of claims made policy.
Third, any analysis of the manner in which an insurer such as QBE conducted itself with respect to a claim must bear in mind the obligations imposed on it by these provisions.
16The policy obtained from CGU by Megbuy pursuant to s 155(1) of the WC Act provided cover for Megbuy's liability under the WC Act (ie workers compensation benefits) but also extended cover to "the employer's liability [arising] independently of [the WC Act] .... for any injury to any such worker.
" The definition of "injury" in s 4 of the WC Act relevantly meant "personal injury arising out of or in the course of employment". This meant that cover was provided by CGU to Megbuy for any liability it incurred in favour of its employees arising out of their use and operation of a motor vehicle in the course of their employment.
17Most claims against an employer for which they are indemnified by the extension of the workers compensation policy in s 155(1) of the WC Act are subject to the restrictions on damages imposed by Division 3 of Part 5 of the WC Act.
However s 151E(2) provides that that Division does not apply to awards of damages to which Chapter 5 of the MAC Act applies. Sub-section 122(1) of the MAC Act provided that Chapter 5 of the MAC Act applied to "and in respect of an award of damages which relates to the .
.. injury to a person caused by the fault of the owner or driver of a motor vehicle in the use or operation of the vehicle" (emphasis added). The meaning of those terms in the MAC Act has been already been noted.
Thus the cover provided by CGU to Megbuy under the extension to its workers compensation insurance policy fully covered any liability Megbuy might incur to its employees that resulted in damages being calculated in accordance with Chapter 5 of the MAC Act
18These proceedings were initially commenced in the Commercial List of the Equity Division. CGU's "defence" was set out in a document entitled "Statement of Issues".
In that document CGU put in issue whether Megbuy satisfied the statutory definition of owner in the MAC Act. It follows from the above that the question as to whether Megbuy was the owner of the forklift affected a number of elements of the double insurance claim.
Megbuy's ownership of the forklift was a necessary precondition to it being liable to Mr Horwood for damages calculated in accordance with Chapter 5 of the MAC and consequently affected the scope of CGU's obligation to indemnify Megbuy. It was also a necessary precondition for QBE being obliged to indemnify Megbuy under the statutory CTP policy described by s 10 of the MAC Act.
19Paragraph A8 of QBE's pleading recited the fact of the settlement of the proceedings against Megbuy for $1.5 million. Paragraph A8 of CGU's pleading responded by stating: "Agreed and the defendant agrees that the sum of $1.5M inclusive of costs was a reasonable sum in the circumstances.
" Paragraph A7 of QBE's pleading recounted its belief at the time the proceedings commenced that the only basis upon which CGU resisted the claim for contribution was the assertion that it was not the owner. In response QBE pleaded (at [A7] ):
"Denied - there are further grounds upon which the defendant refuses to contribute. Mr Horwood's injury is not an injury as defined under the [MAC Act] because it was not caused by the fault of the owner in the use or operation of the vehicle nor was it as a result of and caused during such use or operation by a defect in the vehicle."
20Paragraph B3(a) of CGU's pleading was in similar terms and the balance of the pleading denied the existence of QBE's obligation to indemnify Megbuy.
21Standing alone [A7] of CGU's pleading puts in issue all the elements of the definition of injury including "fault" and "ownership". However the scope of the pleading is complicated by [A8].
|
[
0.010278179310262203,
0.014845605008304119,
-0.013067531399428844,
-0.01231716200709343,
0.03499241918325424,
-0.024116387590765953,
-0.02158532105386257,
0.01605767384171486,
0.017208928242325783,
0.023159032687544823,
-0.0009264565887860954,
-0.018835732713341713,
0.016494961455464363,
-0.002500286791473627,
-0.007410924881696701,
-0.03901500627398491,
0.013917474076151848,
-0.0002736378228291869,
-0.06360124051570892,
-0.03994528949260712,
0.006382912863045931,
-0.0160294771194458,
0.009703527204692364,
0.0477997250854969,
0.016691910102963448,
0.018775353208184242,
-0.0030773086473345757,
-0.007537555415183306,
-0.018592549487948418,
0.009061826393008232,
-0.006166666280478239,
-0.02818017639219761,
-0.01956399343907833,
-0.044126857072114944,
0.020520281046628952,
-0.013367489911615849,
-0.04833577200770378,
0.020757470279932022,
-0.019001390784978867,
-0.013310467824339867,
0.0019420064054429531,
-0.014802444726228714,
0.010478845797479153,
-0.016352206468582153,
0.03539850190281868,
-0.03572015464305878,
0.004231431987136602,
-0.02552630752325058,
-0.004094925709068775,
-0.04152676835656166,
-0.053396228700876236,
-0.03048577532172203,
0.02646631933748722,
-0.02513940818607807,
0.005424425471574068,
0.01858268305659294,
-0.024668268859386444,
-0.05352328345179558,
-0.05280161648988724,
-0.0351707823574543,
-0.0347784161567688,
-0.03443906456232071,
-0.011770679615437984,
0.023515284061431885,
0.014049763791263103,
0.07486214488744736,
-0.02730496972799301,
-0.003069400554522872,
-0.015158983878791332,
-0.04880048334598541,
0.014839076437056065,
0.0057468716986477375,
-0.0423177033662796,
0.021147949621081352,
-0.05222850292921066,
-0.00332047906704247,
-0.015994254499673843,
0.018235210329294205,
0.005297795403748751,
0.025376828387379646,
0.011609382927417755,
0.021771274507045746,
0.0011688212398439646,
0.023451291024684906,
-0.038636647164821625,
-0.007920997217297554,
-0.016297878697514534,
0.00040706497384235263,
-0.030434362590312958,
-0.0313728041946888,
0.019754111766815186,
0.008769421838223934,
0.022076107561588287,
-0.0033906882163137197,
0.017656201496720314,
-0.01285818126052618,
-0.06022163853049278,
0.011978546157479286,
0.03169972449541092,
0.020415591076016426,
0.014879904687404633,
0.024165334179997444,
0.05454761162400246,
-0.047175634652376175,
0.00822475552558899,
0.010328353382647038,
0.03812538832426071,
0.042594920843839645,
0.006069775205105543,
-0.007837999612092972,
-0.009578199125826359,
0.04472208395600319,
-0.01649029366672039,
0.02859492227435112,
-0.02037465199828148,
-0.0035818726755678654,
-0.0028637524228543043,
-0.02146940305829048,
0.0033426431473344564,
-0.00920382421463728,
0.041673582047224045,
0.04113816097378731,
0.021374758332967758,
-0.018258774653077126,
-0.039590634405612946,
-0.018505064770579338,
0.014980941079556942,
-0.034165289252996445,
-0.02768971584737301,
-0.005974871106445789,
-0.010770571418106556,
0.006673912052065134,
-0.016743458807468414,
-0.04301643744111061,
-0.046115126460790634,
-0.03939778730273247,
0.06705156713724136,
0.00375156057998538,
-0.04450475424528122,
-0.03704891726374626,
0.02886039949953556,
0.03753110021352768,
-0.010539642535150051,
-0.028179680928587914,
0.0179541427642107,
-0.022404680028557777,
0.0525110624730587,
-0.056611910462379456,
0.048931561410427094,
0.03591269627213478,
0.01361901592463255,
0.010854469612240791,
-0.011130479164421558,
-0.09101075679063797,
0.02416512556374073,
-0.04188397899270058,
-0.01216132566332817,
-0.004617349244654179,
0.012139195576310158,
0.012837855145335197,
0.00004762290700455196,
0.08510224521160126,
0.008187733590602875,
-0.030408546328544617,
-0.008132010698318481,
-0.015818025916814804,
-0.002440094482153654,
0.030385639518499374,
-0.04536843299865723,
-0.011971860192716122,
0.03493714705109596,
0.0157699603587389,
0.017829598858952522,
-0.007520684041082859,
0.02658160775899887,
0.035411007702350616,
0.046852804720401764,
0.014333835802972317,
-0.006746979430317879,
-0.04046541824936867,
-0.020358743146061897,
0.022007659077644348,
0.01581033132970333,
-0.002300775609910488,
0.023401383310556412,
0.03295021131634712,
-0.003152033081278205,
-0.041473742574453354,
0.022549686953425407,
0.0012709491420537233,
0.004342082422226667,
-0.019740477204322815,
-0.031108779832720757,
-0.015224792994558811,
-0.009948031045496464,
-0.03645595908164978,
0.026750817894935608,
-0.009538074024021626,
0.02230139821767807,
-0.032510288059711456,
-0.05083848536014557,
-0.021609455347061157,
0.052124034613370895,
-0.04432854801416397,
-0.04740624502301216,
0.0011988923652097583,
-0.06345567852258682,
0.0388420969247818,
0.0014194451505318284,
-0.08203175663948059,
0.025334006175398827,
0.004133017733693123,
0.041939400136470795,
0.03057234361767769,
-0.046314772218465805,
-0.025599341839551926,
0.03709689527750015,
-0.013346676714718342,
0.03731716051697731,
-0.0019870554096996784,
-0.013259015046060085,
-0.017247045412659645,
0.012439053505659103,
0.03511118143796921,
0.031008118763566017,
0.0002619361039251089,
-0.03344198316335678,
0.04726039245724678,
0.005927608348429203,
-0.042343296110630035,
0.01697305217385292,
0.040394242852926254,
-0.001187897170893848,
-0.04562286287546158,
0.04656225070357323,
0.01626400649547577,
0.04002684727311134,
0.012876627966761589,
0.017583677545189857,
0.0115358866751194,
-0.022343652322888374,
-0.028897682204842567,
0.05635974183678627,
-0.020966455340385437,
-0.008176191709935665,
-0.00006299345841398463,
-0.026915209367871284,
0.039459966123104095,
-0.0012808418832719326,
-0.0020042001269757748,
0.015184749849140644,
-0.03986264765262604,
-0.023569846525788307,
-0.005585257895290852,
0.01000195648521185,
0.03207015618681908,
-0.013692830689251423,
-0.01585133746266365,
0.024028506129980087,
-0.001155635342001915,
0.017002267763018608,
0.023803727701306343,
0.05648564547300339,
-0.0034966059029102325,
-0.028188668191432953,
-0.029313353821635246,
-0.027019308879971504,
-0.010164353996515274,
-0.014355008490383625,
0.0331948883831501,
0.01017701718956232,
0.00022104335948824883,
-0.01196227129548788,
-0.002149751642718911,
0.02816011570394039,
0.049487046897411346,
0.029131479561328888,
-0.019940556958317757,
0.0030456867534667253,
0.007369943428784609,
0.050669845193624496,
0.02162131480872631,
0.005589576438069344,
-0.034303221851587296,
0.039302922785282135,
0.014507225714623928,
0.008864393457770348,
-0.05170722305774689,
-0.017949668690562248,
-0.043147601187229156,
0.018699197098612785,
-0.021955028176307678,
0.06493549048900604,
-0.027423225343227386,
-0.047947268933057785,
0.009140070527791977,
0.013480490073561668,
-0.13938647508621216,
-0.023844389244914055,
0.01860206387937069,
0.007908418774604797,
0.0031950585544109344,
0.016939029097557068,
-0.011975196190178394,
-0.008601019158959389,
0.023031385615468025,
0.028792381286621094,
0.0076543730683624744,
-0.05809909477829933,
-0.014857892878353596,
0.0184992216527462,
0.049688391387462616,
-0.043631188571453094,
-0.02825755998492241,
-0.022410938516259193,
0.036032967269420624,
-0.022056560963392258,
-0.03894137963652611,
0.001605922938324511,
-0.018694620579481125,
-0.02348564751446247,
0.00006881812441861257,
-0.016912618651986122,
0.027681253850460052,
-0.0028025819920003414,
-0.04294036328792572,
-0.0014500991674140096,
-0.06756477057933807,
-0.0029900046065449715,
-0.01312220934778452,
0.046360909938812256,
0.011603409424424171,
-0.00365450675599277,
0.05195613577961922,
-0.07798317074775696,
-0.022476984187960625,
0.009739691391587257,
0.0338640995323658,
0.1175336018204689,
0.0318632572889328,
0.0026739693712443113,
0.0034684387501329184,
-0.0304428618401289,
-0.00257746665738523,
-0.0020672306418418884,
-0.060623593628406525,
0.009492979384958744,
-0.018393052741885185,
-0.0108528733253479,
-0.011774462647736073,
0.022060023620724678,
-0.005607715342193842,
-0.004935313016176224,
0.053943850100040436,
0.03190983459353447,
-0.012754649855196476,
0.02841125801205635,
-0.009032891131937504,
-0.03438878431916237,
0.03180857375264168,
0.03821592777967453,
-0.047498658299446106,
0.017343314364552498,
0.014865249395370483,
0.030705565586686134,
0.027545640245079994,
-0.027282949537038803,
-0.0337824746966362,
-0.041270237416028976,
0.029254784807562828,
-0.012505698949098587,
-0.018276726827025414,
-0.0004499720816966146,
0.01919938251376152,
-0.003982150927186012,
-0.004324448294937611,
-0.09297666698694229,
0.006727865897119045,
-0.006456910632550716,
0.024145537987351418,
0.03813895583152771,
-0.008828536607325077,
-0.008376197889447212,
0.0039563607424497604,
0.0008028607699088752,
0.03123391605913639,
0.2393186092376709,
-0.0021025955211371183,
-0.03966774791479111,
0.00235763774253428,
0.045590437948703766,
0.005410544108599424,
0.020920494571328163,
0.02595173381268978,
-0.01648510992527008,
-0.03134921193122864,
-0.04906328395009041,
-0.02029353380203247,
0.02616043947637081,
0.027937138453125954,
-0.009857994504272938,
-0.051094405353069305,
-0.04412999376654625,
-0.015765756368637085,
0.06702664494514465,
-0.028266211971640587,
0.017415734007954597,
-0.006119035184383392,
0.022081555798649788,
0.02681623212993145,
-0.07160617411136627,
-0.07120300829410553,
-0.026281168684363365,
0.015441112220287323,
-0.007234284654259682,
0.029880080372095108,
-0.028676150366663933,
-0.022973358631134033,
0.03411843255162239,
-0.0021863048896193504,
-0.02731306478381157,
-0.0010748329805210233,
-0.02460397593677044,
0.03137579932808876,
-0.028707347810268402,
0.057608429342508316,
0.04565415158867836,
-0.01473831757903099,
-0.030016301199793816,
-0.009122179821133614,
0.024756744503974915,
0.014422216452658176,
-0.0008463695412501693,
0.011660844087600708,
-0.016509439796209335,
0.024858804419636726,
-0.0821264237165451,
0.004321674350649118,
-0.027825498953461647,
0.03874600678682327,
-0.022454185411334038,
0.018601402640342712,
0.00119440583512187,
0.02720576338469982,
0.007477461826056242,
-0.036501508206129074,
0.03143025562167168,
0.010332672856748104,
-0.03464408591389656,
0.02887919917702675,
0.002178029390051961,
0.013307682238519192,
-0.06245192512869835,
-0.009810145013034344,
0.03531279042363167,
0.0010026346426457167,
0.004018796607851982,
0.04499998316168785,
0.01744895428419113,
0.008701800368726254,
0.061290524899959564,
-0.001026840414851904,
0.039798539131879807,
0.010578064247965813,
-0.002460658084601164,
-0.025654952973127365,
-0.04159491881728172,
-0.017215022817254066,
0.021756280213594437,
0.009869080036878586,
0.018052782863378525,
0.007110033184289932,
-0.02973840944468975,
0.03754230961203575,
0.04092632606625557,
-0.041517578065395355,
-0.022929351776838303,
-0.037969205528497696,
0.029962625354528427,
0.031433168798685074,
-0.005534446332603693,
0.017390722408890724,
0.03721224144101143,
0.0028750249184668064,
-0.03370580077171326,
-0.04845244809985161,
-0.004653416574001312,
-0.002440711483359337,
-0.01217698398977518,
0.00375970546156168,
-0.041212890297174454,
-0.014515373855829239,
0.013677529990673065,
-0.016047082841396332,
-0.047453105449676514,
-0.01778324879705906,
0.01733185350894928,
0.009297092445194721,
-0.012311296537518501,
-0.005394428037106991,
0.009289950132369995,
0.028879156336188316,
-0.034358248114585876,
0.017644274979829788,
0.05188435688614845,
0.0017420811345800757,
-0.012842242605984211,
0.007548788096755743,
-0.02311048097908497,
0.006786047481000423,
0.016369350254535675,
-0.00500840600579977,
-0.03306562826037407,
-0.00788002647459507,
0.014476913027465343,
0.034287095069885254,
0.015717048197984695,
-0.0012357317609712481,
-0.047945935279130936,
-0.03377009928226471,
0.04011395201086998,
-0.02335497736930847,
-0.008565000258386135,
0.05275576561689377,
0.01397818885743618,
-0.02878318354487419,
-0.03508004546165466,
-0.010844962671399117,
-0.05467156693339348,
0.02483632229268551,
-0.007052561733871698,
-0.0067944033071398735,
-0.03521363064646721,
0.04696490243077278,
-0.05015553534030914,
-0.02071603387594223,
-0.02950185351073742,
-0.004804914817214012,
-0.04050745815038681,
-0.002279384760186076,
-0.02283155918121338,
0.00786619633436203,
0.03041977621614933,
0.03586413338780403,
0.01518252119421959,
-0.04233457148075104,
-0.011989520862698555,
-0.03424648940563202,
-0.005470804870128632,
0.04832049831748009,
0.011045921593904495,
0.05232710391283035,
0.02025015838444233,
0.06095287576317787,
0.03135061264038086,
-0.019050685688853264,
-0.016805490478873253,
-0.02656743675470352,
0.007978019304573536,
0.05733364447951317,
0.032156333327293396,
0.09378477185964584,
-0.009161308407783508,
0.0001725164329400286,
0.006786255165934563,
-0.02501588873565197,
-0.0027874510269612074,
0.04211144521832466,
-0.025314755737781525,
0.014082609675824642,
-0.019700122997164726,
0.00306357117369771,
0.05290458723902702,
-0.05234431475400925,
0.018776454031467438,
-0.017493214458227158,
-0.009506020694971085,
0.10623589158058167,
-0.03832452371716499,
-0.013731122948229313,
0.01737324520945549,
0.044918354600667953,
-0.023408643901348114,
-0.020276036113500595,
0.004916579928249121,
-0.025023600086569786,
0.0013302586739882827,
0.020826052874326706,
0.006884101312607527,
-0.0004609964962583035,
0.0462508425116539,
-0.02180618606507778,
0.006135957315564156,
-0.021496174857020378,
-0.028189556673169136,
0.017145313322544098,
0.0019942165818065405,
0.023649778217077255,
-0.03227692469954491,
-0.002024088753387332,
-0.005267224740236998,
0.03192056715488434,
0.008677423931658268,
0.05345680192112923,
0.007006537634879351,
-0.0531042106449604,
-0.02692621760070324,
0.0034944533836096525,
0.04812166094779968,
-0.06928277015686035,
0.0344981774687767,
0.03743918985128403,
0.007528821472078562,
-0.04796871170401573,
0.020356083288788795,
-0.011887547560036182,
0.00870396476238966,
-0.027978776022791862,
-0.006705152802169323,
-0.027054693549871445,
-0.012861473485827446,
0.003962057176977396,
0.024470243602991104,
0.010072252713143826,
0.015022187493741512,
-0.003475395031273365,
0.0027022522408515215,
0.00956628005951643,
-0.004913259297609329,
0.08243769407272339,
-0.007042914628982544,
-0.01413053646683693,
-0.028085675090551376,
-0.001702923676930368,
0.06154193356633186,
0.013852518983185291,
0.006383362226188183,
0.019214550033211708,
0.02345002256333828,
-0.03196997940540314,
-0.011855538934469223,
0.0023536356166005135,
-0.010037609376013279,
0.02478756569325924,
-0.045901354402303696,
-0.03801433742046356,
0.043289829045534134,
0.0428990013897419,
-0.0035436172038316727,
-0.037538111209869385,
0.023822041228413582,
-0.05150910094380379,
0.0015302276005968451,
-0.009239671751856804,
-0.02583620697259903,
0.001278763753362,
0.009158461354672909,
0.0014150994829833508,
-0.06133287772536278,
-0.028903091326355934,
-0.02455775998532772,
0.01003791019320488,
-0.0319276861846447,
0.004773474298417568,
0.046552933752536774,
-0.03738873079419136,
0.039074141532182693,
-0.03340370953083038,
-0.0018147517694160342,
0.03648901730775833,
0.0005667222430929542,
0.02548045478761196,
0.03717324137687683,
0.012961557134985924,
-0.01061928179115057,
-0.022969383746385574,
0.012363907881081104,
0.007406699005514383,
-0.008787902072072029,
0.00867938157171011,
0.0039644427597522736,
-0.002700603799894452,
-0.03396033123135567,
0.06395094096660614,
-0.02242611162364483,
0.010947292670607567,
0.0006503359763883054,
-0.012634946964681149,
-0.03919927030801773,
-0.04760601744055748,
0.01343146339058876,
-0.011209087446331978,
0.016245035454630852,
-0.0382508784532547,
0.004519602749496698,
-0.012931369245052338,
0.004993870854377747,
-0.03628642484545708,
-0.014206926338374615,
-0.044660814106464386,
-0.024076154455542564,
0.021873660385608673,
0.015758834779262543,
-0.006638870108872652,
0.022229019552469254,
-0.0016171931056305766,
0.029504839330911636,
-0.001225773012265563,
-0.03816593065857887,
-0.05296444520354271,
-0.04607337340712547,
0.023014668375253677,
0.01834973692893982,
-0.003929308615624905,
-0.023842422291636467,
0.01952948048710823,
-0.024078762158751488,
-0.015085900202393532,
-0.024780189618468285,
-0.014807065017521381,
0.03986787796020508,
0.027595585212111473,
-0.018783343955874443,
-0.03519638627767563,
0.03776170313358307,
0.004571778234094381,
-0.0034417633432894945,
-0.044349655508995056,
0.07540537416934967,
-0.01944756880402565,
0.015356752090156078,
-0.014382081106305122,
0.014722827821969986,
-0.0004237512475810945,
0.006028459407389164,
0.01968570053577423,
0.0219745971262455,
-0.0059775193221867085,
-0.014372834004461765,
-0.043331000953912735,
0.024271797388792038,
-0.022033870220184326,
0.01430019736289978,
0.014607397839426994,
0.020351983606815338,
0.012855660170316696,
-0.03352056071162224,
0.05152453854680061,
0.002700353739783168,
-0.005241820123046637,
0.022635897621512413,
0.006026294082403183,
0.013885712251067162,
0.013831346295773983,
0.01397351548075676,
-0.055062633007764816,
0.013861699029803276,
-0.019815977662801743,
0.0012337961234152317,
-0.0005644591874442995,
-0.005761865526437759,
0.002717874711379409,
0.0028682167176157236,
0.0025268634781241417,
-0.01996886357665062,
-0.04764571785926819,
-0.031458523124456406,
-0.052515700459480286,
-0.027054518461227417,
0.0071973432786762714,
0.017065931111574173,
0.019112417474389076,
-0.011771914549171925,
0.019964950159192085,
-0.016043130308389664,
0.032700810581445694,
0.0015109386295080185,
0.055181603878736496,
-0.033936165273189545,
0.022398578003048897,
-0.12317711114883423,
0.010602094233036041,
-0.012267866171896458,
0.029837826266884804,
-0.08224695175886154,
0.0060234335251152515,
-0.03714834153652191,
0.02574653923511505,
-0.009449927136301994,
-0.00791455339640379,
-0.031251586973667145,
-0.003162174951285124,
0.09967401623725891,
0.018055053427815437,
-0.03345020115375519,
0.019324665889143944,
-0.038437485694885254,
-0.05282343178987503,
-0.016016965731978416,
0.023412249982357025,
-0.0011196078266948462,
0.042988695204257965,
0.012991729192435741,
-0.026658883318305016,
0.008987911976873875,
-0.006286845542490482,
-0.048262819647789,
-0.013487203046679497,
-0.025259343907237053,
0.04767235368490219,
-0.017905650660395622,
-0.02434125915169716,
0.003621365875005722,
0.018797295168042183,
0.009496730752289295,
0.029095495119690895,
0.009450310841202736,
-0.005837160628288984,
-0.036702219396829605,
-0.01671275869011879,
-0.0027692699804902077,
0.013243653811514378,
-0.006095153745263815,
-0.008826772682368755,
0.01949331909418106,
0.04172401502728462,
0.0057404376566410065,
0.005764672067016363,
-0.03204835578799248,
-0.036725565791130066,
-0.03221767023205757,
-0.02094431407749653,
-0.027992112562060356,
0.02895784191787243,
0.03023623116314411,
0.013955222442746162,
0.007672332227230072,
-0.007919815368950367,
-0.017741074785590172,
0.07947484403848648,
0.012688593938946724,
-0.01000870019197464,
-0.027912264689803123,
-0.023683924227952957,
0.019892340525984764,
0.012588650919497013,
-0.0013015856966376305,
0.0072719077579677105,
0.024378666654229164,
-0.0046239374205470085,
0.04483182355761528,
-0.02178681083023548,
0.003946991637349129,
-0.04144829511642456,
-0.01788046397268772,
-0.01934335194528103,
0.024179428815841675,
0.006111153867095709,
0.00833954755216837,
0.011432244442403316,
0.025450101122260094,
-0.048645298928022385,
-0.00241714995354414,
-0.009250607341527939,
0.03414248302578926,
0.019825009629130363,
0.00005146696275915019,
-0.03825092688202858,
0.07285986840724945,
-0.033680595457553864,
-0.06760240346193314,
-0.0008381090010516346,
0.003120118286460638,
0.02643323503434658,
-0.01895107701420784,
0.06092987582087517,
0.019279802218079567,
-0.015347563661634922,
-0.03083101660013199,
-0.03581059351563454,
-0.0003584468795452267,
-0.01437282282859087,
0.03515029698610306,
-0.02099430374801159,
-0.03945157676935196,
0.06678202003240585,
-0.0575842522084713,
0.008687123656272888,
-0.00907713919878006,
-0.04175660014152527,
-0.018553351983428,
-0.025506727397441864,
-0.004227439407259226,
-0.01837202161550522,
-0.04734237864613533,
0.007981761358678341,
0.026402102783322334,
0.05912957340478897,
-0.01873031258583069,
0.04849103465676308,
0.015223344787955284,
-0.04204246401786804,
0.02014501951634884,
0.002456963760778308,
0.014886745251715183,
0.03661101311445236,
0.039935797452926636,
-0.00500502111390233,
0.050324536859989166,
-0.02141663059592247,
0.06428968906402588,
-0.005815933458507061,
-0.02437674067914486,
0.005056771449744701,
-0.010793917812407017,
0.04077077656984329,
-0.0055262986570596695,
0.017999358475208282,
0.005326158832758665,
-0.05981177091598511,
0.019058434292674065,
-0.02797171100974083,
-0.029490241780877113,
-0.0020030210725963116,
-0.04531782120466232,
-0.02681209146976471,
-0.010594994761049747,
-0.014487232081592083,
-0.015961628407239914,
-0.0680796355009079,
-0.03730247914791107,
0.01421329379081726,
0.0010486739920452237,
0.07366586476564407,
0.03571614623069763,
-0.040450096130371094,
0.04097764566540718,
0.02118021808564663,
-0.008404691703617573,
0.05286014452576637,
0.0028414928819984198,
-0.02970839850604534,
-0.01036413386464119,
-0.03314916789531708,
-0.00860060378909111,
0.02274431847035885,
-0.023547928780317307,
0.00665926281362772,
0.0012657619081437588,
0.00040836649714037776,
-0.03377372771501541,
0.016973575577139854,
-0.03404182568192482,
0.02545807510614395,
0.02967691794037819,
-0.04096405580639839,
-0.029978053644299507,
-0.01593647338449955,
0.06802728027105331,
0.005656571127474308,
0.042269010096788406,
0.05139581486582756,
-0.0009698648354969919,
0.021700069308280945,
-0.0013289269991219044,
0.034956224262714386,
-0.03134686499834061,
-0.018185796216130257,
-0.02283426746726036,
-0.049870431423187256,
-0.012184676714241505,
-0.02570134960114956,
0.0021185644436627626,
-0.023467715829610825,
0.06882838904857635,
0.013482864014804363,
-0.006636282429099083,
0.011775578372180462,
0.003155302256345749,
0.04495668411254883,
0.0144502567127347,
-0.03390086442232132,
-0.01432680431753397,
0.014220909215509892,
-0.036075565963983536,
-0.04147624969482422,
0.005161409266293049,
-0.010780555196106434,
-0.014535924419760704,
0.030683662742376328,
-0.033083900809288025,
-0.017084935680031776,
-0.026777012273669243,
0.0720464363694191,
-0.02323887124657631,
0.019577914848923683,
-0.008382616564631462,
-0.008613580837845802,
-0.010393458418548107,
-0.0017800205387175083,
0.02380833588540554,
0.08412189036607742,
0.0033635192085057497,
-0.038548544049263,
0.006663464941084385,
-0.0034193433821201324,
0.011743218638002872,
-0.008032131940126419,
0.05394086614251137,
-0.021077647805213928,
-0.012168214656412601,
-0.011553134769201279,
-0.016339724883437157,
0.023022981360554695,
0.01800350844860077,
-0.008045495487749577,
-0.03215133398771286,
-0.037840280681848526,
-0.024890610948204994,
-0.02033814787864685,
0.07649055868387222,
0.017920272424817085,
0.02017279341816902,
-0.009921782650053501
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:38
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"I have always anticipated that there will be one settlement in stages" and that:-
"...there would be two stages to one settlement".
565Mr Hilliard said that when he drafted the TressCox Caveat Undertaking he thought that:-
"...the events would take place in a very short space of time at the same settlement, same occasion."
566However he agreed that it was "hypothetically possible" that Stage 2 might not happen until months after Stage 1.
3 August 2004 - Thirteenth Representation
567This representation is that:-
* Mr Renshall would approach the new funder to finalise arrangements and documentation for the funding (expected to exceed $12 million) and a transfer of equity to the new funder; and
* these arrangements would be completed in the next two weeks.
568This representation arises from a letter sent by Mr Gillard to Mr Hilliard dated 3 August 2004.
569Mr Gillard's letter of 3 August 2004 read:-
"Robert Renshall will now approach the new funder to finalise arrangements and documentation for the funding (expected to exceed $12,000 [sic]) an equity take up of the unitholders position. We would except those arrangements to come into place in the next two weeks".
570It is common ground that the reference to "$12,000" was intended by Mr Gillard to be $12 million.
571In cross-examination, Mr Renshall said that he was "hoping" (rather than "expecting") that this is what would happen.
Sydney Finance Co Pty Limited
572Also on 3 August 2004, Mr Frederick made contact with a Mr Peter Clayton concerning a meeting about a "letter of offer for Huntley".
573Mr Frederick said that Mr Clayton was associated with Sydney Finance Co Pty Limited ("Sydney Finance").
574Sydney Finance was one of a number of financiers with whom Mr Frederick, Mr Moir and Mr Hanna were negotiating concerning possible finance for HTT.
575On 12 August 2004 Mr Moir sent Mr Renshall a "2nd mortgage offer" from Sydney Finance.
576Mr Moir's email read:-
"As discussed, attached is the 2nd mortgage offer. David [Hickie] has already signed it and I have drawn a trust cheque from available funds to pay the application fee ($5,000).
The establishment fee payable to Sydney Finance Co P/L is 1%, however, we had to go through a couple of people to get to them and the total brokerage is 5%(...)
I am seeing the Sydney Finance guy at 12 noon today. I have asked him to have the lender's lawyers instructed asap so that documentation can be ready this week (ideally). The site visit is expected to be tomorrow and I will keep you informed of developments."
577There was a PDF attachment to that email which, I would infer, was the "2nd mortgage offer".
578That document is not in evidence as Mr Renshall was not able to locate it.
579Although this email describes the establishment of $5000 as being "1%" (suggesting a loan of $500,000), the evidence was that the loan proposed from Sydney Finance was to be $4.5 million.
580This assumes significance in light of later events. Accordingly, I shall set out here Mr Renshall's evidence as to his understanding in relation to the proposed $4.5 million loan.
$4.5 million from Sydney Finance
581Mr Renshall said in cross-examination that Mr Hanna told him, on dates he could not recall, that approximately $4.5 million was available through Sydney Finance and that, at some time, Mr Hanna told him that the loan had been "put in place". Mr Renshall said he believed the $4.5 million was "going forward".
582Mr Renshall said he understood that the loan would be made to HTT and secured by a second mortgage to be given by HTT to Sydney Finance over the Land.
583Mr Renshall said that:-
"We paid an application fee with Sydney Finance for a loan, and that was my understanding from Mr Hanna that that was going ahead."
584Mr Renshall said:-
|
[
-0.028535977005958557,
0.007504759822040796,
-0.027704324573278427,
0.0278953667730093,
0.0030424417927861214,
-0.025533044710755348,
-0.0023376105818897486,
0.0030078627169132233,
0.015740428119897842,
0.007117306347936392,
0.025425927713513374,
0.05212213844060898,
-0.010551461949944496,
0.00580077338963747,
-0.0233581755310297,
0.0011987549951300025,
0.018034648150205612,
-0.03474707156419754,
0.05032262206077576,
-0.005755122750997543,
-0.029957549646496773,
-0.02112524025142193,
0.006256867665797472,
0.012814825400710106,
-0.006112509407103062,
0.028089864179491997,
-0.03648030757904053,
0.025060053914785385,
0.04010855033993721,
0.03560889512300491,
0.006881893612444401,
0.003578809555619955,
0.02767481468617916,
0.03026515617966652,
0.004032693337649107,
0.001463990192860365,
0.004730579908937216,
-0.013682791963219643,
-0.03526381775736809,
0.03848794847726822,
-0.01819106563925743,
-0.0036528552882373333,
0.016318581998348236,
0.001404701848514378,
0.05364105477929115,
-0.028586918488144875,
-0.005924996454268694,
-0.011772172525525093,
0.02880777232348919,
0.003095424734055996,
-0.029442252591252327,
-0.0484800860285759,
0.0386069230735302,
0.002239892026409507,
-0.0172588974237442,
-0.006860594265162945,
-0.019813349470496178,
0.0008198160794563591,
-0.0396873913705349,
-0.0015151703264564276,
-0.008268404752016068,
0.00252224737778306,
-0.07065606862306595,
-0.016619311645627022,
-0.008704833686351776,
0.06456564366817474,
0.00813928060233593,
-0.009830694645643234,
0.011672323569655418,
-0.01978050172328949,
-0.02767186239361763,
-0.021253937855362892,
-0.01133545208722353,
-0.010560750961303711,
-0.07850059866905212,
0.005568155087530613,
0.047152478247880936,
0.018708491697907448,
0.0019888312090188265,
0.025530239567160606,
0.04244972765445709,
-0.019279254600405693,
-0.030528908595442772,
0.013646685518324375,
-0.021642418578267097,
0.005923155229538679,
0.017552971839904785,
0.05121643841266632,
0.02370772883296013,
-0.021640650928020477,
-0.0111213568598032,
0.040358223021030426,
0.047792404890060425,
-0.04758696258068085,
-0.00933774746954441,
-0.009491955861449242,
-0.07124094665050507,
0.05886708199977875,
0.0019001482287421823,
0.025783618912100792,
0.0031336601823568344,
0.011887521483004093,
-0.0036541291046887636,
-0.018128259107470512,
-0.00736693199723959,
0.05291518568992615,
0.016975553706288338,
0.01936349831521511,
0.005534656811505556,
-0.017878469079732895,
0.013975298032164574,
-0.015462338924407959,
0.006891302764415741,
0.007710368372499943,
-0.015831543132662773,
-0.007862362079322338,
0.004198328126221895,
0.011919043958187103,
0.023419516161084175,
0.0075943064875900745,
0.03592677041888237,
0.009034868329763412,
0.0536515936255455,
0.0011124323355033994,
-0.07429007440805435,
-0.010972435586154461,
-0.012276045978069305,
-0.02083517238497734,
0.020019864663481712,
-0.01709313876926899,
-0.021743714809417725,
0.015344493091106415,
-0.00839310698211193,
-0.029960641637444496,
-0.03460054099559784,
0.003936394117772579,
0.015555175952613354,
-0.004483560565859079,
0.03364749625325203,
-0.030870111659169197,
0.07037539780139923,
-0.006670105271041393,
-0.019584685564041138,
-0.04435887932777405,
0.009677840396761894,
-0.07327262312173843,
0.023726968094706535,
-0.014402486383914948,
0.008821814320981503,
0.04816291853785515,
0.02526635304093361,
0.0013268959010019898,
0.0014413672033697367,
0.01255546510219574,
0.025372158735990524,
-0.03471418842673302,
0.04181058332324028,
-0.04638953506946564,
0.029249457642436028,
0.05822260305285454,
-0.000814877450466156,
0.02202625572681427,
-0.041822951287031174,
-0.01787738874554634,
-0.010184683836996555,
-0.005060141906142235,
-0.010840258561074734,
0.042880237102508545,
-0.013727976009249687,
-0.034266289323568344,
-0.0010245859157294035,
-0.02370176836848259,
0.040780868381261826,
-0.008412040770053864,
0.015241667628288269,
0.021597089245915413,
0.09524065256118774,
0.00492675369605422,
0.03819067403674126,
-0.03062337450683117,
-0.054139986634254456,
0.06275157630443573,
-0.014650926925241947,
-0.028064964339137077,
-0.04661963880062103,
0.007616404443979263,
-0.0169375017285347,
-0.031727299094200134,
0.006632356904447079,
0.016607632860541344,
-0.0010719181736931205,
0.004053449258208275,
0.03318868577480316,
0.013479580171406269,
0.02905123308300972,
-0.002577846636995673,
0.028361676260828972,
-0.04466629773378372,
-0.006964169442653656,
-0.020195188000798225,
-0.04430161044001579,
0.029299680143594742,
0.04096547141671181,
-0.005135910585522652,
-0.024635041132569313,
-0.0017516077496111393,
-0.05153476819396019,
-0.0262173842638731,
0.014520637691020966,
-0.01941550336778164,
-0.0052527147345244884,
-0.019126076251268387,
-0.00795249454677105,
-0.017969908192753792,
-0.003559245029464364,
0.01839487999677658,
-0.01126916240900755,
0.019403088837862015,
-0.027211584150791168,
-0.03940057381987572,
-0.012797731906175613,
0.013420258648693562,
-0.01777300238609314,
-0.00484075304120779,
0.031354933977127075,
0.06563793122768402,
-0.042386770248413086,
0.01802886091172695,
-0.01097235269844532,
-0.043883394449949265,
-0.02058798260986805,
-0.005768206901848316,
0.03284309804439545,
-0.004023979417979717,
-0.0017568205948919058,
0.03961437568068504,
0.03638015687465668,
0.006450222805142403,
0.003097019623965025,
0.026953261345624924,
-0.027740314602851868,
0.021755868569016457,
0.002571636810898781,
-0.0008614227408543229,
-0.025175029411911964,
0.003529863664880395,
-0.00857093557715416,
0.010390670970082283,
0.00901659857481718,
-0.035306669771671295,
-0.021759996190667152,
0.020037485286593437,
-0.02144751138985157,
-0.00533642852678895,
0.012770403176546097,
0.011793655343353748,
0.013002436608076096,
0.0020156458485871553,
0.047562554478645325,
0.03591766953468323,
0.022058378905057907,
0.021036015823483467,
0.032938309013843536,
0.024427739903330803,
-0.00738272862508893,
-0.010542530566453934,
-0.05092315003275871,
-0.035622693598270416,
0.03762579336762428,
-0.0021774722263216972,
0.0032521283719688654,
0.020242689177393913,
0.0036000190302729607,
-0.00273043941706419,
0.03434623405337334,
0.039404045790433884,
0.040758538991212845,
0.01034625992178917,
0.00772374402731657,
0.02111118659377098,
0.016208086162805557,
0.0005409691366367042,
0.026188531890511513,
0.008861937560141087,
0.02042294479906559,
0.06725899875164032,
-0.01986652985215187,
-0.022055931389331818,
0.03561614081263542,
-0.017246486619114876,
-0.009076278656721115,
0.0017306864028796554,
0.06566742807626724,
-0.0034564188681542873,
-0.040299661457538605,
-0.02338245138525963,
-0.01340596005320549,
-0.16758599877357483,
0.01985032670199871,
-0.014649729244410992,
0.005965116433799267,
-0.00810164213180542,
0.023633282631635666,
-0.014377580024302006,
-0.013874901458621025,
-0.020992422476410866,
0.032001204788684845,
0.04488834738731384,
-0.05593214929103851,
-0.012619954533874989,
0.07582726329565048,
0.04231228679418564,
-0.01674315333366394,
-0.017977509647607803,
0.008639627136290073,
0.030152006074786186,
-0.031400538980960846,
-0.014974061399698257,
-0.05906112492084503,
0.04661323130130768,
-0.0007179831154644489,
0.012692248448729515,
0.020822227001190186,
-0.008893255144357681,
0.026783883571624756,
-0.04723752290010452,
-0.02957824058830738,
-0.01769437827169895,
0.00897694006562233,
-0.018515458330512047,
0.042384613305330276,
-0.013671808876097202,
0.06770403683185577,
0.08503822237253189,
-0.02989337593317032,
0.0025743490550667048,
-0.04662744328379631,
0.01899251900613308,
0.016834411770105362,
-0.007701708935201168,
-0.002246586373075843,
0.016239922493696213,
-0.05609685182571411,
0.008972438983619213,
0.019703315570950508,
0.025313638150691986,
0.007960616610944271,
0.0015758969821035862,
-0.01394024770706892,
-0.0387331023812294,
-0.02745894156396389,
-0.025187864899635315,
-0.02720506489276886,
0.029610052704811096,
0.03400999307632446,
-0.04597583785653114,
-0.021502841264009476,
-0.03239838778972626,
-0.0672096386551857,
0.038605209439992905,
0.023377813398838043,
-0.011901144869625568,
0.024826331064105034,
0.010524052195250988,
-0.04033149778842926,
0.017117386683821678,
0.014026054181158543,
0.02278408221900463,
-0.032604578882455826,
0.00540701812133193,
-0.010440480895340443,
0.04617852717638016,
0.03888801112771034,
-0.060947172343730927,
-0.006764653604477644,
-0.0358743891119957,
-0.11082889139652252,
0.0037713763304054737,
0.020492680370807648,
-0.038477133959531784,
0.024558722972869873,
-0.0022574029862880707,
0.005261930171400309,
-0.012657123617827892,
0.027773957699537277,
0.019081683829426765,
0.2343437373638153,
-0.006352247204631567,
0.018070833757519722,
0.05085570737719536,
0.02392827719449997,
-0.022334767505526543,
-0.0020342511124908924,
0.05159372091293335,
-0.021857837215065956,
-0.04615011066198349,
-0.01251184567809105,
-0.012276955880224705,
0.027300706133246422,
0.019609764218330383,
-0.010786115191876888,
0.036596450954675674,
-0.04580556973814964,
-0.024716082960367203,
0.05612233653664589,
0.02977793663740158,
0.07046736031770706,
-0.031404830515384674,
-0.011848696507513523,
0.006306909956037998,
-0.06354668736457825,
-0.038135185837745667,
-0.008926207199692726,
0.033467888832092285,
-0.024811111390590668,
-0.010539814829826355,
-0.016472293063998222,
-0.001008733524940908,
-0.0034347798209637403,
0.034660693258047104,
0.01330854557454586,
0.025255443528294563,
0.02230600267648697,
0.016658246517181396,
0.0015663948142901063,
0.07004084438085556,
0.012656436301767826,
-0.03045027330517769,
0.019421281293034554,
-0.07747111469507217,
-0.039758503437042236,
-0.025502409785985947,
-0.01004804577678442,
0.019342584535479546,
-0.05136632174253464,
0.0027825867291539907,
-0.023499315604567528,
0.016184989362955093,
-0.020710991695523262,
0.008849888108670712,
-0.002380324061959982,
0.03126182034611702,
0.0018943208269774914,
0.03746604919433594,
-0.03107885643839836,
0.04348582774400711,
-0.0018568069208413363,
0.019997216761112213,
-0.03139393404126167,
0.008522413671016693,
0.017349207773804665,
-0.04834891855716705,
-0.04278572276234627,
-0.029858946800231934,
0.017183858901262283,
0.06421192735433578,
0.016129769384860992,
0.007406715769320726,
0.005611393600702286,
-0.006877421867102385,
0.03721434250473976,
-0.020720431581139565,
-0.015883633866906166,
0.0024837316013872623,
-0.00603677611798048,
-0.004059042781591415,
-0.024953043088316917,
-0.04024634137749672,
-0.001122953137382865,
0.003919987007975578,
0.03742731735110283,
-0.014237440191209316,
-0.045756082981824875,
0.06492988765239716,
-0.006135024130344391,
-0.03387884423136711,
-0.03759363293647766,
-0.006355524994432926,
0.009273448027670383,
-0.02973136305809021,
0.0010859158355742693,
0.011157548055052757,
0.023224705830216408,
-0.023131931200623512,
-0.034142639487981796,
-0.0470660924911499,
-0.003637321526184678,
0.003305453574284911,
0.013106119818985462,
-0.04449741914868355,
0.042737409472465515,
-0.021776167675852776,
-0.018298739567399025,
-0.0025631349999457598,
-0.0747978687286377,
-0.029231498017907143,
-0.023384299129247665,
0.0057168928906321526,
0.012577486224472523,
-0.00740384217351675,
0.053291890770196915,
0.047846030443906784,
0.011368390172719955,
0.03131331503391266,
0.049317628145217896,
0.04930843040347099,
0.013079038821160793,
-0.011611126363277435,
-0.05642201751470566,
0.006447634194046259,
-0.004846295341849327,
0.012463838793337345,
-0.017428399994969368,
-0.020807823166251183,
0.017002802342176437,
-0.014851991087198257,
0.012097594328224659,
-0.04973733797669411,
-0.02910432405769825,
0.01699092797935009,
0.049552321434020996,
0.04558725655078888,
0.018191389739513397,
0.0005984719609841704,
-0.042287591844797134,
0.004246617201715708,
-0.04279136285185814,
0.003143815789371729,
-0.016340347006917,
-0.03701925277709961,
-0.00798265915364027,
0.009284810163080692,
-0.0820978432893753,
0.005131457932293415,
-0.01587170735001564,
0.02361847460269928,
-0.0031955393496900797,
0.043927744030952454,
-0.06950798630714417,
-0.025839658454060555,
0.03150860220193863,
0.01941768452525139,
-0.012534389272332191,
-0.00017010544252116233,
0.019616801291704178,
-0.020796246826648712,
0.013778220862150192,
-0.007019224110990763,
-0.0009075183188542724,
0.015192343853414059,
-0.007794667966663837,
0.02513582818210125,
-0.01578417420387268,
0.04419880732893944,
0.031820908188819885,
-0.0517762117087841,
0.0008060911204665899,
-0.024304544553160667,
-0.02893775701522827,
0.06875146180391312,
0.016624024137854576,
0.004547046031802893,
0.00012116891593905166,
0.030513403937220573,
0.022855723276734352,
-0.03067166544497013,
0.015989501029253006,
-0.008703785017132759,
-0.019822407513856888,
-0.029834801331162453,
0.012246355414390564,
0.000947769673075527,
0.020146964117884636,
-0.025978771969676018,
0.00041108994628302753,
-0.0791482925415039,
-0.014365235343575478,
0.08036202937364578,
0.02125210128724575,
-0.039162252098321915,
-0.013322937302291393,
0.018320288509130478,
-0.023081280291080475,
0.03458709642291069,
0.0007274741656146944,
0.0034388587810099125,
-0.05519580841064453,
-0.0028193192556500435,
0.015491688624024391,
0.006033963058143854,
0.031184004619717598,
0.002515192376449704,
-0.006223773118108511,
0.02590867504477501,
-0.0549033023416996,
-0.01726657897233963,
0.01786161959171295,
-0.0018428654875606298,
-0.004507410805672407,
0.03755943104624748,
-0.0025110545102506876,
-0.047596849501132965,
0.04262780398130417,
0.06489842385053635,
-0.017598560079932213,
-0.04610404744744301,
-0.004065373912453651,
-0.03152212128043175,
-0.008047553710639477,
-0.05466414988040924,
-0.011612778529524803,
0.009243636392056942,
-0.043276168406009674,
-0.025216873735189438,
-0.04392955079674721,
-0.0016734905075281858,
-0.0028822242747992277,
-0.061631619930267334,
0.04014550521969795,
-0.04689311608672142,
0.03520346060395241,
-0.008540158160030842,
0.0318838506937027,
0.011353961192071438,
0.0466756597161293,
-0.01606782339513302,
0.041146621108055115,
0.006942254491150379,
0.022774888202548027,
0.0437234602868557,
0.014718455262482166,
-0.010741449892520905,
-0.018017444759607315,
-0.031453657895326614,
0.016027212142944336,
0.05467808246612549,
0.01780272088944912,
0.02097153849899769,
-0.01901092566549778,
-0.00973474234342575,
0.0234434362500906,
0.002783405128866434,
0.006297360640019178,
-0.038559503853321075,
-0.019985880702733994,
-0.06522586196660995,
-0.00171004724688828,
-0.012997989542782307,
0.0037991232238709927,
-0.024038752540946007,
-0.029617775231599808,
-0.07312597334384918,
0.024295276030898094,
-0.025951994583010674,
-0.029480140656232834,
0.0002470334293320775,
-0.021571874618530273,
-0.022090982645750046,
-0.0028522624634206295,
-0.015596384182572365,
0.013478424400091171,
0.00879606418311596,
-0.008787008933722973,
-0.01908208429813385,
0.051429446786642075,
-0.0019604810513556004,
-0.01650368981063366,
-0.0003873803361784667,
0.048213545233011246,
0.0012579078320413828,
-0.05786538124084473,
0.014363857917487621,
0.013287150301039219,
-0.00022746833565179259,
-0.004024623427540064,
-0.016566939651966095,
0.00990934669971466,
-0.003657643450424075,
0.004715031012892723,
0.035807736217975616,
-0.014965999871492386,
-0.037910982966423035,
0.007451626472175121,
0.0008559076231904328,
-0.03939928486943245,
0.03674055263400078,
-0.031906165182590485,
-0.01322739478200674,
-0.02608039416372776,
-0.017130976542830467,
-0.02027055248618126,
0.020772038027644157,
-0.024169087409973145,
-0.0047989534214138985,
-0.01497963722795248,
0.017232947051525116,
0.005864640232175589,
-0.09131381660699844,
0.003928371239453554,
0.014392176643013954,
0.013760017231106758,
0.02006313018500805,
0.023898079991340637,
0.003778344951570034,
-0.03948396444320679,
0.008045741356909275,
-0.027937976643443108,
0.010098466649651527,
-0.03729052469134331,
-0.011839659884572029,
-0.031732358038425446,
0.003029052633792162,
0.03746848925948143,
-0.063878633081913,
-0.054892390966415405,
0.04837745055556297,
-0.02129950188100338,
-0.021846039220690727,
-0.0005976695101708174,
0.024309035390615463,
0.0026872046291828156,
0.008813450112938881,
0.0070517417043447495,
-0.006398945581167936,
0.01799701154232025,
-0.020306652411818504,
-0.012055899947881699,
-0.04702932387590408,
0.07627556473016739,
0.0019640557002276182,
0.027949364855885506,
0.021781744435429573,
-0.005279402248561382,
0.010962141677737236,
0.02442530170083046,
0.02415589615702629,
0.012361032888293266,
0.031155923381447792,
-0.02945413626730442,
-0.026246683672070503,
0.012871696613729,
-0.011409938335418701,
-0.007109019905328751,
0.0027816807851195335,
0.013770624063909054,
-0.015891749411821365,
-0.011932719498872757,
0.013778774999082088,
-0.00695296935737133,
-0.04691355675458908,
-0.032896965742111206,
-0.000987637904472649,
0.003125079208984971,
0.024466972798109055,
-0.00738881528377533,
0.015943793579936028,
0.005726738832890987,
-0.02070862241089344,
0.022532884031534195,
0.005305850878357887,
-0.027783334255218506,
0.027122898027300835,
0.01445101946592331,
0.002452980959787965,
-0.00017739592294674367,
-0.0564899817109108,
-0.01736770011484623,
-0.014535903930664062,
-0.026343313977122307,
-0.041075825691223145,
0.02862975373864174,
-0.01726306416094303,
-0.04870854690670967,
0.030145801603794098,
0.025503555312752724,
0.028844410553574562,
-0.01521263737231493,
-0.005166019778698683,
-0.030469289049506187,
-0.019440054893493652,
-0.14763325452804565,
0.03406006097793579,
0.02548978663980961,
-0.03214205428957939,
-0.0444953590631485,
0.001112941070459783,
-0.03786151111125946,
0.023366747424006462,
-0.046439770609140396,
0.008223957382142544,
0.006260568741708994,
0.0048327092081308365,
-0.017821716144680977,
-0.010468875989317894,
-0.01627112179994583,
0.03320448473095894,
-0.036996740847826004,
-0.009172395803034306,
-0.07921023666858673,
-0.005418146960437298,
0.013617999851703644,
0.0043123625218868256,
0.0013944830279797316,
0.0338066890835762,
0.007224629167467356,
-0.0031674904748797417,
0.028276681900024414,
-0.08105042576789856,
-0.029725894331932068,
-0.015797846019268036,
-0.05224967002868652,
-0.020395899191498756,
-0.0024018476251512766,
0.09953298419713974,
-0.00005181971573620103,
0.025944102555513382,
0.018283892422914505,
-0.00921601615846157,
-0.052745986729860306,
-0.014219710603356361,
-0.005109598394483328,
0.04852573201060295,
-0.0015924745239317417,
-0.046226635575294495,
-0.00006869972276035696,
0.008737285621464252,
-0.03194968402385712,
-0.026500467211008072,
-0.03699945658445358,
-0.06478627026081085,
-0.059053972363471985,
0.02985331043601036,
0.018132416531443596,
0.018474290147423744,
-0.0027195888105779886,
-0.004860331304371357,
0.029175417497754097,
-0.034787099808454514,
0.037792034447193146,
0.06757243722677231,
0.02963070571422577,
0.025526138022542,
-0.022398021072149277,
-0.001844407757744193,
-0.0265554990619421,
-0.00853192713111639,
0.014172337017953396,
-0.014526902697980404,
0.01128083560615778,
0.03779088705778122,
-0.02429443970322609,
-0.032490428537130356,
-0.018217355012893677,
-0.029289044439792633,
0.01300076488405466,
-0.037460941821336746,
-0.018068494275212288,
0.02715297043323517,
-0.038304876536130905,
-0.018033934757113457,
-0.014044501818716526,
0.009867521934211254,
-0.03073309361934662,
0.0059611559845507145,
0.08576833456754684,
0.04306534677743912,
-0.012708095833659172,
-0.011609336361289024,
0.004520983900874853,
-0.005248656962066889,
-0.056749701499938965,
-0.013786597177386284,
0.010076703503727913,
0.03037528321146965,
-0.023209482431411743,
0.030058976262807846,
0.015071031637489796,
-0.00963067077100277,
-0.03696988523006439,
0.004557066131383181,
-0.015778381377458572,
0.0026711514219641685,
-0.022095128893852234,
-0.01052980124950409,
-0.023988908156752586,
0.007916031405329704,
0.051974549889564514,
0.017724229022860527,
0.016037750989198685,
-0.03262408822774887,
-0.01056603342294693,
-0.008233456872403622,
-0.026733534410595894,
0.026201287284493446,
-0.05904997140169144,
0.013748159632086754,
0.005986928008496761,
0.030357198789715767,
0.005138791166245937,
-0.007286805659532547,
0.022572457790374756,
0.038805507123470306,
0.010735335759818554,
-0.02363497205078602,
0.035406965762376785,
-0.015548682771623135,
0.025610512122511864,
0.015244046226143837,
0.025745244696736336,
-0.019311361014842987,
0.04724987596273422,
0.007588164880871773,
0.029522184282541275,
0.01593003235757351,
0.018928993493318558,
0.003815885167568922,
-0.034194570034742355,
0.024295277893543243,
-0.06230786442756653,
-0.04234855994582176,
0.023463698104023933,
-0.005973628722131252,
0.005372206214815378,
0.008189116604626179,
-0.04691775143146515,
-0.025287143886089325,
0.04879692569375038,
-0.0034112411085516214,
0.003655460197478533,
0.0032499385997653008,
-0.03163832798600197,
-0.020662320777773857,
-0.010640841908752918,
0.05809144303202629,
0.033382222056388855,
0.02458866871893406,
0.028783591464161873,
0.007859688252210617,
0.025229541584849358,
0.04309028759598732,
-0.01015146542340517,
-0.01866861619055271,
-0.03904807195067406,
-0.0692618191242218,
-0.008434651419520378,
0.0359942801296711,
-0.027281831949949265,
0.02686496078968048,
-0.008394425734877586,
-0.02677333727478981,
-0.010723517276346684,
0.020201215520501137,
-0.00833156704902649,
0.010616532526910305,
0.038479283452034,
0.0036072186194360256,
-0.0057419766671955585,
-0.004911981988698244,
0.0602748766541481,
-0.010173614136874676,
0.05826269090175629,
0.0351095125079155,
0.02343786507844925,
0.019318901002407074,
0.03227097913622856,
0.04466690868139267,
0.006901960354298353,
0.021580349653959274,
-0.028276871889829636,
-0.04605576768517494,
0.010965039022266865,
-0.012507962994277477,
0.024670757353305817,
-0.017685014754533768,
0.049636874347925186,
-0.004847805947065353,
-0.0031128856353461742,
-0.0076685152016580105,
0.0019762548618018627,
0.012318715453147888,
0.006370260380208492,
-0.039035942405462265,
-0.023331675678491592,
0.014110641553997993,
-0.04590988904237747,
0.017741547897458076,
0.010243384167551994,
-0.08036927133798599,
-0.07212293148040771,
0.03942745923995972,
-0.009470075368881226,
-0.03060067817568779,
-0.03074643574655056,
0.00870508886873722,
-0.013724875636398792,
0.0355645976960659,
0.029287533834576607,
-0.009894573129713535,
0.04873787611722946,
-0.054369352757930756,
0.04826781153678894,
0.05047117546200752,
-0.05087558552622795,
-0.004740454256534576,
-0.0013631571782752872,
-0.013708568178117275,
-0.017947442829608917,
-0.015459210611879826,
-0.0046721394173800945,
0.011383271776139736,
-0.028833666816353798,
0.0016023365315049887,
0.02972641959786415,
0.051114827394485474,
0.02274678833782673,
-0.04499074071645737,
-0.008997456170618534,
-0.017103934660553932,
-0.017395716160535812,
0.012612954713404179,
0.038019679486751556,
-0.001530684414319694,
0.012882118113338947,
-0.014080898836255074
] |
What was the expected amount of funding from the new funder, according to Mr Gillard's letter of 3 August 2004?
|
[
-0.056077178567647934,
0.005929379723966122,
-0.03877163678407669,
0.0027729070279747248,
0.006142925936728716,
-0.010978051461279392,
-0.02347315475344658,
-0.034474123269319534,
0.015825847163796425,
0.011512932367622852,
0.005092091392725706,
0.043253343552351,
0.002823383780196309,
-0.02194313518702984,
-0.015443798154592514,
-0.017771927639842033,
0.03730732575058937,
-0.020505165681242943,
0.024251148104667664,
-0.052183836698532104,
-0.0032353342976421118,
0.0021596872247755527,
-0.011655469425022602,
0.027639541774988174,
-0.015475327149033546,
-0.020082049071788788,
-0.02299446426331997,
0.01816794089972973,
0.005829403176903725,
0.028708387166261673,
0.006985294166952372,
0.009518665261566639,
0.043408460915088654,
0.03675910085439682,
0.02621876448392868,
-0.019433118402957916,
0.0415305532515049,
-0.006041102577000856,
-0.049522437155246735,
0.03559523820877075,
0.005513609386980534,
0.03481421619653702,
-0.014706497080624104,
-0.002179885283112526,
0.015775159001350403,
-0.035269249230623245,
-0.006835159379988909,
0.002244127681478858,
0.06383299827575684,
0.013090753927826881,
-0.008235175162553787,
-0.04579358175396919,
0.003048175247386098,
-0.03784065321087837,
0.00958231370896101,
0.008456749841570854,
-0.013496940955519676,
0.007458030246198177,
0.015978578478097916,
-0.02135612815618515,
-0.022751033306121826,
-0.01755983754992485,
-0.06021369993686676,
0.029876021668314934,
0.0433974415063858,
0.056486211717128754,
-0.001158889732323587,
-0.032842520624399185,
-0.012012341991066933,
0.008881240151822567,
-0.044461023062467575,
0.0015061314916238189,
0.02824590541422367,
0.025821179151535034,
-0.08036171644926071,
0.012373126111924648,
-0.0011660167947411537,
-0.04403620958328247,
0.014893744140863419,
-0.006011991761624813,
0.031184900552034378,
-0.06545919179916382,
-0.002532615792006254,
0.02274579554796219,
-0.018856175243854523,
0.017267517745494843,
0.022838275879621506,
0.023490987718105316,
0.01554115116596222,
-0.0043944003991782665,
-0.01036629918962717,
0.038147494196891785,
0.013605523854494095,
-0.06056268513202667,
-0.062480852007865906,
0.003846888430416584,
-0.03358331322669983,
0.04528924450278282,
0.0010850296821445227,
0.0007411804399453104,
-0.0034930137917399406,
0.04412929713726044,
-0.021751688793301582,
-0.032705627381801605,
0.017048263922333717,
0.009530949406325817,
0.016223782673478127,
-0.01699027605354786,
-0.033507656306028366,
-0.020455943420529366,
-0.05077194422483444,
0.004635896533727646,
0.022047707810997963,
-0.005236739292740822,
-0.04069610312581062,
0.01321424636989832,
-0.033125195652246475,
0.01641634851694107,
0.009356068447232246,
-0.02926197089254856,
0.019116399809718132,
0.01921149156987667,
0.05605417117476463,
0.014820262789726257,
-0.030062608420848846,
-0.031773217022418976,
0.01174202561378479,
-0.05017847567796707,
0.030544186010956764,
0.05155682936310768,
-0.020746123045682907,
0.031961847096681595,
0.0029615359380841255,
-0.018551163375377655,
0.01542187761515379,
0.012389360927045345,
0.06331735104322433,
-0.001489168149419129,
0.013651004061102867,
-0.000009801482519833371,
-0.0001336314162472263,
0.030504755675792694,
-0.0008121775463223457,
-0.03882522135972977,
0.013686075806617737,
-0.007353461347520351,
0.0011153429513797164,
-0.013454105705022812,
-0.017084132879972458,
0.026597121730446815,
-0.004437051713466644,
-0.04803472012281418,
0.023516960442066193,
-0.016584156081080437,
0.039442215114831924,
-0.02364102005958557,
0.018682997673749924,
-0.06822187453508377,
-0.016265869140625,
0.051313310861587524,
-0.04744456335902214,
0.024240804836153984,
0.005708792712539434,
-0.04206749051809311,
-0.007545093540102243,
0.026991745457053185,
0.04272091016173363,
0.03397731855511665,
-0.001679765060544014,
-0.0033453397918492556,
0.014685227535665035,
-0.04897468909621239,
0.03181077167391777,
0.02987167052924633,
0.000718065828550607,
0.01533858198672533,
0.05206575244665146,
-0.00463838642463088,
0.001325736753642559,
-0.04754740744829178,
-0.02409900538623333,
0.060844358056783676,
0.01058952696621418,
-0.029452381655573845,
-0.019532999023795128,
0.02946375496685505,
-0.035777315497398376,
-0.01938183419406414,
0.01731732115149498,
0.005872934125363827,
-0.032440584152936935,
0.02585260197520256,
-0.024121101945638657,
0.03918502479791641,
-0.00750251580029726,
-0.00010467352694831789,
0.020717309787869453,
-0.016133684664964676,
-0.01638028956949711,
-0.03397220000624657,
-0.031992241740226746,
0.019790474325418472,
0.05720993131399155,
-0.006361043080687523,
-0.01663433015346527,
-0.024655424058437347,
0.010454392991960049,
0.0015607457607984543,
-0.03708955645561218,
-0.037245918065309525,
-0.06516119837760925,
0.014798241667449474,
0.01180021557956934,
0.0035908713471144438,
-0.002730518812313676,
-0.0121895931661129,
0.007252132054418325,
0.025836579501628876,
-0.004075917880982161,
-0.003613941138610244,
0.003293415764346719,
0.016955429688096046,
-0.00712507264688611,
-0.012624964118003845,
-0.0023772581480443478,
0.06465435773134232,
-0.02891986072063446,
0.020391669124364853,
-0.003542970633134246,
-0.017494522035121918,
0.0007438926841132343,
-0.056374695152044296,
-0.03145749121904373,
-0.0167067963629961,
-0.0019303344888612628,
0.04582153260707855,
0.03914671763777733,
0.004476346541196108,
-0.0009085815981961787,
-0.0028113212902098894,
-0.013658472336828709,
-0.037367790937423706,
-0.05663019418716431,
0.01063492801040411,
-0.0016722592990845442,
0.038026899099349976,
-0.02432597428560257,
0.048419103026390076,
0.0208758395165205,
0.0012379693798720837,
0.02377675659954548,
-0.006428658030927181,
0.0034076126758009195,
0.022508669644594193,
-0.005411108490079641,
0.03665345162153244,
0.011318445205688477,
-0.007026470731943846,
0.011275255121290684,
-0.017549948766827583,
-0.009313137270510197,
0.008706426247954369,
0.02130540832877159,
0.039708513766527176,
0.034338463097810745,
0.006000643130391836,
-0.035237040370702744,
-0.06880522519350052,
-0.009245729073882103,
-0.017101602628827095,
0.012058581225574017,
0.010210306383669376,
0.01511336863040924,
0.03184192255139351,
0.009157694876194,
0.039721082895994186,
-0.009772295132279396,
0.018060188740491867,
-0.014667857438325882,
0.026475192978978157,
0.002255671191960573,
0.026828588917851448,
0.024795006960630417,
0.005111363250762224,
0.02690005861222744,
0.016304653137922287,
-0.013514714315533638,
-0.010580155067145824,
-0.020391451194882393,
-0.028830839321017265,
-0.05425671488046646,
0.009174827486276627,
0.056381694972515106,
-0.027957942336797714,
-0.0387316457927227,
-0.029639186337590218,
-0.002995746675878763,
-0.14934948086738586,
-0.02468305267393589,
-0.018595010042190552,
0.026115264743566513,
0.013190762139856815,
0.004787642974406481,
-0.02291041985154152,
0.012943027541041374,
-0.05350234732031822,
-0.03453640267252922,
-0.008307293057441711,
-0.03441958501935005,
-0.00524640828371048,
0.05802815780043602,
-0.012518944218754768,
0.01642695628106594,
-0.04772975668311119,
0.008431822061538696,
0.0011252237018197775,
-0.02945627085864544,
-0.003998791798949242,
-0.048826225101947784,
0.021709943190217018,
0.0008252220577560365,
0.014985415153205395,
0.03514542058110237,
-0.009220017120242119,
0.012949674390256405,
-0.047763098031282425,
-0.0008872037287801504,
-0.014922413975000381,
0.053734514862298965,
-0.0008749021799303591,
0.04456011578440666,
-0.0014250760432332754,
0.04039129987359047,
0.04852408915758133,
-0.008280079811811447,
-0.013383310288190842,
-0.032435543835163116,
-0.001880922820419073,
0.032164499163627625,
0.0022748401388525963,
0.018601302057504654,
0.02607378177344799,
-0.05375344306230545,
-0.04805147647857666,
0.03309042379260063,
0.008468879386782646,
0.022608445957303047,
0.0010190060129389167,
0.003105798503383994,
-0.012106123380362988,
-0.04075733944773674,
-0.013048073276877403,
-0.02934536151587963,
-0.009316913783550262,
0.04492466151714325,
-0.008509143255650997,
0.004572128877043724,
-0.0011997107649222016,
-0.04978584125638008,
0.027400679886341095,
0.01363160740584135,
-0.016746779903769493,
0.05775954946875572,
0.006205984391272068,
-0.025369377806782722,
0.02114812470972538,
0.028658583760261536,
0.011009562760591507,
0.024451935663819313,
0.007167466916143894,
-0.03226860240101814,
0.03973591327667236,
0.035566285252571106,
-0.04041774943470955,
-0.05989516153931618,
-0.007826446555554867,
-0.08988173305988312,
-0.005123273469507694,
0.03108087368309498,
0.01706547848880291,
-0.013019117526710033,
0.0006757097435183823,
-0.00876605324447155,
0.00986821111291647,
0.05400548130273819,
0.0357421450316906,
0.20840643346309662,
-0.031102916225790977,
0.017378056421875954,
0.0678657591342926,
-0.000514694896992296,
-0.04513917118310928,
-0.008302677422761917,
-0.0021458184346556664,
-0.015454232692718506,
-0.03591868653893471,
-0.013845639303326607,
-0.025262463837862015,
0.012221390381455421,
-0.006125236861407757,
0.024052027612924576,
0.051281530410051346,
-0.0728597342967987,
-0.012336835265159607,
0.06851587444543839,
0.028190789744257927,
0.053163014352321625,
-0.02078227885067463,
-0.019423307850956917,
0.003730327356606722,
-0.04357295110821724,
-0.050313036888837814,
0.04811688885092735,
0.05997014418244362,
-0.010593419894576073,
-0.011687119491398335,
0.014941132627427578,
-0.008512287400662899,
0.008246068842709064,
0.040449585765600204,
0.030839046463370323,
-0.007868454791605473,
0.0008247123914770782,
0.0006392056820914149,
0.022436056286096573,
-0.0013929653214290738,
0.015990639105439186,
-0.07041512429714203,
0.015443714335560799,
-0.059553973376750946,
-0.08633066713809967,
-0.02797294780611992,
-0.02520735189318657,
0.005119876004755497,
-0.05702745169401169,
-0.0368170440196991,
-0.012785795144736767,
0.033492397516965866,
-0.022079847753047943,
0.01685960963368416,
-0.01481917779892683,
0.02550431899726391,
-0.009123205207288265,
0.007594976108521223,
-0.04083941876888275,
0.030226202681660652,
0.00010997320350725204,
-0.009678101167082787,
0.0005626438651233912,
0.009413909167051315,
-0.0018035484245046973,
-0.03347652405500412,
-0.002363635925576091,
-0.033366698771715164,
-0.02512519806623459,
0.036910198628902435,
-0.04873659834265709,
-0.005557682365179062,
-0.0047858296893537045,
0.0043426272459328175,
-0.008249189704656601,
0.04293258115649223,
-0.036126911640167236,
0.05122311785817146,
-0.0041479384526610374,
-0.018716908991336823,
0.019575685262680054,
-0.005423433147370815,
0.0021747376304119825,
0.003289000364020467,
0.04778259992599487,
0.009619628079235554,
-0.031152283772826195,
0.021837441250681877,
-0.0009503875044174492,
-0.02699214592576027,
-0.028825392946600914,
-0.012165497057139874,
0.003223119070753455,
-0.049359481781721115,
0.014647994190454483,
-0.024858100339770317,
0.06148258596658707,
0.007785181514918804,
-0.09742464125156403,
-0.049673762172460556,
-0.026304492726922035,
0.007723550777882338,
-0.00788129959255457,
-0.009878018870949745,
0.03622598201036453,
0.015577445738017559,
-0.06482371687889099,
0.00009092702384805307,
-0.03565893694758415,
0.018486080691218376,
-0.007512659765779972,
-0.002624638145789504,
-0.004121745470911264,
0.002751091495156288,
0.025171423330903053,
0.050513602793216705,
0.021222954615950584,
-0.00472221290692687,
0.013489384204149246,
-0.0045572491362690926,
-0.0029668675269931555,
-0.019891541451215744,
0.003241192316636443,
0.043338850140571594,
-0.06330182403326035,
0.046339258551597595,
0.010298440232872963,
-0.024049919098615646,
0.011640342883765697,
-0.009664434008300304,
0.012430453673005104,
-0.004927345551550388,
0.010962792672216892,
0.02256869338452816,
0.06005626171827316,
0.05334128066897392,
0.008085687644779682,
-0.04934180900454521,
-0.023620575666427612,
0.05864262580871582,
0.03658639267086983,
0.02283490262925625,
-0.010586126707494259,
-0.001065787160769105,
0.005836538504809141,
-0.02674432098865509,
-0.013798869214951992,
0.06083568185567856,
0.0006594592705368996,
0.03906455636024475,
-0.028191981837153435,
0.032411180436611176,
-0.037836477160453796,
-0.026797259226441383,
-0.0071031381376087666,
0.039386630058288574,
0.0031387791968882084,
0.0063749938271939754,
0.0016794089460745454,
-0.017006894573569298,
0.005817030556499958,
-0.01605202630162239,
0.017222819849848747,
0.0676368698477745,
-0.004489260725677013,
0.015537681058049202,
-0.06512755900621414,
0.051234856247901917,
0.040552202612161636,
-0.07352388650178909,
-0.003983393311500549,
0.008940101601183414,
-0.017924653366208076,
0.037724416702985764,
-0.007668644189834595,
0.020856183022260666,
0.02949438989162445,
0.06998366117477417,
0.024463577196002007,
-0.0060539464466273785,
0.05956348404288292,
-0.01897815801203251,
-0.003908665385097265,
-0.0914064347743988,
0.002304084599018097,
0.003882984397932887,
0.015925973653793335,
-0.01332407258450985,
-0.026302548125386238,
-0.024902934208512306,
0.004019643180072308,
0.025587420910596848,
-0.018671691417694092,
-0.021541666239500046,
-0.040240123867988586,
-0.005009579472243786,
-0.0318993516266346,
0.011079899035394192,
-0.034635402262210846,
0.004190988838672638,
-0.018223678693175316,
-0.00408400921151042,
0.039640966802835464,
-0.06316930800676346,
0.0067717707715928555,
0.03131476417183876,
0.031206786632537842,
0.014202197082340717,
-0.05153369903564453,
-0.029789527878165245,
0.009328240528702736,
0.01764507219195366,
0.023630743846297264,
0.016366245225071907,
0.017865585163235664,
-0.04465756192803383,
-0.034511540085077286,
0.015872228890657425,
-0.008015191182494164,
-0.03901144862174988,
0.03531679883599281,
-0.010625258088111877,
0.013393676839768887,
-0.04097701981663704,
-0.015229607000946999,
0.01355341263115406,
-0.0535242073237896,
-0.03265239670872688,
-0.04209308326244354,
-0.023194197565317154,
0.004050017334520817,
-0.05782541632652283,
-0.00020578772819135338,
-0.050780199468135834,
0.04650002345442772,
0.027096521109342575,
0.018902335315942764,
-0.01247525867074728,
0.022365521639585495,
-0.00616233516484499,
0.0055875033140182495,
-0.06357752531766891,
-0.04798620939254761,
0.0376104936003685,
0.007796003948897123,
0.0161623302847147,
0.017172031104564667,
0.016048558056354523,
-0.015123771503567696,
0.027748029679059982,
-0.002302990760654211,
0.016445482149720192,
-0.01392100378870964,
0.009313834831118584,
-0.03520810604095459,
-0.006190894171595573,
-0.02084396220743656,
-0.03245706483721733,
-0.032388750463724136,
-0.03861532732844353,
0.01870514452457428,
-0.02853318490087986,
-0.013167540542781353,
-0.027019843459129333,
-0.03626151755452156,
-0.030531756579875946,
0.020751411095261574,
-0.006707720458507538,
-0.010376504622399807,
0.013518113642930984,
-0.011636876501142979,
-0.008481442928314209,
-0.02710171788930893,
-0.03833017498254776,
0.05277332663536072,
-0.00357803818769753,
-0.030751774087548256,
-0.03787973150610924,
0.00038488520658575,
-0.0037852092646062374,
0.005756764207035303,
0.013357358984649181,
0.0016609369777143002,
-0.060194648802280426,
-0.005856822244822979,
0.045884571969509125,
0.010505965910851955,
0.017146511003375053,
0.015072988346219063,
-0.015803607180714607,
0.011864583939313889,
-0.006155082955956459,
0.007656439207494259,
-0.009905613958835602,
-0.04202689230442047,
-0.03388310223817825,
-0.01911051943898201,
-0.031085330992937088,
-0.023347429931163788,
-0.0025644451379776,
-0.026556769385933876,
0.06224470213055611,
-0.03967396169900894,
-0.004457591101527214,
-0.06174849346280098,
-0.028888721019029617,
-0.0022846076171845198,
-0.04719686880707741,
0.014566413126885891,
0.019378209486603737,
0.06662186980247498,
-0.05885943025350571,
0.01822551153600216,
0.008481007069349289,
-0.006585883442312479,
0.008509513922035694,
-0.0043692151084542274,
0.029483964666724205,
0.008760466240346432,
0.018330270424485207,
0.06481312960386276,
0.027746152132749557,
-0.013032644987106323,
0.040616489946842194,
-0.03770861402153969,
-0.028420470654964447,
0.022627532482147217,
-0.013040210120379925,
-0.0357326939702034,
0.031010383740067482,
-0.02354910597205162,
0.013461493887007236,
-0.01421460323035717,
0.025117892771959305,
0.04639754444360733,
0.006106776185333729,
-0.010724089108407497,
-0.004708289168775082,
0.03441441431641579,
0.03644808381795883,
-0.011223744601011276,
-0.009765088558197021,
0.029840711504220963,
0.02492453157901764,
0.009304780513048172,
-0.03321244195103645,
0.02834787778556347,
0.017779463902115822,
0.010611108504235744,
-0.007230023853480816,
-0.014125614427030087,
0.06646707653999329,
0.022019891068339348,
-0.08768528699874878,
0.025762435048818588,
0.00028103264048695564,
-0.033480171114206314,
0.02417558990418911,
0.035298388451337814,
-0.013629341498017311,
-0.024814264848828316,
0.0026441854424774647,
-0.015009202063083649,
0.02060881443321705,
-0.0030217363964766264,
-0.01101774163544178,
0.018729517236351967,
0.002693113638088107,
-0.020431403070688248,
0.03739131987094879,
0.03224271163344383,
-0.05555376037955284,
-0.041317131370306015,
0.018144655972719193,
-0.031315483152866364,
0.03339278697967529,
0.02049083262681961,
0.00629647821187973,
0.017049578949809074,
-0.002720789285376668,
-0.0033931045327335596,
-0.01389652956277132,
0.011748988181352615,
-0.05750211700797081,
0.032677002251148224,
0.008381761610507965,
-0.0037542537320405245,
0.026483628898859024,
0.04894111305475235,
-0.012902549467980862,
-0.022281289100646973,
0.0057869781740009785,
-0.0318266786634922,
-0.027526292949914932,
-0.1341799646615982,
-0.01554756797850132,
0.01638961210846901,
-0.03453652188181877,
-0.07123102992773056,
-0.025084298104047775,
-0.04952776059508324,
0.038044314831495285,
0.04082198813557625,
-0.009248011745512486,
0.01600675657391548,
0.03571189567446709,
-0.029491521418094635,
-0.0005815450567752123,
0.006590800825506449,
0.0016497730975970626,
0.007729277014732361,
0.020801980048418045,
-0.034021809697151184,
0.05417442321777344,
0.031005147844552994,
-0.019420994445681572,
0.01132841408252716,
-0.045201126486063004,
0.01995375193655491,
0.012926386669278145,
0.03389335423707962,
-0.03479738533496857,
-0.01399851031601429,
-0.006282008718699217,
-0.029399899765849113,
0.009161275811493397,
0.01769794151186943,
0.07972069084644318,
-0.0030385483987629414,
0.014326854608952999,
0.004165489226579666,
-0.030119650065898895,
0.011233316734433174,
-0.004318476188927889,
0.0021167760714888573,
0.01628851145505905,
-0.034975532442331314,
-0.020947052165865898,
0.007580012083053589,
0.03754657879471779,
-0.004472023341804743,
0.001642039162106812,
-0.06651472300291061,
-0.004699147306382656,
-0.05716212838888168,
-0.012740576639771461,
-0.004491622559726238,
0.020473355427384377,
-0.011278342455625534,
0.0007619389216415584,
0.016498230397701263,
0.00943188276141882,
-0.001092845806851983,
0.08362043648958206,
0.005120863206684589,
-0.007091263309121132,
-0.08989883214235306,
-0.041814763098955154,
-0.019218748435378075,
-0.04829813167452812,
-0.03560260683298111,
-0.01791580580174923,
-0.03054168075323105,
0.009120418690145016,
-0.00876894686371088,
-0.05082622542977333,
-0.005442730151116848,
-0.06745470315217972,
0.023453518748283386,
-0.014477649703621864,
0.004681216552853584,
0.021082274615764618,
-0.058675043284893036,
-0.0014240226009860635,
0.026897763833403587,
0.00541662098839879,
-0.09478025883436203,
-0.048095475882291794,
0.0630793496966362,
0.015589947812259197,
-0.013067071326076984,
0.01491479016840458,
0.002827513962984085,
-0.0024112772662192583,
-0.020076850429177284,
-0.007857177406549454,
0.017475489526987076,
0.03417045995593071,
-0.05258018523454666,
0.035361871123313904,
0.024441109970211983,
-0.0047783865593373775,
-0.012314955703914165,
-0.02600029855966568,
-0.02295844629406929,
-0.0029138769023120403,
-0.02371259219944477,
-0.0018525089835748076,
-0.004465706646442413,
-0.001055204076692462,
0.03147592023015022,
-0.00680990656837821,
0.0059562320820987225,
-0.019711878150701523,
-0.03180630877614021,
-0.039072029292583466,
-0.0009410574566572905,
-0.0005746809765696526,
-0.04448897764086723,
0.014763731509447098,
0.0079034473747015,
-0.029449861496686935,
-0.06657805293798447,
-0.048029445111751556,
-0.006608278024941683,
0.054433200508356094,
0.04481011629104614,
-0.04824414104223251,
0.04762263596057892,
0.02809210866689682,
0.006065456662327051,
-0.0035921635571867228,
0.03996317833662033,
-0.014382663182914257,
0.008561961352825165,
0.0668114572763443,
0.013101615011692047,
0.013697502203285694,
0.023500723764300346,
0.003856680588796735,
-0.0028210608288645744,
0.003147604875266552,
-0.03983905911445618,
-0.0012743069091811776,
-0.0009015765390358865,
0.016123831272125244,
0.0009916035924106836,
0.03161828964948654,
-0.034309323877096176,
-0.011582612991333008,
0.01373668760061264,
0.004039451014250517,
-0.061550308018922806,
-0.009141781367361546,
0.021584616973996162,
0.006914291996508837,
0.012034830637276173,
0.018012868240475655,
-0.0023293676786124706,
0.043064456433057785,
-0.00035653982195071876,
-0.032165173441171646,
0.05546681955456734,
0.02948281355202198,
0.05691306293010712,
-0.002148484578356147,
-0.023177124559879303,
-0.06777355819940567,
-0.006562634836882353,
0.01648641936480999,
0.007146009244024754,
-0.01137765683233738,
-0.050381626933813095,
-0.026871731504797935,
-0.004892352502793074,
-0.034325264394283295,
0.004737920593470335,
0.0917564406991005,
0.04618145897984505,
-0.05928349867463112,
-0.01729658991098404,
0.026960382238030434,
0.050788287073373795,
0.009465058334171772,
0.056174539029598236,
0.023765187710523605,
0.020140578970313072,
0.019495375454425812,
0.05916275084018707,
0.045734915882349014,
-0.000845888804178685,
0.012345411814749241,
-0.011417345143854618,
-0.00344622484408319,
0.030072158202528954,
0.020580118522047997,
0.008480168879032135,
-0.000014950322110962588,
0.015133061446249485,
0.000950193265452981,
-0.008281972259283066,
-0.030451634898781776,
0.0035659875720739365,
0.024470699951052666,
0.03530428186058998,
0.0144480736926198,
-0.01298743486404419,
0.014321774244308472,
0.0026231214869767427,
-0.013249690644443035,
-0.010485689155757427,
-0.05967152863740921,
-0.026310119777917862,
-0.0052924989722669125,
-0.0030163901392370462,
0.020440012216567993,
-0.03703461214900017,
-0.01177639327943325,
-0.022101236507296562,
0.009755964390933514,
0.04203226789832115,
-0.030146880075335503,
0.05245499685406685,
-0.005768186878412962,
0.027474604547023773,
0.048377517610788345,
-0.06635259836912155,
0.027196256443858147,
-0.000610934104770422,
-0.01577230729162693,
0.002369032707065344,
0.028900470584630966,
0.02836889959871769,
0.045374736189842224,
-0.008056838996708393,
0.010243234224617481,
-0.0013830619864165783,
0.04690165817737579,
0.024137604981660843,
0.014745100401341915,
0.01725936308503151,
-0.026631250977516174,
0.022061282768845558,
0.028293538838624954,
0.02088768407702446,
-0.01216312125325203,
0.02237706072628498,
-0.019032418727874756
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:66
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
In January 2002 Mr Zdrilic became aware of the purchase by HTT of the Land. LEC joined HTT as a defendant to the 2001 Proceedings on 11 December 2002. Throughout this period Mr Zdrilic understood that HTT was undertaking work to rehabilitate the Land at considerable expense.
953In these circumstances Mr Einfeld referred me to the observations of Murphy JA in Streeter v Western Areas Exploration Pty Limited (2011) 278 ALR 291 at [635]:-
"The doctrine of laches comprehends two themes. One is delay implying not just quiescence, but rather acquiescence and assent, and the other is delay involving prejudicial change of circumstances."
954Mr Einfeld placed particular emphasis on the second strand and drew my attention to the remarks of Kindersley VC in Ernest v Vivian (1863) 33 LJ (Ch) 513 at 517 (cited with approval by Hardie J in Boyns v Lackey (1958) SR (NSW) 395 at 403-404 and by Murphy JA in Streeter at [644]):-
"Now, if a person has a just right to mines of which he is not in possession, against those who are in possession of and working them, and if he claims to be the rightful owner (the person in possession being aware of his rights or supposed rights),
if such owner, not being prevented by fraud or concealment stands by for a long period of time whilst those in possession are working the mines, this Court will not lend him assistance (.
..) it is not equitable to allow him to wait until it is ascertained that the persons in possession have succeeded or may have been ruined, and if the subject result in profit, to ask him to put that in his pocket, if in loss, to repudiate the loss."
955Mr Einfeld argued that the words of Kindersley VC are an apt description of Mr Zdrilic's conduct in this case.
956On the other hand Mr Jucovic pointed to material that shows that Mr Renshall and HTT were expecting Mr Zdrilic to make a claim in respect of the Land from as early as January 2000.
957Mr Jucovic also pointed out that LEC did not obtain access to Mr Hulley's five letters of April and May 1999 (referred to in paragraphs 39 to 44 above) until they were produced on discovery in the 2001 Proceedings towards the end of 2002.
Mr Jucovic submitted that it was the production of those letters that led to the 11 December 2002 amendment joining HTT to the 2001 Proceedings. A reading of the Amended Statement of Claim on 11 December 2002 reveals that, indeed, the five letters are central to the plea against HTT.
958In these circumstances, it appears to me that, at this remove, I am not able to come to any final view about the likely outcome of a laches plea in the 2001 Proceedings. I certainly cannot come to the conclusion that such a plea was bound to succeed.
Pleadings
959I should note that Mr Jucovic protested that the defendants have not pleaded that the 2001 Proceedings were bound to fail because of the security for costs applications, or by reason of laches. Again, Mr Jucovic relied on in UCPR r 14.14.
960Although it is not necessary for me to express any view about this matter, it seems to me that these matters should have come as no surprise to the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs' claim was that LEC had, by reason of the events of 2004 and, in particular, the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings on 6 September 2004, lost the opportunity to prosecute the 2001 Proceedings.
In those circumstances I would have thought that it obvious that the plaintiffs had to prove that LEC could have, and would have prosecuted the 2001 Proceedings to trial and would have achieved success at that trial. In those circumstances it should have been obvious to the plaintiffs that the defendants would raise arguments such as these by way of answer.
The merits of the 2001 Proceedings
961Mr Einfeld submitted that, leaving aside the "procedural" matters referred to above, as a matter of substance, the 2001 Proceedings were bound to fail because the errant fiduciary, Mr Hulley, had not caused HTT to acquire any benefit at LEC's expense for the reason that LEC could not, and did not wish to acquire the interest in the Land ultimately obtained by HTT.
|
[
-0.02763434126973152,
0.034871071577072144,
-0.03635476157069206,
0.011515463702380657,
-0.02143687941133976,
-0.01852632500231266,
-0.013792778365314007,
-0.0262848362326622,
-0.002045708941295743,
0.003351358463987708,
-0.027180826291441917,
0.02207672782242298,
-0.028477339074015617,
-0.01040591299533844,
-0.007091932464390993,
-0.0017781711649149656,
0.02977181039750576,
-0.010079864412546158,
-0.031550392508506775,
-0.006503201089799404,
-0.012198456563055515,
-0.03874827176332474,
0.04480866715312004,
0.03457540273666382,
-0.0012382029090076685,
-0.01264304481446743,
-0.011274797841906548,
0.005708608310669661,
0.016380148008465767,
0.03064601495862007,
-0.015222041867673397,
0.04472631961107254,
0.03318771719932556,
-0.026719773188233376,
0.016829151660203934,
-0.0017520984401926398,
0.04351714253425598,
0.042295895516872406,
-0.030367469415068626,
-0.016615867614746094,
0.00008137790428008884,
0.0003685099945869297,
0.012900710105895996,
-0.05753445252776146,
0.030145930126309395,
-0.026569707319140434,
-0.03857206925749779,
-0.04207000136375427,
0.005222279112786055,
0.01621057651937008,
-0.026279384270310402,
-0.013115434907376766,
0.06916790455579758,
-0.028771357610821724,
-0.04883481562137604,
-0.027677420526742935,
-0.042464107275009155,
-0.03532782569527626,
-0.08243834227323532,
0.032225776463747025,
0.007633262313902378,
-0.01705736108124256,
-0.029963338747620583,
-0.007447445765137672,
-0.016873467713594437,
0.10129514336585999,
-0.007766553666442633,
-0.0247512049973011,
0.0019326547626405954,
-0.008204239420592785,
-0.0255888681858778,
-0.015344093553721905,
-0.03370419517159462,
0.02420881576836109,
-0.049870219081640244,
0.029931722208857536,
-0.019418584182858467,
0.005667150020599365,
0.05063549801707268,
0.0055810073390603065,
0.040959060192108154,
-0.014903176575899124,
-0.004653032869100571,
0.02805423177778721,
-0.021824195981025696,
0.0139316963031888,
-0.07438458502292633,
0.001394704100675881,
0.026720767840743065,
-0.03364059701561928,
-0.010279946960508823,
0.0059481048956513405,
0.007743096444755793,
-0.014288646169006824,
0.008676813915371895,
0.01554138958454132,
-0.10760452598333359,
0.04376094043254852,
0.01133047416806221,
0.03144976869225502,
0.004078522324562073,
0.032246582210063934,
-0.027738243341445923,
-0.015158337540924549,
0.010831750929355621,
0.01786138117313385,
0.03725520148873329,
0.025373142212629318,
0.029768584296107292,
0.005508843343704939,
0.020317209884524345,
0.023861687630414963,
-0.00021500058937817812,
0.025041799992322922,
-0.025185437873005867,
-0.020628796890378,
0.014522592537105083,
-0.012190740555524826,
0.04196867346763611,
-0.010377791710197926,
0.05216960608959198,
0.0458352267742157,
0.06371130049228668,
-0.018006445840001106,
-0.03291492536664009,
0.022144921123981476,
0.005417810752987862,
-0.023625805974006653,
0.0012041049776598811,
0.02873309515416622,
-0.013127190060913563,
0.007614471483975649,
-0.010042332112789154,
-0.03789925575256348,
-0.03981013223528862,
-0.010778998956084251,
-0.00570352328941226,
-0.004154771100729704,
0.005965696647763252,
-0.028624285012483597,
0.04063943400979042,
0.044735949486494064,
0.017768772318959236,
-0.047480832785367966,
0.013302532956004143,
-0.0003285883867647499,
0.0075303600169718266,
-0.016461079940199852,
0.008576625026762486,
-0.01802539825439453,
0.009924281388521194,
-0.0035933793988078833,
0.05108674615621567,
0.015651678666472435,
0.04076781123876572,
-0.025469312444329262,
-0.027261145412921906,
-0.005469494964927435,
0.019357936456799507,
0.028403641656041145,
-0.03743184730410576,
0.01036670058965683,
-0.02910381555557251,
0.013720452785491943,
-0.024307135492563248,
-0.020084895193576813,
-0.006832053419202566,
0.04765496030449867,
-0.03853609412908554,
0.009369942359626293,
0.029391318559646606,
0.0057230545207858086,
0.004602931905537844,
-0.05884147807955742,
0.009702076204121113,
0.011335575021803379,
0.063257597386837,
-0.0016449361573904753,
0.011282581835985184,
-0.014727729372680187,
-0.010793421417474747,
0.003114609280601144,
0.042557068169116974,
-0.03351854532957077,
-0.03475344553589821,
-0.009054732508957386,
-0.03164704516530037,
-0.012702787294983864,
0.004327131435275078,
0.027199480682611465,
-0.01810138300061226,
-0.021586420014500618,
0.012744917534291744,
0.03546060249209404,
0.038744281977415085,
-0.025919286534190178,
0.004671845585107803,
-0.022403158247470856,
0.030223911628127098,
-0.019253460690379143,
-0.050835538655519485,
0.04711266979575157,
0.033437322825193405,
-0.011668139137327671,
-0.027412019670009613,
0.007019347511231899,
-0.06024638190865517,
-0.013131002895534039,
0.015714235603809357,
-0.022445976734161377,
0.008325855247676373,
0.018629465252161026,
-0.01385345309972763,
-0.010322274640202522,
0.044657543301582336,
-0.02937365137040615,
-0.019710393622517586,
0.028271598741412163,
-0.0034695675130933523,
-0.0034582328516989946,
-0.016492245718836784,
0.020488955080509186,
0.011595269665122032,
-0.0364154614508152,
0.06402537226676941,
0.009570950642228127,
-0.06193462386727333,
0.024064237251877785,
-0.0018694400787353516,
-0.04036566615104675,
0.014473553746938705,
0.014489980414509773,
0.0013241011183708906,
-0.032158806920051575,
-0.010271824896335602,
0.004831026308238506,
0.021269232034683228,
0.011623856611549854,
0.009984105825424194,
0.044426076114177704,
-0.010915344581007957,
0.019811803475022316,
-0.013811319135129452,
-0.017867879942059517,
-0.014381792396306992,
-0.0608658604323864,
0.0033388936426490545,
0.023528333753347397,
0.04754820838570595,
0.02544010989367962,
0.017893033102154732,
0.002851883415132761,
0.002578150713816285,
-0.008133608847856522,
-0.022164372727274895,
0.04173620417714119,
0.033266857266426086,
0.004008049611002207,
0.022731872275471687,
0.014024574309587479,
0.03278287127614021,
0.02833712473511696,
0.014499092474579811,
0.028000978752970695,
-0.03838196396827698,
-0.01754925772547722,
-0.026600653305649757,
-0.029249805957078934,
0.0185938011854887,
-0.003876889357343316,
-0.009473580867052078,
0.014939004555344582,
0.0401306077837944,
0.02813020534813404,
0.021128734573721886,
-0.008124643005430698,
0.028391629457473755,
0.007150606717914343,
-0.01118789054453373,
-0.01762758381664753,
-0.013141786679625511,
-0.004407582804560661,
0.041167546063661575,
-0.03184458985924721,
0.0017772717401385307,
0.03604583814740181,
-0.014230499975383282,
-0.05103801190853119,
0.0026204281020909548,
-0.033779632300138474,
-0.030047332867980003,
-0.03605056181550026,
0.0585709810256958,
0.013073557056486607,
-0.09620992839336395,
-0.007570628076791763,
-0.003668447956442833,
-0.1578107327222824,
-0.025070682168006897,
-0.004389483947306871,
0.00690958509221673,
-0.01243302971124649,
0.02357974275946617,
-0.05067768692970276,
-0.012879176065325737,
-0.03051588125526905,
0.008816508576273918,
0.013369409367442131,
-0.04159444943070412,
-0.021398860961198807,
0.008405840955674648,
0.002130775945261121,
-0.004384132102131844,
-0.02124588005244732,
-0.008793958462774754,
0.016336191445589066,
-0.05088654160499573,
0.01019216887652874,
-0.037167664617300034,
0.046154193580150604,
0.012548956088721752,
0.031837452203035355,
-0.0007696980610489845,
0.00711592985317111,
-0.0020748567767441273,
-0.059043485671281815,
-0.0028665047138929367,
-0.028413506224751472,
0.03911912441253662,
-0.010705891065299511,
0.030809156596660614,
-0.0028915503062307835,
0.00008316466119140387,
0.0755324587225914,
-0.07345683127641678,
-0.017898671329021454,
-0.02129841409623623,
0.03371084854006767,
0.06070518493652344,
-0.04191982001066208,
0.0016181770479306579,
0.0346674919128418,
-0.07264982908964157,
0.032852355390787125,
-0.0008510392508469522,
-0.012207882478833199,
0.026177387684583664,
0.009546631015837193,
-0.020453792065382004,
-0.04345543310046196,
-0.036800503730773926,
0.010568681173026562,
-0.01096014492213726,
0.009933908469974995,
-0.02593686431646347,
-0.0021052854135632515,
-0.003496498102322221,
-0.004947111010551453,
-0.09275185316801071,
0.0288900937885046,
0.001794861163944006,
-0.014559813775122166,
-0.021802464500069618,
-0.0003534166025929153,
-0.0027922389563173056,
0.019232027232646942,
-0.0253367330878973,
0.01685122586786747,
-0.021589457988739014,
0.006984784733504057,
0.012215561233460903,
0.0020709941163659096,
0.029337266460061073,
-0.058415040373802185,
-0.0064239297062158585,
-0.0024211930576711893,
-0.09991342574357986,
-0.006198171526193619,
0.04426262900233269,
-0.004027715418487787,
0.0001889538107207045,
-0.005053314380347729,
0.03734765201807022,
0.03971753269433975,
0.04265847057104111,
-0.010777730494737625,
0.24725456535816193,
0.00282195839099586,
-0.007203756365925074,
-0.01565368101000786,
0.03419658541679382,
-0.007674066815525293,
0.000902988133020699,
0.0675606057047844,
-0.01941729336977005,
-0.06107998639345169,
-0.040158845484256744,
-0.027760179713368416,
0.012041433714330196,
0.01409955695271492,
-0.05027981847524643,
-0.014904781244695187,
-0.027045808732509613,
-0.029470261186361313,
0.07321331650018692,
0.009746543131768703,
0.033696457743644714,
-0.030654754489660263,
0.009557398036122322,
0.00709404656663537,
-0.05837152898311615,
-0.02435203641653061,
0.0117504196241498,
0.041420552879571915,
-0.04386543110013008,
-0.019587384536862373,
-0.03447471559047699,
-0.0046932995319366455,
0.0024695787578821182,
0.010353049263358116,
-0.012671749107539654,
-0.0028369473293423653,
-0.02713674306869507,
0.022449981421232224,
-0.008420757949352264,
-0.012295342981815338,
-0.009154324419796467,
-0.025273097679018974,
-0.043850552290678024,
-0.01606721058487892,
-0.030596520751714706,
0.022325972095131874,
-0.023526780307292938,
0.0054899961687624454,
0.023151401430368423,
0.04390859603881836,
-0.028234567493200302,
0.016079861670732498,
-0.02829602360725403,
-0.01961394026875496,
-0.02661825902760029,
0.033915042877197266,
-0.03625528886914253,
0.025543896481394768,
0.011534206569194794,
0.019925899803638458,
0.039067886769771576,
0.017623210325837135,
-0.022900378331542015,
0.03814598545432091,
-0.013280094601213932,
0.07280540466308594,
-0.038692016154527664,
0.009440939873456955,
0.07183220982551575,
0.00601542741060257,
0.06395372748374939,
-0.0033271219581365585,
-0.007244114298373461,
-0.0018515458796173334,
0.0326622799038887,
0.02988259866833687,
-0.018863139674067497,
0.020293448120355606,
-0.03414963558316231,
0.023710334673523903,
-0.02187104895710945,
-0.03899697959423065,
0.007027677726000547,
0.005724908784031868,
0.029580794274806976,
0.0035417969338595867,
-0.0194125697016716,
-0.00024966782075352967,
-0.0011798023479059339,
-0.0036371073219925165,
0.019511325284838676,
-0.016716692596673965,
0.0017565047601237893,
0.002914899494498968,
-0.011364571750164032,
-0.03190666809678078,
-0.009243223816156387,
0.006737576797604561,
0.0014307372039183974,
-0.037846967577934265,
-0.0037725854199379683,
0.009046904742717743,
0.027222182601690292,
-0.060189105570316315,
0.03460647538304329,
0.015439162030816078,
-0.03406977653503418,
0.02737480029463768,
-0.03742236644029617,
0.012120068073272705,
0.0024384898133575916,
0.021377433091402054,
0.016292627900838852,
0.0042539373971521854,
0.020487353205680847,
0.06105801463127136,
-0.017690759152173996,
0.041935455054044724,
0.06361053884029388,
0.030268006026744843,
0.00751880370080471,
0.042087703943252563,
-0.04306965321302414,
0.0020770092960447073,
-0.0034554610028862953,
0.0201409999281168,
-0.028635725378990173,
-0.009779802523553371,
0.019917849451303482,
0.026028472930192947,
0.012400698848068714,
-0.019931036978960037,
-0.041922979056835175,
-0.021483592689037323,
0.039927221834659576,
0.021808350458741188,
0.013221532106399536,
0.0009575365693308413,
-0.07036502659320831,
0.018084155395627022,
-0.012671610340476036,
0.004072952549904585,
-0.03598162904381752,
-0.024294381961226463,
0.018369052559137344,
0.02670970931649208,
-0.06932318210601807,
-0.0019042323110625148,
-0.02163676545023918,
-0.005357792600989342,
0.008472620509564877,
0.0037811321672052145,
-0.04595335200428963,
-0.0130631597712636,
0.02042166329920292,
0.009522367268800735,
-0.004059413447976112,
-0.0014297028537839651,
0.04665131866931915,
-0.019497781991958618,
0.018877608701586723,
0.019638843834400177,
-0.013964668847620487,
0.027742203325033188,
0.025152798742055893,
0.05149483308196068,
-0.02877933904528618,
0.04775238782167435,
0.045644182711839676,
-0.03895577788352966,
-0.0014194133691489697,
-0.02495880238711834,
-0.011052229441702366,
0.06860049813985825,
0.046294499188661575,
0.061305999755859375,
-0.023814214393496513,
0.030919060111045837,
-0.017302459105849266,
-0.0536794513463974,
0.03641325980424881,
-0.006701996549963951,
-0.011022457852959633,
0.04129928722977638,
0.02662438340485096,
-0.02756980061531067,
-0.0286608524620533,
-0.02036282978951931,
0.06168198585510254,
-0.038824912160634995,
-0.044164542108774185,
0.0941125676035881,
0.03438716381788254,
-0.023036018013954163,
-0.002051581395789981,
0.012292001396417618,
-0.008562502451241016,
-0.00044828798854723573,
0.028249578550457954,
-0.061821725219488144,
-0.02513796277344227,
-0.029758188873529434,
0.01622028462588787,
0.01670636609196663,
0.03792303800582886,
-0.010696874000132084,
-0.018799802288413048,
0.012752470560371876,
-0.049543291330337524,
-0.05671318992972374,
-0.008060930296778679,
0.009935609064996243,
-0.05824406072497368,
0.025701554492115974,
-0.011159383691847324,
-0.001047770376317203,
-0.01608293130993843,
0.05798346549272537,
-0.01219797320663929,
-0.034093886613845825,
-0.008389576338231564,
0.000030174549465300515,
0.05494079366326332,
-0.07490402460098267,
0.012897827662527561,
0.0370611771941185,
-0.03419485315680504,
0.018564434722065926,
-0.015590360388159752,
0.005639399867504835,
0.011269832029938698,
-0.024372007697820663,
0.03934239596128464,
-0.019271019846200943,
0.025242485105991364,
0.01768774352967739,
0.04881015047430992,
0.0018028856720775366,
0.031481701880693436,
-0.015250537544488907,
0.04340769350528717,
0.019272049888968468,
0.031223829835653305,
0.014124354347586632,
0.006210943218320608,
-0.03608987107872963,
0.03634762391448021,
-0.01781471073627472,
0.006414682138711214,
0.0580059178173542,
0.027871793136000633,
0.02337903156876564,
0.007871459238231182,
0.003620284143835306,
0.035029638558626175,
0.03370605781674385,
0.01968083344399929,
0.0026804516091942787,
-0.0316818468272686,
-0.004517386667430401,
0.009448600932955742,
0.013367397710680962,
0.0224539116024971,
-0.01977103389799595,
-0.0312705896794796,
-0.05918749421834946,
0.02070803940296173,
0.003224165877327323,
-0.011750607751309872,
-0.02425714023411274,
0.01190278772264719,
0.022086692973971367,
-0.01854463666677475,
-0.01889343373477459,
-0.016820162534713745,
0.0012435129610821605,
-0.028055503964424133,
0.014063786715269089,
-0.009079406037926674,
-0.027167174965143204,
0.028423700481653214,
0.0007971346494741738,
0.014077861793339252,
0.030485086143016815,
-0.0224833395332098,
-0.003350457875058055,
-0.002346850000321865,
0.008487081155180931,
0.017823221161961555,
0.0067678941413760185,
0.013278871774673462,
0.008119828067719936,
-0.0011829700088128448,
0.021748166531324387,
0.00239981384947896,
0.022341322153806686,
-0.02290528267621994,
0.051631323993206024,
-0.0034868873190134764,
0.013553864322602749,
-0.04763083532452583,
0.03343619778752327,
-0.03136024996638298,
-0.0688270628452301,
0.008670579642057419,
-0.002969922963529825,
0.012646147049963474,
-0.0007137004286050797,
-0.016855871304869652,
-0.002914620563387871,
0.029525594785809517,
-0.041524991393089294,
-0.015455066226422787,
-0.027173368260264397,
0.009293277747929096,
0.01972362957894802,
-0.0024791762698441744,
-0.027124179527163506,
-0.030786409974098206,
-0.004278401844203472,
-0.010752690024673939,
0.026230350136756897,
-0.05679387226700783,
-0.004626207984983921,
-0.07246764749288559,
0.0303163081407547,
-0.013020963408052921,
-0.018511895090341568,
-0.03365567699074745,
0.007589131593704224,
-0.07576803117990494,
-0.009557424113154411,
-0.003806328633800149,
-0.04013964533805847,
0.06993521004915237,
0.012728258036077023,
0.01560830045491457,
-0.04023422673344612,
0.042919695377349854,
-0.07162453979253769,
-0.009805303066968918,
-0.07954990118741989,
0.07746633887290955,
-0.0007661539129912853,
0.03277861326932907,
0.059449855238199234,
-0.003598911454901099,
-0.026678983122110367,
0.010614483617246151,
0.0275364201515913,
0.009927590377628803,
-0.01753176376223564,
-0.006414102390408516,
-0.028921177610754967,
0.012798487208783627,
0.008697113022208214,
0.016863742843270302,
0.043586645275354385,
0.035307470709085464,
-0.006244049407541752,
-0.0028523302171379328,
0.0410187654197216,
-0.04462442547082901,
-0.013597875833511353,
0.02622455358505249,
0.005398875568062067,
-0.0158563069999218,
-0.012571304105222225,
0.01435029599815607,
0.011423218064010143,
0.005651706364005804,
-0.026010489091277122,
-0.020425967872142792,
-0.009412270970642567,
-0.017494123429059982,
0.02931024506688118,
0.030488140881061554,
-0.002620838349685073,
0.008404625579714775,
-0.04031195864081383,
0.008398809470236301,
-0.05085446313023567,
-0.0029795318841934204,
0.0069409748539328575,
-0.002380658872425556,
0.00008997002441901714,
0.0036422591656446457,
0.03009706921875477,
-0.0025299496483057737,
0.01843946799635887,
-0.035935744643211365,
0.03953048959374428,
-0.03034757636487484,
-0.018962785601615906,
-0.14493991434574127,
0.01220663357526064,
-0.0004245751188136637,
0.018849261105060577,
-0.022687258198857307,
0.020185280591249466,
-0.013260137289762497,
0.018316099420189857,
-0.027179595082998276,
0.0037822197191417217,
0.004689821042120457,
-0.015933824703097343,
-0.022988736629486084,
-0.037614867091178894,
-0.06924304366111755,
0.03286682441830635,
-0.02651059813797474,
-0.016287174075841904,
-0.035721734166145325,
0.013230051845312119,
0.02398957498371601,
0.019052835181355476,
-0.04368070513010025,
0.01116199605166912,
-0.014782452955842018,
0.038253869861364365,
-0.03831516206264496,
-0.062228575348854065,
-0.030607149004936218,
-0.07270368933677673,
-0.0037645830307155848,
-0.03909687697887421,
-0.011908265762031078,
0.04209212586283684,
0.015514496713876724,
0.036725182086229324,
-0.0015137167647480965,
0.0029964493587613106,
0.006562889087945223,
-0.017143914476037025,
-0.008757354691624641,
0.03069321997463703,
-0.02138846181333065,
-0.0185098834335804,
0.008622486144304276,
0.02562282793223858,
-0.012980728410184383,
-0.004195714835077524,
-0.08095091581344604,
-0.017271630465984344,
-0.021580543369054794,
0.0324266254901886,
-0.024698276072740555,
0.04734351485967636,
0.0016475945012643933,
-0.017513498663902283,
0.013730124570429325,
-0.023446545004844666,
-0.015114553272724152,
0.04291708022356033,
0.009547838009893894,
0.02738371305167675,
-0.008405402302742004,
-0.008161777630448341,
-0.019921554252505302,
0.00969712994992733,
0.020898357033729553,
-0.02108154632151127,
-0.03564947843551636,
0.015243856236338615,
0.03111502155661583,
-0.023929357528686523,
-0.007751875091344118,
-0.038885824382305145,
0.01825205236673355,
-0.019305754452943802,
0.014663866721093655,
-0.006959164049476385,
-0.02317570336163044,
-0.020952755585312843,
-0.013128135353326797,
0.023145724087953568,
-0.016401220113039017,
-0.030288510024547577,
0.09856309741735458,
0.012768740765750408,
-0.028290314599871635,
-0.013749622739851475,
0.03230442479252815,
-0.022792458534240723,
-0.03633080795407295,
-0.006237548775970936,
-0.028254657983779907,
-0.0368223562836647,
-0.026525776833295822,
-0.0067657423205673695,
0.000977239920757711,
0.029935982078313828,
0.010940231382846832,
-0.008032181300222874,
-0.05077393725514412,
-0.023893333971500397,
0.06817561388015747,
-0.02228725515305996,
-0.052520763128995895,
0.047955650836229324,
-0.01113386731594801,
0.012862149626016617,
0.0221331175416708,
-0.02447807788848877,
0.00993392150849104,
0.010692774318158627,
-0.03908686712384224,
0.04850230738520622,
-0.055003486573696136,
-0.008993720635771751,
-0.009165853261947632,
-0.0017886890564113855,
0.03696808964014053,
0.03642572462558746,
0.021285777911543846,
0.020879045128822327,
0.028925292193889618,
-0.04155847802758217,
-0.02049543708562851,
0.014667659997940063,
0.06653744727373123,
-0.001726195216178894,
0.024654719978570938,
-0.029548605903983116,
0.023155231028795242,
0.028157826513051987,
0.002709456952288747,
-0.009154587984085083,
0.004607326816767454,
-0.009530539624392986,
0.011642507277429104,
0.007230284158140421,
-0.04869161918759346,
-0.04036412760615349,
-0.015198069624602795,
-0.004619261249899864,
-0.015192286111414433,
-0.0011775847524404526,
-0.02962011657655239,
-0.026362592354416847,
0.031091708689928055,
0.039520349353551865,
-0.00324852392077446,
-0.05131702870130539,
-0.007481972221285105,
0.00539383664727211,
0.011314723640680313,
0.0478958934545517,
0.05500660091638565,
-0.054291982203722,
0.024683142080903053,
-0.009566761553287506,
0.004862117115408182,
0.04679494351148605,
0.030709009617567062,
-0.027302211150527,
-0.01596691645681858,
0.010171697475016117,
-0.045624472200870514,
0.011329964734613895,
-0.02914002537727356,
-0.017263323068618774,
-0.01747908815741539,
-0.003733437741175294,
0.016106581315398216,
0.04859732836484909,
-0.028807001188397408,
0.025273464620113373,
0.008837198838591576,
-0.025026023387908936,
0.013933107256889343,
0.010366873815655708,
0.045564644038677216,
-0.05886514112353325,
0.034399501979351044,
0.05811261013150215,
0.02916290983557701,
0.00236131832934916,
-0.010014173574745655,
0.010177819058299065,
-0.0040635960176587105,
0.05759351700544357,
-0.015089592896401882,
-0.0471167154610157,
-0.047106340527534485,
0.0030033052898943424,
-0.012695427983999252,
-0.019685206934809685,
0.002682184102013707,
0.010544472374022007,
-0.011691378429532051,
0.027185503393411636,
-0.011594465933740139,
0.0005204583867453039,
0.012817942537367344,
-0.04804397001862526,
-0.03701656684279442,
-0.023316515609622,
-0.023359306156635284,
0.03865472227334976,
0.003277015406638384,
-0.05491223186254501,
-0.03243033215403557,
0.0431167334318161,
-0.00935983844101429,
0.0030163652263581753,
-0.024436378851532936,
0.02790316380560398,
0.021960200741887093,
-0.006316159386187792,
0.010761629790067673,
0.019771678373217583,
0.037487585097551346,
0.003463122760877013,
0.03090042993426323,
0.04180876910686493,
-0.026566192507743835,
-0.02816229686141014,
-0.037190984934568405,
0.0024088392965495586,
-0.015737438574433327,
-0.025298578664660454,
-0.001650119316764176,
0.0036026688758283854,
0.006585830356925726,
0.01725028082728386,
0.004920276813209057,
0.02227453887462616,
0.011450858786702156,
-0.047988664358854294,
-0.008034364320337772,
-0.01796998642385006,
-0.0022977180778980255,
-0.010780525393784046,
0.060770321637392044,
-0.0007222105632536113,
0.015573802404105663,
0.018951617181301117
] |
What are the two themes comprehended by the doctrine of laches, according to Murphy JA in Streeter v Western Areas Exploration Pty Limited (2011) 278 ALR 291?
|
[
-0.03939750790596008,
-0.027579184621572495,
-0.030401011928915977,
-0.02147885225713253,
-0.010168686509132385,
0.012067961506545544,
-0.04434994235634804,
-0.013510097749531269,
-0.03021121956408024,
-0.0033207747619599104,
-0.015987452119588852,
0.024383557960391045,
-0.024528898298740387,
-0.007493352051824331,
0.01626359112560749,
-0.008493592962622643,
0.0037078089080750942,
-0.00041796540608629584,
-0.01193250622600317,
-0.04173054173588753,
-0.02374354377388954,
-0.07767730951309204,
-0.015831364318728447,
0.018795380368828773,
0.014524332247674465,
0.007357437629252672,
-0.00915102381259203,
-0.0220184363424778,
-0.0334208644926548,
0.0408807247877121,
-0.007073430344462395,
0.062234241515398026,
0.019804399460554123,
-0.03872828558087349,
0.003405293682590127,
-0.027810879051685333,
-0.005603278987109661,
0.04354795813560486,
-0.05557940900325775,
-0.0464550256729126,
-0.03208133578300476,
-0.03998810052871704,
0.021323537454009056,
-0.04085758328437805,
-0.0061114635318517685,
-0.011297873221337795,
-0.023180769756436348,
-0.049085866659879684,
-0.007266615983098745,
0.02587493509054184,
-0.03033265843987465,
-0.007274332456290722,
0.06852816790342331,
-0.006249799393117428,
-0.04657251760363579,
-0.01502322219312191,
-0.01521402969956398,
-0.022743932902812958,
-0.09052754938602448,
0.07915150374174118,
-0.005577347241342068,
-0.008546763099730015,
0.016232416033744812,
-0.010265138931572437,
0.027058657258749008,
0.006190036423504353,
-0.051104798913002014,
-0.04496080055832863,
0.005839942954480648,
0.016650769859552383,
-0.015828697010874748,
-0.02016444317996502,
-0.029314544051885605,
0.015088186599314213,
-0.05435339733958244,
0.02273590862751007,
-0.03376031294465065,
0.010727309621870518,
-0.013406828977167606,
-0.010896692983806133,
0.02423257566988468,
-0.003671324346214533,
-0.04815007746219635,
-0.003868534229695797,
-0.04022432118654251,
0.04954221844673157,
-0.0511627271771431,
-0.029004504904150963,
0.03053554892539978,
-0.012856941670179367,
-0.011247199028730392,
-0.05479397252202034,
0.03498528152704239,
-0.0204628873616457,
0.010404479689896107,
-0.03101511299610138,
-0.11256537586450577,
0.030361011624336243,
0.02685704454779625,
0.02316918782889843,
0.0004193340428173542,
0.03848016634583473,
-0.013876490294933319,
-0.017471034079790115,
0.025412829592823982,
-0.038441408425569534,
0.012468736618757248,
0.010172175243496895,
0.04380149394273758,
0.017203262075781822,
0.03026469051837921,
0.020032765343785286,
0.008840723894536495,
0.05579959601163864,
-0.057457972317934036,
-0.03308475390076637,
0.04162368178367615,
-0.017452087253332138,
0.011532760225236416,
0.03398939222097397,
-0.010278414003551006,
-0.02598222903907299,
0.054805319756269455,
-0.04081818461418152,
0.02079022489488125,
0.01582295447587967,
0.026763802394270897,
0.013133601285517216,
0.006142181809991598,
0.022505955770611763,
-0.03337642177939415,
-0.024428214877843857,
0.004613610450178385,
-0.017007535323500633,
-0.052677080035209656,
0.019939083606004715,
0.031554482877254486,
-0.045828744769096375,
-0.01965232379734516,
-0.01562771573662758,
0.0070787398144602776,
-0.0075978850945830345,
0.017222585156559944,
-0.03274061158299446,
0.001818386954255402,
-0.004118719603866339,
-0.00739121763035655,
0.015776939690113068,
-0.015786316245794296,
-0.012181670404970646,
-0.015971871092915535,
-0.07052063196897507,
0.08399981260299683,
0.058339864015579224,
0.03885629400610924,
-0.03235156461596489,
-0.023809220641851425,
0.04661339893937111,
0.017953645437955856,
-0.01702050305902958,
-0.007138641085475683,
0.006324315909296274,
0.0021369715686887503,
0.007783489301800728,
0.019169021397829056,
-0.03851994872093201,
-0.013727587647736073,
0.031317200511693954,
-0.016106661409139633,
-0.025039592757821083,
-0.0015421173302456737,
0.007270877715200186,
0.006230851169675589,
-0.042147211730480194,
0.0357571542263031,
0.017398091033101082,
0.04700910672545433,
0.0035710593219846487,
-0.0015312179457396269,
-0.031036242842674255,
0.00882587768137455,
-0.0430748388171196,
0.007977225817739964,
-0.028656180948019028,
-0.016996443271636963,
-0.02509520947933197,
0.004033907316625118,
-0.038525499403476715,
0.03583621606230736,
0.022416621446609497,
-0.041598521173000336,
0.004752092529088259,
-0.004276517778635025,
0.027417389675974846,
-0.02169094607234001,
-0.013384860940277576,
-0.007870635017752647,
-0.02080276794731617,
0.03130045905709267,
-0.015890803188085556,
-0.00102092488668859,
0.039312977343797684,
0.021525176241993904,
0.06367688626050949,
-0.024067780002951622,
-0.04624743014574051,
-0.08816292136907578,
-0.009017077274620533,
0.00830620713531971,
0.013727713376283646,
0.00009063573088496923,
-0.015236365608870983,
-0.03268749266862869,
-0.0070825787261128426,
0.027507511898875237,
-0.05668347701430321,
0.0012662948574870825,
0.015099969692528248,
0.003689321456477046,
-0.0019054115982726216,
0.006054360885173082,
-0.010257077403366566,
-0.004637648817151785,
0.03179268166422844,
0.0911027267575264,
-0.01881871186196804,
0.03638838231563568,
0.03646983951330185,
0.014268402010202408,
0.012783466838300228,
0.014359479770064354,
0.022260164842009544,
0.009762241505086422,
-0.057711586356163025,
-0.020844262093305588,
-0.03241044282913208,
0.046743519604206085,
-0.008862611837685108,
0.03668615221977234,
-0.0024998134467750788,
-0.013015738688409328,
-0.03846845403313637,
-0.023295503109693527,
-0.0041289967484772205,
-0.02343948930501938,
-0.05991124361753464,
0.02596289850771427,
0.010431685484945774,
0.010237987153232098,
0.05145270377397537,
-0.005321096628904343,
-0.009891476482152939,
0.00453784316778183,
-0.013214204460382462,
-0.008702569641172886,
0.026941290125250816,
0.05908260494470596,
-0.011000421829521656,
0.019092045724391937,
0.022682232782244682,
0.02769424207508564,
0.02910270169377327,
-0.002046119188889861,
0.01579734869301319,
-0.056112561374902725,
-0.015073185786604881,
-0.07151762396097183,
-0.02545531652867794,
-0.009675153531134129,
-0.0005451240576803684,
-0.016217758879065514,
0.015909841284155846,
0.0029421793296933174,
-0.01563631184399128,
0.02390584722161293,
0.029679372906684875,
-0.005264763720333576,
0.008947450667619705,
0.01756763830780983,
-0.03913729637861252,
0.004057849291712046,
-0.05680616572499275,
0.010329998098313808,
0.03280378505587578,
0.0016745930770412087,
0.02358883060514927,
-0.02429952844977379,
-0.03390463441610336,
-0.02770712412893772,
-0.0631638839840889,
-0.007752865087240934,
-0.02286290004849434,
0.06020691245794296,
0.031600069254636765,
-0.04111937806010246,
0.00044657671242021024,
-0.05399896949529648,
-0.13010022044181824,
-0.016368664801120758,
0.010653492994606495,
-0.009620984084904194,
0.00911488477140665,
0.021778812631964684,
-0.02428019978106022,
-0.010453990660607815,
0.01383045595139265,
-0.02693733014166355,
-0.024199344217777252,
-0.04867018014192581,
-0.1069444939494133,
0.02457161247730255,
-0.00864365417510271,
-0.026080304756760597,
-0.017381852492690086,
0.00221778335981071,
-0.02098250761628151,
-0.025325754657387733,
-0.020622702315449715,
0.03613485395908356,
0.02557818591594696,
-0.006492404732853174,
0.048086125403642654,
0.042354438453912735,
0.009702552109956741,
-0.020023955032229424,
-0.056901443749666214,
0.013403777033090591,
0.0074913171119987965,
0.03670649603009224,
-0.0029400335624814034,
0.04026149958372116,
-0.04230768606066704,
0.010298172011971474,
0.01618359237909317,
-0.003406642470508814,
0.005443642847239971,
-0.03578532487154007,
0.012669981457293034,
0.019879231229424477,
-0.04609283059835434,
0.02010328508913517,
0.017371637746691704,
-0.06128702685236931,
0.04582246392965317,
-0.019870612770318985,
-0.03970998153090477,
0.016096973791718483,
0.002167487982660532,
-0.021224694326519966,
-0.02633669599890709,
0.034061189740896225,
-0.031958743929862976,
-0.01008453406393528,
-0.027676505967974663,
0.03152540698647499,
0.007641080766916275,
-0.00287288473919034,
0.03941138833761215,
-0.026035670191049576,
0.04486825317144394,
0.0024075147230178118,
-0.0226382315158844,
-0.07327596843242645,
0.02818867191672325,
0.0006526027573272586,
-0.017758121713995934,
-0.026211179792881012,
0.021018490195274353,
-0.006745817605406046,
0.008521830663084984,
-0.02034798450767994,
0.0018255600007250905,
0.04036914184689522,
0.028993161395192146,
-0.022914979606866837,
0.021811645478010178,
-0.05103643238544464,
0.025377053767442703,
0.027887634932994843,
0.015575306490063667,
0.008141824044287205,
0.02128201723098755,
0.025240307673811913,
0.01962047442793846,
0.0038568712770938873,
-0.0013651185436174273,
0.17930884659290314,
0.012010685168206692,
0.014305024407804012,
0.009859740734100342,
0.028911195695400238,
0.002807838376611471,
0.003645289922133088,
0.04412572830915451,
-0.02197602391242981,
-0.029081230983138084,
-0.05029258877038956,
0.0059294989332556725,
0.0284747201949358,
0.006034026853740215,
-0.012512723915278912,
-0.016756845638155937,
-0.03937031328678131,
0.017776794731616974,
0.09697648882865906,
-0.010317295789718628,
0.03770873323082924,
-0.007582413498312235,
-0.006197152193635702,
0.01915302313864231,
0.015987280756235123,
-0.02865237556397915,
0.014386456459760666,
0.07679569721221924,
-0.03262292221188545,
0.003460401203483343,
-0.02126340940594673,
0.01938585191965103,
-0.025837143883109093,
0.012180618941783905,
0.00301537592895329,
-0.02004239708185196,
-0.014654448255896568,
-0.0018837567185983062,
-0.03485236316919327,
0.000962498364970088,
-0.03136947751045227,
-0.031551361083984375,
-0.006347221788018942,
0.0041384631767869,
0.01847337931394577,
-0.058519672602415085,
0.003670168574899435,
-0.035844381898641586,
-0.02072223834693432,
0.05028434470295906,
-0.015633990988135338,
0.0023101468104869127,
-0.006588929332792759,
0.037165552377700806,
-0.06565960496664047,
-0.00439149234443903,
-0.038561657071113586,
0.01932581514120102,
-0.025364862754940987,
-0.010354239493608475,
0.02376074716448784,
-0.0355394147336483,
0.017244691029191017,
0.03638239577412605,
-0.040165938436985016,
0.054176121950149536,
-0.02645699493587017,
-0.01664106734097004,
0.00741158053278923,
-0.02501889131963253,
0.009508814662694931,
0.01961279660463333,
0.00920198205858469,
-0.0018490682123228908,
0.03129933029413223,
0.044090062379837036,
-0.017336569726467133,
0.02894926816225052,
0.028262102976441383,
0.015020585618913174,
0.01225131843239069,
-0.012666421942412853,
0.019498664885759354,
-0.01150971744209528,
0.0039892662316560745,
0.04326826333999634,
0.009999251924455166,
-0.007373882923275232,
0.012907586060464382,
-0.001313753891736269,
-0.012562108226120472,
-0.00944401603192091,
-0.020939156413078308,
0.0020442937966436148,
0.002983526326715946,
-0.033254653215408325,
-0.025734245777130127,
0.034917596727609634,
-0.00580624770373106,
-0.06860684603452682,
-0.032937537878751755,
0.008509526029229164,
0.029001601040363312,
-0.027793288230895996,
0.053282979875802994,
0.034912481904029846,
0.04387746751308441,
0.0536949522793293,
-0.016123544424772263,
-0.0030225072987377644,
0.013782256282866001,
0.0006852875230833888,
-0.011771171353757381,
0.02675117924809456,
-0.0009356860537081957,
0.03345319256186485,
-0.05114234983921051,
0.013390771113336086,
0.0705752819776535,
0.041613902896642685,
-0.008297785185277462,
0.04777871444821358,
-0.01926495134830475,
-0.010672717355191708,
-0.015073038637638092,
0.018814567476511,
-0.015872551128268242,
0.015233642421662807,
-0.0010200864635407925,
0.014249950647354126,
0.012463371269404888,
0.0026630668435245752,
-0.005550944246351719,
-0.009538023732602596,
0.057323332875967026,
0.013890808448195457,
0.018661415204405785,
0.027191167697310448,
-0.023126788437366486,
0.04467933624982834,
-0.00234411982819438,
-0.002948208712041378,
-0.03829497843980789,
-0.02901955507695675,
0.000898026570212096,
0.039190735667943954,
-0.04649278149008751,
0.0019700706470757723,
-0.0066702282056212425,
-0.04170661419630051,
0.02333732321858406,
0.06310112029314041,
-0.05992526561021805,
-0.03870290517807007,
-0.006226133555173874,
-0.00943115446716547,
-0.013140646740794182,
-0.019161656498908997,
0.05541250854730606,
0.01396143902093172,
0.028183499351143837,
-0.03433672711253166,
-0.03375748172402382,
0.05123862996697426,
0.006110949441790581,
0.0225377157330513,
-0.02728728950023651,
0.06009405106306076,
0.017113998532295227,
-0.03631941229104996,
0.004704813007265329,
-0.048430416733026505,
-0.002399110235273838,
0.0946335420012474,
0.06771054863929749,
0.010478252544999123,
0.000294339784886688,
0.03699321299791336,
-0.016657637432217598,
-0.05605366826057434,
0.01403089053928852,
0.01420148927718401,
0.021873604506254196,
0.022655894979834557,
-0.020508989691734314,
-0.020341943949460983,
-0.012175893411040306,
-0.029010510072112083,
0.025501957163214684,
0.013911944814026356,
-0.02554292231798172,
0.038155969232320786,
0.0050760614685714245,
-0.0199179258197546,
0.015379521995782852,
0.006663885898888111,
-0.03280649706721306,
0.012794675305485725,
-0.024959469214081764,
0.012159325182437897,
0.0043946062214672565,
-0.025009775534272194,
0.012730715796351433,
0.014597608707845211,
0.013362721540033817,
0.0037545771338045597,
-0.060898151248693466,
0.008304683491587639,
-0.040996238589286804,
-0.06002489849925041,
-0.034987784922122955,
-0.036979809403419495,
-0.053001269698143005,
-0.013391271233558655,
-0.040426336228847504,
0.03312230855226517,
-0.03966847062110901,
0.05439557135105133,
-0.005682839546352625,
-0.029479021206498146,
0.03422730043530464,
-0.01312852744013071,
0.004544559866189957,
-0.059349823743104935,
0.02881898172199726,
0.0392584428191185,
-0.0080295130610466,
-0.016359426081180573,
0.00037527954555116594,
-0.004216802306473255,
0.009938136674463749,
-0.000244224356720224,
-0.014408448711037636,
0.013149229809641838,
0.011527788825333118,
0.012983271852135658,
0.025013243779540062,
-0.0098919328302145,
0.01831689663231373,
-0.011594582349061966,
0.00006094943091738969,
-0.038973744958639145,
0.007484145928174257,
0.05144960805773735,
-0.01223472785204649,
-0.05123445764183998,
0.050717487931251526,
-0.0037650028243660927,
0.05424552038311958,
0.04555174335837364,
0.030086547136306763,
0.0277475044131279,
-0.010109250433743,
-0.023032695055007935,
-0.00045086859609000385,
-0.00017917586956173182,
0.03507411107420921,
0.04646463319659233,
-0.02877221815288067,
-0.012160533107817173,
-0.0013206801377236843,
0.02547554299235344,
-0.007623836398124695,
-0.01669779233634472,
0.012408478185534477,
-0.058744657784700394,
0.02537282556295395,
0.03274910897016525,
0.00031952038989402354,
-0.010936339385807514,
0.0036238390021026134,
0.023280343040823936,
-0.02698269858956337,
0.00014423677930608392,
0.024162495508790016,
0.017600147053599358,
-0.055880334228277206,
-0.006709278095513582,
-0.04860531538724899,
-0.033679042011499405,
0.048250049352645874,
0.04762567952275276,
0.008090238086879253,
0.03437650948762894,
-0.018668264150619507,
0.002573949284851551,
0.01659500040113926,
0.01624017022550106,
0.016740156337618828,
-0.012950015254318714,
0.02478216588497162,
0.009264537133276463,
-0.007384864613413811,
-0.021095216274261475,
-0.049767665565013885,
0.03445228934288025,
-0.03356364369392395,
0.08260930329561234,
-0.004506404977291822,
0.018254904076457024,
0.007657082751393318,
0.0466410331428051,
-0.008415218442678452,
-0.034130919724702835,
-0.005490496754646301,
-0.019226105883717537,
-0.0009720443049445748,
-0.07455030083656311,
0.02253745310008526,
0.03272339701652527,
0.02184141054749489,
0.00264550419524312,
0.002756107598543167,
-0.03650272637605667,
-0.04669417440891266,
0.015231930650770664,
0.052739985287189484,
-0.03291274607181549,
-0.02001253515481949,
-0.056071970611810684,
0.017424892634153366,
0.05005866661667824,
-0.029914135113358498,
-0.01819218508899212,
0.020922716706991196,
-0.0036561163142323494,
0.001000604243017733,
0.022401506081223488,
-0.023124009370803833,
-0.03654163330793381,
-0.03725995495915413,
-0.023329341784119606,
-0.014901450835168362,
-0.02453017234802246,
0.04321349039673805,
0.07812193781137466,
0.014564888551831245,
-0.029520820826292038,
0.030019346624612808,
-0.02866213023662567,
-0.01548109482973814,
0.0013409972889348865,
0.05415666103363037,
-0.002581473207101226,
0.06104608625173569,
0.030050041154026985,
-0.002295826096087694,
-0.0034138578921556473,
-0.04689164087176323,
0.02431674674153328,
-0.0031075822189450264,
0.047361258417367935,
0.02023177221417427,
-0.06415726989507675,
0.04668152704834938,
0.01713203266263008,
0.013559067621827126,
-0.022702984511852264,
0.018537107855081558,
0.02214815840125084,
-0.0005826567648909986,
0.012538411654531956,
-0.02755093201994896,
0.003302426543086767,
0.00608947454020381,
-0.004054265562444925,
-0.011541432701051235,
-0.012319883331656456,
-0.01334187388420105,
0.01989380642771721,
0.010139274410903454,
0.015068447217345238,
-0.033640023320913315,
-0.043105192482471466,
-0.02100357785820961,
0.02087671495974064,
-0.007841301150619984,
-0.011393552646040916,
0.021338123828172684,
-0.026766497641801834,
0.0124429352581501,
-0.00040105797233991325,
-0.011326870881021023,
-0.002174532739445567,
0.018629981204867363,
-0.0678071528673172,
0.01061095017939806,
0.032882776111364365,
0.00752663891762495,
0.0008879608358256519,
-0.00454110698774457,
0.07015294581651688,
-0.037420451641082764,
0.029805416241288185,
-0.12557193636894226,
0.056421034038066864,
0.01786220073699951,
0.05365048348903656,
-0.01391786802560091,
0.025426043197512627,
-0.02990451641380787,
0.02763422206044197,
-0.024390647187829018,
-0.0063484786078333855,
0.016158778220415115,
0.049832891672849655,
-0.0019472383428364992,
0.004799500107765198,
-0.0675547793507576,
-0.005002656485885382,
0.009310580790042877,
-0.03617534413933754,
0.010292524471879005,
-0.01964837871491909,
0.0437193401157856,
0.02736332267522812,
-0.0377546101808548,
0.056703999638557434,
0.037161968648433685,
0.04782667011022568,
-0.09083953499794006,
-0.07451201230287552,
-0.02852034755051136,
-0.05562644451856613,
-0.004382474813610315,
-0.03253054991364479,
0.03234391659498215,
-0.011120203882455826,
0.0009333798079751432,
0.05307696759700775,
-0.014534972608089447,
-0.008135194890201092,
0.006805433426052332,
-0.021477079018950462,
0.009784489870071411,
0.012331854552030563,
-0.0005122803268022835,
0.02600935660302639,
0.02034592628479004,
-0.015940792858600616,
-0.026409607380628586,
-0.012583873234689236,
-0.04150877520442009,
0.019557548686861992,
-0.029934801161289215,
0.05371997505426407,
-0.026736797764897346,
0.011824325658380985,
-0.0036879112012684345,
-0.010118815116584301,
-0.008079138584434986,
-0.011812731623649597,
-0.011058167554438114,
0.04828597977757454,
-0.023690903559327126,
-0.012644898146390915,
0.030136357992887497,
-0.02707614004611969,
0.03072056919336319,
0.007552150636911392,
-0.03334499150514603,
0.006970391143113375,
-0.01463144738227129,
0.020560700446367264,
0.005967667326331139,
-0.033202625811100006,
-0.010688908398151398,
-0.0016493238508701324,
0.018892362713813782,
-0.01804284006357193,
0.055109985172748566,
0.0319923534989357,
0.024174286052584648,
0.0008546142489649355,
0.005583224818110466,
-0.014746504835784435,
-0.007185875903815031,
-0.008511610329151154,
0.07452773302793503,
0.018987221643328667,
-0.02249559946358204,
0.0020797511097043753,
0.04484054446220398,
-0.01938505284488201,
-0.054119326174259186,
0.00025001788162626326,
-0.04820650815963745,
-0.0399954728782177,
-0.008510193787515163,
-0.013045675121247768,
-0.0028170309960842133,
0.04684922471642494,
-0.0015260657528415322,
-0.0003849499917123467,
-0.03469660505652428,
0.015592462383210659,
0.0472310371696949,
-0.035880088806152344,
-0.047132913023233414,
0.054782334715127945,
-0.019890697672963142,
0.002213000087067485,
0.0431663952767849,
-0.0079202800989151,
0.022527851164340973,
0.01917276531457901,
0.0014489697059616446,
-0.020619360730051994,
-0.04673147201538086,
-0.007704382296651602,
-0.021721169352531433,
0.027254700660705566,
0.032592762261629105,
0.033269163221120834,
-0.028632618486881256,
0.016911478713154793,
0.04481372609734535,
-0.0386078767478466,
-0.0023212707601487637,
-0.0010074892779812217,
0.03990618512034416,
0.03618067130446434,
-0.01760292798280716,
-0.020520957186818123,
0.01049579493701458,
0.025919435545802116,
-0.020782489329576492,
-0.006078436505049467,
0.0006844002637080848,
-0.0045896051451563835,
0.036935146898031235,
0.030997078865766525,
-0.03839496523141861,
-0.00917922705411911,
-0.01140106376260519,
-0.009529562667012215,
0.011952870525419712,
0.030276689678430557,
0.0067657046020030975,
-0.021296456456184387,
-0.004714671988040209,
0.025836721062660217,
-0.017821822315454483,
-0.020523829385638237,
0.027844266965985298,
-0.01904049888253212,
0.0008630626834928989,
0.010554174892604351,
0.060457807034254074,
-0.04720265045762062,
0.016766270622611046,
-0.014635602943599224,
-0.049067165702581406,
0.014561728574335575,
0.01464600209146738,
-0.04091640189290047,
-0.03629307821393013,
0.0025087755639106035,
-0.042715784162282944,
0.0037182457745075226,
-0.01980704255402088,
-0.018543822690844536,
0.0006028637872077525,
0.05394572764635086,
0.011838067322969437,
0.02504272758960724,
-0.05432332679629326,
0.013983096927404404,
0.02020382136106491,
0.02033393643796444,
0.026685260236263275,
0.054949741810560226,
-0.019405795261263847,
-0.06056360900402069,
0.0504474975168705,
0.024168135598301888,
0.01992321014404297,
0.002669057110324502,
-0.048588432371616364,
0.05058150365948677,
-0.006086115259677172,
-0.012876134365797043,
0.03480049595236778,
-0.01596205309033394,
0.006111953407526016,
0.005039677023887634,
-0.01972426474094391,
-0.03977939113974571,
0.03933290019631386,
-0.017537157982587814,
0.017833316698670387,
0.04693709686398506,
-0.012446793727576733,
-0.003908868879079819,
0.005321755073964596,
-0.02534174919128418,
-0.04505090042948723,
-0.002204185351729393,
-0.04253131151199341,
-0.01221549604088068,
0.010563917458057404,
-0.03856537118554115,
-0.05014971271157265,
0.03126896172761917,
0.00047550228191539645,
-0.012048271484673023,
-0.03824431821703911,
0.0276066642254591,
0.012728545814752579,
-0.0025183141697198153,
0.018477048724889755,
-0.004835936706513166,
-0.0024028767365962267,
-0.008501316420733929,
0.04352860152721405,
0.026006676256656647,
0.005410675425082445,
-0.047812432050704956,
-0.035940587520599365,
-0.04292803630232811,
-0.004969391506165266,
-0.01042957417666912,
-0.0054711527191102505,
-0.07465822994709015,
0.030886543914675713,
0.016450045630335808,
0.007189024705439806,
0.023433756083250046,
0.012015333399176598,
0.019968301057815552,
-0.008390774950385094,
0.0022378184366971254,
-0.006928752642124891,
-0.03087243251502514,
0.04435666650533676,
-0.008477783761918545,
0.06088653951883316,
-0.0015233471058309078
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:11
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
165However, Mr Zdrilic's insistence that he could "pinpoint" the date is illustrative of his inclination to make assertions where his memory did not justify the assertion.
166A further example arises from an email Mr Zdrilic sent to Mr Renshall on 21 July 2004 in which he said:-
"Now that it appears the funder will not be available at the time when all these things were supposed to take place we must go back to what was envisaged at the very beginning and that is that Zdrilic, Hickie and Renshall or if you prefer Zdrilic and Renshall as directors of HTT with unanimous decisions made." (emphasis added).
167As will emerge later in this judgment, this email is of some significance in the case.
168In his affidavit evidence, Mr Zdrilic said that, the day after the email was sent, he had a conversation with Mr Renshall in which he said:-
"However, the important thing is that as the funder is not available as yet, we need to change the constitution of HTT to make sure that no decision at board level or member level can be made without my agreement." (emphasis added).
169It seems to me that Mr Zdrilic's email makes clear that he was speaking prospectively and was lamenting the fact that it appeared that the funder "will not" be available "at the time when all these things were supposed to take place".
170However, in his account of his conversation with Mr Renshall there had been a subtle, but significant, change to what he alleges he was saying. Thus, in the conversation, his evidence was that he was merely speaking of funds being "not available as yet".
171Mr Renshall denied having a conversation to this effect with Mr Zdrilic. I think it likely, as Mr Einfeld put to Mr Zdrilic, that Mr Zdrilic reconstructed the 22 July 2004 conversation based upon his 21 July 2004 email.
In doing so he has, perhaps subliminally, embroidered his recollection to change his comment as to the lack of availability of funds being prospective to being merely a statement of the then current position.
172There were other examples like this.
173My conclusion is that, although I did not regard Mr Zdrilic as a dishonest witness, the manner in which he gave his evidence leads me to the conclusion that I should treat his evidence with great care.
The HTT Defendants' witnesses
174The HTT Defendants called four witnesses: Mr Renshall, Mr Moir, Mr Frederick and Mr Gillard.
Mr Renshall
175Mr Renshall was cross-examined for more than three days.
176In closing submissions, no attack was made on Mr Renshall's credit.
177I thought Mr Renshall gave his evidence openly and honestly, although it emerged during the cross-examination that Mr Renshall's recollection of many events during the relevant period was poor.
178The cross-examination also revealed that, in relation to some conversations that Mr Renshall denied in his affidavit evidence, the true state of his recollection was that he simply could not say whether the conversations took place or not.
Other witnesses called
179The HTT Defendants also called Mr James Moir (a solicitor then employed at Swaab Attorneys, who acted for IBIC and IPC), and Mr Chris F (referred to above).
180No criticism was made of the manner in which these two witnesses gave their evidence. I thought they were both trying to give the best of their recollection in a disinterested manner. I accept their evidence.
181The HTT Defendants also called Mr Gillard who, as I have said, was acting in their interests during 2004 (and, indeed, in these proceedings for a time). As I will discuss below in relation to the events of 27 August 2004, I have concerns about some of the evidence Mr Gillard gave.
Mr Hickie and Vocfia
182Although Mr Hickie swore an affidavit in the proceedings, he was not called as a witness.
Some relevant legal principles
183Before turning to a detailed consideration of the facts, I shall set out some of the legal principles which are relevant to the issues to be determined in the proceedings.
|
[
-0.020350053906440735,
0.04704584181308746,
-0.01741372048854828,
0.013861922547221184,
-0.027573635801672935,
-0.06583642214536667,
0.023700673133134842,
-0.04493029788136482,
-0.017666777595877647,
-0.0054502664133906364,
0.0025093285366892815,
0.04386875033378601,
-0.04621685668826103,
0.00969671830534935,
-0.017876794561743736,
0.008701717481017113,
0.052063681185245514,
-0.039390310645103455,
0.004489242564886808,
-0.033236660063266754,
-0.024098793044686317,
-0.03975226730108261,
-0.0004973564646206796,
-0.009918744675815105,
-0.02369856834411621,
-0.026315512135624886,
-0.026449328288435936,
0.025262216106057167,
0.03312718868255615,
0.0323304757475853,
0.027850709855556488,
-0.00891134887933731,
0.053942978382110596,
0.0010633417405188084,
0.0003398582339286804,
-0.02284156158566475,
0.011938042007386684,
0.010169361717998981,
-0.018760614097118378,
0.020055416971445084,
-0.024504272267222404,
-0.010458221659064293,
-0.014678196050226688,
-0.021424267441034317,
0.03606174513697624,
-0.04503103345632553,
-0.007210001349449158,
-0.027789060026407242,
0.009984913282096386,
0.01650572009384632,
-0.03685891628265381,
-0.013001070357859135,
0.046867623925209045,
-0.003847733838483691,
-0.032311178743839264,
-0.010710800997912884,
-0.041129469871520996,
-0.0007202421547845006,
-0.027612844482064247,
0.0172264464199543,
0.021066119894385338,
-0.008078399114310741,
-0.07655099034309387,
0.004861338995397091,
-0.007116904016584158,
0.11212240159511566,
0.01353598851710558,
-0.0342286117374897,
0.00010628190648276359,
-0.0006474238471128047,
-0.05138299986720085,
0.015907928347587585,
-0.031078238040208817,
-0.006666858214884996,
-0.09272562712430954,
0.00036782375536859035,
0.018913716077804565,
0.00690669659525156,
0.03852919116616249,
0.05052434653043747,
0.052820753306150436,
-0.012623618356883526,
0.032110799103975296,
0.024033542722463608,
-0.0011386830592527986,
0.04086525738239288,
0.000906905101146549,
0.041491907089948654,
0.02878841944038868,
-0.038905009627342224,
0.003475099103525281,
0.015857843682169914,
-0.009918018244206905,
-0.05235566943883896,
0.008654287084937096,
-0.004253148566931486,
-0.046401724219322205,
0.039061252027750015,
0.00006414670497179031,
0.029035374522209167,
0.004334610421210527,
0.03156211972236633,
-0.03210070729255676,
-0.04093625396490097,
-0.02085948921740055,
0.03748088702559471,
0.0581245981156826,
0.03733113408088684,
0.023590819910168648,
-0.007445975206792355,
-0.0054256184957921505,
0.01633349247276783,
-0.03281610831618309,
0.0259231086820364,
-0.027997605502605438,
-0.008220632560551167,
-0.022404564544558525,
0.027589602395892143,
0.04765351489186287,
0.004267220851033926,
0.057315271347761154,
0.0350266769528389,
0.0275378730148077,
-0.03760301694273949,
-0.0805206149816513,
0.05150742828845978,
0.007150997407734394,
-0.005491621792316437,
-0.02516787499189377,
0.022509021684527397,
0.018529579043388367,
0.017391866073012352,
-0.003431662917137146,
-0.03740796446800232,
-0.016397560015320778,
-0.0020735985599458218,
0.020625775679945946,
0.027006860822439194,
0.01028524711728096,
-0.066244937479496,
0.0648675486445427,
0.008675086311995983,
0.016569247469305992,
-0.05207522213459015,
-0.00011978746624663472,
-0.030308416113257408,
-0.012040306814014912,
0.021217893809080124,
0.026463862508535385,
0.028361894190311432,
0.030653590336441994,
0.003682435490190983,
0.04207535460591316,
0.011183125898241997,
0.014442207291722298,
-0.0360812284052372,
0.006940328981727362,
-0.018978625535964966,
0.028126021847128868,
0.09135479480028152,
-0.0028784896712750196,
0.031466733664274216,
-0.04035679250955582,
-0.010621987283229828,
-0.010814880952239037,
0.008730544708669186,
0.006976682227104902,
0.02545066736638546,
-0.01504753902554512,
-0.010469538159668446,
0.0042853704653680325,
-0.02582114189863205,
0.07162704318761826,
-0.0018957892898470163,
0.015564974397420883,
0.01225332636386156,
0.05795883387327194,
0.01104311179369688,
-0.008206132799386978,
-0.03266757354140282,
-0.046184368431568146,
0.023520607501268387,
0.006965028587728739,
-0.01517844945192337,
-0.04734451696276665,
-0.002961389720439911,
-0.06735546886920929,
-0.03685680776834488,
-0.008279855363070965,
0.009739508852362633,
-0.015069684945046902,
0.000694582297001034,
0.012555820867419243,
0.05541817098855972,
0.03935850039124489,
-0.011128709651529789,
0.029853548854589462,
-0.03417913615703583,
-0.0227559395134449,
-0.024389298632740974,
-0.023480918258428574,
0.03767799586057663,
0.06508290022611618,
-0.022762339562177658,
-0.017832862213253975,
-0.008612156845629215,
-0.014510957524180412,
0.010568141005933285,
-0.007151770871132612,
-0.06245128810405731,
0.019458115100860596,
0.017644625157117844,
-0.017256924882531166,
-0.029247721657156944,
0.001047434750944376,
-0.024307940155267715,
-0.021442169323563576,
0.00940693449229002,
0.005560413468629122,
-0.04490901157259941,
0.0010258561233058572,
0.008325689472258091,
-0.007826020009815693,
-0.01903151161968708,
0.046466466039419174,
0.021229645237326622,
-0.06845251470804214,
0.04128163307905197,
-0.018514346331357956,
-0.00682726688683033,
0.01801478862762451,
-0.014040052890777588,
-0.003823687322437763,
-0.01275051012635231,
0.00408506253734231,
0.02570013888180256,
-0.001587463659234345,
0.009082714095711708,
0.0416266992688179,
0.012145886197686195,
-0.012289769947528839,
0.00640466483309865,
0.006392782088369131,
0.004802944604307413,
-0.021414266899228096,
-0.028214292600750923,
-0.009870130568742752,
0.020161719992756844,
0.016314532607793808,
0.010697291232645512,
0.004601525142788887,
0.010604405775666237,
-0.004827150143682957,
-0.03208275884389877,
0.010119584389030933,
0.01920352503657341,
0.007023768965154886,
0.0021867721807211637,
0.017131060361862183,
0.012106317095458508,
0.05211838334798813,
0.015895787626504898,
0.0298764631152153,
0.026432828977704048,
-0.008433281444013119,
-0.017484715208411217,
0.004052494652569294,
-0.0804155170917511,
0.03692437335848808,
-0.005060662981122732,
0.02600732073187828,
0.00006272055179579183,
0.02827969193458557,
0.010324687696993351,
0.012201929464936256,
0.04616290330886841,
0.02368028275668621,
0.012595748528838158,
0.020660918205976486,
0.03991292789578438,
0.006649727467447519,
0.001832654234021902,
0.050182946026325226,
-0.02229022979736328,
0.03541654348373413,
0.033451128751039505,
-0.011833488009870052,
-0.01726127415895462,
0.0164402574300766,
-0.02647671103477478,
0.009743728674948215,
0.037838757038116455,
0.05168011412024498,
-0.00783554557710886,
-0.06232573091983795,
-0.03625964745879173,
-0.03858023136854172,
-0.13730277121067047,
-0.02834404818713665,
-0.028867723420262337,
0.03079528734087944,
0.005054892040789127,
-0.00416105892509222,
-0.045285724103450775,
-0.002871618838980794,
-0.06375645101070404,
-0.009998530149459839,
0.009524239227175713,
-0.03395545855164528,
-0.016779474914073944,
0.01277302484959364,
0.012881706468760967,
-0.0039559779688715935,
-0.010705463588237762,
-0.014129036106169224,
0.02485164813697338,
-0.012667176313698292,
0.019152404740452766,
-0.030393095687031746,
0.07864534854888916,
0.01203969307243824,
0.003287704661488533,
0.0035923344548791647,
-0.0221776831895113,
0.006464879959821701,
-0.021845262497663498,
-0.002062067622318864,
-0.014509747736155987,
0.009176569990813732,
-0.026987608522176743,
0.027692731469869614,
0.00024088176724035293,
0.028445372357964516,
0.042322564870119095,
-0.05013362690806389,
-0.040185701102018356,
-0.039418917149305344,
0.036050889641046524,
0.032149896025657654,
0.015916839241981506,
0.036693766713142395,
0.0012074726400896907,
-0.06385163962841034,
0.0005272311973385513,
-0.026320312172174454,
0.0012931880773976445,
0.02938779816031456,
0.0034563387744128704,
0.02504826709628105,
-0.03629825636744499,
-0.023290369659662247,
0.019473355263471603,
-0.004048397298902273,
0.02748424932360649,
0.014763165265321732,
-0.03592656925320625,
-0.034712206572294235,
-0.01781279779970646,
-0.048601359128952026,
-0.017414821311831474,
-0.008271084167063236,
-0.011050945147871971,
-0.005890947300940752,
-0.006515131797641516,
-0.036103732883930206,
0.0362514853477478,
0.028961794450879097,
0.009805652312934399,
-0.016906505450606346,
0.010362058877944946,
0.0065377396531403065,
0.008783968165516853,
0.02135857380926609,
-0.048047006130218506,
0.004782572854310274,
-0.0206020288169384,
-0.08824870735406876,
0.0018270796863362193,
0.03597055375576019,
-0.008263510651886463,
0.0065323528833687305,
0.008137354627251625,
0.029159486293792725,
0.02246074751019478,
0.055784013122320175,
-0.028684623539447784,
0.24532826244831085,
0.022753478959202766,
-0.026835234835743904,
0.011692148633301258,
0.0056587643921375275,
-0.009437394328415394,
0.023272374644875526,
0.05479647219181061,
-0.013808404095470905,
-0.028327330946922302,
-0.005676573142409325,
-0.017289986833930016,
0.019145900383591652,
0.003315981477499008,
-0.0329461432993412,
0.01604553498327732,
-0.0445413738489151,
-0.03489900007843971,
0.05858488008379936,
0.058999963104724884,
0.07449191808700562,
-0.015095647424459457,
0.008788526989519596,
0.015806378796696663,
-0.03903181850910187,
-0.032172173261642456,
0.021368391811847687,
0.040798816829919815,
-0.03651776164770126,
0.02948889136314392,
-0.023552969098091125,
-0.0010035947198048234,
0.0500694140791893,
0.013584893196821213,
0.010170533321797848,
0.013145674020051956,
-0.020531268790364265,
0.005409421399235725,
0.0031318010296672583,
0.008151323534548283,
0.02252396009862423,
-0.031887687742710114,
-0.0007296423427760601,
-0.024162882938981056,
-0.03873923420906067,
0.04065448045730591,
-0.04256744310259819,
0.02357126958668232,
-0.0031084991060197353,
0.014140145853161812,
0.025092482566833496,
0.02817297726869583,
-0.00028827632195316255,
-0.030323324725031853,
-0.002181354444473982,
0.046620406210422516,
-0.021370531991124153,
0.03691297769546509,
-0.019057676196098328,
0.06666886061429977,
0.02383631281554699,
0.04097551107406616,
-0.06253036856651306,
0.04567869007587433,
0.0011184763861820102,
0.00821289885789156,
-0.02480991557240486,
-0.05205099284648895,
0.07888609170913696,
0.02415221370756626,
0.06471150368452072,
0.04939022287726402,
-0.009771828539669514,
-0.019310597330331802,
0.022796573117375374,
-0.012598035857081413,
-0.031725745648145676,
0.007504988927394152,
-0.0004337575228419155,
0.017922881990671158,
-0.029387902468442917,
-0.06471434235572815,
-0.017368657514452934,
0.021946139633655548,
0.023037513718008995,
-0.0008578816778026521,
-0.04759814590215683,
0.037379417568445206,
-0.013473175466060638,
-0.0071694026701152325,
-0.0070246863178908825,
-0.006214043591171503,
-0.007904811762273312,
-0.031909000128507614,
-0.004769411403685808,
-0.017118604853749275,
0.004296151455491781,
-0.01543168630450964,
-0.04690294712781906,
-0.058092664927244186,
0.004711980000138283,
0.021992461755871773,
0.032018084079027176,
-0.0411759577691555,
0.05761436000466347,
-0.0038083482068032026,
-0.018026228994131088,
0.010511094704270363,
-0.04059514403343201,
0.01334954984486103,
0.003225798485800624,
0.012246443890035152,
0.009532780386507511,
0.00443364679813385,
0.016261626034975052,
0.06365024298429489,
-0.005853953771293163,
0.05966497212648392,
0.020744143053889275,
0.026924682781100273,
-0.007436237297952175,
0.01899377442896366,
-0.04706462845206261,
0.003123953938484192,
0.0021991999819874763,
-0.0006537627195939422,
0.0007927786209620535,
-0.027218231931328773,
0.006661374121904373,
0.0018271018052473664,
-0.010466186329722404,
-0.01633785106241703,
-0.01216200739145279,
0.006472114939242601,
0.04192589595913887,
0.026059553027153015,
-0.002708944259211421,
-0.024274222552776337,
-0.06120273470878601,
0.029249602928757668,
-0.029394103214144707,
0.03357461839914322,
-0.034742508083581924,
-0.024461522698402405,
0.008063805289566517,
0.010718345642089844,
-0.06423501670360565,
0.0275558028370142,
-0.061084456741809845,
0.011579285375773907,
0.01562703400850296,
0.013405918143689632,
-0.06920437514781952,
-0.03473780304193497,
0.010358636267483234,
0.02314506657421589,
-0.010556232184171677,
-0.022800952196121216,
0.023436320945620537,
-0.05090856924653053,
-0.010006776079535484,
0.05675066262483597,
-0.0016181758837774396,
0.020986123010516167,
0.010927261784672737,
0.06211557611823082,
0.005505293142050505,
0.02419036440551281,
0.016627080738544464,
-0.008279913105070591,
-0.012490106746554375,
-0.04397638142108917,
-0.019688144326210022,
0.07264000922441483,
0.029524536803364754,
0.0448235347867012,
0.005529199726879597,
0.005576643161475658,
-0.004275055136531591,
-0.029941720888018608,
0.030174678191542625,
-0.016942141577601433,
-0.008300382643938065,
0.0331992544233799,
0.00335516850464046,
-0.004345583729445934,
-0.008670127019286156,
-0.02125684544444084,
0.054119352251291275,
-0.061020586639642715,
-0.03347429260611534,
0.06606796383857727,
0.030544741079211235,
-0.024852175265550613,
-0.013349461369216442,
-0.005055966321378946,
-0.0009491584496572614,
0.06989001482725143,
-0.018456272780895233,
-0.04788715019822121,
-0.025446545332670212,
-0.025231221690773964,
0.012425079010426998,
0.002891650889068842,
0.00034798996057361364,
0.0350729338824749,
-0.03024493344128132,
0.04114045575261116,
-0.06330429017543793,
-0.03703024238348007,
0.04849350452423096,
0.009206222370266914,
-0.021104862913489342,
0.013820147141814232,
-0.019396750256419182,
-0.016219059005379677,
0.022152695804834366,
0.05482104420661926,
0.0343526154756546,
-0.029176656156778336,
0.017507990822196007,
-0.03220051899552345,
0.06179679557681084,
-0.04114135354757309,
-0.023336827754974365,
0.020248377695679665,
-0.05633627623319626,
0.01102532260119915,
-0.048979394137859344,
0.006922003347426653,
-0.0029625589959323406,
-0.0930313915014267,
0.0452878475189209,
-0.06954072415828705,
0.03548942506313324,
0.0034914405550807714,
0.03528407961130142,
-0.01975776068866253,
0.016935627907514572,
-0.01646067202091217,
0.03701964020729065,
-0.008939431048929691,
0.01626606285572052,
-0.0008057055529206991,
0.007887808606028557,
0.01592165231704712,
0.007939867675304413,
-0.0008212567772716284,
0.008402355015277863,
0.051774173974990845,
0.015337061136960983,
0.04065675288438797,
-0.01442901510745287,
-0.012702071107923985,
0.03190501406788826,
0.03224507346749306,
0.01554358284920454,
-0.028452234342694283,
-0.031306929886341095,
-0.044543709605932236,
-0.011205852963030338,
0.018033573403954506,
0.015731247141957283,
-0.03164314478635788,
-0.05974366143345833,
-0.05243653804063797,
0.014234903268516064,
-0.010529606603085995,
-0.02693275921046734,
-0.02969317138195038,
-0.0013155575143173337,
0.013836625032126904,
-0.009291312657296658,
-0.05411616712808609,
-0.04831375554203987,
-0.012913381680846214,
-0.03339380770921707,
0.005938082467764616,
0.01337707880884409,
0.0246454868465662,
0.029711592942476273,
0.0134023018181324,
0.037188876420259476,
0.01209379080682993,
-0.04038844257593155,
0.031534381210803986,
-0.028068218380212784,
-0.005590964108705521,
0.0015214377781376243,
0.0014684480847790837,
0.016764089465141296,
0.0036150363739579916,
-0.02068074233829975,
0.027924470603466034,
-0.0020673673134297132,
0.013456632383167744,
-0.01487094908952713,
0.051402490586042404,
-0.01976843737065792,
-0.0014129694318398833,
-0.02719326689839363,
-0.017080508172512054,
-0.030704697594046593,
-0.030512461438775063,
-0.03300781175494194,
-0.00801476463675499,
-0.002453759778290987,
-0.005801346618682146,
0.0022568211425095797,
0.007765443529933691,
0.014306114986538887,
-0.0704326257109642,
0.023581329733133316,
-0.04050559550523758,
0.021526141092181206,
-0.010968053713440895,
-0.0022622901014983654,
-0.01440291479229927,
-0.04107523337006569,
0.013990974985063076,
0.032464899122714996,
-0.015432463958859444,
-0.050987932831048965,
0.012059705331921577,
-0.05132807418704033,
0.012660247273743153,
-0.019511627033352852,
-0.05127585306763649,
-0.028479641303420067,
0.0010196934454143047,
-0.01972881704568863,
-0.021711306646466255,
0.010441048070788383,
-0.018331700935959816,
0.03496517986059189,
0.009403925389051437,
-0.006236948538571596,
-0.011686240322887897,
0.030752303078770638,
-0.06757903844118118,
-0.04920252040028572,
-0.07742249965667725,
0.07298511266708374,
-0.011651582084596157,
-0.0271916501224041,
0.020623989403247833,
0.012077510356903076,
-0.006042977329343557,
0.022123439237475395,
0.008671984076499939,
-0.009248390793800354,
0.013346306048333645,
-0.00719091622158885,
-0.03196345269680023,
-0.0018025112804025412,
0.0158016886562109,
-0.019253741949796677,
0.04492219537496567,
0.028161976486444473,
0.005077800713479519,
-0.0023049283772706985,
0.06709090620279312,
0.01419726200401783,
0.0047432598657906055,
-0.0057035149075090885,
-0.033059023320674896,
0.022334745153784752,
0.03145517036318779,
-0.024029245600104332,
0.017214972525835037,
-0.0011779062915593386,
0.010535767301917076,
0.007381148170679808,
-0.013923653401434422,
-0.05225924029946327,
0.04300834983587265,
0.04491374269127846,
0.02367003634572029,
0.0033274719025939703,
-0.04958208277821541,
0.0025845577474683523,
-0.013976451009511948,
-0.02060677297413349,
-0.02698778361082077,
0.0330384224653244,
-0.001732574892230332,
-0.00996884424239397,
0.023293642327189445,
-0.005559095647186041,
0.010754745453596115,
-0.024386845529079437,
0.007586360909044743,
0.0017914734780788422,
-0.029086323454976082,
-0.135283425450325,
-0.010668622329831123,
0.016850924119353294,
-0.006979146972298622,
-0.011527689173817635,
0.01714836061000824,
-0.0289476215839386,
-0.00008730260742595419,
-0.023952912539243698,
0.0005482181441038847,
0.00485012773424387,
-0.04146774113178253,
-0.005902262404561043,
-0.03377796709537506,
-0.06792767345905304,
0.004753747954964638,
-0.045244134962558746,
-0.01725696586072445,
-0.07124072313308716,
0.02401941455900669,
0.030692284926772118,
-0.024356797337532043,
-0.01154146809130907,
-0.02665279060602188,
0.026487713679671288,
-0.0030739642679691315,
-0.014961355365812778,
-0.03383529558777809,
-0.02663620561361313,
-0.03423821181058884,
-0.02142016403377056,
-0.00217181327752769,
-0.011547855101525784,
0.04356076940894127,
0.003841609228402376,
0.0016218865057453513,
0.000007635677320649847,
-0.012332569807767868,
0.0173999834805727,
-0.009471300058066845,
0.012616988271474838,
0.025860706344246864,
-0.022641168907284737,
-0.03319317847490311,
-0.007680609356611967,
0.02281198836863041,
-0.03682483732700348,
-0.004171975422650576,
-0.05212222412228584,
-0.05137132853269577,
-0.0308119747787714,
0.019652532413601875,
0.015082839876413345,
0.046651117503643036,
-0.029515467584133148,
-0.024412425234913826,
0.005854511167854071,
-0.007474936079233885,
0.02641342766582966,
0.042158592492341995,
0.04707660898566246,
0.012372242286801338,
-0.06305810064077377,
0.0037740005645900965,
-0.0415109321475029,
-0.006080999504774809,
-0.03565708175301552,
-0.029653748497366905,
-0.052130091935396194,
0.0018727920250967145,
-0.01777360402047634,
0.0018070912919938564,
0.007049815729260445,
-0.02961147017776966,
0.022299284115433693,
0.005264896899461746,
0.012897288426756859,
0.030981024727225304,
-0.0435120090842247,
-0.02931777946650982,
-0.03878725692629814,
0.005786482244729996,
-0.06862632930278778,
-0.0016032825224101543,
0.06647472083568573,
0.036586083471775055,
-0.004675297532230616,
-0.03609625995159149,
0.02277219481766224,
-0.027901537716388702,
-0.045730795711278915,
0.004934211727231741,
0.0019316328689455986,
0.04940790683031082,
-0.013112980872392654,
0.019095323979854584,
-0.017478525638580322,
-0.007669426966458559,
-0.0034119857009500265,
-0.0019423244521021843,
-0.043595388531684875,
-0.024306511506438255,
0.02652648463845253,
-0.013690181076526642,
-0.00884303543716669,
-0.024051742628216743,
0.04514607787132263,
0.021817518398165703,
0.020580297335982323,
-0.01565297320485115,
0.012967216782271862,
-0.027068594470620155,
-0.052709899842739105,
0.053529493510723114,
-0.008747164160013199,
0.009839309379458427,
-0.0028936320450156927,
-0.011114129796624184,
0.018005188554525375,
-0.01588551327586174,
0.023713018745183945,
-0.008463743142783642,
0.0015044464962556958,
-0.022172292694449425,
-0.0025256448425352573,
-0.0062675173394382,
0.05388852208852768,
0.023186491802334785,
0.026901403442025185,
-0.01034009363502264,
0.005976689513772726,
-0.01229187287390232,
-0.006521169561892748,
0.039021264761686325,
0.013417026959359646,
-0.004795562010258436,
-0.036977287381887436,
-0.014384576119482517,
-0.02324127033352852,
-0.012462753802537918,
-0.025141343474388123,
-0.018185973167419434,
-0.0037986121606081724,
0.017485633492469788,
-0.055093515664339066,
-0.0048624551855027676,
0.01809105835855007,
-0.003393973922356963,
-0.02670951746404171,
-0.0394572988152504,
-0.002828942844644189,
0.03384500741958618,
0.002671266905963421,
0.05371428281068802,
0.014471118338406086,
0.012094794772565365,
0.0330161526799202,
0.00029561776318587363,
0.04874229058623314,
0.04584905877709389,
-0.0015976122813299298,
-0.02066977508366108,
-0.05306149646639824,
-0.04820004105567932,
-0.017793703824281693,
0.021187467500567436,
-0.018472572788596153,
-0.004154311493039131,
-0.02374134212732315,
-0.00575993349775672,
-0.0012093869736418128,
0.004144682548940182,
-0.023997308686375618,
0.007032967172563076,
0.048899054527282715,
-0.017090631648898125,
-0.004185738507658243,
-0.018940769135951996,
0.04853857681155205,
-0.02226424589753151,
0.035684142261743546,
0.023196782916784286,
0.03931237757205963,
-0.011628733947873116,
0.03295152634382248,
0.023784397169947624,
0.026932047680020332,
0.02254151552915573,
-0.00038628934998996556,
-0.03757616877555847,
-0.042433351278305054,
-0.004581131972372532,
0.05555254593491554,
-0.014784111641347408,
0.012035224586725235,
0.017831791192293167,
-0.018925005570054054,
0.0055517517030239105,
-0.009209299460053444,
0.004754811991006136,
0.016299095004796982,
-0.018564462661743164,
-0.05072544887661934,
-0.01091520581394434,
-0.006391864735633135,
0.059030260890722275,
-0.010807592421770096,
-0.04767090827226639,
-0.033006589859724045,
0.06300259381532669,
-0.022229313850402832,
0.017962584272027016,
-0.034406453371047974,
0.020930029451847076,
-0.0018870738567784429,
0.008761406876146793,
0.03986828401684761,
-0.02451835572719574,
0.03322756290435791,
-0.04232383891940117,
0.04292362555861473,
0.027809709310531616,
-0.01941516064107418,
-0.01116139069199562,
-0.0111390994861722,
0.01208273321390152,
-0.027336418628692627,
0.020668795332312584,
0.004358257632702589,
0.05912388488650322,
-0.0057368166744709015,
0.010364475660026073,
-0.006201740819960833,
0.01907990127801895,
-0.00617476599290967,
-0.03569599241018295,
-0.019054831936955452,
-0.022229552268981934,
-0.006497932597994804,
-0.0031078504398465157,
0.020655011758208275,
-0.010974627919495106,
0.038784727454185486,
-0.03029901161789894
] |
What was the Court's assessment of Mr Zdrilic's evidence in Land Enviro Corp Pty Limited v HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Limited [2012] NSWSC 382?
|
[
-0.04740716516971588,
0.02537490800023079,
-0.003557046176865697,
-0.00675646448507905,
-0.013726132921874523,
-0.06370948255062103,
0.01883472129702568,
-0.0450701080262661,
-0.021188631653785706,
-0.01896211877465248,
0.009924409911036491,
0.04912851005792618,
-0.04326314479112625,
-0.008879711851477623,
0.03548504039645195,
-0.015527835115790367,
0.017797520384192467,
-0.02059325948357582,
-0.0215434730052948,
-0.0456504225730896,
-0.04097786918282509,
-0.045080553740262985,
-0.0042920284904539585,
0.04024619981646538,
0.005219737999141216,
0.0009315451025031507,
0.004405466839671135,
0.04570505768060684,
0.03742580488324165,
0.03949952498078346,
0.002949022687971592,
0.05052824318408966,
0.036454521119594574,
0.000594290264416486,
-0.030062435194849968,
-0.06159539148211479,
0.059701286256313324,
0.027193637564778328,
-0.04645681381225586,
-0.007212792988866568,
-0.01722896657884121,
-0.037409618496894836,
0.028128115460276604,
-0.03439166769385338,
0.05826490744948387,
-0.0022879408206790686,
-0.019693924114108086,
-0.03715493902564049,
-0.00877305492758751,
0.038107190281152725,
-0.04142529517412186,
0.001970995683223009,
0.04823147878050804,
-0.023486873134970665,
-0.021372197195887566,
0.017066506668925285,
-0.0322071835398674,
-0.02391125075519085,
-0.04799439013004303,
0.029195735231041908,
0.028497867286205292,
0.01317271962761879,
-0.027843456715345383,
0.04047827422618866,
-0.04410359263420105,
0.09125060588121414,
0.019517334178090096,
-0.009180273860692978,
0.01716121844947338,
0.006762617267668247,
-0.009222476743161678,
-0.023530831560492516,
0.016356313601136208,
-0.00016007342492230237,
-0.07674043625593185,
0.010693679563701153,
-0.032776977866888046,
0.0023772851563990116,
0.057130731642246246,
0.03731926158070564,
0.01821150630712509,
-0.03040933981537819,
0.023487016558647156,
0.04227297380566597,
-0.02680269628763199,
0.020488733425736427,
-0.07268592715263367,
-0.013086213730275631,
0.0029131595510989428,
-0.02686131000518799,
0.001211238093674183,
-0.02548057958483696,
0.004944552667438984,
-0.0349431037902832,
-0.006859411019831896,
0.03013896383345127,
-0.050972990691661835,
0.03053881786763668,
-0.015020688064396381,
0.060099370777606964,
0.02381163276731968,
0.007549804635345936,
0.011518937535583973,
0.008195843547582626,
-0.008316967636346817,
-0.027465704828500748,
0.02340162917971611,
0.05118352919816971,
0.0029310747049748898,
0.02095707505941391,
-0.0038962785620242357,
-0.0048722014762461185,
0.0011782061774283648,
-0.017229214310646057,
-0.04103298857808113,
-0.00048564415192231536,
0.001474827411584556,
-0.0006586621166206896,
0.027732882648706436,
0.008869931101799011,
0.013933267444372177,
-0.006823028437793255,
0.06355632841587067,
-0.04692808911204338,
-0.049756839871406555,
-0.016287242993712425,
0.036969561129808426,
0.015145360492169857,
-0.013770264573395252,
-0.017158400267362595,
0.010983812622725964,
-0.0002259230677736923,
-0.07062309235334396,
-0.03844646364450455,
0.014262688346207142,
-0.007485557813197374,
0.009188206866383553,
0.007068558130413294,
-0.012845474295318127,
-0.06134222820401192,
0.00026475617778487504,
0.011613436974585056,
0.029461536556482315,
-0.04781397432088852,
0.003010439919307828,
-0.0001747469650581479,
-0.023500701412558556,
-0.014315740205347538,
0.00007108329009497538,
0.01865168660879135,
-0.004914478864520788,
0.019844025373458862,
0.0372699573636055,
0.003693281440064311,
0.04676717519760132,
-0.004753176122903824,
0.009363311342895031,
-0.0008885923307389021,
-0.022390224039554596,
0.04068983346223831,
-0.0009023795137181878,
-0.022341394796967506,
0.016846003010869026,
-0.0024873565416783094,
0.01665727235376835,
0.030652089044451714,
-0.002017604187130928,
0.06506267935037613,
-0.04007987305521965,
0.012342824600636959,
-0.007529830560088158,
0.011176998727023602,
-0.00043579141492955387,
0.00457236310467124,
0.014072487130761147,
0.002493127016350627,
0.04534916207194328,
0.01577657088637352,
-0.06203277409076691,
-0.021950770169496536,
-0.06472644209861755,
0.015927953645586967,
-0.005169155076146126,
-0.036932915449142456,
-0.06025145947933197,
-0.01507335901260376,
-0.03075801022350788,
-0.07301487028598785,
0.006326259579509497,
0.029893789440393448,
-0.015989091247320175,
-0.0021332225296646357,
0.042621441185474396,
-0.014524431899189949,
0.03541065379977226,
-0.00867385882884264,
0.011852506548166275,
0.001122201792895794,
0.017552031204104424,
0.0050791408866643906,
0.0071142371743917465,
0.034762103110551834,
0.03510432690382004,
-0.007029372733086348,
-0.022205626592040062,
-0.028222577646374702,
-0.06254717707633972,
0.002044942695647478,
-0.004053574055433273,
-0.04074054956436157,
-0.03100314363837242,
-0.002637669909745455,
0.02511855959892273,
-0.028796635568141937,
0.0014625221956521273,
-0.04893957078456879,
-0.04134754836559296,
-0.059663716703653336,
-0.04044131934642792,
-0.00985799916088581,
-0.015806732699275017,
0.005205261521041393,
0.01995537430047989,
0.05177353322505951,
0.025520136579871178,
0.02808511257171631,
-0.04399149492383003,
0.021669194102287292,
0.04255598783493042,
-0.01664915308356285,
-0.003681991947814822,
0.013280467130243778,
-0.01715223491191864,
-0.02811581827700138,
0.016707153990864754,
0.05085894092917442,
-0.00855602603405714,
0.03133139759302139,
0.015775127336382866,
0.011577325873076916,
-0.022498806938529015,
-0.01072520948946476,
-0.013275946490466595,
-0.02559029683470726,
-0.027675971388816833,
-0.04298258200287819,
0.007808254566043615,
0.003075550077483058,
0.040171604603528976,
0.00767176877707243,
0.02952100895345211,
0.016435343772172928,
-0.03600531816482544,
0.03716607764363289,
-0.006651765666902065,
0.04007881134748459,
0.03299466520547867,
0.005400052759796381,
0.018128668889403343,
-0.004845224320888519,
0.010935023427009583,
0.009650626219809055,
0.07641535252332687,
0.0016105755930766463,
-0.007125081494450569,
-0.0001652200153330341,
-0.04448495805263519,
-0.025158165022730827,
0.016979726031422615,
-0.04514935985207558,
0.006365346722304821,
0.007874473929405212,
0.0017494274070486426,
0.0032116235233843327,
0.04297592118382454,
-0.009811501950025558,
-0.00030646403320133686,
0.012777742929756641,
-0.010700142942368984,
0.013194105587899685,
-0.0076553006656467915,
0.007495036814361811,
0.008242214098572731,
-0.020889563485980034,
-0.02752775140106678,
-0.011356464587152004,
-0.02941490337252617,
-0.04564783349633217,
-0.01086090225726366,
-0.03958673030138016,
0.021402647718787193,
0.01623564027249813,
0.06624375283718109,
0.029469525441527367,
-0.07595160603523254,
0.011878241784870625,
-0.04257013276219368,
-0.12121356278657913,
-0.019770687445998192,
-0.004625591449439526,
-0.007647132035344839,
-0.022528279572725296,
-0.017835283651947975,
-0.051620468497276306,
0.00436632102355361,
-0.021573685109615326,
-0.0354543998837471,
-0.002339940285310149,
-0.07079800218343735,
-0.05465263873338699,
0.05682697147130966,
-0.043446943163871765,
0.0075457035563886166,
0.029022550210356712,
-0.012093869037926197,
0.03657333180308342,
-0.00961680430918932,
0.03306151553988457,
-0.019388988614082336,
0.058165110647678375,
0.013403681106865406,
0.023390714079141617,
-0.044027674943208694,
0.0008313099388033152,
-0.02618478424847126,
-0.008509356528520584,
0.009828491136431694,
-0.0029224571771919727,
-0.032516028732061386,
-0.02110343612730503,
0.035282403230667114,
-0.016911514103412628,
-0.006802837364375591,
0.0463152714073658,
-0.03296833485364914,
0.010463055223226547,
-0.018686849623918533,
0.041316092014312744,
-0.011410962790250778,
-0.023979894816875458,
0.07081753760576248,
0.0032244212925434113,
-0.03678402677178383,
-0.012294935062527657,
-0.016772432252764702,
0.012079312466084957,
0.03368496894836426,
0.005630768369883299,
0.01807192526757717,
-0.030337639153003693,
-0.011892147362232208,
-0.01731381192803383,
-0.014215325005352497,
0.03778701648116112,
0.07237046211957932,
0.012325003743171692,
-0.043373096734285355,
-0.07141473144292831,
-0.03417156636714935,
-0.02090015448629856,
-0.00840163603425026,
-0.019153233617544174,
-0.009053097106516361,
0.008767352439463139,
-0.027550315484404564,
0.047446172684431076,
0.022742504253983498,
-0.005962518975138664,
0.02244197390973568,
-0.0062132347375154495,
-0.02944762632250786,
0.007179322186857462,
-0.009620807133615017,
-0.053335804492235184,
0.005489002913236618,
0.02734418399631977,
-0.04065807908773422,
-0.02391623891890049,
0.04928223043680191,
0.023214183747768402,
0.048952821642160416,
-0.0034994224552065134,
0.0066666738130152225,
-0.0001497774792369455,
0.010405122302472591,
-0.010608977638185024,
0.185508593916893,
-0.023006148636341095,
-0.017840303480625153,
0.022418919950723648,
-0.006066997069865465,
-0.023489343002438545,
-0.01032140664756298,
0.055312350392341614,
0.0404934361577034,
-0.024570398032665253,
-0.0910569503903389,
0.011361136101186275,
0.03939902409911156,
0.028397973626852036,
-0.02208956703543663,
-0.0026382210198789835,
-0.019527683034539223,
-0.04560498520731926,
0.06625920534133911,
-0.00930566992610693,
0.06002795696258545,
0.040176764130592346,
-0.01719329133629799,
0.051852501928806305,
-0.02108081988990307,
0.0009239953942596912,
0.03610948473215103,
0.03578055649995804,
-0.02277488447725773,
-0.044290147721767426,
-0.003940328489989042,
0.01037990115582943,
0.01301418524235487,
-0.0022982032969594,
-0.019305270165205002,
-0.013944110833108425,
-0.06828009337186813,
0.02824574150145054,
0.007184125017374754,
0.055383067578077316,
0.001259126584045589,
-0.04635533317923546,
-0.038053542375564575,
0.02485894225537777,
0.02162581868469715,
0.0023334608413279057,
-0.006293096579611301,
-0.029891204088926315,
-0.0059528835117816925,
0.05177215114235878,
-0.018557993695139885,
0.04795306175947189,
-0.045015741139650345,
-0.013074520975351334,
-0.006200619041919708,
0.001407153788022697,
-0.015677789226174355,
0.021902363747358322,
-0.018972203135490417,
0.005500687286257744,
0.04023495689034462,
-0.011854792013764381,
-0.03296435624361038,
0.024983657523989677,
0.005155909340828657,
0.05492524802684784,
-0.05697058141231537,
-0.006862893234938383,
0.042076416313648224,
-0.014692961238324642,
0.042528800666332245,
0.027371369302272797,
-0.02084893360733986,
0.03411538898944855,
0.03374355658888817,
0.031038329005241394,
-0.022065062075853348,
0.04278048127889633,
-0.016892563551664352,
0.07814203202724457,
-0.008519189432263374,
-0.03385189548134804,
-0.012890434823930264,
0.027232768014073372,
0.020466124638915062,
-0.018131669610738754,
-0.009828740730881691,
0.017762303352355957,
0.01516815833747387,
0.008649828843772411,
-0.005009307060390711,
-0.016698429360985756,
-0.022937998175621033,
0.030742062255740166,
-0.028482932597398758,
0.014794333837926388,
-0.005026944447308779,
-0.013121768832206726,
0.003232490736991167,
-0.05336557328701019,
0.014545812271535397,
-0.009746120311319828,
-0.017266057431697845,
-0.04041276499629021,
-0.003994391765445471,
0.008709654211997986,
0.011863619089126587,
0.02219761535525322,
-0.01545214094221592,
0.021790804341435432,
0.009137144312262535,
0.010364455170929432,
-0.036097634583711624,
0.05496787652373314,
0.03328685089945793,
0.03198422119021416,
-0.00982167012989521,
0.04518108814954758,
0.018144939094781876,
0.053572848439216614,
0.001899940543808043,
0.01772526279091835,
-0.041076693683862686,
-0.01187064591795206,
-0.010846459306776524,
0.07117718458175659,
-0.024266177788376808,
0.04580198600888252,
0.003990515600889921,
0.020652692764997482,
-0.013096882030367851,
-0.013521171174943447,
0.024297911673784256,
-0.016352325677871704,
0.014911015518009663,
0.008305058814585209,
0.04075200855731964,
0.01840306632220745,
-0.05718398839235306,
0.04257852956652641,
-0.004795628599822521,
-0.03071504458785057,
-0.03754337877035141,
-0.01187310740351677,
-0.0007133818580769002,
-0.01790669932961464,
-0.016387471929192543,
0.014178212732076645,
-0.034343887120485306,
-0.045085884630680084,
0.02805790863931179,
-0.030864238739013672,
-0.029081933200359344,
-0.0634501650929451,
0.009699038229882717,
0.004813309293240309,
-0.011360333301126957,
0.0027035539969801903,
0.002797919325530529,
0.004983214195817709,
0.010467262007296085,
0.022983748465776443,
0.02323232591152191,
0.03267635405063629,
0.00437598442658782,
0.05976031348109245,
-0.03947121277451515,
0.010522249154746532,
0.020205870270729065,
-0.0024694299791008234,
-0.04334500432014465,
-0.053855136036872864,
-0.05772162228822708,
0.053883202373981476,
0.06660035997629166,
0.03788352012634277,
0.04115430638194084,
0.017670342698693275,
0.008493451401591301,
-0.03355088457465172,
0.03738648071885109,
0.0023452588357031345,
-0.022931313142180443,
0.004035583231598139,
-0.04299088194966316,
0.02376144379377365,
0.022231614217162132,
-0.013640039600431919,
0.037675101310014725,
-0.035586029291152954,
0.012338179163634777,
0.032138142734766006,
0.010084790177643299,
-0.014044220559298992,
0.03294307366013527,
-0.027343537658452988,
-0.07139362394809723,
0.05518173798918724,
0.020248448476195335,
-0.036244671791791916,
-0.00933608878403902,
-0.001466521993279457,
0.031057609245181084,
-0.016864925622940063,
0.052294716238975525,
0.016331404447555542,
-0.014851748012006283,
0.053861238062381744,
-0.03244899958372116,
-0.06121247261762619,
0.003998942673206329,
-0.024724463000893593,
-0.014946301467716694,
0.019253645092248917,
-0.0009908744832500815,
0.010354502126574516,
0.014747388660907745,
0.04647262021899223,
0.04340487718582153,
-0.028225895017385483,
0.030027898028492928,
-0.02715287171304226,
-0.004092505667358637,
-0.03519565239548683,
0.02099538780748844,
-0.013260060921311378,
-0.022783715277910233,
-0.02072354219853878,
0.007915097288787365,
0.030055373907089233,
0.018371010199189186,
-0.05916496366262436,
0.018343662843108177,
-0.008415835909545422,
0.01702861674129963,
0.003816514275968075,
0.05545249581336975,
-0.01704956591129303,
-0.0013543837703764439,
-0.031847286969423294,
0.014246086589992046,
0.003960736095905304,
0.024804843589663506,
0.07092001289129257,
0.013261479325592518,
-0.009855369105935097,
0.012036575935781002,
-0.01707833632826805,
0.029637940227985382,
0.03923299163579941,
0.02224826067686081,
0.01314682699739933,
-0.016894375905394554,
-0.013321802951395512,
0.007275042589753866,
-0.003965666051954031,
0.021293453872203827,
0.01184053998440504,
-0.05272919312119484,
-0.04760913923382759,
-0.03771131858229637,
-0.009786630049347878,
0.012729167006909847,
-0.029297586530447006,
-0.021358082070946693,
-0.06648529320955276,
0.021200010553002357,
0.004503647796809673,
-0.041294846683740616,
0.016075963154435158,
-0.023086080327630043,
0.020838100463151932,
-0.022932957857847214,
-0.1024615690112114,
0.016078805550932884,
0.007702539209276438,
-0.023554734885692596,
0.05159958079457283,
0.018132556229829788,
0.024804048240184784,
0.03295661509037018,
0.0063659450970590115,
0.004416999872773886,
-0.007807525340467691,
0.014332669787108898,
-0.003188956994563341,
-0.0020520519465208054,
-0.006753949914127588,
-0.006975660566240549,
0.030218111351132393,
-0.022092433646321297,
0.014062467031180859,
0.014233953319489956,
0.026251377537846565,
-0.01605413295328617,
0.06044253334403038,
0.017215542495250702,
0.075394406914711,
-0.03273657336831093,
0.011675866320729256,
-0.03712683171033859,
0.031053872779011726,
-0.009231935255229473,
-0.08215697854757309,
-0.0393926165997982,
0.04767150431871414,
0.006439562886953354,
0.01114911213517189,
-0.014597484841942787,
0.005481428932398558,
0.005573189817368984,
0.011678141541779041,
-0.0025891943369060755,
-0.011318010278046131,
0.04584160074591637,
0.03261077031493187,
-0.023685283958911896,
0.028695397078990936,
-0.04498692974448204,
0.005112757906317711,
0.020413149148225784,
0.039517223834991455,
-0.040732551366090775,
0.02497520111501217,
-0.005528729874640703,
-0.03756879270076752,
0.05552620813250542,
-0.05991387367248535,
-0.03526749834418297,
0.003286737250164151,
-0.01299339160323143,
-0.009967160411179066,
-0.0016058003529906273,
-0.004082218743860722,
0.04400765150785446,
0.018016809597611427,
-0.02054019644856453,
-0.0031036590225994587,
0.04785935953259468,
-0.018361592665314674,
0.006688243243843317,
-0.05292189121246338,
0.034652229398489,
-0.022516701370477676,
0.0015151218976825476,
0.02304050512611866,
-0.018333086743950844,
0.01098848320543766,
0.026457270607352257,
0.031697649508714676,
0.029849907383322716,
-0.024959277361631393,
-0.01770123466849327,
-0.04554063081741333,
-0.012378162704408169,
0.007058644667267799,
-0.038821592926979065,
0.026533586904406548,
0.009288386441767216,
-0.020252419635653496,
-0.02060513384640217,
0.02727699838578701,
-0.04242531210184097,
0.03717600926756859,
0.03637206181883812,
-0.03817308321595192,
-0.03663845732808113,
0.012623424641788006,
0.020158451050519943,
0.021226536482572556,
0.020888039842247963,
-0.02347063086926937,
-0.05237104371190071,
0.008748791180551052,
-0.030087992548942566,
-0.009503445588052273,
0.025544658303260803,
0.027112377807497978,
-0.03155595064163208,
0.0033122410532087088,
0.025188667699694633,
0.028447872027754784,
-0.03500065952539444,
-0.009590119123458862,
-0.012702703475952148,
-0.030568638816475868,
0.007297337520867586,
-0.017506802454590797,
0.0004729126230813563,
0.02630285546183586,
-0.01925954781472683,
0.039498232305049896,
-0.004391354508697987,
-0.004896904807537794,
-0.11834894120693207,
0.006007656455039978,
0.012558783404529095,
0.013475230894982815,
-0.008009374141693115,
0.013998085632920265,
-0.024785524234175682,
0.05163303762674332,
0.0006946766516193748,
-0.029564015567302704,
-0.04262938350439072,
-0.01862596720457077,
-0.03455088660120964,
-0.03484852612018585,
-0.006737932097166777,
-0.003788785543292761,
-0.005330024287104607,
-0.02992682345211506,
-0.03908875584602356,
0.026935581117868423,
0.03743872791528702,
-0.02224094048142433,
-0.02008327841758728,
-0.026749830693006516,
0.0029766904190182686,
-0.028756635263562202,
-0.04827321693301201,
-0.01076367124915123,
-0.043320465832948685,
-0.057876646518707275,
-0.01144847646355629,
-0.018269909545779228,
0.023232322186231613,
0.08167395740747452,
-0.04294044151902199,
0.03154820576310158,
0.028120175004005432,
-0.03829424828290939,
0.00954077485948801,
-0.029619527980685234,
-0.020668312907218933,
0.03680456802248955,
-0.029999254271388054,
0.03211281821131706,
-0.019115466624498367,
0.021570144221186638,
-0.03270436450839043,
-0.005051203537732363,
-0.06267832964658737,
-0.03560733050107956,
-0.0031474025454372168,
0.01229314599186182,
-0.013349069282412529,
0.02903943695127964,
0.018876124173402786,
-0.01951613277196884,
0.004528937395662069,
-0.03549749031662941,
0.03652622178196907,
0.030929245054721832,
0.027485618367791176,
0.015589711256325245,
-0.020919999107718468,
-0.019742107018828392,
-0.01736663468182087,
-0.015755603089928627,
-0.06137830391526222,
-0.03919268399477005,
-0.002353228162974119,
0.012230755761265755,
-0.03450090065598488,
-0.0018373416969552636,
0.01680828630924225,
0.03429436683654785,
0.014616628177464008,
0.023578917607665062,
0.013086305931210518,
0.008130832575261593,
-0.05775180831551552,
0.011625286191701889,
-0.05842573940753937,
0.0476565882563591,
0.0014589903876185417,
0.0026273636613041162,
0.06587867438793182,
0.03875260800123215,
0.03699151799082756,
0.0048836711794137955,
0.02804567851126194,
0.013409404084086418,
-0.07655897736549377,
0.006702365819364786,
-0.024574751034379005,
-0.020098699256777763,
-0.00997118093073368,
-0.0014292997075244784,
-0.006002245005220175,
-0.0018223256338387728,
0.015124154277145863,
-0.011357109062373638,
-0.06970275938510895,
-0.026105158030986786,
0.0031416432466357946,
0.003944003488868475,
-0.020594213157892227,
0.009631665423512459,
0.047235943377017975,
-0.026049837470054626,
0.02642415091395378,
-0.025307586416602135,
0.020563360303640366,
0.000771764141973108,
-0.028725339099764824,
0.05627455562353134,
-0.01336404774338007,
0.02525177411735058,
-0.0036464519798755646,
-0.014117649756371975,
0.018423408269882202,
0.028413088992238045,
-0.008692738600075245,
0.02530626393854618,
-0.010147209279239178,
-0.049023520201444626,
-0.030295921489596367,
-0.0333576500415802,
0.026098448783159256,
0.0157888513058424,
-0.017789674922823906,
-0.07002116739749908,
0.009185995906591415,
0.06693858653306961,
0.005565513391047716,
0.023481804877519608,
0.01370382308959961,
0.03524409607052803,
0.01669168286025524,
0.030738811939954758,
-0.014604168012738228,
-0.031180867925286293,
-0.008349470794200897,
-0.0038975519128143787,
-0.026491856202483177,
0.00407665129750967,
-0.010611100122332573,
0.05958082526922226,
0.03620345517992973,
-0.004590948577970266,
-0.0071710217744112015,
0.004309885669499636,
0.004282558336853981,
0.002637433586642146,
-0.01950840651988983,
0.05579680949449539,
0.050227947533130646,
-0.05710180848836899,
0.014526145532727242,
-0.009555325843393803,
0.015712181106209755,
-0.0030087826307862997,
0.002780413953587413,
-0.0025185858830809593,
-0.06637614965438843,
0.003943637013435364,
-0.026909582316875458,
0.0014016698114573956,
-0.013731294311583042,
0.01739376224577427,
-0.04530789330601692,
-0.028458259999752045,
0.005533422343432903,
-0.01911051757633686,
-0.04359419643878937,
-0.013847490772604942,
0.01979784481227398,
0.019390730187296867,
-0.013373762369155884,
0.062058888375759125,
0.030820516869425774,
-0.015273799188435078,
0.037549376487731934,
0.025972452014684677,
0.008525503799319267,
0.04008098691701889,
-0.037381142377853394,
0.03995301574468613,
0.029490482062101364,
0.045844562351703644,
0.02759530022740364,
-0.05850736051797867,
-0.039204828441143036,
0.02686743065714836,
-0.019880250096321106,
-0.04383218288421631,
0.009120253846049309,
0.030428728088736534,
0.006430150009691715,
0.030111242085695267,
0.03371810540556908,
0.020375099033117294,
0.021988840773701668,
-0.04413541033864021,
-0.03155945986509323,
-0.021030355244874954,
-0.03193151205778122,
-0.03584397956728935,
-0.022447830066084862,
-0.021380795165896416,
-0.020834943279623985,
0.025111675262451172,
-0.014317392371594906,
-0.014999027363955975,
-0.021489044651389122,
0.022684039548039436,
-0.03876045346260071,
0.03245916962623596,
-0.05489804223179817,
-0.02695995569229126,
0.03573479875922203,
-0.003209009999409318,
0.003383732633665204,
0.044172659516334534,
-0.04372010380029678,
-0.029374727979302406,
0.018330255523324013,
0.012333315797150135,
-0.025353679433465004,
0.005551759619265795,
-0.03953954949975014,
-0.029364297166466713,
0.004061567131429911,
0.02055557444691658,
-0.008742542006075382,
0.048381149768829346,
-0.005540549289435148,
-0.043823275715112686,
0.00860864482820034,
0.0017384187085554004,
-0.04683925583958626,
-0.053537577390670776,
0.017112676054239273,
0.00921429879963398,
-0.0031782027799636126,
0.008377312682569027
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:5
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
(c)HTT had acquired legal ownership of the Land with notice of LEC's "continuing equitable interest" in the Land and with notice of alleged breaches by Mr Hulley and Mr Hickie.
