id
stringlengths
9
16
vector
listlengths
1.02k
1.02k
title
stringlengths
2
382
abstract
stringlengths
16
3.07k
authors
stringlengths
3
128
categories
stringlengths
5
125
month
stringclasses
12 values
year
int64
1.99k
2.01k
url
stringlengths
31
38
astro-ph/9208006
[ -0.052282895892858505, 0.4718737006187439, 0.7567493319511414, 0.12467625737190247, -0.10746690630912781, -0.33413684368133545, -0.830717146396637, 0.14505892992019653, -0.2368323653936386, 0.9158909320831299, 0.026439068838953972, -0.35118889808654785, -0.16090746223926544, -0.6600843071937561, -0.3643943667411804, 0.08372798562049866, 0.22971394658088684, -0.8109723925590515, -1.4666458368301392, 0.21786747872829437, 0.02279486134648323, -0.10253367573022842, -1.2395477294921875, 0.07506663352251053, -0.5811594128608704, 0.7595798969268799, 0.46733617782592773, 0.48135948181152344, 1.4950292110443115, 1.0425571203231812, -0.21926818788051605, -0.5668975114822388, 0.16638515889644623, -0.4246247410774231, 0.13119137287139893, 0.25613394379615784, 0.47079530358314514, -0.23184044659137726, 0.9743745923042297, -0.4046405553817749, 0.9899554252624512, 0.17198161780834198, 0.6552982926368713, -0.4562068581581116, -0.5986199975013733, 0.2516002953052521, 0.35910600423812866, 0.05856200307607651, 0.14151418209075928, -0.895932137966156, 0.17620103061199188, -0.2642085552215576, 0.0014447809662669897, -1.125910997390747, -0.303116112947464, 0.1914687603712082, 0.2871960997581482, 0.240179181098938, 0.1976950764656067, -0.2507181167602539, 0.3255530297756195, 0.38004830479621887, 0.210106760263443, -0.8993279337882996, -0.4177410304546356, 1.17291259765625, 0.25065869092941284, 0.3091251254081726, -0.039504263550043106, -0.11513996869325638, 0.6381638646125793, 0.3979302942752838, 0.31486743688583374, 0.6447343230247498, -0.31195753812789917, 0.6668919324874878, -0.11162792146205902, -0.593142569065094, -0.6282672882080078, -0.07955686002969742, 0.8273764252662659, 0.5027073621749878, 0.2896821200847626, 0.04787183552980423, -0.3226218521595001, 0.025745701044797897, 0.7087711691856384, 0.20371349155902863, -0.032697293907403946, -0.27830493450164795, -0.18330392241477966, 0.9573343396186829, -1.1896862983703613, 0.17023774981498718, 0.7019524574279785, 0.05447309836745262, -0.766908586025238, -0.11294807493686676, 0.2127116471529007, 0.5987052917480469, 0.21667993068695068, 1.5294214487075806, -0.3598007559776306, 0.36565276980400085, -0.8266612887382507, 0.3133450746536255, 0.19119524955749512, 0.20429889857769012, 0.2574741840362549, -0.6131325960159302, 0.620461106300354, -0.0031394031830132008, 0.5766509771347046, 0.513483464717865, 0.31851959228515625, 0.8233653903007507, -0.3628547191619873, -0.1205981969833374, -0.6513374447822571, -0.18220464885234833, -0.18345457315444946, 0.7502066493034363, 0.42889153957366943, 0.5450141429901123, -0.18333137035369873, 0.10805720090866089, -0.07608149945735931, -0.1108265370130539, -0.6386321187019348, -0.6238260865211487, 0.40027427673339844, -0.2356763631105423, 0.410603791475296, 0.14826315641403198, 0.14104773104190826, 0.22580811381340027, 0.6485480666160583, 0.3152926564216614, -0.06530241668224335, -0.4669772982597351, 0.555148720741272, -0.524506151676178, -0.11636362224817276, 1.3521478176116943, -0.8031229972839355, 0.43972206115722656, -0.1809491068124771, -0.16168153285980225, -0.19483092427253723, 0.3991527259349823, 0.21312056481838226, 0.17011459171772003, -0.23977945744991302, 0.3984757959842682, -0.6633282899856567, -0.37303414940834045, -0.956849217414856, 0.2011161595582962, 0.13719338178634644, -0.07872391492128372, -0.1289173662662506, -0.09160345792770386, 0.9872065782546997, 1.2887519598007202, 0.27346891164779663, 0.07153892517089844, -0.7424906492233276, -0.35507556796073914, -0.0439605712890625, 0.6438971757888794, -0.41418328881263733, -0.19624213874340057, -0.21452292799949646, 0.8925144672393799, 0.26689791679382324, 0.016952015459537506, -0.11432040482759476, -0.3457023501396179, -0.6704720258712769, -0.025666721165180206, 0.04386840760707855, -0.6150689125061035, 0.4853224456310272, 0.3096950650215149, 0.09878787398338318, -0.24789589643478394, -0.10121874511241913, 0.04411149024963379, 0.05658175051212311, -0.24198786914348602, -0.27632448077201843, 0.7006257772445679, -1.161906361579895, 0.4577453136444092, -0.17476718127727509, 0.06277121603488922, -0.6336973309516907, 0.030259566381573677, 0.11175519227981567, -0.14922727644443512, 0.5250269174575806, -0.12261372059583664, -0.98051518201828, 0.8728671669960022, -1.1431115865707397, -0.8253471851348877, 1.2228020429611206, 0.7626309394836426, -0.3292810320854187, 0.25731977820396423, 0.17799173295497894, -0.09164495021104813, -0.46370023488998413, 0.06004844978451729, 0.41628703474998474, 0.6762186884880066, 0.08233681321144104, 0.690412163734436, -0.02153060957789421, 0.4242898225784302, 0.8554643988609314, 0.14008304476737976, -0.3741307556629181, 1.3991143703460693, 0.05813998728990555, -0.27764883637428284, 0.15186981856822968, 0.8636318445205688, -0.26620909571647644, 0.3688437342643738, -0.04817027598619461, 0.2962743043899536, 0.010621092282235622, 0.117880679666996, 0.6115669012069702, -0.07215283811092377, 0.6198505759239197, 0.40165314078330994, 0.16528739035129547, -0.08517935872077942, 0.27361243963241577, -0.30854302644729614, 0.4968906044960022, 0.16364404559135437, 0.05453347787261009, 0.3292306363582611, 0.7463917136192322, 0.1999412626028061, -0.02472304366528988, 0.4191811680793762, -0.6063598394393921, 0.3704279661178589, -0.19278539717197418, 0.12727874517440796, -1.0380593538284302, -0.06518915295600891, -0.09301017224788666, 0.9583651423454285, -0.31584471464157104, -0.4535138010978699, -0.46784740686416626, -0.2072143703699112, -0.34643158316612244, -0.20904767513275146, 0.02189321629703045, -0.037317320704460144, -0.42506635189056396, 0.4018508791923523, 0.5823640823364258, -0.424161434173584, -1.3353513479232788, 0.02101059816777706, -0.34833258390426636, -0.6560068726539612, -0.29001951217651367, 0.10218136757612228, 0.20426376163959503, -0.18473215401172638, 0.42382070422172546, -0.19025789201259613, -0.4659067988395691, 0.8001885414123535, -0.8957495093345642, 0.3673929274082184, -0.5380555391311646, 0.393737256526947, -1.253050446510315, 0.39986592531204224, -0.192521333694458, 0.8328317999839783, -0.4218747019767761, -0.26853400468826294, 0.16707724332809448, -0.42062315344810486, 0.49741652607917786, -0.16383697092533112, -0.05940869078040123, 0.22170811891555786, 0.07411988079547882, -0.5112419724464417, 0.45745956897735596, 0.31164076924324036, -0.39371296763420105, -0.35616904497146606, -0.2193022221326828, 0.3938727378845215, -0.7536184787750244, -0.3654944598674774, 0.5871044993400574, -0.41849350929260254, -1.032336711883545, 0.2343566119670868, 0.30446308851242065, 0.39682215452194214, -0.2507261037826538, 0.26090914011001587, 0.9123109579086304, 0.214679554104805, 0.21393924951553345, 0.4072391390800476, -0.42366883158683777, -0.585929274559021, 0.7202764749526978, -0.09660015255212784, -0.6845399141311646, 0.8451570272445679, 0.5468785762786865, -0.16386277973651886, 0.9491787552833557, -0.4517844021320343, -0.14568950235843658, 0.3139820992946625, 0.07843659818172455, 0.391621857881546, -0.056540828198194504, 0.11889175325632095, 0.4363543689250946, 0.4120636582374573, 0.43417224287986755, 0.8139640092849731, 0.8946366906166077, -0.7285717129707336, -0.022809267044067383, 0.3180128335952759, -0.7057594060897827, -0.07921046018600464, 0.5338101983070374, -0.5342469215393066, -0.31640294194221497, 0.39365053176879883, -0.4845854640007019, -0.31067073345184326, 0.4185244143009186, 0.4277477562427521, 0.5341900587081909, 0.4231642186641693, -0.5855150818824768, -0.20940619707107544, -0.6537001729011536, -0.4333156645298004, -0.7310077548027039, 0.4908509850502014, 0.347933292388916, -0.6086445450782776, -0.2941211760044098, -0.11302519589662552, 0.5157773494720459, 0.006721051875501871, 0.32928135991096497, -0.5070944428443909, 0.2535629868507385, 0.11567740887403488, -1.0868456363677979, -0.3745090961456299, -0.21107402443885803, -0.2763402462005615, 1.0104886293411255, 0.40333274006843567, 0.6877060532569885, -0.508184552192688, -0.18238185346126556, -0.5515480637550354, 0.24162743985652924, -0.11378086358308792, -0.5027528405189514, -0.31328433752059937, -0.06846892088651657, 0.36459091305732727, -0.4634074568748474, -1.337927222251892, -0.5296040177345276, -1.2089523077011108, 0.16362720727920532, -0.936848521232605, -0.8664408326148987, 0.048632945865392685, 0.32334354519844055, 0.3958369493484497, -0.38459157943725586, -0.5995936989784241, -0.06830742210149765, -0.2521597146987915, -0.2219337373971939, 0.21894031763076782, -0.5327537655830383, 0.6522806286811829, -0.18495601415634155, 0.17003509402275085, -0.004851844627410173, -0.17009755969047546, 0.11370088160037994, 0.05558430030941963, -0.526117742061615, 0.18822918832302094, 0.7384175658226013, 0.8333150744438171, -0.4413035213947296, 0.5868291258811951, -0.4552879333496094, -0.013260291889309883, -0.9309258460998535, 0.8164372444152832, 0.12497925013303757, 1.4504075050354004, -0.38034966588020325, -0.108462393283844, 0.3047105073928833, -0.4389156997203827, 0.3450622856616974, 0.25315216183662415, -0.5901591777801514, 0.18124619126319885, -0.06746228784322739, 0.04689345508813858, 0.3307996094226837, -0.30210620164871216, 0.9744069576263428, 0.3171037435531616, 0.6362177729606628, 0.017096590250730515, 0.20889708399772644, 1.1551779508590698, -0.43193164467811584, 0.259285569190979, -0.10788450390100479, 0.5794903039932251, -0.08047966659069061, -0.1271335631608963, 0.31923091411590576, -0.7003434300422668, -0.529354453086853, -0.6625739932060242, 0.9467961192131042, -0.7064773440361023, -0.8277871012687683, 0.8146833777427673, 0.5444082021713257, -0.14096589386463165, 0.48256024718284607, -0.38180163502693176, 0.028827587142586708, -0.3485090434551239, -0.6226913332939148, -1.2654969692230225, -0.376232385635376, -0.14232344925403595, -0.32008567452430725, 0.038965754210948944, 0.34575265645980835, -0.03952367976307869, 0.2882736921310425, -0.11717405915260315, -0.13352622091770172, -0.13175642490386963, 0.5075193047523499, -0.24060417711734772, -0.30211731791496277, 0.550173282623291, -0.6689996123313904, -0.5041856169700623, 0.38396844267845154, 0.38030824065208435, 0.03330494835972786, -0.2289436161518097, -0.13424968719482422, -0.051941707730293274, -0.362662672996521, 0.21122291684150696, -1.0119819641113281, 0.5203194618225098, -0.6665512919425964, -0.14336223900318146, -1.0927447080612183, 0.2722894549369812, -0.5086442828178406, -0.3752678334712982, 0.012726843357086182, -0.5856372117996216, -0.12087313830852509, 0.17657838761806488, 0.15368568897247314, 0.44448187947273254, -0.5648395419120789, 0.7172878384590149, 0.10740643739700317, -0.7052884697914124, -0.7847462296485901, -0.7064393758773804, -0.1505136489868164, 0.06298820674419403, -0.8872709274291992, 0.004230199381709099, -0.5697566866874695, -0.09714952111244202, 0.08469188213348389, 0.3217708468437195, -0.0543290339410305, -0.20353393256664276, -0.01616773009300232, 0.084418386220932, 0.5575771331787109, -0.6614407896995544, -0.4747672975063324, 0.38230520486831665, 0.2519969344139099, 0.8115667700767517, -0.48606860637664795, -1.093188762664795, 0.44244489073753357, -0.8753238320350647, 0.13325974345207214, -0.7938572764396667, -0.4510550796985626, -0.4752618372440338, -0.4116328954696655, 0.052675917744636536, -0.0020946331787854433, 0.20084738731384277, -1.0820844173431396, -0.3657956123352051, -0.09862138330936432, 0.40839090943336487, -0.5299119353294373, 0.29024824500083923, -0.0028624299447983503, 0.22080306708812714, -0.9932315349578857, 0.9220305681228638, -0.15238192677497864, -0.2931464612483978, 0.12020759284496307, 0.038027919828891754, 0.24942442774772644, 0.7506138682365417, 0.1925305426120758, -0.21352624893188477, -0.7566352486610413, 0.24550111591815948, 0.3370259404182434, 0.5527303218841553, -0.18418914079666138, 0.015679243952035904, -0.19958189129829407, 0.3844778537750244, 0.14940780401229858, -0.10649000108242035, -0.36240068078041077, 0.5466998219490051, 0.32438141107559204, 0.22149154543876648, 0.38849422335624695, 0.5793331265449524, 0.2551232576370239, 0.7055494785308838, 0.7797220349311829, -0.37022295594215393, -0.5659971237182617, -0.09548994153738022, -0.8810443878173828, -0.00021268069394864142, 0.32160913944244385, 0.19194576144218445, -0.6032873392105103, -0.3346134126186371, -0.3185719847679138, -0.566956102848053, -0.08466431498527527, 0.09074502438306808, -0.19417373836040497, 0.4495367109775543, -0.2659231722354889, 0.030551722273230553, -0.05094537138938904, -0.1293448656797409, -0.14203710854053497, 0.40977180004119873, 0.2249780297279358, 0.689186692237854, -0.44689542055130005, -0.5467904806137085, -1.0617525577545166, 0.701371967792511, 0.3658658564090729, -0.5214198231697083, 1.0262364149093628, 0.04076675698161125, 0.3703468143939972, 0.05847828835248947, 0.3191572427749634, -0.023087963461875916, -0.5438370704650879, 0.8358964920043945, -0.04611155390739441, 0.05862688273191452, 0.14330986142158508, -0.25523680448532104, -0.446633905172348, 0.08551593124866486, 0.7462332844734192, -0.21645180881023407, 0.12997494637966156, 0.7981526851654053, 0.14743532240390778, -0.6337538957595825, -0.13743159174919128, -0.6041419506072998, 0.08822548389434814, 0.11962562054395676, -0.38525769114494324, -0.673933207988739, 0.43843594193458557, -0.7374904751777649, 0.21089571714401245, 0.7435373067855835, -0.217941552400589, 0.4432424306869507, 0.038105159997940063, 0.17092759907245636, -0.7237755656242371, -0.027852177619934082, 1.6034135818481445, 1.089241623878479, -0.2406410276889801, 0.025035716593265533, 0.3450164794921875, -1.0407627820968628, -0.5924295783042908, 1.2414169311523438, -0.4316510558128357, 0.4514404535293579, -0.07252572476863861, 0.5295324325561523, 0.05376927927136421, 0.2890188992023468, 0.39149239659309387, 0.26297906041145325, -0.9688748121261597, -0.2798610031604767, -0.34780189394950867, -0.36660346388816833, 0.0091005340218544, 0.6370046138763428, -0.02462569810450077, -0.18176773190498352, -0.8251988887786865, -0.4617750346660614, 0.04872163012623787, 0.2165350466966629, -0.17093241214752197, -0.8236916661262512, -0.9731141328811646, -0.6778392195701599, -0.5335647463798523, 0.03144003823399544, 0.7174543142318726, -0.32113882899284363, 0.6603896021842957, -0.015118710696697235, -0.13563686609268188, 0.4874921143054962, 1.2710994482040405, -0.16127409040927887, -0.7614968419075012, -0.9110506772994995, -0.46250617504119873, -0.45762890577316284, -0.9873037338256836, -0.579453706741333, 0.17859134078025818, 0.11422368884086609, 1.0726304054260254, -0.6641102433204651, 0.7567096948623657, -0.6789387464523315, -1.1725645065307617, 0.06622275710105896, -0.8239579796791077, -0.6107404232025146, 0.9477248191833496, -0.7840174436569214, 1.592553734779358, 0.3575083017349243, 0.051523517817258835, 0.10618061572313309, -0.4708782434463501, -1.2799869775772095, 1.1374772787094116, 0.37853407859802246, 1.1792432069778442, 0.48659950494766235, -0.3207205832004547, 0.7574045062065125, 1.2595800161361694, -0.9199528098106384, 0.19946928322315216, 0.1823340207338333, 0.5355769395828247, -0.8717148900032043, 0.4676029086112976, -0.48882314562797546, 0.44543951749801636, 0.6430791616439819, 0.30754199624061584, -0.6220641136169434, 0.057571060955524445, -0.440586656332016, 0.5402644276618958, -1.0733470916748047, -0.0486534982919693, 0.5159998536109924, 0.0009430473437532783, 0.2894827723503113, 0.5067088603973389, -0.3992391526699066, 0.10085999220609665, -0.03977009281516075, -0.2026202231645584, 0.4183589816093445, -0.21236565709114075, -0.9407451748847961, 0.4229467511177063, 0.35420769453048706, 0.025523174554109573, 0.4043225049972534, -0.08448544889688492, -1.1997531652450562, -0.0907277762889862, -1.016947627067566, -0.523731529712677, 0.4936918318271637, -0.22970201075077057, 0.4074080288410187, 0.37101486325263977, -0.3512074649333954, 0.4802210330963135, -0.18073247373104095, 1.0504794120788574, 0.2899354100227356, -0.3210635781288147, -0.7797553539276123, 0.7530319094657898, -0.6680253744125366, -0.4227467179298401, -0.2112474888563156, 0.5831853747367859, -0.42894086241722107, -0.9470540881156921, -0.5177473425865173, 0.49188968539237976, -0.6287572383880615, -0.18256425857543945, 0.011920739896595478, 0.02273682691156864, 0.09932150691747665, -0.2330923229455948, -1.1376882791519165, -0.05926063284277916, -1.0040287971496582, 0.16888804733753204, -0.5595710277557373, 0.8520529270172119, -0.3782691955566406, 0.2792077362537384, 0.4492281675338745, -0.3578754663467407, -0.7085115909576416, 1.202626347541809, 0.30216577649116516, -0.2442503273487091, -0.4702821969985962, 0.03507078066468239, 0.21985375881195068, 0.9601715803146362, -0.33477306365966797, -0.025307996198534966, 0.738060712814331, -0.070456862449646, 0.4910014569759369, -0.5099751353263855, -0.01755429059267044, 0.3453415036201477, -0.06552154570817947, -0.08082867413759232, 0.34710732102394104, 0.05952337756752968, 0.02519247494637966, -0.13038389384746552, 0.001029647421091795, -0.2759218215942383, 0.21986904740333557, 0.050688982009887695, 0.30894935131073, -0.6455986499786377, 0.4699949622154236, -0.5126545429229736, -0.08925749361515045, 0.6403537392616272, -0.9173468351364136, -0.6735020279884338, -0.5521096587181091, -0.16889716684818268, -0.1062610074877739, -0.30604860186576843, -0.4977121353149414, -0.6364792585372925, 0.769766092300415, -0.09437576681375504, -0.1551067978143692, 0.46208611130714417, 0.5041415095329285, 0.23263731598854065, -0.02374093048274517, 0.027579015120863914, -0.26151013374328613, 0.8612686395645142, -0.2011549472808838, -0.7983803153038025, -0.03600103780627251, 0.28161725401878357, -0.8995873928070068, 0.074965700507164, -0.09117724001407623, -0.9721715450286865, -0.5138360261917114, -0.6413978338241577, 0.4054933786392212, -0.8647388815879822, 0.08164303004741669, -0.0919509157538414, -0.6511874198913574, -0.6248725056648254, 0.0271109901368618, 0.3678004741668701, 0.42487019300460815, 0.5471323132514954, 0.41739702224731445, -0.2584463655948639, 1.2292392253875732, 0.7805967926979065, 0.03134722635149956, -0.3692023754119873, -0.5796470642089844, 0.16551119089126587, -0.27406176924705505, -0.1571274846792221, -0.9111970067024231, 1.3115200996398926, -0.640669047832489, -0.2482488602399826, -0.16062602400779724, -0.23295709490776062, -0.09632298350334167, -0.26805010437965393, 0.519460141658783, 0.5971971750259399, -0.9002014994621277, 0.32660195231437683, -0.2091064453125, 0.6055396199226379, 0.18078884482383728, -1.0552910566329956, 0.008104504086077213, -0.8871405124664307, -0.047220148146152496, -1.0664523839950562, 0.6458515524864197, -0.14126715064048767, -0.4815344214439392, -1.0245147943496704, -0.16480477154254913, -0.4331813156604767, -0.32942289113998413, -0.8943510055541992, -0.5542105436325073, -0.020931215956807137, 0.5405969023704529, 0.5131707787513733, 0.5018976330757141, -0.35366079211235046, -0.3755010664463043, -0.7892521023750305, 1.0677660703659058, -0.6530128717422485, 0.18472540378570557, 0.4069673717021942, 0.35904860496520996, -0.6375570297241211, 0.535526692867279, 0.7997850179672241, -0.8394366502761841, 1.06548011302948, 0.3350735604763031, 0.2691684067249298, 0.08816523849964142, -0.23974280059337616, 0.37106651067733765, 1.0615907907485962, 0.2030630260705948, 0.5774411559104919, -0.32450538873672485, 0.380803644657135, -1.046891689300537, 0.1389031708240509, -0.02670121006667614, 0.38316240906715393, 0.6488202810287476, -0.8643691539764404, -0.023836487904191017, -1.1483207941055298, 4.011915683746338, 0.7686015963554382, 0.9386139512062073, 0.01852138340473175, 0.5457284450531006, 0.42534303665161133, -0.19803714752197266, 0.07881752401590347, 0.40545982122421265, 0.06345243752002716, -0.06197262182831764, -0.16900712251663208, 0.8075610995292664, -0.30503660440444946, 0.21749557554721832, 0.5745174884796143, -0.3085986077785492, 0.15404370427131653, 0.474327027797699, -0.8459473848342896, -1.801772117614746, -0.00649858545511961, 0.25256437063217163, 0.384561151266098, 0.1580314040184021, 0.1426534503698349, 0.2859017848968506, -0.11134755611419678, -0.7688754796981812, -0.6381320953369141, -0.7175718545913696, -0.3772580027580261, 0.482714980840683, -0.43570080399513245, -0.6086543798446655, 0.4695858061313629, -0.73536616563797, 0.11856536567211151, -0.04536813497543335, -0.05141652375459671, -0.7767369151115417, -0.9114618897438049, 0.07733526825904846, -0.40131354331970215, 0.3675204813480377, 1.0074726343154907, 0.7222806811332703, 0.5213772654533386, 0.6260088682174683, -0.3293916583061218, 0.15974585711956024, -0.15729323029518127, 0.3008542060852051, 0.2055540233850479, -0.6913929581642151, -0.185325488448143, 0.0631079450249672, -0.24616575241088867, 0.8114532232284546, -1.0072424411773682, 1.0784841775894165, 0.2068754881620407, -0.07926484942436218, 0.5995232462882996, -0.08124620467424393, 0.05819264426827431, 0.14121341705322266, -0.07260992377996445, -0.8191840052604675, -0.2241445630788803, -0.4718754291534424, -0.2476090043783188, -0.12822648882865906, -0.08410084247589111, 0.07195112109184265, -0.12937776744365692, -0.021691476926207542, 0.02952900342643261, 0.384613037109375, 0.3111492693424225, -0.32247623801231384, 0.05931159108877182, -0.24629496037960052, 0.209030881524086, 0.11903712898492813, 1.137429118156433, 0.24622038006782532, -0.052069325000047684, 0.021958917379379272, 0.6977372169494629, 0.019113661721348763, 0.44801896810531616, 0.16922485828399658, 0.46808457374572754, -0.5713961720466614 ]
Binary Black Holes in Stationary Orbits
We show that under certain astrophysical conditions a binary system consisting of two compact objects can be stabilized against indefinite shrinking of orbits due to the emission of gravitational radiation. In this case, the lighter binary companion settles down to a stable orbit when the loss of the angular momentum due to gravitational radiation becomes equal to its gain from the accreting matter from the disk around the more massive primary. We claim that such systems can be stable against small perturbations and can be regarded as steady emitters of gravitational waves of constant frequency and amplitude. Furthermore, X-rays emitted by the secondary can also produce astrophysically interesting situations when coupled with gravitational lensing and Doppler effects.
Sandip K. Chakrabarti (Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Bombay, INDIA)
astro-ph gr-qc
August
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9208006
astro-ph/9208007
[ 0.5508791208267212, 0.6174977421760559, 0.3575364053249359, -0.04545927047729492, -0.15992942452430725, 0.2726920545101166, -0.2959528863430023, 0.04886971041560173, -0.36554738879203796, 1.4834269285202026, 0.5791708827018738, -0.4973381757736206, -0.39803066849708557, -1.2472162246704102, -0.48342546820640564, 0.04498343542218208, -0.30417734384536743, -0.37743428349494934, -1.3877894878387451, -0.2055439054965973, -0.13359208405017853, 0.004889702890068293, -1.589411973953247, -0.3500029146671295, -0.7320122122764587, 0.45335888862609863, 0.09670253843069077, 0.06540975719690323, 0.8536858558654785, 0.7088552713394165, 0.27259963750839233, -0.39759039878845215, -0.15716786682605743, -0.7955788373947144, -0.10015348345041275, -0.0824366882443428, 0.11965825408697128, 0.09788653254508972, 0.9955992102622986, -0.2934685945510864, 0.8621620535850525, -0.17178596556186676, 0.15972517430782318, -0.31505340337753296, -0.3656073808670044, -0.28927838802337646, -0.8424130082130432, 0.06780286133289337, 0.1299445778131485, -1.103488802909851, -0.2693098485469818, 0.25720199942588806, 0.308725506067276, -0.9736928343772888, -0.02646762877702713, -0.1702241748571396, 0.025810185819864273, -0.3733431398868561, -0.13957703113555908, -0.1493668109178543, 0.6095412969589233, 0.43312782049179077, 0.5530004501342773, -0.7415021061897278, -0.34942811727523804, 1.2125401496887207, -0.1309337615966797, -0.08535978943109512, -0.048285920172929764, 0.10346957296133041, -0.25648531317710876, -0.1874334216117859, -0.5610655546188354, 0.08609943091869354, -0.16703109443187714, 0.1957169473171234, -0.40009886026382446, 0.16080611944198608, -1.0136711597442627, -0.7219801545143127, -0.15282359719276428, 0.10336582362651825, -0.21446573734283447, 0.40897679328918457, 0.31412872672080994, -0.7965030074119568, 0.6524984240531921, 0.012296793982386589, 0.721511960029602, 0.6958661079406738, -0.9191315770149231, 0.8178166747093201, -0.6151480078697205, 0.18067270517349243, 0.37554121017456055, 0.11756276339292526, -0.09157797694206238, 0.3356417119503021, 0.5162906050682068, 0.4155980348587036, 0.3682045340538025, 0.6649071574211121, -0.4489211440086365, 0.034625615924596786, -0.2983238697052002, 1.0389623641967773, -0.9164573550224304, 0.30811741948127747, -0.3202728033065796, -0.8539314866065979, -0.13851456344127655, -0.22331053018569946, 0.23183570802211761, -0.20788878202438354, -0.03241874277591705, 0.45907193422317505, -0.8693259954452515, 0.38002562522888184, -0.0660177543759346, -0.7030735611915588, -0.4458312690258026, 0.994725227355957, 0.006586445961147547, -0.04048391059041023, -0.5779943466186523, -0.04994088038802147, -0.4434986412525177, 0.3209836184978485, -1.0419714450836182, -0.0178973451256752, -0.2736937999725342, -0.5628305077552795, -0.636653482913971, 0.7360522150993347, -0.04087725654244423, -0.1712333709001541, 0.7498812675476074, 0.3674750030040741, -0.457604318857193, -0.6314423680305481, 0.05043407157063484, -0.5175748467445374, -0.0466308556497097, 1.3260942697525024, -1.3223259449005127, -0.1915978342294693, -0.31182900071144104, -0.1434081345796585, 0.02669936791062355, 0.2224290519952774, -0.09972874820232391, 0.2981739640235901, 0.24860872328281403, 0.7872713208198547, -0.47510573267936707, -0.24971044063568115, -1.313053011894226, -0.32843297719955444, -0.00357426842674613, -0.7025467157363892, -0.21425609290599823, -0.4470396041870117, -0.557990550994873, 0.5744667053222656, -1.3088730573654175, 0.3998211622238159, -0.30173420906066895, -0.49166035652160645, 0.6464929580688477, -0.4116274118423462, -0.4344852566719055, 0.6323974132537842, -0.8229968547821045, 0.526385486125946, 0.6445098519325256, 0.4384589195251465, 0.3938017189502716, -0.27629250288009644, 0.13226580619812012, 0.30751922726631165, 0.05221671238541603, -0.2802734673023224, 0.22497081756591797, 0.366935670375824, -0.4450601637363434, 0.3948741555213928, -0.128122940659523, 0.13897418975830078, 0.646198034286499, 0.1007825955748558, -0.73285973072052, 0.3531523644924164, -0.8196253776550293, 0.550139307975769, -1.1678696870803833, -0.43486419320106506, -0.6311734914779663, 0.042225245386362076, -0.03553091734647751, -0.7235556244850159, 0.27699995040893555, 0.17678117752075195, -1.0330275297164917, 1.2344038486480713, -0.9406091570854187, 0.03354845941066742, 0.8382106423377991, 0.7814182043075562, -0.7141026854515076, -0.1001356840133667, 0.4890581965446472, -0.2065194696187973, -0.060547079890966415, -0.4347160756587982, 0.4398607313632965, -0.2201346606016159, 0.0836225301027298, 0.14513523876667023, 0.3148626387119293, -0.011026657186448574, 0.23753145337104797, -0.02829120308160782, -0.03344343602657318, 0.7137994766235352, -0.16092993319034576, -0.3245760500431061, 0.7744999527931213, 0.6003229022026062, -0.28908783197402954, 0.6197565793991089, -0.2744080126285553, -0.13277605175971985, -0.03589045628905296, 0.03728097304701805, 0.3260684609413147, -0.4124825596809387, 0.9867876768112183, 0.8104674220085144, -0.3397315740585327, 0.041825734078884125, 0.15811453759670258, -0.2045702338218689, 0.1764572262763977, 0.18872007727622986, -0.7980265021324158, -0.01246621459722519, 0.16171051561832428, -0.24085499346256256, -0.16014859080314636, 0.8201068639755249, -0.25525861978530884, 0.5009241700172424, -0.0520070381462574, 0.8298019170761108, -0.7032270431518555, -0.6182065010070801, -0.2452249825000763, 0.6203513145446777, 0.28396743535995483, -0.8877265453338623, -0.14883096516132355, -0.10097653418779373, 0.03420986235141754, -0.17246085405349731, -0.3616430461406708, -0.099697045981884, -0.662036120891571, 0.45314088463783264, 0.7129387855529785, -0.37309738993644714, -0.7496379017829895, 0.10907486081123352, -0.09775612503290176, -0.029534000903367996, -0.5485038161277771, 0.0877009704709053, -0.4771236479282379, -1.0906188488006592, 0.0377148799598217, -0.11273489147424698, -0.16617994010448456, 1.0445668697357178, -0.25925353169441223, 0.21881595253944397, -0.2675817906856537, 0.4530167877674103, -0.9899032115936279, 0.14136932790279388, -0.17715036869049072, 0.09625104814767838, -0.12442753463983536, -0.3930889368057251, -0.8489120006561279, -0.27092018723487854, 0.5034506320953369, 1.081612467765808, -0.5121319890022278, 0.3762749433517456, 0.45476019382476807, -0.6565809845924377, 0.5547143220901489, 0.19026191532611847, -0.4497145712375641, -0.32801395654678345, -0.7521936297416687, 0.4147999882698059, -0.3436981737613678, 0.3841363489627838, 0.5924668312072754, -0.1562110334634781, -0.4136800467967987, 0.5972929000854492, -0.17818519473075867, 0.5049846768379211, -0.2930634617805481, 0.06600518524646759, 0.5403118133544922, 0.1108161136507988, 0.23139122128486633, -0.14843440055847168, -0.8360687494277954, -0.6737414002418518, 0.4864470362663269, -0.20996688306331635, 0.395834356546402, 0.9458732604980469, 0.4813772439956665, -0.4516718089580536, -0.012794792652130127, -0.6340216398239136, -0.7580421566963196, -0.12770959734916687, -0.7913587093353271, 0.5583338737487793, -0.1538790464401245, 0.2782917618751526, -0.5011681318283081, 0.5326915979385376, -0.4818950295448303, -0.010674012824892998, 0.4960780143737793, 0.15490533411502838, 0.34576037526130676, 0.59174644947052, -0.5300337672233582, -0.23053595423698425, 0.8890537023544312, -0.34057101607322693, -0.2753954827785492, 0.48638978600502014, -0.4178198575973511, 0.27228856086730957, -0.018907885998487473, 0.2982526123523712, 0.02706971764564514, 0.6416275501251221, -0.26452019810676575, 0.001080030808225274, -0.46833109855651855, -0.19932247698307037, -0.11960990726947784, -0.1486905962228775, 0.5009962320327759, -0.1449829638004303, -0.35977113246917725, -0.3489817678928375, -0.011091292835772038, -0.38085463643074036, 0.5015560388565063, -1.2720293998718262, -0.010575508698821068, -0.0823969691991806, -0.3501688838005066, -0.35189101099967957, -0.37952250242233276, 0.4141251742839813, 0.7995159029960632, 0.28285959362983704, 0.63584303855896, -0.5264882445335388, 0.15822678804397583, -0.17476782202720642, 0.7982443571090698, 0.7089365124702454, 0.44239455461502075, 0.04444075748324394, -0.14783377945423126, 0.6018552780151367, -0.24820204079151154, -0.2496536523103714, -0.4373082220554352, -0.7841241955757141, 0.16716116666793823, -0.6744373440742493, -0.5957728624343872, 0.17582374811172485, 0.3013799786567688, 0.576921284198761, -0.4100973308086395, 0.12661968171596527, -0.6087096929550171, -0.8115524053573608, 0.06831444799900055, 0.145959734916687, 0.31067955493927, 0.01967751234769821, -0.5134285092353821, 0.3549661338329315, -0.31554561853408813, 0.439848929643631, 0.5014430284500122, -0.2566637098789215, -0.019660791382193565, 0.17420916259288788, 0.1302901804447174, 0.5959669947624207, -0.21463117003440857, 0.7097280621528625, 0.16390036046504974, 0.4221857786178589, -0.7741272449493408, 0.5634077191352844, 0.42190083861351013, 0.7254242300987244, -0.17336012423038483, -1.1273930072784424, 0.31008651852607727, -0.5783043503761292, 0.4660818874835968, 0.5548087358474731, -0.6857286095619202, -1.2241710424423218, -0.5969589352607727, -0.13045962154865265, 0.5662919282913208, 0.6439369320869446, 0.40745416283607483, -0.20807990431785583, 0.14741572737693787, -0.12332861125469208, 0.13737262785434723, 0.420274555683136, -0.15778136253356934, -0.9152434468269348, -0.36279451847076416, 0.44969531893730164, -0.4221554100513458, 0.09380016475915909, 0.1076539009809494, -1.0125430822372437, -0.31990689039230347, -0.4442487955093384, 0.11553195863962173, -0.5833568572998047, -0.9853341579437256, 1.062371850013733, 0.4236075282096863, -0.14848168194293976, -0.1677122712135315, -0.5381900668144226, 0.021953603252768517, 0.3183201253414154, -0.0028373722452670336, -0.19119256734848022, -0.4340766370296478, -0.4421105980873108, -0.014118803665041924, 1.1731423139572144, 0.6367852687835693, 0.23396442830562592, 0.9519336819648743, -0.09382930397987366, -0.12866945564746857, -0.25491124391555786, 0.24959540367126465, 0.0007061986834742129, 0.11905094981193542, -0.25772663950920105, -0.06718210130929947, -0.39341914653778076, -0.031390637159347534, 0.4390321969985962, -0.22814299166202545, 0.10612399876117706, -0.13756437599658966, -0.8838150501251221, -0.8196102380752563, -0.8067349195480347, -0.514690637588501, 1.7573044300079346, -0.019046280533075333, -0.2594851553440094, 0.3091624081134796, -0.5292354226112366, 0.0645904466509819, -0.45827093720436096, -0.060837797820568085, -0.8314268589019775, 0.2210111916065216, 0.43462130427360535, 0.6611210703849792, -0.035313643515110016, -0.872229278087616, 0.3927919268608093, -0.1360141932964325, -0.9968078136444092, -0.5872424840927124, -0.4870304763317108, -0.48914873600006104, -0.20646171271800995, 0.1680615395307541, -0.4778417944908142, -0.27273595333099365, -0.19169892370700836, -0.37239596247673035, 0.2303200364112854, -0.10128190368413925, -0.8974933624267578, -0.04309733584523201, 0.3570719063282013, 0.8398415446281433, -0.7318601012229919, -0.3812757134437561, 0.2419966608285904, -0.17470978200435638, 0.8537402749061584, -0.016891295090317726, -0.4798721373081207, 0.3646400570869446, -0.7596096992492676, -0.38895031809806824, -0.6701400279998779, 0.057078178972005844, 0.6880747675895691, -0.4641841650009155, 0.018214743584394455, 0.3700655698776245, 0.21927492320537567, 0.18033023178577423, -0.43595632910728455, -0.2907034158706665, 0.5809680223464966, -0.3055528700351715, 0.30090048909187317, -0.36172547936439514, -0.025611039251089096, -0.7333016991615295, 0.9803192615509033, -0.6416533589363098, -0.5779467821121216, -0.21642637252807617, -0.1474543958902359, -0.14466142654418945, 0.9471323490142822, 0.4510761797428131, -0.013419331051409245, -0.2756001949310303, 0.7837686538696289, 0.4973069131374359, 0.10698014497756958, -1.0722333192825317, 0.8531764149665833, -0.2770899832248688, 0.5539444088935852, -0.12395821511745453, 0.28376510739326477, 0.42812612652778625, -0.18682999908924103, 0.9612240791320801, -0.02005895972251892, 0.2974661886692047, 1.1804951429367065, 0.27080869674682617, 0.33452728390693665, 0.3703095614910126, -0.18749886751174927, -0.11403708159923553, -0.717583954334259, -0.7863156199455261, 0.722017228603363, 0.3494764566421509, -0.3649037182331085, 0.2703387141227722, -0.012942834757268429, -0.3573344647884369, -0.45783764123916626, 0.6395024657249451, 0.16808700561523438, 0.1979273408651352, -0.39398232102394104, 0.2715667188167572, 0.17925390601158142, -0.3575373589992523, -0.1484580785036087, 0.48220840096473694, -0.3039378821849823, 0.26869162917137146, -0.31720444560050964, 0.4171181321144104, -0.7228739261627197, -0.7824574112892151, 0.2321804016828537, 0.5627458095550537, -0.5617859959602356, 0.9108042120933533, -0.259335994720459, -0.007149214390665293, -0.44819360971450806, -0.11644526571035385, 0.43839019536972046, -0.1086495965719223, 1.0282249450683594, 0.5734225511550903, 0.07721874117851257, 0.4011242389678955, -0.6089142560958862, -1.0872634649276733, 0.1791737824678421, 0.17657262086868286, -0.9779452085494995, -0.4841918349266052, 0.42560964822769165, 0.057323701679706573, -0.9164143800735474, -0.5792572498321533, -1.2921404838562012, -0.20103228092193604, 0.28821781277656555, -0.04776616394519806, -0.13885512948036194, -0.06680548936128616, -0.40542498230934143, 0.20912595093250275, 0.17066119611263275, 1.2044484615325928, 0.3561435043811798, -0.03082847222685814, 0.31775155663490295, -0.45503243803977966, -0.2290797233581543, 1.4382240772247314, 0.36744990944862366, -0.6789596676826477, 0.09449688345193863, 0.25145503878593445, -0.016539501026272774, 0.11334212869405746, 1.1535797119140625, -0.28045904636383057, 0.588188648223877, -0.08521247655153275, -0.25460290908813477, 0.5648815035820007, 0.09590429812669754, 0.074631467461586, -0.05742640793323517, -0.648327648639679, -0.9046133160591125, -0.15400810539722443, -0.5666317939758301, 0.8568222522735596, 0.6184662580490112, 0.12682197988033295, 0.22422681748867035, -0.557119607925415, -0.3783697187900543, 0.00016346396296285093, -0.151285782456398, -0.0036220536567270756, -0.7926546335220337, -0.5224714875221252, -0.7794163823127747, -0.2089279443025589, 0.23079721629619598, 0.7625098824501038, -0.4417729675769806, 0.2236369252204895, -0.2370939701795578, 0.013826072216033936, 0.4774475395679474, 0.37544187903404236, 0.02661493606865406, -0.6014241576194763, -0.5526752471923828, -0.0209440216422081, 0.007112703751772642, -1.429558515548706, -0.18722698092460632, -0.16556143760681152, 0.3033371567726135, 1.132562279701233, -0.7014268040657043, 0.5694567561149597, -0.6666401028633118, -0.13243761658668518, 0.31182724237442017, 0.5865835547447205, -0.743198573589325, 1.302799940109253, -1.0385875701904297, 0.9620850086212158, 0.5691875219345093, 0.2888600826263428, -0.6542892456054688, 0.7591158151626587, -1.3871805667877197, 0.4775322675704956, 0.31440484523773193, 0.7900505065917969, 0.49208322167396545, 0.1352969855070114, -0.363182932138443, 0.8123842477798462, -0.5322754979133606, -0.049469321966171265, -0.5535547137260437, 0.20162299275398254, 0.15979020297527313, 0.41564980149269104, 0.04843650385737419, 0.9902318716049194, -0.09444574266672134, 0.33812814950942993, -0.8766424655914307, 0.5628880262374878, 0.027988076210021973, 0.8796141147613525, 0.22227974236011505, -0.8564433455467224, 0.5255837440490723, -0.962753176689148, 0.5873929262161255, 0.38533416390419006, -0.38755422830581665, -0.2168903797864914, 0.23380228877067566, 0.5871467590332031, -0.11135253310203552, 0.33506008982658386, -0.22587251663208008, 0.6767787337303162, -0.07887518405914307, 0.863481879234314, 0.41802477836608887, 0.22855541110038757, -0.3277689218521118, 0.7597593069076538, -0.31864994764328003, -0.6441407203674316, 0.8798802495002747, -0.21324492990970612, -0.5290173888206482, -0.16141574084758759, 0.253298282623291, 0.4013521373271942, 0.15810802578926086, 0.027110163122415543, 1.7333279848098755, 0.5373554229736328, -0.759864866733551, 0.8007524013519287, -0.2704479992389679, -0.6969922780990601, -0.38176900148391724, 0.4241728186607361, -1.1683406829833984, -0.6086660027503967, -0.4002320468425751, 0.6925572156906128, -0.11032666265964508, 0.3881222903728485, -0.6628963351249695, -0.09072846174240112, -0.20543205738067627, -0.17712707817554474, -0.7805688977241516, -0.0822371169924736, -0.18281948566436768, 1.0147587060928345, 0.2608150243759155, -0.4236176311969757, 0.17267274856567383, 0.21591302752494812, 1.0142033100128174, 0.1529594361782074, -0.3359037935733795, 1.261176347732544, 0.15566767752170563, -0.008434319868683815, 0.8401704430580139, 0.038044337183237076, 0.2996876537799835, 0.7207242250442505, -0.499396950006485, 0.29280921816825867, 0.5092706680297852, -0.07061748206615448, 0.219553142786026, 0.2130407840013504, -0.10244432836771011, -0.1782648265361786, 0.021765515208244324, -0.1607503592967987, -0.03556093946099281, -0.2258380949497223, 0.2915993332862854, 0.15021772682666779, -0.39031514525413513, 0.6298729181289673, 0.027947504073381424, 0.3232879340648651, -0.1019480898976326, -0.05508054047822952, 0.4048568308353424, -0.6255377531051636, -0.5928826332092285, 0.1329619139432907, -0.3168679177761078, -0.9396766424179077, -0.9731590747833252, 0.6198699474334717, 0.453999787569046, -0.06546353548765182, -0.19395078718662262, 0.6912801861763, 0.3104970157146454, 0.43893489241600037, -0.36275729537010193, 0.3136955499649048, 0.13473594188690186, 0.5498704314231873, 0.5541443228721619, 0.46586742997169495, 0.4582829475402832, 0.6086236834526062, 0.631836473941803, -1.180944800376892, 0.29639264941215515, 0.8185375928878784, -0.7404949069023132, 0.29293113946914673, 0.046580150723457336, -0.2856485843658447, -0.4715275168418884, -0.4243171215057373, -0.230919748544693, -1.4883784055709839, 0.14984166622161865, 0.7313931584358215, -0.638795793056488, 0.03517797216773033, 0.26969102025032043, 0.2007092386484146, 0.7198986411094666, 0.6545475721359253, 0.3352729082107544, -0.5241117477416992, 1.0542598962783813, 0.8195158839225769, 0.5809316039085388, 0.14275650680065155, -0.008071205578744411, -0.2110251486301422, 0.2929873764514923, 0.18630295991897583, -0.707492470741272, 0.7942955493927002, -0.2825508713722229, -0.21873264014720917, -0.357509583234787, 0.15797266364097595, -0.21653759479522705, 0.38064682483673096, 0.5727598667144775, 0.06081673875451088, -0.10803447663784027, -0.07770834863185883, 0.7129380702972412, 0.059985656291246414, -0.5909213423728943, -0.6348204612731934, 0.6029601693153381, -0.6117272973060608, -0.44479629397392273, -0.3206107020378113, 0.624605119228363, 0.044025078415870667, -0.15124459564685822, -0.03851168975234032, -0.45804890990257263, -0.5843260884284973, -0.17722569406032562, -0.4503825306892395, -0.39718690514564514, 0.627503514289856, 0.7056708931922913, 0.38902747631073, -0.6483389735221863, -0.9193121194839478, -0.05596189945936203, -0.35130348801612854, 0.6868139505386353, -0.14894549548625946, 0.25322452187538147, 0.2220948338508606, 0.3625956177711487, -0.46917515993118286, 0.5200013518333435, 0.5770419239997864, 0.06185109540820122, 0.7274709939956665, 0.1953248530626297, -0.17954307794570923, -0.08681368827819824, -0.1223086267709732, -0.1754712611436844, 0.6083353757858276, 0.7493734359741211, -0.15608279407024384, -0.41126158833503723, 0.13193142414093018, -0.5219442844390869, -0.20117339491844177, 0.003711321856826544, 0.509064257144928, 0.29085859656333923, -0.4015766382217407, 0.5894997119903564, -1.210300087928772, 4.061820983886719, 0.5773219466209412, 0.7655397057533264, -0.8074795007705688, 0.9712938070297241, 0.9394732713699341, 0.010643335059285164, -0.47259390354156494, 0.31746307015419006, 0.20957106351852417, 0.023694833740592003, -0.4070497155189514, -0.11464380472898483, 0.28558802604675293, 0.2973748445510864, 0.7819802165031433, 0.37104347348213196, -0.6393502950668335, -0.24444687366485596, 0.05513587221503258, -0.9944018721580505, 0.007563269231468439, 0.027358664199709892, -0.34285563230514526, 0.1819390207529068, 0.6811227798461914, -0.008009042590856552, 0.09243762493133545, -0.4868578612804413, -0.4629552960395813, -0.23008766770362854, -0.681208610534668, 0.020291170105338097, -0.06883104145526886, -1.359998106956482, 0.906744122505188, -0.048035748302936554, -0.571602463722229, 0.6251351833343506, -0.9878861904144287, -0.31675150990486145, -0.6081497073173523, -0.161179319024086, -0.09910884499549866, -0.35942313075065613, 0.9359995722770691, 0.7367554903030396, 0.7504116296768188, 1.246268391609192, -0.305502325296402, 0.0036338174249976873, 0.46171408891677856, 0.284903883934021, -0.3326341211795807, -1.3214138746261597, -0.4304875433444977, -0.1186351552605629, -0.10096538811922073, 0.3494195342063904, -0.18680506944656372, 0.675210177898407, -0.3332400918006897, -0.17882698774337769, 0.12779849767684937, 0.3279730975627899, -0.18767111003398895, 0.1917189210653305, 0.09145858138799667, -0.05313160642981529, 0.16150696575641632, -0.6844357252120972, 0.22133973240852356, -0.2843794822692871, -0.38450339436531067, 0.002581071574240923, 0.1798701286315918, 0.16599535942077637, -0.313103586435318, -0.5896944403648376, 0.006167996674776077, -0.2321791797876358, 0.08654159307479858, -0.5136961340904236, 0.9725720286369324, -0.05478225275874138, 0.7308527827262878, -0.40817323327064514, 0.10940884798765182, 0.03679915890097618, 0.8239565491676331, 0.02628779597580433, 0.3507249355316162, -0.2924150824546814, 0.14658981561660767, -0.6932452917098999 ]
COBE, Gravitational Waves, Inflation and Extended Inflation
We analyse the implications for inflationary models of the cosmic microwave background (cmb) anisotropy measured by COBE. Vacuum fluctuations during inflation generate an adiabatic density perturbation, and also gravitational waves. The ratio of these two contributions to the cmb anisotropy is given for an arbitrary slow-roll inflaton potential. Results from the IRAS/QDOT and POTENT galaxy surveys are used to normalise the spectrum of the density perturbation on the scale $20h^{-1}\Mpc$, so that the COBE measurement on the scale $10^3h^{-1}\Mpc$ provides a lower bound on the spectral index $n$. For `power law' and `extended' inflation, gravitational waves are significant and the bound is $n>0.84$ at the $2$-sigma level. For `natural' inflation, gravitational waves are negligible and the constraint is weakened to $n>0.70$, at best marginally consistent with a recent proposal for explaining the excess clustering observed in the APM galaxy survey. Many versions of extended inflation, including those based on the Brans--Dicke theory, are ruled out, because they require $n\lsim 0.75$ in order that bubbles formed at the end of inflation should not be observed now in the cmb.
David H Lyth and Andrew R Liddle
astro-ph gr-qc hep-ph
August
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9208007
astro-ph/9209001
[ 0.5655799508094788, 0.7494044303894043, 0.9090967774391174, -0.0771963819861412, -0.5288448929786682, -0.028438853099942207, -0.15127119421958923, -0.008334560319781303, -0.030097413808107376, 0.7786594033241272, 0.1846403181552887, -0.5168278217315674, -0.2540309727191925, -0.6514186859130859, -0.6243388056755066, 0.4343271255493164, 0.4250956177711487, -0.4046494662761688, -1.3094792366027832, -0.22108452022075653, -0.6207011938095093, -0.42996299266815186, -0.8373177647590637, -0.4642755389213562, 0.015661073848605156, 0.5849098563194275, -0.16145527362823486, 1.472645878791809, 1.0289909839630127, 0.1932329684495926, 0.300261527299881, -0.8984491229057312, 0.5921231508255005, -0.882946789264679, -0.3904135525226593, -0.2446289211511612, 0.5037636160850525, -0.26899436116218567, 0.4900152087211609, -0.7731550335884094, 0.8334863185882568, -0.03592535853385925, 0.6261222958564758, -0.2591133415699005, -0.05024384707212448, -0.14115633070468903, 0.010050454176962376, -0.7838529944419861, 0.461395263671875, -0.5212967395782471, -0.1023540049791336, 0.3689865469932556, 0.28977105021476746, -1.2347002029418945, -0.06314503401517868, -0.01150529645383358, 0.3140023946762085, -0.25875377655029297, 0.423793226480484, 0.23343726992607117, -0.12968145310878754, 0.5401379466056824, 0.9151281714439392, -0.5317556262016296, -0.6609802842140198, 0.8822219967842102, 0.025271238759160042, -0.8940144181251526, 0.35671666264533997, -0.44886770844459534, -0.2590777575969696, -0.2685430347919464, 0.4358486533164978, 0.07224427908658981, -1.105344295501709, -0.6090603470802307, -0.012682364322245121, 0.5566507577896118, 0.34269702434539795, 0.309319406747818, 0.5639529824256897, 0.43368253111839294, 0.19048278033733368, 0.11145828664302826, 0.2116447538137436, -0.8678149580955505, 0.21173284947872162, 0.6842247843742371, 0.5502344369888306, 0.6923940181732178, -0.030351949855685234, 0.8517773151397705, -0.4650425612926483, -0.3115135729312897, 0.049792565405368805, 0.15108996629714966, -0.43679529428482056, 0.31432899832725525, 0.4174807071685791, 0.4258096218109131, 0.05412307381629944, 0.3739255666732788, -0.3006441593170166, 0.5446974635124207, -0.20699232816696167, 0.19329632818698883, -0.015656428411602974, -0.7420244216918945, -0.36794087290763855, -0.5447856783866882, 0.12340443581342697, 0.018092438578605652, 0.42135611176490784, 0.36508020758628845, 0.3532758951187134, 0.6020412445068359, -0.058096617460250854, 0.21328416466712952, -0.671973705291748, 0.12674139440059662, 0.009298063814640045, 1.0949223041534424, 0.614132285118103, 0.2944403290748596, -0.3036347031593323, -0.06159689649939537, -0.34840619564056396, -0.1237151101231575, -0.6997193098068237, -0.3972907066345215, 0.1863234043121338, -1.37022864818573, -0.6424537897109985, 1.2658013105392456, 0.18345198035240173, 0.24154387414455414, 0.6434482932090759, 0.553770899772644, 0.1669277399778366, -0.47663170099258423, -0.23623205721378326, 0.17382171750068665, -0.450288325548172, 1.014534592628479, -0.4336085915565491, 0.8363579511642456, -0.11134137213230133, 0.28417161107063293, -0.24586525559425354, 0.652438223361969, 0.353885293006897, -0.6863940358161926, 0.2880466878414154, 0.39510947465896606, -0.5159299373626709, -1.0140348672866821, -0.3768841624259949, 0.12850207090377808, -0.4105222523212433, -0.36091068387031555, -0.3469075560569763, -0.3513113558292389, 0.506682813167572, 0.196991428732872, -0.3293164074420929, 0.4503878355026245, -0.7313554883003235, -0.6704500317573547, 0.19049103558063507, 0.07132704555988312, -0.0007633976056240499, 0.6275516152381897, 0.2798197567462921, 0.4616374969482422, 0.32720500230789185, 0.15587589144706726, -0.02814594656229019, -0.523982584476471, -0.20653939247131348, 0.5714388489723206, -0.3994782567024231, -0.5859165191650391, -0.22078919410705566, 0.2521546185016632, 0.644985020160675, -0.04421457275748253, -0.597208559513092, -0.6410381197929382, 0.08080434054136276, -0.38267451524734497, 0.4636903703212738, 0.926281213760376, -0.6472386717796326, 0.40562325716018677, -0.11854870617389679, 0.33402448892593384, -0.24842622876167297, -0.040816862136125565, 0.19151148200035095, -0.5333337187767029, -0.5093285441398621, 0.14435447752475739, -0.5581263303756714, 0.1838056445121765, -0.062095120549201965, -0.12366306781768799, 1.2995182275772095, 1.012175440788269, -0.2549978792667389, -0.22986827790737152, 0.887398898601532, 0.11442553997039795, 0.392387330532074, -0.21715879440307617, 1.1686244010925293, -0.15019148588180542, 0.06835224479436874, 0.5326337814331055, -0.9842236042022705, -0.22569024562835693, 0.8340476751327515, 0.427446186542511, -0.3856227993965149, 0.8380545973777771, -0.6503586769104004, 0.2138376235961914, -1.0965512990951538, 0.9576665759086609, 0.22339624166488647, 0.4924737215042114, -0.5192980170249939, 0.3890470862388611, 0.26374873518943787, 0.37679311633110046, 0.09966646134853363, -0.12876199185848236, 1.0528408288955688, 0.7491987347602844, -0.7454444766044617, 0.002461859257891774, -0.33349609375, 0.031658295542001724, 0.2601865828037262, 0.48648831248283386, 0.020770730450749397, 0.9732385277748108, 0.06347659230232239, -0.10990320146083832, -0.2867034673690796, 0.6681482195854187, -0.3678083121776581, 0.9665492177009583, -0.6009982824325562, -0.26634466648101807, -0.7602166533470154, -0.36528730392456055, 0.06760698556900024, -0.09993612766265869, -0.2274058759212494, -0.47507160902023315, -0.4879688024520874, -0.6024971008300781, 0.6327759623527527, -0.02079007774591446, 0.7131385207176208, 0.08213889598846436, -0.36085471510887146, 0.4520561993122101, 0.11357350647449493, -0.5463294982910156, -1.592044472694397, 0.3247928321361542, -1.106643557548523, -0.04601076617836952, -0.17852795124053955, -0.39302024245262146, 0.7922754883766174, -0.4042400121688843, 0.6150950193405151, -0.08580432832241058, -0.11375101655721664, -0.46613913774490356, -0.7258851528167725, 0.033660147339105606, -0.3156428039073944, 0.5053884983062744, -0.7501002550125122, 0.5788599252700806, -0.06797420233488083, 0.21123972535133362, -0.42742374539375305, 0.20766505599021912, -0.8655691146850586, 0.16731780767440796, 0.8006871938705444, -0.48632004857063293, -0.2727402448654175, 0.4707225561141968, 0.5914714336395264, -0.6959765553474426, 0.27908897399902344, -0.6110403537750244, -0.7334427833557129, -0.3961154818534851, -0.5431564450263977, -0.45861634612083435, -0.3004489243030548, 0.1673680692911148, 0.5462555289268494, 0.6318743228912354, -0.5398416519165039, 0.3416800796985626, 0.4280162751674652, 0.7198045253753662, -0.335496723651886, -0.014713442884385586, 0.5614939332008362, -0.5207915902137756, 0.7843455076217651, -0.19097405672073364, -0.5485126376152039, -0.7467681765556335, -0.0819701999425888, 0.08542444556951523, -0.2676791846752167, 0.15052102506160736, 0.5135481953620911, -0.21180760860443115, 0.7667122483253479, -0.836189866065979, -0.20226135849952698, -0.20163258910179138, -0.3481375277042389, 0.07505139708518982, -0.3541886806488037, -0.4358632266521454, -0.5380308032035828, -0.06476113200187683, 0.5774810910224915, 0.11019459366798401, 0.0351848341524601, -0.603011429309845, -0.278400719165802, 1.3327271938323975, -0.7875367999076843, -0.1304100900888443, -0.07988105714321136, -0.3302231431007385, 0.24233035743236542, -0.2336127609014511, -0.42141789197921753, -0.06518849730491638, 0.520512580871582, 0.3956739902496338, 0.20436140894889832, 0.6525851488113403, -0.03097904659807682, -0.5779276490211487, -0.5199165940284729, -0.9957796335220337, 0.3021688759326935, -0.08078905940055847, 0.5879035592079163, -0.30851784348487854, 0.09749425947666168, -0.3711259365081787, -0.34489721059799194, -0.1555170714855194, 0.8720213770866394, -0.4026157259941101, 0.43622025847435, 0.06938537210226059, -0.3155103325843811, -0.44314655661582947, 0.17945411801338196, 0.7980157136917114, 0.7659401297569275, 0.15052543580532074, 1.1652536392211914, -0.7506930828094482, 0.06893159449100494, -0.7861950993537903, -0.15375499427318573, 0.4008748531341553, -0.6231509447097778, 0.26855576038360596, 0.236018106341362, 0.24470657110214233, -0.6466078162193298, -0.8096992373466492, -0.4249258041381836, -0.07675113528966904, -0.07530185580253601, -0.04188257083296776, -0.41646239161491394, -0.4518240988254547, 0.6913105249404907, 0.689953625202179, 0.26979008316993713, 0.10531029850244522, -0.1389375627040863, -0.2572905123233795, 0.7220306992530823, 0.007909285835921764, -0.5520767569541931, 0.42184311151504517, 0.2273704558610916, 0.4983067214488983, 0.174646258354187, 0.3532024323940277, -0.2908207178115845, 0.2814808487892151, -0.04123048111796379, 0.8216342926025391, 0.4039454460144043, 0.4226944148540497, -0.8644384741783142, 0.40791308879852295, -0.15860700607299805, -0.8684889078140259, -0.48272547125816345, 0.5429317355155945, -0.24703779816627502, 0.7868369817733765, 0.0765748992562294, -0.4192551076412201, 0.3965491056442261, -0.14191710948944092, 0.8485847115516663, 0.3304745554924011, -1.3942502737045288, -0.012036504223942757, -0.5954478979110718, 0.35714101791381836, 0.5346065163612366, 0.7172077894210815, 0.9461204409599304, 0.5934114456176758, 0.47880101203918457, -0.2178737223148346, 0.7697578072547913, 0.007416180334985256, 0.18584707379341125, 0.1807723045349121, 0.5792824625968933, 0.5163170099258423, 0.33058980107307434, 0.4196033775806427, 0.06162634864449501, -0.8066145777702332, -0.42514657974243164, -0.679326593875885, 0.6656322479248047, -0.42200273275375366, -0.6000657081604004, 0.906169056892395, -0.32734549045562744, -0.5490127801895142, -0.09073565900325775, -0.1948695033788681, 0.4325599670410156, -0.017568908631801605, -0.18362164497375488, -0.3790138065814972, 0.027178356423974037, 0.6062374711036682, -1.020687222480774, 0.4304346442222595, 0.7450708150863647, 0.40974539518356323, -0.21412207186222076, 0.7390701174736023, 0.4794647693634033, -0.38829267024993896, 0.09087730199098587, -0.9976022839546204, -0.008557935245335102, -0.5765827298164368, 0.12145006656646729, -0.4380969703197479, 0.34886547923088074, 0.13016587495803833, -0.5650743246078491, 0.31997397541999817, -0.42025062441825867, -0.8809683322906494, -0.49778884649276733, 0.17475371062755585, -0.7963459491729736, 0.6575419902801514, 0.3036133646965027, -0.27039414644241333, -0.5448888540267944, -0.5806853175163269, 0.007732070982456207, -0.25689151883125305, -0.011261462233960629, -0.550485372543335, 0.23135793209075928, 0.11214195191860199, 0.10433965176343918, -0.36575621366500854, -0.6376214027404785, 0.31352290511131287, -0.29251936078071594, -0.6385419368743896, -0.21059143543243408, 0.08337473124265671, -0.4783758223056793, 0.2585107386112213, -0.20530229806900024, 0.5050773024559021, 0.18108214437961578, -0.4636790454387665, 0.007731691002845764, 0.8824910521507263, 0.6388891339302063, -0.9154821038246155, 0.47641003131866455, 0.09933287650346756, 0.3334488570690155, -0.7275704741477966, 0.20006167888641357, 0.5325788259506226, 0.5769316554069519, -0.756282389163971, -0.9911747574806213, 0.10491307824850082, 0.4340132772922516, -1.335325837135315, -0.31609609723091125, -0.4518370032310486, -0.1369752734899521, -0.18892478942871094, -0.8704006671905518, -0.2412107139825821, 0.35982653498649597, 0.6194417476654053, -0.8509066104888916, -0.13099808990955353, -0.7297463417053223, 0.08089091628789902, -0.4709877371788025, -0.27147531509399414, -1.1973047256469727, -0.21367523074150085, -0.4520552456378937, 1.364208459854126, -0.6174087524414062, -0.09041834622621536, -0.0659327507019043, 0.5375332832336426, 0.1898452192544937, 0.3323034644126892, -0.12725292146205902, 0.003155999816954136, 0.04161223769187927, -0.07694587111473083, 0.28938397765159607, 0.44137921929359436, -1.034325361251831, 0.0847834050655365, -0.6360942721366882, -0.22852429747581482, 0.2367437481880188, 0.05256357043981552, -0.06572157889604568, 0.16391710937023163, 0.44856658577919006, 0.1806262880563736, 0.11448777467012405, 0.7262709736824036, 0.41790884733200073, 0.5683473348617554, 0.24653762578964233, -0.2814144790172577, -0.5406906008720398, -0.2930036187171936, -0.5168499946594238, 0.31785720586776733, 0.40361306071281433, -0.08951912820339203, 0.5258046388626099, -0.5877681374549866, 0.031357988715171814, -0.09941861778497696, 0.5503212213516235, 0.4402835965156555, 0.2858363091945648, -0.3474436104297638, 0.07187678664922714, 0.2590048611164093, 0.2620071768760681, 0.36042702198028564, -0.15170694887638092, 0.1276431381702423, -0.8331533670425415, 0.12365897744894028, -0.16287410259246826, -0.8119301199913025, -0.6107528805732727, 0.5987460017204285, 0.6509538888931274, -0.6813778281211853, 1.0793710947036743, 0.3367859125137329, -1.0093621015548706, 0.53275066614151, 0.6517898440361023, 0.5791828632354736, -0.18902342021465302, 0.8484475016593933, 0.2247527837753296, 0.12448380887508392, 0.5133678913116455, 0.27997729182243347, -0.8307657241821289, -0.10534701496362686, 0.8572307229042053, -0.7606149911880493, -0.01602322980761528, -0.12794479727745056, 0.6663291454315186, -0.8911128640174866, 0.05660048499703407, -0.31433865427970886, -0.16381746530532837, 0.13331197202205658, -0.8273026943206787, 0.47900936007499695, -0.7356807589530945, -0.2566792964935303, 0.27380603551864624, 0.5128248929977417, 0.4757092595100403, 0.6143015027046204, 0.13125258684158325, 0.02907264046370983, -0.439197301864624, -0.027811814099550247, 1.4558993577957153, -0.020493295043706894, -0.4340437948703766, -0.5237197875976562, -0.6224625110626221, -0.5014106631278992, -0.4161790609359741, 0.8303433656692505, -0.21056821942329407, -0.053051501512527466, -0.008427567780017853, 0.857255756855011, 0.28336071968078613, 0.2784698009490967, 0.12488152086734772, -0.027640270069241524, -1.1472113132476807, -0.022943517193198204, -0.5112022161483765, 0.011652798391878605, -0.25408080220222473, 0.5182342529296875, 0.09041110426187515, -0.4057016670703888, -0.2454635202884674, -0.7732813954353333, 0.14395976066589355, 0.045580167323350906, -0.03848734870553017, -0.24540024995803833, -0.45227864384651184, -1.0719796419143677, -0.5474656224250793, 0.4379158020019531, -0.07180672883987427, -0.13153323531150818, -0.5579978227615356, 0.45382875204086304, 0.4288925230503082, 0.2331022471189499, 0.7139990329742432, 0.05328163132071495, 0.08083368837833405, -0.22339972853660583, -0.301626056432724, -0.6897178292274475, -0.6773329973220825, 0.18414123356342316, -0.05525124445557594, 0.07129396498203278, 0.44314438104629517, 0.2085830420255661, 0.9238935708999634, 0.5168520212173462, 0.29616090655326843, -0.38662901520729065, -0.5661618113517761, -1.4173640012741089, 0.6632528901100159, -0.12926192581653595, 1.058459997177124, 0.3590523898601532, -0.26042622327804565, -0.26962608098983765, 0.39301756024360657, -0.7806254029273987, 0.8017771244049072, -0.13169944286346436, 0.08688755333423615, -0.5881263613700867, -0.4214586019515991, 0.16728954017162323, 0.588472306728363, -0.8022963404655457, -0.4676553010940552, -0.4856998026371002, -0.16903769969940186, 0.6599422097206116, -0.28818947076797485, -0.2642548084259033, 0.7624235153198242, 0.2065320909023285, 0.0921851098537445, 0.08511678129434586, 0.5671085119247437, -0.2022380232810974, 0.4170994758605957, -0.5610719919204712, 0.35589084029197693, -0.18422918021678925, -0.047615379095077515, 0.6455639004707336, 0.48145541548728943, 0.12865455448627472, -0.40650010108947754, 0.3286527991294861, -0.025605371221899986, 0.07565572112798691, 0.07521583139896393, -0.3836047053337097, 0.6128999590873718, 0.21196529269218445, -0.0035913451574742794, 0.4469788074493408, -0.0011701019247993827, -1.1706633567810059, 0.5369947552680969, -0.6029119491577148, -0.7204118967056274, 0.22600355744361877, 0.2032088190317154, -0.3494984805583954, -0.15885846316814423, -0.38691484928131104, 0.5968114137649536, -0.021858030930161476, -0.06150301545858383, 0.10383962839841843, 0.1713472604751587, -0.5068686008453369, 0.10544541478157043, -0.5298130512237549, -0.49345436692237854, -0.30091792345046997, 0.6263033747673035, -0.7782416343688965, -0.7757374048233032, -0.44792091846466064, 0.3025716245174408, -0.6697472333908081, -0.35477522015571594, -0.40211716294288635, -0.21029070019721985, -0.681993842124939, -0.3233965039253235, -0.7353348135948181, -0.546183168888092, -0.4130992889404297, 0.5494934916496277, -0.5296645760536194, 0.10811694711446762, -0.15470805764198303, 0.482118159532547, 0.648256242275238, -0.0099648367613554, -0.6439273357391357, 0.5621749758720398, 0.7933704257011414, -0.23496297001838684, 0.0954170748591423, 0.19618217647075653, 0.29733917117118835, 0.019304689019918442, -0.6349942684173584, -0.1439305990934372, 0.05021243169903755, -0.20993787050247192, 0.09569656103849411, -0.16139747202396393, 0.06401258707046509, -0.20974861085414886, 0.2077462077140808, 0.7392451167106628, -0.22547227144241333, -0.028974639251828194, 0.06511104106903076, -0.2524641454219818, -0.5874382853507996, -0.3363912105560303, 0.275727778673172, 0.14168158173561096, 0.28950101137161255, -0.016655506566166878, -0.42690861225128174, 0.046915046870708466, -0.7850100994110107, 0.2917132079601288, -0.6455253958702087, 0.06786054372787476, -0.637972891330719, 0.9235603213310242, 0.15536388754844666, -0.08195941150188446, 0.05499088764190674, -0.10247292369604111, 0.12118270248174667, -0.09548374265432358, -0.015324518084526062, 0.5787441730499268, 0.44279801845550537, 0.5336459875106812, 0.06757419556379318, 0.8503015637397766, -0.06908701360225677, 0.4290654957294464, -0.2947118878364563, -0.937076985836029, -0.21714471280574799, 0.9987592697143555, -0.7399111986160278, 0.3681539297103882, 0.2354980707168579, -1.3133705854415894, -0.022280629724264145, -0.6147556900978088, -0.32451876997947693, -0.5558985471725464, 0.7960800528526306, 0.9524579048156738, -0.3255995512008667, -0.051979780197143555, 0.7545784711837769, -0.360501229763031, 0.13351018726825714, 0.40082308650016785, 0.25123798847198486, 0.16972467303276062, 1.1808806657791138, 0.14587639272212982, 0.2392273098230362, 0.019324149936437607, 0.23071260750293732, -0.22214587032794952, 0.4258815050125122, -0.06011275202035904, -0.8910549879074097, 0.9901926517486572, -0.13255392014980316, -0.09234335273504257, 0.41757524013519287, 0.22463545203208923, -0.09157431125640869, 0.8718674778938293, 0.13324816524982452, 0.465636670589447, -0.9469544887542725, -0.014686879701912403, -0.17382891476154327, 0.5558995604515076, 0.28603383898735046, -0.38873037695884705, -0.6392813324928284, -0.7732993364334106, -0.8025974631309509, 0.028469601646065712, 0.24625451862812042, -0.23165348172187805, -0.10738774389028549, -0.6812096834182739, -0.10242021828889847, -0.01862451434135437, 0.003459970001131296, -0.19758377969264984, -0.6834269165992737, 0.7456238269805908, 0.8739410638809204, 0.2851411998271942, 0.624732494354248, -0.6530578136444092, -0.43697506189346313, 0.14950664341449738, 0.8623214960098267, 0.10181330144405365, -0.648461639881134, 1.1502728462219238, -0.013932540081441402, -0.4140108823776245, 0.45442995429039, 0.5397542715072632, -0.2880249619483948, 0.36650004982948303, 0.6878741979598999, 0.5623623728752136, 0.2583024799823761, -0.14735209941864014, 0.14691457152366638, 0.7802116870880127, -0.2682218551635742, 0.6209668517112732, -0.24178896844387054, 0.13758403062820435, -0.3604336678981781, 0.16330045461654663, -0.5294586420059204, 0.7637701630592346, 0.13725921511650085, -0.6099770665168762, 0.023348625749349594, -0.9752980470657349, 4.180602550506592, 1.0481055974960327, 0.4491331875324249, -0.033431533724069595, -0.07224960625171661, 0.31950843334198, 0.23994731903076172, -0.9957353472709656, 0.14734713733196259, -0.07884828746318817, 0.38113754987716675, -0.7096309065818787, 0.09321127086877823, -0.6626170873641968, 0.10403263568878174, 0.7780929207801819, -0.10291381925344467, -0.47874119877815247, 1.0590027570724487, -0.19277463853359222, -1.289852499961853, -0.11697492003440857, -0.46524307131767273, -0.5139378905296326, 0.27337995171546936, 0.10807628929615021, 0.3859955370426178, -0.7370659112930298, -0.15291577577590942, -0.07695800811052322, -0.6328323483467102, -0.5815827250480652, 0.7260284423828125, -0.45891013741493225, -0.5302712321281433, 0.6436637043952942, -0.3787184953689575, -0.35421088337898254, 0.01573258452117443, 0.11301568895578384, -0.04640166461467743, -0.29533833265304565, 0.5515196919441223, -0.17712785303592682, 0.15821842849254608, 1.4492642879486084, 0.8340027332305908, -0.7819526195526123, 0.8437550663948059, -0.7398290634155273, 0.662385880947113, -0.22228309512138367, 0.008100984618067741, -0.0068318210542202, -1.215728759765625, -0.06399207562208176, 0.6849585771560669, 0.01042893435806036, 0.4188128709793091, 0.037459805607795715, 0.06953500211238861, -0.35218575596809387, -0.2293570637702942, 0.2107449173927307, -1.0946688652038574, 0.6040140390396118, 0.4765961170196533, 0.49453219771385193, -0.5376151204109192, -0.3182538151741028, -0.3890225887298584, -0.5284407138824463, -0.15396293997764587, 0.5161025524139404, -0.1851356327533722, 0.10431713610887527, -0.5862300395965576, 0.22900205850601196, -0.3096371591091156, -0.09322142601013184, 0.20895732939243317, -0.1935357004404068, -0.33338722586631775, 0.1932925432920456, 0.6656808257102966, 0.2895176112651825, -0.30031710863113403, -0.7956241965293884, -0.5719943046569824, 0.44739460945129395, 0.00007699053094256669, -0.1149556040763855, -0.13113221526145935, -0.9966504573822021, -0.42307987809181213 ]
The Radial Structure of the Galactic Disc
Three colour photometry on CCD frames in the Special Area SpA23 provides a deep probe of the galactic disc in a low absorption window towards the anticenter. Magnitudes to better than 10% at V = 25 and B-V colour down to V = 23 have been obtained. These new data, used in combination with lower magnitude photographic data in a wider field, give a strong evidence that the galactic density scale length is rather short (2.5 kpc) and drops abruptly beyond 6 kpc.
Annie C. Robin, Michel Creze, Vijay Mohan
astro-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209001
astro-ph/9209002
[ -0.09631010890007019, 0.8936182856559753, 0.27837076783180237, -0.1879701018333435, -0.054266076534986496, -0.28980135917663574, -0.6849755644798279, -0.33392077684402466, -0.14538946747779846, 1.0555201768875122, -0.1924365907907486, 0.23313789069652557, -0.039054833352565765, -0.7346963286399841, -0.5327224731445312, 0.25152602791786194, -0.03590473532676697, -0.8220239281654358, -1.0901789665222168, 0.36003583669662476, -0.20272798836231232, -0.4601968824863434, -1.0330215692520142, -0.2098889946937561, -0.23701469600200653, 0.7415594458580017, 0.32007384300231934, 0.3709336519241333, 0.8524324297904968, 0.11198229342699051, -0.34771230816841125, -0.6348485350608826, -0.04074089601635933, -0.5352182984352112, -0.2690606415271759, 0.33744877576828003, 0.5058087706565857, -0.4633122980594635, 0.203793004155159, -0.37410780787467957, 0.5250676870346069, -0.012829816900193691, 0.9566843509674072, -0.3696366250514984, -0.20892155170440674, 0.10375381261110306, -0.23565198481082916, -0.15002399682998657, 0.49616071581840515, -0.21364128589630127, -0.09661547094583511, 0.172332301735878, 0.4674335718154907, -0.49783089756965637, -0.38680920004844666, -0.40831947326660156, -0.19130131602287292, 0.2048967182636261, -0.28785544633865356, -0.1619420051574707, 0.8108697533607483, 0.3496372103691101, 0.017074786126613617, -0.44263604283332825, -0.20623739063739777, 1.1956603527069092, -0.549303412437439, -0.08912110328674316, -0.3295903205871582, -0.09239005297422409, -0.2012554258108139, 0.23886515200138092, 0.23025552928447723, 0.4552677571773529, -0.890813410282135, -0.12937922775745392, 0.014875486493110657, -0.04777498543262482, -0.28019362688064575, 0.06640516221523285, -0.0409272238612175, 0.2787732183933258, 0.4773714244365692, 0.060378193855285645, 0.19940240681171417, -0.5732020139694214, 0.3470718562602997, 0.012994318269193172, -0.09017080068588257, 0.4581938683986664, -0.29304295778274536, 0.4105803072452545, -0.05269487574696541, -0.4998936951160431, 0.5036472082138062, 0.5390481948852539, -0.504716157913208, -0.09616298973560333, -0.3739907443523407, 0.3694579303264618, 0.23147618770599365, 0.7481130361557007, -0.6750317811965942, 0.3444649577140808, -0.49482032656669617, 0.47999516129493713, 0.21189334988594055, -0.4524642527103424, 0.00780445383861661, -1.2648417949676514, 0.38146042823791504, 0.15595772862434387, 0.2219415158033371, -0.2651260197162628, 0.5251959562301636, 0.37288060784339905, -0.2829990088939667, 0.5590353012084961, -0.35492074489593506, -0.14094582200050354, 0.024022407829761505, 0.5602014660835266, -0.0023303930647671223, 0.27362489700317383, -0.02707638032734394, -0.20510627329349518, -0.29868683218955994, 0.1615602672100067, -0.55583256483078, -0.1457677185535431, -0.024163147434592247, -0.6478475332260132, -0.36509934067726135, 1.2668269872665405, 0.4229382872581482, 0.14594656229019165, 0.9188467264175415, 0.5245916843414307, 0.24134400486946106, -0.5236889719963074, 0.34690457582473755, -0.43556147813796997, 0.3103315532207489, 1.5472413301467896, -0.5507743954658508, 0.36675459146499634, -0.15828491747379303, -0.5802899599075317, -0.2840717136859894, 0.25243860483169556, -0.20580504834651947, -0.6882029175758362, -0.06586188822984695, 0.33718568086624146, -0.5243047475814819, 0.3592824637889862, -0.7439275979995728, 0.08303587138652802, -0.1320999562740326, -0.35088810324668884, 0.4603412449359894, -0.2972305119037628, 0.3773225247859955, 0.3805335462093353, -0.1299329400062561, 0.06386978179216385, -0.8828019499778748, -0.749451756477356, 0.25512728095054626, -0.1392303854227066, 0.30606135725975037, 0.12542039155960083, 0.41400179266929626, 0.6151409149169922, 0.7254018187522888, 0.24622507393360138, -0.16940778493881226, -0.2447989583015442, -0.33255496621131897, 0.4469325542449951, -0.15415877103805542, 0.03513350337743759, 0.08200075477361679, -0.007034847512841225, 0.5955871939659119, 0.22841109335422516, -0.05693140998482704, -0.432456910610199, -0.022892523556947708, -0.1410408914089203, 0.12455391138792038, 0.33562910556793213, -0.5630192160606384, 0.6363299489021301, -0.7668285965919495, 0.24793101847171783, -0.1868899017572403, -0.8019696474075317, 0.3924259543418884, -0.39604318141937256, 0.4284922182559967, 0.3698059320449829, -0.0687451958656311, 0.5738900899887085, -0.05628277733922005, -0.25709667801856995, 0.8347368836402893, 0.6969479918479919, -0.10084813833236694, -0.061011601239442825, 0.6223288774490356, 0.2310512363910675, 0.4163798689842224, -0.11291251331567764, 0.8732662796974182, -0.3396161198616028, -0.23723773658275604, 0.133511483669281, -0.4997223913669586, 0.1517244279384613, 0.5367255210876465, 0.43002626299858093, -0.03125116974115372, 1.1262774467468262, -0.5681862831115723, -0.5997232794761658, -0.3952920138835907, 0.6554094552993774, 0.35179296135902405, 0.29031646251678467, -0.2522779405117035, -0.2666327655315399, 0.39093029499053955, 0.41770055890083313, -0.07058750092983246, -0.6625935435295105, 0.5173859596252441, 1.0199124813079834, -0.0555357001721859, -0.24901950359344482, 0.09280579537153244, -0.10426609963178635, 0.14610177278518677, 0.3720524311065674, 0.04931257665157318, 0.13194683194160461, -0.08660420775413513, -0.7843454480171204, -0.17277799546718597, 0.11719624698162079, -0.22347880899906158, 0.9222267866134644, 0.051583144813776016, -0.5795517563819885, -0.3090221583843231, -0.5256363749504089, -0.11608124524354935, -0.7706160545349121, 0.33400994539260864, 0.08073679357767105, 0.23471765220165253, -0.09286760538816452, 0.18713261187076569, -0.07570083439350128, -0.1392926275730133, 0.6568746566772461, -1.0339016914367676, -0.15491202473640442, 0.38617831468582153, -0.6100615859031677, -0.48233357071876526, 0.4231276512145996, -0.2955706715583801, -0.04736100509762764, -0.07671643048524857, 0.15446987748146057, -0.01426000613719225, -0.22823762893676758, 0.05698440223932266, -0.04174346476793289, 0.0017438337672501802, 0.8913308382034302, -0.89455646276474, 0.46355679631233215, -0.5632909536361694, 0.6396782994270325, -0.8151267766952515, 0.15964899957180023, -0.7632115483283997, 0.22687359154224396, -0.10032150894403458, 0.07812163978815079, -0.7119877934455872, -0.3463882803916931, 0.10551846027374268, -0.014730497263371944, -0.348991334438324, -0.03806489333510399, 0.5457894802093506, -0.37961897253990173, 0.6372870206832886, -0.2783762812614441, -0.9949936270713806, -1.2257417440414429, -0.4577067792415619, 0.29222360253334045, -0.2565576732158661, -0.03073078952729702, 0.25127947330474854, -0.3859644830226898, -0.5663143992424011, -0.056314561516046524, 0.18331894278526306, -0.21088474988937378, 0.11068668216466904, 0.04575476795434952, 0.542929470539093, 0.24254679679870605, 0.8052334785461426, -0.6819326877593994, -1.0247637033462524, 0.11126717180013657, 0.35414382815361023, 0.20175927877426147, -0.12371315807104111, 0.7949935793876648, -0.016925934702157974, -0.6936289072036743, 0.22945979237556458, -0.13378214836120605, -0.01779738999903202, 0.011622272431850433, 0.22137321531772614, 0.6047406196594238, 0.4516359567642212, -0.16075800359249115, -0.7048259377479553, 0.1250179260969162, -0.11960823833942413, 0.2831985056400299, 0.45270586013793945, 0.0007970316801220179, -0.08658339828252792, 0.9538185000419617, -0.6246244311332703, -0.2825731933116913, 0.5821410417556763, -0.21247869729995728, 0.36713001132011414, -0.32067805528640747, -0.38289833068847656, -0.44838568568229675, -0.04851978272199631, 0.3722555339336395, -0.015124737285077572, 0.3288806974887848, -0.39016592502593994, -0.0463518463075161, -0.8229798674583435, -0.1211271733045578, -0.06572764366865158, -0.08179094642400742, 0.1626073718070984, -0.3994027376174927, 0.1528754085302353, -0.20102724432945251, 0.382875919342041, 0.23445402085781097, 0.13518287241458893, -1.1429123878479004, 0.4588036835193634, 0.3660743534564972, -0.8285510540008545, -0.7180049419403076, 0.33358392119407654, 0.11332432180643082, 0.6175480484962463, 0.24791410565376282, 1.0031310319900513, 0.3938562572002411, 0.11878324300050735, -0.12470948696136475, 0.5411801338195801, -0.0575479194521904, -0.24791547656059265, 0.09224768728017807, 0.3129202425479889, 0.45748189091682434, -0.26424142718315125, -0.71611487865448, -0.39826157689094543, -0.8213611245155334, 0.28088805079460144, -0.6542971134185791, -0.8918294906616211, 0.07671172171831131, 1.0919075012207031, 0.11410912126302719, 0.18427777290344238, 0.0014587714103981853, -0.012767819687724113, -0.48732197284698486, 0.4295165240764618, -0.3237513601779938, -0.5904985666275024, 0.705500066280365, -0.005439593456685543, 0.24080637097358704, 0.3004322946071625, 0.10539949685335159, -0.05351626127958298, -0.04042195528745651, 0.15727752447128296, 0.5877058506011963, 0.0012394373770803213, 0.1394418179988861, 0.052679240703582764, 0.2872958481311798, 0.4382440149784088, -0.172048881649971, -1.0296931266784668, 0.605627179145813, 0.5113508701324463, 0.9529774785041809, -0.06040780618786812, -0.5120378136634827, -0.0875283032655716, -0.8461382389068604, -0.002826703479513526, -0.20827090740203857, -0.39745786786079407, 0.3833775520324707, -0.28600361943244934, 0.4919430613517761, -0.061520952731370926, 0.2762354612350464, 0.1940256506204605, 0.04153185337781906, 0.287490576505661, -0.169600248336792, 0.31126922369003296, 0.6253681182861328, 0.027248648926615715, 0.06807854771614075, 0.1222480908036232, -0.13254891335964203, 0.31836140155792236, -0.05525447055697441, -0.22827468812465668, -0.704757571220398, -0.1114405021071434, -0.5834528207778931, 1.0561219453811646, -0.26681143045425415, -0.46448561549186707, 1.011586308479309, -0.5129644870758057, 0.013931307010352612, 0.351276159286499, -0.11189445108175278, -0.011759010143578053, 0.24585022032260895, -0.43086910247802734, -0.24498802423477173, -0.6166552305221558, -0.21577732264995575, 0.07884634286165237, 0.6729779839515686, 0.36133745312690735, -0.09923867136240005, 0.21854820847511292, 0.5427159667015076, 0.22325614094734192, -0.08137965202331543, -0.2005832940340042, -0.5920655727386475, -0.15209375321865082, -0.07951284199953079, -0.39365747570991516, -0.0571528859436512, 0.07889223843812943, 0.36678382754325867, -0.09262936562299728, 0.3986701965332031, -0.16781315207481384, -0.0483565554022789, 0.12987947463989258, 0.30135592818260193, -0.5552237033843994, 0.7629892826080322, 0.2303643673658371, -1.001889705657959, -0.5947069525718689, -0.4538326561450958, -0.142725870013237, -0.6504542827606201, 0.40241768956184387, -0.6557385921478271, 0.2364271879196167, -0.4166514575481415, -0.34004297852516174, 0.31167012453079224, -0.4010108709335327, 0.07419515401124954, -0.6594961881637573, -0.5488597750663757, -0.47883516550064087, -0.26076123118400574, -0.5881627202033997, 0.1629725843667984, -0.4338441789150238, 0.4406169354915619, -0.5118711590766907, 0.07579967379570007, -0.2373824268579483, 0.6304069757461548, 0.09816688299179077, -0.4111245274543762, 0.4005299508571625, -0.1449962556362152, 0.4482000470161438, -0.6291317343711853, -0.4126962125301361, 0.6432604789733887, 0.21130570769309998, 0.10058396309614182, -0.8114981651306152, -1.035300850868225, 0.05673004314303398, -1.1785602569580078, 0.1338883340358734, -0.8469377160072327, 0.3354343771934509, 0.2228020429611206, -1.1569089889526367, 0.4491859972476959, -0.0504295751452446, 0.19121891260147095, -1.1158740520477295, -0.21446996927261353, -0.22772516310214996, 0.10992784798145294, -0.2582190930843353, -0.2922740578651428, -0.43389892578125, 0.28705283999443054, 0.00928779412060976, 0.6884719133377075, -0.03867310658097267, 0.4706815779209137, -0.09773170948028564, 0.13477876782417297, -0.4200094938278198, 0.34708330035209656, -0.005767057649791241, 0.008394916541874409, -0.06629468500614166, 0.24237407743930817, -0.11711331456899643, 0.6982086300849915, -0.6268571019172668, 0.40549880266189575, -1.1991305351257324, -0.4136717617511749, 0.08649177104234695, -0.26167193055152893, -0.23065069317817688, -0.2247346043586731, 0.4205319881439209, -0.6542588472366333, 0.07894786447286606, 1.058692216873169, 0.07992495596408844, 0.1957133263349533, 0.9011192321777344, -0.316108763217926, -0.2949043810367584, -0.7231768369674683, -0.2332831472158432, 0.5640608668327332, 0.25847846269607544, -0.17790040373802185, -0.0009866035543382168, -0.01288056094199419, -0.06113285943865776, -0.40237367153167725, 0.608325719833374, 0.5803125500679016, 0.18919362127780914, 0.8536328673362732, 0.28200697898864746, 0.3752541244029999, 0.32799893617630005, 0.48264217376708984, 0.2023162543773651, -0.09036017209291458, -0.7116932272911072, -0.02748023346066475, -0.12253455817699432, -0.2897409498691559, -0.1835298389196396, 0.007053274195641279, 0.18559299409389496, -0.5921639800071716, 0.9278815984725952, -0.5005394220352173, -0.2787546217441559, 0.17922678589820862, 0.44410157203674316, 1.0861581563949585, -0.06527477502822876, 0.2948687970638275, -0.023208806291222572, 0.054997894912958145, 0.830007791519165, -0.4909937083721161, -0.42770490050315857, -0.10847475379705429, 0.40760013461112976, -0.5378108024597168, -0.23186799883842468, 0.4787861108779907, 0.7501177787780762, -0.3368525505065918, -0.3134264051914215, -0.6473846435546875, -0.289034903049469, 0.021307731047272682, -0.12296278029680252, -0.4742277264595032, -0.46035003662109375, -0.5858665704727173, 0.09060695767402649, 0.28158971667289734, 0.17142146825790405, 0.1921096295118332, 0.2016783207654953, -0.010050012730062008, -0.2398282140493393, 0.33898046612739563, 1.0792038440704346, 0.05454127490520477, 0.011240828782320023, -0.3931536376476288, -0.38655176758766174, -0.6532129049301147, -0.18728287518024445, 0.9124886393547058, 0.05844050645828247, 0.07706515491008759, -0.19158008694648743, 0.12659716606140137, 0.7355439066886902, 0.33417072892189026, 0.24625860154628754, 0.14924758672714233, -0.6833162903785706, -0.25995978713035583, -0.4751313328742981, -0.21306747198104858, -0.042568836361169815, 0.5396741032600403, 0.5402129292488098, -0.3073869049549103, -0.5324558615684509, -0.8562715649604797, 0.1702846735715866, -0.2568320333957672, -0.859529972076416, -0.3205224871635437, -0.8306278586387634, -0.6177629232406616, -0.6351832151412964, 0.5045552849769592, 0.5214052796363831, -0.09456780552864075, -0.10495797544717789, 0.16146939992904663, 0.1573987603187561, 0.41136476397514343, 0.29254692792892456, 0.01090364158153534, 0.09181448817253113, -0.4994903802871704, -0.6870726943016052, 0.02092236652970314, -0.9267731308937073, 0.07956226170063019, -0.2888731360435486, 0.07149489223957062, 0.634395182132721, -0.21746444702148438, 0.6451275944709778, -0.30170321464538574, -0.3441917896270752, 0.042188625782728195, -0.6087542772293091, -0.690780758857727, 0.6898268461227417, -0.36616358160972595, 1.0983359813690186, 0.22660912573337555, -0.32005470991134644, 0.2978375256061554, 0.1575273871421814, -0.7874784469604492, 0.8116856217384338, -0.13108007609844208, 0.5692274570465088, -0.394173800945282, -0.4361744225025177, -0.023827215656638145, 1.0057140588760376, -0.5691127181053162, -0.47467342019081116, 0.03350444138050079, 0.6259788870811462, 0.15079158544540405, -0.23790748417377472, -0.11794403940439224, 0.9365884065628052, 0.03304382041096687, 0.1974930614233017, -0.5671027302742004, 0.11368755251169205, -0.018963491544127464, 0.9937441349029541, -0.09731792658567429, -0.219534233212471, 0.09831609576940536, -0.7518061399459839, 0.1992221474647522, 0.6359150409698486, -0.17396587133407593, -0.1002604067325592, -0.009859796613454819, -0.0631190836429596, -0.5348278284072876, 0.25706496834754944, -0.7205666303634644, 0.32329073548316956, 0.5049153566360474, 0.5761111378669739, 0.20838290452957153, -0.040669940412044525, -0.8706357479095459, 0.3635638952255249, -0.1379612535238266, -0.2870863080024719, -0.3106233477592468, -0.5589720010757446, 0.16940288245677948, 0.3146715760231018, 0.4441482722759247, 0.10338233411312103, 0.09512779861688614, 0.5180954933166504, 1.2659800052642822, -0.43352723121643066, -0.6717485785484314, 0.5552496910095215, -0.6913852095603943, 0.24204890429973602, -0.2880128026008606, 0.33546924591064453, -1.0042625665664673, -0.4725399911403656, 0.2489352822303772, 0.13608667254447937, -0.39868515729904175, 0.11179641634225845, -0.245055690407753, 0.30361926555633545, -0.3595408797264099, 0.06079651042819023, -1.592430830001831, 0.020565075799822807, -0.4018855392932892, 0.2515629827976227, -0.34794196486473083, 0.4021322727203369, -0.04428189620375633, 0.08040380477905273, 0.7478329539299011, -0.1453094780445099, -0.8675429821014404, 0.4133213460445404, 0.5766841173171997, -0.18867281079292297, -0.3391120731830597, 0.49056991934776306, 0.23075109720230103, 0.2814849019050598, -0.8119519352912903, -0.4504176378250122, 0.1723237931728363, -0.29693087935447693, 0.27315959334373474, 0.09480413049459457, 0.7307654023170471, -0.08541102707386017, -0.17294485867023468, 0.24786894023418427, 0.22181080281734467, -0.08147812634706497, -0.022756727412343025, -0.020480722188949585, 0.13894931972026825, 0.2589687705039978, -0.1409054696559906, 0.0005421589012257755, 0.33561646938323975, 0.2545323669910431, 0.05486880987882614, -0.4245899021625519, -0.10856806486845016, -0.321950227022171, -0.7234315276145935, -1.097791075706482, -0.4771192669868469, -0.46903589367866516, 0.5170297622680664, 0.04851141571998596, 0.4513777494430542, 0.19941268861293793, 0.09489841759204865, 0.1352338045835495, -0.1285664290189743, 1.2160197496414185, 0.2350054383277893, 0.36868757009506226, 0.1823856085538864, 0.1950831562280655, 0.05015542730689049, 0.8620904088020325, -0.16284321248531342, -0.5276302695274353, -0.13806596398353577, 0.07845468074083328, -0.7203009128570557, 0.34075090289115906, 0.3400613069534302, -0.23102109134197235, -0.5184630751609802, -0.7318775653839111, 0.16740986704826355, -0.5931251049041748, 0.5317662358283997, 0.8676404356956482, -0.30288946628570557, 0.31322377920150757, 0.24794453382492065, 0.46405890583992004, 0.010766854509711266, 0.6387187242507935, 0.2574872672557831, -0.4498170018196106, 0.7780677676200867, 0.05660535767674446, 0.05162632465362549, -0.11073782294988632, -0.5210641026496887, -0.3858341574668884, -0.18206919729709625, 0.4842321276664734, -0.5182785987854004, 0.4760982096195221, -0.2736377418041229, 0.22556228935718536, -0.23818731307983398, 0.031826090067625046, -0.644493043422699, 0.09392157942056656, 0.3317297697067261, -0.12256889045238495, -0.29710906744003296, -0.5739547610282898, -0.12481770664453506, 0.4623207747936249, 0.17524555325508118, -0.2785237431526184, 0.07477636635303497, -0.6861456632614136, -0.5690300464630127, -0.7245494723320007, 0.018415190279483795, -0.2706506848335266, -0.2635083794593811, -0.08973558247089386, -0.09826710820198059, 0.17190608382225037, -0.2114562690258026, -0.6672350168228149, -0.3210337460041046, 0.2890341579914093, 0.35935789346694946, 0.6436460018157959, 0.20257462561130524, -0.74845951795578, -0.6703042387962341, 0.21771728992462158, 0.4821304976940155, -0.04721951112151146, -0.34535539150238037, 0.4156874716281891, 0.5912677645683289, -0.528118908405304, -0.30973097681999207, 0.48816126585006714, -0.2674214839935303, 0.2225770801305771, 0.2896918058395386, 0.41066330671310425, -0.057976048439741135, -0.34087812900543213, 0.6849186420440674, 0.3021858036518097, 0.3527548611164093, 0.3214041590690613, -0.03594811633229256, 0.45149466395378113, -0.6974536180496216, -0.4966260492801666, -0.42213428020477295, 0.6005496382713318, 0.11558008193969727, -0.12573114037513733, -0.3090428113937378, -0.7327138185501099, 4.578179836273193, 0.8789758086204529, 0.5280545353889465, -0.4860498309135437, 0.36472004652023315, 0.15295925736427307, 0.27126947045326233, -1.056807041168213, 0.37929049134254456, -0.3018110990524292, 0.2792699635028839, -0.3301517069339752, 1.3133233785629272, 0.024293359369039536, -0.015301663428544998, 0.9906122088432312, -0.3941696584224701, -0.42322149872779846, 0.35809189081192017, -0.5780230760574341, -0.48077085614204407, 0.32800471782684326, -0.519874632358551, 0.17848803102970123, 0.5135260224342346, 0.37596502900123596, 0.34122052788734436, -0.07219921052455902, -0.13367292284965515, -0.4500473737716675, -0.09618719667196274, -0.0022944507654756308, 0.43703240156173706, -0.12974438071250916, -0.3921287953853607, 0.8417889475822449, 0.16903454065322876, -0.6262826919555664, 0.21218368411064148, -0.16280333697795868, -0.19989386200904846, -0.9643468260765076, -0.0639638677239418, -0.30884453654289246, 0.13472667336463928, 0.8918691873550415, 0.8364062905311584, 0.6264948844909668, 0.7689242362976074, -0.9326391816139221, -0.07017912715673447, -0.14488430321216583, 0.1893812119960785, -0.17925867438316345, -0.6829787492752075, 0.27294033765792847, 0.3132910132408142, -0.3103814125061035, 0.09407060593366623, 0.06731269508600235, 0.9436315894126892, -0.3728591799736023, -0.33287620544433594, 0.5788702368736267, -0.5916475653648376, 1.2634774446487427, 0.02661486715078354, 0.4076869785785675, -0.6644127368927002, -0.21476151049137115, -0.39597582817077637, -0.9723714590072632, -0.2917727530002594, 0.06646449863910675, 0.5898054838180542, 0.2334262728691101, 0.13905198872089386, -0.48842400312423706, -0.35352981090545654, -0.19491824507713318, 0.2535091042518616, 0.1798376888036728, -0.8026334643363953, 0.40485307574272156, -0.6388939023017883, 0.3334089517593384, 0.4771282374858856, -0.4298970401287079, 0.15131418406963348, 0.7123621702194214, 0.5660185813903809, 0.3991064727306366, -0.5012869238853455, -0.5075432658195496, -0.13694237172603607 ]
Extended Hot Gas Halos Around Starburst Galaxies
Reanalysis of Einstein IPC data and new observations from the GINGA LAC indicate the presence of extended X-ray emission (10-50 kpc) around the starburst galaxy M82. Here we model this emission by calculating numerical hydrodynamic simulations of the starburst event to much later times and larger scales than previously considered. For our models, we adopt a supernova rate of 0.1 ${\rm yr}^{-1}$, and an extended low-density static halo that is bound to the galaxy. There are three stages to the evolution of the wind-blown bubble and the propagation of the shock front: the bubble expands in an almost uniform density disk gas, with a deceleration of the shock front ($t \alt $ 3.6 Myr); breakout from the disk and the upward acceleration of the shock front (3.6 Myr $\alt t \alt$ 18 Myr); propagation into the halo, leading to a more spherical system and shock deceleration (18 Myr $\alt t$). For a halo density of $10^{-3} {\rm cm}^{-3}$, the outflow reaches a distance of 40-50 kpc from the center of the starburst galaxy in 50 Myr. We calculate the time evolution of the X-ray luminosity and find that the extended starburst emits $3\times 10^{39}\lcgs$ to $10^{40}\lcgs$ in the GINGA LAC band and $\sim 10^{41}\lcgs$ in the Einstein or ROSAT HRI band. The degree of the ionization equilibrium in the outflow and its effect on the iron K$\alpha$ line emission are discussed.
Kohji Tomisaka and Joel N. Bregman
astro-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209002
astro-ph/9209003
[ 0.3803878128528595, 0.6314870715141296, 0.649837076663971, -0.14102789759635925, -0.3892138600349426, 0.14319725334644318, -0.4024654030799866, -0.44791179895401, -0.4318922162055969, 1.5598093271255493, 0.3932746946811676, -0.543123185634613, 0.0737818032503128, -0.986187756061554, -0.5166225433349609, 0.23705793917179108, 0.0066922991536557674, -0.6372551321983337, -1.3994601964950562, 0.24273432791233063, -0.5866836309432983, 0.23311693966388702, -1.4448028802871704, -1.039829134941101, -0.7031553387641907, 0.5763596892356873, 0.35512083768844604, 0.36966705322265625, 1.0760598182678223, 0.7460856437683105, 0.2471662163734436, -0.4479980766773224, -0.011500515975058079, -0.699039101600647, -0.6660894751548767, 0.03589785844087601, 0.4169730544090271, -0.08711233735084534, 0.4807465374469757, -0.4048813283443451, 1.0204136371612549, -0.3330783247947693, 0.3485809862613678, -0.5485444664955139, -0.17704133689403534, 0.24228498339653015, -0.38960516452789307, -0.3414609730243683, 0.10805869847536087, -1.2138664722442627, -0.00971951987594366, -0.04453922435641289, -0.0483408160507679, -1.0260545015335083, 0.3189919888973236, -0.17903360724449158, 0.05195941776037216, -0.20364147424697876, 0.3202171325683594, 0.0959397479891777, 0.3317931890487671, 0.3381423354148865, 0.75990229845047, -0.2523333430290222, -0.608257532119751, 1.3500422239303589, -0.24120007455348969, 0.384101927280426, 0.17415402829647064, -0.0049672494642436504, -0.17910003662109375, -0.2995830178260803, -0.8762289881706238, 0.7074587941169739, -0.14890465140342712, 0.20271359384059906, -0.11835698038339615, 0.13916952908039093, -0.4877076745033264, -0.4181213676929474, 0.21689820289611816, -0.026968345046043396, 0.23364441096782684, 0.6869267225265503, 0.5596218705177307, -0.5322858691215515, 0.45550739765167236, 0.379125714302063, 0.028270110487937927, 0.7911035418510437, -0.3600807785987854, 0.6941184401512146, -0.4436054527759552, -0.10445865988731384, 0.7583363652229309, 0.35784655809402466, 0.15930575132369995, 0.5159623026847839, 0.21113215386867523, 0.07885365933179855, 0.2608794867992401, 0.6553451418876648, -0.5506515502929688, 0.002906074048951268, -0.33614882826805115, 1.2037309408187866, -0.17168791592121124, 0.6334608197212219, -0.11314249038696289, -0.6941133141517639, -0.16129161417484283, -0.5151021480560303, 0.1543695330619812, -0.02120722457766533, 0.1948070377111435, 0.4321865439414978, -0.5306182503700256, 0.07607263326644897, -0.4445798099040985, -0.8582627773284912, -0.057554516941308975, 0.8216300010681152, -0.15976721048355103, 0.028675707057118416, -0.24734407663345337, -0.04572611674666405, -0.3244209885597229, 0.3757753372192383, -0.7799271941184998, 0.0592157281935215, -0.3587929904460907, -0.5399571657180786, -0.7280304431915283, 0.7002187371253967, -0.07986446470022202, -0.46643778681755066, 0.8337817788124084, 0.4194319248199463, -0.2890544533729553, -0.6241502165794373, -0.309446781873703, -0.2949960231781006, -0.21870364248752594, 1.13811457157135, -1.2888623476028442, 0.047006942331790924, -0.5020080804824829, -0.17063869535923004, -0.47260019183158875, 0.01099247857928276, -0.21563883125782013, 0.3177928626537323, 0.31663960218429565, 0.6348395943641663, -0.7076288461685181, -0.26248347759246826, -1.0370807647705078, 0.3735477924346924, 0.09954266250133514, -0.8370855450630188, 0.2502211332321167, -0.6700475215911865, -0.28796958923339844, 0.38385632634162903, -1.1492985486984253, 0.2558806240558624, -0.5337529182434082, -0.36386820673942566, 0.1967395395040512, -0.24850201606750488, -0.5442613959312439, 0.715671181678772, -0.7639495730400085, 0.2556944489479065, 0.888496994972229, 0.3167321979999542, 0.22400310635566711, -0.5511373281478882, -0.18973536789417267, 0.020208293572068214, -0.15438468754291534, 0.02404814586043358, -0.2438635230064392, 0.1974126398563385, -0.4674207270145416, 0.06431135535240173, -0.5234871506690979, -0.4262429475784302, 0.3796813189983368, -0.02854434959590435, -0.25322338938713074, 0.826839029788971, -0.6790961027145386, 0.8951420187950134, -0.8695551753044128, -0.2324945032596588, -0.6055054068565369, 0.11623574048280716, 0.534802258014679, -0.49592387676239014, 0.29313328862190247, -0.07405151426792145, -0.6891435980796814, 0.8188194632530212, -0.5650430917739868, 0.21676354110240936, 0.5860196352005005, 0.8837494254112244, -1.1371582746505737, 0.1990337073802948, 0.5032203793525696, 0.020945023745298386, 0.2402341365814209, -0.6300881505012512, 0.3108561635017395, -0.27092432975769043, -0.3682844936847687, -0.22669465839862823, -0.07908905297517776, -0.7636123895645142, 0.5186486840248108, -0.06225624680519104, -0.06507919728755951, 0.7259626388549805, -0.24097707867622375, -0.5431118011474609, 0.5835986733436584, 0.4233192801475525, -0.6653902530670166, 0.2796267569065094, -0.33900266885757446, 0.22711597383022308, -0.013684925623238087, 0.11127078533172607, -0.12478266656398773, -0.43076300621032715, 1.231513261795044, 0.6816909909248352, -0.5999216437339783, 0.2198043316602707, -0.22286632657051086, 0.18279880285263062, 0.20212960243225098, 0.09024228155612946, -0.7443791627883911, 0.8311161398887634, 0.1099465936422348, -0.4754469692707062, -0.5310873985290527, 0.8684065937995911, -0.04814189672470093, 0.336683064699173, 0.36758679151535034, 0.2866416275501251, -0.8995116949081421, -0.4671490490436554, -0.3338111937046051, 0.5866077542304993, 0.1225731372833252, -0.4310939908027649, -0.30676937103271484, -0.03168542683124542, 0.1377868503332138, 0.024216704070568085, -0.2482777237892151, 0.08000574260950089, -0.4140421450138092, 0.36118894815444946, 0.12549348175525665, -0.4250732660293579, -0.7354395985603333, -0.143064945936203, -0.38209596276283264, 0.06292813271284103, -0.37957051396369934, -0.1709049940109253, -0.28787317872047424, -0.6045987010002136, 0.2542088031768799, 0.1265469640493393, -0.6336351037025452, 0.9720823764801025, 0.19631917774677277, -0.1985999494791031, -0.18252752721309662, 0.25290700793266296, -0.711535632610321, 0.379652202129364, -0.5826030373573303, 0.1277438849210739, -0.183147594332695, -0.07742255181074142, -0.9748861193656921, 0.2747741639614105, 0.4680454730987549, 1.2313024997711182, -0.22372932732105255, 0.1628503054380417, 0.5683531761169434, -0.36157408356666565, 0.08683858811855316, 0.06939547508955002, -0.70479416847229, -0.730681836605072, -0.7027401924133301, 0.33937928080558777, -0.30696654319763184, -0.20248931646347046, 0.24432508647441864, -0.20246046781539917, -0.36322730779647827, 0.6296322345733643, -0.18874122202396393, 0.6909653544425964, -0.03454931825399399, 0.03217119723558426, 0.4115179181098938, -0.1091236025094986, 0.6256417632102966, -0.568810760974884, -0.9737576246261597, -0.34661781787872314, 0.5905742049217224, -0.1943105012178421, 0.32582852244377136, 0.9385119676589966, 0.21872422099113464, -0.6124184727668762, 0.5444995164871216, -0.5816860198974609, -0.7536509037017822, -0.013378177769482136, -0.16990971565246582, 0.6242379546165466, 0.1433563232421875, 0.1869201809167862, -0.5952851176261902, 0.06956242024898529, -0.4966391324996948, 0.4237919747829437, 0.23488138616085052, 0.30810999870300293, 0.49892106652259827, 0.5895879864692688, -0.7049263119697571, -0.34123459458351135, 1.0325294733047485, -0.5006383061408997, -0.0271823238581419, 0.34150487184524536, -0.4558314383029938, 0.21333827078342438, -0.08811099827289581, 0.5322312712669373, -0.21884961426258087, 0.6513691544532776, -0.6927357912063599, -0.03767859563231468, -0.8468824028968811, -0.3412002623081207, -0.08722443133592606, -0.18709427118301392, -0.04940878972411156, -0.32380589842796326, -0.4166909158229828, -0.23269227147102356, 0.2265874594449997, -0.7177267074584961, 0.6571102738380432, -0.6922815442085266, 0.20572243630886078, 0.22402313351631165, -0.7053177356719971, 0.1710435450077057, 0.09092670679092407, 0.40207943320274353, 0.4554711878299713, -0.03688961640000343, 0.6432587504386902, -0.5528980493545532, -0.04729347676038742, -0.7804310917854309, 0.5207248330116272, 0.7986287474632263, -0.03451089933514595, 0.6330946683883667, -0.6693758964538574, 0.3571678698062897, -0.4825949966907501, -0.026550428941845894, 0.02329248934984207, -0.44192269444465637, 0.028832480311393738, -0.4800264835357666, -0.6837045550346375, -0.013804522342979908, 0.7693918347358704, 0.9110288023948669, -0.3493462800979614, 0.1910530924797058, -0.24539363384246826, -0.7206934094429016, -0.462179571390152, 0.2830292880535126, 0.5298640131950378, 0.4957343637943268, -0.5560211539268494, 0.5490652322769165, 0.059206582605838776, 0.039942651987075806, 0.4411409795284271, -0.24762743711471558, 0.08382181823253632, 0.2702258825302124, 0.12762591242790222, 0.8086954951286316, -0.032322727143764496, 0.527188241481781, 0.16435550153255463, 0.30677270889282227, -0.7570610642433167, 0.7271043062210083, -0.07724064588546753, 0.32978495955467224, -0.11434435099363327, -0.9248678088188171, 0.6089369654655457, -0.12930651009082794, 0.5214585661888123, 0.5804988145828247, -0.3929451107978821, -0.8913253545761108, -0.5014528632164001, 0.2709433436393738, 0.582299530506134, 0.6908593773841858, 0.6255329847335815, -0.6977553963661194, 0.4577450752258301, -0.31613144278526306, -0.16975116729736328, 0.19579380750656128, 0.09554067254066467, -0.45107004046440125, 0.04922878369688988, 0.18127617239952087, -0.4193218946456909, 0.18836455047130585, 0.2834540009498596, -0.8786037564277649, -0.5616798996925354, 0.0017464321572333574, -0.17838124930858612, -0.4416540861129761, -0.8748496174812317, 1.1916300058364868, 0.2764694094657898, -0.5023093223571777, 0.11770841479301453, -0.7453819513320923, 0.3969702124595642, 0.3590843379497528, -0.11727774888277054, -0.38851305842399597, -0.014390473254024982, 0.19386664032936096, -0.23877973854541779, 0.9076362252235413, 0.6932108998298645, 0.45033174753189087, 0.7105764150619507, -0.19056163728237152, 0.02833215706050396, -0.045157305896282196, 0.5672190189361572, -0.181934654712677, 0.34876906871795654, 0.10748652368783951, 0.31109294295310974, -0.5108521580696106, -0.10531600564718246, 0.2564496397972107, -0.5256897807121277, 0.2917071282863617, 0.16944026947021484, -1.0763134956359863, -1.0908966064453125, -0.21720950305461884, -0.41627079248428345, 1.384106159210205, -0.14250876009464264, -0.1346871256828308, 0.051028478890657425, -0.47399112582206726, 0.16741043329238892, -0.4652358293533325, 0.18595165014266968, -0.6916658878326416, -0.06724363565444946, 0.585959792137146, 0.6008368730545044, -0.029683338478207588, -0.8145633935928345, 0.6195185780525208, -0.2553498446941376, -0.6633636355400085, -0.8445377349853516, -0.08816977590322495, -0.20650216937065125, 0.20910069346427917, -0.25734809041023254, -0.524360716342926, 0.20651701092720032, 0.048980653285980225, -0.12198662757873535, 0.2923040986061096, 0.27004775404930115, -0.9372845888137817, 0.17328305542469025, 0.2593664526939392, 0.5935243964195251, -0.7683677077293396, -0.08649817109107971, 0.5244321823120117, -0.4405445456504822, 0.027012187987565994, -0.20798718929290771, -0.37388521432876587, 0.12961767613887787, -0.8574332594871521, -0.5428889393806458, -0.4245512783527374, 0.3258332312107086, 0.5700339674949646, -0.04882093518972397, 0.2576640248298645, 0.15452514588832855, 0.49379217624664307, -0.11909258365631104, -0.3816101551055908, -0.018735120072960854, 0.22649474442005157, -0.3823130130767822, 0.05449030175805092, -0.46883252263069153, 0.7151129841804504, -0.5506726503372192, 1.1536391973495483, -0.5282882452011108, -0.5623690485954285, -0.4787989854812622, 0.2527059018611908, -0.007451576646417379, 0.7194104790687561, -0.3801632821559906, 0.12223149091005325, 0.039614249020814896, 0.09884731471538544, 0.5403992533683777, 0.3175554573535919, -1.1067696809768677, 0.4102158844470978, -0.13629019260406494, -0.2148241549730301, 0.05541619285941124, 0.09103697538375854, 0.7137504816055298, 0.0742877721786499, 1.0252615213394165, -0.3566352128982544, -0.15030692517757416, 1.0128507614135742, 0.32901376485824585, 0.5681946277618408, 0.6554105281829834, -0.4395201504230499, 0.1894335299730301, -0.5985749363899231, -1.2446497678756714, 0.24959829449653625, 0.09172725677490234, -0.34424957633018494, 0.29756346344947815, -0.03676866367459297, 0.21051785349845886, -0.8176741003990173, 0.3850608170032501, -0.056367579847574234, 0.021674275398254395, -0.10401837527751923, 0.3882197439670563, 0.011002594605088234, -0.13740625977516174, -0.2777050733566284, 0.6443437933921814, 0.03750698268413544, -0.054050713777542114, -0.4323362112045288, 0.3739866018295288, -0.8741111159324646, -0.6091170310974121, 0.3675249218940735, 0.5523970127105713, -0.33527836203575134, 0.8040832281112671, -0.40881749987602234, -0.06909988820552826, -0.132473424077034, -0.124241404235363, 0.5140284299850464, -0.44361791014671326, 0.8545770049095154, 0.4024565815925598, -0.18815012276172638, 0.3495512008666992, 0.06588330119848251, -0.9305280447006226, 0.0005092269857414067, 0.4292546212673187, -0.5455088019371033, -0.0703328549861908, 0.16466158628463745, 0.5312156081199646, -0.7519761919975281, -0.07795184850692749, -1.0135490894317627, 0.0169355645775795, 0.44120168685913086, -0.5818580985069275, -0.019720090553164482, -0.12968763709068298, -0.8209909200668335, 0.5450122356414795, 0.44706469774246216, 0.7016472220420837, 0.2647835910320282, -0.1086231991648674, 0.38600531220436096, -0.9372020959854126, 0.17394030094146729, 0.8430002331733704, 0.4405578076839447, -0.324375182390213, 0.2027483880519867, 0.23220211267471313, -0.011685077100992203, -0.2864617705345154, 1.2064290046691895, -0.7308528423309326, 0.535605788230896, -0.17375072836875916, 0.5081071853637695, 0.37103545665740967, 0.052972838282585144, 0.011642953380942345, 0.010154876857995987, -0.601032555103302, -0.6719403862953186, -0.435679167509079, -0.4982810318470001, 0.7174810767173767, 0.785531759262085, -0.0854649469256401, 0.15728695690631866, 0.005616077687591314, -0.5881242752075195, 0.35649269819259644, -0.2670966386795044, 0.007699801120907068, -0.5936636924743652, -0.4582500159740448, -0.4259375035762787, -0.38806143403053284, 0.3848820924758911, 0.2714293897151947, -0.05551615729928017, 0.2758623957633972, -0.4801710546016693, 0.3076742887496948, 0.11723163723945618, 0.3230826258659363, -0.014800159260630608, -0.37208083271980286, -0.37541475892066956, 0.2688627541065216, -0.07501140236854553, -0.7495818734169006, 0.16266050934791565, -0.049409445375204086, 0.2563339173793793, 0.663763701915741, -0.24510210752487183, 0.472912073135376, -0.43671587109565735, -0.44280198216438293, -0.0376705639064312, 0.05683901906013489, -0.8101764917373657, 0.8547666072845459, -1.1798620223999023, 0.8093559741973877, 0.6963985562324524, -0.04197848215699196, -0.40707024931907654, 0.39123860001564026, -1.5156068801879883, 0.44326162338256836, 0.20855025947093964, 0.4967916011810303, 0.0024293551687151194, 0.055666275322437286, -0.30898958444595337, 0.7271285057067871, -1.185994029045105, -0.06802143901586533, -0.2129250317811966, 0.48362311720848083, 0.205238476395607, 0.3091121017932892, 0.246297687292099, 0.8659442663192749, -0.5193886160850525, 0.6732624769210815, -0.6976549029350281, 0.5514363050460815, -0.08984965831041336, 0.7367832660675049, -0.023477060720324516, -0.48183515667915344, 0.4806464612483978, -1.1125824451446533, 0.8398499488830566, 0.4754081666469574, 0.05183708667755127, -0.5457744002342224, 0.1595369577407837, -0.016039101406931877, -0.45798319578170776, 0.20422561466693878, -0.2296595424413681, 0.9670683145523071, -0.1199120357632637, 0.4197823107242584, 0.19993384182453156, 0.19328761100769043, -0.3531759977340698, 1.0198240280151367, -0.4585235118865967, -0.2228197157382965, 0.5426830053329468, -0.2768652141094208, -0.6712408065795898, -0.5798835158348083, 0.3926321268081665, -0.09676173329353333, 0.26147937774658203, 0.20810088515281677, 1.3302661180496216, 0.21337281167507172, -0.652726411819458, 0.5165224671363831, -0.5277883410453796, -0.8102982044219971, -0.39365488290786743, 0.24889379739761353, -0.9344066977500916, -0.7674636244773865, 0.002158435992896557, 0.4755665361881256, -0.31135010719299316, -0.12607885897159576, -0.32533353567123413, 0.05656016990542412, -0.525278627872467, 0.033361438661813736, -1.246690034866333, -0.1592019498348236, 0.04129503667354584, 0.5014370083808899, -0.11642894893884659, -0.43494850397109985, 0.20665279030799866, 0.3889254927635193, 0.8232793807983398, -0.055305544286966324, -0.8518814444541931, 1.1010631322860718, 0.5843406319618225, 0.020762983709573746, 0.7280069589614868, 0.10658739507198334, 0.22706949710845947, 0.9414084553718567, -0.07446479052305222, -0.06572573632001877, 0.6360712647438049, -0.1045946404337883, 0.3458298444747925, 0.15218740701675415, -0.35955649614334106, -0.00048007030272856355, 0.2096460461616516, 0.019365409389138222, 0.017033061012625694, -0.2570612132549286, 0.33321359753608704, 0.2869567275047302, -0.3889225125312805, 0.2967175245285034, -0.05183781683444977, 0.16939859092235565, 0.041146114468574524, 0.23725175857543945, 0.4135761857032776, -0.398355096578598, -0.4533805847167969, -0.018877025693655014, -0.3556899130344391, -1.134627342224121, -1.1051899194717407, 0.7765809297561646, 0.5907047986984253, -0.07240760326385498, 0.4926961064338684, 0.4163001477718353, 0.34956037998199463, 0.6076258420944214, -0.06280196458101273, 0.35178133845329285, 0.21245551109313965, 0.39172065258026123, 0.5156528949737549, 0.30559754371643066, -0.05916726216673851, 0.6324312686920166, 0.6332130432128906, -1.164263367652893, 0.5235186815261841, 0.8490781784057617, -0.4186035394668579, 0.23623433709144592, 0.1419309377670288, -0.24707774817943573, -0.07983120530843735, -0.6786888241767883, 0.09175951033830643, -0.8117190003395081, 0.08273576945066452, 0.5611963272094727, -0.4618070125579834, 0.00206180801615119, 0.18074841797351837, -0.026262102648615837, 0.33399322628974915, 0.8153573870658875, -0.01948276348412037, -0.4793175458908081, 0.9904096126556396, 0.9656983613967896, 0.3043682277202606, 0.1617816537618637, 0.08018116652965546, 0.2511090934276581, 0.34933316707611084, 0.08616135269403458, -0.8795170783996582, 0.5049660205841064, -0.4640367031097412, -0.43796512484550476, 0.2269631326198578, 0.12921808660030365, 0.20039576292037964, 0.4452705979347229, 0.4321784973144531, 0.024116192013025284, -0.18668702244758606, -0.05234142392873764, 0.6329011917114258, -0.0981907919049263, -0.4954332709312439, -0.00767882727086544, 0.7547319531440735, -0.7596004605293274, -0.10954706370830536, 0.216910257935524, 0.858826220035553, 0.08590894192457199, -0.40819019079208374, 0.040596917271614075, -0.3798469603061676, -0.586141049861908, -0.4340314269065857, -0.44046950340270996, -0.4349869191646576, 0.155641570687294, 0.8192642331123352, 0.34071624279022217, -0.2590370178222656, -0.6115681529045105, -0.2333838939666748, -0.24490803480148315, 0.9273616075515747, -0.44314131140708923, -0.03212687373161316, 0.6529040932655334, 0.20524688065052032, -0.2362544685602188, 0.9121580719947815, 0.14966115355491638, -0.05288296192884445, 0.564428985118866, -0.525715708732605, 0.06587778031826019, -0.17133955657482147, -0.7337722778320312, -0.21427501738071442, 0.5889214277267456, 0.7873836755752563, -0.2954278886318207, -0.4627683162689209, -0.03183462470769882, -0.2833998501300812, -0.13898657262325287, -0.4298265874385834, 0.5285549759864807, 0.2387397736310959, -0.3801702857017517, 0.4598761200904846, -0.575826108455658, 4.302298069000244, 0.31907784938812256, 0.742804229259491, -0.8183024525642395, 1.073467493057251, 1.0077612400054932, 0.07567227631807327, -0.6166009306907654, 0.10052918642759323, -0.730373203754425, -0.05735304579138756, -0.23446038365364075, 0.0411388985812664, 0.3843706548213959, -0.03504078462719917, 0.6647222638130188, 0.0457410030066967, -0.32590609788894653, -0.23377692699432373, 0.08695361763238907, -1.0128884315490723, 0.17593105137348175, -0.45648518204689026, 0.06096982955932617, 0.15715643763542175, 0.22907672822475433, 0.21950608491897583, -0.6456859111785889, -0.6607351899147034, -0.33042722940444946, 0.00803143996745348, -0.5936501026153564, 0.002025940455496311, -0.27745890617370605, -0.9410707354545593, 0.3436424732208252, 0.041063886135816574, -0.3602578341960907, 0.434256374835968, -0.5989543199539185, -0.2802457809448242, -0.3295113444328308, 0.11450663954019547, -0.604105532169342, -0.5231735706329346, 0.8024590015411377, 0.6938290596008301, 0.1648668795824051, 0.5724738240242004, -0.5286506414413452, 0.39294901490211487, 0.26713231205940247, 0.3045429587364197, -0.10567446053028107, -1.4857063293457031, -0.034062985330820084, 0.03217713534832001, -0.638530969619751, -0.04095761105418205, -0.5328480005264282, 0.902249813079834, -0.3433603346347809, -0.25211861729621887, 0.5124542117118835, 0.2820810079574585, 0.1582043170928955, 0.22110053896903992, 0.15454213321208954, -0.399270623922348, 0.13292798399925232, -0.344602108001709, 0.31752920150756836, -0.8294387459754944, -0.2949855625629425, -0.03499231114983559, -0.11429078131914139, 0.19132710993289948, -0.15167754888534546, -0.20506660640239716, -0.02404875122010708, -0.043784186244010925, -0.17920488119125366, -0.6995137929916382, 0.46898916363716125, 0.0061700851656496525, 0.590872585773468, -0.213021382689476, -0.05839943140745163, -0.02026514708995819, 0.15424232184886932, -0.06265351921319962, 0.47197315096855164, -0.36336955428123474, -0.0998569130897522, -0.2152050882577896 ]
The Spectral Index in the CDM Cosmogony
In a recent paper, we suggested that the density fluctuation spectra arising from power-law (or extended) inflation, which are tilted with respect to the Harrison--Zel'dovich spectrum, may provide an explanation for the excess large scale clustering seen in galaxy surveys such as the APM survey. In the light of the new results from COBE, we examine in detail here cold dark matter cosmogonies based on inflationary models predicting power-law spectra. Along with power-law and extended inflation, this class includes natural inflation. The latter is of interest because, unlike the first two, it produces a power-law spectrum without significant gravitational wave production. We examine a range of phenomena, including large angle microwave background fluctuations, clustering in the galaxy distribution, bulk peculiar velocity flows, the formation of high redshift quasars and the epoch of structure formation. Of the three models, only natural inflation seems capable of explaining the large scale clustering of optical galaxies. Such a model, though at best marginal even at present, has some advantages over standard CDM and on most grounds appears to perform at least as well. Power-law inflation's primary interest may ultimately only be in permitting a larger bias parameter than standard CDM; it appears unable to explain excess clustering. Most models of extended inflation are ruled out at a high confidence level.
David H Lyth and Andrew A Liddle
astro-ph gr-qc hep-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209003
astro-ph/9209004
[ 0.3593374490737915, 0.7359058260917664, 0.31289348006248474, -0.291331022977829, 0.2194228321313858, 0.3990117311477661, -0.2855134904384613, -0.018923688679933548, -0.3239385783672333, 1.386181116104126, 0.4535858631134033, -0.46689921617507935, -0.39644065499305725, -0.242620587348938, -0.12270227074623108, 0.07890220731496811, -0.1094091534614563, -0.25089314579963684, -1.3529208898544312, 0.3754255175590515, -0.3720143139362335, -0.23495042324066162, -0.4679603576660156, -0.3420545160770416, -0.4161687195301056, 0.14794161915779114, 0.06930199265480042, -0.2256953865289688, 0.8632065057754517, 0.727229118347168, 0.32777097821235657, -0.20932753384113312, 0.09499074518680573, -1.219225525856018, -0.0790148600935936, 0.20703719556331635, 0.2464049756526947, -0.8668374419212341, 0.20789387822151184, -0.2609240412712097, 0.8279354572296143, -0.25657016038894653, 0.27308231592178345, -0.442246675491333, -0.3395299017429352, -0.08960065245628357, 0.02361609973013401, -0.10297023504972458, -0.5126217007637024, -0.6021412014961243, 0.3071015179157257, -0.3364383280277252, 0.013220640830695629, -0.8681163787841797, 0.15340067446231842, 0.2670339047908783, 0.6176525354385376, 0.4848422408103943, -0.03348969295620918, -0.4966244399547577, 0.24955026805400848, 0.28091877698898315, 0.3247607946395874, -0.6279162764549255, 0.11600174009799957, 0.5667485594749451, 0.07426877319812775, 0.22924809157848358, 0.28419557213783264, 0.0024350332096219063, -0.4738766551017761, 0.045738592743873596, -0.20235320925712585, 0.4134220480918884, 0.16382519900798798, 0.7075989246368408, 0.22744648158550262, -0.5614771246910095, -0.637550950050354, -0.0814729705452919, 0.1907668560743332, 0.48645833134651184, -0.12016589194536209, 0.6675548553466797, -0.178671196103096, -0.42864543199539185, 0.05977332964539528, 0.3517221212387085, 0.5197013020515442, 0.7092636823654175, -0.2020971029996872, 0.7796330451965332, -0.4453238546848297, 0.3505392372608185, 0.18198491632938385, 0.5943200588226318, -0.00467192055657506, 0.2770390212535858, 0.6716591715812683, 0.3155672550201416, -0.1555301994085312, 0.9197563529014587, -0.5423058867454529, 0.13483020663261414, -0.6139079928398132, 1.421360969543457, -0.609891951084137, -0.29262131452560425, -0.057543959468603134, -0.6462367177009583, 0.14293666183948517, -0.26620495319366455, 0.5556403398513794, 0.7502903342247009, -0.16373488306999207, 0.4968600869178772, -0.2140636146068573, 0.00005703502392861992, -0.8335772156715393, -0.3811262845993042, 0.36443984508514404, 0.581387460231781, 0.4201809763908386, 0.5155945420265198, 0.011673176661133766, -0.13259251415729523, -0.5822758674621582, 0.792425811290741, -0.6553391218185425, 0.03657139092683792, -0.6643117070198059, -0.7582311630249023, 0.04971291869878769, 0.42008277773857117, 0.3510068356990814, 0.2605188488960266, 0.22112111747264862, -0.27424055337905884, -0.07063287496566772, -0.6913044452667236, 0.015992656350135803, -0.25434163212776184, -0.13992860913276672, 1.3801809549331665, -1.6947059631347656, -0.1586095690727234, 0.35901734232902527, 0.569232702255249, -0.7956277132034302, -0.05133075639605522, -0.40227657556533813, -0.17760434746742249, -0.08873751014471054, 0.5379365682601929, 0.0778491422533989, 0.05449826642870903, -0.9243667721748352, -0.7036347389221191, 0.20678745210170746, -0.5065188407897949, 0.03116345778107643, -0.3800239562988281, -0.03566354513168335, 1.2488384246826172, -0.1501765251159668, 0.3032146394252777, -0.49630221724510193, -0.2642573416233063, -0.2587742209434509, -0.9001368880271912, 0.0635019913315773, 0.18505840003490448, -0.06084445118904114, 0.40641823410987854, 0.5962870717048645, 0.7340210676193237, 0.32363107800483704, -0.2888888418674469, -0.14753358066082, 0.6740373969078064, 0.1128464937210083, -0.18586593866348267, 0.42489439249038696, 0.47896671295166016, -0.24334079027175903, -0.5307925939559937, -0.0666760504245758, 0.13091914355754852, -0.4471094310283661, -0.15683694183826447, -0.8740575909614563, 0.6980801224708557, -0.7507675290107727, 0.34837085008621216, -1.3026549816131592, 0.1614949256181717, -0.16176629066467285, -0.212812140583992, -0.06344708800315857, -0.3270493745803833, 0.26777276396751404, 0.1497126668691635, -0.960205078125, 1.062402367591858, -0.7959296107292175, -0.05015964061021805, 0.8574288487434387, 0.475564569234848, -0.7691723108291626, 0.30197688937187195, 0.34023571014404297, 0.05005781725049019, -0.15420620143413544, -0.03359123691916466, 0.11085162311792374, 0.2543507218360901, -0.06549521535634995, 0.5025427937507629, 0.5440019965171814, 0.19417418539524078, 0.4610741138458252, 0.20841656625270844, -0.07318656146526337, 0.7523596286773682, -0.3511936664581299, -0.9087536931037903, 0.5668023824691772, 0.808430016040802, 0.16619886457920074, 0.46426069736480713, -0.2285051792860031, -0.3643243610858917, 0.0708167552947998, 0.4080146849155426, -0.11791843175888062, -0.034056808799505234, 0.9483566880226135, 0.5833331942558289, -0.5349813103675842, 0.4272579848766327, 0.21500322222709656, 0.008158721029758453, -0.10984894633293152, 0.5907524228096008, -0.6635487079620361, 0.8663567304611206, 0.6122959852218628, -0.1538131982088089, -0.6734505295753479, 0.4627443253993988, -0.6148513555526733, 0.6056497097015381, 0.5269277691841125, -0.19697394967079163, -1.4132522344589233, -0.11074362695217133, 0.04331260547041893, 0.4670599102973938, -0.11116050183773041, -0.9896630048751831, -0.3344321548938751, 0.4308566153049469, -0.8522926568984985, -0.08940897136926651, 0.1177736222743988, 0.2686850428581238, 0.004552870988845825, 0.4829055964946747, 0.524547815322876, -0.4207950234413147, -0.9817545413970947, -0.2334638386964798, -0.6281511783599854, 0.03665819391608238, -0.6834221482276917, -0.6330958008766174, 0.1927185207605362, 0.11892839521169662, -0.009838294237852097, 0.4725845456123352, -0.44701647758483887, 0.23051616549491882, -0.2568722367286682, -0.26436713337898254, -0.6036586165428162, 0.22507624328136444, -1.0257362127304077, -0.10284949094057083, -0.4374682605266571, 0.6571210026741028, -0.08098186552524567, -0.8940252661705017, 0.22333943843841553, -0.06968938559293747, 0.16599002480506897, 0.19913487136363983, -0.20236656069755554, 0.9851036071777344, -0.013371715322136879, -0.6393706202507019, 0.6251578330993652, 0.08855099976062775, -0.43702432513237, -0.16397403180599213, -0.6469979882240295, 0.7055785655975342, -0.3002070486545563, -0.17778824269771576, 0.9028009176254272, -0.1319131702184677, -0.8424865007400513, 0.34111958742141724, -0.15147535502910614, 0.37715616822242737, -0.32094237208366394, 1.149569034576416, 0.7127456665039062, -0.4644414484500885, 0.7542141675949097, -0.9379104375839233, -0.48921459913253784, -0.43361085653305054, 0.459430068731308, -0.6299707889556885, 0.2651127576828003, 1.1019014120101929, 0.9827132225036621, -0.8142598271369934, 0.9389437437057495, -0.847381591796875, -1.113152027130127, 0.0723135694861412, -0.12371207773685455, 0.21405498683452606, 0.31404006481170654, 0.26145726442337036, -0.6235184073448181, -0.0945616215467453, -0.22544823586940765, 0.45674756169319153, 0.7348172068595886, -0.34136003255844116, 0.37582623958587646, 0.49875956773757935, 0.2882608473300934, -0.0433618538081646, 0.4816318452358246, -0.2783539891242981, -0.1191888302564621, 0.6549595594406128, -0.6647427082061768, 0.07339140772819519, -0.07454736530780792, 0.22780655324459076, 0.016265640035271645, 0.04563432186841965, -0.1719994992017746, 0.013327022083103657, -0.9585831165313721, -0.1420099139213562, 0.35656994581222534, -0.3746168911457062, 0.3254011571407318, -0.5035812258720398, 0.05083584412932396, 0.03308252617716789, 0.2670257091522217, -0.12361998111009598, 0.45836177468299866, -0.9599063396453857, 0.21533674001693726, 0.13272786140441895, -0.48239433765411377, -0.14529624581336975, -0.23818989098072052, 0.2871439754962921, 0.6588950157165527, 0.4691388010978699, 0.1886371672153473, -0.461171954870224, -0.2682597041130066, -0.6913948655128479, 0.5915341377258301, 0.8483721017837524, 0.13560126721858978, -0.4848266839981079, -0.0056817177683115005, -0.07003560662269592, -0.1465741991996765, -0.6522125601768494, -0.22201384603977203, -0.8689883351325989, 0.8005186319351196, -0.8026494979858398, -1.1187487840652466, 0.3896743655204773, 0.1520717442035675, 0.7604070901870728, 0.0026198981795459986, 0.039539486169815063, 0.2384687066078186, 0.06138559803366661, -0.08252060413360596, 0.8424131870269775, -0.13606035709381104, 0.16079989075660706, -0.5156201124191284, 0.7311770915985107, -0.012674171477556229, 0.14847029745578766, 0.3036728501319885, -0.4019428491592407, -0.04278632625937462, -0.38355040550231934, 0.2615596652030945, 0.37014928460121155, -0.49895167350769043, 0.8074501752853394, 0.4856719970703125, -0.13246610760688782, 0.26779428124427795, 0.4127640426158905, 0.4668746292591095, 0.8410659432411194, 0.2873004972934723, -1.0645838975906372, 0.1352584809064865, -0.9132219552993774, 0.12871648371219635, 0.49152544140815735, 0.26032403111457825, -0.823772668838501, -0.17052102088928223, 0.00003423487942200154, 0.43319666385650635, 1.1150611639022827, 1.113817811012268, 0.6913747191429138, 0.27525901794433594, -0.338916152715683, 0.02640306018292904, 0.8375990390777588, -0.15306416153907776, -0.7600644826889038, -0.4444601237773895, 0.549827516078949, -0.2626849412918091, 0.4102519452571869, -0.38612088561058044, -1.145646095275879, 0.2591511607170105, -0.47462931275367737, 0.5632739067077637, -0.20188021659851074, -1.0059516429901123, 0.16781552135944366, 0.13675281405448914, -0.4081028699874878, 0.2710467278957367, -0.20065143704414368, 0.0051287394016981125, -0.3594667613506317, -0.23289285600185394, -0.5946528315544128, -0.555737316608429, 0.5016717910766602, -0.10563205182552338, 0.7539271116256714, 0.6922964453697205, 0.15459169447422028, 0.44174662232398987, 0.10031267255544662, 0.014285143464803696, -0.07911774516105652, 0.30635589361190796, -0.33440983295440674, -0.32970955967903137, 0.22617262601852417, -0.9167029857635498, -0.24080827832221985, -0.5936853885650635, 0.5252636671066284, -0.5522087812423706, -0.1937260925769806, -0.017095498740673065, -0.9193680882453918, -0.4328226149082184, -0.5972710251808167, -0.908682107925415, 0.3216838836669922, -0.30161112546920776, -0.04251610115170479, -0.3059938848018646, -0.34365779161453247, 0.006932318676263094, -0.1894424557685852, 0.022314686328172684, -0.49225136637687683, -0.31369760632514954, 0.5613536834716797, 0.15875881910324097, 0.46216994524002075, -0.3229841887950897, 0.5801583528518677, -0.08044591546058655, -0.3504177927970886, -0.7204176783561707, -0.39055123925209045, 0.30287984013557434, 0.29175782203674316, 0.38135361671447754, -0.0031566096004098654, 0.2194671630859375, -0.21150237321853638, 0.3927580714225769, 0.7577236890792847, -0.08044975996017456, -0.6190563440322876, 0.3941882848739624, 0.0020001986995339394, 1.3492463827133179, -0.423206090927124, -0.37085700035095215, 0.6170343160629272, -0.3362690806388855, 0.48987525701522827, -0.24365897476673126, -0.37787821888923645, 0.20748168230056763, -0.7775565981864929, 0.15268360078334808, -0.4761686325073242, -0.08685356378555298, -0.10129383951425552, -0.16829462349414825, -0.16411219537258148, 0.26013338565826416, 0.8873158097267151, -0.060972537845373154, 0.046236127614974976, -0.6482211947441101, 0.8331414461135864, -0.6873931288719177, -0.017329668626189232, -0.2743537425994873, -0.2722078561782837, -0.7576802372932434, 1.659528374671936, -0.9426174163818359, -0.6012418270111084, 0.16022193431854248, 0.3006006181240082, 0.10923193395137787, 0.09164033085107803, 0.27032408118247986, -0.8307099938392639, -0.16059666872024536, 0.25050199031829834, 1.1163734197616577, 0.6039206385612488, -0.1895885020494461, 0.7744435667991638, 0.05463752895593643, 0.7389821410179138, -0.3589361906051636, 0.08449004590511322, 0.17511221766471863, 0.07124606519937515, 0.43211835622787476, -0.23197127878665924, 0.18383827805519104, 0.9750651717185974, 0.14852958917617798, 0.6478976607322693, -0.20460937917232513, 0.10178215801715851, -0.4207494258880615, -0.3886778652667999, -0.9987503886222839, 0.3093542158603668, -0.25580865144729614, -0.34671205282211304, -0.15419188141822815, -0.7330394387245178, -0.2748119533061981, -0.3305312395095825, 0.7386026978492737, 0.6887859106063843, 0.8101037740707397, 0.8062224388122559, -0.6830806136131287, 0.6793386340141296, -0.2574805021286011, 0.19001883268356323, 0.47923845052719116, -0.19596408307552338, 0.03266306221485138, -0.6487574577331543, -0.2212018370628357, -0.5499822497367859, -0.8306146860122681, 0.2353818267583847, 0.8348668217658997, -0.3735837936401367, 0.8185225129127502, -0.23426951467990875, -0.187379390001297, -0.8000624775886536, 0.20806466042995453, 0.7217914462089539, 0.06479548662900925, 0.32660752534866333, 0.26349183917045593, 0.45707494020462036, 0.4096318185329437, -0.2782330811023712, -0.8823605179786682, -0.9868119955062866, 0.690711498260498, -0.8846457004547119, -0.8367648720741272, 0.4539211392402649, 0.18044154345989227, -0.45455604791641235, -0.4551512897014618, -1.3142911195755005, 0.16075651347637177, 0.34006956219673157, -0.8144480586051941, 0.22309798002243042, 0.43007054924964905, 0.19880744814872742, 0.5602633953094482, -0.00005570148641709238, 0.3050035536289215, 0.3853064477443695, 0.3454532027244568, -0.03812211751937866, -0.9347878694534302, -0.1833641231060028, 0.681239902973175, 0.33763235807418823, -0.5356717109680176, 0.2516101002693176, -0.0825970321893692, -0.8802902698516846, -0.31320643424987793, 0.9902541041374207, -0.12264047563076019, -0.2750060558319092, -0.35758301615715027, 0.02601468749344349, 0.22375528514385223, -0.09576596319675446, -0.50218665599823, 0.5606864094734192, -0.835655152797699, -0.719856858253479, -0.0032723930198699236, 0.4501883387565613, 0.2617943286895752, 0.45173314213752747, -0.036623816937208176, -0.19469423592090607, -0.5026665329933167, -0.1824266016483307, -0.09787628054618835, -0.4558403193950653, -0.37845948338508606, -0.6857764720916748, -0.9640635251998901, -0.9942936897277832, -0.0846748873591423, -0.2249450981616974, 0.5043580532073975, 0.06901834905147552, 0.08448932319879532, 0.30539384484291077, 0.24689364433288574, 0.2771385908126831, 0.7138265371322632, -0.2903479337692261, -0.4445296823978424, -0.7177425622940063, 0.08694672584533691, -0.05552759766578674, -1.2995529174804688, -0.613639235496521, 0.25785791873931885, 0.6312254667282104, 1.165282964706421, -0.796409010887146, 0.35211825370788574, -0.6992902755737305, -0.3734329342842102, -0.028898436576128006, -0.42988818883895874, -0.9023871421813965, 1.3126262426376343, -0.728504478931427, 1.0412979125976562, 0.25211769342422485, -0.199188694357872, -0.0980822890996933, 0.5843847990036011, -0.8423165678977966, 0.5654489398002625, 0.10518597066402435, 0.8434014916419983, 0.6693654656410217, -0.6476304531097412, 0.3790067434310913, 0.31511595845222473, -0.8914557695388794, -0.34076401591300964, 0.0323835089802742, 0.5585175156593323, -0.3798160254955292, -0.20443879067897797, 0.38934898376464844, 0.5293293595314026, -0.09132248163223267, 0.5313478112220764, -0.7815749049186707, -0.19283685088157654, -0.5792708396911621, 0.22949159145355225, -0.5318639278411865, -0.39400723576545715, 0.6235730051994324, -1.1346020698547363, 0.5820717215538025, 0.5032480955123901, -0.1477205455303192, -0.1877090334892273, 0.15792939066886902, -0.3592367470264435, -0.5890486240386963, 0.03490624576807022, -0.37454894185066223, 0.6092009544372559, -0.5017306208610535, 0.08604369312524796, 0.21773554384708405, -0.961424708366394, -0.6966201663017273, 0.8040369749069214, -0.8258357048034668, -0.02144649252295494, 0.31733593344688416, -0.74751877784729, 0.5482439994812012, 0.43675607442855835, -0.6866456270217896, 0.034036245197057724, -0.03599746152758598, 0.6310626268386841, 1.182721734046936, -0.04492269828915596, -0.3731503188610077, 0.29436302185058594, -0.9556429982185364, -0.21717569231987, -0.5918169617652893, 0.32555460929870605, -1.042893648147583, -0.7291894555091858, -0.5585722923278809, -0.29857441782951355, -0.21797294914722443, 0.054154593497514725, -0.2782686650753021, 0.04349995031952858, -0.3221385180950165, -0.452462375164032, -0.18006132543087006, -0.4334932565689087, -0.40762585401535034, 0.4795181453227997, -0.010432261973619461, -0.1648242324590683, -0.135356143116951, -0.11697585880756378, 0.251021146774292, 0.17793473601341248, 0.32521864771842957, 0.5957980751991272, -0.03202575817704201, 0.01282553467899561, 0.20643004775047302, -0.2947103977203369, 0.35518619418144226, 0.5030763149261475, -1.140856385231018, 0.3788264989852905, -0.23640966415405273, 0.14947976171970367, 0.600666344165802, 0.015712745487689972, 0.22508011758327484, 0.7325445413589478, 0.4954514801502228, -0.28210675716400146, 0.24804790318012238, 0.40689367055892944, -0.08434680104255676, 0.6663309931755066, -0.23913782835006714, -0.31978535652160645, 0.01628919504582882, 0.1673080325126648, -0.001489303889684379, -0.3673705458641052, 0.042553093284368515, -0.3070521652698517, 0.3071223497390747, 0.41793498396873474, -0.437319815158844, -0.5795412063598633, -0.8168329000473022, -0.08508975058794022, 0.48455116152763367, 0.14825917780399323, 0.15392369031906128, 0.858119785785675, 0.8842576146125793, 0.1266186684370041, -0.4060017466545105, 0.3273867070674896, 0.7364727258682251, 0.8587114214897156, 0.1886611431837082, 0.5584037899971008, 0.2694788873195648, -0.2345563769340515, -0.3166370391845703, -1.1627172231674194, -0.29009512066841125, 0.19936634600162506, -1.1616426706314087, -0.3372623324394226, 0.28628841042518616, -0.6227012872695923, -0.2795489728450775, -0.614946186542511, 0.5992155075073242, -0.966320276260376, -0.32336798310279846, -0.2215377241373062, -0.3607493042945862, -0.02436872012913227, 0.558865487575531, -0.02670942433178425, 0.5889178514480591, 0.7350079417228699, 0.3568199574947357, -0.2669031322002411, 1.1599022150039673, 0.599513590335846, 0.459391325712204, -0.34605872631073, -0.11314694583415985, -0.11374147236347198, 0.09609871357679367, 0.305377334356308, -0.34894734621047974, 0.4829447567462921, -0.7383359670639038, 0.02870541252195835, -0.8436460494995117, 0.2016560435295105, -0.10784946382045746, -0.10107582062482834, 0.33663150668144226, 0.21131552755832672, -0.41334623098373413, 0.0423235222697258, 0.9815229773521423, 0.8020960688591003, 0.02319859340786934, -0.6335200667381287, 0.1959843933582306, -0.30695804953575134, -0.1964692920446396, -0.5965334177017212, 0.13728085160255432, -0.3051460385322571, -0.002531393663957715, -0.009288323111832142, -0.209313303232193, -0.3524279296398163, -0.11362169682979584, -0.21592311561107635, -0.16392116248607635, 0.5087366700172424, 0.4327188730239868, 0.4578782916069031, 0.5787184238433838, -0.19425487518310547, -0.3161219358444214, 0.20334623754024506, 1.2356599569320679, 0.029021304100751877, 0.6340169906616211, 0.5424574613571167, 0.06028495728969574, -0.9529209136962891, 0.8221829533576965, 0.7679179906845093, -0.3452252745628357, -0.05516819283366203, -0.3012653589248657, 0.17351862788200378, -0.21160173416137695, -0.425796240568161, -0.302893728017807, 0.4969983398914337, 0.5947917699813843, 0.21521775424480438, -0.48938682675361633, 0.15228308737277985, -0.5143005847930908, -0.22710582613945007, -0.13328483700752258, 0.5060235857963562, 0.6876474618911743, -0.3502122759819031, 0.12511073052883148, -0.7326152324676514, 4.200125217437744, 0.3556802570819855, 0.8339388966560364, -0.6594367027282715, 0.2949983775615692, 0.7691022753715515, -0.5880756974220276, -0.2915862798690796, -0.46676966547966003, -0.28273579478263855, 0.31109169125556946, -0.5869348645210266, -0.16372637450695038, 0.6420016884803772, -0.11244037002325058, 0.520725429058075, 0.4596284329891205, 0.6192458868026733, 0.07947076112031937, -0.7052897810935974, -0.9072750210762024, 0.6057745218276978, -0.2630908787250519, -0.3993957042694092, 0.760616660118103, 0.1990252286195755, 0.6245719194412231, -0.8086839318275452, 0.0378274992108345, -0.08447924256324768, -0.4970352351665497, -0.6044474244117737, -0.0425998754799366, -0.5194382667541504, -0.8965417146682739, 0.01899789460003376, -0.007288146298378706, -0.3217516243457794, 0.33017438650131226, -0.49887973070144653, 0.27127400040626526, -1.0973833799362183, -0.35945284366607666, -0.09975062310695648, -0.5814567804336548, 0.30465301871299744, 0.32010987401008606, 0.7934157252311707, 0.4867488145828247, -0.6013800501823425, 0.41146567463874817, 0.27027788758277893, 0.43714234232902527, -0.3145478069782257, -0.6779053211212158, -0.09912974387407303, -0.03336140885949135, 0.2124459594488144, 0.03349579870700836, -0.14600685238838196, 1.08406400680542, -0.38175755739212036, -0.2557688057422638, 0.6642457842826843, 0.4092346429824829, -0.36286619305610657, -0.14146560430526733, -0.2790379524230957, -0.17681479454040527, 0.4556148946285248, -0.633368968963623, 0.11601731926202774, 0.0012089320225641131, -0.8224813342094421, 0.4463790953159332, 0.4974173307418823, -0.06106390058994293, 0.4013717770576477, -0.3908751308917999, 0.15782944858074188, -0.8027130365371704, -0.15792150795459747, -0.2200351059436798, 0.4722398817539215, -0.13654977083206177, 0.3784567713737488, -0.45570793747901917, -0.06435368210077286, -0.10305511206388474, 0.3370404839515686, 0.4666242301464081, 1.0370365381240845, -0.18711891770362854, 0.15499845147132874, -0.6382120847702026 ]
On the Tail Problem in Cosmology
The tail problem for the propagation of a scalar field is considered in a cosmological background, taking a Robertson-Walker spacetime as a specific example. The explicit radial dependence of the general solution of the Klein-Gordon equation with nonminimal coupling is derived, and the inapplicability of the standard calculation of the reflection and transmission coefficients to the study of scattering of waves by the cosmological curvature is discussed.
Valerio Faraoni and Sebastiano Sonego
astro-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209004
astro-ph/9209005
[ 0.6943415999412537, 0.703154444694519, -0.029701076447963715, 0.08188321441411972, -0.2738129794597626, -0.7103776931762695, -0.1644953191280365, -0.03988141939043999, -1.280624270439148, 1.5136491060256958, 0.23553209006786346, 0.20582358539104462, 0.7194462418556213, -0.9732928276062012, -0.40131908655166626, -0.41242945194244385, 0.3375769853591919, -0.33945077657699585, -1.9228975772857666, -0.01529606431722641, 0.08223668485879898, -0.17641879618167877, -1.0147528648376465, -0.35584011673927307, -0.5320363640785217, 0.5351681709289551, 0.579908013343811, -0.03408016264438629, 0.900554895401001, 0.14373642206192017, 0.2426227182149887, -0.7269989252090454, 0.017389947548508644, -1.044297456741333, -0.23156288266181946, -0.004907404538244009, 0.1446196585893631, 0.05032748728990555, 0.7293550968170166, -0.41138985753059387, 1.000646948814392, -0.4585130512714386, 0.06215684115886688, -0.06567027419805527, -0.7688893675804138, 0.4575822055339813, -0.696071207523346, -0.19760039448738098, 0.33763688802719116, -0.20881040394306183, 0.32046040892601013, -0.0454382449388504, 0.44734540581703186, -0.24401605129241943, 0.39477694034576416, -0.32797059416770935, 0.3620874583721161, 0.3820141553878784, -0.3295781910419464, -0.13924238085746765, 0.5108680725097656, 0.24808549880981445, 0.7721548676490784, -0.1318528801202774, 0.07728748768568039, 0.9795910120010376, -0.24079927802085876, 0.9673693180084229, -0.663886547088623, 0.06034766882658005, -0.11674929410219193, -0.38139936327934265, -0.999580979347229, 0.1169598400592804, -0.6165698766708374, 0.4578912556171417, 0.3051091432571411, -0.3583022356033325, -0.48538923263549805, -0.1843770146369934, 0.4982047975063324, 0.3534945845603943, 0.7359845042228699, 0.22589263319969177, 0.1457878202199936, -0.33677688241004944, -0.10250601917505264, 0.02299661934375763, -0.40204986929893494, 0.18338337540626526, 0.22750243544578552, 0.8291875123977661, -0.12894347310066223, -0.23244072496891022, 0.5328122973442078, 0.3508240580558777, -0.5863395929336548, 0.07330088317394257, -0.07339892536401749, -0.2834432125091553, 0.30058202147483826, 0.3332042694091797, -0.6845012903213501, 0.5204333066940308, -0.9984831809997559, 0.5609428882598877, -0.40804770588874817, 0.6656149625778198, 0.03650791198015213, -0.894472062587738, -0.40283823013305664, -0.023601971566677094, 0.8031957149505615, 0.3544083833694458, 0.8852595686912537, 0.9467642307281494, 0.43460842967033386, 0.37414079904556274, -0.43364495038986206, -0.25562813878059387, 0.6415303945541382, 0.11554296314716339, 0.3212921619415283, 0.16609150171279907, -0.3418377935886383, -0.014878474175930023, 0.2903139889240265, 0.06760889291763306, -0.5024147629737854, 0.6437532901763916, -0.13097329437732697, 0.2195274829864502, -0.05219045653939247, 0.8543701767921448, -0.18685884773731232, 0.3059332072734833, -0.21512170135974884, 0.6109541654586792, 0.1410258561372757, -0.37556734681129456, 0.278577595949173, -0.8421972990036011, 0.10680300742387772, 0.8548721671104431, -0.16031557321548462, -0.2583431899547577, 0.11789608001708984, 0.3621271550655365, 0.3327317535877228, -0.2943120002746582, -0.7953094840049744, -0.21513520181179047, 0.1414153277873993, 0.9079996347427368, -0.20550617575645447, 0.1097349300980568, 0.054593876004219055, 0.10961609333753586, -0.38654470443725586, -0.8850592970848083, -0.49473878741264343, 0.10293872654438019, 0.4700837731361389, 1.045395016670227, -0.20417140424251556, 0.32714584469795227, -0.6308696866035461, -1.3065930604934692, -0.4523466229438782, -0.9850414395332336, -0.177214115858078, 0.5227198600769043, -0.5797430872917175, 0.6267157793045044, 0.5425149202346802, 0.4241148829460144, 0.3425133526325226, -1.0202009677886963, -0.9258149266242981, -0.01045849546790123, -0.40620994567871094, -0.34100303053855896, 0.270562082529068, -0.20578445494174957, 0.28731808066368103, -0.5378901958465576, -0.22254784405231476, -0.6567872762680054, -0.20618528127670288, 0.7475435137748718, -0.38207700848579407, 0.32031914591789246, -0.4339347779750824, 0.7081195712089539, -0.9451419711112976, 0.043109435588121414, -0.5625985860824585, 0.044332072138786316, -0.04074649512767792, -0.5231661200523376, 0.2725396454334259, 0.12977583706378937, -0.5936580300331116, 0.06424342095851898, -1.0097938776016235, 0.19337914884090424, 0.3889164328575134, 0.4199981391429901, -0.32756972312927246, 0.640781581401825, -0.11967591196298599, -0.13218453526496887, -0.1492137908935547, -0.15389679372310638, -0.06790399551391602, 0.1302414834499359, 0.41554704308509827, 0.08869064599275589, -0.5729207396507263, -0.036752935498952866, 0.3443392515182495, -0.09518520534038544, 0.540555477142334, 0.6546435356140137, -0.10659944266080856, -0.9147730469703674, 0.3409561514854431, 0.05605975165963173, 0.0721801370382309, -0.2109375149011612, 0.028001658618450165, 0.44787541031837463, -0.1955857276916504, 0.987892746925354, 0.3020046353340149, -0.065188929438591, 0.5207559466362, 0.5958059430122375, -0.3134819567203522, -0.16782183945178986, 0.4570448696613312, -0.5607876181602478, 0.3031761646270752, 0.6556650400161743, -0.3570283055305481, 0.23093314468860626, -0.4191354215145111, 0.19142626225948334, -0.21333114802837372, -0.009825574234127998, 0.10920586436986923, 0.1476941704750061, 0.023751873522996902, 0.4413350522518158, -1.1822024583816528, -0.2913056015968323, -0.31915318965911865, 0.41917237639427185, 0.11082238703966141, -0.509619414806366, -0.007102525793015957, -0.2548682689666748, -0.3998103737831116, -0.779059648513794, -0.5357381105422974, 0.7546830177307129, -0.6421021223068237, -0.11789274960756302, 0.4262664020061493, -0.33836355805397034, -0.9510163068771362, -0.12770093977451324, -0.9962453842163086, -0.09883905202150345, -0.5919050574302673, 0.03339449316263199, 0.825033962726593, -0.9824210405349731, 0.0038188202306628227, 0.04864109680056572, -0.3514428734779358, 0.8375940322875977, 0.15773245692253113, 0.5050730109214783, -0.12455740571022034, 0.23183470964431763, -0.9374861121177673, 0.8685114979743958, -0.6383975148200989, -0.016064336523413658, -0.04160130396485329, 0.011213620193302631, 0.4335820972919464, -0.4399638772010803, 0.5252078175544739, 0.38507306575775146, -0.3612031936645508, 0.32543644309043884, 0.4783061742782593, -0.6871554255485535, 0.7197023034095764, 0.23893211781978607, -0.14790385961532593, -0.2702850103378296, -1.0571043491363525, 0.05232752487063408, -0.3115222752094269, -0.7831166386604309, 0.5544227361679077, -0.5989381670951843, -0.6286590099334717, 0.3336586058139801, -0.8300777077674866, 0.39490142464637756, 0.12026555836200714, 0.45901772379875183, 0.7024462223052979, 0.4063884913921356, -0.36990511417388916, -0.37295201420783997, -0.49683958292007446, 0.25871261954307556, 0.1236533522605896, -1.25797700881958, 0.5255974531173706, 0.6363272070884705, -0.02907768450677395, 0.17264577746391296, 0.6770552396774292, -0.6933320760726929, -0.7254180908203125, 0.7368994951248169, 0.15308961272239685, 0.31409740447998047, 0.1232835128903389, -0.22576096653938293, -1.035546064376831, 0.10385024547576904, 0.37147843837738037, 0.6701681017875671, -0.013020114041864872, -0.3133913576602936, 0.30204474925994873, 0.8053152561187744, 0.9584212899208069, -0.7325801849365234, 0.9622013568878174, -0.21696598827838898, -0.2329157590866089, -0.6520736217498779, -0.054595403373241425, -0.06380005180835724, 0.3028627932071686, 0.8324504494667053, -0.42400458455085754, 0.8468765616416931, -0.25321921706199646, -0.46652233600616455, -0.24679560959339142, -0.13222761452198029, -0.07854478061199188, 0.7466171383857727, -0.1538277268409729, -0.4707077741622925, -0.4378448724746704, -0.031445976346731186, 0.607628583908081, 0.0820436179637909, 0.4491749405860901, -1.235304594039917, 0.7111185789108276, -0.052669867873191833, -0.568925678730011, 0.1160769984126091, 0.2006395012140274, 0.22394800186157227, 0.2947838604450226, 0.6579350233078003, 0.4524981677532196, -0.5306391716003418, -0.34220871329307556, -0.31407684087753296, 0.7347979545593262, -0.01000710017979145, 0.3954515755176544, 0.413675457239151, 0.35043033957481384, 0.4721349775791168, -0.363785982131958, -0.5178313255310059, -0.3379300534725189, -0.7731314301490784, 0.02178104966878891, -0.34155958890914917, -0.2025524377822876, 0.0383690744638443, 0.40910637378692627, 0.6356246471405029, 0.023816589266061783, 0.378627747297287, 0.34931275248527527, 0.002793510677292943, -0.08319057524204254, -0.10017692297697067, -0.3168984353542328, 0.17398272454738617, -0.48987993597984314, -0.17625531554222107, -0.060881152749061584, 0.6478763222694397, -0.2963756024837494, -0.15901677310466766, -0.11990434676408768, 0.0677061527967453, 0.020247172564268112, 0.12537889182567596, -0.3347455561161041, 0.24227741360664368, 0.25624457001686096, 0.47752973437309265, -0.32233163714408875, -0.06389865279197693, 0.7641754150390625, 0.3996501863002777, 0.6669555306434631, -0.9017912745475769, 0.05818813666701317, 0.1030137911438942, 0.4344403147697449, 0.4145740270614624, -1.2320733070373535, -0.40477505326271057, -0.3890485167503357, 0.3329681158065796, -0.3635885417461395, 0.2793731987476349, 1.2713310718536377, 0.11178252100944519, 0.14011457562446594, -0.1311732679605484, -0.21717751026153564, 1.0128895044326782, -0.7967714667320251, -0.2600446045398712, 0.4591318368911743, 0.3046415150165558, -0.07321447134017944, 0.6049172282218933, -0.19742289185523987, 0.1036922037601471, 0.13244251906871796, 0.007494881749153137, 0.7732458114624023, -0.5943911075592041, -0.31128883361816406, 0.3585628569126129, -0.06412242352962494, -0.5773586630821228, 0.8500077724456787, -0.11664222180843353, -0.8372397422790527, -0.2027953714132309, 0.3422395884990692, -0.9546120762825012, -0.8147386312484741, -0.30514320731163025, -0.26813551783561707, 0.966173529624939, 0.5779684782028198, 0.44316744804382324, 0.04475174471735954, 0.47783562541007996, -0.14535824954509735, -0.5566904544830322, 0.39345449209213257, -0.1594485342502594, -0.32567745447158813, -0.4398230016231537, 0.020446395501494408, -0.489917129278183, -0.3623638153076172, 0.7548616528511047, -0.2694721221923828, 0.8079942464828491, -0.04025772213935852, -0.7782595157623291, -0.6583857536315918, 0.15831205248832703, 0.020716292783617973, 0.0913894847035408, -0.20327332615852356, -0.17175056040287018, -0.2826457917690277, 0.008991317823529243, -0.3731025457382202, -0.5010873675346375, -0.2984083294868469, -0.7143977284431458, -0.06774824112653732, -0.10864032059907913, 0.4345336854457855, 0.06706591695547104, -0.8313118815422058, 0.5713477730751038, -0.4357134997844696, 0.020600493997335434, -0.5270521640777588, -0.8328630328178406, -0.1311800628900528, -0.18295469880104065, -0.10944393277168274, 0.7743300795555115, -0.053148746490478516, -0.6487149000167847, 0.5098601579666138, 0.48772570490837097, -0.21133162081241608, -0.3022294342517853, -0.43835923075675964, 0.5560888648033142, 0.3642495572566986, -0.4645957946777344, 0.25635045766830444, 0.27606138586997986, -0.010979061014950275, -0.08438695222139359, -0.016542308032512665, -1.3059442043304443, 0.37338247895240784, -1.0695359706878662, 0.2630496919155121, -1.113080620765686, 0.09617778658866882, -0.08727368712425232, -0.479779988527298, -0.1964883953332901, 0.0608503557741642, -0.33976152539253235, -0.9097437262535095, -0.640081524848938, -0.7067168354988098, 0.6459605693817139, -0.02308717742562294, -0.18013286590576172, -0.6175681948661804, -0.43494361639022827, -0.1408786177635193, 0.9176284670829773, -0.5921286344528198, 0.024261385202407837, 0.24041621387004852, -0.2593308389186859, -0.007984654046595097, 0.6105232834815979, 0.0738602951169014, 0.16944019496440887, 0.18921387195587158, 0.1691129356622696, -0.325456827878952, 1.8013216257095337, 0.009123329073190689, 0.17032195627689362, -0.4669831097126007, 0.11207399517297745, -0.7543197870254517, 0.23768781125545502, -0.3555619418621063, 0.0753258466720581, 0.5607250928878784, -1.0590871572494507, 0.8143355846405029, 0.6553977131843567, 0.35300126671791077, 0.7660437822341919, 0.42904120683670044, -0.5498604774475098, -0.32030510902404785, -1.2720187902450562, -0.8382924199104309, 0.6743521094322205, -0.24530626833438873, 0.08066963404417038, -0.0633939877152443, -0.6266655921936035, -0.5179838538169861, -0.725155770778656, -0.031231576576828957, 0.4000018835067749, 0.2791089713573456, 0.2987728714942932, -0.5456424355506897, 0.38324224948883057, 0.46189528703689575, 0.09989317506551743, 0.4447519779205322, 0.14220121502876282, 0.01842556521296501, -0.1150452122092247, -0.22730207443237305, -0.7347270846366882, -0.4955521821975708, 0.806381344795227, 0.7394697070121765, -0.6627541780471802, 0.878585696220398, -0.22560904920101166, -0.5279344916343689, -0.30848759412765503, 0.35570886731147766, 0.8515880107879639, 0.4239501953125, 0.7075083255767822, 0.2558249235153198, 0.7781050205230713, 0.09204237908124924, -0.026106037199497223, -0.7210125923156738, -0.364024817943573, 0.5030182003974915, -0.1537099927663803, -0.4606632590293884, 0.8996508717536926, -0.30760905146598816, -0.9765884876251221, -0.3638159930706024, -0.5600310564041138, 0.6050625443458557, -0.3014095723628998, -0.40237119793891907, -0.6110357046127319, 0.05242782086133957, -0.09219744056463242, 0.045276906341314316, 0.17308609187602997, 0.4998866021633148, -0.3561919033527374, 0.06242242828011513, 0.1547791212797165, -0.38135969638824463, 0.07791709154844284, 1.3363208770751953, 0.28058913350105286, -0.7282508015632629, 0.023817062377929688, -0.4175127446651459, -0.5274463295936584, -0.24496589601039886, 1.1396411657333374, -0.2698628604412079, 0.4606667459011078, -0.30774620175361633, 0.025873294100165367, 0.6544206142425537, 0.5268118977546692, 0.021463407203555107, 0.1729367971420288, -0.6115132570266724, 0.05959216505289078, -0.21069276332855225, -0.7674185037612915, 0.27684006094932556, 0.26696452498435974, -0.026891473680734634, -0.41781118512153625, -0.2665331959724426, -0.3655606508255005, -0.10915016382932663, -0.6091187596321106, 0.259876549243927, -0.6978550553321838, -0.22837293148040771, -0.5989151000976562, -0.5333529114723206, 0.06295648962259293, 0.6691151261329651, -0.1618749499320984, -0.39587587118148804, -0.5699115991592407, -0.08536602556705475, 0.45678338408470154, 1.0997709035873413, -0.34325745701789856, -0.5072150230407715, -0.5736860036849976, -0.3418283760547638, -0.6370078325271606, -0.7001741528511047, 0.02403392270207405, -0.12846946716308594, -0.31647202372550964, 0.3708309233188629, -0.08778748661279678, 0.3188934624195099, -0.5318968296051025, -0.16954123973846436, 0.8124673366546631, -0.3243560791015625, -0.652089536190033, 1.3366162776947021, -0.2927604913711548, 0.6743285059928894, 0.21470996737480164, -0.3073953688144684, -0.10114458948373795, 0.025511987507343292, -1.008765697479248, 0.4025894105434418, 0.000885862042196095, 0.638066828250885, 0.042469583451747894, -0.00426464481279254, 0.24895954132080078, 0.8805392384529114, -0.8060805797576904, -0.3075619041919708, -1.4480832815170288, 0.15497690439224243, -0.06449166685342789, 0.36723923683166504, 0.014430039562284946, 0.6605817675590515, 0.01946191117167473, 0.5887546539306641, -0.6875981092453003, -0.38754546642303467, 0.5162547826766968, 0.4713424742221832, -0.5615664720535278, 0.2595263719558716, -0.5254722237586975, -0.6978397965431213, -0.1696244478225708, 1.1765663623809814, 0.27114391326904297, 0.34636661410331726, 0.3379364311695099, 0.20936815440654755, -0.30811813473701477, -0.2652788460254669, -1.2152020931243896, 0.5158998370170593, 0.5032164454460144, -0.5414588451385498, 0.574580729007721, -0.48570820689201355, -0.7343562245368958, 0.16194285452365875, -0.4156832695007324, -0.0544905811548233, -0.14935041964054108, -0.6192876696586609, 0.012767198495566845, -0.6806851625442505, 0.2044285386800766, 0.45750322937965393, 0.4740600883960724, 0.6578556299209595, 0.21723535656929016, -0.7945011258125305, -0.43698257207870483, 0.3930276036262512, -1.149964690208435, -0.5337328910827637, -0.6840090155601501, 0.25668418407440186, -0.4748591482639313, -0.6608847379684448, 0.250078022480011, 0.09658680856227875, -0.47956135869026184, -0.10497020184993744, -0.6110279560089111, -0.10741463303565979, 0.02849845215678215, 0.061733949929475784, -0.5580002665519714, -0.35547640919685364, -0.05293668061494827, 0.23146842420101166, -0.08700184524059296, -0.30479419231414795, -0.01965663768351078, 0.04026537761092186, 0.501607358455658, -0.4996820390224457, -0.9983733892440796, 0.5919435024261475, 0.6189454197883606, 0.25788062810897827, 0.5184466242790222, 0.5328157544136047, 1.1217550039291382, 0.6294493675231934, -0.6445667147636414, -0.19328171014785767, 1.0417852401733398, -0.11492424458265305, 0.723827064037323, 0.21647308766841888, -0.20664474368095398, -0.11888676136732101, -0.04256127029657364, -0.021386420354247093, 0.08863572776317596, 0.24226577579975128, -0.05073601379990578, 0.41735148429870605, 0.2576652467250824, 0.20744892954826355, -0.009816838428378105, -0.2272949367761612, 0.4226960241794586, 0.005301834084093571, 0.06985225528478622, 0.032071225345134735, -0.3857063949108124, -0.43643274903297424, -0.7562234401702881, -0.7132036089897156, -0.5329683423042297, 0.27172183990478516, 0.22826477885246277, 0.35561588406562805, 0.4209176301956177, 0.2888616621494293, 0.564304530620575, 0.04865751415491104, -0.0072248405776917934, 0.582024335861206, -0.12673935294151306, 0.6165512204170227, 0.6162954568862915, 0.6034471988677979, -0.1619393676519394, 0.9419271945953369, 0.3754587471485138, -0.036684129387140274, -0.18606580793857574, 0.03075285814702511, -1.530415654182434, 0.048338573426008224, 0.1081261858344078, 0.4024406969547272, -0.03900349140167236, -0.7271448969841003, 0.6494725942611694, -0.15533047914505005, 0.1353692263364792, 0.8674356937408447, -0.15576167404651642, -0.25590822100639343, 0.38974037766456604, -0.0831216350197792, 0.7868355512619019, 0.24118898808956146, 0.21519728004932404, -0.8684166073799133, 1.1360328197479248, 1.0024956464767456, 0.014492862857878208, 0.34384095668792725, -0.08612754940986633, 0.38980501890182495, -0.1418086141347885, 0.2190232127904892, -0.34787604212760925, 1.1745182275772095, 0.37067297101020813, 0.2636881172657013, 0.3522460162639618, -0.12861892580986023, -0.39738649129867554, -0.04780464991927147, 0.06932012736797333, 0.6664626598358154, -0.5136771202087402, -0.4903089702129364, 0.5431663990020752, 1.1040091514587402, -1.0493606328964233, -0.3245616853237152, 0.016423000022768974, -0.8266663551330566, -0.5200424790382385, -0.16674897074699402, 0.2887645363807678, -0.6818384528160095, 0.13248443603515625, -0.22772091627120972, -0.11712276935577393, 0.07605364173650742, -0.5260820984840393, -0.35417014360427856, -0.10079123079776764, 0.8376720547676086, 0.7394607663154602, 0.15869773924350739, 0.43422067165374756, -0.5550236105918884, -0.13182365894317627, 0.41411465406417847, 0.6810397505760193, -0.24654875695705414, 0.08108357340097427, 0.3505384027957916, -0.42598626017570496, -0.26396194100379944, 0.371201753616333, 0.9076948761940002, -0.6876906156539917, 0.5426329970359802, -0.12536360323429108, 0.3235853612422943, 0.14992207288742065, -0.7925745248794556, 0.7115810513496399, 0.38081231713294983, 0.39304685592651367, -0.5048446655273438, 0.0756959542632103, 0.5336611866950989, -0.7793918251991272, -0.12953200936317444, -0.508978009223938, 0.5599629878997803, -0.07284452766180038, -0.2746998965740204, 0.05071578919887543, -0.5696278214454651, 4.224981784820557, 1.1858841180801392, 1.1932346820831299, -0.27514609694480896, 0.43724092841148376, 0.9166251420974731, -0.2637442946434021, -0.16475440561771393, 0.20380212366580963, 0.09722612053155899, 0.02496841549873352, -0.3673328161239624, 0.3040754497051239, 0.11447398364543915, -0.34944605827331543, 0.9023092985153198, -0.1003945842385292, 0.3162364363670349, -0.0616496205329895, -0.5000979900360107, -0.8161487579345703, 0.5678624510765076, -0.05808359384536743, -0.15878544747829437, 0.12033122032880783, 0.4806663990020752, 0.15283417701721191, -0.20631751418113708, -0.16497260332107544, -0.5814582109451294, -0.9937870502471924, -0.4332406222820282, 0.46719881892204285, -0.07574909180402756, -0.23499764502048492, 0.525240421295166, 0.45617246627807617, -0.6388264298439026, -0.26614513993263245, -0.1729816496372223, -0.12641054391860962, -0.6085224151611328, 0.19029170274734497, -0.42029309272766113, 0.0848100408911705, 0.6361119747161865, -0.058793626725673676, 0.5757367610931396, 0.06359319388866425, -0.8792923092842102, 0.6422386765480042, -0.36414211988449097, 0.10575864464044571, -1.1481704711914062, -0.84956294298172, 0.1886425018310547, -0.37920260429382324, -0.28883787989616394, -0.32727956771850586, -0.06563685834407806, 0.8977113962173462, -0.3568069636821747, -0.2596181333065033, 0.025807490572333336, -0.31769734621047974, 0.8202884793281555, 0.8705267906188965, 0.6031298637390137, -0.7790179252624512, 0.43133917450904846, -0.6576440930366516, -0.7204543352127075, 0.08086369931697845, -0.003211435629054904, 0.658574640750885, 0.07030321657657623, 0.005567656829953194, -0.06669708341360092, -0.40894871950149536, -0.42996466159820557, -0.353481650352478, -0.10850449651479721, 0.1907949596643448, -0.22723475098609924, 0.05478852614760399, 0.2674825191497803, 0.43937405943870544, 0.11456882953643799, 0.2699330151081085, 0.37033453583717346, 0.4023463726043701, 1.0987166166305542, -0.030933238565921783, -0.2323112189769745, -0.8980126976966858 ]
Neutrino Flavor Conversion in a Supernova Core
If $\nu_\mu$ or $\nu_\tau$ mix with $\nu_e$, neutrino oscillations and collisions in a supernova (SN) core allow these flavors effectively to participate in $\beta$ equilibrium and thus to obtain a large chemical potential. If a sterile species mixes with $\nu_e$, these effects lead to an anomalous loss of energy and lepton number. We study flavor conversion in a SN core on the basis of a new kinetic equation which rigorously includes neutrino interference and degeneneracy effects. Our discussion serves as an example and illustration of the properties of this ``non-abelian Boltzmann equation''.
G. Raffelt and G. Sigl
astro-ph hep-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209005
astro-ph/9209006
[ 0.178142711520195, 0.24904924631118774, 0.10564545542001724, 0.08514567464590073, -0.4082239866256714, -0.2701025903224945, -0.5777338743209839, -0.2380392849445343, -0.5497545599937439, 1.5567790269851685, 0.4102545380592346, -0.4603521227836609, 0.3928675949573517, -1.1298705339431763, -0.42241108417510986, 0.6639194488525391, -0.02800389938056469, -1.0227657556533813, -1.439392328262329, 0.31453022360801697, -0.09249377250671387, 0.17916272580623627, -1.2430895566940308, -0.3803742527961731, -0.08849355578422546, 1.0701098442077637, 0.217691108584404, -0.34304144978523254, 0.9383091926574707, 0.7396981716156006, -0.1521885246038437, 0.14341333508491516, 0.5343239307403564, -0.7072829008102417, -0.4532538056373596, -0.3292316198348999, -0.4527592062950134, 0.03800757974386215, 0.5358599424362183, -0.5522121787071228, 0.6912312507629395, -0.21760427951812744, 0.13649827241897583, -0.42935359477996826, -0.6884368062019348, 0.32136330008506775, -0.8044453859329224, -0.16655515134334564, 0.6520533561706543, -1.5545575618743896, -0.23536773025989532, 0.13933490216732025, -0.17697660624980927, -1.1753315925598145, -0.16381444036960602, -0.3778069019317627, -0.14718860387802124, -0.35151177644729614, -0.8230887055397034, 0.2347450703382492, 1.4639743566513062, 0.4744105041027069, 0.8328545093536377, -0.4265757203102112, -0.05937844514846802, 1.8110464811325073, 0.15092459321022034, 0.38075703382492065, 0.5017126202583313, 0.3257235586643219, 0.273892879486084, -0.5405824780464172, -0.8690283894538879, -0.030099116265773773, -0.30899935960769653, 0.08677634596824646, 0.04697773978114128, 0.44575896859169006, -1.3883272409439087, -0.8056451678276062, 0.1915273666381836, 0.3084106743335724, -0.08114214241504669, 1.028180718421936, 0.07269483059644699, -0.9386222958564758, 0.29058244824409485, -0.44339752197265625, -0.11658735573291779, 0.5163715481758118, -0.5045745968818665, 0.8536075353622437, 0.2999612092971802, 0.22869589924812317, 0.4471028447151184, 0.21759694814682007, -0.5107951164245605, 0.20332589745521545, 0.30150681734085083, 0.3404347002506256, -0.023585621267557144, 0.11436466127634048, -0.39821332693099976, -0.02684042416512966, -0.7138946056365967, 1.0043461322784424, -0.3106774687767029, 0.35228684544563293, -0.5907875299453735, -0.5269449353218079, -0.284645140171051, -0.26797401905059814, 0.3364356458187103, -0.06665513664484024, -0.04136840999126434, 0.8266710042953491, -0.334867388010025, 0.7520899772644043, -0.6939374804496765, -0.03489784896373749, -0.5946980118751526, 0.6112886071205139, -0.24988466501235962, 0.2564466595649719, -0.28472334146499634, -0.3190385401248932, -0.5646545886993408, 0.7866963148117065, -0.9259870052337646, 0.3189067840576172, 0.13082581758499146, -0.09929025918245316, -0.7154505252838135, 1.4540289640426636, -0.10945888608694077, -0.1855311244726181, 0.7688737511634827, 0.9169837236404419, -0.3019854724407196, -0.6774729490280151, -0.0881628766655922, -0.8900442123413086, -0.08344773948192596, 1.4087634086608887, -1.3471722602844238, 0.12539708614349365, 0.026822621002793312, -0.47953248023986816, -0.7706184387207031, 0.16771790385246277, -0.4432486593723297, 0.19215242564678192, 0.389751672744751, 0.6782707571983337, -0.2483811229467392, -0.13169409334659576, -1.0200315713882446, -0.11802259832620621, -0.6758784055709839, -0.5270448923110962, -0.08215213567018509, -0.042754318565130234, -0.35730573534965515, 0.9945013523101807, -0.5575202703475952, -0.1295904517173767, -0.9178276658058167, -0.3330201208591461, -0.2989143431186676, -0.6131552457809448, -0.8480868339538574, 0.5670893788337708, -0.2943573594093323, 0.721466064453125, 0.38845574855804443, 0.4954145550727844, 0.532734751701355, -0.7027441263198853, 0.0008251071558333933, -0.009510845877230167, -0.5314990878105164, 0.11179529130458832, 0.02552216872572899, 0.6132249236106873, -0.27692803740501404, -0.18618108332157135, 0.05753343179821968, 0.19949555397033691, 0.37893280386924744, -0.1487174779176712, -0.4292844831943512, 0.6826643347740173, -0.34167206287384033, 0.7616643905639648, -0.6177716851234436, -0.44922563433647156, -0.6747660636901855, -0.4015439748764038, -0.6979094743728638, -0.5407772660255432, 0.5834218263626099, -0.4195808172225952, -0.5617570877075195, 0.9638123512268066, -0.9924939274787903, 0.14468468725681305, 1.1595511436462402, 0.10891217738389969, -0.9768040180206299, -0.050403788685798645, 0.051359161734580994, -0.14454911649227142, -0.016857998445630074, -0.5904502868652344, 0.37710270285606384, 0.22489088773727417, -0.011535861529409885, 0.1885332316160202, -0.10032213479280472, -0.2667253017425537, 0.3701583445072174, -0.26914283633232117, 0.2998318374156952, 1.1325231790542603, 0.3030742108821869, 0.13514935970306396, 0.2588164210319519, 0.8895840644836426, -0.30514973402023315, -0.10555969178676605, -0.8223589062690735, 0.3611614406108856, 0.22270521521568298, 0.005389073863625526, 0.7688517570495605, -0.7896299958229065, 0.4553615152835846, 0.7608990669250488, -0.11938217282295227, 0.1495376080274582, 0.11033940315246582, -0.11290313303470612, 0.3731572926044464, -0.14940233528614044, -0.5654960870742798, -0.1821216642856598, -0.06906833499670029, -0.39242568612098694, -0.11145894974470139, 0.9409298896789551, -0.1771063357591629, 0.356281042098999, -0.14866241812705994, 0.20006036758422852, -0.5966380834579468, -0.10263784974813461, -0.23110467195510864, 0.9771741032600403, -0.004032909870147705, -0.030308833345770836, 0.43487679958343506, 0.1519385725259781, 0.13689810037612915, -0.8924323320388794, 0.23536187410354614, 0.551155149936676, -1.096395492553711, 0.45808184146881104, 1.0769332647323608, -0.8212934136390686, -0.4040289521217346, -0.40135613083839417, -0.4644950330257416, 0.16947457194328308, -0.5483130812644958, 0.19151341915130615, -0.5166071653366089, -0.9376288652420044, 0.7310302257537842, -0.07686228305101395, -0.2664381265640259, 0.8623059988021851, -0.4274207353591919, 0.28313982486724854, 0.05395367741584778, 0.7877712845802307, -0.7817654609680176, 0.22386784851551056, -0.5482077598571777, -0.3281633257865906, -0.025272635743021965, -0.5801422595977783, 0.38179779052734375, -0.11733787506818771, 0.1056414246559143, 0.804606556892395, -0.23182693123817444, 0.5153918266296387, 0.29966646432876587, -0.05494283512234688, 0.25604748725891113, 0.27566641569137573, -0.38333889842033386, -0.14686943590641022, -0.8215486407279968, 0.7260096669197083, -0.420701801776886, 0.0037826697807759047, 0.3301892578601837, -0.4488102197647095, -0.4625747501850128, 0.6998342275619507, -0.17161166667938232, 1.0136778354644775, -0.015197455883026123, 0.27222055196762085, 0.1535470187664032, -0.43170562386512756, -0.1728028655052185, -0.34173762798309326, -0.7033775448799133, -0.31815940141677856, 0.26778316497802734, -0.35912367701530457, 0.14105568826198578, 0.4410150647163391, -0.14844870567321777, -0.582033634185791, 0.15115463733673096, -0.3685078024864197, -0.7692465782165527, -0.41040945053100586, -0.47860750555992126, 0.6880161762237549, -0.1743549406528473, 0.2302546352148056, -0.698586642742157, -0.1371384859085083, -0.1362692415714264, -0.07874166965484619, 0.6635821461677551, 0.357253760099411, 0.5988957285881042, 0.6268750429153442, -0.08746916055679321, 0.05623888224363327, 0.6586226224899292, -0.1826035976409912, -0.5310192704200745, 0.23592723906040192, 0.10349597036838531, -0.03102114237844944, 0.4035521149635315, 0.23178327083587646, 0.3903728127479553, 0.4619331955909729, 0.08438276499509811, -0.09622783958911896, -0.3947739005088806, -0.2919125258922577, 0.07214488089084625, 0.3546086251735687, -0.4239523112773895, -0.42974182963371277, -0.7283605933189392, -0.15694478154182434, 0.29381459951400757, -0.6934856176376343, 0.33935627341270447, -1.2994334697723389, -0.017822163179516792, 0.19309061765670776, -0.920732855796814, 0.011030553840100765, 0.08658885210752487, 0.35151180624961853, 0.8952295184135437, 0.26247647404670715, 0.4329780042171478, -0.22095662355422974, 0.1955825835466385, -0.3796108365058899, 0.29634225368499756, 0.3737811744213104, -0.013422566466033459, 0.11047009378671646, -0.08256582915782928, 0.31203076243400574, -0.4799826443195343, -0.4988255202770233, -0.5831860899925232, -0.2751006782054901, 0.2785748839378357, -0.373874306678772, -0.16607390344142914, 0.2558349370956421, 0.5226809978485107, 0.3734419047832489, -0.12631583213806152, 0.45566368103027344, 0.5065320730209351, -0.9374153017997742, -0.017243733629584312, 0.014122704975306988, 0.22779986262321472, 0.19631752371788025, -0.750717282295227, 0.7493672370910645, -0.32199332118034363, 0.4640742242336273, 0.5961043238639832, -0.35485777258872986, 0.16898098587989807, -0.361936092376709, 0.25981152057647705, 0.10118039697408676, -0.10857066512107849, 1.0806515216827393, 0.4438038766384125, 0.28168848156929016, -0.5169641971588135, 0.34270381927490234, 0.3809279203414917, 0.3391675651073456, -0.01818828471004963, -0.7899584174156189, 0.2899665832519531, -0.8022719025611877, -0.08832096308469772, 0.8220546245574951, 0.21574096381664276, -1.0010724067687988, -0.7896735668182373, 0.31075701117515564, 0.5617265105247498, 0.5265641808509827, 1.0621308088302612, 0.17272445559501648, 0.27464422583580017, -0.24497699737548828, 0.4937342405319214, 1.068634033203125, -0.26014623045921326, -0.8100506067276001, 0.01948493905365467, -0.13247527182102203, -0.5361959338188171, -0.16725286841392517, 0.2946561872959137, -0.3959057331085205, -0.25453248620033264, -0.415166437625885, 0.4804821312427521, -0.7477884292602539, -0.8216201066970825, 0.8805863261222839, 0.3073079288005829, -0.027429448440670967, -0.28152379393577576, -0.37871038913726807, -0.38517311215400696, -0.5237972140312195, 0.16250300407409668, -0.8004897832870483, -0.513541579246521, -0.6894577145576477, 0.25042882561683655, 1.1237696409225464, 0.7348212003707886, 0.3075709640979767, 1.2222002744674683, 0.4071260392665863, -0.38541272282600403, -0.023538265377283096, 0.2932654023170471, -0.32807856798171997, 0.003237861441448331, -0.009341038763523102, -0.0769001841545105, -0.8379666209220886, -0.00826241634786129, 0.2817261815071106, 0.1153511181473732, 0.2140357494354248, 0.00927506759762764, -0.8908205628395081, -0.3547815978527069, 0.5658062100410461, -0.4900595545768738, 0.9905089139938354, -0.10360172390937805, -0.0953977182507515, 0.7048532366752625, -0.4071054756641388, 0.43543633818626404, -0.9824249148368835, -0.5412448048591614, -0.4310253858566284, 0.4563354253768921, 0.3004310131072998, 0.4777129888534546, 0.6545135974884033, -0.9435596466064453, -0.15112489461898804, -0.1510380655527115, -0.40833353996276855, -0.8561810851097107, -0.07034672796726227, -0.7589338421821594, -0.3218368887901306, 0.33802470564842224, 0.6934104561805725, -0.16170084476470947, 0.3656628727912903, 0.3718017339706421, -0.022752603515982628, 0.4649987816810608, -0.6478132009506226, -0.20216096937656403, 0.44700199365615845, 0.09805209189653397, -0.8798114061355591, -0.13702848553657532, 0.16097398102283478, -0.39979639649391174, 0.4804636538028717, 0.14327390491962433, -0.5490464568138123, -0.3038162291049957, -1.272792935371399, -0.07240883260965347, -1.2312052249908447, -0.3827560544013977, -0.56451815366745, -0.5320083498954773, -0.1299833506345749, -0.2730625569820404, 0.7069206237792969, -0.017301509156823158, -0.6499288082122803, 0.11140690743923187, 0.5872333645820618, -0.5523636341094971, -0.2156168520450592, -0.32831871509552, -0.18325923383235931, -0.47234025597572327, 1.1002192497253418, -0.9706407189369202, -0.023353658616542816, -0.28574925661087036, 0.11097466200590134, -0.4500387907028198, 1.3242344856262207, 0.13574497401714325, -0.27911150455474854, -0.11522474884986877, 0.145798921585083, 0.3512463867664337, -0.1913658082485199, -0.7470435500144958, 0.6045445799827576, 0.25970953702926636, 0.8298523426055908, -0.6607890129089355, -0.29153481125831604, -0.07412198930978775, -0.2985316514968872, 0.4389286935329437, -0.34298843145370483, 0.9420181512832642, 0.6486481428146362, 0.7563683390617371, 0.5778558850288391, 0.4102054238319397, -0.5341814160346985, -0.3324819505214691, -0.5008625984191895, -1.1135833263397217, 1.0275062322616577, -0.0646762028336525, 0.6242169737815857, -0.4023364782333374, -0.6176245212554932, -0.1793363094329834, -0.5351672768592834, 0.06178155541419983, 0.5232672095298767, 0.03294860199093819, -0.12114989012479782, 0.2236296534538269, 0.41073188185691833, -0.17002159357070923, -0.09903369843959808, 0.6653472781181335, -0.03995238244533539, -0.1415308266878128, -0.6778351664543152, -0.372530996799469, -0.4814296066761017, -1.1326649188995361, 0.5778417587280273, 0.5268262028694153, -0.08152962476015091, 1.0059821605682373, -0.49294888973236084, -0.13000155985355377, -0.5113576650619507, 0.16732928156852722, 1.553562879562378, 0.23861657083034515, 0.5595037341117859, 0.8163551092147827, -0.08841346204280853, 0.6781630516052246, -0.26153650879859924, -0.5438438057899475, 0.14416152238845825, 0.32400161027908325, -0.6955509781837463, -0.14247210323810577, 0.9423385858535767, 0.40360555052757263, -0.8140599131584167, -0.31655070185661316, -1.6613049507141113, -0.9851087331771851, -0.1629539281129837, -0.08590330928564072, -0.1459033340215683, -0.09090137481689453, -0.9962232708930969, 0.6077103018760681, 0.6556351780891418, 0.4735269248485565, -0.01907886564731598, 0.15702220797538757, 0.27721816301345825, -0.5774210691452026, -0.0071776551194489, 0.47627490758895874, 0.11122915893793106, -0.7933122515678406, 0.1717114895582199, -0.30494508147239685, -0.5903615951538086, -0.5600019693374634, 1.0040521621704102, -0.44424453377723694, 0.5935062766075134, -0.01251322589814663, -0.5037286281585693, 0.3724179267883301, 0.4239286482334137, 0.23689495027065277, -0.16303591430187225, -0.7555381059646606, -1.0819133520126343, -0.3046541213989258, -0.12499599158763885, 0.4107584059238434, 0.8413715362548828, 0.20279894769191742, 0.2831088900566101, -0.44177597761154175, -0.10967385023832321, 0.18265454471111298, -0.38823747634887695, -0.6197704672813416, -0.8996261358261108, -0.49521341919898987, -0.7550418376922607, -0.1334998905658722, 0.5326288938522339, 0.5611568093299866, -0.25617772340774536, 0.692361056804657, -0.2003556191921234, -0.006572393700480461, 0.08230317384004593, 0.5519371032714844, 0.44802069664001465, -1.2377430200576782, -0.1600693166255951, -0.18190054595470428, -0.042343199253082275, -1.0471376180648804, 0.05122756212949753, 0.15287566184997559, 0.04094715043902397, 0.911616325378418, -0.9120317697525024, -0.16584554314613342, -0.5294612050056458, -0.5251942276954651, 0.3597506880760193, 0.22852152585983276, -0.5790544748306274, 1.190794825553894, -0.4619092047214508, 0.7265914678573608, 0.3214366137981415, -0.2968977093696594, -0.3835262656211853, -0.5091137886047363, -0.9894911646842957, 0.788219690322876, 0.5602480173110962, 0.8742460608482361, 0.498369038105011, -0.6339659690856934, -0.6152613162994385, 0.7401484847068787, -0.8955928087234497, 0.7819882035255432, -0.678085207939148, 0.26316094398498535, -0.4827558696269989, 0.7197773456573486, -0.11024374514818192, 0.5705653429031372, 0.11761412769556046, 0.41789424419403076, -0.7178997993469238, 0.272396057844162, 0.5185999870300293, 0.9391366839408875, 0.5218450427055359, -0.6755396127700806, 0.019388023763895035, -0.3636915385723114, 0.5335498452186584, 0.1636674851179123, 0.5670497417449951, -0.1780983954668045, 0.450697660446167, -0.3051796555519104, 0.3612910211086273, 0.7819409966468811, -0.5583587288856506, 0.7765563130378723, 0.08336527645587921, -0.2433968186378479, 0.5285383462905884, -0.25690165162086487, -0.9323599934577942, 0.10162686556577682, -0.20963752269744873, -0.6186187863349915, 0.06561896950006485, -0.16757658123970032, -0.022530579939484596, -0.16472075879573822, -0.16124312579631805, -0.5617645978927612, -0.09510031342506409, 0.3537600338459015, 1.338889241218567, -0.0752788782119751, -0.7250851988792419, 0.23107460141181946, -0.5407010912895203, -0.6608754396438599, -0.5860148072242737, 0.4008035957813263, -0.7549134492874146, -0.9799525737762451, -0.05976159870624542, 0.7167103886604309, -0.2869017720222473, -0.49184349179267883, -0.4732104539871216, -0.5849835276603699, -0.33969658613204956, 0.30278757214546204, -0.7797090411186218, -0.2717265784740448, -0.745819091796875, 0.5000806450843811, 0.031780142337083817, -0.20127299427986145, 0.240719273686409, 0.5073514580726624, 0.9282596707344055, 0.16916783154010773, 0.016484921798110008, 1.6268298625946045, 0.10971730202436447, 0.11210933327674866, 0.5145082473754883, -0.2195538729429245, 0.19252192974090576, 0.9691557884216309, -0.34760135412216187, -0.6592341065406799, 0.9909209609031677, 0.12585045397281647, 0.8809506297111511, 0.5099049210548401, -0.1614665985107422, 0.31128618121147156, -0.21470597386360168, 0.030242007225751877, -0.016043666750192642, 0.10698942840099335, 0.01713956706225872, 0.8463940620422363, -0.4901343882083893, -0.3061251640319824, -0.8906001448631287, 0.4945145845413208, -0.017299989238381386, -0.0445583276450634, 0.6476874947547913, -0.5100472569465637, -0.6280055642127991, 0.3776087164878845, -0.562315821647644, -0.7061246633529663, -0.21065132319927216, 0.29703888297080994, 0.6721702218055725, 0.19962473213672638, -0.415107399225235, 0.2533029615879059, 0.41804417967796326, 0.010828698053956032, -0.1991807073354721, 0.12212151288986206, 0.32237714529037476, 0.5886781811714172, 1.385941505432129, -0.036982011049985886, 0.21153457462787628, 0.45687076449394226, 0.45560115575790405, -0.5716326236724854, -0.2356061488389969, 0.8703555464744568, -0.663449227809906, 0.37180235981941223, -0.11649659276008606, -0.6070650815963745, 0.25060391426086426, -0.40021342039108276, 0.1979811191558838, -0.5354197025299072, 0.269705593585968, 0.4484545588493347, -0.12159331887960434, 0.10431892424821854, 0.08358912169933319, 0.6638413071632385, 0.3780570328235626, 0.653878927230835, 1.0318419933319092, -0.8925578594207764, 0.6527235507965088, 0.9863669276237488, 0.3491605222225189, 0.17642980813980103, -0.1926693171262741, 0.02879512310028076, 0.24221967160701752, 0.5086376667022705, -1.0168046951293945, 0.5638163089752197, 0.04375111311674118, -0.5715420842170715, -0.24829789996147156, 0.3732658326625824, 0.3660413920879364, -0.26995617151260376, 0.9555922150611877, 0.0019571383018046618, -0.004812431056052446, -0.3574155569076538, 1.0719002485275269, 0.4272027313709259, -0.8092218041419983, -0.5596267580986023, 0.6354556679725647, -0.7988274693489075, 0.10367907583713531, -0.46559998393058777, 0.7218570113182068, -0.3966616690158844, -0.10063613951206207, -0.14857254922389984, -0.46826010942459106, -0.8498805165290833, -0.4299616515636444, -0.04526226595044136, -0.04886811226606369, 0.7050325274467468, 0.6104229092597961, 0.14305534958839417, -0.07165262848138809, 0.3733026087284088, 0.021708330139517784, 0.3178243041038513, 0.984936535358429, -0.4064907729625702, 0.3122148811817169, 0.5001207590103149, 0.27545076608657837, -0.4512653946876526, 0.3253919780254364, 0.9316651821136475, -0.1957675963640213, 0.28685322403907776, -0.5005667209625244, 0.4400307238101959, 0.32410144805908203, -0.23840941488742828, 0.07479924708604813, 0.49931153655052185, 0.20052026212215424, -0.4952166676521301, -0.3019513785839081, -0.16602224111557007, -0.37185341119766235, -0.428756445646286, -0.09839802235364914, 0.6126878261566162, -0.2798779606819153, 0.151046022772789, 0.4170593321323395, -0.8175852298736572, 3.9474639892578125, 0.40552788972854614, 0.5806155204772949, -0.2049514353275299, 0.8838756084442139, 0.7839524745941162, 0.029399991035461426, -0.4888326823711395, -0.3063407838344574, -0.04458337277173996, -0.011282050982117653, -0.26376423239707947, -0.05075078457593918, 0.35615062713623047, 0.4817167818546295, 0.31554707884788513, -0.3268183171749115, -0.7370551824569702, 0.0642479881644249, 0.0008651242824271321, -1.211066484451294, -0.37834858894348145, 0.3294394016265869, 0.566642701625824, 0.28334900736808777, 0.5129713416099548, 0.07691151648759842, -0.14033502340316772, -0.178665429353714, -0.1578986942768097, 0.16652986407279968, -0.4651905298233032, 0.28126227855682373, 0.18145319819450378, -1.4932974576950073, 0.5614078640937805, -0.3751624524593353, 0.12044362723827362, -0.032241567969322205, -1.0139514207839966, -0.626232385635376, -0.6487558484077454, -0.16319091618061066, -0.49315375089645386, -0.014860836789011955, 0.9932116270065308, 0.30773404240608215, 0.931588351726532, 0.9525390267372131, -1.017194390296936, 0.1612909585237503, 0.002039765240624547, 0.5992355942726135, -0.7201181650161743, -1.1614086627960205, 0.17695794999599457, 0.2641734480857849, -0.0045028915628790855, 0.3354153037071228, -0.2765260338783264, 0.4585613012313843, -0.37410005927085876, -0.19022996723651886, -0.07852742075920105, 0.6142413020133972, -0.04966588318347931, 0.4870464503765106, 0.3575954735279083, -0.4700244963169098, 0.11055267602205276, -0.36888453364372253, -0.0794253870844841, -0.5015456080436707, -0.19313666224479675, 0.23717540502548218, -0.15993241965770721, 0.6316397786140442, 0.2008936107158661, -1.0238014459609985, -0.09032543748617172, 0.26070263981819153, -0.14823687076568604, -0.648377537727356, 1.1098284721374512, -0.006913355085998774, 0.5945664048194885, 0.04787846654653549, 0.2171272188425064, -0.2812138497829437, 0.39898592233657837, -0.3303256928920746, 0.9161175489425659, 0.4099939465522766, 0.5438122749328613, -0.7990927696228027 ]
Inflation at the Electroweak Scale
We present a simple model for slow-rollover inflation where the vacuum energy that drives inflation is of the order of $G_F^{-2}$; unlike most models, the conversion of vacuum energy to radiation (``reheating'') is moderately efficient. The scalar field responsible for inflation is a standard-model singlet, develops a vacuum expectation value of the order of $4\times 10^6\GeV$, has a mass of order $1\GeV$, and can play a role in electroweak phenomena.
L. Knox and M.S. Turner (U. of Chicago/Fermilab)
astro-ph hep-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9209006
astro-ph/9210001
[ 0.683512270450592, 0.36285266280174255, 0.45040279626846313, -0.20110611617565155, -0.5280719995498657, 0.05627748370170593, -0.5688866972923279, 0.31989333033561707, -0.20949137210845947, 1.2683521509170532, 0.31617575883865356, -0.5382118821144104, -0.28317224979400635, 0.19690081477165222, -0.6258050203323364, 0.6953622698783875, 0.2927304804325104, -0.4160466492176056, -1.7446403503417969, 0.15926629304885864, -0.3808113932609558, -0.5200232863426208, -0.8153848052024841, -0.4223712980747223, -0.34934210777282715, 0.10582104325294495, 0.0696854516863823, 1.1598279476165771, 0.7487891912460327, 0.3959990441799164, 0.2061755210161209, -0.9020147323608398, -0.24412068724632263, -0.7847384214401245, -0.2208959311246872, -0.2483830451965332, 0.5920631885528564, -0.7481293678283691, 0.35446980595588684, -0.5476227402687073, 0.2575528621673584, -0.3013734519481659, 1.0080647468566895, -0.2984412610530853, 0.22777386009693146, 0.12805935740470886, 0.30412280559539795, -0.7351310849189758, 0.26080381870269775, -0.10925936698913574, 0.004289236851036549, -0.140884667634964, 0.15204665064811707, -1.2496079206466675, 0.06808662414550781, 0.5987913608551025, 0.4979535639286041, 0.13447558879852295, 0.5968031883239746, -0.16994693875312805, 0.08088523149490356, 0.1366206258535385, 0.7538896203041077, -0.5678144097328186, -0.35581478476524353, 1.3105489015579224, -0.2812897861003876, -0.6408374905586243, 0.5818536877632141, -0.6735171675682068, -0.2896554470062256, -0.33489513397216797, -0.21900488436222076, 0.16800647974014282, -0.798150897026062, -0.8464201092720032, 0.2115214616060257, -0.03343478590250015, 0.249586284160614, 0.3771551847457886, 0.612076461315155, 0.3413132429122925, -0.10023564845323563, -0.23418179154396057, 0.6124963164329529, -0.2915824055671692, 0.14925207197666168, 0.48970821499824524, 0.14887666702270508, 0.20010942220687866, -0.04151289537549019, 0.9548008441925049, -0.285927951335907, -0.07816407829523087, -0.03234109282493591, -0.16201381385326385, -0.19083009660243988, -0.060520824044942856, 0.2593858242034912, 0.44287949800491333, 0.4188843071460724, 0.5677932500839233, -0.5557981133460999, -0.021662654355168343, 0.21162815392017365, 0.3224310576915741, -0.32170671224594116, -0.1299499273300171, -0.21288162469863892, -0.8415853381156921, 0.10223737359046936, -0.17793123424053192, -0.010047998279333115, 0.4901520013809204, 0.1771160215139389, 0.5591613054275513, 0.06307221204042435, 0.22118020057678223, -0.5384348034858704, -0.20269574224948883, 0.22961294651031494, 0.949623167514801, 0.10575919598340988, 0.06163354963064194, 0.23937742412090302, 0.17997126281261444, -0.29170140624046326, -0.10694251954555511, -0.5662996768951416, -0.7813934087753296, 0.3719158172607422, -1.1880805492401123, -0.23962685465812683, 1.1232796907424927, 0.4479708671569824, 0.41334688663482666, 0.2448207288980484, 0.42741963267326355, 0.29757562279701233, -0.9770709276199341, 0.0796174705028534, 0.026658637449145317, -0.42693668603897095, 0.8657141327857971, -0.5886168479919434, 0.3264649510383606, -0.6123641133308411, 0.6757179498672485, -0.25072652101516724, 0.3980531394481659, 0.13530988991260529, -0.8485648036003113, 0.014824128709733486, 0.35459795594215393, -0.8451228737831116, -0.30066949129104614, -0.8718928098678589, 0.2852359414100647, 0.17105741798877716, -0.6852006316184998, -0.1650511920452118, -0.9019061923027039, 0.20715780556201935, 0.4563066065311432, -0.641934871673584, 0.7612833380699158, -0.7288496494293213, -0.6691862940788269, 0.854884922504425, 0.031148850917816162, 0.6848181486129761, 0.17420943081378937, 0.25564488768577576, 0.5495772361755371, 0.4283462464809418, 0.17079734802246094, 0.24138963222503662, -0.536615788936615, -0.3978344202041626, 0.21447230875492096, -0.655472993850708, -0.00648466544225812, -0.4849279820919037, 0.14492535591125488, 0.21682503819465637, 0.17441095411777496, -0.5808725357055664, -0.3477209508419037, -0.02157631702721119, -0.14041966199874878, 0.49642980098724365, 0.8691567182540894, -0.245152086019516, 0.6142026782035828, -0.503319263458252, 0.4077252745628357, -0.21793995797634125, 0.04981740564107895, 0.29708200693130493, -0.4517080783843994, -0.1911434531211853, 0.6422218680381775, -0.0915008932352066, 0.2914186120033264, -0.34110045433044434, 0.1318688690662384, 0.8438581824302673, 0.922844409942627, -0.4595203697681427, -0.4697652757167816, 0.8800008296966553, 0.18647925555706024, 0.2890447974205017, 0.09484611451625824, 0.30038997530937195, -0.26785704493522644, -0.23240527510643005, 0.07783608138561249, -0.49728235602378845, 0.289335697889328, 0.833287239074707, 0.4885823130607605, -0.24151310324668884, 0.7494101524353027, -0.47318652272224426, -0.09792248159646988, -1.2217317819595337, 0.608147919178009, 0.0627821758389473, 0.15882515907287598, -0.43414822220802307, 0.10228635370731354, -0.24111860990524292, 0.2343626767396927, 0.0793960690498352, -0.16423310339450836, 1.3184409141540527, 0.5729318857192993, -0.7665721774101257, 0.07680483907461166, -0.08964721858501434, -0.013743401505053043, 0.5476764440536499, 0.44219449162483215, -0.5898628234863281, 0.7825158834457397, -0.05316447094082832, -0.6355074048042297, -0.1962490826845169, 1.1644060611724854, -0.7305847406387329, 0.9629107713699341, -0.38135120272636414, -0.14689983427524567, -1.1272000074386597, -0.667411208152771, -0.017922163009643555, -0.3694244921207428, -0.34110668301582336, -0.4862886071205139, -0.46602001786231995, -0.3033680021762848, 0.557630717754364, -0.13989482820034027, 0.3892556428909302, 0.11719989031553268, 0.18454892933368683, 0.8000195622444153, 0.2004394382238388, -0.1585758924484253, -1.485918402671814, 0.15363283455371857, -1.2486436367034912, 0.26198625564575195, 0.0452781580388546, -0.7198063135147095, 0.34171754121780396, -0.3307071328163147, 0.17211149632930756, -0.48820868134498596, -0.3077666461467743, 0.21282918751239777, -0.5289602875709534, 0.21352830529212952, -1.066021203994751, 0.3940490484237671, -0.5221419334411621, 0.5693835616111755, -0.06361263245344162, 0.4483899474143982, 0.3352653980255127, 0.10476583242416382, -1.219520092010498, -0.2040560394525528, 0.7326637506484985, -0.2559751272201538, 0.12657766044139862, 0.31119629740715027, 1.1168487071990967, -0.9771970510482788, 0.08854346722364426, -0.25651079416275024, -0.5908516645431519, -0.7702643275260925, -0.3774912655353546, -0.27562227845191956, -0.5814045071601868, 0.03598232567310333, 0.356040358543396, 0.502678394317627, -0.7113627791404724, 0.11469438672065735, 0.3194393813610077, 0.6191003918647766, -0.13770194351673126, -0.4187888205051422, 0.6504489183425903, -0.23059387505054474, 0.7423164248466492, -0.37951603531837463, -0.6200016736984253, -0.6024994850158691, -0.231271892786026, 0.4805023670196533, 0.15727148950099945, 0.5784162282943726, 0.7036747932434082, -0.30516791343688965, 0.6448597311973572, -0.5263139605522156, -0.12792934477329254, 0.1524161994457245, -0.5588832497596741, 0.37223589420318604, 0.09241583943367004, -0.3532205820083618, -0.5163307785987854, -0.6509890556335449, 0.15705500543117523, 0.44919729232788086, 0.29010412096977234, -0.5318414568901062, 0.22668474912643433, 1.062121868133545, -0.1392928510904312, -0.20852749049663544, -0.38007402420043945, -0.08673034608364105, 0.5761235952377319, 0.036397308111190796, -0.16505080461502075, 0.1574580818414688, 0.3145039677619934, 0.4109102189540863, -0.008864233270287514, 0.5215665102005005, -0.14415748417377472, -0.5186414122581482, -0.3297927677631378, -0.8375680446624756, 0.170416459441185, -0.04883255809545517, 0.8548785448074341, 0.35776299238204956, 0.2122180163860321, -0.32873252034187317, 0.30981069803237915, -0.2718646228313446, 0.7802045345306396, -0.5537117123603821, 0.5027319192886353, 0.29068195819854736, -0.06015695631504059, -0.6866573095321655, 0.05939118191599846, 0.8318302035331726, 0.7874577641487122, -0.14390909671783447, 1.2968307733535767, -0.7321995496749878, -0.311918705701828, -0.7546064853668213, -0.19560906291007996, 0.3326939344406128, -0.5479305982589722, 0.0676853209733963, 0.5402388572692871, 0.1457013487815857, -0.34365594387054443, -0.6765677332878113, -0.4633219242095947, -0.27896714210510254, -0.1079365685582161, -0.1659114509820938, -0.6205911636352539, -0.309767484664917, 0.5424420237541199, 0.8941805362701416, 0.5839073657989502, -0.17459028959274292, -0.22861455380916595, -0.5329515337944031, 0.5096151828765869, 0.4961874186992645, -0.4812988042831421, 0.7961636185646057, -0.06317051500082016, 0.17982633411884308, 0.3135140836238861, 0.15731453895568848, -0.17290326952934265, 0.646635115146637, 0.27415332198143005, 0.4534558951854706, 0.49050214886665344, 0.6468816995620728, -0.4065383970737457, 0.23184217512607574, -0.7475508451461792, -0.7145777344703674, -0.30018773674964905, 0.32388630509376526, -0.09471003711223602, 1.0935826301574707, -0.17332665622234344, -0.54095858335495, -0.13954871892929077, 0.09186813235282898, 0.4541994035243988, 0.3140980899333954, -1.165208339691162, -0.5590003728866577, -0.5080236196517944, 0.17436319589614868, 0.1304798573255539, 0.459457665681839, 0.8028587102890015, 0.5491600632667542, 0.4600861072540283, 0.10250723361968994, -0.0095292367041111, 0.07116789370775223, 0.3136366605758667, -0.06875331699848175, 0.43432512879371643, 0.537135660648346, 0.5498771071434021, 0.6920710206031799, -0.08650487661361694, -0.6872397065162659, -0.12252510339021683, -0.1642080694437027, 0.5681635141372681, -0.33827608823776245, -0.23197565972805023, 0.812408983707428, -0.2860240042209625, -0.41597819328308105, -0.35961538553237915, -0.3196010887622833, 0.051025766879320145, 0.375793993473053, -0.23595452308654785, -0.3017635643482208, -0.4861051142215729, 0.21600276231765747, -1.1111620664596558, 0.1362900286912918, 0.7036707401275635, 0.699907660484314, 0.20737385749816895, 0.7802091240882874, 0.26301512122154236, -0.23533318936824799, -0.021419888362288475, -0.9704664945602417, 0.06913373619318008, -0.4052775204181671, -0.02395143359899521, -0.15145297348499298, 0.6006979942321777, 0.2770000696182251, -0.4041721224784851, 0.9962621927261353, -0.14398562908172607, -0.7148589491844177, -0.6009104251861572, 0.33673095703125, -0.46247681975364685, 0.9536699652671814, -0.05734565109014511, -0.6097754240036011, -0.17782047390937805, -0.30603957176208496, -0.030207272619009018, -0.45041394233703613, 0.24553793668746948, -0.5009992122650146, 0.32410886883735657, -0.09521956741809845, -0.29482924938201904, -0.2421162873506546, -0.42272689938545227, 0.09366828948259354, -0.14462023973464966, -0.8032463788986206, -0.3616894781589508, -0.07488100230693817, -0.21036508679389954, 0.3571450710296631, -0.5594539642333984, 0.12038730084896088, 0.19257622957229614, -0.23430970311164856, -0.8644360303878784, 0.9467759132385254, 0.38538798689842224, -0.7094561457633972, 0.6856476068496704, 0.3312746584415436, 0.6061753630638123, -0.9532554745674133, 0.13654328882694244, 0.6197670102119446, 0.4955819249153137, -0.37931889295578003, -0.6159747838973999, 0.3987608253955841, 0.5950126051902771, -0.7134047746658325, -0.039729658514261246, -0.5670979619026184, -0.7245336174964905, 0.2994673252105713, -0.813955545425415, -0.4071071743965149, 0.4167870879173279, 0.44071027636528015, -1.2475042343139648, -0.029596155509352684, -0.9026018977165222, 0.02932138741016388, -0.44792264699935913, 0.10295608639717102, -0.9113996624946594, 0.18542832136154175, -0.4583362936973572, 1.0953329801559448, -0.618853747844696, -0.29041633009910583, -0.6549081206321716, 0.05153641104698181, 0.37844014167785645, 0.11393415927886963, 0.06811416149139404, 0.08601563423871994, -0.004216491710394621, -0.1637270450592041, 0.10065776109695435, 0.693313717842102, -0.9751343727111816, 0.15276232361793518, -0.6627420783042908, -0.05822179839015007, 0.404845654964447, -0.17330993711948395, 0.05255565047264099, -0.14598636329174042, 0.5330505967140198, 0.32822343707084656, 0.5569586753845215, 0.4498474597930908, 0.3610524833202362, 0.7110369801521301, 0.437815397977829, -0.2964455783367157, -0.38405197858810425, -0.6911494731903076, -0.1391674131155014, 0.1801767647266388, 0.578473687171936, -0.13978485763072968, 0.07886118441820145, -0.669215738773346, -0.19327305257320404, -0.30214735865592957, 0.15458934009075165, 0.2928529679775238, 0.0938352569937706, 0.013830241747200489, -0.5120725631713867, -0.16103987395763397, -0.028769569471478462, -0.011810516938567162, -0.25136733055114746, 0.00027527601923793554, -0.9551952481269836, 0.22035832703113556, 0.16660769283771515, -0.5824751257896423, -0.5529628396034241, 0.7449699640274048, 0.6463536024093628, -0.5025027990341187, 0.7654080390930176, -0.3312535881996155, -1.3821392059326172, 0.058539487421512604, 0.3639700710773468, 0.2326144576072693, -0.05860406160354614, 0.21379844844341278, -0.08157319575548172, 0.042611945420503616, 0.9323469996452332, 0.20711937546730042, -0.6435733437538147, -0.6735984683036804, 1.2359699010849, -0.8348215222358704, 0.2701721787452698, -0.009479925036430359, 0.4051785469055176, -0.6500938534736633, 0.346021831035614, -0.23337750136852264, 0.15117163956165314, 0.2680729925632477, -0.7284613847732544, 0.025507913902401924, -0.5795058012008667, -0.2760809361934662, 0.6413776874542236, 1.05666983127594, 0.10764294117689133, 0.6207156181335449, -0.001922084018588066, 0.17404960095882416, -0.19727440178394318, -0.09509613364934921, 1.8159737586975098, 0.04420123249292374, -0.5578688979148865, -0.08123614639043808, -0.45029571652412415, -0.5302149653434753, -0.2621450424194336, 0.826156497001648, 0.28342220187187195, -0.10238400101661682, -0.04429654777050018, 1.138922095298767, 0.15643608570098877, 0.2627100646495819, -0.029338015243411064, -0.05044393241405487, -1.074427604675293, -0.410579651594162, -0.4441471993923187, -0.4428105354309082, 0.1355184018611908, 0.9304978847503662, 0.033060163259506226, -0.5101340413093567, 0.5494313836097717, -0.4684184789657593, 0.22102905809879303, 0.4070710241794586, 0.022996271029114723, 0.24344240128993988, -0.4674108028411865, -0.777083694934845, -0.6864054799079895, 0.4744212329387665, 0.1121835932135582, -0.18470405042171478, -0.3921010494232178, 0.5319964289665222, 0.37275686860084534, 0.17123153805732727, 0.3736817538738251, -0.06690314412117004, 0.005569689441472292, -0.01459953561425209, -0.06882737576961517, -0.5696499347686768, -0.794403612613678, -0.010662968270480633, 0.03464290499687195, 0.06367123872041702, 0.7459589242935181, 0.16929098963737488, 1.4756817817687988, 0.30998024344444275, -0.1585552841424942, -0.4903417229652405, -0.46910494565963745, -0.8456588983535767, 0.5934399962425232, -0.5789651274681091, 1.2224583625793457, 0.8255902528762817, -0.5256456136703491, 0.04330827668309212, 0.1729549765586853, -0.8474954962730408, 0.48162856698036194, -0.2681099474430084, 0.36391255259513855, -0.6400595903396606, -0.2929164469242096, -0.43695130944252014, 0.669876217842102, -0.7776318788528442, -0.666252613067627, 0.2328677475452423, 0.15084266662597656, 0.36651483178138733, -0.1529478281736374, -0.26620420813560486, 0.4067772924900055, -0.03678407892584801, -0.13778120279312134, -0.002479328541085124, 0.3203183114528656, -0.5270583629608154, 0.7713923454284668, -0.553068995475769, -0.03823179751634598, -0.14838911592960358, -0.1656559556722641, 0.4116460382938385, 0.2832317352294922, 0.029469309374690056, -0.42738816142082214, -0.3719763457775116, 0.2776838541030884, -0.10297482460737228, -0.024858832359313965, -0.8917571306228638, 0.5458321571350098, 0.08910355716943741, -0.06176191195845604, 0.2529332935810089, -0.02513650245964527, -1.2283300161361694, 0.5503899455070496, -0.6501086354255676, -0.7961739301681519, 0.5369554162025452, -0.07158104330301285, 0.0017379462951794267, -0.05822866037487984, -0.031139126047492027, 0.5181311368942261, 0.03517797961831093, -0.09845860302448273, 0.633914589881897, 0.23799815773963928, -0.5732738375663757, 0.2887604832649231, -1.0201705694198608, -0.10167979449033737, -0.5568291544914246, 0.3972001075744629, -0.715951144695282, -0.6502485871315002, -0.2833419144153595, 0.18165937066078186, -0.2903423309326172, -0.006297700572758913, -0.24543721973896027, -0.23699229955673218, -0.19603697955608368, -0.2388702630996704, -0.6494988799095154, -0.01604551076889038, -0.06954579800367355, 0.6684085726737976, -0.05485885217785835, 0.2337477058172226, 0.0075907111167907715, 0.5160333514213562, 0.685624361038208, -0.007689428981393576, -0.307847261428833, 0.5144128203392029, 0.6633110642433167, -0.06247148662805557, 0.5514783263206482, 0.40115731954574585, 0.30520525574684143, -0.2959214746952057, -0.3907262086868286, 0.2592228055000305, 0.24908053874969482, -0.4006308913230896, 0.03789093345403671, -0.10566377639770508, 0.622644305229187, -0.38561514019966125, 0.4186975955963135, -0.02907286398112774, 0.2517089545726776, 0.06045684218406677, -0.4514152407646179, -0.3589418828487396, -0.5657130479812622, -0.19316639006137848, 0.721028745174408, -0.1317485123872757, 0.45749056339263916, 0.1942540556192398, -0.2730165123939514, -0.37086915969848633, -0.6155853867530823, 0.6530648469924927, -0.46652987599372864, -0.3199147880077362, -0.33193647861480713, 0.6078715920448303, 0.5318703651428223, -0.2363595813512802, 0.48016899824142456, -0.15731294453144073, 0.1522803008556366, 0.12125598639249802, -0.19445346295833588, 0.9850723743438721, 0.5184915065765381, 0.4672735035419464, 0.5087236166000366, 0.5180286169052124, 0.09298104047775269, 0.1468936949968338, -0.2850477993488312, -1.0835342407226562, 0.25680702924728394, 0.4410804808139801, -0.3211591839790344, -0.2087171971797943, 0.47228220105171204, -0.8964405059814453, -0.7218385338783264, -0.4465087652206421, 0.259635329246521, -1.12504243850708, 0.2752242684364319, 0.8105734586715698, -0.360638827085495, -0.08860880136489868, 1.105293869972229, 0.08084537088871002, 0.3631851077079773, 0.32537388801574707, 0.05805419385433197, 0.37358346581459045, 0.7971344590187073, 0.4052695333957672, -0.00025070924311876297, -0.26711326837539673, 0.1410786211490631, -0.0995473712682724, -0.14788232743740082, 0.17800132930278778, -0.2863355875015259, 0.4609032869338989, -0.20792661607265472, -0.12248528003692627, 0.2501622438430786, -0.5468329191207886, -0.30707037448883057, 0.9287551641464233, -0.022486232221126556, 0.5861714482307434, -0.634470522403717, -0.327818363904953, -0.18507349491119385, 0.27116477489471436, 0.6042407155036926, -0.22862276434898376, -0.13917328417301178, -1.2283307313919067, -0.35226523876190186, -0.4021460711956024, -0.011920841410756111, -0.22302623093128204, -0.1537107676267624, -0.20751886069774628, 0.07049030065536499, 0.38872337341308594, -0.05642145499587059, -0.19384510815143585, -0.71929931640625, 0.3572085201740265, 0.40249204635620117, 0.2757469713687897, 0.5310475826263428, -0.8902590870857239, -0.46237459778785706, -0.03505872189998627, 0.07729179412126541, 0.048910971730947495, -0.39363619685173035, 0.5957253575325012, 0.435323029756546, -0.18700987100601196, 0.5762717127799988, 0.21685610711574554, -0.6765000820159912, 0.6977720856666565, 0.35598763823509216, 0.058264702558517456, -0.24088074266910553, -0.05018825829029083, -0.14213208854198456, 0.5313092470169067, -0.204018235206604, 0.27888792753219604, -0.44320133328437805, 0.07822426408529282, -0.5687865614891052, -0.43313834071159363, -0.9850826263427734, 0.43190234899520874, 0.13869482278823853, -0.30021509528160095, -0.28565141558647156, -0.655010998249054, 4.261294364929199, 0.9637669920921326, 0.49235236644744873, -0.2373296618461609, 0.6203171014785767, 0.24980968236923218, 0.23148725926876068, -1.325380802154541, 0.3946726322174072, -0.6369014978408813, 0.5102456212043762, -0.6938220858573914, 0.5587606430053711, -0.7075366377830505, 0.3760119676589966, 0.8883921504020691, 0.10935078561306, -0.7822173237800598, 1.2282196283340454, -0.419393390417099, -1.1596711874008179, 0.5757447481155396, -0.3284030854701996, -0.14558060467243195, 0.14863716065883636, 0.24637655913829803, 0.6984890699386597, -0.7039985656738281, 0.07344679534435272, -0.4628487527370453, -0.40826216340065, -0.33996909856796265, 0.5851127505302429, -0.33765050768852234, -0.4017917811870575, 0.6443450450897217, -0.27893581986427307, -0.34403860569000244, 0.02046630159020424, 0.015321530401706696, 0.12818643450737, -0.4765305519104004, 0.18064230680465698, 0.046428751200437546, -0.2001379430294037, 1.5534547567367554, 0.31207573413848877, -0.3538816571235657, 1.1440085172653198, -0.5513434410095215, 0.2551512122154236, -0.43339598178863525, 0.11490999907255173, 0.23733240365982056, -0.6715437769889832, -0.42548733949661255, 0.3942243456840515, -0.4485778510570526, 0.3414807617664337, -0.06310798972845078, 0.4907299876213074, -0.42954760789871216, -0.8497669100761414, 0.7717780470848083, -0.8427004814147949, 0.5987250804901123, 0.1678457111120224, -0.07243958115577698, -0.4213911294937134, -0.2570391893386841, -0.3831646144390106, -0.4720926582813263, -0.33764636516571045, 0.39687493443489075, 0.07792002707719803, 0.0781547948718071, -0.35585492849349976, 0.010375511832535267, -0.5316022038459778, -0.03321045637130737, -0.3464619815349579, 0.07865501195192337, -0.43763965368270874, 0.4887274503707886, 0.24501800537109375, 0.5286701321601868, -0.32554152607917786, -0.43506407737731934, 0.013211051002144814, 0.2062123864889145, -0.19430826604366302, -0.0948716476559639, -0.1621783822774887, -0.7268500328063965, -0.4250388741493225 ]
The Edge of the Galactic Disc
As part of a stellar population sampling program, a series of photometric probes at various field sizes and depths have been obtained in a low extinction window in the galactic anticentre direction. Such data set strong constraints on the radial structure of the disc. At the forefront of this "drilling" program, very deep CCD frames probe the most external parts of the disc. Over the whole effective magnitude range (18 to 25), all contributions in the statistics which should be expected from old disc stars beyond 6 kpc vanish, although such stars dominate by far at distances less than 5 kpc. This is the signature of a sharp cut-off in the star density: the edge of the galactic disc between 5.5 and 6 kpc. As a consequence, the galactic radius does not exceed 14 kpc (assuming $R/-/(//sun/)$=8.5). Colours of elliptical galaxies measured in the field rule out the risk of being misled by undetected extinction.
Annie C. Robin, Michel Creze, Vijay Mohan
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210001
astro-ph/9210002
[ 0.3025800883769989, 0.4326625168323517, 0.6911947131156921, 0.039341237396001816, -1.044050931930542, 0.16345441341400146, -0.9392279386520386, -0.215899258852005, -0.4685530960559845, 1.5487174987792969, -0.6894030570983887, -0.6659664511680603, -0.03468118607997894, -0.43056049942970276, -0.21060000360012054, 0.17106254398822784, 0.04972776770591736, -0.07213881611824036, -1.6193065643310547, 0.26913583278656006, 0.02773859351873398, -0.24083103239536285, -0.8660290241241455, -0.20026101171970367, -0.14436151087284088, 0.7961808443069458, -0.01446805614978075, 0.6629764437675476, 1.2893075942993164, 0.8254980444908142, -0.6486406922340393, -0.9107217788696289, 0.1147526279091835, -1.1860430240631104, -0.4018629491329193, -0.1587151139974594, 0.27727609872817993, 0.10409755259752274, -0.27939271926879883, -0.764756977558136, 0.9845519661903381, -0.5242554545402527, 0.20888903737068176, -0.4292750060558319, -0.42003971338272095, -0.16258825361728668, -0.9917852282524109, -0.40326523780822754, 0.7204745411872864, -0.2763172388076782, -0.1794685423374176, -0.14101168513298035, 0.8344038128852844, -0.7984607219696045, -0.08945844322443008, 0.33975669741630554, 0.40637728571891785, 0.22656553983688354, -0.10952866077423096, -0.5419602394104004, 0.5361821055412292, 0.6721267104148865, -0.09786021709442139, -0.7809334397315979, -0.11385875195264816, 0.8397091031074524, -0.5187913179397583, 0.5932468771934509, -0.04647931084036827, -0.29677698016166687, 0.0362834669649601, 0.45596763491630554, -0.3804935812950134, -0.47930824756622314, -0.5567275285720825, -0.0011007918510586023, 0.016067171469330788, -0.8088279962539673, -0.3351924419403076, 0.1668960005044937, -0.4109889566898346, 0.17779307067394257, 0.450870156288147, 0.055131688714027405, 0.7127533555030823, -0.36869141459465027, 0.015370110049843788, 0.20749394595623016, 0.4446895718574524, 0.6937671303749084, -0.45814087986946106, 0.4097493588924408, -0.08911451697349548, -0.32621169090270996, 0.4713446795940399, 0.34811872243881226, -0.10058295726776123, 0.34436100721359253, 0.2559657692909241, 0.5658056139945984, 0.11128894239664078, 0.27170971035957336, -0.567442774772644, 0.5205861926078796, -0.4287729859352112, 0.5043551325798035, 0.4578701853752136, -0.18382631242275238, -0.022692495957016945, -0.6739668250083923, 0.08438391983509064, 0.172834575176239, 0.5637913942337036, 0.5480479001998901, 0.30540162324905396, 0.2187788039445877, -0.28699517250061035, 0.3243674635887146, -0.7631716132164001, -0.5761976838111877, -0.023854896426200867, 0.8645113706588745, 0.5928845405578613, 0.3946474492549896, 0.02196582593023777, -0.9160798192024231, 0.06907445937395096, -0.1785140037536621, -0.7922716736793518, -0.3760489821434021, 0.20458324253559113, -0.7598366737365723, -0.624416172504425, 1.3178024291992188, 0.19548586010932922, 0.004489904269576073, 0.4906633496284485, 0.9077290892601013, -0.28227052092552185, -0.5633792281150818, -0.2201698124408722, -0.27441126108169556, -0.2704402804374695, 1.5231317281723022, -0.5192782282829285, 0.8620272278785706, -0.1736355572938919, -0.4611939489841461, -0.2977684438228607, -0.026653891429305077, 0.11951005458831787, -0.78939288854599, -0.556298017501831, 0.5263550877571106, -0.7452967166900635, -0.22078795731067657, -0.7377893924713135, 0.06296593695878983, -0.2747163772583008, -0.40550529956817627, 0.45458880066871643, -0.6683458685874939, -0.3966310918331146, 0.14138692617416382, -0.16819845139980316, 0.5144255757331848, -0.6337669491767883, -0.8666790127754211, 0.8128982782363892, -0.25871866941452026, -0.11582845449447632, -0.30505484342575073, -0.35704752802848816, 0.36408811807632446, 0.1802307814359665, 0.00805679801851511, 0.46279460191726685, -0.3652741611003876, -0.06463736295700073, 0.3415065407752991, -0.2457788735628128, -0.507740318775177, -0.4092743396759033, 0.06719553470611572, 0.3113217353820801, -0.4506652355194092, 0.06041567027568817, -0.11097639054059982, 0.16153781116008759, -0.1260591298341751, 0.27258241176605225, 0.4139935374259949, -0.7708039879798889, 0.8725481629371643, -0.8453232645988464, 0.3975704610347748, -0.6543307900428772, -0.02053561806678772, 0.06241142377257347, -0.08039360493421555, 0.6584901809692383, -0.1267676204442978, -0.4896325170993805, 0.6136917471885681, 0.061711132526397705, 0.0852467492222786, 1.064260721206665, 0.2376677542924881, 0.13239486515522003, 0.2720644772052765, 0.8393095135688782, 0.04547000676393509, -0.21218569576740265, -0.1366257518529892, 0.7699993252754211, -0.2842004895210266, 0.5975636839866638, 1.1285656690597534, -0.5781905055046082, -0.28426235914230347, 0.6407844424247742, 0.4253014326095581, -0.006723171100020409, 0.697396457195282, 0.010592074133455753, -0.2155349850654602, -0.2611750066280365, 0.6931601166725159, 0.43049511313438416, 0.17686335742473602, -0.3118043839931488, -0.15951251983642578, 0.49476125836372375, 0.4680746793746948, 0.3495055139064789, -0.17158916592597961, 0.6843971014022827, 0.5227609276771545, -0.19300545752048492, -0.5879045724868774, -0.15389220416545868, -0.2579640746116638, 0.38191401958465576, -0.26581379771232605, -0.2340095490217209, 0.745857834815979, -0.17451021075248718, -0.46497243642807007, -0.6562196016311646, 0.19511884450912476, -0.731168806552887, 0.7007842063903809, 0.25765907764434814, 0.053178124129772186, -0.708843469619751, -0.9900064468383789, 0.14502568542957306, 0.19861367344856262, -0.3820350766181946, -0.4983403980731964, -0.24231764674186707, -0.0015463174786418676, 0.6896368861198425, -0.615274965763092, 0.3661945164203644, 0.1837380975484848, -0.5480380058288574, 0.3389873504638672, 0.5108004212379456, -0.7480787038803101, -1.043056607246399, 0.07944636791944504, -0.385737806558609, 0.44434356689453125, 0.21793055534362793, 0.16389648616313934, 0.33486753702163696, -0.5173685550689697, 0.4353770315647125, -0.03986306115984917, -0.12983939051628113, 0.03370118886232376, -0.5317754149436951, -0.07540687918663025, -0.6709379553794861, 0.34819161891937256, -0.4398646950721741, 0.600369930267334, -0.35640913248062134, -0.4225054085254669, -0.2362722009420395, 0.290759801864624, -0.9736848473548889, -0.33645257353782654, 0.7603092193603516, -0.09953204542398453, -0.17273348569869995, 0.8570172786712646, 0.5627692341804504, -0.531152606010437, 0.27368295192718506, 0.14894942939281464, -1.3044445514678955, -1.0954879522323608, -1.2250553369522095, 0.3439849019050598, -0.3574811816215515, -0.2754090130329132, 0.08550867438316345, 0.5375025868415833, -0.4994225800037384, 0.021537235006690025, 0.319316565990448, 0.3201124966144562, -0.36601245403289795, 0.19971618056297302, 0.47629332542419434, -0.26958250999450684, 0.5591367483139038, -0.34632861614227295, -1.3290998935699463, -0.5409978032112122, 0.6929866075515747, -0.21949659287929535, 0.3847493529319763, 0.745287299156189, 0.01479236502200365, -0.40362614393234253, 0.3157491385936737, -0.32170194387435913, -0.43383511900901794, -0.2033577263355255, -0.33039698004722595, 0.4152128994464874, -0.1324344128370285, -0.21412116289138794, -0.45200198888778687, -0.23050075769424438, 0.1259143203496933, 0.5999287366867065, 0.7388888001441956, -0.48757404088974, 0.2607823312282562, 1.0575529336929321, -0.13526242971420288, -0.07825500518083572, 0.4962903559207916, -0.5044353008270264, -0.144321471452713, 0.4009013772010803, -0.5643566250801086, 0.16019243001937866, 0.12637673318386078, 0.6441705822944641, -0.025228062644600868, 0.46939751505851746, -0.006652205716818571, 0.05296074599027634, -0.4503706395626068, -0.7493599653244019, -0.09858600795269012, 0.07282505929470062, 0.31692445278167725, -0.13634762167930603, 0.21126610040664673, -0.30398765206336975, -0.004812960047274828, -0.08302150666713715, 0.29671424627304077, -0.9667426347732544, 0.4355478882789612, 0.4103997051715851, -0.10439994186162949, -0.5520985126495361, 0.47895652055740356, 0.5640872716903687, 0.34402886033058167, -0.1475214958190918, 0.7870043516159058, -0.3594743311405182, -0.3287639617919922, 0.25867000222206116, 0.5368409752845764, 0.035720761865377426, -0.6070203185081482, -0.4249599874019623, 0.03601514920592308, 0.14893034100532532, -0.3544830083847046, -0.6259382367134094, -0.5283157825469971, -0.4811258614063263, -0.03772842884063721, -0.5031331181526184, -1.1904243230819702, -0.1680033802986145, 1.1737295389175415, -0.02865239605307579, 0.19055180251598358, -0.027542492374777794, 0.059687934815883636, 0.10535530000925064, 0.5366607904434204, 0.16768157482147217, 0.12924110889434814, 0.44195544719696045, -0.3695504665374756, 0.1527097374200821, 0.521727979183197, -0.0695379301905632, 0.2643466889858246, 0.7484160661697388, 0.012381920590996742, -0.1939517706632614, 0.32168444991111755, 0.8107715249061584, -0.3587339222431183, 0.24098724126815796, -0.2649690806865692, -0.20333893597126007, -0.3855058550834656, 0.21782155334949493, 0.200129896402359, 0.32763221859931946, 0.1514216959476471, -0.9210000038146973, 0.6560351252555847, -0.779914379119873, 0.23073193430900574, 0.19507455825805664, -0.5004189014434814, -0.1385340392589569, -0.451610803604126, 0.20162104070186615, 0.12291005998849869, 0.9897502064704895, 0.7877493500709534, -0.11101030558347702, 0.10883044451475143, -0.0017011966556310654, 0.19726809859275818, 0.12012786418199539, -0.8490568995475769, -0.033468540757894516, 0.5190277695655823, 0.43823516368865967, -0.0728420540690422, 0.16452118754386902, 0.0745026171207428, -0.8196598887443542, -0.47716662287712097, -1.1489732265472412, 0.3215321898460388, -0.3251596689224243, -0.6305974721908569, 0.7630649209022522, -0.08540957421064377, -0.21130967140197754, 0.2877627909183502, 0.2958228588104248, -0.14872358739376068, 0.7095479369163513, -0.4685578942298889, -0.002580665983259678, -0.5427584648132324, 0.012637291103601456, 0.15127788484096527, 0.8614653944969177, 0.44367170333862305, 0.1667695790529251, 0.5142450928688049, 1.032971739768982, -0.12999925017356873, -0.1917179822921753, -0.320230096578598, -0.9507761597633362, -0.2505277991294861, -0.4686068594455719, -0.07971556484699249, -0.028054047375917435, 0.44072261452674866, 0.2833286225795746, -0.3106080889701843, 0.32366064190864563, -0.2554810345172882, -0.5487775802612305, -0.10583554953336716, 0.36835700273513794, -1.1116812229156494, 0.9080685973167419, 0.03058423101902008, -0.26181745529174805, -0.5785878300666809, -0.23029880225658417, 0.4675138592720032, -0.5041833519935608, -0.33193591237068176, -0.8683813810348511, 0.5498773455619812, 0.17768679559230804, 0.1782534122467041, -0.06511552631855011, -0.5426676869392395, 0.27995437383651733, -0.14554350078105927, -0.594344973564148, -0.7329155802726746, -0.10714486241340637, -0.22969907522201538, 0.534615159034729, 0.17513470351696014, 0.14953118562698364, -0.12051843106746674, 0.0007139700464904308, -0.9220771193504333, 0.35242265462875366, 0.7548618316650391, -0.779586672782898, 0.586654007434845, 0.628235936164856, 0.48061227798461914, -0.8513757586479187, 0.07794807851314545, 0.7781391739845276, 0.08645662665367126, 0.5093446373939514, -0.5218077301979065, -0.18827280402183533, 0.6463745832443237, -0.7524569630622864, 0.18962255120277405, -0.8681069016456604, 0.1811164915561676, -0.07685612887144089, -0.8032378554344177, -0.21758607029914856, 0.3562980592250824, 0.7158868908882141, -0.26709455251693726, -0.8228372931480408, 0.1775127798318863, 0.6811524033546448, -0.42732495069503784, 0.11518669128417969, -0.23095573484897614, 0.10587410628795624, -0.08196157962083817, 0.8669246435165405, -0.5642302632331848, -0.2652719020843506, 0.18267421424388885, -0.3610074520111084, 0.02370680496096611, 0.3489401042461395, -0.28755635023117065, -0.1646675169467926, 0.07877729088068008, 0.5333057641983032, 1.0431602001190186, -0.10660034418106079, -0.7814561724662781, -0.013751777820289135, -0.67027747631073, -0.2828125059604645, 0.37778645753860474, -0.20127160847187042, -0.3911229968070984, 0.3635861277580261, 0.8047628402709961, 0.03178899735212326, 0.21302157640457153, 1.2410879135131836, 0.17278878390789032, -0.07847847044467926, 0.8730601668357849, -0.16391953825950623, -0.26341572403907776, -0.5324682593345642, -0.7057515382766724, 0.38949811458587646, 0.354495644569397, -0.07263315469026566, -0.37243205308914185, -0.22525383532047272, 0.10705552995204926, -0.437161386013031, 0.6255956888198853, 0.7221902012825012, 0.3381188213825226, -0.04838143661618233, -0.6135171055793762, 0.39070332050323486, -0.4760136604309082, 0.738885223865509, 0.6022196412086487, -0.03170441836118698, -0.8472427129745483, -0.13800059258937836, -0.027775777503848076, -0.22125893831253052, -0.2620581388473511, 0.21557773649692535, 0.3807049095630646, -0.19321268796920776, 1.292487382888794, 0.2015317678451538, -0.379692941904068, 0.08198532462120056, 0.6170108318328857, 1.0736759901046753, 0.1607581079006195, 0.20172472298145294, -0.31401360034942627, 0.34208089113235474, 0.4258182644844055, 0.1437138319015503, -0.3158870041370392, -0.35125601291656494, 0.9190775156021118, -0.6608945727348328, -0.08292821049690247, 0.24427053332328796, 0.6444952487945557, -0.41315242648124695, -0.46066030859947205, -0.6749619245529175, 0.16403165459632874, 0.42444145679473877, -0.4953330457210541, -0.12830550968647003, -0.02387355826795101, -0.42329686880111694, 0.045806221663951874, 0.17192110419273376, 0.37755489349365234, 0.1712285429239273, -0.04481789469718933, -0.4027911424636841, -0.6997170448303223, -0.023612095043063164, 1.516161561012268, -0.31633827090263367, -0.7496530413627625, -0.20462064445018768, -0.15725277364253998, -0.5082919597625732, 0.0551748089492321, 1.3739659786224365, -0.3135715425014496, 0.030441349372267723, -0.3332640826702118, 0.4862796664237976, 0.22512197494506836, 0.719886302947998, -0.22602708637714386, 0.7499922513961792, -0.5450332164764404, -0.7422758340835571, -0.23840467631816864, 0.45937660336494446, 0.19443973898887634, 0.6852627396583557, 0.36973440647125244, -0.16492509841918945, -0.19078455865383148, -0.7460538744926453, -0.08246264606714249, -0.18511958420276642, -0.28040629625320435, -0.665244996547699, -0.6164098381996155, -0.6013529896736145, -0.7666823267936707, -0.13964559137821198, 0.817403256893158, 0.001580936135724187, -0.20354081690311432, 0.7013243436813354, 0.20902298390865326, 0.19587986171245575, 0.20050287246704102, -0.13508503139019012, -0.32874205708503723, -0.32318079471588135, 0.09577731788158417, -0.034319840371608734, -1.0379117727279663, -0.1699954867362976, 0.39108023047447205, -0.0896720290184021, 0.300617516040802, 0.40588879585266113, 0.5002700090408325, -0.19631004333496094, -0.09364734590053558, -0.41161540150642395, -0.05195901170372963, -1.0804774761199951, 0.9974658489227295, 0.18170952796936035, 0.93161541223526, 0.7128186225891113, 0.21274565160274506, 0.14135298132896423, 0.1655907779932022, -0.36052390933036804, 0.40690380334854126, 0.12642887234687805, 0.624528706073761, 0.0998074933886528, -0.11502130329608917, -0.8100956082344055, 1.628035545349121, -0.714928388595581, -0.8198786973953247, -0.2426316738128662, 0.19237247109413147, 0.6071961522102356, 0.040701013058423996, -0.42501088976860046, 0.2797841727733612, 0.3417670726776123, -0.2636449337005615, -0.3181796967983246, 0.07977013289928436, -0.6819409132003784, 0.4101555347442627, -0.5603021383285522, -0.4180946946144104, 0.4144285321235657, -1.0688092708587646, 1.2957720756530762, 0.5708321928977966, -0.23286375403404236, -0.12763690948486328, -0.5402076840400696, -0.3256545662879944, -0.2795937657356262, -0.032809577882289886, -0.07135594636201859, 0.7333114147186279, 0.7745875120162964, -0.02911141887307167, -0.03629641607403755, -0.060783419758081436, -0.9200372099876404, 0.5257413983345032, 0.03623170405626297, -0.4544103443622589, 0.10821475833654404, -0.7121926546096802, 0.04814429208636284, 0.35695716738700867, -0.08564920723438263, 0.0916701927781105, -0.29848676919937134, 0.32264402508735657, 0.3184540569782257, -0.09775137901306152, -0.5414808988571167, 0.4580508768558502, -0.9157206416130066, -0.16262146830558777, 0.09373010694980621, -0.24605602025985718, -1.0200769901275635, -0.7367871999740601, -0.08637601137161255, 0.8967729806900024, 0.4301571846008301, -0.6836826205253601, -0.726985514163971, 0.035006456077098846, -0.8239012360572815, 0.2710345685482025, -0.6779168844223022, -1.0378011465072632, -0.35389018058776855, -0.176017627120018, -0.2354450672864914, 0.153470978140831, 0.1082690954208374, -0.23278290033340454, 1.022645354270935, -0.6485856771469116, -0.2866981029510498, 0.6984248161315918, 0.48734933137893677, -0.41559189558029175, -0.051724884659051895, -0.09651851654052734, 0.13307838141918182, 0.6770726442337036, -0.42242005467414856, -0.058725789189338684, 0.5290323495864868, -0.039379242807626724, 0.21405035257339478, -0.2169867902994156, -0.128309965133667, -0.06888290494680405, 0.07905687391757965, 0.10297802835702896, -0.25496983528137207, 0.47605597972869873, 0.4753432273864746, -0.2777394652366638, -0.6646218299865723, -0.2994078993797302, 0.42097339034080505, 0.12365272641181946, -0.11168612539768219, 0.13859879970550537, -0.1470431387424469, -0.4107145071029663, -0.5869624614715576, 0.3411884605884552, -0.7353174090385437, -0.8353215456008911, -0.661995530128479, 0.2654187083244324, 0.3406362235546112, -0.5194336771965027, 0.44461917877197266, 0.36763590574264526, 0.09732390195131302, 0.44524499773979187, 0.15875646471977234, 0.8445804119110107, 0.6065513491630554, 0.5551656484603882, 0.004430864006280899, 0.5232447385787964, 0.1885042041540146, 0.38883763551712036, -0.35279569029808044, -0.8247859477996826, -0.1840045303106308, 0.3920385539531708, -0.852851390838623, -0.03736498951911926, -0.26369041204452515, -0.5233685374259949, 0.03413493558764458, -0.4521195590496063, 0.1905326545238495, -0.8939107060432434, 0.27786967158317566, 1.0279780626296997, -0.07883839309215546, 0.44508975744247437, 0.23428629338741302, 0.275328665971756, -0.23140324652194977, 0.33246585726737976, 0.01510703843086958, -0.08931535482406616, 0.9689279794692993, 0.917576253414154, 0.14270064234733582, 0.08202523738145828, -0.8169997930526733, 0.3171284794807434, -0.34391117095947266, 0.012043976224958897, -0.2715056538581848, 1.0112658739089966, -0.10515651851892471, 0.20251166820526123, -0.42207178473472595, 0.1035737469792366, -0.23062245547771454, 0.25510263442993164, 0.4855453670024872, -0.25487515330314636, -0.4540118873119354, -0.24785898625850677, 0.14554286003112793, 0.6840017437934875, -0.05041377246379852, -0.5611289739608765, 0.1926732361316681, -0.7752375602722168, -0.2861841022968292, 0.3360143005847931, 0.5828269124031067, -0.6738571524620056, -0.5691561102867126, 0.07111099362373352, -0.34645140171051025, -0.016801532357931137, 0.15987510979175568, -0.7512219548225403, -0.24712179601192474, -0.2877874970436096, 0.6472727656364441, 0.7967007160186768, 0.40766674280166626, -0.6640802621841431, -0.06787986308336258, 0.03625357523560524, 0.43646684288978577, -0.3890993893146515, -0.34908202290534973, 1.5572925806045532, -0.014636746607720852, -0.40175434947013855, 0.7895967364311218, -0.12157250195741653, -0.3992840051651001, 0.03044523112475872, 0.2705448865890503, 0.4951222836971283, 0.030617348849773407, -0.28287211060523987, 0.28385284543037415, 0.848225474357605, 0.4771263003349304, 0.22787900269031525, 0.07174602895975113, 0.18022680282592773, -0.3719770908355713, 0.15456129610538483, 0.23067200183868408, 1.1397308111190796, 0.31053462624549866, 0.24867811799049377, 0.5302498936653137, -0.9801906943321228, 4.342537879943848, 0.580985426902771, 0.5320175290107727, -0.03210127353668213, 0.00397112499922514, 0.5590543150901794, 0.07109665125608444, -0.7478100657463074, 0.29967164993286133, -0.3521246314048767, -0.3086237609386444, -0.012692417949438095, 0.12611618638038635, -0.06801536679267883, -0.34164148569107056, 0.8544108271598816, -0.058425892144441605, -0.4109184741973877, 0.19354288280010223, -0.3183010220527649, -0.8387002944946289, 0.21478262543678284, 0.02308725006878376, -0.11329933255910873, 0.16721060872077942, -0.04273122921586037, 0.5535687208175659, -0.37065279483795166, 0.4058113098144531, -0.3942580819129944, -0.4564483165740967, -0.27284178137779236, 0.49114206433296204, -0.7066124081611633, -0.6513539552688599, 0.2777755558490753, 0.27496370673179626, -0.44082120060920715, 0.1123395711183548, -0.1676754355430603, -0.01689797453582287, 0.19379876554012299, 0.17802448570728302, -0.7981186509132385, -0.3966336250305176, 1.1074503660202026, 0.37910935282707214, -0.0667925775051117, 0.4616800546646118, -0.9534766674041748, 0.5482878088951111, -0.17123481631278992, 0.03022005409002304, -0.28351110219955444, -0.8224051594734192, -0.11121927946805954, 0.6665817499160767, -0.37403053045272827, 0.0034320210106670856, -0.07860977202653885, 0.4369303286075592, 0.0019064260413870215, -0.2719454765319824, 0.6693595051765442, -0.48761579394340515, 0.5536731481552124, 0.09664294868707657, -0.09637980163097382, -0.48893487453460693, -0.1615753471851349, -0.10679499059915543, 0.003985361196100712, -0.8187789916992188, -0.4756155014038086, -0.5985916256904602, -0.10347113013267517, 0.10099896788597107, 0.10656767338514328, -0.5011608600616455, -0.31645408272743225, 0.11379306763410568, -0.14084090292453766, -0.7612942457199097, 0.032992493361234665, 0.24820289015769958, -0.03267513960599899, 0.09105384349822998, -0.27879849076271057, -0.29571253061294556, 0.7463064789772034, 0.1547824740409851, 0.04147665947675705, -0.19744257628917694, -0.2640992999076843, -0.1994965821504593 ]
Coordinated UV-optical observations of quasars: the evolution of the Lyman absorption
The average flux decrement shortward the Ly$_{\alpha}$ emission, due to the well-known ``forest'' of absorptions, has been measured in the spectra of 8 quasars. Quasi-simultaneous optical and IUE observations of the two low redshift quasars PKS 0637--75 (z=0.654) and MC 1104+16 (z=0.632) have been carried out, obtaining relatively high S/N, spectrophotometrically calibrated data on their energy distribution from the rest frame H$_{\beta}$ to the Lyman continuum. Six more quasars in the redshift range 2.5-3.4 have been observed in the optical domain. For all the quasars the ``intrinsic'' continuum slope and normalization have been estimated longward the Ly$_{\alpha}$ emission and extrapolated towards the Lyman continuum to measure the average depressions, which have been compared with the model statistics of the Ly$_{\alpha}$ clouds. When all the known classes of absorbers are taken into account with plausible values for their equivalent width distribution and evolution, a good agreement is obtained with the observations. The results for the observed continuum decrement at $z \sim 0.65$ are identical to those predicted by the evolution with redshift of the number of Ly$_{\alpha}$ forest systems including the HST data and within $2\sigma$ of the predicted value using the ``standard'' Ly$_{\alpha}$ evolution (as determined only at high z).
S. Cristiani, E. Giallongo, L. M. Buson, C. Gouiffes, F. La Franca
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210002
astro-ph/9210003
[ 0.11260394006967545, 0.40686067938804626, 0.02331756427884102, 0.04194631427526474, -0.8536362648010254, -0.169027641415596, -0.04148104786872864, 0.1119222342967987, -1.3272241353988647, 1.0519077777862549, 0.004330684896558523, -0.06362593919038773, 0.06853409111499786, -1.110579490661621, -0.4583456218242645, -0.6311730146408081, -0.4790126383304596, -0.27945998311042786, -1.1545408964157104, 0.3220311403274536, 0.14426787197589874, 0.3572468161582947, -1.0382949113845825, -0.18429656326770782, -0.6626763343811035, 0.5526899695396423, 0.6980675458908081, 0.17075754702091217, 0.8303273916244507, 0.8111512064933777, 0.18372491002082825, -0.8706114292144775, 0.17190317809581757, -1.278587818145752, 0.44956478476524353, -0.18515291810035706, 0.4597516357898712, -0.4099138677120209, 0.55397629737854, -0.2216925472021103, 0.5141645073890686, 0.14472050964832306, 0.1139998659491539, -0.5454463362693787, -0.44388583302497864, -0.4054439961910248, -1.2415189743041992, 0.029067251831293106, 0.267363965511322, -0.8796276450157166, 0.1635829210281372, 0.3942547142505646, 0.9381455779075623, -0.0787724032998085, -0.09833317995071411, -0.3916310667991638, -0.18062548339366913, 0.3371136784553528, -0.44206953048706055, -0.5549724102020264, 0.04064572975039482, 0.2763148546218872, 0.6111564040184021, -0.34275075793266296, 0.02514805644750595, 1.6122784614562988, -0.42350080609321594, -0.06649007648229599, -0.17041708528995514, -0.34575212001800537, -0.11306829750537872, 0.4418613910675049, -0.568398118019104, 0.11539264023303986, -0.3756727874279022, 0.53033846616745, 0.39440229535102844, 0.10357974469661713, -0.5552797913551331, -0.056299202144145966, -0.159491166472435, 0.32809364795684814, 0.4937630891799927, 0.5733820199966431, 0.17097313702106476, -0.17114821076393127, 0.37464001774787903, 0.274461954832077, -0.2191377878189087, -0.08683574199676514, -0.6823260188102722, 0.32620689272880554, -0.7357933521270752, -0.14676283299922943, 1.0627015829086304, -0.027125723659992218, -0.3155146539211273, 0.6103571057319641, 0.6535323858261108, 0.4308224022388458, 0.26641276478767395, 1.1971362829208374, -0.6234393119812012, 0.4545900523662567, -0.5871245265007019, 0.517541229724884, 0.27042102813720703, -0.20076091587543488, -0.1646532118320465, -1.26834237575531, 0.3925665318965912, -0.18380215764045715, 0.5573968291282654, -0.25145748257637024, 0.49162036180496216, 0.724612295627594, 0.03740730136632919, 0.5821813344955444, -0.3414209187030792, -0.6990901827812195, -0.20181210339069366, 0.2559807598590851, 0.34073060750961304, 0.20124231278896332, 0.17339672148227692, -0.46452435851097107, 0.014924035407602787, -0.042296815663576126, -0.8121045827865601, 0.37558943033218384, 0.05625542998313904, 0.05102277174592018, -0.4593648612499237, 0.7345760464668274, -0.4205532371997833, 0.23985429108142853, -0.08166752755641937, 0.5824330449104309, -0.01457025483250618, -0.9730754494667053, 0.5341877937316895, -0.12344451993703842, -0.6180805563926697, 1.1053673028945923, -0.452514111995697, 0.03041282296180725, 0.1806315779685974, -0.1720903068780899, -0.7572363018989563, 0.6616899371147156, -0.09662830084562302, -0.7368699908256531, -0.19943828880786896, 0.6110151410102844, -0.4503577947616577, 0.2558155655860901, 0.27231892943382263, 0.02470777928829193, 0.05297470465302467, -0.42570245265960693, -0.17228353023529053, -0.24665473401546478, -0.09841924905776978, 0.35631152987480164, -0.05815880373120308, 0.5272806882858276, -0.4681721031665802, -0.8897674083709717, -0.12689486145973206, -0.050702355802059174, 0.13665999472141266, 0.19909091293811798, -0.3974197208881378, 0.6609178185462952, 0.5312082767486572, 0.03307836130261421, 0.8601217269897461, 0.02929375134408474, -0.21730704605579376, 0.28086167573928833, -0.6271307468414307, -0.5435398817062378, 0.620097815990448, -0.21579822897911072, -0.7404088973999023, -0.36272546648979187, -0.19998742640018463, -0.3807797431945801, 0.21683520078659058, 0.157162144780159, 0.025571826845407486, 0.03662126883864403, -0.3916879892349243, 0.9131973385810852, -0.882683515548706, -0.035670071840286255, -0.13990457355976105, 0.07530432939529419, -0.027470668777823448, -1.2378456592559814, 0.40729570388793945, 0.16991762816905975, 0.07973787933588028, 0.07295606285333633, -0.14382189512252808, -0.28579217195510864, 0.8823952078819275, 0.537926435470581, -0.008888638578355312, 0.8911243677139282, 0.1635483205318451, -0.08969546109437943, 0.3076007068157196, -0.038781747221946716, 0.43922701478004456, -0.2225923389196396, 0.02619844302535057, 0.7716491222381592, -0.5482956767082214, 0.1772378534078598, 0.6356625556945801, 0.3015471398830414, 0.38338398933410645, 0.8302285075187683, 0.3332405388355255, -0.3392808437347412, -0.2599245309829712, 1.1655397415161133, -0.021289566531777382, 0.03883327171206474, -0.14258331060409546, 0.09338310360908508, 0.808504581451416, 0.358166366815567, 0.43985608220100403, -0.007296358235180378, 0.8537875413894653, 0.49664464592933655, 0.479934960603714, -0.2782624661922455, -0.3112015724182129, -0.33924928307533264, -0.06195002794265747, -0.3115915060043335, 0.15308967232704163, 1.1658748388290405, -0.056239452213048935, -0.3087027966976166, -0.4297688603401184, 0.7081869840621948, -0.26345574855804443, 0.4403000771999359, 0.45321884751319885, 0.31178534030914307, -0.782852828502655, -0.7897055745124817, 0.13992737233638763, -0.14478357136249542, -0.44876134395599365, -0.5157803893089294, 0.16411039233207703, 0.2546081244945526, -0.35662272572517395, -0.18961724638938904, -0.22389602661132812, 0.4337766170501709, -0.7879707217216492, 0.4644380211830139, 0.4812650680541992, 0.047682635486125946, -1.1836849451065063, 0.49372780323028564, -0.3132283687591553, -0.05236135795712471, -0.33805543184280396, 0.2417045533657074, 0.39964279532432556, -0.777637243270874, 0.22398905456066132, -0.39424148201942444, 0.13272932171821594, 0.8689479827880859, 0.3618009090423584, -0.4799351692199707, -0.7569281458854675, 0.25960659980773926, -0.605430543422699, 0.4087842106819153, -0.2195899337530136, -0.12270980328321457, -0.23188792169094086, 0.38457104563713074, -0.1787886917591095, -0.29400092363357544, 0.6910202503204346, -0.032103944569826126, 0.017293471843004227, 0.09478429704904556, 0.15257230401039124, -0.5223413109779358, 0.5780227780342102, 0.14671576023101807, -0.5516487956047058, 0.08470798283815384, -0.8267416954040527, -0.20988735556602478, 0.07662949711084366, -0.5406841039657593, 0.3828102648258209, -0.06813642382621765, -0.320208877325058, 0.34548431634902954, 0.44137653708457947, 0.3925226330757141, -0.5425369143486023, 0.47649407386779785, 0.49623844027519226, -0.10440734773874283, 0.3088182508945465, -0.15696726739406586, -0.6028152704238892, -0.5115065574645996, 0.2937663197517395, -0.45390745997428894, 0.22624599933624268, 0.8719343543052673, 0.03971155360341072, -0.43105852603912354, 0.3808690905570984, -0.9894614219665527, -0.4252837896347046, -0.25476711988449097, -0.2912540137767792, 0.7787362933158875, 0.15516765415668488, -0.046252354979515076, -0.7806147336959839, 0.5864433646202087, -0.03023228608071804, 0.5453965663909912, 0.5659774541854858, -0.4108220040798187, 0.21487706899642944, 0.08801298588514328, 0.4497791826725006, -0.16107551753520966, 0.4125458896160126, -0.09826928377151489, -0.3758227825164795, -0.3036450743675232, -0.5815603733062744, 0.49426034092903137, 0.057897962629795074, 0.07083163410425186, -0.06791084259748459, 0.3161882758140564, -0.1254657506942749, -0.2270079106092453, -0.4507087767124176, -0.7303634285926819, -0.0005322404904291034, 0.41287028789520264, 0.5631183385848999, -0.5687364339828491, -0.5614630579948425, -0.07778043299913406, 0.28520041704177856, -0.7769220471382141, -0.11588283628225327, -0.43290871381759644, 0.5387217998504639, -0.5723099708557129, -0.8207959532737732, -0.15040841698646545, 0.26851749420166016, 0.402075856924057, 0.7697516679763794, 0.27362367510795593, 0.44763389229774475, -0.137327641248703, 0.07653152197599411, -0.014130991883575916, 0.4373018145561218, 0.09696397185325623, 0.10842359811067581, 0.27841341495513916, 0.3483380973339081, 0.3752204477787018, 0.28887614607810974, -0.4216007888317108, -0.3896562159061432, -1.018738865852356, 0.16127608716487885, -0.025673367083072662, -1.1124143600463867, -0.08094098418951035, 0.6910911798477173, 0.7872936725616455, -0.011572999879717827, -0.24431054294109344, -0.09762456268072128, -0.18318814039230347, 0.3777828514575958, -0.25838503241539, 0.06026238203048706, 0.4334246516227722, -0.22930051386356354, 0.12036337703466415, 0.2714146375656128, -0.16812220215797424, -0.13077309727668762, -0.021313216537237167, -0.20807652175426483, 0.2505546808242798, -0.09890627861022949, 0.47787609696388245, -0.09316809475421906, 0.7089626789093018, -0.41833803057670593, -0.09203594923019409, -0.2432575225830078, 0.6537730097770691, 0.14250920712947845, 0.8385979533195496, 0.08390163630247116, -1.082108736038208, -0.07609891146421432, -0.3119755983352661, 0.22394713759422302, 0.49213337898254395, -0.6371831297874451, -0.16884203255176544, -0.6539614796638489, -0.12665697932243347, 0.059845756739377975, 0.22563613951206207, 1.1462374925613403, -0.3053324818611145, 0.4409645199775696, -1.1408839225769043, -0.12131045013666153, 0.19338127970695496, -0.5167560577392578, -0.21362091600894928, 0.30034351348876953, -0.16234996914863586, -0.05157804489135742, 0.34325042366981506, -0.672818124294281, -0.45857611298561096, -0.40276476740837097, -0.8690773844718933, 0.5178881883621216, -0.3872375786304474, -0.5235644578933716, 1.507570743560791, 0.11234549432992935, -1.1413882970809937, 0.4794771075248718, 0.12627287209033966, -0.3585752248764038, -0.04494176805019379, 0.08676568418741226, -0.6914443373680115, -0.10848300904035568, 0.05191245302557945, -0.39767271280288696, 0.7330747246742249, 0.6786355972290039, 0.1549704670906067, 0.22306670248508453, 0.7221526503562927, -0.6855447888374329, -0.23616105318069458, 0.5447386503219604, -0.9328545331954956, -0.10299493372440338, 0.38026508688926697, 0.13888686895370483, -0.18700458109378815, -0.06312467902898788, -0.2504332959651947, -0.44569841027259827, 0.3138839900493622, -0.058350637555122375, -1.0847702026367188, -0.382165789604187, 0.2316032201051712, -0.5968767404556274, 0.43072566390037537, -0.033012669533491135, -0.3644441068172455, -0.2931195795536041, 0.4053238034248352, 0.2078397274017334, -0.2896865904331207, 0.11173602938652039, -0.9141408205032349, 0.4375373423099518, -0.10805991291999817, 0.6517277359962463, -0.5592861771583557, -0.4731440246105194, 0.3717859089374542, -0.08686589449644089, -0.5618088841438293, -0.40358632802963257, -0.3367525339126587, -0.09708382934331894, -0.10472770780324936, -0.049849167466163635, 0.0017995618982240558, -0.09130789339542389, -0.2296624779701233, -0.6618483662605286, 0.30485981702804565, 0.20461294054985046, -1.0664266347885132, -0.27195677161216736, 0.7508054375648499, 0.36043742299079895, -0.6120019555091858, -0.127176433801651, 0.2191249579191208, 0.3096172511577606, 0.2999952435493469, 0.24414165318012238, -0.534692108631134, 0.0865563452243805, -1.2767282724380493, 0.24715228378772736, -0.8030219078063965, 0.48721039295196533, 0.4456627070903778, -0.9701651334762573, -0.5831420421600342, 0.7829104065895081, 1.0560463666915894, -0.4338034987449646, -0.2746170163154602, 0.13165220618247986, 0.6504130363464355, -0.17819920182228088, -0.09802218526601791, -0.04281855747103691, 0.5275061130523682, -0.3045838177204132, 1.0551362037658691, -0.7904738187789917, -0.24901610612869263, 0.1642937809228897, -0.11104488372802734, -0.2389289289712906, 0.36348164081573486, 0.03159322962164879, -0.09590049088001251, -0.09182486683130264, 0.34968411922454834, -0.46031564474105835, 0.5027674436569214, -0.6315750479698181, 0.33024582266807556, -0.6595627069473267, 0.05877484008669853, 0.6311481595039368, 0.49265986680984497, -0.18638251721858978, 0.6827659606933594, 0.980135977268219, -0.381849467754364, 0.5193219780921936, 0.8319416046142578, 0.35117754340171814, 0.01141322497278452, 0.5874623656272888, 0.08215019851922989, -0.5698294639587402, -0.8004441261291504, -0.6708802580833435, 0.6266433596611023, 0.3075557053089142, -0.21754078567028046, -0.18997351825237274, 0.32127246260643005, 0.13431420922279358, -1.021146535873413, 0.6771118640899658, 0.5087132453918457, 0.44654059410095215, 0.6699125170707703, -0.5769557952880859, 0.0015966766513884068, -0.09624475240707397, -0.2637214958667755, 0.3683500587940216, -0.3261909782886505, -0.23909038305282593, -0.2107110619544983, 0.114801786839962, -0.9515516757965088, -0.6976137161254883, 0.582905650138855, 0.1989016979932785, -0.0454009510576725, 0.818549633026123, -0.23283852636814117, -0.08025958389043808, -0.33082151412963867, 0.610284686088562, 0.7234809398651123, -0.2588605582714081, 0.5535488724708557, -0.18791231513023376, -0.13899418711662292, 0.4975256621837616, -0.112757608294487, -0.09640137106180191, -0.5632405281066895, 0.5398129820823669, -0.7621864676475525, -0.39525410532951355, 0.6275674104690552, 0.49216824769973755, -1.3023885488510132, -0.08955208212137222, -0.8463453650474548, -0.04434547945857048, 0.23617559671401978, -0.005592761095613241, -1.0146756172180176, 0.184528186917305, -0.3895256221294403, 0.061289552599191666, -0.07988715916872025, 0.43582555651664734, -0.11660376191139221, 0.39112231135368347, -0.40691912174224854, -1.3050180673599243, 0.5692196488380432, 1.0276892185211182, -0.07267554104328156, -0.6848188042640686, 0.5626139640808105, 0.01915072649717331, -0.21388377249240875, -0.2587370276451111, 0.9669364094734192, -0.40035197138786316, 0.4380464255809784, -0.03252289444208145, 0.2083905190229416, 0.08068673312664032, 0.9193886518478394, 0.10244002938270569, 0.44411593675613403, -0.3141987919807434, -0.6885256767272949, -0.8296030163764954, -0.08016644418239594, 0.25762125849723816, 0.2429271787405014, 0.4718603193759918, -0.2696250379085541, -0.1138584166765213, -0.721355676651001, -0.08050274848937988, -0.32909756898880005, -0.4330987334251404, -0.3190181255340576, -0.8836296200752258, -0.21457400918006897, -0.8773506879806519, 0.1897941678762436, 0.5636958479881287, -0.5775702595710754, -0.5601012706756592, -0.4508216679096222, 0.5280560851097107, 0.040787894278764725, 0.8513864278793335, -0.21581532061100006, -0.22460728883743286, -0.7347050905227661, -0.38451096415519714, -0.308796226978302, -0.8494600057601929, 0.11048798263072968, -0.253669798374176, 0.1778583973646164, 0.32827839255332947, -0.43668460845947266, 0.627022922039032, -0.33047735691070557, 0.02161341719329357, 0.3393896520137787, -0.10380225628614426, -0.5877456665039062, 1.026680588722229, -0.4695236086845398, 0.61133873462677, 0.24334539473056793, -0.035813868045806885, 0.16281890869140625, 0.13579581677913666, -0.5514231324195862, 0.5602542757987976, -0.2651437819004059, 1.0462288856506348, 0.20450808107852936, -0.3618132770061493, -0.42872995138168335, 1.3982741832733154, -0.7963497638702393, -0.7549173831939697, -0.5223958492279053, 0.47492972016334534, 0.23866069316864014, -0.0689304992556572, 0.42247456312179565, 0.025858210399746895, -0.18695148825645447, 0.3688935935497284, -0.44287052750587463, 0.18560416996479034, -0.13763168454170227, 0.6207681894302368, -0.1254449188709259, -0.39384928345680237, 0.21792086958885193, -0.4799940288066864, 0.07689806073904037, 0.7179436683654785, 0.1391332894563675, -0.06526704877614975, -0.18715648353099823, 0.3525623083114624, -0.14150546491146088, -0.26464083790779114, -0.9465208649635315, 0.9067573547363281, 0.7723878622055054, 0.23452667891979218, -0.039817746728658676, -0.33157676458358765, -0.9784402847290039, 0.6398019194602966, -0.3087702691555023, -0.4857550859451294, 0.38493236899375916, -0.07416420429944992, 0.14458580315113068, 0.2899910807609558, -0.7759823203086853, 0.20710401237010956, 0.026987286284565926, 0.4929017722606659, 0.6862219572067261, -0.5206507444381714, -0.9865546822547913, 0.981157660484314, -0.7183491587638855, -0.13045604526996613, -0.7755894660949707, 0.6226012110710144, -1.1147159337997437, -0.4444469213485718, 0.11257211863994598, 0.46619272232055664, -0.05450104922056198, -0.5019574761390686, -0.5635974407196045, -0.39373528957366943, -0.40626832842826843, -1.0760517120361328, -0.6932487487792969, -0.014190588146448135, -0.7127892374992371, -0.4341716170310974, -0.6600267887115479, -0.5708480477333069, -0.10776842385530472, -0.10904386639595032, 1.3698348999023438, -0.4305128753185272, -0.32332050800323486, 0.5686730742454529, 0.29315972328186035, -0.14156019687652588, -0.15917286276817322, 0.30576276779174805, 0.5360003113746643, 0.38597628474235535, -0.5402736663818359, 0.27844494581222534, 0.398870050907135, -0.4289725422859192, 0.24814091622829437, -0.29202091693878174, 0.4394088685512543, 0.10667832940816879, 0.312093049287796, -0.19144631922245026, -0.28136396408081055, 0.002092418959364295, 0.5273652672767639, 0.10737916082143784, -0.0075647952035069466, -0.3384545147418976, 0.20394335687160492, -0.5025863647460938, 0.34140899777412415, 0.521901547908783, -0.22383776307106018, -0.13674750924110413, -0.3992355167865753, 0.51578688621521, -0.9094445109367371, -0.4651334583759308, -0.6293072700500488, 0.4372580051422119, 0.2664603590965271, -0.30101096630096436, 0.12033791840076447, 0.24230854213237762, 0.22604385018348694, 0.43367740511894226, -0.4374045133590698, 0.7688185572624207, 0.2097426950931549, 1.1518895626068115, 0.03842149302363396, 0.38345691561698914, 0.18560905754566193, 0.7405238151550293, 0.061209786683321, -1.2912240028381348, 0.10956422984600067, 0.28312867879867554, -0.08222223818302155, 0.4886701703071594, 0.42590710520744324, -0.20810331404209137, 0.08879630267620087, -0.3821856677532196, 0.16276144981384277, -1.2296814918518066, 0.20361940562725067, 0.48456838726997375, -0.5550920367240906, 0.2338302880525589, 0.5977229475975037, 0.36338359117507935, 0.4169667363166809, 0.9069944620132446, 0.03733792155981064, -0.6120510101318359, 1.066327691078186, 0.8313006162643433, 0.07505153119564056, 0.5505762696266174, -0.503723680973053, 0.5001822710037231, -0.019595345482230186, 0.05188826099038124, 0.6811070442199707, 0.9651437997817993, 0.08785262703895569, -0.19271059334278107, -0.16389815509319305, -0.3894473910331726, 0.5192567110061646, -0.3503791093826294, 0.37326866388320923, 0.11709517985582352, -0.27049514651298523, -0.27181971073150635, 0.1304011195898056, 0.6387704014778137, -0.38027945160865784, -0.3022610545158386, -0.015000581741333008, -1.0235589742660522, 0.17701338231563568, 0.20708122849464417, 0.7880570888519287, -0.5977927446365356, -0.038373563438653946, 0.46174418926239014, -0.4953654408454895, 0.00671576289460063, -0.6548830270767212, -0.7143791913986206, -0.13879865407943726, 0.07445862889289856, 1.2772024869918823, -0.025057828053832054, 0.6881817579269409, -0.8508652448654175, -0.08199594914913177, -0.6516886949539185, 0.5836901068687439, -0.1120268777012825, 0.38000568747520447, 0.46134668588638306, 0.7322666049003601, -0.8299063444137573, 0.18780218064785004, 0.31652405858039856, -0.3110905587673187, 0.4362389147281647, 0.3117811679840088, 0.31773823499679565, 0.14543913304805756, -0.2579665184020996, 0.619706928730011, 0.2573712170124054, -0.33291298151016235, 0.7368388772010803, -0.1899283081293106, 0.23015643656253815, -0.6773223876953125, 0.07738162577152252, -0.03083302266895771, 0.6298426389694214, -0.1850019097328186, 0.07234766334295273, -0.5299974679946899, -1.0845520496368408, 4.313989162445068, 0.6029003858566284, 0.28039565682411194, 0.2748646140098572, 1.2621798515319824, 0.5071184635162354, 0.4044560194015503, -0.7197368144989014, 0.1455342173576355, -0.07600264996290207, -0.07439704239368439, -0.3839879631996155, 0.13691191375255585, 0.6061023473739624, -0.29389357566833496, 0.9770352840423584, -0.6049371957778931, -1.092065691947937, 0.4364791810512543, -0.8829885125160217, -0.9131619334220886, 0.46136215329170227, 0.015081063844263554, -0.2453412264585495, 0.19581055641174316, 0.30378419160842896, 0.11452875286340714, -0.8394618034362793, -0.38413020968437195, -0.2371797412633896, -0.367606520652771, -0.587834358215332, 0.9975524544715881, 0.04617447033524513, -0.76129549741745, 0.21364353597164154, -0.00926857441663742, -0.529106616973877, -0.31548812985420227, -0.3978234827518463, -0.1873578131198883, -0.47812366485595703, 0.04841325059533119, -0.394187331199646, 0.00533873587846756, 0.9305725693702698, -0.07779129594564438, 0.02885269746184349, 0.8913490772247314, -0.4401995837688446, 0.2809745669364929, -0.17934828996658325, -0.12669138610363007, -0.34391430020332336, -0.9947688579559326, 0.08223091810941696, 0.24390941858291626, -0.24888163805007935, -0.37132692337036133, 0.2899155914783478, 0.978792130947113, -0.6778028011322021, -0.4057486951351166, 0.02894670143723488, -0.0170544795691967, 0.4758545756340027, 0.09961196780204773, 0.03544224798679352, -0.1043906956911087, -0.07759091258049011, -0.21000324189662933, 0.35976216197013855, -0.14015883207321167, -0.6151995658874512, -0.39077121019363403, 0.4260079860687256, 0.5134846568107605, -0.13895456492900848, -0.16999411582946777, 0.26090702414512634, -0.11459895968437195, 0.03582368418574333, -0.3868280053138733, 0.4265175461769104, 0.36617156863212585, 0.7180395126342773, -0.11295825988054276, 0.07052865624427795, -0.3287614583969116, 0.25904545187950134, 0.09309644252061844, -0.03669251874089241, -0.2966400980949402, -0.41294583678245544, -0.8394040465354919 ]
Cosmic Rays, Gamma Rays and Neutrinos from Point Sources
The suggestion has been made that the energy spectrum from point sources such as AGN (Active Galactic Nuclei) and GBHC (Galactic Black Hole Candidates) is universal, irrespective of the nature of the emitted particles. A comparison of the energy spectrum for cosmic rays at the source and $\gamma$-rays from quasars obtained recently by CGRO (Compton Gamma Ray Observatory) indicates that the prediction is in agreement with the data in the average sense. This suggests that neutrinos from point sources should have a spectral index identical to that of $\gamma$-rays for an individual point source. This prediction is also consistent with the recent observation of neutrinos by Kamiokande and IMB in which the ratio of $\nu_\mu/\nu_e$ is close to 1, instead of 2 as expected from atmospheric neutrinos. For a further test of the model, analysis of the time variation of $\gamma$-ray spectra from quasars is suggested.
Yukio Tomozawa
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210003
astro-ph/9210004
[ 0.518805742263794, 0.7315592765808105, 0.4063952565193176, -0.28377336263656616, -0.31333523988723755, 0.09966002404689789, -0.37054166197776794, 0.07052281498908997, 0.530108630657196, 0.42956456542015076, 0.049352869391441345, 0.0958407074213028, 0.03789689391851425, -0.8599264621734619, -0.06386212259531021, -0.11513427644968033, 0.017703410238027573, -0.7509725689888, -1.110203504562378, -0.5318260788917542, 0.1286330223083496, -0.7059836983680725, -1.1208038330078125, -0.22210761904716492, 0.13154825568199158, 0.4170494079589844, 0.793199360370636, 0.7590855360031128, 0.8418952822685242, 0.6165066957473755, 0.1461784541606903, -1.0009269714355469, 0.022261669859290123, -0.8449581861495972, -0.3766677975654602, 0.009618150070309639, 0.7394147515296936, 0.023032549768686295, 0.5158932209014893, -0.9573972821235657, 0.9947970509529114, 0.19991916418075562, 0.6534117460250854, -0.17158912122249603, 0.23150528967380524, 0.15980874001979828, -0.3427373766899109, -0.3014044463634491, 0.3749223053455353, -0.5082845687866211, -0.08908966928720474, -0.3371131122112274, -0.006537545006722212, -0.30301329493522644, -0.6546104550361633, 0.04088529944419861, -0.2224024385213852, -0.04193887487053871, 0.32031819224357605, 0.3818143606185913, 0.978229820728302, 0.18548282980918884, 0.46118783950805664, -1.271328330039978, -0.49580422043800354, 0.6967551708221436, 0.180930495262146, -0.26160138845443726, -0.00878818053752184, -0.6573379039764404, -0.16199763119220734, 0.21966251730918884, -0.07100623100996017, 0.5798686146736145, -1.02490234375, 0.14289000630378723, -0.15288710594177246, -0.027789071202278137, -0.033560555428266525, 0.20903721451759338, -0.05011134594678879, -0.029882391914725304, 0.19794423878192902, -0.31496864557266235, 0.16871783137321472, -0.7642849683761597, 0.22171813249588013, 0.12170059233903885, 0.18322713673114777, -0.13199608027935028, -0.613009512424469, 0.6772531270980835, 0.13983307778835297, 0.134855255484581, 0.43227359652519226, 0.5067937970161438, -0.41250964999198914, 0.24366074800491333, 0.16969004273414612, -0.19100414216518402, -0.041037071496248245, 0.6172422170639038, -0.6169007420539856, 0.2559422552585602, -0.50128573179245, 0.14432738721370697, -0.12436526268720627, -0.21022118628025055, 0.10672648996114731, -0.6333715319633484, 0.0644008070230484, 0.2965075969696045, 0.14668184518814087, 0.23595480620861053, 0.40402063727378845, 0.5589043498039246, -0.39572370052337646, -0.27298465371131897, -0.47333061695098877, -0.471978098154068, 0.022975636646151543, 0.80437171459198, -0.080735944211483, 0.0325080007314682, -0.2550116777420044, -0.20950767397880554, -0.2010442167520523, 0.533470630645752, -0.7324201464653015, -0.027539251372218132, -0.20852310955524445, -1.1255074739456177, -0.1956961452960968, 0.720129668712616, -0.030424900352954865, 0.4275865852832794, 0.6701838970184326, 0.32170194387435913, 0.4406925439834595, -0.4950665831565857, -0.3362157940864563, 0.4742518663406372, -0.15283995866775513, 1.7839760780334473, -0.7150838971138, 1.0080347061157227, -0.7872757315635681, -0.6648498177528381, 0.10513748228549957, 0.12349686026573181, 0.2755950689315796, -0.5297998189926147, -0.6824838519096375, 0.8268678188323975, -0.8089847564697266, -0.04815923422574997, -0.9052673578262329, -0.15588873624801636, -0.2640189826488495, -0.4541760981082916, 0.012085326947271824, -0.4557555317878723, 0.718906044960022, 0.05338405817747116, 0.18270371854305267, 0.3585151433944702, -0.20756424963474274, -0.7902064323425293, 0.06866314262151718, -0.40109553933143616, -0.10890825092792511, -0.1570788472890854, 0.12577559053897858, 0.35693591833114624, 0.433851957321167, 0.48759225010871887, -0.021490201354026794, -0.3505136966705322, -0.9151700139045715, 0.11004941165447235, -0.11129520833492279, -0.24382583796977997, 0.09418231248855591, -0.08953577280044556, -0.0781257152557373, 0.17597433924674988, -0.07994507998228073, 0.34799665212631226, 0.06650824844837189, -0.32279279828071594, -0.12572532892227173, 0.6540476083755493, -0.6073698401451111, 0.8143603205680847, -0.5969704985618591, 0.07792986184358597, -0.6746784448623657, -0.15701566636562347, -0.004246642347425222, -0.006405544467270374, -0.13152183592319489, 0.35896530747413635, -0.6125879287719727, -0.3610090911388397, -0.8143026828765869, -0.1748582124710083, 0.4863871932029724, 0.622602105140686, -0.32621046900749207, 0.23474517464637756, 0.9398083686828613, 0.0856795534491539, 0.2790204584598541, 0.4298650026321411, 0.7919248938560486, 0.34957900643348694, 0.0015658608172088861, 0.09018711000680923, -0.2616192102432251, -0.28628674149513245, 0.4446417987346649, 0.3177298903465271, 0.2703816890716553, 0.8304753303527832, 0.6452382206916809, -0.769869327545166, -0.7952000498771667, 0.3228291869163513, -0.10556130856275558, 0.24809835851192474, -0.008802184835076332, 0.5409400463104248, -0.2252066433429718, 0.20728126168251038, 0.18522179126739502, 0.015374529175460339, 0.42205607891082764, 0.6768180727958679, -0.01451848354190588, -0.4352794289588928, 0.7680267095565796, -0.46594923734664917, 0.7386553883552551, 0.40120750665664673, -0.1025158017873764, 0.2931061089038849, -0.1688813418149948, -0.019650066271424294, 0.17293521761894226, 0.693950355052948, -0.7534490823745728, 0.8769534826278687, -0.025437604635953903, -0.6003453135490417, -0.41022396087646484, -0.5953754186630249, 0.4396614730358124, 0.3279411792755127, -0.02696884050965309, -0.6683748960494995, -0.3373119831085205, -0.9195364117622375, 0.8166259527206421, -0.36193031072616577, -0.2540372908115387, 0.6556912660598755, -0.2128540426492691, 0.6366153955459595, 0.6221762895584106, -0.45282259583473206, -0.7430657148361206, 0.18870680034160614, -1.0233843326568604, -0.9098621010780334, -0.16051724553108215, -0.2900598645210266, -0.1762278527021408, 0.005750409793108702, 0.6355791091918945, 0.09894196689128876, -0.2629934251308441, 0.8884449005126953, -0.03955646976828575, 0.6077255010604858, -0.501599907875061, 0.2969898283481598, -0.14920856058597565, 0.3626561760902405, -0.7083238363265991, -0.030292825773358345, -0.26669418811798096, 0.13322429358959198, -0.8217480778694153, -0.3572242558002472, -0.32116445899009705, -0.1687144786119461, -0.45714038610458374, -0.04715535417199135, 0.667892336845398, -1.0434468984603882, 0.4597751498222351, -0.07352572679519653, -0.4791076183319092, -1.2617496252059937, -0.29776838421821594, -0.2845294773578644, -0.4694231450557709, -0.36636918783187866, 0.28234943747520447, 0.2719295024871826, -0.48459145426750183, -0.010212290100753307, -0.24944669008255005, 0.054412372410297394, -0.16830874979496002, -0.3950134515762329, 0.06998814642429352, -0.021589912474155426, 0.2795701324939728, -0.8027602434158325, -0.3198697865009308, -0.6623983383178711, -0.20114700496196747, -0.24268345534801483, 0.16267329454421997, 0.7572640180587769, 0.2270278036594391, -0.544214129447937, 0.2075335830450058, -0.6700038313865662, -0.5889323353767395, 0.016607576981186867, 0.1113475039601326, 0.729930579662323, 0.10052184760570526, -0.30144408345222473, -0.8045225143432617, -0.2640937566757202, 0.7496482133865356, 0.5136822462081909, 0.8419512510299683, -0.1593869924545288, 0.0699627548456192, 0.5255321264266968, -1.151881217956543, 0.3128175139427185, 0.39703574776649475, -0.4923979938030243, -0.27319732308387756, 0.08294408023357391, -0.7072552442550659, -0.19649042189121246, -0.012392968870699406, 0.3874589800834656, 0.07537245750427246, 0.7430834770202637, -0.5528860688209534, -0.005967319943010807, -0.4495757818222046, -0.5560900568962097, -0.3980183005332947, 0.4213220179080963, 0.32051321864128113, -0.3408580422401428, 0.259179025888443, -0.09309210628271103, 0.41485223174095154, 0.07133417576551437, 0.34337741136550903, -0.4690902531147003, 0.17802534997463226, 0.13581809401512146, -0.17524248361587524, -0.5038791298866272, -0.25041356682777405, -0.4459177851676941, 0.15188543498516083, 0.4064536690711975, 0.682909369468689, -0.2884829044342041, -0.034889016300439835, -0.4275437891483307, 0.005953147541731596, -0.023955367505550385, 0.12257464230060577, -0.19469130039215088, 0.11391333490610123, 0.243225559592247, -0.6112659573554993, -0.5046815872192383, -0.5720038414001465, -0.4559091031551361, 0.2045467048883438, -0.2676011919975281, -0.36174869537353516, -0.07169993221759796, 0.832489013671875, 0.46878084540367126, -0.22052882611751556, -0.6578190326690674, -0.16599206626415253, -0.009776328690350056, 0.15337340533733368, 0.03311760351061821, -0.39022406935691833, 0.2324277013540268, 0.10722196847200394, 0.483458548784256, 0.17419205605983734, 0.13513092696666718, 0.1448829174041748, 0.49820730090141296, 0.1270943135023117, 0.23494639992713928, 0.8725374341011047, -0.48386141657829285, -0.3778682053089142, 0.2526020407676697, -0.13280615210533142, -0.13148657977581024, -0.14888408780097961, -0.18304204940795898, 0.03016708604991436, 0.6393682360649109, -0.09362755715847015, -0.30539223551750183, 0.8864173889160156, -0.63584965467453, 0.2584814727306366, 0.03855821490287781, -0.7443482875823975, 0.21306534111499786, -0.10304789245128632, 0.30868881940841675, 0.025823315605521202, 0.14773531258106232, 0.7010623216629028, 0.2978360652923584, -0.30016860365867615, -0.3029929995536804, 0.194832444190979, 0.6598339676856995, -0.4847140610218048, 0.0013233207864686847, 1.0272369384765625, -0.2414616048336029, 0.6767422556877136, 0.31907889246940613, 0.4405302107334137, -0.7866986393928528, -0.19052299857139587, -0.15138360857963562, 0.8279614448547363, -0.4726884663105011, -0.648457944393158, 0.9143123626708984, 0.04011378809809685, -0.15746848285198212, 0.5109006762504578, -0.22265905141830444, 0.08521972596645355, 0.03395611792802811, -0.7469139099121094, -0.268789678812027, -0.559958279132843, 0.18962952494621277, -0.43214187026023865, 0.5930218696594238, 0.5835310816764832, -0.007631437387317419, 0.2465217262506485, 0.27603018283843994, 0.4322262108325958, -0.003920592367649078, 0.3919532895088196, 0.23676687479019165, 0.0880521610379219, 0.4095056354999542, -0.354266881942749, 0.033970076590776443, 0.45614415407180786, 0.5878463983535767, -0.055403273552656174, 0.4622959792613983, 0.2689341902732849, -0.12124907970428467, -0.1403624564409256, 0.665945827960968, -0.541750431060791, 0.6228224635124207, 0.1755666583776474, -0.3581278622150421, -0.5622419118881226, -0.13134826719760895, -0.10632253438234329, -0.26061680912971497, -0.5083739757537842, -0.06460446119308472, 0.21468007564544678, -0.5029507875442505, 0.5252859592437744, -0.5304361581802368, -0.42834147810935974, 0.5306987762451172, -0.5705463290214539, -0.853537917137146, -0.3232867419719696, -0.09613559395074844, -0.6467016339302063, -0.32065749168395996, -0.9136940836906433, -0.41249167919158936, -0.18849273025989532, -0.3989083170890808, -0.44767263531684875, 0.43259188532829285, 0.7525548338890076, -0.5590382814407349, 0.24905237555503845, 0.2809942066669464, 1.0670151710510254, -0.945872962474823, -0.17459896206855774, -0.22511810064315796, 0.05445574223995209, 0.20172655582427979, 0.0796104222536087, -0.293351411819458, 0.10386136174201965, -1.0513876676559448, -0.014622353948652744, -0.2249823808670044, 0.0262607429176569, 0.2017059624195099, -0.8655803799629211, -0.13717351853847504, 0.48037680983543396, 0.08432065695524216, -0.44679316878318787, -0.21804141998291016, -0.06919927895069122, -0.16976942121982574, -0.17330749332904816, -0.15508058667182922, -1.2151005268096924, 0.18019749224185944, -0.6104750037193298, 1.0730241537094116, -0.39464449882507324, -0.024484088644385338, -0.16315136849880219, 0.31224802136421204, 0.7002836465835571, 0.5287690162658691, -0.30770108103752136, 0.061841901391744614, 0.10146471858024597, 0.5351487398147583, 0.17078086733818054, 0.17802561819553375, -0.3873128294944763, 0.42441481351852417, -0.29390445351600647, -0.20158158242702484, 0.06468620151281357, -0.42576783895492554, -0.4876428544521332, -0.08778010308742523, 0.9992225170135498, -0.03378261625766754, 0.5559386014938354, 0.26401862502098083, 0.20449237525463104, 0.2084481120109558, -0.08394650369882584, -0.5776491761207581, -0.40409591794013977, 0.07889091223478317, -0.27127668261528015, 0.6491637229919434, -0.19379200041294098, 0.19347381591796875, -0.6623516082763672, -0.41097360849380493, -0.8033878207206726, -0.4793722331523895, -0.37516069412231445, 0.45833808183670044, 0.11654440313577652, -0.05230649188160896, -0.3811083137989044, -0.05306342616677284, -0.16407345235347748, 0.7177403569221497, 0.6430826783180237, 0.03496108204126358, -0.3563160300254822, 0.47014087438583374, -0.03655073046684265, -0.40348395705223083, -0.2738804221153259, 0.3130515515804291, 0.5072968006134033, -0.14561200141906738, 0.5992425084114075, -0.11760281026363373, -0.2808876931667328, 0.18367204070091248, 0.18116649985313416, 0.5085488557815552, -0.6107679605484009, 0.506744384765625, 0.6464765667915344, 0.49894577264785767, 0.8620265126228333, -0.35394999384880066, -0.3384607434272766, -0.4219461977481842, 0.48746809363365173, -0.568027138710022, -0.16990575194358826, 0.08807636052370071, 0.34734445810317993, -0.8200896978378296, -0.2604028880596161, 0.29983577132225037, 0.1556299775838852, 0.6725541949272156, -0.054352324455976486, 0.022115975618362427, -0.3993005156517029, -0.6800253987312317, 0.3388587236404419, 0.08852396160364151, -0.35824671387672424, -0.01346802432090044, -0.27015170454978943, 0.4083385467529297, -0.4270833730697632, -0.004633055999875069, 1.5824308395385742, 0.2288064956665039, -0.04653133824467659, -0.2407969832420349, -0.9461738467216492, -0.0709148719906807, 0.009084915742278099, 0.8834614753723145, -0.17559213936328888, -0.3626977503299713, -0.22992217540740967, 0.47333642840385437, 0.6906399726867676, 0.3730379641056061, 0.13799609243869781, -0.2559168338775635, -0.529801607131958, -0.3187780976295471, -0.4735119342803955, -0.11195796728134155, 0.14916278421878815, 0.4310895502567291, -0.1590217649936676, -0.0916919857263565, 0.626683235168457, -0.3353923559188843, 0.3755553066730499, -0.01711396686732769, 0.022270869463682175, -0.5482507348060608, -0.8009533882141113, -0.6806960701942444, -0.7247618436813354, 0.8706796169281006, 0.5229570865631104, 0.03044353798031807, -0.48108235001564026, 0.5662145018577576, 0.8258018493652344, 0.14138874411582947, 0.262168824672699, 0.12571726739406586, -0.2513768970966339, -0.12194007635116577, -0.28562822937965393, -0.05180467292666435, -0.789017915725708, 0.22013895213603973, 0.1416112780570984, 0.002679424826055765, 0.4686318039894104, 0.20205239951610565, 0.8368493318557739, 0.19047705829143524, -0.33949899673461914, -0.3210761845111847, -0.5418997406959534, -0.8505613803863525, 0.6836459636688232, -0.30901604890823364, 0.8422586917877197, 1.0999525785446167, -0.46075713634490967, 0.5422648787498474, -0.021650271490216255, -0.6923893094062805, 0.350761741399765, 0.16805125772953033, 0.41660261154174805, -0.5853157639503479, -0.28602689504623413, 0.19219322502613068, 1.7739547491073608, -1.0958682298660278, -0.26199886202812195, -0.05267249420285225, 0.0033922852016985416, 0.06550999730825424, -0.2872726321220398, -0.6979066133499146, 0.8052309155464172, 0.301849365234375, 0.39996039867401123, -0.5688316822052002, 0.38066017627716064, -0.2913118004798889, 0.7547004818916321, -0.35188156366348267, 0.09327193349599838, 0.1491539627313614, -0.42349228262901306, -0.1877720057964325, 0.4129403829574585, -0.22442835569381714, 0.47092384099960327, -0.014078076928853989, 0.2069827914237976, -0.47961729764938354, -0.39335817098617554, -0.6629865765571594, 0.5881919860839844, 0.518910825252533, 0.29423999786376953, 0.12351812422275543, 0.39756059646606445, -0.9792912602424622, 0.24225130677223206, -0.4605141282081604, -0.8159536123275757, 0.5931834578514099, -1.0892051458358765, 0.2646389603614807, 0.38657060265541077, 0.07903551310300827, 0.5930742025375366, 0.47067248821258545, 0.11063560098409653, 0.7439432740211487, 0.13237781822681427, -1.1140692234039307, 0.0660485029220581, -0.9329096078872681, -0.07193071395158768, -0.3164519667625427, 0.03339273855090141, -0.7300655245780945, -1.169769287109375, 0.5111578702926636, 0.33237314224243164, -0.15619081258773804, -0.00852028839290142, 0.08642051368951797, 0.4874739944934845, -0.7999191284179688, 0.02271265722811222, -1.1292672157287598, 0.5212313532829285, -0.337989866733551, 0.08915192633867264, 0.05609774589538574, -0.14184987545013428, -0.2190243899822235, -0.4488961398601532, 0.8071682453155518, -0.06080096215009689, -0.2920972406864166, -0.07038536667823792, 0.484447181224823, -0.6571140289306641, 0.3494582772254944, 0.367256224155426, 0.5348256826400757, 0.5672518014907837, -0.5791366100311279, -0.474484920501709, 0.42097803950309753, -0.18387891352176666, 0.23824186623096466, 0.17253728210926056, 0.3125537037849426, -0.2508406639099121, 0.48436108231544495, -0.3784342408180237, 0.28867942094802856, -0.08266653120517731, -0.01173472125083208, -0.27895256876945496, -0.47860872745513916, 0.5001427531242371, 0.12243302166461945, 0.47132962942123413, 0.3779515027999878, -0.2668647766113281, 0.09091172367334366, -0.3708549737930298, -0.7463558912277222, -0.2285226434469223, -0.49856433272361755, -0.691962718963623, -0.8068708181381226, 0.01185291726142168, 0.2710443437099457, -0.2501439154148102, 0.31911036372184753, 0.008471854031085968, 0.021986432373523712, 0.7426491975784302, 0.43981656432151794, 0.6628748774528503, 0.4053162634372711, 0.39542338252067566, 0.4327615201473236, 0.5484004616737366, -0.3521985709667206, 0.11777692288160324, -0.09526597708463669, -1.1514317989349365, -0.12099678069353104, 0.01789594255387783, -0.18290449678897858, -0.2510732114315033, 0.17208248376846313, -0.4050177037715912, -0.1164405420422554, -0.8804794549942017, 0.15757712721824646, -0.4169507920742035, 0.5348637700080872, 1.0682650804519653, -0.35072821378707886, 0.051186613738536835, 0.6989707946777344, 0.09005156904459, -0.010285168886184692, 0.41824576258659363, -0.14832259714603424, -0.1994941234588623, 0.9595304727554321, 0.7347130179405212, 0.03699229285120964, -0.31811094284057617, -0.18516694009304047, -0.07576391100883484, 0.45358455181121826, 0.40834829211235046, 0.37478575110435486, 0.7940073013305664, -0.626862645149231, -0.590144693851471, 0.13587383925914764, -0.023399798199534416, -0.4675425589084625, 0.13745270669460297, 0.1712682694196701, 0.059357672929763794, -1.0174661874771118, -0.42418938875198364, -0.22259442508220673, 0.5555075407028198, 0.39651963114738464, -0.45840924978256226, 0.19249458611011505, -1.0728086233139038, -0.8054969310760498, 0.5331302881240845, 0.13682228326797485, -0.0499514676630497, -0.2507455050945282, -0.27532637119293213, 0.38193845748901367, 0.02793668583035469, -0.469550222158432, -0.5943489670753479, -0.23708006739616394, 0.18225693702697754, 0.745182991027832, 0.604255735874176, 0.5554938912391663, -0.6062771677970886, -0.7125846147537231, 0.2727314531803131, 1.2551385164260864, 0.32234469056129456, -0.17349573969841003, 0.6635172963142395, 0.688490092754364, -0.03611006587743759, 0.09216868877410889, 0.06270793080329895, -0.5827270746231079, 0.46300292015075684, 0.14069966971874237, -0.10620557516813278, -0.03737551346421242, -0.3611368238925934, 0.2389386147260666, 1.0294158458709717, 0.5599237680435181, 0.42950281500816345, -0.1952565610408783, 0.24594490230083466, -0.8930475115776062, 0.3629041016101837, -0.3560696840286255, 0.5320277810096741, 0.4699254333972931, -0.3331906199455261, 0.06802211701869965, -0.6004981994628906, 4.437230110168457, 1.3030041456222534, 0.8171547651290894, 0.27200087904930115, 0.5034505724906921, 0.03521426394581795, 0.5692415237426758, -0.6901690363883972, 0.20930109918117523, -0.5433084964752197, 0.07872038334608078, 0.013078916817903519, 0.83481764793396, -0.8183227181434631, -0.09671543538570404, 1.0088196992874146, 0.18634921312332153, -0.3063661754131317, 1.2906193733215332, -0.6413285136222839, -0.9719158411026001, -0.17785689234733582, -0.05548744276165962, 0.23591327667236328, -0.1998278796672821, 0.5000226497650146, 0.4863515794277191, -0.41182804107666016, 0.06074904650449753, -0.10499132424592972, -0.2838963270187378, -0.11329986155033112, 0.17938275635242462, -0.2616223692893982, -0.8965529799461365, 1.0857957601547241, 0.17502127587795258, -0.10804256051778793, -0.2723138630390167, 0.13372845947742462, -0.2824023365974426, -0.18168900907039642, 0.08828232437372208, -0.8247398138046265, -0.27936944365501404, 1.467995285987854, 0.6554657220840454, 0.16292011737823486, 0.6641600728034973, -0.6318320035934448, 0.1298997402191162, -0.27712175250053406, -0.15485729277133942, -0.2668439745903015, -1.074363350868225, -0.09178734570741653, -0.1815018504858017, -0.5602515339851379, -0.07691393792629242, -0.07845373451709747, 0.6268330812454224, 0.2645281255245209, -0.6539544463157654, 0.5915597081184387, -1.0181078910827637, 0.8652121424674988, -0.04345130920410156, 0.2735205590724945, -0.7708372473716736, 0.2167799025774002, -0.27825844287872314, -0.5289373993873596, -0.5034658312797546, 0.08766796439886093, -0.18687523901462555, 0.024905197322368622, -0.276569128036499, 0.5454049706459045, -0.7098162770271301, 0.19765295088291168, -0.17674702405929565, 0.173507958650589, -0.49646663665771484, 0.1602199524641037, -0.13320834934711456, 0.2770388722419739, 0.03686103969812393, -0.7049877047538757, -0.2678106725215912, 0.6724801659584045, 0.3791444003582001, 0.025283148512244225, -0.23328807950019836, -0.21911104023456573, -0.7883814573287964 ]
Dynamics of the Young Binary LMC Cluster NGC 1850
In this paper we have examined the age and internal dynamics of the young binary LMC cluster NGC 1850 using BV CCD images and echelle spectra of 52 supergiants. Isochrone fits to a BV color-magnitude diagram revealed that the primary cluster has an age of $\tau = 90 \pm 30$ Myr while the secondary member has $\tau = 6 \pm 5$ Myr. BV surface brightness profiles were constructed out to R $>$ 40 pc, and single-component King-Michie (KM) models were applied. The total cluster luminosity varied from L$_B$ = 2.60 - 2.65 $\times 10^6$ L$_B$\sol\ and L$_V$ = 1.25 - 1.35 $\times 10^6$ as the anisotropy radius varied from infinity to three times the scale radius with the isotropic models providing the best agreement with the data. Of the 52 stars with echelle spectra, a subset of 36 were used to study the cluster dynamics. The KM radial velocity distributions were fitted to these velocities yielding total cluster masses of 5.4 - 5.9 $\pm 2.4 \times 10^4$ M\sol\ corresponding to M/L$_B$ = 0.02 $\pm 0.01$ M\sol/L$_B$\sol\ or M/L$_V$ = 0.05 $\pm 0.02$ M\sol/L$_V$\sol. A rotational signal in the radial velocities has been detected at the 93\% confidence level implying a rotation axis at a position angle of 100\deg. A variety of rotating models were fit to the velocity data assuming cluster ellipticities of $\epsilon = 0.1 - 0.3$. These models provided slightly better agreement with the radial velocity data than the KM models and had masses that were systematically lower by a few percent. The preferred value for the slope of a power-law IMF is a relatively shallow, $x = 0.29 \pmm{+0.3}{-0.8}$ assuming the B-band M/L or $x = 0.71 \pmm{+0.2}{-0.4}$ for the V-band.
P. Fischer, D. L. Welch, and M. Mateo
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210004
astro-ph/9210005
[ 0.47693026065826416, 0.5242222547531128, 0.9061163663864136, 0.07301342487335205, -0.37368103861808777, 0.28419169783592224, -0.7971376180648804, -0.12716786563396454, -0.36667194962501526, 0.971807599067688, -0.1033087968826294, -0.6879732012748718, -0.47966572642326355, -0.29243549704551697, -0.807246744632721, -0.5075241327285767, 0.16313627362251282, -0.48126456141471863, -1.4561635255813599, -0.0711047425866127, -0.11299111694097519, -0.5270270109176636, -1.2035449743270874, 0.1299826204776764, -0.05736362189054489, 0.9510575532913208, -0.2788670063018799, 1.1704710721969604, 0.68409264087677, 0.1902107447385788, 0.06900312751531601, -0.9206735491752625, 0.6977347731590271, -0.9819323420524597, -0.5142195820808411, -0.3293408453464508, 0.6181894540786743, -0.10508506000041962, 0.5292329788208008, -0.4630391597747803, 0.373852401971817, -0.5020403861999512, 0.6369219422340393, -0.35594967007637024, -0.26967889070510864, -0.2980712950229645, -0.6473238468170166, -0.06869771331548691, 0.3326646685600281, -0.7003389000892639, -0.4677642583847046, -0.18771514296531677, 1.2469942569732666, -0.7057965993881226, 0.19257226586341858, -0.4821011424064636, 0.10951075702905655, 0.4250900447368622, -0.5059800148010254, -0.35368603467941284, -0.06348446756601334, 0.0894271582365036, 0.06080231815576553, -0.44417789578437805, 0.08619578927755356, 1.1207149028778076, 0.1025192141532898, 0.48881232738494873, -0.33234554529190063, 0.6555940508842468, -0.5100876092910767, 0.4522762894630432, -0.5411409735679626, 0.17748039960861206, -0.3784497082233429, -0.6594593524932861, -0.06092223897576332, -0.16750283539295197, 0.023755300790071487, 0.14614683389663696, 0.012649823911488056, 0.49675026535987854, 0.1002047136425972, -0.04144100472331047, 0.24099592864513397, -0.041340310126543045, -0.20232298970222473, 0.9685500860214233, 0.01296083815395832, 0.8762616515159607, 0.2176915854215622, 0.3194062113761902, -0.056795503944158554, -0.4918447732925415, 0.7787407636642456, 0.08770619332790375, -0.32934269309043884, 0.1974199265241623, 0.4323600232601166, 0.5268672108650208, 0.012928730808198452, 0.32993513345718384, -0.3110142946243286, 0.4465388357639313, -0.5196973085403442, 0.2720465362071991, 0.21471059322357178, 0.2550818622112274, -0.32120829820632935, -0.39326751232147217, 0.30272376537323, -0.03609226271510124, 0.29933229088783264, 0.06448335945606232, 0.3803252875804901, 0.3510083258152008, -0.2321813851594925, 0.6428402066230774, -0.6710221767425537, -0.06835584342479706, 0.21443085372447968, 0.4063733220100403, 0.48920580744743347, 0.39183714985847473, 0.4348822236061096, -0.25373464822769165, 0.13194018602371216, -0.04024532809853554, -0.5684999227523804, 0.505808413028717, 0.49778473377227783, -0.5088948011398315, -1.1743239164352417, 0.36627092957496643, -0.47960513830184937, 0.05047955736517906, 0.30973148345947266, 0.2942819595336914, -0.24969744682312012, -0.21339957416057587, 0.42305442690849304, -0.5867707133293152, 0.3888058662414551, 0.9817060232162476, -0.3584061563014984, 1.018241047859192, 0.28827744722366333, 0.06766115128993988, -0.4409829378128052, -0.012830691412091255, 0.17052790522575378, -1.063977837562561, -0.37473103404045105, 0.3493962585926056, -0.9131820201873779, -0.02052256278693676, -0.2791402041912079, -0.5276026129722595, -0.3063333034515381, -0.12352846562862396, 0.029182156547904015, -0.3042752742767334, 0.6888993382453918, 0.6257378458976746, 0.13891074061393738, 0.44757190346717834, -0.2091122567653656, -1.1471468210220337, -0.0018840880366042256, -0.061051394790410995, -0.11502014100551605, 0.5197622776031494, -0.13435643911361694, 0.13277965784072876, 0.18689808249473572, 0.5744897127151489, 0.7603657841682434, -0.33311617374420166, -0.4019015431404114, 0.6385273337364197, 0.03678584098815918, -0.679537832736969, 0.013618331402540207, 0.18440724909305573, 0.7554423809051514, 0.5182979106903076, -0.0735003650188446, -0.30165374279022217, -0.12384653836488724, 0.011684373021125793, 0.23098936676979065, 0.4069860279560089, -0.45144331455230713, 0.7087770700454712, -1.0058341026306152, 0.29610076546669006, -0.3886420726776123, -0.49565425515174866, 0.16191169619560242, 0.044153958559036255, 0.572047233581543, -0.07402712851762772, -0.4852505326271057, 0.453288197517395, -0.05477911978960037, -0.6391647458076477, 0.4961390197277069, 0.4860494136810303, -0.6191239953041077, -0.4679892659187317, 0.3376774787902832, 0.15806925296783447, -0.32740846276283264, 0.011098889634013176, 0.4013477563858032, -0.2687537372112274, -0.12033221870660782, 0.42672815918922424, 0.25096043944358826, 0.7340924739837646, 0.4145337641239166, 0.84366774559021, -0.05718294903635979, 1.333141565322876, 0.12039586156606674, -0.08691561967134476, -0.6489899158477783, 0.7779679298400879, 0.933372437953949, -0.4741821587085724, -0.10046748071908951, -0.0983019471168518, 0.18927405774593353, 0.20476967096328735, 0.4706898629665375, -0.21786299347877502, 0.7530417442321777, 0.3240428864955902, 0.2463977187871933, 0.1319703906774521, -0.08175371587276459, -0.5722293853759766, 0.12094340473413467, 0.498334139585495, -0.6585767269134521, 0.397460401058197, -0.30019885301589966, -0.41045209765434265, -0.5506940484046936, 0.43272989988327026, -0.32247522473335266, 0.4931134879589081, 0.20934531092643738, 0.05578307434916496, -0.17573390901088715, -0.45014750957489014, 0.006644981447607279, -0.12940417230129242, -0.6692619919776917, -0.5548228621482849, -0.5957449078559875, 0.3442543148994446, 0.42898714542388916, 0.20461532473564148, -0.04205148667097092, 0.13192549347877502, -0.2597184181213379, -0.07664400339126587, 0.4384542405605316, -0.24339903891086578, -1.075789213180542, 0.1444067358970642, -0.7164808511734009, 0.5577776432037354, 0.14539487659931183, 0.21809926629066467, 0.27358248829841614, -0.3119564354419708, 0.2684020698070526, -0.4860924184322357, -0.12081442773342133, 0.23955759406089783, -0.7053192257881165, 0.540795624256134, -0.5745923519134521, 0.8583217859268188, -0.16658717393875122, 0.5851315855979919, -0.04048018530011177, 0.027999378740787506, -0.5299610495567322, -0.1763036549091339, -0.5860843658447266, 0.00338915316388011, -0.10915306955575943, -0.7301096320152283, -0.18565259873867035, 0.45033612847328186, 0.5420923233032227, -0.6739370822906494, 0.4849766492843628, 0.26717621088027954, -0.5288597345352173, -0.9351902008056641, -0.9651196002960205, 0.1474999040365219, 0.007362670730799437, -0.17506346106529236, -0.0047989897429943085, 0.28154176473617554, -0.7031988501548767, 0.31792208552360535, 0.009001106023788452, 0.7426339387893677, -0.23288503289222717, -0.24659189581871033, 0.4457862079143524, 0.22846804559230804, 0.4213622212409973, -0.8926974534988403, -1.2992627620697021, -0.7021211385726929, 0.509390115737915, -0.1143907755613327, -0.2245417982339859, 0.1994321048259735, 0.3383336663246155, -0.08549215644598007, 0.5530960559844971, -0.6603814959526062, 0.18052735924720764, -0.7855849862098694, -0.6758889555931091, 0.5293154120445251, -0.41125231981277466, -0.19531089067459106, -0.735209584236145, -0.16164806485176086, -0.017206087708473206, 0.47270530462265015, 0.3900230824947357, -0.11672370135784149, 0.025241147726774216, 0.7891714572906494, -0.414986789226532, 0.0799253061413765, 0.43170368671417236, 0.07281062006950378, -0.21888037025928497, -0.5399158000946045, -0.7237153649330139, -0.48312798142433167, 0.30649349093437195, 0.30531489849090576, -0.1292145997285843, 0.3831583857536316, 0.29327040910720825, -0.04994365572929382, -0.7523947358131409, -0.5291072130203247, -0.1815052330493927, 0.618596613407135, 0.6617659330368042, -0.20726290345191956, -0.09847887605428696, -0.055101700127124786, 0.07817168533802032, 0.0986984372138977, 0.19762170314788818, -1.0238240957260132, 0.04569572955369949, 0.060601606965065, -0.5898995995521545, -0.019530097022652626, 0.1905348151922226, 0.45887911319732666, 0.44663310050964355, 0.07913364470005035, 0.027501845732331276, -0.014290313236415386, 0.4835256040096283, -0.23485848307609558, 0.4094933271408081, 0.2564472258090973, -0.8004510998725891, -0.2269987165927887, 0.22385011613368988, 0.0587763711810112, -0.730622410774231, -0.9137826561927795, 0.03329749032855034, -0.4800075888633728, -0.17562609910964966, -0.1999109983444214, -0.7893952131271362, -0.3220146894454956, 0.5774456858634949, -0.03462290018796921, 0.22950780391693115, 0.24826733767986298, 0.31292271614074707, 0.17296062409877777, 0.4210069179534912, 0.3733266294002533, 0.18779511749744415, 0.1004718542098999, -0.34056156873703003, 0.7207790017127991, 0.3057997226715088, -0.04279717430472374, -0.158892422914505, 0.4341863691806793, 0.003889130661264062, 0.2874101400375366, 0.6500962972640991, 0.7037093043327332, -0.7055907249450684, 0.6768684387207031, 0.26575738191604614, -0.18973541259765625, -0.3759191334247589, 0.5207939147949219, 0.41950809955596924, 1.099671721458435, 0.10771918296813965, -0.8072556853294373, 0.5442282557487488, -0.17720676958560944, 0.23206092417240143, 0.2732205390930176, -1.1871848106384277, -0.5057618021965027, -0.46075037121772766, 0.2898940145969391, 0.11769188195466995, 0.7920734286308289, 0.7267206311225891, -0.1575555056333542, 0.7684781551361084, -0.25305983424186707, 0.2441663295030594, 0.33144858479499817, -0.12914785742759705, -0.12007825076580048, 0.2949346601963043, -0.019811850041151047, 0.18450507521629333, 0.4385952949523926, -0.14399579167366028, -1.1692907810211182, -0.18599823117256165, -1.0662541389465332, 1.0607103109359741, 0.25010034441947937, -0.42394059896469116, 0.6912577152252197, 0.3165796399116516, -0.48600682616233826, -0.2197074145078659, 0.7595952749252319, 0.22237437963485718, 0.6087493896484375, -0.3130704164505005, -0.6776613593101501, -0.8139572739601135, 0.292396605014801, -0.8662360310554504, 1.2776703834533691, 0.11136851459741592, -0.045057784765958786, 0.38640204071998596, 0.632876992225647, 0.02739681303501129, -0.5875486731529236, -0.4952569901943207, -1.3060497045516968, -0.24564167857170105, -0.1388847380876541, 0.32945317029953003, -0.629961371421814, 0.3295324146747589, 0.4613981246948242, -0.11894939094781876, -0.10204825550317764, 0.515019416809082, -0.5999383330345154, -0.2840385138988495, -0.08384186774492264, -0.7342615723609924, 0.329926997423172, -0.6618701815605164, -0.3355768322944641, -0.6504454016685486, -0.6408677697181702, 1.0796996355056763, -0.3664590120315552, -0.035669758915901184, -0.7903549075126648, 0.4498981237411499, -0.3305020034313202, 0.47740280628204346, -0.21973071992397308, -0.34945017099380493, 0.9385854601860046, -0.6292791962623596, -0.5001504421234131, -0.9779571890830994, 0.30565544962882996, 0.3945552408695221, 0.3734576106071472, 0.08502453565597534, 0.45208293199539185, -0.773550271987915, -0.010284765623509884, -0.5341867804527283, 0.3260241150856018, 0.14496180415153503, -1.0321717262268066, 0.7648531794548035, 0.5525351166725159, 0.95160973072052, -0.8094294667243958, 0.591545581817627, 0.6970984935760498, 0.3703894317150116, 0.13254094123840332, -0.06448516994714737, -0.6494412422180176, -0.08831863105297089, -1.1330645084381104, 0.45106902718544006, -0.8324571251869202, 0.37132641673088074, -0.2843437194824219, -0.6849794387817383, -0.0693068876862526, 0.30939027667045593, 0.5193968415260315, -0.577243447303772, -0.5135440230369568, -0.27039939165115356, 0.38321399688720703, -0.5004366636276245, -0.5699845552444458, -0.6132172346115112, 0.4387182593345642, -0.3980998694896698, 0.9550544023513794, -0.2585783004760742, 0.3732641935348511, 0.13494490087032318, -0.03837181627750397, 0.2935020327568054, 0.4358818531036377, 0.18211908638477325, -0.22025947272777557, -0.10848648846149445, 0.5876577496528625, 0.28755366802215576, 0.643694281578064, -0.856054425239563, -0.1296907216310501, -0.6561956405639648, 0.17724913358688354, -0.48625245690345764, -0.20885390043258667, -0.07118682563304901, 0.6441852450370789, 0.8208681344985962, -0.837665855884552, 0.20416125655174255, 0.52084881067276, 0.9394348859786987, 0.6082717180252075, 0.44714972376823425, -0.6048341393470764, 0.19859731197357178, -0.24504044651985168, 0.22768034040927887, 0.3305043876171112, -0.13134656846523285, 0.36648571491241455, -0.24339435994625092, -0.14104357361793518, -0.2467617690563202, -0.41626042127609253, 0.578920841217041, 0.8107790946960449, 0.2808102071285248, -0.00814987625926733, -0.9116079211235046, 0.17243990302085876, 0.010494635440409184, 0.6076952219009399, -0.13664625585079193, -0.596977949142456, -1.072082757949829, 0.3241206407546997, -0.009330647066235542, -0.6235399842262268, -0.2108629047870636, -0.10644561797380447, 0.6623178720474243, -0.7537621259689331, 0.9945404529571533, 0.04308505728840828, -0.41430145502090454, 0.19117413461208344, 0.18286293745040894, 1.1180883646011353, -0.14407159388065338, 0.6597248911857605, -0.44924792647361755, -0.06395027786493301, 0.8014244437217712, -0.07180611044168472, -0.21444153785705566, -0.9792450666427612, 0.7062092423439026, -0.7053553462028503, -0.019509995356202126, 0.38777339458465576, 0.6015748381614685, -1.080798625946045, -0.048665087670087814, -0.6698577404022217, -0.4297375977039337, 0.9199086427688599, -0.3438137173652649, -0.3611331880092621, -0.4965333044528961, -0.64814692735672, -0.3098236918449402, 0.16778163611888885, 1.0302114486694336, 0.15574045479297638, -0.03377299755811691, -0.2948133051395416, -0.6301630139350891, 0.3220756947994232, 1.5467174053192139, 0.37479066848754883, -0.636236846446991, -0.7243220806121826, -0.15620066225528717, -0.5411754250526428, -0.1231338381767273, 1.056318759918213, 0.1632896512746811, -0.2559451162815094, -0.19792725145816803, -0.16680507361888885, 0.0399346649646759, 1.109635829925537, -0.6016615033149719, 0.37384915351867676, -0.48749804496765137, -0.5572692155838013, -0.4771113395690918, -0.09923803061246872, 0.27349960803985596, 0.8763490915298462, 0.4581483006477356, -0.04977233707904816, 0.13044746220111847, -0.44522425532341003, 0.6422582864761353, -0.04472343623638153, -0.4723932445049286, -0.706082820892334, -0.3463261127471924, -0.6161569356918335, -0.4457390308380127, 0.2815746068954468, 0.5520919561386108, -0.5279793739318848, -0.17470736801624298, 0.20098382234573364, 0.6350070834159851, 0.0034694059286266565, 0.3349054455757141, -0.40343886613845825, -0.7848790287971497, -0.10652454942464828, -0.0639929249882698, 0.18153607845306396, -1.0853527784347534, -0.10963308811187744, 0.3108000159263611, 0.22489964962005615, 0.07261459529399872, 0.07132419943809509, 1.0066113471984863, -0.2006843537092209, 0.1566104143857956, 0.1688154637813568, -0.39855608344078064, -1.1685566902160645, 0.8578741550445557, -0.08026622235774994, 0.8002437949180603, 0.4536817967891693, -0.21266815066337585, 0.08425895869731903, 0.6941262483596802, -0.37186387181282043, 0.5208527445793152, -0.6880514621734619, -0.1025896817445755, -0.0016161736566573381, -0.6550941467285156, -0.5269472002983093, 1.2884907722473145, -0.3268926441669464, -0.48754778504371643, 0.1953522115945816, 0.6130238175392151, 0.4486059844493866, -0.22136540710926056, 0.049827948212623596, 0.24025656282901764, 0.32752856612205505, 0.008306141011416912, -0.22971893846988678, 0.14947621524333954, -0.027416100725531578, 0.3389819860458374, 0.4037685692310333, -0.27126291394233704, 0.16458731889724731, -0.11374727636575699, -0.12301714718341827, 1.0061129331588745, 0.2503904402256012, -0.4441128075122833, -0.005248778499662876, -0.4541531503200531, -0.4466766119003296, -0.4711950421333313, -0.6187444925308228, 0.31301888823509216, 0.09264244139194489, -0.5153741836547852, 0.37522315979003906, 0.09947267174720764, -1.0164381265640259, 0.6870763897895813, -0.5960456728935242, -1.104517936706543, 0.2658649682998657, -0.44932085275650024, -0.32394635677337646, 0.3846983313560486, -0.6426697969436646, 0.5922519564628601, 0.1312076598405838, 0.49033161997795105, 0.3625943958759308, -0.33371955156326294, -0.6585343480110168, -0.22579343616962433, -1.0588347911834717, 0.23088078200817108, -0.456400990486145, -0.05728047341108322, -0.5823658108711243, -0.7000864148139954, 0.012798348441720009, 0.3991472125053406, 0.032070811837911606, -0.5754848122596741, -0.34920310974121094, 0.30555009841918945, -0.8133133053779602, -0.19382458925247192, -0.8025239109992981, -0.5758169293403625, -0.7314229607582092, -0.5769516229629517, -0.6602616906166077, -0.016148105263710022, 0.0685240775346756, 0.22732645273208618, 1.1333659887313843, -0.6229749321937561, -0.0260043703019619, -0.07102548331022263, 0.4603961408138275, 0.33707302808761597, -0.12772591412067413, 0.7217379808425903, 0.35216063261032104, 0.9773386120796204, -1.0445525646209717, -0.3500337302684784, -0.20724426209926605, 0.5086029171943665, 0.14092107117176056, -0.06978627294301987, -0.16686971485614777, 0.17283429205417633, 0.8526867628097534, 0.5955442190170288, -0.26323607563972473, 0.5910041332244873, -0.14031293988227844, 0.15268193185329437, -0.03931248188018799, -0.2064582258462906, -0.059801135212183, 0.040977004915475845, 0.5600225925445557, -0.011503438465297222, -0.13977022469043732, -0.23989525437355042, -0.42032113671302795, -0.04537015035748482, -0.7923759818077087, -0.6827031373977661, -0.5196352005004883, -0.5199155807495117, 0.2998819351196289, 0.19904233515262604, 0.4816339910030365, 0.11034996062517166, 0.17236573994159698, -0.018693793565034866, 0.3313314914703369, 1.082177996635437, 0.09775638580322266, 1.0258591175079346, 0.33229947090148926, 0.1554819643497467, -0.2867904007434845, 0.5920605063438416, -0.14813390374183655, -0.6749355792999268, -0.06155591458082199, -0.28213080763816833, -0.8683231472969055, 0.4741903841495514, -0.10162006318569183, -0.6280819177627563, -0.2587824761867523, -0.3396761119365692, 0.5069637298583984, -0.6224926710128784, 0.24371875822544098, 1.6658470630645752, -0.23422932624816895, 0.19608958065509796, 0.10761480033397675, -0.36703377962112427, -0.23264090716838837, 0.7897805571556091, 0.3450213074684143, -0.3471303880214691, 1.1931915283203125, 0.6419493556022644, 0.24266542494297028, -0.10157694667577744, -0.7170851230621338, 0.5678851008415222, -0.11327628791332245, 0.5101416707038879, 0.09309446811676025, 0.0857609212398529, 0.23267854750156403, 0.08155997842550278, -0.33821287751197815, -0.08266477286815643, 0.4227084517478943, 0.4008312523365021, 0.13429352641105652, 0.15580002963542938, -0.31059613823890686, -0.14695622026920319, 0.47057387232780457, 0.7515032291412354, -0.6521847248077393, -0.6203082203865051, -0.38334694504737854, -0.5808124542236328, -0.1411799043416977, 0.056737229228019714, 0.5640730261802673, -0.3640379011631012, -0.3506350517272949, 0.319134920835495, -0.21535976231098175, -0.17813414335250854, -0.11055175960063934, -0.8667017221450806, -0.787218451499939, -0.6702298521995544, 0.2965428829193115, 0.9662936925888062, 0.6998288631439209, -0.5712295770645142, -0.21349658071994781, -0.07787266373634338, 0.225603386759758, -0.180429607629776, -0.27305659651756287, 0.4567747116088867, 0.3785123825073242, -0.38962218165397644, 0.4448089599609375, 0.43961480259895325, -0.5415653586387634, -0.519146740436554, 0.23915424942970276, 1.0430539846420288, -0.0763649269938469, -0.6556377410888672, 0.4714013934135437, 0.5183050036430359, 0.24439795315265656, -0.038341227918863297, -0.35531672835350037, 0.34846818447113037, -0.6143363118171692, -0.25046396255493164, 0.26535001397132874, 0.8386982679367065, 0.48366132378578186, 0.24048006534576416, 0.06927339732646942, -0.8990854024887085, 4.2387614250183105, 0.5613997578620911, 0.8358375430107117, -0.1037573516368866, 0.17399422824382782, 0.714731752872467, 0.09261094778776169, -1.2607026100158691, -0.008992272429168224, -0.1274830549955368, -0.3521604835987091, 0.04472268372774124, 0.3245408236980438, -0.13294552266597748, -0.48181939125061035, 1.310211420059204, -0.08253051340579987, -0.43222370743751526, 0.16826140880584717, -0.901057779788971, -0.7157526612281799, -0.015322038903832436, -0.24239295721054077, -0.6725103259086609, 0.29358604550361633, 0.2922807037830353, 0.2507390081882477, 0.2705076336860657, -0.06704236567020416, -0.22818446159362793, -1.1321419477462769, -0.3552910089492798, 0.3542710840702057, -0.4671512544155121, -0.44540664553642273, 0.8430154919624329, -0.06612040102481842, -0.5289737582206726, 0.10500949621200562, -0.5631791353225708, 0.2846137285232544, -1.00392746925354, -0.003633031854405999, -0.7368350028991699, -0.3870178163051605, 1.230179786682129, 0.745241641998291, 0.6038303971290588, 0.9860249161720276, -0.47927790880203247, 0.3805660307407379, -0.34970682859420776, -0.11349271237850189, -0.12092038244009018, -0.685303270816803, 0.22576290369033813, 0.326968789100647, -0.023036707192659378, 0.40753522515296936, 0.011479663662612438, 0.3711237609386444, -0.14528384804725647, -0.808480441570282, 0.5004202127456665, -0.27065542340278625, 0.7774266004562378, 0.21994955837726593, 0.3163914382457733, -0.44762852787971497, -0.0757712572813034, -0.2172146439552307, -0.5957579016685486, -0.18452221155166626, 0.05448107048869133, 0.05013662204146385, 0.26133355498313904, 0.2854742109775543, -0.2978016436100006, -0.8130735754966736, -0.15711010992527008, -0.013788620941340923, 0.15074487030506134, -0.6750471591949463, 0.06198937073349953, 0.15023887157440186, 0.3633348345756531, -0.09117516130208969, -0.41434741020202637, -0.5682279467582703, 1.041011929512024, -0.08887838572263718, 0.17517143487930298, 0.16207526624202728, -0.57772296667099, -0.4861277937889099 ]
Evidence for a Very Broad Line Region in PG 1138+222
We present a high S/N spectrum for the quasar PG 1138+222. We detect a very broad HeII$\lambda$4686 emission line component with twice the FWHM of the conventional broad line region (BLR) as evidenced by the Balmer lines. The profile shape and centroid redshift also distinguish this HeII component from the BLR features. The large ratio of HeII\l 4686 to any analogous H$\beta$ emission component is an indicator that it arises in a very high density region ($n_e \simgt 10^{11}-10^{13}$ \cm3). This Helium component is probably emitted in a Very Broad Line Region (VBLR), where the radiation field is so strong that the Str\"omgren depth becomes similar to the geometrical thickness of the emitting clouds. The gas could therefore be optically thin to the Lyman continuum.
Paolo Marziani and Jack W. Sulentic
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210005
astro-ph/9210006
[ 0.2047426551580429, 0.7209974527359009, 0.46489471197128296, -0.8900976777076721, -0.015183541923761368, -0.09386762976646423, 0.4175410866737366, -0.5739511251449585, 0.14968568086624146, 1.02951180934906, -0.139252170920372, -0.21093575656414032, 0.2943851053714752, -0.9006131887435913, -0.2611880302429199, 0.469708114862442, 0.27608153223991394, -0.569977879524231, -1.4912172555923462, 0.14629201591014862, -0.060375019907951355, -0.6397731900215149, -0.702189028263092, -0.7840898036956787, -0.5072121620178223, 0.16071496903896332, -0.038605134934186935, 0.5910954475402832, 1.091046690940857, 0.47375762462615967, 0.017345495522022247, -0.7357008457183838, 0.10322985798120499, -0.07244803011417389, -0.44748935103416443, -0.24194416403770447, 0.14689168334007263, -0.4688250720500946, 0.5615233182907104, -0.8051828145980835, 0.7689927220344543, 0.1233704537153244, 0.9504603147506714, -0.05588771775364876, 0.1516241431236267, 0.4152972102165222, -0.08697833120822906, -1.0478841066360474, 0.6545379757881165, -0.9003763198852539, 0.1459881067276001, -0.02603653445839882, 0.11717263609170914, -0.11690329015254974, 0.38141435384750366, -0.24927876889705658, 0.6981931924819946, 0.2781752943992615, -0.4475630223751068, 0.13338175415992737, 0.43779581785202026, 0.6429283022880554, 0.13864697515964508, -0.4294794499874115, -0.8526621460914612, 0.6399396061897278, -0.6253284215927124, 0.42203566431999207, -0.23722262680530548, -0.31899556517601013, -0.5168075561523438, -0.0033933757804334164, -0.07812032848596573, 0.4951545298099518, -0.3771045207977295, 0.2420225292444229, 0.11869549006223679, -0.05118926614522934, -0.25738412141799927, -0.538223922252655, -0.06725764274597168, 0.7093037962913513, 0.9263861775398254, 0.2578257918357849, 0.5971125364303589, -0.6777501106262207, 0.02225339412689209, -0.14717543125152588, 0.06587107479572296, 0.16033779084682465, 0.07252903282642365, 0.9453144669532776, -0.4385174810886383, 0.3596872389316559, 0.8043784499168396, -0.063944973051548, 0.0027126178611069918, 0.28966084122657776, -0.44909414649009705, 0.5554118156433105, 0.4613587260246277, 0.9289706349372864, -0.1813802272081375, 0.4004404544830322, -0.6192631721496582, 0.25957348942756653, 0.21573100984096527, 0.12582454085350037, -0.22812198102474213, -0.44828885793685913, 0.3515518009662628, 0.5995888710021973, 0.49614882469177246, 0.14587560296058655, 0.9105754494667053, 0.046450529247522354, -0.34588924050331116, -0.03687140718102455, -0.3714757561683655, -0.07814088463783264, -0.12858504056930542, 0.47428444027900696, -0.49340692162513733, 0.05391921103000641, -0.03665514290332794, -0.014141248539090157, -0.1583448350429535, 0.24627047777175903, -0.6521263122558594, 0.18743419647216797, 0.2509651780128479, -0.7371943593025208, -0.287796288728714, 1.0870256423950195, 0.4602455496788025, 0.3245609998703003, 0.516461193561554, 0.5418584942817688, 0.4993784427642822, -1.5530242919921875, -0.19435754418373108, -0.4490673243999481, 0.16349950432777405, 0.7988784313201904, -0.2169857770204544, 0.1965976506471634, 0.5068050622940063, -0.7193669080734253, 0.03967403620481491, -0.059340521693229675, -0.22706325352191925, -0.8745898604393005, -0.029698463156819344, 0.33643099665641785, -0.4937138259410858, -0.42313486337661743, -0.7910186052322388, 0.38107994198799133, -0.5012437701225281, -0.28416749835014343, 0.3544200658798218, -0.8266363143920898, 0.4834389090538025, 0.3962544798851013, -0.6236667633056641, 0.287005215883255, -0.22065620124340057, -1.3126804828643799, 0.7800666689872742, -0.2062530517578125, -0.18588803708553314, 0.9033586382865906, 0.027584243565797806, 0.18700222671031952, 0.24552911520004272, 0.11531725525856018, 0.41436681151390076, -0.289054811000824, -0.871776282787323, 0.1306101381778717, -0.09437466412782669, -0.16690164804458618, -0.10303019732236862, 0.43268823623657227, -0.16987363994121552, 0.4870113730430603, -0.2734169363975525, -0.2496705800294876, 0.3842233121395111, 0.2798013389110565, 0.1965862661600113, 0.16445985436439514, -0.6684778928756714, 0.01542545948177576, -1.2683874368667603, 0.06277810782194138, -0.16128596663475037, -0.3806784749031067, 0.19101567566394806, -0.7006127834320068, 0.24271619319915771, 0.4865102767944336, -0.23383121192455292, 0.4385574460029602, -0.6909783482551575, 0.2693917155265808, 0.7904918789863586, 0.7126629948616028, -0.1699255108833313, -0.2322937697172165, 1.0098971128463745, -0.24712727963924408, 0.18570886552333832, -0.14669889211654663, 0.23225858807563782, -0.12467688322067261, 0.14837415516376495, 0.260731965303421, 0.2734648287296295, -0.31838157773017883, 0.4680905044078827, 0.043392084538936615, -0.2233126014471054, 0.9889918565750122, -0.38418447971343994, -0.04698757454752922, -0.3470102548599243, 0.8981455564498901, 0.5152203440666199, 0.4138830304145813, -0.3113250732421875, -0.10441703349351883, 0.5289916396141052, 0.028843000531196594, 0.33287152647972107, -0.6613152623176575, 0.7090545892715454, 1.0733234882354736, -0.030253013595938683, 0.1018318459391594, 0.20243054628372192, 0.1164560616016388, 0.8561381697654724, 0.35560110211372375, -0.5639714002609253, 0.8050872087478638, -0.20019765198230743, 0.015687735751271248, -0.8747193813323975, 0.5863123536109924, -0.8785181641578674, 0.6685925126075745, -0.049929820001125336, -0.1743927001953125, -0.9035269021987915, -0.4276377856731415, -0.08277034014463425, -0.003553264308720827, -0.25859445333480835, -1.3631534576416016, 0.645947277545929, -0.2119377702474594, 0.09231167286634445, 0.023999208584427834, 0.17759457230567932, 0.4594697654247284, 0.05749782919883728, 0.44682642817497253, 0.5681771636009216, -0.30295783281326294, -1.0887988805770874, 0.1622062474489212, -0.5281468629837036, -0.14649979770183563, -0.034672413021326065, -0.015125637874007225, 0.09309373050928116, -0.6405842304229736, 1.003869652748108, -0.033621590584516525, -0.1655024141073227, 0.31581181287765503, -0.6547290086746216, 0.3899838328361511, -0.6776631474494934, 0.3360929489135742, -0.6950445771217346, 0.4082477390766144, -0.4687974750995636, 0.47011905908584595, -0.2815193235874176, -0.07978655397891998, -1.2379753589630127, -0.04697107523679733, 0.4510587155818939, 0.3591381013393402, 0.25048598647117615, 0.6730096340179443, 1.0823391675949097, -0.6029418110847473, 0.09410598874092102, 0.27136823534965515, -0.7365376949310303, -0.6020461320877075, -0.9282825589179993, 0.07617218047380447, -0.8511037230491638, 0.11134696751832962, 0.2523834705352783, 0.08506999164819717, -0.310008704662323, 0.5849828720092773, -0.2685517966747284, 0.2693759799003601, -0.4514116048812866, 0.1802244782447815, 0.8762093186378479, -0.12911084294319153, 0.7216293215751648, -0.5224086046218872, -0.8558381199836731, -0.7770194411277771, 0.5816159248352051, -0.23735535144805908, -0.11085262149572372, 0.6686281561851501, -0.014311859384179115, -0.3272799849510193, 0.6486353874206543, -0.7471195459365845, -0.2020116001367569, -0.29276880621910095, -0.21862520277500153, 0.576483428478241, -0.38884174823760986, -0.1469656378030777, -0.6069613695144653, 0.0005695871077477932, -0.10941150039434433, 0.6534374952316284, 0.4640982449054718, 0.3298685550689697, -0.03079167753458023, 0.4609721899032593, -0.5836519598960876, -0.7653733491897583, 1.266260027885437, -0.08802971988916397, 0.5586726665496826, -0.5963796377182007, 0.4659634828567505, -0.06194249540567398, 0.5932530760765076, 0.05713421851396561, -0.5930171012878418, 0.20515313744544983, -0.1228056326508522, -0.11606115102767944, -0.1838592141866684, -0.7570914030075073, -0.21554848551750183, 0.04566098004579544, 0.09645761549472809, 0.1390867680311203, -0.1736145168542862, 0.02623816207051277, 0.0032816999591886997, -0.4103580713272095, 0.30031919479370117, -0.6438755393028259, 0.41618677973747253, 0.6863054633140564, -0.3366342782974243, -0.24961504340171814, -0.10986076295375824, 0.456930547952652, 0.6036186218261719, 0.21138091385364532, 1.2008460760116577, -0.42097193002700806, -0.1276201754808426, -0.34082868695259094, 0.40330448746681213, 0.4473612904548645, 0.25508543848991394, -0.04460730403661728, 0.5610095262527466, 0.6769738793373108, -0.5748113393783569, -0.5780019760131836, -0.06837587803602219, -0.7102342247962952, 0.29478126764297485, -0.5131345391273499, -0.5637001991271973, 0.006628702394664288, 0.6661763787269592, 0.44916120171546936, 0.24333436787128448, -0.3495326042175293, 0.13376015424728394, -1.260879635810852, 0.49418318271636963, 0.2398613840341568, 0.02070457860827446, 0.16042286157608032, -0.23396587371826172, -0.2828104794025421, 0.7325934767723083, -0.3361704647541046, 0.06692039221525192, 0.16875766217708588, -0.19388343393802643, 0.954538106918335, 0.15917673707008362, 0.46577194333076477, -0.12958990037441254, 0.6548563838005066, 0.21790839731693268, 0.1644616574048996, -0.8277173638343811, 0.10980134457349777, -0.23113390803337097, 0.9988794326782227, -0.12851598858833313, -0.6243183016777039, 0.25692218542099, -0.500182032585144, 0.018723994493484497, 0.1477256864309311, -0.7402938604354858, -0.525505781173706, -0.13736246526241302, 0.9611197710037231, 0.6292832493782043, 0.49031946063041687, 0.7764970660209656, 0.4998690187931061, -0.3920336365699768, -0.02677696943283081, 0.35111039876937866, 0.4628654718399048, -0.1495489925146103, 0.17321091890335083, -0.011843032203614712, -0.005862066056579351, -0.18006391823291779, 0.1639026552438736, -0.46472877264022827, -0.612158477306366, -0.04589812085032463, -0.06127307191491127, 0.4845447540283203, -0.00623795622959733, -0.07838695496320724, 0.4032781422138214, -0.18244843184947968, -0.2709311842918396, -0.03149205818772316, -0.19088076055049896, -0.1720004379749298, 0.38036152720451355, 0.3030305504798889, -0.009953556582331657, -0.6117533445358276, -0.0912470817565918, -0.9074488878250122, 0.7845714688301086, 0.705837070941925, 1.0793226957321167, 0.19891659915447235, 0.3867124915122986, -0.8310190439224243, -0.24366700649261475, 0.1730128973722458, -0.16427220404148102, 0.3798457384109497, -0.4667896628379822, -0.06544855237007141, -0.37482765316963196, 0.6135527491569519, 0.26610398292541504, -0.4797932207584381, 0.23528937995433807, -0.09237412363290787, -0.8856224417686462, -0.14210131764411926, 0.24219480156898499, -0.40956270694732666, 0.4940919280052185, 0.022393370047211647, -0.5906351804733276, -0.2068604826927185, -0.49673596024513245, 0.09906266629695892, -0.803695023059845, 0.21740353107452393, -0.37857586145401, 0.1425483077764511, -0.1761132925748825, 0.5616747140884399, -0.20579692721366882, -0.6333972811698914, -0.0477844774723053, -0.49012747406959534, -0.27029892802238464, -0.10590143501758575, -1.0100326538085938, -1.0680657625198364, 0.0346025712788105, -0.07351380586624146, -0.056413132697343826, -0.3878721594810486, 0.09934516251087189, -0.5903035998344421, 0.9143781661987305, -0.18457025289535522, -0.651860237121582, -0.3455777168273926, -0.5099382996559143, 0.11142069846391678, -0.6202058792114258, -0.20765085518360138, 0.4563419222831726, -0.07091201096773148, 0.05214175954461098, -0.4140835702419281, -0.8165342807769775, 0.185667023062706, -0.6065952181816101, -0.15784601867198944, -1.1608171463012695, -0.00930078700184822, 0.2601027190685272, -0.6019656658172607, -0.44481536746025085, 0.08634866029024124, 0.7171061038970947, -0.8317559957504272, -0.8820879459381104, -0.30221453309059143, -0.05534509941935539, -0.8532951474189758, 0.144051656126976, -0.6065822243690491, -0.10625452548265457, -0.28429800271987915, 1.166951060295105, -0.7939004898071289, 0.12679781019687653, 0.097632497549057, 0.026167025789618492, -0.12820784747600555, 0.7008665204048157, -0.33866584300994873, 0.551557183265686, -0.4047388732433319, -0.13406036794185638, 0.001975796651095152, -0.15680573880672455, -0.8026048541069031, 0.4018106162548065, -0.787667989730835, 0.11266200244426727, 0.05509692803025246, -0.1150345578789711, 0.03447265923023224, -0.2030886709690094, 0.2945372462272644, 0.2591019868850708, 1.0543256998062134, 0.7904178500175476, 0.21469925343990326, 0.21297197043895721, 0.39321595430374146, -0.6734191179275513, -0.6257624626159668, -0.8602301478385925, -0.25273358821868896, 0.3738876283168793, 0.0876409113407135, -0.06902322918176651, -0.43351122736930847, -0.07493246346712112, -0.12924401462078094, -0.6208804845809937, -0.10942333936691284, 0.7214618921279907, 0.6048536896705627, 0.14101958274841309, -1.0527808666229248, -0.05088485777378082, -0.31153222918510437, 0.30220627784729004, 0.7130644917488098, -0.29673880338668823, -0.9017947912216187, 0.2057967483997345, 0.3270549774169922, -0.8851141333580017, -0.6422666311264038, 0.601098358631134, 0.4161336421966553, -0.19690993428230286, 0.6599404811859131, -0.3925151824951172, -0.25985684990882874, 0.19531545042991638, 0.03642277419567108, 0.7604960799217224, 0.13086706399917603, 0.1567661613225937, 0.25348758697509766, -0.03091224655508995, 0.4092113673686981, -0.18907493352890015, -0.5034641623497009, 0.09209117293357849, 0.4697001576423645, -0.08003249019384384, -0.16037917137145996, -0.2980368435382843, 0.323335736989975, -0.7122256755828857, -0.17173291742801666, -1.056668996810913, -0.0043926541693508625, -0.1758393794298172, -0.4560610055923462, -0.3228619694709778, 0.1948317438364029, -0.32363423705101013, 0.17145936191082, 0.5518440008163452, 0.5512415766716003, -0.17628483474254608, -0.37000977993011475, -0.4236530065536499, -0.14645487070083618, -0.20002441108226776, 1.793686032295227, -0.041467756032943726, -0.5778441429138184, 0.21375772356987, 0.012126542627811432, -0.48725298047065735, -0.6617189049720764, 0.5777425765991211, 0.22652564942836761, 0.26508980989456177, -0.20350275933742523, 0.5258361101150513, -0.04106135293841362, 0.20367492735385895, 0.2354705035686493, 0.30427661538124084, -0.7382575273513794, -0.354381263256073, -0.5312249660491943, -0.017636163160204887, 0.12798970937728882, 0.5870340466499329, 0.7970293760299683, 0.11929206550121307, 0.09199651330709457, -1.1472299098968506, 0.14641684293746948, 0.2808997929096222, -0.18756937980651855, -0.11494240909814835, -0.5921622514724731, -0.5371071696281433, 0.1962769627571106, -0.043009717017412186, 0.8508609533309937, -0.5351172685623169, 0.15923702716827393, 0.4731074869632721, 0.33073750138282776, 0.05534138157963753, -0.15978506207466125, 0.07887644320726395, -0.18771736323833466, -0.8833219408988953, -0.058533601462841034, -0.36171671748161316, -1.6007804870605469, -0.44621941447257996, -0.0773581713438034, -0.07564672082662582, 1.1095547676086426, 0.07765717059373856, 0.7179206609725952, -0.19983592629432678, -0.17588965594768524, -0.7640817761421204, -0.09617388993501663, -0.23935045301914215, 0.9202948808670044, -0.8156816959381104, 0.6266698837280273, 0.3883410096168518, -0.4545229375362396, 0.07295824587345123, 0.4957951307296753, -0.4555419981479645, 0.8380482196807861, -0.31364554166793823, 0.5145306587219238, -0.9405883550643921, -0.12037643045186996, -0.22581036388874054, 0.9586430191993713, -0.6823940873146057, -0.660539448261261, -0.2787858545780182, 0.7152743935585022, 0.8247209787368774, -0.6556299924850464, 0.15369048714637756, 0.7043938636779785, 0.1917840540409088, -0.2900509536266327, -0.1667356789112091, -0.05591486394405365, -0.19490841031074524, 0.5129554271697998, -0.17684081196784973, -0.3765685260295868, -0.5764803290367126, -0.908139169216156, 0.3414076566696167, 0.61185622215271, 0.6070102453231812, -0.08802313357591629, -0.22626708447933197, 0.7128095030784607, -0.26241424679756165, 0.15346789360046387, -0.17215432226657867, 0.8115763068199158, 0.974933385848999, 0.023260856047272682, -0.06152251362800598, -0.752289354801178, -0.7222270965576172, 0.23310478031635284, -0.31923750042915344, -0.10524339973926544, -0.01870151422917843, -0.40875008702278137, -0.12303119152784348, 0.07520316541194916, -0.2399066984653473, 0.6106454133987427, -0.2327774316072464, 0.22221031785011292, 0.2320234328508377, -0.022202080115675926, -0.7806905508041382, 0.2924833595752716, -0.8933473825454712, 0.30524885654449463, -0.49037429690361023, 0.37735864520072937, -0.6067855954170227, -1.1569770574569702, -0.4716731309890747, -0.37851399183273315, -0.6237188577651978, -0.3739788234233856, -0.048247531056404114, 0.229827418923378, 0.20887109637260437, 0.008979907259345055, -0.2870436906814575, -0.15903213620185852, -0.22448593378067017, -0.1227630004286766, 0.05752949044108391, -0.11905544996261597, 0.191909521818161, -0.09367983043193817, 0.8468077778816223, -0.33787062764167786, -0.13288679718971252, 1.043413758277893, 0.09172531217336655, 0.46859556436538696, 0.49686524271965027, 0.9107339382171631, -0.08088753372430801, -0.1296580731868744, -0.40901127457618713, 0.4132004380226135, 0.3856395483016968, -0.35942399501800537, 0.491145521402359, 0.607822060585022, -0.13722902536392212, -0.37543177604675293, -0.4450550377368927, -0.405804306268692, -0.6422871947288513, 0.03834053501486778, -0.5451513528823853, -0.2749084234237671, -0.022488877177238464, 0.4955860674381256, -0.17885001003742218, 0.3549431562423706, 0.8447446227073669, 0.5327430963516235, 0.17242856323719025, -0.8813692331314087, -0.19661851227283478, 0.5967575311660767, -0.4922587275505066, -0.6161848902702332, -0.45902496576309204, 0.2403852790594101, 0.15761326253414154, 0.8931825160980225, -0.0976739451289177, -0.21512442827224731, 0.611294150352478, 0.177423357963562, -0.36550962924957275, 0.5811813473701477, 0.8048640489578247, 0.565029501914978, 0.13032908737659454, 1.498411774635315, 0.4095383584499359, 0.6748998165130615, -0.29234743118286133, -1.1615111827850342, -0.41119393706321716, 0.7838599681854248, -0.21246443688869476, -0.3084560036659241, 0.0001663485891185701, 0.04580429196357727, 0.1199197769165039, -0.7032672166824341, -0.08037994056940079, -0.6835287809371948, 0.415209025144577, 1.0569905042648315, -0.9869382977485657, 0.12211482971906662, 0.08206441253423691, 0.4856717884540558, 0.24807175993919373, 0.12085457891225815, 0.016778670251369476, -0.290774405002594, 1.1865342855453491, 1.0099164247512817, -0.10310930758714676, 0.6050480008125305, 0.09535230696201324, 0.13806112110614777, -0.39386123418807983, 0.9143803119659424, -1.0539500713348389, 0.2919061481952667, -0.02857382595539093, -0.46018487215042114, -0.5460893511772156, -0.17455336451530457, -0.2840418219566345, 0.6954714059829712, 0.7619724273681641, 0.11752666532993317, -0.6398428678512573, -0.2697446644306183, 0.06918172538280487, 0.1470940113067627, 0.1656448394060135, -0.12393724173307419, 0.721098780632019, -1.2363684177398682, -0.5780141949653625, -0.31678345799446106, 0.0406198650598526, -0.5558455586433411, 0.03314458951354027, -0.1679791510105133, -0.16029037535190582, 0.7013537287712097, -0.6007464528083801, -1.0091264247894287, -0.06275202333927155, 0.86821448802948, 0.544041097164154, 0.8467506766319275, -0.31244340538978577, -0.8830139636993408, -0.7034674286842346, 0.2748161256313324, 0.13536828756332397, -0.11722718924283981, -0.15838289260864258, 0.11873243749141693, 0.25167790055274963, -0.8595938086509705, 0.7303573489189148, 0.5256615877151489, -0.6896800398826599, 0.32160207629203796, -0.08070295304059982, -0.34289148449897766, -0.09537395089864731, -0.5990129113197327, 0.5704281330108643, 0.6625074148178101, 0.44717007875442505, 0.5281344652175903, -0.2808211147785187, 0.44420337677001953, -0.9071271419525146, -1.1451776027679443, -0.11995615065097809, 0.14722321927547455, 0.03598859906196594, -0.5817509889602661, 0.17275875806808472, -0.8604840636253357, 4.21722412109375, 0.4934711754322052, 0.5179529190063477, -0.38062500953674316, 0.5763524770736694, 0.9103206396102905, 0.3853800296783447, -0.6584277749061584, 0.9991914629936218, -0.5702399015426636, -0.0012153489515185356, 0.4389689862728119, 0.7973791360855103, 0.20687343180179596, 0.05379573628306389, 0.6587326526641846, -0.2738492786884308, -0.6569657325744629, 0.3568655550479889, -0.13454920053482056, -0.4451259672641754, -0.2901373505592346, -0.5776607394218445, 0.1615249067544937, 0.07468787580728531, 0.06465456634759903, -0.34513401985168457, -0.8964577317237854, -0.3047798275947571, 0.6147897839546204, -0.7200284600257874, -0.13014018535614014, 0.7626852989196777, -0.3762718439102173, -0.4207000136375427, 0.40073058009147644, -0.3374462127685547, -0.2495042085647583, 0.1611441671848297, -0.35923513770103455, -0.21127352118492126, -0.3333771228790283, -0.2460019439458847, -0.02147848904132843, -0.1385076940059662, 1.5818312168121338, 0.2595941722393036, 0.31311991810798645, 1.2716209888458252, -0.6447487473487854, 0.36880913376808167, 0.22995439171791077, -0.06941371411085129, 0.33339089155197144, -0.955807089805603, -0.086576908826828, 0.1730392724275589, -0.5638028383255005, -0.17934271693229675, -0.15702760219573975, 0.8364397287368774, -0.5341210961341858, 0.08160475641489029, 1.2731142044067383, -0.17433205246925354, 0.44139155745506287, 0.20410600304603577, -0.10808127373456955, -0.6152682900428772, -0.28610122203826904, -0.24536502361297607, -0.0915410965681076, -0.0752224326133728, -0.20003966987133026, 0.6515126824378967, -0.264156699180603, 0.34279534220695496, -0.2924126088619232, -0.49831199645996094, -0.02531680464744568, -0.07965083420276642, -0.12151657789945602, -0.490229070186615, 0.26101794838905334, 0.09918974339962006, 0.16136537492275238, 0.16316431760787964, -0.7670772075653076, -0.08586004376411438, 0.866805374622345, 0.5283396244049072, 0.8535611033439636, -0.6567119359970093, 0.2639041543006897, -0.4999036490917206 ]
On the Origin of the Galactic Magnetic Field
The galactic magnetic field is commonly supposed to be due to a dynamo acting on some large scale seed field. A major difficulty with this idea is that estimates of reasonable seed field strengths tend to be quite low, on the order of $\sim10^{-20}$ gauss. Here we examine the contribution due to the flux entrained in winds from protostars formed in the first dynamo e-folding time of a galaxy's existence. Using a minimal estimate of a protostellar magnetic field we find that if each protostar ejects a single current ring, sufficient to maintain flux freezing in the wind, than the large scale average dipole field from all such current rings will be at least 5 orders of magnitude larger than previous seed field estimates. Allowing for a reasonable amount of magnetic activity in protostars during an extended period of mass loss increases this to a dipole seed field of $\sim10^{-12}$ gauss. For the purposes of producing a seed field it is irrelevant whether or not this initial injection of flux takes place in a newly formed galactic disk, or in star forming proto-galactic clouds. The compression of this dipole field into a thin disk will lead to a large scale $B_r\sim 10^{-10.5}$ gauss. Initially, field strengths on smaller scales will be larger, but nowhere near current levels.