72HTT did not file a defence in the 2001 Proceedings. No affidavits were filed in the 2001 Proceedings and there was no discovery between LEC and HTT.
73By Notice of Motion dated 11 March 2003, HTT sought an order that LEC provide security for costs of the proceedings in an amount of approximately $230,000. Other defendants made similar applications for security.
74In August 2003, LEC received advice from Counsel that because LEC was in receivership, it was likely that it would be ordered to provide security for costs.
75On 11 September 2003, LEC instructed its then solicitor to offer some $82,500 for security, on a staged basis.
76It appears that this aspect of the proceedings was overtaken by settlement discussions. Certainly, the security for costs applications were never dealt with by the Court. The likely effect of the security for costs applications is considered further below in the context of the HTT Defendants' submissions as to the likely fate of the 2001 Proceedings.
77Ultimately, the 2001 Proceedings were settled by the relevant parties entering into the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed and by consenting to dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings.
Negotiations to settle the 2001 Proceedings
78On 10 September 2003, HTT's then solicitor, Mr Brian Gillard ("Mr Gillard"), wrote to LEC's then solicitor, Mr Derek Hilliard ("Mr Hilliard"), suggesting that a meeting take place between the parties to see:-
"...whether a suitable arrangement can be agreed to resolve the issues between them".
79There then commenced discussions between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall (who had been appointed a director of HTT on 20 December 1999) to endeavour to settle the 2001 Proceedings.
80The broad basis of discussions that ensued was the possibility of Mr Zdrilic, Mr Renshall and Mr Hickie resolving their differences (and the 2001 Proceedings) by entering into a joint venture, in which each of them would have an interest, in relation to the further rehabilitation and redevelopment of the Land.
The representations
81The plaintiffs claim that between 29 January 2004 and 27 August 2004 HTT made a series of seventeen representations. Many of the representations were allegedly made by Mr Renshall in conversations with Mr Zdrilic. The plaintiffs claim that in reliance on these representations, they entered into the Heads of Agreement, the Non-Dilution Deed and agreed to dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings.
82The plaintiffs claim that at the time of making the representations, HTT and Mr Renshall, or either of them, acted as agent for Mr Renshall's company, Devubo, and as agent for Mr Hickie and his company, Vocifa.
83Alternatively, the plaintiffs claim that HTT made the representations and that Mr Renshall was "involved" in the misleading or deceptive conduct said to arise from them within the meaning of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 75B ("the Act").
84The plaintiffs claim that the representations were made at a time when HTT was involved in dealings with a New Zealand company, IBIS Investment Bank ("IBIS") and a related company, Investment Protection Cover Inc ("IPC"), as trustee for the IPC Joint Venture Trust.
85On 15 March 2004, HTT and IPC entered into an agreement called "Heads of Agreement" ("the IPC Heads of Agreement") pursuant to which it was agreed that IPC would purchase at least 51 per cent of the shares in HTT and the units in the Huntley Trust and pay out HTT's loans.
It was further agreed that after the acquisition by IPC of those shares and units, IPC would be responsible for and provide all working capital in respect of the Project.
86Broadly speaking, the negotiations between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall had, as their object, the settlement of the 2001 Proceedings and also the removal of a caveat that LEC had lodged on the title of the Land on 23 April 2003 ("the Caveat").
|
[
-0.008924832567572594,
0.03797639161348343,
-0.032443445175886154,
0.005235353484749794,
-0.01667693443596363,
-0.00932726077735424,
-0.021488772705197334,
-0.048671022057533264,
0.022589029744267464,
-0.008820446208119392,
-0.007753678597509861,
0.05666393041610718,
-0.032521795481443405,
0.00850141141563654,
-0.010309053584933281,
-0.03039846383035183,
0.04806504771113396,
-0.025658993050456047,
0.003603304037824273,
-0.01128275878727436,
0.014763657934963703,
-0.020070279017090797,
-0.020292052999138832,
0.027123458683490753,
-0.010053008794784546,
-0.022824322804808617,
-0.01637638546526432,
0.024862168356776237,
0.020928559824824333,
0.023824818432331085,
-0.0007091746083460748,
0.005298097152262926,
0.05067925155162811,
-0.023494234308600426,
-0.020957227796316147,
0.005989448167383671,
0.01888984814286232,
0.034692153334617615,
-0.04012444615364075,
-0.007187619339674711,
0.014490318484604359,
0.016166619956493378,
0.02375851757824421,
-0.010551146231591702,
0.05473480001091957,
-0.03799499571323395,
-0.003930292092263699,
-0.02647528052330017,
-0.004563824273645878,
0.005245384760200977,
-0.009454076178371906,
-0.026712404564023018,
0.048402056097984314,
-0.03718264028429985,
-0.0015951956156641245,
-0.005665695760399103,
-0.012459400109946728,
-0.02162989228963852,
-0.06508561968803406,
0.010166068561375141,
0.009770175442099571,
-0.01629079133272171,
-0.05475233122706413,
-0.0058737643994390965,
0.0052365646697580814,
0.1155351847410202,
-0.0025210250169038773,
-0.006653671618551016,
0.00951069500297308,
-0.01063578948378563,
-0.06234251335263252,
-0.035024285316467285,
-0.035560935735702515,
0.005588989704847336,
-0.09139590710401535,
0.012632140889763832,
0.01172566320747137,
0.01433582417666912,
0.039476167410612106,
0.030536847189068794,
0.02847089059650898,
-0.02140478976070881,
-0.018791738897562027,
0.050695791840553284,
-0.015315376222133636,
0.04260007292032242,
-0.030592503026127815,
0.041213445365428925,
0.023636722937226295,
-0.05405321344733238,
-0.013329712674021721,
0.005262407474219799,
0.008683416061103344,
-0.0253065824508667,
-0.008180019445717335,
-0.00584448641166091,
-0.06348942220211029,
0.01893935352563858,
-0.007357720751315355,
0.008927586488425732,
0.007478015497326851,
0.009074289351701736,
-0.009155706502497196,
-0.04132766276597977,
0.015877077355980873,
0.03552998974919319,
0.015196810476481915,
0.02107292041182518,
0.017256103456020355,
0.011767128482460976,
-0.004090385045856237,
-0.040383655577898026,
0.001860791235230863,
-0.0038302214816212654,
-0.0013378121657297015,
-0.016186729073524475,
-0.0003734549100045115,
-0.01588299497961998,
0.021238673478364944,
0.0053617567755281925,
0.062339842319488525,
0.0369153693318367,
0.021259073168039322,
-0.0025403806939721107,
-0.03456621989607811,
0.010498984716832638,
0.013778194785118103,
-0.0022119018249213696,
0.014463324099779129,
0.0419161431491375,
-0.003400068962946534,
0.022735612466931343,
-0.02054634876549244,
-0.02909083478152752,
-0.03648525848984718,
-0.020832674577832222,
0.0016753586241975427,
-0.0018329794984310865,
0.03472591191530228,
-0.04199871048331261,
0.053538575768470764,
0.04659330099821091,
0.02760716713964939,
-0.026839489117264748,
0.02584109641611576,
0.002610647352412343,
-0.011541148647665977,
0.006396410055458546,
0.02812701091170311,
0.04211686924099922,
0.004668861161917448,
0.011294619180262089,
0.02858368679881096,
0.008141209371387959,
0.019894227385520935,
-0.029924925416707993,
-0.04236958920955658,
-0.04703117534518242,
0.06168697029352188,
0.06626157462596893,
-0.05755527690052986,
-0.002669063862413168,
-0.015432965941727161,
-0.005302867386490107,
-0.005331127438694239,
-0.03219344839453697,
-0.01519689243286848,
0.01238555833697319,
-0.03725762292742729,
0.023719126358628273,
0.034536439925432205,
-0.009208494797348976,
0.018306497484445572,
-0.030676547437906265,
-0.0028356595430523157,
0.02452624775469303,
0.0599658377468586,
0.01812354288995266,
-0.008137289434671402,
-0.009943715296685696,
-0.04279765114188194,
-0.0016568511491641402,
0.015599341131746769,
-0.027546152472496033,
-0.030860284343361855,
0.0012226689141243696,
-0.023135466501116753,
0.005934691522270441,
-0.010755063034594059,
0.05740390345454216,
-0.009676354005932808,
-0.01242661289870739,
0.02426208183169365,
-0.0019994499161839485,
0.025798650458455086,
0.011626403778791428,
0.023004181683063507,
-0.03136276826262474,
0.028778858482837677,
0.002514071296900511,
-0.03944401070475578,
0.04723094031214714,
0.05694003403186798,
-0.03274986520409584,
-0.02266613394021988,
0.04108426719903946,
-0.005782549735158682,
-0.00040867243660613894,
-0.017412085086107254,
-0.05773220956325531,
-0.0023247867356985807,
0.028033148497343063,
0.03203792870044708,
0.0010546330595389009,
0.007484466768801212,
0.011898167431354523,
0.016319166868925095,
0.003047112375497818,
0.015780197456479073,
-0.016629690304398537,
-0.040209703147411346,
-0.029836595058441162,
-0.0015642266953364015,
0.010558722540736198,
0.048482779413461685,
0.06047351285815239,
-0.025797666981816292,
0.023441554978489876,
-0.01065902877599001,
-0.010055696591734886,
0.006332957651466131,
-0.006324403919279575,
0.003542770631611347,
-0.03671388328075409,
0.027849722653627396,
0.04733867198228836,
0.03664756566286087,
0.027496082708239555,
0.0344635508954525,
0.04117872565984726,
-0.03212372958660126,
0.05215129628777504,
-0.016891270875930786,
-0.031009502708911896,
-0.03381286561489105,
-0.016281437128782272,
-0.018968315795063972,
0.034991588443517685,
0.04269187152385712,
-0.021164344623684883,
-0.020564043894410133,
-0.01690647564828396,
-0.006274404004216194,
0.015168826095759869,
0.009227965027093887,
0.03710049018263817,
-0.003960040397942066,
-0.0052428781054914,
0.015795428305864334,
0.028448987752199173,
0.009416541084647179,
0.0030808148439973593,
0.0523366741836071,
0.008083263412117958,
-0.018255440518260002,
0.023650366812944412,
-0.03079976886510849,
-0.04728817194700241,
0.015640147030353546,
0.01199241355061531,
0.015177535824477673,
0.011346178129315376,
0.017433470115065575,
0.03323698788881302,
0.04644200950860977,
0.012171518988907337,
0.016073040664196014,
0.020778393372893333,
-0.03405895456671715,
0.007720192428678274,
0.01790008507668972,
-0.002333019394427538,
0.019166996702551842,
-0.0398479625582695,
0.017470771446824074,
0.046374812722206116,
0.001526696258224547,
-0.03322519734501839,
0.0605635866522789,
-0.03193850815296173,
-0.01180846244096756,
-0.017333470284938812,
0.06954289227724075,
-0.013523831963539124,
-0.062310293316841125,
0.004739792086184025,
-0.008625037968158722,
-0.14554208517074585,
-0.004290958400815725,
-0.041484929621219635,
-0.004281381145119667,
-0.005458975676447153,
-0.007848713546991348,
-0.047144774347543716,
-0.019692638888955116,
-0.04114454612135887,
0.022650055587291718,
-0.014083653688430786,
-0.058935750275850296,
-0.006457735784351826,
0.024432413280010223,
0.0034984636586159468,
-0.019386516883969307,
-0.002097736345604062,
-0.0012954616686329246,
0.05472787469625473,
-0.02247229404747486,
-0.00818124134093523,
-0.02320868894457817,
0.07607764005661011,
0.01732845976948738,
0.011884856037795544,
0.017374826595187187,
0.019154982641339302,
-0.00810506846755743,
-0.04320281744003296,
0.013124977238476276,
-0.024366820231080055,
0.05127934738993645,
-0.023115532472729683,
0.04680713638663292,
0.005875863134860992,
-0.01269918866455555,
0.08007998019456863,
-0.05604339390993118,
-0.014979679137468338,
0.000574369914829731,
0.01759137213230133,
0.06050367280840874,
-0.0033567550126463175,
0.006384497974067926,
0.015038875862956047,
-0.06627734005451202,
-0.005106445401906967,
-0.023511435836553574,
-0.012479099445044994,
0.03325573354959488,
-0.01641031913459301,
0.03199739754199982,
-0.030426666140556335,
-0.07418147474527359,
0.00856691226363182,
-0.02415701188147068,
0.05061069130897522,
-0.009462950751185417,
-0.03364546224474907,
-0.00027501085423864424,
-0.006293758749961853,
-0.07294437289237976,
-0.0031840684823691845,
0.025605931878089905,
0.01905958727002144,
0.007169964723289013,
-0.010357811115682125,
-0.025109032168984413,
0.01422837283462286,
0.00732377590611577,
0.00960053876042366,
-0.0339643731713295,
-0.0022157367784529924,
-0.025936992838978767,
0.01739884726703167,
0.040213532745838165,
-0.050891149789094925,
0.0013258204562589526,
-0.03360235318541527,
-0.09334031492471695,
-0.02475704625248909,
0.012638960964977741,
-0.030388223007321358,
0.030041547492146492,
-0.008380508981645107,
0.022165954113006592,
0.04506581276655197,
0.028236662968993187,
0.021919945254921913,
0.23337790369987488,
0.018885556608438492,
-0.01920694299042225,
0.025373315438628197,
-0.00501226307824254,
-0.01056762970983982,
-0.001641166745685041,
0.04617159813642502,
-0.006518063601106405,
-0.05519538000226021,
-0.06175847724080086,
-0.009911262430250645,
-0.0004987278953194618,
0.023992862552404404,
-0.0606665164232254,
-0.017217498272657394,
-0.03388174623250961,
-0.01738940365612507,
0.054809920489788055,
0.012478428892791271,
0.017186123877763748,
0.008723150938749313,
-0.004568533040583134,
-0.017144136130809784,
-0.04722202569246292,
-0.033454686403274536,
0.017488697543740273,
0.06837650388479233,
-0.04264208674430847,
0.006621957290917635,
0.0021775830537080765,
-0.01346217654645443,
0.001479153404943645,
-0.0020828081760555506,
0.0035770260728895664,
0.012254619039595127,
-0.012480092234909534,
0.01040643360465765,
-0.002910612616688013,
0.014869039878249168,
-0.0017611496150493622,
-0.02995862066745758,
-0.03848147392272949,
-0.02016429789364338,
-0.05818672478199005,
0.06063780188560486,
-0.027324672788381577,
0.04561794549226761,
0.03558243811130524,
0.04457234963774681,
-0.027929013594985008,
0.03781897947192192,
-0.024197760969400406,
-0.03400960937142372,
-0.011634057387709618,
0.022397305816411972,
-0.025295361876487732,
0.016775764524936676,
0.006612719036638737,
0.026743611320853233,
0.012227500788867474,
0.02914411947131157,
-0.04505390673875809,
0.016175979748368263,
-0.007000105921179056,
-0.015733124688267708,
-0.0361330546438694,
-0.0025188634172081947,
0.07228105515241623,
0.04921352490782738,
0.06803645938634872,
0.029925622045993805,
-0.02003725990653038,
0.005149723496288061,
0.03583584725856781,
0.01987731084227562,
-0.015327679924666882,
0.0158360805362463,
-0.034453485161066055,
0.02733035385608673,
-0.043834663927555084,
-0.020659232512116432,
0.0036231193225830793,
0.039947234094142914,
0.008261166512966156,
0.012409202754497528,
-0.042901087552309036,
0.019413594156503677,
-0.016062185168266296,
-0.013350401073694229,
0.014419907703995705,
-0.020621197298169136,
0.00868623424321413,
0.013888894580304623,
-0.03798888996243477,
-0.018544137477874756,
0.0199869517236948,
-0.02318190410733223,
-0.03740144893527031,
-0.037482377141714096,
0.020732995122671127,
0.015424339100718498,
0.027354877442121506,
-0.06979280710220337,
0.016718324273824692,
-0.0023482211399823427,
-0.01906752586364746,
-0.002547281561419368,
-0.07322550565004349,
0.007848594337701797,
0.002924239030107856,
0.013392367400228977,
0.03515782207250595,
-0.027402363717556,
0.026592476293444633,
0.07618319988250732,
-0.002262546680867672,
0.05119109898805618,
0.03747452795505524,
0.03639927878975868,
0.05007144436240196,
-0.0019352578092366457,
-0.024170422926545143,
-0.016667338088154793,
0.014117282815277576,
0.01646929793059826,
-0.022390536963939667,
-0.026629935950040817,
0.017855588346719742,
0.01966208592057228,
-0.012171725742518902,
-0.01756439544260502,
-0.03472112864255905,
0.009816937148571014,
0.026103679090738297,
0.003726652590557933,
0.02521888166666031,
-0.017659975215792656,
-0.02787419781088829,
-0.006044575944542885,
-0.021857473999261856,
0.044368188828229904,
-0.0534108467400074,
0.006019338499754667,
0.011141352355480194,
0.0041239503771066666,
-0.05447441712021828,
0.015103627927601337,
-0.05213432013988495,
0.003955384716391563,
-0.0145597904920578,
-0.011860812082886696,
-0.02972381003201008,
-0.014607022516429424,
0.0016944226808845997,
0.019809473305940628,
-0.004482435993850231,
-0.010391413234174252,
-0.005361354909837246,
-0.015957701951265335,
-0.001909012207761407,
0.02272174134850502,
0.021672701463103294,
0.005481168162077665,
0.005825416650623083,
0.04518759995698929,
-0.02819806896150112,
0.06967364251613617,
0.03523750603199005,
-0.038170430809259415,
0.008562475442886353,
-0.03375716507434845,
-0.010162696242332458,
0.07305753976106644,
0.02929535321891308,
0.039424870163202286,
-0.01513621024787426,
-0.015371585264801979,
0.022280870005488396,
-0.025595281273126602,
0.03188122436404228,
-0.009314928203821182,
-0.04097691923379898,
0.010481071658432484,
0.002214680425822735,
-0.01711694337427616,
-0.0316510908305645,
-0.01068035326898098,
0.08384283632040024,
-0.05973721295595169,
-0.012419736944139004,
0.07870852202177048,
0.02079535275697708,
-0.015648141503334045,
0.005034405738115311,
0.016384055837988853,
-0.03505810722708702,
0.038386136293411255,
0.0017434725305065513,
-0.05808595195412636,
-0.02980133704841137,
0.021114923059940338,
0.011354770511388779,
-0.018764829263091087,
0.04210491105914116,
-0.010694469325244427,
-0.021113019436597824,
0.018000731244683266,
-0.05309366062283516,
-0.05663707107305527,
-0.0012472778325900435,
0.038622334599494934,
-0.023915626108646393,
0.02286609634757042,
-0.027309225872159004,
-0.01589064672589302,
-0.000672744819894433,
0.06460312008857727,
0.0074015953578054905,
-0.04732285067439079,
-0.0013091113651171327,
-0.023729002103209496,
0.03776981309056282,
-0.08880728483200073,
0.004338916391134262,
0.006284399423748255,
-0.015410199761390686,
-0.00945329014211893,
-0.05196726694703102,
-0.005646601784974337,
0.004779560025781393,
-0.06555300205945969,
0.0442252941429615,
-0.018329238519072533,
0.00433213310316205,
0.03483820706605911,
0.02066713012754917,
-0.007330743595957756,
0.04428193345665932,
-0.023172961547970772,
0.03839659318327904,
0.02246478572487831,
0.013147053308784962,
0.025379950180649757,
0.025229090824723244,
0.0056379083544015884,
-0.02956416830420494,
0.0111549636349082,
-0.022960396483540535,
0.03926851972937584,
-0.004166408907622099,
0.03858412057161331,
0.013042728416621685,
0.0015340413665398955,
0.048407431691884995,
0.015559629537165165,
0.053476229310035706,
-0.04643568396568298,
-0.04469951614737511,
-0.01618138700723648,
-0.019412627443671227,
0.02585524134337902,
0.029140640050172806,
0.005325654521584511,
-0.04133840277791023,
-0.028012961149215698,
0.030870694667100906,
-0.015021106228232384,
-0.031318485736846924,
0.008700096979737282,
0.02623620815575123,
-0.0025563803501427174,
-0.015190018340945244,
-0.035371724516153336,
-0.025793666020035744,
0.005087906960397959,
-0.031229643151164055,
0.008966425433754921,
0.0030495356768369675,
-0.011469575576484203,
-0.009781320579349995,
-0.034264057874679565,
0.018699923530220985,
0.028538234531879425,
-0.02983061783015728,
-0.026682063937187195,
-0.03805730119347572,
0.026006044819951057,
0.0008269690442830324,
0.030419114977121353,
0.006405319087207317,
0.0070464108139276505,
-0.0006320005049929023,
0.007822833955287933,
0.01520481240004301,
-0.017027126625180244,
-0.01478615589439869,
0.026250166818499565,
-0.003712483448907733,
-0.004657865036278963,
-0.042749278247356415,
-0.03172940015792847,
-0.04484567791223526,
-0.06281859427690506,
-0.02552918903529644,
0.023411793634295464,
0.01204532478004694,
0.010534337721765041,
-0.07739800959825516,
-0.006325706839561462,
0.015729879960417747,
-0.04953991249203682,
0.02435821108520031,
-0.056417446583509445,
0.035267915576696396,
0.0023288149386644363,
-0.005266016349196434,
-0.03028195910155773,
-0.016974369063973427,
-0.0047953384928405285,
-0.0010445163352414966,
-0.0034592256415635347,
-0.0525558777153492,
-0.028788728639483452,
-0.06403963267803192,
0.007952113635838032,
-0.009605037979781628,
-0.026200806722044945,
-0.005973502062261105,
0.005541571881622076,
-0.04206399247050285,
-0.0031412101816385984,
0.007273886352777481,
0.020418250933289528,
0.0621735043823719,
0.06689667701721191,
-0.009166717529296875,
0.01358725968748331,
0.026887547224760056,
-0.022363493219017982,
-0.022399375215172768,
-0.05153321474790573,
0.04295998439192772,
-0.009037788026034832,
0.012475193478167057,
0.019168920814990997,
0.0032536129001528025,
-0.01414181012660265,
0.024130692705512047,
-0.011856057681143284,
0.01696978136897087,
0.00010759160795714706,
-0.010958360508084297,
-0.04012589901685715,
0.015425416640937328,
-0.023205189034342766,
-0.000940594298299402,
0.015007715672254562,
0.023113394156098366,
-0.021826399490237236,
0.007778554689139128,
0.07372944802045822,
0.001362255890853703,
-0.017046308144927025,
0.018300628289580345,
-0.002795523963868618,
-0.006366222631186247,
0.02419820986688137,
0.02510303445160389,
0.010344968177378178,
0.009474731050431728,
-0.014340716414153576,
-0.02502778172492981,
0.028626464307308197,
-0.02155313640832901,
0.054724667221307755,
0.02665652520954609,
0.007901768200099468,
0.0065015824511647224,
-0.04636877402663231,
-0.013133764266967773,
-0.01599918119609356,
-0.043997861444950104,
-0.016817763447761536,
0.013891478069126606,
0.007711180951446295,
0.004010834265500307,
0.013642409816384315,
0.012197626754641533,
0.005964201409369707,
-0.0013478253968060017,
0.00648048659786582,
-0.027585649862885475,
0.0030381688848137856,
-0.11623109877109528,
-0.012751155532896519,
-0.005987375974655151,
-0.00042852284968830645,
0.005317118484526873,
-0.0023851250298321247,
0.0153795862570405,
0.01611468568444252,
-0.01651998609304428,
0.0045013707131147385,
0.0046055614948272705,
-0.052727967500686646,
0.017419829964637756,
-0.025561491027474403,
-0.03588750213384628,
-0.00019758514827117324,
-0.04086686298251152,
-0.03861386328935623,
-0.052114252001047134,
0.0014412697637453675,
0.030155915766954422,
0.028226951137185097,
-0.014155413024127483,
0.011666983366012573,
0.031034870073199272,
0.006203997414559126,
-0.0516669861972332,
-0.07600399851799011,
-0.039244163781404495,
-0.05169028788805008,
-0.04019928351044655,
-0.016667254269123077,
-0.002466576173901558,
0.055024970322847366,
-0.0039877560921013355,
0.01017138920724392,
0.014794793911278248,
-0.011328892782330513,
-0.02685541845858097,
-0.020711364224553108,
0.004440495744347572,
0.051716942340135574,
-0.05602534860372543,
-0.05507587641477585,
-0.018967000767588615,
0.02366749569773674,
-0.009092076681554317,
-0.0009799804538488388,
-0.08950565755367279,
-0.023401550948619843,
-0.04403412714600563,
0.019729740917682648,
0.020132698118686676,
0.024614321067929268,
0.04020017758011818,
-0.00801483541727066,
-0.0021352446638047695,
-0.011796028353273869,
0.026745373383164406,
0.023633692413568497,
-0.01559120137244463,
0.01903359405696392,
-0.035182107239961624,
0.008442766964435577,
0.009440749883651733,
0.0006058229482732713,
0.011534051038324833,
0.015983523800969124,
-0.039648592472076416,
0.013243450783193111,
0.004973028786480427,
-0.023666711524128914,
0.005369773134589195,
-0.04863216355443001,
0.03439441695809364,
-0.0284834373742342,
0.00983159989118576,
-0.004729511681944132,
-0.03557901829481125,
-0.02774379402399063,
-0.022590650245547295,
-0.024325741454958916,
-0.04597404971718788,
-0.02036021091043949,
0.05908773094415665,
0.028821593150496483,
-0.0017024569679051638,
-0.0025660183746367693,
0.02925768494606018,
-0.028442176058888435,
-0.0491621270775795,
-0.007677312474697828,
-0.04142431542277336,
0.03134090453386307,
-0.022382702678442,
0.011600657366216183,
0.0031871094834059477,
0.010231320746243,
-0.010081211104989052,
-0.017021846026182175,
-0.06411943584680557,
-0.011584553867578506,
0.052681226283311844,
-0.012160277925431728,
-0.032469384372234344,
0.020617816597223282,
0.014861881732940674,
-0.010500887408852577,
0.011770185083150864,
-0.02898739092051983,
-0.023003051057457924,
-0.007267145439982414,
-0.04220235347747803,
0.061253614723682404,
-0.008759118616580963,
-0.003864773316308856,
-0.003119824454188347,
0.006764380261301994,
0.01333790086209774,
0.010104972869157791,
0.00778815895318985,
0.013978783041238785,
-0.029088398441672325,
-0.01903453655540943,
0.0035332387778908014,
-0.008862906135618687,
0.10103701800107956,
0.021559232845902443,
0.05915805324912071,
0.020624354481697083,
0.03545994684100151,
-0.008081638254225254,
0.015585075132548809,
-0.009449359029531479,
0.01756221428513527,
-0.016809983178973198,
-0.014343907125294209,
0.011992593295872211,
-0.040183454751968384,
-0.014102050103247166,
-0.021999627351760864,
0.009119389578700066,
-0.0054779876954853535,
0.012624685652554035,
-0.0443776436150074,
0.006514846347272396,
0.030439510941505432,
-0.010023387148976326,
0.010578898712992668,
-0.06405902653932571,
-0.06356050074100494,
0.018598025664687157,
-0.034669168293476105,
0.06394168734550476,
0.006900601089000702,
-0.010005798190832138,
0.04876919835805893,
-0.014889867976307869,
0.03595359995961189,
0.03475382924079895,
0.03037291020154953,
-0.02976469323039055,
-0.03963163122534752,
-0.020870758220553398,
-0.027945619076490402,
0.009458395652472973,
-0.019615616649389267,
0.00020721403416246176,
-0.023492513224482536,
-0.04606359824538231,
-0.02077152580022812,
0.04788339510560036,
-0.017971869558095932,
0.01951950043439865,
0.05248386785387993,
-0.0047456007450819016,
0.00929745938628912,
-0.011008505709469318,
0.0713740661740303,
-0.029506070539355278,
0.05095018073916435,
0.052734583616256714,
0.009105732664465904,
0.011499060317873955,
-0.022959858179092407,
0.017486322671175003,
0.028199052438139915,
0.048484716564416885,
-0.046188756823539734,
-0.036605000495910645,
-0.03084026649594307,
-0.01624421589076519,
-0.01090261060744524,
-0.022075828164815903,
-0.014444975182414055,
0.013261258602142334,
0.014080694876611233,
-0.016993448138237,
-0.019295597448945045,
-0.0010012785205617547,
0.004570238292217255,
-0.011404676362872124,
-0.06367532908916473,
-0.028941728174686432,
-0.021657753735780716,
0.03298955038189888,
-0.009590985253453255,
-0.04899030551314354,
-0.007924092002213001,
0.03636462613940239,
-0.026148729026317596,
-0.009296784177422523,
-0.02356886863708496,
0.032965369522571564,
0.0009518793667666614,
0.010508788749575615,
0.03937770798802376,
-0.03444308787584305,
0.033442460000514984,
-0.025874998420476913,
0.007750190328806639,
0.05546180531382561,
-0.040366966277360916,
-0.0007464478258043528,
0.003320354735478759,
0.01283726654946804,
0.025323837995529175,
0.007474913261830807,
0.014141908846795559,
0.009753838181495667,
-0.012597549706697464,
-0.009873449802398682,
0.012733548879623413,
0.033080220222473145,
-0.001533216331154108,
-0.0646594688296318,
-0.038876261562108994,
-0.0145635437220335,
-0.024439100176095963,
0.004598524421453476,
0.05162043496966362,
0.0007697045220993459,
0.03422214463353157,
0.012291672639548779
] |
What was the purpose of the discussions between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall in relation to the 2001 Proceedings?
|
[
-0.02402898482978344,
0.0010178758529946208,
-0.023634251207113266,
0.009857148863375187,
-0.009114563465118408,
-0.03102494776248932,
0.026371074840426445,
-0.059016674757003784,
0.014075834304094315,
0.008977335877716541,
-0.026222508400678635,
0.07264669239521027,
-0.04165787622332573,
0.020332058891654015,
0.008707993663847446,
-0.00557299517095089,
0.06438608467578888,
-0.05591811239719391,
0.019900785759091377,
-0.020748287439346313,
0.03483111411333084,
-0.017082517966628075,
0.0006070657982490957,
0.039932336658239365,
0.018297605216503143,
-0.021353980526328087,
-0.013462867587804794,
0.03425055742263794,
0.042235687375068665,
0.0054365498945117,
-0.007078981958329678,
0.043885912746191025,
0.04200097545981407,
-0.015195528976619244,
0.015963761135935783,
-0.019646333530545235,
0.041467998176813126,
-0.005336385685950518,
-0.03495466709136963,
-0.018079061061143875,
-0.020576318725943565,
-0.030399193987250328,
0.023044897243380547,
-0.00862364936619997,
0.015619564801454544,
-0.03581371530890465,
-0.03962422162294388,
-0.00645452318713069,
0.017939826473593712,
-0.005109092686325312,
-0.04382799565792084,
-0.017772555351257324,
0.04483330249786377,
-0.029228374361991882,
0.00007978326902957633,
0.006697370670735836,
-0.014131623320281506,
-0.033500391989946365,
-0.045046061277389526,
0.03877625986933708,
0.0232340507209301,
-0.005760472267866135,
-0.02254630997776985,
-0.002911702264100313,
0.015019758604466915,
0.08787823468446732,
0.023581931367516518,
-0.04526485502719879,
0.008152923546731472,
-0.0010021236957982183,
-0.028460372239351273,
-0.008040416985750198,
-0.017959674820303917,
0.015253495424985886,
-0.07082656025886536,
0.023197459056973457,
0.06444872915744781,
-0.010008471086621284,
0.0498330183327198,
0.049299273639917374,
0.04061427712440491,
-0.009338770061731339,
0.004829930607229471,
0.02147054113447666,
0.03106110729277134,
0.0647839680314064,
-0.055299751460552216,
0.044127222150564194,
0.014864056371152401,
-0.05242493748664856,
-0.013630878180265427,
0.01783435232937336,
-0.027992451563477516,
-0.04578327387571335,
-0.031197231262922287,
0.0007776854326948524,
-0.08521504700183868,
0.012700892984867096,
0.01785668171942234,
0.040408264845609665,
0.04209841042757034,
0.009324910119175911,
-0.055599674582481384,
-0.0435103178024292,
0.03513883799314499,
0.05276327580213547,
0.0441589318215847,
0.022470705211162567,
-0.013121291995048523,
-0.0034213997423648834,
-0.017743460834026337,
0.027823688462376595,
-0.02910008653998375,
-0.005725812632590532,
-0.014374262653291225,
-0.042930588126182556,
-0.037327807396650314,
0.018846644088625908,
0.05322083458304405,
-0.0031375105027109385,
0.052451811730861664,
0.04448592662811279,
-0.005858300253748894,
-0.013042264617979527,
-0.04306977242231369,
0.035830315202474594,
0.03507542610168457,
-0.014195039868354797,
0.02903212234377861,
-0.01279410533607006,
0.008302861824631691,
0.03064926527440548,
-0.002299232641234994,
-0.04858458414673805,
0.025379376485943794,
-0.02192116342484951,
-0.009604966267943382,
-0.0030033946968615055,
0.0006572233396582305,
-0.040864259004592896,
0.01615123823285103,
-0.00019893399439752102,
0.029857033863663673,
-0.02526293694972992,
-0.024715805426239967,
-0.013101578690111637,
-0.034780293703079224,
0.01733853481709957,
0.031834185123443604,
0.04038557782769203,
-0.0009058975847437978,
-0.011296995915472507,
0.03679709509015083,
0.014068960212171078,
0.0015717821661382914,
0.0078757144510746,
-0.03583969920873642,
-0.008675756864249706,
-0.0024891698267310858,
0.06243078410625458,
-0.001726685673929751,
-0.0037995553575456142,
-0.0134921595454216,
0.005856200587004423,
0.020893843844532967,
0.02234920673072338,
0.0071576745249331,
0.04864848405122757,
-0.01643349416553974,
0.005325887352228165,
-0.002110173227265477,
-0.054021626710891724,
0.0551505982875824,
0.010708789341151714,
0.013494109734892845,
0.0038944107946008444,
0.05539883300662041,
0.00005009801316191442,
-0.0039484878070652485,
-0.03476158156991005,
-0.04991834610700607,
0.05591758340597153,
0.020028218626976013,
-0.048367198556661606,
-0.018654409795999527,
-0.02831331454217434,
-0.017520930618047714,
-0.04468495398759842,
-0.005204873625189066,
0.05664202198386192,
-0.015609889291226864,
0.009496367536485195,
-0.034539658576250076,
0.010265943594276905,
0.062382400035858154,
0.022953975945711136,
-0.010089593008160591,
-0.04247110337018967,
-0.02491852454841137,
-0.028004219755530357,
-0.015230599790811539,
0.02117476612329483,
0.09226343035697937,
0.0011600700672715902,
-0.0014232108369469643,
0.00028034293791279197,
-0.04691533371806145,
0.012259376235306263,
-0.016902323812246323,
0.009990171529352665,
-0.0141054168343544,
0.03866216167807579,
-0.042754437774419785,
-0.02831660583615303,
-0.0053963130339980125,
0.0077587394043803215,
-0.010061108507215977,
-0.00435339892283082,
-0.013640627264976501,
0.0014853418106213212,
-0.025799954310059547,
0.05012490972876549,
-0.021624790504574776,
-0.05209757760167122,
0.03793007880449295,
-0.026947781443595886,
-0.08311102539300919,
0.012660459615290165,
-0.03144635632634163,
-0.003999507054686546,
0.013789978809654713,
-0.03271298110485077,
0.010634935460984707,
-0.038944974541664124,
-0.020611241459846497,
0.055207509547472,
0.016121789813041687,
0.018405750393867493,
-0.0031669402960687876,
0.004523978102952242,
-0.07185206562280655,
-0.001067042350769043,
-0.009038320742547512,
-0.00876869261264801,
-0.0548272430896759,
-0.01978970319032669,
0.020647117868065834,
0.022261906415224075,
0.038224272429943085,
0.00723292026668787,
0.03165134787559509,
0.023063216358423233,
-0.03713519498705864,
0.012728938832879066,
0.03722864389419556,
-0.01024635974317789,
0.03469877690076828,
-0.00041938177309930325,
0.012506017461419106,
-0.01120828464627266,
0.05683865770697594,
-0.0034561781212687492,
0.03685753047466278,
0.0027732071466743946,
-0.02395733818411827,
0.01365272980183363,
-0.023751508444547653,
-0.01786499284207821,
0.038068488240242004,
-0.027433784678578377,
-0.018880857154726982,
0.020528683438897133,
-0.005594996269792318,
0.014124053530395031,
0.011251800693571568,
-0.008837155997753143,
-0.016522681340575218,
0.06827489286661148,
0.016010841354727745,
0.07122889906167984,
0.025388531386852264,
-0.03184992074966431,
0.03174011781811714,
-0.007163153495639563,
-0.032245125621557236,
-0.005863344296813011,
-0.04642486199736595,
-0.03267010673880577,
-0.021399399265646935,
0.003523288294672966,
-0.025211164727807045,
-0.002314632525667548,
0.05119480565190315,
-0.006940523162484169,
-0.06763667613267899,
0.012331211939454079,
-0.02667921967804432,
-0.1039574071764946,
0.00397093640640378,
-0.0645393654704094,
0.014153048396110535,
-0.025790948420763016,
-0.026768648996949196,
-0.01115286536514759,
0.007578789256513119,
-0.09388936311006546,
-0.0042794086039066315,
0.022307811304926872,
-0.03840651363134384,
-0.011200170032680035,
0.018179547041654587,
0.006942008621990681,
-0.009558758698403835,
0.022317765280604362,
-0.011484473012387753,
0.005335371941328049,
-0.02364441379904747,
-0.011784285306930542,
-0.07679919898509979,
0.04447079077363014,
0.05798330530524254,
0.04046671837568283,
-0.016529474407434464,
-0.05319228023290634,
-0.005094734951853752,
-0.023693375289440155,
0.033036716282367706,
0.033775411546230316,
0.036148156970739365,
-0.0022626814898103476,
0.03523696959018707,
-0.0040457602590322495,
-0.011170239187777042,
0.04082199186086655,
-0.015280465595424175,
-0.05422857403755188,
-0.01763230189681053,
0.0376613587141037,
0.04316796362400055,
-0.0037784436717629433,
0.024009307846426964,
0.015206080861389637,
-0.005580897908657789,
0.011703585274517536,
-0.04484420269727707,
0.05391473323106766,
-0.002700724871829152,
-0.0008617650019004941,
0.01368572749197483,
0.004041676875203848,
-0.04998451843857765,
0.005235584918409586,
0.004837451968342066,
0.03958139568567276,
-0.0026547550223767757,
-0.02994035929441452,
-0.03452910855412483,
-0.06124334782361984,
-0.006506340112537146,
-0.042110517621040344,
-0.011114166118204594,
0.0017973602516576648,
0.019630515947937965,
-0.0007656760280951858,
-0.012770233675837517,
0.010938985273241997,
0.04376029595732689,
-0.01385617908090353,
-0.002503400668501854,
-0.01847860962152481,
-0.005609083920717239,
0.0133223757147789,
0.026182306930422783,
-0.06366885453462601,
-0.0030357216019183397,
-0.024625010788440704,
-0.048926159739494324,
0.021269120275974274,
0.008304535411298275,
0.009502571076154709,
-0.04116734489798546,
-0.0027486723847687244,
0.0258436668664217,
0.03047221712768078,
0.0876850038766861,
-0.018315190449357033,
0.18059659004211426,
0.026024600490927696,
-0.0032859162893146276,
-0.014539355412125587,
0.03623593971133232,
-0.04569421708583832,
0.039694566279649734,
0.041980426758527756,
-0.015676124021410942,
-0.03849617391824722,
-0.03154876083135605,
-0.05239800736308098,
-0.0014958013780415058,
0.016083410009741783,
-0.03069835714995861,
-0.012041442096233368,
-0.05206304043531418,
-0.002993533154949546,
0.05601762980222702,
0.005986794363707304,
0.03289953991770744,
0.045949745923280716,
-0.013949773274362087,
-0.012746226973831654,
0.014902578666806221,
-0.009667913429439068,
-0.00003099919922533445,
0.01991729624569416,
-0.053674157708883286,
-0.004713781177997589,
-0.011881427839398384,
-0.008635297417640686,
0.000039424936403520405,
0.004088688176125288,
0.01248273067176342,
0.0010769107611849904,
-0.0440773069858551,
0.013660788536071777,
0.08354155719280243,
0.0020919744856655598,
0.006284484639763832,
-0.03192732110619545,
-0.007971138693392277,
-0.018151095137000084,
0.005405094474554062,
-0.015784190967679024,
-0.013934086076915264,
-0.0019395166309550405,
-0.0181626807898283,
0.010967765934765339,
0.018891816958785057,
0.024615678936243057,
-0.013416914269328117,
-0.028566041961312294,
-0.004381264094263315,
0.023932788521051407,
0.004943654406815767,
0.011714333668351173,
0.008009648881852627,
0.03433768078684807,
0.018659912049770355,
0.01941792294383049,
-0.03054909221827984,
0.01848657801747322,
-0.02680334262549877,
0.014932542107999325,
-0.05280017852783203,
-0.04558146744966507,
0.015162120573222637,
-0.01655394583940506,
0.03913518786430359,
0.04062603786587715,
0.004844091832637787,
-0.02710595726966858,
0.005540269427001476,
0.056431155651807785,
0.022379891946911812,
0.009820893406867981,
-0.011258085258305073,
0.01010635681450367,
0.025067755952477455,
-0.036282334476709366,
-0.01207316480576992,
0.03561071306467056,
0.014885646291077137,
-0.00890527293086052,
-0.020017264410853386,
0.018470503389835358,
-0.02155023254454136,
0.004041176754981279,
0.03411117568612099,
-0.00583314336836338,
-0.022290842607617378,
0.00403200276196003,
0.024746738374233246,
-0.003083537332713604,
-0.022387711331248283,
-0.03825767710804939,
-0.036328110843896866,
-0.039873700588941574,
-0.01397527102380991,
-0.014299226924777031,
0.004444485064595938,
-0.0505140982568264,
0.00615299167111516,
0.005475686863064766,
0.002734281588345766,
-0.004745511803776026,
-0.03151242807507515,
0.007517147343605757,
-0.002556807128712535,
0.029790112748742104,
-0.008312081918120384,
0.007205780129879713,
0.009632319211959839,
0.04719054698944092,
0.03274309262633324,
0.02186577022075653,
-0.001523347687907517,
0.04302377253770828,
0.03412896767258644,
0.05943675711750984,
-0.026954464614391327,
0.011742835864424706,
-0.02132715843617916,
0.0542650930583477,
-0.011962000280618668,
-0.006793423090130091,
0.03655140846967697,
0.0025274932850152254,
0.01190202310681343,
0.0016572560416534543,
0.03275739401578903,
0.003871449502184987,
0.06110706925392151,
0.024395735934376717,
-0.003720234613865614,
-0.033207982778549194,
-0.057953692972660065,
0.036033354699611664,
-0.0011888152221217752,
-0.03345826268196106,
-0.04032048210501671,
0.0021032621152698994,
-0.0034875127021223307,
0.03566479682922363,
-0.0354892872273922,
0.05412127077579498,
-0.015151971019804478,
0.0025082703214138746,
0.005154975224286318,
-0.022122643887996674,
-0.0632719099521637,
-0.028760788962244987,
0.01909736730158329,
0.05337979272007942,
-0.008353287354111671,
0.006150325294584036,
0.02969169057905674,
-0.028302868828177452,
0.02449784055352211,
0.011745648458600044,
0.009473546408116817,
0.03434418886899948,
0.0064872391521930695,
0.06675688922405243,
-0.04075964167714119,
0.10234721750020981,
0.032088931649923325,
-0.0314505398273468,
-0.006761506199836731,
-0.04394941031932831,
-0.05783946439623833,
0.04526538401842117,
0.029613422229886055,
0.026118090376257896,
0.0007155032362788916,
-0.007152164354920387,
-0.011552819050848484,
0.00836145505309105,
0.012856529094278812,
0.01965939998626709,
0.0004591401375364512,
0.023921802639961243,
-0.016137197613716125,
0.02753502130508423,
0.023042645305395126,
-0.024149669334292412,
0.026852792128920555,
-0.028397364541888237,
-0.0009538333397358656,
0.05761905387043953,
0.03799930959939957,
0.0059747761115431786,
-0.0007163772825151682,
-0.01365424133837223,
0.017287854105234146,
0.04365787282586098,
0.030698928982019424,
-0.010458575561642647,
-0.023282365873456,
-0.006989318877458572,
0.038553155958652496,
-0.04094257578253746,
0.040178168565034866,
0.01297708973288536,
-0.006482514552772045,
0.05727246403694153,
-0.029589928686618805,
-0.04393472895026207,
-0.004997421056032181,
-0.015194328501820564,
-0.008781461045145988,
0.06452913582324982,
-0.007250461261719465,
0.03403293341398239,
-0.04016680270433426,
0.07072953879833221,
0.02637900412082672,
-0.03550481051206589,
0.017616944387555122,
-0.009163560345768929,
0.014217677526175976,
-0.009776639752089977,
0.001355157932266593,
-0.0018168482929468155,
-0.019227420911192894,
0.0022278279066085815,
-0.009407482109963894,
0.015745703130960464,
0.01108579058200121,
0.009213387034833431,
0.05307743325829506,
-0.057085875421762466,
0.024592334404587746,
0.03829987719655037,
-0.01842343993484974,
-0.016555853188037872,
0.01678558439016342,
-0.007849412970244884,
-0.00759885972365737,
-0.0031836049165576696,
-0.00858202576637268,
0.004549349192529917,
0.026607301086187363,
-0.0028644597623497248,
-0.0006314281490631402,
0.009445056319236755,
0.02612096630036831,
0.0277287308126688,
0.0005530698108486831,
0.010438796132802963,
0.03393545374274254,
-0.022082392126321793,
-0.007055535912513733,
0.001297526527196169,
0.05919342488050461,
-0.03747391328215599,
0.03535005822777748,
-0.027468066662549973,
-0.05585375055670738,
0.014424082823097706,
0.016081031411886215,
-0.04895086586475372,
-0.09814453125,
-0.03552583232522011,
0.055371399968862534,
-0.01073917094618082,
-0.05221235752105713,
-0.037852946668863297,
0.0075682117603719234,
0.02233971655368805,
-0.015712693333625793,
-0.03940483182668686,
-0.04609175771474838,
-0.017019635066390038,
-0.06829046458005905,
0.020380329340696335,
-0.01617552526295185,
0.023978039622306824,
0.05164838582277298,
0.001745874062180519,
0.06930504739284515,
-0.0007556049968115985,
-0.0322413332760334,
-0.01643742062151432,
0.002577532548457384,
0.003710054326802492,
0.007530332077294588,
0.004900429397821426,
-0.0028007023502141237,
-0.028539268299937248,
-0.013766881078481674,
-0.011436112225055695,
0.007250847760587931,
0.010240624658763409,
-0.014253271743655205,
0.03979063779115677,
-0.02563406713306904,
-0.026520028710365295,
-0.024404294788837433,
0.04217733070254326,
-0.02088579349219799,
-0.006429493892937899,
-0.02445957437157631,
0.0007626594742760062,
0.012599138543009758,
-0.02318967878818512,
0.005366569384932518,
0.0005122546572238207,
0.04444824159145355,
-0.06196557730436325,
0.01970752142369747,
-0.00425097206607461,
0.029284445568919182,
-0.028089141473174095,
0.00532970204949379,
0.01949143409729004,
-0.04549542814493179,
-0.018616965040564537,
-0.03724176064133644,
-0.0021280257496982813,
-0.027822818607091904,
0.009373984299600124,
-0.033619873225688934,
0.014460012316703796,
0.02982446737587452,
-0.04730396345257759,
-0.02272363379597664,
-0.018687071278691292,
-0.021305914968252182,
-0.018944151699543,
0.02033234015107155,
-0.00023776799207553267,
0.01635788567364216,
0.019680052995681763,
-0.045978352427482605,
-0.0390608012676239,
0.02942121960222721,
-0.015595796518027782,
0.02182900346815586,
-0.020751314237713814,
0.027604296803474426,
-0.04262832552194595,
0.007556108292192221,
0.039036378264427185,
0.025792298838496208,
-0.013864160515367985,
-0.00033832245389930904,
-0.00991814024746418,
0.03400620445609093,
0.02389439567923546,
0.03159699589014053,
-0.04711545258760452,
-0.002587246475741267,
0.0027921178843826056,
-0.0588737390935421,
0.050257228314876556,
0.013689978048205376,
-0.004472328815609217,
-0.04683300480246544,
0.06584160774946213,
-0.049250278621912,
0.009173107333481312,
-0.02242622710764408,
0.01747821271419525,
-0.016001148149371147,
-0.009497135877609253,
0.012435771524906158,
0.02542967163026333,
0.007748328149318695,
-0.010459496639668941,
-0.05734190717339516,
0.00018707281560637057,
-0.030549533665180206,
0.03878876939415932,
0.030351322144269943,
-0.010270423255860806,
-0.009696816094219685,
-0.01898513361811638,
0.01614394225180149,
-0.023672539740800858,
0.020492492243647575,
-0.022627629339694977,
-0.007487725932151079,
-0.01588284596800804,
0.03342922031879425,
-0.03268691152334213,
0.02327057160437107,
-0.017176717519760132,
-0.022364364936947823,
-0.010359887033700943,
0.006399273406714201,
-0.027032921090722084,
-0.10853733122348785,
-0.008341168984770775,
0.006951820570975542,
-0.020674938336014748,
-0.0038758753798902035,
-0.005477853585034609,
-0.014435491524636745,
0.04053928703069687,
-0.037503089755773544,
-0.01951206848025322,
-0.0006969576934352517,
-0.04241308197379112,
-0.03869088739156723,
-0.023649776354432106,
-0.0820595920085907,
0.009605775587260723,
-0.03898392990231514,
-0.031696416437625885,
-0.050879478454589844,
-0.020481960847973824,
0.004127934575080872,
-0.055668216198682785,
-0.0036574688274413347,
-0.00015576487930957228,
0.012283782474696636,
0.024508241564035416,
0.0008732571150176227,
-0.02285306714475155,
-0.05181794613599777,
-0.048639971762895584,
0.008633333258330822,
-0.0003199055790901184,
0.005518751218914986,
0.07635752856731415,
-0.011592792347073555,
0.00942799262702465,
-0.012419226579368114,
0.005889297928661108,
-0.009601738303899765,
-0.0026894717011600733,
-0.003657242516055703,
0.041683100163936615,
-0.0519537515938282,
0.004746077116578817,
-0.001154663390479982,
0.03345751389861107,
-0.001321627525612712,
-0.013347206637263298,
-0.05669299513101578,
-0.008941845037043095,
0.0058464002795517445,
0.0195772685110569,
-0.034289225935935974,
0.015343737788498402,
-0.011472432874143124,
-0.022693973034620285,
-0.008562695235013962,
0.021626930683851242,
0.0483994334936142,
0.03098095953464508,
0.02327023819088936,
-0.011382809840142727,
-0.0512557178735733,
0.024597886949777603,
-0.014082774519920349,
0.012849140912294388,
-0.025875387713313103,
-0.034778840839862823,
-0.04623260721564293,
0.01822315715253353,
-0.006493752356618643,
-0.025178376585245132,
0.007789248134940863,
-0.06335350126028061,
-0.003620533039793372,
0.0021061687730252743,
-0.004875009413808584,
0.0028663123957812786,
-0.0025638819206506014,
-0.05905460566282272,
0.01713692396879196,
0.025914376601576805,
-0.08102663606405258,
-0.025960616767406464,
0.0343637689948082,
0.03191445395350456,
-0.0016040721675381064,
-0.0030142299365252256,
0.004246031399816275,
-0.05752231180667877,
-0.06075301393866539,
0.0018619454931467772,
-0.03234108164906502,
0.05541692301630974,
0.010057198815047741,
-0.0013739942805841565,
0.009199168533086777,
-0.030544565990567207,
0.004579553380608559,
0.011705193668603897,
-0.05589521676301956,
-0.015747640281915665,
0.013442332856357098,
0.021070361137390137,
0.0034017288126051426,
-0.019159821793437004,
0.0568724200129509,
0.022078001871705055,
0.014282762072980404,
-0.04461216181516647,
-0.003276197472587228,
0.012330967001616955,
-0.022419137880206108,
0.027110524475574493,
-0.036638710647821426,
0.006212630309164524,
0.002374450908973813,
-0.04333521053195,
0.04041639342904091,
-0.012097028084099293,
0.02843520976603031,
0.033621687442064285,
-0.025542696937918663,
-0.03205635026097298,
-0.04100346565246582,
-0.012104044668376446,
0.08776503056287766,
-0.014600121416151524,
0.0013895876472815871,
-0.018065765500068665,
0.0030422734562307596,
0.004526953678578138,
-0.03614154830574989,
0.00045375764602795243,
0.00614914670586586,
-0.028964584693312645,
0.04788891226053238,
0.030259696766734123,
-0.06041543930768967,
0.00471976213157177,
-0.007824904285371304,
-0.001794656622223556,
-0.012593371793627739,
0.033716462552547455,
-0.007142273243516684,
0.05749141424894333,
-0.04424886777997017,
0.016251277178525925,
-0.010365906171500683,
-0.025989899411797523,
-0.0061387973837554455,
0.017949553206562996,
0.027301548048853874,
0.028391726315021515,
0.016815930604934692,
-0.010377753525972366,
0.03065163642168045,
0.042473092675209045,
0.04425320029258728,
0.01979556307196617,
0.0012036877451464534,
-0.03698698431253433,
-0.04366814345121384,
-0.04406271129846573,
-0.027669966220855713,
-0.019515125080943108,
-0.01654943637549877,
-0.007191872224211693,
-0.023550057783722878,
-0.017589146271348,
-0.040477458387613297,
0.03589913994073868,
-0.05252893641591072,
0.042207226157188416,
-0.004031447693705559,
-0.02264910750091076,
-0.009491969831287861,
-0.0014094120124354959,
0.02409644052386284,
-0.006217522080987692,
0.00023784571385476738,
0.018664054572582245,
0.0547056719660759,
-0.006605865433812141,
0.02390902489423752,
0.06410418450832367,
-0.003552827052772045,
0.02622869238257408,
0.023908628150820732,
-0.04023922234773636,
-0.024232463911175728,
0.01150569785386324,
0.04112851992249489,
-0.04486015811562538,
-0.0028619624208658934,
0.00823616236448288,
-0.008699137717485428,
-0.006246837321668863,
0.014252823777496815,
-0.007972455583512783,
-0.04763627424836159,
-0.003876097034662962,
0.007884608581662178,
0.011099270544946194,
-0.05367070063948631,
0.039297040551900864,
-0.012146936729550362,
-0.101920485496521,
-0.0024202277418226004,
0.007638724520802498,
0.02133781649172306,
0.0370175838470459,
-0.0326174721121788,
0.028213441371917725,
0.03259902074933052,
0.0027948415372520685,
-0.044169243425130844,
-0.014723742380738258,
0.01505136489868164,
-0.016802748665213585,
0.05159914866089821,
0.04511813819408417,
-0.042618583887815475,
-0.012599343433976173,
-0.012240075506269932,
-0.018103739246726036,
-0.02799367345869541,
0.0025359815917909145,
0.005191239528357983,
0.048492398113012314,
0.008644419722259045,
-0.0031188575085252523,
-0.01791391707956791,
0.02461346797645092,
0.0033705327659845352,
-0.09069186449050903,
0.0205687265843153,
0.03071081079542637,
0.010606997646391392,
-0.016828536987304688,
0.03689832612872124,
-0.019641172140836716,
-0.008788052946329117,
-0.008582115173339844
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:13
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
195In addition to challenging whether the representations had been made in the terms alleged, the defendants contended that the plaintiffs had not relied on any representation made by HTT when entering into the relevant agreements and that the representations were not, in any event, causative of any loss.
196The HTT Defendants contended that, in the alternative, assuming that a right to rescission had arisen, such right had been lost by reason of the plaintiffs' affirmation of the agreements.
197There is an issue in the proceedings as to whether the HTT Defendants have pleaded affirmation. I shall return to this question later in these reasons.
198In that regard, an issue has arisen as to whether, in the case of fraud, it was necessary that the plaintiffs know of their legal right to rescind (as opposed to the facts giving rise to that right) before losing a right to rescind by reason of affirmation (there being no suggestion that the plaintiffs were aware of such a legal right until shortly before they purported to rescind).
Rescission - affirmation - generally
199There was no dispute between the parties as to the general principle applicable. That principle is summarised in Carter et al, Contract Law in Australia, 5th ed (2007) at 18-47/18-48:-
"Following a representor's misrepresentation, the decision to rescind rests with the representee. Because the decision to rescind is a matter of choice (election), the representee is perfectly entitled to elect to affirm the contract.
The rule is that once such an election has taken place, rescission ceases to be available: affirmation is a bar to rescission. The basis of the rule is that 'rescission' and 'affirmation' are mutually exclusive rights: it is a condition of the enjoyment of either one that the other be abandoned.
Affirmation may be express or implied. The former occurs when there is a conscious choice by the representee to affirm the contract. The latter occurs when the choice is inferred on the basis of what the representee has said and done.
In essence, the basis for inferring (or imputing) affirmations is a finding that the representee has behaved in a way which is consistent only with an election in favour of affirmation having been made.
Analysis of the restriction requires a consideration of the elements of affirmation. As in the case of rescission, an election must be made in clear and unequivocal terms, and so an election to rescind or to affirm will not be found unless there are clear and unequivocal words or conduct. The representee must also have sufficient knowledge to make the election. (...)
The question of election does not arise until the party misled acquires knowledge that the representation was false. The representee is entitled to believe the representation, at least until there is some cause for suspicion, and usually beyond that stage.
Accordingly, mere partial information giving some cause for suspicion will not suffice, and a right to rescind may exist notwithstanding the lapse of a considerable time since the making of the contract." (citations omitted)
Rescission - knowledge of a legal right to rescind
200The decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria in Coast Estates Pty Limited v Melevende [1955] VR 433 is authority for the proposition that, where a misrepresentation is fraudulent, it is necessary that the defrauded parties should have known of the right to rescind before affirmation will arise.
201In that case Sholl J said:-
"In my opinion, the law is this. Assuming that rescission is still possible...and that the defrauded party fully knows, or possibly and correctly assumes, the falsity of the representations which induced the contract then...
...if the defrauded party does not know that he has a legal right to rescind, he is not bound by acts which on the face of them are referable only to an intention to affirm the contract, unless those acts are 'adverse to' the opposite party, i.e., unless they involve something to the other party's prejudice or detriment, as, e.g.
|
[
-0.022783147171139717,
0.011447754688560963,
0.002836380386725068,
0.035585083067417145,
0.016167014837265015,
-0.0664689838886261,
0.04409700259566307,
0.0017943140119314194,
0.01766430027782917,
0.02277440018951893,
-0.00981832668185234,
-0.016930382698774338,
-0.02294192835688591,
0.026111740618944168,
-0.01083765085786581,
0.00932328775525093,
0.04611377418041229,
-0.03679593279957771,
0.0003695485647767782,
0.013606952503323555,
-0.03675834834575653,
-0.011065850965678692,
0.043401576578617096,
0.007699488662183285,
0.004541788250207901,
0.03507975861430168,
-0.03115643374621868,
0.04928740859031677,
0.01278589479625225,
-0.016386069357395172,
-0.011948351748287678,
0.01584126614034176,
0.024582961574196815,
-0.03678483888506889,
-0.018290624022483826,
0.008071305230259895,
-0.0012631900608539581,
0.006556695327162743,
0.0003452507662586868,
0.01273623201996088,
-0.007674462627619505,
0.031026797369122505,
0.007447839714586735,
-0.04896555840969086,
0.038165196776390076,
-0.019503263756632805,
0.0024412553757429123,
-0.03889579325914383,
0.011513886041939259,
0.02118700183928013,
-0.07228964567184448,
0.001683671842329204,
0.09086648374795914,
-0.05075628310441971,
-0.015296556055545807,
0.05581451579928398,
-0.013905108906328678,
-0.017578259110450745,
-0.04445023089647293,
0.011326495558023453,
0.004402835853397846,
-0.017577670514583588,
-0.07012863457202911,
-0.02689511328935623,
-0.005613876972347498,
0.03722072392702103,
0.015823962166905403,
-0.028902040794491768,
0.009391989558935165,
-0.05110720917582512,
-0.015002815052866936,
0.02819734625518322,
-0.09890815615653992,
-0.016799045726656914,
-0.10743793100118637,
0.022037558257579803,
0.0013345596380531788,
0.0011335040908306837,
0.007772268261760473,
-0.00519954739138484,
-0.023815875872969627,
-0.017299572005867958,
0.010299455374479294,
0.027143219485878944,
-0.010418305173516273,
-0.008621458895504475,
0.023956337943673134,
0.030934331938624382,
0.004160769283771515,
-0.009570736438035965,
0.010548369027674198,
-0.0007220939733088017,
-0.002573676174506545,
-0.04500095546245575,
0.04194631427526474,
-0.026784365996718407,
-0.056496236473321915,
0.00626903772354126,
-0.0008972639334388077,
0.03688735514879227,
0.023163501173257828,
0.01144234836101532,
-0.004358373582363129,
-0.024975908920168877,
-0.016957523301243782,
0.003948692232370377,
0.03312841057777405,
0.058649130165576935,
0.0398351289331913,
-0.010962782427668571,
-0.003710018005222082,
-0.020772406831383705,
-0.01917095109820366,
0.006929661612957716,
-0.028187301009893417,
0.01770165003836155,
0.04030122235417366,
0.02438867837190628,
-0.012888082303106785,
0.02080756239593029,
0.010347769595682621,
0.02967090532183647,
0.0418412946164608,
-0.008958343416452408,
-0.027057122439146042,
0.01671890914440155,
0.00007192324119387195,
0.018195949494838715,
0.021399356424808502,
0.010342561639845371,
0.03458681330084801,
-0.0076371654868125916,
-0.021047748625278473,
-0.025930846109986305,
-0.019487451761960983,
-0.03752373158931732,
0.02428223378956318,
0.0011638292344287038,
-0.00886443443596363,
-0.0859118402004242,
0.06793159246444702,
0.016901414841413498,
-0.002874599536880851,
-0.01303244847804308,
0.008778644725680351,
-0.007997971028089523,
0.011120954528450966,
0.001404797425493598,
0.023010730743408203,
-0.022178947925567627,
0.036826279014348984,
0.031855929642915726,
0.02873246930539608,
-0.03698040172457695,
0.03199572116136551,
-0.03161376714706421,
0.06278526037931442,
0.010643145069479942,
0.009126462042331696,
0.026603536680340767,
-0.027196573093533516,
0.07505444437265396,
-0.04916872829198837,
-0.013313851319253445,
0.009822876192629337,
0.016559861600399017,
0.010093217715620995,
-0.02272297814488411,
-0.0075150225311517715,
-0.030217286199331284,
-0.0028765422757714987,
-0.00924094021320343,
0.024523522704839706,
-0.012288093566894531,
0.034999582916498184,
0.03657251596450806,
0.04533481225371361,
0.013462123461067677,
-0.013372398912906647,
-0.022479554638266563,
-0.026833834126591682,
-0.008521580137312412,
0.01641915552318096,
0.025645822286605835,
-0.057301513850688934,
0.011697853915393353,
0.0020253928378224373,
-0.008039233274757862,
0.01747041568160057,
0.0007888522231951356,
-0.031748030334711075,
-0.020450156182050705,
0.009960593655705452,
0.02862727642059326,
0.02832367643713951,
-0.021399203687906265,
0.01575584150850773,
-0.045728981494903564,
0.01925620064139366,
-0.011204898357391357,
-0.044538192451000214,
0.014514102600514889,
0.03445382043719292,
-0.02281838469207287,
-0.044800758361816406,
0.00613895570859313,
-0.030906105414032936,
0.030999327078461647,
0.011041194200515747,
-0.03788120672106743,
0.0009689824655652046,
-0.0264448095113039,
0.04046984761953354,
-0.006978021468967199,
0.031392548233270645,
-0.008427263237535954,
-0.039519552141427994,
0.023716548457741737,
0.005557101685553789,
-0.031284742057323456,
-0.03572820499539375,
-0.028051258996129036,
-0.00029179942794144154,
-0.009391273371875286,
0.05731996148824692,
0.011529458686709404,
-0.014372623525559902,
0.0189058817923069,
-0.010965069755911827,
0.0018151885597035289,
0.014562230557203293,
-0.014177670702338219,
0.02796325646340847,
-0.031842153519392014,
0.008249226957559586,
0.004370024427771568,
0.025986861437559128,
0.023674774914979935,
0.036418162286281586,
0.006850491277873516,
-0.018216943368315697,
0.010214630514383316,
0.043435387313365936,
-0.03439806029200554,
-0.007570269517600536,
-0.0034690499305725098,
-0.011650794185698032,
-0.03255650773644447,
-0.0011625668266788125,
-0.036626819521188736,
-0.026429301127791405,
0.018463578075170517,
-0.008552156388759613,
-0.005584926810115576,
0.021371427923440933,
0.04256660118699074,
-0.0014565082965418696,
0.0005282107158564031,
0.028893567621707916,
-0.031867142766714096,
0.020416103303432465,
-0.0005647976649925113,
0.03938743844628334,
0.02369329147040844,
-0.015426259487867355,
0.0062379008159041405,
-0.03769408166408539,
-0.018311284482479095,
-0.0015279845101758838,
-0.015207953751087189,
0.025207238271832466,
0.013963608071208,
0.002476851921528578,
0.011386636644601822,
0.04329851642251015,
0.0521332323551178,
0.03766258805990219,
-0.02186063677072525,
0.06296244263648987,
0.023807046934962273,
0.0023412976879626513,
-0.024108463898301125,
0.03582124039530754,
0.0009056958369910717,
0.002182483673095703,
-0.026912543922662735,
-0.015022222883999348,
-0.0033540953882038593,
0.047578103840351105,
-0.042682234197854996,
0.024245936423540115,
-0.010699053294956684,
0.0701335221529007,
0.010741835460066795,
-0.07936413586139679,
-0.007303615566343069,
0.0009179982007481158,
-0.13314101099967957,
0.00837402418255806,
0.018091559410095215,
-0.014935539104044437,
-0.00986410677433014,
0.019420703873038292,
-0.0297745019197464,
0.008432762697339058,
-0.015179936774075031,
-0.0023908806033432484,
0.009925362654030323,
-0.05688212066888809,
-0.02760118804872036,
-0.005834574345499277,
-0.00812117476016283,
0.01948261633515358,
-0.008266366086900234,
0.04056655988097191,
0.031637437641620636,
-0.018442660570144653,
0.0008520554983988404,
-0.020730113610625267,
0.06311756372451782,
-0.011010643094778061,
0.007665392477065325,
0.03567203879356384,
-0.0111209936439991,
-0.019105257466435432,
-0.022217227146029472,
0.020015669986605644,
-0.008096789941191673,
0.032315537333488464,
-0.016837848350405693,
-0.011758441105484962,
0.01685764081776142,
0.022649871185421944,
0.06102878600358963,
-0.06317366659641266,
0.005269660614430904,
0.004168343730270863,
0.024797851219773293,
0.0595368854701519,
-0.011523568071424961,
0.04309861361980438,
-0.0009029353386722505,
-0.010539540089666843,
0.010250755585730076,
0.014484872110188007,
0.013433345593512058,
0.027680672705173492,
0.0020469145383685827,
0.012112966738641262,
-0.0433381162583828,
-0.0032822326757013798,
-0.019434085115790367,
-0.010456623509526253,
0.04544271156191826,
0.044652413576841354,
-0.017496852204203606,
-0.008495587855577469,
-0.003580097807571292,
-0.0377950482070446,
0.028956163674592972,
-0.023424696177244186,
-0.058676525950431824,
-0.037668272852897644,
-0.008578779175877571,
0.019626963883638382,
0.033670444041490555,
-0.022614752873778343,
0.006559119559824467,
0.0012814354849979281,
-0.0028480947948992252,
-0.0005893374909646809,
0.006284581031650305,
-0.000531779311131686,
-0.026365075260400772,
-0.0012387027963995934,
0.007640141993761063,
-0.06670649349689484,
0.047984085977077484,
0.033036038279533386,
-0.04591689631342888,
0.06156319007277489,
-0.010546887293457985,
-0.016130678355693817,
0.0027000003028661013,
-0.010035515762865543,
0.08808287233114243,
0.2306743711233139,
0.04231769219040871,
0.009222368709743023,
-0.04014338180422783,
0.02108057215809822,
-0.014172391965985298,
0.08741126209497452,
0.03847431764006615,
0.008154504001140594,
-0.03711273521184921,
-0.014586255885660648,
0.005272654816508293,
0.010425793938338757,
0.03155749663710594,
-0.04909702017903328,
0.03024272806942463,
-0.013017796911299229,
0.0014662854373455048,
0.0633259043097496,
0.011468109674751759,
0.025024762377142906,
-0.018109703436493874,
0.030816631391644478,
0.08492935448884964,
-0.03466798737645149,
0.0066885389387607574,
-0.008424853906035423,
0.007205278612673283,
-0.024766236543655396,
-0.006275697145611048,
-0.03699672967195511,
0.04535083472728729,
0.060677748173475266,
-0.050993502140045166,
0.012198906391859055,
-0.03413322567939758,
-0.038197990506887436,
-0.0015481080627068877,
-0.05650575831532478,
0.04192817583680153,
0.04408954083919525,
-0.018191371113061905,
0.026863953098654747,
-0.05285843461751938,
0.007063334807753563,
0.005489094648510218,
-0.031380221247673035,
0.02912467159330845,
0.0362628810107708,
0.008332221768796444,
-0.029438871890306473,
0.013571158051490784,
-0.04191166162490845,
-0.01201577764004469,
-0.055985227227211,
0.013808127492666245,
0.00499549088999629,
0.023709729313850403,
-0.01584421843290329,
0.03550978749990463,
0.03259541466832161,
0.01642620749771595,
0.00324628921225667,
0.0520213283598423,
-0.02590281143784523,
-0.035598691552877426,
-0.05433759465813637,
-0.04248407110571861,
0.07806233316659927,
0.051868513226509094,
0.06231038644909859,
0.02682836353778839,
0.02098110131919384,
0.025998525321483612,
0.014436780475080013,
0.02938796579837799,
-0.03003533184528351,
-0.026837334036827087,
0.02629745751619339,
-0.006975454278290272,
-0.031555842608213425,
-0.03546033054590225,
-0.00403638556599617,
0.03338325396180153,
0.02524315007030964,
-0.010749146342277527,
-0.04445721581578255,
0.031111013144254684,
0.04190504550933838,
0.017305610701441765,
-0.012661232613027096,
-0.019511455669999123,
-0.006586829666048288,
-0.006152800749987364,
-0.01058216579258442,
0.019495129585266113,
0.004792837891727686,
-0.010089303366839886,
-0.0393492616713047,
-0.010736687108874321,
0.01625598594546318,
0.008895470760762691,
0.048779089003801346,
-0.036509398370981216,
0.03768274188041687,
0.020606305450201035,
0.03808734193444252,
-0.039392463862895966,
-0.034737762063741684,
0.028661945834755898,
0.01145623903721571,
0.008316615596413612,
-0.02359868586063385,
0.013010247610509396,
0.05111498758196831,
0.043974895030260086,
-0.0746418833732605,
0.01457920577377081,
0.007953527383506298,
0.048965033143758774,
-0.012309369631111622,
0.033970002084970474,
-0.01357927918434143,
0.01721605844795704,
-0.0011820367071777582,
-0.025920845568180084,
-0.03432139754295349,
0.0038828463293612003,
-0.008192112669348717,
-0.002730216598138213,
-0.015280299820005894,
-0.019638990983366966,
-0.030529437586665154,
0.025523224845528603,
0.014498083852231503,
0.027539104223251343,
0.0032362542115151882,
0.0077596670016646385,
-0.01560484804213047,
-0.042490404099226,
-0.038699422031641006,
0.03588881343603134,
-0.0333881750702858,
-0.01747036911547184,
0.014676336199045181,
-0.02281859889626503,
-0.04529696702957153,
0.002154350746423006,
-0.0505584180355072,
0.0020129194017499685,
0.012642236426472664,
0.011386964470148087,
-0.034618131816387177,
-0.028875967487692833,
-0.03502633795142174,
-0.014752480201423168,
0.012137042358517647,
-0.006690287962555885,
0.0007821680628694594,
-0.023946264758706093,
-0.010034901089966297,
0.05187858268618584,
0.009443528018891811,
0.04332657903432846,
0.020084349438548088,
0.034528087824583054,
-0.02201465517282486,
0.013494097627699375,
0.029792921617627144,
-0.024807032197713852,
-0.015693778172135353,
-0.038553331047296524,
-0.05051678791642189,
0.035950638353824615,
0.021079709753394127,
0.010050859302282333,
0.0017507203156128526,
0.011411973275244236,
0.00679215881973505,
-0.05865966156125069,
-0.013422329910099506,
0.00576161639764905,
-0.02608180232346058,
0.020913396030664444,
-0.024947909638285637,
0.018187422305345535,
-0.013499640859663486,
-0.005202912725508213,
0.0984797328710556,
-0.06469814479351044,
-0.036033011972904205,
0.08986158668994904,
-0.017145948484539986,
-0.03271517902612686,
0.009579901583492756,
0.030493786558508873,
0.004268504213541746,
0.04506951943039894,
0.0138626117259264,
-0.05043945834040642,
-0.025273064151406288,
-0.004558410029858351,
-0.013877545483410358,
0.019068337976932526,
-0.01832212507724762,
0.002653773408383131,
-0.03608648478984833,
0.009834785014390945,
-0.041757822036743164,
-0.01993538625538349,
0.0320717878639698,
-0.002939299214631319,
-0.05404098704457283,
0.022253666073083878,
0.0009093983680941164,
-0.019351372495293617,
-0.0011767549440264702,
-0.005744503811001778,
-0.02491457760334015,
-0.052425846457481384,
0.008331501856446266,
-0.03947149217128754,
-0.01959150657057762,
-0.07016881555318832,
-0.018088122829794884,
0.026032941415905952,
0.0007281855214387178,
0.017678795382380486,
0.0084322988986969,
-0.03725654259324074,
-0.0029457195196300745,
-0.06493078172206879,
0.04595885053277016,
0.02200331911444664,
0.015963120386004448,
-0.018906867131590843,
-0.005522545427083969,
0.009807014837861061,
0.028574693948030472,
0.03506658971309662,
0.021031340584158897,
-0.025873152539134026,
0.06998763978481293,
0.04462079703807831,
0.00234899390488863,
-0.01338473241776228,
-0.016207341104745865,
0.014509796164929867,
0.0424078032374382,
0.04642261937260628,
-0.011088313534855843,
-0.007830630987882614,
-0.0016986988484859467,
-0.06982365250587463,
0.010997502133250237,
0.03872507065534592,
0.03321786969900131,
-0.01804804988205433,
-0.07359092682600021,
-0.02051732689142227,
-0.006202526856213808,
0.02644144371151924,
-0.0006179737392812967,
-0.01095605082809925,
0.0008438551449216902,
-0.054271992295980453,
0.027394859120249748,
-0.024538515135645866,
-0.029701821506023407,
-0.04980314150452614,
0.014744087122380733,
-0.002161092823371291,
-0.018885232508182526,
-0.04844658449292183,
-0.009938593953847885,
0.009695347398519516,
-0.03012131340801716,
0.010747134685516357,
-0.031159553676843643,
-0.012125534005463123,
0.04270714148879051,
0.026807714253664017,
0.005336449481546879,
0.0019762148149311543,
-0.00220013246871531,
0.04323968291282654,
0.01706712879240513,
-0.0058806478045880795,
0.005344530567526817,
-0.0499737448990345,
0.016483237966895103,
0.016164347529411316,
-0.031045502051711082,
0.015515034087002277,
-0.008463267236948013,
0.018532147631049156,
0.008238664828240871,
0.056686270982027054,
-0.001585180638357997,
0.016485080122947693,
-0.024399572983384132,
-0.02307077683508396,
-0.0296782199293375,
-0.006558244116604328,
-0.012474256567656994,
0.008752881549298763,
0.011719729751348495,
-0.006917436141520739,
0.005056052468717098,
0.009774453938007355,
-0.0013500229688361287,
-0.10857515037059784,
0.004070095717906952,
0.002556466031819582,
0.011362329125404358,
-0.022993216291069984,
-0.027309760451316833,
-0.01914965733885765,
-0.007955090142786503,
-0.022631747648119926,
0.005076480098068714,
-0.0041377004235982895,
-0.046233586966991425,
-0.07612797617912292,
-0.0586964376270771,
0.005129661411046982,
-0.03036307729780674,
-0.05558197945356369,
-0.01175820454955101,
0.021696465089917183,
-0.0050309449434280396,
-0.016616638749837875,
0.017351891845464706,
-0.02032782882452011,
-0.04719609394669533,
0.036589063704013824,
-0.03369251638650894,
-0.033809203654527664,
0.04904746636748314,
-0.036660291254520416,
0.025044690817594528,
-0.0851004347205162,
0.08130215853452682,
-0.031068433076143265,
-0.011264396831393242,
0.046694882214069366,
-0.030391395092010498,
-0.00684336107224226,
-0.030426016077399254,
0.01775110885500908,
-0.0069676791317760944,
0.043828681111335754,
-0.01639460399746895,
-0.043185584247112274,
0.06251918524503708,
0.0006757074734196067,
0.012569478712975979,
0.018132347613573074,
0.017434602603316307,
-0.006896279752254486,
-0.005480506457388401,
-0.0002788888232316822,
0.019689971581101418,
-0.02711143158376217,
-0.0069812932051718235,
0.005359748378396034,
0.0010339710861444473,
0.020413031801581383,
0.0016427399823442101,
-0.032189808785915375,
0.02314804680645466,
0.03222334012389183,
0.02912111021578312,
-0.015800675377249718,
-0.03751172497868538,
0.0286240316927433,
-0.018915468826889992,
0.053042151033878326,
0.002438585041090846,
0.002607893431559205,
-0.011941821314394474,
-0.040977928787469864,
-0.053395841270685196,
-0.01936465874314308,
0.0011288526002317667,
-0.021887311711907387,
-0.010475008748471737,
0.008222822099924088,
-0.010086999274790287,
0.0026278523728251457,
-0.04285977780818939,
0.03139149397611618,
-0.0034805743489414454,
0.011960471048951149,
-0.1331329345703125,
0.014127254486083984,
0.004700526129454374,
0.02135445736348629,
-0.024389032274484634,
0.02859642170369625,
-0.007726722862571478,
0.026087060570716858,
-0.03250790387392044,
-0.039658352732658386,
-0.006456408649682999,
-0.06600382924079895,
0.028199724853038788,
-0.0328349806368351,
0.02721630223095417,
-0.013179963454604149,
-0.0433218851685524,
-0.03015938587486744,
-0.05546615272760391,
0.019600674510002136,
0.019071154296398163,
0.0034058289602398872,
-0.018673213198781013,
-0.030236434191465378,
-0.007497063372284174,
-0.031159881502389908,
-0.0172848179936409,
-0.07241811603307724,
-0.014572828076779842,
-0.014651557430624962,
-0.0027528046630322933,
-0.010502192191779613,
-0.03220411390066147,
0.044057026505470276,
-0.012519833631813526,
-0.0441235676407814,
0.0010971702868118882,
0.0033672365825623274,
-0.03651436045765877,
-0.027228767052292824,
0.025258637964725494,
0.017702052369713783,
-0.04460015147924423,
0.012666627764701843,
-0.007855015806853771,
0.04126299172639847,
-0.04143081232905388,
-0.003220832208171487,
-0.0411912202835083,
-0.03384334594011307,
-0.057962823659181595,
0.03518734872341156,
0.0030176553409546614,
0.03491158038377762,
0.013997643254697323,
0.02988077700138092,
-0.02471848763525486,
0.0045378911308944225,
-0.018778087571263313,
0.026576071977615356,
0.014309614896774292,
0.04139286279678345,
-0.02242855355143547,
-0.022733764722943306,
0.010862752795219421,
0.0037281615659594536,
0.016203925013542175,
-0.010864656418561935,
0.0010771886445581913,
-0.020574316382408142,
-0.019007917493581772,
0.04073667898774147,
-0.006829405669122934,
-0.01308277528733015,
0.003624819917604327,
-0.018281932920217514,
-0.013373400084674358,
-0.021926352754235268,
-0.038230571895837784,
-0.020450104027986526,
-0.050937216728925705,
-0.019525092095136642,
-0.008314290083944798,
0.03313348442316055,
0.0206534955650568,
0.018491733819246292,
-0.02330951578915119,
-0.010767878964543343,
0.048126980662345886,
0.004293182399123907,
-0.05962873995304108,
-0.009433443658053875,
0.0006621566717512906,
0.059701599180698395,
0.007121302653104067,
-0.001822198973968625,
-0.02116934210062027,
0.012016608379781246,
-0.004793393891304731,
-0.01983361318707466,
-0.05016172677278519,
-0.01947612874209881,
0.057949334383010864,
-0.026727639138698578,
-0.04844328388571739,
0.014912878163158894,
-0.01505778357386589,
0.033668141812086105,
0.01785772480070591,
-0.024459591135382652,
0.01806868240237236,
-0.0492987185716629,
-0.03476539999246597,
-0.004507225006818771,
-0.018162613734602928,
0.0023165892343968153,
-0.04661642760038376,
0.012456722557544708,
-0.007872977294027805,
0.018487980589270592,
0.02281348966062069,
-0.014510197564959526,
-0.011907595209777355,
-0.02388005144894123,
0.03752020373940468,
-0.02188906818628311,
0.04502096027135849,
0.014157554134726524,
0.04295240715146065,
-0.01789185218513012,
0.0424497090280056,
-0.026021506637334824,
-0.04390038922429085,
0.018410759046673775,
0.03360525891184807,
0.002553062979131937,
0.012623480521142483,
0.005370164755731821,
0.0012102791806682944,
-0.02917432226240635,
0.0026196122635155916,
-0.041501689702272415,
0.020296601578593254,
0.027509547770023346,
-0.055024437606334686,
-0.012494425289332867,
0.05558721348643303,
-0.020662540569901466,
-0.01558289397507906,
-0.04573617875576019,
0.00007380665192613378,
0.031657956540584564,
-0.005158053711056709,
0.0645746961236,
0.019304627552628517,
0.007564978674054146,
0.02312537282705307,
-0.034319598227739334,
0.025804027915000916,
0.06495122611522675,
0.005248494446277618,
-0.002451504347845912,
-0.028860855847597122,
-0.047873739153146744,
-0.02305588871240616,
0.015235398896038532,
-0.025194454938173294,
0.0034235897473990917,
0.038052141666412354,
-0.006590970791876316,
-0.013876832090318203,
0.03890629857778549,
-0.002533617662265897,
-0.040960486978292465,
0.01541479118168354,
0.017059631645679474,
0.013370553962886333,
0.006440809462219477,
0.009987841360270977,
-0.028300317004323006,
0.05215407907962799,
0.05336136743426323,
0.01764652319252491,
-0.015971196815371513,
0.024691572412848473,
-0.010654520243406296,
0.03692156448960304,
0.011765115894377232,
-0.007426717318594456,
-0.019298594444990158,
0.008014043793082237,
-0.015207026153802872,
0.04969228059053421,
0.010049356147646904,
0.007143108639866114,
0.033338695764541626,
-0.036271966993808746,
0.022305743768811226,
-0.007779094390571117,
0.015874583274126053,
-0.003069419413805008,
-0.024001769721508026,
-0.028129825368523598,
0.02023141458630562,
-0.0005236057913862169,
-0.002626097295433283,
0.004112561233341694,
-0.0008091627387329936,
-0.02576240710914135,
0.05645322799682617,
-0.031706102192401886,
0.008249410428106785,
-0.029507633298635483,
0.03091898374259472,
0.004357730504125357,
0.0019151888554915786,
0.0725693628191948,
-0.027286509051918983,
0.02542431466281414,
-0.02531849965453148,
0.017284849658608437,
0.054287318140268326,
-0.03619123622775078,
-0.03076069802045822,
0.003650887403637171,
0.021178578957915306,
-0.02463301457464695,
-0.016170065850019455,
-0.007846930995583534,
-0.009711150079965591,
-0.03640841320157051,
-0.050687525421381,
-0.013861733488738537,
-0.008671407587826252,
0.03827423229813576,
-0.01227661594748497,
-0.03694940730929375,
-0.024094564840197563,
-0.0487334281206131,
0.018853476271033287,
0.007684220094233751,
0.0032189744524657726,
0.02748168259859085,
-0.010832996107637882
] |
What is the general principle applicable to affirmation in the context of rescission of a contract due to misrepresentation?
|
[
-0.08828471601009369,
-0.024402396753430367,
0.01834430731832981,
0.016598939895629883,
0.003990850877016783,
-0.04291805624961853,
0.03361612185835838,
-0.01791776344180107,
-0.011001312173902988,
0.008955038152635098,
-0.0008284281357191503,
-0.03061632066965103,
-0.006524795200675726,
0.029920481145381927,
-0.010506910271942616,
0.006821317598223686,
0.06395495682954788,
-0.04775219410657883,
0.001562381163239479,
0.014842064119875431,
-0.018180180341005325,
-0.031174451112747192,
0.006797994486987591,
0.020539743825793266,
0.006212445441633463,
0.04314236342906952,
0.014230269007384777,
0.009839040227234364,
0.015004165470600128,
-0.01818789914250374,
-0.012455638498067856,
0.028148658573627472,
0.008315661922097206,
-0.053096603602170944,
0.0276752058416605,
0.010171199217438698,
0.0060422238893806934,
-0.02814110741019249,
-0.046437982469797134,
-0.029083920642733574,
-0.013016344048082829,
-0.011424925178289413,
0.012698392383754253,
-0.05532844737172127,
0.02532246895134449,
-0.029447365552186966,
0.006713551003485918,
-0.04726924002170563,
-0.005294605158269405,
0.051016855984926224,
-0.04773176833987236,
-0.010139526799321175,
0.08381544053554535,
-0.029596688225865364,
0.0156039884313941,
0.0731561928987503,
-0.009734269231557846,
-0.0024679540656507015,
-0.03977549448609352,
-0.003696806263178587,
-0.013199401088058949,
-0.03319358825683594,
-0.0808652937412262,
0.0035164812579751015,
0.047719746828079224,
-0.0071372659876942635,
0.04852933809161186,
-0.050930850207805634,
0.01861077919602394,
-0.051531411707401276,
-0.039800286293029785,
0.043354641646146774,
-0.055251121520996094,
0.00028573436429724097,
-0.09102334827184677,
0.006988039705902338,
0.03676594793796539,
0.005561145022511482,
0.00035941903479397297,
0.009686145931482315,
0.00021767691941931844,
-0.006507799495011568,
0.01747671514749527,
0.024665188044309616,
-0.043456368148326874,
0.012435181997716427,
0.015029070898890495,
0.006537493783980608,
0.024070411920547485,
-0.0024379612877964973,
0.037974391132593155,
-0.004095525946468115,
-0.0037037618458271027,
-0.027204040437936783,
0.03044251538813114,
-0.038655221462249756,
-0.014710849151015282,
0.007945987395942211,
0.002231675898656249,
0.06833431869745255,
0.0236170943826437,
-0.0008257264271378517,
0.032896943390369415,
-0.0332113653421402,
-0.006858838256448507,
-0.00930843222886324,
0.05300511047244072,
0.05797794461250305,
0.011368492618203163,
0.019684841856360435,
-0.04609674960374832,
-0.02478685975074768,
-0.0014407506678253412,
0.00405683321878314,
-0.018615765497088432,
0.007572993636131287,
0.02172587625682354,
0.01488600205630064,
0.043988652527332306,
0.0016730389324948192,
0.010851182974874973,
0.009846688248217106,
0.03096332959830761,
-0.0264979787170887,
-0.03183648735284805,
-0.02086004801094532,
0.02514929696917534,
0.02773349918425083,
-0.02376554347574711,
0.056767359375953674,
0.022825339809060097,
-0.0028306287713348866,
0.00008872757462086156,
-0.019294142723083496,
-0.032579004764556885,
-0.03252097964286804,
0.04791387915611267,
-0.0055020456202328205,
-0.0017679246375337243,
-0.08522076904773712,
0.059626031666994095,
-0.027156589552760124,
-0.005614020861685276,
-0.006443527527153492,
-0.04438743740320206,
-0.04451310262084007,
0.03259013965725899,
-0.03211503103375435,
0.06135319918394089,
-0.01799176074564457,
0.008941581472754478,
0.0017167679034173489,
0.03815525025129318,
0.007225389126688242,
0.030550289899110794,
-0.06607367843389511,
0.02612743154168129,
0.0040250723250210285,
0.032272327691316605,
0.021287407726049423,
0.012212398461997509,
0.077125184237957,
0.006303421687334776,
-0.026276428252458572,
0.009719954803586006,
-0.012339162640273571,
-0.04521416872739792,
-0.011364451609551907,
-0.02916811592876911,
0.006767807528376579,
0.01634950377047062,
0.017805999144911766,
0.041809968650341034,
-0.04348032921552658,
0.0054184249602258205,
0.013917630538344383,
0.09863696992397308,
0.011804052628576756,
-0.029364049434661865,
-0.020192936062812805,
-0.02896977588534355,
-0.020341064780950546,
-0.013476929627358913,
0.03958001360297203,
-0.06600601971149445,
-0.0011664994526654482,
0.02291036956012249,
-0.041068531572818756,
0.02032863348722458,
0.028194598853588104,
0.010337053798139095,
-0.01029854267835617,
-0.03653077408671379,
0.016311006620526314,
-0.00950848963111639,
-0.007291955873370171,
-0.01479733269661665,
-0.049280911684036255,
0.013770944438874722,
-0.01215899083763361,
-0.04251547157764435,
0.023486534133553505,
0.049459170550107956,
0.02114028111100197,
-0.05322770029306412,
-0.03869108483195305,
-0.045730091631412506,
0.013684962876141071,
0.0031978741753846407,
-0.011987772770226002,
-0.016035286709666252,
-0.038859762251377106,
0.01696375571191311,
0.021081918850541115,
-0.015345986932516098,
0.018014555796980858,
0.013601177372038364,
-0.036414869129657745,
0.04860936477780342,
0.0015518688596785069,
-0.009886897169053555,
-0.03659047558903694,
0.002557296073064208,
-0.009135371074080467,
0.013193541206419468,
-0.001554901129566133,
-0.03052625060081482,
0.045173279941082,
-0.023272303864359856,
-0.039819058030843735,
0.0042512305080890656,
-0.02074994146823883,
0.03272896632552147,
-0.03613198548555374,
0.02064153365790844,
0.03583430498838425,
0.006769170984625816,
-0.00001721983244351577,
0.03172685578465462,
0.014795714989304543,
-0.025036940351128578,
-0.039337847381830215,
0.032986123114824295,
-0.01331211719661951,
0.0061700111255049706,
0.01577937789261341,
-0.019274190068244934,
-0.011798896826803684,
-0.01752098836004734,
-0.03633621707558632,
-0.0322556309401989,
0.025075174868106842,
-0.03327743336558342,
-0.029942026361823082,
0.006844846066087484,
0.025767797604203224,
0.007170223165303469,
0.010447399690747261,
0.07494379580020905,
0.03503447026014328,
0.017136840149760246,
-0.03974473476409912,
0.009806985966861248,
0.04864104837179184,
0.002651487709954381,
-0.0071463920176029205,
-0.021395597606897354,
0.006177769973874092,
-0.04911404848098755,
0.06463735550642014,
-0.0036530790384858847,
0.014848234131932259,
0.00730951176956296,
0.012245679274201393,
0.045407362282276154,
0.04746120423078537,
0.005083534400910139,
-0.02929019369184971,
0.0683998242020607,
0.03574005514383316,
-0.03399018198251724,
-0.034103162586688995,
0.03729578107595444,
-0.02470657415688038,
-0.008423558436334133,
-0.043942391872406006,
-0.024342184886336327,
-0.015911802649497986,
0.03237822651863098,
-0.04240326210856438,
0.03413134068250656,
-0.022121688351035118,
0.09001509845256805,
0.004534800536930561,
-0.06832083314657211,
0.0024107645731419325,
-0.013238221406936646,
-0.11976902931928635,
0.03571588173508644,
-0.0017085224390029907,
-0.019535165280103683,
-0.010106648318469524,
-0.0030428895261138678,
-0.013269608840346336,
-0.005941722076386213,
-0.007715632673352957,
0.0048700133338570595,
0.015407255850732327,
-0.06543321162462234,
-0.0374557301402092,
-0.01080692745745182,
0.007649758365005255,
0.01045994833111763,
-0.04013488069176674,
0.005257877521216869,
0.03629825636744499,
0.00483748922124505,
-0.0023356154561042786,
-0.013562005013227463,
0.045491039752960205,
-0.04350189119577408,
-0.0017070717876777053,
0.038736581802368164,
-0.005763239227235317,
-0.023377297446131706,
-0.03556239977478981,
0.015914419665932655,
-0.049149010330438614,
0.03169910982251167,
-0.009573977440595627,
0.008098123595118523,
0.013509928248822689,
0.01045171357691288,
0.005131564103066921,
-0.06548484414815903,
-0.029599333181977272,
0.008027325384318829,
-0.00846604723483324,
0.022736096754670143,
0.0005841847159899771,
0.022269515320658684,
0.004121705889701843,
-0.012604583986103535,
0.024623528122901917,
-0.005307233892381191,
0.017821839079260826,
0.006459529977291822,
-0.03541892394423485,
0.00035276138805784285,
-0.020188484340906143,
0.03837805241346359,
-0.02885829098522663,
0.021220901980996132,
0.025135982781648636,
0.06689827144145966,
-0.011369548738002777,
-0.001738042919896543,
0.0024591193068772554,
-0.009824502281844616,
-0.0012674363097175956,
-0.040455132722854614,
-0.05996422469615936,
-0.03906575217843056,
-0.013938380405306816,
0.02850205823779106,
0.014850527048110962,
-0.01695379428565502,
0.024598857387900352,
-0.004264065530151129,
0.012053277343511581,
-0.018700942397117615,
-0.03249991312623024,
0.02718951925635338,
-0.017569854855537415,
0.00795129407197237,
-0.013392256572842598,
-0.04741966724395752,
0.043533626943826675,
0.027476085349917412,
-0.015743298456072807,
0.08049605041742325,
-0.01722598448395729,
-0.01193105150014162,
-0.0028790186624974012,
0.019130049273371696,
0.05084891617298126,
0.19434130191802979,
0.00526692159473896,
-0.010486109182238579,
-0.030233630910515785,
0.055631816387176514,
-0.021799543872475624,
0.07723628729581833,
0.023885471746325493,
-0.016074910759925842,
-0.026841439306735992,
-0.004602259490638971,
0.02609601430594921,
0.017439337447285652,
-0.0040415567345917225,
-0.02919689379632473,
0.026800289750099182,
0.027375830337405205,
0.01201865915209055,
0.06555614620447159,
-0.0018738864455372095,
0.04060037061572075,
0.017674865201115608,
0.03068104200065136,
0.07157083600759506,
-0.014118033461272717,
-0.020303145051002502,
0.0039953975938260555,
0.05391355976462364,
-0.03147993981838226,
0.04018536955118179,
-0.03071826510131359,
0.039799414575099945,
0.0375928170979023,
-0.024962473660707474,
-0.025979239493608475,
-0.02019079215824604,
-0.02908446080982685,
-0.030501412227749825,
-0.050485581159591675,
0.05413924902677536,
0.0039842636324465275,
-0.03399721160531044,
0.034538157284259796,
-0.03853685036301613,
-0.0024011079221963882,
-0.05258418247103691,
-0.008509865030646324,
0.004928471054881811,
-0.009159381501376629,
0.011903722770512104,
-0.014289564453065395,
0.019692201167345047,
-0.05865056440234184,
0.014176890254020691,
-0.05955025181174278,
-0.012321267277002335,
-0.025510182604193687,
0.029125694185495377,
-0.030556173995137215,
0.02951895259320736,
0.01871776208281517,
0.000756414607167244,
0.03211146965622902,
0.0260336771607399,
-0.01696406677365303,
-0.019294140860438347,
-0.025235885754227638,
-0.04788059741258621,
0.03308313712477684,
0.027258634567260742,
0.011651482433080673,
-0.021836750209331512,
-0.002016485668718815,
0.004176721908152103,
0.03376120328903198,
0.03745371103286743,
-0.04345085471868515,
-0.022603336721658707,
0.025990206748247147,
-0.0009580536861903965,
-0.013113747350871563,
-0.01981341652572155,
-0.021507345139980316,
0.01677960343658924,
0.02195071429014206,
0.005010404624044895,
-0.03496255353093147,
0.022129571065306664,
0.008081783540546894,
-0.020621463656425476,
-0.00022210531460586935,
-0.0038505576085299253,
-0.009687569923698902,
-0.005910591688007116,
-0.02619072049856186,
0.014773950912058353,
0.009926825761795044,
-0.00013673047942575067,
-0.02973567694425583,
-0.03253328055143356,
-0.03415563702583313,
-0.0137751754373312,
0.026991436257958412,
-0.04586776718497276,
0.025384461507201195,
0.027751676738262177,
0.052298542112112045,
-0.038139089941978455,
-0.026836302131414413,
-0.004953659605234861,
-0.02827354334294796,
-0.020477604120969772,
-0.022607043385505676,
0.044406186789274216,
0.043893326073884964,
0.058469463139772415,
-0.035359445959329605,
0.014080638065934181,
0.003854045644402504,
0.06299976259469986,
-0.005964479874819517,
0.03535424545407295,
-0.012783781625330448,
0.07679204642772675,
-0.0057330504059791565,
-0.004800912458449602,
-0.0010469069238752127,
0.0475890152156353,
-0.007069667801260948,
0.017614012584090233,
-0.024359824135899544,
-0.0012878109700977802,
0.003097269684076309,
0.0070900460705161095,
0.05791423097252846,
0.02767583169043064,
0.017018986865878105,
0.005230281036347151,
0.01283391285687685,
-0.036710336804389954,
-0.0015912967501208186,
0.023745113983750343,
-0.04561987891793251,
-0.0034905378706753254,
0.005649142898619175,
-0.01262335292994976,
-0.025932082906365395,
-0.0319242998957634,
-0.01254905667155981,
0.028392968699336052,
-0.01647793874144554,
0.05557776242494583,
-0.086440309882164,
-0.0284064169973135,
-0.0028415173292160034,
-0.03478994220495224,
0.005657297093421221,
0.019108347594738007,
0.01183453481644392,
-0.0018860073760151863,
0.01546140294522047,
0.004483568482100964,
-0.015067527070641518,
0.047178130596876144,
0.02079574204981327,
0.04247497394680977,
-0.05168354883790016,
-0.01143586914986372,
0.012921891175210476,
-0.04868360236287117,
0.007593762595206499,
-0.023277800530195236,
-0.04804234951734543,
0.04752838611602783,
0.011496994644403458,
0.0446346290409565,
0.004600401967763901,
0.02123664878308773,
0.004549059085547924,
-0.03504684194922447,
-0.03395215794444084,
0.010646205395460129,
-0.02176601253449917,
0.026150057092308998,
-0.016335921362042427,
0.025229401886463165,
0.01636269874870777,
-0.007537078578025103,
0.07526436448097229,
-0.03885805979371071,
-0.05303630232810974,
0.08334573358297348,
-0.02346637099981308,
-0.026209605857729912,
0.03359377384185791,
0.011412648484110832,
-0.019976994022727013,
0.01385036576539278,
0.0237886980175972,
-0.01349885668605566,
-0.0023953807540237904,
0.006859655492007732,
0.006812949664890766,
0.031771380454301834,
0.016613032668828964,
0.005115996114909649,
-0.020950842648744583,
0.004008702468127012,
-0.008612033911049366,
-0.010352915152907372,
0.0176621675491333,
0.02635835111141205,
-0.033921245485544205,
0.014087377116084099,
-0.008013954386115074,
0.006315852049738169,
-0.0036224876530468464,
-0.022269517183303833,
-0.011066090315580368,
-0.061509810388088226,
-0.016462935134768486,
-0.00427370797842741,
0.01425918098539114,
-0.07116693258285522,
-0.015232172794640064,
0.010214581154286861,
0.012394131161272526,
-0.0062272571958601475,
0.045050762593746185,
-0.02987033501267433,
0.005387885961681604,
-0.029591605067253113,
0.02183162420988083,
0.03378301113843918,
0.03403540328145027,
-0.002480558818206191,
-0.0319906547665596,
0.003939903806895018,
0.028137177228927612,
0.04254814237356186,
-0.019448643550276756,
-0.038105323910713196,
0.03576243668794632,
0.04711950570344925,
-0.008428678847849369,
-0.02559581585228443,
0.0031701084226369858,
0.0323864184319973,
0.03354361280798912,
0.0292457714676857,
-0.02881965972483158,
-0.002995478454977274,
0.02629799209535122,
-0.048894163221120834,
-0.03542809188365936,
0.016377797350287437,
-0.002859208034351468,
0.03286182880401611,
-0.11066178232431412,
-0.005317761097103357,
-0.00736948661506176,
0.02316432259976864,
-0.025793137028813362,
-0.006053033284842968,
-0.040121715515851974,
-0.048102643340826035,
0.04701739549636841,
0.021507201716303825,
-0.014467928558588028,
-0.054864972829818726,
0.030335184186697006,
-0.0042152805253863335,
-0.0011483256239444017,
-0.006176256109029055,
-0.012196166440844536,
-0.002488932339474559,
-0.03288419917225838,
-0.02034861221909523,
0.012030906043946743,
-0.013835606165230274,
0.018878048285841942,
0.010878865607082844,
-0.037317074835300446,
-0.018369462341070175,
0.01578366570174694,
0.04992961138486862,
0.04301096498966217,
0.04668143019080162,
-0.015667768195271492,
-0.05023160204291344,
-0.005795493256300688,
-0.0013714015949517488,
-0.044913191348314285,
-0.006950782146304846,
-0.008736572228372097,
0.024077970534563065,
-0.04116945341229439,
0.025387180969119072,
-0.021820472553372383,
-0.00508886156603694,
0.003050522180274129,
0.004615094047039747,
-0.03240165114402771,
0.004837276414036751,
0.009518453851342201,
-0.015909360721707344,
0.017087258398532867,
-0.011983618140220642,
0.01886437088251114,
0.05483854189515114,
-0.0017809983110055327,
-0.07663498818874359,
0.016307920217514038,
0.016896435990929604,
0.023294471204280853,
-0.007625280879437923,
-0.027946244925260544,
-0.03898899257183075,
-0.0069641550071537495,
-0.03098621778190136,
0.012433906085789204,
-0.016487805172801018,
-0.0036908257752656937,
-0.0660194456577301,
-0.01248917356133461,
0.013163738884031773,
-0.01969030499458313,
-0.04853816702961922,
-0.01196496095508337,
-0.003198599675670266,
-0.022160550579428673,
-0.010511566884815693,
0.03974210470914841,
0.011110823601484299,
0.006659885868430138,
0.008312443271279335,
-0.02114160545170307,
-0.0331023707985878,
0.04454832896590233,
-0.02930567041039467,
0.017758799716830254,
-0.07437752932310104,
0.07481909543275833,
-0.04256284981966019,
-0.00100503652356565,
0.006948049180209637,
-0.019695544615387917,
0.006848928518593311,
-0.014055652543902397,
-0.013762177899479866,
-0.017777685075998306,
0.06626346707344055,
-0.024175157770514488,
-0.06596200913190842,
0.02754886820912361,
0.04012438282370567,
0.019685104489326477,
0.038981083780527115,
0.006833039224147797,
-0.021246962249279022,
0.018521087244153023,
-0.012746240943670273,
0.016064949333667755,
0.02544013224542141,
-0.012363409623503685,
0.0037307923194020987,
-0.01962696947157383,
0.03534030169248581,
0.004112321883440018,
-0.058996278792619705,
0.01338279340416193,
0.036673445254564285,
-0.004844257142394781,
-0.0037765486631542444,
-0.04332536458969116,
0.004842710215598345,
-0.003063341835513711,
0.006275745574384928,
0.041828710585832596,
0.01429931353777647,
-0.02295612171292305,
-0.04389238357543945,
-0.010114947333931923,
-0.028539415448904037,
0.04707666486501694,
-0.010806286707520485,
-0.011816417798399925,
-0.034329745918512344,
-0.016126293689012527,
0.008266725577414036,
-0.044991448521614075,
0.019110942259430885,
-0.011720363050699234,
0.004894505254924297,
-0.16131041944026947,
-0.004514811560511589,
0.018773723393678665,
0.02509484253823757,
-0.01290285773575306,
-0.012372685596346855,
0.009226201102137566,
-0.01032020803540945,
0.007686968892812729,
-0.017707059159874916,
-0.0009437185944989324,
-0.01785314455628395,
0.024675827473402023,
-0.025231877341866493,
-0.0010209387401118875,
-0.009343615733087063,
-0.01869557611644268,
-0.00784496869891882,
-0.022926777601242065,
-0.036642998456954956,
-0.01008564978837967,
0.01795315556228161,
-0.01297362893819809,
-0.021204873919487,
-0.0022822225000709295,
-0.009517976082861423,
-0.037716351449489594,
-0.03000984899699688,
-0.03354042395949364,
-0.0010763774625957012,
0.022029481828212738,
0.027688724920153618,
0.011488761752843857,
0.03814990445971489,
0.002554421778768301,
-0.024609321728348732,
0.017824044451117516,
0.0010076382895931602,
-0.04467377811670303,
-0.0237241480499506,
0.028667723760008812,
0.01736549660563469,
-0.009954233653843403,
0.017345670610666275,
0.03244059160351753,
-0.012357878498733044,
-0.040652140974998474,
0.005754744168370962,
-0.051133912056684494,
-0.004481652285903692,
-0.02430965006351471,
-0.004433281719684601,
-0.022526057437062263,
0.002447893377393484,
0.0344712994992733,
0.01902826502919197,
-0.023551831021904945,
0.03448783606290817,
-0.0456017442047596,
0.025532595813274384,
0.036421410739421844,
0.011355564929544926,
0.02097032591700554,
-0.01537509635090828,
0.013901511207222939,
-0.012136944569647312,
0.015144513919949532,
0.02507075108587742,
0.015233186073601246,
-0.034839216619729996,
-0.01535316463559866,
0.02443581260740757,
-0.004928803537040949,
-0.025501826778054237,
0.020703749731183052,
0.007714028935879469,
0.007223315071314573,
0.012864967808127403,
-0.04468298703432083,
-0.010386575013399124,
-0.03138399496674538,
0.003332744352519512,
-0.03842439502477646,
0.017586275935173035,
0.005596887785941362,
-0.0235572662204504,
-0.036645542830228806,
0.020586861297488213,
0.041531581431627274,
0.030080435797572136,
-0.06884220987558365,
0.0031573704909533262,
-0.00557709950953722,
0.06937120854854584,
-0.022429127246141434,
-0.02145312912762165,
-0.020297111943364143,
0.025467513129115105,
0.010078833438456059,
-0.012943624518811703,
-0.07565420866012573,
-0.05696331709623337,
0.024942547082901,
-0.014355792663991451,
-0.030772484838962555,
0.03634567931294441,
-0.020737696439027786,
0.024392729625105858,
0.028245026245713234,
0.00035985177964903414,
0.01028071902692318,
-0.021039500832557678,
0.027590729296207428,
0.007056197617202997,
-0.005944953765720129,
-0.019376683980226517,
-0.040643058717250824,
0.007091267965734005,
0.008263159543275833,
0.0084089245647192,
-0.022454971447587013,
-0.000683134188875556,
-0.042520344257354736,
-0.054338254034519196,
0.01737864874303341,
-0.03374342992901802,
-0.012951911427080631,
0.005353813525289297,
-0.009029320441186428,
-0.030178993940353394,
0.01458163931965828,
-0.021999454125761986,
-0.05970380827784538,
0.0381908193230629,
0.015784798189997673,
0.017592545598745346,
-0.020437370985746384,
0.016414228826761246,
0.03225070610642433,
-0.036248255521059036,
0.02309192530810833,
-0.014327013865113258,
0.029943516477942467,
0.02999127469956875,
0.004716778174042702,
0.013981514610350132,
0.03182476386427879,
-0.007652054540812969,
-0.042056236416101456,
-0.025421056896448135,
0.021693678572773933,
0.057258009910583496,
-0.001964242896065116,
0.02377401292324066,
0.052792005240917206,
-0.010216619819402695,
0.01766800321638584,
-0.005796145182102919,
0.030008558183908463,
0.042131099849939346,
-0.01067475974559784,
-0.05797676369547844,
-0.03808789700269699,
-0.014799912460148335,
-0.013751943595707417,
-0.038724686950445175,
0.0027273809537291527,
-0.00443772878497839,
0.039166178554296494,
-0.010369222611188889,
0.0366704985499382,
0.0037250982131808996,
-0.029013870283961296,
-0.017207032069563866,
0.013935087248682976,
0.04056807607412338,
0.0061777192167937756,
0.0005096485838294029,
-0.0016471310518682003,
-0.03811809420585632,
0.051785022020339966,
0.02494066394865513,
-0.020896703004837036,
-0.02264883741736412,
-0.029069550335407257,
0.03317501023411751,
0.08810502290725708,
0.015071477741003036,
0.0033134780824184418,
-0.0025148624554276466,
0.0306128840893507,
-0.0011128627229481936,
0.07151404768228531,
0.004568271804600954,
-0.017412526533007622,
-0.020402908325195312,
-0.03985392674803734,
0.03218081220984459,
-0.033971067517995834,
0.0022391739767044783,
0.03253878280520439,
-0.030570946633815765,
-0.03046492114663124,
0.011538450606167316,
-0.008113146759569645,
-0.02396245114505291,
0.004769561812281609,
0.014676523394882679,
-0.04157914221286774,
0.02751123532652855,
-0.024152252823114395,
0.0003334706125315279,
-0.052348293364048004,
0.02650715783238411,
0.02314750850200653,
0.034391969442367554,
0.07136927545070648,
0.01985734887421131,
0.026089714840054512,
-0.05873508378863335,
0.01114777009934187,
0.04266461357474327,
0.013786965049803257,
-0.031985167413949966,
0.014599745161831379,
0.01583719812333584,
-0.021664705127477646,
-0.004347359761595726,
-0.030144378542900085,
-0.04113508760929108,
-0.037022799253463745,
-0.027989892289042473,
-0.00993467215448618,
0.0037877776194363832,
0.07510928064584732,
0.027588726952672005,
0.018158916383981705,
-0.0008028878946788609,
-0.0023532863706350327,
-0.015771862119436264,
0.05334595590829849,
-0.004719969816505909,
-0.01609167642891407,
-0.02403067611157894
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:14
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
, if the defrauded party goes into possession of property sold to him by the contract, or accepts some other benefit thereunder.
This is a form of estoppel, for the other party has in such a case acted to his prejudice upon a representation, made by the defrauded party's conduct, that the latter is going on with the contract. The law does not require the representor in such a case to inquire of the representee whether he knows his legal rights."
202This correctness of this conclusion has been doubted by the authors of Contract Law in Australia (at 15-48) although not by Seddon and Ellinghouse, Cheshire and Fifoot's Law of Contract, 9th ed (2008) at 11.50.
203In the earlier case of O'Connor v S.P. Bray Limited (1936) 36 SR (NSW) 248 at 262 Jordan CJ concluded that knowledge of the legal consequences of facts was not necessary in order that there be affirmation. That decision was reversed by the High Court (in O'Connor v S.P. Bray Limited (1937) 56 CLR 464) but this proposition was not doubted.
204Mr Jucovic pointed out that O'Connor v Bray Limited was a case involving damages for personal injuries (not a fraud case) and that what Sir Frederick Jordan said was obiter.
205Nonetheless, as Pincus J said in Re Hoffman: Ex parte Worrell v Schilling (1989) 85 ALR 145 at 151, it is "weighty authority".
206The matter was discussed by Mason J in Sargent v ASL Developments Limited (1974) 131 CLR 634 at 658. His Honour said:-
"If a party to a contract, aware of a breach going to the root of the contract, or of other circumstances entitling him to terminate the contract, or of other circumstances entitling him to terminate the contract, though unaware of the existence of the right to terminate the contract, exercises rights under the contract, he must be held to have made a binding election to affirm.
Such conduct is justifiable only on the footing that an election has been made to affirm the contract; the conduct is adverse to the other party and may therefore be considered unequivocal in its effect.
The justification for imputing to the affirming party a binding election in these circumstances, though he be unaware of his alternative right, is that, having a knowledge of the facts sufficient to alert him to the possibility of the existence of his alternative right,
he has acted adversely to the other party and that, by so doing, he has induced the other party to believe that performance of the contract is insisted upon.
It is with these considerations in mind that the law attributes to the party the making of a choice, though he be ignorant of his alternative right. For reasons stated earlier the affirming party cannot be permitted to change his position once he has elected.
Whether any distinction should be drawn between this class of case and fraudulent misrepresentation (...) need not be determined. However, it should be kept firmly in mind that the doctrine of election is of general application and that no good purpose is to be served by drawing distinctions in its various applications unless considerations of justice make it necessary or expedient so to do."
207In Re Hoffman Pincus J considered the above authorities and concluded at 151-152:-
"In my respectful opinion, the question whether knowledge of the actual right to rescind is essential in fraud cases is still open, as was said in Sargent's case ...
Although it is true that the authorities are at variance, the better view appears to be that (as was the case, in the opinion of Jordan CJ, in 1936) the weight of authority favours the existence of the general rule that, where knowledge is necessary to make an election effective, it is knowledge of the facts giving rise to the right to elect, not knowledge of the right itself, which must be proved.
|
[
-0.02351476065814495,
0.030828559771180153,
0.009382368065416813,
0.0079570971429348,
0.0017403489910066128,
-0.06297437846660614,
0.051163747906684875,
-0.014105444774031639,
-0.007028802298009396,
0.004611756652593613,
-0.003224694635719061,
0.02741779014468193,
-0.04936648905277252,
-0.00021866745373699814,
-0.0019213155610486865,
-0.0033663217909634113,
0.022159283980727196,
-0.024982497096061707,
-0.03319382295012474,
0.013083010911941528,
-0.04439924284815788,
-0.03849802538752556,
0.023190373554825783,
0.059113677591085434,
0.028368838131427765,
0.0586412288248539,
0.0036603326443582773,
0.024738537147641182,
0.020686542615294456,
-0.028876228258013725,
-0.024141503497958183,
0.0069464752450585365,
0.04865673556923866,
-0.029251817613840103,
-0.04301537200808525,
0.00753356097266078,
0.021068137139081955,
0.013044946826994419,
-0.011414590291678905,
-0.010212916880846024,
-0.006319303996860981,
0.037520889192819595,
0.02382664382457733,
-0.054013535380363464,
0.0518827848136425,
-0.030021388083696365,
0.0021066884510219097,
-0.022470323368906975,
0.047701869159936905,
0.0033890921622514725,
-0.06967725604772568,
0.011467847041785717,
0.10689657181501389,
-0.005968769080936909,
-0.004621807020157576,
0.0273098424077034,
-0.014949411153793335,
-0.013240650296211243,
-0.04997268319129944,
-0.003759569488465786,
0.018940042704343796,
-0.010290647856891155,
-0.10085202753543854,
-0.004461504984647036,
0.01482667587697506,
0.020004484802484512,
-0.029273804277181625,
-0.03874397650361061,
-0.016798989847302437,
-0.027280088514089584,
-0.029437247663736343,
0.039448611438274384,
-0.06857993453741074,
-0.005187947303056717,
-0.09802641719579697,
0.006773230154067278,
-0.01271540392190218,
0.01741967909038067,
0.008380923420190811,
0.02547391876578331,
0.009342486970126629,
-0.03616825491189957,
0.03899802267551422,
0.019504135474562645,
-0.03113689459860325,
0.011166593059897423,
-0.001653420040383935,
0.005441657267510891,
-0.0077028884552419186,
0.004546881187707186,
-0.009940075688064098,
-0.0036370004527270794,
0.02942586876451969,
-0.010397659614682198,
0.02377583645284176,
-0.022145235911011696,
-0.04411013424396515,
-0.00843457505106926,
-0.009980965405702591,
0.02297094836831093,
0.0010387375950813293,
0.032903507351875305,
0.0031023058108985424,
-0.028096772730350494,
-0.04099569097161293,
0.00538212526589632,
0.031585533171892166,
0.040420930832624435,
0.023227712139487267,
-0.0026882877573370934,
-0.012452234514057636,
-0.002899379236623645,
0.029704131186008453,
0.013050432316958904,
-0.025095900520682335,
0.010775540955364704,
0.019261788576841354,
0.014496014453470707,
-0.027434708550572395,
0.015119885094463825,
-0.0003763355780392885,
0.016699884086847305,
0.07158593833446503,
0.002464449964463711,
-0.0216103196144104,
0.0004939446225762367,
-0.006874986924231052,
-0.019815802574157715,
-0.005049246363341808,
0.020249269902706146,
0.05233518034219742,
-0.011297590099275112,
-0.022379079833626747,
-0.027545910328626633,
-0.028657058253884315,
-0.042209260165691376,
0.039923783391714096,
-0.0035181711427867413,
0.008606890216469765,
-0.04726603254675865,
0.0600212924182415,
0.0367237888276577,
-0.016413051635026932,
-0.012780757620930672,
0.005029243882745504,
0.0038981225807219744,
0.03712710738182068,
-0.02303881198167801,
0.012408903799951077,
-0.0162601787596941,
0.029275668784976006,
0.018911955878138542,
0.03224918246269226,
-0.05272805690765381,
0.04455234855413437,
-0.0142333609983325,
0.019496867433190346,
0.0012216231552883983,
0.010784875601530075,
0.005054926965385675,
-0.02119169570505619,
0.030047839507460594,
-0.014653483405709267,
-0.030219968408346176,
-0.020283134654164314,
-0.005825628526508808,
0.026281213387846947,
-0.008376065641641617,
-0.02796063758432865,
-0.018842630088329315,
0.028002889826893806,
-0.023308316245675087,
0.007133611477911472,
-0.02199459820985794,
0.0058540040627121925,
0.02921266295015812,
0.06590090692043304,
0.017253385856747627,
-0.002019573235884309,
-0.04444294422864914,
-0.024086415767669678,
0.003368037287145853,
0.013373560272157192,
-0.010652047581970692,
-0.03694723919034004,
0.018414776772260666,
0.012477083131670952,
-0.009886546991765499,
0.04049154743552208,
0.000029430710128508508,
-0.03531809151172638,
-0.061383213847875595,
0.05343429744243622,
0.046634089201688766,
0.02143685147166252,
-0.022720307111740112,
0.020322686061263084,
-0.011480838991701603,
0.022161992266774178,
0.011097272858023643,
-0.0414532870054245,
0.00543212890625,
0.04694601520895958,
-0.01783609203994274,
-0.034812718629837036,
0.008029970340430737,
-0.05572054907679558,
0.010598418302834034,
0.015097205527126789,
-0.045512694865465164,
0.023139243945479393,
-0.00422386871650815,
0.0027026517782360315,
0.02526966854929924,
0.0059509011916816235,
0.013591266237199306,
-0.03223736956715584,
-0.013578524813055992,
-0.015348503366112709,
-0.011205642484128475,
-0.005938285030424595,
-0.02274072729051113,
0.012882211245596409,
0.008686034008860588,
0.04051864892244339,
0.0015480548609048128,
-0.00714088836684823,
0.005211201496422291,
0.011211843229830265,
-0.025371218100190163,
0.01116738747805357,
0.0067939492873847485,
0.02893752045929432,
-0.04068010300397873,
0.01888240873813629,
-0.004060566425323486,
0.01725875958800316,
0.04308409243822098,
0.025426719337701797,
0.011663787998259068,
-0.018786104395985603,
-0.02591557614505291,
0.03193088248372078,
-0.004194458015263081,
0.004781569354236126,
0.012848053127527237,
-0.023515228182077408,
-0.01050086971372366,
0.005143782123923302,
-0.015297319740056992,
-0.028453825041651726,
0.013715752400457859,
-0.026089994236826897,
-0.00391444843262434,
0.005306434817612171,
0.05305521935224533,
0.023976340889930725,
-0.003245308995246887,
0.014956830069422722,
-0.006821115966886282,
0.016092350706458092,
0.02368311956524849,
0.0017270775279030204,
0.006868880242109299,
-0.026574837043881416,
-0.02642260678112507,
-0.06741445511579514,
-0.04674063250422478,
0.02260204404592514,
-0.003652469487860799,
0.021990599110722542,
-0.031411103904247284,
0.006213981658220291,
-0.026592286303639412,
0.03346238657832146,
0.08044007420539856,
0.04283260554075241,
-0.023786067962646484,
0.0614190511405468,
0.013392427936196327,
-0.013492866419255733,
0.000331045885104686,
0.04527800530195236,
-0.02597121335566044,
-0.012816151604056358,
-0.02529761753976345,
-0.02333718165755272,
-0.024587340652942657,
0.011885485611855984,
-0.07798703014850616,
0.01827901601791382,
-0.018744833767414093,
0.07891573756933212,
-0.0023716941941529512,
-0.06505133211612701,
-0.036240749061107635,
-0.005514107178896666,
-0.14067666232585907,
-0.02231922186911106,
0.021685564890503883,
-0.019232628867030144,
-0.012920414097607136,
0.024901581928133965,
0.0006626288522966206,
-0.0129709392786026,
-0.002333790995180607,
-0.0005190499941818416,
0.014523505233228207,
-0.06862001121044159,
-0.040306709706783295,
0.028419209644198418,
0.015299921855330467,
0.014588575810194016,
-0.018315410241484642,
0.015466929413378239,
0.014137751422822475,
-0.004261697176843882,
0.008377890102565289,
-0.005230763927102089,
0.057529203593730927,
0.008239359594881535,
0.03948922082781792,
0.04488862305879593,
0.0062990980222821236,
-0.027060501277446747,
-0.00858534686267376,
0.0598146878182888,
-0.0000985812657745555,
0.045222070068120956,
-0.005905236583203077,
0.03832583129405975,
-0.004633921664208174,
0.019321294501423836,
0.012356121093034744,
-0.0799822062253952,
0.040410179644823074,
-0.017807185649871826,
0.02396705001592636,
0.07291889935731888,
-0.03103386051952839,
0.055582527071237564,
-0.0032661166042089462,
-0.05415087565779686,
0.007856364361941814,
0.02350737527012825,
-0.0028948746621608734,
0.02218426764011383,
-0.039663929492235184,
-0.039738141000270844,
-0.042225390672683716,
-0.015034124255180359,
-0.027362164109945297,
-0.011258332058787346,
0.05461680144071579,
0.0422801673412323,
-0.006909747142344713,
-0.033041637390851974,
-0.014720256440341473,
-0.053775690495967865,
0.028273852542042732,
-0.00293882773257792,
-0.034011561423540115,
0.009626138024032116,
0.017451230436563492,
-0.013930202461779118,
0.03254511579871178,
-0.017637815326452255,
0.008856928907334805,
0.0051194727420806885,
0.009157571010291576,
-0.006396854761987925,
0.011310124769806862,
0.005196542479097843,
-0.013582675717771053,
-0.0016313322121277452,
0.002877564402297139,
-0.05012102425098419,
0.06204617768526077,
0.014754826202988625,
-0.022401800379157066,
0.05145271494984627,
-0.02291947603225708,
-0.025597993284463882,
0.03625566512346268,
-0.0216958187520504,
0.030353186652064323,
0.23979535698890686,
0.061260905116796494,
-0.0031946487724781036,
-0.01894989050924778,
0.011114947497844696,
-0.013600748032331467,
0.06029856204986572,
-0.0048782918602228165,
0.010517871007323265,
-0.02980068325996399,
0.03070984035730362,
0.011048161424696445,
0.0022703134454786777,
0.02494187280535698,
-0.050328150391578674,
0.0006282118265517056,
-0.012786900624632835,
-0.030390281230211258,
0.08350129425525665,
0.011860212311148643,
0.05013727769255638,
-0.027064373716711998,
0.03972068428993225,
0.05794355273246765,
-0.025359435006976128,
-0.03255593776702881,
-0.0025115145836025476,
-0.006713878363370895,
0.0034710729960352182,
0.003665215102955699,
-0.024294035509228706,
-0.007256980054080486,
0.050441592931747437,
-0.055199842900037766,
0.01610841229557991,
0.02000327780842781,
-0.036759886890649796,
0.03011169284582138,
-0.06209481880068779,
0.04393262043595314,
0.01967054419219494,
-0.03561968356370926,
0.01615346595644951,
-0.051937323063611984,
-0.0019580379594117403,
0.011525471694767475,
-0.018196983262896538,
0.03556784614920616,
-0.0127626433968544,
0.04471142962574959,
-0.03018512949347496,
0.01987985335290432,
-0.05405433475971222,
0.007297293748706579,
-0.020268572494387627,
0.04458274319767952,
-0.026189660653471947,
0.046147774904966354,
-0.042054496705532074,
0.027649641036987305,
-0.02273148111999035,
0.023440377786755562,
-0.000863399647641927,
0.044459033757448196,
-0.02663063071668148,
-0.018214408308267593,
-0.03208190202713013,
-0.04393559694290161,
0.05306537076830864,
0.03689918667078018,
0.05655265599489212,
-0.004866818897426128,
0.036197565495967865,
0.04544847458600998,
0.00473268236964941,
0.014637520536780357,
-0.028499724343419075,
0.0071451435796916485,
0.018498441204428673,
-0.006594396661967039,
-0.014647184871137142,
-0.029176434502005577,
-0.005846234504133463,
0.010682692751288414,
0.005121367517858744,
-0.029885513707995415,
-0.03976321965456009,
0.06269408017396927,
0.035978030413389206,
0.0031929281540215015,
-0.03582831844687462,
-0.02605685219168663,
-0.009713164530694485,
0.0015101999742910266,
-0.06147116795182228,
-0.0026280232705175877,
0.007903018966317177,
-0.021468447521328926,
0.005102050956338644,
-0.014990766532719135,
-0.008899856358766556,
-0.012843998149037361,
0.008520519360899925,
-0.027855131775140762,
0.027848875150084496,
0.014705785550177097,
0.03827320411801338,
-0.020644331350922585,
-0.028304584324359894,
0.0030772299505770206,
0.02198476903140545,
-0.01554300356656313,
-0.036679286509752274,
-0.01445500086992979,
0.03421688452363014,
0.022147109732031822,
-0.0756392627954483,
0.02831583097577095,
-0.01598314568400383,
0.028356192633509636,
0.006049363873898983,
-0.006251473445445299,
-0.0007441971683874726,
0.02098945714533329,
-0.01396799087524414,
-0.02725665085017681,
-0.05145736038684845,
0.018012629821896553,
0.015408752486109734,
-0.0278963353484869,
-0.02701285481452942,
-0.005095524247735739,
-0.018826059997081757,
0.015793146565556526,
0.010919823311269283,
0.018150657415390015,
0.04931887984275818,
0.016366466879844666,
-0.0077247717417776585,
0.007229469250887632,
-0.01212832611054182,
0.004655860364437103,
-0.026739487424492836,
-0.005423244554549456,
0.005069127306342125,
-0.002833480713889003,
-0.07022946327924728,
0.012054476886987686,
-0.03596699237823486,
0.022176437079906464,
0.0008051050826907158,
0.03904517740011215,
-0.029944976791739464,
-0.038758959621191025,
-0.0047691864892840385,
-0.0007480692584067583,
0.004013994242995977,
-0.030314814299345016,
0.02334572933614254,
-0.014677139930427074,
0.016706235706806183,
0.04221520200371742,
-0.001237952383235097,
0.035839151591062546,
0.03284454718232155,
0.023410093039274216,
0.01592974178493023,
0.004359128884971142,
0.02682122029364109,
0.007121691480278969,
-0.022665251046419144,
-0.04362580180168152,
-0.03966538608074188,
0.03872426599264145,
0.055186208337545395,
0.04509764909744263,
-0.031383857131004333,
0.05800061672925949,
-0.005496964789927006,
-0.07139027863740921,
-0.009872404858469963,
0.004211153835058212,
-0.03946177288889885,
0.006717427168041468,
-0.02106865867972374,
-0.02204604633152485,
0.007874204777181149,
0.003684146562591195,
0.09784702211618423,
-0.037777215242385864,
-0.03045840561389923,
0.10949363559484482,
-0.017222721129655838,
-0.018270637840032578,
0.02968616597354412,
0.06532195955514908,
0.00303902430459857,
0.013504213653504848,
0.04384148493409157,
-0.05664276331663132,
-0.009187142364680767,
-0.00942347664386034,
-0.032213445752859116,
0.03174785524606705,
0.005139281507581472,
0.010547906160354614,
-0.04273092374205589,
0.01198445912450552,
-0.00687381299212575,
-0.026681633666157722,
0.03092319890856743,
-0.02207941561937332,
-0.06845475733280182,
-0.0029913405887782574,
0.0014410857111215591,
0.0101088285446167,
-0.004052717238664627,
0.02579776756465435,
-0.0015216711908578873,
-0.050498150289058685,
0.03201949968934059,
-0.03874683007597923,
-0.012060790322721004,
-0.09836762398481369,
-0.006057090125977993,
0.0393325537443161,
-0.018273159861564636,
0.0005144308670423925,
0.015098419040441513,
-0.011032579466700554,
0.0005030430620536208,
-0.04263831675052643,
0.04195653274655342,
0.02347002550959587,
-0.009039131924510002,
0.005518453195691109,
-0.03427533805370331,
0.009647664614021778,
0.0177114550024271,
0.020609160885214806,
-0.01642618142068386,
-0.0013779096771031618,
0.043878547847270966,
0.01719345524907112,
-0.007390361279249191,
0.008834265172481537,
-0.0361681766808033,
-0.0016470339614897966,
0.029417824000120163,
0.03186987340450287,
-0.028099464252591133,
-0.008713302202522755,
-0.0043839579448103905,
-0.025636430829763412,
-0.01013188622891903,
0.029353082180023193,
0.034455087035894394,
0.004692647606134415,
-0.06715217232704163,
0.011807660572230816,
0.01078388188034296,
0.03887990117073059,
-0.00896523054689169,
-0.0034081730991601944,
-0.00628961157053709,
-0.05049886181950569,
0.05252332240343094,
-0.034153733402490616,
-0.023931926116347313,
-0.066680409014225,
-0.006784491240978241,
0.009924616664648056,
-0.044937968254089355,
-0.0015957567375153303,
0.0006264583789743483,
0.019603068009018898,
-0.008945703506469727,
0.03218657895922661,
-0.010842354968190193,
0.014760902151465416,
0.022495560348033905,
0.02129005454480648,
-0.012647008523344994,
0.023128237575292587,
-0.0014151543145999312,
0.025366084650158882,
0.03629150986671448,
0.0003907893842551857,
0.00606762757524848,
-0.02917061187326908,
0.039249565452337265,
0.0012556578731164336,
-0.01710033044219017,
0.021591948345303535,
0.007283815648406744,
0.050415102392435074,
0.01911683939397335,
0.027444694191217422,
-0.014364664442837238,
0.04198962450027466,
-0.00636982312425971,
-0.0004739230789709836,
-0.023082157596945763,
-0.007494835183024406,
-0.0013803441543132067,
0.018612947314977646,
0.022408779710531235,
0.017015473917126656,
0.009633283130824566,
0.022507045418024063,
0.014006542973220348,
-0.09052495658397675,
-0.03149586543440819,
0.005299563053995371,
-0.009476788341999054,
0.00385843007825315,
0.009669356979429722,
-0.0390167273581028,
-0.01698903553187847,
0.002684070263057947,
-0.0011422886746004224,
0.006382768042385578,
-0.046654071658849716,
-0.05178937315940857,
-0.05332877114415169,
0.013182041235268116,
-0.04537837952375412,
-0.03538193553686142,
-0.008918858133256435,
-0.015333467163145542,
-0.03380643203854561,
-0.0049667758867144585,
0.045699529349803925,
-0.026242060586810112,
0.0038399838376790285,
0.05344162508845329,
-0.02700856514275074,
-0.043620895594358444,
0.023854827508330345,
-0.02344047836959362,
-0.009955235756933689,
-0.1075224056839943,
0.1446526199579239,
-0.03024870902299881,
-0.001132747856900096,
0.02892748825252056,
0.009227080270648003,
0.01710810512304306,
-0.009694353677332401,
0.020784959197044373,
-0.045507799834012985,
0.017882272601127625,
0.007348679471760988,
-0.04086938127875328,
0.059586301445961,
0.012893482111394405,
0.024954384192824364,
0.007864357903599739,
0.027827471494674683,
-0.020287783816456795,
-0.004452026914805174,
0.009432443417608738,
0.04275400936603546,
-0.02433398738503456,
-0.013030847534537315,
-0.002977505326271057,
-0.020272688940167427,
-0.0029195083770900965,
0.036835748702287674,
-0.016706068068742752,
0.02759615331888199,
0.028017280623316765,
0.03245401009917259,
-0.0006732578622177243,
-0.012928665615618229,
0.04092618077993393,
-0.004937736317515373,
0.02409820817410946,
0.006083460990339518,
0.003480486338958144,
0.02053139917552471,
-0.0488126277923584,
-0.03769657760858536,
-0.02048521302640438,
0.009705988690257072,
-0.034591760486364365,
0.01595265045762062,
-0.012425076216459274,
-0.03353307768702507,
0.0038392478600144386,
-0.04521358013153076,
0.04993065819144249,
-0.01098551508039236,
-0.02738850750029087,
-0.13171929121017456,
0.037148550152778625,
0.009472116827964783,
0.03276088088750839,
-0.046928372234106064,
-0.011920025572180748,
-0.007325638085603714,
-0.006034901365637779,
0.0011101369746029377,
-0.030885886400938034,
-0.021173149347305298,
-0.03385567665100098,
0.001079979003407061,
-0.01943442039191723,
-0.001297751092351973,
-0.004424963612109423,
0.013509239070117474,
-0.018682312220335007,
-0.05183543264865875,
-0.0005145970499143004,
-0.005113189574331045,
0.01125265285372734,
-0.027948657050728798,
-0.0023184088058769703,
-0.01129561010748148,
-0.007964280433952808,
-0.03461720794439316,
-0.05952629819512367,
-0.022450489923357964,
-0.03580021485686302,
-0.010335627943277359,
-0.035896800458431244,
-0.006090255919843912,
0.03304557129740715,
0.0026112475898116827,
-0.03614237904548645,
0.010806247591972351,
0.010460876859724522,
-0.05276457220315933,
-0.024790214374661446,
0.009143861010670662,
0.026063909754157066,
0.01556803472340107,
-0.01376296952366829,
-0.007314130198210478,
0.03211381286382675,
-0.014666559174656868,
0.007148295640945435,
-0.07745657861232758,
-0.012046520598232746,
-0.06252384185791016,
0.04787757620215416,
-0.04470159485936165,
0.010774722322821617,
0.00881993304938078,
0.015464008785784245,
-0.03875773400068283,
0.014017036184668541,
-0.031605903059244156,
0.07779817283153534,
0.018480533733963966,
0.032145533710718155,
-0.001464811502955854,
-0.02211753837764263,
0.03144822269678116,
0.030915850773453712,
-0.025178758427500725,
0.004245981574058533,
-0.0003911874664481729,
-0.013795573264360428,
-0.04073064774274826,
0.011324567720293999,
0.006936188321560621,
-0.0024862736463546753,
-0.006201029755175114,
-0.0060962168499827385,
0.02401059865951538,
-0.00620224280282855,
-0.028281936421990395,
-0.029021766036748886,
-0.05673954263329506,
-0.019517948850989342,
-0.026799829676747322,
0.02035728469491005,
-0.000998994684778154,
0.04965689033269882,
-0.031303856521844864,
0.026755062863230705,
0.0323384553194046,
-0.023201286792755127,
-0.02493416890501976,
-0.004195966757833958,
-0.018228765577077866,
0.05484616756439209,
0.02384507656097412,
-0.003306278958916664,
-0.020704025402665138,
0.026767071336507797,
-0.04253678768873215,
0.004534752573817968,
-0.04114710912108421,
-0.04702340438961983,
0.04079919680953026,
-0.027707194909453392,
-0.03908925503492355,
0.023017166182398796,
0.004614365287125111,
0.013231019489467144,
-0.012364792637526989,
0.017513899132609367,
0.033388782292604446,
-0.03450895473361015,
-0.02010236121714115,
-0.03348170220851898,
-0.0020679067820310593,
-0.006190851796418428,
-0.03641974925994873,
0.014489020220935345,
-0.015239267610013485,
-0.006105727981775999,
0.005576627794653177,
-0.012591896578669548,
-0.011930746026337147,
-0.0285634882748127,
0.02368755266070366,
0.010267196223139763,
0.04756101965904236,
-0.004682511556893587,
-0.006167578510940075,
-0.00926579162478447,
0.047559138387441635,
-0.016635622829198837,
-0.021004879847168922,
0.02133837901055813,
0.009985865093767643,
-0.019281476736068726,
-0.006560570560395718,
0.00184763188008219,
-0.005479460582137108,
-0.03170819953083992,
0.012859109789133072,
-0.04633631929755211,
0.004937723744660616,
-0.004385975655168295,
-0.033804599195718765,
0.0023324512876570225,
0.0476933978497982,
0.015305845998227596,
-0.009482651017606258,
-0.0590866394340992,
-0.0023598717525601387,
-0.003908233251422644,
0.022796010598540306,
0.006135326344519854,
0.0373421274125576,
-0.013420131988823414,
-0.0013082025106996298,
-0.028813179582357407,
0.009819749742746353,
0.06546654552221298,
0.026175079867243767,
-0.019986946135759354,
-0.021200599148869514,
-0.07464125007390976,
0.0141984848305583,
0.014254413545131683,
-0.0076215206645429134,
0.0014188626082614064,
0.022453786805272102,
0.0011757409665733576,
-0.020798292011022568,
0.034271158277988434,
0.002983155893161893,
-0.037108372896909714,
-0.006231185048818588,
0.008285137824714184,
0.009713415056467056,
-0.03292369470000267,
0.009474213235080242,
-0.03158281743526459,
0.028946496546268463,
0.04390373080968857,
0.028877004981040955,
-0.020742142572999,
0.009199336171150208,
0.0025828180368989706,
0.03104202263057232,
0.0020156160462647676,
-0.008414105512201786,
-0.01910005696117878,
-0.011630063876509666,
-0.014373443089425564,
0.020045142620801926,
-0.001923163770698011,
-0.003437338164076209,
-0.008312875404953957,
-0.03689134493470192,
0.0035713091492652893,
0.0010433965362608433,
0.03315606713294983,
-0.014597060158848763,
-0.02598886378109455,
-0.030741821974515915,
-0.002952967304736376,
-0.0010438322788104415,
-0.02004615031182766,
-0.004157991148531437,
-0.018180742859840393,
-0.033528488129377365,
0.03686175122857094,
-0.01065645832568407,
0.004723560996353626,
-0.036432165652513504,
0.04577749967575073,
0.00787588581442833,
-0.008747855201363564,
0.041513435542583466,
-0.025269797071814537,
0.04653621464967728,
-0.019815687090158463,
0.02651829458773136,
0.05637342482805252,
-0.015987353399395943,
-0.03292103856801987,
0.02078486979007721,
-0.004518923349678516,
-0.011675003916025162,
0.008778288960456848,
-0.008457939140498638,
-0.02472129464149475,
-0.0515570193529129,
-0.022205902263522148,
0.03516470640897751,
0.036360014230012894,
0.007603939156979322,
-0.014607178047299385,
-0.025104369968175888,
-0.013659804128110409,
-0.036132168024778366,
-0.022181566804647446,
0.027420632541179657,
-0.0027553020045161247,
-0.0032505514100193977,
0.007556116208434105
] |
What is the general rule regarding knowledge of the right to elect in cases of affirmation of a contract?
|
[
-0.05626589432358742,
-0.013270866125822067,
0.010702289640903473,
0.0468393936753273,
0.0014992911601439118,
-0.07234298437833786,
0.022670932114124298,
0.0007347670034505427,
-0.02543005347251892,
0.00035506291897036135,
0.028425002470612526,
-0.016291847452521324,
-0.012078926898539066,
0.022405516356229782,
-0.010593059472739697,
-0.012428025715053082,
0.029167629778385162,
-0.04543401300907135,
-0.01967526227235794,
0.02626921236515045,
-0.02895267866551876,
-0.015177242457866669,
-0.03172622621059418,
-0.006503851618617773,
0.02639610879123211,
0.032815881073474884,
-0.017423836514353752,
0.0001787374640116468,
-0.009702740237116814,
-0.0071171363815665245,
-0.021244117990136147,
0.024026839062571526,
-0.002175442175939679,
-0.061485327780246735,
-0.008428848348557949,
0.015910031273961067,
0.028694627806544304,
-0.028587568551301956,
-0.037835899740457535,
-0.03584320470690727,
-0.003385865595191717,
0.004920846316963434,
0.012320506386458874,
-0.05806320905685425,
0.029513714835047722,
-0.013142483308911324,
-0.008270986378192902,
-0.032982513308525085,
0.01672937162220478,
0.024417558684945107,
-0.07168669253587723,
-0.003841613419353962,
0.07417960464954376,
0.0014429427683353424,
0.017057757824659348,
0.05107861012220383,
-0.00483679911121726,
0.0031425782945007086,
-0.035191040486097336,
-0.02928553707897663,
0.0027401733677834272,
-0.01556370034813881,
-0.07920752465724945,
0.014641353860497475,
0.046412087976932526,
-0.0227301474660635,
0.04892660304903984,
-0.06138459965586662,
0.005831258837133646,
-0.03958063945174217,
-0.023624125868082047,
0.03824516385793686,
-0.042809125036001205,
0.002374273259192705,
-0.08048170804977417,
0.0323406346142292,
0.00927524734288454,
-0.00972880981862545,
-0.024702446535229683,
-0.016232378780841827,
-0.03429219871759415,
-0.033197831362485886,
0.05521626025438309,
0.05236489698290825,
-0.0461113415658474,
-0.010737103410065174,
-0.026847749948501587,
0.013840308412909508,
0.01172829419374466,
0.023504620417952538,
-0.0026166578754782677,
-0.0001751821837387979,
0.02215012162923813,
-0.015557701699435711,
0.007242600433528423,
-0.06518306583166122,
-0.007600265555083752,
-0.027680516242980957,
-0.014328816905617714,
0.040115538984537125,
0.0062036216259002686,
0.008983459323644638,
0.013880428858101368,
-0.010970646515488625,
-0.006943371146917343,
0.009639100171625614,
0.021431144326925278,
0.03923754766583443,
0.0033529663924127817,
0.02092343382537365,
-0.04400929436087608,
-0.016587676480412483,
0.04007720202207565,
-0.00653604744002223,
0.0013073482550680637,
-0.0049889166839420795,
0.02098085917532444,
0.029513390734791756,
-0.0024680120404809713,
0.026945635676383972,
-0.00641215406358242,
-0.02747228555381298,
0.024922069162130356,
-0.006429918576031923,
-0.05294215679168701,
-0.014039537869393826,
0.020514827221632004,
-0.015141740441322327,
0.001669627265073359,
0.05668746307492256,
0.05316251516342163,
-0.011541652493178844,
-0.014667115174233913,
-0.004104458261281252,
-0.050529446452856064,
-0.042163699865341187,
0.0030502222944051027,
-0.0191898662596941,
-0.012471760623157024,
-0.06906937062740326,
0.05012362822890282,
0.00017030227172654122,
-0.01785791665315628,
-0.01355823315680027,
0.014658017084002495,
-0.026277586817741394,
0.015919730067253113,
-0.025819363072514534,
0.044586628675460815,
-0.04467135667800903,
0.03560104966163635,
0.014214267022907734,
0.03661111369729042,
-0.03501085564494133,
0.011898569762706757,
-0.06279384344816208,
0.029526717960834503,
-0.028934167698025703,
0.028499342501163483,
0.030026329681277275,
0.04406733065843582,
0.018987542018294334,
0.01776808500289917,
-0.036476507782936096,
-0.0007600728422403336,
-0.02002008445560932,
-0.07025277614593506,
0.034064095467329025,
-0.015705212950706482,
0.022903146222233772,
-0.00748714804649353,
-0.030387014150619507,
0.02018287032842636,
-0.04169643297791481,
0.01115929614752531,
0.020164933055639267,
0.06809703260660172,
0.025790465995669365,
-0.031454894691705704,
-0.030292252078652382,
-0.02253533899784088,
-0.00375962583348155,
0.004563081543892622,
-0.042408253997564316,
-0.06283878535032272,
0.024302268400788307,
0.014223122969269753,
-0.028931977227330208,
0.02311253547668457,
0.02350671961903572,
-0.009835975244641304,
-0.02287239208817482,
0.0141835892572999,
0.05124353617429733,
0.0025578702334314585,
0.00283805257640779,
0.01096878107637167,
-0.0198620967566967,
0.010796275921165943,
0.03286033868789673,
-0.03334296494722366,
0.016079075634479523,
0.03937217965722084,
0.01696818508207798,
-0.05684192106127739,
-0.04161776974797249,
-0.05540882796049118,
0.03540004789829254,
-0.03567442670464516,
-0.061598338186740875,
-0.02538057416677475,
-0.004204973578453064,
0.009299376979470253,
-0.005349458660930395,
-0.0006169399712234735,
0.006897197104990482,
-0.0005041539552621543,
-0.024288661777973175,
0.0011111069470643997,
-0.013741353526711464,
-0.012066472321748734,
0.00326427910476923,
0.0344521664083004,
-0.023410793393850327,
0.006372579839080572,
-0.015811005607247353,
-0.0069057634100317955,
-0.010962366126477718,
-0.03395169600844383,
-0.01388201117515564,
-0.010874618776142597,
0.03023509867489338,
-0.005433926358819008,
-0.022303860634565353,
-0.001892934087663889,
0.013205086812376976,
0.04618312418460846,
0.015132126398384571,
0.0455329492688179,
-0.001213187468238175,
-0.0359356664121151,
-0.04580022022128105,
0.046160176396369934,
0.012011305429041386,
0.016449643298983574,
0.037053726613521576,
-0.06387730687856674,
-0.016007650643587112,
-0.010537388734519482,
-0.06135471537709236,
-0.01750735566020012,
0.021330539137125015,
-0.07316163182258606,
-0.029627226293087006,
-0.012745343148708344,
0.03405679389834404,
0.006699100602418184,
0.0032074281480163336,
0.02917954884469509,
0.015048366971313953,
-0.000017849652067525312,
-0.04924054816365242,
0.022759540006518364,
0.030851811170578003,
-0.002152160508558154,
-0.0022169591393321753,
-0.035631075501441956,
-0.0032975017093122005,
-0.01322496123611927,
-0.004127396736294031,
0.023305566981434822,
-0.0029777782037854195,
0.019322941079735756,
-0.012802115641534328,
0.02890157699584961,
0.02913978509604931,
0.00006517960719065741,
0.0007567769498564303,
0.04273606836795807,
0.012723606079816818,
-0.02639462798833847,
-0.030618472024798393,
0.05680591240525246,
-0.026851670816540718,
-0.027372611686587334,
-0.039027139544487,
-0.028666408732533455,
-0.0207232516258955,
-0.0006566194351762533,
-0.058720704168081284,
0.01599317602813244,
-0.016652127727866173,
0.10415390878915787,
-0.029604051262140274,
-0.04077223315834999,
-0.005787018220871687,
-0.02885560877621174,
-0.1311238706111908,
0.023219609633088112,
-0.006107242312282324,
-0.014051396399736404,
-0.011166045442223549,
-0.004264352843165398,
-0.042692627757787704,
-0.04086683690547943,
0.006921976804733276,
0.03482365608215332,
0.04562268778681755,
-0.06435774266719818,
-0.03115818463265896,
0.017428910359740257,
-0.013618855737149715,
0.018789270892739296,
-0.03369436785578728,
0.00931886862963438,
0.05730399489402771,
0.001451271353289485,
-0.03007260151207447,
-0.01789792627096176,
0.07481347769498825,
0.0014269764069467783,
0.05170542374253273,
0.013225751928985119,
0.010761743411421776,
-0.028104938566684723,
-0.027756763622164726,
0.04424826428294182,
0.003159802872687578,
0.005159149877727032,
0.000715148460585624,
0.03374413400888443,
0.030974697321653366,
-0.025553185492753983,
0.029464278370141983,
-0.04273349046707153,
0.04813430830836296,
-0.0034483864437788725,
0.0061461422592401505,
0.012599248439073563,
-0.020383423194289207,
0.0739031434059143,
-0.005124327726662159,
-0.01795729249715805,
-0.011919867247343063,
0.022017978131771088,
0.0007216554949991405,
-0.00019674286886584014,
-0.10092230141162872,
0.006310103926807642,
-0.030059106647968292,
0.02221614308655262,
-0.04574035108089447,
-0.0016656105872243643,
0.005541937425732613,
0.05304891988635063,
0.021184580400586128,
0.0156713780015707,
-0.019098524004220963,
-0.03855855017900467,
0.001263954909518361,
-0.023516032844781876,
-0.007629765197634697,
0.002856113947927952,
0.039553333073854446,
-0.014754586853086948,
0.024543441832065582,
-0.01908779889345169,
0.035176560282707214,
0.006929861381649971,
-0.004811257589608431,
-0.01058226078748703,
-0.016047250479459763,
0.003695529419928789,
-0.021070990711450577,
0.0404522605240345,
-0.012642881833016872,
-0.04689135402441025,
0.013833924196660519,
0.005814836826175451,
-0.016738541424274445,
0.06765155494213104,
-0.02851039357483387,
-0.021473022177815437,
0.010223990306258202,
0.020183702930808067,
0.04205373674631119,
0.17335014045238495,
0.016591109335422516,
0.002731758402660489,
-0.00410228967666626,
0.056790877133607864,
0.00836119893938303,
0.04404817894101143,
0.0010826674988493323,
0.009772760793566704,
-0.0018734801560640335,
0.043290045112371445,
-0.010768568143248558,
0.0203506238758564,
0.0017316441517323256,
-0.003529246663674712,
0.026338888332247734,
0.015002597123384476,
-0.0174673181027174,
0.07965939491987228,
0.005767025984823704,
0.03899582102894783,
0.026253459975123405,
0.05779038369655609,
0.04354367032647133,
-0.020821722224354744,
-0.06780411303043365,
0.01630401611328125,
0.02198438160121441,
-0.026121430099010468,
0.013619067147374153,
-0.010461299680173397,
0.012802677229046822,
0.03458904102444649,
-0.030235925689339638,
-0.0028415306005626917,
-0.013908845372498035,
-0.030013099312782288,
-0.0030886209569871426,
-0.04644743725657463,
0.04156291112303734,
0.01894352398812771,
-0.05652124062180519,
0.024549759924411774,
-0.0833367183804512,
0.0075996736995875835,
-0.035752955824136734,
-0.02626066654920578,
0.03848423436284065,
0.018433893099427223,
0.0021350644528865814,
0.019551869481801987,
0.04454362392425537,
-0.05844706669449806,
0.010210569947957993,
-0.023869985714554787,
-0.0211123526096344,
-0.03419017419219017,
0.01115372497588396,
-0.02781548537313938,
0.00886671431362629,
0.026752781122922897,
0.0007520026993006468,
0.06251254677772522,
0.012402892112731934,
-0.06095621734857559,
-0.012052640318870544,
-0.04152576997876167,
-0.03954428806900978,
0.07286117970943451,
0.009587995707988739,
0.013164718635380268,
-0.011284283362329006,
0.016520969569683075,
0.02095361240208149,
-0.0013711669016629457,
0.07755457609891891,
-0.024247342720627785,
0.015779664739966393,
0.07877922803163528,
-0.0058098724111914635,
0.014703984372317791,
-0.029758840799331665,
-0.04870250076055527,
0.017663806676864624,
0.020977752283215523,
-0.04337234050035477,
-0.02801278419792652,
0.023066814988851547,
0.03022007830440998,
-0.008467362262308598,
0.012312526814639568,
-0.018807504326105118,
0.01946924440562725,
-0.004411593545228243,
-0.05470168590545654,
0.012922381982207298,
0.04623496159911156,
0.023826558142900467,
-0.0029338556341826916,
-0.03940025717020035,
-0.029061617329716682,
-0.006327472161501646,
0.019451424479484558,
-0.040059756487607956,
0.034898288547992706,
0.04488993063569069,
0.04934940114617348,
0.011207405477762222,
-0.05610903725028038,
-0.009970256127417088,
-0.017637263983488083,
-0.010439648292958736,
-0.015243127010762691,
-0.03803054615855217,
0.07564476877450943,
0.05444549024105072,
-0.01481542643159628,
0.013669569976627827,
0.010169225744903088,
0.08557523041963577,
-0.013494358398020267,
0.005884302780032158,
-0.02840900607407093,
0.05239487439393997,
-0.01383419893682003,
-0.04283101111650467,
0.013626646250486374,
0.044155608862638474,
-0.0011146590113639832,
-0.02712252363562584,
0.003545640967786312,
-0.00331341871060431,
0.017594972625374794,
-0.007157527841627598,
0.02944055013358593,
0.030460819602012634,
0.06563963741064072,
0.007134954910725355,
-0.010838598012924194,
-0.013614153489470482,
0.004963258747011423,
0.02095882035791874,
-0.03844910115003586,
-0.04145745560526848,
-0.02760911174118519,
-0.03140122443437576,
0.005836255848407745,
-0.0024659933988004923,
0.005932412575930357,
0.012512548826634884,
-0.02921353280544281,
0.035417258739471436,
-0.04365088418126106,
-0.039214879274368286,
0.0017359486082568765,
-0.02985876239836216,
-0.004613898694515228,
-0.008953060954809189,
0.025850148871541023,
-0.014666912145912647,
0.012853258289396763,
0.007242749445140362,
-0.03414943441748619,
0.08405628800392151,
0.0582260936498642,
0.018063606694340706,
-0.021859977394342422,
0.0029767919331789017,
-0.0008548801415599883,
-0.012982930988073349,
-0.01275780238211155,
-0.02372051030397415,
-0.04179653152823448,
0.03653980791568756,
0.039815813302993774,
0.06352555751800537,
-0.004145426210016012,
-0.02079029195010662,
-0.02194483019411564,
-0.04368695244193077,
0.008187430910766125,
0.01220773346722126,
-0.01563076488673687,
-0.008559475652873516,
-0.015674922615289688,
0.016626719385385513,
0.049535106867551804,
0.004255277570337057,
0.08102348446846008,
-0.024610798805952072,
-0.005122528411448002,
0.09748270362615585,
-0.02138344943523407,
-0.005349567160010338,
-0.00875309482216835,
0.0525265671312809,
-0.05420932173728943,
0.012313480488955975,
0.01114565972238779,
-0.039826929569244385,
-0.0017960106488317251,
-0.00793436635285616,
-0.006159013602882624,
0.00037156190956011415,
-0.0051734913140535355,
-0.005656164605170488,
-0.04130101948976517,
0.010127339512109756,
-0.005776931997388601,
0.0033493514638394117,
0.026802070438861847,
0.022700784727931023,
-0.06414356082677841,
0.012581381015479565,
0.003999421373009682,
-0.024566739797592163,
-0.009207524359226227,
0.008083228021860123,
0.003410822246223688,
-0.08133044838905334,
0.022503450512886047,
0.01197860762476921,
0.004361132625490427,
-0.07130145281553268,
-0.010768644511699677,
0.025888433679938316,
0.020598219707608223,
-0.010318491607904434,
-0.003192347474396229,
-0.03542685881257057,
0.006108876783400774,
0.01013881340622902,
0.05886103957891464,
0.02930452860891819,
0.05261291190981865,
0.010641232132911682,
-0.024090362712740898,
0.011130264960229397,
-0.005756235681474209,
0.004767917562276125,
0.009405535645782948,
0.021042492240667343,
0.04526058956980705,
0.010428926907479763,
0.017677532508969307,
-0.019219227135181427,
0.029382267966866493,
0.03883613273501396,
0.02287866361439228,
-0.0013679721159860492,
-0.02016439288854599,
-0.0064084529876708984,
-0.029179664328694344,
-0.033807411789894104,
-0.004972132388502359,
0.04350695386528969,
0.007970771752297878,
0.03376081585884094,
-0.08126520365476608,
0.005848530679941177,
0.017934534698724747,
0.01900838315486908,
-0.03860744461417198,
-0.0070218732580542564,
-0.01099068857729435,
-0.07135865837335587,
0.04133935645222664,
-0.0037996473256498575,
-0.017410743981599808,
-0.07131967693567276,
0.01933942176401615,
0.0017235919367522001,
-0.0242129135876894,
-0.011380997486412525,
-0.024202002212405205,
0.0015934441471472383,
-0.014488928951323032,
-0.014965340495109558,
-0.027789633721113205,
0.010292619466781616,
0.015947487205266953,
-0.006114535499364138,
-0.007609275169670582,
-0.04166414961218834,
-0.016053153201937675,
0.01877974346280098,
0.013762679882347584,
0.002287790412083268,
-0.020985910668969154,
-0.0315612331032753,
0.009024430066347122,
-0.018125033006072044,
-0.016855202615261078,
0.015884889289736748,
-0.011824001558125019,
0.040284380316734314,
-0.029925497248768806,
-0.016217797994613647,
-0.0042679086327552795,
0.01332046277821064,
-0.010673485696315765,
0.01771136373281479,
-0.04801443591713905,
-0.0022581687662750483,
0.040380898863077164,
0.009261667728424072,
0.007408131379634142,
0.031247757375240326,
0.0198774803429842,
0.07975059747695923,
0.0011543154250830412,
-0.052019182592630386,
-0.002998149720951915,
0.007564093917608261,
-0.007842715829610825,
-0.009954473003745079,
0.017124833539128304,
-0.04271699860692024,
-0.03849659115076065,
-0.018211208283901215,
0.022669177502393723,
-0.013445647433400154,
0.007420825771987438,
-0.03930487111210823,
-0.01176903210580349,
0.0057593584060668945,
-0.006287930533289909,
-0.060432642698287964,
0.004290691576898098,
-0.005996870342642069,
0.006264775525778532,
0.01228896714746952,
0.03287767246365547,
-0.01803450658917427,
0.020301461219787598,
0.029462141916155815,
-0.030210863798856735,
-0.0017994509544223547,
0.019070617854595184,
-0.047182269394397736,
0.03780272230505943,
-0.07422029227018356,
0.08767261356115341,
-0.03794170916080475,
0.007854337804019451,
0.016431180760264397,
-0.011642375960946083,
0.0009434047969989479,
-0.020186705514788628,
0.013499218039214611,
-0.035491202026605606,
0.06857417523860931,
-0.0216626338660717,
-0.06528705358505249,
0.019986767321825027,
0.0418538860976696,
0.01581556349992752,
0.0012564213247969747,
0.02067442797124386,
-0.022117024287581444,
0.012594793923199177,
0.01021293643862009,
0.029770126566290855,
0.027453668415546417,
0.0026235005352646112,
0.008247649297118187,
-0.0294111967086792,
0.020055314525961876,
0.006413325201719999,
-0.052971966564655304,
0.005254528019577265,
0.05117568001151085,
-0.012056570500135422,
0.003436286700889468,
-0.010025384835898876,
0.010684390552341938,
0.001519407145678997,
-0.006265832111239433,
0.0414065457880497,
0.01051928661763668,
-0.007471942808479071,
-0.06151213496923447,
-0.023655300959944725,
-0.013636317104101181,
0.037510570138692856,
-0.025404416024684906,
-0.0016824838239699602,
-0.060694653540849686,
0.0070663453079760075,
0.010168113745748997,
-0.006572370417416096,
0.02277287095785141,
0.005967321339994669,
-0.012586358934640884,
-0.16112014651298523,
0.019924240186810493,
0.0017734855646267533,
0.03827391564846039,
-0.02035975269973278,
-0.023437058553099632,
0.008497316390275955,
-0.0029775521252304316,
0.058514244854450226,
-0.011025439016520977,
-0.02171235717833042,
-0.014187868684530258,
-0.00723329558968544,
-0.011552807874977589,
0.021425865590572357,
0.009909048676490784,
0.030522119253873825,
0.0015208134427666664,
-0.040987368673086166,
0.02854403480887413,
-0.022554541006684303,
0.0010967858834192157,
-0.02186734229326248,
-0.011306208558380604,
0.012722598388791084,
-0.0023600533604621887,
-0.04974180832505226,
-0.05098208785057068,
-0.038431551307439804,
0.0025610814336687326,
0.02163774147629738,
-0.006314265541732311,
0.015531440265476704,
0.026701152324676514,
0.038601331412792206,
0.0006460953154601157,
0.01225630659610033,
0.0018415841041132808,
-0.043585047125816345,
-0.020280279219150543,
0.014750564470887184,
0.00023590028285980225,
0.0007323515601456165,
0.0005070238257758319,
0.0229069571942091,
0.016801998019218445,
-0.013715378940105438,
-0.0058677163906395435,
-0.03952827677130699,
-0.0012997484300285578,
-0.013339047320187092,
-0.01579475589096546,
-0.034918807446956635,
0.020504925400018692,
0.01526044961065054,
0.0100480942055583,
-0.0005175445112399757,
0.03757389262318611,
-0.06238289922475815,
0.025007596239447594,
0.024888886138796806,
0.02844427339732647,
0.020870748907327652,
0.005478627979755402,
-0.018241913989186287,
-0.001463976688683033,
-0.018237125128507614,
-0.02117319405078888,
0.041222818195819855,
-0.016982950270175934,
-0.030925922095775604,
0.012408964335918427,
0.018974734470248222,
0.00035076754284091294,
0.018691549077630043,
0.0015052955131977797,
0.027807502076029778,
0.019168730825185776,
-0.046049367636442184,
0.01426559779793024,
-0.03841141611337662,
0.009762982837855816,
0.0030094454996287823,
0.03507768362760544,
0.013273529708385468,
0.010969727300107479,
-0.0061246249824762344,
0.012844609096646309,
0.02943374589085579,
0.023086553439497948,
-0.0284851286560297,
0.0015175619628280401,
-0.012924442067742348,
0.0794665589928627,
-0.013321583159267902,
-0.013665137812495232,
-0.028987867757678032,
0.01469194795936346,
-0.022438043728470802,
-0.03662659600377083,
-0.09353674948215485,
-0.03906627371907234,
0.012318034656345844,
0.002646727953106165,
-0.05826219171285629,
0.02499973215162754,
0.005048191174864769,
0.02824401669204235,
-0.004195671994239092,
0.02142077125608921,
0.0012059597065672278,
-0.025560665875673294,
0.0008439123048447073,
-0.004244305193424225,
-0.006518122274428606,
-0.04466162249445915,
-0.03850584477186203,
0.01752225123345852,
-0.038335565477609634,
-0.015131933614611626,
-0.04892073571681976,
-0.02234005741775036,
-0.028138531371951103,
-0.046995531767606735,
0.0029758792370557785,
-0.030711626634001732,
0.0015657946933060884,
-0.008731389418244362,
-0.023747896775603294,
-0.04144603759050369,
0.030339857563376427,
-0.018651997670531273,
-0.029789002612233162,
0.004297427833080292,
0.011797208338975906,
0.00008871245518093929,
-0.044253986328840256,
0.02863316610455513,
0.00497466279193759,
-0.030359769240021706,
0.014142128638923168,
0.004787038546055555,
-0.006767949555069208,
0.0029869768768548965,
-0.01936998777091503,
0.010633150115609169,
0.03393615037202835,
0.003565109334886074,
-0.038028180599212646,
-0.013394291512668133,
0.02054235152900219,
0.016290144994854927,
0.012216324917972088,
-0.013680960051715374,
0.0391325019299984,
0.01982080191373825,
-0.00237301760353148,
-0.008262637071311474,
-0.001270208740606904,
0.06363614648580551,
-0.0018683153903111815,
-0.02105681784451008,
-0.057135727256536484,
-0.07612650841474533,
-0.006494760978966951,
-0.013517739251255989,
0.027339963242411613,
0.004292235244065523,
-0.00009217192564392462,
-0.0015272637829184532,
-0.013438763096928596,
0.015113524161279202,
-0.011749766767024994,
0.02422693371772766,
0.009984332136809826,
0.03263731673359871,
0.009990743361413479,
0.013535754755139351,
0.027455400675535202,
0.005710446275770664,
0.0335141085088253,
0.08490638434886932,
-0.007300002034753561,
-0.039768464863300323,
0.031007865443825722,
-0.014676506631076336,
0.05684677138924599,
0.02996232733130455,
-0.012999598868191242,
-0.006700803525745869,
0.018078524619340897,
-0.0004524070827756077,
0.058967649936676025,
0.006072787567973137,
-0.01133857574313879,
0.03077116422355175,
-0.034948114305734634,
0.03411382809281349,
-0.022523168474435806,
0.010897149331867695,
0.008125164546072483,
-0.013666334562003613,
-0.03724049776792526,
0.02185925841331482,
-0.008643276058137417,
-0.0005963140283711255,
-0.0037419076543301344,
-0.004356905817985535,
-0.008154102601110935,
0.051921162754297256,
-0.018276141956448555,
0.016479240730404854,
-0.04833555594086647,
0.052337631583213806,
0.02016730047762394,
0.010743511840701103,
0.06503812968730927,
-0.0208413228392601,
0.06199001520872116,
-0.03444971516728401,
-0.003545282641425729,
0.03463948518037796,
-0.01342798676341772,
-0.04275745525956154,
-0.006114831194281578,
-0.0026334805879741907,
-0.0011181194568052888,
-0.006599869579076767,
-0.022314496338367462,
-0.02757268212735653,
0.00830174796283245,
-0.0012241529766470194,
-0.009676912799477577,
0.027314897626638412,
0.021188730373978615,
0.02474238909780979,
-0.01590046100318432,
-0.017079347744584084,
-0.021900922060012817,
-0.028259070590138435,
0.05289793387055397,
0.014712926000356674,
-0.017043456435203552,
-0.0005401313537731767
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:68
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
972I am not able to reach any firm conclusion as to whether, on the merits of the case, LEC would have succeeded in the 2001 Proceedings. No submissions were addressed to me on that question. What I can say is that, in my opinion, they were not bound to fail.
Amount recoverable in the 2001 Proceedings
973As I have mentioned, the plaintiffs sought to prove what damages LEC would have recovered in the 2001 Proceedings by tendering reports of Dr Ferrier.
974For the reasons set forth in my Judgment in these proceedings on 5 March 2012 ([2012] NSWSC 177) I rejected the tender of Dr Ferrier's reports.
975In light of that development, the plaintiffs sought to establish what financial recompense LEC would have recovered in the 2001 Proceedings by a calculation of "HTT's financial gains of owning and exploiting the Land" for the financial years 30 June 2000 to 30 June 2011.
The analysis compared "cost to date" with "net asset value" for each financial year and described the difference between those figures as being the "financial gain to date".
976However, as Mr Einfeld pointed out, the calculation depended upon a dramatic increase in the "net asset value" of HTT from $2.861 million for the year ended 30 June 2003 to $22.95 million for the year ended 30 June 2004.
977That increase was based on nothing more than a "Directors Valuation" of the Land at $21 million as at 30 June 2004 (compared to a valuation of $3.3 million for the financial year ended 30 June 2003, described as "Freehold land - at cost").
978There is no evidence before me to justify that "Directors Valuation". The figure probably came from a valuation performed by Mr John Dignan on 18 August 2003. However that valuation has only been admitted as evidence of the fact that Mr Dignan expressed the opinion set forth in it and not evidence of value.
The HTT Defendants served an affidavit by Mr Dignan seeking to prove the valuation, but did not read it. The plaintiffs foreshadowed themselves reading Mr Dignan's affidavit but, in the face of objection, did not do so.
979Therefore, a fundamental plank of the plaintiffs' calculation is absent.
980It follows that the basis of the plaintiffs' calculations as to HTT's "financial gains" from the Project has not been made out.
981There is no other evidence before me as to what account of profits or other financial remedy LEC would have recovered in the 2001 Proceedings and thus no material upon which I could base any assessment as to the value of the chance lost to LEC as a result of the dismissal of those proceedings on 6 September 2004.
Agency - Mr Hickie/Vocifa
982I have mentioned earlier that the plaintiffs claim that HTT and Mr Renshall made the pleaded representations as agent for Mr Hickie and Vocifa.
983In view of my conclusions as to the substance of the plaintiffs' claim, it is not necessary for me to express any opinion about this matter.
984However, and again in deference to the submissions made on this issue, I shall deal with it, although again, briefly.
985In the written submissions the plaintiffs stated:-
"The plaintiffs do not contend that Mr Renshall and HTT were the agents of Mr Hickie and Vocifa generally or for all purposes. They accept that the agency had its limits.
However, even if the authority of Mr Renshall and HTT was limited to acting as a conduit - communicating information for and on behalf of Mr Hickie and Vocifa - as submitted by them, that would be enough to fix them with the legal responsibility for the representations of HTT and Mr Renshall."
986The plaintiffs particularised the claim of agency against Mr Hickie and Vocifa as follows:-
(a) "At all material times, Renshall was a director and shareholder of Devubo and represented it in the negotiations with LEC and Zdrilic;
(b) HTT and Renshall conducted the negotiations with LEC and Zdrilic on behalf of Hickie and Vocifa;
(c) In the course of the negotiations, Renshall represented that he represented Hickie and his interests in the negotiations;
(d) Further:
|
[
-0.029882485046982765,
0.0350465252995491,
-0.018701355904340744,
0.007262688595801592,
0.0005487498710863292,
-0.025111312046647072,
-0.03756183758378029,
-0.017596222460269928,
0.0018269746797159314,
0.006625893991440535,
0.00137861049734056,
0.04306679591536522,
-0.04571021720767021,
0.013165073469281197,
-0.02661101706326008,
-0.024489829316735268,
0.036698635667562485,
-0.055691197514534,
-0.014052617363631725,
-0.008850588463246822,
0.003475829726085067,
-0.004391913767904043,
0.015972696244716644,
0.033365052193403244,
-0.00720696896314621,
-0.021649572998285294,
-0.004343265201896429,
0.015566814690828323,
0.05598742887377739,
0.02834485098719597,
0.005813928786665201,
0.0006846557953394949,
0.04844343289732933,
-0.03916137292981148,
-0.04150935262441635,
-0.013223935849964619,
0.04037200286984444,
0.024838583543896675,
-0.03845982253551483,
0.013075836934149265,
0.0020062834955751896,
0.0058296420611441135,
-0.003923369571566582,
-0.010238807648420334,
0.0633326843380928,
-0.04707787558436394,
-0.02556748129427433,
-0.015228420495986938,
-0.027779219672083855,
0.024189384654164314,
-0.046359799802303314,
-0.03142315521836281,
0.06528421491384506,
-0.0183189045637846,
-0.02404945343732834,
0.01748235523700714,
-0.0027318119537085295,
-0.03263112157583237,
-0.05444696918129921,
0.009344602935016155,
0.014929705299437046,
-0.024067722260951996,
-0.05565765127539635,
-0.005840294063091278,
0.0022542255464941263,
0.09984604269266129,
0.02052958495914936,
-0.01573854312300682,
0.007183271460235119,
-0.02777879871428013,
-0.02941296063363552,
-0.031294677406549454,
-0.024349987506866455,
0.009251725859940052,
-0.10102177411317825,
0.015705915167927742,
0.03768301010131836,
0.007688009180128574,
0.06345535069704056,
0.010742610320448875,
0.0362483486533165,
-0.01720372587442398,
0.015699472278356552,
0.023374740034341812,
-0.03431204706430435,
0.060199715197086334,
-0.027324015274643898,
0.0191697645932436,
0.0030189664103090763,
-0.03371153771877289,
-0.050488971173763275,
0.0032347487285733223,
-0.03909682855010033,
-0.03876706585288048,
0.0005616065463982522,
-0.0011463896371424198,
-0.0928492322564125,
0.044929247349500656,
-0.035127192735672,
0.03457382321357727,
0.013591688126325607,
0.009683896787464619,
0.02378537319600582,
-0.01819787174463272,
0.025688515976071358,
0.019516626372933388,
0.0008405842818319798,
0.017185423523187637,
0.000996485585346818,
0.003031979314982891,
-0.013679997995495796,
-0.003937236499041319,
-0.03829504922032356,
0.013787754811346531,
-0.008184581995010376,
-0.0044595347717404366,
0.005268850363790989,
0.004225154407322407,
0.04448186978697777,
-0.008237880654633045,
0.06721945106983185,
0.026933694258332253,
0.018287641927599907,
-0.023313462734222412,
-0.0483941026031971,
0.025874825194478035,
0.03498971462249756,
0.036711469292640686,
0.0038708464708179235,
0.02278789132833481,
0.0003565942752175033,
0.040131837129592896,
-0.033728018403053284,
-0.046803537756204605,
-0.02207203023135662,
-0.010153461247682571,
0.01218402199447155,
-0.005713125225156546,
0.033077389001846313,
-0.026814719662070274,
0.04031461849808693,
0.06272349506616592,
-0.0028416099958121777,
-0.03564933314919472,
0.04601948708295822,
0.010411222465336323,
0.0025239477399736643,
0.01739807240664959,
0.022222381085157394,
0.0202476866543293,
0.02620805613696575,
0.021689550951123238,
0.019744455814361572,
-0.013633024878799915,
0.04080119729042053,
-0.023091144859790802,
-0.008578530512750149,
-0.02241176925599575,
-0.009843644686043262,
0.06845971196889877,
-0.06830593198537827,
0.015789564698934555,
-0.04205792769789696,
-0.010592862963676453,
-0.012824987061321735,
0.013441085815429688,
-0.008482573553919792,
0.051957059651613235,
-0.03145340830087662,
0.02577986568212509,
0.038942329585552216,
-0.03309888020157814,
0.02530209720134735,
-0.011000634171068668,
0.020670952275395393,
0.028732335194945335,
0.055101457983255386,
0.02596648968756199,
0.010630184784531593,
-0.03976830095052719,
-0.052590422332286835,
0.0060314699076116085,
-0.0018441959982737899,
0.005423930939286947,
-0.05115746706724167,
0.029965709894895554,
0.005690971855074167,
-0.00019095794414170086,
-0.006164421793073416,
0.02391485683619976,
0.0032593708019703627,
-0.00026449013967067003,
-0.0005904458812437952,
-0.008753009140491486,
0.031095992773771286,
-0.02729588933289051,
0.042745787650346756,
-0.03835923224687576,
0.003954262472689152,
-0.01644318923354149,
-0.041800398379564285,
0.03857404738664627,
0.04786636680364609,
-0.031158270314335823,
-0.019919246435165405,
0.04029478132724762,
-0.02010367438197136,
0.001100855995900929,
-0.007811193820089102,
-0.07169084250926971,
-0.002450576052069664,
0.00023696667631156743,
0.03675629943609238,
0.027393639087677002,
0.030922135338187218,
-0.010614253580570221,
0.010172860696911812,
0.00818990170955658,
0.01220730785280466,
-0.02700534276664257,
-0.022470345720648766,
-0.01652950420975685,
0.028717877343297005,
-0.001018705079331994,
0.05971081554889679,
0.05050225183367729,
-0.03203156590461731,
-0.019406301900744438,
-0.0022450850810855627,
-0.03199099004268646,
0.03182732313871384,
-0.037528276443481445,
0.008569377474486828,
-0.013810667209327221,
0.025857025757431984,
0.041300203651189804,
0.027119230479002,
0.03507307171821594,
0.006613352335989475,
0.03208134323358536,
-0.04580105468630791,
0.05178515240550041,
-0.02223646081984043,
-0.0339362695813179,
-0.04762657359242439,
-0.009087598882615566,
0.002932197181507945,
0.03650353476405144,
0.05254874378442764,
-0.018167460337281227,
0.01556005422025919,
-0.015303432941436768,
-0.017732756212353706,
-0.044121500104665756,
0.03284033015370369,
0.023340554907917976,
-0.0021695236209779978,
-0.015017678029835224,
0.01636114902794361,
0.017382025718688965,
0.008051878772675991,
0.006376800127327442,
0.03350276127457619,
0.008583697490394115,
-0.047883838415145874,
-0.004438625182956457,
-0.0119320722296834,
-0.052098389714956284,
0.036555491387844086,
0.01889892667531967,
0.02767983265221119,
0.040407873690128326,
0.011953257955610752,
0.04133303090929985,
0.05577070266008377,
0.05218883603811264,
0.019155140966176987,
0.017884593456983566,
0.0064900945872068405,
-0.019452275708317757,
0.0020494619384407997,
0.02683933638036251,
0.04191618785262108,
-0.026086242869496346,
-0.0060059428215026855,
0.04700147360563278,
-0.0035747038200497627,
-0.016342561691999435,
0.033297907561063766,
-0.025031622499227524,
-0.006876836996525526,
-0.014844553545117378,
0.07966482639312744,
-0.011698736809194088,
-0.08920376002788544,
0.0000760986004024744,
-0.0022409181110560894,
-0.15073274075984955,
-0.010043691843748093,
-0.029578983783721924,
0.006188052240759134,
-0.022849854081869125,
0.009814365766942501,
-0.05269881710410118,
0.021326376125216484,
-0.04418933391571045,
-0.02417774684727192,
0.0019443640485405922,
-0.0644712820649147,
-0.03033166378736496,
0.030926592648029327,
-0.01565461792051792,
-0.011746148578822613,
0.007279791869223118,
-0.022753870114684105,
0.04515152424573898,
-0.021555177867412567,
-0.008924858644604683,
-0.06041868031024933,
0.04384780675172806,
-0.005730354227125645,
0.019509749487042427,
-0.021866852417588234,
-0.0022031578700989485,
0.0030664338264614344,
-0.04223449155688286,
-0.04592462256550789,
-0.017970671877264977,
0.034245170652866364,
-0.02070642076432705,
0.019717087969183922,
-0.003593915142118931,
0.021668920293450356,
0.07441531866788864,
-0.06689546257257462,
-0.034694358706474304,
0.007641658652573824,
0.018826637417078018,
0.053076524287462234,
-0.006647177040576935,
0.039831459522247314,
0.03004712425172329,
-0.029508313164114952,
0.002584384987130761,
0.019648917019367218,
-0.021669022738933563,
0.006988139357417822,
0.003992907702922821,
0.015817785635590553,
-0.023890333250164986,
-0.029814328998327255,
0.013398101553320885,
-0.006559681612998247,
0.035220421850681305,
-0.022430475801229477,
-0.017747610807418823,
-0.00648080138489604,
-0.022608228027820587,
-0.06964654475450516,
0.04296666756272316,
0.031628288328647614,
-0.03324860334396362,
-0.016934115439653397,
-0.009856024757027626,
-0.012880682945251465,
0.027218803763389587,
0.014446541666984558,
0.03643444925546646,
-0.021643653512001038,
-0.011272708885371685,
0.006556572858244181,
0.04319186881184578,
0.031270068138837814,
-0.04598056152462959,
-0.028575176373124123,
-0.022026989609003067,
-0.08475856482982635,
0.0059102787636220455,
0.028072457760572433,
-0.02085973136126995,
0.04397030919790268,
0.009194938465952873,
0.025110488757491112,
0.014697971753776073,
0.03542357310652733,
0.012144813314080238,
0.21153128147125244,
0.0037674347404390574,
-0.01655873842537403,
0.02815570868551731,
-0.011885377578437328,
0.027751460671424866,
0.01322204526513815,
0.06869323551654816,
-0.01352357305586338,
-0.0627969279885292,
-0.06891265511512756,
3.7268759456310363e-7,
0.009734653867781162,
0.031485073268413544,
-0.06336449086666107,
-0.011498264037072659,
-0.05330381542444229,
-0.047424521297216415,
0.05674605816602707,
0.006569246761500835,
0.02924981713294983,
-0.027470126748085022,
-0.02863619290292263,
0.016422102227807045,
-0.060900747776031494,
-0.04043535515666008,
0.00864038523286581,
0.042968351393938065,
-0.02937236800789833,
0.0158795528113842,
0.012604506686329842,
-0.006402395199984312,
-0.004366531036794186,
-0.049290433526039124,
-0.011960010975599289,
0.015107979066669941,
-0.020452091470360756,
0.0325145348906517,
0.033209074288606644,
0.011001779697835445,
0.00562397250905633,
-0.03662225604057312,
-0.06285308301448822,
-0.020304620265960693,
-0.056447625160217285,
0.05302323400974274,
-0.021198857575654984,
0.016729755327105522,
0.043345868587493896,
0.04375002905726433,
-0.024999720975756645,
0.05400834232568741,
-0.010632830671966076,
-0.04273596033453941,
-0.003959455527365208,
0.028288014233112335,
0.005159442313015461,
0.04849850386381149,
-0.033308468759059906,
0.04877910017967224,
0.023431045934557915,
0.01559616532176733,
-0.03963123634457588,
0.012662751600146294,
0.0022106377873569727,
-0.006328553427010775,
-0.03471801429986954,
-0.019738154485821724,
0.06823661923408508,
0.03666606545448303,
0.04340402036905289,
0.064408078789711,
0.003309995634481311,
0.004503513686358929,
0.036392129957675934,
0.00012412854994181544,
-0.0358627513051033,
0.0297655388712883,
-0.006139857694506645,
0.011180703528225422,
-0.038789086043834686,
-0.024547167122364044,
-0.005549692548811436,
0.023366838693618774,
0.027494369074702263,
-0.025685332715511322,
-0.04449045658111572,
0.015020492486655712,
-0.031440362334251404,
-0.009745278395712376,
-0.013953547924757004,
-0.03896747902035713,
0.0020725822541862726,
0.009402765892446041,
-0.036166343837976456,
-0.010126573964953423,
-0.003682010108605027,
-0.012094770558178425,
-0.021112879738211632,
-0.03889647126197815,
0.018053783103823662,
-0.010814381763339043,
0.030797353014349937,
-0.03585556894540787,
0.02474271133542061,
0.018936026841402054,
-0.019499678164720535,
-0.02034003660082817,
-0.023944929242134094,
0.024168770760297775,
-0.009366398677229881,
0.01685628853738308,
0.02378181368112564,
-0.022899078205227852,
0.020640935748815536,
0.04818691313266754,
0.014009742066264153,
0.034786440432071686,
0.024438105523586273,
0.023267988115549088,
0.0661483108997345,
-0.006201073061674833,
-0.07231207191944122,
-0.0065241847187280655,
0.026269108057022095,
0.02857169136404991,
0.0015578130260109901,
-0.040659788995981216,
0.024050749838352203,
0.00033790248562581837,
0.017523929476737976,
-0.0076247649267315865,
-0.04808056354522705,
0.002850000513717532,
0.022079767659306526,
0.02844318188726902,
0.014631249941885471,
0.0039444961585104465,
-0.05907007306814194,
-0.004658032208681107,
-0.019368726760149002,
0.014576545916497707,
-0.03472081199288368,
-0.013704131357371807,
0.014127233065664768,
-0.009397579357028008,
-0.050729863345623016,
0.029053525999188423,
-0.02324194274842739,
0.01991126872599125,
0.008951254189014435,
-0.006466785445809364,
-0.036388810724020004,
-0.008391065523028374,
0.00005769117342424579,
0.0022504753433167934,
-0.000989555031992495,
-0.028568502515554428,
0.0273065697401762,
-0.021791106089949608,
-0.008063428103923798,
0.010648634284734726,
0.043670736253261566,
0.021130753681063652,
-0.008185763843357563,
0.05954957753419876,
-0.004173120018094778,
0.021913014352321625,
0.043148402124643326,
-0.01732231304049492,
0.03209304064512253,
-0.017147444188594818,
-0.011200026609003544,
0.06027134507894516,
0.04509872570633888,
0.02862485870718956,
-0.01744084246456623,
0.03661128506064415,
0.0046862345188856125,
-0.07240298390388489,
0.03278369829058647,
-0.013514243066310883,
-0.029762249439954758,
-0.003930842038244009,
0.0062543549574911594,
0.0031349188648164272,
-0.018952591344714165,
-0.007975864224135876,
0.08226291090250015,
-0.07016230374574661,
-0.013151072897017002,
0.0683748722076416,
0.03480983152985573,
-0.05705130100250244,
-0.023475227877497673,
0.0037348568439483643,
-0.05238422378897667,
0.015261976048350334,
0.0047242045402526855,
-0.05101778730750084,
-0.03451322764158249,
0.038463179022073746,
0.013511326164007187,
-0.020808802917599678,
0.03421495854854584,
0.01792597398161888,
-0.026317821815609932,
0.032636649906635284,
-0.047196462750434875,
-0.05739275738596916,
0.008329884149134159,
0.01846429705619812,
-0.025599481537938118,
0.05472284555435181,
-0.04211917519569397,
-0.031638722866773605,
-0.014782250858843327,
0.029849134385585785,
0.0022817235440015793,
-0.0495191365480423,
-0.029436474665999413,
-0.03316551074385643,
0.010164701379835606,
-0.08311357349157333,
-0.013938943855464458,
0.013629983179271221,
-0.028824638575315475,
-0.007156824227422476,
-0.02138814516365528,
0.006906901020556688,
0.012209751643240452,
-0.05271287262439728,
0.04484240338206291,
-0.045500148087739944,
0.0065237246453762054,
-0.0054975952953100204,
0.0001769449154380709,
0.012317691929638386,
0.0090299928560853,
-0.018619613721966743,
0.02905937097966671,
0.0022436182480305433,
0.01793825440108776,
0.02729237824678421,
0.010547527112066746,
-0.013261288404464722,
0.014194422401487827,
-0.015296036377549171,
-0.012708790600299835,
0.061247918754816055,
-0.0007128095021471381,
0.016646375879645348,
0.000860769534483552,
0.03587627410888672,
-0.005071212537586689,
-0.013048239052295685,
0.025106176733970642,
-0.024710578843951225,
-0.05653967335820198,
-0.03602612391114235,
-0.012622741051018238,
0.014605295844376087,
0.027327824383974075,
-0.01175196748226881,
-0.033245474100112915,
-0.023576948791742325,
0.03703055903315544,
-0.015373168513178825,
-0.0056948475539684296,
-0.02137998305261135,
0.005839466582983732,
0.013640490360558033,
-0.03023592382669449,
-0.038837529718875885,
-0.009369950741529465,
0.01635962724685669,
-0.011267022229731083,
-0.003425485221669078,
-0.013316216878592968,
-0.0025638139341026545,
0.03641287982463837,
-0.054802510887384415,
0.009754507802426815,
0.025780344381928444,
-0.04275289550423622,
-0.011785320937633514,
-0.01005743071436882,
0.04994484409689903,
0.004839353263378143,
0.012057362124323845,
-0.009454398415982723,
-0.0006825566524639726,
-0.012520063668489456,
0.030952418223023415,
-0.015495768748223782,
0.0014420829247683287,
0.012819024734199047,
0.0071368091739714146,
-0.005972690414637327,
-0.01050951424986124,
-0.0356920063495636,
-0.0032289137598127127,
-0.0366036631166935,
-0.033723339438438416,
-0.03403504565358162,
0.017364876344799995,
0.021852469071745872,
0.01486550085246563,
-0.06417069584131241,
0.005817288998514414,
0.008453553542494774,
-0.05294494330883026,
0.0034523415379226208,
-0.06211197376251221,
0.03299300745129585,
0.009905906394124031,
0.010048002004623413,
-0.01620342582464218,
-0.026609333232045174,
-0.015605861321091652,
-0.0589887872338295,
0.002650451147928834,
-0.027188649401068687,
-0.016723716631531715,
-0.0609549842774868,
0.032685473561286926,
-0.011378648690879345,
-0.028708482161164284,
-0.032454777508974075,
0.0168513972312212,
-0.029490254819393158,
-0.018375780433416367,
-0.017346927896142006,
0.0036030872724950314,
0.05846679210662842,
0.043204277753829956,
-0.012510963715612888,
-0.012344126589596272,
0.015987318009138107,
-0.013458594679832458,
0.021758483722805977,
-0.056202828884124756,
0.05326012521982193,
-0.007805572357028723,
0.0019347209017723799,
0.04483257979154587,
-0.0014828407438471913,
-0.04052140563726425,
0.060695990920066833,
0.019889522343873978,
0.02791874296963215,
0.02376917377114296,
0.0020919356029480696,
-0.007118506822735071,
0.027702372521162033,
-0.0010654197540134192,
-0.004933532793074846,
0.044702645391225815,
0.029117180034518242,
-0.008380843326449394,
-0.008569087833166122,
0.03967347741127014,
0.01464705541729927,
-0.004633948672562838,
0.02826358564198017,
-0.027228057384490967,
-0.010456735268235207,
0.009858870878815651,
-0.008407840505242348,
0.006709136068820953,
0.015228784643113613,
0.020894037559628487,
-0.04361950233578682,
0.004278166685253382,
-0.029820073395967484,
0.08309592306613922,
0.01937031000852585,
0.0007095756591297686,
-0.010631196200847626,
-0.019441334530711174,
-0.004798335954546928,
-0.00952145829796791,
-0.03902584686875343,
-0.008413786999881268,
0.0016854285495355725,
0.013104589655995369,
0.03186320140957832,
0.015934079885482788,
0.016570914536714554,
0.014932041987776756,
-0.0008306289091706276,
-0.008201164193451405,
-0.04197963699698448,
0.002007836475968361,
-0.11877833306789398,
0.0032243956811726093,
-0.022032398730516434,
0.023585043847560883,
-0.002645784290507436,
0.009091049432754517,
-0.006473170593380928,
0.04506330564618111,
-0.045170266181230545,
0.006399232428520918,
0.008432661183178425,
-0.013364209793508053,
-0.01756502315402031,
-0.036123618483543396,
-0.048911020159721375,
0.011596566066145897,
-0.04316563159227371,
-0.049398332834243774,
-0.053059786558151245,
0.004127762280404568,
0.02813790552318096,
0.004874212667346001,
0.00020925748685840517,
-0.004755301401019096,
0.01009796466678381,
0.02080836519598961,
-0.02411835454404354,
-0.050728943198919296,
-0.036940187215805054,
-0.06459306925535202,
-0.010405072011053562,
-0.023893242701888084,
-0.02284894697368145,
0.020864831283688545,
-0.011597033590078354,
0.011385265737771988,
0.008074309676885605,
0.00449051009491086,
-0.021415606141090393,
-0.007270944304764271,
-0.0031831692904233932,
0.043075986206531525,
-0.02723877876996994,
-0.03575058653950691,
-0.01872159354388714,
0.02070307731628418,
-0.04919171705842018,
-0.009129376150667667,
-0.0619586743414402,
-0.030248187482357025,
-0.04547343775629997,
0.04393531754612923,
0.03229142352938652,
0.018059905618429184,
0.01608450524508953,
-0.016199400648474693,
0.01709594763815403,
-0.023025546222925186,
0.01932692527770996,
0.025619180873036385,
-0.0031007241923362017,
0.0034630566369742155,
-0.04151986911892891,
0.025099214166402817,
0.002536598825827241,
0.010065136477351189,
0.014593426138162613,
0.01670430414378643,
-0.05456637591123581,
0.011586523614823818,
-0.003507819026708603,
0.018405815586447716,
0.008286661468446255,
-0.06591982394456863,
0.043485578149557114,
-0.016031188890337944,
-0.006976129952818155,
-0.01756175421178341,
-0.046322327107191086,
-0.02653471566736698,
-0.03183773532509804,
-0.009105228818953037,
-0.029722116887569427,
-0.01969321258366108,
0.08921363204717636,
0.033151671290397644,
-0.0022977914195507765,
0.010338423773646355,
-0.0017453799955546856,
0.01890331134200096,
-0.03558363765478134,
0.020103760063648224,
-0.017278749495744705,
-0.014804847538471222,
-0.01902012899518013,
0.006010310258716345,
-0.012134871445596218,
-0.008640386164188385,
-0.003392806276679039,
-0.045209527015686035,
-0.03415520489215851,
-0.01633484475314617,
0.033370036631822586,
-0.019631417468190193,
0.006399675738066435,
0.05371861159801483,
0.011353419162333012,
0.003149242838844657,
0.009480363689363003,
0.014462287537753582,
0.017305713146924973,
-0.03408848121762276,
-0.0315132774412632,
0.047655168920755386,
-0.02668040804564953,
0.009202634915709496,
0.004517007153481245,
0.014716601930558681,
0.0059026735834777355,
-0.000886214489582926,
0.01809709519147873,
0.0060720485635101795,
-0.033603738993406296,
-0.012637371197342873,
0.014378482475876808,
0.003466729074716568,
0.05243339762091637,
-0.002460677409544587,
0.019631342962384224,
0.0034399565774947405,
0.04317057877779007,
0.009810802526772022,
0.00330369733273983,
0.008951463736593723,
0.04709504917263985,
-0.0019451557891443372,
0.0019465660443529487,
0.01386441383510828,
-0.02979588881134987,
-0.012171100825071335,
-0.020679842680692673,
0.014128892682492733,
-0.01942836306989193,
0.03235593065619469,
-0.026391688734292984,
0.022081488743424416,
0.06646046787500381,
0.012892564758658409,
-0.0020791778806596994,
-0.04849822819232941,
-0.015560053288936615,
0.003261041361838579,
-0.016033299267292023,
0.06110714003443718,
0.013533423654735088,
-0.027304593473672867,
0.031051330268383026,
-0.055162400007247925,
0.01755610667169094,
0.025808122009038925,
0.01708926074206829,
0.0032668851781636477,
-0.04624803736805916,
-0.03284779563546181,
-0.041713323444128036,
0.0026449046563357115,
0.004275365266948938,
0.0038061647210270166,
-0.0064013246446847916,
-0.03283301368355751,
-0.009222730994224548,
0.026080669835209846,
-0.019998565316200256,
0.021451417356729507,
0.06488937884569168,
0.004068717826157808,
-0.008256378583610058,
-0.003993276506662369,
0.06906238943338394,
-0.046614859253168106,
0.037323568016290665,
0.02542717754840851,
0.034808069467544556,
0.005045638419687748,
0.0060156891122460365,
0.021487576887011528,
-0.006628057453781366,
0.03770022839307785,
0.008893928490579128,
-0.041780296713113785,
-0.04138105735182762,
-0.0027177920565009117,
-0.010681121610105038,
-0.028087159618735313,
-0.0033294525928795338,
0.014842461794614792,
-0.0023163137957453728,
0.032728929072618484,
-0.011104016564786434,
-0.005617830902338028,
-0.014292011968791485,
0.009023971855640411,
-0.06637471914291382,
-0.024257095530629158,
-0.016531936824321747,
0.01938788965344429,
0.0195060595870018,
-0.05086631327867508,
-0.04296863451600075,
0.03681733459234238,
-0.03312674164772034,
-0.02599259279668331,
-0.0077264872379601,
0.02189982496201992,
-0.019005754962563515,
-0.0004080589860677719,
0.022783741354942322,
-0.030136173591017723,
0.026175396516919136,
-0.03158888220787048,
0.010699399746954441,
0.04843171685934067,
-0.01686408743262291,
-0.02071409299969673,
0.009475438855588436,
0.0340389609336853,
-0.01790381409227848,
0.022982755675911903,
-0.010816601105034351,
-0.0003093828272540122,
-0.019532520323991776,
-0.029208045452833176,
-0.01150281447917223,
0.049691710621118546,
0.001385542913340032,
-0.03810938820242882,
-0.004402404651045799,
-0.01218534354120493,
-0.006100919097661972,
-0.003497572150081396,
0.02882620319724083,
-0.013902165926992893,
-0.0035094802733510733,
0.016678089275956154
] |
What was the basis of the plaintiffs' calculation of HTT's "financial gains" from the Project, and was it made out?
|
[
-0.004077223129570484,
0.007463570684194565,
0.007308796513825655,
0.023885508999228477,
0.01718885451555252,
-0.031080616638064384,
-0.024985721334815025,
-0.018669992685317993,
0.009109556674957275,
0.008647452108561993,
-0.008577046915888786,
0.028835080564022064,
-0.0304401908069849,
-0.01722692884504795,
-0.028873780742287636,
0.0003525888023432344,
0.0492682121694088,
-0.02001209929585457,
0.004637642297893763,
-0.020595716312527657,
-0.02134990505874157,
-0.027334829792380333,
-0.03227241337299347,
0.006201585289090872,
-0.006574617233127356,
0.013922711834311485,
-0.02209567092359066,
0.0011895883362740278,
0.03029572404921055,
0.012368095107376575,
0.0427895113825798,
0.006367858499288559,
0.001328896963968873,
-0.059749990701675415,
-0.04554399475455284,
-0.06133738160133362,
0.007398268673568964,
0.026736464351415634,
-0.05469714477658272,
-0.026437774300575256,
-0.018533335998654366,
0.00750915240496397,
0.00488327769562602,
-0.035453226417303085,
0.06922955811023712,
-0.035185087472200394,
-0.020723987370729446,
-0.026206472888588905,
-0.03903057426214218,
0.05080041661858559,
0.01107091549783945,
-0.023981507867574692,
0.03311248868703842,
-0.022115975618362427,
0.012462044134736061,
-0.011015660129487514,
-0.034762363880872726,
-0.03798827528953552,
-0.01989145018160343,
-0.009618713520467281,
0.0017444180557504296,
-0.02084311656653881,
-0.0654461681842804,
-0.03331323340535164,
-0.008039305917918682,
0.09165491908788681,
0.07987376302480698,
0.019746018573641777,
0.017367269843816757,
0.0030940002761781216,
-0.05084683373570442,
-0.03968799114227295,
0.0014514029026031494,
0.00026673078536987305,
-0.0579049251973629,
-0.007133141625672579,
0.01752794161438942,
-0.01104731671512127,
0.05001196265220642,
0.03550403565168381,
-0.00042063870932906866,
-0.04979301989078522,
0.030895426869392395,
0.03235097602009773,
-0.012176791206002235,
0.022416608408093452,
0.023288799449801445,
0.013747465796768665,
0.03307224065065384,
-0.07665113359689713,
-0.012430527247488499,
-0.014092570170760155,
-0.012202173471450806,
-0.017029160633683205,
-0.017767611891031265,
-0.014055018313229084,
-0.07788553833961487,
0.027948612347245216,
-0.00463869608938694,
0.04442460089921951,
0.04588593170046806,
0.014491698704659939,
0.012929652817547321,
-0.033878128975629807,
0.02132030948996544,
-0.03176245838403702,
0.04713919013738632,
0.021107671782374382,
0.032181330025196075,
0.012097963131964207,
-0.00593738816678524,
0.012083536945283413,
-0.003001643344759941,
0.019704485312104225,
-0.03799205645918846,
0.0015132047701627016,
0.022196989506483078,
0.017542943358421326,
0.044175244867801666,
-0.02903495728969574,
0.02896011807024479,
-0.05139276757836342,
0.040977928787469864,
-0.054768528789281845,
-0.010066226124763489,
-0.049930788576602936,
-0.006559193134307861,
-0.00031219847733154893,
0.0033888109028339386,
0.041454214602708817,
0.009003430604934692,
0.025475503876805305,
-0.005115789361298084,
-0.00481742387637496,
-0.027778638526797295,
-0.02494426816701889,
0.0033568120561540127,
0.005352070555090904,
0.0038712024688720703,
-0.027545088902115822,
0.07622924447059631,
0.02003013901412487,
-0.03462574630975723,
-0.03322117030620575,
0.07291996479034424,
-0.041529249399900436,
0.032718781381845474,
-0.000836083316244185,
0.029233142733573914,
0.03549426794052124,
0.013059158809483051,
0.00990249402821064,
0.055624715983867645,
-0.029046520590782166,
0.00838419422507286,
-0.02700478956103325,
0.04919162392616272,
-0.01458723284304142,
-0.012988426722586155,
0.013249891810119152,
-0.004992467816919088,
0.028676003217697144,
0.0292417723685503,
-0.023654405027627945,
-0.020158881321549416,
0.006977263372391462,
0.017092064023017883,
0.010463379323482513,
-0.009602532722055912,
0.03126979619264603,
-0.00850029569119215,
-0.010516786947846413,
0.015381981618702412,
0.011831767857074738,
0.015097234398126602,
0.0165234487503767,
0.03438916429877281,
0.010685750283300877,
0.005967999808490276,
-0.017396116629242897,
-0.0448567271232605,
0.023216336965560913,
0.013319507241249084,
-0.028647784143686295,
-0.04091062769293785,
0.030795767903327942,
0.002075742930173874,
0.004641450475901365,
0.02937009185552597,
0.01963748224079609,
0.01431470550596714,
0.0012387780006974936,
0.03143520653247833,
0.005029784049838781,
0.0032543116249144077,
-0.04464057460427284,
0.050396546721458435,
-0.042970046401023865,
-0.012707047164440155,
-0.016055453568696976,
-0.018528176471590996,
0.016786111518740654,
0.03174472227692604,
-0.0009320093085989356,
-0.03773823380470276,
0.006738913711160421,
-0.06036251783370972,
0.032930295914411545,
-0.036003097891807556,
0.018402744084596634,
-0.04125112667679787,
-0.03480086848139763,
0.046278342604637146,
-0.009136216714978218,
0.01562601514160633,
-0.021778440102934837,
-0.015988631173968315,
0.04151112213730812,
-0.021523039788007736,
-0.051319971680641174,
-0.03629574552178383,
-0.014431371353566647,
0.006990847177803516,
0.01441606879234314,
0.029444150626659393,
0.03999092057347298,
-0.009424789808690548,
0.02718799002468586,
-0.0017379220807924867,
-0.018232377246022224,
-0.014265473932027817,
0.013243627734482288,
0.000498033594340086,
-0.016214745119214058,
0.05349549278616905,
0.027242369949817657,
0.02960892766714096,
-0.042475625872612,
0.0436137355864048,
0.023135369643568993,
0.02169509045779705,
0.03788421303033829,
0.007724656257778406,
0.003546895692124963,
-0.03089558705687523,
-0.015392730943858624,
-0.0012235677568241954,
0.07101207971572876,
0.013773811049759388,
-0.014736367389559746,
0.04010336846113205,
-0.01063433289527893,
-0.05315076559782028,
0.028665760532021523,
0.003696884261444211,
0.0879083126783371,
0.0005885859718546271,
-0.012754235416650772,
0.032399654388427734,
0.0012852804502472281,
0.022268397733569145,
0.02582397498190403,
0.009792332537472248,
0.015802673995494843,
-0.019244426861405373,
-0.008323264308273792,
-0.05034869536757469,
-0.05398593097925186,
0.06984519958496094,
-0.004607729613780975,
0.007384073920547962,
0.0376313142478466,
-0.025668548420071602,
0.03716312348842621,
0.030058743432164192,
0.005533600226044655,
-0.013017450459301472,
0.011610656045377254,
-0.020984049886465073,
-0.004612290300428867,
0.028189847245812416,
-0.013241629116237164,
0.027500776574015617,
-0.019731394946575165,
0.013779066503047943,
-0.019380714744329453,
0.0005048509337939322,
0.010365818627178669,
0.01576058194041252,
-0.034699924290180206,
-0.017150895670056343,
-0.0068862237967550755,
0.0781126618385315,
-0.033070437610149384,
-0.06685835868120193,
-0.01225611288100481,
-0.047533612698316574,
-0.1287076771259308,
-0.021643174812197685,
0.02244945801794529,
0.01704471930861473,
-0.030020924285054207,
0.030046474188566208,
-0.029165396466851234,
-0.01593623496592045,
0.003015875816345215,
0.016456222161650658,
-0.03977419063448906,
-0.05658352002501488,
-0.013780362904071808,
0.015209104865789413,
-0.049869660288095474,
-0.006495236419141293,
-0.0386272557079792,
-0.029388263821601868,
0.041569601744413376,
-0.019260913133621216,
0.015238468535244465,
-0.014053508639335632,
0.01757020503282547,
0.01433913316577673,
-0.0019815335981547832,
0.005385112948715687,
0.04415920004248619,
0.05370569974184036,
-0.06647907942533493,
0.005625837482511997,
-0.025277208536863327,
-0.00041725265327841043,
0.00027563481125980616,
0.007776574231684208,
-0.025295265018939972,
0.012241694144904613,
0.07050208002328873,
-0.02121756598353386,
-0.02183353714644909,
-0.025808481499552727,
0.02464987523853779,
0.022955220192670822,
0.018265821039676666,
0.009661081247031689,
0.008561015129089355,
-0.0008150688954629004,
0.0007140741217881441,
0.0023209082428365946,
-0.010628549382090569,
0.027019675821065903,
0.010861489921808243,
0.023984026163816452,
-0.043364327400922775,
-0.026645412668585777,
0.0014651751844212413,
-0.021986529231071472,
-0.03131492808461189,
0.0037935443688184023,
-0.05470849946141243,
0.03421281650662422,
0.020567787811160088,
-0.03794630616903305,
0.0331537127494812,
0.008365937508642673,
0.022907113656401634,
-0.029698701575398445,
-0.035082604736089706,
0.009330363012850285,
0.021074499934911728,
-0.0026009916327893734,
0.022188054397702217,
0.004373835399746895,
-0.020986296236515045,
-0.028285009786486626,
-0.015622636303305626,
0.0009077531867660582,
-0.025850320234894753,
-0.005563005339354277,
0.018048066645860672,
-0.05091574043035507,
-0.008872561156749725,
0.046032022684812546,
-0.0013550390722230077,
0.06091233342885971,
-0.00951366312801838,
0.029161207377910614,
0.016214394941926003,
0.03354566916823387,
0.06589394807815552,
0.19216497242450714,
-0.05444195121526718,
0.0188111774623394,
0.06817995756864548,
-0.009900422766804695,
-0.0026627685874700546,
-0.03910108283162117,
0.03731327876448631,
-0.046021390706300735,
-0.04081003740429878,
-0.019394177943468094,
0.054510828107595444,
0.03061346337199211,
0.01820707507431507,
-0.040718112140893936,
0.013162958435714245,
-0.045120637863874435,
-0.03700990974903107,
0.04411022365093231,
-0.007429148070514202,
0.029329175129532814,
-0.02042808197438717,
-0.03259528800845146,
-0.027294717729091644,
-0.05690540745854378,
-0.05370700731873512,
-0.027084950357675552,
0.0786372572183609,
-0.013247079215943813,
0.00921009574085474,
-0.03061632625758648,
0.04237504303455353,
0.04530663043260574,
0.04394318908452988,
-0.0008368660928681493,
-0.008811433799564838,
-0.04588397592306137,
0.01504870131611824,
-0.013418936170637608,
0.019575290381908417,
0.030950576066970825,
-0.04975467175245285,
-0.06974930316209793,
-0.04694700241088867,
-0.028749166056513786,
0.015212186612188816,
-0.010609123855829239,
0.03991441801190376,
-0.0006677781930193305,
0.01125861331820488,
-0.010453684255480766,
0.04518141970038414,
-0.020527206361293793,
-0.027506040409207344,
-0.03055850975215435,
-0.01117744017392397,
-0.025999018922448158,
0.07123582065105438,
-0.01993647962808609,
-0.01385823916643858,
0.021058565005660057,
-0.001138386782258749,
-0.02381937950849533,
-0.011835213750600815,
-0.018343327566981316,
0.01317035872489214,
-0.07101452350616455,
-0.01399638969451189,
0.07783932238817215,
0.044241856783628464,
0.030600478872656822,
0.008301285095512867,
-0.03944490849971771,
0.00301241222769022,
0.04960096627473831,
0.01986987702548504,
-0.029119521379470825,
0.03262104094028473,
0.029469018802046776,
-0.014174405485391617,
-0.01715458184480667,
-0.03983152657747269,
0.008111618459224701,
0.028726080432534218,
0.014537873677909374,
-0.016165103763341904,
-0.047603245824575424,
-0.0058970763348042965,
-0.009080554358661175,
-0.012112942524254322,
-0.028418036177754402,
-0.015814634039998055,
0.003773776115849614,
-0.026553433388471603,
0.016194814816117287,
0.006553038489073515,
0.01831026002764702,
0.002827752148732543,
-0.02309325709939003,
-0.026209024712443352,
0.02399630844593048,
-0.01247415505349636,
0.018164481967687607,
-0.0001292878296226263,
0.043562181293964386,
0.03217591345310211,
0.02197333797812462,
-0.013147876597940922,
-0.0026989851612597704,
0.022263094782829285,
-0.013198130764067173,
-0.02207067236304283,
0.025189224630594254,
-0.05025092139840126,
0.0657997652888298,
-0.0044337110593914986,
0.000659206707496196,
-0.008434230461716652,
0.06317232549190521,
0.06572289019823074,
0.021539052948355675,
-0.01991424895823002,
-0.045975957065820694,
0.003943852614611387,
0.006871150806546211,
-0.01884249411523342,
-0.009915000759065151,
-0.009619527496397495,
-0.000024933651729952544,
-0.009993741288781166,
0.018880806863307953,
0.00966621283441782,
-0.03158140182495117,
-0.014785857871174812,
0.030960097908973694,
0.040188997983932495,
0.023535391315817833,
0.02545376680791378,
-0.06359077244997025,
0.012814449146389961,
0.00452000368386507,
0.002492236904799938,
-0.010718618519604206,
-0.012109014205634594,
0.002172541106119752,
-0.0021049678325653076,
-0.04401768371462822,
0.01382389198988676,
-0.03465365990996361,
-0.024140076711773872,
-0.0015003776643425226,
-0.018148822709918022,
-0.050775282084941864,
-0.05215108022093773,
-0.012692058458924294,
0.010174707509577274,
-0.00907079130411148,
0.019470375031232834,
-0.0034791885409504175,
0.00023920430976431817,
-0.02587839588522911,
0.056722890585660934,
-0.00923333503305912,
0.02490626648068428,
-0.018484298139810562,
0.051981668919324875,
-0.048362478613853455,
0.03151823952794075,
0.03833390027284622,
-0.026071352884173393,
-0.0029021939262747765,
-0.014597074128687382,
-0.027807002887129784,
0.0940050408244133,
0.04458491876721382,
0.007047899533063173,
-0.01674097590148449,
0.02528243139386177,
-0.01783486269414425,
-0.10615519434213638,
0.05282020568847656,
0.006523961201310158,
-0.012003189884126186,
-0.008846360258758068,
-0.019350996240973473,
-0.0019707907922565937,
-0.0664440393447876,
-0.022650159895420074,
0.04567686840891838,
-0.0510421022772789,
-0.014230785891413689,
0.06826797872781754,
0.007610581815242767,
-0.033992037177085876,
0.018686560913920403,
-0.014793876558542252,
-0.05031626299023628,
-0.017994320020079613,
-0.032457102090120316,
0.017399387434124947,
0.00351573689840734,
0.019362198188900948,
0.026445841416716576,
-0.012308316305279732,
0.012767922133207321,
-0.0012047833297401667,
-0.028166063129901886,
-0.021938158199191093,
-0.044799692928791046,
-0.06500659137964249,
0.011380680836737156,
0.007073068059980869,
-0.02467031218111515,
0.00574157340452075,
0.03985869511961937,
-0.024449151009321213,
-0.006403313484042883,
-0.016601260751485825,
-0.003813336370512843,
-0.04024038091301918,
-0.006137233227491379,
-0.018926870077848434,
-0.032046880573034286,
-0.0593111477792263,
0.01857365481555462,
-0.028673876076936722,
-0.05247289314866066,
-0.017655568197369576,
0.028863077983260155,
0.03423505648970604,
0.015657572075724602,
-0.028866343200206757,
-0.004791983403265476,
-0.0314813069999218,
-0.0013516712933778763,
-0.024544499814510345,
0.03221145272254944,
-0.010686270892620087,
0.013115426525473595,
-0.0216476172208786,
0.038889165967702866,
-0.0031342129223048687,
0.06156507506966591,
0.03710736706852913,
0.045747384428977966,
-0.035356588661670685,
0.03895002231001854,
-0.022534484043717384,
-0.003367647295817733,
0.04197900369763374,
0.021513884887099266,
0.03921085223555565,
-0.00459623895585537,
-0.007915363647043705,
-0.00016476681048516184,
0.026267707347869873,
-0.004762300755828619,
-0.003380641806870699,
0.008736992254853249,
-0.06922411173582077,
0.01685919426381588,
-0.013576917350292206,
-0.007364280987530947,
-0.02062276378273964,
0.02605975978076458,
-0.025584058836102486,
0.003980759996920824,
-0.009161857888102531,
-0.0243928674608469,
0.015102984383702278,
-0.006942349020391703,
-0.03672971948981285,
-0.015726421028375626,
-0.07626098394393921,
0.008994100615382195,
0.014862456358969212,
-0.04393278434872627,
-0.005945676937699318,
0.013593796640634537,
0.029261507093906403,
-0.015478935092687607,
-0.07203955203294754,
-0.056916024535894394,
-0.023569997400045395,
-0.0014137874823063612,
0.0346602201461792,
-0.0033765099942684174,
-0.004059428349137306,
-0.012878146953880787,
-0.00808386504650116,
-0.020016036927700043,
-0.0007549597066827118,
-0.006950050126761198,
0.035485684871673584,
0.014677725732326508,
-0.016786057502031326,
-0.03465454652905464,
0.05612006038427353,
-0.04135569557547569,
0.008052951656281948,
-0.04228032007813454,
0.015395399183034897,
-0.06572289019823074,
-0.04741394519805908,
-0.03995528444647789,
-0.007792997173964977,
-0.018574191257357597,
-0.019706400111317635,
-0.02432604320347309,
0.03434569016098976,
-0.02146461047232151,
-0.05144447088241577,
-0.00430958392098546,
-0.02947305701673031,
0.029172666370868683,
0.01703246869146824,
0.0004602595290634781,
-0.012312929145991802,
-0.0160408653318882,
-0.028087489306926727,
-0.005436405539512634,
0.013420394621789455,
-0.012447054497897625,
-0.020500171929597855,
-0.0065594022162258625,
-0.02306470088660717,
0.005330957472324371,
0.03365880250930786,
-0.02783374674618244,
0.03815615177154541,
-0.005137063097208738,
-0.03271886706352234,
-0.013149883598089218,
-0.008131486363708973,
-0.000334851851221174,
0.01592816784977913,
-0.01254147756844759,
0.00553581677377224,
0.044640135020017624,
-0.013985431753098965,
-0.04582957550883293,
-0.04391762241721153,
0.06232711672782898,
-0.03417467698454857,
-0.008057082071900368,
-0.04491128772497177,
-0.03180922195315361,
-0.022842807695269585,
0.028604790568351746,
0.008852456696331501,
0.016679050400853157,
0.039756130427122116,
-0.015179011970758438,
-0.046366289258003235,
-0.011407498270273209,
0.019246945157647133,
0.011098717339336872,
0.03154484182596207,
0.038988228887319565,
0.00846531055867672,
-0.012306317687034607,
0.014942196197807789,
0.017051061615347862,
0.00896128173917532,
0.009633955545723438,
-0.020821398124098778,
0.011372231878340244,
0.04692550748586655,
-0.0320264957845211,
0.04600682109594345,
0.009794190526008606,
-0.04051331430673599,
-0.04421474412083626,
-0.02155221626162529,
-0.0294435266405344,
0.07157579809427261,
-0.02442990057170391,
0.05035397782921791,
-0.018419278785586357,
-0.032991595566272736,
0.012567945756018162,
0.01091811154037714,
-0.01619657874107361,
-0.03717637062072754,
0.034453168511390686,
0.007965898141264915,
0.018033159896731377,
0.00027670885901898146,
0.05974121019244194,
0.028536509722471237,
-0.0016922587528824806,
0.042163215577602386,
-0.027838967740535736,
0.0019302278524264693,
-0.12636978924274445,
-0.017294716089963913,
0.015196279622614384,
-0.017549019306898117,
-0.005574312061071396,
0.00951544288545847,
0.03818292170763016,
0.005860168486833572,
0.001261197030544281,
-0.006639421917498112,
-0.0033911371137946844,
0.02467014268040657,
-0.023575477302074432,
-0.0115862051025033,
-0.022862698882818222,
0.02152232453227043,
-0.05463140457868576,
0.004516989458352327,
-0.06980139017105103,
-0.014602904208004475,
0.01577060855925083,
0.010301074013113976,
-0.02786974608898163,
-0.008913318626582623,
0.02398565597832203,
-0.007563488092273474,
-0.06173710152506828,
-0.05694784224033356,
-0.030627219006419182,
0.01596057042479515,
-0.04478032514452934,
0.0004554486076813191,
-0.0022566423285752535,
0.013846821151673794,
0.037272557616233826,
-0.034655388444662094,
-0.0008901317487470806,
-0.032118283212184906,
0.0034360026475042105,
-0.04567277804017067,
-0.022101813927292824,
0.03577760234475136,
-0.0652455985546112,
-0.05851905047893524,
0.031213123351335526,
0.024254877120256424,
0.02459576353430748,
0.018176479265093803,
-0.04564685747027397,
-0.004062411841005087,
-0.031058987602591515,
0.006985842250287533,
0.029112979769706726,
0.02555648609995842,
-0.005493917502462864,
-0.015160067938268185,
0.0535920150578022,
-0.008836663328111172,
-0.01779666356742382,
0.03886013850569725,
-0.0021660421043634415,
0.01433678437024355,
-0.031013891100883484,
-0.017134269699454308,
-0.015542706474661827,
-0.02713179960846901,
0.03144334629178047,
-0.022030550986528397,
-0.01462731696665287,
-0.023414617404341698,
-0.02316964790225029,
0.07180007547140121,
0.030119528993964195,
-0.010921666398644447,
0.011975106783211231,
-0.019436877220869064,
-0.008303753100335598,
0.03316182643175125,
-0.0479249469935894,
0.0034724741708487272,
-0.03232791647315025,
0.005661727860569954,
-0.04471040517091751,
-0.019536133855581284,
0.09064344316720963,
0.04562389478087425,
0.01792561262845993,
0.00663035549223423,
0.009903226979076862,
0.03253316879272461,
-0.008860564790666103,
0.015928879380226135,
-0.022497214376926422,
-0.029228374361991882,
-0.04868192970752716,
0.02549835294485092,
-0.0002135483082383871,
0.03256582096219063,
0.0041481503285467625,
-0.012733223848044872,
-0.02959533780813217,
0.0022296083625406027,
0.04355625808238983,
-0.008358275517821312,
-0.012638618238270283,
0.023941678926348686,
-0.003344886004924774,
-0.013786382973194122,
0.00495590316131711,
-0.01676473207771778,
-0.040439557284116745,
-0.05430999770760536,
-0.004788838792592287,
0.02836727723479271,
-0.03543035313487053,
-0.004382586106657982,
0.03151610866189003,
-0.03607714921236038,
-0.01013154350221157,
0.03893590345978737,
0.009888442233204842,
0.0359620675444603,
0.04185744374990463,
-0.03630267456173897,
-0.0027191375847905874,
-0.0010559833608567715,
0.015279958955943584,
0.030882662162184715,
0.02244735322892666,
-0.022148650139570236,
0.026059983298182487,
-0.008958217687904835,
-0.007628516294062138,
0.019129587337374687,
0.024432329460978508,
0.03448435291647911,
0.02147720381617546,
0.025175796821713448,
0.0003672325692605227,
-0.020937783643603325,
-0.04540610313415527,
0.03957753628492355,
-0.00803169421851635,
0.0427812896668911,
-0.054290007799863815,
0.043331000953912735,
0.05598707124590874,
0.00503193773329258,
0.010439117439091206,
-0.0034793242812156677,
0.030718689784407616,
0.03759542852640152,
-0.016665847972035408,
0.012417388148605824,
-0.0021676141768693924,
-0.009924778714776039,
0.04465576261281967,
-0.03039993718266487,
-0.0013401464093476534,
0.04919535666704178,
-0.01777220331132412,
-0.004042270593345165,
-0.05789874121546745,
-0.017172807827591896,
-0.019395409151911736,
0.05391072854399681,
-0.028584612533450127,
0.01770782098174095,
-0.006945970002561808,
-0.010393163189291954,
0.01115704420953989,
0.00953992921859026,
-0.03400447219610214,
0.04852883145213127,
0.021359965205192566,
0.01463665533810854,
-0.003990276250988245,
0.039479851722717285,
0.07583828270435333,
-0.009168324992060661,
0.035645946860313416,
0.013692482374608517,
0.019589679315686226,
-0.02708982117474079,
0.011821769177913666,
0.012582884170114994,
0.014069669879972935,
0.0416126549243927,
0.0066903140395879745,
-0.02870440110564232,
0.010626629926264286,
0.012221896089613438,
-0.030287254601716995,
-0.002551352372393012,
-0.03216777369379997,
0.030144385993480682,
0.00776209682226181,
0.0029023357201367617,
-0.013780717737972736,
0.01783575862646103,
0.013144505210220814,
0.009300537407398224,
-0.06943706423044205,
-0.00003538583405315876,
-0.00270729954354465,
-0.002214075531810522,
-0.011726418510079384,
-0.0046272873878479,
-0.05199282243847847,
0.011364717036485672,
-0.03148505836725235,
-0.019954537972807884,
-0.019284600391983986,
0.029043523594737053,
-0.03970877453684807,
0.06695622205734253,
0.04197811335325241,
0.03174919635057449,
0.037479009479284286,
-0.014209332875907421,
-0.00981475692242384,
0.01824391633272171,
0.017149919643998146,
-0.011688361875712872,
0.04029759764671326,
0.015032416209578514,
0.017151473090052605,
0.03500234708189964,
-0.004842083901166916,
-0.03279426693916321,
0.03120403178036213,
-0.025571901351213455,
0.003404374001547694,
0.03320649266242981,
0.015134209766983986,
-0.023803701624274254,
0.030295507982373238,
0.0179118849337101,
-0.03292778506875038,
-0.036122798919677734,
0.024038078263401985,
0.001687846495769918,
0.010181834921240807,
-0.01430024579167366
] |
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:42
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
626There is no evidence at all explaining how Mr Renshall could have represented that $18 million would be advanced.
627Nor is there any evidence explaining on what basis Mr Renshall stated that $18 million would be advanced by 15 September 2004.
628That date is, or is approximately, the "sunset date" under the IPC Heads of Agreement. It may be that it was for that reason that Mr Renshall nominated this date. However, he did not say so.
629My conclusion is that no reasonable basis for the making of these statements concerning the $18 million has been established. It follows that they were misleading or deceptive.
630The combination of Mr Zdrilic's and Mr Hilliard's notes also leads me to conclude that Mr Renshall did say something to Mr Zdrilic about $4.5 million being advanced.
631Mr Zdrilic's note that Mr Renshall said that he did not want to "rock the boat" and that Mr Renshall said something to the effect that "if the funder wants to put in $4.5 million, then so be it" appears very much to be an occasion on which Mr Zdrilic was endeavouring to capture Mr Renshall's exact words.
632On Mr Renshall's own account of it, the day before Mr Hanna had told him that $4.5 million "should be coming in a few days". I do not see a statement by Mr Renshall that, in effect, if the funder wanted to put in $4.5 million shortly, then "so be it", was inconsistent with that earlier statement.
633This was another statement as to a future matter.
634However, on this occasion, I think Mr Renshall did have reasonable grounds to make this statement.
635He had been told (and in my view had no reason to doubt) that Mr Hickie had signed a loan offer form for a $4.5 million advance and that HTT had paid a fee to Sydney Finance. He had been assured by Mr Hanna that the $4.5 million "should be coming in a few days". Accordingly, in my opinion Mr Renshall's statement about this figure was not misleading or deceptive.
636Based on Mr Zdrilic's note, I am also satisfied that Mr Renshall said something about funder having "organised" $40 million.
637To "organise" is to "make arrangements or preparations for" something (Concise Oxford Dictionary 11th edition) or to "obtain; get; make" (Macquarie Dictionary 3rd edition).
638Mr Zdrilic's note suggests that Mr Renshall had qualified the statement that the funds were "organised".
639Mr Zdrilic's note says that Mr Renshall qualified each statement about the $40 million by saying "but the availability of those funds comes in stages". In Mr Zdrilic's rendering of the conversation in his affidavit he said something slightly different. He said that Mr Renshall had said that the $40 million "will come in stages".
640It appears to me most likely that whatever Mr Renshall said about the $40 million, he made clear that although the funds had been "organised", they were not yet "available".
641The reference in this note to the funder having "organised" $40 million must have conveyed to Mr Zdrilic that, so far as Mr Renshall knew, it was necessary for the funder to make arrangements or preparations for the advance and was thus not using its own funds. Rather, it was "organising" funds from a third party.
642So far as the IBC loan of $40 million was concerned, Mr Renshall's evidence was as follows:-
* the only document he saw concerning the proposed IBC loan was the Ping Letter of 24 August 2004;
* he knew that Mr Ping was associated with IBIS but did not know what the relationship was;
* he did not know whether IBC was bound to provide funds to IPC;
* on the other hand, he did not know that IBC was not bound to provide such funds;
* he believed that Mr Moir had done some due diligence in respect of Mr Ping's capabilities;
* he had seen from Mr Ping's letter that IBC's proposed loan was subject to a successful review by the IBC group of IPC and that until that review had been completed to the satisfaction of IBC, there was no assurance that IBC would advance the $40 million;
|
[
-0.0029163744766265154,
0.028043663129210472,
-0.01661713421344757,
0.019013341516256332,
-0.03395330533385277,
-0.02171880379319191,
0.011601458303630352,
-0.035872697830200195,
-0.021501531824469566,
0.008558213710784912,
-0.002385118743404746,
0.03747835010290146,
-0.03631570562720299,
0.00771988183259964,
-0.01833123154938221,
-0.012884302996098995,
0.05118191987276077,
-0.004570210352540016,
0.016506312415003777,
-0.013618430122733116,
0.004055982921272516,
-0.026664959266781807,
0.007816133089363575,
0.029372764751315117,
-0.004099748097360134,
-0.007234102115035057,
-0.021645119413733482,
0.02408384159207344,
0.05454181134700775,
0.01851503551006317,
0.015830595046281815,
-0.015628734603524208,
0.0637011006474495,
0.01571134850382805,
0.02817736379802227,
-0.019666312262415886,
0.01071856264024973,
0.008935760706663132,
-0.0220280010253191,
0.04589635878801346,
0.004400800447911024,
-0.0008789923158474267,
-0.0023789445403963327,
0.023960500955581665,
0.08147086948156357,
-0.020126784220337868,
-0.010522015392780304,
-0.023384660482406616,
0.022093378007411957,
0.009770506992936134,
-0.029832785949110985,
-0.03472021967172623,
0.045421335846185684,
0.00231087114661932,
-0.015168551355600357,
-0.014758351258933544,
-0.0005303176585584879,
-0.00905311293900013,
-0.039310093969106674,
0.004920864477753639,
0.016046246513724327,
-0.025792337954044342,
-0.04338395223021507,
-0.02761312760412693,
-0.0010486977407708764,
0.09503597766160965,
0.001627510879188776,
0.0025337091647088528,
-0.00009627668623579666,
-0.004511990584433079,
-0.05631794035434723,
-0.0039009004831314087,
0.0092087397351861,
-0.03194500133395195,
-0.1069665476679802,
-0.014908391050994396,
0.05090285465121269,
-0.012887642718851566,
0.03392016515135765,
0.06421053409576416,
0.048203468322753906,
-0.011252016760408878,
0.0006630889838561416,
-0.0051469518803060055,
-0.0110659534111619,
0.01093511376529932,
-0.03180227428674698,
0.02501513808965683,
-0.0033113891258835793,
0.0033654009457677603,
-0.0013758934801444411,
0.05006277188658714,
0.041111353784799576,
-0.05240757763385773,
0.009360458701848984,
0.0031987265683710575,
-0.043636731803417206,
0.04132421314716339,
0.021398842334747314,
0.021920688450336456,
0.005931917577981949,
0.03455033898353577,
-0.010702892206609249,
-0.003019059309735894,
-0.011239675804972649,
0.02504110336303711,
0.04273200035095215,
0.06385207921266556,
-0.014200834557414055,
-0.016300799325108528,
-0.013661019504070282,
0.004937569610774517,
-0.0036526313051581383,
0.06188302859663963,
0.02301132306456566,
-0.009261978790163994,
-0.030719758942723274,
0.005407025571912527,
0.010214860551059246,
0.019580796360969543,
0.017920013517141342,
0.01371693704277277,
0.020375816151499748,
0.023412540555000305,
-0.06856486201286316,
0.016841867938637733,
-0.012678288854658604,
-0.009213190525770187,
-0.01523594930768013,
0.02323809266090393,
-0.01862829364836216,
0.031070828437805176,
-0.023394547402858734,
-0.018209250643849373,
-0.04520237073302269,
0.005894726142287254,
0.020386599004268646,
-0.041976217180490494,
0.014130119234323502,
-0.06893625110387802,
0.02595497854053974,
-0.0042449552565813065,
0.022914545610547066,
-0.029990142211318016,
0.0022172045428305864,
-0.06909950822591782,
-0.003854590468108654,
0.01381192822009325,
-0.0008375782635994256,
0.0678754597902298,
-0.0021867428440600634,
0.0007198533276095986,
0.04239959642291069,
0.00975781213492155,
0.02810780704021454,
-0.019170043990015984,
-0.005708563141524792,
-0.021126065403223038,
0.01221249345690012,
0.057626236230134964,
-0.0327778160572052,
0.04605242237448692,
-0.03037143126130104,
-0.04090980812907219,
-0.01897498033940792,
0.0028096395544707775,
0.007480836473405361,
0.04468624293804169,
-0.01932647079229355,
-0.026057427749037743,
-0.005892859771847725,
-0.013569062575697899,
0.06395578384399414,
0.00019701301062013954,
0.019247278571128845,
0.010330993682146072,
0.06449991464614868,
0.002398676937445998,
0.007206943351775408,
-0.028370918706059456,
-0.06384778767824173,
0.05550454556941986,
0.029415272176265717,
-0.006783973425626755,
-0.022366445511579514,
0.008873142302036285,
-0.010446205735206604,
-0.017115013673901558,
0.005710839759558439,
0.0037932749837636948,
0.010102433152496815,
-0.015269586816430092,
0.021795233711600304,
0.016374964267015457,
0.04267299920320511,
-0.017042966559529305,
-0.0006325734429992735,
-0.023754490539431572,
-0.0019719109404832125,
-0.017631804570555687,
-0.015201632864773273,
0.03893642872571945,
0.03707408905029297,
-0.029370998963713646,
-0.013632463291287422,
0.03342336416244507,
-0.033281948417425156,
-0.01548144593834877,
0.009238111786544323,
-0.02135264314711094,
0.023421339690685272,
-0.010457966476678848,
-0.01793561317026615,
0.007464620750397444,
0.011908356100320816,
-0.00001428356881660875,
0.007295542862266302,
-0.017026007175445557,
0.017116587609052658,
-0.05773433297872543,
-0.04299330711364746,
0.019135940819978714,
0.023416144773364067,
0.023085735738277435,
0.028268003836274147,
0.06856248527765274,
-0.06051365286111832,
0.04554297402501106,
-0.025284796953201294,
-0.04140052571892738,
0.000326430395944044,
-0.013430716469883919,
0.004436414688825607,
-0.013059942983090878,
0.011688968166708946,
0.04038810357451439,
0.009651985950767994,
0.042975448071956635,
-0.009718228131532669,
-0.007808308582752943,
-0.01761126145720482,
-0.014703133143484592,
0.0033566064666956663,
0.02782927267253399,
-0.024347981438040733,
0.03807299956679344,
0.006741763092577457,
0.023794112727046013,
0.012036003172397614,
0.014673718251287937,
0.017073027789592743,
-0.012233802117407322,
-0.008501372300088406,
-0.002491315593943,
0.027272293344140053,
0.018853874877095222,
0.03032926842570305,
0.004678462632000446,
0.02915126085281372,
0.03369008004665375,
0.0446174293756485,
0.0036203868221491575,
0.0361672043800354,
0.02533833682537079,
-0.010576920583844185,
-0.03962697461247444,
-0.03709286078810692,
-0.052436716854572296,
0.02736891247332096,
-0.017935216426849365,
0.03935249149799347,
0.002126882551237941,
0.022274639457464218,
0.00771000562235713,
0.022579345852136612,
0.040848057717084885,
-0.002913022879511118,
0.006603289395570755,
0.01073809526860714,
0.024796899408102036,
0.03402741253376007,
0.005194516386836767,
0.01328811515122652,
-0.02215670235455036,
0.04666711762547493,
0.022057022899389267,
-0.0024242615327239037,
-0.016378015279769897,
0.007889893837273121,
-0.007950833067297935,
-0.010075530037283897,
0.009989693760871887,
0.05200266093015671,
-0.020676467567682266,
-0.05030507594347,
-0.067682646214962,
-0.010130586102604866,
-0.1571914255619049,
-0.016195332631468773,
0.003362536197528243,
0.0559212788939476,
0.008348838426172733,
0.020592737942934036,
-0.03252806514501572,
-0.015362134203314781,
-0.05646951496601105,
0.009373961947858334,
0.014678208157420158,
-0.042040467262268066,
-0.012601813301444054,
0.05596713349223137,
0.04182272031903267,
-0.029802517965435982,
0.012464468367397785,
-0.02434176579117775,
-0.001892919186502695,
-0.01127939485013485,
0.008601637557148933,
-0.026234585791826248,
0.02718506008386612,
0.006237667053937912,
-0.02680004946887493,
-0.0038005677051842213,
-0.016856549307703972,
0.02352156862616539,
-0.04420582577586174,
-0.03696439415216446,
-0.007945643737912178,
0.036424215883016586,
-0.02359524555504322,
0.04282495751976967,
-0.0039012690540403128,
0.053642868995666504,
0.05084129795432091,
-0.05785999819636345,
-0.03404426574707031,
-0.03551406040787697,
0.02628420479595661,
0.004093635361641645,
0.006053913850337267,
0.03088773973286152,
-0.0011647306382656097,
-0.04789739474654198,
0.0023426134139299393,
0.00850119162350893,
0.03555411472916603,
0.03592763841152191,
0.029494427144527435,
0.01509731076657772,
-0.014342348091304302,
-0.020522361621260643,
0.0094225462526083,
-0.03525981307029724,
0.02500247023999691,
0.008965703658759594,
-0.0656530037522316,
-0.027277996763586998,
-0.04913941025733948,
-0.10537221282720566,
0.006237603258341551,
-0.00752095365896821,
-0.027687761932611465,
0.012419098988175392,
-0.00767563609406352,
-0.030597399920225143,
0.0324862003326416,
0.022573823109269142,
0.00009796466474654153,
-0.003921904601156712,
0.00933128222823143,
0.0008180242730304599,
0.037109047174453735,
0.030371466651558876,
-0.06664268672466278,
-0.022927269339561462,
-0.023536106571555138,
-0.09773173183202744,
0.024579722434282303,
0.013342281803488731,
-0.004362528212368488,
-0.005127710290253162,
0.007508135866373777,
0.00511148339137435,
0.033246081322431564,
0.04171192646026611,
-0.037717435508966446,
0.2545056939125061,
-0.026931412518024445,
0.02009456232190132,
0.03522754833102226,
0.045033201575279236,
-0.028557436540722847,
-0.008918480947613716,
0.031490959227085114,
-0.016998548060655594,
-0.04063452407717705,
-0.003388449549674988,
-0.05006968602538109,
0.00812980905175209,
0.01604938879609108,
-0.04989225044846535,
0.0019359597936272621,
-0.053296659141778946,
-0.007827552035450935,
0.07161487638950348,
-0.011825081892311573,
0.028980478644371033,
-0.01739639788866043,
-0.002937610261142254,
0.013534783385694027,
-0.05671938508749008,
-0.048815250396728516,
0.02696375735104084,
0.043655525892972946,
-0.011460402049124241,
0.022189322859048843,
-0.0035799769684672356,
-0.018999630585312843,
0.026383796706795692,
-0.016527347266674042,
0.027737801894545555,
0.0273614302277565,
-0.023517558351159096,
0.03885962814092636,
-0.01725160889327526,
0.05441465228796005,
-0.001948116929270327,
-0.026981296017766,
-0.01250664982944727,
-0.0636923760175705,
-0.003298857482150197,
0.0076105594635009766,
-0.03480970859527588,
0.01887524500489235,
-0.01015712134540081,
0.010581973008811474,
-0.00023346459784079343,
0.028304139152169228,
-0.004975970834493637,
0.015533636324107647,
0.011914071626961231,
0.06115388870239258,
-0.008810430765151978,
0.037405747920274734,
-0.0014282112242653966,
0.0540812648832798,
-0.014539005234837532,
0.03786221146583557,
-0.008133224211633205,
0.029983235523104668,
0.013511279597878456,
-0.029479453340172768,
-0.06356173753738403,
-0.07631120830774307,
0.023703254759311676,
-0.008654776960611343,
0.048022251576185226,
0.04266505688428879,
0.028698891401290894,
-0.0046682716347277164,
0.008487489074468613,
-0.019242966547608376,
0.017018992453813553,
-0.0021289861761033535,
-0.0030207668896764517,
0.007566725369542837,
-0.022946590557694435,
-0.04475150629878044,
0.00037911575054749846,
0.022375766187906265,
0.02075786702334881,
-0.024515774101018906,
-0.02872714400291443,
0.05869400128722191,
-0.024325085803866386,
-0.04121603071689606,
-0.051920175552368164,
-0.006061115302145481,
0.00846650917083025,
-0.014038304798305035,
-0.014004837721586227,
0.007159429602324963,
-0.006483825854957104,
-0.006778192240744829,
-0.05574415251612663,
-0.056087929755449295,
-0.0013592875329777598,
0.02097436413168907,
0.024796055629849434,
-0.04648490622639656,
0.04192805662751198,
0.0027692897710949183,
-0.014675025828182697,
0.006651990581303835,
-0.0401383712887764,
0.017661098390817642,
-0.03269549086689949,
0.029806146398186684,
-0.005180819425731897,
-0.021513942629098892,
0.03906325623393059,
0.047167640179395676,
0.02709357626736164,
0.10134974122047424,
0.0130644915625453,
0.01728544570505619,
0.012938481755554676,
-0.02983809821307659,
-0.0036219616886228323,
-0.0022439390886574984,
-0.018958957865834236,
0.00584758073091507,
-0.021471412852406502,
-0.02078692428767681,
0.0202854722738266,
-0.020651845261454582,
0.03639117628335953,
-0.01799428090453148,
-0.02128930389881134,
0.016861604526638985,
0.06399980932474136,
0.007948576472699642,
-0.005116387736052275,
0.01258056703954935,
-0.035374611616134644,
0.034224316477775574,
-0.02676546759903431,
0.017037251964211464,
-0.011382573284208775,
-0.01701803132891655,
0.01550055667757988,
0.009630358777940273,
-0.052692946046590805,
-0.004600629210472107,
-0.013587959110736847,
0.017640994861721992,
0.028380077332258224,
0.007484477944672108,
-0.0388253778219223,
-0.02583961933851242,
0.03096495196223259,
0.015482180751860142,
-0.03231969103217125,
-0.006861110683530569,
0.03686865419149399,
-0.009489634074270725,
-0.016492510214447975,
0.0026586721651256084,
-0.012068267911672592,
0.023281043395400047,
-0.033259179443120956,
0.05467868968844414,
0.004040502477437258,
0.03947135806083679,
0.023965278640389442,
-0.020944438874721527,
-0.0016669671749696136,
-0.02347373776137829,
-0.02089577540755272,
0.04820224270224571,
0.027468202635645866,
0.04976126179099083,
-0.011720043607056141,
-0.006635433062911034,
0.004751165863126516,
-0.04374353587627411,
0.0028274927753955126,
0.009726600721478462,
-0.049530237913131714,
-0.0034554654266685247,
0.019835885614156723,
-0.04178299754858017,
0.020055940374732018,
-0.03630804270505905,
0.032787445932626724,
-0.0571104995906353,
0.0009985493961721659,
0.0750592052936554,
0.010559569112956524,
-0.028323739767074585,
-0.02176573872566223,
0.006874179933220148,
-0.03905687853693962,
0.06529637426137924,
-0.01576327718794346,
-0.03310379758477211,
0.0006942464970052242,
-0.024882445111870766,
-0.0035416013561189175,
-0.0016745834145694971,
0.004261680878698826,
0.020733708515763283,
-0.010505220852792263,
0.040880974382162094,
-0.03808363527059555,
-0.024886714294552803,
0.0039014844223856926,
-0.005785604473203421,
-0.023477794602513313,
0.0015768669545650482,
0.011552129872143269,
-0.01802573911845684,
0.028509072959423065,
0.0698971375823021,
0.01810762658715248,
-0.011727800592780113,
-0.016472846269607544,
-0.031018562614917755,
0.03088347613811493,
-0.06375584006309509,
-0.04523419961333275,
-0.005994613282382488,
-0.04462374001741409,
-0.002071159891784191,
-0.01868670992553234,
-0.0069060917012393475,
-0.00033430923940613866,
-0.0776846706867218,
0.07310772687196732,
-0.07096779346466064,
-0.011803624220192432,
-0.012377222999930382,
0.0497530959546566,
0.018182361498475075,
0.0013864479260519147,
-0.013508609496057034,
0.02344360202550888,
-0.04433843493461609,
-0.0004876645398326218,
0.011961054056882858,
0.01590498350560665,
-0.009560412727296352,
-0.0018173379357904196,
0.0041884020902216434,
0.044711798429489136,
0.014195900410413742,
0.0006764250574633479,
0.033815015107393265,
0.00044341268949210644,
-0.004850079771131277,
0.02946540340781212,
-0.004560505039989948,
-0.013708737678825855,
-0.024091919884085655,
-0.02783084660768509,
-0.037245240062475204,
-0.005419784225523472,
0.030534012243151665,
0.0008194301626645029,
-0.02559303119778633,
-0.050754647701978683,
-0.06452427804470062,
0.016848068684339523,
-0.026750648394227028,
-0.03945454582571983,
0.0061105298809707165,
-0.03498679772019386,
0.016597304493188858,
-0.008218029513955116,
-0.032638274133205414,
0.0031695447396486998,
-0.0118047334253788,
-0.01935768686234951,
0.007687481120228767,
0.004112291615456343,
-0.0005311139393597841,
0.008965411223471165,
0.009371244348585606,
0.055596597492694855,
0.021109363064169884,
-0.026020342484116554,
0.030919553712010384,
0.004693364258855581,
-0.008257264271378517,
0.01814034953713417,
0.005416083615273237,
0.0011058972449973226,
-0.0020020443480461836,
-0.042135078459978104,
0.029155271127820015,
-0.0026823554653674364,
0.007538707461208105,
0.0005219628219492733,
0.032731685787439346,
0.011779677122831345,
0.023007510229945183,
-0.007483700290322304,
0.007503545843064785,
-0.02554091438651085,
-0.0312938429415226,
-0.023351548239588737,
-0.00852672103792429,
0.012843146920204163,
-0.023627031594514847,
-0.03856673836708069,
-0.0005511905183084309,
0.012927154079079628,
-0.0404704250395298,
0.019514335319399834,
-0.01911652833223343,
0.0041476706974208355,
-0.0019429962849244475,
0.0452406108379364,
0.005169545765966177,
-0.005182921886444092,
-0.005617177113890648,
0.002840549685060978,
0.01069578342139721,
-0.0586230605840683,
0.0129069983959198,
-0.03830667957663536,
0.014340766705572605,
0.03168506175279617,
-0.06627823412418365,
-0.054830554872751236,
0.01013136375695467,
-0.009347649291157722,
-0.041957687586545944,
-0.01366922352463007,
0.011180343106389046,
0.04529918357729912,
-0.012708082795143127,
-0.00011404657561797649,
-0.004435868933796883,
0.007433807943016291,
-0.02111448347568512,
0.024189474061131477,
-0.07461531460285187,
0.07920543849468231,
-0.004266488831490278,
0.027364499866962433,
-0.013689660467207432,
0.019486024975776672,
0.011134681291878223,
0.03960198536515236,
0.013724424876272678,
-0.0169063750654459,
0.013150015845894814,
-0.015409757383167744,
-0.06321066617965698,
-0.011279777623713017,
-0.0029229228384792805,
-0.0027880349662154913,
0.02939814142882824,
-0.001508717774413526,
0.001113786594942212,
-0.05163637921214104,
0.024546654894948006,
0.007793677970767021,
-0.005143139977008104,
-0.035838473588228226,
-0.022270942106842995,
0.0051712337881326675,
0.025431083515286446,
0.005244358908385038,
0.00023704330669716,
-0.01096311118453741,
-0.007314915303140879,
0.0048935855738818645,
-0.025265907868742943,
-0.05313682183623314,
0.03381122648715973,
0.024633826687932014,
0.04124245420098305,
-0.03177275136113167,
-0.03911842033267021,
0.012216785922646523,
-0.003256614785641432,
-0.004590322729200125,
-0.0020496766082942486,
0.03619762510061264,
-0.0475679449737072,
-0.015219931490719318,
0.006220277398824692,
0.003565769176930189,
0.01101973932236433,
-0.00956360436975956,
0.014512457884848118,
-0.03382640704512596,
-0.024189915508031845,
-0.14997807145118713,
-0.03652965649962425,
0.00040867962525226176,
-0.022159608080983162,
-0.033349450677633286,
-0.019887486472725868,
-0.05723188817501068,
-0.011841938830912113,
-0.01600969396531582,
-0.008527817204594612,
-0.01055982057005167,
0.022722676396369934,
0.014876854605972767,
-0.014095794409513474,
-0.07814493030309677,
0.041506603360176086,
-0.030793964862823486,
-0.005666201934218407,
-0.06547572463750839,
-0.017862286418676376,
0.019937826320528984,
-0.008639613166451454,
-0.012527930550277233,
-0.0055409991182386875,
-0.0077412924729287624,
0.0012511606328189373,
0.02136930823326111,
-0.0343598946928978,
-0.04886455088853836,
-0.028033290058374405,
-0.018775051459670067,
-0.026729263365268707,
0.021063227206468582,
0.08148053288459778,
0.007282307371497154,
0.018160704523324966,
0.007038909941911697,
-0.010326043702661991,
-0.02720050700008869,
-0.010714801028370857,
-0.006894712336361408,
0.019648900255560875,
-0.03745359182357788,
-0.03522336483001709,
0.002327126683667302,
0.032321907579898834,
-0.007691110018640757,
-0.03383766487240791,
-0.06861559301614761,
-0.01779751107096672,
-0.05623384937644005,
0.009580632671713829,
0.024578258395195007,
0.06679541617631912,
-0.007765964604914188,
-0.033288855105638504,
0.016132470220327377,
-0.011216843500733376,
0.03926599398255348,
0.07948232442140579,
0.03689413145184517,
-0.010382331907749176,
-0.044785402715206146,
0.006129147484898567,
-0.037568219006061554,
-0.019928982481360435,
-0.009421192109584808,
0.008196942508220673,
-0.025710200890898705,
0.015031022019684315,
-0.008994954638183117,
-0.012325040064752102,
0.0014543855795636773,
-0.06591053307056427,
0.008925721049308777,
-0.006197021808475256,
-0.000579572340939194,
0.009537171572446823,
-0.053410086780786514,
-0.021052148193120956,
-0.014211754314601421,
-0.0005166988703422248,
-0.07327913492918015,
-0.002517440589144826,
0.04412746801972389,
0.04307958856225014,
-0.02090097963809967,
-0.02190362475812435,
-0.02033027820289135,
-0.06341982632875443,
-0.03936760872602463,
-0.015399754978716373,
0.0040677315555512905,
0.04078839719295502,
-0.015728391706943512,
0.03627370670437813,
-0.0018125722417607903,
-0.010784863494336605,
-0.025155436247587204,
-0.02140016481280327,
-0.01673680730164051,
-0.0008543842122890055,
0.01289705652743578,
0.00707256281748414,
-0.0023908682633191347,
0.0013498817570507526,
0.01840728335082531,
0.0036110575310885906,
0.029847417026758194,
-0.004667402245104313,
-0.02290257252752781,
0.003262854414060712,
-0.03160332515835762,
0.05131733790040016,
-0.059634532779455185,
0.003252079477533698,
-0.0021905340254306793,
0.027990464121103287,
0.027060693129897118,
-0.039752427488565445,
0.05083980783820152,
-0.0026419851928949356,
0.009017574600875378,
-0.013979046605527401,
0.0008728061802685261,
0.007688320707529783,
0.03385363519191742,
0.046453967690467834,
0.010343041270971298,
0.006242846604436636,
0.04062071815133095,
-0.027917247265577316,
0.03976205736398697,
0.014831212349236012,
-0.011672227643430233,
0.010100088082253933,
-0.010746321640908718,
0.01061324868351221,
-0.04021310433745384,
-0.014346766285598278,
-0.022507674992084503,
0.00607176311314106,
-0.02783060446381569,
0.009680179879069328,
-0.04096027836203575,
0.010267332196235657,
0.03330165520310402,
-0.018271731212735176,
-0.02837049402296543,
-0.01600504294037819,
-0.006673115771263838,
0.019837167114019394,
0.008887125179171562,
0.028343141078948975,
-0.0004972093156538904,
0.0025753332301974297,
0.036649782210588455,
0.0065703485161066055,
0.03492897376418114,
0.03267591819167137,
0.025549471378326416,
-0.047756414860486984,
-0.030385170131921768,
-0.051841773092746735,
-0.02373393625020981,
0.03212422877550125,
-0.015395602211356163,
0.01566915400326252,
-0.028817621991038322,
0.0009129248792305589,
-0.01366868894547224,
0.017107492312788963,
-0.0280600618571043,
0.008047540672123432,
0.04728769510984421,
-0.012764452025294304,
-0.008684358559548855,
-0.004275668878108263,
0.06885752826929092,
-0.029759228229522705,
0.02026246301829815,
-0.0012593050487339497,
0.060353513807058334,
0.00012295774649828672,
0.0012923537287861109,
0.02803077921271324,
-0.005608872044831514,
-0.005659565329551697,
-0.016129057854413986,
-0.02390925958752632,
-0.03639097511768341,
0.01624683290719986,
0.06125153228640556,
-0.03438520431518555,
0.03152686730027199,
0.02580549195408821,
0.0012637266190722585,
0.040554407984018326,
-0.0006287710275501013,
0.020715365186333656,
0.005932538770139217,
-0.022665558382868767,
-0.004407880827784538,
-0.0005692680133506656,
-0.04175122082233429,
0.0029745048377662897,
0.015612165443599224,
-0.043772947043180466,
-0.047727711498737335,
0.04509162902832031,
-0.02736162766814232,
-0.010429363697767258,
-0.012870734557509422,
0.03130944073200226,
-0.014294267632067204,
-0.01470772922039032,
0.03167787194252014,
0.005821375176310539,
0.012735907919704914,
-0.022145671769976616,
0.028334965929389,
0.028432833030819893,
-0.007268161047250032,
-0.025600530207157135,
-0.015328875742852688,
-0.04614779353141785,
-0.020063485950231552,
0.015361170284450054,
0.023907648399472237,
0.03138051554560661,
-0.01024883333593607,
0.0336981862783432,
0.0018188473768532276,
0.0558033362030983,
-0.03810465708374977,
-0.01721826195716858,
-0.019001087173819542,
-0.015515358187258244,
-0.02305912785232067,
-0.03287924826145172,
0.06238612160086632,
-0.03962826728820801,
0.042092520743608475,
-0.021041888743638992
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:27
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
393Mr Renshall denied making this representation and said that:-
"I did not represent to Mr Zdrilic that any funding beyond $9 million would be advanced".
394Again, it seems Mr Renshall was speaking of the $9 million "Interim Loan" referred to in the IPC Heads of Agreement.
395The note made by Mr Zdrilic does point to the probability that Mr Renshall said something in this conversation about the possibility of a funder spending $85 million.
396But Mr Zdrilic accepted, in cross-examination, that he did not believe, based upon what he claims Mr Renshall said to him, that HTT had then obtained a binding commitment to advance $85 million. What Mr Zdrilic understood from Mr Renshall was that Mr Renshall was having discussions with a funder about proposals, not commitments, to advance funds.
397Indeed, he agreed that he knew that there was no commitment from any funder to provide $85 million at this stage.
398Further, the draft Heads of Agreement being prepared by Mr Hilliard on Mr Zdrilic's behalf at this time, referred to HTT obtaining a loan of approximately $9 million (not $85 million).
399For these reasons I think it plain that, whatever Mr Renshall said on 15 March 2004 was not relied upon by Mr Zdrilic as representing a statement as to a commitment of funds, or at all.
16 March 2004 - Sixth Representation
400The plaintiffs claim that the next day, a further representation was made that:-
* the new funder had approval from a bank in New Zealand for its funding;
* the new funder would spend millions of dollars on the Project; and
* it was in the best interest of both HTT and LEC to settle the 2001 Proceeding immediately so as not to jeopardise the deal between HTT and the new funder.
401Again, the representation was alleged to have taken place in a conversation between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall.
402Mr Zdrilic claims Mr Renshall said:-
"The funder has approval from the bank in New Zealand. The funder will spend millions of dollars. Let's sign the deal and not jeopardise getting this funder as they are hard to get."
403Mr Zdrilic made a note which was substantially to this effect and included:-
"They have approval from Bank in New Zealand"; and
"Robert says they are going to spend hundreds of millions of dollars".
404Mr Zdrilic's note does have the appearance of one made contemporaneously with his conversation with Mr Renshall.
405In his affidavit evidence, Mr Renshall denied making this statement, and said that he said:-
"Look, the mine has been closed for some years and you would have to spend extraordinary amounts to open it up again for commercial operations. We are not going to see any of that sort of revenue for some years. If we are lucky we can get someone investing and hope that the revenue comes later".
406However, in cross-examination he did not adhere to this denial and did not dispute that he said the words attributed to him by Mr Zdrilic.
407This conversation took place the day after HTT entered into the IPC Heads of Agreement which document did contemplate, albeit subject to many conditions, that IPC would spend "millions" on the Project.
408In those circumstances, I am satisfied that Mr Renshall did say words to the effect deposed to by Mr Zdrilic. However, what was said on this occasion (together with whatever was said on the occasion of the Fifth Representation) was overtaken, in my opinion, by events shortly thereafter.
23 March 2004 - Seventh Representation
409This representation is that:-
* HTT had an arrangement with the new funder whereby the new funder would provide a loan of $12 million instead of $9 million; and
* the new funder was a company called "IBIS Pty Limited".
410This representation is alleged to have been made by Mr Renshall during a meeting at Mr Hilliard's office attended by Mr Renshall, Mr Zdrilic, Mr Hilliard and Mr Gillard.
|
[
-0.016385767608880997,
0.03516905754804611,
-0.009205312468111515,
0.018324609845876694,
-0.023966072127223015,
-0.009954897686839104,
0.002055780729278922,
-0.04842502251267433,
-0.005935976281762123,
-0.006289310287684202,
0.003466444555670023,
0.04029642418026924,
-0.019854746758937836,
0.01180365402251482,
-0.011139815673232079,
-0.0296609029173851,
0.030201569199562073,
-0.013402885757386684,
0.011364107951521873,
-0.005208412650972605,
-0.007170864846557379,
-0.026876287534832954,
0.013837475329637527,
0.014151068404316902,
-0.0007670040940865874,
0.0020613439846783876,
-0.04440277814865112,
0.01767752133309841,
0.04646112769842148,
0.017922276630997658,
0.0098356232047081,
-0.00936693511903286,
0.04484646022319794,
-0.022966718301177025,
0.025022730231285095,
-0.007740519009530544,
0.02831467054784298,
0.010328138247132301,
-0.038355354219675064,
0.018346183001995087,
0.0016236562514677644,
0.01445149164646864,
0.005344581790268421,
0.008937805891036987,
0.06622416526079178,
-0.037602826952934265,
0.009844408370554447,
-0.01892727240920067,
0.02799934893846512,
0.009365154430270195,
-0.01689246855676174,
-0.03636440634727478,
0.051500529050827026,
-0.03136734291911125,
-0.02927025407552719,
0.0018303454853594303,
-0.01691950112581253,
-0.0009560819016769528,
-0.06055006757378578,
0.018290823325514793,
0.011380719020962715,
-0.01829768344759941,
-0.07022798806428909,
-0.003495848970487714,
-0.02269541472196579,
0.12575501203536987,
0.001034705899655819,
0.004904391244053841,
0.000638844445347786,
-0.010343445464968681,
-0.05783743038773537,
-0.00037449051160365343,
-0.03153735771775246,
0.005483618006110191,
-0.09836120903491974,
0.014772574417293072,
0.03402451053261757,
0.014875116758048534,
0.014177105389535427,
0.04099801555275917,
0.05181683599948883,
-0.02345552109181881,
-0.019355250522494316,
0.02580076828598976,
-0.021589547395706177,
0.008757785893976688,
-0.014968212693929672,
0.027253560721874237,
0.020081663504242897,
-0.029991041868925095,
-0.0034380347933620214,
0.025055088102817535,
0.024318531155586243,
-0.05414048582315445,
0.025734171271324158,
0.0006969703827053308,
-0.050892893224954605,
0.04557185247540474,
0.008926966227591038,
0.021258849650621414,
0.018950877711176872,
0.02196808159351349,
-0.02878735400736332,
-0.020680807530879974,
-0.006096103228628635,
0.031393833458423615,
0.04525768384337425,
0.03643685579299927,
0.0016156542114913464,
-0.018095802515745163,
-0.02046980708837509,
0.0021847342140972614,
0.011883099563419819,
0.02054552175104618,
-0.007095634937286377,
-0.006564602255821228,
-0.015864763408899307,
0.016524402424693108,
0.039813630282878876,
-0.003956228960305452,
0.027606990188360214,
0.038186993449926376,
0.026994768530130386,
-0.01013311930000782,
-0.06127764657139778,
-0.02079019881784916,
-0.001003952231258154,
-0.016514239832758904,
0.008799190632998943,
0.00601130211725831,
-0.004920843988656998,
0.03352779895067215,
-0.01172702293843031,
-0.023001128807663918,
-0.03406869247555733,
-0.016088122501969337,
0.01093824952840805,
-0.03192896768450737,
0.015283811837434769,
-0.059884484857320786,
0.0429980605840683,
0.03161749243736267,
-0.0109989233314991,
-0.038747407495975494,
0.01520334742963314,
-0.047202300280332565,
0.007945919409394264,
0.010588418692350388,
0.01637369580566883,
0.05187808722257614,
0.020960159599781036,
0.0014370772987604141,
0.03035319223999977,
0.017692076042294502,
0.010129472240805626,
-0.023191453889012337,
0.013039054349064827,
-0.04141769930720329,
0.003952525090426207,
0.07791943848133087,
-0.029603667557239532,
0.03730742633342743,
-0.020167309790849686,
-0.05538928881287575,
-0.01675874926149845,
0.03388184681534767,
0.016713036224246025,
0.029299112036824226,
-0.026046568527817726,
-0.02035658247768879,
0.0220772847533226,
-0.015449527651071548,
0.07411706447601318,
-0.010219858027994633,
0.010670671239495277,
0.017345933243632317,
0.055640265345573425,
0.013465533964335918,
0.017306528985500336,
-0.018571823835372925,
-0.06037124991416931,
0.04146254062652588,
0.015491588972508907,
-0.005752166733145714,
-0.028029100969433784,
-0.012394080869853497,
-0.02823864296078682,
-0.023986665531992912,
-0.009090879932045937,
0.03555503115057945,
-0.011701238341629505,
0.009788543917238712,
0.023442847654223442,
-0.0031949765980243683,
0.02883654646575451,
-0.03847651928663254,
0.01914321258664131,
-0.04855194315314293,
-0.007656571455299854,
-0.01996511034667492,
-0.022790534421801567,
0.028759900480508804,
0.0594446063041687,
-0.028569016605615616,
-0.00423061940819025,
0.032681114971637726,
-0.010743062011897564,
-0.005655124317854643,
-0.026331674307584763,
-0.05457821860909462,
0.017549915239214897,
-0.00480893487110734,
-0.0027773126494139433,
0.007662235293537378,
0.030753910541534424,
0.003277296433225274,
0.02000671811401844,
-0.011535965837538242,
0.006685837171971798,
-0.03782736510038376,
-0.04381328448653221,
0.03315085172653198,
-0.010450826026499271,
0.015975622460246086,
0.009553535841405392,
0.06392544507980347,
-0.08816999197006226,
0.012858645059168339,
-0.017351344227790833,
0.002453161869198084,
-0.030098997056484222,
-0.030873995274305344,
0.006168284919112921,
-0.01607329584658146,
0.020577171817421913,
0.060823265463113785,
0.013253571465611458,
-0.009017754346132278,
0.03142842650413513,
0.024449558928608894,
-0.010717985220253468,
0.012525996193289757,
-0.017592933028936386,
0.035685162991285324,
-0.05003048852086067,
-0.00255778175778687,
-0.01876751333475113,
0.011426589451730251,
0.010332383215427399,
-0.009752992540597916,
0.0028899856843054295,
-0.015222510322928429,
-0.010284563526511192,
0.00983467698097229,
-0.003230447182431817,
0.033646631985902786,
-0.009224982000887394,
-0.006893856450915337,
0.019982654601335526,
0.024448856711387634,
0.02571067214012146,
0.004606420639902353,
0.013088936917483807,
0.013486118987202644,
-0.016644539311528206,
0.009405302815139294,
-0.051085464656353,
-0.05244976654648781,
0.03709171712398529,
-0.04175989702343941,
0.02335403487086296,
0.011079062707722187,
0.025306062772870064,
0.016024895012378693,
0.04096473753452301,
0.02078901417553425,
0.014948196709156036,
0.0031606985721737146,
0.009449293836951256,
0.03697989508509636,
0.03132820501923561,
0.013208200223743916,
0.04938807338476181,
-0.04559725522994995,
0.043916329741477966,
0.04456714168190956,
-0.02991974726319313,
-0.024385811761021614,
0.020085232332348824,
-0.00427968380972743,
-0.02676473930478096,
0.01797759160399437,
0.049011800438165665,
-0.01863761991262436,
-0.06944867223501205,
-0.054799020290374756,
-0.04044594243168831,
-0.15311332046985626,
-0.009603973478078842,
0.004509177524596453,
0.016898132860660553,
0.002410001354292035,
0.010821543633937836,
-0.029807524755597115,
-0.0068914759904146194,
-0.030878322198987007,
0.015456417575478554,
-0.01145676989108324,
-0.0443282425403595,
-0.05525331571698189,
0.02510778233408928,
0.01636131852865219,
-0.028269406408071518,
0.002423622878268361,
0.02200106903910637,
0.026790449395775795,
-0.011923969723284245,
0.012536590918898582,
-0.04548487439751625,
0.032580699771642685,
0.010974726639688015,
-0.012587303295731544,
-0.0011567106703296304,
0.008564210496842861,
0.01925625652074814,
-0.04224398359656334,
0.00011497980449348688,
-0.01860041171312332,
0.015009317547082901,
-0.0211475882679224,
0.04848412051796913,
0.013084563426673412,
0.04952868074178696,
0.06140103563666344,
-0.043080300092697144,
-0.033814217895269394,
-0.029460495337843895,
0.03485601767897606,
0.03568851575255394,
0.009697402827441692,
0.03289669752120972,
-0.001969721633940935,
-0.03252771496772766,
-0.001073474995791912,
-0.016767950728535652,
0.013315708376467228,
0.013887129724025726,
-0.00037434781552292407,
0.031205667182803154,
-0.023750964552164078,
-0.04740007221698761,
0.02792799286544323,
-0.032643578946590424,
0.059495169669389725,
0.006601006258279085,
-0.01237232144922018,
-0.055278897285461426,
-0.01641896553337574,
-0.06431765854358673,
-0.009071986190974712,
0.00936403963714838,
0.0026277629658579826,
0.009705659933388233,
-0.0015908932546153665,
-0.03209904953837395,
0.02816779352724552,
0.01318244356662035,
0.009678429923951626,
-0.0001370360841974616,
-0.0026426096446812153,
-0.004855722188949585,
0.02789870649576187,
0.049671564251184464,
-0.06722185015678406,
-0.012329533696174622,
-0.021672919392585754,
-0.09551529586315155,
0.014662951231002808,
0.05816294625401497,
-0.01458248682320118,
0.013227690942585468,
0.010608340613543987,
0.04280400276184082,
0.04533799737691879,
0.04717124626040459,
0.012227922677993774,
0.2617984116077423,
-0.016269898042082787,
0.016957612708210945,
0.021471677348017693,
0.016282817348837852,
-0.03528115153312683,
0.007917682640254498,
0.031377408653497696,
0.010767263360321522,
-0.04557625204324722,
-0.03093242272734642,
-0.029280101880431175,
0.019051887094974518,
0.036880724132061005,
-0.022954870015382767,
0.018305784091353416,
-0.04107851907610893,
-0.006743577308952808,
0.06064046546816826,
-0.003474364522844553,
0.029886221513152122,
0.01434369571506977,
0.004487560596317053,
-0.03038785792887211,
-0.04578253999352455,
-0.0267495084553957,
0.01981739141047001,
0.047611214220523834,
-0.047239430248737335,
0.021320657804608345,
-0.005461258348077536,
0.005303633399307728,
0.039769504219293594,
-0.017443183809518814,
0.022965263575315475,
0.014042767696082592,
-0.023891033604741096,
0.003533652750775218,
0.008381403982639313,
0.05339588224887848,
-0.020536674186587334,
-0.03608323633670807,
0.005849071778357029,
-0.03564586862921715,
-0.032695889472961426,
0.031557273119688034,
-0.033655792474746704,
0.0030242165084928274,
-0.028827443718910217,
0.031944096088409424,
-0.014638411812484264,
0.048742711544036865,
-0.01432675402611494,
-0.005484388209879398,
-0.021186700090765953,
0.023178212344646454,
-0.0251360721886158,
0.04377538710832596,
0.01960097812116146,
0.0555875338613987,
-0.007175832521170378,
0.04020865634083748,
-0.03125445172190666,
0.03897567465901375,
-0.0031543499790132046,
-0.03175853565335274,
-0.03635696321725845,
-0.03619895130395889,
0.03153962641954422,
0.021120233461260796,
0.04256506636738777,
0.03556814789772034,
-0.01097896695137024,
-0.013066009618341923,
0.029901940375566483,
-0.010756268166005611,
-0.018577268347144127,
-0.01478527020663023,
-0.01734531670808792,
-0.0008451880421489477,
-0.030741015449166298,
-0.04669486731290817,
-0.01278235949575901,
0.02357395738363266,
0.01676977425813675,
0.005635743495076895,
-0.03237853944301605,
0.020633338019251823,
-0.033877402544021606,
-0.038633473217487335,
-0.03360328450798988,
0.00063187291380018,
-0.003340169321745634,
-0.02703571319580078,
-0.009458918124437332,
-0.012852274812757969,
0.01562013290822506,
0.0009426683536730707,
-0.04136144369840622,
-0.054399389773607254,
0.014953958801925182,
0.008924628607928753,
0.03901427984237671,
-0.03121323511004448,
0.019942522048950195,
-0.00008297916792798787,
-0.030545944347977638,
0.011736862361431122,
-0.05384109914302826,
0.026588935405015945,
-0.0042120409198105335,
0.016424104571342468,
-0.019223716109991074,
-0.009119517169892788,
0.037837471812963486,
0.06474210321903229,
-0.01421311590820551,
0.05972303822636604,
0.019734743982553482,
0.07185637950897217,
0.00852832943201065,
-0.024523383006453514,
-0.027428407222032547,
0.005857022013515234,
0.006425757426768541,
0.007928663864731789,
-0.04721391946077347,
-0.007836917415261269,
0.019937172532081604,
-0.007058223243802786,
0.03318826109170914,
-0.01911652833223343,
-0.03442709892988205,
0.030118321999907494,
0.05078819766640663,
0.019283588975667953,
0.010365610010921955,
0.012608956545591354,
-0.056233812123537064,
0.04794737696647644,
-0.04767196625471115,
0.011776154860854149,
-0.037470053881406784,
-0.011964928358793259,
-0.0008840012014843524,
0.01462864875793457,
-0.06643059849739075,
0.012755810283124447,
-0.02495461516082287,
-0.006536069326102734,
0.024800557643175125,
-0.007699460256844759,
-0.055527765303850174,
-0.04213869944214821,
0.006569684948772192,
0.004273167811334133,
-0.02782459184527397,
-0.008627759292721748,
0.02740761637687683,
-0.030193060636520386,
-0.019914202392101288,
0.03011350706219673,
0.018284177407622337,
0.0021977864671498537,
-0.009017067961394787,
0.07199273258447647,
-0.00912958849221468,
0.04415110871195793,
0.033477913588285446,
-0.028897898271679878,
-0.05795231834053993,
-0.0629223883152008,
-0.01383894681930542,
0.06102679669857025,
0.01063424814492464,
0.04653983563184738,
0.017162062227725983,
0.006729573011398315,
0.0009294364717788994,
-0.024773992598056793,
0.023452937602996826,
-0.020400874316692352,
-0.030017677694559097,
-0.0034163445234298706,
0.0070173772983253,
-0.0006244688993319869,
-0.013357528485357761,
-0.02283531241118908,
0.05485323444008827,
-0.07106467336416245,
0.017079444602131844,
0.05548817664384842,
-0.0013708565384149551,
-0.022922048345208168,
0.0059013403952121735,
-0.006539858877658844,
0.0017572682118043303,
0.031035801395773888,
-0.01867459900677204,
-0.022455845028162003,
-0.015082411468029022,
0.009723440743982792,
0.010317198932170868,
-0.014566854573786259,
0.015399538911879063,
0.009190714918076992,
0.022367723286151886,
0.05405953526496887,
-0.06564424932003021,
-0.019638201221823692,
0.04257705435156822,
0.01930703967809677,
-0.02144073322415352,
0.017527051270008087,
0.01632029376924038,
-0.03271940350532532,
0.005794265773147345,
0.046482428908348083,
0.005959047004580498,
-0.034781135618686676,
-0.005723945330828428,
-0.019531182944774628,
0.030293436720967293,
-0.05366945266723633,
-0.02091148868203163,
-0.0022906234953552485,
-0.043209366500377655,
-0.01336809154599905,
-0.022963784635066986,
0.015653768554329872,
-0.008185287937521935,
-0.08061854541301727,
0.08526141941547394,
-0.0816863551735878,
-0.006729403976351023,
-0.005010591354221106,
0.028262609615921974,
-0.005748077295720577,
0.013632296584546566,
-0.04350300133228302,
0.03611868619918823,
-0.05276056006550789,
-0.003559662727639079,
0.02834201790392399,
-0.011282641440629959,
-0.02683958038687706,
-0.033470917493104935,
0.005578840617090464,
0.04356757551431656,
0.039912134408950806,
0.01669931225478649,
0.022797802463173866,
0.007896293886005878,
-0.005788575392216444,
0.013539168052375317,
0.022523660212755203,
0.025915348902344704,
-0.041113175451755524,
-0.03211023285984993,
-0.03340674936771393,
-0.01494381483644247,
0.024844972416758537,
-0.015250703319907188,
-0.020245181396603584,
-0.03912211209535599,
-0.041188690811395645,
0.015191887505352497,
0.0005874860216863453,
-0.0281171053647995,
-0.018233904615044594,
-0.004423157311975956,
-0.010779736563563347,
-0.00982994306832552,
-0.03543778136372566,
0.010901977308094501,
-0.020681004971265793,
-0.0005006190040148795,
-0.009894096292555332,
0.029080016538500786,
0.025247368961572647,
0.008843592368066311,
-0.020247312262654305,
0.04508375748991966,
0.028415044769644737,
-0.015241498127579689,
0.04720847308635712,
0.011127011850476265,
0.009286629036068916,
0.01844608783721924,
0.007737125735729933,
0.007945607416331768,
-0.006467452272772789,
-0.030784552916884422,
0.022820794954895973,
0.0029847752302885056,
-0.01207694225013256,
-0.003444839734584093,
0.06758442521095276,
-0.010757862590253353,
0.020132947713136673,
-0.02274874784052372,
-0.019408078864216805,
-0.026188675314188004,
-0.030921485275030136,
-0.04987291619181633,
-0.00479168863967061,
0.006677480414509773,
0.005269452463835478,
-0.030280744656920433,
0.002359621226787567,
0.03300317004323006,
-0.0891370177268982,
0.029022496193647385,
-0.00629264023154974,
0.027359643951058388,
-0.00770898163318634,
0.015383739024400711,
-0.000048506062739761546,
-0.029381759464740753,
0.015012476593255997,
0.010851672850549221,
-0.021048080176115036,
-0.07052739709615707,
0.01949736848473549,
-0.04837764799594879,
-0.005540995858609676,
0.020493900403380394,
-0.04717063903808594,
-0.04021108150482178,
0.011629799380898476,
0.007178586907684803,
-0.02632325142621994,
0.004299398511648178,
0.0009458608692511916,
0.04927034303545952,
0.021301258355379105,
-0.013788165524601936,
-0.0020799473859369755,
0.015016768127679825,
-0.033001355826854706,
-0.003388775046914816,
-0.07112446427345276,
0.0738464891910553,
-0.008273852989077568,
0.0027286603581160307,
0.013487964868545532,
0.009610671550035477,
0.009431874379515648,
0.024809222668409348,
0.0133914053440094,
-0.009912359528243542,
0.04509054124355316,
0.0017851360607892275,
-0.05766959488391876,
-0.009870053268969059,
0.0066953315399587154,
-0.02412899024784565,
0.016811547800898552,
-0.00482318177819252,
-0.027913574129343033,
-0.02079656347632408,
0.03801225498318672,
0.03625606372952461,
0.005063993856310844,
-0.030991654843091965,
-0.0179783683270216,
-0.012313570827245712,
0.037194136530160904,
0.014499197714030743,
0.011504702270030975,
0.003256571479141712,
-0.018299587070941925,
0.008423692546784878,
-0.011616873554885387,
-0.052164897322654724,
0.04991607740521431,
0.03205622360110283,
0.041800353676080704,
-0.019234154373407364,
-0.04191119596362114,
-0.003966779448091984,
-0.02490387111902237,
0.005876949522644281,
-0.023566409945487976,
0.04405707120895386,
-0.019952155649662018,
-0.023668738082051277,
0.002360159531235695,
0.020044492557644844,
-0.0007632933557033539,
-0.0058182599022984505,
0.031725119799375534,
-0.022869011387228966,
0.010691938921809196,
-0.14207202196121216,
-0.02414872869849205,
-0.008663712069392204,
-0.04875897988677025,
-0.031038401648402214,
-0.006524490192532539,
-0.0185445137321949,
-0.0007332430104725063,
-0.02942303940653801,
-0.0039986209012568,
-0.012094524689018726,
-0.004850790370255709,
0.008705542422831059,
-0.022663360461592674,
-0.04293535649776459,
0.03007180243730545,
-0.06344912201166153,
0.006574767641723156,
-0.07923511415719986,
-0.009356450289487839,
0.016613192856311798,
0.010321682319045067,
0.013975227251648903,
-0.009561621583998203,
0.04688781872391701,
-0.005048481281846762,
-0.004438695497810841,
-0.029258163645863533,
-0.03151770308613777,
-0.020182717591524124,
-0.029609380289912224,
-0.003149706171825528,
-0.014081309549510479,
0.08571480214595795,
-0.03734954074025154,
0.0018674002494663,
0.024555038660764694,
-0.016888214275240898,
-0.01829097792506218,
0.007246662396937609,
-0.013932880014181137,
0.02284875325858593,
-0.02707510255277157,
-0.024669010192155838,
-0.0007022296776995063,
0.031439654529094696,
-0.007014372851699591,
-0.017280740663409233,
-0.06056679040193558,
-0.02629389800131321,
-0.04601309821009636,
0.03143942728638649,
0.015785258263349533,
0.04400477930903435,
-0.013943818397819996,
-0.022402102127671242,
-0.0015603845240548253,
-0.023891635239124298,
0.02607482112944126,
0.049654386937618256,
0.016599662601947784,
0.010941608808934689,
-0.056308992207050323,
-0.004659570753574371,
-0.04946642369031906,
0.0006459716241806746,
-0.02163412980735302,
-0.0074428110383450985,
-0.03544125705957413,
0.004677838645875454,
-0.011201191693544388,
-0.012592930346727371,
0.00022375304251909256,
-0.04387626424431801,
0.02630540356040001,
-0.029716607183218002,
-0.002019230043515563,
0.005384939722716808,
-0.029701579362154007,
-0.01703656278550625,
-0.03455587103962898,
-0.005559361539781094,
-0.07021576166152954,
0.009468607604503632,
0.07626331597566605,
0.05312336981296539,
-0.018522154539823532,
-0.02081102877855301,
0.016178270801901817,
-0.048295650631189346,
-0.051633406430482864,
-0.0155953299254179,
-0.012053903192281723,
0.061482202261686325,
-0.014863653108477592,
0.029864447191357613,
-0.014433828182518482,
-0.006924915127456188,
0.010186892002820969,
0.013589304871857166,
-0.037408649921417236,
0.002340971725061536,
0.01400470919907093,
-0.014465950429439545,
-0.02605857327580452,
-0.025725552812218666,
0.008455954492092133,
0.006728257052600384,
0.024563247337937355,
-0.045500487089157104,
-0.020276708528399467,
0.003510798094794154,
-0.019578583538532257,
0.04448694363236427,
-0.07034269720315933,
0.002036225749179721,
0.02288931980729103,
-0.013580440543591976,
0.013532711192965508,
-0.007454249542206526,
0.009779820218682289,
0.011778776533901691,
0.028873590752482414,
-0.016326846554875374,
0.022659821435809135,
-0.01174249593168497,
0.06527657061815262,
0.043102603405714035,
0.03574134036898613,
0.003501278581097722,
0.03446102887392044,
-0.023493630811572075,
0.007470617536455393,
0.02626749686896801,
-0.002376911463215947,
0.025455912575125694,
-0.007986717857420444,
0.00741280522197485,
-0.024293078109622,
-0.02206517569720745,
-0.014907201752066612,
0.003415954066440463,
-0.010043923743069172,
0.014157307334244251,
-0.05723637342453003,
-0.012305946089327335,
0.024924101307988167,
-0.030313201248645782,
-0.01158418133854866,
-0.009935722686350346,
-0.0007210036856122315,
0.02688179723918438,
0.0243823379278183,
0.013684116303920746,
0.0133913429453969,
-0.0034066778607666492,
0.04256058856844902,
-0.016963712871074677,
0.05128033459186554,
0.04006373509764671,
0.007544923108071089,
-0.04629327356815338,
-0.05065389350056648,
-0.04835835099220276,
-0.029289983212947845,
0.02600632980465889,
-0.016787651926279068,
-0.002136280294507742,
-0.03823528066277504,
-0.03458935022354126,
-0.013379892334342003,
0.03715290129184723,
-0.022093692794442177,
0.02184070460498333,
0.04417767748236656,
-0.018355291336774826,
-0.014174535870552063,
0.0007769755320623517,
0.051355890929698944,
-0.011772182770073414,
0.054114483296871185,
0.01980665512382984,
0.00719944154843688,
-0.02855212613940239,
-0.022898131981492043,
0.015800757333636284,
0.01603979803621769,
0.022493842989206314,
-0.024317199364304543,
-0.03511771559715271,
-0.03830369561910629,
0.00003227413253625855,
0.026579800993204117,
-0.022380638867616653,
0.003534166142344475,
0.033256735652685165,
-0.0028659524396061897,
0.024723412469029427,
0.010823431424796581,
0.038064632564783096,
0.023744000121951103,
-0.014250685460865498,
-0.014294983819127083,
-0.01991243287920952,
-0.006800875999033451,
0.024690469726920128,
-0.013468166813254356,
-0.04916195198893547,
-0.033459778875112534,
0.06943251937627792,
-0.01492287963628769,
-0.019490566104650497,
-0.017515648156404495,
0.021056659519672394,
-0.017334353178739548,
0.023570070043206215,
0.050349682569503784,
0.0014463051920756698,
0.05284088850021362,
-0.016637226566672325,
0.022800026461482048,
0.044162120670080185,
-0.011245006695389748,
-0.021657496690750122,
-0.007650391664355993,
-0.011867101304233074,
-0.005371810868382454,
0.010953937657177448,
-0.01285130437463522,
0.03801445662975311,
-0.024398749694228172,
0.017191799357533455,
-0.01352665014564991,
0.04814283549785614,
-0.010560501366853714,
-0.007116569671779871,
-0.015142268501222134,
-0.017753753811120987,
-0.016733741387724876,
-0.02641141228377819,
0.0323454849421978,
0.0076726144179701805,
0.004924362059682608,
-0.007204160559922457
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:51
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"On the Monday [30 August 2004] I think I called [Mr Moir] and asked him, 'I have got the caveat, can I come down?', and he said - we had a discussion, some short discussion, and it was agreed that when, after I had gone up to the Supreme Court with the settlement consent orders that I would go to the Land Titles Office and lodge it for him. The client was ignorant of those arrangements".
770Mr Gillard's reference to going to the Supreme Court "with the settlement consent orders" is reference to the fact, on 30 August 2004 he attended the Court Registry "re approval of short minutes". This is recorded in Mr Gillard's time costing printouts.
771Thereafter Mr Gillard personally attended what he described as the Land Titles Office (now Land and Property Information), and lodged the Withdrawal of Caveat for registration.
772Mr Gillard did not deliver the Withdrawal of Caveat to Swaab Attorneys or Mr Moir. He did not, as he told Mr Hilliard he would, have a "separate settlement" with Mr Moir at which he handed over the Withdrawal of Caveat.
He did not exchange the Withdrawal of Caveat for the foreshadowed cheque for $4.5 million. He simply complied with Mr Moir's direction to lodge the Withdrawal of Caveat at the Land Titles Office.
773In my opinion, he thereby acted in breach of his undertaking to Mr Hilliard.
774However, in my opinion, for the reasons I have set out above, this had nothing to do with the decision of Mr Zdrilic to cause the plaintiffs to enter the Non-Dilution Deed. Nor did it have anything to do with Mr Hilliard and Mr Zdrilic's decision to commit LEC to the Short Minutes of Order.
Final version IPC Head of Agreement Produced
775On 1 September the final version of the IPC Heads of Agreement was produced to Mr Hilliard and to Mr Zdrilic.
776Mr Zdrilic agreed that he had sought to look at this agreement, because it would show the arrangements between HTT and the funder.
777It will be recalled that on 25 August 2004 Mr Hilliard had made a note that Mr Zdrilic had told him that:-
"There is a document between HTT & Funder".
778Mr Zdrilic said that he did not look at the document with great care but that he did notice the provision in annexure "A" to the document stipulating that settlement of the transactions with the New Zealand funder would not take place until 28 days after the issue of a development approval.
It will be recalled that as early as 2 March 2004 Mr Zdrilic had told Mr Hilliard that Mr Renshall had told him that funds were "conditional on re-zoning".
779Mr Zdrilic knew that there had been no re-zoning and yet he was neither dismayed or surprised to read this.
780In these circumstances the HTT Defendants submit:-
"Mr Zdrilic's indifference to the arrangements between HTT and its funder reveals the reality - on 27 August, no representation was made which conveyed (expressly or impliedly) any assurance (as distinct to hopes) that funds would come in the short term; moreover, if any such assurance had been given, Mr Zdrilic certainty did not rely upon it in settling the substantive transactions."
781It seems to me there was substance in these submissions.
782Mr Hilliard also read the final version of the IPC Heads of Agreement and saw that IPC's acquisition of its interests in HTT might not take place until re-zoning and agreed that:-
"...a large sum of money that might be paid from the New Zealand funder to Huntley - to HTT under this agreement might not be paid until a long way down the track...or ever, if there was no re-zoning."
Consent orders made 6 September 2004
783As I have mentioned, 27 August 2004 was a Friday. Accordingly, if IPC was to make available $4.5 million "next week" that would have to occur between Monday 30 August and Friday 3 September 2004.
784Mr Hilliard's time costing records contain a entry for Thursday 2 September 2004:-
|
[
-0.04890578240156174,
0.021432124078273773,
-0.0314214825630188,
0.030993809923529625,
-0.0033256295137107372,
-0.03582199662923813,
0.009047204628586769,
-0.023203007876873016,
-0.019547272473573685,
0.02806468866765499,
-0.005798602011054754,
0.01924053579568863,
-0.02914457395672798,
0.0061904084868729115,
-0.017808597534894943,
-0.012433169409632683,
0.033407460898160934,
-0.002416511531919241,
0.027229519560933113,
-0.01123559009283781,
-0.012372870929539204,
-0.049528494477272034,
-0.00580277293920517,
0.01950807496905327,
-0.02714919112622738,
-0.020267121493816376,
-0.012235516682267189,
0.03454182296991348,
0.02198861353099346,
0.034072667360305786,
-0.003580333199352026,
0.003939793910831213,
0.04601549357175827,
-0.0038389009423553944,
-0.021956058219075203,
-0.020051375031471252,
0.04216582328081131,
-0.016325153410434723,
-0.03194807469844818,
0.01170643512159586,
-0.02908678539097309,
0.020268499851226807,
0.002273712307214737,
-0.03137528523802757,
0.047831080853939056,
-0.030268298462033272,
-0.013354916125535965,
-0.009158347733318806,
0.018040824681520462,
0.03285028412938118,
-0.018284402787685394,
-0.02361913211643696,
0.01882559433579445,
-0.04585631936788559,
-0.02077377401292324,
-0.022261343896389008,
-0.011644333600997925,
0.007820501923561096,
-0.02954370528459549,
-0.0009756345534697175,
0.011393820866942406,
0.0018254327587783337,
-0.04131088778376579,
0.015979574993252754,
0.002855714876204729,
0.10604765266180038,
0.01578102447092533,
0.01606339029967785,
-0.004678377881646156,
-0.018260570243000984,
-0.03503573313355446,
0.012232699431478977,
-0.011155445128679276,
-0.010459739714860916,
-0.09392879158258438,
0.026301346719264984,
0.013136528432369232,
-0.033766504377126694,
0.009504170157015324,
0.019316140562295914,
0.05108994245529175,
-0.026773463934659958,
0.013881364837288857,
0.03971152752637863,
-0.030710160732269287,
0.012075495906174183,
-0.013658341020345688,
0.030499473214149475,
0.0122806616127491,
-0.005875278264284134,
0.0005448698066174984,
-0.006780269555747509,
0.030006688088178635,
-0.043982088565826416,
-0.023049263283610344,
-0.020138494670391083,
-0.04512860253453255,
0.035265225917100906,
-0.01250949501991272,
0.01380197238177061,
0.011231222189962864,
0.030503500252962112,
0.0068130106665194035,
-0.013708296231925488,
0.03735259175300598,
0.0383763425052166,
0.02703770063817501,
0.023980777710676193,
0.0012633763253688812,
-0.011866801418364048,
0.003853755770251155,
-0.017810314893722534,
0.02846354804933071,
-0.0031180507503449917,
-0.005148779600858688,
-0.01344283763319254,
-0.004985259845852852,
-0.004073377698659897,
0.031496934592723846,
-0.001066747703589499,
0.06822129338979721,
0.0397798977792263,
0.020162848755717278,
-0.022959841415286064,
-0.038035713136196136,
0.01900376006960869,
0.03764333948493004,
-0.03160454332828522,
0.01393113937228918,
0.032612018287181854,
0.01562182791531086,
0.04956205561757088,
-0.02559896931052208,
-0.027678661048412323,
-0.02046326920390129,
-0.03149928152561188,
0.00482433196157217,
-0.010888218879699707,
0.005950981751084328,
-0.0976659432053566,
0.03032722882926464,
0.012494727969169617,
0.0232317466288805,
-0.06194144859910011,
0.04464239999651909,
-0.03226722404360771,
-0.024315712973475456,
-0.00107347103767097,
-0.006557506043463945,
0.0246728602796793,
0.0033212064299732447,
0.012646547518670559,
-0.002423317637294531,
-0.012423689477145672,
0.0398903526365757,
-0.05743108689785004,
-0.03284767270088196,
0.007533939555287361,
0.014279929921030998,
0.06508179754018784,
-0.013940886594355106,
0.016275973990559578,
0.005061648786067963,
0.0028415864799171686,
-0.021053699776530266,
-0.01507790107280016,
-0.009278961457312107,
0.02848844788968563,
0.004066441208124161,
-0.02312404289841652,
0.026500822976231575,
-0.010757047683000565,
0.05795689672231674,
-0.006443653721362352,
0.00824236124753952,
0.03176984190940857,
0.08227632939815521,
-0.008230681531131268,
0.009872966445982456,
-0.01811983995139599,
-0.038959212601184845,
0.04306621477007866,
0.010619327425956726,
-0.03979875147342682,
-0.04683614894747734,
0.035612985491752625,
-0.03176150098443031,
-0.028290722519159317,
-0.004020958207547665,
0.0211460143327713,
0.005501433275640011,
0.0003032063541468233,
0.01500660553574562,
0.04529889300465584,
0.0032914059702306986,
-0.012161166407167912,
-0.006317773833870888,
-0.026216037571430206,
0.003199297236278653,
0.012837295420467854,
-0.059042975306510925,
0.0331856943666935,
0.04181752726435661,
-0.008282431401312351,
-0.034126557409763336,
0.010190845467150211,
-0.02023841254413128,
-0.026947200298309326,
0.03172321245074272,
-0.05411660298705101,
-0.0031549232080578804,
0.039830438792705536,
-0.000968281296081841,
-0.01941814087331295,
0.03390377759933472,
-0.008298715576529503,
0.0009678032365627587,
-0.011585366912186146,
0.023691250011324883,
-0.027210794389247894,
0.012185007333755493,
-0.0062005240470170975,
-0.01689053885638714,
-0.014627126045525074,
0.0014100538101047277,
0.07737226784229279,
-0.086588054895401,
0.03207219019532204,
-0.0026646105106920004,
-0.0204795952886343,
-0.0037763849832117558,
0.0062007359229028225,
0.00470723956823349,
-0.011595389805734158,
0.029414698481559753,
0.03377657011151314,
-0.02538151666522026,
0.013272562064230442,
0.003182406770065427,
0.010416432283818722,
-0.0068168481811881065,
0.06651390343904495,
-0.012241027317941189,
0.008926586247980595,
-0.0078076086938381195,
-0.013088760897517204,
-0.009395629167556763,
0.015573847107589245,
0.008725420571863651,
-0.02808459848165512,
-0.00595579668879509,
-0.025684084743261337,
0.006136148236691952,
0.03714131936430931,
-0.006520242430269718,
0.03789418190717697,
0.008385795168578625,
-0.010062151588499546,
0.04190285876393318,
0.025709403678774834,
0.042494818568229675,
-0.019646387547254562,
0.034432440996170044,
0.012214251793920994,
-0.01700657606124878,
-0.0032583284191787243,
-0.02669215016067028,
-0.07208825647830963,
0.04408949613571167,
-0.005858039949089289,
0.015736479312181473,
0.008623274974524975,
0.020763026550412178,
0.06367234140634537,
0.007161315996199846,
0.024473635479807854,
0.010031906887888908,
0.02050066739320755,
0.003323004813864827,
0.0021529116202145815,
-0.016441194340586662,
0.005983625538647175,
0.04143866151571274,
-0.03475281223654747,
0.0394330658018589,
0.049419526010751724,
0.007464918307960033,
0.019163057208061218,
0.024898426607251167,
-0.01877199299633503,
-0.02939525805413723,
0.024236628785729408,
0.06975731253623962,
0.00194172456394881,
-0.03134341537952423,
-0.08382510393857956,
-0.019818605855107307,
-0.14414851367473602,
-0.021823108196258545,
-0.017457718029618263,
-0.0069382404908537865,
0.004655826836824417,
0.006627481430768967,
-0.03448529914021492,
-0.011088591068983078,
-0.03592883050441742,
0.014019349589943886,
0.0057103512808680534,
-0.04544297605752945,
0.018559077754616737,
0.047995734959840775,
-0.0015563840279355645,
-0.01868867501616478,
-0.0018817856907844543,
0.004698287229984999,
0.011667401529848576,
-0.037056565284729004,
0.005079666618257761,
-0.06236254796385765,
0.03281335160136223,
-0.009659307077527046,
0.027897924184799194,
0.012920980341732502,
-0.01049599889665842,
0.029672222211956978,
-0.03753683716058731,
-0.008401777595281601,
-0.023718763142824173,
0.01915193535387516,
-0.018059635534882545,
0.05733431130647659,
0.005050930660218,
0.04770241305232048,
0.044540487229824066,
-0.05995689332485199,
0.009543250314891338,
-0.009939507581293583,
0.020267626270651817,
0.041888121515512466,
0.004126057960093021,
0.024777930229902267,
-0.022856315597891808,
-0.07359112054109573,
-0.0010937824845314026,
0.006548295263200998,
0.01998148299753666,
0.036533746868371964,
-0.01976533606648445,
0.0056653982028365135,
-0.01820003055036068,
-0.03815367817878723,
0.006043499335646629,
-0.018758323043584824,
0.012734631076455116,
0.05240791290998459,
-0.02681533247232437,
0.003334332723170519,
-0.020475801080465317,
-0.04116552323102951,
-0.005314312409609556,
0.006818924564868212,
-0.0003257068165112287,
0.016963360831141472,
-0.023201804608106613,
-0.020732523873448372,
0.031009921804070473,
0.04078664630651474,
0.009419625625014305,
-0.0273305531591177,
-0.0009235433535650373,
-0.032878577709198,
0.05851176381111145,
0.05409085750579834,
-0.038136277347803116,
0.0038383733481168747,
-0.015307633206248283,
-0.10135628283023834,
-0.05593698099255562,
0.02671116404235363,
-0.02810141257941723,
0.010313673876225948,
-0.013012932613492012,
0.025474991649389267,
-0.0012672654120251536,
0.04040983319282532,
0.01125762052834034,
0.25630420446395874,
0.0041385493241250515,
-0.009825197048485279,
0.04657017067074776,
0.02249562367796898,
-0.024226276203989983,
0.028275446966290474,
0.05047113820910454,
-0.01283592265099287,
-0.036290884017944336,
0.014423423446714878,
0.005122395697981119,
0.004811800550669432,
0.01213433500379324,
-0.005702116526663303,
0.03514597937464714,
-0.06953368335962296,
-0.020799465477466583,
0.09487710893154144,
-0.018186230212450027,
0.05465184897184372,
-0.0050721969455480576,
-0.0012848678743466735,
-0.020161569118499756,
-0.07909289002418518,
-0.046743243932724,
0.029902180656790733,
0.05789761245250702,
-0.03963233157992363,
-0.012349193915724754,
-0.012386237271130085,
-0.022331275045871735,
0.03493490815162659,
-0.010704796761274338,
0.022115569561719894,
0.03796377032995224,
-0.02265586145222187,
-0.003035235684365034,
-0.008860105648636818,
0.03112976625561714,
0.0002458301605656743,
-0.046784475445747375,
-0.024965139105916023,
-0.05361763387918472,
-0.05044679716229439,
0.0026993330102413893,
-0.019121378660202026,
0.048298075795173645,
-0.043152593076229095,
-0.004302272107452154,
-0.0010656428057700396,
0.04430802911520004,
-0.019882025197148323,
0.0005481496918946505,
-0.026485500857234,
0.04944153130054474,
-0.016801483929157257,
0.0562768317759037,
-0.010498992167413235,
0.02894636243581772,
0.016602130606770515,
0.03603879734873772,
-0.014753478579223156,
0.0021095687989145517,
0.000689841341227293,
0.004712816793471575,
-0.06812872737646103,
0.018791943788528442,
0.07302439212799072,
0.03467252850532532,
0.007976075634360313,
-0.0020495359785854816,
-0.03315398842096329,
0.039072100073099136,
0.030597155913710594,
-0.007337653543800116,
-0.032884594053030014,
0.004455664660781622,
-0.0395989827811718,
-0.004014305770397186,
-0.007209048606455326,
-0.02869597263634205,
-0.009033049456775188,
0.013247333467006683,
0.017240403220057487,
-0.006711809430271387,
-0.014969268813729286,
0.03006344847381115,
-0.026090851053595543,
-0.03897404298186302,
0.003932198043912649,
0.0018494464457035065,
-0.013613814488053322,
-0.03610898181796074,
-0.02237405814230442,
-0.019493287429213524,
0.014547398313879967,
-0.019677605479955673,
-0.042416755110025406,
-0.028347661718726158,
0.008327283896505833,
0.028367862105369568,
0.0072643510065972805,
-0.03881639987230301,
0.01576896570622921,
-0.02185138873755932,
-0.012444576248526573,
0.007881596684455872,
-0.05429333820939064,
0.019813496619462967,
-0.006033293902873993,
0.004399667493999004,
-0.011781184002757072,
0.005525925196707249,
0.05015065148472786,
0.08883081376552582,
-0.0016449784161522985,
0.05642382800579071,
0.0391833633184433,
0.014310406520962715,
-0.005891377571970224,
-0.01652977243065834,
-0.024944530799984932,
-0.005582834128290415,
-0.011924131773412228,
-0.014757052063941956,
-0.016570325940847397,
-0.014057266525924206,
-0.0271794144064188,
0.0033210173714905977,
-0.013959127478301525,
-0.03447708487510681,
-0.033424366265535355,
-0.015130664221942425,
0.043290093541145325,
0.014422372914850712,
0.020002450793981552,
0.0012018062407150865,
-0.04604440554976463,
0.006195297464728355,
-0.04310660436749458,
0.01409225445240736,
-0.020572979003190994,
-0.00030643734498880804,
0.010402858257293701,
-0.008951098658144474,
-0.06652064621448517,
0.027036232873797417,
-0.07116382569074631,
-0.005576943047344685,
0.030816076323390007,
0.032410379499197006,
-0.024663951247930527,
-0.018150202929973602,
0.026982594281435013,
0.013463819399476051,
-0.01593528315424919,
-0.0063088806346058846,
0.011579263024032116,
-0.03975878283381462,
-0.025505606085062027,
0.014866086654365063,
0.011834336444735527,
-0.010699682869017124,
0.03351963311433792,
0.040288541465997696,
-0.014119090512394905,
0.07185660302639008,
0.0357230082154274,
-0.04288347437977791,
-0.005776620004326105,
-0.031552575528621674,
0.001515256823040545,
0.05806704983115196,
0.005416504573076963,
0.03954862058162689,
0.024427710101008415,
0.012504993937909603,
0.020126262679696083,
-0.018869182094931602,
0.034169793128967285,
-0.00008084058936219662,
-0.047948941588401794,
0.0009339810931123793,
-0.015326391905546188,
0.010611485689878464,
-0.020702175796031952,
-0.028211446478962898,
0.06599975377321243,
-0.05570117384195328,
-0.002275279723107815,
0.07938700169324875,
0.047410111874341965,
-0.008502844721078873,
0.011985249817371368,
0.03530779853463173,
-0.004503538832068443,
0.048694368451833725,
-0.014441688545048237,
-0.041639234870672226,
-0.022876927629113197,
-0.01127165649086237,
0.006933359894901514,
-0.0090574836358428,
0.0021407180465757847,
0.019413230940699577,
0.009436771273612976,
0.0592358335852623,
-0.05126870051026344,
0.0070440019480884075,
0.03269263729453087,
-0.003882160410284996,
-0.050394777208566666,
0.01760486513376236,
0.051782429218292236,
-0.024375321343541145,
0.03875438868999481,
0.05499494448304176,
0.03335949033498764,
-0.033965855836868286,
-0.027707766741514206,
-0.01581036113202572,
0.015092418529093266,
-0.05056610703468323,
-0.020229000598192215,
0.0200392734259367,
-0.058849550783634186,
-0.008723607286810875,
-0.0064840903505682945,
-0.006715449038892984,
0.001784116611815989,
-0.0728352889418602,
0.05401211604475975,
-0.0667092427611351,
-0.012626773677766323,
-0.008106387220323086,
0.05973685160279274,
-0.003647954436019063,
0.05889896675944328,
0.008195720613002777,
0.03062627464532852,
-0.02025279775261879,
0.0074394033290445805,
0.00918419286608696,
0.00267079658806324,
0.003319022711366415,
0.0006860521389171481,
-0.025076549500226974,
0.0028608592692762613,
0.04736681282520294,
-0.0006629785057157278,
0.027386384084820747,
-0.002874184399843216,
-0.0065425122156739235,
0.021587928757071495,
0.012855404056608677,
0.04481277987360954,
-0.03178167715668678,
-0.053656402975320816,
-0.03536386415362358,
0.009902875870466232,
0.03754575923085213,
0.004562604706734419,
-0.003762684529647231,
-0.06489075720310211,
-0.06077633425593376,
-0.006614773068577051,
-0.05052033066749573,
-0.01758147031068802,
0.02270614542067051,
0.008416619151830673,
-0.0029213193338364363,
0.008822922594845295,
-0.08595191687345505,
-0.014435824938118458,
0.002840802539139986,
-0.013825138099491596,
0.029751038178801537,
0.00041197321843355894,
0.019168872386217117,
-0.02158009633421898,
0.021530378609895706,
0.03085494413971901,
0.025192085653543472,
-0.018483297899365425,
0.012490116991102695,
-0.02309013530611992,
-0.003448737785220146,
-0.022087818011641502,
-0.018867481499910355,
0.003776775673031807,
-0.005921078380197287,
-0.011880995705723763,
0.011681605130434036,
0.006133138667792082,
-0.03033258579671383,
0.006621167063713074,
0.0018899865681305528,
-0.03125752508640289,
-0.004037417471408844,
-0.02770809456706047,
0.005607983097434044,
-0.033456552773714066,
-0.04104604944586754,
0.009165922179818153,
0.010220563970506191,
0.020137781277298927,
-0.012936036102473736,
-0.035773806273937225,
0.03330995514988899,
0.03484247624874115,
-0.07810938358306885,
-0.0018243653466925025,
-0.008829129859805107,
0.03954993933439255,
0.0035989941097795963,
0.004480848554521799,
0.002388064516708255,
-0.0279487706720829,
0.028174683451652527,
0.03813871368765831,
0.01767847128212452,
-0.05695208162069321,
-0.006548689678311348,
-0.02426091767847538,
-0.0035087892320007086,
0.029670678079128265,
-0.029692918062210083,
-0.028191955760121346,
0.00981858093291521,
-0.04281331226229668,
-0.016302097588777542,
0.026477990671992302,
-0.015096794813871384,
0.009471748024225235,
0.024586360901594162,
0.0029062526300549507,
0.02998608723282814,
0.026223575696349144,
-0.036556169390678406,
-0.024775557219982147,
-0.0392407663166523,
0.04554418474435806,
0.0029163993895053864,
-0.00475070858374238,
-0.014540127478539944,
0.006829201243817806,
-0.020842423662543297,
0.01291241217404604,
0.02235584706068039,
-0.03670745715498924,
0.0014478074153885245,
-0.007252426352351904,
-0.030280878767371178,
0.0029103029519319534,
0.00646766135469079,
0.0092119500041008,
0.011154856532812119,
0.020257847383618355,
-0.000027140624297317117,
0.005542634986341,
0.02890954352915287,
0.012706564739346504,
-0.02423921413719654,
-0.005829830188304186,
-0.013383057899773121,
-0.017809979617595673,
0.038873765617609024,
0.0022084233351051807,
0.033581625670194626,
0.017608197405934334,
-0.028838565573096275,
-0.0010060687782242894,
-0.01202712394297123,
-0.04662414640188217,
0.010292318649590015,
0.010715716518461704,
0.017404472455382347,
-0.011630842462182045,
-0.08124954253435135,
-0.008723574690520763,
-0.030521778389811516,
-0.037050507962703705,
-0.024897299706935883,
0.016791919246315956,
0.00005451682227430865,
0.007320899982005358,
0.024951204657554626,
0.01322897244244814,
0.009444541297852993,
-0.0046571954153478146,
-0.0056082881055772305,
-0.04394340142607689,
-0.014949576929211617,
-0.14313752949237823,
-0.005015090573579073,
0.0016965997638180852,
-0.040354128926992416,
-0.017916763201355934,
0.0181268360465765,
-0.035237375646829605,
0.004381874576210976,
-0.026994099840521812,
-0.017150772735476494,
-0.016565369442105293,
-0.012036838568747044,
0.011560727842152119,
-0.016460901126265526,
-0.020719511434435844,
0.004938023630529642,
-0.029848694801330566,
-0.006970491260290146,
-0.06192624196410179,
0.03262327238917351,
0.02898208424448967,
0.005466924514621496,
0.015053941868245602,
-0.01921311393380165,
0.024871092289686203,
-0.015993326902389526,
-0.024251814931631088,
-0.054651666432619095,
-0.056272126734256744,
-0.0495552234351635,
-0.056431740522384644,
0.0022670566104352474,
-0.008796453475952148,
0.07927127182483673,
-0.015975236892700195,
0.03560712933540344,
0.01668502762913704,
-0.03737682104110718,
-0.00885115098208189,
-0.01080347876995802,
0.00003888296487275511,
0.0386841744184494,
-0.022215289995074272,
0.0014882554532960057,
-0.02554423175752163,
0.013149328529834747,
-0.016854051500558853,
0.0015410593478009105,
-0.07657071202993393,
-0.04865163937211037,
-0.030927980318665504,
0.005123118404299021,
0.001501619117334485,
0.05038575455546379,
0.0020956210792064667,
0.004447804298251867,
0.020541060715913773,
-0.013476859778165817,
0.05789666250348091,
0.03493522107601166,
0.02349894866347313,
-0.0043819863349199295,
-0.0760028213262558,
-0.004372257273644209,
-0.04852219671010971,
-0.026237880811095238,
-0.019570082426071167,
-0.008531809784471989,
0.007596613839268684,
0.03973855823278427,
-0.025418180972337723,
0.017255913466215134,
0.013359036296606064,
-0.015866346657276154,
0.015019970946013927,
-0.0532497838139534,
0.02393212728202343,
-0.0021412670612335205,
-0.03843195363879204,
-0.007441164925694466,
-0.00905007403343916,
-0.0107627147808671,
-0.06462130695581436,
-0.029270058497786522,
0.05104156956076622,
0.0557827465236187,
0.008238627575337887,
0.002303679008036852,
0.002634804230183363,
-0.039967749267816544,
-0.02797034941613674,
-0.006686783395707607,
0.009490038268268108,
0.058529775589704514,
0.003912881016731262,
0.011546725407242775,
0.00016497580509167165,
0.0004473402223084122,
-0.01835697516798973,
0.0001793295523384586,
-0.043893929570913315,
-0.03866155818104744,
-0.01150134950876236,
-0.001618697657249868,
-0.020240075886249542,
-0.0037299073301255703,
0.047597985714673996,
0.01335414219647646,
0.004687310196459293,
-0.008236139081418514,
-0.008977945894002914,
-0.009163971059024334,
-0.04489947482943535,
0.010933252982795238,
-0.047029606997966766,
-0.018188172951340675,
0.014124302193522453,
-0.0009336965158581734,
-0.01083869207650423,
0.011575652286410332,
-0.016964728012681007,
-0.021751565858721733,
0.007167736534029245,
-0.030083172023296356,
0.039628855884075165,
0.026928773149847984,
0.08383847773075104,
0.02576453424990177,
0.05558457598090172,
-0.00782803911715746,
0.017317982390522957,
0.01974417455494404,
0.021021997556090355,
0.0049618082121014595,
0.013356003910303116,
0.0013277643593028188,
0.004392866976559162,
0.014026524499058723,
-0.04973849654197693,
-0.00009326623694505543,
0.010540797375142574,
0.0028054621070623398,
-0.013995615765452385,
0.0042486852034926414,
-0.04291938245296478,
-0.0012542959302663803,
0.043915923684835434,
-0.0016822459874674678,
-0.0215618796646595,
-0.012116880156099796,
-0.01759510114789009,
-0.00626436248421669,
-0.011910954490303993,
0.024910109117627144,
0.023877520114183426,
-0.004649776965379715,
0.022851623594760895,
0.013931318186223507,
0.023415515199303627,
0.027183758094906807,
-0.005655626766383648,
-0.055477794259786606,
-0.034881845116615295,
-0.06523831933736801,
-0.027991481125354767,
0.03135022521018982,
-0.023119591176509857,
0.02492751181125641,
-0.029435670003294945,
-0.018029799684882164,
-0.022384867072105408,
0.007144540082663298,
0.002169091021642089,
0.027232108637690544,
0.04156264290213585,
-0.010617288760840893,
-0.006920497864484787,
0.0037526809610426426,
0.05028702691197395,
-0.02755892649292946,
0.04118230193853378,
0.05489206686615944,
0.013600476086139679,
0.00047396504669450223,
0.04927052557468414,
0.03755028918385506,
0.0054967948235571384,
0.01363645400851965,
-0.020666023716330528,
-0.025481464341282845,
-0.00417108042165637,
-0.00010825368372024968,
-0.0093115558847785,
0.009375644847750664,
0.022798558697104454,
0.004359908867627382,
-0.013744513504207134,
0.002076400676742196,
-0.002487429417669773,
0.04854443296790123,
0.055645931512117386,
-0.033209290355443954,
-0.01800735667347908,
-0.027683310210704803,
-0.010226793587207794,
0.016711188480257988,
-0.02763989008963108,
-0.06754147261381149,
-0.05639154464006424,
0.05693742632865906,
-0.019879411906003952,
0.031592268496751785,
-0.04120739549398422,
0.05235580727458,
-0.027972789481282234,
0.006705577950924635,
0.008167773485183716,
-0.03139444813132286,
0.03693375736474991,
-0.03643958270549774,
0.018770068883895874,
0.04952417314052582,
-0.014150082133710384,
-0.041195400059223175,
-0.024017922580242157,
0.008495399728417397,
-0.005956736393272877,
-0.001982442568987608,
-0.0012668431736528873,
0.03205377236008644,
-0.0002058806421700865,
0.01775985024869442,
0.0059597487561404705,
0.004751977045089006,
0.015312712639570236,
-0.03521854057908058,
-0.017355358228087425,
-0.011700859293341637,
-0.034352339804172516,
0.0024162863846868277,
0.04907313734292984,
-0.010753551498055458,
0.010232189670205116,
-0.008278979919850826
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:8
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
(f)if Suncorp refuses to extend the facility, and HTT cannot refinance, the Land will have to be sold;
(g)HTT does not have the financial resources to undertake the development of a golf course and residential development on the Land;
(h)HTT currently intends to sell the Land if and when it is rezoned for residential development;
(i)in that regard the planning proposal approved by Wollongong City Council on 12 December 2011 is to be sent to the Department of Planning for consideration by the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure;
(j)even if HTT is able to secure an extension of the Suncorp loan (or refinance that loan) when land filling is completed, it will be unable to make interest payments and the Land will have to be sold to repay the debt; and
(k)HTT has not sought or obtained funding in respect of the potential residential and golf course development of the Land.
Relief claimed
121The plaintiffs claim declarations that the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed have been rescinded by reason of the service of the Caveat lodged by LEC on the title of the Land on 11 October 2006, or alternatively by service of the Statement of Claim in these proceedings on 26 March 2007.
122Alternatively, the plaintiffs seek orders pursuant to the s 87(2) of the Act setting those agreements aside.
123The plaintiffs also seek to set aside an order dismissing the 2001 Proceedings made on 6 September 2004.
124The plaintiffs also claim damages.
125By reason of the order made by Barrett J in these proceedings in Land Enviro Corp Pty Ltd and Others v HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Ltd and Others (2008) 72 NSWLR 160,
the damages that the plaintiffs are able to claim in these proceeds are those they have suffered by reason of their entering into the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed and, the consent given by them to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings.
The plaintiffs' witnesses
126The plaintiffs called two witnesses: Mr Zdrilic and Mr Hilliard.
Mr Hilliard
127At all relevant times, Mr Hilliard was a partner of the law firm TressCox (previously Tress Cocks & Maddox until 2004). Mr Hilliard assumed conduct of the 2001 Proceedings in August 2003.
He acted for the plaintiffs throughout the negotiations to settle the 2001 Proceedings including in relation to the entry by the plaintiffs into the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed and in relation to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings on 6 September 2004.
128Mr Hilliard was admitted as a solicitor in 1977. In 1995 he was given specialist accreditation by the Law Society of New South Wales in the area of "commercial litigation - insolvency".
129Thus, at the time he starting acting in the 2001 Proceedings, he was an experienced solicitor.
130Mr Hilliard kept diary entries in relation to his many dealings with Mr Zdrilic and with other parties, particularly Mr Gillard, the solicitor then acting for the HTT Defendants.
131I have no hesitation in accepting the accuracy and reliability of Mr Hilliard's diary entries. Indeed, Mr Einfeld accepted that they were "unimpeachable".
132Mr Hilliard was cross-examined for approximately two days, over a three-day period.
133Overall, I thought Mr Hilliard gave his evidence honestly and openly in the face of a vigorous cross-examination.
134However, in my opinion, the cross-examination established that, at least on one occasion, Mr Hilliard's account of a conversation with Mr Zdrilic, to the extent it went further than Mr Hilliard's diary entries, was not completely reliable.
135In cross-examination, particular attention was placed on Mr Hilliard's account of a conversation he had with Mr Zdrilic on 13 February 2004 in which, according to his affidavit, Mr Zdrilic made reference to a "big funder (...) coming along".
Those words are significant, as they are ones Mr Zdrilic attributed on a number of occasions to Mr Renshall, in particular in connection with the Second Representation (discussed below), which, according to Mr Zdrilic, was made at around this time.
|
[
-0.042767658829689026,
0.04967302456498146,
-0.027687719091773033,
-0.015547960065305233,
-0.026087747886776924,
-0.05748213082551956,
-0.03819121792912483,
-0.04140780493617058,
0.0070279622450470924,
-0.01011731382459402,
0.012816001661121845,
0.025756075978279114,
-0.03907701373100281,
-0.004970666486769915,
0.011019553989171982,
-0.04641830548644066,
0.03616362437605858,
-0.02441663295030594,
-0.0029298504814505577,
-0.00916649866849184,
-0.035639598965644836,
-0.01556195504963398,
0.011181184090673923,
0.023991385474801064,
-0.04146841913461685,
0.00916983187198639,
-0.04931836575269699,
0.01348027866333723,
0.011770760640501976,
0.0405416339635849,
-0.013548816554248333,
0.0035924857947975397,
0.04268309101462364,
-0.018041757866740227,
-0.02317146398127079,
-0.0485638789832592,
0.03091491013765335,
0.018611202016472816,
-0.04462805762887001,
-0.013702974654734135,
-0.018166985362768173,
0.015187535434961319,
0.02074502408504486,
-0.01297183707356453,
0.05095449835062027,
-0.04820609092712402,
-0.02855062298476696,
-0.002208542777225375,
-0.008235162124037743,
0.02977081574499607,
-0.04924088716506958,
0.012627435848116875,
0.040140118449926376,
-0.02155327796936035,
-0.010036565363407135,
0.019438941031694412,
-0.030868101865053177,
-0.026127882301807404,
-0.06662189960479736,
0.024873744696378708,
0.007078938186168671,
-0.006776304449886084,
-0.06388934701681137,
0.009602855890989304,
-0.03916548192501068,
0.0974879264831543,
0.027105238288640976,
-0.025334617123007774,
0.017224982380867004,
-0.00898126233369112,
-0.0051649147644639015,
-0.030189547687768936,
-0.030094796791672707,
0.005431212019175291,
-0.1041274294257164,
0.023051494732499123,
0.002190715167671442,
0.018645383417606354,
0.04264776408672333,
0.035854533314704895,
0.041634172201156616,
-0.021688638255000114,
0.0068184309639036655,
0.04449569806456566,
-0.06246400251984596,
0.0075064767152071,
-0.024327296763658524,
0.014208047650754452,
0.03255828097462654,
-0.03467560559511185,
0.0025512557476758957,
0.0011726111406460404,
0.0023268721997737885,
-0.03169800713658333,
0.0012598949251696467,
0.0011838239151984453,
-0.06658543646335602,
0.024958882480859756,
-0.055084459483623505,
0.05160873383283615,
-0.007118642795830965,
0.009148410521447659,
-0.00813650619238615,
-0.00740066496655345,
0.005397943779826164,
0.050664789974689484,
0.029798345640301704,
0.02246793918311596,
0.0407235212624073,
-0.015907740220427513,
0.01603933982551098,
-0.005812968593090773,
0.004253420513123274,
0.002308898139744997,
-0.009797883220016956,
-0.005904436577111483,
0.014519809745252132,
0.003082193434238434,
0.004424748942255974,
0.006758055649697781,
0.0075058951042592525,
0.00014377757906913757,
0.017308952286839485,
-0.025911888107657433,
-0.041174452751874924,
0.027313586324453354,
0.02753690630197525,
0.04007952660322189,
0.013107012026011944,
0.006600046530365944,
0.0032481495290994644,
0.04835939407348633,
-0.03486772999167442,
-0.027035901322960854,
-0.006613415665924549,
-0.004369174130260944,
0.004850650206208229,
0.015910819172859192,
-0.007535499986261129,
-0.03110063634812832,
0.042911823838949203,
0.059336330741643906,
-0.012168016284704208,
-0.06638868153095245,
0.04181116819381714,
-0.007807049434632063,
-0.008376244455575943,
-0.010853976011276245,
0.018920045346021652,
0.001360974507406354,
0.0179304052144289,
0.011975198052823544,
0.027852917090058327,
-0.006399477366358042,
0.03057645633816719,
-0.05836532264947891,
-0.014449910260736942,
0.004404106643050909,
-0.0001448368711862713,
0.04319550469517708,
-0.03884851559996605,
0.04875265061855316,
-0.004329181741923094,
0.004139655735343695,
-0.020969625562429428,
0.016594626009464264,
0.004954245872795582,
0.03290453180670738,
-0.024047553539276123,
0.03395900875329971,
0.02433183044195175,
-0.02668033540248871,
0.02702110819518566,
-0.007208939641714096,
0.023838931694626808,
0.025284098461270332,
0.04740583896636963,
0.02152174338698387,
-0.013485381379723549,
-0.0016524832462891936,
-0.04966149851679802,
0.026680337265133858,
0.028331179171800613,
-0.03935965523123741,
-0.05049653723835945,
0.0038985463324934244,
-0.03370721638202667,
-0.043888550251722336,
-0.007636194117367268,
0.041319236159324646,
-0.003424969268962741,
-0.012770652770996094,
0.03798189014196396,
0.015840524807572365,
0.00931921973824501,
-0.016187304630875587,
0.008922777138650417,
-0.05421688035130501,
0.003083200892433524,
0.02459702640771866,
-0.010587078519165516,
0.02000434882938862,
0.0925731360912323,
-0.026884378865361214,
-0.03039076179265976,
0.003099781693890691,
-0.018248749896883965,
-0.014453284442424774,
-0.01322127878665924,
-0.04782692715525627,
-0.012107550166547298,
-0.010249373503029346,
0.0077847749926149845,
0.014619161374866962,
-0.0041460697539150715,
-0.02716226316988468,
-0.009081123396754265,
-0.007890458218753338,
0.008436022326350212,
-0.02534870058298111,
-0.031239625066518784,
-0.015932433307170868,
-0.004982189275324345,
0.0033134999684989452,
0.04112028703093529,
0.06179509684443474,
-0.024273069575428963,
0.023449625819921494,
0.00759589858353138,
-0.011082365177571774,
0.027185119688510895,
-0.015986444428563118,
0.006178279872983694,
-0.005784257315099239,
0.052706003189086914,
0.04955846443772316,
0.019303053617477417,
-0.029974572360515594,
0.04269576445221901,
0.03277511149644852,
-0.026972012594342232,
0.023904381319880486,
0.005682626739144325,
-0.0167912058532238,
-0.01985672488808632,
-0.011682812124490738,
0.007324748206883669,
0.020537083968520164,
0.015686169266700745,
0.009570568799972534,
-0.003391152946278453,
0.012125319801270962,
-0.013670931570231915,
0.027500061318278313,
-0.01601392589509487,
0.03035769611597061,
-0.006895731203258038,
-0.008267581462860107,
0.0102212093770504,
-0.014672544784843922,
0.03325491398572922,
0.04310554638504982,
0.050529129803180695,
-0.006628895178437233,
-0.03432319685816765,
-0.0017547846073284745,
-0.016123421490192413,
-0.017832793295383453,
0.021159155294299126,
-0.05451425164937973,
0.004517416935414076,
-0.00003476974961813539,
0.0026232455857098103,
0.03100235015153885,
0.02550043724477291,
0.027133513242006302,
0.042970962822437286,
0.01788017526268959,
0.013616949319839478,
0.00240371935069561,
-0.011102380231022835,
0.025020277127623558,
0.028798775747418404,
-0.03185974806547165,
0.009242934174835682,
0.027400635182857513,
-0.013897627592086792,
-0.015992972999811172,
0.027715105563402176,
-0.005455915816128254,
-0.020826078951358795,
0.014669164083898067,
0.06569414585828781,
-0.023680418729782104,
-0.0646512359380722,
-0.03156730532646179,
-0.04033859819173813,
-0.1674603372812271,
0.02921348810195923,
-0.017885973677039146,
0.010557740926742554,
-0.007841131649911404,
0.0015501129673793912,
-0.0005105237942188978,
-0.016883816570043564,
-0.04729272425174713,
0.001614325330592692,
-0.00996649544686079,
-0.07178378850221634,
-0.013137337751686573,
0.04589950665831566,
-0.04546897113323212,
-0.004242782946676016,
0.0019620296079665422,
0.008112783543765545,
0.03753725066781044,
-0.03333921357989311,
0.01069299690425396,
-0.031208623200654984,
0.05061204358935356,
0.022999582812190056,
0.015361704863607883,
0.0012847550678998232,
-0.013494981452822685,
0.00533986696973443,
-0.04062620922923088,
-0.007578157354146242,
0.0187192652374506,
0.01825743354856968,
-0.012791899964213371,
0.04995524510741234,
0.009359796531498432,
0.010262377560138702,
0.07518664747476578,
-0.07651039212942123,
-0.016333555802702904,
-0.041333168745040894,
0.03383694216609001,
0.02537696808576584,
-0.010627114214003086,
0.020106514915823936,
0.007748746778815985,
-0.06197524070739746,
-0.014363459311425686,
-0.00024085484619718045,
-0.014995933510363102,
0.03553811460733414,
-0.008444579318165779,
-0.0020860389340668917,
-0.011899092234671116,
-0.03745746985077858,
-0.012275563552975655,
-0.021822018548846245,
0.059663642197847366,
0.024321386590600014,
-0.02109900489449501,
-0.03356238454580307,
-0.04163146764039993,
-0.05241251736879349,
0.007135105784982443,
-0.0026841387152671814,
-0.03265064209699631,
-0.001759675913490355,
-0.016034534201025963,
-0.011788768693804741,
0.015564113855361938,
0.024969855323433876,
-0.007855129428207874,
-0.021210456266999245,
-0.02391761913895607,
-0.029217278584837914,
0.05065581947565079,
-0.005451218690723181,
-0.058862555772066116,
0.008974364958703518,
-0.024838484823703766,
-0.07811613380908966,
-0.015449709258973598,
0.03576667606830597,
-0.006824053358286619,
0.011392902582883835,
-0.0018168407259508967,
0.026921618729829788,
0.026313871145248413,
0.032645002007484436,
0.015602288767695427,
0.2423504739999771,
0.006258072797209024,
-0.04129493609070778,
0.02824592962861061,
0.015690578147768974,
-0.0278276726603508,
0.02183833159506321,
0.061848994344472885,
0.013020028360188007,
-0.04964326694607735,
-0.06661004573106766,
0.039935845881700516,
0.01243334636092186,
0.01194725465029478,
-0.011080524884164333,
0.02449943497776985,
-0.029821688309311867,
-0.050731245428323746,
0.07326647639274597,
0.01627391390502453,
0.037659525871276855,
-0.005094592459499836,
0.017205653712153435,
0.016636688262224197,
-0.07089564204216003,
-0.016137156635522842,
0.014830893836915493,
0.0306813083589077,
-0.06511466950178146,
0.0161166749894619,
-0.028895029798150063,
-0.03001163713634014,
0.03648754954338074,
-0.0029002446681261063,
-0.01216910406947136,
0.023990415036678314,
-0.01523805595934391,
0.019095374271273613,
-0.0038820572663098574,
0.03545087203383446,
-0.023172341287136078,
-0.021144870668649673,
-0.04617058113217354,
-0.02191602624952793,
-0.033006247133016586,
0.036294471472501755,
-0.020390406250953674,
0.04481108859181404,
-0.00044919573701918125,
0.031492698937654495,
-0.013110495172441006,
0.020608192309737206,
-0.014140351675450802,
-0.018962688744068146,
-0.043293729424476624,
0.0390816405415535,
-0.004709198139607906,
0.03710407391190529,
-0.013307839632034302,
0.023417282849550247,
0.013509001582860947,
0.01942836493253708,
-0.05665260925889015,
0.023355666548013687,
0.009256069548428059,
-0.01650603674352169,
-0.010338127613067627,
-0.005025679245591164,
0.04939864203333855,
0.01485215499997139,
0.049905382096767426,
0.004040619824081659,
-0.01469882670789957,
-0.004840610083192587,
0.0346202589571476,
-0.0005566983600147069,
-0.028756335377693176,
0.04205922409892082,
-0.02179006114602089,
0.0004738820134662092,
-0.03132005035877228,
-0.04635768383741379,
-0.007921182550489902,
0.018196335062384605,
0.019572241231799126,
0.010861082933843136,
0.003076195251196623,
0.031887125223875046,
-0.012587124481797218,
-0.01887652464210987,
0.02558300644159317,
-0.04822646081447601,
-0.011013870127499104,
0.003744385438039899,
-0.017480216920375824,
-0.014625705778598785,
-0.005066962447017431,
-0.03253358229994774,
-0.006978620775043964,
-0.027350138872861862,
0.04846878722310066,
-0.006512073799967766,
0.002710804110392928,
-0.05276889726519585,
0.04844062402844429,
-0.007248838897794485,
0.008832382038235664,
0.006820342503488064,
-0.04738647863268852,
-0.008148347027599812,
-0.008695474825799465,
0.011493928730487823,
0.0033482187427580357,
-0.0013373310212045908,
0.030074236914515495,
0.051509518176317215,
-0.03222087398171425,
0.035500604659318924,
0.04736991226673126,
0.033722035586833954,
0.0023053546901792288,
0.025560149922966957,
-0.05458963289856911,
0.020399346947669983,
-0.017036037519574165,
0.015377876348793507,
-0.03511020913720131,
0.02715376764535904,
0.023420454934239388,
0.013313298113644123,
-0.005543256178498268,
-0.006791721098124981,
-0.05700824409723282,
-0.015900447964668274,
0.00885526742786169,
0.00010082080552820116,
0.013397444039583206,
0.0030200500041246414,
-0.037746187299489975,
-0.0030152318067848682,
-0.005721267778426409,
-0.012736012227833271,
-0.009867182932794094,
-0.02167404815554619,
0.00785574410110712,
0.0027978583239018917,
-0.06599252671003342,
0.01518593542277813,
-0.03932679817080498,
-0.01635432429611683,
0.011728709563612938,
0.016040818765759468,
-0.05528555437922478,
-0.02793506532907486,
0.0069434670731425285,
-0.0440499372780323,
-0.0086522763594985,
-0.018943483009934425,
0.03683270514011383,
-0.02542794682085514,
-0.009270211681723595,
0.03105802647769451,
0.03922712430357933,
0.012319153174757957,
0.020826244726777077,
0.056161291897296906,
-0.04384707659482956,
0.060212090611457825,
0.027942048385739326,
-0.001554731628857553,
0.017626222223043442,
-0.09065498411655426,
-0.013935890048742294,
0.02870885655283928,
0.04189348965883255,
0.03723053261637688,
0.015869414433836937,
0.024065222591161728,
-0.008779888041317463,
-0.05341489613056183,
0.02716882713139057,
0.006947852671146393,
-0.017745468765497208,
-0.001950585749000311,
-0.005856433417648077,
-0.00735430559143424,
-0.020191453397274017,
-0.010863562114536762,
0.05232793465256691,
-0.06091085076332092,
-0.03126418590545654,
0.0787118673324585,
0.017453206703066826,
-0.007211906835436821,
0.04123809561133385,
0.0018611197592690587,
0.018470555543899536,
0.050039295107126236,
0.020563708618283272,
-0.04166005179286003,
-0.0032615954987704754,
0.006573630962520838,
0.01985754445195198,
-0.03410957381129265,
0.03294132277369499,
0.01898452825844288,
-0.024955250322818756,
0.04844071716070175,
-0.047715261578559875,
-0.02588239312171936,
0.009585863910615444,
-0.022967897355556488,
-0.05753827840089798,
0.01648016832768917,
-0.039096858352422714,
0.009581503458321095,
0.02873041108250618,
0.06016416847705841,
0.022110817953944206,
-0.04264790564775467,
0.0010768645443022251,
-0.0006551435799337924,
0.002381142694503069,
-0.08174639195203781,
-0.0040200515650212765,
-0.0033337795175611973,
-0.025775333866477013,
-0.032660435885190964,
0.00206374516710639,
-0.0162846390157938,
0.005066180136054754,
-0.0407651886343956,
0.03515291586518288,
-0.021738315001130104,
-0.02027258090674877,
-0.0002228607627330348,
0.062358882278203964,
-0.01298289280384779,
0.03779882937669754,
-0.012848103418946266,
0.028181783854961395,
-0.017237816005945206,
0.05281773582100868,
0.03847828507423401,
0.01869620382785797,
-0.027208685874938965,
0.0022052288986742496,
-0.007448811084032059,
0.005192096345126629,
0.05317077040672302,
0.027057399973273277,
0.02826358564198017,
-0.005148530937731266,
-0.0027972511015832424,
0.01709236390888691,
0.04173252359032631,
0.03917922452092171,
-0.036411117762327194,
-0.031067335978150368,
-0.02631388045847416,
0.012050062417984009,
0.005094657186418772,
0.01112586073577404,
-0.03679778054356575,
-0.01834723725914955,
-0.05833684280514717,
0.02462553046643734,
-0.005418216343969107,
-0.03715676814317703,
-0.014058511704206467,
-0.01016970630735159,
-0.0035499867517501116,
0.004600259009748697,
-0.044363752007484436,
-0.036553237587213516,
0.0010804845951497555,
-0.01210024207830429,
0.027265770360827446,
0.031627073884010315,
-0.038044702261686325,
0.014295964501798153,
-0.05450616776943207,
0.03988766670227051,
0.006280462257564068,
-0.038720160722732544,
0.006230381783097982,
0.014725254848599434,
0.011602014303207397,
-0.008636275306344032,
-0.010815313085913658,
0.02461106702685356,
-0.004539318382740021,
-0.015292894095182419,
-0.009729905985295773,
-0.017323076725006104,
0.004648340400308371,
-0.0029626924078911543,
0.017926128581166267,
-0.013208822347223759,
0.031008154153823853,
-0.0353427417576313,
0.03535730764269829,
-0.03781526908278465,
-0.054890260100364685,
-0.030218565836548805,
0.046296317130327225,
-0.007302353624254465,
0.007290755398571491,
0.0036101341247558594,
0.028478361666202545,
0.011635045520961285,
-0.06527931243181229,
-0.00246819038875401,
-0.03567361459136009,
0.05136276036500931,
-0.00024547791690565646,
0.010325555689632893,
0.0025039936881512403,
-0.05806538835167885,
0.020134173333644867,
-0.025824708864092827,
0.016818895936012268,
-0.05591032654047012,
0.0072411661967635155,
-0.04963504150509834,
-0.011490842327475548,
-0.005436955019831657,
-0.038031984120607376,
-0.047574516385793686,
0.027632761746644974,
-0.04280500113964081,
-0.01811087131500244,
0.0306392852216959,
0.008634677156805992,
0.04955798014998436,
0.026604603976011276,
0.005863593891263008,
0.0015296003548428416,
0.03517160937190056,
-0.02622874267399311,
-0.00865448173135519,
-0.05883965641260147,
0.07288723438978195,
-0.022139308974146843,
0.008641453459858894,
0.007980040274560452,
-0.013063753955066204,
-0.003175014164298773,
0.03376663103699684,
0.019200967624783516,
-0.0027142863254994154,
0.0013570244191214442,
-0.0018842971185222268,
-0.003906989004462957,
0.02390291355550289,
0.014170548878610134,
0.004168080165982246,
0.006076452787965536,
0.05084388703107834,
-0.015259873121976852,
-0.03555570915341377,
0.028912853449583054,
0.0012583878124132752,
-0.005826692096889019,
0.020281655713915825,
-0.005345805082470179,
-0.02351212501525879,
0.014410750940442085,
-0.002848295262083411,
0.02002285234630108,
0.0007046106620691717,
-0.03140554949641228,
-0.00463468674570322,
0.011437554843723774,
-0.006587735842913389,
0.04944933205842972,
0.012412878684699535,
0.023970048874616623,
-0.017136842012405396,
-0.023670099675655365,
-0.008111665956676006,
-0.015575324185192585,
-0.05456545576453209,
-0.01524442434310913,
0.021070586517453194,
0.028871696442365646,
0.027585159987211227,
0.023245494812726974,
0.023142511025071144,
-0.0009207920520566404,
0.0046290447935462,
0.022430529817938805,
-0.026352260261774063,
-0.02140960469841957,
-0.13529011607170105,
-0.023694733157753944,
0.005806264467537403,
-0.008958502672612667,
-0.03719935566186905,
0.02759195677936077,
-0.02887815050780773,
0.018183832988142967,
-0.04632367938756943,
0.0077623785473406315,
0.0030221883207559586,
-0.024939166381955147,
-0.02447544038295746,
-0.024703428149223328,
-0.05102202296257019,
0.031202318146824837,
-0.029990628361701965,
-0.031193776056170464,
-0.061744436621665955,
0.03919639065861702,
-0.011243065819144249,
-0.004847854841500521,
0.0015871188370510936,
-0.03184324875473976,
-0.0050511290319263935,
-0.002529105171561241,
-0.05543883144855499,
-0.042284008115530014,
-0.020263561978936195,
-0.060410741716623306,
-0.02141212858259678,
0.01236841082572937,
-0.009485040791332722,
0.07205185294151306,
-0.01896938681602478,
0.026652734726667404,
0.01288705226033926,
0.003461181651800871,
-0.016256561502814293,
-0.021831966936588287,
-0.011181880719959736,
0.0316743440926075,
-0.021361950784921646,
-0.018661651760339737,
0.0024307738058269024,
0.019424868747591972,
-0.034145187586545944,
-0.008018982596695423,
-0.06906100362539291,
-0.04085425287485123,
-0.03150617703795433,
0.03743096813559532,
0.013058320619165897,
0.024603212252259254,
0.0004755674162879586,
0.0076454938389360905,
0.04438294842839241,
-0.02760019339621067,
-0.0011675737332552671,
0.04579722508788109,
0.013165533542633057,
0.018385782837867737,
-0.05445859953761101,
0.004952081944793463,
-0.007442900445312262,
0.011746583506464958,
-0.029796188697218895,
-0.026615820825099945,
-0.0021365471184253693,
-0.003706971649080515,
0.011422736570239067,
0.007853605784475803,
-0.030466148629784584,
-0.018283171579241753,
0.0024649903643876314,
0.020942622795701027,
-0.005821612197905779,
0.011590356007218361,
-0.02114895172417164,
-0.006296632345765829,
-0.05262501537799835,
0.028215907514095306,
-0.04203597828745842,
0.005431612487882376,
0.07244469225406647,
0.04603492468595505,
0.019781680777668953,
-0.010444063693284988,
0.004667588509619236,
-0.018678737804293633,
-0.07804186642169952,
0.008196464739739895,
-0.021554378792643547,
-0.019444573670625687,
-0.0169538464397192,
0.016937000676989555,
-0.009295353665947914,
-0.0016132586169987917,
0.0072393156588077545,
0.002654044423252344,
-0.04300825670361519,
0.005089829675853252,
0.006749976892024279,
0.005179052706807852,
-0.04126712307333946,
0.04322519525885582,
0.01975860446691513,
0.007065603043884039,
0.013378416188061237,
-0.05136670917272568,
0.003335375804454088,
-0.020838333293795586,
-0.0394272655248642,
0.04223180189728737,
-0.06328318268060684,
0.012100246734917164,
0.010069678537547588,
-0.012418646365404129,
0.011854119598865509,
0.008352917619049549,
0.006953946780413389,
0.013288585469126701,
0.036484044045209885,
-0.019844580441713333,
0.0005596120026893914,
0.0060621825978159904,
0.07997632026672363,
0.015261583961546421,
0.04553285241127014,
-0.0046262177638709545,
0.04838188365101814,
0.038189467042684555,
0.026396140456199646,
0.02876611426472664,
0.028490854427218437,
0.003051604377105832,
-0.015600418671965599,
0.037593256682157516,
-0.04851672425866127,
-0.029889889061450958,
-0.02901354432106018,
0.012950914911925793,
0.009055186063051224,
0.00413999380543828,
-0.030312038958072662,
0.018417149782180786,
0.04456653818488121,
-0.004785826429724693,
-0.014057639986276627,
-0.024331750348210335,
-0.02857954055070877,
0.008231664076447487,
0.02220049314200878,
0.06439708173274994,
0.02928246185183525,
-0.031337589025497437,
0.06628847867250443,
0.0007113012834452093,
0.012121127918362617,
0.0248369462788105,
-0.006463173311203718,
-0.05626533553004265,
-0.053706277161836624,
-0.03727960214018822,
-0.037535376846790314,
0.025762174278497696,
-0.042098820209503174,
0.014603378251194954,
-0.04380752146244049,
-0.014938518404960632,
-0.024189043790102005,
0.022236360237002373,
-0.026390891522169113,
-0.013369535095989704,
0.05319405347108841,
-0.007931448519229889,
0.009212520904839039,
0.010928654111921787,
0.03174575790762901,
-0.0526328943669796,
0.04773987829685211,
0.08639051020145416,
0.025347717106342316,
0.01451618131250143,
-0.015236523933708668,
0.030708778649568558,
0.03651408851146698,
0.02107934281229973,
-0.013720021583139896,
-0.032926663756370544,
-0.012354901060461998,
0.021633829921483994,
0.016482891514897346,
-0.014917982742190361,
0.015719199553132057,
0.01677909679710865,
0.014605795033276081,
0.03468695655465126,
0.01253421138972044,
0.033226851373910904,
0.03717728704214096,
-0.01667703129351139,
-0.023587843403220177,
-0.0284693893045187,
-0.0015419303672388196,
-0.0035024876706302166,
0.0016017568996176124,
-0.060054387897253036,
-0.024718401953577995,
0.06004175543785095,
-0.024834059178829193,
-0.022711249068379402,
-0.014346526004374027,
0.022087067365646362,
-0.0019249613396823406,
0.01645243912935257,
-0.0005981205613352358,
-0.016268998384475708,
0.006863211281597614,
-0.032059695571660995,
0.016786232590675354,
0.07022073864936829,
-0.019371330738067627,
0.018008217215538025,
-0.014185239560902119,
-0.006619367748498917,
-0.002704852493479848,
0.028740644454956055,
-0.019365545362234116,
0.00945411529392004,
-0.004249013494700193,
-0.025501331314444542,
-0.016464417800307274,
0.01778976060450077,
-0.0013583212858065963,
-0.06738786399364471,
-0.009095622226595879,
0.0066436841152608395,
-0.049959614872932434,
0.01634603552520275,
0.00007344688492594287,
0.020444173365831375,
0.035268351435661316,
0.014629080891609192
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:17
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
228It follows that if the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed are invalidated by force of an order made under s 87(2) of the Act, then the consent orders filed in Court on 6 September 2004 would also be set aside.
Rule 36.15(1)
229Thirdly, the Court has power under r 36.15(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) ("UCPR") to set aside a judgment or an order if it is shown that it was given, entered or made irregularly, illegally or against good faith.
230In Perpetual Trustees Australia Limited v Heperu Pty Limited & Ors [No 2], the Court said at [16] that the focus of the rule is on the giving, entry or making of the judgment or order.
231What is required for the application of the "against good faith" limb in r 36.15(1) of the UCPR, is some impeachment of the intention or behaviour of a person who procured a consent order, at the time it is made.
232The plaintiffs seek to impeach the behaviour of the defendants as involving conduct in contravention of s 52 of the Act in connection with the making of the Heads of Agreement, the Non-Dilution Deed and their formal embodiment in the consent orders of 6 September 2004.
Rule 36.15(2)
233Fourthly, an order may also be set aside if the parties to the proceedings consent: UCPR, r 36.15(2). Section 80 of the Act authorises the Court to direct things to be done: Tyco (Australia) Pty Ltd t/as ADT Security v Signature Security Group Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1029.
234The plaintiffs contend that pursuant to s 80 and s 87 of the Act, the defendants to these proceedings ought be restrained from relying upon, and the parties to the 2001 Proceedings be directed to consent to the setting aside of, the consent orders filed on 6 September 2004.
The availability of funds
235Thirteen of the seventeen representations pleaded concern the availability of funds to HTT in relation to the Project.
236Accordingly I will now consider the evidence concerning the availability of funds, and the state of knowledge that Mr Renshall and Mr Zdrilic had about that matter.
237In the course of considering this evidence, I shall also consider the representations pleaded in relation to this subject and generally.
The position in mid 2003
238I have referred above to the Caveat lodged by LEC on the title of the Land on 23 April 2003. The interest in the Land claimed by the Caveat was described as "Constructive Trust".
239Mr Renshall said that the Caveat "rendered Huntley virtually incapable of refinancing".
240In mid 2003 this was a problem because HTT was in default in relation to two of its secured creditors.
241One of those secured creditors was Greater Pacific Capital Limited ("GPC").
242On 24 May 2003 GPC sent HTT a notice stating that HTT's $2 million facility limit had been exceeded, that the outstanding balance as at 22 April 2003 was $2,233,565 and requesting action to "restore this facility" by repaying capitalised interest of $418,617 and paying an amount of $700,000 in reduction of the principal.
243On 29 May 2003 another secured creditor of HTT, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia ("CBA") made a demand for repayment by 30 June 2003 of loan facilities totalling $2,973,164.
244It will be recalled that, at this time, the 2001 Proceedings were pending.
245On 12 August 2003 there was a discussion between Mr Gillard and Mr Hilliard about HTT's need to refinance the CBA and GPC debts. On that date Mr Hilliard made a note that "details of new financier" were to be provided.
246I have referred above to Mr Gillard's letter of 10 September 2003 suggesting a meeting to endeavour to resolve the 2001 Proceedings. That letter also stated that HTT had been taking steps for refinancing of its loans "with various lenders".
247On 18 October 2003 Mr Zdrilic met with Mr Renshall. According to Mr Zdrilic, this was the occasion on which the question of a "big funder" having an involvement in the Project was first discussed.
248Mr Zdrilic claims Mr Renshall said:-
|
[
-0.029285715892910957,
0.015690430998802185,
0.0013819945743307471,
0.01585436798632145,
-0.009383092634379864,
-0.05484383925795555,
-0.010963384993374348,
-0.03149142116308212,
0.000903950072824955,
0.010182389058172703,
-0.0006941441679373384,
-0.009359805844724178,
-0.02893013134598732,
-0.00007797996659064665,
-0.01686842180788517,
-0.03888358175754547,
0.03589266538619995,
-0.00908731296658516,
0.0033442156855016947,
-0.00933739636093378,
-0.03810742869973183,
-0.007945464923977852,
-0.010845192708075047,
0.001541615347377956,
-0.011386469006538391,
0.03006906807422638,
-0.014302660711109638,
0.034284815192222595,
0.010897809639573097,
0.026918919757008553,
-0.008796017616987228,
-0.009332575835287571,
0.028627455234527588,
-0.05689443275332451,
0.022309456020593643,
-0.014799625612795353,
0.020796258002519608,
0.01473438274115324,
-0.03596828877925873,
-0.004835054744035006,
-0.02172880433499813,
0.032906726002693176,
0.014962207525968552,
-0.024976644665002823,
0.07519793510437012,
-0.029061203822493553,
-0.009045632556080818,
-0.020476503297686577,
0.017501721158623695,
0.03816680982708931,
-0.05234367027878761,
-0.02142006903886795,
0.06800681352615356,
-0.03347213193774223,
-0.047260429710149765,
0.01727166399359703,
-0.01957331970334053,
0.01795448549091816,
-0.05258658155798912,
0.0032991839107125998,
0.023418204858899117,
-0.021933047100901604,
-0.08037171512842178,
0.010134059935808182,
0.0043981363996863365,
0.05048290640115738,
0.012449334375560284,
-0.014589928090572357,
0.010760153643786907,
-0.020569926127791405,
-0.024291900917887688,
0.011733835563063622,
-0.042174842208623886,
0.002923052292317152,
-0.09391780942678452,
0.021820493042469025,
0.029300900176167488,
-0.00047015928430482745,
0.01871710643172264,
0.004163665696978569,
0.019217723980545998,
-0.0183927733451128,
0.0011268844828009605,
0.02229997143149376,
-0.03964098170399666,
0.005056773778051138,
-0.0017728102393448353,
0.028232203796505928,
0.039741989225149155,
-0.02880450338125229,
0.0007596167852170765,
0.00009270603186450899,
0.013655046932399273,
-0.023030247539281845,
0.018799152225255966,
-0.016985608264803886,
-0.05450277030467987,
0.07272311300039291,
-0.031102478504180908,
0.04073931276798248,
0.0056845941580832005,
0.035561226308345795,
0.008674031123518944,
-0.017463557422161102,
0.011469868943095207,
0.007937075570225716,
0.033150479197502136,
0.026233479380607605,
0.03518155217170715,
-0.010740312747657299,
-0.0012772685149684548,
-0.023126626387238503,
0.017125530168414116,
-0.007055685855448246,
0.008921267464756966,
0.010116997174918652,
0.02915356121957302,
-0.01708059571683407,
-0.004737556912004948,
-0.014081520959734917,
0.0036644451320171356,
0.04074527695775032,
0.052082695066928864,
-0.019773928448557854,
-0.06446318328380585,
0.009851804003119469,
0.040294039994478226,
0.024523748084902763,
-0.00533679686486721,
0.03522114455699921,
0.005564606748521328,
0.012252225540578365,
-0.0344720296561718,
-0.03078143671154976,
-0.017388729378581047,
-0.03358651325106621,
-0.004263816401362419,
0.018843116238713264,
0.00845988281071186,
-0.06584901362657547,
0.0439094677567482,
0.04556205868721008,
-0.003044678131118417,
-0.04147086292505264,
0.03220212832093239,
-0.02398819848895073,
0.040338821709156036,
-0.011706827208399773,
0.008254626765847206,
0.018270345404744148,
0.014559284783899784,
0.02340707741677761,
0.03958612680435181,
0.003313391702249646,
0.05893063545227051,
-0.041584562510252,
-0.009751895442605019,
0.00943036749958992,
0.02662150375545025,
0.07054141908884048,
-0.055288974195718765,
0.03417591378092766,
-0.011184404604136944,
-0.013214955106377602,
0.002996621187776327,
-0.012046296149492264,
0.04439269006252289,
-0.019514698535203934,
-0.013658631592988968,
0.019446909427642822,
0.026464808732271194,
-0.010881541296839714,
0.011311416514217854,
-0.01121111586689949,
0.01753946579992771,
0.028856322169303894,
0.02508636564016342,
0.01591956429183483,
-0.0167856402695179,
-0.012206547893583775,
-0.030538970604538918,
0.029131580144166946,
0.022873811423778534,
-0.0390259213745594,
-0.02478369139134884,
0.03154372423887253,
-0.016684796661138535,
0.025918176397681236,
0.004309510812163353,
0.019036734476685524,
-0.007572819013148546,
-0.0257694311439991,
0.0507628433406353,
0.0321485735476017,
-0.0036085748579353094,
-0.029132483527064323,
0.007208381313830614,
-0.035011690109968185,
0.019400564953684807,
0.029607761651277542,
-0.02002790756523609,
0.029226073995232582,
0.052008021622896194,
-0.02937130257487297,
0.0025001559406518936,
-0.0017760922200977802,
-0.036900393664836884,
0.028212949633598328,
-0.005320449825376272,
-0.05457977578043938,
0.009718424640595913,
0.0027471210341900587,
0.004887992050498724,
0.01020871289074421,
-0.030261749401688576,
-0.0008085257722996175,
-0.04124956950545311,
-0.017863277345895767,
-0.009714108891785145,
-0.020665155723690987,
-0.015234023332595825,
-0.007527496665716171,
0.004596265032887459,
-0.010679589584469795,
0.039996374398469925,
0.024223539978265762,
-0.04123853147029877,
-0.004435140173882246,
0.004063223488628864,
0.012396196834743023,
0.03186685964465141,
-0.029084008187055588,
0.04882076010107994,
-0.0008197898278012872,
0.05198253318667412,
0.04284181445837021,
0.02889994904398918,
0.022667748853564262,
0.03344132751226425,
-0.0030999353621155024,
-0.02657170593738556,
-0.01861429773271084,
0.02797534503042698,
-0.009033694863319397,
-0.0095897875726223,
-0.024381062015891075,
-0.01959301345050335,
-0.0012894273968413472,
0.020974481478333473,
-0.020053159445524216,
0.012794816866517067,
-0.0038037155754864216,
-0.04315776377916336,
0.030672593042254448,
0.001128351199440658,
0.03130824491381645,
0.011877038516104221,
-0.002729975152760744,
0.02161273919045925,
0.003575705923140049,
-0.012969139963388443,
0.040400922298431396,
0.03701110556721687,
-0.009666142985224724,
-0.00810079276561737,
-0.008946607820689678,
-0.015402093529701233,
-0.03680551424622536,
0.01727141998708248,
-0.02338552102446556,
0.01907918229699135,
0.006402712780982256,
0.02164836786687374,
0.02313537336885929,
-0.0015220055356621742,
0.03388993442058563,
0.027356626465916634,
-0.006824459880590439,
0.031497109681367874,
0.020713012665510178,
0.022737210616469383,
0.009775214828550816,
0.06031443551182747,
-0.05282629281282425,
0.035460177809000015,
0.007346484810113907,
-0.028886698186397552,
-0.04673618823289871,
-0.004795456305146217,
-0.04366783797740936,
0.021493954584002495,
0.02165335603058338,
0.07955485582351685,
-0.005178122315555811,
-0.04960153251886368,
-0.012524413876235485,
-0.014309578575193882,
-0.13979211449623108,
-0.03701738268136978,
0.0013494573067873716,
0.008983848616480827,
-0.0030699449125677347,
0.006172128487378359,
-0.010290361009538174,
-0.0018995518330484629,
-0.03414112329483032,
0.004113445989787579,
-0.015675880014896393,
-0.07229994237422943,
-0.019716201350092888,
0.00646223733201623,
0.023778527975082397,
-0.02997484616935253,
-0.01721716672182083,
0.013674503192305565,
0.021672803908586502,
-0.029562635347247124,
-0.002483236137777567,
-0.06190069019794464,
0.0699150413274765,
-0.02502625621855259,
0.007044754922389984,
0.016782090067863464,
-0.020738165825605392,
0.00910547561943531,
-0.054314833134412766,
0.007958678528666496,
-0.05631906911730766,
0.012523580342531204,
-0.007808290887624025,
0.042512014508247375,
0.021038688719272614,
0.010158163495361805,
0.08493219316005707,
-0.09346739202737808,
0.01750561222434044,
-0.01307756919413805,
0.013812384568154812,
0.06965243816375732,
0.004939015954732895,
0.017269033938646317,
-0.008999723009765148,
-0.015083876438438892,
-0.0004910081624984741,
0.022489195689558983,
-0.01143718883395195,
0.04119868949055672,
-0.00005223831249168143,
0.008371110074222088,
-0.03491581976413727,
-0.0435236394405365,
-0.022702736780047417,
-0.04207438603043556,
0.07150289416313171,
0.058394260704517365,
-0.026936175301671028,
-0.015166867524385452,
-0.0404931902885437,
-0.043819282203912735,
0.012094881385564804,
-0.005138044245541096,
-0.030173437669873238,
-0.009934012778103352,
0.01022152230143547,
-0.015792086720466614,
0.03769804537296295,
-0.002253533573821187,
-0.02598295733332634,
-0.04643009230494499,
-0.022878754884004593,
-0.007017058786004782,
0.029613954946398735,
0.033113934099674225,
-0.011922044679522514,
0.015468397177755833,
-0.011244290508329868,
-0.08411773294210434,
-0.003021150827407837,
0.04010613262653351,
-0.03546220064163208,
-0.007761895190924406,
-0.019785108044743538,
0.016058586537837982,
0.011110810562968254,
0.02777884341776371,
0.006786407437175512,
0.24397166073322296,
-0.01958145759999752,
-0.006278178188949823,
0.041033368557691574,
0.005582644138485193,
-0.0060351635329425335,
0.02677684836089611,
0.050741516053676605,
-0.006282232701778412,
-0.03705913946032524,
0.008956111036241055,
-0.034637484699487686,
0.011527301743626595,
0.03144831582903862,
-0.03474197909235954,
-0.00009858343400992453,
-0.02571936324238777,
-0.03783425688743591,
0.1073894128203392,
-0.019725559279322624,
0.018916821107268333,
-0.018974676728248596,
-0.005360735580325127,
0.01700947806239128,
-0.04274112358689308,
-0.022179722785949707,
0.04547479748725891,
0.042644135653972626,
-0.020904673263430595,
0.006547155324369669,
-0.017725924029946327,
-0.014306401833891869,
0.04732707515358925,
0.009952174499630928,
-0.03350415453314781,
-0.015987345948815346,
-0.05477099493145943,
0.012404349632561207,
-0.017920201644301414,
0.053681381046772,
-0.0025533123407512903,
-0.04653764143586159,
-0.031139057129621506,
-0.044223252683877945,
-0.018239295110106468,
0.024112187325954437,
-0.02259056083858013,
0.03428899496793747,
0.01146180834621191,
0.008535698056221008,
-0.026427805423736572,
-0.020870264619588852,
-0.02555142156779766,
-0.01090583112090826,
-0.04360562562942505,
0.013290795497596264,
-0.007448033429682255,
0.041486382484436035,
0.007432965561747551,
0.04975270479917526,
0.0012494068359956145,
-0.0010282890871167183,
-0.0568576455116272,
0.03409001603722572,
-0.010868917219340801,
-0.011741180904209614,
-0.060202568769454956,
0.029009904712438583,
0.06449573487043381,
0.03672051057219505,
0.03850359097123146,
0.03311346843838692,
-0.012269656173884869,
0.010353830642998219,
0.06884491443634033,
0.018316496163606644,
-0.03128992021083832,
0.024633903056383133,
-0.017268864437937737,
-0.036990534514188766,
-0.01889995113015175,
-0.019452979788184166,
-0.017118392512202263,
0.014842688106000423,
0.009680317714810371,
0.008385082706809044,
-0.012112855911254883,
0.02910074032843113,
0.002045482862740755,
-0.027256034314632416,
-0.0223768912255764,
-0.02084803767502308,
-0.011287250556051731,
0.04077420383691788,
-0.012650898657739162,
-0.005156052764505148,
0.005863067228347063,
0.0020836503244936466,
-0.017295315861701965,
-0.049415938556194305,
-0.015004956163465977,
-0.009246458299458027,
0.013611986301839352,
-0.048758748918771744,
0.03516441956162453,
-0.010123692452907562,
-0.009968641214072704,
0.007722740527242422,
-0.05433598533272743,
0.006208634003996849,
0.01729564741253853,
0.022170348092913628,
-0.009648784063756466,
-0.008429211564362049,
0.00803208164870739,
0.05790090560913086,
-0.024950843304395676,
0.0361153781414032,
0.060885194689035416,
0.06235288083553314,
-0.01557519007474184,
0.019023515284061432,
-0.025698810815811157,
0.04462739825248718,
-0.007190840784460306,
-0.022333884611725807,
-0.036210279911756516,
0.03050295077264309,
0.01955653354525566,
0.04429318383336067,
0.018818868324160576,
-0.01194476243108511,
-0.00877368450164795,
0.022760484367609024,
0.05197489261627197,
0.022290602326393127,
0.02599773183465004,
0.0023639011196792126,
-0.01958964578807354,
0.06536424905061722,
-0.015014003030955791,
-0.007173402234911919,
-0.011083821766078472,
0.001797661418095231,
0.014381753280758858,
-0.020161956548690796,
-0.03282271325588226,
0.0018016491085290909,
-0.09373298287391663,
-0.0031380753498524427,
0.004478034097701311,
0.028998324647545815,
-0.009912732057273388,
-0.060371626168489456,
-0.001662554917857051,
-0.04303279146552086,
-0.01617719791829586,
0.0036030192859470844,
0.026078956201672554,
-0.011550841853022575,
-0.0191770251840353,
0.015042332001030445,
-0.0030277948826551437,
0.01361976657062769,
0.021353131160140038,
0.051270101219415665,
-0.04267088323831558,
0.02862713672220707,
0.0347149521112442,
-0.004590320400893688,
-0.025655196979641914,
-0.040824923664331436,
-0.027081618085503578,
0.06907651573419571,
0.017521800473332405,
0.01648113876581192,
0.008980806916952133,
0.022620953619480133,
0.013666780665516853,
-0.02038446255028248,
0.00048184505430981517,
0.0013119925279170275,
-0.017565812915563583,
0.014409942552447319,
-0.015261633321642876,
-0.0017980157863348722,
-0.03576825559139252,
-0.018361445516347885,
0.061228543519973755,
-0.04940960928797722,
-0.04525555297732353,
0.08499529212713242,
0.011529570445418358,
-0.00811430811882019,
0.0029788727406412363,
0.011234940961003304,
0.03011619672179222,
0.023173313587903976,
-0.007964512333273888,
-0.04098153114318848,
0.0038750774692744017,
-0.011987544596195221,
0.008198817260563374,
-0.037525326013565063,
-0.002993195317685604,
-0.0015202471986413002,
-0.04953562468290329,
0.023205053061246872,
-0.03649129346013069,
-0.01839769259095192,
0.023497121408581734,
0.027695273980498314,
-0.03447321429848671,
0.04436906427145004,
0.012701643630862236,
-0.008946491405367851,
-0.014299998059868813,
0.07226051390171051,
0.03912254422903061,
-0.06613925844430923,
-0.031596969813108444,
-0.04954184964299202,
0.02716980315744877,
-0.08023356646299362,
0.008546805009245872,
-0.0035400574561208487,
-0.031106363981962204,
0.005979989655315876,
0.007203757297247648,
-0.004408387001603842,
0.007470985874533653,
-0.031541723757982254,
0.07639490813016891,
-0.0065887258388102055,
-0.022258419543504715,
0.004208756610751152,
0.06366678327322006,
-0.010945894755423069,
0.032636161893606186,
-0.020220493897795677,
-0.014224786311388016,
0.02873186580836773,
0.02150828391313553,
0.020216651260852814,
0.043579548597335815,
-0.0352160781621933,
0.004794718232005835,
0.0239532683044672,
0.05300729721784592,
0.03054802305996418,
-0.012623148038983345,
0.011170930229127407,
0.0005223349435254931,
-0.015630057081580162,
-0.017920907586812973,
0.0109708271920681,
0.03508821502327919,
-0.036505598574876785,
-0.0321134477853775,
-0.03245296701788902,
0.008854877203702927,
0.004399735014885664,
0.030607640743255615,
-0.02990397810935974,
-0.04602498188614845,
-0.06386512517929077,
0.030859269201755524,
-0.004466706421226263,
-0.02702244743704796,
-0.02507747896015644,
-0.01821042411029339,
0.0013964578974992037,
0.0005720218759961426,
-0.022881213575601578,
0.004340749233961105,
-0.05147750303149223,
0.013852651230990887,
0.024455735459923744,
0.020243361592292786,
-0.018609780818223953,
0.0021288900170475245,
-0.00894071999937296,
0.047159407287836075,
0.012128670699894428,
0.00263915560208261,
0.015200712718069553,
0.03156326711177826,
-0.004883463494479656,
-0.005986363627016544,
-0.016651561483740807,
0.03695739805698395,
-0.01122977677732706,
0.0006449880311265588,
-0.028664523735642433,
-0.0046673668548464775,
-0.023695068433880806,
0.03093285672366619,
0.026099970564246178,
-0.03188161179423332,
0.016076721251010895,
-0.05247459188103676,
0.01757815293967724,
-0.04750509932637215,
-0.05757555365562439,
0.002398101380094886,
0.027026139199733734,
-0.004376944620162249,
0.0071562216617167,
-0.022054890170693398,
0.024420838803052902,
0.018493853509426117,
-0.09769921749830246,
-0.019701991230249405,
-0.0022982913069427013,
0.058794017881155014,
-0.004663847852498293,
-0.0052662682719528675,
0.013362506404519081,
-0.03265208378434181,
0.006039568223059177,
-0.011221800930798054,
0.0051452964544296265,
-0.027518458664417267,
0.00014731544069945812,
-0.042128585278987885,
-0.007471238728612661,
-0.004505104850977659,
-0.030247699469327927,
-0.036784086376428604,
0.003267057705670595,
-0.036125533282756805,
0.027193862944841385,
0.0058009144850075245,
-0.008684647269546986,
0.044985637068748474,
0.04735732823610306,
-0.004948219750076532,
0.0023947882000356913,
0.06943335384130478,
-0.07740333676338196,
-0.008058217354118824,
-0.09345477819442749,
0.06889738887548447,
0.006240085233002901,
-0.005693272687494755,
0.009899847209453583,
-0.022514179348945618,
-0.018969861790537834,
0.0066877854987978935,
0.009796246886253357,
-0.03948590159416199,
0.019449813291430473,
-0.009674856439232826,
-0.030301664024591446,
0.03174488991498947,
0.01870957389473915,
0.02388865314424038,
0.021646391600370407,
-0.002586108399555087,
-0.025855762884020805,
-0.011940342374145985,
0.018811672925949097,
0.02552417851984501,
-0.029581062495708466,
0.03490443900227547,
-0.016806038096547127,
-0.008114876225590706,
0.022690745070576668,
0.012479789555072784,
0.01147913932800293,
0.016534194350242615,
-0.02447839081287384,
0.01665567047894001,
-0.036733098328113556,
-0.05515001341700554,
0.02432325854897499,
-0.0018757152138277888,
0.0008640414453111589,
-0.0029186210595071316,
-0.019290316849946976,
0.03030260093510151,
-0.02074613608419895,
-0.038036689162254333,
-0.017762472853064537,
-0.0194076057523489,
0.03287156671285629,
-0.004065185319632292,
-0.0003752994234673679,
-0.0057787518016994,
-0.015675324946641922,
0.006040726788341999,
0.0444982573390007,
-0.03208862617611885,
0.03025203011929989,
-0.12712684273719788,
0.006123743485659361,
0.0032842138316482306,
-0.0040879142470657825,
-0.027942141517996788,
0.00557822547852993,
-0.05068881809711456,
0.01957465149462223,
-0.0533406063914299,
-0.028177810832858086,
-0.021941836923360825,
-0.0390273816883564,
-0.006932840216904879,
-0.021337581798434258,
-0.020134883001446724,
0.018830327317118645,
-0.03238649293780327,
-0.017759734764695168,
-0.040598221123218536,
0.014487076550722122,
0.005885395221412182,
0.0027429864276200533,
-0.01568470522761345,
-0.049552805721759796,
0.005397379398345947,
-0.0005084591684862971,
-0.01845150999724865,
-0.060351576656103134,
-0.021964535117149353,
-0.03639299049973488,
-0.028700757771730423,
-0.04365992546081543,
-0.02000027522444725,
0.07567466795444489,
-0.01499844342470169,
-0.0022060659248381853,
0.01701252907514572,
-0.05452023074030876,
-0.04007672518491745,
-0.0007824642234481871,
0.01106715202331543,
0.02417944371700287,
-0.00738123431801796,
-0.04314681142568588,
-0.02788834273815155,
0.02854667790234089,
-0.03560802340507507,
-0.002072193892672658,
-0.039873868227005005,
-0.05017569288611412,
-0.05663277208805084,
0.05373724550008774,
-0.002855874365195632,
0.025047313421964645,
0.006269753444939852,
0.03609449416399002,
-0.012396831065416336,
-0.0013076345203444362,
0.01823568157851696,
0.04521908238530159,
0.004177233669906855,
0.022592099383473396,
-0.039453670382499695,
-0.004340775310993195,
-0.0071898880414664745,
0.008110307157039642,
-0.06630498915910721,
-0.012865343131124973,
0.005423258990049362,
0.016315585002303123,
-0.0165676549077034,
0.018848614767193794,
-0.03421607241034508,
-0.011519171297550201,
0.011133672669529915,
0.0019092392176389694,
-0.0306045264005661,
0.012348311953246593,
-0.005648916587233543,
0.02424204722046852,
-0.06426872313022614,
-0.015849754214286804,
-0.034461237490177155,
-0.008296982385218143,
0.07652122527360916,
0.03119383566081524,
0.0019442766206339002,
-0.0341680683195591,
0.03069620579481125,
-0.03625424578785896,
-0.0471261702477932,
0.002674942137673497,
0.006814558990299702,
0.0376749187707901,
-0.006221451330929995,
0.02142811007797718,
-0.006308797746896744,
0.024611078202724457,
0.0005930835613980889,
0.004228808451443911,
-0.06345097720623016,
-0.0006813487270846963,
0.03821884095668793,
-0.0328994020819664,
-0.017305124551057816,
0.04191000759601593,
0.019281618297100067,
-0.03238018602132797,
0.040995754301548004,
0.010669982060790062,
-0.016327520832419395,
-0.023547811433672905,
-0.0558018684387207,
0.032903093844652176,
-0.04536967724561691,
0.011529684998095036,
-0.008653521537780762,
-0.016422322019934654,
-0.014075283892452717,
-0.013288812711834908,
0.01678987592458725,
-0.00580644840374589,
0.014614785090088844,
-0.026725459843873978,
-0.009309387765824795,
0.03433933109045029,
0.0637589544057846,
0.03626575320959091,
0.04711184278130531,
-0.016157299280166626,
0.03052004985511303,
-0.0052550784312188625,
-0.02509988471865654,
0.009048188105225563,
0.036168958991765976,
0.02021305076777935,
-0.02640938200056553,
0.030998632311820984,
-0.029863188043236732,
-0.02451454848051071,
-0.006560969166457653,
0.009439405053853989,
0.012589660473167896,
0.014301353134214878,
-0.0340714193880558,
0.013854592107236385,
0.03966107964515686,
-0.03753624111413956,
-0.006259434390813112,
-0.013311784714460373,
-0.025300640612840652,
0.03694506734609604,
0.009222987107932568,
0.03223703056573868,
0.00670913839712739,
-0.03978399187326431,
0.02336823381483555,
0.027998315170407295,
0.018135089427232742,
0.030642205849289894,
0.029598621651530266,
-0.006244460120797157,
-0.05071983113884926,
-0.025032369419932365,
-0.012401578947901726,
0.030735906213521957,
-0.017721600830554962,
0.037622302770614624,
-0.00718144653365016,
-0.013155139982700348,
-0.03635260835289955,
0.031950339674949646,
-0.024908849969506264,
-0.023539843037724495,
0.019608503207564354,
-0.011885073035955429,
-0.009642615914344788,
-0.03690522536635399,
0.05604463070631027,
-0.01484538335353136,
0.05900607258081436,
0.06420997530221939,
0.006609294097870588,
-0.007744926959276199,
-0.01283170748502016,
0.027065472677350044,
0.02201564982533455,
0.028566870838403702,
-0.013567189686000347,
-0.005382148083299398,
-0.025911711156368256,
0.005407665856182575,
0.01089087687432766,
-0.006826389580965042,
0.015206526033580303,
0.03412686660885811,
0.0067366803996264935,
0.02874881587922573,
-0.04083852097392082,
0.03737201169133186,
0.009236525744199753,
-0.040731824934482574,
-0.019502177834510803,
-0.007043604273349047,
-0.0160631462931633,
-0.023142972961068153,
-0.024705663323402405,
-0.041140660643577576,
-0.002560890279710293,
0.06542819738388062,
0.014863315038383007,
-0.015545513480901718,
-0.03228781744837761,
0.010253408923745155,
-0.01867077127099037,
0.009972406551241875,
0.03680421784520149,
-0.028616519644856453,
0.01481131836771965,
-0.03161289170384407,
0.027054807171225548,
0.04976525902748108,
-0.031430501490831375,
-0.01915932074189186,
-0.011733357794582844,
0.02359129674732685,
-0.025448061525821686,
-0.0008405388798564672,
0.013799752108752728,
0.03478272631764412,
0.009009046480059624,
0.004733721259981394,
-0.009779428131878376,
0.038207873702049255,
0.01132082100957632,
-0.0729132816195488,
-0.03980676457285881,
-0.03496912494301796,
-0.045052506029605865,
0.007234828546643257,
0.01798160746693611,
-0.0015882905572652817,
-0.030061814934015274,
-0.010689218528568745
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:29
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"GPC are requesting that they be paid out or they will appoint a receiver. We are attempting to obtain interim finance to payout GPC and the Commonwealth Bank. The funds are to be provided in accordance with the Heads of Agreement with IPC."
427In cross-examination, Mr Zdrilic said he did not give any thought as to whether what he claims Mr Renshall said amounted to a binding commitment.
428Mr Renshall said the funds would arrive "tomorrow" (that is 26 March 2004). Mr Zdrilic agreed that he understood that to mean that the funds would have to arrive the next day.
429Mr Zdrilic agreed that he knew that, the next day, $4 million had not arrived.
430Mr Zdrilic said that Mr Renshall had given him an explanation for that delay, which he had accepted, and that "we moved forward".
431Thus, it seems clear, except perhaps for a period of 24 hours from 25 March 2004, Mr Zdrilic could not have relied upon whatever it was that was said to him by Mr Renshall.
432In any event, Mr Zdrilic agreed that what he came to know the next day, that is 26 March 2004, was that the amounts owing by HTT to CBA and to GPC were to be paid out, but not by the New Zealand funder.
433Rather, the funds were to be advanced by a company known as DTC No 1 Pty Limited ("DTC").
434Thus if, as Mr Zdrilic's note suggests, he was told on 25 March 2004 that "tomorrow" $4 million would be advanced by "the new funder", he must have appreciated, when DTC suddenly came on the scene the next day, either that the "new funder" had not come up with the money after all, or that it was sourcing loan funds from a third party.
The first "expensive" loan - the DTC advance
435On 26 March 2004 HTT entered into an agreement with DTC.
436So far as the evidence reveals, from Mr Zdrilic's point of view, DTC came on the scene out of the blue. There is no reference, prior to 26 March 2004, to DTC in any document tendered in the proceedings. In Mr Zdrilic's evidence, all references prior to 26 March 2004 had been to "the new funder".
437The DTC loan was the first of three loans that the parties referred to as the "expensive loans".
438The DTC loan was for $6.8 million. It was used to pay the amount then owing by HTT to CBA (approximately $3.29 million), and the amount owing by HTT to GPC (approximately $3.095 million), together with certain fees and expenses. It will be recalled that CBA and GPC had been pressing for payment since mid 2003.
439The DTC loan was for a term of six months (expiring on 26 September 2004) at an interest rate of 25 per cent.
440There is no evidence of what role, if any, IBIS or IPC played in the negotiation of the loan to HTT from DTC. All that is revealed is that IBIS guaranteed repayment to DTC of the loan.
441On 26 March 2004 Mr Hilliard executed a "Caveator's Consent" to the mortgage granted by HTT to DTC over the Land.
442Mr Zdrilic was fully aware of this and said that "of course" he knew that DTC was different from any "big funder" spoken of by Mr Renshall.
443On 26 March 2004 Mr Hilliard wrote to Mr Zdrilic:-
"I refer to our discussions earlier today and confirm that, on behalf of LEC, as caveator, I have consented to discharge of mortgages in favour of the Commonwealth Bank and Great [sic] Pacific Capital Limited and registration of a mortgage in favour of DTC No 1 Pty Limited in respect of an advance of $6.8 million(...)
A meeting has been arranged with Brian Gillard and Robert Renshall in my office at 3pm on Monday 29 March 2004. The purpose of the meeting is to obtain full disclosure of the way in which [HTT] holds its interest in the land and its relationship with the proposed new funder which will be lending the $12 million referred to in the draft Heads of Agreement".
444The fact that Mr Hilliard saw the purpose of the proposed 29 March 2004 meeting as being to obtain "full disclosure" of HTT's relationship with "the proposed new funder" it makes clear, in my opinion,
|
[
-0.019186140969395638,
0.04325534775853157,
-0.03321411833167076,
0.026263248175382614,
-0.035167425870895386,
-0.02917955443263054,
0.012047636322677135,
-0.04357515648007393,
-0.029278738424181938,
0.023168539628386497,
-0.01250496506690979,
0.03366073593497276,
-0.024069156497716904,
0.014084495604038239,
-0.012918851338326931,
-0.05132584273815155,
0.02680019475519657,
-0.04659314081072807,
0.012859460897743702,
-0.011841919273138046,
0.00017918636149261147,
-0.029888058081269264,
0.023051723837852478,
0.03784731775522232,
-0.002312075812369585,
-0.010066346265375614,
-0.03381117805838585,
0.024581974372267723,
0.03849255293607712,
0.04077848419547081,
0.006675815209746361,
0.0030468415934592485,
0.04042657092213631,
-0.013108468614518642,
0.019921233877539635,
0.008144647814333439,
0.010242768563330173,
-0.0014503642451018095,
-0.043018024414777756,
0.02861090563237667,
0.01758953556418419,
0.014723609201610088,
0.012436452321708202,
0.016514481976628304,
0.05915334075689316,
-0.040103211998939514,
-0.02551622875034809,
-0.011919688433408737,
0.007586894556879997,
0.005351260770112276,
-0.025745410472154617,
-0.03177005425095558,
0.023226799443364143,
-0.031793877482414246,
-0.008343185298144817,
-0.03661872819066048,
0.007693072780966759,
-0.0248284749686718,
-0.06378530710935593,
0.017258772626519203,
0.02947230264544487,
-0.0033130471128970385,
-0.041282881051301956,
0.004252737388014793,
-0.003039810573682189,
0.12919080257415771,
0.01693091168999672,
0.009844081476330757,
0.0039023689460009336,
-0.004626710433512926,
-0.04378698393702507,
-0.012612994760274887,
-0.014882759191095829,
-0.021065009757876396,
-0.08525177836418152,
0.027384109795093536,
0.014022083953022957,
-0.02128068543970585,
0.03598342090845108,
0.03069250099360943,
0.035930197685956955,
-0.050131168216466904,
-0.009992738254368305,
0.008899485692381859,
-0.03739498555660248,
0.003662879578769207,
-0.039982907474040985,
0.034189626574516296,
0.00551278330385685,
-0.04879143461585045,
-0.009671114385128021,
0.016156811267137527,
0.04350536689162254,
-0.034497786313295364,
0.01214547548443079,
0.0038020818028599024,
-0.03640969842672348,
0.054087892174720764,
0.007931120693683624,
0.021225037053227425,
0.028691593557596207,
0.013322281651198864,
-0.005764785222709179,
-0.024240076541900635,
0.008942904882133007,
0.02624729461967945,
0.05008335039019585,
0.032654475420713425,
-0.020983656868338585,
-0.002180451527237892,
-0.0028079948388040066,
0.004158098250627518,
0.007151407655328512,
0.008389990776777267,
0.0024481830187141895,
0.0011001048842445016,
-0.01299490500241518,
-0.00611222255975008,
0.026819871738553047,
0.003672870108857751,
0.04280420020222664,
0.023246845230460167,
0.03648683428764343,
-0.00887190643697977,
-0.0606440044939518,
-0.015301700681447983,
0.005800371058285236,
0.04636434093117714,
-0.005633954890072346,
0.03594907745718956,
-0.02109699696302414,
0.015002417378127575,
-0.00677266251295805,
-0.012197297997772694,
-0.026852931827306747,
-0.005139682907611132,
0.0006203355733305216,
-0.04267922416329384,
0.012095664627850056,
-0.061762914061546326,
0.03395502641797066,
0.05833059176802635,
0.0018416944658383727,
-0.04515109956264496,
0.026114266365766525,
-0.06404544413089752,
-0.020543735474348068,
-0.01807956025004387,
-0.0013760398142039776,
0.0729837715625763,
0.025721214711666107,
0.0024751366581767797,
0.035643599927425385,
-0.0011126830941066146,
0.008079004473984241,
-0.03430210053920746,
-0.008207697421312332,
-0.045814644545316696,
0.019549226388335228,
0.0727231428027153,
-0.030965883284807205,
0.023446515202522278,
0.027181191369891167,
-0.05532383546233177,
-0.029797637835144997,
0.008785853162407875,
0.024135468527674675,
0.03389880806207657,
-0.018333569169044495,
0.0036423164419829845,
0.00597019586712122,
-0.018720943480730057,
0.06787364184856415,
-0.0025005373172461987,
0.007208659779280424,
0.022706180810928345,
0.0464019700884819,
0.004656244069337845,
0.03578117489814758,
-0.022117238491773605,
-0.040730856359004974,
0.03841087594628334,
0.0065696523524820805,
-0.011563912965357304,
-0.03607908636331558,
0.008878206834197044,
-0.02391144447028637,
-0.023526253178715706,
-0.010193908587098122,
0.01747707836329937,
-0.03127339854836464,
-0.00022266140149440616,
0.026122311130166054,
0.016138972714543343,
0.01730552315711975,
-0.009638659656047821,
0.007427873555570841,
-0.029888758435845375,
0.025592805817723274,
-0.018300572410225868,
-0.03782141953706741,
0.01930879056453705,
0.07131776958703995,
-0.0017509961035102606,
-0.0031858854927122593,
0.021627476438879967,
-0.03325648605823517,
-0.0030765621922910213,
0.000008305648407258559,
-0.05200344696640968,
-0.006829575635492802,
0.0029637792613357306,
0.007059788331389427,
-0.019529663026332855,
0.022570768371224403,
-0.010357744060456753,
-0.0035452665761113167,
-0.011870523914694786,
0.02320488914847374,
-0.019604159519076347,
-0.007610414642840624,
0.017188427969813347,
-0.018853511661291122,
0.02674500085413456,
0.03454587608575821,
0.05314301326870918,
-0.08123619854450226,
0.03764292597770691,
-0.029910681769251823,
-0.027086663991212845,
-0.012786331586539745,
-0.005562892183661461,
0.004040578380227089,
-0.029245421290397644,
0.028617072850465775,
0.04371633380651474,
0.0054216207936406136,
-0.005957969464361668,
0.010841582901775837,
-0.00366305117495358,
-0.002039562677964568,
0.032910771667957306,
-0.012977724894881248,
-0.005877323914319277,
-0.02964080683887005,
-0.011558066122233868,
-0.016963070258498192,
0.016290053725242615,
-0.000079602119512856,
-0.03833571448922157,
-0.007211387623101473,
-0.007928856648504734,
0.0029002425726503134,
0.00693880021572113,
-0.02597479149699211,
0.02591707929968834,
0.0009993200656026602,
-0.0026473344769328833,
0.03181616961956024,
0.0350370854139328,
0.020858176052570343,
0.010997346602380276,
0.04047592356801033,
0.009768325835466385,
-0.01369667798280716,
0.011013454757630825,
-0.04256242886185646,
-0.06128765270113945,
0.01768706738948822,
-0.029807772487401962,
0.02789502963423729,
0.0012820186093449593,
0.022575393319129944,
0.02945150062441826,
0.010501309297978878,
0.04375282675027847,
0.03339368477463722,
0.01784665323793888,
-0.008647710084915161,
0.0355183482170105,
0.005522934254258871,
-0.003697478910908103,
0.022166986018419266,
-0.035100627690553665,
0.06523671001195908,
0.04616567865014076,
0.010511883534491062,
-0.006823612377047539,
0.03838248550891876,
-0.008227015845477581,
-0.04792463779449463,
0.02742483839392662,
0.06692975759506226,
-0.02110174484550953,
-0.06398029625415802,
-0.043237365782260895,
-0.019067272543907166,
-0.15391486883163452,
-0.019820820540189743,
0.010097316466271877,
0.0007062879158183932,
-0.010469778440892696,
0.009570912458002567,
-0.06078166142106056,
0.0003127721429336816,
-0.026906829327344894,
0.03463728353381157,
-0.0007580571109429002,
-0.052606143057346344,
-0.023754654452204704,
0.05109849199652672,
0.02067631669342518,
-0.0383329838514328,
0.007153389509767294,
0.022882986813783646,
0.005322696641087532,
-0.02634858526289463,
0.011710150167346,
-0.010863645002245903,
0.01363406702876091,
-0.01292677503079176,
-0.00446008425205946,
0.029590724036097527,
-0.001441586297005415,
0.03265482932329178,
-0.052928172051906586,
0.0031913225539028645,
0.012368748895823956,
0.03609563037753105,
-0.0261146891862154,
0.030197568237781525,
-0.00949727464467287,
0.03427449241280556,
0.08367787301540375,
-0.02680194564163685,
-0.022561274468898773,
-0.03859231248497963,
0.008718523196876049,
0.05555296316742897,
-0.009222394786775112,
0.020724736154079437,
-0.01328163594007492,
-0.0302010178565979,
0.005850266665220261,
0.00556544354185462,
-0.004321228247135878,
0.03881550952792168,
0.011002792976796627,
0.016534654423594475,
-0.01887166127562523,
-0.037877146154642105,
0.0013208410236984491,
-0.037284303456544876,
0.03360166400671005,
0.0032015203032642603,
-0.024120748043060303,
-0.012297612614929676,
-0.030819429084658623,
-0.09172765910625458,
-0.00643658684566617,
0.018032072111964226,
-0.028618888929486275,
0.00027830456383526325,
-0.0024840713012963533,
-0.025843726471066475,
0.01382590364664793,
0.0028119822964072227,
0.0024496279656887054,
-0.013975962996482849,
0.012448303401470184,
0.002550368430092931,
0.03321267291903496,
0.040579162538051605,
-0.051869746297597885,
0.00022863569029141217,
-0.034182965755462646,
-0.10322971642017365,
-0.010708203539252281,
0.042542602866888046,
-0.01094062626361847,
0.018183615058660507,
0.00874138344079256,
0.017831778153777122,
0.00608745077624917,
0.0621979646384716,
-0.008146179839968681,
0.2514485716819763,
-0.015868766233325005,
-0.006507301703095436,
0.028223950415849686,
0.02708776853978634,
-0.03408382833003998,
-0.0072434102185070515,
0.053918179124593735,
0.00424737436696887,
-0.062213461846113205,
-0.02444228157401085,
-0.00158392742741853,
0.010939463041722775,
0.030925357714295387,
-0.02439400739967823,
-0.0082230931147933,
-0.054522186517715454,
-0.020151734352111816,
0.06968030333518982,
0.00025310207274742424,
0.04346534237265587,
-0.0043693226762115955,
0.0017920888494700193,
-0.014551562257111073,
-0.07381270080804825,
-0.05730997025966644,
0.025478100404143333,
0.05375294387340546,
-0.03360321372747421,
0.03494534268975258,
-0.032201215624809265,
-0.016490548849105835,
0.03245658800005913,
0.018046116456389427,
0.019710972905158997,
0.010687525384128094,
-0.01561528630554676,
0.010265903547406197,
0.0042655328288674355,
0.048832960426807404,
-0.008742652833461761,
-0.04620921239256859,
-0.016876980662345886,
-0.031148282811045647,
-0.041362714022397995,
0.0015864493325352669,
-0.047718703746795654,
0.019025893881917,
-0.03605104982852936,
-0.011097673326730728,
-0.03079589083790779,
0.03620346635580063,
-0.01828492060303688,
-0.005359984934329987,
-0.024902721866965294,
0.03863980993628502,
0.009591217152774334,
0.048345550894737244,
0.0024774535559117794,
0.0246924739331007,
0.025730730965733528,
0.04521401971578598,
-0.011996996589004993,
0.019084664061665535,
-0.0032653305679559708,
-0.03806455060839653,
-0.005155229475349188,
-0.014263603836297989,
0.0572013258934021,
0.0012979451566934586,
0.0252153892070055,
0.03149564191699028,
-0.00015355917275883257,
-0.0013101411750540137,
0.028476152569055557,
0.0006326724542304873,
0.02517300844192505,
0.023205745965242386,
-0.018678443506360054,
-0.005086281802505255,
-0.04077131301164627,
-0.027814241126179695,
-0.02145780250430107,
0.02431477978825569,
0.013685856014490128,
0.008479534648358822,
-0.026892703026533127,
0.029275856912136078,
-0.03542374074459076,
-0.018472125753760338,
-0.02462276630103588,
0.010291735641658306,
-0.028449062258005142,
-0.02473197691142559,
-0.03129551187157631,
-0.009833496063947678,
0.017464958131313324,
-0.013158704154193401,
-0.03631361946463585,
-0.07029397785663605,
0.01088029332458973,
0.012660536915063858,
0.00873146764934063,
-0.03184397518634796,
0.029405122622847557,
-0.01635099947452545,
-0.029425842687487602,
0.03174932673573494,
-0.06024939566850662,
0.015941467136144638,
-0.028269989416003227,
0.007370352745056152,
-0.01195615716278553,
0.004724177997559309,
0.022591743618249893,
0.04953085258603096,
-0.016572263091802597,
0.03558173403143883,
0.041600730270147324,
0.026575474068522453,
0.015845194458961487,
-0.019835222512483597,
-0.01815706677734852,
0.0026614773087203503,
-0.014721321873366833,
0.01591859757900238,
-0.02193155698478222,
-0.019268054515123367,
0.030471602454781532,
-0.02809545025229454,
0.013411564752459526,
-0.022571293637156487,
-0.02756183035671711,
0.010069567710161209,
0.06589629501104355,
0.01361866481602192,
0.01164715364575386,
-0.009218156337738037,
-0.02581603266298771,
0.007964019663631916,
-0.04779576137661934,
-0.00247298670001328,
-0.058759238570928574,
0.01863304153084755,
0.0023134297225624323,
-0.0081523098051548,
-0.06561705470085144,
0.06220833584666252,
-0.029650665819644928,
0.017087077721953392,
0.01558283343911171,
0.006002233363687992,
-0.026614302769303322,
-0.02956445701420307,
0.022478211671113968,
0.004565143957734108,
-0.019843406975269318,
-0.017875762656331062,
0.017496075481176376,
-0.033753905445337296,
-0.009683636948466301,
0.0026154976803809404,
0.019258549436926842,
0.01904177851974964,
0.03138738498091698,
0.03430157154798508,
-0.026330403983592987,
0.05047828331589699,
0.05702037364244461,
-0.021010177209973335,
-0.034464895725250244,
-0.0552540123462677,
-0.006301008630543947,
0.06019926071166992,
0.025399697944521904,
0.02772168256342411,
0.0021243479568511248,
-0.013644817285239697,
0.02106928825378418,
-0.029663609340786934,
0.04160996899008751,
-0.015944229438900948,
-0.04240461811423302,
-0.002831363119184971,
-0.005325044970959425,
-0.01675259880721569,
-0.01042214222252369,
-0.014865678735077381,
0.027130339294672012,
-0.05358264222741127,
-0.006234041415154934,
0.07574111968278885,
0.006926027592271566,
-0.005906757898628712,
-0.009838358499109745,
0.023810280486941338,
0.013083708472549915,
0.028488149866461754,
-0.012870709411799908,
-0.03162900358438492,
-0.0017964538419619203,
0.0020383044611662626,
0.009435348212718964,
0.0032880615908652544,
0.027327312156558037,
-0.006088843569159508,
0.012513816356658936,
0.04696881026029587,
-0.06060187891125679,
0.0006178607582114637,
0.020192043855786324,
0.013551388867199421,
-0.037621501833200455,
0.019047273322939873,
-0.0013150020968168974,
-0.0202977042645216,
0.00874884333461523,
0.04664214327931404,
0.04424967244267464,
-0.017951223999261856,
-0.05162511765956879,
-0.04681354761123657,
0.014193627052009106,
-0.031085824593901634,
-0.02863800711929798,
-0.005259051453322172,
-0.04279562830924988,
-0.017498241737484932,
-0.014259801246225834,
0.0019701351411640644,
-0.0057764663361012936,
-0.06195501983165741,
0.08901206403970718,
-0.07840576022863388,
-0.008403428830206394,
-0.029114095494151115,
0.034714553505182266,
-0.00011713724961737171,
0.031858716160058975,
-0.015765756368637085,
0.034396637231111526,
-0.031229954212903976,
0.007234380580484867,
0.02517382800579071,
0.01891522854566574,
0.0023489848244935274,
0.0006780329858884215,
-0.015922654420137405,
0.06286974251270294,
0.06709648668766022,
0.009555071592330933,
0.028529223054647446,
0.016426971182227135,
-0.017294257879257202,
0.03102583810687065,
-0.005513068754225969,
0.027243608608841896,
-0.044674474745988846,
-0.016374191269278526,
-0.044095106422901154,
-0.0001851709675975144,
0.02075788751244545,
-0.0014225081540644169,
-0.034615885466337204,
-0.06095311418175697,
-0.06019985303282738,
0.005964216776192188,
-0.032075975090265274,
-0.03829154744744301,
-0.013866985216736794,
0.0020472288597375154,
0.01803222857415676,
-0.0009931155946105719,
-0.021001940593123436,
-0.004556150175631046,
0.0006733265472576022,
-0.009144021198153496,
-0.011498672887682915,
-0.014795109629631042,
0.016286000609397888,
-0.009225423447787762,
-0.010153789073228836,
0.0659690648317337,
0.01746968738734722,
-0.018066277727484703,
0.024235064163804054,
-0.011264618486166,
-0.009312320500612259,
0.014802563935518265,
-0.002499824156984687,
-0.019571278244256973,
-0.016407031565904617,
-0.014221719466149807,
0.01565202884376049,
-0.0006912555545568466,
-0.019204050302505493,
-0.010090867057442665,
0.019550543278455734,
-0.0015757059445604682,
0.0019440012983977795,
-0.023504743352532387,
-0.01544321607798338,
-0.030280807986855507,
-0.062070317566394806,
-0.025598878040909767,
-0.0008641669410280883,
0.012355376966297626,
0.018371207639575005,
-0.01398474257439375,
0.013697356916964054,
0.022648878395557404,
-0.06894446164369583,
0.029658960178494453,
-0.014748241752386093,
0.02248157188296318,
0.015278724022209644,
0.013165457174181938,
-0.009660802781581879,
-0.04226704314351082,
0.017315812408924103,
0.011294997297227383,
-0.0027866442687809467,
-0.0480504035949707,
-0.002712127286940813,
-0.040545493364334106,
-0.01803772523999214,
0.022970575839281082,
-0.02021961100399494,
-0.032446544617414474,
0.014559007249772549,
-0.03597715497016907,
0.008618311956524849,
0.02728026546537876,
-0.010007278993725777,
0.024172702804207802,
0.02306634560227394,
-0.018626241013407707,
0.019078774377703667,
0.018010221421718597,
-0.011480875313282013,
-0.009077873080968857,
-0.03733476623892784,
0.05983550846576691,
0.00033349881414324045,
0.01595044881105423,
-0.007614961825311184,
0.011270073242485523,
0.01526000164449215,
0.014083362184464931,
0.01768532209098339,
-0.008290938101708889,
0.03134020045399666,
0.0055347466841340065,
-0.05028952285647392,
-0.03167598322033882,
-0.028093302622437477,
0.00017045259301085025,
0.010881807655096054,
0.03149520233273506,
-0.008580127730965614,
-0.017147473990917206,
0.0564262755215168,
0.012542398646473885,
0.001886875368654728,
0.010721560567617416,
-0.018715649843215942,
-0.0036670896224677563,
0.019902173429727554,
0.0064512863755226135,
0.018938623368740082,
0.026956504210829735,
0.016017694026231766,
-0.004107415210455656,
-0.015915006399154663,
-0.04025669023394585,
0.03028441034257412,
0.017909502610564232,
0.033264800906181335,
-0.02906722202897072,
-0.0561690516769886,
-0.002338631544262171,
-0.03794174641370773,
-0.05450740084052086,
-0.01657520793378353,
0.041384756565093994,
-0.035597749054431915,
-0.01553677674382925,
0.014500526711344719,
0.03158526122570038,
0.0036599792074412107,
-0.024135300889611244,
0.03801028057932854,
-0.01726132072508335,
-0.04214527830481529,
-0.14070792496204376,
-0.01789671555161476,
-0.013006476685404778,
-0.03209741413593292,
-0.024905668571591377,
-0.015365386381745338,
-0.032314665615558624,
0.007640794385224581,
-0.0023492753971368074,
0.007878825068473816,
-0.03788691759109497,
-0.01099332980811596,
0.026253195479512215,
-0.02525736205279827,
-0.04479261115193367,
0.017879411578178406,
-0.05035636946558952,
0.0038747796788811684,
-0.07590826600790024,
0.029021454975008965,
0.014361836947500706,
-0.011307135224342346,
0.013361133635044098,
-0.03079218976199627,
0.024769868701696396,
-0.014082853682339191,
-0.0063007306307554245,
-0.06422765552997589,
-0.036175016313791275,
-0.035969436168670654,
0.010100997984409332,
-0.03108370490372181,
-0.0070146722719073296,
0.08928274363279343,
-0.04053761065006256,
0.008511929772794247,
0.022055665031075478,
-0.017316065728664398,
-0.012066042050719261,
-0.001264084130525589,
0.0007610233151353896,
0.04214853420853615,
-0.00998160894960165,
-0.007032805122435093,
-0.02559066005051136,
0.022672301158308983,
-0.003195878816768527,
-0.009821811690926552,
-0.057663001120090485,
-0.042843643575906754,
-0.06034611910581589,
0.027088046073913574,
0.010900292545557022,
0.05901021882891655,
-0.010140282101929188,
-0.01628919690847397,
0.02021554298698902,
-0.02576141618192196,
0.02907971292734146,
0.04715891182422638,
0.022204704582691193,
-0.011011725291609764,
-0.07897394895553589,
-0.014422435313463211,
-0.042958393692970276,
-0.0014844265533611178,
-0.02546463906764984,
0.007914815098047256,
-0.013982396572828293,
0.0094162467867136,
-0.027039024978876114,
-0.01937706209719181,
0.009886747226119041,
-0.0778307393193245,
-0.011698425747454166,
-0.03070255182683468,
0.0250402819365263,
0.019723236560821533,
-0.03524871543049812,
-0.018230071291327477,
-0.010919797234237194,
-0.00026807296671904624,
-0.07133138924837112,
-0.0007478977786377072,
0.06402858346700668,
0.03392386808991432,
0.00588361406698823,
-0.01829446293413639,
-0.006578901316970587,
-0.056500811129808426,
-0.04711800813674927,
-0.015926053747534752,
0.006857769098132849,
0.03912152349948883,
-0.023559510707855225,
0.031423017382621765,
0.011559251695871353,
0.008592484518885612,
-0.023571118712425232,
-0.00921974889934063,
-0.007653675973415375,
-0.0031932287383824587,
-0.002675977535545826,
-0.007768585346639156,
-0.048334527760744095,
-0.04019976779818535,
0.03680191934108734,
0.0313749797642231,
0.02619464136660099,
-0.05385470390319824,
-0.009469794109463692,
0.012570979073643684,
-0.035222068428993225,
0.049067702144384384,
-0.058196257799863815,
-0.007130700629204512,
0.028413334861397743,
0.0053299241699278355,
-0.002800878370180726,
-0.0012568545062094927,
0.03809472545981407,
0.006164351478219032,
0.014749827794730663,
-0.031243735924363136,
0.0020219432190060616,
-0.00024544194457121193,
0.09593594819307327,
0.037881478667259216,
0.034373968839645386,
0.0008427123539149761,
0.04305171221494675,
-0.01363243255764246,
0.039595916867256165,
0.019148916006088257,
-0.004728687461465597,
-0.006194319110363722,
0.007977272383868694,
0.001442211214452982,
-0.04334287717938423,
-0.016564877703785896,
-0.004468454048037529,
0.021729132160544395,
-0.0059554134495556355,
-0.0020367831457406282,
-0.041543085128068924,
0.0027302540838718414,
0.00670573441311717,
-0.0137783233076334,
0.0019789361394941807,
-0.0032309044618159533,
-0.02809157408773899,
0.0035824989899992943,
-0.011566140688955784,
0.05058170482516289,
0.009912909008562565,
0.005233219359070063,
0.05057140812277794,
-0.003593701170757413,
0.03814008831977844,
0.020407861098647118,
0.032370541244745255,
-0.025107041001319885,
-0.03590523079037666,
-0.03983822837471962,
-0.022086361423134804,
0.057606447488069534,
-0.019578803330659866,
0.008943354710936546,
-0.03246455267071724,
-0.018813136965036392,
-0.047323793172836304,
0.009470228105783463,
-0.01947309821844101,
0.019543906673789024,
0.05806075409054756,
-0.032824184745550156,
-0.010061349719762802,
0.01926814392209053,
0.0542924739420414,
-0.004825437441468239,
0.02824477292597294,
0.045570988208055496,
0.01625160314142704,
0.01273264829069376,
0.0285527054220438,
0.028688877820968628,
0.02248399145901203,
0.032965030521154404,
0.004872570279985666,
-0.042930856347084045,
-0.024419190362095833,
0.014066082425415516,
0.01271151378750801,
-0.008875524625182152,
0.014402699656784534,
0.0071099624037742615,
-0.01011659950017929,
0.017385870218276978,
0.017011411488056183,
0.03615281730890274,
0.042713019996881485,
-0.03508186340332031,
-0.0221144687384367,
-0.006238168571144342,
-0.00015925138723105192,
0.00586456386372447,
-0.0198944341391325,
-0.06734690815210342,
-0.04816972464323044,
0.0597718320786953,
-0.00016763304302003235,
-0.011185131035745144,
-0.012190123088657856,
0.04202441871166229,
-0.025203444063663483,
-0.0030489573255181313,
0.007617210503667593,
-0.006070025730878115,
0.045455969870090485,
-0.009318899363279343,
0.0291980542242527,
0.05743827670812607,
-0.01076493225991726,
-0.049115438014268875,
-0.0000266640472545987,
0.00780699634924531,
-0.019131839275360107,
0.012391651049256325,
0.02912360243499279,
0.03811156749725342,
0.003795991651713848,
0.003032111329957843,
-0.006739580072462559,
0.05155961215496063,
-0.027486488223075867,
-0.020295187830924988,
-0.024618839845061302,
-0.003152093617245555,
-0.006481855642050505,
-0.0013530036667361856,
0.05519615113735199,
0.015211445279419422,
-0.005699894391000271,
0.00197424809448421
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:58
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
You mentioned that the two smaller loans have been replaced - can I have a copy of the loan agreements for my file. Is there anything else that the Funder needs from us before providing the rest of the agreed money and has the Funder finalised the acquisition of the units from the smaller unitholders."