Ethan T. Vishniac
astro-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210006
astro-ph/9210007
[ 0.3942437469959259, 0.48118340969085693, 0.4048411250114441, -0.07924138754606247, -0.9725741147994995, 0.10142240673303604, -0.7030288577079773, -0.45654234290122986, -1.0000299215316772, 1.1737451553344727, 0.5671844482421875, -1.038286805152893, 0.39027050137519836, -0.6812494993209839, -0.7058981657028198, -0.315451443195343, 0.26649823784828186, -0.5222252607345581, -1.6574122905731201, 0.1470116376876831, -0.22710999846458435, -0.1501302719116211, -1.4043939113616943, -0.5951874256134033, -0.4231931269168854, 0.6433331966400146, 0.4038669466972351, 0.20664392411708832, 0.8540233373641968, 0.05786678194999695, 0.04630380868911743, -0.18103866279125214, -0.18330880999565125, -0.3357064425945282, 0.17483015358448029, -0.018557673320174217, -0.30831626057624817, 0.45168164372444153, 1.1504247188568115, -0.12724649906158447, 1.1641883850097656, -0.2542110085487366, 0.31377214193344116, -0.48470601439476013, -0.587794840335846, -0.05826354771852493, -0.6917956471443176, -0.3418888747692108, 0.6465882062911987, -1.0318843126296997, 0.40935903787612915, 0.11736110597848892, 0.7340647578239441, -1.16558039188385, 0.5538203716278076, -0.10474779456853867, 0.23860621452331543, 0.05356448143720627, -0.8581434488296509, -0.24189378321170807, 0.1702444702386856, 0.4046410322189331, 0.5985923409461975, -0.15854573249816895, -0.15565921366214752, 1.1229223012924194, -0.38824665546417236, 0.4716620445251465, -0.2861275374889374, 0.35505959391593933, -0.051220908761024475, -0.29404938220977783, -0.7227174043655396, 0.34732168912887573, -0.8583868741989136, 0.19234012067317963, 0.20039817690849304, -0.10730873793363571, -1.0732619762420654, -0.7741848230361938, -0.19978497922420502, 0.34314486384391785, 0.9352387189865112, 0.45225411653518677, 0.4280151128768921, -0.7334133386611938, 0.09978540241718292, 0.2706671953201294, -0.14386361837387085, 0.49805185198783875, 0.17617323994636536, 0.8380813598632812, -0.5364677309989929, 0.3988053500652313, 0.7902711033821106, 0.050168924033641815, -0.02643776684999466, 0.050319068133831024, 0.5195891857147217, 0.12130805850028992, 0.4588896632194519, 0.20719192922115326, -0.5423974394798279, 0.25355494022369385, -0.8335232138633728, 0.6154952049255371, -0.4379187524318695, 0.6598885655403137, 0.026156827807426453, -0.8732433319091797, 0.23622311651706696, -0.4477647542953491, 0.17040161788463593, 0.09581668674945831, 0.2916054129600525, 0.7164287567138672, 0.32218340039253235, 0.28293004631996155, -0.5663585066795349, -0.7668696045875549, 0.49963459372520447, 0.12928429245948792, 0.05462387576699257, 0.02856176719069481, 0.23424431681632996, -0.35723772644996643, -0.2900266647338867, 0.43481773138046265, -0.9225225448608398, -0.10813551396131516, -0.5016429424285889, 0.2768270969390869, -0.4124775826931, 0.7609127759933472, 0.009245266206562519, 0.05275987461209297, 0.2208804190158844, 0.6591082811355591, -0.27476486563682556, -0.9881898164749146, 0.4559086263179779, -0.7320258021354675, 0.07144953310489655, 1.0361328125, -1.236918568611145, -0.0452578105032444, -0.41579651832580566, 0.32600802183151245, -0.45320186018943787, 0.2564007341861725, -0.7187855839729309, -0.1770375669002533, 0.054877933114767075, 0.5108989477157593, -0.42069271206855774, 0.16247321665287018, -0.23576323688030243, -0.29392528533935547, -0.399984747171402, -0.7980418801307678, 0.4821380376815796, -0.034435003995895386, 0.017029916867613792, 0.5983467698097229, -0.3251058757305145, 0.20975624024868011, -0.7485929131507874, -0.982883632183075, -0.23081591725349426, -0.5443758964538574, -0.049219805747270584, 0.30629658699035645, -0.5323573350906372, 0.3378794491291046, 0.5601417422294617, 0.316727876663208, 0.8801424503326416, -0.8677195906639099, -0.45094892382621765, -0.1707269251346588, -0.029850201681256294, -0.0024532931856811047, 0.4350411295890808, 0.15010057389736176, -0.01868077553808689, 0.16791057586669922, -0.31249484419822693, -0.3818361163139343, -0.5375970602035522, 0.5507413148880005, -0.3648500442504883, 0.27737608551979065, -0.7719496488571167, 0.4571739137172699, -0.4332799017429352, 0.07954660803079605, -0.6838309168815613, 0.009425892494618893, -0.06374047696590424, -0.4650000333786011, 0.7889037728309631, 0.17012616991996765, -0.43969693779945374, 0.3953583836555481, -0.2932080626487732, 0.21806767582893372, 0.5944818258285522, 0.7103127837181091, -0.5317349433898926, 1.0306956768035889, 0.36446139216423035, -0.2144748717546463, -0.4686582386493683, 0.0038790451362729073, -0.13932664692401886, 0.30404379963874817, 0.11433165520429611, 0.3999411165714264, -0.5806491374969482, 0.35139942169189453, -0.04519540071487427, 0.07762879133224487, 0.08937669545412064, 0.23446831107139587, -0.3880844712257385, -0.11492712050676346, 0.2349482774734497, 0.6767470240592957, 0.30135518312454224, -0.05089401826262474, -0.18259745836257935, 0.11918199807405472, 0.3338701128959656, 0.3331116735935211, -0.029696784913539886, 0.09030058234930038, 0.7203655242919922, 0.13763517141342163, -0.5934337973594666, 0.19792050123214722, -0.37805894017219543, -0.5469037890434265, 0.009183055721223354, -0.11746524274349213, -0.5444156527519226, 0.5287843346595764, -0.20673952996730804, 0.24440158903598785, -0.3699532449245453, 0.3798629641532898, -0.16786308586597443, -0.31599366664886475, 0.03657642379403114, 0.43600210547447205, -0.9469171762466431, -0.23865915834903717, 0.12492954730987549, 0.5980163216590881, -0.47702330350875854, -0.5941516757011414, -0.2276366949081421, 0.3837459683418274, 0.01651323400437832, -0.3944680094718933, -0.0633298009634018, 0.726707935333252, -0.7757532000541687, 0.547673225402832, 0.6154028177261353, 0.010356994345784187, -0.9575185775756836, 0.01954871602356434, -0.6070621013641357, 0.2281382530927658, -0.4268679618835449, 0.3041619658470154, 0.4306963086128235, -1.0930447578430176, 0.04875045269727707, -0.5022497177124023, -0.13304530084133148, 0.4073590636253357, 0.10757041722536087, 0.23657873272895813, -0.3449918031692505, 0.42074185609817505, -0.606180727481842, 0.5464060306549072, -0.7256650924682617, 0.2920196056365967, -0.01902967318892479, -0.1507335752248764, -0.0002628526126500219, -0.9457736611366272, 0.5495705008506775, 0.4426460862159729, -0.12472612410783768, 0.043240197002887726, 0.6169062852859497, -0.3922874629497528, 0.6348251700401306, 0.6879562735557556, -0.5005767941474915, -0.9511272311210632, -1.5863887071609497, 0.10152628272771835, -0.19510219991207123, -0.18138869106769562, 0.7726288437843323, -0.3774452209472656, -0.9593682885169983, 0.710898756980896, -0.6024285554885864, 0.6919716596603394, -0.17451739311218262, 0.29133665561676025, 0.43060368299484253, 0.1427931785583496, -0.34129253029823303, 0.01937250606715679, -0.36335548758506775, -0.05408177524805069, 0.29781851172447205, -0.5470886826515198, -0.29840922355651855, 0.5542199015617371, 0.2148321568965912, -0.05558228865265846, 0.41174575686454773, -0.14668208360671997, -0.6346731185913086, 0.5366663336753845, -0.37994492053985596, 0.8204372525215149, -0.32022717595100403, -0.24644027650356293, -0.8702591061592102, 0.4202254116535187, -0.38371098041534424, 0.4920124411582947, 0.412669837474823, -0.3424074649810791, 0.35900047421455383, 0.5555759072303772, 0.05439237877726555, -0.3067493140697479, 1.0596963167190552, 0.13539764285087585, -0.08556104451417923, -0.09491191059350967, -0.04239540547132492, 0.3452729880809784, 0.09025657922029495, -0.06400438398122787, 0.1270150989294052, 0.6195098757743835, 0.2196100354194641, -0.3915784955024719, -0.40985241532325745, -0.7872124910354614, -0.2588126063346863, 0.49823442101478577, 0.07187306880950928, -0.42704540491104126, -0.5668712258338928, -0.34963375329971313, 0.28616705536842346, -0.5622562766075134, 0.13634370267391205, -0.8969608545303345, 0.10255651921033859, 0.2212591916322708, -0.698661744594574, 0.03713411092758179, 0.514602780342102, 0.8689578175544739, 0.8851609826087952, 0.9377373456954956, 0.3732704818248749, -0.06745384633541107, 0.3096785843372345, -0.15913501381874084, 0.7855114936828613, 0.27766740322113037, -0.17843738198280334, 0.8399125337600708, 0.12330373376607895, 0.7166830897331238, -0.4557490050792694, -0.9708426594734192, -0.01695149764418602, -0.387424498796463, 0.447072297334671, -0.8187668919563293, -0.6821147203445435, -0.6148300766944885, 1.1337058544158936, 0.09125473350286484, -0.3598828911781311, 0.0779617503285408, 0.08528055995702744, -0.6542816758155823, 0.231076180934906, -0.006508266553282738, 0.5773460865020752, 0.20803265273571014, -1.0653185844421387, 0.16699081659317017, 0.18689653277397156, 0.4139516353607178, -0.044214874505996704, -0.3445394039154053, -0.06563593447208405, -0.20758379995822906, 0.29107362031936646, 0.688635528087616, -0.018305804580450058, 0.48866868019104004, 0.09215520322322845, 0.8933872580528259, -0.5383003950119019, 0.3559744358062744, 0.47405460476875305, 0.7012452483177185, 0.47677019238471985, -1.0675811767578125, 0.3156985640525818, -0.44543665647506714, 0.3622351586818695, 0.8955523371696472, -0.9128280878067017, -0.7679300904273987, -0.8730175495147705, 0.14858949184417725, -0.4644020199775696, 0.3605123460292816, 1.1030062437057495, -0.22878961265087128, -0.00029667181661352515, -0.267509788274765, -0.04247528314590454, 0.6547340154647827, -0.7801680564880371, -0.4628742039203644, 0.39746445417404175, 0.3194343149662018, 0.1296069622039795, 0.31987714767456055, 0.083595871925354, -0.907934844493866, 0.29705432057380676, -0.4089711606502533, 0.739605188369751, -0.5309173464775085, -0.8008596897125244, 0.33366140723228455, -0.07929924875497818, -0.7671931385993958, 0.32370108366012573, -0.35280555486679077, -0.553834080696106, 0.40457648038864136, 0.11332631856203079, -0.6374949216842651, -0.46246305108070374, -0.469727098941803, -0.2171459048986435, 0.860875129699707, 0.018918756395578384, 0.4759107232093811, 0.20602519810199738, 0.3987577259540558, -0.19125433266162872, -0.4963702857494354, 0.49240508675575256, 0.012979374267160892, 0.17920158803462982, -0.726504921913147, 0.5938597321510315, -0.3634755611419678, 0.28040459752082825, -0.18503853678703308, -0.44543856382369995, 0.0876842737197876, 0.19775599241256714, -1.0797137022018433, -0.5028959512710571, 0.25244519114494324, -0.6225862503051758, 0.10470622777938843, 0.1061052531003952, -0.18645323812961578, 0.23997701704502106, -0.11099514365196228, 0.2094283103942871, -0.4253320097923279, -0.39961904287338257, -0.9338181614875793, 0.42761796712875366, 0.559497058391571, 0.4050908088684082, 0.08315109461545944, -1.0795363187789917, 0.5061900615692139, 0.22147807478904724, -0.16801363229751587, -0.8621311783790588, -1.2311705350875854, -0.07970679551362991, -0.09492084383964539, 0.24756743013858795, 0.27009639143943787, 0.3174169361591339, -0.23121227324008942, 0.1545467972755432, 0.15489421784877777, 0.5263058543205261, -0.9312569499015808, -0.6136029362678528, 0.763575553894043, 0.2153063267469406, -0.39014241099357605, 0.2943747043609619, 0.5477004647254944, -0.3446752727031708, 0.08872082829475403, -0.09260471910238266, -0.7225277423858643, -0.2112174928188324, -1.245614767074585, -0.013383084908127785, -0.9480090737342834, 0.1132705956697464, 0.2740006148815155, -0.970065176486969, -0.03680158033967018, 0.026622354984283447, 0.36611151695251465, -0.6592656373977661, -0.47503381967544556, -0.3675086498260498, 0.6780909299850464, -0.09777836501598358, -0.3384335935115814, -0.29672759771347046, 0.5142509937286377, -0.4542355537414551, 1.4052151441574097, -0.6789982318878174, -0.5184376835823059, 0.26118162274360657, -0.38256216049194336, -0.5550504326820374, 0.6451841592788696, -0.2521078288555145, -0.10592272877693176, 0.4254318177700043, 0.295536071062088, -0.4338407516479492, 0.7138247489929199, -0.38477662205696106, 0.44259050488471985, -0.42327675223350525, 0.16601867973804474, -0.19908958673477173, 0.23291327059268951, -0.14354881644248962, 0.33097708225250244, 0.5975213050842285, -0.514445960521698, 0.634708821773529, 0.7500919699668884, 0.3854111135005951, 0.3824741840362549, 0.684115469455719, -0.20517967641353607, -0.1420472264289856, -1.330578327178955, -0.5298866629600525, 0.9416638016700745, 0.11073587089776993, -0.15252946317195892, 0.15978682041168213, 0.1199507787823677, -0.23851671814918518, -1.0148470401763916, 0.07347650825977325, 0.14956629276275635, 0.08137878775596619, 0.3931015133857727, -0.31825411319732666, 0.2337673306465149, 0.0018862650031223893, 0.10886300355195999, 0.11807562410831451, -0.20097029209136963, 0.06896545737981796, -0.06813779473304749, -0.08726665377616882, -0.8802024722099304, -0.5542342066764832, 0.8418099284172058, 0.3321952223777771, -0.3220815062522888, 1.5523276329040527, -0.31416839361190796, -0.4940965473651886, 0.06223452091217041, 0.1440710425376892, 0.8385816812515259, 0.3852338492870331, 0.41947442293167114, 0.34822389483451843, 0.12938933074474335, 0.45230793952941895, 0.0037390857469290495, -0.13352783024311066, -0.4365990459918976, 0.807652473449707, -0.14887793362140656, -0.16281265020370483, 0.5524457097053528, 0.3759184181690216, -1.1064279079437256, -0.2145841419696808, -0.8167599439620972, -0.025424616411328316, -0.2884094715118408, -0.3041413128376007, -0.5325219035148621, 0.23623530566692352, -0.028869684785604477, -0.035162460058927536, 0.35836103558540344, 0.9064739942550659, 0.03782666102051735, 0.06919381022453308, -0.31720370054244995, -0.8339105248451233, 0.013743573799729347, 1.5245877504348755, 0.26817038655281067, -0.97828209400177, 0.35143953561782837, -0.025561731308698654, -0.5396528840065002, 0.25006774067878723, 1.1198738813400269, -0.14312836527824402, 0.24366368353366852, 0.2722606956958771, 0.03146969527006149, 0.6731023192405701, 0.3711303174495697, -0.225027933716774, 0.26777738332748413, -0.7216716408729553, -0.7536678910255432, -0.6807241439819336, -0.17220018804073334, 0.08362031728029251, 0.08828924596309662, 0.6951957941055298, -0.2686120271682739, -0.30764347314834595, -0.7258496880531311, -0.12648163735866547, -0.3374146521091461, -0.13988682627677917, -0.34586301445961, -0.42745915055274963, -0.10110685974359512, -0.31292465329170227, -0.45362719893455505, -0.01447529997676611, -0.07059642672538757, 0.04055062681436539, -0.08799253404140472, 0.25557366013526917, 0.39218658208847046, 0.755110502243042, -0.29858294129371643, -0.4553685486316681, -0.5880222916603088, -0.3344918191432953, -0.5475484132766724, -1.0459703207015991, 0.2491491436958313, 0.007297967094928026, -0.09883998334407806, 0.8233445882797241, -0.10049434751272202, 1.1533794403076172, -0.7272111773490906, -0.43328145146369934, 0.2314097285270691, -0.18771256506443024, -0.32129836082458496, 0.7400922179222107, -0.34198522567749023, 0.5299269556999207, 0.5106471180915833, 0.37330707907676697, 0.0033442098647356033, -0.13266870379447937, -0.6933990120887756, -0.017606712877750397, -0.07042984664440155, 0.8807238340377808, -0.21014350652694702, -0.19817118346691132, -0.27061426639556885, 0.5384870767593384, -0.9292471408843994, -0.5223227739334106, -0.8752277493476868, 0.3966568112373352, 0.1723240613937378, 0.47455811500549316, -0.1114867553114891, 1.1019747257232666, 0.35566797852516174, 0.19598738849163055, -0.4844483435153961, 0.39503079652786255, 0.14343127608299255, 0.5596894025802612, -0.05986040085554123, -0.17793844640254974, 0.03496314957737923, -0.39526596665382385, -0.029231589287519455, 1.0631413459777832, 0.30426740646362305, 0.1407763659954071, -0.40356239676475525, -0.18726232647895813, -0.13883274793624878, -0.058740079402923584, -0.8925969004631042, 0.6320682764053345, 0.3459590971469879, -0.5429779291152954, -0.1553647220134735, -0.23093152046203613, -0.6717746257781982, 0.44779062271118164, -0.3893772065639496, -0.36689653992652893, 0.13715404272079468, -0.5971885919570923, -0.01639641262590885, 0.0934503898024559, -0.0647476390004158, -0.014829902909696102, 0.09345149993896484, 0.5736986994743347, 0.28003090620040894, -0.49403831362724304, -0.4253310561180115, 0.8665284514427185, -1.068375587463379, -0.3165387809276581, -0.789702832698822, 0.4017055928707123, -1.0792118310928345, -1.2858397960662842, -0.03201093524694443, 0.5468255281448364, -0.6065364480018616, -0.2532925009727478, -0.8291741013526917, -0.1608351469039917, -0.15581807494163513, 0.006374603137373924, -0.7046382427215576, -0.4152733087539673, 0.04412703588604927, 0.10421879589557648, -0.048306968063116074, -0.17583973705768585, -0.03005341626703739, -0.05711803212761879, 1.3093957901000977, -0.39382973313331604, -0.2872239649295807, 1.0680040121078491, 0.4996878504753113, -0.16264177858829498, 0.6812170147895813, 0.8279083967208862, 0.9953867197036743, 0.670721173286438, -0.44352561235427856, 0.1295635998249054, 0.599157989025116, 0.08530829101800919, 0.4678070545196533, 0.23715463280677795, -0.20714642107486725, -0.15879206359386444, -0.43989846110343933, -0.1553170531988144, -0.24060218036174774, 0.5628467798233032, 0.11885374039411545, 0.11920515447854996, 0.06160000339150429, -0.4312508702278137, 0.15588627755641937, -0.07461631298065186, 0.3900216221809387, 0.5144677758216858, 0.2630062401294708, -0.6812459230422974, -0.8032910227775574, 0.30819371342658997, -0.9012303948402405, -0.45413586497306824, -0.40001222491264343, -0.24505078792572021, 1.0059479475021362, 0.4067288935184479, 0.18000197410583496, 0.9284148216247559, 0.6039276719093323, 0.08927229046821594, -0.4324879050254822, 0.7189064025878906, 0.10584288835525513, 0.8547186255455017, 0.33773553371429443, 0.5585669279098511, 0.19517314434051514, 0.9098494648933411, 0.05449310690164566, -1.1877479553222656, 0.7550157308578491, 0.7859404683113098, -0.793325662612915, -0.6790898442268372, -0.7274504899978638, 0.07129853218793869, 0.1586245745420456, -0.24152809381484985, 0.043616119772195816, -0.3414151668548584, 0.30368977785110474, 1.0561003684997559, -0.08145907521247864, 0.4364511966705322, -0.06204475089907646, 0.16554056107997894, 0.6907402873039246, 0.05488799139857292, 0.5207778811454773, -0.7679120302200317, 0.5598008036613464, 0.9333266615867615, 0.012504947371780872, 0.09342057257890701, -0.2689985930919647, 0.2192527800798416, 0.06283877789974213, 0.8235001564025879, -0.3607858121395111, 1.0154950618743896, 0.830371618270874, 0.06768140941858292, -0.3387831449508667, -0.2916022837162018, -0.09010711312294006, 0.04532281681895256, 0.49578648805618286, -0.101340651512146, 0.04348431155085564, -0.26439571380615234, 0.6636468768119812, 0.7346847057342529, -0.6797686219215393, -0.2621743679046631, 0.2765863537788391, -0.4617323875427246, -0.3501819670200348, 0.05754981189966202, 0.4782930016517639, -0.7348459959030151, 0.12507691979408264, 0.0315076969563961, -0.4775196611881256, -0.5009441375732422, -0.85052090883255, -0.258055180311203, -0.5858744978904724, 0.5404762625694275, 0.6727738976478577, -0.14455439150333405, 0.7877756953239441, -0.5524734258651733, -0.31270116567611694, 0.021221987903118134, 0.6004343628883362, -0.18116210401058197, 0.04507319629192352, 0.822483241558075, 0.7557908296585083, -0.17427214980125427, 0.36793479323387146, 0.8592919707298279, -0.47164079546928406, 0.7934702634811401, -0.6157662272453308, 0.425863116979599, -0.13075073063373566, 0.026641016826033592, 0.6392589211463928, 0.8162647485733032, 0.45838508009910583, 0.1381681114435196, -0.4610360562801361, 0.2534642219543457, -0.9695167541503906, -0.43554529547691345, 0.06531932950019836, 0.6765682697296143, -0.09418963640928268, 0.2702161967754364, 0.09559846669435501, -0.8893721699714661, 4.202963352203369, 0.5854827761650085, 0.5007851123809814, -0.1759030520915985, 0.6529639363288879, 0.953288197517395, -0.08922459185123444, -0.7175437211990356, 0.461794376373291, -0.15344856679439545, -0.045297130942344666, 0.008680743165314198, 0.06948339939117432, 0.18336553871631622, -0.13163478672504425, 0.6952933073043823, -0.18270190060138702, -0.47776737809181213, -0.14345785975456238, -0.6162055134773254, -0.774715006351471, 0.08308828622102737, -0.09645736962556839, -0.3092504143714905, 0.23368197679519653, 0.5663326978683472, 0.6841124892234802, -0.5884957313537598, -0.32928189635276794, -0.3241561949253082, -0.7905811667442322, -0.39127764105796814, 0.5296151638031006, -0.06571877002716064, -0.7018202543258667, 0.3188665509223938, -0.12612304091453552, -0.4174867570400238, -0.2639750838279724, -0.5359435081481934, -0.5588613152503967, -0.22500315308570862, 0.209896057844162, -1.126648187637329, -0.14595367014408112, 1.0284483432769775, 0.46456411480903625, 0.5770812630653381, 0.5288804173469543, -1.2066075801849365, 0.4611879885196686, -0.052644502371549606, 0.12155750393867493, -0.47187310457229614, -1.3447751998901367, 0.14881178736686707, 0.3646172881126404, 0.014956987462937832, -0.10677224397659302, 0.17778773605823517, 0.39488351345062256, -0.5404796004295349, 0.09498154371976852, 0.5586085915565491, -0.1801631599664688, 0.4139193296432495, 0.050601135939359665, 0.4585501253604889, -0.8047831654548645, 0.04475779086351395, -0.3598850667476654, -0.5177654027938843, -0.3093659281730652, -0.2736797630786896, 0.719542920589447, 0.19098824262619019, 0.2268241047859192, 0.15740802884101868, -0.4086579978466034, -0.5405170917510986, 0.16066977381706238, -0.11577021330595016, -0.26051807403564453, 0.07527712732553482, -0.16969625651836395, 0.6267623901367188, 0.11092425882816315, 0.37393030524253845, 0.11407867819070816, 0.7860131859779358, -0.11431308835744858, 0.6129663586616516, -0.08749432861804962, 0.023723803460597992, -0.36715763807296753 ]
Effect of Neutrino Heating on Primordial Nucleosynthesis
We have modified the standard code for primordial nucleosynthesis to include the effect of the slight heating of neutrinos by $e^\pm$ annihilations. There is a small, systematic change in the $^4$He yield, $\Delta Y \simeq +1.5\times 10^{-4}$, which is insensitive to the value of the baryon-to-photon ratio $\eta$ for $10^{-10}\la \eta \la 10^{-9}$. We also find that the baryon-to-photon ratio decreases by about 0.5\% less than the canonical factor of 4/11 because some of the entropy in $e^\pm$ pairs is transferred to neutrinos. These results are in accord with recent analytical estimates.
B. Fields, S. Dodelson, M.S. Turner (U. Chicago/Fermilab)
astro-ph hep-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9210007
astro-ph/9211001
[ 0.4189550578594208, 0.10974086076021194, 0.7101746201515198, 0.09610947221517563, -0.4931928813457489, -0.5015258193016052, -0.2353629469871521, -0.1970946490764618, -0.7012860178947449, 0.7747859358787537, -0.3661048412322998, -0.004479013383388519, 0.3899892270565033, -0.7310455441474915, -0.37907880544662476, 0.06146213039755821, -0.21639297902584076, -0.7590179443359375, -1.6691161394119263, 0.636237382888794, 0.23818668723106384, -0.5355306267738342, -0.7446022629737854, -0.13881587982177734, -0.35944849252700806, -0.008247638121247292, 0.4041224718093872, 0.8145498037338257, 0.8753342032432556, 0.1701498031616211, 0.05039752274751663, -0.7369809150695801, 0.4189969599246979, -0.772769033908844, 0.09373120218515396, -0.20639976859092712, 0.3062184751033783, -0.8892556428909302, -0.1509431004524231, -0.46337151527404785, 0.8983180522918701, -0.2957541048526764, 0.5634377598762512, -0.10980741679668427, -0.43639031052589417, 0.002036217600107193, 0.09958748519420624, -0.15877968072891235, 0.47049349546432495, -0.8291641473770142, -0.03373798727989197, 0.05973338708281517, 0.25570935010910034, -0.18260473012924194, 0.18483436107635498, -0.07014001905918121, 0.21635818481445312, 0.31699463725090027, -0.6864831447601318, -0.5587407350540161, 0.5576346516609192, 0.21605826914310455, 0.084525927901268, -0.1308499425649643, -0.8293700218200684, 1.633014440536499, 0.07489490509033203, 0.6644825339317322, -0.19733449816703796, 0.0045629143714904785, 0.18997277319431305, 0.3280656039714813, -0.07334227114915848, 0.6360130310058594, -0.11082799732685089, 0.21676704287528992, 0.19213752448558807, 0.15457327663898468, -0.2317938208580017, 0.16113020479679108, 0.1199837252497673, 0.3275589644908905, 0.1283383071422577, 0.7962521314620972, -0.21215936541557312, -0.8680688142776489, 0.3935851454734802, 0.07849705219268799, 0.4563075304031372, -0.36348628997802734, 0.21911989152431488, 0.3252490162849426, 0.04700399190187454, 0.25798892974853516, 1.0393445491790771, -0.06124590337276459, -0.4913617670536041, 0.25673383474349976, 0.7074648141860962, 0.7261596918106079, -0.10518933832645416, 0.988361120223999, -0.5837798714637756, -0.08423351496458054, -0.7655660510063171, 0.18836577236652374, 0.6256428956985474, -0.1374858319759369, 0.3266160488128662, -1.252267837524414, -0.2522977292537689, 0.011826470494270325, -0.011271646246314049, -0.3445967137813568, 0.48680904507637024, 0.448255717754364, -0.17088240385055542, -0.06939458847045898, -0.1742958277463913, -0.21961094439029694, -0.33192190527915955, 0.4650435149669647, 0.32224828004837036, -0.06867468357086182, 0.19498035311698914, -0.15544337034225464, 0.2325199842453003, -0.0805952399969101, -0.731149435043335, -0.463510662317276, 0.47118526697158813, -0.7257837057113647, -0.5893068909645081, 1.0971739292144775, 0.8890058994293213, 0.07697266340255737, 0.4719367027282715, 1.327369213104248, 0.3137877881526947, -1.0395236015319824, -0.30593690276145935, -0.6842569708824158, -0.017332766205072403, 1.3373361825942993, -0.6471644043922424, -0.05497445911169052, 0.25653091073036194, -0.41659310460090637, -1.1713587045669556, 0.34138762950897217, -0.3639998733997345, -0.8027010560035706, -0.42128118872642517, 0.6455750465393066, -0.8004719614982605, 0.21003229916095734, -0.6802185773849487, -0.07514329999685287, -0.2555684745311737, -0.3587314784526825, 0.30586639046669006, -0.46912235021591187, 0.48767468333244324, 0.8380036354064941, -0.5683627724647522, 0.6320146322250366, -0.9379510283470154, -0.5668986439704895, -0.1846262365579605, -0.10454286634922028, -0.20344392955303192, 0.7191133499145508, 0.04279540851712227, 0.6897732019424438, 0.5239550471305847, 0.4670117199420929, 0.13948899507522583, -0.65582275390625, -0.7498583197593689, 0.4058675169944763, 0.2300032526254654, 0.3210547864437103, 0.2953581213951111, 0.292940229177475, -0.17814107239246368, 0.39415448904037476, -0.0019313086522743106, 0.06458993256092072, 0.5063962936401367, 0.5043767094612122, 0.5001283288002014, 0.7585064768791199, -1.191200852394104, 0.4161737561225891, -0.7515074610710144, -0.3185760974884033, 0.02916986495256424, -0.4657238721847534, -0.2835055887699127, -0.7175900340080261, 1.2596931457519531, 0.02512190118432045, -0.2111213356256485, 0.30176132917404175, -0.2642807066440582, -0.6607076525688171, 1.1074737310409546, 0.39515507221221924, -0.22039084136486053, 0.012069488875567913, 0.2691954970359802, -0.18990474939346313, 0.007962578907608986, -0.0036937082186341286, 0.5802565217018127, -0.2571510672569275, -0.46485763788223267, 0.48727574944496155, -0.17078740894794464, -0.26312723755836487, 0.46424564719200134, 0.5943178534507751, -0.44747063517570496, 1.0073143243789673, -0.1789681762456894, -0.4785221219062805, -0.06575841456651688, 0.22279486060142517, -0.09802724421024323, -0.17700083553791046, -0.4006642997264862, 0.16057999432086945, -0.00812531542032957, 0.08773993700742722, 0.7981429100036621, -0.5076979994773865, 0.5325909852981567, 0.8600757718086243, 0.34838658571243286, -0.2428813874721527, 0.2065812051296234, -0.294293612241745, -0.045621126890182495, 0.179748997092247, -0.03004961833357811, 0.9058089256286621, -0.2615540623664856, -0.46794891357421875, -0.6573396325111389, 0.005754650104790926, -0.453675240278244, 0.7811300158500671, 0.29680079221725464, -0.03690783679485321, -0.7975183129310608, -0.44862252473831177, -0.13705231249332428, 0.20184284448623657, -0.4005756974220276, -0.3063969314098358, 0.009752932004630566, 0.2451237440109253, -0.22220243513584137, 0.0010420214384794235, 0.07207949459552765, 0.5145564675331116, -0.4888395369052887, 0.6438059210777283, 0.6242142915725708, -0.17972466349601746, -1.0752196311950684, -0.28707775473594666, -0.773065447807312, 0.057440225034952164, 0.07905730605125427, 0.1480415314435959, 0.7545626759529114, -0.3885381519794464, 0.2633126676082611, -0.28412550687789917, -0.15198981761932373, 1.1860963106155396, -0.9220454096794128, 0.0010863583302125335, -0.8761560916900635, 0.09564542025327682, -0.777965247631073, 0.6639823913574219, -0.1796937733888626, 0.37117311358451843, 0.015126815065741539, 0.09698700904846191, -0.44900310039520264, 0.026020102202892303, 0.6452561616897583, -0.06353448331356049, 0.08732166141271591, 0.26464301347732544, 0.39936429262161255, -0.5626782178878784, 0.48351365327835083, -0.32460445165634155, 0.056055545806884766, -0.5353958606719971, -0.7048075795173645, 0.37720969319343567, -0.2105095386505127, -0.29222622513771057, 0.1748266965150833, -0.4946231245994568, -0.6584855318069458, 0.3793122172355652, -0.10312709212303162, 0.2675674855709076, -0.05214779078960419, 0.5565351843833923, 0.12248046696186066, 0.16259373724460602, 0.4076004922389984, -0.08288892358541489, -0.4529513716697693, -0.2562806308269501, 0.3526494801044464, -0.16423244774341583, 0.10617087781429291, 1.2320388555526733, 0.09593489021062851, -0.5791911482810974, 0.4011130928993225, -0.3017497956752777, -0.41897618770599365, 0.3658360540866852, 0.21389684081077576, 0.47005587816238403, 0.4141824245452881, -0.2921263873577118, -0.3684786260128021, 0.16318008303642273, 0.17065966129302979, 0.5349591374397278, 0.5671887993812561, -0.3245798349380493, 0.10852992534637451, 0.8153910040855408, -0.5643792748451233, -0.5924516320228577, 0.7600220441818237, -0.4405710995197296, -0.27595141530036926, -0.3928220272064209, -0.4243406355381012, 0.46706974506378174, 0.45032641291618347, 0.21094252169132233, -0.21527741849422455, 0.4675617218017578, -0.021461796015501022, 0.4279792904853821, -0.863336443901062, -0.5022993087768555, -0.27531346678733826, 0.6755387783050537, 0.25283047556877136, -0.03314875066280365, -0.6226857900619507, -0.08045169711112976, 0.0770200788974762, -0.35040003061294556, 0.47820061445236206, -0.9030577540397644, 0.5811101198196411, 0.2618590295314789, -0.4865742325782776, -0.2541091740131378, 0.0777469351887703, -0.3257601261138916, 0.5847939848899841, 0.19065669178962708, 0.9094002842903137, 0.0789073035120964, 0.31863388419151306, 0.044453784823417664, -0.12924310564994812, -0.15012450516223907, 0.3260510265827179, 0.48166611790657043, 0.04904889687895775, -0.06919414550065994, -0.08401363343000412, -1.049371600151062, -0.18277987837791443, -1.117724061012268, 0.31968098878860474, -0.9808461666107178, -0.7582871913909912, 0.3211557865142822, 0.5868056416511536, 0.41079580783843994, 0.019722795113921165, -0.2801770865917206, -0.0304398275911808, -1.0608012676239014, 0.43764081597328186, 0.23683570325374603, -0.06290120631456375, 0.3833077549934387, -0.970719039440155, -0.2989461123943329, 0.0501183345913887, -0.10110095888376236, 0.35472387075424194, -0.3729352056980133, 0.13528968393802643, 0.16449382901191711, -0.019555412232875824, 0.07812772691249847, -0.3005833327770233, 0.7177088856697083, 0.2728574573993683, -0.2521379590034485, -0.5250371098518372, 0.21982945501804352, 0.7444494962692261, 0.9152700901031494, -0.5786669850349426, -1.623239278793335, -0.668860673904419, -0.6286399364471436, -0.13107024133205414, 0.5425164699554443, -0.4670606851577759, -0.7503687739372253, -0.22301775217056274, 0.15873359143733978, 0.24855034053325653, 0.2557665705680847, 0.6806222200393677, 0.01960354670882225, 0.5626115202903748, -1.0954641103744507, 0.09232404083013535, 0.8310228586196899, 0.21777842938899994, 0.4788670539855957, 0.17538031935691833, 0.7252851724624634, -0.0107548413798213, 0.3951016068458557, -0.5320179462432861, -0.778411328792572, -1.0653706789016724, -0.5508129596710205, 1.1767218112945557, -0.15336190164089203, -0.9515024423599243, 1.1318483352661133, 0.015950385481119156, -0.13263605535030365, 0.7257362008094788, -0.1930144876241684, -0.3141827881336212, 0.037754278630018234, 0.6069367527961731, -0.4618898928165436, -0.028941571712493896, 0.025615209713578224, -0.6934575438499451, -0.01729864440858364, 0.7960956692695618, 0.31165528297424316, -0.12542784214019775, 0.5682882070541382, -0.41419652104377747, 0.04691892862319946, 0.17870889604091644, -0.7782148718833923, 0.07405994832515717, 0.07546551525592804, 0.25385135412216187, -0.334290474653244, 0.07060427218675613, 0.29062965512275696, -0.5077154040336609, 0.3130517899990082, -0.1510964184999466, 0.17854711413383484, -0.042265940457582474, -0.23934327065944672, 0.3105025887489319, 0.3690584897994995, -0.08206105977296829, -0.36296510696411133, -0.44825807213783264, -0.6440443992614746, -0.1593645215034485, 0.11271187663078308, 0.3825890123844147, -0.18155808746814728, 0.6730645895004272, 0.5164472460746765, -0.6073095798492432, 0.2185177206993103, -0.6577881574630737, 0.13482804596424103, -0.4923573136329651, -0.4265519678592682, -0.5412072539329529, -0.23826691508293152, -0.4955231249332428, 0.4569525122642517, 0.3729376196861267, -0.021859461441636086, 0.09815416485071182, -0.07275822013616562, 0.1891360878944397, 0.6284589171409607, 0.015392323955893517, -1.085731863975525, 0.05769156664609909, 0.22559918463230133, -0.11132125556468964, -0.8691388368606567, -0.5632479786872864, 0.3773569166660309, 0.08037327229976654, 0.20993877947330475, 0.13534441590309143, -0.8730008006095886, 0.28102248907089233, -1.1725986003875732, 0.2329826056957245, -0.9196420311927795, 0.5650349855422974, -0.2630695402622223, -0.7746501564979553, -0.1506694108247757, -0.14012350142002106, 0.8959304094314575, -0.8105372786521912, -0.7448475956916809, -0.6173204779624939, 0.91334068775177, -0.3064315617084503, 0.059584468603134155, -0.5320951342582703, 0.28841468691825867, -0.4098038077354431, 0.7734714150428772, -0.4417382478713989, -0.22878161072731018, -0.2599269449710846, 0.38565564155578613, 0.30631399154663086, 0.5743201971054077, 0.09313264489173889, -0.07778847217559814, -0.163185253739357, -0.363925576210022, 0.033262696117162704, 0.609258234500885, -0.5028660893440247, 0.5418074727058411, -0.7156896591186523, -0.21232442557811737, -0.04410792514681816, 0.07528280466794968, -0.48893195390701294, 0.03149988502264023, 0.6249831318855286, -0.17642980813980103, 0.8562782406806946, 1.1475549936294556, -0.041508909314870834, 0.1130867600440979, 0.2777509093284607, -1.099311113357544, -0.5153762102127075, -0.28681817650794983, -0.1348489373922348, 0.7644974589347839, 0.3502037823200226, 0.017576685175299644, -0.3491371273994446, 0.1496293842792511, -0.03961649909615517, -0.9211761355400085, 0.8541016578674316, 0.10756121575832367, 0.3642084300518036, 0.533170223236084, -0.1329798400402069, 0.0806104987859726, 0.20360927283763885, 0.2628856599330902, 0.835820198059082, -0.35187268257141113, -0.6022521257400513, -0.30945172905921936, -0.2512017488479614, -0.13662242889404297, -0.9051563739776611, 0.6324043273925781, 0.5051360130310059, -0.6457914113998413, 1.0206377506256104, -0.18051296472549438, 0.03808187320828438, -0.02710590325295925, 0.48167380690574646, 0.7211928963661194, -0.49050259590148926, 0.5035862326622009, -0.4795372784137726, -0.6286598443984985, 0.5401773452758789, -0.40391650795936584, -0.44328662753105164, -0.32624080777168274, 0.4765858054161072, -0.43420395255088806, 0.10945965349674225, 0.19820941984653473, 0.3304608464241028, -0.6513731479644775, -0.1453230082988739, -1.1512047052383423, 0.10839025676250458, -0.19755922257900238, -0.42878901958465576, -1.0153653621673584, 0.16648516058921814, -0.46172070503234863, 0.5600814819335938, 0.41716882586479187, 0.32039907574653625, 0.32441428303718567, 0.178798109292984, -0.21718424558639526, -0.9992092251777649, 0.9408273696899414, 1.2448369264602661, 0.526619017124176, -0.20344401895999908, 0.09425345063209534, -0.37531495094299316, -0.5837743878364563, -0.46732044219970703, 0.8300418853759766, -0.42700281739234924, 0.1690349578857422, -0.19987618923187256, 0.07872989773750305, 0.3239423632621765, 0.5496401190757751, 0.10853032022714615, 0.7426953911781311, -0.7294982671737671, -0.0489988848567009, -0.40281060338020325, -0.11347884684801102, 0.1919955611228943, 1.050417184829712, 0.596011221408844, -0.08953182399272919, -0.5644034147262573, -0.5771881341934204, 0.20205111801624298, 0.22211286425590515, -0.4783005118370056, -0.19684775173664093, -0.781907320022583, -0.8094980716705322, -0.5489609241485596, 0.2945135235786438, -0.011633113957941532, -0.5991190671920776, 0.5090622305870056, -0.09541187435388565, 0.2065369188785553, -0.33090806007385254, 0.9014397859573364, 0.2820969820022583, -0.038619838654994965, -0.7937116622924805, 0.19855432212352753, -0.1413211077451706, -1.1628612279891968, -0.39402276277542114, -0.525679886341095, 0.09403818845748901, 1.0861395597457886, -0.098515585064888, 0.6335466504096985, -0.3355967402458191, 0.030329788103699684, 0.2266380339860916, -0.08939289301633835, -1.1651365756988525, 0.4846239686012268, -0.5220966339111328, 0.24753378331661224, 0.3238123059272766, -0.9150561094284058, 0.11324962973594666, 0.18073736131191254, -1.0798566341400146, 0.6753129959106445, -0.5672602653503418, 1.231931447982788, 0.18185074627399445, -0.2796705663204193, 0.06326494365930557, 1.2150812149047852, -1.0924710035324097, -0.0920744389295578, -0.5446916818618774, 0.16202124953269958, 0.08616869896650314, 0.03459477424621582, 0.22302314639091492, 0.10941031575202942, -0.3889215588569641, 0.33556029200553894, -0.59646075963974, -0.25343045592308044, -0.11193618178367615, 0.7123117446899414, -0.21931172907352448, -0.6375721096992493, 0.4630613625049591, -0.6012066602706909, 0.18546566367149353, 0.43246951699256897, -0.015387505292892456, -0.5091366767883301, -0.10403652489185333, 0.5001192092895508, -0.10777938365936279, 0.10826636105775833, -0.6525908708572388, 0.6144227385520935, 0.23456968367099762, 0.6090862154960632, 0.3795481026172638, 0.13621267676353455, -1.2252271175384521, 0.2075212001800537, -0.3605114221572876, -0.49406152963638306, 0.09813062846660614, 0.1458936184644699, 0.07685652375221252, 0.2547169029712677, -0.26037296652793884, 0.26919910311698914, -0.24993577599525452, 0.2386704683303833, 0.5059187412261963, 0.2631125748157501, -0.5787449479103088, 0.42262670397758484, -1.0278115272521973, 0.07127866894006729, -1.012913465499878, 0.4422895610332489, -1.1740723848342896, -0.8572220206260681, 0.01775432378053665, 0.3453540503978729, -0.6957939863204956, -0.5904561877250671, -0.12426841259002686, -0.5478141903877258, -0.013300055637955666, -0.42983850836753845, -0.5508150458335876, -0.037082381546497345, -0.5005017518997192, -0.23023851215839386, -0.18452078104019165, -0.01897655799984932, -0.12331073731184006, 0.4508305788040161, 0.8080400824546814, -0.33382540941238403, -0.5233949422836304, 0.6715579628944397, 0.3961021304130554, 0.480197012424469, 0.061321236193180084, 0.7233579754829407, 0.6462454199790955, -0.06718648225069046, -0.8142162561416626, -0.33650514483451843, 0.6952349543571472, 0.04245242103934288, 0.31834709644317627, -0.022811591625213623, 0.4991525411605835, 0.5805093050003052, -0.25185033679008484, -0.1699848771095276, 0.22915737330913544, -0.19310376048088074, -0.6008847951889038, -0.2637818455696106, -0.07577481865882874, 0.4051981270313263, -0.1951678991317749, -0.3689005970954895, 0.8469411730766296, -0.21118228137493134, -0.22495213150978088, -1.196915864944458, -0.2561904489994049, 0.12873665988445282, -0.9079559445381165, -0.8818761110305786, -0.48581206798553467, 0.12052293121814728, -0.30381539463996887, 0.24067798256874084, -0.19816328585147858, -0.5828040242195129, 0.43806731700897217, 0.08319832384586334, -0.09362248331308365, 0.28260132670402527, 0.5452173352241516, 0.8057270050048828, 0.3351917564868927, 0.2711274325847626, 0.09711496531963348, 0.9222899675369263, -0.037992432713508606, -0.7289183139801025, -0.23434820771217346, -0.005869089160114527, -0.485922634601593, 0.8518092632293701, 0.6810615062713623, -0.18851681053638458, -0.36774346232414246, -0.41692832112312317, -0.14858309924602509, -0.6101043820381165, 0.6063367128372192, 0.7534860372543335, -0.30911728739738464, 0.14220699667930603, 0.009946213103830814, 0.13801053166389465, 0.6034558415412903, 0.8987998366355896, 0.15314532816410065, -0.8448708653450012, 0.959700345993042, 0.849637508392334, -0.38389673829078674, 0.5423965454101562, -0.483399361371994, 0.13553233444690704, -0.15761898458003998, 0.03416978940367699, -0.2567991614341736, 0.2048225998878479, -0.3087906837463379, -0.10015764087438583, 0.08347565680742264, -0.05365698039531708, 0.008645882830023766, -0.03563128784298897, 0.27132007479667664, 0.433609277009964, -0.611788809299469, -0.8956577181816101, 0.2754564881324768, 0.060496337711811066, -0.41869059205055237, -0.8884924650192261, 0.2925918996334076, -0.7382099628448486, -0.5517580509185791, -0.27745744585990906, 0.6091011166572571, -0.43589848279953003, -0.22230078279972076, -0.5766999125480652, 0.049097076058387756, 0.03202412277460098, -0.7023085951805115, -0.4853942096233368, 0.25894245505332947, 0.44065120816230774, 0.8653167486190796, 0.4597650468349457, 0.5566070079803467, -0.6963041424751282, -0.25939059257507324, 0.10953035205602646, 0.6235985159873962, 0.2600555419921875, 0.663153886795044, 0.4671351909637451, 0.673014223575592, -0.37638404965400696, 0.2899566888809204, 0.5389358997344971, -0.5181386470794678, 0.28015661239624023, 0.4140760898590088, 0.49968966841697693, -0.089070163667202, -0.17301836609840393, 0.12194973975419998, 0.2770342528820038, 0.20167867839336395, 0.3077089488506317, 0.24884429574012756, 0.28957319259643555, -0.45288941264152527, -0.11534421145915985, -0.06284134835004807, 0.5238580107688904, 0.33895647525787354, -0.09797985106706619, -0.674529492855072, -0.6547464728355408, 4.229963779449463, 0.648144543170929, 0.4831741452217102, -0.7670078873634338, 0.4933456480503082, 0.24226391315460205, 0.19337953627109528, -0.2326827496290207, 0.38258111476898193, 0.01959158107638359, -0.03339783102273941, 0.5248569250106812, 0.7857492566108704, 0.5339301228523254, -0.15429866313934326, 0.4338766038417816, -0.19995644688606262, -0.25264042615890503, 0.48720768094062805, -0.43594807386398315, -0.9051220417022705, 0.08023064583539963, -0.08484108746051788, 0.34848353266716003, 0.41868793964385986, 0.10424055904150009, -0.190740168094635, -0.05033603310585022, -0.527708113193512, -0.3126349151134491, -0.5024658441543579, -0.6398174166679382, 1.3607693910598755, -0.0552414245903492, -0.48311784863471985, 0.598637580871582, -0.1722867637872696, -0.6304426193237305, 0.123836450278759, -0.3589949607849121, -0.4439610242843628, -0.512168288230896, -0.06232971325516701, -0.42569801211357117, 0.5187220573425293, 1.3899327516555786, 0.8302876949310303, 0.6277394890785217, 0.834102988243103, -0.7322478890419006, 0.19305109977722168, 0.15818747878074646, -0.6216229200363159, -0.29139435291290283, -0.8385218977928162, -0.33094531297683716, -0.03733295574784279, -0.7565460801124573, -0.2591150403022766, -0.057432785630226135, 0.9600498080253601, -1.0218397378921509, -0.5953506827354431, 0.580329179763794, -0.2287600189447403, 0.5797204971313477, 0.3097241520881653, 0.06691022962331772, -0.5687431693077087, 0.2142593413591385, -0.08525580912828445, -0.25376492738723755, -0.7738310694694519, -0.363584041595459, 0.2720654010772705, -0.16492019593715668, 0.5195761322975159, -0.3565921187400818, 0.22589640319347382, 0.3880596160888672, -0.1553872525691986, 0.12340568006038666, -0.12817400693893433, 1.1036479473114014, -0.23477813601493835, 0.8189902901649475, -0.25421348214149475, -0.36429423093795776, 0.04545057564973831, 0.5676472783088684, -0.08431384712457657, 0.6518397331237793, -0.3813384771347046, 0.46219784021377563, -0.5254438519477844 ]
A Burst of Speculation
Self-consistent models of gamma-ray burst source regions at 100 Kpc distance are possible if the radiating plasma is confined to very thin sheets, and I estimate parameters. Energy sources might be elastic (by starquakes) or magnetic (by reconnection), but mechanisms remain obscure. I discuss a very speculative model involving collisions between comets in a hypothetical inner Oort cloud.
J. I. Katz
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211001
astro-ph/9211002
[ 0.15953007340431213, 0.16706790030002594, 0.38817644119262695, -0.3254173696041107, -0.5659202933311462, -0.13883076608181, -1.0823537111282349, 0.027414094656705856, 0.01506842765957117, 1.3508503437042236, 0.32101187109947205, -0.5525670051574707, 0.03236857429146767, -0.2591724395751953, -0.5082413554191589, 0.32909971475601196, 0.34332945942878723, 0.08229570835828781, -0.600090503692627, -0.6633985042572021, -0.3108426034450531, 0.1543961465358734, -1.1545506715774536, 0.057726792991161346, -0.8114173412322998, 0.7271826863288879, 0.4181118607521057, 0.5260325074195862, 0.9928798079490662, 0.6436459422111511, 0.1951303482055664, -0.8308103084564209, 0.03252193704247475, -1.0266966819763184, 0.07600962370634079, -0.1871759295463562, 0.49862876534461975, -0.5438464283943176, 0.4316389858722687, -0.47080540657043457, 0.2100207507610321, 0.06474215537309647, 0.8468887209892273, -0.5912003517150879, -0.18275900185108185, 0.39761555194854736, 0.27495676279067993, -0.42395108938217163, 0.7823201417922974, 0.032367609441280365, -0.020200083032250404, -0.21166464686393738, -0.03158843144774437, -0.5792598128318787, 0.0074120182543993, -0.024894921109080315, 0.18884970247745514, 0.5231210589408875, -0.1475653350353241, 0.29646432399749756, 0.3977959454059601, 0.6310315728187561, 0.5268183946609497, -0.8506869077682495, 0.019986744970083237, 1.0057846307754517, -0.017201077193021774, -0.9267270565032959, 0.00956475269049406, -0.08067519962787628, 0.10644937306642532, -0.14890068769454956, -0.5229027271270752, 0.0831594243645668, 0.08940669894218445, -0.10653336346149445, -0.04001028090715408, 0.0035866694524884224, -0.27479907870292664, 0.339492529630661, 0.3041152358055115, 0.14249736070632935, -0.2008289396762848, -0.041704144328832626, 0.18346326053142548, -0.12710542976856232, 0.27291712164878845, 0.09316423535346985, -0.2528556287288666, 0.06714195013046265, -0.3692340552806854, 0.7610486745834351, -0.3422926664352417, 0.3230174481868744, 0.364389568567276, 0.2503095865249634, -0.47773855924606323, 0.5121921896934509, 0.4455164968967438, 0.5587577223777771, -0.5298737287521362, 0.6000271439552307, -0.5583392977714539, 0.7476783394813538, 0.3222230076789856, 0.3842165172100067, -0.09761660546064377, -0.013538826256990433, -0.22972826659679413, -0.9504235982894897, 0.4441623091697693, 0.058529049158096313, 0.17431041598320007, 0.619526743888855, -0.017171459272503853, 0.7601300477981567, -0.6018354892730713, 0.300750732421875, -1.1005016565322876, -0.22687265276908875, -0.14104622602462769, 0.689093828201294, 0.7079070806503296, 0.3780255615711212, 0.1752495914697647, -0.08271733671426773, 0.07334525883197784, 0.14903484284877777, -0.6987491846084595, -0.2956043481826782, -0.1546422690153122, -1.10381281375885, -0.1246102973818779, 0.90726637840271, 0.040432158857584, 0.026832373812794685, 0.36519479751586914, 0.05830489844083786, 0.45724812150001526, -0.9266189932823181, -0.5484070181846619, 0.060117948800325394, -0.32300618290901184, 1.2394572496414185, -0.7180522084236145, 0.5975710153579712, -0.5715140700340271, 0.2673238515853882, -0.2852616608142853, 0.6807063221931458, 0.26548928022384644, -0.5041503310203552, -0.05149755999445915, -0.08244499564170837, -1.0661439895629883, -0.3417956233024597, -0.33277323842048645, 0.2292580008506775, 0.16663651168346405, -0.16916526854038239, 0.15934310853481293, 0.05361831560730934, 0.13251623511314392, 0.3503166437149048, 0.2509729862213135, 0.27850139141082764, -1.1351149082183838, -1.0493167638778687, 0.43203455209732056, -0.03340892866253853, -0.16991522908210754, 0.5325535535812378, -0.2305767983198166, 0.4082212746143341, 0.9416787624359131, -0.08786650002002716, 0.10034835338592529, -0.8714460134506226, -0.8538838028907776, -0.24371907114982605, -0.49290019273757935, -0.06343608349561691, -0.24807022511959076, 0.8458120822906494, -0.08598047494888306, -0.07771610468626022, -0.6606383919715881, -0.1908360719680786, 0.45521730184555054, -0.3320285677909851, 0.15755751729011536, 0.27846941351890564, -1.059403419494629, 0.6101213693618774, -0.4675721228122711, 0.759922444820404, -0.5550270676612854, 0.08378290385007858, 0.3948400318622589, -0.6449870467185974, 0.2900230288505554, 0.6620787978172302, -0.5936752557754517, 0.5761586427688599, 0.05733183026313782, -0.32897627353668213, 0.5710373520851135, 0.6669802665710449, -1.0762405395507812, 0.18138433992862701, 0.4282580614089966, -0.08975924551486969, 0.15672342479228973, -0.038840580731630325, 0.9369674324989319, -0.0020763527136296034, 0.09971558302640915, 0.40892887115478516, -0.6698039770126343, -0.022798510268330574, 0.6922106146812439, 0.10073817521333694, 0.29979103803634644, 0.340894877910614, -0.41179606318473816, -0.11533525586128235, -0.26109573245048523, 0.8231992125511169, 0.034892864525318146, 0.20274193584918976, -0.5453659892082214, 0.28635361790657043, 0.3322641849517822, 0.19417449831962585, -0.10855782777070999, -0.4608093798160553, 0.8799765110015869, 0.10730632394552231, -0.5169247388839722, 0.13301235437393188, 0.4426822066307068, -0.12903650104999542, 0.6809728741645813, 0.058696772903203964, -0.467212051153183, 0.6681614518165588, -0.02294423058629036, -0.06594741344451904, -0.5357745289802551, 0.975497841835022, -0.6652819514274597, 0.5104852318763733, -0.39177194237709045, -0.5738290548324585, -0.6403869986534119, -0.658676028251648, -0.07182997465133667, 0.11042062193155289, 0.20539873838424683, -0.7177725434303284, -0.7352912425994873, 0.25005796551704407, 0.1789625734090805, -0.34665873646736145, 0.23076167702674866, -0.1806710958480835, -0.09765847027301788, 0.46107250452041626, 0.06925971806049347, -0.4204520285129547, -1.0895717144012451, 0.15383483469486237, -0.09816326200962067, 0.04957477003335953, -0.37692707777023315, -0.6545811891555786, -0.17962297797203064, -0.22579807043075562, 0.6150116920471191, 0.030054794624447823, 0.10265107452869415, 0.18081118166446686, -0.19554565846920013, 0.3991544246673584, -0.3235718905925751, -0.14005444943904877, -0.5538091659545898, 0.37554070353507996, -1.129980206489563, 0.44896751642227173, -0.13715586066246033, -0.19825083017349243, -0.48264944553375244, 0.4253849685192108, 0.6542711853981018, 0.36617767810821533, -0.3525163531303406, 0.2821231186389923, 0.7420473098754883, -0.598778486251831, 0.2391725778579712, -0.23814839124679565, -0.15685869753360748, -0.8189533948898315, -0.8145636320114136, -0.4788241684436798, 0.26871663331985474, -0.2128051221370697, 0.27692359685897827, 0.3219647705554962, -0.4756002426147461, -0.14409181475639343, 0.0789816826581955, 0.2626248300075531, -0.41841235756874084, -0.09816855937242508, 0.6390001177787781, -0.29630470275878906, 0.9623214602470398, -0.08514458686113358, -0.7348666787147522, -0.7695395946502686, 0.29093682765960693, -0.6413429379463196, -0.15741322934627533, 0.42029017210006714, 0.3328312337398529, -0.7083469033241272, 0.5594286322593689, -0.34623005986213684, -0.1869196891784668, 0.3419307470321655, -0.09055396914482117, 0.6765625476837158, 0.4422356188297272, -0.04195772111415863, -0.1673775017261505, -0.22882910072803497, -0.46171844005584717, 0.5742242932319641, 0.5394258499145508, -0.04386220872402191, -0.2478489875793457, 1.0618793964385986, -0.34836259484291077, -0.8424113988876343, 0.5751601457595825, -0.48826682567596436, 0.22249257564544678, -0.033733755350112915, -0.32168444991111755, -0.27596184611320496, 0.07535804808139801, 0.3520183265209198, 0.19817981123924255, 0.3176316022872925, -0.2548970878124237, 0.2039027065038681, -0.28525179624557495, -0.527050793170929, 0.0734599232673645, -0.06623636186122894, 1.0110403299331665, -0.003996418323367834, -0.6136658787727356, -0.3043401837348938, 0.26994049549102783, -0.2226644903421402, 0.1395803838968277, -0.6700839996337891, 0.43368130922317505, -0.10040295869112015, -0.9831436276435852, -0.3544328212738037, -0.20836539566516876, 0.32481715083122253, 0.6408138871192932, 0.059353724122047424, 1.2032042741775513, -0.5944142937660217, 0.38121911883354187, -0.5246652960777283, 0.4835219085216522, -0.022548247128725052, -0.9936248064041138, -0.04485011100769043, 0.2700386047363281, 0.29013165831565857, -0.6521515846252441, -0.40112608671188354, 0.20270460844039917, -0.6704936027526855, 0.1971612125635147, -0.0081375353038311, -0.8250051736831665, -0.09173990786075592, 0.8265125751495361, 0.6577626466751099, 0.3849969208240509, -0.42204347252845764, 0.6248726844787598, -0.36356961727142334, 0.2247074395418167, 0.011969598941504955, -0.11949922144412994, 0.6218504309654236, 0.08060485869646072, 0.36014315485954285, 0.17670384049415588, -0.3638344705104828, 0.5031371712684631, 0.27434423565864563, 0.06506361812353134, 0.3826773166656494, 0.3899875283241272, 0.2820824980735779, -0.44881635904312134, 0.36251500248908997, 0.5249338746070862, -0.13514618575572968, -0.2951870560646057, 1.2611377239227295, -0.32824769616127014, 0.42150723934173584, -0.4068853557109833, -0.41273751854896545, 0.046584151685237885, -0.2942958176136017, 0.4046243131160736, 0.39869216084480286, -1.01577889919281, -1.0285824537277222, -0.0919545367360115, 0.17360346019268036, 0.5191574096679688, 0.33707869052886963, 1.2352626323699951, 0.06084360182285309, 0.490729421377182, 0.22655640542507172, 0.4157702922821045, 0.18415586650371552, -0.08000307530164719, 0.2719757556915283, 0.3085828125476837, 0.6255741715431213, 0.3594968914985657, 0.8542532324790955, 0.21178573369979858, -0.9121267795562744, -0.42257317900657654, -0.83146071434021, 0.7696930170059204, -0.5799180269241333, -0.3484838008880615, 0.7653771638870239, 0.3515690863132477, -0.5156508684158325, 0.4300345480442047, 0.2824055254459381, 0.2735084891319275, 0.10566402971744537, -0.1733686327934265, -0.5618020296096802, -0.41762575507164, 0.3687189817428589, -0.27371394634246826, 0.6049708127975464, 0.6234073042869568, 0.6478708982467651, -0.01284312829375267, 0.1191641315817833, -0.16625431180000305, -0.27872273325920105, 0.405269056558609, -0.6050317883491516, -0.17906954884529114, 0.4582032561302185, -0.06276705116033554, -0.23141685128211975, 0.32658231258392334, 0.4414868950843811, -0.8052211999893188, -0.09429754316806793, -0.6281302571296692, -1.0175701379776, -0.25964105129241943, 0.2736571133136749, -0.5227046012878418, 0.6026564240455627, -0.30595770478248596, 0.15947310626506805, -0.4795932471752167, 0.3526281416416168, 0.137296661734581, -0.005967446602880955, 0.21655137836933136, -0.4885985851287842, 0.05314822122454643, -0.3018395006656647, 0.31110429763793945, -0.32125547528266907, -1.0997647047042847, 0.3511258363723755, -0.32979440689086914, -0.6620574593544006, -0.5002970695495605, -0.19606460630893707, -0.2416779100894928, -0.20300167798995972, -0.8248913288116455, 0.28708311915397644, 0.2348272204399109, -0.6117277145385742, -0.1748085916042328, -0.04535171389579773, 0.1827859878540039, -0.9057828187942505, -0.06438270956277847, -0.02106359787285328, 0.7221412062644958, -1.0501480102539062, -0.6569749116897583, 0.42885592579841614, -0.13700318336486816, 0.116939976811409, -0.5891961455345154, -0.24630731344223022, 0.38452088832855225, -0.8684191107749939, 0.25490108132362366, -0.42809513211250305, -0.09281938523054123, -0.18231336772441864, -0.37445902824401855, -0.2095872014760971, 0.4871479868888855, 0.9041829705238342, -0.3605426549911499, -0.08131200820207596, -0.357023686170578, 0.29360994696617126, -0.7204501032829285, -0.296564519405365, 0.0688743069767952, -0.1897478699684143, -0.8512228727340698, 1.619971513748169, -0.7568220496177673, -0.4432598054409027, -0.04691608250141144, -0.3100464344024658, 0.02065937966108322, 0.22496294975280762, 0.10079099237918854, -0.1730891317129135, -0.49147748947143555, 0.17891576886177063, 0.09165267646312714, 0.3627503216266632, -0.6618024706840515, 0.0011424471158534288, -0.11733496934175491, -0.2512366473674774, 0.034940559417009354, -0.23325791954994202, 0.30299586057662964, -0.21079514920711517, 0.7247262597084045, -0.2486080378293991, 0.22719430923461914, 0.6444506049156189, 0.6791701316833496, 0.681346595287323, 0.38325420022010803, -0.3791174590587616, -0.5494605302810669, -0.1026839166879654, -0.4521302282810211, 0.19246315956115723, -0.1759290099143982, 0.04675564542412758, 0.23229777812957764, -0.44405514001846313, -0.6147666573524475, -0.6131042242050171, 0.055114734917879105, -0.4628826975822449, 0.30532631278038025, -0.023869961500167847, -0.8207300901412964, 0.13690070807933807, 0.10873191803693771, 0.7456038594245911, 0.37849903106689453, -0.1145482212305069, -0.703842282295227, -0.36770594120025635, -0.17084024846553802, -0.9040494561195374, -0.8503111600875854, 0.7082348465919495, 0.7551624178886414, -0.523257851600647, 0.5723124742507935, -0.26076361536979675, -0.04734548181295395, -0.3401925265789032, -0.013436597771942616, 0.5591896772384644, -0.40288153290748596, 0.93768310546875, 0.5783407688140869, -0.042741090059280396, 0.325559139251709, 0.14865334331989288, -1.2049745321273804, -0.22349603474140167, 0.6090041399002075, -0.6423916816711426, -0.33231785893440247, 0.38501325249671936, 0.5050004124641418, -1.0828248262405396, -0.19095830619335175, -0.33926907181739807, -0.2625058889389038, 0.6370936632156372, -0.464153528213501, -0.7280169725418091, -0.8675129413604736, -0.4105933904647827, -0.09116312861442566, 0.011447757482528687, 0.10006774961948395, 0.7676786184310913, 0.041846226900815964, 0.07588567584753036, -0.6288993954658508, -0.3667106628417969, 1.3399090766906738, 0.1423340141773224, -0.7493877410888672, -0.10737192630767822, 0.25812438130378723, -0.8882506489753723, -0.6259822845458984, 1.44547700881958, -0.22832947969436646, 0.10445500165224075, 0.44125738739967346, 0.8956385254859924, 0.7625756859779358, 0.24634526669979095, -0.4940885007381439, 1.2030794620513916, -1.5484236478805542, -0.35974058508872986, -0.4278683364391327, 0.1361110806465149, 0.5974142551422119, 0.6715340614318848, -0.0347817987203598, -0.5919867157936096, -0.11297540366649628, -0.7548723816871643, -0.007341597694903612, -0.04491915926337242, -0.7562556266784668, -0.0839194729924202, -0.6739156246185303, -0.5488507151603699, -0.05824538692831993, 0.22501851618289948, 0.17677462100982666, -0.12173750251531601, 0.22951079905033112, 0.7051642537117004, -0.0011613090755417943, -0.31859976053237915, 0.39504924416542053, -0.11878655850887299, 0.30865752696990967, -0.5294144153594971, -0.12210153788328171, -0.3818521797657013, -1.4742546081542969, 0.2400156706571579, -0.6745794415473938, -0.3388665020465851, 0.9649598598480225, -0.4909861981868744, 0.6052809357643127, 0.10295072942972183, -0.6418828964233398, -0.6825335025787354, -1.0212960243225098, -1.451030969619751, 0.8279768228530884, -0.23105528950691223, 0.7463417649269104, 0.6704884171485901, -0.250469446182251, -0.023994198068976402, -0.2118063122034073, -0.5633883476257324, 0.2506912648677826, -0.10650058835744858, 0.31798359751701355, -0.1600106656551361, 0.47806939482688904, 0.5578704476356506, 0.49168074131011963, -0.6335658431053162, -0.41979196667671204, -0.6069685220718384, 0.07115218043327332, 0.460593581199646, 0.16175691783428192, -0.25665703415870667, 0.546390175819397, 0.6211270689964294, 0.6732608675956726, -0.0664728656411171, 0.1830759346485138, -0.8963695764541626, 0.14500896632671356, -0.12895643711090088, 0.16737037897109985, 0.021181758493185043, -0.4114466905593872, 0.6697859168052673, 0.40250253677368164, 0.26863160729408264, -0.5254839658737183, 0.2365955114364624, -0.37652522325515747, -0.32072755694389343, 0.1337544173002243, -0.9373167157173157, 0.7666234374046326, 0.8195589780807495, -0.05987629294395447, 0.6680296659469604, -0.23010358214378357, -0.8394726514816284, 0.7040556073188782, -0.6236854791641235, -0.7955291867256165, 0.4929038882255554, 0.05368369445204735, 0.36907199025154114, 0.1941492110490799, -0.9052788019180298, 0.051546018570661545, 0.03972690925002098, 0.9174416661262512, 0.9548290967941284, 0.44844624400138855, -0.28768956661224365, 0.9149302244186401, -0.7245085835456848, -0.6440118551254272, -0.6192727088928223, 0.7368240356445312, -0.6710963845252991, -0.8306025266647339, -0.8629443645477295, 0.009899767115712166, -0.11591897159814835, -0.5317144989967346, 0.12219400703907013, -0.15615592896938324, -0.1130605936050415, -0.15125131607055664, -0.7846964597702026, -0.36768490076065063, -0.5447261333465576, 0.35611504316329956, -0.0893777385354042, 0.38157927989959717, 0.39380767941474915, 0.4390661120414734, 0.7122946977615356, -0.49313321709632874, -0.26038601994514465, 1.1282823085784912, 0.4303821623325348, -0.21983492374420166, 0.7460561990737915, 0.060317061841487885, 0.3685525357723236, 0.36060959100723267, -0.24402347207069397, 0.5478454232215881, 0.04182184115052223, -0.3496474027633667, 0.9833170175552368, 0.06581491231918335, -0.0036942739970982075, 0.06726682186126709, -0.3044523000717163, -0.015511464327573776, 0.09241001307964325, -0.06999079883098602, 0.15069304406642914, 0.18296658992767334, -0.6938813924789429, -0.03396821394562721, 0.3179166913032532, 0.05237175524234772, 0.4264587461948395, -0.36596882343292236, 0.026258273050189018, -0.15965895354747772, -0.44170841574668884, 0.41412532329559326, -0.9620777368545532, -0.23400074243545532, -0.512866199016571, 0.8554455637931824, 0.08738762140274048, -0.26148083806037903, -0.0025601384695619345, 0.1202617958188057, 0.26439744234085083, -0.06687645614147186, -0.4705132246017456, 0.6424061059951782, 0.5139986276626587, 0.0685407742857933, -0.023369772359728813, 0.7035920023918152, 0.2759351134300232, 0.5522366762161255, -0.24543824791908264, -1.3520711660385132, 0.26749706268310547, 0.3945658206939697, 0.32301008701324463, -0.5676959156990051, 0.679882287979126, -1.159182071685791, 0.34602630138397217, -0.7848988175392151, 0.6855758428573608, -1.0078779458999634, -0.06732430309057236, 0.34457075595855713, -0.5269899964332581, 0.25621917843818665, 0.2339440882205963, -0.16226623952388763, -0.13236060738563538, 0.525408148765564, 0.272437185049057, 0.4973236322402954, 1.004736065864563, 1.1578274965286255, 0.30492594838142395, -0.5252838730812073, -0.041091520339250565, 0.3257608711719513, 0.29651251435279846, -0.03101428598165512, -0.5900295972824097, 1.0659236907958984, -0.22958208620548248, -0.03454344719648361, 0.1346505731344223, -0.2139379233121872, -0.036391161382198334, 0.7566398978233337, 0.6086024641990662, 0.745061993598938, -0.5610815286636353, -0.36929237842559814, 0.6630158424377441, 0.5251713395118713, 1.2410253286361694, -0.08654040843248367, 0.19993938505649567, -0.718614399433136, -0.26708462834358215, -0.28477901220321655, 0.8928449749946594, -0.5066617131233215, -0.1068170890212059, 0.28018009662628174, -0.7864738702774048, -0.044869519770145416, -0.30014416575431824, -0.009308046661317348, -0.3529462516307831, 0.2833981215953827, 1.1122326850891113, 0.33427226543426514, 0.34603118896484375, -0.7975639700889587, -0.2615625858306885, 0.062270764261484146, 0.8710486888885498, -0.5563489198684692, -0.4168533980846405, 0.727595329284668, -0.19658653438091278, -0.884441077709198, 0.9951750040054321, 0.25742998719215393, -0.46896541118621826, 0.7321090698242188, 0.2840573191642761, 0.15366962552070618, 0.07674426585435867, -0.1822986900806427, 0.4500878155231476, 1.0708140134811401, -0.09956250339746475, 0.5364115238189697, -0.6062254905700684, -0.10309132933616638, -0.6795276403427124, -0.3215809762477875, -0.3678814172744751, 0.49321576952934265, -0.3379633128643036, -0.3364347219467163, 0.25398534536361694, -1.0611950159072876, 4.221297740936279, 1.0310745239257812, 0.9546483755111694, -0.515815019607544, 0.5593406558036804, 0.5187800526618958, 0.36338624358177185, -0.17482657730579376, 0.32364997267723083, -0.3616388738155365, 0.4236595332622528, -0.324908971786499, 0.38510140776634216, -0.14063288271427155, -0.15331871807575226, 0.7619643807411194, -0.21250072121620178, -0.2965080440044403, 0.8649192452430725, 0.14491625130176544, -1.423649787902832, -0.14237239956855774, -0.5609650015830994, -0.6607971787452698, -0.07161960005760193, 0.433322548866272, -0.04121215641498566, -0.7507213950157166, -0.34811609983444214, -0.16731925308704376, -0.20151102542877197, -0.7381950616836548, 0.8045186996459961, -0.6252867579460144, -0.9810044765472412, 0.14491525292396545, -0.024712445214390755, -0.05497252196073532, 0.14209838211536407, 0.07529464364051819, -0.009488911367952824, -0.17632782459259033, 0.3652450740337372, -0.08653779327869415, 0.1780351847410202, 1.1540570259094238, 0.6271814107894897, -0.4508698880672455, 0.5409603714942932, -0.8371849060058594, 0.4332457482814789, -0.2816844880580902, 0.062162965536117554, -0.11306911706924438, -0.9320924282073975, -0.15188704431056976, 0.3215401768684387, -0.8234714269638062, -0.9401659369468689, 0.07974650710821152, 0.6491544246673584, 0.19516107439994812, -0.49874818325042725, 0.7972050309181213, -0.18654078245162964, 0.17134203016757965, 0.42803630232810974, 0.14531151950359344, -0.2967548966407776, 0.007666794117540121, -0.5381296873092651, 0.10530725866556168, 0.13811737298965454, -0.5335149765014648, 0.778692364692688, 0.31553807854652405, -0.6647213101387024, 0.21593928337097168, -0.766795814037323, 0.16536583006381989, -0.5582013726234436, -0.2105986326932907, -0.6529592871665955, 0.4450523555278778, -0.25259459018707275, 0.5956606268882751, 0.1507962942123413, -0.42004403471946716, -0.20221316814422607, 0.16427165269851685, -0.042847611010074615, 0.8444781303405762, 0.16583989560604095, 0.15541425347328186, 0.10288447141647339 ]
Detection of brown dwarfs by the micro-lensing of unresolved stars
The presence of brown dwarfs in the dark galactic halo could be detected through their gravitational lensing effect and experiments under way monitor about one million stars to observe a few lensing events per year. We show that if the photon flux from a galaxy is measured with a good precision, it is not necessary to resolve the stars and besides more events could be observed.
Paul Baillon, Alain Bouquet, Yannick Giraud-H\'eraud and Jean Kaplan
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211002
astro-ph/9211003
[ 0.13297279179096222, 1.0079296827316284, 0.1368217170238495, -0.2818514406681061, -0.49601566791534424, 0.09142160415649414, -1.010738730430603, -0.37969455122947693, 0.4268440902233124, 0.8425019979476929, -0.07652595639228821, -0.4120688736438751, 0.04736854135990143, -0.8498271107673645, -0.9265753030776978, 0.01990622654557228, -0.5404676795005798, -0.38603734970092773, -2.1003239154815674, -0.4602045714855194, -0.7637059092521667, -0.8639332056045532, -1.05479896068573, -0.6415191292762756, -0.045701295137405396, 0.5258930921554565, 0.4266686737537384, 0.4568578898906708, 0.9087183475494385, 0.17469310760498047, -0.004258397035300732, -0.8664210438728333, -0.11991142481565475, -0.6333889961242676, -0.9482194781303406, 0.37020885944366455, -0.19744785130023956, -0.5755499005317688, 0.44967398047447205, -0.6218711733818054, 0.7989149689674377, -0.6186770796775818, 0.7981324791908264, -0.6760979294776917, -0.23389899730682373, -0.22560399770736694, -0.33796557784080505, 0.022284984588623047, 0.12510055303573608, 0.27997127175331116, -0.002056476892903447, -0.5329083204269409, 0.6253438591957092, -0.2885323464870453, 0.34302565455436707, -0.464824378490448, -0.008906685747206211, 0.6173046231269836, -0.37973353266716003, -0.09240978956222534, 0.6403874754905701, 0.43262970447540283, 0.213797926902771, -0.10807792097330093, 0.14371980726718903, 0.9213179349899292, -0.19169402122497559, 0.11997353285551071, -0.37158650159835815, 0.11838161200284958, -0.6738048195838928, -0.15632264316082, 0.029991135001182556, 0.5221554040908813, -0.4070206582546234, -0.14629560708999634, 0.42136242985725403, -0.3294884264469147, -0.34983301162719727, 0.13488586246967316, 0.24902823567390442, 0.31477054953575134, 0.46113696694374084, 0.6327474117279053, 0.32764923572540283, -0.6660210490226746, 0.5143162608146667, 0.535805881023407, -0.017401115968823433, 0.5729125738143921, -0.016786159947514534, 0.8711374402046204, 0.124055877327919, 0.009113031439483166, 0.5784780979156494, -0.14658547937870026, -0.21910399198532104, -0.2952665090560913, 0.5904420018196106, 0.1207023337483406, 0.5131821632385254, 0.3988513648509979, -0.6143088936805725, 0.03678681701421738, -0.9188337326049805, 0.28720203042030334, 0.2431270182132721, 0.5350086092948914, 0.139206200838089, -0.8106716275215149, -0.24292360246181488, 0.29749131202697754, 0.49725720286369324, -0.26009976863861084, 0.821104884147644, 0.6439744830131531, 0.21108943223953247, 0.610389232635498, -0.7200391888618469, -0.036420293152332306, 0.14663827419281006, 0.7991952300071716, 0.15636810660362244, 0.16649283468723297, -0.13189400732517242, -0.6185330748558044, -0.26216360926628113, 0.5309286713600159, -0.5385726094245911, 0.24674084782600403, -0.16958971321582794, -1.3586782217025757, -0.2601340115070343, 0.8536201119422913, -0.23245485126972198, 0.16126589477062225, 0.8309291005134583, 0.5393661856651306, -0.3801250457763672, -0.6514877676963806, 0.3679293394088745, -0.47386136651039124, 0.18372274935245514, 1.5653384923934937, -0.32383865118026733, 0.4218222498893738, -0.8944209814071655, -0.36956071853637695, -0.3882239758968353, 0.09041143208742142, -0.8242602348327637, -0.09690841287374496, 0.3127177953720093, 1.0519317388534546, -0.8423833250999451, -0.10950322449207306, -0.6754868626594543, -0.2111136019229889, 0.2879844307899475, -0.6725233793258667, -0.05216657370328903, -0.8034396171569824, 0.6805264949798584, 0.9962448477745056, 0.09902765601873398, 0.23042096197605133, -0.7189940214157104, -0.4465964436531067, -0.0072747464291751385, -0.3346657454967499, 0.08643738180398941, -0.35678666830062866, 0.03863588348031044, 0.5398679375648499, 0.6984564065933228, 0.43695804476737976, 0.07880105823278427, -0.8793616890907288, -0.10011120140552521, 0.5361945033073425, -0.24422991275787354, 0.09019100666046143, -0.06567112356424332, -0.06205814331769943, 1.0110843181610107, 0.16455893218517303, -0.6186729073524475, 0.273924320936203, -0.188760906457901, 0.3979180157184601, 0.05576863884925842, 1.0523711442947388, -0.4336280822753906, 0.30168500542640686, -0.9928629398345947, 0.360639363527298, -0.03859072923660278, 0.1555069237947464, 0.45895448327064514, 0.13820238411426544, 0.29079920053482056, 0.19891208410263062, -0.05832332372665405, 0.1034323051571846, -0.07412894070148468, 0.07744668424129486, 0.081285260617733, 0.7381247282028198, -0.5674915313720703, 0.4361790716648102, 0.8702235817909241, -0.6291750073432922, 0.1107606589794159, -0.18744666874408722, 0.5573667287826538, 0.052936356514692307, 0.03790938854217529, 0.06316845864057541, -0.7047490477561951, -0.5414465069770813, 0.9378915429115295, 0.11493237316608429, -0.13146953284740448, 0.44188693165779114, -0.41177329421043396, -0.4184132516384125, -0.24413232505321503, 0.4819389283657074, 0.24993348121643066, 0.04062119126319885, 0.28326332569122314, 0.3927239775657654, 0.17769445478916168, 0.6498561501502991, -0.18558263778686523, -0.7834848761558533, 1.22780442237854, 1.0575809478759766, -0.6472745537757874, 0.09615648537874222, 0.7021955847740173, -0.5368115305900574, 0.6069390177726746, 0.41334280371665955, -0.11274807155132294, 0.11238685995340347, -0.23103511333465576, -0.15841569006443024, -0.22936072945594788, 0.42794522643089294, 0.021728241816163063, 0.4241698682308197, -0.1760486364364624, -0.0038900445215404034, -0.7917496562004089, -0.7092904448509216, 0.1668688803911209, -0.017285984009504318, -0.07112181186676025, -0.7023189663887024, 0.07959761470556259, -0.2979077994823456, 0.49877944588661194, -0.22745758295059204, -0.37372076511383057, 0.8179463148117065, -0.19451558589935303, 0.06877075135707855, 0.12962643802165985, 0.027725348249077797, -0.6307637691497803, -0.04575103893876076, -0.4292333722114563, 0.15301750600337982, -0.5447083711624146, -0.040815893560647964, 0.563586413860321, -0.9883729815483093, 0.3234604597091675, -0.557152509689331, 0.21057772636413574, 0.9272536635398865, -0.48622187972068787, 0.2461661994457245, -0.6598269939422607, 0.32863566279411316, -0.730302095413208, 0.9569682478904724, -0.5466737151145935, -0.44318875670433044, 0.23665256798267365, -0.08912031352519989, -0.5458296537399292, -0.6809821724891663, 0.4095074236392975, -0.24417096376419067, -0.2755969166755676, 0.4975539743900299, 1.020082950592041, -0.9993866086006165, 0.370358407497406, -0.5904545187950134, -0.2678641080856323, -0.543976902961731, -0.13722479343414307, 0.3624267578125, -0.8111512064933777, 0.187394917011261, 0.4151705503463745, 0.1415707916021347, -0.6832777857780457, 0.30245542526245117, -0.5491605997085571, 0.29624632000923157, -0.34994250535964966, 0.4094526469707489, 0.22641807794570923, 0.14071083068847656, 0.5134459733963013, -0.4316076636314392, -0.8943603038787842, -0.38447728753089905, 0.1971398890018463, -0.27705278992652893, 0.7064329385757446, 0.819193959236145, 0.04077325388789177, -0.517410933971405, 0.8167504072189331, -0.5948047041893005, -0.6183558702468872, 0.7517843842506409, 0.05213291943073273, 0.30747807025909424, -0.013606661930680275, -0.006539590656757355, -0.2695843279361725, -0.5946751236915588, -0.2658817172050476, 0.40253007411956787, 0.5734410285949707, -0.7947009801864624, -0.09008167684078217, 0.5724869966506958, -0.2538919746875763, -0.5083479285240173, 1.379187822341919, -0.49638670682907104, 0.018997415900230408, -0.47130778431892395, -0.232547327876091, 0.5157293081283569, 0.25361716747283936, 0.011819382198154926, 0.018369631841778755, 0.5191527009010315, 0.1149425059556961, -0.2824101448059082, -0.8056105971336365, -0.38469722867012024, 0.05220215767621994, 0.03307047486305237, 0.02764776349067688, -0.19931469857692719, 0.36795109510421753, 0.14633306860923767, 0.8308793902397156, -0.36532920598983765, 0.30525025725364685, -1.1023808717727661, 0.32394155859947205, -0.0069582778960466385, -0.4717736542224884, -0.5805459022521973, 0.7307719588279724, 0.14704306423664093, 0.22021399438381195, 0.6457832455635071, 0.7085900902748108, -0.02611745335161686, 0.1291244477033615, -0.8108269572257996, 0.29590895771980286, -0.3382394015789032, 0.14573319256305695, 0.14114099740982056, 0.5537140965461731, 0.7351609468460083, -0.8724079132080078, -0.684089183807373, -0.607819139957428, -0.7794605493545532, -0.0719328448176384, -0.9935019612312317, -0.20398178696632385, -0.2540086805820465, 0.65020352602005, 0.8459779024124146, 0.031083034351468086, 0.20997373759746552, -0.1278678923845291, -0.87767493724823, -0.1758754700422287, 0.6958582997322083, -0.41778144240379333, 0.936207115650177, -0.5388479232788086, 0.17241297662258148, 0.9471122622489929, -0.01870563253760338, 0.09517589956521988, 0.015379718504846096, -0.09965713322162628, 0.9231728911399841, 0.05305099859833717, 0.003417262574657798, -0.4612688720226288, -0.13948017358779907, 0.36063042283058167, 0.5309903025627136, -0.10488330572843552, 0.4154742658138275, 0.2715253233909607, 0.8749017715454102, 0.02187313511967659, -0.19442583620548248, -0.8028008937835693, -0.46260780096054077, 0.5270792841911316, -0.36177119612693787, -0.923255443572998, 0.006994888186454773, -0.803415060043335, 0.7159228920936584, -0.34351974725723267, 0.39053601026535034, 0.5055469274520874, 0.3645980954170227, 0.446697860956192, -0.5347282290458679, 0.46749573945999146, 0.8685914874076843, -0.02892313152551651, -0.40355512499809265, 0.6337066888809204, 0.6549943685531616, 0.44254371523857117, 0.7294884324073792, -0.33785441517829895, -0.7209275364875793, -0.29107996821403503, -0.19601859152317047, 1.25758957862854, -0.23647451400756836, -0.17316487431526184, 0.6992906928062439, -0.13223396241664886, -0.5050865411758423, 0.37657997012138367, -0.29776161909103394, 0.08988355845212936, 0.08911696821451187, -0.2922155559062958, -0.4709855616092682, -0.5700986385345459, 0.5531796216964722, -0.06810234487056732, 0.8739655613899231, 0.2535848021507263, 0.227111354470253, 0.4988047182559967, 0.3072901666164398, -0.012079778127372265, -0.2984321713447571, 0.12096747010946274, -0.3377753794193268, -0.08089639991521835, -0.5986983180046082, -0.4173552095890045, -0.007915303111076355, -0.32241708040237427, 0.8716378808021545, -0.9504963755607605, 0.33339521288871765, -0.07578767836093903, -0.35367393493652344, 0.5806203484535217, 0.4288542568683624, -0.02689165621995926, 0.33836716413497925, -0.2221464216709137, -0.2721431255340576, -0.6991411447525024, -0.3086036145687103, -0.5730217099189758, -0.3212231695652008, 0.17334555089473724, -0.7193664312362671, -0.4342198669910431, -0.38489505648612976, 0.5260797739028931, -0.2733845114707947, -1.0302373170852661, 0.07409384101629257, -0.40025246143341064, -0.26273390650749207, -0.7327219247817993, -0.9287094473838806, -0.7019875645637512, -0.26631873846054077, -0.5350351929664612, 0.7046246528625488, 0.10523706674575806, -0.35831454396247864, -0.4473336637020111, 0.8424597382545471, 0.21808485686779022, -0.7184910178184509, -0.30075517296791077, 0.07766406983137131, 0.6183909773826599, -0.547340452671051, 0.3876287341117859, 0.1685086041688919, 0.5604696273803711, 0.3926074504852295, -0.9562386870384216, -0.9184221029281616, 0.2983737289905548, -1.20733642578125, -0.1581614464521408, -1.3722437620162964, 0.08836130797863007, 0.5514435172080994, -0.5577957034111023, 0.2584173381328583, -0.2910168468952179, 0.42305877804756165, -1.385933518409729, -0.08361269533634186, -0.5411757230758667, 1.0325547456741333, -0.3225574791431427, -0.4241430461406708, -0.8054905533790588, -0.02693082019686699, -0.23916099965572357, 0.9560235142707825, -1.0162466764450073, 0.41686829924583435, -0.241082102060318, 0.46580398082733154, 0.23070749640464783, 0.41205430030822754, -0.5183337330818176, 0.4453330636024475, 0.24622514843940735, 0.4493793547153473, 0.13068369030952454, 0.6365299224853516, -0.5907602310180664, 0.13998495042324066, -1.010697364807129, -0.7308794260025024, -0.22317123413085938, 0.056062404066324234, 0.03532415255904198, -0.02988615073263645, 0.5541009306907654, -0.6531662344932556, 0.9101651310920715, 0.18090617656707764, 0.24117320775985718, 0.9372950196266174, 0.6712125539779663, -0.8989740610122681, -0.6693532466888428, -0.7247616648674011, -0.7752062678337097, 0.28140199184417725, 0.445992112159729, 0.030331207439303398, -0.3765172064304352, 0.006922569591552019, -0.43686503171920776, -0.7359287142753601, 0.3293599486351013, 0.6477312445640564, 0.484415739774704, 0.4506687521934509, -0.6385600566864014, 0.023402173072099686, 0.6052656769752502, 0.5427171587944031, -0.0089032631367445, 0.4626885652542114, -0.6652634143829346, 0.15029993653297424, -0.39996880292892456, -0.43950507044792175, -0.7012569308280945, 0.6483855247497559, 0.7045013904571533, -0.6934061050415039, 0.9205325245857239, -0.680413544178009, -0.17224524915218353, 0.23678337037563324, -0.26970234513282776, 0.740362286567688, -0.17111879587173462, 0.4142196774482727, -0.17620784044265747, 0.1415993720293045, 0.4443756937980652, -0.4591415822505951, -0.4466954171657562, -0.3564959466457367, 0.672339141368866, -0.5594492554664612, -0.3684564232826233, 0.07825244218111038, 0.5277414917945862, -0.8737564086914062, -0.42624369263648987, -0.4679156243801117, 0.377444326877594, -0.7485457062721252, -0.826242208480835, 0.35425275564193726, 0.060775671154260635, -0.40798258781433105, 0.3462241291999817, 0.6274872422218323, 0.25454071164131165, 0.19456516206264496, 0.32382723689079285, 0.5577298402786255, -0.5470862984657288, 0.5808616280555725, 1.5279433727264404, -0.02137153409421444, -0.5762341022491455, -0.28148025274276733, -0.30031293630599976, -0.33054617047309875, -0.10096930712461472, 1.458178997039795, 0.22145657241344452, 0.3658468723297119, 0.18443463742733002, 0.6123130917549133, 0.3392988443374634, -0.202703595161438, -0.042598240077495575, 0.5933158993721008, -0.9087650775909424, -0.24705198407173157, -0.14272981882095337, 0.5714643597602844, 0.15076184272766113, 1.0255259275436401, 0.4801802337169647, -0.34159228205680847, 0.042568426579236984, -0.4085317552089691, 0.15669554471969604, -0.7139151096343994, -0.6462258100509644, -0.8057158589363098, -0.8614609241485596, -0.4309273064136505, -0.055740177631378174, 0.4658333361148834, 0.7210344076156616, 0.46069473028182983, 0.18217283487319946, 0.5225016474723816, -0.3862423598766327, 0.34050801396369934, 0.43424859642982483, -0.04014237970113754, 0.43925929069519043, -0.4230375587940216, -0.5278636813163757, -0.22402802109718323, -0.7528586387634277, -0.34957873821258545, 0.4672105610370636, -0.12303780764341354, 0.434282124042511, 0.048348553478717804, 0.33052414655685425, -0.025467611849308014, -0.11750946193933487, 0.3128637373447418, -0.5139023065567017, -1.0814762115478516, 0.6647109985351562, -0.8294388055801392, 1.119194746017456, 0.5764108896255493, -0.8817343711853027, 0.2692554295063019, -0.23112785816192627, -0.7276747822761536, -0.1400848627090454, -0.17594923079013824, 0.874458909034729, -0.4388294219970703, -0.7159351110458374, 0.09079284965991974, 1.1035107374191284, -0.8080755472183228, -0.44771841168403625, -0.39328983426094055, 0.5198476314544678, 0.5910479426383972, -0.010905012488365173, -0.07004182040691376, 0.8853330612182617, 0.053618911653757095, 0.5918651223182678, -0.2399452179670334, -0.09874042868614197, -0.19786612689495087, 0.5420499444007874, -0.13554935157299042, -0.44744667410850525, -0.03221939876675606, -0.6762210726737976, 0.6224840879440308, 0.01246325857937336, 0.632000207901001, 0.1329086720943451, -0.10150592029094696, -0.358755499124527, -0.9651545286178589, 0.1882437914609909, -0.5125472545623779, 0.2607749402523041, 0.2916872203350067, 0.3691672682762146, 0.7224105596542358, -0.09409110248088837, -0.4745468199253082, -0.2111867517232895, -0.6391679644584656, -0.33201947808265686, -0.3059605062007904, -0.8117709755897522, 0.11185255646705627, -0.06623071432113647, -0.1131853461265564, 0.2689664661884308, 0.058561816811561584, 0.7608545422554016, 0.6969009041786194, -0.2620977759361267, -0.30666327476501465, 0.7499079704284668, -1.6316081285476685, -0.0972525030374527, -0.6325389742851257, -0.26128679513931274, -1.0841543674468994, -0.8777219653129578, 0.6579341888427734, -0.35158056020736694, -0.532751739025116, -0.5824301242828369, -0.20551201701164246, 0.17599652707576752, 0.2587847411632538, -0.21266983449459076, -0.6770919561386108, -0.02994908206164837, -0.05037044361233711, 0.04307683929800987, 0.17797625064849854, -0.0885956808924675, -0.14510567486286163, -0.05438847839832306, 1.1428297758102417, -0.15683819353580475, -0.5965988636016846, 0.3477521538734436, 1.1729878187179565, -0.26472917199134827, 0.5562102198600769, 0.45308971405029297, 1.3002649545669556, 0.4549139738082886, -0.31284889578819275, -0.059858448803424835, 0.6508945226669312, 0.08841394633054733, 0.5713818073272705, 0.9866359233856201, 0.46357259154319763, -0.4220699965953827, -0.21568602323532104, -0.5284975171089172, 0.22342181205749512, 0.6168521046638489, -0.3774624466896057, -0.3132038116455078, -0.7076378464698792, 0.2513439953327179, -0.21328993141651154, 0.0854429379105568, 0.03953405097126961, 0.08775510638952255, 0.5710455179214478, -0.052044015377759933, -0.18825075030326843, 0.03990527242422104, -0.6484740972518921, -0.8079931139945984, -0.5476231575012207, -0.495838463306427, 0.30116719007492065, 0.031669411808252335, 0.8058522343635559, 0.599250316619873, 0.08863788843154907, -0.06159031391143799, 0.430999219417572, 1.043971300125122, 0.5585813522338867, 0.6945835947990417, -0.033767834305763245, 0.16413389146327972, -0.4678969383239746, 0.4801318347454071, -0.09249376505613327, -0.7280303835868835, -0.09931754320859909, 0.4438627064228058, -1.1576393842697144, -0.28184211254119873, 0.1302538961172104, -0.061363738030195236, -0.8540548086166382, -0.42202985286712646, 0.050322212278842926, 0.06696006655693054, 0.4637978971004486, 1.064449667930603, -0.15255452692508698, -0.20656225085258484, 1.236793875694275, -0.12870915234088898, 0.3039569556713104, 0.7250386476516724, 0.21896992623806, -0.5641643404960632, 1.0175764560699463, 0.7154304385185242, 0.4500959515571594, -0.1747553050518036, -0.12044457346200943, -0.36590126156806946, 0.01115757878869772, 0.462202250957489, -1.0151278972625732, 0.5898014307022095, -0.08105994760990143, -0.10703937709331512, 0.2074042558670044, -0.2070411890745163, -0.46731486916542053, 0.18600016832351685, 0.07429690659046173, -0.010080431587994099, -0.1304899901151657, -0.1503709852695465, 0.2636418044567108, 0.5804145336151123, 0.1653965711593628, -0.4270738959312439, 0.46533820033073425, -1.216625690460205, -0.12555108964443207, 0.014911847189068794, 0.3270682990550995, -0.15105105936527252, 0.1569669246673584, -0.17633424699306488, -0.2897166609764099, 0.11490286141633987, -0.5973970293998718, -0.020417770370841026, -0.36201542615890503, 0.016870399937033653, 0.7417341470718384, 0.9172736406326294, 0.3397243022918701, -1.0027321577072144, -0.3837050497531891, 0.7027970552444458, 0.31393980979919434, 0.29101940989494324, -0.49489539861679077, 1.0134556293487549, 0.3502340018749237, -1.0252388715744019, 0.38161078095436096, 0.9093297719955444, -0.16175577044487, 0.25406938791275024, 0.07112306356430054, 0.4551379680633545, 0.2998266816139221, -0.7317845821380615, 0.6769922971725464, 0.7749680280685425, 0.3395206928253174, 0.24105186760425568, -0.004627279005944729, 0.44191643595695496, -0.5744479894638062, 0.23802009224891663, -0.8049456477165222, 0.5648518204689026, 0.4221738576889038, -0.3668646812438965, -0.13000261783599854, -0.8327710628509521, 4.028891086578369, 0.5961654782295227, 0.5700181722640991, 0.12874478101730347, 0.5616724491119385, 0.5801087021827698, 0.2405572235584259, -0.7751837372779846, 0.4597906172275543, -0.9530414938926697, 0.5598935484886169, -0.5537042617797852, 0.5891786217689514, 0.3248271644115448, 0.24404700100421906, 0.797946035861969, -0.00011342869402142242, -0.08503877371549606, 0.09305070340633392, -0.19986848533153534, -0.8092024922370911, 0.4482918977737427, -0.47312214970588684, -0.341280996799469, 0.31446921825408936, 0.34405583143234253, 0.06648868322372437, -0.7346940636634827, -0.04690594971179962, -0.5045186877250671, -1.2975963354110718, -0.1126304566860199, 0.44160348176956177, -0.21764659881591797, -0.3733925521373749, 0.47945839166641235, -0.1815033257007599, 0.14720000326633453, -0.20393621921539307, -0.23446616530418396, 0.09236674755811691, -1.0150710344314575, 0.0586797259747982, -0.6647132039070129, 0.45544692873954773, 0.5387125015258789, 0.09310074895620346, 0.4193197190761566, 0.7105308175086975, -1.1251683235168457, 0.4399855136871338, -0.26588311791419983, -0.06942497193813324, -0.48426035046577454, -1.281888484954834, -0.3401632010936737, -0.08034943789243698, -0.807344377040863, -0.6055611371994019, -0.6002311706542969, 0.7345796227455139, -0.502356231212616, -0.8097677230834961, 1.0699734687805176, -0.9096828103065491, 0.6373544335365295, 0.3614829480648041, 0.5464632511138916, -0.6165975332260132, 0.0430973656475544, -0.3310491740703583, -0.5211503505706787, -0.2609468102455139, -0.4653359651565552, 0.42693114280700684, 0.4978911876678467, 0.11284973472356796, 0.17599539458751678, -0.6490710973739624, -0.4121072590351105, -0.36084452271461487, -0.010150015354156494, -0.6293305158615112, 0.21673816442489624, -0.20503494143486023, 0.6469926834106445, 0.4378625750541687, -0.5664867162704468, 0.5660427808761597, 0.46398353576660156, 0.3248935043811798, 0.6340153813362122, -0.6693227291107178, -0.26430803537368774, -0.17356529831886292 ]
Evolution of Elliptical Galaxies: The Multiphase Model
We present a multiphase model for the evolution of elliptical galaxies. Diffuse gas, molecular clouds, stars and remnants are taken into account. Cloud--cloud collisions and stimulated processes are the main causes of star formation. The occurrence of winds driven by Supernovae is considered, and the evolution of the system is computed also after the first wind, allowing for further star formation from the restored gas. The evolution of the abundances of 15 elements or isotopes is followed with detailed stellar nucleosynthesis. Stellar lifetimes are taken into account and a new IMF has been adopted. The gas removal due to the Supernovae explosions depends on the galactic mass and the presence of dark matter; the subsequent wind episodes are crucial to the intergalactic gas enrichment. Good agreement is obtained for current SNs rates, Star Formation Rate and gas masses when compared to the available data.
Federico Ferrini, Bianca Maria Poggianti
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211003
astro-ph/9211004
[ -0.11804620176553726, 0.494905024766922, 0.6202667355537415, 0.30522000789642334, -0.4648853838443756, -0.6551623344421387, -0.6045586466789246, 0.14153137803077698, -0.4169131815433502, 1.5677874088287354, 0.3018195331096649, -0.32735639810562134, 0.0032287759240716696, -0.5428807139396667, -0.4054091274738312, -0.12382225692272186, 0.0007173599442467093, -0.6221698522567749, -1.2923835515975952, -0.145218625664711, 0.1394328624010086, -0.04258895665407181, -1.151336908340454, -0.42974379658699036, -0.19338713586330414, 0.9666579961776733, 0.7892128229141235, 0.4267091751098633, 1.1962101459503174, 0.2442002296447754, 0.3145202696323395, -0.37900254130363464, -0.009185523726046085, -0.9950902462005615, -0.10186245292425156, 0.0740833654999733, 0.540515661239624, -0.48729342222213745, 0.6590087413787842, -0.3249415159225464, 1.1282697916030884, 0.2647501230239868, 0.6091023683547974, -0.5857547521591187, -0.44830211997032166, -0.21594052016735077, 0.13300195336341858, 0.5085988640785217, 0.36475324630737305, -0.42791786789894104, -0.1295318752527237, -0.10671063512563705, 0.07854573428630829, -1.0068544149398804, 0.10236988216638565, -0.8485775589942932, 0.038791052997112274, 0.26313531398773193, -0.2504018247127533, -0.5066643953323364, 0.47553589940071106, 0.7167051434516907, 0.632022500038147, -0.2781236469745636, -0.271266371011734, 1.4008220434188843, -0.015372495166957378, 0.61972576379776, -0.12786135077476501, -0.3557084798812866, -0.20866475999355316, 0.05791917070746422, 0.018979864194989204, 0.45285385847091675, -0.29494205117225647, 0.0715705156326294, -0.017185300588607788, -0.4941401779651642, -1.0064470767974854, 0.009353856556117535, -0.2172064632177353, 0.47718799114227295, 0.4692399203777313, 0.5943553447723389, -0.20259210467338562, -0.9359467029571533, 0.5814353227615356, 0.3992190957069397, 0.028374221175909042, 0.08771026879549026, 0.12212467193603516, 0.8028745651245117, -0.6310848593711853, -0.0334729440510273, 0.6794824004173279, 0.1436052769422531, -0.45144566893577576, -0.07532165944576263, 0.5385216474533081, 0.7598759531974792, 0.333163321018219, 1.2438714504241943, -0.6312383413314819, 0.27084627747535706, -0.29407843947410583, 0.6689178943634033, -0.034305643290281296, 0.05430982634425163, 0.005580654367804527, -0.443724662065506, -0.17364735901355743, 0.151547372341156, 0.6715005040168762, -0.04399178549647331, -0.06359501928091049, 0.8890619874000549, -0.44192662835121155, 0.35472744703292847, -0.0904640480875969, -0.06996836513280869, -0.1820603758096695, 0.5847165584564209, -0.030556201934814453, 0.24206507205963135, -0.36138081550598145, -0.4543900191783905, 0.4801650047302246, 0.24218371510505676, -0.7230672240257263, 0.1349799484014511, -0.08011958748102188, -0.2856607735157013, -0.376524418592453, 0.32298901677131653, -0.2740795612335205, 0.25772732496261597, 0.815772533416748, 0.29951393604278564, -0.16395486891269684, -0.8290439248085022, 0.12016570568084717, -0.6556874513626099, 0.17440727353096008, 1.2938590049743652, -0.9182121157646179, 0.5090413093566895, 0.06585091352462769, 0.13926494121551514, -0.38260528445243835, 0.0490148700773716, -0.23634126782417297, -0.3205782175064087, -0.0839185044169426, 0.5409780144691467, -0.21537847816944122, 0.2140314280986786, -0.9705826640129089, -0.4150855839252472, -0.8054457306861877, -0.5382567644119263, 0.7154625654220581, -0.32203930616378784, -0.004665861371904612, 0.8037535548210144, -0.4890790283679962, 0.16423097252845764, -0.7412883639335632, -0.4293893873691559, -0.15524107217788696, -0.0813397467136383, -0.262104332447052, 0.4674849212169647, 0.21901707351207733, 0.8014786243438721, 0.6595391035079956, 0.45218148827552795, 0.14954477548599243, -0.5435284972190857, -0.46855291724205017, 0.1264757364988327, 0.3286507725715637, -0.6634998321533203, 0.32493096590042114, 0.5356382131576538, 0.12335202842950821, 0.02289031818509102, -0.4092015326023102, 0.06344855576753616, 0.04551251232624054, 0.3057270348072052, -0.16221983730793, 0.6972566246986389, -1.1330209970474243, 0.5875245928764343, -0.6522757411003113, -0.15044936537742615, -0.14038193225860596, -0.026111522689461708, -0.2761284410953522, -1.0810174942016602, 0.7025312781333923, 0.13434383273124695, -0.8886747360229492, 0.551863968372345, -1.1337945461273193, -0.3288968503475189, 0.8743218779563904, 0.039752550423145294, -1.0823023319244385, -0.02624589391052723, 0.23906975984573364, 0.12261996418237686, -0.06303100287914276, 0.07866017520427704, 0.3736456632614136, 0.24611736834049225, -0.1863805502653122, 0.144054114818573, 0.5654864311218262, -0.08689229935407639, 0.5033801794052124, -0.03297475725412369, -0.30490511655807495, 1.2282459735870361, -0.1559915542602539, -0.7525554299354553, 0.051384277641773224, 0.3695155382156372, -0.16612277925014496, 0.2907635271549225, -0.03555293381214142, 0.220164954662323, -0.04276586323976517, 0.27155330777168274, 0.8355721235275269, 0.0756596252322197, 0.9725756049156189, 0.8817017078399658, 0.0858805701136589, -0.26130926609039307, 0.0390564426779747, 0.4290391504764557, -0.11317779868841171, 0.19013366103172302, -0.07717206329107285, 0.5358498096466064, -0.30986109375953674, 0.29094600677490234, -0.6044296622276306, 0.597313404083252, -0.8773149251937866, 0.9072515964508057, 0.4929070472717285, 0.08339421451091766, -0.7757169008255005, -0.03939616680145264, -0.02360457181930542, 0.6751657724380493, -0.029228894039988518, -0.39056530594825745, -0.16634570062160492, 0.3926527202129364, -0.11845216900110245, -0.5559552311897278, -0.44833508133888245, 0.2514663636684418, -0.5007799863815308, 0.13395993411540985, 0.9768307209014893, -0.17714658379554749, -1.2123619318008423, 0.0053170546889305115, -0.30508217215538025, -0.062135618180036545, 0.034461211413145065, 0.15234605967998505, -0.05967474356293678, -0.5198550820350647, 0.32528600096702576, -0.2563118040561676, 0.10738002508878708, 0.8391909003257751, -0.3904682695865631, -0.04490767791867256, -0.21769367158412933, 0.16213616728782654, -1.1841484308242798, -0.049041733145713806, -0.6035339832305908, 0.6592699885368347, -0.32953208684921265, -0.3654426634311676, -0.23438569903373718, -0.4716120958328247, 0.21481791138648987, 0.1459151953458786, 0.020830683410167694, 0.05982808768749237, 0.584862470626831, -0.3639863431453705, 0.9625757336616516, 0.24348141252994537, 0.14911915361881256, -0.6821202635765076, -0.6056261658668518, 0.7540181279182434, -0.23552305996418, -0.5230225920677185, 0.5480791926383972, 0.020899483934044838, -0.5839207768440247, 0.4550580382347107, -0.12874887883663177, 0.4266030788421631, 0.2130616158246994, 0.8726994395256042, 0.6159926056861877, 0.06440673768520355, 0.22842180728912354, -0.212937131524086, -0.592704176902771, -0.5426660776138306, 0.35344862937927246, -0.26715508103370667, -0.3653852641582489, 1.0503098964691162, 0.36983349919319153, -0.08065404742956161, 0.888206422328949, -0.6218951940536499, -0.603735625743866, -0.026853663846850395, -0.15281683206558228, 0.350137859582901, 0.4135836064815521, -0.36652833223342896, -0.5392629504203796, -0.25851523876190186, -0.20748640596866608, 0.688413143157959, 0.46214255690574646, -0.7184683084487915, -0.09427714347839355, 0.4342321753501892, -0.4352834224700928, -0.43068328499794006, 1.1655272245407104, -0.3480270504951477, -0.19336244463920593, -0.13118477165699005, -0.5904767513275146, -0.023073820397257805, 0.37230953574180603, 0.3327782452106476, 0.10885871946811676, 0.5510346293449402, -0.2934633791446686, -0.40620291233062744, -0.34160783886909485, 0.05205407366156578, -0.33035969734191895, 0.30775949358940125, 0.1140207052230835, -0.04983402043581009, -0.6309874653816223, 0.0827684998512268, 0.04318736121058464, -0.33360791206359863, 0.06896143406629562, -0.6287338137626648, 0.09909670799970627, -0.172845721244812, -0.548165500164032, -0.4259531795978546, -0.3448961675167084, 0.24849168956279755, 0.7771362662315369, 0.6107398271560669, 0.6063283085823059, 0.39661362767219543, -0.4748728573322296, -0.6124692559242249, -0.09277591109275818, 0.42738282680511475, 0.2163437008857727, 0.2022097110748291, 0.10272173583507538, 0.5836250185966492, -0.08720650523900986, -0.9493213295936584, -0.803377628326416, -1.1388789415359497, -0.2001381814479828, -1.2463551759719849, -0.18928422033786774, 0.36947184801101685, 0.2809736430644989, 0.4088553190231323, -0.4597899615764618, -0.048518817871809006, -0.19198274612426758, -0.8363717198371887, 0.21438348293304443, -0.011059139855206013, -0.32783520221710205, 0.8045946359634399, -0.45590323209762573, 0.20716531574726105, -0.28475186228752136, 0.3765784800052643, 0.8196203708648682, -0.6029269695281982, -0.1698383241891861, 0.07602894306182861, 1.168182611465454, 0.3491598665714264, -0.09650494158267975, 0.962756872177124, 0.27323296666145325, 0.12447413802146912, -0.5539287328720093, 0.3706512153148651, 0.7841154932975769, 1.0496164560317993, -0.5171067714691162, -0.9931718707084656, 0.4529254138469696, -0.7371710538864136, -0.19702427089214325, 0.3790918290615082, -0.7969455122947693, -0.680240273475647, -0.789410412311554, 0.01918884925544262, -0.0759066715836525, -0.10245824605226517, 0.9528535008430481, -0.1971558928489685, 0.7439903020858765, -0.2941192090511322, -0.2342899590730667, 1.12336003780365, -0.0432051382958889, -0.3382774591445923, 0.43743160367012024, 0.11218193173408508, -0.3733370900154114, 0.48368117213249207, -0.32722628116607666, -0.9242232441902161, -0.8478899002075195, -0.2520528733730316, 0.4789987802505493, -0.760956346988678, -0.7208915948867798, 0.2636239528656006, -0.13462014496326447, -0.3056604564189911, 0.8669283390045166, -0.4822148084640503, -0.2881793677806854, 0.40247952938079834, -0.030984796583652496, -1.3430331945419312, -0.8242318630218506, -0.3156181871891022, -0.29168611764907837, 0.585417628288269, 0.4730885922908783, -0.17832234501838684, 0.28251296281814575, 0.537034273147583, -0.39371201395988464, 0.4484855532646179, 0.42649292945861816, 0.10605688393115997, 0.534309446811676, -0.4538537263870239, 0.028907407075166702, -0.6178128719329834, -0.16983067989349365, 0.9156278371810913, -0.48960477113723755, -0.0497111901640892, -0.5377214550971985, -0.15800851583480835, -0.3149973452091217, -0.3557809591293335, -0.4995741546154022, 0.4984487295150757, -0.7613429427146912, -0.2930465042591095, -0.07157082855701447, -0.41445088386535645, -0.3258420526981354, -0.16452063620090485, 0.19876830279827118, -0.8474437594413757, -0.07455983012914658, 0.11807670444250107, -0.8364381790161133, 0.595474898815155, -1.2802492380142212, 0.5676234364509583, -0.0689004436135292, -0.4577499032020569, -0.7287330031394958, -0.3441618084907532, -0.07269315421581268, -0.10686114430427551, -0.26962217688560486, 0.681429922580719, -0.4592207670211792, -0.19491338729858398, 0.3346914052963257, 0.9405973553657532, -0.2848280668258667, -0.8113973140716553, -0.13652348518371582, 0.40163785219192505, -0.13630802929401398, -0.8641635775566101, -0.06831417977809906, 0.8278126120567322, -0.1134260892868042, 0.7690765261650085, -0.14500457048416138, -1.2481333017349243, 0.39223721623420715, -0.8568582534790039, 0.5889008045196533, -0.8734397292137146, -0.10011697560548782, -0.22118741273880005, -0.9480599164962769, -0.08457759022712708, 0.1438179761171341, 0.23787832260131836, -1.0913687944412231, -0.2367861121892929, -0.13562916219234467, 0.7924038171768188, -0.2590062916278839, 0.035393789410591125, -0.28441348671913147, 0.180934876203537, -1.2789260149002075, 0.9021351337432861, 0.1280960738658905, -0.09952261298894882, 0.0026860644575208426, 0.5513743758201599, -0.5064921379089355, 0.8510239124298096, 0.28393805027008057, 0.014109835028648376, -0.2857329249382019, 0.27414387464523315, 0.24955765902996063, 0.5758563876152039, -0.5041643977165222, 0.3453356623649597, -0.7588303089141846, 0.24363069236278534, -0.8657738566398621, 0.2720619738101959, -0.07484588772058487, -0.05315842106938362, 1.0223824977874756, -0.300255686044693, 0.4199804663658142, 0.9593303203582764, 0.02771518938243389, 0.3302920162677765, 0.7361416220664978, -0.47774893045425415, -0.34063521027565, -0.7506831884384155, -0.7611832022666931, 0.4230797290802002, 0.6691275238990784, -0.2318863868713379, -0.4205532371997833, 0.1872165948152542, -0.5057317018508911, -0.7485354542732239, 0.5252947807312012, 0.10774800926446915, -0.15568120777606964, 0.749959409236908, -0.3151147961616516, -0.4766274690628052, 0.09985850006341934, 0.10698650777339935, 0.6439912915229797, 0.12653429806232452, 0.011366661638021469, -0.24429744482040405, -0.32260629534721375, -0.18637578189373016, -1.021950602531433, 0.09361180663108826, 0.3543342649936676, -0.4401721954345703, 1.1429991722106934, 0.08686870336532593, -0.5194340348243713, -0.11076483130455017, -0.5981004238128662, 0.8386865258216858, -0.09142350405454636, 0.3703656494617462, 0.1635553538799286, 0.09034668654203415, 0.185029074549675, -0.5026994943618774, -0.6793187856674194, -0.34438011050224304, 0.5999799966812134, -0.7359939217567444, -0.18969976902008057, 0.3536185324192047, 0.17133007943630219, -0.4080718457698822, 0.06744634360074997, -0.9901314377784729, -0.25614750385284424, -0.08643548935651779, -0.42096441984176636, -0.7328188419342041, -0.1105993315577507, -0.4212843179702759, 0.43212616443634033, 0.715361475944519, 0.6984525918960571, -0.02592521347105503, 0.06180800497531891, 0.38047167658805847, -0.4587414562702179, 0.15525931119918823, 1.3504935503005981, 0.488719642162323, -0.6105496287345886, -0.6459871530532837, -0.2380346953868866, -0.6180469393730164, 0.21116869151592255, 0.9451321959495544, 0.29112446308135986, 0.3753040134906769, 0.2629929482936859, -0.29757508635520935, 0.28839436173439026, 0.6313037276268005, 0.439831405878067, 0.38753512501716614, -0.5127493143081665, -0.836552619934082, -0.332174152135849, -0.322492778301239, -0.09917834401130676, 0.9758157134056091, 0.22964157164096832, 0.015349236316978931, -0.9046132564544678, -0.4365368187427521, 0.1997612565755844, -0.4802718758583069, -0.18632327020168304, -0.9440380930900574, -0.8193999528884888, -0.9178864359855652, -0.6794910430908203, 0.6295374035835266, 0.7389605641365051, -0.5403189659118652, 0.7479716539382935, 0.0002322728541912511, 0.17981615662574768, 0.4418306350708008, 0.8258448839187622, -0.12565326690673828, -0.6010069847106934, -0.4208899140357971, -0.114386186003685, -0.1365741789340973, -1.2180947065353394, -0.40995699167251587, -0.37771549820899963, 0.07943839579820633, 0.8941946625709534, -0.6818713545799255, 0.5505134463310242, -0.98007732629776, -0.6091372966766357, 0.5225154757499695, 0.09486336261034012, -0.8811666965484619, 0.8589767813682556, -0.5345080494880676, 1.1888597011566162, -0.08201301842927933, -0.4613538682460785, -0.21515460312366486, 0.04324673116207123, -1.095592737197876, 0.6494566798210144, 0.3696134388446808, 0.8274197578430176, 0.8473314642906189, -0.5483731031417847, 0.4120124578475952, 0.6599708199501038, -0.7578439116477966, 0.3757232427597046, -0.5557783842086792, 0.705693781375885, -0.1757775843143463, 0.5898036956787109, 0.001884560682810843, 0.5172367095947266, -0.19499489665031433, 0.3399101793766022, -0.41801774501800537, -0.09285351634025574, 0.20558063685894012, 0.3143933117389679, -0.02032247930765152, -0.23029719293117523, 0.9159902334213257, -0.4574762284755707, 0.3175501823425293, 0.494792103767395, 0.11328437924385071, -0.016925262287259102, -0.2478959560394287, 0.07965220510959625, -0.3348690867424011, -0.14145147800445557, -0.9161601662635803, 0.4321068227291107, 0.044889576733112335, -0.24244274199008942, 0.558457612991333, 0.15481799840927124, -1.0145275592803955, 0.3606947660446167, -0.4861740171909332, -0.9254661202430725, -0.0034510332625359297, -0.1984201967716217, 0.07175668329000473, 0.33959639072418213, 0.14613376557826996, 0.0006407576147466898, 0.0019117007032036781, 0.38511785864830017, 0.7279452085494995, 0.17987056076526642, -0.4919961094856262, 0.4452537000179291, -0.7872588038444519, -0.27559372782707214, -0.6778033375740051, 0.32729533314704895, -1.0621949434280396, -0.7704702615737915, -0.23309889435768127, 0.2933337688446045, 0.007242369931191206, -0.5055007934570312, -0.45182347297668457, -0.23312917351722717, 0.5061681866645813, -0.5412473678588867, -0.48673155903816223, 0.015913937240839005, -0.8779969811439514, 0.20365361869335175, -0.06653160601854324, -0.1441083699464798, 0.4428096115589142, -0.2469981610774994, 0.8352937698364258, 0.27251139283180237, -0.3334767818450928, 1.2638742923736572, 0.2589365243911743, -0.3659607768058777, 0.6157045364379883, 0.06946918368339539, 0.42042121291160583, 0.3853149712085724, -0.7461897730827332, 0.38865193724632263, 0.5256236791610718, 0.08577516674995422, 0.6143536567687988, -0.44951096177101135, -0.14601285755634308, 0.4797402620315552, -0.2912122905254364, 0.3611637353897095, 0.6192843914031982, -0.058055371046066284, -0.3190365135669708, 0.3081128001213074, -0.15917493402957916, 0.19572782516479492, -0.3083508312702179, 0.24593786895275116, -0.13704505562782288, -0.07819493114948273, -0.19725902378559113, -0.5114232897758484, -0.4400227963924408, 0.48570236563682556, -0.634643018245697, -0.7878623604774475, -0.17366959154605865, 0.060875147581100464, 0.3226628601551056, 0.3628615438938141, -0.30462247133255005, 0.2900673747062683, 0.6911505460739136, -0.29548290371894836, -0.47624510526657104, 0.5354242324829102, 0.24142961204051971, 0.389112263917923, 1.0044132471084595, 0.7980256080627441, -0.1932792365550995, 0.6903397440910339, -0.04074924439191818, -0.7657818794250488, 0.28469353914260864, 0.37792089581489563, -0.7508329153060913, -0.11181134730577469, -0.12930473685264587, -0.31349778175354004, -0.2004653960466385, -0.5741816163063049, -0.019121041521430016, -0.3874076306819916, -0.10809466242790222, 0.6386231184005737, -0.38241103291511536, -0.032703373581171036, 0.06906472146511078, 0.5071965456008911, 0.3303731679916382, 0.823625385761261, 0.6620345115661621, -0.666823148727417, 1.0738978385925293, 0.628836452960968, 0.2788406312465668, 0.37417230010032654, -0.5630626678466797, -0.4121573567390442, 0.4741094410419464, 0.129390686750412, -0.5574179291725159, 1.4112262725830078, -0.51813143491745, -0.10977885872125626, -0.49128779768943787, -0.06174417585134506, -0.012604257091879845, -0.20486460626125336, 0.3314337432384491, -0.12619130313396454, -0.23947745561599731, 0.0004883755464106798, 0.43640437722206116, 0.734707236289978, -0.05109817907214165, -0.9833653569221497, 0.2846093475818634, -0.3792351186275482, -0.10387052595615387, -0.6173610091209412, 0.6120594143867493, 0.050763651728630066, -0.0608808733522892, -0.4052022099494934, -0.6255950927734375, -0.4858287274837494, -0.6488174796104431, -0.0883769541978836, -0.5076658129692078, -0.08919890224933624, 0.4302253723144531, 0.3762778639793396, 0.07639209181070328, -0.6136954426765442, -0.269103080034256, 0.09194863587617874, 1.091081976890564, -0.35252493619918823, 0.29889753460884094, -0.061899248510599136, 0.7277501225471497, -1.0455002784729004, 0.46528613567352295, 0.7456067204475403, -0.2959853708744049, 1.2667311429977417, 0.18609628081321716, 0.21375641226768494, -0.18933814764022827, -0.040779631584882736, 0.03641044721007347, 0.794577956199646, 0.3687800467014313, 0.16700923442840576, -0.3701167702674866, 0.38835054636001587, -1.2191689014434814, -0.3080032169818878, -0.005936346482485533, 0.6050294041633606, 0.7687300443649292, -0.21633775532245636, -0.05841296911239624, -0.7477243542671204, 4.1204752922058105, 0.7208171486854553, 0.14913034439086914, -0.3224298357963562, 0.7480495572090149, 0.588582456111908, 0.4933181405067444, -1.2510322332382202, 0.2843005359172821, 0.2343815565109253, 0.16785413026809692, -0.2805718183517456, 0.8474834561347961, 0.35552680492401123, 0.4985409677028656, 0.42046764492988586, -0.14619974792003632, -0.830628514289856, 0.3808390498161316, -0.7115079164505005, -1.4180407524108887, 0.3361220061779022, 0.15888957679271698, 0.08312825113534927, 0.5848127007484436, 0.2380232959985733, -0.06338027864694595, -0.1473606675863266, -0.3249061405658722, -0.6418271660804749, -0.5919254422187805, -0.6692887544631958, 0.13805025815963745, -0.038944218307733536, -0.9719135761260986, 0.6304205656051636, -0.2392691820859909, -0.26056545972824097, 0.04152805730700493, -0.03695442155003548, -0.39965441823005676, -0.2648487091064453, -0.28675809502601624, -0.3234708607196808, -0.10558506101369858, 1.4012610912322998, 0.4099161922931671, 1.0427566766738892, 0.6738812327384949, -0.7400434613227844, 0.055419016629457474, 0.20140774548053741, 0.7901667952537537, -0.04498998820781708, -1.1396000385284424, -0.3279555141925812, 0.14148785173892975, -0.19649504125118256, -0.010873131453990936, 0.18686020374298096, 1.0164765119552612, -0.24802662432193756, -0.08079399168491364, 0.3145175874233246, -0.2930191159248352, 0.3387223482131958, 0.14947064220905304, -0.021203789860010147, 0.10142353177070618, 0.20163588225841522, -0.5185534954071045, -0.5753571391105652, -0.2150554358959198, -0.47734662890434265, -0.10762546211481094, -0.07572295516729355, 0.5071447491645813, 0.1763029396533966, 0.1619422733783722, 0.23890085518360138, -0.19181285798549652, -0.1758672297000885, -0.8157058358192444, 0.7163379788398743, 0.19080233573913574, 0.8791955709457397, -0.13273143768310547, -0.28753694891929626, 0.10503319650888443, 0.7626132965087891, -0.2930944263935089, 0.37728989124298096, -0.11192227154970169, 0.454334020614624, -0.35941898822784424 ]
Gravitational Radiation from Colliding Vacuum Bubbles: Envelope Approximation to Many-Bubble Collisions
We introduce an approximation to calculate the gravitational radiation produced by the collision of true-vacuum bubbles that is simple enough to allow the simulation of a phase transition by the collision of hundreds of bubbles. This ``envelope approximation'' neglects the complicated ``overlap'' regions of colliding bubbles and follows only the evolution of the bubble walls. The approximation accurately reproduces previous results for the gravitational radiation from the collision of two scalar-field vacuum bubbles. Using a bubble nucleation rate given by $\Gamma = \Gamma_0 e^{\beta t}$, we simulate a phase transition by colliding 20 to 200 bubbles; the fraction of vacuum energy released into gravity waves is $E_{\rm GW}/E_{\rm vac} = 0.06(H/\beta)^2$ and the peak of the spectrum occurs at $\omega_{\rm max}=1.6\beta$ ($H^2=8\pi G\rho /3$ is the Hubble constant associated with the false-vacuum phase). The spectrum is very similar to that in the two-bubble case, except that the efficiency of gravity-wave generation is about five times higher, presumably due to the fact that a given bubble collides with many others. Finally, we consider two further ``statistical'' approximations, where the gravitational radiation is computed as an incoherent sum over individual bubbles weighted by the distribution of bubble sizes. These approximations provide reasonable estimates of the gravitational-wave spectrum with far less computation.
Arthur Kosowsky and Michael S. Turner
astro-ph hep-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211004
astro-ph/9211005
[ -0.03505400940775871, 0.42333751916885376, 0.4980788826942444, -0.11221820116043091, -0.275997519493103, 0.1006167009472847, -0.11098561435937881, 0.1991916298866272, -0.5197474956512451, 1.253165364265442, 0.42597389221191406, 0.32453233003616333, -0.6881935596466064, -1.3214949369430542, 0.28973588347435, 0.6033730506896973, 0.5010338425636292, 0.1029028668999672, -0.7455149292945862, 0.1667075902223587, 0.44506970047950745, -0.3578789234161377, -0.86856609582901, -0.8341462016105652, -0.21179981529712677, 0.40675684809684753, 0.6891751885414124, 0.13080710172653198, 0.9224892258644104, 1.2745304107666016, 0.5605548620223999, -0.47100532054901123, -0.08167418092489243, -0.41782352328300476, 0.011369884945452213, -0.5021021962165833, -0.20677508413791656, -0.7513251304626465, 1.139732003211975, -0.639918327331543, 0.7056258916854858, -0.12418177723884583, 0.09446440637111664, -0.1717623919248581, -0.5404458045959473, -0.04253964126110077, 0.05224122479557991, 0.5051407217979431, -0.05877327546477318, -0.8547060489654541, 0.06504702568054199, -0.32077351212501526, 0.5000233054161072, -0.8274381160736084, -0.3530636429786682, -0.09703488647937775, -0.07771651446819305, -0.23909738659858704, -0.34212708473205566, 0.6779102683067322, 0.017329035326838493, -0.13856962323188782, 0.19769535958766937, -0.4574540853500366, -0.6268908977508545, 1.1328098773956299, -0.47658252716064453, 1.0232667922973633, 0.04262585937976837, -0.5564687252044678, 0.25793445110321045, 0.29852136969566345, -0.014212474226951599, 0.653705358505249, -0.5839805603027344, 0.3382521867752075, -0.7118484377861023, -0.6301390528678894, -0.9953022599220276, 0.16138099133968353, -0.16993239521980286, -0.4805065393447876, -0.2190609574317932, 1.1687648296356201, -0.18262554705142975, -0.1217893734574318, -0.26029708981513977, -0.6232615113258362, 0.34695595502853394, -0.5003358125686646, 0.053283896297216415, 0.3439977169036865, -0.8200779557228088, -0.010521144606173038, 0.10354584455490112, 0.6721993684768677, -0.37850409746170044, -0.1376895159482956, -0.206633061170578, 0.3164239227771759, -0.12550237774848938, 0.9617924690246582, -0.5410676598548889, -0.28440722823143005, -0.5288406610488892, 0.727860152721405, 0.06516759097576141, 0.7420904636383057, 0.1956561654806137, -1.1928240060806274, 0.5458305478096008, 0.25535741448402405, 0.7366126179695129, 0.42279279232025146, -0.5185776352882385, 0.09999807178974152, -0.5478557348251343, -0.023088429123163223, -0.49671828746795654, -0.6532800793647766, 0.11935251206159592, 0.4774223566055298, 0.1286643147468567, 0.4602896571159363, -0.5532628893852234, 0.30717626214027405, 0.10527019202709198, 0.5123935341835022, -0.24310441315174103, 0.37242087721824646, 1.08157479763031, -0.10779404640197754, 0.10781661421060562, 0.08599498867988586, -0.11347372084856033, 0.6395235657691956, 0.6879988312721252, 0.6113750338554382, -0.010978881269693375, -0.6570528149604797, 0.378038227558136, -0.7250646352767944, 0.7689195871353149, 0.7982807755470276, -0.9357829093933105, 1.1857688426971436, 0.7736402153968811, -0.6161118149757385, -0.142535001039505, -0.5311284065246582, -0.043428968638181686, -0.6844926476478577, -0.29495012760162354, 0.3878953754901886, 0.2931869328022003, -0.3070157468318939, -0.4177643060684204, 0.3002145290374756, -0.14234960079193115, 0.38220641016960144, 1.2133151292800903, 0.6931161880493164, 0.35574832558631897, 1.298542857170105, -0.01558320689946413, 0.04864395037293434, -0.6304372549057007, -1.1970959901809692, -0.04417555406689644, 0.23880186676979065, -0.4126213490962982, 0.5317531228065491, 0.42062586545944214, 0.4420906603336334, 1.1376725435256958, 0.8151645660400391, -0.10181095451116562, -0.1980000138282776, -0.4849150776863098, 0.08303669840097427, -0.43826428055763245, -0.20248083770275116, 0.25329193472862244, 0.7129107117652893, 0.24482792615890503, 0.14109858870506287, 0.7560595273971558, 0.18069671094417572, -0.06506925076246262, -0.3420250713825226, -0.5687904953956604, -0.070664182305336, -0.8117998242378235, 1.3225433826446533, -0.31894049048423767, -0.08513401448726654, -0.9135358333587646, -0.4472152292728424, -0.29846614599227905, -0.3221965730190277, 0.31084582209587097, 0.47747308015823364, -0.6337193846702576, 0.7306177616119385, -1.044464111328125, -0.6975494027137756, 0.9423863887786865, -0.04938192665576935, 0.2538694143295288, -0.7947859168052673, 0.7095476984977722, 0.20214378833770752, 0.0807972326874733, 0.06334556639194489, 0.1264396607875824, 0.40954557061195374, 0.02630556933581829, -0.033718179911375046, 0.3018895983695984, 0.5341151356697083, 0.5251421928405762, 0.07885224372148514, -0.5031411647796631, 1.4817845821380615, 0.18940676748752594, -0.2867490351200104, -0.31418997049331665, 0.6744549870491028, -0.2914024591445923, 0.6217467188835144, -0.022809110581874847, 0.4035588204860687, 0.13600729405879974, 0.38552045822143555, 0.07488289475440979, -0.4702613949775696, 1.0412006378173828, 1.1640245914459229, 0.7686643004417419, 0.5210965871810913, 0.004621059633791447, 0.5129936933517456, 0.019300615414977074, 0.3444783687591553, 0.05337640270590782, 0.7846100926399231, 0.40248122811317444, -0.22476816177368164, -0.24127864837646484, 0.7746893167495728, -0.8692474365234375, 0.4636583626270294, -0.09326823800802231, 0.2433086782693863, -1.1830472946166992, 0.24552638828754425, 0.5602924823760986, -0.5195391774177551, 0.35593122243881226, -0.5733596682548523, -0.8671858310699463, 0.3711134195327759, -0.15247461199760437, -0.535828173160553, 0.9601246118545532, 0.14564889669418335, -1.0053716897964478, -0.6367339491844177, 0.7725846767425537, -0.5112937092781067, -0.957728385925293, 0.045375432819128036, -0.9775384664535522, 0.11203865706920624, -0.2797265946865082, -0.37269511818885803, -0.014276048168540001, 0.5100393295288086, 0.48637983202934265, -0.669790506362915, 0.3631971776485443, -0.02533734403550625, -0.1831430047750473, 0.051951196044683456, -0.36975347995758057, 0.26413342356681824, -0.6461755037307739, 0.193000927567482, -1.2654403448104858, 0.14774300158023834, -0.3763912618160248, -0.6901789307594299, 0.2920539081096649, -0.05083074793219566, 0.05855342000722885, 1.0773298740386963, -0.11877930164337158, -0.3808823823928833, -0.22457925975322723, -0.8002471923828125, 0.8321607112884521, 0.2455337643623352, -0.3670121133327484, -0.1312209516763687, -0.3381888270378113, 0.4792306125164032, -0.11907844990491867, -0.0066507188603281975, 0.4003713130950928, -0.6211329102516174, -0.9028852581977844, 0.28023773431777954, -0.21112225949764252, 0.26228711009025574, -0.5823127627372742, 0.8291281461715698, 0.8455960154533386, 0.21188297867774963, 0.8856357932090759, -0.432662695646286, 0.057566914707422256, -0.02432478591799736, 0.3237011432647705, -0.43002843856811523, 0.3624453544616699, 0.570663571357727, 0.6092191934585571, 0.00798815954476595, 0.6482529640197754, -1.103281855583191, -0.6513487696647644, -0.09399072080850601, 0.5467100143432617, -0.1732226312160492, 0.02937246859073639, 0.0940425917506218, 0.10507604479789734, -0.44441384077072144, -0.6343642473220825, 0.06277895718812943, 0.8533787727355957, -0.5316886305809021, -0.038585953414440155, 0.36366912722587585, 0.03968126326799393, -0.37627795338630676, -0.10076817870140076, -0.5361729264259338, -0.57267826795578, 0.623210072517395, -0.2041449248790741, -0.2761372923851013, 0.7059866189956665, 0.4914162755012512, -0.09677864611148834, 0.049229945987463, -0.36029934883117676, -0.38955357670783997, -0.22696636617183685, 0.06859758496284485, -0.3534240424633026, 0.3866146504878998, 0.5758094191551208, -0.6736351251602173, -0.6093482375144958, -0.08070747554302216, 0.1964704841375351, 0.11076454818248749, 0.7526601552963257, 0.150343120098114, 0.6973088383674622, 0.01642473042011261, -0.19383521378040314, -0.2840411067008972, -0.009174779057502747, 0.5553128123283386, 1.319266676902771, -0.0713396817445755, 0.7613058090209961, -0.22488437592983246, -0.6701197624206543, -0.3476168215274811, 0.3839394450187683, -0.2321527898311615, 0.005530426744371653, 0.28277766704559326, -0.22757552564144135, -0.3694455325603485, -0.08798103779554367, -0.30294856429100037, -0.501144528388977, -1.303845763206482, 0.4442543387413025, -0.3138214945793152, -0.16530287265777588, -0.3947279453277588, 0.3401592969894409, 0.35003286600112915, 0.10990233719348907, 0.14070741832256317, -0.30663248896598816, -0.7861979007720947, -0.09485237300395966, 0.09599345177412033, -0.35872042179107666, 0.3814362585544586, -0.11030110716819763, 0.3507513403892517, 0.10115981101989746, 0.11260400712490082, -0.08949582278728485, 0.29479920864105225, -0.019351638853549957, 0.18434637784957886, 0.2433701604604721, 0.727937638759613, 0.1001645103096962, 0.3196093738079071, 0.1448279768228531, -0.11865682899951935, -0.0882873386144638, -0.16320742666721344, 0.8937111496925354, 0.8191724419593811, 0.5641470551490784, -0.2098463773727417, 0.045528706163167953, -0.742933988571167, 0.285161554813385, 0.23066970705986023, -0.7972507476806641, -0.6818817853927612, -0.3171088397502899, 0.5250958800315857, 0.12095613032579422, -0.36295631527900696, 0.4056830108165741, 1.0306769609451294, 0.8525845408439636, 0.2517564594745636, -0.18050438165664673, 0.7722227573394775, -0.019785316661000252, 0.8339986801147461, 0.8612386584281921, 0.12234317511320114, 0.1680133193731308, 0.15046916902065277, -0.011351531371474266, -0.5673515200614929, -0.1635204553604126, -0.20906388759613037, 1.3784387111663818, -0.5031092166900635, -0.458227276802063, 0.6653205156326294, 0.38259726762771606, -0.3675991892814636, 0.6101654767990112, -0.03887192904949188, -0.16924014687538147, 0.005301980301737785, -0.5268633365631104, -0.35378578305244446, -0.26183852553367615, 0.29874664545059204, -0.695221483707428, 0.7309129238128662, 0.7020660042762756, -0.3784709870815277, 0.38219282031059265, -0.13952752947807312, 0.24736246466636658, 0.5905483365058899, 0.2889857292175293, -0.47499504685401917, -0.01342413667589426, -0.07409751415252686, -0.9057334065437317, -0.2000480741262436, -0.2321874499320984, 0.7213413715362549, 0.19719243049621582, 0.18084120750427246, 0.1085103377699852, -0.3616691827774048, 0.2638617157936096, -0.6951083540916443, -0.41417229175567627, 0.6307462453842163, -0.0130950678139925, 0.029347730800509453, -0.6657989025115967, -0.3719427287578583, -0.03663332760334015, 0.08612873405218124, -0.08270829916000366, 0.21161723136901855, 0.10871274769306183, -0.2379290610551834, -0.04445803910493851, -0.3382284641265869, -1.0423851013183594, 0.6556564569473267, -0.15455560386180878, -0.47247186303138733, 0.2400360256433487, -0.7874053120613098, 0.16541770100593567, 0.5567317605018616, -0.016207749024033546, 0.31747063994407654, -0.39082956314086914, 1.02681303024292, -0.37077945470809937, 0.966418445110321, 0.49368923902511597, -1.0748212337493896, 0.18389666080474854, 0.8880921006202698, 0.5843712091445923, -0.42166462540626526, 0.24086354672908783, 0.2406080663204193, 0.2969454228878021, 0.1906946301460266, -0.4291951656341553, -0.29777756333351135, 0.1726706176996231, -0.6773385405540466, 0.1235065907239914, -0.8724713325500488, -0.7963786125183105, -0.6564922332763672, -0.8741949200630188, -0.15311193466186523, 0.23875831067562103, 0.20251283049583435, -0.6756989359855652, 0.17384055256843567, -0.3606772720813751, -0.16552437841892242, -0.14526991546154022, -0.12954306602478027, -0.3767492175102234, -0.7129904627799988, -1.100119709968567, 1.0776389837265015, -0.050203658640384674, -0.056361936032772064, 0.17980608344078064, -0.1488143652677536, 0.3219867944717407, 0.26775288581848145, -0.016964321956038475, 0.3186757564544678, -0.2858145534992218, -0.42768657207489014, 0.3033010959625244, 0.4408243000507355, -0.4846101403236389, -0.09131617099046707, -0.5627689361572266, 0.9599183797836304, -0.2029195874929428, -0.718147873878479, 0.11784278601408005, -0.2910703718662262, 0.3804757595062256, 0.44997385144233704, 0.2368624359369278, 1.2161314487457275, -0.13024185597896576, 0.5454871654510498, 0.15128059685230255, -0.5428703427314758, 0.1986192911863327, -0.22806359827518463, -0.27121999859809875, -0.020001059398055077, 0.28288939595222473, 0.3784319758415222, -0.7174695730209351, -0.44878655672073364, -0.25723353028297424, -1.1708670854568481, 0.18448808789253235, 0.5098027586936951, 0.10102326422929764, 0.9428743124008179, -0.2692902088165283, 0.45504051446914673, 0.036865271627902985, -0.27926012873649597, 0.07218416035175323, -0.33799371123313904, 0.03455214947462082, -0.37302398681640625, 0.17513681948184967, -0.4997040629386902, -0.39487940073013306, 0.47630739212036133, 0.8162744641304016, -0.8143242001533508, 0.7480206489562988, 0.013253696262836456, -0.24287278950214386, -0.6592464447021484, 0.7355476021766663, -0.16260194778442383, 0.5994219779968262, 0.7233243584632874, 0.11140475422143936, -0.37798354029655457, 0.41176527738571167, 0.5440993309020996, -0.8643358945846558, -0.49509233236312866, 0.9650999307632446, -0.2688497006893158, 0.31617385149002075, -0.08277562260627747, -0.12334980070590973, -0.08010512590408325, -0.09541427344083786, -1.152079463005066, -0.12065155059099197, -0.4082830548286438, -0.545539379119873, -0.23305697739124298, -0.30182942748069763, -0.9688274264335632, 0.34983715415000916, 0.14842313528060913, -0.4642796814441681, 0.7289000749588013, -0.15056546032428741, 0.023125382140278816, -0.6463267207145691, -0.30051979422569275, 1.021036982536316, 0.6262577772140503, -0.6032376289367676, 0.3892439305782318, 0.33712825179100037, 0.012754938565194607, -0.9163121581077576, 0.9012898802757263, 0.026464788243174553, 0.037076033651828766, -0.5180914402008057, 0.48825526237487793, 0.26287391781806946, 0.318125456571579, 0.4364440441131592, -0.22888405621051788, -0.6491119861602783, -0.03560177981853485, 0.039489515125751495, -0.306700199842453, 0.22459980845451355, 0.8796672224998474, -0.5337666869163513, -0.1461934596300125, -0.39594724774360657, -0.48355215787887573, -0.28587591648101807, 0.18510976433753967, -0.4121842086315155, -0.555961549282074, -1.064774513244629, -0.6619728803634644, -0.8042751550674438, 0.18968191742897034, 0.896802544593811, -0.7287779450416565, 0.31941965222358704, -0.21460500359535217, 0.9072022438049316, 0.19568565487861633, 0.07634206861257553, 0.6954736709594727, -0.9541494846343994, -0.22864846885204315, -0.14869855344295502, -0.7028986215591431, -0.37938210368156433, -0.6051260232925415, -1.2527215480804443, 0.20421169698238373, 1.202038288116455, -0.03998987749218941, 0.6578053832054138, -0.23525139689445496, -1.0448932647705078, 0.9467254877090454, -0.06999552994966507, -0.3298904001712799, 0.44951707124710083, -0.3024669587612152, 1.4181636571884155, -0.0551566444337368, -0.122830830514431, 0.2711666524410248, -0.09253006428480148, -1.0268152952194214, 1.4215114116668701, -0.35420721769332886, 0.8176252245903015, -0.1514604538679123, -0.6997365355491638, -0.19586209952831268, 0.8388669490814209, -0.45961594581604004, 0.14283671975135803, 0.002856404520571232, 0.43296876549720764, -1.0107167959213257, -0.2681773602962494, 0.4106353521347046, 0.13036808371543884, -0.14180925488471985, -0.7510015964508057, -0.4764429032802582, 0.08301609754562378, 0.09581902623176575, -0.09399726241827011, -0.043646857142448425, -1.234336495399475, -0.2037338763475418, -0.020595114678144455, 0.40930086374282837, 0.5068130493164062, 0.17125239968299866, 0.2789187729358673, 0.10861174762248993, -0.04317215830087662, 0.20961427688598633, -0.24378423392772675, -0.835081160068512, 0.7288627028465271, 0.3880043923854828, 0.18089056015014648, 0.5871914625167847, -0.46374180912971497, -1.5487059354782104, -0.07970739156007767, -0.04322415590286255, -1.1953444480895996, -0.30117401480674744, 0.066989466547966, -0.6059755086898804, 1.0196596384048462, -0.8124509453773499, 0.008378739468753338, -0.13843192160129547, 1.34373939037323, 0.8504658937454224, -0.5309200882911682, -0.6329158544540405, -0.07770698517560959, -0.33884724974632263, 0.6560345888137817, -0.4292241334915161, 0.43425148725509644, -0.5116161704063416, -1.1739164590835571, -0.30827441811561584, 0.47571608424186707, -0.25004228949546814, -0.3323904275894165, 0.028373872861266136, -0.0895662009716034, -0.32134974002838135, -0.5757122039794922, -1.110037922859192, -0.22208768129348755, -0.4366162419319153, 0.47565746307373047, 0.023102911189198494, -0.11745338886976242, 0.10261189192533493, 0.04337696731090546, 0.3315602242946625, -0.2681443989276886, -0.43779459595680237, 0.45418041944503784, -0.34722262620925903, 0.018090976402163506, -0.20492765307426453, 1.445683240890503, -0.06335432827472687, 0.4903872013092041, -0.39474785327911377, 0.36303287744522095, 0.42477181553840637, 0.09519581496715546, 0.7189622521400452, 0.2482624650001526, -0.2810811996459961, 0.3074108064174652, -0.04208174720406532, -0.2213323563337326, 0.5244853496551514, 0.355960488319397, 0.010617250576615334, 0.8842381238937378, -0.7703309655189514, 0.04016062989830971, 0.3834763765335083, -0.1994808465242386, 0.37168172001838684, -0.513905942440033, -0.0860271006822586, -0.6612743735313416, 0.14162351191043854, 1.0881329774856567, -0.8891053795814514, -0.6733259558677673, -0.18791569769382477, 0.23949134349822998, 0.622349739074707, 0.0320574976503849, -0.2641920745372772, -0.28440481424331665, 0.25342002511024475, -0.15269573032855988, -0.45942577719688416, 0.5411750078201294, 0.29556459188461304, 0.06037174165248871, 1.0288407802581787, 0.06103185564279556, 0.18143241107463837, 0.3824783265590668, -0.2594967484474182, -0.6729759573936462, 0.01581168733537197, -0.33179837465286255, -0.14834628999233246, 0.13534045219421387, 0.5805423259735107, -0.6791065335273743, 0.1781349629163742, -0.37571120262145996, 0.4123532176017761, -0.5755029916763306, 0.09840665012598038, 0.3578132688999176, -1.1500985622406006, -0.4704577922821045, 0.25113412737846375, -0.11994467675685883, 0.054213106632232666, -0.20611102879047394, 0.3887513279914856, 0.08222124725580215, 0.8365602493286133, 1.3136887550354004, 0.23441942036151886, -0.507944643497467, -0.2340826541185379, -0.32284170389175415, 0.2598281502723694, 0.13363946974277496, -1.027186393737793, 0.3271994888782501, -0.5317907333374023, 0.13068635761737823, -0.33636850118637085, -0.6974143981933594, -0.13919268548488617, -0.5345973968505859, 0.660816490650177, 0.6737409830093384, -0.9584303498268127, 0.021055148914456367, 0.017771853134036064, 0.4295268654823303, 0.6264967322349548, -0.5472433567047119, 0.19724074006080627, -1.1451482772827148, 0.3366473913192749, -1.04598069190979, 0.3600277304649353, -0.18776798248291016, -0.6299733519554138, -0.8321855068206787, 0.013061593286693096, 0.7706843614578247, -0.8084768056869507, -0.5782994031906128, -0.7002667188644409, 0.4841856360435486, 0.3233495056629181, 0.07503177970647812, 0.25512778759002686, -0.004698788747191429, -0.7196769118309021, -0.7979452013969421, 0.5766963958740234, -0.3988191485404968, -0.07300090044736862, -0.02009924314916134, -0.07236461341381073, -0.6823607683181763, 0.7841230630874634, 0.8059234023094177, -1.3659279346466064, 0.3212839365005493, 0.4870928227901459, 0.7327156662940979, 0.040925074368715286, -0.8563833236694336, 0.26447147130966187, 0.14784657955169678, -0.00902747455984354, 1.1190507411956787, -0.6773281097412109, 0.24424998462200165, -0.895389974117279, -0.08279673010110855, -0.5513746738433838, 0.11186082661151886, 0.45492663979530334, -0.28462982177734375, -0.09005507826805115, -1.046591877937317, 3.890505790710449, 0.2425924688577652, 0.2239510864019394, -0.5678553581237793, 0.31038352847099304, 0.11858423799276352, 0.732524573802948, -0.037764787673950195, 0.44074225425720215, -0.7439296841621399, -0.2672039568424225, 0.1188526302576065, 0.9737538695335388, -0.6786507368087769, 0.9587454795837402, 0.9260502457618713, -0.2029363363981247, -0.7639651894569397, 0.6847242116928101, -0.8713679909706116, -1.381659984588623, -0.3618738651275635, 0.09629032015800476, 0.6522193551063538, 0.6770933866500854, 1.0709601640701294, -0.5435178279876709, -1.34843909740448, -1.0190612077713013, -0.4390820562839508, -0.1591441035270691, -0.5136586427688599, -0.24378550052642822, 0.2105710804462433, -0.5858011245727539, 0.1590132862329483, -0.12953349947929382, 0.2687145471572876, 0.5859209299087524, -0.20498816668987274, 0.06692221760749817, -1.9871052503585815, 0.6598023176193237, -0.1150117889046669, 0.0002357473422307521, 0.9202471375465393, 0.9897067546844482, 0.8683243989944458, 0.43449148535728455, 0.09238360077142715, 0.15083716809749603, -0.13193024694919586, -0.36255425214767456, 0.6935137510299683, -0.4387625753879547, -0.5083879232406616, 0.0334467850625515, -0.8189669847488403, 0.7187743782997131, -0.7044409513473511, 0.8726980686187744, -0.30688604712486267, -0.34064626693725586, 0.4993525445461273, 0.6810480356216431, 0.06066308170557022, -0.44132789969444275, -0.196455180644989, -0.31867802143096924, 0.03470318391919136, -0.6455527544021606, -0.48408615589141846, -0.7792781591415405, 0.17195077240467072, 0.16821147501468658, -0.12536455690860748, -0.19511142373085022, -0.11544185876846313, 0.13385909795761108, 0.04415077716112137, -0.6980005502700806, 0.45193326473236084, -0.26697784662246704, -0.02287048101425171, -0.15285082161426544, 0.817929208278656, -0.3238125741481781, 0.24746821820735931, -0.4123423397541046, 0.03517359867691994, -0.08110581338405609, 0.6845026612281799, -0.8251560926437378, 0.12968184053897858, -0.7224191427230835 ]
Centri`fugal' Force around a Black Hole
Besides having some very interesting perturbatively unstable orbits, it seems that for a Schwarzschild black hole, below $r=3M$, the force always increases inward with increasing angular momentum. Here this previously known result is derived with greater simplicity, and a similar analysis is performed for black holes with angular momentum and charge.
A.Y.Shiekh
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211005
astro-ph/9211006
[ 0.5606004595756531, 0.6273384094238281, 0.45299702882766724, -0.23801308870315552, -0.28831279277801514, -0.08558249473571777, -0.8851128220558167, 0.038265250623226166, 0.08186032623052597, 1.0820753574371338, -0.012530922889709473, 0.38621318340301514, -0.2509233355522156, -0.493728369474411, -0.43457287549972534, 0.15281960368156433, 0.15196265280246735, -0.22293326258659363, -1.5146527290344238, -0.5366294384002686, -0.10699944943189621, -0.24163275957107544, -1.3961209058761597, -0.5429566502571106, -0.40884166955947876, 0.5815746784210205, 0.37278494238853455, 1.2823309898376465, 0.669409453868866, 0.7650513052940369, 0.4051794111728668, -1.2010115385055542, 0.2156386375427246, -0.7833420634269714, -0.757582426071167, 0.16465677320957184, 0.6856651306152344, -0.3352193236351013, -0.3151681125164032, -0.4486671984195709, 1.060738205909729, -0.018382316455245018, 0.3134714663028717, -0.551903247833252, 0.049250148236751556, 0.19763830304145813, -0.27798178791999817, -0.044565703719854355, 0.7793194651603699, -0.8567655682563782, -0.02591993845999241, -0.2027127593755722, 0.338718980550766, -0.7444300055503845, -0.491592139005661, 0.1919025033712387, 0.20151498913764954, 0.41130077838897705, 0.5965195298194885, -0.12980902194976807, 0.46859514713287354, 0.37957754731178284, 0.4540081322193146, -1.1035993099212646, -0.29725560545921326, 0.8541593551635742, -0.2560890316963196, 0.23813463747501373, -0.24282431602478027, -0.3025605082511902, 0.0912722647190094, -0.08120911568403244, -0.6365802884101868, 0.33859267830848694, -1.1092002391815186, -0.017845164984464645, 0.5879908800125122, 0.07800458371639252, -0.14162254333496094, 0.3092067539691925, 0.6211463809013367, 0.17296035587787628, 0.41828653216362, 0.05582139268517494, 0.22741590440273285, -0.16588012874126434, 0.3298135995864868, 0.44491663575172424, -0.24512603878974915, 0.6173269152641296, 0.37961164116859436, 0.4144642651081085, -0.0539662130177021, -0.21200507879257202, 0.8393503427505493, 0.2026308923959732, -0.2996269166469574, 0.7136070728302002, 0.016316592693328857, 0.22280725836753845, 0.17935040593147278, 0.5588211417198181, -0.2777332663536072, 0.1879563331604004, -0.5220414996147156, 0.5584374070167542, 0.20305807888507843, 0.13497309386730194, 0.24556931853294373, -0.4510325789451599, 0.2367396354675293, 0.2505654990673065, 0.0838436633348465, 0.35260650515556335, 0.4509789049625397, 0.06733015179634094, -0.5007483959197998, 0.3286232352256775, -1.2398232221603394, -0.2692185938358307, -0.16001726686954498, 0.9345120191574097, 0.6890312433242798, 0.3308747708797455, 0.29510268568992615, -0.416914701461792, -0.3661981523036957, 0.19176828861236572, -0.7964601516723633, -0.09806478768587112, -0.13969381153583527, -0.9067055583000183, -0.8378534317016602, 1.0229122638702393, 0.49353641271591187, -0.06298824399709702, 0.4622310400009155, 0.594021737575531, -0.23764191567897797, -0.8280429244041443, 0.1657128781080246, -0.13356134295463562, -0.3908524513244629, 1.5103256702423096, -0.4185164272785187, 0.5023691058158875, -0.5401920676231384, -0.6971485614776611, -0.6808822154998779, 0.012621952220797539, 0.7051053047180176, -0.664824366569519, -0.6721697449684143, 0.2839149832725525, -1.105191946029663, -0.1135593056678772, -0.7660953402519226, -0.18253342807292938, 0.006988569162786007, -0.29332268238067627, 0.15847067534923553, -0.7362085580825806, 0.8247371912002563, 0.6994600892066956, -0.6631653904914856, 0.4260988235473633, -0.8965793251991272, -0.31184619665145874, 0.5168722867965698, 0.05911922827363014, -0.08943560719490051, -0.016733497381210327, 0.148982971906662, 0.23738709092140198, 0.4771175980567932, 0.15142209827899933, -0.39268481731414795, -0.6356139779090881, -0.01789230853319168, 0.4094409644603729, -0.19187012314796448, -0.13276632130146027, -0.20870892703533173, -0.16718733310699463, 0.06592939049005508, -0.07798518240451813, 0.09807848185300827, -0.4236099421977997, -0.003993562422692776, -0.3204963505268097, 0.04501393809914589, 0.9651303887367249, -0.3481866717338562, 0.784917414188385, -0.8211824893951416, -0.061299096792936325, -0.3100833594799042, 0.1214761808514595, 0.10968990623950958, 0.0416787788271904, 0.29364776611328125, 0.29836490750312805, -0.32373571395874023, 0.31365966796875, -0.4184100925922394, -0.3807033896446228, 0.42797109484672546, 0.6803842782974243, -0.5957198143005371, -0.10857575386762619, 0.9533625841140747, 0.08412165939807892, -0.520544171333313, -0.04300191253423691, 0.18256345391273499, -0.34109804034233093, 0.48630863428115845, -0.013353727757930756, -0.8773675560951233, -0.45336368680000305, 0.8682170510292053, 0.5512784123420715, 0.03617062792181969, 0.5312433838844299, -0.2498437613248825, -0.3367169201374054, -0.27734726667404175, 0.4307740330696106, 0.11620918661355972, 0.06045889854431152, -0.16160541772842407, 0.24464865028858185, -0.04215550422668457, 0.29550254344940186, 0.3796316981315613, -0.5696583986282349, 0.31178411841392517, 0.5580587387084961, -0.14110466837882996, 0.36491653323173523, 0.7107622027397156, -0.4173390865325928, 0.6815720200538635, 0.08214030414819717, -0.2611553966999054, 0.8367652297019958, -0.32656556367874146, 0.1087036207318306, -0.5742090344429016, 0.4519435167312622, -0.4948226511478424, 0.7691050171852112, 0.11419205367565155, -0.13921824097633362, -0.5669065117835999, -0.7154526710510254, -0.26710569858551025, 0.16211380064487457, 0.04001607745885849, 0.016062552109360695, -0.3148128092288971, -0.7254559993743896, 0.04342469945549965, -0.2916796803474426, -0.3713398575782776, 0.8667857050895691, -0.5018407702445984, 0.547315776348114, 0.04177667945623398, -0.443031907081604, -1.242433786392212, 0.48147547245025635, -1.4228274822235107, -0.07034298032522202, 0.032556965947151184, 0.15786443650722504, 0.5512189865112305, -0.11444112658500671, 0.5778332352638245, 0.27603620290756226, -0.0274087842553854, 0.8333269357681274, -0.2189774513244629, 0.6143010258674622, -0.4946305751800537, 0.26537320017814636, -0.532120406627655, 0.7869199514389038, -0.6881051659584045, 0.1913493424654007, -0.32985052466392517, -0.18247288465499878, -0.9459527134895325, -0.022513533011078835, 0.08667926490306854, -0.11351528018712997, -0.22851085662841797, -0.045252203941345215, 0.77495938539505, -0.6890946626663208, -0.1982467621564865, -0.20443245768547058, -0.37344199419021606, -0.8652158975601196, -0.9268714785575867, 0.39648404717445374, -0.5139580368995667, -0.7769806385040283, 0.13908398151397705, 0.20197243988513947, -0.22791346907615662, 0.08597401529550552, 0.08092895895242691, -0.18204593658447266, -0.25639164447784424, 0.33607199788093567, -0.2276073545217514, 0.010468345135450363, 0.44786739349365234, -0.2031208723783493, -0.6972438097000122, -0.6034385561943054, 0.12407833337783813, -0.2943527102470398, 0.10696081817150116, 0.7081654667854309, 0.28353381156921387, -0.6201187968254089, 0.8376078009605408, -0.5146803259849548, -0.5442607998847961, 0.4015006721019745, 0.03955406695604324, 0.5869293212890625, -0.101017527282238, 0.05192328989505768, -0.5129978656768799, -0.3219713568687439, 0.11016198247671127, 0.435385525226593, 0.15150676667690277, -0.3538459837436676, 0.19327077269554138, 0.6616407036781311, -0.12556850910186768, -0.44923102855682373, 0.2633863389492035, -0.5034880042076111, -0.11090781539678574, 0.14894317090511322, -0.32637521624565125, 0.30220118165016174, 0.30738863348960876, 0.29657506942749023, -0.3828947842121124, 0.3917124271392822, -0.386440634727478, -0.18262885510921478, -0.5990559458732605, -0.6169764399528503, -0.15068630874156952, 0.2804076373577118, -0.34437987208366394, 0.3888986110687256, -0.0844196304678917, -0.062286894768476486, 0.6985154151916504, 0.235648050904274, 0.3020436465740204, -0.6619910001754761, 0.5480157732963562, 0.34152600169181824, -0.4908914566040039, -0.2929256856441498, -0.1335614025592804, 0.310258150100708, 0.1619860976934433, 0.6017909049987793, 0.963824987411499, 0.04485505819320679, -0.36083823442459106, -0.40506505966186523, 0.12461283802986145, 0.06642555445432663, 0.021213604137301445, 0.6342540383338928, -0.12168285995721817, 0.5814610123634338, -0.6055302023887634, -0.7726725935935974, -0.04500154033303261, 0.015793433412909508, 0.06826625019311905, -0.31946098804473877, -0.9495340585708618, -0.22183670103549957, 0.7420876026153564, 0.696742057800293, -0.1216658502817154, -0.08135733753442764, 0.27643999457359314, -0.4096388518810272, -0.059998590499162674, 0.1267451047897339, 0.03159993141889572, 0.8361226916313171, -0.4382142126560211, 0.385454386472702, 0.23357650637626648, -0.15978628396987915, -0.382147878408432, -0.25258293747901917, 0.3923637568950653, 0.30281221866607666, 0.8949194550514221, 0.6044920682907104, -0.9115052223205566, 0.009386642836034298, -0.23671193420886993, -0.022219322621822357, -0.2983645796775818, 0.12530194222927094, 0.3570370078086853, 0.7273152470588684, 0.11927786469459534, -0.6591670513153076, -0.23376673460006714, -0.09987641125917435, 0.34060999751091003, 0.4675845801830292, -1.2114275693893433, -0.47869184613227844, 0.20004430413246155, 0.5031032562255859, 0.299079954624176, 0.4016936123371124, 0.5462645888328552, 0.1934034675359726, 0.38246363401412964, 0.11279644817113876, 0.021886587142944336, 0.8122169375419617, -0.27505528926849365, 0.05510333925485611, 0.6037028431892395, 0.40268322825431824, -0.05816902965307236, 0.40091779828071594, -0.07213142514228821, -0.7235599756240845, 0.03810734301805496, -0.6820448637008667, 0.42761415243148804, -0.296927273273468, -0.49997225403785706, 0.3858565092086792, -0.03364870324730873, -0.328297883272171, 0.16106820106506348, -0.23431499302387238, 0.20216001570224762, 0.2212592512369156, -0.38650763034820557, -0.35580411553382874, -0.7189278602600098, 0.11268141120672226, -0.457837849855423, 0.9212175607681274, 0.5250217318534851, 0.1496337205171585, -0.021810561418533325, -0.01204429566860199, 0.6883119940757751, 0.03563614934682846, 0.2520827054977417, -0.8087578415870667, -0.445797860622406, 0.04133794456720352, 0.20354458689689636, -0.17491590976715088, -0.14272475242614746, 0.09866738319396973, -0.46378830075263977, 0.46753254532814026, -0.207326740026474, -0.05684051662683487, -0.5067877173423767, 0.4925632178783417, -0.39521071314811707, 0.5797103643417358, -0.3894910216331482, -0.10350920259952545, -0.16234375536441803, -0.2833714485168457, 0.4105916917324066, -0.6593894362449646, 0.2101261168718338, -0.4475725293159485, 0.37975168228149414, -0.07635267823934555, 0.08914710581302643, 0.00019062639330513775, -0.4672190546989441, 0.23749572038650513, -0.25144726037979126, -0.5681501030921936, -0.8867027759552002, -0.1973063051700592, -0.15740810334682465, 0.14872229099273682, 0.33793169260025024, -0.3033577501773834, 0.16058559715747833, -0.18542812764644623, -0.7749192118644714, 0.8802841305732727, 0.574891209602356, -0.785553514957428, 0.2796647250652313, 0.1038917601108551, 0.6966372728347778, -1.0594818592071533, 0.0012299353256821632, 0.16511273384094238, 0.29776039719581604, -0.20424671471118927, -0.26897507905960083, -0.2281235158443451, 0.26406216621398926, -1.1830602884292603, -0.012168041430413723, -0.26678162813186646, 0.3391098976135254, 0.18572506308555603, -0.21235640347003937, 0.3248271942138672, 0.497846782207489, 0.2865504026412964, -0.671052873134613, -0.5371660590171814, -0.6573002934455872, 0.14551527798175812, 0.0553564615547657, -0.46431782841682434, -1.2170952558517456, 0.6687571406364441, -0.7701181769371033, 0.6471027135848999, -0.8039502501487732, -0.7093852758407593, 0.13324561715126038, 0.3995523452758789, 0.09917420148849487, 0.1751173585653305, -0.03931719437241554, 0.11593061685562134, -0.17406170070171356, 0.45355647802352905, -0.1988471895456314, 0.5919308662414551, -0.5534377098083496, 0.17763903737068176, -0.14917831122875214, 0.07596030831336975, 0.024880602955818176, 0.009691473096609116, -0.04899115860462189, -0.008969486691057682, 0.882498562335968, -0.5857936143875122, -0.04320243373513222, 0.46071958541870117, 0.19025932252407074, 0.33994922041893005, -0.04314590245485306, -0.7855539917945862, -0.530134916305542, -0.007900361903011799, -0.6581013798713684, 0.2699298858642578, 0.15746885538101196, 0.38799580931663513, -0.2056768387556076, -0.005092115141451359, 0.11023516952991486, -0.6361369490623474, -0.34069839119911194, 0.06319030374288559, -0.014392789453268051, 0.2555290460586548, -0.405952125787735, -0.12063351273536682, 0.1723342090845108, -0.08979316800832748, 0.09173223376274109, -0.07545142620801926, -0.9347590804100037, 0.4072967767715454, 0.22683916985988617, -0.6479341983795166, -0.1961316615343094, 0.7189708352088928, 0.24099363386631012, -0.9540431499481201, 0.7769232392311096, 0.04198328033089638, -0.26384472846984863, 0.4148876368999481, -0.16257721185684204, 0.46463435888290405, -0.48089584708213806, 0.5425950288772583, -0.47157204151153564, 0.1265418529510498, 0.7552099227905273, 0.06762296706438065, -0.5139778852462769, -0.1702658236026764, 0.6629195809364319, -0.3914306163787842, -0.12917177379131317, 0.13659337162971497, 0.21465809643268585, -1.2604643106460571, 0.44699445366859436, -0.011546755209565163, 0.521916925907135, 0.5659743547439575, -0.02190166339278221, -0.04037797451019287, -0.0836409330368042, -0.538650393486023, 0.16371679306030273, 0.7474692463874817, 0.20460443198680878, 0.6087198853492737, 0.4684697687625885, -0.09832924604415894, -0.5420501232147217, 0.6503880023956299, 1.3237648010253906, 0.40418729186058044, -0.4194241464138031, 0.212239608168602, 0.25532644987106323, -0.3629854917526245, -0.5193580985069275, 1.2351062297821045, -0.019842537119984627, 0.03161567449569702, -0.32181596755981445, 0.8069981932640076, -0.2539742887020111, 0.047780923545360565, 0.3082863390445709, -0.09107141196727753, -0.9939002394676208, -0.2872348129749298, -0.5626164078712463, -0.5722561478614807, 0.18533848226070404, 0.8983206152915955, 0.8385534286499023, 0.520897388458252, 0.2706335186958313, -0.9092609286308289, 0.0709676593542099, -0.2049841582775116, -0.31771495938301086, -0.38297250866889954, -0.8128615021705627, -0.13157282769680023, -0.753624677658081, 0.9205423593521118, 0.1587717980146408, 0.6337204575538635, 0.1822419911623001, 0.47588834166526794, 0.2191358357667923, -0.217443585395813, 0.38829198479652405, -0.21197931468486786, -0.4129282832145691, -0.4020739197731018, 0.06931478530168533, -0.30148085951805115, -0.6968846321105957, 0.049215544015169144, 0.19076168537139893, -0.7930938601493835, 0.16520902514457703, 0.19819140434265137, 0.6565473675727844, -0.08752689510583878, -0.08489149063825607, -0.4033373296260834, -0.5117211937904358, -0.9772716760635376, 0.7692376375198364, -0.9151739478111267, 0.486713707447052, 0.6282017230987549, -0.0005415239720605314, 0.015315581113100052, 0.30691707134246826, -0.7819063067436218, 0.5509592294692993, -0.2348647266626358, 0.6231438517570496, -0.5758293867111206, -0.4409823417663574, -0.18965591490268707, 1.0042906999588013, -1.1668747663497925, -0.5435771346092224, -0.31525325775146484, 0.11153571307659149, 0.14739149808883667, 0.2679365575313568, -0.08872918784618378, 0.6798679828643799, 0.3001667559146881, -0.10230565816164017, -0.5691550970077515, 0.08093318343162537, -0.6401042342185974, 0.40567559003829956, -0.544497549533844, 0.13804589211940765, -0.0441959984600544, -0.5368033051490784, 0.013677863404154778, 1.1540062427520752, 0.11978677660226822, 0.1476004272699356, 0.19059906899929047, -0.39748460054397583, -0.3255595266819, -0.06992264837026596, -0.7025215029716492, 0.5339947938919067, 0.3623749613761902, -0.1271088719367981, 0.30935585498809814, -0.10454969108104706, -0.906338632106781, 0.4320700466632843, -0.7121304869651794, -0.2675182521343231, 0.2412022054195404, -0.14330977201461792, 0.0135051803663373, 0.21917971968650818, -0.6886513829231262, 0.5623803734779358, 0.554757297039032, 0.4369678199291229, 0.4394667446613312, 0.36563533544540405, -0.7011418342590332, 0.09829506278038025, -0.5832525491714478, 0.04006790742278099, -0.16411477327346802, 0.156488299369812, -1.0347785949707031, -1.1005278825759888, 0.4189178943634033, 0.16068525612354279, -0.6704456210136414, -0.10991717875003815, -0.33124393224716187, -0.07174181938171387, -0.2074531763792038, -0.05315393954515457, -0.473289430141449, 0.1386898308992386, -0.4045819938182831, -0.06876939535140991, -0.45875629782676697, -0.2696661949157715, -0.6310584545135498, 0.026198530569672585, 0.7603081464767456, -0.04649966210126877, -0.1283903270959854, 0.8665986061096191, 0.8287879824638367, -0.41277292370796204, 0.5822973251342773, 0.5182414650917053, 0.543656587600708, 0.3665991425514221, -0.20052559673786163, -0.02840355783700943, 0.14375801384449005, -0.07718382030725479, 0.054214414209127426, -0.09352371841669083, 0.003943285904824734, 0.038943950086832047, 0.5042160749435425, -0.21550093591213226, 0.23968373239040375, -0.0013880260521546006, 0.09508120268583298, -0.0003183296648785472, -0.26253846287727356, 0.38118159770965576, 0.5631806254386902, -0.04182666912674904, 0.3244742751121521, 0.6132346391677856, -0.169551819562912, -0.4299774765968323, -0.2593595087528229, 0.007058804389089346, -0.7267492413520813, -0.6221218109130859, -0.6029209494590759, 0.6728270649909973, -0.1587008833885193, -0.07053258270025253, 0.7623317837715149, -0.15216827392578125, 0.5056999325752258, -0.16149841248989105, 0.1401945948600769, 0.9565156698226929, 0.576483964920044, 0.40575605630874634, 0.6221832036972046, 0.4836956858634949, -0.04502733424305916, 0.11587443202733994, -0.20525744557380676, -0.7070183753967285, 0.23855946958065033, 0.4709775447845459, -0.3302704989910126, -0.09555342048406601, 0.16626474261283875, -0.8124375343322754, -0.6468872427940369, -1.059829592704773, 0.31945309042930603, -0.6488997340202332, 0.06953834742307663, 1.1731624603271484, -0.5863102674484253, 0.6216112971305847, 0.0910850539803505, 0.16754698753356934, 0.057500168681144714, 0.185784712433815, -0.33934536576271057, -0.12071792036294937, 1.4325416088104248, 0.8184350728988647, 0.15457527339458466, 0.06712228059768677, -0.86524498462677, 0.16500070691108704, 0.22429224848747253, -0.2934257984161377, -0.0013380907475948334, 0.9456031322479248, -0.323482483625412, 0.022563142701983452, 0.1939729005098343, -0.6561575531959534, -0.22672607004642487, 0.39792150259017944, 0.0977724939584732, 0.6052004098892212, -0.7854855060577393, -0.09265222400426865, 0.7748371362686157, 0.24352701008319855, 0.37313076853752136, -0.09193746000528336, 0.09687935560941696, -1.5243840217590332, 0.1438370794057846, -0.09922093898057938, 1.0069279670715332, -0.1512756049633026, -0.18943087756633759, -0.23911093175411224, -0.4146970510482788, 0.2641201913356781, -0.8937184810638428, -0.44276198744773865, -0.5002604722976685, 0.10631583631038666, 0.7944293022155762, -0.025160498917102814, 0.3937493860721588, -1.0443768501281738, -0.12435787916183472, -0.008379533886909485, 0.7578008770942688, -0.21520502865314484, -0.6715524196624756, 0.7635658979415894, 0.4700819253921509, -0.07279741764068604, 0.41148003935813904, 0.30474406480789185, -0.24234816431999207, 0.560064971446991, 0.3495944142341614, 0.5792299509048462, 0.12718819081783295, -0.4729996919631958, 0.48076149821281433, 0.7213455438613892, 0.24156546592712402, -0.1292513608932495, -0.2766081690788269, 0.2550505995750427, -0.3498569130897522, 0.06415177136659622, -0.1526441127061844, 0.5713778734207153, 0.13872270286083221, -0.41989025473594666, -0.020077884197235107, -0.31139639019966125, 4.414205074310303, 1.0871691703796387, 0.7582623958587646, 0.04102484881877899, 0.5330166816711426, 0.7130560278892517, 0.06487824022769928, -0.5674101114273071, 0.5251353979110718, -0.1495782434940338, 0.1869782656431198, -0.4070598781108856, 1.1032402515411377, -0.5374288558959961, -0.005100516136735678, 1.005481243133545, -0.1326744556427002, -0.25199946761131287, 0.7458556890487671, -0.6174719929695129, -0.8057546019554138, 0.22125770151615143, -0.15769349038600922, 0.004286016337573528, 0.15582330524921417, 0.3608500063419342, 0.3628387749195099, -0.3709328770637512, 0.013952233828604221, -0.22920657694339752, -0.810373842716217, -0.5575044751167297, 0.77861487865448, -0.2610718011856079, -0.3917245864868164, 0.4894289970397949, -0.9414638876914978, -0.34808918833732605, -0.04038543999195099, -0.07051371783018112, -0.7661544680595398, -0.5409632325172424, 0.4218083918094635, -0.766473650932312, -0.7154422402381897, 0.6377622485160828, 0.4773302972316742, -0.2940804362297058, 0.5218521952629089, -0.828686535358429, 0.2683805525302887, -0.5817226767539978, 0.295982301235199, 0.09531692415475845, -0.773756206035614, -0.18043853342533112, -0.13599617779254913, -0.9427787661552429, -0.06283843517303467, -0.10493261367082596, 0.3462546765804291, 0.11366024613380432, -0.3936672508716583, 0.6347234845161438, -0.5543336868286133, 0.6885108947753906, 0.20349279046058655, -0.18388527631759644, -0.39859429001808167, 0.018762029707431793, -0.14147086441516876, -0.23555026948451996, -0.46461546421051025, 0.2816028892993927, 0.2680016756057739, -0.32323047518730164, -0.6367366909980774, -0.316597580909729, -0.3803248405456543, -0.21680361032485962, -0.32302364706993103, 0.0008252359693869948, -0.606864333152771, 0.3880665898323059, 0.03098619543015957, 0.5869163274765015, -0.31080368161201477, -0.8535352945327759, -0.46693190932273865, 0.49912863969802856, -0.21007095277309418, 0.5922412276268005, 0.15825626254081726, 0.07299571484327316, -0.314594030380249 ]
The ($\log R_e$, $\mu_e$) Plane of Hot Stellar Systems
Two families of hot stellar systems, named {\it `ordinary'\/} and {\it 'bright'\/}, are identified in the ($\log R_e, \mu_e$) plane built with a luminosity--limited sample of ellipticals and bulges of S0s and spirals of the Virgo and Fornax clusters. This finding, based on {\it ad hoc\/} new observations, is confirmed by a much larger set of literature data for $\sim1500$ galaxies. The {\it `ordinary'\/} family is biparametric: $L_T\propto I_e\,R_e^2$; its members are fainter that $M_B\simeq-19.3$ and smaller than $\re\simeq3$ kpc (whatever $M_B$ is). The {\it 'bright'\/} family is uniparametric ($\mu_e$ depends on $R_e$ alone) and hosts brightest cluster members and QSO parent galaxies. We show that the segregation in the ($\log R_e, \mu_e$) plane has an important counterpart in the behavior of various physical parameters, which is markedly different for galaxies smaller ({\it `ordinary'\/} family) and larger ({\it 'bright'\/} family) than $R_e=3$ kpc.