857This certainly shows that Mr Zdrilic was still speaking in terms of "the Funder" (although by now he must have known it was not IPC). Mr Zdrilic was also expressing a desire to "meet the people from the Funder side".
858But he was not complaining that misrepresentations had been made to him or that HTT was in breach of its obligations under the Heads of Agreement. He was also aware that "the two smaller loans" (which I would infer to be the Frenkail and Goncalves loans) had by then been refinanced.
859On 9 December 2004 Mr Zdrilic attended a board meeting of Sentel.
860The minutes of that meeting read:-
"Robert mentioned that David Brodie (Head of Planning) would like to be fully briefed on all that is going on with the site - he will also help us with the DIPLAR. They would like to know if he could buy the hospital site.
Sam was not aware that this could be possible before the settlement of the land. But Robert said we can sell section by section and obtain a deposit - all deals can be done on contingent on zoning [sic]. Then when the funder comes in it will be a bonus as we have started the ball rolling".
861This minute shows that, as at 9 December 2004, Mr Zdrilic was content to wait until the "funder comes in".
862On 17 December 2004 Mr Zdrilic sent a further email to Mr Renshall in which he complained that his requests for information were not being met. He said:-
"As you are aware we have negotiated and signed an agreement to work together and stop further legal costs on both sides. I have taken a huge reduction from 50% holding in LEC directly and indirectly to less than 10%, agreed that the interest on my loan is now 10% instead of 20% and other substantial expenses including legal fees were foregone.
This was done on the basis of your many representations on behalf of HTT as a director of HTT. Some of those representations included the Joint Venture Funder buying the 'smaller unit holders and shareholders' in HTT and providing about $12.0m to pay off the existing loans and prepay interest on those loans for about six months."
863At this point in the email, Mr Zdrilic is making reference to what appears to be the Eleventh and Thirteenth Representations, or something similar.
864However Mr Zdrilic went on to say:-
"I made a point that I would like to see the Funder representatives and that we should hold a HTT directors meeting. Again you stayed silent on this which means you are not really interested. If you have any concerns about me knowing things it can only mean one thing and that is that something is wrong.
If there is a delay about something happening like the Funder not providing the money because certain things on our side have not been fulfilled it is not the end of the word but I like to know what we have not done - I just want to be informed. My understanding at the moment is that more rehabilitation needs to be done before the Funder will provide the money - that is the extent of my knowledge."
865Mr Zdrilic asked for "copies of loan agreements between HTT and lenders" and for some further particular information including "the terms of the Funder funding" and the "latest with the Funder equity purchase of 'smaller' unit holders and shareholders".
866This shows that Mr Zdrilic was well aware that the funding that HTT had in the Heads of Agreement promised to raise was not to hand and was expressing dissatisfaction about the amount of information being provided.
867But he was also expressing the view that it was "not the end of the world" if the lack of funding was a result of things "on our side" not being "fulfilled".
868On 18 January 2005 HTT entered into a Deed of Loan with Provident. The loan was for an amount of $6 million at an interest rate of 10.99 per cent over a two-year term.
|
[
-0.01817869022488594,
0.04040944203734398,
-0.009177037514746189,
0.01004253700375557,
-0.02807800844311714,
-0.04525948315858841,
0.0214174073189497,
-0.0390482172369957,
0.0007293427479453385,
0.016023507341742516,
0.00099616136867553,
0.034731704741716385,
-0.03778721019625664,
0.024469805881381035,
-0.02410164102911949,
-0.02954169176518917,
0.03148354962468147,
-0.03971496969461441,
0.0022273752838373184,
-0.044340748339891434,
-0.0012520300224423409,
0.013147905468940735,
0.06370630860328674,
0.014643763191998005,
-0.008283931761980057,
0.003887171158567071,
-0.05415812507271767,
0.007099939044564962,
0.0519719272851944,
0.021048501133918762,
-0.0021561728790402412,
0.02615024894475937,
0.0842343419790268,
-0.01467193104326725,
0.009572342969477177,
-0.025499064475297928,
0.021281110122799873,
-0.01495360303670168,
-0.02706274576485157,
0.009149822406470776,
-0.018174907192587852,
0.022485651075839996,
0.005220151040703058,
-0.011426755227148533,
0.05835521221160889,
-0.03247889131307602,
0.003601746167987585,
-0.028137240558862686,
0.003960153087973595,
0.016528073698282242,
-0.048552270978689194,
-0.027890194207429886,
0.02767431177198887,
-0.05111265182495117,
-0.023165037855505943,
-0.015715233981609344,
-0.02288852632045746,
-0.004523834679275751,
-0.04874386265873909,
0.02349863573908806,
0.010528579354286194,
0.019037017598748207,
-0.054867926985025406,
0.0050981915555894375,
0.00602059718221426,
0.11510303616523743,
0.011642170138657093,
-0.01483585499227047,
0.009258436970412731,
-0.004308674018830061,
-0.036093153059482574,
0.019247546792030334,
-0.004478064831346273,
-0.010042690671980381,
-0.08903806656599045,
0.01104820054024458,
0.009795042686164379,
0.012781561352312565,
0.02631828375160694,
0.025747966021299362,
0.06360030919313431,
-0.025665849447250366,
-0.030714241787791252,
0.0026278181467205286,
-0.007925180718302727,
-0.0020465338602662086,
-0.011923052370548248,
0.019451916217803955,
0.02124638855457306,
-0.031861647963523865,
0.014866014942526817,
0.00920410081744194,
0.023640239611268044,
-0.030775919556617737,
-0.00833674892783165,
0.013869715854525566,
-0.06717119365930557,
0.050019968301057816,
0.0014655721606686711,
0.02326367050409317,
-0.004778998903930187,
0.020181674510240555,
0.0022823999170213938,
-0.04457186907529831,
0.0069667017087340355,
0.014101075939834118,
0.05991680175065994,
0.05019751936197281,
0.011267111636698246,
-0.010139345191419125,
-0.003846097271889448,
0.005777222570031881,
0.016635745763778687,
-0.006767295766621828,
-0.006843969225883484,
0.004178832285106182,
0.001304274657741189,
-0.011284609325230122,
0.0711410790681839,
-0.011879472061991692,
0.028006551787257195,
0.0055542862974107265,
0.026125170290470123,
0.0005772961885668337,
-0.06528384983539581,
-0.00976037047803402,
-0.00146628194488585,
-0.0005136359250172973,
-0.008005226962268353,
0.020691346377134323,
-0.01673303358256817,
0.01889072172343731,
-0.029250511899590492,
-0.01827494241297245,
-0.0018011359497904778,
0.004205449018627405,
0.009206642396748066,
-0.032615214586257935,
0.012646041810512543,
-0.043527182191610336,
0.03838995844125748,
0.017136964946985245,
0.00147679029032588,
-0.05154074728488922,
0.020340872928500175,
-0.02707914263010025,
0.02461935020983219,
0.01558949239552021,
-0.002406556624919176,
0.044522568583488464,
-0.0037301008123904467,
-0.004566646181046963,
0.011273869313299656,
0.011811994016170502,
-0.017585689201951027,
-0.03201984241604805,
-0.007107146084308624,
-0.043346140533685684,
0.02482997626066208,
0.06988278031349182,
-0.061952728778123856,
0.030948080122470856,
-0.031030412763357162,
-0.04172730818390846,
-0.013164937496185303,
0.051569368690252304,
-0.02072100341320038,
0.03667924925684929,
-0.023259587585926056,
-0.019780844449996948,
0.021842271089553833,
-0.015841495245695114,
0.05117841437458992,
0.0026319033931940794,
-0.023000244051218033,
0.02727113850414753,
0.04766028746962547,
0.00296304770745337,
0.00898805633187294,
-0.01767154037952423,
-0.023066379129886627,
0.04452585428953171,
-0.014235506765544415,
-0.005535885691642761,
-0.04250330105423927,
0.008244132623076439,
-0.04808179661631584,
-0.038662198930978775,
-0.003004851285368204,
0.019358690828084946,
-0.0064379130490124226,
0.014492710120975971,
0.03871580958366394,
0.008569600060582161,
0.023919757455587387,
-0.03577654808759689,
0.004126014653593302,
-0.040353208780288696,
-0.005633085034787655,
-0.016440855339169502,
-0.0024545148480683565,
0.03102247603237629,
0.0703444555401802,
-0.04725877568125725,
-0.04473192244768143,
0.02561607025563717,
-0.01471862755715847,
0.0011303620412945747,
-0.024707451462745667,
-0.0673263743519783,
0.00023246735509019345,
-0.01503189466893673,
-0.0001582733093528077,
0.01430132519453764,
0.016798507422208786,
-0.014717149548232555,
-0.017617372795939445,
-0.03207233548164368,
0.010518672876060009,
-0.019802125170826912,
-0.046886004507541656,
0.03619914874434471,
-0.013606159947812557,
-0.00912643875926733,
0.028408009558916092,
0.029464248567819595,
-0.049784447997808456,
0.006793537177145481,
-0.03419188782572746,
-0.03244677558541298,
-0.008311811834573746,
-0.03179757669568062,
-0.0016167295398190618,
-0.014682344160974026,
0.04128322750329971,
0.042572200298309326,
0.01814132370054722,
0.006739524193108082,
0.00504571758210659,
-0.011922678910195827,
-0.03301764279603958,
-0.0037211671005934477,
-0.020742131397128105,
-0.017790237441658974,
-0.030919034034013748,
0.020267751067876816,
-0.014913245104253292,
-0.006433957722038031,
0.03299950808286667,
0.0049988566897809505,
-0.005084139294922352,
-0.012323561124503613,
-0.00768436910584569,
-0.004007196519523859,
-0.009511230513453484,
0.013561132363975048,
0.010339023545384407,
0.004196910187602043,
0.004227634984999895,
0.01215367205440998,
0.018607262521982193,
0.04415884241461754,
0.0032572264317423105,
0.008405040949583054,
-0.033481717109680176,
0.003318591509014368,
-0.029606055468320847,
-0.08253330737352371,
0.02888238988816738,
-0.0033951960504055023,
0.01907460391521454,
0.015525557100772858,
-0.006782646756619215,
0.01755562610924244,
0.016199380159378052,
0.04618903994560242,
0.04293062910437584,
0.0000014510683286061976,
0.02613121084868908,
0.01591707393527031,
0.020471088588237762,
0.028322484344244003,
0.027239279821515083,
-0.03560717776417732,
0.02336166612803936,
0.04049548879265785,
-0.032882049679756165,
-0.006312435958534479,
0.02657708153128624,
-0.03501756861805916,
-0.009456755593419075,
0.024391528218984604,
0.0696353167295456,
-0.0031117433682084084,
-0.06777972728013992,
-0.04983144626021385,
-0.015499400906264782,
-0.15996477007865906,
-0.013567465357482433,
-0.020383451133966446,
0.002030059928074479,
-0.0049712094478309155,
0.019128115847706795,
-0.03251437097787857,
0.018793299794197083,
-0.027995942160487175,
-0.010060488246381283,
0.007801043801009655,
-0.04866768419742584,
-0.008411463350057602,
0.033921755850315094,
-0.00012660655193030834,
0.010470828972756863,
0.01602226123213768,
0.05045410245656967,
0.02658013254404068,
-0.01568726636469364,
0.008836708962917328,
-0.03628316521644592,
0.03556623309850693,
0.021046239882707596,
-0.025472689419984818,
0.022468477487564087,
0.014309626072645187,
0.03815704211592674,
-0.03001108579337597,
0.016276102513074875,
0.01244437973946333,
0.02629023976624012,
-0.009966263547539711,
0.04979866370558739,
-0.002121348399668932,
0.052760712802410126,
0.06353654712438583,
-0.08019692450761795,
-0.02965039759874344,
-0.024580178782343864,
0.03261697292327881,
0.07041829079389572,
0.006564151030033827,
0.025940287858247757,
0.011212006211280823,
-0.06550472229719162,
0.016668980941176414,
-0.019788026809692383,
0.012461435981094837,
0.03424510359764099,
0.0002447849838063121,
0.010314881801605225,
-0.03170517459511757,
-0.046812865883111954,
0.008187017403542995,
-0.031101807951927185,
0.027878180146217346,
-0.008798686787486076,
-0.018750043585896492,
-0.0239422544836998,
-0.05196978896856308,
-0.032365832477808,
0.00041267796768806875,
0.0009902480524033308,
-0.04176326468586922,
0.004717572126537561,
0.02448054403066635,
-0.04925401136279106,
0.029245691373944283,
-0.007073812186717987,
0.013100013136863708,
-0.01331660058349371,
-0.0031288559548556805,
-0.0057319593615829945,
0.03312912955880165,
0.024152761325240135,
-0.06421440839767456,
-0.0034657421056181192,
-0.002510686870664358,
-0.11403192579746246,
-0.018708836287260056,
0.05144887417554855,
-0.01838644966483116,
0.01880202628672123,
-0.0072040557861328125,
0.01842113770544529,
-0.0015783393755555153,
0.05126703158020973,
0.007051416207104921,
0.25855353474617004,
-0.0024876997340470552,
0.002656341064721346,
0.033636532723903656,
0.030305474996566772,
-0.031366925686597824,
0.03600144758820534,
0.039255768060684204,
0.007102707400918007,
-0.04453454166650772,
0.008851251564919949,
0.010564885102212429,
0.022992754355072975,
0.03376809507608414,
-0.015971900895237923,
0.005288352724164724,
-0.062146011739969254,
-0.006396087352186441,
0.05953380465507507,
0.013313796371221542,
0.04584110155701637,
0.015323953703045845,
-0.00024053323431871831,
0.01066477783024311,
-0.04258541390299797,
-0.03659190610051155,
0.03411705419421196,
0.03237808868288994,
-0.046665605157613754,
-0.0323341004550457,
-0.017350666224956512,
-0.010851613245904446,
0.056836389005184174,
-0.013464146293699741,
0.02622763067483902,
0.01713421940803528,
-0.01649179682135582,
0.023609189316630363,
-0.0036766785196959972,
0.03752513229846954,
-0.002979008248075843,
-0.03405786678195,
-0.0073691378347575665,
-0.0429813414812088,
-0.04012208804488182,
0.026477336883544922,
-0.03402359038591385,
0.01938496343791485,
-0.004236280452460051,
0.00468524731695652,
-0.004566418472677469,
0.02602243237197399,
-0.025868024677038193,
-0.012713978998363018,
-0.03085619956254959,
0.0250591691583395,
-0.03726635128259659,
0.059459388256073,
0.016472233459353447,
0.04466381296515465,
0.03764742612838745,
0.03702916204929352,
-0.008440421894192696,
0.04397137090563774,
-0.031454287469387054,
-0.03414631634950638,
-0.036367323249578476,
-0.01951717957854271,
0.028237881138920784,
0.032129134982824326,
0.01287931576371193,
-0.011607863940298557,
0.00048590530059300363,
0.020549166947603226,
0.04954963177442551,
-0.03837839886546135,
-0.021634278818964958,
0.01892973855137825,
-0.035315126180648804,
0.009046017192304134,
-0.06466082483530045,
-0.02593984641134739,
-0.01841595582664013,
0.048579685389995575,
0.01505452860146761,
-0.0043985904194414616,
-0.018297627568244934,
0.02710794098675251,
-0.025740090757608414,
-0.03287431225180626,
-0.019994433969259262,
0.000900939223356545,
0.028354555368423462,
-0.024830522015690804,
-0.02692761830985546,
-0.02855593152344227,
-0.00581813370808959,
-0.04807773977518082,
-0.04431477189064026,
-0.028887450695037842,
0.01790083944797516,
0.021052151918411255,
0.013048791326582432,
-0.028050662949681282,
0.017803499475121498,
-0.036830171942710876,
-0.016624679788947105,
0.02320769429206848,
-0.0390130877494812,
0.02909938246011734,
-0.0145651800557971,
0.02995714731514454,
0.001474162912927568,
0.003262650454416871,
0.024621257558465004,
0.06649817526340485,
-0.020076289772987366,
0.06946427375078201,
0.03748760744929314,
0.023839963600039482,
-0.020741771906614304,
0.0128193199634552,
-0.05554250255227089,
0.008851743303239346,
-0.015261477790772915,
0.03508982062339783,
0.0014803720405325294,
-0.011316440999507904,
0.008819290436804295,
0.004152119159698486,
-0.010499014519155025,
-0.01929115317761898,
-0.041656240820884705,
0.007168386597186327,
0.06470262259244919,
0.030974876135587692,
-0.04546796903014183,
-0.004620518535375595,
-0.08213219791650772,
0.006616224069148302,
-0.034755438566207886,
0.002876833314076066,
-0.03940282762050629,
-0.02665689028799534,
0.0032121383119374514,
0.02049790881574154,
-0.0641946941614151,
0.056107208132743835,
-0.05511268600821495,
-0.019738011062145233,
0.035254377871751785,
0.02464420534670353,
-0.02102082222700119,
-0.03479435667395592,
0.02267165668308735,
0.020842501893639565,
-0.030988402664661407,
-0.03505025804042816,
0.024281678721308708,
-0.032722108066082,
-0.001854851609095931,
-0.001939591602422297,
0.004668486304581165,
0.01367913093417883,
-0.015820473432540894,
0.05410678684711456,
-0.02167370915412903,
0.05176278203725815,
0.031247345730662346,
-0.03059486299753189,
-0.030844734981656075,
-0.05728231742978096,
-0.032289378345012665,
0.038521658629179,
0.009592719376087189,
-0.01494081225246191,
0.0049781640991568565,
0.027947019785642624,
0.01187761127948761,
-0.03185351565480232,
0.02153608202934265,
0.01301274262368679,
-0.0355951227247715,
-0.0047934637404978275,
-0.019014080986380577,
-0.007308967877179384,
-0.004567964468151331,
-0.013700976967811584,
0.07422207295894623,
-0.07868397235870361,
-0.0204343032091856,
0.07083641737699509,
0.028521092608571053,
-0.016255762428045273,
0.027956046164035797,
0.010763891972601414,
0.04736052453517914,
0.04849673807621002,
-0.006119710858911276,
-0.04768385738134384,
0.026804905384778976,
0.00040765252197161317,
-0.002311429474502802,
-0.006563852075487375,
0.014876816421747208,
-0.007128389552235603,
0.013672457076609135,
0.04261915758252144,
-0.03479563817381859,
-0.019294973462820053,
0.020732784643769264,
0.005586383864283562,
-0.001681052497588098,
0.02423383854329586,
0.023679228499531746,
-0.029075978323817253,
0.019910605624318123,
0.05458878353238106,
-0.0011287520173937082,
-0.03660062327980995,
-0.00686682341620326,
-0.02622193656861782,
0.036685049533843994,
-0.05964142829179764,
-0.01699533313512802,
-0.005958111956715584,
-0.052866991609334946,
-0.009044730104506016,
-0.04012651368975639,
0.023497967049479485,
-0.009251080453395844,
-0.05930492654442787,
0.0460384376347065,
-0.055979251861572266,
-0.006402631290256977,
-0.026786575093865395,
0.04271179810166359,
0.024179503321647644,
0.026171531528234482,
-0.006547778379172087,
0.014050476253032684,
-0.028142882511019707,
0.0347314290702343,
0.04181927070021629,
-0.016713755205273628,
0.001657776185311377,
-0.02979167364537716,
-0.029083043336868286,
-0.00253208982758224,
0.059027835726737976,
0.001514620496891439,
0.0012410986237227917,
0.01773643307387829,
-0.001774368342012167,
0.016757383942604065,
0.007357075810432434,
0.030532775446772575,
-0.038317322731018066,
-0.015575872734189034,
-0.05609134957194328,
-0.029432442039251328,
-0.010061989538371563,
0.018906909972429276,
-0.03225267678499222,
-0.057562392204999924,
-0.03142409399151802,
0.013158156536519527,
-0.017674332484602928,
-0.054631877690553665,
-0.01321498118340969,
0.00607179244980216,
-0.004764379933476448,
0.009308519773185253,
-0.037876322865486145,
0.02852894924581051,
-0.017183398827910423,
-0.03350558131933212,
0.03263433277606964,
-0.014696447178721428,
0.00888411607593298,
-0.009782252833247185,
0.017865130677819252,
0.030590521171689034,
0.007017265073955059,
-0.021777290850877762,
-0.002902604639530182,
-0.000888060312718153,
-0.011873142793774605,
-0.011617161333560944,
0.012339846231043339,
0.008061274886131287,
0.01798921264708042,
-0.026101019233465195,
0.023133374750614166,
-0.019626779481768608,
-0.0032754233106970787,
-0.011908912099897861,
0.003299856325611472,
-0.007304338272660971,
0.0001912971056299284,
-0.015941694378852844,
-0.02765820547938347,
-0.005725071299821138,
-0.04873225465416908,
-0.03224297612905502,
0.0136423883959651,
-0.019534708932042122,
-0.011180117726325989,
-0.006751514971256256,
0.013032660819590092,
0.030531354248523712,
-0.0693502277135849,
0.02707662247121334,
0.012943356297910213,
0.05713506042957306,
0.013961090706288815,
0.032935209572315216,
-0.0004807206569239497,
-0.018885018303990364,
0.014238914474844933,
-0.0029045746196061373,
-0.0014653127873316407,
-0.04921520873904228,
0.0023641218431293964,
-0.032046157866716385,
-0.010775147005915642,
-0.005511618684977293,
-0.04444487765431404,
-0.06406448781490326,
0.031810861080884933,
-0.03361973166465759,
-0.011399468407034874,
0.015929710119962692,
-0.003284786595031619,
0.03720545023679733,
0.009466219693422318,
0.01834084466099739,
0.001135704223997891,
0.005776632577180862,
-0.04135310649871826,
-0.01586330495774746,
-0.05913349241018295,
0.06662581115961075,
-0.0044896421022713184,
0.0076139080338180065,
0.034925736486911774,
0.012725498527288437,
-0.01723536103963852,
0.01119651272892952,
0.0017075554933398962,
-0.014557079412043095,
-0.009874876588582993,
-0.014615531079471111,
-0.037222184240818024,
-0.011112255044281483,
-0.021229665726423264,
0.031803425401449203,
0.009975173510611057,
0.05284053459763527,
-0.006237013731151819,
-0.011564903892576694,
0.047950807958841324,
0.02414522133767605,
0.015680840238928795,
-0.026713166385889053,
-0.002639371668919921,
-0.007947731763124466,
0.030075008049607277,
-0.0022952675353735685,
0.042935535311698914,
0.02625664696097374,
-0.0021017370745539665,
-0.013396582566201687,
-0.008944941684603691,
-0.06895468384027481,
0.0469641350209713,
0.0033934765961021185,
0.024359088391065598,
-0.008869541808962822,
-0.060514774173498154,
0.012372402474284172,
-0.0167770367115736,
-0.0026973928324878216,
-0.030600547790527344,
0.02363765984773636,
-0.015833834186196327,
-0.0007448905962519348,
0.008521913550794125,
0.027719011530280113,
0.027670670300722122,
-0.015357479453086853,
-0.009318504482507706,
-0.020934386178851128,
-0.021441714838147163,
-0.1363437920808792,
-0.0064783175475895405,
-0.021786315366625786,
-0.06444020569324493,
-0.013355834409594536,
-0.0021781562827527523,
-0.017834991216659546,
0.04703444242477417,
-0.02878325618803501,
-0.0037354209925979376,
0.004175352398306131,
-0.013825594447553158,
0.011491904966533184,
-0.004740709438920021,
-0.001122479559853673,
-0.0007025342783890665,
-0.04160040244460106,
-0.00017689637024886906,
-0.06522698700428009,
0.052869994193315506,
0.02193172462284565,
0.00446553947404027,
0.006535115651786327,
-0.005440037697553635,
0.021957799792289734,
0.0019855904392898083,
0.01030728593468666,
-0.04763855040073395,
-0.03208427503705025,
-0.002248317003250122,
-0.025323940441012383,
0.0023860903456807137,
-0.013984417542815208,
0.06533178687095642,
-0.03272010758519173,
0.009505657479166985,
0.0016432249685749412,
0.006371269002556801,
-0.009408707730472088,
-0.005470598582178354,
-0.031590357422828674,
0.01790686510503292,
-0.031801845878362656,
0.002390640787780285,
-0.023308828473091125,
0.03359442949295044,
0.014905614778399467,
-0.01045306958258152,
-0.06845290958881378,
-0.027485404163599014,
-0.01419266127049923,
0.035194505006074905,
0.015181874856352806,
0.042868442833423615,
-0.0104476073756814,
-0.01050619501620531,
0.028287218883633614,
-0.02053188718855381,
0.009595431387424469,
0.03778102621436119,
0.006325232330709696,
0.0008082303684204817,
-0.05269515886902809,
0.028671730309724808,
-0.030413758009672165,
0.013028975576162338,
0.003205038607120514,
-0.03411433845758438,
-0.00955292023718357,
0.014325495809316635,
-0.01758582890033722,
-0.029076658189296722,
-0.02721807174384594,
-0.04335549846291542,
0.030785974115133286,
-0.042928531765937805,
0.02561655081808567,
0.00003552328053046949,
-0.05292972922325134,
-0.01769842579960823,
-0.04010641947388649,
-0.007216008845716715,
-0.0630461648106575,
0.01355429831892252,
0.07539250701665878,
0.0494658425450325,
-0.006313610821962357,
-0.017416389659047127,
-0.013195708394050598,
-0.02972143143415451,
-0.08972761034965515,
0.011376080103218555,
0.03114839643239975,
-0.009247809648513794,
-0.02028031088411808,
0.041105061769485474,
-0.015071473084390163,
-0.01870487444102764,
0.020835647359490395,
0.009983156807720661,
-0.06080302223563194,
0.01997842639684677,
0.0034109491389244795,
0.0136710861697793,
-0.025276904925704002,
-0.005904082208871841,
0.04627064988017082,
-0.008250492624938488,
0.027863971889019012,
-0.03600515052676201,
0.00506201945245266,
-0.015025991015136242,
-0.04159772768616676,
-0.0021272082813084126,
-0.02344479225575924,
-0.006365540903061628,
-0.022812703624367714,
-0.01129905041307211,
-0.010067316703498363,
0.003980128560215235,
0.01791282743215561,
0.027951844036579132,
0.029922224581241608,
-0.042294424027204514,
0.017839066684246063,
0.005483935121446848,
0.06542084366083145,
0.02968762442469597,
0.015000225976109505,
0.02449507638812065,
0.021208427846431732,
-0.004056326113641262,
0.012903312221169472,
0.037032488733530045,
0.0075643714517354965,
0.014578070491552353,
0.008222506381571293,
0.012162105180323124,
-0.03390825167298317,
-0.005541617516428232,
-0.0218430757522583,
-0.015242616645991802,
-0.016401946544647217,
0.003346092766150832,
-0.011983544565737247,
-0.01101874653249979,
0.015336474403738976,
0.001791737973690033,
-0.012741059996187687,
0.0002168298960896209,
0.003169883508235216,
0.005038355011492968,
-0.0012675592442974448,
-0.028293147683143616,
0.004588613286614418,
-0.010060219094157219,
0.057467635720968246,
0.005452483426779509,
0.05330337584018707,
0.03876328095793724,
0.021480385214090347,
-0.0016258632531389594,
-0.06354927271604538,
-0.027706768363714218,
-0.020993920043110847,
0.02450382336974144,
-0.011801935732364655,
-0.004445777274668217,
-0.021994246169924736,
-0.03725685179233551,
0.004613138735294342,
0.008168892003595829,
-0.027706312015652657,
0.016975339502096176,
0.027516577392816544,
-0.026858646422624588,
-0.011410449631512165,
0.010613800957798958,
0.03477505221962929,
-0.010377217084169388,
0.04701725393533707,
0.03212153539061546,
0.048710018396377563,
-0.011345569975674152,
0.013811726123094559,
0.028907302767038345,
0.023014867678284645,
0.06858907639980316,
-0.0026055958587676287,
-0.026131341233849525,
-0.0266399122774601,
0.03355683758854866,
0.03347538411617279,
-0.01491453219205141,
0.017931340262293816,
0.027756188064813614,
0.012120413593947887,
0.04675619676709175,
0.02232368104159832,
0.025442197918891907,
0.04544811323285103,
-0.027826914563775063,
-0.05873379111289978,
-0.02639908343553543,
-0.02356589213013649,
0.035140957683324814,
-0.01777457259595394,
-0.02957802638411522,
-0.05466705933213234,
0.052187543362379074,
0.015952397137880325,
-0.0077157774940133095,
-0.036199700087308884,
0.05408262088894844,
0.003353191539645195,
0.026571959257125854,
0.0155784972012043,
0.011678372509777546,
0.036776408553123474,
-0.0029717562720179558,
0.02419806644320488,
0.029470354318618774,
0.010311818681657314,
-0.03888033702969551,
-0.031327828764915466,
-0.011567079462110996,
-0.0074963816441595554,
0.011094530113041401,
-0.004507803358137608,
0.05489812791347504,
-0.009558944962918758,
0.006690517533570528,
0.0168685894459486,
0.02845865860581398,
0.002959473291411996,
-0.023006895557045937,
-0.014214497990906239,
-0.022199660539627075,
-0.005547161214053631,
-0.014901571907103062,
0.05038800835609436,
-0.002107273554429412,
-0.011534599587321281,
-0.026048950850963593
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:25
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"I've made my own enquiries with the council and the EPA. You've gone some way to repairing the damage done by Hulley. However, we need to show all the government authorities that there are new owners and a new team. I want us to have a clean break from the past. I don't want Bruce Hulley, Sam Zdrilic or any of those guys involved going forward."
370In cross-examination, Mr Renshall said:-
"And I had said to Mr Hanna that we were in a situation of disagreement or negotiations with Mr Zdrilic, that his caveat was about claiming the Land and Mr Hanna had the view there again that he wanted a clean start and wanted to keep with existing directors".
371Mr Frederick also gave evidence of a conversation he had had with Mr Hanna in early February 2004 to the following effect:-
Mr Hanna: "What is the issue with this caveat which has been lodged over the land?"
Mr Frederick: "The caveat was lodged by LEC, which is a company owned by Sam Zdrilic, one of Hulley's old partners. Those are the guys that originally had the site and are responsible for the previous problems. There was no proper management structure in place to run the site. That is why eventually the site was shut down by the EPA".
Mr Hanna: "We have clean up that mess. I don't want Hulley, Ansell or Zdrilic or any of the guys from the old guard in anyway associated with the project in the future. They are all out (...) we need new management going forward. It's our decision who stays and goes as we are bringing in the money. We will decide who and what is good for the site."
372Mr Frederick said that he passed this on to Mr Renshall.
373So far as concerns HTT "providing security" for LEC's debt to Mr Zdrilic, Mr Frederick said he had a conversation with Mr Hanna in around mid February 2004 to the following effect:-
Mr Frederick: "Rob told me that Zdrilic wants around $5.5M acknowledged by HTT as a loan to Zdrilic."
Mr Hanna: "On what basis? To who is the money currently owed and what is it for?"
Mr Frederick: "I think the money is currently owed by LEC to Zdrilic. It's for an investment Zdrilic made in LEC for the project years ago. We don't have any documentary evidence of the money or what it was used for."
Mr Hanna: "It's an investment, not a loan to Huntley. If his debt is to be acknowledged why not acknowledge debts to all of the other small investors in HTT? We can't agree to that."
374Mr Frederick said that he also relayed this to Mr Renshall.
375Neither Mr Renshall nor Mr Frederick were challenged in cross-examination about these conversations.
376In those circumstances my conclusion is that Mr Gillard's letter, which obviously reflected Mr Renshall's instructions to him, correctly stated the "requirements of incoming finance is" and it was thus neither misleading or deceptive or in any other way properly the subject of complaint.
377In any event, as emerges below, Mr Zdrilic did become a director of HTT, albeit as an alternate to Mr Renshall. Nonetheless, he attended board meetings concurrently with Mr Renshall.
11 March 2004 - Fourth Representation
378This representation was that the new funder was "unlikely to accept" Mr Zdrilic as a director of HTT.
379This representation arises from an email which Mr Gillard sent Mr Hilliard in which he stated:-
"...it is unlikely the new funder will accept Sam [Zdrilic] as a director or a 5 man Board".
380For the reasons outlined in relation to the Third Representation, Mr Gillard's statement that it was "unlikely" that the new funder would accept Mr Zdrilic as a director of HTT reflected Mr Hanna's position and was thus neither misleading nor deceptive.
15 March 2004 - IPC Heads of Agreement
381On 15 March 2004, HTT and IPC entered into the IPC Heads of Agreement.
382According to Mr Moir, this document was drafted, principally, by Mr Hanna.
383The agreement is highly conditional in nature.
384The agreement's essential terms were that:-
|
[
-0.07614313066005707,
0.030265111476182938,
-0.0113983741030097,
-0.023504214361310005,
0.009511515498161316,
-0.033240705728530884,
-0.005426126066595316,
-0.03561566397547722,
-0.015611258335411549,
0.0021564143244177103,
-0.0006468255305662751,
0.05537675693631172,
-0.03215838223695755,
0.007829968817532063,
-0.04309717193245888,
-0.054984647780656815,
0.0431104339659214,
-0.0023674149997532368,
-0.010510689578950405,
-0.01778600364923477,
-0.03288555517792702,
-0.02492666244506836,
-0.006351040210574865,
-0.01413202565163374,
-0.002365111606195569,
0.011145656928420067,
-0.012090089730918407,
0.011731408536434174,
-0.011479939334094524,
0.015424528159201145,
0.002076784148812294,
0.01695183292031288,
0.014332621358335018,
-0.030426599085330963,
0.03189779818058014,
-0.028916627168655396,
0.039618026465177536,
-0.011716773733496666,
-0.031398821622133255,
-0.009162655100226402,
-0.006192064844071865,
0.01346168015152216,
0.004076849669218063,
-0.022078927606344223,
0.051519181579351425,
-0.020986640825867653,
0.007927434518933296,
-0.02917127124965191,
0.016406765207648277,
0.029636170715093613,
-0.030210595577955246,
-0.0026760061737149954,
0.028103675693273544,
-0.026096295565366745,
0.0013661837438121438,
0.0040442501194775105,
0.006780131720006466,
-0.0037545952945947647,
-0.07867635786533356,
-0.004207184072583914,
0.0038012764416635036,
-0.006760981399565935,
-0.08160938322544098,
0.024747833609580994,
-0.008431512862443924,
0.10649246722459793,
0.019382614642381668,
-0.0038347577210515738,
-0.004927651025354862,
0.001556216273456812,
-0.06867077946662903,
-0.011784239672124386,
-0.015470238402485847,
-0.012970056384801865,
-0.09689025580883026,
0.023401010781526566,
0.0016732093645259738,
-0.0016113813035190105,
0.03406098112463951,
0.026524865999817848,
0.0392778106033802,
-0.015403641387820244,
0.010169938206672668,
0.024071287363767624,
-0.02394304983317852,
-0.0022641890682280064,
-0.03221631050109863,
0.013301092199981213,
0.022623388096690178,
-0.025275154039263725,
-0.0063583943992853165,
0.010527298785746098,
0.018732300028204918,
-0.03864642232656479,
-0.0038972655311226845,
0.000845588743686676,
-0.0096266008913517,
0.031320855021476746,
0.007204251829534769,
0.009354810230433941,
-0.0031699882820248604,
0.0141660887748003,
-0.029340578243136406,
-0.026995308697223663,
-0.015682125464081764,
0.022508418187499046,
0.03961477056145668,
0.018590958788990974,
0.01726306788623333,
-0.006682631094008684,
-0.012441746890544891,
-0.004762604366987944,
-0.0048944600857794285,
0.0005660252063535154,
-0.02347724325954914,
-0.0009272813913412392,
-0.007700934540480375,
0.012432399205863476,
0.05994250252842903,
0.01746000349521637,
0.04260900616645813,
0.03764363378286362,
0.022617682814598083,
-0.014009309932589531,
-0.038129936903715134,
-0.017140163108706474,
0.007922764867544174,
-0.016386639326810837,
0.01031454373151064,
0.036875780671834946,
-0.005851675756275654,
0.02392606809735298,
-0.027430424466729164,
-0.009431739337742329,
-0.035273149609565735,
0.005375715903937817,
-0.0016556903719902039,
-0.002033049240708351,
0.010966227389872074,
-0.0476602241396904,
0.02872321382164955,
0.013354124501347542,
-0.0002594903635326773,
-0.054367806762456894,
0.027860913425683975,
-0.03157259151339531,
0.004601713735610247,
-0.00011660120799206197,
0.0009006489999592304,
0.06685707718133926,
0.003084868425503373,
0.0006957425503060222,
0.02401071786880493,
0.014558011665940285,
0.036607783287763596,
-0.01789245568215847,
0.0030390871688723564,
-0.03787161782383919,
0.03828248381614685,
0.08595161139965057,
-0.016557566821575165,
0.03549300506711006,
0.0009012811351567507,
-0.012668440118432045,
0.011957680806517601,
0.018298529088497162,
0.005384099204093218,
0.040153756737709045,
-0.006493428256362677,
0.007325220853090286,
0.02910679019987583,
-0.007583197206258774,
0.05259326845407486,
0.015062742866575718,
-0.0067555601708590984,
0.025215575471520424,
0.06297381222248077,
0.01684882678091526,
-0.0036248236428946257,
-0.013566136360168457,
-0.06847554445266724,
0.026002418249845505,
0.0024895714595913887,
-0.037843942642211914,
-0.065179742872715,
-0.0051784091629087925,
-0.02632560208439827,
-0.02112412638962269,
0.007123205345124006,
0.016860095784068108,
-0.023660549893975258,
0.0029394603334367275,
0.013695629313588142,
0.010655252262949944,
0.034084025770425797,
-0.030302802100777626,
-0.006718758028000593,
0.007935644127428532,
-0.015501022338867188,
-0.04561111330986023,
-0.013165843673050404,
0.03752490505576134,
0.1057472676038742,
-0.017296409234404564,
-0.013329442590475082,
0.011917995288968086,
-0.025744689628481865,
-0.015904564410448074,
-0.027841247618198395,
-0.055642206221818924,
0.008819463662803173,
0.01475366298109293,
-0.003656344721093774,
0.006752451881766319,
0.016100719571113586,
-0.026045264676213264,
-0.009323892183601856,
-0.01648879051208496,
0.03552161902189255,
-0.03282157704234123,
-0.0402899831533432,
-0.021853383630514145,
-0.02706962451338768,
0.013877751305699348,
0.0259445458650589,
0.05632880702614784,
-0.09947723150253296,
0.03826254978775978,
-0.03261060640215874,
-0.018998082727193832,
-0.0306295957416296,
-0.035206444561481476,
0.0324312187731266,
-0.01422139909118414,
0.0000833200101624243,
0.03171515837311745,
0.008196752518415451,
0.014612611383199692,
0.022967655211687088,
0.01705973781645298,
0.01710200309753418,
-0.0011480521643534303,
-0.008673382923007011,
-0.009681563824415207,
-0.031192218884825706,
-0.00314291357062757,
0.014641954563558102,
0.013169561512768269,
0.012800770811736584,
-0.002289344323799014,
-0.006575195584446192,
-0.017738012596964836,
0.004905316047370434,
-0.008191332221031189,
-0.008089583367109299,
0.05162850394845009,
0.02207554504275322,
-0.003488698974251747,
0.03634245693683624,
0.024045230820775032,
0.020387303084135056,
0.016319576650857925,
0.04976630583405495,
0.01546905655413866,
-0.030012207105755806,
-0.0015111573738977313,
-0.03125390037894249,
-0.07155407220125198,
0.027940059080719948,
-0.0008968284819275141,
-0.002675336552783847,
0.025571398437023163,
0.03255196288228035,
0.023114994168281555,
0.011775742284953594,
0.026717185974121094,
0.0471789687871933,
0.028712298721075058,
-0.0033960947766900063,
0.01809076964855194,
0.02942490205168724,
0.02027403749525547,
0.04904992878437042,
-0.05658138915896416,
0.029831666499376297,
0.06456141918897629,
-0.020407386124134064,
-0.033320195972919464,
0.05007576569914818,
-0.046853139996528625,
-0.035609450191259384,
0.01803583651781082,
0.05831144377589226,
0.0005532450159080327,
-0.08000350743532181,
-0.034089792519807816,
-0.03242931887507439,
-0.17215141654014587,
-0.039995916187763214,
-0.012113175354897976,
0.026385094970464706,
0.004244311712682247,
0.008899546228349209,
-0.04216250777244568,
0.021340593695640564,
-0.03203989937901497,
0.010826698504388332,
-0.01585998386144638,
-0.054225996136665344,
-0.044338420033454895,
0.0345478281378746,
0.011657222174108028,
0.005163396708667278,
0.015481419861316681,
0.01868240348994732,
0.03223450481891632,
-0.020384108647704124,
-0.004027434159070253,
-0.050077296793460846,
0.05702986940741539,
-0.006419238168746233,
-0.014643577858805656,
-0.024254320189356804,
0.018349554389715195,
-0.011407089419662952,
-0.02610829472541809,
0.02295224741101265,
-0.0008229271625168622,
0.038363128900527954,
-0.024036288261413574,
0.04524572566151619,
-0.01373431645333767,
0.046090368181467056,
0.061810895800590515,
-0.0692053809762001,
-0.018947601318359375,
-0.025245096534490585,
0.0424707867205143,
0.022145461291074753,
-0.004402723629027605,
0.018190694972872734,
-0.016188601031899452,
-0.07792101800441742,
0.010251670144498348,
-0.018346775323152542,
-0.01345187146216631,
0.0672466829419136,
0.008005626499652863,
0.011547520756721497,
-0.030002199113368988,
-0.02856111340224743,
0.02205769717693329,
-0.05138897895812988,
0.041269391775131226,
0.02271951362490654,
-0.026867572218179703,
-0.015096940100193024,
-0.03418863192200661,
-0.03521110489964485,
-0.0037895056884735823,
0.020140351727604866,
-0.01918305829167366,
0.010186542756855488,
-0.028160858899354935,
-0.02634149044752121,
0.02602156437933445,
0.0041384100914001465,
0.014174790121614933,
0.0012213272275403142,
0.0008514405926689506,
-0.008970590308308601,
0.05188888683915138,
0.022556694224476814,
-0.08510970324277878,
-0.03403853252530098,
-0.006604516413062811,
-0.11501400917768478,
-0.008108577691018581,
0.02180521748960018,
-0.018693242222070694,
0.028205156326293945,
-0.015022799372673035,
0.01673622615635395,
0.01215455774217844,
0.06422276794910431,
0.03801678121089935,
0.23173315823078156,
-0.010489667765796185,
-0.024734171107411385,
0.04776361584663391,
0.029936468228697777,
-0.02687922678887844,
0.010699741542339325,
0.04759954661130905,
-0.0131815942004323,
-0.039388447999954224,
-0.04820089042186737,
-0.022516798228025436,
0.0317981094121933,
0.034115903079509735,
-0.025182358920574188,
0.019191276282072067,
-0.038776151835918427,
-0.012327144853770733,
0.06871405988931656,
0.054714787751436234,
0.05920441821217537,
-0.013761111535131931,
0.017048008739948273,
0.01702565886080265,
-0.04944358021020889,
-0.039983659982681274,
0.007684607990086079,
0.05095541477203369,
-0.04813932254910469,
-0.005973560735583305,
-0.009475297294557095,
-0.0061617158353328705,
0.03137572482228279,
-0.0025010453537106514,
0.011091427877545357,
0.0035980273969471455,
-0.03734543174505234,
-0.005090279970318079,
0.009513760916888714,
0.02058945968747139,
0.003938897978514433,
-0.048407167196273804,
-0.02488788776099682,
-0.017726222053170204,
-0.0426802895963192,
0.03729305416345596,
-0.01999508962035179,
0.03944936394691467,
-0.014243868179619312,
0.015638865530490875,
-0.03527306392788887,
0.02916114032268524,
-0.0179781261831522,
-0.01503781322389841,
-0.020350061357021332,
0.05626605451107025,
-0.02469106949865818,
0.015601747669279575,
0.008679521270096302,
0.05813121050596237,
0.017755530774593353,
0.03550379350781441,
-0.01512067299336195,
-0.007522591855376959,
-0.02705773524940014,
-0.0014670988311991096,
-0.042953334748744965,
0.0014006951823830605,
0.040722377598285675,
0.038344547152519226,
0.04276693984866142,
0.028621522709727287,
0.001548302243463695,
0.028372956439852715,
0.046846915036439896,
-0.005023379810154438,
-0.036302994936704636,
0.013423379510641098,
-0.0219099298119545,
0.004561150912195444,
-0.039380330592393875,
-0.03753959760069847,
-0.016513260081410408,
0.042536355555057526,
0.023247133940458298,
0.008521070703864098,
-0.020748715847730637,
0.0432102270424366,
-0.03163881599903107,
-0.005969401448965073,
0.002908384660258889,
0.005606450606137514,
-0.029513848945498466,
-0.004681599326431751,
-0.030735891312360764,
-0.0431198850274086,
0.0049796379171311855,
-0.030564837157726288,
-0.0430019311606884,
-0.04944842681288719,
0.02101350948214531,
0.016414962708950043,
0.010163597762584686,
-0.029495814815163612,
0.038997162133455276,
-0.013054685667157173,
-0.03162823244929314,
0.03382303938269615,
-0.042610857635736465,
0.005721558351069689,
0.03607820346951485,
0.019141394644975662,
0.01003761775791645,
-0.0043269875459373,
0.03153172880411148,
0.07166391611099243,
0.00006869119533803314,
0.06000407785177231,
0.033749379217624664,
0.052155595272779465,
-0.001938297413289547,
-0.00656631076708436,
-0.048116788268089294,
-0.028655163943767548,
-0.02047858014702797,
0.023327086120843887,
-0.019810250028967857,
0.006529026664793491,
0.005897522438317537,
0.025189777836203575,
-0.0031535723246634007,
-0.03646797686815262,
-0.005960353184491396,
0.02271871455013752,
0.044498078525066376,
0.03963511064648628,
0.020818371325731277,
0.00029125920264050364,
-0.03279850631952286,
0.026333868503570557,
-0.05679643899202347,
0.00560350064188242,
-0.052798256278038025,
-0.019627109169960022,
-0.002124583814293146,
0.0060638426803052425,
-0.053477611392736435,
0.005409309174865484,
-0.015832295641303062,
0.003564570564776659,
0.007046321872621775,
0.014687026850879192,
-0.044665854424238205,
-0.043674297630786896,
0.02760019712150097,
0.00788942165672779,
-0.018925057724118233,
-0.020311931148171425,
-0.006573323160409927,
-0.026493260636925697,
-0.005664805881679058,
0.03501751646399498,
-0.001230958616361022,
0.00794649962335825,
0.03422955051064491,
0.04936730116605759,
-0.025362372398376465,
0.055051080882549286,
0.07798983156681061,
-0.009055035188794136,
-0.05444611236453056,
-0.046046867966651917,
-0.015594782307744026,
0.05117514729499817,
0.01816662773489952,
0.053918518126010895,
-0.0007081635994836688,
-0.0022666340228170156,
0.0038318228907883167,
0.0078375693410635,
0.04732677713036537,
0.004203755874186754,
-0.05351532623171806,
0.00992699433118105,
-0.027179216966032982,
-0.014969143085181713,
-0.013838022947311401,
-0.008732903748750687,
0.04397519305348396,
-0.040514349937438965,
0.009682188741862774,
0.059146393090486526,
0.0070327408611774445,
-0.022780807688832283,
0.02438570000231266,
0.019520286470651627,
-0.019097089767456055,
0.01990342326462269,
0.0018151778494939208,
-0.03812070190906525,
-0.028748372569680214,
0.002804908435791731,
0.018456360325217247,
0.001167859067209065,
0.038476523011922836,
0.027682621031999588,
0.026018580421805382,
0.04177830368280411,
-0.07034101337194443,
-0.038246557116508484,
0.013735051266849041,
0.02483137883245945,
-0.019232839345932007,
0.03454035520553589,
-0.01285562478005886,
-0.025188585743308067,
0.025747239589691162,
0.030546940863132477,
0.013912994414567947,
-0.027463050559163094,
-0.015424848534166813,
-0.03761439397931099,
0.04635659232735634,
-0.036158476024866104,
-0.016882967203855515,
-0.008338906802237034,
-0.0363544300198555,
-0.007205456495285034,
-0.0038054294418543577,
0.03905268758535385,
-0.005911113228648901,
-0.07697916030883789,
0.055728014558553696,
-0.07920170575380325,
0.0122792087495327,
-0.0013717000838369131,
0.029190531000494957,
0.00828565377742052,
0.02276499755680561,
0.009411228820681572,
0.004987798631191254,
-0.01761147379875183,
0.0122909527271986,
0.03946797922253609,
0.011225147172808647,
0.015454110689461231,
-0.005492574535310268,
-0.02836008369922638,
0.023486949503421783,
0.03894883021712303,
0.011771866120398045,
0.02811576798558235,
0.01395378727465868,
-0.016392234712839127,
0.02685314416885376,
-0.01649339124560356,
0.017569996416568756,
-0.04079224169254303,
-0.03866323083639145,
-0.008428544737398624,
-0.016227712854743004,
-0.004972702823579311,
0.020901305601000786,
-0.01712377555668354,
-0.06527838855981827,
-0.05338362604379654,
0.006989459507167339,
-0.00918242521584034,
-0.029006555676460266,
-0.012994266115128994,
0.007411697879433632,
-0.01588422991335392,
-0.0018540524179115891,
-0.04539106413722038,
-0.032985467463731766,
-0.009880179539322853,
-0.031602758914232254,
-0.010196109302341938,
-0.010596603155136108,
0.0007510822615586221,
-0.006453815381973982,
-0.0017215425614267588,
0.03674616664648056,
0.014431960880756378,
-0.018322130665183067,
0.01536839734762907,
-0.001099904184229672,
0.0023563504219055176,
-0.021549087017774582,
0.025193048641085625,
0.00544422771781683,
-0.01130921021103859,
-0.008610066957771778,
0.02172284945845604,
-0.015443792566657066,
-0.019014740362763405,
-0.01412302628159523,
0.04294188320636749,
-0.009731591679155827,
0.007869318127632141,
-0.03110358864068985,
-0.020178617909550667,
-0.025549480691552162,
-0.047074876725673676,
-0.046552881598472595,
0.009677625261247158,
-0.009887956082820892,
-0.008204692043364048,
-0.003771301358938217,
0.008391442708671093,
0.03472563624382019,
-0.06398557871580124,
0.020427346229553223,
0.015382517129182816,
0.04312487319111824,
0.013207441195845604,
0.02678346261382103,
0.030200470238924026,
-0.01208718866109848,
0.004090758506208658,
0.0136035131290555,
-0.005669501610100269,
-0.041526827961206436,
0.00503432797268033,
-0.07186523824930191,
-0.001234674477018416,
-0.009508672170341015,
-0.047088515013456345,
-0.047354720532894135,
0.005593460518866777,
-0.01793968304991722,
0.004362915642559528,
0.03315874561667442,
0.00006362933345371857,
0.031678181141614914,
0.030285349115729332,
0.012072412297129631,
0.009793519973754883,
0.04012355953454971,
-0.06008267030119896,
-0.007041445001959801,
-0.06394123286008835,
0.06021532043814659,
-0.016285190358757973,
0.005864027421921492,
-0.030301829800009727,
0.0002902652195189148,
0.00021225650561973453,
0.02837924286723137,
0.009931117296218872,
-0.016363387927412987,
0.009438235312700272,
-0.017070814967155457,
-0.04112008586525917,
0.0046417126432061195,
0.0027262934017926455,
0.007310138083994389,
0.027300922200083733,
0.04300972446799278,
-0.013769740238785744,
-0.012101561762392521,
0.023408440873026848,
0.018436895683407784,
0.00902019627392292,
-0.0033019105903804302,
-0.02411612868309021,
-0.005635660607367754,
0.022378358989953995,
-0.027725985273718834,
0.00900542363524437,
0.015644676983356476,
-0.016632113605737686,
0.0013371310196816921,
0.00493508018553257,
-0.034342098981142044,
0.03996068984270096,
0.007109622471034527,
0.038739487528800964,
-0.01564861088991165,
-0.05409521237015724,
0.00927566085010767,
-0.022383490577340126,
0.001963935559615493,
-0.024126075208187103,
0.02066699229180813,
-0.001423017936758697,
-0.014494147151708603,
0.006356731057167053,
0.031088341027498245,
0.03658188879489899,
-0.045889340341091156,
0.04820329323410988,
-0.03637048602104187,
-0.008088084869086742,
-0.1455266922712326,
-0.004452177789062262,
-0.012548645958304405,
-0.017513586208224297,
-0.030411625280976295,
-0.0021974744740873575,
0.0023138762917369604,
0.02121037431061268,
-0.02059152163565159,
-0.0037643159739673138,
0.003621350973844528,
-0.013674725778400898,
0.016881318762898445,
-0.023772338405251503,
-0.02215021848678589,
-0.0037532479036599398,
-0.0669972151517868,
-0.008967372588813305,
-0.054049301892519,
0.022761601954698563,
0.03911622613668442,
-0.002389592584222555,
-0.04070499166846275,
-0.02566966414451599,
0.010997183620929718,
0.01529497280716896,
-0.005820577498525381,
-0.05979514867067337,
-0.023120155557990074,
-0.02087823487818241,
-0.01175189670175314,
-0.0028078125324100256,
-0.013556902296841145,
0.06277015805244446,
-0.0015258408384397626,
0.020165562629699707,
0.025142688304185867,
-0.02985529974102974,
-0.014572898857295513,
0.00960478000342846,
-0.02877447009086609,
0.03602055832743645,
-0.03392713889479637,
-0.020738687366247177,
-0.010449989698827267,
0.009879175573587418,
-0.024288779124617577,
0.002555960090830922,
-0.07457508891820908,
-0.036288850009441376,
-0.02142154611647129,
0.028437083587050438,
0.011364106088876724,
0.05613093823194504,
-0.003547494998201728,
-0.009558489546179771,
0.01668928749859333,
-0.0310061015188694,
0.00029169346089474857,
0.04490409791469574,
0.003849707543849945,
0.014731447212398052,
-0.031187565997242928,
-0.009723895229399204,
-0.038147035986185074,
-0.013376245275139809,
-0.05447008088231087,
-0.016312427818775177,
-0.022079981863498688,
0.042008448392152786,
-0.022444823756814003,
-0.02483520470559597,
-0.01400109101086855,
-0.04330139607191086,
0.03854089230298996,
-0.02247789315879345,
0.007742519956082106,
0.004316101782023907,
-0.03874724358320236,
-0.0005947996978648007,
-0.02135119028389454,
0.012740564532577991,
-0.03028939850628376,
-0.007100926246494055,
0.09182870388031006,
0.01942918635904789,
-0.01103296224027872,
-0.038942210376262665,
0.054836634546518326,
-0.023827798664569855,
-0.04454458877444267,
-0.0187535360455513,
0.0023227648343890905,
0.04660719633102417,
-0.025448421016335487,
0.035266440361738205,
0.013681222684681416,
0.018159758299589157,
0.01947852037847042,
-0.010456345975399017,
-0.06145778298377991,
-0.0028928841929882765,
-0.006165856961160898,
0.0123206228017807,
-0.008059797808527946,
-0.012058649212121964,
0.030519139021635056,
0.011140112765133381,
0.043102577328681946,
-0.017705470323562622,
-0.01166306622326374,
-0.016490990296006203,
-0.013460169546306133,
0.023630034178495407,
-0.04012486711144447,
0.009989198297262192,
-0.002076727570965886,
-0.02692132256925106,
0.0029350242111831903,
0.002225330797955394,
0.01604611426591873,
0.03432121500372887,
0.009254793636500835,
-0.02974570542573929,
-0.007492951117455959,
0.001782443723641336,
0.05913003534078598,
0.007596357725560665,
0.018572859466075897,
-0.008858788758516312,
0.035039469599723816,
-0.0013381302123889327,
0.029476990923285484,
0.00020134146325290203,
-0.012097910977900028,
-0.013217086903750896,
-0.03203975781798363,
0.018612703308463097,
-0.05057841166853905,
-0.02103836089372635,
-0.021002154797315598,
-0.0022535461466759443,
0.01775633543729782,
0.013320415280759335,
-0.04173861816525459,
0.009003795683383942,
0.03629856929183006,
0.005553715862333775,
-0.015142930671572685,
-0.04090934246778488,
-0.004866602830588818,
-0.0002498477406334132,
-0.009964031167328358,
0.029239244759082794,
0.030459797009825706,
0.015491331927478313,
0.02673429623246193,
-0.021226294338703156,
0.03851151466369629,
0.04996836557984352,
-0.009798813611268997,
-0.04733223840594292,
-0.04598567634820938,
-0.05172249302268028,
-0.023452473804354668,
0.005539989564567804,
-0.030603600665926933,
0.013825319707393646,
-0.02321512997150421,
-0.046360768377780914,
0.001280904863961041,
0.014975697733461857,
-0.013202561065554619,
0.031156545504927635,
0.04136420041322708,
-0.04489614814519882,
-0.001809515873901546,
-0.0025274285580962896,
0.07806216925382614,
-0.0036012849304825068,
0.04713159427046776,
0.028505045920610428,
0.02044510655105114,
0.0038996990770101547,
0.015172144398093224,
0.030363451689481735,
-0.014245855621993542,
0.054078396409749985,
-0.013802443630993366,
-0.02406424842774868,
-0.04476426914334297,
0.010976334102451801,
-0.005767754279077053,
-0.00790600385516882,
0.007373231463134289,
0.007476951461285353,
-0.00033537985291332006,
0.03652011603116989,
-0.009225036017596722,
0.028078101575374603,
0.0595465824007988,
-0.036167386919260025,
-0.04162834957242012,
-0.025629492476582527,
0.0003186340909451246,
0.0006050541414879262,
-0.014663569629192352,
-0.03839221969246864,
-0.030048053711652756,
0.04443575069308281,
0.004036424681544304,
0.017865212634205818,
-0.04753773659467697,
0.05443290248513222,
-0.01215415820479393,
0.012106566689908504,
0.0032702351454645395,
0.006946960464119911,
0.047926608473062515,
-0.03520192205905914,
0.0010718926787376404,
0.057869065552949905,
-0.005015761125832796,
-0.0034221659880131483,
0.0035999100655317307,
-0.006105713080614805,
-0.001466950518079102,
0.011609179899096489,
-0.0023213294334709644,
0.002484025899320841,
0.007108823861926794,
0.010857353918254375,
-0.0011842044768854976,
0.021900231018662453,
0.011935655027627945,
-0.04750688001513481,
0.0014142111176624894,
-0.019580289721488953,
0.0005780761712230742,
-0.01073965709656477,
0.026238150894641876,
0.02877124957740307,
-0.02096838504076004,
-0.00986993033438921
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:0
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Land Enviro Corp Pty Limited v HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Limited [2012] NSWSC 382
Hearing dates: 6 February 2012 - 16 March 2012
Decision date: 20 April 2012
Jurisdiction: Equity Division
Before: Stevenson J
Decision: The Third Amended Statement of Claim and the First and Second Cross Claims are dismissed.
Catchwords:
Trade and commerce - Trade practices - Misleading or deceptive conduct - Representations - Setting aside of consent order discontinuing proceedings - Damages for loss of opportunity to prosecute discontinued proceedings - Likelihood of success of discontinued proceedings -
Fiduciary duties - Whether necessary to demonstrate ability to pursue opportunity appropriated by errant fiduciary - Laches - Entitlement to rescission - Necessity of knowledge of legal right to rescind - Affirmation - Restitutio in integrum - Intervention third party rights - Agency
Legislation Cited: Fair Trading Act 1987
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
Cases Cited: Alati v Kruger (1955) 94 CLR 216
Boyns v Lackey (1958) SR (NSW) 395
Bullabidgee Pty Limited v McCleary [2010] NSWSC 145
Coast Estates Pty Limited v Melevende [1955] VR 433
Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Limited v The Producers and Citizens Cooperative Assurance Company of Australia Limited (1931) 46 CLR 41
Connectland Pty Ltd v Cardno Forbes Rigby Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 391
Consul Development Pty Limited v DPC Estates Pty Limited (1975) 132 CLR 373
Crabtree - Vickers Pty Limited v Australian Direct Mail Advertising & Addressing Co Pty Limited (1975) 133 CLR 72
Digi-Tech (Australia) Limited v Brand [2004] NSWCA 58
Ernest v Vivian (1863) 33 LJ (Ch) 513
Freeman and Lockyer v Buckhurst Park Properties (Mangal) Limited [1964] 2 QB 480
Harvey v Phillips (1956) 95 CLR 235
Henjo Investments Pty Limited v Collins Marrickville Pty Limited (1998) 39 FCR 546
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351
Land Enviro Corp Pty Ltd v HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Ltd (2008) 72 NSWLR 160
Land Enviro Corp Pty Ltd v HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 177
Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Limited (1998) 196 CLR 494
Molotu Pty Limited v Solar Power Limited (1989) 6 BPR 13,460
Nikolaou v Papasavas, Phillips & Co (1989) 166 CLR 394
O'Connor v S.P. Bray Limited (1936) 36 SR (NSW) 248
O'Connor v S.P. Bray Limited (1937) 56 CLR 464
Pacific Carriers Limited v BNP Paribas (2004) 218 CLR 451
Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd v Heperu Pty Ltd & Ors [No 2] (2009) 78 NSWLR 190
Pririe v Richardson [1927] 1 KB 448
Re Hoffman: Ex parte Worrell v Schilling (1989) 85 ALR 145
Sargent v ASL Developments Limited (1974) 131 CLR 634
Singh v Ginelle Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 310
Spies v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1991) 24 NSWLR 691
Steve Masselos & Co v Young [2011] NSWCA 352
Streeter v Western Areas Exploration Pty Limited (2011) 278 ALR 291
Tenji v Henneberry & Associates Pty Limited (2000) 98 FCR 324
Tiplady v Gold Coast Carlton Pty Limited (1984) 8 FCR 438
Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165
Tyco (Australia) Pty Ltd t/as ADT Security v Signature Security Group Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1029
Warman International Limited v Dwyer (1995) 182 CLR 544
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315
Wentworth v Rogers (No 5) (1986) 6 NSWLR 534
|
[
-0.0733209028840065,
0.01974654570221901,
-0.005137977190315723,
-0.017463717609643936,
-0.04675430804491043,
-0.019524171948432922,
-0.009713488630950451,
-0.027690721675753593,
0.01618942804634571,
-0.010145043022930622,
0.036368440836668015,
0.029476918280124664,
-0.024464987218379974,
-0.007768807001411915,
0.03788462281227112,
-0.046061161905527115,
-0.015244998037815094,
0.004993341863155365,
-0.015281060710549355,
-0.013721879571676254,
-0.0851372554898262,
-0.027383074164390564,
0.008926117792725563,
0.021769579499959946,
0.03076053410768509,
0.029163165017962456,
-0.013267365284264088,
0.031657177954912186,
0.013406063430011272,
0.07177235931158066,
-0.0077592660672962666,
0.03184708580374718,
0.022169336676597595,
-0.010973202995955944,
-0.011464798822999,
-0.036852262914180756,
0.010471324436366558,
0.016153164207935333,
-0.05982353165745735,
0.010293342173099518,
-0.023035837337374687,
-0.034305743873119354,
0.021099111065268517,
-0.06207878142595291,
0.07203063368797302,
0.0013413617853075266,
-0.006882104557007551,
-0.040422841906547546,
0.016709793359041214,
0.0032940793316811323,
-0.06229832023382187,
0.02270965278148651,
0.07067423313856125,
-0.016540927812457085,
0.020944863557815552,
-0.006866514682769775,
-0.01850796304643154,
-0.01415798719972372,
-0.05768682807683945,
0.012575699016451836,
0.0011501864064484835,
0.02803494781255722,
-0.03726990520954132,
0.01021956093609333,
0.010802676901221275,
0.07231530547142029,
0.002772141247987747,
-0.018540503457188606,
0.002022092929109931,
-0.015287749469280243,
-0.022577296942472458,
-0.01922815851867199,
0.012361597269773483,
-0.0006352192722260952,
-0.10066643357276917,
-0.00032155521330423653,
-0.00016408294322900474,
0.016884034499526024,
0.05261022225022316,
-0.008013803511857986,
0.022925756871700287,
-0.007959585636854172,
-0.02078840881586075,
0.011122182942926884,
-0.008923900313675404,
0.019523419439792633,
-0.04273716360330582,
0.0054963198490440845,
-0.0060090571641922,
-0.033737774938344955,
-0.019116820767521858,
-0.03297114372253418,
-0.026475848630070686,
-0.026273176074028015,
0.02006399631500244,
0.0024852112401276827,
-0.05912283807992935,
0.04761720076203346,
-0.02788577601313591,
0.04368346557021141,
-0.016040345653891563,
0.01704377867281437,
-0.0049364445731043816,
0.006136838346719742,
0.020903004333376884,
-0.00450164545327425,
0.018146933987736702,
0.013200167566537857,
0.01951184868812561,
0.016054369509220123,
0.0052368720062077045,
-0.009169372729957104,
0.01607009768486023,
0.0295990202575922,
-0.04737609997391701,
-0.008108084090054035,
0.04939211159944534,
-0.0031751981005072594,
0.01087935734540224,
0.010999604128301144,
0.01878385804593563,
0.008077417500317097,
0.08713942021131516,
-0.040697239339351654,
-0.05076222121715546,
-0.007793872617185116,
0.011712851002812386,
0.021937133744359016,
0.014321980997920036,
-0.025000398978590965,
0.00543456943705678,
-0.036784857511520386,
-0.05710713192820549,
-0.018405312672257423,
-0.03231789916753769,
-0.025495339184999466,
0.03580633923411369,
-0.01667448692023754,
0.012514361180365086,
-0.02421404980123043,
0.041488345712423325,
0.027465177699923515,
0.012138394638895988,
-0.04576481878757477,
0.003361986018717289,
-0.021388936787843704,
-0.004500237759202719,
0.007324020843952894,
0.029317064210772514,
0.008856542408466339,
0.017258165404200554,
0.01147381030023098,
0.05485513061285019,
0.009881383739411831,
0.04501587525010109,
-0.042033761739730835,
0.024636145681142807,
-0.007695135660469532,
-0.016133932396769524,
-0.0009774771751835942,
-0.05020776391029358,
0.04626041278243065,
-0.008274776861071587,
-0.003149412339553237,
0.0033714021556079388,
0.02987951971590519,
-0.007848449051380157,
0.04553363844752312,
-0.028196807950735092,
0.02281338907778263,
0.023867810145020485,
-0.005455697886645794,
0.012202979065477848,
-0.040691740810871124,
0.0001592180778970942,
-0.006265501491725445,
0.0704893246293068,
0.013104516081511974,
-0.06208689138293266,
-0.009458954446017742,
-0.07041537016630173,
-0.005827806890010834,
-0.03650224581360817,
-0.033195093274116516,
-0.050724953413009644,
-0.003864153753966093,
-0.03424454480409622,
-0.08257004618644714,
0.015806248411536217,
0.017974501475691795,
-0.01595361717045307,
-0.022071631625294685,
0.04783419519662857,
0.01840232126414776,
-0.016248386353254318,
0.015288176946341991,
0.019920215010643005,
-0.045938216149806976,
0.03188667446374893,
0.021343734115362167,
-0.045004069805145264,
0.029600437730550766,
0.03087674453854561,
-0.06168634071946144,
-0.06852215528488159,
-0.027847787365317345,
0.002011460717767477,
0.027545930817723274,
-0.002430529100820422,
-0.018805934116244316,
-0.025508666411042213,
-0.005874766502529383,
-0.0032270322553813457,
0.0008177526178769767,
-0.025041067972779274,
-0.014412765391170979,
-0.02088478021323681,
-0.02076049894094467,
-0.05249921232461929,
0.017090272158384323,
0.002735502552241087,
0.0020896466448903084,
0.0011840889928862453,
0.03391963988542557,
0.03177494928240776,
0.032547418028116226,
-0.005766177549958229,
0.035414062440395355,
0.04570063576102257,
0.00046062181354500353,
0.010172481648623943,
0.0002067174355033785,
0.03689861297607422,
-0.005145849194377661,
0.0030033900402486324,
0.007724219001829624,
0.006121535785496235,
0.01974438689649105,
0.03411652520298958,
0.01838778890669346,
-0.027788195759058,
-0.027058593928813934,
0.02250940352678299,
-0.05475350096821785,
-0.03625950962305069,
-0.029050230979919434,
0.020766641944646835,
0.0008482993580400944,
0.028618106618523598,
0.011445240117609501,
-0.00015810198965482414,
0.02080249972641468,
-0.03819577395915985,
0.035976164042949677,
-0.021169885993003845,
0.015619758516550064,
0.024166136980056763,
-0.019321460276842117,
0.017176814377307892,
-0.002446759957820177,
0.004760392941534519,
0.03339860960841179,
0.0572902113199234,
0.005789079703390598,
-0.018784791231155396,
-0.005846756510436535,
-0.0066520581021904945,
-0.02157542109489441,
0.0007493763114325702,
0.0038519096560776234,
0.006852773018181324,
-0.00041697791311889887,
0.034654371440410614,
0.02253122627735138,
0.013633709400892258,
0.025657277554273605,
0.023091008886694908,
-0.018448637798428535,
0.03403759002685547,
0.00271376920863986,
0.01998940296471119,
0.019108736887574196,
0.010311078280210495,
-0.02685668133199215,
0.028438998386263847,
0.0010733116650953889,
-0.017282545566558838,
-0.05847399681806564,
0.010491683147847652,
-0.046630557626485825,
0.01168730203062296,
0.02242923714220524,
0.07680854946374893,
0.009206175804138184,
-0.05334974080324173,
0.01873578131198883,
-0.04576123133301735,
-0.16796442866325378,
0.0009318218217231333,
-0.005677474662661552,
-0.017146192491054535,
0.008090210147202015,
0.0011950756888836622,
-0.030341852456331253,
0.000011301601261948235,
0.005543740000575781,
-0.004489854909479618,
-0.0041563864797353745,
-0.07210236042737961,
-0.0598764531314373,
0.02656080387532711,
-0.046403802931308746,
-0.020013151690363884,
-0.0005258268211036921,
0.017836615443229675,
0.028842229396104813,
-0.03179161250591278,
0.0197466928511858,
-0.00796536821871996,
0.04318195581436157,
-0.009412359446287155,
0.024709036573767662,
-0.04181130975484848,
-0.02044423669576645,
-0.00025546798133291304,
-0.03999113291501999,
-0.007504492532461882,
0.009443710558116436,
-0.005195999518036842,
-0.008876674808561802,
0.0348043218255043,
0.04337569326162338,
-0.0017683528130874038,
0.04038237780332565,
-0.06965132057666779,
-0.016334056854248047,
-0.02594633586704731,
0.01627964898943901,
0.012271098792552948,
0.005697856657207012,
0.037625014781951904,
0.0037555478047579527,
-0.03328326344490051,
-0.0006333229830488563,
-0.0007557574426755309,
0.021146051585674286,
0.05406290665268898,
-0.06222027912735939,
-0.0025622649118304253,
-0.05752530321478844,
-0.015798375010490417,
-0.01570354588329792,
-0.039099983870983124,
0.06171184778213501,
0.07752757519483566,
-0.03142448887228966,
-0.054598234593868256,
-0.011370455846190453,
-0.03178868070244789,
0.0016300131101161242,
-0.01851383037865162,
-0.04162752255797386,
0.012905032373964787,
0.0038400846533477306,
-0.03805451840162277,
0.04885770380496979,
0.016793493181467056,
0.01941206306219101,
0.013988851569592953,
-0.01027250662446022,
-0.02481875754892826,
0.0012105426285415888,
0.019227322190999985,
-0.026827001944184303,
-0.012659743428230286,
-0.00875155534595251,
-0.08969130367040634,
0.0020248866640031338,
0.02381422556936741,
-0.035826776176691055,
0.05676184222102165,
-0.01887214183807373,
0.014435152523219585,
-0.0026630947832018137,
0.006297333166003227,
0.027883348986506462,
0.2080337554216385,
0.022116078063845634,
-0.019788801670074463,
0.00798519141972065,
0.015912620350718498,
-0.017120420932769775,
0.028533831238746643,
0.03455532342195511,
0.046640098094940186,
-0.020692933350801468,
-0.05199871212244034,
-0.005202768370509148,
0.012283063493669033,
0.031665701419115067,
-0.03596080094575882,
0.006245467811822891,
0.001294147688895464,
-0.003478199476376176,
0.0739365741610527,
0.015086316503584385,
0.05034768208861351,
-0.030050620436668396,
-0.015252437442541122,
0.03201541304588318,
-0.03720463812351227,
0.0031186961568892,
0.03534000739455223,
-0.0037865571212023497,
-0.049324989318847656,
0.03726106882095337,
-0.01733233593404293,
-0.02582562528550625,
0.033254727721214294,
0.005485087167471647,
-0.004568937234580517,
-0.015835678204894066,
-0.034880928695201874,
0.022560471668839455,
0.0014380451757460833,
0.06607318669557571,
-0.028086114674806595,
-0.040388938039541245,
0.0008757738396525383,
0.012866256758570671,
0.02512035146355629,
0.014204053208231926,
-0.0003991697449237108,
-0.01623331755399704,
-0.009519554674625397,
0.04549913480877876,
-0.0300042275339365,
0.013343008235096931,
-0.01634397730231285,
-0.008713260293006897,
-0.010071639902889729,
-0.01783287152647972,
-0.024643663316965103,
-0.011303506791591644,
-0.056784454733133316,
0.0447491817176342,
-0.00018452925723977387,
-0.010030624456703663,
-0.05689483508467674,
0.015320945531129837,
-0.006828314159065485,
0.02446247637271881,
-0.04171302542090416,
-0.014571452513337135,
0.05032402276992798,
0.03250785544514656,
0.019530080258846283,
0.0397728867828846,
0.00748420599848032,
0.042051732540130615,
0.05181829258799553,
-0.0038161000702530146,
-0.02501961775124073,
0.025950750336050987,
-0.006703480612486601,
0.039174146950244904,
-0.02520107664167881,
0.0016341476002708077,
-0.019549259915947914,
-0.008358119986951351,
0.02295505441725254,
-0.029668297618627548,
0.027396950870752335,
0.03319362550973892,
0.012947316281497478,
0.03190966323018074,
-0.02518634870648384,
-0.05555831640958786,
-0.043995436280965805,
0.01735581085085869,
-0.07231397181749344,
0.01145930401980877,
0.04012829810380936,
0.008016207255423069,
-0.012471096590161324,
-0.010445468127727509,
-0.0034564209636300802,
0.010189647786319256,
0.03456789255142212,
-0.04177803546190262,
0.003390875179320574,
0.016937904059886932,
-0.016126491129398346,
0.008666264824569225,
-0.037536345422267914,
-0.005154510959982872,
-0.014037462882697582,
-0.002963640261441469,
0.004581109620630741,
0.027173859998583794,
0.005309620872139931,
0.01807556487619877,
-0.029141366481781006,
0.028551550582051277,
0.04359768331050873,
0.0336824432015419,
0.007783733773976564,
-0.005657540634274483,
-0.03376837074756622,
-0.012598007917404175,
0.0039853486232459545,
0.011681011877954006,
-0.030317414551973343,
0.030149154365062714,
0.004465325269848108,
0.02753506414592266,
-0.006445067934691906,
-0.017586572095751762,
-0.014481968246400356,
0.023775368928909302,
0.01895798370242119,
0.020267020910978317,
0.040270816534757614,
0.012396547012031078,
0.021171025931835175,
0.013518636114895344,
-0.0009106172365136445,
-0.01619488000869751,
-0.03981317952275276,
0.00926330778747797,
0.006913988851010799,
-0.016857702285051346,
0.007091806270182133,
-0.023852981626987457,
-0.04712904244661331,
-0.005506268236786127,
-0.003631065832450986,
0.009319453500211239,
-0.018609078601002693,
-0.030189884826540947,
0.012158263474702835,
-0.00035406165989115834,
0.002555763814598322,
-0.029051000252366066,
0.009756652638316154,
0.01615653559565544,
0.009128477424383163,
-0.008780003525316715,
-0.005236632656306028,
0.04767625406384468,
-0.00731958681717515,
0.03131256625056267,
-0.025026410818099976,
0.020368287339806557,
0.013644739054143429,
-0.008958776481449604,
-0.009419048205018044,
-0.047792140394449234,
-0.049025554209947586,
0.08367417007684708,
0.03819061815738678,
0.03354684263467789,
0.03409401327371597,
0.028255367651581764,
-0.006343482993543148,
-0.06375347077846527,
0.035138264298439026,
0.023658178746700287,
-0.01219036802649498,
0.011187576688826084,
-0.032182615250349045,
-0.015082287602126598,
0.008245195262134075,
-0.0007324395119212568,
0.062184710055589676,
-0.04305284470319748,
-0.006965861190110445,
0.06978652626276016,
0.009097207337617874,
-0.02865184284746647,
0.03333791717886925,
0.03017391450703144,
-0.009760867804288864,
0.0292512197047472,
0.025992903858423233,
-0.05037960410118103,
-0.03379276767373085,
0.04885613173246384,
-0.003025713609531522,
-0.020137349143624306,
0.07745105773210526,
0.022711165249347687,
-0.01613566093146801,
0.01616864651441574,
-0.06655305624008179,
-0.055255740880966187,
0.02057512104511261,
-0.024974992498755455,
-0.014687882736325264,
0.034227363765239716,
-0.021822841838002205,
-0.0025434051640331745,
0.018163863569498062,
0.0467497855424881,
0.0053678774274885654,
-0.06804969161748886,
-0.027467459440231323,
-0.03206833079457283,
0.048835549503564835,
-0.0753033310174942,
0.011907117441296577,
-0.018992528319358826,
-0.008457367308437824,
-0.002530893078073859,
0.0032204792369157076,
0.022448599338531494,
0.012747072614729404,
-0.04225483164191246,
0.04773390293121338,
0.033557482063770294,
-0.0052475943230092525,
0.01704222522675991,
0.028815479949116707,
-0.013228203170001507,
0.03264433518052101,
-0.02649826370179653,
0.003055453533306718,
0.055968765169382095,
0.07125425338745117,
0.060445062816143036,
0.02039501816034317,
0.009022215381264687,
-0.025986865162849426,
-0.00803268700838089,
0.0461483858525753,
0.08096636086702347,
0.02116580121219158,
0.03188209608197212,
-0.028826892375946045,
-0.020153123885393143,
0.017391012981534004,
0.0033907066099345684,
0.011644570156931877,
-0.007980229333043098,
-0.057971127331256866,
-0.00984814204275608,
-0.015152940526604652,
0.004323281813412905,
0.012259977869689465,
-0.023835817351937294,
-0.011642307043075562,
-0.0556853711605072,
0.029064390808343887,
-0.009559685364365578,
-0.03313712775707245,
-0.016646379604935646,
0.0019419975578784943,
0.01848040148615837,
-0.003593709086999297,
-0.0403314046561718,
0.00561519106850028,
0.026080701500177383,
-0.017123347148299217,
0.0225517675280571,
0.019289981573820114,
0.005568317137658596,
0.030170174315571785,
0.009965303353965282,
0.02208232507109642,
0.02275608852505684,
-0.023317942395806313,
0.023105069994926453,
0.016975710168480873,
-0.002979499055072665,
-0.02847517468035221,
-0.010729419998824596,
0.008466606959700584,
-0.009404522366821766,
0.01684306561946869,
0.040936924517154694,
0.014332232996821404,
0.014093415811657906,
0.010965757071971893,
0.03633506968617439,
-0.006552412174642086,
0.026612654328346252,
-0.046149842441082,
0.06242484226822853,
-0.010246967896819115,
-0.07186616957187653,
-0.04107051342725754,
0.06140890344977379,
0.005826336331665516,
-0.02015376091003418,
-0.011682840995490551,
0.02719733864068985,
-0.0282982736825943,
-0.05095613747835159,
-0.0018132806289941072,
0.0008062598062679172,
0.04437935724854469,
0.0164167582988739,
-0.009639199823141098,
-0.01807929389178753,
-0.04695819318294525,
-0.0002432560286251828,
-0.00377402501180768,
0.0036101595032960176,
-0.0230849776417017,
-0.019608013331890106,
-0.055999044328927994,
-0.01397032756358385,
0.025531521067023277,
-0.05284155160188675,
-0.03785738721489906,
-0.005694136023521423,
-0.045333582907915115,
-0.015952767804265022,
0.03350361809134483,
-0.01769327186048031,
0.01583211123943329,
0.0338016077876091,
-0.011671300046145916,
0.015736771747469902,
0.0053994921036064625,
-0.04597673937678337,
0.022516751661896706,
-0.0536222942173481,
0.04622030258178711,
-0.01678668148815632,
0.0016283869044855237,
0.0037173619493842125,
0.003299315692856908,
0.008503610268235207,
0.012970156036317348,
0.014086487703025341,
0.02766556851565838,
-0.010867515578866005,
-0.04070057347416878,
-0.050259873270988464,
0.054442521184682846,
0.024759596213698387,
-0.03209158033132553,
0.016467813402414322,
0.017810171470046043,
-0.00546739948913455,
-0.03990863636136055,
0.012879344634711742,
-0.024008415639400482,
-0.014909406192600727,
0.04877661541104317,
-0.033343516290187836,
-0.04003695771098137,
-0.004276707768440247,
0.013890177011489868,
0.023447109386324883,
0.020985353738069534,
0.03169294074177742,
-0.01912461780011654,
0.04277266189455986,
-0.023851793259382248,
0.022067124024033546,
0.0032058984506875277,
-0.0017715392168611288,
-0.02700887992978096,
0.005019850097596645,
0.014795380644500256,
0.01568317413330078,
-0.024357952177524567,
-0.019896745681762695,
-0.017814235761761665,
0.013406255282461643,
0.02385459654033184,
0.019526952877640724,
0.004122568294405937,
0.04433301463723183,
-0.013005169108510017,
0.044116172939538956,
-0.03369647264480591,
0.04118145629763603,
-0.13622675836086273,
0.01519785262644291,
0.028997913002967834,
0.01762116700410843,
-0.023966966196894646,
0.021890323609113693,
-0.0034332394134253263,
0.018242722377181053,
-0.028215518221259117,
-0.016138935461640358,
-0.018970509991049767,
-0.058984026312828064,
0.0011110558407381177,
-0.023598702624440193,
0.01733378879725933,
0.008767204359173775,
0.00837764609605074,
-0.02918986976146698,
-0.029388489201664925,
0.0008714658324606717,
0.016586776822805405,
0.010736770927906036,
-0.0013589992886409163,
0.0066773793660104275,
0.014463038183748722,
-0.0033782317768782377,
-0.053674425929784775,
0.001704584457911551,
-0.033990129828453064,
-0.06150626391172409,
-0.023318693041801453,
-0.03191785514354706,
0.0311492457985878,
0.07708869874477386,
-0.014901242218911648,
0.026151929050683975,
0.007570858579128981,
-0.048827897757291794,
-0.04332422837615013,
-0.014926711097359657,
-0.029048819094896317,
0.030049066990613937,
-0.015001029707491398,
-0.04829452931880951,
0.013551279902458191,
0.026489613577723503,
-0.057860832661390305,
-0.013634737581014633,
-0.04522841051220894,
-0.01653122715651989,
0.0004176054790150374,
0.025892289355397224,
-0.006640332285314798,
0.0198475681245327,
0.01403920166194439,
-0.014319153502583504,
-0.0004550032608676702,
-0.0036474792286753654,
0.03988194838166237,
0.030653994530439377,
-0.036733102053403854,
0.034149330109357834,
0.0012126521905884147,
-0.027366328984498978,
0.008744321763515472,
-0.0010822989279404283,
-0.060882020741701126,
0.0008243413758464158,
-0.007042413577437401,
0.043811727315187454,
-0.02179529517889023,
-0.016166143119335175,
-0.0058085015043616295,
-0.017745180055499077,
0.028030365705490112,
-0.005777485202997923,
0.011826557107269764,
-0.002597624436020851,
-0.04829852655529976,
-0.002578306244686246,
-0.03535532206296921,
0.00944806169718504,
0.0017065440770238638,
0.03967876359820366,
0.0438094362616539,
0.019285257905721664,
-0.009420441463589668,
-0.018336612731218338,
0.039978329092264175,
-0.007715645711869001,
-0.06315948814153671,
0.010589796118438244,
-0.03341149538755417,
0.04379470646381378,
-0.004022656008601189,
0.010079813189804554,
-0.015246208757162094,
0.006466733757406473,
-0.03920333459973335,
-0.008920221589505672,
-0.060523707419633865,
-0.029390083625912666,
0.006334430072456598,
-0.024386977776885033,
-0.02510727383196354,
0.002801865106448531,
0.04534574970602989,
-0.04328316077589989,
0.03897515684366226,
-0.011408433318138123,
0.023780470713973045,
-0.004630926996469498,
-0.013691764324903488,
0.02750231884419918,
-0.027065899223089218,
0.0450475811958313,
0.008627439849078655,
-0.006945490371435881,
0.018839597702026367,
-0.01210456807166338,
-0.011416139081120491,
0.006732054986059666,
-0.005364842247217894,
-0.032964713871479034,
0.00428365683183074,
0.01904572732746601,
0.04741896688938141,
0.011297878809273243,
-0.010777279734611511,
-0.035896945744752884,
0.04232182726264,
0.026905421167612076,
0.01662968099117279,
-0.0018888757331296802,
0.02697436884045601,
0.009861912578344345,
-0.04580771178007126,
0.007153138518333435,
-0.05801471322774887,
-0.037261296063661575,
0.0021639547776430845,
0.011697488836944103,
0.007858485914766788,
-0.006311110220849514,
-0.008846334181725979,
-0.025914857164025307,
0.06472118198871613,
-0.03886198252439499,
-0.015947340056300163,
-0.050145894289016724,
-0.012023056857287884,
0.02205747552216053,
-0.018650347366929054,
0.06153477728366852,
0.03511083871126175,
-0.018526297062635422,
0.013173985294997692,
-0.02927309088408947,
0.02317192777991295,
0.014645801857113838,
-0.007892824709415436,
-0.024125676602125168,
-0.05846099182963371,
-0.01952040009200573,
-0.039997201412916183,
0.029821304604411125,
-0.03401288390159607,
0.021100930869579315,
-0.032359328120946884,
-0.03503575921058655,
-0.012298171408474445,
0.017050189897418022,
-0.04110170155763626,
-0.013279398903250694,
0.018727008253335953,
0.03392120823264122,
-0.01302021462470293,
0.027371391654014587,
0.010791807435452938,
-0.046560488641262054,
0.02603597193956375,
0.04477529600262642,
-0.00501665286719799,
0.05690717697143555,
-0.04786615073680878,
0.016146333888173103,
0.06591976433992386,
0.025217369198799133,
0.006850715260952711,
-0.04108302295207977,
-0.009135239757597446,
-0.009715026244521141,
-0.014243588782846928,
-0.005244806874543428,
0.03292970731854439,
0.01382017694413662,
-0.0028931335546076298,
0.012065871618688107,
0.036634597927331924,
0.031874533742666245,
0.02793785370886326,
-0.04541485756635666,
-0.0376339815557003,
-0.036795858293771744,
-0.0419117771089077,
-0.043651241809129715,
-0.02644975297152996,
-0.02597145363688469,
0.0014557195827364922,
0.08159200847148895,
-0.025630775839090347,
-0.04272690415382385,
-0.01518181525170803,
-0.010064953938126564,
-0.006186801008880138,
0.045129552483558655,
0.011386236175894737,
-0.03195946291089058,
0.07525444775819778,
-0.022642644122242928,
0.019165752455592155,
0.037714265286922455,
-0.03825033828616142,
-0.011753542348742485,
0.016651930287480354,
0.013274558819830418,
-0.007619299925863743,
-0.008317341096699238,
-0.03240365535020828,
-0.028875475749373436,
0.01419172715395689,
-0.014696281403303146,
0.013424797914922237,
0.05811186879873276,
-0.005727208219468594,
-0.008100062608718872,
-0.04131888970732689,
-0.017274266108870506,
-0.01831524819135666,
-0.024006521329283714,
0.0015176847809925675,
0.0062028272077441216,
0.021926598623394966,
0.00038929074071347713
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:46
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
684At 2.00pm Messrs Gillard, Renshall and Hickie attended Mr Hilliard's office for the settlement. Mr and Mrs Zdrilic were also present.
685At the outset, Mr Gillard announced that:-
"The money is not ready."
686Not only that, but, as Mr Gillard and Mr Renshall were expecting, but Mr Hilliard and Mr Zdrilic were not, Mr Moir was not present.
687According to Mr Zdrilic, Mr Gillard said the money was not ready because of "technical issues that have nothing to do with HTT".
688Mr Gillard denied this and said that he gave no explanation for Mr Moir's non-appearance, and that none was sought.
689Mr Hilliard gave evidence of the following conversation:-
Mr Hilliard: "I expected James Moir to be present with the $4.5 million. I've also got the Withdrawal of Caveat for him."
Mr Gillard: "James Moir won't be attending this settlement. I will be having a separate settlement with him at which time I will hand over the Withdrawal of Caveat".
Mr Hilliard: "I thought I'd be handing the Withdrawal of Caveat direct to James Moir. The conditions to be satisfied before I hand over the Withdrawal of Caveat are set out in my draft letter to HTT" [Mr Hillard was referring to the TressCox Caveat Undertaking].
Mr Gillard: "I'll give you an undertaking to give it to him".
690Mr Gillard disputed that Mr Hilliard had said "the conditions to be satisfied before I hand over the Withdrawal of Caveat are set out in my draft letter to HTT" but otherwise he did not dispute the conversation. Indeed he said he clearly recalled saying that he would give Mr Hilliard an undertaking to give the Withdrawal of Caveat to Mr Moir.
691Mr Hilliard also said that he had a number of questions to ask about the draft IPC Heads of Agreement enclosed with Mr Gillard's letter of 27 August 2004.
692Mr Renshall asked to look at the draft and then told Mr Hilliard that it had been superseded and that Mr Moir had the final version.
693Mr Hilliard made some notes in respect of the draft agreement he had been given including, in respect of clause 3.1(b) (which was in the same form as in the final document):-
"Has IPC provided proof of its Financial position?"
694Mr Hilliard agreed that his perusal of the draft agreement made it obvious to him that the document:-
"Contained no obligation imposed upon the New Zealand funder to provide any money any time soon".
695The HTT Defendants relied on this evidence as demonstrating that, whatever may have been said by Renshall to Mr Zdrilic, it was by now clear that HTT had no committed funder.
27 August 2004 - The Seventeenth Representations
696It was in these circumstances that, during the settlement meeting of 27 August 2004, the Seventeenth Representations were allegedly made.
697Those representations were as follows:-
* that the new funder would advance $4.5 million "next week" and that the balance of the $12 million would be paid on 15 September 2004;
* the new funder would by 15 September 2004 put in $12 million by way of loan funds which would cover the existing loans of $7 million, the Cook Land purchase for $3 million, and other things for $2 million;
* on top of the $12 million loan advance, the new funder would pay $6.5 million to the "small investors" for their units;
* the new funder would take a 71.25 per cent equity stake by purchasing all of the shares in HTT and units in the Huntley Trust other than those held by Sentel;
* finalisation of the deal and the advancement of funds was assured;
* there was no impediment to funds being advanced by the new funders;
* the funds were definitely going to be advanced to HTT by the new funder;
* the new funder had plenty of money;
* the new funder was obliged to advance the funds;
* it made no difference whether the funds were advanced by the new funder today or next week because HTT had an agreement with the new funder that the $12 million would be advanced by 15 September 2004;
|
[
0.014846954494714737,
0.032812707126140594,
-0.03777783736586571,
0.005535498261451721,
-0.011475012637674809,
-0.04348719120025635,
-0.007965448312461376,
-0.014395848847925663,
0.0064756073988974094,
0.000020797746401512995,
0.02786162495613098,
0.02166213095188141,
-0.0328449010848999,
0.005094961728900671,
-0.03273628652095795,
-0.018176013603806496,
0.051537349820137024,
-0.0067966352216899395,
0.03066989779472351,
-0.021459054201841354,
-0.010564140044152737,
-0.020513204857707024,
-0.021999577060341835,
0.043953653424978256,
-0.001901039620861411,
-0.025193827226758003,
-0.044949356466531754,
0.013300548307597637,
0.04357105866074562,
0.02608184702694416,
0.0115280132740736,
0.0072830915451049805,
0.011533426120877266,
0.007033375557512045,
-0.014982681721448898,
-0.00603768415749073,
0.019732961431145668,
0.005946611054241657,
-0.03476186841726303,
0.015187520533800125,
-0.009220593608915806,
0.029626324772834778,
0.004347169306129217,
-0.0003140523040201515,
0.08351939171552658,
-0.04038003459572792,
0.001707834075205028,
-0.01279742643237114,
0.025773003697395325,
0.0318814255297184,
-0.029878584668040276,
-0.05938131734728813,
0.024332158267498016,
-0.007398625370115042,
-0.005682599265128374,
-0.02919696643948555,
-0.01425414253026247,
0.01629113033413887,
-0.014622341841459274,
-0.007909269072115421,
-0.013671181164681911,
0.01541133038699627,
-0.06419321149587631,
0.004935809876769781,
0.011772369034588337,
0.10537120699882507,
0.003313138848170638,
0.010593513026833534,
0.005888829007744789,
-0.016169987618923187,
-0.03861868008971214,
-0.020489556714892387,
-0.02169579267501831,
-0.00510905496776104,
-0.07810819149017334,
0.020390182733535767,
0.018558792769908905,
0.011074423789978027,
0.029033716768026352,
0.02798277512192726,
0.05419236421585083,
0.004897234961390495,
-0.0031383943278342485,
0.027207940816879272,
-0.03742970898747444,
-0.004694253206253052,
0.007916586473584175,
0.0005630609812214971,
0.03244490548968315,
-0.01464620977640152,
0.01864870823919773,
0.002119292737916112,
0.027393102645874023,
-0.07078893482685089,
-0.01583670638501644,
-0.0011366793187335134,
-0.06668207794427872,
0.050999339669942856,
-0.014796651899814606,
0.017758827656507492,
-0.00829726830124855,
0.017318667843937874,
-0.030419863760471344,
-0.018368443474173546,
0.013369539752602577,
0.03544439747929573,
0.04717699810862541,
0.03043210692703724,
0.02252906747162342,
-0.011774381622672081,
0.014614530839025974,
-0.008778457529842854,
0.01830989122390747,
0.0067094299010932446,
-0.02035856805741787,
-0.005743884015828371,
0.007172096520662308,
-0.011507426388561726,
0.010381055064499378,
0.006352810654789209,
0.03752080723643303,
0.004843031521886587,
0.050800155848264694,
-0.028640370815992355,
-0.04660550877451897,
0.006043765228241682,
-0.010841384530067444,
-0.011300590820610523,
0.013228564523160458,
0.014768149703741074,
-0.020113032311201096,
0.003681036876514554,
-0.029728317633271217,
-0.03352729603648186,
-0.025131160393357277,
-0.009123438037931919,
0.008560489863157272,
-0.003329749219119549,
0.010480349883437157,
-0.06726028770208359,
0.019588977098464966,
0.02148781344294548,
0.018066629767417908,
-0.05533110722899437,
0.03821982443332672,
-0.03394053131341934,
0.003325647907331586,
-0.017651835456490517,
0.011874916031956673,
0.019848236814141273,
0.008057148195803165,
-0.0028059540782123804,
-0.005446263123303652,
-0.004610038362443447,
0.03579118102788925,
-0.0372207909822464,
-0.00696709705516696,
-0.010485001839697361,
0.007319403812289238,
0.09216181188821793,
-0.029424142092466354,
0.008656305260956287,
-0.009945530444383621,
-0.006841103080660105,
-0.021198512986302376,
-0.019115107133984566,
0.005581319332122803,
0.028048306703567505,
-0.02156313695013523,
-0.011724228039383888,
0.02105175517499447,
-0.05804761126637459,
0.0571359246969223,
0.00851824413985014,
0.0055822343565523624,
0.0136648491024971,
0.06601158529520035,
0.0059741102159023285,
0.03463326394557953,
-0.003313732333481312,
-0.03661486506462097,
0.07460515201091766,
0.039590876549482346,
-0.030101453885436058,
-0.030106835067272186,
0.021537384018301964,
-0.024615803733468056,
-0.041425738483667374,
-0.0014148375485092402,
0.00968112051486969,
-0.011795133352279663,
-0.0007653964566998184,
0.03455987572669983,
0.00719493580982089,
0.026294374838471413,
-0.01814616098999977,
0.013873019255697727,
-0.03993392735719681,
-0.024536985903978348,
0.0007207125891000032,
-0.043159209191799164,
0.037717387080192566,
0.06205118075013161,
-0.041642118245363235,
-0.005746521987020969,
-0.011400796473026276,
-0.010209118947386742,
-0.034374695271253586,
0.010014687664806843,
-0.05273934826254845,
-0.010352998971939087,
0.03961881622672081,
0.0003368555917404592,
-0.004259670618921518,
0.009053604677319527,
0.02184036374092102,
0.00944413524121046,
-0.017802001908421516,
0.01075515802949667,
-0.019719330593943596,
0.012143188156187534,
0.026204340159893036,
0.00707444129511714,
0.02128765918314457,
0.012926778756082058,
0.06296249479055405,
-0.0502278171479702,
0.030962293967604637,
-0.015243212692439556,
-0.04585203900933266,
-0.005987738724797964,
-0.029589688405394554,
-0.0060196444392204285,
0.0006190818967297673,
0.033500052988529205,
0.0411120280623436,
0.02546684816479683,
0.003294527530670166,
0.01861506514251232,
0.044999860227108,
-0.05918033793568611,
0.056037537753582,
-0.021363001316785812,
0.009574554860591888,
-0.019765058532357216,
-0.005454998929053545,
0.009951476007699966,
0.011432238854467869,
0.018422726541757584,
-0.016930973157286644,
0.0032994456123560667,
-0.00111574016045779,
0.0005198385915718973,
0.0031292454805225134,
0.0027248424012213945,
0.030146783217787743,
-0.0017860395601019263,
-0.021304327994585037,
0.027132917195558548,
0.019398780539631844,
0.04443423077464104,
-0.010066312737762928,
0.022875547409057617,
0.021469874307513237,
-0.0003863728779833764,
-0.03080725111067295,
-0.04346344247460365,
-0.05642341822385788,
0.045703139156103134,
-0.008718187920749187,
0.024420635774731636,
0.007337701972573996,
0.006817916873842478,
0.027752676978707314,
0.0358046256005764,
0.021173324435949326,
0.0006658789934590459,
0.008482517674565315,
-0.017848102375864983,
-0.017656099051237106,
0.012712577357888222,
-0.017537854611873627,
0.026596665382385254,
-0.02420547418296337,
0.029154760763049126,
0.0644569844007492,
0.010524247772991657,
-0.0134564358741045,
0.023444002494215965,
-0.018132243305444717,
-0.0011468071024864912,
0.02702466771006584,
0.06501171737909317,
0.005922284908592701,
-0.03271574527025223,
-0.05027167499065399,
-0.023415841162204742,
-0.1620451956987381,
0.01110767014324665,
-0.010501408949494362,
0.008133414201438427,
0.0003273367474321276,
0.025062566623091698,
-0.00929664820432663,
0.015077091753482819,
-0.029268618673086166,
-0.006188055034726858,
-0.0031576319597661495,
-0.047265440225601196,
0.012764493003487587,
0.04626155644655228,
-0.011869538575410843,
-0.035974275320768356,
-0.002353604882955551,
0.01078321784734726,
0.03461458534002304,
-0.04379978030920029,
0.0035344150383025408,
-0.03875822201371193,
0.04364651441574097,
0.0038279639557003975,
0.02704109065234661,
0.0029687308706343174,
-0.015739362686872482,
0.014166810549795628,
-0.03909110277891159,
-0.0024969123769551516,
-0.03750171884894371,
0.00580801023170352,
-0.014356005936861038,
0.04582752287387848,
-0.01624315232038498,
0.0366414338350296,
0.06518063694238663,
-0.0544232539832592,
-0.01583903096616268,
-0.025098849087953568,
0.001767704146914184,
0.03484337031841278,
0.008424702100455761,
0.012945771217346191,
0.015533742494881153,
-0.07110081613063812,
-0.005192132201045752,
0.02428000420331955,
0.022628309205174446,
0.04561608284711838,
0.01137548964470625,
0.014276226982474327,
-0.052711356431245804,
-0.0387333482503891,
-0.0010134191252291203,
-0.006428644526749849,
0.004373878240585327,
0.02805558778345585,
-0.04591750353574753,
-0.003373007755726576,
-0.00977290142327547,
-0.07736703753471375,
0.015477079898118973,
0.03311828896403313,
-0.0025412701070308685,
0.04247771203517914,
-0.014906934462487698,
-0.040874190628528595,
0.03957836329936981,
0.031778305768966675,
0.02665620669722557,
0.0010423632338643074,
0.021576792001724243,
0.002424837788566947,
0.05692584067583084,
0.029312483966350555,
-0.019338225945830345,
-0.006481165532022715,
-0.005892235320061445,
-0.10550811141729355,
-0.01481263805180788,
0.04534898325800896,
-0.010446702130138874,
0.026390762999653816,
0.007214623503386974,
0.015738949179649353,
0.005508867092430592,
0.025615038350224495,
0.028013037517666817,
0.25586026906967163,
0.008016388863325119,
-0.01731715351343155,
0.031211603432893753,
0.021056590601801872,
-0.0004173706111032516,
-0.007495207246392965,
0.007971454411745071,
-0.03721094876527786,
-0.05195411294698715,
-0.022551778703927994,
-0.01157646905630827,
0.009112238883972168,
-0.01839587837457657,
-0.019342798739671707,
0.03615112230181694,
-0.06695498526096344,
-0.02335023693740368,
0.07146412134170532,
0.013079599477350712,
0.04762911796569824,
0.0006660284707322717,
-0.028694117441773415,
0.02539793960750103,
-0.06908217072486877,
-0.03842644393444061,
0.018011989071965218,
0.057286348193883896,
-0.05113476142287254,
-0.009181012399494648,
-0.016743401065468788,
-0.007923506200313568,
0.05064786225557327,
0.004484259057790041,
0.031257446855306625,
0.02645297721028328,
0.0049649691209197044,
0.02214748039841652,
0.0006629399140365422,
0.029365647584199905,
-0.004235260654240847,
-0.049169547855854034,
0.0014408491551876068,
-0.024349071085453033,
-0.0524076446890831,
0.032730694860219955,
-0.026584235951304436,
0.050890129059553146,
-0.03580707684159279,
0.006907939445227385,
0.008223628625273705,
0.020083412528038025,
-0.032476089894771576,
0.006515000946819782,
-0.020618660375475883,
0.04099353402853012,
-0.027055906131863594,
0.052975233644247055,
-0.009783272631466389,
0.04001288861036301,
0.005021226592361927,
0.02823220007121563,
-0.04229876399040222,
-0.013722119852900505,
0.009355319663882256,
-0.01755804568529129,
-0.07928556948900223,
-0.03640960901975632,
0.03249088674783707,
0.03826615959405899,
0.03579595685005188,
0.01944630779325962,
-0.02562534436583519,
0.00890512764453888,
0.01991666667163372,
-0.007948754355311394,
-0.0483994223177433,
0.006114603485912085,
-0.008898749016225338,
-0.01916705258190632,
-0.03128155320882797,
-0.056160666048526764,
-0.032086990773677826,
0.014023448340594769,
0.020076556131243706,
0.016213566064834595,
-0.03183741122484207,
0.055687759071588516,
-0.024245524778962135,
-0.03168093040585518,
-0.00860089436173439,
-0.019542250782251358,
0.011374936439096928,
-0.02904869243502617,
-0.00034303864231333137,
-0.008919059298932552,
0.02443479560315609,
0.0033374554477632046,
-0.05693168193101883,
-0.02368202805519104,
0.020814236253499985,
0.01364222913980484,
0.03293590247631073,
-0.03950733691453934,
0.0400712825357914,
-0.016798237338662148,
-0.018965208902955055,
-0.010475197806954384,
-0.053379494696855545,
-0.0394238717854023,
-0.01677151769399643,
-0.008309509605169296,
0.012296706438064575,
-0.03644169121980667,
0.06364603340625763,
0.038326967507600784,
-0.01006085705012083,
0.06257042288780212,
0.02957487292587757,
0.005948758218437433,
-0.014123874716460705,
0.010031098499894142,
-0.041194166988134384,
-0.020347315818071365,
-0.012676217593252659,
-0.0016688742907717824,
-0.01901724375784397,
-0.0021673741284757853,
-0.01214730367064476,
-0.005186667665839195,
0.0057379803620278835,
-0.02981320582330227,
-0.046584319323301315,
0.010815730318427086,
0.02945040352642536,
0.017444193363189697,
0.026444097980856895,
0.001010083593428135,
-0.03783899545669556,
0.008417520672082901,
-0.04675443470478058,
0.02105935476720333,
-0.010347733274102211,
-0.024655375629663467,
0.004982775077223778,
0.009156775660812855,
-0.04940582066774368,
0.00042611086973920465,
-0.06404197216033936,
0.009810036048293114,
-0.001693019294179976,
0.025195026770234108,
-0.04529479146003723,
-0.007044810336083174,
0.018225286155939102,
0.030674198642373085,
-0.008798019029200077,
-0.013301441445946693,
0.03330595791339874,
-0.01105028297752142,
-0.003963798750191927,
0.009491032920777798,
0.025866955518722534,
-0.0032153164502233267,
0.03392660617828369,
0.07509538531303406,
-0.017023641616106033,
0.049919165670871735,
0.0202712994068861,
-0.05062456056475639,
0.013857832178473473,
-0.04487713798880577,
-0.011389164254069328,
0.07239341735839844,
-0.0019838742446154356,
0.03210904821753502,
0.0579894594848156,
0.009825564920902252,
0.0258597731590271,
-0.011255128309130669,
0.03514525294303894,
0.01758480817079544,
-0.028716864064335823,
0.002321304054930806,
0.0095216054469347,
-0.0021885023452341557,
-0.016300445422530174,
-0.0257724542170763,
0.041286349296569824,
-0.06890077888965607,
-0.01456594467163086,
0.0637216866016388,
0.018378544598817825,
-0.028242027387022972,
-0.007568922825157642,
-0.008905533701181412,
-0.01643260568380356,
0.05404062196612358,
-0.020590215921401978,
-0.020031534135341644,
-0.017580300569534302,
-0.00697680376470089,
0.008610589429736137,
0.0002186941565014422,
0.018090609461069107,
0.01081167720258236,
0.00666837440803647,
0.0407683327794075,
-0.03433053195476532,
-0.03422160819172859,
0.007581633049994707,
0.018481815233826637,
-0.0049296491779387,
0.00582905625924468,
0.028941910713911057,
-0.05135432258248329,
0.01181836612522602,
0.038729723542928696,
0.040353622287511826,
-0.04027026891708374,
-0.009844805113971233,
-0.02761227823793888,
0.01667766273021698,
-0.04331611469388008,
-0.013208783231675625,
0.03273361548781395,
-0.04890892282128334,
-0.013891148380935192,
-0.0032929249573498964,
-0.01074673980474472,
0.00002923600004578475,
-0.06727468967437744,
0.07527581602334976,
-0.05237584933638573,
-0.008758094161748886,
0.01794946752488613,
0.05133635923266411,
-0.022806424647569656,
0.027757132425904274,
-0.004973547533154488,
0.018321793526411057,
-0.0014795775059610605,
-0.004993132781237364,
0.049116101115942,
0.0012958160368725657,
-0.01867746375501156,
-0.015065954066812992,
-0.005244096741080284,
-0.016784340143203735,
0.051448218524456024,
0.0077253952622413635,
0.034525468945503235,
-0.00688618328422308,
-0.001741576474159956,
0.008256408385932446,
0.014505011029541492,
0.006257698405534029,
-0.052172429859638214,
-0.01584586128592491,
-0.03631041571497917,
0.00045370275620371103,
0.012055173516273499,
0.0013815488200634718,
-0.004128553904592991,
-0.06972022354602814,
-0.07668255269527435,
0.018917974084615707,
-0.006251144222915173,
-0.020860666409134865,
-0.016085462644696236,
0.0004876194871030748,
-0.022686142474412918,
0.016371440142393112,
-0.033900510519742966,
-0.007625526748597622,
0.013363776728510857,
-0.019939403980970383,
0.004699543584138155,
0.016943974420428276,
0.015917163342237473,
-0.003561300691217184,
0.006943012122064829,
-0.011065392754971981,
0.028357859700918198,
-0.03996466472744942,
0.03778897598385811,
-0.01858651079237461,
-0.005922977346926928,
0.007855028845369816,
-0.017459610477089882,
0.004760676063597202,
0.011381545104086399,
0.013139547780156136,
0.026344994083046913,
0.03915571793913841,
-0.04964097589254379,
-0.0019062019418925047,
0.021800270304083824,
-0.014330115169286728,
0.026042193174362183,
-0.029129790142178535,
-0.019744040444493294,
-0.03761463612318039,
-0.03730551153421402,
-0.013635423965752125,
0.014486094005405903,
0.01699194498360157,
0.005808009300380945,
-0.04746289178729057,
-0.010357762686908245,
0.019051309674978256,
-0.04969971999526024,
0.03341786190867424,
-0.043032705783843994,
0.047828689217567444,
-0.005147215444594622,
0.023312143981456757,
-0.0018814621726050973,
-0.02725232020020485,
0.009544512256979942,
0.01230538822710514,
-0.001948460005223751,
-0.04643488675355911,
-0.0024838256649672985,
-0.043945614248514175,
0.007823128253221512,
0.01627185568213463,
-0.026843788102269173,
-0.027238138020038605,
0.006649228278547525,
-0.026999861001968384,
-0.008777033537626266,
0.003688613185659051,
0.003202765481546521,
0.019038209691643715,
-0.029115159064531326,
0.009921841323375702,
0.01891239918768406,
0.05087282508611679,
-0.03770321607589722,
-0.04672769829630852,
-0.04577063024044037,
0.035969894379377365,
-0.008829188533127308,
0.005987910553812981,
-0.0034020752646028996,
-0.01645989529788494,
-0.014189394190907478,
0.032128166407346725,
0.0006544493953697383,
-0.021765220910310745,
0.03203565627336502,
-0.014111663214862347,
-0.030205372720956802,
-0.0034198143985122442,
0.02992834523320198,
-0.0015297535574063659,
0.021334631368517876,
0.019520603120326996,
-0.02098366618156433,
0.01716216653585434,
0.012335041537880898,
0.018285855650901794,
-0.01951722800731659,
-0.007572975941002369,
-0.012232334353029728,
0.003742799162864685,
0.06651138514280319,
0.01432044617831707,
0.024908877909183502,
0.0012448943452909589,
-0.032524801790714264,
0.0024841539561748505,
0.0034320063423365355,
-0.06674925982952118,
0.02772451750934124,
0.016554366797208786,
0.026021365076303482,
-0.00946122221648693,
-0.07045809924602509,
-0.005387680605053902,
-0.019264010712504387,
-0.024886852130293846,
-0.022422604262828827,
0.0455918163061142,
-0.014282519929111004,
-0.02352094277739525,
0.0299980528652668,
0.02797613851726055,
-0.00639339117333293,
0.0043525081127882,
0.00531409028917551,
-0.030335187911987305,
-0.018862247467041016,
-0.14154751598834991,
0.0038518260698765516,
0.010234174318611622,
-0.03662858158349991,
-0.024545298889279366,
-0.005126458127051592,
-0.03445172309875488,
0.0212714783847332,
-0.043611712753772736,
-0.008726846426725388,
0.015341786667704582,
-0.00379480654373765,
0.020778827369213104,
-0.009760023094713688,
-0.05156686529517174,
0.00617453595623374,
-0.028037285432219505,
-0.012726622633635998,
-0.08958200365304947,
0.022157667204737663,
0.019681841135025024,
0.015495331957936287,
-0.004607027862221003,
0.003229384543374181,
0.033913351595401764,
-0.02375372312963009,
0.017697695642709732,
-0.08331301063299179,
-0.04196152836084366,
-0.009630613960325718,
-0.045022863894701004,
0.026985224336385727,
-0.007444330491125584,
0.06246790289878845,
-0.028507383540272713,
-0.013190126046538353,
0.018543649464845657,
-0.019732706248760223,
-0.026296351104974747,
-0.008019940927624702,
0.014225487597286701,
0.04311157763004303,
-0.002826559590175748,
-0.017303476110100746,
-0.014751357957720757,
0.014618069864809513,
-0.014474403113126755,
-0.0049575455486774445,
-0.09264650195837021,
-0.021693721413612366,
-0.041097041219472885,
0.016760749742388725,
0.04849807545542717,
0.04436487704515457,
-0.026055099442601204,
-0.028216995298862457,
0.008057386614382267,
-0.024318832904100418,
0.05253705382347107,
0.049831144511699677,
0.0338408499956131,
0.006838557310402393,
-0.05647752806544304,
-0.017610915005207062,
-0.05158528685569763,
-0.018323468044400215,
-0.017366528511047363,
-0.024874042719602585,
-0.015389341861009598,
0.017646942287683487,
-0.022649433463811874,
-0.012714896351099014,
-0.012299002148211002,
-0.050511684268713,
0.018598517403006554,
-0.049428630620241165,
-0.008489993400871754,
-0.014540248550474644,
-0.03597394376993179,
-0.01101397443562746,
-0.00827657338231802,
0.0008755858871154487,
-0.06631235033273697,
-0.029665984213352203,
0.04901236295700073,
0.054635193198919296,
0.004183591343462467,
-0.03404918685555458,
0.0009385892772115767,
-0.013540981337428093,
-0.04681675508618355,
0.007394278421998024,
-0.007249101530760527,
0.012996071018278599,
-0.03721468523144722,
0.02188812755048275,
0.008278186433017254,
-0.015941161662340164,
-0.02038784883916378,
0.006739479023963213,
-0.03997107595205307,
-0.01770918257534504,
0.018079886212944984,
-0.005189182702451944,
-0.021716488525271416,
-0.01059720665216446,
0.05342104285955429,
0.009934877045452595,
0.0028652173932641745,
-0.0036102691665291786,
-0.014489661902189255,
-0.0038102162070572376,
-0.05281675234436989,
0.03700387850403786,
-0.052205104380846024,
-0.0022252502385526896,
0.024203607812523842,
0.01493887323886156,
0.015250550583004951,
0.010290197096765041,
0.015474480576813221,
-0.017627820372581482,
0.021466035395860672,
-0.012370866723358631,
0.02206580527126789,
0.015537051483988762,
0.061121322214603424,
0.020922811701893806,
0.048354148864746094,
0.004457475617527962,
0.03480542078614235,
-0.0042310296557843685,
0.026070617139339447,
0.030342845246195793,
0.013370299711823463,
0.014108848758041859,
-0.030148742720484734,
0.01247742772102356,
-0.017979290336370468,
0.008754760958254337,
0.020240819081664085,
0.009359585121273994,
-0.011939430609345436,
0.021708916872739792,
-0.055542752146720886,
-0.03446066007018089,
0.02967860735952854,
-0.01637338288128376,
-0.027137868106365204,
-0.004673538729548454,
-0.020358290523290634,
0.016019809991121292,
-0.0072620827704668045,
0.02170894853770733,
0.036384109407663345,
-0.0020795464515686035,
0.02666364051401615,
-0.013296560384333134,
0.02618255652487278,
0.04823850467801094,
0.001737186568789184,
-0.024560071527957916,
-0.05175430700182915,
-0.04918719828128815,
-0.02253778651356697,
0.04790685698390007,
-0.012857097201049328,
0.008582751266658306,
-0.01757398433983326,
-0.035409245640039444,
-0.02369355410337448,
0.010559954680502415,
-0.02628379873931408,
0.02766687609255314,
0.03698744997382164,
-0.02518552727997303,
0.005513625685125589,
-0.004477494861930609,
0.07103968411684036,
-0.04084586724638939,
0.04076599329710007,
0.049114830791950226,
0.05330881476402283,
0.006103352643549442,
0.011600010097026825,
0.013347710482776165,
0.0038721072487533092,
-0.009435358457267284,
-0.02012784220278263,
-0.04307180643081665,
-0.0397510789334774,
-0.01314044464379549,
0.01981661655008793,
-0.00687686912715435,
0.005172073375433683,
0.040225837379693985,
-0.0022931175772100687,
0.03569861128926277,
0.009955174289643764,
0.018790194764733315,
0.03516995534300804,
-0.021358858793973923,
-0.04806451499462128,
-0.011330017820000648,
-0.026573704555630684,
0.0002320836647413671,
0.0033972584642469883,
-0.0634647086262703,
-0.059605225920677185,
0.05735310539603233,
-0.0214122012257576,
-0.01735568232834339,
-0.030005598440766335,
0.032299529761075974,
-0.01497412659227848,
0.028737841174006462,
0.05063780024647713,
-0.04157800227403641,
0.035016920417547226,
-0.03879331797361374,
0.028911318629980087,
0.052316732704639435,
-0.011760163120925426,
-0.028767600655555725,
0.007105311844497919,
0.021866554394364357,
-0.0016860261093825102,
-0.003538090270012617,
0.01707351952791214,
0.0475558303296566,
-0.025003835558891296,
0.019970407709479332,
0.020789893344044685,
0.015592559240758419,
-0.0016990232979878783,
-0.02894127182662487,
-0.05509672686457634,
-0.007323956582695246,
-0.05816667526960373,
0.005683558527380228,
0.05573917552828789,
0.013444925658404827,
0.02753765694797039,
-0.018974924460053444
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:52
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"Telephone to Sam Zdrilic discussing plan to finalise other claims and litigation".
785Mr Hilliard agreed that this entry referred to his proposed attendance on the following Monday, 6 September 2004, at court to hand up the Short Minutes dismissing the 2001 Proceedings.
786Mr Hilliard gave the following evidence in cross-examination:-
Q: "... when you discussed with Mr Zdrilic the plan to finalise litigation you told him in fact that you were proposing to hand the short minutes or order to the court so that the court could make orders in accordance with it; would that be right?"
A: "I don't recall the content, but I don't disagree with what you put to me."
787On Monday, 6 September 2004 Mr Hilliard attended court with Mr Gillard. The orders dismissing the 2001 Proceedings were made.
788Mr Hilliard said that he had no reason to doubt that the settlement he expected to take place between Mr Gillard and Mr Moir would take place.
789But Mr Hilliard agreed that, at the time he consented to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings, he did not ask Mr Gillard or Mr Moir whether the "settlement" had taken place.
790It also follows that Mr Hilliard consented to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings without receiving from Mr Gillard the confirmation of settlement from Mr Moir that he recorded in his "to do" list on 27 August 2004.
791Not only that, but Mr Hilliard could not recall Mr Zdrilic making any enquiry, between 27 August and 6 September 2004, as to whether the $4.5 million had been paid.
792Mr Hilliard gave the following evidence, some of which I have referred to above:-
Q: "At the end of the day on 27 August 2004 the position that had come about was that Mr Moir had not turned up and that no funds had been paid over the HTT?"
A: "That's correct."
Q: "But you understood, based upon something which had been said at the settlement, that $4.5 million would be paid to HTT over the next week or so, indeed the next week?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "So what was said as you understood it at the settlement was that the $4.5 million would be paid next week?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And 27 August 2004 was a Friday?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And you gave Mr Gillard the withdrawal of caveat?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And he gave you an undertaking?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And the undertaking was that he would give it to Mr Moir?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "At a subsequent settlement?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "As it was described to you?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And you expected, did you, that Mr Gillard would, in exchange for giving the withdrawal to Mr Moir, receive funds?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "That is, the $4.5 million said to be payable to HTT in the next week?"
A: "Yes."
...
Q: "And what you were expecting was Mr Gillard would write to you confirming that he had settled and that he had received the $4.5 million?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "Then come 6 September, you went to court with Mr Gillard and joined with him in having the 2001 Proceedings dismissed?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "And you told Mr Einfeld yesterday that you did that without checking to see whether, between 27 August and 6 September, the $4.5 million had been paid?"
A: "Yes."
Q: "Did you between those two dates, 27 August and 6 September, have any discussion with your client, Mr Zdrilic, about whether or not the $4.5 million had been paid?"
A: "I don't recall having such a conversation."
793Mr Hilliard was expecting there to be a "settlement" between Mr Gillard and Mr Moir. He expected that at that settlement, Mr Gillard would hand to Mr Moir the Withdrawal of Caveat handed over on 27 August 2004. He expected Mr Gillard would write to him confirming when that had occurred. He had heard nothing from Mr Gillard.
He certainly did not know that Mr Gillard had already lodged the Withdrawal of Caveat but, more relevantly to the present point, he must have assumed, based on what Mr Gillard had told him, that as at 6 September 2004, there had been no settlement and that no funds had been advanced by the funder to HTT.
|
[
-0.032611723989248276,
0.02623053640127182,
-0.054995279759168625,
0.013896213844418526,
0.002060176571831107,
-0.03531230613589287,
0.004314259625971317,
-0.01803543232381344,
0.010143265128135681,
0.020352300256490707,
-0.0023413635790348053,
0.014266016893088818,
-0.014198863878846169,
-0.008274652063846588,
-0.021934477612376213,
-0.0330938920378685,
0.0356476865708828,
-0.02855709008872509,
0.01156436838209629,
-0.007568993140012026,
0.025610366836190224,
-0.013266605325043201,
0.003829158144071698,
0.03769078850746155,
-0.0339442640542984,
-0.03989057615399361,
-0.02640402503311634,
0.010909628123044968,
0.029970524832606316,
0.032668597996234894,
-0.009285934269428253,
0.007764413952827454,
0.05326184257864952,
0.01138096023350954,
-0.0019505100790411234,
0.002828609896823764,
0.012618438340723515,
-0.009629675187170506,
-0.03678632155060768,
0.029957685619592667,
-0.018448930233716965,
0.0017987084574997425,
0.010690020397305489,
-0.01639993116259575,
0.045435260981321335,
-0.02614462934434414,
-0.02291577123105526,
-0.0018111839890480042,
0.023793091997504234,
0.020661506801843643,
-0.033716414123773575,
-0.041833680123090744,
0.02995525673031807,
-0.01905740797519684,
-0.009970486164093018,
-0.010378443636000156,
-0.00806533545255661,
0.023831309750676155,
-0.030159244313836098,
0.02972930297255516,
0.01797049678862095,
0.0023345474619418383,
-0.045902542769908905,
-0.01510442141443491,
0.005588504485785961,
0.09169332683086395,
-0.0004977639764547348,
0.007620634976774454,
0.00034025710192508996,
-0.023265015333890915,
-0.02955036051571369,
-0.007586273830384016,
-0.004718041513115168,
0.005613020155578852,
-0.07183782011270523,
0.02470814250409603,
0.023228062316775322,
-0.0061424290761351585,
0.02698444575071335,
0.02985580824315548,
0.05477001518011093,
-0.0119317090138793,
-0.007286855019629002,
0.048990316689014435,
-0.060574401170015335,
0.013556815683841705,
0.011692093685269356,
0.04165878891944885,
0.025907061994075775,
-0.018538525328040123,
-0.00016626753495074809,
0.004483385942876339,
0.010073083452880383,
-0.052822791039943695,
-0.014426042325794697,
-0.02246992103755474,
-0.07024860382080078,
0.03322526812553406,
-0.012933575548231602,
0.018152790144085884,
0.0044870320707559586,
0.008960073813796043,
-0.026853276416659355,
-0.0440523587167263,
0.015174207277595997,
0.02691110409796238,
0.06576920300722122,
0.029641469940543175,
0.011450634337961674,
-0.012314767576754093,
-0.007938875816762447,
0.003547828644514084,
-0.0022275166120380163,
0.011079436168074608,
-0.016615036875009537,
-0.013148771598935127,
-0.00985926203429699,
0.02368704229593277,
0.04155810922384262,
-0.025963928550481796,
0.07647702097892761,
0.005173183511942625,
0.029902366921305656,
-0.02890666201710701,
-0.018053805455565453,
0.05176248773932457,
0.002607166999951005,
-0.034711286425590515,
-0.020659947767853737,
0.034912340342998505,
-0.024592669680714607,
0.0402107834815979,
-0.01286885142326355,
-0.03445688635110855,
-0.001159390900284052,
-0.004432410933077335,
0.024249637499451637,
-0.01208864152431488,
0.004484171513468027,
-0.07170707732439041,
0.036349378526210785,
0.019163787364959717,
0.02901431918144226,
-0.049829624593257904,
0.005903969053179026,
-0.044548168778419495,
-0.025224553421139717,
0.016895823180675507,
0.02752886340022087,
-0.01956958696246147,
0.026793532073497772,
-0.010423676110804081,
-0.004303892608731985,
-0.0067179519683122635,
0.043077170848846436,
-0.04655788838863373,
-0.029652386903762817,
0.005551333073526621,
0.025454487651586533,
0.06553705781698227,
-0.019517727196216583,
0.0069560762494802475,
-0.002356159035116434,
0.020264549180865288,
-0.008124853484332561,
-0.006491377484053373,
-0.004390781745314598,
-0.002811923623085022,
-0.001500011538155377,
-0.019241252914071083,
-0.005140019580721855,
-0.04246063902974129,
0.07229506969451904,
0.0004734192043542862,
0.02810930833220482,
0.019223688170313835,
0.06819205731153488,
0.01029753778129816,
0.02616773173213005,
-0.03860010951757431,
-0.035406578332185745,
0.023497259244322777,
0.012881320901215076,
-0.03271985426545143,
-0.04551798850297928,
0.03036804124712944,
-0.022922217845916748,
-0.029433319345116615,
-0.00409652478992939,
0.01946924440562725,
-0.0159841850399971,
-0.0072880578227341175,
0.007318930234760046,
0.02406543493270874,
0.04061291739344597,
0.028857596218585968,
0.00726332888007164,
-0.06574875861406326,
-0.02947784960269928,
-0.006790520157665014,
-0.03910016268491745,
0.022297702729701996,
0.05593552812933922,
0.00018841872224584222,
-0.028895575553178787,
-0.011325467377901077,
-0.00045998572022654116,
-0.017917344346642494,
0.005061930511146784,
-0.03270964324474335,
-0.012405588291585445,
0.02857181243598461,
-0.019824689254164696,
-0.018676908686757088,
0.017865866422653198,
-0.009465044364333153,
0.005971988197416067,
-0.00952825602144003,
0.010649539530277252,
-0.04297264665365219,
0.007595947943627834,
-0.009754414670169353,
-0.023385172709822655,
-0.00327693996950984,
0.017028283327817917,
0.04217854514718056,
-0.07476461678743362,
0.042426034808158875,
-0.031364575028419495,
-0.03211590275168419,
0.0015523455804213881,
0.0018821449484676123,
0.0126092080026865,
-0.013853350654244423,
0.01137305237352848,
0.03632001951336861,
-0.015738854184746742,
0.021515406668186188,
0.003430626355111599,
0.03628652170300484,
-0.01523252110928297,
0.06492573767900467,
-0.005298999138176441,
-0.0009813166689127684,
-0.0017925780266523361,
-0.004651268012821674,
-0.005860117729753256,
0.008854934945702553,
0.02596442401409149,
-0.015822509303689003,
-0.016369998455047607,
-0.004125741310417652,
-0.011088037863373756,
0.030280405655503273,
0.007657065521925688,
0.03910607099533081,
0.00803533848375082,
-0.014381124638020992,
0.03248477727174759,
0.004174048081040382,
0.05601675435900688,
-0.015480275265872478,
0.03198361024260521,
0.024735702201724052,
-0.006446452345699072,
-0.015442555770277977,
-0.011671583168208599,
-0.04329130798578262,
0.03427737206220627,
-0.005641158204525709,
0.02178543619811535,
-0.012310484424233437,
-0.03126120567321777,
0.04509125277400017,
0.016025569289922714,
0.04825089871883392,
0.026719173416495323,
0.017755215987563133,
-0.0034783442970365286,
-0.004653434734791517,
0.003011719323694706,
-0.016876747831702232,
0.050256382673978806,
-0.03528963401913643,
0.03983942046761513,
0.044027943164110184,
-0.04597586393356323,
0.021033361554145813,
0.005268442444503307,
-0.006453486159443855,
-0.006620059721171856,
0.018675243481993675,
0.06703034043312073,
-0.01741275005042553,
-0.04097631573677063,
-0.06936673820018768,
-0.03783659636974335,
-0.14146795868873596,
-0.020975034683942795,
-0.05453334003686905,
0.007406394463032484,
0.002581279957666993,
0.0047022816725075245,
-0.0015696149785071611,
-0.0004613516211975366,
-0.04403352364897728,
0.013275984674692154,
0.022243725135922432,
-0.044719718396663666,
0.026918640360236168,
0.036578767001628876,
-0.013815589249134064,
0.006321074441075325,
-0.015875743702054024,
0.010020959191024303,
0.024130893871188164,
-0.054913148283958435,
-0.019445080310106277,
-0.04434957355260849,
0.04268285259604454,
-0.007131695747375488,
0.02480885572731495,
0.017814964056015015,
-0.021355975419282913,
0.0041560223326087,
-0.031224094331264496,
0.008155004121363163,
-0.025143705308437347,
0.035992447286844254,
-0.016848741099238396,
0.05941564962267876,
0.0005345323588699102,
0.047109514474868774,
0.06335962563753128,
-0.0613832101225853,
-0.014592704363167286,
-0.022237947210669518,
0.029415611177682877,
0.032518938183784485,
0.003155200509354472,
0.01300919707864523,
-0.013439693488180637,
-0.07014474272727966,
-0.009959529154002666,
0.006146812345832586,
0.031023288145661354,
0.012905132956802845,
-0.005573432892560959,
-0.008034680970013142,
-0.0320575125515461,
-0.019486261531710625,
0.010429559275507927,
-0.004931624513119459,
-0.003372395411133766,
0.04520595446228981,
-0.027711233124136925,
0.008178513497114182,
-0.01035243459045887,
-0.04517710208892822,
-0.010637455619871616,
0.03233649581670761,
0.001959968591108918,
0.0008807256235741079,
-0.03530893102288246,
-0.02668854221701622,
0.023498445749282837,
0.030197950080037117,
0.011800572276115417,
-0.00956611055880785,
-0.025689825415611267,
-0.009465187788009644,
0.04396538436412811,
0.005870223976671696,
-0.008392232470214367,
0.02477884478867054,
-0.006639826111495495,
-0.12462971359491348,
-0.04826198145747185,
0.015873773023486137,
-0.03381903097033501,
0.01108121033757925,
0.009188065305352211,
0.012105905450880527,
0.015459205023944378,
0.020809289067983627,
0.019254861399531364,
0.2415313720703125,
-0.003112698905169964,
-0.018051473423838615,
0.03336601331830025,
0.016201650723814964,
-0.009926749393343925,
0.007437319960445166,
0.01774708181619644,
-0.021325813606381416,
-0.05445194989442825,
-0.016168871894478798,
0.006601325701922178,
-0.00442113121971488,
-0.007041063159704208,
0.0007693839725106955,
0.007253325544297695,
-0.08261871337890625,
-0.01885060966014862,
0.08974917232990265,
0.005174621473997831,
0.06187395006418228,
-0.008240429684519768,
-0.0032077343203127384,
-0.0124239232391119,
-0.06349500268697739,
-0.023330772295594215,
0.013802698813378811,
0.04199172183871269,
-0.04275863990187645,
0.025333508849143982,
-0.0265162643045187,
0.0020563655998557806,
0.04094076156616211,
-0.016848482191562653,
0.04042636975646019,
0.033670712262392044,
0.009441085159778595,
-0.019303686916828156,
0.0030336291529238224,
0.003496180521324277,
0.01849239133298397,
-0.04747195541858673,
-0.02411511167883873,
-0.04663329944014549,
-0.05723930150270462,
-0.006774121429771185,
-0.02550678141415119,
0.05175986513495445,
-0.08155550807714462,
0.001109377364628017,
0.026577619835734367,
0.03652413189411163,
-0.0012614913284778595,
-0.011770942248404026,
-0.02482043206691742,
0.02073812484741211,
0.012333621270954609,
0.05712838098406792,
0.02350783534348011,
0.03849722072482109,
-0.00032749056117609143,
0.03098670020699501,
-0.015761379152536392,
0.012001222930848598,
0.016198983415961266,
0.01608419418334961,
-0.0370461642742157,
0.012081325985491276,
0.06011703610420227,
0.010972494259476662,
0.017742089927196503,
0.005365155637264252,
-0.03432483598589897,
0.001730963820591569,
0.03485553339123726,
0.010662649758160114,
-0.05738318711519241,
0.01902034319937229,
-0.02294762060046196,
-0.008944660425186157,
-0.017870962619781494,
-0.06934744864702225,
-0.010769536718726158,
0.02925248257815838,
0.01610422320663929,
0.018625160679221153,
-0.0660019963979721,
0.04121193289756775,
-0.02019810490310192,
-0.020541345700621605,
0.014703524298965931,
-0.015883080661296844,
-0.01982000656425953,
-0.044136568903923035,
0.010057171806693077,
0.004760092590004206,
0.020033232867717743,
-0.004411707632243633,
-0.028734739869832993,
0.007042521610856056,
0.006771460175514221,
0.024388886988162994,
0.009371370077133179,
-0.04313305765390396,
0.047935400158166885,
-0.012161493301391602,
-0.021547680720686913,
-0.028595928102731705,
-0.05220135673880577,
-0.012963573448359966,
-0.04440906643867493,
-0.014616347849369049,
0.024297846481204033,
-0.013101756572723389,
0.039237309247255325,
0.09143760800361633,
-0.011241955682635307,
0.03900300711393356,
0.02905617095530033,
0.008747884072363377,
-0.020900817587971687,
0.03183140233159065,
-0.060437459498643875,
0.01805255562067032,
-0.03226374834775925,
0.02725747786462307,
-0.0031476288568228483,
-0.0019980003125965595,
0.02094641514122486,
-0.008538955822587013,
-0.020504802465438843,
-0.03149578347802162,
-0.021883638575673103,
-0.01958836056292057,
0.06636592000722885,
0.05196528136730194,
0.011424155905842781,
-0.017669718712568283,
-0.04674617201089859,
0.005296322982758284,
-0.011909177526831627,
0.012954662553966045,
-0.017807088792324066,
-0.005312206223607063,
0.012779638171195984,
0.008310428820550442,
-0.07210887223482132,
0.01382913626730442,
-0.07090877741575241,
0.0002572204975876957,
0.015513674356043339,
0.015221914276480675,
-0.06577468663454056,
-0.012489080429077148,
-0.008787404745817184,
-0.009260905906558037,
0.002351375762373209,
0.008546225726604462,
-0.0027534228283911943,
-0.053006213158369064,
0.002574110636487603,
0.0030840816907584667,
0.014730374328792095,
0.006663694977760315,
0.029025768861174583,
0.05532129108905792,
-0.011375559493899345,
0.07103273272514343,
0.04030407965183258,
-0.03595083951950073,
0.015589742921292782,
-0.05023687705397606,
-0.0013120095245540142,
0.07058729976415634,
-0.002361050108447671,
0.021294597536325455,
0.009260238148272038,
0.05657599866390228,
0.03448629379272461,
-0.007887620478868484,
0.03134824335575104,
-0.011944922618567944,
-0.014300314709544182,
0.0015542375622317195,
0.005012523382902145,
-0.004208827391266823,
-0.007771678734570742,
-0.017749905586242676,
0.02441256120800972,
-0.05450452119112015,
-0.0269253421574831,
0.05707937479019165,
0.009283573366701603,
-0.017167039215564728,
0.014803205616772175,
-0.008300058543682098,
-0.00808043498545885,
0.026702038943767548,
-0.014284305274486542,
-0.022357335314154625,
-0.008797275833785534,
-0.019602777436375618,
0.051636479794979095,
0.01914788968861103,
0.016127562150359154,
0.021212399005889893,
-0.002772222040221095,
0.039175037294626236,
-0.06047506257891655,
-0.01726835034787655,
0.023346276953816414,
0.019114306196570396,
-0.02426104061305523,
0.02051306702196598,
-0.0007002796628512442,
-0.02329344116151333,
0.012772946618497372,
0.04156363010406494,
0.029446491971611977,
-0.03263475373387337,
-0.012005805037915707,
-0.038848746567964554,
0.013376549817621708,
-0.04773113504052162,
-0.013955965638160706,
0.021494099870324135,
-0.052779730409383774,
0.0026732399128377438,
-0.01796051487326622,
-0.024513542652130127,
-0.002238193992525339,
-0.0873180627822876,
0.055812641978263855,
-0.05879583954811096,
0.0005529811605811119,
-0.008351228199899197,
0.04278130084276199,
-0.009211316704750061,
0.047082990407943726,
-0.0077520408667624,
0.017675818875432014,
-0.034575819969177246,
0.003632544307038188,
-0.01626851223409176,
-0.020303256809711456,
0.012177803553640842,
-0.006213424261659384,
-0.015640344470739365,
-0.021480035036802292,
0.038885537534952164,
-0.004965855274349451,
0.017134154215455055,
-0.0002484566066414118,
-0.015018777921795845,
-0.021303491666913033,
0.04803987219929695,
0.03341294825077057,
-0.00783370342105627,
-0.03499956801533699,
-0.03898581489920616,
0.008445742540061474,
0.03077078051865101,
-0.011562928557395935,
-0.008476845920085907,
-0.05396788939833641,
-0.07252293825149536,
0.016436491161584854,
-0.028409508988261223,
-0.023059368133544922,
-0.002751849591732025,
0.009795710444450378,
-0.006215662229806185,
0.0031270207837224007,
-0.0641903281211853,
-0.011998496018350124,
0.0036114156246185303,
-0.0424313023686409,
-0.006999113131314516,
0.030962077900767326,
0.015211887657642365,
-0.0015952603425830603,
-0.008159478195011616,
0.043467096984386444,
0.0036091178189963102,
-0.024974772706627846,
0.014457874931395054,
-0.045255109667778015,
-0.013062391430139542,
0.005316167138516903,
-0.02372055873274803,
0.016779301688075066,
0.010248363018035889,
-0.007703408598899841,
0.029395513236522675,
0.010858849622309208,
-0.03962947428226471,
-0.02106635272502899,
0.027161603793501854,
-0.0397324413061142,
-0.007442047819495201,
-0.032754816114902496,
-0.010025239549577236,
-0.037404920905828476,
-0.032619498670101166,
-0.0242958664894104,
-0.02832500822842121,
0.006489962805062532,
0.0014147390611469746,
-0.015366045758128166,
0.0352056510746479,
0.03823703154921532,
-0.07967130839824677,
-0.0062555307522416115,
-0.03270897641777992,
0.028153084218502045,
-0.002775001572445035,
-0.00838944036513567,
0.0074216746725142,
-0.044059302657842636,
0.043364036828279495,
0.004321764688938856,
0.0036889929324388504,
-0.04514192417263985,
0.007321245968341827,
-0.01111477892845869,
-0.009049491956830025,
0.03221156820654869,
-0.0307812187820673,
-0.035745151340961456,
0.0031221359968185425,
-0.05614091455936432,
0.008362098596990108,
0.006083039566874504,
-0.0056779636070132256,
0.013260739855468273,
-0.006632375996559858,
0.012044228613376617,
0.04616457223892212,
0.06612037122249603,
-0.04595017433166504,
-0.02314145304262638,
-0.017103983089327812,
0.04098384454846382,
-0.003832833608612418,
-0.02277006022632122,
0.008502727374434471,
-0.005881920922547579,
-0.029228007420897484,
0.020921947434544563,
0.027854742482304573,
-0.016640355810523033,
0.03256239742040634,
-0.019000772386789322,
-0.011176900938153267,
0.010139371268451214,
-0.006982823833823204,
-0.012595603242516518,
0.03319808468222618,
0.046469636261463165,
0.00023054698249325156,
-0.00019319468992762268,
0.0132180480286479,
0.006101282779127359,
0.0006899799918755889,
-0.038621485233306885,
-0.0034337295219302177,
0.004988471046090126,
0.05413153022527695,
-0.011401556432247162,
0.04296983405947685,
0.011480630375444889,
-0.014314708299934864,
0.015690580010414124,
-0.026106558740139008,
-0.04460690915584564,
0.038170818239450455,
0.03670332953333855,
0.009853480383753777,
0.03198041394352913,
-0.10169046372175217,
0.0032547814771533012,
-0.014519023708999157,
-0.05236171931028366,
-0.02571428194642067,
0.04959610104560852,
0.0015698724891990423,
-0.02422826923429966,
0.026847686618566513,
0.020166242495179176,
0.0005449801101349294,
0.008006618358194828,
0.0023332065902650356,
-0.02119217999279499,
-0.03755015507340431,
-0.1285361349582672,
0.005933085456490517,
0.017475692555308342,
-0.03464234620332718,
-0.0322515070438385,
0.009179191663861275,
-0.00431039510294795,
0.013527330942451954,
-0.014253775589168072,
-0.004815428517758846,
0.01948804222047329,
-0.03426491096615791,
-0.0015067108906805515,
-0.006502597592771053,
-0.04213409125804901,
-0.004686244763433933,
-0.03848923370242119,
-0.003614406567066908,
-0.054595254361629486,
0.046409931033849716,
0.022481072694063187,
-0.01994325779378414,
0.022013647481799126,
0.009035098366439342,
0.010764298029243946,
0.0028980541974306107,
0.0009129345417022705,
-0.057208169251680374,
-0.040523894131183624,
-0.033079296350479126,
-0.02691924385726452,
0.021402603015303612,
-0.024241400882601738,
0.08959061652421951,
-0.023541443049907684,
0.03371475264430046,
-0.01149093545973301,
-0.023603256791830063,
0.011068775318562984,
-0.011434261687099934,
-0.00371424644254148,
0.05661126226186752,
-0.022342590615153313,
-0.022755863144993782,
-0.008676196448504925,
0.009919911623001099,
-0.030512791126966476,
0.0015488837379962206,
-0.06599320471286774,
-0.02934752032160759,
-0.03469235077500343,
0.021357886493206024,
-0.02046957239508629,
0.055291514843702316,
-0.015977969393134117,
-0.028949325904250145,
0.013853889890015125,
-0.005495620891451836,
0.059605978429317474,
0.028192758560180664,
0.035469841212034225,
0.009012392722070217,
-0.08441367745399475,
0.0008349679410457611,
0.02056114189326763,
-0.016585197299718857,
0.003610926913097501,
-0.03562335669994354,
0.00492631271481514,
0.01281708013266325,
-0.031667597591876984,
0.02063513547182083,
0.03395102918148041,
-0.025966903194785118,
0.009417226538062096,
-0.023195749148726463,
0.0030507720075547695,
0.017578959465026855,
-0.04854783043265343,
-0.010102937929332256,
-0.0066863843239843845,
0.018991973251104355,
-0.06657136231660843,
-0.024917766451835632,
0.05875619128346443,
0.01837223581969738,
0.007595884148031473,
0.0012238796334713697,
-0.01434007752686739,
-0.0224531851708889,
-0.03294172137975693,
0.004647460300475359,
0.003897836897522211,
0.043744686990976334,
-0.0010936137987300754,
-0.002618954051285982,
-0.0031627994030714035,
-0.008024306036531925,
-0.024340897798538208,
-0.007951701059937477,
-0.025726739317178726,
-0.03979311138391495,
-0.011480438522994518,
-0.0011531157651916146,
-0.011894536204636097,
-0.0256828460842371,
0.04978291317820549,
0.010809111408889294,
-0.0033600060269236565,
-0.0038481869269162416,
-0.016639016568660736,
-0.0295276939868927,
-0.06653524935245514,
0.025289857760071754,
-0.04619762673974037,
0.0051885624416172504,
0.02041943185031414,
0.015295268036425114,
0.006705915555357933,
0.006948750000447035,
-0.0025757048279047012,
-0.013854363933205605,
0.017089230939745903,
-0.02164090983569622,
0.021144988015294075,
0.02972928248345852,
0.09608922153711319,
-0.0005204104236327112,
0.04768737033009529,
-0.007738291751593351,
0.007467720657587051,
0.01794813945889473,
0.02855827473104,
-0.0016997111961245537,
-0.0036994372494518757,
0.013140193186700344,
-0.03577763959765434,
0.010381989181041718,
-0.05370714142918587,
-0.00842492375522852,
0.005181743297725916,
0.017792578786611557,
-0.015574565157294273,
-0.002336404751986265,
-0.06263333559036255,
0.005961730610579252,
0.0556497722864151,
0.002422541379928589,
-0.020253725349903107,
0.02019464410841465,
-0.03279595077037811,
0.020559463649988174,
-0.0035925202537328005,
0.06360569596290588,
0.023523125797510147,
-0.002664877101778984,
0.024933140724897385,
0.014356610365211964,
0.05746525153517723,
0.020545920357108116,
0.00477573974058032,
-0.036642663180828094,
-0.04708346724510193,
-0.046910468488931656,
-0.023493416607379913,
0.03353668004274368,
-0.026743482798337936,
0.011933567002415657,
-0.03461914882063866,
-0.018523404374718666,
-0.0002473479835316539,
-0.011335127986967564,
-0.010802402161061764,
0.016816163435578346,
0.023929258808493614,
-0.023370860144495964,
0.010907876305282116,
-0.025748228654265404,
0.04593115299940109,
0.003858025651425123,
0.03461933508515358,
0.05287325754761696,
0.04337415471673012,
-0.017377417534589767,
0.06534895300865173,
0.04357678070664406,
-0.002269563265144825,
-0.012397533282637596,
-0.012121465988457203,
-0.03270326554775238,
0.004239591304212809,
-0.018321480602025986,
0.024936985224485397,
-0.0032971282489597797,
0.005024699494242668,
0.026049017906188965,
-0.006946086883544922,
0.007540580350905657,
0.01043273787945509,
-0.006096768192946911,
0.05808689072728157,
-0.0036237924359738827,
-0.025623442605137825,
0.02496577985584736,
-0.0048950472846627235,
0.043620385229587555,
-0.014686085283756256,
-0.07986162602901459,
-0.06267604231834412,
0.03873657435178757,
0.028006570413708687,
0.01688184030354023,
-0.026000507175922394,
0.009579828940331936,
-0.03165203705430031,
0.019363632425665855,
0.028278134763240814,
-0.042343657463788986,
0.035671696066856384,
-0.016662098467350006,
0.02779507450759411,
0.06885163486003876,
0.00294411345385015,
-0.03560391440987587,
0.0005672609549947083,
-0.011791844852268696,
-0.010817286558449268,
-0.00034680322278290987,
0.0002526603639125824,
0.033292680978775024,
-0.03274789825081825,
0.007745711598545313,
0.007291837595403194,
0.02638634294271469,
0.028309732675552368,
-0.0452321320772171,
-0.02144920639693737,
-0.008113617077469826,
-0.022248651832342148,
0.020471209660172462,
0.033100493252277374,
-0.0038421775680035353,
0.01316650491207838,
-0.018995344638824463
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:67
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
962In support of this argument Mr Einfeld relied upon the statement made by the High Court in Warman International Limited v Dwyer (1995) 182 CLR 544 at 557 that a fiduciary must account for what has been acquired "at the expense of the trust".
963Mr Einfeld relied upon the fact that LEC was not able to raise funds to complete the LEC Contract and pointed to the evidence which I have outlined at paragraphs 47 to 55 above and in particular, Mr Zdrilic's evidence that he accepted that from 21 May 1999 Powercoal was entitled to sell the Land to whoever it wished.
Mr Einfeld also relied on the letters of Mr Brown of 3 and 4 June 1999 in which Mr Brown said that LEC was not in position to fund the purchase.
964However, it appears to me that this submission does not reflect a fair reading of what the High Court said in Warman International Limited v Dwyer.
965The relevant principle was stated at 562:-
"...it is firmly established that the liability of a fiduciary to account for a profit or gain made in breach of fiduciary duty does not depend upon the person to whom that obligation is owed suffering a loss or injury; and it is ordinarily immaterial to the fiduciary's liability to account that the person to whom the fiduciary obligation is owed could not have earned that profit or gain.
The courts have always insisted on compliance by fiduciaries with strict and rigorous standards with a view to ensuring that they do not expose themselves to a conflict of interest and duty.
The point is that that fiduciary is not entitled to make a profit out of, or by reason of, a fiduciary position without the knowledge and assent of the person to whom the fiduciary duty is owed". (citations omitted)
966Earlier, at 557, the Court stated:-
"It has been suggested that the liability of the fiduciary to account for a profit made in breach of the fiduciary duty should be determined by reference to the concept of unjust enrichment, namely, whether the profit is made at the expense of the person to whom the fiduciary duty is owed, and to the honestly and bona fides of the fiduciary.
But the authorities in Australia and England deny that the liability of a fiduciary to account depends upon detriment to the plaintiff or to the dishonestly and bona fides of the fiduciary" (citations omitted).
967Further, the Court drew attention to the remarks of Gibbs J in Consul Development Pty Limited v DPC Estates Pty Limited (1975) 132 CLR 373 at 394 where His Honour stated:-
"Where the rule applies, the liability of the person in the fiduciary position does not depend on the fact that the person to whom the duty is owed has suffered injury or loss".
968The passage in Warman upon which Mr Einfeld relied followed from this passage and was in the following terms:-
"The stringent that the fiduciary cannot profit from his trust is said to have two purposes: (1) that the fiduciary must account for what has been acquired at the expense of the trust, and (2) to ensure the fiduciaries generally conduct themselves 'at a level higher than that trodden by the crowd'." (at 557; emphasis added; citation omitted).
969However, as Mr Jucovic submitted, the latter statement is not a statement of the rule, but rather of the purpose of the rule.
970That is made clear by a passage which appears in the Judgment immediately following that upon which Mr Einfeld relied:-
"Thus, it is no defence that the plaintiff was unwilling, unlikely or unable to make the profits for which an account is taken..." (at 558; citations omitted).
971In those circumstances, in my opinion, it would not have been necessary for LEC to prove, in the 2001 Proceedings, that it could have itself acquired the Land, or made profit from its development, provided it could show that, as it pleaded, Mr Hulley, in breach of his fiduciary obligations to LEC, caused HTT to do so at its profit.
|
[
-0.02834510989487171,
0.03839510679244995,
-0.02372436225414276,
0.003224677639082074,
-0.02181928977370262,
-0.02471270225942135,
-0.010321130976080894,
-0.03434550017118454,
-0.01074612233787775,
-0.01515236310660839,
-0.023521391674876213,
0.05295909568667412,
-0.061694346368312836,
0.008014353923499584,
-0.02435772866010666,
-0.009641335345804691,
0.040356479585170746,
-0.02489883080124855,
-0.06424605846405029,
-0.025774763897061348,
0.007968480698764324,
-0.03534041717648506,
0.03153626248240471,
0.01781497709453106,
-0.007014982867985964,
-0.01617910899221897,
0.02247120440006256,
0.0006841854774393141,
0.022024264559149742,
0.009359994903206825,
0.025523995980620384,
0.012804803438484669,
0.010174721479415894,
-0.034318022429943085,
0.037371791899204254,
-0.007916396483778954,
0.042829375714063644,
0.005682637915015221,
-0.0132529865950346,
0.01166691817343235,
0.04329252615571022,
0.02317061647772789,
0.004467860329896212,
-0.07562246173620224,
0.03989225998520851,
-0.031389329582452774,
-0.03284740820527077,
-0.03518021106719971,
-0.0242011696100235,
0.011818046681582928,
-0.02797139249742031,
0.02044079266488552,
0.08547233790159225,
-0.016252564266324043,
0.004966116975992918,
0.032346904277801514,
-0.013762540183961391,
-0.019413508474826813,
-0.05864743888378143,
-0.018396738916635513,
0.01065362524241209,
-0.07788055390119553,
-0.06204503774642944,
-0.006211579777300358,
0.0016550106229260564,
0.06290265917778015,
-0.018024645745754242,
-0.01421063020825386,
-0.0037461547181010246,
-0.035162560641765594,
-0.030016900971531868,
0.008662465959787369,
-0.02423274703323841,
0.02158701978623867,
-0.08911412954330444,
0.032989080995321274,
-0.015716148540377617,
0.02139873057603836,
0.04394863173365593,
-0.009747625328600407,
0.026770422235131264,
-0.009780562482774258,
-0.0016052697319537401,
0.024172384291887283,
-0.00793404784053564,
0.01651626266539097,
-0.057282205671072006,
0.03409917652606964,
0.025617314502596855,
0.005632729735225439,
-0.03748069703578949,
-0.032636601477861404,
0.023766877129673958,
-0.027590526267886162,
0.002540966495871544,
0.014427964575588703,
-0.06917272508144379,
0.04586401954293251,
-0.00009771852637641132,
0.02407745271921158,
0.008524603210389614,
0.05553390830755234,
0.005585270002484322,
-0.05127986893057823,
-0.018668336793780327,
0.012409917078912258,
0.008537091314792633,
0.027289601042866707,
0.004689302295446396,
-0.00008427585271419957,
0.000513341452460736,
0.010919671505689621,
0.022354504093527794,
0.006318286061286926,
-0.0310794860124588,
-0.003917799796909094,
0.031094348058104515,
-0.018293794244527817,
0.0217210091650486,
-0.014230165630578995,
0.016319142654538155,
0.004387446213513613,
0.04291587322950363,
-0.025457866489887238,
-0.05891766399145126,
0.022556882351636887,
-0.03493793308734894,
-0.006680273450911045,
-0.016208475455641747,
0.049147240817546844,
0.011942856013774872,
0.026873337104916573,
-0.01210057269781828,
-0.03631319850683212,
-0.03227655217051506,
-0.00613160477951169,
0.03758592903614044,
0.014366021379828453,
0.005486706737428904,
-0.01857041008770466,
0.025111151859164238,
0.06503457576036453,
0.001862518722191453,
-0.052506111562252045,
0.003625514917075634,
0.007967745885252953,
-0.005054266192018986,
0.005611926317214966,
-0.0005889143794775009,
-0.03956680744886398,
-0.0017173051601275802,
0.030359039083123207,
0.04826965555548668,
-0.02448984421789646,
0.030466154217720032,
-0.08035106956958771,
0.01591147482395172,
-0.033572036772966385,
0.006422013510018587,
0.05372558906674385,
-0.02599109150469303,
0.03588356077671051,
-0.00835519190877676,
-0.0038881541695445776,
-0.0336938202381134,
0.01911120116710663,
-0.04146450757980347,
0.012545185163617134,
-0.033635128289461136,
0.03829791396856308,
0.05369943007826805,
-0.0031746947206556797,
-0.017340006306767464,
-0.04062654823064804,
0.0010938732884824276,
0.02047957107424736,
0.04463154822587967,
0.008073453791439533,
-0.01419675163924694,
-0.007248831447213888,
-0.041873835027217865,
0.0009919770527631044,
-0.005086816847324371,
0.037242867052555084,
-0.0478922538459301,
-0.009301245212554932,
-0.013546222820878029,
-0.02552187629044056,
0.023513738065958023,
0.02819558046758175,
-0.034306976944208145,
-0.02903841808438301,
0.009380321949720383,
0.005676641128957272,
-0.02020896039903164,
-0.041415970772504807,
0.012511484324932098,
-0.014176160097122192,
0.01854761131107807,
-0.019679196178913116,
-0.05174507573246956,
0.040059641003608704,
0.02679635025560856,
-0.015204666182398796,
-0.055700384080410004,
0.021941589191555977,
-0.03430039435625076,
-0.0061718919314444065,
0.018252134323120117,
-0.04093555361032486,
0.016375912353396416,
-0.04737050086259842,
0.0008300981135107577,
0.035381823778152466,
0.03121846541762352,
-0.04808654636144638,
0.01979067176580429,
-0.012005056254565716,
0.03721761330962181,
-0.021909726783633232,
-0.023127853870391846,
0.0018646047683432698,
0.032092127948999405,
0.009850708767771721,
0.047354117035865784,
0.06099015474319458,
-0.012078417465090752,
0.016566254198551178,
-0.024449752643704414,
-0.035358455032110214,
0.02563604712486267,
-0.013659021817147732,
0.011127188801765442,
-0.026159876957535744,
0.010688585229218006,
0.0017842664383351803,
0.01348293200135231,
0.055500950664281845,
0.01837562955915928,
-0.00510024419054389,
-0.04939793795347214,
-0.028407203033566475,
-0.01906128041446209,
-0.03354659676551819,
0.003395958337932825,
-0.005582870915532112,
-0.0330912247300148,
0.001832244568504393,
0.03197067603468895,
-0.009063626639544964,
0.011601387523114681,
0.016447946429252625,
-0.012981834821403027,
-0.03461642563343048,
-0.02183341234922409,
0.04450114443898201,
0.01011931337416172,
0.017595568671822548,
0.032860927283763885,
0.0056693945080041885,
0.011437037028372288,
-0.00679027708247304,
0.013699903152883053,
0.006135326810181141,
-0.039955541491508484,
0.0004311730735935271,
-0.026374544948339462,
-0.03743887320160866,
-0.004818339832127094,
-0.004667115863412619,
0.022896286100149155,
-0.00257904757745564,
0.022037560120224953,
0.028097327798604965,
0.02744509093463421,
0.05121637508273125,
0.041420917958021164,
-0.010195891372859478,
0.01223289780318737,
0.0025654854252934456,
-0.008851123042404652,
0.04059021174907684,
0.023401573300361633,
-0.02966883033514023,
-0.006174770183861256,
0.033853691071271896,
-0.04065508395433426,
-0.033437229692935944,
0.0507960319519043,
-0.02762989141047001,
0.0267717856913805,
-0.017615854740142822,
0.0739535242319107,
-0.019106898456811905,
-0.09295462816953659,
-0.0076083107851445675,
0.0016380349406972528,
-0.14229479432106018,
0.005578553304076195,
0.010031187906861305,
0.011237628757953644,
-0.009619557298719883,
0.025909477844834328,
-0.04899721220135689,
0.0020584994927048683,
-0.028434554114937782,
-0.030272169038653374,
0.0067817047238349915,
-0.06984566152095795,
-0.015942178666591644,
-0.001468409551307559,
-0.006177200004458427,
-0.012909753248095512,
0.015999313443899155,
0.006790660787373781,
0.021044259890913963,
-0.019893014803528786,
-0.006907681003212929,
-0.028222225606441498,
0.01964157074689865,
0.022067207843065262,
0.0091837914660573,
0.01029075775295496,
0.03607573360204697,
-0.01612095534801483,
-0.0494789183139801,
0.0030729533173143864,
-0.023880336433649063,
0.03125055506825447,
-0.01805911213159561,
0.002377839293330908,
-0.0004060231731273234,
0.023577487096190453,
0.08581642806529999,
-0.07165349274873734,
-0.0005317587638273835,
0.027318943291902542,
0.035055749118328094,
0.04013534635305405,
-0.013011274859309196,
0.025243844836950302,
-0.000014335106243379414,
-0.0649571344256401,
-0.0053089153952896595,
-0.027693618088960648,
-0.05435195937752724,
0.05935310572385788,
-0.015383107587695122,
0.004157777410000563,
-0.06206228956580162,
-0.042704690247774124,
-0.008096241392195225,
-0.024630242958664894,
0.06020791456103325,
0.019387835636734962,
0.0034040461760014296,
0.007500121835619211,
-0.015760717913508415,
-0.05763208121061325,
-0.00477931322529912,
0.02598632499575615,
-0.03932095691561699,
0.029166363179683685,
-0.005385463126003742,
0.00427695969119668,
0.04387683793902397,
-0.018577024340629578,
-0.000005223123935138574,
-0.02150844968855381,
0.02674121782183647,
-0.006760592572391033,
0.008333892561495304,
0.03694932535290718,
-0.014660738408565521,
-0.006996388081461191,
-0.009664412587881088,
-0.08000640571117401,
0.026359010487794876,
0.029975228011608124,
0.000602089159656316,
0.042235154658555984,
0.003745907684788108,
0.012437695637345314,
0.008576721884310246,
0.035438600927591324,
0.02918805554509163,
0.22143004834651947,
0.004016296472400427,
0.0036944267340004444,
0.03781385347247124,
-0.017147639766335487,
0.0013612054754048586,
0.013046188279986382,
0.048412829637527466,
-0.047920625656843185,
-0.055586330592632294,
-0.045391689985990524,
0.013465075753629208,
0.04200385510921478,
0.025319518521428108,
-0.060235973447561264,
-0.011473268270492554,
-0.008661525323987007,
-0.014413055032491684,
0.0718981996178627,
0.015595855191349983,
0.02278512716293335,
0.002593149896711111,
0.016988519579172134,
0.02194000594317913,
-0.05950742959976196,
-0.04955650120973587,
0.012153572402894497,
0.011911408975720406,
-0.01755957305431366,
0.03060171566903591,
-0.04416364058852196,
-0.030743690207600594,
0.023613696917891502,
-0.0273167472332716,
-0.009198381565511227,
0.019043145701289177,
-0.013770357705652714,
0.004536372609436512,
-0.042356107383966446,
0.04556881636381149,
0.004728303756564856,
-0.03917307406663895,
-0.042094044387340546,
-0.02914169803261757,
-0.020892534404993057,
0.019847188144922256,
-0.05155271664261818,
0.02182196080684662,
-0.016849610954523087,
0.05824756622314453,
-0.04729936644434929,
0.017357151955366135,
-0.036551594734191895,
0.003446452086791396,
-0.015312566421926022,
0.04002035781741142,
-0.02169877104461193,
0.030205823481082916,
-0.0031877842266112566,
0.01765083707869053,
0.07366523891687393,
0.021331535652279854,
0.0005417026113718748,
0.03765983507037163,
-0.01324823684990406,
-0.0004520360962487757,
-0.018243256956338882,
0.02330804616212845,
0.04088481888175011,
0.024135272949934006,
0.021748829632997513,
0.04303618147969246,
0.030220957472920418,
0.030788306146860123,
0.045550424605607986,
0.0005297731258906424,
0.006263799034059048,
0.04651084542274475,
-0.011601756326854229,
-0.00717589259147644,
-0.02783871442079544,
-0.012303809635341167,
0.0031227765139192343,
0.01929929107427597,
0.02012094296514988,
0.004278536420315504,
-0.015983356162905693,
0.011999035254120827,
-0.002701736520975828,
-0.028766877949237823,
0.013353422284126282,
-0.007917648181319237,
-0.02610851638019085,
-0.005168780218809843,
-0.01737327314913273,
-0.010658991523087025,
-0.020796729251742363,
-0.004310058429837227,
-0.031019793823361397,
-0.02083415538072586,
0.02470318228006363,
-0.008876592852175236,
0.016887294128537178,
-0.012619823217391968,
0.03864599019289017,
0.0766756534576416,
-0.029948733747005463,
0.03136433660984039,
-0.03863576427102089,
0.005588593427091837,
0.04761246591806412,
0.040204472839832306,
-0.009610328823328018,
0.0013305722968652844,
0.03915156051516533,
0.0331873819231987,
-0.01057808380573988,
0.034803152084350586,
0.04201224818825722,
0.012453406117856503,
-0.0014993873191997409,
0.007967181503772736,
-0.001118410611525178,
0.010831900872290134,
-0.0039699929766356945,
0.015286426059901714,
-0.014779570512473583,
0.013198168016970158,
0.02849699556827545,
0.007920490577816963,
-0.002814135979861021,
-0.022157445549964905,
-0.030516011640429497,
-0.021675368770956993,
0.09448964893817902,
0.012760655023157597,
0.006067628040909767,
-0.000657157797832042,
-0.07786304503679276,
0.023938842117786407,
-0.006311264354735613,
0.015926601365208626,
-0.0661202222108841,
0.005095424130558968,
0.025893056765198708,
-0.007767724338918924,
-0.03968942165374756,
-0.04051647707819939,
-0.012437138706445694,
0.023075446486473083,
0.01390793640166521,
0.002918341662734747,
-0.03518783673644066,
0.004527909681200981,
0.005969326943159103,
0.0070135812275111675,
-0.0048479982651770115,
-0.024210499599575996,
0.023799428716301918,
-0.006602517794817686,
-0.00019808619981631637,
0.030456749722361565,
-0.020735273137688637,
0.044349562376737595,
0.023285236209630966,
0.08989787101745605,
-0.0033634828869253397,
0.007491860538721085,
0.034702710807323456,
-0.02945747599005699,
-0.009646760299801826,
-0.0259120911359787,
-0.03261074423789978,
0.046686168760061264,
0.06669867783784866,
0.01897822506725788,
-0.05659111961722374,
0.015995334833860397,
-0.009725488722324371,
-0.03397326171398163,
0.02192121185362339,
0.0422961600124836,
-0.039018210023641586,
0.0102443378418684,
-0.006684200372546911,
-0.030592836439609528,
-0.004958897829055786,
-0.017826389521360397,
0.03635532408952713,
-0.04721138998866081,
-0.017816253006458282,
0.0887218788266182,
0.01903090998530388,
-0.03621720150113106,
0.002037668600678444,
0.04077526926994324,
-0.0602898932993412,
-0.019256964325904846,
0.003491610987111926,
-0.055869486182928085,
-0.01757594384253025,
-0.013397561386227608,
-0.00017660476441960782,
-0.0024474940728396177,
0.02830399014055729,
-0.0023617250844836235,
-0.0028571023140102625,
0.03378966823220253,
-0.08533266931772232,
-0.03331780061125755,
0.0008996055112220347,
0.06593455374240875,
-0.04473584517836571,
0.005099129863083363,
0.0017190672224387527,
0.002884687390178442,
0.010969823226332664,
0.07379025965929031,
0.015557988546788692,
-0.07456500083208084,
-0.03954354301095009,
-0.013158349320292473,
0.026148999109864235,
-0.08201257884502411,
0.004776240326464176,
-0.008491819724440575,
-0.0002533586521167308,
-0.005824557039886713,
-0.003458926221355796,
-0.02710174210369587,
0.0075711035169661045,
-0.032220661640167236,
0.05492189899086952,
-0.038917701691389084,
-0.0012581127230077982,
-0.01593334786593914,
-0.0007761568413116038,
0.002524541225284338,
0.01025146059691906,
0.02681765705347061,
0.05323151499032974,
-0.013377704657614231,
-0.006313317455351353,
0.024806078523397446,
0.02248564176261425,
-0.06519067287445068,
0.020769529044628143,
-0.02471110410988331,
-0.010700126178562641,
0.028424546122550964,
0.0038014687597751617,
0.03810974955558777,
0.03136168792843819,
-0.01628962717950344,
0.001523353043012321,
0.014436081051826477,
0.026069920510053635,
-0.035480838268995285,
-0.06475312262773514,
-0.005549946799874306,
-0.015012039802968502,
0.013036330230534077,
-0.005121368914842606,
-0.006027467083185911,
-0.01679801568388939,
-0.033377647399902344,
0.016723591834306717,
-0.03143978491425514,
-0.014930873177945614,
-0.013215282000601292,
-0.012535158544778824,
0.026581142097711563,
-0.007423788774758577,
-0.03583795577287674,
-0.0035162849817425013,
0.02380824089050293,
-0.008795211091637611,
-0.01517433486878872,
-0.02258331887423992,
0.019412938505411148,
0.025130823254585266,
-0.013781324028968811,
0.019328949972987175,
0.01421354804188013,
-0.009336216375231743,
0.02307661436498165,
0.014629854820668697,
0.005664566531777382,
-0.006933584343641996,
0.0030750716105103493,
0.004998657386749983,
0.0033620973117649555,
-0.012581516057252884,
0.0253664031624794,
0.0012016826076433063,
0.01946231536567211,
-0.014469180256128311,
0.026978904381394386,
-0.011344489641487598,
0.009647391736507416,
-0.025220347568392754,
0.01733735203742981,
-0.017799237743020058,
-0.049676571041345596,
-0.005619153846055269,
-0.0072344643995165825,
0.02416349947452545,
0.00944010354578495,
-0.00877026654779911,
0.0014297383604571223,
0.0036580972373485565,
-0.035183221101760864,
-0.002273700200021267,
-0.040200747549533844,
0.013227716088294983,
0.0011240107705816627,
0.0210400577634573,
0.011755463667213917,
-0.015900863334536552,
-0.00976665411144495,
-0.06014974042773247,
0.01617860235273838,
-0.02672562561929226,
-0.049282778054475784,
-0.05027442425489426,
0.02230028435587883,
-0.0009592333226464689,
-0.013049691915512085,
-0.00033433205680921674,
-0.005834592971950769,
-0.07899915426969528,
0.007550323382019997,
0.021816851571202278,
-0.007522221654653549,
0.05999651923775673,
0.06333007663488388,
0.01173973549157381,
-0.0260403323918581,
0.041985735297203064,
-0.006825865712016821,
0.019095471128821373,
-0.0857686698436737,
0.0855613723397255,
0.00936357956379652,
0.026615386828780174,
0.041308678686618805,
-0.007125534117221832,
0.004465967416763306,
0.017836494371294975,
0.01341274194419384,
-0.007392285857349634,
-0.015572319738566875,
0.0007034955779090524,
-0.020434342324733734,
0.02195514552295208,
-0.005074148066341877,
0.011422421783208847,
-0.010265346616506577,
0.0020794509910047054,
-0.044031620025634766,
0.016499120742082596,
-0.0005624693585559726,
-0.01898503303527832,
0.004111785441637039,
0.02101348713040352,
-0.008028424344956875,
-0.008537527173757553,
-0.006139101926237345,
0.01429409347474575,
0.016333959996700287,
0.025683989748358727,
-0.025974467396736145,
-0.018790768459439278,
0.0002904277353081852,
-0.008379514329135418,
0.046680789440870285,
0.027359770610928535,
-0.004113201051950455,
0.012802240438759327,
-0.03243391215801239,
-0.022188106551766396,
0.01176996249705553,
-0.035409536212682724,
-0.009810821153223515,
-0.019814861938357353,
-0.00829355325549841,
-0.019082974642515182,
0.03096756897866726,
0.01232339907437563,
-0.0030728988349437714,
-0.0019522904185578227,
0.04348443076014519,
-0.019312536343932152,
0.012532486580312252,
-0.12917695939540863,
0.0052708908915519714,
-0.025769000872969627,
0.03446855768561363,
-0.02881537191569805,
0.022126508876681328,
0.0055716014467179775,
-0.004140196368098259,
0.008834844455122948,
0.005169725976884365,
-0.01030227541923523,
-0.013829516246914864,
0.002216637134552002,
-0.03549319878220558,
-0.04281669482588768,
0.024274572730064392,
-0.04508189111948013,
-0.02253926917910576,
-0.026026293635368347,
0.009746044874191284,
0.015942445024847984,
0.0178812388330698,
-0.009334808215498924,
-0.024734482169151306,
0.009270227514207363,
-0.004868096671998501,
-0.04966578260064125,
-0.04934399574995041,
-0.016438785940408707,
-0.09025043994188309,
-0.01563987135887146,
0.0006861627334728837,
-0.0016192221082746983,
0.05652466043829918,
0.02565162256360054,
0.020762892439961433,
0.008033081889152527,
0.003682521404698491,
-0.005332320928573608,
-0.013381881639361382,
-0.025097014382481575,
0.027425814419984818,
-0.004738165996968746,
0.024182390421628952,
0.024878663942217827,
-0.009687150828540325,
-0.020728155970573425,
0.0011722403578460217,
-0.05941632762551308,
-0.0169356819242239,
-0.04896540194749832,
0.010183406062424183,
-0.03240324929356575,
0.03961925208568573,
0.010872665792703629,
0.0064230188727378845,
-0.015326030552387238,
-0.028379667550325394,
0.0032754968851804733,
0.03669977933168411,
0.039950042963027954,
-0.002314096549525857,
-0.01663784682750702,
0.0068259937688708305,
0.011806055903434753,
0.024436572566628456,
-0.048961564898490906,
-0.01344260573387146,
-0.022947687655687332,
0.004529532976448536,
0.016291331499814987,
-0.01101918425410986,
-0.016090281307697296,
-0.051721084862947464,
0.0394577756524086,
-0.016569921746850014,
0.02251875028014183,
0.009539857506752014,
-0.037729229778051376,
-0.03893725574016571,
-0.012884857133030891,
-0.005764697678387165,
-0.005352702457457781,
0.0018062948947772384,
0.09973868727684021,
0.028715282678604126,
-0.009454159997403622,
0.0003684735856950283,
0.022208254784345627,
-0.011630183085799217,
-0.06275743991136551,
-0.009660644456744194,
-0.02568756230175495,
-0.031738560646772385,
-0.02231294848024845,
0.0587930902838707,
0.018878500908613205,
0.005281806457787752,
-0.0176748838275671,
-0.01843928173184395,
-0.032530274242162704,
0.0069452994503080845,
0.053068600594997406,
0.008675222285091877,
-0.028648652136325836,
0.010819777846336365,
-0.004677112214267254,
0.014308186247944832,
0.013158089481294155,
0.024875318631529808,
0.009454628452658653,
-0.011938897892832756,
0.020942403003573418,
-0.015726102516055107,
-0.04552890732884407,
-0.021164314821362495,
0.0010995219927281141,
-0.004419825039803982,
0.004003413487225771,
-0.012508141808211803,
0.03162694349884987,
0.004846269264817238,
-0.005719170439988375,
-0.021980198100209236,
-0.019143110141158104,
0.027004292234778404,
0.038058169186115265,
-0.012756578624248505,
0.014469089917838573,
-0.016754334792494774,
0.07013001292943954,
-0.016574248671531677,
-0.015139846131205559,
-0.011692642234265804,
0.016103120520710945,
0.0036641114857047796,
-0.01721126027405262,
0.026716968044638634,
-0.04639516398310661,
-0.03287970647215843,
0.0018031198997050524,
0.014146794565021992,
0.029719267040491104,
-0.00798866804689169,
-0.026502178981900215,
-0.06798623502254486,
0.04891789332032204,
0.01675555296242237,
-0.008668812923133373,
-0.06291190534830093,
-0.03063216432929039,
-0.004545729141682386,
0.03981469199061394,
0.051735490560531616,
0.06428820639848709,
-0.054906997829675674,
0.032707348465919495,
-0.019137263298034668,
0.02877894416451454,
0.03757196664810181,
0.020141078159213066,
-0.06760493665933609,
-0.029729682952165604,
-0.04097653552889824,
-0.031346533447504044,
0.009425751864910126,
-0.03566507250070572,
0.011347318068146706,
0.006228953134268522,
-0.005034768488258123,
-0.00022180717496667057,
0.017004063352942467,
-0.039983075112104416,
0.05138221010565758,
0.028550779446959496,
-0.003055894747376442,
-0.0049256496131420135,
-0.04186437278985977,
0.05235736817121506,
-0.047389425337314606,
0.06314373016357422,
0.037176065146923065,
0.009619081392884254,
0.011809884570538998,
-0.010454441420733929,
0.00281101418659091,
-0.012128576636314392,
0.03634451702237129,
-0.023160627111792564,
-0.007243226747959852,
-0.026097295805811882,
-0.00885199848562479,
0.00207437458448112,
-0.05363570526242256,
0.021442502737045288,
0.035402797162532806,
-0.00426800362765789,
0.03331417590379715,
-0.021562200039625168,
0.03979210555553436,
0.040021032094955444,
-0.040886297821998596,
-0.06033441796898842,
-0.015350629575550556,
0.015148595906794071,
0.012249688617885113,
0.024074051529169083,
-0.0031390655785799026,
-0.03032521717250347,
0.05143812671303749,
-0.034683503210544586,
-0.008524460718035698,
-0.04919406399130821,
0.03096674010157585,
-0.03767033666372299,
-0.016208255663514137,
0.007810049224644899,
-0.02524065040051937,
0.0422472320497036,
-0.021910758689045906,
0.0065636709332466125,
0.07389484345912933,
-0.02493979223072529,
-0.032185427844524384,
0.007059463299810886,
0.0389055535197258,
0.0070665571838617325,
-0.0337584912776947,
0.008778129704296589,
0.018877357244491577,
0.0028809269424527884,
-0.014683040790259838,
0.020220628008246422,
0.034413114190101624,
0.0038210670463740826,
-0.007793024647980928,
-0.04621031880378723,
-0.014973039738833904,
-0.04803382605314255,
0.004978162702172995,
0.031192492693662643,
0.017125185579061508,
-0.036032821983098984,
0.021484186872839928
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:26
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
* IPC would purchase at least 51 per cent of the "Shares" (a term not defined in the agreement but presumably a reference to the shares in HTT and the units in the Huntley Trust) and would advance $7.66 million for that purpose (clause 2.1);
* IPC would purchase the "Shares" no later than 42 days after a "rezoning approval" was achieved allowing what is set out in annexure "D" to the agreement. Annexure "D" was described as an "Indicative Project" and contained what was described as a "Brief Description of Proposed Project" (clause 3.2(a));
* IPC was to provide "proof that it has the Funds required to settlement the Purchase of the shares in the Business" (clause 3.2(b)). "The Business" was defined to mean the business of HTT "which is Mining, Land Fill and Development of the rest of the unused Site";
* IPC was to be "responsible" for providing "all working capital required to operate the Business" and to "meet all subsequent costs associated with the operation of the Business over and above the Revenue earned from the Clean Fill operation, the Sale of Coal - wash and Coking Coal" (clause 3.3);
* IPC and HTT were to use their best endeavours to obtain an "Interim Loan" for $9 million which was to be used to make the payments referred to in annexure "G" which included the amounts for which Mr McKenzie's proposed loan of $9 million was to be used (namely, reducing the amount owing by HTT to CBA by $300,000;
payment of the amount owing by HHT to GPC, estimated at $3 million, and; a deposit to the MySuper Trust of $1.
03 million) (clause 4.2);
* there was to be a due diligence period (clause 3.1);
* the arrangements were subject to numerous "Further Agreements" (clause 5); and
* the payments were to be made within 180 days of the date of the agreement, that is by 9 September 2004 (clause 6 - the "Sunset Clause").
385Mr Renshall said that his understanding of the agreement was that:-
* IPC would advance money to acquire 51 per cent of the shares in HTT and the units in the Huntley Trust for $7.6 million;
* IPC would also advance $9 million to payout the existing mortgagees of HTT secured over the Land (in accordance with annexure "G" to the agreement); and
* both payments were to be made by the Sunset Date of 9 September 2004.
386As I have set out, one of the terms of the IPC Heads of Agreement obliged IPC to provide proof that it "has the Funds required to settle the Purchase of the share in the Business".
387The plaintiffs submit that, in fact, IPC had no funds of its own which it was prepared to commit to the transaction.
15 March 2004 - Fifth Representation
388Mr Renshall allegedly made this representation on 15 March 2004 orally to Mr Zdrilic on the same day as the IPC Heads of Agreement.
389The representation pleaded is that the new funder would:-
* spend $85 million on the Project;
* do everything necessary to complete the Project to rehabilitate and develop the Land; and
* be in charge of the Project.
390According to Mr Zdrilic, Mr Renshall said:-
"The funder will spend $85 million to do everything at Huntley including building a golf course, tennis courts and education facilities. The funder will be in charge and have control. They have their requirements".
391Mr Zdrilic made a note included:-
"One time Renshall one time Sam.
The funder will spend $85M to do everything, inclg build golf course, tennis, education, etc etc.
(Only thing will be left is houses but they will be in the plan as well...)"
392The note made no reference to the funder being "in charge of the Project". The part of the note dealing with the funder spending "$85M" does not have the appearance of a note made during the conversation.