Massimo Capaccioli, Nicola Caon and Mauro D'Onofrio
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211006
astro-ph/9211007
[ 0.4342959523200989, 0.7551173567771912, 0.24796903133392334, 0.20942114293575287, -0.19360078871250153, 0.04146744683384895, 0.3291911780834198, -0.03710087016224861, 0.2551893889904022, 1.6189757585525513, 0.3402266204357147, 0.2821376323699951, -0.14061042666435242, -1.029376745223999, -0.1576453596353531, 0.35337868332862854, -0.012941878288984299, -0.38566726446151733, -1.0435572862625122, -0.013828943483531475, 0.18589305877685547, -0.0999276340007782, -1.0340458154678345, -0.6600342988967896, -0.22923021018505096, 0.5017743110656738, 0.7708765268325806, 0.6242346167564392, 0.9627547264099121, 1.092293381690979, 0.46294501423835754, -0.30656641721725464, -0.25497859716415405, -0.39928972721099854, -0.6850484013557434, -0.3048396110534668, 0.5417628884315491, -1.2789918184280396, 0.9410102963447571, -1.1799143552780151, 0.38768187165260315, 0.48904949426651, 0.23848827183246613, -0.31877270340919495, 0.11238843202590942, 0.25299695134162903, -0.034550901502370834, -0.24985335767269135, 0.06106158718466759, -0.9214927554130554, -0.07315846532583237, -0.47429779171943665, 0.1943182796239853, -0.5158500075340271, -0.20697468519210815, -0.2891198396682739, 0.14339710772037506, 0.5535171031951904, -0.5731008052825928, 0.50022953748703, 0.3290228545665741, 0.21939989924430847, 0.2493937611579895, -0.828355610370636, -0.41156598925590515, 0.706203281879425, -0.19058983027935028, 0.310673326253891, -0.06600719690322876, -0.4824609160423279, -0.5445278286933899, -0.26568958163261414, -0.14976219832897186, 0.5167568325996399, -0.3384808599948883, 0.5365301966667175, -0.36072975397109985, -0.7234702110290527, 0.10230187326669693, 0.08242639899253845, 0.022392094135284424, 0.2405591905117035, -0.06926064193248749, 0.3653838634490967, -0.33106115460395813, -0.4190438985824585, 0.5334991812705994, 0.5354791879653931, 0.39165061712265015, 0.15296699106693268, -0.13329073786735535, 0.7137061357498169, -0.5104373693466187, 0.08816840499639511, 0.28764477372169495, 0.8014554977416992, -0.13745121657848358, 0.5299712419509888, 0.18851841986179352, 0.06568088382482529, -0.04815252497792244, 1.2382359504699707, -0.7987080216407776, -0.19483764469623566, -0.8659042716026306, 1.1479564905166626, -0.4044952392578125, 0.007702612318098545, 0.38761717081069946, -0.9313147068023682, 0.21008910238742828, 0.29380813241004944, 0.3396555185317993, -0.2857418954372406, -0.05791842192411423, -0.15428639948368073, 0.04137232154607773, 0.1401345282793045, -1.380886435508728, -0.7097432017326355, -0.4957745671272278, 0.7122678160667419, 0.4010448455810547, 0.9002207517623901, -0.0734570100903511, -0.08993744105100632, -0.1672857701778412, 0.2838050127029419, -0.506269097328186, 0.34028181433677673, 0.3109660744667053, -0.7464048266410828, -0.4459483325481415, 0.5327252745628357, -0.3020889163017273, 0.24096240103244781, 0.5221216082572937, 0.4382951855659485, 0.1940935105085373, -0.50221186876297, -0.44991225004196167, 0.23814226686954498, 0.22539056837558746, 1.1827621459960938, -0.14950942993164062, 0.6222909092903137, -0.3103368580341339, 0.12174997478723526, -0.3011496365070343, 0.5460411310195923, 0.03856397420167923, -0.3906508982181549, 0.02876807563006878, 0.7314109206199646, -0.5683515667915344, -0.4045547544956207, -0.8619987368583679, -0.1439628005027771, 0.18784929811954498, -0.2633703052997589, 0.008348043076694012, -0.5209068059921265, 0.5114663243293762, 1.5593985319137573, -0.34110429883003235, 0.8321799635887146, -0.6623660922050476, -0.257240355014801, -0.06742416322231293, 0.3653087615966797, -0.6205952167510986, 0.8166864514350891, 0.11489034444093704, 0.21073296666145325, 0.8860730528831482, 0.5173474550247192, 0.0879288837313652, -0.42274078726768494, -0.9635670781135559, 0.7939679622650146, -0.03982783854007721, -0.6532880067825317, 0.1308155506849289, 0.2050032615661621, -0.5133830904960632, -0.0724998265504837, -0.39172813296318054, 0.2126128375530243, 0.440883070230484, -0.2725732922554016, -0.6632339358329773, 0.16082316637039185, -0.6242402195930481, 0.7264454960823059, -0.8153848648071289, 0.5454723834991455, -0.5656875967979431, -0.39769336581230164, 0.0654229149222374, -0.43779587745666504, 0.28076300024986267, -0.0598025806248188, -0.604366660118103, -0.22850988805294037, -1.253899335861206, -0.453783243894577, -0.07711823284626007, 0.42692700028419495, -0.7369733452796936, 0.15202704071998596, 0.5735542178153992, 0.23981225490570068, 0.40192121267318726, -0.6081397533416748, 0.10563328117132187, 0.09227015823125839, -0.4395853579044342, -0.13452711701393127, -0.10552928596735, 0.2776261270046234, 0.5610799789428711, 0.6031275391578674, -0.19452616572380066, 1.0590299367904663, 0.1994941234588623, -0.2557264268398285, -0.10860714316368103, 1.3043239116668701, -0.15441396832466125, 0.3209507167339325, 0.1595972776412964, -0.09139864891767502, 0.6181556582450867, 0.3926273584365845, 0.029517069458961487, -0.4925904870033264, 1.2439056634902954, 1.0308668613433838, 0.00945792905986309, 0.4038558900356293, 0.6721566915512085, 0.18123884499073029, 1.4962742328643799, -0.031165478751063347, -0.5994842052459717, 0.5793063044548035, 0.15213797986507416, -0.06202498823404312, -0.5522670149803162, 0.8093211650848389, -0.5935174822807312, 0.4158507287502289, 0.22010783851146698, -0.4711686074733734, -1.3521023988723755, -0.01860281080007553, 0.36156922578811646, 0.0645480528473854, 0.43457484245300293, -0.9680989384651184, -0.222803995013237, -0.07754985988140106, -0.015908440575003624, -0.12280281633138657, -0.5241872668266296, -0.08904866874217987, -0.7088029384613037, -0.12432520091533661, 0.7342923283576965, -0.39065873622894287, -0.5783597826957703, 0.06945374608039856, -0.750799834728241, -0.11545480042695999, 0.1356765627861023, -0.22295816242694855, 0.4052615761756897, 0.11862438917160034, 0.5897917151451111, 0.22665084898471832, -0.5183385610580444, 0.167472243309021, -0.40280771255493164, 0.1600407063961029, -0.6983771324157715, 0.6733617782592773, -0.6890313029289246, 0.25986194610595703, -1.056501865386963, -0.053637973964214325, -0.04825366288423538, -0.35242846608161926, -0.012136552482843399, -0.37368887662887573, 0.45071548223495483, -0.03190010413527489, -0.22138479351997375, 0.6924902200698853, 0.04395928606390953, -0.696733295917511, 0.8346301317214966, 0.29381614923477173, -0.5261048078536987, -0.24188916385173798, -0.494037926197052, 0.31419637799263, -0.5765240788459778, -0.46159523725509644, 0.10879568755626678, 0.09683685749769211, -0.3125908374786377, 0.42387059330940247, 0.410737544298172, 0.6805573105812073, -0.5548455119132996, 0.2930513918399811, 0.6231646537780762, -0.25893327593803406, 0.7253980040550232, -0.6635502576828003, -0.7615240812301636, -0.5315430760383606, 0.6021181344985962, 0.02288191393017769, 0.7148804664611816, 0.5474077463150024, 0.496651828289032, -1.0329455137252808, 0.5954724550247192, -0.9106009602546692, -0.5775958895683289, -0.2104591429233551, -0.5698056221008301, 0.530003011226654, -0.30876925587654114, 0.02070480026304722, -0.2911030948162079, -0.12132283300161362, -0.0811786949634552, 0.42032891511917114, 0.6727611422538757, 0.4258192181587219, -0.061737943440675735, 0.5882335305213928, -0.30343592166900635, 0.20918238162994385, 0.30952930450439453, -0.4554566442966461, -0.012196595780551434, 0.3691057860851288, -0.5071340203285217, -0.04895272105932236, -0.01900937594473362, 0.22177982330322266, 0.01988280937075615, -0.0281046312302351, -0.07768362760543823, -0.10159601271152496, -0.952299952507019, -0.6975668668746948, 0.40775400400161743, 0.9251722693443298, 0.7820616960525513, -0.5625730156898499, -0.5885540843009949, 0.21532052755355835, -0.08095940202474594, 0.08366219699382782, 0.44691142439842224, -0.6473568677902222, 0.045583318918943405, 0.33686500787734985, -0.648484468460083, -0.15879584848880768, 0.012518246658146381, 0.4615483283996582, 0.8448690176010132, 0.2881832420825958, 0.4094441533088684, -0.5401325821876526, -0.1904272735118866, -0.5501689910888672, 0.09938111901283264, 0.47939011454582214, -0.06654410064220428, 0.2564305067062378, -0.06704156845808029, 0.5332998633384705, -0.7044220566749573, -0.20437116920948029, -0.44908928871154785, -0.8708255887031555, 0.6330094337463379, -0.011896717362105846, -0.5648220777511597, 0.17998121678829193, 0.1557455211877823, 1.0413850545883179, 0.09325533360242844, -0.1443922072649002, -0.18850462138652802, 0.060267314314842224, 0.5003398060798645, 0.5412657260894775, -0.5352744460105896, 0.18295681476593018, -0.10633083432912827, -0.14272785186767578, 0.9239798188209534, 0.15523119270801544, 0.020353732630610466, -0.20490536093711853, -0.010243885219097137, 0.49110665917396545, 0.7369763255119324, -0.3041723668575287, -0.19627122581005096, 0.5743576884269714, 0.3831426799297333, -0.10068531334400177, -0.4087750315666199, 0.48603957891464233, 0.16608598828315735, 1.3750174045562744, 0.3729820251464844, 0.13849912583827972, -0.7040477395057678, -1.1289770603179932, 0.7201910018920898, 0.39784228801727295, -0.7964913249015808, -1.0415786504745483, -0.16621923446655273, 0.17578265070915222, 0.16037814319133759, 0.6381522417068481, 0.8581883311271667, 1.081254243850708, 0.8232026100158691, -0.2551880180835724, 0.16790492832660675, 0.8110173940658569, -0.052447184920310974, 0.20584267377853394, 0.49166205525398254, -0.14937959611415863, 0.31389880180358887, 0.7601809501647949, -0.37742090225219727, -1.305909276008606, -0.01987544260919094, -0.21576476097106934, 0.9479238986968994, 0.21314556896686554, -0.7555646300315857, 0.6437717080116272, -0.677405834197998, -0.36114367842674255, 0.46487513184547424, -0.4169406592845917, -0.37023285031318665, 0.705200731754303, -0.32522135972976685, -0.782102644443512, 0.27994686365127563, 0.137645423412323, -0.6583408713340759, 1.0318676233291626, 0.9164477586746216, -0.23071889579296112, 0.8649923205375671, 0.4275674521923065, -0.05119798332452774, -0.13045507669448853, 0.9142752289772034, -0.6733518242835999, -0.02481808327138424, 0.2735859155654907, -0.5516469478607178, -0.06484498083591461, 0.05010432377457619, 0.5705299973487854, -0.5513591766357422, 0.34147197008132935, -0.15769410133361816, -0.7566298842430115, -0.4380745589733124, -0.6096338033676147, -0.46515828371047974, 0.48616695404052734, 0.08077329397201538, -0.002612851560115814, -0.2775997519493103, 0.07097839564085007, -0.1273861676454544, 0.10933034867048264, 0.11029378324747086, 0.06518101692199707, -0.16712139546871185, 0.004675749223679304, 0.07329203188419342, -0.27232128381729126, -0.7834787368774414, 0.42394542694091797, -0.4075201153755188, -0.5379239320755005, -0.25481918454170227, -0.37885087728500366, -0.30096763372421265, 0.41890281438827515, 0.14358913898468018, -0.19435420632362366, -0.13447542488574982, 0.20818905532360077, -0.2522141635417938, 0.41706719994544983, 0.5150560140609741, -1.404026746749878, 0.0763646587729454, 0.6655147671699524, 0.8796979784965515, -0.2580755054950714, -0.4621492922306061, 0.5642770528793335, 0.6030004024505615, -0.4597001075744629, -0.29954758286476135, 0.09014382213354111, -0.4798756241798401, -1.2814596891403198, 0.0026891797315329313, -0.9389126896858215, -0.5886737108230591, 0.28405997157096863, -0.40764132142066956, 0.12505699694156647, 0.27992910146713257, 0.4096396863460541, -0.5317450761795044, -0.7470886707305908, -0.7242686748504639, 0.2263401597738266, -0.5937615036964417, -0.4704514741897583, -0.45976582169532776, -0.1376536786556244, -0.9310520887374878, 1.3202157020568848, -0.9262164235115051, -0.05573709309101105, 0.170402392745018, 0.4229397177696228, 0.1801222860813141, 0.3705325722694397, 0.4226192533969879, 0.07527682185173035, -0.5948390364646912, 0.04119924455881119, 0.1290176659822464, 0.5122135281562805, -0.5573773980140686, 0.25436362624168396, -0.3575320541858673, 0.2915230989456177, 0.024210909381508827, -0.17845343053340912, 0.09951827675104141, -0.6996133327484131, 0.5051052570343018, -0.07288731634616852, -0.06164880096912384, 0.748578667640686, 0.3620923161506653, 0.40056830644607544, -0.12435545772314072, -0.7567498683929443, -0.10905078798532486, 0.048365093767642975, -0.1057426705956459, 0.5117663145065308, 0.09445919096469879, -0.5528303384780884, -0.7198770046234131, -0.5405325889587402, -0.5649480819702148, -0.20920057594776154, -0.25012797117233276, 0.7261481285095215, 0.1715472936630249, 0.8128527402877808, -0.5712971091270447, 0.3462921380996704, 0.13613185286521912, 0.1777881532907486, -0.14336682856082916, 0.12662135064601898, -0.19247886538505554, -0.7654750347137451, -0.17773960530757904, -0.7541843056678772, -0.41314560174942017, 0.6024196743965149, 0.3299233019351959, -0.29746460914611816, 0.6916911005973816, -0.13244959712028503, -0.33875948190689087, -0.0818561464548111, 0.6098734140396118, 0.006312831770628691, -0.03367044776678085, 0.46914538741111755, 0.3179031014442444, -0.052110541611909866, 0.894264817237854, 0.00869056861847639, -0.6426697969436646, -0.5186817646026611, 1.0042228698730469, -0.5297978520393372, 0.09895069897174835, 0.39604446291923523, -0.055344752967357635, -0.7539874911308289, -0.4040975272655487, -0.5706757307052612, 0.32392600178718567, 0.24984301626682281, -0.45350348949432373, 0.20968633890151978, -0.14087940752506256, -0.2910947799682617, 0.8147513270378113, 0.25009435415267944, 0.06162278354167938, 0.472667396068573, -0.11986652761697769, 0.10915670543909073, -0.6954841017723083, -0.4288210868835449, 1.088070034980774, 0.5514364838600159, -0.6304827332496643, 0.17720572650432587, -0.07960955798625946, -0.12580972909927368, -0.7151179313659668, 0.8384202718734741, -0.16263991594314575, -0.33111637830734253, 0.11899995058774948, 0.06892354041337967, 0.23670531809329987, 0.0755535289645195, -0.44609448313713074, 0.19341027736663818, -0.8306459188461304, -0.5059314966201782, 0.0976915955543518, -0.10459206253290176, 0.8336969614028931, 0.6851299405097961, 0.25548672676086426, 0.11651168018579483, -0.03113744407892227, 0.30655139684677124, 0.3177119195461273, -0.22928032279014587, -0.771538496017456, -0.49288615584373474, -0.47000956535339355, -0.8783225417137146, 0.041779570281505585, 0.2611211836338043, 0.9030512571334839, -0.315707266330719, 0.5636070966720581, 0.732657253742218, 0.36685842275619507, 0.07213638722896576, 0.40244144201278687, -0.2317502647638321, -0.3047926127910614, 0.04214387759566307, -0.047276463359594345, -0.16919271647930145, -0.9143362045288086, -0.21098658442497253, 0.0011453795013949275, -0.35018566250801086, 1.163974642753601, 0.05583213269710541, 0.6171129941940308, -0.28893589973449707, -0.8471961617469788, 0.8511720299720764, -0.2797960638999939, -1.1097023487091064, 1.3788174390792847, -0.6696264743804932, 1.066891074180603, 0.23668614029884338, -0.8377113342285156, -0.5852487087249756, -0.08781035989522934, -0.9087356328964233, 0.3109916150569916, 0.2562974989414215, 0.5082458853721619, -1.2638771533966064, -0.9253305196762085, -0.42171648144721985, 0.3562207818031311, -1.28621506690979, -0.24497662484645844, -0.25392845273017883, 0.6716680526733398, -0.7024547457695007, 0.12010199576616287, -0.3491046130657196, -0.21835559606552124, -0.11089011281728745, -0.009923878125846386, -0.7993252873420715, 0.17673295736312866, 0.15525342524051666, 0.2835251986980438, -0.0939994677901268, 0.06638240814208984, 0.37214192748069763, -0.5862612724304199, 0.21812033653259277, -0.2299364060163498, 0.13954123854637146, -0.14873509109020233, -0.029529647901654243, -0.27904999256134033, -0.3023023307323456, -0.059118542820215225, -0.8388329148292542, 0.8022142052650452, 0.41790521144866943, 0.3645515441894531, 0.8479430675506592, -0.0702972561120987, -1.2437642812728882, 0.13697290420532227, -0.639706015586853, -0.8439822196960449, -0.039944473654031754, 0.41948485374450684, 0.2726978063583374, 0.732132613658905, -0.612125813961029, -0.24303682148456573, 0.5515332221984863, 0.8603899478912354, 0.8793572783470154, -0.1375265270471573, -0.36470773816108704, 0.5740829706192017, -1.0349379777908325, -0.32750698924064636, -0.3190176486968994, 0.5901798009872437, -1.413514494895935, -1.0311461687088013, -0.16416537761688232, -0.8420752286911011, -0.2451537400484085, -0.2336995154619217, 0.5371189713478088, -0.37523093819618225, -0.7288691401481628, -0.5846219062805176, -0.4908774197101593, -0.3683881461620331, -1.0704950094223022, 0.36535516381263733, -0.009850717149674892, -0.1847323477268219, 0.4638035297393799, 0.1835375726222992, 0.7894214391708374, 0.2781607508659363, -0.4392260015010834, 0.678507924079895, 0.19506366550922394, -0.10417690128087997, -0.08408636599779129, 0.2690201699733734, 0.40176546573638916, 0.23167845606803894, -0.5559996366500854, 0.29020142555236816, 0.47983962297439575, -0.4410891532897949, 0.4425719082355499, 0.04574289172887802, -0.41974586248397827, -0.04513977840542793, -0.5727634429931641, -0.6178205013275146, 0.1141657754778862, -0.4182869493961334, -0.260052353143692, 0.360172301530838, -0.0027916065882891417, -0.5004715919494629, -0.09250815212726593, 0.1303272694349289, 0.7249126434326172, -0.21220184862613678, -0.25329384207725525, -0.46760571002960205, 0.02666369639337063, 0.7869625091552734, -0.1626301109790802, -0.5038174986839294, -0.3932216465473175, 0.2730640470981598, 0.0316280722618103, -0.3438195586204529, 0.05605822429060936, 0.47641465067863464, 0.14329728484153748, 0.29385480284690857, 0.18913009762763977, 0.22843311727046967, 0.16444167494773865, 0.27363893389701843, 0.4227922558784485, 0.20807941257953644, 0.5149663686752319, 0.05409251153469086, -0.10407669842243195, -1.1625113487243652, -0.528903067111969, -0.1376074105501175, -0.7297374606132507, -0.45805123448371887, 1.0821647644042969, -0.4011143743991852, -0.32793816924095154, -0.7545044422149658, -0.02000741846859455, -0.09279078990221024, 0.8922247886657715, 0.08288396894931793, -0.790949821472168, -0.011025216430425644, 0.7245537638664246, -0.15107174217700958, -0.0867122933268547, 0.4556182622909546, 0.21363383531570435, 0.14687009155750275, 0.6580979228019714, 0.6768673062324524, 0.4403052031993866, 0.04991912469267845, -0.19520792365074158, -0.2571882903575897, 0.5127539038658142, 0.7251291871070862, -0.23120622336864471, 0.6146860718727112, -0.9498106241226196, 0.04880073666572571, -0.28247401118278503, -0.22726096212863922, -0.5174318552017212, -0.13369859755039215, 0.11696559190750122, 1.1224384307861328, -0.5081955790519714, -0.04913954809308052, 0.21132682263851166, 0.4197958707809448, 0.49408212304115295, -0.08950027078390121, 0.5481768250465393, -1.103554606437683, 0.006618628278374672, -0.8024389147758484, 0.1241057813167572, 0.12803839147090912, -0.30089089274406433, -0.6220740079879761, 0.23677515983581543, 0.06782802194356918, -0.5199908018112183, -0.5854929685592651, -0.2881234288215637, 0.616761326789856, 1.1414434909820557, -0.31671130657196045, -0.024368107318878174, -0.48448383808135986, -0.39262720942497253, -0.7013278603553772, 0.8080592751502991, 0.38287654519081116, -0.2597499191761017, 0.5603004693984985, 0.8432428240776062, -1.3875904083251953, 0.4273926317691803, 0.47996386885643005, -0.2831743061542511, 0.5454296469688416, 0.510921835899353, 0.454271137714386, 0.40064123272895813, -0.45268648862838745, 0.28275924921035767, 0.32452207803726196, -0.19157063961029053, 0.5576938986778259, 0.07616294920444489, 0.025030670687556267, -0.38492551445961, -0.31790074706077576, -0.36575546860694885, 0.24136193096637726, 0.026989202946424484, -0.7823167443275452, -0.12959837913513184, -1.0168055295944214, 4.119504928588867, 0.5914527177810669, 0.19075514376163483, -0.45130375027656555, 0.6783173680305481, 0.7889528274536133, 0.13647180795669556, -0.0479792021214962, 0.24231044948101044, -0.6827811598777771, 0.4562798738479614, 0.044818371534347534, 0.3714364767074585, -0.4251388907432556, 0.0792049914598465, 0.2884545922279358, -0.2938600480556488, -0.24174147844314575, -0.21347561478614807, -0.11942407488822937, -1.264174222946167, 0.2899547219276428, -0.090642549097538, -0.2637638449668884, 0.31113898754119873, 1.005761742591858, 0.007920005358755589, -0.5072645545005798, -0.5168778300285339, -0.059257566928863525, -0.5700782537460327, -0.734978973865509, 0.08960328996181488, -0.3111726939678192, -0.8991120457649231, 0.13320127129554749, -0.570789635181427, -0.463826984167099, 0.16449563205242157, 0.12663787603378296, -0.07960713654756546, -0.5440088510513306, 0.46674221754074097, -0.6154746413230896, 0.4895217716693878, 0.8406764268875122, 0.42920222878456116, -0.12463943660259247, 0.3467177152633667, -0.667732834815979, 0.03204718232154846, 0.5120230913162231, 0.7400482892990112, 0.08254829794168472, -0.77809739112854, -0.3243546783924103, -0.09103148430585861, -0.5894554853439331, 0.31506505608558655, -0.34663206338882446, 0.6398990154266357, -0.6223254799842834, -0.5801419615745544, 1.006435751914978, 0.09309175610542297, 0.4786103665828705, 0.381177693605423, -0.14027124643325806, -0.1448470503091812, -0.4826779067516327, -0.6589963436126709, 0.10315674543380737, -0.18872782588005066, 0.09783802181482315, 0.08475617319345474, 0.19972090423107147, 0.21016904711723328, 0.45817625522613525, -0.8697168827056885, 0.6897512674331665, -0.5730210542678833, -0.027332598343491554, -0.24441085755825043, 0.6648667454719543, 0.4862135052680969, 0.7148271799087524, -0.3500653803348541, 0.4495083689689636, -0.7754269242286682, 0.7184178829193115, -0.09075244516134262, 0.5327615141868591, 0.3189123868942261, -0.29862889647483826, -1.0176119804382324 ]
Generalized Einstein Theory on Solar and Galactic Scales
We study a generalized Einstein theory with the following two criteria:{\it i}) on the solar scale, it must be consistent with the classical tests of general relativity, {\it ii}) on the galactic scale, the gravitational potential is a sum of Newtonian and Yukawa potentials so that it may explain the flat rotation curves of spiral galaxies. Under these criteria, we find that such a generalized Einstein action must include at least one scalar field and one vector field as well as the quadratic term of the scalar curvature.
Masakatsu Kenmoku, Yuko Okamoto and Kazuyasu Shigemoto
astro-ph gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211007
astro-ph/9211008
[ 0.1845131367444992, 0.2427195906639099, 0.45673784613609314, 0.34062498807907104, -0.1805419623851776, 0.20870715379714966, -0.16572627425193787, -0.180092453956604, -0.3373194932937622, 0.9830892086029053, 0.3123399615287781, -0.744533896446228, 0.004193711560219526, -0.8717941641807556, -0.3152287006378174, 0.3202037513256073, -0.4030310809612274, -0.45552223920822144, -1.1040403842926025, -0.018865125253796577, -0.03289894387125969, 0.35739314556121826, -0.784950852394104, -0.5572333931922913, -0.1867709755897522, 0.6856918931007385, -0.03509323671460152, 0.505656898021698, 1.3163546323776245, 0.9861738681793213, 0.542172372341156, -0.11232485622167587, -0.06962636858224869, -0.6962538361549377, -0.5975285768508911, 0.4276248514652252, 0.027416717261075974, -0.5659969449043274, 0.6866711974143982, -0.3513081669807434, 1.148664116859436, -0.45457470417022705, 0.5338383316993713, -0.06867130100727081, -0.7778573632240295, -0.11926795542240143, -0.5937597751617432, -0.05876721069216728, -0.07957074046134949, -1.2604209184646606, 0.001019118120893836, -0.33124592900276184, 0.196232870221138, -0.8308442831039429, 0.2541219890117645, -0.21902748942375183, -0.1687464863061905, -0.12146837264299393, -0.7625663876533508, -0.02816031686961651, 0.6350418925285339, 0.38057568669319153, 0.9645106196403503, -0.8429023027420044, -0.027795109897851944, 1.5065044164657593, 0.2567496597766876, 0.22732865810394287, -0.02343706227838993, 0.03334522619843483, -0.24175506830215454, -0.21995365619659424, -0.4405636489391327, 0.17013436555862427, -0.33701038360595703, 0.8699934482574463, -0.04741945490241051, 0.03775384649634361, -0.17502537369728088, -0.29564806818962097, 0.04145730286836624, 0.024719882756471634, -0.2671852111816406, 0.9329454898834229, 0.46498242020606995, -0.5178683400154114, -0.04640129953622818, 0.00995746161788702, -0.07224390655755997, 0.13488659262657166, -0.016148973256349564, 0.5699440240859985, -0.3450661301612854, 0.4574042558670044, 0.6700765490531921, 0.5878340601921082, -0.14690712094306946, 0.5787578821182251, 0.37688013911247253, -0.2788691520690918, 0.24732159078121185, 0.27030882239341736, -1.1760438680648804, 0.2516308128833771, -0.7661754488945007, 0.783622682094574, -0.8991472125053406, 0.4803619384765625, -0.7486874461174011, -0.5100924968719482, -0.26408934593200684, 0.48237738013267517, 0.3140084743499756, 0.49981430172920227, -0.11564485728740692, 0.8581211566925049, -0.5622375011444092, -0.03461012244224548, -0.8662363886833191, -0.5278615355491638, -0.041355766355991364, 0.6748384833335876, -0.705626904964447, 0.3980163335800171, -0.32213321328163147, -0.7018635869026184, -0.06943296641111374, 1.1040242910385132, -0.3932753801345825, 0.412697434425354, -0.2330954521894455, -0.42421650886535645, 0.08396026492118835, 0.5042228698730469, 0.012861954979598522, -0.21987193822860718, 0.1727021187543869, 0.3545980155467987, -0.3416581451892853, -0.38590362668037415, 0.22994761168956757, -0.5608951449394226, -0.027059519663453102, 1.0415934324264526, -0.6799108386039734, 0.1418144255876541, -0.4096192419528961, -0.34823280572891235, -0.7978102564811707, -0.28202351927757263, -0.3692608177661896, 0.016226578503847122, 0.3553535044193268, 0.43395373225212097, -0.2233293205499649, 0.18591219186782837, -1.0140494108200073, -0.06461925059556961, -0.07027485221624374, -1.0329817533493042, 0.32006606459617615, 0.26772189140319824, -0.28187471628189087, 0.41561201214790344, -0.8019362688064575, -0.052382692694664, -0.13206584751605988, -0.20728212594985962, 0.1657918095588684, -0.2958613336086273, -0.5050552487373352, 0.3029405474662781, -0.29506582021713257, 0.479143351316452, 0.5626699924468994, 0.6423918604850769, -0.0035475243348628283, -0.6191419959068298, 0.11120469868183136, 0.2924341857433319, -0.38505083322525024, -0.23608233034610748, 0.38893815875053406, 0.9278101921081543, -0.14490465819835663, 0.43629685044288635, 0.4181978106498718, 0.15890955924987793, 0.5810078978538513, 0.273577481508255, -0.4225844442844391, 0.5631698966026306, -0.6137415170669556, 0.9202555418014526, -0.5750453472137451, 0.21492116153240204, -0.8590061664581299, 0.40698400139808655, -0.21443064510822296, 0.03813273087143898, 0.06545831263065338, 0.25871503353118896, -0.9932714700698853, 0.01811530441045761, -0.9259980916976929, 0.3099623918533325, 0.17872367799282074, 0.48675695061683655, -0.9988915324211121, -0.22405998408794403, 0.583027184009552, -0.40625786781311035, 0.35960525274276733, 0.2637980580329895, 0.23436413705348969, 0.3174501061439514, 0.18839609622955322, 0.24594618380069733, -0.10005773603916168, -0.6402745246887207, 0.6799124479293823, 0.2719586193561554, -0.057745277881622314, 0.8123175501823425, -0.18094708025455475, -0.3477039933204651, 0.21228690445423126, 0.38284292817115784, -0.3761155307292938, 0.05898795649409294, 0.267426997423172, 0.4068548381328583, 0.0908837765455246, 0.2113022655248642, 0.844527006149292, -0.19553734362125397, 0.7465503215789795, 0.8076794147491455, -0.4918023347854614, 0.21677879989147186, 0.6686925292015076, -0.0956612229347229, 0.051450856029987335, 0.07558698207139969, -0.7984126210212708, 1.0844409465789795, -0.49278685450553894, -0.33446016907691956, -0.37041160464286804, 0.5624770522117615, -0.8352038860321045, 0.1619265079498291, 0.16984979808330536, 0.10040631145238876, -1.2330437898635864, 0.22927871346473694, 0.059732481837272644, 0.7279841899871826, 0.1179894283413887, -1.2800829410552979, -0.18335981667041779, -0.12648625671863556, -0.046494074165821075, -0.4486199915409088, -0.1579095423221588, 0.7686979174613953, -0.5469288229942322, 0.19134187698364258, 0.7022967338562012, -0.3386613428592682, -0.5999907851219177, 0.08325084298849106, -0.3039120137691498, -0.10006024688482285, -0.2675096392631531, -0.08631353080272675, -0.08458901196718216, -0.5526357293128967, 0.2605546712875366, 0.6366454362869263, 0.08265741169452667, 0.5925101637840271, 0.35862013697624207, 0.12978433072566986, -0.21946558356285095, -0.09975802153348923, -0.8900558352470398, 0.0499458909034729, -1.324904441833496, -0.020395437255501747, -0.094765804708004, -0.4197927713394165, -0.5175292491912842, 0.27180230617523193, 0.2838500738143921, 0.5858811736106873, -0.5933221578598022, 0.370050847530365, 0.3427319824695587, -0.6014227271080017, 0.43324005603790283, 0.4647730886936188, -0.028761278837919235, 0.07911211252212524, -0.1635717898607254, 0.8459684252738953, -0.38963761925697327, 0.1683187633752823, 1.1346765756607056, -0.29518190026283264, -0.604297935962677, 0.2994080185890198, -0.07540255039930344, 0.5327883362770081, -0.06815196573734283, 0.5655144453048706, 0.6203902959823608, -0.5131481885910034, 0.4096992015838623, -0.2939162850379944, -0.23337653279304504, -0.4835883677005768, 0.2437383234500885, -0.5719476342201233, 0.5785180330276489, 0.4494260549545288, 0.4562051594257355, -0.8805479407310486, 0.20252615213394165, -0.5756434202194214, -0.9331955313682556, -0.033401008695364, -0.4952135980129242, 0.2778846323490143, 0.16765929758548737, 0.07082214951515198, -0.386409193277359, -0.5480435490608215, -0.5205405354499817, 0.31853798031806946, 0.7235713005065918, 0.20986352860927582, 0.6026687026023865, 0.7385650277137756, 0.17551542818546295, 0.14525052905082703, 0.7420886754989624, -0.23611854016780853, 0.26090824604034424, 0.05410371720790863, 0.014063334092497826, 0.6187068819999695, -0.20981080830097198, 0.5621457695960999, -0.14317356050014496, 0.5418737530708313, -0.4402797818183899, -1.0586951971054077, -0.8653172254562378, -0.7377848029136658, 0.022918200120329857, 0.05956069007515907, -0.42618435621261597, -0.14897401630878448, -0.45783209800720215, -0.3917559087276459, 0.2919752299785614, 0.09073962271213531, 0.34866729378700256, -1.0695080757141113, 0.3087727129459381, 0.5764267444610596, -0.7170272469520569, -0.4496268033981323, -0.08520689606666565, 0.5580947995185852, 0.3046259880065918, 0.9208351969718933, 0.3136530816555023, -0.29633796215057373, -0.2289751023054123, -0.3633909821510315, 0.7693012952804565, 0.6980458498001099, 0.4444372057914734, -0.013925829902291298, -0.3986480236053467, 0.22481591999530792, -0.714022159576416, -0.5787392258644104, -0.5309697389602661, -0.3761887550354004, 0.29345470666885376, -0.4747505187988281, -0.06295111030340195, 0.05172267556190491, 0.3673953115940094, 0.873580813407898, -0.06856866925954819, -0.326186865568161, -0.05145658552646637, -0.5564340353012085, -0.3633876442909241, 0.5939019322395325, 0.44177311658859253, -0.11351627856492996, -0.4937323331832886, 0.738131046295166, 0.4297017753124237, 0.637933611869812, 0.6437839269638062, -0.32234349846839905, -0.3834805488586426, -0.5227031707763672, 0.38778483867645264, 0.29570531845092773, 0.14042480289936066, 0.44821619987487793, 0.24744027853012085, 0.19136373698711395, -0.44017109274864197, 0.7715064883232117, 0.48567914962768555, 0.24425560235977173, -0.6016178131103516, -1.1069272756576538, 0.2255171686410904, -0.20465993881225586, 0.17776215076446533, 0.7688243985176086, 0.04862481355667114, -0.9558908939361572, -0.5762420296669006, 0.281628280878067, 0.5008032917976379, 0.22786745429039001, 0.9028266668319702, -0.451408326625824, 0.4651150703430176, -0.19661295413970947, 0.012509985826909542, 0.7345424890518188, 0.1257649064064026, -0.5002068877220154, 0.1798630952835083, 0.17495767772197723, -0.1506393551826477, 0.5877968072891235, 0.15766896307468414, -0.7771998643875122, -0.5689297914505005, -0.48638176918029785, 0.5672450661659241, -0.6148765087127686, -1.0035864114761353, 0.6057333946228027, 0.10294349491596222, -0.486291766166687, 0.43330422043800354, -0.5910959839820862, 0.15836270153522491, -0.10658308863639832, -0.0077522918581962585, -0.31335940957069397, 0.20456884801387787, -0.041955821216106415, -0.21659614145755768, 1.0729031562805176, 0.5579627156257629, 0.35820433497428894, 0.3139477074146271, 0.0730413943529129, 0.052548594772815704, -0.12111485004425049, 0.333665132522583, -0.06025564670562744, -0.35569384694099426, -0.1585414558649063, -0.04293321445584297, -0.4903084933757782, -0.2035270482301712, 0.5216037034988403, -0.3877348005771637, 0.585281252861023, 0.24361352622509003, -0.6233500838279724, -0.5465077757835388, -0.3255295157432556, -0.4511786699295044, 0.378155916929245, -0.23157505691051483, -0.3822353482246399, 0.09154315292835236, -0.05093052610754967, -0.11710193008184433, -0.81974858045578, -0.2853878438472748, -0.6344212293624878, -0.010325285606086254, 0.44098448753356934, 0.28381919860839844, 0.4512609541416168, -0.677308976650238, 0.7030767798423767, -0.37594106793403625, -0.641370952129364, -0.5677924156188965, -0.5067513585090637, -0.602222204208374, -0.5397405624389648, 0.3370274603366852, -0.4742870032787323, -0.016612505540251732, 0.4029328227043152, 0.46004095673561096, 0.40839484333992004, 0.19813287258148193, -0.4448786675930023, -0.4897162914276123, 0.43113911151885986, 0.3338790833950043, -0.453893780708313, 0.3074741065502167, 0.4015635550022125, 0.08288310468196869, 0.464292049407959, -0.08958814293146133, -0.7395555973052979, 0.17406408488750458, -1.1747910976409912, -0.11914653331041336, -0.8006949424743652, -0.5719554424285889, 0.18744848668575287, -0.10394802689552307, 0.3103082478046417, 0.28078174591064453, -0.010507256723940372, -0.6260112524032593, -0.2465963363647461, -0.049616001546382904, 0.08983875811100006, -0.8135620355606079, -0.06370656937360764, -0.7594208717346191, -0.007590130902826786, -0.37586262822151184, 1.1977050304412842, -1.3925714492797852, -0.2301858812570572, 0.3221054971218109, -0.394479900598526, -0.9624536037445068, 0.35539424419403076, 0.1084124967455864, 0.08480740338563919, 0.018812641501426697, 0.451583594083786, 0.10438740998506546, 0.8626036047935486, -0.23965001106262207, 0.5848459601402283, 0.012680621817708015, 0.3217986524105072, -0.6235309839248657, -0.10270140320062637, -0.2168554812669754, -0.2592375874519348, 1.0686208009719849, -0.5944362878799438, 0.10422733426094055, 0.9107153415679932, 0.3292001485824585, 0.8781133890151978, 0.0182030126452446, -1.2587964534759521, 0.15820331871509552, -0.4134935736656189, -0.3637441098690033, 0.723042368888855, -0.19377869367599487, -0.37991076707839966, -0.22676323354244232, -0.5468127727508545, -0.36171990633010864, 0.010675781406462193, -0.43995073437690735, 0.43545621633529663, -0.05468420684337616, -0.36793431639671326, -0.26374369859695435, 0.09082790464162827, -0.5358539819717407, 0.02329687401652336, 0.3134734630584717, 0.22801050543785095, -0.001628801808692515, -0.34832704067230225, -0.37237903475761414, -0.5770347118377686, -0.42473071813583374, 0.24979831278324127, 0.5703734159469604, -0.4261598289012909, 0.6959720253944397, -0.2760997414588928, -0.3304339051246643, -1.0143826007843018, -0.025743545964360237, 0.6593372821807861, -0.20066091418266296, 0.3060922920703888, 0.2532522678375244, -0.17625823616981506, -0.14056722819805145, 0.20568932592868805, -0.47215649485588074, -0.48041948676109314, 0.39909571409225464, -0.3097394108772278, -0.35604554414749146, 0.5012160539627075, 0.337973952293396, -0.37046486139297485, -0.7485441565513611, -1.2205325365066528, -0.4143400192260742, -0.02274460531771183, -0.3340364694595337, -0.06533150374889374, -0.4153912365436554, -0.6524796485900879, 0.3870411515235901, 0.8468226790428162, 0.7274235486984253, -0.4036780595779419, 0.1801321655511856, 0.11261174082756042, -0.45080822706222534, -0.33043450117111206, 0.7362241148948669, 0.16549061238765717, -0.3522323668003082, -0.17144307494163513, -0.20196707546710968, 0.004196677822619677, -0.48754337430000305, 0.8080828189849854, -0.5005471706390381, 0.07954958826303482, -0.055663079023361206, 0.3875350058078766, 0.16474181413650513, -0.030263716354966164, -0.39863282442092896, -0.046851545572280884, -0.857840359210968, -0.6460053324699402, 0.03630971163511276, 0.1992044299840927, 0.7144344449043274, 0.7810191512107849, -0.14559297263622284, -0.1979033648967743, -0.14452648162841797, 0.04836374893784523, -0.06620939075946808, -0.05257999897003174, -0.5664020776748657, -0.8075788617134094, -0.6328610181808472, -0.95100337266922, -0.13553088903427124, -0.2758066952228546, 0.3056621253490448, -0.3739017844200134, 0.23449940979480743, -0.14936557412147522, 0.27672359347343445, -0.11546491831541061, 0.40410470962524414, -0.1824464648962021, -0.6089681386947632, -0.8223731517791748, 0.4492134749889374, -0.21033132076263428, -0.8755843043327332, 0.08775688707828522, -0.21585646271705627, 0.008814833126962185, 0.7042797207832336, -0.4756116271018982, 1.0025084018707275, -0.21324031054973602, -0.22436852753162384, 0.0052499910816550255, -0.15470969676971436, -0.6261981129646301, 0.7169643044471741, -0.3272690176963806, 0.8431543111801147, 0.7111698389053345, 0.022544927895069122, -0.4619826078414917, -0.6255168318748474, -0.8775656819343567, 0.1842576265335083, 0.3146168887615204, 0.46687039732933044, 0.22753460705280304, -1.3051302433013916, 0.29023048281669617, 0.19490833580493927, -1.067477822303772, 0.3084315061569214, -0.5355612635612488, 0.3790361285209656, -0.5008940696716309, -0.06230500340461731, 0.1455388218164444, 0.49667999148368835, -0.70207679271698, 0.5382274985313416, -0.5184285640716553, 0.41821393370628357, 0.3246544897556305, 0.48676541447639465, -0.2015739381313324, -0.7458897233009338, 0.29910242557525635, -0.7594192028045654, 0.2390223741531372, 0.04463425651192665, -0.14119496941566467, 0.3510027229785919, 0.16077986359596252, 0.20794880390167236, -0.12381359189748764, 0.3500869870185852, -0.4665127694606781, 0.4016091227531433, 0.3317321240901947, 0.20897741615772247, 0.08911853283643723, -0.25283241271972656, -0.6131259799003601, -0.05624432489275932, -0.7526379227638245, -0.6195909380912781, 0.04591602459549904, -0.3357207775115967, 0.0950707271695137, 0.27256694436073303, -0.0035725946072489023, -0.3712885081768036, -0.31411027908325195, 0.9247161149978638, 1.2631360292434692, 0.16219142079353333, -0.3803284764289856, 0.1939665824174881, -0.7158812880516052, -0.6738892793655396, 0.08420807868242264, 0.14602774381637573, -0.5244336724281311, -0.5710642337799072, 0.030369160696864128, -0.1741422414779663, -0.49760788679122925, 0.04108195751905441, -0.230841726064682, -0.08413546532392502, -0.4957062602043152, 0.2419300228357315, -0.1697056144475937, -0.15958011150360107, -0.12728731334209442, 0.15191888809204102, 0.6034263968467712, -0.5858374834060669, 0.1955450475215912, -0.6648335456848145, 0.9436148405075073, 0.0033220867626369, -0.40501219034194946, 1.0827255249023438, -0.05668936297297478, 0.09141534566879272, 0.644561231136322, -0.053062889724969864, 0.4756024479866028, 0.6688344478607178, -0.2917209565639496, 0.023079216480255127, 0.5981931686401367, -0.4318865239620209, 0.465352863073349, 0.007354722823947668, -0.4456218183040619, 0.2511577904224396, 0.44300469756126404, 0.16850444674491882, -0.5160861015319824, -0.5722607970237732, 0.20522837340831757, 0.3276022672653198, -0.16908712685108185, 0.330166220664978, -0.18533989787101746, 0.1900140345096588, 0.5571675300598145, 0.15662206709384918, 0.01779029704630375, -1.004052996635437, -0.27630728483200073, 0.19731207191944122, -0.5152305364608765, -0.7272616624832153, -0.5001588463783264, 0.25647082924842834, 0.2796274721622467, -0.0723719522356987, -0.53849196434021, 0.21534964442253113, 0.058391015976667404, 0.06290778517723083, -0.1535627841949463, 0.26585134863853455, 0.42234277725219727, 0.9091285467147827, 0.9851090908050537, 0.3934652805328369, 0.31485703587532043, 0.20378288626670837, 0.5436554551124573, -1.1938695907592773, 0.6850001215934753, 0.432507187128067, -0.5455144643783569, 0.12099859863519669, -0.24488408863544464, 0.09254581481218338, -0.49944642186164856, -0.6774064898490906, -0.3287808299064636, -0.27735793590545654, 0.3012726306915283, -0.06229626014828682, -0.06381915509700775, 0.5685594081878662, 0.21735569834709167, -0.19311925768852234, 0.6468860507011414, 0.3301424980163574, -0.10053461045026779, -0.28025177121162415, 0.716327965259552, 1.0773513317108154, -0.10675187408924103, -0.14683890342712402, -0.5136018991470337, -0.3708254098892212, 0.9103134870529175, 0.6556214094161987, -0.4557580053806305, 0.14592571556568146, -0.40363118052482605, -0.33244019746780396, 0.006952208466827869, -0.008880442008376122, -0.37820544838905334, 0.2957983613014221, 0.14009633660316467, 0.8175211548805237, 0.1879972666501999, -0.013942187651991844, 0.45801517367362976, 0.5294125080108643, -0.3390769362449646, -0.18500210344791412, 0.6665168404579163, -0.37994980812072754, 0.3425159454345703, -0.8693802952766418, 0.7858313322067261, 0.21424125134944916, -0.11663569509983063, -0.4425681233406067, -0.1010083258152008, -0.1136111319065094, -1.1494107246398926, -0.027977874502539635, -0.2088356614112854, 0.15502236783504486, 0.8127034902572632, -0.042645275592803955, 0.5270889401435852, -0.04592103511095047, -0.20144404470920563, -0.013233250007033348, 1.3793389797210693, -0.04678014665842056, -0.13215751945972443, 0.5336460471153259, 0.0881427675485611, -0.465731680393219, 0.6791859269142151, 0.744811475276947, -0.18732325732707977, 0.44271111488342285, -0.48898693919181824, 0.16629040241241455, 0.11558427661657333, -0.007672461215406656, 0.13993921875953674, 0.8432506322860718, 0.8928481340408325, -0.16658033430576324, -0.5567190647125244, 0.013855144381523132, -0.8203851580619812, -0.20728585124015808, -0.2895677387714386, 0.6874681711196899, 0.32935968041419983, -0.0804058238863945, 0.6508454084396362, -0.5524201989173889, 4.370614528656006, 0.729466438293457, 0.5863099098205566, -0.17896194756031036, 0.7271814346313477, 0.8390451073646545, 0.274970144033432, -0.013667531311511993, 0.44923195242881775, -0.4012448787689209, 0.0505109578371048, -0.07132339477539062, 0.29106569290161133, 0.1771811991930008, 0.19608627259731293, 0.44279587268829346, 0.4906221926212311, 0.32568594813346863, -0.534906268119812, 0.17220768332481384, -1.0805844068527222, 0.211111381649971, 0.3845788240432739, -0.08003348857164383, 0.29844316840171814, 0.33704742789268494, 0.5972234606742859, -0.5200015306472778, -0.3339134752750397, -0.5679447650909424, -0.27210837602615356, -0.44462206959724426, -0.6083502173423767, 0.15594005584716797, -1.4383643865585327, 1.1735529899597168, 0.28780606389045715, -0.30771350860595703, 0.41009750962257385, -0.43468329310417175, -0.16872985661029816, -0.43626755475997925, 0.21889503300189972, 0.04724283143877983, -0.5680558681488037, 0.5270749926567078, 0.9157209992408752, 0.44154277443885803, 0.5257217288017273, -0.3819582164287567, 0.051520440727472305, 0.15472319722175598, 0.699062705039978, -0.5931992530822754, -1.0222928524017334, -0.2707092761993408, -0.264962375164032, -0.3365464210510254, 0.30058765411376953, -0.6385423541069031, 0.7857400178909302, -0.42726558446884155, -0.2087947428226471, 0.22429393231868744, 0.09239005297422409, 0.049005135893821716, 0.5604129433631897, 0.39014407992362976, -0.1507359892129898, 0.13857527077198029, -0.3145301938056946, 0.4365104138851166, -0.5347421169281006, -0.562232255935669, 0.17973917722702026, -0.1274598240852356, 0.07786479592323303, 0.40342476963996887, -0.3515873849391937, 0.29692766070365906, -0.5935786962509155, 0.44214826822280884, 0.04508323222398758, 0.47403210401535034, -0.06579429656267166, 0.4006592631340027, -0.25806301832199097, 0.13167037069797516, -0.33582696318626404, 0.6881628036499023, 0.24926187098026276, 0.9172481298446655, -0.39343157410621643, -0.17307232320308685, -0.8352237939834595 ]
The Mad Era: A Possible New Resolution to the Horizon, Flatness, and Monopole Problems
A cosmology with a dynamical Planck mass $m_{pl}$ is shown to solve the horizon and monopole problems (and possibly flatness) if there is an early MAD (modified aging) era where the universe becomes older than in the standard model as a result of a large $m_{pl}$: the causality condition is $m_{pl}(T_c)/ m_{pl}(T_o) \gta T_c/T_o$ ($T_c$ is some high temperature while $T_o = 2.74K$.) Unlike inflation, there is no period of vacuum domination nor any entropy violation. We study: a) bare scalar theories of gravity, b) self-interacting models, and c) bare theories with a phase transition in the matter sector.
Katherine Freese and Janna J Levin
astro-ph gr-qc hep-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211008
astro-ph/9211009
[ 0.3492062985897064, 0.06303802877664566, 0.33488550782203674, 0.3275255560874939, -0.39761674404144287, -0.5012630224227905, -0.6632809638977051, -0.18451997637748718, -0.8042094111442566, 0.8371975421905518, 0.006073262542486191, -0.37897923588752747, 0.4215088486671448, -0.928121030330658, -0.43817204236984253, -0.0815623328089714, -0.19845643639564514, -0.30924078822135925, -1.4957102537155151, -0.36998865008354187, 0.057682670652866364, -0.1742008477449417, -1.155847191810608, -0.4156056344509125, -0.795750617980957, 0.513567328453064, 0.2999741733074188, 1.1893725395202637, 1.6718100309371948, 0.38045939803123474, 0.02426370419561863, -0.5464032888412476, 0.014525783248245716, -0.9022210836410522, -0.09520702064037323, 0.15144799649715424, 0.37853965163230896, -0.5305910110473633, 0.0721202939748764, -0.16854026913642883, 1.1646578311920166, -0.24328064918518066, 0.8146432042121887, -0.7122665047645569, -0.2885231375694275, -0.3036375343799591, 0.088277667760849, -0.01154880877584219, 0.3688195049762726, -1.2637748718261719, 0.12351994216442108, 0.19432763755321503, 0.8492541313171387, -0.11065829545259476, 0.07920711487531662, -0.3799692988395691, -0.08069826662540436, 0.008614669553935528, 0.18248014152050018, -0.14547836780548096, 0.33614349365234375, 0.28061404824256897, 0.5347015857696533, 0.07844451814889908, -0.948547899723053, 1.061719298362732, 0.14656829833984375, 0.7845579981803894, -0.2374100536108017, 0.16980524361133575, 0.4025321900844574, 0.5686700940132141, 0.08022280037403107, 0.4697798192501068, -0.2070736289024353, 0.12011722475290298, -0.2697068750858307, -0.06568336486816406, -0.43749040365219116, -0.24677774310112, 0.32706373929977417, 0.07667043060064316, 0.5797640085220337, 0.6068844795227051, 0.08446216583251953, -0.22116762399673462, 0.530363142490387, 0.11789293587207794, 0.11227235198020935, -0.11583947390317917, -0.2013905942440033, 0.780500054359436, -0.216961070895195, 0.296782523393631, 0.5433864593505859, 0.06065519526600838, -0.09539468586444855, 0.2853911221027374, 0.08689075708389282, 0.4662820100784302, 0.23561592400074005, 1.1315124034881592, -0.39710670709609985, 0.5841085314750671, -0.6727281212806702, 0.41651052236557007, 0.5054116249084473, 0.16347432136535645, 0.44375333189964294, -1.1336331367492676, -0.27805885672569275, -0.14923125505447388, 0.041636861860752106, -0.1949547827243805, 0.33375200629234314, 0.039232347160577774, -0.03374378755688667, 0.37108612060546875, -0.5390859246253967, -0.1798047125339508, -0.08456866443157196, 0.5918485522270203, 0.33955836296081543, -0.05942142382264137, -0.0345546193420887, -0.10737801343202591, -0.18763276934623718, -0.27239173650741577, -0.6189054250717163, -0.24479903280735016, 0.4451119303703308, -0.43798747658729553, -0.5511886477470398, 0.7104071974754333, 0.3511938750743866, 0.2842591404914856, 0.6463467478752136, 1.1891833543777466, 0.16999487578868866, -0.8405262231826782, 0.16097499430179596, -0.5317784547805786, -0.5572295188903809, 1.361397624015808, -0.36260536313056946, -0.0764453187584877, 0.20752793550491333, -0.38145822286605835, -1.0057576894760132, -0.03148389980196953, -0.08070820569992065, -0.8776366114616394, -0.26315128803253174, 0.691457211971283, -0.6613373756408691, 0.5675753355026245, -0.5695254802703857, 0.07363703846931458, 0.27155157923698425, -0.5499351620674133, 0.2790276110172272, -0.6721997261047363, 0.4452914595603943, 0.915229082107544, -0.12920257449150085, 0.5972073674201965, -1.029184341430664, -0.6344984173774719, -0.2579522430896759, 0.04929318279027939, -0.20062091946601868, 0.2334766536951065, -0.05196027830243111, 0.6886538863182068, 0.6467625498771667, 0.3175472915172577, 0.22541140019893646, -1.123420000076294, -0.6784330010414124, 0.3401202857494354, -0.0076095303520560265, 0.3930482268333435, 0.7512497901916504, 0.24021798372268677, 0.8589610457420349, -0.02513522282242775, -0.6934643983840942, -0.32954683899879456, 0.5571525692939758, -0.00876406580209732, -0.08478575944900513, 0.5478498339653015, -0.5043110847473145, 0.663429856300354, -0.9418026208877563, 0.4005235731601715, -0.1530817747116089, -0.020106829702854156, -0.1956048160791397, -0.574897050857544, 0.9225376844406128, 0.39265626668930054, -0.5165127515792847, 0.3509160280227661, -0.20340536534786224, -0.25712868571281433, 0.7930846214294434, 0.7827966213226318, -0.12328522652387619, 0.3085198998451233, 0.5780511498451233, -0.050920188426971436, 0.11597796529531479, 0.18763074278831482, 0.6774601340293884, 0.03910423070192337, -0.2839798033237457, 0.39784854650497437, -0.6781774759292603, -0.09535343945026398, 0.5894889235496521, 0.3781382739543915, 0.09541215747594833, 0.37313535809516907, 0.06819003075361252, -0.4768640100955963, -0.5928532481193542, 0.20724202692508698, 0.009807238355278969, -0.09132688492536545, -0.12819449603557587, 0.12458126991987228, -0.4967186748981476, 0.26444798707962036, 0.20066526532173157, -0.6346216201782227, 0.9171720743179321, 0.22773464024066925, -0.20607908070087433, -0.19407260417938232, 0.3794465661048889, -0.39096856117248535, 0.3077067732810974, 0.21502308547496796, 0.11866085231304169, 0.9087059497833252, -0.1251244992017746, -0.09912656247615814, -0.40665996074676514, 0.1876554787158966, -0.5092501044273376, 0.4124790132045746, 0.005366186611354351, -0.2768302261829376, -0.83940190076828, -0.3092927038669586, -0.08238119632005692, 0.011682342737913132, 0.2637089490890503, -0.09965827316045761, -0.644022524356842, 0.060036759823560715, -0.51708984375, -0.0036995764821767807, -0.32536736130714417, 0.592583179473877, -0.8251271843910217, 0.1650926023721695, 0.8584176898002625, -0.0591583251953125, -1.084433913230896, -0.0512683279812336, -0.5224997997283936, -0.004275313578546047, 0.5286940336227417, 0.7958906888961792, 0.6746067404747009, -0.5787312984466553, 0.09268450736999512, -0.18156616389751434, -0.3196890950202942, 1.2120097875595093, -0.9384397268295288, -0.3208223581314087, -0.6450409293174744, 0.4310801923274994, -0.888846755027771, 0.40871497988700867, -0.5935661792755127, 0.6904364824295044, -0.1875520944595337, -0.018312929198145866, -0.7706134915351868, -0.10289128124713898, 0.7608149647712708, 0.09830012172460556, -0.09118688106536865, 0.3078271448612213, 0.7872062921524048, -0.636184811592102, 0.5487486720085144, -0.3142845630645752, -0.14695009589195251, -0.7646384835243225, -1.1667227745056152, 0.16319607198238373, 0.018115000799298286, -0.26948150992393494, 0.2825150191783905, -0.29577913880348206, -0.9711551666259766, 0.381862610578537, 0.2792361378669739, 0.3822224736213684, -0.15491952002048492, 0.24747778475284576, 0.30282002687454224, -0.06837955862283707, 0.9430416822433472, 0.16165423393249512, 0.014559467323124409, -0.24868109822273254, 0.4417303800582886, -0.25222551822662354, 0.11030377447605133, 1.4252433776855469, -0.005080204922705889, -0.36272192001342773, 0.5486218333244324, -0.5400285124778748, -0.1810583472251892, 0.4785558879375458, 0.19316735863685608, 0.4711565375328064, 0.13061738014221191, 0.06558769941329956, -0.2814163267612457, -0.1057509332895279, 0.3709409832954407, 0.6947855353355408, 0.3519553244113922, 0.13681510090827942, -0.292187362909317, 0.9573626518249512, -0.08731286227703094, -0.02685784362256527, 1.2125258445739746, -0.34085044264793396, 0.0005559853161685169, -0.03341827914118767, -0.22619497776031494, 0.1899264007806778, 0.41554683446884155, 0.4152303636074066, -0.1229204311966896, 0.6391394734382629, -0.1288958489894867, 0.5254095196723938, -0.49026745557785034, -0.4703509211540222, 0.0013844538480043411, 0.49560248851776123, 0.08702131360769272, -0.40893468260765076, 0.157585009932518, 0.08745530247688293, 0.22568227350711823, 0.2292432337999344, 0.2246074378490448, -0.8909807205200195, 0.380487859249115, -0.3496452271938324, -0.5632022619247437, -0.5495897531509399, 0.18032100796699524, 0.5427018404006958, 0.6880187392234802, -0.1901586949825287, 0.9908175468444824, 0.051027264446020126, -0.10117807984352112, -0.20251592993736267, 0.33455485105514526, -0.14539684355258942, 0.10944268852472305, 0.36960887908935547, 0.2432786077260971, 0.4995518624782562, -0.2829069495201111, -1.3125485181808472, -0.038822196424007416, -1.2263082265853882, 0.20569778978824615, -0.7788193225860596, -0.8453445434570312, 0.2760930061340332, 0.4286906123161316, 0.47563719749450684, 0.3395320773124695, -0.10720731317996979, 0.2979162931442261, -1.0833930969238281, -0.05485951900482178, 0.19864024221897125, -0.07015837728977203, 0.586993396282196, -0.5381043553352356, -0.2784323990345001, 0.09779144078493118, -0.12669241428375244, 0.3892591893672943, 0.06526500731706619, -0.30621665716171265, 0.4142661690711975, 0.04857320338487625, 0.4769376814365387, -0.532087504863739, 0.5067830085754395, 0.1090048998594284, 0.012799395248293877, -0.19294008612632751, 0.16656240820884705, 0.4923551678657532, 0.8293074369430542, -0.6646470427513123, -1.1349796056747437, -1.0564911365509033, -0.025627970695495605, -0.2153497338294983, 0.47135719656944275, -0.9205548167228699, -0.47670549154281616, -0.479499876499176, 0.27415895462036133, 0.33083415031433105, 0.8415639996528625, 0.5754812955856323, 0.27651381492614746, 0.7652931213378906, -0.45049041509628296, -0.07873285561800003, 0.27290987968444824, 0.17951196432113647, 0.35523632168769836, 0.7001957297325134, 0.7686718106269836, 0.11594847589731216, 0.4001791477203369, -0.24899588525295258, -0.7633557915687561, -0.9462976455688477, -0.28599944710731506, 1.3321760892868042, -0.022290773689746857, -0.6948654055595398, 1.1255850791931152, -0.3445117473602295, -0.24678991734981537, 0.4907873272895813, -0.12451378256082535, -0.1050189658999443, 0.02042757347226143, 0.242246612906456, -0.28103578090667725, -0.2554289698600769, -0.04586497321724892, -0.3777986168861389, 0.15224698185920715, 0.5808203816413879, 0.37424543499946594, 0.0679454356431961, 0.4995470643043518, -0.5247048139572144, -0.14987893402576447, -0.272403359413147, -0.7348812818527222, 0.1834108680486679, -0.6849369406700134, 0.04296804219484329, -0.3017006516456604, -0.09194174408912659, 0.1886666864156723, -0.37629640102386475, -0.00844119768589735, -0.5285987257957458, -0.5381690859794617, -0.009706451557576656, 0.14445514976978302, -0.38029661774635315, -0.07719077169895172, 0.052728813141584396, -1.0498356819152832, 0.012996175326406956, -0.5224162340164185, -0.6512935757637024, -0.2556500732898712, 0.46738386154174805, -0.5624551177024841, 0.10337516665458679, -0.2912048101425171, -0.16347375512123108, 0.041548606008291245, -1.0793291330337524, 0.41232621669769287, -0.4320032000541687, -0.31852394342422485, -0.8816766142845154, -0.08698131889104843, -0.530818521976471, 0.2958628535270691, -0.08240103721618652, 0.5074003338813782, -0.36890047788619995, -0.528571605682373, 0.23260511457920074, 0.7870182394981384, 0.2900489270687103, -1.0488678216934204, -0.07548554241657257, 0.23680844902992249, -0.011023208498954773, -0.22165678441524506, -0.5973603129386902, 0.8365629315376282, -0.2362924963235855, 0.11658024787902832, -0.829957127571106, -0.1505575329065323, 0.36923161149024963, -0.7039961814880371, 0.3762795329093933, -0.7645437717437744, 0.26195281744003296, 0.37158533930778503, -0.5973762273788452, 0.16773506999015808, -0.024591337889432907, 0.5770139098167419, -0.700226366519928, -0.44099754095077515, -0.4837450087070465, 0.9043444991111755, -0.19592110812664032, -0.36249402165412903, -0.2409946620464325, 0.2585533857345581, -0.8499199748039246, 1.0870482921600342, -0.5322142839431763, -0.05902868136763573, -0.16443520784378052, 0.01426627580076456, -0.13030539453029633, 0.3308115303516388, -0.07639722526073456, 0.36310282349586487, 0.03918827697634697, 0.014964360743761063, -0.11528962850570679, 0.9766181111335754, -0.8351671099662781, 0.2421615570783615, -0.9189814329147339, 0.2778116762638092, -0.07662991434335709, 0.05658305436372757, -0.26893821358680725, -0.0024900389835238457, 0.5070886015892029, -0.07705522328615189, 1.059545874595642, 1.017018437385559, -0.23462088406085968, 0.3064781725406647, 1.0212247371673584, -0.766504168510437, 0.045542094856500626, -0.09940497577190399, -0.4409715235233307, 0.5958006381988525, -0.0837133526802063, 0.2408280074596405, 0.10830666124820709, -0.25475451350212097, -0.14457255601882935, -0.2672431170940399, -0.02793566882610321, 0.5617539882659912, 0.05890939384698868, 0.9252660274505615, -0.5949785709381104, 0.07489705085754395, 0.0254722461104393, 0.14141081273555756, 0.2846875488758087, 0.5298274755477905, -0.39087074995040894, -0.13366472721099854, -0.18024948239326477, -0.2833520770072937, -1.311536192893982, 0.4487624168395996, 0.8081958293914795, -0.6412705779075623, 0.8763139247894287, -0.21230806410312653, -0.01781199872493744, -0.006791284307837486, 0.5547706484794617, 0.58355712890625, -0.6977425813674927, 0.3613130450248718, -0.6255379915237427, -0.2441883534193039, 0.7067164182662964, -0.4345947206020355, -0.13293007016181946, -0.29303959012031555, 0.2620619237422943, 0.14026129245758057, -0.32538193464279175, 0.43549469113349915, 0.6352752447128296, -0.7520619630813599, -0.28562307357788086, -0.9268178939819336, 0.13549630343914032, 0.2158428430557251, -0.3808266222476959, -0.894268810749054, -0.1928103268146515, -0.3380243182182312, 0.3109375238418579, -0.03185718506574631, 0.6781243085861206, 0.5780287981033325, 0.14846372604370117, -0.6967405080795288, -0.7842972874641418, 0.4331839978694916, 1.3712999820709229, 0.41108110547065735, -0.609235942363739, 0.15245269238948822, 0.24438226222991943, -0.42086440324783325, -0.38112756609916687, 1.5005531311035156, -0.23695108294487, -0.026274539530277252, -0.28841251134872437, -0.003969482611864805, 0.07254720479249954, 0.7678462862968445, 0.11676301807165146, 0.3553810119628906, -1.1018328666687012, -0.08460421860218048, -0.008810732513666153, -0.28621405363082886, -0.47097232937812805, 0.26361945271492004, 0.5402069091796875, -0.5112285614013672, 0.15892690420150757, -0.8258248567581177, 0.04651292786002159, -0.013778580352663994, -0.2816547155380249, -0.16487672924995422, -0.8833549618721008, -0.5688608288764954, -0.3973986506462097, 0.2103549689054489, 0.09820754826068878, -0.07221019268035889, -0.2730123698711395, 0.18310339748859406, 0.8156934380531311, -0.04706934094429016, 0.9335635900497437, -0.26236626505851746, -0.06802096217870712, -0.4756651818752289, 0.2206687331199646, -0.6799605488777161, -1.2414805889129639, -0.3815424144268036, -0.3874720335006714, -0.06683538854122162, 0.6835375428199768, 0.32064443826675415, 0.7146017551422119, -0.30838367342948914, -0.08624206483364105, -0.04871267452836037, -0.5551104545593262, -1.1767430305480957, 0.41723495721817017, -0.36720484495162964, 0.588859498500824, 0.09460359066724777, -1.1850520372390747, 0.13326215744018555, -0.14122292399406433, -0.7753586769104004, 0.6196700930595398, -0.47911134362220764, 1.367061734199524, 0.11478554457426071, -0.5396555662155151, -0.10675519704818726, 1.0053510665893555, -1.0990447998046875, -0.2926458418369293, -0.7349913120269775, 0.34361395239830017, -0.04493553191423416, -0.20063874125480652, 0.6348261833190918, 0.095281220972538, 0.18212583661079407, 0.43586108088493347, -0.5789670944213867, -0.06552271544933319, -0.46773919463157654, 0.2928137481212616, -0.38637927174568176, -0.04429777339100838, 0.09969019144773483, -0.5466779470443726, 0.5534908175468445, 0.4447912275791168, 0.38625162839889526, -0.29300811886787415, -0.19779574871063232, -0.008592447265982628, -0.051405057311058044, -0.04367394000291824, -0.293709933757782, 0.6923062801361084, 0.32135578989982605, 0.6548088788986206, 0.0004489818529691547, 0.04178726300597191, -1.1934581995010376, 0.34259840846061707, -0.22161178290843964, -0.4682904779911041, 0.2587886154651642, -0.4114154577255249, 0.17455975711345673, -0.008184832520782948, -0.5028616786003113, 0.36430326104164124, 0.18349361419677734, 0.44344666600227356, 0.14342603087425232, -0.10531406104564667, -0.4430364668369293, 0.8150693774223328, -1.2664449214935303, -0.3928615152835846, -1.1708872318267822, 0.798697292804718, -1.09283447265625, -0.6351454257965088, 0.4691762328147888, -0.1238526850938797, -0.6836692094802856, -0.22723537683486938, -0.4512166976928711, -0.3974524140357971, -0.3056747317314148, -1.289577603340149, -1.4890104532241821, -0.1577165722846985, -0.5746188163757324, 0.3009515106678009, -0.17719337344169617, 0.36635011434555054, 0.06596557796001434, 0.433915376663208, 1.4289339780807495, -0.3562316298484802, -0.7595778703689575, 0.5944717526435852, -0.06279726326465607, -0.022317664697766304, -0.5345878601074219, 0.866443932056427, 0.00642781239002943, -0.04415680468082428, -0.9826775789260864, 0.011075119487941265, 0.27387911081314087, -0.4467576742172241, 0.4219593405723572, -0.3687747120857239, -0.04627547040581703, 0.017020707949995995, -0.09287469834089279, 0.34524694085121155, 0.18795828521251678, -0.2153151035308838, -0.30441465973854065, -0.4657062292098999, -0.0039956592954695225, 0.3619864881038666, 0.10136691480875015, -0.0399937741458416, 0.14956876635551453, -0.09012355655431747, -0.3455946147441864, -0.5677526593208313, -0.11715825647115707, 0.1548997014760971, -0.9938216209411621, -0.25518563389778137, -0.38191911578178406, 0.27331647276878357, 0.018513770774006844, -0.009548029862344265, -0.08852501958608627, 0.21789367496967316, 0.09485148638486862, -0.09931238740682602, -0.6137092113494873, 0.5137564539909363, 0.37855976819992065, 1.0026994943618774, 0.12450459599494934, 0.700977087020874, -0.07915034890174866, 0.4093135893344879, -0.3364426791667938, -0.5058688521385193, 0.04808121547102928, 0.522716760635376, -0.14629021286964417, 0.21792073547840118, 0.051376014947891235, -0.7447963356971741, -0.08670683950185776, -0.24083757400512695, 0.11582708358764648, -0.9325236082077026, 0.456463098526001, 0.5728696584701538, -0.3067372739315033, 0.4176901876926422, -0.31903916597366333, 0.1181037649512291, 0.23867212235927582, 0.7765846252441406, 0.14993916451931, -0.2502872049808502, 0.7360832691192627, 0.7228301167488098, -0.27015459537506104, 0.5778045058250427, -0.5629797577857971, -0.12004760652780533, -0.48446106910705566, 0.19431142508983612, -0.41162192821502686, 0.43974584341049194, -0.11755377054214478, 0.31351199746131897, -0.11121539026498795, 0.0050422511994838715, -0.18477049469947815, -0.35423603653907776, 0.2782912254333496, 0.14211368560791016, -1.013912320137024, -0.3450888991355896, 0.5042122602462769, 0.6497101187705994, -0.12467411905527115, -0.09539502114057541, 0.22000131011009216, -0.33787935972213745, -0.2703007459640503, 0.013125981204211712, 0.5960246324539185, -0.41154128313064575, -0.29284435510635376, -0.6415355801582336, 0.2745440900325775, 0.4517957866191864, -0.49478039145469666, -0.4895019233226776, 0.29874172806739807, 0.396292507648468, 1.5307369232177734, 0.6262524724006653, 0.349244087934494, -0.9881890416145325, -1.0413093566894531, -0.7588328123092651, 0.352916955947876, -0.33315739035606384, 0.3156774938106537, 0.6305556893348694, 0.726417601108551, -0.09284942597150803, 0.0660257637500763, 0.734944760799408, -0.526372492313385, 0.23222212493419647, 0.26437437534332275, 0.5328589677810669, 0.3907061219215393, -0.2909165322780609, 0.13961631059646606, 0.8418986201286316, -0.2643360495567322, 0.6087364554405212, -0.022746242582798004, 0.28566452860832214, -0.6983135938644409, -0.09139540046453476, -0.2888307571411133, 0.3515426814556122, -0.43750736117362976, -0.33236947655677795, -0.33098548650741577, -0.5442020297050476, 4.194857597351074, 0.35413363575935364, 0.47516554594039917, -0.30752691626548767, 0.4487497806549072, 0.41650307178497314, 0.4401051998138428, -0.3118683695793152, 0.4604511260986328, 0.22362752258777618, 0.08969045430421829, 0.05700450390577316, 1.0010969638824463, 0.5581452250480652, 0.1944250464439392, 0.6636658906936646, -0.2082900106906891, -0.3109930455684662, 0.48474740982055664, -0.6072698831558228, -0.771870493888855, -0.49693161249160767, 0.24814572930335999, -0.04710632562637329, 0.6364160776138306, -0.05417836084961891, 0.734602689743042, -0.49102288484573364, -0.31868982315063477, -0.17070268094539642, -1.0780339241027832, -0.8727417588233948, 1.074569582939148, -0.2990489900112152, -0.4773557186126709, 0.2800220549106598, 0.39324504137039185, -0.07686910778284073, -0.4875287711620331, 0.055098868906497955, -0.28617435693740845, -0.4472537636756897, -0.03187434747815132, -0.3245462477207184, 0.4282345771789551, 0.9539783596992493, 0.674884021282196, 0.26437196135520935, 0.5018036365509033, -0.8444353342056274, 0.36774811148643494, 0.043375413864851, -0.36791372299194336, -0.5347724556922913, -1.3379851579666138, 0.4378945231437683, -0.6439568400382996, -0.6103436350822449, -0.5573944449424744, -0.023758629336953163, -0.008920841850340366, -0.5181201100349426, -0.7185843586921692, 0.4635733664035797, -0.32176560163497925, 0.44052398204803467, 0.057250019162893295, -0.007615293376147747, 0.026618963107466698, -0.381198525428772, -0.27328452467918396, -0.40280869603157043, -0.05197206512093544, 0.08832301199436188, 0.5399657487869263, 0.18091148138046265, 0.1942090094089508, -0.6580113768577576, 0.38627544045448303, 0.15502414107322693, -0.3565901517868042, 0.42969557642936707, -0.21496883034706116, 0.8698930740356445, -0.30086514353752136, 0.3686550259590149, -0.03561750054359436, -0.5530345439910889, 0.5377486944198608, 0.7233176231384277, 0.03156564384698868, 0.271915465593338, -0.3891875743865967, 0.22129318118095398, -0.2778744101524353 ]
Fireballs in the Galactic Halo and $\gamma$-Ray Bursts
If gamma ray burst sources are in the galactic halo they inevitably involve a creation of an opaque pair plasma fireball, just like in cosmological sources. We find that the typical physical conditions in a galactic halo fireball are: optical depth $\ap 10^8$, thermal energy $\ap 100 KeV$, maximal relativstic expansion $\G \ap 300 $ and a maximal baryonic load of $\ap 10^{-15} M_\odot$. This does not rule out galctic halo models but it poses an addtional severe constraint on all such sources. A comparison of these conditions with the physical conditions at cosmological fireballs reveal that galactic halo fireballs are less favorable than cosmological ones as sources of gamma ray bursts.
Tsvi Piran and Amotz Shemi
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211009
astro-ph/9211010
[ 0.3030879497528076, -0.15518958866596222, 0.42501795291900635, 0.22653985023498535, -0.25742337107658386, -0.5454920530319214, -0.5922329425811768, -0.027575353160500526, -0.4299520254135132, 0.968927800655365, -0.011185781098902225, -0.25202426314353943, 0.32192182540893555, -0.6840322613716125, -0.09882128238677979, -0.10137993842363358, -0.0000037578356568701565, -0.3850790858268738, -1.436059832572937, 0.40042921900749207, 0.6400243639945984, 0.2913113534450531, -1.0127208232879639, -0.3999604284763336, -0.009451054036617279, 0.3677997291088104, 1.1624081134796143, 0.2673720717430115, 0.8338005542755127, 0.44847679138183594, -0.2933260500431061, -1.2266932725906372, 0.4198761284351349, -1.0525099039077759, -0.39737457036972046, 0.2881210744380951, 0.15847456455230713, -0.399598091840744, -0.03745529428124428, 0.37695300579071045, 0.6259667277336121, 0.05715734884142876, 1.0405993461608887, -0.24103505909442902, -0.7952085733413696, 0.08665533363819122, 0.1072225496172905, -0.3575611710548401, 0.4242188632488251, -0.7317938208580017, -0.09614598751068115, 0.05909072235226631, 0.5461564064025879, 0.4115372896194458, 0.46643102169036865, -0.6184784770011902, 0.19436252117156982, 0.3828537166118622, -0.32832464575767517, -0.5174573063850403, 0.8693346977233887, 0.3352212607860565, 0.75457763671875, -0.41301169991493225, -0.4711849093437195, 1.302230715751648, -0.22156094014644623, 0.34784573316574097, -0.20412401854991913, -0.3712051808834076, 0.5863553881645203, 0.0645698755979538, 0.022330960258841515, 0.7385258674621582, -0.3839004337787628, 0.07351274788379669, -0.0016827770741656423, 0.3431394398212433, -0.8060812950134277, -0.18747076392173767, 0.21073156595230103, -0.0793282687664032, 0.2741350531578064, 0.2922930121421814, -0.17617201805114746, -0.9321953654289246, 0.7872212529182434, 0.07445982843637466, -0.11311715096235275, -0.1989041566848755, 0.25687387585639954, 0.48685258626937866, -0.06999597698450089, 0.21848858892917633, 1.058089017868042, 0.029471909627318382, -0.7492942810058594, 0.10514169931411743, 0.48946133255958557, 0.8027395009994507, -0.4116906523704529, 1.415117859840393, -0.6559263467788696, 0.32612261176109314, -0.47030171751976013, 0.5242953300476074, 0.4040370583534241, -0.09234324097633362, 0.3564167022705078, -1.1073929071426392, 0.03348969295620918, 0.20263224840164185, 0.6304214596748352, -0.02688356675207615, 0.6631220579147339, 0.506230890750885, -0.35667112469673157, 0.6292480826377869, -0.6371691823005676, -0.017964446917176247, -0.2993510663509369, 0.858877420425415, 0.034891631454229355, -0.03427618369460106, 0.5705258250236511, -0.27516961097717285, -0.021459385752677917, 0.16891023516654968, -0.7120614051818848, 0.32631731033325195, 0.3795418441295624, -0.6792988181114197, -0.32812246680259705, 1.1955043077468872, 0.5574584603309631, -0.2104441374540329, 0.5156106948852539, 0.9566894173622131, 0.24173422157764435, -1.1485363245010376, 0.123743936419487, -0.35152581334114075, -0.00960866641253233, 1.3887149095535278, -0.7218919396400452, -0.11371888965368271, 0.09346941113471985, -0.5219113230705261, -0.8222975134849548, 0.2419649064540863, 0.39362508058547974, -0.512521505355835, 0.04580622538924217, 0.0678131952881813, -0.9372077584266663, 0.30816370248794556, -0.6610521078109741, 0.07616756111383438, 0.29259419441223145, -0.4896511733531952, 0.24546660482883453, -0.1856134533882141, 0.5093483924865723, 0.7624964714050293, -0.41880133748054504, 0.5562365055084229, -1.0238288640975952, -0.4788273870944977, -0.3312835395336151, -0.00948403961956501, -0.5843038558959961, 0.35949650406837463, 0.25491610169410706, 0.6330326795578003, 0.5606049299240112, 0.5097434520721436, 0.0714552253484726, -0.6263649463653564, -0.7228869199752808, 0.5181677341461182, 0.4639393985271454, 0.1612907499074936, -0.08932741731405258, 0.03701440989971161, -0.5748939514160156, -0.11297652870416641, -0.06987284123897552, -0.08795209228992462, 0.7472840547561646, 0.14222562313079834, 0.554869532585144, 0.45619770884513855, -1.4685003757476807, 0.4071158766746521, -0.9361777305603027, 0.4500585198402405, 0.04383016750216484, -0.3161638379096985, 0.01649218425154686, -0.9367384910583496, 0.7563199996948242, 0.10457982122898102, -0.14003486931324005, 0.4374673068523407, -0.7566790580749512, -0.47113385796546936, 0.9011536240577698, 0.6657727360725403, -0.515794038772583, 0.1660442352294922, 0.1036432534456253, -0.14806708693504333, 0.4992254674434662, 0.021417612209916115, 0.8002601265907288, -0.28774458169937134, 0.011276856996119022, 0.26032719016075134, -0.04679548740386963, -0.3211541473865509, 0.4905938506126404, 0.3095177114009857, 0.49662142992019653, 0.7780909538269043, 0.21540296077728271, -0.662761926651001, 0.054034773260354996, 0.3902823030948639, -0.6465266346931458, 0.14078648388385773, -0.28757262229919434, -0.21413886547088623, 0.1763804852962494, 0.13500289618968964, 0.530022919178009, -0.7156147956848145, 0.6154857873916626, 0.7127901315689087, -0.006370274815708399, -0.038052018731832504, 0.10584168881177902, -0.7536836862564087, 0.31469595432281494, 0.4619641900062561, -0.3715541958808899, 0.20578069984912872, -0.1643284261226654, -0.33617329597473145, -0.19898994266986847, 0.24842102825641632, -0.8028651475906372, 0.6265486478805542, 0.04241706430912018, 0.08922187983989716, -1.072468638420105, -0.4073852300643921, 0.34004107117652893, 0.22521357238292694, 0.05111822113394737, -0.1999163031578064, -1.0338259935379028, 0.28250041604042053, -0.5135191679000854, -0.4536774158477783, -0.36682137846946716, 0.28531649708747864, -0.8176952600479126, 0.7066134810447693, 0.49574288725852966, -0.20788568258285522, -1.0233067274093628, 0.2015717327594757, 0.06032906472682953, -0.32223138213157654, -0.07570093870162964, 0.6229094862937927, 0.2827880382537842, -0.46257519721984863, 0.40065622329711914, -0.17711949348449707, -0.3483813405036926, 0.9313230514526367, -1.0079337358474731, 0.021984988823533058, -0.6614440679550171, 0.39036592841148376, -1.1107258796691895, 0.32722657918930054, -0.49376437067985535, 0.8651711344718933, 0.1341349184513092, 0.39470574259757996, -0.5113877654075623, -0.159669890999794, 0.7724649310112, 0.08392412215471268, -0.1578327864408493, 0.17280477285385132, 0.4533837139606476, -0.4025469422340393, 0.5491079092025757, -0.04070033133029938, -0.09826163202524185, -0.2892419993877411, -0.7730257511138916, -0.03982746973633766, -0.22617299854755402, -0.4183543622493744, 0.5861771106719971, 0.039202265441417694, -0.6703665852546692, 0.2934221625328064, 0.24167056381702423, 0.48611918091773987, 0.17610491812229156, 0.2577280104160309, -0.20463304221630096, 0.5449997186660767, 0.3488175570964813, 0.012249547988176346, -0.6033056974411011, -0.3655869662761688, -0.13602282106876373, 0.09790043532848358, -0.12451695650815964, 1.187833309173584, 0.03376525640487671, -0.4658261239528656, 0.3083266615867615, -0.38870465755462646, -0.10443279147148132, 0.5210734009742737, -0.010731205344200134, 0.9340561628341675, 0.3619770109653473, -0.6158106923103333, -0.2755352854728699, 0.09907525777816772, 0.34797513484954834, 0.022233091294765472, 0.4632852077484131, -0.3798273801803589, -0.181056410074234, 1.030792236328125, -0.03302958607673645, -0.4730478525161743, 0.8357981443405151, -0.3083110749721527, -0.08210649341344833, 0.08478883653879166, -0.2798989415168762, 0.21556930243968964, -0.13289675116539001, 0.6514149308204651, -0.10203801095485687, 0.157529816031456, -0.3783148527145386, -0.051176853477954865, -0.5770668983459473, -0.9434564709663391, -0.09904995560646057, 0.7865269780158997, 0.28289952874183655, 0.24353796243667603, -0.2886776328086853, 0.2496359795331955, -0.3717605173587799, -0.21347610652446747, 0.18820086121559143, -0.7148281335830688, 0.47721052169799805, 0.4936777651309967, -1.2854710817337036, -0.43648797273635864, -0.15438732504844666, -0.225416362285614, 0.35889893770217896, -0.050043851137161255, 0.4568456709384918, 0.04421956092119217, 0.10593638569116592, -0.2469344437122345, 0.6109633445739746, -0.22600845992565155, 0.34302133321762085, 0.17451196908950806, 0.16083627939224243, -0.062462419271469116, -0.015512489713728428, -0.8362869024276733, -0.30584001541137695, -1.1355255842208862, 0.38637012243270874, -0.8935874104499817, -0.717573344707489, 0.8644850254058838, 0.37450265884399414, 0.2045871913433075, -0.3470813035964966, -0.3587163984775543, 0.47802579402923584, -0.6299125552177429, 0.09476513415575027, 0.25798705220222473, -0.34683525562286377, 0.7051962614059448, -0.9257580637931824, -0.47149184346199036, 0.14380110800266266, -0.18733789026737213, -0.012001216411590576, -0.4453996419906616, 0.05309689790010452, -0.00384890241548419, 0.1777280569076538, 0.31011468172073364, -0.5437329411506653, 1.0539546012878418, 0.5092930197715759, -0.17561465501785278, -0.5789148807525635, 0.5989912748336792, 0.31452420353889465, 0.46062278747558594, -0.8667075037956238, -1.376702070236206, -0.5452707409858704, -0.9117802977561951, 0.00902510154992342, 0.7496449947357178, -0.05322537571191788, -0.3185344934463501, -0.20933547616004944, -0.1787102222442627, 0.3437236547470093, 0.2148117572069168, 0.5905513763427734, 0.06778143346309662, 0.24577972292900085, -0.8312528729438782, -0.19082915782928467, 0.7297260165214539, -0.38756662607192993, 0.5526959300041199, -0.05901007354259491, 0.448941707611084, -0.11761388182640076, 0.5245392322540283, -0.23302368819713593, -1.3129998445510864, -0.50974041223526, -0.6271828413009644, 0.748879611492157, -0.15185973048210144, -1.2411564588546753, 1.0810133218765259, -0.18873925507068634, 0.07866872847080231, 0.32775193452835083, -0.054998110979795456, 0.030616365373134613, -0.27919405698776245, 0.47227227687835693, -0.4487605094909668, -0.6005412936210632, -0.3795296847820282, -0.08232393860816956, -0.12876473367214203, 0.6804907321929932, -0.045344527810811996, 0.4602062404155731, 0.030028896406292915, -0.37129148840904236, 0.07357096672058105, 0.1763879507780075, -0.24806660413742065, 0.18248964846134186, 0.34777000546455383, -0.2798854410648346, -0.7118570804595947, -0.6896569728851318, 0.24770070612430573, -0.2863086760044098, 0.0036536301486194134, -0.7395926117897034, -0.6549134254455566, -0.4039373993873596, 0.02997199445962906, -0.20357351005077362, 0.0869879201054573, 0.09039569646120071, -0.47827911376953125, -0.043612588196992874, -0.04559267312288284, -0.5621077418327332, 0.0980171412229538, -0.04692918807268143, -0.8324741125106812, 0.13300955295562744, -0.010309289209544659, -0.08476197719573975, 0.45205333828926086, -0.6219406723976135, 0.35665228962898254, -0.22738148272037506, -0.33347463607788086, -0.4802438020706177, -0.2263442575931549, -0.9715718030929565, 0.48049694299697876, -0.3020418882369995, 0.731200635433197, -0.20979534089565277, 0.049036379903554916, 0.15050607919692993, 0.41786980628967285, -0.22608768939971924, -0.583928108215332, -0.6315896511077881, 0.36181944608688354, -0.11474815011024475, -0.6326032876968384, -1.0965217351913452, 1.0502184629440308, -0.7305769920349121, 0.5266815423965454, -0.2987317442893982, -1.0107598304748535, -0.332878977060318, -1.0092487335205078, 0.5900267958641052, -0.764268159866333, 0.8160929083824158, -0.15781371295452118, -0.7850029468536377, 0.19128596782684326, 0.3384292423725128, 1.1668769121170044, -0.7696710824966431, -0.34760862588882446, -0.3221358358860016, 0.5744102001190186, -0.4324219524860382, 0.1629309356212616, -0.5819488167762756, 0.17410391569137573, -0.5866855382919312, 0.6209982633590698, -0.3380381166934967, -0.5123468041419983, 0.10283486545085907, 0.4610823392868042, 0.032497588545084, 0.5058544278144836, 0.1603119671344757, 0.10610464215278625, -0.060866694897413254, -0.2262813150882721, 0.04945551976561546, 0.9355911612510681, -0.6257320046424866, -0.08629977703094482, -0.8354527950286865, -0.026670638471841812, -0.012252558022737503, 0.18484555184841156, -0.274292528629303, 0.4117066264152527, 0.26212531328201294, -0.0869925320148468, 0.7814866304397583, 1.1381524801254272, 0.13104695081710815, 0.5230724811553955, 0.6441847085952759, -0.5205804109573364, -0.24129660427570343, -0.2348836362361908, -0.40979012846946716, 0.5545903444290161, 0.16513535380363464, -0.004706470295786858, -0.21708564460277557, -0.0794311910867691, -0.13136889040470123, -0.6996463537216187, 0.603608250617981, -0.1059073656797409, 0.3509455919265747, -0.12392791360616684, -0.22136397659778595, -0.47080785036087036, -0.06437564641237259, 0.1342967301607132, 0.6677775979042053, -0.4630933105945587, -0.39784666895866394, -0.023951858282089233, -0.5586414933204651, -0.47117942571640015, -0.7837483286857605, 0.21473246812820435, 0.5830090045928955, -0.4299165904521942, 1.1875097751617432, -0.4849432408809662, 0.2352636605501175, -0.18142037093639374, 0.39054980874061584, 0.8544654250144958, -0.8366787433624268, 0.4423661530017853, -0.3205457627773285, -0.23001521825790405, 0.4375688433647156, -0.8095936179161072, -0.34724390506744385, -0.03229071944952011, 0.7490496635437012, -0.426917165517807, -0.07995419204235077, 0.49291563034057617, 0.1783285140991211, -0.40052878856658936, -0.523796558380127, -0.758676290512085, -0.0003414310049265623, 0.35503992438316345, -0.10667769610881805, -0.864712655544281, -0.08150316774845123, -0.13414137065410614, 0.40993472933769226, 0.4153350591659546, 0.9652047753334045, 0.21375788748264313, 0.384982168674469, -0.03416544198989868, -0.9190644025802612, 0.731753408908844, 1.4509047269821167, 0.5409298539161682, -0.12066683918237686, 0.17431211471557617, -0.028268877416849136, -1.080377221107483, -0.8033673763275146, 0.9911060333251953, 0.018018601462244987, 0.3993821144104004, 0.22128506004810333, 0.10675063729286194, 0.49963241815567017, 0.6415721774101257, -0.6025682091712952, 0.21252356469631195, -0.338922381401062, -0.4624575078487396, -0.37716054916381836, -0.3307788074016571, -0.18113218247890472, 0.7224605679512024, 0.6464242339134216, -0.31127825379371643, -0.005911556538194418, -0.42104804515838623, 0.09771692007780075, -0.10889937728643417, -0.402396023273468, -0.44445109367370605, -1.0880422592163086, -0.21880316734313965, -0.179342120885849, 0.42414790391921997, 0.533149242401123, -0.09957238286733627, 0.5252936482429504, 0.19203723967075348, 0.5403609871864319, -0.15199853479862213, 1.1936379671096802, -0.6567659974098206, -0.2822723090648651, -0.8321437239646912, -0.1913328915834427, -0.15606318414211273, -1.4744349718093872, 0.02895062416791916, -0.44279366731643677, -0.1011962816119194, 1.2035019397735596, -0.14125847816467285, 0.4280673563480377, -0.4091278314590454, -0.08298865705728531, -0.2218003273010254, -0.1084403321146965, -0.9474353790283203, 0.43880075216293335, -0.14724692702293396, 0.35510489344596863, 0.2031497359275818, -1.0361700057983398, 0.37739306688308716, -0.03553881123661995, -0.7637348175048828, 0.16441276669502258, -0.07583321630954742, 1.0670520067214966, 0.5255218744277954, -1.0000720024108887, -0.34087464213371277, 1.0630475282669067, -0.7971161603927612, -0.12215924263000488, -0.10393538326025009, 0.1331029087305069, -0.4232196509838104, 0.502071738243103, -0.0573875717818737, -0.1386258453130722, -0.3920897841453552, 0.35902509093284607, -0.5331831574440002, 0.22961634397506714, -0.11208187788724899, 0.6432300806045532, -0.19473706185817719, -0.12946954369544983, 0.31755444407463074, -0.160954549908638, -0.07723351567983627, 0.24620671570301056, 0.3366226553916931, -0.3636053502559662, -0.08628518879413605, 0.26742494106292725, -0.2909235656261444, -0.340139776468277, -0.6557527780532837, 0.5302109122276306, 0.20071107149124146, 0.6418958902359009, 0.33023566007614136, -0.18590374290943146, -1.264714002609253, 0.21346259117126465, -0.6022583842277527, -0.590433657169342, 0.4659804701805115, -0.0925041064620018, -0.005033100955188274, 0.053762201219797134, -0.12114310264587402, 0.8961859345436096, 0.160838320851326, 0.40022704005241394, 0.6494821310043335, -0.013287928886711597, -0.3720814883708954, 0.9616726040840149, -0.8634494543075562, 0.014727135188877583, -0.8175047636032104, 0.6418748497962952, -1.0556503534317017, -0.9216994643211365, -0.3035123944282532, 0.21239930391311646, -0.10817922651767731, -0.3158133924007416, -0.07506079226732254, -0.6112166047096252, -0.36099424958229065, -0.6968913078308105, -0.8804202079772949, -0.25143668055534363, -0.5301169157028198, 0.056626565754413605, -0.3744204342365265, 0.12261076271533966, 0.16314303874969482, 0.17536680400371552, 1.1848448514938354, -0.26129859685897827, -0.9516042470932007, 0.7469383478164673, 0.7841365933418274, 0.6600326895713806, 0.0835733637213707, 0.49021202325820923, 0.395287424325943, 0.24401044845581055, -0.8361085653305054, 0.12914055585861206, 0.8978931903839111, -0.26677584648132324, 0.39324870705604553, -0.05630473047494888, 0.14699076116085052, 0.2820698618888855, -0.1461048126220703, 0.35116180777549744, 0.24726909399032593, 0.05803569406270981, -0.5177992582321167, -0.21255269646644592, 0.04327501356601715, 0.44155827164649963, 0.10914289951324463, -0.11871663480997086, 0.8514304757118225, -0.020842809230089188, -0.2605886459350586, -0.7341357469558716, 0.17449511587619781, 0.09061763435602188, -0.8609894514083862, -0.5144115686416626, -0.6207155585289001, 0.18005339801311493, -0.18232277035713196, 0.027595490217208862, -0.28289973735809326, -0.10077569633722305, -0.20290246605873108, 0.08452814817428589, -0.3342217803001404, 0.35544586181640625, 0.5904151797294617, 0.3902148902416229, 0.43365171551704407, 0.8920519351959229, -0.38733503222465515, 1.2352324724197388, -0.03307643160223961, -0.6577230095863342, -0.3029923439025879, -0.0560416541993618, 0.027750352397561073, 0.10176898539066315, 0.516334056854248, -0.06901449710130692, -0.3377024531364441, -0.6139849424362183, 0.19036611914634705, -1.298926830291748, 0.28274744749069214, 0.1937159150838852, -0.4186397194862366, 0.375577837228775, -0.24612517654895782, 0.009447133168578148, 0.3156568706035614, 1.0157443284988403, 0.30901196599006653, -0.6593937873840332, 1.0345308780670166, 0.7751784920692444, -0.2960415482521057, 0.3493877053260803, -0.4883682429790497, 0.2793443500995636, -0.41948679089546204, -0.36790770292282104, -0.48833975195884705, 0.41276031732559204, -0.15547706186771393, -0.03213660791516304, 0.10436639934778214, -0.20683515071868896, 0.10343828797340393, -0.3236798346042633, 0.4208960235118866, 0.46719688177108765, -1.005105972290039, -0.3394392430782318, 0.19417142868041992, 1.1374571323394775, -0.028691183775663376, -0.8937340378761292, 0.16434410214424133, -0.6083713173866272, -0.5630068778991699, -0.9573681950569153, 1.2112029790878296, -0.05381631851196289, -0.19108976423740387, -0.5706004500389099, -0.0014917784137651324, -0.05593591555953026, -0.5500296950340271, -0.3411693572998047, -0.08674712479114532, 0.20498163998126984, 1.2283976078033447, 0.07414799928665161, 0.36454370617866516, -0.7459735870361328, -0.4830183982849121, -0.15432961285114288, 0.4360295236110687, -0.09575556218624115, 0.4872764050960541, 0.3424413204193115, 0.9449577331542969, -0.5011146068572998, 0.1600724160671234, 0.5761041641235352, -0.44358670711517334, 0.4961937665939331, 0.2857455313205719, 0.36098000407218933, -0.11568528413772583, -0.555743396282196, 0.3697446882724762, 0.761393129825592, -0.15735502541065216, 0.027183806523680687, -0.2935752868652344, 0.818946897983551, -0.24679692089557648, -0.44645407795906067, 0.38232266902923584, 0.5343891978263855, -0.12681007385253906, -0.4656972289085388, 0.0062735253013670444, -0.9643957614898682, 4.206021308898926, 0.513414740562439, 0.47454044222831726, 0.09824290871620178, 0.5762259364128113, 0.41843241453170776, -0.07933630794286728, -0.22600841522216797, 0.5163148045539856, 0.1952020525932312, -0.009465985000133514, -0.18029949069023132, 0.5783510804176331, 0.7141333222389221, -0.006091015879064798, 0.8183451294898987, -0.34154030680656433, -0.29865992069244385, 0.35541826486587524, -0.7693119049072266, -1.2876087427139282, 0.2639234662055969, 0.13319943845272064, -0.2139526903629303, 0.1702893227338791, 0.2101230025291443, -0.0006418187986128032, -0.17344877123832703, -0.520121157169342, -0.199342742562294, -0.4300406873226166, -0.45198944211006165, 1.0575306415557861, -0.09263365715742111, -0.7240450978279114, 0.3830062448978424, 0.09303174167871475, 0.03626777604222298, 0.010972336865961552, -0.042262814939022064, -0.3506495952606201, -0.7132389545440674, -0.08085282891988754, -0.38247039914131165, 0.13289904594421387, 0.6845459938049316, 0.2988743185997009, 0.37835514545440674, 0.817459225654602, -0.6363784670829773, 0.5959145426750183, 0.3011600375175476, 0.07777748256921768, -0.584933876991272, -0.6440286040306091, 0.42914342880249023, -0.3309098184108734, -0.28195616602897644, -0.3511050343513489, 0.22574661672115326, 0.9893720746040344, -0.9095174670219421, -0.7053336501121521, 0.2067270278930664, 0.010142357088625431, 0.10748863965272903, 0.2472720742225647, -0.07083522528409958, -0.4099874794483185, 0.2482384294271469, -0.2801780700683594, -0.04353981092572212, -0.22055140137672424, -0.34190893173217773, 0.4649316370487213, 0.4330238103866577, 0.16447053849697113, -0.6088908314704895, 0.11878412961959839, 0.16232995688915253, -0.29096320271492004, 0.059431951493024826, -0.4574178159236908, 1.0675456523895264, -0.04562155529856682, 0.26495128870010376, 0.10240119695663452, -0.48647230863571167, -0.18372435867786407, 0.9531043767929077, 0.1228196769952774, 0.3395180106163025, 0.1915685087442398, 0.310760498046875, -0.13458211719989777 ]
Gamma-Ray Bursts and Neutron Star Mergers - Possibly the Strongest Explosions in the Universe
$\gamma$-ray bursts have baffled theorists ever since their accidental discovery at the sixties. We suggest that these bursts originate in merger of neutron star binaries, taking place at cosmological distances. These mergers release $\approx 10^{54}ergs$, in what are possibly the strongest explosions in the Universe. If even a small fraction of this energy is channeled to an electromagnetic signal it will be detected as a grbs. We examine the virtues and limitations of this model and compare it with the recent Compton \g-ray observatory results.
Tsvi Piran
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211010
astro-ph/9211011
[ 0.6356103420257568, 0.5637523531913757, 0.7491639256477356, -0.09699929505586624, -0.3150637745857239, 0.09704764187335968, -0.159048929810524, -0.014023804105818272, -0.5412212014198303, 1.3457025289535522, 0.47081634402275085, -0.7601603269577026, -0.2181326001882553, -1.1478314399719238, 0.34520626068115234, 0.30537790060043335, -0.44899803400039673, -0.1843867301940918, -1.2460969686508179, 0.19486530125141144, 0.5560317635536194, 0.44453510642051697, -0.7265801429748535, -0.6773499250411987, -0.5407651662826538, 0.6416065096855164, 0.594474196434021, 0.40704819560050964, 1.2148089408874512, 0.9569159150123596, 0.38765642046928406, 0.012883847579360008, -0.5386236310005188, -0.8210865259170532, -0.3635497987270355, 0.1505804806947708, 0.24403752386569977, -0.4009179174900055, 0.5939614176750183, -0.20601886510849, 0.5507945418357849, -0.2192896157503128, 0.6318596005439758, 0.06165989115834236, -0.6655788421630859, 0.20300298929214478, -0.4178527891635895, -0.1680186241865158, -0.2429570108652115, -0.9678533673286438, -0.2819504141807556, -0.6089057326316833, 0.4554910361766815, -0.6865177750587463, 0.3220745623111725, -0.08504688739776611, 0.10141795873641968, -0.09795492887496948, -0.787224531173706, 0.17238174378871918, 0.8581820726394653, 0.34820467233657837, 0.42065858840942383, -1.108589768409729, 0.3819091022014618, 1.2439523935317993, 0.5833048820495605, -0.1302124559879303, -0.3319924473762512, 0.0730709657073021, -0.024226602166891098, -0.03071342594921589, -0.22288869321346283, 0.2113218754529953, -0.39632636308670044, 0.36521029472351074, -0.05132140964269638, -0.04449860006570816, -0.14700177311897278, 0.038476668298244476, 0.09844237565994263, 0.04292064532637596, -0.18158137798309326, 0.5957624316215515, 0.1462934911251068, -0.34079447388648987, 0.01138305850327015, 0.3796497583389282, 0.2638952136039734, 0.020487304776906967, -0.759698212146759, 0.296207070350647, -0.11413256824016571, 0.4643818140029907, 0.07937784492969513, 0.8275628685951233, -0.2688826024532318, 0.6621858477592468, 0.4972533583641052, -0.28143250942230225, 0.029290881007909775, 0.5475981831550598, -1.0554895401000977, 0.28338125348091125, -0.5568519830703735, 0.8367104530334473, -0.3207879662513733, 0.5328962802886963, -0.5561269521713257, -0.5954911708831787, 0.00860569253563881, 0.7829655408859253, 0.48080554604530334, 0.5119418501853943, -0.10657495260238647, 0.7451262474060059, -0.0730346068739891, -0.1618926078081131, -0.9917522072792053, -0.42198190093040466, -0.04736516624689102, 0.3358381986618042, -0.21073345839977264, 0.7565242648124695, -0.6501049399375916, -0.8436128497123718, 0.03082602098584175, 0.1964268684387207, -0.5301946401596069, 0.12012511491775513, -0.37776362895965576, -0.18348826467990875, 0.1653498113155365, 0.5425070524215698, 0.22329139709472656, 0.003276227507740259, 0.49917495250701904, 0.4759678840637207, -0.9150872230529785, -1.2230128049850464, 0.0844174176454544, -0.26213201880455017, -0.0547940619289875, 0.9053645730018616, -0.7876002192497253, 0.23029249906539917, -0.3995381295681, -0.08219130337238312, -0.8323816657066345, 0.09394169598817825, -0.33555060625076294, -0.06651706248521805, 0.1777370423078537, 0.17681051790714264, -0.16503499448299408, -0.10401473939418793, -0.8791487216949463, -0.22606870532035828, 0.022931816056370735, -0.6213963627815247, 0.31464436650276184, -0.09536413103342056, -0.009871618822216988, 0.7979578375816345, -0.5154954195022583, 0.42307737469673157, -0.5771410465240479, -0.026885902509093285, 0.19823719561100006, 0.05567271262407303, -0.2152128368616104, 0.5104367733001709, -0.21500489115715027, 0.5145869851112366, 0.9553754925727844, 0.7847221493721008, -0.0579034797847271, -0.33340105414390564, -0.30627721548080444, 0.6595691442489624, -0.5772804021835327, -0.47474467754364014, 0.3710891604423523, 0.6968805193901062, -0.2902124226093292, 0.18139201402664185, 0.35568132996559143, -0.038267672061920166, 0.6289218068122864, 0.1807260811328888, -0.6163095235824585, 0.525532066822052, -0.7783035039901733, 1.0284364223480225, -0.7617760896682739, 0.14520412683486938, -0.8035924434661865, 0.1840190440416336, -0.05318943038582802, -0.3832271099090576, 0.23523558676242828, 0.1569364070892334, -0.7814199328422546, 0.3486863970756531, -0.40893232822418213, 0.4482828974723816, -0.07633772492408752, 0.6483181118965149, -0.7981787323951721, 0.43908193707466125, 0.8913225531578064, -0.10042423754930496, 0.13686148822307587, 0.28706273436546326, 0.1020164042711258, 0.13286271691322327, 0.024813244119286537, 0.44779354333877563, -0.027621103450655937, -0.0790608823299408, 0.9641084671020508, 0.006455115973949432, 0.12505128979682922, 1.0184063911437988, 0.47735440731048584, -0.13627110421657562, 0.5176700949668884, 0.6938560009002686, -0.4453631639480591, 0.4020378291606903, 0.12946417927742004, 0.07708010077476501, 0.45553454756736755, -0.019977064803242683, 1.0390417575836182, -0.26694968342781067, 0.7217861413955688, 0.6961057782173157, -0.5289435982704163, 0.16305795311927795, 0.4495925307273865, -0.16610866785049438, 0.2743445634841919, 0.09331361204385757, -1.0706305503845215, 1.162103295326233, -0.16647261381149292, -0.19397860765457153, 0.2505580484867096, 0.711242139339447, -0.8072727918624878, 0.42831912636756897, 0.13840994238853455, -0.10600286722183228, -1.379941701889038, 0.39493271708488464, 0.48511528968811035, 0.5462545156478882, 0.02675231173634529, -1.0938003063201904, -0.10749601572751999, -0.11064404994249344, 0.026843814179301262, -0.9773436784744263, -0.4907454252243042, 0.31075942516326904, -0.7262916564941406, 0.2263410985469818, 0.3481297194957733, -0.5438705086708069, -0.6086780428886414, -0.2972543239593506, -0.48678702116012573, 0.034370262175798416, -0.18873414397239685, -0.3106422424316406, -0.35451510548591614, -0.605280876159668, 0.6499725580215454, 0.47936999797821045, 0.07518980652093887, 0.018925657495856285, -0.13502298295497894, 0.4901973307132721, -0.15715926885604858, -0.026992393657565117, -0.8742339611053467, 0.158987358212471, -1.1424614191055298, 0.39680686593055725, -0.31427308917045593, -0.45690131187438965, -0.26260948181152344, 0.091560497879982, 0.3690156638622284, 0.3257547914981842, -0.20982308685779572, 0.5010446906089783, 0.26394087076187134, -0.9294415712356567, 0.346238374710083, 0.596138596534729, -0.3852202296257019, 0.019222993403673172, 0.02002417854964733, 0.9066017866134644, -0.34399113059043884, 0.26337239146232605, 1.0863183736801147, -0.46287110447883606, -0.5331100225448608, 0.22775062918663025, 0.26495110988616943, 0.9146725535392761, -0.23195192217826843, 0.10371419787406921, 0.6150191426277161, -0.4996499717235565, 0.3063252568244934, -0.34390825033187866, -0.4295307397842407, -0.415263295173645, 0.7403639554977417, -0.6519122123718262, 0.29361727833747864, 0.4776930809020996, 0.7695532441139221, -0.7919113636016846, 0.25251343846321106, -0.4243273437023163, -1.020195722579956, -0.47938859462738037, -0.7381501197814941, 0.21383962035179138, 0.009202386252582073, -0.3191162645816803, -0.007900497876107693, -0.37489357590675354, -0.4134429693222046, 0.737361490726471, 0.6950047612190247, 0.18324598670005798, 0.39272332191467285, 0.871059000492096, -0.024614829570055008, 0.023914845660328865, 0.6129637360572815, -0.35206636786460876, 0.3333685100078583, 0.3298215866088867, -0.05047648400068283, 0.18339397013187408, 0.4364471733570099, 0.37585553526878357, 0.08700734376907349, 0.3080395460128784, 0.024927256628870964, -0.6569950580596924, -1.2026342153549194, -0.9173080921173096, -0.005987765267491341, 0.01607172004878521, -0.13188041746616364, -0.12128324061632156, -0.1322004795074463, -0.021062906831502914, -0.0800323635339737, 0.051468610763549805, 0.6798329949378967, -0.42109444737434387, 0.36812928318977356, 0.706036388874054, -0.7491974830627441, -0.22200916707515717, 0.014083320274949074, 0.6182713508605957, 0.4561867415904999, 0.9719581007957458, 0.1792575865983963, -0.4897863566875458, -0.1290978491306305, -0.18639618158340454, 0.582487165927887, 0.2307409644126892, -0.052338726818561554, 0.12432631850242615, -0.16488836705684662, 0.21530526876449585, -0.5701993703842163, -0.841648280620575, -0.4924991726875305, -0.3419734537601471, 0.2532331049442291, -0.7801766395568848, -0.06454911082983017, -0.2760351002216339, 0.45374763011932373, 1.066195011138916, -0.05966046825051308, -0.018124215304851532, 0.1519073247909546, -0.3696692883968353, 0.10509113222360611, 0.1443813443183899, 0.43308764696121216, -0.053303543478250504, -0.7121965885162354, 0.8182656168937683, 0.3370923399925232, 0.1438666433095932, 0.8253955245018005, -0.4398568868637085, -0.0265591349452734, -0.23137140274047852, 0.5011392831802368, 0.5597924590110779, 0.2719957232475281, -0.07628340274095535, 0.2916860580444336, -0.16802750527858734, -0.6156611442565918, 0.8676697611808777, 0.6703447699546814, 0.40343043208122253, -0.49760177731513977, -1.1436551809310913, 0.3332761228084564, -0.7702938318252563, 0.0014653869438916445, 0.6462260484695435, -0.13390767574310303, -0.7302114963531494, -0.021474918350577354, 0.305197536945343, 0.4869120717048645, -0.23373836278915405, 0.9424031972885132, 0.10964582115411758, 0.5102537274360657, -0.08651041239500046, 0.023459143936634064, 0.9479828476905823, 0.06480471789836884, -0.12262749671936035, 0.15539249777793884, 0.11709795147180557, 0.34775280952453613, 0.4448528587818146, 0.46524539589881897, -0.8034191727638245, -0.6725272536277771, -0.4169870615005493, 0.8726921081542969, -0.4408071041107178, -0.8527857065200806, 0.32050764560699463, 0.2739231288433075, -0.4245966076850891, 0.6427754759788513, -0.41652366518974304, 0.12123430520296097, 0.07553409785032272, -0.00519166374579072, -0.37177774310112, 0.20746566355228424, -0.12173447757959366, -0.5501528382301331, 1.0727416276931763, 0.25323331356048584, 0.25093305110931396, 0.22402873635292053, 0.10283349454402924, -0.11713464558124542, -0.07651187479496002, 0.5946972370147705, -0.5850637555122375, -0.001594466157257557, 0.16518236696720123, -0.4002288579940796, -0.34441980719566345, -0.018556449562311172, 0.6125978231430054, -0.5660503506660461, 0.3786943256855011, 0.44353073835372925, -0.6880868673324585, -0.4636387526988983, -0.06533955037593842, -0.827034056186676, 0.35644933581352234, -0.4489576816558838, -0.5984882712364197, -0.29195329546928406, -0.3125680983066559, -0.21955327689647675, -0.5013802647590637, -0.5851398706436157, -0.7207868099212646, -0.4659581780433655, 0.06754332035779953, 0.09667223691940308, 0.2016076147556305, -0.28497275710105896, 0.40677130222320557, -0.5938171148300171, -0.8441076874732971, -0.8321213722229004, -0.5857040882110596, -0.4415644407272339, -0.32413187623023987, -0.03505150228738785, -0.27982839941978455, 0.2428351491689682, 0.3996271789073944, 0.7857927083969116, 0.1746722161769867, 0.3378653824329376, -0.41907382011413574, -0.2838856875896454, 0.2556954324245453, 0.2313229888677597, -0.7428256273269653, -0.0504876933991909, 0.48855558037757874, 0.31679776310920715, 0.3822011351585388, -0.39719468355178833, -0.5905388593673706, 0.3910733461380005, -1.487000584602356, 0.3496547043323517, -0.8137715458869934, -0.4904995858669281, -0.25667479634284973, -0.34636834263801575, 0.2795603573322296, 0.23252473771572113, -0.19456681609153748, -0.4826648235321045, -0.4647880494594574, -0.19664286077022552, 0.3259517550468445, -0.48065030574798584, 0.06032915040850639, -0.6417434215545654, -0.1935333013534546, -0.3609580099582672, 1.266795039176941, -0.9383381605148315, -0.1251954287290573, 0.5099707841873169, -0.32041269540786743, -0.9085187315940857, -0.07991266250610352, 0.019242199137806892, -0.1338445097208023, -0.3952445387840271, 0.20550382137298584, 0.30587512254714966, 0.6120060086250305, 0.17351627349853516, 0.2650357782840729, -0.1308031678199768, 0.31791162490844727, -0.30233854055404663, 0.1172976866364479, -0.18830648064613342, -0.48611870408058167, 0.8882577419281006, -0.20130541920661926, -0.47216397523880005, 0.6671956777572632, 0.29405680298805237, 0.7471545338630676, -0.12820196151733398, -0.6213805675506592, -0.022721173241734505, -0.8304964900016785, -0.622189998626709, 0.46677088737487793, 0.005802619736641645, -0.36291664838790894, -0.22179196774959564, -0.5009191632270813, -0.5516663193702698, -0.04105281084775925, -0.16504980623722076, 0.12852178514003754, 0.2581212520599365, 0.33171242475509644, -0.47474366426467896, 0.024686671793460846, -0.11806543916463852, -0.21584786474704742, 0.44709157943725586, 0.01292937621474266, -0.39513126015663147, -0.4915408790111542, -0.11179404705762863, -0.6902691125869751, -0.712496280670166, 0.34470680356025696, 0.9949733018875122, -0.24341168999671936, 0.6921011805534363, -0.2997540831565857, -0.3150240480899811, -0.963845431804657, -0.06411287188529968, 0.29952624440193176, -0.13877156376838684, 0.5690076947212219, 0.041527215391397476, -0.00031909634708426893, 0.26552367210388184, 0.5331037640571594, -0.6235542297363281, -0.6046540141105652, 0.6809207201004028, -0.0968196839094162, -0.3468795418739319, 0.694235622882843, -0.0010008614044636488, -0.5060005784034729, -0.9964543581008911, -0.6068165302276611, -0.3635869026184082, 0.3412175476551056, -0.5828431844711304, 0.044476598501205444, -0.49462229013442993, -0.2451827973127365, 0.28285184502601624, 0.7056029438972473, 0.38252493739128113, -0.46020063757896423, 0.297881156206131, 0.03589373826980591, -0.4567809998989105, 0.01894465461373329, 0.9220048189163208, 0.12052959203720093, -0.24894773960113525, -0.29239073395729065, -0.32393938302993774, 0.3577482998371124, -0.6236359477043152, 1.0684558153152466, -0.9298006892204285, -0.18032455444335938, 0.005722856614738703, 0.34959402680397034, -0.27801433205604553, -0.16544651985168457, -0.34893596172332764, 0.05437390133738518, -0.6364302039146423, -0.38781028985977173, 0.053533658385276794, 0.04543045163154602, 0.3095056116580963, 0.4545040428638458, -0.282974511384964, 0.037860799580812454, -0.16376809775829315, 0.3585738241672516, -0.03923279047012329, -0.19324325025081635, -0.5469983816146851, -0.9543642997741699, -0.7016520500183105, -0.7055166363716125, -0.3892718553543091, 0.026484500616788864, 0.35722923278808594, -0.3329222500324249, 0.19242462515830994, 0.13604050874710083, 0.09962733089923859, 0.1288224309682846, 0.3518868088722229, 0.014417234808206558, -0.04901967942714691, -0.4118613600730896, 0.512395977973938, -0.09465626627206802, -1.1765806674957275, 0.0787125676870346, -0.4943358302116394, 0.23510394990444183, 1.014235019683838, -0.35037142038345337, 0.7298303246498108, 0.11803098767995834, -0.5644041299819946, 0.24977362155914307, -0.04713935777544975, -0.43353721499443054, 0.7282527685165405, -0.370107501745224, 1.1394965648651123, 0.7757625579833984, 0.5706450343132019, 0.06925109773874283, -0.8652771711349487, -1.0665453672409058, 0.32612237334251404, 0.31591224670410156, 0.42113059759140015, -0.13865245878696442, -1.0958846807479858, 0.24765492975711823, 0.3177933394908905, -0.9936554431915283, 0.13696815073490143, -0.3153863847255707, 0.504188597202301, -0.2535787522792816, -0.17438311874866486, -0.01593678444623947, 0.5794124603271484, -0.39465317130088806, 0.19199594855308533, -0.26295480132102966, 0.15768244862556458, 0.5140244364738464, -0.06409497559070587, 0.05123621225357056, -0.6744572520256042, 0.19259199500083923, -0.49811556935310364, -0.1097186803817749, 0.036065470427274704, -0.26859787106513977, 0.3739950358867645, 0.06032320857048035, 0.1613093912601471, -0.4156649708747864, 0.6140953898429871, -0.8737492561340332, 0.5841345191001892, 0.8278761506080627, 0.36391010880470276, 0.24234433472156525, -0.29235169291496277, -0.8550905585289001, 0.1793137937784195, -0.5176510810852051, -0.7993878722190857, 0.1668250858783722, -0.0320327952504158, -0.00033480781712569296, -0.17630749940872192, -0.4778699576854706, -0.4195687174797058, -0.33306536078453064, 1.3260869979858398, 1.0289909839630127, 0.17753693461418152, -0.18458595871925354, 0.5066442489624023, -0.7101485133171082, -0.5298583507537842, 0.030392101034522057, 0.03102973848581314, -0.7552062273025513, -0.324753999710083, -0.18727755546569824, -0.07160136848688126, -0.13799211382865906, 0.022861309349536896, 0.14142003655433655, 0.17200836539268494, -0.4481818675994873, 0.025518197566270828, -0.07794184982776642, -0.1767638921737671, -0.5342151522636414, 0.33439794182777405, 0.06074044480919838, -0.4685589671134949, -0.2608741223812103, -0.30836281180381775, 0.6382436156272888, -0.05639273300766945, -0.406389445066452, 1.0285532474517822, 0.06791581958532333, -0.11492212861776352, 0.5298422574996948, 0.12801864743232727, 0.34737375378608704, 0.6000718474388123, -0.32736560702323914, -0.08271877467632294, 0.3646973669528961, -0.011771918274462223, 0.09513954818248749, -0.2567322850227356, -0.7487325668334961, 0.24119116365909576, 0.10995243489742279, 0.21907316148281097, -0.42580360174179077, -0.34292104840278625, -0.20721018314361572, 0.06266193091869354, -0.04063801467418671, -0.09407959133386612, -0.1328323632478714, -0.30032163858413696, 0.4716230630874634, -0.02613024413585663, -0.34092977643013, -0.7741474509239197, -0.44022122025489807, 0.3506835401058197, -0.6186848878860474, -0.6869015693664551, -0.3907714784145355, 0.5330588221549988, 0.20508860051631927, -0.2465299367904663, -0.17511695623397827, 0.2702924907207489, -0.051217492669820786, 0.014357070438563824, -0.08182596415281296, 0.5376055836677551, 0.4012703597545624, 0.6645100116729736, 0.930309534072876, 0.20083120465278625, 0.521514892578125, 0.637617826461792, 0.13035984337329865, -1.4243336915969849, 0.49853143095970154, 0.20797257125377655, -0.4529324173927307, 0.0616329051554203, -0.02628159336745739, -0.2089197337627411, -0.2468244582414627, -0.8287515640258789, -0.24960297346115112, -0.5214924216270447, 0.005121750757098198, -0.19925573468208313, -0.27618253231048584, 0.2667853534221649, -0.028256820514798164, 0.1192377433180809, 0.7641915082931519, 0.38466566801071167, 0.48549726605415344, -0.030150316655635834, 0.2775709927082062, 0.7504894137382507, 0.28841862082481384, -0.28927746415138245, -0.6013628244400024, -0.027111690491437912, 0.6477819681167603, 0.1650393158197403, -0.01216980256140232, 0.45700210332870483, -0.49879714846611023, 0.19586946070194244, 0.0614163912832737, -0.3324936628341675, -0.011652723886072636, 0.12288811802864075, 0.12718448042869568, 0.8833270072937012, 0.19763827323913574, 0.14010344445705414, -0.03181498125195503, 0.5408236384391785, -0.2374935746192932, -0.19628943502902985, 0.5088129639625549, -0.6857953667640686, 0.42695149779319763, -1.089505672454834, 0.4755362868309021, 0.21407172083854675, -0.2800476849079132, -0.8304332494735718, -0.0957421138882637, -0.2551742494106293, -1.0390359163284302, -0.328857958316803, -0.5801272988319397, 0.34197330474853516, 0.6903828978538513, -0.08219394087791443, 0.7843616008758545, -0.4031192362308502, -0.16386213898658752, -0.4616200029850006, 1.2918503284454346, 0.046847958117723465, -0.1780773103237152, 0.15621507167816162, 0.027742300182580948, -0.7961689829826355, 0.3289234936237335, 0.5853026509284973, -0.41518378257751465, 0.6006343364715576, -0.15467146039009094, -0.0002569645585026592, 0.0735563412308693, -0.012537016533315182, 0.03564456105232239, 0.827480137348175, 0.545477032661438, -0.038563165813684464, -0.6390457153320312, 0.2116599678993225, -0.6356427073478699, -0.264901340007782, -0.5429753065109253, 0.5184552669525146, 0.3707122504711151, -0.11711078137159348, 0.6516721248626709, -0.7168250679969788, 4.364346027374268, 1.1518292427062988, 0.5014118552207947, -0.039395567029714584, 0.7190162539482117, 0.7306854724884033, 0.46693626046180725, 0.1552281230688095, -0.14965887367725372, -0.37341275811195374, -0.22626861929893494, -0.14861862361431122, 0.33605340123176575, -0.2886289954185486, 0.300356388092041, 0.3957991898059845, 0.3914528787136078, 0.1557103544473648, -0.41495004296302795, 0.3715837299823761, -1.0144833326339722, 0.29949504137039185, 0.12755681574344635, -0.1096886396408081, 0.5095406174659729, 0.4140264093875885, 0.1936330646276474, -0.28474947810173035, -0.3119686543941498, -0.2981393337249756, 0.02847778983414173, -0.5146818161010742, -0.5960773825645447, -0.14987331628799438, -1.4698406457901, 1.0757955312728882, -0.0404403917491436, -0.44565349817276, 0.3057805299758911, -0.1152796521782875, -0.1252787858247757, -0.3293397128582001, -0.4572194814682007, 0.1044546365737915, -0.3047611713409424, 0.787291407585144, 0.9641480445861816, 0.299418181180954, 0.5281870365142822, -0.5358418822288513, 0.1658151000738144, -0.19311797618865967, 0.3955335021018982, -0.2867472767829895, -0.6881927847862244, -0.09661085158586502, 0.18521787226200104, -0.2808132767677307, 0.037562642246484756, -0.08936712890863419, 1.351664423942566, -0.4255911111831665, -0.14680328965187073, 0.18218401074409485, 0.5662224888801575, 0.5160373449325562, 0.6161447763442993, 0.09710691124200821, 0.16658978164196014, -0.4902215600013733, -0.3168070316314697, 0.10053367167711258, -0.30905720591545105, -0.8811236023902893, 0.31324294209480286, -0.3220668137073517, 0.3879055678844452, 0.6555691957473755, -0.6344132423400879, 0.36200493574142456, -1.0595669746398926, 0.03564731404185295, -0.12488918006420135, -0.043703049421310425, -0.044643599539995193, 0.6830070614814758, -0.18446436524391174, 0.24889864027500153, -0.3757244646549225, 0.6529757976531982, -0.2065003216266632, 0.7660703063011169, -0.5942502617835999, -0.6395200490951538, -0.42782071232795715 ]
A Possible Solution to the Horizon Problem: The Mad Era for Massless Scalar Theories of Gravity
Extensions of Einstein gravity which allow the gravitational constant $G$ to change with time as the universe evolves may provide a resolution to the horizon problem without invoking a period of vacuum domination and without the subsequent entropy violation. In a cosmology for which the gravitational constant is not in fact constant, the universe may be older at a given temperature than in a standard Hot Big Bang universe; thus, larger regions of space could have come into causal contact at that temperature. This opens the possibility that large regions became smooth at some high temperature without violating causality. The extra aging of the universe can be accomplished by an early period with a large Planck mass, a period we call the MAD era (Modified Aging era or the Massively Aged and Detained era). We discuss in this paper theories of gravity in which the gravitational constant is replaced with a function of a scalar field. However, this resolution to the smoothness problem
Janna J Levin and Katherine Freese
astro-ph gr-qc hep-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211011
astro-ph/9211012
[ -0.1994376927614212, 0.23145000636577606, -0.32137465476989746, -0.09623916447162628, -0.38921108841896057, 0.26673048734664917, -0.13235582411289215, -0.3377557396888733, -0.3926589787006378, 1.2196290493011475, 0.7012119889259338, 0.1000247597694397, -0.1584763079881668, -0.9486634731292725, -0.5833526253700256, -0.5102620124816895, 0.8534414768218994, -0.15061715245246887, -0.985579252243042, -0.08490777015686035, -0.3621641993522644, 0.3076331615447998, -0.6820282340049744, -0.41613367199897766, -0.8188716173171997, 0.7637134790420532, 0.10840633511543274, 0.4210584759712219, 0.7193048596382141, 0.941739022731781, 0.29723355174064636, 0.29861947894096375, -0.5850846171379089, -0.5435519814491272, 0.07141783833503723, -0.5658894777297974, 0.05120139569044113, -0.5222931504249573, 0.5982094407081604, -0.5345596075057983, 0.5711175203323364, 0.3542134463787079, 0.3848749101161957, -0.08827899396419525, -0.2524934411048889, -0.471356600522995, 0.32540249824523926, 0.09472817182540894, -0.3370595872402191, -0.6136648654937744, 0.3339984714984894, -0.20493192970752716, 0.12016961723566055, -0.5135732293128967, -0.30670395493507385, -0.6913920640945435, 0.09718474745750427, -0.014322513714432716, -0.04545189440250397, 0.5994462966918945, 0.2750779390335083, 0.6447325348854065, -0.03029005602002144, -0.9919385313987732, -0.46372896432876587, 0.7546221613883972, -0.0869838073849678, 0.30962929129600525, 0.46242472529411316, -0.5845767855644226, -0.15338724851608276, -0.2029554694890976, -0.22495324909687042, 0.736149251461029, 0.10755901783704758, 0.5001446604728699, -0.3598911762237549, -0.2692139744758606, -0.5379817485809326, 0.06020154803991318, -0.6343349814414978, -0.2909049093723297, -0.026287686079740524, 0.35966554284095764, -0.2623039186000824, -0.11449850350618362, 0.2324131429195404, -0.5347511172294617, 0.19841107726097107, 0.06097256392240524, -0.6517557501792908, 0.9224643707275391, -1.06227445602417, -0.1549074351787567, 0.9319937825202942, 0.6077072620391846, -0.12959690392017365, 0.5541264414787292, 0.060448646545410156, 0.2949826717376709, -0.3851012885570526, 1.256198763847351, -0.521006166934967, 0.20580890774726868, -0.062074076384305954, 0.596420407295227, -0.29920923709869385, 0.4524296820163727, -0.5127842426300049, -0.7625961899757385, -0.01065262034535408, 0.20930911600589752, 0.41706544160842896, 0.036414407193660736, 0.11606466770172119, 0.7787703275680542, -0.26974084973335266, -0.03295096755027771, -0.4246288537979126, -0.5808089375495911, -0.2858729660511017, 0.5475267171859741, -0.03629670292139053, 1.074607491493225, -0.2629186809062958, 0.007821435108780861, 0.0438992865383625, 0.09722652286291122, -0.673706591129303, -0.09812305867671967, 0.37767472863197327, -0.6809478402137756, -0.010347743518650532, -0.17767418920993805, -0.3156428337097168, 0.4855261743068695, 0.027470208704471588, 0.06344176828861237, 0.058491844683885574, -0.803661584854126, -0.189790278673172, -0.0746910348534584, 0.3728049099445343, 1.1262555122375488, -1.039859652519226, 0.13168664276599884, 0.25944146513938904, 0.1184856966137886, -0.29787006974220276, 0.041572924703359604, 0.4372546374797821, -0.9353371262550354, -0.2183467447757721, 0.7228133082389832, -0.3796059787273407, -0.5834920406341553, -0.6769341230392456, -0.359368234872818, -0.3020187318325043, -0.07047522068023682, 0.5597755908966064, -0.18610620498657227, 0.47896450757980347, 0.8857243061065674, 0.22057412564754486, 0.5036976933479309, -0.684822678565979, -0.9266074299812317, 0.06943406164646149, 0.17668192088603973, -0.363503098487854, 0.2955220341682434, 0.2670031785964966, 0.77316814661026, 0.7255347371101379, 0.06924772262573242, -0.09235928952693939, -0.2837996482849121, -0.9490683078765869, -0.1315748244524002, 0.10925625264644623, -0.6448628902435303, 0.395029753446579, 0.6533262133598328, 0.16552479565143585, 0.1406603306531906, 0.1845037043094635, -0.33068612217903137, 0.8124627470970154, -0.42620718479156494, -0.6036468148231506, 0.5265382528305054, -0.591657817363739, 0.34820324182510376, -1.0387815237045288, 0.4076533615589142, -0.6746937036514282, -0.49093097448349, 0.3009476959705353, -1.0999184846878052, 0.4648294448852539, 0.07122084498405457, -0.727830171585083, 0.8017985820770264, -0.856386125087738, -0.4750649929046631, 0.6674431562423706, 0.5656618475914001, -0.4899192154407501, 0.5178825855255127, 0.5737025737762451, 0.3517818748950958, -0.2939738929271698, 0.14005249738693237, 0.2690351903438568, 0.19706198573112488, -0.6477668881416321, 0.5642186999320984, -0.11968856304883957, -0.06301569938659668, 0.42566853761672974, 0.09629426151514053, 0.1903357356786728, 0.7164316177368164, 0.04433169215917587, -0.4186520278453827, 0.10051488131284714, 1.1928538084030151, 0.0864604040980339, 0.6222580075263977, -0.34732353687286377, -0.4215371906757355, 0.7532434463500977, 0.38856831192970276, 0.5302969217300415, -0.5226478576660156, 0.61702561378479, 0.4215961694717407, 0.22608943283557892, -0.14038434624671936, 0.1668792963027954, 0.3872815668582916, 0.9869211316108704, 0.12241780757904053, -1.0892367362976074, 0.7251478433609009, 0.3329717814922333, 0.22555576264858246, -0.6615873575210571, 0.49436652660369873, -0.7526379227638245, 0.5109675526618958, 0.6396149396896362, -0.3976415991783142, -0.738108217716217, -0.24554374814033508, 0.4036688804626465, 0.6407367587089539, -0.010609271004796028, -0.4494515061378479, -0.46052396297454834, 0.3412764072418213, -0.6510612964630127, -0.2517649829387665, 0.15002968907356262, -0.46992483735084534, -0.5432931780815125, 0.048276662826538086, 0.8754096627235413, -0.3930330276489258, -1.3461077213287354, -0.09453265368938446, 0.19070814549922943, -0.15349410474300385, -0.5110573172569275, -0.6269981861114502, 0.20764344930648804, -0.25271710753440857, 1.637367844581604, -0.00494546489790082, -0.357962042093277, 0.13454098999500275, -0.7139055132865906, 0.08144406229257584, -0.9588038325309753, 0.8634685277938843, -1.0522652864456177, 0.2734459638595581, -0.8282213807106018, 0.5701911449432373, -0.7308956980705261, -0.6737138628959656, 0.01720719411969185, 0.2891443073749542, -0.14843378961086273, 0.8459962010383606, -0.23570294678211212, 0.10807204991579056, -0.5063477158546448, -0.6436852812767029, 0.6905369758605957, 0.8085395693778992, -0.31203392148017883, -0.04660627618432045, -0.973852813243866, 0.8059548139572144, -0.3707691729068756, -0.3854821026325226, 0.5603874325752258, 0.12195040285587311, -0.7102091908454895, 0.1920340210199356, 0.3732357323169708, 0.6604352593421936, -0.2761709690093994, -0.07004845142364502, 1.0304338932037354, 0.08502616733312607, 0.728253185749054, 0.15827533602714539, -0.4581725001335144, -0.5472792387008667, 0.8615841269493103, -0.5648940205574036, 0.37938016653060913, 0.4057248532772064, 0.3190646469593048, -0.44436854124069214, 0.9027455449104309, -0.794511079788208, -0.6471571326255798, -0.30347293615341187, -0.38250210881233215, 0.3450295329093933, -0.18158459663391113, 0.11486389487981796, 0.06762334704399109, 0.1106540784239769, 0.30925825238227844, 0.6682966947555542, 0.6325574517250061, -0.004427425097674131, 0.23027800023555756, 0.11656477302312851, -0.2727607786655426, -0.04819217696785927, 0.9246257543563843, 0.2678831219673157, -0.1049814373254776, 0.3876914978027344, -0.36790749430656433, -0.08442655950784683, -0.006586729548871517, 0.06549341231584549, 0.08786491304636002, -0.24698004126548767, -0.010945918038487434, 0.041119519621133804, -1.1767221689224243, -0.5268652439117432, -0.22982385754585266, 0.2888229787349701, 0.6316403150558472, -0.8433274030685425, -0.4026380181312561, -0.10959524661302567, -0.23426410555839539, 0.3435685634613037, 0.33672967553138733, -0.5200855731964111, 0.1941707730293274, 0.06546979397535324, -0.9734319448471069, -0.3295688331127167, -0.6211687326431274, 0.1664227992296219, 1.2040342092514038, 0.17991003394126892, 0.3975227177143097, -0.2850305140018463, -0.3234848380088806, 0.1354127824306488, 0.4212820827960968, 0.13763366639614105, -0.2430124282836914, -0.6189311146736145, -0.09544076770544052, 0.25424957275390625, -0.5102916359901428, -0.7393351197242737, -0.023519324138760567, -0.7826153039932251, 0.269455224275589, -0.0712854191660881, -0.8007049560546875, 0.3574312925338745, 0.10878447443246841, 0.7726109027862549, 0.11409556120634079, 0.36827993392944336, -0.39310842752456665, 0.21375662088394165, 0.029571648687124252, 0.46095219254493713, -0.8033377528190613, 0.448000431060791, 0.17763453722000122, 0.5425666570663452, 0.37009209394454956, -0.11760452389717102, 0.49410107731819153, 0.2370975762605667, -0.3786901533603668, 0.11243647336959839, 0.0467941090464592, 0.5969419479370117, -0.010776511393487453, 0.719059407711029, 1.2120622396469116, 0.29542985558509827, -0.5324237942695618, 0.9739674925804138, 0.3241361081600189, 0.8774328827857971, -0.49993622303009033, -0.4358517527580261, -0.4991888701915741, -0.8056476712226868, 0.13653628528118134, 0.20979687571525574, -0.5922389626502991, -0.7140030264854431, 0.24999089539051056, -0.44355252385139465, 0.7946581840515137, 0.29041290283203125, 0.8496321439743042, 0.8903737664222717, -0.09592694044113159, -0.05026104673743248, 0.26512953639030457, 0.9374063014984131, -0.49265727400779724, -0.09815794229507446, -0.5128009915351868, 0.07450183480978012, -0.16941393911838531, 0.5725366473197937, -0.2930387854576111, -0.9887228608131409, -0.8298124074935913, -0.5949053168296814, 1.3848718404769897, -0.2501996159553528, -0.6915083527565002, 0.43352624773979187, 0.6902957558631897, -0.2061585783958435, 0.2512538731098175, -0.33022600412368774, 0.19009113311767578, 0.08865832537412643, -0.6199968457221985, -0.8452083468437195, -0.465783029794693, -0.3526349365711212, -0.3976977467536926, 0.3573407530784607, 0.46350809931755066, 0.24222156405448914, 0.6332501173019409, -0.07834890484809875, -0.5719454288482666, -0.45868760347366333, 0.5769344568252563, -0.5705116391181946, 0.010805731639266014, 0.6256713271141052, -0.5966036915779114, -0.11278440058231354, 0.3297487795352936, -0.033629436045885086, -0.21556192636489868, -0.841982364654541, 0.4130714237689972, -0.8374377489089966, -0.4157498776912689, -0.49493077397346497, -0.729682445526123, 0.950405478477478, -0.1229793056845665, -0.08801227062940598, 0.22359010577201843, -0.4912654459476471, -0.4205128848552704, -0.7024189233779907, 0.09960181266069412, -0.5716633796691895, -0.21866171061992645, -0.1309109777212143, -0.22802910208702087, 0.018542427569627762, -0.9842854738235474, 0.9416148066520691, -0.17543694376945496, -0.21786542236804962, -0.4091244041919708, -0.4116201400756836, 0.020429622381925583, -0.058880239725112915, 0.5203647613525391, 0.019780034199357033, 0.011871786788105965, 0.3593413233757019, 0.24221834540367126, 0.47130462527275085, -0.5870880484580994, -0.8407585024833679, -0.06338396668434143, 0.39808887243270874, 0.4669772982597351, -0.6282927989959717, -0.8151753544807434, 0.574728786945343, -0.3931984603404999, 0.4652291536331177, 0.1917208433151245, -0.6690223217010498, 0.21525923907756805, -0.7707961797714233, 0.5162542462348938, -0.566111147403717, -0.42163920402526855, -0.4169974625110626, -0.24754273891448975, -0.6067082285881042, 0.6606572270393372, -0.06577718257904053, -0.7237598299980164, 0.24441634118556976, -0.389778196811676, 0.4116522967815399, -0.8840708136558533, 0.3715265989303589, -0.2449444830417633, -0.5512439012527466, -1.0732183456420898, 1.4932973384857178, 0.027181735262274742, -0.6083269715309143, 0.40970897674560547, -0.5025209784507751, -0.23853838443756104, 0.7089459300041199, 0.36682364344596863, 0.1134268194437027, -1.3446294069290161, 0.06124713271856308, 0.029022518545389175, 0.03727540001273155, -0.23035724461078644, 0.45001187920570374, -0.4009224772453308, 0.891302227973938, 0.8771601319313049, 0.28058505058288574, 0.30748704075813293, -0.4629586637020111, 0.5189246535301208, -0.1642569601535797, 0.21565493941307068, 0.6228803396224976, 0.6615786552429199, 0.1426170915365219, 0.06910135596990585, -0.5984177589416504, -0.3536002039909363, -0.3586367964744568, -0.8894808292388916, 0.1717452108860016, -0.15389315783977509, -0.4274536669254303, -0.563096284866333, -0.3256542682647705, -0.6711632609367371, -0.36352241039276123, 0.17543379962444305, 0.4201599657535553, 0.04185127839446068, 0.47965696454048157, -0.7426838278770447, 0.1420731395483017, -0.02403438650071621, 0.4283740818500519, 0.7172293663024902, -0.16617116332054138, -0.12049191445112228, -0.11789742112159729, 0.1142716035246849, -0.854601263999939, -0.908099353313446, 0.5248833298683167, 0.6675511598587036, -0.7488656640052795, 0.6561600565910339, 0.5255721211433411, 0.03965122997760773, -0.2364083081483841, 0.29012855887413025, 0.9551992416381836, -0.7238128781318665, 0.441008061170578, 0.3675035238265991, -0.11066059023141861, 0.49220341444015503, 0.26783114671707153, -0.7280454039573669, -0.2458869367837906, 1.114634394645691, -0.9209471940994263, 0.3832283914089203, 0.9004229307174683, -0.292654812335968, -0.9801329970359802, -0.4433009624481201, -0.31506842374801636, 0.08036120235919952, 0.3263425827026367, -0.43080851435661316, -0.25896498560905457, 0.12746743857860565, -0.5956640243530273, -0.10740514099597931, -0.11568553000688553, 0.6919111013412476, 0.9492086172103882, -0.14709514379501343, -0.1633823812007904, -0.6181719899177551, -0.13048751652240753, 0.7335235476493835, 0.09847455471754074, -0.48186567425727844, 0.005953453481197357, 0.16410617530345917, -0.1497270166873932, -0.7352076768875122, 1.0135949850082397, -0.19785597920417786, 0.5639173984527588, -0.04104514792561531, 0.15167295932769775, 0.6681194305419922, 0.2428874969482422, -0.9033699035644531, 0.781686544418335, -0.8009226322174072, -0.9131362438201904, -0.1287074089050293, 0.2246122509241104, 0.22005794942378998, 0.06157316267490387, 0.054343804717063904, -0.1180591955780983, -0.28043389320373535, -0.2107114940881729, 0.4749206304550171, 0.011921186000108719, -0.30032601952552795, -0.5017189979553223, -0.7447196841239929, -1.1993411779403687, -0.06212171912193298, -0.3231472074985504, 0.695398211479187, -0.8509835004806519, 0.8575876951217651, 0.3213968873023987, 0.3721757233142853, 0.412171870470047, 1.0414860248565674, -0.35499799251556396, -0.07601801306009293, -0.8350107669830322, -0.08364762365818024, 0.14195898175239563, -1.420864462852478, -0.4372153580188751, -0.7659841179847717, 0.5355113744735718, 1.395571231842041, -0.3508983552455902, 0.24389155209064484, -0.11262404918670654, -0.6526981592178345, 0.16095325350761414, -0.2874048352241516, -0.5569455623626709, 1.4067223072052002, 0.05815174803137779, 1.0135002136230469, 0.5918530225753784, -0.1832563579082489, 0.18801316618919373, -0.1410907506942749, -0.6117056608200073, 0.9340962767601013, -0.23206140100955963, 0.9787583947181702, 0.05548303201794624, -0.5602046251296997, 0.2965741455554962, 0.4436512887477875, -0.8350731730461121, -0.12066725641489029, -0.3948134481906891, 0.5691279172897339, -0.3035675287246704, 0.4476100504398346, -0.13942502439022064, 0.2557004988193512, 0.05684215947985649, 0.07316569983959198, -1.1235787868499756, 0.055037468671798706, -0.9191970229148865, 0.1966416835784912, -0.1632579267024994, -0.26824241876602173, 0.39327847957611084, -0.556472659111023, 0.5894687175750732, 0.6040794253349304, -0.40581071376800537, -0.036071911454200745, -0.22953011095523834, -0.2009085863828659, -0.06636272370815277, 0.04629700630903244, -0.36435821652412415, 0.7452980279922485, 0.2832772433757782, 0.03134089708328247, 1.020168423652649, 0.27467435598373413, -1.0168005228042603, 0.5206066966056824, -0.7349825501441956, -1.0461978912353516, 0.6353071928024292, -0.32228726148605347, 0.540699303150177, 0.08712705969810486, -0.7567362785339355, -0.45014646649360657, -0.21254053711891174, 1.047197699546814, 1.040294885635376, 0.01462387666106224, -0.8153167366981506, 1.038537859916687, -0.9479811787605286, 0.2106841802597046, -0.1984165757894516, 0.4610803723335266, -0.3189239203929901, -1.1804158687591553, -0.6020544767379761, -0.2199464738368988, -0.3041668236255646, -0.25123098492622375, 0.1428879350423813, -0.20202381908893585, -0.006705026607960463, 0.0018492493545636535, -0.2165464162826538, -0.4372124671936035, -1.4998997449874878, 0.3504527509212494, 0.02949313446879387, -0.6699339747428894, 0.2719142436981201, -0.09535863250494003, 0.9035427570343018, -0.19458825886249542, 0.10640221834182739, 1.5255763530731201, -0.009154282510280609, -0.0061799162067472935, -0.0497431717813015, 0.7235337495803833, 0.426338791847229, 0.30757689476013184, -1.1069949865341187, 0.4563031494617462, 0.2684323787689209, -0.09007140249013901, 0.7685912847518921, -0.00028813621611334383, 0.08227396756410599, 0.5068091750144958, 0.19910523295402527, 0.09715968370437622, -0.5368821024894714, -0.2126867026090622, 0.041790787130594254, 0.3690759837627411, -0.3643088936805725, 0.036121390759944916, 0.45639464259147644, 0.5898091197013855, 0.7105085253715515, -0.3575745224952698, -0.41219326853752136, -0.7369515895843506, 0.004409906454384327, 0.5748807191848755, -0.5858724117279053, -0.16734376549720764, -0.7510896325111389, 0.6807805299758911, 0.12766334414482117, -0.053758200258016586, -0.7931228280067444, 0.2619147002696991, 0.7438213229179382, 0.31619250774383545, -1.1463474035263062, 0.5290166139602661, 0.1821969449520111, 0.4049292206764221, 0.7999008893966675, 0.2854439914226532, 0.40969598293304443, 0.62812340259552, -0.20574742555618286, -1.4208451509475708, 0.1550605595111847, -0.1416238397359848, -0.4258059859275818, -0.2563381791114807, 0.4368462860584259, -0.5085560083389282, -0.09689535945653915, -0.4098813533782959, 0.2954182028770447, -0.1938772201538086, -0.4209240674972534, -0.13713806867599487, -0.588183581829071, -0.24236109852790833, 0.3365848958492279, -0.26843568682670593, 0.601311445236206, 0.5126166343688965, 0.7450968027114868, 0.04667964205145836, 1.4997601509094238, 0.8183553814888, 0.15475472807884216, -0.22607241570949554, -0.17899487912654877, 0.2806881070137024, 0.0579071044921875, 0.6904353499412537, -0.5993435978889465, 0.7676101922988892, -1.0410264730453491, 0.24599790573120117, -0.998304545879364, -0.04311201348900795, -0.7024967074394226, -0.30248916149139404, 0.9742558598518372, 0.39930418133735657, -0.95099937915802, 0.1182173416018486, 0.20190022885799408, 0.11707783490419388, 0.5708228349685669, -0.386739581823349, 0.7360098361968994, -0.6620891690254211, -0.7541483640670776, -0.5816161632537842, 0.3418712615966797, -0.42602622509002686, 0.32782548666000366, -0.7038348317146301, -0.10372190177440643, -0.17260318994522095, -0.2636175751686096, -0.36580732464790344, -0.437357634305954, 0.5640736222267151, 0.9361744523048401, 0.12201301753520966, -0.15056657791137695, -0.860008180141449, -0.30458250641822815, -0.3211710453033447, 1.1383320093154907, 0.08802416920661926, 0.3689124584197998, 0.32800573110580444, 0.057301416993141174, -0.6860463619232178, 0.8860233426094055, 0.8343650698661804, -0.4099472463130951, 1.2748304605484009, -0.5181126594543457, -0.015095188282430172, 0.0554775707423687, -0.6723718047142029, 0.22155305743217468, 1.0348327159881592, -0.3667026162147522, 0.5749438405036926, -0.5481429100036621, 0.5642574429512024, -0.3276587128639221, -0.23876836895942688, -0.02711726538836956, 0.3592377007007599, 0.7515373826026917, -0.4305596649646759, -0.19148561358451843, -1.5187585353851318, 3.9795074462890625, 0.3643523156642914, 0.7460382580757141, 0.3092718720436096, 0.3242281973361969, 0.9341359734535217, 0.2986678183078766, 0.16988368332386017, 0.11370383203029633, -0.3499129116535187, 0.5200529098510742, 0.10663662105798721, 0.4632996916770935, 0.15614324808120728, -0.46725955605506897, 0.3147413432598114, 0.5626971125602722, -0.25207847356796265, 0.010723843239247799, -0.23157379031181335, -1.1844547986984253, -0.02855687588453293, -0.06036292389035225, 0.24294140934944153, 0.3950473964214325, 0.3549548387527466, -0.18485181033611298, -0.5975667238235474, -0.8721787929534912, 0.1716543436050415, -0.21431300044059753, -0.6608735918998718, 0.9361434578895569, -0.5763299465179443, -0.9405757188796997, -0.11399737000465393, -0.1430167406797409, -0.07187038660049438, 0.4890083968639374, -0.5691044926643372, -0.3790992200374603, -0.6128674745559692, 0.3742026686668396, 0.017616335302591324, 0.2880425751209259, 1.1993191242218018, 0.47252368927001953, 0.44898363947868347, 0.877792239189148, -0.31825345754623413, -0.23805607855319977, 0.3862631916999817, -0.3333754241466522, 0.034967321902513504, -1.0237231254577637, -0.2950533628463745, 0.10377917438745499, -0.2065669596195221, -0.28245845437049866, -0.3710295259952545, 0.300946444272995, -0.12176437675952911, -0.19294007122516632, 0.20567819476127625, -0.2789444327354431, 0.1741178035736084, -0.11019743978977203, -0.08804216235876083, -0.18101583421230316, 0.023771991953253746, -0.5149216055870056, -0.08267661929130554, -0.21348537504673004, -0.5656542181968689, -0.23368436098098755, 0.41286134719848633, 0.44627320766448975, 0.12194826453924179, -0.319257527589798, 0.4523661136627197, -0.8089090585708618, 0.12177929282188416, -0.5605010986328125, 0.5463665127754211, 0.24217955768108368, 1.0879698991775513, -0.11551249027252197, 0.43200910091400146, -0.5526684522628784, 0.5156075358390808, 0.233660027384758, 0.531732439994812, 0.3025593161582947, 0.5686728358268738, -0.3140912353992462 ]
On the rotation of polarization by a gravitational lens
It is proved that the field of a gravitational lens induces no rotation in the polarization vector of electromagnetic radiation, in agreement with the previous literature, but with a different approach. The result is generalized to the case of less conventional gravitational lenses (static cosmic strings and gravitational waves).
Valerio Faraoni
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211012
astro-ph/9211013
[ 0.3110068440437317, 0.38978445529937744, 0.12321770936250687, -0.42498254776000977, -0.5302906632423401, -0.0781184509396553, -0.8256320953369141, -0.20119541883468628, -1.0020575523376465, 1.2108923196792603, -0.028903977945446968, 0.10006052255630493, 0.20949463546276093, -0.7112401723861694, -0.9806938171386719, 0.1586073487997055, 0.0018095102859660983, -0.5615962147712708, -1.4849437475204468, 0.24866291880607605, -0.3254077732563019, -0.29081517457962036, -0.9847654700279236, -0.057606954127550125, -0.5201649069786072, 0.2927124500274658, 0.3238162398338318, 0.20961759984493256, 0.611803412437439, 0.7254993915557861, 0.7759436368942261, -0.7759408950805664, -0.17014771699905396, -0.9850796461105347, -0.33020493388175964, -0.6771382093429565, 0.4392889738082886, -0.308647483587265, 0.6778174638748169, -0.24316546320915222, 0.509352445602417, -0.14485879242420197, 0.13198243081569672, -0.9454057812690735, -0.47318315505981445, 0.10647470504045486, 0.20682339370250702, 0.06617920100688934, 0.4438762664794922, -0.7578988671302795, 0.5482088327407837, 0.5331786274909973, 0.5855048298835754, -1.0912052392959595, -0.01855786144733429, 0.00707941735163331, -0.13388250768184662, 0.3603266775608063, 0.1144353523850441, -0.5983632206916809, -0.00669931061565876, 0.029913635924458504, 0.3986280560493469, -0.5222247838973999, 0.13369758427143097, 0.8797202706336975, -0.7018421292304993, 0.39383742213249207, -0.09689008444547653, -0.057654548436403275, -0.3361385762691498, -0.8187214136123657, -0.40056750178337097, 0.024427451193332672, -0.3946370780467987, 0.09669259190559387, -0.04940804839134216, -0.1698135882616043, -0.3576917052268982, -0.4072643518447876, 0.3455486297607422, 0.0808596983551979, -0.08754347264766693, 0.5563538670539856, 0.24452292919158936, -0.6540325880050659, 0.3981756567955017, 0.3829389810562134, 0.054867278784513474, 0.6604069471359253, -0.13804426789283752, 0.2963177561759949, -0.47294285893440247, -0.07213660329580307, 0.7939022183418274, -0.7014008164405823, -0.1166447103023529, 0.046055153012275696, 0.1662377119064331, -0.10661257058382034, -0.44680026173591614, 1.147903323173523, -0.5471598505973816, -0.05417916551232338, -0.32047292590141296, 0.5237453579902649, -0.7139684557914734, 0.4507583975791931, 0.25557592511177063, -1.0246533155441284, 0.36736732721328735, -0.10900196433067322, 0.3496450185775757, 0.6615229845046997, 0.6603602766990662, 0.46245768666267395, -0.1191093921661377, 0.3316044807434082, -0.10557398945093155, -0.8383453488349915, -0.3151281476020813, 0.11936894804239273, 0.08454325050115585, 0.26647189259529114, 0.06634162366390228, -0.06714411079883575, -0.3176751434803009, 0.3505214750766754, -0.7204502820968628, 0.2419261932373047, -0.4937303364276886, -0.6922664642333984, -0.7789617776870728, 0.7740904092788696, -0.1079024150967598, -0.13067010045051575, 0.3113399147987366, 0.5064045786857605, -0.2997872829437256, -0.14549629390239716, -0.040467049926519394, -0.23895984888076782, 0.3923070728778839, 1.1952868700027466, -0.8293609619140625, 0.23655378818511963, -0.3894047439098358, -0.5450896620750427, 0.2537357807159424, 0.5715165138244629, -0.009653360582888126, -1.025234580039978, 0.1391659528017044, 0.6779203414916992, -0.7461356520652771, 0.0033273445442318916, -0.6798033714294434, -0.24169643223285675, -0.03982164338231087, -0.3042612075805664, -0.31126299500465393, 0.13059213757514954, -0.11286848038434982, 0.19328992068767548, -0.010413484647870064, 0.34921327233314514, -0.4220763146877289, -0.11462319642305374, 0.4603017270565033, -0.6304076313972473, 0.18599462509155273, 0.4856872260570526, -0.38301950693130493, 0.37847697734832764, 0.5335344672203064, 0.31737297773361206, 0.19351528584957123, -0.5528419017791748, -0.06635693460702896, 0.6262651681900024, -0.37765076756477356, 0.04524931311607361, 0.36717963218688965, 0.0008780729840509593, -0.15550245344638824, -0.06743893027305603, -0.47368255257606506, -0.07170718908309937, 0.82004714012146, -0.30533406138420105, 0.07197587937116623, 0.6080203056335449, -1.012955665588379, 0.911776602268219, -0.6110532283782959, -0.19591790437698364, -0.46957969665527344, 0.30849817395210266, 0.7853228449821472, -0.8950068950653076, 0.3374944031238556, -0.041006170213222504, -0.3146752417087555, 0.7046655416488647, -0.23482652008533478, -0.8165708184242249, 1.2129899263381958, 0.31449413299560547, -0.49799734354019165, 0.32244253158569336, 0.3073120713233948, -0.03596070408821106, 0.1471015363931656, -0.5998618602752686, 0.6826374530792236, 0.009821293875575066, 0.17633138597011566, -0.2168561816215515, -0.11998875439167023, 0.10210151225328445, 0.43749451637268066, 0.11716954410076141, 0.4238699674606323, 0.5964800715446472, -0.40961703658103943, -0.18786385655403137, -0.19288954138755798, 0.8537218570709229, -0.07516968250274658, -0.03458358719944954, -0.21575848758220673, 0.11343706399202347, -0.06629258394241333, 0.4225827753543854, 0.6149126887321472, -0.5090488195419312, 0.9668205976486206, 0.7695702314376831, -0.8754794001579285, 0.5015744566917419, 0.009647274389863014, -0.414773553609848, 0.2554982006549835, 0.30542683601379395, -0.43539243936538696, 0.7683663368225098, 0.263386607170105, -0.42872151732444763, -0.5081250071525574, 1.1761049032211304, 0.03311903774738312, 0.7705891132354736, 0.06857439130544662, -0.5207004547119141, -0.9998243451118469, -0.4878014028072357, -0.29161587357521057, 0.09107676148414612, -0.17649780213832855, -0.49023157358169556, -0.4799642562866211, -0.33804649114608765, -0.5019593834877014, -0.24407100677490234, -0.05665529891848564, 0.9804427027702332, -0.8117904663085938, 0.3763265013694763, 0.6122575402259827, -0.120248943567276, -1.0773065090179443, 0.07287517189979553, -0.9236509203910828, 0.17676277458667755, -0.4522288739681244, -0.16536590456962585, 0.1910732537508011, -0.6750569939613342, 0.7252627015113831, 0.23656794428825378, -0.22319035232067108, 1.0018266439437866, -0.09394016116857529, 0.5881744623184204, 0.0042707729153335094, 0.3086586892604828, -0.690352201461792, 0.8306943774223328, -0.5796405673027039, 0.3134608566761017, -0.1562601774930954, 0.10348153114318848, -0.7576746940612793, 0.22509458661079407, 0.4028475284576416, 0.7864633202552795, -0.21361663937568665, 0.7490296363830566, 0.30483490228652954, -0.8246963024139404, 0.4959065318107605, 0.5145540237426758, -0.6810929179191589, -0.18209677934646606, -0.7029107213020325, -0.22460833191871643, -0.21697987616062164, 0.07874296605587006, 0.02266869507730007, -0.015046779066324234, -0.030043885111808777, 0.507175862789154, -0.3795873522758484, 0.32736751437187195, -0.5020017027854919, 0.31662535667419434, 0.42282795906066895, 0.15576611459255219, 0.8606253862380981, -0.1304161101579666, -0.4101451635360718, -0.3464602828025818, 0.5339195728302002, -0.4560970962047577, -0.02057092823088169, 1.1664408445358276, 0.2972436845302582, -0.6136574149131775, 0.3660639822483063, -0.3178432285785675, -0.748043954372406, 0.11680389195680618, -0.02613820694386959, 0.29928264021873474, 0.02279609441757202, 0.33767569065093994, -0.7113872170448303, 0.11855564266443253, -0.4486556053161621, -0.10080724209547043, 0.09428264200687408, 0.005585855804383755, -0.0016014216234907508, 0.9513869285583496, -0.5860896706581116, -0.6444015502929688, 0.12296503782272339, -0.5830782651901245, -0.09254416823387146, 0.008675036951899529, -0.6411898136138916, 0.07667779922485352, -0.055964335799217224, 0.36240750551223755, -0.34476205706596375, 0.35917195677757263, -0.041098255664110184, -0.15065234899520874, -0.5428891181945801, -0.5142703652381897, 0.39163756370544434, 0.4548616409301758, 0.7010256052017212, -0.01491349283605814, -0.7612942457199097, 0.039287809282541275, -0.03692811727523804, -0.20236530900001526, 0.4758800268173218, -1.2269554138183594, -0.09771402180194855, 0.19046597182750702, -0.4492235779762268, -0.470636785030365, 0.11829151958227158, 0.1217208281159401, 0.9716069102287292, 0.23012696206569672, 0.7859506607055664, -0.2898794710636139, 0.021188130602240562, -0.6941293478012085, 0.3787357807159424, -0.3791021406650543, 0.3392433524131775, 0.15957050025463104, -0.07899963855743408, 0.6677770614624023, -0.21090181171894073, -0.9068483114242554, -0.371695339679718, -0.6196760535240173, 0.32674339413642883, -0.2308196872472763, 0.1053571105003357, 0.19267849624156952, 1.1597384214401245, 0.45915332436561584, -0.18483778834342957, -0.4215114414691925, 0.12239397317171097, 0.14071770012378693, 0.16272707283496857, 0.346059113740921, 0.490344762802124, 1.0275362730026245, -0.20390573143959045, 0.20248952507972717, -0.4071862995624542, 0.26654770970344543, 0.16066767275333405, 0.372985303401947, 0.07308661937713623, -0.43188542127609253, 0.2635652422904968, 0.07562673836946487, -0.5860083699226379, 0.4058791697025299, 0.0184943825006485, -0.20173470675945282, -0.6567330360412598, 0.7317981123924255, 0.47273123264312744, 0.43257996439933777, -0.13284733891487122, -0.3826081156730652, 0.1778775155544281, -0.3559179902076721, 0.32335683703422546, 0.8401257991790771, -0.6557385921478271, -0.04257606714963913, -0.6055434346199036, -0.3179970383644104, 0.12079659104347229, 0.42675307393074036, 0.5205622911453247, -0.16962295770645142, 0.19834092259407043, -0.48884788155555725, 0.2365325689315796, 0.01912826858460903, -0.01576065830886364, -0.33804434537887573, 0.1416458636522293, 0.30801600217819214, 0.4934189021587372, 0.043362781405448914, 0.18956024944782257, -0.688676655292511, -0.5610496401786804, -0.6760748624801636, 0.24910464882850647, -0.5273138284683228, -0.06574750691652298, 1.3302490711212158, -0.10617785900831223, 0.30556589365005493, 0.4262782633304596, 0.4389788508415222, -0.382805198431015, -0.14102764427661896, -0.02810564637184143, -0.665869951248169, 0.3295646011829376, 0.7320960164070129, -0.12971274554729462, 1.08497953414917, 0.4199361503124237, 1.01556396484375, 0.41248562932014465, 0.5643362998962402, 0.08544108271598816, -0.15214566886425018, 0.08887390792369843, -0.2158561497926712, -0.47746598720550537, 0.11236974596977234, -0.44955796003341675, -0.18495848774909973, 0.5264999270439148, 0.4151037037372589, 0.35310089588165283, 0.5744395852088928, -0.12479162216186523, -0.5708349943161011, -0.2719278037548065, -0.19928716123104095, -0.33154425024986267, 0.4313371777534485, -0.11790860444307327, -0.03957724943757057, -0.01995185948908329, -0.2070668786764145, -0.13035491108894348, -0.4178464412689209, 0.016872478649020195, -0.09645693004131317, 0.5601288080215454, -0.16731572151184082, 0.6976296901702881, -0.12346740067005157, -1.053073525428772, 0.32305529713630676, -0.4397128224372864, -0.8303664922714233, -0.21163825690746307, -0.566329300403595, -0.6114256381988525, 0.0003322760167066008, 0.17946121096611023, -0.453473299741745, 0.2462654858827591, -0.8290723562240601, 0.2204139232635498, 0.3389210104942322, 0.4511552155017853, -0.6455980539321899, 0.6036328673362732, 0.48842594027519226, 0.1942492574453354, -0.8305072784423828, -0.3501759171485901, 0.35035255551338196, -0.3239094018936157, 0.3282483220100403, 0.2508765757083893, -0.4816277325153351, 0.13959310948848724, -1.1088565587997437, -0.25826674699783325, -0.5587060451507568, -0.21758565306663513, 0.13967934250831604, -0.30394667387008667, -0.5215768814086914, 0.12438470125198364, 0.5449473857879639, -0.6640239953994751, -0.12066953629255295, -0.28723007440567017, 0.21062396466732025, -0.3604947328567505, -0.2575211822986603, -0.3765977621078491, 0.043991830199956894, -0.6312642097473145, 1.5758806467056274, -0.46450477838516235, -0.25310981273651123, -0.17659598588943481, 0.2563839852809906, -0.44925153255462646, 0.5588982701301575, 0.44644829630851746, -0.6276893615722656, 0.4917614758014679, 0.3231651484966278, -0.048625100404024124, 0.5573599934577942, -1.0572487115859985, 0.45596712827682495, -0.30582213401794434, -0.09464611113071442, -0.27344411611557007, -0.291229784488678, 0.35625529289245605, -0.004477459937334061, 0.8091261982917786, -1.0167057514190674, -0.03577198088169098, 1.3323657512664795, 0.16111916303634644, 0.39920079708099365, -0.3143806755542755, -0.003971656318753958, -0.08287227898836136, -0.4795270562171936, -0.3079237937927246, 0.504392683506012, 0.25209295749664307, -0.012448051944375038, -0.17312708497047424, 0.0886070504784584, 0.27851298451423645, -1.225549340248108, 0.9130757451057434, -0.33278951048851013, 0.2247667908668518, -0.13289135694503784, -0.024623725563287735, -0.37403205037117004, -0.6310461759567261, 0.5437807440757751, 0.3179636001586914, 0.250990629196167, -0.21216648817062378, -0.2524276673793793, 0.31102368235588074, -0.9860563278198242, -0.2956705689430237, 0.4431094825267792, 0.8073318600654602, -0.7183408737182617, 0.6797784566879272, 0.011145670898258686, -0.07144870609045029, -0.2914908826351166, 0.6067050099372864, 0.27886271476745605, -0.032737307250499725, 0.7104119658470154, 0.29010337591171265, 0.0066551887430250645, 0.11219076812267303, 0.029653705656528473, -0.7578717470169067, -0.2357126921415329, 0.5325745940208435, -0.5595715641975403, -0.14745782315731049, -0.13395388424396515, 0.8020796179771423, -0.7197660207748413, -0.2260800004005432, -1.3225977420806885, 0.12675395607948303, 0.5552042722702026, -0.347190260887146, -0.563727855682373, -0.1586420238018036, -0.7735782861709595, 0.40920087695121765, 0.4768415689468384, 0.4209652543067932, 0.15036484599113464, 0.1571073681116104, -0.3977014720439911, -0.8456479907035828, -0.08474011719226837, 1.2660225629806519, 0.027907181531190872, -0.7719350457191467, -0.17715735733509064, 0.012326797470450401, -0.4281407594680786, -0.8621954321861267, 1.1745185852050781, -0.12636470794677734, 0.12403212487697601, 0.19878804683685303, 0.003973945509642363, 0.8845140337944031, 0.137246236205101, -0.2905395030975342, 0.9609747529029846, -0.944267988204956, -0.2591803967952728, -0.40477752685546875, -0.3113284111022949, 0.6296764612197876, 1.0415914058685303, 0.4147188067436218, -0.601178765296936, -0.09982019662857056, -0.5787919759750366, 0.12574335932731628, 0.2998542785644531, -0.7856420278549194, -0.9498043060302734, -0.5588849186897278, -0.3994920253753662, -0.1884622722864151, 0.5650203227996826, 0.08564523607492447, -0.26375213265419006, -0.26494720578193665, -0.35614290833473206, 0.450805127620697, 0.21197167038917542, 1.0307554006576538, 0.15547367930412292, -0.6347041130065918, -0.9649825692176819, -0.8612946271896362, -0.08855444192886353, -0.9166260957717896, -0.42829611897468567, -0.024612274020910263, -0.14117620885372162, 0.11131364852190018, -0.3178959786891937, 1.271544098854065, -0.6419106125831604, -0.4071487784385681, -0.22091613709926605, -0.6351957321166992, -0.7985429763793945, 0.7821301817893982, -0.3601851761341095, 0.776762068271637, 0.3535268008708954, 0.5414336919784546, 0.03202133625745773, 0.37482452392578125, -0.9380185604095459, 0.44057077169418335, -0.5914859771728516, 0.7825617790222168, 0.09988211840391159, -0.8828945159912109, -0.2620287239551544, 0.9648053050041199, -0.5379356741905212, -0.07892392575740814, -0.0640096440911293, 0.18784454464912415, 0.07160940766334534, 0.12715138494968414, 0.18569649755954742, 0.9257429838180542, -0.03861478716135025, 1.1213243007659912, -0.2595430612564087, -0.2132498174905777, -0.04688374325633049, 0.17209738492965698, -0.17003782093524933, -0.5888388156890869, -0.062335096299648285, -0.5002657771110535, 0.320081502199173, 1.0245625972747803, -0.11774419248104095, -0.34491297602653503, 0.35925212502479553, 0.3337583839893341, -0.31518206000328064, 0.24427403509616852, -0.12674137949943542, 0.430831640958786, 0.507249653339386, -0.41862809658050537, -0.045738041400909424, -0.2771059274673462, -1.4959931373596191, 0.39044657349586487, -0.2134505957365036, -0.5090361833572388, 0.41540881991386414, -0.20897544920444489, -0.28844887018203735, 0.39911460876464844, -0.018035413697361946, -0.005276138428598642, 0.19589297473430634, 0.2235516607761383, 0.740041971206665, -0.39127251505851746, -0.6191200613975525, 0.5354018211364746, -0.2198445200920105, -0.6799317598342896, -0.7393153309822083, 0.2898269593715668, -1.080184817314148, -0.7013974785804749, 0.279558002948761, 0.3636930286884308, -0.18075881898403168, -0.9715718030929565, -0.38129928708076477, -0.1993970423936844, -0.225468248128891, -0.5753501653671265, -1.5021634101867676, -0.11659818887710571, -0.2809460759162903, 0.24019795656204224, -0.3643767833709717, 0.11573783308267593, 0.11981768161058426, -0.33798325061798096, 0.8445247411727905, -0.7727781534194946, -0.41719716787338257, 0.8123510479927063, -0.0808643028140068, -0.31212317943573, 0.2344156950712204, 0.5139505863189697, 0.4857426881790161, 1.0052005052566528, -0.3893420100212097, -0.31423574686050415, -0.24444754421710968, -0.4499262571334839, -0.04667428880929947, 0.20243504643440247, 0.42369991540908813, 0.0034814991522580385, -0.15820519626140594, -0.0647081732749939, 0.3709983825683594, 0.013063231483101845, -0.17267942428588867, -0.0787915363907814, -0.0699712485074997, 0.5018738508224487, 0.20605157315731049, 0.08037374913692474, 0.9821963310241699, -0.24065160751342773, 0.18493476510047913, -0.019826622679829597, -0.33051639795303345, 0.20071028172969818, -0.8047022223472595, -0.2109503298997879, -0.4043981730937958, 0.6048084497451782, 0.2500148117542267, 0.028732603415846825, 0.35849282145500183, 0.2098497897386551, 0.27820590138435364, 0.12211856991052628, -0.5435419082641602, -0.07820404320955276, 0.015538638457655907, 0.9205194115638733, 0.314068466424942, 0.5938733220100403, 0.6137745976448059, 1.2033005952835083, 0.2257104367017746, -0.35188156366348267, 0.3884676992893219, 0.4631268382072449, -0.5177993178367615, 0.27474477887153625, 0.29134276509284973, 0.08192643523216248, 0.19358818233013153, -1.2107508182525635, 0.23077869415283203, -0.7129260897636414, 0.5614086389541626, 0.4051291048526764, -0.9657942652702332, 0.2199016809463501, 0.03799066320061684, 0.23963722586631775, 0.1751250922679901, 0.9087267518043518, 0.5921227335929871, -0.8567344546318054, 0.8868980407714844, 0.9128441214561462, 0.24598796665668488, -0.134650319814682, -0.07955390959978104, 0.06459788978099823, 0.21983857452869415, 0.40224799513816833, 0.039002373814582825, 0.9994779229164124, 0.00838214997202158, -0.47147637605667114, 0.4074140787124634, 0.023156646639108658, -0.13683336973190308, 0.6163036823272705, 0.38135161995887756, 0.41514840722084045, -0.3576386272907257, -0.3881382346153259, 0.4715157151222229, 0.3294045925140381, -0.4828198254108429, -0.11626818031072617, 0.18177933990955353, -0.8125221133232117, -0.44494810700416565, -0.807591438293457, 0.5836076736450195, -0.0705704391002655, -0.2887420654296875, 0.12623392045497894, -0.400769978761673, -0.42620790004730225, -0.7263819575309753, -0.3023025095462799, -0.8501717448234558, 0.6837186217308044, 0.6674225926399231, 0.3415756821632385, 0.03536159545183182, -1.0103013515472412, -0.11979511380195618, -0.6469615697860718, 0.0911693200469017, 0.02027134597301483, 0.06297449767589569, 0.4546049237251282, 0.4344535768032074, -0.5883616805076599, 0.6059902310371399, 0.9229010939598083, -0.4899468421936035, -0.03977254778146744, 0.17338645458221436, 0.17904071509838104, 0.18365710973739624, -0.21070973575115204, -0.1832531988620758, 0.338268518447876, 0.6854457259178162, 0.07047830522060394, 0.22720672190189362, 0.46993470191955566, -0.27441197633743286, 0.09857458621263504, -0.009071985259652138, 0.6299463510513306, 0.00241451570764184, -0.3160378932952881, -0.03665895387530327, -1.1324883699417114, 4.313477039337158, 0.6818459630012512, 1.2876163721084595, -0.16440819203853607, -0.13236865401268005, 0.5076169967651367, -0.03773204982280731, -0.8531967401504517, 0.41880735754966736, -0.286195307970047, -0.28629156947135925, 0.08783350139856339, 0.15924182534217834, 0.21275490522384644, 0.28962650895118713, 1.2399617433547974, 0.11845239251852036, -0.6226357221603394, 0.48727846145629883, -0.25714734196662903, -0.8210752010345459, -0.000021188989194342867, -0.7838757634162903, -0.637994110584259, 0.3824353516101837, 0.1820560246706009, 0.13122470676898956, -0.6679006814956665, -0.2787589728832245, -0.3214387595653534, -0.6133131980895996, -0.25337469577789307, -0.05408487096428871, -0.03253648057579994, -0.977724552154541, 0.770116925239563, -0.07326607406139374, -0.5266667008399963, 0.2978039085865021, -0.22883838415145874, 0.17595916986465454, -0.5270445942878723, 0.5354691743850708, 0.0527864508330822, 0.7513580322265625, 0.8601700663566589, 0.6236536502838135, 0.010331557132303715, 0.8618330359458923, -0.6847966313362122, 0.2628343403339386, 0.38107937574386597, -0.07239363342523575, -0.05785802751779556, -0.6239549517631531, -0.11989852786064148, 0.557602047920227, -0.7157897353172302, -0.07836274802684784, -0.019955899566411972, 0.2395281344652176, -0.8817943334579468, -0.37940987944602966, 0.5590233206748962, 0.2184332311153412, 0.10795985907316208, 0.029202299192547798, 0.3438591957092285, -0.7387928366661072, -0.4168291687965393, -0.5042394995689392, -0.2188916951417923, -0.5225535035133362, 0.12123728543519974, 0.3423660695552826, 0.20039264857769012, -0.11899634450674057, -0.2014797031879425, -0.023422954604029655, 0.08474015444517136, 0.26371830701828003, 0.47286316752433777, -0.21302948892116547, -0.09540501981973648, 0.3411850333213806, 0.2286207377910614, 0.25129491090774536, 0.04664933308959007, -0.36256515979766846, 0.41708138585090637, 0.2738659381866455, -0.052942972630262375, -0.2098788321018219, -0.022439144551753998, -0.11317485570907593 ]
Particle Astrophysics after COBE: Blois92 Summary Talk
The IV Rencontres de Blois, on Particle Astrophysics, held at the Ch\^ateau de Blois, June 15-20, 1992, was a meeting well-timed for a reconsideration of the issues in particle astrophysics in the light of the COBE discovery of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) fluctuations. This is a summary of what I thought were the most interesting things discussed at Blois: (1) The near-success of Cold Dark Matter (CDM) in predicting the COBE fluctuation amplitude, which favors the hypothesis that structure formed in the universe through gravitational collapse. (2) The indications that $\Omega\approx1$ and that the power spectrum has a little more power on supercluster and larger scales than CDM. These are suggested by the IRAS and CfA redshift surveys and POTENT galaxy peculiar velocity analysis, and also by the COBE data. (3) The consequent demise of CDM and the rise of hybrid schemes such as Cold+Hot Dark Matter (C+HDM). (4) The possible implications for neutrino masses and mixings, and for cosmology, of the recent results on solar neutrinos. (5) The first discovery of TeV $\gamma$ rays from an extragalactic source, which was announced at Blois. I also summarize here a number of the exciting ongoing and planned experiments and observations discussed at Blois: CERN experiments on $\nu_\mu \nu_\tau$ oscillations, which may be sufficiently sensitive to detect the $\nu_\tau$ if
Joel R. Primack
astro-ph hep-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211013
astro-ph/9211014
[ 0.04715951159596443, 0.3709423542022705, 0.5818646550178528, 0.04683695361018181, -0.6853405833244324, 0.3665328323841095, -0.42576366662979126, 0.20441019535064697, -0.6039652824401855, 1.4605443477630615, 0.8417362570762634, -0.5058025121688843, -0.35786786675453186, -0.9721376299858093, -0.6720159649848938, 0.0651128962635994, -0.03408455103635788, -0.08167847990989685, -0.8381267189979553, 0.35559141635894775, -0.3348093628883362, -0.25544241070747375, -1.3480511903762817, -0.7929631471633911, -0.12273319065570831, 0.8538995981216431, 0.521794319152832, 0.5878477096557617, 0.9055042862892151, 0.6007580161094666, 0.19563867151737213, -0.8519901037216187, -0.10125025361776352, -0.8233302235603333, -1.0113338232040405, -0.5978016257286072, 0.16616690158843994, -0.3438354730606079, 1.215172529220581, -0.5406707525253296, 0.7013770937919617, -0.0516904816031456, 0.7447487115859985, -0.2261539101600647, -0.6288406848907471, 0.2122230976819992, 0.22677449882030487, -0.5468586683273315, 0.2053474336862564, -1.1800434589385986, 0.5636013150215149, 0.433223694562912, 0.7425228357315063, -0.5778368711471558, 0.28080883622169495, -0.21274517476558685, -0.196987122297287, 0.5128340125083923, -0.06217782571911812, 0.4756559431552887, 0.531653642654419, 0.5125688314437866, 1.0472071170806885, -0.13635946810245514, -0.5951425433158875, 1.170953631401062, -0.061252254992723465, 0.2837580740451813, 0.010902396403253078, -0.06598103046417236, -0.1630382239818573, -0.06128259748220444, -0.13238222897052765, 0.15855218470096588, -0.9644847512245178, 0.30456387996673584, 0.2544156312942505, -0.02476378157734871, -0.6183910965919495, -0.05107378959655762, 0.3488510549068451, 0.22284016013145447, -0.11687280982732773, 0.8189122676849365, -0.16194581985473633, -0.5491360425949097, -0.02772163599729538, 0.3120953142642975, -0.049527477473020554, 0.042482711374759674, 0.13733944296836853, 0.5106804370880127, -0.5787258148193359, -0.19401076436042786, 0.5785114169120789, -0.2624695897102356, -0.23293310403823853, 0.1335953325033188, 0.07213668525218964, 0.44378840923309326, 0.21180391311645508, 0.6098114252090454, -0.6426709294319153, -0.05389503389596939, -0.7170760035514832, 0.9321790337562561, -0.04899384453892708, 0.8112456202507019, 0.10535001009702682, -1.4075405597686768, 0.27221357822418213, -0.3497365713119507, 0.3245886564254761, -0.004850469995290041, 0.23538200557231903, 0.648831844329834, 0.06508082896471024, 0.8115473985671997, -0.5704826712608337, -0.46860790252685547, -0.18091249465942383, 0.8077987432479858, -0.011155767366290092, 0.37723803520202637, -0.25539180636405945, -0.5284430980682373, -0.3106958568096161, -0.15952430665493011, -0.2785309851169586, 0.40717241168022156, 0.10361865162849426, -0.31254011392593384, -0.4126977026462555, 0.6319239735603333, 0.25132450461387634, -0.08281075209379196, 0.1418556123971939, 0.6678820252418518, -0.025463595986366272, -0.5443426966667175, 0.4320223927497864, 0.23994497954845428, -0.2878188192844391, 0.9234375953674316, -0.8978646397590637, 0.11108854413032532, -0.7838489413261414, 0.38160455226898193, -0.19562216103076935, 0.27498099207878113, -0.6719072461128235, -0.18995784223079681, 0.01122422143816948, 0.4407283067703247, -0.5273223519325256, 0.05599386245012283, -0.5770782232284546, -0.1612197905778885, 0.3035535216331482, -0.44554978609085083, 0.08334887772798538, -0.03400886431336403, 0.6389873027801514, 0.38620758056640625, -0.6114820837974548, -0.013643584214150906, -0.745182454586029, -0.3970785439014435, -0.18567973375320435, -0.42368966341018677, -0.19370557367801666, 0.5675460696220398, -0.6157251000404358, 0.43859633803367615, 0.7790976166725159, 0.5354617238044739, 0.2519143223762512, -0.4752798080444336, -0.6908708810806274, 0.4509395360946655, 0.018607597798109055, 0.1877882033586502, 0.230632945895195, 0.6367979049682617, -0.35207685828208923, -0.49098458886146545, -0.6466013193130493, -0.19541513919830322, 0.22785431146621704, -0.32468751072883606, -0.3639633059501648, 0.07398050278425217, -0.48911336064338684, 0.9239549040794373, -0.7993110418319702, 0.09615479409694672, -0.7613344192504883, 0.12522651255130768, 0.4539499878883362, -0.6086857318878174, 0.17533543705940247, -0.02995498664677143, 0.012750408612191677, 0.04204218089580536, -0.9227755069732666, -0.0020721901673823595, 0.4178113341331482, 0.7610192894935608, -0.6117343902587891, 0.15223820507526398, 0.25968021154403687, 0.13398660719394684, 0.45398107171058655, -0.3102055788040161, -0.011280206963419914, -0.47420746088027954, -0.3324654996395111, -0.19976864755153656, -0.40107670426368713, 0.15439894795417786, 0.35584279894828796, 0.34967467188835144, 0.27567389607429504, 0.7467058897018433, -0.24140776693820953, -0.33584102988243103, 0.03704983741044998, 0.7042760252952576, -0.15917439758777618, 0.06270134449005127, 0.13510830700397491, 0.5575231909751892, 0.1202995553612709, 0.7640483975410461, 0.3003491759300232, -0.38996779918670654, 0.5992940664291382, 0.5436635613441467, 0.05474036931991577, 0.06019356846809387, 0.18365731835365295, -0.37174707651138306, 0.6193317770957947, 0.04428565129637718, -1.1247262954711914, 0.48477768898010254, -0.058045875281095505, -0.26072224974632263, -0.29049938917160034, 0.583593487739563, -0.2732596695423126, 0.4352176785469055, 0.10925647616386414, 0.18594945967197418, -1.0838862657546997, 0.21060293912887573, 0.11173899471759796, -0.01740187406539917, -0.5270145535469055, -1.2084038257598877, -0.1647668480873108, 0.055491842329502106, -0.04095761477947235, -0.5934898257255554, 0.00611464399844408, 0.49037039279937744, -0.8295570015907288, 0.1346571296453476, 0.5617275834083557, -0.26433947682380676, -0.49694299697875977, 0.04796505719423294, -0.6932368874549866, 0.12187120318412781, -0.3036133348941803, 0.330410361289978, -0.05409914255142212, -0.5273751616477966, 0.9180841445922852, 0.28901758790016174, -0.38093942403793335, 0.5878304839134216, -0.013844712637364864, 0.3850896954536438, -0.38498157262802124, 0.1998823583126068, -0.6356799602508545, 0.8944523930549622, -1.0635415315628052, 0.11851269751787186, -0.6239241361618042, 0.23387371003627777, 0.18202632665634155, -0.7107059359550476, 0.33020126819610596, 0.8073721528053284, -0.09387994557619095, 0.7121266722679138, 0.14366255700588226, -1.0040080547332764, 0.6274646520614624, -0.20587487518787384, -0.110059954226017, -0.18986313045024872, -1.0268560647964478, 0.4399305582046509, -0.30412063002586365, 0.09778103232383728, 0.3378424644470215, -0.3625064492225647, -0.6131454706192017, 0.38314080238342285, -0.09510122984647751, 0.7120891213417053, -0.21832776069641113, 0.6244806051254272, 0.48183491826057434, 0.5394988059997559, 0.1771731823682785, -0.07892820239067078, -1.0500357151031494, -0.48049670457839966, 0.43699684739112854, -0.5107485055923462, 0.5016531944274902, 0.3191916048526764, 0.28877517580986023, -0.6352230310440063, 1.014884352684021, -0.607134997844696, -0.9384105205535889, 0.4853174686431885, 0.15784430503845215, 0.2424742728471756, -0.4334356486797333, -0.3614887297153473, 0.17632004618644714, -0.3192690312862396, -0.5294593572616577, 0.3318321406841278, 0.9107046127319336, -0.15211547911167145, 0.3492276668548584, 0.803300678730011, -0.029104942455887794, -0.41601863503456116, 0.5987178683280945, -0.35665029287338257, -0.13218343257904053, 0.22259089350700378, -0.4562011957168579, 0.597746729850769, -0.01990066096186638, 0.44443053007125854, -0.12600605189800262, 0.511339545249939, -0.2289050966501236, -0.20986925065517426, -0.7018784284591675, -0.1875438094139099, -0.4540904760360718, 1.1740474700927734, 0.35798314213752747, -0.5845769643783569, -0.4650026559829712, -0.2937124967575073, 0.308238685131073, -0.6929416656494141, 0.09924674779176712, -0.7910053730010986, -0.14562222361564636, -0.07991994917392731, -0.12432993948459625, -0.2207142859697342, 0.4642452001571655, 0.4062689244747162, 0.4692574143409729, 0.48582395911216736, 0.2618527114391327, -0.5290037989616394, -0.1785118132829666, -0.20553942024707794, 0.5644820928573608, 0.40882712602615356, 0.2734515070915222, 0.1959758996963501, -0.0011435742489993572, 0.59698885679245, -0.3828091621398926, -0.7218632102012634, -0.5095335841178894, -1.0731853246688843, 0.5042715668678284, -0.07769490033388138, -0.15210533142089844, -0.028567781671881676, 0.41963323950767517, 0.5284289717674255, -0.02820453979074955, 0.12558971345424652, 0.07875026017427444, -0.4073943495750427, -0.1741792857646942, 0.3377963602542877, -0.07086338847875595, 0.5988484621047974, -1.0312104225158691, 0.31052929162979126, 0.3737030625343323, 0.07952935993671417, -0.008003120310604572, -0.33425208926200867, 0.26239222288131714, 0.2601112127304077, 0.5099908113479614, 0.26778918504714966, -0.3796728849411011, 0.21808072924613953, -0.015490171499550343, 0.45994359254837036, -0.96797114610672, 0.11348094046115875, 0.5173550248146057, 0.8370751142501831, 0.17245958745479584, -0.9065567255020142, -0.09640230983495712, -1.1839884519577026, 0.6201463341712952, 0.1839262694120407, -0.38954222202301025, -0.8180756568908691, -0.4584004878997803, 0.18335238099098206, -0.42168405652046204, 0.4937794506549835, 1.3223841190338135, 0.15539279580116272, 0.5489212274551392, -0.30759960412979126, -0.48654255270957947, 0.3605857193470001, -0.5611647367477417, -0.38382425904273987, 0.4286387264728546, 0.15123403072357178, -0.14367111027240753, 0.4237280488014221, -0.45209306478500366, -1.1776933670043945, 0.19169193506240845, -0.44838008284568787, 0.7199494242668152, -0.1368318796157837, -0.021949216723442078, 0.28934556245803833, -0.45864009857177734, -0.15472915768623352, 0.916369616985321, 0.27629896998405457, -0.16224385797977448, 0.46255722641944885, 0.10648811608552933, -0.5320929288864136, 0.16546331346035004, 0.3346262574195862, -0.5896998643875122, 0.6327017545700073, 0.2899860441684723, 0.3613492548465729, 0.8752244710922241, -0.03694654256105423, 0.0436599962413311, -0.37732937932014465, 0.3262537717819214, -0.3667229115962982, -0.02242642268538475, 0.7746943831443787, -0.28755876421928406, -0.4875580668449402, 0.3046489357948303, 0.3933444321155548, -0.2742479741573334, 0.6879704594612122, -0.2793928384780884, -0.6254974007606506, -0.10434874892234802, 0.40183183550834656, -0.48226600885391235, 0.5569301843643188, -0.20589785277843475, -0.13415277004241943, -0.14671999216079712, -0.09479086846113205, 0.16049626469612122, -0.5135557055473328, -0.4264333248138428, -0.32461339235305786, -0.2775798738002777, 0.014638658612966537, 0.8405647873878479, 0.7725439667701721, -0.9621226191520691, 0.48313242197036743, -0.2905367910861969, -0.00367280887439847, -0.6710555553436279, -0.10059278458356857, 0.12965089082717896, 0.432351291179657, 0.6073049902915955, 0.2983783185482025, 0.32985207438468933, -0.0972033366560936, -0.1092289462685585, 0.4590798020362854, 0.21555903553962708, -0.1351729929447174, -0.5184445381164551, 0.11152899265289307, 0.49782803654670715, -0.575491726398468, -0.44669732451438904, 0.8110629916191101, -0.21359120309352875, 0.17183823883533478, -0.5675892233848572, -0.6214686036109924, 0.11347059905529022, -1.0856621265411377, -0.2460794448852539, -1.2380337715148926, -0.21292658150196075, 0.4664258658885956, -0.13258923590183258, 0.44786491990089417, 0.2165078967809677, -0.10246264934539795, -1.2331169843673706, -0.7501226663589478, -0.5611008405685425, 0.44366201758384705, -0.0593341626226902, -0.20790670812129974, -0.4755185842514038, -0.12236417829990387, -1.0563454627990723, 1.1238089799880981, -0.8904191255569458, -0.4567972421646118, -0.2076846957206726, 0.11430305242538452, -0.20603927969932556, 0.6183516383171082, 0.08806765079498291, -0.2525518238544464, 0.12286980450153351, 0.048703745007514954, 0.2292049527168274, 1.1546365022659302, -0.4837696850299835, -0.07842328399419785, -0.4115711450576782, -0.17200276255607605, -0.26375576853752136, -0.1555960327386856, 0.6860784888267517, 0.3442440330982208, 0.8608522415161133, -0.10010641068220139, -0.04980604723095894, 0.5240963697433472, 0.5864842534065247, 1.0244115591049194, -0.0007478250190615654, -0.5214118957519531, 0.24427255988121033, -0.7564736008644104, -0.8743158578872681, 0.2747263014316559, 0.13506220281124115, 0.04801914840936661, -0.5972260236740112, -0.21188320219516754, -0.13090965151786804, -0.5577245354652405, 0.42779478430747986, 0.074449323117733, 0.20769941806793213, 0.14200197160243988, 0.34192222356796265, -0.12285801023244858, -0.23693260550498962, 0.3251606225967407, 0.1644601970911026, 0.4100000560283661, 0.12136213481426239, -0.39101335406303406, -0.4228152930736542, -0.5275957584381104, -0.8514437675476074, 0.33783358335494995, 0.7611077427864075, -0.3209250569343567, 0.5905411839485168, -0.03750826418399811, -0.07606858760118484, -0.3750288188457489, 0.7624242901802063, 0.6900292634963989, 0.1219419613480568, 0.7997972369194031, 0.3763086497783661, -0.15174120664596558, 0.369943767786026, 0.323330283164978, -0.28055280447006226, -0.2888113558292389, 1.0805332660675049, 0.12156862020492554, -0.12102728337049484, 0.2591188848018646, 0.6287956237792969, -0.5948034524917603, -0.7978559732437134, -1.3231128454208374, 0.9071955680847168, 0.48988690972328186, -0.1865539252758026, -0.37899231910705566, -0.017806218937039375, -0.14862973988056183, 0.5154677033424377, 0.9962003827095032, 0.5596207976341248, 0.519624650478363, 0.03464813902974129, 0.0681096687912941, -0.3318476974964142, -0.09283581376075745, 1.1788039207458496, 0.6037905216217041, -1.3353381156921387, 0.23269160091876984, -0.3995984196662903, -0.3745785653591156, -0.30239441990852356, 1.715010166168213, -0.03707991540431976, -0.03374781459569931, 0.32421037554740906, 0.22511515021324158, -0.09778652340173721, -0.04695521295070648, 0.28200051188468933, 0.24805869162082672, -0.1846545934677124, -0.4492369592189789, -0.14128246903419495, -0.10655252635478973, -0.11356361210346222, 0.2893756031990051, 0.4665563702583313, -0.4460878074169159, 0.032163288444280624, -0.4627014696598053, -0.17236091196537018, -0.13886427879333496, -0.23482468724250793, -0.9789280891418457, -0.15532200038433075, -0.45944684743881226, 0.052443258464336395, 0.17551514506340027, 0.3609074354171753, 0.022886652499437332, 0.40783998370170593, -0.2607441246509552, 0.6493676900863647, -0.21595504879951477, 1.0368934869766235, -0.4989202320575714, -0.13210426270961761, -0.49495139718055725, -0.1025996208190918, -0.18671207129955292, -0.355459064245224, -0.23900865018367767, -0.5155888199806213, -0.8229724168777466, 1.109609842300415, -0.16793644428253174, 1.1329824924468994, -0.43134111166000366, -0.48495399951934814, -0.07210275530815125, -0.620043933391571, -1.0749565362930298, 0.5720073580741882, -0.43776747584342957, 0.9655657410621643, 0.8445309400558472, -0.510283350944519, -0.18060797452926636, -0.13253618776798248, -0.9331400990486145, 0.18817968666553497, 0.4713723361492157, 1.0899653434753418, -0.1955455243587494, -1.2736226320266724, -0.16134393215179443, 0.5916504263877869, -1.146944284439087, -0.6837391257286072, -0.4513290524482727, 0.59912109375, -0.3230533301830292, 0.027625693008303642, -0.39506977796554565, 0.6875125169754028, -0.253856360912323, 0.22296498715877533, -0.16264362633228302, 0.44301486015319824, 0.6551632881164551, -0.09426145255565643, -0.018985986709594727, -0.425595223903656, 0.03085932321846485, -0.4692324697971344, 0.007255326025187969, 0.3811410069465637, -0.17722509801387787, -0.6245250701904297, -0.018648726865649223, -0.2782796323299408, -0.18681183457374573, 0.20942914485931396, -0.4910872280597687, 0.776864767074585, 0.3398328721523285, 0.012138072401285172, 0.23034140467643738, -0.029903383925557137, -1.087647557258606, 0.518125057220459, -0.4347136914730072, -0.38602668046951294, -0.0374269001185894, 0.34887123107910156, -0.4195076823234558, 0.08676981925964355, -0.8384464383125305, 0.08892618119716644, 0.08701708167791367, 0.32547464966773987, 0.381826788187027, -0.5655440092086792, -0.3498627245426178, 0.15022940933704376, -1.1756247282028198, -0.6095012426376343, -1.2625974416732788, 0.5716277360916138, -0.7010801434516907, -1.1792479753494263, 0.14090535044670105, -0.5671929121017456, -0.05889159068465233, -0.1326063573360443, -0.14184492826461792, -0.09341107308864594, 0.058586668223142624, -0.4779435396194458, -0.20397447049617767, -0.2715035080909729, -0.5506454110145569, 0.511938214302063, -0.2452423870563507, -0.32251232862472534, -0.005424532573670149, 0.15973378717899323, 0.9838947653770447, -0.14644820988178253, -0.9995752573013306, 0.6917798519134521, 0.6163321137428284, 0.2845970690250397, 0.5630172491073608, 0.3335787355899811, -0.13112366199493408, 0.8366514444351196, -0.7507930397987366, 0.18844588100910187, 0.47527047991752625, 0.15263083577156067, 0.8043202757835388, 0.25446009635925293, -0.054327186197042465, 0.29739534854888916, 0.057449545711278915, -0.08557069301605225, 0.03425516560673714, 0.01023801974952221, 0.31608814001083374, 0.4925948977470398, 0.3216649889945984, -0.264584481716156, 0.2392793744802475, -0.987784206867218, -0.062071263790130615, -0.2377234846353531, -0.1449565440416336, -0.8025051951408386, -0.48946213722229004, 0.4458707869052887, -0.8084951043128967, -0.8287222981452942, -0.3406005799770355, -0.10737138241529465, 0.46220889687538147, -0.403474360704422, 0.4830285310745239, 0.6572433710098267, 0.4765763580799103, 0.002057588892057538, -0.06939450651407242, 0.1476675570011139, -0.045952510088682175, 0.8320409059524536, 0.564247727394104, -0.1414598524570465, 0.20659810304641724, 0.4677746295928955, 0.3128424286842346, -1.0924004316329956, 0.3439173698425293, 0.46515384316444397, -0.4591943323612213, 0.013557372614741325, 0.09153128415346146, -0.4100775420665741, -0.25113096833229065, -0.6503981947898865, 0.2904037833213806, -0.3388102948665619, 0.0490257553756237, 0.1105361208319664, -0.26003190875053406, 0.05453864485025406, 0.5116252899169922, 0.4540870487689972, 0.1131444126367569, 0.5002341866493225, -0.027195686474442482, -0.399703711271286, 1.3270483016967773, 1.2082388401031494, 0.6198810338973999, 0.13266219198703766, -0.08354856073856354, -0.007054516114294529, 0.12914778292179108, 0.2512882649898529, -0.8854253888130188, 0.2763107717037201, 0.1843584030866623, 0.46461230516433716, 0.2362804412841797, -0.04879722744226456, -0.3947305381298065, -0.17920029163360596, 0.3566884994506836, 0.9122445583343506, -0.287386029958725, -0.3119752109050751, 0.3407938480377197, 0.25576522946357727, -0.3818603456020355, -0.42952606081962585, 0.8745839595794678, -0.6486722230911255, 0.303586483001709, -0.8259590268135071, 0.3020550012588501, -0.15977780520915985, 0.10275843739509583, -0.32078295946121216, -0.13576240837574005, -0.6116012334823608, -0.6641276478767395, 0.03901247680187225, -0.2753099799156189, 0.49726414680480957, 1.0611257553100586, -0.058930009603500366, 0.5850542187690735, -0.9626829624176025, -0.2450956404209137, -0.19834595918655396, 0.5953124761581421, -0.038152992725372314, 0.2537035346031189, 0.6758809685707092, 0.03755465894937515, -0.4152906537055969, 0.5647277235984802, 0.6150978207588196, -0.7487903237342834, 0.34803342819213867, -0.6045499444007874, 0.5073525309562683, 0.14661714434623718, -0.17012304067611694, 0.3248853385448456, 0.7305478453636169, -0.19932718575000763, -0.40174010396003723, -0.40038540959358215, 0.5200393199920654, -0.4941556751728058, -0.05658125877380371, -0.2887754738330841, 0.40906453132629395, 0.14683766663074493, -0.5582862496376038, 0.08031024783849716, -1.3837027549743652, 4.307890892028809, 0.5527794361114502, 0.1044713705778122, 0.37823423743247986, 0.39640361070632935, 0.4925995171070099, -0.28371676802635193, -0.0011157894041389227, 0.2694559693336487, -0.592927873134613, -0.08091513812541962, -0.39556387066841125, -0.13845397531986237, 0.2742553651332855, 0.5202335715293884, 0.9454310536384583, -0.32496628165245056, -0.10975716263055801, -0.1774791032075882, -0.2500140368938446, -1.0255184173583984, -0.4987696409225464, 0.04451436176896095, 0.27329644560813904, 0.03284298628568649, 0.3744538724422455, 0.01426729280501604, -0.08071963489055634, -0.8499128222465515, 0.22286053001880646, -0.31186041235923767, -0.2009078562259674, -0.0469781756401062, -0.03882386535406113, -0.7820544242858887, 0.08673781156539917, 0.3242878317832947, 0.3348076641559601, 0.21294109523296356, -0.25780346989631653, 0.1207161471247673, -0.8919261693954468, 0.5137780904769897, -0.5377964377403259, -0.5880537033081055, 0.3487580418586731, -0.17697182297706604, 0.21210764348506927, -0.11726750433444977, -0.7218031883239746, 0.5224729180335999, 0.2913120985031128, 0.5331252813339233, -0.639174222946167, -0.6624307036399841, -0.24189479649066925, 0.49230241775512695, -0.27442073822021484, -0.5254584550857544, -0.36310938000679016, 0.6440491676330566, -0.907204270362854, -0.4525081515312195, 0.5245349407196045, 0.25987276434898376, 0.3363271653652191, 0.24735131859779358, 0.37768980860710144, -0.09968118369579315, -0.011770100332796574, -0.2773202955722809, -0.5369754433631897, -0.855635941028595, -0.5075079202651978, 0.44649094343185425, 0.10979370027780533, -0.12358086556196213, -0.07376399636268616, 0.5360815525054932, 0.00397486612200737, -0.4481460452079773, 0.04716666415333748, -0.6164813041687012, -0.09937452524900436, 0.13209982216358185, 0.9691230058670044, -0.0930890366435051, -0.17895832657814026, -0.027598554268479347, -0.024726776406168938, 0.05782395601272583, 0.6771742701530457, -0.11661425977945328, -0.4066500961780548, -0.31536829471588135 ]
On the General Properties of Matter
By means of a general classification of the different kinds of matter of nature form a chain from the world of the subatomic particles to the large bodies of the universe, the galaxies. Then, it proposes a new baryonic force for the universe that is the fifth force which has been proposed in the literature. It explains the universal expansion itself and shows why the expansion must be slowing down at present. This force depends on the ratio of the number of neutrons to the number of protons. Its potential for the Universe is a well. At the bottom of the well the potential is of the form $kx^2$, where $x$ is the separation among the bodies under consideration. It is suggested that Nature has six fundamental forces which are unified in pairs and, therefore, reduced to three at $t=0$. The condition for having a closed universe is found. This new force, called superweak force in this paper, explains also the evolution of galaxies and shows how the arms of spiral galaxies(including barred spirals) are formed. The variation of the Hubble constant with time is shown. It is shown that quarks are formed of prequarks which may be the true elementary particles. The paper also gives a physical explanation for quark confinement. The energies of baryon states are calculated in a simple manner. The paper proposes the existence of four more bosons, one for the superweak interaction and three for the superstrong interaction. The six figures will be sent by mail upon request.
Mario Everaldo de Souza (Departamento de Fisica, Universidade Federal de Sergipe, Aracaju, Brazil)
astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9211014
astro-ph/9212001
[ 0.4458504021167755, 0.6580219864845276, 0.8616767525672913, 0.08582539856433868, -0.31241485476493835, -0.31240373849868774, -0.5750837922096252, -0.050559431314468384, -0.7406641244888306, 1.2329412698745728, 0.055962346494197845, -0.4033065736293793, -0.5434816479682922, -0.8152090311050415, -0.11825645714998245, 0.3222227096557617, 0.30840376019477844, -0.32844337821006775, -1.4476066827774048, -0.5318990349769592, 0.2509782910346985, -0.6636320352554321, -0.9720803499221802, -0.7294707298278809, -0.567367434501648, 0.6068756580352783, 0.3987669050693512, 1.097642421722412, 0.8700023889541626, 0.9739430546760559, 0.17911787331104279, -0.2732022702693939, -0.07016181945800781, -0.9817560911178589, 0.26418593525886536, -0.4078105092048645, 0.3508952558040619, -0.8114425539970398, 0.2795906960964203, -0.48723307251930237, 0.7329570651054382, 0.31740808486938477, 0.772243082523346, -0.6850889325141907, -0.18441736698150635, -0.166098490357399, 0.2688645124435425, -0.1233263835310936, 0.2832900881767273, -0.6288256645202637, -0.3881012201309204, 0.2994450330734253, 0.4316408634185791, -0.13548417389392853, 0.051260869950056076, 0.05848364904522896, 0.15587112307548523, -0.14940987527370453, -0.5394580960273743, -0.33154478669166565, 0.6569502353668213, 0.4312044084072113, 0.5577610731124878, -0.4110677242279053, -0.32159996032714844, 1.265405535697937, -0.4851122498512268, 0.2972334623336792, 0.01049110945314169, -0.7077628374099731, -0.09420053660869598, 0.31576839089393616, -0.18681612610816956, 0.4858115017414093, -0.7480249404907227, 0.3113802671432495, -0.22310273349285126, 0.0976572185754776, 0.03263122960925102, 0.18977764248847961, -0.01025981642305851, 0.23843726515769958, 0.7196364402770996, 0.3120671808719635, 0.459018737077713, -0.6004518866539001, -0.11979050934314728, 0.19390495121479034, 0.027049999684095383, -0.37407591938972473, -0.4451753795146942, 0.7124640345573425, -0.11204476654529572, -0.3316684365272522, 0.4665759801864624, 0.3807446360588074, -0.46865758299827576, -0.393351286649704, -0.15339992940425873, 0.015931837260723114, -0.17491447925567627, 0.46963948011398315, -0.6115603446960449, -0.03321791812777519, -0.4696398675441742, 0.19761519134044647, -0.3182794153690338, -0.6110735535621643, -0.5392178893089294, -0.814969539642334, 0.3622412383556366, 0.43205875158309937, 0.6194232702255249, -0.3961791396141052, -0.09420578181743622, 0.47939568758010864, 0.2668635845184326, -0.058419253677129745, -0.34464409947395325, -0.0336163192987442, 0.013694537803530693, 0.5258801579475403, 0.37952670454978943, 0.13574112951755524, -0.7516840100288391, 0.41895169019699097, 0.37909996509552, -0.3657064735889435, -1.0522793531417847, -0.3175559639930725, 0.23658743500709534, -0.604826807975769, -0.12264388799667358, 1.1805775165557861, 0.23168393969535828, 0.41248583793640137, 0.09957004338502884, 0.109027199447155, 0.4044700562953949, -1.2756714820861816, -0.5300419926643372, -0.11905086785554886, 0.39183342456817627, 1.256617784500122, -0.2457866221666336, 0.6251140832901001, 0.5103484392166138, -0.620719850063324, -0.6178210377693176, -0.22036392986774445, 0.6735034584999084, -1.0746068954467773, -0.5676611661911011, -0.10502340644598007, -0.653540313243866, 0.0310073159635067, -0.6572185754776001, -0.18411660194396973, -0.6738612651824951, -0.3142763376235962, 0.17918096482753754, -0.23079746961593628, 0.3445322811603546, 1.0149760246276855, 0.24904301762580872, 0.511539101600647, -0.35096797347068787, -0.7672491669654846, 0.21491090953350067, -0.35841530561447144, 0.31991830468177795, -0.07878474146127701, 0.23577076196670532, 0.7286444902420044, 0.46354779601097107, 0.306199312210083, 0.5704734921455383, -0.019061850383877754, -0.5418218970298767, 0.29496103525161743, -0.49004822969436646, -0.2602587640285492, 0.2704928517341614, 0.3225044012069702, -0.14370253682136536, -0.04267243668437004, 0.16209791600704193, -0.24996639788150787, -0.08725661039352417, -0.06350375711917877, -0.03094468265771866, 0.3476598560810089, -0.6699778437614441, 0.32944896817207336, -0.7490333914756775, -0.28839826583862305, -0.6549383401870728, -0.33190229535102844, -0.05480640381574631, -0.7992156147956848, 0.23360808193683624, 0.41958341002464294, -0.3035595715045929, 0.5388201475143433, 0.6087443828582764, -0.4583909809589386, 0.881565511226654, 0.22339265048503876, 0.5349577069282532, 0.26669859886169434, 0.7771194577217102, -0.16946221888065338, 0.47363829612731934, -0.2693818509578705, 0.6870113015174866, -0.4650600552558899, -0.011394169181585312, 0.16631485521793365, -0.2405325025320053, 0.4779919385910034, 0.5500805974006653, 0.36931827664375305, -0.43263766169548035, 1.0976637601852417, 0.6833875775337219, -0.4579669237136841, -0.38819584250450134, 0.8653091192245483, 0.5412521362304688, -0.18111225962638855, -0.4799131751060486, 0.08847454190254211, 0.4146094024181366, 0.41007718443870544, 0.6737579703330994, -0.09909649193286896, 0.43309637904167175, 0.7053244113922119, 0.4284907877445221, -0.17775556445121765, 0.2882630228996277, -0.5447306632995605, 0.4449911117553711, 0.7034757137298584, 0.19502905011177063, 0.3331153094768524, 0.02777130901813507, -0.44284194707870483, -0.2808492183685303, -0.019724272191524506, 0.13230030238628387, 0.838860034942627, 0.08719430863857269, -0.13043656945228577, -0.6158104538917542, -0.6227697730064392, 0.0627957358956337, -0.1346459686756134, 0.07454388588666916, -0.23173975944519043, -0.17779472470283508, -0.11865200847387314, 0.38243567943573, -0.14179708063602448, -0.4663906991481781, -0.5196142792701721, -0.6808612942695618, -0.0385059118270874, 0.4451526999473572, -0.2703746259212494, -1.3221592903137207, 0.13497982919216156, -0.9799681901931763, -0.20405130088329315, 0.677438497543335, -0.08803154528141022, 0.18516388535499573, -0.07459324598312378, 0.15010321140289307, -0.3186569809913635, -0.08943493664264679, 0.7187477946281433, -0.8871164917945862, 0.3566620647907257, -0.4690028131008148, 0.7755710482597351, -0.49720340967178345, 0.28012922406196594, -0.2110254466533661, -0.19123482704162598, 0.03020770102739334, -0.22048769891262054, -0.8588259220123291, -0.47042497992515564, 0.34380215406417847, 0.02085203491151333, -0.0975368544459343, -0.37699079513549805, 0.8020086884498596, -0.7765774726867676, 0.38098573684692383, -0.16710762679576874, -1.016222596168518, -0.36534619331359863, -0.47139427065849304, -0.30968087911605835, -0.41043639183044434, -0.17670351266860962, 0.5072171688079834, 0.11414122581481934, -0.42071592807769775, 0.03800170123577118, -0.07432617247104645, 0.25473085045814514, -0.1491284966468811, 0.409477561712265, 0.6032987236976624, -0.03630605340003967, 1.188708782196045, -0.12450474500656128, 0.025875728577375412, -0.335024893283844, 0.19564901292324066, -0.6480340361595154, 0.0869280993938446, 0.6306070685386658, 0.6522073149681091, -0.14190661907196045, 0.4287276566028595, -0.6763547658920288, -0.10222063213586807, -0.3715369999408722, -0.11159001290798187, 0.44117438793182373, 0.09827127307653427, -0.40374138951301575, -0.2434757649898529, 0.26464492082595825, 0.30597925186157227, 1.1648459434509277, 0.49437016248703003, -0.12976504862308502, 0.03922133520245552, 0.9509813189506531, -0.4669439494609833, 0.03575412929058075, 0.26889708638191223, -0.20181496441364288, -0.42848435044288635, -0.22527724504470825, -0.6654373407363892, -0.3234797716140747, 0.34854912757873535, 0.16408751904964447, 0.09499907493591309, 0.6704971790313721, -0.3556411564350128, 0.3444085717201233, -0.41981807351112366, -0.7913321852684021, 0.2772887945175171, -0.009116174653172493, 0.2774639129638672, -0.3880539834499359, 0.19261950254440308, 0.4796220064163208, 0.3038782477378845, 0.39071449637413025, 0.4799603819847107, -0.5355920791625977, 0.5310937166213989, -0.38551753759384155, -0.06412816047668457, -0.6233696341514587, -0.2055329978466034, -0.5309303998947144, 1.0622612237930298, 0.34813207387924194, 1.1406153440475464, -0.39219558238983154, -0.44354429841041565, -0.45369046926498413, -0.0750688835978508, 0.37996888160705566, 0.048669617623090744, -0.4771452248096466, 0.05828620120882988, 0.31577587127685547, -0.2957986891269684, -0.47364771366119385, -0.4203890860080719, -0.9742628931999207, 0.1900649070739746, -0.2051694244146347, -1.203465223312378, -0.12832725048065186, 0.21251022815704346, 0.957115113735199, 0.09714752435684204, -0.3083803355693817, -0.3526051938533783, -0.819071888923645, 0.10584321618080139, 0.28283262252807617, -0.7176389694213867, -0.11706926673650742, -0.3872045874595642, -0.10942764580249786, 0.020811941474676132, 0.45707112550735474, 0.20908018946647644, -0.17531122267246246, -0.41428548097610474, 0.755247175693512, 0.1949319988489151, 0.6683363914489746, -0.5209092497825623, 0.5766790509223938, -0.3763018548488617, -1.6089991331100464, -0.7318761348724365, 0.056154824793338776, 0.2911786437034607, 0.8335519433021545, 0.04410099238157272, -0.3303752839565277, -0.2492033690214157, -0.0921459048986435, 0.49878308176994324, 0.4903109669685364, -1.0756903886795044, -0.2799105644226074, -0.2415832132101059, 0.7263701558113098, 1.106939673423767, -0.14403444528579712, 0.4815836548805237, 0.3097182512283325, 0.4182911217212677, -0.2742604911327362, 0.4159245491027832, 0.9720174074172974, -0.17838317155838013, 0.7178288698196411, 0.4443167448043823, 0.29798364639282227, 0.4175611734390259, 0.46402236819267273, -0.2635490894317627, -1.1623953580856323, -0.5579542517662048, -0.6570565700531006, 1.2117438316345215, -0.2139510065317154, -0.5736859440803528, 0.9205061197280884, -0.18093010783195496, -0.4574301838874817, -0.09410546720027924, -0.37439537048339844, -0.31393057107925415, 0.07554919272661209, -0.1302085518836975, -0.3441299498081207, -0.35306379199028015, 0.03241909295320511, -0.9245492815971375, 0.4092422127723694, 1.2601797580718994, -0.23247182369232178, 0.3289833068847656, 1.0087714195251465, 0.16124777495861053, -0.024636777117848396, 0.284746915102005, -1.214842677116394, 0.008913245052099228, -0.08552433550357819, -0.13516360521316528, -0.7309685349464417, 0.019278237596154213, 0.33530813455581665, -0.14394132792949677, 0.1283983588218689, 0.5775521397590637, -0.23097296059131622, -0.1668887883424759, 0.04981013759970665, -0.4664255976676941, 0.6687890887260437, 0.14067625999450684, -0.42700105905532837, -0.7407059669494629, -0.27648070454597473, -0.16892793774604797, -0.28803592920303345, 0.3305181860923767, -0.3464997708797455, 0.18993772566318512, -0.25481343269348145, -0.19387061893939972, -0.7282442450523376, -0.2113836109638214, 0.21838663518428802, -0.02976970374584198, -0.7191935777664185, -0.28912171721458435, -0.36911413073539734, -0.33678585290908813, 0.4178491532802582, -0.2678632438182831, -0.24282211065292358, -0.35917046666145325, -0.1772346943616867, -0.3554779589176178, 1.3758279085159302, -0.2944883406162262, -0.6705580353736877, 0.6710191369056702, 0.38338854908943176, 0.7882267832756042, -1.092810034751892, -0.25564754009246826, 0.03178313001990318, 0.20594994723796844, 0.04512416943907738, -0.44757503271102905, -0.48571306467056274, 0.9327199459075928, -1.1183202266693115, 0.373708039522171, -0.1556355208158493, 0.008679676800966263, -0.57591313123703, -1.4918221235275269, -0.42729878425598145, -0.05390414968132973, 1.1032800674438477, -0.3314712941646576, -0.7231014370918274, -0.16344881057739258, 0.6734350919723511, -0.5654154419898987, 0.300165057182312, -0.8747406005859375, -0.09125108271837234, -0.2827822268009186, 1.533631682395935, -0.5523202419281006, 0.17396678030490875, 0.29219454526901245, -0.3019676208496094, 0.4288490414619446, 1.0222376585006714, 0.034331414848566055, -0.23254382610321045, -0.15897278487682343, 0.34211960434913635, 0.4529127776622772, 0.5144264101982117, -0.4966709017753601, 0.39920318126678467, -0.6010416746139526, 0.004495540633797646, 0.39665642380714417, 0.13007508218288422, -0.590414822101593, 0.40879562497138977, 0.5589444637298584, -0.31990209221839905, 0.4167690873146057, 1.1934771537780762, 0.07096243649721146, 0.2361544668674469, 0.6747947931289673, -0.5836513042449951, -0.7731350064277649, 0.036770183593034744, 0.2641032338142395, 0.7068589329719543, 0.21637143194675446, 0.5659798979759216, -0.566724956035614, -0.1892116367816925, -0.014991157688200474, -0.5187414288520813, 0.1783488690853119, 0.8511837720870972, 0.9732332825660706, 0.592256486415863, -0.3916104733943939, 0.37563586235046387, 0.028419706970453262, -0.3089803159236908, 0.15953455865383148, -0.2570723295211792, -0.9895760416984558, -0.20673762261867523, 0.06386067718267441, -0.27312663197517395, -0.2773341238498688, 0.16340814530849457, 0.46230578422546387, -0.4242982268333435, 1.0926756858825684, 0.058561794459819794, -0.6856560707092285, 0.10542294383049011, 0.38391953706741333, 0.6000001430511475, -0.09113362431526184, 0.482505738735199, -0.44987761974334717, -0.1753518134355545, 0.2971019148826599, -0.1337554156780243, -0.1835203766822815, -0.9186398983001709, 0.8226034641265869, -0.8541814684867859, -0.12217202037572861, 0.10028473287820816, 0.2994178831577301, -0.660563588142395, 0.04871760681271553, -1.3033639192581177, -0.719799816608429, -0.27229568362236023, 0.033215638250112534, -0.07425974309444427, -0.14993959665298462, -0.1655973643064499, 0.2948339581489563, 0.32362237572669983, 0.03885418549180031, -0.22096316516399384, -0.2529356777667999, -0.2949329614639282, -1.0558198690414429, 0.30662351846694946, 1.5425822734832764, 0.07904890924692154, -0.17679163813591003, -0.014366399496793747, 0.12175717204809189, -0.36660704016685486, -0.3862118422985077, 0.3576536178588867, -0.2264142781496048, 0.010270611383020878, -0.43575677275657654, 0.8176124691963196, 0.6681561470031738, 0.7224744558334351, 0.0432843416929245, 0.09870471805334091, -0.9399917721748352, -0.25241973996162415, -0.7653442621231079, -0.35382863879203796, -0.16793332993984222, 0.43928617238998413, -0.0010763584868982434, -0.12344585359096527, 0.38882216811180115, -0.5425792336463928, -0.13741952180862427, 0.3213047683238983, -0.6384935975074768, -0.383501261472702, -0.868709921836853, -1.2642409801483154, -0.6056866645812988, 0.16133210062980652, 0.8518387079238892, -0.7441455125808716, -0.08517970889806747, -0.2567799687385559, 0.6691907644271851, 0.23301494121551514, 0.6881491541862488, 0.19184541702270508, -0.2081054151058197, -0.50751793384552, 0.3405039608478546, -0.38351085782051086, -1.2204766273498535, -0.6863662600517273, 0.5758387446403503, 0.4863804280757904, 1.0495189428329468, -0.10457129031419754, 0.5935512185096741, 0.11360319703817368, -0.2888641953468323, 0.05172466114163399, -0.2874111533164978, -0.44258639216423035, 0.8650557994842529, -0.42535656690597534, 1.1399933099746704, -0.4117353856563568, -1.2407184839248657, -0.005331943277269602, 0.4923635423183441, -0.6149623394012451, 0.9686113595962524, -0.03430614247918129, 0.8422589898109436, 0.4189935624599457, -0.10120147466659546, -0.45862746238708496, 0.992995023727417, -0.4344939589500427, -0.3126647174358368, 0.28298434615135193, 0.3918021619319916, 0.3161594271659851, -0.5313566327095032, 0.3783167004585266, -0.17185594141483307, 0.2778608500957489, -0.29365354776382446, -0.5915548801422119, -0.09387192875146866, -0.43409839272499084, 0.5799797773361206, 0.21255718171596527, -0.8019272685050964, 0.08030808717012405, -0.23918206989765167, 0.3779124915599823, 0.9560301303863525, 0.27368298172950745, -0.38635143637657166, -0.39403384923934937, 0.27778103947639465, 0.06723372638225555, -0.20750896632671356, -0.756094217300415, 0.9178717732429504, 0.2815631926059723, 0.6339421272277832, -0.14431655406951904, -0.0954410657286644, -1.269681453704834, 0.23051351308822632, -0.26270315051078796, -0.36406001448631287, 0.2507091462612152, -0.07302998751401901, -0.31905022263526917, 0.528081476688385, -0.08706044405698776, 0.6219371557235718, 0.19755379855632782, 0.9138804078102112, 0.9649720788002014, -0.30817800760269165, -0.30685847997665405, 0.26638755202293396, -0.6874160170555115, 0.35877540707588196, -0.6131184697151184, 0.5698676109313965, -0.771645188331604, -0.913578450679779, 0.05851328372955322, 0.1383819878101349, -0.19722530245780945, -0.3974587023258209, -0.4394257068634033, 0.18673621118068695, -0.5399019718170166, -0.5717852711677551, -0.5114907026290894, -0.073076531291008, -0.5809609293937683, 0.18268202245235443, -0.6147464513778687, 0.2994125783443451, -0.11952576786279678, -0.37590286135673523, 0.7973996996879578, -0.3898943066596985, -0.21978981792926788, 0.798062264919281, 0.06612449884414673, -0.3191711902618408, -0.10401075333356857, 0.8035483360290527, 0.26355499029159546, 0.45218589901924133, -1.0095809698104858, -0.00044751862878911197, 0.37999242544174194, -0.13531018793582916, 0.1104016825556755, -0.30501788854599, 0.24812448024749756, -0.11054522544145584, 0.20772400498390198, 0.14625783264636993, -0.09610981494188309, 0.31131288409233093, -0.22588792443275452, 0.21730628609657288, -0.2656376361846924, 0.30605369806289673, 0.054326124489307404, 0.14257565140724182, 0.6283665895462036, 0.18843302130699158, -0.4122633934020996, -0.8538493514060974, -0.2243213951587677, 0.7346890568733215, -0.7290292382240295, -1.0077850818634033, -0.038216255605220795, 0.5394192934036255, 0.40635356307029724, -0.5810226798057556, -0.09317010641098022, -0.5289398431777954, 0.3524872958660126, 0.015926910564303398, 0.6726424098014832, 0.41712695360183716, 0.2811558246612549, 0.6793920993804932, 0.7036452889442444, 0.36146262288093567, 0.09320836514234543, 0.3683185279369354, -0.37874072790145874, -0.40842384099960327, -0.1367473602294922, 0.21542082726955414, -0.275826096534729, 0.3230399191379547, 0.9547622799873352, -0.4904121458530426, 0.15305235981941223, -0.6429410576820374, 0.23717346787452698, -0.9528771042823792, 0.5541244149208069, 0.7800651788711548, -0.5916645526885986, 0.1053382158279419, 0.3516717851161957, 0.3786604702472687, -0.12784893810749054, 0.3429235816001892, 0.358497679233551, -0.24546502530574799, 1.064369797706604, 0.9361663460731506, -0.026029283180832863, 0.06267061829566956, -0.5219563245773315, -0.10048089921474457, -0.17187628149986267, 0.16527698934078217, 0.3054300546646118, 1.2174111604690552, -0.24318157136440277, -0.03702780231833458, -0.15036286413669586, -0.07263050973415375, 0.006821298971772194, -0.42502766847610474, 0.18776823580265045, 0.30963683128356934, -0.9793347120285034, -0.4849493205547333, 0.08892668783664703, 0.7571488618850708, -0.24398216605186462, -0.32478705048561096, -0.036898158490657806, -0.7720436453819275, -0.18411988019943237, -0.32680264115333557, 0.6689600348472595, -0.2258273810148239, -0.3091144561767578, -0.38099244236946106, -0.02813786454498768, 0.19002793729305267, -0.33783867955207825, -0.506421685218811, 0.023362310603260994, 0.000596347264945507, 0.9872127175331116, 0.4264693558216095, 0.9036345481872559, -0.47863414883613586, -0.5868396162986755, -0.2477037012577057, 0.7557892799377441, -0.23444637656211853, 0.47457876801490784, 0.057692527770996094, 0.6958396434783936, -1.2933324575424194, 0.1620219498872757, -0.08296455442905426, -0.4771573841571808, 0.3015438914299011, 0.5834322571754456, -0.022989336401224136, 0.19523929059505463, -0.1897527277469635, 0.4026497006416321, 0.5090706944465637, -0.06675697863101959, 1.1199712753295898, -0.18662898242473602, 0.18858930468559265, -0.9633119106292725, -0.2161012589931488, 0.10318191349506378, 0.5254116654396057, 0.11398572474718094, -0.10848312824964523, -0.7069064378738403, -0.8642705082893372, 4.180281162261963, 0.6131898164749146, 0.47857969999313354, -0.17895539104938507, 0.6738738417625427, 0.42492011189460754, 0.09790219366550446, -0.35294729471206665, 0.3936460018157959, -0.6401470899581909, 0.10051849484443665, 0.27391597628593445, 0.19535990059375763, -0.3936059772968292, -0.15279561281204224, 0.17405076324939728, -0.5411122441291809, -0.35229164361953735, 0.6561866402626038, -0.8493330478668213, -0.9695053100585938, -0.15796911716461182, -0.37657538056373596, 0.04657997936010361, 0.4428972601890564, 0.2576705813407898, -0.2400124967098236, -0.26337915658950806, -0.23432190716266632, -0.3991941809654236, -0.006253269966691732, -0.6036658883094788, 0.8205685615539551, -0.05969976261258125, -0.062018051743507385, 0.6341922879219055, -0.0607399120926857, -0.49645259976387024, 0.5187579393386841, -0.08545196801424026, -0.46773332357406616, -0.7937379479408264, 0.4225974977016449, -0.48749956488609314, -0.2789946496486664, 1.819813847541809, 0.7687145471572876, 0.29964518547058105, 0.9515777826309204, -0.3789748549461365, 0.6078904867172241, -0.21111495792865753, -0.44390562176704407, 0.39520570635795593, -0.978604257106781, -0.13876378536224365, 0.0992141142487526, -0.0646892562508583, 0.42935118079185486, -0.28637731075286865, 0.6046296954154968, -0.10572459548711777, -0.6937726140022278, 0.3904571533203125, -0.2799247205257416, 0.6103838086128235, -0.40253928303718567, -0.3122667372226715, -0.047327909618616104, -0.09322840720415115, -0.44206520915031433, -0.16513793170452118, -0.18463443219661713, -0.008125558495521545, -0.011887205764651299, -0.22653524577617645, 0.0019319102866575122, -0.4977632164955139, -0.7847386598587036, 0.23594149947166443, -0.0456397570669651, 0.21176861226558685, -0.23463065922260284, 0.539706289768219, 0.3188383877277374, 0.3381417393684387, -0.06643076986074448, -0.38743555545806885, -0.0915951207280159, 0.3301819860935211, -0.097862109541893, 0.24970078468322754, -0.4072951078414917, -0.014257938601076603, -0.8564448356628418 ]
A rotating black hole in the Galactic Center
Recent observations of Sgr A* give strong constraints for possible models of the physical nature of Sgr A* and suggest the presence of a massive black~hole with M<2 10^6 M_sun surrounded by an accretion disk which we estimate to radiate at a luminosity of <7 10^5 L_sun. We therefore calculate the appearance of a standard accretion disk around a Kerr hole in Sgr A* following from general relativity and a few fundamental assumptions. Effective temperature and luminosity of the disk spectra do not depend on the unknown viscosity mechanism but instead are quite sensitive to variations of intrinsic parameters: the mass, the accretion rate, the angular momentum of the accreting hole and the inclination angle. A radiation field of L~7 10^4 - 7 10^5 L_sun and T_eff ~ 2-4 10^4 K can be ascribed to a rapidly rotating Kerr~hole (a>0.9) accreting 10^-8.5 - 10^-7 M_sun/yr at a black~hole mass of M=2 10^6 M_sunseen almost edge on. A low mass black hole of M<10^3 M_sun seems to be very unlikely. We provide a ``Hertzsprung-Russell diagram for black holes'' together with simple scaling laws to provide an easy-to-handle test for the black hole model.
Heino Falcke, Peter L. Biermann, Wolfgang J. Duschl and Peter G. Mezger
astro-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212001
astro-ph/9212002
[ 0.48339614272117615, 0.27233219146728516, 0.6743054986000061, -0.1468275636434555, -0.14531952142715454, 0.18601307272911072, -0.5573477745056152, 0.10307538509368896, -0.18382307887077332, 1.2849502563476562, 0.5399537682533264, -0.33685168623924255, -0.350730299949646, -0.8601622581481934, -0.4110041558742523, 0.20427833497524261, -0.028270326554775238, -0.10638995468616486, -1.5648478269577026, 0.06727083027362823, -0.27496087551116943, -0.33266937732696533, -1.0816437005996704, -1.1426286697387695, -0.20226933062076569, 1.0518938302993774, -0.40652763843536377, 0.57047438621521, 0.9838353991508484, 1.0331560373306274, 0.2439144253730774, -0.5872535705566406, -0.2239176332950592, -0.5780524015426636, -0.9609095454216003, 0.003070662496611476, 0.3199566900730133, -0.4120897948741913, 0.4509538412094116, -0.2640318274497986, 1.1789554357528687, -0.3890148103237152, 0.5898630023002625, -0.07199128717184067, -0.6308240294456482, -0.31145116686820984, -0.12275820970535278, -0.3324991464614868, 0.6188047528266907, -1.2312768697738647, 0.25214678049087524, -0.2154601365327835, 0.01107165776193142, -1.079843521118164, 0.10950149595737457, -0.4005323052406311, 0.3826630413532257, 0.5432671308517456, 0.557373583316803, 0.14075428247451782, 0.5002519488334656, 0.9159878492355347, 0.6410370469093323, -0.5184657573699951, -0.3135664463043213, 1.239376187324524, 0.1193646490573883, 0.6213489174842834, 0.2122109979391098, -0.20389069616794586, -0.9001626968383789, -0.2390657365322113, -0.11904780566692352, 0.7193623185157776, -0.9002054333686829, 0.4317980110645294, -0.058973804116249084, -0.3038575053215027, -0.17742174863815308, -0.8556013107299805, 0.7525397539138794, 0.18209557235240936, 0.15662086009979248, 0.014400997199118137, -0.0007543714600615203, -0.24640688300132751, 0.14392226934432983, 0.6819717884063721, 0.3184404671192169, 0.3216918706893921, -0.15975508093833923, 0.7253112196922302, -0.41394463181495667, -0.4666058123111725, 0.6814480423927307, 0.7479208111763, 0.02524166740477085, 0.4027397930622101, 0.2930048108100891, -0.15690878033638, 0.08568630367517471, 0.6804351806640625, -1.2727707624435425, -0.14153699576854706, -1.0642199516296387, 1.1931312084197998, -0.04366614669561386, 0.6019124388694763, -0.5224094986915588, -0.913178563117981, -0.2302396595478058, 0.0833907499909401, 0.2525990307331085, 0.5325787663459778, 0.49538639187812805, 0.9742090106010437, -0.4440295696258545, 0.01040054764598608, -1.0792315006256104, -0.8157708048820496, 0.41930538415908813, 0.7378930449485779, 0.1676238477230072, 0.5087665915489197, 0.16797305643558502, -0.6415086984634399, 0.18348312377929688, 0.18161532282829285, -0.4906100928783417, 0.13849680125713348, -0.2646944224834442, -0.3328250050544739, -0.08315468579530716, 0.7653647065162659, 0.33475637435913086, 0.23564349114894867, 0.4230114817619324, 0.9804713129997253, -0.29666265845298767, -0.45058029890060425, -0.04889407381415367, -0.2662474513053894, -0.37271326780319214, 1.0700037479400635, -1.0730340480804443, -0.00003548098902683705, -0.22234824299812317, -0.2155967354774475, -0.4665527641773224, 0.14911127090454102, -0.35429850220680237, 0.10813633352518082, 0.055704984813928604, 0.4426688253879547, -0.60213702917099, -0.12770424783229828, -1.35615074634552, 0.09986917674541473, -0.28300032019615173, -0.8286370635032654, 0.18326735496520996, -0.16793479025363922, 0.6378753781318665, 0.4534264802932739, -0.6340120434761047, 0.30694639682769775, -0.5528449416160583, -0.19771547615528107, 0.1570160835981369, -0.3219715654850006, -0.599551796913147, 0.3270716369152069, -0.47689077258110046, 0.4038144052028656, 0.4502706229686737, 0.6081457734107971, 0.14289505779743195, -0.6523303389549255, -0.23737098276615143, -0.053063079714775085, 0.0706113949418068, -0.3366709351539612, -0.17654214799404144, 0.4017249345779419, 0.11630161106586456, -0.09946820139884949, -0.30189263820648193, 0.07044922560453415, 0.48087579011917114, -0.3202561140060425, -0.5402568578720093, 1.0588675737380981, -0.6962839365005493, 1.319627046585083, -0.9313050508499146, -0.06110045686364174, -0.5576796531677246, 0.0019961432553827763, 0.12176535278558731, -0.1856333464384079, 0.3144683539867401, 0.1961255669593811, -0.5924009680747986, 0.29920870065689087, -0.9127288460731506, 0.0932043120265007, 0.4077788293361664, 0.7729386687278748, -0.8814800381660461, 0.16069425642490387, 0.5992892384529114, -0.4152940809726715, -0.17824694514274597, -0.14695842564105988, 0.23761075735092163, -0.20863890647888184, 0.07151596993207932, 0.25488656759262085, 0.2654811441898346, -0.7507190108299255, 0.27023905515670776, -0.4413481056690216, -0.34860095381736755, 0.9822165369987488, 0.17734479904174805, -0.4410897195339203, 0.12556672096252441, 0.3324119746685028, -0.2467157393693924, 0.18736954033374786, 0.06822040677070618, 0.35721978545188904, 0.053767863661050797, 0.3505355715751648, 0.17873729765415192, -0.3790074586868286, 1.1037516593933105, 0.6669440865516663, -0.2227613776922226, 0.3884136378765106, 0.3961859941482544, -0.23426596820354462, 0.24057795107364655, 0.5671771168708801, -0.5965161323547363, 0.9898151755332947, -0.3303937613964081, -0.21307872235774994, -0.4731748104095459, 0.6668416261672974, -0.6625088453292847, 0.7901682257652283, 0.22927500307559967, 0.05376989766955376, -1.072750449180603, -0.5409731268882751, -0.09078098088502884, 0.3221563398838043, -0.3109568655490875, -0.7809874415397644, -0.49497362971305847, 0.042079053819179535, 0.15724003314971924, -0.8277320861816406, -0.27672797441482544, 0.18707185983657837, -0.3839593827724457, 0.6480681300163269, 0.05792849883437157, -0.6619752049446106, -0.80290687084198, 0.06650988012552261, -0.7022345066070557, 0.032344140112400055, -0.18678618967533112, -0.05246961861848831, -0.16028393805027008, -0.23468439280986786, 0.4579606056213379, 0.07242321223020554, -1.0377076864242554, 0.6596830487251282, 0.31818464398384094, 0.23901115357875824, -0.3138941824436188, -0.009091125801205635, -0.7299866676330566, 0.3823741674423218, -1.0318795442581177, -0.19528767466545105, -0.6199037432670593, 0.13180717825889587, -0.8285562992095947, 0.008036748506128788, 0.08101604878902435, 0.7576714754104614, -0.24431975185871124, 0.6112415194511414, 0.22204609215259552, -0.5231233835220337, 0.6826984882354736, 0.20553167164325714, -1.1057851314544678, -0.4665136933326721, -1.0915015935897827, 0.6724238395690918, -0.4362142086029053, -0.2534395158290863, 0.5035646557807922, -0.16718725860118866, -0.6914340257644653, 0.32949069142341614, -0.51029372215271, 0.4850786030292511, 0.0877314954996109, 0.1617664396762848, 0.8718789219856262, -0.0434640571475029, 0.6117830276489258, -0.4315389394760132, -0.6704263091087341, -0.49287840723991394, 0.3479038178920746, 0.07015310972929001, 0.5078988671302795, 0.9451090097427368, 0.6432571411132812, -0.7518081068992615, 0.7286022901535034, -1.1812102794647217, -0.8253434300422668, 0.5696316361427307, 0.10199800133705139, 0.0905945748090744, -0.11743250489234924, 0.24669286608695984, -0.37164756655693054, -0.8871015906333923, -0.8935422301292419, 0.8678677678108215, 0.9007524847984314, -0.28275081515312195, 0.628666877746582, 0.43718650937080383, 0.23672166466712952, 0.3843952715396881, 1.6196047067642212, -0.2896445393562317, 0.24696198105812073, 0.15875564515590668, -0.13073937594890594, 0.6301819682121277, -0.2907431125640869, -0.015922365710139275, -0.2385168969631195, 0.32008808851242065, -0.5210151672363281, -0.06934249401092529, -0.9700767993927002, -0.8620807528495789, 0.20056693255901337, 0.5982023477554321, 0.17004068195819855, 0.21145528554916382, -0.34375548362731934, -0.023572832345962524, -0.18493865430355072, 0.16015414893627167, 0.13100789487361908, -1.1517150402069092, 0.24959000945091248, -0.18806438148021698, -0.1253824084997177, -0.5934399366378784, 0.03483085334300995, -0.0035895376931875944, 0.30122053623199463, 0.3417792320251465, 0.6831828355789185, 0.13251489400863647, -0.1813586950302124, -0.9630037546157837, 0.5540622472763062, 0.16691966354846954, 0.29631099104881287, 0.060538746416568756, -1.0510882139205933, 0.518412172794342, -0.07865400612354279, -0.4632662832736969, -0.4819727838039398, -0.7132979035377502, 0.115044504404068, -0.6020431518554688, -0.6590754985809326, -0.17851412296295166, 0.6639206409454346, 0.901896595954895, 0.043644096702337265, 0.19754567742347717, -0.10147038847208023, -0.6190227270126343, 0.028727632015943527, 0.33236292004585266, 0.3536728620529175, 0.7182921171188354, -0.6752583384513855, 0.5430583357810974, 0.1609351634979248, 0.5711823105812073, 0.24395523965358734, -0.03646313026547432, 0.10554974526166916, -0.004445166327059269, 0.7913141846656799, -0.07316961139440536, -0.1378421038389206, 0.6823344230651855, 0.2698899507522583, -0.14525368809700012, -0.46819987893104553, 0.1267269104719162, 0.4892430007457733, 0.49425721168518066, 0.2627981901168823, -0.8807779550552368, 0.33258727192878723, -0.6266536116600037, 0.32586669921875, 0.6557420492172241, 0.13292312622070312, -0.9486806392669678, -0.32827964425086975, -0.3878392279148102, -0.2525091767311096, 0.2604581415653229, 0.5438163876533508, -0.5076809525489807, 0.3605998456478119, -0.4231645464897156, -0.2613481283187866, 0.5677534937858582, -0.6956915855407715, -0.09241636097431183, 0.6640746593475342, 0.015823671594262123, -0.40399104356765747, 0.28579479455947876, -0.3371141850948334, -1.0952885150909424, 0.34224507212638855, -0.4345974922180176, 0.933628499507904, -0.6604434251785278, -0.6060155034065247, 0.08334127813577652, 0.11405560374259949, -0.045858077704906464, 0.7824552655220032, -0.6528784036636353, 0.21616560220718384, 0.13011950254440308, -0.2625759541988373, -0.6710774898529053, -0.09336381405591965, 0.5530176162719727, -0.051536355167627335, 0.5331129431724548, 0.6584691405296326, 0.6050862073898315, 0.7209455370903015, 0.4183458387851715, 0.22512394189834595, -0.1553167998790741, 0.5179985761642456, 0.037852250039577484, -0.31357818841934204, 0.24822044372558594, 0.1854783445596695, -0.41303685307502747, -0.10324624180793762, 0.20421893894672394, -0.4608202576637268, 0.07334170490503311, -0.3909270167350769, -0.5576124787330627, -0.4229329526424408, -0.21120187640190125, -0.20952099561691284, 1.2114193439483643, 0.060083407908678055, -0.14545318484306335, 0.017706118524074554, -0.09963452070951462, -0.4030248820781708, -0.36729592084884644, -0.07379297912120819, -0.5742887258529663, -0.3997308909893036, 0.8382622599601746, -0.408925324678421, 0.6864585280418396, -0.6198475956916809, 0.4408194124698639, 0.3322051763534546, -0.8284117579460144, -0.6813468933105469, -0.6641321182250977, -0.09458669275045395, -0.07456060498952866, 0.08976853638887405, -0.30799371004104614, 0.1563897579908371, -0.23232293128967285, -0.07582022994756699, -0.09153436869382858, 0.09502582252025604, -0.2283220738172531, 0.7248965501785278, -0.07113832235336304, 0.3131141662597656, -0.7563639879226685, 0.2576349377632141, 0.7773658037185669, -0.5649581551551819, 0.4913802146911621, -0.22035731375217438, -0.613136351108551, 0.42904481291770935, -1.5652663707733154, -0.35730379819869995, -0.771679699420929, -0.12771101295948029, 0.42861586809158325, -0.3051009178161621, 0.43213173747062683, -0.21103239059448242, 0.5437037348747253, -0.5929590463638306, -0.5737771391868591, -0.23710918426513672, 0.5185341835021973, -0.45890113711357117, -0.3629872798919678, -0.34531888365745544, -0.024970611557364464, -0.8736398816108704, 0.8966410160064697, -0.7358156442642212, -0.21343031525611877, 0.2311374843120575, 0.009250583127140999, -0.49141010642051697, 0.21678538620471954, -0.5042046308517456, -0.26321908831596375, 0.29743725061416626, 0.7354512214660645, 0.6984556913375854, 0.3581334054470062, -0.5388752818107605, 0.47610384225845337, -0.267809122800827, 0.3496353030204773, -0.17839334905147552, -0.27077096700668335, 0.1929434835910797, 0.6753155589103699, 0.897136390209198, -0.19331921637058258, -0.06553494930267334, 1.0544588565826416, -0.058290187269449234, 0.5526760220527649, 0.46054384112358093, -0.10252435505390167, 0.6171534657478333, -0.4389881491661072, -0.6095100045204163, 0.5744447112083435, -0.037905942648649216, -0.22416232526302338, -0.18577998876571655, -0.1959937959909439, -0.29886117577552795, -0.37163230776786804, 0.0948905348777771, -0.02063930407166481, 0.20349550247192383, -0.23410971462726593, 0.11144275963306427, -0.26680490374565125, -0.24931295216083527, -0.011800333857536316, 0.7517445087432861, 0.5507149696350098, -0.3312223553657532, -0.23049955070018768, -0.21395114064216614, -0.6087167859077454, -0.28513339161872864, 0.6202050447463989, 0.5223342776298523, 0.18190549314022064, 0.9250731468200684, -0.36056867241859436, -0.14864516258239746, 0.47240570187568665, -0.34872952103614807, 0.4248689115047455, 0.4482663571834564, 0.6250551342964172, 0.3704223930835724, -0.0019884328357875347, 0.4394308626651764, 0.6530473232269287, -0.5568670034408569, -0.4611104726791382, 0.9572504758834839, -0.3144599497318268, -0.2819976210594177, 0.08292297273874283, 0.27946344017982483, -0.0425773561000824, -0.17676910758018494, -1.3145445585250854, 0.11607781797647476, 1.0178171396255493, -0.4149619936943054, -0.36188408732414246, -0.2585521638393402, -0.6059357523918152, 0.7961387634277344, 0.6778030395507812, 0.35755956172943115, 0.48737338185310364, 0.4045620262622833, -0.5011444687843323, -0.6505807042121887, 0.3229185938835144, 1.135166049003601, 0.12196964025497437, -0.11573155969381332, 0.1871170699596405, -0.08489417284727097, -0.425996869802475, 0.020322728902101517, 0.6126232743263245, -0.3354346752166748, 0.06248684599995613, -0.37370753288269043, 0.38703227043151855, 0.2678890526294708, 0.0062901028431952, 0.03924286365509033, 0.21619799733161926, -0.711427628993988, -0.7982901334762573, -0.2396913468837738, -0.38422146439552307, 0.5293729305267334, 0.6276870965957642, -0.2144472450017929, 0.012603729963302612, -0.3970072865486145, -0.8022322654724121, 0.07902581989765167, -0.3543590009212494, -0.08030982315540314, -0.47459691762924194, -0.2407766431570053, -0.7184749245643616, 0.024350734427571297, 0.21669496595859528, 0.5535575747489929, 0.2801388204097748, 0.5659059882164001, 0.06272449344396591, 0.050866708159446716, 0.43300583958625793, 0.3266431987285614, 0.27869805693626404, -0.10777286440134048, -0.6114029288291931, 0.12085484713315964, -0.3491062819957733, -1.266847014427185, -0.18412907421588898, 0.30629509687423706, -0.23871372640132904, 1.0655587911605835, 0.17157377302646637, 0.7731571793556213, -0.2595048248767853, -0.6645655632019043, -0.12972977757453918, -0.7771320343017578, -0.9128731489181519, 0.47637253999710083, -1.0567729473114014, 0.5823700428009033, 0.8028386831283569, 0.0013964760582894087, -0.6128475666046143, 0.3610919117927551, -1.2959699630737305, 0.4629100561141968, 0.29530808329582214, 0.5766239762306213, -0.2845931351184845, -0.6411104202270508, 0.03829295560717583, 0.29676955938339233, -0.8410048484802246, -0.498274028301239, -0.27155566215515137, 0.3651059567928314, 0.0801616683602333, -0.21789653599262238, 0.35241958498954773, 1.1172575950622559, 0.1443757712841034, 0.6476107239723206, -0.46250438690185547, 0.6982966661453247, 0.06615325808525085, 0.5213271975517273, -0.5653769969940186, -0.5711552500724792, 0.07034701853990555, -0.5868948101997375, 0.3095335066318512, 0.6736155152320862, 0.00810130313038826, -0.09490758180618286, 0.10718254745006561, -0.4636317193508148, -0.1710018664598465, 0.17543788254261017, -0.7653445601463318, 0.7870609164237976, -0.03738393634557724, 0.5932552218437195, -0.010559296235442162, -0.4692676067352295, -0.48840388655662537, 0.6164578199386597, -0.54644376039505, -0.15465973317623138, 0.14915359020233154, -0.390899658203125, -0.0026465014088898897, -0.0638967975974083, 0.12215326726436615, 0.03255436569452286, -0.12075275182723999, 0.680000901222229, 0.549238383769989, -0.4126514494419098, -0.30093878507614136, 0.08715271949768066, -0.6025590896606445, -0.20565344393253326, -0.12544533610343933, -0.20928184688091278, -0.49487438797950745, -1.3241157531738281, 0.4001140594482422, 0.0425373837351799, -0.8252440690994263, -0.17983737587928772, -0.7174602150917053, -0.23973692953586578, -0.31871822476387024, -0.13790231943130493, -0.26784610748291016, 0.05588459596037865, 0.0506291501224041, 0.5519938468933105, 0.18310484290122986, -0.7319966554641724, 0.15713317692279816, -0.015124846249818802, 0.5832318663597107, -0.5354079008102417, -0.4762749969959259, 0.48710867762565613, 0.11807933449745178, -0.2842731475830078, 0.7469832897186279, 0.09159045666456223, 0.05951015651226044, 0.3643917739391327, -0.34156879782676697, 0.1469210684299469, 0.04183223471045494, 0.2561052739620209, 0.3207402229309082, 0.2140674591064453, 0.20951813459396362, 0.5787917971611023, -0.11808650195598602, 0.6357955932617188, 0.6148869395256042, -0.10427410155534744, 0.041049446910619736, -0.48016199469566345, 0.062625952064991, 0.12829963862895966, -0.2698570191860199, 0.2487812638282776, -0.1549718976020813, -0.05391841009259224, 0.12425311654806137, -0.5414806008338928, -0.6457018852233887, 0.1086849570274353, -0.5584006905555725, -0.9904953837394714, -1.0041227340698242, 0.2848277688026428, 0.5254364609718323, -0.03470306843519211, -0.2766321301460266, 0.98911052942276, 0.06637222319841385, 0.028118934482336044, -0.451725035905838, 0.4176746606826782, 0.6165100336074829, 0.1663067787885666, 0.8811631202697754, 0.29454120993614197, 0.10931050032377243, 0.12150109559297562, 0.13107706606388092, -0.8349412083625793, 0.4350045621395111, 0.47396066784858704, -1.0581233501434326, 0.26078706979751587, 0.2860269248485565, -0.4176488518714905, -0.13800953328609467, -0.6920762062072754, 0.43163707852363586, -0.5977659821510315, 0.12289455533027649, 0.4190702736377716, -0.008881214074790478, 0.008394264616072178, 0.3894880414009094, 0.27857547998428345, 0.13147304952144623, 0.41790539026260376, 0.286287784576416, -0.4349250793457031, 0.4132903218269348, 1.0749949216842651, 0.36640462279319763, 0.2881607711315155, -0.39781659841537476, 0.10816925019025803, 0.32353538274765015, 0.3277420103549957, -0.8668713569641113, 0.6444806456565857, -0.2296828329563141, 0.29329362511634827, 0.06357810646295547, 0.09389182180166245, -0.016226474195718765, 0.5659394860267639, 0.5992880463600159, 0.5973995923995972, -0.005576093215495348, 0.003635839093476534, 0.40964147448539734, 0.8453028202056885, -0.32361823320388794, -0.030877884477376938, 0.43577447533607483, 0.0815173089504242, -0.022590991109609604, -0.27186769247055054, 0.6864937543869019, 0.4203188419342041, -0.4544537365436554, -0.5444855093955994, -0.30611452460289, -0.4806980490684509, -0.9503098726272583, -0.17066578567028046, -0.7253215312957764, 0.46449363231658936, 0.9707390069961548, 0.72283536195755, 0.316746324300766, -0.8539322018623352, -0.10990393906831741, 0.2383178174495697, 1.1034398078918457, 0.008072889409959316, 0.273920476436615, 1.149328351020813, 0.11486394703388214, -0.10205456614494324, 0.5628175735473633, -0.06201956793665886, -0.5690451264381409, 0.010884067043662071, -0.18223018944263458, -0.21880412101745605, -0.023670556023716927, -0.4057908356189728, 0.2279442846775055, 0.4042646288871765, 0.6064808368682861, -0.21853823959827423, -0.11601641774177551, 0.5039529800415039, -0.6630610823631287, 0.011165035888552666, -0.45909583568573, 0.5486272573471069, 0.39548924565315247, -0.5626838803291321, 0.8462002277374268, -0.3390670418739319, 4.2153401374816895, 0.3239532709121704, 0.8761076331138611, -0.6609385013580322, 0.4974172115325928, 0.7146539688110352, -0.1428881585597992, -0.5973780155181885, 0.4046352207660675, -0.37909260392189026, -0.03342104330658913, -0.2097170203924179, 0.2275262176990509, -0.39717555046081543, 0.1588592678308487, 0.7101991176605225, -0.25744926929473877, 0.33936208486557007, 0.19050626456737518, -0.22363540530204773, -1.5478569269180298, 0.3538689613342285, -0.05398929864168167, -0.18527351319789886, -0.022949183359742165, 0.011894328519701958, 0.30505770444869995, -0.6297004222869873, -0.3635491728782654, -0.04026412591338158, -0.2748520076274872, -0.5554251670837402, -0.14585089683532715, -0.1832001805305481, -1.6336064338684082, 0.6347696781158447, -0.3187412917613983, -0.18069986999034882, 0.17629225552082062, -0.08768008649349213, -0.2127157747745514, -0.7808676958084106, -0.16500306129455566, -0.7190507054328918, -0.49901309609413147, 1.0765539407730103, 0.726234495639801, 0.26648297905921936, 0.1372489333152771, -0.9516592025756836, 0.37015342712402344, 0.18593406677246094, 0.6681549549102783, -0.26820436120033264, -1.36038076877594, -0.39448508620262146, -0.08258962631225586, -0.5586475133895874, -0.1759311556816101, -0.34330201148986816, 0.674730658531189, -0.49069827795028687, -0.16957220435142517, 0.20551440119743347, 0.4681870937347412, 0.28457266092300415, 0.6252407431602478, -0.15146495401859283, -0.6428592801094055, -0.1677938997745514, 0.09221601486206055, -0.23353751003742218, -0.6618167757987976, -0.040205709636211395, 0.29078876972198486, -0.14592963457107544, -0.42447349429130554, -0.16766998171806335, -0.42207804322242737, -0.04566577821969986, -0.29162657260894775, 0.003630660241469741, -0.7523543238639832, 0.5993303656578064, 0.27789101004600525, 0.3664596676826477, 0.22955432534217834, -0.5432877540588379, 0.3579067289829254, 0.2536270022392273, -0.40159955620765686, 0.5402071475982666, -0.08862011134624481, -0.07361507415771484, -0.31343933939933777 ]
Structure in a Loitering Universe
We study the formation of structure for a universe that undergoes a recent loitering phase. We compare the nonlinear mass distribution to that in a standard, matter dominated cosmology. The statistical aspects of the clustered matter are found to be robust to changes in the expansion law, an exception being that the peculiar velocities are lower by a factor of $\sim 3$ in the loitering model. Further, in the loitering scenario, nonlinear growth of perturbation occurs more recently ($z\sim 3-5$) than in the matter dominated case. Differences in the high redshift appearances of the two models will result but observable consequences depend critically on the chosen form, onset and duration of the loitering phase.
Hume A. Feldman and August E. Evrard
astro-ph hep-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212002
astro-ph/9212003
[ 0.5437765717506409, 0.399251252412796, 0.3628564178943634, 0.19638776779174805, -0.22991813719272614, 0.30148637294769287, -0.3511267900466919, 0.045874614268541336, -0.3551301956176758, 1.2535383701324463, 0.47038033604621887, -0.4037213623523712, -0.4759725332260132, -0.8760852813720703, -0.4718628525733948, -0.5284779667854309, 0.028726384043693542, -0.6874127984046936, -1.2562013864517212, -0.4743087887763977, -0.11017803847789764, 0.18649716675281525, -1.2316973209381104, -0.2877163887023926, -0.5414615273475647, 0.41927123069763184, 0.011102511547505856, -0.16845466196537018, 1.1028538942337036, 0.851732075214386, 0.3195119798183441, -0.6686050891876221, -0.05186471715569496, -1.3096765279769897, -0.0744137167930603, -0.26129499077796936, 0.5420565605163574, 0.0523369200527668, 0.588658332824707, -0.15909291803836823, 0.915565013885498, -0.007746069226413965, 0.3494287431240082, -0.14793796837329865, -0.5231924653053284, -0.39946624636650085, -0.4786074757575989, -0.3588561713695526, 0.04364887624979019, -0.645548403263092, -0.03794798627495766, 0.4710816442966461, 0.03291032090783119, -0.3139576017856598, -0.31351348757743835, -0.06383242458105087, 0.09211086481809616, -0.5693608522415161, -0.4720439314842224, -0.2758055329322815, 0.8151161074638367, 0.4353909492492676, 0.28328895568847656, -0.6299258470535278, -0.21783322095870972, 1.1066052913665771, -0.02904757857322693, 0.008485587313771248, -0.21842455863952637, -0.5257383584976196, 0.22497108578681946, 0.00005515397060662508, -0.3748483657836914, 0.005037885159254074, -0.15949130058288574, 0.08813324570655823, -0.380331426858902, 0.05142258107662201, -1.1780086755752563, -0.2490236461162567, 0.19874274730682373, 0.26091644167900085, 0.24892444908618927, 0.5580297708511353, 0.5599274635314941, -0.5533360242843628, 0.5323857069015503, -0.14030767977237701, 0.4652648866176605, 0.5001755356788635, -0.7603557109832764, 0.8769797682762146, -0.8774293661117554, 0.25966811180114746, 0.9532336592674255, 0.007072845008224249, 0.020277580246329308, 0.4303287863731384, 1.0586256980895996, 0.6790456771850586, 0.005998749751597643, 0.920812726020813, -0.7101495862007141, 0.3813112676143646, -0.4938182234764099, 0.7054159045219421, -0.6129461526870728, 0.21282769739627838, -0.3981872498989105, -1.0070611238479614, 0.17029421031475067, 0.20320025086402893, 0.0015075320843607187, 0.12342949211597443, -0.13611280918121338, 0.6627659201622009, -0.7250658273696899, 0.1688358038663864, 0.1466795653104782, -0.7421084642410278, -0.7997108697891235, 0.3845978081226349, -0.1889440268278122, 0.03859253600239754, -0.15672481060028076, 0.2527908980846405, -0.10703075677156448, 0.025449395179748535, -1.0672595500946045, -0.06329638510942459, -0.3693368136882782, -0.3860880434513092, -0.24714644253253937, 0.7192510962486267, 0.1903521716594696, -0.18042437732219696, 0.4078183174133301, 0.3615034520626068, -0.27103444933891296, -0.6652938723564148, 0.16345320641994476, -0.5324860215187073, 0.45046430826187134, 1.2168946266174316, -1.5162686109542847, -0.09444577246904373, -0.2423917055130005, 0.07119923084974289, -0.0904320627450943, 0.11484868079423904, -0.10542187839746475, -0.1328069567680359, 0.03769005089998245, 0.784349262714386, -0.2233268767595291, -0.002116418443620205, -1.058044672012329, 0.2414044439792633, -0.4624202251434326, -0.28418266773223877, -0.14452718198299408, 0.02569711208343506, -0.6283586025238037, 0.5875653624534607, -0.7972002029418945, 0.22996832430362701, -0.221025750041008, -0.7604983448982239, 0.23234039545059204, -0.47010502219200134, -0.38993653655052185, 0.3355982303619385, -0.6428543925285339, 0.4678782820701599, 0.22034187614917755, 0.6814931035041809, 0.5330836772918701, 0.09391006082296371, 0.2783835530281067, 0.38331446051597595, -0.11914709210395813, -0.2063927948474884, 0.4334164559841156, 0.462115615606308, -0.7156959176063538, 0.5533403158187866, -0.14344604313373566, -0.1342269331216812, 0.47338786721229553, 0.028932955116033554, -0.2814584970474243, 0.20991696417331696, -1.1943604946136475, 0.22007489204406738, -0.7949077486991882, -0.21871818602085114, -0.4902479648590088, 0.192996546626091, -0.0855492427945137, -0.6142476797103882, -0.021479343995451927, 0.2346135824918747, -0.7519455552101135, 0.8989905118942261, -0.7972521185874939, -0.36127743124961853, 0.9300378561019897, 0.825029730796814, -0.9132858514785767, 0.18873268365859985, 0.4581942558288574, -0.021079154685139656, -0.012686226516962051, -0.4640013575553894, 0.5198937058448792, -0.00968520063906908, -0.11684948951005936, 0.2514132559299469, 0.03922133147716522, -0.06436288356781006, 0.17414824664592743, 0.28396376967430115, 0.2274269014596939, 0.6137431859970093, -0.1404261440038681, -0.0906510278582573, 0.5872042179107666, 0.7774225473403931, 0.14545628428459167, 0.6275987029075623, -0.08148263394832611, 0.045417848974466324, 0.058764804154634476, 0.25292274355888367, 0.5861900448799133, -0.04815809056162834, 0.5186673402786255, 0.6031956672668457, 0.16318106651306152, -0.019969068467617035, -0.23538698256015778, -0.17811428010463715, 0.20331694185733795, 0.4851020276546478, -0.3864807188510895, 0.03350565955042839, 0.22852137684822083, -0.08538339287042618, -0.3346806466579437, 1.0252875089645386, -0.46153777837753296, 0.40342965722084045, 0.1255570352077484, 0.6956073045730591, -0.9031760692596436, -0.5200036764144897, 0.08468273282051086, 0.7620964050292969, 0.050714462995529175, -0.7807881236076355, -0.013979291543364525, -0.01781282387673855, -0.6062968373298645, -0.2864183187484741, -0.04290088638663292, -0.043584007769823074, -0.48649197816848755, 0.4340823292732239, 0.3489627540111542, -0.21534639596939087, -1.0522898435592651, -0.27521035075187683, -0.16503889858722687, -0.6328169703483582, -0.49399876594543457, 0.0800541564822197, -0.3201170265674591, -0.9010978937149048, 0.5259366631507874, 0.053227826952934265, -0.09971150010824203, 0.8396322131156921, -0.4018334448337555, 0.28899189829826355, 0.03995756432414055, 0.544291079044342, -0.7474461793899536, 0.25785505771636963, -0.25711458921432495, 0.5347058773040771, -0.38686269521713257, -0.3527579605579376, -0.30359724164009094, -0.38525187969207764, 0.3206787407398224, 0.7395614385604858, -0.42245879769325256, 0.11387036740779877, 0.5048417448997498, -0.4644024670124054, 0.29665932059288025, 0.4022226631641388, -0.3695319592952728, -0.2571094036102295, -0.6759097576141357, 0.32248592376708984, -0.5013424158096313, 0.0536152683198452, 0.5017163753509521, 0.28328004479408264, -0.3196418583393097, 0.5297321677207947, -0.07280674576759338, 0.4369708001613617, -0.1668347716331482, 0.3826088607311249, 0.2883683145046234, 0.1888977736234665, 0.33979204297065735, -0.2990247905254364, -0.6927998661994934, -0.7129469513893127, 0.143785759806633, -0.46636536717414856, -0.17648358643054962, 0.7563350796699524, 0.25254663825035095, -0.3874343931674957, 0.40668410062789917, -0.5654675364494324, -0.8159993290901184, 0.4673617482185364, -0.3747308850288391, 1.0192219018936157, 0.17847411334514618, -0.00895015336573124, -0.5915589928627014, 0.4096008539199829, -0.46295303106307983, 0.1713588535785675, 0.4855465292930603, 0.21891345083713531, 0.3239363431930542, 0.9102939963340759, -0.7843601107597351, 0.041771359741687775, 0.7179920673370361, -0.3029409646987915, -0.6124931573867798, 0.20617301762104034, -0.5966758728027344, 0.043785929679870605, -0.07643849402666092, -0.11673177033662796, -0.29728472232818604, 0.5946033000946045, -0.3696097433567047, -0.18026453256607056, -0.2053322046995163, -0.07342980802059174, -0.048344552516937256, -0.19254542887210846, 0.5039435625076294, -0.11474291980266571, -0.4398932456970215, -0.2719156742095947, 0.21259507536888123, -0.41282883286476135, 0.4448533356189728, -1.122014045715332, 0.44151344895362854, 0.05769277364015579, -0.39933568239212036, -0.313242107629776, -0.6152799725532532, 0.016830632463097572, 0.7840378880500793, 0.3544396460056305, 0.9114832282066345, -0.6934600472450256, 0.08139600604772568, -0.06765951961278915, 0.8666867613792419, 0.1661483347415924, 0.22811685502529144, 0.17112118005752563, -0.11304967850446701, 0.5829998254776001, -0.2212507724761963, -0.1939297914505005, 0.0586492195725441, -0.8666978478431702, 0.2061575949192047, -0.5268688797950745, -0.4045858085155487, 0.027306532487273216, 0.3280129134654999, 0.6286964416503906, -0.4002181589603424, 0.2180182784795761, 0.17691659927368164, -0.45207318663597107, 0.41676226258277893, 0.12581117451190948, 0.09219356626272202, 0.02977134846150875, -0.5127379298210144, 0.0649932250380516, -0.6305977702140808, 0.11401444673538208, 0.3438238501548767, -0.3789706230163574, -0.42639267444610596, 0.11416655033826828, 0.48978161811828613, 0.581853449344635, -0.4348030984401703, 0.9276251196861267, -0.1008480116724968, 0.6698963642120361, -0.7704393863677979, 1.0395466089248657, 0.0971079170703888, 0.47057783603668213, -0.187689408659935, -0.9869972467422485, 0.8979756236076355, -0.8349387645721436, 0.6253070831298828, 0.7436150908470154, -1.083541989326477, -0.853628933429718, -0.3353077471256256, -0.1491633802652359, 0.6593781113624573, 0.6141924858093262, 0.32119715213775635, -0.5052545666694641, 0.11595375090837479, -0.021499674767255783, 0.1238430067896843, 0.4831760823726654, -0.26766833662986755, -0.37392058968544006, -0.39382562041282654, 0.2606094181537628, -0.25956133008003235, 0.009029942564666271, 0.05733745917677879, -0.43622279167175293, -0.0988762155175209, -0.4753682017326355, 0.05692937597632408, -0.862928032875061, -1.030258297920227, 0.8508610725402832, 0.43626582622528076, -0.3131885230541229, -0.19855889678001404, -0.44542643427848816, -0.10690422356128693, 0.10948920994997025, 0.06862442940473557, -0.10146810859441757, -0.5607133507728577, 0.13424356281757355, -0.30925148725509644, 1.1312865018844604, 0.586251974105835, 0.2698739469051361, 0.7959076166152954, -0.028206847608089447, -0.5274104475975037, -0.2778284549713135, 0.06647423654794693, 0.10963991284370422, 0.06072114780545235, -0.11346635967493057, -0.21871225535869598, -0.5810994505882263, -0.34737324714660645, 0.4674361050128937, -0.3742290735244751, -0.06350246071815491, 0.028405476361513138, -0.52434903383255, -0.5278827548027039, -0.4096173942089081, -0.6297763586044312, 0.9879204034805298, -0.19995656609535217, -0.010833358392119408, 0.11659368872642517, -0.4055350124835968, -0.178288072347641, -0.325198233127594, -0.37413686513900757, -0.79181307554245, 0.153647318482399, 0.5317023396492004, 0.5118608474731445, 0.019329307600855827, -1.0369350910186768, 1.062658667564392, -0.4341925382614136, -0.5210859179496765, -0.46151676774024963, -0.3803347647190094, -0.5557353496551514, -0.02198992483317852, -0.21443530917167664, -0.4733400344848633, -0.39604273438453674, -0.3742734491825104, 0.021690161898732185, 0.16232039034366608, -0.331380158662796, -0.9183583855628967, -0.5841043591499329, 0.4084774851799011, 0.692036509513855, -0.932047426700592, -0.22793516516685486, 0.3144112825393677, -0.2139369398355484, 0.857343316078186, 0.48666316270828247, -0.6861616373062134, 0.11812518537044525, -0.44598111510276794, 0.06958438456058502, -0.5377985835075378, 0.3746066689491272, -0.07964091747999191, -0.628678560256958, -0.19915829598903656, 0.3141309320926666, 0.27459394931793213, 0.06035247817635536, -0.320240318775177, -0.4025537967681885, 0.507815420627594, -0.39832091331481934, 0.19066950678825378, -0.8895972371101379, -0.2568148374557495, -1.044325351715088, 1.1230344772338867, -0.5840244889259338, -0.6854102611541748, 0.4300353229045868, -0.2595245838165283, 0.10958170890808105, 0.49164047837257385, 0.1451403647661209, -0.06820626556873322, -0.17069092392921448, 1.1056019067764282, -0.03446255251765251, -0.06330470740795135, -0.7234718799591064, 0.6167616844177246, 0.0033389520831406116, 0.4404875338077545, -0.1520310938358307, -0.2190919667482376, 0.44383785128593445, 0.06671438366174698, 0.9853747487068176, -0.3691377639770508, 0.12867021560668945, 0.781263530254364, 0.16541995108127594, 0.13289174437522888, 0.3542369306087494, -0.15269093215465546, -0.6174497008323669, -0.29528576135635376, -0.8048517107963562, 0.2763668894767761, 0.13897351920604706, -0.3067305386066437, 0.21409375965595245, 0.14763735234737396, -0.06261682510375977, -0.9675402045249939, 0.9365001320838928, 0.15215450525283813, 0.2426258623600006, -0.6066398620605469, -0.3415141999721527, 0.09436776489019394, -0.3729643225669861, 0.05829742178320885, 0.2847849726676941, -0.6334457397460938, -0.2146121710538864, -0.008206610567867756, 0.2654092311859131, -0.819874107837677, -0.3395976722240448, -0.04826913774013519, 0.8538321256637573, -0.33849695324897766, 0.7832610607147217, -0.38159602880477905, -0.038515444844961166, -0.36682993173599243, 0.008375871926546097, 0.34737369418144226, 0.03272811323404312, 0.7894892692565918, 0.7940139174461365, 0.22977516055107117, 0.34476202726364136, -0.2500736117362976, -1.0928785800933838, 0.446609228849411, 0.23249417543411255, -0.9621336460113525, -0.2905912697315216, -0.025125473737716675, 0.2956081032752991, -0.9455942511558533, -0.8075321912765503, -1.3553498983383179, -0.2795374095439911, 0.3352464437484741, 0.2764333486557007, -0.3765031397342682, 0.19950559735298157, -0.15539157390594482, 0.0628332868218422, -0.06491498649120331, 1.239580750465393, -0.11481696367263794, -0.22870922088623047, 0.4319673180580139, -1.1104025840759277, 0.09008442610502243, 1.4080085754394531, 0.31747475266456604, -0.5455990433692932, -0.26368066668510437, -0.2694539427757263, 0.031235698610544205, 0.046652235090732574, 0.7879772186279297, -0.7572291493415833, 0.4490738809108734, 0.10840138047933578, 0.10101058334112167, 0.6121106743812561, 0.12546485662460327, 0.34773364663124084, 0.12846896052360535, -0.1891421526670456, -0.9536880850791931, -0.6731129288673401, -0.42201530933380127, 0.6181037425994873, 0.46303051710128784, -0.20799311995506287, -0.2644433081150055, -0.4783710539340973, -0.4094880521297455, -0.040231429040431976, 0.026156751438975334, -0.3313812017440796, -0.5919080376625061, -0.6254278421401978, -0.6043312549591064, 0.17809227108955383, 0.17920994758605957, 0.7076020240783691, -0.6427482962608337, 0.015364349819719791, -0.2565234899520874, -0.11806587129831314, 0.5485925078392029, 0.5692643523216248, -0.17158572375774384, -0.6390700340270996, -0.911858081817627, 0.20020687580108643, -0.06729599833488464, -1.0882624387741089, -0.21210360527038574, -0.4918847680091858, 0.5235205888748169, 0.7145790457725525, -0.5415793061256409, 0.5852897763252258, -0.116798996925354, 0.2645246386528015, 0.35221561789512634, 0.3071317672729492, -0.6329466104507446, 1.0977839231491089, -0.72613525390625, 1.0146135091781616, 0.33137309551239014, 0.33855029940605164, 0.15644262731075287, 0.7835911512374878, -1.2504597902297974, 0.08448072522878647, -0.06113775447010994, 1.0579322576522827, 0.5807456970214844, -0.19629408419132233, -0.3739411234855652, 1.0729769468307495, -0.8873164653778076, -0.14567190408706665, -0.49944809079170227, 0.4313364624977112, 0.15311111509799957, 0.06027038022875786, -0.25559306144714355, 0.7916693687438965, 0.043478384613990784, 0.31245455145835876, -0.6701375246047974, 0.16003428399562836, -0.24778196215629578, 0.4667782187461853, 0.4038946330547333, -0.5757763385772705, 0.3167640268802643, -0.9521510004997253, 0.6913771033287048, 0.3767242431640625, -0.07905293256044388, 0.019613448530435562, 0.22271259129047394, 0.6297233700752258, -0.1650797426700592, 0.153669536113739, -0.042143043130636215, 0.3020990192890167, 0.09939230978488922, 0.5653467774391174, 0.44333603978157043, -0.17530225217342377, -0.3682651221752167, 0.7846177816390991, -0.4620622396469116, -0.38544076681137085, 1.0742274522781372, -0.17697115242481232, -0.5655106902122498, -0.37349265813827515, -0.2745193839073181, 0.31731274724006653, -0.010940260253846645, 0.26180434226989746, 1.2784843444824219, 0.8196331858634949, -0.8141461610794067, 1.1458936929702759, -0.16776502132415771, -0.5056642889976501, -0.4958849847316742, 0.45776334404945374, -1.1054850816726685, -0.9163413047790527, -0.5860776901245117, 0.6169257760047913, -0.29402005672454834, 0.1599828600883484, -0.31285789608955383, 0.007281159982085228, -0.41117173433303833, -0.026156779378652573, -1.0742145776748657, -0.14570586383342743, 0.07117108255624771, 0.5085928440093994, 0.1252746433019638, -0.3873554766178131, 0.2788953483104706, 0.29157906770706177, 0.4684637784957886, 0.04601109027862549, -0.343966007232666, 1.1966687440872192, 0.20356935262680054, 0.03787405416369438, 0.9510945677757263, 0.13762472569942474, 0.2888314425945282, 0.6240042448043823, -0.3258575201034546, 0.19799423217773438, 0.8005109429359436, -0.01978265307843685, 0.5669687986373901, -0.2830810546875, 0.10814971476793289, 0.14404909312725067, 0.05852752551436424, 0.10082133859395981, 0.27707356214523315, 0.06920242309570312, -0.3492268919944763, 0.316293329000473, -0.19322648644447327, 0.7238553762435913, 0.007495279889553785, 0.3232656419277191, 0.13797342777252197, 0.18299026787281036, 0.24907316267490387, -0.38529157638549805, -0.25894004106521606, 0.28945478796958923, -0.4595135450363159, -0.7636374235153198, -1.146257996559143, 0.6920301914215088, 0.31133008003234863, -0.30267295241355896, -0.2933914065361023, 0.16651158034801483, 0.532375693321228, 0.46221277117729187, -0.3049306869506836, 0.45391491055488586, 0.5157762169837952, 0.474857360124588, -0.11010859906673431, 0.770467221736908, 0.3572436571121216, 0.548831582069397, 0.16012783348560333, -0.8951008915901184, 0.1801980882883072, 0.7976176142692566, -0.4768545925617218, 0.5415069460868835, 0.2897818982601166, 0.06653165072202682, -0.11463743448257446, -1.1092618703842163, -0.0009076294954866171, -1.158376693725586, -0.1960052102804184, 0.7172116637229919, -0.8003766536712646, -0.08057942986488342, 0.10803285241127014, 0.20014862716197968, 0.6847146153450012, 0.6150368452072144, 0.5998432040214539, -0.3969219923019409, 1.284170389175415, 0.7019296884536743, 0.19213584065437317, -0.21714426577091217, -0.3072585165500641, -0.39042049646377563, 0.00842240173369646, 0.06648730486631393, -0.4692869782447815, 0.3094037175178528, -0.2966029644012451, -0.3487415611743927, -0.4620674252510071, -0.2079273760318756, 0.05905052646994591, -0.0632728710770607, 1.0901315212249756, -0.04121912270784378, -0.439215749502182, 0.18506929278373718, 0.5311981439590454, 0.18916931748390198, -0.5343457460403442, -0.4106898605823517, 0.3642354905605316, -0.31097349524497986, -0.46480828523635864, -0.04494255408644676, 0.9619908928871155, 0.2251347005367279, -0.16332851350307465, -0.17990829050540924, -0.42031070590019226, -0.42443859577178955, -0.2435888797044754, -0.9027855396270752, -0.6785594820976257, 0.41196703910827637, 0.9273902773857117, 0.12128648161888123, -0.6815934777259827, -0.8118610978126526, -0.1513417363166809, -0.4681280553340912, 0.9079793691635132, 0.10969646275043488, 0.6253566741943359, 0.4500363767147064, 0.2650894820690155, -0.4180881083011627, 0.2886449694633484, 0.5016570687294006, -0.33397921919822693, 0.4852255880832672, -0.13047903776168823, -0.40125593543052673, -0.4424108564853668, -0.4844314754009247, 0.3447354733943939, 0.700742244720459, 0.640643298625946, 0.053761985152959824, -0.2217213213443756, 0.18283724784851074, -0.07793544977903366, -0.16150155663490295, 0.08972368389368057, 0.6681333184242249, 0.1711135357618332, -0.3785586357116699, 0.6904969215393066, -1.1696257591247559, 4.274284362792969, 0.7247816920280457, 0.788662314414978, -0.11931607127189636, 0.6034507155418396, 0.9812166094779968, 0.5894704461097717, -0.12710002064704895, 0.2836950421333313, 0.11538749188184738, 0.1578797549009323, -0.3504257798194885, -0.36195898056030273, 0.4151979088783264, 0.3299347758293152, 0.9155977964401245, 0.19790305197238922, -0.2533869445323944, -0.27650633454322815, -0.29995447397232056, -0.9754919409751892, 0.16214057803153992, -0.08513492345809937, -0.43049919605255127, 0.23384228348731995, 0.426597535610199, 0.1616477519273758, 0.13097722828388214, -0.25377389788627625, -0.21405097842216492, -0.07473736256361008, -0.7636532187461853, 0.13197863101959229, -0.1618526577949524, -0.9042129516601562, 0.15206453204154968, -0.12313496321439743, -0.7635747790336609, 0.7608417272567749, -0.5637952089309692, -0.36701861023902893, -0.507451057434082, 0.03348254784941673, -0.173871710896492, -0.7595478892326355, 0.6053796410560608, 0.712083101272583, 0.7397929430007935, 1.217329978942871, -0.18579955399036407, 0.47772839665412903, 0.015327620320022106, 0.09845592081546783, -0.29835349321365356, -1.2553653717041016, -0.1242368221282959, 0.1860184222459793, -0.35569506883621216, 0.10609874874353409, -0.29098746180534363, 1.1093547344207764, -0.45349401235580444, -0.5104166269302368, 0.29787537455558777, 0.5906823873519897, -0.13264724612236023, 0.2360885888338089, -0.29367634654045105, -0.07451477646827698, -0.06677991151809692, -0.22765178978443146, -0.0793035626411438, -0.6729899644851685, -0.3229009211063385, -0.08692281693220139, 0.04031580686569214, 0.1392798125743866, -0.365589439868927, -0.4864409565925598, -0.12403872609138489, 0.3270498216152191, -0.008373440243303776, -0.46363043785095215, 0.4395335614681244, 0.34790781140327454, 0.6931104063987732, -0.0005935223307460546, -0.002515290630981326, -0.33905553817749023, 0.6551769971847534, 0.39339354634284973, 0.38363876938819885, -0.19446834921836853, -0.2808903455734253, -0.6169103384017944 ]
Gravity's rainbow
Could COBE DMR be detecting the imprint from a spectrum of gravitational waves generated during inflation? The conventional inflationary prediction had been that the cosmic microwave anisotropy is dominated by energy density fluctuations generated during inflation and that the gravitational waves contribute negligibly. In this paper, we report on recent work (in collaboration with R. Davis, H. Hodges, and M. Turner) that has shown that the conventional wisdom may be wrong; specifically, gravitational waves may dominate the anisotropy in inflationary models where the spectrum of perturbations deviates significantly from scale invariance (e.g., extended and power-law inflation models and extreme versions of chaotic inflation). If gravitational waves do dominate at the large-angular scales measured by COBE DMR, the expectation and interpretation of anisotropies on small-angular scales is profoundly altered. Invited Paper for Proceedings of the Journees Relativistes, Amsterdam, May 14-16, 1992
George F. Smoot and Paul J. Steinhardt
astro-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212003
astro-ph/9212004
[ 0.38419508934020996, 1.0184708833694458, 0.04520105943083763, 0.30276939272880554, -0.08011447638273239, 0.029461542144417763, -0.34524017572402954, -0.25534722208976746, -0.045452989637851715, 1.5208823680877686, 0.350990891456604, -0.3064682185649872, -0.1712629199028015, -1.0738589763641357, -0.7293043732643127, 0.4086889922618866, -0.05701663717627525, -1.0344617366790771, -1.2091679573059082, 0.30068063735961914, -0.23204445838928223, 0.07426449656486511, -1.651125431060791, -0.4554630219936371, -0.4477657973766327, 0.5239158272743225, 0.33298489451408386, -0.17574147880077362, 1.1688950061798096, 0.9210779666900635, 0.13555315136909485, 0.17757929861545563, 0.48168739676475525, -0.7927237153053284, -0.6286560297012329, -0.46346917748451233, -0.05214528366923332, 0.21780987083911896, 0.8853358030319214, -0.3554829955101013, 0.706676721572876, -0.07783184200525284, 0.35592663288116455, -0.3949461281299591, -0.7722736597061157, -0.14636150002479553, 0.10928559303283691, -0.21332772076129913, 0.40773123502731323, -0.990488588809967, -0.4599447250366211, 0.22216512262821198, 0.31444311141967773, -0.8925907015800476, 0.11151495575904846, 0.2888983488082886, -0.1538289338350296, -0.14987769722938538, -0.5666543245315552, -0.042148150503635406, 0.7029381394386292, 0.4937455654144287, 0.49080517888069153, -0.5004798769950867, 0.13798095285892487, 1.5903749465942383, -0.4677252769470215, 0.2305963784456253, -0.4485442638397217, 0.029734205454587936, -0.03543061390519142, -0.5454224348068237, -0.2895207107067108, -0.09508329629898071, 0.09619829803705215, 0.23574253916740417, 0.16223327815532684, 0.39149025082588196, -1.133908748626709, -0.3230658769607544, -0.3582198917865753, 0.3448531925678253, -0.2626384198665619, 0.6890456080436707, 0.3739235997200012, -0.6188285946846008, 0.452959269285202, -0.7275055646896362, 0.11901465058326721, 0.32843294739723206, -0.6009624004364014, 0.5880937576293945, -0.424127459526062, -0.08116522431373596, 0.5012926459312439, 0.04848077893257141, -0.16772529482841492, 0.7360384464263916, 0.06913383305072784, 0.630285918712616, -0.23112323880195618, 0.5734472274780273, -0.4709480106830597, 0.2553291320800781, -0.5442731380462646, 1.1827014684677124, -0.6065101623535156, 0.6530865430831909, -0.0910557210445404, -1.0642625093460083, -0.19966447353363037, -0.24268965423107147, 0.5117307305335999, -0.08615930378437042, 0.5000534057617188, 0.9272609949111938, -1.210591197013855, 0.31157180666923523, -0.7812851667404175, -0.7337495684623718, -0.43481865525245667, 0.7570948004722595, -0.12068966031074524, 0.8434988856315613, -0.15333743393421173, -0.0823633000254631, -0.41829004883766174, 0.21525882184505463, -0.7903503179550171, 0.4429137110710144, -0.3894589841365814, -0.6403666734695435, -0.5359347462654114, 1.213538408279419, -0.17851892113685608, 0.033885836601257324, 0.8858787417411804, 0.6918001174926758, -0.318642795085907, -0.5192667245864868, 0.12382935732603073, -0.536108136177063, 0.3611012101173401, 1.4662222862243652, -1.7212034463882446, 0.5599486231803894, -0.6274105310440063, 0.1414232850074768, -0.37723326683044434, 0.25480690598487854, -0.04695544019341469, 0.3038868010044098, 0.41570982336997986, 0.47701019048690796, -0.4911910593509674, -0.25705236196517944, -1.3357089757919312, -0.08035905659198761, 0.20687688887119293, -0.39758509397506714, -0.49275222420692444, -0.15118525922298431, -0.3180273473262787, 0.5605934262275696, -1.0614584684371948, 0.12613026797771454, -0.21866761147975922, -0.44114330410957336, -0.07239550352096558, -0.2078758031129837, -0.4653284251689911, 0.7016674876213074, -0.6025852560997009, 0.17542435228824615, 0.9621176719665527, 0.7351188659667969, 0.318075567483902, 0.1935139149427414, 0.16678667068481445, 0.2808804512023926, -0.07281946390867233, 0.12288473546504974, -0.20163790881633759, 0.6605212688446045, -0.036097705364227295, 0.11081980168819427, -0.10921651124954224, 0.12684722244739532, 0.23371192812919617, -0.00018076333799399436, -0.6378819942474365, 0.37704697251319885, -1.227990746498108, 0.9360314607620239, -0.5405834317207336, -0.2575567662715912, -0.23230737447738647, -0.029594017192721367, -0.2226630598306656, -0.5964887738227844, 0.45587798953056335, 0.13998456299304962, -0.33951249718666077, 1.182633399963379, -0.329886794090271, 0.058505017310380936, 0.5638741850852966, 0.7218984961509705, -1.054269790649414, 0.030421679839491844, 0.47235992550849915, 0.36375290155410767, 0.014930273406207561, -0.653362512588501, 0.4916320741176605, -0.3647306561470032, -0.5022501349449158, 0.2263210266828537, 0.38619932532310486, 0.033699218183755875, 0.6486424207687378, 0.007577241864055395, 0.15788117051124573, 1.2898544073104858, -0.33881449699401855, -0.1696738451719284, 0.8179320693016052, 0.9852808117866516, -0.517808735370636, 0.697867214679718, -0.438890278339386, -0.021113403141498566, 0.5939453840255737, 0.03681766241788864, 0.4934954047203064, -0.8136410117149353, 1.2186369895935059, 1.008582592010498, -0.5480282306671143, 0.13615038990974426, 0.006227804347872734, -0.29331061244010925, 0.3324708342552185, 0.3796415627002716, -0.8347479701042175, 0.21248312294483185, 0.40944918990135193, -0.6805580854415894, -0.09672514349222183, 0.8226550817489624, -0.7972443699836731, 0.8722518086433411, -0.07649943232536316, 0.488023579120636, -1.3367750644683838, 0.07651619613170624, -0.7299755811691284, 0.7259112000465393, -0.03187098726630211, -0.25770509243011475, 0.19606883823871613, 0.0478200763463974, -0.08270790427923203, -0.27596166729927063, 0.1211472898721695, 0.12104546278715134, -0.7477242350578308, 0.0010166573338210583, 0.21036453545093536, -0.5383577942848206, -0.9607337713241577, -0.25231170654296875, -0.1486792415380478, -0.26712289452552795, -0.4167121648788452, -0.2779417634010315, -0.33337002992630005, -0.5973216891288757, 0.11285067349672318, 0.148015558719635, -0.09281221777200699, 0.6345420479774475, -0.4421340525150299, 0.16237583756446838, -0.01988990232348442, 0.5563405752182007, -0.9217835664749146, 0.22342287003993988, -0.330070436000824, 0.4417584240436554, -0.04769790917634964, -0.16555388271808624, -0.43106821179389954, -0.1447407305240631, 0.6751970052719116, 0.12747439742088318, -0.8276291489601135, 0.32039549946784973, 0.49827274680137634, -0.10332414507865906, 0.26068058609962463, 0.14416496455669403, -0.819640040397644, -0.26417267322540283, -0.8602223992347717, 0.8076770901679993, -0.06563317030668259, 0.11402412503957748, 0.5081326961517334, -0.31901830434799194, -0.2366952747106552, 0.7251750230789185, 0.1692531257867813, 0.749870777130127, -0.2998305559158325, 0.06542675942182541, 0.08082130551338196, 0.02402593195438385, -0.10235334932804108, -0.6097143888473511, -1.0669018030166626, -0.24004866182804108, 1.02760648727417, 0.04580328240990639, -0.06276078522205353, 0.6456171870231628, 0.3442668616771698, -0.766765832901001, 0.11457925289869308, -0.654406726360321, -0.2292400449514389, -0.1044587716460228, -0.18257592618465424, 0.3289230763912201, 0.2525850534439087, 0.2441655695438385, -0.7543279528617859, -0.1931854486465454, -0.23522047698497772, 0.18094423413276672, 0.7176762819290161, -0.3215584456920624, 0.19325578212738037, 0.9394184947013855, -0.7093580961227417, -0.26356667280197144, 0.6536746621131897, -0.636717677116394, -0.09968124330043793, 0.15290048718452454, -0.005342164076864719, -0.28649795055389404, 0.4770829677581787, -0.059141840785741806, -0.040002141147851944, 0.7935970425605774, -0.4303349256515503, -0.05666588619351387, -0.3250066339969635, -0.4001002013683319, 0.2208361178636551, 0.15243302285671234, 0.3733386695384979, -0.10599935799837112, -0.4142656624317169, -0.5218096971511841, 0.0505547970533371, -0.45876798033714294, 0.7371175289154053, -1.3934532403945923, 0.3753572404384613, -0.04934904724359512, -1.0641908645629883, 0.20524932444095612, -0.30162909626960754, 0.21364600956439972, 0.8601517081260681, 0.38218680024147034, 0.45708736777305603, -0.24372270703315735, -0.11106999218463898, -0.2841581404209137, 0.5117698907852173, 0.29081061482429504, -0.15097230672836304, 0.3538784384727478, -0.467425674200058, -0.02989373542368412, -0.38147374987602234, -0.4710812568664551, -0.834812343120575, -0.7712607383728027, 0.49027666449546814, -0.5654069185256958, -0.3262609839439392, 0.35191142559051514, 0.8660048246383667, 0.4439294934272766, 0.054641980677843094, 0.182273268699646, -0.3741633892059326, -0.5299793481826782, 0.38393527269363403, 0.03303307294845581, -0.2543448805809021, 0.3296632170677185, -0.9190630912780762, -0.12258399277925491, -0.10237941145896912, 0.15920333564281464, 0.465654581785202, -0.1309208869934082, -0.06756550073623657, 0.22925259172916412, 0.23146142065525055, 0.31047990918159485, 0.0052088540978729725, 0.6580502986907959, 0.5094809532165527, -0.012044611386954784, -0.9211048483848572, 0.6220553517341614, 0.36067306995391846, 0.6938444375991821, -0.05025269463658333, -0.6435869336128235, 0.7070273756980896, -0.49316272139549255, 0.48354586958885193, 0.3395172953605652, -0.23674148321151733, -0.8471505641937256, -0.7188236713409424, -0.21123006939888, 0.14671140909194946, 0.6028619408607483, 0.7716356515884399, -0.4870193302631378, 0.5762399435043335, -0.32820552587509155, 0.05527038499712944, 0.5461030006408691, 0.36812371015548706, -0.17764490842819214, -0.2440035492181778, 0.5389245748519897, -0.7680357098579407, 0.07889757305383682, 0.26327112317085266, -0.5286586284637451, -0.2260381281375885, -0.6867431998252869, 0.42189982533454895, -0.2856671214103699, -0.874646782875061, 0.7847806811332703, 0.09529029577970505, -0.5293249487876892, 0.15716148912906647, -0.4969030022621155, -0.11756128072738647, 0.3020928204059601, 0.06276645511388779, -0.5679585933685303, -0.4335007965564728, -0.34540194272994995, -0.27206891775131226, 0.5099505186080933, 0.7879989147186279, 0.6124340295791626, 1.2841466665267944, -0.027836276218295097, 0.06207815930247307, 0.12301772832870483, 0.36644142866134644, -0.6141582131385803, 0.05917735397815704, 0.23775024712085724, -0.6055654287338257, -0.43988755345344543, 0.30610668659210205, 0.4747186601161957, -0.006594072561711073, 0.018929656594991684, 0.06159987300634384, -0.5078710317611694, -0.7900875210762024, -0.3312411308288574, -0.7135049104690552, 0.9082154035568237, 0.13863320648670197, -0.1905292272567749, -0.18101385235786438, -0.06521445512771606, 0.14374980330467224, -0.5554331541061401, -0.14715777337551117, -0.4661133587360382, 0.34185168147087097, 0.6808792352676392, 0.5089005827903748, 0.3590724766254425, -0.6404668092727661, 0.7092928886413574, -0.6447739005088806, -0.9185101985931396, -0.9898428320884705, -0.08855023980140686, -0.7934925556182861, 0.04962705075740814, 0.2425079345703125, 0.1332940012216568, -0.2496374547481537, 0.1721748411655426, 0.7286714315414429, 0.17345507442951202, -0.40197229385375977, -0.7422922253608704, 0.20540377497673035, 0.20649120211601257, 0.7349196672439575, -0.6981122493743896, -0.5922335386276245, 0.5255962610244751, -0.33044931292533875, 0.5090082287788391, 0.1319086104631424, -1.1307554244995117, 0.4366474747657776, -1.0810778141021729, -0.7444290518760681, -0.8461592793464661, 0.010503226891160011, -0.5075953602790833, -0.5853462815284729, -0.13663437962532043, 0.2647132873535156, 0.5276917219161987, -0.5470992922782898, -0.5634434223175049, -0.22666895389556885, 0.2923635244369507, -0.2932372987270355, 0.31155335903167725, -0.4942267835140228, 0.09704842418432236, -0.7813650369644165, 1.4953765869140625, -0.3963474631309509, -0.5800230503082275, 0.07017778605222702, -0.01878068409860134, -0.3355163335800171, 1.0979176759719849, 0.18955129384994507, -0.5137686729431152, -0.20805367827415466, 0.12237698584794998, 0.4747174084186554, 0.5211866497993469, -0.6236392259597778, 0.43805521726608276, -0.59433513879776, 0.3244694471359253, -0.37289783358573914, 0.08331210166215897, 0.421516090631485, 0.11911413818597794, 0.2148810178041458, -0.15407197177410126, -0.10254156589508057, 1.052956223487854, 0.3002338707447052, 0.8152671456336975, 0.08984402567148209, 0.21451470255851746, 0.1935909241437912, -0.7104504704475403, -0.7950852513313293, 0.3495209217071533, 0.3290182054042816, -0.35076722502708435, 0.04675254970788956, -0.2066347450017929, 0.20897427201271057, -0.5099652409553528, 1.259230375289917, 0.0888543650507927, 0.03702859580516815, -0.04978074133396149, 0.4600145220756531, 0.1729470044374466, 0.1505611389875412, -0.16475917398929596, 0.38064801692962646, -0.032734524458646774, -0.4237810969352722, -0.24590420722961426, -0.5850477814674377, -0.9430102109909058, -0.4737491309642792, 0.09083370119333267, 0.7286069989204407, -0.7092149257659912, 0.8653004765510559, -0.39937451481819153, -0.02050129696726799, -0.7087116837501526, 0.5048744678497314, 0.5494577884674072, -0.2991856336593628, 1.3715457916259766, 0.7775970697402954, -0.18344078958034515, 0.4482845366001129, -0.1489635705947876, -0.8378759026527405, 0.09299781918525696, 0.6359220147132874, -1.2010126113891602, 0.03782723471522331, 0.5997522473335266, 0.6926265358924866, -1.0551468133926392, -0.885156512260437, -1.1866815090179443, -0.20291846990585327, 0.6300827860832214, -0.6401011943817139, 0.09810712188482285, -0.4360094666481018, -0.5599240064620972, 0.19722643494606018, 0.2501774728298187, 0.9577439427375793, 0.5052986145019531, -0.019556840881705284, 0.5984629988670349, -0.6180570721626282, 0.03584415838122368, 1.263094186782837, 0.6126580834388733, -0.33333897590637207, -0.2947622239589691, -0.1368204653263092, -0.302338182926178, -0.18343530595302582, 0.6951324939727783, -0.6128974556922913, 0.4215560257434845, 0.22228072583675385, 0.1105710119009018, 0.5944728255271912, -0.21034874022006989, 0.10924466699361801, 0.3794335722923279, -0.9044767618179321, -0.7378989458084106, -0.4328063428401947, -0.3223278224468231, 0.33094096183776855, 1.0268704891204834, -0.05687585845589638, -0.25377243757247925, -0.7054412364959717, -0.21441401541233063, -0.10491211712360382, -0.6843515634536743, -0.5981084704399109, -1.0696446895599365, -0.7282421588897705, -1.1153777837753296, 0.3856213390827179, -0.0963464006781578, 0.4490134119987488, -0.7607080936431885, 0.633156418800354, -0.5037888884544373, 0.31374141573905945, -0.13171258568763733, 0.900152325630188, -0.24059264361858368, -0.6722594499588013, -0.3165958821773529, 0.13414494693279266, 0.21538902819156647, -0.989802896976471, -0.12817463278770447, -0.24441993236541748, 0.6017327904701233, 1.003600835800171, -0.7844704389572144, 0.5019784569740295, -0.5395565032958984, -0.14964495599269867, -0.01583612896502018, -0.08819601684808731, -0.5408979654312134, 0.9229287505149841, -0.9210690855979919, 1.3579998016357422, 0.5136364698410034, 0.06822868436574936, -0.08276448398828506, 0.18683697283267975, -1.0326889753341675, 0.48774057626724243, 0.14396685361862183, 0.5971648693084717, 0.18886946141719818, -1.0434966087341309, -0.3046923577785492, 1.4565504789352417, -0.5305993556976318, 0.09780749678611755, -0.043658580631017685, 0.6583839058876038, -0.45947474241256714, 0.4494640827178955, -0.3240194618701935, 0.8985628485679626, 0.249819815158844, 0.13881638646125793, -0.2847175896167755, 0.4052899181842804, 0.6053591966629028, 0.6344934105873108, 0.006730952300131321, -0.9921793937683105, 0.6458496451377869, -1.288760781288147, 0.8501443862915039, 0.3385714888572693, -0.2648871839046478, -0.39731475710868835, 0.37154150009155273, 0.1453094482421875, -0.5878929495811462, 0.4288672208786011, -0.9418571591377258, 0.5964794754981995, 0.03198685869574547, 1.117423415184021, 0.3187450170516968, 0.3126940429210663, -0.4908311069011688, 0.44203242659568787, -0.18649592995643616, -0.7731966972351074, 0.3682529628276825, -0.09421806782484055, -0.41465863585472107, -0.09324841946363449, -0.021371565759181976, 0.18369249999523163, 0.21438321471214294, 0.5656429529190063, 1.2177585363388062, 0.49222421646118164, -0.16891522705554962, 1.0291357040405273, -0.30628231167793274, -0.9153915047645569, -0.38489145040512085, 0.40888291597366333, -1.1531189680099487, -0.9519815444946289, 0.12432900816202164, 0.8164621591567993, -0.13895539939403534, -0.14068880677223206, 0.40163692831993103, -0.20137974619865417, -0.20991671085357666, 0.559232771396637, -1.0539522171020508, -0.4643144905567169, -0.11047881096601486, 0.30233144760131836, -0.004252816084772348, 0.3296484351158142, 0.33965104818344116, 0.8205382823944092, 0.430103063583374, 0.06069369614124298, -0.7173399925231934, 1.6418979167938232, 0.22024491429328918, -0.10391177982091904, 0.813997209072113, -0.1894797682762146, 0.28882408142089844, 1.2165957689285278, -0.28589633107185364, -0.15846431255340576, 0.943666398525238, 0.12973518669605255, 0.5673577785491943, 0.2966301143169403, -0.35801687836647034, 0.2202819138765335, -0.17694412171840668, 0.444445937871933, 0.1154654324054718, -0.04346247389912605, 0.26135560870170593, 0.5044362545013428, -0.1783125400543213, -0.020158153027296066, -0.5944997668266296, 0.03214144706726074, -0.12370753288269043, -0.3091883659362793, 0.5208449363708496, -1.0382943153381348, -0.3545581102371216, 0.09276564419269562, -0.5472815632820129, -1.2040729522705078, -0.8316209316253662, 0.3944859206676483, 0.8039349913597107, -0.37385833263397217, -0.3021683394908905, 0.49409666657447815, 0.0729483887553215, 0.42356905341148376, -0.04415133222937584, 0.40158215165138245, 0.33505240082740784, 0.24490667879581451, 0.17475783824920654, -0.0201119277626276, -0.10525217652320862, 0.6420590281486511, 0.3216174244880676, -0.8643293380737305, 0.0235636867582798, 0.6703859567642212, -0.8528008460998535, 0.10958778858184814, -0.05189953371882439, -0.16276630759239197, -0.048877038061618805, -0.25804662704467773, 0.16395412385463715, -0.6788963079452515, 0.2734155058860779, 0.4747443199157715, -0.5711978673934937, -0.07531721144914627, 0.15557973086833954, -0.18567295372486115, 0.5000981092453003, 0.6835231184959412, 0.4158228635787964, -0.8490740060806274, 1.109683632850647, 0.7170612215995789, 0.6961314678192139, -0.03377135843038559, -0.036165717989206314, -0.2853129804134369, 0.34375831484794617, -0.026717577129602432, -1.0284531116485596, 0.33663302659988403, -0.23518043756484985, -0.30233243107795715, 0.11852478981018066, 0.43406543135643005, -0.07941700518131256, 0.37162458896636963, 0.40033474564552307, 0.24223445355892181, -0.1300087720155716, 0.23243121802806854, 0.35785311460494995, -0.20803816616535187, -0.8131710290908813, -0.23761098086833954, 0.19332346320152283, -0.7456958293914795, -0.22045442461967468, -1.106583595275879, 0.6836792826652527, -0.0859709084033966, -0.6267980933189392, -0.3943166732788086, -0.6903831362724304, -0.4779745936393738, -0.6044633388519287, -0.5688523650169373, -0.27172428369522095, 0.5062605142593384, 0.6905518174171448, 0.11763090640306473, 0.11066669970750809, -0.6849758625030518, 0.05661322548985481, 0.1645936518907547, 1.1113225221633911, -0.16344736516475677, 0.18324317038059235, 0.41166049242019653, 0.22298355400562286, -0.8621664047241211, 0.1287221759557724, 1.012665867805481, -0.1431550532579422, 0.44579318165779114, 0.0035141995176672935, 0.11099313944578171, 0.01915786601603031, -0.5342405438423157, -0.02177652344107628, 1.351179599761963, 0.5477315187454224, -0.44178980588912964, -0.5533751845359802, -0.05717405304312706, -0.47836244106292725, -0.3261280655860901, -0.5341701507568359, 1.0827325582504272, 0.2571171522140503, -0.26707664132118225, -0.033267583698034286, -1.10428786277771, 3.9042346477508545, 0.501516580581665, 1.0278722047805786, -0.3281378746032715, 0.3070739507675171, 1.0773934125900269, 0.24321506917476654, -0.036271799355745316, 0.06340331584215164, -0.17534753680229187, 0.10953035205602646, -0.2210271656513214, 0.16564634442329407, 0.23096239566802979, 0.47459837794303894, 1.0080777406692505, -0.11461379379034042, -0.3913281261920929, -0.3349059820175171, 0.052135903388261795, -1.4580943584442139, -0.26676613092422485, 0.3103440999984741, -0.35020947456359863, -0.0362786166369915, 0.9236573576927185, -0.029169626533985138, -0.31400054693222046, -0.8682997822761536, -0.4402320981025696, -0.32903745770454407, -0.39969754219055176, -0.0676286593079567, -0.1706230193376541, -1.491431474685669, 1.0584561824798584, 0.13198743760585785, -0.602526068687439, 0.6798995137214661, -0.44957175850868225, -0.091236412525177, -0.902682900428772, 0.06614486128091812, -0.25554901361465454, -0.0405486561357975, 1.0224089622497559, 0.6950644254684448, 0.4961615800857544, 0.8245994448661804, -0.8602636456489563, -0.2524060010910034, 0.02255183272063732, 0.3514454662799835, -0.3452163636684418, -1.0747605562210083, -0.2611360549926758, 0.2802422046661377, -0.4855780303478241, 0.4910264313220978, -0.20226158201694489, 1.2081413269042969, -0.7009347081184387, -0.5733023285865784, 0.2865097224712372, 0.5077061653137207, 0.326627641916275, 0.4667528569698334, -0.05489625409245491, -0.3910735249519348, -0.20868632197380066, -0.651443362236023, -0.0792868360877037, -0.6532514095306396, -0.11535398662090302, -0.2996201515197754, 0.16632558405399323, 0.5885792970657349, -0.3532315790653229, -0.6307356357574463, -0.25992801785469055, -0.15095408260822296, 0.0025056989397853613, -0.6623753309249878, 0.6088556051254272, -0.41307172179222107, 0.7029558420181274, -0.3041151165962219, 0.15590602159500122, -0.2680954337120056, 0.9531853795051575, 0.13706186413764954, 0.6240683794021606, -0.4157787263393402, 0.5507057309150696, -0.38801655173301697 ]
Recent advances in extended inflationary cosmology
Extended inflation is a promising new approach to implementing the inflationary universe scenario. This paper reviews recent advances including a new, more robust mechanism for ending extended inflation, a new prediction for the density fluctuation spectrum generated by extended inflation, and the discovery that extended inflation can produce gravitational waves that can significantly add to the cosmic background anisotropy. Invited Talk at the Journees Relativistes, Amsterdam, May 14-16, 1992
Paul J. Steinhardt
astro-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212004
astro-ph/9212005
[ 0.3250387907028198, 0.25231850147247314, 0.43063437938690186, 0.6612733006477356, -0.3353346288204193, 0.3166435658931732, -0.3049682378768921, -0.03120618686079979, 0.056387368589639664, 0.8359792232513428, 0.5315161347389221, -0.05770339444279671, -0.026979751884937286, -0.48093611001968384, -0.3585152328014374, -0.5035679936408997, 0.09435933083295822, -0.37186193466186523, -1.6731458902359009, 0.0013236388331279159, -0.12561540305614471, -0.23147857189178467, -1.0123282670974731, -0.43232327699661255, -0.8467100262641907, 0.13853226602077484, 0.28471916913986206, 0.25525233149528503, 0.7030875086784363, 0.7447881102561951, 0.0052842795848846436, -0.645420253276825, -0.04618038609623909, -1.0545659065246582, 0.23837244510650635, -0.4155469238758087, 0.35825610160827637, -0.6996932625770569, 0.778987467288971, -0.1252577155828476, 0.6218745112419128, 0.06726017594337463, 0.18981532752513885, -0.4020720422267914, -0.3562958538532257, -0.027235982939600945, -0.10485351830720901, 0.488559752702713, 0.23720291256904602, -0.3510657250881195, 0.22360120713710785, -0.46798235177993774, 0.1674688458442688, -0.5346794724464417, 0.10302670300006866, -0.08225499093532562, -0.024462183937430382, 0.41002991795539856, -0.0063549368642270565, -0.18299022316932678, 0.2654465138912201, 0.22421322762966156, 0.03508327901363373, -0.8700202703475952, 0.09210554510354996, 0.8157387971878052, 0.20548775792121887, 0.2515522837638855, -0.2605918347835541, -0.4347761273384094, 0.08322888612747192, 0.26443246006965637, 0.48968684673309326, 0.7358042001724243, 0.31543606519699097, 0.38708415627479553, 0.03351934254169464, -0.35630449652671814, -1.4684274196624756, 0.3275071382522583, 0.08831142634153366, -0.005632778163999319, 0.26871734857559204, 0.40586039423942566, -0.7296384572982788, -0.374286413192749, -0.16255596280097961, -0.0647912323474884, 0.21084991097450256, 0.1308107227087021, 0.3664451837539673, 0.5561048984527588, -1.2044180631637573, 0.27300676703453064, 1.0334678888320923, 0.11112037301063538, -0.23299238085746765, 0.34874317049980164, 0.12406108528375626, 0.6932681202888489, -0.12240777909755707, 1.0877193212509155, 0.09584809839725494, 0.33811450004577637, -0.35881146788597107, 0.9198248386383057, -0.1573968380689621, 0.06713821738958359, -0.07555705308914185, -1.1153727769851685, 0.48446232080459595, 0.10829733312129974, 0.6016518473625183, 0.09962287545204163, 0.196281298995018, 0.49396806955337524, -0.26442059874534607, 0.252411812543869, -0.5337085723876953, -0.5263115167617798, -0.05646567791700363, 0.7858102321624756, 0.496782511472702, 0.139899343252182, 0.2693781852722168, -0.20633818209171295, 0.3347429931163788, 0.10223617404699326, -1.071821928024292, -0.0874398946762085, 0.009318126365542412, -0.44478246569633484, -0.4560937285423279, -0.21110843122005463, 0.2535574734210968, 0.3396609127521515, 0.328765869140625, 0.136002317070961, -0.28013259172439575, -0.7497730255126953, 0.24003304541110992, -0.8212257623672485, 0.3292997479438782, 0.7219287753105164, -1.3663270473480225, 0.28928446769714355, -0.07047051191329956, 0.3887996971607208, -0.6834225654602051, 0.3037250339984894, 0.3292834758758545, -0.33904317021369934, -0.28825199604034424, 0.1578400880098343, -0.8458284735679626, 0.08818367123603821, -1.1723026037216187, -0.5109612345695496, 0.451521098613739, -0.2266550064086914, 0.1471572369337082, -0.00251220166683197, 0.2184944897890091, 1.2540779113769531, -0.41905921697616577, 0.14734609425067902, -0.4851779341697693, -0.4789332449436188, 0.2966017723083496, 0.32154643535614014, -0.9488319158554077, 0.4720759987831116, 0.08785151690244675, 0.5194870829582214, 0.5445446372032166, 0.3571593165397644, 0.11414206773042679, -0.35110655426979065, -0.7778497338294983, 0.03670107573270798, 0.26813116669654846, -0.8336108326911926, 0.711239755153656, 0.6217894554138184, -0.2256980836391449, -0.0023079286329448223, 0.3559267222881317, 0.16637283563613892, 0.3887147009372711, 0.21482126414775848, -0.18760022521018982, 0.9015762805938721, -0.9547232985496521, 0.39149537682533264, -0.9471091628074646, -0.07489313185214996, -0.650388777256012, -0.20255924761295319, -0.06223741173744202, -1.150063395500183, 0.744361400604248, -0.1467037945985794, -0.7820457816123962, 0.946125864982605, -0.9297816753387451, -1.0803791284561157, 1.0041369199752808, 0.4304318130016327, -0.20129595696926117, 0.3349684178829193, 0.899608314037323, 0.09529728442430496, -0.3304748237133026, 0.22044195234775543, 0.3504718542098999, 0.22371599078178406, -0.8549451231956482, 0.020594673231244087, -0.03775070980191231, 0.5910078287124634, 0.5477274060249329, 0.17717944085597992, 0.1502234786748886, 0.7255613207817078, 0.3402267098426819, -0.771491527557373, -0.1287079006433487, 0.5971711874008179, -0.20069953799247742, 0.11799049377441406, -0.4254182279109955, -0.4752356708049774, 0.3277706503868103, -0.022689787670969963, 0.3070552349090576, 0.06712078303098679, 0.8943410515785217, 0.03719286620616913, 0.1434212476015091, 0.07021558284759521, -0.414482980966568, 0.4978112578392029, -0.036498889327049255, 0.4545789659023285, -0.32122495770454407, 0.4596323072910309, 0.854769229888916, 0.21912595629692078, -0.6465694904327393, 0.23058636486530304, -0.5991221070289612, 0.7346065044403076, -0.029694940894842148, 0.72225421667099, -1.044528603553772, -0.17817582190036774, -0.19073718786239624, 0.749496340751648, -0.08173826336860657, -0.5812942981719971, -0.29157397150993347, 0.20910045504570007, -0.7183972597122192, 0.3554101586341858, 0.05959738790988922, -0.013953947462141514, -0.8996203541755676, 0.010632796213030815, 0.7377402782440186, -0.18746331334114075, -1.315475583076477, 0.4195249080657959, -0.2241678684949875, -0.7750290632247925, -0.06459599733352661, 0.5868897438049316, 0.2945365905761719, 0.4413657784461975, 0.8861719369888306, 0.040228892117738724, 0.0447077713906765, 1.1685755252838135, -0.9911884665489197, -0.7122665047645569, -0.5967454314231873, 0.7910313606262207, -0.9183029532432556, 0.05213847756385803, -0.7783336043357849, 0.6779020428657532, -0.12656493484973907, -0.21629564464092255, 0.29071006178855896, 0.04815780743956566, 0.48768532276153564, 0.4910305440425873, -0.4113819897174835, -0.06961087882518768, -0.06809468567371368, -0.8817398548126221, 1.0744158029556274, 0.34172940254211426, -0.0062990812584757805, -0.06272133439779282, -0.5974138975143433, 0.650116503238678, -0.49489033222198486, -0.43902871012687683, 0.5258290767669678, -0.1415945142507553, -0.9632505178451538, 0.1326310932636261, -0.02094637043774128, 0.2568318247795105, -0.16859035193920135, 0.4293365776538849, 0.8697988986968994, 0.2435886114835739, 0.17470963299274445, -0.08691677451133728, -0.10060252994298935, -0.6477656960487366, 0.6472757458686829, -0.33028486371040344, 0.1150982603430748, 1.2155858278274536, 0.7694808840751648, -0.6859678626060486, 1.049169898033142, -1.016619086265564, -0.6424371600151062, 0.2102404236793518, 0.3779056668281555, 0.19506432116031647, 0.22282153367996216, 0.1338794231414795, -0.07096207141876221, 0.47045499086380005, -0.4279728829860687, 0.7817990779876709, 0.7070709466934204, -0.4898270070552826, 0.1028817892074585, 0.3909720182418823, -0.19822004437446594, 0.20606327056884766, 0.6834076642990112, 0.0761079341173172, -0.6770790219306946, 0.32240405678749084, -0.5413777232170105, 0.1352199912071228, 0.43257981538772583, 0.31849339604377747, 0.15823446214199066, -0.12331782281398773, -0.37795621156692505, 0.23369468748569489, -0.9903035163879395, -0.0338357575237751, 0.32487574219703674, 0.009878652170300484, 0.5808844566345215, -0.3391966223716736, -0.18486197292804718, 0.08127329498529434, -0.04213661700487137, 0.2920804023742676, 0.4634062349796295, -0.8341028094291687, 0.17082050442695618, -0.3799143433570862, -0.9017243385314941, -0.35085025429725647, -0.3017461597919464, -0.15548934042453766, 0.5947211384773254, 0.4267818033695221, 0.06425143033266068, -0.3091930150985718, -0.4615055024623871, -0.41873103380203247, 0.647681474685669, 0.19508837163448334, -0.3997443914413452, -0.29880768060684204, 0.08087235689163208, 0.4951627254486084, 0.4709142744541168, -0.7609302997589111, -0.5990085601806641, -1.2333347797393799, 0.5605421662330627, -0.5782860517501831, -0.3982998728752136, 0.12941640615463257, 0.26552116870880127, 0.701068639755249, -0.1909836381673813, 0.29429179430007935, -0.04168868064880371, -0.4820157587528229, 0.15359051525592804, -0.2042740434408188, -0.7081493735313416, 0.7989838123321533, -0.42096033692359924, -0.21436826884746552, -0.1690884828567505, -0.03658946231007576, 0.24951647222042084, -0.5135868787765503, -0.3779919743537903, -0.16220401227474213, 0.27420076727867126, 0.5955742597579956, 0.08029304444789886, 0.5378565788269043, 0.6155793070793152, -0.11890655755996704, -0.6729716062545776, 0.837964653968811, 0.28930750489234924, 1.121665358543396, 0.12759678065776825, -0.8124728202819824, -0.06626435369253159, -0.3277074098587036, -0.3127053380012512, 0.18278780579566956, -0.07595812529325485, -0.6977495551109314, -0.23850101232528687, -0.11942468583583832, 0.4281729757785797, 0.44188979268074036, 0.5702735185623169, 0.3099989593029022, 0.5562707185745239, 0.19471044838428497, 0.11932317167520523, 1.2727222442626953, -0.33967071771621704, 0.0892643928527832, 0.3174689710140228, 0.3148474395275116, -0.3629564046859741, -0.09046366065740585, 0.050204820930957794, -0.8170817494392395, -0.3079318404197693, -0.37327590584754944, 1.123674988746643, -0.5413581728935242, -0.747927725315094, 0.36781781911849976, 0.3179771304130554, -0.8044266104698181, 0.8035323023796082, -0.3819986879825592, -0.12563513219356537, 0.11240733414888382, -0.5055868625640869, -0.7550709843635559, -0.6075232625007629, 0.46868059039115906, -0.6811996102333069, 0.21887338161468506, 0.4459415674209595, -0.30818745493888855, 0.5902274250984192, 0.36737149953842163, -0.4661179780960083, 0.2962682545185089, 0.4098583459854126, -0.3496999740600586, -0.14752429723739624, 0.21185752749443054, -0.16823548078536987, -0.4542759954929352, 0.09879685193300247, 0.4325384497642517, -0.42739400267601013, -0.25325679779052734, 0.3715480864048004, -0.08362161368131638, -0.2798421084880829, -0.46866142749786377, -0.8200696110725403, 1.1778404712677002, -0.2666657269001007, 0.2600388526916504, -0.8541570901870728, -0.5427944660186768, -0.3612438440322876, -0.363967627286911, 0.2727201581001282, -0.5274825096130371, 0.28517040610313416, 0.4282935559749603, 0.08635635673999786, 0.2317039668560028, -0.5329330563545227, 0.4481782615184784, -0.009564694948494434, -0.5127045512199402, -0.43249279260635376, -0.08550280332565308, 0.04585247486829758, 0.31856444478034973, 0.33194905519485474, 0.10153859108686447, -0.544622004032135, -0.165242537856102, -0.04093235731124878, 0.46663492918014526, -0.6099564433097839, -1.2581816911697388, 0.1923285573720932, 0.267971932888031, 0.8521382808685303, -0.7460681796073914, -0.7703808546066284, 0.29665589332580566, 0.3728950619697571, 0.7285091280937195, -0.45031964778900146, -1.0294361114501953, 0.2894277274608612, -1.304517149925232, 0.3879834711551666, -0.35852035880088806, -0.17042699456214905, -0.2338646650314331, -0.8418716788291931, -0.5110421180725098, 0.14451727271080017, 0.24342705309391022, -0.16354511678218842, 0.29562675952911377, -0.23314408957958221, 0.6202137470245361, -0.48042091727256775, 0.1262887716293335, -0.11847450584173203, 0.37434425950050354, -1.3113377094268799, 0.9915249347686768, -0.39702385663986206, -0.6715608835220337, 0.2893045246601105, -0.19108650088310242, 0.13728873431682587, 0.40350037813186646, 0.7162314057350159, -0.6858643889427185, -0.5948062539100647, -0.1788584440946579, 0.5669243931770325, 0.9229695796966553, -0.057112738490104675, 0.40995877981185913, -0.22248826920986176, 0.5926413536071777, 0.16231591999530792, -0.11567221581935883, -0.0896969884634018, -0.11933373659849167, 0.2520653009414673, -0.11763059347867966, -0.0763457864522934, 1.180930495262146, -0.400232195854187, 0.45400336384773254, 0.39304986596107483, -0.3185441493988037, -0.6857126951217651, 0.17519435286521912, -0.6941581964492798, 0.3927471935749054, 0.18677684664726257, -0.4142112731933594, -0.14465521275997162, 0.027538489550352097, -0.21172212064266205, -0.4569336175918579, 0.38554495573043823, 0.06250400096178055, 0.1525854915380478, -0.024534543976187706, -0.925568163394928, 0.5691575407981873, -0.04895706847310066, -0.27306821942329407, 0.36283615231513977, 0.12029173225164413, 0.3157884478569031, -0.1281922161579132, -0.12149593234062195, -0.11058498173952103, -0.9093644022941589, -0.15933749079704285, 0.375133752822876, -0.6059607267379761, 0.7013190984725952, 0.07823634147644043, -0.11235176771879196, -0.2507984936237335, -0.028794502839446068, 0.1953597366809845, -0.3958832323551178, 0.4886091649532318, 0.1995885819196701, 0.33940020203590393, 0.5300697684288025, -0.20256425440311432, -0.47477781772613525, -0.16942673921585083, 0.5601369738578796, -1.1070771217346191, -0.23259761929512024, 0.17034131288528442, -0.032486896961927414, -0.6176055073738098, 0.10989049077033997, -1.268492579460144, -0.2440037578344345, 0.31836187839508057, -0.470624715089798, -0.31189021468162537, 0.22742819786071777, -0.28466370701789856, 0.3920946717262268, -0.06496201455593109, 0.7878603339195251, 0.23475660383701324, -0.12112635374069214, 0.11305863410234451, -1.2185745239257812, -0.18807995319366455, 0.9200089573860168, 0.2663760483264923, -0.6512299180030823, 0.26017889380455017, 0.25780102610588074, -0.5459163188934326, -0.2613166868686676, 1.053600788116455, -0.20596346259117126, 0.02555486559867859, 0.0162199754267931, 0.01612170971930027, 0.24593298137187958, 0.8167681097984314, -0.2268146127462387, 0.13134336471557617, -0.5769872665405273, -0.47342535853385925, -0.37806519865989685, -0.5163146257400513, 0.15683554112911224, 0.8245545625686646, -0.3217993974685669, -0.20658211410045624, -0.7404231429100037, -0.7851235270500183, 0.22698242962360382, 0.2465416043996811, -0.05426334589719772, -0.6501697301864624, -0.5995206236839294, -0.8090075850486755, -0.3173447847366333, -0.05690823495388031, 0.4456299841403961, -0.688990592956543, 0.6044157147407532, 0.14157143235206604, -0.182623028755188, 0.43273547291755676, 0.9421161413192749, -0.026738811284303665, -0.8069761991500854, -0.4408766031265259, -0.15156838297843933, -0.274643212556839, -1.0321167707443237, -0.5343611836433411, -0.4247604310512543, 0.9480118155479431, 1.1993569135665894, -0.5827586054801941, 0.6459847688674927, -0.3310711681842804, -0.3310067355632782, 0.3283151686191559, 0.15273387730121613, -0.3049241900444031, 1.1705201864242554, -0.36268267035484314, 1.2056938409805298, 0.2268584966659546, -0.05991922691464424, -0.05245543271303177, 0.4208359718322754, -0.7168427109718323, 1.2112122774124146, -0.07242001593112946, 1.0278067588806152, 1.0068036317825317, -1.0486122369766235, 0.21066506206989288, 0.6302403807640076, -0.46510574221611023, 0.006450951099395752, -0.31574928760528564, 0.8523980975151062, -0.6839871406555176, 0.213663250207901, 0.15511664748191833, 0.3655550479888916, -0.36894845962524414, 0.10799691081047058, -0.4972072243690491, -0.010119513608515263, -0.6371573805809021, 0.43708908557891846, 0.06388596445322037, -0.3515925705432892, 0.6139551401138306, -0.7398861050605774, 0.5161229968070984, 0.5734286308288574, 0.11455066502094269, -0.24552366137504578, -0.27999570965766907, 0.40585821866989136, 0.15971367061138153, 0.09979582577943802, -0.7451452016830444, 0.8135204315185547, -0.05621315538883209, 0.21903932094573975, 0.10748660564422607, -0.1632237285375595, -0.7599632143974304, 0.8493989706039429, -0.8262110352516174, -0.5369492769241333, 0.5325459837913513, -0.18611228466033936, 0.08236325532197952, 0.7415648698806763, -0.7755813002586365, 0.38524359464645386, -0.499637246131897, 0.5493635535240173, 1.1337361335754395, -0.09367188811302185, -0.578034520149231, 0.6822143197059631, -0.5701063871383667, 0.15302687883377075, -0.5752146244049072, 0.6600503921508789, -0.8057113885879517, -0.7987474203109741, -0.23966756463050842, -0.15780477225780487, -0.5560129880905151, 0.35289251804351807, -0.2535194158554077, -0.0939161479473114, -0.17209216952323914, -1.009365200996399, -0.404079407453537, -0.02632131427526474, -0.9937734007835388, 0.6940215826034546, -0.1363527625799179, -0.14388267695903778, -0.252786248922348, -0.331211656332016, 0.5174218416213989, 0.2733321189880371, -0.19979315996170044, 1.268057107925415, 0.2744019627571106, -0.04811371862888336, -0.39132237434387207, 0.6489870548248291, 0.25369468331336975, 0.32396364212036133, -1.0423475503921509, 0.034846119582653046, 0.3729126751422882, -0.09019091725349426, 0.32674160599708557, -0.07721806317567825, 0.09318749606609344, 0.29047077894210815, 0.4537436068058014, 0.648386538028717, 0.2848964035511017, -0.14972642064094543, -0.10680896043777466, 0.06988263875246048, 0.180297389626503, -0.06813454627990723, -0.04431011155247688, -0.05152788385748863, 0.5044316053390503, -0.32459506392478943, -0.39846017956733704, -0.40599456429481506, 0.13198429346084595, 0.7599583864212036, -0.2742106020450592, -0.6136916875839233, -0.6636359691619873, 0.2033645063638687, 0.15779730677604675, -0.032608818262815475, -0.5701460242271423, 0.34289824962615967, 0.5830215811729431, -0.3495509624481201, -0.5670595765113831, 0.25728604197502136, 0.37242835760116577, 0.9336181282997131, 0.552994430065155, 0.06852936744689941, -0.07246392965316772, 0.38663044571876526, -0.04453594982624054, -0.2615951895713806, -0.07403545826673508, 0.31075167655944824, -0.7890474200248718, 0.24534857273101807, 0.09250950068235397, -0.29609590768814087, -0.6498562097549438, -0.46722427010536194, 0.6943061351776123, -1.1704444885253906, -0.4687812924385071, 0.05086507648229599, -0.3186529576778412, -0.5293328762054443, 0.4044123888015747, 0.416980504989624, 0.11331068724393845, 0.8816186189651489, 0.2711871862411499, -0.3904514014720917, 1.3274608850479126, 0.6515552997589111, 0.2026231586933136, -0.5011537671089172, -0.6413453817367554, -0.36173567175865173, 0.11003974825143814, 0.17939436435699463, -0.0867510437965393, 0.9287118315696716, -0.8316084146499634, 0.5843304991722107, -0.8202596306800842, -0.32936492562294006, 0.2595778703689575, -0.18889565765857697, 0.19025146961212158, 0.04467533528804779, -0.5029551386833191, -0.1945800930261612, 0.5497066974639893, 0.5036852955818176, -0.13835321366786957, -0.9931305646896362, 0.09807097166776657, -0.5884689092636108, -0.2961274981498718, -0.8017851710319519, 0.5092614889144897, -0.11886100471019745, -0.24550515413284302, -0.9477342367172241, 0.037831082940101624, -0.015339134261012077, -0.7038607001304626, -0.6777470707893372, -0.031029965728521347, 0.0535823255777359, 0.7011235952377319, -0.1036047711968422, 0.5475873351097107, -0.6772828698158264, -0.15699490904808044, -0.33292582631111145, 0.8612792491912842, 0.16621989011764526, 0.6262819766998291, 0.09399422258138657, 0.23581326007843018, -1.0054211616516113, 0.4929090142250061, 0.41631191968917847, -0.8478424549102783, 0.357637494802475, -0.1512630581855774, 0.10341397672891617, -0.10097577422857285, -0.3284532427787781, 0.13538095355033875, 0.5084414482116699, -0.05189410597085953, 0.8987001180648804, -0.4639631509780884, 0.1704520881175995, -0.670461118221283, 0.03892301395535469, 0.17848527431488037, 0.564730167388916, 0.6364346742630005, -0.5394432544708252, -0.252115935087204, -1.1526572704315186, 4.172186374664307, 0.6231534481048584, 0.6446210145950317, -0.12236836552619934, 0.5763899683952332, 0.8441206216812134, 0.13573850691318512, -0.1196490228176117, 0.1604136824607849, -0.3878421187400818, 0.3050656318664551, -0.5142084956169128, 0.050253842025995255, -0.2153666764497757, 0.3393462300300598, 0.615547239780426, 0.5410434007644653, -0.39936113357543945, 0.3653261959552765, -0.8309005498886108, -1.4234522581100464, 0.2073792666196823, 0.42555564641952515, -0.009236008860170841, 0.2719863951206207, 0.2587341070175171, 0.13284730911254883, -0.5060231685638428, -0.7704375386238098, -0.6302999258041382, -0.5541113615036011, -0.7739560604095459, 0.7222679257392883, -0.399039089679718, -0.5865934491157532, 0.5637890100479126, -0.2736237347126007, -0.22091272473335266, -0.19591955840587616, -0.6680863499641418, 0.05751954764127731, -0.9509761333465576, -0.10496483743190765, -0.5368421673774719, -0.6446206569671631, 1.553863763809204, 0.48680275678634644, 1.1499735116958618, 0.7054152488708496, -0.2842322885990143, -0.12826049327850342, 0.14135654270648956, -0.07697766274213791, 0.3127481937408447, -0.46971872448921204, -0.46291476488113403, -0.16627348959445953, -0.1455499529838562, 0.29125797748565674, -0.10935740917921066, 0.9184026122093201, -0.13619014620780945, -0.21247680485248566, 0.6654558181762695, -0.16946399211883545, -0.30066654086112976, -0.15109044313430786, -0.02446494996547699, -0.37688565254211426, -0.32918667793273926, -0.7820027470588684, -0.20585273206233978, 0.03903735801577568, -0.4492308795452118, 0.28045153617858887, 0.31447336077690125, 0.3404335081577301, -0.07685143500566483, -0.1398351490497589, 0.4641454219818115, -0.2757452726364136, -0.1591729074716568, -0.21499265730381012, 0.4663831293582916, -0.0384925939142704, 1.3756517171859741, -0.11585953086614609, -0.11972329020500183, 0.23193198442459106, 0.7050648331642151, 0.1598590612411499, 0.33673572540283203, 0.019398657605051994, 0.43546733260154724, -0.509306013584137 ]
The Escape of Gravitational Radiation from the Field of Massive Bodies
We consider a compact source of gravitational waves of frequency $\omega$, in or near a massive spherically symmetric distribution of matter or a black hole. Recent calculations have led to apparently contradictory results for the influence of the massive body on the propagation of the waves. We show here that the results are in fact consistent and in agreement with the ``standard'' viewpoint in which the high frequency compact source produces the radiation as if in a flat background, and the background curvature affects the propagation of these waves.
Richard H. Price, Jorge Pullin and Prasun Kundu
astro-ph gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212005
astro-ph/9212006
[ 0.11381770670413971, 0.16575279831886292, 0.2868693470954895, -0.10771401971578598, -0.34559693932533264, -0.7626733779907227, -0.2610597014427185, -0.42573922872543335, -0.5144333839416504, 0.8130465745925903, -0.44519656896591187, -0.27986714243888855, 0.0580156184732914, -0.5489819645881653, -0.352518767118454, -0.5027768015861511, -0.0802302211523056, -0.1407763957977295, -1.491539716720581, 0.0960828885436058, 0.40499162673950195, -0.27112269401550293, -1.1263771057128906, -0.35592710971832275, -0.14940279722213745, 0.1926041543483734, 0.37848207354545593, 1.044564127922058, 0.6174381375312805, 0.3217700123786926, -0.11051995307207108, -0.9401639699935913, 0.2919807732105255, -1.4780560731887817, 0.05418219789862633, 0.45324864983558655, 0.394250750541687, -0.6121474504470825, -0.17078262567520142, 0.1477082073688507, 0.3657405972480774, -0.21187269687652588, 0.8522092700004578, -0.8042184114456177, -0.2140621840953827, 0.23530389368534088, -0.08177776634693146, -0.35583123564720154, 0.6577168107032776, -0.5010036826133728, 0.14230945706367493, -0.07914804667234421, 1.0348482131958008, -0.21929001808166504, 0.34116867184638977, -0.4452435076236725, 0.3282568156719208, 0.37864890694618225, -0.12446083128452301, -0.5678662657737732, 0.5087461471557617, 0.0466335266828537, 0.5006151795387268, -0.43387770652770996, -0.43313097953796387, 1.1607993841171265, 0.01850082352757454, 0.5416496992111206, -0.2062428593635559, -0.20957376062870026, 0.4823004901409149, 0.38419046998023987, -0.0839681625366211, 0.5500907301902771, -0.5559209585189819, 0.2759164273738861, -0.054976411163806915, 0.13384369015693665, -0.44881516695022583, 0.019980892539024353, 0.4302511215209961, -0.14410097897052765, 0.4837948977947235, -0.04776651784777641, -0.020632589235901833, -0.8706417679786682, 0.5258976221084595, 0.12214598804712296, -0.21961303055286407, 0.24242687225341797, 0.021418996155261993, 0.37205976247787476, -0.1273743063211441, 0.11783317476511002, 0.6981871128082275, 0.013668960891664028, -0.49137046933174133, 0.12707695364952087, 0.4184053838253021, 0.6304096579551697, 0.2643407881259918, 1.1204856634140015, -0.5950016379356384, 0.5140942931175232, -0.4764396846294403, 0.44696202874183655, 0.5981108546257019, -0.18032817542552948, 0.15652059018611908, -1.16340172290802, 0.05350087583065033, 0.4212193489074707, 0.1687455028295517, -0.014340324327349663, 0.5319167375564575, 1.0265181064605713, -0.22189971804618835, 0.7545974254608154, -0.0282821673899889, -0.03890083357691765, -0.3606334328651428, 0.960324764251709, 0.47092872858047485, -0.5431310534477234, -0.10250885039567947, -0.3809375762939453, 0.14927177131175995, 0.09405688941478729, -0.8477234244346619, -0.024490220472216606, 0.12404223531484604, -0.39440828561782837, -0.4406870901584625, 0.8066045641899109, 0.497787207365036, 0.033271655440330505, 0.7581076622009277, 0.8458659052848816, 0.47723525762557983, -1.2595672607421875, -0.18270327150821686, -0.4448259472846985, -0.41767147183418274, 1.0769031047821045, -0.47252023220062256, -0.46209803223609924, 0.4638484716415405, -0.5906020402908325, -0.8933438658714294, 0.4465962052345276, 0.3673752248287201, -0.518824577331543, 0.3340468108654022, 0.4472103416919708, -0.5433916449546814, 0.1174599751830101, -0.3175056576728821, 0.32102546095848083, 0.028019631281495094, -0.5948075652122498, -0.24670065939426422, -0.14060984551906586, 0.443959504365921, 1.0262854099273682, -0.39446407556533813, 0.40596291422843933, -0.6448898315429688, -0.7890510559082031, -0.14817093312740326, -0.10129348188638687, -0.26792579889297485, 0.45522981882095337, 0.4521177113056183, 0.5061078667640686, 0.9194705486297607, 0.33788609504699707, -0.34003782272338867, -0.7352052330970764, -0.5671038627624512, 0.3929152488708496, -0.03393502160906792, 0.08706051111221313, 0.23472397029399872, -0.21531809866428375, -0.24961303174495697, -0.22715310752391815, -0.8366166949272156, -0.7963931560516357, 0.6487268805503845, 0.3571673333644867, 0.18309859931468964, 0.3909691274166107, -0.6682949662208557, 0.7174220085144043, -0.8449046611785889, 0.5475021004676819, -0.1234547346830368, -0.21172437071800232, -0.1783355325460434, -1.1766828298568726, 0.7614114880561829, 0.02954452857375145, -0.023979641497135162, 0.2293807864189148, -0.5981358885765076, -0.13846136629581451, 1.0267373323440552, 0.6084996461868286, -0.08486620336771011, 0.1420462727546692, 0.3525643050670624, -0.5284004211425781, 0.19289125502109528, 0.003468700684607029, 0.8295183181762695, -0.695128321647644, -0.01392147596925497, 0.36107775568962097, -0.6129279136657715, -0.24825307726860046, 0.3383937180042267, 0.527043342590332, 0.15756507217884064, 0.4024535119533539, -0.2088174968957901, -0.8304211497306824, -0.35057395696640015, 0.25304675102233887, -0.07226409018039703, 0.12741300463676453, 0.21256454288959503, 0.029665319249033928, 0.3108632266521454, 0.23941557109355927, 0.15658535063266754, -0.4027758240699768, 0.6111307740211487, 0.5603176355361938, -0.40052491426467896, -0.28303903341293335, -0.06449543684720993, -0.22700223326683044, 0.43215304613113403, 0.13786564767360687, -0.42623263597488403, 0.6430157423019409, -0.316371887922287, -0.4865994155406952, -0.47327739000320435, 0.2584725320339203, -0.7140928506851196, 0.5452212691307068, 0.22246792912483215, 0.2195524275302887, -1.0135221481323242, -0.9987128973007202, 0.17083972692489624, -0.2757229804992676, 0.040359072387218475, -0.024619437754154205, -0.9018197059631348, 0.17264914512634277, 0.11201432347297668, -0.36288097500801086, -0.4591079354286194, 0.23693418502807617, -0.3559440076351166, 0.6612605452537537, 0.6030508279800415, 0.17985467612743378, -1.3608366250991821, 0.21928882598876953, -0.12131636589765549, -0.4394758343696594, -0.004502457566559315, 0.29515567421913147, 0.7805461287498474, -0.7937610745429993, 0.27547213435173035, -0.16671565175056458, -0.43410181999206543, 1.1740026473999023, -0.3820633292198181, 0.0027038725093007088, -0.678396463394165, 0.3561095893383026, -0.7156808972358704, 0.35762375593185425, -0.4652481973171234, 0.7543780207633972, 0.1724834442138672, 0.5345896482467651, -0.8443275094032288, -0.1322796493768692, 0.8679507970809937, 0.2113875150680542, 0.2614850699901581, 0.06499365717172623, 0.7071112990379333, -0.930016040802002, 0.6813403964042664, -0.035782620310783386, -0.757868230342865, -0.468203067779541, -0.7836474776268005, 0.42221397161483765, -0.24472734332084656, -0.4931427240371704, 0.1817857325077057, 0.0936911329627037, -0.6180664300918579, 0.08381365239620209, 0.3410688638687134, 0.39703208208084106, 0.03831993415951729, 0.3202913999557495, 0.0016677833627909422, -0.0342244990170002, 0.4137464463710785, 0.10884469747543335, -0.6594024300575256, -0.3418651223182678, 0.1525115966796875, -0.23788884282112122, 0.06744056195020676, 1.4124432802200317, -0.057837605476379395, -0.3433365225791931, 0.7363656759262085, -0.7718506455421448, -0.30358654260635376, 0.3718445301055908, 0.016551243141293526, 0.7340617179870605, 0.3968852460384369, -0.47538891434669495, -0.629155158996582, -0.13988526165485382, 0.07030521333217621, 0.47185462713241577, 0.2980107367038727, 0.4496612548828125, 0.06139807030558586, 1.1823195219039917, -0.4287938177585602, -0.4624232351779938, 0.6652480363845825, -0.31667453050613403, 0.03549817204475403, -0.3147982656955719, -0.2814297378063202, 0.17527659237384796, 0.7373082041740417, 0.19003747403621674, -0.18530772626399994, 0.4191587567329407, -0.015249273739755154, 0.021554376929998398, -0.559868335723877, -0.6789746880531311, -0.10610033571720123, 0.7631679773330688, 0.33261486887931824, 0.4595552980899811, -0.19985313713550568, -0.10611294209957123, -0.22092020511627197, -0.3965516984462738, 0.0763121247291565, -1.168810486793518, 0.8990762829780579, -0.003141960594803095, -0.3487069606781006, -0.224257692694664, 0.2333860993385315, 0.012451715767383575, 0.7351811528205872, 0.19035007059574127, 0.9501539468765259, 0.22355088591575623, -0.11449283361434937, 0.25106850266456604, 0.6429399847984314, -0.06856810301542282, 0.39585384726524353, 0.10314232110977173, 0.5809788107872009, 0.3919837772846222, 0.07413596659898758, -0.7284112572669983, -0.1957295686006546, -1.3291070461273193, 0.22153085470199585, -0.6024422645568848, -0.7394837737083435, 0.6806938052177429, 0.3852936625480652, 0.5726777911186218, -0.31476226449012756, -0.37955349683761597, 0.20549605786800385, -0.9353885054588318, 0.21092697978019714, 0.2840595841407776, -0.04858413338661194, 0.7415192723274231, -0.5774704217910767, -0.49799802899360657, 0.10753736644983292, -0.12351007759571075, -0.17841993272304535, -0.1642962247133255, -0.28505465388298035, -0.19519288837909698, 0.10150139778852463, 0.41568422317504883, -0.38079896569252014, 0.2605625092983246, 0.32343897223472595, -0.10839100927114487, -0.06834598630666733, 0.8386770486831665, 0.655958890914917, 0.8981121182441711, -0.662682831287384, -1.1894092559814453, -0.5177291035652161, -0.2123454064130783, -0.016012761741876602, 0.716674268245697, -0.3264800012111664, -0.4854000210762024, -0.41761478781700134, 0.052651744335889816, 0.12238759547472, 0.16802294552326202, 0.4345449209213257, 0.22533968091011047, 0.22215542197227478, -0.6152791976928711, -0.16439393162727356, 0.5592737197875977, -0.18611861765384674, 0.39515483379364014, -0.07041594386100769, 0.4430138170719147, -0.2476823329925537, 0.3114943206310272, -0.15015149116516113, -0.8654410243034363, -0.5769880414009094, -0.2911151349544525, 0.7466145753860474, -0.3367343842983246, -0.9571536779403687, 0.9339091777801514, -0.13520872592926025, -0.3020690977573395, 0.41245198249816895, -0.42420750856399536, 0.10862314701080322, -0.2028808891773224, 0.6173798441886902, -0.030087785795331, -0.20739947259426117, -0.03828704357147217, -0.39555230736732483, 0.038588836789131165, 0.5789536237716675, 0.12696781754493713, 0.4245414733886719, 0.39152073860168457, -0.7117541432380676, 0.20375816524028778, -0.19590285420417786, -0.06628374010324478, 0.30646374821662903, -0.2677105963230133, 0.1718551516532898, -0.5391780734062195, 0.030784621834754944, 0.07617048174142838, -0.9566608667373657, 0.2953498065471649, -0.7183263897895813, -0.6502784490585327, -0.43686389923095703, -0.022543536499142647, -0.2831050753593445, 0.09240061789751053, -0.009643753059208393, -0.9555088877677917, -0.3376367390155792, -0.17725571990013123, -0.45813825726509094, 0.05139099806547165, 0.08085035532712936, -0.8143290877342224, 0.14372020959854126, -0.2598787546157837, -0.010996339842677116, -0.05634714663028717, -0.702332079410553, 0.08561506122350693, -0.1503160446882248, -0.720440149307251, -0.6124393343925476, -0.4222019612789154, -0.5657253861427307, 0.45831939578056335, -0.017232945188879967, 0.32889458537101746, -0.5958563089370728, 0.19343392550945282, 0.11475896835327148, 0.5184983611106873, -0.11723507940769196, -0.7001334428787231, -0.067241370677948, 0.24050766229629517, -0.10500682890415192, -0.7986202836036682, -0.8336554765701294, 0.7618960738182068, -0.12141308188438416, -0.3184545934200287, -0.4802333414554596, -0.6729612350463867, 0.20887541770935059, -1.3270924091339111, 0.2349216639995575, -0.6483535766601562, 0.8385177254676819, 0.2512245178222656, -0.520870566368103, 0.34794527292251587, 0.23871184885501862, 0.7955630421638489, -0.9014362692832947, -0.15453697741031647, -0.17066095769405365, 0.8705887198448181, -0.18324647843837738, 0.37562158703804016, -0.29187479615211487, 0.037123389542102814, -0.3566683530807495, 0.8272624611854553, -0.5554481744766235, -0.1343713104724884, 0.4500625729560852, 0.3568071722984314, -0.31948229670524597, 0.34965282678604126, -0.011678406968712807, -0.18217796087265015, -0.3813284635543823, -0.2161787897348404, -0.023888489231467247, 0.9450151324272156, -0.7172621488571167, -0.2519395351409912, -0.7390882968902588, -0.49360716342926025, 0.028317561373114586, -0.12674179673194885, -0.32281574606895447, 0.15310342609882355, 0.26053643226623535, -0.26874038577079773, 0.9524977207183838, 1.1664342880249023, -0.05586029589176178, 0.03763112425804138, 0.8329975605010986, -0.11899976432323456, -0.3301835060119629, -0.14831137657165527, -0.4350934624671936, 0.5518332719802856, 0.26799237728118896, -0.43735286593437195, 0.2823095917701721, -0.12272549420595169, 0.48748818039894104, -0.7356953024864197, 0.696294903755188, 0.01805834099650383, 0.540034294128418, 0.5314502716064453, -0.45242682099342346, 0.15554577112197876, -0.5343936681747437, 0.0068158237263560295, 1.041614294052124, -0.3824132978916168, -0.9985970258712769, -0.03412437438964844, -0.14264892041683197, -0.5736586451530457, -0.6893971562385559, 0.47848430275917053, 0.4362531900405884, -0.7293523550033569, 1.0616893768310547, -0.008322350680828094, -0.20285871624946594, 0.22016550600528717, 0.31772807240486145, 0.5386470556259155, -0.42116808891296387, 0.7649539113044739, -0.805527925491333, 0.17196297645568848, 0.6479678153991699, -0.6959574222564697, -0.07630075514316559, -0.465216726064682, 0.7343743443489075, -0.1150040477514267, -0.18957573175430298, 0.09181666374206543, 0.17245469987392426, -0.38620010018348694, -0.33437252044677734, -0.8554614186286926, 0.03346424177289009, 0.31402823328971863, -0.526095986366272, -1.182794451713562, 0.14748115837574005, -0.3323815166950226, 0.22007526457309723, -0.11467377841472626, 0.8949586749076843, 0.09616222977638245, 0.1449751853942871, -0.28550630807876587, -0.7445977330207825, 0.8226114511489868, 1.491274118423462, 0.44494321942329407, 0.0495898500084877, 0.17895837128162384, -0.3746945559978485, -0.8137555718421936, -0.6068651676177979, 1.247857928276062, -0.42661550641059875, -0.0031611609738320112, -0.1669434905052185, 0.2225252240896225, 0.3719877600669861, 1.0004775524139404, -0.06244704872369766, 0.013641265220940113, -0.7526858448982239, -0.39310869574546814, -0.21525676548480988, -0.4408792555332184, -0.3823241889476776, 0.8405381441116333, 0.9062222242355347, -0.39091169834136963, -0.014154990203678608, -0.3060794472694397, 0.2672954201698303, 0.02593797631561756, -0.41260868310928345, 0.013115564361214638, -0.5825356841087341, -0.6381619572639465, -0.49370115995407104, 0.42043575644493103, 0.33625468611717224, -0.1698867827653885, 0.03443892300128937, 0.21588049829006195, 0.59881591796875, 0.12246327847242355, 0.8667790293693542, -0.6671961545944214, -0.04559223726391792, -0.649244487285614, 0.14173106849193573, -0.23396842181682587, -1.2160735130310059, -0.2088153064250946, -0.5811054110527039, -0.18700458109378815, 0.8209701180458069, -0.017885860055685043, 0.9185399413108826, -0.22941821813583374, 0.2292579561471939, -0.2069355845451355, -0.5833876132965088, -0.859551191329956, 0.6408506631851196, -0.3636093735694885, 0.38870665431022644, 0.4873863160610199, -0.96848064661026, 0.12711583077907562, 0.22710350155830383, -0.9482859969139099, 0.6915587186813354, -0.07133340835571289, 1.1569314002990723, -0.03328002244234085, -0.5766223073005676, -0.25822335481643677, 1.4898122549057007, -0.8357133269309998, -0.6727110147476196, -0.44426533579826355, 0.14441189169883728, -0.31363603472709656, 0.2633475661277771, 0.37029123306274414, 0.12806621193885803, -0.3537452220916748, 0.4741353690624237, -0.8310909867286682, 0.587700605392456, -0.1791977435350418, 0.689411461353302, -0.288144588470459, -0.23850290477275848, -0.059205811470746994, -0.6404208540916443, 0.4758668839931488, 0.5037956237792969, 0.34363651275634766, -0.31198135018348694, -0.5244903564453125, 0.4996620714664459, 0.023750292137265205, -0.4445348381996155, -0.8130293488502502, 0.6711208820343018, 0.5752067565917969, 0.8770134449005127, 0.388791024684906, -0.5927961468696594, -0.8173655867576599, 0.3675837814807892, -0.5015658140182495, -0.23570935428142548, 0.2018575519323349, -0.24702602624893188, 0.03314647823572159, -0.20757372677326202, -0.2559914290904999, 0.8921715021133423, 0.4163286089897156, 0.08262700587511063, 0.6700621843338013, -0.07772190123796463, -0.403479665517807, 1.2394846677780151, -1.0884987115859985, -0.1854880154132843, -0.7080672383308411, 0.5391131043434143, -1.259727954864502, -0.7565521597862244, -0.24840179085731506, 0.1801740676164627, -0.6050491333007812, -0.46816155314445496, -0.1601613312959671, -0.6012744903564453, -0.23507346212863922, -0.6490482091903687, -0.38757985830307007, 0.014039460569620132, -0.5704829692840576, 0.013858186081051826, -0.3490842580795288, -0.11994002759456635, 0.04203770309686661, 0.4404822885990143, 1.2664967775344849, -0.461629718542099, -1.034906029701233, 0.7367998361587524, 0.36062097549438477, 0.47274842858314514, -0.2666156589984894, 0.780848503112793, 0.16321253776550293, -0.22666919231414795, -0.7339561581611633, 0.09475555270910263, 0.5783159136772156, -0.0650239810347557, 0.3691657483577728, -0.2259330451488495, 0.702672004699707, 0.02319650910794735, 0.2278899848461151, 0.31037408113479614, 0.4003467559814453, -0.010444628074765205, -0.4494098126888275, -0.2787962257862091, -0.22078077495098114, 0.3350098729133606, 0.26106852293014526, -0.10901393741369247, 0.5519957542419434, 0.031227722764015198, -0.34593620896339417, -0.6294991970062256, -0.33684098720550537, 0.09276893734931946, -0.8471041917800903, -0.6454966068267822, -0.1547662764787674, 0.39237144589424133, -0.036840688437223434, 0.1577269583940506, -0.19575591385364532, -0.3949079215526581, -0.37724998593330383, 0.2128533273935318, -0.06911265105009079, 0.6524736881256104, 0.8412778377532959, 0.5189678072929382, 0.25935977697372437, 0.44070926308631897, -0.006518441252410412, 0.779371440410614, -0.3013543486595154, -0.7872363328933716, -0.27020084857940674, 0.23302917182445526, -0.17054219543933868, 0.47377249598503113, 0.6387383937835693, 0.10349974036216736, -0.8556057810783386, -0.16257934272289276, 0.05589144304394722, -0.9178884625434875, 0.13890507817268372, 0.6305593252182007, -0.3541828691959381, 0.15826691687107086, 0.02002606727182865, 0.32745787501335144, 0.7172556519508362, 0.7927165031433105, -0.25422972440719604, -0.7457892298698425, 1.0377302169799805, 0.5464850068092346, -0.24480056762695312, 0.3238886594772339, -0.4879622459411621, 0.42370232939720154, -0.6517722010612488, -0.09583475440740585, -0.08793798834085464, 0.6752052307128906, -0.20116859674453735, 0.3021447956562042, 0.28006085753440857, -0.10025642067193985, -0.28365182876586914, 0.11242062598466873, 0.8165072798728943, 0.395306795835495, -0.9802119135856628, -0.5679458379745483, 0.41577401757240295, 0.7190511226654053, -0.1149795651435852, -0.7456576824188232, -0.05859503895044327, -0.3562382757663727, -0.38486674427986145, -0.5277462601661682, 0.7185215950012207, -0.032481562346220016, -0.13167347013950348, -0.5732994079589844, -0.06384449452161789, 0.11069180071353912, -0.41055190563201904, -0.5433490872383118, -0.09384779632091522, 0.34698155522346497, 0.883967399597168, 0.5545437335968018, 0.5563973188400269, -0.9935764670372009, -0.7449930906295776, -0.1379343569278717, 0.3603515326976776, -0.239406019449234, 0.24102695286273956, 0.29526251554489136, 0.6890535354614258, -0.30578961968421936, 0.36004143953323364, 0.14121800661087036, -0.5456470847129822, 0.5020151138305664, 0.2793835997581482, 0.16311043500900269, -0.5325537919998169, -0.34361496567726135, -0.004429872613400221, 0.6164822578430176, -0.18214039504528046, 0.5047507286071777, 0.15083812177181244, 0.34117555618286133, -0.5092737674713135, -0.3605314791202545, -0.2247321605682373, 0.6792718768119812, 0.0729789286851883, -0.2592647075653076, -0.33043989539146423, -0.6018871665000916, 4.215323448181152, 0.3472575545310974, 0.7050395607948303, -0.6971794962882996, 0.8490942716598511, 1.0037188529968262, 0.33115193247795105, -0.5207220911979675, 0.40962961316108704, 0.004335788544267416, -0.19538477063179016, -0.0645514652132988, 0.9199464917182922, 0.5921201705932617, 0.04059351608157158, 0.5936020612716675, -0.4516228437423706, -0.5091720819473267, 0.5728317499160767, -0.8149363994598389, -0.8053380846977234, 0.025163164362311363, 0.007417666260153055, 0.20540206134319305, 0.5468449592590332, 0.38857197761535645, -0.2024829238653183, -0.11823083460330963, -0.18273364007472992, -0.0870688185095787, -0.6139702200889587, -0.6143772602081299, 0.7239494323730469, 0.08024749904870987, -0.3688925504684448, 0.3532397449016571, 0.18688057363033295, -0.7616307139396667, -0.006527113262563944, 0.11731686443090439, -0.4578433036804199, -0.25523990392684937, -0.4638949930667877, 0.1297241598367691, -0.1271464228630066, 0.9116921424865723, 0.3317287266254425, 0.2679581046104431, 0.7366934418678284, -0.6018016934394836, 0.9185219407081604, 0.10764475166797638, -0.17148452997207642, -0.32172489166259766, -0.971916913986206, -0.09192252159118652, -0.2899889647960663, -0.4714595377445221, -0.8042073845863342, -0.262648344039917, 1.0776870250701904, -0.7465827465057373, -0.5943976640701294, 0.8341429829597473, -0.18175797164440155, 0.379999577999115, 0.2575207054615021, -0.15037450194358826, -0.34661534428596497, -0.21468394994735718, -0.29705512523651123, 0.10819795727729797, -0.4022136926651001, 0.025410639122128487, 0.17628709971904755, 0.45322850346565247, 0.08259690552949905, -0.5170927047729492, 0.151572585105896, 0.6074585914611816, -0.30191776156425476, 0.0394597165286541, -0.48597434163093567, 0.7374849319458008, -0.056506168097257614, 0.6990833282470703, -0.024733688682317734, -0.6842226982116699, 0.4962306320667267, 0.7716099619865417, 0.22631357610225677, 0.5604916214942932, -0.14603769779205322, 0.1117975264787674, 0.02753046713769436 ]
Two Populations and Models of Gamma Ray Bursts
Gamma-ray burst statistics are best explained by a source population at cosmological distances, while spectroscopy and intensity histories of some individual bursts imply an origin on Galactic neutron stars. To resolve this inconsistency I suggest the presence of two populations, one at cosmological distances and the other Galactic. I build on ideas of Shemi and Piran (1990) and of M\'esz\'aros and Rees (1993) involving the interaction of fireball debris with surrounding clouds to explain the observed intensity histories in bursts at cosmological distances. The distances to the Galactic population are undetermined because they are too few to affect the statistics of intensity and direction; I explain them as resulting from magnetic reconnection in neutron star magnetospheres.
J. I. Katz
astro-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9212006
cond-mat/9204001
[ -0.19486621022224426, 0.364584356546402, -0.24180391430854797, 0.413790762424469, 0.024864979088306427, -0.3095957934856415, 0.014481395483016968, -0.6655527949333191, -0.36480045318603516, 1.593130350112915, 0.848210871219635, 0.10261371731758118, 0.8439173102378845, -1.302260398864746, 0.39327266812324524, 0.17146745324134827, -0.7587709426879883, -0.6416842341423035, -0.6007249355316162, -0.03133269399404526, 0.3284531831741333, -0.01168044377118349, -0.9936216473579407, -0.6767533421516418, -0.6306060552597046, 0.4887540638446808, -0.5746070742607117, 0.25893715023994446, 1.0635701417922974, 1.2100677490234375, 0.5646275281906128, -0.4893345534801483, -0.3906100392341614, -0.8997504711151123, -0.3591131865978241, -0.2130182683467865, 0.0600411631166935, 0.6656644940376282, 0.5955535769462585, -0.21414755284786224, 1.0411819219589233, -0.1963476538658142, 0.7399024963378906, 0.263788104057312, -0.9789465069770813, -0.2750804126262665, -0.7796350121498108, -0.6871218681335449, -0.2638935446739197, -1.2923661470413208, 0.4608798027038574, 0.38745859265327454, 0.810019314289093, -0.1773424744606018, -0.2954077124595642, 0.012492291629314423, 0.5428304672241211, 0.46701040863990784, -0.43765977025032043, -0.8171514868736267, 0.6383141279220581, -0.18857133388519287, 0.7219989895820618, -1.12796950340271, 0.5386655926704407, 0.08750220388174057, -0.43522703647613525, 0.45728516578674316, -0.38176682591438293, -0.5534912943840027, -0.8583717346191406, -0.2262393981218338, -0.053049977868795395, -0.5459457039833069, -0.4068509340286255, 0.4808206260204315, -0.049762532114982605, -0.7993716597557068, -1.4216161966323853, -0.1281059831380844, -0.40965309739112854, -0.3757811188697815, -0.16325153410434723, 0.0552695207297802, 0.25690269470214844, 0.031483761966228485, -0.2371794730424881, -0.13460184633731842, -0.16471929848194122, 0.2924700677394867, 0.1357538104057312, 1.2034226655960083, 0.00046292704064399004, 0.24633921682834625, 0.6257532238960266, 0.9873738288879395, 0.07198689877986908, 0.8031516075134277, 0.7626703977584839, 0.27495670318603516, -0.6286283731460571, 0.29702839255332947, -0.6116931438446045, 0.7683892846107483, -0.5185341835021973, 0.8748159408569336, 0.21449944376945496, -0.2375941425561905, -0.5284152626991272, -0.6346163153648376, -0.004228677600622177, 0.31831496953964233, 1.0623825788497925, 0.8730844259262085, -0.10700991749763489, 0.5569693446159363, -0.21720848977565765, -0.15503261983394623, -0.6699029207229614, -0.04176722466945648, 0.22887888550758362, -0.18362398445606232, 0.511999249458313, 0.2892008125782013, 0.286665141582489, -0.8193966150283813, 0.5892322659492493, 0.508749783039093, -0.2916599214076996, -0.41581425070762634, 0.03934783488512039, -0.31161096692085266, 0.39193499088287354, 0.596329927444458, -0.44084596633911133, -0.1494913548231125, 0.006470132153481245, 0.37052521109580994, 0.21326462924480438, -0.13022471964359283, 0.7733513712882996, -0.9833824634552002, 0.3871159255504608, 0.4523645043373108, 0.1392984539270401, -0.16468486189842224, 0.6846314072608948, 0.46143656969070435, -0.08374267816543579, 0.8476859927177429, -0.3904774785041809, -0.14033648371696472, 0.04852815344929695, 0.4110970199108124, 0.4123959541320801, 0.3558040261268616, -0.4235362410545349, 1.1324870586395264, -0.6541864275932312, -0.2250535935163498, 0.8199977874755859, -0.016724560409784317, -0.13010697066783905, 0.15419259667396545, -0.7242907285690308, -0.12281855195760727, -0.48054125905036926, -0.7457617521286011, 0.6221414804458618, -0.4542161226272583, -0.42278045415878296, 0.4166368544101715, -0.6177323460578918, 0.5253639817237854, 0.07486032694578171, -0.4815700352191925, 0.5429944396018982, 0.4514848589897156, 0.5265566110610962, 0.5133429169654846, -0.505219042301178, 0.01612989977002144, 1.2372833490371704, -0.17447271943092346, -0.3967141807079315, -0.025879858061671257, -0.8923431634902954, -0.7234768271446228, 0.2540155351161957, 0.22229675948619843, -0.48246631026268005, 0.12040381133556366, -0.253525048494339, -0.018958156928420067, -0.30535557866096497, -0.634072482585907, -1.0601861476898193, 0.7492687702178955, -0.0969914123415947, -0.8206596374511719, -0.7897894978523254, 0.09087260067462921, -0.5526883602142334, 0.40833353996276855, -0.8820732235908508, 0.48993948101997375, 0.46290916204452515, 0.3898966908454895, -0.6457356214523315, 0.09404322504997253, 0.41913989186286926, -0.45833620429039, 0.5174591541290283, 0.6997388005256653, 0.15673436224460602, -0.2249099463224411, -0.4306285083293915, 0.17449983954429626, 0.8067977428436279, -0.12497813999652863, 0.7028135657310486, 0.1105949878692627, 0.26591771841049194, 0.7126299738883972, -0.18687155842781067, -0.15307123959064484, 0.28911131620407104, 0.09035603702068329, -0.010226713493466377, -0.27624455094337463, 0.4211637079715729, 0.5179204940795898, -0.14954081177711487, 0.07643767446279526, 0.7195276021957397, 0.698777973651886, 0.0808660164475441, 0.9565203785896301, 0.302447110414505, 0.16547103226184845, -0.5881368517875671, 0.2198406159877777, 0.4599705934524536, -0.362521231174469, -0.2785300016403198, 0.17202936112880707, -0.7512301802635193, -0.11746972054243088, -0.9503558278083801, 0.530102014541626, 0.03868706896901131, 0.8936179876327515, 0.4072081446647644, 0.2887148857116699, -1.1809941530227661, -0.33983156085014343, -0.036411602050065994, -0.13334773480892181, -0.23480458557605743, 0.03006119467318058, 0.21930629014968872, 0.1726662963628769, -0.1176934614777565, -0.42349910736083984, 0.46988874673843384, 0.3678947985172272, -0.2540733218193054, 0.3687637448310852, -0.3189929127693176, -0.034343983978033066, -0.8719726204872131, -0.45752397179603577, -0.6154138445854187, 0.14449025690555573, -0.36711159348487854, 0.043655797839164734, 1.0915396213531494, -0.9938474893569946, 0.41381657123565674, 0.2190817892551422, 0.35909026861190796, 0.30594372749328613, 0.052036430686712265, 0.7767056822776794, 0.696830153465271, 0.12292733788490295, -0.7284440398216248, 0.06491412222385406, -0.7758586406707764, 0.041982073336839676, -0.4738079309463501, 0.7946888208389282, 0.6251007318496704, -0.20212236046791077, 0.31483227014541626, -0.7792409658432007, -0.7203742265701294, -0.42573660612106323, -0.4604644775390625, -0.000018554681446403265, -0.23578107357025146, 0.20071950554847717, -0.9231199622154236, -0.1682845652103424, -0.29749730229377747, 1.2898061275482178, 0.4136491119861603, -0.38252779841423035, 0.6147749423980713, 0.504797101020813, 0.1596856415271759, 0.19888491928577423, -0.03479859232902527, 0.40571197867393494, 0.25563862919807434, 1.3362460136413574, 1.233449935913086, -0.3067502975463867, -0.4065845310688019, -0.8208585977554321, -0.6832405924797058, 0.09556961804628372, -0.08898316323757172, -1.1183807849884033, -0.03830115869641304, 1.1514697074890137, 0.452389657497406, -0.8703942894935608, 0.005886686034500599, -1.2275316715240479, -0.9172173738479614, 0.12297458946704865, -0.14094550907611847, 0.6260803937911987, -0.4382106065750122, 0.2970145642757416, -0.6240779757499695, 0.10836807638406754, 0.7773067355155945, 0.19179771840572357, 0.2520156502723694, -0.3842836320400238, 0.28866949677467346, 0.21561075747013092, 0.028367625549435616, 0.41066938638687134, -0.03283616155385971, -0.16948235034942627, 0.29095351696014404, 0.8160980939865112, -0.7865570187568665, -0.07337354123592377, 0.493091881275177, 0.8478572964668274, 0.686754584312439, 0.5362441539764404, -0.5720568299293518, -0.4710094630718231, -0.6327521204948425, -0.40268567204475403, 0.4178553521633148, 0.36114832758903503, -0.7298449873924255, 0.13311821222305298, -0.4459918737411499, -0.40575093030929565, 0.45329126715660095, 0.3231639564037323, 0.3832864761352539, -0.7345505356788635, 0.7838046550750732, 0.4381469786167145, -0.3173174560070038, 0.20566783845424652, -0.40944918990135193, -0.12694840133190155, -0.0881425216794014, 0.5031864643096924, 0.8797231912612915, -1.1588234901428223, -0.51454097032547, 0.05504585802555084, 1.5813052654266357, 0.8326563239097595, 0.5925692319869995, 0.7966660857200623, 0.04708267003297806, 0.4179159104824066, -0.23867399990558624, -0.3271405100822449, -0.3156278133392334, -0.027394907549023628, -0.5279965400695801, -0.44881802797317505, 0.12975943088531494, 0.28898921608924866, 0.808718740940094, 0.7780055999755859, 0.40529748797416687, 0.035233382135629654, 0.5741456747055054, 0.45998260378837585, 0.5746491551399231, 0.40405839681625366, -0.3484456539154053, -0.43893301486968994, -1.156524419784546, 0.07915137708187103, 0.23069924116134644, 0.2990769147872925, -0.011364754289388657, -0.11867891997098923, -0.624819278717041, -0.7638599872589111, 0.3357235789299011, 0.41168487071990967, -0.05078448727726936, 0.7103898525238037, 0.46113741397857666, 0.14486092329025269, -0.5070701241493225, 0.35725513100624084, -0.03847644478082657, 0.1967022866010666, 0.5897050499916077, -0.8185442686080933, -0.05808364227414131, -0.3496483266353607, 0.5746901035308838, 1.0871750116348267, -0.7240417003631592, -0.41158175468444824, -0.6335608959197998, 0.5815918445587158, -0.5558987855911255, -0.4024335741996765, 0.7114895582199097, -0.15514621138572693, 0.1920345276594162, 0.24459640681743622, -0.2815788984298706, 0.4027305543422699, -0.6132086515426636, -0.06526488810777664, -0.04202272370457649, -0.4808675944805145, -1.0885932445526123, -0.30824190378189087, -0.24578048288822174, 0.2526314854621887, 0.12221688777208328, -0.5883325338363647, -0.3280177712440491, 0.046034421771764755, -0.6932370662689209, -0.6021464467048645, -0.37594568729400635, -0.840886116027832, 0.6986619234085083, -0.0632934421300888, 0.3649674355983734, -0.04762205854058266, 0.29593706130981445, -0.12869468331336975, -0.07112641632556915, 0.26714637875556946, -0.403489351272583, 0.4453052580356598, 0.8520004749298096, 0.23182463645935059, 0.7225626707077026, 1.0157561302185059, -0.3460780084133148, 0.23569700121879578, 0.04002130776643753, 0.1020893007516861, -0.36785951256752014, -0.3167297840118408, -0.1529082953929901, -0.5713539719581604, -0.8263416290283203, 0.6511610746383667, -0.4565539062023163, 1.2027816772460938, 0.15143921971321106, -1.0618706941604614, -1.1215685606002808, 0.5010514855384827, -1.0567078590393066, 0.2216065227985382, -0.39596182107925415, -0.5303078889846802, 0.5257294178009033, 0.1274394392967224, -0.28054219484329224, 0.8472040891647339, 0.033707406371831894, -0.8666185140609741, 0.30084311962127686, -0.009158750995993614, -0.705772340297699, 0.3985466957092285, -0.5746808052062988, 0.729060173034668, -0.6903353929519653, 0.4192787706851959, -0.02660379372537136, -0.42775484919548035, -0.2761481702327728, 0.19505123794078827, -0.2789040505886078, -0.37966006994247437, -0.3063809275627136, -0.23502235114574432, 0.426938533782959, -0.39782798290252686, 0.4347645938396454, -0.20891226828098297, -0.9386476874351501, 0.4301385283470154, -0.21656496822834015, -0.19940045475959778, 0.026994014158844948, 1.2626128196716309, 0.11803008615970612, 0.016036711633205414, 0.07241055369377136, -0.5506404638290405, 0.011391500942409039, 0.16427114605903625, -0.19449248909950256, -1.3447670936584473, 0.1769193559885025, -0.5859665274620056, -0.08472142368555069, -0.13074494898319244, 0.6348658800125122, 0.020492831245064735, -0.47903165221214294, -0.102385014295578, -0.34518173336982727, 0.0008996531832963228, -0.30062755942344666, 0.049851931631565094, -0.21645516157150269, -0.944678008556366, -0.5582326650619507, 0.5958234071731567, -0.2014501839876175, 0.3708130419254303, 0.9866759181022644, -0.2149296998977661, -0.5126380920410156, 0.4829103946685791, -0.2506908178329468, -0.276896595954895, -0.5572240948677063, 0.6499035358428955, 0.0656532272696495, -0.1486431211233139, -0.7233718037605286, 0.24730466306209564, -1.3698844909667969, 0.2522551715373993, -0.013685551472008228, -0.06179230660200119, 0.056928154081106186, -0.4250582754611969, 0.5963594913482666, -0.8033310174942017, 0.21665437519550323, 0.4428443908691406, 0.07522664964199066, 0.6156535148620605, 0.044664714485406876, -0.2774356007575989, -0.6683388352394104, -0.8631593585014343, -0.5589144825935364, 1.0160762071609497, 0.20283207297325134, 0.08200488239526749, -0.13480909168720245, -1.187045693397522, 0.23118329048156738, -0.21091388165950775, 0.3509330451488495, -0.41213393211364746, -0.2933995723724365, -0.18385083973407745, 0.44504034519195557, 0.38731855154037476, -0.24378345906734467, -0.3263256549835205, 0.10494726896286011, 0.006417366210371256, -0.14697174727916718, 0.05451677739620209, -0.02365156263113022, -0.8449929356575012, 0.011127634905278683, 0.22811730206012726, 0.25770804286003113, -0.21294072270393372, 0.4589790999889374, -0.3353979289531708, -0.39496278762817383, -0.42537543177604675, -0.0014780365163460374, -0.3858839273452759, 0.49252626299858093, 0.8927173018455505, 0.03907692804932594, -0.034089017659425735, 0.01877702958881855, 1.1989898681640625, -0.7849473357200623, 0.2247677594423294, 0.393993079662323, -0.6253365874290466, -0.5640585422515869, -0.13727261126041412, 0.4204728901386261, -0.1621631532907486, -0.5332330465316772, -1.044064998626709, -0.33820775151252747, 0.06430663168430328, -0.7583714127540588, 0.32951924204826355, -0.8339431881904602, -0.7333730459213257, 0.0733393132686615, 0.39363282918930054, -0.24731585383415222, -0.08027729392051697, 0.1868807077407837, -0.5247200131416321, -0.26588091254234314, -0.531245231628418, 0.909879744052887, -0.16512294113636017, -0.2410513013601303, -0.4833121597766876, -0.6086919903755188, -0.5481921434402466, 0.1560927927494049, 0.17673394083976746, -0.40037038922309875, 0.26235121488571167, 0.4109854996204376, 1.201053500175476, 0.3794635236263275, 0.2778247892856598, 0.22170040011405945, -0.5018872022628784, -0.004941724240779877, -0.3940723240375519, -0.45153161883354187, -0.1265350580215454, 0.445266455411911, 0.6885969638824463, -0.5387686491012573, 0.3246244490146637, 0.19825495779514313, -0.35727301239967346, -0.3800925612449646, -0.7718561291694641, 0.2472706139087677, -0.9248059391975403, -0.7469868063926697, -0.8445287942886353, -0.5090939998626709, 0.2157471626996994, 0.31648823618888855, -0.4005223214626312, -0.6798419952392578, -1.4005451202392578, 0.007508414331823587, 0.19016264379024506, 0.08176802843809128, 0.2254227101802826, -0.301146000623703, -1.0717880725860596, 0.33956393599510193, -0.2604854106903076, 0.050268806517124176, -0.08655449748039246, -0.469136506319046, -0.36064019799232483, 0.11098174750804901, -0.1827247142791748, 1.2088253498077393, -0.3975844979286194, -0.022366870194673538, -0.2220422923564911, 0.2523570656776428, -0.38801828026771545, -0.4258362352848053, -0.15309520065784454, 0.08663147687911987, -0.22494877874851227, 0.039405904710292816, 0.49453073740005493, 0.81119704246521, -0.7146190404891968, -0.10424903780221939, -0.632764995098114, -0.31441155076026917, -0.1261437088251114, -1.1128466129302979, -0.02372612990438938, 0.1677706390619278, -0.82658451795578, 0.055759645998477936, -1.159144639968872, 0.05110756307840347, -0.09574556350708008, 0.0357535183429718, -0.10685182362794876, 0.968021035194397, -0.4544700086116791, 0.8559643030166626, -0.6216314435005188, -0.4949849247932434, -0.2550635039806366, 0.26412710547447205, -0.17191743850708008, 1.1003903150558472, -0.4977818429470062, -0.3664487302303314, -0.20605890452861786, -0.016891755163669586, -0.49541547894477844, 0.32620084285736084, -0.7829470634460449, -0.059098247438669205, -0.37412935495376587, -0.6443281769752502, -0.06439428776502609, 0.48577362298965454, 0.1156853586435318, 0.01846725307404995, -0.8843043446540833, -0.39038243889808655, -0.5396209359169006, 0.3160930275917053, -0.14781048893928528, -0.21042978763580322, -0.32222631573677063, -0.2924979329109192, 0.6551293730735779, -0.08858206123113632, 0.05736992508172989, 0.5433489680290222, -0.1311105638742447, -0.1846867799758911, -0.471347451210022, -0.13186851143836975, -0.0877770408987999, 0.06316500157117844, -0.361358642578125, -0.3875274360179901, -0.36928993463516235, 0.22283108532428741, -0.03559204563498497, -0.7395151853561401, -0.5119178295135498, 1.0789661407470703, -0.37756142020225525, 0.15558867156505585, -0.4245370328426361, -0.35230210423469543, 0.003947895485907793, 0.7308745980262756, -0.3929602801799774, 0.03628179058432579, 0.18266524374485016, 0.977695882320404, -0.14714479446411133, -0.4713621437549591, 1.040519118309021, 0.31565752625465393, 0.02254057489335537, -0.42723867297172546, -0.5625411868095398, 0.7633944749832153, 0.4409997761249542, -0.5890330076217651, 1.0282152891159058, -0.07117725163698196, 0.5724858045578003, -0.3957485854625702, -0.12505848705768585, -0.13764816522598267, 0.48567652702331543, 0.23702400922775269, 0.48893848061561584, 0.7372012734413147, 0.24879679083824158, 0.30771470069885254, -0.2866800129413605, 0.46073049306869507, -0.2482803612947464, 0.40864256024360657, 0.09320895373821259, 0.6211012005805969, -0.09773705899715424, 0.7356601357460022, 0.0757421925663948, 0.4203259348869324, 0.5055122375488281, 0.21737131476402283, -0.3910916745662689, 0.05743745341897011, 0.20743487775325775, 0.28618189692497253, -0.7299606800079346, -0.12012987583875656, -0.34726598858833313, 0.024119151756167412, -0.32373401522636414, 0.034740447998046875, -0.05234891176223755, -0.015089825727045536, 0.7990149259567261, 0.5580671429634094, 0.30601438879966736, 0.5178983211517334, 0.5237017273902893, 0.03831830993294716, 0.44780808687210083, 1.3634209632873535, 0.4943627417087555, 0.6746799349784851, 0.5026523470878601, -0.9456637501716614, 0.037103768438100815, 0.6737212538719177, -0.9504210352897644, 0.03730640932917595, -0.3812255561351776, 0.07279203087091446, -0.1975022852420807, -0.9374983310699463, 0.2224830538034439, -1.1194181442260742, 0.2541194260120392, 0.9517603516578674, -0.5351311564445496, 0.6633263230323792, 0.5940383076667786, -0.0544825941324234, 0.12228622287511826, 0.9595028162002563, -0.09593687206506729, -0.24820993840694427, 1.1359679698944092, 0.6497474312782288, -0.3984471559524536, 0.41975530982017517, 0.14179663360118866, -0.2669481337070465, 0.0547834150493145, -0.48053231835365295, -0.14935140311717987, 0.7789275646209717, -0.23370662331581116, -0.7507062554359436, 0.6995254158973694, 0.054690536111593246, 0.15829896926879883, -0.07946880161762238, -0.2075645625591278, 0.3531631827354431, -0.23694899678230286, 0.1213642880320549, 1.1271467208862305, 0.14079099893569946, 0.3859773576259613, -0.5517404079437256, -0.37258926033973694, -0.01470204722136259, 0.34453070163726807, -1.088581919670105, 0.7138159871101379, -0.009130299091339111, 0.20834039151668549, 0.19477134943008423, -0.15308120846748352, -0.2709851861000061, -0.40861138701438904, -0.23025965690612793, -0.8532047867774963, 0.8455792665481567, -0.4120165705680847, 0.9108684659004211, 0.5184066891670227, -0.5918408036231995, 0.19320476055145264, 0.38349074125289917, 0.9295057654380798, 0.18998558819293976, 0.20987921953201294, 1.0570460557937622, 0.4814291298389435, -0.722492516040802, 0.9041510820388794, 0.5130848288536072, -0.61517333984375, 0.7868043780326843, -0.2786238193511963, 0.11551593989133835, 0.5125488638877869, 0.3158435523509979, 0.3567894697189331, -0.13255058228969574, 0.2079160362482071, -0.22008733451366425, -0.21014893054962158, -0.6449026465415955, -0.6305551528930664, -0.2739901840686798, -0.9966942071914673, -0.16851207613945007, -0.13350333273410797, 0.5962800979614258, 0.3837512135505676, -0.12188677489757538, 4.032341003417969, 1.429824948310852, 0.1960596740245819, 0.32047954201698303, -0.0031922615598887205, 0.8091099262237549, -0.15762381255626678, -0.2752632200717926, -0.10860864073038101, -0.6121802926063538, 0.20979605615139008, 0.36846089363098145, -0.2873348295688629, -0.225804403424263, -0.5253591537475586, 0.5242239236831665, -0.0001662731810938567, 0.034742437303066254, -0.641990065574646, -1.20343816280365, -0.2390795201063156, 0.3201417028903961, 0.24172759056091309, -0.8563674688339233, 0.06328308582305908, -0.17605213820934296, -0.11663651466369629, -0.4516555368900299, -0.3800410032272339, -0.13849589228630066, -0.5790173411369324, -0.9006590843200684, 0.03258749470114708, 0.3468071222305298, -0.4696632921695709, 0.05949004366993904, 0.3495234251022339, -0.5595779418945312, 0.14284858107566833, 0.700421929359436, 0.08365984261035919, -0.15203066170215607, -0.30917325615882874, -0.05888693407177925, -1.5738121271133423, 0.5764477252960205, 0.28717920184135437, 1.2144485712051392, -0.030661581084132195, 0.0804823711514473, 0.3552440106868744, -0.03695012256503105, 0.24214886128902435, 0.08504260331392288, -1.014811396598816, 0.39030560851097107, -0.7369705438613892, -0.16350984573364258, 0.10843004286289215, -0.03760692477226257, 1.2945475578308105, 0.2372971922159195, -0.4179610311985016, 0.011404120363295078, 0.3723738193511963, 1.046819806098938, 0.7612519860267639, 0.18540550768375397, -0.4977940618991852, -0.5690735578536987, -0.19564612209796906, -0.14328689873218536, -1.3450566530227661, 0.23193618655204773, 0.1781536340713501, 0.16620895266532898, -0.37159478664398193, 0.516147792339325, 0.18755416572093964, 0.125727578997612, 0.33598053455352783, -0.1638355404138565, -0.37409690022468567, -0.09654892235994339, -0.12513451278209686, 0.6333569884300232, -0.12677352130413055, 0.4086945950984955, -0.1256512701511383, 0.238105908036232, -0.02209879830479622, 1.4308515787124634, 0.01457221806049347, -0.3136827051639557, -0.48256686329841614 ]
Universal quantum critical dynamics of two-dimensional antiferromagnets
The universal dynamic and static properties of two dimensional antiferromagnets in the vicinity of a zero-temperature phase transition from long-range magnetic order to a quantum disordered phase are studied. Random antiferromagnets with both N\'{e}el and spin-glass long-range magnetic order are considered. Explicit quantum-critical dynamic scaling functions are computed in a 1/N expansion to two-loops for certain non-random, frustrated square lattice antiferromagnets. Implications for neutron scattering experiments on the doped cuprates are noted.