The first item on the note ("One time Renshall one time Sam") forms no part of the alleged representation but records a matter with which Mr Zdrilic was most concerned at this time, namely his position on the HTT board.
|
[
-0.017421036958694458,
0.0300754401832819,
-0.020005030557513237,
0.006048140581697226,
-0.02476612851023674,
-0.038122158497571945,
-0.008034787140786648,
-0.00903672818094492,
0.005513699259608984,
-0.005073874723166227,
0.007932750508189201,
0.03450707346200943,
-0.0214894637465477,
-0.008590392768383026,
0.008644619956612587,
-0.04594853147864342,
0.02530336007475853,
0.011874571442604065,
0.010151488706469536,
-0.011697760783135891,
-0.01493466179817915,
-0.01544166635721922,
0.005501215346157551,
0.02720828726887703,
-0.011462030932307243,
0.022870700806379318,
-0.05476795509457588,
0.04394248500466347,
0.028118165209889412,
0.02394583448767662,
0.012568715959787369,
-0.013589879497885704,
0.012560466304421425,
-0.029417840763926506,
0.013714449480175972,
-0.022432632744312286,
0.011377681978046894,
0.021779166534543037,
-0.03403737023472786,
0.009990781545639038,
0.02939995750784874,
-0.0037444881163537502,
0.014123063534498215,
-0.017115339636802673,
0.060523491352796555,
-0.030493231490254402,
0.013783187605440617,
-0.033016055822372437,
-0.01620561257004738,
0.01510887872427702,
-0.037350188940763474,
-0.013127258978784084,
0.030693424865603447,
-0.012474278919398785,
-0.014889700338244438,
-0.027119670063257217,
-0.01985824666917324,
-0.00017342032515443861,
-0.057613395154476166,
0.00002294320256623905,
-0.02296728827059269,
-0.017413420602679253,
-0.07116101682186127,
0.010491497814655304,
0.0059574320912361145,
0.12266036868095398,
0.03405607119202614,
-0.007139979861676693,
0.0034443940967321396,
-0.001581349759362638,
-0.07483239471912384,
-0.017656536772847176,
-0.0002870038151741028,
-0.013118725270032883,
-0.09533724188804626,
0.004807170480489731,
0.03526150435209274,
0.03170567750930786,
0.002127449493855238,
0.04070175066590309,
0.031007852405309677,
-0.044936653226614,
-0.0025671888142824173,
0.04503915086388588,
-0.02371254190802574,
0.03860607370734215,
-0.05896352604031563,
0.03573670983314514,
0.00794411264359951,
-0.04992211237549782,
-0.01373351737856865,
0.0010994714684784412,
0.045132916420698166,
0.0038683146703988314,
-0.0062596662901341915,
-0.010705913417041302,
-0.03721057251095772,
0.03434612974524498,
-0.021686943247914314,
0.02307327464222908,
0.015575166791677475,
0.007211426272988319,
-0.007796345744282007,
0.008706901222467422,
-0.027143031358718872,
0.036241333931684494,
0.012055213563144207,
0.028162511065602303,
0.01820920594036579,
-0.0018108334625139832,
0.0016660357359796762,
-0.02634168043732643,
0.04000584036111832,
0.022000756114721298,
0.006331253331154585,
-0.004071538802236319,
0.03313109651207924,
-0.009242269210517406,
0.02871434949338436,
0.03191060200333595,
0.03235669434070587,
-0.0004470610583666712,
0.02051279880106449,
-0.011201057583093643,
-0.057134922593832016,
-0.007239603437483311,
-0.02115521766245365,
-0.0018441957654431462,
0.005192747805267572,
0.040206242352724075,
-0.01776510663330555,
-0.0015585243236273527,
-0.024846892803907394,
-0.020084349438548088,
-0.05509605631232262,
0.009718936868011951,
0.0046858531422913074,
-0.024371802806854248,
-0.002244748407974839,
-0.06042696535587311,
0.051454558968544006,
0.013923481106758118,
0.019990593194961548,
-0.0511007159948349,
0.03386497125029564,
-0.033731814473867416,
0.017978720366954803,
0.0012176375603303313,
-0.021433280780911446,
0.05686469376087189,
-0.028810301795601845,
0.02025851234793663,
0.048345185816287994,
-0.0349058099091053,
0.0030572470277547836,
-0.04647224768996239,
0.0006029417854733765,
-0.06542942672967911,
0.009289434179663658,
0.023061173036694527,
-0.02471029944717884,
0.026472391560673714,
0.008680912666022778,
-0.061302002519369125,
-0.02259473130106926,
0.009632901288568974,
-0.009616981260478497,
0.03251076489686966,
-0.02993103489279747,
0.02113046497106552,
0.03853797912597656,
-0.007112414110451937,
0.04040853679180145,
0.002310656476765871,
0.0029913228936493397,
0.0100891487672925,
0.04394722729921341,
0.01796276867389679,
-0.017451511695981026,
-0.021006861701607704,
-0.06263250857591629,
0.05343543365597725,
-0.0016445443034172058,
-0.024655787274241447,
-0.03383587673306465,
0.013268884271383286,
0.00796733982861042,
0.007745656184852123,
-0.004568792879581451,
0.0679793655872345,
-0.023890161886811256,
0.013963820412755013,
0.024660469964146614,
0.023708665743470192,
0.04822899401187897,
-0.03401491418480873,
0.01970984786748886,
-0.0358273983001709,
0.03624137118458748,
0.019002849236130714,
0.0012353858910501003,
0.04370075464248657,
0.049939289689064026,
-0.06005364656448364,
-0.03597163408994675,
0.022470157593488693,
-0.030771005898714066,
0.020439838990569115,
-0.02719363197684288,
-0.06211070716381073,
-0.0005246790242381394,
-0.031142110005021095,
0.007394135929644108,
0.0062659746035933495,
0.018384646624326706,
-0.0056592561304569244,
0.040327947586774826,
-0.008977730758488178,
0.00187823420856148,
-0.03708064928650856,
-0.025420978665351868,
0.022956639528274536,
-0.0035024171229451895,
0.046407777816057205,
0.012508093379437923,
0.06289545446634293,
-0.0634128749370575,
0.030702022835612297,
0.009623182006180286,
0.002832574537023902,
-0.018029678612947464,
0.006180476862937212,
0.0034900126047432423,
0.009633347392082214,
0.026193929836153984,
0.02621251344680786,
0.05792202055454254,
-0.007742723450064659,
0.021037964150309563,
0.009783786721527576,
-0.024334771558642387,
-0.0012396516976878047,
0.006502804346382618,
0.022103093564510345,
-0.054413072764873505,
-0.013914166018366814,
-0.011970438063144684,
0.028340589255094528,
0.020767081528902054,
-0.03591581806540489,
-0.003916299901902676,
-0.009316019713878632,
-0.004435609560459852,
0.027780728414654732,
-0.02863067016005516,
0.033964402973651886,
0.010136466473340988,
0.015326585620641708,
0.018389316275715828,
0.025073498487472534,
0.0029843735974282026,
0.021317558363080025,
0.03795866295695305,
0.002463575452566147,
-0.0029781993944197893,
-0.03320493921637535,
-0.0412704236805439,
-0.05679304897785187,
0.04333040118217468,
0.005916742607951164,
0.017449187114834785,
-0.012083391658961773,
0.023977098986506462,
0.030894659459590912,
0.02832048572599888,
0.005968358367681503,
-0.0012570202816277742,
0.010863397270441055,
-0.0005359548958949745,
0.011910832487046719,
0.013416824862360954,
-0.012917743064463139,
0.030549677088856697,
-0.03977189213037491,
0.0701320692896843,
0.04806168004870415,
-0.0015672609442844987,
-0.019698498770594597,
0.035113222897052765,
-0.05665615200996399,
-0.04338551685214043,
-0.03422093763947487,
0.07543519884347916,
-0.017694976180791855,
-0.04378621280193329,
-0.023731378838419914,
-0.04027712345123291,
-0.15366515517234802,
-0.021965574473142624,
-0.012916596606373787,
0.014948958531022072,
0.004010932054370642,
0.004795745946466923,
-0.037146005779504776,
0.012087163515388966,
-0.01441242452710867,
0.04991259425878525,
-0.010329809039831161,
-0.03943886607885361,
-0.03562496602535248,
0.017646634951233864,
0.03433338552713394,
-0.022783854976296425,
0.00037067101220600307,
-0.0007847758824937046,
-0.001090125530026853,
-0.021579932421445847,
-0.004668455570936203,
-0.014492024667561054,
-0.0003759060346055776,
0.01393247302621603,
0.004390096291899681,
0.0190700963139534,
0.030593544244766235,
0.02488919161260128,
-0.05619242414832115,
-0.00591120682656765,
-0.01423236820846796,
-0.0007103451644070446,
-0.01960250735282898,
0.05068757385015488,
0.008649428375065327,
0.02148919180035591,
0.0613822266459465,
-0.07685305178165436,
0.02446737512946129,
-0.05084871128201485,
0.03538322076201439,
0.036591459065675735,
0.0348421148955822,
0.05007319152355194,
-0.011989767663180828,
-0.019654761999845505,
-0.004738057032227516,
-0.011924187652766705,
-0.003121078247204423,
0.059106841683387756,
-0.030950509011745453,
0.007162632420659065,
-0.03305261209607124,
-0.055849261581897736,
-0.005529995076358318,
-0.05405276641249657,
0.0597064346075058,
0.02069513313472271,
-0.050739407539367676,
-0.0105445496737957,
-0.03895452246069908,
-0.06823311746120453,
-0.013451678678393364,
-0.013326458632946014,
-0.0003697738575283438,
0.008436592295765877,
-0.025679579004645348,
-0.026290787383913994,
-0.0030627630185335875,
0.008083313703536987,
0.011236435733735561,
-0.023472025990486145,
-0.010208706371486187,
-0.03600041940808296,
0.019387589767575264,
0.022104142233729362,
-0.05783341825008392,
0.019670559093356133,
-0.04546729102730751,
-0.08081284165382385,
-0.0023195683024823666,
0.007414218503981829,
-0.00945238396525383,
0.0423857755959034,
-0.006203504744917154,
0.004656217060983181,
0.029115743935108185,
0.039900124073028564,
-0.006874989718198776,
0.24713271856307983,
-0.027806250378489494,
0.02863464504480362,
0.022186197340488434,
0.018280602991580963,
0.0005061653791926801,
-0.009694678708910942,
0.039914824068546295,
-0.009903999045491219,
-0.04331585764884949,
-0.030542921274900436,
-0.004961702041327953,
0.021082865074276924,
0.027913201600313187,
-0.029215307906270027,
0.030697589740157127,
-0.011065119877457619,
-0.013480983674526215,
0.059287842363119125,
-0.007658498827368021,
0.011300706304609776,
-0.034254029393196106,
-0.003802248975262046,
-0.008117714896798134,
-0.04925187677145004,
-0.05425142124295235,
0.02641005627810955,
0.05804608389735222,
-0.052487410604953766,
-0.005255270283669233,
0.005940292961895466,
-0.009073503315448761,
0.07289756834506989,
0.0009357341914437711,
0.0011147032491862774,
0.00031285674776881933,
-0.03075351193547249,
0.02619805932044983,
-0.0033046843018382788,
0.058425284922122955,
0.009360253810882568,
-0.036353372037410736,
-0.009405120275914669,
-0.06250123679637909,
-0.020332572981715202,
0.014718936756253242,
-0.03012491576373577,
0.019188292324543,
-0.00017014384502545,
0.02925216779112816,
-0.002020088490098715,
0.049322545528411865,
-0.016179712489247322,
0.015499979257583618,
-0.008445820771157742,
0.018226798623800278,
-0.01336094830185175,
0.04763386398553848,
0.0012677045306190848,
0.029719211161136627,
0.007562681566923857,
0.028745314106345177,
0.01017135288566351,
-0.010419663041830063,
-0.011244288645684719,
-0.025534646585583687,
-0.07306241989135742,
-0.01951761730015278,
0.03714524954557419,
-0.003627941245213151,
0.02560178004205227,
0.028661392629146576,
-0.008172647096216679,
0.014352799393236637,
0.029434897005558014,
-0.00015611427079420537,
-0.01174788735806942,
-0.010011278092861176,
-0.005582678131759167,
0.002704028273001313,
-0.035083189606666565,
-0.026744794100522995,
-0.014762189239263535,
0.028338106349110603,
0.03285123407840729,
-0.00841987319290638,
-0.032661113888025284,
0.05067257583141327,
-0.013365082442760468,
-0.03306938335299492,
-0.011861557140946388,
-0.03520064428448677,
0.02242824248969555,
0.003108442761003971,
-0.004949030000716448,
-0.017012376338243484,
0.015104436315596104,
0.017685990780591965,
-0.07260125875473022,
-0.029052525758743286,
0.0231156125664711,
-0.004327624104917049,
0.019472312182188034,
-0.04600992426276207,
0.010913409292697906,
0.004777915310114622,
0.0035771781112998724,
0.04077978432178497,
-0.04472041875123978,
0.035311561077833176,
0.018781360238790512,
0.005891962442547083,
-0.009452411904931068,
0.007338342256844044,
0.04061385616660118,
0.06663346290588379,
0.007113446015864611,
0.07064169645309448,
0.04002218320965767,
0.047529179602861404,
-0.007053535431623459,
-0.02511432021856308,
-0.02800755202770233,
-0.007140462752431631,
0.012423768639564514,
-0.0048318360932171345,
-0.044749561697244644,
-0.013025705702602863,
0.023417245596647263,
-0.013813505880534649,
0.012289448641240597,
-0.01139765977859497,
-0.005627154838293791,
0.00560011388733983,
0.08276088535785675,
0.00004250176789355464,
-0.0008339520427398384,
0.004234871827065945,
-0.01126493327319622,
0.02249355986714363,
-0.03861760348081589,
-0.005313465371727943,
-0.025798741728067398,
-0.012223513796925545,
0.01987943984568119,
0.04919697344303131,
-0.03913839906454086,
0.008645658381283283,
-0.03135888651013374,
0.010307833552360535,
0.0208421740680933,
-0.02230691909790039,
-0.02267792634665966,
-0.029035331681370735,
0.024984676390886307,
0.012489561922848225,
-0.011145750060677528,
-0.015267926268279552,
0.012227799743413925,
-0.00722460774704814,
-0.020666578784585,
0.01953328773379326,
-0.01263571996241808,
0.012538868002593517,
-0.008528148755431175,
0.04963606595993042,
-0.008932316675782204,
0.04393678158521652,
0.007646441925317049,
-0.04281134158372879,
-0.021120378747582436,
-0.05133557692170143,
-0.016202418133616447,
0.053297244012355804,
0.02637602761387825,
0.054625313729047775,
0.00845358707010746,
0.02405671589076519,
0.005155188962817192,
-0.053003426641225815,
0.04052912816405296,
0.000760538678150624,
-0.05575067177414894,
0.0034382513258606195,
-0.00021779912640340626,
-0.01598615013062954,
0.0004948980640619993,
-0.026908600702881813,
0.06205921620130539,
-0.05798494070768356,
0.007660046685487032,
0.07648497819900513,
0.0004783929034601897,
-0.029138585552573204,
-0.011966829188168049,
0.044696494936943054,
0.0052701313979923725,
-0.0009733547340147197,
-0.029929645359516144,
-0.030294030904769897,
0.010460876859724522,
0.024160243570804596,
0.013859824277460575,
-0.006269750185310841,
0.01486801914870739,
-0.013521643355488777,
0.003081337781623006,
0.03251573070883751,
-0.05731477588415146,
0.007839656434953213,
0.023798882961273193,
0.00046477853902615607,
-0.01854589208960533,
0.01590902730822563,
0.01545428391546011,
-0.025370988994836807,
0.013770880177617073,
0.04933023452758789,
0.0012176071759313345,
-0.03289997950196266,
-0.022397378459572792,
-0.012814357876777649,
0.022784657776355743,
-0.05752819776535034,
-0.026871174573898315,
0.007717875763773918,
-0.017327353358268738,
0.0004423617210704833,
-0.03289104998111725,
0.005276465322822332,
-0.0004132303292863071,
-0.05531998351216316,
0.05939335748553276,
-0.05747608840465546,
-0.00017045933054760098,
-0.040739357471466064,
0.06220519542694092,
0.0017533872742205858,
0.0027138141449540854,
-0.04797368496656418,
0.06069713458418846,
-0.020859919488430023,
0.02166391909122467,
0.07065663486719131,
0.008532371371984482,
-0.032239142805337906,
-0.03459536284208298,
0.028650781139731407,
0.029513537883758545,
0.04408551752567291,
0.02077784389257431,
0.04333474487066269,
0.003873596666380763,
0.008026453666388988,
0.01676628179848194,
-0.016248280182480812,
0.009148151613771915,
-0.004820298403501511,
-0.022909071296453476,
-0.008599602617323399,
0.016424695029854774,
0.036171894520521164,
-0.00535452738404274,
-0.017195703461766243,
-0.03891216963529587,
-0.041827015578746796,
-0.008239634335041046,
-0.04585869237780571,
-0.046832822263240814,
0.007801304571330547,
-0.00455758860334754,
-0.008471892215311527,
-0.00030827760929241776,
-0.05384790524840355,
0.014501621946692467,
0.0021255160681903362,
-0.018013885244727135,
0.017113471403717995,
-0.0040853251703083515,
-0.00931323692202568,
0.017434904351830482,
-0.0185326486825943,
0.031065477058291435,
-0.008134542964398861,
-0.0035979219246655703,
0.0029765015933662653,
-0.03903428465127945,
0.02436758577823639,
0.01000275369733572,
-0.013080612756311893,
-0.021806249395012856,
-0.01706426590681076,
-0.004493118729442358,
0.023175232112407684,
-0.015243197791278362,
-0.02567930519580841,
-0.025834081694483757,
0.05536751076579094,
0.026385508477687836,
0.03250376880168915,
-0.028001360595226288,
-0.012960102409124374,
-0.042768366634845734,
-0.052202146500349045,
-0.0349273607134819,
0.01779726892709732,
0.012911836616694927,
0.011408944614231586,
-0.05752194672822952,
0.0098760100081563,
0.0035112679470330477,
-0.06316374242305756,
0.011772437021136284,
-0.00539321219548583,
0.0304265134036541,
0.034949734807014465,
0.0229660477489233,
0.014329591765999794,
-0.011150132864713669,
-0.011608961969614029,
0.019182084128260612,
0.024809349328279495,
-0.05239786580204964,
-0.03691581264138222,
-0.0375499501824379,
-0.012104055844247341,
0.03394804894924164,
-0.032195672392845154,
-0.049277663230895996,
0.035905372351408005,
-0.0011800721986219287,
-0.002054851036518812,
-0.0018285464029759169,
-0.010032218880951405,
0.04900413751602173,
0.012334453873336315,
0.003301833523437381,
-0.040182631462812424,
0.00775947468355298,
-0.021700384095311165,
0.004851218778640032,
-0.04359092190861702,
0.05614480376243591,
-0.033581506460905075,
0.01427268236875534,
-0.01567436195909977,
0.0028535930905491114,
0.01995631493628025,
0.024543220177292824,
0.01802133023738861,
-0.0019505766686052084,
-0.04381130263209343,
-0.019820500165224075,
-0.056296929717063904,
0.01296255923807621,
-0.03158098831772804,
0.027419107034802437,
0.020412161946296692,
-0.0015219144988805056,
-0.02580702304840088,
-0.04425782710313797,
0.048092715442180634,
0.013087022118270397,
0.010602675378322601,
0.010610991157591343,
-0.007806464098393917,
-0.019948866218328476,
-0.00019670816254802048,
0.003224195446819067,
0.022065386176109314,
0.007385998032987118,
-0.06738755851984024,
-0.025898568332195282,
0.021615169942378998,
-0.026258867233991623,
0.0351024866104126,
0.008863152004778385,
0.03779849410057068,
-0.03835687041282654,
-0.035595543682575226,
-0.03091135062277317,
-0.033594537526369095,
-0.0004623412387445569,
0.002725704573094845,
0.026445554569363594,
-0.03549480810761452,
0.0056987483985722065,
0.04809369891881943,
0.03870221972465515,
-0.01033821515738964,
-0.01264406368136406,
0.014213625341653824,
-0.002579624531790614,
-0.016613226383924484,
-0.14714708924293518,
-0.06115846335887909,
-0.005685995798557997,
-0.04865194857120514,
-0.016110023483633995,
-0.016400760039687157,
-0.02496395632624626,
-0.003275853581726551,
-0.013868593610823154,
-0.00028614309849217534,
-0.026180392131209373,
0.0038083347026258707,
0.020317867398262024,
-0.01329251378774643,
-0.019126176834106445,
0.010837700217962265,
-0.0515480563044548,
0.01368631236255169,
-0.05956753343343735,
0.02661972865462303,
0.02743559703230858,
0.015425876714289188,
-0.01158952061086893,
-0.02842172048985958,
0.03475252911448479,
-0.011518370360136032,
-0.019680839031934738,
-0.03628847002983093,
-0.037885718047618866,
-0.03846075013279915,
-0.007214069832116365,
-0.029455874115228653,
0.007105185184627771,
0.05773923173546791,
0.01276644691824913,
0.022841785103082657,
0.018460193648934364,
-0.006369030103087425,
-0.03591585531830788,
-0.027586765587329865,
-0.011961609125137329,
0.0221945121884346,
-0.026552408933639526,
-0.0622611828148365,
0.004588534124195576,
0.031348973512649536,
0.00885269045829773,
-0.010424609296023846,
-0.09149418026208878,
-0.015231963247060776,
-0.03603703901171684,
-0.010535256005823612,
0.031505703926086426,
0.03970891609787941,
0.008867019787430763,
-0.00797232799232006,
0.017380187287926674,
-0.04472080618143082,
-0.009347346611320972,
0.040379494428634644,
-0.0018438916886225343,
-0.0009895898401737213,
-0.06041302904486656,
-0.011566330678761005,
-0.017701800912618637,
-0.0021977475844323635,
-0.024136776104569435,
-0.0063736941665410995,
-0.012295260094106197,
-0.004087979905307293,
0.011962233111262321,
-0.009725336916744709,
-0.004404178820550442,
-0.06954850256443024,
0.014698881655931473,
-0.007556722033768892,
0.021143324673175812,
0.014079257845878601,
-0.019011542201042175,
0.00446158554404974,
-0.019752904772758484,
-0.0180487260222435,
-0.041360124945640564,
0.014426344074308872,
0.044848304241895676,
0.02647433988749981,
0.005915326997637749,
-0.019880857318639755,
0.029234666377305984,
-0.040537070482969284,
-0.047827329486608505,
-0.009465683251619339,
0.024757210165262222,
0.0001317777787335217,
-0.05323491990566254,
0.026577437296509743,
-0.0020355458837002516,
0.002066569169983268,
0.006931539624929428,
0.011117961257696152,
-0.03757812827825546,
-0.016600249335169792,
0.017915405333042145,
0.016461748629808426,
-0.04119470342993736,
-0.004882049281150103,
0.008717128075659275,
-0.033322133123874664,
0.027592051774263382,
-0.03404485061764717,
-0.023404095321893692,
0.004675474017858505,
-0.04278954863548279,
0.04881375655531883,
-0.06410294026136398,
0.014564844779670238,
0.024798324331641197,
0.018346216529607773,
0.013715768232941628,
-0.008430391550064087,
0.006779450923204422,
0.009706243872642517,
-0.0003140517801512033,
-0.03909493237733841,
0.015878694131970406,
0.054251350462436676,
0.07075954973697662,
0.03048274852335453,
0.04120808094739914,
-0.012409955263137817,
0.07882225513458252,
0.007397716864943504,
0.032303716987371445,
0.03769320994615555,
-0.007637666072696447,
0.043087851256132126,
0.02722516469657421,
0.008380260318517685,
-0.0345173105597496,
-0.029971091076731682,
-0.024273904040455818,
0.007276326417922974,
0.005552615970373154,
0.004734640941023827,
-0.016310011968016624,
-0.007788721937686205,
0.012718191370368004,
-0.045068323612213135,
-0.01918872632086277,
-0.01633923314511776,
-0.00589434988796711,
0.008579119108617306,
-0.02257397584617138,
0.03269237279891968,
0.0012943530455231667,
-0.007910650223493576,
0.04597367346286774,
0.00040187870035879314,
0.03131379932165146,
0.029834484681487083,
0.022718528285622597,
-0.03141677752137184,
-0.04030703753232956,
-0.03760361671447754,
-0.031547725200653076,
0.019953260198235512,
-0.013875174336135387,
0.019204746931791306,
-0.03980131447315216,
-0.041915930807590485,
-0.03651834651827812,
0.021910881623625755,
-0.013542776927351952,
0.00963123794645071,
0.02385883219540119,
0.0076030101627111435,
-0.015655608847737312,
0.00031204489641822875,
0.04151985049247742,
-0.019257865846157074,
0.0411602184176445,
0.028420811519026756,
0.01623319461941719,
-0.028941353783011436,
0.013464431278407574,
0.035866085439920425,
0.03402409702539444,
0.0581209696829319,
-0.01192633155733347,
-0.054588187485933304,
-0.037642158567905426,
0.020721668377518654,
0.017409052699804306,
-0.00772511214017868,
0.008701675571501255,
0.04499703645706177,
0.007050745189189911,
0.05060926079750061,
0.015917887911200523,
0.039944183081388474,
0.03830409795045853,
-0.03796005621552467,
-0.01929638907313347,
-0.026585739105939865,
-0.03059985116124153,
0.01606467179954052,
-0.010554193519055843,
-0.02794509008526802,
-0.03892090171575546,
0.057720623910427094,
-0.012232252396643162,
-0.014262412674725056,
-0.0007793869008310139,
0.01784994825720787,
-0.012193623930215836,
0.006242921110242605,
0.0199297983199358,
0.05212917551398277,
0.013585731387138367,
-0.02750004641711712,
0.008745037019252777,
0.027155134826898575,
-0.0037432785611599684,
-0.02533739060163498,
0.0016328295459970832,
-0.0018289886647835374,
0.004863549489527941,
0.008570786565542221,
-0.008552072569727898,
0.007710217032581568,
0.02581745758652687,
0.01091099064797163,
0.018603727221488953,
0.045054949820041656,
-0.02544127218425274,
-0.03511561453342438,
-0.008393398486077785,
-0.006034374237060547,
-0.009075863286852837,
-0.030525872483849525,
0.06969815492630005,
-0.016717737540602684,
-0.015322789549827576,
-0.007958239875733852
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:32
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
476The Heads of Agreement did not specify by what time HTT was obliged to "obtain" the finance referred to in clause 4.7. Nor did the Heads of Agreement specify, in terms, when, in relation to the obtaining by HTT of finance, or at all, LEC would discontinue the 2001 Proceedings or withdraw the Caveat.
477Did the parties intend that LEC would withdraw the Caveat and discontinue the 2001 Proceedings at the same time that HTT obtained finance pursuant to clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement to payout DTC and the other secured creditors over the Land?
478The Heads of Agreement does not say so in terms.
479The recitals to the Heads of Agreement, which I have set out earlier, suggest that the parties intended that the entry into the proposed structure, set out at paragraph 84 above, would occur simultaneously with the withdrawal of the Caveat and the discontinuance of the 2001 Proceedings. But the recitals make no reference to the obtaining of finance by HTT.
480The guiding principal is that stated by the High Court in Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165 at [40]:-
"This court, in Pacific Carriers Limited v. BNP Paribas [(2004) 218 CLR 451], has recently reaffirmed the principle of objectivity by which the rights and liabilities of the parties to a contract are determined.
It is not the subjective beliefs or understanding of the parties about their rights and liabilities that govern their contractual relations. What matters is what each party by words and conduct would have led a reasonable person in the position of the other party to believe.
References to the common intention of the parties to the contract are to be understood as referring to what a reasonable person would have understood by the language in which the parties have expressed their agreement.
The meaning of the terms of a contractual document is determined by what a reasonable person would have understood them to mean. That, normally, requires consideration not only of the text, but also of the surrounding circumstances known to the parties, and the purpose and object of the transaction."
481It is by no means clear to me that a reasonable person in the position of HTT would have understood, from the language used in the Heads of Agreement, that its obligation to obtain finance was to be performed simultaneously with the other obligations imposed on the parties by the Heads of Agreement.
482In any event, as which will see below, Mr Hilliard adopted the position that it was appropriate to adopt a "2 Stage" approach to settlement of the transactions referred to in the Heads of Agreement. I shall return to this aspect later in these reasons.
Were the plaintiffs induced to execute the Heads of Agreement by the representations made prior to 13 May 2004?
483In my opinion, for the reasons I have outlined above, nothing conveyed to Mr Zdrilic in the circumstances of the Third and Fourth Representations (concerning Mr Zdrilic's position on the HTT board and the recognition of liability for his loan to LEC) was either misleading or deceptive. What was conveyed as to the funder's position was, on the evidence, in truth the funder's position.
484Nor did what was said about those matters induced the plaintiffs to execute the Heads of Agreement. After all, despite what Mr Zdrilic had been told about the funder's attitude to Mr Zdrilic being on the HTT board, at the end of the day he was given a place on the board.
485Further, for the reasons I have explained above, I cannot accept that what was conveyed to Mr Zdrilic by Mr Renshall in the circumstances the subject of the alleged Second, and Fifth to Ninth Representations (concerning the availability of funds) induced Mr Zdrilic to commit the plaintiffs to the Heads of Agreement.
486To the extent that the plaintiffs allege these representations were misleading or deceptive because they conveyed that there was a commitment from a funder to advance monies, I do not accept that there was any such representation.
|
[
-0.012463675811886787,
0.022913774475455284,
-0.02005866914987564,
0.018876157701015472,
-0.0009209072450175881,
-0.054281286895275116,
0.011410177685320377,
-0.03295176103711128,
-0.011602489277720451,
0.030145345255732536,
0.017113395035266876,
0.012390428222715855,
-0.03371984139084816,
0.021248359233140945,
-0.0105973519384861,
-0.018693832680583,
0.052125561982393265,
-0.03618129715323448,
-0.025152303278446198,
-0.0037072652485221624,
-0.01413388829678297,
-0.01933937706053257,
-0.009476343169808388,
0.0301744993776083,
-0.013023902662098408,
0.005972050596028566,
-0.04171636328101158,
-0.00335215637460351,
-0.016330592334270477,
0.013194545172154903,
-0.022204389795660973,
0.024449583142995834,
0.0044673141092062,
-0.026724936440587044,
0.009753340855240822,
-0.023874331265687943,
0.014092731289565563,
0.027866169810295105,
-0.042512696236371994,
-0.0009218738996423781,
-0.02199869602918625,
-0.0008604061440564692,
0.014130902476608753,
-0.017012393102049828,
0.06515789777040482,
-0.034544143825769424,
-0.012806279584765434,
-0.04011920839548111,
-0.011553945951163769,
0.027611374855041504,
-0.04033222049474716,
-0.04601193964481354,
0.03003668785095215,
-0.02855467051267624,
0.023525213822722435,
0.01631118729710579,
-0.026140712201595306,
-0.05244676023721695,
-0.05568858981132507,
0.020357917994260788,
0.010105228051543236,
-0.029767649248242378,
-0.05656059831380844,
-0.010610692203044891,
-0.013362026773393154,
0.05279462784528732,
0.025642139837145805,
-0.01705821231007576,
0.008804877288639545,
-0.02111244574189186,
-0.02037031576037407,
0.008040486834943295,
-0.022753503173589706,
0.021641448140144348,
-0.09285712987184525,
0.035787638276815414,
0.005898784846067429,
0.00656364019960165,
0.05151435360312462,
0.002587829250842333,
0.02720949798822403,
-0.021244214847683907,
0.01577533781528473,
0.03638787940144539,
-0.02672070637345314,
0.027832739055156708,
-0.04239196702837944,
0.0339878648519516,
0.028534643352031708,
0.015757421031594276,
0.0021195837762206793,
-0.03419983386993408,
0.034183964133262634,
-0.029519543051719666,
-0.010328360833227634,
-0.019450794905424118,
-0.05707370117306709,
0.0322781540453434,
-0.028249621391296387,
0.027924630790948868,
0.002603673143312335,
0.04346570000052452,
-0.011808770708739758,
-0.06388046592473984,
0.037195369601249695,
0.04337335005402565,
0.053852736949920654,
0.013465327210724354,
0.0038200123235583305,
-0.0024737983476370573,
-0.0009827411267906427,
-0.0026057306677103043,
0.008572280406951904,
-0.004173925146460533,
-0.02727636881172657,
-0.02552388794720173,
-0.013454199768602848,
0.019185995683073997,
0.001892979722470045,
0.0031478251330554485,
0.022936398163437843,
0.006498770322650671,
0.05257085710763931,
-0.01510133221745491,
-0.03300272300839424,
0.008823846466839314,
0.014553142711520195,
-0.00384477898478508,
-0.009914285503327847,
0.061319656670093536,
0.009118391200900078,
0.0006602896610274911,
-0.0052153863944113255,
-0.05469920113682747,
0.0002578638377599418,
0.02008446678519249,
0.029582733288407326,
-0.027387050911784172,
-0.011481765657663345,
-0.060251716524362564,
0.04585424065589905,
0.03325152397155762,
-0.015793003141880035,
-0.009220888838171959,
0.03140263631939888,
-0.00556330569088459,
0.0015359757235273719,
0.022320982068777084,
-0.003975140396505594,
0.03000929206609726,
0.008221570402383804,
-0.0005207227077335119,
-0.006369987968355417,
-0.0032233339734375477,
0.007991908118128777,
-0.03293425217270851,
-0.030680201947689056,
-0.01866881735622883,
0.003286830149590969,
0.08418305963277817,
-0.016864178702235222,
0.06907078623771667,
0.021814683452248573,
-0.03120826557278633,
-0.03149629011750221,
-0.005678584333509207,
-0.0031502745114266872,
0.02525719627737999,
-0.01548391580581665,
0.018253635615110397,
0.014998890459537506,
-0.0024840019177645445,
0.059211019426584244,
-0.009195059537887573,
-0.014344241470098495,
0.03117246739566326,
0.06434017419815063,
0.011519944295287132,
-0.009449899196624756,
0.0011439702939242125,
-0.040909603238105774,
0.012270449660718441,
0.0007606291910633445,
-0.03522850573062897,
-0.007320471107959747,
0.0009166189120151103,
0.005455940496176481,
-0.03144187107682228,
-0.005461990833282471,
0.04813091829419136,
-0.021902484819293022,
-0.030994433909654617,
0.023900851607322693,
0.00901749823242426,
-0.015085498802363873,
-0.013633333146572113,
0.01061678770929575,
-0.027343468740582466,
-0.011310283094644547,
-0.007462047506123781,
-0.010458556935191154,
0.013167749159038067,
0.07054030150175095,
-0.003522557206451893,
-0.031042737886309624,
0.014359258115291595,
-0.053188521414995193,
-0.010392701253294945,
-0.01588447391986847,
-0.058987442404031754,
-0.01871875301003456,
-0.014747264795005322,
0.0014393092133104801,
-0.009539380669593811,
0.04113717004656792,
-0.0467948243021965,
-0.003030923428013921,
-0.030528772622346878,
0.0013281299034133554,
-0.008779175579547882,
0.0009790073381736875,
-0.013531957753002644,
-0.009308532811701298,
0.020060362294316292,
0.023508768528699875,
0.045790910720825195,
-0.08649875223636627,
0.022282801568508148,
-0.019623473286628723,
-0.030152224004268646,
-0.007900831289589405,
-0.01103249005973339,
-0.01616884395480156,
-0.032354794442653656,
0.05562010407447815,
0.03422922641038895,
0.013461743481457233,
-0.002570158103480935,
0.02055925317108631,
0.010410130955278873,
-0.014282170683145523,
0.010015904903411865,
0.0045507135801017284,
-0.004530712496489286,
-0.026526261121034622,
-0.04967880621552467,
-0.024456093087792397,
-0.0332193560898304,
0.03161657601594925,
-0.033890530467033386,
0.0000888696959009394,
0.007622355595231056,
-0.021015960723161697,
-0.0027458462864160538,
-0.01041426882147789,
0.028337247669696808,
0.010041782632470131,
0.01013496145606041,
0.07380012422800064,
0.013486437499523163,
-0.020075282081961632,
0.02610783837735653,
0.06070691719651222,
0.013652533292770386,
-0.039885442703962326,
0.00477670319378376,
-0.06092400476336479,
-0.032835453748703,
0.03760550171136856,
0.039176300168037415,
0.01882638968527317,
0.007642356213182211,
0.0034568654373288155,
0.00866343080997467,
0.05275527015328407,
0.04136732220649719,
0.04286473989486694,
0.007022341713309288,
0.0262864101678133,
0.02249705046415329,
0.023083960637450218,
-0.010395675897598267,
0.05005808547139168,
-0.04199051111936569,
0.03695682808756828,
0.026803303509950638,
-0.035509802401065826,
-0.04798299819231033,
0.03445112705230713,
0.002723667537793517,
0.028231006115674973,
0.03239569440484047,
0.08796006441116333,
-0.023214267566800117,
-0.08953896909952164,
-0.026519108563661575,
-0.013935764320194721,
-0.14365163445472717,
0.00739611592143774,
0.01162410993129015,
-0.024169135838747025,
-0.009245776571333408,
0.0515654981136322,
-0.04498165845870972,
-0.02408200316131115,
-0.0040047019720077515,
-0.005972305778414011,
0.014502163045108318,
-0.07550156861543655,
-0.03348464518785477,
0.007797799538820982,
-0.0022361986339092255,
-0.021822331473231316,
0.00012840828276239336,
0.028823379427194595,
0.060138147324323654,
-0.01668812520802021,
-0.005439933855086565,
-0.04467945173382759,
0.04379582032561302,
-0.008174164220690727,
0.02483292669057846,
0.0056806583888828754,
-0.003585661528632045,
0.006974038667976856,
-0.04930955916643143,
0.0005644639604724944,
-0.02648277021944523,
0.018971500918269157,
-0.01903628557920456,
0.057099152356386185,
0.00039567804196849465,
0.04942629858851433,
0.08575738966464996,
-0.05664093792438507,
-0.019607948139309883,
-0.0052778166718780994,
0.00907779112458229,
0.08463571220636368,
0.008272589184343815,
0.006822717841714621,
0.011449276469647884,
-0.05934535339474678,
0.021673761308193207,
0.010394890792667866,
-0.0038802821654826403,
0.040225446224212646,
0.01011828426271677,
-0.0008954420336522162,
-0.025267690420150757,
-0.05968356877565384,
-0.024461502209305763,
-0.04384710639715195,
0.028839411213994026,
0.007415394764393568,
-0.01966465823352337,
-0.011937257833778858,
-0.026059668511152267,
-0.07039844244718552,
0.0070297447964549065,
0.01592223346233368,
-0.023373564705252647,
-0.0029683304019272327,
-0.0029255037661641836,
-0.0070768133737146854,
0.0402049645781517,
0.011882217600941658,
0.00920113455504179,
-0.02365696243941784,
0.006258350796997547,
-0.004416259936988354,
0.00019561880617402494,
0.030783656984567642,
-0.03962630406022072,
0.025744441896677017,
-0.01080779917538166,
-0.07517614215612411,
-0.014979666098952293,
0.03987801820039749,
-0.021100670099258423,
0.01669512502849102,
-0.023246271535754204,
0.018602972850203514,
0.03395693004131317,
0.05192405730485916,
0.04519619420170784,
0.2223270833492279,
-0.014719594269990921,
0.0038247117772698402,
0.03384726867079735,
0.03804220259189606,
-0.01019198726862669,
0.012322177179157734,
0.031865812838077545,
-0.016951192170381546,
-0.053399037569761276,
-0.0442742183804512,
0.02327466383576393,
0.022056568413972855,
0.028370443731546402,
-0.033719539642333984,
-0.008261135779321194,
-0.0543387234210968,
-0.04917602241039276,
0.07766526937484741,
-0.009975395165383816,
0.027054859325289726,
0.014134509488940239,
-0.004903155378997326,
0.007953397929668427,
-0.0777641087770462,
-0.041944731026887894,
0.0323764830827713,
0.016436681151390076,
-0.02614135667681694,
-0.018493300303816795,
-0.03619114309549332,
-0.00607852591201663,
0.036369726061820984,
-0.029552757740020752,
-0.008631224744021893,
-0.003768758848309517,
-0.010967069305479527,
0.022343933582305908,
-0.013744063675403595,
0.03872670233249664,
0.0329129658639431,
-0.04618231952190399,
-0.03959167003631592,
-0.03288513794541359,
-0.029789289459586143,
0.03622377663850784,
-0.009964234195649624,
0.020618338137865067,
0.0018500796286389232,
0.0029058968648314476,
-0.04481641575694084,
0.0021343929693102837,
-0.05085860565304756,
-0.03173671290278435,
-0.024466393515467644,
0.021647552028298378,
-0.03943397477269173,
0.059664323925971985,
-0.0018393914215266705,
0.027453213930130005,
0.07230231165885925,
0.003721873741596937,
-0.025369545444846153,
0.01298678107559681,
-0.02255023829638958,
-0.0383092537522316,
-0.049316782504320145,
-0.01643441431224346,
0.03574477881193161,
0.03717576712369919,
0.05283132940530777,
0.03253016620874405,
0.027478255331516266,
0.006212149281054735,
0.005865184590220451,
-0.0005115614621900022,
-0.019305221736431122,
0.0114329494535923,
-0.0012159448815509677,
-0.018218567594885826,
-0.05489116534590721,
-0.011272597126662731,
-0.013159394264221191,
0.04178857058286667,
0.01236862875521183,
-0.0007148667937144637,
-0.010060634464025497,
0.006738780066370964,
-0.014481423422694206,
-0.0023134094662964344,
-0.014014160260558128,
0.0009092446998693049,
0.03815590962767601,
0.00019904547662008554,
-0.05161226540803909,
-0.0239389818161726,
-0.0026247387286275625,
-0.015425953082740307,
-0.01377279032021761,
-0.024921387434005737,
-0.01569460891187191,
0.008511444553732872,
-0.0033573703840374947,
-0.05292603373527527,
0.0295974463224411,
0.016789251938462257,
0.020736759528517723,
-0.0049924226477742195,
-0.05323820933699608,
0.019012844190001488,
-0.005457121413201094,
0.008873535320162773,
0.0010102406376972795,
-0.005338843446224928,
0.0373401865363121,
0.054124318063259125,
-0.018911905586719513,
0.047176193445920944,
0.05505424737930298,
0.05311711132526398,
-0.003065308788791299,
0.00387048302218318,
-0.017363695427775383,
0.027493109926581383,
0.004970374517142773,
0.013918185606598854,
-0.008901160210371017,
-0.013737461529672146,
0.016473475843667984,
0.005742750130593777,
-0.037183426320552826,
-0.010437862947583199,
-0.036278363317251205,
0.02986920438706875,
0.015453482046723366,
0.049695730209350586,
-0.0073432582430541515,
0.03608238324522972,
-0.026190783828496933,
-0.035828571766614914,
-0.028256265446543694,
0.036955587565898895,
-0.03812321648001671,
0.009619662538170815,
0.004800989292562008,
0.017475392669439316,
-0.060346879065036774,
0.026643019169569016,
-0.043675024062395096,
0.006658671423792839,
0.02255300059914589,
0.02461446449160576,
-0.0037047455552965403,
-0.06901920586824417,
-0.008892649784684181,
-0.05626615136861801,
-0.006461513694375753,
-0.014135847799479961,
0.04259508475661278,
-0.01736518368124962,
-0.016612423583865166,
-0.0028245928697288036,
0.03560261428356171,
0.008757115341722965,
0.012558276765048504,
0.09190713614225388,
-0.014932677149772644,
0.042710717767477036,
0.039130136370658875,
-0.028157871216535568,
-0.018581626936793327,
-0.05863173305988312,
-0.010981384664773941,
0.07837401330471039,
0.02826577052474022,
0.02032943069934845,
0.027631323784589767,
0.00796936359256506,
0.005602105986326933,
-0.03923669457435608,
0.04323400929570198,
0.015076772309839725,
-0.015235128812491894,
0.0196249820291996,
-0.023156557232141495,
0.00661942083388567,
-0.009988222271203995,
-0.015954215079545975,
0.04264065995812416,
-0.05218450352549553,
-0.015508647076785564,
0.08148013055324554,
0.008727346546947956,
-0.024349547922611237,
0.030487386509776115,
0.004598388914018869,
-0.00883681420236826,
0.02359721064567566,
0.010567831806838512,
-0.019475489854812622,
0.010167444124817848,
0.002334403106942773,
0.006763918790966272,
-0.03098900243639946,
0.024535391479730606,
-0.005175677128136158,
-0.0020615512039512396,
0.026342768222093582,
-0.07096029818058014,
-0.03898003324866295,
0.01836819387972355,
0.04143182933330536,
-0.049272824078798294,
0.025156322866678238,
-0.01617460697889328,
-0.020533470436930656,
-0.0019270332995802164,
0.03499525040388107,
0.03723040968179703,
-0.06237373501062393,
0.011527988128364086,
-0.016073791310191154,
0.02266613207757473,
-0.07732973247766495,
-0.01739434525370598,
0.01779855415225029,
-0.028603989630937576,
0.011714297346770763,
-0.013800294138491154,
0.012068476527929306,
0.004158159252256155,
-0.038759633898735046,
0.061552368104457855,
-0.019829872995615005,
0.02818954922258854,
-0.017073098570108414,
0.03326258435845375,
0.009272778406739235,
0.04812173545360565,
0.007688848301768303,
0.055819518864154816,
-0.0005557747790589929,
0.029695812612771988,
0.03694400563836098,
0.007244748063385487,
-0.03120998851954937,
0.0033366726711392403,
-0.024470847100019455,
0.005247806664556265,
0.05944325029850006,
0.00999830849468708,
0.007730092853307724,
0.027379821985960007,
-0.03710439056158066,
0.03433272987604141,
-0.003307874081656337,
0.027342259883880615,
-0.022888928651809692,
-0.06353483349084854,
-0.025072649121284485,
0.02073652669787407,
0.0408259816467762,
0.0014361875364556909,
-0.014272362925112247,
-0.03852372616529465,
-0.056133005768060684,
0.032404717057943344,
-0.0034764138981699944,
-0.040449634194374084,
-0.015618648380041122,
0.005595902446657419,
-0.00789802148938179,
-0.005370941944420338,
-0.08573547005653381,
-0.007335410453379154,
-0.000017423491954104975,
-0.018486388027668,
-0.024067619815468788,
-0.04192346706986427,
-0.0292055644094944,
-0.002336982637643814,
-0.0062643797136843204,
0.022307205945253372,
0.02588798478245735,
0.030929172411561012,
0.014834152534604073,
-0.021705280989408493,
0.02557259611785412,
0.011468923650681973,
0.020919447764754295,
-0.008585730567574501,
0.006830728612840176,
-0.000009256873454432935,
0.02438296750187874,
-0.01899726316332817,
0.001252176589332521,
-0.025012673810124397,
0.03965999558568001,
-0.020152777433395386,
0.018625551834702492,
-0.03036154992878437,
-0.027596868574619293,
-0.018284907564520836,
-0.06968031078577042,
-0.015322692692279816,
-0.012302285060286522,
0.011664782650768757,
-0.03596224635839462,
-0.01253930851817131,
0.051416926085948944,
0.0422656312584877,
-0.057093922048807144,
0.01047755591571331,
-0.012240025214850903,
0.01144630927592516,
-0.015062281861901283,
-0.028124060481786728,
-0.01096018124371767,
-0.025883160531520844,
-0.002782597905024886,
-0.0010428704554215074,
-0.024473218247294426,
-0.023942142724990845,
0.02254689671099186,
-0.02730482630431652,
-0.009780344553291798,
0.0038952415343374014,
-0.026035938411951065,
-0.03263988718390465,
0.014893160201609135,
-0.01783336140215397,
-0.014256606809794903,
0.01696939393877983,
0.004108114168047905,
0.01983748748898506,
0.04252735897898674,
-0.01279568113386631,
-0.015225648880004883,
0.030823299661278725,
-0.028600329533219337,
-0.004709173925220966,
-0.060969363898038864,
0.054659318178892136,
0.010365563444793224,
0.03552009165287018,
0.013684483245015144,
-0.007764272857457399,
-0.008976836688816547,
0.020479023456573486,
0.00625195587053895,
-0.020996198058128357,
0.002984503284096718,
0.0027265625540167093,
-0.050025295466184616,
0.002536487067118287,
0.025784755125641823,
0.005761309992522001,
0.05100463330745697,
0.04523240402340889,
-0.01889941282570362,
-0.024990497156977654,
0.04140051081776619,
-0.009149208664894104,
0.01749868132174015,
0.02042163908481598,
-0.02123226225376129,
0.012859308160841465,
0.005317353177815676,
0.02404107339680195,
-0.013727634213864803,
0.03522743657231331,
-0.04782252758741379,
0.007056449539959431,
-0.03051576390862465,
-0.028042316436767578,
0.033648308366537094,
0.008478809148073196,
0.032196294516325,
-0.014794312417507172,
-0.0635162889957428,
-0.02104465663433075,
-0.0467410609126091,
-0.05042591691017151,
-0.01977997086942196,
0.02962440811097622,
-0.01442866399884224,
0.016886234283447266,
0.0030816446524113417,
0.009514255449175835,
0.003936254419386387,
-0.026529958471655846,
0.029206886887550354,
0.004899331368505955,
-0.012663920409977436,
-0.13620354235172272,
0.01103128120303154,
-0.007097121328115463,
-0.01318697165697813,
-0.028030896559357643,
0.012037807144224644,
-0.010577165521681309,
0.01704578474164009,
-0.02127029187977314,
0.013042842037975788,
0.008024520240724087,
-0.020366737619042397,
-0.021990960463881493,
-0.031513236463069916,
-0.043070804327726364,
0.007959426380693913,
-0.029448512941598892,
-0.016133977100253105,
-0.04746907204389572,
0.02467234432697296,
0.0153470104560256,
-0.017723945900797844,
0.03023918904364109,
-0.017193904146552086,
-0.008860420435667038,
0.004211547784507275,
-0.067766934633255,
-0.08611304312944412,
-0.02359187789261341,
-0.013514316640794277,
-0.036712951958179474,
-0.028035828843712807,
0.007578747346997261,
0.019416050985455513,
-0.0021238019689917564,
-0.012225686572492123,
0.00009857120312517509,
-0.015449809841811657,
-0.03469365835189819,
-0.00985618308186531,
0.01845918409526348,
0.03609481081366539,
-0.022816067561507225,
-0.032225221395492554,
-0.012610789388418198,
0.004001275170594454,
0.009301332756876945,
-0.006710686255246401,
-0.05727098509669304,
-0.013693542219698429,
-0.060487303882837296,
0.027396555989980698,
0.03276202827692032,
0.02752705104649067,
0.021940212696790695,
-0.02790088579058647,
0.010875583626329899,
-0.007576407864689827,
0.0030676356982439756,
0.027625329792499542,
0.025335485115647316,
-0.002124104183167219,
-0.0666917935013771,
-0.006754210684448481,
-0.00027052502264268696,
0.002832362661138177,
-0.02995328977704048,
0.01182833407074213,
-0.04032506048679352,
-0.002727417042478919,
-0.025513645261526108,
-0.011686915531754494,
-0.005103639326989651,
-0.015635984018445015,
0.0034496912267059088,
-0.01121660228818655,
0.009411286562681198,
0.0022656277287751436,
0.002053790958598256,
-0.012378795072436333,
-0.04744930937886238,
0.00007787112554069608,
-0.047712575644254684,
-0.016594480723142624,
0.09280426055192947,
0.0414823554456234,
-0.003430351847782731,
-0.005404636263847351,
0.010391972959041595,
-0.006997370161116123,
-0.06319977343082428,
-0.0031779545824974775,
-0.008947676979005337,
0.025953466072678566,
-0.011610160581767559,
0.01951233297586441,
0.00042497942922636867,
0.018717432394623756,
0.01122650783509016,
-0.006052517332136631,
-0.038016073405742645,
-0.0018762740073725581,
0.04612252488732338,
-0.009914115071296692,
-0.04068779945373535,
-0.013581694103777409,
0.01362324133515358,
0.024669310078024864,
0.005910575855523348,
-0.01824696734547615,
-0.033475764095783234,
-0.004683577921241522,
-0.015104290097951889,
0.021954074501991272,
-0.07255058735609055,
-0.0229682307690382,
-0.017284715548157692,
-0.020403442904353142,
-0.0009578909375704825,
0.03808818385004997,
0.0006342525593936443,
-0.005510885268449783,
0.012620842084288597,
-0.024098418653011322,
0.012287294492125511,
0.007403394673019648,
0.05976777523756027,
0.012938285246491432,
0.026887990534305573,
0.008351020514965057,
0.07771700620651245,
-0.004304501228034496,
-0.007723014336079359,
0.00835862010717392,
0.03635304793715477,
0.01622062921524048,
-0.00424323882907629,
0.029801229014992714,
-0.015557577833533287,
-0.00018226230167783797,
-0.016955696046352386,
0.005204490851610899,
-0.005055483430624008,
-0.0009875439573079348,
-0.02834557183086872,
0.008060170337557793,
0.044981710612773895,
0.02204643376171589,
-0.019940193742513657,
0.0018374004866927862,
-0.005512661300599575,
0.002329177688807249,
0.005204295739531517,
0.06413889676332474,
0.022499151527881622,
-0.04798753932118416,
0.036651913076639175,
0.007073774002492428,
-0.0005934061482548714,
0.03811425715684891,
0.0002262886264361441,
-0.037495724856853485,
-0.0141673618927598,
-0.030968962237238884,
-0.014608711004257202,
0.03755921497941017,
-0.017569204792380333,
0.008595304563641548,
0.004075245466083288,
-0.0025132806040346622,
-0.03857377544045448,
0.06782130151987076,
-0.005846178159117699,
0.03670170158147812,
0.022463858127593994,
-0.04468211531639099,
-0.021488213911652565,
-0.009192043915390968,
0.02335568703711033,
-0.017595941200852394,
0.033146932721138,
0.04053259268403053,
0.017373347654938698,
0.008408538065850735,
-0.003692485624924302,
0.0297841876745224,
0.03652176633477211,
0.02332596853375435,
-0.01303718239068985,
-0.045651864260435104,
-0.03606012836098671,
-0.002847070340067148,
0.04608481749892235,
0.0014188067289069295,
-0.021308213472366333,
0.01954394020140171,
0.01337327342480421,
0.02303084172308445,
-0.005964178591966629,
0.042813561856746674,
0.05934775993227959,
-0.03054129332304001,
-0.06596174091100693,
-0.014875421300530434,
-0.01191328652203083,
0.042206600308418274,
0.003327964572235942,
-0.07476633042097092,
-0.0036355566699057817,
0.06604087352752686,
0.0031210645101964474,
-0.016665339469909668,
-0.03253910318017006,
0.03269428759813309,
-0.002411167835816741,
0.031118856742978096,
-0.017426781356334686,
-0.011298025958240032,
0.04925050958991051,
-0.01771754026412964,
0.0115134809166193,
0.06386006623506546,
0.011905530467629433,
-0.04730862006545067,
-0.012418007478117943,
0.022538043558597565,
-0.04524766281247139,
-0.010932980105280876,
0.027848515659570694,
0.01612047478556633,
0.007984990254044533,
0.016643868759274483,
-0.013082521967589855,
0.052984073758125305,
-0.0015452721854671836,
-0.008570892736315727,
-0.04466560110449791,
0.008888970129191875,
-0.033710237592458725,
-0.03245225548744202,
0.033561091870069504,
0.01854487508535385,
0.0012186369858682156,
-0.013202905654907227
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:20
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
290Mr Moir acted for IBIS (and IPC) until September 2004. During that time he also acted for HTT in relation to its search for finance.
The "Sunday meeting" 15 February 2004
291On Sunday 15 February 2004, Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall had a meeting at which, according to Mr Zdrilic, the "true agreement" between them was reached.
292Mr Zdrilic claimed the "true agreement" was that, as a part of the overall settlement of the 2001 Proceedings, he, Mr Renshall and Mr Hickie would each have a place on the board of HTT, and that decisions between the three men would have to be unanimous thus giving each, in effect, power of veto.
293This alleged agreement is significant in a number of ways.
294First, it is relevant to the alleged Third and Fourth Representations (which were to the effect that the "new funder" would not countenance Mr Zdrilic on the board of HTT: see below).
295Secondly, as we shall see, it is relevant to Mr Zdrilic's reaction to the revelation in mid July, that no funding was in place at that time.
296Mr Zdrilic gave an account of the conversation in his affidavit.
297However, I consider a more reliable guide to what was said to be found in the email Mr Zdrilic sent to Mr Hilliard on the following day (16 February 2004), in which he referred to his conversation with Mr Renshall and said he had obtained "some more information for you to put in the 'draft'."
298At that time, Mr Hilliard was preparing an earlier draft of what became the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement.
299Relevantly, Mr Zdrilic's email read as follows:-
(1) "A new company will be formed to operate through a trust, and this company will have 3 shareholders, namely - Devubo Pty Limited ATF The Renshall Family Trust, Vocifa Pty Limited ATF The Hickie Family Trust and (a company still to be formed) ATF The Zdrilic Family Trust". [The "company still to be formed" was ultimately Amy Holdings].
(2) Each of the companies will hold one share each in the new company.
(3) The new company will hold 27.75% in [HTT] and the other 72.25% is owned by a number of smaller investors who could number a few dozen and I think most of these were found by Renshall as part of his getting an initial interest in the project.
(4) The new company will have 3 directors Robert Renshall, David Hickie and Sam Zdrilic - secretary can be Renshall. All decisions have to be unanimous.
(5) The new company will recognise $5.5m loan to Sam's new company (...)
(7) Because there are many small shareholders we need directors on the [HTT] board to be Renshall, Hickie and Zdrilic. I do not particularly wish to be on that board but I do not think there is any way to make sure that adverse decisions are made to my detriment [sic - presumably Mr Zdrilic meant to say "not to my detriment")]. Again the decisions need to be unanimous and secretary can be Renshall.
(8) Because the new company has only 27.75% shareholding there should be an agreement between the small shareholders and the 27.75% owners that no decision can be made at shareholder level without the agreement of the 27.75% shareholders or at least say 93% which basically means we all have to agree - not sure if this is possible.
(...) The important thing here from my point is to make sure that I am protected and that there is not something behind the scene where I can be adversely affected. Renshall has many small shareholder friends (...) In other words some sort of warranty needs to be given that there is not something there that I am not aware of that may impact on the agreement thereby adversely affecting me".
300As I have mentioned, Mr Zdrilic gave an account of the 15 February 2004 meeting in his affidavit. However, it was different from his email in two important ways.
301First, in the email Mr Zdrilic said that the board decisions of HTT "need to be unanimous". He did not assert in the email that Mr Renshall had agreed to this. In his affidavit account of the conversation Mr Zdrilic said that he had proposed unanimity and that Mr Renshall had simply said "yes that is fine".
|
[
-0.02092966064810753,
0.029478561133146286,
-0.026098385453224182,
0.0261370912194252,
-0.013312931172549725,
-0.04428625851869583,
0.0064024245366454124,
-0.05581725016236305,
-0.013310762122273445,
0.02183731272816658,
-0.010963293723762035,
0.02337292954325676,
0.00851947907358408,
-0.006431817542761564,
-0.05389031022787094,
-0.03168094530701637,
0.04935596138238907,
-0.03897383064031601,
0.003359111724421382,
-0.01224550325423479,
-0.014974821358919144,
-0.017080314457416534,
-0.01649741642177105,
0.029206890612840652,
0.0005653029656969011,
-0.011693147011101246,
-0.023627959191799164,
0.04813001677393913,
0.04524357616901398,
0.01942875050008297,
0.012041141279041767,
0.006302846595644951,
0.01083044707775116,
-0.008493637666106224,
0.016506873071193695,
-0.004133355338126421,
0.0226731114089489,
-0.017328856512904167,
-0.02653662860393524,
0.018747465685009956,
-0.01924886181950569,
-0.008208573795855045,
-0.02053692750632763,
-0.01644871197640896,
0.042709916830062866,
-0.014692051336169243,
-0.002667393069714308,
-0.02408408746123314,
0.00939654279500246,
0.00883141253143549,
-0.033491041511297226,
-0.030644502490758896,
0.024173906072974205,
-0.01610044576227665,
-0.016073603183031082,
0.02848759852349758,
-0.02383246459066868,
0.017608879134058952,
-0.033353209495544434,
0.001453392906114459,
0.0037420769222080708,
0.003116590902209282,
-0.04665166512131691,
-0.000042867079173447564,
-0.0010555435437709093,
0.10821010917425156,
0.015358222648501396,
-0.022946797311306,
0.012883736751973629,
-0.03801440820097923,
-0.061889395117759705,
0.002752067055553198,
-0.053423650562763214,
-0.007395581807941198,
-0.08947326987981796,
0.01200408861041069,
0.04029413312673569,
0.007597135845571756,
0.030300965532660484,
0.03726151958107948,
0.03523639217019081,
-0.020233891904354095,
0.001529694302007556,
0.03947754576802254,
-0.005276666954159737,
0.046259451657533646,
-0.00021075039694551378,
0.06593441218137741,
0.015274333767592907,
-0.014323323033750057,
-0.005517048295587301,
-0.008430708199739456,
0.01858648844063282,
-0.048411812633275986,
-0.0005815376061946154,
0.004988526459783316,
-0.06655871123075485,
0.01724155806005001,
-0.015058651566505432,
0.025707272812724113,
0.001564057427458465,
0.0030828663147985935,
-0.029817797243595123,
-0.0613403245806694,
-0.030965087935328484,
0.049580685794353485,
0.04420221969485283,
0.021645262837409973,
-0.007523193024098873,
-0.004820242058485746,
-0.008104351349174976,
-0.007526866160333157,
-0.018457401543855667,
0.0036207346711307764,
-0.021522561088204384,
-0.013913318514823914,
-0.010205855593085289,
0.010009515099227428,
0.049880389124155045,
0.01676759123802185,
0.06362265348434448,
0.03805799037218094,
0.026097649708390236,
-0.04008563980460167,
-0.045604363083839417,
0.027654660865664482,
0.011122452095150948,
0.008581777103245258,
-0.02107233554124832,
0.005597448442131281,
0.014517073519527912,
-0.00014487402222584933,
-0.03236514702439308,
-0.04560959339141846,
0.009140233509242535,
-0.024480275809764862,
0.012349460273981094,
-0.026702294126152992,
0.013495362363755703,
-0.07940606772899628,
0.053074371069669724,
0.021248772740364075,
0.00015149565297178924,
-0.048371508717536926,
0.009349536150693893,
-0.06233970820903778,
0.0006477263523265719,
0.004439814016222954,
0.005875118542462587,
0.007681653369218111,
0.021276002749800682,
0.0130111463367939,
0.002888425486162305,
-0.010939651168882847,
0.03354823961853981,
-0.04985314980149269,
0.019795550033450127,
-0.015169893391430378,
0.04427103325724602,
0.07959486544132233,
-0.012434585019946098,
0.020644038915634155,
-0.019694529473781586,
-0.013574638403952122,
-0.019108621403574944,
0.021246127784252167,
-0.00038978984230197966,
0.03546679764986038,
-0.00887305662035942,
-0.001013567904010415,
0.008993793278932571,
-0.05243309959769249,
0.09134382754564285,
0.003515396500006318,
-0.02716260589659214,
0.013361603952944279,
0.0784972608089447,
0.0058747511357069016,
-0.0032584057189524174,
-0.037885189056396484,
-0.04105411469936371,
0.04849127680063248,
0.010368306189775467,
-0.04430016130208969,
-0.03616175428032875,
-0.003970165271311998,
-0.02398168295621872,
-0.012506195344030857,
-0.01007459033280611,
0.019701514393091202,
-0.008192782290279865,
0.009636412374675274,
0.018075641244649887,
0.05423980951309204,
0.0055606006644666195,
0.01045706495642662,
0.009354512207210064,
-0.04435460641980171,
-0.0009547616937197745,
0.00732168834656477,
-0.04821746051311493,
0.0013400845928117633,
0.07805278152227402,
-0.03414861112833023,
-0.004428395070135593,
0.016444748267531395,
-0.010249648243188858,
0.006814584601670504,
-0.018055910244584084,
-0.02389519475400448,
-0.03129791468381882,
0.013233371078968048,
-0.01785331405699253,
-0.012742881663143635,
-0.004857184831053019,
-0.02787713147699833,
-0.017964491620659828,
-0.027065441012382507,
0.010240936651825905,
-0.0249309241771698,
-0.015062852762639523,
0.009393053129315376,
0.005802332889288664,
0.008784990757703781,
0.028538215905427933,
0.052658528089523315,
-0.06877876073122025,
0.018924878910183907,
-0.026116466149687767,
-0.012207857333123684,
-0.025654733180999756,
-0.015543092042207718,
0.0028848855290561914,
-0.02465338259935379,
0.019867505878210068,
0.05889929458498955,
-0.004068940877914429,
0.022779013961553574,
0.02238677628338337,
0.007206303533166647,
-0.04171152412891388,
0.018309658393263817,
0.02235574647784233,
0.00036292962613515556,
-0.022012023255228996,
0.028365660458803177,
-0.010089704766869545,
0.02202974073588848,
0.020269274711608887,
-0.02365942671895027,
-0.007427521515637636,
0.013741771690547466,
-0.010126756504178047,
-0.008363657630980015,
0.0019209875026717782,
0.03625432401895523,
-0.01564890146255493,
0.004073925781995058,
0.01938033476471901,
0.015842095017433167,
0.014054041355848312,
0.0015974401030689478,
0.03085303120315075,
0.019458457827568054,
0.00505077326670289,
0.0076685878448188305,
-0.0005676706205122173,
-0.04610560089349747,
0.03242376446723938,
0.007116514723747969,
0.008607654832303524,
-0.009386541321873665,
0.026407038792967796,
0.009893816895782948,
-0.010568510740995407,
-0.006946641020476818,
0.010624160058796406,
-0.01966923475265503,
0.011111552827060223,
0.04018193110823631,
0.04069453477859497,
0.015297270379960537,
0.05899461358785629,
-0.017014281824231148,
0.02186061441898346,
0.04146943613886833,
-0.023002685979008675,
0.017051540315151215,
0.03386472538113594,
-0.05139252915978432,
-0.00014267330698203295,
0.020357737317681313,
0.0610351525247097,
-0.010143508203327656,
-0.042275071144104004,
-0.02992640808224678,
-0.028957445174455643,
-0.1580696851015091,
-0.03567569702863693,
-0.05091436207294464,
0.009043301455676556,
0.002166840946301818,
-0.007158329244703054,
-0.02916654199361801,
0.0066381036303937435,
-0.05265054851770401,
0.004312990698963404,
0.005230472423136234,
-0.03973643481731415,
-0.0020123240537941456,
0.05135996267199516,
0.033811796456575394,
-0.028420956805348396,
0.005609204526990652,
0.00971959251910448,
0.006546564865857363,
-0.014319831505417824,
-0.011749018914997578,
-0.058845482766628265,
0.07144931703805923,
0.006537514738738537,
0.050665631890296936,
0.01186977606266737,
0.04543719440698624,
0.04701540246605873,
-0.04809674620628357,
0.0030149484518915415,
0.017033612355589867,
0.03503204882144928,
-0.014376722276210785,
0.004113523289561272,
0.011105789802968502,
0.01818765699863434,
0.056683436036109924,
-0.041026320308446884,
-0.01965983770787716,
-0.0020997016690671444,
0.02259400486946106,
0.00215066852979362,
0.03487565368413925,
0.004534207750111818,
-0.000639880308881402,
-0.0506800077855587,
-0.00025155095499940217,
0.004335359670221806,
-0.006189371924847364,
0.030412649735808372,
-0.017156481742858887,
0.01751139387488365,
-0.013200798071920872,
-0.03551347181200981,
-0.0054109361954033375,
-0.018272850662469864,
0.032881006598472595,
0.017853308469057083,
-0.04243232309818268,
-0.027017394080758095,
-0.025274991989135742,
-0.04215133562684059,
0.01669394224882126,
0.007098247297108173,
0.0035500521771609783,
0.006765137426555157,
0.005246198736131191,
-0.02565877139568329,
0.02757476456463337,
0.03268672525882721,
0.014666947536170483,
-0.019432494416832924,
-0.0007206329610198736,
-0.010208570398390293,
0.012080011889338493,
0.025033140555024147,
-0.0383727103471756,
0.010831700637936592,
-0.012431098148226738,
-0.10121548920869827,
-0.001577827613800764,
0.025729183107614517,
-0.03275858238339424,
0.0034719782415777445,
0.008696859702467918,
0.027172541245818138,
-0.000871865195222199,
0.034834638237953186,
-0.0017599768470972776,
0.25375983119010925,
0.020038383081555367,
0.025477547198534012,
-0.009132005274295807,
0.04221649095416069,
-0.02340802177786827,
0.030917370691895485,
0.04718923941254616,
-0.01621825620532036,
-0.0322984978556633,
-0.0009361904812976718,
0.004174179397523403,
0.0508691780269146,
0.012395037338137627,
-0.004786743316799402,
-0.0016486693639308214,
-0.07915286719799042,
-0.011688814498484135,
0.05685887858271599,
0.013087662868201733,
0.07897452265024185,
-0.0005610017105937004,
0.0071541257202625275,
0.011458293534815311,
-0.04439428821206093,
-0.029989732429385185,
0.029541566967964172,
0.030026007443666458,
-0.056521907448768616,
0.04269585758447647,
-0.025978511199355125,
-0.002334863878786564,
0.04060600325465202,
-0.0018392358906567097,
0.014492635615170002,
0.006608073599636555,
-0.02032174915075302,
-0.008759771473705769,
0.028698695823550224,
0.02453380636870861,
-0.013483816757798195,
-0.05405408516526222,
0.014785733073949814,
-0.04648762196302414,
-0.023470070213079453,
0.01267043873667717,
-0.05252717807888985,
0.03876936063170433,
-0.009587270207703114,
-0.0018901145085692406,
0.02549358457326889,
0.015644116327166557,
-0.030444473028182983,
-0.011268249712884426,
-0.016810372471809387,
0.04166077449917793,
-0.017987562343478203,
0.010210939683020115,
0.01724781095981598,
0.016192471608519554,
0.017339883372187614,
0.031154800206422806,
-0.03855141997337341,
0.015114869922399521,
-0.008091389201581478,
-0.03320949152112007,
-0.07327857613563538,
-0.0074889943934977055,
0.05788267403841019,
0.0454624705016613,
0.043139249086380005,
0.04293297976255417,
-0.0017699066083878279,
0.0247948057949543,
0.03271201252937317,
-0.019922345876693726,
-0.04233803227543831,
0.01472512912005186,
-0.01676519587635994,
-0.003142197383567691,
-0.013490273617208004,
-0.04009122774004936,
-0.024282924830913544,
0.013355678878724575,
0.009359770454466343,
-0.0009504267363809049,
-0.06463106721639633,
0.0525706447660923,
-0.027965527027845383,
-0.001017992035485804,
-0.018416402861475945,
0.009505124762654305,
-0.0027806120924651623,
-0.021741218864917755,
0.004596177488565445,
-0.024005325511097908,
0.012118835002183914,
-0.004118603188544512,
-0.03692590817809105,
-0.03901740536093712,
-0.00488649494946003,
0.005885065533220768,
0.0063045434653759,
-0.02641548216342926,
0.031657230108976364,
0.036740489304065704,
-0.015579941682517529,
0.02153461053967476,
-0.0422019436955452,
0.011283230036497116,
-0.017245478928089142,
0.011684083379805088,
0.004898733925074339,
0.019145948812365532,
0.025847433134913445,
0.05590173602104187,
0.009033390320837498,
0.08205588907003403,
0.03490965813398361,
-0.0008611392113380134,
-0.005343640688806772,
0.013354826718568802,
-0.059918321669101715,
-0.00879322923719883,
0.011435071937739849,
0.002376153599470854,
0.024393795058131218,
0.019062651321291924,
0.016310447826981544,
-0.011037083342671394,
-0.02211897075176239,
-0.04378735274076462,
-0.026196926832199097,
-0.009910468012094498,
0.035858411341905594,
0.03102300502359867,
-0.009466229937970638,
0.007387581747025251,
-0.05644764378666878,
0.029176274314522743,
-0.05715084820985794,
0.0028905286453664303,
-0.020826883614063263,
-0.04491549730300903,
-0.013337893411517143,
0.015750424936413765,
-0.05599858984351158,
0.004589955322444439,
-0.0652189627289772,
0.009780842810869217,
-0.003446189919486642,
-0.001545149483717978,
-0.06916763633489609,
-0.05239473655819893,
-0.015673605725169182,
0.0035214938689023256,
-0.012283934280276299,
-0.005348727572709322,
0.057541921734809875,
-0.036431875079870224,
-0.009367870166897774,
0.028323929756879807,
0.01137953344732523,
0.03582704812288284,
0.02663978934288025,
0.0732112005352974,
0.01793840155005455,
0.07920674979686737,
0.006515377201139927,
-0.01698186807334423,
-0.018865099176764488,
-0.06291401386260986,
-0.01812163181602955,
0.04719531536102295,
0.042154472321271896,
0.0056940484791994095,
0.039855215698480606,
0.00261575891636312,
-0.0077804988250136375,
0.001398009597323835,
0.05626798793673515,
0.011545036919414997,
-0.035923536866903305,
0.033731408417224884,
0.011386462487280369,
0.015397917479276657,
-0.003202779684215784,
-0.023452455177903175,
0.07509876787662506,
-0.06706416606903076,
-0.01594933308660984,
0.0562962107360363,
0.018731603398919106,
-0.007636466529220343,
-0.014029266312718391,
0.013362103141844273,
-0.02261851355433464,
0.032408587634563446,
-0.04778777435421944,
-0.02487376146018505,
0.0006280960515141487,
0.0007455656304955482,
0.017977707087993622,
-0.02216080017387867,
0.02582455240190029,
-0.01221027784049511,
-0.02943161502480507,
0.04247860610485077,
-0.028243310749530792,
0.0039550792425870895,
0.04188475012779236,
0.0239810049533844,
-0.026620106771588326,
0.019556637853384018,
-0.0046289036981761456,
-0.03105052001774311,
0.0021524238400161266,
0.0537334680557251,
-0.0023343260399997234,
-0.022980740293860435,
-0.017877239733934402,
-0.021781858056783676,
0.035087209194898605,
-0.04377030208706856,
-0.015581230632960796,
0.025824571028351784,
-0.062070731073617935,
-0.0018165805377066135,
-0.01660339906811714,
0.008204998448491096,
0.0004775869019795209,
-0.054935622960329056,
0.09450455009937286,
-0.06418105214834213,
0.013763229362666607,
0.0071998415514826775,
0.045904677361249924,
-0.01576230302453041,
0.01589357852935791,
-0.03748858720064163,
0.04433223232626915,
0.005884517449885607,
0.037697143852710724,
0.0013080753851681948,
-0.01956605724990368,
0.012793046422302723,
-0.01895737089216709,
0.013547186739742756,
0.007394562941044569,
0.04067253693938255,
-0.009754003956913948,
0.008930524811148643,
-0.0020949665922671556,
-0.029090793803334236,
-0.009717443957924843,
-0.0018525113118812442,
0.0034592528827488422,
-0.029145775362849236,
-0.020427845418453217,
-0.056896086782217026,
0.007745474111288786,
-0.0011133577208966017,
0.016809571534395218,
-0.0392114594578743,
-0.06704020500183105,
-0.05979083478450775,
0.0249724593013525,
-0.01891021430492401,
-0.027041025459766388,
0.0018760411767289042,
-0.017514226958155632,
-0.0055841743014752865,
-0.005681632552295923,
-0.028254255652427673,
-0.009775091893970966,
-0.006033504381775856,
-0.03643130511045456,
-0.0315265916287899,
0.016853487119078636,
0.005879967473447323,
-0.008037075400352478,
0.0014540390111505985,
0.02939443103969097,
0.01432658452540636,
-0.025861142203211784,
0.02512950822710991,
-0.002467919373884797,
-0.015050769783556461,
-0.007079747039824724,
0.0035980558022856712,
-0.02855672687292099,
-0.011971160769462585,
-0.023724913597106934,
0.021352723240852356,
-0.010881530120968819,
-0.024758512154221535,
-0.02007696032524109,
0.040768079459667206,
-0.02644512616097927,
0.0011713425628840923,
-0.029060034081339836,
-0.0008612459059804678,
-0.0350838340818882,
-0.018935294821858406,
-0.036145731806755066,
0.008314887061715126,
0.0005042635602876544,
0.00874210987240076,
-0.03780794516205788,
-0.002342846477404237,
0.03130141273140907,
-0.07105875760316849,
-0.0029888537246733904,
-0.0012901762966066599,
0.04189804196357727,
-0.007022767327725887,
0.04114222526550293,
-0.0014768863329663873,
-0.04615968465805054,
-0.014324532821774483,
0.008467338979244232,
-0.00299884588457644,
-0.05679436773061752,
-0.003923536743968725,
-0.04012570530176163,
0.02266131527721882,
-0.007499006111174822,
-0.040042463690042496,
-0.014706609770655632,
0.01350306160748005,
-0.014391987584531307,
0.0014020944945514202,
0.011378294788300991,
-0.011272047646343708,
0.03403780236840248,
0.020642710849642754,
-0.009479744359850883,
-0.0056367418728768826,
0.024944251403212547,
-0.037260934710502625,
-0.0347285158932209,
-0.05201691761612892,
0.06512446701526642,
-0.02004864625632763,
-0.008033840917050838,
0.019085751846432686,
0.00011137140973005444,
0.018280472606420517,
0.0390685610473156,
0.012403802946209908,
-0.019026126712560654,
0.020926248282194138,
-0.002891623182222247,
-0.028202103450894356,
-0.013700012117624283,
0.007160802371799946,
-0.026655886322259903,
0.01263777632266283,
0.03533288463950157,
-0.028757896274328232,
0.0019019434694200754,
0.044493526220321655,
0.043995313346385956,
0.0021378137171268463,
-0.011682340875267982,
-0.028411749750375748,
0.014573486521840096,
0.015402192249894142,
-0.008342735469341278,
0.042561646550893784,
0.03161666542291641,
-0.009959487244486809,
0.01096426323056221,
0.003785700537264347,
-0.05219822749495506,
0.03347541391849518,
0.021384667605161667,
0.02510489709675312,
-0.01504850946366787,
-0.09085136651992798,
0.01592797413468361,
-0.050651077181100845,
-0.021814456209540367,
-0.025607384741306305,
0.032040491700172424,
-0.01698840968310833,
-0.006343110930174589,
0.020213723182678223,
0.03353167325258255,
-0.0031969400588423014,
-0.01029269490391016,
0.042313575744628906,
-0.007619247306138277,
-0.029441198334097862,
-0.1465427577495575,
-0.009135651402175426,
-0.014733201824128628,
-0.028490271419286728,
-0.0074920798651874065,
0.013876831158995628,
-0.009460460394620895,
0.025485267862677574,
-0.0161289069801569,
0.007666809484362602,
-0.022889195010066032,
-0.03051610104739666,
0.02615288645029068,
-0.025554029271006584,
-0.04144790768623352,
0.012838119640946388,
-0.04122486710548401,
-0.002563188085332513,
-0.06178247183561325,
0.05962444841861725,
0.004917279351502657,
-0.0007348523358814418,
-0.015480000525712967,
-0.0008182437741197646,
0.01978546753525734,
0.002527515171095729,
0.007592076901346445,
-0.035653822124004364,
-0.0332648865878582,
-0.026510076597332954,
-0.027170952409505844,
0.03664430230855942,
0.01474014762789011,
0.053665924817323685,
-0.01784186065196991,
0.002945147454738617,
0.013089899905025959,
-0.025696154683828354,
0.010731136426329613,
-0.02069779857993126,
0.008647403679788113,
0.04818158224225044,
-0.020669957622885704,
-0.0380045548081398,
-0.009231260046362877,
0.008195130154490471,
-0.003292735666036606,
0.0035747180227190256,
-0.04155215993523598,
-0.034815967082977295,
-0.02259826473891735,
0.002081609331071377,
0.004220175091177225,
0.06537137180566788,
-0.029095670208334923,
-0.015879251062870026,
0.0027086809277534485,
-0.03996704891324043,
0.05835054814815521,
0.057548992335796356,
-0.005209443625062704,
0.013906474225223064,
-0.042939443141222,
0.01087791658937931,
-0.04764234647154808,
0.005673103500157595,
-0.03318442404270172,
-0.02135639265179634,
-0.01933227851986885,
-0.003948903642594814,
-0.03148013725876808,
-0.009485742077231407,
0.023362310603260994,
-0.03908267617225647,
0.015878921374678612,
-0.02547788806259632,
-0.008505117148160934,
0.006394721567630768,
-0.048333439975976944,
-0.01793537847697735,
0.002397374017164111,
0.029161008074879646,
-0.0727115347981453,
-0.003303883131593466,
0.058234378695487976,
0.05058515444397926,
0.012158701196312904,
-0.0426219180226326,
-0.0015641289064660668,
-0.030014459043741226,
-0.04492213577032089,
-0.014405719935894012,
0.00003381337955943309,
0.03533659502863884,
-0.006431993562728167,
0.05695147067308426,
0.0014711281983181834,
-0.009099699556827545,
0.0028825709596276283,
0.0009280899539589882,
-0.053508371114730835,
-0.013584032654762268,
0.0029431951697915792,
-0.021982653066515923,
-0.019994433969259262,
-0.03848426416516304,
0.04919647052884102,
-0.013117126189172268,
0.003125445917248726,
-0.02974615804851055,
0.02921321801841259,
-0.021429752930998802,
-0.05082511156797409,
0.045886535197496414,
-0.01963771879673004,
0.005740527994930744,
-0.0015687887789681554,
-0.015466669574379921,
0.026823654770851135,
0.00016597162175457925,
0.03085409849882126,
-0.0033107693307101727,
-0.0002276292216265574,
-0.01883978396654129,
0.013113145716488361,
0.003170953830704093,
0.05216434970498085,
0.03371930494904518,
0.011526376008987427,
0.005342179909348488,
0.009896301664412022,
-0.02991154044866562,
0.004251147620379925,
0.01704292930662632,
-0.00966944731771946,
0.0017913359915837646,
-0.007617609109729528,
0.005192555487155914,
-0.04029984772205353,
-0.007521010469645262,
0.0015404544537886977,
0.025763608515262604,
-0.012446580454707146,
0.010061296634376049,
-0.04409302398562431,
0.012339690700173378,
0.008078769780695438,
-0.00927352998405695,
-0.013948281295597553,
-0.011102787218987942,
-0.024267157539725304,
0.010823840275406837,
-0.02247118018567562,
0.025900188833475113,
0.035308852791786194,
0.023843374103307724,
0.02921968884766102,
-0.009920087642967701,
0.04666139557957649,
0.06837974488735199,
0.026704568415880203,
-0.03991654887795448,
-0.05990546569228172,
-0.07733142375946045,
-0.03298855200409889,
0.04599178582429886,
-0.003200242295861244,
-0.0020839101634919643,
-0.02048480324447155,
-0.012508368119597435,
-0.012987124733626842,
-0.006215455010533333,
-0.0044941590167582035,
-0.007017247844487429,
0.03930577263236046,
-0.024417974054813385,
-0.014445409178733826,
0.009459379129111767,
0.057852182537317276,
-0.02932693436741829,
0.045279473066329956,
0.049325622618198395,
0.027800336480140686,
-0.017813190817832947,
0.027244649827480316,
0.0361054390668869,
0.019639426842331886,
0.02008901908993721,
0.013823265209794044,
-0.047348398715257645,
-0.020602621138095856,
-0.0039931065402925014,
0.04081053286790848,
0.004055455327033997,
0.02499522641301155,
0.0379616878926754,
-0.017994841560721397,
0.02069774642586708,
0.010426119901239872,
0.023739993572235107,
-0.011228600516915321,
-0.0038757515139877796,
-0.02610863745212555,
-0.0036058861296623945,
-0.019232818856835365,
0.02458960749208927,
-0.004879250191152096,
-0.04443466663360596,
-0.05117267370223999,
0.05569958686828613,
-0.034025516360998154,
0.012830969877541065,
0.008935725316405296,
0.028754493221640587,
0.004154338035732508,
0.023698871955275536,
0.017144059762358665,
-0.02643931657075882,
0.02960732951760292,
-0.048318859189748764,
0.028429148718714714,
0.02851739153265953,
-0.018502578139305115,
-0.03140833228826523,
0.00587176438421011,
-0.013674141839146614,
-0.03792060166597366,
0.0033098715357482433,
0.012353290803730488,
0.05641142651438713,
-0.054850708693265915,
0.009075681678950787,
-0.01427612453699112,
0.034036148339509964,
0.0025196752976626158,
-0.02221210114657879,
-0.008604941889643669,
-0.01880239136517048,
-0.012357974424958229,
-0.006886772811412811,
0.06712229549884796,
0.026128290221095085,
0.00016551207227166742,
-0.036232203245162964
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:33
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
487Otherwise, the circumstances as revealed to Mr Zdrilic throughout March to May 2004 must have made clear to him that HTT's dealings with the proposed funder were at a stage where HTT could do no more than promise, as it did in clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement, that it would, within an unspecified time in the future, obtain finance from "a new" funder.
488At the time of entering into the Heads of Agreement, Mr Zdrilic knew that, faced with a threat from GPC to appoint a receiver, HTT was obliged to resort to an expensive, short term loan from DTC.
489Mr Zdrilic also knew that HTT had made, or was about to resort to even more expensive, term borrowings, over an even shorter term from Ms Goncalves and Frenkail.
490In my opinion, it must have been obvious to Mr Zdrilic from those circumstances, and from the terms of clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement itself (that HTT "shall obtain" funding estimated at $12 million from the unnamed "new funder"), that it was entirely up in the air whether any such funding would be forthcoming.
491I find that the plaintiffs were not induced to enter the Heads of Agreement by reason of any of the Second to Ninth Representations.
First "proof of funds" letter
492On 24 May 2004, Mr Renshall wrote the first of a series of letters which the parties have referred to as the "proof of funds letters".
493On HTT letterhead, Mr Renshall wrote to Mr Moir:-
"I have been asking since signing the JV agreement for IBIS to give us something to show they can complete this deal. I believe we have been very patient in this regard".
494Mr Renshall agreed that, at no time, did he tell Mr Zdrilic about this, or any of the subsequent "proof of funds" letters.
26 May 2004 - Tenth Representation
495This is the first alleged representation to be made after entry into the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement.
496The representation alleged is:-
"That the new funder would advance funds to HTT in about one month's time to enable HTT to refinance its current high interest loans in the total sum of approximately $9 million."
497The representation is alleged to have arisen from a conversation between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall in which, according to Mr Zdrilic, Mr Renshall said:-
"The big funder will replace the expensive loans in about one month's time".
498On 26 May 2004, Mr Zdrilic made a note that recorded Mr Renshall saying words to this effect.
499Mr Renshall did not dispute making this statement.
500Whatever basis Mr Renshall may have had for making this statement, it was quickly overtaken by events.
501On 5 June 2004, Mr Hilliard had a conversation with Mr Gillard in which he enquired as to when Mr Zdrilic could "have a meeting with the funder".
502According to Mr Hilliard's note, Mr Gillard's response was that such a meeting could take place "once the documents are signed off" and that:-
"We don't want what has been negotiated with the funder to be undone by [Mr Zdrilic]".
16-18 June 2004 - Eleventh Representation
503This representation is that the shares and units held by the "little" shareholders and unit holders in the Huntley Trust (which held a 71.34 per cent interest in the Project) would be transferred to the new funder in the near future.
504The representation is said to derive, first, from a letter Mr Gillard sent Mr Hilliard on 16 June 2004 in which he said:-
"No 'remaining small shareholders' elected to continue participating in the project and the remaining shareholding and unitholding will be taken up by the financier in the near future".
505The representation is also said to derive from a conversation Mr Zdrilic said he had with Mr Renshall. Mr Zdrilic made a note (which was signed by Mr Renshall "sighted as agreed") in which it was stated that "what would happen later when financier comes in" was that Sentel would hold 28.66 per cent of the shares in HTT and that the "funder" would hold the remaining 71.34 per cent.
|
[
-0.013390137813985348,
0.06492255628108978,
-0.004701655823737383,
0.0054703098721802235,
-0.020354874432086945,
-0.022829696536064148,
0.009864890947937965,
-0.036088429391384125,
-0.0155099555850029,
0.01194587629288435,
0.008767243474721909,
0.022359706461429596,
-0.039055224508047104,
0.018969407305121422,
-0.028968941420316696,
-0.01851457729935646,
0.05117133632302284,
-0.0038692059461027384,
0.021702362224459648,
-0.021734612062573433,
-0.006456813775002956,
-0.024512216448783875,
-0.026606516912579536,
0.02930818870663643,
-0.014613221399486065,
0.002702467842027545,
-0.06005452945828438,
0.023665927350521088,
0.040273282676935196,
0.02647489309310913,
0.012277304194867611,
0.008025690913200378,
0.03340715542435646,
0.006516595836728811,
0.004613263066858053,
-0.00703876418992877,
0.012431887909770012,
0.012717420235276222,
-0.03806562349200249,
0.019688675180077553,
-0.01628761738538742,
0.02415546588599682,
0.020068811252713203,
-0.011292573995888233,
0.05378430336713791,
-0.04220251366496086,
0.0101422518491745,
-0.02238895744085312,
0.013848516158759594,
0.020126676186919212,
-0.03328226879239082,
-0.03590898588299751,
0.032146841287612915,
-0.029582444578409195,
-0.01485748216509819,
-0.02420986443758011,
-0.027545632794499397,
-0.005561365745961666,
-0.020942339673638344,
0.0007378117297776043,
0.014938791282474995,
-0.008509034290909767,
-0.09043515473604202,
0.0021342202089726925,
-0.011980297975242138,
0.10764145851135254,
-0.00048120261635631323,
0.0003111748374067247,
0.008162090554833412,
0.006073787342756987,
-0.04950467497110367,
-0.005249327514320612,
-0.041200075298547745,
0.008423112332820892,
-0.09599311649799347,
0.00143889628816396,
0.028278516605496407,
0.006378789432346821,
0.031370654702186584,
0.04812578111886978,
0.057899147272109985,
-0.007054605986922979,
-0.011397894471883774,
0.004751618020236492,
-0.012944013811647892,
0.020182432606816292,
-0.005173580255359411,
0.020035287365317345,
0.026857366785407066,
-0.02460738644003868,
0.008140855468809605,
0.013839875347912312,
0.014104077592492104,
-0.050108976662158966,
0.009973336942493916,
0.015393619425594807,
-0.058525435626506805,
0.031373631209135056,
0.012767958454787731,
0.035082995891571045,
0.0015063208993524313,
0.027611857280135155,
-0.030070045962929726,
-0.022040318697690964,
-0.0005669202655553818,
0.02561144158244133,
0.07909822463989258,
0.04511599987745285,
-0.01047510839998722,
-0.007206745445728302,
-0.016755908727645874,
0.0008983137086033821,
-0.00013842087355442345,
0.02425524592399597,
-0.01656303182244301,
0.005250581074506044,
-0.011930160224437714,
-0.008423065766692162,
0.028278818354010582,
-0.00523753697052598,
0.04824080318212509,
0.016151873394846916,
0.024555018171668053,
-0.026880735531449318,
-0.05075300112366676,
-0.018745433539152145,
-0.009876464493572712,
0.0010846073273569345,
0.019653549417853355,
0.028495395556092262,
-0.009018320590257645,
0.023442458361387253,
-0.0011570656206458807,
-0.03210555762052536,
-0.004462237004190683,
-0.0014801231445744634,
0.013908066786825657,
-0.02778240665793419,
0.015129701234400272,
-0.039893295615911484,
0.03812067210674286,
0.023701205849647522,
0.00381519109942019,
-0.05798834562301636,
0.0050842659547924995,
-0.05004030466079712,
-0.007269932422786951,
-0.00252419407479465,
0.01870626024901867,
0.05056624859571457,
0.00381859322078526,
-0.012752840295433998,
0.02687789313495159,
-0.004083078354597092,
-0.0063247703947126865,
-0.01561176311224699,
0.005063137970864773,
-0.08117382973432541,
0.025073392316699028,
0.08041748404502869,
-0.02450617402791977,
0.01394987665116787,
0.005419733468443155,
-0.07038707286119461,
-0.012682984583079815,
0.015924084931612015,
0.01905084401369095,
0.014890521764755249,
-0.02043434977531433,
0.009552080184221268,
0.03219583258032799,
-0.021605180576443672,
0.08846453577280045,
0.01577647216618061,
0.004447351209819317,
0.025095993652939796,
0.0423782616853714,
0.0029201176948845387,
0.013897618278861046,
-0.004170310217887163,
-0.03281320258975029,
0.052459754049777985,
0.01858442649245262,
-0.01354931015521288,
-0.043737590312957764,
-0.005474558565765619,
-0.021982984617352486,
-0.037349313497543335,
-0.011492297984659672,
0.03335968777537346,
-0.01851922832429409,
0.00948550458997488,
0.01950785145163536,
0.04409657418727875,
0.019467072561383247,
-0.01494651474058628,
0.022980906069278717,
-0.04688481241464615,
-0.021994944661855698,
0.00020105800649616867,
-0.03057822398841381,
0.011509985662996769,
0.06126978248357773,
-0.04675024747848511,
-0.03067978285253048,
0.018694203346967697,
-0.018942279741168022,
0.0028905037324875593,
-0.019577743485569954,
-0.061698198318481445,
-0.013049103319644928,
-0.010649359785020351,
0.0017577080288901925,
-0.023688623681664467,
0.011852691881358624,
-0.01963658444583416,
0.02691059187054634,
-0.01539610605686903,
0.010092143900692463,
-0.04494587704539299,
-0.0012380019761621952,
0.008369414135813713,
-0.0032221900764852762,
0.014157263562083244,
0.017451884225010872,
0.03281537815928459,
-0.08181069046258926,
0.0268609207123518,
-0.031882040202617645,
-0.02043427899479866,
-0.0330510288476944,
-0.023869816213846207,
0.01067359559237957,
-0.0032447767443954945,
0.02989208698272705,
0.06394089013338089,
0.01478191651403904,
-0.0008031998295336962,
0.029511485248804092,
-0.004789954982697964,
-0.005978171247988939,
0.014605983160436153,
-0.023737899959087372,
0.009804509580135345,
-0.04216993227601051,
-0.01582498475909233,
-0.012485476210713387,
-0.0004487192491069436,
0.029776768758893013,
-0.0293894000351429,
-0.012765735387802124,
-0.002517679473385215,
-0.010453462600708008,
0.007293130271136761,
-0.023603564128279686,
0.033204276114702225,
-0.0003714060876518488,
0.00010004384239437059,
0.02222875878214836,
0.027742506936192513,
0.0226112212985754,
0.004285780247300863,
0.03353090211749077,
0.01849636808037758,
0.006224794313311577,
-0.002939637051895261,
-0.03655362129211426,
-0.07940524816513062,
0.051240019500255585,
-0.038258377462625504,
0.02975943125784397,
0.0009455968393012881,
0.016027210280299187,
0.035124439746141434,
0.01969868503510952,
0.02396790124475956,
0.007532522547990084,
-0.003457968356087804,
0.00562283955514431,
0.03662358224391937,
0.004087957087904215,
0.007430126424878836,
0.01701975241303444,
-0.015975872054696083,
0.031360071152448654,
0.04499219357967377,
-0.033866286277770996,
-0.022989973425865173,
0.01109720952808857,
-0.02294771559536457,
-0.020271196961402893,
0.03090079315006733,
0.062090661376714706,
-0.02580411359667778,
-0.08205131441354752,
-0.04043051600456238,
-0.03754729777574539,
-0.14398075640201569,
-0.0012793565401807427,
0.013886707834899426,
0.013651267625391483,
-0.008958768099546432,
0.020704327151179314,
-0.017354467883706093,
0.0026158480904996395,
-0.0487888939678669,
0.011638455092906952,
0.0015692319720983505,
-0.0424506850540638,
-0.025529684498906136,
0.02861691266298294,
0.030187983065843582,
-0.0008822482777759433,
-0.009267617017030716,
0.017387397587299347,
0.017322557047009468,
-0.014951588585972786,
0.03502320125699043,
-0.03986842557787895,
0.05249154567718506,
-0.0031457021832466125,
-0.0011002776445820928,
0.013248776085674763,
-0.003409484401345253,
0.054775170981884,
-0.05712965130805969,
0.014945179224014282,
-0.026225101202726364,
0.030458638444542885,
-0.025013064965605736,
0.03695882111787796,
-0.024916138499975204,
0.039527107030153275,
0.06711425632238388,
-0.052018944174051285,
-0.040961120277643204,
-0.037019308656454086,
0.031790345907211304,
0.05851966142654419,
0.008503565564751625,
0.012241816148161888,
0.008473563939332962,
-0.06346099823713303,
-0.002644245745614171,
-0.01551770605146885,
0.018341800197958946,
0.05022318288683891,
0.011008813977241516,
0.02565859630703926,
-0.035278595983982086,
-0.06924321502447128,
0.009281836450099945,
-0.030333006754517555,
0.049479685723781586,
0.006286230869591236,
-0.02953009307384491,
-0.03176748380064964,
-0.02062261290848255,
-0.07372075319290161,
0.00190142507199198,
0.024778379127383232,
-0.018761614337563515,
0.013074271380901337,
0.0016779121942818165,
-0.03677774593234062,
0.037941742688417435,
0.03846730664372444,
-0.00358489784412086,
-0.014073402620851994,
0.006738684605807066,
-0.008045612834393978,
0.04734289273619652,
0.030360927805304527,
-0.049815528094768524,
-0.00014480312529485673,
-0.02149837650358677,
-0.09058526158332825,
0.0020335970912128687,
0.04878246784210205,
-0.01026985328644514,
0.024218253791332245,
-0.01475828979164362,
0.020524324849247932,
0.03271634876728058,
0.0514691062271595,
-0.00029619759880006313,
0.26107245683670044,
-0.006761078257113695,
0.01929999701678753,
0.028165986761450768,
0.02289222553372383,
-0.03745739161968231,
0.005749760195612907,
0.050670113414525986,
0.0058805737644433975,
-0.04882936552166939,
-0.00012102710752515122,
0.009577066637575626,
0.024933110922574997,
0.026838283985853195,
-0.0224309004843235,
0.038583993911743164,
-0.038643382489681244,
-0.00798877701163292,
0.054528187960386276,
0.002756053116172552,
0.05566617101430893,
-0.0024050483480095863,
-0.0066780936904251575,
-0.007985370233654976,
-0.05070849135518074,
-0.021737035363912582,
0.029338020831346512,
0.04334793612360954,
-0.03149450197815895,
-0.014043317176401615,
-0.0167005006223917,
0.004620224703103304,
0.043867453932762146,
-0.004271779675036669,
0.021756611764431,
0.02568495087325573,
-0.02196250669658184,
0.026720115914940834,
0.003077011089771986,
0.053251877427101135,
-0.020740609616041183,
-0.038066934794187546,
-0.002563789952546358,
-0.039742931723594666,
-0.025050371885299683,
0.019236523658037186,
-0.029505031183362007,
0.007407219614833593,
-0.014886632561683655,
-0.0032353003043681383,
0.013871146366000175,
0.032488156110048294,
-0.02901913784444332,
-0.00857278611510992,
-0.015874266624450684,
0.05246627703309059,
-0.019345877692103386,
0.05853945389389992,
0.03795340284705162,
0.03579448163509369,
0.028211699798703194,
0.0482979454100132,
-0.05254889279603958,
0.03519803285598755,
0.007905068807303905,
-0.03724838048219681,
-0.05375605821609497,
-0.04164119437336922,
0.04313557967543602,
0.031149961054325104,
0.02671145647764206,
0.014587451703846455,
-0.01755852811038494,
-0.01662910357117653,
0.03741190582513809,
-0.049279723316431046,
-0.022128937765955925,
-0.01331697404384613,
-0.029771603643894196,
-0.008547664619982243,
-0.016351107507944107,
-0.03667483851313591,
-0.02911960519850254,
0.03840086609125137,
0.03437183052301407,
0.009755680337548256,
-0.01992732845246792,
0.009985051117837429,
-0.03169630095362663,
-0.015722069889307022,
-0.020750079303979874,
-0.005505837965756655,
0.006255587097257376,
-0.03591594845056534,
-0.032290492206811905,
-0.01117278728634119,
0.004192689899355173,
-0.0011125897290185094,
-0.047347430139780045,
-0.049152541905641556,
0.008002059534192085,
-0.007884244434535503,
0.016828201711177826,
-0.042524904012680054,
0.010880486108362675,
0.0182266253978014,
-0.013784599490463734,
0.010188823565840721,
-0.0514337494969368,
0.009996715001761913,
-0.010745519772171974,
0.007142350543290377,
0.00585404084995389,
0.001011121436022222,
0.03456764295697212,
0.05014234781265259,
-0.012729638256132603,
0.044112127274274826,
0.03910587728023529,
0.018472222611308098,
0.026569487527012825,
0.004695957060903311,
-0.03298111632466316,
0.008501208387315273,
0.014919530600309372,
0.012776671908795834,
-0.023455103859305382,
-0.0008875459316186607,
0.009361520409584045,
-0.022209858521819115,
0.0013517183251678944,
-0.022983219474554062,
-0.023633768782019615,
0.030140340328216553,
0.05069327354431152,
0.030024440959095955,
-0.006239333190023899,
-0.007393112871795893,
-0.046408675611019135,
0.02889961749315262,
-0.02735757827758789,
0.009561878629028797,
-0.028163431212306023,
-0.0015410204650834203,
-0.0021316432394087315,
0.02331366203725338,
-0.06896425038576126,
0.020228959619998932,
-0.042251426726579666,
0.010923284105956554,
0.025812290608882904,
0.017924051731824875,
-0.06042572110891342,
-0.02882789820432663,
0.01396582368761301,
0.011678493581712246,
-0.02796933799982071,
-0.012381822802126408,
0.02108725532889366,
-0.02584945224225521,
-0.003731838194653392,
0.022649727761745453,
0.014591456390917301,
-0.0040702433325350285,
0.004803829826414585,
0.05654940381646156,
-0.00846367608755827,
0.023248551413416862,
0.03540557622909546,
-0.04305693507194519,
-0.03490525111556053,
-0.055404964834451675,
-0.006137610878795385,
0.06300235539674759,
-0.002299034269526601,
0.03462286666035652,
0.04058777168393135,
0.006951711140573025,
0.008171257562935352,
-0.012188294902443886,
0.02604713849723339,
0.007302227430045605,
-0.012560841627418995,
0.0036786990240216255,
-0.005381501745432615,
-0.010134191252291203,
0.0009493673569522798,
-0.027274571359157562,
0.03964576870203018,
-0.07077620923519135,
-0.015157993882894516,
0.06178097426891327,
0.029595715925097466,
-0.0216227937489748,
0.006309203337877989,
-0.014654114842414856,
0.003265734761953354,
0.042278219014406204,
-0.024106716737151146,
-0.013224426656961441,
-0.008072840049862862,
-0.018176570534706116,
-0.006192617118358612,
0.0009365555015392601,
0.020404642447829247,
0.00469959294423461,
0.017834406346082687,
0.024876058101654053,
-0.05432482808828354,
-0.024024616926908493,
0.014704887755215168,
0.02192324958741665,
-0.016100021079182625,
0.026370812207460403,
0.01933722198009491,
-0.03926336020231247,
-0.0103539377450943,
0.0462786927819252,
0.008192455396056175,
-0.03292775899171829,
0.01559772714972496,
-0.029085509479045868,
0.02423907071352005,
-0.04862356558442116,
-0.01720811426639557,
-0.009591594338417053,
-0.05608871579170227,
-0.004618864040821791,
-0.01157752238214016,
0.01366334967315197,
-0.002032075310125947,
-0.07840470224618912,
0.07478068768978119,
-0.07097878307104111,
0.006683018058538437,
-0.0009699436486698687,
0.054238103330135345,
-0.022211318835616112,
0.02808288112282753,
-0.020905541256070137,
0.06253465265035629,
-0.026923831552267075,
0.004676737356930971,
0.0305307786911726,
-0.010092114098370075,
-0.0010746942134574056,
0.0064366827718913555,
-0.017123037949204445,
0.014841974712908268,
0.05651767924427986,
0.010057850740849972,
0.016108805313706398,
-0.007403407711535692,
-0.02039922960102558,
0.03710688650608063,
0.003688511438667774,
0.014013659209012985,
-0.05280575901269913,
-0.02838960289955139,
-0.045654259622097015,
-0.017148159444332123,
-0.007529487367719412,
-0.00661228084936738,
-0.0381232425570488,
-0.06757988780736923,
-0.04252757504582405,
0.015134687535464764,
-0.013178491033613682,
-0.03279554843902588,
-0.022797107696533203,
-0.005414164159446955,
-0.020476628094911575,
0.014096034690737724,
-0.04601291939616203,
0.020960263907909393,
-0.0030626626685261726,
-0.03113325498998165,
-0.005004760343581438,
-0.0002145834150724113,
0.015366110019385815,
-0.017000826075673103,
-0.02171570621430874,
0.048108406364917755,
0.015117774717509747,
0.00648769736289978,
0.02638661302626133,
0.0011042057303711772,
-0.021331924945116043,
0.008170965127646923,
0.007433833088725805,
-0.005306831561028957,
-0.012968480587005615,
0.005062957294285297,
0.027826400473713875,
0.0018216425087302923,
-0.02700001932680607,
-0.0160528551787138,
0.05506642907857895,
-0.016658250242471695,
0.016705701127648354,
-0.017751963809132576,
-0.008311521261930466,
-0.024190854281187057,
-0.04602627828717232,
-0.04837440699338913,
-0.0013406062498688698,
-0.006978379096835852,
-0.006397746503353119,
-0.0205136239528656,
0.024145307019352913,
0.025120649486780167,
-0.06511447578668594,
0.043748196214437485,
0.00626798253506422,
0.016820425167679787,
-0.007574018556624651,
0.004134563263505697,
-0.015912622213363647,
-0.025259144604206085,
0.00928043108433485,
0.022692877799272537,
-0.00788123533129692,
-0.03055592067539692,
0.023900480940937996,
-0.04907939210534096,
-0.004976792726665735,
0.018437964841723442,
-0.04085024073719978,
-0.03166622295975685,
0.03339255228638649,
-0.005445745773613453,
0.00030907304608263075,
0.016606401652097702,
0.012438362464308739,
0.03866686671972275,
0.022056305781006813,
-0.005040351301431656,
-0.010233026929199696,
0.022725814953446388,
-0.055126164108514786,
-0.01776272803544998,
-0.07959946244955063,
0.048562824726104736,
-0.013002880848944187,
0.007829496636986732,
0.008860420435667038,
-0.011812686920166016,
0.009412843734025955,
0.03214789554476738,
0.016095677390694618,
-0.0035020061768591404,
0.037296004593372345,
-0.014164021238684654,
-0.06243365257978439,
-0.017783567309379578,
0.010157549753785133,
-0.021615006029605865,
0.04567248374223709,
0.02059507928788662,
-0.022765060886740685,
-0.021720848977565765,
0.03985875844955444,
0.022239703685045242,
0.005846832413226366,
-0.028564972802996635,
-0.024065135046839714,
-0.00366468308493495,
0.02590670995414257,
-0.016393698751926422,
0.02308405004441738,
0.00471579609438777,
-0.016613133251667023,
-0.005813593044877052,
0.008086648769676685,
-0.062179990112781525,
0.021835515275597572,
0.011866839602589607,
0.02138809859752655,
-0.012327331118285656,
-0.0504753403365612,
0.0014861079398542643,
-0.02662772126495838,
0.003778266254812479,
-0.03424980118870735,
0.05926157161593437,
-0.0023854547180235386,
-0.005261706188321114,
0.017853137105703354,
0.013405711390078068,
-0.0021212147548794746,
-0.006488556042313576,
0.02700221724808216,
-0.021980270743370056,
-0.02931186743080616,
-0.1377609223127365,
-0.04496365785598755,
-0.004760459065437317,
-0.04496312886476517,
-0.01799904927611351,
0.0020279099699109793,
-0.034135401248931885,
0.01790839433670044,
-0.04453106224536896,
-0.0069832755252718925,
0.008391127921640873,
-0.03644848242402077,
0.022305356338620186,
-0.014532836154103279,
-0.04378359392285347,
0.02388717420399189,
-0.04884011670947075,
0.006737837567925453,
-0.0778416320681572,
0.010518093593418598,
0.019300583750009537,
-0.0060092913918197155,
-0.004948094487190247,
-0.01205605361610651,
0.03173720836639404,
-0.01362576149404049,
0.00605880469083786,
-0.05750121921300888,
-0.028659924864768982,
0.00670698843896389,
-0.036029841750860214,
0.01444930024445057,
-0.0228553619235754,
0.08177655935287476,
-0.025103304535150528,
0.0008873032056726515,
0.021961769089102745,
-0.021630195900797844,
-0.0020626250188797712,
0.004574998747557402,
-0.007080425508320332,
0.028129203245043755,
-0.02286897599697113,
-0.01596144214272499,
-0.004530890379101038,
0.019722003489732742,
0.004834464285522699,
-0.0040702419355511665,
-0.07523005455732346,
-0.015526097267866135,
-0.03168884664773941,
0.023806950077414513,
0.03557629883289337,
0.041066259145736694,
-0.008768913336098194,
-0.020666072145104408,
0.0179878119379282,
-0.03370244428515434,
0.02380496636033058,
0.051748789846897125,
0.025001160800457,
-0.000017147734979516827,
-0.06298798322677612,
0.010511893779039383,
-0.025978805497288704,
0.004718955606222153,
-0.02026440016925335,
-0.010850158520042896,
-0.0315687395632267,
0.015236332081258297,
-0.022325152531266212,
-0.028630567714571953,
-0.013602450489997864,
-0.06033294275403023,
0.014015646651387215,
-0.038945380598306656,
0.017460722476243973,
0.016048207879066467,
-0.02622823975980282,
-0.037462156265974045,
-0.019138332456350327,
-0.0030610489193350077,
-0.06399267166852951,
0.003441001521423459,
0.0768650621175766,
0.05322543904185295,
-0.005553227383643389,
-0.014937710016965866,
0.02104940451681614,
-0.04385561868548393,
-0.04524699226021767,
-0.0086044417694211,
-0.0072600762359797955,
0.04929285869002342,
-0.01880663074553013,
0.02997824177145958,
-0.006258147303014994,
-0.005128784105181694,
0.013690652325749397,
0.01119497511535883,
-0.052452921867370605,
-0.0012317347573116422,
-0.0032086630817502737,
-0.019676977768540382,
-0.031394876539707184,
-0.013769509270787239,
0.02100689709186554,
0.0028033878188580275,
0.00508956890553236,
-0.06405601650476456,
0.0015983014600351453,
-0.0014567869948223233,
-0.03185775876045227,
0.03814730793237686,
-0.0498826690018177,
0.00715049309656024,
-0.00119777990039438,
-0.010030694305896759,
0.0005073581705801189,
0.00016808130021672696,
0.02738804742693901,
0.019169693812727928,
0.012599091045558453,
-0.03339717909693718,
0.02209511399269104,
-0.012681374326348305,
0.06126967445015907,
0.025034239515662193,
0.03459823876619339,
-0.006394129246473312,
0.03603237122297287,
-0.004094790201634169,
0.027708083391189575,
0.03495783731341362,
0.0000800223060650751,
0.0312550850212574,
0.003755389479920268,
0.0073947724886238575,
-0.02742288075387478,
-0.012945608235895634,
-0.004183409735560417,
-0.0031884328927844763,
-0.0074142576195299625,
0.02199428342282772,
-0.055321767926216125,
-0.009800971485674381,
0.012680734507739544,
-0.014179029501974583,
-0.019760238006711006,
-0.007369874510914087,
-0.028055327013134956,
0.034832101315259933,
0.01859535463154316,
0.026996973901987076,
0.02454265020787716,
0.0218422319740057,
0.051980625838041306,
-0.016078300774097443,
0.053076960146427155,
0.04584384337067604,
0.006984944920986891,
-0.04544106498360634,
-0.07546106725931168,
-0.04848042130470276,
-0.026596657931804657,
0.02988041751086712,
-0.01918705739080906,
0.010870994068682194,
-0.03195582702755928,
-0.025360554456710815,
-0.05345236510038376,
0.023012137040495872,
-0.019535426050424576,
0.028297564014792442,
0.03077610395848751,
-0.03739766404032707,
-0.007811714429408312,
0.019046975299715996,
0.0519547313451767,
-0.013694172725081444,
0.032165657728910446,
0.018065866082906723,
0.03185698762536049,
-0.02316260151565075,
0.026198947802186012,
0.02990715205669403,
0.032477181404829025,
0.01164827961474657,
-0.006801806390285492,
-0.03229697793722153,
-0.03101077862083912,
-0.005840921774506569,
0.027141552418470383,
0.022159721702337265,
0.0000998213654384017,
0.020492510870099068,
-0.001957389060407877,
0.022632285952568054,
0.02590867690742016,
0.027243973687291145,
0.046282365918159485,
-0.02137599140405655,
-0.03124162182211876,
-0.006997580174356699,
-0.021436844021081924,
0.02714713104069233,
-0.011719346977770329,
-0.0628838911652565,
-0.026932217180728912,
0.08015903830528259,
-0.01387214194983244,
-0.019446350634098053,
-0.022785568609833717,
0.02484450861811638,
0.012290981598198414,
0.021726960316300392,
0.024660194292664528,
-0.012722888961434364,
0.0325031615793705,
-0.024166958406567574,
0.03674166649580002,
0.03287704288959503,
-0.002849459880962968,
-0.03641603887081146,
-0.023815974593162537,
-0.0054033007472753525,
-0.025121500715613365,
0.035136036574840546,
-0.0016585799166932702,
0.04069310426712036,
-0.015085670165717602,
0.021057622507214546,
-0.010992457158863544,
0.042539406567811966,
0.0002953039656858891,
0.0031047428492456675,
-0.03503705561161041,
-0.020040757954120636,
-0.009397638030350208,
-0.023236660286784172,
0.05221100151538849,
0.011709730140864849,
0.0018320095259696245,
-0.014437096193432808
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:35
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
522Arising out of that meeting Mr Moir prepared a letter dated 24 June 2004, addressed to Mr Hanna, in which he stated:-
"I have received signed contracts from unitholders to sell their units in the Huntley Unit Trust to Ibis, with a total number of units in the Trust covered in those signed agreements making up at least 51% of the equity in the unit trust; and
[HTT] has provided all of the due diligence information set out in the agreement dated 15 March 2004 between HTT and Ibis".
523Mr Moir said, and I accept, that he would not have composed this letter if he did not believe its contents were true.
524The inference I draw is that it reflects matters discussed at the meeting of 23 June 2004 (at which Mr Renshall was present) and points to the conclusion that, as at 23 June 2004, Mr Renshall had been told something to the effect set forth in the letter.
Mr Gillard calls for withdrawal of the Caveat
525It will be recalled that, pursuant to clause 2.2 of the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement, LEC agreed to withdraw the Caveat that, on 23 April 2003, it had lodged on the title of the Land.
526The Heads of Agreement did not, in terms, state by what date this was to occur.
527In early July 2004, Mr Gillard commenced agitating for the immediate withdrawal of the Caveat.
528On 6 July 2004 he wrote to Mr Hilliard's employee, Mr Simon Bennett:-
"I am instructed that [other documentation called for by the Heads of Agreement] should not delay the delivery by your client of the Withdrawal of Caveat(...)
As stated, we are expecting the Withdrawal of Caveat to be ready for delivery today. Please advise immediately of any issue which might delay the Withdrawal".
529As things turned out, the Withdrawal of Caveat was not handed over by LEC until the settlement of 27 August 2008. The fact that Mr Gillard was agitating for its immediate delivery is relevant to what occurred on and after 27 August 2004 once the Withdrawal of Caveat was handed over.
530Not surprisingly, Mr Zdrilic's instructions to Mr Bennett, as recorded in Mr Bennett's file note of 6 July 2004 were that:-
"Caveat w/drawn if funder comes up with his obligations (at the same time as caveat w/drawn)".
July 2004 - Funder not in place
531Also on 6 July 2004, Mr Gillard had a conversation with Mr Bennett in which, according to Mr Bennett's note, Mr Gillard said:-
"Have lost the funder".
532Mr Gillard's comment "have lost the funder" was, it seems, reflected in a letter that Mr Bennett sent to Mr Gillard two days later on 8 July 2004 in which he stated:-
"[Mr Zdrilic] has advised me that as the funder is not yet in place he needs to be appointed as a full Director of HTT. Additionally HTT's constitution should be amended such that all decisions of Directors are unanimous and all decisions of members must be made with a minimum 80% majority.
This is of particular importance to [Mr Zdrilic] whilst there is no funder in place. Could you please forward me a copy of the constitution of HTT so that I can make the necessary adjustments".
533This communication is important in two respects.
534First, it makes clear that, as at 8 July 2004, Mr Zdrilic knew that there was "no funder in place".
535Second, Mr Zdrilic's reaction to that situation was not to assert that the lack of a committed funder was inconsistent with any representations made earlier to him by Mr Renshall or inconsistent with HTT's obligations under the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement.
536Rather, Mr Zdrilic sought to reinstate the arrangements (his place on the board of HTT with a power of veto) advocated in his email of 15 February 2004 to Mr Renshall, referred to above.
Third "proof of funds" letter
537Two days later, on 10 July 2004, Mr Renshall sent the third of his "proof of funds" letters to IPC.
538This letter was marked to Mr Hanna's attention (copy to Mr Moir) and read:-
"As you are aware, clause 3.1(b) of the Heads of Agreement dated 15 March 2004 between Huntley and IPC requires IPC to show proof that it has the funds to complete the transaction.
|
[
-0.03662943094968796,
0.05194950848817825,
-0.025321010500192642,
0.017743680626153946,
-0.009721518494188786,
-0.09926670789718628,
0.0018865101737901568,
-0.017170879989862442,
-0.031903982162475586,
-0.0017677794676274061,
-0.012773316353559494,
0.02188890241086483,
-0.041692182421684265,
0.011043584905564785,
-0.024627018719911575,
-0.020110737532377243,
0.049164146184921265,
-0.01242552325129509,
-0.004497800953686237,
-0.02839486300945282,
-0.04076988622546196,
-0.025801952928304672,
0.011368358507752419,
0.025585373863577843,
-0.01473172102123499,
-0.02139812335371971,
-0.014789286069571972,
0.012267710641026497,
0.013833907432854176,
0.03325001522898674,
-0.008760950528085232,
-0.010929286479949951,
0.009168083779513836,
0.0006360156694427133,
0.005274435970932245,
-0.027191298082470894,
0.05048570781946182,
0.0020428623538464308,
-0.020493153482675552,
-0.022667143493890762,
-0.03874049335718155,
0.048445649445056915,
0.00699587631970644,
-0.02462434209883213,
0.06083579733967781,
-0.038233231753110886,
0.004369169007986784,
-0.02465781383216381,
0.011965113691985607,
0.03464488685131073,
-0.0595046803355217,
-0.014513423666357994,
0.014120722189545631,
0.003982238471508026,
-0.0035670918878167868,
-0.014087890274822712,
-0.008976977318525314,
0.002893198747187853,
-0.03551284596323967,
0.006847791373729706,
0.011259854771196842,
-0.02330797351896763,
-0.05725394934415817,
-0.003945575561374426,
0.006532111670821905,
0.06916006654500961,
0.018635988235473633,
-0.013070793822407722,
-0.006868403870612383,
-0.011120633222162724,
-0.058296967297792435,
0.03212501481175423,
-0.030509209260344505,
-0.006688713561743498,
-0.08906079828739166,
0.017962273210287094,
0.023330459371209145,
-0.015712417662143707,
0.026135673746466637,
0.02465658448636532,
0.038153793662786484,
-0.014311796985566616,
-0.0037871517706662416,
0.037182070314884186,
-0.02892531082034111,
0.004655483644455671,
-0.009531513787806034,
0.025819461792707443,
0.02386315166950226,
-0.004120814148336649,
0.0031329228077083826,
-0.02016638219356537,
0.027213646098971367,
-0.06917548924684525,
-0.021190159022808075,
-0.010797139257192612,
-0.055307935923337936,
0.034598853439092636,
-0.007513928692787886,
-0.005157453939318657,
0.016927622258663177,
0.05988777056336403,
-0.012509170919656754,
-0.02274809591472149,
0.027708858251571655,
0.03501887619495392,
0.0663764551281929,
0.027507608756422997,
0.00360240344889462,
-0.021881742402911186,
-0.020152626559138298,
0.008857532404363155,
0.019046608358621597,
0.0023727326188236475,
0.0015435528475791216,
-0.011921695433557034,
-0.019337700679898262,
0.006319079082459211,
0.031670961529016495,
-0.00013828222290612757,
0.04160849750041962,
0.011985312215983868,
0.0234209094196558,
-0.026012655347585678,
-0.054396048188209534,
0.0032409843988716602,
-0.014130896888673306,
-0.04684426262974739,
0.005757539067417383,
0.03660562261939049,
-0.005155457183718681,
0.030800841748714447,
-0.0433746837079525,
-0.059800248593091965,
-0.03152964264154434,
-0.016759226098656654,
0.006586750037968159,
0.011860203929245472,
0.012294203042984009,
-0.06536336988210678,
0.02468540146946907,
0.019544491544365883,
-0.01065064687281847,
-0.04371703043580055,
0.02777644619345665,
-0.01756233535706997,
0.012567313387989998,
0.008816380985081196,
-0.010963741689920425,
0.016658548265695572,
-0.000905421853531152,
0.003622316289693117,
0.00987615343183279,
0.0013823172776028514,
0.055192478001117706,
-0.05345530807971954,
-0.010836159810423851,
-0.023507041856646538,
0.0407068245112896,
0.08333346992731094,
-0.017535105347633362,
0.032162994146347046,
-0.02287641167640686,
-0.017481695860624313,
-0.008799823932349682,
0.023180685937404633,
0.008339053951203823,
0.03930626064538956,
0.00845364760607481,
-0.008201414719223976,
0.03189581260085106,
-0.014507729560136795,
0.07616034895181656,
-0.0067087565548717976,
0.0065796589478850365,
0.025929711759090424,
0.059631045907735825,
-0.001991129945963621,
-0.013984625227749348,
-0.014673665165901184,
-0.0558241568505764,
0.052605971693992615,
0.009727316908538342,
-0.033848896622657776,
-0.03321234881877899,
0.03103327937424183,
0.005067966878414154,
-0.02936878241598606,
-0.008715488947927952,
0.027926994487643242,
-0.013540418818593025,
-0.0021843474823981524,
0.03585265204310417,
0.04959694668650627,
-0.0016865081852301955,
-0.030781960114836693,
-0.003187978407368064,
-0.010456286370754242,
0.010778749361634254,
-0.013599315658211708,
-0.02673116698861122,
0.019111767411231995,
0.061352141201496124,
-0.022515051066875458,
-0.019689397886395454,
0.015861166641116142,
-0.030863724648952484,
-0.010000956244766712,
0.01184892188757658,
-0.05752616748213768,
-0.026836726814508438,
-0.00031030786340124905,
-0.02315933257341385,
-0.01700802892446518,
0.025781484320759773,
-0.00979172345250845,
-0.028414102271199226,
-0.010389118455350399,
0.015276312828063965,
-0.036577507853507996,
-0.011992020532488823,
0.011564143002033234,
0.011395988054573536,
-0.034674759954214096,
0.023078223690390587,
0.06770924478769302,
-0.07694575935602188,
0.023053433746099472,
-0.018986856564879417,
-0.03561336174607277,
0.0019730010535568,
-0.03060160204768181,
0.010704240761697292,
-0.024529244750738144,
0.031359221786260605,
0.029064778238534927,
-0.0006972587434574962,
0.028354624286293983,
0.0013848473317921162,
0.004186748526990414,
-0.003737916937097907,
0.005054013803601265,
0.011449519544839859,
0.018904151394963264,
-0.0020834230817854404,
0.00311852665618062,
-0.010989478789269924,
-0.00019385151972528547,
0.028768958523869514,
-0.004187417216598988,
-0.0022185288835316896,
0.02849765121936798,
0.009740346111357212,
-0.0020744185894727707,
0.005993096623569727,
0.038548488169908524,
0.004312151577323675,
0.0005004996783100069,
0.048757877200841904,
0.003979911562055349,
0.052654433995485306,
0.010352062061429024,
0.027450809255242348,
0.013396693393588066,
-0.011978895403444767,
-0.007865616120398045,
-0.0385027714073658,
-0.06070813909173012,
0.04616870731115341,
-0.010543739423155785,
0.003036370500922203,
0.01719554327428341,
0.03026314452290535,
0.0432930588722229,
0.016490086913108826,
0.017469117417931557,
0.005291496403515339,
0.015177106484770775,
0.020683808252215385,
0.03772207722067833,
-0.014745582826435566,
0.006248646881431341,
0.03732471913099289,
-0.023554876446723938,
0.0464506559073925,
0.044233787804841995,
-0.03133700042963028,
-0.010757663287222385,
0.004657987505197525,
-0.01639300025999546,
-0.026855915784835815,
0.022907590493559837,
0.05294688791036606,
0.0029462557286024094,
-0.03608755022287369,
-0.032583773136138916,
-0.01060924120247364,
-0.14895722270011902,
-0.01868370547890663,
-0.018551921471953392,
0.008773748762905598,
0.0037235973868519068,
0.013420630246400833,
-0.031858619302511215,
0.00244086142629385,
-0.04017695412039757,
0.016935868188738823,
-0.0033272060099989176,
-0.04965346306562424,
-0.00792350061237812,
0.015453864820301533,
0.0047952295280992985,
-0.011198687367141247,
0.011718116700649261,
0.009163567796349525,
0.04289776459336281,
-0.01998969353735447,
0.007837741635739803,
-0.05052359402179718,
0.04626932367682457,
-0.0010120106162503362,
0.022144898772239685,
-0.0010184994898736477,
0.0011651471722871065,
0.028642890974879265,
-0.04122411087155342,
-0.0016565298428758979,
-0.02287367172539234,
0.01326081808656454,
-0.014331631362438202,
0.05970124155282974,
-0.011634576134383678,
0.05299647897481918,
0.07557081431150436,
-0.052819471806287766,
0.008124123327434063,
-0.031240150332450867,
0.04049929603934288,
0.041897695511579514,
-0.031609583646059036,
-0.015324611216783524,
0.016767188906669617,
-0.05113324895501137,
0.013381987810134888,
-0.0077738952822983265,
0.005274239461869001,
0.015525519847869873,
0.014353013597428799,
0.02480667270720005,
-0.03809986636042595,
-0.032151754945516586,
-0.002019425854086876,
-0.034186217933893204,
0.024153361096978188,
0.04787272587418556,
-0.05550742149353027,
-0.013409227132797241,
-0.03964230790734291,
-0.03934480994939804,
0.006166727747768164,
0.027484817430377007,
-0.025021599605679512,
0.012030888348817825,
0.004318134393543005,
-0.030910933390259743,
0.03505416959524155,
0.025557102635502815,
-0.00032995655783452094,
-0.03473459556698799,
0.021566519513726234,
-0.012569454498589039,
0.04732900857925415,
0.038219671696424484,
-0.030602356418967247,
-0.008120092563331127,
-0.008384685963392258,
-0.09446033835411072,
0.0018935990519821644,
0.03612003102898598,
0.0019384333863854408,
0.010667121037840843,
-0.0024374343920499086,
0.04087016358971596,
0.018920235335826874,
0.07475253194570541,
-0.005988565739244223,
0.2571059763431549,
0.019671613350510597,
-0.01313873939216137,
0.05951940268278122,
0.03851215913891792,
-0.02802806720137596,
0.015204265713691711,
0.019053352996706963,
-0.0011369932908564806,
-0.039955735206604004,
-0.006707645952701569,
-0.03131483122706413,
0.02821386232972145,
-0.009201758541166782,
-0.007648843340575695,
0.028299113735556602,
-0.04581950604915619,
-0.008439273573458195,
0.07570744305849075,
-0.01979767344892025,
0.045592620968818665,
-0.0006206976249814034,
-0.0012341992696747184,
-0.0033844688441604376,
-0.06529498845338821,
-0.03177831321954727,
0.05356600880622864,
0.040106676518917084,
-0.056826893240213394,
-0.003087750868871808,
-0.014178833924233913,
-0.002325316658243537,
0.04411136731505394,
0.015906983986496925,
0.020621957257390022,
0.006371382623910904,
-0.014060687273740768,
-0.014031937345862389,
0.013973378576338291,
0.036969300359487534,
-0.008000338450074196,
-0.05647921934723854,
0.027739638462662697,
-0.05222098529338837,
-0.029815012589097023,
0.012619607150554657,
-0.02484525740146637,
0.02831960842013359,
-0.021380383521318436,
0.0028157264459878206,
0.003585099708288908,
-0.0067362599074840546,
-0.009828798472881317,
0.011956699192523956,
-0.02883109077811241,
0.06642621010541916,
-0.025914840400218964,
0.03438181057572365,
-0.0026606034953147173,
0.0470120832324028,
0.004837143234908581,
0.026309514418244362,
-0.03943326324224472,
0.019160885363817215,
0.0007967726560309529,
-0.031138820573687553,
-0.07840529084205627,
-0.01841995306313038,
0.0461324118077755,
0.05835997685790062,
0.023609083145856857,
0.03867404907941818,
-0.02104279398918152,
0.021922437474131584,
0.004953799303621054,
0.0073674628511071205,
-0.014671031385660172,
-0.0036114193499088287,
-0.028639880940318108,
0.009995969012379646,
-0.016873657703399658,
-0.03212627023458481,
-0.027094336226582527,
0.036531586199998856,
0.03405427187681198,
0.0016745724715292454,
0.000041935119952540845,
0.0451241210103035,
-0.03190799802541733,
-0.016570912674069405,
-0.001020740601234138,
-0.022011088207364082,
-0.004466070793569088,
-0.035131096839904785,
-0.033777426928281784,
-0.023456014692783356,
-0.005176106002181768,
-0.007236542645841837,
-0.03195444121956825,
0.0005317436880432069,
-0.01692783832550049,
0.006456035189330578,
0.011478998698294163,
-0.04020363464951515,
0.0291375070810318,
-0.0005050672334618866,
0.0010509148705750704,
0.012226107530295849,
-0.052715543657541275,
0.008886031806468964,
0.026439040899276733,
0.0131188053637743,
-0.006212220527231693,
-0.010212446562945843,
0.016861895099282265,
0.07564547657966614,
-0.021974964067339897,
0.059828609228134155,
0.03541179001331329,
0.026425326243042946,
0.02287476882338524,
0.0036535279359668493,
-0.06005297228693962,
0.016492323949933052,
-0.006482565775513649,
-0.021951308473944664,
-0.009423266164958477,
-0.011112584732472897,
0.01588534004986286,
0.022811032831668854,
-0.025511659681797028,
-0.027327122166752815,
-0.03586895018815994,
0.014194073155522346,
0.02835201658308506,
0.032312627881765366,
-0.012065570801496506,
0.005387192126363516,
-0.03697560727596283,
0.028096042573451996,
-0.03926236927509308,
0.013880235143005848,
-0.026650698855519295,
-0.002563158283010125,
-0.0005703821079805493,
0.012295319698750973,
-0.05091178044676781,
0.018172819167375565,
-0.06397940963506699,
-0.020572608336806297,
0.02400853857398033,
0.046758417040109634,
-0.032124243676662445,
-0.034475695341825485,
0.015473265200853348,
-0.009772888384759426,
-0.003217378631234169,
-0.015282120555639267,
-0.009316127747297287,
-0.040296770632267,
0.005853785667568445,
0.007701111491769552,
0.012958232313394547,
0.015562793239951134,
0.0103840297088027,
0.0626993253827095,
-0.019151048734784126,
0.05165664106607437,
0.04839830845594406,
-0.003458065912127495,
0.0024651323910802603,
-0.05120692029595375,
-0.03327491134405136,
0.0714857280254364,
-0.002392410533502698,
0.03188684210181236,
-0.015153363347053528,
0.00910354033112526,
0.020544646307826042,
-0.008313764818012714,
0.0469299741089344,
0.005215877201408148,
-0.05707404017448425,
0.00437814649194479,
-0.008050958625972271,
0.019158650189638138,
-0.010320478118956089,
-0.022194433957338333,
0.05936918780207634,
-0.021443363279104233,
0.003614631248638034,
0.07293586432933807,
0.023703759536147118,
-0.01901237852871418,
0.024400290101766586,
-0.003992644138634205,
-0.015886196866631508,
0.05887015908956528,
-0.011208837851881981,
-0.04444845765829086,
-0.019116155803203583,
-0.021200336515903473,
0.04546782746911049,
-0.02842818945646286,
0.014052651822566986,
0.005152256228029728,
-0.0032698733266443014,
0.06454318016767502,
-0.06745944172143936,
-0.024818364530801773,
0.03298322856426239,
0.047477807849645615,
-0.040358979254961014,
0.006477939896285534,
0.028274212032556534,
-0.044468916952610016,
0.025481941178441048,
0.06278729438781738,
0.04829110577702522,
-0.0631546601653099,
-0.00014901053509674966,
-0.02954341657459736,
0.03517940267920494,
-0.01740928739309311,
-0.031296249479055405,
0.003487616777420044,
-0.05819626897573471,
-0.017628999426960945,
-0.0029721762984991074,
0.004752377048134804,
-0.005416002590209246,
-0.04839946702122688,
0.04294726252555847,
-0.04954250156879425,
-0.008149802684783936,
-0.00684842374175787,
0.03825092688202858,
-0.004693293012678623,
0.015150495804846287,
-0.012022350914776325,
0.03551691770553589,
-0.010333248414099216,
0.03667439892888069,
0.024498876184225082,
0.011453072540462017,
-0.01545622106641531,
0.007287264335900545,
-0.01973126269876957,
-0.0050228675827383995,
0.011478191241621971,
0.01565149426460266,
0.022662034258246422,
0.01889275386929512,
-0.015947794541716576,
0.010681457817554474,
0.01290914323180914,
0.05808942764997482,
-0.053863730281591415,
-0.03260016068816185,
-0.026687541976571083,
0.0005005957209505141,
0.013177182525396347,
0.008324607275426388,
-0.035091985017061234,
-0.06480656564235687,
-0.06609045714139938,
-0.0009665125398896635,
-0.06548228114843369,
-0.02341187559068203,
0.017794867977499962,
0.007209048140794039,
-0.0026131318882107735,
0.014868857339024544,
-0.07679746299982071,
-0.006655478850007057,
-0.016495341435074806,
-0.04191058501601219,
-0.009313155896961689,
-0.02845121920108795,
0.0006754444912075996,
0.01184417400509119,
0.023566458374261856,
0.03007962554693222,
0.016253218054771423,
-0.001208420959301293,
0.030040549114346504,
0.010403018444776535,
-0.006415394134819508,
-0.016689227893948555,
-0.0257868729531765,
0.008108532987535,
0.0032589370384812355,
-0.017436116933822632,
0.008102944120764732,
-0.0032716882415115833,
-0.04165465012192726,
-0.00407540425658226,
0.04489026591181755,
-0.01526755653321743,
0.008757361210882664,
-0.02350304275751114,
-0.008477907627820969,
0.0016323415329679847,
-0.022735999897122383,
-0.00014921704132575542,
0.007150663994252682,
0.00856832880526781,
-0.02200060524046421,
-0.02204572968184948,
0.018913060426712036,
0.03753882274031639,
-0.07699792087078094,
-0.009046274237334728,
0.0043775830417871475,
0.04704129323363304,
0.0016115219332277775,
0.02049858309328556,
0.022629553452134132,
-0.031047530472278595,
-0.014884289354085922,
0.008464071899652481,
0.016469592228531837,
-0.04321480542421341,
0.012900506146252155,
-0.06615057587623596,
0.00373747362755239,
0.04180780425667763,
-0.020039359107613564,
-0.03745143488049507,
-0.0007245208835229278,
-0.03308786451816559,
0.0014019019436091185,
-0.01021432876586914,
0.005942548159509897,
0.009158506989479065,
0.029751138761639595,
0.011394105851650238,
-0.01530752144753933,
0.04110656678676605,
-0.06545498967170715,
-0.03275104984641075,
-0.03436053544282913,
0.07018697261810303,
0.009324759244918823,
-0.0025053408462554216,
0.011102654971182346,
0.015401836484670639,
0.014070043340325356,
0.029708130285143852,
0.0009512170217931271,
-0.03196234628558159,
0.014258239418268204,
-0.006650961935520172,
-0.04068377986550331,
0.01519650686532259,
0.002862362889572978,
-0.00407996354624629,
0.023837029933929443,
0.04463149979710579,
-0.03217868506908417,
0.013698266819119453,
0.04100530967116356,
0.0054962108843028545,
-0.0179122481495142,
-0.015020965598523617,
-0.009314549155533314,
-0.0016926499083638191,
0.0219144094735384,
-0.04583871737122536,
0.01664627157151699,
0.0015022206353023648,
-0.02136050909757614,
-0.0006380354752764106,
0.010618391446769238,
-0.03751646727323532,
0.029480062425136566,
-0.0036877901293337345,
0.017743906006217003,
0.007180295884609222,
-0.05407207831740379,
0.019361965358257294,
-0.02461659163236618,
-0.004658972844481468,
-0.02444429323077202,
0.005094589199870825,
0.0029407416004687548,
-0.0018756361678242683,
0.02605428360402584,
0.017804892733693123,
0.009255936369299889,
-0.025975719094276428,
0.010320444591343403,
-0.04708244651556015,
0.0063296216540038586,
-0.1373838186264038,
-0.020390484482049942,
-0.017551559954881668,
-0.02001369372010231,
-0.030444229021668434,
0.012186132371425629,
-0.034464091062545776,
0.01643151417374611,
-0.019860444590449333,
0.00309848808683455,
0.011310677975416183,
-0.044147055596113205,
0.007720613852143288,
-0.013181754387915134,
-0.011766212061047554,
-0.0028615796472877264,
-0.02689826488494873,
-0.01792731136083603,
-0.068755142390728,
0.03979352116584778,
0.022915681824088097,
-0.0049438076093792915,
-0.01687600649893284,
-0.018983779475092888,
0.03136805072426796,
-0.0002989847562275827,
-0.011715293861925602,
-0.08029752224683762,
-0.03373277559876442,
-0.0009182407520711422,
-0.03857705742120743,
0.003893269458785653,
-0.0012429794296622276,
0.07088403403759003,
0.006333701312541962,
0.012254669331014156,
0.03233370929956436,
-0.04207181930541992,
-0.013914552517235279,
0.0008558448753319681,
0.005032011773437262,
0.02041645161807537,
0.00859975814819336,
-0.01850663311779499,
-0.014992143958806992,
0.02482079714536667,
-0.0165180005133152,
-0.009507501497864723,
-0.05968943238258362,
-0.011424473486840725,
-0.031171554699540138,
0.032827701419591904,
-0.011247429996728897,
0.04161597415804863,
-0.010065874084830284,
-0.012503686361014843,
0.018316548317670822,
-0.030504852533340454,
0.02896060049533844,
0.031961556524038315,
0.006147144827991724,
0.013438395224511623,
-0.058264464139938354,
0.0030401628464460373,
-0.032111216336488724,
-0.030422357842326164,
-0.05195990204811096,
-0.017096709460020065,
-0.028416169807314873,
0.03755234554409981,
-0.02048843912780285,
-0.008735273964703083,
-0.0073612588457763195,
-0.030534973368048668,
0.045028332620859146,
-0.04671305790543556,
0.0007349781808443367,
0.01473770197480917,
-0.011643614619970322,
-0.012320669367909431,
-0.05089749023318291,
-0.008797191083431244,
-0.056697335094213486,
-0.033390916883945465,
0.08569179475307465,
0.031792331486940384,
-0.012099701911211014,
-0.029270604252815247,
0.03687312826514244,
-0.03135520964860916,
-0.05490062013268471,
-0.0001380830944981426,
-0.002771959640085697,
0.045564670115709305,
-0.032994531095027924,
0.022934632375836372,
-0.01932121254503727,
-0.03286915272474289,
0.027404796332120895,
-0.008161879144608974,
-0.05606226250529289,
-0.008861846290528774,
-0.009473860263824463,
0.004138993099331856,
-0.011268751695752144,
-0.009523874148726463,
0.059491075575351715,
-0.004572649952024221,
0.005443947855383158,
-0.009482486173510551,
0.01808432675898075,
-0.0036668702960014343,
-0.016488829627633095,
0.0245862677693367,
-0.04442042484879494,
-0.0069878241047263145,
0.0027968354988843203,
-0.020865894854068756,
-0.024031637236475945,
0.021133484318852425,
0.01894739829003811,
0.012986062094569206,
0.0002705812221392989,
-0.02875605598092079,
0.016538584604859352,
-0.007700894959270954,
0.050624530762434006,
0.03424444422125816,
0.04094334691762924,
-0.018938712775707245,
0.02512013539671898,
0.011155850253999233,
-0.016753101721405983,
0.026195190846920013,
-0.0050805676728487015,
0.0006115188589319587,
-0.007318269927054644,
0.006255626678466797,
-0.05416112020611763,
-0.002994574373587966,
0.0213428046554327,
0.002005184069275856,
-0.011288782581686974,
0.02494814060628414,
-0.03142380341887474,
-0.00041081709787249565,
0.0032196291722357273,
-0.00478573702275753,
-0.0569562166929245,
-0.03521304950118065,
-0.012081115506589413,
0.016592716798186302,
-0.012541510164737701,
0.0297694094479084,
0.03372977301478386,
0.0073865861631929874,
0.052005019038915634,
0.0017853681929409504,
-0.006432834081351757,
0.047257859259843826,
0.005276593845337629,
-0.07543665170669556,
-0.040878232568502426,
-0.049219947308301926,
-0.004386390093713999,
0.006697080563753843,
-0.018336424604058266,
0.01837776042521,
-0.03680390492081642,
-0.020162751898169518,
-0.03162050619721413,
0.027072180062532425,
-0.018423955887556076,
0.026745252311229706,
0.013425683602690697,
-0.02384364977478981,
-0.01518841553479433,
-0.018582670018076897,
0.06663408875465393,
-0.03448204696178436,
0.03689445182681084,
0.034940604120492935,
0.02274634875357151,
0.004263612441718578,
0.028053343296051025,
0.02831621840596199,
0.02799602597951889,
0.028669942170381546,
-0.046442434191703796,
-0.01871647499501705,
-0.01221941877156496,
0.02654716931283474,
-0.0014886942226439714,
0.015103744342923164,
0.024547770619392395,
0.02083437703549862,
-0.013643147423863411,
0.033527158200740814,
-0.033272434026002884,
0.043435003608465195,
0.032676950097084045,
-0.0407303050160408,
-0.024900607764720917,
-0.0381757877767086,
0.016311930492520332,
0.05471029505133629,
-0.013228358700871468,
-0.06223244592547417,
-0.02325274422764778,
0.050243377685546875,
-0.032738640904426575,
0.022189082577824593,
-0.029265332967042923,
0.03451475501060486,
-0.010937364771962166,
-0.004043642897158861,
0.014248127117753029,
-0.03893832117319107,
0.02969280630350113,
-0.046225450932979584,
0.03871003910899162,
0.04046717286109924,
0.008746232837438583,
-0.03607657924294472,
-0.01954730786383152,
0.020550601184368134,
-0.015513538382947445,
0.02483767457306385,
0.001404036651365459,
0.046114008873701096,
-0.008777040056884289,
0.026262303814291954,
0.0001783918123692274,
0.02510649338364601,
0.019298585131764412,
-0.029427895322442055,
-0.0652397945523262,
-0.027445387095212936,
-0.005367431789636612,
-0.004485486540943384,
0.050055548548698425,
0.00935673713684082,
0.017758876085281372,
-0.02348482608795166
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:34
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
506Arising out of the conversation that Mr Zdrilic had with Mr Renshall that led to that note, Mr Zdrilic sent an email to Mr Hilliard dated 18 June 2004, in which he referred to his meeting with Mr Renshall and said "this is what I can tell you to move things along".
507What followed in the email was a discussion as to the current position in regard to the shares in HTT and units in the Huntley Trust, in the course of which Mr Zdrilic said:-
"What happens when a funder is found?...
This all seems ok if the Funder comes along but what if Funder does not come along and we have a different scenario (...)
You should know it is not 100 % sure that the funder we have in mind will come good but Renshall is working on other funders as well".
508Plainly, at this point, no matter what had been said to him before, Mr Zdrilic had serious doubts about whether any funder (even the one "we have in mind") would deliver, whether by acquiring the units of the "little'" shareholders, or at all.
509Three days later, on 21 June 2004 Mr Zdrilic wrote to Mr Hilliard:-
"Further to my email to you of 18/6/04 where I was contemplating what would happen if funder not in place at same time as all the rest of things that need to be done.
I just spoke to Robert Renshall who is very confident that funder will come good and it is geared to happen on 3/7/04".
510What this shows, in my opinion, is that, as at mid June 2004 Mr Zdrilic could recognise that there was no commitment from any funder "we have in mind" and was contemplating the possibility that that funder would "not come along".
511Evidently he raised that concern with Mr Renshall who did no more than to express confidence that the funder "will come good" and that he expected this would happen by 3 July 2004.
512As we shall see, 3 July 2004 came and went without funding being in place.
Second "proof of funds" letter
513On 23 June 2004 Mr Renshall wrote the second of his "proof of funds" letters.
514This letter was addressed to the "IPC Joint Venture Trust" and marked to the attention of Mr Moir and stated:-
"As you are aware, clause 3.1(b) of the Heads of Agreement dated 15 March 2004 between Huntley and IPC requires IPC to show proof that it has the funds the complete the transaction.
Huntley has repeatedly asked James Hanna of IPC and all connected with the agreement including yourself for this evidence. Despite these repeated requests, the information has still not been forthcoming.
Huntley requires that proof of funds be shown, and the breach of clause 3.1(b) be rectified within 15 days of the date of this letter."
IPC Due Diligence
515Mr Hanna's letter of 31 January 2004 from IBIS to HTT foreshadowed that IBIS would conduct due diligence before advancing funds.
516There is evidence to suggest that some form of due diligence took place.
517On 5 May 2004 Mr Frederick made a note that Mr Hanna had set aside a week to do work on IPC's due diligence on HTT.
518On 6 May 2004, Mr Moir sent an email to Mr Renshall setting out certain matters that Mr Hanna was said to require "to complete the due diligence".
519The list included access to HTT's business offices for the purpose of a review of all of HTT's financial and other records, a copy of HTT's 12 month business plan including income and expenditure projections, copies of income tax and financial statements and executed share transfer agreements from 51 per cent of the shareholders in HTT and 51 per cent of the unit holders in the unit trust.
520Mr Moir concluded that Mr Hanna was:-
"Under timing constraints and would appreciate the information today, so that all issues with the NZ Reserve bank can be sewn up".
521On 23 June 2004 a meeting took place between Messrs Renshall, Moir, Hanna and Frederick.
|
[
-0.037209246307611465,
0.04139864072203636,
-0.026798825711011887,
0.017488403245806694,
-0.027602342888712883,
-0.039076391607522964,
0.019880132749676704,
-0.03633170574903488,
-0.01105496659874916,
0.018202679231762886,
-0.024260129779577255,
0.04429585486650467,
-0.02138254977762699,
-0.01074350904673338,
-0.022298840805888176,
-0.029965993016958237,
0.02540099062025547,
-0.006902115419507027,
0.022950539365410805,
-0.027753323316574097,
-0.016414253041148186,
-0.027369745075702667,
0.02030978910624981,
0.00878515187650919,
-0.028213435783982277,
0.0034956943709403276,
-0.04671309515833855,
0.014394466765224934,
0.025284288451075554,
0.0413302443921566,
-0.011642592027783394,
0.010520746000111103,
0.031082019209861755,
-0.00359726813621819,
0.030806703492999077,
-0.0193301010876894,
0.0173993818461895,
0.0007158645312301815,
-0.026105906814336777,
0.013905368745326996,
-0.004236224573105574,
0.029830317944288254,
-0.009425951167941093,
-0.00015956746938172728,
0.04733633995056152,
-0.017862824723124504,
-0.00625177938491106,
-0.027477672323584557,
0.013551853597164154,
0.004136429168283939,
-0.025551417842507362,
-0.016388747841119766,
0.04052798077464104,
-0.00029875003383494914,
-0.03120456263422966,
-0.0432245098054409,
-0.015219888649880886,
-0.011697307229042053,
-0.04171023145318031,
0.008406555280089378,
0.012611320242285728,
0.0010012761922553182,
-0.06742186099290848,
0.0036542657762765884,
-0.01443224586546421,
0.1022738665342331,
-0.0041292146779596806,
-0.024876676499843597,
-0.000985891674645245,
0.0017510211328044534,
-0.04468340054154396,
-0.00990298856049776,
-0.03132740408182144,
-0.006090966984629631,
-0.09921032935380936,
0.003039383329451084,
0.026701010763645172,
0.01266147568821907,
0.020363712683320045,
0.03805294632911682,
0.03469141572713852,
0.0067796651273965836,
-0.024813847616314888,
0.01372609008103609,
-0.0017645066836848855,
0.0030895411036908627,
-0.007529668044298887,
0.042109400033950806,
0.026847323402762413,
-0.01583654247224331,
0.02038271352648735,
0.025338714942336082,
0.017522430047392845,
-0.04343956336379051,
-0.006718803662806749,
0.00611143046990037,
-0.04981999099254608,
0.035098399966955185,
-0.011062756180763245,
0.03963609039783478,
0.020173508673906326,
0.03275270760059357,
-0.027616020292043686,
-0.024836953729391098,
-0.014015218243002892,
0.04479726776480675,
0.057795241475105286,
0.027854835614562035,
-0.006374721881002188,
-0.00876114796847105,
-0.0017173053929582238,
0.008766216225922108,
0.018564773723483086,
0.03387095406651497,
0.007231586612761021,
-0.015242494642734528,
-0.0169035904109478,
0.02560259774327278,
0.04147839918732643,
0.02916116453707218,
0.03898424655199051,
0.0110313193872571,
0.019889183342456818,
-0.0032821851782500744,
-0.09050159901380539,
0.0026450592558830976,
-0.004730356391519308,
-0.01697169616818428,
0.001803716877475381,
0.012813754379749298,
-0.010615527629852295,
0.004750055260956287,
-0.021745532751083374,
-0.025569191202521324,
-0.01266893558204174,
0.0008894444908946753,
-0.0061370921321213245,
-0.015373832546174526,
0.01650472730398178,
-0.06442751735448837,
0.04573936387896538,
0.007616525981575251,
-0.009512292221188545,
-0.05544956400990486,
-0.008731454610824585,
-0.01097910851240158,
0.0013399292947724462,
-0.007771756500005722,
-0.00036082701990380883,
0.053128063678741455,
-0.00021929510694462806,
0.00026656410773284733,
0.02465379424393177,
0.001454952172935009,
0.028248198330402374,
-0.030310234054923058,
0.000603503140155226,
-0.046286921948194504,
0.04667419195175171,
0.06109330803155899,
0.011040870100259781,
0.009613385424017906,
-0.002200863789767027,
-0.025525150820612907,
-0.004415488336235285,
0.013427873142063618,
0.025133812800049782,
0.03608265146613121,
-0.015723254531621933,
-0.005802641622722149,
0.018501220270991325,
-0.03375723212957382,
0.079402856528759,
0.009189394302666187,
0.025668857619166374,
0.01568554900586605,
0.0610678531229496,
0.017966676503419876,
0.0005867734435014427,
-0.021245788782835007,
-0.04591841623187065,
0.06374820321798325,
0.01605912670493126,
-0.022242173552513123,
-0.06284681707620621,
-0.018628394231200218,
-0.006134351249784231,
-0.03499317169189453,
-0.01711774803698063,
0.037369754165410995,
-0.016137195751070976,
-0.01247953437268734,
0.02595454268157482,
0.04892795905470848,
0.028897970914840698,
-0.023050276562571526,
0.029280485585331917,
-0.025265751406550407,
0.0004960354417562485,
-0.01683945581316948,
-0.0251865666359663,
0.022938039153814316,
0.062933050096035,
-0.01533324271440506,
0.005359120201319456,
0.03175085410475731,
-0.02164269983768463,
0.0028962057549506426,
-0.0004890006384812295,
-0.047573477029800415,
0.004674383904784918,
-0.011068027466535568,
-0.01412845030426979,
0.0034689600579440594,
0.025424590334296227,
-0.04167506843805313,
-0.012885128147900105,
-0.018288472667336464,
-0.014773162081837654,
-0.035860855132341385,
-0.023352529853582382,
0.033284302800893784,
0.031366512179374695,
-0.002088290872052312,
0.019213058054447174,
0.040268298238515854,
-0.07249144464731216,
0.030772916972637177,
-0.012341435998678207,
-0.03463566303253174,
-0.005026401951909065,
-0.024669146165251732,
0.01954811066389084,
-0.018205007538199425,
0.02945641241967678,
0.028950560837984085,
0.01734934002161026,
0.019556676968932152,
0.011947140097618103,
0.018691109493374825,
-0.028590954840183258,
-0.02739916928112507,
-0.0004063243104610592,
0.01413446944206953,
-0.030056115239858627,
-0.009835087694227695,
0.014444767497479916,
0.01030727382749319,
0.026290487498044968,
0.005192098207771778,
0.0022949858102947474,
0.019271323457360268,
0.015727858990430832,
-0.003755490528419614,
0.0005630062660202384,
0.02557060681283474,
0.02463260479271412,
0.004571201279759407,
0.03627724573016167,
0.005551498848944902,
0.004638876765966415,
0.0008881596731953323,
0.0319388285279274,
0.01815309002995491,
0.005650952458381653,
-0.0071067214012146,
-0.027694521471858025,
-0.06497437506914139,
0.027637843042612076,
-0.04107825458049774,
0.01423460990190506,
0.006510998122394085,
0.0392681248486042,
0.021342912688851357,
-0.007210578303784132,
0.009247261099517345,
0.012413805350661278,
0.03034171834588051,
0.021100929006934166,
0.0369136780500412,
0.02291828580200672,
0.023852113634347916,
0.014724815264344215,
-0.03789813444018364,
0.07170850038528442,
0.027152860537171364,
-0.00457409443333745,
-0.05291448533535004,
0.03432906046509743,
-0.010689894668757915,
-0.016408458352088928,
0.03341829404234886,
0.05585348606109619,
-0.0051794215105473995,
-0.03673505410552025,
-0.037584539502859116,
-0.007128504570573568,
-0.1523333042860031,
-0.0362037755548954,
-0.007050409913063049,
0.02186661586165428,
-0.0022564923856407404,
0.0011787438997998834,
-0.04097909852862358,
0.01836060918867588,
-0.06876160949468613,
0.024253148585557938,
0.011707982048392296,
-0.03370331972837448,
-0.004505111835896969,
0.04973757266998291,
0.0468025729060173,
-0.010798733681440353,
0.013244425877928734,
0.010426034219563007,
0.0005811964510940015,
-0.024037521332502365,
0.004518899135291576,
-0.03668564185500145,
0.052844781428575516,
-0.01322444248944521,
0.0015414273366332054,
-0.006180606782436371,
-0.007586788386106491,
-0.009189519099891186,
-0.027952944859862328,
0.01575777679681778,
0.010361948050558567,
0.004793019965291023,
-0.011870662681758404,
0.02153446339070797,
-0.010618197731673717,
0.0428798571228981,
0.06061933934688568,
-0.05587388947606087,
-0.014012003317475319,
-0.05196065828204155,
0.03462965413928032,
0.032863274216651917,
0.008667741902172565,
0.03825534135103226,
0.007028660736978054,
-0.061186783015728,
-0.020316939800977707,
-0.018986482173204422,
0.004491402301937342,
0.04099953919649124,
-0.0016127971466630697,
0.009692653082311153,
-0.027555245906114578,
-0.04570849984884262,
-0.004593151621520519,
-0.04926785081624985,
0.036721061915159225,
0.007194508332759142,
-0.04675192013382912,
-0.04102199152112007,
-0.06066880375146866,
-0.0631343275308609,
-0.006755473092198372,
-0.0033648430835455656,
-0.011945340782403946,
-0.0052331495098769665,
-0.021317733451724052,
-0.03892074525356293,
0.02054074965417385,
0.021241014823317528,
0.0038626526948064566,
-0.030197519809007645,
-0.00999731570482254,
-0.022244807332754135,
0.04969244450330734,
0.05604758486151695,
-0.046489231288433075,
-0.002874737372621894,
-0.02351430431008339,
-0.09238720685243607,
0.007189767435193062,
0.019591955468058586,
-0.025770267471671104,
0.007181340828537941,
0.00015338834782596678,
0.044867582619190216,
0.005751327145844698,
0.06667637079954147,
-0.03573745861649513,
0.2593671679496765,
-0.015941860154271126,
0.006848308723419905,
0.019200263544917107,
0.0037203386891633272,
-0.045743901282548904,
0.010018957778811455,
0.0548340268433094,
-0.0018482606392353773,
-0.044525790959596634,
0.0024785485584288836,
-0.004949552472680807,
0.024354200810194016,
0.017046498134732246,
0.015347481705248356,
0.01336738746613264,
-0.0728888139128685,
-0.01329125091433525,
0.0786684900522232,
0.0015838484978303313,
0.05737769603729248,
0.0021171977277845144,
-0.020425423979759216,
0.0195696372538805,
-0.060860712081193924,
-0.06162218004465103,
0.027165602892637253,
0.029890399426221848,
-0.055687014013528824,
0.012568367645144463,
-0.020520208403468132,
0.004148129373788834,
0.03970974311232567,
0.026223136112093925,
0.048767201602458954,
0.00595683790743351,
-0.02360798791050911,
-0.009867417626082897,
0.014367658644914627,
0.011548233218491077,
-0.010988998226821423,
-0.04453974589705467,
0.01670769788324833,
-0.027843885123729706,
-0.01076008751988411,
-0.005757087841629982,
-0.061716072261333466,
0.013561910018324852,
-0.01210028026252985,
-0.014197154901921749,
0.01169789768755436,
0.030239079147577286,
-0.0007149696466512978,
-0.015733180567622185,
-0.003056503366678953,
0.06638940423727036,
-0.015484288334846497,
0.03901642933487892,
-0.006941019091755152,
0.04938095062971115,
0.009638317860662937,
0.039839036762714386,
-0.012675628066062927,
0.026081684976816177,
0.003572899615392089,
-0.016184097155928612,
-0.07913791388273239,
-0.03820744901895523,
0.04232368245720863,
0.027229933068156242,
0.02060844749212265,
0.032292649149894714,
0.017155401408672333,
-0.00992639921605587,
0.022486619651317596,
-0.03867267072200775,
-0.026839254423975945,
0.028007052838802338,
-0.02894817665219307,
0.023241806775331497,
-0.01784111000597477,
-0.022967498749494553,
-0.018964866176247597,
0.01975952461361885,
0.02138199843466282,
0.008002301678061485,
-0.0255865640938282,
0.04567412659525871,
-0.005836119409650564,
-0.0030801689717918634,
-0.041309453547000885,
0.0013060588389635086,
-0.0015705506084486842,
-0.017145156860351562,
-0.022392727434635162,
-0.020829323679208755,
-0.014956185594201088,
0.005623000208288431,
-0.046357132494449615,
-0.06593269109725952,
-0.011237584054470062,
0.02001277729868889,
0.03267969563603401,
-0.02187551185488701,
0.012516111135482788,
0.011850173585116863,
-0.017315490171313286,
0.029248399659991264,
-0.0405883826315403,
0.018341753631830215,
-0.015033233910799026,
0.01914399117231369,
-0.011147070676088333,
0.0005530694616027176,
0.03618020564317703,
0.06085510924458504,
-0.004395157564431429,
0.058643683791160583,
0.018208734691143036,
0.025232810527086258,
0.006362137384712696,
0.0021407052408903837,
-0.037118587642908096,
0.005222111474722624,
-0.0033754319883883,
-0.021051425486803055,
-0.02274251915514469,
-0.01667007803916931,
0.026769880205392838,
0.015323180705308914,
0.0012232015142217278,
-0.02892765961587429,
-0.015257265418767929,
0.016555653885006905,
0.04698456823825836,
0.020904850214719772,
0.006068679969757795,
-0.00764245493337512,
-0.03325999155640602,
0.03564758598804474,
-0.0407293327152729,
0.010910642333328724,
-0.010491343215107918,
-0.017203809693455696,
0.009348667226731777,
0.04156716912984848,
-0.062084272503852844,
0.002519280184060335,
-0.031111963093280792,
0.009507056325674057,
0.03182103484869003,
0.04010322690010071,
-0.059422414749860764,
-0.04856729507446289,
0.020419366657733917,
0.010903267189860344,
-0.021162156015634537,
-0.02197098918259144,
0.04220632091164589,
-0.039922721683979034,
0.006699129939079285,
0.03054007887840271,
0.015058633871376514,
0.002141697332262993,
-0.0039511388167738914,
0.047395505011081696,
-0.0004898239276371896,
0.03732090815901756,
0.053271278738975525,
-0.029278291389346123,
-0.013159211724996567,
-0.05892707780003548,
-0.04463633894920349,
0.050777897238731384,
0.025391818955540657,
0.01210379134863615,
-0.006221436429768801,
0.006645194720476866,
0.00016868925013113767,
-0.024383651092648506,
0.05230644345283508,
0.018210818991065025,
-0.03273731842637062,
0.012749719433486462,
0.005027965176850557,
-0.00578464986756444,
0.008602297864854336,
-0.027523530647158623,
0.027772122994065285,
-0.05186968669295311,
-0.0035289712250232697,
0.07108931243419647,
0.019430633634328842,
-0.009139820002019405,
0.010696847923099995,
0.016770964488387108,
-0.008638419210910797,
0.051185693591833115,
-0.0069557796232402325,
-0.021193111315369606,
-0.0018143201014027,
-0.020749688148498535,
0.00986428651958704,
0.0028792577795684338,
0.024404678493738174,
-0.004104308784008026,
-0.0005687971715815365,
0.056806858628988266,
-0.04844554141163826,
-0.020429560914635658,
0.02399507723748684,
0.0363679900765419,
-0.030087877064943314,
0.01834721304476261,
0.0039699929766356945,
-0.04011824354529381,
0.02079775743186474,
0.06803454458713531,
0.03480035439133644,
-0.03784871846437454,
-0.004759479779750109,
-0.018590716645121574,
0.04543319717049599,
-0.002214923268184066,
-0.033024419099092484,
-0.00004211116902297363,
-0.04103279858827591,
-0.014821036718785763,
-0.040421560406684875,
0.0007747734780423343,
-0.00358953676186502,
-0.08626196533441544,
0.07115393877029419,
-0.06157418712973595,
0.01264315564185381,
-0.02533561922609806,
0.046308789402246475,
-0.013416403904557228,
0.0022220085375010967,
-0.022219737991690636,
0.04292641207575798,
0.00582266366109252,
0.05181267857551575,
0.029809027910232544,
0.013799254782497883,
-0.02049403078854084,
0.016583895310759544,
-0.017652394250035286,
0.03015270084142685,
0.03228358179330826,
0.014565476216375828,
0.015898996964097023,
-0.009791197255253792,
-0.016663063317537308,
0.03551698476076126,
-0.0073614041320979595,
0.031642161309719086,
-0.04162171483039856,
-0.008629251271486282,
-0.023481329903006554,
-0.007657884620130062,
-0.003128585871309042,
0.008821249008178711,
-0.031248005107045174,
-0.07936884462833405,
-0.06337128579616547,
0.018108876422047615,
-0.02734215557575226,
-0.04356655478477478,
-0.02200624905526638,
-0.019685326144099236,
-0.002751890104264021,
0.009958622977137566,
-0.05970868095755577,
0.0073393722996115685,
-0.024689806625247,
-0.019299928098917007,
0.0010699870763346553,
-0.022709405049681664,
0.01724439300596714,
0.00443062512204051,
0.008072610013186932,
0.032701559364795685,
0.0028687368612736464,
-0.002427198924124241,
0.025351859629154205,
-0.0061552696861326694,
-0.02562316134572029,
0.0038097393698990345,
0.008624606765806675,
0.00241743098013103,
-0.0005354881868697703,
-0.023435847833752632,
0.038308363407850266,
-0.012041052803397179,
-0.018068131059408188,
-0.0329543799161911,
0.054515570402145386,
-0.013832063414156437,
0.017878729850053787,
-0.030700726434588432,
-0.03207201510667801,
-0.016173388808965683,
-0.03133609890937805,
-0.03924505040049553,
0.005902099888771772,
-0.014021722599864006,
-0.005035110749304295,
-0.018912453204393387,
0.009077713824808598,
0.021786289289593697,
-0.09025947749614716,
0.04210640490055084,
0.014731531031429768,
0.0171198770403862,
-0.010448622517287731,
0.022397834807634354,
0.010845454409718513,
-0.03163215517997742,
-0.008272897452116013,
-0.003839717945083976,
-0.0019313093507662416,
-0.05967289209365845,
0.023111212998628616,
-0.05598948150873184,
-0.01941259577870369,
0.0217593964189291,
-0.02915377914905548,
-0.054224591702222824,
0.025004111230373383,
-0.019823219627141953,
-0.017893357202410698,
-0.016221512109041214,
0.0013810594100505114,
0.024502422660589218,
0.02644067443907261,
0.007728196680545807,
-0.05456843972206116,
0.039447084069252014,
-0.057077113538980484,
-0.023381147533655167,
-0.038588669151067734,
0.08284828811883926,
0.0020390984136611223,
-0.006014770362526178,
-0.022557653486728668,
0.019329402595758438,
0.034674983471632004,
0.01818983070552349,
0.005677560344338417,
-0.016849612817168236,
-0.008798858150839806,
-0.0023349886760115623,
-0.07086137682199478,
-0.019772805273532867,
0.009001124650239944,
-0.010450833477079868,
0.030256561934947968,
0.013709980994462967,
-0.021993353962898254,
-0.018692923709750175,
0.03141922131180763,
0.01953190751373768,
-0.01403465773910284,
-0.023501534014940262,
-0.023673130199313164,
0.03815628960728645,
0.015266293659806252,
-0.02469796873629093,
-0.00007668020407436416,
-0.011079649440944195,
-0.02249392867088318,
-0.009522934444248676,
-0.004832732956856489,
-0.03890351206064224,
0.03924504294991493,
0.0103217838332057,
0.024505598470568657,
0.0008053097408264875,
-0.05232313275337219,
-0.0031974853482097387,
-0.01833650842308998,
0.009955218061804771,
-0.013312408700585365,
0.012246903032064438,
-0.004606397822499275,
-0.009344385005533695,
0.033653002232313156,
0.024639436975121498,
0.020443454384803772,
-0.013723237439990044,
0.027315130457282066,
-0.0035022320225834846,
-0.012381086125969887,
-0.14424797892570496,
-0.033300869166851044,
-0.014646508730947971,
-0.0227854885160923,
-0.021197674795985222,
-0.002692663110792637,
-0.02312185987830162,
0.03245404362678528,
-0.030777735635638237,
0.005175394471734762,
-0.0018907004268839955,
-0.028006458654999733,
0.021983526647090912,
-0.015072021633386612,
-0.02602653205394745,
-0.004583463538438082,
-0.024541137740015984,
-0.0038611518684774637,
-0.08050370961427689,
0.03675736486911774,
0.020380012691020966,
-0.006596246734261513,
-0.00010865845979424194,
-0.0030330554582178593,
0.034129220992326736,
-0.014255356974899769,
0.014808414503932,
-0.06504233926534653,
-0.03733354061841965,
-0.008951444178819656,
-0.03742919862270355,
-0.014167683199048042,
0.011492401361465454,
0.05836109817028046,
-0.01566562056541443,
0.021431654691696167,
0.003731111064553261,
-0.03898922726511955,
-0.02233082801103592,
0.002200572518631816,
-0.017779894173145294,
0.0318019762635231,
0.0002986943582072854,
-0.023794159293174744,
0.00974159687757492,
0.017819862812757492,
0.0028480379842221737,
-0.024446656927466393,
-0.07435965538024902,
-0.03696310892701149,
-0.03440895304083824,
0.0257565937936306,
0.00854889489710331,
0.026574812829494476,
-0.03607361018657684,
-0.007792733609676361,
-0.005402329843491316,
-0.030903758481144905,
0.013039078563451767,
0.03310660645365715,
0.0037221016827970743,
0.0028860443271696568,
-0.04427133873105049,
-0.006852578371763229,
-0.0361853688955307,
-0.030712513253092766,
-0.03089904598891735,
-0.013418855145573616,
-0.04413006082177162,
0.008579984307289124,
-0.009047074243426323,
-0.03882547467947006,
0.03232823684811592,
-0.06112631782889366,
0.019788343459367752,
-0.01236633025109768,
-0.007826698012650013,
0.005197435617446899,
-0.029719466343522072,
-0.026401527225971222,
-0.026855945587158203,
0.015060771256685257,
-0.058915507048368454,
-0.007054281886667013,
0.08282697945833206,
0.042353272438049316,
0.003306151134893298,
-0.019288375973701477,
0.010743162594735622,
-0.0344494991004467,
-0.054471779614686966,
-0.010976247489452362,
0.019714144989848137,
0.023672863841056824,
-0.013826718553900719,
0.03923197463154793,
-0.008564513176679611,
-0.010286186821758747,
0.010312053374946117,
0.005701940506696701,
-0.03145870938897133,
0.0113521758466959,
-0.0007002114434726536,
-0.0009478345746174455,
-0.04513034224510193,
-0.014423493295907974,
0.07406267523765564,
0.0030095658730715513,
0.017818814143538475,
-0.022429756820201874,
0.0007371183601208031,
0.016072161495685577,
-0.03220874071121216,
0.051883403211832047,
-0.027455709874629974,
0.013277807272970676,
-0.007284423802047968,
0.026005951687693596,
0.01708149164915085,
0.004171299748122692,
0.05330081284046173,
0.018719414249062538,
-0.00006320601096376777,
-0.043927088379859924,
0.0044973259791731834,
-0.010813724249601364,
0.05949670448899269,
0.034171536564826965,
-0.0017148617189377546,
-0.031584542244672775,
0.02105087973177433,
-0.008388202637434006,
0.00679629435762763,
0.04614686965942383,
-0.0045433733612298965,
0.0038687833584845066,
-0.02034427970647812,
0.00034018547739833593,
-0.04294317215681076,
-0.026520641520619392,
-0.016330014914274216,
-0.008470265194773674,
0.000891686649993062,
0.0033385660499334335,
-0.04079138860106468,
0.003651915118098259,
0.029094859957695007,
-0.013688134960830212,
-0.029867691919207573,
-0.011669062077999115,
-0.011671493761241436,
0.0217739287763834,
0.0023501317482441664,
0.055405739694833755,
0.029289117082953453,
0.03398599475622177,
0.041676927357912064,
-0.0006348203169181943,
0.02880285307765007,
0.058580182492733,
0.02292008511722088,
-0.0633283481001854,
-0.06933317333459854,
-0.05341022089123726,
-0.014167937450110912,
0.0404636412858963,
-0.030232761055231094,
0.02552081272006035,
-0.051686543971300125,
-0.030222084373235703,
-0.02468860149383545,
-0.005087402183562517,
-0.023052094504237175,
0.03564921021461487,
0.004916402976959944,
-0.01987370103597641,
-0.0005094240186735988,
-0.0036243631038814783,
0.051754601299762726,
-0.016203779727220535,
0.04487929865717888,
0.027865484356880188,
0.011686970479786396,
-0.00009054367546923459,
0.013477657921612263,
0.013612718321383,
0.015322876162827015,
0.04405033960938454,
-0.0059781987220048904,
-0.03013589046895504,
-0.015056168660521507,
0.034073907881975174,
0.009120909497141838,
-0.0010724887251853943,
0.058204591274261475,
0.02559145912528038,
-0.005134950391948223,
0.03167015314102173,
-0.005514899734407663,
0.043972451239824295,
0.021109556779265404,
-0.020836884155869484,
-0.034040942788124084,
-0.008428596891462803,
-0.008694552816450596,
0.038363970816135406,
-0.03276445344090462,
-0.0527130588889122,
-0.029620788991451263,
0.05154770240187645,
-0.005264716222882271,
0.012041792273521423,
-0.03231815621256828,
0.03017492964863777,
-0.011238954029977322,
0.010179313831031322,
0.0135949170216918,
0.012729906477034092,
0.01690737158060074,
-0.018032267689704895,
0.04271576926112175,
0.0213293619453907,
-0.0013790277298539877,
-0.018425414338707924,
-0.021124012768268585,
-0.016934165731072426,
-0.03749889135360718,
0.025917910039424896,
0.02294437773525715,
0.04684358462691307,
-0.009497671388089657,
0.04210236668586731,
-0.0005121129215694964,
0.061218712478876114,
-0.030268846079707146,
-0.03399105742573738,
-0.034123118966817856,
-0.02902260608971119,
-0.008391781710088253,
-0.008088446222245693,
0.03197666257619858,
0.0044935718178749084,
-0.003937749192118645,
-0.024666430428624153
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:45
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
The failure to have $12 million (approx) available from the new funder at settlement to discharge all current liabilities of HTT is a matter of concern. Nevertheless, LEC, in the spirit of cooperation and goodwill, has instructed us that the Withdrawal of Caveat be made available today, for the settlement provided that the various prerequisites to settlement (...) are fulfilled".
669Mr Hilliard's letter was written in light of Mr Gillard's letter of 26 August 2004 and on the assumption that $4.5 million (rather than $12 million) would be available on settlement.
670Nonetheless, the letter indicated a preparedness on Mr Hilliard's behalf (and thus Mr Zdrilic's behalf) to "proceed with today's settlement" notwithstanding that clause 4.
7 of the Heads of Agreement (pursuant to which HTT was obliged to "obtain sufficient finance from a new funder" to payout HTT's secured creditors) "had not been complied with yet and will not have been complied with at the conclusion of the proposed settlement to occur today".
671The letter is significant for a number of reasons.
672First it indicates to me that whatever had been said, to this point, about the availability of funds was overtaken by the announcement in the letter.
673The letter announced that the plaintiffs proposed to proceed to settle, notwithstanding the fact that, on their case, the one matter that mattered most to them (the availability of funds) had not and was not going to occur.
674Not only that, the plaintiffs indicated that they proposed to consent to the proposed clause 8.4 of the Non-Dilution Deed which was in the following terms:-
"Notwithstanding the terms of the Heads of Agreement, the parties accept that each party has substantially complied with the obligations under the Heads of Agreement and that there is no subsisting breach to which this part currently applies."
675There was thus to be a waiver of any non-compliance with the terms of the Heads of Agreement including, critically, clause 4.7.
676Further, although this is not stated in terms in the letter, the letter made clear that there was indeed to be a "2 Stage" settlement and that Mr Hilliard accepted that a critical aspect of "Stage 2" (pursuant to which HTT would comply with the balance of its obligations under clause 4.
7 of the Heads of Agreement - namely to provide the balance (over and above $4.5 million) of the estimated $12 million required to pay out HTT's secured creditors) would not occur on 27 August 2004.
677Further, Mr Hilliard was proposing to hand over the Withdrawal of Caveat (an integral part of "Stage 2").
678As will emerge shortly, the matter was made even clearer when it became apparent, two hours later, that no funds at all were to be provided on 27 August 2004.
679It is plain that, at this stage, Mr Hilliard expected that Mr Moir would attend the settlement on behalf of the "new funder". He made a note of "parties expected to attend" which included Mr Moir.
680Mr Gillard's letter raised two matters.
681First it enclosed a copy of an early draft of the 15 March 2004 IPC Heads of Agreement. I shall return to this below.
682Second Mr Gillard said:-
"As previously indicated, the arrangements with the funder are not finalized and are subject to commercial negotiations concluding.
Our client believes that on conclusion of those negotiations funds in accordance with the Heads of Agreement between our parties will be available but that a commercially acceptable substituted arrangement substantially in accordance with the terms of clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement will satisfy the requirements of that Agreement.
In any case our client will rely on clause 8.4 of the Deed of Non-Dilution and Merger in relation to that issue".
683What Mr Gillard meant by his expression "as previously indicated" was not explored in cross-examination. So far as the evidence reveals, this letter comprised the first occasion on which any suggestion was made to the plaintiffs that arrangements with the funder were "not finalised" and were "subject to commercial negotiations concluding".
|
[
-0.006358567625284195,
0.012048391625285149,
-0.03406648710370064,
0.020696716383099556,
0.024300839751958847,
-0.05480065196752548,
-0.0005299454205669463,
-0.01686541549861431,
0.005972599610686302,
-0.0017906513530761003,
0.035718146711587906,
0.01859402097761631,
-0.03192612901329994,
0.014751268550753593,
-0.026336366310715675,
-0.03194781020283699,
0.029268814250826836,
-0.018479766324162483,
-0.007144518196582794,
0.0003068318183068186,
-0.04059627279639244,
-0.006340398453176022,
0.004906865768134594,
0.013528897427022457,
-0.033831749111413956,
-0.009375103749334812,
-0.0363348163664341,
-0.011559413745999336,
0.016371244564652443,
0.026931583881378174,
-0.0002424813574180007,
0.0033852665219455957,
0.026195399463176727,
-0.01565701887011528,
0.01669120043516159,
-0.03129146620631218,
0.01619310863316059,
0.0029313666746020317,
-0.029410922899842262,
0.023304350674152374,
-0.02615622617304325,
0.03769795596599579,
0.012551429681479931,
-0.028928030282258987,
0.07086188346147537,
-0.022107569500803947,
-0.0022212930489331484,
-0.019976701587438583,
0.010773789137601852,
0.020839471369981766,
-0.03252362087368965,
-0.05195387825369835,
0.04245736822485924,
-0.028566988185048103,
-0.021798662841320038,
-0.011130502447485924,
-0.011205206625163555,
-0.011427945457398891,
-0.0435846745967865,
-0.0033791186287999153,
-0.019666658714413643,
-0.011985019780695438,
-0.05689670518040657,
0.005314030218869448,
-0.00015684906975366175,
0.06669699400663376,
0.01806710846722126,
-0.003153652884066105,
0.017811177298426628,
-0.009289251640439034,
-0.023959044367074966,
0.0025261545088142157,
-0.016411401331424713,
0.01834956742823124,
-0.09351847320795059,
0.039460472762584686,
-0.0008774016750976443,
0.010810043662786484,
0.011414051987230778,
-0.009146873839199543,
0.031499773263931274,
-0.016739849001169205,
-0.0020708234515041113,
0.05512000992894173,
-0.045359574258327484,
-0.0014504323480650783,
0.006933729629963636,
0.02524789422750473,
0.04572557285428047,
-0.017806097865104675,
0.002698110183700919,
-0.007603650446981192,
0.015525090508162975,
-0.05000561103224754,
-0.018251290544867516,
-0.009316123090684414,
-0.08130734413862228,
0.03815625235438347,
-0.03368045389652252,
0.009983996860682964,
0.009214158169925213,
0.04402690753340721,
-0.01590309478342533,
-0.01371036283671856,
0.03390471264719963,
0.03207279369235039,
0.05963965877890587,
0.02154874987900257,
0.027488643303513527,
-0.0038299690932035446,
0.005667758174240589,
-0.024019811302423477,
0.03261806070804596,
-0.017439814284443855,
-0.025600090622901917,
0.022061947733163834,
0.010429336689412594,
-0.009149299934506416,
0.0051699550822377205,
-0.008525778539478779,
0.03120611608028412,
0.0010986959096044302,
0.03462513908743858,
-0.030089030042290688,
-0.029840625822544098,
-0.007357083726674318,
-0.004985965322703123,
-0.021505137905478477,
0.015371602028608322,
0.032707855105400085,
0.01813206635415554,
0.031525492668151855,
-0.043761249631643295,
-0.025340648368000984,
-0.024849018082022667,
0.033557310700416565,
0.02111665904521942,
0.011601926758885384,
0.019015483558177948,
-0.054409321397542953,
0.018708378076553345,
0.028358427807688713,
-0.006280421745032072,
-0.07827411592006683,
0.037900425493717194,
-0.043524786829948425,
0.029275404289364815,
-0.004146429244428873,
0.012393112294375896,
0.015017660334706306,
0.007027692161500454,
0.0075112031772732735,
0.0031984976958483458,
0.0029940831009298563,
0.05091646686196327,
-0.06703845411539078,
-0.02463562786579132,
-0.015974970534443855,
0.0017465612618252635,
0.08628397434949875,
-0.015897998586297035,
0.05666421726346016,
-0.01826596073806286,
-0.0230716485530138,
-0.01568424701690674,
0.005403182469308376,
0.011625133454799652,
0.03308374807238579,
-0.02365419827401638,
-0.005241836421191692,
0.024931320920586586,
-0.02497950755059719,
0.050944115966558456,
-0.006012073718011379,
-0.0019432840636000037,
0.024953650310635567,
0.06777267158031464,
0.008575232699513435,
0.021053077653050423,
-0.011934681795537472,
-0.024221742525696754,
0.035784006118774414,
0.004757174756377935,
-0.03686903417110443,
-0.03748209401965141,
0.03167662397027016,
-0.012460666708648205,
-0.02429276518523693,
-0.015227233059704304,
0.0020455343183130026,
-0.01763283833861351,
-0.011590751819312572,
0.028319060802459717,
0.04996030032634735,
0.008322647772729397,
-0.012068449519574642,
-0.008044106885790825,
-0.044506680220365524,
-0.026871955022215843,
-0.02695118449628353,
-0.027337802574038506,
0.019779611378908157,
0.06748110055923462,
0.0042140972800552845,
-0.02516566775739193,
-0.003109883051365614,
-0.02249552495777607,
-0.010146450251340866,
-0.012883666902780533,
-0.06266158819198608,
-0.03182806819677353,
0.0026905459817498922,
-0.0297496747225523,
-0.0070191980339586735,
-0.0040054237470030785,
-0.019390413537621498,
0.014069722034037113,
-0.009919845499098301,
-0.01383827906101942,
-0.02260284125804901,
0.0068602547980844975,
-0.014710074290633202,
0.0010485220700502396,
-0.0021997380536049604,
0.023046690970659256,
0.05622923746705055,
-0.06160233914852142,
0.01909828372299671,
0.011244363151490688,
-0.014601855538785458,
0.002943560015410185,
-0.021817320957779884,
0.019649842754006386,
0.014574384316802025,
0.04378792643547058,
0.03861282020807266,
0.02430119551718235,
0.021857257932424545,
0.005604892037808895,
0.005169338546693325,
-0.017579322680830956,
0.029520714655518532,
-0.027839815244078636,
-0.01575569249689579,
-0.023258589208126068,
-0.01411838922649622,
-0.0051491959020495415,
0.0033968219067901373,
0.0124466298148036,
-0.01284105610102415,
0.02905365638434887,
-0.016517138108611107,
-0.012187597341835499,
-0.0007814971613697708,
-0.004176781512796879,
0.02671719901263714,
-0.007383993826806545,
-0.00844478141516447,
0.04116728529334068,
0.03803341090679169,
0.023769915103912354,
0.02005116455256939,
0.05831659957766533,
0.01766878180205822,
-0.017311204224824905,
0.005422678310424089,
-0.046205248683691025,
-0.056949637830257416,
0.04477307200431824,
-0.019531330093741417,
0.02149416320025921,
0.003125588409602642,
-0.0005034012719988823,
0.0353442020714283,
0.013841193169355392,
0.03648527339100838,
0.0343865305185318,
0.011865299195051193,
0.027897978201508522,
-0.007000194862484932,
-0.014209434390068054,
0.032295383512973785,
0.04857022687792778,
-0.020200906321406364,
0.03850870952010155,
0.057534243911504745,
-0.04176893085241318,
-0.02962619997560978,
0.021906230598688126,
0.019291283562779427,
0.004823942203074694,
0.013613061979413033,
0.07823649793863297,
0.0021739741787314415,
-0.054902393370866776,
-0.050619687885046005,
-0.013609075918793678,
-0.15691834688186646,
0.006831197999417782,
-0.0001611967309145257,
-0.0006235925247892737,
0.004432546440511942,
0.028978748247027397,
-0.01679486595094204,
0.0035156067460775375,
-0.02342696487903595,
-0.008706474676728249,
0.016222620382905006,
-0.06657763570547104,
0.0068302820436656475,
0.044458456337451935,
-0.015211209654808044,
-0.0124356122687459,
-0.02560540661215782,
0.04169856011867523,
0.04573312774300575,
-0.052251044660806656,
-0.030755875632166862,
-0.046009790152311325,
0.056449998170137405,
-0.042553845793008804,
0.019271861761808395,
0.020335862413048744,
0.00005025127757107839,
0.02574663609266281,
-0.06596484780311584,
0.0000165078690770315,
-0.06616256386041641,
0.020449895411729813,
-0.018271377310156822,
0.06802894920110703,
-0.016203513368964195,
0.04565615579485893,
0.08656766265630722,
-0.07198304682970047,
-0.00394422048702836,
-0.02513369917869568,
0.023603130131959915,
0.026412233710289,
-0.011724807322025299,
-0.006210744380950928,
-0.001931299571879208,
-0.06254489719867706,
0.0005765585228800774,
0.023563634604215622,
-0.011042729020118713,
0.02569861337542534,
0.02398703061044216,
0.00877887848764658,
-0.04535232111811638,
-0.057613201439380646,
-0.013562049716711044,
-0.025250839069485664,
0.027106929570436478,
0.03969322890043259,
-0.020862357690930367,
0.0016734619857743382,
-0.01178676076233387,
-0.06597461551427841,
0.014875256456434727,
0.023406535387039185,
-0.04360956698656082,
0.0026762126944959164,
-0.01794946938753128,
-0.025741785764694214,
0.0490410253405571,
-0.0019558167550712824,
0.013027322478592396,
-0.0164293572306633,
0.02054494619369507,
-0.0054159280844032764,
0.027004415169358253,
0.04751332849264145,
-0.0370846726000309,
-0.006473778281360865,
-0.004852211568504572,
-0.09378373622894287,
-0.00714239152148366,
0.057601574808359146,
-0.007449086289852858,
0.02918851748108864,
0.004969774279743433,
0.01906505413353443,
0.015782881528139114,
0.04820755124092102,
0.022030316293239594,
0.24459417164325714,
0.0005591947701759636,
0.008107577450573444,
0.07339552044868469,
0.02457711473107338,
-0.010555322282016277,
0.011434477753937244,
0.029686495661735535,
-0.04510726034641266,
-0.05997784063220024,
-0.03459802642464638,
0.017053067684173584,
0.023255575448274612,
0.027286719530820847,
0.0053709703497588634,
0.038152918219566345,
-0.04064469039440155,
-0.009230796247720718,
0.0847432017326355,
0.007605704944580793,
0.054973553866147995,
-0.02522224932909012,
-0.004747969098389149,
0.022236071527004242,
-0.08544529229402542,
-0.055851954966783524,
0.009830312803387642,
0.0650145411491394,
-0.03753821551799774,
-0.003312637796625495,
-0.028132818639278412,
-0.00494147976860404,
0.03568342328071594,
-0.021900402382016182,
-0.007444301620125771,
-0.005972117651253939,
-0.00561028067022562,
0.022143634036183357,
-0.006793172098696232,
0.028268106281757355,
0.009034732356667519,
-0.043200500309467316,
0.008341203443706036,
-0.030635729432106018,
-0.07117222249507904,
0.026954161003232002,
-0.033776018768548965,
0.04509171470999718,
-0.02425660565495491,
0.013098949566483498,
-0.016079474240541458,
0.015645204111933708,
-0.02104969136416912,
0.0032698148861527443,
-0.04126851260662079,
0.033555783331394196,
-0.0305017102509737,
0.04525421932339668,
-0.0021011503413319588,
0.040391188114881516,
0.015254482626914978,
0.006664016284048557,
-0.034260861575603485,
0.004128206055611372,
0.004341654479503632,
-0.01696794107556343,
-0.051187869161367416,
-0.0016500725178048015,
0.03367558494210243,
0.03481452539563179,
-0.003764834487810731,
0.02228100225329399,
-0.016454102471470833,
0.011651200242340565,
0.017041847109794617,
-0.01896277628839016,
-0.04206715524196625,
0.024599533528089523,
0.016234016045928,
-0.0027657796163111925,
-0.031532805413007736,
-0.02482886053621769,
-0.029208676889538765,
0.030604610219597816,
0.04091072827577591,
0.026732955127954483,
0.0005372130544856191,
0.04096907749772072,
-0.021853920072317123,
-0.024301854893565178,
-0.02073948085308075,
-0.02864217571914196,
0.01170865073800087,
-0.01911933161318302,
-0.014676887542009354,
-0.02555704303085804,
0.046833109110593796,
-0.02345326356589794,
-0.020399900153279305,
-0.02541372925043106,
-0.020041413605213165,
0.0038982753176242113,
0.01852201297879219,
-0.04259138181805611,
0.023589737713336945,
-0.004086671397089958,
-0.013748329132795334,
-0.021619189530611038,
-0.059999220073223114,
-0.005553722847253084,
-0.03533872961997986,
0.0026056959759444,
-0.002071724971756339,
-0.026354094967246056,
0.04911715164780617,
0.052042435854673386,
-0.011312136426568031,
0.019548235461115837,
0.04081781953573227,
0.000693970883730799,
-0.006917447783052921,
0.015450799837708473,
-0.0092309033498168,
0.021488754078745842,
-0.012541115283966064,
0.0007907141698524356,
0.02378406748175621,
-0.012914832681417465,
-0.0024039207492023706,
-0.0031638217624276876,
0.0032518873922526836,
-0.03708193451166153,
-0.04263291135430336,
0.021497562527656555,
0.020424572750926018,
0.03684234991669655,
0.005983703304082155,
0.0036171053070575,
-0.04686707258224487,
-0.024166211485862732,
-0.043095480650663376,
0.009208323433995247,
-0.029084613546729088,
-0.015670765191316605,
-0.017354222014546394,
0.00996144488453865,
-0.044372912496328354,
0.02386314794421196,
-0.05786849930882454,
0.00962270237505436,
0.009548824280500412,
0.046012140810489655,
-0.010151419788599014,
-0.03345219045877457,
-0.013969768770039082,
-0.032810430973768234,
-0.02407795377075672,
0.009056668728590012,
-0.0015150702092796564,
-0.007236667908728123,
0.004860980436205864,
-0.008700808510184288,
0.007251238450407982,
0.016967574134469032,
0.027229076251387596,
0.07905130088329315,
-0.023845944553613663,
0.042647045105695724,
0.03239114582538605,
-0.03204820677638054,
0.01962261274456978,
-0.028727728873491287,
-0.009823914617300034,
0.07745347172021866,
0.009382613003253937,
0.0038407237734645605,
0.03921886906027794,
0.0511612668633461,
0.020468145608901978,
-0.0171419195830822,
0.043872326612472534,
0.01413352508097887,
-0.040222182869911194,
-0.0005382331437431276,
-0.01060908567160368,
-0.0005458344239741564,
-0.002372721442952752,
-0.006891468074172735,
0.007069692015647888,
-0.06754441559314728,
-0.010675515048205853,
0.05972851812839508,
0.018348129466176033,
-0.013690006919205189,
0.011582750827074051,
-0.02835281752049923,
0.012366184964776039,
0.04711363837122917,
-0.03611694648861885,
-0.007953083142638206,
0.0031488644890487194,
-0.011012106202542782,
0.04360388219356537,
-0.015700535848736763,
0.018436523154377937,
0.0019473072607070208,
-0.0018598362803459167,
0.028234247118234634,
-0.04548582062125206,
-0.01921212300658226,
0.001473326701670885,
0.049822915345430374,
-0.04766971617937088,
0.01255252305418253,
0.01704617775976658,
-0.05241706967353821,
0.021480482071638107,
0.03476036339998245,
0.02155895158648491,
-0.054741956293582916,
-0.007453111000359058,
-0.0024330075830221176,
-0.00746037345379591,
-0.06592598557472229,
-0.009133837185800076,
0.010793045163154602,
-0.05489875003695488,
0.0036448591854423285,
-0.015006856061518192,
-0.007005696184933186,
-0.0072667463682591915,
-0.057622577995061874,
0.03166795149445534,
-0.050737347453832626,
0.003490268252789974,
-0.01585422269999981,
0.07406265288591385,
0.012472926639020443,
0.03747351095080376,
0.02717023901641369,
0.014858718030154705,
-0.026934657245874405,
-0.0012674428289756179,
0.06115349009633064,
0.03042498789727688,
-0.009389749728143215,
0.006303857546299696,
-0.032969918102025986,
-0.03643352538347244,
0.05817379802465439,
0.02756454609334469,
0.044495075941085815,
-0.015578649006783962,
-0.009788168594241142,
0.00953245721757412,
0.010632450692355633,
0.011689549311995506,
-0.01993558555841446,
-0.06332441419363022,
-0.057642098516225815,
0.015895098447799683,
0.008594343438744545,
-0.004297842737287283,
-0.014100544154644012,
-0.04684559255838394,
-0.07822489738464355,
-0.002622222527861595,
-0.0050435299053788185,
-0.01610122062265873,
-0.016615625470876694,
0.013811011798679829,
-0.0266922228038311,
0.019501185044646263,
-0.05795300379395485,
-0.012868370860815048,
-0.008496880531311035,
-0.016278402879834175,
-0.0006266582640819252,
-0.0019692005589604378,
-0.013852455653250217,
0.01676441729068756,
-0.01068587601184845,
0.038511376827955246,
0.013388256542384624,
0.0036654388532042503,
0.0006044512847438455,
-0.033166851848363876,
-0.005294044502079487,
0.029118459671735764,
-0.013530991040170193,
0.006420791614800692,
0.018963128328323364,
0.02387952245771885,
-0.008511756546795368,
0.0002567718329373747,
-0.03677081689238548,
-0.02078079991042614,
0.01101344358175993,
-0.020964350551366806,
0.005540816579014063,
-0.03439491614699364,
-0.02665110118687153,
-0.026641899719834328,
-0.039796777069568634,
-0.028899893164634705,
-0.004543459974229336,
0.007449643686413765,
-0.0044400328770279884,
-0.008048895746469498,
0.037726029753685,
0.004385243635624647,
-0.0791126936674118,
-0.0004217743990011513,
-0.014291119761765003,
0.07255164533853531,
-0.006253854837268591,
0.006280024070292711,
0.016859179362654686,
-0.013572140596807003,
-0.005318907089531422,
0.007628453895449638,
-0.02571646124124527,
-0.035857751965522766,
-0.0011440414236858487,
-0.020297907292842865,
-0.014961672015488148,
0.04584423452615738,
-0.04498179256916046,
-0.0479893684387207,
-0.005006150342524052,
-0.04099000617861748,
0.0007460197666659951,
0.010887084528803825,
-0.007633554749190807,
0.016236120834946632,
-0.003226863220334053,
0.029814191162586212,
0.038270823657512665,
0.07479498535394669,
-0.02932796999812126,
-0.012454956769943237,
-0.05724627524614334,
0.048799801617860794,
0.0030229855328798294,
0.01659872755408287,
0.005015592090785503,
-0.02136768028140068,
-0.021659478545188904,
0.012503408826887608,
0.02100568450987339,
-0.01624368131160736,
0.019547605887055397,
-0.013255965895950794,
-0.03370470553636551,
0.01757514476776123,
0.02228708565235138,
0.012806088663637638,
0.03140319138765335,
0.06053437665104866,
-0.01909375935792923,
-0.0031083030626177788,
0.029599154368042946,
0.004448543768376112,
0.009938095696270466,
-0.0010816151043400168,
-0.006513125263154507,
-0.0035339947789907455,
0.0411904938519001,
0.008241555653512478,
0.01270595658570528,
0.011713122949004173,
-0.03248835727572441,
0.0013309868518263102,
-0.026119442656636238,
-0.050370000302791595,
0.024272773414850235,
0.04020347818732262,
0.03646653890609741,
0.020062945783138275,
-0.07018731534481049,
-0.0201429296284914,
-0.03620241954922676,
-0.04027016833424568,
-0.027411479502916336,
0.03085589036345482,
0.012360571883618832,
0.00380691047757864,
0.029416264966130257,
0.01397496648132801,
-0.002527517732232809,
0.0002728142135310918,
0.026127461344003677,
-0.027248939499258995,
-0.023196926340460777,
-0.14201633632183075,
0.02308640256524086,
-0.002822241047397256,
-0.0035938574001193047,
-0.03155644237995148,
0.003003108548000455,
-0.060332898050546646,
0.03204279765486717,
-0.0421028658747673,
0.003387099364772439,
0.005781855434179306,
-0.018564075231552124,
-0.01589721255004406,
-0.019052701070904732,
-0.025430642068386078,
0.029648957774043083,
-0.03170325234532356,
-0.005222053732722998,
-0.05854185298085213,
0.015807081013917923,
0.03002823144197464,
0.0017943308921530843,
-0.00675584701821208,
-0.011340804398059845,
0.00036478674155659974,
-0.008830121718347073,
0.01201710943132639,
-0.07908739149570465,
-0.01891367882490158,
-0.00983760692179203,
-0.0283182505518198,
0.000024423719878541306,
-0.010206921026110649,
0.051851097494363785,
-0.011940420605242252,
-0.023819928988814354,
0.006627244874835014,
-0.02016298659145832,
-0.019854016602039337,
-0.005263262428343296,
-0.0018959669396281242,
0.004894394427537918,
-0.017101319506764412,
-0.00755007890984416,
0.010426433756947517,
0.026189586147665977,
-0.018426932394504547,
-0.004140704404562712,
-0.08173944056034088,
-0.027876906096935272,
-0.06967512518167496,
0.04862666502594948,
0.012775124050676823,
0.021119659766554832,
-0.007648903410881758,
0.011824233457446098,
0.02558107301592827,
-0.023838002234697342,
0.019697202369570732,
0.046739377081394196,
0.022533835843205452,
-0.0037253117188811302,
-0.07203429937362671,
-0.030744200572371483,
-0.0046087754890322685,
0.0009184182854369283,
-0.03126798942685127,
-0.004377960227429867,
-0.01336994394659996,
0.028721384704113007,
-0.021246887743473053,
-0.033248789608478546,
-0.02494429051876068,
-0.019656796008348465,
0.02638259530067444,
-0.029657209292054176,
0.014530397951602936,
0.013799387030303478,
-0.024689115583896637,
0.003745144931599498,
-0.02269122190773487,
-0.018749238923192024,
-0.06803509593009949,
-0.043666861951351166,
0.09012284874916077,
0.038362130522727966,
-0.010629737749695778,
-0.03491640463471413,
-0.00023312860867008567,
0.0078504029661417,
-0.06203998252749443,
-0.0023899637162685394,
0.008645395748317242,
0.018161268904805183,
-0.037817973643541336,
0.026313170790672302,
0.019856655970215797,
-0.015801602974534035,
-0.003666533622890711,
0.0014890379970893264,
-0.053520724177360535,
-0.010610174387693405,
0.006269263569265604,
0.005288003943860531,
-0.0070069320499897,
0.031002426519989967,
0.042699143290519714,
0.00030397254158742726,
0.014081771485507488,
-0.034467197954654694,
-0.01719316467642784,
-0.010836126282811165,
-0.048274263739585876,
0.011192127130925655,
-0.04818672686815262,
-0.005144823808223009,
0.0022071595303714275,
0.008606011979281902,
-0.023915456607937813,
0.012944640591740608,
0.018887892365455627,
-0.004303859546780586,
0.03197865933179855,
-0.01753370277583599,
0.016840839758515358,
0.016794588416814804,
0.068892702460289,
0.014271991327404976,
0.06124020740389824,
-0.010364927351474762,
0.06362565606832504,
0.0071319034323096275,
-0.0016099035274237394,
0.01812482811510563,
0.020625805482268333,
0.007999254390597343,
-0.026888763532042503,
0.027886690571904182,
-0.03944418579339981,
0.021390968933701515,
-0.01561719086021185,
0.012529319152235985,
0.010609036311507225,
0.015231190249323845,
-0.05310926213860512,
-0.007545141037553549,
0.02771584317088127,
0.013843017630279064,
-0.03031827136874199,
0.0016261186683550477,
-0.027201836928725243,
0.015150063671171665,
0.0045111714862287045,
0.03107389807701111,
0.004533854313194752,
-0.0049008578062057495,
0.01987007074058056,
-0.008411098271608353,
-0.005986155476421118,
0.04935004562139511,
-0.01948787271976471,
-0.02220030315220356,
-0.032817140221595764,
-0.029469670727849007,
-0.002866700990125537,
0.01565791480243206,
-0.016347011551260948,
0.019899902865290642,
-0.0336550772190094,
-0.031214730814099312,
-0.007082150783389807,
0.0343063548207283,
-0.0291640292853117,
0.021087821573019028,
0.04023200273513794,
-0.0452435165643692,
-0.013990437611937523,
-0.02448592521250248,
0.07395731657743454,
-0.019382046535611153,
0.07089852541685104,
0.033245429396629333,
0.024017484858632088,
0.020770326256752014,
0.031792525202035904,
0.0033975476399064064,
0.011044866405427456,
0.011219100095331669,
-0.024874340742826462,
-0.017836859449744225,
-0.016347460448741913,
-0.003076902125030756,
-0.0011767210671678185,
-0.0016241564881056547,
0.03689153492450714,
0.02072414942085743,
0.007618855684995651,
0.019829507917165756,
0.0023845317773520947,
0.02007075399160385,
0.045410703867673874,
-0.0060830689035356045,
-0.01936437375843525,
0.00508685689419508,
-0.011226559057831764,
0.002968022832646966,
0.0020500170066952705,
-0.04568552225828171,
-0.028691474348306656,
0.04251513630151749,
-0.016087783500552177,
-0.018460553139448166,
-0.025743627920746803,
0.007143524941056967,
-0.02246631309390068,
0.02793843485414982,
0.03020436502993107,
-0.02614099718630314,
0.05302157625555992,
-0.03258179873228073,
0.03287261724472046,
0.06527639925479889,
0.008119843900203705,
-0.048868026584386826,
-0.012511180713772774,
0.012884794734418392,
-0.002914214739575982,
-0.011174343526363373,
0.02060963213443756,
0.04409322887659073,
-0.0008459803648293018,
0.008343790657818317,
-0.010323579423129559,
0.02599168010056019,
0.002585512585937977,
-0.026832329109311104,
-0.02496100403368473,
-0.008690500631928444,
-0.06273303180932999,
0.021108293905854225,
0.026920534670352936,
0.020598195493221283,
0.005591129418462515,
-0.01171115692704916
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:59
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
869Mr Zdrilic became aware of this loan, at the latest, on 22 February 2005 when he attended a directors meeting of Sentel.
870At that meeting, according to the minutes:-
"Robert asked Sam to think about the prospect of Huntley not taking off and having a plan B. This is only because if for some reason we do not get re-zoning we need to make money out of the site."
871Mr Zdrilic knew that any funding from "the New Zealand funder" was conditional on re-zoning. Thus if, contrary to what I have found, Mr Zdrilic still believed that IPC or IBIS was "the funder" he was aware that Mr Renshall was raising the serious possibility of HTT not getting re-zoning and the need to consider a "plan B" in that event.
872The minutes also record that:-
"We have two loans:
1. Provident $6m - interest 10.9% - fixed interest - 2 years only
2. DTC $4.5m - 25% interest"
873Thus Mr Zdrilic was aware not only of the Provident loan but also that the DTC loan had been reduced from $6.8 million to $4.5 million.
874The following month, on 8 March 2005 Mr Zdrilic claimed that he heard from Mr Frederick, for the first time, that (to use the words in Mr Zdrilic's note):-
"New Zealand Funder deal collapsed on 15/9/04".
875As I have said earlier, in my opinion, Mr Zdrilic knew, from the terms of his conversation with Mr Renshall on 16 September 2004, that IPC "was not really putting any money" into the Project. Further, by this stage, Mr Zdrilic knew that Provident had advanced $6 million. In those circumstances, it is hard to see what significance Mr Zdrilic could sensibly attach to Mr Frederick's statement.
876Certainly, although he denied it, the evidence shows that Mr Zdrilic made no complaint to Mr Renshall until, at the earliest, August 2006.
877Mr Zdrilic was asked what he did after finding out (allegedly for the first time) on 8 March 2005 that the "New Zealand funder deal collapsed on 15/9/04".