Subir Sachdev and Jinwu Ye
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204001
cond-mat/9204002
[ -0.2436605840921402, 0.017493199557065964, 0.10437724739313126, -0.18107780814170837, 0.11864122003316879, -0.27979278564453125, 0.0015071238158270717, -0.5351938605308533, -0.9736072421073914, 1.6719874143600464, -0.03970273956656456, -0.35343611240386963, -0.06918312609195709, -0.9616398215293884, -0.4216270446777344, 0.1519477218389511, 0.16930775344371796, -0.3261851966381073, -1.4059959650039673, 0.0371018685400486, 0.7329484224319458, 0.15582717955112457, -0.3465377986431122, -0.6874809861183167, 0.02259870618581772, 0.84010910987854, 0.6821686625480652, 0.727504551410675, 1.2102874517440796, 0.49193549156188965, 0.659507155418396, -0.4102465808391571, -0.5436270833015442, -0.7581923007965088, -0.2777651250362396, -0.08834753185510635, -0.4680308997631073, -0.34832268953323364, 0.8462414741516113, -0.05280459672212601, 0.8904144763946533, -0.003122274298220873, 0.3841622471809387, -0.05818060413002968, 0.1751021295785904, 0.1255519539117813, -0.4671344459056854, -0.14630527794361115, -0.2160792052745819, -1.217754602432251, 0.23699918389320374, 0.2314724177122116, 1.3770267963409424, -0.7896850109100342, 0.048469655215740204, -0.9530146718025208, 0.19557948410511017, 0.7527219653129578, 0.2844248116016388, -0.22395242750644684, 0.4169585406780243, 0.31604504585266113, 0.08261050283908844, -1.056504249572754, 0.3351215422153473, 0.757312536239624, -0.13142569363117218, 1.14824378490448, -0.5475170016288757, -0.9131969809532166, -0.4131994843482971, -0.17238762974739075, -0.7254251837730408, -0.145183727145195, -0.3501885235309601, 0.1150621622800827, -0.19274690747261047, -0.8440957069396973, -0.8141311407089233, -0.6899605989456177, -0.12479761242866516, -0.06766712665557861, -0.23487859964370728, 0.40286239981651306, -0.49792996048927307, 0.2815071940422058, -0.2354200780391693, -0.12701378762722015, -0.04812758043408394, 0.11422272771596909, 0.818709135055542, 1.1939735412597656, -0.23428158462047577, -0.33171185851097107, 0.5178784728050232, 0.9464797377586365, 0.47197335958480835, 0.02972736395895481, -0.042527470737695694, 0.3768542408943176, 0.02236303687095642, 0.6538243293762207, -0.09129688143730164, 0.8048405647277832, -0.5271435976028442, 0.4471876323223114, -0.4094648063182831, -0.009580266661942005, -0.27593696117401123, -0.15593448281288147, 0.19252683222293854, -0.6535648107528687, 0.7645717859268188, 1.1881624460220337, 0.43435361981391907, 0.009863435290753841, 0.23525463044643402, 0.022920986637473106, -1.0873855352401733, -0.2611072063446045, 0.5131068825721741, -0.2709200978279114, 0.8452812433242798, 0.8656135201454163, -0.4526990056037903, -0.09103972464799881, 0.5530572533607483, 0.22731000185012817, -0.3789108693599701, 0.1515728235244751, 0.8673811554908752, -0.30850183963775635, 0.3491462469100952, -0.2897254228591919, -0.6375190019607544, 0.12453301250934601, -0.5035863518714905, -0.005981888622045517, 0.5964401960372925, -0.8737636804580688, 0.19738472998142242, -0.7964003086090088, 0.48950323462486267, 1.123777151107788, 0.2785429358482361, 0.6441578269004822, -0.3092045485973358, 0.08027388155460358, 0.09651371091604233, 0.2044103741645813, 0.053441066294908524, 0.19309979677200317, -0.5997450947761536, 0.37914329767227173, -0.5985374450683594, 0.46636587381362915, -0.5203071236610413, 0.825546383857727, -0.512136697769165, -0.6336729526519775, 0.05760509893298149, -0.08126037567853928, 0.08824564516544342, 0.22646309435367584, -0.13045871257781982, 0.27241209149360657, -0.29999983310699463, -0.46607285737991333, -0.3147028684616089, -0.1336778700351715, -0.03134489059448242, -0.1534242331981659, 0.040197208523750305, 0.5618350505828857, 0.6769106388092041, -0.06299194693565369, 0.8108965158462524, -0.6428011655807495, -0.5354295372962952, -0.026526611298322678, -0.021961066871881485, -0.623601496219635, 0.6709438562393188, 0.3935415744781494, -0.462747186422348, -0.18956789374351501, -0.4560546875, -0.10839765518903732, -0.1791144162416458, -0.399946928024292, -0.399630606174469, 0.17270559072494507, -0.2585417926311493, 0.10839136689901352, -0.9038010239601135, 0.5194088816642761, -0.8920742869377136, 0.2976304888725281, -0.3167501389980316, 0.30411067605018616, -0.25273075699806213, 0.31960150599479675, -0.7347825169563293, -0.2829384207725525, -1.3287700414657593, -0.14874105155467987, 0.42484551668167114, 0.6818388104438782, -0.4074293375015259, -0.008552458137273788, 0.20839765667915344, 0.03110235556960106, 0.014237472787499428, -0.20119965076446533, 0.15719936788082123, 0.48590320348739624, -0.4502463936805725, 0.244673952460289, 0.37279924750328064, 0.17932313680648804, 0.9235193133354187, 0.6209434866905212, -0.06101209297776222, 0.9058248996734619, -0.2927984297275543, -0.3364478349685669, 0.3487774729728699, 0.4867312014102936, 0.4264954924583435, -0.23365724086761475, 0.2539990246295929, 0.5605903267860413, 0.07768674939870834, 0.5698764324188232, 0.28072044253349304, 0.087303526699543, 0.6326624155044556, 0.6126472353935242, 0.5607369542121887, 0.40401145815849304, 0.00797668844461441, -0.2897791564464569, 0.5376860499382019, 0.10157565027475357, 0.021108023822307587, 0.036959849298000336, -0.5780724883079529, 0.1383240967988968, -1.10792076587677, 1.011147379875183, -0.6112868785858154, 0.4241400361061096, -0.14501966536045074, 0.3842601478099823, -1.4221913814544678, -0.22748145461082458, 0.3076349198818207, 0.14923053979873657, -0.14692825078964233, -0.29010480642318726, -0.06277060508728027, 0.2951906621456146, -0.28035038709640503, -0.8042453527450562, -0.6148707270622253, 0.6473976373672485, 0.07822414487600327, 0.4618982672691345, 0.5202519297599792, -0.24422146379947662, -0.8452137112617493, -0.29693424701690674, -1.1673003435134888, 0.02288382686674595, -1.1549466848373413, 0.044301003217697144, 0.6112107634544373, -0.7687435746192932, 1.0557973384857178, -0.10710016638040543, -0.5193941593170166, 0.48157039284706116, 0.44191721081733704, 0.4886581003665924, 0.6060245633125305, -0.011836830526590347, -0.9089502692222595, 0.09944971650838852, -0.8825871348381042, 0.5749347805976868, -0.6842945218086243, -0.1705833524465561, 0.8454843759536743, -0.5543104410171509, 0.15580077469348907, -0.7061144709587097, 0.07192118465900421, 0.1096619963645935, 0.19853103160858154, -0.5388597249984741, 0.030355602502822876, 0.5551329255104065, -0.19517332315444946, 0.07848483324050903, -1.4842908382415771, 0.7120949625968933, -0.020401112735271454, -0.4056674540042877, 0.5030704736709595, 0.05861315131187439, -0.5621906518936157, 0.6594959497451782, 0.41110360622406006, -0.26150816679000854, 0.11640138179063797, 0.4464510977268219, 0.3682376444339752, 0.1501079499721527, -0.0977751761674881, -0.37452664971351624, -0.5347509980201721, 0.42298078536987305, 0.5209974050521851, -0.5449422001838684, 0.09659776836633682, 0.8144900798797607, 0.40385982394218445, -0.8708499670028687, 0.2713310718536377, -1.2965141534805298, -0.3767136335372925, -0.15507179498672485, -0.4148639738559723, 0.5644563436508179, 0.07680246978998184, 0.0034923795610666275, -0.8202267289161682, 0.07056480646133423, 1.091226577758789, 0.9489992260932922, 0.3334384858608246, 0.1242942065000534, 0.6864421367645264, 0.1976601481437683, 0.36960992217063904, 0.08817975968122482, 0.3413104712963104, -0.7448344826698303, -0.6951349973678589, 0.4845687747001648, -0.5102186799049377, 0.4631587266921997, -0.1804417222738266, -0.030544864013791084, 0.5262207984924316, 0.38264206051826477, -0.32989710569381714, -0.41921770572662354, -0.8150206804275513, -0.22088979184627533, 0.29814282059669495, 0.8243687748908997, 0.19673800468444824, -0.34707000851631165, -0.7174205183982849, 0.02551569603383541, -0.013202514499425888, -0.2920791208744049, 0.7804986834526062, -0.5621069669723511, 0.26249203085899353, -0.07421092689037323, -0.38268181681632996, 0.47894832491874695, -0.5563896894454956, -0.004866930656135082, 0.27215710282325745, 0.4643317461013794, 0.5305437445640564, -0.5728045701980591, -0.5230406522750854, -0.794779360294342, 0.5437681674957275, 0.49222317337989807, 0.8047204613685608, -0.039278242737054825, -0.17420829832553864, 0.12688586115837097, -0.8085557818412781, -0.5606957077980042, -0.273571252822876, -0.12353173643350601, -0.3910762071609497, -0.17527642846107483, -0.05849865451455116, 0.3288777470588684, 0.3877028524875641, -0.2753477692604065, 0.7320822477340698, -0.0030187605880200863, 0.8690340518951416, 1.007460117340088, 0.5031435489654541, 0.672823429107666, -0.9360763430595398, 0.26794496178627014, -0.7570323944091797, 0.03116181306540966, 0.5150681734085083, 0.1872720718383789, -0.33236217498779297, -0.6109532713890076, -0.12277845293283463, -0.40135878324508667, 0.6724855899810791, 0.1764405220746994, -0.9032554626464844, -0.04443821683526039, 0.7374697923660278, 0.18556468188762665, -0.11304358392953873, 0.14730268716812134, 0.9600086808204651, 0.2430860549211502, 0.38962557911872864, -0.5121370553970337, 0.15591663122177124, 0.1427116096019745, 0.20944568514823914, 0.4262166917324066, -0.6515392661094666, -0.9312334656715393, -0.9462769031524658, 0.6505634784698486, -0.8104321360588074, -0.32491636276245117, 0.8110915422439575, 0.535149872303009, 0.3525688648223877, -0.5910201668739319, -0.4506921172142029, 0.8076770901679993, -0.33761537075042725, 0.1613723784685135, 0.016935497522354126, 0.03320801630616188, -0.08048214018344879, 0.9875107407569885, -0.25437578558921814, -0.6810144186019897, -0.023877695202827454, -0.18706582486629486, 0.7433081269264221, -0.1724003106355667, -0.28161224722862244, -0.004836427979171276, -0.15470950305461884, -0.27472320199012756, 0.4559086263179779, 0.11777001619338989, -0.15184232592582703, 0.5215317010879517, 0.6501115560531616, 0.2177988588809967, 0.0790102481842041, 0.7626010179519653, 0.22803471982479095, 1.2469125986099243, 0.5277287364006042, -0.18229323625564575, 0.12233606725931168, 0.20997820794582367, -0.0368867851793766, 0.0008364357054233551, 0.20125925540924072, -0.1210818886756897, -0.3841124176979065, -0.6306766867637634, -0.21633166074752808, -0.5075681805610657, -0.4342859387397766, 0.04047159478068352, -0.34539398550987244, 0.08201391249895096, 0.6695164442062378, -0.870894730091095, -0.25763413310050964, -0.4022122025489807, -0.7742017507553101, 0.12690716981887817, -0.031289152801036835, -0.11321975290775299, 0.4071815609931946, -0.10197973996400833, -0.17651401460170746, -0.5168091058731079, -0.5715347528457642, -0.3341093361377716, -0.1637592911720276, 0.46694186329841614, -0.0012283286778256297, 0.22872017323970795, -0.04232624173164368, 0.4205809235572815, -0.4260352849960327, 0.5246246457099915, -0.39652112126350403, -0.03242860734462738, -0.705974817276001, -0.12672081589698792, 0.39397531747817993, 0.023846754804253578, -0.2777509391307831, -0.19576339423656464, 0.5086000561714172, 0.4114156663417816, -0.3452872633934021, -0.4859972298145294, -0.4936743378639221, 0.6405635476112366, 0.13264106214046478, -0.11989939957857132, 0.02873450517654419, 0.7537702918052673, 0.0010919790947809815, 0.6122199892997742, 0.05159371718764305, -0.8001564145088196, 0.24344943463802338, -0.37204787135124207, 0.9562813639640808, -1.3202515840530396, -0.4844838082790375, 0.06672932952642441, 0.015693750232458115, 0.19965028762817383, 0.49264034628868103, -0.057724904268980026, -0.6108373999595642, -0.4883933663368225, -0.34783536195755005, -0.2580248713493347, -0.08356016874313354, 0.019858336076140404, -0.4684542715549469, -0.45682772994041443, -0.6358769536018372, 0.41096964478492737, -0.3258378803730011, 0.7788329720497131, 0.7186852693557739, 0.2690952718257904, -0.10675527155399323, 0.45947185158729553, 0.29548656940460205, -0.2371266782283783, -0.2802899479866028, 0.07510080188512802, 0.0753587931394577, 0.1892302930355072, -0.49944475293159485, 0.46093058586120605, -1.0042587518692017, 0.6608253121376038, 0.1119951605796814, -0.9245612621307373, 0.32011473178863525, 0.645124614238739, 1.066404938697815, -0.9210606217384338, 0.016756994649767876, 0.3071862459182739, 0.2326579988002777, 0.48621702194213867, 0.11991392076015472, -1.3680297136306763, -0.4955654442310333, -0.5705415606498718, -0.4546639919281006, 0.3736075460910797, 0.14927954971790314, 0.1632934808731079, -0.3513112962245941, -0.7060053944587708, -0.24797126650810242, -0.5985478162765503, 0.23223884403705597, 0.12715934216976166, 0.4758182168006897, 0.0709809958934784, -0.07507622987031937, 0.10344285517930984, -0.7770423889160156, 0.2900814116001129, 0.05677074193954468, -0.14387735724449158, 0.17458990216255188, 0.13880419731140137, -0.5197012424468994, -0.917813241481781, -0.12072094529867172, -0.12191249430179596, -0.16408401727676392, -0.11273809522390366, 0.6334139704704285, 0.2552071511745453, 0.04209655523300171, -0.23460471630096436, -0.2106889933347702, 0.11593873053789139, 0.43174830079078674, 0.5850690007209778, 0.40206974744796753, 0.7045033574104309, -0.05584859848022461, 0.26043927669525146, -0.41670170426368713, -0.2884126901626587, 0.8771827816963196, -0.4701351225376129, 0.23762695491313934, 0.7691025137901306, 0.7603581547737122, -0.7376240491867065, -0.7120318412780762, -0.4305368661880493, 0.034000687301158905, 0.3193676471710205, -0.26954615116119385, -0.11739270389080048, -0.20784611999988556, 0.2278805375099182, 0.2546391189098358, 0.751816987991333, 0.5035151243209839, 0.47475844621658325, 0.1632947474718094, -0.73240727186203, -0.32371535897254944, -0.0741901621222496, 1.4651089906692505, -0.5917354226112366, -0.951474666595459, -0.19405686855316162, -0.09798502177000046, -1.0133042335510254, 0.062337081879377365, 0.27960196137428284, -0.00918601918965578, -0.24938593804836273, 0.19129478931427002, -0.13823974132537842, 0.6586803197860718, 0.6647499799728394, -0.38867732882499695, -0.1860649138689041, 0.10264516621828079, -1.0887683629989624, -0.11637594550848007, 0.014234228059649467, 0.2864644527435303, -0.26362332701683044, -0.42572975158691406, -0.6381117701530457, -0.09146328270435333, -0.3772425353527069, -0.8482399582862854, -1.2825781106948853, -0.027589280158281326, -0.928632915019989, -0.011433186009526253, -0.9279929399490356, -0.2538009285926819, 0.17568302154541016, 0.1918419897556305, -0.20522527396678925, 0.4633139967918396, -0.5964235663414001, 0.2558182179927826, 0.16628678143024445, 0.7654792666435242, -0.5422855019569397, -1.1081159114837646, -0.4873523414134979, 0.23513911664485931, 0.15494228899478912, 0.06210489571094513, -0.47469857335090637, -0.39660555124282837, 0.21361280977725983, 0.1583019345998764, 0.2164347618818283, 0.63396155834198, -0.8183528780937195, -0.4289366602897644, -0.023802198469638824, -0.7076147794723511, -1.0204976797103882, 0.3531669080257416, 0.658612072467804, 0.5002325177192688, 0.8038504123687744, -0.0692346841096878, -0.23330438137054443, -0.09307838976383209, -0.1674180030822754, 0.006680972874164581, -0.4988183379173279, -0.30584120750427246, -0.18845346570014954, -0.32712459564208984, -0.05065985769033432, -0.09171335399150848, -0.7278499603271484, 0.29032188653945923, -0.5344789028167725, 0.16378669440746307, -0.3340531885623932, -0.010065941140055656, 0.006597556173801422, -0.2972145974636078, 0.18237583339214325, 1.0040969848632812, -0.088865265250206, 0.24895308911800385, 0.1391458958387375, -0.15052847564220428, -0.26262056827545166, 0.5933195352554321, 0.34852638840675354, -0.11750932782888412, -0.3855436146259308, 0.10426722466945648, 0.1367681920528412, 0.5093899369239807, -0.44669318199157715, -0.5996376276016235, -0.46456992626190186, -0.22568479180335999, -1.1837412118911743, 0.3111831247806549, 0.9037292003631592, -0.7719396948814392, -0.07341566681861877, -0.2682492434978485, -1.1360645294189453, 0.5687195062637329, 0.0019317850237712264, -0.6582146883010864, -0.1743430495262146, -0.1164645329117775, -0.4868144690990448, -0.04589071497321129, -0.41827505826950073, 0.3695814907550812, 0.03584335371851921, 0.7299802303314209, -0.14447642862796783, -0.5427148342132568, -0.07699175924062729, 0.12153267115354538, -0.840950608253479, -0.05283864960074425, -1.1821404695510864, 0.536675751209259, -0.2155996710062027, -0.8054421544075012, 0.08086676895618439, 0.1188892126083374, -0.23567362129688263, -0.19812270998954773, -0.23850856721401215, 0.09288594126701355, -0.11454419046640396, -0.16922052204608917, 0.07248153537511826, -0.4711502492427826, -0.5084969997406006, 0.48179325461387634, 0.24520710110664368, -0.185555100440979, 0.37331151962280273, 0.23685391247272491, 0.2694764733314514, -0.7469630837440491, -0.010806657373905182, 0.6954692602157593, -0.027801822870969772, -0.38979804515838623, -0.013898774981498718, 0.581265926361084, -0.6193501353263855, 0.3256717026233673, -0.6736705899238586, -0.07499941438436508, 0.00012583172065205872, 0.6331191658973694, 0.8770490288734436, 0.49706119298934937, 0.3875156342983246, -0.23958852887153625, 0.7143386602401733, 0.0761343389749527, 0.0225059911608696, 0.37215283513069153, 0.33386531472206116, 1.099002480506897, 0.17360065877437592, -0.20365263521671295, 0.0418415367603302, 0.09588324278593063, 0.2960264980792999, -0.2617289423942566, -0.37951231002807617, -0.22335919737815857, 0.345767617225647, -0.03864016383886337, -0.6587910056114197, -0.2492326945066452, -0.2350183129310608, -0.11932159215211868, 0.3053157925605774, 0.46723371744155884, 0.08236636221408844, 0.6934453845024109, 1.0930033922195435, -0.04828231781721115, 0.1262066811323166, 0.5120497345924377, 0.4673873782157898, 0.579590380191803, 0.404886931180954, 0.37463852763175964, 0.3750491440296173, 0.5344920754432678, 0.28183406591415405, -0.5719723701477051, 0.4748215675354004, 0.27879342436790466, -0.9266282320022583, -0.037863340228796005, 0.12969304621219635, -0.23789948225021362, 0.12221704423427582, -0.3073379099369049, 0.8703956007957458, -0.35740411281585693, 0.36791032552719116, 0.5269851088523865, -0.016276681795716286, -0.08647038042545319, 0.6648078560829163, -0.11758945882320404, 0.590794563293457, 0.10214979946613312, -0.09658907353878021, -0.30546796321868896, 0.5604302287101746, 1.2609893083572388, 0.1510237753391266, 0.6838880181312561, -0.18217681348323822, -0.09225280582904816, 0.15100988745689392, 0.9518967866897583, -0.3844040632247925, 0.37349599599838257, -0.842615008354187, 0.3397311866283417, -0.11438402533531189, 0.49817973375320435, -0.29405921697616577, 0.03834547847509384, 0.6215564608573914, 0.22356650233268738, -0.09804903715848923, 0.1880599558353424, 1.48671555519104, 0.4853792190551758, -0.7689104080200195, -0.364847332239151, -0.14442428946495056, -0.7967188954353333, -0.28023168444633484, -0.6790143847465515, 0.612644612789154, 0.17344026267528534, 0.18585744500160217, -0.14390701055526733, -0.5182631611824036, -0.2937544882297516, -0.7341035604476929, -0.29579487442970276, -1.0641868114471436, 0.04079578071832657, 0.012922991067171097, 0.23910441994667053, 0.16702306270599365, -0.720228374004364, -0.5602187514305115, -0.36052024364471436, 0.756714940071106, -0.10772743076086044, -0.17531882226467133, 0.675192654132843, -0.07108110934495926, -1.000188946723938, 0.44864949584007263, 0.6939834952354431, -0.5191404819488525, 0.6508386731147766, -0.8116049766540527, 0.15085092186927795, 0.0965317115187645, -0.03850725293159485, 0.11271433532238007, -0.1268398016691208, 0.29220741987228394, -0.40157318115234375, -0.41962793469429016, 0.19270028173923492, -1.0103731155395508, -0.42208459973335266, -0.8836324214935303, 0.5064471960067749, -0.22683970630168915, 0.37227898836135864, -0.05694898962974548, -0.24424704909324646, 4.17332649230957, 0.605098307132721, 1.0954105854034424, 0.31989187002182007, 0.8376215100288391, 1.2602447271347046, -0.6147308945655823, 0.4284518361091614, -0.01839323155581951, -0.976022481918335, -0.9125813841819763, 0.38895073533058167, 0.002513590967282653, -0.4302152395248413, -0.4861565828323364, 1.0303009748458862, -0.7531745433807373, 0.1810024380683899, -0.374128520488739, -1.154802918434143, -0.5823904275894165, -0.5038504004478455, 0.31391066312789917, -0.3944997489452362, 0.27796828746795654, 0.41866588592529297, 0.39885005354881287, -1.0356217622756958, -0.7198647856712341, 0.30419033765792847, -0.7625760436058044, -0.6525126099586487, 0.24881760776042938, -0.05989788472652435, -0.9817766547203064, 0.21263064444065094, 0.2166910469532013, -0.17221640050411224, 0.642944872379303, -0.30762946605682373, -0.0736924409866333, -0.6387685537338257, 0.5214667916297913, -0.19573144614696503, -0.6069697141647339, 1.1913460493087769, -0.3452889919281006, 0.9380699992179871, 0.35214492678642273, -0.5306881666183472, 0.51337730884552, 0.21720224618911743, 0.35327157378196716, -0.9514443874359131, -0.6079289317131042, 0.4128357470035553, -0.500336229801178, 0.13428494334220886, 0.3310309052467346, -0.2334602326154709, 0.5944845080375671, -0.10662268847227097, -0.9600794315338135, 0.017972182482481003, 0.06928045302629471, 0.48735642433166504, 0.4189712405204773, 0.7091159820556641, 0.2116842269897461, 0.11875487864017487, -0.40039047598838806, -0.4215051233768463, -0.5478153824806213, 0.055947110056877136, 0.4587770998477936, -0.1192963719367981, -0.37383902072906494, 0.721379280090332, 0.5660993456840515, -0.062039945274591446, -0.21375885605812073, -0.053647201508283615, -0.7389360666275024, -0.282355397939682, 0.04152959585189819, 0.8949581384658813, -0.3309996426105499, -0.16352565586566925, -0.3906099200248718, 0.42507195472717285, 0.13742460310459137, 1.1562860012054443, 0.46699732542037964, 0.45912089943885803, -1.1790939569473267 ]
Spin Singlet Quantum Hall Effect and Nonabelian Landau-Ginzburg Theory
We show that the Halperin-Haldane SQHE wave function can be written in the form of a product of a wave function for charged semions in a magnetic field and a wave function for the Chiral Spin Liquid of neutral spin-$\12$ semions. We introduce field-theoretic model in which the electron operators are factorized in terms of charged spinless semions (holons) and neutral spin-$\12$ semions (spinons). Broken time reversal symmetry and short ranged spin correlations lead to $SU(2)_{k=1}$ Chern-Simons term in Landau-Ginzburg action for SQHE phase. We construct appropriate coherent states for SQHE phase and show the existence of $SU(2)$ valued gauge potential. This potential appears as a result of ``spin rigidity" of the ground state against any displacements of nodes of wave function from positions of the particles and reflects the nontrivial monodromy in the presence of these displacements. We argue that topological structure of $SU(2)_{k=1}$ Chern-Simons theory unambiguously dictates {\it semion} statistics of spinons.
Alexander Balatsky (Los Alamos National Laboratory)
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204002
cond-mat/9204003
[ -0.0745425745844841, 0.1730322688817978, 0.1582443118095398, 0.7405394315719604, -0.45266619324684143, -0.16441895067691803, -0.5134924054145813, -0.33344441652297974, -0.7616702318191528, 1.501328706741333, 1.005165934562683, -0.26177358627319336, 0.6700871586799622, -1.6188615560531616, -0.5532094836235046, -0.019249383360147476, -0.47350457310676575, -0.9272692799568176, -1.2430310249328613, -0.3421664834022522, -0.10696462541818619, -0.1435614675283432, -0.8655795454978943, -0.8465576767921448, -0.3688969016075134, 0.3723328411579132, -0.16948875784873962, 0.6334584355354309, 0.37143582105636597, 0.21061761677265167, 0.8639549016952515, -0.08597757667303085, 0.21787014603614807, -1.3587164878845215, 0.18799476325511932, 0.4260529577732086, 0.03418320044875145, 0.19486621022224426, 0.5798721313476562, 0.06365560740232468, 0.815502941608429, -0.22272218763828278, 0.11199668794870377, -0.06143958121538162, -0.12339559942483902, -0.23130078613758087, -0.7819300889968872, -0.4943012297153473, -0.6097078919410706, -1.8234180212020874, -0.11401183903217316, -0.10468018054962158, 0.8851529955863953, 0.19856809079647064, 0.40455713868141174, -0.16862909495830536, -0.2555066645145416, 0.00827222689986229, 0.06553646922111511, 0.268600195646286, 0.3174039125442505, -0.2987363040447235, 0.7205420732498169, -0.8900078535079956, -0.19419656693935394, 0.3133973479270935, -0.01524247694760561, 1.3428709506988525, 0.15207287669181824, -0.1167573630809784, 0.08502203971147537, 0.28305310010910034, -0.5186461806297302, -0.07901011407375336, -0.7070770263671875, 0.29069727659225464, 0.15879255533218384, -0.5057280659675598, -1.211083173751831, -0.3388816714286804, -0.028411567211151123, -0.5711262822151184, -0.13069865107536316, 0.4595729112625122, -0.2302510142326355, -0.3415514826774597, -0.7781975865364075, -0.517318606376648, -0.2545366585254669, 0.5101655125617981, 0.6866881847381592, 0.7463892698287964, -0.2541211247444153, -0.20151691138744354, 0.6498543620109558, 0.12760908901691437, 0.5564581155776978, 0.07281293720006943, 0.03601217642426491, 0.29729121923446655, 0.2847954034805298, 0.040832970291376114, -0.4877135157585144, 0.7199844121932983, 0.01294638216495514, 1.0762355327606201, -0.7611450552940369, 0.49396857619285583, 0.4890206754207611, -0.3687106668949127, 0.131127268075943, -0.4311894476413727, 0.3455807566642761, 0.815007746219635, -0.7122125625610352, 0.9113464951515198, -0.1317175328731537, 0.0710538700222969, -0.9741020202636719, -0.014641575515270233, 0.19782818853855133, 0.764863133430481, 1.0750136375427246, 0.7769848704338074, -0.19328828155994415, -0.13652555644512177, 0.6068568825721741, 0.43400630354881287, -0.30097290873527527, -0.02035747841000557, 0.7027379274368286, 0.6177350282669067, -0.2875114977359772, 1.0366597175598145, -0.7377285361289978, 0.6141302585601807, -0.4640657603740692, 0.33879584074020386, 0.35221078991889954, -0.07719998806715012, 0.6772028803825378, -0.8195359110832214, 0.010816692374646664, 0.8574192523956299, -0.5092456936836243, -0.17899082601070404, 0.2915298640727997, -0.14307482540607452, -0.35914546251296997, 0.03623643517494202, -0.6933701634407043, 0.31982022523880005, -0.0707884430885315, -0.0920090451836586, -0.4235767126083374, -0.019426565617322922, 0.17665117979049683, 0.287188321352005, -0.24354295432567596, -0.9362584948539734, 0.44506004452705383, 0.16738513112068176, 0.0817905068397522, 0.33650195598602295, -0.3240930438041687, -0.24132011830806732, -0.5622591972351074, -0.23080021142959595, 0.8565040230751038, -0.08608347922563553, -0.816822350025177, 0.3570689857006073, -0.42131471633911133, 0.7915478944778442, -0.024850573390722275, 0.32649126648902893, 0.8162761926651001, -0.12583039700984955, 0.043747443705797195, -0.36107000708580017, 0.19775770604610443, 0.17370398342609406, 1.1403238773345947, 0.511799693107605, 0.26821169257164, 0.17803768813610077, -0.3354940414428711, -0.6927546262741089, -0.19532747566699982, 0.07037834823131561, 0.27559518814086914, 0.16311056911945343, 0.27385297417640686, -0.1712794005870819, -0.5958902835845947, 0.2166687697172165, -0.6067575812339783, 0.47920283675193787, -0.4785682260990143, -0.3852520287036896, -0.1671673208475113, 0.09796428680419922, -0.8825839757919312, 1.0473673343658447, -0.9744928479194641, -0.19733093678951263, 0.9572426080703735, 0.5453281402587891, -0.7017030715942383, 0.050004128366708755, 0.18767663836479187, -0.14367824792861938, 0.13570721447467804, 0.21717306971549988, 0.5980549454689026, 0.4318296015262604, -0.2726779282093048, 0.6164942979812622, 0.051381271332502365, 0.3292592167854309, 0.2372330278158188, 0.373467355966568, -0.11046051234006882, 0.4191106855869293, 0.11786467581987381, -0.37146374583244324, 0.05243738740682602, 0.41952812671661377, 0.2924997806549072, -0.36240118741989136, -0.4621526896953583, 0.5813431739807129, -0.06962335109710693, 0.16888275742530823, 0.35788899660110474, -0.22429737448692322, -0.03086261823773384, 0.5350684523582458, 0.3334159851074219, 0.24398274719715118, -0.6609731912612915, -0.47085002064704895, 0.13385295867919922, 0.1501743346452713, -0.037447333335876465, -0.48068803548812866, -0.5072848796844482, -0.030997753143310547, -0.775811493396759, 0.33488887548446655, -0.3697781562805176, -0.13524970412254333, -0.020111151039600372, 0.4409972131252289, -1.0464690923690796, -0.2733156383037567, 0.584020733833313, -0.020303713157773018, -0.37629973888397217, 0.09193016588687897, 0.0031249243766069412, -0.5363971590995789, -0.10486104339361191, -0.23867349326610565, 0.1284489780664444, 0.3493105471134186, 0.16243785619735718, 0.025480661541223526, -0.0045587169006466866, -0.2583695650100708, -1.4743303060531616, -0.6584625840187073, -0.4649699628353119, -0.1102626696228981, -0.5034403800964355, 0.508063018321991, 0.6209689974784851, -1.1676312685012817, 0.9589207172393799, -0.43371355533599854, 0.09107016026973724, 0.6396706104278564, -0.7418709397315979, 0.5623112320899963, 0.2750794291496277, 0.41608762741088867, -0.8018479347229004, 0.6690030694007874, -0.6830434203147888, 0.4408192038536072, -0.31142333149909973, -0.01591130532324314, 0.7190269231796265, -0.6687494516372681, 0.42762210965156555, -0.19220305979251862, -0.06600896269083023, 0.5358477830886841, 0.019529767334461212, -0.2694363296031952, -0.15891358256340027, 0.09937844425439835, 0.10910341143608093, -0.16418825089931488, -0.7913196682929993, 0.19983330368995667, 0.027541818097233772, -0.3356354534626007, 0.07811032235622406, 0.3620051443576813, -1.1490293741226196, 0.23472388088703156, -0.06221554055809975, -0.009798828512430191, -0.005683955270797014, 0.7178755402565002, 0.5783180594444275, -0.09425139427185059, -0.16529732942581177, -0.7408115267753601, -0.4051917493343353, 0.32861703634262085, -0.05188077688217163, -0.4691011309623718, 0.14015300571918488, 0.6743512749671936, -0.0696936845779419, -0.2680702209472656, 0.012606045231223106, -1.1238681077957153, -0.1223631352186203, 0.3463091552257538, -0.28493955731391907, 0.7681869268417358, -0.2612167298793793, -0.48973339796066284, -0.32021206617355347, -0.5450253486633301, 1.2617270946502686, 0.05025326460599899, 0.31874212622642517, -0.42720019817352295, 0.7260700464248657, 0.6335333585739136, 0.3632405400276184, 0.12102089822292328, -0.30361276865005493, -0.11462114006280899, -1.3059296607971191, -0.035878878086805344, -0.5198104381561279, 0.3472842872142792, 0.4838104844093323, 0.34432438015937805, 0.08736968785524368, 1.0370051860809326, -0.3079824149608612, -0.9213942289352417, 0.4558163285255432, -0.0744936391711235, 0.052778083831071854, 0.9838874936103821, 0.019834527745842934, -0.1178102195262909, -0.8597049117088318, -0.2580004930496216, -0.15968571603298187, -0.09526853263378143, 0.21749261021614075, -0.5371538400650024, 0.04898762330412865, -0.2545572519302368, -0.5995762944221497, 0.9241926670074463, -0.5990221500396729, 0.42760616540908813, 0.47820183634757996, 0.45018714666366577, 0.4364033639431, -0.3394967019557953, -0.1393440067768097, 0.014808478765189648, 1.032143473625183, 0.49384739995002747, 0.8196736574172974, 1.1040095090866089, -0.3593124449253082, 0.4804611802101135, -0.35084161162376404, -0.9453301429748535, -0.12368814647197723, -0.062013931572437286, -0.36773964762687683, 0.1476409137248993, 0.047235313802957535, 0.48562899231910706, 0.26244792342185974, -0.4285820722579956, 0.07687605172395706, 0.166263148188591, 0.4695238471031189, 1.112458348274231, 0.40843087434768677, 0.07169211655855179, -0.8054376840591431, -0.04782943055033684, -0.3015303909778595, -0.10229663550853729, 0.044005606323480606, 0.05682111904025078, -0.34119853377342224, -0.6486775279045105, -0.7696325182914734, -0.5507398843765259, 0.7054526209831238, 0.3452455401420593, -0.1409710943698883, 0.38871151208877563, 0.3083467483520508, 0.6432358026504517, -0.6116434335708618, -0.18112896382808685, 0.49060818552970886, 0.3343459367752075, 0.06822355836629868, -0.974120557308197, 0.3756078779697418, -0.29878389835357666, 0.9745477437973022, 0.6712629795074463, -0.6346037983894348, -0.6529731750488281, -0.19855408370494843, 1.3148504495620728, -0.11781767755746841, -0.29209327697753906, 1.0728765726089478, 0.9822296500205994, 0.14603669941425323, -0.5725056529045105, -0.06460225582122803, 0.746998131275177, -0.9421745538711548, 0.04692743346095085, -0.688502848148346, -0.21813344955444336, -0.317497193813324, 0.8759912848472595, -0.20762185752391815, -0.47883257269859314, -0.403077095746994, -0.20073100924491882, -0.005689012352377176, -0.28790923953056335, -0.31326454877853394, 0.05559198930859566, -0.2439580261707306, -0.41955164074897766, 0.7265481948852539, 0.3923117518424988, 0.05918164551258087, -0.21922042965888977, -0.17270755767822266, -0.2219230979681015, -0.2063281536102295, 0.10162562876939774, -0.36445438861846924, 0.8736670017242432, 0.20925983786582947, -0.3646210730075836, 0.34073662757873535, -0.42604315280914307, -0.28688403964042664, -0.2235419899225235, 0.4231565296649933, -0.006418416276574135, -0.5318547487258911, -0.4160962402820587, -0.39720314741134644, -0.9757688641548157, -0.7125462293624878, 0.4068118929862976, 0.24887843430042267, 0.3300338387489319, 0.0990205928683281, -0.7896280884742737, -0.6070099472999573, 0.00802766252309084, -0.6346551775932312, 0.829818606376648, -0.41187360882759094, 0.13179779052734375, 0.028212139382958412, -0.2270725667476654, -0.01747569814324379, 0.060206856578588486, -0.31020495295524597, -1.0481213331222534, 0.6606234908103943, 0.49174606800079346, 0.26344403624534607, 0.06412430852651596, -0.3591907322406769, 0.5098985433578491, -0.3532623052597046, 0.632993221282959, -0.5142905116081238, -0.001914131105877459, -0.6371769905090332, -0.5650221705436707, 0.4293919503688812, 0.3550148904323578, -0.05268597602844238, -0.01069781556725502, 0.006537318229675293, 0.5080587863922119, -0.20154976844787598, -0.05752566084265709, -1.0262000560760498, 0.47592586278915405, 0.18504764139652252, -0.06237521022558212, -0.16746632754802704, 0.6864815354347229, -0.2590733766555786, 1.007227897644043, -0.04761485382914543, -1.1548150777816772, 0.5666261911392212, -0.4240071773529053, 0.4449266493320465, -0.928494930267334, 0.008173641748726368, -0.7392463684082031, 0.3489064574241638, 0.3021984398365021, 0.7450293302536011, -0.14158914983272552, -0.18885084986686707, -0.4888207018375397, 0.04204675182700157, 0.08310530334711075, 0.040555886924266815, -0.22517715394496918, -0.13708651065826416, -0.4934759736061096, -1.0326796770095825, 0.9003135561943054, -0.9775707125663757, 0.32668444514274597, 0.5838460922241211, -0.03274054452776909, -0.3128424882888794, 0.03155310079455376, 0.08656160533428192, -0.054560258984565735, -0.09273602813482285, 0.4305627644062042, -0.32025277614593506, 0.19786803424358368, -0.6658632159233093, 0.3005315065383911, -1.149903655052185, 0.4967797100543976, 0.08321644365787506, -0.23051346838474274, -0.0005216162535361946, 0.563240110874176, 0.5911011099815369, -0.5443586111068726, 0.46197807788848877, -0.246681347489357, 0.3062053620815277, 0.7076995968818665, 0.6334666609764099, -0.5614525675773621, -0.48928406834602356, -0.4472752511501312, -0.9376991391181946, 0.26796677708625793, 0.23360370099544525, -0.10636519640684128, -0.009522338397800922, -0.3308863937854767, -0.44958794116973877, -0.21871145069599152, 0.34870535135269165, 0.490772008895874, -0.08266229182481766, -0.23425637185573578, 0.16492290794849396, 0.28725361824035645, 0.2093428671360016, -0.19954656064510345, 0.16288498044013977, 0.09485972672700882, 0.5590624809265137, 0.4419844448566437, -0.8288122415542603, -0.8437459468841553, -0.3883219063282013, 0.4497188925743103, 0.23654982447624207, 0.05352446436882019, 0.7435681223869324, 0.041851434856653214, 0.04021431505680084, 0.0816086009144783, 0.19629201292991638, 0.044039566069841385, -0.04475436359643936, 0.712331235408783, 0.2644827365875244, 0.3761827349662781, 0.12899525463581085, -0.14180023968219757, -0.2931910455226898, 0.20198103785514832, -0.12575261294841766, -1.068739891052246, -0.5656794905662537, 0.9447692632675171, 0.3116821348667145, -0.8429601788520813, 0.4050920009613037, -0.801386296749115, -0.2990356385707855, -0.05341586843132973, -0.271122545003891, 0.024854108691215515, -0.4141703248023987, -0.28929758071899414, 0.320769727230072, 0.4234722852706909, 0.21315240859985352, 0.9317280054092407, -0.40056735277175903, -0.1229209154844284, -0.7331517338752747, 0.14500799775123596, 1.163615345954895, -0.8602266311645508, -0.9426971077919006, -0.31167447566986084, 0.24681468307971954, -1.138962984085083, -0.018615569919347763, 0.8573071360588074, 0.5119767189025879, 0.7813751101493835, 0.16972050070762634, 0.0007015864830464125, 0.559765100479126, 0.7042827010154724, -0.2007618248462677, 0.3455420732498169, -0.11258915811777115, -1.001968502998352, 0.014278571121394634, -0.23720605671405792, -0.23936690390110016, 0.29279592633247375, -0.11636871099472046, 0.3536175489425659, -0.009872070513665676, 0.011099409312009811, -0.1656804084777832, -0.5072755217552185, -0.3232611119747162, -0.6192494630813599, -0.5117928385734558, -1.0031487941741943, -0.22529204189777374, 0.09969029575586319, 0.4449675977230072, -0.0283051710575819, -0.1063024178147316, -0.5915722250938416, 0.28994980454444885, -0.2505793869495392, 0.06312046200037003, 0.3005554974079132, -0.7495463490486145, -0.033411361277103424, -0.0002745355886872858, -0.23881980776786804, 0.022804860025644302, -0.011561883613467216, -0.23368601500988007, -0.18626952171325684, 0.4374600052833557, -0.6792047023773193, 0.4287843406200409, -0.8672035932540894, -0.5999580025672913, 0.1940268576145172, 0.030757233500480652, -0.8830956816673279, 0.2757505476474762, 1.1465758085250854, -0.1048816367983818, 0.13611087203025818, -0.06560105085372925, -0.06924974173307419, -0.10369237512350082, -0.8134682178497314, 0.5375537872314453, 0.16013574600219727, 0.3071881830692291, 0.30842870473861694, -0.5081257820129395, -0.08787503093481064, 1.098514437675476, -0.5375728011131287, 0.48464491963386536, -0.6889553666114807, 0.41350826621055603, -0.2822244167327881, -0.2557674050331116, -1.0700268745422363, -0.1409475952386856, -0.40299326181411743, 0.9366691708564758, 0.0979536846280098, -0.466267853975296, 0.03601982444524765, 0.3299424350261688, -0.08262305706739426, 0.19275203347206116, 0.343193918466568, -0.40817955136299133, 0.0344984196126461, 0.27241697907447815, -0.3082779347896576, 1.1101716756820679, 0.37434935569763184, -0.3405221104621887, -0.9154384732246399, -0.2562706172466278, -0.8163877725601196, 0.3245430588722229, 0.06601405888795853, -0.6206063032150269, 0.5273581147193909, -0.1387554556131363, -0.31624871492385864, 0.5051191449165344, -0.7519338130950928, -0.5636477470397949, -0.14783357083797455, -0.13720308244228363, -0.5767646431922913, -0.17253892123699188, -0.5875802636146545, 0.6318103671073914, -0.011734276078641415, 0.6700866222381592, -0.2522774934768677, -0.37205979228019714, -0.22253000736236572, 0.16995041072368622, -0.9168513417243958, 0.025685613974928856, -0.8601695895195007, 0.49667301774024963, -0.33833545446395874, -0.9101647138595581, 0.10848353058099747, 0.9669698476791382, -0.04175843298435211, -0.61179518699646, -0.8368818759918213, -0.18067233264446259, -0.273845911026001, -0.1656670868396759, 0.31886935234069824, -0.8935986161231995, -0.50753253698349, 0.4629158079624176, -0.11293474584817886, -0.1410408914089203, 0.4706449508666992, 0.5702296495437622, 0.2733532190322876, -0.04870845004916191, -0.622136652469635, 1.229833960533142, 0.37022262811660767, -0.6689234375953674, 0.8241752982139587, -0.26204124093055725, 0.26259559392929077, 0.8158424496650696, -0.7084944844245911, -0.6182376146316528, 0.3823964595794678, 0.24234040081501007, 1.2658830881118774, 0.12178392708301544, -0.1468040943145752, 0.32282203435897827, 0.47269466519355774, -0.0853014886379242, 0.17123660445213318, 0.12195678800344467, -0.5986684560775757, 1.0476555824279785, -0.43064314126968384, 0.35174432396888733, 0.08728084713220596, 0.15902267396450043, -0.06339530646800995, -0.4446929395198822, -0.14170946180820465, 0.06941281259059906, 0.13428080081939697, 0.18505172431468964, -1.218095064163208, 0.6249523162841797, -0.5716938376426697, -0.23929603397846222, -0.1176343634724617, 0.005030331201851368, -0.4968029260635376, 0.26057419180870056, 0.5540991425514221, 0.22973941266536713, 0.2727648615837097, 0.4627223312854767, -0.12407516688108444, 0.8009198307991028, 0.300205796957016, 0.9092167019844055, 0.2883727550506592, 0.8673543334007263, -0.11412311345338821, -0.6972639560699463, 0.35407793521881104, 0.20983178913593292, -1.1039141416549683, -0.010477636940777302, -0.2603650689125061, -0.4257945120334625, -0.389306902885437, -0.14097166061401367, 0.38366031646728516, -0.6825495362281799, -0.1545865684747696, 1.089652419090271, -0.41067954897880554, -0.0952528640627861, 0.8857100605964661, -0.20048590004444122, -0.3939501941204071, 0.8405086398124695, 0.025794902816414833, -0.9472855925559998, 0.8127356171607971, 0.7419983744621277, -0.06366125494241714, -0.05786295607686043, 0.40098249912261963, -0.4066769778728485, -0.326735258102417, -0.06042046099901199, -1.197198748588562, 0.64057457447052, -1.11994206905365, 0.00397807452827692, 0.17641393840312958, -0.03560783341526985, 0.46061834692955017, 0.5449982285499573, 0.15496115386486053, 0.20901654660701752, 0.03408427909016609, -0.03805883973836899, 1.0638972520828247, 0.8890545964241028, -0.22020307183265686, -0.8986653685569763, -0.4288560450077057, 0.24460294842720032, -0.7403973937034607, -0.28568732738494873, 0.5431367754936218, 0.3088986277580261, 0.14316372573375702, 0.3000519275665283, -0.01022803969681263, -0.31414034962654114, -0.4286290407180786, -0.22228547930717468, -1.015033483505249, -0.0656610056757927, 0.20097725093364716, 0.4293473958969116, -0.002254043472930789, -0.1292141228914261, 0.2932884097099304, -0.46199172735214233, 1.1760772466659546, -0.3378542959690094, 0.37263303995132446, 0.41107794642448425, -0.2760828137397766, 0.2959590256214142, 0.5650040507316589, 0.48138484358787537, -0.9007667303085327, 0.652148962020874, -0.7847463488578796, 0.4459075629711151, 1.0146251916885376, 0.16402021050453186, -0.06717253476381302, 0.26733601093292236, -0.08331142365932465, -0.0037472050171345472, -0.6258130073547363, -0.44942301511764526, -0.9746897220611572, 0.021772893145680428, -0.16670462489128113, 0.5798605680465698, -0.41252604126930237, 0.4480668306350708, 0.6146170496940613, -0.9016970992088318, 4.136869430541992, 0.7791848182678223, 0.8236504197120667, 0.20908646285533905, 0.17653699219226837, 0.609522819519043, -0.21961212158203125, 0.15914154052734375, 0.43715813755989075, -0.9706457257270813, 0.3261140286922455, -0.3338428735733032, -0.21055752038955688, -0.365881085395813, -0.6459547281265259, 1.2408974170684814, 0.4032372832298279, -0.031730785965919495, -0.2658218741416931, -0.884293258190155, -0.29343798756599426, 0.016799837350845337, 0.4092382788658142, 0.11992233246564865, -0.253383070230484, 0.5436939597129822, 0.581493616104126, -0.32582539319992065, -0.8065748810768127, -0.0997585728764534, -0.922803521156311, -0.6430609822273254, 0.2533488869667053, -0.37103480100631714, -0.5925260186195374, 0.7130638360977173, 0.3084746301174164, 0.23225590586662292, -0.14117351174354553, -0.5414204001426697, -0.13236278295516968, -0.12987007200717926, 0.23489485681056976, -0.08716756105422974, -1.012571930885315, 0.555012583732605, -0.1909543126821518, 0.824040949344635, 0.7700925469398499, -0.9524239897727966, 0.5353652238845825, -0.37650367617607117, 0.2592519521713257, -0.5247578024864197, -0.7484920024871826, 0.4167288839817047, -0.3043319284915924, 0.0680108591914177, -0.01915282942354679, -0.23068882524967194, 0.624997615814209, -0.05551637336611748, -0.4725325107574463, -0.560730516910553, -0.11225709319114685, 0.46868041157722473, 1.0716233253479004, 0.3506821393966675, 0.1269374042749405, 0.28777453303337097, -0.510111391544342, -0.09230682253837585, -0.5738979578018188, 0.043030716478824615, 0.3651232421398163, -0.021736206486821175, 0.3770659565925598, -0.009707009419798851, 0.4404407739639282, -0.3173995614051819, -0.25456440448760986, 0.04934095963835716, -0.5223050713539124, 0.23703409731388092, -0.2070612609386444, 1.3342617750167847, -0.3166213035583496, -0.10946235805749893, -0.41192203760147095, 0.8312639594078064, 0.6225957870483398, 1.3404178619384766, 0.7634133696556091, -0.2448064237833023, -0.9915196299552917 ]
A novel class of singlet superconductors
A new class of singlet superconductors with a gap function $\Delta(\bk, \omega_n)$ which is {\it odd} in both momentum and Matsubara frequency is considered. Some of the physical properties of this superconductivity are discussed and it is argued that: i) the electron-phonon interaction can produce this kind of pairing, ii) in many cases there is no gap in the quasiparticle spectrum, iii) these superconductors will exhibit a Meissner effect.
Alexander Balatsky and Elihu Abrahams
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204003
cond-mat/9204004
[ 0.19129616022109985, -0.4621394872665405, 0.5891228914260864, 0.1941298395395279, 0.04886500537395477, -0.9775778651237488, 0.14408312737941742, -0.45300647616386414, -0.9405532479286194, 1.6063450574874878, 0.39594706892967224, 0.19094803929328918, 0.332395076751709, -0.7999883890151978, -0.057726696133613586, 0.575857400894165, -0.6171374320983887, -0.457874059677124, -1.3098939657211304, 0.339346706867218, 0.16969579458236694, 0.2969251573085785, -1.4950950145721436, -0.6710395812988281, -0.5856566429138184, 0.9636093974113464, 0.5029265880584717, 0.723561704158783, 0.9748877882957458, 0.7170811891555786, 0.38137099146842957, -0.8657097220420837, 0.33250969648361206, -0.5532004833221436, -0.6361386775970459, 0.059157636016607285, -0.2623666226863861, 0.04574589431285858, 0.7614375948905945, -0.13397783041000366, 1.0742342472076416, -0.32077133655548096, -0.4209210276603699, 0.14832288026809692, -0.6188037991523743, -0.10252970457077026, -0.6169425845146179, 0.3449782729148865, 0.18667317926883698, -1.208112359046936, 0.41360747814178467, 0.12421734631061554, 1.1359480619430542, -0.2731192409992218, -0.09164679795503616, -0.008750961162149906, -0.3793768882751465, -0.4731937348842621, -0.3966062068939209, -0.17607572674751282, 0.2657599151134491, -0.013778160326182842, 0.5753674507141113, -0.3383970558643341, -0.10016321390867233, 0.0285255815833807, -0.45452579855918884, 0.9587820172309875, 0.3649260103702545, -1.1165783405303955, -0.24741612374782562, -0.28595104813575745, -0.7880680561065674, 0.18342547118663788, -0.8546053171157837, 0.4263317883014679, 0.19237425923347473, -0.4843723475933075, -1.5379976034164429, -0.4505711495876312, -0.4048609733581543, -0.4786946177482605, -0.313361257314682, 0.3422362208366394, -0.2908838093280792, -0.4299814701080322, -0.6193786859512329, -0.8209214806556702, -0.17066216468811035, -0.0034202022943645716, 0.5745879411697388, 0.5009945034980774, -0.09920130670070648, -0.19122862815856934, 0.9992653131484985, 0.52256840467453, 0.2531798481941223, 0.39142245054244995, 0.4666318893432617, -0.2392062097787857, 0.13192464411258698, 0.5224735140800476, -0.3145208954811096, 0.7926361560821533, -0.6880193948745728, 0.36772841215133667, -0.19174787402153015, 0.25725772976875305, -0.19672448933124542, -0.7638425230979919, -0.19636963307857513, -0.1637115180492401, 0.549205482006073, 0.6594016551971436, -0.5379660129547119, 0.6319890022277832, 0.2764243185520172, 0.07795290648937225, -1.378588080406189, -0.06497911363840103, 0.40669745206832886, 0.299372136592865, 0.697188675403595, 0.6218633055686951, -0.18628893792629242, 0.15024806559085846, 0.18310408294200897, 0.7962115406990051, -0.13793446123600006, 1.241513967514038, -0.1052551195025444, 0.01102110929787159, -0.10455301403999329, 0.498888224363327, -1.3051265478134155, 0.28304561972618103, -0.5405282974243164, 0.054813582450151443, 0.6094048619270325, -0.20159783959388733, 0.6537727117538452, -0.7099661827087402, 0.3497270941734314, 1.1653209924697876, 0.9553434252738953, -0.062382325530052185, 0.19783632457256317, -0.07315395027399063, -0.32968297600746155, 0.5049912929534912, -0.4089376628398895, 0.2347204089164734, -0.19338294863700867, 0.4480087161064148, -0.007614773698151112, 1.1146769523620605, -0.24340295791625977, 0.3925905227661133, -0.6394816040992737, -0.4761883020401001, 0.6854854226112366, -0.07288635522127151, -0.09734932333230972, 0.24153132736682892, -0.21484051644802094, -0.012352021411061287, -0.38423609733581543, 0.15481941401958466, -0.11195359379053116, -0.5181806087493896, 0.024822833016514778, -0.2479432225227356, -0.18315432965755463, 1.1747266054153442, 0.39107435941696167, 0.15726175904273987, 0.702434778213501, -0.5866090059280396, -0.26145175099372864, -0.006977399345487356, -0.14867036044597626, -0.4521094560623169, 0.9413672685623169, -0.04767744243144989, 0.012240749783813953, -0.2537964880466461, -0.185743510723114, -0.39027905464172363, -0.11686115711927414, 0.39131492376327515, -0.1597277671098709, 0.2207629680633545, -0.14449888467788696, -0.05565870925784111, -0.47660180926322937, 0.09306994080543518, -0.8634912967681885, 0.62399822473526, -0.5599363446235657, 0.4093513786792755, -0.23814623057842255, 0.18990986049175262, -0.7326691746711731, 0.1527298390865326, -1.5616848468780518, 0.27138563990592957, 0.27292904257774353, 0.39172834157943726, -0.4049813449382782, 0.08564289659261703, 0.3176582157611847, -0.5349531173706055, 0.7903150916099548, -0.17864662408828735, -0.08977320790290833, 0.46838536858558655, -0.25985971093177795, 0.23515987396240234, -0.17951831221580505, 0.05420122295618057, 0.40270206332206726, 0.4768974483013153, 0.09438221901655197, 0.5731879472732544, 0.12567727267742157, -0.9352450966835022, 0.09607496112585068, 0.4335021674633026, 0.15460138022899628, 0.1945628523826599, -0.2733565866947174, 0.40905436873435974, 0.6794931292533875, 0.31598615646362305, 0.026293231174349785, 0.7673341631889343, 0.6254213452339172, 0.366850346326828, 0.4908083379268646, 0.22222620248794556, -0.4798114001750946, -0.37157002091407776, -0.08147930353879929, -0.5272862911224365, 0.37354734539985657, 0.24982675909996033, -0.7385666370391846, 0.40240684151649475, -0.3161609470844269, 0.6291062831878662, -0.16127420961856842, 0.6349684596061707, 0.24733474850654602, 0.3085279166698456, -0.9581990242004395, -0.09107828885316849, 0.2577994763851166, 0.2553672194480896, -0.2693973481655121, 0.18977554142475128, -0.15824206173419952, 0.012565030716359615, -0.05068904906511307, -0.42061251401901245, -0.4804176986217499, 1.2614428997039795, -0.3409847915172577, 0.15738460421562195, 0.44486361742019653, -0.040001098066568375, -1.3958418369293213, -0.21054229140281677, -0.7291210293769836, -0.24310657382011414, -1.291345238685608, 0.4641643166542053, 1.0644086599349976, -0.9474366903305054, 0.45028606057167053, -0.31129440665245056, -0.23574748635292053, 0.32750433683395386, -0.38321322202682495, 0.5434239506721497, 0.5617949962615967, 0.36580848693847656, -1.0377801656723022, 0.5005915760993958, -0.8170970678329468, -0.10581282526254654, -0.503669023513794, 0.33407896757125854, 0.616588294506073, -0.48340919613838196, 0.3459557294845581, -0.4938155710697174, -0.4599977135658264, -0.24708722531795502, 0.05474397912621498, -0.28749504685401917, 0.0412302128970623, 0.6050795316696167, -0.3153018653392792, 0.1018340140581131, -0.7549532651901245, 0.5189509391784668, 0.5400353074073792, -0.44060635566711426, 0.09425795078277588, 0.13039951026439667, 0.08823615312576294, 0.6773290634155273, 0.49741265177726746, -0.03402278572320938, 0.09213102608919144, 0.32874608039855957, 0.13844843208789825, 0.4717688262462616, -0.20660242438316345, -0.11604060232639313, -0.5080925822257996, 0.6932147741317749, 0.18392184376716614, -0.6882769465446472, -0.17911787331104279, 0.3146682381629944, -0.0798797532916069, -0.8441205024719238, 0.11087267100811005, -1.6159085035324097, -0.25756576657295227, 0.03304307907819748, -0.18050816655158997, 0.28637221455574036, 0.15020254254341125, -0.324627161026001, -1.3736501932144165, -0.29058027267456055, 0.45065024495124817, 0.20576365292072296, -0.5471229553222656, 0.12504462897777557, 0.19876545667648315, 0.5543857216835022, 0.23321010172367096, 0.09498836100101471, -0.09049078077077866, -0.07337270677089691, -0.7179713845252991, 0.3995685577392578, -0.5656152963638306, -0.015063329599797726, 0.2912044823169708, -0.043437570333480835, -0.11859753727912903, 1.0847175121307373, -0.6446309089660645, -0.46996769309043884, -0.47053733468055725, -0.012943358160555363, 0.09471559524536133, 0.5329720377922058, -0.2597689628601074, -0.1450572907924652, -0.6413397789001465, -0.2928543984889984, 0.2770496904850006, 0.055779557675123215, 0.7288150191307068, -0.4020550847053528, 0.38313183188438416, 0.5836580991744995, 0.25478243827819824, 0.9055896401405334, -0.1846173107624054, -0.06305211782455444, 0.5008026957511902, 0.10314656794071198, 0.8946055173873901, -0.1647815853357315, -0.5662571787834167, -0.2567112147808075, 0.5567713975906372, 0.5518467426300049, 0.8623772263526917, 1.0297987461090088, -0.035945892333984375, -0.4950985908508301, -0.04420853406190872, -0.29450881481170654, -0.43293049931526184, -0.32364335656166077, -0.3507081866264343, -0.2857278287410736, -0.0612185001373291, 0.5856891870498657, 0.38657185435295105, -0.1402650624513626, 0.266527384519577, 0.6782699823379517, 0.3793087601661682, 0.9718590974807739, 0.12900392711162567, 0.7800235748291016, -1.0910180807113647, -0.11072715371847153, -0.7282472252845764, 0.28697502613067627, 0.43746814131736755, -0.15664075314998627, -0.2883211672306061, -0.4912279546260834, -0.21864888072013855, -0.752361536026001, 0.9265055060386658, 0.10613072663545609, -0.7715005874633789, 0.6392016410827637, -0.35627004504203796, -0.20939260721206665, -1.3164722919464111, -0.06346730142831802, 1.1642409563064575, 0.4003094434738159, 0.09985828399658203, -1.0247068405151367, 0.22377651929855347, -0.5714496970176697, 0.6816608905792236, 0.3999179005622864, -0.8668935298919678, -0.7213498950004578, -0.4137161672115326, -0.3583565354347229, -0.5465212464332581, -0.907867431640625, 1.7245302200317383, -0.034759100526571274, 0.2973994016647339, -0.5409265756607056, -0.23204956948757172, 1.0185534954071045, -0.461363822221756, -0.25957968831062317, 0.18247583508491516, -0.2458731085062027, 0.1601167768239975, 0.6402627825737, -0.5057888627052307, -0.8742792010307312, 0.05782623589038849, -0.8592217564582825, -0.4238869845867157, 0.22392384707927704, -0.19458554685115814, -0.10919728875160217, -0.5331248641014099, -0.3469401001930237, 0.16419269144535065, 0.220608189702034, 0.02807857282459736, 0.08081717789173126, -0.12105747312307358, -0.04487723857164383, 0.2880692183971405, 0.6313381195068359, 0.5244943499565125, 1.4277424812316895, 1.3168416023254395, -0.11281197518110275, 0.04267788305878639, -0.02148277685046196, -0.262285053730011, -0.16573166847229004, 0.4623548984527588, 0.6082229614257812, -0.310871422290802, -0.091521255671978, -0.07556270062923431, -0.9128047227859497, -0.4550471603870392, 0.21510860323905945, -0.7324289679527283, 0.3309730887413025, 0.9045162200927734, -0.9746811389923096, -0.6248752474784851, 0.0025725222658365965, -1.3597822189331055, 0.3179352283477783, 0.37322136759757996, -0.26676350831985474, 0.5733115077018738, -0.16962078213691711, -0.10899330675601959, -0.3183843195438385, -0.4518160820007324, -0.3507841229438782, -0.07551445811986923, 0.9478293061256409, 0.6058533787727356, 0.8121258020401001, -0.19997964799404144, 0.3013220727443695, -0.583307683467865, 0.839997410774231, -0.731635570526123, 0.019939623773097992, -0.7167338132858276, 0.0783095508813858, 0.08538448810577393, -0.38167017698287964, -0.037005312740802765, -0.3875342607498169, 0.05350060388445854, 0.06816580146551132, -0.03601227328181267, -0.3132733404636383, -0.5494052767753601, 0.7194694876670837, 0.12468200922012329, -0.6301742792129517, 0.2346750646829605, 0.5699400901794434, 0.13177405297756195, 0.36721405386924744, -0.28759822249412537, -0.6783149242401123, 0.46785131096839905, -0.1939263790845871, 0.7687199711799622, -1.0653468370437622, -0.1513115018606186, 0.10885646194219589, -0.8350360989570618, 0.44455933570861816, 0.6117081046104431, 0.19527865946292877, -0.07141841948032379, -0.5739479064941406, -0.13295550644397736, 0.030812343582510948, -0.03196136653423309, 0.12013493478298187, -0.805687427520752, -0.6627014875411987, -0.9600750803947449, 0.20079731941223145, 0.16607451438903809, 0.6252506971359253, 0.4691116213798523, -0.13294640183448792, -0.06022712588310242, 0.09676142036914825, 0.2585858702659607, 0.12196941673755646, -0.3272740840911865, 0.4597989022731781, 0.1846965104341507, 0.42813029885292053, -0.728905439376831, 0.09049592167139053, -0.6498094797134399, 0.9120381474494934, -0.3329050838947296, -0.78785640001297, 0.18940700590610504, 0.6213246583938599, 1.2480674982070923, -1.0172107219696045, -0.2690637707710266, 0.3402114510536194, 0.11877543479204178, 0.07982522249221802, 0.366502046585083, -1.0745710134506226, -0.9586644172668457, -0.3690500259399414, -0.884913980960846, 0.391272634267807, 0.29172787070274353, -0.1355057954788208, -0.3319370150566101, 0.21808841824531555, 0.29894185066223145, 0.3475293219089508, 0.5045886635780334, 0.19167152047157288, 0.39431580901145935, 0.35374200344085693, 0.2727903127670288, -0.18326595425605774, -0.539897620677948, -0.08372875303030014, -0.5564110279083252, -0.07436566799879074, -0.5311416387557983, 0.48003876209259033, -0.41110318899154663, -0.3387293219566345, -0.17717379331588745, -0.07408841699361801, 0.02256547287106514, 0.1860106736421585, 1.0686537027359009, -0.48862746357917786, -0.08051902055740356, -0.5859406590461731, -0.023758750408887863, 0.1546861082315445, 0.3873230814933777, 0.4309837520122528, -0.13156718015670776, 0.06530264019966125, 0.1570909023284912, 0.9153774380683899, -0.6013081073760986, -1.1048208475112915, 0.3451938331127167, -0.03675059601664543, -0.2770565450191498, 0.4018820524215698, 0.30783316493034363, -1.1682568788528442, -0.11706694215536118, -0.40788426995277405, -0.42040735483169556, 0.02330297790467739, -0.04522709921002388, -0.06999519467353821, 0.14990706741809845, -0.5079910159111023, 0.6056658029556274, 0.4558875262737274, 0.08248232305049896, 0.23467400670051575, -0.13558921217918396, -0.2499658614397049, -0.7202485799789429, 0.4635449945926666, 1.1793965101242065, -0.3146919012069702, -0.8961337804794312, -0.14934276044368744, -0.1666865050792694, -0.49039363861083984, -0.28099924325942993, 0.5119047164916992, -0.35349413752555847, 0.33783403038978577, 0.11673066765069962, 0.3609156310558319, 0.2021922916173935, 0.6139004230499268, 0.10874848067760468, 0.278434157371521, 0.4389212131500244, -0.46245136857032776, -0.341793030500412, -1.002262830734253, 0.3269460201263428, 0.35249006748199463, -0.44448569416999817, 0.4495125710964203, -0.006851582787930965, -0.5368854403495789, -0.3299974203109741, -1.1217408180236816, 0.2005224972963333, -1.1593759059906006, -0.3432716727256775, -0.6897278428077698, 0.012270360253751278, 0.47546958923339844, 0.3961527347564697, -0.2930041551589966, 0.07287226617336273, -0.6204304099082947, -0.08212405443191528, -0.4779452681541443, 0.20803284645080566, -0.8488572835922241, -0.6594732999801636, -0.08016107976436615, 0.18326127529144287, -0.6970697641372681, 0.3919365108013153, 0.10312628746032715, -0.3661661148071289, -0.079274982213974, 0.0727306455373764, 0.39264193177223206, 0.8097143173217773, -0.9399945735931396, -0.9284778237342834, 0.12674739956855774, 0.3636094033718109, -0.3464914560317993, 0.3727169632911682, 0.14768505096435547, 0.7702507972717285, 0.25521713495254517, 0.15530282258987427, -0.009018215350806713, -0.02755747176706791, -0.33153659105300903, -0.5727612972259521, 0.28566083312034607, 0.3848707973957062, -0.3996274471282959, -0.08926435559988022, 0.5768107771873474, 0.4972207248210907, -0.8634001612663269, 0.7143944501876831, -0.5603067874908447, -0.0754551962018013, -0.5704258680343628, 0.042529910802841187, -0.3142503798007965, -0.44003424048423767, 0.038021694868803024, 1.083709716796875, -0.28543928265571594, -0.3518381416797638, 0.038399916142225266, 0.903037428855896, -0.6153370141983032, 0.5248125791549683, 0.27469149231910706, 0.33695313334465027, -0.29008615016937256, 0.5213360786437988, -0.6658890843391418, 0.04716150090098381, -0.07619738578796387, -0.7667322754859924, -0.0543409138917923, -0.12805025279521942, -0.4313538372516632, 0.5761341452598572, 0.47662946581840515, -1.115181803703308, 0.346601277589798, -0.4078214764595032, -1.074118971824646, 0.14153167605400085, -0.8878635764122009, 0.017417989671230316, -0.320952832698822, -0.14908860623836517, -0.11555550247430801, 0.20803016424179077, -0.4944378435611725, -0.24671491980552673, 0.2401856929063797, 1.054319977760315, 0.1897374391555786, -0.6503850817680359, -0.5293493270874023, -0.08196454495191574, -0.7519429326057434, -0.5501857995986938, -0.026434602215886116, 0.5655178427696228, -0.33404505252838135, -0.5855169296264648, -0.06043713912367821, 0.35375186800956726, -0.027292948216199875, -0.14676256477832794, 0.42705225944519043, -0.659064769744873, -0.36777231097221375, -0.05483755096793175, 0.16349515318870544, -0.6553884148597717, -0.5953971743583679, 0.12365745007991791, -0.4704657793045044, -0.44298645853996277, 0.9135715365409851, 0.614501953125, -0.11812368035316467, 0.1702818125486374, 0.12407577037811279, 0.2997906804084778, 0.5668414235115051, -1.0660905838012695, 0.47996020317077637, -0.028373222798109055, 0.5328604578971863, 1.2982217073440552, -0.6209702491760254, 0.23462478816509247, 0.7054193019866943, 0.7870982885360718, 1.0372415781021118, 0.9017954468727112, 0.49084439873695374, 0.5065305829048157, 0.6731880307197571, 0.10757720470428467, 0.15296532213687897, -0.09523959457874298, 0.6976655125617981, 0.7888645529747009, -0.06696934998035431, 0.1750059574842453, -0.3621217608451843, -0.2151079922914505, -0.23199783265590668, 0.26133638620376587, -0.761236846446991, -0.016314364969730377, 0.47693097591400146, -0.19338926672935486, -0.9018121957778931, -0.26322925090789795, -0.4401503801345825, 0.05127130448818207, 0.27676019072532654, 0.05205671489238739, -0.401979923248291, 0.530380368232727, 0.6600770354270935, -0.1155107170343399, 0.5063823461532593, 0.5408040881156921, -0.056109629571437836, 1.0201948881149292, 0.5737770199775696, 0.22546149790287018, 0.23827579617500305, 0.5544995665550232, 0.22324541211128235, -0.90726637840271, -0.3140006959438324, 0.13236086070537567, -1.0110533237457275, 0.39082810282707214, -0.3358277380466461, -0.26139265298843384, -0.0761621743440628, -0.33991533517837524, 0.2700260281562805, -0.043481700122356415, 0.7507871985435486, 0.7655049562454224, -0.17523081600666046, -0.0509524792432785, 0.6302452683448792, -0.07895471900701523, -0.012826249934732914, 0.48819756507873535, -0.484087198972702, 0.014784493483603, 0.6573866009712219, 1.538817048072815, -0.28552281856536865, 0.7453230023384094, 0.8081367015838623, -0.5463768243789673, 0.41692298650741577, 0.5921750068664551, -0.2299318164587021, 0.1566646546125412, -0.3971516191959381, -0.3695306181907654, 0.1698368787765503, 0.3712494373321533, 0.31678277254104614, -0.1277732402086258, -0.43820562958717346, -0.2514050602912903, -0.2233361452817917, 0.2686503529548645, 1.077296495437622, 0.506688117980957, -1.3060611486434937, -0.7504721283912659, -0.3408125340938568, -0.6491796374320984, -0.3108338713645935, -0.21866141259670258, 0.2184583693742752, 0.4490041732788086, -0.02712976559996605, 0.5330575704574585, -0.5468583106994629, -0.5618504881858826, -1.206595540046692, -0.05673496797680855, -0.7788357138633728, 0.12380939722061157, 0.3809957504272461, 0.20695112645626068, 0.41856932640075684, -0.33457863330841064, 0.3628773093223572, -0.006530158221721649, 1.085545539855957, -0.4079444408416748, -0.13032813370227814, 0.5123699307441711, 0.20277832448482513, -0.19461648166179657, -0.007171621546149254, 1.0108391046524048, -0.36753979325294495, 0.7316436171531677, -0.39838907122612, 0.403582900762558, 0.01313761156052351, -0.37840691208839417, 0.5697858929634094, 0.10802958905696869, -0.2285035252571106, 0.2632938325405121, 0.17778131365776062, -0.25834766030311584, -0.8477059006690979, 0.09064950793981552, -0.8288467526435852, 0.6468107104301453, -0.67583167552948, 0.5299038290977478, -0.32222965359687805, -0.3041592836380005, 4.020838737487793, 1.4946844577789307, 1.0460284948349, 0.2050555795431137, 0.6576839685440063, 0.8130847811698914, -0.37580880522727966, -0.40850400924682617, -0.016703002154827118, -1.0681370496749878, -0.623083770275116, 0.14795532822608948, 0.3635454475879669, -0.0041855983436107635, -0.023789038881659508, 0.7932788133621216, -0.2326124608516693, 0.4213158190250397, 0.33474645018577576, -0.8476078510284424, -1.3542119264602661, -0.11480335891246796, 0.10529401153326035, 0.7288045883178711, -0.255371630191803, 0.3121565580368042, 0.3271445035934448, -0.8774353861808777, -0.1438293606042862, -0.49637946486473083, -0.5917004942893982, -0.7611743807792664, 0.46174904704093933, -0.8866346478462219, -0.7998618483543396, 0.0263160839676857, 0.1374373584985733, 0.19966456294059753, 0.12103095650672913, 0.1544637233018875, -0.13945242762565613, -0.4729504883289337, 0.4256646931171417, -1.0918465852737427, -0.9638128280639648, 0.8818936347961426, -0.3655554950237274, 1.1903778314590454, 0.4499100148677826, -0.4032186269760132, 0.07373301684856415, -0.33476290106773376, 0.28097864985466003, -1.073096513748169, -0.7360086441040039, 0.3002152144908905, -0.2131887823343277, -0.4641466438770294, -0.2175428718328476, 0.10970202088356018, 0.4451514184474945, 0.017812015488743782, 0.21842901408672333, -0.008995244279503822, -0.23421919345855713, 0.6320936679840088, 0.019354047253727913, 0.8832165002822876, -0.07722563296556473, 0.008235141634941101, 0.15316157042980194, -0.7480292320251465, -0.5885120034217834, -0.6498352289199829, 0.11811061203479767, -0.24298909306526184, -0.0651950016617775, 0.6154870986938477, 0.19136887788772583, -0.3404611051082611, -0.568023681640625, -0.09444697946310043, -0.3461611270904541, -0.10206963121891022, 0.424277126789093, 0.6612098217010498, 0.028433751314878464, -0.11417949944734573, 0.6403429508209229, 0.32201236486434937, 0.4110981225967407, 1.0313397645950317, 0.5674512982368469, 0.15023528039455414, -1.0551117658615112 ]
Physics beyond quasi-particles: Spectrum and completeness of the 3 state superintegrable chiral Potts model
We find the rules which count the energy levels of the 3 state superintegrable chiral Potts model and demonstrate that these rules are complete. We then derive the complete spectrum of excitations in the thermodynamic limit in the massive phase and demonstrate the existence of excitations which do not have a quasi-particle form. The physics of these excitations is compared with the BCS superconductivity spectrum and the counting rules are compared with the closely related $S=1$ XXZ spin chain.
Srinandan Dasmahapatra, Rinat Kedem and Barry M. McCoy
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204004
cond-mat/9204005
[ 0.2342374175786972, -0.5939634442329407, 0.3245757222175598, 0.5589542388916016, -0.2112008035182953, -1.098055362701416, 0.09229373931884766, -0.5018371939659119, -0.7930411100387573, 1.335816740989685, 0.6344810128211975, -0.6249663829803467, 0.2391010820865631, -0.6650003790855408, -0.9919220209121704, 0.26859721541404724, -0.27654215693473816, -0.4243090748786926, -1.0167236328125, -0.2168446183204651, -0.016481786966323853, -0.0613638237118721, -0.2557821273803711, -0.3491189181804657, -0.8357741832733154, 1.1168733835220337, 0.24783337116241455, 0.8471152186393738, 0.8725762963294983, 0.5779714584350586, 0.3046664595603943, -0.32744067907333374, -0.6793351769447327, -0.5958003401756287, -0.15100084245204926, 0.0489196851849556, -0.058202121406793594, -0.1533900797367096, 0.5408810973167419, -0.0565752349793911, 1.0505807399749756, -0.3562460243701935, 0.14196930825710297, -0.038231223821640015, -0.02419365756213665, 0.4619029760360718, 0.2003442943096161, 0.3473603427410126, -0.18990091979503632, -1.556948184967041, 0.28243187069892883, 0.1849491447210312, 0.6805136799812317, -0.7227039337158203, -0.12805433571338654, -0.3079488277435303, -0.18659035861492157, 0.6937990784645081, 0.34779584407806396, -0.11708522588014603, -0.4042300581932068, 0.1056574359536171, 1.2663685083389282, -0.5354663133621216, -0.2522355616092682, 0.8010362982749939, -0.019465787336230278, 1.6731876134872437, 0.03493693470954895, -0.09679784625768661, -0.1131502091884613, -0.0021047231275588274, -0.9470100998878479, -0.3389357328414917, -0.6448236703872681, 0.05948219075798988, 0.08430569618940353, -0.5433569550514221, -0.6181565523147583, -0.45036083459854126, 0.5548059940338135, -0.13702967762947083, 0.06849301606416702, 0.042515188455581665, 0.1373213678598404, -0.027748998254537582, 0.3368186950683594, 0.042093425989151, -0.32101306319236755, 0.5046476721763611, 0.3472389876842499, 1.0507475137710571, -0.43382659554481506, -0.3490154445171356, 0.07318736612796783, 0.4624238908290863, -0.1190873458981514, -0.06607676297426224, -0.15212079882621765, 0.129489928483963, 0.38505998253822327, 1.0221914052963257, -0.15735003352165222, 0.4856986701488495, -0.7792164087295532, 0.9627001881599426, -0.17820239067077637, 0.5883937478065491, 0.016927234828472137, -0.915878415107727, -0.39164304733276367, -0.5070171356201172, 0.7585881948471069, 0.9206780195236206, -0.21715673804283142, 0.9558709263801575, -0.793894350528717, 0.07853689044713974, -1.3265650272369385, 0.05890638008713722, 0.15253876149654388, 0.13546620309352875, 1.0329025983810425, 0.5032476186752319, -0.2736453413963318, -0.12770402431488037, 0.17909136414527893, 0.5691642165184021, -0.0846019983291626, 0.6977612972259521, 0.536700427532196, 0.49985602498054504, 0.018831944093108177, 0.5840338468551636, -1.4858957529067993, 0.6219131946563721, -0.013798517175018787, 0.15048591792583466, 0.3104945123195648, -0.28890636563301086, 0.5890405178070068, -0.75340735912323, -0.10294413566589355, 0.8135495185852051, 0.0065139359794557095, 0.11251228302717209, 0.24839892983436584, 0.5504778623580933, -0.27154070138931274, 0.2068079113960266, -0.812345564365387, 0.1447470635175705, -0.029694093391299248, 0.24622957408428192, -0.8372710347175598, 0.3951488733291626, -0.5126588344573975, 0.3351181745529175, -0.256258100271225, -0.5258705615997314, -0.17951329052448273, 0.24052691459655762, -0.3468097448348999, 0.423777312040329, -0.08503631502389908, -0.06496258825063705, -0.8714447617530823, -0.3038735091686249, 0.30268004536628723, -0.40581077337265015, -0.6744991540908813, 0.4279811680316925, 0.3584519028663635, 0.7274665832519531, 0.26352933049201965, 0.03513437882065773, 0.48150694370269775, -0.16738225519657135, -0.7377138137817383, -0.03463279455900192, 0.01540698204189539, 0.2870390713214874, 0.5877072215080261, -0.11104141175746918, -0.40504190325737, -0.5088531374931335, -0.4445496201515198, -1.059905767440796, -0.5347614288330078, 0.2622201442718506, -0.22662387788295746, 0.2648010551929474, -0.0018879043636843562, 0.48838499188423157, -0.39537763595581055, -0.04682677984237671, -1.0096826553344727, 0.43468353152275085, -0.012441289611160755, -0.4341236650943756, -0.5354387760162354, -0.042213235050439835, -0.8389866948127747, 0.38770514726638794, -1.1762138605117798, -0.6732324957847595, 0.4772813022136688, 0.4736124575138092, -0.576134979724884, -0.23450446128845215, -0.45414668321609497, 0.24578073620796204, 0.5100163817405701, -0.3269692659378052, 0.18685416877269745, 0.2463238388299942, 0.196131631731987, 0.044149190187454224, 0.09382278472185135, 0.19959214329719543, 0.4883067309856415, -0.184482604265213, 0.10923982411623001, 0.9575069546699524, -0.43651431798934937, -0.7531672120094299, 0.5269516110420227, 0.524569571018219, 0.12866224348545074, -0.13150182366371155, -0.028839508071541786, 0.7536550760269165, -0.5845075845718384, 0.48435935378074646, 0.2845250368118286, -0.01798308454453945, 0.3429432809352875, 0.20708319544792175, 0.5800155997276306, -0.007901241071522236, -0.3143715560436249, 0.2013610452413559, 0.20170842111110687, 0.07258554548025131, -0.6328556537628174, -0.034785326570272446, -0.3746426999568939, 0.5503801703453064, -0.7728521823883057, 0.683353066444397, -0.42898082733154297, 0.2558313310146332, -0.1845369040966034, 0.054152801632881165, -1.1571033000946045, 0.18472805619239807, -0.02644333802163601, 0.6468449831008911, -0.22103363275527954, -0.2509315311908722, -0.46736738085746765, -0.21781626343727112, -0.1433957815170288, -0.6951356530189514, 0.250018447637558, 0.8362675905227661, -0.10892190784215927, 0.1969720721244812, 0.18594799935817719, -0.3349289894104004, -1.0335090160369873, -0.3139841854572296, -0.6006805300712585, 0.04701635614037514, -0.8250023722648621, 0.3440375328063965, 0.7727550268173218, -0.8975576162338257, 0.5738440155982971, -0.010146008804440498, -0.822716236114502, 0.614619255065918, 0.43742987513542175, 0.5821009874343872, 0.6210086941719055, -0.10409285128116608, -1.024190068244934, -0.026371804997324944, -0.4270934462547302, 0.5536891222000122, -0.8067936301231384, -0.195626899600029, 0.4166004955768585, -0.8322767019271851, 0.4829963743686676, -0.2484465390443802, -0.03823468089103699, 0.4404498040676117, 0.26999497413635254, -0.48912957310676575, 0.4586872458457947, 0.44541314244270325, -0.014218115247786045, -0.16340318322181702, -1.4693734645843506, 0.6189260482788086, 0.25366970896720886, -1.0846894979476929, 0.49203890562057495, -0.3114320933818817, -0.950385570526123, 0.39715704321861267, -0.2825410068035126, -0.05776146426796913, -0.08392461389303207, 0.5956157445907593, 0.08319835364818573, 0.021932946518063545, 0.40956246852874756, 0.27884504199028015, -0.47183671593666077, 0.12925048172473907, 0.2664213478565216, -0.41185829043388367, -0.19013911485671997, 0.6781695485115051, -0.21362856030464172, -0.03774241730570793, 0.5752126574516296, -1.3156589269638062, -0.13489267230033875, 0.4197918474674225, -0.03400750085711479, 0.8594948649406433, -0.30909428000450134, -0.14026480913162231, -0.39091265201568604, -0.4662354588508606, 0.9051466584205627, 0.5000408291816711, 0.37501367926597595, -0.21825623512268066, 0.7148571610450745, 0.22540169954299927, 0.575340211391449, -0.8698453903198242, 0.632128894329071, -0.5797612071037292, -0.39311930537223816, 0.011308926157653332, -0.7867607474327087, 0.4291094243526459, 0.06031351163983345, -0.09636010974645615, 0.1538536250591278, 1.1834050416946411, -0.5174798369407654, -0.5625549554824829, -0.3185984790325165, -0.21011751890182495, 0.13473014533519745, 0.7813974022865295, -0.005878708325326443, -0.057042431086301804, -0.9067841172218323, -0.012305187061429024, 0.4868701100349426, 0.16414012014865875, 0.9070262312889099, -0.19622473418712616, 0.660361111164093, 0.2814372479915619, -0.766598641872406, 0.5396491289138794, -0.4366297423839569, 0.6415562033653259, 0.17873401939868927, 0.29468458890914917, 0.6950487494468689, -0.20406125485897064, -0.6216641664505005, -0.4457494914531708, 1.569588541984558, 0.6838294863700867, 0.7775666117668152, 0.5909653902053833, 0.04822142794728279, 0.6315823793411255, -0.8501901030540466, -0.8735119104385376, 0.05642104521393776, -0.08128952980041504, 0.1886645257472992, -0.10394863784313202, -0.12321306765079498, 0.3699066936969757, 0.1766268014907837, -0.29552513360977173, 0.2627382278442383, -0.12380807846784592, 0.6362831592559814, 0.4935885965824127, -0.010443429462611675, 0.44634541869163513, -0.5414803624153137, 0.3784449100494385, -0.5969576835632324, 0.11029528081417084, -0.10350386798381805, -0.011375272646546364, -0.5435970425605774, -0.3077476918697357, -0.33576735854148865, -0.5542786121368408, 0.6609790325164795, -0.03987326845526695, -0.20195434987545013, 0.5398491024971008, 0.29204854369163513, 0.21515552699565887, -0.3779778480529785, 0.027818022295832634, 1.180488109588623, 0.528950035572052, 0.34295958280563354, -1.0208866596221924, 0.43647342920303345, 0.22821079194545746, 0.5786173939704895, 0.8790729641914368, -0.43527036905288696, -1.0343576669692993, -0.9292415976524353, 0.4866984486579895, -1.1129469871520996, -0.4984857141971588, 1.3651043176651, 0.1677040010690689, 0.08583450317382812, -0.8149929642677307, -0.34958937764167786, 0.8981799483299255, -0.6780070662498474, -0.346998929977417, -0.6549822688102722, 0.07280322164297104, -0.09721134603023529, 0.9037832021713257, -0.4545579254627228, -0.5828378200531006, -0.32080432772636414, -0.1990978717803955, 0.20172502100467682, -0.5235379338264465, -0.5705066323280334, -0.0996490865945816, 0.11683256179094315, 0.11515825986862183, 0.5018468499183655, -0.2507844567298889, -0.1425504982471466, -0.36623984575271606, -0.13334621489048004, -0.34685301780700684, -0.15728765726089478, 0.49542236328125, 0.15149277448654175, 0.9354502558708191, 0.4727097451686859, 0.5297248363494873, 0.09478394687175751, 0.529772162437439, -0.13535219430923462, -0.09143926203250885, 0.014075558632612228, -0.002205674769356847, -0.6686356663703918, -0.8171960115432739, 0.0336281917989254, -0.7238379120826721, -0.46147093176841736, 0.24653621017932892, -0.24300822615623474, 0.4827537536621094, -0.024198194965720177, -0.7702005505561829, -0.4879617393016815, -0.17471469938755035, -0.6881275773048401, 0.7755506634712219, -0.7277565598487854, -0.022563260048627853, 0.20985394716262817, -0.18193238973617554, -0.04965328052639961, -0.3808717131614685, -0.13292834162712097, -0.43560609221458435, 0.029991213232278824, 0.370449036359787, 0.08201666176319122, 0.6926067471504211, -0.4104920029640198, 0.7374211549758911, -0.19117580354213715, 0.4679652750492096, -0.6589059233665466, -0.4899252951145172, -0.5547758340835571, -0.5348880887031555, 0.17966726422309875, -0.016245126724243164, -0.39121079444885254, -0.15581630170345306, 0.06036938726902008, 0.42221108078956604, -0.34479570388793945, 0.16019275784492493, -0.4622785151004791, 0.6037775874137878, 0.19545023143291473, 0.02184443362057209, 0.37561124563217163, 0.9203894734382629, 0.09100935608148575, 0.4487763047218323, 0.5162131786346436, -0.8226913213729858, 0.8009205460548401, 0.08028240501880646, 0.5895304083824158, -0.7569968104362488, -0.2875640094280243, 0.1749543845653534, 0.4077256917953491, 0.33628013730049133, 0.7189059257507324, -0.3392515182495117, -0.39638087153434753, -0.3904825747013092, -0.2319469153881073, -0.17270298302173615, -0.2818457782268524, -0.029167521744966507, 0.3109772801399231, -0.1366858184337616, -0.8012183308601379, 0.5577343702316284, -0.35217157006263733, 0.8647766709327698, 0.11783761531114578, 0.14845454692840576, -0.09030516445636749, 0.6645511984825134, 0.7491834759712219, -0.021470267325639725, -0.031684134155511856, 0.2751215994358063, -0.10000067204236984, 0.7519417405128479, -0.7676677703857422, -0.32258763909339905, -1.29252028465271, 1.0191975831985474, -0.0806957259774208, -0.18186704814434052, 0.027322707697749138, 0.9677616357803345, 0.7852534651756287, -0.9176163077354431, 0.4278564155101776, 0.05028138682246208, 0.25795605778694153, 0.8174055218696594, 0.770656168460846, -0.6409007906913757, -0.02121581695973873, -0.7937138080596924, -1.4127678871154785, 0.6290097236633301, 0.2031468003988266, -0.004071174189448357, -0.4391874670982361, -0.7116706967353821, -0.14687812328338623, -0.21109089255332947, 0.30256178975105286, 0.45625603199005127, -0.34543007612228394, -0.25913190841674805, -0.06801628321409225, 0.07874120026826859, -0.07291867583990097, -0.12823879718780518, -0.14502884447574615, 0.25178393721580505, 0.16810795664787292, 0.10771112143993378, -0.1421913504600525, -0.684459924697876, 0.019271954894065857, 0.2444913685321808, -0.014813353307545185, 0.22242897748947144, 0.816407322883606, 0.2202983796596527, -0.4422112703323364, -0.4326694905757904, -0.42904120683670044, 0.20724350214004517, 0.2675759494304657, 0.3382819890975952, 0.07213065773248672, 0.6508114337921143, -0.37797820568084717, -0.09554767608642578, -0.2699572741985321, 0.1625821888446808, 0.42963331937789917, -0.7618924379348755, -0.021681439131498337, 1.2335889339447021, 0.046174827963113785, -0.8084166646003723, 0.037043116986751556, -0.8253362774848938, 0.16778703033924103, -0.21876224875450134, -0.5971279144287109, -0.5855234265327454, -0.19668233394622803, -0.05145607888698578, 0.23001693189144135, 1.0337074995040894, 0.598965585231781, 0.6452282071113586, 0.07459520548582077, -0.4883377254009247, -0.5614446401596069, 0.08480505645275116, 1.2786343097686768, -0.0032136368099600077, -0.6927763819694519, -0.3370780944824219, 0.6971878409385681, -0.6991226077079773, -0.0377037413418293, 1.2828816175460815, -0.038569919764995575, 0.6552190780639648, -0.40373823046684265, -0.021282779052853584, 0.5855753421783447, 0.8325324058532715, -0.1246827095746994, 0.24973127245903015, -0.2875773012638092, -0.8083570003509521, -0.20580251514911652, -0.0941045805811882, -0.01673741079866886, 0.04232984408736229, -0.6323460936546326, -0.20015433430671692, -0.3056013584136963, -0.22506292164325714, -0.49892619252204895, -1.233595371246338, -0.21777643263339996, -1.2696983814239502, -0.38257455825805664, -0.7629751563072205, -0.055435314774513245, 0.10383646935224533, 0.3235398530960083, -0.19521191716194153, 0.3504008948802948, -0.9756287932395935, -0.28129956126213074, 0.08750772476196289, 0.0031427033245563507, -0.34790799021720886, -1.1167830228805542, -0.5494173765182495, 0.274690181016922, -0.4727073907852173, 0.024752799421548843, -0.2874172627925873, 0.07959941774606705, -0.20638111233711243, 0.19629839062690735, -1.068439245223999, 0.5262770056724548, -1.302901268005371, -0.8620390892028809, 0.11745894700288773, -0.1514817327260971, -1.2588609457015991, 0.0587548092007637, 0.8244086503982544, 0.14546100795269012, 0.7061352729797363, -0.20918753743171692, -0.08615004271268845, -0.5320592522621155, -0.9466630220413208, -0.3061755895614624, 0.0824994221329689, -0.4520712196826935, -0.25997450947761536, -0.7467523813247681, 0.2077445387840271, 0.39713916182518005, -0.8587549328804016, 0.5105622410774231, -0.6579806208610535, 0.7794837355613708, -0.9482592940330505, 0.39855337142944336, -0.32860761880874634, -0.0007518437341786921, -0.009290712885558605, 1.7531089782714844, -0.2120615392923355, 0.32797950506210327, 0.5387805104255676, -0.25979119539260864, -0.3989437520503998, 0.2099248319864273, 0.27569258213043213, -0.26007649302482605, 0.06574561446905136, 0.313144326210022, -0.17935332655906677, 0.7373139262199402, -0.20578813552856445, -0.3816397488117218, -0.519584596157074, -0.5067561864852905, -1.1390104293823242, 0.19078601896762848, 0.23900790512561798, -1.0726090669631958, 0.25991329550743103, -0.1557053029537201, -1.0751203298568726, 0.2489599883556366, -0.24342946708202362, -0.41486814618110657, -0.18713723123073578, -0.14766399562358856, -0.7426498532295227, -0.491337388753891, 0.13624434173107147, 0.5470999479293823, -0.00029510108288377523, 0.26563841104507446, -0.22626802325248718, -0.37155383825302124, -0.42252740263938904, 0.22365988790988922, -0.7312644124031067, 0.35719385743141174, -1.4096869230270386, 0.653272807598114, -0.37741705775260925, -0.5449241399765015, -0.058654624968767166, 0.5553125143051147, -0.15629425644874573, -0.2804619371891022, -0.3577687442302704, 0.1989327073097229, 0.3319613039493561, -0.08985615521669388, -0.3913266360759735, -0.5916813015937805, -0.5680420994758606, 0.6306784749031067, 0.3725318908691406, 0.18827702105045319, 0.291625440120697, 0.5472479462623596, 0.347823828458786, -0.49549150466918945, 0.21687434613704681, 1.5404422283172607, 0.5437007546424866, -0.2797049582004547, 0.47995057702064514, 0.060322072356939316, 0.2961218059062958, 0.6679337620735168, -0.53628009557724, -0.6735716462135315, 0.523725152015686, 0.21301347017288208, 1.6275542974472046, 0.7730689644813538, 0.6657047867774963, 0.35061633586883545, 0.16888941824436188, -0.16734269261360168, 0.8945894837379456, 0.40449780225753784, -0.12879814207553864, 0.923393726348877, -0.29965612292289734, 0.26815879344940186, 0.027581771835684776, 0.31786420941352844, 0.050166692584753036, -0.5629317760467529, -0.13341039419174194, -0.29833683371543884, -0.15748712420463562, 0.6720588803291321, -0.7464143633842468, -0.46017566323280334, -0.41046035289764404, -0.4153364896774292, -0.16050496697425842, 0.09476081281900406, 0.018996717408299446, -0.009293806739151478, 0.4804653525352478, -0.02931213565170765, 0.37877464294433594, 0.6096986532211304, 0.22669470310211182, 0.4479632079601288, 0.1628079116344452, 0.7696191072463989, 0.4935493767261505, 0.7214195728302002, 0.17344051599502563, -0.5091944932937622, 0.22953544557094574, 0.37961429357528687, -0.9340898394584656, 0.3577851951122284, -0.19346952438354492, -0.35052433609962463, -0.015462320297956467, 0.03464536368846893, 0.33309704065322876, -0.7924656271934509, -0.11676447838544846, 0.7690092325210571, -0.07616584002971649, -0.1018008440732956, 0.5967131853103638, -0.4059062600135803, -0.03311670571565628, 0.22545701265335083, -0.05227021500468254, -0.3765743672847748, 0.19832955300807953, 0.9541054964065552, -0.038944825530052185, 0.508228600025177, 0.3877893090248108, -0.0709797665476799, -0.15801455080509186, 0.30760324001312256, -0.673362672328949, 0.8305174112319946, -0.8420109748840332, -0.3527105450630188, 0.10010332614183426, -0.1221303939819336, -0.10601511597633362, 0.11950060725212097, 0.11824744194746017, 0.1765185445547104, -0.9484688639640808, -0.055442653596401215, 1.2102866172790527, 0.024128330871462822, -0.9474018812179565, -1.138102650642395, -0.5041449666023254, 0.1901819258928299, -0.0832182765007019, 0.03906274959445, 0.5637155771255493, 0.18450002372264862, -0.1700447052717209, 0.2604992687702179, -0.4515700936317444, -0.33231672644615173, -1.2646541595458984, 0.21846193075180054, -0.7334701418876648, 0.1263197958469391, 0.4946931302547455, 0.1493166834115982, 0.3281934857368469, -0.4318667948246002, 0.022516587749123573, -0.20103101432323456, 1.2923327684402466, 0.02342189848423004, -0.061157237738370895, 0.44801437854766846, -0.06299928575754166, -0.5659120082855225, 0.822449266910553, 0.3427363932132721, -0.7181103229522705, 1.0470775365829468, -0.8640817403793335, 0.7773566842079163, 0.4691750109195709, 0.10434983670711517, 0.20396828651428223, -0.17863988876342773, 0.06801895797252655, -0.1563669890165329, -0.2996649742126465, -0.10829959064722061, -1.0009148120880127, -0.3131273090839386, -0.6254900693893433, 0.32137444615364075, -0.13553516566753387, 0.20790797472000122, 0.04026351124048233, -0.19812728464603424, 4.038188457489014, 0.44552579522132874, 0.7534328699111938, 0.07340583950281143, 0.7988530993461609, 0.883154571056366, 0.0334373340010643, 0.014316820539534092, 0.26685670018196106, -0.8020595908164978, -0.32026734948158264, 0.033107977360486984, -0.007861530408263206, -0.057516761124134064, -0.2258705347776413, 1.1649917364120483, -0.16102056205272675, 0.344192773103714, 0.010175477713346481, -0.9513108134269714, -0.1900508850812912, 0.10544435679912567, 0.4302510917186737, -0.22642874717712402, 0.011143384501338005, 0.19251924753189087, 0.5405372977256775, -1.1082884073257446, -0.44970810413360596, -0.16100826859474182, -0.7657654881477356, -0.6294789910316467, 0.6985870003700256, -0.5412101745605469, -0.6709197759628296, 0.3335411846637726, -0.08589959144592285, 0.09678729623556137, 0.3242447078227997, 0.280520498752594, -0.15979745984077454, -0.4428461194038391, 0.30777424573898315, 0.24584899842739105, 0.02794518508017063, -0.049050040543079376, -0.3224449157714844, 1.0988621711730957, 0.34418562054634094, -0.959449052810669, 0.05832599848508835, -0.30872300267219543, 0.2780419588088989, -0.40761569142341614, -0.13185100257396698, 0.22470974922180176, -0.5466189384460449, -0.41745099425315857, -0.5074431300163269, 0.0668284073472023, 0.8746259212493896, -0.6855050325393677, -0.14889663457870483, 0.3607828915119171, -0.18214328587055206, 0.45991799235343933, 0.868054986000061, -0.2364870011806488, -0.2346532940864563, 0.0902215763926506, -0.7361416220664978, -0.3790367543697357, -0.49481114745140076, 0.04866618663072586, 0.38133704662323, -0.04862215742468834, 0.06065426766872406, 0.6412671804428101, 0.8877072930335999, -0.02978340908885002, -0.6471524834632874, 0.10878556966781616, -0.3504740297794342, 0.6728476881980896, -0.26178649067878723, 0.9851221442222595, -0.32835233211517334, 0.13541756570339203, -0.2610147297382355, 0.517210841178894, 0.29224422574043274, 1.3548557758331299, 0.3894500434398651, 0.6520618796348572, -1.1793920993804932 ]
Investigations of Pairing in Anyon Systems
We investigate pairing instabilities in the Fermi-liquid-like state of a single species of anyons. We describe the anyons as Fermions interacting with a Chern-Simons gauge field and consider the weak coupling limit where their statistics approaches that of Fermions. We show that, within the conventional BCS approach, due to induced repulsive Coulomb and current-current interactions, the attractive Aharonov-Bohm interaction is not sufficient to generate a gap in the Fermion spectrum.
M.I.Dobroliubov, I.I.Kogan, and G.W.Semenoff
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204005
cond-mat/9204006
[ -0.07221443951129913, -0.11913733929395676, 0.1434355527162552, -0.10532383620738983, 0.09212814271450043, 0.21831530332565308, 0.030048035085201263, -0.41257739067077637, -1.4054136276245117, 1.9511486291885376, 0.5617473721504211, -0.023150604218244553, 0.6869157552719116, -0.696136474609375, 0.23265281319618225, -0.4571607708930969, -0.44862523674964905, -0.45944368839263916, -1.062353253364563, -0.16706721484661102, 0.38576000928878784, -0.710382878780365, -0.6677303314208984, -0.1276964396238327, 0.11392951756715775, 1.017828345298767, -0.07429651916027069, 0.5195602774620056, 1.0802792310714722, 0.9196804761886597, 0.6939030885696411, -0.591564416885376, -0.2118021845817566, -0.6806374788284302, -0.17611324787139893, -0.529781699180603, -0.7593204379081726, -0.015308908186852932, 1.0710171461105347, -0.423958957195282, 0.8627328276634216, -0.737288773059845, 0.15701644122600555, -0.05510285496711731, -0.8801572918891907, -0.16370989382266998, -0.9083917737007141, -0.01612011343240738, -0.2330119013786316, -1.5847208499908447, 0.7256671786308289, -0.16771943867206573, 0.9367200136184692, 0.5349697470664978, -0.62461918592453, -0.28844359517097473, 0.3058529198169708, -0.10032098740339279, -0.32230132818222046, -0.08190266788005829, 0.8412787914276123, -0.41064900159835815, 0.7435158491134644, -1.2294832468032837, 0.48300865292549133, 0.04319268465042114, -0.45152223110198975, 0.5046773552894592, -0.38517606258392334, -0.8788331151008606, -0.9874257445335388, -0.5797279477119446, 0.0647708922624588, -0.14422886073589325, -0.435621052980423, 0.7216551899909973, 0.24817480146884918, -0.6228622198104858, -1.4946637153625488, -0.16742730140686035, -0.14373472332954407, 0.019214313477277756, -0.40214550495147705, 0.6833164095878601, -0.07123738527297974, 0.14022639393806458, -0.2475820630788803, 0.0025593482423573732, -0.3508652448654175, 0.30323249101638794, 0.5766428709030151, 0.8903579115867615, -0.7636098265647888, 0.6328136324882507, 0.5182619690895081, 0.6334067583084106, -0.04598718509078026, 0.5003888607025146, -0.028399912640452385, -0.21692010760307312, 0.35058802366256714, 0.7908788323402405, -0.8111249208450317, 0.7656168937683105, -1.2355005741119385, 0.03432346507906914, -0.37212491035461426, 0.2013428658246994, 0.018422754481434822, -0.5149407982826233, 0.4153267741203308, -0.15372686088085175, 0.5684928297996521, 0.5999731421470642, 0.08665303885936737, 0.5417546033859253, -0.6319169402122498, 0.14676396548748016, -0.9561398029327393, -0.48391976952552795, 0.44760197401046753, -0.5020860433578491, 0.45395544171333313, 0.8239298462867737, 0.19904100894927979, 0.10253719985485077, 1.0419533252716064, 0.7498496770858765, -0.5118746757507324, 0.391492635011673, 0.47348132729530334, 0.1381525844335556, 0.6164462566375732, 0.2930113971233368, -0.4924764335155487, 0.1415671557188034, -0.6277936697006226, 0.46634674072265625, 0.26116105914115906, 0.028425050899386406, 0.6202918887138367, -0.8690685033798218, 0.6381348967552185, 1.030038595199585, 0.5496165752410889, -0.22935257852077484, 0.7704548239707947, -1.0159733295440674, -0.009959659539163113, 0.2450329065322876, -0.12755762040615082, -0.18324582278728485, -0.019357265904545784, 0.2728025019168854, -0.13630954921245575, 0.07292486727237701, 0.034376468509435654, 0.4765493869781494, -0.5787203311920166, -0.31337490677833557, 0.395790159702301, 0.24502727389335632, -0.10222765803337097, 0.18558844923973083, -0.3726157248020172, 0.49404674768447876, -0.412054181098938, -0.4319812059402466, 0.2930760383605957, -1.1957919597625732, -0.10027226060628891, 0.4174313247203827, -0.7083646655082703, 0.09041154384613037, -0.1141020655632019, -0.08252905309200287, 0.5575159192085266, -0.024271558970212936, 0.21674904227256775, 0.408543199300766, -0.2785450220108032, -0.2885134518146515, 1.1493089199066162, -0.18076448142528534, -0.20501604676246643, -0.10483421385288239, -0.14028210937976837, -0.7381756901741028, 0.035086676478385925, 0.0702129378914833, -0.7224857211112976, -0.09632381051778793, 0.00037607981357723475, 0.8091471791267395, -0.11658739298582077, -0.15446226298809052, -1.3715392351150513, 0.5458078384399414, 0.0449046865105629, -0.20317308604717255, -0.8534284830093384, 0.7045047283172607, -0.7423825263977051, 0.8803256154060364, -1.369355320930481, -0.02724185772240162, 0.022748852148652077, -0.07672643661499023, -0.7816091179847717, 0.4441651403903961, 0.10571569204330444, -0.16581794619560242, 0.4482690393924713, 0.003842192003503442, -0.04706637188792229, 0.7884950041770935, 0.20129451155662537, 0.44829991459846497, 0.36131247878074646, 0.3207869529724121, 0.673244297504425, 0.32131510972976685, 0.08872747421264648, 0.8974565863609314, 0.20583204925060272, 0.00194223178550601, 0.7140318155288696, 0.10219559073448181, 0.45442745089530945, -0.12090837210416794, -0.34469348192214966, 0.2684781849384308, 1.0613042116165161, 0.0820404440164566, 0.6475206017494202, 0.2575523555278778, 0.41509300470352173, 0.5035825371742249, 0.9059104323387146, 0.26037582755088806, 0.2500106990337372, -0.165878564119339, 0.7286722660064697, -0.13176082074642181, 0.5182658433914185, 0.07467333972454071, 0.07292809337377548, 0.44879186153411865, -0.49133169651031494, 0.8118252158164978, -0.23720024526119232, 0.49303245544433594, 0.17595931887626648, -0.27335187792778015, -0.6691038012504578, -0.06067994609475136, 0.4972233772277832, 0.06464798748493195, -0.20830203592777252, -0.045427288860082626, -0.021887267008423805, -0.38772934675216675, -0.5009371638298035, -0.2529663145542145, 0.03486620634794235, 0.5499007105827332, -0.039969686418771744, -0.013893157243728638, 0.5396881103515625, -0.5070092678070068, -1.4792146682739258, -0.01211561169475317, -0.8105218410491943, -0.1244841143488884, -0.8964687585830688, 0.09128338098526001, 1.0751533508300781, -1.0566051006317139, 0.7726364731788635, 0.22107598185539246, -0.08240804821252823, 0.35728731751441956, -0.11593445390462875, 0.5977562069892883, 0.8522070050239563, 0.9023493528366089, -0.544792652130127, 0.20848043262958527, -0.07680562138557434, 0.3856949210166931, -0.4991939663887024, 0.35566264390945435, 0.8373890519142151, -0.2101052850484848, 0.8027157783508301, -0.7915187478065491, -0.6074326634407043, -0.8564602732658386, -0.3601658046245575, -0.7959108948707581, -0.23306378722190857, 0.21842794120311737, -0.2878328859806061, -0.02896491438150406, -0.7013636231422424, 0.8499745726585388, 0.5529946684837341, -0.683901846408844, 0.4235462248325348, 0.5198896527290344, -0.059886522591114044, -0.033554960042238235, 0.1158549040555954, 0.08835931867361069, -0.19420360028743744, 0.5456849336624146, 0.5813561081886292, 0.3575797975063324, -0.07415977120399475, -0.3507276177406311, -0.09663355350494385, 0.5942776203155518, 0.3154720366001129, -0.507862389087677, -0.1887584626674652, 0.7707740068435669, 0.5299255847930908, -0.7863950729370117, 0.3704710006713867, -1.2101197242736816, -0.5682691335678101, 0.3535747528076172, -0.28667953610420227, 0.984599232673645, -0.011159829795360565, 0.1483270674943924, -0.21839073300361633, 0.21189720928668976, 0.441422700881958, 0.5992014408111572, 0.42109358310699463, -0.14568817615509033, 0.9174501895904541, 0.20937088131904602, 0.2565423250198364, -0.15370365977287292, 0.670274555683136, -0.4524674415588379, -0.461664617061615, 0.6554266810417175, -0.11556265503168106, 0.3365766704082489, -0.04623272642493248, 0.7093484401702881, -0.13253246247768402, 0.8031381964683533, -0.1349579244852066, -1.0820298194885254, -0.8139140605926514, 0.18102841079235077, 0.4635307490825653, 0.48081791400909424, -0.7114278674125671, -0.7804723978042603, -1.011165976524353, -0.5042871236801147, -0.1159956306219101, 0.21894390881061554, 0.5307915806770325, -0.2724304795265198, 0.06155753135681152, 0.3478389382362366, -0.6001155376434326, 0.7449036836624146, -0.68638676404953, 0.05967872217297554, 0.3681875765323639, 1.2205259799957275, 1.3022055625915527, -0.8966899514198303, -0.20525118708610535, -0.5648325085639954, 1.183860421180725, 0.4007890820503235, 0.718254029750824, 0.5497168898582458, -0.5323296189308167, 0.15907758474349976, -0.5284366011619568, -0.17194709181785583, -0.40495628118515015, 0.19114720821380615, 0.18049770593643188, -0.5094568133354187, -0.26839539408683777, 0.0348755419254303, 0.6681292057037354, 0.2888532876968384, -0.33919456601142883, 0.22035972774028778, 0.5924842953681946, 0.6279467940330505, 0.4996257424354553, 0.8643713593482971, -0.742213249206543, -0.37557053565979004, -0.6780467629432678, 0.16617783904075623, -0.202504962682724, -0.05436311289668083, -0.16577425599098206, -0.4926508665084839, -0.9569000601768494, -0.7758311629295349, 0.2733345329761505, 0.05176708847284317, -0.2667112648487091, 1.01137375831604, 0.5117405652999878, 0.14974132180213928, -0.040954869240522385, -0.2364855706691742, 0.40382125973701477, -0.10824479907751083, 0.8311063647270203, -0.5287557244300842, 0.08637626469135284, 0.07957106828689575, 0.5784897208213806, 1.1306771039962769, -0.7020801305770874, -0.6001505255699158, -0.49977555871009827, -0.3473564684391022, -0.41708600521087646, -0.23435081541538239, 1.0581557750701904, -0.004965685307979584, -0.27967727184295654, -0.08886492997407913, 0.2958484888076782, 0.945410430431366, -0.539890706539154, -0.3497929871082306, -0.20417889952659607, -0.5508252382278442, -0.5098549127578735, 0.05795560032129288, 0.4314967393875122, -0.09670159965753555, 0.05253102257847786, -0.25901758670806885, 0.09580902755260468, -0.3168417513370514, -0.8190426230430603, -0.11491897702217102, -0.04172191023826599, -0.6046025156974792, 0.3498757481575012, -0.7090390920639038, 0.30264928936958313, -0.11687330156564713, -0.1270262897014618, -0.4521782696247101, -0.23854896426200867, -0.07662257552146912, 0.30496901273727417, 0.682925283908844, 0.6636649370193481, 0.2992156147956848, -0.045030318200588226, 0.9006580114364624, -0.5794743895530701, 0.29519253969192505, 0.246123805642128, 0.09316125512123108, -0.6959483623504639, -0.7986551523208618, -0.22932955622673035, -0.9404814839363098, -1.2370357513427734, 0.3718188405036926, -0.1517225056886673, 0.7079950571060181, -0.03128792718052864, -0.2456434667110443, -0.2043219804763794, -0.2391798496246338, -1.3466140031814575, -0.13437935709953308, 0.0508076436817646, 0.056652870029211044, 0.6035683751106262, -0.037386491894721985, 0.11409656703472137, 0.1482381522655487, -0.5252493619918823, -0.38652342557907104, 0.4866412580013275, 0.9054034352302551, -0.09826429933309555, 0.9118034839630127, 0.016271322965621948, 0.8245487809181213, -0.3440149426460266, 1.0147532224655151, 0.06897607445716858, -0.6581919193267822, -0.6774711608886719, -0.11635448038578033, 0.038762785494327545, -0.5479647517204285, 0.1755279004573822, 0.2713899314403534, 0.7417845726013184, 0.19597575068473816, -0.08795399963855743, -0.4714914560317993, -1.0947346687316895, 1.0250601768493652, -0.16086997091770172, -0.3884713649749756, 0.04254527390003204, 0.7108653783798218, 0.22494064271450043, 0.44481226801872253, -0.5004075169563293, -0.47151297330856323, -0.288621187210083, -0.1432109773159027, -0.24802784621715546, -1.2463291883468628, 0.32344159483909607, -0.32854902744293213, -0.8561248183250427, 0.674216628074646, 0.5826845169067383, -0.2970800995826721, -0.15180689096450806, 0.03188106045126915, -0.28561878204345703, 0.3160642087459564, -0.7211369276046753, -0.2541942000389099, -0.5711459517478943, -0.5147665143013, -0.5064936280250549, 0.9314722418785095, 0.03358466923236847, -0.07450178265571594, 0.6261552572250366, -0.04112306982278824, 0.7007777690887451, 0.4200233817100525, 0.0243817251175642, 0.03819423168897629, 0.026985863223671913, 0.7508107423782349, 0.09860535711050034, -0.11910218745470047, -0.648451030254364, 0.04335485026240349, -0.8235260248184204, 0.6834762692451477, 0.17933961749076843, -0.46981096267700195, -0.3862890601158142, 0.3046773672103882, 0.3122609853744507, -0.27086347341537476, -0.0710124745965004, -0.4570624828338623, -0.05680987238883972, 1.0023289918899536, 0.49995532631874084, -0.28893664479255676, -0.42388391494750977, -0.5492031574249268, -1.0223618745803833, 0.9785184264183044, 0.013219178654253483, 0.2610415518283844, -0.7391852140426636, -1.2236719131469727, 0.6489258408546448, -0.1848263442516327, 0.12538884580135345, -0.23789454996585846, 0.464220255613327, 0.14835631847381592, -0.1859016716480255, -0.3140524625778198, -0.12742754817008972, 0.045900508761405945, -0.21664606034755707, -0.510014533996582, -0.006326604168862104, -0.12788067758083344, 0.3472447395324707, -0.6608337759971619, -0.10829760879278183, -0.24806641042232513, -0.13336163759231567, -0.0009332491899840534, 0.35214391350746155, -0.6572719812393188, -0.22123990952968597, -0.5145652294158936, -0.09772754460573196, -0.17710883915424347, 0.08190560340881348, 0.6469659805297852, 0.2891124188899994, -0.3374563455581665, -0.20910347998142242, 0.4107362926006317, -0.6202174425125122, 0.008973225019872189, 0.518413782119751, 0.22938469052314758, -0.22604742646217346, 0.6404174566268921, 0.2086855173110962, -0.8806899785995483, -0.20991720259189606, -0.6094260811805725, 0.0821203961968422, -0.5103616118431091, -0.22258038818836212, 0.5326506495475769, 0.31498125195503235, -0.11195424199104309, 0.2573339641094208, 0.6540641188621521, 0.3264888823032379, 0.24744001030921936, -0.2817460596561432, -0.01381850615143776, -0.5324154496192932, -0.4582514464855194, 1.1719107627868652, -0.9343960881233215, -0.7319542765617371, -0.5130077004432678, -0.5869680643081665, -0.5443722605705261, -0.5230951905250549, 0.14585040509700775, -0.5534104108810425, 0.47884601354599, 0.37431100010871887, 0.8191438317298889, 0.35208451747894287, 0.31150445342063904, 0.1515035629272461, -0.04969741031527519, 0.24855874478816986, -0.25697216391563416, -0.6912971138954163, -0.037479303777217865, 0.17436456680297852, 0.0660049095749855, -0.462282657623291, 0.46251702308654785, 0.36069783568382263, -0.43610599637031555, -0.37638211250305176, -0.7208473086357117, -0.17370355129241943, -1.113529086112976, -0.7304911613464355, -0.5288670063018799, -0.6875544786453247, 0.01803288608789444, -0.07765615731477737, -0.4427835941314697, -0.14395597577095032, -0.8663963675498962, -0.3431749939918518, -0.2880023121833801, -0.1218138039112091, -0.25527411699295044, -0.8242563009262085, -0.9358342885971069, -0.21633027493953705, -0.2387806922197342, -0.3355950117111206, -0.16725461184978485, 0.054662108421325684, -0.4209136962890625, 0.28809165954589844, -1.0179508924484253, 0.535132646560669, -0.7423154711723328, -0.364419162273407, -0.3555889129638672, -0.2520385682582855, -0.43036985397338867, 0.03148729354143143, 0.3608195185661316, 0.4373311996459961, 0.09031274169683456, 0.2315630167722702, 0.7895440459251404, 0.3325594365596771, -0.7075961828231812, -0.2743936777114868, -0.482967734336853, -0.21686437726020813, -0.6493151783943176, -1.0888121128082275, 0.10773157328367233, 0.3495212197303772, -0.7713955044746399, 1.0300997495651245, -0.3915506899356842, 0.09916668385267258, -0.23800498247146606, -0.3783716857433319, -0.10019243508577347, 0.5010597705841064, -0.4921966791152954, 0.4961288869380951, -0.24444669485092163, -0.6236737370491028, -0.09154617041349411, 0.10069428384304047, -0.3798716366291046, 0.24747151136398315, 0.13228026032447815, -0.04722819849848747, -0.4209047257900238, 0.5222843885421753, 0.1039578840136528, 0.5507885217666626, -0.38621053099632263, -0.2491161972284317, -0.27272871136665344, -0.32770922780036926, -0.17762252688407898, 0.3322688341140747, 0.7177097797393799, -0.85652095079422, -0.38960695266723633, -0.41827163100242615, -1.3996254205703735, 0.10975851118564606, -0.6743478178977966, -0.13528096675872803, -0.36148449778556824, -0.5400699973106384, 0.36354920268058777, -0.4071519672870636, -0.026184890419244766, 0.647337794303894, 0.15229593217372894, 0.20848825573921204, -0.16056762635707855, 0.4082881510257721, 0.11180586367845535, 0.2749176025390625, -0.35288339853286743, -0.13588181138038635, -0.5132483243942261, 0.6572615504264832, -0.29595163464546204, -0.9499631524085999, -0.5519375205039978, 0.5371392965316772, -0.4255872070789337, 0.3394089341163635, -0.47347211837768555, -0.3179146349430084, -0.14128750562667847, 0.3310849964618683, 0.18343131244182587, -0.05607961118221283, 0.11697491258382797, 0.704305112361908, -0.05168302357196808, -0.2396802455186844, 0.6855794191360474, -0.23532938957214355, -0.32666727900505066, -0.4013811945915222, 0.06431498378515244, 0.7412146925926208, 0.5802987813949585, -0.04337272420525551, 1.2277690172195435, 0.459850013256073, 0.36190536618232727, -0.1399790495634079, -0.2818988263607025, 0.42957615852355957, 0.3968443274497986, -0.0002357125049456954, 0.64273601770401, 0.5018233060836792, 0.2802761197090149, 0.29575595259666443, -0.13703492283821106, 0.4210553765296936, -0.11703205853700638, 0.4155188500881195, 0.515902042388916, 0.44538572430610657, -0.27017277479171753, 0.17905907332897186, 0.5740480422973633, -0.06476662307977676, 0.5183994770050049, -0.2874454855918884, -0.16514913737773895, 0.21243922412395477, 0.5149545073509216, 0.08521462231874466, -0.2772032618522644, -0.2169172316789627, -0.11947443336248398, 0.1445586383342743, 0.20767171680927277, 0.5427966117858887, -0.1814926713705063, 0.43522122502326965, 0.7813302874565125, 0.24710454046726227, -0.09882226586341858, 0.651489794254303, 0.6918797492980957, 0.1985616385936737, 0.4190938472747803, 0.6619973182678223, 0.8089700937271118, 0.0008979930425994098, -0.3378095030784607, -1.1305451393127441, -0.16271790862083435, 0.3024035096168518, -1.520260214805603, 0.09245876967906952, -0.7093940377235413, -0.08828193694353104, -0.36346739530563354, -0.5168857574462891, 0.29295241832733154, -0.6879124045372009, 0.5480188131332397, 0.5170350670814514, 0.16867776215076447, 0.05901870131492615, 0.07800726592540741, -0.5544083118438721, -0.09387922286987305, 0.2284351885318756, 0.2760787308216095, -0.11316805332899094, 0.6893021464347839, 0.9759928584098816, -0.12003610283136368, 0.3286096155643463, 0.34462806582450867, -0.3622613847255707, 0.06463459879159927, 0.17603181302547455, -0.33126315474510193, 0.04179629683494568, -0.10570310056209564, -0.6704524159431458, 0.40308916568756104, -0.04480346292257309, -0.27878034114837646, -0.011614702641963959, -0.021919403225183487, 0.446005254983902, -0.4328431785106659, 0.13670748472213745, 1.1998801231384277, 0.27749866247177124, -0.13129931688308716, -0.5731049180030823, -0.4149981439113617, -0.557659924030304, -0.16731414198875427, -0.9465548396110535, -0.242362841963768, -0.05837530270218849, 0.4015865921974182, -0.3363630473613739, -0.6426519155502319, -0.479301393032074, -0.8408963680267334, -0.5709967613220215, -1.118945598602295, 0.47530031204223633, -0.7415452599525452, 0.4127413034439087, 0.4523114860057831, -0.0788639560341835, 0.6845389604568481, 0.4070155918598175, 0.7045233249664307, -0.06253155320882797, 0.10045164078474045, 0.7416192889213562, 0.4533573091030121, -0.3755260407924652, 0.7482738494873047, 0.8306402564048767, -0.6860981583595276, 0.28461483120918274, -0.9322692155838013, -0.4255174696445465, -0.10535915195941925, -0.46065643429756165, 0.6763289570808411, 0.13489502668380737, -0.05018269643187523, -0.5224993824958801, -0.05513015389442444, -0.2689441442489624, -0.10192281752824783, 0.21573583781719208, -0.6476061940193176, -0.2611974775791168, 0.1041618213057518, 0.5498999357223511, 0.525361180305481, -0.43553146719932556, 4.117039203643799, 1.3960845470428467, 0.49704697728157043, 0.7693786025047302, 0.21000303328037262, 1.2685985565185547, -0.2945675849914551, 0.1798715591430664, 0.10180158913135529, -0.06695625931024551, -0.17457681894302368, 0.02457049861550331, -0.17255687713623047, -0.005834512412548065, -0.3388705253601074, 0.5611966252326965, 0.11338014155626297, 0.280846506357193, 0.4625290036201477, -0.8894239664077759, -0.18934786319732666, 0.07833782583475113, 0.3995440900325775, -0.8407806158065796, 0.2125035524368286, 0.02653205581009388, 0.10581021755933762, -0.44869574904441833, -1.338729739189148, -0.06685946136713028, -0.9167575240135193, -0.625585675239563, 0.4216288626194, -0.5878700613975525, -0.49568411707878113, 0.2666466236114502, -0.2852226197719574, -0.3578130006790161, 0.6324303150177002, 0.28878259658813477, -0.31454116106033325, -0.24505580961704254, 0.3716786801815033, -0.2981422543525696, -0.5804752111434937, 0.552678644657135, -0.036984533071517944, 1.1305594444274902, -0.17913074791431427, 0.22753621637821198, 0.3858727812767029, 0.0835769921541214, 0.16766399145126343, -0.1215791404247284, -0.9467836618423462, 0.2300516664981842, -0.7934554815292358, -0.03150998428463936, 0.3698582351207733, -0.11420108377933502, 0.6812426447868347, -0.24584665894508362, -0.6705769300460815, -0.31422096490859985, -0.00048645923379808664, 0.5104764103889465, 0.9664865732192993, 0.4523265063762665, -0.24329310655593872, 0.3155238628387451, -0.20491231977939606, -0.41909417510032654, -0.367347776889801, 0.37263223528862, 0.13436859846115112, 0.6034572124481201, -0.02729804441332817, 0.5944394469261169, -0.21697784960269928, -0.3355061709880829, -0.19111566245555878, -0.18658986687660217, -0.35159558057785034, 0.5778973698616028, 0.029891563579440117, 0.28778454661369324, -0.06806689500808716, 0.12023578584194183, -0.6823821663856506, 0.3859255611896515, 0.8152259588241577, 0.8768652081489563, 0.009212122298777103, -0.44103139638900757, -0.9356787204742432 ]
Chirality Ordering of Chiral Spin Liquids
We study the effect of introducing a weak antiferromagnetic interplanar exchange coupling in the two dimensional frustrated Heisenberg model. We show that a ferromagnetic(FM) ordering of chirality - {\it i.e.}, same chirality on adjacent planes - is energetically favoured, thus leading to bulk violation of the discrete symmetries parity($P$) and time reversal($T$).
D. M. Gaitonde, Dileep P. Jatkar and Sumathi Rao
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204006
cond-mat/9204007
[ 0.2879105806350708, 0.007409616839140654, -0.2347622662782669, 0.14599397778511047, -0.24409596621990204, -0.5991795063018799, 0.14746682345867157, -0.8657411932945251, -0.5740552544593811, 2.013552188873291, 0.6042091846466064, 0.017019769176840782, 0.22060959041118622, -0.4859706461429596, -0.07445477694272995, 0.40726348757743835, 0.48601409792900085, -0.7628852725028992, -1.5303137302398682, -0.20599329471588135, -0.4116336703300476, -0.19693322479724884, -0.9309225082397461, -0.4763302803039551, -0.4919506907463074, 1.1910489797592163, 0.23812974989414215, 0.14416803419589996, 1.3042621612548828, 0.5454603433609009, 0.4069945216178894, 0.05878101661801338, -0.35496652126312256, -1.2546221017837524, 0.042681410908699036, 0.4065912663936615, 0.05152875557541847, -0.2228773683309555, 0.4793248474597931, -0.6941077709197998, 1.2813115119934082, -0.107783742249012, 0.49914804100990295, -0.5276669859886169, -0.6370086073875427, -0.2030785083770752, -0.1378198117017746, -0.2661648094654083, -0.09487434476613998, -1.285573124885559, 0.4067925214767456, 0.3733986020088196, 0.4817008078098297, 0.13135874271392822, -0.2534545361995697, -0.02896006777882576, 0.28311535716056824, 0.712554931640625, -0.36114540696144104, 0.050085969269275665, 0.08932337164878845, -0.025008758530020714, 0.446353942155838, -0.9050287008285522, 0.07540087401866913, 0.7783786058425903, 0.044622860848903656, 1.3771002292633057, 0.7085193395614624, -0.681289553642273, -0.5927562117576599, -0.7638992667198181, -0.1907026320695877, 0.05203600227832794, -0.047923650592565536, 0.18171441555023193, -0.5316329598426819, -0.225026935338974, -0.47983089089393616, -0.6128354072570801, -0.6568822860717773, -0.14561939239501953, -0.6726183295249939, 0.6588385105133057, 0.10508152842521667, -0.6306970119476318, -0.6685476303100586, 0.7479467988014221, 0.33361053466796875, 0.9793484807014465, 0.14177699387073517, 1.1272848844528198, -0.02729129046201706, -0.500603437423706, -0.02681266888976097, 0.6003074645996094, -0.02584792673587799, 0.14371812343597412, 0.4294608235359192, 0.34502801299095154, 0.2689061462879181, 0.6809464693069458, -0.2846023440361023, 0.8734846115112305, -0.20215876400470734, 0.48939400911331177, 0.16559956967830658, -0.032520268112421036, -1.0223731994628906, -0.4371878504753113, -0.0850817859172821, 0.46334341168403625, 0.22869005799293518, 0.8522472381591797, 0.3314029574394226, 0.13378381729125977, 0.1956065595149994, 0.025075262412428856, -0.7980173230171204, -0.6704092621803284, 0.3251968324184418, 0.44596603512763977, 0.8723478317260742, 0.8130838871002197, -0.0715019702911377, -0.3829593360424042, 0.7541806101799011, 0.4513813853263855, -0.0773015096783638, 0.4738670587539673, 0.17160075902938843, -0.41835275292396545, -0.009836443699896336, -0.3069189488887787, 0.11667988449335098, 0.30872103571891785, -0.5584355592727661, -0.04614841938018799, 0.4948243796825409, 0.1347811073064804, 0.1503477245569229, -0.802635908126831, -0.14553403854370117, 0.24896888434886932, 0.4792221784591675, 0.10455086082220078, 0.6809836626052856, -0.2869815230369568, 0.25435659289360046, 0.3582318127155304, -0.5502340197563171, 0.2098248451948166, -0.07115859538316727, 0.2386614829301834, -0.5962548851966858, 0.7794578075408936, -0.7681661248207092, 0.6967511177062988, -0.23992407321929932, -0.5301455855369568, 0.5087507963180542, -0.8503827452659607, 0.13593339920043945, 0.10777054727077484, -0.15268339216709137, 0.08152671903371811, -0.1657068282365799, 0.013181518763303757, -0.46558189392089844, -0.14999985694885254, 0.22474908828735352, -0.011883835308253765, -0.04890388250350952, 0.40804746747016907, 0.9180793762207031, -0.22614389657974243, 1.1968729496002197, 0.5561110973358154, -0.4577842056751251, -0.3924623131752014, -0.5761393308639526, -0.7851915955543518, 0.30774104595184326, 0.30439281463623047, -0.06134936586022377, 0.038552865386009216, -1.0766178369522095, -0.011350960470736027, 0.46952876448631287, 0.3082577586174011, -0.5598768591880798, 0.2606896162033081, -0.7558102011680603, -0.09190024435520172, -0.9270005226135254, -0.42985889315605164, -0.7964961528778076, 1.1172899007797241, -0.3664891719818115, -0.5909014344215393, -0.8101089000701904, -0.0755232572555542, -1.1035706996917725, -0.3407898247241974, -2.021207332611084, 0.3958510756492615, 0.47306740283966064, 0.49641770124435425, -0.7103903293609619, 0.3728366494178772, 0.3950936198234558, -0.21934087574481964, 0.14842143654823303, -0.12907525897026062, -0.07151878625154495, -0.5685914158821106, -1.0110455751419067, -0.16921380162239075, 0.39799022674560547, -0.08810210973024368, 0.8071479201316833, 0.02436407469213009, 0.01069517433643341, 0.47636133432388306, -0.08359614759683609, -0.04443703964352608, 0.604781985282898, 0.3231017589569092, 0.3870556354522705, 0.3083483576774597, 0.034274134784936905, 1.1189310550689697, -0.12728029489517212, 0.6306426525115967, 0.9804548025131226, 0.6452319025993347, 0.6412692070007324, 0.9362331032752991, 0.2095467895269394, 0.5553291440010071, 0.34329119324684143, 0.2170192003250122, 0.35783612728118896, 0.29009225964546204, -0.3910712003707886, 0.13113030791282654, -1.2113248109817505, 0.1331772357225418, -1.249769926071167, 0.577583372592926, -0.29447099566459656, 1.042673110961914, 0.4814547896385193, 0.40065303444862366, -0.8395567536354065, 0.19323697686195374, 0.3392098546028137, 0.3115024268627167, -0.4822971224784851, -0.10939973592758179, 0.20487982034683228, 0.3612217605113983, -0.6974026560783386, 0.17730525135993958, -0.044014912098646164, 0.0024453408550471067, -0.26534605026245117, -0.10829758644104004, -0.2988395392894745, 0.040550339967012405, -1.3257533311843872, -0.5652982592582703, -0.8179653286933899, -0.14646972715854645, -0.8081871271133423, -0.22819942235946655, 0.533783495426178, -0.6006577610969543, 1.3593108654022217, 0.1416640430688858, -0.5006728172302246, -0.16022464632987976, -0.04416867718100548, 0.610165536403656, 0.5536118149757385, 0.41461989283561707, -0.5848909020423889, -0.1916314959526062, -0.8912623524665833, 0.9190012812614441, -0.7054638862609863, 0.3868325650691986, 0.003924338612705469, -0.3642244040966034, -0.22899718582630157, -0.16741357743740082, -0.7166528701782227, -0.11334598809480667, -0.6788854598999023, -0.49457210302352905, -0.4066583812236786, 0.6847931742668152, -0.4661560356616974, -0.21838250756263733, -0.7003914713859558, 1.555225133895874, 0.024793295189738274, -0.3900410234928131, 0.4592148959636688, 0.04760410264134407, -0.7102709412574768, 0.8538116812705994, -0.15988966822624207, 0.5590750575065613, -0.1735498160123825, 0.9193159937858582, 1.298983097076416, 0.43746402859687805, 0.11275395005941391, -0.6450129747390747, -0.8603134751319885, 0.3308095932006836, 0.5519236326217651, -1.0339927673339844, -0.4552236497402191, 0.5693744421005249, 0.6309381127357483, -0.39166152477264404, 0.6272515058517456, -0.5320174694061279, -1.099178671836853, -0.715772271156311, -0.2663401663303375, 0.35184916853904724, -0.23515163362026215, -0.09906433522701263, -0.29584500193595886, -0.22196851670742035, 0.24393920600414276, 0.5030373334884644, 0.1084083765745163, -0.16726048290729523, 0.0890444740653038, 0.2100999802350998, 0.4061430096626282, 0.3370271921157837, 0.6539300084114075, -0.716732919216156, -0.5216758847236633, 0.5445873737335205, -0.7916866540908813, 0.38158470392227173, 0.4896513819694519, 0.2689895033836365, -0.05458593741059303, 0.4265921711921692, -0.45743876695632935, -0.2777751684188843, -0.9047963619232178, -0.17980696260929108, 0.2503626346588135, 1.08047354221344, -0.2820773720741272, -1.0230529308319092, -0.7540026903152466, -0.5650490522384644, 0.8710007071495056, 0.41990387439727783, 1.1578532457351685, -0.7171887159347534, 0.5512164831161499, 0.6269265413284302, -0.6422702074050903, -0.16923834383487701, -0.4227675795555115, 0.10472103953361511, 0.20656029880046844, 0.8545491099357605, 1.1848335266113281, -0.9923908114433289, -1.1445047855377197, -0.8393043279647827, 0.873590886592865, 0.5353386998176575, 0.23743081092834473, 0.07762719690799713, -0.5121987462043762, 0.10143560916185379, -0.8989037871360779, -0.8818553686141968, 0.25283506512641907, 0.10524287074804306, -0.5794951915740967, -0.20970335602760315, 0.5642248392105103, 0.4937721788883209, 0.3441562056541443, -0.02887882851064205, -0.5265550017356873, 0.713463544845581, 0.5182156562805176, 1.193671703338623, 0.06833666563034058, 0.6654579043388367, 0.05408913269639015, -0.23938621580600739, -0.231137216091156, -0.1489323079586029, -0.12531757354736328, -0.2917253375053406, -0.06161222234368324, -0.7325634956359863, -0.337222695350647, 0.021172650158405304, 0.05812401697039604, 0.756513774394989, -0.22149653732776642, 0.4849596917629242, 0.06742066890001297, 0.030546635389328003, -0.2956262230873108, -0.7171468138694763, 0.16683578491210938, 0.4407144784927368, 0.5734691619873047, 0.033489879220724106, 0.240907683968544, 0.19529786705970764, 0.6988222002983093, 0.5333914756774902, -0.824128270149231, -0.8728269934654236, -0.5861140489578247, 0.5795177817344666, -0.6132742166519165, -0.13267378509044647, 0.5299068093299866, 0.03812677413225174, 0.3771244287490845, -0.014091740362346172, -0.5390306711196899, 0.3554415702819824, -0.3186708986759186, 0.2590242922306061, -0.2144448459148407, 0.06435709446668625, 0.04434724524617195, 0.9120180606842041, 0.09839887171983719, -0.5041032433509827, -0.5343295335769653, -0.2598748207092285, 0.91974937915802, -0.13902510702610016, -0.8640536069869995, 0.33689019083976746, -0.47334548830986023, -0.282471239566803, 0.5635596513748169, 0.3990645110607147, 0.6715099215507507, 0.8579037189483643, 0.08750839531421661, -0.3880544602870941, -0.027990471571683884, 0.5080445408821106, 0.11794117838144302, 0.9371869564056396, 0.7030540108680725, 0.672725260257721, 0.05637728050351143, 0.07084380090236664, -0.033144913613796234, -0.52836674451828, 0.6367442607879639, 0.06853947043418884, -0.5781694054603577, -0.8658080101013184, -0.4771113395690918, -0.515046238899231, -0.44574642181396484, 0.08408772945404053, -0.35002562403678894, 0.5381674766540527, 0.7628710865974426, -0.7093198895454407, -0.6624910235404968, -0.6226310729980469, -0.38149723410606384, 0.3054133951663971, -0.07524379342794418, -0.026660509407520294, 0.6731147170066833, -1.2928593158721924, 0.07197548449039459, 0.4713152348995209, -0.15814891457557678, -0.5203217267990112, -0.28570595383644104, -0.04062620922923088, -0.12361867725849152, 0.13323351740837097, -0.4175598621368408, 0.6824246048927307, 0.2619607150554657, 0.4918047785758972, 0.26437172293663025, -0.3172537088394165, -0.6391106843948364, -0.6395843625068665, 0.05104489251971245, -0.27145034074783325, -0.11440003663301468, -0.4175918400287628, 0.49048787355422974, -0.2447735071182251, -0.3610021471977234, -0.20471709966659546, -1.0078603029251099, 0.8227931261062622, 0.20054829120635986, -0.8246876001358032, -0.4891413152217865, 0.9152470827102661, -0.055885881185531616, 0.22539213299751282, 0.20267772674560547, -0.6001781225204468, 0.03776291012763977, 0.11093926429748535, 0.19322215020656586, -0.6798710227012634, -0.7785337567329407, -0.0686168223619461, 0.33701109886169434, 0.07213256508111954, 0.8482401967048645, -0.5384153723716736, -0.7002783417701721, -0.0995241105556488, -0.6541403532028198, 0.10821957886219025, -0.2574889063835144, 0.23395109176635742, -0.07325993478298187, -0.5097025036811829, -1.3063329458236694, 0.8141595721244812, -0.6725283861160278, -0.4507007598876953, 0.37389782071113586, 0.12291108816862106, 0.19131217896938324, 1.0082106590270996, 0.3495789170265198, -0.6681054830551147, -0.8159410953521729, -0.018171638250350952, -0.22452335059642792, 0.2474093735218048, -0.7313138842582703, 0.49061068892478943, -1.357979655265808, 0.5929890275001526, 0.38291361927986145, -0.4166938364505768, 0.19982045888900757, -0.8555454015731812, 1.0899945497512817, -0.6418353915214539, 0.12839868664741516, -0.22400914132595062, 0.13366597890853882, 0.8393465876579285, 0.002753429114818573, -0.9573621153831482, -0.29881006479263306, -0.6868616938591003, -1.2134218215942383, 0.6533176302909851, 0.1404937356710434, 0.3426300287246704, -0.2425350695848465, -0.6543117761611938, 0.069091796875, -0.10789936780929565, 0.04701176658272743, 0.5428645014762878, -0.20041444897651672, -0.1163649931550026, 0.3048926591873169, 0.18294276297092438, -0.3692754805088043, -0.44411295652389526, 0.26145312190055847, 0.17986609041690826, -0.23622660338878632, 0.13301359117031097, -0.1767342984676361, -1.2493581771850586, -0.21330079436302185, 0.5329924821853638, 0.5275819897651672, -0.02827300690114498, 0.8133605718612671, -0.06603974103927612, -0.506883978843689, -0.4682488739490509, 0.1854964643716812, -0.23978222906589508, 0.03736022487282753, 0.6521818041801453, 0.363135427236557, 0.2934006154537201, -0.02619844675064087, -0.0632031038403511, -0.5772058963775635, 0.33093103766441345, 1.526346206665039, -0.5940542817115784, -0.6175685524940491, -0.028693946078419685, -0.07325739413499832, 0.09037547558546066, -0.6038825511932373, -0.6876097917556763, -0.09046108275651932, 0.6972545385360718, -0.5290727615356445, 0.36135509610176086, 0.1569623053073883, -0.3337630033493042, 0.8088707327842712, 0.7662602663040161, 0.054845139384269714, 0.4217807948589325, -0.1019650250673294, -0.5030513405799866, -0.6502967476844788, -0.4204441010951996, 1.4814478158950806, -0.5082754492759705, -0.6828639507293701, -0.02998770959675312, -0.21280695497989655, -1.1691181659698486, -0.1429557502269745, 0.7143714427947998, 0.5887782573699951, 0.7403506636619568, 0.4672955870628357, 0.15524940192699432, 0.5179075598716736, 0.6971734166145325, -0.1656503677368164, -0.3845532536506653, 0.19476759433746338, -0.7189604640007019, -0.07958028465509415, 0.484850138425827, 0.3067838251590729, -0.0377025343477726, -0.9508420825004578, -0.07447826117277145, -0.06605274975299835, -0.17533206939697266, -0.5096457004547119, -1.1804654598236084, -0.6694042682647705, -1.3897805213928223, -0.9742131233215332, -0.9235995411872864, -0.6087459325790405, -0.06364651024341583, 0.06121692806482315, -0.4671982228755951, 0.6417015790939331, -0.7822756171226501, -0.5771583914756775, 0.3389972746372223, 0.5360088348388672, -0.32710257172584534, -0.7241787910461426, -0.8867143988609314, 0.024530978873372078, -0.23340477049350739, 0.20719602704048157, -0.11626642942428589, 0.4071108400821686, -0.5723139643669128, 0.010381842963397503, -0.6681031584739685, 0.7308025360107422, -0.8119702935218811, -0.15644487738609314, 0.5517667531967163, -0.03161646053195, -0.6789761185646057, 0.6036394834518433, 0.22101040184497833, 0.3495577573776245, 0.5992147922515869, -0.7026075720787048, 0.10614398866891861, 0.641474723815918, -0.7456474304199219, -0.7803472876548767, -0.2343849241733551, -0.31297290325164795, -0.15452006459236145, -0.7990904450416565, 0.8316903710365295, 0.45047086477279663, -1.3320412635803223, 0.020093804225325584, -0.2434791922569275, 0.2896074950695038, -0.16444775462150574, -0.4454971253871918, 0.32320356369018555, 0.39073121547698975, -0.4886944890022278, 0.38280612230300903, -0.05193851888179779, -0.591294527053833, 0.16295112669467926, -0.3128146231174469, -0.6156201362609863, 0.05352824926376343, 0.49060842394828796, -0.9779199957847595, 0.21868444979190826, 1.0863447189331055, -1.0765742063522339, 0.35823991894721985, 0.29286396503448486, -0.4461109936237335, -0.7745681405067444, -0.3979567885398865, -0.7894407510757446, 0.7008456587791443, -0.055459920316934586, -0.9351138472557068, -0.5759045481681824, -0.21192865073680878, -0.35913628339767456, -0.3619239032268524, -0.3113894760608673, -0.06207949295639992, -0.3917998969554901, -0.19883716106414795, -0.7628910541534424, -0.14024600386619568, -0.26945760846138, 0.03668186068534851, 0.4039090871810913, 0.32025930285453796, -0.34400835633277893, -0.3054557144641876, -0.4877317249774933, 0.11527413129806519, -0.9569938778877258, 0.3909001052379608, -0.45931118726730347, 0.7739359140396118, 0.136863112449646, -0.5448296666145325, -0.5352411270141602, -0.06954538077116013, 0.2285282164812088, -0.03506970778107643, 0.39990055561065674, 0.6381852030754089, 0.2464257925748825, 0.6141733527183533, -0.5126844644546509, 0.08570186793804169, -0.038955699652433395, 0.7171464562416077, 0.15973255038261414, -0.6221690773963928, 0.8790102601051331, 0.3412443995475769, 0.16495360434055328, 0.0013947790721431375, -0.2780575156211853, 1.065709114074707, -0.0750802755355835, -0.7985431551933289, 0.6729840040206909, 0.2488892674446106, 0.4300971031188965, -0.0900464728474617, -0.8451061248779297, -0.39918312430381775, 0.23393939435482025, 0.4862780272960663, 0.7219502925872803, 0.5198588371276855, 0.21772561967372894, 0.8665661811828613, 0.5149235129356384, 0.3606056272983551, 0.23873426020145416, 0.2816655933856964, -0.06619996577501297, 0.6033411026000977, -0.4170546531677246, 0.5948675274848938, -0.31417733430862427, 0.1783904880285263, -0.04210984706878662, 0.22932173311710358, -0.24592317640781403, 0.8366939425468445, 0.23991438746452332, 0.46673646569252014, -0.7940508723258972, -0.6475895047187805, -0.3249181807041168, 0.14112401008605957, 0.4781908690929413, 0.2795213460922241, 0.3541719615459442, 0.5501148700714111, 0.479231059551239, -0.026352370157837868, -0.10723324865102768, 0.13658203184604645, 0.5528823137283325, -0.23758567869663239, 0.04620382934808731, 0.8100129961967468, 0.665389358997345, 0.6580316424369812, 0.28992214798927307, -0.04856731742620468, -0.5469813942909241, 1.2015106678009033, -1.0409728288650513, -0.6792160868644714, -0.31993359327316284, -0.7592194080352783, -0.10588706284761429, -0.3761828541755676, 0.5954343676567078, -0.5249412655830383, 0.35496100783348083, 0.6121661067008972, -0.5548918843269348, 0.3518978953361511, 0.517012894153595, -0.06465870141983032, 0.5824347138404846, 0.43085312843322754, 0.711491584777832, -0.8175303339958191, 1.1637241840362549, 0.711975634098053, 0.051367394626140594, -0.07876183837652206, 0.1821271777153015, 0.2418854832649231, -0.49586838483810425, 0.3326883912086487, -0.1536627858877182, 1.252125859260559, -0.6885706186294556, -0.2605508863925934, 0.8406260013580322, 0.22653719782829285, -0.2528848946094513, -0.13829369843006134, 0.6353467106819153, 0.7862062454223633, -0.17921708524227142, -0.19254767894744873, 1.3238407373428345, 0.23265035450458527, 0.3199421167373657, -0.3243270516395569, 0.19924958050251007, -0.08490274846553802, -0.718690037727356, -0.4441410303115845, 0.45875751972198486, 0.010558713227510452, 0.5089569687843323, 0.20474876463413239, -0.7115122079849243, -0.21240383386611938, -0.2328191101551056, -0.3333698511123657, -0.8446479439735413, 0.6598863005638123, 0.5046030282974243, 1.0624655485153198, 0.06043868511915207, -0.9108508825302124, -0.06982852518558502, 0.3062322437763214, 0.8287267684936523, 0.14407406747341156, 0.35755330324172974, 0.012986844405531883, 0.03868599236011505, -0.22211536765098572, 0.8285396099090576, 1.109973669052124, -0.26681920886039734, 1.079485535621643, -0.689037024974823, 0.7944767475128174, -0.257405549287796, -0.04059094935655594, 0.09302962571382523, 0.6605337858200073, 0.44078585505485535, -0.7979755997657776, -0.5548680424690247, -0.05532344803214073, -1.0987921953201294, 0.045177802443504333, -1.1920334100723267, -0.22536751627922058, 0.2789847254753113, 0.45482492446899414, 0.2424185872077942, -0.14885513484477997, 3.8077681064605713, 0.8219162225723267, 0.5265682935714722, 0.46370774507522583, 0.5293709635734558, 0.49010327458381653, 0.40854936838150024, -0.4454188346862793, 0.6948546171188354, -0.7608819007873535, -0.3926360309123993, 0.3257383406162262, -0.15980635583400726, -0.19892656803131104, 0.3208717405796051, 0.6658194661140442, 0.16799713671207428, 0.19976000487804413, -0.4345012605190277, -0.91139155626297, -0.4883204400539398, -0.2679966688156128, 0.13061511516571045, -0.4484168291091919, 0.6832378506660461, 0.04940333962440491, -0.17328669130802155, -0.5878473520278931, -0.41684263944625854, -0.25868427753448486, -0.7298922538757324, -0.5201060771942139, 0.811499297618866, -0.0054467166773974895, -0.9909748435020447, 0.08002989739179611, 0.7397729754447937, -0.32133951783180237, 0.6682248115539551, 0.863341212272644, -0.5445302724838257, -1.194338321685791, 0.16237479448318481, -0.058053210377693176, -1.1641361713409424, 0.603776752948761, -0.6129134893417358, 0.8999984860420227, -0.5414047837257385, -0.7184482216835022, 0.2337949573993683, -0.07520730048418045, -0.2456441968679428, -0.40866297483444214, -1.2954590320587158, 0.17247261106967926, -0.27251186966896057, -0.6550118327140808, 0.2954653799533844, 0.5766035914421082, 0.8775464296340942, 0.5440998673439026, -0.5196893811225891, 0.28645411133766174, -0.021830840036273003, -0.1027219370007515, 0.8083171248435974, 0.34556955099105835, -0.18360351026058197, -0.00531370984390378, -0.41398924589157104, -0.008822654373943806, -0.050795778632164, 0.0482819601893425, 0.7958707213401794, 0.47000986337661743, -0.24731309711933136, 0.09051258862018585, 0.14879046380519867, 0.4297591745853424, 0.09960418194532394, -0.19017454981803894, -0.5670770406723022, 0.20946580171585083, -0.1417211890220642, 0.38143497705459595, -0.9734195470809937, 0.1483209729194641, -0.18952833116054535, 0.3507121503353119, 0.32209548354148865, 1.0484161376953125, -0.085149385035038, -0.3802400529384613, -0.39318495988845825 ]
Theory of Directed Polymers
We develop a theory of polymers in a nematic solvent by exploiting an analogy with two-dimensional quantum bosons at zero temperature. We argue that the theory should also describe polymers in an {\sl isotropic} solvent. The dense phase is analyzed in a Bogoliubov-like approximation, which assumes a broken symmetry in the phase of the boson order parameter. We find a stiffening of the longitudinal fluctuations of the nematic field, calculate the density-density correlation function, and extend the analysis to the case of ferro- and electrorheological fluids. The boson formalism is used to derive a simple hydrodynamic theory which is indistinguishable from the corresponding theory of polymer nematics in an isotropic solvent at long wavelengths. We also use hydrodynamics to discuss the physical meaning of the boson order parameter. A renormalization group treatment in the dilute limit shows that logarithmic corrections to polymer wandering, predicted by de Gennes, are unaffected by interpolymer interactions. A continuously variable Flory exponent appears for polymers embedded in a {\sl two}-dimensional nematic solvent. We include free polymer ends and hairpin configurations in the theory and show that hairpins are described by an Ising-like symmetry-breaking term in the boson field theory.
R.D. Kamien, P. Le Doussal, and D.R. Nelson
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204007
cond-mat/9204008
[ 0.6844755411148071, 0.6736863851547241, -0.36250030994415283, 0.47686058282852173, -0.3684600591659546, 0.20778581500053406, -0.07092886418104172, -0.6867818236351013, 0.017471708357334137, 1.1546229124069214, 0.6775220036506653, -0.2462703138589859, 0.7480113506317139, -1.4299575090408325, -0.33080658316612244, 0.12701541185379028, -0.6223796010017395, 0.3880925476551056, -1.3960376977920532, -0.21775934100151062, -0.4890352785587311, 0.09190202504396439, -1.3565750122070312, -0.6597631573677063, -0.4073903262615204, -0.12219499796628952, -0.046572353690862656, 0.2542029917240143, 0.3763888478279114, 0.7007452845573425, 0.0331573449075222, -0.728924572467804, -0.22576577961444855, -1.9948517084121704, 0.26973092555999756, -0.12272509187459946, 0.20078596472740173, 0.6169679164886475, 0.6721206903457642, -0.5016451478004456, 0.5091726779937744, 0.5132417678833008, -0.3006221055984497, -0.18034620583057404, 0.19701571762561798, -0.6961045265197754, -0.9035041332244873, -0.999932587146759, -0.606273889541626, -0.741196870803833, 0.11936142295598984, 0.4665215313434601, 0.76463782787323, -0.11385814845561981, -0.06200060620903969, -0.08048377931118011, 0.0838269367814064, -0.5574687123298645, -0.13987737894058228, -0.19171656668186188, 1.0961652994155884, -0.7089529633522034, 0.4643491506576538, -0.6835547685623169, 0.88504558801651, -0.0882817804813385, 0.007244473323225975, 0.8951550722122192, 0.21194754540920258, -0.09839677065610886, -0.31853556632995605, 0.4547496438026428, -0.17238478362560272, -0.7059844136238098, -0.7120881080627441, 0.06724678725004196, 0.5471835136413574, -0.412514865398407, -0.8116201758384705, 0.018489528447389603, -0.0920194685459137, -0.8189249038696289, -0.3567922115325928, 0.5910474061965942, 0.1621633917093277, -0.08447518199682236, -0.427820086479187, -0.2550951838493347, 0.11531897634267807, 0.5835266709327698, 0.5676990747451782, 0.9581336379051208, -0.05560443922877312, 0.10696727782487869, 0.10735759884119034, 0.37396347522735596, -0.023159973323345184, 0.5698962807655334, 0.4766257107257843, 0.18580912053585052, -0.35948821902275085, 0.33930474519729614, -0.6665692925453186, 0.7126498222351074, -0.22803373634815216, 0.6431294083595276, -0.08811686933040619, -0.13667406141757965, 0.711992084980011, -0.2820127010345459, 0.11319513618946075, 0.35893696546554565, 0.46307966113090515, 0.5295446515083313, -0.7628239989280701, 0.6546047329902649, 0.1127382144331932, 0.08330788463354111, -0.16443708539009094, -0.4113498032093048, -0.4571533799171448, 0.3953041434288025, 0.8596183061599731, 0.606890082359314, -0.36266353726387024, -0.38342610001564026, 0.5059329271316528, 0.15582847595214844, -0.43612608313560486, -0.3254888355731964, -0.21982061862945557, 0.15607988834381104, -0.11963405460119247, 1.1132532358169556, -0.31178855895996094, 0.15972058475017548, 0.17113466560840607, 0.1733008474111557, 0.3923059105873108, 0.2870437800884247, 0.29159969091415405, -0.5183155536651611, 0.8145010471343994, 1.1706595420837402, -0.7598714232444763, -0.42876890301704407, -0.24202488362789154, 0.2080039232969284, 0.49857503175735474, 0.33590415120124817, -0.557527482509613, -0.4232071340084076, -0.16983160376548767, 0.4421379268169403, 0.29754143953323364, 0.12792004644870758, -0.6871324777603149, 0.24680371582508087, -0.2539583444595337, -0.4615837633609772, -0.31350505352020264, -0.22708988189697266, 0.5732459425926208, -0.2252812683582306, -1.0358158349990845, 0.11131222546100616, -0.5053050518035889, -0.7386662364006042, 0.7957171201705933, -0.38356339931488037, -0.5859860181808472, 0.5256013870239258, -0.10093101114034653, 0.7662147283554077, 0.03223300352692604, 0.7375423908233643, 0.7747325897216797, 0.0572313629090786, 0.07494565844535828, 0.06468170881271362, 0.34404662251472473, -0.10113975405693054, 0.7142176628112793, 0.4791421592235565, -0.31965968012809753, 0.08512682467699051, -0.12929551303386688, -1.0952876806259155, 0.3244355320930481, 0.06349952518939972, -0.6610310673713684, 0.05597284436225891, 0.04307689145207405, 0.17104053497314453, -1.0965136289596558, -0.291165828704834, -0.4309696555137634, 0.44514593482017517, -0.289712131023407, -0.6775407791137695, -0.7647310495376587, 0.20063050091266632, -0.6520046591758728, 0.5185719132423401, -0.6496487855911255, -0.18977755308151245, 0.276570588350296, 0.9691162705421448, -0.760854959487915, -0.26562538743019104, 0.688736617565155, 0.1574389785528183, 0.05295329913496971, 0.8198471069335938, 0.6012677550315857, 0.2850092649459839, -0.09666656702756882, 0.5506190061569214, 0.5042576789855957, 0.12399251013994217, 0.23153752088546753, 0.12893693149089813, 0.15392380952835083, 0.42315036058425903, -0.011642097495496273, -0.15972499549388885, 0.021244565024971962, 0.5565502643585205, 0.23286370933055878, -0.9145631790161133, 0.26932528614997864, 0.3916197717189789, 0.09168603271245956, 0.4905008375644684, 1.1647695302963257, 0.2617047131061554, -0.11579951643943787, 0.4158906638622284, -0.18870896100997925, -0.19759173691272736, -0.14161895215511322, -0.16849035024642944, -0.012102137319743633, 0.015273183584213257, -0.17344234883785248, -0.5513112545013428, -0.662818431854248, 0.35975971817970276, -0.7613052129745483, 0.26394209265708923, 0.1009291410446167, 0.45051953196525574, 0.4126053750514984, 0.9242602586746216, -0.9464040398597717, -0.46156856417655945, -0.09963463991880417, 0.32284486293792725, 0.022388234734535217, -0.07047596573829651, 0.6717637181282043, 0.047849930822849274, -0.08390287309885025, -0.37315624952316284, 0.5324348211288452, 0.44756001234054565, 0.0777127593755722, 0.25416308641433716, 0.13804294168949127, -0.11004693806171417, -1.2428966760635376, -0.4104773700237274, -0.4622068703174591, -0.10695382952690125, -0.5455162525177002, 0.5581174492835999, 1.3555387258529663, -1.3002281188964844, 0.7188109159469604, -0.36010220646858215, -0.3271125257015228, 0.2102569192647934, -0.6833868622779846, 0.12295147031545639, 0.40361642837524414, 0.4732077717781067, -0.5046587586402893, 0.4278770983219147, -0.6521934270858765, 0.41470083594322205, -0.7474513053894043, 0.4321416914463043, 0.871834397315979, -0.5819727778434753, 0.9000457525253296, -0.6477711796760559, -0.6003605723381042, 0.22819766402244568, 0.4538135230541229, -0.20295605063438416, -0.2909582555294037, 0.04492536932229996, -0.6397380828857422, -0.5017837882041931, -0.1488344818353653, 0.604881763458252, -0.04164827615022659, -0.23325839638710022, 0.38285893201828003, 0.30283042788505554, 0.07686883956193924, 0.17121747136116028, 0.458612859249115, -0.09940829873085022, 0.16106942296028137, 0.8237543106079102, 0.4190075397491455, 0.001744288019835949, -0.3232535421848297, -0.15026767551898956, -0.5035011172294617, -0.7408135533332825, 0.11345884203910828, -0.32644087076187134, 0.0617251917719841, 0.32738807797431946, -0.1127275750041008, -0.49345076084136963, -0.07417941838502884, -1.4461579322814941, -0.25541752576828003, -0.16470423340797424, -0.17229382693767548, 1.2319821119308472, -0.3203169107437134, -0.5503680109977722, -0.8817712664604187, 0.4247957766056061, 0.8497747778892517, -0.309052437543869, 0.448169082403183, -0.676136314868927, 1.0934721231460571, 0.663159191608429, 0.03789526969194412, 0.12185923010110855, -0.37898963689804077, -0.20079763233661652, -0.7120843529701233, -0.05334559828042984, -1.5642839670181274, -0.07889094948768616, -0.2672427296638489, 0.6085942983627319, 0.5399398803710938, 0.8774773478507996, -0.2668207585811615, -0.7636083364486694, -0.22510996460914612, -0.16423650085926056, 0.5377486944198608, 1.1708781719207764, 0.20645873248577118, 0.33997341990470886, -0.57539963722229, -0.546959400177002, -0.65186607837677, -0.37221258878707886, 0.4694775938987732, -0.6852858066558838, 0.17997261881828308, 0.5578919649124146, 0.08205592632293701, 0.3569570481777191, -0.425211101770401, -0.2185065895318985, 0.2891678214073181, 0.5524933338165283, 0.6572704315185547, -0.8312973976135254, -0.30798861384391785, 0.5084810853004456, 0.9706832766532898, 0.18876758217811584, 0.9873634576797485, 0.48378124833106995, 0.14814336597919464, 0.5555940270423889, -0.14306102693080902, -1.3324425220489502, -0.15094271302223206, 0.24414578080177307, -0.3420792520046234, -0.264113187789917, -0.05467655509710312, -0.055519361048936844, 0.453960657119751, 0.6119347810745239, 0.1819850504398346, 0.46378159523010254, 0.08308016508817673, 1.076778769493103, 1.512984037399292, -0.14136703312397003, -0.4754491448402405, -0.42311039566993713, -0.6797659993171692, -0.6599576473236084, -0.33090969920158386, 0.10788998752832413, -0.4792991280555725, -0.6013991832733154, -0.8113004565238953, -0.4158543348312378, 0.6016470193862915, 0.43038296699523926, 0.21924200654029846, 0.4987049996852875, -0.09947513043880463, 0.610100269317627, -0.9647843837738037, -0.03589944913983345, 0.5494044423103333, -0.3388732969760895, 0.4822017550468445, -0.9255061745643616, 0.7787160873413086, -0.5897796750068665, 0.9937460422515869, 1.046911597251892, -1.0724918842315674, -0.8431589603424072, 0.29280686378479004, -0.2504563629627228, -0.5948379039764404, 0.21158817410469055, 0.13777336478233337, 0.7201907634735107, 0.27862080931663513, -0.585456371307373, -0.42611265182495117, 0.07198720425367355, -1.0619490146636963, 0.46601441502571106, -0.26011648774147034, -0.3585869371891022, -0.273384690284729, 0.28025496006011963, -0.3142012655735016, -0.3689481317996979, -0.2493445724248886, -0.6848723292350769, 0.1646541804075241, 0.19920945167541504, -0.8736740350723267, -0.5910204648971558, -0.09624592214822769, -0.5419152975082397, 0.44309061765670776, -0.26540204882621765, 0.3321892321109772, -0.1814270317554474, 0.01087362039834261, -0.6240337491035461, -0.7555598616600037, 0.2838020324707031, -0.46120956540107727, 0.6639214158058167, -0.06828833371400833, 0.11296490579843521, 0.6520807147026062, 0.04115307703614235, -0.09613098204135895, -0.3032098114490509, 0.06668845564126968, -0.1309032291173935, -0.03473243489861488, -0.5258067846298218, -0.4450814127922058, -1.0672694444656372, -0.36708319187164307, 0.5981823205947876, -0.5187345743179321, 0.5212666988372803, -0.015532398596405983, -0.6471068859100342, 0.12404464185237885, -0.07206861674785614, -0.8569738864898682, 0.7394270896911621, 0.1404084414243698, -0.0426376536488533, 0.2628948390483856, -0.3511703908443451, 0.1347321718931198, 0.5400712490081787, -0.42973896861076355, -0.9278035163879395, 0.7265276908874512, 0.5176693201065063, -0.17846991121768951, 0.21546059846878052, -0.38502374291419983, 0.5496724247932434, -0.6783387660980225, 0.2411385178565979, -0.4254796504974365, 0.02512112632393837, -0.706060528755188, -0.18101826310157776, 0.17636166512966156, 0.07593050599098206, -0.1989421248435974, -0.2586153745651245, -0.0008145474712364376, 0.5011617541313171, -0.10746435075998306, 0.5200141072273254, -1.5677119493484497, 0.4507308304309845, 0.08542089909315109, -0.022257424890995026, -0.3731674551963806, 0.6010630130767822, 0.4418565630912781, 0.21503891050815582, 0.25074502825737, -0.5618237257003784, 0.5178456902503967, 0.06621908396482468, 0.618224561214447, -0.9365474581718445, 0.09792837500572205, -0.7310914397239685, -0.431858092546463, 0.08590172976255417, 0.523625373840332, 0.00952970515936613, 0.7580952048301697, -0.6098862886428833, -0.4365525543689728, -0.1355067491531372, 0.12425114214420319, -0.32522234320640564, -0.21189755201339722, -0.5549578666687012, -0.9244384765625, 1.2558056116104126, -0.5383336544036865, -0.0004223608411848545, 0.766318678855896, -0.3513195216655731, -0.15517473220825195, 0.2692152261734009, 0.695035994052887, -1.066994071006775, 0.2098025530576706, 1.30259108543396, -0.25901010632514954, 0.057686347514390945, -0.7533366680145264, 1.0206410884857178, -0.860362708568573, 0.6589250564575195, -0.06288526952266693, -0.14286808669567108, 0.12053947895765305, 0.2660338878631592, 0.25738170742988586, -0.6980599761009216, 0.07232996076345444, 0.26558879017829895, 0.14198721945285797, 0.6002217531204224, 0.31709879636764526, -0.0418892577290535, -1.1591122150421143, -0.19138355553150177, -0.7311081886291504, 0.6907979846000671, 0.10972486436367035, -0.23581066727638245, -0.22782233357429504, -0.7462553977966309, -0.3096163272857666, 0.001355201588012278, 0.9711483120918274, 0.32809847593307495, 0.31234708428382874, -0.014129959978163242, 0.4930528700351715, 0.40843838453292847, 0.14668907225131989, 0.30943945050239563, 0.34750470519065857, -0.8221158385276794, 0.3255787491798401, -0.0349256657063961, -0.9291935563087463, -1.0030618906021118, -0.0711648091673851, 0.6486820578575134, 0.06521981954574585, -0.2612856924533844, 0.37505337595939636, 0.18507051467895508, -0.16192695498466492, -0.27804499864578247, -0.09722000360488892, 0.13812881708145142, 0.6805844306945801, 0.42452168464660645, 0.2083015739917755, -0.2990042269229889, 0.2386510819196701, 0.20476412773132324, -0.4058169424533844, 0.3904079794883728, 0.526080846786499, -0.9133179783821106, -0.8401877880096436, -0.16455808281898499, 0.3327958285808563, -1.439334750175476, -1.218410849571228, -0.8480854630470276, -0.14402906596660614, 0.47237667441368103, -0.18962256610393524, 0.059802133589982986, -0.27609625458717346, -0.14073143899440765, 0.1775353103876114, 0.6941157579421997, 0.40277332067489624, 0.062354061752557755, -0.04974478483200073, -0.4385847747325897, -0.4962080121040344, -0.103582963347435, 1.4137862920761108, -0.4586588144302368, -0.7155349254608154, -0.36279624700546265, -0.6063893437385559, -0.8163103461265564, 0.028640931472182274, 0.9871588349342346, -0.16080428659915924, 0.4596536159515381, 0.059620875865221024, 0.3886832892894745, 0.7148562073707581, 0.8276339173316956, -0.3212427794933319, 0.167968288064003, 0.3887190818786621, -1.2237260341644287, -0.16523593664169312, -0.16422080993652344, 0.2834993898868561, 0.8119829297065735, -0.53249591588974, 0.08353079110383987, 0.04353618994355202, -0.21693338453769684, -0.14419680833816528, -0.6174541115760803, 0.5884138345718384, -0.4571235477924347, -0.3212718069553375, -0.5032073855400085, -0.4695180654525757, 0.08788583427667618, 0.01508986484259367, -0.27626827359199524, -0.45933499932289124, -0.534485399723053, -0.12207507342100143, 0.17262433469295502, -0.17455840110778809, 0.02939533442258835, 0.0045638540759682655, -0.7123873829841614, -0.144475519657135, -0.14948324859142303, -0.23855537176132202, -0.14778588712215424, -0.1450146585702896, -0.09509332478046417, -0.08867034316062927, -0.0630248636007309, 0.6638043522834778, 0.11140453070402145, -0.2001420110464096, 0.112481988966465, 0.1660442352294922, -0.8056076169013977, 0.2731442451477051, 0.0008290842524729669, -0.15525700151920319, -0.07671792060136795, 0.3874625265598297, 0.40131592750549316, 0.5302512049674988, -0.5837638974189758, -0.15393182635307312, 0.19215303659439087, 0.2565792202949524, 0.08002863079309464, -0.4208245277404785, 0.5325098633766174, 0.3420197069644928, -0.6747271418571472, -0.20942862331867218, -1.0929923057556152, -0.4019159972667694, -0.09150385856628418, 0.05557389184832573, -0.8823784589767456, 0.17152039706707, -0.4158921539783478, 0.974198579788208, 0.45213639736175537, -0.4153688848018646, -0.09151170402765274, 0.949581503868103, -0.33996155858039856, 0.351274311542511, -0.04589010030031204, 0.14525452256202698, -0.17598740756511688, 0.7536637187004089, -0.6654264330863953, 1.3688158988952637, 0.13730305433273315, 0.3494851589202881, -0.29475560784339905, -0.08931541442871094, -1.0181477069854736, 0.07977057248353958, -0.3309699296951294, -0.8033329844474792, 0.3664616644382477, 0.0236650537699461, -0.38966116309165955, 1.073683500289917, -0.5310813784599304, -0.7181256413459778, -0.14150026440620422, -0.7147181034088135, -0.693737268447876, 0.001567915198393166, -0.2908386290073395, 0.7718965411186218, -0.14960245788097382, 0.307218462228775, -0.2191329151391983, -0.21059532463550568, 0.34086570143699646, 0.27759045362472534, -0.9538717269897461, -0.268218457698822, -0.7092575430870056, 0.18788348138332367, -0.5532573461532593, -0.8509293794631958, 0.524972140789032, 1.3834006786346436, -0.3418317139148712, -0.19918370246887207, -0.5774593353271484, -0.4973655939102173, -0.32768514752388, 0.5782589316368103, 0.6419404745101929, -0.26040172576904297, -0.1760510802268982, 0.9583426713943481, -0.6463515162467957, -0.47161397337913513, 1.0349200963974, 0.35783055424690247, 0.05649607256054878, -0.10915657877922058, -0.3560749292373657, 1.0263136625289917, 0.1898151934146881, -0.4778288006782532, 1.6114033460617065, 0.025478878989815712, 0.7775893807411194, 0.545543372631073, -0.7377414107322693, -0.12087664753198624, 0.2977398931980133, 0.4419807195663452, 1.1076799631118774, -0.03768359497189522, 0.03423607721924782, 0.11591511219739914, 0.2727632224559784, 0.13875870406627655, -0.07477877289056778, 0.338906466960907, -0.46113160252571106, 0.7256180047988892, -0.6986207365989685, 0.673896074295044, 0.2506747245788574, 0.1921580582857132, -0.29652464389801025, -0.5310190320014954, -0.3130629062652588, -0.0842232033610344, -0.37283530831336975, 0.24631987512111664, -0.8061566948890686, 0.6496046185493469, -0.6285721659660339, 0.24717925488948822, 0.19581928849220276, -0.45559147000312805, -0.29304006695747375, 0.3189808130264282, 0.04718027636408806, 0.06352782249450684, 0.3076700270175934, 0.6168715357780457, -0.2709828019142151, 0.3770413100719452, 0.19809330999851227, 1.2224853038787842, 0.7770770192146301, 0.8439847826957703, 0.12617836892604828, -0.48923423886299133, 0.18098045885562897, 0.6046813726425171, -1.0232053995132446, 0.284254252910614, 0.2898178696632385, 0.03155938908457756, -0.48143550753593445, -0.35062089562416077, 0.25571006536483765, -1.1392710208892822, -0.2920058071613312, 0.8979216814041138, 0.036049358546733856, -0.0625094547867775, 0.744030773639679, 0.07464608550071716, 0.1789095401763916, 0.7693642973899841, 0.5448660254478455, -0.829785943031311, 1.1791900396347046, 0.6405672430992126, 0.43469300866127014, 0.11465951800346375, -0.41186171770095825, -0.6108706593513489, -0.21781405806541443, -0.29144230484962463, -0.4595318138599396, 1.0473606586456299, -0.3637542724609375, 0.044532082974910736, 0.004353221505880356, -0.31675681471824646, 0.30691707134246826, 0.5792186260223389, -0.17263434827327728, -0.09723973274230957, -0.4302234351634979, -0.24380362033843994, 1.1503249406814575, 0.9673171639442444, -0.7797043919563293, -1.023406744003296, -0.43725496530532837, 0.6032398343086243, -0.7976307272911072, -0.05810266360640526, 0.47356727719306946, 0.8069522976875305, 0.11299450695514679, 0.2391439974308014, 0.03157918155193329, -0.9600026607513428, -0.3215513527393341, -0.46671754121780396, -0.8892706632614136, 0.14747439324855804, -0.3580455780029297, 0.19674167037010193, 0.4280342757701874, -0.43802815675735474, 0.11516213417053223, 0.04925839230418205, 1.1220388412475586, 0.35462650656700134, 1.0527853965759277, 1.0251553058624268, -0.3956453800201416, 0.16258375346660614, 0.32290637493133545, -0.20354042947292328, -1.342301368713379, 0.2559451162815094, -0.5856980681419373, 0.24636170268058777, 0.35827767848968506, 0.18240034580230713, -0.42317935824394226, -0.05208297073841095, -0.3090863823890686, -0.6131430864334106, -0.2550869882106781, -0.5174261927604675, -0.7104016542434692, 0.06445958465337753, -0.1521625518798828, -0.05967625230550766, 0.04332269728183746, 0.32459864020347595, 0.7674009799957275, -0.5285588502883911, 3.9320108890533447, 1.317551851272583, 0.9206302762031555, -0.29108089208602905, 0.1575252264738083, 0.27144911885261536, -0.14350517094135284, -0.27668511867523193, -0.11951125413179398, -0.7894642353057861, 0.23433099687099457, -0.41620326042175293, -0.2562023997306824, -0.8197046518325806, -0.3648892343044281, 1.1329457759857178, 0.717068612575531, -0.1155577301979065, -0.058335836976766586, -0.18495766818523407, -0.17527124285697937, 0.742042601108551, 0.11438442766666412, -0.14685821533203125, 0.3254231810569763, 0.6628749370574951, -0.6085812449455261, 0.13286130130290985, -0.5978391170501709, -0.47247084975242615, -0.8818139433860779, -0.4696807861328125, 0.352251797914505, -0.3176175653934479, -0.33019623160362244, 0.8099684715270996, 0.5597449541091919, -0.10530317574739456, 0.02037852443754673, -0.04596495255827904, -0.2085970789194107, 0.5443599820137024, 0.15444974601268768, 0.20148438215255737, -1.1547648906707764, 1.0835710763931274, -0.2720177173614502, 0.8231701850891113, 1.2586044073104858, -0.46484166383743286, 0.4281602203845978, -0.3134707808494568, -0.41568833589553833, -0.16005206108093262, -1.1706897020339966, 0.3443971276283264, -0.47709324955940247, -0.2819831371307373, -0.5772604942321777, -0.23691298067569733, 1.2193248271942139, 0.00041133613558486104, -0.2672135829925537, -0.5183124542236328, -0.49295952916145325, 0.38081052899360657, 0.3889915943145752, 0.5199223160743713, 0.060432273894548416, 0.06941647827625275, -0.42367011308670044, 0.08571740984916687, -0.8798213005065918, 0.42425960302352905, 0.13173413276672363, 0.3397751748561859, -0.04917497932910919, -0.18823865056037903, -0.2659291923046112, -0.15099677443504333, 0.0780767872929573, 0.026860440149903297, -0.35821858048439026, 0.6473573446273804, 0.17894892394542694, 0.932234525680542, -0.5270729064941406, -0.5347915291786194, 0.06672994047403336, 0.5982440710067749, 0.08141087740659714, 1.2472416162490845, 0.18023738265037537, 0.02825946919620037, -1.0648573637008667 ]
Image of the Energy Gap Anisotropy in the Vibrational Spectum of a High Temperature Superconductor
We present a new method of determining the anisotropy of the gap function in layered high-Tc superconductors. Careful inelastic neutron scattering measurements at low temperature of the phonon dispersion curves in the (100) direction in La_(1.85)Sr_(.15)CuO_4 would determine whether the gap is predominately s-wave or d-wave. We also propose an experiment to determine the gap at each point on a quasi-two-dimensional Fermi surface.