878He said:-
'What I did, I intensified my efforts in trying to get as much information as I possibly could about what the hell was going on at Huntley (...) I was trying to get as much information as possible. I was trying bit by bit, knowing what they have done, so I had to be careful, how I was going to do it, so I tried to get as much information as possible to learn what is going on (...)
First of all, I was trying to organise meetings, which was very difficult because always someone was late. I was trying to organise the meetings bit by bit, I tried to become a full director knowing now I am in total trouble because I have no veto power, I am not a director. I tried to become a director, I tried to get my $5.5 million loan put back into HTT and they would be first steps."
879But examination of the documentary record after 8 March 2005 does not corroborate these assertions by Mr Zdrilic.
880On the very day that Mr Frederick told Mr Zdrilic that the "New Zealand funder deal collapsed", Mr Zdrilic circulated an agenda for a meeting of directors of HTT (which he suggested take place on 17 March 2005). He suggested that there be included on the agenda:-
"...general business including an update on funding, coal, re-zoning, accounts, tax returns etc"
881Mr Zdrilic asserted that he put these matters on the agenda because:-
"I wanted to know what is going on so that I can then see what next step I was going to take (...) maybe taking legal action (...) I said I had to find the information to see then what my legal rights are, what I can do. First of all I had to be informed."
882I do not accept this evidence. It is obvious from the form of Mr Zdrilic's email that he was proposing an agenda of matters to be considered at a meeting of HTT in the normal course with a view to progressing the Project; not with a view to obtaining information to be used in future legal proceedings.
|
[
-0.01379440538585186,
0.024013744667172432,
-0.03975564241409302,
-0.008960086852312088,
-0.02743496373295784,
-0.0313158743083477,
0.009899021126329899,
-0.03644062206149101,
0.012383893132209778,
0.01379566453397274,
-0.0086954515427351,
0.017595762386918068,
-0.029356785118579865,
0.016426946967840195,
-0.004802392330020666,
-0.027325408533215523,
0.04087258502840996,
-0.010545163415372372,
0.017436960712075233,
-0.03311805799603462,
-0.004030098207294941,
-0.011289756745100021,
0.045344285666942596,
0.0370715893805027,
-0.004871138837188482,
0.02319287694990635,
-0.03939947858452797,
0.00388002279214561,
0.03508855774998665,
0.014292269013822079,
-0.0018546389183029532,
-0.0006600620690733194,
0.05106271058320999,
-0.02237473987042904,
-0.001972328405827284,
-0.03367327153682709,
0.03925700858235359,
-0.012765844352543354,
-0.03361250460147858,
-0.0019279016414657235,
-0.03429798036813736,
0.012579595670104027,
-0.01464718859642744,
-0.0017206461634486914,
0.05841262638568878,
-0.03601915389299393,
0.0012151302071288228,
-0.010129437781870365,
0.0293621476739645,
0.03004823997616768,
-0.02834738790988922,
-0.04178743064403534,
0.005892257671803236,
-0.016521887853741646,
-0.03684321418404579,
-0.020648900419473648,
-0.012120180763304234,
-0.014797798357903957,
-0.04015357047319412,
0.014060741290450096,
0.011017654091119766,
-0.0009822988649830222,
-0.06444695591926575,
0.011946510523557663,
0.014587651006877422,
0.12956076860427856,
0.008258400484919548,
-0.009476075880229473,
-0.01246869470924139,
-0.008793627843260765,
-0.06038351356983185,
-0.008594789542257786,
0.029834650456905365,
-0.004794304259121418,
-0.08010101318359375,
0.03132161498069763,
0.01617038995027542,
-0.010980330407619476,
0.06104833260178566,
0.03261101245880127,
0.04897842928767204,
-0.026111310347914696,
-0.03440636396408081,
0.014719328843057156,
-0.0018413314828649163,
0.031194470822811127,
-0.0152138601988554,
0.027118733152747154,
0.005758561193943024,
-0.027765464037656784,
0.011844584718346596,
0.013420846313238144,
0.005364723037928343,
-0.03530948981642723,
-0.007817241363227367,
0.004170564003288746,
-0.04746144637465477,
0.024034684523940086,
-0.003230384550988674,
0.02873392030596733,
0.03311164677143097,
0.001328077632933855,
-0.003950607031583786,
-0.03523356840014458,
-0.022046253085136414,
0.020943064242601395,
0.04152218624949455,
0.03781187906861305,
0.0238944198936224,
-0.01065040472894907,
-0.0023767563980072737,
-0.011525405570864677,
-0.0006495143170468509,
0.017212960869073868,
-0.0020854559261351824,
0.0011286914814263582,
-0.022651562467217445,
0.018916595727205276,
0.06744556874036789,
-0.008184507489204407,
0.034814491868019104,
0.0049370997585356236,
0.036519430577754974,
-0.011516815051436424,
-0.06481995433568954,
-0.03205997869372368,
0.0002325777750229463,
-0.006735499948263168,
-0.006454015150666237,
0.0258956179022789,
-0.012752649374306202,
-0.00730837881565094,
-0.005756502039730549,
-0.021907707676291466,
-0.006039444822818041,
-0.012182051315903664,
-0.014604385942220688,
-0.022347955033183098,
0.0065452056005597115,
-0.06789164245128632,
0.03158268705010414,
0.013911518268287182,
-0.00012104478082619607,
-0.06467513740062714,
-0.003797373501583934,
-0.009548558853566647,
-0.01582755520939827,
0.02393503300845623,
0.01841764524579048,
0.04409763962030411,
0.008252957835793495,
0.0017829096177592874,
0.01711321249604225,
0.0028672746848315,
-0.006169299595057964,
-0.04407096281647682,
0.02120562084019184,
-0.010369145311415195,
0.015613938681781292,
0.05411774665117264,
0.0010486446553841233,
0.04597504809498787,
-0.029934288933873177,
-0.042828068137168884,
-0.02394241653382778,
0.03981085121631622,
0.015058142133057117,
0.023616192862391472,
-0.021240800619125366,
-0.00451548770070076,
0.04640897363424301,
-0.024064213037490845,
0.06412573158740997,
-0.0195501446723938,
0.01904762163758278,
0.014760995283722878,
0.02948484569787979,
0.015564963221549988,
-0.0026956091169267893,
-0.02580268122255802,
-0.05574243515729904,
0.0570114403963089,
0.0078549450263381,
-0.006145150400698185,
-0.05754683539271355,
0.009508581832051277,
-0.06343923509120941,
-0.028522051870822906,
0.012281708419322968,
0.01539327297359705,
0.009156056679785252,
0.031083907932043076,
0.012930900789797306,
0.03025747276842594,
0.032514892518520355,
-0.04554048553109169,
0.016481807455420494,
-0.036395661532878876,
-0.008279059082269669,
-0.03720702975988388,
-0.01890401355922222,
0.027767423540353775,
0.05589156970381737,
-0.011430720798671246,
-0.020754577592015266,
0.020529737696051598,
-0.0290134996175766,
0.006328895688056946,
-0.02077477239072323,
-0.05844154953956604,
-0.019184859469532967,
0.003962136339396238,
-0.0011533362558111548,
0.021625632420182228,
0.009108312427997589,
-0.012307172641158104,
0.0035056842025369406,
-0.01741223782300949,
0.020433394238352776,
-0.035862743854522705,
-0.02138727717101574,
0.04765723645687103,
-0.0017383728409186006,
-0.02009098418056965,
0.02113165333867073,
0.04143446311354637,
-0.059884171932935715,
0.011489788070321083,
-0.006613978184759617,
-0.042123205959796906,
-0.00563636003062129,
-0.03222106397151947,
0.014285172335803509,
-0.016270563006401062,
0.04518825188279152,
0.039064500480890274,
0.00797516293823719,
0.013842596672475338,
0.019502073526382446,
0.005293854046612978,
-0.008718585595488548,
0.022410936653614044,
-0.026597047224640846,
0.006752500310540199,
-0.05855117738246918,
0.008093062788248062,
0.005510106682777405,
0.01289379969239235,
0.013294879347085953,
-0.018242258578538895,
0.00018861793796531856,
-0.020326469093561172,
-0.029251566156744957,
0.003952465485781431,
-0.01534127164632082,
0.0355999618768692,
-0.000046817021939205006,
-0.0054045747965574265,
0.019125154241919518,
0.030337952077388763,
0.026025116443634033,
0.01956036314368248,
0.021077310666441917,
0.002448549959808588,
-0.001794348587282002,
0.01987265609204769,
-0.024967215955257416,
-0.07440782338380814,
0.019161328673362732,
-0.021088222041726112,
0.008029550313949585,
0.01007845252752304,
0.03152329847216606,
0.000965419108979404,
0.0021900807041674852,
0.023675046861171722,
0.010530293919146061,
0.004493675194680691,
-0.0028128260746598244,
0.001471332274377346,
-0.006552288308739662,
0.005899343173950911,
0.0253972876816988,
-0.029798908159136772,
0.02872895449399948,
0.024059036746621132,
0.004264787770807743,
-0.021856676787137985,
0.03054024651646614,
-0.018336281180381775,
-0.07151258736848831,
0.0064981128089129925,
0.049487002193927765,
-0.0027563776820898056,
-0.024358926340937614,
-0.023078860715031624,
-0.0324389822781086,
-0.15859998762607574,
-0.034333497285842896,
-0.0041048163548111916,
0.028735525906085968,
0.009236300364136696,
-0.0009605718078091741,
-0.03521177917718887,
0.03677130490541458,
-0.025787843391299248,
0.007696575950831175,
-0.03051985800266266,
-0.03390532732009888,
-0.021896967664361,
0.025044525042176247,
0.010152256116271019,
-0.019465157762169838,
-0.0026837047189474106,
0.0299211535602808,
0.01690072938799858,
-0.019497951492667198,
0.035745155066251755,
-0.007232775911688805,
0.05323510244488716,
0.03736061230301857,
0.0026250011287629604,
-0.006338492501527071,
0.011680599302053452,
0.03998313471674919,
-0.016214512288570404,
-0.006780344992876053,
0.02197740599513054,
0.025039080530405045,
-0.021942896768450737,
0.05019717663526535,
0.017615413293242455,
0.041402965784072876,
0.07274426519870758,
-0.07738697528839111,
-0.02299884706735611,
-0.02453380450606346,
0.031352825462818146,
0.035574208945035934,
0.0014599838759750128,
0.015413989312946796,
0.0035384350921958685,
-0.03023950755596161,
0.0032749881502240896,
-0.023064149543642998,
-0.0017428238643333316,
0.03750070929527283,
0.023362452164292336,
0.028552865609526634,
-0.03197779506444931,
-0.028442515060305595,
0.022204948589205742,
-0.020298907533288002,
0.03770022094249725,
0.013733495026826859,
-0.04246200993657112,
-0.014058135449886322,
-0.025531940162181854,
-0.032464124262332916,
0.0121566541492939,
0.006817239802330732,
-0.02310255728662014,
0.00269097532145679,
-0.012693655677139759,
-0.03988480195403099,
0.016517717391252518,
0.018410397693514824,
0.016456618905067444,
-0.0038957728538662195,
-0.012249302119016647,
-0.03588303178548813,
0.055705584585666656,
0.010058118961751461,
-0.028928421437740326,
-0.02544248476624489,
-0.007615446113049984,
-0.10661036521196365,
-0.027729762718081474,
0.04530962184071541,
-0.03779659420251846,
0.007788690738379955,
-0.02323809638619423,
0.029360255226492882,
0.02348288707435131,
0.053734470158815384,
-0.004237042274326086,
0.2699594497680664,
-0.0162641778588295,
0.01011414360255003,
0.02129686437547207,
0.018384946510195732,
-0.03962848335504532,
0.005482989363372326,
0.05551319196820259,
0.00695662759244442,
-0.039945073425769806,
-0.014945839531719685,
-0.005539666395634413,
0.02555381879210472,
0.018224384635686874,
-0.01564631424844265,
0.016598505899310112,
-0.07852667570114136,
-0.03142464905977249,
0.07604800164699554,
0.021128911525011063,
0.05878274142742157,
0.028187531977891922,
0.0024342029355466366,
-0.015925364568829536,
-0.045912329107522964,
-0.03480198606848717,
0.029065025970339775,
0.04709979146718979,
-0.036269981414079666,
0.019458137452602386,
-0.012245218269526958,
-0.012384270317852497,
0.06272374838590622,
0.0015627401880919933,
0.022327622398734093,
0.016030030325055122,
-0.0035230559296905994,
0.04438885673880577,
0.013463618233799934,
0.04018488898873329,
0.002449726453050971,
-0.02522808127105236,
-0.04561680182814598,
-0.01960631087422371,
-0.04050412029027939,
-0.009151270613074303,
-0.038271140307188034,
-0.0005379526992328465,
-0.004281534813344479,
0.02781064249575138,
0.01153731532394886,
0.0634242594242096,
-0.02227281779050827,
-0.029275689274072647,
-0.01441194023936987,
0.012550141662359238,
-0.015380654484033585,
0.048310790210962296,
0.02140558697283268,
0.0754857286810875,
0.04362229257822037,
0.042397402226924896,
-0.0023647358175367117,
0.03198052570223808,
-0.01610242947936058,
-0.02394814044237137,
-0.03893027827143669,
-0.019277533516287804,
0.04922907054424286,
0.013385742902755737,
0.039613693952560425,
0.013311346992850304,
0.007515666075050831,
0.0055358498357236385,
0.03820120915770531,
-0.022875336930155754,
-0.009173446334898472,
0.0168659258633852,
-0.041977204382419586,
-0.007480947766453028,
-0.02976071462035179,
-0.024476487189531326,
0.002418677555397153,
0.03178703412413597,
0.01420050859451294,
-0.017151733860373497,
-0.03531904146075249,
0.023205026984214783,
-0.02256469614803791,
-0.030189890414476395,
-0.025625986978411674,
-0.01708940416574478,
0.008654381148517132,
-0.025524169206619263,
-0.006650018505752087,
-0.0186001006513834,
-0.001187642221339047,
-0.02904694527387619,
-0.05889357253909111,
-0.054249875247478485,
0.023415502160787582,
0.011543300934135914,
0.0282699353992939,
-0.03135847672820091,
-0.01055967714637518,
-0.016005713492631912,
0.0007605778519064188,
0.03598662465810776,
-0.025359245017170906,
0.013101952150464058,
0.0063065397553145885,
0.03895322233438492,
-0.017512183636426926,
-0.02276112325489521,
0.04348817095160484,
0.0511816069483757,
-0.02189108356833458,
0.07028879970312119,
-0.008529217913746834,
0.04474067687988281,
0.0005797846824862063,
-0.0034164998214691877,
-0.015965405851602554,
0.026835113763809204,
-0.0010409574024379253,
-0.000956977135501802,
-0.041078925132751465,
-0.020474087446928024,
0.0348070003092289,
-0.0087451646104455,
0.026440748944878578,
-0.007259329315274954,
-0.010754173621535301,
-0.009654019959270954,
0.05003964900970459,
0.029503829777240753,
-0.038486722856760025,
-0.01843269169330597,
-0.07504983991384506,
0.014119375497102737,
-0.04811672493815422,
0.013058430515229702,
-0.025934578850865364,
-0.024042556062340736,
0.017358234152197838,
0.017623938620090485,
-0.06361809372901917,
0.048926979303359985,
-0.062208496034145355,
-0.01273635309189558,
0.037781957536935806,
-0.01578657329082489,
-0.04440147802233696,
-0.033400408923625946,
0.02670847810804844,
0.030569002032279968,
-0.013798689469695091,
-0.04555760696530342,
0.024953385815024376,
-0.028810949996113777,
0.007706005126237869,
0.022968577221035957,
0.013427013531327248,
0.014427121728658676,
0.021568305790424347,
0.04849519580602646,
-0.00949164293706417,
0.0378202460706234,
0.05291013419628143,
-0.0227127093821764,
-0.05824610963463783,
-0.04900890588760376,
-0.023881293833255768,
0.044978827238082886,
0.020159438252449036,
0.033264823257923126,
0.002591869793832302,
0.0035633936058729887,
-0.023653801530599594,
-0.019476307556033134,
0.049955740571022034,
0.026951000094413757,
-0.02701505646109581,
0.015792978927493095,
-0.03503146767616272,
-0.014616685919463634,
-0.027733195573091507,
-0.02085365727543831,
0.04862571135163307,
-0.049413926899433136,
0.00017266046779695898,
0.08105523139238358,
0.02120736427605152,
-0.03831355273723602,
0.03191585838794708,
0.02689460478723049,
-0.0199766643345356,
0.04428624361753464,
0.013793590478599072,
-0.04370926320552826,
0.024496162310242653,
-0.0017095062648877501,
0.0004499871574807912,
-0.007593224290758371,
0.03036348707973957,
0.008178826421499252,
0.02799629420042038,
0.053950224071741104,
-0.01651040092110634,
-0.0055724503472447395,
0.02967504970729351,
0.029096243903040886,
-0.013968445360660553,
0.008050462231040001,
0.01445075310766697,
-0.031472932547330856,
0.05889318510890007,
0.051933445036411285,
0.025146836414933205,
-0.024408778175711632,
-0.0272425077855587,
-0.031093185767531395,
0.02188175916671753,
-0.03213110193610191,
-0.027013080194592476,
-0.003064736258238554,
-0.029904328286647797,
-0.02831750363111496,
-0.02206892892718315,
0.02887321077287197,
-0.0006611642893403769,
-0.04549543559551239,
0.03578338399529457,
-0.06323222070932388,
-0.018431659787893295,
-0.012598435394465923,
0.04225021228194237,
0.006916843820363283,
0.024042556062340736,
0.004714545793831348,
0.010750862769782543,
-0.029036954045295715,
0.0089485552161932,
0.046794064342975616,
-0.011362863704562187,
-0.000787715136539191,
0.006963545456528664,
-0.025521233677864075,
0.03173665329813957,
0.047943659126758575,
0.03073640540242195,
0.012383148074150085,
-0.007493287790566683,
-0.022307580336928368,
0.011119470000267029,
-0.010744506493210793,
0.02788771130144596,
-0.03706210106611252,
0.0060313427820801735,
-0.03629882261157036,
-0.01834396831691265,
-0.0010494893649592996,
0.025525912642478943,
-0.020921839401125908,
-0.061577167361974716,
-0.033841874450445175,
0.010958964936435223,
0.0014409322757273912,
-0.05194484815001488,
-0.011682022362947464,
0.008046474307775497,
0.011463331989943981,
-0.02763359248638153,
-0.052679240703582764,
0.00893349852412939,
0.006055022124201059,
-0.002657143631950021,
0.0256423968821764,
-0.0075692422688007355,
-0.009559581987559795,
-0.018133878707885742,
0.012243125587701797,
0.00964329019188881,
0.007809020578861237,
-0.024894196540117264,
0.007751396857202053,
0.009988458827137947,
0.009625434875488281,
-0.008044474758207798,
0.012938660569489002,
0.01418890431523323,
-0.010397650301456451,
-0.030682280659675598,
0.03886968269944191,
0.02466881461441517,
-0.0012689922004938126,
-0.023919837549328804,
0.02146405726671219,
-0.013029959984123707,
0.009321672841906548,
-0.017336230725049973,
-0.0044005014933645725,
0.014962690882384777,
-0.05361171066761017,
-0.014168375171720982,
0.001040694653056562,
0.0024409363977611065,
0.007144976872950792,
-0.016527952626347542,
0.02043764293193817,
0.034567248076200485,
-0.049408916383981705,
0.02966790460050106,
-0.006502040661871433,
0.022129451856017113,
0.016440870240330696,
0.03284933790564537,
0.018482472747564316,
-0.03308052197098732,
0.0007044961676001549,
0.01888112537562847,
0.020835790783166885,
-0.052126891911029816,
0.038372159004211426,
-0.05672510340809822,
0.007513899821788073,
0.01182175986468792,
-0.04294729232788086,
-0.0756579041481018,
0.022729773074388504,
-0.03480108082294464,
-0.017942970618605614,
0.019521478563547134,
-0.010592046193778515,
0.042467035353183746,
0.011706631630659103,
-0.0019572279416024685,
-0.03183600679039955,
0.010513723827898502,
-0.0667494684457779,
0.004499811679124832,
-0.06399477273225784,
0.050989046692848206,
-0.01695336028933525,
0.012766668573021889,
0.012990374118089676,
0.005733131431043148,
0.0017680296441540122,
0.009586266241967678,
0.018371615558862686,
-0.00954041164368391,
-0.011525833047926426,
-0.005490250885486603,
-0.05146351829171181,
-0.010622451081871986,
-0.03071591630578041,
0.01331847719848156,
0.026639427989721298,
0.02415853552520275,
0.01738898642361164,
-0.012397806160151958,
0.03941619023680687,
0.02499992586672306,
0.010982667095959187,
-0.03455057740211487,
-0.008740117773413658,
0.0033087655901908875,
0.023167293518781662,
-0.0031409806106239557,
0.028209982439875603,
0.013714403845369816,
-0.015983039513230324,
-0.01811210997402668,
0.0003042226890102029,
-0.05011032521724701,
0.04115060716867447,
-0.0026212872471660376,
0.02307545579969883,
-0.005710020661354065,
-0.033866193145513535,
0.0010010049445554614,
-0.023152001202106476,
0.00989505648612976,
-0.025947075337171555,
0.018322063609957695,
-0.012691808864474297,
-0.010875933803617954,
0.0022276840172708035,
0.021113455295562744,
0.01629750430583954,
-0.03473450243473053,
0.007557573262602091,
-0.03179803118109703,
-0.008252987638115883,
-0.14452040195465088,
-0.008072835393249989,
-0.015790604054927826,
-0.05454672873020172,
-0.009542212821543217,
-0.008404679596424103,
-0.012127861380577087,
0.020046712830662727,
-0.043961796909570694,
-0.009166071191430092,
-0.00611067283898592,
0.0048019555397331715,
0.027929242700338364,
-0.023012548685073853,
-0.025263505056500435,
-0.011411732994019985,
-0.041945964097976685,
0.02466060221195221,
-0.06388941407203674,
0.015116590075194836,
0.01655733399093151,
0.0011347108520567417,
0.012533079832792282,
-0.02811235561966896,
0.031201180070638657,
-0.008553605526685715,
0.01440724078565836,
-0.0518285296857357,
-0.046543993055820465,
-0.01627124659717083,
-0.027049724012613297,
-0.014237776398658752,
-0.023579813539981842,
0.10264475643634796,
-0.0329662524163723,
0.01776357740163803,
0.011572353541851044,
-0.010838782414793968,
-0.013552689924836159,
0.003254567040130496,
-0.004001612775027752,
0.03236883133649826,
-0.027778608724474907,
-0.03492971509695053,
-0.01750454120337963,
0.04558151215314865,
-0.003015486989170313,
-0.007172390352934599,
-0.0626935213804245,
-0.019446833059191704,
-0.014824879355728626,
0.05461814999580383,
0.019574789330363274,
0.04415708780288696,
-0.011610599234700203,
-0.004606982227414846,
0.010308772325515747,
-0.026069048792123795,
0.009782462380826473,
0.06157545745372772,
-0.008920297957956791,
0.013113001361489296,
-0.04927273839712143,
0.02203299105167389,
-0.05605385825037956,
0.010583405382931232,
-0.037465859204530716,
-0.036565303802490234,
-0.030494485050439835,
0.01460941694676876,
-0.0217446219176054,
0.0011257482692599297,
-0.00894897896796465,
-0.04318370297551155,
0.03636479005217552,
-0.049685828387737274,
0.017723148688673973,
0.0005719356704503298,
-0.02943285182118416,
-0.010495331138372421,
-0.04541255906224251,
0.006036035716533661,
-0.06407957524061203,
-0.0012681501684710383,
0.06060931086540222,
0.05474182590842247,
0.016434593126177788,
-0.021770983934402466,
0.012687098234891891,
-0.04400647059082985,
-0.08549810200929642,
-0.004329064395278692,
0.025437844917178154,
0.04243386909365654,
-0.02546345628798008,
0.019869839772582054,
-0.032242003828287125,
0.0004955852054990828,
0.0235507283359766,
-0.0001742466411087662,
-0.0742630660533905,
-0.01491134986281395,
-0.01925165206193924,
-0.01986144855618477,
-0.023847155272960663,
-0.023839715868234634,
0.05119355395436287,
-0.0021625643130391836,
0.014727945439517498,
-0.022382697090506554,
0.0066197579726576805,
-0.011151010170578957,
-0.06217113137245178,
0.02066008746623993,
-0.05159375071525574,
0.029242385178804398,
0.010006093420088291,
-0.016005638986825943,
-0.01351123210042715,
0.008670049719512463,
0.011317349039018154,
0.03417316824197769,
-0.011287531815469265,
-0.03390534222126007,
0.014938806183636189,
0.005546817556023598,
0.06288368999958038,
0.03287370130419731,
0.010754031129181385,
-0.023969508707523346,
0.04308193549513817,
0.010940486565232277,
0.00841527059674263,
0.04447709396481514,
-0.001358435139991343,
-0.010449623689055443,
0.008130301721394062,
0.009453940205276012,
-0.05331213399767876,
-0.02688760869204998,
-0.038893237709999084,
-0.0004830111865885556,
0.007345724850893021,
0.006738679483532906,
-0.03936423361301422,
0.01625460758805275,
0.04114115610718727,
-0.019484996795654297,
-0.01159904059022665,
-0.037572842091321945,
0.027183860540390015,
0.0037298586685210466,
-0.013485267758369446,
-0.007821646519005299,
0.019719384610652924,
-0.016262201592326164,
0.005239225924015045,
0.015326092019677162,
0.053037021309137344,
0.0174028929322958,
0.023389915004372597,
-0.02810928225517273,
-0.04981275275349617,
-0.03623989224433899,
-0.027217254042625427,
0.017994381487369537,
-0.019245658069849014,
-0.00035054964246228337,
-0.043487489223480225,
-0.04056920111179352,
-0.025102971121668816,
0.03186894208192825,
-0.033328570425510406,
0.02450340986251831,
0.029410183429718018,
-0.012416020967066288,
-0.025836937129497528,
-0.010576129890978336,
0.0499257929623127,
-0.012555429711937904,
0.0608731172978878,
0.02715175785124302,
0.029380062595009804,
-0.01815408281981945,
-0.010801050812005997,
0.03157057240605354,
0.01335728820413351,
0.033592768013477325,
0.00011260863539064303,
-0.03267814591526985,
-0.01836441271007061,
0.020751720294356346,
0.014554258435964584,
-0.024878505617380142,
0.026927059516310692,
-0.007674757391214371,
0.009300118312239647,
0.03796644136309624,
0.012151815928518772,
0.053863972425460815,
0.013651721179485321,
-0.017161831259727478,
-0.044961489737033844,
-0.016900569200515747,
-0.040626682341098785,
0.032603293657302856,
-0.026402927935123444,
-0.045160070061683655,
-0.05680708587169647,
0.0688495859503746,
-0.01119164191186428,
0.02344454452395439,
-0.01479792594909668,
0.030901825055480003,
-0.015417719259858131,
0.017275268211960793,
-0.009956472553312778,
0.010004750452935696,
0.022194879129529,
-0.02135724015533924,
0.011032398790121078,
0.03248952329158783,
-0.01445003505796194,
-0.025140760466456413,
-0.004799094516783953,
-0.0006732207257300615,
-0.007069122977554798,
0.019894247874617577,
-0.03000013530254364,
0.04264327511191368,
-0.0015347875887528062,
-0.021824801340699196,
-0.0040295603685081005,
0.045649439096450806,
-0.011758657172322273,
-0.026180798187851906,
-0.02530168555676937,
-0.04074385017156601,
0.003715408965945244,
-0.023288797587156296,
0.06058996915817261,
-0.010829080827534199,
0.006393332965672016,
-0.015609407797455788
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:44
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
3. We do not yet have these details.
4. The funder is still operating on the basis of the Heads of Agreement which requires funding for $12 million comprising the retirement of the DTC No. 1 Pty Limited loan (approx. $7 million), the purchase price of the Cook land and costs (approx. $3 million) and estimate [sic] funding and other expenses and other working capital (approx. $2 million)(...)
The further funding is believed to be relatively assured depending on HTT being able to demonstrate meeting the funder's requirements(...)
We confirm our arrangements to attend at 2pm tomorrow and have arranged for James Moir to attend at that time for furtherance of arrangements with his client".
655Mr Renshall said he instructed Mr Gillard to write this letter on the basis of:-
* his conversation with Mr Hanna on 24 August 2004;
* the Ping Letter of 24 August 2004; and
* the terms of the IPC Heads of Agreement.
656There are a number of observations to be made about this letter.
657First, it is clear that words are missing from the end of the paragraph numbered "1" in the letter. Although Mr Gillard denied this, it is clear to me that the words that are missing are words to the effect "will attend the settlement" so that the paragraph numbered "1" should have read something like:-
"The funder has arranged for a draw down of $4.5 million for tomorrow for which purpose James Moir on behalf of the funder will attend the settlement".
658This reading of the letter is consistent with the last paragraph, in which Mr Gillard confirmed that Mr Moir would attend the settlement at 2pm "tomorrow" (that is 27 August 2004) "for furtherance of arrangements with his client".
659In my opinion, notwithstanding Mr Gillard's evidence to the contrary, the letter conveyed, and was intended by Mr Gillard to convey, that Mr Moir would attend the settlement on 27 August 2004 with $4.5 million.
660Second, Mr Gillard's statement that the further funding was believed to be "relatively assured" must be read in light of the fact that Mr Gillard was not able to provide the "details" sought in Mr Hilliard's question "3", namely the terms of loan funds, including interest and repayment dates.
27 August 2004 - the settlement
66127 August 2004 was a Friday.
662Mr Gillard gave evidence that, at some time during the morning, Mr Renshall told him that, contrary to what was foreshadowed in Mr Gillard's letter addressed to Mr Hilliard of 26 August 2004, Mr Moir would not be attending the settlement scheduled for 2pm that day.
663Mr Gillard said nothing to this effect in the two affidavits he swore. The evidence only emerged during the cross-examination of Mr Gillard. Mr Gillard was the last witness to be called.
664No doubt, for this reason, such proposition was not put to Mr Renshall in cross-examination.
665Mr Renshall, who gave evidence before Mr Gillard, said he could not recall whether he was expecting Mr Moir to be present at the settlement.
666In advance of the settlement, Mr Gillard met Mr Hilliard at around noon.
667The solicitors exchanged letters both dated 27 August 2004.
668Mr Hilliard's letter said:-
"Notwithstanding the fact that clause 4.
7 of the Heads of Agreement has not been complied with yet and will not have been complied with at the conclusion of the proposed settlement to occur today our clients, in the spirit of working together for the commercial success of the project and as a sign of their continuing goodwill, are prepared to proceed with today's settlement and to this end have accepted the insertion of clause 8.
4 to the draft Deed of Non-Dilution and Merger [which provided that each party accepted that there had been substantial compliance with and no breach of the Heads of Agreement].
We note that you do not yet have detail [sic] of the terms of the proposed loan including interest rate and repayment date. We do not accept that a director of HTT would arrange a loan of $4.5 million without knowing these basic conditions. We require to be informed about them at 2pm today, if not before (...)
|
[
-0.007788070943206549,
0.04160785302519798,
-0.0046117412857711315,
0.018075017258524895,
0.0054709287360310555,
-0.0565185584127903,
-0.0070109898224473,
-0.026520604267716408,
-0.021818626672029495,
0.02262653410434723,
0.0009296598145738244,
-0.0012425091117620468,
-0.03055371716618538,
0.017668548971414566,
-0.018571168184280396,
-0.04276953265070915,
0.015290583483874798,
-0.022199973464012146,
0.021180812269449234,
-0.018055543303489685,
-0.023408010601997375,
-0.0416090190410614,
0.0059234644286334515,
0.012552597559988499,
-0.008025739341974258,
-0.0262118149548769,
-0.05158398672938347,
0.00087468430865556,
0.028994396328926086,
0.04203801229596138,
-0.006530503276735544,
0.002466724719852209,
0.04605935886502266,
-0.007898171432316303,
-0.014065022580325603,
-0.015299374237656593,
0.028561919927597046,
0.015475316904485226,
-0.030658112838864326,
0.045474614948034286,
-0.011784631758928299,
0.033123597502708435,
-0.014690035954117775,
0.0009260799270123243,
0.057268306612968445,
-0.021113092079758644,
-0.007633233908563852,
-0.012725950218737125,
0.025294989347457886,
0.007416240405291319,
-0.053154490888118744,
-0.05725059658288956,
0.035481832921504974,
-0.00979029480367899,
-0.04741834104061127,
-0.01509765349328518,
-0.04229990765452385,
-0.0007759027648717165,
-0.023637421429157257,
-0.003128345590084791,
-0.003174064215272665,
-0.00404067849740386,
-0.040959011763334274,
0.01390055287629366,
0.035411085933446884,
0.08592677861452103,
0.005690492689609528,
0.002943148370832205,
-0.0022746166214346886,
-0.01615312695503235,
-0.04452380910515785,
0.0007074422319419682,
-0.017616031691432,
-0.006654929835349321,
-0.0979660227894783,
0.03451809659600258,
0.04231049865484238,
-0.007973193190991879,
0.012464703060686588,
0.0017734309658408165,
0.031617648899555206,
0.0029413357842713594,
-0.00875350646674633,
0.016531113535165787,
-0.017983222380280495,
0.016125347465276718,
0.00156593753490597,
0.02668466791510582,
0.016097955405712128,
-0.021164342761039734,
0.0025864974595606327,
-0.016368888318538666,
0.027924323454499245,
-0.04213571548461914,
-0.015388604253530502,
-0.04749106243252754,
-0.05481274798512459,
0.02727452479302883,
0.009268158115446568,
0.01651584543287754,
-0.00584139209240675,
0.016878215596079826,
0.00235908105969429,
-0.012056508101522923,
0.007159208878874779,
0.05075126141309738,
0.04325129836797714,
0.01806185394525528,
0.02013348415493965,
-0.006948123686015606,
-0.009185190312564373,
-0.01881427876651287,
0.01639154739677906,
0.027152396738529205,
-0.006771071348339319,
-0.003948174882680178,
0.004957645665854216,
-0.019192632287740707,
0.011453892104327679,
-0.004357954952865839,
0.027906836941838264,
-0.0018431179923936725,
0.029933344572782516,
-0.0024808854795992374,
-0.031435154378414154,
-0.007563014514744282,
-0.005697922315448523,
-0.00702809588983655,
0.0226503424346447,
0.02923649735748768,
-0.003374305320903659,
0.02173253335058689,
-0.018802423030138016,
-0.03203252702951431,
-0.01670805737376213,
-0.018239134922623634,
0.015321122482419014,
0.005899139679968357,
0.007536162622272968,
-0.06831536442041397,
0.05603095144033432,
0.03240184858441353,
-0.010099045000970364,
-0.06238923221826553,
0.026166805997490883,
-0.0439513698220253,
0.010038254782557487,
0.00013451366976369172,
-0.0015540409367531538,
0.022164173424243927,
0.028426218777894974,
0.02079804614186287,
0.011627955362200737,
0.03014031983911991,
0.02166122756898403,
-0.060222722589969635,
-0.0041535599157214165,
-0.03245682269334793,
0.03145766630768776,
0.08416029065847397,
-0.04259486868977547,
0.06712541729211807,
-0.01249841321259737,
-0.012510718777775764,
-0.005104457028210163,
-0.019304635003209114,
0.008324069902300835,
-0.001780716353096068,
0.0035004997625947,
-0.025747746229171753,
0.04583050310611725,
-0.04877669736742973,
0.05053745210170746,
0.010845768265426159,
0.01893732137978077,
0.02601655386388302,
0.06261678785085678,
0.01188722811639309,
0.02529006265103817,
-0.013139920309185982,
-0.045472633093595505,
0.08083568513393402,
0.015746718272566795,
-0.0064025698229670525,
-0.029968349263072014,
0.009585863910615444,
-0.03649356961250305,
-0.031287118792533875,
-0.00063424272229895,
0.00975683145225048,
-0.02600720524787903,
-0.01107995118945837,
0.0060365451499819756,
0.008730098605155945,
0.022772861644625664,
-0.0032244687899947166,
0.029043300077319145,
-0.053499143570661545,
0.009382297284901142,
-0.025483014062047005,
-0.03749193623661995,
0.021330637857317924,
0.05019252747297287,
-0.04346466436982155,
-0.031123049557209015,
-0.010513558983802795,
-0.03592700883746147,
-0.014165055938065052,
-0.011038189753890038,
-0.032094571739435196,
-0.004763761069625616,
0.012117830105125904,
-0.0077736577950417995,
-0.011091305874288082,
0.021358024328947067,
0.016356268897652626,
-0.005969286430627108,
0.011643284931778908,
0.019299322739243507,
-0.02840343676507473,
0.007041024509817362,
0.029551947489380836,
0.0008619876462034881,
0.020525913685560226,
0.014789559878408909,
0.038080789148807526,
-0.018477287143468857,
0.03667217120528221,
-0.012897410430014133,
-0.02605474926531315,
-0.002786606550216675,
-0.016548993065953255,
0.002716397400945425,
-0.013976570218801498,
0.04191044718027115,
0.05002276971936226,
0.029130401089787483,
0.007582824677228928,
0.011681385338306427,
0.035601288080215454,
-0.04743998497724533,
0.023637600243091583,
0.0037304717116057873,
0.02299232967197895,
-0.0074052768759429455,
-0.027804400771856308,
0.03171766549348831,
0.04014553874731064,
-0.0021389778703451157,
-0.019008424133062363,
-0.0029970069881528616,
-0.006384127773344517,
0.009877953678369522,
-0.007164856418967247,
-0.02152625285089016,
0.03649546578526497,
0.013695711269974709,
-0.010821043513715267,
0.030636725947260857,
0.008806553669273853,
0.013895093463361263,
0.019602160900831223,
0.060003604739904404,
0.009752118960022926,
-0.009875774383544922,
-0.020294202491641045,
-0.0391894094645977,
-0.05246749520301819,
0.030519403517246246,
-0.007850406691432,
0.03577922284603119,
0.014143687672913074,
0.021336158737540245,
0.014417066238820553,
0.010842984542250633,
0.038919780403375626,
0.02644052915275097,
0.006941643543541431,
-0.0028924462385475636,
0.003179695690050721,
0.02862432971596718,
-0.005242604296654463,
0.031930066645145416,
-0.022856058552861214,
0.03546730801463127,
0.06514066457748413,
-0.007053922861814499,
-0.014376192353665829,
0.0171185489743948,
-0.011010320857167244,
-0.012140476144850254,
0.016103174537420273,
0.07369150221347809,
-0.01104794256389141,
-0.04507041350007057,
-0.021971063688397408,
-0.015393409878015518,
-0.16003648936748505,
-0.008324939757585526,
-0.0006482829339802265,
-0.004382116720080376,
0.016236187890172005,
0.02316759154200554,
-0.026285827159881592,
0.005680170375853777,
-0.048105139285326004,
0.01883535459637642,
0.00805317610502243,
-0.05580155923962593,
0.018298054113984108,
0.05500223860144615,
0.03954369202256203,
-0.0167692881077528,
-0.008722556754946709,
0.015574987046420574,
0.015721548348665237,
-0.03891005367040634,
-0.00352461077272892,
-0.007523846812546253,
0.025708796456456184,
-0.0273655466735363,
0.011689070612192154,
0.022813694551587105,
-0.0014192562084645033,
0.00976287480443716,
-0.04561960697174072,
-0.02122988924384117,
-0.042621590197086334,
0.018684860318899155,
-0.017145760357379913,
0.05098257586359978,
-0.011927894316613674,
0.031321752816438675,
0.09417295455932617,
-0.06633656471967697,
-0.025393525138497353,
-0.03833139315247536,
0.015034681186079979,
0.044157497584819794,
0.0109638636931777,
0.012104366905987263,
0.013922817073762417,
-0.0775970071554184,
-0.00003417960397200659,
0.031251706182956696,
0.03570502623915672,
0.021216288208961487,
-0.007276240270584822,
0.01571084000170231,
-0.03872337192296982,
-0.024019673466682434,
-0.012640668079257011,
-0.03509855642914772,
0.01867135800421238,
0.011323250830173492,
-0.05085427314043045,
0.003250203561037779,
-0.025418531149625778,
-0.050385843962430954,
0.004969528876245022,
0.008772621862590313,
0.0016501666978001595,
0.031967923045158386,
0.00038874102756381035,
-0.01999075338244438,
0.02317500300705433,
0.021453650668263435,
0.0013323478633537889,
-0.011705840937793255,
-0.022527653723955154,
-0.022569220513105392,
0.02881341055035591,
0.02519858069717884,
0.0042533609084784985,
-0.004427573177963495,
-0.009451847523450851,
-0.11434316635131836,
-0.03001781553030014,
0.027232065796852112,
-0.02402253821492195,
0.03891023248434067,
-0.018396658822894096,
0.022489842027425766,
0.013226932846009731,
0.051991336047649384,
0.03608802706003189,
0.2702137529850006,
-0.020393798127770424,
-0.01704353652894497,
0.027701126411557198,
0.005528158508241177,
-0.01422798726707697,
-0.02139945700764656,
0.04669218510389328,
-0.030833614990115166,
-0.04365617409348488,
0.006859314627945423,
0.00022285520390141755,
0.023455625399947166,
0.008911866694688797,
-0.0014343231450766325,
0.03639804199337959,
-0.07359859347343445,
-0.025199703872203827,
0.07645875215530396,
0.004579224623739719,
0.05971454828977585,
-0.05394045636057854,
-0.02037016674876213,
0.00029923251713626087,
-0.050745125859975815,
-0.06391221284866333,
0.04961221665143967,
0.0796341747045517,
-0.04547552391886711,
0.0013796075945720077,
-0.010796226561069489,
-0.013814186677336693,
0.004452878143638372,
0.0026240809820592403,
0.012354190461337566,
0.012372142635285854,
-0.02417907305061817,
0.03575626760721207,
0.015818554908037186,
0.02739686705172062,
-0.002567834220826626,
-0.04475534334778786,
0.0007075749454088509,
-0.06460584700107574,
-0.04145928844809532,
-0.0019901569467037916,
-0.031708426773548126,
0.02531428635120392,
-0.034779224544763565,
-0.02109651267528534,
-0.01101217046380043,
0.02973748929798603,
0.0042483750730752945,
0.020551886409521103,
-0.031078843399882317,
0.05771925300359726,
-0.03349427506327629,
0.03354258835315704,
-0.027094468474388123,
0.039665814489126205,
-0.004031861200928688,
0.016776015982031822,
-0.014174794778227806,
0.013992613181471825,
0.0005515040829777718,
-0.01736561208963394,
-0.030106699094176292,
-0.02593144215643406,
0.04396836832165718,
0.038958314806222916,
0.04238762706518173,
0.03237833082675934,
-0.017897741869091988,
0.004462318029254675,
0.04213452711701393,
0.00432713283225894,
-0.007158832158893347,
0.019574102014303207,
-0.003020591102540493,
-0.005836111959069967,
-0.032659757882356644,
-0.011572111397981644,
-0.009027862921357155,
0.008402634412050247,
0.03915075212717056,
0.016131671145558357,
-0.03877095878124237,
0.039240624755620956,
-0.020533306524157524,
-0.014788085594773293,
-0.03236716240644455,
-0.02581814117729664,
0.008314218372106552,
-0.03697359561920166,
0.021904349327087402,
-0.011052279733121395,
0.015058851800858974,
0.011444702744483948,
-0.04753708466887474,
-0.06269598007202148,
0.007267499342560768,
0.008501407690346241,
0.02557922713458538,
-0.04987658932805061,
0.0541222020983696,
0.013232087716460228,
-0.006713663227856159,
0.008372215554118156,
-0.05140604078769684,
-0.02282470464706421,
-0.038788676261901855,
-0.0026911713648587465,
0.015899570658802986,
-0.017408151179552078,
0.020116569474339485,
0.03414886072278023,
-0.014932619407773018,
0.051030486822128296,
0.01909390278160572,
0.010666247457265854,
-0.0165810976177454,
0.028214789927005768,
-0.03176472336053848,
0.002735109766945243,
-0.01486524660140276,
0.012723389081656933,
-0.02728886529803276,
-0.02864847145974636,
-0.009752806276082993,
0.017404813319444656,
-0.007550946436822414,
-0.027026671916246414,
-0.0680229663848877,
0.015610646456480026,
0.04653819650411606,
0.007584528531879187,
0.010344283655285835,
-0.008145425468683243,
-0.06264469027519226,
0.015266098082065582,
-0.03985303267836571,
0.023515867069363594,
-0.02101910673081875,
-0.009945068508386612,
-0.0002326369722140953,
0.0027556323911994696,
-0.09070111811161041,
0.015329932793974876,
-0.0478338785469532,
0.019345594570040703,
0.006092206574976444,
0.049361325800418854,
-0.04027489572763443,
-0.02459557354450226,
0.017857663333415985,
-0.017180953174829483,
-0.013516764156520367,
-0.008379636332392693,
0.020400650799274445,
-0.013936520554125309,
-0.013925038278102875,
0.004791173152625561,
0.010535139590501785,
0.017717357724905014,
0.008605844341218472,
0.043459367007017136,
-0.021710338070988655,
0.028751783072948456,
0.029942592605948448,
-0.0276009701192379,
0.013707309029996395,
-0.04399053007364273,
-0.013593955896794796,
0.08699934184551239,
-0.017379745841026306,
-0.011933386325836182,
0.035386547446250916,
0.017657354474067688,
0.035060420632362366,
-0.053512394428253174,
0.037685371935367584,
0.0068315365351736546,
-0.024747487157583237,
-0.0009998745517805219,
0.014106872491538525,
0.006493685767054558,
-0.016323307529091835,
-0.032763026654720306,
0.04334620386362076,
-0.0633520632982254,
-0.03242538124322891,
0.06660769879817963,
0.026575028896331787,
-0.02408107928931713,
-0.0002915821969509125,
0.013073054142296314,
0.002729679923504591,
0.03193097934126854,
-0.040744613856077194,
-0.031203005462884903,
-0.01244085468351841,
0.008316721767187119,
0.029604721814393997,
0.027176126837730408,
-0.006355721037834883,
0.013009131886065006,
0.0378020815551281,
0.0308633204549551,
-0.026682190597057343,
-0.022301124408841133,
0.012469426728785038,
-0.00017501307593192905,
-0.03593175858259201,
0.015395083464682102,
0.01939491368830204,
-0.049475185573101044,
0.026925263926386833,
0.03512522950768471,
0.01872049644589424,
-0.013267941772937775,
-0.014837786555290222,
-0.02199610322713852,
0.020683029666543007,
-0.06358405202627182,
-0.011661717668175697,
0.012784620746970177,
-0.021894702687859535,
-0.006949024740606546,
-0.022702062502503395,
-0.012508614920079708,
0.00026467425050213933,
-0.07649476826190948,
0.06034156680107117,
-0.06511379033327103,
0.012190109118819237,
0.005930671002715826,
0.04892983287572861,
0.016109993681311607,
0.016831807792186737,
-0.01077544130384922,
0.05340851843357086,
-0.03134748712182045,
0.0058614397421479225,
0.024446949362754822,
0.03398152440786362,
0.005371920298784971,
0.007530894596129656,
0.003704915288835764,
0.028781894594430923,
0.02680387906730175,
0.02175784669816494,
0.025747861713171005,
-0.00870691891759634,
-0.0016766134649515152,
0.009325944818556309,
0.02766019105911255,
0.0014022717950865626,
-0.034190040081739426,
-0.0413045696914196,
-0.02435953915119171,
0.009059291332960129,
-0.013704722747206688,
-0.009923218749463558,
-0.007633702829480171,
-0.07748088985681534,
-0.07059425115585327,
0.0019358099671080709,
-0.017800752073526382,
-0.014596485532820225,
-0.03160781040787697,
-0.005725769326090813,
-0.0066312700510025024,
0.0012453696690499783,
-0.037424180656671524,
0.001267269835807383,
0.0007732777739875019,
0.005377935711294413,
0.006967741996049881,
0.01960887387394905,
0.004564708098769188,
-0.003635720582678914,
-0.014688488095998764,
0.04121124744415283,
-0.0026315730065107346,
-0.011848162859678268,
0.023370914161205292,
-0.018377745524048805,
0.018854660913348198,
0.011838850565254688,
-0.011026241816580296,
-0.008380911312997341,
0.010083574801683426,
0.005772947799414396,
-0.003912864252924919,
-0.027536990121006966,
-0.05170246958732605,
-0.0010360039304941893,
0.0024233958683907986,
-0.011511381715536118,
0.019944343715906143,
-0.036288294941186905,
0.007059337105602026,
-0.0275014266371727,
-0.032625745981931686,
-0.01891522854566574,
0.005721920635551214,
0.006573703605681658,
-0.0017047562869265676,
0.0019420802127569914,
0.017156533896923065,
0.021463248878717422,
-0.08016791194677353,
0.036721937358379364,
-0.016872741281986237,
0.025577157735824585,
-0.00693559180945158,
0.032463718205690384,
0.01343829371035099,
-0.026924313977360725,
-0.009918078780174255,
-0.019556548446416855,
0.014780276454985142,
-0.03265507519245148,
-0.008134191855788231,
-0.05213174968957901,
0.007655059918761253,
0.0045738546177744865,
-0.020582331344485283,
-0.057305242866277695,
0.03380370885133743,
-0.0488290935754776,
-0.011962582357227802,
0.0007140962989069521,
0.006247056182473898,
0.03147014230489731,
-0.0016304142773151398,
0.021649295464158058,
-0.0033708233386278152,
0.06428281962871552,
-0.015420649200677872,
-0.026304537430405617,
-0.02773026004433632,
0.050560545176267624,
0.000463957607280463,
0.04625162109732628,
0.0009452570811845362,
0.014055035077035427,
-0.011377793736755848,
0.03807424008846283,
0.014496236108243465,
-0.024155989289283752,
0.008656312711536884,
0.0024485639296472073,
-0.0341075100004673,
0.007089320570230484,
0.023971734568476677,
0.024129429832100868,
0.030146120116114616,
0.02099093236029148,
-0.014606514945626259,
-0.018066493794322014,
0.024713894352316856,
-0.014111642725765705,
-0.026385009288787842,
0.0027945779729634523,
-0.02133912593126297,
0.015412448905408382,
0.02228657342493534,
0.003358981804922223,
0.028410783037543297,
-0.006905150134116411,
-0.03358028829097748,
0.028034286573529243,
-0.04346192628145218,
-0.06417359411716461,
0.04416823387145996,
0.003869962878525257,
0.022927891463041306,
-0.023601844906806946,
-0.04270630329847336,
-0.027061209082603455,
-0.044388297945261,
-0.03142806515097618,
0.005284321494400501,
0.04266357421875,
-0.02688582055270672,
-0.016021370887756348,
0.03326423466205597,
0.033072084188461304,
-0.022762814536690712,
-0.0025136193726211786,
0.014566508121788502,
-0.0442148856818676,
-0.0015572217525914311,
-0.1457103043794632,
0.00989865604788065,
0.013017946854233742,
-0.0346786230802536,
-0.036860883235931396,
0.0037060310132801533,
-0.061589017510414124,
0.040171001106500626,
-0.025813866406679153,
-0.017549816519021988,
-0.010427889414131641,
-0.022753939032554626,
0.015812981873750687,
-0.003514754120260477,
-0.04492932930588722,
0.015721432864665985,
-0.0263520535081625,
0.01361384429037571,
-0.04802609235048294,
0.01962335966527462,
0.028882808983325958,
0.02529914677143097,
-0.023838650435209274,
-0.007175774313509464,
0.007606819737702608,
-0.0038547790609300137,
-0.01607259176671505,
-0.06814496219158173,
-0.03687474504113197,
-0.004536201246082783,
-0.02939712442457676,
-0.03227784484624863,
-0.0033225705847144127,
0.0753435492515564,
0.037527475506067276,
0.030161382630467415,
0.008235537447035313,
-0.00527465995401144,
-0.03808235377073288,
-0.01487630046904087,
0.03178167715668678,
0.024222100153565407,
-0.01702067442238331,
-0.0069295563735067844,
0.022148625925183296,
0.015120577067136765,
-0.01568598300218582,
-0.027673158794641495,
-0.061885956674814224,
-0.0009433134109713137,
-0.061786651611328125,
0.03333374485373497,
-0.00106536946259439,
0.040299899876117706,
-0.02871616743505001,
0.021854594349861145,
-0.015468208119273186,
-0.004275113809853792,
0.02603236213326454,
0.05639633163809776,
0.010161071084439754,
-0.01046351995319128,
-0.0699421688914299,
-0.024117272347211838,
-0.030083196237683296,
-0.016904758289456367,
-0.030040618032217026,
-0.006950569339096546,
-0.024784782901406288,
-0.01113029383122921,
-0.0023542356211692095,
-0.021097909659147263,
-0.03201081231236458,
-0.06635180860757828,
0.021677875891327858,
-0.014130162075161934,
0.006879397202283144,
0.006909805350005627,
-0.03809676319360733,
0.020427700132131577,
-0.03209785372018814,
0.0024600026663392782,
-0.08096160739660263,
-0.0515584833920002,
0.06283348798751831,
0.03516470268368721,
0.01810952089726925,
-0.013461465016007423,
0.02091500163078308,
-0.047890324145555496,
-0.021526401862502098,
0.0019250049954280257,
0.0185200534760952,
0.030040591955184937,
-0.03496024012565613,
0.025425581261515617,
0.0018490994116291404,
-0.014315970242023468,
-0.0032792664133012295,
0.0031102271750569344,
-0.026419389992952347,
-0.02173612453043461,
-0.003173506585881114,
-0.0095236049965024,
-0.017674019560217857,
-0.0014865510165691376,
0.04250481352210045,
-0.0012604777002707124,
0.009145157411694527,
-0.013077070005238056,
-0.003573528490960598,
-0.011435513384640217,
-0.05656636878848076,
0.038016702979803085,
-0.06108666956424713,
0.020211236551404,
0.0078095910139381886,
0.017784830182790756,
-0.019192513078451157,
-0.0008889313321560621,
0.014021247625350952,
0.001224500359967351,
0.0029401422943919897,
-0.009857315570116043,
0.004945716820657253,
0.018715014681220055,
0.06237205117940903,
0.029527047649025917,
0.04933863505721092,
0.016056885942816734,
0.035813212394714355,
-0.01992885023355484,
0.009954972192645073,
0.02376522682607174,
0.010109907947480679,
0.023532874882221222,
-0.052554454654455185,
0.02167930267751217,
-0.02270667441189289,
0.009669546037912369,
-0.027575403451919556,
0.00961193535476923,
-0.019235875457525253,
0.01815924048423767,
-0.053847648203372955,
-0.028539571911096573,
0.026111040264368057,
-0.0037014430854469538,
-0.01395583339035511,
0.007729455828666687,
-0.00788327120244503,
0.014100332744419575,
-0.0242192130535841,
0.03793846070766449,
0.005121591500937939,
0.002560863271355629,
0.03218548372387886,
-0.01976504921913147,
0.03502393513917923,
0.025450240820646286,
0.017768463119864464,
-0.029570981860160828,
-0.0297990795224905,
-0.04572129622101784,
-0.006488401908427477,
0.057445671409368515,
-0.012704631313681602,
0.020711543038487434,
-0.0408453643321991,
-0.021802781149744987,
-0.031347326934337616,
0.000494634616188705,
-0.013699272647500038,
0.04869048297405243,
0.040540244430303574,
0.017852026969194412,
-0.019005853682756424,
-0.011044968850910664,
0.053263336420059204,
-0.030456997454166412,
0.04465120658278465,
0.03635626658797264,
0.042795222252607346,
0.0015115502756088972,
0.02115292102098465,
0.036454442888498306,
0.0077433353289961815,
-0.010558830574154854,
-0.03348772972822189,
-0.0418899804353714,
-0.03026784025132656,
0.022716782987117767,
0.018110912293195724,
0.02641577459871769,
0.04007212072610855,
0.04680892080068588,
0.004597896244376898,
0.026362745091319084,
-0.0036339617799967527,
0.01470947079360485,
0.04087953269481659,
-0.026184657588601112,
-0.03291769698262215,
-0.02466457337141037,
-0.013448158279061317,
0.0004892451106570661,
0.0315294973552227,
-0.044258520007133484,
-0.050304293632507324,
0.030262764543294907,
-0.024408899247646332,
-0.019215544685721397,
-0.032663166522979736,
0.010378262959420681,
-0.015461403876543045,
0.03925938904285431,
0.05585714057087898,
-0.021028723567724228,
0.027352651581168175,
-0.040439706295728683,
0.02006632834672928,
0.0739571750164032,
-0.024507369846105576,
-0.05454906448721886,
-0.024863095954060555,
-0.01945262961089611,
-0.02042713575065136,
-0.006748724728822708,
0.007403133902698755,
0.05092645063996315,
-0.00920935906469822,
-0.004737521056085825,
-0.0037893347907811403,
0.013180801644921303,
0.004402088467031717,
-0.013832885771989822,
-0.03143097832798958,
0.01570500060915947,
-0.022521279752254486,
-0.0011153251398354769,
0.06141636520624161,
-0.01663251966238022,
0.010817042551934719,
-0.029213199391961098
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:50
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
750That conduct is also impossible to reconcile with the proposition that Mr Hilliard and the plaintiffs were induced to consent to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings on the basis of anything said on (or indeed before) 27 August 2004 concerning the availability of funds or the prospect of $4.5 million arriving "next week" or at all.
751I will return to that aspect of the matter shortly. I pause to note that 27 August 2004 was a Friday. The "next week" ended on Friday 3 September 2004.
Stage 1 and Stage 2
752I have mentioned that on 28 July 2004 Mr Hilliard advised Mr Zdrilic that settlement of the transactions contemplated by the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement would proceed in two stages.
753The first stage involved settlement "between you and the other parties prior to the funder coming on board" and involved execution of board minutes, directors' consents, members' application for shares, execution of share transfers, execution of the Non-Dilution Deed, and most significantly, execution of the Short Minutes of Order dismissing the 2001 Proceedings.
754Stage 2 involved "settlement with a funder". At this stage it was proposed that Mr Hilliard would hand over the TressCox Caveat Undertaking and the Withdrawal of Caveat in exchange for letters from Messrs Hickie and Ansell resigning as directors of HTT and, most significantly the provision of funds.
755Absent funds, Mr Hilliard could have insisted that only Stage 1 proceed and that the Withdrawal of Caveat not be handed over until funds were provided.
756It is hard to see on what basis Mr Gillard and Mr Renshall could have resisted that course.
757What happened however, notwithstanding that no funds were to hand, was that Mr Hilliard agreed that not only would Stage 1 proceed, but also part of Stage 2, namely the handing over of the Withdrawal of Caveat.
758I am satisfied that Mr Hilliard was induced to part with the Withdrawal of Caveat because of the terms of the undertaking given to him by Mr Gillard and because of the statement made by Mr Gillard that he would hand over the Withdrawal of Caveat to Mr Moir at a "separate settlement" at which, Mr Hilliard correctly inferred settlement $4.5 million would be handed over.
759But I am not satisfied that this had anything to do with the execution by the plaintiffs of the Non-Dilution Deed, nor the execution by Mr Hilliard of the Short Minutes concerning the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings.
760Those documents were to be executed and handed over as part of Stage 1.
761I find no suggestion in the evidence that execution of these documents was contingent in any way on the production of funds.
762Indeed, Mr Hilliard's letter of 27 August 2004 made clear that he (and thus the plaintiffs) were "in the spirit of working together for the commercial success of the project and as a sign of continuing goodwill" prepared to proceed with the settlement, even to the extent of handing over the Withdrawal of Caveat, despite the fact that (as Mr Hilliard and the plaintiffs then understood it) $4.
5 million (rather than $12 million) was to be advanced to HTT.
763Thus Mr Hilliard's letter indicated the plaintiffs would, for these reasons, proceed with both Stages 1 and 2.
764When it turned out that no funds (not even the $4.5 million) were to be handed over on 27 August 2004 the decision by Mr Hilliard to proceed with Stage 2 was made on the basis of Mr Gillard's undertaking and assurance about the "separate settlement".
765My finding is that Mr Hilliard and the plaintiffs proposed to proceed with Stage 1 in any event, and did so.
766Although Mr Hilliard had, as I have set out above, anticipated that, all other things being equal, Stages 1 and 2 would take part as one settlement, that is not how things worked out on the day.
767The events of the following week make this clear.
The lodgement of the Withdrawal of Caveat
768Notwithstanding the terms of his undertaking, Mr Gillard did not deliver the Withdrawal of Caveat to Mr Moir "in relation to the funding" as set out in his letter of 26 August 2004, or at all.
769Mr Gillard said:-
|
[
-0.014361797831952572,
0.020585132762789726,
-0.056301552802324295,
0.035211190581321716,
0.006695479620248079,
-0.006020910106599331,
0.0021869493648409843,
0.013047403655946255,
0.010354415513575077,
0.02637026272714138,
0.009090734645724297,
0.017234209924936295,
-0.00911283865571022,
-0.005930962041020393,
-0.024870868772268295,
-0.01561783067882061,
0.03718975931406021,
-0.031756605952978134,
0.017260588705539703,
0.0025622164830565453,
-0.014562482014298439,
-0.016716687008738518,
0.02382912114262581,
0.01237491425126791,
-0.03878924250602722,
-0.016582651063799858,
-0.007446636445820332,
-0.0054296222515404224,
0.030779555439949036,
0.06089899316430092,
-0.008579091168940067,
0.008265768177807331,
0.013850627467036247,
0.005209439434111118,
-0.018006499856710434,
-0.009173760190606117,
0.023736506700515747,
-0.00003301762626506388,
-0.042231570929288864,
0.02995009906589985,
-0.033342305570840836,
0.010727963410317898,
0.01949489489197731,
0.010201816447079182,
0.0512324795126915,
-0.03393302857875824,
-0.03630724921822548,
-0.02000604383647442,
-0.0016325425822287798,
0.012611919082701206,
-0.028060683980584145,
-0.03605012968182564,
0.015260957181453705,
-0.029017994180321693,
-0.005605902057141066,
-0.0038215864915400743,
-0.024105850607156754,
-0.01394959818571806,
-0.041724927723407745,
0.0453682616353035,
0.011661571450531483,
-0.0016146058915182948,
-0.040378764271736145,
-0.0004835334839299321,
0.009838569909334183,
0.05103973299264908,
0.0010920737404376268,
-0.008061434142291546,
0.0053102197125554085,
-0.009449881501495838,
-0.03185217082500458,
0.003619479015469551,
-0.001654396764934063,
-0.014606624841690063,
-0.09819789230823517,
0.00795197207480669,
0.049431491643190384,
-0.007424655836075544,
0.03369685262441635,
0.02031763084232807,
0.03487670421600342,
-0.020084122195839882,
-0.008294333703815937,
0.051240477710962296,
-0.04174422472715378,
0.018087321892380714,
0.016304347664117813,
0.025287413969635963,
0.03135477378964424,
-0.008798277005553246,
-0.01554163172841072,
-0.00808427482843399,
0.002652558730915189,
-0.06266292929649353,
-0.0006920837913639843,
-0.02409183606505394,
-0.07323408126831055,
0.06325410306453705,
-0.00095378264086321,
0.029274553060531616,
0.014166646637022495,
0.02642950788140297,
-0.03315793722867966,
-0.008424722589552402,
0.03775842860341072,
0.038462646305561066,
0.05350986868143082,
0.021084386855363846,
0.005309326574206352,
-0.016491271555423737,
0.007625430356711149,
-0.011691898107528687,
0.016482213512063026,
0.003431251971051097,
-0.012075298465788364,
-0.005907585844397545,
0.02001984976232052,
-0.0015974381240084767,
0.014164953492581844,
0.01858600787818432,
0.05256742984056473,
-0.0009074996924027801,
0.031240243464708328,
-0.026014450937509537,
-0.017511744052171707,
0.011813884600996971,
0.02874162793159485,
-0.009284494444727898,
0.0004610297328326851,
0.03052365779876709,
-0.017805812880396843,
0.04487714543938637,
-0.01576361060142517,
-0.043221957981586456,
-0.019300879910588264,
0.013065923936665058,
0.007053782697767019,
-0.006995201576501131,
0.03914335370063782,
-0.06456433236598969,
0.05775507912039757,
0.02236320823431015,
-0.0064779166132211685,
-0.04223224148154259,
0.012525527738034725,
-0.04737015441060066,
-0.01397348940372467,
0.0028048264794051647,
0.02944665215909481,
0.005091988481581211,
0.0011865533888339996,
-0.004771660082042217,
0.004493792075663805,
0.0010237242095172405,
0.05958458036184311,
-0.03518443927168846,
-0.036466460675001144,
-0.009157163091003895,
0.017425091937184334,
0.07566936314105988,
-0.0011287161614745855,
0.021833017468452454,
-0.019054226577281952,
0.015668535605072975,
0.005426255986094475,
0.006661796942353249,
0.007578378077596426,
0.005450153723359108,
0.0027794374618679285,
-0.013751700520515442,
0.0031985847745090723,
-0.0168598759919405,
0.050328463315963745,
-0.014246391132473946,
0.03014553152024746,
0.02434627152979374,
0.08812092989683151,
0.005481393542140722,
0.030958738178014755,
-0.04414533078670502,
-0.034302305430173874,
0.048536837100982666,
0.008657627739012241,
-0.03966524079442024,
-0.03925637528300285,
0.030205361545085907,
-0.018626201897859573,
-0.03498584032058716,
0.0024015384260565042,
0.023176223039627075,
-0.007082543335855007,
-0.006216039415448904,
0.02780291810631752,
0.012610816396772861,
0.025287769734859467,
-0.00786364171653986,
-0.002668554661795497,
-0.04666607081890106,
-0.01911422610282898,
-0.0031356727704405785,
-0.037701502442359924,
0.03298557922244072,
0.05530684441328049,
0.0023454814217984676,
-0.033990588039159775,
0.010812626220285892,
-0.02162000723183155,
-0.008741050027310848,
0.02652224339544773,
-0.03490711376070976,
-0.004810610320419073,
0.005496027413755655,
-0.011807124130427837,
-0.027060240507125854,
0.0005095551023259759,
0.0008560320711694658,
-0.018587371334433556,
0.0059858886525034904,
-0.01714915595948696,
-0.03439468517899513,
-0.0005643661716021597,
-0.015952318906784058,
0.010990303941071033,
-0.03896293044090271,
0.0066633084788918495,
0.05595993995666504,
-0.07235528528690338,
0.015436628833413124,
-0.019330818206071854,
-0.024240359663963318,
-0.00799716729670763,
-0.006193908862769604,
0.019396541640162468,
0.0072233909741044044,
0.032806333154439926,
0.005922478158026934,
0.0017113154754042625,
0.011328494176268578,
0.018028242513537407,
0.017977626994252205,
-0.021862253546714783,
0.04418753460049629,
0.0006558383465744555,
0.00602292874827981,
0.014677850529551506,
-0.020356636494398117,
-0.017417076975107193,
0.029812956228852272,
0.01695132441818714,
-0.017166156321763992,
0.0020634590182453394,
0.013855867087841034,
-0.02495790645480156,
0.014448283240199089,
-0.012689068913459778,
0.010070203803479671,
0.005689410958439112,
-0.01903120055794716,
0.04202757403254509,
0.024256717413663864,
0.03879239410161972,
0.03712256997823715,
0.035664673894643784,
0.018433909863233566,
-0.03124019131064415,
-0.01958334445953369,
-0.03221729397773743,
-0.02848264016211033,
0.02754106931388378,
0.002087564440444112,
-0.0046377032995224,
0.018222330138087273,
-0.02907583862543106,
0.0386030375957489,
0.00638360483571887,
0.024197489023208618,
0.028610453009605408,
0.02611342817544937,
0.04449116438627243,
0.0009574134019203484,
-0.020019149407744408,
0.009515735320746899,
0.03810398653149605,
-0.002802813658490777,
0.04719271510839462,
0.04339292645454407,
-0.059417475014925,
-0.0009299186640419066,
0.01233584713190794,
0.00033266370883211493,
0.004961598198860884,
0.02013539709150791,
0.0627269446849823,
-0.006355135701596737,
-0.03098697029054165,
-0.05675864592194557,
-0.017173275351524353,
-0.1578449159860611,
0.021295087411999702,
-0.01800464279949665,
-0.016466237604618073,
0.003029316198080778,
0.006674779113382101,
-0.012001091614365578,
-0.011449793353676796,
-0.034963447600603104,
-0.010591592639684677,
0.028217511251568794,
-0.058122728019952774,
0.004118907731026411,
0.058931492269039154,
0.008173031732439995,
-0.021068230271339417,
0.0068967207334935665,
0.0065884822979569435,
0.04099234566092491,
-0.03898628428578377,
-0.025550268590450287,
-0.06436415761709213,
0.04818372800946236,
-0.022137455642223358,
0.014706377871334553,
0.0007001194753684103,
-0.0024148477241396904,
0.03210440278053284,
-0.051258593797683716,
-0.014831678941845894,
-0.0553811751306057,
0.013659359887242317,
-0.01590658351778984,
0.0497610904276371,
0.0036386954598128796,
0.05410097911953926,
0.09450835734605789,
-0.0588822141289711,
0.002834803657606244,
-0.05428565666079521,
0.02171202003955841,
0.0465378537774086,
-0.012132101692259312,
-0.006209421902894974,
-0.0015522608300670981,
-0.06587085872888565,
0.021471960470080376,
-0.0013314196839928627,
0.000466865545604378,
0.0029334533028304577,
0.0047661131247878075,
0.010463899001479149,
-0.019783981144428253,
-0.038692303001880646,
-0.0005928594036959112,
-0.025776611641049385,
0.01749345287680626,
0.03391190618276596,
-0.07214007526636124,
-0.0034791359212249517,
-0.010577082633972168,
-0.06432095915079117,
0.018366724252700806,
0.026440775021910667,
-0.018051765859127045,
-0.01564948447048664,
-0.027629896998405457,
-0.03683922439813614,
0.03323045372962952,
0.019188066944479942,
-0.0005469608586281538,
-0.039022449404001236,
-0.007909761741757393,
-0.0021809975150972605,
0.03961432725191116,
0.034556739032268524,
-0.02472029998898506,
0.01822158508002758,
-0.019349481910467148,
-0.12100126594305038,
-0.014996729791164398,
0.02380390465259552,
-0.03369281813502312,
0.007425658870488405,
0.007979295216500759,
0.01727309450507164,
0.0048468150198459625,
0.01858028769493103,
0.005632888060063124,
0.25010815262794495,
-0.006534604821354151,
0.0011104921577498317,
0.06222112849354744,
0.04123435541987419,
-0.0014551295898854733,
0.02010253258049488,
0.04720089212059975,
-0.025503894314169884,
-0.05410496145486832,
-0.035875916481018066,
-0.023146875202655792,
0.026392804458737373,
0.002507719211280346,
-0.0013435047585517168,
0.03172796592116356,
-0.0717225894331932,
-0.026414334774017334,
0.09675711393356323,
-0.0024911726359277964,
0.07280915230512619,
-0.046667132526636124,
0.002475927583873272,
0.013217179104685783,
-0.07351209223270416,
-0.035366471856832504,
0.013264323584735394,
0.03811708092689514,
-0.026204781606793404,
-0.004014349076896906,
-0.03202396258711815,
0.00428549200296402,
0.01575198769569397,
-0.011989902704954147,
-0.00597494887188077,
0.03507474809885025,
0.014429681934416294,
-0.004096823278814554,
0.007923193275928497,
0.03434304893016815,
-0.0029201132711023092,
-0.040526341646909714,
-0.021657541394233704,
-0.057046741247177124,
-0.03183451667428017,
0.008355378173291683,
-0.006893406622111797,
0.02987104095518589,
-0.04878511279821396,
-0.024787984788417816,
0.010181731544435024,
0.02024352364242077,
0.003983248025178909,
-0.000959420227445662,
-0.0011208783835172653,
0.024840692058205605,
-0.01340989675372839,
0.05736545845866203,
-0.017513783648610115,
0.0421789176762104,
-0.0012689889408648014,
0.01610678806900978,
-0.03012181632220745,
0.013582023791968822,
0.002763078548014164,
-0.013243013061583042,
-0.05415910482406616,
0.019875312224030495,
0.06498915702104568,
0.04000335559248924,
0.011747179552912712,
0.010140916332602501,
-0.04030710458755493,
-0.0019409871893003583,
0.021046096459031105,
0.0055124168284237385,
-0.05714014545083046,
-0.0010046536335721612,
0.004545088857412338,
-0.0005177375860512257,
-0.00799716915935278,
-0.05190141499042511,
-0.02104041911661625,
0.029722504317760468,
0.020978515967726707,
0.00720586720854044,
-0.023970315232872963,
0.059739939868450165,
-0.016024842858314514,
-0.04324564337730408,
0.0031023514457046986,
-0.016196370124816895,
0.0026592195499688387,
-0.001648038043640554,
0.017923371866345406,
-0.029093747958540916,
0.027958041056990623,
-0.001848209765739739,
-0.026165151968598366,
-0.0239518191665411,
-0.030294323340058327,
0.019708318635821342,
0.03313066437840462,
-0.041956428438425064,
0.010249805636703968,
-0.023647667840123177,
0.006184878759086132,
-0.022544147446751595,
-0.053827181458473206,
-0.029893595725297928,
-0.051587510854005814,
0.009578129276633263,
-0.007277060300111771,
-0.028995193541049957,
0.0005994283128529787,
0.08278420567512512,
0.010000820271670818,
0.03867042437195778,
0.026123980060219765,
0.03188811615109444,
0.007560582831501961,
0.011195456609129906,
-0.031039509922266006,
0.017037317156791687,
-0.010433687828481197,
-0.002913252916187048,
-0.026108283549547195,
-0.01721036061644554,
0.012332704849541187,
-0.0005769242998212576,
-0.0074305362068116665,
-0.042916856706142426,
-0.030516061931848526,
0.01156997587531805,
0.03543032705783844,
0.00938114058226347,
0.014280501753091812,
-0.005779407452791929,
-0.05114174261689186,
0.002174420515075326,
-0.035207461565732956,
-0.008320282213389874,
-0.020036639645695686,
-0.011449156329035759,
-0.0041260262951254845,
0.03298969194293022,
-0.07348580658435822,
0.01987902633845806,
-0.05856999382376671,
0.010496421717107296,
0.00009217891056323424,
0.04849909618496895,
-0.056269992142915726,
-0.008833244442939758,
0.00966537557542324,
-0.015184495598077774,
-0.019498364999890327,
0.004109834786504507,
-0.003043580101802945,
-0.0340924970805645,
0.003814080497249961,
-0.004016511607915163,
0.03225432336330414,
0.0018675499595701694,
0.051719292998313904,
0.07770505547523499,
-0.004405554383993149,
0.06348618119955063,
0.03331790864467621,
-0.022544115781784058,
0.014063804410398006,
-0.020999975502490997,
-0.023851953446865082,
0.08782350271940231,
0.006315253209322691,
-0.0033124475739896297,
-0.009220968931913376,
0.034381795674562454,
0.013456637039780617,
-0.013613029383122921,
0.04454880580306053,
-0.005841458216309547,
-0.008870305493474007,
-0.0011082582641392946,
0.00887856725603342,
0.005875668488442898,
0.008802952244877815,
-0.013479390181601048,
0.01811659149825573,
-0.05399273708462715,
-0.02491999790072441,
0.07404688000679016,
0.0061113229021430016,
-0.015379801392555237,
-0.01861923560500145,
0.005638930480927229,
0.0007738671265542507,
0.04510410875082016,
0.004410220310091972,
-0.015938783064484596,
-0.027076315134763718,
-0.004568284377455711,
0.03921906650066376,
-0.00560477189719677,
0.015028179623186588,
0.009031158871948719,
-0.006627922412008047,
0.05324573814868927,
-0.050873879343271255,
-0.02205221727490425,
0.024019088596105576,
0.006328503601253033,
-0.04294444993138313,
0.02356729470193386,
0.00027291756123304367,
-0.031229473650455475,
0.03226624056696892,
0.06961534172296524,
0.03854392096400261,
-0.06881338357925415,
0.007133998442441225,
-0.039914727210998535,
-0.0008358259219676256,
-0.04315222054719925,
-0.046894609928131104,
-0.00546060549095273,
-0.07355228811502457,
0.02157808654010296,
-0.022621670737862587,
-0.00866700429469347,
0.004270079080015421,
-0.06362906098365784,
0.038671933114528656,
-0.060654208064079285,
0.014936374500393867,
-0.007394091226160526,
0.059981558471918106,
0.0035381410270929337,
0.051541682332754135,
0.00027066655457019806,
0.02268662489950657,
-0.039649005979299545,
0.021362990140914917,
0.00001066413096850738,
0.02814534120261669,
-0.010269032791256905,
-0.0030156795401126146,
-0.023465508595108986,
0.016902733594179153,
0.043419498950242996,
-0.008902497589588165,
0.015695370733737946,
0.014458992518484592,
-0.0024227784015238285,
0.013454356230795383,
0.008242427371442318,
0.026378141716122627,
-0.03504351153969765,
-0.048800744116306305,
-0.06498590856790543,
0.023209597915410995,
0.02425716072320938,
-0.018382150679826736,
-0.013123676180839539,
-0.04571042209863663,
-0.08029645681381226,
0.030172860249876976,
-0.022411450743675232,
-0.010056904517114162,
-0.00820954516530037,
0.0051546222530305386,
-0.017240609973669052,
0.021197330206632614,
-0.0536474883556366,
-0.005097775254398584,
-0.004983952268958092,
-0.01833581179380417,
-0.010736743919551373,
0.03806152194738388,
0.0003816611715592444,
-0.004041584208607674,
-0.02872295305132866,
0.026210835203528404,
-0.00445524649694562,
-0.027045326307415962,
0.0021893256343901157,
-0.013014623895287514,
0.006343682296574116,
-0.010723392479121685,
-0.03406369686126709,
0.006058108527213335,
-0.0019071564311161637,
-0.003872947534546256,
0.014990151859819889,
0.023910149931907654,
-0.044657498598098755,
0.001120194559916854,
0.008898173458874226,
-0.037138160318136215,
0.033641863614320755,
-0.03134545311331749,
-0.02330130897462368,
-0.031295087188482285,
-0.01692897267639637,
-0.0363922156393528,
-0.012184159830212593,
0.015121347270905972,
-0.03708996623754501,
-0.0024119310546666384,
0.03712312877178192,
0.020031845197081566,
-0.06772483885288239,
-0.01530612912029028,
-0.037116073071956635,
0.05561460182070732,
-0.0001894905581139028,
-0.007982226088643074,
0.01345817744731903,
-0.03805549442768097,
0.0270016361027956,
-0.02401791512966156,
-0.003448078641667962,
-0.06341458112001419,
-0.008118730038404465,
-0.03274574875831604,
-0.0005644468474201858,
0.05489465594291687,
-0.023768367245793343,
-0.04352356866002083,
0.013948739506304264,
-0.03523259982466698,
-0.00534326396882534,
0.008747352287173271,
0.007860204204916954,
0.01674792729318142,
0.007381794974207878,
0.021159060299396515,
0.01614883914589882,
0.05085591971874237,
-0.016555577516555786,
-0.023371482267975807,
-0.05422580614686012,
0.05778517201542854,
0.005437318701297045,
0.004498687107115984,
0.009534109383821487,
-0.00646193278953433,
-0.022639689967036247,
0.003231493290513754,
0.029373472556471825,
-0.002252392703667283,
0.009087449871003628,
-0.011197278276085854,
-0.028448740020394325,
0.052373070269823074,
0.008179468102753162,
0.013978967443108559,
0.03871055692434311,
0.051092516630887985,
-0.00916454941034317,
-0.009392664767801762,
0.010811956599354744,
-0.0013354254188016057,
-0.021759793162345886,
-0.02446499466896057,
-0.008034365251660347,
0.018696293234825134,
0.037803418934345245,
0.01499509159475565,
0.0028117187321186066,
0.007663409225642681,
-0.03845616802573204,
0.011922216974198818,
-0.03711428493261337,
-0.0566854253411293,
0.02975430339574814,
0.028652476146817207,
0.006016171537339687,
0.001090325997211039,
-0.06591765582561493,
-0.011612934991717339,
-0.021456848829984665,
-0.04360697418451309,
-0.02048129215836525,
0.0116547467187047,
0.01361689530313015,
-0.021940438076853752,
0.056703682988882065,
0.034331925213336945,
-0.0030568342190235853,
0.012589790858328342,
0.02226635254919529,
-0.03281930088996887,
-0.008872493170201778,
-0.14544543623924255,
0.03220400586724281,
0.019406668841838837,
-0.011748802848160267,
-0.03262470290064812,
0.009020690806210041,
-0.01166978757828474,
0.006171829532831907,
-0.045821454375982285,
-0.009476855397224426,
0.011634081602096558,
-0.03115249238908291,
-0.04937824234366417,
-0.02165118418633938,
-0.03897254168987274,
0.030566968023777008,
-0.028133828192949295,
-0.008499298244714737,
-0.048475708812475204,
0.006750765722244978,
0.02026418410241604,
-0.003049961756914854,
0.010621757246553898,
-0.006347688380628824,
-0.0006539809401147068,
-0.01380261778831482,
0.0022319548297673464,
-0.07179784029722214,
-0.029119636863470078,
-0.05097465217113495,
-0.03616345673799515,
-0.022662078961730003,
-0.025191860273480415,
0.08130253106355667,
-0.013495679944753647,
0.03325891122221947,
0.0035424907691776752,
-0.027083666995167732,
-0.025355752557516098,
-0.01644200272858143,
-0.00021680488134734333,
0.033366765826940536,
0.0021304264664649963,
-0.04434959217905998,
-0.0034112308640033007,
0.009877249598503113,
-0.011433357372879982,
0.011209066025912762,
-0.04405076429247856,
-0.04397357255220413,
-0.05219406262040138,
0.04870792105793953,
0.010092642158269882,
0.015345599502325058,
-0.005196901969611645,
-0.01599387638270855,
0.012608693912625313,
-0.017799364402890205,
0.0584174245595932,
0.0475352443754673,
0.03671175241470337,
0.019526416435837746,
-0.03057640977203846,
0.004135665483772755,
-0.01809782348573208,
0.018332360312342644,
-0.024478714913129807,
0.002301139058545232,
0.0064454576931893826,
0.015397402457892895,
-0.030078718438744545,
0.014333273284137249,
-0.024094248190522194,
-0.020100446417927742,
-0.0037158287595957518,
-0.041918348520994186,
-0.046381112188100815,
0.01883445680141449,
-0.02096828632056713,
-0.009928392246365547,
-0.030578136444091797,
-0.004589858464896679,
-0.06218038126826286,
-0.020145807415246964,
0.08852310478687286,
0.03536203131079674,
-0.02205422706902027,
-0.01678619347512722,
-0.015096860937774181,
-0.021910134702920914,
-0.021947424858808517,
-0.009936637245118618,
-0.0007059203344397247,
0.023010393604636192,
-0.02371836081147194,
0.023833537474274635,
-0.0060065677389502525,
-0.023406686261296272,
-0.0295316893607378,
0.014458049088716507,
-0.01279047317802906,
-0.004498335067182779,
-0.012986292131245136,
-0.015277141705155373,
-0.007068794220685959,
0.015411680564284325,
0.0455949567258358,
-0.00011153142258990556,
0.02856324426829815,
-0.03014271892607212,
-0.013487594202160835,
-0.019385678693652153,
-0.05296699330210686,
0.034308724105358124,
-0.05671268329024315,
-0.00744319474324584,
0.019639668986201286,
0.03178292512893677,
-0.007946806959807873,
0.002021702006459236,
0.015042911283671856,
-0.036138590425252914,
0.01434260606765747,
-0.03183961659669876,
0.015994084998965263,
0.011643709614872932,
0.06661424040794373,
0.028645580634474754,
0.06424988061189651,
-0.005866187158972025,
0.04089713469147682,
-0.0040987152606248856,
0.0016092469450086355,
0.007346155121922493,
0.03491171821951866,
0.012599386274814606,
-0.03581495210528374,
0.02450612373650074,
-0.03725724667310715,
0.0018345771823078394,
-0.01167727168649435,
-0.0032638986594974995,
0.0076109967194497585,
0.0045420327223837376,
-0.03993529826402664,
-0.005515212193131447,
0.04890120029449463,
-0.015929164364933968,
-0.012719920836389065,
0.007510631810873747,
-0.03821590170264244,
0.01264842040836811,
0.008813092485070229,
0.08064563572406769,
0.015534776262938976,
0.0062892865389585495,
0.042558662593364716,
0.037049174308776855,
-0.004215202759951353,
0.021332597360014915,
-0.002245644573122263,
-0.017393192276358604,
-0.031051428988575935,
-0.0339355506002903,
-0.020058803260326385,
0.027032123878598213,
-0.015575520694255829,
0.02457979880273342,
-0.014685163274407387,
-0.03658292070031166,
-0.008838092908263206,
0.036825038492679596,
-0.011502208188176155,
0.0350387804210186,
0.04066762700676918,
-0.03387678787112236,
-0.009709288366138935,
-0.012497751042246819,
0.04115910083055496,
-0.027757730334997177,
0.0481400266289711,
0.030783627182245255,
0.0369771271944046,
0.016162309795618057,
0.050897154957056046,
0.023976411670446396,
0.01587194949388504,
0.02428237535059452,
-0.03170742467045784,
-0.028419258072972298,
0.021742219105362892,
-0.022921988740563393,
0.022154079750180244,
-0.02104870229959488,
0.029294533655047417,
-0.00759968813508749,
-0.022112971171736717,
-0.006148353219032288,
0.004430566448718309,
0.01979163847863674,
0.030021414160728455,
-0.03195222467184067,
-0.015826627612113953,
0.005120772868394852,
-0.006108717527240515,
0.019888127222657204,
-0.009563389234244823,
-0.06566119939088821,
-0.03719019517302513,
0.03971950337290764,
0.0007348973304033279,
-0.009284495376050472,
-0.0171451848000288,
0.02100718766450882,
-0.018418336287140846,
0.019273366779088974,
0.013844911940395832,
-0.017405245453119278,
0.01678830198943615,
-0.01624630019068718,
0.025536471977829933,
0.06937726587057114,
-0.0052381898276507854,
-0.024668846279382706,
-0.011434177868068218,
-0.025819333270192146,
-0.03198900446295738,
-0.017483191564679146,
0.01001290325075388,
0.0249156691133976,
-0.03622683137655258,
0.008246613666415215,
0.006078981328755617,
0.024262307211756706,
0.029895389452576637,
-0.03280327469110489,
-0.030499810352921486,
0.0008548583718948066,
-0.055888861417770386,
0.03629438579082489,
0.032332539558410645,
-0.002499416470527649,
0.024886824190616608,
-0.007520677987486124
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:47
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
* Mr Frederick and Mr Tugrul were the directors nominated by the new funder to represent the new funder on the board of HTT; and
* Mr Frederick resided in New Zealand.
698In final submissions, Mr Jucovic said that the last two representations (concerning Messrs Frederick and Tugrul) were not pressed.
699The balance of the representations concerns the availability of funds.
700According to Mr Zdrilic's evidence, Mr Renshall made the representations orally, for the most part in one continuous monologue.
701Mr Zdrilic made no note of the alleged representations.
702Mr Renshall denied making the representations. In particular he denied:-
(a)saying that the project would progress at a "fast pace". He said that "nothing in property development happens at a fast pace";
(b)saying the various figures attributed to him;
(c)giving any assurance that the funding would be forthcoming.
703Mr Renshall said he had no control over the funding.
704Mr Renshall said he did recall saying something to the effect:-
"There has been a delay in the funding. I except that will be remedied shortly."
705Mr Renshall said that in making that statement he relied upon his conversation with Mr Hanna on 24 August 2004, the Ping Letter and the terms of the IPC Heads of Agreement.
706In his evidence, Mr Hilliard made no reference to Mr Renshall having made representations of the kind alleged by Mr Zdrilic.
707On the contrary, Mr Hilliard said that his conversation with Mr Gillard, set out above, occurred "at the outset" of the 27 August 2004 meeting.
708Mr Hilliard said that, after that exchange took place there was a preliminary review of documents for settlement during which period Mr Renshall "apparently made a number of telephone calls to Michael Ansell trying to locate him to attend the meeting".
709Thus, although Mr Hilliard referred to his recollection of what Mr Renshall was doing that afternoon, he made no mention of any statements of the kind attributed by Mr Zdrilic to Mr Renshall.
710In these circumstances, I am not satisfied that any of the representations alleged by Mr Zdrilic were made.
711For reasons I will explain below, I do accept that Mr Hilliard left the settlement of 27 August 2004 believing that there would be a further settlement, at some time in the future, between Mr Gillard and Mr Moir at which time $4.
5 million would be handed over (in exchange for a Withdrawal of the Caveat). However, for reasons I will explain, this was based upon an undertaking given by Mr Gillard to Mr Hilliard and not based upon anything Mr Renshall said.
The settlement proceeds
712Whatever was said, and notwithstanding the absence of Mr Moir or any funds from IPC or any other party, Stage 1 of the settlement (as envisaged by Mr Hilliard) proceeded.
713The Non-Dilution Deed was executed, the Short Minutes dismissing the 2001 Proceedings were executed and minutes of board meetings and other documents were executed.
714The result was that the structure referred to at paragraph 72 above was established whereby the Zdrilic family (through Amy Holdings) became an equal 1/3 shareholder (with Messrs Renshall and Hickie) in Sentel, and thus, in turn, acquired a 27.5 per cent interest in HTT and in the Huntley Trust.
715Not only that, but Mr Hilliard delivered to Mr Gillard the Withdrawal of Caveat notwithstanding that no funds were handed over and that, according to Mr Hilliard's plans, this was to only occur at Stage 2 of the settlement and only in exchange for funds.
716This occurred in the circumstances set out below.
Mr Renshall's state of mind
717I have set out above the evidence so far as concerns Mr Renshall's state of mind as to the availability of funds from Sydney Finance (the $4.5 million) and IBC/Mr Ping (the $40 million).
718In cross-examination, Mr Renshall maintained that his belief was that the funds from IPC "were coming".
719He said:-
|
[
-0.04046007990837097,
0.028211034834384918,
-0.01839897222816944,
0.00012484991748351604,
-0.008153705857694149,
-0.036632928997278214,
0.0026721234899014235,
-0.015109810046851635,
0.006908012554049492,
0.007204623427242041,
0.011657592840492725,
0.041669849306344986,
-0.03236605226993561,
0.012724562548100948,
-0.030442366376519203,
-0.035635173320770264,
0.05040596053004265,
-0.028028858825564384,
0.015593407675623894,
-0.017023080959916115,
0.004086329601705074,
-0.013679573312401772,
-0.01174316368997097,
0.028413577005267143,
0.00004299949068808928,
-0.0015557855367660522,
-0.008542826399207115,
0.037744879722595215,
0.022755101323127747,
0.03177322447299957,
0.009945901110768318,
0.007336596958339214,
0.010004900395870209,
-0.024147406220436096,
0.002553223865106702,
-0.022537698969244957,
0.021853897720575333,
-0.001035351655445993,
-0.029616260901093483,
0.023201340809464455,
-0.0028235502541065216,
0.02297997660934925,
0.023982904851436615,
0.0063772364519536495,
0.06530512869358063,
-0.033848702907562256,
0.0011128798360005021,
-0.033316608518362045,
0.011728302575647831,
0.02877899445593357,
-0.0206401739269495,
-0.040610797703266144,
0.016543297097086906,
-0.034321125596761703,
-0.014715409837663174,
-0.0029510625172406435,
-0.04052449390292168,
0.016877993941307068,
-0.0448901429772377,
0.024716617539525032,
0.012619193643331528,
0.005400124471634626,
-0.049431174993515015,
0.01347372680902481,
-0.012335219420492649,
0.12444333732128143,
-0.004677970428019762,
-0.003945629578083754,
0.00884263776242733,
-0.010183997452259064,
-0.05172204598784447,
-0.01345578208565712,
-0.03594845160841942,
-0.02826063521206379,
-0.09824339300394058,
0.020016146823763847,
0.024746587499976158,
0.010965244844555855,
0.012220809236168861,
0.030063020065426826,
0.05427324026823044,
-0.011550561524927616,
0.000890696479473263,
0.02882508561015129,
-0.015941739082336426,
0.010243273340165615,
-0.0157853402197361,
0.039465468376874924,
0.03668704256415367,
-0.027584727853536606,
-0.008537326008081436,
0.02046590857207775,
0.005512017756700516,
-0.05045229196548462,
-0.010947340168058872,
-0.0010524727404117584,
-0.048129599541425705,
0.04863983392715454,
0.0029249032959342003,
0.015702325850725174,
0.014707297086715698,
0.012829577550292015,
-0.03997061774134636,
-0.027795160189270973,
-0.00019902722851838917,
0.021158339455723763,
0.0348699688911438,
0.033648617565631866,
-0.008382580243051052,
-0.005410492420196533,
0.017148897051811218,
-0.023707671090960503,
-0.0015441946452483535,
0.01297932118177414,
-0.014764528721570969,
-0.027623308822512627,
-0.00043431276571936905,
-0.00238797883503139,
0.03521861135959625,
0.003534062299877405,
0.05405338481068611,
0.025186151266098022,
0.03642285615205765,
-0.008886562660336494,
-0.06933055073022842,
-0.003089072648435831,
0.002713144524022937,
-0.006211555562913418,
-0.010816116817295551,
0.003657552180811763,
-0.006450077053159475,
0.025322994217276573,
-0.02504441700875759,
-0.05015421286225319,
-0.03046007826924324,
0.004143108148127794,
-0.005453186575323343,
-0.011981275863945484,
0.011832931078970432,
-0.049648359417915344,
0.0314360074698925,
0.035834066569805145,
0.019721755757927895,
-0.06665131449699402,
-0.0015216105384752154,
-0.049416329711675644,
-0.008863664232194424,
0.004711427725851536,
0.02661025896668434,
0.04454551637172699,
-0.012533105909824371,
-0.007400805596262217,
0.02826852910220623,
0.02797594666481018,
0.0565805584192276,
-0.02551029436290264,
0.0032495525665581226,
-0.0169479139149189,
0.02965140901505947,
0.06509658694267273,
-0.030685054138302803,
0.004378273617476225,
-0.010195504873991013,
-0.037942055612802505,
-0.030152009800076485,
0.011550516821444035,
0.004256047308444977,
0.01828840933740139,
-0.012263655662536621,
-0.013982478529214859,
0.0023611471988260746,
-0.026698466390371323,
0.05074929818511009,
0.011728943325579166,
0.01163597870618105,
0.02241331711411476,
0.09792318195104599,
0.0074054403230547905,
0.013863226398825645,
-0.02008013427257538,
-0.05297498032450676,
0.05080277845263481,
0.023105816915631294,
-0.022159356623888016,
-0.024455133825540543,
-0.0049628703854978085,
-0.011213778518140316,
-0.03567260131239891,
-0.0017213159007951617,
0.039643965661525726,
0.00036417480441741645,
0.014692205004394054,
0.0307221170514822,
0.012099900282919407,
0.02803470939397812,
-0.008825289085507393,
0.001957182539626956,
-0.04242658242583275,
-0.01198187842965126,
0.0010181544348597527,
-0.002334467601031065,
0.03127545118331909,
0.07350022345781326,
-0.021880634129047394,
-0.014652407728135586,
0.01057848334312439,
-0.013925270177423954,
-0.02152945287525654,
-0.01226011011749506,
-0.0444648452103138,
-0.005438884254544973,
0.01777748391032219,
0.0005331544671207666,
-0.00694244122132659,
0.005426839925348759,
-0.023219628259539604,
0.0025491993874311447,
-0.009068304672837257,
0.01416573766618967,
-0.04934150353074074,
-0.03471146896481514,
-0.0002354656026000157,
0.004352995194494724,
0.0006784650031477213,
0.03931402042508125,
0.04924337565898895,
-0.06419862806797028,
0.016595441848039627,
-0.04787702113389969,
-0.013426681980490685,
-0.028522765263915062,
-0.017005741596221924,
0.014735808596014977,
-0.020367955788969994,
0.027402415871620178,
0.04541226476430893,
0.03298189118504524,
0.009434480220079422,
0.029581667855381966,
0.017880314961075783,
-0.030870161950588226,
0.0525929220020771,
-0.00364150432869792,
-0.01290834229439497,
-0.04257989302277565,
0.0026021869853138924,
-0.006353004369884729,
0.01848910190165043,
0.04125717282295227,
-0.006772193592041731,
0.018231431022286415,
-0.0011329347034916282,
0.00443236343562603,
0.011258118785917759,
0.0005163488676771522,
0.02664342150092125,
0.010650881566107273,
-0.015975704416632652,
0.02087485045194626,
0.01208717841655016,
0.03586290776729584,
-0.003510185517370701,
0.038723964244127274,
0.012475783936679363,
-0.015299733728170395,
0.0040695033967494965,
-0.030579425394535065,
-0.05568142980337143,
0.032332807779312134,
-0.01648063026368618,
0.009911506436765194,
-0.00010636571823852137,
0.018121911212801933,
0.021939631551504135,
0.03524389863014221,
0.025886060670018196,
-0.001546491519547999,
0.028835294768214226,
-0.010845039039850235,
0.011080696247518063,
0.035290252417325974,
-0.010685483925044537,
0.04494163393974304,
-0.02228052169084549,
0.034665826708078384,
0.027408959344029427,
-0.01495353877544403,
-0.02943786419928074,
0.030953790992498398,
-0.014837384223937988,
-0.00928595568984747,
0.005865956656634808,
0.06260079145431519,
0.015284518711268902,
-0.06447995454072952,
-0.033743374049663544,
-0.0423431359231472,
-0.1640833616256714,
-0.017932994291186333,
-0.025723133236169815,
0.013169191777706146,
0.003605342237278819,
0.009472329169511795,
-0.03590130805969238,
0.012996437959372997,
-0.05632445216178894,
-0.01569823920726776,
0.007868845015764236,
-0.0526142492890358,
-0.022609779611229897,
0.036602240055799484,
0.02289409562945366,
-0.020786447450518608,
0.0005169233772903681,
0.027161337435245514,
0.02586003951728344,
0.0011187797645106912,
-0.004896767437458038,
-0.033038944005966187,
0.044238824397325516,
0.003950932528823614,
0.002311715856194496,
0.01569591835141182,
0.0065538096241652966,
0.0026145162992179394,
-0.0489896759390831,
-0.01056293398141861,
0.0017539402469992638,
0.015535824000835419,
-0.027118243277072906,
0.05211197957396507,
-0.009488429874181747,
0.03644724190235138,
0.07408667355775833,
-0.032795555889606476,
-0.01612100377678871,
-0.021802440285682678,
0.024060312658548355,
0.043858084827661514,
0.028376683592796326,
0.021514348685741425,
0.006816089618951082,
-0.04674752429127693,
0.011916319839656353,
-0.01257355697453022,
0.023944951593875885,
0.049802422523498535,
0.0014064665883779526,
0.040550485253334045,
-0.02304334007203579,
-0.04118785634636879,
0.0016855067806318402,
-0.025480085983872414,
0.02307586558163166,
0.02187916822731495,
-0.03448944911360741,
-0.015422200784087181,
-0.034770168364048004,
-0.028672244399785995,
0.009385854005813599,
0.02718055434525013,
-0.01620136760175228,
0.017695361748337746,
-0.00815819762647152,
-0.02897024340927601,
0.01879626139998436,
0.037086423486471176,
0.006495288573205471,
-0.019638236612081528,
-0.005419360939413309,
-0.021784253418445587,
0.049490801990032196,
0.045595865696668625,
-0.04774486646056175,
0.014055682346224785,
-0.017751187086105347,
-0.10311182588338852,
0.0013519228668883443,
0.01592433452606201,
-0.0283706896007061,
0.011061201803386211,
-0.021119244396686554,
0.035871073603630066,
0.014644518494606018,
0.037624865770339966,
0.015300409868359566,
0.25702914595603943,
-0.015598072670400143,
0.0023789112456142902,
0.030186861753463745,
0.030423086136579514,
-0.01633637212216854,
0.01460849680006504,
0.042955249547958374,
-0.012122762389481068,
-0.03860844671726227,
-0.0445198230445385,
-0.01982744038105011,
0.030044522136449814,
0.02635139226913452,
-0.03042292594909668,
0.02830377034842968,
-0.047799251973629,
-0.027822639793157578,
0.06670874357223511,
0.005061713978648186,
0.040382269769907,
-0.011759389191865921,
-0.016167636960744858,
0.0028736316598951817,
-0.042672958225011826,
-0.032759539783000946,
0.02325005829334259,
0.048727698624134064,
-0.042957853525877,
-0.011031394824385643,
-0.0024830938782542944,
-0.003257588716223836,
0.05100097879767418,
-0.0008837730856612325,
0.03501758351922035,
0.02447235770523548,
-0.014081267639994621,
0.0350276455283165,
-0.009489898569881916,
0.045099686831235886,
-0.008360978215932846,
-0.04960399866104126,
-0.00741859944537282,
-0.053486116230487823,
-0.05391900986433029,
0.0296830702573061,
-0.015806131064891815,
0.0368867926299572,
-0.020227981731295586,
0.02758081629872322,
0.005984390154480934,
0.03686702623963356,
-0.0006581209599971771,
-0.024754608049988747,
-0.015198007225990295,
0.035073619335889816,
-0.00256916182115674,
0.04089701548218727,
0.00556136155501008,
0.04069874808192253,
0.001780813210643828,
0.025695733726024628,
-0.006512301042675972,
0.004977062344551086,
0.012785791419446468,
-0.03044426627457142,
-0.08136184513568878,
-0.008044268935918808,
0.052485838532447815,
0.06287483125925064,
0.052361685782670975,
0.029143838211894035,
-0.024629773572087288,
-0.0008028592565096915,
0.02224225550889969,
-0.007298939861357212,
-0.01866328902542591,
-0.02111705392599106,
-0.0021170969121158123,
-0.007293829694390297,
-0.034892596304416656,
-0.04776947945356369,
-0.0349876843392849,
0.032514769583940506,
0.020149439573287964,
0.01491600926965475,
-0.03101772628724575,
0.0508287250995636,
-0.04930407926440239,
-0.03758225589990616,
-0.02682110108435154,
-0.009613968431949615,
0.002239085966721177,
-0.02743404358625412,
-0.021575506776571274,
-0.023613067343831062,
0.013757769018411636,
-0.013308248482644558,
-0.04405907168984413,
-0.04164863005280495,
0.002514150459319353,
-0.015058422461152077,
0.008078169077634811,
-0.037238575518131256,
-0.007670204620808363,
-0.011907645501196384,
-0.027629587799310684,
0.0024871723726391792,
-0.0659649521112442,
-0.008507505059242249,
0.007830382324755192,
-0.000016860125469975173,
-0.006985632702708244,
-0.0086833406239748,
0.05101943761110306,
0.0524442195892334,
0.01204670313745737,
0.06905265152454376,
0.03476787358522415,
0.040349893271923065,
0.024157948791980743,
0.006993103306740522,
-0.048885539174079895,
-0.026956573128700256,
0.00944880023598671,
0.024320323020219803,
-0.04757315665483475,
-0.01645497977733612,
0.011163218878209591,
-0.0015702727250754833,
0.031127650290727615,
-0.0262492336332798,
-0.04283873364329338,
-0.009067853912711143,
0.05834450200200081,
0.02670799009501934,
-0.009624640457332134,
-0.0007317150593735278,
-0.052021101117134094,
-0.00004727159102912992,
-0.05088405683636665,
0.02602962777018547,
-0.03401608765125275,
-0.006041011773049831,
-0.014963630586862564,
0.024733606725931168,
-0.055101413279771805,
0.0198749378323555,
-0.04705636203289032,
-0.0029104372952133417,
0.00641579320654273,
0.01780909113585949,
-0.06471578031778336,
0.002755415625870228,
0.027513815090060234,
0.04285041242837906,
-0.017588073387742043,
0.0013330021174624562,
0.03172101825475693,
-0.03282352164387703,
0.008272247388958931,
0.02129906229674816,
0.027988100424408913,
0.004047457594424486,
0.016086099669337273,
0.07025966048240662,
-0.03036496229469776,
0.05059270188212395,
0.012778719887137413,
-0.04516662657260895,
-0.026841595768928528,
-0.04315666854381561,
-0.023969849571585655,
0.0697999894618988,
0.004166844766587019,
0.027679631486535072,
0.0414334312081337,
0.03307174891233444,
0.02415769174695015,
-0.007032016292214394,
0.0234152153134346,
0.006777550093829632,
-0.03570696711540222,
-0.035962048918008804,
-0.0012787774903699756,
-0.005431824363768101,
0.00948368664830923,
-0.022629709914326668,
0.051029302179813385,
-0.06872014701366425,
-0.008182011544704437,
0.0702195093035698,
0.0215374156832695,
-0.02556455321609974,
-0.004271124489605427,
0.007012041285634041,
0.0021245800890028477,
0.054767705500125885,
0.0022364738397300243,
-0.05287247523665428,
-0.025455450639128685,
0.005194270052015781,
0.014965113252401352,
-0.0007616770453751087,
0.03763298690319061,
0.016978751868009567,
-0.009537611156702042,
0.0521581694483757,
-0.04717670753598213,
-0.019253211095929146,
0.02303255908191204,
0.0050995792262256145,
-0.012036217376589775,
0.030620846897363663,
0.00893526989966631,
-0.02865760587155819,
0.014560389332473278,
0.053692009299993515,
0.00822057481855154,
-0.05676252394914627,
0.010032194666564465,
-0.03852127492427826,
0.011921834200620651,
-0.03283098712563515,
-0.03361597657203674,
0.009366581216454506,
-0.0567723773419857,
0.0005190856172703207,
-0.01591310277581215,
0.021555893123149872,
-0.004891128279268742,
-0.07919931411743164,
0.05275464430451393,
-0.07012089341878891,
0.0024530705995857716,
-0.027754565700888634,
0.04864630475640297,
-0.009352386929094791,
0.03216392919421196,
-0.0010189826134592295,
0.04037157818675041,
-0.024100666865706444,
-0.005312358029186726,
0.03817342594265938,
0.004439567215740681,
-0.007234011311084032,
-0.020702363923192024,
-0.02399810403585434,
0.012611211277544498,
0.04685633257031441,
-0.008252152241766453,
0.03519400581717491,
-0.005956777837127447,
-0.018228597939014435,
-0.003274675225839019,
0.007938125170767307,
0.03417230024933815,
-0.04460001736879349,
0.00794646143913269,
-0.04473898932337761,
-0.007922482676804066,
0.017423730343580246,
-0.00022437667939811945,
-0.017996571958065033,
-0.06689579039812088,
-0.05498495325446129,
0.00989294983446598,
-0.02912837825715542,
-0.01547428872436285,
0.003438173560425639,
-0.011236405931413174,
-0.014039312489330769,
0.005697815213352442,
-0.04997759312391281,
-0.013058612123131752,
0.0007880225894041359,
-0.022393526509404182,
-0.0069975838996469975,
0.022002654150128365,
0.012986189685761929,
0.010777631774544716,
-0.019595880061388016,
0.03495809808373451,
0.03151559457182884,
-0.030479561537504196,
0.01140634622424841,
-0.005014130845665932,
-0.021137816831469536,
0.021624453365802765,
-0.0074266972951591015,
-0.012959755957126617,
-0.005974020808935165,
-0.013721365481615067,
0.011068018153309822,
0.014866974204778671,
-0.02448311075568199,
-0.0010262002469971776,
0.047519005835056305,
-0.025943947955965996,
0.011714047752320766,
-0.028781931847333908,
-0.02559015154838562,
-0.04646698012948036,
-0.02748127654194832,
-0.04518294334411621,
0.018431540578603745,
0.011194142512977123,
0.0014797893818467855,
-0.0410519614815712,
-0.010289976373314857,
0.02432946301996708,
-0.05484827980399132,
0.025229593738913536,
-0.03524486720561981,
0.04674481227993965,
-0.00018591643311083317,
0.009282443672418594,
-0.010812620632350445,
-0.013152957893908024,
-0.0030888221226632595,
0.01736949197947979,
-0.006119638215750456,
-0.06710834801197052,
0.007220036815851927,
-0.07178102433681488,
-0.00766974501311779,
0.04290013015270233,
-0.032705157995224,
-0.04567306116223335,
0.04337166249752045,
-0.013615488074719906,
-0.013440164737403393,
0.014515585266053677,
0.005410654004663229,
0.015155240893363953,
0.025045696645975113,
-0.000763922231271863,
-0.007088842336088419,
0.019089803099632263,
-0.04229677468538284,
-0.027706041932106018,
-0.06098921597003937,
0.05900483578443527,
-0.04934769496321678,
0.01254507340490818,
0.005684762727469206,
-0.026909133419394493,
0.0001349016383755952,
0.026380395516753197,
0.02282457984983921,
-0.015863236039876938,
0.01787460409104824,
-0.023375026881694794,
-0.0438288077712059,
0.0032407992985099554,
-0.0066645885817706585,
-0.008104860782623291,
0.03590025380253792,
0.02607858180999756,
-0.02394150383770466,
-0.006579236127436161,
0.03256542608141899,
0.023264747112989426,
0.0019305688329041004,
-0.006342870648950338,
-0.0235015656799078,
-0.012356407940387726,
0.04976864159107208,
0.02589181810617447,
0.026601867750287056,
0.008664676919579506,
-0.03741782158613205,
0.012792453169822693,
-0.000930262147448957,
-0.049653101712465286,
0.0302275437861681,
0.013718358241021633,
0.01046639122068882,
-0.019847074523568153,
-0.054063670337200165,
0.009101789444684982,
-0.0008319840999320149,
-0.010133625939488411,
-0.040351275354623795,
0.02445596270263195,
-0.019093239679932594,
-0.03432032838463783,
0.013921670615673065,
0.013131363317370415,
0.01628662645816803,
0.0152552155777812,
0.03016311302781105,
-0.036985136568546295,
-0.025833912193775177,
-0.14009413123130798,
-0.00028398202266544104,
0.008267189376056194,
-0.03874349966645241,
-0.011384017765522003,
0.004952409770339727,
-0.005156343337148428,
0.016915498301386833,
-0.053132571280002594,
-0.010576950386166573,
0.0017156960675492883,
-0.023931842297315598,
0.02479429356753826,
-0.015155240893363953,
-0.02673974260687828,
-0.010663487948477268,
-0.04550027847290039,
0.010271218605339527,
-0.0742303729057312,
0.026806440204381943,
0.012266880832612514,
-0.006079725921154022,
-0.003987425472587347,
-0.006330144591629505,
0.01672913134098053,
-0.003756271442398429,
-0.004077985882759094,
-0.06464346498250961,
-0.025794003158807755,
-0.040711089968681335,
-0.029145637527108192,
0.012102835811674595,
0.002606423106044531,
0.08304530382156372,
-0.04127362370491028,
0.01947099342942238,
0.019335884600877762,
-0.026805734261870384,
-0.005373417865484953,
0.00032134406501427293,
-0.0165390782058239,
0.04774967208504677,
-0.018570292741060257,
-0.03984377160668373,
0.0008206672500818968,
0.03707057610154152,
-0.0132990013808012,
-0.022048721089959145,
-0.05280127376317978,
-0.030351273715496063,
-0.026617644354701042,
0.02558579109609127,
0.028022944927215576,
0.035747963935136795,
-0.012614598497748375,
-0.02323622815310955,
0.005168391857296228,
-0.023492082953453064,
0.041627053171396255,
0.04415920749306679,
0.027859587222337723,
0.004687673412263393,
-0.04193020239472389,
-0.02512548863887787,
-0.035360947251319885,
-0.007510749157518148,
-0.022387851029634476,
-0.014482409693300724,
-0.008447966538369656,
0.005929352715611458,
-0.012578879483044147,
-0.007520825136452913,
-0.013323069550096989,
-0.05211324244737625,
0.01882517710328102,
-0.036628495901823044,
-0.006465847138315439,
0.01731128990650177,
-0.03542328253388405,
-0.012804142199456692,
-0.030682362616062164,
-0.0042948126792907715,
-0.04806247353553772,
-0.00449609337374568,
0.06292013078927994,
0.05177893862128258,
0.005891189444810152,
-0.023164216428995132,
0.013945896178483963,
-0.022472431883215904,
-0.05228289216756821,
0.009937867522239685,
-0.0036927792243659496,
0.02342754229903221,
-0.046843335032463074,
0.038061004132032394,
0.0028093531727790833,
-0.02715158276259899,
0.0069361100904643536,
0.011466683819890022,
-0.048072513192892075,
0.0009892211528494954,
0.021295582875609398,
-0.021166356280446053,
-0.04490944743156433,
-0.005225334782153368,
0.04998794198036194,
0.0025746263563632965,
0.02587524801492691,
-0.03128567337989807,
-0.01970810443162918,
-0.017214113846421242,
-0.042481955140829086,
0.030842429026961327,
-0.043116044253110886,
0.00431777210906148,
0.01422115322202444,
0.011844485066831112,
0.025829274207353592,
0.020456941798329353,
0.016484104096889496,
0.03459663689136505,
0.03180075064301491,
-0.024015309289097786,
0.008197025395929813,
-0.012079804204404354,
0.06038936600089073,
0.033218275755643845,
0.04318566992878914,
0.0004520625516306609,
0.03942999616265297,
-0.013755396008491516,
0.01930209808051586,
0.045919883996248245,
0.015707088634371758,
0.019309207797050476,
-0.019107641652226448,
0.013522769324481487,
-0.01409660093486309,
-0.005557386204600334,
0.005092170555144548,
-0.002147375838831067,
-0.021251270547509193,
0.02551446482539177,
-0.046132642775774,
-0.009111403487622738,
0.019836798310279846,
0.0031387547496706247,
-0.021039258688688278,
-0.004414306953549385,
-0.023265957832336426,
0.03240729123353958,
-0.009188964031636715,
0.047625601291656494,
0.010624243877828121,
-0.001026234240271151,
0.047406408935785294,
0.021816497668623924,
0.031345345079898834,
0.015907667577266693,
0.01756417565047741,
-0.045439738780260086,
-0.06871237605810165,
-0.04654214158654213,
-0.013148924335837364,
0.017208967357873917,
-0.01495805662125349,
0.02378256805241108,
-0.02720491960644722,
-0.060911040753126144,
-0.0241690780967474,
0.027734072878956795,
-0.024345573037862778,
0.03650495782494545,
0.03702821210026741,
-0.04407587647438049,
0.005765256471931934,
0.0023206265177577734,
0.035264287143945694,
-0.012415244244039059,
0.04246814176440239,
0.042323630303144455,
0.028080303221940994,
-0.011852814815938473,
0.027077972888946533,
0.04196866974234581,
0.014792243018746376,
0.009164176881313324,
-0.014347602613270283,
-0.05616499483585358,
-0.041509345173835754,
-0.017286648973822594,
0.03178049996495247,
-0.01470611710101366,
0.0015780272660776973,
0.03508339822292328,
0.003174650017172098,
-0.006691453512758017,
-0.006200980860739946,
0.023724228143692017,
0.03287394344806671,
-0.041856277734041214,
-0.0389183945953846,
-0.01777699403464794,
-0.011617704294621944,
0.017611736431717873,
-0.024844586849212646,
-0.055836498737335205,
-0.022789450362324715,
0.06339295208454132,
0.006339448504149914,
-0.015084322541952133,
-0.037891846150159836,
0.026870688423514366,
-0.02502218447625637,
0.02598107047379017,
0.023688027635216713,
-0.019158054143190384,
0.02435232885181904,
-0.028480051085352898,
0.029864929616451263,
0.06637000292539597,
-0.026653563603758812,
-0.0016015879809856415,
-0.01258015539497137,
-0.012111770920455456,
-0.006516209803521633,
0.007933021523058414,
0.010446312837302685,
0.03644612804055214,
-0.023397784680128098,
0.015500991605222225,
0.005925692617893219,
0.02407963015139103,
0.0006673012394458055,
-0.03933034464716911,
-0.02891434170305729,
-0.023638300597667694,
-0.006566557567566633,
0.006015823222696781,
0.040403589606285095,
0.023029129952192307,
-0.021523509174585342,
-0.03137555345892906
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:37
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"The funder will be in a position to provide the funds and enter into its commercial transactions with Huntley within three weeks".
554Mr Hilliard's note of that day reads:-
"Funder - 3 weeks time".
A two-stage settlement?
555The next day, 28 July 2004, Mr Hilliard wrote to Mr Zdrilic confirming what Mr Gillard had said to him the day before, and raised the possibility of the ultimate settlement of the transactions occurring in two stages.
556Mr Hilliard said:-
"I am informed by Brian Gillard that the funder will be in a position to provide the funds and enter into its commercial transactions with HTT within 3 weeks. It makes sense that the overall settlement be in two stages with your interests being protected via the Withdrawal of Caveat being held by TressCox until the second stage of settlement takes place. The two stages proposed are:-
1. settlement between you and the other parties prior to the funder coming on board (with the Withdrawal of Caveat being withheld); and
2. settlement with the funder with the Withdrawal of Caveat being handed over conditional upon the funds being provided (not less than $10,000,000) and David Hickie and Michael Ansell resigning as directors of HTT.
During the first stage you will become the alternate director for Robert Renshall. I see no difficulty in you not being a director during the intervening period given that you have not been a director of HTT in the past. By holding a Withdrawal of Caveat your interests are protected."
557In the same letter, Mr Hilliard proposed that amongst the documents to be prepared to affect settlement would be a:-
"Letter by TressCox to HTT undertaking to hand over Withdrawal of Caveat upon the funder making funds available and David Hickie and Michael Ansell resigning as directors of HTT".
558Around that time Mr Hilliard prepared a first draft of that letter. Relevantly the draft letter (which I shall call the "TressCox Caveat Undertaking") read:-
"In consideration for the settlement taking place we hereby undertake to hold an original Withdrawal of Caveat(...)with such Withdrawal of Caveat to be delivered to Mr Brian Gillard(...)at the time of, (or if they do not occur simultaneously) or upon the last to occur of the following events:-
1. The provision of approximately $12,000,000 by the 'new funder' to HTT pursuant to clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement;
2. The resignation of David Hickie and Michael John Ansell and any other director of HTT, other than Robert Michael Renshall; and
3. The appointment by the 'new funder' referred to in clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement, of two or more directors to the board of HTT".
559Items 1, 2 and 3 in the TressCox Caveat Undertaking were the essential elements of what Mr Hilliard described as "Stage 2" of the settlement. This, and subsequent iterations of the TressCox Caveat Undertaking thus contemplated that "Stage 2" might not occur simultaneously with "Stage 1".
One circumstance in which this could occur would be if the parties were ready to implement Stage 1, but not Stage 2 (for example, because funds were unavailable).
560On 2 August 2004, Mr Hilliard sent Mr Gillard a proposed index of the documents to be dealt with at settlement. The index listed documents to be handed over at "Stage 1" and documents to be handed over at "Stage 2".
561Included in the documents to be handed over at Stage 1 were Short Minutes of Order dismissing the 2001 Proceedings.
562Included in the documents to be handed over at Stage 2 were the Withdrawal of Caveat and the TressCox Caveat Undertaking.
563Subsequent iterations of Mr Hilliard's index were, relevantly, to the same effect and show that from early August, Mr Hilliard (and thus Mr Zdrilic) were planning to hand over the Short Minutes of Order as part of Stage 1 of the settlement.
564Mr Hilliard gave oral evidence that:-
|
[
-0.005115852225571871,
0.0010931958677247167,
-0.05119045078754425,
0.026676828041672707,
0.015212364494800568,
-0.03395555540919304,
-0.01252947561442852,
-0.00030013060313649476,
0.014307241886854172,
0.01637091115117073,
0.020621979609131813,
0.04540446028113365,
-0.012668244540691376,
0.015915682539343834,
0.015371756628155708,
-0.01958814635872841,
0.03322475031018257,
-0.05660947784781456,
0.02756514586508274,
-0.009554371237754822,
-0.04210781678557396,
-0.004760104697197676,
0.010545462369918823,
0.01953009143471718,
-0.02757834456861019,
0.009639598429203033,
-0.0033771649468690157,
0.015084204263985157,
0.01843356527388096,
0.07424657046794891,
-0.007558053825050592,
0.005099473986774683,
0.008064649067819118,
0.012233709916472435,
0.01854761689901352,
-0.002156807342544198,
0.03729116916656494,
-0.02197917364537716,
-0.04056709632277489,
0.01807504892349243,
-0.03663726523518562,
0.0002862931869458407,
0.024050019681453705,
-0.006835326086729765,
0.040254686027765274,
-0.016978906467556953,
-0.0195419080555439,
-0.03133624419569969,
-0.005847925320267677,
0.0032261633314192295,
-0.054475195705890656,
-0.024652093648910522,
0.012939432635903358,
-0.014014896005392075,
0.004668108653277159,
0.02043469250202179,
-0.03321973979473114,
-0.0070761991664767265,
-0.055668849498033524,
-0.006601007655262947,
-0.007934676483273506,
0.013087867759168148,
-0.08052290230989456,
0.012917280197143555,
0.0007595311035402119,
0.06636475771665573,
0.014163925312459469,
-0.01835888996720314,
-0.00364650203846395,
-0.005724508780986071,
-0.040292683988809586,
-0.0021390810143202543,
-0.0038078748621046543,
-0.0061645167879760265,
-0.09013102948665619,
-0.0012102978071197867,
0.032745610922575,
-0.004154652822762728,
0.039160557091236115,
0.015654586255550385,
0.02451878972351551,
-0.029197456315159798,
-0.021416446194052696,
0.047140367329120636,
-0.01589253544807434,
0.03671957179903984,
0.03345569968223572,
0.01961531676352024,
0.039754100143909454,
-0.002808107528835535,
0.014300490729510784,
0.007675367407500744,
0.003983118571341038,
-0.05413634702563286,
0.0037896116264164448,
-0.02371109649538994,
-0.05738772451877594,
0.03130870684981346,
0.011623854748904705,
0.016240298748016357,
-0.0032126009464263916,
0.04127582907676697,
-0.01600782200694084,
0.009350883774459362,
0.03543077036738396,
0.06393375992774963,
0.040194474160671234,
0.023387635126709938,
0.014439437538385391,
-0.018843889236450195,
0.02024664171040058,
-0.02121487818658352,
0.007569955661892891,
0.002797724213451147,
-0.013980348594486713,
-0.01588316448032856,
0.023744577541947365,
0.007712012622505426,
0.03267977014183998,
0.026759140193462372,
0.04456586763262749,
0.004640364553779364,
0.053490687161684036,
-0.026554938405752182,
-0.01795416884124279,
-0.002774310065433383,
0.030208123847842216,
-0.004640690982341766,
0.03052065335214138,
-0.005064692348241806,
-0.002146600279957056,
0.038947269320487976,
-0.002425247570499778,
-0.028798744082450867,
-0.04231231287121773,
0.010745356790721416,
-0.004793445114046335,
-0.0011142316507175565,
0.037451621145009995,
-0.04069774970412254,
0.06507142633199692,
0.029194539412856102,
-0.02848700061440468,
-0.04746352508664131,
0.030064338818192482,
-0.06989068537950516,
0.00819683913141489,
0.018266282975673676,
0.023727666586637497,
0.056111812591552734,
0.002154710702598095,
0.014729565940797329,
-0.0003237267956137657,
0.023868560791015625,
0.03369290381669998,
-0.04984062910079956,
-0.007195053156465292,
-0.044939782470464706,
0.007163467817008495,
0.06729236245155334,
-0.0068175033666193485,
0.014582641422748566,
-0.009988673031330109,
-0.01750965043902397,
0.002588973380625248,
-0.0030496905092149973,
-0.0316404327750206,
0.0281008780002594,
0.005633613094687462,
-0.014001562260091305,
0.010046343319118023,
-0.009110918268561363,
0.016359888017177582,
-0.009030808694660664,
0.007242186926305294,
0.0180978961288929,
0.09102378785610199,
0.0025571146979928017,
0.030572259798645973,
-0.013091354630887508,
-0.05855158343911171,
0.06247857213020325,
-0.02433847263455391,
-0.0393301397562027,
-0.028933299705386162,
0.02648097276687622,
-0.020564397796988487,
-0.026945853605866432,
0.005875312257558107,
0.01690654084086418,
-0.009747878648340702,
0.02018650993704796,
0.03593285754323006,
0.022640591487288475,
0.024701004847884178,
0.01383071020245552,
0.020651735365390778,
-0.027101999148726463,
-0.013224966824054718,
-0.018757272511720657,
-0.03699558973312378,
0.03982444107532501,
0.06433724611997604,
0.0024374336935579777,
-0.024245932698249817,
0.0018789757741615176,
-0.027649275958538055,
-0.022373013198375702,
0.011193951591849327,
-0.050122298300266266,
-0.01294681802392006,
-0.00007072512380545959,
-0.023969652131199837,
-0.0004790060920640826,
0.00764774065464735,
0.0007742237066850066,
0.0009716834756545722,
0.013266520574688911,
-0.03571249544620514,
-0.0450562909245491,
-0.006574282888323069,
0.01915387436747551,
0.021413464099168777,
-0.0431196466088295,
0.01923578605055809,
0.03880755975842476,
-0.05175634101033211,
0.01610659994184971,
-0.012297941371798515,
-0.010312649421393871,
-0.013520956039428711,
-0.017467482015490532,
-0.0014796272153034806,
0.005976625718176365,
0.02872331626713276,
0.04019160941243172,
-0.0031000070739537477,
0.010836882516741753,
0.028211645781993866,
0.0235759187489748,
-0.024316871538758278,
0.02233300544321537,
0.016295958310365677,
-0.034312739968299866,
-0.014476718381047249,
-0.013122521340847015,
-0.010395468212664127,
0.011818943545222282,
0.017101211473345757,
-0.02355937659740448,
-0.022755319252610207,
0.01907041110098362,
-0.0033676184248179197,
-0.0006791570922359824,
0.004055466502904892,
0.021938739344477654,
0.006088591646403074,
-0.011528979986906052,
0.02082686498761177,
0.022397613152861595,
0.026994038373231888,
0.02949550189077854,
0.016377341002225876,
0.020582005381584167,
-0.013002878986299038,
0.0071067833341658115,
-0.038439374417066574,
-0.05427934601902962,
0.03614606335759163,
0.029577717185020447,
-0.013035550713539124,
0.019763389602303505,
0.012671377509832382,
0.029702192172408104,
0.037069596350193024,
0.03202159330248833,
0.011347014456987381,
0.024902626872062683,
0.02878458797931671,
0.01984565518796444,
-0.024425415322184563,
0.008729659952223301,
0.03134594112634659,
0.02053951285779476,
0.04348202422261238,
0.05083222687244415,
-0.037515368312597275,
-0.029867926612496376,
0.030430220067501068,
-0.015668008476495743,
-0.01007163431495428,
0.005829378962516785,
0.06165046989917755,
0.00818057730793953,
-0.050030454993247986,
-0.02492534928023815,
-0.017057526856660843,
-0.14294397830963135,
0.009587625041604042,
-0.013535493053495884,
0.010820599272847176,
0.007573331706225872,
0.016576619818806648,
-0.012500219978392124,
0.0035679058637470007,
-0.03518752008676529,
0.019596116617321968,
0.051996152848005295,
-0.05077698454260826,
-0.0176235344260931,
0.03561101481318474,
0.025052353739738464,
-0.008240980096161366,
0.004150766413658857,
0.014224936254322529,
0.024733813479542732,
-0.038190554827451706,
-0.020368918776512146,
-0.07973235845565796,
0.06323489546775818,
-0.005486187059432268,
0.011491114273667336,
-0.005683936178684235,
0.027025120332837105,
0.03344396874308586,
-0.04958268627524376,
-0.01419635396450758,
-0.03493284434080124,
-0.01658075489103794,
-0.00982939824461937,
0.04724670574069023,
-0.006080891005694866,
0.041566308587789536,
0.06529249250888824,
-0.027311405166983604,
0.023751933127641678,
-0.04533302038908005,
0.03973350301384926,
0.022942520678043365,
0.007692237850278616,
-0.007178443018347025,
0.014812798239290714,
-0.0627165287733078,
0.020590031519532204,
0.014265605248510838,
-0.030002033337950706,
0.0347258597612381,
-0.015108749270439148,
0.0321158841252327,
-0.028112435713410378,
-0.0446564257144928,
-0.01894250139594078,
-0.03893982619047165,
0.03939368203282356,
0.02858302928507328,
-0.05398273840546608,
-0.007264409679919481,
-0.010000609792768955,
-0.05515033379197121,
-0.0023236700799316168,
0.0018983883783221245,
-0.015967929735779762,
-0.0059243012219667435,
-0.013346973806619644,
-0.04221859946846962,
0.01895792968571186,
0.024166887626051903,
0.024294311180710793,
-0.046597469598054886,
0.014079618267714977,
-0.023059410974383354,
0.04396972432732582,
0.0241707731038332,
-0.0568472258746624,
0.002501747803762555,
-0.035562992095947266,
-0.13026395440101624,
0.0006068842485547066,
0.028289977461099625,
-0.0378447100520134,
0.010313975624740124,
-0.0036020551342517138,
0.02943716011941433,
-0.016850901767611504,
0.04087081551551819,
0.024543752893805504,
0.2435367852449417,
0.011225084774196148,
0.0019603397231549025,
0.07109377533197403,
0.061986226588487625,
-0.03454716503620148,
0.030743299052119255,
0.031076380982995033,
-0.0068882605992257595,
-0.04095784202218056,
-0.010878169909119606,
-0.025193125009536743,
0.038155291229486465,
0.02021758072078228,
-0.006080664228647947,
0.06642698496580124,
-0.04922876134514809,
-0.0277996975928545,
0.06194615364074707,
0.00012677723134402186,
0.0671241506934166,
-0.04029553011059761,
0.0014934638747945428,
0.015130603685975075,
-0.06173087656497955,
-0.041065771132707596,
0.005993679631501436,
0.056859031319618225,
-0.036267321556806564,
-0.031035207211971283,
-0.017338549718260765,
0.01739523932337761,
0.024676041677594185,
0.01410300750285387,
-0.008000276051461697,
0.01851069927215576,
0.00160309171769768,
-0.006935334298759699,
-0.011335182934999466,
0.05321728065609932,
-0.007003882434219122,
-0.04580743610858917,
0.025253405794501305,
-0.0650404542684555,
-0.04441877454519272,
0.0010971084702759981,
-0.008951118215918541,
0.04201902449131012,
-0.02535920962691307,
-0.021585864946246147,
-0.004552233964204788,
0.002931352239102125,
-0.008236773312091827,
-0.011882915161550045,
-0.004856606479734182,
0.010903115384280682,
-0.011435383930802345,
0.024852894246578217,
-0.020022600889205933,
0.036074064671993256,
-0.020221196115016937,
0.009825997054576874,
-0.037977755069732666,
0.0037862779572606087,
0.01663736253976822,
-0.02294773980975151,
-0.057948265224695206,
0.011329268105328083,
0.04154250770807266,
0.061241235584020615,
0.0028327745385468006,
0.015366648323833942,
-0.009541073814034462,
-0.012123535387217999,
0.02782505564391613,
-0.022524505853652954,
-0.04361816123127937,
-0.01576208509504795,
-0.021340621635317802,
0.012474815361201763,
-0.023245520889759064,
-0.04403814300894737,
-0.020793912932276726,
0.011564124375581741,
0.04825298488140106,
0.007727733347564936,
-0.04355867579579353,
0.07629939913749695,
-0.03096020594239235,
-0.0340864323079586,
-0.013089638203382492,
-0.011683210730552673,
0.019961221143603325,
-0.030144697055220604,
-0.04489218071103096,
-0.04139968380331993,
0.02585386298596859,
-0.012445388361811638,
-0.030731990933418274,
-0.013143532909452915,
-0.019383173435926437,
0.001375354710035026,
0.009198776446282864,
-0.04409010708332062,
0.01399241667240858,
-0.03348168730735779,
-0.005856655538082123,
-0.006305808201432228,
-0.042936522513628006,
-0.03215290606021881,
-0.03929036110639572,
0.005431083030998707,
-0.025460127741098404,
-0.002387179294601083,
0.03652733564376831,
0.08611960709095001,
0.014899074099957943,
0.02004200592637062,
0.05521991848945618,
0.029616987332701683,
0.012782308273017406,
0.01587623357772827,
-0.059627752751111984,
0.0059479111805558205,
0.01294156163930893,
-0.022746186703443527,
-0.013940264470875263,
-0.017637772485613823,
0.030179882422089577,
-0.01078227162361145,
-0.02182677574455738,
-0.04229374974966049,
-0.029320577159523964,
0.0318983793258667,
0.022222314029932022,
0.02699037827551365,
0.01920902542769909,
-0.01918092928826809,
-0.05365122854709625,
0.007248832378536463,
-0.0416509248316288,
0.012611019425094128,
-0.052192382514476776,
-0.016518574208021164,
-0.007356178481131792,
-0.00221804017201066,
-0.0325809083878994,
0.03843487426638603,
-0.039196453988552094,
-0.0027244221419095993,
-0.012221211567521095,
0.030444834381341934,
-0.04413459822535515,
-0.009804286062717438,
0.021900640800595284,
-0.009247390553355217,
-0.012244712561368942,
-0.01593071222305298,
-0.011435634456574917,
-0.04177440330386162,
-0.008280296809971333,
0.005190782714635134,
0.009033973328769207,
-0.002581449458375573,
0.038752004504203796,
0.0578291192650795,
-0.021525677293539047,
0.05775052681565285,
0.05678200721740723,
-0.03287633880972862,
-0.007772720418870449,
-0.02964227832853794,
-0.03018108196556568,
0.06910303980112076,
-0.005821625702083111,
0.007254843600094318,
0.003291455563157797,
0.04422030970454216,
0.02925056219100952,
-0.03017243556678295,
0.045886579900979996,
0.014665534719824791,
-0.043977610766887665,
0.0019010261166840792,
0.0030342889949679375,
0.03434300050139427,
-0.003225441090762615,
-0.01081004273146391,
0.019884450361132622,
-0.04961831867694855,
-0.012060806155204773,
0.07832391560077667,
0.01272997073829174,
-0.01867981255054474,
-0.021718183532357216,
0.0023953181225806475,
0.006235355976969004,
0.04219147562980652,
0.02529049851000309,
-0.027107464149594307,
-0.032058022916316986,
-0.0016736859688535333,
0.02498430386185646,
-0.004318713676184416,
0.021779002621769905,
0.017443286255002022,
0.009918398223817348,
0.031079623848199844,
-0.051812008023262024,
0.0006923351320438087,
0.02056141011416912,
0.014569203369319439,
-0.05671902745962143,
0.03390054404735565,
0.005311568733304739,
-0.05010272562503815,
0.033353909850120544,
0.03864660486578941,
-0.003141209250316024,
-0.08164091408252716,
0.00682550435885787,
-0.026950927451252937,
-0.009295342490077019,
-0.03160819783806801,
-0.030412761494517326,
-0.008186078630387783,
-0.07127734273672104,
0.025783924385905266,
-0.02919176034629345,
0.021094022318720818,
0.0019075663294643164,
-0.05276744067668915,
0.027279512956738472,
-0.04443351924419403,
0.0353829488158226,
0.007714663632214069,
0.04870591685175896,
0.005443733651190996,
0.05814019590616226,
-0.023168453946709633,
0.035287849605083466,
0.002612847136333585,
0.014307931996881962,
0.048265814781188965,
0.006322597153484821,
-0.02171485312283039,
0.008222511038184166,
-0.025880100205540657,
0.027541780844330788,
0.05397273600101471,
0.015032176859676838,
0.01994987577199936,
-0.0029917636420577765,
-0.01307832170277834,
0.02573109045624733,
-0.018373310565948486,
0.0156831294298172,
-0.0192096009850502,
-0.028527358546853065,
-0.04780947044491768,
-0.0031623635441064835,
0.010205441154539585,
0.001620871713384986,
-0.019947636872529984,
-0.03559653088450432,
-0.04925261810421944,
0.01263473555445671,
-0.016777530312538147,
-0.041822873055934906,
0.013967481441795826,
0.0031607779674232006,
-0.019393980503082275,
0.024239687249064445,
-0.04299506917595863,
-0.015238920226693153,
0.008020652458071709,
-0.024076439440250397,
-0.010860759764909744,
0.015681317076086998,
-0.03242383897304535,
-0.013379685580730438,
0.012337408028542995,
0.033878929913043976,
0.010693910531699657,
-0.04630466550588608,
-0.007109746336936951,
-0.027706269174814224,
0.026578528806567192,
-0.03386083245277405,
-0.030962860211730003,
0.0272597037255764,
-0.00043072583503089845,
-0.014018312096595764,
0.0410771518945694,
-0.003460266627371311,
-0.0457940511405468,
0.019969573244452477,
0.004802986513823271,
-0.03793417662382126,
0.016077419742941856,
-0.03891819342970848,
-0.006225875113159418,
-0.00591451907530427,
-0.01620805263519287,
-0.002813400700688362,
0.017540138214826584,
-0.004873227793723345,
-0.012799321673810482,
-0.0278994869440794,
0.008360975421965122,
-0.00648014061152935,
-0.0788474753499031,
0.002763771452009678,
-0.005010909866541624,
0.04401078075170517,
0.011668057180941105,
-0.016826875507831573,
0.001107900869101286,
-0.03453132137656212,
0.005874024238437414,
0.006306735333055258,
-0.02801435999572277,
-0.052289534360170364,
-0.006175052374601364,
-0.054058682173490524,
0.013012228533625603,
0.030545871704816818,
-0.0365888848900795,
-0.05103854089975357,
0.018424291163682938,
-0.03212116286158562,
-0.002125427359715104,
0.014936556108295918,
0.0006023726309649646,
0.011442689225077629,
0.003232658375054598,
0.04794634133577347,
-0.004997811280190945,
0.03482595086097717,
-0.04605480656027794,
-0.014360994100570679,
-0.06282027065753937,
0.0459081307053566,
-0.0061129005625844,
0.019860755652189255,
0.0045496029779314995,
-0.011603889055550098,
0.0010182129917666316,
0.00991151388734579,
0.01076878234744072,
-0.010587388649582863,
0.021394243463873863,
-0.028887761756777763,
-0.011612205766141415,
0.024530066177248955,
-0.015548218972980976,
-0.012765810824930668,
0.05162246897816658,
0.045671816915273666,
-0.0356777086853981,
-0.00155647995416075,
0.002546794479712844,
-0.004885246977210045,
-0.022155387327075005,
-0.00045156004489399493,
-0.006493902299553156,
-0.002739492105320096,
0.018311163410544395,
0.020199593156576157,
0.012491729110479355,
-0.005723750684410334,
-0.05268579348921776,
-0.020960072055459023,
-0.010401779785752296,
-0.04220690578222275,
0.02881832793354988,
0.021678868681192398,
-0.0008213468827307224,
0.02171393856406212,
-0.060064684599637985,
-0.019170964136719704,
-0.009682212956249714,
-0.014293606393039227,
-0.03606127202510834,
0.01583629474043846,
-0.0054354737512767315,
-0.015088707208633423,
0.04511488601565361,
0.014158932492136955,
-0.0031425354536622763,
0.014393174089491367,
0.028035523369908333,
-0.032549820840358734,
-0.036056168377399445,
-0.15174350142478943,
0.007480261847376823,
0.0031657028011977673,
-0.020416496321558952,
-0.029533574357628822,
0.003173475619405508,
-0.037118300795555115,
0.009131678380072117,
-0.03350153565406799,
0.015107862651348114,
-0.01040127407759428,
-0.010302594862878323,
-0.039761923253536224,
-0.012336576357483864,
-0.011789670214056969,
0.010009143501520157,
-0.042610399425029755,
0.0032554869540035725,
-0.05216629058122635,
0.011316504329442978,
0.04577889293432236,
0.012175051495432854,
-0.003075492102652788,
-0.005358153488487005,
0.019342226907610893,
0.00043520706822164357,
0.023021211847662926,
-0.05372329428792,
-0.024402648210525513,
-0.03781997039914131,
-0.046208806335926056,
-0.045936260372400284,
-0.011362246237695217,
0.07725747674703598,
-0.01545303501188755,
0.007236700039356947,
0.011574368923902512,
-0.01996580883860588,
-0.02946820855140686,
-0.006593507714569569,
-0.0022346386685967445,
0.03434605896472931,
0.008836835622787476,
-0.037484310567379,
-0.0065610394813120365,
0.0015283540124073625,
-0.026511384174227715,
-0.005970202386379242,
-0.05194198712706566,
-0.05565887689590454,
-0.028519123792648315,
0.022153815254569054,
0.011380205862224102,
0.014326263219118118,
-0.002029437804594636,
-0.004393274430185556,
0.016902104020118713,
-0.02961013838648796,
0.043264564126729965,
0.0449775792658329,
0.03849043697118759,
0.017602205276489258,
-0.030848676338791847,
-0.0015381661942228675,
-0.024131804704666138,
-0.0005031893379054964,
-0.005269484594464302,
0.03503900766372681,
0.0016297416295856237,
0.05455750599503517,
-0.02055940590798855,
-0.02525963820517063,
-0.03546454384922981,
-0.046304959803819656,
0.01388002373278141,
-0.05861446633934975,
-0.010450918227434158,
0.01456778310239315,
-0.029383722692728043,
-0.024055639281868935,
-0.031843151897192,
-0.003744185669347644,
-0.0556911937892437,
0.007784984540194273,
0.08338458091020584,
0.04952359199523926,
-0.021364137530326843,
-0.02663557045161724,
-0.006355402059853077,
-0.008960298262536526,
-0.027045438066124916,
-0.01205506082624197,
0.02639276720583439,
0.01657281070947647,
-0.06035575643181801,
0.025689061731100082,
0.0018547213403508067,
-0.012199967168271542,
-0.013967929407954216,
-0.00008855101623339579,
-0.04356319084763527,
-0.022709550336003304,
-0.008731001988053322,
-0.0006391570786945522,
-0.024474451318383217,
0.023612646386027336,
0.05691774562001228,
-0.009894524700939655,
0.010011514648795128,
-0.04596155509352684,
0.016700129956007004,
-0.015442279167473316,
-0.015838462859392166,
0.026980647817254066,
-0.024299828335642815,
0.007932559587061405,
0.010943867266178131,
0.015566198155283928,
0.004343530163168907,
0.0020353817380964756,
0.009224449284374714,
0.0012436918914318085,
-0.005024789832532406,
-0.03293211758136749,
0.021757876500487328,
0.0018766919383779168,
0.027964603155851364,
0.028886226937174797,
0.07545845210552216,
-0.0260801799595356,
0.037327997386455536,
0.017247775569558144,
-0.003182727610692382,
0.029831847175955772,
0.03197510913014412,
-0.02366137132048607,
-0.03302588686347008,
0.017804432660341263,
-0.06538370996713638,
-0.014609015546739101,
0.0017807866679504514,
0.013262252323329449,
0.011347899213433266,
0.008027133531868458,
-0.03926912695169449,
-0.03409093990921974,
0.017438821494579315,
-0.004648040980100632,
-0.003283182391896844,
-0.0007158369990065694,
-0.03212689980864525,
0.025133207440376282,
0.009757433086633682,
0.05137220397591591,
0.02303655631840229,
-0.014455292373895645,
0.040509093552827835,
0.023971542716026306,
-0.005238831043243408,
0.049625664949417114,
-0.013409360311925411,
-0.027727533131837845,
-0.04855573922395706,
-0.036335960030555725,
-0.023712599650025368,
0.01141723059117794,
-0.029791822656989098,
0.023841973394155502,
-0.005799794103950262,
-0.06769558042287827,
-0.008144872263073921,
0.031996950507164,
-0.009413985535502434,
0.028431275859475136,
0.03547137230634689,
-0.024543067440390587,
-0.01322873868048191,
-0.007922276854515076,
0.05673491954803467,
-0.01101658958941698,
0.06248539686203003,
0.01992262527346611,
0.010205186903476715,
0.015500039793550968,
0.023741766810417175,
0.03268682211637497,
0.01238878071308136,
0.0571865551173687,
-0.019285842776298523,
-0.02402339316904545,
0.023640895262360573,
0.0012356950901448727,
0.0353090763092041,
0.0029701755847781897,
0.028468886390328407,
-0.014571052975952625,
0.007089063059538603,
-0.0037595294415950775,
0.004745139740407467,
0.026376938447356224,
0.022222157567739487,
-0.06683123856782913,
-0.03482924401760101,
0.008500004187226295,
-0.030296221375465393,
0.036067813634872437,
0.0027139107696712017,
-0.07360467314720154,
-0.03241383284330368,
0.021628836169838905,
-0.016268616542220116,
-0.008649406023323536,
-0.01593076065182686,
0.018108753487467766,
0.01817896217107773,
0.02950163371860981,
0.027669178321957588,
0.011942331679165363,
0.044643789529800415,
-0.03853117302060127,
0.04478372260928154,
0.04966307803988457,
-0.03176870197057724,
-0.008430873043835163,
-0.013323239982128143,
-0.012943779118359089,
-0.008938140235841274,
-0.011957320384681225,
-0.028491830453276634,
0.02692617103457451,
-0.02169140800833702,
0.02201594039797783,
0.0027001637499779463,
0.033014241605997086,
0.028348911553621292,
-0.02275165729224682,
-0.0072791120037436485,
-0.02357608638703823,
-0.05022282898426056,
0.029273662716150284,
0.04583703726530075,
-0.009537327103316784,
-0.019831327721476555,
-0.03285938873887062
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:39
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
"I saw it as a short term funding proposal which at that time, together with the 6.8, gave us a majority of the debt funding we required to fulfil part of the IPC Heads of Agreement. It wasn't perfect, otherwise we would have made it 5.2 and then it would have been $12 million. But that's by the by."
585The "6.8" to which Mr Renshall referred was the DTC loan of $6.8 million. Mr Renshall's point was that if the "short term funding proposal" represented by the proposed advance from Sydney Finance was $5.
2 million (rather than $4.5 million) then the total of "short term" funds advanced would be $6.8 million plus $5.2 million = $12 million - the figure referred to in clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement.
586I accept that this evidence reflected Mr Renshall's state of mind.
The "expensive loans" fall due
587On 12 August 2004 the Goncalves debt ($175,000) fell due. Interest continued to accrue on that loan at 60 per cent per annum.
588On 14 August 2004 the Frenkail loan ($577,000) fell due. Interest continued to accrue on that loan at the rate of 52 per cent per annum.
Settlement date selected
589At some stage, Friday 27 August 2004 was selected as the date upon which the transactions referred to in the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement would be settled.
590The events which occurred on the days leading up to 27 August 2004, namely 24, 25 and 26 August 2004, are of critical significance in this case and require careful consideration.
24 August 2004 - Fourteenth Representation
591The pleaded Fourteenth Representation is that the new funder would advance $4.5 million to HTT on the settlement of the matters set out in the Heads of Agreement.
592This representation is alleged to have been made orally on 24 August 2004 by Mr Gillard to Mr Hilliard.
593According to Mr Hilliard, Mr Gillard said:-
"The new funder will be providing a sum of approximately $4.5 million on settlement".
594Mr Hilliard's note of the statement reads:-
"DRH to write to BG re: $4.5m & borrowings of $12m".
595In cross-examination Mr Hilliard said:-
"I believed I was being told that we don't have $12m for the settlement, we only have $4.5".
596Mr Gillard said:-
"I do recall clearly that I said in words generally to the effect 'the funder will be providing about $4.5 million' and I recall that prompted him to say in words generally to the effect 'I thought you were getting $12 million.
DTC lent $6.8 million - how does $4.5 million fit in?' I said in words to effect 'I do not know - I will find out' and I then wrote the words set out in Item 1 of my file note".
597Mr Gillard's file note reads:-
"Conference Derek.
DTC No 1 P/L lent $6.8 mill. How does $4.5 mill fit in?"
598The $4.5 million to which Mr Gillard referred was, evidently, the amount of the contemplated advance from Sydney Finance.
599This conversation between Mr Gillard and Mr Hilliard appears to be the first occasion on which Mr Hilliard, and thus Mr Zdrilic, was aware that $4.5 million (rather than the $12 million referred to in clause 4.7 of the 13 May 2004 Heads of Agreement) would be provided on settlement.
600Mr Gillard's response to Mr Hilliard's question as to how the $4.5 million "fitted in" must have made clear to him that Mr Gillard had limited knowledge about the matter.
601Mr Hilliard followed the matter up in a letter he wrote to Mr Gillard the next day, 25 August 2004, in which he said:-
"During(...)discussions Mr Gillard indicated that the 'new funder' would be providing a sum of approximately $4.5 million on settlement. Mr Sam Zdrilic, on his own behalf, and on behalf of Sentel Pty Limited is concerned that this is not the amount contemplated by clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement".
602In that letter Mr Hilliard also asked the following questions (to which I shall return below):-
1. "What amount will the new funder provide on settlement? What is the break-up between loan and equity?
2. How will the monies provided by the new funder on settlement be applied? Please provide a detailed list of payees and amounts;
|
[
-0.026998033747076988,
0.03457622975111008,
-0.00031618642969988286,
0.007138747256249189,
-0.007691192906349897,
-0.029996152967214584,
0.01597721129655838,
-0.0028395236004143953,
-0.0056503755040466785,
0.030715474858880043,
-0.0036957936827093363,
0.01879369467496872,
-0.025880226865410805,
0.016085762530565262,
-0.005067719612270594,
-0.054211895912885666,
0.026147078722715378,
-0.04459129646420479,
0.0313604474067688,
-0.03708764165639877,
0.021947616711258888,
-0.008980079554021358,
0.00609698286280036,
0.039556074887514114,
0.003129485761746764,
0.007990682497620583,
-0.05404425412416458,
0.0277851615101099,
0.030508698895573616,
0.06087230145931244,
0.013582033105194569,
-0.012381457723677158,
0.0528147853910923,
-0.0005611158558167517,
-0.0069522918201982975,
-0.008123553358018398,
0.006602415349334478,
-0.017154108732938766,
-0.03312257304787636,
0.010014732368290424,
0.01975264586508274,
0.018377263098955154,
0.03290073573589325,
0.03401688486337662,
0.05370837822556496,
-0.04080645740032196,
-0.012712165713310242,
-0.006726101506501436,
0.01234095823019743,
0.02183600701391697,
-0.02913125976920128,
-0.06887125223875046,
0.05229635164141655,
0.0016292969230562449,
-0.024377722293138504,
-0.014237877912819386,
-0.006884428672492504,
-0.014512834139168262,
-0.053829826414585114,
-0.0055725667625665665,
0.011079618707299232,
0.017684461548924446,
-0.05325334146618843,
-0.020726943388581276,
0.01663852110505104,
0.11682251840829849,
0.01363526750355959,
-0.004046877846121788,
-0.0013986843405291438,
-0.019249873235821724,
-0.03542907536029816,
-0.006378769874572754,
0.018453411757946014,
-0.016226543113589287,
-0.10001203417778015,
-0.004962093196809292,
0.0371425524353981,
0.009830738417804241,
0.041025687009096146,
-0.0001728950737742707,
0.0452137216925621,
-0.012529220432043076,
-0.03895091637969017,
0.0008360809879377484,
-0.0382114052772522,
-0.0010696458630263805,
-0.020151980221271515,
0.04048978164792061,
0.02737196907401085,
-0.014416713267564774,
-0.013657866045832634,
0.005777787417173386,
0.007918541319668293,
-0.059161003679037094,
0.00854018609970808,
0.030145853757858276,
-0.05426601693034172,
0.06025123968720436,
0.000589416129514575,
-0.010087830945849419,
-0.004079306963831186,
0.015601007267832756,
-0.01195871364325285,
-0.019754694774746895,
0.03107292205095291,
0.016715306788682938,
0.04186280444264412,
0.041016723960638046,
-0.0005620045121759176,
-0.00476357014849782,
-0.0003909046354237944,
-0.009268886409699917,
-0.004686060361564159,
0.03027096763253212,
0.009883041493594646,
-0.013269273564219475,
0.008446676656603813,
0.009533287025988102,
0.06908801943063736,
-0.010800635442137718,
0.04008365049958229,
-0.03309205174446106,
0.023071881383657455,
-0.0015741399256512523,
-0.04432367533445358,
0.010701371356844902,
-0.024201838299632072,
0.021834740415215492,
0.0140013936907053,
0.03597305342555046,
-0.033503685146570206,
0.03769912198185921,
-0.018265407532453537,
-0.03642408549785614,
-0.03191247582435608,
0.01288733072578907,
0.007299854885786772,
-0.011141430586576462,
0.01751558855175972,
-0.05835973098874092,
0.04047635197639465,
0.010688371025025845,
-0.003929196856915951,
-0.047600798308849335,
0.017353270202875137,
-0.02334313653409481,
0.025434402748942375,
0.014110995456576347,
-0.007243429310619831,
0.032414428889751434,
0.02608833648264408,
0.0005621834425255656,
0.026160938665270805,
-0.006354772485792637,
0.030372681096196175,
-0.04701761156320572,
0.003743723500519991,
-0.022157637402415276,
0.004759530536830425,
0.04628784582018852,
-0.05450547859072685,
0.01043642032891512,
-0.018530212342739105,
-0.059586599469184875,
-0.022413136437535286,
0.011335557326674461,
0.017316460609436035,
0.02054310031235218,
-0.019351724535226822,
-0.01364881731569767,
-0.014445080421864986,
-0.049244146794080734,
0.07343979924917221,
0.028110401704907417,
0.019766543060541153,
0.01790129393339157,
0.06855574995279312,
0.012829257175326347,
0.04437203332781792,
-0.04106888175010681,
-0.034556224942207336,
0.03599891811609268,
0.015122245997190475,
-0.03493901342153549,
-0.0351804718375206,
0.019080858677625656,
-0.0013942908262833953,
-0.03404281288385391,
0.0009974805871024728,
-0.005195746198296547,
-0.00700741121545434,
0.011159789748489857,
0.03488419950008392,
0.032194774597883224,
0.00442521832883358,
-0.027130836620926857,
0.015548545867204666,
-0.07340048998594284,
0.004342705011367798,
-0.025247249752283096,
-0.030108559876680374,
0.02340792492032051,
0.046377599239349365,
-0.03176228329539299,
-0.027427442371845245,
-0.004544166848063469,
-0.03597693517804146,
-0.008637000806629658,
0.005060188937932253,
-0.03934318199753761,
-0.02137025259435177,
-0.00009758300438988954,
0.0002447612350806594,
0.0007687957840971649,
0.005823534447699785,
-0.009196010418236256,
0.03086584061384201,
-0.0023544274736195803,
0.0015581379411742091,
-0.0564262792468071,
-0.01996242254972458,
0.006267466116696596,
-0.00816781260073185,
0.03999146446585655,
0.02676095813512802,
0.05850872024893761,
-0.07223081588745117,
0.003621085314080119,
-0.019401095807552338,
-0.031044702976942062,
-0.012861787341535091,
-0.015572542324662209,
0.012359810061752796,
0.009742681868374348,
0.020964035764336586,
0.043804582208395004,
0.028795914724469185,
0.013364586979150772,
0.019184419885277748,
-0.007965244352817535,
-0.03817633166909218,
0.020065275952219963,
-0.00976753793656826,
0.0033420459367334843,
-0.034202203154563904,
0.012545271776616573,
-0.012223836034536362,
0.012107695452868938,
0.008725041523575783,
-0.014101723209023476,
0.005697921849787235,
-0.022867267951369286,
-0.03762988746166229,
-0.017350805923342705,
0.0027701035141944885,
0.0010806163772940636,
0.013231327757239342,
-0.006682633422315121,
0.03621463105082512,
0.02721000462770462,
0.028684109449386597,
0.0061289239674806595,
0.019403036683797836,
0.020282285287976265,
-0.01361154392361641,
0.024941064417362213,
-0.056855302304029465,
-0.06494894623756409,
0.01989547722041607,
-0.0018998924642801285,
0.04105658084154129,
0.027784641832113266,
-0.005053017288446426,
0.037679124623537064,
0.03697531297802925,
0.05598604306578636,
0.009315678849816322,
0.020561188459396362,
-0.0026485584676265717,
0.002828066935762763,
0.009611017070710659,
-0.013858598656952381,
0.045141465961933136,
-0.028680497780442238,
0.04093645140528679,
0.037421565502882004,
-0.015024458058178425,
-0.01628643088042736,
-0.028646714985370636,
-0.013691782020032406,
-0.020028317347168922,
0.01791621744632721,
0.06313389539718628,
-0.0059204911813139915,
-0.060422174632549286,
-0.06727961450815201,
-0.03328584134578705,
-0.17147675156593323,
-0.02107764221727848,
0.0007174663478508592,
0.013394820503890514,
-0.00391395902261138,
0.002756174188107252,
-0.0219475906342268,
0.015106817707419395,
-0.0367702879011631,
0.030324216932058334,
0.0386604368686676,
-0.04604203999042511,
0.020475059747695923,
0.051730625331401825,
0.04471615329384804,
-0.013067358173429966,
-0.0010516251204535365,
0.023006293922662735,
0.01741984114050865,
-0.0403444878757,
0.00759314838796854,
-0.031229285523295403,
0.025354377925395966,
-0.021554799750447273,
-0.013002777472138405,
0.053467053920030594,
-0.02380298264324665,
0.05386574938893318,
-0.04388938844203949,
-0.030255822464823723,
-0.010254759341478348,
0.010657966136932373,
-0.019348489120602608,
0.060120195150375366,
-0.007838396355509758,
0.0510941818356514,
0.07207443565130234,
-0.05795280262827873,
-0.030077151954174042,
-0.060552928596735,
0.02058088406920433,
0.052516937255859375,
0.01755409687757492,
0.002094161929562688,
0.022686462849378586,
-0.025773432105779648,
-0.007477212231606245,
0.03574344143271446,
0.020894868299365044,
0.019940683618187904,
0.016084512695670128,
0.013879596255719662,
-0.007701464928686619,
-0.01889740861952305,
-0.012122845277190208,
-0.02866421267390251,
0.028790757060050964,
0.02348952554166317,
-0.03191601112484932,
-0.01053143385797739,
-0.00824173167347908,
-0.05143044888973236,
0.008340870961546898,
0.0214140173047781,
-0.04086104780435562,
0.01976131647825241,
0.024704379960894585,
-0.03939816728234291,
-0.0004532798193395138,
0.018658846616744995,
0.027485137805342674,
0.00010253275831928477,
0.01024063490331173,
-0.010199718177318573,
0.07552492618560791,
0.03155980631709099,
-0.051907848566770554,
-0.007048571482300758,
-0.02663704752922058,
-0.12434157729148865,
0.011857700534164906,
0.008683746680617332,
-0.015132110565900803,
0.035787515342235565,
-0.0020367589313536882,
0.007515385281294584,
0.016075031831860542,
0.06280117481946945,
0.011304366402328014,
0.24338136613368988,
-0.006979069206863642,
0.021480334922671318,
0.03511105850338936,
0.022751832380890846,
-0.035955946892499924,
0.02332889288663864,
0.03165125846862793,
-0.012618658132851124,
-0.04639388993382454,
-0.005904321558773518,
0.02314801886677742,
-0.005288921762257814,
0.031707968562841415,
-0.028494959697127342,
0.01800544746220112,
-0.05242673307657242,
-0.01708461344242096,
0.046310022473335266,
-0.0010025687515735626,
0.03191421553492546,
-0.04521320015192032,
-0.02409515343606472,
0.0050629908218979836,
-0.06683746725320816,
-0.03104548156261444,
0.01949680596590042,
0.05773365870118141,
-0.024019410833716393,
0.023832987993955612,
-0.002683056518435478,
-0.0016848437953740358,
0.027978410944342613,
-0.008560790680348873,
0.04209776595234871,
0.035766877233982086,
-0.010172686539590359,
0.017369912937283516,
-0.010783770121634007,
0.06654725223779678,
0.010556825436651707,
-0.03782324120402336,
-0.011807103641331196,
-0.0952465832233429,
-0.04610542953014374,
-0.021645283326506615,
0.005999534856528044,
0.031625211238861084,
-0.0415334515273571,
0.004250882193446159,
-0.03353424742817879,
0.02550487034022808,
-0.008913721889257431,
0.011347891762852669,
-0.016964266076683998,
0.033527325838804245,
-0.01623619720339775,
0.04601075127720833,
-0.014066169038414955,
0.02625681832432747,
0.007888397201895714,
0.027624763548374176,
-0.0043930793181061745,
0.01697814278304577,
-0.016506431624293327,
-0.03616743162274361,
-0.030987601727247238,
-0.03038094751536846,
0.024084780365228653,
0.010881404392421246,
0.002732291119173169,
0.0392623245716095,
0.014494610019028187,
0.01599370315670967,
0.01658826880156994,
-0.015474758110940456,
-0.000020276618670322932,
0.02245064452290535,
0.020363163203001022,
-0.03466246277093887,
-0.049914758652448654,
-0.05682908743619919,
-0.03788458928465843,
0.007557783741503954,
0.0301684383302927,
0.017822731286287308,
-0.03901878371834755,
0.0069397869519889355,
-0.031670600175857544,
-0.027825819328427315,
-0.03239711374044418,
0.007724420633167028,
0.011531018652021885,
-0.03983544558286667,
-0.01536016259342432,
0.01093953289091587,
0.02672816440463066,
-0.019961068406701088,
-0.04301558434963226,
-0.04382474720478058,
-0.005804020445793867,
-0.0317021869122982,
-0.009641391225159168,
-0.06254009157419205,
0.025016101077198982,
-0.02812669239938259,
-0.016198094934225082,
0.02591640315949917,
-0.02767525427043438,
0.0013094809837639332,
-0.04005267471075058,
-0.0036664502695202827,
0.004125955514609814,
-0.02363703027367592,
0.041688498109579086,
0.062388721853494644,
0.00042590571683831513,
0.029817752540111542,
0.03617830201983452,
0.015704574063420296,
0.017332762479782104,
-0.009017287753522396,
-0.03348485380411148,
0.007225795183330774,
0.012909048236906528,
0.05147921293973923,
-0.035018883645534515,
-0.030003925785422325,
-0.007497688755393028,
-0.011236702091991901,
0.037589386105537415,
-0.01963666081428528,
-0.040589768439531326,
0.0019494063453748822,
0.06091788411140442,
0.04620938003063202,
-0.020937614142894745,
-0.0161745622754097,
-0.06545946002006531,
-0.008846466429531574,
-0.004184477496892214,
-0.009206597693264484,
-0.020588591694831848,
-0.017144493758678436,
-0.0032235472463071346,
0.008668492548167706,
-0.03507688641548157,
0.038562990725040436,
-0.02504059486091137,
0.028874343261122704,
0.0018676508916541934,
0.030760783702135086,
-0.06309475004673004,
-0.012541684322059155,
0.0073763844557106495,
0.0038415032904595137,
-0.008862100541591644,
-0.010890591889619827,
0.003774168435484171,
-0.023976538330316544,
-0.011221732944250107,
-0.02519701048731804,
0.010799531824886799,
0.016864167526364326,
0.007437604479491711,
0.03868981450796127,
-0.022843414917588234,
-0.009096641093492508,
0.028719916939735413,
-0.020606307312846184,
-0.023731015622615814,
-0.021436816081404686,
-0.01666814275085926,
0.04680819809436798,
0.007073710672557354,
0.01186354085803032,
0.014097242616117,
0.024800384417176247,
0.022580958902835846,
-0.03459770232439041,
0.02393978461623192,
-0.007931887172162533,
-0.05234908685088158,
-0.04784711077809334,
0.0008924172725528479,
-0.002210329519584775,
0.020126041024923325,
-0.014537440612912178,
0.04348844289779663,
-0.056702930480241776,
-0.022121934220194817,
0.09110930562019348,
0.012009735219180584,
-0.0324505940079689,
-0.014747582376003265,
-0.0022752350196242332,
0.013036897405982018,
0.052819035947322845,
-0.009279745630919933,
-0.01743987388908863,
-0.022086914628744125,
0.020423350855708122,
0.00771308271214366,
-0.009991584345698357,
0.023756032809615135,
0.026263125240802765,
-0.024001646786928177,
0.034620609134435654,
-0.06076110154390335,
-0.011415473185479641,
0.02026478387415409,
-0.002965424442663789,
-0.006149669643491507,
0.027692118659615517,
0.0045221890322864056,
-0.02920754812657833,
0.013009664602577686,
0.016441622748970985,
-0.0032374500297009945,
-0.06093946471810341,
-0.025691812857985497,
-0.04669523984193802,
0.014699064195156097,
-0.06337825208902359,
-0.026102688163518906,
-0.002845189068466425,
-0.04516631364822388,
-0.025343362241983414,
-0.035912442952394485,
0.0008246678044088185,
-0.006256976630538702,
-0.06975255161523819,
0.03112111985683441,
-0.049650516360998154,
-0.02065463922917843,
-0.023722335696220398,
0.05786978453397751,
0.005925751756876707,
0.023575905710458755,
-0.0031417447607964277,
0.039944108575582504,
-0.038553617894649506,
0.026724739000201225,
0.030300641432404518,
-0.016373442485928535,
0.02622946910560131,
-0.009559396654367447,
-0.012968519702553749,
0.00243674055673182,
0.04491551220417023,
0.022238627076148987,
0.03753240779042244,
-0.000016566707927268,
0.011561327613890171,
-0.023591389879584312,
0.014903279021382332,
0.005185420624911785,
-0.029887624084949493,
-0.005840201862156391,
-0.05663050711154938,
-0.016287006437778473,
-0.01997922547161579,
-0.001488436246290803,
-0.02323397807776928,
-0.043721359223127365,
-0.04262567684054375,
0.02724495530128479,
-0.01937524601817131,
-0.01933300495147705,
-0.02382938750088215,
-0.006701718550175428,
-0.003389662830159068,
-0.01031311322003603,
-0.05197877064347267,
0.014653493650257587,
0.01845836453139782,
-0.01903577521443367,
-0.0005662480252794921,
0.002661168109625578,
-0.012216073460876942,
-0.0145057812333107,
0.0146625442430377,
0.042234305292367935,
0.02388160489499569,
-0.04463184252381325,
0.03285135701298714,
0.008472856134176254,
-0.027071164920926094,
0.008571667596697807,
-0.01562688685953617,
0.0025091893039643764,
-0.008217258378863335,
-0.017904814332723618,
0.04626757279038429,
-0.019423967227339745,
-0.028736863285303116,
-0.01100435946136713,
-0.040906310081481934,
-0.03776458650827408,
0.02584262378513813,
0.005143178626894951,
-0.00011257549340371042,
-0.04227983579039574,
-0.03880457580089569,
-0.031627051532268524,
-0.012661089189350605,
0.0030422951094806194,
0.00037674003397114575,
-0.018589545041322708,
0.020593706518411636,
0.01924615539610386,
-0.05247640237212181,
0.02229200303554535,
-0.0007214236538857222,
0.031594935804605484,
0.027680927887558937,
0.009268158115446568,
0.004024269059300423,
-0.010914935730397701,
0.026483025401830673,
0.009268571622669697,
0.007937917485833168,
-0.04487411677837372,
-0.0016706363530829549,
-0.03989091515541077,
0.00845192838460207,
0.02120434306561947,
-0.05337648093700409,
-0.04858279973268509,
0.023285511881113052,
-0.027944859117269516,
-0.0022993702441453934,
0.016077756881713867,
0.007388198282569647,
0.04099510610103607,
0.01707649976015091,
-0.006889955140650272,
0.00801872555166483,
0.012323619797825813,
-0.030446376651525497,
0.0018195781158283353,
-0.013148138299584389,
0.056321028620004654,
-0.0039057207759469748,
0.03035268560051918,
0.01904342696070671,
0.014237958937883377,
-0.008956369943916798,
0.029071904718875885,
0.033977873623371124,
-0.0019531785510480404,
0.017127200961112976,
-0.011708577163517475,
-0.029959576204419136,
-0.009927038103342056,
-0.027210837230086327,
-0.0057482244446873665,
0.023825906217098236,
0.02617637626826763,
-0.0014423737302422523,
-0.028476133942604065,
0.01981348544359207,
0.005582266952842474,
0.00023680202139075845,
-0.03302447497844696,
-0.022637853398919106,
0.01007237657904625,
0.0216157715767622,
-0.0211062990128994,
0.03462648391723633,
0.009513101540505886,
-0.02625180408358574,
0.0002655495482031256,
-0.02088256925344467,
-0.06002233177423477,
0.04295261576771736,
0.0011750352568924427,
-0.009281650185585022,
-0.0045422944240272045,
-0.05712759122252464,
0.0005279086763039231,
-0.03558073937892914,
-0.03452456369996071,
-0.04741935059428215,
0.022899791598320007,
-0.02113339677453041,
-0.05028069391846657,
0.026530712842941284,
0.020701566711068153,
0.012819325551390648,
0.015624066814780235,
0.01944117248058319,
-0.03310930356383324,
-0.0036301251966506243,
-0.14550507068634033,
0.005391182377934456,
-0.0006045448826625943,
-0.04653259366750717,
-0.029109889641404152,
-0.009481747634708881,
-0.04387957975268364,
0.004185305908322334,
-0.008002609014511108,
-0.01110564824193716,
0.011840809136629105,
0.009907335974276066,
0.011811509728431702,
-0.008947581052780151,
-0.035010237246751785,
0.024549981579184532,
-0.045877207070589066,
0.009072639048099518,
-0.05926736071705818,
0.015528913587331772,
0.027061186730861664,
0.009257384575903416,
0.0022456555161625147,
-0.006471309345215559,
-0.000036668676330009475,
0.011608532629907131,
0.015480500645935535,
-0.04424915462732315,
-0.028019823133945465,
-0.028695816174149513,
-0.022234976291656494,
-0.0077461861073970795,
0.009813196957111359,
0.07429171353578568,
-0.009424608200788498,
0.033293429762125015,
0.00662566814571619,
0.001103895134292543,
-0.026662465184926987,
-0.01180637814104557,
-0.010620011016726494,
0.021367941051721573,
-0.015598626807332039,
-0.038038160651922226,
0.005200243089348078,
0.018955662846565247,
-0.02153446525335312,
-0.03332105651497841,
-0.0632488951086998,
-0.023789064958691597,
-0.04888933151960373,
0.01821502298116684,
0.0036479623522609472,
0.04109464958310127,
0.025474993512034416,
-0.0003182217478752136,
0.016213512048125267,
-0.03277609124779701,
0.00888318382203579,
0.06659536063671112,
0.043471287935972214,
-0.009088810533285141,
-0.0779886394739151,
-0.0023420455399900675,
0.0055336798541247845,
0.011336740106344223,
0.006014795508235693,
0.005766588728874922,
-0.00450081005692482,
0.0027374960482120514,
-0.03394486755132675,
-0.01101668830960989,
0.0032759481109678745,
-0.07500720769166946,
0.005105136893689632,
-0.025549469515681267,
0.0038475210312753916,
0.03965739905834198,
-0.027374165132641792,
-0.008777203969657421,
-0.0006773474160581827,
-0.016064904630184174,
-0.06709889322519302,
0.01965274102985859,
0.06922668218612671,
0.015724098309874535,
-0.005238713230937719,
-0.02870900183916092,
0.00793053861707449,
-0.05228690803050995,
-0.04783553630113602,
0.006439687218517065,
0.019113877788186073,
0.020153505727648735,
-0.02762754075229168,
0.02018439769744873,
0.00805085338652134,
0.00483756372705102,
-0.0017791116843000054,
0.007295772898942232,
-0.012094834819436073,
-0.0092947818338871,
-0.017444288358092308,
0.009440891444683075,
-0.0075484588742256165,
0.016515173017978668,
0.04509646072983742,
0.006119322497397661,
0.02341034635901451,
-0.004788792226463556,
-0.01845603808760643,
-0.022391190752387047,
-0.037874218076467514,
0.017478646710515022,
-0.06569366902112961,
0.007292499765753746,
0.008593025617301464,
0.02463865466415882,
-0.0011190245859324932,
-0.020365264266729355,
0.038828082382678986,
0.04355953633785248,
0.03007432632148266,
-0.011077229864895344,
0.02640489861369133,
0.017024710774421692,
0.062052395194768906,
0.019952993839979172,
0.02106717973947525,
0.026365676894783974,
0.03061158023774624,
-0.00027880939887836576,
0.027948347851634026,
0.027127956971526146,
0.010723578743636608,
0.024792062118649483,
-0.004444873426109552,
0.01958414725959301,
-0.060424137860536575,
-0.027615226805210114,
0.02556433156132698,
0.024940263479948044,
-0.01631423644721508,
0.014683442190289497,
-0.04170010983943939,
-0.0026528097223490477,
0.036976102739572525,
0.0073908427730202675,
-0.012885388918220997,
0.005262644495815039,
-0.01356732752174139,
0.006118331104516983,
-0.012889835983514786,
0.026434289291501045,
-0.029949577525258064,
-0.010102972388267517,
0.05643574148416519,
-0.006329151336103678,
0.06776397675275803,
0.030781695619225502,
0.022637518122792244,
-0.024460075423121452,
-0.05169306695461273,
-0.03140678629279137,
0.014305840246379375,
0.06507574766874313,
0.0006400744314305484,
0.0020267029758542776,
0.0016981168882921338,
-0.02880331501364708,
0.002028140937909484,
-0.005621373187750578,
-0.01430616807192564,
0.04096154868602753,
0.05730400234460831,
-0.022572489455342293,
-0.004995676688849926,
0.00048032531049102545,
0.03994040563702583,
0.010165105573832989,
0.031514737755060196,
0.03477698937058449,
0.04101839289069176,
0.012869841419160366,
0.05237777531147003,
0.020918231457471848,
-0.003074486507102847,
-0.02649167738854885,
0.008856014348566532,
-0.04205763712525368,
-0.013556421734392643,
0.008669981732964516,
0.02072056569159031,
-0.0016136786434799433,
0.03461397811770439,
0.02235134318470955,
0.001393853104673326,
-0.00006844820018159226,
0.0239661056548357,
0.018478671088814735,
0.04835635423660278,
-0.022966530174016953,
-0.05183161795139313,
-0.024192264303565025,
-0.03724592179059982,
-0.00672757625579834,
0.001129539217799902,
-0.04449409991502762,
-0.04010116308927536,
0.08217579126358032,
0.030265534296631813,
-0.019587455317378044,
-0.01348470151424408,
0.037715476006269455,
-0.02003616839647293,
0.016279639676213264,
-0.0014476412907242775,
-0.013143894262611866,
0.04116614907979965,
-0.04911797121167183,
0.015462049283087254,
0.050684742629528046,
-0.02314143069088459,
-0.046299077570438385,
-0.03711194545030594,
-0.02052571438252926,
-0.027603382244706154,
0.00808947253972292,
0.0011379410279914737,
0.03843029960989952,
-0.0072593591175973415,
-0.01870884746313095,
0.0059073735028505325,
0.05817055702209473,
0.00001551701825519558,
-0.028137344866991043,
-0.017495986074209213,
-0.002666875021532178,
-0.020597245544195175,
0.024495653808116913,
0.051814157515764236,
-0.020290402695536613,
0.0011576821561902761,
-0.018166683614253998
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:61
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
895Nonetheless, Mr Zdrilic continued to be involved in the venture. On 13 September 2006 he sent an email to Mr Frederick (with a copy to Mr Renshall and Mr Tugrul) in which he said:-
"...I appreciate the work that you say you are doing and Robert is doing and others are doing. But this does not change the fact that I should be involved as well and have information to enable me to make proper business comments. You have all decided to keep me out as was made obvious by David Hickie at the last meeting on 16/8/06.
At that meeting a comment was made that I am talking too much about my loan yet in recent emails I did not mention the loan at all and still I am not getting the information that I have requested and that everybody agreed that I will get and soon (...)
One of the things that I have observed over time and I mentioned it in my previous correspondence is that we should have a system of proper reporting on a regular basis (...)
In summary I'm trying to get the information that I have been trying to get for a long time. I simply want to know the position of the company. I wanted to assist with the obtaining of finance to get rid of these expensive loans but I cannot get my contacts involved because I am not given information to be able to explain to these people the true position of the company."
896This email, sent a little over a month before lodgement of the Caveat on 11 October 2006 (relied upon as constituting rescission of the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed), makes no complaint about any conduct of HTT or Mr Renshall referrable to those documents.
897On the contrary, at this stage, Mr Zdrilic's complaint was that he was not being given sufficient information about the venture that those documents established.
898Approximately a month later, on 11 October 2006, LEC lodged a caveat on the title of the Property. That caveat claimed an interest in the Land described as:-
"Constructive trust and/or equitable charge".
899The facts relied upon were, in effect a draft pleading which included an assertion that the Heads of Agreement were "void ab initio".
900The "draft pleading" revived the complaints earlier made in the 2001 Proceedings, and also alleged that, prior to entering the Heads of Agreement and the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings, the following representations were made to LEC and Mr Zdrilic:-
(a) "that funding for the project was imminent;
(b) that funding would come from a big funder from New Zealand and the new NZ funder would be HTT's partner in the Joint Venture Project;
(c) that the funder would put money in to pay out all existing loans. The loans would be at normal commercial rates;
(d) that some existing loans were at high rates and would be replaced by the new funder;
(e) that the funder would put in other substantial money as necessary;
(f) that the funder would take control of the project;
(g) that the funder would pour in millions of dollars into the project;
(h) that the funder was very wealthy;
(i) that the funder would provide funding without delay; and
(j) that the funder would purchase most, if not all, units in the Huntley Trust held by smaller unit holders ie. All units except those units held by Sentel."
901There is no hint in the material of these allegations having been made before the date of the lodgement of the Caveat.
902There was debate before me as to whether the lodgement of the Caveat did amount to an act of rescission.
903It is not necessary to resolve that debate. It is common ground that the commencement of these proceedings in March 2007 did amount to a purported rescission and that no relevant event occurred between the lodgement of the Caveat and the commencement of proceedings.
Affirmation - conclusion
904Assuming that the representations pleaded were made and were relied on and, contrary to my findings, led to the entry by the plaintiffs into the Heads of Agreement and Non-Dilution Deed, I think it clear from this analysis of the events from September 2004 that,
|
[
-0.04967198893427849,
0.04717429354786873,
-0.00353701482526958,
-0.0013884033542126417,
-0.019506532698869705,
-0.06081288307905197,
0.013812978751957417,
-0.0384737029671669,
-0.006736855022609234,
-0.023024197667837143,
0.02065933868288994,
0.015669450163841248,
-0.03607948496937752,
0.013649729080498219,
-0.0432581789791584,
-0.042773354798555374,
0.06360446661710739,
-0.02027764357626438,
-0.01249932311475277,
-0.010060048662126064,
-0.010956725105643272,
-0.0009580714977346361,
0.06437931209802628,
0.0125997019931674,
-0.01850103586912155,
0.008592838421463966,
-0.03248187154531479,
0.030236152932047844,
0.0455012284219265,
0.012106752023100853,
0.014832369051873684,
0.014544742181897163,
0.04922701045870781,
-0.006099096033722162,
-0.003329062834382057,
-0.019658369943499565,
0.03436407819390297,
0.028739459812641144,
-0.03262382745742798,
0.009021990932524204,
-0.014989260584115982,
0.02901584468781948,
0.019765861332416534,
-0.02514534816145897,
0.0698079988360405,
-0.032192956656217575,
-0.026369648054242134,
-0.04305090382695198,
-0.005616866983473301,
0.0424773134291172,
-0.0640992671251297,
-0.020686089992523193,
0.03633321449160576,
-0.010214746929705143,
0.014804661273956299,
-0.016408788040280342,
-0.013954143039882183,
-0.013284736312925816,
-0.05940737947821617,
0.0123253483325243,
0.008378222584724426,
-0.01730494573712349,
-0.0441073440015316,
-0.010952640324831009,
-0.015379484742879868,
0.10148503631353378,
0.0017814248567447066,
-0.00009781055268831551,
0.003969976212829351,
-0.02260436676442623,
-0.024872712790966034,
-0.009508884511888027,
-0.035784587264060974,
-0.0035038013011217117,
-0.10261429101228714,
0.031168848276138306,
0.026578348129987717,
0.006836377549916506,
0.026155879721045494,
0.013281683437526226,
0.052909329533576965,
-0.02251441590487957,
-0.009629666805267334,
0.0378539152443409,
0.003466623602434993,
0.009953773580491543,
-0.019924795255064964,
0.042208872735500336,
0.027969134971499443,
-0.014399310573935509,
-0.021991699934005737,
-0.004871689714491367,
0.007137286011129618,
-0.061192288994789124,
-0.00004101380909560248,
0.02626458741724491,
-0.06512729823589325,
0.03240642324090004,
-0.007355959620326757,
0.035109881311655045,
0.021761737763881683,
0.0316319577395916,
-0.009566282853484154,
-0.03828390687704086,
0.013554377481341362,
0.01390755269676447,
0.035952791571617126,
0.025249525904655457,
0.02022620290517807,
0.006153187248855829,
0.00581368338316679,
-0.015530504286289215,
-0.0048850360326468945,
-0.000509193807374686,
0.004870675038546324,
0.0012436524266377091,
-0.0023939362727105618,
-0.0072159916162490845,
0.04666003957390785,
0.00014814089809078723,
0.0350743792951107,
0.03124270774424076,
0.028110472485423088,
-0.007702984847128391,
-0.04742639511823654,
0.009908181615173817,
-0.00909140333533287,
-0.010234261862933636,
0.015773916617035866,
0.03129780292510986,
0.011637545190751553,
0.022028112784028053,
-0.027921343222260475,
-0.05808805674314499,
-0.014998838305473328,
0.005754027049988508,
-0.006327176932245493,
-0.0037948316894471645,
0.019842294976115227,
-0.05909808352589607,
0.04404132068157196,
0.025646047666668892,
0.0011228431249037385,
-0.04556887969374657,
0.01882721669971943,
-0.009318625554442406,
0.010126633569598198,
0.010668421164155006,
0.015068361535668373,
0.02876773476600647,
0.02812323346734047,
-0.0019291331991553307,
-0.016866130754351616,
0.009424123913049698,
0.05865071713924408,
-0.03619787469506264,
0.020611479878425598,
-0.05024924501776695,
0.03411579132080078,
0.09535551071166992,
-0.04314747825264931,
0.01722370833158493,
-0.05550319701433182,
-0.0187904704362154,
-0.015849323943257332,
0.034529220312833786,
-0.00459377421066165,
0.035818394273519516,
-0.028297461569309235,
0.015573732554912567,
0.03072068840265274,
-0.04213079810142517,
0.05619093403220177,
-0.012361698783934116,
0.0012552551925182343,
0.02203691191971302,
0.08969780057668686,
0.002689968328922987,
0.005023675505071878,
-0.022065719589591026,
-0.03662152960896492,
0.025216083973646164,
-0.005773087963461876,
-0.032855600118637085,
-0.04905547574162483,
0.0072380248457193375,
-0.023858103901147842,
-0.0052763186395168304,
-0.013920262455940247,
0.030351266264915466,
-0.005477339494973421,
-0.006755157373845577,
0.05251837521791458,
0.01715944893658161,
0.003317542839795351,
-0.027711765840649605,
-0.009409795515239239,
-0.04981827735900879,
0.003189231501892209,
-0.023142579942941666,
-0.030362002551555634,
0.040283266454935074,
0.0719948559999466,
-0.05231298506259918,
-0.014050115831196308,
0.024463558569550514,
-0.018905967473983765,
-0.015306747518479824,
0.0019885015208274126,
-0.06837809085845947,
0.00019379696459509432,
-0.005673881154507399,
-0.0004286259354557842,
-0.003380407113581896,
0.01742190681397915,
-0.015270487405359745,
0.008230596780776978,
-0.03187033161520958,
-0.009603714570403099,
-0.019761722534894943,
-0.021392833441495895,
-0.006167320534586906,
0.018488379195332527,
-0.00254236813634634,
0.02923816628754139,
0.03967747464776039,
-0.053901590406894684,
0.0023378615733236074,
-0.027521532028913498,
-0.007710785139352083,
-0.011975986883044243,
-0.019851647317409515,
0.0352453775703907,
-0.015865972265601158,
0.01746603287756443,
0.006327108945697546,
0.006305237766355276,
0.021472152322530746,
-0.0007950721774250269,
0.027121804654598236,
-0.02177678607404232,
0.0033280348870903254,
-0.008014338091015816,
-0.006705573759973049,
-0.04139091074466705,
-0.008362258784472942,
-0.007530953269451857,
0.019559599459171295,
0.033757030963897705,
-0.011379088275134563,
-0.00934575591236353,
0.014637853018939495,
0.00937674380838871,
-0.024584470316767693,
-0.012574023567140102,
0.03450185805559158,
0.018223118036985397,
-0.0007193326018750668,
0.053940147161483765,
0.021903669461607933,
0.03705510124564171,
0.016075199469923973,
0.03407462686300278,
0.030613884329795837,
-0.025529872626066208,
0.020140353590250015,
-0.036684852093458176,
-0.05321338027715683,
0.058425627648830414,
-0.020260002464056015,
0.005676526576280594,
0.033984582871198654,
0.03046470321714878,
0.002981845522299409,
0.03780366852879524,
0.00083355006063357,
-0.003970927093178034,
0.022271418944001198,
0.0014662810135632753,
0.009047542698681355,
0.00499690743163228,
0.031990859657526016,
0.03550725430250168,
-0.05833354592323303,
0.008826476521790028,
0.052922844886779785,
-0.016903838142752647,
-0.021034760400652885,
0.012684766203165054,
-0.05319032445549965,
-0.03961807116866112,
0.020863119512796402,
0.05634044110774994,
0.0014374736929312348,
-0.06027557700872421,
-0.02745826169848442,
-0.03871944174170494,
-0.14634639024734497,
-0.04165477305650711,
-0.006218713242560625,
0.0026463507674634457,
0.006465735379606485,
0.018671337515115738,
-0.04129086062312126,
-0.003970888908952475,
-0.05204815790057182,
-0.004354724660515785,
0.013866465538740158,
-0.05023570731282234,
-0.02281404659152031,
0.024315619841217995,
0.011208759620785713,
-0.011784312315285206,
0.019476069137454033,
0.005263695027679205,
0.040019575506448746,
-0.012038012966513634,
0.01796511933207512,
-0.05468132346868515,
0.06727952510118484,
0.020719097927212715,
-0.0021054879762232304,
-0.01197197288274765,
0.001343907555565238,
0.0157762598246336,
-0.017094861716032028,
-0.0033131446689367294,
-0.001364498515613377,
0.020116399973630905,
-0.01728418469429016,
0.04708993807435036,
0.002517144428566098,
0.058177024126052856,
0.046662166714668274,
-0.061523474752902985,
0.009646693244576454,
-0.03147241100668907,
0.01163189671933651,
0.05221543833613396,
-0.00044881243957206607,
-0.0024971391540020704,
0.00006358305836329237,
-0.041110944002866745,
0.016575070098042488,
-0.012099108658730984,
-0.030503449961543083,
0.024932561442255974,
-0.01004024688154459,
0.005686587654054165,
-0.03331327438354492,
-0.05115709453821182,
-0.002087725792080164,
-0.004729135427623987,
0.04460786655545235,
0.022193744778633118,
-0.027705736458301544,
-0.001754025463014841,
-0.03281308338046074,
-0.04435203969478607,
0.025965653359889984,
0.0011223384644836187,
-0.03188766539096832,
0.0013221112312749028,
-0.006527186371386051,
-0.01750740222632885,
0.00835296418517828,
0.019492831081151962,
0.02533295936882496,
-0.023355498909950256,
-0.016469188034534454,
-0.002864052075892687,
0.027282102033495903,
0.037093594670295715,
-0.036194223910570145,
0.006024633999913931,
-0.0050794826820492744,
-0.08571173995733261,
-0.019672425463795662,
0.03949581831693649,
-0.01816154271364212,
0.008104388602077961,
-0.02643389254808426,
0.05906393751502037,
0.032172948122024536,
0.01945449411869049,
-0.0033910321071743965,
0.2441895753145218,
-0.010303924791514874,
0.012833564542233944,
0.021459870040416718,
0.022533508017659187,
0.017903219908475876,
0.014621454291045666,
0.05793420225381851,
-0.013164299540221691,
-0.05264537036418915,
-0.020296933129429817,
-0.0004866986128035933,
0.03295128419995308,
0.02963523380458355,
-0.025796420872211456,
0.024629730731248856,
-0.02817625366151333,
-0.018703870475292206,
0.06277911365032196,
0.0014080278342589736,
0.03603224828839302,
-0.013932582922279835,
0.011766787618398666,
0.020048247650265694,
-0.0558454655110836,
-0.01673516444861889,
0.04791269823908806,
0.06883629411458969,
-0.05210621654987335,
0.004851481877267361,
-0.006773169152438641,
-0.008864409290254116,
0.05022985860705376,
0.012286027893424034,
-0.003799652447924018,
-0.003201097948476672,
-0.003818378085270524,
-0.00284728966653347,
-0.007585734594613314,
0.040146905928850174,
0.01293970923870802,
-0.03188382834196091,
-0.0394030399620533,
-0.022808024659752846,
-0.05647938326001167,
0.025118162855505943,
-0.02256665751338005,
0.023038839921355247,
0.019907455891370773,
0.02646593376994133,
-0.013671084307134151,
0.024559875950217247,
-0.04252665862441063,
-0.027118172496557236,
0.0017946698935702443,
0.03896080702543259,
-0.04674176499247551,
0.06697128713130951,
-0.006112623494118452,
0.07322730869054794,
0.007169147953391075,
0.04259330779314041,
-0.045389387756586075,
0.022399388253688812,
-0.009084814228117466,
-0.025683604180812836,
-0.04845286160707474,
-0.0020458553917706013,
0.05474115163087845,
0.046620000153779984,
0.05568898096680641,
0.027271069586277008,
-0.011915802024304867,
-0.005439823493361473,
0.04149920493364334,
-0.00008905444701667875,
-0.05400986596941948,
0.002750501735135913,
-0.02647876925766468,
0.03354426473379135,
-0.02920525334775448,
-0.028992939740419388,
-0.033973611891269684,
0.03825201466679573,
0.006662091705948114,
0.0035447250120341778,
-0.02773052640259266,
0.06090794503688812,
-0.016679678112268448,
-0.010917093604803085,
-0.02382209524512291,
-0.014683987945318222,
0.021552927792072296,
0.00771015789359808,
-0.0018484876491129398,
-0.03301941975951195,
-0.0010235300287604332,
-0.03523322939872742,
-0.018649229779839516,
-0.014386278577148914,
0.006038988940417767,
0.00024782551918178797,
0.02049705944955349,
-0.03238648176193237,
-0.006827590521425009,
-0.010821526870131493,
-0.0173918716609478,
-0.00049244036199525,
-0.05029306933283806,
0.014852003194391727,
0.014579245820641518,
0.023109151050448418,
-0.010483351536095142,
-0.0008447651052847505,
0.019280223175883293,
0.050073083490133286,
-0.017342805862426758,
0.028871798887848854,
0.032611504197120667,
0.008555096574127674,
0.02290545590221882,
-0.034685224294662476,
-0.03310307115316391,
-0.03105708211660385,
-0.00949012953788042,
0.0022004011552780867,
-0.02899167127907276,
0.0011341514764353633,
-0.007955806329846382,
0.01968212053179741,
-0.014152979478240013,
-0.008389810100197792,
-0.03156386688351631,
0.01903652586042881,
0.036515168845653534,
0.025585321709513664,
0.029882438480854034,
-0.010661132633686066,
-0.062385864555835724,
0.029792511835694313,
-0.03452599421143532,
0.016223400831222534,
-0.0551302470266819,
-0.020427068695425987,
0.011022686026990414,
0.01290941797196865,
-0.049041323363780975,
0.03445782884955406,
-0.05790941044688225,
-0.005872021429240704,
0.003901803633198142,
0.024322863668203354,
-0.023592662066221237,
-0.04407573491334915,
0.004082863684743643,
0.014956767670810223,
-0.023141369223594666,
-0.012167259119451046,
0.011948974803090096,
-0.020811423659324646,
0.010664285160601139,
0.01021234504878521,
0.04443591460585594,
0.003740290878340602,
-0.00876261293888092,
0.07878462970256805,
-0.020235197618603706,
0.033553216606378555,
0.06100154295563698,
-0.020123975351452827,
-0.026327308267354965,
-0.06022065505385399,
-0.036070726811885834,
0.056982774287462234,
0.019625317305326462,
0.032440125942230225,
-0.023310214281082153,
0.005103370174765587,
-0.032303016632795334,
-0.04605691134929657,
0.034481294453144073,
0.02322401851415634,
-0.04714890196919441,
0.011334463022649288,
-0.016483664512634277,
-0.017749620601534843,
-0.004501378629356623,
-0.010836207307875156,
0.0667715072631836,
-0.052865564823150635,
0.005055963061749935,
0.09113378077745438,
0.030335132032632828,
-0.010461663827300072,
0.020257964730262756,
-0.019537346437573433,
0.015501715242862701,
0.03760116174817085,
-0.01853736862540245,
-0.027170317247509956,
-0.025766177102923393,
-0.019246703013777733,
0.005470827221870422,
-0.03052574023604393,
0.037573881447315216,
-0.0010832016123458743,
-0.02033444680273533,
0.04919232055544853,
-0.039298541843891144,
-0.03237249329686165,
0.03466825932264328,
0.04975322261452675,
-0.040482230484485626,
0.020166952162981033,
-0.004247345961630344,
-0.03366376832127571,
0.024026092141866684,
0.03997015953063965,
-0.0005341212963685393,
-0.061936743557453156,
0.007710891310125589,
-0.021211568266153336,
0.0035947863943874836,
-0.04780944809317589,
-0.04031712934374809,
-0.007691596634685993,
-0.06503060460090637,
-0.014651548117399216,
-0.03784414380788803,
0.034009236842393875,
-0.006056396756321192,
-0.04186337813735008,
0.0645039826631546,
-0.03745150938630104,
-0.005020747892558575,
-0.02169947884976864,
0.0017251045210286975,
0.008472408168017864,
0.030466392636299133,
-0.029720155522227287,
0.011655333451926708,
0.009416796267032623,
0.02430698275566101,
0.06732756644487381,
0.0010937803890556097,
-0.019906993955373764,
0.015615389682352543,
-0.007956652902066708,
0.0026195822283625603,
0.03900287300348282,
0.00783261377364397,
0.0032578534446656704,
0.010684482753276825,
-0.008696064352989197,
0.03911673277616501,
-0.009607193991541862,
0.043019212782382965,
-0.04309558868408203,
-0.04297251254320145,
-0.017564287409186363,
-0.02806559018790722,
0.017368333414196968,
0.01668059080839157,
-0.04279439151287079,
-0.06345309317111969,
-0.06053829565644264,
0.01920793019235134,
-0.006265081465244293,
-0.03976437821984291,
-0.016923923045396805,
0.018228644505143166,
-0.02251758798956871,
0.008024375885725021,
-0.05788232013583183,
-0.0034161913208663464,
-0.03135985881090164,
-0.015290950424969196,
0.009628262370824814,
-0.005330213811248541,
0.007223960943520069,
0.017801640555262566,
0.022170178592205048,
0.04206452518701553,
0.0493072085082531,
-0.004450249020010233,
-0.0002409936860203743,
-0.017308006063103676,
0.01240269560366869,
-0.01335105299949646,
0.016589537262916565,
0.013200122863054276,
0.0029244294855743647,
-0.013592398725450039,
0.011216101236641407,
0.010165160521864891,
-0.003970342222601175,
0.0023904386907815933,
0.045121725648641586,
-0.00941811315715313,
-0.005056675057858229,
-0.012803989462554455,
-0.0038762048352509737,
-0.011761181056499481,
-0.052306994795799255,
-0.03309646248817444,
0.0003941590548492968,
0.011731600388884544,
-0.04053144156932831,
-0.02410017140209675,
0.01088948268443346,
0.028553888201713562,
-0.05204160884022713,
0.0036699578631669283,
0.0054666632786393166,
0.052407290786504745,
-0.0033270264975726604,
0.020336706191301346,
0.017367618158459663,
-0.017397329211235046,
0.004702270962297916,
0.014073227532207966,
0.007992763072252274,
-0.06005038321018219,
0.01299955788999796,
-0.06648331880569458,
-0.023142686113715172,
0.00869685783982277,
-0.03641805425286293,
-0.04654435068368912,
0.0037614437751471996,
-0.015078116208314896,
-0.02036331221461296,
0.018142694607377052,
-0.006488117855042219,
0.04114415496587753,
0.028827743604779243,
0.011834011413156986,
0.008797550573945045,
0.039285071194171906,
-0.07846835255622864,
-0.036664929240942,
-0.04223719611763954,
0.04820256680250168,
-0.030597079545259476,
-0.0158928781747818,
0.029313117265701294,
-0.013923696242272854,
-0.02137032523751259,
0.023486441001296043,
0.0005228595691733062,
-0.013309959322214127,
0.016733093187212944,
-0.0014792339643463492,
-0.053101204335689545,
0.017917290329933167,
0.003020127071067691,
0.026079099625349045,
0.010889090597629547,
0.03473794832825661,
-0.016541950404644012,
-0.006200495641678572,
0.055904168635606766,
0.008558626286685467,
0.0015619539190083742,
-0.0022138399071991444,
0.005796122830361128,
-0.0013419309398159385,
0.04795536771416664,
-0.009557649493217468,
-0.0063102105632424355,
0.02826758287847042,
-0.042387012392282486,
-0.024209341034293175,
0.0032842587679624557,
-0.02095896378159523,
0.043480608612298965,
0.02765144221484661,
0.008538159541785717,
-0.012860322371125221,
-0.042640093713998795,
0.02724308706820011,
-0.03018614463508129,
0.0024957770947366953,
-0.02665451541543007,
0.02886657789349556,
0.011580493301153183,
0.0007620397955179214,
0.01011052168905735,
-0.027130357921123505,
0.05149366706609726,
-0.015416262671351433,
0.038581106811761856,
-0.027749139815568924,
-0.00446318881586194,
-0.14942790567874908,
0.01071588508784771,
-0.02678084373474121,
-0.02200673706829548,
0.005973894149065018,
-0.012461578473448753,
-0.02741909958422184,
0.034912485629320145,
-0.02448558621108532,
-0.003596300259232521,
-0.015076383017003536,
0.0015297700883820653,
-0.022077202796936035,
-0.024405313655734062,
-0.023120373487472534,
0.00892652478069067,
-0.021560994908213615,
-0.01404818519949913,
-0.08265130966901779,
0.030962947756052017,
0.023839998990297318,
-0.0012230252614244819,
-0.009208950214087963,
-0.02180992066860199,
0.01823708973824978,
0.004109884146600962,
-0.017919406294822693,
-0.064203642308712,
-0.027898937463760376,
-0.028995582833886147,
-0.04443899914622307,
-0.012947258539497852,
0.011421103961765766,
0.06532112509012222,
-0.016055764630436897,
0.010170331224799156,
0.01236273255199194,
-0.031382638961076736,
-0.03335573524236679,
-0.009791241958737373,
-0.03908999636769295,
0.03312254324555397,
-0.039258867502212524,
-0.02550821378827095,
-0.009772996418178082,
0.03754258155822754,
-0.0024523583706468344,
0.01689830981194973,
-0.07418067753314972,
-0.046734657138586044,
-0.036751504987478256,
0.04619434103369713,
-0.005249741952866316,
0.028679771348834038,
0.004169255495071411,
0.0018457857659086585,
0.005400016903877258,
-0.017889637500047684,
0.020855357870459557,
0.014110145159065723,
0.0036135572008788586,
0.00146206421777606,
-0.01737026311457157,
0.004796184133738279,
-0.02516484633088112,
-0.00722266361117363,
-0.03212204948067665,
-0.0037968545220792294,
-0.021305477246642113,
0.010144472122192383,
-0.008559094741940498,
-0.029057588428258896,
-0.0036672845017164946,
-0.023136861622333527,
0.021002255380153656,
-0.03430159389972687,
0.012008357793092728,
-0.019284846261143684,
0.0030633641872555017,
-0.02263091690838337,
-0.05877717584371567,
-0.017937637865543365,
-0.03587430715560913,
-0.022999465465545654,
0.06751639395952225,
0.039375532418489456,
-0.013224615715444088,
-0.01113926526159048,
0.0057015432976186275,
-0.02821400761604309,
-0.07857678085565567,
0.005627389531582594,
-0.01647222600877285,
0.029788348823785782,
-0.03762700408697128,
0.043947506695985794,
0.004208669066429138,
0.013298798352479935,
0.03628366440534592,
-0.010980005376040936,
-0.04527575895190239,
0.006365151610225439,
0.026991287246346474,
-0.01258936244994402,
-0.031891144812107086,
-0.004590821918100119,
0.026624716818332672,
-0.017748162150382996,
0.029455512762069702,
-0.01295005064457655,
-0.011612143367528915,
0.004798568319529295,
-0.04848609119653702,
0.021874498575925827,
-0.024309851229190826,
0.005208514165133238,
0.007563366089016199,
-0.0037811908405274153,
-0.007475767284631729,
0.014069212600588799,
0.021467113867402077,
0.01928430236876011,
0.004760959185659885,
-0.035756006836891174,
0.008467189967632294,
-0.0030236660968512297,
0.07003004103899002,
0.027202896773815155,
0.008635488338768482,
-0.02543269842863083,
0.022862816229462624,
0.006897664628922939,
-0.018996480852365494,
0.03938772529363632,
0.016278661787509918,
0.020928945392370224,
0.008959317579865456,
-0.0021304076071828604,
-0.030995383858680725,
-0.014037828892469406,
-0.02329094707965851,
-0.010290355421602726,
0.015374147333204746,
0.007246213033795357,
-0.04058060422539711,
-0.005401925649493933,
0.052391983568668365,
-0.022371716797351837,
0.0031301192939281464,
-0.031090904027223587,
0.012855850160121918,
0.022234726697206497,
0.01672758348286152,
0.03171515837311745,
0.019191822037100792,
-0.0028584168758243322,
0.05731366574764252,
-0.01857655495405197,
0.006330277305096388,
0.03951731324195862,
-0.020313017070293427,
-0.05040566623210907,
-0.03524493798613548,
-0.04203226789832115,
-0.05420837551355362,
0.007767057977616787,
-0.003200784558430314,
0.005263545550405979,
-0.015525725670158863,
-0.01505240984261036,
-0.01759309135377407,
0.050203144550323486,
-0.015967532992362976,
0.017651936039328575,
0.02341240644454956,
-0.031098434701561928,
-0.0060674273408949375,
-0.008567995391786098,
0.06876413524150848,
-0.016948631033301353,
0.05293392017483711,
0.016006993129849434,
0.027640681713819504,
0.027617281302809715,
0.011737861670553684,
0.032779622822999954,
0.01660279557108879,
0.049271393567323685,
-0.007060556206852198,
-0.041091859340667725,
-0.02396482788026333,
0.003189756302163005,
0.025095200166106224,
-0.008202336728572845,
-0.008308942429721355,
0.011566690169274807,
0.0075744581408798695,
0.022689417004585266,
-0.005612003616988659,
0.024462562054395676,
-0.013401844538748264,
-0.02950926311314106,
-0.033967580646276474,
-0.03507626801729202,
-0.029497554525732994,
0.05038527026772499,
-0.03840329125523567,
-0.057981908321380615,
-0.04353867098689079,
0.061876483261585236,
-0.027912482619285583,
0.014831304550170898,
-0.024578839540481567,
0.010572808794677258,
-0.01661290042102337,
-0.0024532098323106766,
0.02743975631892681,
-0.023612555116415024,
0.030732998624444008,
-0.0036807777360081673,
0.012449078261852264,
0.05197962000966072,
-0.004861638881266117,
-0.005260245408862829,
-0.022233856841921806,
0.024408666417002678,
0.004210891667753458,
-0.012522418051958084,
0.0030392834451049566,
0.03037172555923462,
0.004846647847443819,
0.01991395652294159,
0.01997189037501812,
0.04742195084691048,
0.017124870792031288,
-0.04780552163720131,
-0.028834311291575432,
-0.03304119035601616,
-0.011459368281066418,
-0.01425972767174244,
0.028439803048968315,
0.029437091201543808,
0.005745291709899902,
0.011559374630451202
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:56
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
833Mr Einfeld opened the case upon the basis that the HTT Defendants would contend that the plaintiffs had affirmed the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed and the case was conducted upon that basis. In particular cross-examination of Mr Zdrilic covered, among many other issues, the plaintiffs alleged affirmation of the relevant agreements.
834Mr Jucovic points to UCPR r 14.14(2) which provides:-
"In a defence (...) a party must plead specifically any matter:
(a) that if not pleaded specifically, may take the opposite part by surprise, or
(b) that the party alleges makes any claim, defence or other case of the opposite party not maintainable..."
835In view of the reference in the pleadings to "waiver or election" I find it difficult to accept that the plaintiffs had been taken by surprise by the defendants' contention that rescission is precluded by affirmation.
836However I accept that the defendants' failure to plead affirmation does constitute a breach of UCPR r 14.14(2)(b) in that the question of affirmation is a matter that the defendants allege make the plaintiffs' claim for rescission "not maintainable".
837The authorities establish that, notwithstanding non-compliance with this rule, the court may, in a proper case, give effect to defences which are not pleaded: Pririe v Richardson [1927] 1 KB 448 at 453.
838This matter was heard over a period of almost six weeks. As I have mentioned, the cross-examination of Mr Zdrilic took five days. One matter about which Mr Zdrilic was cross-examined was affirmation. In all the circumstances I do not think that the plaintiffs have been prejudiced by the defendants' agitation of that issue, notwithstanding that fact that is was not specifically pleaded.
Affirmation - events from September 2004
839The evidence makes clear that, for almost two years after September 2004, Mr Zdrilic continued to be actively involved in the Project notwithstanding the fact that, to his knowledge, IBIS/IPC funding was not forthcoming.
840Mr Zdrilic's evidence was that he did not become aware of HTT's termination of the 15 March 2004 IPC Heads of Agreement until March of 2005.
841Nonetheless, he did know that, despite whatever was said at the settlement on 27 August 2004, no funds were forthcoming from IPC or IBIS. Not only that, but Mr Zdrilic was aware that funding was sought, and obtained, from other sources.
842On 16 September 2004, the day on which HTT terminated the 15 March 2004 Heads of Agreement, Mr Zdrilic had a conversation with Mr Renshall.
843Mr Zdrilic made the following note of the conversation:-
"Robert said that before the joint venture partners consisted of 2 parties. Mr Ping is one of them who is ready to put in $40.0m but the other party IPC was not really putting any money so moving forward we will be dealing with Mr Ping [sic] side.
Settlement will be done on Friday or Monday.
St George will put money depending on valuation which is being done now.
Robert wants to get enough so that money owing to Sentel by HTT about $3.0m can be repaid". (emphasis added).
844Although he initially denied it, Mr Zdrilic ultimately accepted that what his note showed was that he knew, as at 16 September 2004, that IPC was not "putting any money in" but St George would put money in depending on a valuation.
845In his affidavit evidence about this conversation, Mr Zdrilic attributed to Mr Renshall the words "The Joint Venture Party is still coming" (which words have no reflection in the diary note) but attributed to Mr Renshall no words corresponding to the note he made that Mr Renshall said "the other party IPC is not really putting any money".
846I do not accept that the conversation occurred as Mr Zdrilic deposed in his affidavit. It must have been clear to Mr Zdrilic, as a result of this conversation, that IPC was no longer to be in the picture, and that any funding for HTT was to come from other sources.
|
[
-0.04859016835689545,
0.041079260408878326,
-0.011744800955057144,
0.025052867829799652,
-0.024216121062636375,
-0.07022561877965927,
0.02930089458823204,
-0.028226802125573158,
-0.01851104572415352,
0.0002904245920944959,
-0.015704428777098656,
0.008814817294478416,
-0.028416365385055542,
0.008825275115668774,
-0.009029561653733253,
-0.003098114160820842,
0.05656234174966812,
-0.04092363268136978,
0.028740854933857918,
-0.014563428238034248,
-0.011469753459095955,
-0.020555628463625908,
0.05338501185178757,
0.029903657734394073,
-0.01046017650514841,
0.013709410093724728,
-0.05001199245452881,
0.04122135043144226,
0.05188898369669914,
0.035818930715322495,
-0.000962395453825593,
0.0055661615915596485,
0.042359359562397,
-0.029746269807219505,
0.0288452859967947,
-0.012948453426361084,
0.019447920843958855,
0.008675476536154747,
-0.026655755937099457,
0.013969589956104755,
-0.009791813790798187,
0.014892419800162315,
0.008891994133591652,
-0.004728086292743683,
0.07400982826948166,
-0.025816544890403748,
0.002322100568562746,
-0.025196854025125504,
-0.005324354395270348,
0.041130293160676956,
-0.0467766597867012,
-0.02405322529375553,
0.07693243026733398,
-0.03207120671868324,
-0.03065926767885685,
0.0013708194019272923,
-0.03921569883823395,
0.023625407367944717,
-0.043223533779382706,
0.04594378173351288,
0.03024512343108654,
-0.02155710570514202,
-0.05990474671125412,
0.03994269669055939,
-0.03282713145017624,
0.10106181353330612,
0.01070393342524767,
-0.007248636335134506,
0.005804143380373716,
-0.015807971358299255,
-0.06510627269744873,
0.003182468004524708,
-0.049300551414489746,
-0.014584202319383621,
-0.0909033864736557,
0.021827759221196175,
0.038056351244449615,
-0.005917620845139027,
0.025900686159729958,
0.03138710558414459,
0.024010011926293373,
-0.043182726949453354,
0.01303421426564455,
0.039288878440856934,
-0.0370415523648262,
0.02091493271291256,
-0.018044032156467438,
0.030465010553598404,
-0.015149708837270737,
-0.024725712835788727,
-0.013246402144432068,
0.03333250805735588,
0.013848358765244484,
-0.027934115380048752,
0.004072122275829315,
0.00010329968790756539,
-0.0519866980612278,
0.036154501140117645,
0.009081397205591202,
0.04406662657856941,
0.03080364502966404,
-0.002367932815104723,
-0.013472722843289375,
-0.015450481325387955,
0.0040917475707829,
0.0338079035282135,
0.07928143441677094,
0.0646052286028862,
-0.006472191773355007,
-0.003934046253561974,
-0.005275464616715908,
0.0060738022439181805,
-0.00996097270399332,
0.02144281379878521,
-0.010457873344421387,
-0.00033567872014828026,
-0.014868369325995445,
0.0380522646009922,
0.029637068510055542,
0.004971010144799948,
0.05163560435175896,
0.038861945271492004,
0.046148985624313354,
-0.0028511914424598217,
-0.07353752851486206,
0.02322153002023697,
0.008673249743878841,
0.010342447087168694,
0.015367481857538223,
0.020870737731456757,
0.017992809414863586,
0.01816997118294239,
-0.010390912182629108,
-0.039132509380578995,
-0.03079819492995739,
-0.03129611909389496,
0.014657986350357533,
-0.015600110404193401,
0.0034403190948069096,
-0.10576663911342621,
0.05718512088060379,
0.01882886327803135,
0.03744278848171234,
-0.05327343940734863,
0.04143051430583,
-0.06800267100334167,
0.014003781601786613,
0.00914247240871191,
0.04035690799355507,
0.014241162687540054,
0.01486992184072733,
-0.0015578644815832376,
0.04081156104803085,
0.004736670758575201,
-0.0010856767185032368,
-0.03436298295855522,
-0.013816025108098984,
0.021049020811915398,
0.021726053208112717,
0.07437863945960999,
-0.01421778742223978,
0.037665173411369324,
-0.003908134065568447,
-0.05161206051707268,
-0.028861461207270622,
0.0041631595231592655,
0.027739232406020164,
0.0141029953956604,
-0.01670064404606819,
-0.010507991537451744,
0.01978369988501072,
-0.021949728950858116,
0.06776820123195648,
0.006377886049449444,
0.0010365003254264593,
0.029656555503606796,
0.026777226477861404,
0.015444979071617126,
0.003146481467410922,
-0.02986476942896843,
-0.05315099284052849,
0.05162571743130684,
0.02167545258998871,
0.003791843308135867,
-0.021417977288365364,
-0.0021683303639292717,
-0.027827318757772446,
-0.006442320067435503,
0.011550107970833778,
0.01752910204231739,
-0.008770385757088661,
-0.0039644367061555386,
0.038714390248060226,
0.020154085010290146,
0.04487033933401108,
-0.04218200966715813,
0.03107946552336216,
-0.039000581949949265,
0.010149035602807999,
-0.017988920211791992,
-0.03356826677918434,
0.013494160026311874,
0.077288419008255,
-0.014131751842796803,
-0.0012937383726239204,
-0.0001520191872259602,
-0.020195666700601578,
0.006222984753549099,
-0.0018077632412314415,
-0.06655150651931763,
0.011017444543540478,
-0.011662540026009083,
-0.005007049068808556,
-0.02327200584113598,
0.017006797716021538,
-0.00821359921246767,
0.01820991560816765,
-0.008208611980080605,
0.00999390333890915,
-0.0331987589597702,
-0.01192551851272583,
0.017501574009656906,
-0.02818240411579609,
-0.007767155300825834,
0.01500761229544878,
0.036737941205501556,
-0.08575451374053955,
0.011064664460718632,
-0.028731467202305794,
-0.027895962819457054,
0.015170998871326447,
-0.005087483208626509,
0.02170596830546856,
-0.017031513154506683,
0.02680584229528904,
0.05280251055955887,
0.014786725863814354,
0.021413393318653107,
0.0042723105289042,
0.013373061083257198,
0.004940831568092108,
0.004070022143423557,
0.03561391681432724,
0.0018841656856238842,
-0.003986813127994537,
-0.019106809049844742,
-0.005026449915021658,
0.021389048546552658,
0.020102784037590027,
-0.009481455199420452,
0.021989855915308,
-0.010048030875623226,
-0.02719982899725437,
0.001435623737052083,
0.010856276378035545,
0.05564630404114723,
0.02530810981988907,
0.007307511754333973,
0.035217639058828354,
0.03661397099494934,
0.0331721194088459,
0.03598763793706894,
0.00850579421967268,
0.010059576481580734,
-0.030490269884467125,
-0.02344760112464428,
-0.04872315004467964,
-0.06513067334890366,
0.015929732471704483,
-0.016468994319438934,
-0.0035577667877078056,
-0.0205723624676466,
-0.017206886783242226,
0.0031957454048097134,
0.047669049352407455,
0.03443203121423721,
0.04390663653612137,
-0.007211707532405853,
0.020132532343268394,
0.03470970690250397,
0.015175501815974712,
-0.002639553975313902,
0.03955322131514549,
-0.011714767664670944,
0.014222754165530205,
0.008937286213040352,
-0.015399123542010784,
-0.01857053115963936,
0.02028839848935604,
-0.03651639074087143,
-0.014311644248664379,
0.009954339824616909,
0.06611774116754532,
-0.023397071287035942,
-0.05229544639587402,
-0.04819440841674805,
-0.02459236979484558,
-0.15076616406440735,
-0.017683120444417,
0.008466873317956924,
0.01883864961564541,
-0.010738356038928032,
0.01998806931078434,
-0.036412350833415985,
0.02089099772274494,
-0.033081769943237305,
0.009637932293117046,
0.004456713330000639,
-0.04639541357755661,
-0.024658197537064552,
0.01360349077731371,
-0.0012459392892196774,
-0.00485946424305439,
-0.015672748908400536,
0.011041602119803429,
-0.0025565961841493845,
-0.008242262527346611,
-0.012535160407423973,
-0.024778662249445915,
0.047800227999687195,
-0.011303612031042576,
0.02362874150276184,
0.009245682507753372,
-0.009219430387020111,
-0.0023942524567246437,
-0.03916766867041588,
0.03475182130932808,
-0.002547201933339238,
0.01567893661558628,
-0.023722685873508453,
0.004301088862121105,
0.0009667163249105215,
0.029835309833288193,
0.06425896286964417,
-0.05157412588596344,
-0.016262447461485863,
-0.020479455590248108,
0.01011121179908514,
0.07075582444667816,
-0.0036805253475904465,
0.03980875015258789,
-0.014906644821166992,
-0.006981654092669487,
0.0009241420193575323,
-0.026005402207374573,
0.016619380563497543,
0.009561420418322086,
-0.00946055818349123,
0.017224865034222603,
-0.006256187334656715,
-0.03657897189259529,
0.0029349331744015217,
-0.017249559983611107,
0.06063343212008476,
0.005423371680080891,
-0.04070735350251198,
-0.034394267946481705,
-0.012897759675979614,
-0.08086244761943817,
-0.017434341832995415,
-0.0032113033812493086,
-0.013235410675406456,
-0.023954767733812332,
-0.005200904794037342,
-0.01667851023375988,
0.044567566365003586,
0.0199732705950737,
0.00717912707477808,
-0.011228776536881924,
-0.021274592727422714,
0.011497598141431808,
0.0009527318179607391,
0.055008821189403534,
-0.04977310448884964,
0.029799140989780426,
-0.013611522503197193,
-0.08038467913866043,
0.04565980285406113,
0.028133945539593697,
-0.01127006858587265,
-0.007913360372185707,
0.005277435760945082,
0.02499178797006607,
0.03111795336008072,
0.01016558613628149,
0.00711996341124177,
0.23631873726844788,
0.022696955129504204,
-0.005835369229316711,
0.010003606788814068,
0.012676170095801353,
-0.027076829224824905,
0.021616386249661446,
0.05216934531927109,
0.005661608185619116,
-0.05133030191063881,
-0.01459211390465498,
-0.005624251905828714,
0.011592159979045391,
0.030821308493614197,
-0.03179455175995827,
0.021972758695483208,
-0.032479431480169296,
-0.015417885035276413,
0.08274215459823608,
-0.010427108965814114,
0.03075324557721615,
-0.0074605802074074745,
-0.0032814093865454197,
0.0240463949739933,
-0.024029752239584923,
-0.024723626673221588,
0.02392868511378765,
0.0630163624882698,
-0.03639746829867363,
0.016935216262936592,
-0.02212384156882763,
-0.00403522327542305,
0.0558156743645668,
-0.013221953064203262,
-0.011380212381482124,
0.008343758061528206,
-0.03613578528165817,
0.00918638613075018,
-0.004647247027605772,
0.04271889850497246,
0.005963009316474199,
-0.030104471370577812,
-0.006244816817343235,
-0.06257598847150803,
-0.017554443329572678,
0.011250331066548824,
-0.01400948315858841,
0.03540365397930145,
-0.0007812721887603402,
0.026207314804196358,
0.004833454266190529,
0.03526954725384712,
0.0026042871177196503,
-0.03317250683903694,
-0.011115376837551594,
0.03136123716831207,
-0.02023133635520935,
0.014260321855545044,
-0.016512755304574966,
0.04274136945605278,
-0.01552015170454979,
0.04001826420426369,
0.003953307867050171,
0.04578705132007599,
-0.011148511432111263,
-0.002667658496648073,
-0.06625457853078842,
-0.005355618428438902,
0.09666641056537628,
0.017977610230445862,
0.06890778243541718,
0.04320400953292847,
0.007463238202035427,
-0.004509001970291138,
0.021655872464179993,
-0.009301752783358097,
-0.038943830877542496,
0.0019287816248834133,
-0.024908650666475296,
0.003809291636571288,
-0.037194084376096725,
-0.05372702702879906,
-0.03312338888645172,
0.027153315022587776,
0.005437515210360289,
-0.0023765123914927244,
-0.051193416118621826,
0.022478537634015083,
-0.013655195944011211,
-0.02274194173514843,
-0.008396550081670284,
-0.019492922350764275,
-0.006919579114764929,
-0.009480682201683521,
-0.0006097099394537508,
-0.009890523739159107,
0.019724883139133453,
-0.03561629727482796,
-0.023551277816295624,
-0.07879019528627396,
-0.0010456935269758105,
-0.0004630453186109662,
0.020149795338511467,
-0.00607164204120636,
0.02282225526869297,
0.02453569509088993,
-0.019154805690050125,
-0.0013535128673538566,
-0.06209713593125343,
0.003767511574551463,
0.0140495290979743,
0.017082806676626205,
-0.035617224872112274,
-0.0029099041130393744,
0.015155532397329807,
0.054835423827171326,
-0.029122142121195793,
0.05248922482132912,
0.025676796212792397,
0.0544305182993412,
0.01881774142384529,
0.008068317547440529,
-0.05279109254479408,
0.02590472623705864,
-0.015324119478464127,
0.001003095181658864,
-0.01826287806034088,
-0.0009658068302087486,
0.0007484276429750025,
-0.002950803143903613,
-0.004472419153898954,
-0.007443353068083525,
-0.02161313407123089,
0.017045095562934875,
0.06378781795501709,
0.025857241824269295,
0.010159597732126713,
-0.01134693156927824,
-0.048039086163043976,
0.013407086953520775,
-0.05064864084124565,
0.007229652255773544,
-0.01947212778031826,
-0.006685128901153803,
0.0207821074873209,
0.003953329287469387,
-0.07828684896230698,
0.03141380101442337,
-0.03893854841589928,
-0.00812605582177639,
0.019058268517255783,
0.004643870051950216,
-0.03902552276849747,
-0.048400793224573135,
-0.013643255457282066,
-0.01494026742875576,
-0.002745821373537183,
-0.004299495834857225,
0.03830733895301819,
-0.02573302388191223,
-0.011738034896552563,
0.03919067606329918,
-0.0012124435743317008,
0.014671096578240395,
0.004838071297854185,
0.05295512452721596,
-0.005093386862426996,
0.04025745764374733,
0.014513167552649975,
-0.024614430963993073,
-0.0283511895686388,
-0.05483721196651459,
-0.010283251293003559,
0.04327619448304176,
0.0015382441924884915,
0.010879374109208584,
0.022821860387921333,
0.02221924439072609,
-0.017749948427081108,
-0.05271073430776596,
0.020051414147019386,
0.00417278753593564,
-0.031090082600712776,
0.00815093144774437,
-0.010239352472126484,
-0.0009506501373834908,
-0.007565618492662907,
-0.014149116352200508,
0.06919913738965988,
-0.06791962683200836,
-0.016984105110168457,
0.08654492348432541,
-0.005638475064188242,
-0.002287080278620124,
-0.019327672198414803,
0.013622885569930077,
-0.00849983561784029,
0.04278848320245743,
-0.011490165255963802,
-0.055745821446180344,
0.00308196316473186,
-0.012055310420691967,
0.007440235931426287,
0.0031485389918088913,
0.01608172617852688,
0.0188454482704401,
-0.040315769612789154,
0.018954545259475708,
-0.03712593391537666,
-0.04066000133752823,
0.015091100707650185,
0.011391839943826199,
-0.05633953586220741,
0.02172740548849106,
-0.01916034333407879,
-0.009534712880849838,
0.016467422246932983,
0.05346789211034775,
0.03728660196065903,
-0.04386156052350998,
-0.02730153314769268,
-0.024984359741210938,
0.03447503596544266,
-0.09397267550230026,
-0.026022858917713165,
0.002464679069817066,
-0.04270109534263611,
0.018151769414544106,
-0.014442733488976955,
-0.004880943801254034,
0.00030143934418447316,
-0.0773792713880539,
0.07079624384641647,
-0.07958368957042694,
-0.004687153734266758,
-0.020199958235025406,
0.034062258899211884,
-0.004620646126568317,
0.019108572974801064,
0.016705920919775963,
0.029146019369363785,
-0.041195839643478394,
0.02596464194357395,
0.033646225929260254,
0.004139801021665335,
-0.010462237522006035,
-0.015000860206782818,
0.009029781445860863,
0.023812098428606987,
0.05219697579741478,
0.005226484965533018,
0.005385612603276968,
0.0031241776887327433,
-0.033231984823942184,
0.03136742115020752,
0.017368163913488388,
0.04210205376148224,
-0.04193345457315445,
-0.08167847245931625,
-0.023286284878849983,
-0.00448624650016427,
0.03830057382583618,
-0.008958113379776478,
-0.018397480249404907,
-0.05880631506443024,
-0.03617174178361893,
0.01572449691593647,
-0.032137393951416016,
-0.03235439583659172,
-0.02522161230444908,
0.0030966089107096195,
-0.007112592924386263,
-0.01689765602350235,
0.004728257656097412,
-0.014753925614058971,
-0.015846971422433853,
-0.00013906189997214824,
0.031099505722522736,
0.016306806355714798,
0.015095530077815056,
0.01246173307299614,
-0.00827739667147398,
0.028864622116088867,
-0.000020058127120137215,
-0.006491074804216623,
0.022425057366490364,
-0.015360252000391483,
0.0030376678332686424,
-0.0017566460883244872,
-0.0020720220636576414,
0.004796439781785011,
-0.004405048675835133,
-0.037217941135168076,
0.021270062774419785,
0.010162437334656715,
-0.009201336652040482,
-0.0042726644314825535,
0.03758666291832924,
-0.007297575939446688,
0.02313726209104061,
-0.028370019048452377,
-0.004184219986200333,
-0.04844547063112259,
-0.045459140092134476,
-0.05939708277583122,
0.0035951007157564163,
0.031017597764730453,
0.023074951022863388,
0.010754375718533993,
0.024206457659602165,
0.014012550003826618,
-0.07704541832208633,
0.02159358561038971,
-0.04258223995566368,
0.017731036990880966,
0.002792485523968935,
-0.009610302746295929,
-0.020641736686229706,
-0.019161123782396317,
-0.005192046985030174,
0.02094825729727745,
0.010624970309436321,
-0.05709204077720642,
-0.0008231882238760591,
-0.043257419019937515,
-0.015298529528081417,
0.03748991712927818,
-0.042932216078042984,
-0.033662643283605576,
0.00018980016466230154,
0.0025154962204396725,
-0.020535647869110107,
-0.0020183674059808254,
-0.027074633166193962,
0.06561898440122604,
0.036214325577020645,
-0.025126876309514046,
-0.0031071617268025875,
0.024685725569725037,
-0.04789583384990692,
0.0047456989996135235,
-0.07546157389879227,
0.07478317618370056,
-0.01459283847361803,
-0.0179203599691391,
0.025192193686962128,
-0.013389903120696545,
-0.0149049898609519,
-0.010837105102837086,
0.012159446254372597,
-0.03343043848872185,
-0.0075909290462732315,
-0.016251936554908752,
-0.05287651717662811,
-0.010662583634257317,
-0.023172177374362946,
0.0168357752263546,
0.04121072217822075,
-0.008901827968657017,
-0.01622435636818409,
-0.01127772219479084,
0.04609732702374458,
0.03613746538758278,
0.0024397068191319704,
0.008445692248642445,
-0.020181426778435707,
0.0139138950034976,
0.019232261925935745,
0.01443153154104948,
-0.00255730957724154,
-0.004555110819637775,
-0.015983333811163902,
0.020392492413520813,
0.006961252074688673,
-0.04129427298903465,
0.028741175308823586,
0.01936008408665657,
0.04871823638677597,
-0.013476621359586716,
-0.022395923733711243,
-0.024280285462737083,
-0.02569698542356491,
-0.022178955376148224,
-0.004757337272167206,
0.02708020806312561,
-0.012768286280333996,
0.00890218187123537,
0.01007593423128128,
0.005627508740872145,
0.019593991339206696,
-0.021148137748241425,
0.0057359482161700726,
-0.006970126181840897,
-0.025079259648919106,
-0.1390158236026764,
-0.032049622386693954,
0.00949740782380104,
-0.021025754511356354,
-0.017269743606448174,
-0.010861464776098728,
-0.012645543552935123,
-0.003961256239563227,
-0.03720084950327873,
0.0068609025329351425,
0.0018234471790492535,
-0.0404687337577343,
0.04144825413823128,
-0.02620634064078331,
-0.032122306525707245,
0.02848493866622448,
-0.06297844648361206,
0.004413087852299213,
-0.050670284777879715,
-0.008684555068612099,
0.01056456845253706,
0.000014250806088966783,
-0.04624253511428833,
-0.02954254299402237,
0.0068032993003726006,
0.0050241113640367985,
-0.005884897895157337,
-0.03890380635857582,
-0.028041474521160126,
-0.043726060539484024,
0.010808952152729034,
-0.043003376573324203,
-0.01762544736266136,
0.06351450085639954,
-0.0004754288529511541,
0.004426260944455862,
0.0129935871809721,
0.020929059013724327,
0.0016133530298247933,
-0.02095400169491768,
-0.01978236436843872,
0.03867858275771141,
-0.037777964025735855,
-0.01719455048441887,
0.01539530698210001,
0.02242458425462246,
-0.011083356104791164,
0.005679868161678314,
-0.06160934269428253,
-0.028630904853343964,
-0.04736786708235741,
0.0320010632276535,
0.015564926899969578,
0.05734068155288696,
-0.014863496646285057,
0.0006643736269325018,
-0.011110182851552963,
-0.004373814910650253,
0.01619352400302887,
0.05515312775969505,
0.010342170484364033,
0.0074174730107188225,
-0.022806348279118538,
0.0007984955445863307,
-0.010407223366200924,
0.012452599592506886,
-0.05205538496375084,
-0.0025326721370220184,
-0.0015569445677101612,
-0.008738142438232899,
0.0035961780231446028,
0.034283801913261414,
-0.0016896355664357543,
-0.03851207345724106,
0.00226860074326396,
-0.01776053197681904,
0.016440851613879204,
0.013919086195528507,
-0.06483658403158188,
-0.015912620350718498,
-0.04942912608385086,
-0.013564571738243103,
-0.031055008992552757,
-0.010416282340884209,
0.06111247465014458,
0.014212122187018394,
-0.015386346727609634,
-0.030816450715065002,
0.001602630945853889,
-0.026884667575359344,
-0.04662018641829491,
-0.01364702358841896,
0.013381063006818295,
0.02199777401983738,
0.015457331202924252,
0.025977065786719322,
-0.01850341074168682,
0.010805714875459671,
-0.009557798504829407,
0.00506726885214448,
-0.06008350849151611,
-0.014809440821409225,
0.03176780790090561,
-0.008572975173592567,
-0.019782058894634247,
-0.008304091170430183,
0.030347635969519615,
-0.004291099030524492,
0.015336327254772186,
-0.03995916619896889,
-0.0007956477347761393,
-0.02395070344209671,
-0.0708165243268013,
0.06422660499811172,
-0.057179760187864304,
-0.0021739043295383453,
0.0015265463152900338,
0.02174379862844944,
0.027113866060972214,
-0.012901914305984974,
0.004975484684109688,
0.0007478802581317723,
0.006465310230851173,
-0.0282482597976923,
0.02920927107334137,
-0.02696659415960312,
0.0777243822813034,
0.04349008947610855,
0.015062077902257442,
-0.0007057792972773314,
0.041350554674863815,
-0.02588712051510811,
-0.014283332042396069,
0.021692462265491486,
-0.013799245469272137,
-0.008363463915884495,
-0.012393171899020672,
-0.0008075594087131321,
-0.011412753723561764,
0.007535250391811132,
-0.02846517041325569,
0.008779261261224747,
-0.029426652938127518,
0.013884139247238636,
-0.037581104785203934,
0.009479143656790257,
0.05230838432908058,
-0.013277187012135983,
-0.014702786691486835,
-0.019147876650094986,
-0.002240834990516305,
0.013706566765904427,
-0.0011308153625577688,
0.01803145557641983,
0.011317474767565727,
-0.013023926876485348,
0.04920215904712677,
-0.005701880436390638,
0.027550963684916496,
0.014604438096284866,
0.02076425589621067,
-0.06024792045354843,
-0.030874308198690414,
-0.006529979407787323,
-0.019378192722797394,
0.03371042385697365,
-0.012985522858798504,
0.004479120951145887,
-0.03370233625173569,
-0.0245173592120409,
-0.011453263461589813,
0.020861361175775528,
-0.03966827318072319,
-0.011864723637700081,
0.04342013970017433,
-0.005787130445241928,
-0.011295709758996964,
-0.01496084313839674,
0.06007575988769531,
-0.02855338528752327,
0.038001686334609985,
0.034421052783727646,
0.01905505545437336,
-0.03722436726093292,
-0.010068373754620552,
0.029251379892230034,
0.020143529400229454,
0.013183298520743847,
-0.017641758546233177,
-0.027028601616621017,
-0.04036708548665047,
-0.026966959238052368,
0.032496094703674316,
-0.01692022942006588,
-0.014641710557043552,
0.02387341856956482,
-0.010914552956819534,
0.02979857474565506,
0.018694883212447166,
0.015129569917917252,
0.02197396382689476,
-0.01682182028889656,
-0.010699441656470299,
-0.032954297959804535,
-0.014185524545609951,
0.013361452147364616,
-0.03164733946323395,
-0.057271040976047516,
-0.02202954702079296,
0.04946030676364899,
-0.010989672504365444,
0.017223183065652847,
-0.007040456868708134,
0.02015157975256443,
-0.00028394180117174983,
0.03055940568447113,
0.05048122629523277,
-0.0050438703037798405,
0.018163038417696953,
-0.027379373088479042,
0.026443148031830788,
0.03175003081560135,
-0.00885277334600687,
-0.03719017654657364,
-0.0031588885467499495,
-0.006838231347501278,
-0.02141517400741577,
0.0179758183658123,
0.005429149139672518,
0.02662988379597664,
0.02043442241847515,
-0.013986299745738506,
-0.012179659679532051,
0.028671251609921455,
-0.010970205068588257,
-0.036860112100839615,
-0.002064700936898589,
-0.0121972830966115,
-0.024261686950922012,
-0.01994783990085125,
0.055478401482105255,
0.016280151903629303,
0.01631801389157772,
0.004488447681069374
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:16
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
84, 85); but there is a dictum of Lindley L.J. which is distinct enough: '. . . nor have I the slightest doubt that a consent order can be impeached, not only on the ground of fraud but upon any grounds which invalidate the agreement it expresses in a more formal way than usual .
. . To my mind the only question is whether the agreement on which the consent order was based can be invalidated or not. Of course if that agreement cannot be invalidated the consent order is good': Huddersfield Banking Co. Ltd. v. Henry Lister & Son Ltd." (emphasis added)
221The Supreme Court's inherent power to set aside a judgment entered by consent is exercisable by reference to the principles as laid down in Harvey v Phillips: Singh v Ginelle Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 310, per Campbell JA at [35] (Beazley JA and Handley AJA agreeing).
This power was also referred to by Handley JA in his judgment in Spies v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1991) 24 NSWLR 691 at 696G to 697C. In his text, Spencer Bower and Handley, Res Judicata (2009), his Honour at p 244 [17.04] cited this decision (and Harvey v Phillips) as authority for the proposition that a judgment:-
"... entered by consent (...) can be set aside on any ground, including fraud, on which a court can set aside a contract." (at 192)
222I have been referred to the decision in Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd v Heperu Pty Ltd & Ors [No 2] (2009) 78 NSWLR 190. That case concerned an application to set aside a judgment that had been entered after a hearing on the merits.
The application was based on additional or fresh evidence that had become available, based on which allegations of misrepresentations prior to and at the trial had been made. It was not contended that the misrepresentations were fraudulent.
223The Court of Appeal (Allsop P, Campbell JA and Handley AJA) made reference to the Court's power to set aside a judgment procured by fraud (discussed above) and continued:-
"There is no support in the decided cases for holding that perfected orders can be set aside for innocent misrepresentation."
224The plaintiffs submit, and I accept, that that statement must be read in the context of that case, in which there had been a judgment after a hearing on the merits.
I do not think the Court intended to express a principle applicable to consent orders (perfected or otherwise), because, as demonstrated above, the decided cases do support the proposition that consent orders can be set aside for innocent misrepresentation - on the basis of the equitable jurisdiction to set aside contracts for innocent misrepresentation.
Some of those cases were decided by Campbell JA and Handley AJA.
225The Court of Appeal (Macfarlan and Whealy JJA) in Connectland Pty Ltd v Cardno Forbes Rigby Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 391 at [5] has recently referred to Harvey v Phillips in dismissing an application for leave to appeal against a consent judgment said to have been induced by a misrepresentation.
The Court concluded at [6] that the applicant did not have an arguable case that the representation relied on was erroneous. It was not suggested by the Court that the applicant would need to show fraud to succeed in the appeal.
226Consequently I accept that, fraud, and more particularly fraudulent misrepresentation, is not required to be shown in order to enliven the inherent power described in Harvey v Phillips.
The passage from that case extracted above reveals that it is the status of the agreement which determines the status of a consent order reflecting or manifesting that agreement. As Lindley LJ observed in the Huddersfield Banking case referred to by the High Court in Harvey v Phillips, the consent order is simply a formal manifestation of the agreement.
227The relevant principle does not discriminate between the means by which the agreement may be invalidated. The material consideration is whether or not the agreement is to be invalidated. Once it is, then the consent is liable to be set aside.
|
[
-0.03311537578701973,
0.03709658607840538,
-0.001136592123657465,
0.007794477976858616,
0.009513485245406628,
-0.04691442847251892,
-0.0070075662806630135,
-0.020932745188474655,
0.022165745496749878,
0.017669426277279854,
0.0037544264923781157,
0.018865494057536125,
-0.020255843177437782,
0.018014956265687943,
-0.02211564965546131,
-0.004226672928780317,
0.02527575194835663,
-0.0082627572119236,
-0.025513622909784317,
0.0029462813399732113,
-0.04106207937002182,
0.0012403827859088778,
-0.0020355789456516504,
0.0007305826293304563,
0.024470532312989235,
0.04239828139543533,
0.016003921627998352,
0.023136664181947708,
-0.014372598379850388,
-0.031075624749064445,
-0.018010200932621956,
0.016960840672254562,
0.0396454855799675,
0.014854916371405125,
0.027646401897072792,
-0.012633352540433407,
-0.0010451662819832563,
-0.012635706923902035,
-0.012518919073045254,
-0.014291609637439251,
-0.018687624484300613,
0.02136511541903019,
0.004083407577127218,
-0.0525357723236084,
0.0478220097720623,
-0.0018860343843698502,
0.0010268882615491748,
-0.020605815574526787,
0.001528169377706945,
0.03109016641974449,
-0.06023649126291275,
0.01579897478222847,
0.10594017803668976,
-0.019963959231972694,
-0.03209036588668823,
0.04862063005566597,
-0.016753049567341805,
0.014666697941720486,
-0.04945656657218933,
-0.004727101884782314,
0.01637502759695053,
-0.01957722380757332,
-0.10109489411115646,
-0.0020806051325052977,
0.0360964871942997,
0.015534610487520695,
-0.01894858479499817,
-0.008850730024278164,
-0.018668172881007195,
-0.015577675774693489,
-0.021428406238555908,
0.06541766226291656,
-0.021222025156021118,
0.022039277479052544,
-0.08568313717842102,
0.03156514838337898,
0.008321146480739117,
0.019302016124129295,
0.03759879246354103,
0.0018452617805451155,
-0.00018945692863781005,
-0.03846601024270058,
-0.037836406379938126,
0.014599794521927834,
-0.02387346141040325,
-0.005391570273786783,
0.00561629980802536,
0.013154411688446999,
0.02158455364406109,
0.019617874175310135,
0.033199895173311234,
0.007205468136817217,
0.03866538405418396,
-0.031953975558280945,
0.0007197323720902205,
-0.004033513832837343,
-0.061896007508039474,
0.027372730895876884,
-0.010460495948791504,
0.03382883593440056,
0.033187754452228546,
-0.010586820542812347,
0.017876645550131798,
-0.016064874827861786,
-0.03269992768764496,
0.02945753186941147,
0.020393921062350273,
0.05601728707551956,
0.07075925916433334,
0.008576227352023125,
0.017681021243333817,
-0.04321596398949623,
0.03869730606675148,
0.02022874914109707,
-0.03034711256623268,
-0.0075202458538115025,
0.030350297689437866,
0.011254262179136276,
0.010254522785544395,
0.023258421570062637,
-0.02387571893632412,
0.051974810659885406,
0.03664432838559151,
0.023548131808638573,
-0.053846925497055054,
0.007939583621919155,
0.021242473274469376,
0.028834333643317223,
-0.05269695818424225,
0.023143557831645012,
0.0066289291717112064,
-0.015442224219441414,
-0.015099575743079185,
-0.015248923562467098,
-0.015248017385601997,
0.008249144069850445,
0.03942012041807175,
0.01403898000717163,
-0.017402702942490578,
-0.0660301148891449,
0.06662806123495102,
0.004907058551907539,
0.0578390508890152,
-0.019307930022478104,
-0.021153492853045464,
-0.034771230071783066,
0.04670422524213791,
-0.014655038714408875,
0.029590992256999016,
-0.010334517806768417,
0.016109973192214966,
0.028092991560697556,
0.014007828198373318,
-0.024920661002397537,
0.028023026883602142,
-0.07118196040391922,
0.03456921502947807,
0.014262649230659008,
0.04091326519846916,
0.04457248002290726,
-0.014828892424702644,
0.03882885351777077,
-0.03431818261742592,
0.03232862055301666,
0.037603456526994705,
-0.016446823254227638,
0.018421102315187454,
-0.011816300451755524,
-0.01642518863081932,
-0.06457380950450897,
0.03870709240436554,
-0.019844256341457367,
0.004530261270701885,
-0.024160604923963547,
0.026920082047581673,
0.028553660959005356,
0.033178675919771194,
0.023936765268445015,
-0.03846196085214615,
0.007068947423249483,
-0.027299700304865837,
0.0016369200311601162,
0.007521864492446184,
-0.008669650182127953,
-0.06042232736945152,
0.031127678230404854,
0.012447194196283817,
-0.0199042409658432,
0.024925291538238525,
0.01808014325797558,
-0.03401462361216545,
-0.02502831444144249,
0.025537606328725815,
0.04894348233938217,
0.04207535460591316,
-0.03203996643424034,
-0.006443785969167948,
-0.01856645755469799,
0.01422082632780075,
0.01130674872547388,
-0.048685964196920395,
0.05068052560091019,
0.03695300221443176,
-0.0350339449942112,
-0.024108638986945152,
-0.016338907182216644,
-0.05356990545988083,
0.012367074377834797,
0.016641812399029732,
-0.014803389087319374,
0.006635347381234169,
-0.006018904037773609,
-0.01277900580316782,
0.011814429424703121,
0.009877408854663372,
0.0002899960381910205,
-0.02792089432477951,
0.0026333739515393972,
-0.011044844053685665,
-0.0041872188448905945,
-0.009004203602671623,
0.010722492821514606,
-0.006288438569754362,
0.0245958361774683,
0.013705232180655003,
0.04384529963135719,
-0.05038735643029213,
0.04006148502230644,
0.018821390345692635,
-0.004621215630322695,
0.0309214536100626,
-0.015260576270520687,
0.069272480905056,
-0.042191874235868454,
-0.0033596144057810307,
0.017099644988775253,
0.008834261447191238,
0.039573680609464645,
0.028295239433646202,
0.00303566362708807,
-0.04394390806555748,
-0.023679180070757866,
0.05546833947300911,
-0.030873998999595642,
-0.007072966080158949,
-0.0011428124271333218,
0.015418165363371372,
-0.03618709370493889,
0.008127381093800068,
-0.037116847932338715,
-0.020755738019943237,
0.012029393576085567,
-0.013089326210319996,
0.039751071482896805,
0.02021012268960476,
0.010651864111423492,
-0.017713798210024834,
0.008239616639912128,
0.03595782071352005,
0.008295485749840736,
-0.005783614236861467,
-0.009977287612855434,
0.038779549300670624,
-0.005397495348006487,
0.01199287548661232,
-0.01842835731804371,
0.00021589013340417296,
-0.02665388211607933,
0.00238855741918087,
-0.023929262533783913,
0.011178245767951012,
-0.008230303414165974,
0.009379517287015915,
0.02297401987016201,
0.005729104392230511,
0.04933029040694237,
0.05384589359164238,
-0.04347939044237137,
0.05331625044345856,
0.004389101639389992,
0.013915433548390865,
0.0026390706188976765,
0.04284356161952019,
-0.006667877547442913,
0.030017487704753876,
-0.0028998376801609993,
-0.04523623362183571,
-0.04133229702711105,
-0.008276797831058502,
-0.036655914038419724,
0.039093878120183945,
-0.0005591368535533547,
0.06031152606010437,
0.017267374321818352,
-0.07236238569021225,
-0.026438448578119278,
0.004923056811094284,
-0.13740116357803345,
0.019529804587364197,
0.005840831436216831,
-0.007662750314921141,
-0.0026891687884926796,
0.02697388082742691,
-0.020982742309570312,
0.0265725776553154,
-0.009162254631519318,
0.002361716702580452,
0.01766948215663433,
-0.06083560734987259,
-0.03604595363140106,
0.006088878493756056,
0.03204978257417679,
-0.0077295005321502686,
-0.008370053954422474,
0.013775702565908432,
0.014969153329730034,
-0.035811878740787506,
0.0020099750254303217,
-0.052275221794843674,
0.038806259632110596,
-0.01699739694595337,
0.02975129336118698,
0.025926683098077774,
-0.0387364961206913,
-0.016306832432746887,
-0.02781784161925316,
-0.011792891658842564,
-0.023442771285772324,
0.036047905683517456,
-0.02336770109832287,
0.020545167848467827,
0.03737930580973625,
0.012311027385294437,
0.06147366017103195,
-0.08857589215040207,
0.025014284998178482,
-0.0355747826397419,
0.014408309943974018,
0.03592969477176666,
-0.004740364849567413,
0.05059180036187172,
0.0014529195614159107,
-0.01148107461631298,
0.036791007965803146,
0.013630601577460766,
-0.01575528271496296,
0.01447327621281147,
0.0013980998191982508,
-0.017128800973296165,
-0.03614155948162079,
0.00019533347222022712,
-0.014151397161185741,
-0.04072894901037216,
0.06000329926609993,
0.048010725528001785,
-0.006585827562958002,
0.0033816369250416756,
-0.03674677386879921,
-0.039395254105329514,
0.014901774935424328,
-0.006877046078443527,
-0.04271875321865082,
-0.02742225117981434,
0.007662692107260227,
-0.006767921149730682,
0.019202660769224167,
-0.017132006585597992,
0.009963512420654297,
0.001658075489103794,
0.0004684411396738142,
-0.009449323639273643,
-0.007314916700124741,
-0.008713501505553722,
0.037250764667987823,
-0.019536249339580536,
-0.01596660725772381,
-0.06382427364587784,
-0.003971420228481293,
0.009349179454147816,
-0.05753505229949951,
0.03225615620613098,
-0.04060547798871994,
0.010446708649396896,
0.02719305083155632,
-0.010292657651007175,
0.030712440609931946,
0.232285276055336,
0.036655645817518234,
-0.00013739067071583122,
0.013383232988417149,
0.018244793638586998,
-0.012741903774440289,
0.03754604607820511,
0.04112494736909866,
0.010609190911054611,
-0.016896691173315048,
0.022839276120066643,
-0.033654309809207916,
0.00034959736512973905,
0.04130206257104874,
-0.03795159235596657,
0.0210916418582201,
-0.03175262361764908,
-0.005908864084631205,
0.06933648884296417,
-0.015375816263258457,
0.05303460359573364,
-0.004009518306702375,
0.0400882363319397,
0.03456086665391922,
-0.04371671378612518,
-0.009882374666631222,
0.034027647227048874,
-0.004433769732713699,
-0.0043714153580367565,
-0.0070954542607069016,
-0.03552411124110222,
0.013643602840602398,
0.035379573702812195,
-0.052024632692337036,
0.017042551189661026,
-0.014181866310536861,
-0.0014595744432881474,
0.011477001942694187,
-0.0384829007089138,
0.05297732725739479,
0.038323499262332916,
-0.012813787907361984,
-0.022196240723133087,
-0.003379954257979989,
0.007439688313752413,
0.007847204804420471,
-0.00375115848146379,
-0.02466277778148651,
0.00010532285523368046,
0.006689792964607477,
-0.04461931437253952,
-0.00895319040864706,
-0.02618447318673134,
0.012543447315692902,
-0.05985754728317261,
0.021515995264053345,
-0.02789437025785446,
0.057864606380462646,
-0.005945985205471516,
0.07377882301807404,
0.024506347253918648,
0.01384285930544138,
-0.015359016135334969,
0.04401915892958641,
0.00040263670962303877,
0.014754582196474075,
-0.048726826906204224,
-0.02180585451424122,
0.03876323252916336,
0.026665393263101578,
0.058580148965120316,
0.017435533925890923,
0.03189997375011444,
0.044389739632606506,
0.047312650829553604,
-0.006834584753960371,
-0.02720690332353115,
0.02903865836560726,
-0.01118399016559124,
-0.030389780178666115,
-0.02075253054499626,
-0.004533835221081972,
0.017650872468948364,
0.040399324148893356,
0.005369569640606642,
0.00252367346547544,
-0.02594156377017498,
0.05454867333173752,
0.024761103093624115,
-0.013333261013031006,
-0.03036758489906788,
0.014343802817165852,
-0.03994882106781006,
0.059052590280771255,
-0.013187520205974579,
0.017150284722447395,
0.0052080536261200905,
-0.019285406917333603,
-0.014776702038943768,
0.025759680196642876,
-0.02075187861919403,
-0.015837321057915688,
0.025656327605247498,
-0.07127004861831665,
0.032564032822847366,
-0.0076474291272461414,
0.028251785784959793,
0.001031740801408887,
0.000992556568235159,
0.02091100439429283,
0.006679433863610029,
-0.010711980983614922,
-0.032207030802965164,
-0.023261073976755142,
0.019567186012864113,
0.06929176300764084,
-0.037127118557691574,
0.04546204209327698,
0.052861716598272324,
0.06115907058119774,
-0.04113330692052841,
0.02248057723045349,
0.00676386384293437,
0.02510829269886017,
-0.012078765779733658,
-0.005549288354814053,
-0.053530141711235046,
0.016501592472195625,
0.037188105285167694,
0.011234068311750889,
0.016937725245952606,
-0.01747846230864525,
0.014691286720335484,
0.016298066824674606,
0.0379650741815567,
0.022970404475927353,
0.04532314091920853,
0.004020738881081343,
-0.01597871631383896,
0.03349357470870018,
0.004929265007376671,
0.009851389564573765,
0.01079350896179676,
0.012683786451816559,
0.03203383833169937,
-0.0033041606657207012,
-0.02383015677332878,
-0.0015240644570440054,
-0.0742168202996254,
0.013419965282082558,
-0.0011459516827017069,
0.01863287016749382,
-0.027882998809218407,
-0.03939702734351158,
-0.04040231928229332,
-0.0077538397163152695,
0.00945974700152874,
-0.02578977309167385,
0.01864507980644703,
-0.002978986594825983,
0.008530555292963982,
0.040157560259103775,
-0.01965194195508957,
0.036926236003637314,
0.02555306814610958,
0.04093422740697861,
-0.023682905361056328,
0.014947275631129742,
0.027809446677565575,
-0.02936951071023941,
-0.03738600015640259,
-0.04016996920108795,
-0.032700762152671814,
0.04649314284324646,
0.017173193395137787,
0.009437451139092445,
-0.007606131490319967,
0.01841583289206028,
0.05196290835738182,
-0.035428427159786224,
-0.00015516846906393766,
-0.015710145235061646,
-0.01850569248199463,
0.009381601586937904,
0.005656706169247627,
-0.03932710364460945,
-0.011534555815160275,
-0.03024694323539734,
0.04770231619477272,
-0.07625626772642136,
-0.04052476957440376,
0.07994097471237183,
-0.002981197787448764,
-0.03218620643019676,
0.007060690317302942,
0.015281541272997856,
0.0019981120713055134,
0.04938272759318352,
0.011875010095536709,
-0.05724514275789261,
0.030884619802236557,
-0.04689880087971687,
-0.019876353442668915,
0.024898182600736618,
-0.03322713449597359,
0.0015992801636457443,
-0.030852949246764183,
0.021815093234181404,
-0.02958240546286106,
-0.002968033542856574,
0.01222231239080429,
-0.0048895603977143764,
-0.0636182501912117,
0.014009682461619377,
0.015166250988841057,
0.001780076650902629,
0.020639043301343918,
0.03430958837270737,
0.00955850537866354,
-0.030036864802241325,
-0.019543906673789024,
-0.06425114721059799,
0.012703077867627144,
-0.085365429520607,
0.017954999580979347,
-0.0014496637741103768,
0.020165251567959785,
0.004085849039256573,
-0.003614333225414157,
-0.024134241044521332,
0.003842744743451476,
-0.026829754933714867,
0.04657676815986633,
0.017634408548474312,
-0.02278105728328228,
0.014564618468284607,
0.026259686797857285,
-0.001071898266673088,
0.020853236317634583,
0.009360799565911293,
-0.0023937842343002558,
0.009473944082856178,
0.05198206007480621,
0.00560308713465929,
0.00019827504002023488,
-0.021345429122447968,
0.02721386030316353,
0.006888582371175289,
0.03798786550760269,
0.00919343437999487,
-0.009656881913542747,
0.02222670242190361,
-0.00007340383308473974,
-0.03143266215920448,
-0.03581351786851883,
-0.022701475769281387,
0.006210502702742815,
-0.00995965301990509,
-0.07129164785146713,
0.00974364299327135,
0.01805342733860016,
0.02279597334563732,
0.024775784462690353,
-0.008450577035546303,
-0.002692442387342453,
-0.07201190292835236,
0.04474761709570885,
0.013338678516447544,
-0.04884326830506325,
-0.013352208770811558,
-0.018806124106049538,
-0.0062721301801502705,
-0.024216823279857635,
-0.01434294879436493,
0.03622697666287422,
0.0208467785269022,
0.00020768819376826286,
0.026660362258553505,
-0.016260115429759026,
-0.04906058311462402,
0.004118225071579218,
0.02104862779378891,
0.011400694027543068,
0.02606196515262127,
0.017436716705560684,
0.07866396754980087,
0.04304032027721405,
0.01076007355004549,
-0.024937046691775322,
-0.014518017880618572,
0.03888022154569626,
0.015034843236207962,
-0.02722274325788021,
-0.030511366203427315,
0.024463241919875145,
0.021225688979029655,
-0.003095577470958233,
0.028657620772719383,
-0.03037639521062374,
0.024704251438379288,
-0.0232546366751194,
-0.007180625572800636,
-0.008970959112048149,
-0.016312874853610992,
0.01869809813797474,
0.021497495472431183,
0.030053023248910904,
0.010524307377636433,
-0.0010499644558876753,
-0.00029417872428894043,
-0.004608955234289169,
-0.1127481609582901,
-0.025149600580334663,
0.012243125587701797,
0.036736827343702316,
-0.007772417273372412,
0.024016527459025383,
-0.010756336152553558,
-0.036073509603738785,
0.004157721064984798,
-0.01649370789527893,
0.00865547452121973,
-0.03506867215037346,
-0.06721575558185577,
-0.03746983781456947,
-0.004074786324054003,
-0.02547401189804077,
-0.07886077463626862,
-0.005423530470579863,
-0.013573093339800835,
-0.055320557206869125,
-0.014847407117486,
0.030504407361149788,
-0.030423181131482124,
0.012709155678749084,
0.05750918760895729,
-0.022755684331059456,
-0.015278891660273075,
0.047973357141017914,
-0.06552526354789734,
0.003954519052058458,
-0.09186694025993347,
0.05167706310749054,
-0.011758540757000446,
0.04116407409310341,
0.020727181807160378,
-0.018093805760145187,
-0.015377090312540531,
-0.024510154500603676,
0.006633989978581667,
-0.01935403421521187,
0.028182175010442734,
-0.02195385843515396,
-0.02830458991229534,
0.03838445246219635,
-0.005704442039132118,
0.04108178988099098,
0.027460306882858276,
0.014581715688109398,
-0.00011091258784290403,
-0.010699698701500893,
0.0003616575268097222,
0.02396504208445549,
-0.030246976763010025,
0.018345637246966362,
-0.01161240041255951,
-0.02846728079020977,
0.008198226802051067,
0.019445018842816353,
-0.008999126963317394,
0.030370954424142838,
-0.023168789222836494,
0.031016621738672256,
-0.049579136073589325,
-0.02192799746990204,
0.009295562282204628,
-0.0016179070807993412,
-0.00820399634540081,
-0.01739206723868847,
-0.006208973005414009,
0.01923426240682602,
-0.0070615424774587154,
-0.04560355097055435,
-0.014807452447712421,
-0.017899315804243088,
-0.0212242491543293,
-0.008891720324754715,
-0.008342226967215538,
-0.05638633668422699,
-0.02649093233048916,
-0.004452046938240528,
0.023598462343215942,
-0.03766434267163277,
0.013105805963277817,
-0.13190700113773346,
0.0017199697904288769,
0.012679794803261757,
0.011738249100744724,
-0.010984035208821297,
0.014239007607102394,
-0.03982013091444969,
0.018198495730757713,
-0.022319039329886436,
-0.05129462480545044,
-0.03495556861162186,
-0.04650982469320297,
-0.029470186680555344,
-0.027279406785964966,
-0.007787509821355343,
0.019315360113978386,
-0.026959335431456566,
-0.00928585510700941,
-0.021255074068903923,
-0.022751694545149803,
0.032448071986436844,
-0.010798979550600052,
-0.013833021745085716,
-0.019877268001437187,
0.00465289456769824,
-0.011337499134242535,
-0.019823094829916954,
-0.08126534521579742,
-0.032970573753118515,
-0.011437171138823032,
-0.040316756814718246,
-0.002820204244926572,
0.014567642472684383,
0.04161018878221512,
-0.011682959273457527,
-0.009527208283543587,
-0.011502441018819809,
-0.033667340874671936,
-0.05944288894534111,
-0.010791890323162079,
-0.011104412376880646,
0.029037687927484512,
-0.016453048214316368,
-0.023239973932504654,
-0.02152423933148384,
0.015094323083758354,
-0.032116156071424484,
-0.017234884202480316,
-0.01132738683372736,
-0.030005622655153275,
-0.052127655595541,
0.022517960518598557,
-0.004960690159350634,
0.03495481610298157,
0.023417308926582336,
0.012237888760864735,
-0.035486526787281036,
0.00786700937896967,
-0.010165928862988949,
0.05454019084572792,
0.004909677430987358,
0.005513529758900404,
-0.026469439268112183,
-0.01582927256822586,
0.012019269168376923,
0.0324799008667469,
-0.052791718393564224,
0.007711159996688366,
-0.01368043664842844,
0.02218220755457878,
-0.019771365448832512,
0.027573075145483017,
-0.03008507750928402,
-0.0022413271944969893,
0.011761280708014965,
0.01816461980342865,
0.012230489403009415,
-0.015889395028352737,
0.00017807877156883478,
-0.011454612016677856,
-0.04693744704127312,
-0.021077539771795273,
-0.051624082028865814,
0.012996481731534004,
0.022208990529179573,
0.01398443803191185,
-0.0265127494931221,
0.002192733809351921,
0.011201628483831882,
-0.03752172365784645,
-0.051064953207969666,
-0.005791094619780779,
0.01067623496055603,
0.06721228361129761,
-0.0013731750659644604,
-0.021758202463388443,
-0.002318236045539379,
0.015100299380719662,
-0.0261423047631979,
-0.025504659861326218,
-0.07003766298294067,
-0.015571288764476776,
0.05844194069504738,
-0.037405312061309814,
-0.048820849508047104,
0.022240906953811646,
-0.00753418542444706,
0.020367318764328957,
0.034324273467063904,
0.042215749621391296,
-0.03172225505113602,
-0.06184028089046478,
-0.0611267164349556,
-0.016098765656352043,
-0.029798947274684906,
0.02293701469898224,
-0.017649656161665916,
0.0030474390368908644,
-0.00006185991514939815,
-0.009381798096001148,
0.02945268340408802,
-0.019615383818745613,
0.013668281026184559,
-0.028566911816596985,
-0.03774359077215195,
0.033380672335624695,
0.042742349207401276,
0.008417882025241852,
0.06449944525957108,
-0.012426621280610561,
0.053491465747356415,
-0.036640558391809464,
-0.013074028305709362,
-0.0027004526928067207,
0.03819935396313667,
0.015384962782263756,
-0.04707716032862663,
0.012156995013356209,
-0.012566700577735901,
-0.07713659107685089,
0.008147260174155235,
-0.049128685146570206,
0.025219136849045753,
-0.014376339502632618,
-0.039866771548986435,
-0.009709919802844524,
0.03851945325732231,
-0.004848283249884844,
-0.020748652517795563,
-0.011000994592905045,
-0.0021259840577840805,
-0.001218023942783475,
0.007256056647747755,
0.0272050891071558,
0.060702309012413025,
-0.02831106446683407,
0.01536351814866066,
-0.008568004705011845,
-0.0060580032877624035,
0.030523376539349556,
0.006984262727200985,
0.026107443496584892,
-0.034200605005025864,
-0.03181498125195503,
-0.014702397398650646,
0.0062346807681024075,
-0.019575990736484528,
-0.001364738680422306,
0.020924802869558334,
0.0045439451932907104,
0.006609924603253603,
0.02545470930635929,
-0.02188277803361416,
-0.03591107204556465,
0.02766517736017704,
0.00022854990675114095,
-0.006428164895623922,
-0.05076264962553978,
0.02146305702626705,
-0.0287382323294878,
0.07074746489524841,
0.03489907830953598,
0.027938321232795715,
-0.008396083489060402,
-0.0339445061981678,
0.007696850690990686,
0.01823185198009014,
0.019446374848484993,
0.023337949067354202,
-0.030553482472896576,
-0.012566696852445602,
-0.0072762020863592625,
0.054669249802827835,
-0.010004866868257523,
0.015201890841126442,
-0.0013404145138338208,
-0.024390848353505135,
0.009418165311217308,
-0.016958488151431084,
0.03258290886878967,
0.021621666848659515,
-0.0523504763841629,
-0.05118544027209282,
-0.008634270168840885,
-0.042022913694381714,
-0.0011271111434325576,
0.021887633949518204,
-0.005477593280375004,
-0.036269284784793854,
0.02941248007118702,
-0.016224121674895287,
-0.014670894481241703,
-0.020113052800297737,
0.025847114622592926,
-0.010919488035142422,
-0.017029808834195137,
0.027583949267864227,
0.01221414189785719,
0.04127234220504761,
-0.0204938892275095,
0.0010910145938396454,
0.035040952265262604,
-0.04209500923752785,
-0.04958730190992355,
-0.02608274109661579,
-0.02304544858634472,
-0.028494130820035934,
-0.01714950241148472,
-0.005495344288647175,
0.0027924550231546164,
-0.02274860069155693,
-0.0036590283270925283,
-0.0007954539032652974,
0.038811564445495605,
0.016180114820599556,
-0.05276867002248764,
-0.02057223580777645,
-0.04551045596599579,
-0.06362918764352798,
-0.02584904618561268,
0.005887696053832769,
-0.01881648786365986,
-0.03490868955850601,
0.03280370682477951
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:60
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
883On 15 April 2005 Mr Zdrilic sent an email to Mr Renshall suggesting that money be deposited into the Sentel bank account. Mr Zdrilic, Mr Renshall and Mr Hickie had agreed, at the Sentel board meeting of 25 October 2004, to open that bank account. Mr Zdrilic's email appears to be a routine suggestion to keep the funds in the bank account.
884On 27 May 2005 Mr Zdrilic sent an email to HTT's accountant, Mr Bill Bartlett ("Mr Bartlett"), telling him that he was sending to him by express post some share and unit transfer forms in relation to HTT and the Huntley Trust.
Mr Zdrilic agreed that he did this for the purpose of having Mr Bartlett deal with the share and unit transfers from himself and Messrs Renshall and Hickie into Sentel. He agreed that this was for the purpose, in May 2005, of putting into effect some of the things required by the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed.
885In the email Mr Zdrilic also told Mr Bartlett that Sentel had recently exercised some options to acquire units in the Huntley Trust.
886On 30 June 2005 Mr Zdrilic wrote to Mr Renshall:-
"You may remember we were thinking of calling the directors meeting of [HTT]. There are still a few things to be sorted out to do with shares and units. I thought that perhaps you and I meet first and go over a few things including the latest on the funding situation to get rid of that high interest rate that we are paying.
If you are not making too much progress we should have a look at the people I know and how we could bring them in. However, as I said before we need to have our shares and units fixed up together with anything else that needs looking over before we can introduce these people..."
887Once again Mr Zdrilic was suggesting that he and Mr Renshall "sort out" details regarding the HTT shares and Huntley Trust units. He referred to the "funding situation" without complaint or assertion of prior misrepresentation or breach of agreement.
888On 21 July 2005 Mr Zdrilic made a note of a conversation with Mr Gillard. He said:-
"I rang B Gillard to talk to him about the fixing and bringing up to date shares and units in HTT."
889Mr Zdrilic recorded Mr Gillard as saying:-
"The best thing to do is to find the Funder and agree that somehow the Funder will buy all the small unit holders or at least most of them. (emphasis in original)"
890Mr Zdrilic's note continues:-
"He said no funder will come in unless they have 51% or more."
891This makes clear that, as at 21 July 2005, Mr Zdrilic was not only aware that no funder had "come in" but that no funder had yet acquired 51 per cent or more of the shares in HTT or units in the Huntley Trust.
These are the matters that were the subject of the representations complained of in these proceedings, notably the Eleventh Representation. Mr Zdrilic's note reveals that he knew that, as late as July 2005, the events the subject of these alleged representations had not come to pass.
892Almost a year later, on 30 June 2006, Mr Zdrilic attended a meeting of the directors of HTT. At that meeting Mr Zdrilic complained about the involvement of Mr Frederick and Mr Tugrul in HTT and said:-
"I do not want to come to meetings and have 3 people against me. I want to get involved and get swamped with the work."
893The "three people" to whom Mr Zdrilic was referring to were Messrs Renshall, Frederick and Tugrul. Nonetheless, Mr Zdrilic was expressing enthusiasm for getting "involved" and being "swamped with the work". Mr Einfeld described this statement as a "unequivocal affirmation" by Mr Zdrilic of the Heads of Agreement and Non-Dilution Deed. I agree.
894Mr Zdrilic made no complaint about the events of 2006 until a meeting of the directors of HTT on 16 August 2006. Even then, Mr Zdrilic's complainant was only in muted terms when he said to Mr Renshall and Mr Hickie:-
"Ok obviously it seems to me that you guys play the game pretty well when we came to the agreement. So this was all in the back of your minds."
|
[
-0.02972451038658619,
0.03809670731425285,
-0.023179810494184494,
0.011313560418784618,
-0.029626457020640373,
-0.057333193719387054,
0.02156328782439232,
-0.06621915847063065,
0.01064396370202303,
-0.0034135442692786455,
0.011802863329648972,
0.025352980941534042,
-0.029538866132497787,
0.0015141156036406755,
-0.020507216453552246,
-0.032733023166656494,
0.03685178980231285,
-0.03880683705210686,
0.00264050904661417,
-0.03708919510245323,
-0.010325750336050987,
-0.007154866121709347,
0.03822484612464905,
0.029205406084656715,
-0.04004442319273949,
0.015043959952890873,
-0.03461553528904915,
0.011377325281500816,
0.037064291536808014,
0.0303230918943882,
0.006450374610722065,
0.023044856265187263,
0.048885997384786606,
0.0081725362688303,
-0.007905848324298859,
-0.014140459708869457,
0.012801333330571651,
-0.008542259223759174,
-0.020284635946154594,
0.010794617235660553,
-0.02754594385623932,
0.020747428759932518,
0.019113821908831596,
-0.023086830973625183,
0.043267812579870224,
-0.03657698631286621,
-0.008874819613993168,
-0.012057210318744183,
0.01039883866906166,
0.04709147289395332,
-0.05293365195393562,
-0.04703599587082863,
0.05050412565469742,
-0.04069849103689194,
0.0033824474085122347,
-0.015597923658788204,
-0.037307653576135635,
0.013810055330395699,
-0.045798175036907196,
-0.013826455920934677,
0.01775605045258999,
0.008737767115235329,
-0.06367181241512299,
-0.003332753200083971,
-0.001717305975034833,
0.12516409158706665,
0.023483075201511383,
-0.012355873361229897,
-0.00613570399582386,
-0.016932906582951546,
-0.048947595059871674,
-0.010949437506496906,
-0.01167300995439291,
0.01201257947832346,
-0.08198929578065872,
0.026995137333869934,
0.04649565368890762,
-0.006243432871997356,
0.037904877215623856,
0.017328666523098946,
0.057582754641771317,
-0.04296722635626793,
-0.014588131569325924,
0.012867121957242489,
0.00429865438491106,
0.0039011873304843903,
-0.012748013250529766,
0.04493747279047966,
0.005839058663696051,
-0.01915023662149906,
0.016171326860785484,
0.016814587637782097,
0.01674952171742916,
-0.04509493708610535,
0.001115821418352425,
0.023253144696354866,
-0.05362142622470856,
0.04128681868314743,
-0.018970469012856483,
0.028604766353964806,
0.02350642904639244,
0.02028348110616207,
-0.042023032903671265,
-0.03182070329785347,
-0.0016157646896317601,
0.045052558183670044,
0.06869318336248398,
0.033921584486961365,
0.04062727466225624,
0.004285078961402178,
-0.009370345622301102,
0.015260649845004082,
0.007127464283257723,
0.01712631806731224,
-0.019298957660794258,
-0.02447402849793434,
-0.021502140909433365,
0.02197946608066559,
0.06251130253076553,
-0.005735395476222038,
0.04329174384474754,
0.02284448780119419,
0.02090076543390751,
-0.009857001714408398,
-0.06241072714328766,
-0.007573165465146303,
-0.00396595848724246,
-0.024740859866142273,
-0.021577831357717514,
0.02023153007030487,
0.003892007516697049,
0.016635436564683914,
0.00037195332697592676,
-0.047244295477867126,
0.01659252680838108,
0.02971663512289524,
0.0023911837488412857,
-0.004143277648836374,
0.022606559097766876,
-0.05670171603560448,
0.03779086098074913,
0.01860164664685726,
-0.00610033655539155,
-0.05946642532944679,
0.012519948184490204,
-0.00998456310480833,
-0.005502254702150822,
0.036000240594148636,
0.0024158121086657047,
0.05249427631497383,
0.01326658297330141,
0.0033939459826797247,
0.013837889768183231,
0.012632926926016808,
-0.02376440167427063,
-0.022334938868880272,
-0.00739716412499547,
-0.031454797834157944,
0.022646306082606316,
0.07618015259504318,
-0.004213721491396427,
0.022905517369508743,
-0.04285527393221855,
-0.03030344843864441,
-0.004862732253968716,
-0.0011992142535746098,
0.006157107651233673,
0.04431583359837532,
-0.019178055226802826,
0.009803496301174164,
0.004351035691797733,
-0.03194575011730194,
0.04828602820634842,
0.0024752386379987,
0.00838510598987341,
0.02677919529378414,
0.04924199730157852,
0.021447982639074326,
0.005215756595134735,
-0.03993634134531021,
-0.03359369561076164,
0.03878983482718468,
-0.0073954639956355095,
-0.025947144255042076,
-0.04849206283688545,
0.019685423001646996,
-0.03572877496480942,
-0.017239732667803764,
-0.006498866248875856,
0.026071494445204735,
-0.01360816415399313,
0.0007010757690295577,
0.045122984796762466,
0.031198211014270782,
0.01822579652070999,
-0.019584093242883682,
0.012120641767978668,
-0.03296108543872833,
-0.0039407978765666485,
-0.006411722395569086,
-0.025061624124646187,
0.04056243598461151,
0.0590612031519413,
-0.04625511169433594,
-0.030585715547204018,
0.01367125567048788,
-0.02459445595741272,
0.011533578857779503,
-0.004701277706772089,
-0.05851326510310173,
0.01885547675192356,
0.0006587288226000965,
-0.02384352684020996,
-0.02735128253698349,
0.028676792979240417,
-0.036641158163547516,
0.0054895952343940735,
-0.024797694757580757,
-0.012675120495259762,
-0.03855005279183388,
-0.01373325102031231,
0.02880328893661499,
0.0027948326896876097,
0.0002903936547227204,
0.017942549660801888,
0.013035725802183151,
-0.04193916916847229,
0.00815716665238142,
-0.016051992774009705,
-0.020542453974485397,
-0.009204894304275513,
-0.0551491305232048,
0.017883911728858948,
0.004363509360700846,
0.015593265183269978,
0.02609286457300186,
0.01829703338444233,
-0.001819716184400022,
0.024986138567328453,
-0.0029137313831597567,
-0.03801015391945839,
0.01067319605499506,
0.00506338058039546,
-0.03226197138428688,
-0.05294593796133995,
0.013555425219237804,
-0.00791860930621624,
0.002255660016089678,
0.03218972310423851,
-0.005154142156243324,
-0.006059757899492979,
0.018330344930291176,
-0.013865407556295395,
0.0021278434433043003,
0.009378328919410706,
0.028033459559082985,
0.003131129080429673,
-0.00926976278424263,
0.030260832980275154,
0.0044489577412605286,
0.0291359331458807,
0.04672972112894058,
0.01566219888627529,
0.005792907904833555,
-0.01352451741695404,
0.013210959732532501,
-0.023509163409471512,
-0.07234206050634384,
0.047018274664878845,
0.003909129183739424,
0.010464342311024666,
0.01103213056921959,
0.009170278906822205,
0.021830493584275246,
0.0243371594697237,
-0.007087507750838995,
0.01071189995855093,
0.0011927657760679722,
0.006982078310102224,
0.03189613297581673,
0.028326936066150665,
0.0262722447514534,
0.039879925549030304,
-0.053677935153245926,
0.03278595954179764,
0.05555231124162674,
-0.0244298093020916,
-0.05297313258051872,
0.032682884484529495,
-0.03833507373929024,
-0.03072415664792061,
0.02090219222009182,
0.05303942412137985,
-0.0002655979187693447,
-0.07622937858104706,
-0.028781725093722343,
-0.05524666979908943,
-0.15169435739517212,
-0.020706478506326675,
-0.036176130175590515,
0.02152658998966217,
0.00010034180013462901,
-0.012268459424376488,
-0.05471102148294449,
0.024058138951659203,
-0.05045834928750992,
-0.013816253282129765,
0.014979982748627663,
-0.046299465000629425,
-0.0002416912466287613,
0.02307908795773983,
0.008925390429794788,
-0.010883755050599575,
0.015470306389033794,
0.027621261775493622,
0.03035229817032814,
-0.023799806833267212,
0.027521269395947456,
-0.04752487689256668,
0.06213637813925743,
0.017549308016896248,
-0.0310153029859066,
-0.009126832708716393,
0.004836017265915871,
0.025236835703253746,
-0.012213357724249363,
0.0035056027118116617,
0.020918916910886765,
0.013938396237790585,
-0.01254277490079403,
0.04511410370469093,
-0.004811766557395458,
0.05663543567061424,
0.05986519530415535,
-0.06889169663190842,
-0.004257918801158667,
-0.04597511887550354,
0.040217164903879166,
0.046214666217565536,
0.041991930454969406,
-0.0033049399498850107,
-0.006908143870532513,
-0.04483664035797119,
0.007148530799895525,
-0.02364945411682129,
-0.006957036908715963,
0.04022006317973137,
-0.023858925327658653,
-0.004107024986296892,
-0.03724881261587143,
-0.05207221210002899,
0.006854443345218897,
-0.017378248274326324,
0.030913565307855606,
0.021650608628988266,
-0.03423973545432091,
-0.018197689205408096,
-0.04599808156490326,
-0.02432469092309475,
-0.008265461772680283,
0.02614705264568329,
-0.0258333757519722,
0.002129528671503067,
0.010860082693397999,
-0.03965669870376587,
0.020278383046388626,
0.024206288158893585,
0.015490354038774967,
-0.015031876042485237,
-0.0024785706773400307,
-0.010995260439813137,
0.0175210852175951,
0.011949158273637295,
-0.05265166237950325,
0.009397986344993114,
-0.022396886721253395,
-0.09579481929540634,
-0.0019115806790068746,
0.041496582329273224,
-0.030880870297551155,
-0.005101446062326431,
-0.009915663860738277,
0.036338355392217636,
-0.005936093628406525,
0.023606546223163605,
-0.0029972027987241745,
0.25249460339546204,
0.0001745165209285915,
0.010771428234875202,
0.02310609444975853,
0.008318095467984676,
0.003738721599802375,
0.02528492361307144,
0.03460153564810753,
-0.005872916895896196,
-0.04420562833547592,
-0.021573031321167946,
-0.005851626396179199,
0.0043085841462016106,
0.029639938846230507,
-0.01810646243393421,
0.031438495963811874,
-0.02363762818276882,
-0.019159337505698204,
0.05035828426480293,
0.00897897593677044,
0.03401344642043114,
0.011346923187375069,
0.00017346434469800442,
0.004707221873104572,
-0.02375909313559532,
-0.03213303163647652,
0.011677787639200687,
0.04706134274601936,
-0.05099499225616455,
0.009544851258397102,
0.0005937406094744802,
-0.008593998849391937,
0.0733742043375969,
0.011410105973482132,
0.0258925948292017,
0.010899192653596401,
0.013775077648460865,
-0.012140164151787758,
0.02585516683757305,
0.04558674991130829,
0.021520845592021942,
-0.037344399839639664,
0.0061903721652925014,
-0.027879400178790092,
-0.038518864661455154,
0.04596717655658722,
-0.028948603197932243,
0.036656610667705536,
-0.02168405055999756,
0.03849555924534798,
0.003276469651609659,
0.014088183641433716,
-0.025231044739484787,
-0.0338207483291626,
-0.008952781558036804,
0.037500496953725815,
-0.02676089107990265,
0.028534291312098503,
0.021342173218727112,
0.03341880068182945,
0.0340065062046051,
0.03961210697889328,
-0.033602774143218994,
0.026930661872029305,
-0.02678154781460762,
-0.042392682284116745,
-0.06464799493551254,
-0.011480026878416538,
0.03346814960241318,
0.04265913739800453,
0.024356098845601082,
0.002423652447760105,
-0.024069558829069138,
0.017614271491765976,
0.04326024651527405,
-0.0234445221722126,
-0.025829948484897614,
0.002350028371438384,
-0.04099182412028313,
0.014167762361466885,
-0.05242755264043808,
-0.025693116709589958,
-0.02495759353041649,
0.04214414954185486,
0.015219013206660748,
0.01618168316781521,
-0.04862212389707565,
0.0404498465359211,
-0.01734474115073681,
-0.015449082478880882,
0.008747241459786892,
-0.000952057249378413,
0.02641821652650833,
-0.011027086526155472,
-0.014140044339001179,
-0.026790233328938484,
-0.00574355386197567,
-0.025760404765605927,
-0.03487454727292061,
-0.03679405897855759,
0.005314035806804895,
-0.013781052082777023,
0.007347714155912399,
-0.052091654390096664,
0.0161419864743948,
-0.014931968413293362,
-0.02358897589147091,
0.02785377949476242,
-0.031367845833301544,
0.011648503132164478,
0.01594974473118782,
0.02841252274811268,
0.020401731133461,
0.011927531100809574,
0.03340083360671997,
0.045682642608881,
-0.011430311016738415,
0.03290558233857155,
0.033606983721256256,
0.025846833363175392,
0.013194946572184563,
-0.01234966516494751,
-0.05533275008201599,
-0.003217113669961691,
-0.0014013561885803938,
0.011925463564693928,
-0.01770532689988613,
-0.0015339002711698413,
-0.0007238559774123132,
0.020509952679276466,
-0.00016379418957512826,
-0.0243921410292387,
-0.02986188419163227,
0.01867525838315487,
0.05642833933234215,
0.019999343901872635,
0.0019647639710456133,
-0.02932850271463394,
-0.06216501072049141,
0.029788566753268242,
-0.035635024309158325,
-0.00047212143545039,
-0.0215599462389946,
-0.028842074796557426,
0.009259514510631561,
0.019027234986424446,
-0.031959451735019684,
0.05126477777957916,
-0.050917256623506546,
0.005826376844197512,
0.026952438056468964,
0.015725016593933105,
-0.02725893259048462,
-0.029261168092489243,
0.011056454852223396,
0.033516135066747665,
-0.011559320613741875,
-0.02696114405989647,
0.050837550312280655,
-0.04162163287401199,
-0.009767900221049786,
0.012982030399143696,
0.03279997408390045,
0.018574737012386322,
0.002390790032222867,
0.07751017808914185,
-0.0264741200953722,
0.027569880709052086,
0.02738131769001484,
-0.03581028804183006,
-0.02476506307721138,
-0.07365743815898895,
-0.039533890783786774,
0.03201030194759369,
0.023531056940555573,
0.03166928142309189,
0.0050844354555010796,
-0.010506508871912956,
-0.0055661615915596485,
-0.029091553762555122,
0.01840745098888874,
0.016182804480195045,
-0.06518381834030151,
0.00046625323011539876,
-0.011256671510636806,
-0.006735959555953741,
0.019426193088293076,
-0.010436320677399635,
0.07370363920927048,
-0.0504247285425663,
-0.010586013086140156,
0.08465612679719925,
0.00908952672034502,
-0.020184600725769997,
0.0228573065251112,
0.002057837788015604,
0.003982385154813528,
0.05335842818021774,
0.007023474667221308,
-0.06445416808128357,
0.0018733153119683266,
-0.02165505290031433,
-0.025680143386125565,
-0.044222477823495865,
0.04358400031924248,
0.015081468038260937,
-0.01837603561580181,
0.05888567492365837,
-0.041306354105472565,
-0.027891898527741432,
0.03799627348780632,
0.03917716071009636,
-0.045277275145053864,
0.019524261355400085,
0.017771687358617783,
-0.0346287339925766,
0.009156162850558758,
0.06905114650726318,
-0.011246586218476295,
-0.08428777009248734,
-0.0116107277572155,
-0.027536187320947647,
0.02232460305094719,
-0.04271494224667549,
-0.03974834084510803,
-0.0403863824903965,
-0.04497307911515236,
-0.02074570581316948,
-0.04356680065393448,
0.009325538761913776,
-0.004072361160069704,
-0.07164094597101212,
0.061980925500392914,
-0.044266000390052795,
0.015457001514732838,
-0.011453699320554733,
0.02773076482117176,
0.0029926577117294073,
0.02901950478553772,
-0.034841202199459076,
0.016671527177095413,
-0.008143715560436249,
0.04144689813256264,
0.05007892847061157,
-0.012498484924435616,
-0.004619302693754435,
-0.022263454273343086,
0.0022530918940901756,
-0.010110699571669102,
0.034070104360580444,
-0.003279344877228141,
0.024479512125253677,
0.009973343461751938,
-0.029226891696453094,
0.013182006776332855,
0.015324453823268414,
0.039859410375356674,
-0.05956267565488815,
-0.010542048141360283,
-0.022295571863651276,
-0.031216565519571304,
-0.0004466537793632597,
0.027805699035525322,
-0.042231302708387375,
-0.07605017721652985,
-0.031140949577093124,
0.011496241204440594,
-0.03486262261867523,
-0.022713635116815567,
-0.0044510746374726295,
-0.011726206168532372,
-0.024032434448599815,
0.014014294371008873,
-0.06762371957302094,
0.010928326286375523,
-0.01900104433298111,
-0.022469092160463333,
0.013248954899609089,
0.004465405363589525,
-0.015344604849815369,
0.008114941418170929,
0.0037617909256368876,
0.01700936071574688,
0.019088560715317726,
-0.038909848779439926,
0.04232817515730858,
0.0037183850072324276,
-0.01672007516026497,
-0.033356063067913055,
0.0032150091137737036,
0.013354807160794735,
0.0024235339369624853,
-0.031343456357717514,
0.01805337518453598,
-0.0017273048870265484,
-0.012862521223723888,
-0.020104486495256424,
0.02683302015066147,
-0.010928653180599213,
-0.005533173214644194,
-0.029695574194192886,
-0.006765083409845829,
-0.004717524163424969,
-0.06475398689508438,
-0.023896317929029465,
0.0006122231134213507,
-0.0287847351282835,
-0.008704973384737968,
0.007332245819270611,
-0.001661606365814805,
0.028957262635231018,
-0.04056522995233536,
0.023783672600984573,
0.0038732029497623444,
0.03293933719396591,
0.007619077805429697,
0.04585343599319458,
0.006150614470243454,
-0.023016247898340225,
0.009079323150217533,
0.0007225759327411652,
-0.007623502518981695,
-0.056098584085702896,
0.02882949449121952,
-0.0677160695195198,
-0.022391052916646004,
0.008710907772183418,
-0.04625916853547096,
-0.04710804671049118,
0.010969302617013454,
-0.01576058566570282,
0.01766284368932247,
0.016280878335237503,
0.010899539105594158,
0.05282311514019966,
-0.0043970271944999695,
0.002412476111203432,
-0.026612909510731697,
0.017313022166490555,
-0.07541143149137497,
-0.01418553851544857,
-0.05345143377780914,
0.05156833678483963,
-0.009764764457941055,
-0.012941205874085426,
0.03399437665939331,
-0.004683364182710648,
-0.007455938030034304,
0.013286196626722813,
0.01500075962394476,
-0.01964002475142479,
0.007156739942729473,
-0.01308626588433981,
-0.03349243476986885,
-0.014126185327768326,
-0.03059818223118782,
0.001046105520799756,
0.023720229044556618,
0.029840977862477303,
-0.01629025489091873,
-0.0075978245586156845,
0.04537240415811539,
0.012002489529550076,
0.013014604337513447,
-0.006733790971338749,
0.006335224024951458,
0.02074354700744152,
0.02052304334938526,
-0.014717647805809975,
-0.001144231529906392,
0.006474300287663937,
-0.03147352486848831,
-0.02846563793718815,
0.007535771932452917,
-0.031197328120470047,
0.021667534485459328,
0.03940047323703766,
0.02217044308781624,
-0.002250786405056715,
-0.047794830054044724,
0.0013789014192298055,
-0.007428737357258797,
-0.01738840527832508,
-0.031141778454184532,
0.015941444784402847,
0.02224995754659176,
0.0013505348470062017,
0.0076544517651200294,
0.012597344815731049,
0.020490460097789764,
-0.010005294345319271,
0.011631688103079796,
-0.004189382307231426,
-0.0196177139878273,
-0.13702110946178436,
-0.039717596024274826,
-0.00876505859196186,
-0.06556259840726852,
-0.017070118337869644,
-0.011983640491962433,
-0.018655363470315933,
0.06700611114501953,
-0.04165804386138916,
0.010189259424805641,
0.021277913823723793,
-0.010309085249900818,
0.009602629579603672,
-0.01726168394088745,
-0.014573951251804829,
0.006350042764097452,
-0.046751443296670914,
0.0144486203789711,
-0.0924002081155777,
0.016176965087652206,
0.011937767267227173,
-0.010820284485816956,
-0.006731455679982901,
-0.0032864550594240427,
0.019537625834345818,
0.009828749112784863,
0.012877533212304115,
-0.038240354508161545,
-0.03299204632639885,
-0.013793379999697208,
-0.031586017459630966,
0.009847861714661121,
0.004639051388949156,
0.05229906737804413,
-0.008015669882297516,
0.02043726108968258,
0.008783244527876377,
-0.014678883366286755,
-0.00463721202686429,
0.015308273024857044,
-0.03896902874112129,
0.028553303331136703,
-0.02239299565553665,
-0.031001657247543335,
0.02682098187506199,
0.049142006784677505,
-0.009810891933739185,
-0.003776107681915164,
-0.05456417798995972,
-0.028212696313858032,
-0.008192821405827999,
0.016891807317733765,
0.03167777881026268,
0.03855820745229721,
0.02149851806461811,
-0.021293601021170616,
0.014675897546112537,
-0.0357048474252224,
0.026888778433203697,
0.03708323463797569,
0.01906718499958515,
-0.0030797526706010103,
-0.042777445167303085,
0.02799910120666027,
-0.03592677041888237,
-0.0017339799087494612,
-0.008577066473662853,
-0.032554615288972855,
-0.015911774709820747,
0.016144253313541412,
-0.0013108174316585064,
-0.032574333250522614,
-0.002859488595277071,
-0.05029391124844551,
0.02947850152850151,
-0.029987303540110588,
0.013802033849060535,
0.00923937652260065,
-0.04915256425738335,
-0.020734058693051338,
-0.047277700155973434,
0.03013322316110134,
-0.053105562925338745,
0.01736573874950409,
0.06575990468263626,
0.03990453481674194,
-0.01663624495267868,
-0.011915826238691807,
0.016085203737020493,
-0.035120949149131775,
-0.05589167773723602,
0.010852854698896408,
0.029478896409273148,
0.03158865123987198,
-0.03657485544681549,
0.0400930717587471,
-0.005722330883145332,
0.0027987267822027206,
0.01045901607722044,
0.0023961185943335295,
-0.08405600488185883,
-0.0069914027117192745,
0.005437946412712336,
-0.004488395527005196,
-0.03302398696541786,
-0.02809612639248371,
0.04546373337507248,
-0.016024701297283173,
0.01633288525044918,
-0.008882975205779076,
0.009149634279310703,
-0.015402987599372864,
-0.04194316267967224,
0.03872572258114815,
-0.026521537452936172,
0.013527147471904755,
0.02037372812628746,
-0.026914596557617188,
-0.0025597638450562954,
0.0060570877976715565,
0.012332203797996044,
0.027830105274915695,
-0.011521216481924057,
-0.032124705612659454,
0.01361924596130848,
-0.010377430357038975,
0.06408524513244629,
0.04964632913470268,
0.014863261952996254,
-0.015812203288078308,
0.0332527831196785,
-0.001750729512423277,
0.006793497130274773,
0.03211041912436485,
-0.00007655112131033093,
0.007176870014518499,
-0.016033267602324486,
-0.003982395399361849,
-0.033927563577890396,
-0.019887546077370644,
-0.025443026795983315,
-0.01584799773991108,
0.005777495913207531,
0.0009705330594442785,
-0.03995867446064949,
0.03010077029466629,
0.012542549520730972,
-0.004380944650620222,
-0.02063838019967079,
-0.032098595052957535,
-0.0016412865370512009,
0.02919519878923893,
0.021098364144563675,
0.006388823967427015,
0.024394895881414413,
0.005946952383965254,
0.04921000078320503,
0.021885225549340248,
0.06586800515651703,
0.01890910416841507,
-0.011997605673968792,
-0.035398345440626144,
-0.041667528450489044,
-0.0354250967502594,
-0.004962364211678505,
-0.001078099594451487,
-0.020639849826693535,
0.005021735094487667,
-0.0245998315513134,
-0.03708279877901077,
-0.012666602618992329,
-0.0033777658827602863,
-0.008201245218515396,
0.01522236317396164,
0.023507166653871536,
-0.028371695429086685,
-0.006893167272210121,
-0.01290863286703825,
0.0407622866332531,
-0.01709546335041523,
0.057995665818452835,
0.03950457274913788,
0.040766641497612,
-0.008644231595098972,
0.013854126445949078,
0.03352932631969452,
0.03693898767232895,
0.049651358276605606,
-0.011503495275974274,
-0.0199259202927351,
-0.02454337850213051,
0.02659260481595993,
0.01240659411996603,
-0.014558703638613224,
0.020482143387198448,
0.029795799404382706,
0.0018104554619640112,
0.0432613231241703,
0.023612486198544502,
0.04064486175775528,
-0.002841691020876169,
-0.010532667860388756,
-0.05189784616231918,
-0.02578972652554512,
-0.01674770936369896,
0.045558590441942215,
-0.012195034883916378,
-0.04008948802947998,
-0.023911725729703903,
0.06445226073265076,
0.0018809757893905044,
0.01185568142682314,
-0.00827370397746563,
0.026590537279844284,
-0.01112179271876812,
-0.0015737907961010933,
0.038303449749946594,
-0.012796681374311447,
0.025719350203871727,
-0.012971778400242329,
0.01428693812340498,
0.030258730053901672,
-0.008359220810234547,
-0.0036816103383898735,
-0.00295974756591022,
-0.0019672056660056114,
0.015039244666695595,
0.017415249720215797,
-0.017498783767223358,
0.04702683910727501,
0.0024030061904340982,
0.030339716002345085,
0.008953755721449852,
0.07602328807115555,
-0.0013976595364511013,
-0.03642548620700836,
-0.027710767462849617,
-0.040581099689006805,
-0.022380508482456207,
-0.029921121895313263,
0.036303311586380005,
0.022022880613803864,
-0.021003326401114464,
-0.02328503131866455
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:40
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
3. In respect of monies to be provided by way of loan funds, please advise the terms of the loan including interest rate and repayment date;
4. In respect of any monies to be provided in the future by way of loan, will there be a facility agreement between the new funder and HTT Huntley Heritage Pty Limited? If so, please provide a copy of the draft facility agreement..."
Mr Ping Huang
603On the same day Mr Ping Huang ("Mr Ping") wrote a letter ("the Ping Letter") to Mr Moir on the letterhead of Investment Business Corporation (iBC) Group Pty Ltd ("IBC").
604The letter read:-
"This letter is to confirm that Investment Business Corporation Group Pty Ltd. (iBC Group) will invest A$40 million into the Huntley project subject to the successful review by iBC Group. This money will be invested by no later that 10 September 2004 and will be used to refinance loans and to complete the purchase of units in the Huntley Trust". (emphasis added).
605Mr Moir sent Mr Gillard a copy of the Ping Letter the next day, 25 August 2004.
606Mr Renshall was not able to say precisely when he received the letter but it must have been at or around that time.
Mr Renshall's "proof of funds" conversation with Mr Hanna
607Also on the same day Mr Renshall had a conversation with Mr Hanna to the following effect:-
Mr Renshall: "I have requested proof that the funds are available in three separate letters without receiving a response. Will the funds be available soon?"
Mr Hanna: "Yes, the funds will be ready in the next few days".
Mr Renshall: "Well, I'd like some assurance the funds are on the way".
Mr Hanna: "I'll get Ping to confirm his commitment in writing and get James Moir to give you a copy. In any case there should be $4.5 million coming in a few days".
608Mr Renshall agreed that, when referring to the $4.5 million in this conversation, Mr Hanna made no reference to Sydney Finance. However, as set out above, Mr Renshall said that on other occasions, the dates of which he could not recall, Mr Hanna had said the $4.5 million was available through Sydney Finance.
609Mr Hanna's reference to getting "Ping to confirm his commitment in writing" either reflected, or led to, the Ping Letter.
25 August 2004 - Fifteenth Representation
610This representation is said to arise from a conversation between Mr Zdrilic and Mr Renshall on 25 August 2004.
611The representation pleaded is that:-
* the funder would be putting $18 million into the Project, of which $10 million was the purchase of equity;
* $4.5 million would be paid on settlement and the balance of the $18 million would be paid on 15 September 2004;
* the new funder had organised funding in the sum of $40 million which would be advanced in stages.
612Mr Zdrilic said, during a telephone conversation, that Mr Renshall said:-
"The funder will be putting in $18.0m of which $10.0m is equity. If the funder wants to put in $4.5m then so-be-it as the rest will be paid on 15 September 2004. I don't want to rock the boat. The funder has already organised $40.0m which will come in stages. The re-zoning and the plans to Council will be happening soon."
613Mr Zdrilic's note of his conversation with Mr Renshall reads:-
"Spoke to R Renshall
He said he will try to meet me on Friday before the meeting re settlement. I suggested we meet before so he can fill me in on things. He said the Funder will be putting in $18m of which $10.0m approx will be equity and the rest loans.
He does not want to rock the boat - if Funder wants to put in $4.5m (the rest will be on 15/9/04) then so be it. HTT has an agreement how much equity will be paid & how much loan. The funder has already organised $40m but the availability of those funds comes in stages.
Firstly $4.5m will be used to payout American Re insurance as they have become the 1st mortgagee. Then little loans will be repaid & part of $6.8m. The rest of equity and loan will be paid on 15/9/04".
|
[
-0.05175362154841423,
0.02789844386279583,
-0.007171023171395063,
0.03148473799228668,
-0.017731597647070885,
-0.04502213001251221,
0.015662861987948418,
-0.022725015878677368,
-0.010292698629200459,
-0.01759459637105465,
0.019496889784932137,
0.0571921244263649,
0.013857140205800533,
-0.0077460831962525845,
-0.010376131162047386,
-0.05560179427266121,
0.0188054908066988,
0.003141670487821102,
0.0317959226667881,
-0.036858513951301575,
-0.02456674911081791,
-0.021861348301172256,
-0.012602115981280804,
0.013175218366086483,
0.0007227002060972154,
-0.020998504012823105,
-0.0329357348382473,
0.044030848890542984,
0.033217817544937134,
0.014269916340708733,
0.004714486189186573,
-0.020032107830047607,
0.04637622460722923,
-0.007294849026948214,
0.02733604796230793,
-0.04297919198870659,
0.012406003661453724,
0.008940406143665314,
-0.03176989033818245,
0.04089174047112465,
0.0028136102482676506,
0.01560031808912754,
0.007199428975582123,
0.02025483176112175,
0.04587549716234207,
-0.03295909985899925,
-0.009547727182507515,
-0.02158352918922901,
0.013166386634111404,
0.0013228482566773891,
-0.021536890417337418,
-0.044084832072257996,
0.03344501927495003,
-0.001556403236463666,
-0.05715673789381981,
-0.0015712592285126448,
-0.03170063719153404,
0.015875959768891335,
-0.06994703412055969,
-0.01919575035572052,
0.020601725205779076,
-0.012453134171664715,
-0.07591564953327179,
-0.01207004114985466,
-0.0009216094040311873,
0.087884820997715,
0.01569940522313118,
0.01636490412056446,
0.006853502709418535,
-0.007306959014385939,
-0.04751237481832504,
-0.019262470304965973,
-0.022613583132624626,
-0.010469832457602024,
-0.09633784741163254,
0.02215098962187767,
0.04229903593659401,
0.013659719377756119,
0.02475093863904476,
0.032577600330114365,
0.0363825298845768,
-0.030940108001232147,
-0.04284396767616272,
0.01120707206428051,
-0.008564331568777561,
-0.0014924982096999884,
-0.02384430356323719,
0.03270450234413147,
0.018188703805208206,
-0.012018377892673016,
-0.002789589576423168,
0.006766475271433592,
0.015236318111419678,
-0.030468346551060677,
0.003751372219994664,
-0.008870800957083702,
-0.03469495475292206,
0.05360288918018341,
-0.023122936487197876,
0.020713238045573235,
0.012049303390085697,
0.02657131850719452,
-0.017957525327801704,
-0.02772328071296215,
-0.04046079143881798,
0.03648390993475914,
0.045071784406900406,
0.0256746057420969,
0.01592688262462616,
-0.007032881025224924,
-0.00039460795233026147,
0.007103265263140202,
0.002541257767006755,
0.01895623281598091,
0.00935767125338316,
-0.04648608714342117,
-0.001584594720043242,
0.017195696011185646,
0.058139801025390625,
0.011258714832365513,
0.011184346862137318,
0.007339970208704472,
0.0188923217356205,
-0.0001714180689305067,
-0.0730709359049797,
-0.020359277725219727,
-0.0591026209294796,
0.010453074239194393,
0.011287053115665913,
0.02975047565996647,
-0.011365940794348717,
0.003070188919082284,
-0.03904091566801071,
-0.007288459222763777,
-0.03679926320910454,
0.006065359339118004,
0.006205832585692406,
-0.023510778322815895,
0.004809279460459948,
-0.03751390054821968,
0.022083571180701256,
-0.001614819630049169,
-0.0065937889739871025,
-0.06156760826706886,
0.021109655499458313,
-0.04125883802771568,
0.03601238131523132,
0.034419942647218704,
-0.00019827256619464606,
0.054127611219882965,
0.012903626076877117,
0.018853921443223953,
0.03147146478295326,
0.00018197859753854573,
0.02744942344725132,
-0.045521330088377,
0.027090582996606827,
-0.07216165959835052,
0.03725850582122803,
0.059110965579748154,
-0.008389919064939022,
0.035029683262109756,
-0.009950502775609493,
-0.03943230211734772,
-0.018394019454717636,
-0.008909753523766994,
0.034951429814100266,
0.0317438542842865,
-0.01832442544400692,
0.01883826218545437,
0.0053186677396297455,
-0.007024668622761965,
0.056221768260002136,
0.016826927661895752,
0.031307633966207504,
0.01651599444448948,
0.051548752933740616,
0.018412521108984947,
0.0018054640386253595,
-0.027122531086206436,
-0.07181686162948608,
0.06010064110159874,
0.024959398433566093,
0.010141890496015549,
-0.048026904463768005,
0.03649832308292389,
-0.027596669271588326,
-0.012552200816571712,
-0.007414776366204023,
0.044531892985105515,
-0.015256984159350395,
-0.01681460812687874,
0.04317838326096535,
0.02917736954987049,
0.03691631928086281,
-0.026752211153507233,
0.024453839287161827,
-0.030914271250367165,
-0.006810233928263187,
-0.017117775976657867,
-0.005199405364692211,
0.025356490164995193,
0.04737420380115509,
-0.026609711349010468,
-0.002886024070903659,
0.02135305292904377,
-0.01078746933490038,
0.002583850175142288,
-0.012145844288170338,
-0.05229109525680542,
0.0021730358712375164,
-0.04221875220537186,
-0.014214841648936272,
0.0034635814372450113,
0.014696294441819191,
0.0006487679202109575,
-0.014340713620185852,
-0.0187268927693367,
0.018766552209854126,
-0.03697682172060013,
-0.03625358268618584,
0.04361114278435707,
0.019859181717038155,
0.019361043348908424,
0.02641374059021473,
0.04751275107264519,
-0.00733956228941679,
0.038785263895988464,
-0.008275601081550121,
-0.04655633121728897,
-0.02474738471210003,
-0.02504001557826996,
0.01506875827908516,
-0.0004893304430879653,
0.012021553702652454,
0.05653107911348343,
0.049410946667194366,
0.003283257130533457,
0.02259841561317444,
0.020305057987570763,
-0.005429246928542852,
-0.0067824735306203365,
-0.01863209530711174,
0.03036089986562729,
-0.04125899076461792,
0.006631934549659491,
0.000500062364153564,
0.026246236637234688,
0.0045907022431492805,
-0.0037928447127342224,
-0.008556908927857876,
-0.003982629626989365,
-0.0007730883662588894,
0.004391881171613932,
-0.006993664428591728,
0.032461538910865784,
0.017541829496622086,
0.0013416571309790015,
-0.0022593631874769926,
0.013946084305644035,
0.005167168099433184,
0.0017409365391358733,
0.032287511974573135,
0.019045447930693626,
-0.01612168177962303,
-0.0003815547679550946,
-0.03590843454003334,
-0.08741103857755661,
0.031071843579411507,
-0.03622197359800339,
0.029059793800115585,
0.0061613526195287704,
0.024461932480335236,
0.002309234580025077,
-0.00909952912479639,
0.029236633330583572,
0.007151761557906866,
-0.005931522697210312,
-0.022563809528946877,
0.026320522651076317,
0.04153488948941231,
0.037783317267894745,
0.008456684648990631,
-0.016330404207110405,
0.06127190589904785,
0.03808879107236862,
0.001934850588440895,
-0.05496712774038315,
0.02416086755692959,
-0.03798174485564232,
-0.023056162521243095,
-0.011178688146173954,
0.06903129070997238,
-0.022429080680012703,
-0.03592139482498169,
-0.019547557458281517,
-0.024648556485772133,
-0.16984841227531433,
-0.055550798773765564,
-0.0036461118143051863,
0.031176887452602386,
0.0096518499776721,
0.017375895753502846,
-0.033212810754776,
0.010261849500238895,
-0.005687712226063013,
0.014586354605853558,
-0.013596118427813053,
-0.04477989301085472,
-0.003944000229239464,
0.051450904458761215,
0.040109943598508835,
-0.019859107211232185,
0.006800281815230846,
0.006946216337382793,
0.0007367822690866888,
-0.037664562463760376,
0.009714863263070583,
-0.01730743795633316,
0.06198747083544731,
-0.00104053586255759,
-0.0005008818116039038,
0.007872781716287136,
-0.02207067795097828,
0.01751050353050232,
-0.03693801164627075,
-0.03358732536435127,
0.004011861514300108,
0.024922749027609825,
-0.016376856714487076,
0.044464025646448135,
0.028932027518749237,
0.043975699692964554,
0.07417372614145279,
-0.04432095214724541,
-0.005828175228089094,
-0.01640070229768753,
0.04392759129405022,
0.02513689547777176,
0.04426223784685135,
0.028169777244329453,
0.0063992212526500225,
-0.04002125561237335,
-0.03580603376030922,
0.009012624621391296,
0.003279110649600625,
0.032471634447574615,
0.005666408687829971,
-0.013038503006100655,
-0.014696658588945866,
-0.04714065045118332,
-0.022695031017065048,
-0.042234815657138824,
0.04318573325872421,
0.022966530174016953,
-0.019573934376239777,
-0.03482408449053764,
-0.034108273684978485,
-0.05153379961848259,
0.0022669192403554916,
-0.006399117410182953,
-0.024396389722824097,
0.0359627790749073,
0.023612184450030327,
-0.023102767765522003,
0.00727359252050519,
0.009052964858710766,
-0.004800448659807444,
0.008228002116084099,
-0.008852447383105755,
-0.02021920494735241,
0.027148185297846794,
0.022025832906365395,
-0.0472639799118042,
-0.023602982982993126,
-0.006117008626461029,
-0.10777752101421356,
0.01564279943704605,
0.024025673046708107,
-0.03811530023813248,
0.013250757940113544,
-0.002914279466494918,
0.022347085177898407,
0.02759181149303913,
0.042090050876140594,
-0.006187348160892725,
0.25328636169433594,
0.005229228176176548,
0.046768609434366226,
0.04105105251073837,
0.016937293112277985,
-0.03913489356637001,
-0.01995345950126648,
0.028160009533166885,
-0.01205701008439064,
-0.03577965870499611,
-0.019160287454724312,
0.02240629680454731,
0.02645476534962654,
0.01849217712879181,
-0.015344930812716484,
0.006014934740960598,
-0.05967447906732559,
0.007477597799152136,
0.07200820744037628,
-0.004064133390784264,
0.06059287488460541,
-0.03399883583188057,
-0.06863995641469955,
-0.011469090357422829,
-0.03518218547105789,
-0.057240381836891174,
0.036893486976623535,
0.06930232048034668,
-0.05245621129870415,
0.04727999493479729,
-0.0008983849547803402,
-0.0059059192426502705,
0.03184416890144348,
0.005621551536023617,
0.0474579893052578,
0.012087521143257618,
-0.009282351471483707,
0.022239867597818375,
0.013196076266467571,
0.062035948038101196,
0.00176520727109164,
-0.034494731575250626,
0.017989754676818848,
-0.05155705660581589,
-0.01756754145026207,
0.011422961950302124,
-0.061511650681495667,
0.01007029414176941,
-0.01869276911020279,
0.023209232836961746,
0.010883700102567673,
0.026973433792591095,
-0.01504973229020834,
-0.0010738784912973642,
-0.008546638302505016,
0.04803670197725296,
-0.009694320149719715,
0.01557520404458046,
-0.009273082949221134,
0.034728288650512695,
-0.0058661880902945995,
0.017747163772583008,
-0.022844478487968445,
0.021246841177344322,
-0.0016518791671842337,
-0.051867078989744186,
-0.07167588919401169,
-0.03269873559474945,
0.02730018086731434,
0.0405840128660202,
0.03403167054057121,
0.02769036963582039,
0.016891947016119957,
-0.005770902615040541,
0.05434802547097206,
-0.024384085088968277,
-0.014390821568667889,
-0.018574552610516548,
-0.00298135238699615,
0.012754583731293678,
-0.012067480944097042,
-0.03579196706414223,
-0.019313113763928413,
0.014474167488515377,
0.04261909797787666,
0.013777465559542179,
-0.05018593743443489,
0.04215734452009201,
-0.01761985570192337,
0.0029687639325857162,
-0.04221831262111664,
-0.020132241770625114,
0.013821035623550415,
-0.010093823075294495,
-0.0008345346432179213,
-0.02515055425465107,
0.010718492791056633,
-0.0018443798180669546,
-0.057701870799064636,
-0.045915987342596054,
0.007642241194844246,
0.006328345276415348,
0.016863668337464333,
-0.03811744228005409,
0.04019605740904808,
0.020305272191762924,
-0.041891682893037796,
0.01622314378619194,
-0.05958724766969681,
0.019265485927462578,
0.012692009098827839,
0.013180765323340893,
0.010167822241783142,
0.003249377477914095,
0.047985926270484924,
0.06100625917315483,
-0.012799615040421486,
0.05478977411985397,
0.020996078848838806,
0.021671675145626068,
0.017708560451865196,
-0.024615226313471794,
-0.06232672184705734,
-0.017987797036767006,
0.002903616288676858,
0.00972913857549429,
-0.008196487091481686,
-0.01073974184691906,
0.00872564036399126,
0.022034725174307823,
0.02354624681174755,
-0.03077966533601284,
-0.01478112768381834,
-0.004245144315063953,
0.06322626024484634,
0.009204906411468983,
0.007964994758367538,
0.012429767288267612,
-0.03580303490161896,
0.027860768139362335,
-0.03737762197852135,
0.016118144616484642,
-0.03438710421323776,
-0.018955066800117493,
0.008048273622989655,
0.021258005872368813,
-0.04714607819914818,
-0.012571501545608044,
-0.024779409170150757,
0.012330819852650166,
0.005618951749056578,
0.01705590821802616,
-0.04448991268873215,
-0.032160986214876175,
0.007824794389307499,
0.005199137609452009,
-0.008382974192500114,
-0.01943894661962986,
0.008545518852770329,
-0.03969213366508484,
-0.018153434619307518,
0.030594706535339355,
0.01451337244361639,
0.033085305243730545,
-0.007911551743745804,
0.05588669702410698,
-0.020609676837921143,
0.027334149926900864,
0.03401869162917137,
-0.04407574236392975,
0.0021845356095582247,
-0.03266320377588272,
-0.03924369812011719,
0.035580821335315704,
-0.011960141360759735,
0.02160106599330902,
0.020472565665841103,
0.004313842859119177,
0.005726153962314129,
-0.03724683076143265,
0.031153468415141106,
-0.0030043204315006733,
-0.050462037324905396,
-0.013284719549119473,
-0.004144324455410242,
-0.0414142981171608,
-0.00038376689190045,
-0.027318982407450676,
0.030421476811170578,
-0.04827367886900902,
-0.024763746187090874,
0.07503518462181091,
0.001443035900592804,
-0.03309890627861023,
0.015915285795927048,
0.010742382146418095,
-0.012836207635700703,
0.016444895416498184,
-0.01638590171933174,
-0.0200306735932827,
-0.035760246217250824,
0.0086644496768713,
0.001983232796192169,
-0.0005020170356146991,
-0.0017736838199198246,
-0.006250595208257437,
-0.005324167665094137,
0.030222851783037186,
-0.04059751704335213,
-0.03298399597406387,
0.027294978499412537,
-0.01130177453160286,
-0.004339395556598902,
0.025849157944321632,
0.022074731066823006,
-0.05168192833662033,
0.01294243335723877,
0.044842712581157684,
-0.014308078214526176,
-0.0370483361184597,
-0.0028101298958063126,
-0.027038872241973877,
0.021684177219867706,
-0.036930572241544724,
-0.009611133486032486,
0.01949448324739933,
-0.02678862027823925,
-0.028716012835502625,
-0.04251106083393097,
-0.0016925204545259476,
-0.006433066446334124,
-0.0627862736582756,
0.05498030409216881,
-0.055341094732284546,
0.01721116341650486,
-0.024194249883294106,
0.0603293739259243,
0.010129226371645927,
0.008621900342404842,
-0.032440435141325,
0.05745578184723854,
-0.0017056193901225924,
0.006536609493196011,
0.03980182483792305,
0.014079572632908821,
0.001403731177560985,
-0.014931256882846355,
-0.011490165255963802,
0.02954952046275139,
0.025260761380195618,
0.015099747106432915,
0.005717813037335873,
-0.00404947018250823,
-0.016166601330041885,
0.002145181642845273,
-0.019462423399090767,
0.005219604354351759,
-0.04006916284561157,
-0.010483295656740665,
-0.03235732764005661,
0.0030798783991485834,
-0.012465369887650013,
-0.0047805034555494785,
-0.013389724306762218,
-0.04821966961026192,
-0.04677188768982887,
-0.008388299494981766,
-0.03728800266981125,
-0.02379710040986538,
-0.0012014241656288505,
-0.0072136144153773785,
0.001818070188164711,
-0.002269734861329198,
-0.039602600038051605,
0.03923531994223595,
-0.008830785751342773,
0.02863851562142372,
-0.013447371311485767,
0.022149546071887016,
-0.014089119620621204,
-0.0016539188800379634,
0.011722864583134651,
0.03717983141541481,
0.005913466215133667,
-0.019009852781891823,
0.05619615316390991,
0.0045203096233308315,
-0.003784424625337124,
-0.0050236135721206665,
0.011936669237911701,
0.005456463899463415,
0.001455226680263877,
-0.016369622200727463,
0.0493190698325634,
-0.02367342635989189,
-0.035764504224061966,
-0.006212692242115736,
0.043272729963064194,
-0.005401902832090855,
0.022209450602531433,
-0.02573067881166935,
-0.019838809967041016,
-0.03977333381772041,
-0.03183294087648392,
-0.01969115436077118,
-0.00640235235914588,
-0.005170564167201519,
0.0010146682616323233,
0.006719918921589851,
0.01696678251028061,
0.035993535071611404,
-0.057946305721998215,
0.022901756688952446,
0.008984136395156384,
0.02863573469221592,
0.00874344166368246,
0.061542823910713196,
0.019767319783568382,
-0.031045256182551384,
-0.010320398956537247,
0.009545517154037952,
-0.019947223365306854,
-0.05184677988290787,
0.009822963736951351,
-0.053906094282865524,
-0.02600567229092121,
0.028915023431181908,
-0.03898942098021507,
-0.08427180349826813,
0.043199799954891205,
-0.017369596287608147,
-0.012834427878260612,
-0.018892670050263405,
0.02052300237119198,
0.04143770411610603,
0.016443366184830666,
0.037806760519742966,
-0.03690465912222862,
0.03836294636130333,
-0.05510782450437546,
-0.025509623810648918,
-0.045217808336019516,
0.05218620225787163,
-0.01847604289650917,
0.022942254319787025,
-0.028055615723133087,
0.001005078898742795,
0.01978622004389763,
0.05039440467953682,
0.012980354949831963,
0.0028284217696636915,
0.01371857337653637,
-0.02498895302414894,
-0.042968057096004486,
0.046522799879312515,
-0.020635807886719704,
-0.012317458167672157,
0.029247697442770004,
0.008635105565190315,
-0.024817241355776787,
-0.03488188236951828,
0.006954369135200977,
0.03687761723995209,
-0.01996198296546936,
0.00009816026431508362,
-0.016473831608891487,
0.009489037096500397,
0.012135758064687252,
-0.0020470432937145233,
0.016388846561312675,
-0.00995339173823595,
-0.03940340504050255,
-0.019588330760598183,
0.00743517093360424,
-0.04061644896864891,
0.055754996836185455,
0.0039329309947788715,
0.008490907959640026,
-0.020671987906098366,
-0.036598484963178635,
-0.015580184757709503,
-0.014361920766532421,
0.0020331067498773336,
-0.03112725540995598,
0.026982946321368217,
-0.011346605606377125,
-0.05491606518626213,
0.01765531301498413,
0.018732745200395584,
0.02295183390378952,
-0.013125242665410042,
-0.004335043951869011,
-0.00409111799672246,
-0.022486813366413116,
-0.14920155704021454,
-0.009891921654343605,
-0.01393634919077158,
-0.03137173131108284,
-0.05448200926184654,
-0.0019388387445360422,
-0.06528809666633606,
0.008112833835184574,
-0.01951306313276291,
0.012211361899971962,
-0.005950169637799263,
0.004414359573274851,
0.0005212787073105574,
-0.02010323293507099,
-0.009044758975505829,
0.01855417713522911,
-0.03710401803255081,
0.008722524158656597,
-0.08417923003435135,
0.015449704602360725,
0.033042725175619125,
0.01609238237142563,
0.0027551641687750816,
0.0076123434118926525,
0.019200405105948448,
-0.004663161933422089,
0.02135518379509449,
-0.04975971207022667,
-0.0384027473628521,
0.011689770966768265,
-0.03103179670870304,
0.004723777528852224,
0.022857364267110825,
0.07860065251588821,
0.0210260096937418,
0.005796494893729687,
0.022530900314450264,
-0.03980962559580803,
-0.04741154611110687,
-0.024388959631323814,
-0.01320376992225647,
0.02999466471374035,
-0.002740987576544285,
-0.043630268424749374,
-0.014732795767486095,
0.02487165294587612,
-0.015744497999548912,
-0.040821801871061325,
-0.04638780280947685,
-0.022798538208007812,
-0.03947769105434418,
0.000655308598652482,
0.00929338950663805,
0.02192007750272751,
0.0001276305119972676,
-0.007608783431351185,
0.008426373824477196,
-0.03534911945462227,
0.02468406967818737,
0.05577896162867546,
0.001758886151947081,
-0.0003806194581557065,
-0.06615608930587769,
-0.017995774745941162,
-0.02117198146879673,
-0.02941747196018696,
-0.01197366788983345,
0.004544355906546116,
-0.002788146259263158,
0.014899474568665028,
-0.014468496665358543,
-0.01721431501209736,
-0.020803477615118027,
-0.035914648324251175,
0.02107413299381733,
-0.026980949565768242,
-0.008450817316770554,
0.0004587812873069197,
-0.04770541191101074,
-0.005725301336497068,
-0.025611693039536476,
-0.0057503958232700825,
-0.03456505015492439,
0.0035104649141430855,
0.05140602961182594,
0.052920863032341,
0.007750107906758785,
0.002051183022558689,
0.035685308277606964,
-0.03628895804286003,
-0.03190602734684944,
-0.01783653162419796,
-0.011642593890428543,
0.024642134085297585,
-0.0324433408677578,
0.029692884534597397,
-0.005330259911715984,
-0.01859101466834545,
0.01097988709807396,
-0.0033855049405246973,
-0.025646552443504333,
-0.005679751746356487,
-0.0015506381168961525,
-0.006502241361886263,
-0.02515210025012493,
0.0003219117352273315,
0.035774536430835724,
-0.016844091936945915,
0.016237381845712662,
-0.018202805891633034,
-0.02822733111679554,
-0.01834776997566223,
-0.0324498675763607,
0.0467480905354023,
-0.05793321132659912,
0.03338439762592316,
-0.014200186356902122,
0.009008243680000305,
0.011309287510812283,
-0.0044583347626030445,
0.03726804256439209,
0.00894758477807045,
0.008050157688558102,
-0.02538408525288105,
0.018460560590028763,
-0.016423657536506653,
0.03922153264284134,
0.02937224693596363,
-0.015338791534304619,
0.005726302042603493,
0.058867666870355606,
0.006070480216294527,
0.0330609567463398,
0.022091420367360115,
-0.016583837568759918,
0.0199331883341074,
-0.025455623865127563,
0.02323080599308014,
-0.02862093597650528,
-0.03635065257549286,
0.027564458549022675,
0.02927340939640999,
-0.003964424133300781,
0.009500868618488312,
-0.03266162425279617,
-0.03098786063492298,
0.03492387756705284,
-0.012162139639258385,
-0.022582948207855225,
-0.033248353749513626,
-0.0038847143296152353,
0.015442506410181522,
-0.020366713404655457,
0.02669091895222664,
0.00006122690683696419,
0.013332702219486237,
0.018682587891817093,
-0.017210209742188454,
0.018190614879131317,
0.0452444925904274,
0.011073184199631214,
-0.05709545314311981,
-0.04726176708936691,
-0.060939084738492966,
-0.008722582831978798,
0.024874873459339142,
-0.016313716769218445,
0.03165759518742561,
-0.034843556582927704,
-0.028091533109545708,
-0.019641561433672905,
0.009483187459409237,
-0.010325080715119839,
0.011223113164305687,
0.04709455743432045,
0.014409131370484829,
0.003214813070371747,
0.004032129887491465,
0.07304514944553375,
-0.0022787125781178474,
0.044125355780124664,
0.042756788432598114,
0.015752745792269707,
0.0016705013113096356,
-0.013441137038171291,
0.027728645130991936,
-0.003879280062392354,
0.043772097676992416,
-0.014222461730241776,
-0.044345639646053314,
-0.021615151315927505,
0.007312471978366375,
0.04527141526341438,
-0.0026431092992424965,
0.05004033073782921,
0.05779736116528511,
0.011917375028133392,
0.02875298261642456,
-0.0077888863161206245,
0.04588717967271805,
0.035555701702833176,
-0.027932381257414818,
-0.038377802819013596,
-0.03253132477402687,
-0.016020052134990692,
0.021479329094290733,
0.00866950023919344,
-0.024416320025920868,
-0.06107131391763687,
0.0689811259508133,
-0.04189293459057808,
-0.011725102551281452,
-0.014034396037459373,
0.015068336389958858,
-0.014213972724974155,
0.022601457312703133,
0.0341048389673233,
0.0157293900847435,
0.0412556529045105,
-0.03844696283340454,
0.03390536829829216,
0.03586755692958832,
-0.021221010014414787,
-0.018252216279506683,
-0.00008043272828217596,
-0.044403769075870514,
-0.0032232534140348434,
0.01877961866557598,
0.01686267741024494,
0.013662131503224373,
-0.00829776655882597,
0.03626496344804764,
0.003104299074038863,
0.06707281619310379,
0.00588432140648365,
-0.028766298666596413,
-0.020030861720442772,
-0.004884589463472366,
-0.00868814717978239,
-0.03235388174653053,
0.04255315288901329,
-0.024379391223192215,
0.010776109993457794,
-0.013003059662878513
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:19
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
265The "Business Profile" described IBIS as a "small building society" the directors of which were planning to "rebirth it as a full trading bank in New Zealand with Overseas Branches in both Australia and the Cook Islands offering its customers and clients a wide range of 'face to face' and 'internet' Financial Services".
266Amongst the "services" to be provided were "Superannuation Fund Management" services through an entity to be known as "MySuper". In that regard it was stated:-
"MySuper will offers Is [sic] Superannuation Management Trust. The Trust will grow its Funds Under Management (FUM) and Funds Under Advice (FUA) by acquiring Financial Planning, Financial Dealership, Accounting and Taxation Planning Businesses. FUM and FUA will be invested into a variety of programs operated by the IPC Investment Trust".
267The "Financial Projections" set forth projected balance sheets and profit and loss statements for various entities and trusts.
268There were projections for the "IPC Joint Venture Trust" which described that trust's "source of investment capital" as being debentures subscribed to by the MySuper Trust of some $758 million.
269Mr Renshall said that he could not recall examining these documents carefully. He said he recognised that they were projections and were aspirational in nature.
270The plaintiffs submitted:-
"The financial projections were of an extravagantly optimistic nature based upon an assumption that 'IBIS Investment Bankers' could prospectively increase its assets from a nil base to a approximately $724 million by June 2005 through a series of prospective ventures".
271That appears to me to be a reasonable description of the document.
James Hanna
272As mentioned, Mr Hanna signed both the 30 and 31 January 2004 letters from IBIS.
273Mr Hanna signed the 30 January 2004 letter "for President" and the 31 January 2004 letter "IBIS Property Department".
274There is, in evidence, a business card describing Mr Hanna as a "principal" of IBIS.
275Mr Frederick gave evidence that Mr Hanna had introduced himself to Mr Frederick as the "President of IBIS Bank New Zealand" and that he gave Mr Frederick a business card that stated that position.
276Unbeknown to the parties, Mr Hanna was then, and was at all relevant times, an undischarged bankrupt.
277Mr Hanna was not called as a witness in the proceedings.
278However, many other witnesses gave evidence of conversations with Mr Hanna.
279That evidence was admitted only to prove what Mr Hanna said, and not as evidence of the truth of what Mr Hanna said.
Christopher Frederick
280IBIS's letter of 30 January 2004 referred to a site meeting attended by Messrs Renshall, Hanna and Frederick.
281Mr Frederick gave evidence in the proceedings. I have referred to him in my discussion about the credit of witnesses.
282He said he was introduced to Mr Hanna in around January 2004 and that between then and September 2004 he worked under Mr Hanna's supervision "as a consultant of IBIS in attempting to establish business for IBIS in Australia".
283Mr Frederick held units in the Huntley Trust.
284On 27 August 2004, as part of the settlement effected that day, he became a director of HTT.
James Moir
285IBIS's letter of 31 January 2004 referred to "our key personnel" as including Mr Frederick Swaab and Mr James Moir.
286Mr Swaab was the principal of Swaab Attorneys. So far as the evidence reveals, he did not play a significant role in the events with which this case is concerned. He did not give evidence.
287Mr Moir was an employee of Mr Swaab. Mr Moir gave evidence and I have referred to him above in my discussion of the credit of witnesses.
288Mr Frederick introduced Mr Moir to Mr Hanna.
289On 10 February 2004 IBIS (by Mr Hanna) retained Swaab Attorneys as its solicitors in Australia.
|
[
-0.051125988364219666,
0.015503104776144028,
-0.03852932155132294,
-0.013072622939944267,
-0.0046128383837640285,
-0.03641236945986748,
0.015530786477029324,
0.012709333561360836,
0.0021172056440263987,
0.03969474509358406,
-0.019069956615567207,
0.05674606189131737,
-0.01630987972021103,
-0.023649854585528374,
-0.041528403759002686,
-0.01229255273938179,
0.058664996176958084,
-0.021019471809267998,
-0.008134493604302406,
-0.007884994149208069,
-0.017102938145399094,
-0.011103817261755466,
-0.0006261665839701891,
0.009947404265403748,
-0.001883177668787539,
0.02481693960726261,
-0.000012521203643700574,
0.012044249102473259,
0.0062408410012722015,
0.01665068417787552,
0.01950172893702984,
0.000735417939722538,
-0.003934607841074467,
-0.0021551791578531265,
0.051630426198244095,
-0.01954742707312107,
0.009915746748447418,
-0.0038837960455566645,
-0.04208321124315262,
-0.015337456949055195,
0.005807111039757729,
0.00934849213808775,
0.0008580539142712951,
0.02586493454873562,
0.05680425837635994,
-0.03781921789050102,
0.009226180613040924,
-0.013935036957263947,
-0.011629206128418446,
0.03692757710814476,
0.008008845150470734,
0.0018175094155594707,
0.0008939201361499727,
0.02673359215259552,
-0.004461587406694889,
0.006961832754313946,
-0.0001558822114020586,
0.026771672070026398,
-0.04554705694317818,
0.027114180848002434,
0.0037192380987107754,
-0.009764120914041996,
-0.04228447750210762,
-0.004363760352134705,
-0.011449162848293781,
0.08333611488342285,
-0.007462707813829184,
-0.03321919962763786,
-0.00563937658444047,
0.00255693681538105,
-0.046439457684755325,
-0.005096981767565012,
-0.03798132389783859,
0.001380508067086339,
-0.06926562637090683,
-0.01226133480668068,
0.031174201518297195,
0.03856084123253822,
0.03777102380990982,
0.05305992066860199,
0.025044487789273262,
0.01027714554220438,
-0.03342830389738083,
0.02452659234404564,
-0.06238687038421631,
0.025386003777384758,
-0.009929288178682327,
0.041930388659238815,
-0.006067900452762842,
0.007197456434369087,
-0.002797081833705306,
-0.009298468939960003,
0.05098091810941696,
-0.046279557049274445,
-0.007160544395446777,
-0.014217287302017212,
-0.021181736141443253,
0.01644468866288662,
-0.0005223112530075014,
0.0201448742300272,
-0.002476478461176157,
0.006314930971711874,
-0.014099453575909138,
-0.01747571863234043,
0.007322492077946663,
-0.005101041402667761,
0.03705257922410965,
0.05817587301135063,
-0.020275432616472244,
-0.014654971659183502,
-0.0006870910292491317,
-0.0008316287421621382,
-0.0003367528843227774,
0.0274795014411211,
0.02388021908700466,
0.02095869928598404,
0.02253914065659046,
0.010782677680253983,
0.007081259042024612,
0.0005734151927754283,
0.04540301114320755,
0.01592671498656273,
0.02103998512029648,
-0.025153981521725655,
-0.03101738542318344,
0.005525938235223293,
0.014199594035744667,
0.0067823585122823715,
-0.017086748033761978,
0.0062880185432732105,
-0.03065968118607998,
-0.019934827461838722,
0.0024329936131834984,
-0.03609761968255043,
-0.0386764258146286,
-0.02687610685825348,
0.031696997582912445,
0.022148942574858665,
-0.01681089960038662,
-0.042822934687137604,
0.05842891335487366,
0.04932096228003502,
0.0009797781240195036,
-0.04083647206425667,
0.012800649739801884,
-0.0422341525554657,
0.004574768710881472,
-0.013333176262676716,
-0.02351563796401024,
0.00547516904771328,
-0.01383960247039795,
0.005120520479977131,
-0.0008486098959110677,
0.02172626554965973,
0.061735935509204865,
-0.04567146301269531,
0.04086277633905411,
-0.03987859562039375,
0.06887921690940857,
0.025942761451005936,
0.007757014594972134,
0.021979672834277153,
0.0081661781296134,
-0.02438049390912056,
-0.03830696642398834,
0.053868819028139114,
0.01361345499753952,
-0.010673843324184418,
-0.00044958910439163446,
0.040233064442873,
0.0032243106979876757,
-0.04788907617330551,
0.08354932814836502,
0.015351083129644394,
0.0011690553510561585,
0.0024272024165838957,
0.08817607164382935,
0.01232675276696682,
0.04753180593252182,
-0.051602695137262344,
-0.04341637343168259,
0.055987123399972916,
-0.011459645815193653,
0.046585191041231155,
-0.034699052572250366,
0.027492793276906013,
0.0064948247745633125,
0.0007436062442138791,
0.031167631968855858,
0.06905724108219147,
0.009539800696074963,
-0.023981310427188873,
0.04444493353366852,
-0.02608884684741497,
0.01889560930430889,
-0.005971954669803381,
-0.011424487456679344,
-0.02906591072678566,
0.015097943134605885,
-0.007829826325178146,
-0.01660311035811901,
0.030358286574482918,
0.06104468181729317,
-0.042957596480846405,
-0.013606526888906956,
0.02407197467982769,
0.000658986100461334,
-0.011644162237644196,
-0.013152682222425938,
-0.023220106959342957,
-0.0038814048748463392,
-0.009674746543169022,
0.01703547313809395,
0.017209302634000778,
-0.015449721366167068,
-0.010744186118245125,
0.03933199122548103,
0.016848094761371613,
0.016038993373513222,
-0.035464782267808914,
-0.03867783769965172,
0.018285060301423073,
0.019646838307380676,
0.03205683082342148,
0.027323735877871513,
0.07674294710159302,
-0.033032748848199844,
-0.0011000081431120634,
-0.010540607385337353,
-0.07526542991399765,
0.021156439557671547,
-0.008538409136235714,
-0.003226672997698188,
-0.03537707403302193,
0.01964542642235756,
0.05326102674007416,
0.011419933289289474,
0.027518251910805702,
0.06269356608390808,
0.03382740169763565,
-0.018314028158783913,
-0.02405284345149994,
0.02317863516509533,
-0.009374532848596573,
-0.055539049208164215,
0.01621895655989647,
-0.005333573557436466,
0.0478617325425148,
0.015422309748828411,
0.04734736308455467,
0.002348888199776411,
0.0056340196169912815,
-0.026702314615249634,
-0.007110749837011099,
0.01515922974795103,
0.022913644090294838,
0.011807459406554699,
0.0034376794937998056,
0.0025366670452058315,
0.00785737857222557,
0.011948710307478905,
-0.015310595743358135,
-0.005301508121192455,
0.017916401848196983,
-0.021822744980454445,
-0.04352717101573944,
-0.038130857050418854,
-0.041404638439416885,
-0.01728155091404915,
0.013007242232561111,
-0.019556958228349686,
0.008331486023962498,
0.010570187121629715,
0.022610407322645187,
0.013604610227048397,
0.050366248935461044,
0.010635343380272388,
-0.01481972448527813,
-0.011397654190659523,
0.04582642391324043,
-0.011842548847198486,
-0.022270848974585533,
0.009890399873256683,
-0.013477901928126812,
0.03718101605772972,
0.03774440661072731,
0.0076616969890892506,
0.013442955911159515,
0.029833760112524033,
-0.07441651076078415,
0.010942193679511547,
0.030289670452475548,
0.05944817140698433,
-0.0068565551191568375,
0.0010630997130647302,
-0.043849725276231766,
-0.026407761499285698,
-0.15767189860343933,
-0.021565483883023262,
0.025616731494665146,
0.0317009873688221,
-0.00650760205462575,
0.0175570547580719,
-0.0010564191034063697,
0.02148747257888317,
-0.032173313200473785,
-0.020639639347791672,
-0.05041279271245003,
-0.042882632464170456,
-0.016592854633927345,
0.008831403218209743,
0.025778736919164658,
-0.019576547667384148,
0.012567354366183281,
0.016555819660425186,
0.020294824615120888,
-0.009841679595410824,
0.020961347967386246,
-0.02190934307873249,
0.04011203721165657,
0.009152920916676521,
0.023148417472839355,
-0.019184507429599762,
0.006558356806635857,
0.028720859438180923,
-0.04951602965593338,
-0.022152069956064224,
0.045021992176771164,
0.020609023049473763,
-0.012400739826261997,
0.03456531837582588,
-0.007965306751430035,
0.03606921434402466,
0.05909812077879906,
-0.052282996475696564,
-0.03261692821979523,
-0.02659207209944725,
0.006658937316387892,
0.0321495421230793,
-0.013906093314290047,
0.03842562437057495,
0.00909210555255413,
-0.030067961663007736,
0.00644704420119524,
0.023930927738547325,
-0.012432652525603771,
0.0219161044806242,
0.0014509406173601747,
-0.01623019576072693,
0.024410486221313477,
-0.03060821443796158,
0.005799692124128342,
-0.060459405183792114,
0.014298293739557266,
0.03579452633857727,
-0.008026765659451485,
-0.04061781242489815,
-0.033852845430374146,
-0.07427762448787689,
0.0016953981248661876,
0.006043973378837109,
-0.012691693380475044,
-0.007403546012938023,
-0.01398738194257021,
0.005936277098953724,
-0.00858136173337698,
0.021572265774011612,
0.032716695219278336,
-0.02974080853164196,
0.027729948982596397,
-0.01874973438680172,
0.035297006368637085,
0.04237906262278557,
0.020624693483114243,
-0.015473231673240662,
0.003823499893769622,
-0.08743536472320557,
-0.01038074865937233,
0.02305751107633114,
-0.008277973160147667,
0.030687624588608742,
-0.004680482670664787,
0.035885248333215714,
0.021756170317530632,
0.015634452924132347,
0.0059150648303329945,
0.24791470170021057,
-0.009471474215388298,
-0.0070776077918708324,
0.011756421998143196,
0.012307667173445225,
-0.009737441316246986,
0.012202086858451366,
0.06663069874048233,
-0.0018800593679770827,
-0.048402488231658936,
-0.024644704535603523,
0.03097977675497532,
0.025332259014248848,
0.03845665603876114,
-0.008662289939820766,
-0.0122931357473135,
-0.056586675345897675,
-0.044486433267593384,
0.06459581851959229,
0.004249575547873974,
0.062058281153440475,
0.00787469930946827,
0.008021312765777111,
0.02996028959751129,
-0.060856156051158905,
-0.03294019028544426,
0.03493311628699303,
0.04062636196613312,
-0.03540988266468048,
0.05045712739229202,
-0.03722519055008888,
-0.0016684376168996096,
0.004400081466883421,
0.03046625293791294,
0.004232726525515318,
-0.014835049398243427,
-0.03450653329491615,
0.009947423823177814,
0.006177979987114668,
0.04369007423520088,
-0.018529240041971207,
-0.04750540480017662,
0.022897440940141678,
-0.028414079919457436,
-0.002898867940530181,
0.014004994183778763,
-0.023868802934885025,
0.06259340047836304,
-0.013001514598727226,
-0.012067475356161594,
-0.001941267866641283,
0.024790717288851738,
-0.02227054536342621,
0.0060056643560528755,
0.009859913028776646,
0.04872046038508415,
0.014843275770545006,
0.012366672977805138,
-0.02967590093612671,
0.0537075474858284,
0.015020147897303104,
0.032704807817935944,
-0.00458479905501008,
-0.016241705045104027,
-0.003746991977095604,
-0.005984525196254253,
-0.09178850799798965,
-0.04872031882405281,
0.020572615787386894,
0.00821315310895443,
0.011310162954032421,
0.03236793354153633,
0.016619741916656494,
0.014271126128733158,
0.017478305846452713,
-0.005665420554578304,
0.008577113971114159,
0.01770746521651745,
0.015849104151129723,
-0.010560540482401848,
-0.02682778798043728,
-0.03211179003119469,
-0.03530136123299599,
-0.0012637368636205792,
-0.00021523391478694975,
-0.02264287695288658,
-0.06289230287075043,
0.10043379664421082,
-0.03290526568889618,
-0.022072451189160347,
-0.03971632570028305,
-0.011390614323318005,
-0.01836661621928215,
0.005531782750040293,
0.009985248558223248,
0.002461470663547516,
0.04190768301486969,
0.008951371535658836,
-0.03283700719475746,
-0.0517636314034462,
0.021680403500795364,
0.018411334604024887,
0.02760375291109085,
0.014375289902091026,
0.039773229509592056,
-0.008427072316408157,
0.014190059155225754,
0.004968454595655203,
-0.0003064466582145542,
-0.007121162489056587,
-0.030839845538139343,
0.02074979618191719,
0.005203043110668659,
0.009783544577658176,
0.02387230284512043,
0.019784508273005486,
-0.0402582585811615,
0.057438161224126816,
0.01234179176390171,
0.030787872150540352,
0.024337034672498703,
-0.031923722475767136,
-0.06741264462471008,
-0.009745802730321884,
0.005850894842296839,
-0.016507776454091072,
-0.03882387652993202,
-0.04768886789679527,
-0.002389234956353903,
-0.028058938682079315,
0.017201995477080345,
-0.017979657277464867,
-0.031917307525873184,
-0.0015722777461633086,
0.033178143203258514,
0.007145998068153858,
0.0020089312456548214,
0.015934232622385025,
-0.03058028034865856,
0.025893762707710266,
-0.02798117883503437,
0.0011876925127580762,
0.006148696877062321,
-0.016889329999685287,
0.0204226803034544,
-0.013485120609402657,
-0.07132686674594879,
-0.020236322656273842,
-0.02455773577094078,
0.012897074222564697,
0.03818988427519798,
0.0358983613550663,
-0.043537020683288574,
-0.01562017947435379,
0.013027667067945004,
0.03964701294898987,
-0.019586224108934402,
-0.02101898193359375,
0.0547318160533905,
-0.060670871287584305,
0.011247659102082253,
-0.003250452224165201,
-0.03548378124833107,
0.000031843901524553075,
-0.029855631291866302,
0.04348328709602356,
-0.00680790888145566,
0.03397706151008606,
0.03584626317024231,
-0.009409111924469471,
-0.006299670785665512,
-0.06358183920383453,
-0.03097020462155342,
0.004327606875449419,
0.008446058258414268,
0.018382936716079712,
-0.02160833217203617,
0.0417652353644371,
0.025592532008886337,
-0.04422006383538246,
0.021221697330474854,
-0.0016871221596375108,
-0.02073156274855137,
0.011112848296761513,
0.035579923540353775,
0.01733093149960041,
-0.020712684839963913,
-0.020846838131546974,
0.01896294392645359,
-0.05827147513628006,
-0.013543754816055298,
0.0721333920955658,
0.022241001948714256,
-0.015336540527641773,
-0.010060157626867294,
0.035438552498817444,
-0.006875494495034218,
0.030963174998760223,
-0.02131059020757675,
-0.0021843628492206335,
0.007547555025666952,
0.02381938509643078,
0.011493797414004803,
-0.0092247249558568,
0.037814341485500336,
0.006543990224599838,
-0.007139152847230434,
0.05702346935868263,
-0.007078029680997133,
0.03741804137825966,
0.025357810780405998,
0.017603538930416107,
-0.027308858931064606,
-0.014860570430755615,
-0.004404858220368624,
-0.04135556146502495,
0.016445109620690346,
0.01316917221993208,
0.014873865060508251,
-0.05857144668698311,
-0.04834260419011116,
-0.019322697073221207,
0.0109870545566082,
-0.04718621075153351,
-0.01197807863354683,
0.02170782908797264,
-0.012332543730735779,
-0.02798173576593399,
-0.0004573537444230169,
0.006097641307860613,
0.006819674279540777,
-0.013288233429193497,
0.04066864401102066,
-0.0489584244787693,
-0.02534649707376957,
-0.018293075263500214,
0.03353356570005417,
0.0016343422466889024,
0.01143114548176527,
-0.013982933014631271,
0.04597625136375427,
-0.02753818966448307,
0.05538050830364227,
0.01176875177770853,
-0.014270956628024578,
-0.019212616607546806,
-0.009267551824450493,
0.0059473635628819466,
-0.018941687420010567,
0.008082510903477669,
0.0032341687474399805,
0.003511470276862383,
0.03182413429021835,
-0.030006611719727516,
-0.001405622810125351,
-0.00948400516062975,
0.023815207183361053,
-0.04366137832403183,
-0.049195971339941025,
-0.04996364191174507,
0.008128995075821877,
0.005392811261117458,
-0.011160491034388542,
-0.0307011716067791,
-0.04140221327543259,
-0.0381639264523983,
0.0486995205283165,
-0.032369326800107956,
-0.03423101827502251,
0.00339159625582397,
-0.025443710386753082,
-0.0022601899690926075,
-0.04026924446225166,
-0.039472226053476334,
0.022760145366191864,
0.04199173301458359,
-0.03584444895386696,
-0.010825080797076225,
0.025893056765198708,
0.008842548355460167,
-0.016957417130470276,
-0.010907091200351715,
0.03196408227086067,
0.02366742491722107,
-0.052344996482133865,
0.02309577725827694,
0.0016873383428901434,
-0.007599269039928913,
-0.015250079333782196,
-0.014641888439655304,
-0.01324945967644453,
0.02605968341231346,
-0.032866112887859344,
0.022589698433876038,
-0.013908200897276402,
-0.016791177913546562,
-0.020467465743422508,
0.05458766594529152,
-0.019393952563405037,
0.019519444555044174,
-0.01680012233555317,
-0.013692430220544338,
-0.05438229441642761,
-0.01655345968902111,
-0.032851628959178925,
-0.002723920624703169,
-0.00011623703903751448,
-0.02325546182692051,
-0.00833652913570404,
0.012517835013568401,
0.013636431656777859,
-0.08887778222560883,
0.019161934033036232,
-0.004869626834988594,
0.006962645798921585,
0.0035072178579866886,
0.03281984478235245,
-0.008259052410721779,
-0.022969814017415047,
0.008475592359900475,
-0.015252026729285717,
0.009862802922725677,
-0.055632371455430984,
-0.021626347675919533,
-0.06392493098974228,
0.030533261597156525,
-0.0017812439473345876,
-0.025287730619311333,
-0.03388002887368202,
0.062424544245004654,
-0.046603407710790634,
-0.011313938535749912,
-0.0303525160998106,
0.023222964257001877,
0.028875645250082016,
0.04660562053322792,
0.033077336847782135,
-0.038434725254774094,
0.023597104474902153,
-0.05659640207886696,
-0.01076412107795477,
-0.02345990017056465,
0.1045125275850296,
-0.018348822370171547,
0.002811815356835723,
-0.032784752547740936,
0.03143789991736412,
0.021506119519472122,
0.029230209067463875,
-0.00023613024677615613,
-0.013043452985584736,
0.03124665841460228,
-0.008643217384815216,
-0.06494881957769394,
0.008021810092031956,
0.004266878589987755,
0.0019734736997634172,
0.002269468968734145,
0.018064038828015327,
-0.03468884900212288,
-0.0043319156393408775,
0.0005604835459962487,
0.051653459668159485,
-0.06599875539541245,
-0.012575600296258926,
-0.01619916968047619,
0.007831655442714691,
0.0009696829365566373,
-0.03968758136034012,
0.03247826546430588,
0.004139120690524578,
-0.006461501121520996,
0.02149496041238308,
0.011943561024963856,
-0.030561581254005432,
0.06349831819534302,
-0.01603897474706173,
0.017444944009184837,
-0.019551850855350494,
-0.0060593499802052975,
0.01092568226158619,
-0.03742850571870804,
-0.003280836855992675,
-0.019246315583586693,
0.03619126230478287,
-0.04292300343513489,
-0.024645637720823288,
-0.010392353869974613,
0.04070707783102989,
-0.008595691062510014,
0.01650683395564556,
-0.004964011255651712,
-0.018613412976264954,
0.009062337689101696,
-0.14166325330734253,
-0.030032219365239143,
0.026476463302969933,
-0.025717705488204956,
-0.012801360338926315,
-0.006343373563140631,
0.00939519889652729,
-0.04156496375799179,
-0.03837322071194649,
0.01644151844084263,
-0.01320374384522438,
0.020574558526277542,
0.005045877769589424,
0.0003370557096786797,
-0.023309679701924324,
0.013201922178268433,
0.00042381093953736126,
-0.026644445955753326,
-0.08469565212726593,
0.026060421019792557,
0.0018557929433882236,
0.04041064530611038,
0.020997164770960808,
-0.03775502368807793,
0.0016859191237017512,
-0.02270290069282055,
-0.040689047425985336,
-0.03584197163581848,
-0.035599395632743835,
-0.017057111486792564,
-0.015506663359701633,
0.03412124887108803,
0.006579043343663216,
0.04559871181845665,
-0.0010267803445458412,
-0.013523785397410393,
-0.007401082664728165,
-0.04608627408742905,
-0.023593813180923462,
-0.03655260428786278,
-0.044977735728025436,
0.04546887055039406,
-0.0323452427983284,
-0.04155191779136658,
-0.010395725257694721,
-0.00356275518424809,
0.002000864129513502,
-0.013938724994659424,
-0.047227587550878525,
-0.07754405587911606,
-0.034969575703144073,
-0.007263452745974064,
0.00008622087625553831,
0.03828779235482216,
-0.008357370272278786,
-0.016957497224211693,
-0.00455582607537508,
-0.0220074150711298,
-0.012404865585267544,
0.05090581253170967,
-0.024237962439656258,
0.004504636395722628,
-0.02516639418900013,
-0.022912127897143364,
-0.022781554609537125,
-0.009089132770895958,
-0.003331520827487111,
-0.026257570832967758,
-0.032206207513809204,
-0.008268607780337334,
-0.033521752804517746,
-0.015512415207922459,
-0.022324087098240852,
-0.031640924513339996,
0.0347895473241806,
-0.020528146997094154,
-0.001018799259327352,
-0.00857557263225317,
-0.02901841700077057,
-0.025531815364956856,
-0.01788509078323841,
-0.012653137557208538,
-0.02159823291003704,
-0.010782753117382526,
0.06963608413934708,
0.024654341861605644,
-0.007040618918836117,
-0.03785927593708038,
-0.017009811475872993,
-0.012523137964308262,
-0.04512481018900871,
-0.02378079481422901,
-0.008627849631011486,
0.014163822866976261,
-0.016374880447983742,
0.03093738481402397,
0.011626646853983402,
-0.0233111921697855,
0.011968519538640976,
-0.0021074970718473196,
0.003766176989302039,
0.01179391611367464,
-0.03333267942070961,
-0.011514555662870407,
-0.010285221971571445,
0.0030015301890671253,
0.02548356167972088,
-0.02560037188231945,
0.016011647880077362,
0.0309324711561203,
-0.02181299589574337,
-0.031828299164772034,
0.0035208826884627342,
0.03827501833438873,
-0.07033861428499222,
0.03952772542834282,
-0.033878032118082047,
0.051642224192619324,
0.00882530864328146,
-0.014486833475530148,
0.026004042476415634,
0.025608675554394722,
-0.00481542618945241,
-0.030930910259485245,
0.032514579594135284,
0.022602830082178116,
0.017042212188243866,
0.03992170840501785,
0.003056494751945138,
-0.01912081614136696,
0.05331737548112869,
-0.020797256380319595,
0.008532688021659851,
0.035127852112054825,
0.05358447879552841,
0.023098144680261612,
-0.016753261908888817,
0.01064178254455328,
-0.03225906565785408,
-0.038352057337760925,
-0.025740932673215866,
0.03363163024187088,
-0.021235443651676178,
0.0016950065037235618,
-0.031221330165863037,
-0.002395050833001733,
0.01960725337266922,
-0.026125270873308182,
-0.06868389993906021,
-0.006479144562035799,
-0.00003992672645836137,
-0.0037873091641813517,
-0.042839523404836655,
0.054187435656785965,
0.023509278893470764,
0.011173439212143421,
0.04732644557952881,
-0.00656529888510704,
0.022301895543932915,
0.0667148306965828,
0.031172972172498703,
-0.03785890340805054,
-0.08522668480873108,
-0.07728433609008789,
-0.04704327508807182,
0.00445098290219903,
-0.0457148440182209,
0.0033858497627079487,
-0.025773681700229645,
-0.04417048767209053,
-0.019373144954442978,
-0.0020722250919789076,
-0.018067216500639915,
-0.04926716536283493,
0.019108254462480545,
0.017239481210708618,
0.004823910538107157,
0.013486783020198345,
0.0291107427328825,
-0.013875392265617847,
0.04735257104039192,
0.03436356782913208,
0.023780303075909615,
0.017626458778977394,
-0.020918220281600952,
0.051494259387254715,
0.012561501935124397,
0.00617438368499279,
-0.01372892688959837,
-0.044132672250270844,
0.01838570274412632,
-0.02651968225836754,
0.03382005915045738,
-0.008604520931839943,
0.03180113434791565,
0.02474365569651127,
0.0024027428589761257,
0.05948174372315407,
0.02118697203695774,
0.043853409588336945,
0.0029622092843055725,
-0.020679980516433716,
-0.018313230946660042,
-0.048783838748931885,
-0.002860648324713111,
0.022890493273735046,
-0.00023661917657591403,
-0.021208688616752625,
-0.07402108609676361,
0.037457115948200226,
0.016500098630785942,
-0.0045858109369874,
-0.0015471490332856774,
0.030832603573799133,
-0.020241552963852882,
0.002797271590679884,
-0.006342746317386627,
0.027066288515925407,
-0.019387923181056976,
-0.006727734114974737,
0.017872069031000137,
0.04902063310146332,
-0.010507150553166866,
-0.0007283206796273589,
-0.022310690954327583,
-0.009122665040194988,
-0.004216778092086315,
0.055166758596897125,
0.015567519702017307,
0.007338112220168114,
-0.024078138172626495,
0.007434041704982519,
0.0017409371212124825,
0.038175731897354126,
0.016297761350870132,
-0.03798997774720192,
-0.030049201101064682,
-0.05779758468270302,
-0.01565314643085003,
-0.020484698936343193,
0.052227143198251724,
0.016725730150938034,
-0.0009223945671692491,
-0.017979957163333893
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:49
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
736The "settlement" that Mr Gillard was to "confirm" could only occur if funds were exchanged for the Withdrawal of Caveat.
737Mr Gillard said that:-
"It wasn't made clear to me that is what he intended (...) I don't think I [undertook] to write to him at all (...) I had no intention of writing to him about a settlement with Mr Moir".
738The transcript records Mr Gillard using the word "understood" rather than "undertook". However, the context makes clear that Mr Gillard said "undertook".
739In my opinion, Mr Gillard must be mistaken in his recollection. There was no reason for Mr Hilliard to write the note on his "to do" list unless it reflected not only his understanding but also Mr Gillard's agreement.
740I find, consistently with the terms of the undertaking given by Mr Gillard to Mr Hilliard, and consistently with Mr Hilliard's note, that Mr Gillard undertook to deliver the Withdrawal of Caveat to Mr Moir, to exchange it for $4.5 million, and to then write to Mr Hilliard confirming that he had "settled" with Mr Moir.
741That Mr Hilliard understood there was to be a separate "settlement" between Mr Gillard and Mr Moir is also confirmed by events immediately after the 27 August 2004 meeting concluded (at around 8pm).
742Mr Hilliard then rang Mr Moir and the following conversation took place:-
Mr Hilliard: "I expected that you would be attending the meeting today for the settlement with Robert Renshall and Brian Gillard".
Mr Moir: "I thought you knew I had arranged with Brian Gillard that we would do a separate settlement following your settlement?"
Mr Hilliard: "No I wasn't aware of that. I expected that I would be giving the Withdrawal of Caveat direct to you. However, Brian Gillard has undertaken that he will deliver it to you. I assume that you will then be lodging it with the RG's?"
Mr Moir: "Yes, I will be attending to the formalities of the discharges and lodging the Withdrawal of Caveat."
Mr Hilliard: "Brian Gillard has given me a copy of the draft Heads of Agreement between HTT and IPC. Robert Renshall tells me that it is a draft which has been superseded and that you have the original."
Mr Moir: "Yes. That must be an earlier version. I have the original which is dated 15 March 2004."
Mr Hilliard: "Can you provide a copy of that to me?"
Mr Moir: "Yes." (emphasis added)
743During the settlement (at around 6.30pm) Mr Moir sent Mr Hilliard an email concerning the 15 March 2004 IPC Heads of Agreement and confirming that the intention of that document was that IPC would take a 51 per cent controlling interest in the Project via the Huntley Trust and that the Huntley Trust would be the "joint venture vehicle" under that Heads of Agreement.
744In his reply (sent at 8.47pm) Mr Hilliard said:-
"Thanks for that. We have just completed the settlement. Would you please give Brian Gillard a copy of the agreement dated 15 March 2004 when he sees you for your settlement to give to me". (emphasis added)
745The emphasised words show clearly, in my opinion, that Mr Hilliard was contemplating that there would be a "settlement" between Mr Gillard and Mr Moir.
746There is no reference in the oral communications between Messrs Hilliard, Gillard and Moir to when the further "settlement" would take place.
747Mr Hilliard did not assert, in his evidence in chief, or under cross-examination, that Mr Gillard had made any statement to him about when the "settlement" with Mr Moir would take place.
748Mr Hilliard did say, in answer to a question I asked, that based on something that had been said to him on 27 August 2004, he understood that the $4.5 million would be paid to HTT over the "next week or so, indeed the next week".
749However, an expectation on the part of Mr Hilliard, as at 27 August 2004, that the $4.5 million would arrive "the next week" is irreconcilable with Mr Hilliard's and Mr Zdrilic's conduct during that next week.
|
[
-0.022390490397810936,
0.0277653057128191,
-0.027323974296450615,
-0.0007939598872326314,
0.0012405809247866273,
-0.04646444320678711,
0.007992873899638653,
0.005275083240121603,
0.014654790051281452,
-0.026351286098361015,
0.014032404869794846,
0.003944320138543844,
-0.041340313851833344,
0.01191803440451622,
-0.0343322679400444,
-0.01873483881354332,
0.04197390750050545,
-0.020364126190543175,
0.023032618686556816,
-0.023801671341061592,
-0.010966104455292225,
-0.02792147360742092,
0.006200964096933603,
0.05201130732893944,
-0.0218207910656929,
-0.02311486192047596,
-0.0059025585651397705,
0.006909695453941822,
0.03923575580120087,
0.007607319392263889,
-0.014591746963560581,
-0.009848653338849545,
0.015870582312345505,
0.010948125272989273,
-0.007329913787543774,
0.00864904373884201,
0.04013609141111374,
-0.013951626606285572,
-0.026781857013702393,
0.05537746101617813,
-0.03285468369722366,
0.0141409020870924,
-0.0031256317161023617,
-0.026142559945583344,
0.03458524867892265,
-0.03800710290670395,
-0.004076381679624319,
-0.010952873155474663,
0.006370071321725845,
0.035391274839639664,
-0.0578894168138504,
-0.04205908626317978,
0.013473876751959324,
-0.002050144597887993,
0.014023277908563614,
-0.020146910101175308,
-0.040822841227054596,
0.025596238672733307,
-0.02178838662803173,
-0.006291511934250593,
0.027613092213869095,
-0.03358887881040573,
-0.03631928563117981,
0.008569027297198772,
0.005190656054764986,
0.06724627315998077,
-0.0007299755816347897,
0.031627755612134933,
0.002318653045222163,
-0.02334815450012684,
-0.0465766042470932,
0.01734965853393078,
-0.003234760370105505,
-0.001188431167975068,
-0.07935008406639099,
0.02535327523946762,
0.03327667713165283,
-0.014988172799348831,
-0.004700346849858761,
0.034648358821868896,
0.045100994408130646,
-0.011723044328391552,
-0.012117273174226284,
0.023656273260712624,
-0.06087006255984306,
0.008792544715106487,
-0.01576976478099823,
0.03834288939833641,
0.02481831982731819,
-0.00941801629960537,
-0.0022552781738340855,
0.002994702197611332,
0.027646565809845924,
-0.04697452113032341,
-0.03193224221467972,
-0.03450329974293709,
-0.0266106016933918,
0.05362394079566002,
-0.036806076765060425,
-0.015131126157939434,
0.022008681669831276,
0.012525780126452446,
-0.025405965745449066,
-0.012454149313271046,
0.013675685971975327,
0.036002788692712784,
0.031422652304172516,
0.01441396027803421,
-0.009182463400065899,
-0.022601081058382988,
-0.005246308166533709,
0.0004497336340136826,
0.02235748991370201,
0.010078742168843746,
-0.007721446920186281,
-0.005234983749687672,
-0.011902528814971447,
-0.0075087277218699455,
0.06327438354492188,
0.008254175074398518,
0.051284197717905045,
0.014918825589120388,
0.05100223794579506,
-0.016718056052923203,
-0.04711208865046501,
0.0012156977318227291,
-0.011177348904311657,
-0.024417275562882423,
0.02472500130534172,
0.012150495313107967,
0.003307279432192445,
0.04952168092131615,
-0.03285224363207817,
-0.044695619493722916,
-0.018965302035212517,
-0.006862424314022064,
0.014477244578301907,
0.0007238812395371497,
0.008090618997812271,
-0.08247465640306473,
0.04476562514901161,
0.04610937088727951,
0.014903145842254162,
-0.05582970380783081,
0.026761803776025772,
-0.03609977290034294,
0.016456659883260727,
-0.0003854421083815396,
0.004026093985885382,
0.00676727807149291,
0.019522273913025856,
-0.00026616177638061345,
-0.0195241030305624,
-0.009817436337471008,
0.06418447196483612,
-0.057970210909843445,
0.013388796709477901,
-0.01205451786518097,
0.016179159283638,
0.09646059572696686,
-0.013905417174100876,
0.031022487208247185,
-0.016191452741622925,
-0.0012437155237421393,
-0.00803539901971817,
-0.007479492109268904,
0.0063341399654746056,
0.021935515105724335,
0.010465143248438835,
-0.01738395355641842,
0.025238893926143646,
-0.02342972718179226,
0.09152381867170334,
-0.009412058629095554,
0.01795891672372818,
0.030244631692767143,
0.09854744374752045,
0.003872769419103861,
0.026019422337412834,
-0.012252528220415115,
-0.033267710357904434,
0.05959828197956085,
0.000965750077739358,
-0.03751908242702484,
-0.030701396986842155,
0.04468253627419472,
-0.029622262343764305,
-0.04761166125535965,
0.002134927548468113,
0.014947707764804363,
-0.005942025687545538,
-0.009977465495467186,
0.04660586640238762,
0.05647054314613342,
0.026768622919917107,
0.0014915241627022624,
-0.007813694886863232,
-0.035046014934778214,
0.0040251826867461205,
-0.03033045493066311,
-0.02947542630136013,
0.02888493239879608,
0.05090272054076195,
-0.013379474170506,
-0.03836842626333237,
-0.002873190212994814,
-0.030752550810575485,
-0.04010326415300369,
0.03512906655669212,
-0.04818430915474892,
-0.0116066113114357,
0.013914013281464577,
-0.010328236036002636,
-0.022276263684034348,
0.0048002866096794605,
0.005836105905473232,
0.0056021385826170444,
-0.02958781272172928,
-0.011331315152347088,
-0.054917383939027786,
0.00998426228761673,
-0.00006476735143223777,
-0.01681162789463997,
-0.006330512929707766,
0.0033256523311138153,
0.09768396615982056,
-0.06619351357221603,
0.05011795461177826,
-0.011842407286167145,
-0.004386386834084988,
-0.006364177446812391,
-0.0019818986766040325,
0.02139587700366974,
-0.00021111781825311482,
0.02948097698390484,
0.050390709191560745,
-0.023436132818460464,
0.033418137580156326,
-0.0131702721118927,
0.010170184075832367,
-0.010053930804133415,
0.03400536999106407,
-0.01788334921002388,
0.024109553545713425,
-0.0029044696129858494,
-0.0006034885300323367,
-0.012932599522173405,
0.016665372997522354,
0.009222843684256077,
-0.010061956942081451,
0.008561915718019009,
0.0033915892709046602,
0.002502947812899947,
0.001996758859604597,
0.0030751286540180445,
0.04532407596707344,
0.0037730629555881023,
-0.010486850515007973,
0.047943178564310074,
0.03096923977136612,
0.06023787707090378,
0.0417960025370121,
0.03577302768826485,
0.01839069090783596,
-0.015111098065972328,
0.0019545683171600103,
-0.04407305642962456,
-0.04654546454548836,
0.03737573325634003,
-0.019910985603928566,
0.012931731529533863,
-0.014235944487154484,
-0.003467435948550701,
0.026951422914862633,
0.036342255771160126,
0.017377063632011414,
0.012227222323417664,
0.0046017952263355255,
0.010995951481163502,
0.001029929262585938,
-0.007790088653564453,
-0.004858592990785837,
0.037603043019771576,
-0.02422553114593029,
0.05117098614573479,
0.06611961126327515,
-0.009600761346518993,
0.017521651461720467,
0.014927325770258904,
-0.002547286683693528,
0.004286134149879217,
0.016130108386278152,
0.06510874629020691,
0.004860715474933386,
-0.017875123769044876,
-0.05898304656147957,
-0.02609981596469879,
-0.1453901082277298,
0.01353670097887516,
-0.01419338770210743,
0.010650044307112694,
0.002944481559097767,
0.0186149999499321,
-0.014484754763543606,
0.0007967082201503217,
-0.03368542343378067,
0.0341680683195591,
0.004065288230776787,
-0.04291378706693649,
0.00797093566507101,
0.030478481203317642,
-0.013269705697894096,
-0.020783495157957077,
-0.005814848933368921,
0.00559327332302928,
0.02644994668662548,
-0.03804583474993706,
0.001415751059539616,
-0.050832659006118774,
0.05634951591491699,
-0.016168607398867607,
0.011903776787221432,
0.029095912352204323,
-0.0032933158800005913,
0.014660905115306377,
-0.04520970955491066,
-0.01989120803773403,
-0.031808119267225266,
0.021073343232274055,
-0.019455915316939354,
0.07237739115953445,
-0.0315682552754879,
0.07477514445781708,
0.07310941070318222,
-0.07847211509943008,
0.010324979200959206,
-0.038130275905132294,
0.0069901542738080025,
0.039173003286123276,
-0.012239571660757065,
0.02625267207622528,
-0.008670889772474766,
-0.030705805867910385,
-0.0017638965509831905,
0.0076624546200037,
0.010449633933603764,
0.014249851927161217,
-0.010870222933590412,
0.008496547117829323,
-0.030722182244062424,
-0.03374117985367775,
-0.008972669020295143,
-0.01586027257144451,
0.03591021150350571,
0.05706792324781418,
-0.04703785106539726,
-0.000036614201235352084,
-0.009054693393409252,
-0.04170660302042961,
-0.011086300015449524,
0.0439041443169117,
-0.006258806679397821,
0.013554895296692848,
-0.0068529872223734856,
-0.039703618735075,
0.04276914894580841,
0.029829178005456924,
0.008242633193731308,
-0.018249940127134323,
0.011516375467181206,
-0.010881069116294384,
0.04105458781123161,
0.03675161302089691,
-0.030134189873933792,
0.007655482739210129,
0.00021817920787725598,
-0.09346980601549149,
-0.004905780777335167,
0.03213769942522049,
-0.016165997833013535,
0.04070102050900459,
0.004220492672175169,
0.023186614736914635,
0.01740477792918682,
0.050690945237874985,
0.009282246232032776,
0.26199427247047424,
0.006558332126587629,
-0.02477688528597355,
0.06713944673538208,
0.02504670061171055,
-0.02507423236966133,
0.005015088245272636,
0.013200287707149982,
-0.012882196344435215,
-0.04525172710418701,
0.010954816825687885,
0.024526339024305344,
-0.0008558068075217307,
-0.02008526585996151,
-0.00858401507139206,
0.04209349304437637,
-0.06922499090433121,
-0.021065043285489082,
0.08443894982337952,
0.003526104846969247,
0.048634666949510574,
-0.025633305311203003,
-0.012245534919202328,
0.0049080271273851395,
-0.08073301613330841,
-0.01934746839106083,
0.028870878741145134,
0.04487011581659317,
-0.03641791269183159,
0.014876979403197765,
-0.01862489990890026,
-0.0047461530193686485,
0.03579206019639969,
-0.008332334458827972,
0.014480860903859138,
0.02983294427394867,
0.007783306296914816,
-0.02795102261006832,
-0.007188580930233002,
0.03867550939321518,
-0.004210520535707474,
-0.055089354515075684,
-0.005847549997270107,
-0.07136556506156921,
-0.05745331570506096,
-0.0018596301088109612,
-0.02717466652393341,
0.042684342712163925,
-0.04580644890666008,
0.019119111821055412,
0.005237427074462175,
0.0018478967249393463,
0.01041547954082489,
0.019601641222834587,
0.006959181744605303,
0.05275900289416313,
-0.020677966997027397,
0.061538077890872955,
-0.004016235936433077,
0.03062109649181366,
0.010947315953671932,
0.01094051543623209,
-0.014197380281984806,
0.0010031206766143441,
0.0315762422978878,
-0.007377014495432377,
-0.06709649413824081,
-0.008422862738370895,
0.03365730121731758,
0.04748446121811867,
0.01847073994576931,
0.033529628068208694,
-0.021723942831158638,
0.024886971339583397,
0.032584842294454575,
0.00826337467879057,
-0.029133368283510208,
0.002372989896684885,
0.0024570398963987827,
0.01626935973763466,
-0.025399670004844666,
-0.04885927215218544,
-0.026546867564320564,
0.006036071572452784,
0.03060956671833992,
0.005621155258268118,
-0.050655871629714966,
0.0526767335832119,
-0.016197223216295242,
-0.019068175926804543,
-0.019653847441077232,
-0.022644497454166412,
-0.003470546333119273,
-0.03883820027112961,
0.005293089896440506,
-0.01941028982400894,
0.02287875860929489,
-0.00838558655232191,
-0.0373903252184391,
-0.037180688232183456,
-0.013579092919826508,
0.0023187946062535048,
0.03488333895802498,
-0.046112507581710815,
0.034935396164655685,
-0.00566980242729187,
-0.010912349447607994,
-0.0064351120963692665,
-0.05900052934885025,
-0.011294626630842686,
-0.00010202104022027925,
0.0036724801175296307,
0.006599821615964174,
-0.024581007659435272,
0.024863678961992264,
0.04912618175148964,
-0.016464507207274437,
0.04128365218639374,
0.014687853865325451,
0.027144163846969604,
0.0034478269517421722,
-0.004790291655808687,
-0.060585156083106995,
0.023711133748292923,
-0.00809530634433031,
-0.004539229907095432,
-0.025852281600236893,
-0.02099028415977955,
0.0030672396533191204,
0.00126831722445786,
0.004539175890386105,
-0.03115863911807537,
-0.016896603628993034,
0.0029968470335006714,
0.04329966381192207,
0.02643565647304058,
0.00973446574062109,
-0.02235490083694458,
-0.022242967039346695,
0.001694360631518066,
-0.05880069360136986,
0.02655418962240219,
-0.035618968307971954,
0.007279100827872753,
0.00014686152280773968,
0.013248924165964127,
-0.0678131952881813,
0.004215592052787542,
-0.06619442999362946,
0.0040925671346485615,
0.00597728556022048,
0.05304722487926483,
-0.05679820850491524,
-0.027728548273444176,
0.004611003212630749,
-0.020293252542614937,
-0.0031887663062661886,
0.0030409900937229395,
-0.02222173474729061,
-0.030519338324666023,
-0.0038603171706199646,
0.017150038853287697,
0.014893622137606144,
0.009441133588552475,
0.0085084717720747,
0.06652150303125381,
-0.005777423735707998,
0.0610484816133976,
0.0386841781437397,
-0.033715080469846725,
0.015068015083670616,
-0.03401448577642441,
0.0031999351922422647,
0.06601963192224503,
0.01528024859726429,
0.010378964245319366,
0.02647516503930092,
0.009847159497439861,
0.017287923023104668,
-0.006466145161539316,
0.025961585342884064,
-0.011176062747836113,
-0.03427311033010483,
0.0006654633907601237,
0.003792198607698083,
-0.0029230716172605753,
-0.01857348345220089,
-0.016268668696284294,
-0.00012077881547156721,
-0.044678471982479095,
-0.0002787457488011569,
0.056990284472703934,
0.0005624873447231948,
-0.00792471133172512,
0.024013642221689224,
0.0034256919752806425,
-0.03189798817038536,
0.030411459505558014,
-0.027936503291130066,
-0.016184449195861816,
0.0026618752162903547,
-0.024229200556874275,
0.04500994831323624,
-0.0031327621545642614,
0.01438883040100336,
0.019297296181321144,
0.0007634626817889512,
0.0529320053756237,
-0.04453583061695099,
-0.04271765798330307,
0.02335616946220398,
0.02462134324014187,
-0.05683562532067299,
0.007972175255417824,
0.019551916047930717,
-0.0554853156208992,
0.02745695412158966,
0.03000091202557087,
0.033367082476615906,
-0.051290448755025864,
-0.0015930189983919263,
-0.021740732714533806,
-0.010700470767915249,
-0.036274537444114685,
-0.034751515835523605,
0.0009934387635439634,
-0.04539835453033447,
-0.013192731887102127,
-0.02247689478099346,
-0.023341329768300056,
-0.003781768726184964,
-0.06129845231771469,
0.02305668033659458,
-0.05668364465236664,
0.004527569282799959,
-0.006237782537937164,
0.05067390203475952,
-0.011310151778161526,
0.04214746877551079,
0.015480616129934788,
0.03725506365299225,
-0.02168067917227745,
-0.016410553827881813,
0.03858433663845062,
-0.00017457810463383794,
-0.012840284034609795,
-0.015788672491908073,
-0.033836930990219116,
0.005362892989069223,
0.029006747528910637,
0.004925035405904055,
0.026940742507576942,
0.01849912852048874,
-0.00415933458134532,
-0.027963455766439438,
0.01401873305439949,
0.027157140895724297,
-0.04251551628112793,
-0.038673266768455505,
-0.02024511806666851,
0.012816594913601875,
0.01918664202094078,
-0.026315322145819664,
-0.010722720995545387,
-0.07254153490066528,
-0.07450772076845169,
-0.001383477938361466,
-0.038853175938129425,
0.0009250817238353193,
-0.026533018797636032,
0.02105025388300419,
-0.011607129126787186,
0.011144192889332771,
-0.03914874419569969,
-0.0071210963651537895,
0.0013494364684447646,
0.0065561747178435326,
-0.01163521595299244,
0.03898821398615837,
0.0058671957813203335,
-0.00977054238319397,
-0.01599578745663166,
0.04411773756146431,
0.008915634825825691,
-0.002463072771206498,
0.023912860080599785,
-0.004287109710276127,
0.0034460441675037146,
0.023198770359158516,
-0.029996775090694427,
0.01687617041170597,
0.006683332845568657,
0.0021697122137993574,
-0.005706171505153179,
0.027005968615412712,
-0.05486850067973137,
0.013194547034800053,
0.04650279879570007,
-0.025076696649193764,
0.004662930965423584,
-0.0233840961009264,
-0.01209308486431837,
-0.02788960374891758,
-0.004821465816348791,
-0.015012666583061218,
-0.017879977822303772,
0.02445097453892231,
0.014046571217477322,
-0.013878372497856617,
0.032562579959630966,
0.028115294873714447,
-0.10102488100528717,
0.0022085229866206646,
-0.02718331664800644,
0.04062945395708084,
-0.017385197803378105,
0.01498392503708601,
0.014411108568310738,
-0.03720983490347862,
0.013610683381557465,
0.01353636384010315,
0.0015674640890210867,
-0.04895644262433052,
0.008137280121445656,
-0.042613789439201355,
-0.008085689507424831,
0.03921402990818024,
-0.01989770494401455,
-0.054373376071453094,
0.00016095858882181346,
-0.02436918392777443,
-0.0024214424192905426,
0.007839762605726719,
0.014706936664879322,
0.004073097370564938,
-0.009817458689212799,
0.0060561406426131725,
0.010543116368353367,
0.06834249198436737,
-0.03181600198149681,
-0.024775447323918343,
-0.026039913296699524,
0.06759422272443771,
-0.008027175441384315,
0.008046425879001617,
-0.004725530277937651,
0.0029117753729224205,
-0.010672594420611858,
0.01088713202625513,
0.04141850769519806,
-0.034657929092645645,
0.03502030670642853,
-0.0025700568221509457,
-0.038027241826057434,
0.02093805931508541,
-0.008466239087283611,
-0.021280858665704727,
0.02884487248957157,
0.04738347604870796,
-0.02310076542198658,
0.0005949011538177729,
0.013288472779095173,
-0.0017020824598148465,
-0.01858038641512394,
-0.009696139954030514,
0.004279676824808121,
0.01306900940835476,
0.04890768229961395,
-0.018738646060228348,
0.02955881506204605,
-0.00024533746181987226,
-0.045471061021089554,
0.00691309105604887,
-0.010833398438990116,
-0.0459647998213768,
0.008916565217077732,
0.026098081842064857,
0.038312334567308426,
-0.005985536612570286,
-0.06872659921646118,
-0.0147238839417696,
-0.013890331611037254,
-0.02838083915412426,
-0.02602437511086464,
0.03873938322067261,
-0.01607174053788185,
-0.016868136823177338,
0.03212002292275429,
0.019963985309004784,
-0.013107335194945335,
-0.009026172570884228,
-0.008202279917895794,
-0.026385366916656494,
-0.027614112943410873,
-0.14335760474205017,
0.005889444146305323,
0.0050231595523655415,
-0.03987256810069084,
-0.028074752539396286,
-0.004663340747356415,
-0.03581387549638748,
-0.008604323491454124,
-0.02890794910490513,
-0.0205486211925745,
-0.015605863183736801,
-0.013231717050075531,
-0.009650073945522308,
0.001621462288312614,
-0.03865883871912956,
0.02229500561952591,
-0.028480570763349533,
-0.012884287163615227,
-0.0737328827381134,
0.04548267275094986,
0.017209678888320923,
-0.001594433095306158,
0.005853696726262569,
0.014574364759027958,
0.053811121731996536,
-0.013542752712965012,
-0.000019524946765159257,
-0.05540881305932999,
-0.03891415894031525,
-0.013673940673470497,
-0.06543765962123871,
0.013826980255544186,
-0.01868773065507412,
0.07036180049180984,
-0.003015818540006876,
0.01704329252243042,
0.02795727550983429,
-0.03750769421458244,
0.012171022593975067,
-0.01000545360147953,
0.004965540952980518,
0.03361334651708603,
0.008295327425003052,
-0.041956398636102676,
-0.009642723947763443,
0.015392761677503586,
-0.03287436440587044,
0.0038826654199510813,
-0.06927891075611115,
-0.022485503926873207,
-0.049507878720760345,
0.029757795855402946,
0.013590547256171703,
0.035542480647563934,
-0.004641334991902113,
-0.002973909955471754,
0.009673170745372772,
-0.033957310020923615,
0.04396593198180199,
0.05288428068161011,
0.03867487981915474,
0.000009181556379189715,
-0.06461329013109207,
-0.030032599344849586,
-0.010851462371647358,
-0.03252106532454491,
-0.04974495992064476,
-0.009793940000236034,
0.008615627884864807,
0.01283386442810297,
-0.028957096859812737,
0.016108259558677673,
0.004201550502330065,
-0.01759270206093788,
0.011729712598025799,
-0.051505498588085175,
0.010580510832369328,
0.02098110131919384,
-0.04062088951468468,
-0.0067167701199650764,
-0.030916700139641762,
-0.03143951669335365,
-0.06211825832724571,
-0.03491992503404617,
0.02302205190062523,
0.027965078130364418,
0.00020461635722313076,
-0.016677992418408394,
0.000947094988077879,
-0.025285083800554276,
-0.038406871259212494,
0.004584959242492914,
0.013706475496292114,
0.03312921151518822,
-0.0432245209813118,
0.010585574433207512,
0.0005835688789375126,
-0.02726767212152481,
-0.030983492732048035,
0.016463592648506165,
-0.04631014168262482,
-0.030407562851905823,
-0.0010178235825151205,
0.022950949147343636,
-0.015454486012458801,
-0.012574671767652035,
0.058469902724027634,
-0.002269366290420294,
0.017792662605643272,
-0.03645778074860573,
-0.002493880223482847,
-0.0042595467530190945,
-0.05943571403622627,
0.01176762767136097,
-0.02997763268649578,
0.007704544346779585,
0.0028477173764258623,
0.009256870485842228,
-0.032902613282203674,
0.03336048498749733,
0.004113449715077877,
-0.008199740201234818,
0.01247969176620245,
-0.009276085533201694,
0.02681160718202591,
0.0021725886035710573,
0.07680007815361023,
0.009465767070651054,
0.04312464967370033,
-0.012547684833407402,
0.03599296882748604,
-0.007416338659822941,
0.015529511496424675,
0.00990881398320198,
-0.006889017298817635,
0.012896220199763775,
-0.038577985018491745,
0.010383863002061844,
-0.028152398765087128,
0.002322935964912176,
0.02321203425526619,
-0.009867877699434757,
-0.015423610806465149,
0.010355747304856777,
-0.05326594412326813,
-0.024354303255677223,
0.019473617896437645,
0.013148022815585136,
-0.045559704303741455,
0.0038582608103752136,
-0.03469786047935486,
0.00740658538416028,
0.009190117940306664,
0.02805544063448906,
0.022536687552928925,
0.01406036876142025,
0.03063896670937538,
-0.00267933146096766,
0.011348702944815159,
0.013738972134888172,
-0.015239906497299671,
-0.04640485718846321,
-0.013478424400091171,
-0.05052606761455536,
-0.010052328929305077,
0.028504975140094757,
-0.005206122994422913,
0.028653349727392197,
-0.03249634802341461,
-0.017577234655618668,
-0.029116585850715637,
-0.005274512339383364,
-0.01835736259818077,
0.027557624503970146,
0.04918557405471802,
-0.008779739029705524,
-0.010345911607146263,
-0.030597859993577003,
0.0632999911904335,
0.00148403225466609,
0.015088138170540333,
0.02243909053504467,
0.022638307884335518,
0.00596061535179615,
0.0394800640642643,
0.016842730343341827,
-0.0038028995040804148,
-0.006064442917704582,
-0.040545981377363205,
0.0035113163758069277,
-0.01720774732530117,
-0.024025389924645424,
0.024181334301829338,
-0.0007235626108013093,
0.027533961459994316,
0.031585875898599625,
-0.012128918431699276,
-0.002045572502538562,
-0.010224150493741035,
-0.0038117123767733574,
0.062318988144397736,
-0.026271842420101166,
-0.027661263942718506,
0.004927456844598055,
-0.03106674924492836,
0.03840405493974686,
-0.00868942029774189,
-0.05551048740744591,
-0.03129430487751961,
0.05857757851481438,
-0.024230629205703735,
0.013258853927254677,
-0.024338314309716225,
-0.006224323529750109,
-0.038264453411102295,
0.03288859874010086,
0.020909054204821587,
-0.03208364173769951,
0.0334935337305069,
-0.03914133459329605,
0.023395193740725517,
0.04965456947684288,
-0.006394363474100828,
-0.03750716149806976,
0.0017906718421727419,
0.0010496621252968907,
0.013577458448708057,
0.009327554143965244,
-0.0035469585563987494,
0.02049584500491619,
-0.032059576362371445,
0.0024397633969783783,
0.01266518048942089,
0.03138658404350281,
0.018030676990747452,
-0.027209235355257988,
-0.03711725398898125,
-0.008721308782696724,
-0.03107159212231636,
-0.0018945122137665749,
0.05310283228754997,
0.002491579158231616,
0.010224067606031895,
-0.031262461096048355
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:6
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
87The idea was that the Zdrilic interests would participate in the Project by having an equal shareholding (with the Renshall and Hickie) interests in Sentel. Sentel would, in turn, hold a 27.5 per cent interest in HTT and the Huntley Trust.
88The proposed structure can be illustrated as follows:-
89As I have mentioned, the plaintiffs claim that in reliance on the representations, they entered into, inter alia, the Heads of Agreement.
90The Heads of Agreement recited that:-
"The parties to these Heads of Agreement have agreed to resolve their disputes on the basis set out herein which essentially involves the formation of a new company to be known as Sentel Pty Limited ('Sentel') in which they or their nominees will equally hold together with the smaller shareholders the issued share capital and Sentel in turn will recognise their loans and hold approximately 34.
75% of the issued capital of HTT and approximately 34.75% of the units in the Huntley Trust and LEC will withdraw the Caveat and otherwise surrender its claim against HTT and Hickie".
91The Heads of Agreement, in order to become effective, required a number of transactions to be entered into. A settlement of those transactions was contemplated.
92A significant obligation in Heads of Agreement was found in clause 4.7 which stated:-
"HTT shall obtain sufficient finance from a new funder (estimated at but not limited to approximately $12 million) to payout [existing mortgagees] and any other creditor holding security over the Huntley Mine, and to purchase the complimentary [sic] land (...) and to prepay 6 months interest on the loans from the new funder."
93Clause 4.8 of the Heads of Agreement stated:-
"The parties acknowledge that HTT will or is likely to require further debt and/or equity funding to complete the rehabilitation of the Huntley Mine (and the complimentary [sic] land) and to complete the development of that land for the best possible return..."
94A final settlement of the transactions took place on 27 August 2004. On that date the Non-Dilution Deed was executed and Short Minutes of Order providing for the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings were signed. A Withdrawal of the Caveat was also handed over. The events leading to, and occurring on and after the 27 August 2004 settlement are considered in detail below.
95By reason of the Non-Dilution deed, Sentel's equity in HTT and the Huntley Trust became 27.5 per cent, rather than a slightly higher percentage contemplated earlier.
The particular representations
96The seventeen representations fall into four broad categories.
Representations as to the availability of finance and the financial position of IPC
97The plaintiffs claim the representations made were that:-
(a)IPC was of financial substance;
(b)IPC would become a joint venture partner with HTT, with the controlling interest in HHT;
(c)IPC would purchase at least 51 per cent of shares and units in HTT and the Huntley Trust;
(d)IPC would provide finance to payout existing mortgages over the Land; and
(e)IPC would provide substantial sums required to effect the Project.
Representations as to restrictions imposed by IPC
98The plaintiffs claim that Mr Renshall and HTT represented that IPC would not agree that:-
(a)Mr Zdrilic have the right of veto at HTT board meetings;
(b)Mr Zdrilic be a director of HTT at all; and
(c)HTT provide security to Mr Zdrilic in respect of a loan Mr Zdrilic had made to LEC.
Representations as to Mr Renshall's interest in the Huntley Trust
99The plaintiffs relied upon representations alleged to be made by HTT as to the extent to which units controlled by Mr Renshall in the Huntley Trust were available to be transferred to Sentel. In closing submissions this aspect of the claim was not pressed.