Michael E. Flatte
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204008
cond-mat/9204009
[ -0.24173301458358765, -0.39902734756469727, 0.08650997281074524, 0.24668873846530914, 0.09374578297138214, -0.3372960090637207, -0.340626060962677, -0.6856008768081665, -0.5017699599266052, 1.7813069820404053, 0.6849520206451416, -0.1797431856393814, 1.0417203903198242, -0.7910890579223633, -0.47591346502304077, 0.13673733174800873, -0.2577662765979767, -0.21999700367450714, -1.1444056034088135, -0.12028845399618149, 0.14001958072185516, -0.20495647192001343, -1.024868130683899, -0.5176532864570618, -0.5327132344245911, 0.9010177254676819, 0.07647483050823212, 0.5559830665588379, 0.9580978155136108, 0.7596853375434875, 0.28584161400794983, -0.6370759010314941, -0.11970855295658112, -1.3605273962020874, -0.22781845927238464, 0.4736643135547638, -0.3689485192298889, -0.37178054451942444, 0.43101951479911804, -0.5308887362480164, 1.1381809711456299, -0.6179422736167908, 0.03528090566396713, -0.5210269093513489, -1.1708567142486572, 0.22687621414661407, -0.20870868861675262, -0.6328165531158447, 0.1312415450811386, -1.4106487035751343, 0.1595582813024521, 0.2889859974384308, 0.8215777277946472, -0.0986492782831192, -0.11227910965681076, -0.5324625968933105, 0.36145928502082825, 0.7314127683639526, 0.24956953525543213, -0.6961520910263062, 0.3781549036502838, 0.336539089679718, 0.37861716747283936, -0.898269772529602, 0.26242923736572266, 0.7543748021125793, -0.3319414556026459, 0.8049361705780029, -0.2645414173603058, -0.7100408673286438, -0.8637773394584656, -0.4936769902706146, -0.024647274985909462, -0.27104029059410095, -1.182625412940979, -0.35630542039871216, -0.6021484136581421, -0.6395338773727417, -1.3049275875091553, -0.6196600794792175, 0.08023398369550705, -0.5070920586585999, -0.8549387454986572, 0.8593564033508301, 0.06486742198467255, -0.009846861474215984, -0.24353674054145813, 0.10527270287275314, 0.20410986244678497, 0.3017193675041199, 0.919512927532196, 0.9979785680770874, -0.15380072593688965, -0.09049011766910553, 0.382266104221344, 0.7515010237693787, 0.13745971024036407, 0.1039414033293724, -0.06567216664552689, 0.44052574038505554, 0.08641842752695084, 0.7148339748382568, -0.13033075630664825, 0.7038098573684692, -0.5285861492156982, 0.5428798794746399, -0.34279707074165344, -0.05876738950610161, 0.09321035444736481, -0.4243434965610504, 0.3581164479255676, -0.14327964186668396, 0.11817534267902374, 0.422071248292923, -0.5105143189430237, 1.1442196369171143, 0.1937752515077591, -0.4972672760486603, -0.8050904273986816, -0.23407256603240967, 0.02099665068089962, 0.03052423894405365, 0.8950814008712769, 0.6888390183448792, 0.27980154752731323, -0.40572187304496765, 1.0459909439086914, 0.7980139255523682, 0.11843208223581314, -0.07396602630615234, 0.18109692633152008, 0.32432985305786133, 0.323007196187973, 0.49594080448150635, -0.8515788912773132, -0.18743383884429932, -0.1542145311832428, 0.29641610383987427, 0.1684635728597641, 0.21131983399391174, 0.3581528067588806, -0.6769829392433167, 0.24919147789478302, 0.7261036038398743, 0.02400948293507099, 0.02637372724711895, 0.23078817129135132, -0.1661159247159958, -0.13453435897827148, 0.46657034754753113, -0.33580291271209717, -0.0800148993730545, 0.6148549914360046, 0.20402278006076813, -0.6679335236549377, 0.6131552457809448, -0.08434512466192245, 0.5489498972892761, -0.7265993356704712, -0.8849111795425415, 0.4069376587867737, 0.09132401645183563, 0.20301926136016846, 0.3788367211818695, -0.34735190868377686, -0.15060502290725708, -0.9505043029785156, -0.38376376032829285, 0.14038285613059998, -0.02542548067867756, -0.25197190046310425, 0.19676990807056427, -0.24030207097530365, 0.5964287519454956, 0.9027751088142395, 0.10136380046606064, 0.7711793184280396, -0.2684789001941681, -0.14368069171905518, -0.1542106568813324, -0.7601327896118164, -0.5273021459579468, 0.7608932256698608, -0.10156825184822083, 0.022158613428473473, -0.0873994380235672, -0.9439229369163513, -0.17034918069839478, -0.5648624300956726, 0.13398370146751404, -0.26198944449424744, 0.535658061504364, -0.5475335717201233, -0.07904612272977829, 0.06750297546386719, 0.05232176184654236, -1.1648904085159302, 0.9173060059547424, 0.0843154713511467, -0.37998461723327637, -0.6531990170478821, 0.16478078067302704, -1.3094632625579834, -0.17718727886676788, -1.748063564300537, -0.09152498096227646, 0.5628955364227295, 0.6795375347137451, -0.9372923970222473, 0.17796681821346283, 0.3520449995994568, -0.16019275784492493, 0.26256370544433594, -0.11524074524641037, 0.23414424061775208, 0.2004449963569641, -0.5216914415359497, 0.4547726809978485, 0.2349558174610138, 0.17216795682907104, 0.21630650758743286, 0.46616941690444946, -0.05271479859948158, 0.8618975877761841, -0.09847530722618103, -0.23659278452396393, 0.1368762105703354, 0.2884385585784912, -0.007573703303933144, -0.10052492469549179, -0.20887145400047302, 0.5139239430427551, 0.26829713582992554, 0.3316251039505005, 1.3761978149414062, 0.33480024337768555, 0.8511016964912415, 0.7947462201118469, 0.08009733259677887, -0.14350242912769318, 0.15038542449474335, 0.34981974959373474, 0.3998328745365143, 0.39296334981918335, -0.06330631673336029, -0.008032171986997128, -0.704664945602417, 0.5416859984397888, -1.0030708312988281, 0.6374552845954895, -0.4801585376262665, 0.7386659979820251, 0.45136502385139465, 0.21949484944343567, -1.2962325811386108, -0.004342296160757542, 0.06956928223371506, 0.23420007526874542, -0.29330679774284363, -0.14134110510349274, 0.5161423087120056, 0.5565503239631653, -0.35440725088119507, -0.2697817385196686, -0.31887727975845337, 0.5420559048652649, 0.17239470779895782, 0.019604546949267387, -0.23641589283943176, -0.08663735538721085, -1.526879906654358, -0.7800825834274292, -0.5315424799919128, 0.14369584619998932, -0.49544084072113037, 0.9136871099472046, 0.6769464612007141, -0.9097353219985962, 1.715684413909912, 0.4405287802219391, -0.3897199034690857, 0.6682525873184204, -0.036404792219400406, 1.0217646360397339, 0.21981629729270935, 0.29218074679374695, -1.0002909898757935, 0.3868710398674011, -0.5777419805526733, 0.6525781154632568, -0.285086452960968, -0.37437641620635986, 1.4080431461334229, -0.2469569891691208, 0.5338187217712402, -0.09902077913284302, -0.40390393137931824, -0.22394414246082306, -0.5659824013710022, -0.9494087100028992, -0.5457112789154053, 0.0820598378777504, -0.6618205308914185, 0.28062674403190613, -0.7157890796661377, 1.1948620080947876, 0.10124539583921432, -0.5774336457252502, 0.4571076035499573, 0.5808202028274536, -0.5472946763038635, 0.6472342610359192, 0.22464434802532196, 0.15402063727378845, -0.1297481507062912, 1.323653221130371, 0.611562192440033, 0.07715143263339996, 0.4933173358440399, -0.6616207361221313, -0.5220405459403992, 0.03912132605910301, 0.4561281204223633, -0.9147259593009949, -0.7192986011505127, 1.1279172897338867, 0.43139171600341797, -1.0414366722106934, -0.04491526260972023, -1.1412874460220337, -0.1645973026752472, 0.20680396258831024, -0.7697154879570007, 0.6596960425376892, -0.2177995890378952, 0.06312728673219681, -0.6083993315696716, -0.23852801322937012, 0.7406310439109802, 0.7088777422904968, 0.4123714864253998, -0.2280866801738739, 0.5762766599655151, -0.07681945711374283, 0.5425300002098083, 0.04121216759085655, -0.06023620441555977, -0.5728285312652588, -0.5262279510498047, 0.6172880530357361, -0.653624951839447, 0.7205216884613037, 0.3351372182369232, 0.2616211175918579, 0.21857011318206787, 0.22399753332138062, -1.2704938650131226, -0.39679697155952454, -0.9205262064933777, -0.17443391680717468, 0.006984157487750053, 1.0068340301513672, -0.30400770902633667, -0.5877343416213989, -1.5917260646820068, -0.28407636284828186, -0.14380817115306854, 0.21521978080272675, 1.2452036142349243, -0.8349392414093018, 0.6954333186149597, -0.20765742659568787, -0.7310968041419983, 0.7324255704879761, -0.6811636090278625, -0.31919288635253906, 0.06412354111671448, 0.30276724696159363, 0.9292804598808289, -0.8105364441871643, -0.800160825252533, -0.8599022030830383, 1.588022232055664, 0.6011766195297241, 0.8154584765434265, 0.42743542790412903, -0.48544231057167053, 0.2313249558210373, -0.6730467081069946, -0.7515118718147278, 0.06498610228300095, 0.03257891535758972, -0.6024014949798584, -0.22389012575149536, 0.12179376184940338, 0.68777996301651, 0.5762729048728943, 0.31381767988204956, 0.19363899528980255, 0.16208261251449585, 0.6793859601020813, 1.473563313484192, 0.37026190757751465, 0.7267153859138489, -0.4261351525783539, 0.2870880961418152, -0.3241107165813446, 0.3608929514884949, 0.22280247509479523, -0.26107752323150635, -0.1654098927974701, -0.21828728914260864, -0.14798244833946228, 0.17346417903900146, 0.7647476196289062, 0.27867966890335083, -0.4586249887943268, 0.7091014385223389, 0.30778616666793823, -0.030067114159464836, -1.001258373260498, -0.22849036753177643, 0.7574886083602905, 0.3636995851993561, 0.022542227059602737, -0.3834089934825897, 0.07868386059999466, 0.22626373171806335, 0.6158855557441711, 0.9829310178756714, -0.7010383605957031, -1.082476258277893, -0.4136876165866852, 0.21760724484920502, -0.572168231010437, -0.29950401186943054, 1.0675630569458008, 0.02330777794122696, 0.8014696836471558, -0.3340100347995758, 0.31926095485687256, 1.5115326642990112, -0.4612217843532562, 0.3256674110889435, -0.5557209253311157, -0.0292044747620821, -0.1519555151462555, 0.6216449737548828, -0.29154348373413086, -0.2637443542480469, -0.5929270386695862, -0.4294780492782593, 0.21245123445987701, -0.3565545678138733, 0.26122918725013733, -0.8202406167984009, -0.6797817945480347, -0.12601710855960846, 0.2830536663532257, 0.30195045471191406, 0.20753325521945953, 0.2326316386461258, 0.47434529662132263, -0.9741429686546326, -0.1835852563381195, 0.16564497351646423, -0.14288018643856049, 1.123073935508728, 0.6716744303703308, 0.5793696641921997, -0.13068412244319916, 0.20648686587810516, -0.6118951439857483, -0.06669607758522034, 0.024674640968441963, -0.6014717221260071, -0.40077582001686096, -0.6652554869651794, -0.5990221500396729, -0.2324238419532776, -0.8562836050987244, 0.5201402306556702, -0.8086562156677246, 0.700858473777771, 0.1400679498910904, -0.4850638508796692, -0.7246429324150085, -0.10291209071874619, -0.8384903073310852, 0.1650191992521286, -0.1611156463623047, 0.03992069140076637, 0.3269398808479309, -0.4913281500339508, -0.009729417972266674, 0.011549319140613079, -0.17156077921390533, -0.5898410677909851, 0.5583220720291138, 0.3857492208480835, -0.106644406914711, 0.9813432097434998, -0.6350250244140625, 0.08534470945596695, -0.14804516732692719, 0.6868927478790283, 0.41675788164138794, -0.18681682646274567, -0.7227864861488342, -0.3580838441848755, -0.3660185635089874, -0.22944387793540955, -0.012541557662189007, 0.04649798199534416, 0.4815219044685364, 0.6446800827980042, -0.0515872985124588, -0.1705372929573059, -1.1264910697937012, 0.7488958239555359, 0.14187470078468323, -0.306777685880661, -0.3868042826652527, 1.2059165239334106, -0.2683364152908325, 0.4434022009372711, 0.1166214719414711, -0.9860551357269287, 0.4275398552417755, -0.287754625082016, 0.9113914370536804, -1.4938496351242065, -0.1877353936433792, -0.13247251510620117, 0.5287730693817139, 0.25381091237068176, 0.9679976105690002, -0.04901883378624916, -0.2095191925764084, -0.00458768755197525, -0.4592652916908264, -0.11534713208675385, 0.05490237474441528, -0.3362332582473755, 0.08598276972770691, -1.0256024599075317, -1.013475775718689, 1.5094494819641113, -0.3003481924533844, 0.13383856415748596, 0.7971081137657166, 0.6020990014076233, -0.12860089540481567, 0.045877788215875626, 0.3623706102371216, -0.2717365324497223, -0.5326624512672424, 0.48791664838790894, 0.17533744871616364, 0.8109209537506104, -0.28746703267097473, 0.2644933760166168, -0.9021645784378052, 0.29742223024368286, -0.23366665840148926, -0.3416421115398407, -0.03379380330443382, 0.09150808304548264, 0.8774402737617493, -0.8633626699447632, -0.17476843297481537, -0.7033226490020752, 0.2489476203918457, 1.453157901763916, 0.20509356260299683, -0.6477080583572388, -0.45584094524383545, -0.6290332078933716, -0.44355878233909607, 0.6178034543991089, 0.14975816011428833, -0.5420727133750916, -0.8928952813148499, -0.22283576428890228, 0.5339412689208984, -0.3704172968864441, -0.17917977273464203, 0.14439207315444946, 0.4902692437171936, -0.2543546259403229, 0.24393586814403534, 0.07827133685350418, -0.2061132788658142, -0.249141126871109, -0.16202545166015625, 0.05069064721465111, 0.2098095417022705, -0.282714307308197, -0.1314137578010559, -0.4676474630832672, -0.39629897475242615, 0.5478963851928711, 0.7766804099082947, -0.5128481388092041, 1.1934680938720703, -0.09066186100244522, 0.10787903517484665, 0.03907717391848564, -0.6241711378097534, -0.11382301896810532, 0.3229232132434845, 0.789740264415741, 0.38052868843078613, -0.18618424236774445, -0.011791405268013477, 0.17161868512630463, -0.8702223300933838, 0.40630847215652466, 0.791786789894104, -0.13595199584960938, -0.9788182377815247, 0.00043700227979570627, 0.5362246036529541, -0.941935122013092, 0.14857788383960724, -1.2910906076431274, 0.10586856305599213, 0.3746471703052521, -1.1227341890335083, -0.15831437706947327, -0.42341384291648865, 0.07105570286512375, 0.10121987760066986, 0.9142798781394958, 0.2539316713809967, -0.09564034640789032, 0.8613156676292419, -0.3507629632949829, -0.7049697041511536, -0.2606106102466583, 1.4299192428588867, -1.0322422981262207, -0.9040196537971497, -0.32590678334236145, -0.5685336589813232, -0.903754472732544, -0.5528032183647156, 0.7822189927101135, -0.02883400022983551, 0.3779049515724182, 0.68524569272995, 0.3520045578479767, 0.25749656558036804, 0.18810339272022247, 0.2273564487695694, -0.03460211306810379, 0.22333839535713196, -0.681429386138916, -0.3045901656150818, -0.069525346159935, 0.20597223937511444, 0.4919421970844269, -0.6305602788925171, -0.022313501685857773, -0.06896970421075821, -0.2098412662744522, -1.0137132406234741, -0.7122243046760559, -0.31890079379081726, -1.412325143814087, -0.6176685690879822, -0.8889463543891907, -0.20457224547863007, -0.4035825729370117, -0.381923109292984, -0.43607431650161743, 0.43632248044013977, -0.8159896731376648, -0.6905347108840942, -0.11173627525568008, 0.6351439952850342, 0.025777796283364296, -0.44388777017593384, -1.0844355821609497, -0.3523642122745514, -0.14468470215797424, 0.06305380910634995, 0.11336959153413773, 0.2788476347923279, -0.8610377311706543, 0.5108401775360107, -0.7530017495155334, 1.0123906135559082, -0.710272490978241, -0.4098847508430481, 0.3953953683376312, -0.1935635358095169, 0.19474154710769653, 0.344359815120697, 0.32690155506134033, 0.05166138708591461, -0.04875306412577629, 0.05744994059205055, 0.3391302824020386, 0.2980572581291199, -1.27155601978302, 0.07693245261907578, -0.42346659302711487, -0.42897191643714905, 0.20648068189620972, -0.8234929442405701, 0.3896520435810089, 0.19618023931980133, -0.840498149394989, 0.5914109945297241, -0.4210548400878906, -0.2687647342681885, -0.37367337942123413, -0.3085674047470093, -0.17772534489631653, 0.3277590870857239, -0.6190646886825562, 0.8831261992454529, 0.041773755103349686, -0.7158210873603821, -0.14299292862415314, 0.01284351758658886, -0.5538416504859924, 1.075329065322876, -0.02199433371424675, 0.42343810200691223, -0.03134703263640404, 0.3695576786994934, -0.5426954030990601, 0.5015798211097717, -0.449653685092926, -0.7409250140190125, -0.9828470349311829, -0.20367148518562317, -0.6232150197029114, -0.22555309534072876, 0.3413202464580536, -0.5489885210990906, 0.23266837000846863, -0.6814347505569458, -0.39723896980285645, 0.3485581874847412, -0.6885291337966919, -0.12043988704681396, -0.6690925359725952, -0.172284796833992, -0.36755096912384033, 0.06944623589515686, -0.15834911167621613, 0.4867669939994812, -0.09709455072879791, 0.6001348495483398, -0.26152750849723816, 0.17668552696704865, 0.16049131751060486, -0.08268120139837265, -1.193121075630188, -0.18415094912052155, -0.7413286566734314, 0.5714897513389587, 0.090725839138031, -0.6579188108444214, -0.3353056311607361, -0.03326569125056267, -0.11456727981567383, -0.09278405457735062, 0.09208479523658752, 0.11078812927007675, -0.1663380265235901, 0.5274671912193298, 0.5638765692710876, -0.4551470875740051, -0.2657197415828705, 1.2165029048919678, 0.4523894190788269, 0.10427296906709671, 0.5703898668289185, 0.391802579164505, 0.06717545539140701, -0.43479838967323303, -0.4711640775203705, 1.4663163423538208, 0.251210480928421, -0.761525571346283, 1.0063056945800781, 0.13528606295585632, -0.16771256923675537, 0.4969872534275055, -0.7893387079238892, 0.2792988121509552, -0.38691598176956177, 0.31138163805007935, 1.0347861051559448, 0.3404095470905304, 0.018054170534014702, 0.8880616426467896, 0.22081302106380463, 0.4184786379337311, 0.40650472044944763, 0.3373452425003052, 0.378343790769577, 0.5723073482513428, -0.3231126368045807, 0.10429982841014862, 0.2472173422574997, 0.25984615087509155, 0.2132667750120163, -0.46907928586006165, -0.427142858505249, 0.8353826403617859, 0.4301479756832123, 0.87403804063797, -0.7931339740753174, 0.0659772977232933, 0.10191752761602402, -0.12233938276767731, -0.3835136890411377, 0.753303050994873, 0.11687032878398895, 0.7830019593238831, 1.2696454524993896, 0.46485933661460876, 0.2629321813583374, 0.2599279582500458, 0.8059239983558655, 0.10661455243825912, 0.18662399053573608, 0.5180866718292236, 0.5683497190475464, 0.8573741912841797, 0.3600992262363434, -0.5633060336112976, -0.11470723897218704, 0.5057114958763123, -1.4328126907348633, 0.027130471542477608, -0.1723773181438446, -0.22587500512599945, 0.026523087173700333, -0.8804699182510376, 1.0850884914398193, -0.5688382983207703, 0.24864190816879272, 0.9508432745933533, 0.015645693987607956, 0.049726445227861404, 0.12343447655439377, -0.42112645506858826, 0.42746782302856445, 0.8177796602249146, -0.17329086363315582, -0.7097154855728149, 0.7666224837303162, 1.4298739433288574, 0.2790916860103607, -0.34579020738601685, 0.5995558500289917, -0.005123672541230917, -0.10244517028331757, -0.2091119885444641, -0.3048967123031616, 0.9840839505195618, -0.15018469095230103, -0.10336723923683167, 0.4669460654258728, 0.5132880806922913, 0.014628000557422638, 0.3283570408821106, -0.12651857733726501, 0.5914916396141052, -0.44977372884750366, 0.6921139359474182, 0.8490952253341675, 0.3806547224521637, -0.3361799716949463, -0.4348066747188568, -0.6780633330345154, 0.34513917565345764, -0.1320933848619461, -0.9892110824584961, 0.3533821702003479, 0.05057946965098381, 0.7366008758544922, -0.08962279558181763, -0.3648276925086975, -0.3895094394683838, -1.1549444198608398, -0.19395850598812103, -0.8155748248100281, -0.06281464546918869, 0.22209058701992035, 0.2809697985649109, 0.3783567547798157, -0.6134499311447144, 0.43379002809524536, 0.597851574420929, 0.9094955325126648, 0.2336178421974182, 0.48919588327407837, 0.3570469319820404, 0.02428116649389267, -0.1417628526687622, 0.5196775794029236, 0.47424477338790894, -0.16686169803142548, 0.7846314311027527, -0.894590437412262, 0.012103928253054619, -0.1911296397447586, 0.15593692660331726, 0.326947420835495, 0.3423469364643097, 0.20582899451255798, -0.47860977053642273, -0.6948104500770569, 0.2564714252948761, -0.6728745698928833, -0.375304251909256, -1.1598284244537354, 0.13914696872234344, -0.5136394500732422, 0.3854152262210846, 0.08939150720834732, -0.2569166123867035, 3.700284004211426, 0.7945069670677185, 1.1014771461486816, 0.43544265627861023, 0.36582979559898376, 1.0108836889266968, -0.5646661520004272, 0.15934355556964874, 0.5604715347290039, -1.1470046043395996, -0.16170473396778107, -0.12162284553050995, -0.1524953544139862, -0.2740049958229065, 0.2584410309791565, 0.5853697657585144, -0.45213979482650757, 0.2742358446121216, -0.03129208832979202, -0.9287605881690979, -0.6270715594291687, -0.24325916171073914, 0.2950632870197296, -0.761092483997345, -0.056595899164676666, 0.18190446496009827, 0.637608528137207, -0.45616087317466736, -0.7528749108314514, 0.029174312949180603, -1.39224112033844, -0.8893008232116699, 0.5511356592178345, -0.04742816835641861, -0.7412186861038208, 0.6651572585105896, 0.44565173983573914, -0.27644261717796326, 0.5911717414855957, 0.4517821967601776, -0.4289166331291199, -0.4157228469848633, 0.3753731846809387, 0.009222745895385742, -1.182593822479248, 1.004302740097046, -0.49113231897354126, 0.4198794662952423, -0.21245239675045013, -0.017885154113173485, 0.7089197635650635, -0.23402820527553558, 0.05144038423895836, -0.4773077666759491, -0.9181102514266968, -0.04216092824935913, -0.09976107627153397, -0.3233466148376465, 0.025466512888669968, -0.4922409951686859, 0.5650796294212341, 0.01213074941188097, -0.3553773760795593, -0.39462733268737793, -0.2119075506925583, 0.12228722870349884, 1.0983351469039917, -0.07633043825626373, 0.609643280506134, -0.21861116588115692, -0.20465975999832153, -0.24708089232444763, -0.5748900175094604, 0.5945464372634888, 0.38183870911598206, -0.5069261789321899, -0.41137492656707764, 0.4123634099960327, 0.05275747925043106, -0.38059863448143005, -0.2698555290699005, -0.6267585158348083, -1.4194079637527466, 0.45340651273727417, 0.6643785238265991, 0.3526122570037842, -0.6155769228935242, -0.35721755027770996, -0.17327390611171722, 0.1813669353723526, 0.11849076300859451, 0.9675064086914062, 0.5380306839942932, 0.6013427376747131, -0.8040110468864441 ]
Order Parameters, Broken Symmetry, and Topology
We introduce the theoretical framework we use to study the bewildering variety of phases in condensed--matter physics. We emphasize the importance of the breaking of symmetries, and develop the idea of an order parameter through several examples. We discuss elementary excitations and the topological theory of defects.
James P. Sethna
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204009
cond-mat/9204010
[ -0.1466260701417923, -0.4819207787513733, 0.1785275936126709, 0.38456228375434875, 0.2764286994934082, 0.008726530708372593, 0.39093828201293945, -0.6496720910072327, -0.2148502916097641, 1.0667277574539185, 0.45597800612449646, 0.24470916390419006, 0.7197710275650024, -0.7290340065956116, -0.3063800632953644, 0.4604232609272003, -0.6203981041908264, -0.22524240612983704, -1.3057385683059692, 0.23166677355766296, 0.06101113557815552, -0.6155768036842346, -0.9595937728881836, -0.6779769062995911, -0.365597665309906, 0.5237652063369751, 0.47201016545295715, 0.5226938128471375, 0.9099010229110718, 1.2075039148330688, -0.2986064553260803, -0.3428332805633545, -0.037556059658527374, -1.3558152914047241, -0.46989738941192627, 0.046047382056713104, -0.23539051413536072, -0.8307464718818665, 0.14114446938037872, -0.5257242918014526, 0.6604071855545044, -0.4076708257198334, 0.48193612694740295, -0.39937731623649597, -0.2402476817369461, 0.0597931444644928, -0.20603588223457336, -0.6413267850875854, -0.22891198098659515, -0.9083747863769531, 0.09017381817102432, 0.37994539737701416, 0.43517816066741943, -0.17184537649154663, -0.05758226662874222, 0.2502003610134125, 0.15897266566753387, -0.035710662603378296, -0.045489393174648285, -0.1843566745519638, -0.16990505158901215, 0.022563738748431206, 0.2985381782054901, -1.3500465154647827, 0.28692173957824707, 0.20211823284626007, -0.47208172082901, 0.5730302333831787, -0.06322629749774933, 0.18285343050956726, -0.6373595595359802, -0.21544627845287323, 0.10721973329782486, -0.4446442425251007, -0.5015659928321838, -0.20867380499839783, 0.06160739064216614, -0.6125417351722717, -0.7989360690116882, -0.24196630716323853, -0.24090947210788727, -0.3679388761520386, -0.31134340167045593, 1.0487793684005737, 0.05789746716618538, 0.01615077257156372, 0.051411110907793045, 0.724277913570404, 0.026693180203437805, 0.3480563759803772, 0.008044742979109287, 0.8203205466270447, -0.6885131597518921, 0.02661200612783432, 0.5409603714942932, 0.338769793510437, -0.5597802996635437, 0.7753101587295532, 0.25833866000175476, 0.30056118965148926, -0.19413840770721436, 1.2401392459869385, -0.610602080821991, 0.8674300312995911, -0.5162747502326965, 0.44941237568855286, -0.02644588239490986, 0.25615352392196655, -0.04866690933704376, -0.7670722603797913, 0.5643618702888489, 0.25234270095825195, 0.009875131770968437, 0.7345690131187439, -0.26514074206352234, 0.6745292544364929, 0.43535172939300537, -0.053825680166482925, -1.1712878942489624, -0.4171546995639801, -0.28182289004325867, 0.8967688083648682, 0.6387449502944946, 0.5870417356491089, -0.020104171708226204, -0.14879778027534485, 0.63906329870224, 1.0078279972076416, -0.7150169014930725, 0.02392192743718624, -0.19670383632183075, -0.6045562624931335, -0.6234821081161499, 0.5904422402381897, -0.8528290390968323, 0.08528422564268112, -0.8463433384895325, 0.7002168297767639, 0.22499611973762512, 0.5400428771972656, -0.1585090607404709, -0.5123304128646851, 0.49005448818206787, 1.0411015748977661, 0.6483355164527893, -0.44591024518013, 0.5157634019851685, 0.24799342453479767, -0.3753480315208435, 0.12889112532138824, -0.6923496127128601, -0.39483746886253357, 0.48245543241500854, -0.05339410528540611, -0.23432303965091705, 0.39334985613822937, -0.8381314873695374, 0.4854971766471863, -0.11895505338907242, -0.35542935132980347, 0.47126296162605286, -0.5289870500564575, 0.43068769574165344, 0.36916661262512207, -0.3493881821632385, -0.1091775968670845, -0.7971500754356384, -0.4728318154811859, 0.4759032130241394, 0.15157391130924225, -0.402955025434494, 0.1805942803621292, 0.141332745552063, 0.6528018116950989, 1.1583596467971802, 0.8043933510780334, 0.7243742942810059, -0.3069048821926117, -0.5615724325180054, 0.42475613951683044, -0.10334384441375732, -0.7239378690719604, 0.5476503372192383, 0.25603553652763367, -0.3466302454471588, 0.09946580976247787, -0.5743550658226013, 0.287485271692276, 0.463214635848999, 0.34750863909721375, -0.4977433681488037, 0.2575903832912445, -0.574673056602478, 0.14804433286190033, -0.5240820646286011, -0.07941970974206924, -1.413362979888916, 0.891259491443634, 0.06453613191843033, -0.8411902785301208, -0.5872214436531067, 0.5792782306671143, -1.023241400718689, -0.46463173627853394, -1.8692446947097778, 0.08500537276268005, 0.11915407329797745, 0.9753882884979248, -0.8927819728851318, 0.2542622685432434, 0.4031025767326355, -0.2858429551124573, 0.06279566884040833, -0.15806828439235687, 0.16294929385185242, 0.25393760204315186, -0.44935160875320435, -0.24994398653507233, 0.506259560585022, 0.39772868156433105, 0.3757375180721283, -0.14626453816890717, -0.6241835355758667, 0.8971894383430481, -0.16102555394172668, 0.06743878871202469, 0.3231947720050812, 0.32625865936279297, -0.0734766498208046, -0.13623851537704468, -0.5216203331947327, 0.37975865602493286, 0.3806496262550354, 0.26665958762168884, 1.3053185939788818, 0.0822998657822609, 0.36695635318756104, 0.5334718227386475, 0.3352321982383728, 0.18615727126598358, -0.1721912920475006, 1.023637056350708, 0.10384754836559296, 0.10268782824277878, -0.35163286328315735, 0.023232733830809593, -0.5933965444564819, 0.624464750289917, -0.9765603542327881, 0.19842703640460968, -0.4861984848976135, 0.816936731338501, 0.3129979968070984, 0.2568657696247101, -1.287216067314148, -0.27816998958587646, 0.009601681493222713, 0.5492309927940369, -0.32456931471824646, -0.7259011268615723, 0.37999701499938965, 0.3232872188091278, -0.32896479964256287, 0.07830984145402908, 0.15065410733222961, 0.8314067125320435, 0.177575021982193, -0.43346065282821655, -0.13762642443180084, -0.6832440495491028, -1.7378358840942383, -0.5034350752830505, -0.9934362769126892, -0.1419452726840973, -0.2816329300403595, 0.17830875515937805, 0.32318028807640076, -0.7195913791656494, 1.7398059368133545, 0.05616172403097153, -0.5563749074935913, 0.18024824559688568, -0.349968284368515, 0.7924649715423584, -0.3405917286872864, 0.9597476720809937, -0.8031024932861328, 0.48199647665023804, -0.7891775369644165, 0.6488913297653198, 0.07228728383779526, -0.7006136775016785, 0.9217764139175415, -0.5164291262626648, 0.49754372239112854, 0.044680967926979065, -0.2453124076128006, 0.0933476984500885, -0.5252893567085266, -0.684989869594574, -0.6923004388809204, 0.21609021723270416, -0.6318511366844177, -0.026405254378914833, -0.576023519039154, 1.007930874824524, -0.2373032122850418, -0.2939581871032715, 0.9557386040687561, 0.4422466456890106, -0.7995688319206238, 0.42965540289878845, -0.23387673497200012, 0.47242772579193115, -0.41632193326950073, 0.6936366558074951, 1.5683014392852783, 0.07147803902626038, 0.28659477829933167, -0.7554961442947388, -0.5360075235366821, 0.4767603576183319, 0.2683788537979126, -1.1729987859725952, -0.4537632465362549, 0.7949911952018738, 0.5065630674362183, -0.9197195172309875, 0.4195881187915802, -0.7968869209289551, -0.7641184329986572, -0.2792057991027832, -0.19040530920028687, 0.4619079828262329, -0.35849639773368835, 0.4399591386318207, -0.40290138125419617, 0.12306467443704605, 0.21412625908851624, 0.6959317326545715, 0.22045248746871948, 0.4336169362068176, 0.5211668610572815, 0.19063177704811096, 0.5330710411071777, 0.4735250174999237, 0.27768370509147644, -0.2007252722978592, -0.2622133791446686, 0.15333181619644165, -0.699640154838562, 0.5981460809707642, 0.3809463679790497, 0.5225030779838562, 0.09728572517633438, 0.9575263261795044, -0.9945920705795288, -0.44794565439224243, -0.42418786883354187, -0.14007830619812012, 0.38294219970703125, 0.4179445505142212, 0.5698618292808533, -0.4852215051651001, -0.9066024422645569, -0.8461670875549316, 0.10662905871868134, 0.059213556349277496, 1.144292950630188, -0.12827584147453308, 0.5766753554344177, 0.5520285367965698, -0.5116958022117615, 0.05862807855010033, -0.5661126971244812, -0.0888439267873764, 0.6814029216766357, 0.4665635824203491, 1.2970377206802368, -0.47250762581825256, -0.707984983921051, -0.2813037633895874, 0.8823185563087463, 0.9390395879745483, 0.5585974454879761, 0.27218422293663025, -0.4301418662071228, 0.22629651427268982, -1.0236214399337769, -0.2727200388908386, 0.1728864312171936, 0.08103741705417633, -0.5337001085281372, -0.18629512190818787, -0.10128001868724823, 0.13712544739246368, -0.0817808136343956, 0.7109333276748657, 0.12820985913276672, -0.04198345169425011, 0.9481847882270813, 1.1212109327316284, 0.175916850566864, 0.38897305727005005, -0.6572930812835693, -0.3689979016780853, -0.30804651975631714, 0.10246089845895767, 0.7276501655578613, -0.697559118270874, -0.23223601281642914, -0.4552195966243744, 0.2892378866672516, 0.08790822327136993, 0.10689957439899445, 0.49680978059768677, -0.5948920249938965, 0.3112789988517761, 0.39880815148353577, 0.20062510669231415, -1.521674633026123, 0.10927165299654007, 0.42525020241737366, 0.005637133494019508, 0.029425527900457382, -1.1469048261642456, -0.16707375645637512, -0.1542605757713318, 0.26151034235954285, 0.6167997717857361, -0.2792888879776001, -0.9657875299453735, 0.026798978447914124, 0.37561890482902527, -0.8533191084861755, 0.024379588663578033, 0.5235022902488708, 0.741671085357666, 0.33570557832717896, -0.13170790672302246, 0.15003101527690887, 1.2898308038711548, -0.20115754008293152, 0.21649767458438873, -0.3496488928794861, 0.7776583433151245, -0.16377133131027222, 1.207172155380249, -0.1803550273180008, -0.3204725682735443, -0.8814375996589661, -0.566081166267395, 0.8494613766670227, 0.0375199094414711, -0.36648812890052795, -0.4103941321372986, -0.3137924075126648, -0.1782420128583908, 0.24217000603675842, -0.11663587391376495, 0.25508472323417664, 0.2988402843475342, -0.013255092315375805, -0.8319600224494934, -0.9329040050506592, 0.24625329673290253, -0.34398719668388367, 0.31693536043167114, 0.5721362233161926, 0.7493287920951843, 0.17247645556926727, 0.012848020531237125, -0.2984023988246918, -0.2162582278251648, 0.6391733884811401, -0.4107895791530609, -0.037440020591020584, -0.2913196384906769, -0.47245293855667114, -0.40690672397613525, -0.23232977092266083, 0.33042746782302856, -0.9761728644371033, -0.13951833546161652, -0.4201062023639679, -0.49692630767822266, -0.4783938229084015, -0.1323728710412979, -0.6430580615997314, 0.45976722240448, 0.05933310464024544, -0.08573921024799347, 0.7543880939483643, -1.0034863948822021, -0.2506311535835266, -0.6764693260192871, -0.05702059715986252, 0.16259810328483582, 0.050969067960977554, 0.09787742793560028, -0.09636983275413513, 0.9230209589004517, -0.21673740446567535, 0.7462114095687866, 0.44886091351509094, 0.4517347812652588, 0.09256044030189514, -0.5191409587860107, -0.5985845923423767, 0.22274677455425262, -0.13388222455978394, -0.48867687582969666, -0.09243723005056381, -0.21962440013885498, 0.902684211730957, 0.3440706431865692, -0.0633416697382927, -0.28870776295661926, -1.5363104343414307, 0.24209414422512054, 0.015295908786356449, -0.3180173635482788, -0.6331028938293457, 1.1940070390701294, -0.4901270568370819, -0.4403824210166931, -0.4991922676563263, -0.7249923944473267, -0.10296366363763809, -0.2681620419025421, 0.8209090828895569, -1.3549948930740356, -0.5544058680534363, -0.7198421955108643, -0.4676326811313629, 0.3884914219379425, 0.8172715902328491, 0.15483403205871582, -0.7464147806167603, -0.4598201811313629, -0.782122790813446, 0.25246819853782654, -0.06712301075458527, 0.10220029205083847, -0.4437975585460663, -0.7757168412208557, -1.3769240379333496, 1.6113358736038208, -0.10822895169258118, -0.3514653742313385, 0.5649184584617615, 0.009619752876460552, 0.4526769518852234, 0.5785569548606873, 0.41942283511161804, -0.34891021251678467, -1.1392881870269775, 0.4707045257091522, -0.3086458742618561, 0.9899511933326721, -1.0029971599578857, 0.43528783321380615, -1.0742000341415405, 0.790744960308075, 0.17611375451087952, 0.15911419689655304, 0.6880914568901062, -0.9620338082313538, 0.9472196102142334, -0.25788846611976624, -0.10092169791460037, -0.46937432885169983, 0.49896371364593506, 0.684169590473175, 0.42714056372642517, -0.7594422101974487, -0.4792930781841278, -1.4383729696273804, -0.8056821823120117, 0.6580283045768738, 0.12372608482837677, -0.3408980965614319, -0.6005301475524902, -0.3364298641681671, 0.1496882140636444, 0.11694090813398361, 0.18388667702674866, 0.27316224575042725, 0.9181901812553406, 0.014678475446999073, 0.5010543465614319, -0.2436419278383255, 0.05696595460176468, -0.5235908627510071, 0.5753142237663269, -0.018179310485720634, -0.6606021523475647, 0.04078032076358795, -0.5082342624664307, -0.9531496167182922, -0.3692930042743683, 0.3038708567619324, 0.7858023047447205, -0.5950256586074829, 1.0968924760818481, -0.12135720252990723, -0.742827832698822, -0.27549827098846436, -0.389201283454895, -0.20272906124591827, 0.46822071075439453, 0.40098339319229126, 0.16769011318683624, -0.3097533583641052, 0.007756371051073074, 0.2783973813056946, -0.8673595190048218, -0.11142110824584961, 1.0681164264678955, -0.5604028701782227, -0.8072953820228577, 0.05153163522481918, 0.3124954104423523, -0.9559108018875122, -0.5579878687858582, -0.5807541012763977, -0.18795235455036163, 0.052887532860040665, -1.279180884361267, -0.058421988040208817, 0.0008061371627263725, -0.07561765611171722, 0.5315548181533813, 1.0483981370925903, 0.12830285727977753, 0.734018087387085, 0.32205450534820557, -0.3578118681907654, -0.6554340720176697, -0.08149518817663193, 1.4303535223007202, -0.6341530084609985, -1.1555372476577759, -0.21512891352176666, -0.8229051828384399, -0.808372974395752, -0.2933884561061859, 0.9939326047897339, 0.29118064045906067, 0.3336513936519623, 0.026765871793031693, 0.2958187758922577, 0.5652685165405273, 0.5333015322685242, 0.029736343771219254, -0.18767522275447845, -0.165260910987854, -0.8904111385345459, -0.0001473672455176711, 0.4063566327095032, 0.3037962317466736, 0.4571857750415802, -0.5421828031539917, -0.08468813449144363, 0.5009133219718933, -0.07894884049892426, -0.7467240691184998, -0.31611528992652893, -0.6663517355918884, -1.1614741086959839, -0.7320414185523987, -0.5227462649345398, -0.6473771929740906, -0.36593642830848694, 0.16693426668643951, -0.37259232997894287, 0.1046295017004013, -0.20683054625988007, 0.16596372425556183, -0.5276889204978943, 0.6122252941131592, 0.157673180103302, -0.4185259938240051, -0.5043503642082214, -0.273995965719223, -0.027258124202489853, -0.34798771142959595, -0.4909844398498535, 0.17460650205612183, -0.4534676671028137, 0.3369354009628296, -0.36483773589134216, 1.415140986442566, -1.0727336406707764, -0.43460190296173096, -0.1364801824092865, -0.2533493638038635, -0.28843259811401367, 0.8474017977714539, -0.37388312816619873, 0.4727790057659149, 0.3190472424030304, -0.2828228175640106, 0.36186683177948, 0.509284496307373, -0.6605322360992432, -0.07113289088010788, 0.06868711858987808, -0.1411719173192978, 0.048884067684412, -0.4746183454990387, 0.39985936880111694, -0.0260244719684124, -1.1131361722946167, 0.12414297461509705, -0.08196049928665161, 0.31630364060401917, -0.13242091238498688, -0.7452836036682129, 0.24512141942977905, 0.11118312925100327, -0.7665064334869385, 0.6843892335891724, -0.2705453932285309, -1.082502841949463, 0.005879058036953211, 0.25527241826057434, -0.06878332048654556, -0.030700400471687317, 0.03717191889882088, -0.2634483277797699, 0.17257679998874664, 0.27866488695144653, -0.8725019693374634, 0.6045594215393066, 0.0319589339196682, -0.16273096203804016, -0.6916261315345764, -0.0049043577164411545, -0.8314304947853088, 0.5854682326316833, 0.5275492668151855, -0.4328828454017639, 0.3135797679424286, -0.8440536260604858, -0.6745287775993347, -0.035431377589702606, -0.4140430688858032, -0.4031636714935303, -0.22221557796001434, -0.3131125271320343, -0.4939495921134949, -0.08449867367744446, -0.023382455110549927, 0.623482882976532, -0.45226871967315674, 0.4698460102081299, -0.32198092341423035, 0.49124377965927124, -0.20673604309558868, 0.1699238121509552, -1.0490931272506714, 0.6003164649009705, -0.4042041003704071, 0.5188130736351013, 0.011288346722722054, -0.7407005429267883, -0.2710181772708893, -0.0691511332988739, 0.04951214790344238, 0.12076779454946518, 0.23527373373508453, -0.029292713850736618, -0.4540339410305023, 0.09891438484191895, 0.5692338347434998, 0.01840057782828808, -0.6968696117401123, 0.6986703872680664, 0.2191174477338791, -0.12679259479045868, 0.2356620877981186, 0.576511800289154, -0.09713731706142426, -0.0535387247800827, -0.15757779777050018, 1.4449446201324463, 0.2744680345058441, -0.05100296437740326, 1.0899943113327026, 0.2277309000492096, 0.13974463939666748, 0.3507506251335144, -0.6504203677177429, 0.04853229969739914, 0.2161005586385727, 0.2709023952484131, 0.8197839856147766, 0.40120208263397217, 0.49227774143218994, 0.9390409588813782, 0.7730427980422974, 0.43006807565689087, -0.07773110270500183, -0.05910639464855194, 0.19584950804710388, -0.27087870240211487, -0.6983827948570251, 0.5367192029953003, 0.3926982283592224, 0.3967210054397583, 0.0769476518034935, -0.2835560739040375, -0.6559076905250549, 0.17218463122844696, -0.2593686282634735, 0.24203163385391235, -1.0255773067474365, 0.1693946272134781, -0.19432638585567474, 0.27612900733947754, 0.013971537351608276, 0.08880309760570526, 0.0331738106906414, 0.44915375113487244, 0.2853555977344513, 0.29238784313201904, 0.15584170818328857, 0.5691835880279541, 0.12560231983661652, 0.07330881059169769, 0.16220007836818695, 0.528527557849884, 0.863499104976654, 1.4657756090164185, 0.0202161967754364, -0.9693821668624878, -0.16840477287769318, 0.5017082691192627, -0.6576328873634338, -0.29283472895622253, 0.20330262184143066, 0.043189987540245056, -0.05631150305271149, -0.6608949899673462, 0.4967677891254425, -1.1727049350738525, -0.23435260355472565, 0.6978727579116821, 0.030686162412166595, -0.37810003757476807, 0.7033331394195557, -0.08829937875270844, 0.21555104851722717, 0.6409375071525574, 0.05921940878033638, -0.3222605586051941, 1.283911943435669, 1.1640503406524658, 0.3443160057067871, -0.3419143259525299, 0.24543017148971558, -0.6285520195960999, -0.43310579657554626, -0.15423056483268738, -0.47373536229133606, 0.4877983033657074, -0.613070011138916, -0.3443889021873474, 0.5136017799377441, 0.26571300625801086, -0.1063651591539383, 0.6884086728096008, 0.5896801352500916, 1.0656895637512207, -0.6699439287185669, -0.4219057559967041, 0.1667332798242569, -0.1045272946357727, 0.011730454862117767, -0.013532216660678387, -0.34894776344299316, -0.20894284546375275, -0.11413335055112839, -0.8946548104286194, 0.8080638647079468, 0.36701565980911255, 0.4671652317047119, -0.32843488454818726, -0.005434062797576189, 0.17824366688728333, -0.373045951128006, -0.8375606536865234, -0.5421512722969055, 0.4076389670372009, 0.47400644421577454, 0.4268174171447754, 0.04062553867697716, -0.31742849946022034, 0.1452467441558838, 0.2575942575931549, 1.0747809410095215, 0.23539410531520844, 0.7859179973602295, 0.5875248312950134, 0.28517332673072815, -0.3023741841316223, 0.6686645150184631, 0.5174556970596313, -0.6563840508460999, 0.7594262361526489, -0.2927792966365814, -0.48957762122154236, 0.23479986190795898, -0.202400803565979, 0.3829268515110016, 0.5684604644775391, 0.5816603302955627, -0.5441307425498962, -0.6951361298561096, 0.45416581630706787, -0.8012072443962097, -0.14366105198860168, -0.2389340102672577, 0.034800685942173004, 0.5998625755310059, 0.09083990007638931, 0.2082187533378601, -0.7556878924369812, 3.837026834487915, 1.096540093421936, 0.5693014860153198, 0.32209256291389465, 0.5134268403053284, 0.3998563885688782, 0.20475336909294128, -0.0820104330778122, 0.6746782660484314, -0.8055748343467712, 0.017234545201063156, 0.5139116644859314, 0.07357423007488251, -0.007001704070717096, 0.19947098195552826, 0.11039600521326065, -0.1689453125, 0.2685002088546753, -0.3406452536582947, -0.2666838765144348, -0.3791292607784271, 0.32124456763267517, 0.4603291451931, -0.2741972506046295, 0.2341809719800949, 0.2061377465724945, 0.2617438733577728, -0.6695266962051392, -1.2111729383468628, -0.32847967743873596, -0.8400982618331909, -1.1676079034805298, 0.4630899131298065, -0.054302915930747986, -1.3291096687316895, 0.707403302192688, 0.9963964819908142, -0.32998108863830566, 0.3922699987888336, -0.22469089925289154, -0.7530518174171448, -0.8681963682174683, 0.13162530958652496, 0.009695851244032383, -0.2923775911331177, 1.0659129619598389, -0.49197548627853394, 0.8099614381790161, -0.07023756206035614, -0.4066735506057739, 0.0676737129688263, 0.16338790953159332, -0.03222522512078285, -0.1200493797659874, -1.1066950559616089, -0.44564691185951233, -0.6831247210502625, -0.5500742793083191, 0.11888542026281357, 0.2435477375984192, 0.86562180519104, 0.23712840676307678, -0.3313645124435425, -0.014393696561455727, -0.534887969493866, -0.12533289194107056, 0.6959448456764221, 0.17187325656414032, -0.1594233363866806, 0.029476238414645195, 0.410476952791214, 0.11937880516052246, -0.3649241328239441, 0.7546837329864502, 0.4978879392147064, 0.06708209961652756, -0.22305287420749664, 0.5651426911354065, 0.031055761501193047, 0.7701361775398254, -0.41091030836105347, -0.47131362557411194, -0.8736711144447327, 0.5759129524230957, 0.3246053457260132, 0.9008094072341919, -0.8231843709945679, -0.4366154968738556, -0.08220244199037552, 0.7273911237716675, 0.3003038465976715, 1.1665626764297485, 0.4972381889820099, 0.7845120429992676, -0.3131990134716034 ]
Meissner Effect and Constraints
We notice some beautiful geometrical defects found in liquid crystals, and explain them by imposing a constraint. We study the way constraints can occur, and introduce the concept of massive fields. We develop the theory of magnetic field expulsion in superconductors as an example. We notice strong analogies with the formation of grain boundaries in crystals, and realize that we do not understand crystals very deeply
James P. Sethna, Ming Huang
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204010
cond-mat/9204011
[ 0.2802090346813202, 0.02295880764722824, 0.6942811608314514, 0.3112954795360565, 0.06715579330921173, 0.20744185149669647, 0.1635795533657074, -0.42255881428718567, -0.38570931553840637, 1.705876350402832, 0.7486476302146912, 0.09719264507293701, 0.11106719821691513, -0.7169123291969299, -0.15882179141044617, 0.6321957111358643, -0.47779080271720886, -0.91154545545578, -1.345392107963562, 0.26558685302734375, 0.3647763729095459, -0.2723606824874878, -1.1802209615707397, -0.19384141266345978, -0.3101070821285248, 0.22677253186702728, -0.15650641918182373, 0.007268330082297325, 1.1836048364639282, 0.8093371987342834, 0.5273100137710571, -0.12027464061975479, -0.024204958230257034, -0.7815435528755188, -0.05225762724876404, -0.0786530151963234, 0.10767627507448196, -0.31707456707954407, 1.0775458812713623, -0.8420181274414062, 0.9013582468032837, 0.011307877488434315, 0.9879449009895325, 0.0925862267613411, -0.42241933941841125, 0.07375465333461761, -0.1695093959569931, -0.33839598298072815, 0.012087584473192692, -1.4278037548065186, 0.6944870948791504, 0.1737876534461975, 0.824303150177002, -0.38688141107559204, 0.17358015477657318, 0.1670464277267456, -0.09915591776371002, 0.3796733021736145, -0.3166489005088806, 0.37255463004112244, 0.37975531816482544, -0.3033224940299988, 0.4473191797733307, -1.299269199371338, 0.37620165944099426, 0.03838493302464485, -0.3943423330783844, 0.9626601338386536, -0.1296108514070511, -0.5716163516044617, -0.6542603373527527, -0.8040761351585388, -0.3816979229450226, -0.6364719867706299, -0.5760288834571838, 0.7982037663459778, 0.09084610641002655, -0.5217524766921997, -0.7808935046195984, -0.47790849208831787, -0.4323127567768097, -0.2852637469768524, -0.3008694648742676, 0.2191808819770813, -0.22681723535060883, -0.3927459120750427, -0.15691925585269928, -0.7715924382209778, 0.2622785270214081, 0.33499157428741455, 0.6581886410713196, 0.9696766138076782, -0.31247076392173767, 0.23496828973293304, 0.3024354875087738, 0.3247216045856476, 0.066365547478199, 0.8310987949371338, -0.0201405119150877, 0.37014198303222656, -0.4203800559043884, -0.0024753122124820948, -0.412219375371933, 0.722993791103363, -0.12284528464078903, 0.8602191209793091, 0.2995123565196991, 0.05023588985204697, -0.09013601392507553, -0.7066514492034912, 0.5847622156143188, 0.07493672519922256, 0.7524457573890686, 1.1285691261291504, 0.5316844582557678, 0.3163701891899109, -0.4307583272457123, 0.36594149470329285, -0.6152591705322266, -0.0656435638666153, 0.21482238173484802, 0.2740600109100342, 0.600837230682373, 1.188228964805603, 0.10589224845170975, 0.3302459716796875, 0.6146126985549927, 0.2058543860912323, -0.25907179713249207, -0.31583330035209656, -0.3427011966705322, -0.12352325767278671, 0.005824624095112085, 0.6392480731010437, -0.06250782310962677, 0.3610624372959137, -0.1935528665781021, 0.628250777721405, 0.2817319333553314, -0.5188297629356384, 0.16320042312145233, -0.4285387694835663, 0.720440685749054, 0.9851402640342712, 0.15410253405570984, 0.4136474132537842, 0.34137001633644104, -0.891947329044342, 0.012342484667897224, 0.13451524078845978, -0.536342442035675, 0.004249421413987875, -0.4945927560329437, 0.08461141586303711, -0.08657293021678925, 0.0257550235837698, -0.7829702496528625, 0.1009775772690773, -0.8969051241874695, -0.6837290525436401, 0.12779158353805542, -0.6664282083511353, -0.18756742775440216, -0.16221186518669128, -0.36447498202323914, -0.1405070424079895, -0.3870181143283844, 0.3324443995952606, -0.026810428127646446, -0.6177502870559692, -0.2416456788778305, 0.5716307759284973, 0.1503535807132721, 0.6216260194778442, 0.3209995627403259, 0.17927846312522888, 0.3044043183326721, -0.4685860276222229, 0.26319482922554016, 0.14372025430202484, -0.2931768596172333, -0.4874389171600342, 1.1515052318572998, 0.2426851987838745, -0.20569460093975067, -0.3816019594669342, -0.23045247793197632, -0.802078366279602, -0.13586916029453278, 0.15416689217090607, -0.5418100357055664, 0.031468331813812256, -0.6942700743675232, 0.5139936804771423, -0.8922533988952637, -0.1918056458234787, -0.6253848671913147, 0.3703654408454895, -0.3523343503475189, -0.24325807392597198, -0.2416435331106186, 0.49744296073913574, -0.8107050657272339, 0.09720867872238159, -1.6225359439849854, 0.5061612725257874, 0.6395567655563354, -0.14434708654880524, -0.46474313735961914, 0.3311610221862793, 0.08750180900096893, 0.07746558636426926, 0.43517011404037476, -0.08591123670339584, -0.3013457655906677, 0.519400954246521, -0.28046613931655884, 0.2965763509273529, 0.17949815094470978, 0.3265761733055115, 0.9573589563369751, -0.19250231981277466, -0.20315921306610107, 0.23842540383338928, 0.6184369325637817, -0.3363346457481384, 0.08196085691452026, 0.4602772891521454, 0.5577142238616943, 0.09571228176355362, 0.06518866866827011, 0.6847624778747559, 0.2531619668006897, 0.32290971279144287, 0.674656867980957, 0.5302203297615051, 0.6279500722885132, 0.8746669292449951, 0.7857322692871094, 0.3098667860031128, -0.7101763486862183, -0.2795243561267853, 0.4993668496608734, 0.030128590762615204, 0.2854272425174713, 0.6637330055236816, 0.03571135923266411, -0.10703825205564499, -0.767164945602417, 0.18322224915027618, -0.45283082127571106, 0.8240495324134827, 0.01622169278562069, 0.7150699496269226, -1.0514278411865234, 0.05597146973013878, -0.23053304851055145, 0.07975802570581436, -0.5238034129142761, -0.8842180967330933, -0.14030294120311737, -0.19722172617912292, -0.34684959053993225, -0.24893979728221893, -0.48337188363075256, 0.8301267623901367, -0.03886355459690094, -0.1957385241985321, -0.17334842681884766, -0.45657286047935486, -1.0175482034683228, -0.2511298954486847, -0.9172672033309937, -0.19477224349975586, -0.47646719217300415, -0.027642520144581795, 0.9098478555679321, -0.619125485420227, 0.7894003391265869, 0.47635167837142944, -0.1082095354795456, 0.3140608072280884, -0.17925366759300232, 0.7996044754981995, 0.3227993845939636, -0.013644970953464508, -0.9753297567367554, 0.6493530869483948, -0.622913658618927, 0.34986597299575806, -0.07684119790792465, -0.5827730894088745, 0.2989009916782379, -0.6728178262710571, 0.29699456691741943, -0.04250962287187576, -0.7828966975212097, -0.008884048089385033, -0.07974303513765335, -0.6021378040313721, 0.206000417470932, 0.2297000288963318, -0.6275162100791931, -0.36740294098854065, -1.2654966115951538, 0.7241218686103821, 0.10446052998304367, -0.39083144068717957, 0.6498559713363647, 0.5737102031707764, -0.14828413724899292, 0.38609886169433594, -0.2802160084247589, -0.18336531519889832, 0.05733203515410423, 0.8471396565437317, 1.237571120262146, 0.75428706407547, -0.15070514380931854, -0.2399211972951889, -0.9831514358520508, 0.6991531848907471, 0.31012558937072754, -1.4410651922225952, 0.3796881437301636, 0.7016847729682922, 0.17863145470619202, -0.4459702670574188, 0.7476232051849365, -1.1727174520492554, -0.7031227350234985, -0.023774083703756332, -0.633770227432251, 0.24251434206962585, -0.15667127072811127, -0.42670971155166626, -0.742121696472168, 0.2580609619617462, 0.6195395588874817, 0.2581217586994171, 0.6355326771736145, 0.12576177716255188, 0.6028728485107422, 0.4844808876514435, 0.34229132533073425, -0.374197781085968, 0.854857325553894, 0.2479160875082016, -1.1384295225143433, 0.494772732257843, -0.7106208801269531, -0.14248980581760406, 0.2880605459213257, 0.1785612851381302, -0.0063375793397426605, 0.3796389698982239, 0.008254142478108406, -0.20727156102657318, -1.0148745775222778, -0.08069693297147751, 0.4603714346885681, 0.23036521673202515, -0.5732029676437378, 0.5366711616516113, -0.824528157711029, -0.06126028299331665, 0.5670148730278015, -0.40639638900756836, 0.3690669536590576, -1.1569527387619019, 0.5716947317123413, 0.031010005623102188, -0.7392621636390686, -0.23562614619731903, -0.7056781649589539, -0.053729552775621414, 0.26970386505126953, 0.6355518102645874, 0.7405964732170105, -0.5321586728096008, -0.777741551399231, 0.31984061002731323, 0.7565566897392273, 0.8843272924423218, 0.39757028222084045, 0.4111368656158447, -0.29763442277908325, 0.2551230490207672, -0.6300100088119507, -0.7011665105819702, -0.2812141478061676, -0.2552163302898407, -0.11459006369113922, -0.392572820186615, -0.608447790145874, -0.214641273021698, 0.35906779766082764, -0.007686747703701258, 0.2488725334405899, -0.11864176392555237, 0.635409414768219, 0.2989738881587982, 0.22903360426425934, 0.7882999777793884, 0.11623477190732956, -0.28057748079299927, -0.5614922642707825, 0.491993248462677, 0.4956718683242798, -0.10346017777919769, -0.17383535206317902, -1.0791912078857422, -0.5442179441452026, -0.5686994194984436, 0.22919508814811707, 0.6802208423614502, -0.5259808897972107, 0.5508372783660889, 0.07302660495042801, -0.06564929336309433, 0.12193874269723892, -0.006032618228346109, 0.4442559778690338, 0.7159232497215271, 0.5351174473762512, -0.9741420149803162, -0.013870978727936745, -0.2111242115497589, 0.06939874589443207, 0.42328211665153503, 0.30685660243034363, -0.9671093821525574, -0.6145250201225281, 0.6130369305610657, -0.15824715793132782, -0.49422919750213623, 1.0622856616973877, 0.5011875033378601, -0.07554522156715393, -0.29831480979919434, 0.21931800246238708, 0.22413022816181183, -0.4534800946712494, -0.6983378529548645, -0.3375280797481537, 0.01075413916260004, -0.21737878024578094, 0.6931309700012207, -0.16558043658733368, -0.5800055265426636, -0.04628613218665123, -0.3841741681098938, 0.2285936176776886, -0.27746912837028503, -0.6267011165618896, 0.289304256439209, -0.26589930057525635, -0.7971895933151245, 0.3087398409843445, -0.20357868075370789, -0.030526839196681976, 0.45142942667007446, 0.2769869863986969, -0.17316551506519318, -0.4795584976673126, 0.4713799059391022, 0.37840813398361206, 0.7923357486724854, 0.7946292757987976, 0.2911584675312042, 0.13234412670135498, -0.06308930367231369, -0.24607177078723907, 0.4282056391239166, -0.06791932135820389, 0.00036857047234661877, -0.3965485095977783, -0.42210403084754944, -0.3523569107055664, -0.5109440088272095, -0.4710029661655426, 0.5990653038024902, -0.2658863067626953, 0.718043863773346, 0.33200573921203613, -0.7847614288330078, -0.3915867805480957, -0.18775556981563568, -0.2128942459821701, 0.4392654597759247, -0.5251264572143555, -0.37047821283340454, -0.5671718120574951, -0.04443198814988136, -0.6695668697357178, 0.7291025519371033, -0.3525755703449249, -0.3056415021419525, 0.3329509198665619, 0.3147597312927246, -0.0674271509051323, 0.7765771746635437, 0.11311706900596619, 0.6179487109184265, -0.1985485553741455, -0.16746017336845398, -0.1718095988035202, -0.035032838582992554, -0.49948135018348694, -0.031580183655023575, -0.17816905677318573, -0.5552908778190613, 0.35889893770217896, -0.2882443368434906, 0.49585920572280884, 0.4835659861564636, -0.40392160415649414, -0.15618188679218292, -0.3519807755947113, 0.046993665397167206, 0.5478762984275818, -0.3351544141769409, -0.02497033029794693, 0.4974415600299835, -0.29096609354019165, 0.05352893844246864, 0.19729164242744446, -0.7451835870742798, 0.24394671618938446, -0.25743815302848816, -0.012239716947078705, -0.5497070550918579, 0.28650912642478943, -0.47553038597106934, 0.039213601499795914, 0.27103927731513977, 0.4396122694015503, 0.36469128727912903, 0.10400507599115372, -0.8906396627426147, -0.2067301720380783, 0.06287990510463715, -0.3875844180583954, 0.11181195080280304, -0.23329871892929077, -0.22484008967876434, -0.2640024423599243, 0.6635900735855103, -1.0193660259246826, -0.3316013216972351, 0.5788878202438354, 0.010725381784141064, 0.211618110537529, 0.7124930620193481, 0.15115632116794586, -0.45875734090805054, 0.14865273237228394, 0.1325407773256302, -0.3816191852092743, 0.43377992510795593, -0.822454571723938, 0.5191698670387268, -1.1793560981750488, 0.9611514806747437, -0.10016608983278275, -0.6059331893920898, -0.1373458206653595, 0.3950691521167755, 0.7689452767372131, -0.7282125353813171, 0.30104178190231323, 0.5766130685806274, 0.04294700175523758, 0.9688844084739685, 0.30408579111099243, -0.4935417175292969, -1.1073204278945923, -0.7694759368896484, -0.8762521743774414, 0.6020882725715637, 0.033190879970788956, -0.20663601160049438, -0.5728359818458557, -0.5419985055923462, 0.02127240039408207, -0.19256825745105743, 1.1726500988006592, 1.0709128379821777, 0.44948819279670715, -0.2570810317993164, 0.14258155226707458, 0.931440532207489, -0.6022463440895081, -0.49818888306617737, 0.05056535825133324, -0.32076120376586914, -1.2968300580978394, 0.12218549847602844, -0.20527544617652893, -1.556730031967163, -0.5582287907600403, 0.3479311764240265, 0.0969085618853569, 0.055878326296806335, 0.9114360213279724, -0.5938382148742676, -0.3128367066383362, -0.5079470872879028, 0.3288516700267792, -0.09956930577754974, -0.16156518459320068, 0.7110291123390198, -0.28052639961242676, 0.1621374785900116, -0.24456621706485748, 0.33093327283859253, -1.1624003648757935, -0.7603975534439087, 0.3265196681022644, 0.06829986721277237, -0.12142913043498993, 0.4134918451309204, -0.2997089922428131, -0.16201454401016235, -0.6496990323066711, -0.33813661336898804, 0.2406153678894043, -0.2528054714202881, -0.5760676860809326, 0.843051552772522, -0.005959103349596262, -0.3809254467487335, 0.6320629715919495, 0.1935390681028366, -0.09580356627702713, 0.38666126132011414, -0.0035946802236139774, -0.4561627209186554, -0.67204350233078, -0.5228596925735474, 1.3731719255447388, -0.4722195267677307, -0.5519759654998779, -0.5339069366455078, -0.26373469829559326, -0.5741286873817444, 0.13580536842346191, 0.5440882444381714, -0.8385825753211975, 0.08348523825407028, 0.4256644546985626, 0.27500468492507935, 0.3225466310977936, 0.5405615568161011, -0.14655332267284393, 0.5653409957885742, 0.1809426248073578, -1.0168384313583374, -0.6685755848884583, 0.11120356619358063, 0.2624710202217102, 0.18870149552822113, -0.6629365682601929, 0.05540092661976814, 0.08198335021734238, -0.7304401993751526, -0.6794622540473938, -0.7722682356834412, 0.29811862111091614, -1.1832836866378784, -0.27807754278182983, -0.5192533135414124, -0.2546033263206482, 0.1980661153793335, 0.42295214533805847, 0.2444555163383484, -0.9700675010681152, -0.6727615594863892, 0.6616930365562439, 0.5712426900863647, 0.010776838287711143, 0.04835226386785507, -0.7590015530586243, -0.674593448638916, 0.09248274564743042, 0.40662673115730286, 0.1776130199432373, -0.353641539812088, 0.42841610312461853, 0.36835312843322754, 0.33411234617233276, -1.096642017364502, 0.4694286584854126, -0.09535595029592514, -0.1527492254972458, 0.16863372921943665, -0.005581030156463385, -0.7364987730979919, 0.6031883955001831, 0.0018783494597300887, 0.3033337891101837, 0.02043473720550537, 0.19479121267795563, -0.08784501999616623, -0.11842745542526245, -0.21141467988491058, 0.064364492893219, -0.6076475381851196, 0.5019683241844177, -0.10426950454711914, -0.19809915125370026, -0.16090697050094604, 0.021097108721733093, -1.0135315656661987, 0.0322922058403492, -0.02041972056031227, 0.551569938659668, -0.1607838273048401, 0.2453160434961319, -0.5608274340629578, -0.14541183412075043, -0.6655232906341553, 0.7003455758094788, -0.6174204349517822, -0.40054240822792053, 0.12341193854808807, 0.05961998924612999, -0.3489236831665039, 0.2923174500465393, 0.3712460696697235, -0.7787244915962219, 0.22174367308616638, 0.4530654847621918, -0.5320160984992981, 0.2154468297958374, -0.12987980246543884, -0.4875446557998657, -0.12946055829524994, -0.11708424985408783, -0.5736866593360901, 0.8860689401626587, 0.42743703722953796, -0.653562605381012, -0.6082439422607422, -0.6614221930503845, -0.7242525815963745, 0.04178837686777115, -0.6914685368537903, 0.18594084680080414, -0.1808936893939972, 0.13736490905284882, 0.19314728677272797, -0.14408405125141144, -0.45501673221588135, 0.5696420073509216, -0.3446168899536133, 0.7457973957061768, -0.554937481880188, -0.1474192887544632, -0.2285352647304535, 0.5605683922767639, -1.0631614923477173, -0.4678760766983032, -0.8047019243240356, 0.5791085362434387, -0.18946927785873413, -0.5564143657684326, -0.7151530385017395, 0.30771952867507935, -0.4620863199234009, -0.35780084133148193, -0.09909317642450333, 0.6820740103721619, 0.3808268904685974, -0.13398335874080658, 0.2467913180589676, -0.21208041906356812, 0.1748584359884262, 0.4753850996494293, 0.18285760283470154, -0.8004729747772217, 0.07689610868692398, 0.08742914348840714, 0.11811736226081848, 0.06482894718647003, 0.16492561995983124, 0.5100555419921875, 0.3717007339000702, -0.22346898913383484, 0.7413194179534912, -0.12507012486457825, 0.41639378666877747, 0.6425644755363464, -0.4007055163383484, -0.2569087743759155, 0.5596346259117126, 0.2605830430984497, 0.3045835793018341, 0.31487932801246643, -0.2449982911348343, 0.7303878664970398, 0.4735190272331238, -0.3416348695755005, 0.6208635568618774, 0.43441691994667053, 0.1801621913909912, 1.0992690324783325, 0.3596893548965454, 0.1539406031370163, 0.27148497104644775, 0.17265565693378448, 0.08341199159622192, -0.09804854542016983, -0.2402029037475586, -0.470440536737442, 0.22116495668888092, -0.229488804936409, -0.4866141378879547, -0.04679984599351883, -0.4388681650161743, -0.18644723296165466, -0.42833706736564636, 0.3463696539402008, 0.15061770379543304, 0.46747830510139465, 1.065742015838623, 0.576897144317627, 0.34326454997062683, -0.09316889196634293, 0.496967613697052, 0.8042860627174377, -0.25362876057624817, 0.3193167448043823, 0.8694570660591125, 0.6296511888504028, 0.14875103533267975, -1.1130253076553345, -0.2752283811569214, 0.1297583132982254, -1.297132134437561, -0.12650443613529205, 0.05827563628554344, -0.5916795134544373, 0.22517700493335724, -0.4944412410259247, 0.23794442415237427, -0.6003440022468567, 0.055207278579473495, 0.7201479077339172, -0.7342202067375183, 0.4302048981189728, 0.9940914511680603, 0.4429306089878082, 0.7587016820907593, 1.0488182306289673, -0.01338503509759903, -0.12407242506742477, 1.3876665830612183, 0.44441476464271545, -0.3598725497722626, 0.1919110119342804, 0.26423120498657227, -0.5443387031555176, -0.27244096994400024, 0.6267105340957642, -0.3478911519050598, 0.48348256945610046, -0.2938445806503296, -0.08505246788263321, -0.5859237909317017, 0.25979161262512207, -0.5361524820327759, -0.2226422280073166, -0.08415783941745758, 0.37043479084968567, -0.3474273383617401, -0.43792960047721863, 0.8837971687316895, 0.9457729458808899, -0.20930618047714233, -0.750924825668335, -0.7968870997428894, -0.05256287008523941, -0.1788419783115387, -0.6103470921516418, 0.0026867103297263384, 0.21410037577152252, 0.5402296185493469, -0.2422124743461609, -0.4409966766834259, -0.714401364326477, -1.0968046188354492, -0.1360437572002411, -0.49808865785598755, 0.3494250476360321, -0.2162056267261505, 0.9027854204177856, 0.3887723386287689, -0.6818257570266724, -0.017388898879289627, -0.18889428675174713, 0.9505296349525452, -0.3566409945487976, 0.410976767539978, -0.03880108520388603, 0.34457841515541077, -0.9403402209281921, 0.25049981474876404, 0.4300689101219177, -0.26793956756591797, 0.7561148405075073, -0.32674312591552734, -0.26701608300209045, 0.3438829779624939, -0.19934791326522827, 0.24230404198169708, 0.25612807273864746, 0.2989257276058197, -0.1842796355485916, -0.3324551582336426, -1.1865854263305664, -0.7595620155334473, -0.07065075635910034, -0.37999227643013, 0.7458173036575317, 0.2336535006761551, 0.341761976480484, 0.40474018454551697, -0.3393302261829376, 4.175390243530273, 0.6764006018638611, 0.5397289991378784, 0.11746463179588318, 0.8270333409309387, 0.847952127456665, 0.03957367688417435, -0.16229860484600067, -0.10959161818027496, -0.5092285871505737, 0.06295758485794067, 0.41425424814224243, -0.1839679628610611, 0.00931630004197359, -0.6398860216140747, 0.6596056818962097, -0.3872304856777191, 0.27270936965942383, 0.07599512487649918, -0.9403753876686096, 0.18116796016693115, -0.008066067472100258, 0.5310404896736145, -0.19289833307266235, 0.27471914887428284, 0.1099521741271019, 0.3617441952228546, -0.7160662412643433, -0.25122132897377014, -0.5559180974960327, -0.22852398455142975, -0.9424741864204407, -0.1343042254447937, -0.13497966527938843, -0.5258563160896301, 0.09641317278146744, 0.15576761960983276, -0.251941978931427, 0.060283008962869644, -0.3905564844608307, -0.47818663716316223, -0.16945461928844452, 0.4553535282611847, 0.013208127580583096, -1.5309383869171143, 1.1514164209365845, -0.62044757604599, 1.1614296436309814, 0.61631840467453, -0.4973164200782776, 0.6222209334373474, 0.1658814698457718, 0.31333404779434204, -0.3052026629447937, -0.8023667335510254, 0.5419846177101135, -0.2873687446117401, 0.029101135209202766, 0.1813986599445343, 0.14094758033752441, 0.9516387581825256, 0.07469873875379562, -0.7077878713607788, 0.2704034149646759, -0.0433390811085701, 0.8674069046974182, 0.6519982814788818, 0.5594408512115479, -0.5008740425109863, 0.093313068151474, -0.4991050958633423, 0.09329310804605484, -0.29944050312042236, -0.27702561020851135, 0.4330604374408722, -0.02790050022304058, -0.4833959639072418, 0.6615042686462402, 0.2964223027229309, -0.01725415699183941, 0.1549822837114334, -0.33725887537002563, 0.014398329891264439, 0.04392743110656738, 0.04675514996051788, 1.2511578798294067, 0.2953498065471649, 0.010361979715526104, -0.14022642374038696, 1.062047004699707, 0.6391199827194214, 0.651856541633606, -0.03537755459547043, 0.11804448068141937, -0.9875733852386475 ]
Fredholm Determinant Representation for Correlation Functions in XXO Heisenberg Chain
Space and time dependent temepreture correlation fucntions in the Hiesenberg XXO chain are evaluated in the magnetic field. The other name of the model is isotropic xy model in the transverse magnetic field. In the thermodynamic limit correlations in the model are represented as Fredhom determinanat. We expect this to to solve the problem of evaluation of asymptotics of temperature correlations.
F.Colomo, A.G. Izergin, V. Korepin
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204011
cond-mat/9204012
[ -0.09298267960548401, 0.1840464174747467, 0.27052658796310425, 0.02965480089187622, -0.09420055896043777, 0.39570263028144836, -0.029073603451251984, -0.3253362476825714, -0.5848928093910217, 1.2649548053741455, 0.8966730833053589, -0.5092371106147766, 0.6029711365699768, -1.155867099761963, 0.15964633226394653, 0.7835586667060852, -0.488044410943985, -0.32640352845191956, -0.9809938073158264, -0.26831990480422974, 0.48358434438705444, -0.5707221627235413, -0.7713409662246704, -1.2027297019958496, -0.6463788151741028, 0.2248307466506958, 0.12888039648532867, -0.026051001623272896, 1.3882924318313599, 0.37919867038726807, 0.27070480585098267, -0.44075220823287964, -0.24866293370723724, -0.7578504681587219, -0.5558398962020874, -0.31290507316589355, -0.12540645897388458, -0.27919188141822815, 0.6233652830123901, -0.6308820247650146, 1.1393722295761108, -0.06002449989318848, 1.099331021308899, -0.2712513208389282, -0.22997619211673737, 0.04004956781864166, 0.242721825838089, -0.3180563151836395, -0.13269636034965515, -0.9867521524429321, 0.8891615867614746, -0.2532911002635956, -0.1230330616235733, -0.32890650629997253, -0.4516739249229431, 0.08192746341228485, 0.0830923542380333, -0.2825795114040375, -0.11255203187465668, -0.4939424693584442, 0.6699448823928833, 0.5616893768310547, 0.6160055994987488, -1.0477070808410645, 0.27201157808303833, 0.6214613318443298, 0.14652566611766815, 0.6297492980957031, -0.16396668553352356, -0.6027945280075073, -0.7863819003105164, -0.42774200439453125, 0.16386424005031586, -0.18388311564922333, -0.6931416988372803, 0.27485284209251404, -0.46684005856513977, -0.3593602776527405, -1.0132216215133667, -0.3045196235179901, -0.07157989591360092, 0.09678611159324646, -0.12440164387226105, 1.278990626335144, -0.0055182380601763725, -0.2718772888183594, -0.6633135676383972, 0.44157931208610535, 0.3344976007938385, -0.18276768922805786, 0.30642908811569214, 1.0128337144851685, -0.07257548719644547, -0.06431791931390762, 0.42315804958343506, 0.7807359099388123, -0.27298614382743835, 0.6914243698120117, 0.6275776028633118, 0.17423716187477112, -0.8940811157226562, 1.3353437185287476, -0.25986990332603455, 0.4634154140949249, -0.4520987868309021, -0.09075379371643066, 0.012658363208174706, 0.04796324670314789, -0.38753029704093933, -0.10385839641094208, 0.1050061583518982, 0.1467108279466629, 0.6683710217475891, 0.6325868368148804, 0.01578882336616516, 0.7472985982894897, 0.0421820692718029, 0.05846284702420235, -0.9144635200500488, -0.09280848503112793, -1.1223134994506836, -0.2999555170536041, -0.2687667906284332, 0.25485432147979736, 0.5235379338264465, -0.6109023690223694, 0.8234850168228149, 0.5189191102981567, -0.11145496368408203, 0.024974379688501358, 0.20623858273029327, -0.04791531711816788, 0.3749704658985138, 0.9230677485466003, 0.10959425568580627, 0.08508666604757309, -0.10367536544799805, 0.7900043725967407, -0.16578535735607147, -0.13125035166740417, 0.15521013736724854, -0.1871703565120697, 1.0380641222000122, 1.0046980381011963, -0.1618226170539856, 0.08534198999404907, 0.6844792366027832, -0.5066097974777222, 0.11260457336902618, 0.08695617318153381, -0.883983314037323, 0.021202653646469116, 0.000050210768677061424, -0.12380187213420868, -0.4497368335723877, 0.30364397168159485, -0.9656150937080383, 0.839667022228241, -0.8810688257217407, -0.49856510758399963, 0.03664855286478996, -0.13853667676448822, 0.026266172528266907, 0.2519826591014862, -0.6836344003677368, -0.03778325766324997, -0.5205625295639038, -0.35467034578323364, 0.23244312405586243, 0.0018180457409471273, -0.2848449945449829, 0.41099032759666443, 0.5433757901191711, 0.02685621567070484, -0.06848609447479248, 0.44059842824935913, 1.3318911790847778, 0.5439739227294922, 0.179387167096138, 0.3152664601802826, -0.522844135761261, -0.358206570148468, 1.3959466218948364, 0.015736160799860954, -0.5090041160583496, -0.3505961298942566, -0.7900534272193909, -0.5488467812538147, 0.6362999677658081, 0.26783815026283264, -0.35362404584884644, 0.316267192363739, -0.465600848197937, -0.10791824758052826, -0.49827367067337036, -0.3058909773826599, -1.1711926460266113, -0.146724671125412, -0.054363176226615906, -0.4784523844718933, -1.0435045957565308, 0.521252453327179, -0.7740402221679688, -0.3713618814945221, -1.0743337869644165, -0.03695223480463028, 0.5007565021514893, -0.037037886679172516, -0.5811228156089783, 0.4181118309497833, 0.026365896686911583, 0.060842227190732956, 0.36383411288261414, 0.1491813212633133, 0.7229622006416321, 0.01925017312169075, -0.9013473391532898, 0.003943104762583971, 0.546090841293335, 0.11934266984462738, 0.41781488060951233, 0.35766133666038513, 0.021342873573303223, 0.5826836228370667, -0.36898791790008545, 0.12300238758325577, 0.6014675498008728, 0.5265017151832581, 0.35834842920303345, -0.1318834125995636, 0.06089518219232559, 0.759197473526001, 0.6331102848052979, 0.25470277667045593, 1.448869228363037, 0.21533352136611938, 0.5359649062156677, 1.0215733051300049, 0.8673611283302307, 0.5746988654136658, 0.1560531109571457, -0.1461339294910431, 0.6792618036270142, 0.25878992676734924, -0.26784950494766235, -0.3622475564479828, -0.6200743317604065, 0.08890539407730103, -0.5419231653213501, 0.3658486008644104, -0.5278213620185852, 0.9327667355537415, -0.0033869859762489796, -0.44102388620376587, -0.7206747531890869, -0.023804370313882828, 0.14497552812099457, 0.2486572414636612, -0.14507631957530975, 0.008362896740436554, 0.36962178349494934, 0.26695024967193604, -0.4742056429386139, 0.3276250660419464, 0.4152243137359619, 0.8001280426979065, 0.396653950214386, 0.24173076450824738, -0.3197132349014282, -0.4958583414554596, -1.362611174583435, -0.4258902668952942, -0.5901296138763428, 0.17357660830020905, -0.21308833360671997, -0.21847152709960938, 0.8045029044151306, -0.9019145965576172, 1.4391471147537231, 0.2554877996444702, -0.3104438781738281, -0.08212099969387054, 0.08685673773288727, 0.7866088151931763, 0.6991983652114868, 0.6375411748886108, -1.2272011041641235, 0.12165166437625885, -1.1936438083648682, 0.406189501285553, -0.5584962964057922, -0.3048061728477478, 0.7371960878372192, -0.3245779573917389, 0.1645095944404602, -0.16335976123809814, -0.9907578229904175, -1.0256601572036743, -1.0291452407836914, -0.11838988214731216, -0.03436964750289917, 0.46378472447395325, -0.5943068861961365, -0.14008158445358276, -0.41107386350631714, 1.2486331462860107, -0.29837527871131897, -0.390842080116272, 0.3966740071773529, 1.096481442451477, -0.6192949414253235, 0.10238411277532578, 0.13264861702919006, 0.4825165867805481, 0.06909210234880447, 1.0481518507003784, 1.4203639030456543, -0.021514959633350372, 0.006285268347710371, -0.6140438914299011, -1.184247612953186, 0.17332853376865387, 0.19200031459331512, -0.9911124110221863, -0.6827377676963806, 0.6690743565559387, 0.18818305432796478, -0.5701097846031189, 0.206051766872406, -1.6203796863555908, -0.8650653958320618, -0.29477936029434204, 0.06355684995651245, 1.0607171058654785, -0.1815245896577835, 0.38900771737098694, -0.23270027339458466, -0.22313492000102997, 0.5599168539047241, 0.4301920533180237, 0.05206787958741188, -0.043773431330919266, 0.8548375368118286, 0.48252424597740173, -0.45047876238822937, 0.45049887895584106, 0.3889172673225403, -0.7287927269935608, 0.1567089557647705, 0.8406696915626526, -0.20906561613082886, 0.23431098461151123, 0.41926395893096924, 0.252044677734375, 0.27977311611175537, 0.4125406742095947, -0.6478935480117798, -0.5016169548034668, -0.696985125541687, -0.20047342777252197, 1.0889887809753418, 0.5847204327583313, -0.5479121208190918, -0.028377719223499298, -0.7097448110580444, -0.14936389029026031, -0.314048707485199, 0.10943891853094101, 0.6418190598487854, -0.360500305891037, 0.4663078486919403, 0.16337324678897858, -0.1413528174161911, 0.35680708289146423, -0.2478514313697815, -0.5160629749298096, 0.1944539099931717, 0.4538903832435608, 1.001015305519104, -1.0731836557388306, -0.11022546887397766, -0.08953738212585449, 0.6795264482498169, 0.40605950355529785, 0.24052469432353973, 0.5249018669128418, -0.39351123571395874, 0.15636026859283447, -0.7100773453712463, -1.0080174207687378, 0.019331885501742363, -0.14455275237560272, -0.6334180235862732, -0.5729822516441345, -0.32489854097366333, -0.7293875813484192, 0.7079824209213257, 0.9893380999565125, -0.19070586562156677, 0.532143235206604, 0.39372017979621887, 0.6446871757507324, 0.13009017705917358, 0.8316933512687683, -0.43188872933387756, 0.05371443182229996, -0.7077770233154297, -0.014336430467665195, 0.250137060880661, -0.3716297447681427, 0.08379317075014114, -0.6340409517288208, -0.30599215626716614, -0.39946767687797546, 0.6987770199775696, 0.3489902913570404, 0.12130926549434662, 0.7976169586181641, 0.3649532198905945, -0.1007222905755043, -0.7281760573387146, 0.24880416691303253, -0.28119122982025146, 0.40611112117767334, 0.6886538863182068, -0.4573102593421936, 0.7718972563743591, -0.48399633169174194, 0.6270623207092285, 0.8035163879394531, -0.011743650771677494, -0.692603349685669, -0.06329139322042465, 0.7993555068969727, -0.21860264241695404, 0.42209139466285706, 0.9261773228645325, -0.40493544936180115, 0.2059229463338852, 0.09481852501630783, 0.11458727717399597, 0.07050483673810959, -0.658227801322937, 0.2583441138267517, 0.20420867204666138, 0.20693621039390564, -0.6323504447937012, 0.9806423783302307, 0.4079184830188751, -0.7174782752990723, 0.05639132484793663, -0.2503194808959961, 0.51063072681427, -1.0056732892990112, -0.02144291065633297, -0.3738833963871002, -0.42730990052223206, -0.6778292059898376, 0.17724333703517914, -0.36981338262557983, 0.7030987739562988, 0.09322846680879593, -0.03729211166501045, -0.7958981394767761, -0.5259872674942017, 0.6464119553565979, -0.21208177506923676, 0.11548259109258652, 0.6007295250892639, 0.39627906680107117, 0.5416816473007202, 0.11313541978597641, -0.06698773801326752, 0.13126753270626068, 0.1375327706336975, -0.20334915816783905, 0.41251763701438904, -0.7177899479866028, -0.6745685935020447, -0.6371580362319946, -0.9886198043823242, 0.29254594445228577, -0.46802419424057007, 0.9182015657424927, 0.27149370312690735, -0.9513130784034729, -0.7285100221633911, -0.2657167315483093, -0.7693828344345093, 0.3150135576725006, 0.27875083684921265, -0.1862773448228836, -0.16094957292079926, 0.07788019627332687, -0.7827745676040649, 0.11099524050951004, -0.786881148815155, -0.8240880966186523, 0.2128811627626419, 0.3141656219959259, -0.22297079861164093, 0.09931204468011856, -0.4584152400493622, 0.547661542892456, 0.03704886510968208, 0.5278438329696655, 0.1344379037618637, -0.7587481141090393, -0.7076631188392639, 0.011185472831130028, -0.7050542235374451, -0.6454764604568481, -0.26509466767311096, 0.23516786098480225, 0.11907705664634705, -0.08520780503749847, 0.11339177936315536, -0.022759204730391502, -1.0645356178283691, 0.7846978306770325, -0.21030476689338684, -0.6357861161231995, 0.05027976632118225, 1.2593382596969604, 0.09930414706468582, 0.20059967041015625, 0.23829162120819092, -0.23545825481414795, 0.0024733212776482105, 0.008885389193892479, 0.4465322196483612, -1.2388248443603516, 0.025453729555010796, -0.6179091334342957, 0.20551154017448425, 0.13145644962787628, 0.6875457763671875, -0.010746046900749207, -0.026626117527484894, 0.10147980600595474, -0.34815818071365356, -0.11300816386938095, -0.6882897615432739, -0.3300480246543884, -0.4482627213001251, -0.3952360451221466, -1.3584163188934326, 1.2141516208648682, -0.19787418842315674, -0.21297909319400787, 0.6699293255805969, 0.011118951253592968, -0.39918506145477295, 0.8825350403785706, -0.19281232357025146, -0.17072542011737823, -0.1479998677968979, 0.3150939345359802, -0.35627326369285583, 0.08144821971654892, -0.1440529227256775, 1.0280590057373047, -0.8394545912742615, 0.5058349967002869, 0.22419144213199615, 0.10124434530735016, -0.14084786176681519, -0.6777888536453247, 0.6290087699890137, -1.207700252532959, -0.5554414987564087, 0.07726322114467621, 0.48566675186157227, 0.7763174772262573, -0.20494846999645233, -0.4898034632205963, -0.4787641167640686, -1.0540847778320312, -1.1561708450317383, 0.535878598690033, -0.031162893399596214, -0.18000003695487976, -0.6632333993911743, -0.9783915281295776, 0.5301936268806458, -0.5610802173614502, 0.1606309562921524, -0.017783502116799355, -0.18350626528263092, -0.10839705914258957, 0.11524264514446259, 0.7630346417427063, 0.19123007357120514, -0.2328789383172989, 0.03091375157237053, -0.4594968259334564, -0.5664057731628418, -0.0709306001663208, -0.4373941719532013, -0.9053982496261597, -0.09557212889194489, 0.6804454922676086, 0.5113743543624878, 0.21536460518836975, 0.6343132853507996, -0.47694888710975647, -0.4321536421775818, -0.35893547534942627, 0.34533753991127014, 0.5884755849838257, 0.5897100567817688, 0.5542343258857727, 0.15051227807998657, -0.3205389082431793, -0.5842000246047974, 0.15013352036476135, -1.239613652229309, 0.3014543354511261, 0.9546929001808167, -0.5760750770568848, -0.6346611380577087, -0.4515969455242157, -0.09625519812107086, -0.5255581140518188, -0.5129546523094177, -0.8771593570709229, -0.5402865409851074, -0.08758895844221115, -1.0221437215805054, 0.6527982354164124, -0.2571212649345398, -0.25166457891464233, -0.31382042169570923, 0.6113875508308411, -0.009569301269948483, 0.12054166197776794, 0.0019852060358971357, -0.3578512370586395, -0.70762038230896, -0.11537802964448929, 0.8826143741607666, -0.9441268444061279, -0.2778059244155884, -0.6648039817810059, -0.7462299466133118, -0.8493020534515381, -0.3160701394081116, -0.12105809152126312, -0.5077678561210632, 0.29023507237434387, 0.6609774231910706, 0.5686003565788269, 0.7167053818702698, 0.06837590038776398, 0.0013867937959730625, -0.222533717751503, 0.4314787685871124, -0.6232250928878784, -0.8027097582817078, -0.005727315787225962, 0.2906264066696167, 0.8668416738510132, -0.8976858854293823, 0.1084003672003746, -0.03875484690070152, 0.1449226588010788, -0.8284549713134766, -0.721246600151062, 0.1386142075061798, -1.4171314239501953, -0.30873292684555054, -0.6246465444564819, -0.4306294023990631, -0.14861202239990234, 0.2263929545879364, -0.42316028475761414, -0.021430857479572296, -0.4007115364074707, -0.3724746108055115, 0.5510814785957336, 0.5101909637451172, 0.4241504669189453, 0.10927991569042206, -1.2894740104675293, 0.25015971064567566, 0.013646005652844906, -0.380239337682724, 0.18374262750148773, -0.17172862589359283, -0.505734384059906, 0.48927921056747437, -0.6139646172523499, 0.5045904517173767, -0.5676789283752441, 0.001992085948586464, 0.37184497714042664, 0.2796398997306824, 0.4184872806072235, 0.44417285919189453, -0.4794529378414154, 0.3380550742149353, 0.10433788597583771, 0.4140186607837677, 0.5279340744018555, 0.23913171887397766, -1.1445008516311646, -0.28710487484931946, -0.40119701623916626, 0.44694992899894714, 0.2258990854024887, -0.7837814092636108, 0.45234277844429016, 0.3742177188396454, -1.2316889762878418, 0.5999059081077576, -0.2547820210456848, -0.05227072536945343, 0.12391653656959534, 0.3113527297973633, -0.013535323552787304, 0.8948469161987305, 0.24184980988502502, 0.6452076435089111, -0.6149143576622009, -0.4721420407295227, 0.1425853967666626, 0.15250538289546967, -0.7263032793998718, 0.47322019934654236, 0.15126505494117737, -0.7180657982826233, -0.08993563801050186, 0.8310631513595581, -1.1733773946762085, 0.28337332606315613, -0.5760265588760376, -0.47829321026802063, -0.19167988002300262, -0.2214115709066391, 0.03160613402724266, 0.6197318434715271, -0.2067348062992096, -0.809579610824585, 0.4064573049545288, -0.7260194420814514, -0.48151448369026184, 0.15635083615779877, -0.1867966502904892, 0.07593990862369537, -0.13503779470920563, -0.10440231114625931, -0.16311435401439667, -0.16864237189292908, -0.23131424188613892, 0.3724392354488373, -0.292549729347229, 0.5642447471618652, -0.09660429507493973, 0.5442517995834351, -0.03029760532081127, 0.4765314757823944, -0.8974930644035339, -0.09286385774612427, -0.45861902832984924, 0.6205991506576538, 0.021650340408086777, -0.6660280823707581, 0.09190277755260468, -0.1251499205827713, -0.3633885681629181, 0.3092232346534729, -0.02657805196940899, 0.3428966999053955, 0.03749512508511543, 0.6623638868331909, -0.05958101153373718, -0.08879496157169342, -0.46584460139274597, 1.0386863946914673, 0.5329689383506775, -0.0749785453081131, -0.03119647689163685, 0.06744424253702164, 0.4169236719608307, -0.26278021931648254, -0.03504510968923569, 0.4638845920562744, 0.4361705780029297, -0.9628930687904358, 1.16835618019104, -0.05777089297771454, 0.5474645495414734, -0.31012648344039917, 0.04101576283574104, -0.19470766186714172, -0.09870471805334091, 0.5947998762130737, 0.7671291828155518, 0.6806419491767883, 0.6507951617240906, 0.5200673341751099, 0.1171133741736412, 0.9356668591499329, 0.7179681658744812, 0.5817229747772217, -0.07849854230880737, 0.6878181099891663, -0.497339129447937, 0.6500927209854126, -0.15937495231628418, 0.013632705435156822, 0.08369120210409164, 0.30079185962677, -0.7211359739303589, 0.06632603704929352, -0.396020770072937, 0.3580095171928406, -0.2185724824666977, -0.48598501086235046, -0.1704866588115692, 0.4981694519519806, 0.7000319957733154, 0.22063472867012024, 0.6128790378570557, 0.044096242636442184, 0.6895588040351868, 0.2891372740268707, -0.15440431237220764, 0.5312982797622681, 0.40629807114601135, -0.06611719727516174, 0.8663365840911865, 0.5064729452133179, 0.5804717540740967, -0.05680401623249054, 0.03277693688869476, -1.195907711982727, -0.33166584372520447, 0.6727959513664246, -1.035994052886963, 0.09319789707660675, 0.19162671267986298, -0.08010656386613846, 0.45144039392471313, -0.4024604260921478, 0.6168851852416992, -0.2327396422624588, 0.3371211886405945, 0.5130132436752319, -0.19149288535118103, 0.20039968192577362, 0.7939566969871521, -0.10778360813856125, 0.7978407144546509, 0.8928129076957703, 0.6674746870994568, -0.22739852964878082, 0.6957111954689026, 1.1381973028182983, 0.06958464533090591, 0.20424647629261017, 0.2766839861869812, -0.25486624240875244, -0.16213756799697876, -0.22087788581848145, -0.5233065485954285, 0.7779994010925293, -0.5606330633163452, -0.2525571286678314, 0.27944302558898926, 0.24900896847248077, -0.18305878341197968, -0.19769206643104553, 0.43390318751335144, 0.4662328064441681, -0.4730990529060364, -0.003080368973314762, 0.568333089351654, 0.037930138409137726, 0.6093342304229736, 0.3666726350784302, 0.15664565563201904, -0.09230884164571762, 0.1256408840417862, -1.1582386493682861, 0.3232768177986145, 0.41374167799949646, 0.37019577622413635, 0.4139472544193268, -1.0178965330123901, -0.5217946767807007, -0.4151650667190552, -0.038031499832868576, -0.5449985265731812, 0.6565252542495728, -0.6102656126022339, 0.618432879447937, -0.008427361957728863, -0.6776213645935059, 0.4124544560909271, 1.0571441650390625, 0.8900590538978577, 0.32476797699928284, 0.655422568321228, 0.6340622305870056, 0.16873030364513397, -0.23114000260829926, 0.43302667140960693, 0.804189145565033, -0.2886853814125061, 0.46449774503707886, -0.2373223453760147, 0.29280009865760803, -0.06032577529549599, 0.27153560519218445, -0.10619471222162247, 0.05380771681666374, 0.07383034378290176, -0.2346033900976181, -0.7175530791282654, -0.08434242010116577, -1.1099601984024048, -0.5273712277412415, -0.9970636367797852, 0.5193158388137817, 0.4285491108894348, -0.0012961747124791145, 0.19697804749011993, -0.27749934792518616, 3.9387147426605225, 1.2472275495529175, 0.46528008580207825, -0.2657337784767151, 0.7425287961959839, 0.9966241121292114, 0.05964469164609909, -0.19482605159282684, -0.11306268721818924, -0.4104447364807129, 0.5612269639968872, 0.0656718760728836, 0.19135141372680664, -0.4287630021572113, 0.17222632467746735, 0.6730979084968567, -0.4068325459957123, 0.276375949382782, 0.05942285805940628, -0.8202978372573853, -0.8139738440513611, 0.36844027042388916, -0.3480494022369385, -0.2893748879432678, 0.5192728638648987, -0.19081410765647888, -0.0362221822142601, -0.3834143280982971, -1.104122281074524, -0.15873685479164124, -0.06867349147796631, -0.5275793671607971, -0.45019766688346863, -0.14516040682792664, -0.626462996006012, -0.2750816345214844, 0.17313629388809204, -0.6882793307304382, 0.09060420095920563, 1.0645899772644043, -0.030364220961928368, -1.0015937089920044, 0.04803246632218361, 0.3907967805862427, -1.2675793170928955, 0.6824497580528259, -0.06797833740711212, 0.7708771824836731, -0.07476653903722763, -0.32465511560440063, -0.01914353109896183, -0.5808485150337219, 0.25732851028442383, -0.5401709079742432, -1.0494110584259033, 0.10978952050209045, -0.5290581583976746, -0.5267755389213562, -0.07455038279294968, -0.23767982423305511, 1.0910414457321167, -0.1357080042362213, -0.4476813077926636, -0.13461445271968842, -0.4906347692012787, 0.7766230702400208, 0.1572975367307663, -0.36632922291755676, -0.13057757914066315, -0.49599093198776245, -0.6474938988685608, -0.3299102485179901, -0.9550023674964905, 0.21629810333251953, 0.872587263584137, 0.02698003314435482, -0.6525043845176697, 0.679939329624176, -0.015103829093277454, -0.6257362961769104, -0.24620409309864044, -0.5554066896438599, -0.7031969428062439, -0.048596207052469254, 0.3048866391181946, 0.7380407452583313, -0.5413488149642944, 0.13294003903865814, -0.344035267829895, 0.5462968945503235, 0.18088622391223907, 1.157473087310791, 0.27992498874664307, 0.020901033654808998, -0.6906274557113647 ]
Tweed in Martensites: A Potential New Spin Glass
We've been studying the ``tweed'' precursors above the martensitic transition in shape--memory alloys. These characteristic cross--hatched modulations occur for hundreds of degrees above the first--order shape--changing transition. Our two--dimensional model for this transition, in the limit of infinite elastic anisotropy, can be mapped onto a spin--glass Hamiltonian in a random field. We suggest that the tweed precursors are a direct analogy of the spin--glass phase. The tweed is intermediate between the high--temperature cubic phase and the low--temperature martensitic phase in the same way as the spin--glass phase can be intermediate between ferromagnet and antiferromagnet.
James P. Sethna, Sivan Kartha, Teresa Cast'an, and James A. Krumhansl
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204012
cond-mat/9204013
[ -0.12482549995183945, 0.5294868350028992, 0.5790662169456482, 0.32306405901908875, -0.03626704588532448, 0.1314481645822525, -0.07726146280765533, -0.3156626224517822, 0.21773141622543335, 1.346790075302124, 0.32692259550094604, 0.2830032408237457, 0.3766673803329468, -1.1282336711883545, -0.05254129320383072, 0.34488412737846375, -0.5351236462593079, 0.1634514033794403, -0.8840982913970947, 0.18046000599861145, 0.07449471205472946, 0.138019859790802, -0.9478350281715393, -0.6858503222465515, -0.7944169044494629, 0.6060712933540344, 0.5548971891403198, 0.14935123920440674, 1.024657964706421, 0.19049124419689178, -0.31231576204299927, -0.53875333070755, 0.03770271688699722, -0.9561264514923096, -0.4720081686973572, -0.37234005331993103, 0.5043798089027405, 0.3293447196483612, 0.3156355619430542, 0.06592529267072678, 1.0276020765304565, 0.21882398426532745, 0.6028991341590881, -0.5725659728050232, -0.18132276833057404, -0.10974616557359695, 0.3269045352935791, -0.39528170228004456, 0.13289637863636017, -0.5647123456001282, 0.1052776500582695, 0.38066259026527405, 0.5918533802032471, -1.3862972259521484, -0.5616466999053955, 0.2495412677526474, 0.713615894317627, 0.44157910346984863, 0.35024192929267883, -0.06563027203083038, 0.5829251408576965, 0.20732663571834564, 0.18558451533317566, -0.7810551524162292, 0.4536333382129669, 0.282511442899704, -0.23311613500118256, 0.789544403553009, 0.40300220251083374, -0.4620356559753418, -0.5691419243812561, 0.3497273623943329, -0.05812690779566765, -0.4507768452167511, -0.2771416902542114, 0.5149083137512207, -0.01317578088492155, -0.36239445209503174, -0.7386224269866943, -0.29739874601364136, -0.14723844826221466, 0.38115358352661133, -0.6235083341598511, 0.9806519150733948, -0.5949986577033997, -0.22206076979637146, -0.7462052702903748, 0.13261999189853668, -0.018417486920952797, 0.007021087687462568, -0.263104110956192, 0.8423382043838501, 0.3962078392505646, 0.24853327870368958, 0.3585202693939209, 0.3588990569114685, -0.09575574100017548, 0.6717148423194885, 0.11056330054998398, 0.621544361114502, 0.42709553241729736, 1.8201640844345093, -0.9388688206672668, 0.507878303527832, -0.7777017951011658, 0.41026240587234497, 0.15493600070476532, -0.41804084181785583, 0.2719513177871704, -0.8001620769500732, 0.5783569812774658, 0.7908269166946411, 0.27071473002433777, 0.6602528095245361, 0.14162088930606842, 0.5265400409698486, 0.5675821304321289, 0.5181230902671814, -0.6389743685722351, -0.36410006880760193, 0.07519396394491196, 0.6029325127601624, 0.3435870110988617, 0.35845333337783813, 0.2568375766277313, 0.20715314149856567, 0.869140088558197, 0.6422209739685059, -0.03899620473384857, -0.7162310481071472, 0.2153453826904297, -0.5241307020187378, -0.2694697976112366, 0.8470763564109802, 0.3029803931713104, -0.3613770008087158, -0.006285743322223425, 0.36000901460647583, 0.014778329990804195, 0.4955264925956726, 0.2122546136379242, -1.0404142141342163, 0.5281313061714172, 1.122568130493164, 0.07678062468767166, 0.09292647987604141, 0.5758585333824158, -0.2074977308511734, -0.18657267093658447, 0.5791978240013123, -0.34612640738487244, -0.46302345395088196, -0.18754690885543823, 0.14492198824882507, 0.05017635226249695, 0.2654941976070404, -1.0620546340942383, 1.0419654846191406, -0.6576016545295715, -0.3090689182281494, 0.5356153249740601, -0.8919217586517334, 0.003949206322431564, 0.42378664016723633, -0.5104700922966003, 0.031229335814714432, -0.8205548524856567, -0.6300621032714844, 0.26488980650901794, 0.12278975546360016, 0.16418083012104034, 0.24417568743228912, 0.09247414022684097, 0.21150529384613037, 0.7179033756256104, 0.7297927141189575, 0.5886860489845276, -0.7524940967559814, -0.16488593816757202, 0.09752246737480164, -0.32110676169395447, -0.39450186491012573, 1.2823104858398438, -0.1454511135816574, -0.30381858348846436, -0.20605823397636414, -0.9138301610946655, -0.4188537001609802, 0.423881471157074, 0.1629498451948166, 0.13167719542980194, -0.014673901721835136, -0.5766373872756958, 0.34546661376953125, -1.099953055381775, -0.3181634247303009, -0.5885401964187622, 0.34186211228370667, -0.58759605884552, -1.3129159212112427, -0.3165053129196167, -0.7086465954780579, -0.4704003632068634, -0.5331987142562866, -1.6018390655517578, 0.011916427873075008, 0.49212732911109924, 0.7839818596839905, -0.5851715207099915, 0.2034214735031128, 0.7259970307350159, 0.4100712835788727, -0.2469671070575714, -0.03370049595832825, 0.769062876701355, 0.6596154570579529, -0.901222288608551, 0.5305651426315308, 0.09831386059522629, -0.18965904414653778, 0.37201252579689026, 0.11293100565671921, -0.3671949505805969, 0.5349588990211487, -0.4203183054924011, 0.027648869901895523, -0.013519522733986378, 0.4560614824295044, 0.4814281463623047, -0.6567397117614746, 0.2477753609418869, 0.3610669672489166, 0.19787715375423431, 0.43430086970329285, 1.5471011400222778, 0.8494970798492432, 0.005404512397944927, 0.7153051495552063, 0.7504808306694031, 0.2992311418056488, 0.37344956398010254, 0.40551212430000305, 0.16140347719192505, 0.17785035073757172, -0.6021754145622253, 0.156393364071846, -0.4746163487434387, -0.1110372543334961, -0.792373538017273, -0.12919528782367706, -0.6571864485740662, 1.3341169357299805, 0.9353647828102112, -0.37930354475975037, -1.7565068006515503, -0.7766021490097046, 0.3088723421096802, 0.3122826814651489, -0.3469966948032379, 0.4129047095775604, 0.6920123100280762, 0.528174638748169, -0.26657140254974365, -0.09059330821037292, 0.11227231472730637, 0.6712780594825745, -0.4523048400878906, -0.07644381374120712, -0.7570977807044983, -0.34595832228660583, -1.0246825218200684, -0.5143075585365295, -0.335470974445343, 0.15079057216644287, -0.5352653861045837, -0.15826737880706787, 0.7324545979499817, -1.0848982334136963, 0.7361044883728027, 0.2000764012336731, -0.6271683573722839, 0.06756410747766495, -0.5589320659637451, 0.14460811018943787, 0.1813451647758484, 0.09331300109624863, -1.1029993295669556, 0.5302518606185913, -0.7511875629425049, 0.2687798738479614, -0.2405693382024765, -0.2211354821920395, 0.4900921583175659, 0.09312191605567932, -0.4851914942264557, 0.019654201343655586, -0.6866524815559387, -0.25141435861587524, -0.8403350114822388, -0.506749153137207, 0.6808272004127502, -0.30692991614341736, -1.0158519744873047, 0.25087037682533264, -0.9404250383377075, 1.4485974311828613, -0.26022833585739136, -0.48304483294487, 0.7739898562431335, 0.7141112685203552, -0.8199921250343323, 0.6252561807632446, -0.15761908888816833, 0.2783789336681366, -0.07385741174221039, 0.8819718956947327, 0.9726434946060181, -0.0725518986582756, -0.24172750115394592, -1.222688913345337, 0.014513521455228329, 0.2692727744579315, 0.514991283416748, -0.9415127038955688, -1.1549975872039795, 0.6419426798820496, 0.8239248991012573, -0.884044885635376, -0.16152139008045197, -0.7299671173095703, -0.18259991705417633, 0.6715690493583679, -0.3887747824192047, 1.0640981197357178, -0.48478472232818604, -0.09788243472576141, -0.19553646445274353, -0.3056921660900116, 0.23132987320423126, -0.28189876675605774, 0.7076725363731384, -0.8440422415733337, 0.6597736477851868, 0.7382112145423889, -0.3926776349544525, 0.3696698844432831, 0.08426639437675476, -0.5383813381195068, -0.25122982263565063, 0.2670843303203583, -0.31470027565956116, 0.09208301454782486, 0.5170015692710876, -0.28605905175209045, -0.1840853989124298, 0.7373372316360474, -0.6320666074752808, -0.7819362282752991, -0.45065340399742126, -0.4065171480178833, 1.2708481550216675, 0.6472288966178894, -0.20021869242191315, -0.16812217235565186, -1.3394763469696045, -0.5986202359199524, 0.22882913053035736, -0.1459488719701767, 0.1891847401857376, -0.5316586494445801, 0.10396208614110947, 0.16156797111034393, -0.22974532842636108, 0.2545216977596283, 0.2254873365163803, -0.6574037075042725, 0.2403108775615692, 0.40367591381073, 0.6853052377700806, -0.1721297651529312, -0.14695121347904205, 0.5459390878677368, 0.9165433049201965, 0.3684295415878296, 0.8009573221206665, 0.5679984092712402, -0.21223659813404083, 0.05831766501069069, -0.524865984916687, -1.0588150024414062, 0.029891768470406532, -1.0313239097595215, -0.6358770132064819, -0.9456804394721985, 0.049328360706567764, 0.1439722180366516, 0.6464802622795105, 0.6872642040252686, 0.7534765601158142, 0.7589264512062073, -0.06353262066841125, 0.85945063829422, 0.9165835380554199, 0.4716973602771759, -0.19281212985515594, 0.008566278032958508, -0.823945164680481, 0.26440146565437317, 0.04164810851216316, 0.09317021816968918, 0.251740425825119, -0.3735913634300232, -0.436691015958786, -0.14620697498321533, 0.23635686933994293, 0.2168249487876892, 0.07475496828556061, 0.41513291001319885, 0.3301863372325897, 0.25731584429740906, -0.4950176775455475, -0.2330314964056015, 0.476161390542984, 0.6487138271331787, 0.5059930682182312, -0.8705175518989563, -0.3062993288040161, -0.6084627509117126, 0.27482491731643677, 0.10878349095582962, 0.10757998377084732, -0.4066352844238281, -0.05968260392546654, -0.4408979117870331, -0.11234450340270996, -0.33403822779655457, 0.03812669962644577, 0.6899468302726746, 0.06964293867349625, -0.7519916296005249, 0.047531891614198685, 0.3508913815021515, -0.7555882930755615, -0.2577188313007355, 0.25379037857055664, 0.2627330422401428, -0.744965136051178, 0.6627936959266663, 0.23867134749889374, -0.9954650402069092, 0.24378705024719238, 0.0419919416308403, 0.5159099698066711, -0.11962705850601196, -0.7225396633148193, -0.8806852102279663, -0.4423018991947174, -0.10549674183130264, 0.6533529162406921, 0.01663454994559288, 0.09070740640163422, 0.30604711174964905, -0.6418033838272095, -0.5136216878890991, -0.7399200797080994, 0.20160463452339172, 0.27850574254989624, 0.2913473844528198, 1.0824499130249023, -0.033731985837221146, -0.0551765076816082, -0.36375460028648376, -0.6444258689880371, -0.34672150015830994, 0.4257141351699829, -0.6158520579338074, -0.051790058612823486, 0.18059073388576508, -0.6245738863945007, -0.2888185381889343, -0.5250076651573181, 0.5449710488319397, -0.8853269815444946, 0.7212774753570557, 0.33265984058380127, -1.0026607513427734, 0.42717236280441284, -0.14858826994895935, -0.4198836088180542, -0.02865935117006302, -0.09535390138626099, -0.6789813041687012, 0.30386510491371155, -1.289813756942749, 0.2908530831336975, 0.07851826399564743, -0.344821572303772, -0.44376301765441895, 0.2113761156797409, -0.0396052785217762, -0.31777119636535645, 0.4444972574710846, -1.0821131467819214, 0.1879020482301712, -0.42388567328453064, 0.22268956899642944, -0.19984450936317444, -0.15774892270565033, -0.03826553374528885, 1.2753252983093262, -0.6732915639877319, -0.3693099021911621, -0.05496935918927193, -0.3897421658039093, 0.4688994288444519, 0.1289408802986145, 0.23804792761802673, -0.4006953835487366, -1.043163776397705, 0.58017498254776, 0.38460350036621094, -0.35396909713745117, -0.4113538861274719, 0.7023330926895142, -0.2354351431131363, -0.8512999415397644, -0.5327104926109314, -0.3177241384983063, -0.3299441635608673, -0.31592634320259094, 1.04454505443573, -0.9644997715950012, -1.0275896787643433, -0.4619938135147095, 0.2527417540550232, 0.8695964217185974, 0.5730941891670227, -0.027371879667043686, -0.3332499861717224, -0.5249549746513367, -0.5841788053512573, 0.1754264235496521, -0.4040767252445221, -0.09658443927764893, -0.3397240936756134, -0.35156843066215515, -0.6219635605812073, 0.718329906463623, -0.01806102879345417, -0.44772154092788696, 0.210020512342453, 0.7177616357803345, -0.15515826642513275, 0.5502241253852844, 0.3887321650981903, -0.32862237095832825, -0.6182657480239868, 0.5224825739860535, 0.26271572709083557, 0.5103314518928528, -0.46536165475845337, -0.21243701875209808, -0.8296387195587158, 0.3138958215713501, 0.483299195766449, 0.5636945366859436, 0.3556554913520813, -0.8477995991706848, 0.4525420665740967, -0.6870777606964111, -0.1165691614151001, 0.10185984522104263, -0.282869815826416, 1.3794403076171875, -0.09735774993896484, -0.6043090224266052, -0.22499120235443115, -0.6748725771903992, -1.5012357234954834, 0.4780278503894806, -0.25102928280830383, -0.6592609286308289, -1.4086740016937256, -0.742640495300293, 0.4282873570919037, -0.729417622089386, 1.2796090841293335, 0.38619741797447205, 0.4581160545349121, 0.8688732981681824, -0.0026303597260266542, 0.5654409527778625, 0.3188612163066864, -0.22264626622200012, 0.46532636880874634, -0.25459787249565125, -0.06817019730806351, -0.21437481045722961, -1.2805670499801636, -1.0296951532363892, -0.3424893915653229, 0.257599413394928, 0.3130083680152893, -0.5430849194526672, 0.45032963156700134, -0.17066852748394012, -0.39763984084129333, -0.06086667254567146, 0.48397231101989746, -0.22927963733673096, 0.13977406919002533, -0.05581587925553322, 0.1301097422838211, -0.8951653838157654, 0.4599754214286804, 0.23139183223247528, -0.5565474629402161, -0.18916694819927216, 1.0085586309432983, -0.21272149682044983, -0.6919654607772827, -0.9056879878044128, 0.03220232576131821, -0.6732290387153625, -0.4217815101146698, -0.06436465680599213, 0.929637610912323, 0.15898999571800232, -1.3808594942092896, 0.12624934315681458, -0.19432418048381805, -0.031850457191467285, 0.07777844369411469, 0.8862252235412598, 0.37198758125305176, 0.5872895121574402, 0.48543062806129456, -0.3721556067466736, -0.4761633574962616, 0.05713101476430893, 0.9558857679367065, -0.038052741438150406, -0.48076391220092773, 0.26561182737350464, -0.31294989585876465, -0.4275432527065277, -0.08425495028495789, 0.7836175560951233, -0.5894407033920288, 0.24702230095863342, -0.20727181434631348, -0.06986761838197708, 0.6501660346984863, 0.5603322386741638, 0.2582591474056244, 0.06668885052204132, 0.25516796112060547, -0.857724130153656, -0.5808115601539612, 0.0789802223443985, 0.0836905837059021, 0.3395649194717407, -0.3235670030117035, 0.4041941165924072, -0.049017295241355896, 0.43489959836006165, -0.7282143831253052, -0.7457616925239563, -0.6648204326629639, -0.893035352230072, -0.4611228406429291, -0.48851487040519714, -0.626250147819519, -0.17942316830158234, -1.0014835596084595, -0.04360822215676308, -0.4518175423145294, 0.22669614851474762, -0.06775452941656113, 0.4463956654071808, 0.7719112038612366, -0.4617350399494171, 0.4759623408317566, -0.13402597606182098, 0.03318867087364197, -0.5672852396965027, 0.12533165514469147, 0.24341893196105957, 0.21744589507579803, -0.4379696249961853, 0.2582520842552185, -0.4718620479106903, 0.9242021441459656, -0.8846757411956787, -0.092034712433815, 0.11618141084909439, 0.5833345055580139, -0.029740463942289352, 0.712094247341156, -0.748380720615387, 0.12067469209432602, 0.08922462910413742, -0.16510432958602905, 0.22108827531337738, 0.20350883901119232, -0.8155174851417542, 0.08739062398672104, 0.03600926697254181, 0.584015965461731, -0.14692719280719757, -0.3861236870288849, -0.05827168747782707, 0.10203349590301514, -1.044628620147705, 0.1343737244606018, -0.4135957360267639, 0.4634948968887329, -0.7278542518615723, 0.4636715352535248, -0.49228671193122864, 0.9306588768959045, -0.5559773445129395, 0.19795332849025726, -0.29804617166519165, -0.07095274329185486, 0.24354197084903717, 0.4286462962627411, -0.3886076509952545, 0.01565849408507347, 0.548997163772583, -0.979222297668457, 0.2372744083404541, 0.4432550072669983, -0.4397938847541809, 0.4794136583805084, -0.3019752502441406, -1.3676338195800781, -0.02052350901067257, -0.09121354669332504, -0.48744383454322815, 1.0879634618759155, -0.6010224223136902, 0.10087814927101135, 0.22853614389896393, -0.029373623430728912, -0.6285765171051025, 0.33553141355514526, -0.6490199565887451, -0.6024935841560364, -0.10114218294620514, -0.33988091349601746, 0.05508027970790863, 0.5483431220054626, -0.6046034097671509, -0.09281016141176224, -0.8027506470680237, 0.37379395961761475, 0.3453194499015808, -0.7972636222839355, 0.5022996664047241, 0.3700813949108124, -0.665340781211853, 0.580355703830719, -0.3643169105052948, 0.8270906209945679, -0.9592242240905762, -0.780927300453186, -0.40273383259773254, 0.3112104535102844, -0.9147375822067261, 0.04905533418059349, -0.09516813606023788, 0.03927645459771156, 0.05224766954779625, 0.8032786250114441, 0.05989539250731468, 0.1268097460269928, -0.03559378162026405, 1.2418299913406372, 0.10795381665229797, 0.016069013625383377, 0.503895103931427, 0.6909958124160767, 0.24467960000038147, 0.08112546056509018, -0.3329688310623169, 1.2475682497024536, 0.02773088403046131, 0.1696958839893341, 1.0035442113876343, 0.1181812733411789, 0.9228766560554504, -0.014819405972957611, -0.27243515849113464, 0.10128460824489594, 0.24738352000713348, 0.5317482352256775, 0.2029031664133072, -0.07353702932596207, 0.2928772270679474, 1.1508280038833618, -0.3956681787967682, 0.0974140390753746, -0.5534291863441467, -0.2665347456932068, 0.13590960204601288, 0.43153440952301025, -0.787936270236969, 0.3041546642780304, 0.4695753753185272, -0.19846569001674652, -0.19162617623806, -1.1132434606552124, -0.2170644849538803, 0.0608331672847271, -0.48482823371887207, 0.31545549631118774, -0.5279581546783447, -0.3128815293312073, 0.5159288048744202, 0.14041969180107117, 0.24280428886413574, -0.44760003685951233, -0.019318407401442528, 0.7262146472930908, 0.7080377340316772, -0.06084758788347244, -0.9479617476463318, 0.24330565333366394, -0.394809365272522, 0.8236007690429688, -0.356537789106369, 1.1199795007705688, 0.6919749975204468, 0.7008845806121826, 0.008686759509146214, -1.181302547454834, -0.4486720860004425, 0.719691276550293, -0.6417027115821838, 0.3110567331314087, 0.3682708740234375, -0.2501855790615082, -0.25055956840515137, -0.547684907913208, 0.66322261095047, -0.6462470293045044, 0.24348308145999908, 0.5924506187438965, 0.14741550385951996, -0.11046696454286575, 0.28561556339263916, 0.36272168159484863, 0.1444978415966034, 0.5566189885139465, -0.0010025514056906104, 0.15526683628559113, 0.7671335339546204, 0.9294939637184143, 0.43079301714897156, -0.0007073721499182284, -0.5928754806518555, -0.9107695817947388, 0.022775735706090927, -0.08124719560146332, -0.6426371335983276, 0.6571981310844421, -0.3633212149143219, 0.14995531737804413, 0.20713619887828827, -0.09385841339826584, 0.1867307871580124, -0.5197752714157104, 0.5368463397026062, 0.5509853363037109, -0.5213385820388794, 0.4993169605731964, -0.15446604788303375, 0.3276796340942383, 0.30619874596595764, 0.1195368766784668, 0.5346534252166748, -0.6472309827804565, 0.12111929804086685, -0.8028865456581116, -0.06240476295351982, -0.061980728060007095, 0.4057656228542328, 0.10351495444774628, 0.09037069976329803, -0.7063623070716858, -0.8588109016418457, 0.37265393137931824, -0.2387276589870453, 0.6958162188529968, 0.12158024311065674, 0.16356438398361206, 0.38886383175849915, -0.43626266717910767, 0.22749891877174377, 0.5845692753791809, 0.7888204455375671, 0.7314243912696838, 1.296060562133789, 0.5169532895088196, 0.30698418617248535, 0.4900851845741272, 0.6200539469718933, 0.37979811429977417, -0.2392704337835312, 0.6343499422073364, -0.415850430727005, 0.045355185866355896, 0.059884242713451385, -0.5548282265663147, 0.9534732699394226, 0.02323993667960167, -0.13643397390842438, -0.7037809491157532, -0.33390793204307556, -0.3697356879711151, -0.4340086281299591, -0.28728213906288147, -0.6747568249702454, 0.07743216305971146, 0.19373643398284912, -0.020103299990296364, 0.2077510803937912, -0.39038246870040894, 3.8736767768859863, 0.8792599439620972, -0.14803564548492432, 0.37611258029937744, 0.7699500322341919, 1.3354593515396118, 0.3953244090080261, 0.19770562648773193, -0.265640527009964, -0.46990200877189636, 0.3343619108200073, -0.3504790663719177, 0.5631166696548462, -0.08996035903692245, 0.20814278721809387, -0.022937245666980743, -0.5409289598464966, 0.44345229864120483, -0.12648367881774902, -1.0483319759368896, -0.3047354221343994, 0.22316525876522064, -0.3906431198120117, -0.6055511236190796, 0.9528557062149048, -0.12155788391828537, 0.11174140125513077, -0.05293123051524162, -0.6343019008636475, -0.03933621570467949, -0.5718078017234802, -0.2796325981616974, 0.14139574766159058, -0.236437126994133, -0.6241409182548523, 0.3057212233543396, 0.4340709149837494, -0.3499681055545807, -0.5039860606193542, 0.7698726058006287, -0.1340554803609848, -0.302146852016449, -0.2946573793888092, -0.18595752120018005, -0.6555235385894775, 0.9094841480255127, -0.7406289577484131, 0.7515471577644348, -0.13270100951194763, -0.7571303844451904, 0.6386758685112, 0.22787855565547943, 0.47303932905197144, 0.08193697780370712, -0.9287696480751038, -0.3830482065677643, -0.890692949295044, -0.1283268928527832, -0.27134087681770325, 0.009046949446201324, 0.8570693135261536, 0.8351806402206421, -0.6599563360214233, -0.40037164092063904, -0.5619555711746216, 0.48700031638145447, 0.3030247986316681, -0.3144884407520294, -0.3430566191673279, 0.004090832080692053, -0.7193169593811035, -0.1882634162902832, -0.18829303979873657, -0.2749779224395752, 1.143377423286438, -0.16174688935279846, -0.3149019181728363, 1.015556812286377, 0.4128175377845764, 0.5739288926124573, -0.5875043869018555, -0.4956946074962616, -0.012837724760174751, 0.011617926880717278, -0.16746731102466583, 0.7980517148971558, -0.038467973470687866, -0.9459412693977356, 0.25123360753059387, 0.17879745364189148, -0.16177502274513245, 1.3925820589065552, -0.0869373232126236, 0.28778305649757385, -0.10593415051698685 ]
Beyond the ``principle of local symmetry'': derivation of a general crack propagation law
We derive a general crack propagation law for slow brittle cracking, in two and three dimensions, using symmetry, gauge invariance, and gradient expansions. Our derivation provides explicit justification for the ``principle of local symmetry,'' which has been used extensively to describe two dimensional crack growth, but goes beyond that principle to describe three dimensional crack phenomena as well. We also find that there are new materials properties needed to describe the growth of general cracks in three dimensions, besides the fracture toughness and elastic constants previously used to describe cracking.
Jennifer Hodgdon and James P. Sethna
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204013
cond-mat/9204014
[ 0.3501307964324951, 0.2725784480571747, 0.23501980304718018, 0.010630783624947071, 0.8022695779800415, -0.2886379659175873, -0.07237933576107025, -0.38713735342025757, -1.035523772239685, 1.4656566381454468, 1.1140475273132324, 0.12108640372753143, 0.5729339122772217, -1.1525901556015015, 0.04510698840022087, -0.0033225486986339092, -0.30640047788619995, -0.8265131115913391, -0.8892279863357544, -0.3655722141265869, 0.8256911635398865, -0.6591187119483948, -1.4872305393218994, -0.7266960144042969, -0.35663366317749023, 0.5890303254127502, 0.40297931432724, 0.5260075926780701, 1.028364658355713, 0.3948312997817993, 0.8391770720481873, -1.042285442352295, 0.27635881304740906, -0.2449711114168167, -0.39290082454681396, -0.6451412439346313, -0.03176404535770416, -0.010103674605488777, 0.44156163930892944, -0.35763880610466003, 0.6710752844810486, 0.2619495987892151, 0.8679035902023315, -0.072960264980793, -0.8117996454238892, -0.37566739320755005, -0.02681739069521427, 0.07757174223661423, -0.05015818402171135, -1.4627221822738647, 0.44751179218292236, -0.4132361114025116, 0.4648471474647522, -0.014003321528434753, -0.3445339798927307, -0.2611895501613617, -0.10076060146093369, 0.1581212282180786, 0.036302600055933, -0.04930856451392174, 0.7303569912910461, -0.15980541706085205, 0.8252750039100647, -0.9398126602172852, 0.499534547328949, 0.6931951642036438, -0.35021719336509705, 0.2776058614253998, -0.2809988260269165, -0.6302929520606995, -1.0539262294769287, -0.8698445558547974, -0.31394311785697937, -0.11322575807571411, -0.1868923306465149, 1.0265934467315674, 0.5015739798545837, 0.09874945133924484, -1.7370212078094482, -0.6474432945251465, -0.7250832915306091, -0.595197856426239, -0.9509733319282532, 0.577195942401886, -0.3027207553386688, -0.5612303614616394, 0.3823501169681549, -0.21273626387119293, -0.3455609083175659, -0.2805492877960205, 0.24604499340057373, 0.40300461649894714, 0.7681624293327332, -0.23395611345767975, 0.6121237874031067, 0.6611185073852539, -0.19340519607067108, 0.6214052438735962, -0.06010914221405983, 0.3725060224533081, -0.5977193713188171, 0.6554911136627197, -0.3693082928657532, 0.3785031735897064, -0.3504968285560608, 0.33830147981643677, 0.040020789951086044, 0.17469845712184906, 0.07072023302316666, -0.574428379535675, -0.37208685278892517, -0.33403393626213074, -0.393646776676178, 1.252027988433838, -0.20661428570747375, 0.4044346213340759, -0.5364728569984436, 0.153213232755661, -0.560763418674469, 0.6452063322067261, 0.22500555217266083, -0.4530113637447357, 0.7499171495437622, 0.8113477230072021, 0.2702871263027191, -0.6194629669189453, 0.7309343814849854, 0.455658882856369, -1.007895827293396, -0.5507984757423401, 0.16927482187747955, 0.30322763323783875, -0.13868167996406555, 0.017882585525512695, -0.5539712309837341, 0.36606743931770325, -0.10373131185770035, 0.14947479963302612, 0.30522966384887695, -0.15855877101421356, 0.6769714951515198, -0.2418019324541092, 0.683938205242157, 1.098137617111206, -0.19497770071029663, 0.40567564964294434, 0.5699271559715271, -0.9399080276489258, -0.14356891810894012, 0.5396392941474915, -0.26153525710105896, -0.07566221803426743, -0.8428316712379456, 0.6651414036750793, -0.013535580597817898, -0.02806052565574646, -0.657099723815918, 0.4441513419151306, -0.8931058645248413, -0.31062811613082886, 0.09479376673698425, -0.034410540014505386, 0.11171285808086395, 0.5665256381034851, -0.19994992017745972, -0.4127632677555084, 0.09768733382225037, 0.24227650463581085, 0.09169139713048935, -0.6740241646766663, 0.13714143633842468, 0.0926910936832428, -0.40939754247665405, 0.7159641981124878, 0.07380490750074387, 0.6047470569610596, 0.4122856855392456, 0.16263636946678162, 0.3307894766330719, -0.018980298191308975, -0.15563663840293884, -0.2223067581653595, 1.0579807758331299, 0.2511105239391327, 0.025807522237300873, 0.4091532528400421, -0.5047421455383301, -0.4257712662220001, -0.6812032461166382, 0.7528074383735657, 0.16105368733406067, 0.3234376013278961, -0.6471996903419495, 0.7029989957809448, -0.10617539286613464, -0.3599620759487152, -0.6468802094459534, 0.038877494633197784, -0.218281552195549, -0.6032202839851379, -0.531187117099762, 0.5462818145751953, -0.8850783109664917, 0.32644233107566833, -1.1796245574951172, 0.6261053681373596, -0.5059691071510315, 0.15101982653141022, -0.1924571394920349, -0.07663913816213608, -0.2691953778266907, 0.33811184763908386, 0.7523810267448425, -0.05985597148537636, 0.38853633403778076, 0.3628292381763458, -0.521830141544342, 0.20036031305789948, 1.2451529502868652, -0.4001852869987488, 0.7816988229751587, 0.47973203659057617, -0.28770560026168823, 0.6010684370994568, -0.1720123440027237, -0.4920409619808197, 0.7458305358886719, 0.2894863188266754, 0.7709399461746216, 0.5798220038414001, -0.45083558559417725, 0.9066005349159241, 0.33022138476371765, 0.19804678857326508, 0.6844666600227356, 0.8478736281394958, 0.04662902280688286, 0.6608395576477051, 0.4165537655353546, 0.38385364413261414, 0.1241857260465622, -0.4520012140274048, 0.604211688041687, 0.6021263599395752, 0.1078246682882309, 0.06727644056081772, -0.12160095572471619, 0.38644200563430786, -0.7550197243690491, 0.6827797889709473, -1.1352757215499878, 0.9362180233001709, -0.4667050540447235, 0.060271039605140686, -0.665725588798523, 0.7216333746910095, 0.513399600982666, 0.27275729179382324, -0.8468020558357239, -0.795893669128418, 0.026174509897828102, 0.0008367361733689904, -0.3479378819465637, -0.13896974921226501, 0.08196528255939484, 1.2174913883209229, 0.27429962158203125, 0.3782246708869934, -0.05999604985117912, -0.3401852548122406, -0.9013937711715698, -0.839821994304657, -0.828399658203125, -0.4918903112411499, -0.4718867838382721, 0.001202496001496911, 1.2569012641906738, -0.7438622713088989, 0.7706327438354492, -0.5519747138023376, -0.3719702959060669, 0.5458579063415527, 0.46094992756843567, 0.8222566843032837, 0.9515564441680908, 0.048391614109277725, -0.8713203072547913, 0.05236830934882164, -0.42426642775535583, 0.6531454920768738, -0.16150224208831787, 0.5305601954460144, 0.8461124897003174, -0.4517119824886322, 0.45947086811065674, -0.8823323249816895, -0.7130827307701111, -0.7576029300689697, 0.028498144820332527, -0.5381973385810852, -0.43504875898361206, 0.977313756942749, -0.010379279032349586, -0.25362148880958557, -0.6777229309082031, 1.2025370597839355, 0.34827232360839844, -1.0983209609985352, 1.2161656618118286, 0.9446907639503479, -0.44916555285453796, 0.41350534558296204, -0.5138511657714844, -0.4467954933643341, -0.13281498849391937, 1.566630244255066, 0.8692939877510071, 0.269808292388916, -0.17693999409675598, -0.4824008643627167, -0.6868213415145874, 0.6718995571136475, -0.3325175344944, -0.6232877373695374, -0.5746704339981079, 1.1511297225952148, 0.1240868866443634, -0.8492887020111084, 0.8248727917671204, -1.100040316581726, -0.44306352734565735, -0.3016544282436371, -0.5805314779281616, 0.7402991056442261, -0.1962227076292038, 0.30203497409820557, -0.160885289311409, 0.5596192479133606, 0.37713953852653503, 0.9623814225196838, 0.03785915672779083, -0.4404681921005249, 0.5863568782806396, 0.5038350224494934, 0.50452721118927, -0.6238288879394531, 0.44415074586868286, -0.07581869512796402, -0.4456201195716858, 0.5054998993873596, -0.7109860777854919, 0.280722975730896, 0.11952295154333115, -0.15734535455703735, 0.30660468339920044, 0.23658961057662964, -0.7068400382995605, -0.03847348317503929, -0.6731761693954468, 0.6482422947883606, 0.510848343372345, 0.38141611218452454, -0.5488017797470093, 0.39236214756965637, -0.6165460348129272, -0.3014585077762604, 0.3845672607421875, 0.4199378490447998, 0.638460099697113, -0.0809544250369072, 0.9200299978256226, -0.07557452470064163, -0.34998616576194763, 0.6026756167411804, -0.41605275869369507, -0.47973790764808655, -0.09562356770038605, 0.8433080315589905, 1.1039211750030518, -0.5124107599258423, -1.0234534740447998, 0.12446662038564682, 1.1680494546890259, 0.4301227927207947, 0.5196167230606079, 0.6597896218299866, 0.01988261379301548, 0.05764137953519821, -0.5664092302322388, 0.06606077402830124, -0.19073721766471863, -0.04603870213031769, -0.5133330821990967, -0.5873970985412598, 0.06989624351263046, -0.7111990451812744, 0.6642037630081177, 0.09531933069229126, 0.7119735479354858, -0.4105716049671173, 1.0166064500808716, 0.8080445528030396, 0.41351285576820374, 1.222935676574707, 0.4674115777015686, -0.20372819900512695, -1.08553946018219, 0.2915363311767578, 1.2033913135528564, -0.3278639614582062, -0.34304359555244446, -0.7182214260101318, -0.14456723630428314, -0.296019971370697, 0.18678712844848633, -0.23416732251644135, -0.40987879037857056, 0.29478204250335693, -0.23396547138690948, 0.6016572713851929, -0.4911545217037201, -0.6311007142066956, -0.2734275758266449, 0.35268068313598633, 0.06420094519853592, -0.8962904810905457, 0.10784512758255005, -0.7007459998130798, 1.022023320198059, 0.9882660508155823, -0.9216611385345459, -1.0114210844039917, -0.468384712934494, -0.010790209285914898, -0.6706873774528503, 0.039881519973278046, 0.9491245746612549, -0.13357789814472198, -0.32951435446739197, -0.9538638591766357, -0.45628178119659424, 0.2548578083515167, 0.6130017638206482, -0.2887865900993347, 0.08097720891237259, 0.04666536673903465, -0.5728473663330078, 0.4244791865348816, 0.2029327005147934, -0.8914396166801453, -0.49083298444747925, -0.24371051788330078, -0.32228389382362366, -0.7954236268997192, -0.20348215103149414, -0.6985458731651306, -0.1554274559020996, -0.6237809062004089, 0.26443392038345337, 0.2329244613647461, 0.7409478425979614, 0.284233033657074, 0.4374749958515167, -0.2148214876651764, -1.0073977708816528, 0.6262575387954712, 0.19389212131500244, -0.04132276400923729, 0.40495067834854126, 0.9690417051315308, -0.09431186318397522, 0.30364635586738586, 0.42170843482017517, 0.3991277515888214, 1.0753161907196045, -0.35812893509864807, 0.02832067385315895, -0.17239226400852203, 0.25459739565849304, -0.8543732166290283, -1.370484471321106, 0.033850450068712234, -0.40662914514541626, 0.7222806811332703, 0.5757607817649841, -0.47618618607521057, -0.32603663206100464, -0.189867302775383, -0.6708085536956787, -0.24830277264118195, -0.643133819103241, -0.21136602759361267, 0.16838893294334412, -0.03777110576629639, -0.15501394867897034, 0.8264736533164978, -0.5310766696929932, 0.1016155257821083, 0.6177875399589539, 1.2350162267684937, -0.4272530972957611, 0.563390851020813, -0.1317647397518158, -0.15649248659610748, -0.43074560165405273, 0.6055828928947449, -0.27790334820747375, -0.9927433133125305, -0.3407149314880371, -0.11492200940847397, -0.5159780979156494, -1.2756288051605225, -0.37045392394065857, 0.008674096316099167, 0.6775279641151428, 0.5260271430015564, -0.4224132001399994, -0.16073279082775116, -1.4217925071716309, 1.1656734943389893, -0.20155344903469086, -0.9410961866378784, -0.10106512904167175, 0.6218501329421997, -0.23230023682117462, 0.7854788303375244, 0.203161358833313, -0.5924287438392639, 0.053238049149513245, 0.2970565855503082, 0.37893813848495483, -0.7975330948829651, 0.2882002890110016, -0.4750099778175354, -1.391635775566101, 0.08646193146705627, 0.4172130227088928, 0.3245733678340912, -0.4649030864238739, -0.4685242176055908, -0.5525432229042053, -0.2474900782108307, -0.09802252799272537, 0.03257757052779198, -0.7484939694404602, -0.2455325722694397, -0.17191368341445923, 0.19774825870990753, 0.4250029921531677, -0.26889511942863464, 0.1875760406255722, 0.24897462129592896, 0.09653395414352417, 0.5597062110900879, -0.1986647993326187, 0.06952062249183655, -0.3985847234725952, 0.4818934202194214, -0.2121504247188568, -0.4685409963130951, -0.8943771123886108, 0.4688734710216522, -1.1982513666152954, 0.9822354912757874, -0.4417340159416199, -0.12789693474769592, 0.20126201212406158, 0.11370141804218292, 0.32062655687332153, -0.5060327053070068, 0.3947892487049103, -0.13936465978622437, 0.26710066199302673, 0.6454674601554871, 0.020769057795405388, -0.3343559801578522, -0.9536616802215576, -0.42086055874824524, -1.4250150918960571, 0.7433297634124756, -0.1672983467578888, 0.12286768108606339, -1.1363495588302612, 0.11219428479671478, 0.41629189252853394, -0.24305571615695953, 0.24785469472408295, 0.4214172959327698, 0.27843210101127625, -0.14620015025138855, 0.1030225083231926, -0.5045397877693176, -0.4372887909412384, -0.23197631537914276, 0.41058728098869324, -0.6101824641227722, -0.7876694202423096, 0.5845596194267273, -0.4013427197933197, -1.4572265148162842, -0.19705219566822052, 0.23073524236679077, 0.33884745836257935, -0.2880459725856781, 0.6184777021408081, -0.4876761734485626, 0.008485478349030018, 0.05205591022968292, -0.3421725034713745, -0.36335816979408264, 0.178249791264534, 0.5139440894126892, 0.0519067645072937, 0.697862446308136, -0.6048930287361145, 0.4627365171909332, -0.9517975449562073, 0.25227493047714233, 0.36855337023735046, -0.16169746220111847, -0.017186321318149567, 0.17439338564872742, 0.17487233877182007, -1.324775218963623, -0.25235623121261597, 0.017009271308779716, 0.19565749168395996, -0.22113946080207825, -0.4684283137321472, 0.7465938925743103, -0.30718860030174255, -0.44323551654815674, 0.6034221649169922, 0.6946433186531067, -0.22629253566265106, 0.18060581386089325, 0.1967555433511734, 0.2769024074077606, -0.5065419673919678, 0.16718709468841553, 1.0731569528579712, -0.4983251392841339, -0.4201525151729584, -1.058104395866394, -0.4104345738887787, 0.06353215873241425, 0.15774421393871307, 0.07531177997589111, -0.32086777687072754, 0.27652090787887573, 0.9593446850776672, 0.8886752724647522, 0.9012583494186401, -0.2756332457065582, -0.06978403776884079, -0.1511121243238449, 0.11784186959266663, -0.6687790751457214, -0.9713535308837891, -0.8454527854919434, -0.009125107899308205, 0.6017345190048218, -0.5349063277244568, 0.5692393183708191, 0.34355229139328003, -0.7162259817123413, -0.5859847664833069, -1.1657160520553589, 0.43669021129608154, -1.6239681243896484, -0.4096952974796295, -0.7617334723472595, -0.7185879945755005, 0.12149789929389954, 0.3250146210193634, 0.42890655994415283, -0.42505550384521484, -1.1808679103851318, 0.1952306628227234, -0.5187384486198425, -0.13851894438266754, -0.41075581312179565, -0.12328123301267624, -1.024390459060669, -0.34003743529319763, 0.22522613406181335, 0.12367435544729233, -0.8038288950920105, -0.007398442830890417, 0.0664861649274826, 0.4505116045475006, 0.06167182698845863, 0.41407719254493713, -0.7177560329437256, -0.5085508823394775, 0.09355144202709198, -0.5091737508773804, -0.5647661089897156, -0.11949937790632248, -0.26786550879478455, 0.13694682717323303, 0.18518373370170593, 0.13405035436153412, 0.026226172223687172, -0.15672367811203003, -0.7761724591255188, -0.2542804777622223, -0.5051104426383972, -0.04320412129163742, -0.5513299703598022, -0.9788938760757446, 0.19189120829105377, 0.11903338134288788, -0.95997554063797, 0.5156340599060059, 0.1619122475385666, -0.23179753124713898, -0.23944734036922455, -0.16488023102283478, 0.04338861629366875, 0.7805371284484863, -0.5631954073905945, 0.9740014672279358, -0.10759462416172028, 0.2609045207500458, -0.8691338896751404, 0.2900240421295166, -0.31854248046875, 0.9380233883857727, -0.07675634324550629, -0.45772576332092285, -0.8895671367645264, 0.23659072816371918, -0.5528499484062195, -0.09639101475477219, -0.6127576231956482, -0.3778744041919708, -0.6569472551345825, -0.1440315544605255, -0.26293477416038513, 0.7922855019569397, 0.4093092083930969, -1.016130805015564, -0.5413703918457031, 0.04756368696689606, -0.4296162724494934, 0.017660818994045258, -1.0499290227890015, -0.46236827969551086, -0.4606143832206726, -0.20604464411735535, -0.004694452043622732, -0.30564722418785095, 0.028487028554081917, 0.24269011616706848, 0.46181488037109375, 0.6252902150154114, -0.6969315409660339, 0.6376310586929321, -0.1586889773607254, 0.4676611125469208, -1.2426539659500122, -0.7181084752082825, -0.6607387065887451, -0.2243361473083496, -0.6173484325408936, -1.1561007499694824, -0.05009585618972778, 0.6629661321640015, -0.5124328136444092, -0.45457106828689575, -0.6235511898994446, 0.3867129683494568, 0.7490717768669128, 0.30427587032318115, -0.6845667362213135, 0.2603359818458557, -0.04441826418042183, 0.5701636672019958, -0.08173999935388565, -0.2709614932537079, 0.018415652215480804, 0.9520353078842163, 0.41079437732696533, 0.23578229546546936, -0.07710439711809158, 0.4849695861339569, -0.13577930629253387, -0.7606015205383301, 1.2483782768249512, 0.4950258433818817, 0.821465790271759, 0.057871896773576736, 0.11078924685716629, 0.5519541501998901, 0.3183387219905853, 0.3328624665737152, 0.43368202447891235, 0.466573566198349, 0.07173322141170502, 0.2737686336040497, 0.6703416109085083, -0.29108738899230957, 0.288465291261673, 1.0310620069503784, 0.42170250415802, 0.7663785815238953, -0.2984846830368042, 0.11645574867725372, 0.5226094126701355, 0.6053995490074158, 0.3672965168952942, 0.017005402594804764, -0.19561271369457245, -0.37893012166023254, -0.03997248783707619, 0.0835515707731247, 0.40690022706985474, -0.31250929832458496, -0.4814665913581848, 0.009842067025601864, -0.1678660809993744, 0.6937458515167236, -0.003775068325921893, 0.12369866669178009, 1.052369475364685, 0.7755051851272583, 0.6503368616104126, 0.6012348532676697, 0.49990466237068176, 0.3367649018764496, 0.08233318477869034, 0.755423367023468, 0.6989116668701172, 0.7239342331886292, -0.19881874322891235, -0.9713298082351685, -0.02377815917134285, 0.7124905586242676, -2.1547772884368896, -0.7047725915908813, -0.5260071158409119, -0.3385939598083496, -0.17010755836963654, -0.8195480108261108, 0.6212683916091919, -0.36110997200012207, 0.4617142081260681, 0.9405920505523682, 0.3096371591091156, -0.2492065727710724, 0.5596598386764526, -0.5071200132369995, 0.12599030137062073, 1.208809733390808, -0.15047481656074524, -0.37114423513412476, 0.656805157661438, 1.0018244981765747, -0.2617363929748535, 1.1754814386367798, -0.10255959630012512, -0.3039446771144867, 0.32308733463287354, -0.05317813530564308, -0.0038777906447649, 0.8435104489326477, -0.648632287979126, -0.9968535900115967, 0.11589975655078888, 0.9205754995346069, -0.9949055314064026, 0.24297386407852173, 0.3468712270259857, 0.7939992547035217, -0.47156068682670593, 0.3059838116168976, 1.0916944742202759, -0.10679133981466293, -0.12037447839975357, -0.4003501236438751, -0.14398235082626343, -0.015817176550626755, 0.4240260124206543, -1.2750989198684692, 0.1027836874127388, 0.3793795108795166, 0.27293726801872253, -0.49971258640289307, -0.9573039412498474, -0.41138866543769836, -1.1751853227615356, -0.20053355395793915, -0.3873192369937897, 0.4031127095222473, -0.07458125799894333, 0.4844469726085663, 0.002462919568642974, -0.6891466379165649, 0.2521476745605469, 0.3937501609325409, 1.1326981782913208, -0.43732064962387085, 0.6126905083656311, 0.5978891253471375, 0.7218171954154968, -0.33922305703163147, 0.9192320108413696, 0.46302467584609985, -0.883614718914032, 0.33223387598991394, -0.40568476915359497, 0.44377246499061584, -0.16014927625656128, -0.3881986439228058, -0.044440001249313354, 0.07022719085216522, 0.3242144286632538, -1.1752468347549438, -0.27630701661109924, -0.6088559627532959, -0.9625011086463928, -0.06011679396033287, -0.6865704655647278, 0.03754549100995064, -0.14625412225723267, -0.05396039038896561, -0.6637038588523865, 0.3712040185928345, 3.6111910343170166, 1.075417160987854, 0.735357403755188, 0.4033184349536896, 1.1934329271316528, 1.1552261114120483, -0.10889902710914612, -0.24261070787906647, 0.3987038731575012, -0.47281119227409363, 0.19392985105514526, 0.555009126663208, 0.523506760597229, 0.0423838309943676, -0.48310932517051697, 0.9243172407150269, -0.10846508294343948, 0.936138927936554, 0.5672048926353455, -0.9711214303970337, -0.25526949763298035, 0.11369535326957703, 0.33952558040618896, -0.6192433834075928, 0.23654446005821228, 0.31173834204673767, 0.16022293269634247, -1.181644082069397, -0.501798689365387, 0.4540177583694458, -0.6220266222953796, -0.859542965888977, 0.2952381670475006, -0.06391613930463791, -0.5177971720695496, 0.5333860516548157, 0.09778260439634323, -0.2742222845554352, 0.25417613983154297, 0.41208314895629883, 0.005232665222138166, 0.17838817834854126, -0.017510244622826576, -0.07312830537557602, -0.9324295520782471, 1.470856785774231, -0.31053975224494934, 0.9261007905006409, 0.6368035674095154, -0.7314549684524536, 0.18638382852077484, 0.0706075131893158, 0.59724360704422, -0.0717054232954979, -1.0040146112442017, 0.17407441139221191, -0.20755966007709503, -0.5527908205986023, 0.5831459164619446, 0.06452519446611404, 1.148971676826477, 0.034366194158792496, -0.3153142035007477, 0.3640223443508148, -0.07591674476861954, 0.1228271871805191, 1.0303701162338257, -0.08618452399969101, -0.5076417326927185, 0.26772555708885193, -0.1297646164894104, -0.18280020356178284, -0.4638402462005615, 0.5796098113059998, 0.14631420373916626, -0.09329550713300705, -0.5914876461029053, 0.7208476662635803, -0.03910712152719498, -0.03571898117661476, -0.14135679602622986, -0.5213955044746399, -0.4847440719604492, -0.09045419842004776, -0.08165986835956573, 1.3731554746627808, 0.19800680875778198, 0.03927014023065567, -0.6311386227607727, 0.8600426912307739, 0.2908695638179779, 1.391176462173462, -0.14150960743427277, -0.2680283188819885, -0.7127770781517029 ]
Blockspin Cluster Algorithms for Quantum Spin Systems
Cluster algorithms are developed for simulating quantum spin systems like the one- and two-dimensional Heisenberg ferro- and anti-ferromagnets. The corresponding two- and three-dimensional classical spin models with four-spin couplings are maped to blockspin models with two-blockspin interactions. Clusters of blockspins are updated collectively. The efficiency of the method is investigated in detail for one-dimensional spin chains. Then in most cases the new algorithms solve the problems of slowing down from which standard algorithms are suffering.
U.-J. Wiese and H.-P. Ying
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204014
cond-mat/9204015
[ -0.32198452949523926, 0.16108189523220062, 0.5807316899299622, 0.23811951279640198, -0.3636544346809387, -0.3477005064487457, -0.2858935296535492, -0.1514323651790619, -0.6192071437835693, 1.6075315475463867, 0.6438490748405457, -0.37824803590774536, 0.6239509582519531, -0.6451512575149536, 0.24103929102420807, 0.36764952540397644, -0.23974423110485077, -0.4110422134399414, -0.7609103322029114, 0.012268473394215107, 0.2135584056377411, -0.2379080355167389, -0.6197141408920288, -0.7727988958358765, -0.7567182183265686, 0.4577828347682953, 0.07231570035219193, 0.3794850707054138, 1.2571797370910645, 1.2406216859817505, 0.3222125172615051, -0.2602077126502991, -0.3667469322681427, -0.8142268657684326, -0.5809707045555115, 0.1392040103673935, 0.22690188884735107, 0.10896331816911697, 0.6660877466201782, -0.3484944999217987, 1.2967571020126343, -0.34704911708831787, 0.8965742588043213, 0.2010846734046936, -0.5651271939277649, -0.28096234798431396, 0.4820871949195862, -0.7418368458747864, -0.28486117720603943, -1.0906977653503418, 0.19917595386505127, 0.1835332214832306, 0.28340429067611694, -0.45045536756515503, 0.09009294956922531, 0.39313194155693054, 0.3035002052783966, -0.3370763957500458, -0.11060155183076859, 0.19882354140281677, 1.0093201398849487, 0.29516205191612244, 0.5875004529953003, -0.6449316740036011, 0.45096004009246826, 1.1203407049179077, -0.25570374727249146, 0.2982431650161743, 0.0345228835940361, -0.6614968180656433, 0.010146360844373703, -0.5244390368461609, -0.0329660102725029, 0.32335034012794495, -0.8611909747123718, 0.26992329955101013, 0.3227381110191345, -0.3379122316837311, -0.44907432794570923, -0.4528456926345825, 0.06576064974069595, -0.4524224102497101, -0.3481506109237671, 0.6740701198577881, 0.14938274025917053, -0.5071890354156494, 0.13397081196308136, 0.31764209270477295, -0.2779389023780823, 0.4174419343471527, 0.09471272677183151, 0.8528034687042236, 0.2403351068496704, -0.20432528853416443, -0.14967751502990723, 0.8699532747268677, -0.03873829171061516, 0.30409109592437744, 0.7019278407096863, 0.06606901437044144, -0.40526649355888367, 0.5783056616783142, -0.7883141040802002, 0.3301266133785248, -0.7779487371444702, 0.7089034914970398, 0.32149457931518555, 0.36000990867614746, -0.6237457394599915, -0.4148014187812805, 0.17384983599185944, 0.20355749130249023, 0.17775140702724457, 0.6363875269889832, 0.14311417937278748, 0.582263708114624, 0.39981067180633545, -0.019050003960728645, -1.0876801013946533, -0.15203315019607544, -0.2647090554237366, -0.022662032395601273, 0.27513015270233154, 0.084551140666008, -0.05244079604744911, -0.6096974611282349, 0.44890275597572327, 0.8433423638343811, -0.2987231910228729, -0.35469841957092285, -0.22447672486305237, 0.09378533065319061, 0.20497830212116241, 0.941084086894989, 0.5187702775001526, 0.41513803601264954, -0.07596161216497421, 0.7869004607200623, 0.12687061727046967, -0.4574753940105438, 0.3955778479576111, -0.5901315808296204, 0.5357804298400879, 0.659821093082428, -0.17761211097240448, -0.06453744322061539, 0.5275774002075195, -0.6571642160415649, -0.35094043612480164, 0.37553685903549194, -0.5446748733520508, -0.216398224234581, 0.04133684188127518, 0.12846145033836365, -0.4000897705554962, 0.7200254201889038, -0.7395636439323425, 0.9244570732116699, -0.9159073829650879, -0.8942170739173889, 0.394619882106781, -0.0383981429040432, -0.33565187454223633, 0.052822891622781754, -0.19762928783893585, -0.03201150894165039, -0.6871953010559082, -0.6387151479721069, -0.043544139713048935, -0.4191773235797882, -0.2809712588787079, -0.21325543522834778, -0.37116438150405884, 0.5044348835945129, 0.4207536280155182, 0.23857669532299042, 0.6442636847496033, 0.1389387995004654, 0.5080217123031616, 0.13691845536231995, -0.9727869629859924, -0.2773967683315277, 0.7954927086830139, 0.38212329149246216, 0.20648352801799774, -0.06658495962619781, -0.8879401087760925, -0.053352512419223785, 0.4902019798755646, 0.18535016477108002, -0.3796426057815552, 0.5256953835487366, -0.4889988601207733, 0.4020844101905823, -0.07004233449697495, -0.3290211260318756, -0.9735884666442871, 0.8851818442344666, -0.059591758996248245, -0.42792990803718567, -0.6916038990020752, 0.1644766926765442, -0.8175508975982666, 0.40780913829803467, -0.7948505878448486, 0.4048178791999817, 0.14808981120586395, 0.6339793801307678, -0.46922141313552856, 0.33202698826789856, 0.29154402017593384, 0.09627693146467209, 0.32083719968795776, 0.029981771484017372, 0.32401251792907715, -0.3779289722442627, -0.34263941645622253, -0.21443288028240204, 0.9364956021308899, -0.4779946208000183, 0.5273428559303284, -0.32199200987815857, -0.0981554239988327, 0.8707406520843506, 0.07465039193630219, 0.0778079628944397, 0.276015043258667, 0.49794283509254456, 0.11930236220359802, -0.3652763068675995, -0.15054500102996826, 1.1967183351516724, -0.09754644334316254, 0.4231524169445038, 1.3236002922058105, 0.20293495059013367, 0.19562453031539917, 0.38922810554504395, -0.13495339453220367, 0.1099199578166008, 0.11164354532957077, 0.46169769763946533, 0.30698683857917786, 0.3351548910140991, -0.003471753792837262, 0.49511000514030457, -0.7323580384254456, -0.1669739931821823, -0.2681020200252533, 0.47976046800613403, -0.5016211271286011, 0.9732373952865601, 0.5131652355194092, -0.18392618000507355, -0.7455461621284485, -0.08964606374502182, 0.15581613779067993, 0.48640555143356323, -0.319896399974823, -0.54758220911026, 0.18718808889389038, 0.38489896059036255, -0.20382140576839447, -0.6324294805526733, -0.08142043650150299, 0.8081924319267273, -0.20997971296310425, 0.6073145866394043, -0.6809252500534058, 0.18311159312725067, -0.8079982995986938, -0.5332971811294556, -0.6284588575363159, 0.0389859639108181, -0.26330316066741943, 0.19163617491722107, 1.091076135635376, -0.2876476049423218, 0.680863618850708, -0.031584057956933975, -0.1877012401819229, 0.49033069610595703, 0.2539959251880646, 1.349872350692749, -0.08654226362705231, -0.17405205965042114, -0.3348003327846527, 0.6101709008216858, -1.2051010131835938, 0.19432196021080017, -0.25104963779449463, 0.6582067608833313, -0.012176137417554855, -0.3395778238773346, -0.06935466080904007, -0.2704690098762512, -0.26371678709983826, -0.1750434786081314, -0.18453535437583923, -0.4691160321235657, -0.5678389668464661, 0.13397032022476196, -0.49463844299316406, -0.2172388732433319, -0.6412093043327332, 0.6591719388961792, 0.06828784942626953, -0.27838578820228577, 1.0473321676254272, 0.5182639360427856, -0.6096224784851074, 0.3534802496433258, -0.6183063387870789, 0.7117278575897217, 0.14715054631233215, 0.7171721458435059, 1.1135990619659424, -0.04858247935771942, 0.44166257977485657, -0.7199344635009766, -0.2662952244281769, 0.13095414638519287, 0.380095899105072, -1.1654317378997803, -0.11786340177059174, 0.37555161118507385, 0.5027338862419128, -0.6517892479896545, 0.05989651754498482, -0.4857103228569031, -0.95895916223526, 0.14998206496238708, -0.21337103843688965, 0.23311938345432281, -0.41706380248069763, 0.042048461735248566, -0.2638658583164215, -0.4712024927139282, -0.1028866171836853, 0.427995502948761, 0.6051550507545471, -0.2812247574329376, 0.7998822927474976, 0.3754470646381378, 0.08217010647058487, 0.4138176143169403, 0.643094539642334, -0.6319025158882141, 0.3961132764816284, 0.29575398564338684, -0.2691378593444824, 0.01876247674226761, 0.43775150179862976, 0.028374135494232178, 0.691366970539093, 0.4047410488128662, -1.0653671026229858, -0.37017494440078735, -0.4662106931209564, -0.6603430509567261, 0.6407338380813599, 0.13574719429016113, -0.6730339527130127, 0.12421668320894241, -0.797134280204773, -0.3809044659137726, 0.6132126450538635, -0.3103315830230713, 0.8083301186561584, -0.42741358280181885, 0.5611770749092102, -0.3615098297595978, -0.2918309271335602, 0.17573866248130798, -0.026827406138181686, -0.1600993275642395, 0.029976259917020798, 0.4142751395702362, 0.7808921337127686, -0.7920476198196411, -0.2819746434688568, -0.48456624150276184, 0.8422576785087585, 0.7308189272880554, 0.9887853860855103, 0.7469437122344971, -0.1194392517209053, 0.22013318538665771, -0.6217136979103088, -0.6210735440254211, 0.16550689935684204, -0.17178596556186676, -0.616813600063324, -0.5825824737548828, -0.3026580214500427, -0.5372056365013123, 0.3488353490829468, 0.9742798805236816, -0.07127329707145691, 0.08066810667514801, 0.47429776191711426, 0.3749028146266937, 0.2784603238105774, 0.5995703339576721, 0.17721574008464813, 0.11399008333683014, -1.0027179718017578, 0.9658727645874023, 0.07249486446380615, 0.14520300924777985, -0.023909587413072586, -0.1467599868774414, -0.6024508476257324, -0.6053805351257324, 0.5381932854652405, 0.49410274624824524, -0.08299432694911957, 0.307661771774292, 0.16760851442813873, 0.1933913677930832, -0.8375515937805176, 0.20262329280376434, -0.0399334654211998, 0.39602604508399963, -0.32300513982772827, -0.6418071985244751, 0.14137686789035797, 0.21415694057941437, 0.48322659730911255, 1.184536099433899, 0.04582037031650543, -0.5640813708305359, -0.648286759853363, 0.22348403930664062, -0.3406916558742523, -0.32954469323158264, 0.8278704881668091, -0.4647270441055298, 0.19535310566425323, 0.30561622977256775, -0.42619168758392334, 0.19279316067695618, -0.7623821496963501, -0.016202840954065323, 0.5008556842803955, 0.3401810824871063, -0.2118881195783615, 0.8617017865180969, 0.5846442580223083, -0.09486016631126404, -0.27469202876091003, -0.14133895933628082, 0.09343419224023819, -0.12078776210546494, -0.48117637634277344, -0.10250875353813171, -0.435674250125885, -0.47102391719818115, 0.4594303071498871, -0.10067171603441238, 0.7245664000511169, -0.09198018163442612, 0.09519387036561966, -0.5494871735572815, -0.577632486820221, 0.14139050245285034, -0.28212878108024597, 0.1445748209953308, 0.5608440637588501, 0.4654757082462311, 0.34520429372787476, 0.4687322974205017, 0.26958343386650085, -0.20560403168201447, 0.35042330622673035, 0.41544783115386963, 0.45705288648605347, -0.28715360164642334, -0.5081909894943237, -0.8214523792266846, -0.375629723072052, 0.3002294898033142, -0.3035198450088501, 1.183997631072998, 0.2211330533027649, -0.8086695075035095, -0.7563663125038147, 0.5110018849372864, -1.031889796257019, 0.8149932622909546, -0.9163280725479126, -0.4714401960372925, 0.38775724172592163, -1.0338901281356812, -0.6494064927101135, -0.25961101055145264, -0.03349236398935318, -0.45636945962905884, 0.30157214403152466, 0.4937218427658081, -1.028232455253601, 0.2234944850206375, -1.032855749130249, 0.5124334096908569, -0.37941572070121765, 0.2542126774787903, -0.299264132976532, -0.48844537138938904, -0.14160358905792236, 0.49520382285118103, -0.7421676516532898, -0.2830679714679718, -0.12587998807430267, -0.4723522663116455, 0.4909953474998474, -0.06767667829990387, 0.7741601467132568, 0.2832016050815582, -0.6049484014511108, 0.33297592401504517, 0.04470076411962509, -0.8275959491729736, 0.13283886015415192, 1.2647565603256226, -0.38900646567344666, -0.24721115827560425, -0.42703479528427124, -0.8423649072647095, 0.023273814469575882, -0.4082767963409424, -0.02937151864171028, -0.8385878801345825, -0.27185142040252686, -0.6693316698074341, -0.16883990168571472, -0.04030510038137436, 0.583419144153595, 0.6010128855705261, -0.34539130330085754, 0.07555367797613144, -0.4918071925640106, -0.19811688363552094, -0.4905169904232025, -0.11898712068796158, -0.35439735651016235, -0.05994866415858269, -0.9573892951011658, 0.6117268800735474, -0.13745525479316711, -0.194945827126503, 0.25445953011512756, 0.4924428462982178, -0.15306022763252258, 0.5235218405723572, -0.5857149362564087, 0.03533539921045303, -0.15364281833171844, 0.3448713719844818, -0.14838145673274994, 0.45742249488830566, -0.6562562584877014, 0.19427964091300964, -0.851092517375946, 0.4664674401283264, 0.30533328652381897, 0.11498568207025528, 0.22345252335071564, -0.48073920607566833, 0.4832778573036194, -0.65988689661026, -0.06316044926643372, 0.5187698006629944, 0.17196966707706451, 1.133922815322876, 0.33059051632881165, -0.9045552611351013, -0.31880301237106323, -1.232984185218811, -0.7444539070129395, 0.5253779292106628, -0.07211112976074219, -0.11191853135824203, -0.5771118998527527, -1.057793378829956, 0.17794640362262726, -0.3013748228549957, 0.39420071244239807, 0.19958019256591797, -0.6222689151763916, -0.006386284716427326, -0.3250204622745514, 0.254782497882843, -0.06113900616765022, -0.6111463308334351, 0.7074849009513855, 0.3775427043437958, -0.9088911414146423, -0.3438844382762909, -0.28407251834869385, -0.8725686073303223, -0.533863365650177, 0.9218301177024841, 0.4495173692703247, 0.06436359882354736, 0.8045873641967773, -0.3922211825847626, -0.2186615914106369, -0.10705447196960449, 0.08467863500118256, -0.013300905004143715, 0.7124126553535461, 0.25550711154937744, -0.2961929142475128, -0.5677156448364258, -0.14436893165111542, 0.0380750373005867, -0.807295024394989, -0.35338956117630005, 0.6384550333023071, -0.3209100663661957, -0.2541241943836212, -0.12753616273403168, 0.3762448728084564, -0.41002190113067627, -0.44625186920166016, -0.7874654531478882, 0.05039810389280319, -0.10073482990264893, -0.9755677580833435, 0.00515762809664011, -0.13431918621063232, -0.6414245367050171, 0.09527776390314102, 0.8824799656867981, -0.2904244661331177, 0.16951920092105865, -0.1398107260465622, -0.9256354570388794, -1.14725661277771, -0.0803920179605484, 1.2536273002624512, -0.37538257241249084, -0.563188374042511, -0.1477910578250885, -0.5521638989448547, 0.24242645502090454, -0.07256385684013367, 0.7320126295089722, -0.3439793288707733, -0.03417978063225746, 0.12668702006340027, 0.5388192534446716, 0.043382469564676285, 0.31847211718559265, 0.02312895841896534, 0.12206362932920456, 0.32377979159355164, -0.7433434724807739, -0.46534350514411926, 0.08140074461698532, 0.40213873982429504, 0.6331998109817505, -0.49701714515686035, 0.3252057731151581, -0.20290936529636383, -0.10610222071409225, -0.7998772263526917, -0.8883193731307983, 0.08520331978797913, -0.9510154724121094, -0.5968090891838074, -1.1908061504364014, -1.0694037675857544, -0.5410156846046448, -0.17976388335227966, 0.022641833871603012, 0.22881093621253967, -0.8357269167900085, -0.04723746329545975, 0.6216402649879456, 0.06011665612459183, -0.038603153079748154, -0.3410758078098297, -0.9402532577514648, 0.022883491590619087, -0.6979554891586304, -0.05223245918750763, 0.4502905011177063, 0.30901965498924255, -0.8372254371643066, 0.13396145403385162, -0.5744801759719849, 0.8745474815368652, -0.5739991664886475, -0.6273433566093445, 0.12599554657936096, -0.07550215721130371, -0.20126351714134216, -0.14550864696502686, -0.5834295749664307, -0.18995116651058197, 0.10496765375137329, -0.3837839961051941, 0.4478026032447815, 0.34310778975486755, -0.6559420824050903, 0.428191214799881, -0.5718269944190979, 0.4933350682258606, -0.012261439114809036, -0.7548619508743286, 0.2345794439315796, -0.09991785883903503, -1.0912054777145386, 0.4053577780723572, -0.9309329390525818, 0.6088520288467407, -0.29578113555908203, 0.3246830105781555, 0.30985257029533386, 0.6086465716362, -0.2778494656085968, 0.5619456171989441, 0.08768245577812195, -0.3287723660469055, 0.11115732043981552, -0.20759117603302002, -0.22975373268127441, 0.4854184091091156, 0.025357341393828392, -0.7416969537734985, -0.2605697810649872, 0.7717784643173218, -0.2855711877346039, 0.035078197717666626, -0.6195865273475647, -0.059908293187618256, -0.7250831127166748, -0.13281334936618805, -0.7224019169807434, 0.5773333311080933, -0.17113129794597626, -0.10800410062074661, -0.4597994387149811, -0.5018049478530884, -0.3564390540122986, 0.407731294631958, -0.2877979576587677, -0.21910694241523743, -0.5346936583518982, 0.0034504204522818327, -0.5240036249160767, 0.07124023139476776, -0.18566937744617462, -0.20958489179611206, -0.5018372535705566, 0.24535199999809265, 0.0013077688636258245, 0.17359083890914917, 0.12905839085578918, 0.3027428388595581, -0.6162001490592957, -0.012618164531886578, -0.2069985270500183, 0.5332655310630798, -0.2684754729270935, -0.19218574464321136, -0.07804982364177704, 0.05135902762413025, -0.14119233191013336, -0.134958416223526, -1.0010672807693481, 0.04328766465187073, 0.35874420404434204, 0.832675576210022, -0.44861966371536255, 0.09814244508743286, 0.05795236676931381, 1.104905366897583, 0.25662973523139954, -0.6951332092285156, 0.22609974443912506, 0.10746297985315323, 0.43220528960227966, 0.06008552014827728, -0.6495485901832581, 1.0270030498504639, 0.4357122778892517, -0.6648727655410767, 1.34320867061615, -0.16138021647930145, 1.021144986152649, 0.08964363485574722, 0.5429491996765137, -0.039885323494672775, 0.1596166044473648, 0.7139180302619934, 0.5128344893455505, 0.44096049666404724, 0.12071046233177185, 0.02591669000685215, -0.4434643089771271, 0.17853058874607086, 0.3069955110549927, 0.34483107924461365, -0.6692047715187073, 0.4880160093307495, -0.47375380992889404, 0.5591888427734375, -0.29080742597579956, 0.13653689622879028, -0.4599464237689972, -0.08823450654745102, -0.07797855883836746, 0.08955363929271698, -0.09317880868911743, 0.18334174156188965, -0.5524300932884216, -0.0030709020793437958, -0.19951224327087402, 0.07952713966369629, 0.05288694426417351, 0.08562877774238586, 0.188906729221344, 0.2878955900669098, 0.6764894127845764, 0.5334559679031372, 0.027594981715083122, 0.4656990170478821, 0.5104252099990845, -0.11579579859972, 0.4110737144947052, 0.8470953702926636, 0.9697217345237732, 0.39526277780532837, -0.051160093396902084, -0.7408421635627747, 0.12451352179050446, 0.9222986698150635, -1.0385326147079468, 0.15450303256511688, 0.209377720952034, -0.13568687438964844, 0.2880430817604065, -1.0558415651321411, 0.25852394104003906, -0.37933728098869324, -0.22290590405464172, 0.8005457520484924, 0.5330896377563477, 0.10483230650424957, 0.06499876827001572, -0.06070621311664581, 0.5609388947486877, 0.794960081577301, 0.04787766560912132, -0.044292304664850235, 1.0801655054092407, 0.9051433801651001, 0.24923613667488098, 0.08034703880548477, 0.10709766298532486, 0.09689731895923615, -0.23045814037322998, -0.11609409749507904, -0.531630277633667, 1.0357474088668823, -0.28878775238990784, -0.376362681388855, 0.26460206508636475, 0.12293294072151184, 0.1533186137676239, -0.06091892719268799, -0.20766419172286987, 0.8676648139953613, -0.15688230097293854, -0.22482876479625702, 0.7621459364891052, 0.32269087433815, 0.6438549757003784, 0.599726676940918, 0.28047993779182434, 0.24362923204898834, -0.007815535180270672, -0.46131595969200134, 0.5929719805717468, 0.016888553276658058, 0.21066267788410187, -0.05525795370340347, -0.6200109124183655, -0.4303962290287018, -0.8184969425201416, -0.2842988073825836, -0.5720685720443726, 0.9756728410720825, 0.1054772436618805, 0.9314659237861633, -0.13986283540725708, -0.4668954610824585, 0.4546189308166504, 0.8131727576255798, 1.0059490203857422, -0.07690831273794174, 0.4157162606716156, 0.45888540148735046, 0.12822842597961426, -0.12644252181053162, 0.8782280683517456, 0.6385805010795593, -0.7794507145881653, 0.3655351400375366, -0.5256667137145996, -0.3190501630306244, -0.41354119777679443, -0.30087554454803467, 0.7808168530464172, 0.5008044838905334, 0.23470690846443176, -0.4671136736869812, -0.7306891083717346, 0.18293844163417816, -1.2405240535736084, -0.14832383394241333, -0.871868908405304, 0.16003233194351196, 0.0771816298365593, 0.3931354284286499, 0.3825806975364685, -0.19496232271194458, 4.20798397064209, 0.951379120349884, 0.7242363691329956, 0.21306785941123962, 1.0262377262115479, 0.3231487274169922, 0.306161105632782, -0.3934737741947174, 0.280380517244339, -0.6009255647659302, 0.18654420971870422, 0.14088350534439087, 0.3387370705604553, -0.4972018301486969, 0.07935184985399246, 0.0582314133644104, -0.17696161568164825, 0.43319937586784363, 0.23504669964313507, -1.1558786630630493, -0.6976942420005798, 0.4441428482532501, 0.05940597504377365, -0.2802690863609314, -0.2391614019870758, -0.5396082997322083, 0.4267377555370331, -0.7784034013748169, -0.6140369176864624, -0.42960312962532043, -0.5098050832748413, -0.9366270899772644, 0.3849717378616333, -0.5402241945266724, -0.7558678984642029, 0.10410989075899124, 0.29141679406166077, 0.2031467854976654, 0.26843276619911194, 0.5412812232971191, 0.03513287007808685, -0.2847806513309479, -0.7293549180030823, -0.21551458537578583, -0.9196183085441589, 0.9700137972831726, -0.25773555040359497, 0.9271599054336548, -0.26063811779022217, -0.2902766764163971, 0.8800296187400818, -0.6265104413032532, 0.5293118953704834, -0.054981932044029236, -1.671077847480774, 0.07940720021724701, -0.429534912109375, -0.35024353861808777, -0.5000227689743042, 0.101564422249794, 1.188895583152771, 0.3227282464504242, -0.34974783658981323, 0.10445543378591537, -0.11818953603506088, 0.5870347619056702, 0.4687429964542389, 0.0708288699388504, -0.3437090516090393, -0.058314453810453415, -0.28668972849845886, -0.30077093839645386, -0.5843854546546936, -0.49738025665283203, 0.6616035103797913, -0.2525745928287506, -0.7652871608734131, 0.5929227471351624, -0.1972467452287674, -0.2749139070510864, -0.4648011028766632, -0.8836054801940918, -0.8655491471290588, 0.18804629147052765, 0.18783263862133026, 0.24196912348270416, -0.5086876153945923, -0.05543792247772217, -0.1473836600780487, 0.27269062399864197, -0.12165895849466324, 1.1506378650665283, 0.148408904671669, -0.028667455539107323, -0.20846027135849 ]
Logarithmically slow domain growth in nonrandomly frustrated systems: Ising models with competing interactions
It is known that in systems which contain randomness explicitly in their Hamiltonians (e.g., due to impurities), the characteristic size L of the ordered domains can grow only logarithmically with time t following a quench below the transition temperature. However, in systems without such imposed randomness, much faster power law growth has generally been predicted. Motivated by the slow dynamics present in glasses, we have been looking for counterexamples, i.e., for models without randomness which nonetheless order logarithmically slowly. Here, we discuss two closely related models for which we have simple physical arguments that such slow growth occurs. The basis of these arguments is the claim that the free energy barriers to domain growth in these models are proportional to L. Thus, the barriers grow as the domains coarsen. We present the results of Monte Carlo simulations, which lend strong support to our claims of growing barriers and logarithmically slow dynamics. Finally, we discuss how quickly the system orders when it is cooled continuously through the transition (rather than quenched).