Representations as at IPC representation on the board of HTT
|
[
-0.02326078899204731,
0.04492628201842308,
0.01681153103709221,
0.012164438143372536,
-0.02444710209965706,
-0.059383146464824677,
0.026737377047538757,
-0.00014897077926434577,
0.02297391928732395,
-0.009021316654980183,
0.02071373537182808,
0.018006009981036186,
-0.020459413528442383,
0.01927804760634899,
-0.045325398445129395,
-0.04115496203303337,
0.041385117918252945,
-0.03514240309596062,
-0.005205122288316488,
-0.025983333587646484,
-0.025663405656814575,
-0.0064092837274074554,
0.007973442785441875,
0.02825348637998104,
-0.01939437724649906,
0.01361838635057211,
-0.055190425366163254,
0.0294804684817791,
0.038454338908195496,
0.018926074728369713,
0.030346229672431946,
0.03710317984223366,
0.055426035076379776,
-0.016407355666160583,
0.004443261306732893,
-0.04111238569021225,
0.03343505784869194,
-0.0014051038306206465,
-0.0389070101082325,
0.000005883697212993866,
0.010102897882461548,
0.006201597396284342,
0.026286546140909195,
-0.01706501841545105,
0.04968603700399399,
-0.0422280877828598,
-0.004512866027653217,
-0.03920699656009674,
0.0012858123518526554,
0.04305862635374069,
-0.05652066320180893,
-0.019523127004504204,
0.03794005140662193,
-0.013268603943288326,
0.0041368198581039906,
-0.0012334577040746808,
-0.030339326709508896,
0.010986736044287682,
-0.05649776756763458,
-0.006024529691785574,
0.0006112469709478319,
-0.007485880982130766,
-0.04740840196609497,
0.0059149912558496,
0.029690558090806007,
0.0813111960887909,
0.020985962823033333,
0.006808577571064234,
0.0023699263110756874,
-0.021727710962295532,
-0.03769164904952049,
0.0006081054452806711,
-0.036794714629650116,
-0.02296355366706848,
-0.0893225371837616,
0.03571043163537979,
0.02414843626320362,
0.014211541973054409,
0.026536958292126656,
0.005209749564528465,
0.03469261899590492,
-0.0345420241355896,
-0.03292020037770271,
0.037892043590545654,
-0.026067135855555534,
0.03189965337514877,
-0.038008276373147964,
0.04151337966322899,
0.024828512221574783,
-0.04385355859994888,
-0.01776769571006298,
-0.00932702049612999,
0.015737485140562057,
-0.0204263087362051,
1.8215594366211008e-7,
0.01219176221638918,
-0.09518276154994965,
0.011998237110674381,
0.008740575984120369,
0.012338190339505672,
0.005967454984784126,
0.020495496690273285,
-0.022761233150959015,
-0.024203142151236534,
0.004626336507499218,
0.012383731082081795,
0.048893917351961136,
0.0263386070728302,
0.031398702412843704,
0.01677354983985424,
0.01301000639796257,
-0.037979841232299805,
-0.0032053820323199034,
0.015236679464578629,
-0.0076649184338748455,
-0.01817002147436142,
0.015237180516123772,
-0.028497811406850815,
0.033943060785532,
0.016110746189951897,
0.03262992575764656,
0.000550170021597296,
0.024690674617886543,
-0.0038282587192952633,
-0.039518073201179504,
-0.010852871462702751,
-0.007137123961001635,
0.025468744337558746,
0.014622247777879238,
0.043619558215141296,
0.0014656512066721916,
0.006245973985642195,
-0.01810597814619541,
-0.021925639361143112,
-0.015325294807553291,
0.027228176593780518,
0.003544349456205964,
0.016620155423879623,
0.0023355474695563316,
-0.048165153712034225,
0.061197955161333084,
0.01786871626973152,
-0.0028204249683767557,
-0.04957721382379532,
0.02042306587100029,
-0.01367021631449461,
0.019665293395519257,
0.028698138892650604,
0.017852339893579483,
0.05631299316883087,
0.01725967973470688,
0.010393346659839153,
0.020355544984340668,
0.01576291024684906,
0.011759242042899132,
-0.02672107331454754,
0.006066466681659222,
-0.030514966696500778,
0.0431755967438221,
0.0732467919588089,
-0.05477936938405037,
0.018850041553378105,
-0.019261734560132027,
-0.05182104557752609,
-0.015332584269344807,
0.014186838641762733,
-0.00495320837944746,
0.02852133847773075,
-0.028161749243736267,
0.015227718278765678,
0.026280686259269714,
0.011728822253644466,
0.03752930089831352,
-0.0222646351903677,
0.004654280375689268,
0.0306874830275774,
0.06666877865791321,
0.013878854922950268,
-0.019210562109947205,
-0.008859407156705856,
-0.03413334861397743,
0.03472688049077988,
0.0025772450026124716,
-0.051357485353946686,
-0.04944869503378868,
0.03704813867807388,
-0.02756020799279213,
-0.011643161065876484,
-0.0028494272846728563,
0.055164311081171036,
-0.012094133533537388,
-0.0019893127027899027,
0.0626569390296936,
0.00491981441155076,
0.017209762707352638,
-0.01754068024456501,
-0.006282503716647625,
-0.03870817646384239,
0.04388510808348656,
0.0068523697555065155,
0.00796560849994421,
0.030919820070266724,
0.03666967153549194,
-0.04301726073026657,
-0.06466664373874664,
0.03107624687254429,
-0.01999388262629509,
0.0022762129083275795,
-0.039199549704790115,
-0.04644378274679184,
-0.017607921734452248,
0.003595174988731742,
0.02703472226858139,
-0.015347716398537159,
0.003644698765128851,
-0.003952916711568832,
0.0170756746083498,
-0.017190156504511833,
0.026717450469732285,
-0.03183057904243469,
-0.023499537259340286,
-0.008199755102396011,
0.002402252983301878,
0.04986582323908806,
0.027279574424028397,
0.03695852681994438,
-0.03912726044654846,
0.020444029942154884,
-0.03791298717260361,
0.014681540429592133,
-0.020029643550515175,
-0.025564206764101982,
0.009384904988110065,
-0.027357013896107674,
0.049602899700403214,
0.03928440064191818,
0.041898418217897415,
-0.009789742529392242,
0.044883761554956436,
-0.008630583062767982,
-0.03921717777848244,
0.02938597835600376,
-0.0012548378435894847,
-0.013427097350358963,
-0.05599699914455414,
0.002777265850454569,
-0.01582779549062252,
0.015990959480404854,
0.03546523675322533,
-0.029204266145825386,
-0.017486879602074623,
0.01414187066257,
-0.030427532270550728,
0.0041514006443321705,
-0.0008602034067735076,
0.03706395626068115,
-0.00599990738555789,
-0.01170168537646532,
0.006051706150174141,
0.02755412645637989,
0.017160501331090927,
0.0018755353521555662,
0.07254903018474579,
0.006025093141943216,
0.0032078472431749105,
0.015098847448825836,
-0.01779772713780403,
-0.0396132692694664,
0.028714487329125404,
0.03994952514767647,
0.0018793212948367,
0.03866742551326752,
0.010384281165897846,
-0.0014297637389972806,
0.007409353274852037,
-0.024165282025933266,
-0.01589009165763855,
0.014236466959118843,
0.0035935607738792896,
0.009968952275812626,
0.0030527415219694376,
-0.032886866480112076,
0.04389369115233421,
-0.0584733709692955,
0.030359286814928055,
0.05617571249604225,
-0.01573801040649414,
-0.025850754231214523,
0.038930002599954605,
-0.062455758452415466,
-0.011969291605055332,
-0.00656495476141572,
0.0855017602443695,
-0.004804681520909071,
-0.05509183928370476,
-0.005184333771467209,
-0.05924049764871597,
-0.14970913529396057,
-0.0029326356016099453,
-0.02578296698629856,
0.0009872998343780637,
0.013574863784015179,
0.019363200291991234,
-0.025895411148667336,
-0.008793177083134651,
-0.02383776195347309,
0.00209606159478426,
-0.01636495254933834,
-0.06584914028644562,
-0.03357315436005592,
0.006678584031760693,
-0.010837933048605919,
-0.025572121143341064,
-0.013368992134928703,
0.021033771336078644,
0.022479962557554245,
-0.0080967852845788,
0.0182651374489069,
-0.053503602743148804,
0.09288208186626434,
0.001956276362761855,
0.0066499290987849236,
0.02346910908818245,
-0.00990101508796215,
0.028598729521036148,
-0.03368232399225235,
0.0020836559124290943,
0.012762933038175106,
0.020345237106084824,
-0.013443795032799244,
0.05063721910119057,
0.008166898041963577,
0.022511513903737068,
0.06561792641878128,
-0.05195177346467972,
-0.00873284786939621,
-0.009856559336185455,
0.030944539234042168,
0.04695376008749008,
0.0319855622947216,
0.00020148965995758772,
-0.0015277110505849123,
-0.03818897530436516,
0.01207378227263689,
-0.016046714037656784,
0.0025877789594233036,
0.030623823404312134,
-0.0011012431932613254,
0.02041284739971161,
-0.02357148751616478,
-0.057526446878910065,
-0.01255385484546423,
-0.02625972218811512,
0.06313669681549072,
0.018979929387569427,
-0.026866581290960312,
-0.02628723345696926,
-0.032449979335069656,
-0.04683130234479904,
0.021244589239358902,
0.02911985106766224,
-0.0050227465108036995,
0.00807704497128725,
-0.00575120048597455,
-0.027172574773430824,
0.016846677288413048,
-0.023084016516804695,
0.015254114754498005,
-0.023432251065969467,
-0.02996882051229477,
-0.04454401507973671,
0.012268953025341034,
0.011171058751642704,
-0.039786648005247116,
0.004690387286245823,
-0.004596211481839418,
-0.09713124483823776,
-0.006692077033221722,
0.02631942741572857,
-0.027838638052344322,
0.028169769793748856,
-0.01418937649577856,
0.016644248738884926,
0.028474517166614532,
0.036617085337638855,
0.029021386057138443,
0.2408982813358307,
-0.007833494804799557,
0.02056409977376461,
0.017907174304127693,
0.03882937878370285,
0.011889254674315453,
0.03276972472667694,
0.04588586464524269,
-0.014549948275089264,
-0.027669725939631462,
-0.03880845755338669,
-0.00439593568444252,
0.015747560188174248,
0.04161963239312172,
-0.024520542472600937,
0.02812209352850914,
-0.0037810513749718666,
-0.016915934160351753,
0.04183575138449669,
-0.036948904395103455,
0.0254854504019022,
-0.003663070499897003,
-0.01106320135295391,
-0.006290809717029333,
-0.02941145934164524,
-0.017481211572885513,
0.04620036855340004,
0.045830000191926956,
-0.06833066046237946,
0.00751921720802784,
-0.00018692802404984832,
-0.0018994364654645324,
0.05589514970779419,
0.006209356710314751,
-0.015466947108507156,
-0.00741892633959651,
-0.015248381532728672,
0.017614705488085747,
0.0032184235751628876,
0.05930246412754059,
0.01173301413655281,
-0.04230760410428047,
-0.018211569637060165,
-0.016027355566620827,
-0.03853555768728256,
0.04295283183455467,
-0.0178139079362154,
0.031776998192071915,
0.024387123063206673,
0.028279880061745644,
-0.010952129028737545,
0.016427673399448395,
-0.03084694780409336,
-0.015828099101781845,
0.003930546343326569,
0.007423250004649162,
-0.04171069338917732,
0.0448828749358654,
0.02262328751385212,
0.0056131500750780106,
0.02081693336367607,
0.012973408214747906,
-0.03908681869506836,
-0.006407242268323898,
-0.021568909287452698,
-0.04107825458049774,
-0.10933830589056015,
0.020897990092635155,
0.05190898850560188,
0.036808911710977554,
0.07330089807510376,
0.007576430682092905,
-0.017153393477201462,
-0.004953662399202585,
0.03349962830543518,
-0.0031633134931325912,
-0.018647359684109688,
-0.011315831914544106,
0.013294738717377186,
0.012628164142370224,
-0.05941801518201828,
-0.03642386943101883,
-0.027554631233215332,
0.02861662209033966,
0.014360870234668255,
0.010313009843230247,
-0.03289300203323364,
0.035984139889478683,
-0.043517377227544785,
-0.029975831508636475,
0.00675348611548543,
-0.03264781832695007,
0.04034924507141113,
0.020765874534845352,
-0.025951558724045753,
-0.033205918967723846,
0.026079965755343437,
-0.017316339537501335,
-0.05235615000128746,
0.0015450187493115664,
0.0077999490313231945,
0.002888905117288232,
0.005187994800508022,
-0.047588396817445755,
0.004602142609655857,
0.004545434378087521,
0.019532544538378716,
0.024795977398753166,
-0.056102633476257324,
0.025313928723335266,
0.020079532638192177,
0.014688254334032536,
0.016588138416409492,
-0.017710980027914047,
0.024272458627820015,
0.02568039298057556,
-0.03937934339046478,
0.07139479368925095,
0.03842814266681671,
0.03985685855150223,
0.027062222361564636,
0.007618941366672516,
-0.05244823545217514,
-0.055727072060108185,
0.024413079023361206,
-0.024888508021831512,
-0.02494974620640278,
0.0069527155719697475,
0.010082127526402473,
0.008806101977825165,
0.0025258043315261602,
-0.010008612647652626,
-0.024205755442380905,
0.03672819212079048,
0.026611482724547386,
-0.0008466467843391001,
0.026174943894147873,
0.0014844664838165045,
-0.01953011006116867,
-0.012447824701666832,
-0.05298912525177002,
-0.009613506495952606,
-0.011236445978283882,
-0.026525618508458138,
0.00741849048063159,
0.02095738984644413,
-0.02033795602619648,
0.008773183450102806,
-0.05855531990528107,
-0.012399242259562016,
-0.012904454953968525,
0.008954363875091076,
-0.01587219536304474,
-0.0444386750459671,
0.017435863614082336,
0.000420228810980916,
-0.017310388386249542,
-0.03451103717088699,
-0.0017047756118699908,
-0.006946553476154804,
-0.00631309300661087,
0.003705199807882309,
0.029386650770902634,
0.01802637241780758,
0.017688490450382233,
0.08064183592796326,
-0.0301592368632555,
0.0372442826628685,
0.01759539358317852,
-0.03183664754033089,
-0.025994757190346718,
-0.04377368465065956,
-0.01171062607318163,
0.04227786138653755,
-0.01027426403015852,
0.023303013294935226,
0.041924238204956055,
0.0011123496806249022,
0.01194346696138382,
-0.040943946689367294,
0.05904531106352806,
0.0028112223371863365,
-0.0660366639494896,
-0.002684124279767275,
-0.003027880098670721,
-0.020039519295096397,
-0.03743752837181091,
-0.014111709780991077,
0.09252776205539703,
-0.055583056062459946,
-0.0447818785905838,
0.07540585845708847,
0.0024785238783806562,
-0.03341928869485855,
0.026308132335543633,
-0.0076445057056844234,
-0.020694779232144356,
0.05277907848358154,
0.008094673976302147,
-0.03975857421755791,
-0.008376823738217354,
0.014944599941372871,
0.00100039504468441,
-0.05484497547149658,
0.02700967714190483,
-0.01737104170024395,
-0.013675197958946228,
0.0411347895860672,
-0.038781337440013885,
-0.02619894966483116,
0.028416724875569344,
0.008466893807053566,
-0.022676946595311165,
0.027093421667814255,
0.0061027174815535545,
-0.04174283146858215,
0.005240392871201038,
0.027989018708467484,
-0.039244864135980606,
-0.055668652057647705,
0.02269117161631584,
-0.02546786330640316,
0.034705158323049545,
-0.06884485483169556,
-0.02232372760772705,
0.007879476994276047,
-0.024348394945263863,
-0.017060020938515663,
-0.024441439658403397,
0.017411362379789352,
0.0011947120074182749,
-0.07386405020952225,
0.04047030583024025,
-0.01771746203303337,
-0.004339371807873249,
-0.03296356648206711,
0.0361749529838562,
-0.007285257335752249,
0.009777276776731014,
-0.02595449611544609,
0.0470779724419117,
-0.006420304533094168,
0.023145509883761406,
0.0722338929772377,
0.023019254207611084,
-0.004945661872625351,
-0.010269681923091412,
0.011943497695028782,
0.00093727873172611,
0.04541182518005371,
-0.0028407657518982887,
0.03142371028661728,
0.03488197550177574,
-0.019114801660180092,
0.009462951682507992,
-0.009765340015292168,
0.03233734145760536,
-0.039322786033153534,
-0.03201347589492798,
-0.015234541147947311,
-0.016366327181458473,
0.004908326547592878,
0.014618624933063984,
-0.026024581864476204,
-0.05957900732755661,
-0.03250352665781975,
0.01837395317852497,
-0.03249778226017952,
-0.024991929531097412,
-0.003864346304908395,
-0.008938786573708057,
-0.025630367919802666,
0.005396708846092224,
-0.07457106560468674,
0.03036200813949108,
-0.006273952778428793,
0.0001577037328388542,
-0.002385931322351098,
-0.024420149624347687,
-0.014518175274133682,
-0.0004897307371720672,
-0.006076909601688385,
0.03967968374490738,
0.021492106840014458,
-0.014579178765416145,
0.008709217421710491,
-0.017831100150942802,
-0.0262767244130373,
-0.00047792590339668095,
-0.004800968803465366,
0.029417265206575394,
-0.03255508840084076,
-0.013983338139951229,
-0.015495159663259983,
0.010234775952994823,
-0.02413375861942768,
0.008985279127955437,
0.03203684464097023,
0.004680403508245945,
-0.009089319035410881,
-0.021639179438352585,
-0.02104613184928894,
-0.04938502609729767,
-0.051195308566093445,
-0.04137837514281273,
0.010809195227921009,
0.01144518330693245,
0.00953709613531828,
-0.057366255670785904,
0.020621944218873978,
-0.005347003228962421,
-0.03146769851446152,
0.03826066851615906,
-0.011271879076957703,
0.0619039386510849,
0.025159675627946854,
0.035796213895082474,
-0.017116686329245567,
-0.011542693711817265,
-0.017688175663352013,
-0.00859906617552042,
-0.01869913935661316,
-0.043128851801157,
-0.025514699518680573,
-0.03697090223431587,
-0.007225037086755037,
0.038091547787189484,
-0.028894761577248573,
-0.0354856438934803,
0.02591591700911522,
-0.006937248166650534,
0.00814011786133051,
0.006853736005723476,
0.00824256706982851,
0.022616729140281677,
0.048603784292936325,
0.005761005450040102,
-0.018522057682275772,
0.03309488669037819,
-0.05427301302552223,
-0.012771635316312313,
-0.08385498076677322,
0.029172202572226524,
-0.05096793174743652,
0.02819015271961689,
0.0258551687002182,
-0.018964413553476334,
-0.01576278731226921,
-0.006190876942127943,
-0.011087299324572086,
-0.012564153410494328,
-0.00688308198004961,
-0.00926673598587513,
-0.040867481380701065,
0.015274746343493462,
-0.012678149156272411,
0.03735841065645218,
0.0022209323942661285,
0.04060957580804825,
-0.042103562504053116,
-0.006175207439810038,
0.02688814327120781,
0.03728359937667847,
-0.01568313129246235,
0.022484607994556427,
0.00427914597094059,
-0.023632222786545753,
0.018323825672268867,
0.030721424147486687,
-0.009374549612402916,
-0.0022035357542335987,
-0.06457040458917618,
-0.04027201235294342,
0.013293823227286339,
-0.014470621943473816,
0.023112894967198372,
-0.0021247530821710825,
0.03697901591658592,
-0.01706741750240326,
-0.04101401939988136,
-0.001642808085307479,
-0.005377581808716059,
0.0022701225243508816,
-0.01819513365626335,
0.02047153003513813,
-0.014609954319894314,
-0.006222509779036045,
0.00700896792113781,
0.02200940065085888,
0.016649896278977394,
0.013818483799695969,
0.010074814781546593,
-0.027865245938301086,
0.005229848437011242,
-0.13128912448883057,
-0.0327458381652832,
-0.0038649423513561487,
-0.023692982271313667,
0.01725497469305992,
-0.001737808110192418,
-0.0031597893685102463,
-0.0007272061775438488,
-0.016195544973015785,
-0.004657382145524025,
-0.0026702629402279854,
-0.028462853282690048,
0.017577942460775375,
-0.023209556937217712,
-0.00014029163867235184,
-0.0014560712734237313,
-0.05673960596323013,
-0.001708836411125958,
-0.054190706461668015,
-0.011931086890399456,
0.012328429147601128,
0.0295090451836586,
0.018557265400886536,
0.007557888049632311,
0.01765519194304943,
0.009383703581988811,
-0.02344789355993271,
-0.04868992790579796,
-0.0239400751888752,
-0.0078434394672513,
-0.02357095666229725,
0.019885849207639694,
0.011974307708442211,
0.05885351449251175,
0.018167845904827118,
-0.005075349472463131,
0.012892286293208599,
-0.024447083473205566,
-0.00538648571819067,
-0.002181887160986662,
-0.015621761791408062,
0.027395954355597496,
-0.04299352318048477,
-0.036191657185554504,
-0.018122592940926552,
0.06374629586935043,
0.00582360802218318,
-0.018445614725351334,
-0.07608694583177567,
-0.013839892111718655,
-0.012593413703143597,
0.020355841144919395,
0.028007416054606438,
0.03146069869399071,
0.04110804572701454,
-0.01964537613093853,
0.013364115729928017,
-0.035647690296173096,
0.03170221298933029,
-0.0012252872111275792,
-0.008847495540976524,
-0.008092495612800121,
-0.023606831207871437,
-0.015522405505180359,
-0.029165616258978844,
-0.009076996706426144,
-0.043032046407461166,
0.0010466856183484197,
0.00838270504027605,
0.028065966442227364,
-0.01666697859764099,
-0.012946194969117641,
-0.0097196651622653,
-0.0374724455177784,
0.04133138805627823,
-0.02615303359925747,
0.018000807613134384,
-0.008177348412573338,
-0.022171396762132645,
-0.020375363528728485,
-0.05751500651240349,
-0.04527708515524864,
-0.03463329002261162,
0.001219455967657268,
0.06018960848450661,
0.03828907012939453,
-0.009520900435745716,
-0.03219572454690933,
0.015468331053853035,
-0.010460556484758854,
-0.062374744564294815,
0.005383222829550505,
-0.005819229409098625,
0.01467061135917902,
-0.04550717771053314,
0.023808198049664497,
-0.002401761244982481,
-0.024627551436424255,
0.026216473430395126,
0.00000997515962808393,
-0.0747203677892685,
-0.006603853311389685,
0.040007852017879486,
0.012177308090031147,
-0.029838979244232178,
0.006433564703911543,
0.007640577387064695,
-0.030885012820363045,
0.032896630465984344,
-0.02453647367656231,
-0.01115283090621233,
-0.019430192187428474,
-0.029714254662394524,
0.03542584180831909,
-0.05789747089147568,
0.0005621761665679514,
-0.0026856844779103994,
0.017445120960474014,
0.018720941618084908,
0.006913164630532265,
0.0027875287923961878,
0.021003127098083496,
-0.018341058865189552,
-0.034338369965553284,
0.013118235394358635,
0.00918547809123993,
0.060728397220373154,
0.04689661040902138,
0.03510483354330063,
0.009701515547931194,
0.0760989859700203,
-0.004455421585589647,
-0.002533235354349017,
0.028353018686175346,
0.03174137696623802,
0.031968116760253906,
-0.022876134142279625,
0.02330036833882332,
-0.009906363673508167,
0.0027529143262654543,
-0.010537183843553066,
0.009362604469060898,
0.01147792860865593,
0.02803773060441017,
-0.04753999412059784,
-0.012627390213310719,
0.015943234786391258,
-0.02533182129263878,
0.0003966024669352919,
-0.010525289922952652,
-0.01982368342578411,
0.02996576763689518,
-0.005432321690022945,
0.024793237447738647,
-0.004232138395309448,
-0.007373441010713577,
0.045924022793769836,
-0.016737239435315132,
0.02621041052043438,
0.030153103172779083,
0.008139344863593578,
-0.0369727723300457,
-0.051771897822618484,
-0.024349918588995934,
-0.023825116455554962,
-0.00110142573248595,
-0.00766812264919281,
0.000633546500466764,
-0.015797022730112076,
-0.04037204012274742,
-0.06402336806058884,
0.03663649410009384,
-0.018128102645277977,
0.012650640681385994,
0.027214225381612778,
-0.01589951291680336,
0.00011951286433031783,
0.021396566182374954,
0.05351369455456734,
-0.007834574207663536,
0.04965817183256149,
0.045676469802856445,
0.007966284640133381,
-0.01647932454943657,
0.02153741382062435,
0.04019865766167641,
0.03858143836259842,
0.05220924690365791,
-0.02402777038514614,
-0.053644921630620956,
-0.0358714833855629,
-0.01775018498301506,
0.033346377313137054,
-0.0037868712097406387,
-0.006758037023246288,
0.04830062761902809,
0.020421475172042847,
0.02248169109225273,
-0.01256337109953165,
0.039410803467035294,
0.029275480657815933,
-0.0419292077422142,
-0.07161188125610352,
-0.033863238990306854,
-0.04530856013298035,
0.030058737844228745,
-0.02187829464673996,
-0.034646786749362946,
-0.02152211219072342,
0.02598811499774456,
0.009430420584976673,
-0.019936276599764824,
-0.02522740513086319,
0.04095197468996048,
0.007970749400556087,
0.04849379137158394,
0.04510907456278801,
0.0005276354495435953,
0.036402974277734756,
-0.02314860001206398,
0.004046007990837097,
0.03321008384227753,
-0.0036000299733132124,
-0.02729732170701027,
-0.0037141181528568268,
-0.0011451381724327803,
0.02120700478553772,
0.011549828574061394,
0.010408422909677029,
0.015307480469346046,
-0.014258707873523235,
0.010897201485931873,
-0.011597737669944763,
0.023572318255901337,
0.014433460310101509,
-0.026411497965455055,
-0.03244037181138992,
-0.03444623202085495,
-0.01042218692600727,
-0.016026444733142853,
0.03901132941246033,
0.01663084886968136,
0.001649059122428298,
0.00037276424700394273
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:62
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
as the HTT Defendants have submitted, the plaintiffs and Mr Zdrilic persistently, and over an extended period, engaged in conduct and evinced intentions which were consistent only with affirmation of the agreements, thereby disentitling themselves to rescission.
905On 16 September 2004 Mr Zdrilic became aware of the fact that IPC was no longer to provide funding. At the very latest, in March 2005, he became aware that arrangements between HTT and IPC had been terminated in September 2004.
906Mr Zdrilic knew that HTT had not organised the funding referred to in clause 4.7 of the Heads of Agreement and yet he continued to participate in the affairs of both HTT and Sentel in furtherance of the joint venture established by the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed.
907For that reason, and assuming that the plaintiffs otherwise had a right to rescind the Heads of Agreement and the Non-Dilution Deed, in my opinion they have lost that right by reason of their affirmation of the agreements.
908The position in terms of potential relief under s 87 of the Act is no different.
The Court, exercising its statutory powers will normally be guided by the principles applicable to the equitable remedy of recession: Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Limited (1998) 196 CLR 494 at 535; Henjo Investments Pty Limited v Collins Marrickville Pty Limited (1998) 39 FCR 546 at 564; Tenji v Henneberry & Associates Pty Limited (2000) 98 FCR 324.
Where, as here, the plaintiffs have repeatedly affirmed their contracts, relief by way of rescission ought not be granted in equity or under s 87: Bullabidgee Pty Limited v McCleary [2010] NSWSC 145 at [63] - [67].
Restitutio in integrum
909The plaintiffs submit that restitutio in integrum is possible.
910The plaintiffs submit that:-
(a)Devubo and Vocifa could have their units reassigned;
(b)Mr Renshall and Mr Hickie could have their debts reassigned;
(c)the plaintiffs "could" (although the plaintiff's submissions do not reveal whether they "would") accept orders under which they would no longer enforce the debt of $5.5 million against Sentel and under which they would hold the benefit of their shares in Sentel for the benefit of either HTT, Mr Renshall, Mr Hickie, Devubo and Vocifa or as they may direct; and
(d)so far as the units transferred by interests associated by Mr Hulley and Mr Ansell are concerned, Sentel could be directed to hold these units for the benefit of the relevant transferees.
911It appears to me that there is an air of unreality about these submissions. Accepting that substantial restitution is sufficient in equity, I cannot see how, at this remove, HTT could be put back in the position that it was at the date of the Heads of Agreement and Non-Dilution Deed or even at the date of the purported rescission.
912Since 2004 HTT has continued to develop the Project and, on any view of the evidence, expended substantial amounts. That work had led to the position outlined at [110] to [119] above.
913I accept the HTT Defendants' submission that:-
"Adjustment of the interest of the parties after 8 years is for practical purposes now impossible. It is not just a matter of transferring shares or units.
Vast amounts have been spent by HTT, just allowance for which (certainly from LEC) would be illusory. There is no manner in which these events could be unravelled such as would permit the parties to be restored in any measure to their former positions."
Third party rights
914The HTT Defendants also submit that rescission could not be permitted because the rights of third parties have intruded.
915Again, Mr Jucovic submits that the defendants in answer to the rescission claim did not plead this matter.
916It is true that the defendants in answer to the claim for rescission did not, in terms, plead the plea in respect of third party rights.
917However, it is pleaded in relation to the (not pressed) claim of estoppel.
918That pleading was particularised as follows:-
|
[
-0.041806742548942566,
0.03803352266550064,
-0.007664695847779512,
0.027598340064287186,
-0.02747379057109356,
-0.046941448003053665,
0.044932495802640915,
-0.03522632271051407,
0.021973857656121254,
-0.01135352160781622,
-0.022051945328712463,
-0.003649285528808832,
-0.04181136563420296,
0.01004213560372591,
-0.004466939251869917,
-0.028198642656207085,
0.022810427471995354,
-0.008253609761595726,
-0.009614809416234493,
-0.0077440631575882435,
-0.03053559921681881,
0.007074963301420212,
0.03216393664479256,
0.005569322966039181,
-0.032474759966135025,
0.002591515891253948,
-0.048447929322719574,
0.027658244594931602,
0.02195771038532257,
0.04364901781082153,
-0.014558328315615654,
0.04377906024456024,
0.02934941276907921,
-0.027726052328944206,
0.013566626235842705,
-0.027580201625823975,
0.006272634491324425,
-0.009944522753357887,
-0.020783737301826477,
0.024251772090792656,
-0.004506324417889118,
0.0361776165664196,
0.008769347332417965,
-0.042503535747528076,
0.0511031411588192,
-0.026717012748122215,
-0.03371736407279968,
-0.02066938765347004,
-0.039555199444293976,
0.03828345611691475,
-0.07082400470972061,
-0.008305559866130352,
0.05476302653551102,
-0.027382750064134598,
-0.024522842839360237,
0.013494032435119152,
-0.02641434408724308,
-0.013861899264156818,
-0.026258165016770363,
0.037102047353982925,
-0.0011741329217329621,
-0.009719952940940857,
-0.038978952914476395,
-0.02750311605632305,
-0.010520556010305882,
0.10000592470169067,
0.012392477132380009,
-0.0025196834467351437,
0.01097170915454626,
-0.03379257768392563,
-0.03729381039738655,
0.01727639138698578,
-0.039745695888996124,
0.01144220121204853,
-0.08905600756406784,
0.014538007788360119,
0.021150944754481316,
-0.007670802064239979,
0.043403007090091705,
-0.0073437257669866085,
0.027597006410360336,
-0.03424958139657974,
0.024689482524991035,
0.027213625609874725,
-0.03578168898820877,
0.02814587764441967,
-0.01587151363492012,
0.03341298922896385,
0.018411414697766304,
-0.04345593973994255,
0.003087153658270836,
-0.014531917870044708,
-0.033257775008678436,
-0.03016873076558113,
0.013634803704917431,
0.02931702323257923,
-0.07303479313850403,
0.04398755729198456,
-0.03437800332903862,
0.01733606867492199,
0.026546847075223923,
-0.011150338687002659,
0.013581527397036552,
-0.03761336952447891,
0.015232529491186142,
0.025475626811385155,
0.05423495173454285,
0.04066195711493492,
0.03450920432806015,
0.009399283677339554,
-0.010337458923459053,
-0.03813501074910164,
0.006141292862594128,
0.0036979676224291325,
-0.019698966294527054,
-0.0029452566523104906,
0.02412157878279686,
-0.0024949577637016773,
0.037237390875816345,
0.01925109326839447,
0.010403591208159924,
0.02022496983408928,
0.02758246473968029,
-0.021139094606041908,
-0.06714307516813278,
0.027669157832860947,
0.019036244601011276,
0.02721683494746685,
0.00004307522249291651,
0.020762071013450623,
-0.013885848224163055,
-0.00042651762487366796,
-0.014161255210638046,
-0.035467274487018585,
-0.020870916545391083,
-0.015176254324615002,
-0.01845594309270382,
-0.016167283058166504,
-0.004434624221175909,
-0.08763037621974945,
0.0407351590692997,
0.026952743530273438,
0.01598874107003212,
-0.03327002748847008,
0.027545394375920296,
0.0006706349086016417,
0.0032229330390691757,
0.00875814724713564,
0.01697814278304577,
0.03119986318051815,
0.032988712191581726,
0.02520669810473919,
0.03609256446361542,
-0.004919108934700489,
0.005996676627546549,
-0.04271217808127403,
-0.024641135707497597,
0.028508955612778664,
0.057169798761606216,
0.04745713248848915,
-0.11729088425636292,
0.028962280601263046,
-0.010108075104653835,
-0.03748273849487305,
-0.03304516524076462,
0.0019468016689643264,
0.007739291526377201,
0.03423084691166878,
-0.013648717664182186,
0.024146992713212967,
0.03960060328245163,
0.01335207000374794,
0.03051290288567543,
-0.0067023891024291515,
-0.01241067610681057,
0.02068835124373436,
0.026504799723625183,
0.018375970423221588,
-0.013408096507191658,
-0.021690845489501953,
-0.03771792724728584,
0.023664092645049095,
0.0035035049077123404,
-0.02845468558371067,
-0.0391569510102272,
0.02090815268456936,
-0.022957902401685715,
-0.005091608967632055,
0.002300999127328396,
0.03945349529385567,
-0.011378209106624126,
-0.0217654537409544,
0.05576237663626671,
0.04013466089963913,
0.016099661588668823,
-0.040663279592990875,
0.024398911744356155,
-0.051330506801605225,
0.004420972894877195,
-0.004668103996664286,
-0.015852389857172966,
0.028849460184574127,
0.054370153695344925,
-0.0470905601978302,
-0.048622649163007736,
0.0006226398982107639,
0.0034804402384907007,
0.015836261212825775,
-0.029500676319003105,
-0.03309778869152069,
-0.011379414238035679,
-0.00594810675829649,
0.026022978127002716,
0.02146850898861885,
-0.003940742928534746,
-0.028775256127119064,
0.002715853275731206,
0.0046833897940814495,
0.005687270779162645,
-0.047259390354156494,
-0.026981784030795097,
0.0031590068247169256,
-0.004755358211696148,
0.015695318579673767,
-0.0071160621009767056,
0.03764617070555687,
-0.026198148727416992,
-0.001904981560073793,
-0.0009579476900398731,
0.009028092958033085,
-0.02952892892062664,
-0.03999330848455429,
0.0075006806291639805,
-0.01836807280778885,
0.0381423644721508,
0.02383432351052761,
0.023100562393665314,
-0.00029166031163185835,
0.03725289925932884,
-0.002403551945462823,
-0.021794501692056656,
-0.008940293453633785,
0.02676580473780632,
-0.03193475678563118,
-0.03541065379977226,
-0.026297086849808693,
0.0108419731259346,
0.006149233318865299,
0.022910453379154205,
-0.016477175056934357,
0.00646226666867733,
-0.00045785363181494176,
-0.022610550746321678,
0.014676143415272236,
0.0028272191993892193,
0.03717229515314102,
-0.009206769987940788,
-0.0001824269420467317,
0.01243333425372839,
0.012553499080240726,
0.004629466682672501,
0.041886452585458755,
0.03783213719725609,
0.0010879860492423177,
-0.05719008669257164,
-0.006673645693808794,
-0.029343636706471443,
-0.03909900039434433,
0.030444364994764328,
0.006786589045077562,
-0.0005956630920991302,
0.017026139423251152,
0.014388641342520714,
0.01548236608505249,
0.040131814777851105,
0.014289754442870617,
0.017813783138990402,
0.0060317437164485455,
-0.008533310145139694,
0.007400728762149811,
0.0302839707583189,
0.03200225532054901,
0.034181542694568634,
-0.07710857689380646,
0.03835606575012207,
-0.00002961443897220306,
-0.016489513218402863,
-0.028796721249818802,
0.036986734718084335,
-0.04515508562326431,
0.004767038393765688,
0.02085244469344616,
0.0835336372256279,
0.004904651548713446,
-0.08676563948392868,
0.0006978441379033029,
-0.03084680624306202,
-0.14704495668411255,
-0.006004324182868004,
0.0032575326040387154,
-0.007378795649856329,
-0.002696121344342828,
0.028748005628585815,
-0.04746996983885765,
0.01779513619840145,
-0.025440022349357605,
0.01876048371195793,
-0.021018674597144127,
-0.06740426272153854,
-0.0216669999063015,
0.029819251969456673,
-0.0030111209489405155,
0.0029789309483021498,
-0.0007535183103755116,
0.02470429800450802,
0.02601761743426323,
-0.018423480913043022,
0.028778554871678352,
-0.04475145787000656,
0.051229458302259445,
0.012238913215696812,
0.012364647351205349,
0.0007945558172650635,
-0.0027173259295523167,
0.017877059057354927,
-0.05131359398365021,
0.009151764214038849,
-0.018617380410432816,
0.013203212060034275,
-0.012888215482234955,
0.0418984554708004,
0.016969993710517883,
0.022899527102708817,
0.061181504279375076,
-0.06774899363517761,
-0.019306065514683723,
-0.02975650504231453,
0.03184974566102028,
0.0450751967728138,
0.021615587174892426,
0.027332808822393417,
-0.020959902554750443,
-0.03733200579881668,
-0.009447465650737286,
-0.0020466321147978306,
0.012542211450636387,
0.04980750381946564,
-0.019918952137231827,
0.006423525512218475,
-0.023641377687454224,
-0.046478305011987686,
0.008512448519468307,
-0.04646988958120346,
0.09033557772636414,
0.018821531906723976,
-0.016368087381124496,
-0.011021047830581665,
-0.01422847993671894,
-0.04287448525428772,
0.018578195944428444,
0.016224559396505356,
-0.03850626200437546,
-0.01016759593039751,
0.010669074021279812,
-0.02605629339814186,
0.013076283037662506,
0.012746029533445835,
0.0015748022124171257,
-0.019239673390984535,
-0.010476283729076385,
-0.0054501816630363464,
0.010967976413667202,
0.014092820696532726,
-0.04109432175755501,
-0.01151611190289259,
-0.006347490940243006,
-0.11640692502260208,
0.01688089594244957,
0.03448619693517685,
-0.021119052544236183,
0.006758603733032942,
-0.008267764002084732,
0.003358899848535657,
0.0194003377109766,
0.017184855416417122,
0.02498217485845089,
0.2690403461456299,
0.009854134172201157,
0.021498359739780426,
0.03190860152244568,
0.017117034643888474,
-0.008057941682636738,
0.03379269689321518,
0.046847131103277206,
0.0025182196404784918,
-0.03462233766913414,
-0.04652957245707512,
0.015274543315172195,
0.02464832179248333,
0.05837419629096985,
-0.03386295214295387,
-0.02154235541820526,
-0.03195975720882416,
-0.027357617393136024,
0.04640498384833336,
-0.0012766849249601364,
0.033666763454675674,
-0.015081661753356457,
-0.00904909335076809,
-0.007903095334768295,
-0.04650002717971802,
-0.03578154742717743,
0.04264203459024429,
0.052963148802518845,
-0.047070346772670746,
0.004731380380690098,
-0.02167660929262638,
-0.013639519922435284,
0.061317309737205505,
-0.0054357838816940784,
0.00782841257750988,
0.008900819346308708,
-0.039465244859457016,
0.013157527893781662,
0.00399145670235157,
0.031110670417547226,
0.0016135761979967356,
-0.020719142630696297,
-0.031234344467520714,
-0.012420418672263622,
-0.011443180032074451,
0.018886657431721687,
-0.038613177835941315,
0.03697453439235687,
0.02721082977950573,
0.031992461532354355,
-0.010308397002518177,
0.015023880638182163,
-0.01664288155734539,
-0.038344960659742355,
-0.03634907677769661,
0.019574126228690147,
-0.039468102157115936,
0.033148977905511856,
0.02116098627448082,
0.022501783445477486,
0.033480796962976456,
0.005781513173133135,
-0.05993157997727394,
0.02873833104968071,
-0.024637868627905846,
-0.008269582875072956,
-0.06400389224290848,
0.04288827255368233,
0.061890892684459686,
0.034019529819488525,
0.05288209021091461,
0.030485959723591805,
0.005306015256792307,
-0.000728315208107233,
0.030098741874098778,
0.0025392419192939997,
-0.004692575428634882,
0.009861266240477562,
-0.00712693203240633,
-0.01373691763728857,
-0.05514354258775711,
-0.02900947444140911,
-0.01755901239812374,
0.005799090024083853,
0.024381371214985847,
-0.023413723334670067,
-0.040238652378320694,
0.010875959880650043,
0.0014214348047971725,
-0.012969763949513435,
-0.02065601572394371,
-0.04216780513525009,
-0.0025595822371542454,
0.017909256741404533,
0.001185265020467341,
-0.008363446220755577,
0.010075542144477367,
-0.0010521294316276908,
-0.01784551702439785,
-0.03301861509680748,
0.01801472343504429,
0.00557542871683836,
-0.0057863206602633,
-0.06374175101518631,
0.01606813445687294,
0.005637390073388815,
0.0161818228662014,
0.016005052253603935,
-0.045304667204618454,
0.009613423608243465,
0.004555202089250088,
0.03548191115260124,
0.028148476034402847,
-0.008663815446197987,
0.005705717019736767,
0.05242686718702316,
-0.01568189263343811,
0.06265956163406372,
0.06606002151966095,
0.04329823702573776,
-0.007131210993975401,
-0.027873652055859566,
-0.03960270807147026,
0.015376929193735123,
0.000917391269467771,
0.012800720520317554,
-0.016213659197092056,
-0.01999584585428238,
-0.006942050531506538,
-0.023135345429182053,
-0.004269205499440432,
-0.005315463989973068,
-0.026085879653692245,
0.014155707322061062,
0.015415612608194351,
0.01928381435573101,
-0.0353175513446331,
-0.009661325253546238,
-0.029353579506278038,
0.014165879227221012,
-0.022352434694767,
-0.009576243348419666,
-0.01370836142450571,
-0.009389872662723064,
0.00288202241063118,
0.014133314602077007,
-0.031216109171509743,
0.03322999179363251,
-0.052307382225990295,
-0.003939324989914894,
-0.006967023015022278,
0.026725109666585922,
-0.027379879727959633,
-0.040648967027664185,
-0.016201451420783997,
-0.02103111334145069,
-0.014794931747019291,
-0.029788877815008163,
0.010683455504477024,
-0.013421816751360893,
-0.02317485399544239,
0.02188907191157341,
-0.002937594661489129,
0.021298957988619804,
-0.01469916757196188,
0.06927696615457535,
-0.02037154696881771,
0.04742426797747612,
0.046284936368465424,
-0.0075763920322060585,
-0.015548814088106155,
-0.0594228059053421,
-0.0342809297144413,
0.041480325162410736,
0.004446768667548895,
-0.013394281268119812,
0.0077300360426306725,
0.02513309381902218,
0.0012149239191785455,
-0.05612918362021446,
0.019378965720534325,
0.007351226173341274,
-0.029574595391750336,
0.039180170744657516,
-0.029584424570202827,
-0.007454018108546734,
-0.019383085891604424,
-0.002262414898723364,
0.03923241049051285,
-0.07295001298189163,
-0.03889765962958336,
0.0866469219326973,
0.029479429125785828,
-0.009378233924508095,
-0.0010477444157004356,
0.010308711789548397,
0.003975300583988428,
0.031095294281840324,
0.021661188453435898,
-0.055234719067811966,
-0.0002284975489601493,
-0.009779260493814945,
0.0219119843095541,
-0.024230295792222023,
0.035533253103494644,
0.018912233412265778,
-0.02377292886376381,
0.018495267257094383,
-0.04895254224538803,
-0.02531055174767971,
0.020812682807445526,
0.03023807890713215,
-0.042751867324113846,
0.04268081858754158,
0.02943180687725544,
-0.02335943467915058,
0.0034919448662549257,
0.02417941577732563,
0.017621172592043877,
-0.0677725076675415,
-0.033173780888319016,
-0.044091738760471344,
0.034397341310977936,
-0.09400667995214462,
0.003442187327891588,
0.017919380217790604,
-0.04220235347747803,
0.0015765528660267591,
-0.021151874214410782,
0.02296370454132557,
0.002990421839058399,
-0.05322030931711197,
0.022754203528165817,
-0.030568638816475868,
0.011678698472678661,
-0.011349737644195557,
0.02852455899119377,
-0.00889072846621275,
0.03845473378896713,
0.0117639834061265,
0.020378246903419495,
0.00040719748358242214,
0.0435333251953125,
0.04392942786216736,
0.0198895912617445,
-0.028473639860749245,
-0.0012375407386571169,
0.00757715804502368,
0.020039962604641914,
0.06577778607606888,
-0.009015609510242939,
0.03452993556857109,
0.021803725510835648,
-0.0286707803606987,
0.02670479379594326,
0.041628219187259674,
0.04956257715821266,
-0.03781823068857193,
-0.02177734486758709,
-0.028562961146235466,
0.014064920134842396,
0.008905191905796528,
0.03917674720287323,
-0.021362651139497757,
-0.035867840051651,
-0.022152364253997803,
0.027027903124690056,
-0.00036843461566604674,
-0.02184206061065197,
-0.0009201031643897295,
0.004939935635775328,
0.0024132998660206795,
-0.0005430406308732927,
-0.05952748283743858,
0.020362865179777145,
-0.0052910782396793365,
-0.01785687729716301,
0.019471658393740654,
-0.01066024973988533,
-0.02886096015572548,
-0.0006022386369295418,
0.0008242037147283554,
0.02690964937210083,
-0.010058684274554253,
-0.02302687242627144,
-0.013290475122630596,
0.017489036545157433,
-0.008583920076489449,
-0.0030441482085734606,
0.0224398635327816,
0.00902505125850439,
0.013861766085028648,
-0.020593637600541115,
-0.0076438141986727715,
-0.004581260960549116,
0.006239049136638641,
0.007184623274952173,
0.036208588629961014,
-0.01281172875314951,
0.023606181144714355,
-0.022188808768987656,
-0.013221636414527893,
-0.0324087031185627,
-0.06890901923179626,
-0.03927448391914368,
0.013704629614949226,
0.00026602830621413887,
-0.002517213113605976,
-0.04149233177304268,
0.01151966955512762,
-0.008531256578862667,
-0.04532033950090408,
0.01332344114780426,
-0.017366796731948853,
0.05534517392516136,
0.01351682748645544,
-0.005252872593700886,
-0.03258950263261795,
-0.007597222924232483,
0.006566974334418774,
-0.01144934818148613,
0.0014841394731774926,
-0.047034427523612976,
-0.00238966615870595,
-0.05656054615974426,
-0.01732315681874752,
0.009067072533071041,
-0.056145161390304565,
-0.06306502223014832,
0.020095720887184143,
-0.02113066427409649,
-0.000204788229893893,
-0.004185222554951906,
-0.02885429933667183,
0.047625452280044556,
0.040433336049318314,
-0.002556390827521682,
-0.007696810178458691,
0.018716325983405113,
-0.03275800496339798,
-0.018830634653568268,
-0.09129777550697327,
0.07531147450208664,
-0.0023165273014456034,
-0.013605313375592232,
0.026395060122013092,
-0.012223044410347939,
-0.022766325622797012,
0.01222248375415802,
0.007127640303224325,
-0.008919129148125648,
-0.02636520192027092,
-0.0037516450975090265,
-0.025380855426192284,
-0.01483120396733284,
-0.023583874106407166,
0.008088754490017891,
0.035353586077690125,
0.04591589793562889,
-0.016110138967633247,
-0.0159652940928936,
0.035809557884931564,
0.020607784390449524,
0.028359094634652138,
0.015660490840673447,
-0.016347574070096016,
0.0019478601170703769,
0.03315247595310211,
0.01807844080030918,
0.009667424485087395,
0.03191244229674339,
-0.0047762393951416016,
-0.011042225174605846,
0.0019713714718818665,
-0.031597673892974854,
0.04451252147555351,
0.015995711088180542,
0.02001015469431877,
-0.005190450698137283,
-0.02560458704829216,
-0.008446530438959599,
-0.05369299650192261,
-0.028462126851081848,
-0.019941145554184914,
0.03629041463136673,
0.028237879276275635,
0.033942803740501404,
0.013817389495670795,
-0.011354957707226276,
0.017945103347301483,
0.01334881316870451,
0.031705111265182495,
-0.020842168480157852,
-0.008083922788500786,
-0.12815286219120026,
-0.02967251092195511,
0.005148596595972776,
-0.010406652465462685,
-0.013097327202558517,
0.014640158042311668,
-0.009488132782280445,
0.019431695342063904,
-0.02166084572672844,
0.003089725272729993,
-0.015074606984853745,
-0.05415324866771698,
0.03211602941155434,
-0.03213553503155708,
-0.015121056698262691,
0.005251963157206774,
-0.04622674733400345,
-0.015297957696020603,
-0.05463261529803276,
0.028549686074256897,
0.0032538459636271,
0.001699274405837059,
-0.001843815902248025,
-0.05944915488362312,
0.01173591148108244,
-0.017170362174510956,
-0.018207207322120667,
-0.021540896967053413,
-0.026322796940803528,
-0.046929262578487396,
-0.028624657541513443,
-0.012596655637025833,
-0.01091340184211731,
0.021494092419743538,
-0.012568346224725246,
0.01936015859246254,
-0.015663664788007736,
-0.0043570613488554955,
-0.019378818571567535,
-0.009803314693272114,
0.0031109650153666735,
0.03822285309433937,
-0.02819729782640934,
-0.05014004185795784,
-0.007372258231043816,
0.015046510845422745,
0.016174377873539925,
-0.02261878363788128,
-0.03910234570503235,
-0.03443297743797302,
-0.027661509811878204,
0.027867067605257034,
0.04592953249812126,
0.07250737398862839,
0.0037501216866075993,
0.007147049065679312,
0.011498037725687027,
-0.04515419527888298,
0.0278943981975317,
0.03118457831442356,
0.02540668658912182,
0.03546668961644173,
-0.024645743891596794,
-0.004009275697171688,
0.005149900447577238,
0.0027450521010905504,
-0.017065472900867462,
-0.010091571137309074,
-0.012056994251906872,
-0.002392708556726575,
0.017160655930638313,
0.012212675996124744,
-0.012536615133285522,
-0.06614599376916885,
0.013854344375431538,
-0.026171309873461723,
0.001006034086458385,
-0.010139325633645058,
-0.0642596036195755,
-0.012711013667285442,
-0.0521845705807209,
0.004727337975054979,
-0.04352991655468941,
0.005051513202488422,
0.06483422964811325,
0.027942191809415817,
-0.00737592251971364,
-0.0350852869451046,
0.021572597324848175,
-0.032844413071870804,
-0.06972724199295044,
0.010251748375594616,
0.004497900605201721,
0.02082102932035923,
-0.01659073308110237,
0.029849017038941383,
-0.01787458546459675,
0.013418477959930897,
0.02321150153875351,
-0.002579513704404235,
-0.06328607350587845,
-0.009243234992027283,
0.055132608860731125,
-0.022403305396437645,
-0.04144556447863579,
0.026899931952357292,
0.01882961019873619,
-0.016726365312933922,
0.019213173538446426,
-0.023607609793543816,
-0.010343306697905064,
-0.036535944789648056,
-0.047453004866838455,
0.03655114397406578,
-0.029629986733198166,
0.029293013736605644,
0.0037215626798570156,
0.0156729593873024,
0.011968118138611317,
-0.010748069733381271,
0.011831393465399742,
-0.014361534267663956,
0.010044100694358349,
-0.019517377018928528,
-0.018705911934375763,
0.002108936430886388,
0.06836725026369095,
0.047798458486795425,
0.03884746879339218,
-0.007562620565295219,
0.03881991282105446,
0.004866334144026041,
-0.03480473905801773,
0.03804733604192734,
0.02869788557291031,
0.039514508098363876,
-0.028677232563495636,
0.006848660763353109,
-0.02037300355732441,
-0.027636433020234108,
-0.027725661173462868,
-0.006285748910158873,
0.015364833176136017,
0.014530989341437817,
-0.03244907408952713,
0.016689511016011238,
0.032859332859516144,
-0.0024803057312965393,
-0.010658555664122105,
0.002095260890200734,
-0.03597021847963333,
0.024460621178150177,
-0.007268877234309912,
0.06294254958629608,
0.012455057352781296,
-0.02753565087914467,
0.03557201847434044,
-0.026026571169495583,
0.017691321671009064,
0.02619306743144989,
0.011264367960393429,
-0.04678477719426155,
-0.07377593964338303,
0.004812837112694979,
-0.019971460103988647,
0.03233875334262848,
-0.0008283160859718919,
0.0033252418506890535,
-0.025510253384709358,
-0.03503725305199623,
-0.012301282025873661,
0.027828965336084366,
-0.02498621679842472,
0.007424166891723871,
0.05295795202255249,
-0.05325516313314438,
0.007544288411736488,
0.01417380478233099,
0.030438927933573723,
-0.04628658667206764,
0.05389761924743652,
0.05910462513566017,
0.02355281449854374,
-0.021465986967086792,
0.010513147339224815,
0.018500547856092453,
0.03781905397772789,
0.029714979231357574,
-0.02128259837627411,
-0.02635330520570278,
-0.03708331659436226,
-0.005218064412474632,
0.025318000465631485,
-0.00009351981134386733,
0.004913661628961563,
0.04269268736243248,
0.022299176082015038,
0.03434846177697182,
-0.008812064304947853,
0.04435442388057709,
0.03586897626519203,
-0.029107989743351936,
-0.04196058586239815,
-0.029512198641896248,
-0.016150033101439476,
-0.004166812635958195,
-0.027632426470518112,
-0.02958347648382187,
-0.02843235805630684,
0.0772915631532669,
0.005207699257880449,
-0.015178813599050045,
-0.01845632866024971,
0.051057491451501846,
0.03165193274617195,
0.04467162489891052,
0.04521552845835686,
0.001807043794542551,
0.028881976380944252,
-0.019716927781701088,
0.0009804617147892714,
0.037321168929338455,
-0.03311213105916977,
-0.02302156575024128,
-0.019131891429424286,
0.005265426822006702,
-0.012209741398692131,
-0.007023032288998365,
0.016986241564154625,
0.013644381426274776,
0.002869528951123357,
-0.008833492174744606,
-0.002665913198143244,
0.023312341421842575,
0.005385186988860369,
-0.035383544862270355,
-0.03273007273674011,
-0.0238091591745615,
-0.01105415541678667,
-0.01976725272834301,
0.03673340380191803,
0.012837679125368595,
0.019940700381994247,
0.011961152777075768
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:41
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
614Mr Zdrilic's note commences with scattered points that appear to have been made during the conversation. The date "15/9" appears, as does the figure "$18m". The latter figure is linked by an arrow to notes "$7-8m Loans $10.0 Eq". Those figures include "$6.8m" (the amount of the DTC loan, about to fall due), and "$700,000", although not "4.5m" or "40m".
615The text set out above appears to have been written separately, at some time after the actual conversation.
616Ultimately, Mr Renshall did not dispute the substance of what Mr Zdrilic said about this conversation. He said he could not remember what was said.
617Mr Hilliard made a note of what Mr Zdrilic told him about this conversation which, relevantly, reads:-
"He spoke to Robert Renshall
There is a document between HTT & Funder
Loan $4.5m
Eventually $18m
$10m - equity
$8m - loans
Balance of monies to be paid 15/9/04".
618Mr Hilliard's note did not refer to "$40m". Mr Hilliard's note suggests that Mr Zdrilic told him that the amount ultimately to be advanced was "18m" - hence the use of the word "eventually" in relation to that figure.
619Mr Hilliard's note also makes clear that Mr Zdrilic told him that Mr Renshall had said that there was a document dealing with the relationship between HTT and "the funder".
620Mr Einfeld submitted that, when considering Mr Zdrilic's note of this conversation, I should take particular care to take into account the possibility that Mr Zdrilic had not recorded exactly what was said by Mr Renshall but, rather, Mr Zdrilic's "gloss" of the conversation.
621Mr Einfeld reminded me of the oft quoted words of McClelland CJ in Eq in Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315 at 318-319:-
"Where, in civil proceedings, a party alleges that the conduct of another was misleading or deceptive, or likely to mislead or deceive (which I will compendiously described as "misleading") within the meaning of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (or s 42 of the Fair Trading Act), it is ordinarily necessary for that party to prove to the reasonable satisfaction of the court:
(1) what the alleged conduct was;
and (2) circumstances which rendered the conduct misleading.
Where the conduct is the speaking of words in the course of a conversation, it is necessary that the words spoken be proved with a degree of prevision sufficient to enable the court to be reasonably satisfied that they were in fact misleading in the proved circumstances.
In many cases (but not all) the question whether spoken words were misleading may depend upon what, if examined at the time, may have been to be relatively subtle nuances flowing from the use of one word, phrase or grammatical construction rather than another, or the presence or absence of some qualifying word of phrase, or condition."
622According to Mr Zdrilic's note, Mr Renshall said:-
* the funder "will be" putting in $18 million;
* $4.5 million of that $18 million might (the word "if" was used) be put in prior to 15 September 2004;
* the $4.5 million "will be" used to payout the existing first mortgagee American Reinsurance;
* the balance of $18 million "will be" be put in by 15 September 2004; and
* the funder had "already organised" $40 million which will be available "in stages".
623The combination of Mr Zdrilic's and Mr Hilliard's notes lead me to conclude that Mr Renshall did tell Mr Zdrilic that that the funder would "eventually" advance $18 million and that such advance would be made by 15 September 2004.
624The reference in both diary notes to "15/9/04" (Mr Zdrilic's note refers to that date twice) leads me to conclude that Mr Renshall specified this date in his conversation with Mr Zdrilic and that Mr Zdrilic thought it important enough to convey to Mr Hilliard.
625These were representations as to future matters. The onus was on the HTT Defendants to adduce evidence that Mr Renshall had reasonable grounds to make these statements.
|
[
-0.008927872404456139,
0.04704204574227333,
-0.01902717910706997,
0.005703349597752094,
-0.02149561606347561,
-0.029900478199124336,
-0.0066808294504880905,
-0.024242617189884186,
-0.019138608127832413,
-0.010613563470542431,
-0.0040826923213899136,
0.03341912478208542,
-0.03962348774075508,
-0.0014516533119603992,
-0.0027907241601496935,
-0.03454614803195,
0.02777896076440811,
-0.029323333874344826,
0.006972596049308777,
-0.0127510204911232,
0.008498930372297764,
0.008480442687869072,
0.02285219542682171,
0.022084353491663933,
-0.005236461292952299,
0.009441268630325794,
-0.051856834441423416,
-0.006135268602520227,
0.058420296758413315,
0.02310352958738804,
0.024529511108994484,
-0.0037295096553862095,
0.02343662828207016,
-0.0017371324356645346,
0.00498398719355464,
0.006733158137649298,
0.002786787459626794,
-0.011510713025927544,
-0.03268152475357056,
0.03581075742840767,
-0.007735935505479574,
-0.009741591289639473,
-0.012433351017534733,
0.01677062176167965,
0.05893592908978462,
-0.03311314061284065,
0.013218546286225319,
-0.009769187308847904,
0.008549308404326439,
-0.006203038152307272,
-0.028302976861596107,
-0.02490878477692604,
0.03416690230369568,
-0.001532968832179904,
-0.02637815847992897,
-0.02086733467876911,
-0.028999144211411476,
-0.002079585799947381,
-0.07073420286178589,
0.010870401747524738,
-0.010577347129583359,
-0.003556318348273635,
-0.08865833282470703,
-0.018384410068392754,
-0.03326159343123436,
0.10177890211343765,
0.013053614646196365,
0.0038780150935053825,
0.005880538374185562,
-0.00284109846688807,
-0.029047159478068352,
0.024050487205386162,
0.004024061374366283,
-0.021237079054117203,
-0.09562666714191437,
0.011769871227443218,
0.0012474791146814823,
0.003631798317655921,
0.015439211390912533,
0.048176057636737823,
0.037252798676490784,
-0.023597752675414085,
0.004172306042164564,
0.018467111513018608,
-0.0014159908751025796,
0.025658544152975082,
-0.036010999232530594,
0.02558525651693344,
0.020091120153665543,
-0.050523415207862854,
0.01000268291682005,
0.021538985893130302,
0.03787462040781975,
-0.05175291746854782,
0.037469860166311264,
-0.008081536740064621,
-0.06676889210939407,
0.03448624536395073,
0.0040084305219352245,
0.03506530448794365,
0.038566865026950836,
0.04317677766084671,
-0.019644809886813164,
-0.0032742212060838938,
-0.010514318011701107,
0.017884794622659683,
0.0400262326002121,
0.0450463742017746,
0.01930651254951954,
-0.02498667500913143,
0.0026648498605936766,
0.009138618595898151,
-0.004547660704702139,
0.02182488888502121,
0.0006791729829274118,
-0.0012138941092416644,
0.0050577763468027115,
0.03416479751467705,
0.03813273459672928,
-0.003193087410181761,
0.018210528418421745,
0.030951574444770813,
0.04690323770046234,
-0.0004231987113598734,
-0.07725922018289566,
-0.004184397403150797,
-0.004430137109011412,
0.003810328897088766,
-0.008077753707766533,
-0.007129972334951162,
0.0003360806149430573,
0.04216305539011955,
-0.028245940804481506,
-0.008609052747488022,
-0.0399731770157814,
0.0042425524443387985,
0.020080359652638435,
-0.0038880363572388887,
0.03971123695373535,
-0.06329110264778137,
0.035430632531642914,
0.03217265009880066,
-0.0026560125406831503,
-0.04369819164276123,
0.029815571382641792,
-0.06159757822751999,
-0.013645697385072708,
-0.018169501796364784,
0.02111811190843582,
0.04512755945324898,
-0.008699486032128334,
-0.011253848671913147,
0.03037424013018608,
-0.0024797709193080664,
0.0020289260428398848,
-0.02710477076470852,
-0.012684636749327183,
-0.02423814870417118,
-0.01535320095717907,
0.06546894460916519,
0.01224812027066946,
0.0451694093644619,
-0.026588711887598038,
-0.04796244576573372,
0.005374500062316656,
0.01296184677630663,
-0.0002349348069401458,
0.040158502757549286,
-0.028270261362195015,
-0.01649823784828186,
0.027266856282949448,
-0.02831398695707321,
0.07712330669164658,
-0.0056280833669006824,
0.007911437191069126,
0.015408978797495365,
0.03381490707397461,
0.006976431701332331,
0.01826770044863224,
-0.006839379668235779,
-0.05242415517568588,
0.031183259561657906,
0.010219622403383255,
-0.013186843134462833,
-0.012650322169065475,
0.001358230598270893,
-0.029691871255636215,
-0.025686193257570267,
0.01383989304304123,
0.00887812115252018,
-0.011899502947926521,
-0.02502584457397461,
0.029911547899246216,
0.013922436162829399,
0.03484371304512024,
-0.0459311343729496,
0.01809844933450222,
-0.04299874231219292,
-0.008162670768797398,
-0.04148540273308754,
-0.010397827252745628,
0.00736929289996624,
0.05134223774075508,
-0.033560410141944885,
-0.0259229838848114,
-0.00934026762843132,
-0.04240472614765167,
0.005420336965471506,
-0.0008996000397019088,
-0.014057484455406666,
0.0022773202508687973,
-0.001288086175918579,
0.005642338190227747,
0.003340835450217128,
0.012389256618916988,
0.002826634794473648,
0.009965391829609871,
-0.004664140287786722,
0.006308331619948149,
-0.06357589364051819,
-0.0427522137761116,
0.05313827097415924,
-0.017100809141993523,
0.030139725655317307,
0.03717197850346565,
0.0446275994181633,
-0.07904735207557678,
0.029783552512526512,
-0.023126021027565002,
-0.02534531056880951,
0.010567452758550644,
-0.009556818753480911,
0.007267102599143982,
-0.019155537709593773,
0.014057338237762451,
0.06642307341098785,
0.026707304641604424,
0.03793880343437195,
-0.008200646378099918,
0.007007082458585501,
-0.01806998997926712,
-0.005770927295088768,
-0.018382301554083824,
0.014664771035313606,
-0.04255884885787964,
0.00045818646322004497,
-0.005908036604523659,
0.02171037346124649,
0.03026050329208374,
-0.013642075471580029,
-0.014555403031408787,
-0.02828243561089039,
-0.02205432578921318,
-0.0027885118033736944,
0.0015130203682929277,
0.01129064615815878,
0.023558292537927628,
0.007253503892570734,
0.02565710060298443,
0.03278450295329094,
0.03533116728067398,
-0.007091989275068045,
0.028122013434767723,
0.02173089049756527,
-0.01611112803220749,
-0.000284510082565248,
-0.02076091431081295,
-0.07501107454299927,
0.036717794835567474,
-0.04215051978826523,
0.012038101442158222,
0.010009880177676678,
0.013507821597158909,
0.0018755970522761345,
0.022708367556333542,
0.05696845427155495,
0.006160758901387453,
-0.016877319663763046,
0.013113628141582012,
-0.00025787201593630016,
0.02975103072822094,
-0.0008739592740312219,
0.026368996128439903,
-0.04713490232825279,
0.027782225981354713,
0.033251117914915085,
-0.01804971694946289,
-0.055938225239515305,
0.005902506411075592,
-0.03148319944739342,
-0.014367460273206234,
-0.007734980899840593,
0.04340899735689163,
-0.006311963312327862,
-0.07184971868991852,
-0.07238540798425674,
-0.015334729105234146,
-0.15071740746498108,
-0.023753775283694267,
-0.020366784185171127,
0.052096933126449585,
0.0010515665635466576,
0.02144656889140606,
-0.04840114340186119,
0.00012245304242242128,
-0.03502746671438217,
0.009287956170737743,
0.021996458992362022,
-0.04943873733282089,
-0.02258792705833912,
0.024346766993403435,
0.02405472844839096,
-0.015711942687630653,
0.016736196354031563,
-0.004463574383407831,
0.021993951871991158,
-0.015060103498399258,
0.015841586515307426,
-0.06198738515377045,
0.03266375884413719,
0.006099125370383263,
-0.04634847119450569,
0.02071733959019184,
-0.019706161692738533,
0.031872306019067764,
-0.020858854055404663,
-0.025008443742990494,
-0.013044570572674274,
0.019633308053016663,
-0.032814931124448776,
0.0281332079321146,
-0.007108651101589203,
0.0566059947013855,
0.04537119343876839,
-0.06656771898269653,
-0.04808121174573898,
-0.025367477908730507,
0.038426414132118225,
0.03727838769555092,
0.026699790731072426,
0.020162619650363922,
-0.008884421549737453,
-0.04642052948474884,
-0.008462154306471348,
-0.01382349245250225,
-0.007023847196251154,
0.02337120845913887,
-0.00925937108695507,
0.00305433408357203,
-0.03015115298330784,
-0.01479868870228529,
-0.02209804207086563,
-0.024604804813861847,
0.05000811070203781,
0.01004044245928526,
-0.04630428925156593,
-0.014383474364876747,
-0.04858017712831497,
-0.08276613056659698,
-0.019058549776673317,
0.004762375261634588,
-0.020106377080082893,
-0.010367603041231632,
0.009098820388317108,
-0.024246886372566223,
0.021024193614721298,
-0.002738360082730651,
0.01707111857831478,
-0.018100600689649582,
0.010498818941414356,
0.00589786609634757,
0.05029236897826195,
0.042594343423843384,
-0.03771374002099037,
-0.011720201000571251,
0.0014524329453706741,
-0.10783449560403824,
0.004362767096608877,
0.04087647423148155,
-0.003074610373005271,
0.025188816711306572,
0.009404018521308899,
0.0478050671517849,
0.02344967983663082,
0.04600055143237114,
-0.021926362067461014,
0.2513088285923004,
-0.010581720620393753,
0.028393294662237167,
0.03402458131313324,
0.027453580871224403,
-0.04914281517267227,
0.01703556440770626,
0.028501013293862343,
-0.005894720554351807,
-0.04040555655956268,
-0.0026664279866963625,
-0.003695475170388818,
0.011262379586696625,
0.02456543780863285,
-0.04416433349251747,
0.024461204186081886,
-0.046137794852256775,
-0.0057070255279541016,
0.06353814154863358,
0.011595272459089756,
0.04190624877810478,
-0.020358307287096977,
0.013624664396047592,
0.015236184000968933,
-0.08669044822454453,
-0.024377673864364624,
0.0042334734462201595,
0.037218328565359116,
-0.018100988119840622,
0.012142221443355083,
-0.025589296594262123,
-0.008148553781211376,
0.025647500529885292,
0.01566094532608986,
0.01308799721300602,
-0.012808275409042835,
-0.02363971620798111,
-0.006674444768577814,
-0.013474943116307259,
0.05625161528587341,
-0.006692462135106325,
-0.024599453434348106,
-0.002391047542914748,
-0.04380623251199722,
-0.047810304909944534,
0.0018593507120385766,
-0.02096410281956196,
0.0013201709371060133,
-0.04833420738577843,
-0.0015138768358156085,
-0.0020638101268559694,
0.03188171237707138,
0.013056205585598946,
0.02796129509806633,
0.01328036468476057,
0.04179633408784866,
0.00798365380614996,
0.058344848453998566,
0.004777808208018541,
0.04368257150053978,
-0.00489602517336607,
0.04826962202787399,
-0.011996595188975334,
0.030883513391017914,
0.005504201166331768,
-0.020545072853565216,
-0.003817996708676219,
-0.04734165966510773,
0.05174260213971138,
-0.00906018540263176,
0.039281874895095825,
0.04161979630589485,
0.02226998098194599,
0.011479855515062809,
0.012794403359293938,
-0.05927223712205887,
-0.042255938053131104,
-0.04011979699134827,
0.030926082283258438,
0.024114742875099182,
-0.00934375450015068,
-0.01960678957402706,
0.012133711017668247,
0.0056873201392591,
0.03601734712719917,
0.011395180597901344,
-0.05535060912370682,
0.03340424597263336,
-0.007488017901778221,
-0.012079020030796528,
-0.018847286701202393,
-0.004435071721673012,
-0.016372695565223694,
-0.029865005984902382,
-0.02598835714161396,
-0.009420625865459442,
-0.009858567267656326,
-0.031083466485142708,
-0.06449480354785919,
-0.04979074373841286,
0.02071452885866165,
-0.013092635199427605,
0.05185864493250847,
-0.027834603562951088,
0.02847500517964363,
0.0035265551414340734,
-0.01656167581677437,
-0.003099842695519328,
-0.04309869557619095,
0.005811556242406368,
-0.032765038311481476,
0.014796755276620388,
0.006793740671128035,
0.006574829109013081,
0.040554843842983246,
0.06423652172088623,
-0.018363501876592636,
0.03095140866935253,
0.004266951233148575,
0.014296815730631351,
0.021890264004468918,
0.003366052405908704,
-0.05380375310778618,
0.024849601089954376,
0.0056639076210558414,
0.020126627758145332,
0.01128922589123249,
0.021338921040296555,
0.034209221601486206,
0.009650114923715591,
-0.006092899478971958,
-0.02436874806880951,
-0.0141065688803792,
0.012811217457056046,
0.07130451500415802,
0.034027937799692154,
-0.001120657310821116,
-0.0112773971632123,
-0.055588625371456146,
0.01558294240385294,
-0.01238670852035284,
0.024759836494922638,
-0.030260756611824036,
-0.004242421127855778,
0.017931805923581123,
0.006324363872408867,
-0.05840039625763893,
0.013493278995156288,
-0.05161251872777939,
0.030301863327622414,
0.026212766766548157,
-0.01657886616885662,
-0.04043731465935707,
-0.041323285549879074,
0.02040291391313076,
-0.020270133391022682,
-0.006430120673030615,
0.0049147275276482105,
0.04296668991446495,
-0.030423613265156746,
-0.0007539924699813128,
0.05233573541045189,
-0.014021598733961582,
0.009349181316792965,
-0.007352793123573065,
0.05243809148669243,
0.019924070686101913,
0.017363835126161575,
0.006218819413334131,
-0.03174901381134987,
-0.024406878277659416,
-0.027746129781007767,
-0.005851570516824722,
0.04245005175471306,
0.013118154369294643,
0.04799889028072357,
0.00011603128223214298,
0.01218206062912941,
-0.019837096333503723,
-0.05579274147748947,
0.007925126701593399,
0.007710096426308155,
-0.017016829922795296,
-0.0013815710553899407,
-0.00455067353323102,
0.022837020456790924,
0.02716662921011448,
-0.029731005430221558,
0.0479138046503067,
-0.08411906659603119,
-0.015078071504831314,
0.08492926508188248,
-0.0008409244474023581,
-0.030046788975596428,
-0.004352412652224302,
-0.04538331925868988,
-0.024002771824598312,
0.06874742358922958,
-0.046510323882102966,
-0.026753254234790802,
-0.0027484374586492777,
0.01016298122704029,
-0.006522750947624445,
0.02409033663570881,
0.0010392169933766127,
-0.0027429566252976656,
0.02385655604302883,
0.0333225317299366,
-0.05357054993510246,
-0.03410040959715843,
0.029562784358859062,
0.009120403788983822,
-0.035892657935619354,
0.02320459485054016,
-0.00860410463064909,
-0.04708768427371979,
0.0204657893627882,
0.07575925439596176,
0.019054966047406197,
-0.031434666365385056,
-0.004677304066717625,
-0.024382155388593674,
0.014877798967063427,
-0.046656474471092224,
-0.02048620954155922,
-0.012896811589598656,
-0.04964659363031387,
0.011803664267063141,
-0.028946470469236374,
-0.0019252969650551677,
-0.0041694119572639465,
-0.05127352103590965,
0.07040700316429138,
-0.056767381727695465,
0.013770448043942451,
0.00006894403486512601,
0.05256764590740204,
0.0077112275175750256,
0.021767256781458855,
-0.005407792516052723,
0.0269173551350832,
-0.008249795995652676,
0.015386732295155525,
0.03002305142581463,
-0.009603643789887428,
-0.008491299115121365,
-0.013166844844818115,
-0.026444030925631523,
0.03701487556099892,
0.03141265735030174,
0.023159006610512733,
0.0350988507270813,
-0.016953768208622932,
-0.010403178632259369,
-0.003262300742790103,
0.03082076460123062,
0.009670163504779339,
-0.028759868815541267,
-0.019750278443098068,
-0.04791313782334328,
-0.015660064294934273,
0.018865277990698814,
-0.014357193373143673,
-0.031952790915966034,
-0.056868355721235275,
-0.05693419277667999,
0.0328204520046711,
-0.0205348152667284,
-0.031950004398822784,
-0.014753885567188263,
-0.0053429752588272095,
0.011105788871645927,
-0.01184602826833725,
-0.03262806311249733,
0.00782355573028326,
0.0028486268129199743,
-0.0036648933310061693,
-0.01303597167134285,
0.03189357370138168,
0.01629064232110977,
-0.006207538768649101,
-0.0007441898342221975,
0.06277841329574585,
0.026876870542764664,
-0.03904854133725166,
0.045384205877780914,
-0.01430540345609188,
-0.00745041761547327,
0.006224133539944887,
-0.013468164950609207,
0.009588748216629028,
-0.008553966879844666,
-0.008929685689508915,
0.029921920970082283,
0.009376606903970242,
0.005568589083850384,
-0.02209123782813549,
0.030010344460606575,
-0.004550882149487734,
0.0025020288303494453,
-0.026368457823991776,
-0.002764074131846428,
-0.020405380055308342,
-0.03322641924023628,
-0.01716500148177147,
-0.001347202924080193,
0.018300533294677734,
-0.0030085768084973097,
-0.019221890717744827,
-0.009368677623569965,
0.04373807832598686,
-0.04542185366153717,
0.028209121897816658,
-0.006162033881992102,
0.02056773193180561,
0.021599311381578445,
0.018549097701907158,
-0.000495940912514925,
-0.026264650747179985,
0.0031117433682084084,
0.007179922424256802,
0.01273312233388424,
-0.0605098158121109,
0.011625467799603939,
-0.03698819503188133,
0.0017014227341860533,
0.035437341779470444,
-0.05484520271420479,
-0.0436621755361557,
0.01909533329308033,
-0.018964780494570732,
-0.0315321609377861,
0.012882218696177006,
0.0034977032337337732,
0.017850548028945923,
0.0002615932025946677,
0.015425234101712704,
0.013776510953903198,
0.04696075618267059,
-0.050996746867895126,
0.02312861755490303,
-0.04523628577589989,
0.07373576611280441,
-0.02070855163037777,
0.020708853378891945,
-0.0006923865294083953,
-0.0021018185652792454,
-0.013555051758885384,
0.04062316566705704,
-0.0026843782979995012,
-0.0167066752910614,
0.0474226288497448,
-0.03357931971549988,
-0.044682420790195465,
-0.006412239745259285,
0.026412269100546837,
-0.012281260453164577,
0.023943079635500908,
0.01071024127304554,
-0.023096153512597084,
-0.044822175055742264,
0.024928318336606026,
-0.0005250515532679856,
-0.0014194285031408072,
-0.004843384958803654,
-0.004178841132670641,
0.014120984822511673,
-0.00128096470143646,
0.019865073263645172,
0.002004405250772834,
-0.009040916338562965,
-0.01928270235657692,
-0.011278949677944183,
0.0062905773520469666,
-0.04546237364411354,
0.0272052064538002,
0.044167593121528625,
0.004979816731065512,
-0.02350037358701229,
-0.0441347137093544,
-0.010653708130121231,
-0.045887645334005356,
-0.01804404892027378,
-0.014013946987688541,
0.03333475813269615,
-0.03124905191361904,
0.00246118544600904,
0.006618250161409378,
0.01287715882062912,
0.02154749631881714,
-0.025930147618055344,
0.022143449634313583,
-0.0244798231869936,
0.01611952669918537,
-0.1529928296804428,
0.02299034781754017,
0.018780197948217392,
-0.007956191897392273,
-0.014414981007575989,
-0.00023676559794694185,
-0.03731134906411171,
-0.014756849966943264,
-0.039047230035066605,
0.0026142706628888845,
0.03559050336480141,
-0.008834418840706348,
0.024739792570471764,
-0.0421631820499897,
-0.056568969041109085,
0.028342587873339653,
-0.060327451676130295,
-0.024742547422647476,
-0.0940486267209053,
0.01453971117734909,
0.018549533560872078,
-0.0007018033065833151,
0.013717830181121826,
-0.013589435257017612,
0.010341783054172993,
-0.0003645835677161813,
0.015782922506332397,
-0.018143579363822937,
-0.03638627752661705,
-0.019493209198117256,
-0.011626147665083408,
-0.030959807336330414,
-0.016065916046500206,
0.08558157086372375,
-0.015784084796905518,
0.0005623658071272075,
-0.0024707824923098087,
0.005261939950287342,
-0.016077829524874687,
-0.017487864941358566,
-0.028319252654910088,
0.039771709591150284,
-0.023679981008172035,
-0.030375178903341293,
0.03167524188756943,
0.04679161310195923,
-0.013513102196156979,
-0.009909359738230705,
-0.061650894582271576,
-0.021333269774913788,
-0.04989755153656006,
0.043517496436834335,
0.008244404569268227,
0.0240203645080328,
-0.01905686967074871,
-0.018040645867586136,
0.005637223366647959,
-0.010893131606280804,
0.03016851469874382,
0.033617790788412094,
0.015217548236250877,
0.006350323557853699,
-0.05726413056254387,
0.007423756644129753,
-0.0017009254079312086,
0.016733616590499878,
-0.016997789964079857,
0.01697213016450405,
-0.017263751477003098,
-0.0034672576002776623,
-0.007246782537549734,
0.006238212808966637,
0.00874745287001133,
-0.07202807068824768,
0.030696040019392967,
-0.01638093777000904,
-0.01714956760406494,
0.016317183151841164,
-0.04878922924399376,
-0.013119302690029144,
-0.023083442822098732,
0.016755012795329094,
-0.04907852038741112,
0.013612418435513973,
0.04456641525030136,
0.040835246443748474,
-0.0019286737078800797,
-0.01432754099369049,
-0.007002133876085281,
-0.025170912966132164,
-0.06592633575201035,
-0.006533716339617968,
-0.021924059838056564,
0.05339059233665466,
-0.0002935136144515127,
0.035280514508485794,
0.004694558214396238,
0.01042129285633564,
-0.02584134228527546,
-0.01712564006447792,
-0.03613803908228874,
-0.03910002484917641,
0.0014729206450283527,
-0.008668367750942707,
-0.02990858443081379,
-0.012062286026775837,
0.04084036871790886,
-0.0002794664178509265,
0.01809442602097988,
-0.025538580492138863,
0.01997586339712143,
-0.01313718780875206,
-0.05010328069329262,
0.0363805927336216,
-0.07000456005334854,
0.00833571795374155,
0.005482993554323912,
0.010115113109350204,
0.029452301561832428,
0.010260572656989098,
0.04300425946712494,
-0.004992919508367777,
0.053780753165483475,
-0.017551107332110405,
0.006048337556421757,
0.04373955726623535,
0.06227587163448334,
0.01909605786204338,
0.010845321230590343,
-0.012835393659770489,
0.033342327922582626,
-0.00023184766178019345,
0.00984292384237051,
0.016846876591444016,
-0.023950425907969475,
0.004798810463398695,
-0.023599792271852493,
0.020013680681586266,
-0.05286083742976189,
-0.01599346101284027,
0.004596036393195391,
0.015450684353709221,
-0.013960326090455055,
0.00568547286093235,
-0.05112273618578911,
-0.0026553538627922535,
0.04389653727412224,
0.007518688682466745,
-0.021164674311876297,
-0.005539115983992815,
-0.010213521309196949,
0.03626642003655434,
0.0349474772810936,
0.02874387614428997,
0.016157185658812523,
-0.014720764942467213,
0.04846901819109917,
0.003148745745420456,
0.04647795855998993,
0.04831574484705925,
-0.01799052767455578,
-0.03374914079904556,
-0.02460593730211258,
-0.05129608139395714,
-0.02649979665875435,
0.05234462022781372,
-0.027498191222548485,
0.018755054101347923,
-0.021116845309734344,
-0.006971864495426416,
-0.010032772086560726,
-0.02825232967734337,
-0.02765997312963009,
-0.012872652150690556,
0.03545083850622177,
0.011100836098194122,
-0.019759925082325935,
-0.009884202852845192,
0.043150682002305984,
-0.02162320166826248,
0.0214875228703022,
0.00283281272277236,
0.03047560714185238,
-0.0002159738214686513,
0.010882178321480751,
0.03792368620634079,
-0.007627484388649464,
0.007638325449079275,
-0.010543638840317726,
-0.04285946488380432,
-0.0375170037150383,
-0.006780189462006092,
0.009607995860278606,
-0.013241161592304707,
0.036849044263362885,
0.044149789959192276,
0.005606077145785093,
0.028109673410654068,
0.02530232071876526,
0.005470855627208948,
0.01694837398827076,
-0.00023013939789962023,
-0.02565642073750496,
-0.024479223415255547,
-0.012068470008671284,
0.015287643298506737,
0.02568553201854229,
-0.03905479982495308,
-0.04589741677045822,
0.06422797590494156,
-0.013231056742370129,
-0.01657942496240139,
-0.002578405663371086,
0.02994030900299549,
-0.01320879627019167,
0.02392522804439068,
0.02410825714468956,
-0.0167065542191267,
0.05842223018407822,
-0.04434918612241745,
0.02586987055838108,
0.04640718176960945,
-0.01436895877122879,
-0.053826574236154556,
-0.0033793742768466473,
-0.0009827340254560113,
-0.0014346890384331346,
0.01570875570178032,
-0.012762208469212055,
0.043544646352529526,
-0.019215404987335205,
-0.006673356518149376,
-0.00044333565165288746,
0.05236179754137993,
-0.034876443445682526,
-0.0435163713991642,
-0.0076409862376749516,
0.0003544303181115538,
-0.0237493384629488,
0.007352637127041817,
0.06979487091302872,
-0.0056602368131279945,
0.00469036353752017,
-0.012164948508143425
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:3
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
39In support of those propositions, the plaintiffs point to five letters that Mr Hulley sent Powercoal between 15 April and 7 May 1999. Three of those letters were sent on HTT letterhead. Two were sent on LEC letterhead. Mr Hulley signed each letter as a director of the relevant company.
40On 15 April 1999, Mr Hulley sent a letter dated 15 April 1999 on HTT letterhead to Powercoal which advised Powercoal that HTT had been endeavouring, unsuccessfully, to "complete an acceptable arrangement" with LEC for funds to be loaned to LEC to enable it to complete the LEC Contract. The letter stated that HTT was ready, willing and able to "complete the Contract for Sale".
41On 18 April 1999, Mr Hulley sent a letter dated 18 April 1999 on LEC letterhead to Powercoal which advised Powercoal that LEC had exhausted every possible course of action to organise funding,
that a board meeting of LEC had been called to consider the appointment of an administrator and that in the event Powercoal issued a Notice of Termination of the LEC Contract, LEC had "no bona fide defence or sustainable argument against that course of action".
According to the plaintiffs, this letter was sent without the knowledge or authorisation of the board of LEC.
42On the same day (18 April 1999), Mr Hulley sent a letter dated 18 April 1999 on HTT letterhead to Powercoal advising that in the event that Powercoal did issue a Notice of Termination to LEC, then HTT requested the opportunity to acquire the Land and undertake the "Mine Rehabilitation Plan".
The letter stated that the directors of HTT (Ms Hulley-Beck and Messrs Hulley and Hickie) gave their undertaking to Powercoal that they were prepared to execute a contract for sale of land in identical terms to the LEC Contract. The letter also indicated the preparedness of the directors of HTT to indemnify Powercoal against any claim or litigation initiated by LEC.
43On 7 May 1999, Mr Hulley sent a letter dated 7 May 1999 on LEC letterhead to Powercoal stating that Mr Hulley was not able to indicate that LEC in its own right had the funds available to complete the purchase. According to the plaintiffs, this letter was sent without the knowledge or authorisation of the board of LEC.
44On the same day (7 May 1999), Mr Hulley sent a letter on HTT letterhead to Powercoal making a non-binding offer to Powercoal for the provision of security and maintenance resources "whilst Powercoal considers its position".
45LEC was not able to comply with Powercoal's Notice to Complete.
46On 7 May 1999, Powercoal terminated the LEC Contract.
Events taking place after termination of Powercoal Contract
47On 21 May 1999, Mr Zdrilic and LEC's then solicitor, Mr Allan Brown, attended a meeting with representatives of Powercoal in the hope of persuading Powercoal to extend the time for LEC to complete the LEC Contract.
48As Mr Zdrilic was unable to provide Powercoal with evidence of LEC's ability to finance the purchase of the Land or its rehabilitation, Powercoal refused to take the matter further.
49Mr Zdrilic accepted that, at the meeting of 21 May 1999, he had unsuccessfully sought an indulgence from Powercoal. From that time, Mr Zdrilic agreed Powercoal was entitled to sell the Land to whomever it wished.
50Mr Zdrilic gave the following evidence:-
Q: "So far as Powercoal was concerned, you believed at that time that was the end of it, that was as far as you could take it with Powercoal; correct?
A: If Powercoal were not prepared to give us an extension of time for me to put in order what needs to be put in order, then we have to face the facts and that was the end of it.
Q: And Powercoal wasn't prepared to give you that extension, was it, when you went to see them?
A: That's a fair assessment."
51Mr Zdrilic also accepted that, at that time, LEC did not have the funds to complete the Contract. Furthermore, Mr Zdrilic accepted that he did not have the funds to advance to LEC to enable it to complete the purchase.
|
[
-0.026371989399194717,
0.05257146805524826,
-0.012893200851976871,
-0.012031801976263523,
0.010165891610085964,
-0.07483620196580887,
0.010784081183373928,
-0.05745154619216919,
-0.0012466413900256157,
0.004132126457989216,
0.02693643979728222,
0.04755977541208267,
-0.042481936514377594,
0.010256047360599041,
-0.035748861730098724,
-0.03174752742052078,
0.04325181618332863,
0.0038922876119613647,
-0.02597835659980774,
-0.004446621052920818,
-0.012811875902116299,
-0.04738004133105278,
0.03048405423760414,
0.03708338737487793,
-0.03832551836967468,
-0.016154875978827477,
-0.0028746433090418577,
0.0192525926977396,
0.010773470625281334,
0.020514298230409622,
0.018150774762034416,
0.027615929022431374,
0.0666319951415062,
0.018747609108686447,
0.027880728244781494,
-0.03450256586074829,
0.045002058148384094,
-0.01964930258691311,
-0.030705204233527184,
-0.0023386399261653423,
-0.005436134524643421,
0.007993768900632858,
0.017806047573685646,
-0.06872724741697311,
0.02123851515352726,
-0.01987995207309723,
-0.003771451534703374,
-0.02025589346885681,
0.0025666095316410065,
0.00919928215444088,
-0.058639734983444214,
0.011714674532413483,
0.057547882199287415,
-0.03873610496520996,
0.003923311829566956,
0.0037330123595893383,
-0.019177177920937538,
-0.03453085571527481,
-0.07355424761772156,
-0.007861894555389881,
0.0017407637787982821,
-0.02666815184056759,
-0.08597604185342789,
0.00849473848938942,
-0.03427380695939064,
0.11230077594518661,
0.020294057205319405,
-0.005080199334770441,
0.00977895874530077,
-0.013145076110959053,
-0.03372390940785408,
-0.012766300700604916,
-0.014627098105847836,
0.005519642028957605,
-0.1016407385468483,
0.009855056181550026,
0.012077189050614834,
-0.009571559727191925,
0.07067189365625381,
0.02963547222316265,
0.04022181034088135,
-0.026694513857364655,
-0.012931534089148045,
0.055263351649045944,
0.0024041859433054924,
-0.0239581111818552,
-0.039217758923769,
0.058784790337085724,
-0.014636071398854256,
-0.033469654619693756,
0.011034385301172733,
-0.002858275780454278,
0.007702479604631662,
-0.034756530076265335,
-0.009632064960896969,
0.014109347946941853,
-0.05856465920805931,
0.00046317154192365706,
-0.0009075364796444774,
0.023219432681798935,
-0.012060649693012238,
0.00037269352469593287,
0.007161745335906744,
-0.031055500730872154,
-0.027501970529556274,
0.051473744213581085,
0.05595964938402176,
0.021062565967440605,
0.06552668660879135,
0.01524577010422945,
-0.007733603939414024,
-0.010080834850668907,
0.014356084167957306,
-0.01796998456120491,
-0.002286770613864064,
0.012248679995536804,
-0.019728926941752434,
-0.022618314251303673,
0.02498800866305828,
-0.00898442231118679,
0.04576896131038666,
0.03452781215310097,
-0.006077711004763842,
-0.025020161643624306,
-0.0460917167365551,
0.008404816500842571,
0.0259234718978405,
-0.019394123926758766,
-0.0065853651612997055,
0.04423922300338745,
0.012028960511088371,
0.02747187949717045,
-0.04057830199599266,
-0.01572648249566555,
-0.038082342594861984,
0.02771952748298645,
-0.02991572394967079,
-0.003489559283480048,
0.024748560041189194,
-0.051427971571683884,
0.04009813070297241,
0.01783573254942894,
-0.002179688774049282,
-0.058601945638656616,
0.022456711158156395,
0.01350912731140852,
-0.020768791437149048,
-0.010761008597910404,
0.026906106621026993,
0.03012944757938385,
0.03047509305179119,
0.05137258395552635,
0.0442529059946537,
-0.009306486696004868,
-0.016925038769841194,
-0.008158551529049873,
-0.04994460567831993,
-0.01855574920773506,
0.01829753816127777,
0.045397356152534485,
-0.03622329980134964,
0.06634116917848587,
-0.0053283292800188065,
0.005533689167350531,
-0.0001399897300871089,
-0.027626849710941315,
-0.019780650734901428,
0.02547730691730976,
-0.01753750815987587,
0.03423008695244789,
0.04039701446890831,
-0.027270952239632607,
0.04827360808849335,
-0.023143552243709564,
-0.028001412749290466,
0.017038047313690186,
0.026258569210767746,
0.00036634167190641165,
-0.010564833879470825,
0.005735840182751417,
-0.06371542066335678,
-0.003454623045399785,
-0.01126357726752758,
-0.04931486397981644,
-0.05591094121336937,
0.022963324561715126,
-0.05775763839483261,
-0.0074613806791603565,
-0.008068355731666088,
0.04455958306789398,
-0.027601422742009163,
-0.0032887363340705633,
-0.00961105152964592,
0.009991391561925411,
0.03913753479719162,
0.0018903367454186082,
0.01250455528497696,
-0.020364200696349144,
-0.015881594270467758,
-0.03605241701006889,
-0.020276201888918877,
0.01828821375966072,
0.06896352767944336,
-0.012359432876110077,
-0.03702671080827713,
0.027212971821427345,
0.014501039870083332,
0.00616983138024807,
-0.04235703870654106,
-0.048048969358205795,
0.008450432680547237,
-0.02078554593026638,
0.009374176152050495,
0.0503736175596714,
0.02112569473683834,
-0.035894107073545456,
-0.016728417947888374,
-0.02786610648036003,
0.03909963369369507,
-0.01269425731152296,
-0.04153905436396599,
0.014089451171457767,
-0.0019165008561685681,
-0.012345601804554462,
0.010614149272441864,
0.009562206454575062,
-0.03983980044722557,
0.034376125782728195,
-0.03104233555495739,
-0.03596901893615723,
0.010308327153325081,
-0.03611426427960396,
0.004332367330789566,
-0.016627347096800804,
-0.005466939881443977,
0.05363527312874794,
0.008669598959386349,
0.05843192711472511,
0.0361008457839489,
0.009624601341784,
-0.012761338613927364,
0.025203203782439232,
-0.012952334247529507,
-0.05551180616021156,
-0.02962365560233593,
-0.011187175288796425,
0.016251714900135994,
0.009498906321823597,
0.029606811702251434,
-0.006601030472666025,
-0.002896498888731003,
0.011500975117087364,
-0.012370551005005836,
-0.0007932151202112436,
-0.03594585880637169,
0.06460888683795929,
0.012560508213937283,
0.010686001740396023,
0.026412352919578552,
0.029923081398010254,
0.02744864486157894,
0.0231243297457695,
0.02824396826326847,
0.005191523116081953,
-0.010172544978559017,
0.005214540287852287,
-0.027277132496237755,
-0.02093532308936119,
0.04522275552153587,
-0.018327122554183006,
-0.005851395428180695,
-0.02106294594705105,
-0.005237107630819082,
0.040411628782749176,
0.027557386085391045,
-0.0029219358693808317,
0.029860233888030052,
0.0179040115326643,
-0.02126319892704487,
-0.00715373270213604,
0.04488309845328331,
0.03419985622167587,
0.015196001157164574,
-0.08143863081932068,
0.04519900679588318,
0.02312164194881916,
-0.035260532051324844,
-0.054758306592702866,
0.06859336793422699,
-0.033301882445812225,
-0.029723666608333588,
-0.01289798878133297,
0.06113772094249725,
-0.012276913039386272,
-0.06664177775382996,
-0.016107020899653435,
-0.01441262848675251,
-0.1591441035270691,
-0.016265280544757843,
-0.013377141207456589,
-0.014910534024238586,
-0.01572386734187603,
-0.005962486378848553,
-0.028008172288537025,
-0.002492422703653574,
-0.005898404400795698,
-0.030430953949689865,
0.03487879037857056,
-0.050395768135786057,
-0.016737783327698708,
0.01755101978778839,
-0.030472690239548683,
0.020694170147180557,
-0.012201440520584583,
0.009163564071059227,
0.04133227467536926,
-0.039702512323856354,
0.012002060189843178,
-0.023195510730147362,
0.05472594127058983,
0.00806833989918232,
0.000974745606072247,
0.00004519237336353399,
0.007723342161625624,
-0.02911868318915367,
-0.045963335782289505,
0.029721133410930634,
-0.013166304677724838,
0.06082380190491676,
-0.01598627306520939,
0.008863723836839199,
-0.00444856658577919,
0.019512375816702843,
0.06998509913682938,
-0.06357624381780624,
-0.004867032170295715,
-0.002237168373540044,
0.0375058576464653,
0.04171286150813103,
0.004006248898804188,
0.002957923337817192,
-0.004977255128324032,
-0.06272431463003159,
0.015042316168546677,
-0.012857967987656593,
-0.03969336673617363,
0.016265954822301865,
-0.007446846924722195,
0.004163175355643034,
-0.05055305361747742,
-0.045922353863716125,
0.03339539095759392,
-0.04004479572176933,
0.05466664209961891,
-0.013486244715750217,
-0.01347420271486044,
0.001490587368607521,
0.01249488815665245,
-0.038274943828582764,
-0.019073499366641045,
0.027462588623166084,
-0.006170016247779131,
-0.010607562959194183,
-0.025442758575081825,
-0.012693267315626144,
0.034836478531360626,
-0.006364018656313419,
0.011712250299751759,
0.02614491432905197,
0.014088613912463188,
-0.01683410257101059,
0.03283992037177086,
0.018201790750026703,
-0.08304810523986816,
0.0012454664101824164,
-0.02216046303510666,
-0.1056671291589737,
-0.03733742609620094,
0.018798694014549255,
-0.026081129908561707,
0.012893179431557655,
-0.012810897082090378,
0.00635775038972497,
0.028059542179107666,
0.038581300526857376,
0.03901612013578415,
0.2400640994310379,
-0.009161921218037605,
-0.028823522850871086,
0.03263266757130623,
0.04013148695230484,
-0.01622224971652031,
0.0013957986375316978,
0.0425388440489769,
-0.016291160136461258,
-0.046014316380023956,
-0.008915888145565987,
0.017635006457567215,
0.008963307365775108,
0.04241470620036125,
-0.011656158603727818,
0.0007556898053735495,
-0.03814304620027542,
-0.000437220063759014,
0.06421324610710144,
0.03134071081876755,
0.020200325176119804,
-0.010304689407348633,
-0.00040035496931523085,
0.0027367661241441965,
-0.05780980736017227,
-0.03177781403064728,
0.006457196548581123,
0.02331572398543358,
-0.05340658500790596,
-0.01625094562768936,
-0.02076778933405876,
-0.028732774779200554,
0.036016110330820084,
-0.009086987935006618,
-0.01017136313021183,
0.012112523429095745,
-0.01876387931406498,
0.00023656489793211222,
-0.004359683021903038,
0.004283783957362175,
-0.027373887598514557,
-0.03364163637161255,
-0.027462422847747803,
-0.0048020691610872746,
-0.031103292480111122,
0.01996523141860962,
-0.040245965123176575,
0.057960253208875656,
0.00881966669112444,
0.0008408118737861514,
-0.00811594445258379,
0.051545169204473495,
-0.045959144830703735,
-0.04586956650018692,
-0.00935266725718975,
0.0200343020260334,
0.004592651501297951,
0.050669100135564804,
-0.008293443359434605,
0.057091958820819855,
0.04324468970298767,
0.032710686326026917,
-0.03957521170377731,
0.04430007562041283,
-0.005602648481726646,
0.014313610270619392,
-0.022430067881941795,
0.0166141539812088,
0.04353689029812813,
0.009020431898534298,
0.049723342061042786,
-0.01643170602619648,
0.007118965033441782,
0.02142045460641384,
0.046882640570402145,
-0.0077949706465005875,
-0.04669126123189926,
0.036405693739652634,
-0.019232651218771935,
0.020264187827706337,
0.0028058679308742285,
-0.03312404081225395,
0.0019375813426449895,
0.01896045356988907,
0.0142457140609622,
0.01239658985286951,
0.0014322934439405799,
-0.004002508707344532,
-0.01895231381058693,
0.0004978901706635952,
0.0006676717894151807,
0.025998178869485855,
-0.006181613076478243,
-0.018814273178577423,
-0.039436858147382736,
-0.03667285665869713,
0.027905050665140152,
-0.03306758403778076,
0.019991720095276833,
-0.042949460446834564,
0.015972165390849113,
0.03658205270767212,
-0.020206620916724205,
-0.006948502734303474,
0.012488997541368008,
0.0058932011015713215,
-0.025247633457183838,
0.02669261023402214,
-0.023404443636536598,
0.07003779709339142,
0.03201077878475189,
0.03388511389493942,
0.0009682831587269902,
0.0017766637029126287,
0.039012081921100616,
0.0598614402115345,
-0.0036268746480345726,
0.04045227915048599,
0.0546429418027401,
0.029524700716137886,
0.011720318347215652,
-0.03188055381178856,
-0.050113338977098465,
-0.009611336514353752,
-0.03209686651825905,
-0.007415437605232,
0.013171653263270855,
-0.01626681536436081,
0.004215204156935215,
-0.010085128247737885,
-0.03098669834434986,
-0.02633260004222393,
-0.01701008528470993,
-0.013379472307860851,
0.029543999582529068,
0.019721347838640213,
0.0009944167686626315,
0.010723639279603958,
-0.054464247077703476,
-0.0007843184284865856,
-0.028029272332787514,
-0.0018695949111133814,
-0.04450425133109093,
-0.0439339205622673,
0.020610986277461052,
-0.03964334726333618,
-0.045681167393922806,
-0.006070640403777361,
0.011655476875603199,
0.022565044462680817,
0.006376327481120825,
0.005177531857043505,
-0.03216823935508728,
-0.02916855178773403,
0.0074468934908509254,
-0.005053750704973936,
-0.0007430525729432702,
0.010267565958201885,
-0.00378752825781703,
-0.03330569714307785,
-0.023155469447374344,
0.05359857529401779,
0.007495021913200617,
0.027887482196092606,
0.034532688558101654,
0.056193768978118896,
-0.00852834340184927,
0.06089362874627113,
0.09644252061843872,
0.008561268448829651,
-0.017245719209313393,
-0.048281121999025345,
-0.03350431099534035,
0.027946898713707924,
0.04392991214990616,
0.06898132711648941,
-0.01004656683653593,
-0.020170249044895172,
0.007568389642983675,
-0.022595439106225967,
0.052993159741163254,
0.043947234749794006,
-0.07183697074651718,
0.008065245114266872,
-0.017679188400506973,
0.009239427745342255,
-0.0014271653490141034,
-0.004184134304523468,
0.03955484554171562,
-0.05117427185177803,
-0.0011178716085851192,
0.08094245940446854,
0.0244150273501873,
-0.023495646193623543,
0.042990632355213165,
0.004831038415431976,
-0.017948618158698082,
0.033170606940984726,
0.02069307677447796,
-0.02260150946676731,
-0.029547709971666336,
0.008131689392030239,
0.009421746246516705,
0.017383607104420662,
-0.00682568084448576,
0.0009812916396185756,
0.029722832143306732,
0.02395995520055294,
-0.07660652697086334,
-0.04194428026676178,
0.010806865058839321,
0.04170330986380577,
-0.0441460944712162,
0.0022715299855917692,
0.02488049305975437,
-0.012769821099936962,
0.005441304761916399,
0.03326835483312607,
0.012723395600914955,
-0.03349610045552254,
-0.02292894385755062,
-0.002391461981460452,
0.036415740847587585,
-0.0734667256474495,
0.03699960932135582,
0.004948586691170931,
-0.00810643844306469,
0.023540785536170006,
-0.01942257583141327,
-0.012874672189354897,
-0.002241244073957205,
-0.05344277247786522,
0.07010648399591446,
-0.05090467631816864,
0.01285705529153347,
-0.010887275449931622,
0.030293313786387444,
0.015751123428344727,
0.026652513071894646,
0.01900341734290123,
0.015307629480957985,
-0.011029642075300217,
0.028331829234957695,
0.03736661747097969,
-0.003553645219653845,
-0.019316524267196655,
0.015505609102547169,
0.017560770735144615,
0.033905029296875,
0.034879170358181,
0.01026039756834507,
0.009657316841185093,
-0.005534662399441004,
-0.028949515894055367,
0.023112688213586807,
0.024521490558981895,
0.021810686215758324,
-0.03068452514708042,
-0.06404020637273788,
-0.008305656723678112,
-0.015623001381754875,
-0.020822282880544662,
0.01927085965871811,
-0.008338319137692451,
-0.02954912558197975,
-0.050820257514715195,
0.016740428283810616,
-0.016761578619480133,
-0.01674199104309082,
-0.017874693498015404,
0.006992849055677652,
0.014020435512065887,
-0.010141479782760143,
-0.06735149025917053,
-0.029934197664260864,
0.013906938955187798,
-0.009645427577197552,
-0.004213480744510889,
-0.02053009904921055,
0.0003441707813180983,
0.03062182478606701,
0.0007945177494548261,
0.01332069467753172,
0.009100839495658875,
-0.007367102429270744,
0.004785590339452028,
-0.012373454868793488,
0.015519761480391026,
-0.026945915073156357,
0.04695663973689079,
0.017291665077209473,
0.010172618553042412,
-0.018378334119915962,
0.00788943562656641,
-0.004298831801861525,
0.004372859839349985,
-0.0023623902816325426,
0.04464113339781761,
-0.004516375716775656,
0.007572486996650696,
-0.025852220132946968,
-0.03230077773332596,
-0.02759086899459362,
-0.06476862728595734,
-0.028503740206360817,
-0.018694905564188957,
0.0017206919146701694,
0.008562748320400715,
-0.00274193799123168,
-0.009262612089514732,
0.016630753874778748,
-0.040238820016384125,
-0.019667914137244225,
-0.023343686014413834,
0.015606953762471676,
-0.0007942243828438222,
-0.012356777675449848,
-0.029108913615345955,
-0.03603146970272064,
-0.014165908098220825,
0.0007824327331036329,
0.015877531841397285,
-0.0423421747982502,
-0.012095090933144093,
-0.017009630799293518,
0.007679210044443607,
0.019398367032408714,
-0.06914335489273071,
-0.05729372799396515,
0.02766164392232895,
-0.03234625607728958,
0.005579848773777485,
0.015366759151220322,
-0.01766217313706875,
0.03585057333111763,
0.007101557217538357,
0.004412929527461529,
0.010509965009987354,
0.011607367545366287,
-0.05588860437273979,
0.007208709139376879,
-0.049384865909814835,
0.05508137494325638,
0.01872529275715351,
0.01881399005651474,
0.005545164458453655,
-0.0016095134196802974,
0.0038737840950489044,
0.014784461818635464,
0.013731851242482662,
-0.0043146805837750435,
-0.02033125050365925,
-0.0013762202579528093,
-0.04221641272306442,
0.03127569705247879,
-0.01619662158191204,
0.03824087977409363,
0.00807129219174385,
0.011742840521037579,
-0.01599285565316677,
0.022809522226452827,
0.017420724034309387,
0.004420914687216282,
-0.00814594142138958,
0.0028353030793368816,
-0.008199679665267467,
-0.015003344044089317,
0.035800110548734665,
-0.028816767036914825,
-0.009224514476954937,
0.006134857423603535,
-0.00279554002918303,
-0.025432057678699493,
0.028181424364447594,
-0.036775052547454834,
0.034625373780727386,
0.019783519208431244,
0.012596036307513714,
0.02795102633535862,
-0.04728373885154724,
-0.009164542891085148,
-0.03621871396899223,
-0.03236529231071472,
-0.01523797120898962,
0.03380923345685005,
0.03279408812522888,
-0.00048470470937900245,
0.02166147157549858,
0.041125454008579254,
0.0029196706600487232,
-0.007613730151206255,
-0.009076457470655441,
-0.033861469477415085,
-0.00972047820687294,
-0.12904521822929382,
-0.019118187949061394,
-0.03547186404466629,
0.0069626267068088055,
-0.024583231657743454,
0.0006168124382384121,
-0.00006157518510008231,
0.050491105765104294,
-0.01291719637811184,
0.004195001441985369,
0.008774408139288425,
-0.04721122607588768,
-0.01022692397236824,
-0.018342643976211548,
-0.022077003493905067,
0.01440940797328949,
-0.0462774895131588,
-0.009370984509587288,
-0.04492165893316269,
0.049643468111753464,
0.03879062086343765,
0.0007649209583178163,
-0.029869727790355682,
-0.020884724333882332,
-0.0023038850631564856,
0.011875597760081291,
-0.013332420028746128,
-0.07240767031908035,
-0.02315473183989525,
-0.01877553202211857,
-0.01483199279755354,
0.011640588752925396,
-0.0010723096784204245,
0.06461264938116074,
0.003151856828480959,
0.03948274999856949,
0.019748367369174957,
-0.0108505142852664,
-0.03560606390237808,
-0.026475921273231506,
-0.00691155856475234,
0.03474823385477066,
-0.02667170763015747,
-0.024652596563100815,
-0.02747693844139576,
-0.03486131876707077,
-0.017918171361088753,
0.0036525768227875233,
-0.06617607176303864,
-0.05434976890683174,
-0.032070476561784744,
0.01460455171763897,
0.021481143310666084,
0.040188636630773544,
0.018552372232079506,
0.0025411322712898254,
0.016114475205540657,
-0.017723601311445236,
0.01873045600950718,
0.02647671103477478,
0.04727238044142723,
0.02758888527750969,
-0.03418673202395439,
0.020930245518684387,
-0.026800276711583138,
-0.003836216637864709,
0.017938347533345222,
-0.00011458669905550778,
-0.019787689670920372,
0.0218183770775795,
-0.023071208968758583,
-0.012291926890611649,
-0.012098873034119606,
-0.032504551112651825,
0.020981941372156143,
-0.014210015535354614,
0.005160968750715256,
-0.018134191632270813,
-0.037283945828676224,
-0.03256307169795036,
-0.027300508692860603,
0.020474372431635857,
-0.04373808577656746,
-0.004518528003245592,
0.06334328651428223,
0.045051105320453644,
-0.0021320972591638565,
-0.014710296876728535,
0.023191027343273163,
-0.0021705543622374535,
-0.05081479623913765,
-0.0224031712859869,
-0.012657757848501205,
0.02464037388563156,
-0.027220141142606735,
0.00908256508409977,
0.005142663139849901,
0.035547029227018356,
0.016627658158540726,
-0.037315886467695236,
-0.0832962766289711,
0.014312461949884892,
0.030475325882434845,
0.005802010651677847,
-0.041015759110450745,
0.032794974744319916,
0.028183020651340485,
0.04877139627933502,
0.011957607232034206,
-0.05345303192734718,
-0.015530395321547985,
-0.014160353690385818,
-0.014146704226732254,
0.024817347526550293,
-0.023805849254131317,
-0.0028141606599092484,
0.01796460896730423,
0.006509039085358381,
0.005374965723603964,
-0.011679846793413162,
0.001883789780549705,
0.010528245940804482,
0.014855755493044853,
-0.03604445978999138,
-0.03317184001207352,
-0.014401134103536606,
0.08254307508468628,
0.016379592940211296,
0.012426674365997314,
-0.02613525278866291,
0.04949643462896347,
0.016172245144844055,
0.03317444026470184,
0.025440454483032227,
0.014812731184065342,
0.015119745396077633,
-0.021183853968977928,
0.0050169723108410835,
-0.0367145910859108,
-0.053421709686517715,
-0.021767277270555496,
-0.009767265059053898,
0.011620430275797844,
-0.021880922839045525,
-0.050324779003858566,
0.015868667513132095,
0.023629406467080116,
-0.005561163183301687,
0.007824801839888096,
-0.05185779929161072,
-0.01882852613925934,
0.007282430771738291,
-0.000026228726710542105,
0.03076474741101265,
0.04007083922624588,
-0.02515294961631298,
0.04823056980967522,
-0.014913597144186497,
0.025647707283496857,
0.022595331072807312,
0.010958501137793064,
-0.058191027492284775,
-0.036008503288030624,
-0.003178312676027417,
-0.01743108034133911,
0.03122706711292267,
-0.029040422290563583,
-0.015923313796520233,
-0.01628943905234337,
-0.0064595965668559074,
-0.003128014737740159,
0.026898948475718498,
-0.02865924872457981,
0.021202733740210533,
0.026009339839220047,
-0.0150688998401165,
0.01079602725803852,
-0.004775682929903269,
0.06541913002729416,
-0.007593196351081133,
0.04612327367067337,
0.03743192180991173,
0.029519082978367805,
-0.013636690564453602,
-0.0003269435546826571,
0.026489023119211197,
0.02114987187087536,
0.018450859934091568,
-0.014872567728161812,
-0.03316067159175873,
-0.023441486060619354,
0.031043928116559982,
-0.0001394734572386369,
-0.007370071019977331,
-0.0011352987494319677,
0.007405709940940142,
0.0031760786660015583,
0.04714014753699303,
0.008318665437400341,
0.0407392680644989,
0.026523534208536148,
-0.03677435964345932,
-0.014002705924212933,
-0.028911631554365158,
-0.012354327365756035,
0.010202006436884403,
-0.0062367613427340984,
-0.062071654945611954,
-0.05242714658379555,
0.029279738664627075,
-0.007217343430966139,
0.00868286844342947,
-0.029846079647541046,
0.005273664370179176,
0.002190214116126299,
0.0052177757024765015,
0.010096552781760693,
0.00614481745287776,
0.027889542281627655,
0.002772196428850293,
0.009327546693384647,
0.0034660235978662968,
-0.005005948711186647,
-0.00593598885461688,
0.004390856251120567,
0.012977627106010914,
-0.017879901453852654,
0.003351784311234951,
-0.017822375521063805,
0.043162159621715546,
-0.02455834113061428,
0.009061599150300026,
0.0009206588147208095,
0.024396559223532677,
0.009839610196650028,
-0.012906186282634735,
-0.024047086015343666,
-0.030354470014572144,
-0.03296893462538719,
-0.00912496168166399,
0.04946643114089966,
-0.0063318610191345215,
-0.001064992044121027,
0.006658830214291811
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:64
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
(c)Mr and Mrs Zdrilic have suffered a reduction of their interest in the Project to 10 per cent via the 1/3 holding of Amy Holdings in Sentel;
(d)Mr and Mrs Zdrilic have lost the value of the loan owed to them by LEC; and
(e)Mr Zdrilic has lost the opportunity of being apart of the decision making process of HTT.
928In view of the findings I have made, my conclusion is that none of the plaintiffs have suffered damage as a result of any conduct of the defendants.
929However, extensive submissions were made by Mr Jucovic and by Mr Einfeld concerning the first and second heads of the damage claim, namely the loss suffered by LEC as a result of its inability to pursue the 2001 Proceedings.
930I have come to the conclusion that the plaintiffs have not made out a basis to set aside the 6 September 2004 order pursuant to which the plaintiffs consented to the dismissal of the 2001 Proceedings.
It follows, of course, that in my view, it was the plaintiffs' consent to the dismissal of those proceedings, not any conduct of the defendants, that has resulted in LEC losing the opportunity to pursue the 2001 Proceedings.
931However, out of deference to the extensive submissions made by Mr Jucovic and Mr Einfeld about the value of LEC's lost opportunity, I shall address the issues raised by those submissions, albeit briefly.
The 2001 Proceedings - damages for loss of opportunity - generally
932The damages (if any) suffered by LEC arising from the loss of opportunity to prosecute the 2001 Proceedings must be determined at the date when the 2001 Proceedings would have come on for hearing - that is the "notional date for hearing" of the 2001 Proceedings: Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351 at 368;
Nikolaou v Papasavas, Phillips & Co (1989) 166 CLR 394 at 403-404; Steve Masselos & Co v Young [2011] NSWCA 352 at [48-50].
933In Nikolaou v Papasavas, Phillips & Co, Wilson, Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ said at 404:-
"That loss would ordinarily be quantified by the trial judge taking a broad brush approach to the several matters that in a particular case may require to be resolved - the likely date when (...
) the action would have come to trial, the evidence that would or should have been available to the plaintiff at that time, the relevant principles of law then governing the assessment of damages (...) in order to arrive at a figure representing the loss suffered by the plaintiff when his action against the defendant was dismissed."
Were the 2001 Proceedings bound to fail?
934It will be recalled that, in the 2001 Proceedings, LEC claimed that HTT held the Land on constructive trust for LEC and claimed, amongst other relief, an account of profits.
935As I set about in paragraph 71 above, the basis upon which that relief was sought was that:-
(a)after the LEC Contract was terminated, HTT had, with knowledge, made use of information and opportunities which Mr Hulley and Mr Hickie had acquired as directors of LEC;
(b)HTT had received the benefit of the Land in circumstances where it knew of Mr Hulley's and/or Mr Hickie's breaches of fiduciary and statutory duties to LEC; and
(c)HTT had acquired legal ownership of the Land with notice of LEC's "continuing equitable interest" in the Land and with notice of alleged breaches by Mr Hulley and Mr Hickie.
936The background to the 2001 Proceeding is set out early in this judgment, including:-
(a)LEC's entry into the LEC Contract with Powercoal on 29 June 1998 (paragraphs 28 to 37 above);
(b)Mr Hulley's alleged role in subverting LEC's interest under the LEC Contract (paragraphs 38 to 45 above);
(c)Powercoal's termination of the LEC Contract (paragraph 46 above);
(d)the statements made by LEC's then solicitor, Mr Brown, as to LEC's inability to fund the purchase from Powercoal (paragraphs 54 to 55 above);
(e)the entry by HTT into the contract with Powercoal on 11 April 2000, and its completion on 17 October 2000 (paragraphs 56 to 62 above); and
(f)the progress of the 2001 Proceedings (paragraphs 63 to 77 above).
937Mr Einfeld submitted that the 2001 Proceedings were bound to fail for three reasons:-
|
[
-0.04838316887617111,
0.020711757242679596,
-0.03137374296784401,
0.004362537059932947,
0.01719078980386257,
-0.029259243980050087,
0.007449635770171881,
-0.03955609351396561,
0.03665713965892792,
0.0073125408962368965,
-0.027367819100618362,
0.014412442222237587,
-0.024849772453308105,
0.005878316704183817,
-0.02033665031194687,
-0.026031551882624626,
0.029198210686445236,
-0.00045275999582372606,
-0.025335773825645447,
0.000783911207690835,
0.0022841482423245907,
0.0024654713924974203,
0.02491024322807789,
0.02011915296316147,
-0.026162315160036087,
-0.01692626066505909,
-0.020503642037510872,
0.01548608485609293,
0.02528272196650505,
0.01406131312251091,
-0.020739611238241196,
0.017554746940732002,
0.057562872767448425,
-0.03140223026275635,
0.0058230808936059475,
-0.007606420665979385,
0.03330231457948685,
0.0066792042925953865,
-0.026286426931619644,
0.004707257729023695,
0.036094509065151215,
0.002926888410001993,
0.016215849667787552,
-0.04746362566947937,
0.07027353346347809,
-0.029545335099101067,
-0.021577782928943634,
-0.030116159468889236,
-0.027618994936347008,
-0.0058827451430261135,
-0.038264356553554535,
-0.014485162682831287,
0.05392478406429291,
-0.03535372391343117,
-0.023485418409109116,
-0.02341410703957081,
-0.0256558358669281,
-0.027464458718895912,
-0.04164516180753708,
0.0026137756649404764,
0.0019015349680557847,
-0.004369811620563269,
-0.035014137625694275,
-0.025665579363703728,
-0.016217898577451706,
0.11195798218250275,
-0.02482445165514946,
-0.004430358298122883,
0.007158627733588219,
-0.009036586619913578,
-0.030309896916151047,
-0.00024075433611869812,
-0.03212374076247215,
0.018260812386870384,
-0.0905308797955513,
0.020336171612143517,
0.010954620316624641,
-0.0004252616490703076,
0.08239418268203735,
0.02500714734196663,
0.0381513386964798,
-0.015141314826905727,
-0.0019686573650687933,
0.04492563754320145,
-0.017565656453371048,
0.0022728131152689457,
-0.06837308406829834,
0.03804413601756096,
0.01932614855468273,
-0.044674817472696304,
-0.006172834429889917,
0.008703990839421749,
0.0004982345853932202,
-0.006283191964030266,
0.00666913203895092,
-0.0010043025249615312,
-0.10680539906024933,
0.01801484078168869,
-0.014555121771991253,
0.016412563621997833,
0.018002264201641083,
0.0027449754998087883,
-0.011977804824709892,
-0.05917889252305031,
-0.0012583555653691292,
0.020012909546494484,
0.054177481681108475,
0.04093638435006142,
0.04272862896323204,
0.008742427453398705,
-0.0176532082259655,
-0.027471361681818962,
-0.0052019087597727776,
0.009250474162399769,
-0.024523720145225525,
-0.01673762872815132,
0.012556933797895908,
-0.014405688270926476,
0.05030670389533043,
-0.005635980051010847,
0.05806903541088104,
0.021231569349765778,
0.044330697506666183,
-0.012388761155307293,
-0.037075113505125046,
0.01788073219358921,
0.020814528688788414,
0.003797569777816534,
-0.008099560625851154,
0.04744129255414009,
-0.0013162923278287053,
0.008881877176463604,
-0.011575902812182903,
-0.0605735220015049,
-0.03846273943781853,
-0.012555873021483421,
-0.03032821975648403,
0.0046262904070317745,
0.017675770446658134,
-0.04099535569548607,
0.06698199361562729,
0.04042902588844299,
0.01038883812725544,
-0.04546968266367912,
0.014645117335021496,
0.0234934501349926,
-0.006565650459378958,
0.0036022483836859465,
0.01593295857310295,
0.006247034762054682,
0.020271357148885727,
0.032513152807950974,
0.026850903406739235,
-0.026547372341156006,
0.029944712296128273,
-0.01987125352025032,
-0.043503209948539734,
-0.039411865174770355,
0.042242079973220825,
0.04409170523285866,
-0.06075423210859299,
0.004626363981515169,
-0.010453255847096443,
0.018238157033920288,
-0.006148924119770527,
0.018227286636829376,
-0.012303954921662807,
0.030765974894165993,
-0.029854126274585724,
0.015287822112441063,
0.02286820486187935,
-0.027081670239567757,
0.0010105931432917714,
-0.020123865455389023,
0.012248599901795387,
0.01791567914187908,
0.01650058664381504,
0.001991981640458107,
-0.011972798965871334,
-0.01067187450826168,
-0.032144490629434586,
0.01020046602934599,
0.02853640727698803,
-0.05312606319785118,
-0.05623508617281914,
0.011891962960362434,
0.0014526481973007321,
-0.015027722343802452,
-0.009273876436054707,
0.03544014319777489,
-0.009369960986077785,
-0.024782536551356316,
0.020893368870019913,
0.028913304209709167,
0.035814180970191956,
-0.02715572528541088,
0.00939133483916521,
-0.03504357859492302,
0.0006631394498981535,
-0.023949969559907913,
-0.041616905480623245,
0.035807475447654724,
0.048422057181596756,
-0.04667263105511665,
-0.03258414566516876,
0.028239024803042412,
-0.02626950293779373,
0.016453392803668976,
-0.025585761293768883,
-0.03520834073424339,
-0.007780092768371105,
0.010778886266052723,
0.0020700853783637285,
0.037142712622880936,
0.031897857785224915,
0.00482593011111021,
-0.002674225252121687,
-0.004842867609113455,
0.007604395505040884,
-0.027898171916604042,
-0.03377145901322365,
0.008737505413591862,
0.033093955367803574,
-0.02279888652265072,
0.02301706187427044,
0.030694326385855675,
-0.016497433185577393,
0.013755851425230503,
-0.02258254773914814,
-0.03478682413697243,
0.01642908900976181,
-0.006202314980328083,
0.014223172329366207,
-0.02921309508383274,
0.015973715111613274,
0.018254369497299194,
0.03628630191087723,
0.020975181832909584,
0.021644312888383865,
-0.012577902525663376,
-0.06326144188642502,
0.019246328622102737,
-0.021380100399255753,
-0.047902662307024,
-0.005147142801433802,
-0.03473614156246185,
0.013464703224599361,
0.010700776241719723,
0.05020452290773392,
0.004670938476920128,
0.026146506890654564,
0.0009630961576476693,
-0.03853965923190117,
-0.016696274280548096,
-0.006540607661008835,
0.04089313745498657,
0.012362895533442497,
0.007792233489453793,
0.008866723626852036,
0.008771121501922607,
0.020308542996644974,
0.012491717003285885,
0.053425468504428864,
0.010303013026714325,
-0.03448612615466118,
-0.004092955030500889,
0.012413093820214272,
-0.025249028578400612,
0.018125448375940323,
0.010722748003900051,
0.014412342570722103,
0.005805172957479954,
-0.009054610505700111,
0.02003967948257923,
0.02792222984135151,
-0.024315034970641136,
0.03914941847324371,
0.01865331642329693,
-0.02032732218503952,
-0.016615161672234535,
0.013427882455289364,
0.004188130144029856,
0.029521221294999123,
-0.054778385907411575,
-0.002581479260697961,
0.01650223322212696,
-0.0019182212417945266,
-0.020225469022989273,
0.03659210354089737,
-0.010936537757515907,
-0.008919864892959595,
-0.03247053176164627,
0.07349143922328949,
-0.015727629885077477,
-0.0806623324751854,
0.02788539230823517,
-0.026320692151784897,
-0.1456555426120758,
-0.017810728400945663,
-0.03878961130976677,
-0.031392619013786316,
-0.014836417511105537,
0.011295421980321407,
-0.05122044309973717,
0.002466038102284074,
-0.04114700108766556,
0.007621249184012413,
-0.01902216114103794,
-0.05903702974319458,
-0.01820407062768936,
0.004250942263752222,
-0.044425949454307556,
0.017769213765859604,
0.007128817494958639,
0.0242770966142416,
0.052168164402246475,
-0.03467421978712082,
0.01567072980105877,
-0.05998463183641434,
0.0688137486577034,
0.024461869150400162,
0.027958804741501808,
0.010610111989080906,
-0.009905767627060413,
-0.00008604791219113395,
-0.036124177277088165,
0.011981927789747715,
-0.026324154809117317,
0.035047613084316254,
-0.005514177028089762,
0.029858466237783432,
0.008873985148966312,
0.01071910746395588,
0.08176925778388977,
-0.05836581811308861,
-0.04145646467804909,
-0.008088306523859501,
0.03762303292751312,
0.04209103062748909,
-0.014264986850321293,
0.0018473324598744512,
0.010344551876187325,
-0.07027299702167511,
0.014254082925617695,
-0.013906021602451801,
-0.01576819270849228,
0.051394328474998474,
0.0034968142863363028,
0.01585220731794834,
-0.021160876378417015,
-0.045097604393959045,
0.02488940767943859,
-0.023958908393979073,
0.05430401489138603,
-0.007697094231843948,
-0.021594708785414696,
0.01465066708624363,
-0.034948404878377914,
-0.06877752393484116,
0.007002466823905706,
0.01340535655617714,
0.0019409757805988193,
-0.03213074803352356,
-0.019183708354830742,
-0.012115567922592163,
0.019096368923783302,
-0.008217218331992626,
-0.001058807596564293,
-0.007880089804530144,
-0.010733183473348618,
-0.03470611572265625,
-0.024626342579722404,
0.014902550727128983,
-0.0610642284154892,
0.013873436488211155,
-0.005308960564434528,
-0.10187820345163345,
-0.02460756152868271,
0.005845723673701286,
-0.030259674414992332,
0.016075074672698975,
-0.0021652071736752987,
0.010059354826807976,
0.06223996356129646,
0.04083770141005516,
0.016363848000764847,
0.22633041441440582,
0.01599901355803013,
-0.019179174676537514,
0.00018194019503425807,
-0.014992556534707546,
-0.02650715783238411,
0.012445437721908092,
0.039676666259765625,
-0.013209711760282516,
-0.05113452300429344,
-0.06578648835420609,
-0.005374216940253973,
-0.0014000666560605168,
0.043386586010456085,
-0.050639256834983826,
-0.04183318465948105,
-0.03294094651937485,
-0.030823806300759315,
0.06053563579916954,
0.01623203419148922,
0.0326966717839241,
-0.004501551855355501,
-0.0009606837411411107,
0.0007425092626363039,
-0.044844821095466614,
-0.04193286597728729,
0.012119099497795105,
0.0531349778175354,
-0.06719820201396942,
-0.0003392236540094018,
-0.030031252652406693,
-0.004390660673379898,
0.04536159709095955,
-0.013279789127409458,
0.010234671644866467,
0.008487286977469921,
-0.03307001292705536,
0.012740680947899818,
0.021763702854514122,
-0.011534763500094414,
0.018406525254249573,
-0.015376892872154713,
-0.09084528684616089,
0.004177293740212917,
-0.04841359704732895,
0.037711042910814285,
-0.025447068735957146,
0.02188597433269024,
0.03064804896712303,
0.025410301983356476,
-0.025563456118106842,
0.027808455750346184,
-0.029339030385017395,
-0.030687090009450912,
-0.024927256628870964,
0.025677619501948357,
-0.023290783166885376,
0.0377269946038723,
0.012768097221851349,
0.023894721642136574,
0.05475308373570442,
0.010059364140033722,
-0.029677128419280052,
0.01106916181743145,
-0.023543892428278923,
0.035822153091430664,
-0.042135268449783325,
0.030006928369402885,
0.07250019907951355,
0.015902532264590263,
0.05717051774263382,
-0.001004495075903833,
0.002464630641043186,
0.008275030180811882,
0.012649237178266048,
0.015578788705170155,
-0.003373244311660528,
0.07333154231309891,
-0.02171761356294155,
0.004572998266667128,
-0.041268378496170044,
-0.02927805297076702,
-0.008505807258188725,
0.03519932180643082,
0.019185656681656837,
0.0027388932649046183,
-0.0304107628762722,
-0.015518777072429657,
0.011956418864428997,
-0.02415490709245205,
0.006222438998520374,
-0.026565589010715485,
0.02666936069726944,
0.017676709219813347,
-0.021017100661993027,
-0.018466666340827942,
0.0059989080764353275,
-0.012484447099268436,
0.011461370624601841,
-0.028825338929891586,
0.0017303925706073642,
-0.0014479785459116101,
0.007669810671359301,
-0.05666479095816612,
0.018883898854255676,
-0.0006802192074246705,
-0.01222304254770279,
-0.0037824143655598164,
-0.05085353925824165,
0.005171840079128742,
-0.0005842751706950366,
0.029414121061563492,
0.03295053914189339,
-0.029867075383663177,
0.022867459803819656,
0.04460892081260681,
0.029209058731794357,
0.056197598576545715,
0.04590335860848427,
0.05000665783882141,
0.024505261331796646,
0.0166217889636755,
-0.02216699719429016,
-0.020022263750433922,
-0.010472701862454414,
0.014807119965553284,
0.0033385981805622578,
-0.01863766275346279,
0.030152175575494766,
0.03102780319750309,
0.004747883882373571,
-0.030599698424339294,
-0.018624858930706978,
-0.01303607877343893,
0.04753623902797699,
0.03241853043437004,
-0.03098638355731964,
0.0027189620304852724,
-0.045976780354976654,
-0.00006890238000778481,
-0.009193912148475647,
-0.009023552760481834,
-0.022902607917785645,
-0.010457799769937992,
0.006605510134249926,
0.003331296844407916,
-0.04321666434407234,
0.004165929742157459,
-0.05056441202759743,
0.0018449357012286782,
-0.007899676449596882,
-0.0008960947161540389,
-0.029390595853328705,
-0.01214624848216772,
-0.0055523402988910675,
0.012820945121347904,
-0.0020425606053322554,
-0.01823442243039608,
0.03025667928159237,
-0.009747123345732689,
0.020004449412226677,
0.015936248004436493,
0.010661875829100609,
0.05228351801633835,
0.0540899857878685,
0.05998462811112404,
-0.024412309750914574,
0.05857573822140694,
0.05510661378502846,
-0.01778322272002697,
-0.037721674889326096,
-0.02271956577897072,
-0.03290659189224243,
0.0461578331887722,
0.032953981310129166,
0.03255589306354523,
0.0015729299047961831,
0.012796267867088318,
-0.004996180068701506,
-0.012423672713339329,
0.04897134006023407,
0.018341248854994774,
-0.004982802551239729,
0.026997234672307968,
-0.01122299861162901,
-0.039326246827840805,
-0.005635553505271673,
-0.007067153230309486,
0.04755091667175293,
-0.05198066309094429,
-0.015357873402535915,
0.0949687510728836,
0.0405634306371212,
-0.023429829627275467,
0.014919785782694817,
0.024512795731425285,
0.01063886471092701,
0.042229391634464264,
0.020263060927391052,
-0.046570777893066406,
-0.0011766841635107994,
0.016927480697631836,
0.025852268561720848,
0.006454924587160349,
0.03463832288980484,
-0.004514825996011496,
-0.016434529796242714,
0.03752556070685387,
-0.05608002096414566,
-0.05794505774974823,
0.02163221500813961,
0.030623288825154305,
-0.017240628600120544,
0.025648677721619606,
0.025465602055191994,
0.012506394647061825,
-0.007948740385472775,
0.05094942823052406,
-0.00704652164131403,
-0.0385134257376194,
0.00868793111294508,
-0.04986326023936272,
0.04457975551486015,
-0.09491952508687973,
0.03633364289999008,
0.027689436450600624,
-0.0358448401093483,
-0.0015087277861312032,
-0.01117554772645235,
0.034646909683942795,
0.010581937618553638,
-0.06270875036716461,
0.038809940218925476,
-0.02200271189212799,
0.012433835305273533,
-0.0010378211736679077,
0.018995044752955437,
0.024011261761188507,
0.02741924673318863,
0.011079208925366402,
0.009284375235438347,
0.02731618471443653,
0.03232661262154579,
0.025096897035837173,
0.006722157821059227,
-0.03719813749194145,
0.010853291489183903,
-0.02160334400832653,
-0.01154184527695179,
0.02982492186129093,
0.012694265693426132,
0.011242102831602097,
0.017123110592365265,
-0.008725582621991634,
0.01578429341316223,
0.013076511211693287,
0.012699054554104805,
-0.014260533265769482,
-0.04833226650953293,
-0.004090825095772743,
-0.023402437567710876,
0.025943269953131676,
0.05046379193663597,
-0.0019081427017226815,
-0.031715277582407,
-0.05551484599709511,
0.023126954212784767,
0.01818242482841015,
-0.03920391574501991,
-0.003935016691684723,
0.004222177900373936,
-0.0023832684382796288,
-0.012490672059357166,
-0.06524576991796494,
-0.014508008025586605,
-0.003934930544346571,
-0.0072800833731889725,
0.02562233805656433,
-0.031552504748106,
-0.03005414642393589,
0.02943599782884121,
0.00872971210628748,
0.0045439195819199085,
0.02046743780374527,
-0.034515101462602615,
-0.008742192760109901,
-0.016913561150431633,
-0.018391329795122147,
-0.008057826198637486,
0.04254767671227455,
0.00980007741600275,
-0.016530828550457954,
-0.022661494091153145,
-0.002872450975701213,
0.01848278008401394,
0.00873636081814766,
-0.017704786732792854,
0.03706555813550949,
0.011884303763508797,
0.0006253874744288623,
-0.026580365374684334,
-0.019975170493125916,
-0.025620488449931145,
-0.045229021459817886,
-0.013741716742515564,
0.009294979274272919,
0.01272730715572834,
-0.021288976073265076,
-0.05772511288523674,
0.016180796548724174,
0.005726877599954605,
-0.03491775691509247,
-0.018891792744398117,
-0.03863723203539848,
0.012733178213238716,
0.013512949459254742,
-0.009840901009738445,
-0.021656138822436333,
0.006701755803078413,
0.008136237971484661,
-0.009170656092464924,
0.003770584473386407,
-0.04067147523164749,
0.004168648272752762,
-0.07080955058336258,
0.021396728232502937,
-0.013027900829911232,
-0.0296584814786911,
-0.03179068863391876,
0.02771301381289959,
-0.06862468272447586,
-0.008164673112332821,
-0.00815412774682045,
-0.03141850605607033,
0.03365832194685936,
0.04753531143069267,
0.008752439171075821,
-0.01133051048964262,
0.0507003553211689,
-0.05397272855043411,
0.024246960878372192,
-0.08379916846752167,
0.06083670258522034,
-0.011568519286811352,
0.012257128953933716,
0.05995042622089386,
0.003992397803813219,
-0.04663557931780815,
0.022065050899982452,
0.007739904336631298,
0.018759500235319138,
-0.03300927206873894,
-0.00786281656473875,
-0.023157889023423195,
0.043961457908153534,
-0.019993474707007408,
0.0028686514124274254,
0.007760314270853996,
0.044607531279325485,
-0.019767815247178078,
-0.022061480209231377,
0.05130576714873314,
-0.028933964669704437,
0.0032233765814453363,
0.02973545715212822,
-0.0058893621899187565,
-0.0018128773663192987,
0.062191326171159744,
0.029318178072571754,
0.024864545091986656,
0.0036570229567587376,
-0.023477913811802864,
-0.036812517791986465,
0.014668330550193787,
-0.04741564393043518,
0.050351910293102264,
-0.0027005935553461313,
-0.0036637955345213413,
0.01771574839949608,
-0.034310370683670044,
0.004959347192198038,
-0.0323113277554512,
-0.04349497705698013,
-0.012747717089951038,
-0.002502514747902751,
0.03936408460140228,
-0.008135859854519367,
0.00843779742717743,
0.030466198921203613,
0.03154320642352104,
-0.010852654464542866,
0.028879443183541298,
-0.04422032833099365,
-0.03234289586544037,
-0.12009372562170029,
-0.0026298784650862217,
-0.02554372325539589,
-0.014835248701274395,
-0.004192017018795013,
0.014456924982368946,
0.0073824068531394005,
0.01712050475180149,
-0.017734922468662262,
0.0005229406524449587,
0.015872780233621597,
-0.02969973534345627,
-0.02221713587641716,
-0.01848921738564968,
-0.03209856525063515,
0.013412480242550373,
-0.012263276614248753,
-0.032588884234428406,
-0.04157053306698799,
0.01601431518793106,
0.0182491485029459,
0.004476101137697697,
-0.01620994508266449,
-0.032358359545469284,
-0.021534288302063942,
0.009119341149926186,
-0.030609069392085075,
-0.03618141636252403,
-0.02837839536368847,
-0.05038969963788986,
-0.01631244458258152,
-0.0025004115886986256,
0.0021056998521089554,
0.043685585260391235,
0.0074418289586901665,
0.030335282906889915,
-0.0035546193830668926,
0.017339132726192474,
-0.01149294525384903,
-0.0014227480860427022,
-0.002125599654391408,
0.0334712415933609,
-0.04764213785529137,
-0.024170195683836937,
-0.0002944490115623921,
0.028959495946764946,
-0.006401123479008675,
-0.00827853661030531,
-0.08187331259250641,
-0.026518331840634346,
-0.025018325075507164,
0.05320688709616661,
-0.00607320386916399,
0.035058412700891495,
0.028627505525946617,
-0.01167310681194067,
0.01084591168910265,
-0.00004653925134334713,
0.006185255944728851,
0.005231643561273813,
0.007698879111558199,
0.026648739352822304,
-0.03429247811436653,
0.006200522184371948,
-0.012778292410075665,
0.014072737656533718,
0.007328610401600599,
-0.02086641639471054,
-0.019690848886966705,
0.0205080546438694,
0.024274352937936783,
0.012537892907857895,
0.014355609193444252,
-0.03497770056128502,
0.016583630815148354,
-0.014048956334590912,
0.0006957687437534332,
-0.022507227957248688,
-0.042205531150102615,
-0.014628583565354347,
-0.01470921840518713,
0.011603438295423985,
-0.027408577501773834,
-0.02492835745215416,
0.08542591333389282,
0.04885145649313927,
-0.027211839333176613,
-0.022155044600367546,
0.027255386114120483,
-0.02090904861688614,
-0.053229764103889465,
-0.014975454658269882,
-0.028739655390381813,
0.0021474480163306,
-0.0112286526709795,
0.021004820242524147,
0.01102822832763195,
0.012866375967860222,
0.02246607095003128,
-0.009171310812234879,
-0.09010551869869232,
-0.002885966096073389,
0.04219769686460495,
-0.017760176211595535,
-0.027438296005129814,
0.05133048817515373,
-0.0004726327024400234,
-0.009407578967511654,
0.04588432237505913,
-0.0042273816652596,
-0.023093657568097115,
-0.02148677036166191,
-0.0399215929210186,
0.02519945241510868,
-0.03140639513731003,
0.0008190473890863359,
-0.024451781064271927,
-0.01703491061925888,
0.02040739171206951,
0.0021675489842891693,
0.007128714583814144,
0.002991678426042199,
0.005197300110012293,
-0.04106064513325691,
-0.03755544126033783,
0.009910311549901962,
0.09120142459869385,
0.0004119552031625062,
0.03231215104460716,
-0.006569117307662964,
0.039517346769571304,
0.02834980934858322,
0.007898572832345963,
0.023222023621201515,
0.025582769885659218,
0.01855587214231491,
-0.01588542014360428,
0.0253315269947052,
-0.0508158914744854,
-0.040474411100149155,
-0.026671098545193672,
-0.01799308881163597,
0.00011667748913168907,
-0.007598839234560728,
-0.0518932081758976,
0.018114417791366577,
0.037252798676490784,
0.002395985182374716,
0.01612212508916855,
-0.04271465539932251,
-0.04484744742512703,
0.013708459213376045,
-0.005893204361200333,
0.049999430775642395,
0.03038810007274151,
-0.03060953877866268,
0.027882056310772896,
-0.030927062034606934,
0.0336139015853405,
0.057202041149139404,
0.0025184310507029295,
-0.022048844024538994,
-0.0576249398291111,
0.02249489538371563,
-0.057217393070459366,
0.003514437470585108,
-0.020411599427461624,
-0.0030274917371571064,
-0.0159741397947073,
-0.016484806314110756,
-0.018308673053979874,
0.04633573070168495,
-0.029517117887735367,
0.0325210765004158,
0.03937291353940964,
-0.02708573266863823,
0.02613970637321472,
-0.011884348466992378,
0.024075770750641823,
-0.03982628509402275,
0.05227268487215042,
0.07602699846029282,
0.07398038357496262,
-0.015346909873187542,
0.02424817718565464,
0.03418627381324768,
0.025409068912267685,
0.0425385907292366,
-0.030045846477150917,
-0.053680628538131714,
-0.03629975765943527,
-0.032443657517433167,
0.037191953510046005,
-0.017126014456152916,
0.0029116987716406584,
0.01699129119515419,
0.004266220144927502,
0.012403788976371288,
-0.007830262184143066,
0.028431953862309456,
0.018839694559574127,
0.014436258934438229,
-0.04349808022379875,
-0.030612871050834656,
-0.00647907005622983,
0.023506447672843933,
-0.016731172800064087,
-0.03714580461382866,
-0.04542960226535797,
0.04250728711485863,
0.011606313288211823,
0.006455002818256617,
-0.0019366994965821505,
0.0177973210811615,
0.005139302462339401,
0.022751670330762863,
-0.014340510591864586,
0.01491509284824133,
0.035703450441360474,
-0.002182608237490058,
0.010165054351091385,
0.03689710050821304,
-0.010830799117684364,
-0.0023765075020492077,
0.002325075911357999,
0.021920157596468925,
-0.015420294366776943,
-0.0007552632596343756,
0.00942740123718977,
0.015389807522296906,
-0.024929799139499664,
-0.011394895613193512,
-0.017545687034726143,
0.013658075593411922,
-0.004082276485860348,
-0.05136948451399803,
-0.042860761284828186,
-0.04228135570883751,
0.00490316329523921,
0.012343401089310646,
0.014669835567474365,
0.004926248453557491,
-0.03487882763147354,
0.007243847008794546
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:30
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
that whatever Mr Renshall had thus far said to Mr Zdrilic (whether by reason of the alleged Second, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh or Eighth Representations), Mr Zdrilic was relying on Mr Hilliard to establish the final position on his behalf and on behalf of LEC.
29 March 2004 meeting
445This meeting was attended by Messrs Zdrilic, Hilliard, Renshall and Gillard.
446The meeting led to what Mr Hilliard described on 6 April 2004 as a "close to...final version" of the proposed Heads of Agreement between the parties.
447Clause 3.6 of that draft Heads of Agreement provided that:-
"HTT shall obtain sufficient finance from a new funder (estimated at but not limited to $12 million) to payout DTC No 1 Pty Limited and American Re (...)".
448It was also at this meeting of 29 March 2004 that Sentel was named as the proposed "New Co" (although, Sentel was not incorporated until 30 June 2004).
29 April 2004 - Ninth Representation
449This representation, again alleged to have been made orally in a conversation between Mr Renshall and Mr Zdrilic, was that an injection of funds by the new funder in the sum of $50 million to $70 million was available subject only to the new funder obtaining a banking licence to bring the funds into Australia.
450Mr Zdrilic claims Mr Renshall said:-
"The $577,000 borrowing (including interest) is to buy units of unit holders by HTT that was supposed to be paid by our Joint Venture Partner. The Joint Venture Partner did not yet get the banking licence to be able to bring into Australia $50m, $60m or $70m.
Units purchased will be held in escrow for the funder. The loan of $6.8m and $577,000 is guaranteed by the Joint Venture Partner. If the Joint Venture Partner does not pay all the money for the units purchase by HTT (which will be held in Escrow) the units will then be owned by HTT."
451The reference to a "$577,000 borrowing" was a reference to a proposed loan by Frenkail Pty Limited to HTT in that amount. This was the second of the "expensive loans". I shall refer to it further below.
452Mr Zdrilic made a note of the conversation. Critically it says:-
"Robert says joint venturer did not get Banking licence yet & that some things to be done with our reserve bank to be able to bring in $50m, $60m, $70m".
453In his affidavit evidence, Mr Renshall denied making the representation although he agreed he did say:-
"We are borrowing $577,000 to pay ten percent deposits to the small shareholders when they sign the agreements to transfer the units to the funder".
454However, in cross-examination Mr Renshall retreated from this denial and, ultimately, did not deny saying any of the words attributed to him by Mr Zdrilic.
455Assuming that Mr Zdrilic's note is a reliable guide as to what Mr Renshall said, the alleged representation appears to me to be no more than a statement by Mr Renshall of his understanding that the "Joint Venturer" had not yet got whatever "licence" was needed from the Reserve Bank to bring funds into Australia.
456It was not suggested to Mr Renshall that this was not his understanding.
457In my opinion, this falls short of a representation that any particular amount of money was available to be advanced, let alone would be advanced.
The second "expensive" loan - the Frenkail Pty Limited mortgage
458On 14 May 2004 HTT granted a mortgage to Frenkail Pty Limited ("Frenkail") over the Land to secure an advance of $577,000.
459The term of the advance was three months. It was thus repayable on 14 August 2004.
460Several weeks earlier, on 29 April 2004, Ms Penny Evans (a partner at TressCox), reviewed the draft loan agreement underlying the Frenkail mortgage and wrote to Mr Zdrilic:-
"The terms seem very harsh from the borrower's perspective.
The main purpose of the loan appears to be to enable HTT Huntley to pay 10% deposits to enable the purchase by HTT Huntley of units in the Huntley Trust...
|
[
-0.018053393810987473,
0.02265285886824131,
-0.0036567277275025845,
0.022185489535331726,
-0.009103509597480297,
-0.028328949585556984,
0.021934660151600838,
-0.013825824484229088,
-0.0014999568229541183,
0.013707754202187061,
0.008038789965212345,
0.039121080189943314,
-0.025957327336072922,
0.00827012024819851,
-0.038733914494514465,
-0.05284961685538292,
0.048434268683195114,
-0.023203128948807716,
0.010619080625474453,
-0.022049468010663986,
-0.002456304617226124,
-0.014212013222277164,
0.03440120071172714,
0.04995390400290489,
-0.0021980798337608576,
-0.0041701155714690685,
-0.0508146733045578,
0.030627697706222534,
0.05172887071967125,
0.022391270846128464,
0.024656707420945168,
0.025752155110239983,
0.05330685153603554,
-0.0037441030144691467,
-0.00017936791118700057,
-0.010545625351369381,
0.014808797277510166,
0.004997937940061092,
-0.04392698034644127,
0.031132537871599197,
-0.022637544199824333,
0.004657217767089605,
0.015519150532782078,
-0.006948966067284346,
0.06936225295066833,
-0.041692160069942474,
0.01691605895757675,
-0.02629435993731022,
0.012105247005820274,
0.021379299461841583,
-0.039247456938028336,
-0.02009686455130577,
0.04625929147005081,
-0.02449582703411579,
-0.008324668742716312,
0.008183040656149387,
-0.03868349269032478,
-0.0012187993852421641,
-0.06300020217895508,
0.0050826044753193855,
0.021962802857160568,
0.0012665208196267486,
-0.07321101427078247,
0.002843015594407916,
-0.012411525472998619,
0.09458255022764206,
0.018855318427085876,
0.0018950930098071694,
0.02398327738046646,
-0.03835401311516762,
-0.04485788941383362,
-0.0164825189858675,
-0.012911387719213963,
-0.009028887376189232,
-0.10063712298870087,
0.03827021270990372,
0.03919017314910889,
0.03437437489628792,
0.04894832894206047,
0.03696925565600395,
0.054859280586242676,
-0.01391119509935379,
-0.04171937331557274,
0.025292212143540382,
0.0010483639780431986,
0.035894203931093216,
-0.04541224613785744,
0.019239680841565132,
0.025519391521811485,
-0.028605151921510696,
-0.03537162393331528,
0.008781267330050468,
0.007957828231155872,
-0.06014107167720795,
0.005901468452066183,
0.0266500823199749,
-0.05793622136116028,
0.030529838055372238,
0.0022950731217861176,
0.02983655035495758,
-0.011745774187147617,
0.02562524937093258,
-0.01666403003036976,
-0.04304502159357071,
0.0002491168270353228,
0.01900886371731758,
0.03903347626328468,
0.03659665212035179,
-0.0015915455296635628,
0.00353867094963789,
3.6406248682396836e-7,
0.001958076376467943,
-0.005419777240604162,
0.01477714441716671,
-0.0023377372417598963,
-0.005961140617728233,
0.004005081951618195,
-0.0028118817135691643,
0.03737159073352814,
-0.001184553257189691,
0.015705112367868423,
0.023994963616132736,
0.04101842641830444,
-0.023819079622626305,
-0.05058436095714569,
-0.010453915223479271,
-0.028299307450652122,
0.016398411244153976,
0.006394364405423403,
0.01889442652463913,
0.007683095056563616,
0.010208938270807266,
-0.025571027770638466,
-0.04071044921875,
-0.007880399003624916,
0.017583753913640976,
-0.01619885116815567,
-0.034639425575733185,
0.01735709421336651,
-0.04583462327718735,
0.03386529162526131,
0.00728628458455205,
0.007327689323574305,
-0.03415556252002716,
0.028018586337566376,
-0.0263514406979084,
-0.01026272401213646,
-0.00182043865788728,
-0.002862098626792431,
0.06588879227638245,
0.013240310363471508,
0.0033757889177650213,
0.034867413341999054,
-0.004917273763567209,
-0.0044974954798817635,
-0.014978421851992607,
0.01829073205590248,
-0.04557635635137558,
0.029422668740153313,
0.08348850905895233,
-0.04233274236321449,
0.018301354721188545,
-0.008064577355980873,
-0.053061213344335556,
-0.030178165063261986,
0.006257379427552223,
-0.010841330513358116,
0.03731172904372215,
-0.029118873178958893,
0.004687359090894461,
0.035290446132421494,
-0.03978857398033142,
0.08000529557466507,
0.01384287141263485,
0.002343648811802268,
0.03182486444711685,
0.03776251897215843,
-0.0010122477542608976,
0.020044127479195595,
-0.01302207913249731,
-0.03257590904831886,
0.037222571671009064,
-0.0024834563955664635,
0.002718923147767782,
-0.025326550006866455,
0.008987256325781345,
-0.005154215730726719,
-0.039812225848436356,
-0.009178884327411652,
0.02749733254313469,
-0.013751279562711716,
0.002603813074529171,
0.036093469709157944,
0.007123387418687344,
0.02829992212355137,
-0.03208120912313461,
0.006372041534632444,
-0.04561004787683487,
-0.0018280891235917807,
0.0074378191493451595,
-0.02326694317162037,
0.038495633751153946,
0.052824247628450394,
-0.04671427235007286,
-0.019139928743243217,
0.023135287687182426,
-0.03666844591498375,
-0.018091684207320213,
-0.013697820715606213,
-0.060974299907684326,
-0.005839491728693247,
-0.005128052551299334,
-0.005980634596198797,
0.0036287265829741955,
0.03181234002113342,
-0.02397449128329754,
-0.0014298585010692477,
0.004762155935168266,
0.019016094505786896,
-0.04586079716682434,
-0.025051603093743324,
0.02310372330248356,
-0.01461018342524767,
0.037268124520778656,
0.029126858338713646,
0.04507286101579666,
-0.04261882230639458,
0.004061784129589796,
-0.042464837431907654,
-0.007425310090184212,
-0.028959425166249275,
-0.022579174488782883,
0.00967333372682333,
-0.027089977636933327,
0.016092203557491302,
0.06387482583522797,
0.019373303279280663,
0.0061099776066839695,
0.026395287364721298,
-0.023123065009713173,
-0.02183535322546959,
0.016284285113215446,
-0.01982244849205017,
-0.0024128714576363564,
-0.04529755935072899,
0.0012321863323450089,
-0.013993293978273869,
0.019981876015663147,
0.027060626074671745,
-0.014965810813009739,
-0.04407050833106041,
-0.016426119953393936,
-0.01397029310464859,
0.003254635026678443,
-0.019451521337032318,
0.023644637316465378,
0.0004739288124255836,
-0.010961565189063549,
0.03188985958695412,
0.02295728027820587,
0.02394796907901764,
0.027256052941083908,
0.03880259767174721,
0.010342994704842567,
-0.012033175677061081,
0.02254413068294525,
-0.06229482591152191,
-0.047996703535318375,
0.021440790966153145,
-0.004304760135710239,
0.003641074988991022,
0.035302549600601196,
0.03535282611846924,
0.011803515255451202,
0.015380382537841797,
0.04106392338871956,
0.006562136113643646,
0.0028730295598506927,
0.007073772605508566,
0.018509235233068466,
0.025222113355994225,
0.006905091926455498,
0.04207432642579079,
-0.051037587225437164,
0.03994402661919594,
0.06024307757616043,
-0.009291678667068481,
-0.022063393145799637,
0.016816692426800728,
-0.0500812791287899,
0.0012270653387531638,
0.01646018959581852,
0.06962298601865768,
-0.008028460666537285,
-0.07310735434293747,
-0.013652577996253967,
-0.03941335901618004,
-0.15594026446342468,
0.001174907316453755,
-0.012276413850486279,
0.012092746794223785,
-0.009183221496641636,
0.007622234523296356,
-0.03632637485861778,
0.010963252745568752,
-0.026624517515301704,
0.01171007938683033,
0.018632935360074043,
-0.05892569571733475,
-0.022904852405190468,
0.03298167139291763,
-0.001842712750658393,
-0.01463143341243267,
0.02195630595088005,
0.00205755652859807,
0.021356942132115364,
-0.01958123780786991,
0.027585141360759735,
-0.05823555961251259,
0.034295544028282166,
0.027786890044808388,
-0.021873699501156807,
0.0189481470733881,
0.01198648102581501,
0.03146965429186821,
-0.03575977683067322,
0.00006545129872392863,
0.012842300347983837,
0.028117792680859566,
-0.010594811290502548,
0.04139569774270058,
-0.01790991611778736,
0.04819473251700401,
0.059942763298749924,
-0.04526962712407112,
-0.023620765656232834,
-0.027475062757730484,
0.021593526005744934,
0.040471792221069336,
0.004616139456629753,
0.021498991176486015,
0.01632627844810486,
-0.07403959333896637,
-0.012780345045030117,
-0.008149808272719383,
0.0022440138272941113,
0.03780786320567131,
0.0038894047029316425,
0.014854658395051956,
-0.0656924620270729,
-0.037613991647958755,
-0.0003637880436144769,
-0.03127121552824974,
0.050453800708055496,
0.013209085911512375,
-0.011086438782513142,
-0.03475899621844292,
-0.011067231185734272,
-0.05653577670454979,
0.030530715361237526,
0.032739557325839996,
-0.024835962802171707,
0.029517941176891327,
0.001487652538344264,
-0.030500398948788643,
-0.0009623305522836745,
0.012856901623308659,
0.04599730297923088,
-0.016084816306829453,
-0.031478241086006165,
-0.017066381871700287,
0.038476746529340744,
0.016836317256093025,
-0.07318326830863953,
-0.01930626668035984,
0.000658612116239965,
-0.11040596663951874,
-0.0032099601812660694,
0.05109244957566261,
-0.016617316752672195,
0.03301643952727318,
0.0033357602078467607,
-0.002093507442623377,
0.007790972013026476,
0.03274323046207428,
0.0036955459509044886,
0.2600959539413452,
0.0025720957200974226,
0.016875389963388443,
0.022930141538381577,
0.0003698050568345934,
-0.0100965341553092,
-0.009841938503086567,
0.025261566042900085,
0.002327356953173876,
-0.03416784107685089,
-0.01823733188211918,
0.02282528020441532,
0.03244248777627945,
0.043803855776786804,
-0.05415821820497513,
0.021124351769685745,
-0.05633584037423134,
-0.016769910231232643,
0.04158349707722664,
-0.0045212083496153355,
0.03899300470948219,
0.02152116410434246,
0.0025964840315282345,
-0.016712384298443794,
-0.04904485493898392,
-0.034169506281614304,
0.019467949867248535,
0.022221526131033897,
-0.029772115871310234,
0.008080730214715004,
-0.026748398318886757,
-0.009679854847490788,
0.041463546454906464,
-0.003160425927489996,
0.03147813677787781,
0.006829515565186739,
-0.0163822453469038,
0.013625060208141804,
0.012942338362336159,
0.08678192645311356,
0.0016164804110303521,
-0.03199705481529236,
0.01077940221875906,
-0.033430565148591995,
-0.05610143020749092,
0.007268435787409544,
-0.003965984098613262,
0.02677997015416622,
-0.0002881089167203754,
0.027951808646321297,
-0.034819670021533966,
0.008840958587825298,
-0.030648961663246155,
-0.035025015473365784,
-0.014455767348408699,
0.048014771193265915,
-0.026807095855474472,
0.07061488181352615,
0.02417244203388691,
0.056389354169368744,
0.0036168061196804047,
0.023922037333250046,
-0.053846217691898346,
0.03448022902011871,
-0.029305798932909966,
-0.047417156398296356,
-0.04752683266997337,
-0.035615917295217514,
0.009744586423039436,
0.010268080979585648,
0.017867891117930412,
0.005678445566445589,
-0.0007745582261122763,
0.040062278509140015,
0.0460110604763031,
-0.031249413266777992,
-0.033098604530096054,
-0.0020626767072826624,
-0.030970437452197075,
-0.015942838042974472,
-0.02833746187388897,
-0.0418429933488369,
-0.0031350364442914724,
0.022995728999376297,
0.007986482232809067,
-0.015683995559811592,
-0.02593042142689228,
0.015783101320266724,
-0.011353932321071625,
-0.02187999337911606,
-0.04494428634643555,
0.0005368153215385973,
0.02574106864631176,
-0.007924367673695087,
-0.045236002653837204,
-0.020299099385738373,
-0.0005629102233797312,
-0.012428836897015572,
-0.04511520266532898,
-0.034289274364709854,
0.015008926391601562,
-0.008805660530924797,
-0.014910764992237091,
-0.02581196278333664,
0.023719187825918198,
-0.026546074077486992,
-0.021892640739679337,
0.021055247634649277,
-0.05560879036784172,
0.012661892920732498,
-0.0059218755923211575,
0.01960248500108719,
0.037166059017181396,
0.009378583170473576,
0.06735751032829285,
0.026670826599001884,
-0.019127078354358673,
0.06345737725496292,
0.027041485533118248,
0.018365930765867233,
0.03200161084532738,
-0.027400998398661613,
-0.061201680451631546,
-0.015165124088525772,
-0.008731217123568058,
0.025065390393137932,
-0.042028240859508514,
-0.0004422261263243854,
0.0009126539807766676,
-0.019035328179597855,
0.009208114817738533,
-0.03491165488958359,
-0.036226674914360046,
0.024472039192914963,
0.04484456405043602,
0.04131802171468735,
-0.01652451977133751,
-0.0011697605950757861,
-0.06114878132939339,
0.014908208511769772,
-0.06337149441242218,
-0.027299894019961357,
-0.028171658515930176,
-0.031633686274290085,
0.004531842656433582,
0.019167695194482803,
-0.03456779196858406,
0.03385435417294502,
-0.04154784977436066,
0.016258584335446358,
-0.012447946704924107,
0.027854131534695625,
-0.029729656875133514,
-0.03610297664999962,
0.008390387520194054,
0.0012181088095530868,
-0.011887673288583755,
-0.02052048221230507,
0.030178876593708992,
-0.024430889636278152,
0.004192996304482222,
-0.012976267375051975,
0.033463723957538605,
0.0101482467725873,
0.001913271495141089,
0.05284063518047333,
0.0016720035346224904,
0.011300225742161274,
0.029385702684521675,
-0.03628040850162506,
-0.023241478949785233,
-0.05347941443324089,
-0.005594227463006973,
0.05658849701285362,
0.04329521581530571,
0.01625927910208702,
0.02043883129954338,
0.01578335464000702,
-0.024767853319644928,
-0.03743785619735718,
0.02642185427248478,
0.01160621177405119,
-0.0384388230741024,
-0.0298647228628397,
-0.007508138194680214,
-0.015638228505849838,
0.0023104920983314514,
-0.014900187961757183,
0.04807427525520325,
-0.07282011210918427,
-0.01379372924566269,
0.06727319210767746,
0.00748959556221962,
-0.024336999282240868,
0.010637464001774788,
0.01050291582942009,
-0.006506820674985647,
0.025660306215286255,
-0.015194202773272991,
-0.007218976505100727,
-0.005015805829316378,
0.02109774388372898,
0.005065406672656536,
-0.022454600781202316,
0.04331061244010925,
-0.0046730791218578815,
0.015123276039958,
0.04241028428077698,
-0.05542359501123428,
-0.005846819840371609,
0.00974403228610754,
0.0015059998258948326,
-0.02268369309604168,
0.04400825500488281,
0.0008286014199256897,
-0.006743392441421747,
0.003057533409446478,
0.03649282082915306,
-0.009609266184270382,
-0.057644642889499664,
-0.0032606753520667553,
-0.04353189840912819,
0.024599846452474594,
-0.05873233079910278,
-0.005920018535107374,
0.0008370426949113607,
-0.055396631360054016,
-0.0295609962195158,
-0.03219356760382652,
0.03780389204621315,
-0.005259898956865072,
-0.07580029219388962,
0.05838353931903839,
-0.043945908546447754,
0.003984301351010799,
-0.0019009585957974195,
0.028778454288840294,
-0.004706161096692085,
0.01767766661942005,
-0.04346245154738426,
0.030312635004520416,
0.012241039425134659,
0.014017118141055107,
0.04250454157590866,
-0.01428807619959116,
-0.00039898446993902326,
-0.020366298034787178,
-0.019881365820765495,
0.006838384084403515,
0.05455717071890831,
0.013151437044143677,
0.012437735684216022,
0.013101570308208466,
-0.01654130592942238,
0.01169054489582777,
0.006131778471171856,
0.02567036636173725,
-0.045782726258039474,
-0.014299807138741016,
-0.036555271595716476,
-0.025320883840322495,
-0.015831323340535164,
0.00371567253023386,
-0.03675220534205437,
-0.06993260234594345,
-0.04252895340323448,
0.008994963020086288,
-0.031991127878427505,
-0.027811307460069656,
-0.024082167074084282,
-0.029659055173397064,
-0.023662347346544266,
0.004919921513646841,
-0.041498854756355286,
0.02943759597837925,
0.004363564308732748,
-0.0036130836233496666,
-0.028169576078653336,
-0.003434533253312111,
0.0028694006614387035,
-0.013471188955008984,
-0.018217556178569794,
0.05584815517067909,
0.03564334288239479,
-0.02325947768986225,
0.023988641798496246,
0.023737812414765358,
-0.012202740646898746,
0.01100645586848259,
0.004990711808204651,
-0.00027040240820497274,
0.006348717026412487,
-0.002209289465099573,
0.02242269739508629,
-0.010068271309137344,
-0.03616328164935112,
0.012234297581017017,
0.0031858820002526045,
-0.024708528071641922,
0.023359887301921844,
-0.01023029163479805,
-0.024139203131198883,
-0.03169433772563934,
-0.04918837919831276,
-0.0361635647714138,
0.00827134121209383,
-0.011191473342478275,
-0.0026443195529282093,
-0.02659437619149685,
0.021969705820083618,
0.049266714602708817,
-0.04418524354696274,
0.018903926014900208,
0.014911932870745659,
0.03402404859662056,
0.019134661182761192,
0.04414764419198036,
-0.007147305179387331,
-0.022139456123113632,
0.023989910259842873,
-0.011083432473242283,
-0.006350172217935324,
-0.046828970313072205,
0.008378741331398487,
-0.04302056506276131,
-0.006973211653530598,
0.019718460738658905,
-0.046317506581544876,
-0.03125711530447006,
0.015341107733547688,
-0.006729981396347284,
-0.02185184508562088,
0.005259926896542311,
-0.0012514879927039146,
0.051730960607528687,
0.01932501420378685,
0.005716199520975351,
0.004542529582977295,
0.019298605620861053,
-0.0477098785340786,
-0.007201951928436756,
-0.07811816036701202,
0.05765494331717491,
-0.019937003031373024,
0.017935611307621002,
0.005981240887194872,
-0.013262052088975906,
0.007655500900000334,
0.0255309846252203,
0.017928117886185646,
-0.012063142843544483,
0.0301034115254879,
-0.017007164657115936,
-0.046919796615839005,
-0.006847131997346878,
-0.0074929301626980305,
-0.026892201974987984,
0.006914560217410326,
0.018576880916953087,
-0.011402616277337074,
-0.009463702328503132,
0.044732715934515,
0.029117858037352562,
-0.021660199388861656,
-0.01778588257730007,
-0.017778698354959488,
0.006696654483675957,
0.0010272585786879063,
-0.0008606109186075628,
0.012058675289154053,
-0.0003767459711525589,
-0.037481945008039474,
-0.007211522664874792,
0.011411606334149837,
-0.05302566662430763,
0.03313583880662918,
0.039104800671339035,
0.0309758223593235,
-0.020287254825234413,
-0.06041984260082245,
0.02331024967133999,
-0.04794026538729668,
-0.013254575431346893,
-0.05583259463310242,
0.042580123990774155,
-0.013132801279425621,
-0.013155839405953884,
0.013416302390396595,
0.01908007450401783,
0.046664025634527206,
0.014437016099691391,
0.024780692532658577,
-0.014743419364094734,
-0.019779201596975327,
-0.14007055759429932,
-0.002843368100002408,
0.00278244586661458,
-0.03740003705024719,
-0.039073288440704346,
0.0017940237885341048,
-0.02248542383313179,
0.047853022813797,
-0.017408357933163643,
0.014439685270190239,
-0.001452127587981522,
-0.009439703077077866,
0.015915775671601295,
-0.020460139960050583,
-0.020502902567386627,
0.0336604081094265,
-0.04717007651925087,
0.0019473069114610553,
-0.08180112391710281,
-0.0054138884879648685,
0.02158384583890438,
0.0028795627877116203,
0.0188814178109169,
0.004799009300768375,
-0.0011276062577962875,
0.009851120412349701,
0.00853800494223833,
-0.04349201172590256,
-0.02090572565793991,
-0.004444193094968796,
-0.04413743317127228,
0.0044953967444598675,
-0.00020226191554684192,
0.06939006596803665,
-0.0357322171330452,
0.003015807829797268,
0.02204226888716221,
-0.032113607972860336,
-0.01845001056790352,
-0.009511773474514484,
-0.013671007938683033,
0.03688553348183632,
-0.033121950924396515,
-0.03426585718989372,
0.006656774319708347,
0.025757867842912674,
0.01864246465265751,
-0.017024362459778786,
-0.06866241246461868,
-0.030052414163947105,
-0.02722218818962574,
0.02530606836080551,
0.015481650829315186,
0.06325303018093109,
0.027335621416568756,
-0.029236536473035812,
0.036137305200099945,
-0.03262048214673996,
0.013327637687325478,
0.039295461028814316,
0.03275728598237038,
0.007066692225635052,
-0.030382785946130753,
0.010609613731503487,
-0.008760112337768078,
0.004877776373177767,
-0.031016577035188675,
-0.01617152988910675,
-0.003209932940080762,
0.02154501900076866,
-0.030243858695030212,
-0.04099229350686073,
-0.010362177155911922,
-0.0466127023100853,
0.01319894939661026,
-0.05749854817986488,
0.01656796596944332,
0.004970026668161154,
-0.03507392853498459,
-0.01963898353278637,
-0.031662825495004654,
0.011968988925218582,
-0.037412531673908234,
0.02520841360092163,
0.06374217569828033,
0.05799148604273796,
-0.019108405336737633,
-0.01597008667886257,
0.03074674680829048,
-0.024970194324851036,
-0.0617603063583374,
-0.01627388782799244,
0.0013496032916009426,
0.02796785905957222,
0.0016900948248803616,
0.04235762730240822,
0.0029534362256526947,
-0.006046278867870569,
-0.007206583861261606,
0.009696410968899727,
-0.05163312703371048,
0.0012867001350969076,
0.01659275032579899,
-0.015951037406921387,
-0.030569832772016525,
-0.017188452184200287,
0.00321371341124177,
0.010265457443892956,
0.021016031503677368,
-0.028388090431690216,
0.01607307232916355,
-0.018964504823088646,
-0.03179338574409485,
0.024216074496507645,
-0.035708747804164886,
-0.004288296215236187,
0.011685720644891262,
-0.012684755027294159,
-0.009592258371412754,
-0.0073341797105968,
0.03159438818693161,
0.02963576465845108,
-0.0015208028489723802,
-0.024156225845217705,
-0.005759524181485176,
-0.011254070326685905,
0.04393485188484192,
0.02623642049729824,
-0.0001846602390287444,
0.011806095950305462,
0.04251571372151375,
-0.0003896696725860238,
0.016162613406777382,
0.012965250760316849,
0.0035546154249459505,
0.02116227336227894,
-0.005271255970001221,
0.01835515908896923,
-0.03204145282506943,
-0.028062164783477783,
0.003773315344005823,
-0.011860225349664688,
-0.005695353262126446,
0.017987199127674103,
-0.06011402979493141,
0.01670243591070175,
0.0295815858989954,
-0.01006060466170311,
-0.026798201724886894,
-0.0011975988745689392,
-0.011643145233392715,
0.00740248104557395,
0.015481245703995228,
0.007919659838080406,
0.024538548663258553,
-0.014309168793261051,
0.04949377104640007,
-0.034425005316734314,
0.04523792117834091,
0.038209546357393265,
0.01736808940768242,
-0.03678446635603905,
-0.0444072000682354,
-0.059811580926179886,
-0.038480523973703384,
0.036914121359586716,
-0.010446428321301937,
-0.008033846504986286,
0.008090408518910408,
-0.030073007568717003,
-0.024971170350909233,
0.04081685096025467,
-0.02071433514356613,
0.014330368489027023,
0.03996646776795387,
-0.012182647362351418,
0.019730523228645325,
0.007919348776340485,
0.06426790356636047,
-0.005536953918635845,
0.04832807928323746,
0.05143953114748001,
0.04147101938724518,
-0.015576924197375774,
0.020862819626927376,
0.04041718691587448,
0.041713155806064606,
0.012710615061223507,
0.010984758846461773,
-0.03358703851699829,
-0.006241155788302422,
0.027834447100758553,
0.001929541933350265,
-0.015962019562721252,
0.01245895866304636,
0.028807202354073524,
0.0015949190128594637,
0.042769357562065125,
0.01649205945432186,
0.024609822779893875,
0.05036492273211479,
-0.018333403393626213,
-0.03042706660926342,
-0.019784314557909966,
-0.033493828028440475,
0.014093853533267975,
-0.024310093373060226,
-0.04536666348576546,
-0.0534752793610096,
0.05825166404247284,
-0.0007262463914230466,
-0.018385527655482292,
-0.012793305329978466,
0.03324751928448677,
0.0018526660278439522,
0.033433426171541214,
0.02577170729637146,
-0.013941637240350246,
0.05360247194766998,
-0.01508118025958538,
0.02580949291586876,
0.04308918118476868,
0.002089043613523245,
-0.03402247279882431,
-0.00942284520715475,
-0.005368896294385195,
-0.01883983425796032,
0.009164506569504738,
0.004185673780739307,
0.03431828320026398,
0.00832420401275158,
-0.008687090128660202,
0.0037978030741214752,
0.05370377004146576,
0.0026931348256766796,
-0.021099818870425224,
-0.007332219742238522,
-0.03234001249074936,
0.005208751652389765,
-0.02866186387836933,
0.024771729484200478,
-0.004736007656902075,
-0.016813641414046288,
0.013599655590951443
] | null |
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792:54
|
nsw_caselaw:54a636e83004de94513d9792
|
809Further, part of the arrangement was that Sentel would assume responsibility to pay to Mr Zdrilic an amount equivalent to the amount owed to them by LEC. LEC was in receivership and no ability itself to cause this money to be repaid.
810Further, on 26 August 2004, Mr Hilliard had written to the LEC receiver stating:-
"We confirm our previous advise that the settlement produces as good a result as could be obtained by being successful in the litigation and that is why we recommended such settlement."
811Faced with that advice, there was every reason for Mr Zdrilic to proceed with Stage 1 of the settlement, and thereby achieve an equal interest with the Renshall and Hickie interest in Sentel, and thereby a significant interest in the Land and the Project notwithstanding the fact that funding to HTT was not yet in place.
Subsequent dealings between HTT, Mr Renshall and IBIS/IPC
812On 4 September 2004, Mr Renshall wrote a further "proof of funds" letter to IPC, marked to the attention of Mr Hanna:-
"Please be advised that the heads of agreement between [IPC] and [HTT] expires on the 15/9/04 and no extensions will be granted. On numerous occasions during the past 4 months I have asked for a demonstration of funds and proof (please see 3.1-b of agreement) that you can complete this agreement.
This has not been forthcoming. Furthermore I have asked for the work done by the list of consultants at a cost of $160,000 to be forwarded to us and that has not been received. [HTT] will take action to recover those funds and damages should the agreement not been finalised."
813On 16 September 2004 Mr Renshall wrote to IPC terminating the 15 March 2004 Heads of Agreement. His letter read:-
"Further to our letter dated 10/07/04, I note that IPC has failed to complete on the due date and has not responded to the letter. IPC has offered Huntley no excuses for its failure to complete, has given Huntley no date when it may be able to complete and has still failed to show it has funds to complete.
In the circumstances, Huntley has little alternative but to terminate the agreement dated 15th March 04 and this letter constitutes formal notice of that termination.
Huntley reserves its right to take legal action for false and misleading conduct by you on a number of issues."
814Heated correspondence between Mr Renshall and IPC followed.
815On 22 September 2004 Mr Renshall wrote to Mr Hanna:-
"Please note any action taken by you in any way against the Huntley project will initiate criminal proceedings against you for fraud including the misappropriation of $160,000 which was to be paid to an agreed list of consultants but was in fact put into your bank account.
We will be using all of the people you have mentioned and 6 others who are on public record as describing you as a fraud as witnesses together with a raft of false and misleading documents not to mention your failure to disclose you are an undischarged bankrupt. As for putting funds into My Super, which does not even have a bank account and no assets I am sure that will make wonderful reading..."
816This correspondence reveals that, by 22 September 2004, Mr Renshall had become aware that Mr Hanna was an undischarged bankrupt. The evidence does not reveal precisely when Mr Renshall learned this. It was not suggested to him that it was any time before 6 September 2004, the date on which the 2001 Proceedings were dismissed.
817The tone of Mr Renshall's letter suggests the information was just to hand, as was whatever prompted Mr Renshall to refer to "others" on the record as describing Mr Hanna as a "fraud" and to a "raft of misleading documents".
Mr Renshall said he could not remember when, or from whom he obtained this information but said his misgivings about Mr Hanna arose around mid September. I am satisfied Mr Renshall had no such misgivings before then.
818On 1 October 2004, in the email to Mr Rutherford, referred to earlier in these reasons, Mr Renshall said:-
|
[
-0.06733998656272888,
0.062351126223802567,
-0.00544594693928957,
-0.0034553403966128826,
-0.012986221350729465,
-0.0363336056470871,
0.02043995074927807,
-0.023442070931196213,
-0.0011924756690859795,
-0.009310432709753513,
-0.02707415074110031,
0.058876968920230865,
-0.043700721114873886,
0.019598044455051422,
-0.023176735267043114,
-0.013075382448732853,
0.04844455420970917,
-0.022642025724053383,
0.004324458539485931,
-0.019114777445793152,
0.001590730040334165,
-0.02635067328810692,
0.013333894312381744,
0.031192658469080925,
-0.016346344724297523,
-0.0033357241190969944,
-0.021265385672450066,
0.030453572049736977,
-0.006762295961380005,
0.03535992279648781,
0.0050258575938642025,
-0.014349020086228848,
0.055717792361974716,
0.002602623775601387,
-0.010899193584918976,
-0.01670411415398121,
0.021596601232886314,
0.009570174850523472,
-0.03477774187922478,
0.00906088761985302,
0.013680845499038696,
0.008912266232073307,
0.022245002910494804,
-0.0014783008955419064,
0.04505269229412079,
-0.03997160494327545,
0.01226624846458435,
-0.029961498454213142,
-0.0007061116630211473,
0.026331407949328423,
-0.02998224087059498,
-0.009679647162556648,
0.06921909004449844,
-0.011251932941377163,
-0.019830038771033287,
-0.00905035249888897,
-0.024829300120472908,
0.018210800364613533,
-0.04909631982445717,
0.013494406826794147,
0.03312969580292702,
-0.01290214154869318,
-0.0637214407324791,
0.007125446107238531,
0.014073766767978668,
0.11049942672252655,
0.012014422565698624,
-0.001407128176651895,
-0.006433460395783186,
-0.023484788835048676,
-0.06548689305782318,
-0.02028021402657032,
-0.04044128954410553,
-0.003861531149595976,
-0.08770295977592468,
0.026185475289821625,
0.05016070604324341,
0.018913408741354942,
0.03607035428285599,
0.037704624235630035,
0.03437061235308647,
-0.03929826617240906,
-0.020659221336245537,
0.037034910172224045,
-0.006819421891123056,
0.021931972354650497,
-0.019878678023815155,
0.036056969314813614,
0.009571238420903683,
-0.02830585651099682,
0.008251550607383251,
0.027706308290362358,
0.005967973731458187,
-0.03440812602639198,
0.014039483852684498,
-0.004569861106574535,
-0.0591721385717392,
0.033146679401397705,
-0.01160596776753664,
0.021149195730686188,
0.021213024854660034,
0.0037602176889777184,
0.005089277867227793,
-0.0233900249004364,
-0.007392693776637316,
0.03233307600021362,
0.03013773262500763,
0.015135474503040314,
0.022272076457738876,
-0.007939092814922333,
-0.00755332363769412,
-0.018703589215874672,
0.012249387800693512,
0.014220474287867546,
0.007340264040976763,
0.005315440706908703,
0.008088306523859501,
-0.007921991869807243,
0.0655035525560379,
-0.010928347706794739,
0.04258476197719574,
0.006749918218702078,
0.02752160280942917,
0.015000132843852043,
-0.05820091813802719,
-0.009559438563883305,
-0.030313506722450256,
-0.0031060106121003628,
0.02379872277379036,
0.04204058274626732,
-0.025374360382556915,
0.0381612703204155,
-0.028511369600892067,
0.0012426762841641903,
-0.005882204510271549,
0.017673427239060402,
-0.015264800749719143,
-0.020737620070576668,
0.025204062461853027,
-0.06050755828619003,
0.06509241461753845,
0.025508252903819084,
0.000007397482931992272,
-0.0625540092587471,
-0.0036965087056159973,
-0.039812780916690826,
0.01275548618286848,
0.007233306299895048,
0.011178403161466122,
0.03989310562610626,
-0.006507233716547489,
0.012830284424126148,
0.04848860949277878,
0.019758418202400208,
0.015271017327904701,
-0.007996117696166039,
0.0015792151680216193,
-0.050783026963472366,
0.05398355796933174,
0.0717099979519844,
-0.03972172364592552,
0.019644850865006447,
-0.03872636333107948,
-0.028325149789452553,
-0.015585432760417461,
-0.008231482468545437,
-0.009113586507737637,
0.045545876026153564,
-0.008463256992399693,
-0.0005129172932356596,
0.03751756250858307,
-0.02861114963889122,
0.07472499459981918,
-0.0028218876104801893,
-0.00127562100533396,
0.03289475664496422,
0.027784055098891258,
0.02931240387260914,
0.007763061206787825,
-0.007429576013237238,
-0.05502858757972717,
0.03340744972229004,
-0.005184196401387453,
-0.008644242770969868,
-0.04741398245096207,
0.032134804874658585,
-0.025905726477503777,
-0.018255840986967087,
-0.005126418080180883,
0.05106557160615921,
0.003618149319663644,
-0.01724683679640293,
0.05062580481171608,
0.02694067358970642,
0.018077010288834572,
-0.02938241884112358,
0.0065917279571294785,
-0.03687667101621628,
0.009994247928261757,
-0.026156248524785042,
-0.04561324045062065,
0.040728867053985596,
0.039154548197984695,
-0.016745103523135185,
-0.018573850393295288,
0.0254648607224226,
-0.02638317458331585,
-0.013600070960819721,
0.0024904224555939436,
-0.05488331988453865,
0.020790884271264076,
-0.01574094593524933,
-0.006557872518897057,
-0.0036183237098157406,
0.025312265381217003,
-0.009846147149801254,
-0.0050823874771595,
0.0005728263058699667,
0.032998789101839066,
-0.04534521698951721,
-0.027224604040384293,
0.01188766397535801,
-0.014008641242980957,
0.023185279220342636,
0.0120205944404006,
0.06703244894742966,
-0.07067307829856873,
0.04171200469136238,
-0.021013446152210236,
-0.03852788731455803,
-0.00854779314249754,
-0.03866642713546753,
0.030485333874821663,
-0.032440803945064545,
0.024545809254050255,
0.034830618649721146,
0.005142198409885168,
0.01075283344835043,
0.025787649676203728,
0.0017549175536260009,
-0.00908041000366211,
-0.011708248406648636,
0.003470038529485464,
-0.004457165487110615,
-0.06190834939479828,
-0.00897955521941185,
0.011521304957568645,
0.04393211379647255,
0.015222660265862942,
-0.006827095989137888,
-0.0073654018342494965,
-0.006290679331868887,
-0.0002963129081763327,
-0.012980502098798752,
-0.0035894718021154404,
0.02352810464799404,
0.0025311436038464308,
0.013612227514386177,
0.036707554012537,
0.05351979285478592,
0.03405388444662094,
0.009518897160887718,
0.04660468548536301,
0.019173651933670044,
-0.024408474564552307,
0.032972678542137146,
-0.022157886996865273,
-0.056040022522211075,
0.03601241111755371,
-0.023485342040657997,
0.003117053071036935,
0.014829462394118309,
0.041831955313682556,
0.01934860832989216,
0.024438785389065742,
0.0006971166585572064,
0.029456907883286476,
0.040515050292015076,
0.015268419869244099,
0.015434429049491882,
0.02244648151099682,
0.022855812683701515,
0.03415704891085625,
-0.06395275145769119,
0.06303691118955612,
0.04014589264988899,
-0.012928299605846405,
-0.040145836770534515,
0.031809251755476,
-0.038768112659454346,
-0.04370903596282005,
-0.01564509980380535,
0.0746772289276123,
-0.008110212162137032,
-0.06549884378910065,
-0.027366090565919876,
-0.016117718070745468,
-0.16130007803440094,
-0.03183175250887871,
-0.01672409288585186,
0.007680188398808241,
-0.004464109893888235,
0.009880976751446724,
-0.045335616916418076,
0.01920023001730442,
-0.02239200659096241,
0.04787672311067581,
0.015672560781240463,
-0.051889874041080475,
-0.011134317144751549,
0.017528019845485687,
0.025773929432034492,
-0.010541439056396484,
-0.001380617031827569,
0.02294362522661686,
0.02728797309100628,
-0.019910452887415886,
0.01734105497598648,
-0.046265143901109695,
0.02479644864797592,
-0.01626460812985897,
-0.0104279899969697,
-0.022607365623116493,
-0.00036603689659386873,
0.010162293910980225,
-0.044726599007844925,
0.019863935187458992,
-0.018597381189465523,
0.0024751732125878334,
-0.020952995866537094,
0.04859240725636482,
-0.03208886459469795,
0.02285606972873211,
0.07543483376502991,
-0.0815180242061615,
-0.02220221608877182,
-0.0321628637611866,
0.024537621065974236,
0.04207158833742142,
-0.0022174392361193895,
0.007173274643719196,
0.0018152063712477684,
-0.037259750068187714,
-0.012628507800400257,
-0.005955202970653772,
0.005168721545487642,
0.04074491932988167,
-0.010725128464400768,
0.006765320431441069,
-0.016779033467173576,
-0.05771142244338989,
0.005509188398718834,
-0.03425716608762741,
0.05658012256026268,
-0.017032049596309662,
-0.03324500471353531,
-0.027434634044766426,
-0.031081825494766235,
-0.0669793039560318,
-0.012218523770570755,
0.0066382973454892635,
-0.024420011788606644,
-0.012388229370117188,
-0.02750924974679947,
0.0064142984338104725,
0.005280639976263046,
0.002765962155535817,
0.00727984681725502,
0.00490322383120656,
-0.00019229466852266341,
-0.03827342391014099,
0.027065349742770195,
0.023918772116303444,
-0.04786281660199165,
-0.015949612483382225,
-0.01926891691982746,
-0.08587519824504852,
-0.00831417553126812,
0.04178494215011597,
-0.03132281079888344,
-0.004168273415416479,
-0.025649946182966232,
0.03449123725295067,
0.0232612956315279,
0.04031576216220856,
0.015033765695989132,
0.25567105412483215,
-0.009841641411185265,
-0.018324166536331177,
0.021233554929494858,
-0.00847912859171629,
-0.043417271226644516,
0.007041105534881353,
0.05990519002079964,
0.008280683308839798,
-0.03450080752372742,
-0.023603254929184914,
-0.018401023000478745,
0.0014409691793844104,
0.051344774663448334,
-0.032241836190223694,
0.00022777164122089744,
-0.04757946357131004,
-0.004959332291036844,
0.06718384474515915,
-0.007923060096800327,
0.03994348645210266,
-0.007678778376430273,
0.0055738757364451885,
-0.020479360595345497,
-0.053287263959646225,
-0.032989826053380966,
0.03650464117527008,
0.0729425698518753,
-0.044194020330905914,
-0.0034358142875134945,
0.009388112463057041,
-0.021824827417731285,
0.029786881059408188,
0.003609386272728443,
0.021553289145231247,
0.007548783905804157,
-0.026126259937882423,
0.003037199145182967,
0.04044552892446518,
0.03189116716384888,
0.004111297894269228,
-0.03556199371814728,
-0.02430465631186962,
-0.014782203361392021,
-0.029786264523863792,
0.0015101900789886713,
-0.015420123934745789,
0.04164054989814758,
0.014351052232086658,
0.00983337126672268,
-0.03645371273159981,
0.02903088927268982,
-0.01998061127960682,
-0.006057548336684704,
-0.007158927619457245,
0.03216634690761566,
-0.01813727244734764,
0.0502571165561676,
-0.007794322445988655,
0.06822530925273895,
0.046611860394477844,
0.02666747197508812,
-0.027640685439109802,
0.030825406312942505,
-0.01821836642920971,
-0.017553560435771942,
-0.0696963518857956,
-0.01967543177306652,
0.05422062799334526,
0.01558731123805046,
0.03288231045007706,
0.032907884567976,
-0.004649342969059944,
0.0017023766413331032,
0.025218693539500237,
-0.010777628049254417,
0.0002453134802635759,
0.020682068541646004,
-0.021916190162301064,
0.031203391030430794,
-0.050582416355609894,
-0.023417891934514046,
-0.029124870896339417,
0.028685010969638824,
0.0025843887124210596,
-0.01091087982058525,
0.0018509814981371164,
0.02402607537806034,
-0.05051727220416069,
-0.007641648408025503,
-0.010401275008916855,
-0.011921779252588749,
-0.007077510934323072,
0.019791992381215096,
-0.04777082800865173,
0.001194072188809514,
-0.014623570255935192,
-0.008537333458662033,
-0.0436721108853817,
-0.05797256901860237,
0.00609478959813714,
-0.0060910629108548164,
0.024650130420923233,
-0.057382892817258835,
0.023000966757535934,
0.0010881227208301425,
-0.005258702207356691,
0.038926053792238235,
-0.044142235070466995,
-0.0019417799776419997,
0.005928647238761187,
0.01293550431728363,
0.03869113326072693,
-0.024127915501594543,
0.027474526315927505,
0.045127637684345245,
-0.004855358973145485,
0.05095857009291649,
0.03147164359688759,
0.04602133855223656,
0.022049644961953163,
-0.006986486725509167,
-0.044913940131664276,
-0.009955151006579399,
0.0001999611995415762,
0.023969022557139397,
-0.017407046630978584,
-0.021391401067376137,
0.02558787912130356,
0.021648800000548363,
0.0007313679088838398,
-0.004709332715719938,
0.009661124087870121,
0.005747456103563309,
0.06311189383268356,
0.030028000473976135,
0.006630711257457733,
-0.030013512820005417,
-0.029782898724079132,
-0.005147416610270739,
-0.03353755921125412,
0.0013677541865035892,
-0.022028593346476555,
-0.03212406486272812,
0.0032408987171947956,
0.01483698096126318,
-0.07384510338306427,
0.0015124004567041993,
-0.029941266402602196,
0.03691478446125984,
-0.015733320266008377,
0.003632250474765897,
-0.05198853090405464,
-0.03232554346323013,
-0.000030776132916798815,
-0.0040634749457240105,
-0.03262203559279442,
-0.034317538142204285,
0.019350562244653702,
-0.03359231352806091,
0.018192745745182037,
0.03692321479320526,
-0.008289700374007225,
0.02147851325571537,
-0.0019818588625639677,
0.05478525534272194,
-0.012980183586478233,
0.009262447245419025,
0.05373280122876167,
-0.0110553540289402,
-0.0039593372493982315,
-0.028093842789530754,
-0.04332960397005081,
0.04104582220315933,
0.023750197142362595,
0.03174850344657898,
-0.011336877010762691,
0.04007744416594505,
0.02335042878985405,
-0.04742676392197609,
0.021646909415721893,
0.017059162259101868,
-0.050720229744911194,
-0.01499627809971571,
-0.0044876267202198505,
-0.027813956141471863,
-0.027739692479372025,
-0.028116026893258095,
0.0389062762260437,
-0.06155354157090187,
-0.0332057848572731,
0.09012297540903091,
0.026714937761425972,
-0.014210077002644539,
0.004919764585793018,
0.0005414895713329315,
-0.00022827801876701415,
0.04764268174767494,
-0.003926123026758432,
-0.05371281877160072,
-0.0055658710189163685,
-0.010382852517068386,
0.024432340636849403,
0.02017836831510067,
0.01239730603992939,
-0.014323492534458637,
0.009129242040216923,
0.02904723398387432,
-0.058046016842126846,
-0.01731955073773861,
0.0055670239962637424,
0.03764589875936508,
-0.046961430460214615,
0.012466948479413986,
-0.0010938640916720033,
-0.016560062766075134,
0.03634301573038101,
0.03853412717580795,
0.016475891694426537,
-0.034890394657850266,
-0.024640334770083427,
-0.0368226021528244,
0.04743749648332596,
-0.044807951897382736,
-0.01571587845683098,
-0.011701192706823349,
-0.01463847141712904,
-0.016235321760177612,
-0.0443449504673481,
0.002733488567173481,
-0.004348256159573793,
-0.07745586335659027,
0.05072692781686783,
-0.037889398634433746,
0.006827601231634617,
-0.00942139234393835,
0.020655954256653786,
0.002387842396274209,
0.03254466503858566,
0.004613928496837616,
0.034598853439092636,
-0.02577955834567547,
0.03363160416483879,
0.042599815875291824,
0.01848054677248001,
-0.004607429727911949,
0.0014408217975869775,
-0.01697779819369316,
0.010353445075452328,
0.03504041209816933,
0.019230561330914497,
0.04954150691628456,
0.02372540347278118,
-0.012040460482239723,
0.04539373517036438,
0.00013807449431624264,
0.00934572797268629,
-0.03619936481118202,
-0.037007786333560944,
0.006296008359640837,
0.013123299926519394,
0.002396609401330352,
0.019875898957252502,
-0.022036341950297356,
-0.033422742038965225,
-0.05851452425122261,
0.027462810277938843,
-0.03716082498431206,
-0.0350344181060791,
0.0020055314525961876,
-0.003704614005982876,
-0.02009390853345394,
-0.008585135452449322,
-0.025908391922712326,
0.018326645717024803,
-0.004484072793275118,
-0.0047976355999708176,
0.006796094123274088,
0.00931983906775713,
-0.007099368143826723,
0.010351470671594143,
-0.011508136056363583,
0.034192927181720734,
0.015088528394699097,
-0.0069746472872793674,
0.023394253104925156,
0.009559319354593754,
0.006108924280852079,
-0.004227473866194487,
0.03733441233634949,
-0.0003849684144370258,
0.00779004069045186,
-0.025363242253661156,
0.04944968596100807,
-0.00731188477948308,
0.0005668444791808724,
-0.011937743984162807,
0.04591238126158714,
-0.002156040631234646,
-0.0037557892501354218,
-0.022815117612481117,
-0.02084195613861084,
-0.038217075169086456,
-0.05603758245706558,
-0.04649459570646286,
0.008601842448115349,
0.007007896434515715,
0.02055402286350727,
-0.014876564964652061,
0.0016755369724705815,
0.011359118856489658,
-0.0979367345571518,
0.020569711923599243,
-0.002008513081818819,
0.01579388976097107,
-0.005390823818743229,
0.02061857469379902,
-0.005372015293687582,
-0.022682687267661095,
-0.010787205770611763,
-0.024471905082464218,
0.0119011290371418,
-0.0357307530939579,
0.005553115624934435,
-0.06336051225662231,
0.00751457316800952,
0.023706145584583282,
-0.0503363274037838,
-0.04977589100599289,
0.022591905668377876,
-0.015519578009843826,
0.016400178894400597,
-0.0049459971487522125,
0.009196177124977112,
0.039018578827381134,
0.017582111060619354,
0.0011438773944973946,
-0.036469269543886185,
0.01386677660048008,
-0.06293486803770065,
-0.006385819986462593,
-0.04461706057190895,
0.04569312557578087,
-0.007764318026602268,
0.009772692807018757,
-0.00750758359208703,
0.031152257695794106,
0.00430831266567111,
0.012953322380781174,
0.01799788698554039,
-0.0016791140660643578,
0.0003661233640741557,
-0.003043864853680134,
-0.06827763468027115,
0.010022168047726154,
-0.035545770078897476,
0.0015521891182288527,
0.042058005928993225,
0.028375782072544098,
-0.015268905088305473,
-0.00798248965293169,
0.051212068647146225,
0.01669950596988201,
-0.01051869336515665,
-0.0023475103080272675,
-0.004541036672890186,
-0.008441991172730923,
0.01813983917236328,
-0.00903662946075201,
0.017723487690091133,
0.0024937218986451626,
-0.01869138889014721,
-0.03588884696364403,
0.003237000899389386,
-0.02780718170106411,
0.04996900632977486,
0.010970203205943108,
0.009052271023392677,
-0.02872052602469921,
-0.01793508045375347,
0.002750084735453129,
-0.011039656586945057,
-0.00226997141726315,
-0.022325215861201286,
0.015901541337370872,
0.019374467432498932,
-0.02092152088880539,
0.026987344026565552,
0.013181827031075954,
0.025870710611343384,
-0.038496024906635284,
0.003777167061343789,
-0.02167256735265255,
-0.02886842004954815,
-0.13857001066207886,
-0.02254447713494301,
-0.006763004232198,
-0.021896762773394585,
-0.007262527942657471,
0.0012825694866478443,
-0.014459461905062199,
0.02469373308122158,
-0.030865050852298737,
0.007569963578134775,
-0.009684553369879723,
-0.03202298283576965,
-0.015669086948037148,
-0.024563200771808624,
-0.06618178635835648,
0.02645435556769371,
-0.013933771289885044,
0.013666637241840363,
-0.06445419043302536,
-0.012317475862801075,
0.03230582922697067,
0.031931862235069275,
-0.02811732515692711,
-0.00013371203385759145,
0.012629593722522259,
-0.007620949298143387,
-0.003932163584977388,
-0.05982353165745735,
-0.03972141072154045,
-0.016494199633598328,
-0.048579346388578415,
-0.023884054273366928,
0.011031038127839565,
0.036322370171546936,
0.007627006620168686,
0.024625878781080246,
0.02031344547867775,
-0.012339693494141102,
-0.036187317222356796,
0.009409400634467602,
-0.022620465606451035,
0.039443906396627426,
-0.018550803884863853,
-0.054201170802116394,
0.009891237132251263,
0.03239067271351814,
-0.018432730808854103,
-0.021801969036459923,
-0.06949744373559952,
-0.06027599051594734,
-0.0383419431746006,
-0.00712776742875576,
0.006926366128027439,
0.055432699620723724,
0.0117135439068079,
0.011719690635800362,
-0.0004443733487278223,
-0.03021085262298584,
0.03556337580084801,
0.046415891498327255,
-0.006338290870189667,
0.014142856933176517,
-0.03360208496451378,
0.0042485687881708145,
-0.0030896118842065334,
0.0005779449711553752,
-0.014575373381376266,
-0.018669072538614273,
-0.029298491775989532,
0.019754426553845406,
-0.004907114896923304,
-0.04105640947818756,
0.009666232392191887,
-0.07054834812879562,
0.03744157776236534,
-0.0027751363813877106,
0.01780197024345398,
-0.003148777410387993,
-0.036695562303066254,
-0.025666996836662292,
-0.05429815128445625,
0.00838534813374281,
-0.05240293964743614,
-0.026590492576360703,
0.06338284909725189,
0.0043591889552772045,
-0.007357248105108738,
-0.027661800384521484,
0.027966395020484924,
-0.037898022681474686,
-0.05014463886618614,
-0.014412308111786842,
0.0025339657440781593,
0.009331535547971725,
-0.014680419117212296,
0.00202002446167171,
-0.005919652990996838,
0.03238581493496895,
0.006551747675985098,
-0.00009052996756508946,
-0.08189672976732254,
-0.01816939190030098,
0.04636311158537865,
0.004350495524704456,
-0.01902179792523384,
0.005549014545977116,
0.02901627868413925,
0.004176606424152851,
0.056621164083480835,
-0.03192239627242088,
-0.028643421828746796,
0.008446956053376198,
-0.018647626042366028,
0.059543874114751816,
-0.025381457060575485,
-0.0007176996441558003,
-0.01786378026008606,
0.021992288529872894,
0.011213778518140316,
-0.012510597705841064,
0.03392393887042999,
0.038838859647512436,
0.0008421954116784036,
-0.02259087935090065,
-0.010312995873391628,
-0.009676717221736908,
0.07437090575695038,
0.032754309475421906,
0.024193311110138893,
0.03791835904121399,
0.0561765618622303,
-0.009293311275541782,
0.018874196335673332,
0.007960236631333828,
0.020060209557414055,
0.015650665387511253,
-0.02868209034204483,
0.006971036083996296,
-0.01781575195491314,
-0.031211156398057938,
-0.024111974984407425,
-0.01629563979804516,
-0.01255849003791809,
-0.008877573534846306,
-0.033986449241638184,
-0.007805857807397842,
0.025993093848228455,
-0.01632455736398697,
-0.014131521806120872,
-0.018035629764199257,
-0.026474446058273315,
0.00035828043473884463,
0.004895309917628765,
0.02606070414185524,
-0.00914005283266306,
0.005867820233106613,
0.04239821806550026,
-0.03949669003486633,
0.011058766394853592,
0.0166923925280571,
0.008933530189096928,
-0.04750886559486389,
-0.03784707188606262,
-0.02581438422203064,
-0.019740024581551552,
0.0346127450466156,
-0.013127717189490795,
0.012750796042382717,
-0.03980926796793938,
-0.013051431626081467,
-0.03203841298818588,
0.015375219285488129,
-0.029713593423366547,
0.02706814743578434,
0.034688375890254974,
-0.013227112591266632,
-0.012487474828958511,
-0.014797805808484554,
0.07358027249574661,
-0.014108270406723022,
0.03652426227927208,
0.03504764661192894,
0.02109067514538765,
0.009548086673021317,
0.007915154099464417,
0.03422829881310463,
0.02005469985306263,
0.03580966964364052,
-0.02523268386721611,
-0.03063241019845009,
-0.029198316857218742,
0.011304983869194984,
-0.006414848379790783,
0.0007573163020424545,
0.020747877657413483,
0.007778220344334841,
0.016664404422044754,
0.03234773874282837,
0.017641594633460045,
0.013484806753695011,
0.038260333240032196,
-0.04704480245709419,
-0.05839920416474342,
-0.04236124828457832,
-0.027402350679039955,
0.038052111864089966,
-0.0027990746311843395,
-0.036302365362644196,
-0.022913858294487,
0.023023953661322594,
-0.012322061695158482,
-0.0021387413144111633,
-0.022440966218709946,
0.02808745764195919,
-0.010020630434155464,
0.0025790808722376823,
0.035672374069690704,
0.00884879007935524,
0.02696191519498825,
-0.014845207333564758,
-0.003915598150342703,
0.01742580533027649,
-0.00711608724668622,
-0.03197099268436432,
-0.012879841029644012,
0.006649577058851719,
-0.010322479531168938,
0.025950510054826736,
0.013817371800541878,
0.013384584337472916,
-0.014187988825142384,
0.004483512602746487,
0.017008770257234573,
0.04126899689435959,
-0.02631537616252899,
-0.03800889104604721,
-0.042472515255212784,
-0.004425977822393179,
0.003575187874957919,
-0.008287783712148666,
0.07643838971853256,
-0.002692835172638297,
-0.0006414102972485125,
0.009322051890194416
] | null |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.