Joel D. Shore, Mark Holzer, and James P. Sethna
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204015
cond-mat/9204016
[ 0.36422380805015564, 0.1648440659046173, 0.550326943397522, 0.2770672142505646, -0.0032356642186641693, -0.4391900897026062, -0.2095305323600769, -0.09633248299360275, -0.8022748827934265, 1.564386248588562, 0.679409384727478, -0.1014462560415268, 0.4110863506793976, -0.42880144715309143, 0.22721146047115326, 0.39258766174316406, 0.08380527049303055, -0.6795698404312134, -1.1545612812042236, 0.2116718292236328, -0.019145915284752846, -0.35689884424209595, -0.514420747756958, -0.3988599181175232, -0.5253384113311768, 0.47469764947891235, -0.1608257293701172, 0.5997942686080933, 1.1027839183807373, 0.8889135122299194, 0.3046489357948303, -0.3883236348628998, -0.6253018975257874, -0.7473452687263489, -0.5449141263961792, -0.17053990066051483, -0.4134499728679657, -0.3693813383579254, 0.7162624001502991, -0.24246567487716675, 0.6125490069389343, -0.6539183259010315, 0.7022514343261719, -0.03806110844016075, -0.709787905216217, 0.011924910359084606, -0.019772302359342575, -0.33887118101119995, 0.03721410408616066, -1.4216915369033813, 0.08271726965904236, -0.03471336141228676, 0.5062850117683411, -0.9753168821334839, -0.018389148637652397, 0.11340998113155365, 0.2899935245513916, -0.11023586988449097, 0.006271739024668932, -0.2476319521665573, 0.8368664979934692, 0.20929934084415436, 0.6235944628715515, -0.37692371010780334, 0.11189155280590057, 0.770973265171051, -0.44797104597091675, 0.791223406791687, 0.09230457246303558, -0.7008180618286133, -0.17135533690452576, -0.7798068523406982, -0.593805193901062, 0.31489047408103943, -0.8131296038627625, 0.31602993607521057, 0.4793255031108856, -0.704603910446167, -0.7623584866523743, -0.5169594287872314, 0.10006074607372284, -0.43837839365005493, -0.22637665271759033, 0.44433075189590454, -0.0353504978120327, -0.7684644460678101, 0.3286718428134918, -0.22489111125469208, -0.24076049029827118, 0.838392972946167, 0.21550968289375305, 0.5591444373130798, -0.07934519648551941, -0.20315147936344147, 0.4127005636692047, 0.9955278038978577, 0.1897481381893158, 0.3552689254283905, 0.05874389410018921, 0.030411364510655403, -0.3051106631755829, 0.7924928665161133, -0.5606188178062439, 0.4134844243526459, -1.4225887060165405, 0.2545211911201477, -0.21804118156433105, 0.2534964382648468, -0.5945181250572205, -0.5923364758491516, -0.0856822207570076, 0.014390530064702034, 0.634489119052887, 0.8627541661262512, 0.06184478476643562, 0.6751225590705872, 0.3287927806377411, -0.19961339235305786, -1.0443297624588013, -0.29282939434051514, -0.4310363829135895, 0.09704213589429855, 0.34691405296325684, 0.2639751434326172, -0.03761604428291321, -0.3844295144081116, -0.03043476864695549, 1.0203211307525635, -0.6927673816680908, -0.06952017545700073, -0.20794963836669922, 0.17281481623649597, 0.1512838900089264, 0.5597285032272339, 0.2722446918487549, 0.18815426528453827, -0.3998914361000061, 0.43800339102745056, 0.30728083848953247, -0.5575088858604431, 0.5501720309257507, -0.734403669834137, 0.5188385248184204, 0.7743000388145447, 0.1207500547170639, -0.037574201822280884, 0.5329825282096863, -0.6058841943740845, -0.11997393518686295, 0.3899199962615967, -0.6623228788375854, -0.1975783407688141, 0.11833366751670837, 0.40172168612480164, -0.015040268190205097, 0.29580140113830566, -0.7904329895973206, 0.7271707653999329, -0.6487597227096558, -1.084509253501892, 0.6056510210037231, -0.002954148454591632, -0.47644010186195374, 0.5310288667678833, -0.5358119010925293, -0.015198636800050735, -0.4903755187988281, -0.47347551584243774, 0.5376104712486267, -0.6861467361450195, -0.5720252990722656, 0.32670941948890686, -0.26556748151779175, 0.6966411471366882, 0.41184568405151367, 0.2748253643512726, 0.9082888960838318, 0.00033544751931913197, 0.5971951484680176, 0.508894145488739, -0.6025282740592957, -0.3061204254627228, 1.2228952646255493, 0.09534825384616852, -0.020253317430615425, -0.012784892693161964, -0.2770374119281769, -0.2766927480697632, 0.5161442160606384, 0.31264910101890564, -0.6859126687049866, 0.5409372448921204, -0.4290439188480377, 0.8209272027015686, -0.4475201964378357, -0.31912440061569214, -1.170777440071106, 0.7443097233772278, -0.1176493689417839, -0.1657274216413498, -0.5030093789100647, 0.3875059485435486, -1.0707929134368896, 0.33869072794914246, -0.9621181488037109, 0.24518583714962006, 0.7237842082977295, 0.27231496572494507, -0.2153068482875824, -0.0545056089758873, 0.21060070395469666, -0.22211213409900665, 0.5568876266479492, -0.35839712619781494, -0.062139950692653656, 0.053288135677576065, 0.06535306572914124, 0.32686275243759155, 0.6326120495796204, -0.2575414180755615, 0.9330691695213318, 0.29526570439338684, -0.4474881887435913, 1.498364806175232, 0.1571047306060791, -0.3674280047416687, 0.17237909138202667, 0.4702148735523224, 0.3363468647003174, -0.43435174226760864, -0.10489287227392197, 1.0295259952545166, 0.09514497220516205, 0.5046204328536987, 1.213757872581482, 0.1961200088262558, 0.37991371750831604, 0.7144389152526855, 0.025519847869873047, 0.37142202258110046, -0.0405600443482399, 0.21227534115314484, 0.4925347864627838, 0.061099179089069366, -0.18017908930778503, 0.7669164538383484, -0.5441925525665283, -0.2838281989097595, -0.4732654094696045, 0.12223073840141296, -0.7024465203285217, 1.058838129043579, 0.2432297170162201, 0.10823510587215424, -0.9650216102600098, 0.39678144454956055, 0.233243927359581, 0.6709771156311035, -0.38977837562561035, -0.5163654088973999, 0.06267126649618149, 0.047564223408699036, -0.22242966294288635, -0.8696679472923279, -0.39162588119506836, 0.9384020566940308, -0.15819285809993744, 0.6154182553291321, 0.25018104910850525, -0.06576159596443176, -1.0243483781814575, -0.16809001564979553, -0.9098185300827026, -0.0632464587688446, -0.4449259340763092, 0.1360083520412445, 1.1038538217544556, -0.5551432967185974, 0.33693814277648926, -0.20926770567893982, -0.3105064332485199, 0.7783037424087524, -0.07288727909326553, 0.989310622215271, -0.324727863073349, 0.15050093829631805, -0.7934774160385132, 0.4404478669166565, -0.9441038966178894, 0.2772216796875, -0.061045773327350616, 0.48344022035598755, 0.11359935253858566, 0.019138416275382042, 0.13465352356433868, -0.24752509593963623, -0.14371663331985474, 0.0020782549399882555, -0.0035855595488101244, -0.41850075125694275, -0.2859293818473816, 0.45743849873542786, -0.3785741925239563, -0.29541346430778503, -0.6467316150665283, 0.9055473208427429, 0.002851252444088459, -0.1773640662431717, 1.01968514919281, 0.3250957131385803, -0.5500458478927612, 0.4910731613636017, -0.43615806102752686, 0.46886545419692993, 0.0189103651791811, 0.8970012068748474, 1.0004854202270508, -0.322274774312973, 0.23140522837638855, -0.42155778408050537, -0.05279599502682686, 0.28640514612197876, 0.6164566874504089, -1.0977613925933838, -0.110624298453331, 0.4934496283531189, 0.5002922415733337, -0.6108965873718262, -0.10804107785224915, -1.0095365047454834, -1.0591411590576172, -0.2576397657394409, -0.42592653632164, 0.3812309205532074, -0.06023675948381424, -0.16442765295505524, -0.9705016613006592, -0.44787299633026123, -0.23322047293186188, 0.6060317754745483, 0.5223231911659241, -0.796241044998169, 0.9339165091514587, 0.4812646806240082, 0.45879629254341125, 0.19902968406677246, 0.3250396251678467, -0.5064465403556824, -0.015205493196845055, 0.760577917098999, -0.17300796508789062, 0.11516701430082321, 0.3600119352340698, -0.30067452788352966, 0.278061181306839, 0.7867097854614258, -0.49806034564971924, -0.5558264255523682, -0.3754127025604248, -0.8023502230644226, 0.29780057072639465, 0.23684188723564148, -0.059261027723550797, -0.0560573972761631, -0.7054193615913391, -0.18358787894248962, 0.2889491021633148, -0.5440467596054077, 1.0428422689437866, -0.8756757974624634, 0.2929544746875763, -0.16464383900165558, -0.29659369587898254, -0.04368353262543678, -0.08197467029094696, 0.1844705492258072, 0.22042493522167206, 0.6249409914016724, 0.37057310342788696, -0.42434754967689514, -0.38545042276382446, -0.1654416173696518, 0.86936354637146, 1.0309425592422485, 0.7268009185791016, 0.9325527548789978, -0.14268606901168823, -0.18461233377456665, -0.5889487266540527, -0.8700705170631409, 0.16955892741680145, 0.08170510083436966, -0.7097443342208862, -0.6151628494262695, -0.36352670192718506, -0.7462658286094666, 0.5738441944122314, 0.46286898851394653, 0.22998829185962677, 0.052285999059677124, 0.2656180262565613, 0.38802430033683777, 0.8551341891288757, 0.26597774028778076, -0.11454617977142334, 0.029143232852220535, -0.9842174053192139, 0.8853691816329956, 0.14694543182849884, 0.26423653960227966, -0.18581731617450714, -0.2410629540681839, -0.42811593413352966, -0.8484343886375427, 0.3819258511066437, 0.21283580362796783, -0.5764959454536438, 0.4662163257598877, 0.10729151964187622, 0.13529741764068604, -0.44424229860305786, 0.02244807593524456, 0.3510887324810028, 0.3094671070575714, -0.15256793797016144, -1.0558102130889893, 0.607650876045227, 0.460103839635849, 0.26119256019592285, 0.9978160262107849, -0.19876447319984436, -0.778140127658844, -0.6863994002342224, 0.14571791887283325, -0.4130055010318756, -0.10746823251247406, 0.5281091332435608, 0.15689311921596527, -0.30971795320510864, -0.16562378406524658, 0.020600585266947746, 0.7963739037513733, -1.1421350240707397, -0.2780601382255554, 0.024327155202627182, 0.18818868696689606, -0.6834067702293396, 0.7031217813491821, 0.13046656548976898, -0.5330016613006592, 0.05716446042060852, -0.08355492353439331, 0.032934967428445816, -0.12387781590223312, -0.7563936114311218, -0.07536614686250687, -0.3181818723678589, -0.6596341133117676, 0.6759886741638184, -0.02391788549721241, 0.08094742149114609, -0.16780637204647064, 0.3593578338623047, -0.39093250036239624, -0.20718492567539215, -0.07907531410455704, 0.37178024649620056, 0.4003274440765381, 0.2360433042049408, 0.22532130777835846, 0.5611506104469299, 0.27116188406944275, 0.1612902283668518, -0.12537527084350586, 0.10101645439863205, 0.4386228024959564, 0.05168234929442406, -0.3626818060874939, -0.267229825258255, -0.3765060305595398, -0.5727773308753967, 0.030224883928894997, -0.31043899059295654, 0.9921625256538391, 0.11698891967535019, -0.7192431688308716, -1.1851820945739746, -0.0265794787555933, -0.8864750266075134, 0.8380964994430542, -0.08226214349269867, -0.6998739838600159, 0.355438768863678, -0.4992735981941223, -0.7783063650131226, -0.2119804471731186, -0.2685272693634033, -0.4144584834575653, 0.5580809116363525, 0.8174852728843689, -0.30177292227745056, -0.04908442497253418, -0.6033028960227966, 0.2817190885543823, -0.3314116597175598, 0.47516435384750366, -0.436096727848053, -0.5577978491783142, -0.5393540859222412, 0.3128770589828491, -0.41044437885284424, -0.46072816848754883, -0.060486096888780594, -0.21109016239643097, 0.20923353731632233, 0.011396575719118118, 0.456231027841568, -0.23139935731887817, -0.5982357263565063, 0.7558955550193787, 0.31641098856925964, -0.6503117680549622, 0.3043477535247803, 0.9631032943725586, -0.17740295827388763, -0.250522643327713, 0.13270381093025208, -0.7658842206001282, 0.11425448209047318, -0.5570129156112671, 0.17028973996639252, -0.9944523572921753, -0.5100547075271606, -0.40152084827423096, -0.16230998933315277, 0.2845507264137268, 0.38789892196655273, 0.5047986507415771, -0.3738548159599304, -0.03308769688010216, -0.4361802637577057, 0.18117904663085938, -0.587475061416626, 0.05257287248969078, -0.3909060060977936, -0.340181440114975, -1.0411063432693481, 0.47677114605903625, 0.09322033822536469, 0.2673221230506897, 0.19684752821922302, 0.1010766476392746, -0.019012166187167168, 0.7161267995834351, -0.5501090884208679, 0.4147114157676697, 0.2131374031305313, -0.038705311715602875, 0.21906664967536926, 0.4972531497478485, -0.7535810470581055, 0.2892950475215912, -1.0173496007919312, 0.9465951919555664, 0.2370034158229828, -0.006149933207780123, -0.1497454047203064, 0.05352512374520302, 0.4632856547832489, -0.7371281981468201, 0.4435931444168091, 0.59919273853302, 0.06888358294963837, 0.8289854526519775, 0.15675023198127747, -0.7331787347793579, -0.7010960578918457, -0.931700587272644, -0.8358688950538635, 0.6962517499923706, -0.01152182649821043, -0.32835930585861206, -0.5446330904960632, -0.875291109085083, 0.04062512144446373, -0.1374550610780716, 0.22387847304344177, 0.46551498770713806, 0.005465878173708916, -0.2431047558784485, -0.21305547654628754, 0.6829419136047363, -0.1358053982257843, -0.004979074466973543, 0.28029194474220276, 0.29542452096939087, -0.658553957939148, -0.2078741192817688, -0.390240341424942, -0.9502769708633423, -0.49323979020118713, 1.0563740730285645, 0.22409141063690186, -0.15816690027713776, 1.0218861103057861, 0.0028851788956671953, -0.4615267217159271, -0.03471992164850235, 0.02527770772576332, -0.1088763102889061, 0.3070409297943115, 0.3268822431564331, 0.1859118640422821, -0.30312663316726685, 0.048578597605228424, 0.24428363144397736, -0.5524917244911194, -0.16210034489631653, 0.4601662755012512, -0.5747594833374023, -0.35891199111938477, 0.30022069811820984, 0.29169124364852905, -0.7250385880470276, -0.4702055752277374, -0.717021644115448, -0.055450085550546646, -0.4076172113418579, -1.1132957935333252, 0.22313852608203888, -0.039816517382860184, -0.4761667549610138, 0.22948919236660004, 0.7601898312568665, -0.31222641468048096, 0.05408085137605667, 0.16221988201141357, -0.8501701354980469, -0.8244270086288452, 0.005441009066998959, 1.222416877746582, -0.15136636793613434, -0.5251548290252686, -0.15352670848369598, -0.31549790501594543, 0.09510568529367447, 0.15678060054779053, 0.5561201572418213, -0.22193095088005066, 0.11717407405376434, -0.11928264051675797, 0.3866480886936188, 0.08896874636411667, 0.3544450104236603, 0.06401391327381134, 0.18397295475006104, 0.036931250244379044, -0.5261601805686951, -0.04921631142497063, 0.06755358725786209, 0.33197182416915894, 1.053865671157837, -0.21468502283096313, 0.4216384291648865, -0.7043928503990173, -0.595899760723114, -0.7618334889411926, -1.018370509147644, 0.20089660584926605, -0.9939978122711182, -0.30902624130249023, -1.0395716428756714, -0.5317942500114441, -0.34546393156051636, 0.5642068386077881, -0.07759838551282883, 0.10713174939155579, -0.5956442356109619, -0.2798084616661072, 0.5559008717536926, 0.036843590438365936, 0.10005759447813034, -0.4203954041004181, -0.9967833757400513, -0.030171943828463554, -0.6909334659576416, -0.34584975242614746, -0.07596038281917572, 0.12532953917980194, 0.2023567408323288, 0.3615851402282715, -0.4226999580860138, 0.9104447364807129, -0.8945620656013489, -1.0012836456298828, 0.24963201582431793, -0.3473852574825287, -0.14143086969852448, 0.21630044281482697, -0.4366856515407562, 0.35727450251579285, 0.2849019765853882, 0.026727277785539627, 0.057052381336688995, -0.026957716792821884, -0.8671135306358337, 0.24991567432880402, -0.6152300238609314, 0.49084046483039856, 0.08060801774263382, -0.43844226002693176, 0.2614707946777344, 0.1490895003080368, -0.8183256983757019, 0.29035302996635437, -0.9850147366523743, 0.3799262046813965, -0.5067151188850403, 0.5460626482963562, 0.1402633637189865, 0.5572734475135803, -0.17522993683815002, 0.4258427619934082, -0.34131234884262085, -0.36801785230636597, 0.23491613566875458, 0.014851167798042297, -0.37894120812416077, 0.6426059007644653, 0.148580402135849, -0.33202627301216125, -0.2251008152961731, 0.767991304397583, -0.20395462214946747, 0.3130436837673187, -0.47058096528053284, -0.02404908463358879, -0.2939748167991638, 0.058333538472652435, -1.1342062950134277, 0.7808884382247925, 0.10380539298057556, -0.11944720894098282, -0.2270398586988449, -0.4920464754104614, -0.39173924922943115, 0.15706448256969452, -0.28730717301368713, 0.042665995657444, -0.6655554175376892, -0.04088510945439339, -0.32008129358291626, 0.054324641823768616, -0.1501568704843521, 0.1493297666311264, -0.41154900193214417, 0.620643138885498, -0.16044148802757263, -0.13991215825080872, -0.34709787368774414, 0.4540456533432007, -0.9086443781852722, 0.35429954528808594, -0.3110489547252655, 0.6012855172157288, -0.35498908162117004, -0.2604570984840393, -0.19074051082134247, 0.3722268342971802, -0.16145621240139008, -0.05886295065283775, -0.4749017059803009, -0.20491144061088562, 0.0053714183159172535, 0.5126962065696716, -0.3049700856208801, -0.038533300161361694, -0.02388922870159149, 0.8317358493804932, 0.5874204039573669, -0.7902095317840576, -0.07211338728666306, 0.03079945780336857, 0.369101345539093, -0.08971492201089859, -0.3895435631275177, 0.965126633644104, 0.18362286686897278, -0.5660560131072998, 0.9720665216445923, 0.0810631662607193, 0.3732583224773407, 0.34752264618873596, 0.2143891155719757, 0.0852261483669281, 0.4172734022140503, 0.6613149642944336, 0.4863280653953552, 0.5532680153846741, 0.2825595438480377, 0.260206937789917, -0.33877453207969666, 0.0021449760533869267, 0.5286602973937988, 0.4027760624885559, -0.2945396304130554, 0.39969244599342346, -0.13525578379631042, 0.23489414155483246, -0.21006551384925842, 0.03629691153764725, -0.1745707094669342, 0.20325012505054474, -0.017512446269392967, -0.09040135890245438, -0.08911004662513733, 0.26874029636383057, -0.5479770302772522, -0.23676471412181854, -0.44290947914123535, 0.18556326627731323, -0.003645282005891204, -0.0873987227678299, 0.1953725814819336, 0.46663716435432434, 0.9768178462982178, 0.30428025126457214, -0.19603806734085083, 0.5764179825782776, 0.2684631049633026, 0.4549391269683838, 0.32692334055900574, 0.4274040162563324, 0.8248679637908936, 0.29501521587371826, 0.08581895381212234, -0.9987362623214722, 0.24337700009346008, 0.6022953987121582, -1.5854164361953735, -0.06767936795949936, 0.053426411002874374, -0.25663650035858154, 0.1511189192533493, -0.7640490531921387, 0.26726484298706055, -0.45697081089019775, -0.24528977274894714, 0.7637926340103149, 0.23536574840545654, 0.27578482031822205, 0.17990757524967194, -0.08450451493263245, 0.6705275177955627, 0.25690600275993347, 0.18131087720394135, -0.011523148976266384, 0.994987964630127, 1.2644752264022827, -0.1328800469636917, 0.29561111330986023, -0.15290392935276031, 0.026478547602891922, 0.06789783388376236, 0.44216254353523254, -0.3450566232204437, 1.2126730680465698, -0.8005123734474182, -0.34835460782051086, 0.2967216372489929, 0.09784572571516037, 0.17155534029006958, -0.06044220179319382, -0.002947330242022872, 0.35013219714164734, -0.5756093263626099, -0.43039408326148987, 1.3667447566986084, 0.8746282458305359, -0.2820224165916443, 0.23640985786914825, 0.4399176239967346, -0.06099066138267517, -0.21566276252269745, -0.7156161069869995, 0.9701289534568787, -0.08890422433614731, 0.12878072261810303, -0.026430385187268257, -0.9086543917655945, -0.18517561256885529, -1.110474705696106, -0.2744762897491455, -0.8396715521812439, 1.1498712301254272, 0.488389253616333, 0.572936475276947, 0.44278934597969055, -0.8195520043373108, 0.4400846064090729, 0.4547974169254303, 1.1186741590499878, -0.1271555870771408, 0.11181867867708206, 0.5821710228919983, 0.46757665276527405, -0.32669496536254883, 0.8923638463020325, 0.706842839717865, -0.2552192509174347, 0.9295949339866638, -0.5196284651756287, -0.019035253673791885, 0.3563630282878876, -0.262159138917923, 0.6353456974029541, 0.41322165727615356, 0.18953801691532135, -0.282857745885849, -0.5296527147293091, -0.12094753235578537, -1.2691601514816284, -0.3538898825645447, -0.8160528540611267, 0.502520740032196, -0.21867913007736206, 0.39239686727523804, 0.2834985554218292, -0.47235357761383057, 4.197356700897217, 1.0027095079421997, 0.9216637015342712, 0.3336327075958252, 1.2110720872879028, 0.5454801321029663, 0.007804775610566139, -0.028228769078850746, 0.39893123507499695, -0.8975119590759277, -0.3738424777984619, 0.2251552790403366, 0.36329737305641174, -0.5626858472824097, -0.04361528530716896, 0.16759508848190308, -0.2715422511100769, 0.45941153168678284, 0.023532891646027565, -0.9508933424949646, -0.7806664109230042, 0.41150131821632385, 0.39351752400398254, -0.10156387835741043, -0.19905714690685272, -0.6854164600372314, 0.5707982182502747, -1.168624997138977, -0.26768290996551514, -0.4535800516605377, -0.4828091263771057, -0.9935164451599121, 0.5265511274337769, -0.7186206579208374, -0.7709179520606995, 0.29329732060432434, 0.10125651955604553, 0.004426110535860062, 0.35446518659591675, -0.19105161726474762, -0.18804161250591278, -0.17510153353214264, 0.05959373712539673, -0.49604955315589905, -0.6278921961784363, 1.4686418771743774, -0.20120830833911896, 1.2082070112228394, 0.18456366658210754, -0.519470751285553, 0.21056705713272095, -0.5125392079353333, 0.5292541980743408, -0.1662963330745697, -1.4177577495574951, 0.15100276470184326, -0.1827232539653778, -0.33743056654930115, -0.5883277058601379, -0.10706007480621338, 0.42275989055633545, -0.08458580821752548, -0.1384223997592926, 0.3344789147377014, 0.03836007043719292, 0.5581674575805664, 0.17600995302200317, -0.1802983582019806, -0.42586567997932434, 0.18783287703990936, -0.34715861082077026, -0.4832237958908081, -0.41408056020736694, -0.13818970322608948, 0.230957493185997, -0.4525909125804901, -0.5660781264305115, 0.32618340849876404, -0.1299017071723938, 0.12256737798452377, -0.6857426166534424, -0.8978438973426819, -0.941762387752533, 0.45017337799072266, -0.0033493046648800373, 0.5734336972236633, -0.3384835124015808, 0.14499592781066895, -0.25074031949043274, 0.3408387005329132, 0.21926388144493103, 1.3195704221725464, 0.012672580778598785, 0.1617984026670456, -0.7753586769104004 ]
Logarithmically slow domain growth in nonrandomly frustrated systems--- A summary of the major results
Here, we summarize the most important results of our study of logarithmically slow growth of domains following a quench in two models without randomness in their Hamiltonians. This is a slightly updated version of a paper to appear in the Proceedings of the 1st Annual Tohwa University International Symposium, Fukuoka, Japan (American Institute of Physics, 1992). It is meant to serve as a brief summary of cond-mat/9204015 for those who do not wish to read all the details contained therein (and don't want to hassle with 2 MBytes of tex/ps files).
Joel D. Shore, James P. Sethna, Mark Holzer, and Veit Elser
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204016
cond-mat/9204017
[ 0.4223751723766327, -0.29991716146469116, 0.36651191115379333, 0.07758039236068726, -0.10757500678300858, -0.4672655463218689, 0.09211273491382599, -0.5436156988143921, -0.4902305006980896, 1.5943348407745361, 0.9256085753440857, 0.09547047317028046, 0.31453946232795715, -0.7154650688171387, -0.33079493045806885, 0.45120689272880554, 0.06046893075108528, -0.34458208084106445, -1.795616626739502, -0.2907413840293884, -0.014642137102782726, -0.25267162919044495, -1.1498327255249023, -0.2848873734474182, -0.38524001836776733, 0.6492384076118469, 0.4976385831832886, 0.6831955313682556, 0.740520179271698, 0.1078769862651825, 0.2664361894130707, -0.5033273100852966, 0.46546921133995056, -1.1836246252059937, -0.09569227695465088, 0.18963001668453217, 0.29982081055641174, -0.3364576995372772, 0.8514373302459717, -0.6803266406059265, 1.5293265581130981, -0.4117707312107086, 0.48448464274406433, -0.10525240749120712, -0.7787740230560303, 0.1222948282957077, -0.09830344468355179, 0.5261459350585938, 0.18679244816303253, -1.3622205257415771, 0.2761712074279785, 0.2072772979736328, 0.7454032897949219, -0.5591750741004944, -0.15007032454013824, -0.32616958022117615, -0.13507869839668274, 0.4484177827835083, 0.1528342217206955, 0.02297135256230831, 0.4437454044818878, -0.13447502255439758, 0.9667892456054688, -1.0397605895996094, -0.34654465317726135, 0.6601748466491699, -0.5119513869285583, 1.0029959678649902, 0.016654890030622482, -0.2719593048095703, -0.5716623663902283, -0.3399985134601593, -0.5589087009429932, 0.10021064430475235, -0.5323593616485596, 0.6454364061355591, -0.14418110251426697, -0.7230072021484375, -1.3372094631195068, -0.241390198469162, 0.013415046967566013, -0.33987435698509216, -0.03813818469643593, 0.3570426106452942, 0.03659630939364433, 0.024747652933001518, -0.2641836702823639, -0.2710426151752472, -0.38861411809921265, 0.4526132643222809, 0.45898231863975525, 1.2310932874679565, -0.026388920843601227, 0.01798836514353752, 0.37963345646858215, 0.4470295011997223, 0.5614163875579834, 0.22430351376533508, 0.25254642963409424, 0.3850111961364746, -0.311833918094635, 0.1927339732646942, -0.2676909565925598, 0.606505811214447, -0.7320907115936279, 1.1345640420913696, -0.2826629877090454, 0.4500318169593811, 0.03440813720226288, -0.4174277186393738, 0.44928839802742004, -0.3022175431251526, 0.24296541512012482, 0.7098101377487183, 0.37215951085090637, 0.5805872082710266, 0.217730313539505, 0.11001217365264893, -1.2718607187271118, -0.24608784914016724, 0.42087802290916443, 0.1268761307001114, 0.6550014615058899, 0.533900260925293, -0.263500452041626, -0.11444156616926193, 0.29684314131736755, 0.24963153898715973, -0.6174322962760925, 0.41571366786956787, 0.48239582777023315, -0.20687367022037506, 0.1334741711616516, 0.22587667405605316, -1.046500563621521, 0.5912187099456787, 0.09662775695323944, 0.3946111500263214, 0.3102926015853882, 0.031450316309928894, 0.5883956551551819, -0.181340292096138, -0.22996629774570465, 0.7272636294364929, -0.032539885491132736, 0.7140891551971436, 0.23713380098342896, 0.4190424084663391, -0.19223305583000183, 0.24332265555858612, -0.4744715094566345, 0.20068630576133728, -0.19241581857204437, 0.6351593732833862, -0.14900918304920197, 0.2478804737329483, -0.5270847082138062, 0.3517230451107025, -0.5790518522262573, -0.4734714925289154, 0.6811159253120422, -0.19908201694488525, 0.2673509120941162, 0.061873890459537506, -0.26723071932792664, -0.10560822486877441, -0.41759100556373596, -0.4969785511493683, -0.023454483598470688, -0.20649701356887817, -0.32453131675720215, 0.3448140025138855, -0.04342305660247803, 0.6774016618728638, 0.09086677432060242, -0.18874451518058777, 0.48656365275382996, 0.08704692125320435, 0.0032725150231271982, -0.24784305691719055, 0.016826095059514046, -0.30180490016937256, 0.7019198536872864, 0.07792310416698456, -0.19108644127845764, -0.3069475591182709, -0.6236373782157898, -0.16796131432056427, -0.5568101406097412, 0.32014545798301697, -0.23693309724330902, -0.054115936160087585, -0.4893542528152466, 0.6220993399620056, -0.9918993711471558, -0.21745973825454712, -0.9666138887405396, 0.8375138640403748, -0.6004561185836792, 0.11043046414852142, -0.08614664524793625, -0.12400483340024948, -1.4497390985488892, 0.026874767616391182, -1.523990273475647, 0.06747491657733917, 0.24590378999710083, 0.04736585170030594, -0.693317711353302, 0.283725768327713, 0.3803776800632477, -0.25602591037750244, 0.4911685287952423, -0.2701475918292999, 0.13615591824054718, -0.2880246341228485, 0.04504721239209175, 0.27191653847694397, 0.15368852019309998, 0.3333861827850342, 0.9703835844993591, 0.2674253284931183, -0.09036770462989807, 1.0104985237121582, -0.2739550769329071, -0.43653374910354614, 0.3454448878765106, 0.7542631030082703, 0.2455095797777176, -0.021804094314575195, 0.17183229327201843, 0.56155925989151, 0.04121194779872894, 0.6437265872955322, 0.8165550827980042, 0.13321037590503693, 0.48672932386398315, 0.38448864221572876, 0.7558324337005615, 0.004497184418141842, 0.03479848429560661, -0.10195355117321014, 0.5045856237411499, 0.3109862804412842, 0.30725350975990295, -0.1953069567680359, -0.7500305771827698, 0.4162326455116272, -0.9468457102775574, 0.8512974977493286, -0.18403521180152893, 0.6276866793632507, 0.4001975953578949, 0.5791726112365723, -0.6020787358283997, 0.4937456250190735, 0.39969712495803833, -0.3421443998813629, -0.379021018743515, -0.6922680139541626, 0.010196669027209282, -0.05425744503736496, -0.6798518896102905, -0.4600173234939575, 0.1404614895582199, 0.4713512361049652, -0.010200487449765205, -0.668918251991272, 0.24700427055358887, 0.09069647639989853, -1.166176438331604, 0.07620468735694885, -0.6606532335281372, 0.03147619217634201, -0.6152836084365845, 0.3806249499320984, 0.3882148861885071, -0.7828578948974609, 0.787211537361145, 0.24025999009609222, -0.09406936168670654, 0.5924932956695557, -0.2461424022912979, 0.1619368940591812, -0.19384077191352844, 0.058542054146528244, -0.7083252668380737, -0.021571196615695953, -1.0477086305618286, 0.4399119019508362, -0.055336132645606995, -0.058790259063243866, 0.9308504462242126, -0.4947887659072876, 0.1003229171037674, -0.7717804908752441, -0.45599570870399475, 0.6719805002212524, -0.29760462045669556, -0.47378870844841003, -0.10704469680786133, 0.9055314064025879, 0.3289305865764618, -0.3278948962688446, -0.40692538022994995, 0.7151839733123779, 0.40146249532699585, -0.4121421277523041, 0.17545795440673828, -0.13087224960327148, -0.2884962558746338, 0.19827133417129517, -0.1800706386566162, 0.3239298164844513, 0.14670322835445404, 0.3102390468120575, 0.5417793393135071, 0.3119019865989685, -0.054636772722005844, -0.4736039638519287, -0.6341524720191956, 0.01785026304423809, -0.15032438933849335, -0.6235672831535339, 0.2038220763206482, 0.7513203024864197, -0.26028597354888916, -0.6245933175086975, 0.5731610059738159, -1.1442276239395142, -0.2166450172662735, -0.18992851674556732, -0.16927239298820496, 0.5279715061187744, -0.22144104540348053, -0.11981517821550369, -0.4815550744533539, -0.3353154957294464, 0.8675963282585144, 0.3527699112892151, 0.4810231328010559, -0.6857796311378479, 0.3476441502571106, 0.10303763300180435, 0.12076011300086975, -0.43975579738616943, 0.6070489883422852, -0.47342702746391296, -0.3219911754131317, 0.12911880016326904, -0.7823004722595215, -0.2973957657814026, 0.28842654824256897, 0.2966521680355072, 0.1697434037923813, 0.5564996004104614, -0.5401320457458496, -0.31591442227363586, -0.6561296582221985, 0.11139682680368423, 0.18455299735069275, 1.1690047979354858, -0.5917697548866272, -0.5188964009284973, -0.4933430254459381, -0.4723043739795685, 0.5068222284317017, -0.07942435145378113, 0.5091933012008667, -0.616385281085968, 0.3023652732372284, -0.5603517889976501, -0.5451935529708862, 0.4153893291950226, -0.34159067273139954, -0.013501960784196854, 0.49795207381248474, 0.7182517051696777, 0.6205266714096069, -0.35286179184913635, -0.43576180934906006, -0.5377151966094971, 0.5955275893211365, 0.22701723873615265, 0.8712644577026367, 0.5082657337188721, -0.2512574791908264, -0.06196580082178116, -0.633342981338501, -0.8276577591896057, -0.352382093667984, -0.027904421091079712, -0.3133816123008728, -0.16964662075042725, 0.08251474052667618, 0.19452668726444244, 0.3123202621936798, -0.6481799483299255, -0.17162413895130157, 0.22773878276348114, 0.7012740969657898, 1.1516971588134766, 0.3325760066509247, 0.30775001645088196, -0.06139850616455078, -0.37296155095100403, 0.17526289820671082, 0.19681498408317566, 0.09054474532604218, 0.02157280407845974, -0.2671816647052765, -0.7913089990615845, -0.30778616666793823, -0.35306546092033386, 0.792431652545929, 0.2791823744773865, -0.16446511447429657, 0.7840654253959656, 0.14341817796230316, 0.3807862401008606, -0.4473140835762024, -0.04080002009868622, 0.26803675293922424, 0.586437463760376, 0.5873997807502747, -0.6313703656196594, 0.7307459712028503, -0.09364981949329376, 0.659696102142334, 0.8481076955795288, -0.6683430075645447, -1.1373414993286133, -0.5344516038894653, 0.6889762878417969, -0.33034634590148926, -0.061624035239219666, 0.8164278268814087, 0.24380311369895935, 0.5475026965141296, 0.1190674751996994, -0.15731747448444366, 0.7923917770385742, -0.7089845538139343, -0.171856090426445, -0.22835637629032135, -0.6147189140319824, -0.291102796792984, 0.3760596215724945, -0.0968610942363739, -0.8841748237609863, -0.5631625652313232, -0.39162734150886536, 0.09603139013051987, -0.1856718212366104, 0.02010386809706688, 0.6869908571243286, -0.30070871114730835, -0.6081836819648743, 0.9268666505813599, 0.37434983253479004, -0.14192989468574524, -0.0611349381506443, 0.07022306323051453, -0.200520321726799, -0.06398339569568634, 0.3042723834514618, -0.11742668598890305, 1.3241599798202515, 0.8421292304992676, 0.38104480504989624, 0.4662293493747711, 0.3346250653266907, -0.14783446490764618, -0.07967960089445114, 0.31049010157585144, -0.3678162097930908, -0.887549638748169, -0.5906814336776733, -0.029124397784471512, -0.7951486706733704, -0.45164254307746887, -0.11161362379789352, -0.6504632830619812, 0.6718054413795471, 0.35909491777420044, -0.23932386934757233, -0.5100072622299194, -0.10809104144573212, -0.7740976810455322, 0.2095242291688919, -0.8310959339141846, -0.5683861970901489, -0.19176030158996582, -0.007871953770518303, 0.11015262454748154, 0.5997236967086792, -0.028280531987547874, -0.7829720377922058, 0.43907156586647034, 0.02254468947649002, 0.5660284161567688, 1.1380428075790405, -0.2838541269302368, 0.530189573764801, -0.44282597303390503, 0.7688823342323303, -0.4812149107456207, -0.5494322776794434, -0.30284324288368225, -0.6674217581748962, 0.13243457674980164, -0.22395607829093933, -0.7207249402999878, -0.06870640814304352, 0.12276344746351242, 0.448615700006485, -0.46042975783348083, -0.884093165397644, -0.8997536897659302, 1.0667136907577515, 0.3775480091571808, -0.12726812064647675, 0.5264514684677124, 0.2810758054256439, 0.5426105856895447, 0.4807715117931366, 0.0337880477309227, -0.5910192131996155, 0.3744952976703644, 0.2630350887775421, 0.42895257472991943, -0.8209608197212219, -0.5841884016990662, -0.29194363951683044, -0.4335482120513916, -0.3789953589439392, 0.35523754358291626, 0.12168707698583603, -0.47355949878692627, -0.026677047833800316, -0.09859030693769455, -0.368590384721756, -0.08088410645723343, -0.3514193296432495, -0.41009271144866943, 0.34125223755836487, -0.8703173398971558, 0.25207939743995667, -0.6759420037269592, 0.4205710291862488, 0.36498379707336426, 0.031072404235601425, 0.12823548913002014, 0.4104732573032379, 0.20064131915569305, 0.09029297530651093, -0.12731119990348816, 0.3212064504623413, 0.39777207374572754, 0.1288607269525528, -0.3728630244731903, 0.7053821682929993, -0.9520255327224731, 0.6375095844268799, -0.598956823348999, -0.6893561482429504, 0.12349535524845123, 0.37817272543907166, 0.4754330813884735, -0.4187878370285034, -0.12982036173343658, 0.12174300104379654, 0.3188803195953369, 0.8035005331039429, -0.3274401128292084, -0.19916115701198578, -0.5771140456199646, -0.39036425948143005, -0.8474892377853394, 0.3566385507583618, 0.29555559158325195, 0.24370799958705902, -0.5208187699317932, -0.3270907998085022, -0.07631644606590271, 0.030740967020392418, -0.29007741808891296, 0.7030794024467468, 0.04682093858718872, -0.1180049404501915, -0.26328739523887634, -0.2881747782230377, -0.2730764150619507, -0.1270975023508072, -0.2841072380542755, -0.011256963945925236, 0.0708267092704773, -0.13212592899799347, -0.7158433198928833, -1.268882393836975, -0.6218236684799194, 0.463101863861084, 0.04365582391619682, -0.26670756936073303, 1.096765398979187, -0.34251636266708374, 0.03622666001319885, 0.24000786244869232, 0.10970698297023773, -0.218446746468544, 0.10207793861627579, 0.7127252221107483, 0.38336873054504395, 0.8645195960998535, 0.1626904159784317, 0.29860353469848633, -0.48146572709083557, -0.15220776200294495, 0.12121933698654175, -0.7370573878288269, -0.20984067022800446, 0.7604995965957642, 0.2530374825000763, -0.9467014074325562, 0.45923614501953125, -0.866422712802887, -0.2986737787723541, 0.3042895495891571, -0.4825587272644043, -0.12541161477565765, -0.4053140878677368, -0.05876201391220093, 0.1475507766008377, 0.6258932948112488, -0.015883417800068855, 0.23810802400112152, -0.2929490804672241, 0.08580010384321213, -0.31232574582099915, -0.30281853675842285, 1.5774308443069458, 0.06784417480230331, -0.9038519263267517, -0.06611575186252594, -0.1413959413766861, -0.6888558864593506, 0.4612731337547302, 1.1570818424224854, 0.5187464952468872, 0.24392026662826538, 0.5898706912994385, -0.16431401669979095, 0.44461485743522644, 0.33921533823013306, 0.07135983556509018, -0.0415847972035408, 0.11345449835062027, -1.020766258239746, -0.21284367144107819, -0.2863248884677887, 0.1613781899213791, 0.42629045248031616, -0.13454191386699677, 0.01896589621901512, -0.08005814999341965, -0.24899981915950775, -0.00748224463313818, -1.125741958618164, -0.0635150745511055, -1.364789605140686, -0.39721739292144775, -0.8165714144706726, -0.22694188356399536, 0.16262918710708618, 0.22124944627285004, 0.06723678857088089, 0.1580836921930313, -0.7499569654464722, -0.05711565911769867, 0.19597306847572327, 0.28188326954841614, -0.10552059859037399, -1.0253361463546753, -0.4127185344696045, 0.22139544785022736, -0.25215211510658264, 0.26442113518714905, -0.4942798316478729, 0.012717646546661854, -0.012782208621501923, 0.26397234201431274, -1.0832234621047974, 0.4067903757095337, -1.0874416828155518, -0.9668315052986145, 0.28511476516723633, -0.45674386620521545, -1.1192716360092163, 0.14415565133094788, 0.3193160891532898, 0.24205413460731506, 0.23324474692344666, -0.23372140526771545, -0.2359272539615631, 0.23047901690006256, -0.9264704585075378, -0.007608245592564344, -0.2581270933151245, 0.13556928932666779, -0.04242928698658943, -0.6071501970291138, -0.08222737163305283, 0.6200088262557983, -1.0148682594299316, -0.026430336758494377, -0.15341494977474213, 0.6315672993659973, -0.4593833088874817, -0.09535887837409973, 0.016215570271015167, -0.14854158461093903, -0.3992643654346466, 1.1574997901916504, -0.13403472304344177, -0.23045535385608673, 0.0843978077173233, 0.019809488207101822, -0.18399964272975922, 0.8855885863304138, 0.23257406055927277, -0.7989439964294434, -0.7130869626998901, 0.5468931794166565, -0.18048344552516937, 0.5740813612937927, -0.5555681586265564, -0.5671272277832031, -0.7323101758956909, -0.5475751161575317, -0.7662704586982727, 0.8137563467025757, 0.7328915596008301, -0.8010542392730713, -0.5053715705871582, -0.13848760724067688, -0.5338042974472046, -0.04210972413420677, -0.770774781703949, -0.5805595517158508, -0.22856929898262024, -0.258062481880188, -0.36735111474990845, -0.051942866295576096, -0.03428402543067932, 0.6359745860099792, 0.36377593874931335, 0.9775822758674622, -0.2701288163661957, -0.42141810059547424, -0.7187727093696594, 0.19540536403656006, -1.0299241542816162, -0.10161420702934265, -0.5302886366844177, 0.17920203506946564, -0.3718269169330597, -0.9633023738861084, -0.00712260976433754, 0.3877819776535034, 0.13168369233608246, 0.09486164897680283, 0.029236212372779846, -0.23993684351444244, 0.30437272787094116, 0.23850247263908386, -0.5190858244895935, -0.22038838267326355, -0.2866918444633484, 0.49845942854881287, -0.3791099488735199, -0.059914056211709976, 0.6163032650947571, 0.008736150339245796, 0.7030012011528015, -0.017352977767586708, 0.14230847358703613, 0.5534998774528503, 0.34507086873054504, -0.36074501276016235, 0.6887116432189941, -0.02063125930726528, 0.448089063167572, 0.3857313394546509, -1.21930730342865, -0.4810165762901306, 0.44058889150619507, 0.5721414685249329, 0.8251330256462097, 0.7247260808944702, 0.008652267046272755, 0.2769981026649475, 0.35409167408943176, 0.5200046300888062, 0.442182332277298, 0.8299437165260315, 0.1957172453403473, 0.9066910147666931, -0.23076654970645905, -0.18407931923866272, 0.396634042263031, -0.42655906081199646, -0.4597145915031433, 0.07123587280511856, -0.13690882921218872, 0.25292521715164185, -0.22449786961078644, 0.31984028220176697, -0.6531267166137695, -0.25487837195396423, -0.6338465809822083, 0.052475687116384506, 0.23314513266086578, 0.15807507932186127, 0.3187273442745209, 0.9103863835334778, 0.8975131511688232, -0.123210608959198, 0.4254299998283386, 0.4384310841560364, 0.06447093933820724, 0.6841421127319336, -0.38429537415504456, 0.7354166507720947, 0.39641115069389343, 0.3674776554107666, 0.19472207129001617, 0.017863573506474495, 0.2692948579788208, 0.35898447036743164, -1.3940043449401855, -0.33718806505203247, -0.6039689779281616, -0.43287184834480286, -0.08027062565088272, -0.6345180869102478, 0.28438645601272583, -0.23052310943603516, 0.5743944048881531, 0.9758930802345276, -0.30801308155059814, 0.5650201439857483, 0.7893680930137634, -0.017317811027169228, 0.05120475962758064, 1.0581930875778198, -0.15513142943382263, -0.3368246555328369, 0.9401024580001831, 1.1973034143447876, -0.6046942472457886, 0.24435387551784515, 0.19371463358402252, -0.3082953095436096, 0.5940134525299072, 0.22503015398979187, -0.5110349655151367, 0.6833077073097229, -0.30862361192703247, -0.07173102349042892, 0.12739335000514984, 0.2617609202861786, -0.07535429298877716, -0.33702948689460754, 0.16271017491817474, 0.31744450330734253, -0.3281596004962921, -0.015373623929917812, 1.0853550434112549, 0.49017009139060974, -0.32702240347862244, -1.0547274351119995, -0.21501079201698303, -0.002230897080153227, 0.10916561633348465, -0.8682507872581482, 0.5377441048622131, 0.19214175641536713, -0.16969367861747742, 0.04246102645993233, -0.4657484292984009, -0.29981863498687744, -1.3867073059082031, -0.12606146931648254, -0.6071138978004456, -0.11986657977104187, -0.00008762063225731254, 0.6512167453765869, 0.20426423847675323, -0.6991317272186279, -0.08286556601524353, 0.2118791937828064, 0.8825580477714539, -0.26427170634269714, 0.15529057383537292, 0.17519201338291168, 0.07747799903154373, -0.5365618467330933, 0.6803025007247925, 0.7962990403175354, -1.0686054229736328, 1.084395170211792, -0.5801811814308167, 0.7519598603248596, 0.1402997225522995, -0.00802636332809925, -0.09054642170667648, 0.4014437198638916, 0.056457679718732834, -0.36990347504615784, -0.09107925742864609, -0.5899661183357239, -0.7670471668243408, 0.15041925013065338, -0.7938989400863647, 0.18752586841583252, -0.09577348083257675, 0.23926980793476105, -0.15630795061588287, -0.6920470595359802, 4.209671974182129, 1.3842138051986694, 0.5771698355674744, 0.02002805285155773, 0.7172139286994934, 0.896476149559021, -0.10795506834983826, -0.6485542058944702, -0.15301989018917084, -0.6819226145744324, -0.3502117097377777, -0.11167564243078232, 0.19065554440021515, -0.0854090079665184, -0.3866949677467346, 1.0163977146148682, -0.4269849956035614, 0.15447969734668732, -0.08886096626520157, -0.9950640797615051, -0.8267402052879333, -0.0486016683280468, 0.5599960088729858, -0.007215889636427164, -0.13626572489738464, 0.23599736392498016, 0.48988816142082214, -0.6545119881629944, -0.03346215933561325, -0.3886382579803467, -0.8995922207832336, -0.7640129327774048, 0.24390071630477905, -0.10770438611507416, -0.4769827723503113, -0.12932443618774414, -0.3148738741874695, -0.2815266251564026, -0.2233225703239441, 0.13800795376300812, -0.04953997582197189, -0.422711044549942, 0.22966651618480682, -0.4919331669807434, -0.71856689453125, 0.9053217172622681, -0.5774102807044983, 0.9402543902397156, 0.2783280313014984, -0.5764283537864685, 0.770027220249176, -0.19304171204566956, 0.13806219398975372, -0.6359325051307678, -0.7375587821006775, 0.3379291892051697, -0.34370800852775574, 0.3271419405937195, 0.32031527161598206, -0.011219068430364132, 0.1514134258031845, -0.10005485266447067, -0.08087204396724701, 0.1502353399991989, 0.064867302775383, 0.7916074395179749, 0.5270164608955383, 0.3787057399749756, 0.12668107450008392, 0.14996252954006195, -0.6002071499824524, -0.7179213762283325, -0.6868103742599487, -0.16461583971977234, 0.21739962697029114, -0.07728210836648941, -0.2113921195268631, 0.3335578441619873, 0.05656396970152855, 0.1826099306344986, 0.21278512477874756, -0.02877202257514, 0.11915003508329391, 0.23102818429470062, -0.30487027764320374, 1.1057792901992798, -0.1877836287021637, -0.09208813309669495, -0.09613307565450668, 0.5144470930099487, 0.6261317729949951, 1.105667233467102, 0.24647672474384308, -0.17640787363052368, -0.9012547731399536 ]
On Models with Inverse-Square Exchange
A one-dimensional quantum N-body system of either fermions or bosons with $SU(n)$ colors interacting via inverse-square exchange is presented in this article. A class of eigenstates of both the continuum and lattice version of the model Hamiltonians is constructed in terms of the Jastrow-product type wave function. The class of states we construct in this paper corresponds to the ground state and the low energy excitations of the model that can be described by the effective harmonic fluid Hamiltonian. By expanding the energy about the ground state we find the harmonic fluid parameters (i.e. the charge, spin velocities, etc.), explicitly. The correlation exponent and the compressibility of are also found. As expected the general harmonic relation(i.e. $v_S=(v_Nv_J)^{1/2}$) is satisfied among the charge and spin velocities.
Z.N.C. Ha and F.D.M. Haldane
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204017
cond-mat/9204018
[ -0.08262161165475845, 0.5477249026298523, -0.20664715766906738, 0.36305034160614014, 0.0014206282794475555, 0.0358864963054657, 0.38878414034843445, -0.5679710507392883, -0.591856837272644, 1.5685449838638306, 0.4749188721179962, -0.2515430152416229, 0.37010979652404785, -1.107655644416809, -0.45816752314567566, 0.22607657313346863, -0.2612234950065613, -0.5207046866416931, -1.6721735000610352, 0.2756500840187073, -0.2755313217639923, -0.27980831265449524, -0.49273747205734253, -1.1093765497207642, -0.3020215928554535, 0.7017041444778442, 0.005229478236287832, -0.12653131783008575, 0.6593887805938721, 0.6705793142318726, 0.39084726572036743, -1.0240545272827148, -0.1022946834564209, -0.967749297618866, -0.4098656475543976, 0.18330974876880646, -0.32076045870780945, -0.5236883759498596, 0.5571746230125427, -0.4456300139427185, 0.4997998774051666, -0.08637525141239166, 0.29501232504844666, -0.17281793057918549, 0.22703123092651367, -0.24515709280967712, -1.0351452827453613, -0.5934833884239197, -0.24451252818107605, -0.9729610681533813, 0.8691532611846924, 0.7933116555213928, 0.18833857774734497, -0.002298163715749979, -0.15187424421310425, -0.01281001977622509, 0.05875243619084358, -0.2516217827796936, -0.38050615787506104, 0.18880783021450043, 0.6577458381652832, -0.05721825733780861, 0.768729031085968, -0.5185914039611816, -0.1884133517742157, 1.0053273439407349, -0.30954277515411377, 1.2028601169586182, -0.1397228240966797, 0.03525128588080406, -0.28561821579933167, 0.08528713136911392, 0.6863517761230469, -0.15548467636108398, -0.7365022301673889, 0.06513523310422897, 0.13701876997947693, -0.2987353205680847, -0.7754139304161072, -0.20820842683315277, -0.38616445660591125, -0.16535769402980804, -0.34975776076316833, 0.13732776045799255, 0.009982465766370296, -0.4589487910270691, -0.8296380043029785, 0.0022406443022191525, 0.4182378947734833, 0.9069651365280151, 1.0113991498947144, 1.1645005941390991, -0.08430328965187073, -0.24554084241390228, 0.45236292481422424, 0.6942415237426758, -0.21562664210796356, 0.367010235786438, 0.4389386773109436, 0.3434326946735382, 0.22682926058769226, 0.848075270652771, -0.2820311486721039, 0.7302830815315247, -0.4623439610004425, 0.4498262107372284, -0.01669909991323948, 0.20157073438167572, -0.03032636269927025, -1.132951259613037, -0.00016058090841397643, 0.3397756516933441, 0.08448942005634308, 0.574456512928009, -0.14363940060138702, 0.7268561124801636, 0.3213880658149719, -0.09045980125665665, -0.4215257167816162, -0.2088913768529892, -0.25643521547317505, 0.16790489852428436, 0.25850313901901245, -0.04911336675286293, -0.4383748471736908, -0.20835375785827637, 0.17539507150650024, 0.30128246545791626, -0.12011341005563736, 0.24152399599552155, -0.01672080159187317, 0.07246227562427521, -0.32187753915786743, 0.48650550842285156, 0.039395932108163834, 0.6598109006881714, -0.2123262882232666, 0.24064010381698608, 0.3778206408023834, 0.0008695439319126308, 0.20026898384094238, -0.9475014805793762, -0.14137035608291626, 0.6341263055801392, -0.32616472244262695, 0.5585949420928955, 0.6588360071182251, -0.19757694005966187, 0.6037300825119019, 0.48607608675956726, -0.7564016580581665, -0.23796355724334717, -0.20460519194602966, -0.06306999921798706, 0.13621190190315247, -0.059699803590774536, -0.7168241143226624, 0.5704823732376099, -0.8151127099990845, -0.21079899370670319, 0.6408648490905762, 0.2947981357574463, 0.1359083652496338, -0.0275112371891737, -0.9303018450737, -0.5317592620849609, -0.17572906613349915, -0.9807345867156982, 0.2424297034740448, -0.3522520661354065, -0.2962445616722107, 0.4347243010997772, 0.03227781876921654, 0.5787019729614258, 0.05070604011416435, 0.311775803565979, 0.47007042169570923, -0.12770195305347443, -0.41105058789253235, 0.09198203682899475, -0.16157783567905426, -0.25036531686782837, 1.015718936920166, 0.5267534255981445, 0.07296018302440643, -0.47398850321769714, -0.07063652575016022, -0.22944995760917664, 0.29458269476890564, 0.42081326246261597, -0.09233219921588898, 0.2831055521965027, 0.22098760306835175, 0.27125030755996704, -1.0106067657470703, -0.31787949800491333, -0.5791725516319275, -0.06590478122234344, -0.21683387458324432, -0.6308124661445618, 0.13753566145896912, 0.03892206400632858, -1.1342499256134033, 0.4705342948436737, -1.7052503824234009, 0.12930049002170563, 0.8178986310958862, 0.6590253710746765, -0.00039108225610107183, 0.20825481414794922, 0.27147310972213745, -0.44957879185676575, -0.29076093435287476, 0.14895978569984436, 0.38068917393684387, 0.2587413489818573, -0.4509340226650238, 0.14851610362529755, 0.493762731552124, 0.08798304945230484, 0.7079944014549255, -0.5193338394165039, -0.3284185826778412, 0.313326358795166, 0.16295932233333588, -0.06667067110538483, -0.090388722717762, 0.5236877799034119, 0.5505043268203735, 0.12981069087982178, -0.3698684573173523, 0.26906126737594604, -0.6693600416183472, 0.6214183568954468, 0.9402416944503784, 0.2948140799999237, -0.03414717689156532, 0.6890605688095093, 0.5266119837760925, -0.3148806095123291, -0.03212333470582962, 0.14066024124622345, 0.7935879230499268, 0.3585590720176697, -0.4625140130519867, -0.2647419571876526, -0.07532521337270737, 0.01627408154308796, -0.659529447555542, 0.3240337371826172, -0.9090452194213867, 0.37943577766418457, 0.0649157240986824, 0.17579881846904755, -0.14984208345413208, 0.1642175018787384, 0.5390769839286804, 0.39251819252967834, -0.3161998987197876, -0.7414170503616333, 0.965056836605072, 0.0854046568274498, -0.08092755079269409, -0.2797514498233795, -0.13218964636325836, 0.8365234136581421, -0.455877423286438, -0.109492227435112, -0.12155089527368546, -0.48076003789901733, -1.0566946268081665, 0.021947937086224556, -0.5326954126358032, -0.5748371481895447, -0.3941631615161896, 0.1381559818983078, 0.797764003276825, -0.8448594212532043, 1.2204091548919678, -0.4819490313529968, 0.16539227962493896, 0.2804435193538666, -0.5401289463043213, 0.2529332637786865, -0.45392683148384094, 0.670996367931366, -0.6578655242919922, 0.5588873028755188, -1.2475069761276245, 0.5015653967857361, -0.7366161346435547, -0.06509306281805038, 0.7636277675628662, -0.6542208194732666, -0.23495782911777496, 0.4001780152320862, -0.044893424957990646, -0.2517738938331604, -0.6410515904426575, -0.20919011533260345, -0.3465491235256195, 0.3437829613685608, -0.5454148650169373, -0.39739638566970825, -0.641657292842865, 0.7211456298828125, -0.5006742477416992, -0.3057986795902252, 0.5596232414245605, 0.34528446197509766, -0.9026487469673157, 0.6995923519134521, -0.33171942830085754, -0.2394576221704483, 0.018118975684046745, 0.8673639297485352, 1.3532860279083252, 0.16114665567874908, 0.23490776121616364, -0.384305864572525, -0.2791529595851898, 0.18255500495433807, 0.08499330282211304, -0.8560490012168884, -0.07661072909832001, 0.36712104082107544, 0.18815015256404877, -0.18701781332492828, 0.3297367990016937, -1.2974915504455566, -0.5692892670631409, -0.1493193507194519, 0.27847883105278015, 0.9139715433120728, -0.28681936860084534, -0.33946970105171204, -0.4373481869697571, -0.39550307393074036, 0.6760217547416687, 0.5622588992118835, 0.4470631778240204, -0.009422273375093937, 0.4917812943458557, -0.3128252625465393, -0.17413337528705597, 0.028096606954932213, -0.009798896498978138, -0.4893660545349121, -0.9509139060974121, -0.0366828590631485, -1.1768327951431274, -0.02433105744421482, 0.409494012594223, 0.1938428282737732, 0.16253060102462769, 0.4212764501571655, -0.7514262795448303, -0.18971887230873108, -0.667345404624939, -0.04581405967473984, 0.2874402105808258, 0.7895058989524841, -0.11410564929246902, -0.27076786756515503, -0.7031940221786499, -0.28520503640174866, 0.3449552059173584, -0.14123977720737457, 0.41785600781440735, -0.21060775220394135, 0.47261545062065125, 0.19344472885131836, -0.11357974261045456, -0.02954890951514244, 0.20922130346298218, 0.5793497562408447, 0.6733497977256775, 0.055419694632291794, 0.7617968320846558, -0.6661093235015869, -0.19172585010528564, -0.35351791977882385, 1.5072951316833496, 0.2990812659263611, 0.13110189139842987, 0.1804308146238327, -0.16700272262096405, -0.16802559792995453, -0.07664591819047928, -0.44475629925727844, -0.4655148386955261, -0.18640516698360443, -0.5157665014266968, -0.35382479429244995, 0.24153856933116913, 0.20802664756774902, 0.7305628657341003, 0.14675773680210114, -0.003782813437283039, 0.16918867826461792, 0.7228840589523315, 0.3698265552520752, 0.7629325985908508, -0.24353700876235962, -0.20252133905887604, -0.04098466783761978, -0.6572949290275574, -0.06778714805841446, 0.002530941739678383, 0.569657027721405, -0.10848569124937057, -0.45073315501213074, -0.3818088471889496, 0.047664470970630646, 0.42248088121414185, 0.11503054201602936, -0.3004772663116455, 0.5743136405944824, 0.46575814485549927, 0.33304330706596375, -1.1036591529846191, 0.44481930136680603, 0.5712205171585083, 0.6611340045928955, 0.7186740040779114, -0.5863747596740723, 0.5072320103645325, -0.7382331490516663, 0.40965619683265686, 0.2187977284193039, -0.43083655834198, -0.48029759526252747, 0.34028881788253784, 0.6834266185760498, -0.6881101727485657, -0.020432116463780403, 0.8914767503738403, 0.5296753644943237, -0.03540943190455437, -0.07621541619300842, -0.21689815819263458, 0.5122334361076355, -1.0003925561904907, -0.49273350834846497, -0.24006642401218414, -0.4590950608253479, -0.8811899423599243, -0.024242166429758072, -0.1932799518108368, -0.018556227907538414, 0.020057931542396545, -0.060754310339689255, 0.8496679067611694, -0.3383249044418335, -0.420491099357605, -0.3032516837120056, -0.13320881128311157, -0.35165002942085266, 0.575532078742981, 0.7521975040435791, -0.48859113454818726, -0.22338621318340302, -0.2626761496067047, -0.505618155002594, -0.7019578814506531, -0.07253069430589676, -0.48642295598983765, 1.143207311630249, 0.7694622278213501, 0.16260646283626556, 0.6958858370780945, 0.40026217699050903, -0.5400797128677368, 0.15891782939434052, 0.39639443159103394, 0.29238611459732056, -0.36148974299430847, 0.10200240463018417, -0.3650937080383301, -0.7899027466773987, 0.06696280092000961, 0.6564406752586365, -0.40349045395851135, 0.6438706517219543, -0.22654910385608673, -0.5164307951927185, -0.36160147190093994, -0.25617289543151855, -0.12665899097919464, 0.6672527194023132, -0.4725167453289032, -0.16305916011333466, 0.15844091773033142, -1.0972442626953125, -0.5637431740760803, -0.2551424503326416, 0.06671018153429031, -0.476407527923584, 0.40984106063842773, -0.11974143981933594, 0.19785113632678986, -0.16397511959075928, -0.8628606200218201, 0.9032986164093018, -0.026697613298892975, -0.0012825868325307965, 0.16337154805660248, -0.6169781684875488, -0.027418890967965126, -0.06819213926792145, 0.6377764344215393, -0.27464812994003296, -0.0928666815161705, 0.4882000684738159, -0.1771525889635086, -0.14635807275772095, 0.07244759052991867, 0.2590404450893402, -0.439951628446579, 0.7265496253967285, 0.1343482881784439, -0.6044021248817444, 0.07719298452138901, 0.45880749821662903, 0.08782334625720978, 0.6589910984039307, 0.23265673220157623, -0.789775550365448, 0.19338077306747437, 0.0010101012885570526, 0.7976560592651367, -0.5115291476249695, -0.32081592082977295, -0.4968675374984741, -0.40827804803848267, -0.0504133366048336, 0.5479753613471985, -0.5444933176040649, -0.2369709461927414, -0.12812352180480957, -0.017437592148780823, -0.37897634506225586, -0.8160175085067749, 0.23838616907596588, -0.6451697945594788, -1.2636871337890625, -0.9325624108314514, 0.7084713578224182, -0.2532922923564911, 0.0495431125164032, 0.4935415983200073, -0.39462244510650635, -0.39561179280281067, 0.4520692825317383, 0.16909708082675934, -0.986039400100708, -0.8681599497795105, 0.7351754307746887, -0.6146205067634583, -0.17589639127254486, -0.6618863344192505, 0.6441996693611145, -0.6112572550773621, 0.8406489491462708, -0.2701832354068756, -0.660365641117096, 0.1639520823955536, -0.08643143624067307, 0.4073133170604706, -0.7807758450508118, 0.564596951007843, 0.3052956461906433, 0.3890635371208191, 0.6395067572593689, 0.016004739329218864, -0.09312789142131805, -0.5219250321388245, -0.9226598143577576, -0.8487675189971924, 0.3783971667289734, 0.02511877380311489, 0.20176725089550018, -0.5048892498016357, -0.5314626097679138, -0.34054046869277954, -0.5708165168762207, 0.056072209030389786, 0.26048460602760315, 0.2392279952764511, 0.412657767534256, -0.4245063066482544, 0.4734500050544739, -0.00466934684664011, 0.43234536051750183, 0.15317195653915405, -0.5586886405944824, -0.09610568732023239, 0.12918023765087128, -0.12827491760253906, -0.6272414922714233, -0.0592125840485096, 0.2563517987728119, 0.4536629319190979, 0.1817934811115265, 0.5582438707351685, -0.13248389959335327, -0.3735825717449188, -0.29035207629203796, 0.15556564927101135, 0.09490690380334854, 0.7954796552658081, 0.4768112897872925, -0.08885637670755386, 0.3213139772415161, -0.3817999064922333, 0.5860987305641174, -0.19756625592708588, 0.3747786581516266, 0.5767138004302979, -0.7778287529945374, -0.16509072482585907, 0.3361411392688751, -0.041519660502672195, -0.6610513925552368, -0.9642206430435181, -1.0151739120483398, -0.2960682511329651, 0.3907551169395447, -0.637461245059967, 0.13245804607868195, -0.27039635181427, -0.6577052474021912, 0.07716896384954453, 0.49701613187789917, 0.13999269902706146, 0.41714194416999817, 0.09609387069940567, -0.5808507204055786, -0.3608413636684418, -0.4052349030971527, 0.8368098139762878, -0.15336522459983826, -0.7771092057228088, -0.440785676240921, -0.477047324180603, -0.734343945980072, 0.16446468234062195, 0.6151926517486572, 0.7027459740638733, 1.0084601640701294, 0.295014351606369, -0.04913293942809105, 0.6349328756332397, 0.8476131558418274, -0.2024877518415451, 0.023918909952044487, 0.11404605209827423, -0.8073087930679321, -0.22822101414203644, -0.2661954462528229, 0.47374799847602844, 0.12773685157299042, -0.17506012320518494, 0.032293692231178284, 0.22474735975265503, -0.29932448267936707, -0.6147789359092712, -0.5244802832603455, 0.1532335728406906, -1.2631815671920776, -0.09510938078165054, -0.14814147353172302, -0.5639992356300354, -0.3626401424407959, 0.8128778338432312, -0.619361162185669, 0.025443166494369507, -0.6014818549156189, 0.11045406013727188, 0.8950278162956238, -0.07032391428947449, 0.35937753319740295, -0.8391878604888916, -0.8727935552597046, -0.3460415303707123, -0.3499962389469147, -0.0667237713932991, -0.4177494943141937, -0.09530219435691833, -0.3245665729045868, -0.04334517568349838, -0.4309583604335785, 0.8477450013160706, -0.3774755597114563, -0.9459918737411499, 0.020253334194421768, 0.3945431411266327, -0.26077860593795776, 0.6101152896881104, 0.3147115409374237, 0.1325569599866867, 0.17815932631492615, -0.3136385977268219, 0.19260753691196442, 0.16932722926139832, -1.2528713941574097, 0.5495721101760864, 0.21252672374248505, 0.27433907985687256, -0.0015427990583702922, -0.6219682097434998, 0.1369168758392334, 0.9598302245140076, -0.5205571055412292, 0.05137044936418533, -0.32468825578689575, 0.7467920184135437, 0.023690439760684967, -0.270122230052948, -0.36370694637298584, -0.6222724914550781, 0.18062840402126312, 1.0033828020095825, -0.33846402168273926, -0.7886291742324829, -0.2646629512310028, 0.16213998198509216, -0.3364829421043396, 0.4559727609157562, 0.1351625770330429, -0.3921436667442322, 0.47683605551719666, 0.7239896655082703, -0.4544776380062103, 0.6200687289237976, -0.1438949853181839, 0.019925549626350403, -0.4162398874759674, -0.7069379091262817, -0.7000605463981628, 0.7866560220718384, 0.5523584485054016, -0.7249231934547424, 0.6058319211006165, -0.6698216795921326, -0.6267624497413635, 0.40029990673065186, -0.09805528074502945, -0.48184552788734436, -0.7011867761611938, -0.6765369772911072, -0.36355817317962646, 0.06228407472372055, -0.049913275986909866, 0.2210366427898407, -0.33328530192375183, 0.7210254073143005, 0.028603430837392807, -0.5142159461975098, -0.2972549796104431, 0.31689247488975525, -0.763454258441925, 0.4318225085735321, 0.15611258149147034, 0.7132776975631714, 0.059692855924367905, -1.0466673374176025, -0.5335292816162109, 0.4391665756702423, -0.26281511783599854, -0.3745199739933014, -0.573239803314209, -0.4121665358543396, -0.3685741126537323, 0.06921239197254181, -0.004434789530932903, -0.303148090839386, -0.2764684557914734, 0.7823477983474731, 0.522094190120697, -0.5748474597930908, 0.5493870973587036, -0.0971580296754837, -0.32560697197914124, -0.5746286511421204, -0.7966731786727905, 0.6532152891159058, -0.2263166755437851, -0.6099010109901428, 0.7900928854942322, 0.11639689654111862, 0.04592841863632202, 0.051178671419620514, -1.104605793952942, -0.30745217204093933, 0.17087122797966003, 0.9618817567825317, 0.7824339270591736, 0.2972232401371002, 0.38070303201675415, 0.4468268156051636, 0.38323163986206055, 0.2934102416038513, -0.06592453271150589, 0.5655301213264465, -0.3778502643108368, 0.4853837490081787, -0.34576329588890076, 0.6553340554237366, -0.3000999987125397, 0.4808715879917145, 0.13015681505203247, -0.2056824266910553, -0.34305980801582336, -0.05064355954527855, -0.34254133701324463, 0.6232727766036987, -0.44393521547317505, 0.0008207599748857319, -0.49573737382888794, 0.1327396035194397, 0.3871854841709137, -0.2587946355342865, -0.2777528762817383, 0.7008267641067505, 0.6175360679626465, 0.23108895123004913, 0.05433182790875435, 0.16299177706241608, 0.2327730804681778, 0.580190122127533, 0.2841903269290924, 0.7342101335525513, 0.746799111366272, 0.5552934408187866, -0.2845674455165863, -0.4008632004261017, -0.4788125455379486, 0.841851532459259, -1.065366506576538, 0.0976618304848671, -0.5531635880470276, -0.10274986177682877, 0.3804562985897064, -0.5230345726013184, 0.5358148813247681, -0.6470687389373779, -0.1444607377052307, 0.9649873971939087, -0.33089256286621094, 0.007250017952173948, 1.3319779634475708, 0.15785612165927887, 0.2530480921268463, 0.26368236541748047, -0.006988923065364361, -0.644158661365509, 1.4361815452575684, 1.5875670909881592, -0.4032970070838928, 0.008251202292740345, -0.12079371511936188, -0.4874548017978668, 0.5012296438217163, 0.7273095846176147, -0.3353508710861206, 0.40271371603012085, -0.36575332283973694, -0.08161615580320358, -0.030075756832957268, 0.3293148875236511, -0.5791636109352112, 0.3361256718635559, 0.5259850025177002, 0.3340596556663513, -0.6905770301818848, -0.2677697539329529, 1.1057543754577637, 0.24868890643119812, -0.1587800234556198, -0.8277437686920166, 0.22201129794120789, 0.2234923094511032, -0.3882480561733246, -0.319267600774765, 0.8902158737182617, 0.5554723739624023, 0.13274644315242767, -0.19745784997940063, -0.7328115105628967, -0.21390150487422943, -0.6761521697044373, -0.6281236410140991, -0.5265924334526062, 0.08542949706315994, 0.5819074511528015, 0.6374795436859131, -0.34955552220344543, -0.23230819404125214, 0.2765097916126251, -0.14739368855953217, 0.9932738542556763, 0.15174293518066406, 0.6071349382400513, 0.12158443033695221, -0.14445088803768158, -0.33474525809288025, 0.9130355715751648, 0.3997584879398346, -0.6187655329704285, 0.027009421959519386, -0.0960891842842102, 0.3310542702674866, 0.2604394257068634, -0.4877251982688904, 0.17879734933376312, 0.07301435619592667, 0.05655474215745926, -0.07243058830499649, -0.06813665479421616, 0.11708663403987885, -0.882422924041748, -0.098312146961689, -0.19432325661182404, 0.14516156911849976, 0.7059841156005859, 0.17380614578723907, 0.47382283210754395, -0.5873282551765442, 4.2640604972839355, 0.5259682536125183, 1.0533632040023804, -0.13758662343025208, 0.4273635149002075, 0.24752266705036163, -0.09121596068143845, -0.2709863483905792, 0.5631116032600403, -0.7264105677604675, -0.09327699989080429, 0.010116552002727985, -0.22358182072639465, -0.2814462184906006, 0.2913324534893036, 0.8893894553184509, 0.11111365258693695, 0.14113013446331024, -0.004199860617518425, -0.8390584588050842, -0.5527331829071045, 0.33233141899108887, -0.08106279373168945, -0.08428005874156952, 0.36984583735466003, 0.32330745458602905, -0.2495030015707016, -0.25725340843200684, -0.6356226801872253, -0.5033836364746094, -0.5371240377426147, -0.4784475266933441, -0.13621285557746887, -0.006692415103316307, -0.35989418625831604, 0.17853225767612457, 0.46655306220054626, 0.18008944392204285, -0.09993323683738708, 0.24358242750167847, 0.19168533384799957, -0.7274648547172546, 0.30427590012550354, 0.14446191489696503, -1.1070772409439087, 0.6479310393333435, -0.1348646730184555, 0.619175136089325, 0.44295620918273926, 0.036304354667663574, 0.26322662830352783, 0.10681089758872986, 0.024461407214403152, 0.9631157517433167, -0.988661527633667, 0.0035923956893384457, -0.017403943464159966, -0.33259403705596924, -0.29411861300468445, -0.09603089094161987, 0.9962339997291565, 0.08382323384284973, -0.2448156177997589, -0.5630578994750977, -0.3207499384880066, 0.35157421231269836, 0.25985631346702576, 0.7106530070304871, -0.5546529293060303, 0.2771439552307129, -0.28109943866729736, -0.46083885431289673, -0.5343074798583984, 0.2810631990432739, 0.5707658529281616, -0.04864969104528427, -0.025041725486516953, 0.24266280233860016, 0.005166103132069111, 0.22499513626098633, 0.08026964962482452, -0.06649047881364822, -0.605046808719635, 0.3161652386188507, 0.28912296891212463, 0.8945644497871399, -0.4275536835193634, -0.2701387405395508, 0.1565610021352768, 0.5824480652809143, 0.5543928742408752, 1.5269289016723633, 0.32431483268737793, -0.5251728892326355, -1.02176833152771 ]
Absence of Dipole Transitions in Vortices of Type II Superconductors
The response of a single vortex to a time dependent field is examined microscopically and an equation of motion for vortex motion at non-zero frequencies is derived. Of interest are frequencies near $\Delta^{2}/E_{F}$, where $\Delta$ is the bulk energy gap and $E_{F}$ is the fermi energy. The low temperature, clean, extreme type II limit and maintaining of equilibrium with the lattice are assumed. A simplification occurs for large planar mass anisotropy. Thus the results may be pertinent to materials such as $NbSe_2$ and high temperature superconductors. The expected dipole transition between core states is hidden because of the self consistent nature of the vortex potential. Instead the vortex itself moves and has a resonance at the frequency of the transition.
Theodore C. Hsu (CRTBT-CNRS, Grenoble France)
cond-mat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9204018
cond-mat/9205001
[ 0.5102449655532837, 0.3455994427204132, 0.4837626516819, 0.6614750027656555, -0.23959028720855713, -0.04877643659710884, -0.09588887542486191, -0.5406497120857239, -1.139839768409729, 1.4498391151428223, -0.32783809304237366, -0.2431892603635788, 0.2100682407617569, -0.8752727508544922, -0.17642897367477417, -0.06078546494245529, 0.060654960572719574, 0.062632255256176, -0.827536404132843, -0.3186001777648926, -0.5614376664161682, 0.14624269306659698, -0.757715106010437, -0.3953181505203247, -1.0165271759033203, 0.10513325035572052, 0.5235597491264343, 0.34286031126976013, 0.8840397000312805, 0.8661555647850037, 0.519691526889801, -0.3068843185901642, 0.21391019225120544, -0.8500546216964722, 0.1397615373134613, -0.03820830211043358, 0.09835932403802872, -0.09947559237480164, 0.21221230924129486, -1.0506054162979126, 1.0339632034301758, -0.19543571770191193, -0.12275343388319016, -0.24689553678035736, 0.09598556905984879, 0.02566806599497795, -0.03083868697285652, -0.4335414469242096, -0.33704498410224915, -1.6444765329360962, 0.17586350440979004, 0.2317090481519699, -0.2121092826128006, 0.008202487602829933, 0.42309683561325073, -0.11203957349061966, -0.8487133979797363, -0.2815215587615967, -0.33297210931777954, 0.4518783986568451, 0.7076557874679565, -0.6636707782745361, 0.9489205479621887, -0.406528115272522, 0.4583679139614105, 0.5998492240905762, -0.11890356987714767, 1.4609688520431519, -0.17535939812660217, 0.6083641052246094, 0.02793460339307785, 0.16686788201332092, -0.04797555133700371, -0.348808228969574, -0.8544324636459351, 0.7039133906364441, 0.12723886966705322, -0.5407664179801941, -0.3662068545818329, -0.4563251733779907, 0.2890452444553375, -0.596981406211853, -0.32377082109451294, 0.515448808670044, -0.18203119933605194, -0.5785070061683655, -0.10160355269908905, -0.35859259963035583, -0.2296265959739685, 0.5167877078056335, 0.48464909195899963, 1.0175944566726685, 0.5634893774986267, 0.40225324034690857, 0.40923380851745605, 0.4672565758228302, 0.23058860003948212, 0.03140127286314964, 0.06436195224523544, 0.28019091486930847, 0.32281458377838135, 1.0297889709472656, -0.3911897540092468, 0.9835935831069946, -0.5545841455459595, 0.3833635449409485, 0.36131659150123596, 0.4425405263900757, 0.29253193736076355, -0.5270402431488037, -0.25865796208381653, 0.7713906764984131, -0.08054251968860626, 0.496362566947937, -0.3226597309112549, 0.5635396838188171, 0.701610267162323, -0.3825283348560333, -0.5237471461296082, -0.031116580590605736, 0.11960051208734512, -0.31875213980674744, 0.5012649893760681, 0.8743234872817993, -0.8358481526374817, -0.43346574902534485, -0.5168565511703491, 0.20451906323432922, 0.6969864964485168, -0.8836517930030823, -0.2829448878765106, -0.210036501288414, -0.46140798926353455, 0.7802796363830566, -0.5463432669639587, 0.7658302187919617, 0.2919972836971283, 0.323589026927948, 0.29439592361450195, -0.04290661960840225, 0.3295440375804901, -0.8438061475753784, 0.40307292342185974, 0.953414261341095, -0.3236016035079956, 0.5997578501701355, 0.23545418679714203, 0.39201733469963074, -0.7494542002677917, -0.45175108313560486, -1.117540717124939, -0.04309491068124771, -0.38867515325546265, 0.2335646152496338, 0.09247928112745285, -0.1958020180463791, -0.24055908620357513, 0.09551036357879639, -0.9015579223632812, 0.003109192941337824, 0.22576509416103363, 0.41120976209640503, 0.238753080368042, 0.05438382178544998, 0.06351323425769806, -0.03840569034218788, -0.8009924292564392, -0.959426760673523, 0.4763994514942169, -0.980336606502533, 0.14992953836917877, 0.024652395397424698, -0.10366459935903549, 0.3554728031158447, 0.2394944578409195, 0.3675861358642578, 0.4255114197731018, 0.09949227422475815, 0.10745542496442795, 0.37514665722846985, -0.003646272700279951, 0.16233766078948975, 0.36131417751312256, 0.6491391658782959, 0.564911961555481, 0.15512429177761078, -0.2662513554096222, 0.11424080282449722, 0.2578764855861664, 0.11147724092006683, 0.5749685764312744, 0.9171561002731323, -0.9984477758407593, 0.39747315645217896, -0.22185967862606049, 0.03214220702648163, -0.8052617907524109, 0.3484431803226471, -0.14031274616718292, -0.822903037071228, 0.14505690336227417, 0.2979756295681, -1.263657808303833, 0.7856733202934265, -0.9920071959495544, 0.05810306966304779, 1.1788796186447144, 0.3014310598373413, -0.5693148970603943, -0.1438005566596985, 0.26302570104599, 0.19465044140815735, 0.06638273596763611, 0.4648931622505188, 0.3878922760486603, -0.006976438220590353, -0.16266168653964996, 0.3969811201095581, 0.1603502780199051, 0.1608903706073761, 0.08767786622047424, 0.010330106131732464, 0.1996336579322815, 0.7220743894577026, -0.0802595242857933, -0.7728838920593262, 0.16306725144386292, 0.33090323209762573, 0.4050526022911072, -0.04880316182971001, -0.25375717878341675, 1.050762414932251, -0.815980076789856, 0.24133379757404327, 1.0616813898086548, -0.16707751154899597, 0.008773359470069408, 0.4179137051105499, -0.052085019648075104, -0.17384541034698486, 0.089877650141716, -0.18694330751895905, 0.26213106513023376, -0.18304306268692017, -0.002300440100952983, 0.2709079384803772, -0.5591264367103577, 0.01589234359562397, -0.713081955909729, 0.03759356960654259, -0.5268135070800781, 0.401079386472702, 0.6750869154930115, -0.08810662478208542, -0.8112073540687561, 0.04262353852391243, 0.5290102958679199, 0.9475534558296204, -0.26475799083709717, -0.2957417964935303, -0.4987824559211731, 0.4317881762981415, -1.0291199684143066, -0.21811768412590027, 0.6050286293029785, 0.8966703414916992, -0.4351430833339691, 0.09467018395662308, 0.41511279344558716, -0.5333333015441895, -1.2642537355422974, -0.8251518607139587, -1.0848842859268188, 0.28733280301094055, -0.9127969145774841, -0.4865871071815491, 0.7699300050735474, 0.05020303651690483, 0.6817688941955566, -0.4696931838989258, 0.23094657063484192, 0.09280825406312943, 0.17342770099639893, 0.46729519963264465, 0.22727294266223907, -0.2737561762332916, -0.6958985328674316, 0.6118407845497131, -0.3565322756767273, 0.3597973585128784, -0.009029136039316654, -0.4876803755760193, -0.5123410820960999, -0.8876171112060547, -0.19212931394577026, 0.01408530306071043, 0.5434466600418091, 0.7364439368247986, 0.23683251440525055, -0.32318586111068726, -0.8758618831634521, -0.19293780624866486, -0.15415479242801666, -0.9837237000465393, -0.3057641088962555, -0.2950229048728943, 0.13840363919734955, -0.8114784359931946, 0.4981602728366852, -0.012729130685329437, -0.9301404356956482, 0.5929359197616577, -0.3200947940349579, 0.365047425031662, -0.007431612350046635, 1.3582819700241089, 0.8063027858734131, 0.14907817542552948, 0.6278685927391052, -0.5336383581161499, -0.1612931787967682, 0.19463340938091278, 0.6125446557998657, -1.1785917282104492, 0.2016386091709137, 0.39055562019348145, 0.17346002161502838, -0.09208826720714569, 0.06516783684492111, -0.9374094605445862, -0.18156839907169342, -0.08340820670127869, -0.21081145107746124, 0.3412596881389618, -0.16727742552757263, -0.5537925362586975, -0.1389702409505844, -0.12050756812095642, 0.7207985520362854, -0.20616909861564636, 0.16819585859775543, -1.2227892875671387, 0.39275801181793213, 0.6208522915840149, 0.7025483846664429, -0.5518118739128113, 0.7058035135269165, -0.7252169847488403, -0.6049056649208069, -0.14303474128246307, -0.471045583486557, -0.19973202049732208, 0.5595629215240479, 0.2996699810028076, 0.25997817516326904, 0.4674737751483917, -0.30101069808006287, 0.0798410177230835, -0.23156443238258362, 0.25837215781211853, -0.2899675667285919, 0.47132593393325806, 0.16246265172958374, 0.6002662777900696, -1.2211112976074219, -0.149667426943779, 0.7324042320251465, -0.6391844153404236, 1.0906065702438354, -0.9281963109970093, 0.35179147124290466, 0.08855253458023071, -0.3162553906440735, 0.5382052659988403, -0.3701447546482086, 0.6700725555419922, 0.08732789009809494, 0.6517084836959839, 0.5365496277809143, -0.28633183240890503, -1.109138011932373, -0.1442873775959015, 0.1928359568119049, 0.50958651304245, 0.2524458169937134, 0.8984447717666626, -0.10553394258022308, 0.4245241582393646, -0.2724314332008362, -0.8034322261810303, 0.4695093035697937, -0.3207927644252777, -0.5589683055877686, -0.7840688824653625, -0.0090409554541111, 0.13821303844451904, 0.48213687539100647, -0.6754753589630127, -0.3638250231742859, -0.19791607558727264, 0.43029555678367615, -0.22797581553459167, 0.8410412073135376, 0.3953569531440735, -0.10046335309743881, -0.1480555236339569, -0.5617545247077942, 0.1449599713087082, -0.5542442202568054, 0.13343118131160736, -0.4571051001548767, -0.9855217337608337, -0.291664719581604, -0.08693334460258484, 0.5394028425216675, 0.19959977269172668, -0.3451670706272125, 0.39292535185813904, 0.3626212477684021, 0.7681969404220581, 0.01753302477300167, -0.028097718954086304, -0.03823239356279373, 0.3987152874469757, 0.018937768414616585, -1.366995096206665, 0.6056898236274719, -0.6112127304077148, 0.5618560910224915, 0.5251686573028564, -0.49692782759666443, -0.6402488350868225, -0.3337022662162781, 0.8259806036949158, -0.8793209791183472, 0.28624337911605835, 0.8534297347068787, 0.4360472857952118, -0.014272875152528286, -0.31780898571014404, -0.06286203116178513, -0.1943833976984024, -0.36925873160362244, -0.4070649743080139, -0.1567719280719757, -0.01377776637673378, 0.19720816612243652, 0.1696111261844635, -0.143208846449852, -0.2514320909976959, -0.28141340613365173, -0.6003606915473938, 0.4036185145378113, -0.21425481140613556, -0.3322514295578003, 0.37661072611808777, -0.2204340398311615, 0.14619646966457367, 1.1925681829452515, 0.13036677241325378, -0.7151623368263245, -0.14365226030349731, -0.12005767971277237, -0.20523712038993835, -0.8928239941596985, -0.08773548156023026, -0.3794984817504883, 0.09073378890752792, -0.09794418513774872, 0.2916291654109955, 0.032180748879909515, 0.06554803997278214, -0.18190990388393402, -0.45497187972068787, 0.47737428545951843, -0.16749410331249237, 0.13962672650814056, -0.7555254697799683, 0.006490663625299931, -0.4102124869823456, -0.3192864656448364, 0.5575766563415527, 0.3393128216266632, 0.3936547338962555, -0.337240606546402, -0.5818833708763123, 0.05599341168999672, -0.2257634401321411, -0.6050258278846741, 0.5282762050628662, -0.014863586984574795, -0.6465244889259338, -0.11406603455543518, 0.02670496329665184, -0.128132626414299, 0.16512884199619293, -0.15520504117012024, -0.01731681078672409, 0.9059690833091736, -0.12389370054006577, -0.361795037984848, 0.03522500768303871, 0.013689613901078701, 0.6027281880378723, -0.451620876789093, -0.019588977098464966, -0.48359301686286926, -0.7252328991889954, -0.20878827571868896, -0.1837674081325531, 0.35562145709991455, -0.3031997084617615, 0.42408421635627747, -0.22289742529392242, -0.11492205411195755, 0.6140720248222351, -0.03338198363780975, 0.6109997034072876, -0.20206889510154724, 1.4316545724868774, -0.29083606600761414, -0.9122568368911743, -0.1344587802886963, 0.5360196828842163, -0.08381760120391846, 0.41604992747306824, 0.599111020565033, -1.2677727937698364, -0.16067925095558167, 0.4378645420074463, 0.954211950302124, -0.5659059286117554, 0.05453572794795036, -0.3995599150657654, 0.3642469644546509, -0.5390129089355469, 0.4423486292362213, 0.757942795753479, 0.37337514758110046, -0.1596364676952362, -0.4668824076652527, 0.17802660167217255, -0.13905911147594452, -0.040883619338274, -0.5492285490036011, -0.15479588508605957, -0.8818532824516296, 0.57786625623703, -0.35025644302368164, -0.49870967864990234, 0.3017997145652771, -0.016889384016394615, 0.2114894688129425, 0.31267955899238586, 0.06924480199813843, -0.5835112929344177, 0.7766063213348389, 0.30625665187835693, -0.13479478657245636, 0.657666027545929, -0.8372887372970581, 0.15159636735916138, -0.868976354598999, 0.5773451924324036, -0.7358585596084595, -0.21373018622398376, 0.3292272090911865, 0.25642481446266174, 0.5430322885513306, -0.7383525967597961, 0.553572952747345, 0.2839272618293762, 0.3209955394268036, 0.45042145252227783, 0.20373806357383728, -1.0989314317703247, -0.39160043001174927, -1.3727452754974365, -0.7867906093597412, 0.8245562314987183, -0.32252204418182373, -0.1713016778230667, -0.17892415821552277, 0.2279541790485382, -0.1702856421470642, -1.055212140083313, 1.7097065448760986, 1.2729933261871338, 0.13789872825145721, 0.1544511318206787, -0.13873925805091858, 0.10754435509443283, 0.2044941782951355, 0.0459069162607193, 0.5746718645095825, -0.525657057762146, -0.28648844361305237, 0.22920003533363342, -0.47513213753700256, -0.8375389575958252, -0.45119741559028625, 0.6877204179763794, 0.036136843264102936, -0.1071946918964386, 0.970550000667572, -0.0907026082277298, -0.3955115079879761, -0.03912869468331337, 0.000802026130259037, 0.1921945959329605, 0.18517792224884033, 0.41696420311927795, -0.0623045340180397, -0.36322054266929626, 0.13500843942165375, -0.24018238484859467, -0.8472945094108582, -0.2945992648601532, 0.19010122120380402, 0.009618637152016163, -0.1369929015636444, 0.48851877450942993, -0.2557542324066162, -0.7893356084823608, -0.7963540554046631, -0.48734182119369507, -0.40217992663383484, -0.479172021150589, -1.2275344133377075, -0.4555014371871948, -0.10698176175355911, -0.17684951424598694, 0.26528605818748474, 0.5208514928817749, -0.17781531810760498, 0.5302040576934814, 0.19258959591388702, -0.1226956695318222, -0.5704395174980164, -0.06478063762187958, 1.7300361394882202, 0.4175076484680176, -0.42353665828704834, -0.2526044249534607, -0.6024942398071289, -0.42117106914520264, -0.29114651679992676, 1.2404905557632446, -0.11428842693567276, 0.6947202682495117, -0.304667592048645, -0.44275224208831787, 0.538041889667511, 0.9447395205497742, -0.28092795610427856, 0.2717728912830353, 0.39944395422935486, -0.6620944142341614, 0.08995072543621063, 0.3778376877307892, 0.7652185559272766, 0.3417648673057556, -0.5656372308731079, -0.13653035461902618, 0.30719292163848877, -0.4199146032333374, -0.02031097747385502, -0.26310476660728455, 0.02025461569428444, -0.812102198600769, -0.8065891265869141, -1.1647340059280396, -0.40723735094070435, -0.06849414110183716, -0.30604737997055054, 0.1988695114850998, -0.560859739780426, -0.3759673237800598, 0.31741559505462646, 0.2786678671836853, 0.5024311542510986, 0.17060427367687225, -0.07301650196313858, -1.3015687465667725, -0.12721753120422363, -0.45831096172332764, -0.047734882682561874, -0.675653874874115, 0.2683795988559723, 0.10621974617242813, -0.214264377951622, -0.1821470558643341, -0.5802667737007141, -0.4131759703159332, -0.4464016556739807, 0.00786668062210083, 0.13379421830177307, -0.9974924921989441, 0.48742082715034485, 0.16786380112171173, 0.11892002075910568, -0.22143810987472534, -0.12314082682132721, 0.3912469148635864, -0.595464289188385, -0.8285689353942871, -0.5414286851882935, -0.628976047039032, 0.5998628735542297, -0.26975858211517334, -0.08957735449075699, 0.4265448749065399, 0.7247327566146851, -0.7549231648445129, -0.5037502646446228, -0.6760377883911133, 0.15438635647296906, -0.3438675105571747, -0.5259514451026917, -0.6529223322868347, 0.4633551239967346, -0.5748906135559082, 0.8973239660263062, 0.27786293625831604, -0.36957982182502747, 0.3857010304927826, -0.07326221466064453, -0.8438799977302551, 0.34293949604034424, 0.7005766034126282, 0.08997476100921631, 0.4474385380744934, 0.7359382510185242, -0.915920615196228, 1.0086519718170166, -0.0957832932472229, 0.2767803966999054, -0.27882149815559387, 0.44963183999061584, -0.9432920217514038, 0.6792375445365906, 0.5295036435127258, -0.4267171323299408, -0.2027154564857483, -0.6261022090911865, -0.6461752653121948, 0.1448156088590622, -0.7582085132598877, -0.17630673944950104, -1.1743756532669067, -0.1798766404390335, -0.5419946908950806, 0.25687769055366516, -0.20285846292972565, 0.04701300337910652, 0.44491681456565857, 0.14047467708587646, -0.9608599543571472, -0.19474785029888153, 0.065158911049366, 0.4235266447067261, -0.8635686039924622, 0.8461064696311951, -0.3064534664154053, 0.30937233567237854, -0.4839797616004944, -0.7895817756652832, -0.3102501332759857, 0.6867239475250244, -0.9884065389633179, -0.5627901554107666, -1.1919527053833008, 0.4764779806137085, 0.4135929048061371, 0.449047327041626, -0.09104354679584503, -0.2513093948364258, -0.08144643157720566, 0.7312626242637634, -0.07061822712421417, 0.21442978084087372, 0.2951342761516571, 0.1802782565355301, 0.8901484608650208, -0.16813841462135315, -0.274530291557312, 0.6066373586654663, -0.17522548139095306, -0.580269992351532, 0.8339517712593079, 0.052869763225317, 1.2794808149337769, 0.8530135750770569, 0.23679344356060028, -1.1863903999328613, 0.007525898516178131, 0.2224479764699936, 0.9251242280006409, 0.1114831492304802, -0.23749922215938568, 0.28060513734817505, -0.02171473763883114, -0.15374796092510223, 0.49649420380592346, 0.29899951815605164, -0.8878514766693115, 0.9912839531898499, -0.4595690369606018, 1.0027058124542236, 0.25401708483695984, 0.5471802353858948, -0.3288128674030304, -1.0762112140655518, -0.4910218417644501, -0.37161916494369507, 0.05209847539663315, 0.6254317164421082, -0.876955509185791, -0.13338296115398407, -0.16684715449810028, -0.23048263788223267, 0.6480371356010437, 0.44372159242630005, -0.3720875680446625, 0.26856324076652527, 0.7259540557861328, 0.747199535369873, -0.08525634557008743, 0.1888299584388733, -0.2841900885105133, 0.6077404618263245, -0.814509928226471, 0.8052691221237183, 1.2803950309753418, 1.091354489326477, 0.20678399503231049, -0.25140124559402466, -0.10799112170934677, 0.3298555612564087, -1.0363309383392334, -0.09732939302921295, -0.20025154948234558, -0.77640300989151, 0.2683151066303253, -0.549209713935852, 1.0514057874679565, -1.0503277778625488, 0.04365663230419159, 1.1463721990585327, -0.799744188785553, 0.0005154503742232919, 0.14640656113624573, -0.1334875375032425, 0.09741803258657455, 0.8828849196434021, 0.18210749328136444, -0.16270291805267334, 0.8939830660820007, 0.7361053824424744, -0.32709431648254395, 0.20873773097991943, -0.12170155346393585, -0.4562256336212158, -0.007000864017754793, 0.09944961220026016, -0.8671466112136841, 0.4986226260662079, 0.08458054065704346, -0.4115786552429199, 0.03587119281291962, -0.05570157617330551, 0.20708255469799042, 0.135555699467659, 0.1934531033039093, 0.09226732701063156, -0.3313853442668915, -0.025538580492138863, 0.9126248359680176, 0.4027611315250397, -0.27212345600128174, -0.7749037146568298, -0.41457051038742065, 0.00013645771832671016, -0.9141479134559631, 0.3668275475502014, 0.6175280809402466, -0.4443333148956299, -0.17298032343387604, -0.16820989549160004, -0.7721230983734131, -0.4390256404876709, -0.2621152698993683, -0.5035520195960999, -0.2180669903755188, 1.092599630355835, 0.11644042283296585, 0.7148303389549255, -0.357048362493515, 0.3063321113586426, 0.041491251438856125, 0.6959605813026428, 1.327727198600769, -0.3911885917186737, 0.605655312538147, 0.35713648796081543, 0.32425135374069214, -0.041172683238983154, 0.9234951734542847, 0.07192222774028778, -0.4961931109428406, -0.18492265045642853, -0.5593980550765991, 0.3369911313056946, 0.18131406605243683, 0.030894994735717773, -0.035265643149614334, 0.25764942169189453, 0.10559290647506714, 0.03435054048895836, -0.07638292759656906, -0.23142704367637634, -1.225827932357788, 0.1868162453174591, -0.09333202987909317, 0.658735990524292, 0.1893065720796585, 0.4961851239204407, -0.06347537785768509, -0.7839524149894714, 4.007063388824463, 0.6771917939186096, 0.3973501920700073, -0.6292387247085571, 0.27351269125938416, 0.4806864261627197, 0.30077898502349854, -0.8262559771537781, -0.1442321389913559, -0.48964375257492065, -0.3746521770954132, 0.12382258474826813, -0.15677237510681152, -0.05032173544168472, 0.10103762149810791, 0.43856844305992126, -0.23288188874721527, -0.4799114167690277, 0.2513687312602997, -0.5004642605781555, -0.5537872910499573, 0.021407928317785263, 0.04282747954130173, 0.10649334639310837, 0.057118009775877, 0.019160393625497818, 0.09113417565822601, -0.3409152328968048, -0.15153725445270538, -0.25538870692253113, -0.41371214389801025, 0.02683977037668228, 0.4884197413921356, -0.6469089388847351, -0.4119310975074768, 0.3214142322540283, 0.19488376379013062, 0.7302451133728027, 0.018442779779434204, 0.0923861637711525, 0.12680552899837494, 0.2557658553123474, -0.30616122484207153, -0.06783635914325714, -0.7769917845726013, 0.6817964315414429, -0.06770309805870056, 1.747185230255127, 0.9682777523994446, -1.4040924310684204, 0.4508014917373657, -0.0687868595123291, 0.3792255222797394, -0.1597806215286255, -0.6908296942710876, 0.5126494765281677, -0.6399675011634827, -0.6974587440490723, -0.4216098189353943, 0.35674843192100525, 1.5373647212982178, -0.27304360270500183, -0.28650233149528503, -0.226758673787117, -0.007242445833981037, 0.48281583189964294, 0.6517085433006287, 0.8022474050521851, -0.5151621699333191, 0.5622968673706055, 0.176652193069458, -0.5004791021347046, -0.5939086675643921, -0.06378936022520065, 0.5770774483680725, 0.1595572680234909, -0.041545312851667404, 0.06655369699001312, 0.3486112058162689, -0.02982640452682972, 0.16907811164855957, -0.19162240624427795, 0.08614335209131241, 0.11557190120220184, -0.3340950012207031, 1.2218436002731323, -0.7699087262153625, 0.3336848318576813, -0.13891614973545074, 0.696343183517456, 0.42949795722961426, 1.2820504903793335, -0.30654266476631165, -0.5050978660583496, -1.1018341779708862 ]
Coulomb drag between two-dimensional electron systems
The Coulomb contribution to the temperature-dependent rate of momentum transfer, $1/\tau_D$, between two electron systems in parallel layers is determined by setting up two coupled Boltzmann equations, with the boundary condition that no current flows in the layer where an induced voltage is measured. The effective Coulomb interaction between the layers is determined selfconsistently, allowing for the finite thickness of the layers. As $T\rightarrow 0$, we find that $1/\tau_DT^2$ approaches a constant value. At higher temperatures $1/\tau_DT^2$ exhibits a maximum at $T=T_{\rm max}$ and then decreases as $1/T$ with increasing temperature. The value of $T_{\rm max}$ depends on the layer separation $d$ according to $T_{\rm max}\propto d^{-\alpha}$, where $\alpha\simeq 0.8$. The overall magnitude of the calculated $1/\tau_D$ is approximately one half of the results of a recent experiment, suggesting that other mechanisms of momentum transfer may be important.
Antti-Pekka Jauho and Henrik Smith
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205001
cond-mat/9205002
[ -0.06482278555631638, -0.1566980928182602, 0.47379299998283386, -0.0047633047215640545, 0.26751068234443665, -0.3811645805835724, 0.08618343621492386, -0.49303579330444336, -0.6950559020042419, 0.8627411127090454, 0.8371354341506958, -0.8675622940063477, 0.6614692807197571, -0.7754930257797241, -0.17104308307170868, 0.8784807324409485, -0.23984861373901367, -0.6633949875831604, -1.0564829111099243, -0.37597841024398804, 0.19611383974552155, -0.5660668611526489, -0.6071652173995972, -0.6369184851646423, -0.4058023691177368, 0.8219634294509888, 0.11365362256765366, 0.944611132144928, 1.0699406862258911, 1.1185303926467896, 0.25306758284568787, -0.8291351199150085, -0.5506213307380676, -0.6098649501800537, -0.21505774557590485, 0.023943161591887474, 0.12228434532880783, -0.23559625446796417, 0.3340510129928589, 0.017617663368582726, 1.1853150129318237, -0.21729432046413422, 0.5617449879646301, -0.04853281006217003, -0.07336018234491348, 0.586746335029602, -0.5458623170852661, -0.3213162124156952, -0.016546402126550674, -1.342119812965393, -0.03519659489393234, 0.20678596198558807, 0.2537623643875122, 0.2122468799352646, -0.05762998387217522, -0.18136082589626312, -0.19760185480117798, -0.12381474673748016, 0.04144386574625969, -1.0590161085128784, 0.6511507630348206, -0.0323655903339386, 0.5615489482879639, -1.2441993951797485, 0.3892193138599396, 0.9929786920547485, -0.20742614567279816, 0.46718475222587585, -0.08856739848852158, -0.4048437774181366, -1.0403231382369995, -0.41636088490486145, 0.11069498211145401, -0.059394434094429016, -0.7532036900520325, -0.2901436686515808, -0.18827863037586212, -0.24968674778938293, -0.5453168749809265, -0.12170158326625824, 0.3352945148944855, -0.51911860704422, -0.5380113124847412, 0.7465341687202454, 0.6177420616149902, -0.2947263717651367, 0.28077375888824463, 0.34487080574035645, 0.03018035925924778, 0.16270141303539276, 0.23306229710578918, 1.0606642961502075, 0.08562564849853516, -0.3457707464694977, 0.3545267581939697, 0.7215416431427002, 0.4746507704257965, 0.5383017063140869, 0.5614669919013977, 0.6393947601318359, -0.2042018175125122, 0.9956817626953125, -0.9755669832229614, 0.8388996720314026, -0.5411022305488586, 0.40461263060569763, -0.015010365284979343, 0.006553011946380138, -0.3301607072353363, -0.5243546366691589, 0.6584625840187073, 0.14652752876281738, 0.39036911725997925, 0.6397169232368469, -0.12593001127243042, 0.17963378131389618, -0.2102842628955841, -0.7619844079017639, -0.4834531545639038, -0.18417812883853912, -0.06481651961803436, -0.14728553593158722, 0.5711354613304138, 0.7331066131591797, -0.17198088765144348, -0.4008635878562927, 0.35810375213623047, 1.1132198572158813, -0.17918077111244202, 0.35246601700782776, 0.24638724327087402, 0.20395536720752716, -0.004965989850461483, 0.8046731352806091, -0.8463336825370789, 0.2551060616970062, -0.13008537888526917, 0.3647359609603882, 0.3886895775794983, 0.16688142716884613, 0.9111400246620178, -0.6235805749893188, 0.07683250308036804, 1.0474196672439575, 0.1595030128955841, 0.5619174242019653, 0.38968905806541443, 0.1368999034166336, 0.45247697830200195, -0.1213274672627449, -0.8453149795532227, -0.2802370488643646, -0.043604496866464615, -0.03988340124487877, 0.1522686630487442, 0.778374195098877, -0.8484169244766235, 0.6173806190490723, -0.9496096968650818, -0.24748769402503967, 0.656983494758606, 0.3576039671897888, -0.37422171235084534, -0.11743690818548203, -0.4845529794692993, -0.12431270629167557, -0.2752366065979004, -0.7592310905456543, 0.6420990228652954, -0.013828817754983902, 0.01979842223227024, 0.22599004209041595, 0.1403641402721405, 0.2377113401889801, 0.3211594521999359, 0.359549343585968, 0.6898807883262634, 0.32074102759361267, 0.39108964800834656, 0.2434130609035492, -0.7104834318161011, -0.5563883185386658, 0.7637137770652771, -0.20582212507724762, -0.5704246163368225, -0.11678126454353333, -1.1328105926513672, -0.41292572021484375, 0.14279215037822723, 0.18853068351745605, -0.2439938336610794, 0.36124974489212036, -0.3799103796482086, 0.7010523676872253, -0.03126952797174454, -0.1769576370716095, -0.4625437557697296, 0.3464001715183258, -0.19846083223819733, -0.5169301629066467, -0.8008798956871033, 0.20491278171539307, -0.5667662024497986, -0.1588231325149536, -0.9871276021003723, 0.05273697152733803, 0.5822477340698242, 0.2799511253833771, -0.5892463326454163, -0.09099167585372925, -0.028221039101481438, -0.16217350959777832, 0.34696996212005615, 0.1255049854516983, 0.3723074495792389, -0.0483844131231308, 0.34608811140060425, -0.036992285400629044, 0.712105929851532, -0.09958463162183762, 0.5760869979858398, 0.6656596064567566, -0.14286988973617554, 0.5259755849838257, -0.4869523048400879, 0.27449166774749756, 0.06927792727947235, 0.4699556231498718, 0.30765044689178467, -0.2371603399515152, -0.15265512466430664, 0.6981604695320129, 0.2299332618713379, -0.09585858136415482, 1.0825470685958862, 0.5261721611022949, 0.43875524401664734, 0.7794263958930969, 0.08809316158294678, 0.02867373824119568, 0.00822227168828249, -0.2711062729358673, 0.8361757397651672, -0.34911003708839417, 0.4684479832649231, -0.1131330281496048, -0.46715834736824036, 0.021459827199578285, -0.2834535539150238, 0.6763420701026917, -0.7082386612892151, 0.8143388628959656, 0.11733365803956985, -0.11005163937807083, -1.2428653240203857, -0.19478127360343933, 0.4108298420906067, 0.42451927065849304, -0.2255488485097885, -0.5086297988891602, -0.5848227143287659, 0.2680412828922272, 0.25912216305732727, -0.5067675113677979, -0.14012855291366577, 1.0830799341201782, -0.023574652150273323, 0.36824262142181396, -0.06803502142429352, -0.25584185123443604, -1.5649902820587158, -0.5961562991142273, -0.8801329135894775, 0.04252985864877701, 0.33141762018203735, -0.03426353260874748, 0.48032882809638977, -0.74825519323349, 1.2287160158157349, 0.24405737221240997, 0.15091551840305328, 0.8349878787994385, 0.2502453029155731, 0.8328900337219238, 0.531085729598999, -0.13017116487026215, -0.4212675988674164, 0.34934529662132263, -0.12392843514680862, 0.6688538789749146, -0.22692005336284637, -0.46492719650268555, 0.5932839512825012, -0.20079676806926727, -0.08469688147306442, -0.7175573706626892, -0.5123656988143921, -0.13472086191177368, 0.39892250299453735, -0.32356324791908264, -0.9028751254081726, 0.22397512197494507, -0.7905291318893433, -0.2107519656419754, -0.13209274411201477, 1.0649484395980835, 0.3217654824256897, -0.5709564685821533, 0.7897505760192871, 0.1725606918334961, -0.06328064948320389, 0.02126006782054901, 0.054243624210357666, -0.1544366329908371, 0.1598690003156662, 0.7720282673835754, 0.5693358778953552, -0.012884117662906647, 0.34092018008232117, -0.6681243777275085, -0.9115571975708008, -0.5901941061019897, 0.19830746948719025, -1.1842280626296997, 0.043693020939826965, 0.4373585283756256, 0.4763510227203369, -0.6696219444274902, -0.2455655038356781, -1.4716687202453613, -0.217948317527771, -0.4309873580932617, -0.25270959734916687, 1.101990818977356, 0.049167025834321976, -0.32720747590065, -0.19250312447547913, -0.35710957646369934, 0.5074590444564819, 0.31724420189857483, -0.05931345745921135, -0.4585990905761719, 0.8449447154998779, 0.15482541918754578, 0.7860564589500427, 0.3283536434173584, 0.24614234268665314, -0.38199904561042786, 0.3495774269104004, 0.07896017283201218, -0.5807649493217468, 0.3055799603462219, 0.2842971682548523, 0.21518675982952118, 0.08378072828054428, 0.527294397354126, -0.9145247340202332, -0.8917802572250366, -1.161536693572998, -0.48500463366508484, 0.16683152318000793, 0.5410938858985901, -0.5159658193588257, 0.46654701232910156, -0.5103825330734253, 0.035641200840473175, 0.11096317321062088, 0.25826865434646606, 1.1990079879760742, -0.19841551780700684, 0.6066446304321289, -0.039314959198236465, -0.2781674861907959, -0.04269183427095413, -0.746418297290802, -0.1455691009759903, 0.3752369284629822, 0.3715982735157013, 1.1701990365982056, -0.9787469506263733, -0.5174619555473328, -0.4348010718822479, 1.1983953714370728, 0.6054764986038208, 0.7643336653709412, 0.6599310636520386, -0.23100557923316956, 0.06293804198503494, -0.3658936023712158, -0.7359485030174255, 0.2569590210914612, 0.050919029861688614, -0.6111920475959778, -0.9274572134017944, -0.12907718122005463, -0.06116702780127525, 0.6545627117156982, 0.14567717909812927, 0.09703709930181503, 0.24739189445972443, 0.27518701553344727, 1.0558018684387207, 0.893359899520874, 0.3388707637786865, -0.5084835290908813, -0.20577383041381836, -0.4994834363460541, 0.3106926381587982, -0.15988726913928986, 0.1818827986717224, -0.3004353642463684, -0.6141403317451477, -0.12435910105705261, 0.21472981572151184, 1.0532795190811157, 0.3090011477470398, 0.05114181712269783, 0.6518055200576782, 0.21249155700206757, 0.0671943724155426, -0.2120734304189682, 0.43898022174835205, 0.3191332519054413, 0.6708145141601562, 0.021601155400276184, -0.847513735294342, 0.43781518936157227, 0.003601280739530921, 0.4101555347442627, 0.7857864499092102, -0.739708662033081, -1.1589744091033936, -0.2815125584602356, 0.7111556529998779, -0.6982681155204773, -0.14726561307907104, 0.570694088935852, -0.1002984493970871, 0.4366165101528168, -0.0886077806353569, -0.09535329043865204, 0.6619260311126709, -0.7023707032203674, -0.0028340399730950594, -0.4643319249153137, 0.17512613534927368, -0.3537627160549164, 0.5206099152565002, 0.16122010350227356, -0.3619772791862488, -0.7335705757141113, -0.12542255222797394, -0.27128681540489197, -0.30422332882881165, -0.2753254175186157, -0.441298246383667, -0.23697486519813538, -0.7610242366790771, 0.5387982130050659, -0.3012448847293854, 0.6877715587615967, 0.5341545939445496, 0.33084192872047424, -0.2547421455383301, -0.5319987535476685, 0.2579973340034485, 0.07937200367450714, 0.7387683391571045, 0.5319274663925171, 0.5821113586425781, 0.2639221251010895, -0.08725962042808533, 0.04320462793111801, 0.027810318395495415, 0.05662763863801956, -0.3467550575733185, 0.14612919092178345, -0.47909820079803467, -0.21582788228988647, -0.8481964468955994, -0.3191002607345581, 0.14105387032032013, -0.7582393288612366, 0.898409903049469, 0.06864114105701447, -0.48296141624450684, -0.4145430326461792, -0.11000446230173111, -1.1862256526947021, 0.13587969541549683, -0.41391411423683167, -0.7281206846237183, 0.4905318319797516, -0.45769554376602173, -0.3952553868293762, -0.0227096788585186, -0.7822887301445007, -0.036615900695323944, 0.365658164024353, 0.5341807007789612, -0.5828294157981873, 0.7607855200767517, -0.1372518092393875, 0.7820402383804321, -0.6531778573989868, 0.5044722557067871, -0.149550199508667, -0.11087191104888916, -0.31108638644218445, -0.27968573570251465, -0.24979142844676971, -0.720813512802124, 0.3923957347869873, 0.07931626588106155, 0.7656689882278442, 0.5869107246398926, 0.25988101959228516, -0.09750284999608994, -0.5490127205848694, 0.5652002096176147, -0.06802985072135925, -0.7701154947280884, 0.20092110335826874, 0.9608330726623535, 0.3083227276802063, 0.23088108003139496, -0.2159888595342636, 0.0962926596403122, 0.09910387545824051, -0.282624214887619, 0.2148026078939438, -1.2610334157943726, -0.6829445958137512, -0.2276022732257843, -0.1441594809293747, 0.10303910821676254, 0.418089896440506, -0.030866434797644615, -0.22547368705272675, 0.15581008791923523, -0.3486311733722687, -0.3202243745326996, -0.0770837590098381, -0.5035296082496643, -0.14264518022537231, -0.3918568789958954, -1.208803415298462, 0.771697998046875, -0.1249256506562233, -0.0814305767416954, 0.6123406887054443, 0.2347162812948227, -0.051843415945768356, -0.1418432593345642, 0.3644670248031616, 0.3081075847148895, 0.09303682297468185, 1.0077919960021973, -0.2329002022743225, 0.3421730399131775, -0.8973263502120972, 0.46614527702331543, -1.2531019449234009, 1.0104987621307373, -0.232860267162323, -0.20947128534317017, 0.12586452066898346, 0.3205486536026001, 0.6140562891960144, -1.0194791555404663, -0.38095661997795105, -0.005189074669033289, 0.20646871626377106, 0.6994717121124268, 0.24223726987838745, -0.32261842489242554, -0.5748001337051392, -0.7294217348098755, -0.7213516235351562, 0.3022921085357666, 0.130700945854187, -0.3836316466331482, -0.58094722032547, -0.7391083836555481, -0.30632156133651733, 0.10312968492507935, 0.4534779191017151, 0.6168773174285889, 0.4253791272640228, 0.1661144495010376, -0.05854368209838867, -0.07396969199180603, 0.08637803792953491, 0.12207891047000885, -0.4809459447860718, -0.008876494131982327, -0.8389509320259094, 0.143851175904274, -0.25582385063171387, -0.9848283529281616, -0.19001798331737518, -0.009580603800714016, -0.07735471427440643, 0.04360627755522728, 0.5301159620285034, -0.2226509302854538, -0.26668182015419006, 0.26703086495399475, -0.5502272844314575, -0.3807855546474457, 0.4290851056575775, 0.33210569620132446, 0.0019143745303153992, 0.18504644930362701, -0.17728720605373383, 0.5329480171203613, -0.7534429430961609, -0.05926712974905968, 0.7663664221763611, 0.004260066896677017, -0.5627675652503967, 0.03397123143076897, -0.1981477588415146, -0.757092297077179, -0.4348923861980438, -0.7162525653839111, -0.5144873857498169, -0.15925097465515137, -0.6740961074829102, 0.6247544884681702, -0.638960063457489, -0.23301053047180176, 0.5219480991363525, 0.973785400390625, -0.17065149545669556, -0.6369520425796509, 0.35487672686576843, -0.7847822904586792, -0.3028870224952698, -0.19827929139137268, 1.7161569595336914, -0.6296167373657227, -0.7489912509918213, -0.08965663611888885, -0.7621434330940247, -0.025109944865107536, 0.3636671006679535, -0.05441637337207794, 0.02695712447166443, 0.6328398585319519, -0.13846184313297272, 0.841190755367279, 0.11359231919050217, 0.31522542238235474, 0.06683873385190964, -0.44306841492652893, 1.004016637802124, -0.905072033405304, -0.19632722437381744, -0.09163271635770798, 0.5450060367584229, 0.8967742919921875, -0.9656988978385925, 0.48662540316581726, 0.17624381184577942, -0.3523194193840027, -0.5142924189567566, -0.6408692598342896, 0.2914903163909912, -0.9075730443000793, -0.700079619884491, -0.7830752730369568, -0.3569639325141907, -0.032090120017528534, -0.40199002623558044, 0.08774182945489883, 0.024146420881152153, -0.6953859329223633, -0.20588858425617218, 0.19632834196090698, 0.27322259545326233, 0.12755833566188812, -0.3745396137237549, -0.7867580652236938, -0.006439714692533016, -0.2764038145542145, -0.5861659049987793, 0.09363003075122833, -0.11474236845970154, -0.4143938720226288, -0.15542808175086975, -0.4597548544406891, 0.7702992558479309, -0.43477606773376465, -0.5164618492126465, 0.2036539763212204, 0.32936280965805054, -0.6566927433013916, -0.061725739389657974, 0.1408655196428299, 0.018077367916703224, 0.27735769748687744, 0.21805013716220856, 0.1778421252965927, 0.22262971103191376, -1.2167576551437378, -0.036927126348018646, -0.4645281732082367, -0.08093889057636261, -0.2554137408733368, -0.5892792344093323, 0.28555598855018616, 0.5457944273948669, -0.8505956530570984, 0.5813466310501099, -0.10794391483068466, 0.18735747039318085, 0.0017228627111762762, -0.2723460793495178, 0.08039136976003647, 0.1928308755159378, -0.40761086344718933, 0.9149084091186523, -0.5982573628425598, -0.4730475842952728, -0.27206557989120483, -0.017072316259145737, -0.7502772212028503, 0.5191709995269775, 0.39424994587898254, -0.3828468918800354, 0.14067308604717255, 0.44846123456954956, -0.27401474118232727, 0.25695815682411194, -0.5477230548858643, 0.24466033279895782, -0.5606496930122375, -0.7563149929046631, -0.27836179733276367, 0.493760347366333, -0.006708116736263037, -0.39414694905281067, -0.19270016252994537, -0.7493754625320435, -0.5838467478752136, 0.8751881718635559, -0.6516482830047607, -0.5517250299453735, -0.5083885788917542, -0.5279911756515503, 0.4016638994216919, -0.20928631722927094, -0.13130931556224823, 0.10034940391778946, 0.007231270894408226, 0.23206637799739838, -0.25251340866088867, 0.38236021995544434, 0.4677829444408417, 0.013573070988059044, -0.7451440691947937, -0.07455278187990189, -0.8368682265281677, 0.3921246826648712, -0.11868581920862198, -0.6115412712097168, -0.21316488087177277, 0.22616712749004364, -0.21052220463752747, 0.16979098320007324, -0.47623297572135925, 0.022516263648867607, -0.020013531669974327, 0.2446371465921402, -0.10455069690942764, -0.0763329565525055, -0.43903547525405884, 1.066469669342041, 0.35123470425605774, -0.7304401993751526, 1.1102081537246704, 0.18976861238479614, 0.43376606702804565, -0.49135929346084595, -0.5099654793739319, 0.7408527135848999, -0.33399727940559387, -0.5118711590766907, 1.4097044467926025, -0.2592630386352539, 0.2036542147397995, -0.14555077254772186, -0.20523758232593536, -0.24110586941242218, -0.2041536569595337, 0.3015356659889221, 0.562663733959198, 0.5328185558319092, 0.34319719672203064, 0.5473334193229675, 0.1151512935757637, 0.19401045143604279, 0.25705811381340027, 0.7289730310440063, 0.5157419443130493, 0.47355157136917114, 0.10047576576471329, -0.21517321467399597, 0.4069517254829407, 0.35847118496894836, -0.28804466128349304, 0.0769970640540123, -0.07911986112594604, 0.15621529519557953, 0.2946572005748749, 0.7183104753494263, -0.7218376994132996, 0.1298065185546875, -0.6050118803977966, -0.030839303508400917, 0.059305254369974136, 0.3651832342147827, 0.27269819378852844, 0.8878195285797119, 0.4087905287742615, 0.47668570280075073, 0.25562942028045654, 0.437625527381897, 0.20271115005016327, 0.014717024751007557, 0.4458807706832886, 1.2500319480895996, 0.5982739329338074, 0.676444947719574, 0.03786243498325348, -0.958012580871582, -0.11943798512220383, 0.4278322756290436, -0.9495744705200195, -0.056107405573129654, -0.14822377264499664, -0.28162577748298645, -0.08018653094768524, -0.826939046382904, 0.1768861711025238, -0.6439476609230042, 0.13742642104625702, 0.6692823171615601, -0.11169056594371796, 0.4093095660209656, 0.5438745021820068, -0.3998315930366516, 0.37299951910972595, 0.560835063457489, 0.09953834861516953, -0.13804113864898682, 0.8049894571304321, 0.8668402433395386, -0.3547661304473877, 0.091388039290905, -0.17484360933303833, -0.13753360509872437, 0.23922351002693176, 0.4950093626976013, -0.044941410422325134, 0.8567240834236145, -0.3867095410823822, -0.3465632498264313, 0.7450703382492065, 0.31685778498649597, 0.039570003747940063, 0.14789508283138275, -0.25895601511001587, 0.44561007618904114, -0.20957280695438385, 0.2420363873243332, 0.7658366560935974, 0.017407355830073357, 0.07437708228826523, -0.4118095934391022, -0.21661947667598724, -0.08291478455066681, -0.3036138713359833, -0.48014765977859497, 0.28054946660995483, 0.8693932890892029, 0.26219987869262695, -0.5332937836647034, -0.8834400177001953, -0.05297849699854851, -1.0965702533721924, -0.07142488658428192, -0.72475665807724, 0.6093213558197021, -0.14850206673145294, 0.3033430576324463, 0.09241744875907898, -0.8408424854278564, 0.44879817962646484, 0.11482222378253937, 1.3334664106369019, 0.12896640598773956, 0.28317880630493164, 0.3905341327190399, 0.31441670656204224, -0.5281417965888977, 0.4404824674129486, 0.7919726967811584, -0.9545824527740479, 0.5085790753364563, -0.22810034453868866, -0.26562201976776123, 0.08618378639221191, 0.021307775750756264, 0.22026468813419342, -0.01469484344124794, 0.25619539618492126, -0.6426738500595093, -0.318546861410141, 0.20775385200977325, -1.0024608373641968, 0.21406839787960052, -1.021966576576233, -0.04454037547111511, -0.4112783372402191, 0.5449490547180176, -0.19222570955753326, -0.15466557443141937, 4.141575813293457, 1.6088610887527466, 0.42905163764953613, -0.040324632078409195, 0.11783178150653839, 0.3504776358604431, -0.02258826419711113, -0.10139002650976181, 0.15211918950080872, -0.8869408965110779, 0.1361430138349533, 0.4564189910888672, -0.12792906165122986, -0.5519701242446899, -0.21101008355617523, 0.5014539957046509, -0.279600590467453, 0.0419965460896492, 0.30279824137687683, -0.5735376477241516, 0.030051182955503464, 0.4836437702178955, 0.5060253143310547, -0.5051512718200684, -0.06896013766527176, 0.10693319886922836, 0.608227550983429, -0.647462010383606, -0.990999162197113, 0.013019515201449394, -1.1465917825698853, -1.1820062398910522, -0.1733698695898056, -0.6456907987594604, -1.1587895154953003, 0.4651106297969818, 0.12726226449012756, -0.5437656044960022, 0.12121656537055969, 0.35619309544563293, -0.1978716105222702, -0.10656450688838959, 0.05399448052048683, 0.22069814801216125, -1.2628973722457886, 0.53724205493927, -0.5561956167221069, 0.6900277733802795, 0.4936676025390625, -0.340148001909256, 0.4757896065711975, -0.8601073622703552, 0.025074468925595284, -0.42391833662986755, -0.9514725208282471, 0.042721621692180634, -0.30045151710510254, -0.4675750434398651, 0.10504483431577682, 0.14597389101982117, 0.9662993550300598, -0.15852347016334534, -0.25755879282951355, -0.2782415449619293, 0.26281535625457764, 0.6052093505859375, 1.0551555156707764, 0.08096212148666382, 0.1170588806271553, -0.468231737613678, -0.07721088826656342, -0.27341264486312866, -0.6705065369606018, 0.6185482740402222, 0.12166330218315125, -0.03547505661845207, -0.27456825971603394, 0.8049715757369995, -0.29895517230033875, -0.5217549204826355, -0.4856429398059845, -0.4581589102745056, -0.7564001083374023, 0.8831577897071838, 0.07078023999929428, 0.6498314738273621, -0.48251062631607056, -0.36716771125793457, -0.43321695923805237, 0.5283493995666504, -0.027928808704018593, 1.3555388450622559, -0.1277545690536499, -0.25277838110923767, -0.7451158165931702 ]
Roughening of Reconstructed Crystal Surfaces and the Hubbard Model
We consider a model of a reconstructed crystal surface, first considered by Villain and Vilfan (Europhys. Lett. 12, p. 523 (1990) and Surf. Sci. 257, p. 368 (1991)) for the gold (110) surface, in which roughening occurs via the formation of anisotropic steps traversing the entire length of the crystal. The model is studied by a mapping to a spin--1/2 Fermion system in 1+1 dimensions, which, in the absence of islands, is precisely the Hubbard model. We consider a general $\pbyo$ reconstruction, in the presence of inter--step interactions and closed islands. Our analysis predicts the existence of a new type of rough phase, with incommensurate correlations in the reconstruction order parameter and unusual momentum space singularities at a characteristic ``Fermi momentum'' and its harmonics, analagous to the Luttinger liquid of one--dimensional Fermions. The general phase structure for $p>1$ is as follows: for $p>2$, there is a flat ordered (FO), a rough incommensurate (RI), and a flat incommensurate phase (FI). The FO--RI and FO--FI transitions are of the commensurate to incommensurate type, and the FI--RI transition is in the Kosterlitz--Thouless (KT) universality class. For $p=2$, the FI phase is replaced by a flat disordered phase (FD), and there may be a new rough disordered phase (RD). The FO--FD transition is now of Ising type, and the FD--RD and RI--RD transitions are in the KT universality class.
Leon Balents and Mehran Kardar
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205002
cond-mat/9205003
[ 0.19450534880161285, 0.02884519286453724, 0.09558434784412384, -0.1336359977722168, 0.09418092668056488, -0.746606171131134, -0.4756539762020111, 0.22726036608219147, -0.7634707093238831, 1.3108880519866943, 1.3088924884796143, -0.4165925979614258, 0.09924375265836716, -0.5731906294822693, -0.46794965863227844, 0.2543387711048126, -0.2556791603565216, -0.6000196933746338, -0.5032917857170105, -0.08369109034538269, 0.45976123213768005, -0.3947147727012634, -1.7389507293701172, -0.17602621018886566, -0.10680701583623886, 0.5645609498023987, 0.838412880897522, -0.06669938564300537, 1.103877067565918, 0.30101072788238525, 0.740529477596283, -0.5052489042282104, 0.4402780830860138, -0.7333015203475952, 0.368196040391922, 0.02758955955505371, 0.28725966811180115, -0.29512345790863037, 0.3569008708000183, -0.36763206124305725, 0.7288702130317688, 0.38271212577819824, 0.40287110209465027, -0.2661783695220947, -0.804502010345459, -0.7605173587799072, -0.6412549614906311, 0.4513041377067566, 0.5848078727722168, -0.7427203059196472, 0.12762580811977386, -0.31470462679862976, -0.015052789822220802, -0.7762370705604553, -0.2905752658843994, 0.29262053966522217, 0.15503455698490143, 0.18656297028064728, -0.4775201678276062, -0.2292158603668213, 0.2935376763343811, 0.17607742547988892, 0.5605142712593079, -0.8226138949394226, 1.0440638065338135, 0.925035297870636, -0.43649470806121826, 0.706893265247345, 0.10581661015748978, -0.2592652142047882, 0.24669279158115387, -0.8019376397132874, -0.6973022222518921, 0.07333040237426758, -0.3738059103488922, 0.3598805069923401, -0.0026751733385026455, -0.6684475541114807, -1.2759147882461548, 0.025944480672478676, 0.11794165521860123, -0.5707385540008545, -0.8170233964920044, 0.38804274797439575, -0.25910186767578125, -0.1694725602865219, 0.6699928045272827, -0.1535768359899521, 0.452949196100235, 0.2779550552368164, 0.422576904296875, 0.6044280529022217, 0.7719385623931885, -0.3385029733181, 0.6372196078300476, 1.0944414138793945, 0.3661450445652008, 0.7396808862686157, 0.0757094994187355, 0.7238098978996277, -0.2860839068889618, 1.1034413576126099, -0.7573524713516235, 1.0219218730926514, -0.28614938259124756, 0.8151100277900696, 0.19007714092731476, 0.392788827419281, -0.2621991038322449, -0.5165205597877502, 0.2511136829853058, -0.4321141242980957, 0.2597404718399048, 0.8308466672897339, -0.414387971162796, 0.4562110900878906, 0.2660955786705017, 0.3992912769317627, -0.17052558064460754, -0.5955755710601807, 0.3044576644897461, 0.28136569261550903, 0.7458528876304626, 0.03065846487879753, 0.3656077980995178, -0.586804986000061, -0.2918224036693573, 0.7661251425743103, -1.3027838468551636, 0.1515229344367981, 0.020804522559046745, -0.24995622038841248, -0.025272535160183907, 0.2712290287017822, -0.910814106464386, 0.3289121389389038, -0.4681331217288971, 0.3726170063018799, -0.3032841980457306, -0.18498462438583374, 1.0208650827407837, -0.39692720770835876, 0.07219432294368744, 1.1596614122390747, -0.2517988979816437, 0.8448549509048462, 0.32539650797843933, -0.1898047775030136, 0.042896535247564316, 0.9008059501647949, -0.011039444245398045, -0.6482298970222473, -0.6538920998573303, 0.7554442286491394, 0.3482070565223694, 0.42768487334251404, -0.011339099146425724, 0.39085379242897034, -0.8937730193138123, -0.6541099548339844, 0.15361006557941437, 0.2785030007362366, -0.12953650951385498, 0.36990246176719666, -0.18202254176139832, -0.11714629828929901, -0.5560863018035889, -0.39726805686950684, -0.12008169293403625, -0.7051358222961426, 0.2514858543872833, -0.5267325639724731, 0.5526161789894104, 0.5956482291221619, 0.48576417565345764, 0.0751478523015976, 0.42312225699424744, -0.4542364776134491, -0.06691115349531174, -0.27658897638320923, -0.6131349205970764, -0.34018203616142273, 0.9278206825256348, 0.08057989180088043, 0.3007216453552246, -0.6576619148254395, -1.01386559009552, -0.007278842385858297, -0.544583797454834, 0.901367723941803, 0.19563934206962585, 0.7816010117530823, -0.45208540558815, 1.0207191705703735, -0.6650044322013855, -0.10809694975614548, -0.25869306921958923, 0.3558447062969208, -1.1273576021194458, -0.5173042416572571, 0.13018830120563507, 0.3157036006450653, -0.5686486959457397, 0.31268662214279175, -1.3115694522857666, 0.415429025888443, 0.3629656136035919, 0.4989132285118103, -0.8240209817886353, -0.29659774899482727, 0.12174257636070251, 0.12751404941082, 0.6435343027114868, -0.8362672328948975, 0.3924841582775116, 0.03530678525567055, 0.06833663582801819, 0.22257691621780396, 0.5624617338180542, -0.2701016664505005, 0.3853226602077484, 0.2587738037109375, -0.03966328874230385, 0.5401477217674255, -0.040334563702344894, -0.821918785572052, -0.07415555417537689, 0.9138005971908569, 0.683427631855011, -0.16463600099086761, -0.22936564683914185, 0.5190564393997192, -0.1898353099822998, 0.0052192783914506435, -0.01783098466694355, 0.2601456046104431, 0.3662102520465851, 0.38855651021003723, 0.5663912892341614, 0.08002838492393494, 0.23047739267349243, 0.04000581055879593, 0.5487176179885864, 0.4874282479286194, 0.47089898586273193, 0.3647739589214325, -0.3118191957473755, 0.1990557312965393, -0.6662350296974182, 0.8625475168228149, -0.5902947783470154, 1.078220009803772, 0.28270846605300903, 0.5875759720802307, -0.4978328347206116, -0.5304684042930603, -0.06522339582443237, 0.4259527623653412, 0.32881802320480347, -0.7355967164039612, -0.21474146842956543, 0.48751991987228394, 0.28386199474334717, -0.5343473553657532, 0.009076536633074284, 0.8731551170349121, 0.20815010368824005, 0.09510595351457596, 0.4017603099346161, -0.7330482006072998, -1.0608651638031006, -0.34554049372673035, -0.744407057762146, -0.0197975542396307, -0.28825685381889343, -0.18652445077896118, 0.4515255391597748, -0.6025888919830322, 0.21333646774291992, -0.6212427020072937, -0.41681453585624695, 0.6228649616241455, 0.0001507665147073567, 0.822952151298523, 0.36685657501220703, -0.5068171620368958, -0.4306521713733673, 0.6566209197044373, -0.8800252676010132, 0.3778809607028961, 0.25032535195350647, -0.039192769676446915, 0.4981517791748047, -0.11879536509513855, -0.5952036380767822, -0.8356447815895081, -0.49115607142448425, 0.285849392414093, -0.4602365493774414, -0.11411474645137787, 0.1579684317111969, 0.9889941215515137, 0.2686188817024231, -0.5320367217063904, -0.7449350357055664, 0.865437924861908, 0.3056129217147827, -0.5954417586326599, 0.543566882610321, 0.6238253116607666, -1.3394403457641602, 0.39924538135528564, -0.10838291794061661, 0.12241557240486145, 0.16483232378959656, 0.4357970654964447, 0.9279225468635559, -0.09797464311122894, 0.43326327204704285, -0.7905462980270386, -0.9245730042457581, -0.1179904043674469, -0.3853732645511627, -0.3598823547363281, -0.02632100135087967, 1.3785903453826904, 0.25440287590026855, -0.3574572205543518, -0.0232623890042305, -0.8285520076751709, -0.7606529593467712, 0.031675372272729874, -0.1330937296152115, 0.4393967092037201, 0.3862411081790924, 0.05729259178042412, -0.5464788675308228, 0.34366050362586975, 0.36785709857940674, 0.8400693535804749, 0.37889039516448975, -1.5848331451416016, 0.5502011179924011, 0.28735852241516113, 0.6323533058166504, 0.027320777997374535, 0.6984372735023499, -0.10041693598031998, -0.5080574750900269, 0.6044989228248596, -0.18530282378196716, -0.22369910776615143, -0.030842721462249756, 0.5078385472297668, -0.5050392150878906, 0.2689080238342285, -0.31855884194374084, -0.18838585913181305, -0.35084837675094604, -0.25271013379096985, 0.29597628116607666, 0.8269487023353577, 0.1625770926475525, 0.7254270315170288, -0.323883056640625, -0.2789527177810669, 0.1420125514268875, 0.08167487382888794, 0.5687739253044128, -1.1080448627471924, 0.44522321224212646, -0.4404003918170929, -0.31065794825553894, 0.11636967957019806, -0.2657965123653412, 0.024012070149183273, 0.32092559337615967, 1.023173451423645, 0.624489963054657, -0.5525824427604675, -0.6414034366607666, -0.15060651302337646, 0.5661187767982483, 0.5755732655525208, 0.7964791059494019, 0.03536059334874153, 0.21898344159126282, -0.4565640389919281, -0.0005012117908336222, -0.4927343726158142, -0.8151189088821411, -0.71157306432724, -1.0075660943984985, -0.6555097699165344, -0.4689790904521942, -0.28889837861061096, 0.4673325717449188, -0.44961705803871155, 0.39416444301605225, 0.03544146567583084, 0.7857038378715515, 0.18982826173305511, 1.2194976806640625, 0.9695281386375427, 0.0842372328042984, -0.09212367981672287, -0.6506633758544922, 0.6185578107833862, 0.441311776638031, 0.05260152369737625, -0.21476079523563385, -0.11420636624097824, 0.3231799006462097, -0.717571496963501, 0.5795159339904785, 0.06577316671609879, -0.4071144163608551, 0.6129248738288879, -0.1748999059200287, 0.6459237933158875, 0.18951022624969482, -0.08343464881181717, 0.1550992727279663, 0.5115633010864258, 0.365074098110199, -0.9552233219146729, 0.3399038314819336, -0.22620470821857452, 0.6445266604423523, 0.28775256872177124, -0.1610403209924698, -0.9329310655593872, -1.2342517375946045, -0.2605220079421997, -0.48433107137680054, 0.19557949900627136, 0.7492097616195679, -0.011241992935538292, 0.22957412898540497, -0.29223284125328064, -0.33010128140449524, -0.04793914034962654, -0.6006261110305786, -0.12403373420238495, 0.5769088864326477, -0.24683119356632233, -0.3141654431819916, 0.2857167720794678, 0.34908822178840637, -0.16031302511692047, 0.01794584095478058, -0.2422497719526291, 0.5957084894180298, -0.011802726425230503, -0.3145201504230499, -0.08156965672969818, 0.055708397179841995, -0.9228200316429138, 0.32685691118240356, 0.26959317922592163, -0.0035333270207047462, -0.23603765666484833, 0.19157180190086365, -0.4312705993652344, -0.48706334829330444, 0.3876984417438507, -0.1341363936662674, 0.4582124650478363, 0.3358980119228363, -0.533209502696991, 0.6687390208244324, 0.2828882932662964, -0.6930211186408997, 0.3315766453742981, 0.7204346656799316, 0.02403402514755726, -0.5519670844078064, -0.5003082752227783, 0.02073129080235958, 0.10591571033000946, -0.7940969467163086, -0.6980558633804321, -0.19470030069351196, 0.834291398525238, 0.5278676152229309, -0.5811082720756531, -0.28107979893684387, 0.5432403087615967, -0.490824818611145, -0.1585242748260498, -0.45767319202423096, -0.5151187181472778, 0.1483185589313507, -0.8362308144569397, -0.13716016709804535, 0.4688158333301544, -0.7025615572929382, -0.5626296401023865, 0.6184064149856567, 0.45976999402046204, 0.07283742725849152, 0.4201285243034363, -0.4469265937805176, 0.5350348949432373, -0.07513768970966339, -0.4892304837703705, -0.821559488773346, -0.18680040538311005, -0.10512208193540573, -0.053966719657182693, -0.8983569741249084, -0.05415184050798416, -0.198960080742836, -0.3655593991279602, 0.05546301603317261, -0.31752318143844604, 0.08630923181772232, -0.6276239156723022, -0.1893143504858017, 0.8584875464439392, 0.11290279775857925, -0.9696877002716064, 0.22831928730010986, 0.08924208581447601, -0.46727490425109863, 0.18377940356731415, 0.5866156220436096, -1.1322627067565918, 0.6845896244049072, -0.44189614057540894, 0.18888315558433533, -1.202366828918457, -0.2398245483636856, -0.8903083801269531, -1.4012435674667358, 0.05180544778704643, 0.6927627921104431, 0.4998527467250824, -0.46379923820495605, -0.6115224361419678, -0.1718217432498932, -0.1953822672367096, -0.36098089814186096, -0.2588689625263214, -0.2741890549659729, -0.06326573342084885, -0.3135441541671753, 0.3319183588027954, -0.031420666724443436, -0.0934513732790947, 0.03437746688723564, -0.21478812396526337, 0.4748392403125763, 0.6710845828056335, -0.04097985848784447, -0.23245510458946228, -0.3788738548755646, 0.25394973158836365, 0.25198525190353394, 0.5393375754356384, -0.46160414814949036, 0.460631787776947, -1.4694253206253052, 1.0030573606491089, -0.5576189756393433, -0.7275356650352478, 0.10391081124544144, 0.5625868439674377, 0.4220119118690491, -0.8797197341918945, 0.04655527323484421, 0.05907103046774864, -0.24023239314556122, 0.44971123337745667, 0.020201662555336952, -0.3639075458049774, -0.5347781181335449, -0.4980846345424652, -0.8935145139694214, 1.01229727268219, 0.0830531194806099, -0.025098029524087906, -0.10039965063333511, -0.21879072487354279, 0.10912136733531952, -0.3911624252796173, 0.4819057285785675, 0.7322260141372681, -0.06961829960346222, -0.06310372054576874, -0.33853259682655334, -0.3215431272983551, -0.7306981086730957, -0.12612800300121307, 0.4718985855579376, 0.10249974578619003, 0.11277835071086884, -0.21223624050617218, -0.3550926446914673, -0.7805419564247131, -0.3579823076725006, 0.4963971674442291, -0.007070689927786589, -0.5945296287536621, 0.2916014790534973, -0.22050261497497559, -0.23248760402202606, -0.31929823756217957, 0.0016574920155107975, -0.07511354982852936, 0.19250886142253876, 0.3089450001716614, 0.1674957275390625, 0.6618894338607788, 0.14979425072669983, 0.4095950424671173, -0.3681202232837677, -0.3645041286945343, 0.6155702471733093, -0.7778066992759705, -0.7111785411834717, -0.007044223602861166, 0.2271437793970108, -0.961119532585144, 0.15015889704227448, -0.5489704012870789, -0.006262670736759901, -0.2208021879196167, -0.26567137241363525, -0.3510656952857971, -0.27632850408554077, -0.3577110171318054, 0.27599579095840454, 0.3865036964416504, -0.3434063196182251, 0.05509728193283081, -0.21482177078723907, -0.1123456135392189, -0.03229650482535362, 0.3780391812324524, 1.3143019676208496, -0.541198194026947, -0.3771466910839081, -0.7011243104934692, -0.4174674451351166, -0.6505725979804993, 0.5332387089729309, 0.3733751177787781, 0.08924879133701324, 0.34493502974510193, 0.9743227958679199, 0.47574666142463684, 0.6362678408622742, 1.1718578338623047, 0.16885589063167572, 0.07401666790246964, -0.31768813729286194, -1.0768978595733643, -0.4282841384410858, 0.28044939041137695, 0.4579087495803833, 0.9647560715675354, -0.1708858758211136, -0.12567271292209625, 0.49768540263175964, -0.022180218249559402, -0.15113632380962372, -1.3647445440292358, 0.18061447143554688, -0.7331554293632507, -0.6881667375564575, -0.7270285487174988, -0.5900833010673523, 0.31541240215301514, 0.4592832624912262, -0.5148410201072693, 0.25361981987953186, -0.22819113731384277, -0.31912893056869507, -0.0932837650179863, 0.10445470362901688, 0.09323688596487045, -0.22037096321582794, -0.7370920181274414, 0.04633638635277748, -0.17124930024147034, -0.6579397916793823, -0.5526167154312134, -0.14657387137413025, -0.2768367826938629, 0.4501763582229614, -0.7461870312690735, 0.38222020864486694, -0.8613477349281311, -0.26738446950912476, 0.385483980178833, -0.1335776448249817, -0.9630518555641174, 0.19597463309764862, -0.06718109548091888, 0.48446303606033325, 0.1523132175207138, -0.07360007613897324, -0.35694602131843567, -0.20979182422161102, -0.23487326502799988, 0.10327291488647461, -0.07069376856088638, 0.09539463371038437, -0.1559939682483673, -0.06094428524374962, 0.6544986963272095, 0.03695220872759819, -1.1803237199783325, 0.15488339960575104, 0.14658258855342865, 0.09856534749269485, -0.11507434397935867, 0.4360511898994446, -0.26168471574783325, 0.2748025953769684, 0.2742389738559723, 1.0351210832595825, -0.01345529593527317, -0.38957300782203674, -0.37245023250579834, -0.6461254954338074, -0.25775960087776184, 0.6759262681007385, -0.14273348450660706, -0.6547055840492249, -0.3511260151863098, 0.3743695914745331, -0.12303201854228973, -0.4947671592235565, -0.47258439660072327, 0.2049594223499298, -1.1110519170761108, -0.865530252456665, -0.45002809166908264, 0.4232281446456909, 0.20968155562877655, -0.719079852104187, -0.0013142311945557594, 0.02146480605006218, -0.6659526824951172, 0.04503149911761284, -1.0864094495773315, -0.839929461479187, 0.07624983787536621, -1.1900007724761963, 0.1508854776620865, 0.38945016264915466, -0.25862765312194824, 0.278862327337265, 0.08763609081506729, 0.4491252303123474, -0.06150222569704056, -0.010506002232432365, -0.7614438533782959, 0.3895004689693451, -0.831763744354248, -0.3910233676433563, -0.32594960927963257, 0.32573559880256653, -0.6865649819374084, -0.9381698369979858, -0.1087169423699379, 0.9232673048973083, 0.5843287110328674, -0.3632943034172058, 0.14742252230644226, 0.28195062279701233, 0.43788349628448486, 0.08288957923650742, -0.9160682559013367, 0.09653572738170624, 0.3402084708213806, 0.7947052121162415, -0.31452658772468567, -0.4783458113670349, 0.4519248902797699, 0.5059022903442383, 0.5447639226913452, 0.07220287621021271, -0.1064707413315773, 0.47427985072135925, -0.2463051676750183, -1.0833935737609863, 1.015669345855713, 0.2818411588668823, 0.8920484781265259, 0.18805184960365295, 0.2252647578716278, 0.5331477522850037, 0.352566123008728, 0.5499493479728699, 0.5557246804237366, -0.3166479170322418, -0.2595105469226837, 0.4620186388492584, 0.5448410511016846, -0.25126999616622925, 0.052081771194934845, 0.8905742168426514, 0.10802008211612701, 0.23240314424037933, -0.15432773530483246, 0.0840420126914978, -0.21982452273368835, 0.22103160619735718, -0.16959519684314728, 0.3186855912208557, 0.41824138164520264, 0.2727847993373871, -0.6417018175125122, 0.5408637523651123, -0.45784279704093933, -0.02117416076362133, -0.8568869829177856, 0.5732293725013733, 0.20811337232589722, 0.252994179725647, -0.02600470557808876, 0.14957426488399506, 1.091339349746704, 0.3019389510154724, -0.37763670086860657, 0.700101912021637, 0.273090660572052, -0.17470107972621918, 0.37041375041007996, 1.088202714920044, 0.1934192180633545, 0.5551431179046631, 0.2824849486351013, -0.8263081312179565, -0.37124931812286377, -0.08260923624038696, -1.54501473903656, -0.1537981629371643, -0.5282951593399048, -0.2277713268995285, -0.3749995529651642, -0.7801151275634766, 0.44164106249809265, -0.6974834203720093, -0.19919222593307495, 1.4396202564239502, -0.08733948320150375, -0.30081361532211304, 0.5970739722251892, 0.2854509651660919, 0.6488044261932373, 1.2330985069274902, 0.3337026834487915, -0.1785130351781845, 1.367482304573059, 0.6502318978309631, -0.12497206032276154, 0.16806082427501678, 0.1086067408323288, 0.3716900050640106, 0.422349214553833, 0.7903082370758057, -0.2365390509366989, 0.6389442086219788, -0.3052345812320709, 0.004936233628541231, -0.2457130402326584, 0.009454094804823399, -0.37278497219085693, 0.052256274968385696, 0.6020758748054504, 0.3278248608112335, -0.49284204840660095, -0.05451499670743942, 1.1618508100509644, 0.3527717590332031, 0.4322124123573303, -0.5173546075820923, -0.04629172012209892, -0.2881888151168823, -0.09480945020914078, -1.207261562347412, 0.6298953890800476, -0.31109750270843506, 0.23040162026882172, -0.36367565393447876, 0.09692006558179855, -0.38547006249427795, -0.6429955959320068, -0.1531505137681961, -0.40813395380973816, 0.31225526332855225, 0.8570601344108582, 0.44476935267448425, 0.5599588751792908, -0.6707602143287659, 0.17361792922019958, 0.0991697683930397, 1.0436170101165771, -0.4097946584224701, 0.7536075115203857, 0.9613054990768433, 0.7245225310325623, -0.5127203464508057, 0.24955801665782928, -0.015749260783195496, -0.7433528304100037, 0.9146450161933899, -0.44549763202667236, 0.38973578810691833, -0.19518573582172394, -0.4271324574947357, 0.05095500499010086, -0.19914284348487854, 0.5146521925926208, -0.7859094738960266, -0.3549114763736725, 0.10257834941148758, -0.9824370741844177, -0.0947706401348114, -1.0802034139633179, 0.7921856641769409, 0.14391496777534485, 0.45513036847114563, -0.3206154704093933, -0.21628965437412262, 4.013918399810791, 0.7311802506446838, 0.9024816155433655, 0.13190028071403503, 1.2927976846694946, 0.6550823450088501, -0.13236501812934875, -0.9541437029838562, 0.0771154835820198, -0.25441133975982666, 0.023430587723851204, 0.3171742260456085, 0.16611143946647644, 0.009057329967617989, -0.8774101138114929, 0.3416757881641388, -0.6077970862388611, -0.08281395584344864, 0.27917546033859253, -1.4064747095108032, -0.5345214605331421, -0.08020255714654922, 0.43675467371940613, -0.5289041996002197, 0.10987745970487595, 0.5413685441017151, 0.5339158177375793, -0.7782760858535767, 0.2697848677635193, -0.3866700232028961, -0.6376956701278687, -0.7586649656295776, -0.0037512772250920534, -0.006460901815444231, -0.6639900803565979, 0.5635844469070435, 0.05835140869021416, -0.14554110169410706, -0.08622266352176666, -0.12012425810098648, 0.23560315370559692, -0.22894521057605743, 0.1454964131116867, -0.09333455562591553, -1.0855861902236938, 0.8632997870445251, -0.9276081919670105, 1.042967677116394, -0.013077599927783012, -1.0682324171066284, 0.7814109921455383, -0.5143769383430481, 0.5993871688842773, -0.2484298050403595, -1.3670010566711426, -0.059301625937223434, -0.06798737496137619, -0.12312670797109604, -0.4695681035518646, 0.6597231030464172, 0.6172073483467102, 0.17803744971752167, 0.19505634903907776, -0.20246881246566772, -0.2553636431694031, 0.7538420557975769, 0.8097968101501465, -0.495086133480072, -0.5534618496894836, 0.8127090334892273, -0.5080302953720093, -0.7097209692001343, -0.22143298387527466, -0.2465866357088089, 0.1896485686302185, -0.3281773030757904, -0.3351925313472748, 0.5785992741584778, -0.38867372274398804, -0.047991637140512466, 0.2753825783729553, -0.32765454053878784, 0.19942966103553772, 0.07728179544210434, -0.1728455126285553, 0.7728938460350037, 0.6794155240058899, 0.5489075779914856, 0.41089051961898804, 0.17683634161949158, 0.22300037741661072, 0.8908536434173584, -0.07281302660703659, -0.6168807744979858, -0.8035265207290649 ]
Bilinear Quantum Monte Carlo: Expectations and Energy Differences
We propose a bilinear sampling algorithm in Green's function Monte Carlo for expectation values of operators that do not commute with the Hamiltonian and for differences between eigenvalues of different Hamiltonians. The integral representations of the Schroedinger equations are transformed into two equations whose solution has the form $\psi_a(x) t(x,y) \psi_b(y)$, where $\psi_a$ and $\psi_b$ are the wavefunctions for the two related systems and $t(x,y)$ is a kernel chosen to couple $x$ and $y$. The Monte Carlo process, with random walkers on the enlarged configuration space $x \otimes y$, solves these equations by generating densities whose asymptotic form is the above bilinear distribution. With such a distribution, exact Monte Carlo estimators can be obtained for the expectation values of quantum operators and for energy differences. We present results of these methods applied to several test problems, including a model integral equation, and the hydrogen atom.
Shiwei Zhang and M.H. Kalos
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205003
cond-mat/9205004
[ -0.3289779722690582, 0.2840455174446106, 0.35667482018470764, 0.9628807902336121, -0.5689359903335571, -0.5659794211387634, -0.31872811913490295, -0.2014324814081192, -0.3485301434993744, 0.6551425457000732, 0.42191365361213684, 0.4148886203765869, 0.29437097907066345, -0.38177868723869324, -0.6273825168609619, 0.6480123996734619, -0.03756661340594292, -0.021899577230215073, -1.3195563554763794, 0.0613376721739769, -0.1770440936088562, -0.4364076554775238, -0.9144619703292847, -0.46263498067855835, -0.24365730583667755, 0.31326866149902344, 0.004322613123804331, 0.4609942138195038, 0.7308739423751831, 0.6637557744979858, 0.448819637298584, -0.2879182994365692, 0.7353953719139099, -1.1903537511825562, -0.4459971785545349, -0.28022271394729614, 0.261525958776474, -0.5381150841712952, 0.6144497990608215, -0.29622507095336914, 1.5688396692276, 0.075553759932518, -0.16313612461090088, -0.28174352645874023, 0.04859165847301483, -0.12809599936008453, -0.1303686946630478, 0.22589866816997528, -0.2805163562297821, -1.2140470743179321, -0.145575612783432, 0.4766198694705963, -0.0802534818649292, -0.547224223613739, -0.11636583507061005, -0.1471889764070511, -0.14469943940639496, 0.49084794521331787, 0.11789721995592117, 0.021202396601438522, 0.4842836558818817, -0.16703945398330688, 0.3618965744972229, -0.24053077399730682, -0.05548888072371483, 1.0942583084106445, 0.04092332720756531, 0.5126550197601318, 0.5115085244178772, 0.23340079188346863, -0.5253105163574219, 0.12043530493974686, 0.335368275642395, -0.09316260367631912, -0.6532572507858276, 0.45040449500083923, -0.49232789874076843, -0.306459903717041, -0.5341305136680603, 0.3128544092178345, -0.14469538629055023, 0.10307973623275757, -0.44823816418647766, 0.499884694814682, -0.23369425535202026, -0.10837981849908829, -0.027154263108968735, 0.24486669898033142, 0.3510160446166992, 0.37986379861831665, 0.6348631381988525, 0.8614150285720825, 0.15499180555343628, -0.1344001591205597, 0.45156827569007874, 0.8408064246177673, -0.07522163540124893, 0.6833145618438721, 0.844842255115509, 0.2235097885131836, 0.06815987080335617, 0.833939790725708, -0.5099384188652039, 0.2111165076494217, -0.7394440770149231, 0.6672487854957581, -0.31899401545524597, 0.657941460609436, -0.0024580995086580515, -0.4119141697883606, 0.019585734233260155, 0.07416900247335434, 0.17727890610694885, 0.7474268078804016, -0.25417473912239075, 0.721604585647583, 0.39686688780784607, -0.20553268492221832, -0.038392167538404465, 0.07902251929044724, 0.32573258876800537, -0.16107453405857086, 0.5068398714065552, 0.2929393947124481, -0.38959142565727234, -0.5012505054473877, -0.31462064385414124, 0.3399573564529419, -0.40538519620895386, -0.40612977743148804, 0.16954638063907623, 0.18183490633964539, -0.3977072536945343, 0.9861821532249451, -0.3342214822769165, 0.383663535118103, 0.029270274564623833, 0.4915821850299835, 0.5025436878204346, 0.058842968195676804, 0.13540039956569672, -1.044299602508545, -0.1071837991476059, 0.9180132746696472, -0.5051180124282837, 0.18805630505084991, 0.3102739155292511, 0.5853908061981201, -0.615005612373352, 0.179295614361763, -0.8481029272079468, -0.10692447423934937, -0.21714651584625244, -0.08012979477643967, 0.5843166708946228, -0.1561184823513031, 0.31158778071403503, -0.031345125287771225, -0.4482528269290924, -0.19731922447681427, 0.5962222814559937, -0.10272221267223358, -0.09053581207990646, 0.6200900077819824, -0.16562366485595703, -0.2899499833583832, -0.7184709310531616, -0.40469810366630554, 0.16573773324489594, -0.41065526008605957, 0.16749116778373718, 0.1042834222316742, -0.06936050206422806, 0.6510752439498901, 0.5461019277572632, 0.45602795481681824, 0.5221338868141174, -0.19133944809436798, -0.03762834146618843, 0.04224754869937897, 0.014239046722650528, -0.11662072688341141, 0.7862832546234131, 0.595416784286499, 0.19219258427619934, -0.43587714433670044, -0.7295148372650146, 0.506702184677124, -0.11576104909181595, 0.4390822947025299, -0.28273656964302063, 0.1877915859222412, -0.34457477927207947, 0.48891252279281616, -0.788133442401886, 0.24622105062007904, -0.5842078328132629, 0.5782767534255981, -0.8600994944572449, -0.4595211148262024, 0.5692716240882874, -0.369897723197937, -1.260263442993164, -0.1643400639295578, -1.023833990097046, 0.15404833853244781, 0.6205803155899048, 0.2393222153186798, -0.48998942971229553, -0.18778502941131592, 0.03298962116241455, -0.27447712421417236, -0.24986878037452698, 0.13643881678581238, -0.21226716041564941, 0.18590320646762848, -0.22029921412467957, 0.1789100170135498, 0.3709838390350342, 0.34862521290779114, 0.2894161641597748, 0.27684712409973145, -0.40664541721343994, 0.7028731107711792, 0.2437770515680313, -0.8222392797470093, -0.25198131799697876, 0.32415351271629333, 0.6688182353973389, -0.13928304612636566, -0.21215595304965973, 0.6686916947364807, -0.6516426801681519, 0.48200738430023193, 0.358344167470932, 0.10565965622663498, 0.4962742328643799, 0.6054196357727051, 0.8825265765190125, -0.0621219240128994, 0.0350775383412838, 0.18642765283584595, 0.4642910957336426, -0.17548245191574097, -0.3708425462245941, 0.5791959762573242, -0.3864459693431854, 0.653184175491333, -0.732231855392456, 0.4250236749649048, -0.2106858193874359, 0.6390315890312195, 0.11282192170619965, 0.7086424231529236, -0.7349843382835388, -0.25181859731674194, 0.21766304969787598, 0.11629733443260193, -0.550396740436554, -1.1119604110717773, 0.18416953086853027, 0.47220298647880554, -0.23876966536045074, -0.4043740928173065, 0.1262822449207306, 1.225231647491455, -0.3137367367744446, 0.5070351362228394, -0.06492557376623154, 0.06313925236463547, -1.4338933229446411, -0.21647509932518005, -0.37389642000198364, 0.36288273334503174, -0.31863903999328613, -0.211933895945549, 0.7570522427558899, -0.751617968082428, 0.7897172570228577, -0.22614485025405884, -0.03658013045787811, 0.8483238220214844, -0.5074039697647095, 0.12538138031959534, -0.16843342781066895, 0.26188912987709045, -0.48965007066726685, 0.4992438554763794, -0.908311128616333, 0.17251421511173248, 0.2634887993335724, -0.45629215240478516, 0.2652534544467926, -0.3103877305984497, -0.25247979164123535, -0.151854008436203, 0.22536911070346832, -0.025973981246352196, -0.04971137270331383, 0.04788708686828613, 0.2150573879480362, 0.32846206426620483, 0.4765910506248474, -0.2453133761882782, -0.23034684360027313, 0.6353684067726135, 0.0859728753566742, -0.6796360015869141, 0.31662896275520325, 0.3345343768596649, -0.8013876080513, 0.33194756507873535, -0.10975437611341476, 0.49542585015296936, -0.31461167335510254, 1.0423765182495117, 0.6640772223472595, 0.11359994113445282, 0.4128590226173401, -1.287682294845581, -0.5636778473854065, 0.1382349282503128, -0.2232208251953125, -1.2002958059310913, -0.14369408786296844, 0.8374096155166626, -0.5482028126716614, -0.6192366480827332, 0.2649252712726593, -1.3009376525878906, -0.47612375020980835, 0.055534761399030685, 0.02866281010210514, 0.9864194989204407, 0.1038944348692894, 0.11883866041898727, -0.028042307123541832, -0.1439361423254013, 0.7197543382644653, 0.2747402489185333, 0.4794749617576599, -0.8931102156639099, 0.39258214831352234, 0.2679159939289093, 0.1809469610452652, 0.3680974543094635, 0.5787269473075867, -0.20743604004383087, 0.16081665456295013, -0.0013775466941297054, -0.7697082757949829, -0.21384742856025696, 0.28496697545051575, -0.17614780366420746, 0.4316016733646393, 0.7670414447784424, -0.703557014465332, -0.10786020755767822, -0.5072312355041504, 0.040498510003089905, -0.11643192917108536, 0.8341957926750183, 0.113345667719841, -0.43817028403282166, -0.5335534811019897, -0.3396393060684204, 0.4779914319515228, -0.13519223034381866, 0.27330711483955383, -1.0123176574707031, -0.018187399953603745, -0.5966883897781372, 0.24759285151958466, 0.20928208529949188, -0.43016988039016724, 0.4056435525417328, 0.6054078936576843, 0.4334617555141449, 0.5591446757316589, -0.02262810431420803, 0.062289927154779434, 0.04457961767911911, 0.6865242719650269, 0.25242066383361816, 0.448565810918808, 0.5937429070472717, 0.004456120543181896, -0.1938420832157135, 0.2462448924779892, -0.6443312764167786, -0.045949507504701614, -1.0893054008483887, -0.3860540986061096, -0.8623784780502319, 0.03549773991107941, -0.3121250569820404, 0.6696839332580566, -0.24054819345474243, 0.3862594962120056, 0.14359386265277863, 0.5354557633399963, 0.12388438731431961, 1.0100477933883667, 0.29119637608528137, -0.06746219098567963, -0.13826116919517517, -0.43343567848205566, 0.023785145953297615, -0.5841631889343262, 0.3929598331451416, -0.11189011484384537, -0.8131935000419617, -0.2925697863101959, -0.5782089829444885, 0.9727649092674255, -0.10001631826162338, -0.4798557460308075, 0.5157104134559631, -0.1337614506483078, 0.14077503979206085, 0.030132174491882324, -0.3119980990886688, 0.2319289743900299, 0.7146679162979126, 0.5745150446891785, -0.957801878452301, 0.33570611476898193, -0.25185662508010864, 0.5921783447265625, 0.4258589744567871, -0.2143498957157135, -0.5372266173362732, -0.5397080183029175, 0.2908954620361328, -0.9929445385932922, 0.34792494773864746, 0.6246352791786194, 0.2309323400259018, 0.5909846425056458, -0.5365536212921143, -0.3828474283218384, 0.21558645367622375, -0.356538325548172, -1.034000277519226, 0.07599694281816483, 0.1359373927116394, -0.20202451944351196, 0.7116091251373291, -0.30676594376564026, -0.5678117871284485, -0.4391184449195862, -0.38908976316452026, 1.0179193019866943, -0.34320300817489624, 0.17104531824588776, 0.14226900041103363, -0.17468397319316864, -0.007210297975689173, 1.231192708015442, 0.18194513022899628, -0.23851238191127777, -0.20271988213062286, -0.3241330683231354, -0.34286633133888245, -0.15766756236553192, 0.0365823470056057, -0.33547163009643555, 0.13718950748443604, 0.5508620142936707, 0.08277768641710281, 0.07337191700935364, 0.1680099219083786, 0.04704722762107849, -0.36786890029907227, 0.8766496777534485, -0.1326783299446106, -0.09822144359350204, -0.22562168538570404, -0.6398778557777405, -0.35585200786590576, -0.5771157741546631, 0.6367776989936829, 0.20442746579647064, 0.5346063375473022, 0.07794880121946335, -0.7415857315063477, -0.2367250770330429, 0.2597030997276306, -0.409137487411499, -0.0030177123844623566, -0.4191760718822479, -0.7260047197341919, 0.08294907212257385, -0.502608060836792, -0.7063811421394348, 0.6849384903907776, -0.165196493268013, 0.08383224159479141, 0.682038426399231, -0.009016857482492924, -0.629488468170166, 0.4580869972705841, -0.7379462122917175, 0.762747585773468, -0.02473622001707554, 0.11499201506376266, -0.5623006224632263, -0.5448159575462341, 0.37971827387809753, 0.05203475058078766, -0.24987412989139557, -0.2983470857143402, -0.2851049304008484, 0.33896300196647644, 0.04956968501210213, 0.6119041442871094, 0.044389255344867706, 0.011544881388545036, -0.49846047163009644, 1.051857829093933, -0.2704381048679352, -0.5736008286476135, -0.4357620179653168, 0.9985654950141907, -0.0978924036026001, 0.1832289844751358, 0.12588350474834442, -0.9172192811965942, -0.2346988022327423, 0.2319989800453186, 0.6356557607650757, -0.43340468406677246, -0.8712608218193054, -0.5925708413124084, -0.373977392911911, -0.1120898649096489, 0.7186620235443115, 0.3420774042606354, -0.4833638668060303, -0.3899073898792267, -0.7190614938735962, 0.19456173479557037, -0.46023988723754883, 0.04180711507797241, -0.5717641115188599, -0.3714611828327179, -0.48588183522224426, 0.6381579637527466, -0.4005308747291565, 0.0883769690990448, 0.3024010956287384, -0.15460345149040222, 0.31037214398384094, 0.39991530776023865, 0.06775308400392532, -0.6069300770759583, 0.11288746446371078, 0.2515161633491516, 0.03521183878183365, 0.3482717275619507, -0.6060298681259155, 0.5164344906806946, -0.7350904941558838, 0.6535134315490723, -0.5572803020477295, -0.5751241445541382, 0.3786862790584564, -0.08478336036205292, 0.7073107361793518, -0.9683757424354553, -0.0044718896970152855, 0.27298372983932495, -0.015350074507296085, 0.2663094699382782, -0.022207587957382202, -0.85479336977005, -0.4229903519153595, -0.9089281558990479, -0.9626724123954773, 0.11160174012184143, -0.2981218993663788, 0.16715967655181885, -0.44034552574157715, -0.08757361024618149, -0.3620224893093109, -0.964085042476654, 0.4346613883972168, 1.0796877145767212, 0.1910714954137802, 0.566914975643158, -0.26026543974876404, -0.07736804336309433, 0.1925126165151596, -0.07650676369667053, 0.45633986592292786, 0.4001428186893463, 0.15835051238536835, -0.03902783617377281, -0.8126182556152344, -0.7390654683113098, -0.7716948390007019, 0.627570629119873, 0.2812504768371582, -0.4192592203617096, 0.6219619512557983, -0.203484907746315, -0.37433573603630066, 0.2613964378833771, 0.5786669850349426, 0.3059772551059723, 0.4770107567310333, 0.2244129776954651, -0.22110295295715332, -0.28384050726890564, -0.09388327598571777, 0.15095335245132446, 0.25981608033180237, -0.6301591992378235, 0.6228163242340088, -0.5500412583351135, -0.09310942143201828, 0.8088963031768799, 0.3649400472640991, -0.49287962913513184, -0.0619647279381752, -0.8225858807563782, -0.4037410318851471, -0.07794369757175446, -0.885255753993988, -0.6372838020324707, -1.3359891176223755, -0.6303318738937378, 0.31988388299942017, 0.6042341589927673, -0.34694036841392517, -0.042929552495479584, -0.1244666650891304, 0.17232009768486023, -0.5715477466583252, -0.1315011829137802, 1.21299147605896, -0.20878130197525024, -0.6001917719841003, -0.47553130984306335, -0.255458265542984, -0.36845657229423523, 0.288216233253479, 0.6033264398574829, 0.049260202795267105, 0.8940489888191223, 0.5160905718803406, -0.06511447578668594, 0.25602400302886963, 0.4890187084674835, -0.3572338819503784, 0.3590658903121948, -0.11835364997386932, -0.8114212155342102, -0.14505064487457275, 0.060573335736989975, 0.22070035338401794, 0.9898009300231934, 0.24182584881782532, 0.2893660068511963, -0.1397891640663147, 0.18360406160354614, -0.3376701772212982, -0.897584855556488, -0.08150070160627365, -0.5098024606704712, -0.2095087468624115, -1.1192282438278198, -0.29477521777153015, -0.1904863566160202, 0.17044106125831604, 0.06560100615024567, 0.008394776843488216, -0.9703876376152039, 0.4441089332103729, 0.02502809464931488, 0.4622042775154114, 0.035746630281209946, 0.11247333139181137, -0.4044029414653778, -0.4627600610256195, -0.551888644695282, -0.29050347208976746, -0.34630483388900757, 0.12902787327766418, -0.4764944016933441, -0.283268541097641, -0.410797119140625, 0.6828761100769043, -0.8697758913040161, -0.41839921474456787, 0.5436819791793823, 0.3250105082988739, -1.0545291900634766, 0.1446750909090042, 0.18836262822151184, 0.3415612578392029, 0.589402973651886, -0.6539321541786194, -0.128423810005188, -0.2310613989830017, -1.2488021850585938, 0.20639410614967346, -0.4920785427093506, 0.6703397631645203, -0.08701180666685104, -0.19964656233787537, 0.5683172941207886, 0.47156694531440735, -0.5954998731613159, -0.2904503047466278, -0.35385510325431824, 0.07990119606256485, -0.7315685749053955, -0.4244544208049774, 0.24520860612392426, 0.07943186163902283, -0.39271318912506104, 1.1030722856521606, -0.32680729031562805, -0.20284123718738556, -0.09340991079807281, -0.004681661259382963, -0.14603890478610992, 0.48803555965423584, 0.7023053765296936, -0.26301488280296326, -0.37204983830451965, 0.7301602363586426, -0.1096111536026001, 0.12311629951000214, -0.7004018425941467, -0.16672727465629578, -0.6128345727920532, -0.008555031381547451, -0.9865834712982178, 0.5463002324104309, -0.0513681098818779, -0.30009129643440247, -0.2899530231952667, -0.28579196333885193, -0.8472477197647095, 0.33950963616371155, -1.0409493446350098, -0.589924693107605, -0.6489163041114807, -0.5174238085746765, -0.22393126785755157, 0.29284512996673584, -0.49828433990478516, 0.04980974271893501, 0.3524552583694458, 0.21534352004528046, -0.7549951076507568, -0.5650918483734131, -0.2875284254550934, 0.39779427647590637, -0.6208009123802185, 0.2854585349559784, -0.5715507864952087, 0.7143461108207703, -1.2611347436904907, -0.8030838966369629, -0.2211730033159256, 0.497510701417923, -0.5135192275047302, -0.6488792896270752, -0.5515347719192505, -0.00380687671713531, 0.19942009449005127, -0.07603693753480911, -0.3246276080608368, -0.1877516359090805, -0.4924144148826599, 0.3381454646587372, 0.0226993877440691, -0.2237381786108017, 0.4750795066356659, 0.4583593010902405, 0.29998087882995605, -0.04977886378765106, -0.17747873067855835, 0.20109577476978302, -0.09755586832761765, -0.6599993109703064, 0.8832847476005554, 0.11870907992124557, 0.6110467314720154, -0.021462393924593925, -0.8876004815101624, -0.2187248319387436, 0.1110452339053154, 0.06850080192089081, 0.7149325013160706, 0.18216946721076965, -0.049932342022657394, 0.03369138762354851, 0.23113930225372314, 0.1977892816066742, 0.09534251689910889, 0.40846115350723267, -0.2272147387266159, 0.5062497854232788, -0.2678326964378357, 0.07741554826498032, 0.3901774287223816, 0.1189926266670227, -0.48868459463119507, -0.5060836672782898, -0.07755383849143982, 0.37557435035705566, -0.35235247015953064, 0.4461800456047058, -0.7816745042800903, -0.03360297530889511, -0.5097303986549377, 0.06629036366939545, 0.36551129817962646, 0.051430072635412216, -0.305377334356308, 0.9293240308761597, 0.99876868724823, 0.503117561340332, -0.403784841299057, 0.7562983632087708, -0.25347718596458435, 1.2772090435028076, -0.30940839648246765, 0.3984467387199402, 0.4384838342666626, 0.6938985586166382, 0.042655788362026215, -0.34666937589645386, 0.2237209528684616, 0.7385774850845337, -1.4497543573379517, -0.029075879603624344, -0.6764662265777588, -0.47539713978767395, -0.48127099871635437, -0.4653211832046509, 0.483770489692688, -0.21905465424060822, 0.02686840295791626, 1.4779080152511597, -0.2863500118255615, -0.14593155682086945, 0.7953267693519592, -0.11810813099145889, 0.33415988087654114, 0.4642176926136017, 0.16095826029777527, 0.1678312122821808, 0.9249151349067688, 1.2354880571365356, -0.08356568962335587, 0.3032721281051636, -0.21898013353347778, -0.6493947505950928, 0.5101224184036255, 0.2643561065196991, -0.64007169008255, 0.03771863877773285, -0.6888733506202698, -0.08393354713916779, 0.11624102294445038, 0.43764662742614746, 0.058406468480825424, -0.5215684771537781, 0.8895668387413025, 0.2487022876739502, -0.5349352359771729, -0.15230116248130798, 0.538062572479248, 0.6756563782691956, 0.020057527348399162, -0.4996176064014435, -0.28463274240493774, 0.11564670503139496, -0.062358055263757706, -0.760802686214447, 0.49381014704704285, -0.3585301339626312, -0.3169488310813904, -0.1439126431941986, -0.3056503236293793, -0.21982470154762268, -0.516822874546051, -0.21475200355052948, -0.20246165990829468, 0.18936438858509064, 0.1548498123884201, 0.8215208649635315, 0.3537657558917999, -0.22306610643863678, 0.08416196703910828, 0.7379936575889587, 0.8230634927749634, 0.29669541120529175, 0.5546132922172546, 0.004370908252894878, 0.46381431818008423, -0.2242867648601532, 1.041229248046875, 0.533294677734375, -0.9403062462806702, 0.6426962614059448, -0.32051095366477966, 0.6060253977775574, 0.08223085105419159, -0.1264493763446808, 0.7755784392356873, 0.03175067529082298, -0.07488138973712921, -0.3335951268672943, -0.024860743433237076, 0.37715470790863037, -0.9812999963760376, 0.08910492062568665, -0.4983902871608734, 0.24955929815769196, 0.11736832559108734, 0.2195298671722412, -0.037168238312006, -0.6303128004074097, 4.355086803436279, 0.6492980718612671, 0.1199958547949791, -0.3112056255340576, 0.5602191686630249, 0.4546425938606262, 0.3620571792125702, -0.874444842338562, -0.035403210669755936, -1.1310794353485107, 0.10149706900119781, -0.2444242238998413, 0.24250075221061707, 0.09087484329938889, -0.02090511843562126, 0.283308744430542, -0.07032972574234009, 0.16331595182418823, 0.21181094646453857, -1.2564557790756226, -0.14613059163093567, 0.3763309717178345, 0.04206770658493042, -0.09036717563867569, 0.39391541481018066, -0.16031207144260406, 0.4161081910133362, -0.33723968267440796, -0.1142752468585968, -0.5290071368217468, -0.34557396173477173, -0.4917040467262268, 0.3592304289340973, -0.44237619638442993, -0.6252570748329163, 0.4417338967323303, 0.15242727100849152, 0.36488622426986694, -0.147422656416893, 0.08123032748699188, -0.06046536937355995, -0.04739934951066971, 0.5441737771034241, 0.3709982931613922, -0.06537901610136032, 0.4224265217781067, -0.3402211666107178, 0.8537648916244507, 0.19965289533138275, -0.6979923844337463, 0.6113225817680359, -0.21982590854167938, 0.5089348554611206, -0.12065315991640091, -1.5679529905319214, -0.3678688406944275, -0.3584994077682495, -0.07628264278173447, -0.6972966194152832, 0.21081341803073883, 0.6393869519233704, 0.1574539691209793, -0.5953176021575928, -0.12332206964492798, -0.38061389327049255, 0.8972574472427368, 0.17773683369159698, 0.6118881106376648, -0.2839536964893341, 0.5798152089118958, -0.49489545822143555, -0.8184341788291931, -0.059002142399549484, -0.49019286036491394, 0.7100486755371094, -0.06291021406650543, 0.03776470571756363, 0.3480742573738098, -0.26790401339530945, 0.2528194189071655, -0.053960878401994705, -0.28580331802368164, -0.3518611490726471, 0.2784979045391083, 0.34624385833740234, 1.1534069776535034, -0.3654722273349762, -0.2572616934776306, 0.7832639217376709, 0.38386404514312744, 0.03384818881750107, 1.2871025800704956, -0.03374405950307846, -0.22320230305194855, -0.6761197447776794 ]
Low Energy Behavior of Quantum Adsorption
We present an exact solution of a 1D model: a particle of incident energy $E$ colliding with a target which is a 1D harmonic ``solid slab'' with $N$ atoms in its ground state; the Hilbert space of the target is restricted to the ($N+1$) states with zero or one phonon present. For the case of a short range interaction, $V(z)$, between the particle and the surface atom supporting a bound state, an explicit non-perturbative solution of the collision problem is presented. For finite and large $N$, there is no true sticking but only so-called Feshbach resonances. A finite sticking coefficient ${\sl s}(E)$ is obtained by introducing a small phonon decay rate $\eta$ and letting $N\to\infty$. Our main interest is in the behavior of ${\sl s}(E)$ as $E\to 0$. For a short range $V(z)$, we find ${\sl s}(E)\sim E^{1/2}$, regardless of the strength of the particle-phonon coupling. However, if $V(z)$ has a Coulomb $z^{-1}$ tail, we find ${\sl s}(E)\to\alpha$, where $0 < \alpha < 1$. [A fully classical calculation gives ${\sl s}(E)\to 1$ in both cases.] We conclude that the same threshold laws apply to 3D systems of neutral and charged particles respectively.
D.P. Clougherty and W. Kohn
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205004
cond-mat/9205005
[ 0.34071192145347595, -0.4591359794139862, 0.7107908129692078, 0.015001305378973484, 0.02399882674217224, -0.6588020324707031, -0.11393740028142929, -0.4849777817726135, -0.7505795955657959, 1.2055983543395996, 1.0274021625518799, -0.22116461396217346, 1.1674654483795166, -0.3568132221698761, -0.2772420346736908, 0.43638500571250916, 0.18408676981925964, 0.275601327419281, -1.315109133720398, 0.5113614797592163, 0.6143413186073303, -0.6692377924919128, -1.022650957107544, -0.5188575983047485, -0.8083378076553345, 0.625381588935852, 0.9191983938217163, 0.6547560095787048, 0.7196483612060547, 0.7179350852966309, 0.7156110405921936, -0.8351566791534424, 0.06550455838441849, -0.45560508966445923, -0.35444799065589905, -0.17666946351528168, -0.4491158425807953, -0.137741357088089, 0.5230251550674438, -0.0246108490973711, 0.7494311928749084, -0.753719687461853, 0.02407900243997574, -0.12956355512142181, -0.5237749218940735, -0.22479204833507538, 0.6479740142822266, 0.5185501575469971, 0.4492667317390442, -1.563461184501648, 0.08882105350494385, 0.48700281977653503, 0.3322371542453766, -0.16338209807872772, -0.4083913266658783, -0.21154017746448517, 0.10483812540769577, -0.2158762514591217, -0.05906031280755997, -0.2504465878009796, 0.27251893281936646, -0.037691887468099594, 0.3506421148777008, -1.2171303033828735, -0.10627122223377228, 0.6045990586280823, -0.3184622824192047, 0.863070547580719, -0.5491613149642944, -0.26000338792800903, -0.09170080721378326, -0.35034894943237305, -0.9680929183959961, -0.032428156584501266, -0.7443946599960327, 0.2259013056755066, -0.38354724645614624, 0.21952272951602936, -0.12129631638526917, -0.23329883813858032, 0.5646508932113647, 0.14952115714550018, -0.3677465617656708, 0.17203545570373535, -0.2030973732471466, 0.371175616979599, -0.28249725699424744, 0.0159929059445858, -0.6910379528999329, 0.03189677372574806, 0.2561313807964325, 0.9235683083534241, -0.7363597750663757, 0.7048720121383667, 0.8816195726394653, 0.6068975925445557, -0.4439410865306854, 0.762333869934082, 0.32032763957977295, -0.4864881932735443, 0.7800948023796082, 1.3589750528335571, -0.40403512120246887, 0.3994969427585602, -0.5976120233535767, 0.3473171293735504, -0.2784327566623688, 0.5803982615470886, 0.03379601240158081, -0.4922415316104889, 0.3506549000740051, 0.08368481695652008, 0.1013883426785469, 0.6643772125244141, 0.37532904744148254, 0.045027025043964386, -0.3857448697090149, -0.21872293949127197, -0.8952023983001709, -0.7885512709617615, 0.7194643616676331, -0.3870171904563904, 0.7106907963752747, 0.7125070691108704, 0.21544569730758667, 0.16119688749313354, 0.7759844660758972, 0.5089727640151978, -0.1854351907968521, 0.09697455912828445, 0.9466728568077087, -0.09471601247787476, -0.08706206828355789, -0.4080648720264435, -1.0625547170639038, 0.004134350456297398, 0.17172503471374512, -0.15726657211780548, -0.3965078592300415, 0.2920648753643036, 0.4248929023742676, 0.34346991777420044, -0.024312559515237808, 1.1552467346191406, -0.05277244746685028, 0.1408267766237259, 0.5062438249588013, 0.3994903266429901, -0.005104631185531616, 0.11137626320123672, -0.459841787815094, -0.6616339683532715, 0.644318163394928, 0.06454141438007355, -0.8642922639846802, -0.23499630391597748, -0.6530479192733765, 0.23303748667240143, -0.568253755569458, -0.1415727734565735, 0.6036449074745178, 0.08531316369771957, -0.10088329762220383, 0.7880175113677979, -0.1245780885219574, 0.3886066973209381, -0.4367201030254364, -0.029554011300206184, 0.2930954098701477, -0.7458362579345703, 0.021594054996967316, 0.3987835943698883, -0.7512331008911133, 0.23323024809360504, 0.07349390536546707, 0.34303292632102966, 0.3367099463939667, -0.32851746678352356, 0.5246053338050842, 0.6500597596168518, -0.5671417117118835, -0.38912150263786316, 0.7182273864746094, 0.5717160105705261, 0.6191956996917725, -0.4060339033603668, -0.6377092599868774, -0.8431016802787781, 0.8246723413467407, 0.38817915320396423, -0.3461969196796417, -0.04088518023490906, -0.28360652923583984, 0.7951365113258362, 0.09267348796129227, 0.43623071908950806, -1.2455027103424072, 0.08974376320838928, 0.3146437704563141, -0.6213016510009766, -0.19952206313610077, 0.449627548456192, -1.1336158514022827, 0.6266815662384033, -1.0737462043762207, -0.46655330061912537, 0.21306833624839783, 0.6651835441589355, -0.8512324690818787, 0.8046274781227112, 0.09890260547399521, -0.32085728645324707, 0.45554792881011963, -0.3302338123321533, 0.2108364850282669, -0.018127519637346268, -0.6384166479110718, -0.1313844472169876, -0.0995381698012352, 0.46994835138320923, 0.6217322945594788, 0.9519152641296387, -0.05397231504321098, 0.23990610241889954, -0.2951672673225403, -0.3633793890476227, -0.09865059703588486, 0.6621648669242859, -0.10620604455471039, -0.1863248646259308, 0.002724141115322709, 0.7902185320854187, 0.022689977660775185, 1.005627989768982, 0.16667896509170532, -0.7130701541900635, 0.7565305233001709, 0.5043553113937378, 0.1899547129869461, 0.03546938672661781, -0.32443782687187195, 0.12838228046894073, 0.3469221293926239, 0.36478191614151, -0.5766956210136414, 0.4171903729438782, -0.43503355979919434, 0.5414999127388, -0.872790515422821, 0.39428940415382385, -0.1918947547674179, 0.07021614164113998, 0.5727939605712891, -0.1007009744644165, -1.603763461112976, -0.36032634973526, 0.034656595438718796, 0.5903115272521973, 0.017317337915301323, -0.6969569325447083, -0.12454291433095932, 0.12319561839103699, -0.774590790271759, -0.9297866225242615, 0.4419032633304596, 0.8238458633422852, -0.27660125494003296, 0.20791016519069672, -0.25506117939949036, -0.5464847087860107, -0.7198251485824585, -0.3908565044403076, -0.9948613047599792, 0.28205716609954834, -0.6019148826599121, 0.324687123298645, 0.7932607531547546, -0.6126623153686523, 1.475744605064392, 0.9066680669784546, -0.9755141735076904, 0.5040186047554016, 0.25080758333206177, 0.34805378317832947, 0.9398831129074097, 1.1172586679458618, -0.795727550983429, 0.7082163691520691, -0.00998514425009489, -0.19376282393932343, -0.06528196483850479, -0.6638765931129456, 0.8679774403572083, 0.3715367913246155, 0.5056380033493042, -0.1433836966753006, -0.3532092571258545, -0.23441468179225922, 0.1463894546031952, -0.787266194820404, -0.36940285563468933, 0.33744990825653076, -0.038683805614709854, 0.2636658847332001, -0.5101301074028015, 0.5719481706619263, -0.3095763623714447, -0.7361096739768982, 0.5265780091285706, 0.27520453929901123, -0.44411396980285645, 0.5227583646774292, -0.003214335534721613, 0.631763756275177, 0.0161837600171566, 1.1862049102783203, 0.6421864032745361, 0.1739208996295929, 0.02252345345914364, 0.10329487919807434, -0.4752293527126312, 0.38922417163848877, -0.12742774188518524, -0.8427788615226746, 0.18883565068244934, 0.7812340259552002, -0.21119944751262665, -1.264748215675354, 0.6875631809234619, -0.7363676428794861, -0.6585178971290588, 0.41674819588661194, -0.693148136138916, 0.4464873969554901, -0.07105740904808044, -0.074892558157444, -0.4729219675064087, -0.36537450551986694, -0.6097488403320312, 0.24298277497291565, -0.5112212300300598, 0.5454514622688293, 0.2507801353931427, 0.44339150190353394, 0.7191217541694641, 0.521854043006897, 0.3774887025356293, -0.4150432348251343, 0.4097485840320587, -0.012381533160805702, -0.4217703938484192, 0.22159597277641296, -0.17677924036979675, -0.03336847200989723, 0.5788715481758118, 0.5741271376609802, -0.8513125777244568, -1.0327810049057007, -0.5599817037582397, -0.5032899975776672, -0.23662972450256348, 0.955267071723938, -0.6012267470359802, -0.35432958602905273, -1.0084221363067627, -0.06575258821249008, -0.24484166502952576, 0.6018625497817993, 1.0121771097183228, -0.0631064623594284, 0.3368290364742279, -0.39623361825942993, -0.5959861874580383, 0.30349302291870117, 0.08679774403572083, -0.07158663123846054, 0.13672864437103271, 0.7575714588165283, 0.6367527842521667, -0.9005626440048218, -1.3524821996688843, 0.011851713992655277, 1.1923266649246216, 0.6712751984596252, 0.06834204494953156, 0.16720916330814362, -0.01555721927434206, -0.2848895788192749, -0.507993221282959, -0.7051260471343994, -0.13949048519134521, -0.4574134349822998, 0.21152126789093018, 0.06988658010959625, 0.46214693784713745, -0.4442063570022583, 0.21795688569545746, 0.15026982128620148, 0.5559340715408325, 0.5497481226921082, 0.6514453291893005, 0.2660001516342163, 0.2350485622882843, 0.7602702379226685, -0.4747164845466614, 0.5724184513092041, -0.4098491072654724, 0.9210089445114136, -0.03971663862466812, -0.1524379551410675, 0.45332449674606323, -0.23907651007175446, -0.01161046139895916, -0.5841183066368103, 0.608936607837677, 0.43181630969047546, -0.03811563551425934, 0.02661135233938694, 0.589363157749176, -0.08998054265975952, -0.634732723236084, -0.2851558029651642, 0.7720481157302856, 0.3444192111492157, 0.4945968985557556, -1.0514236688613892, -0.1635015606880188, -0.05988871306180954, 0.553480863571167, 0.7148134112358093, -0.35028076171875, -0.8019992709159851, -0.7167583107948303, -0.11194398999214172, -1.0814568996429443, 0.5491647124290466, 0.8222451210021973, -0.44498705863952637, -0.20455500483512878, -0.42698463797569275, -0.10014055669307709, 1.0636348724365234, 0.21764488518238068, -0.24723957479000092, 0.33578169345855713, 0.06508693844079971, -0.09602372348308563, 0.5552230477333069, -0.8986109495162964, 0.26601937413215637, -0.5306761264801025, -0.23295965790748596, 0.40720415115356445, -0.49066007137298584, -0.8147948980331421, -0.7129343152046204, -0.1278003603219986, -0.21907255053520203, 0.40475472807884216, 0.8198047280311584, -0.17060630023479462, 0.021898262202739716, 0.39578941464424133, -0.2890092730522156, 0.32036179304122925, 0.27094006538391113, 0.2832948863506317, 1.4786497354507446, 0.1865430623292923, 0.703407883644104, 0.253183513879776, 0.7192195653915405, -0.13692741096019745, -0.2599909007549286, 1.0113880634307861, 0.15351901948451996, -0.6627569198608398, -0.30142441391944885, 0.13262486457824707, -0.7619895339012146, -0.9082517623901367, 0.22057382762432098, -0.022676758468151093, -0.3332342505455017, 0.46600624918937683, -1.0022183656692505, -0.9523085951805115, -0.36332497000694275, -0.5294157862663269, 0.6924335360527039, -0.4731379747390747, -0.07173563539981842, 1.180077075958252, 0.048172228038311005, 0.01719694212079048, -0.5544760823249817, -0.3765745460987091, -0.6065294146537781, 0.2333887815475464, 0.8650410771369934, -0.468962162733078, 1.2797049283981323, -0.11585815995931625, 0.26467177271842957, -0.901136040687561, 0.4351939260959625, -0.6197620034217834, 0.07521653920412064, -0.5454375147819519, -0.08231697231531143, -0.2633639872074127, -0.2418156862258911, 0.15104864537715912, 0.1476844698190689, 0.18966829776763916, 0.14804115891456604, -0.1761922836303711, -0.3562798500061035, -0.34024176001548767, 0.4556311070919037, 0.15571415424346924, -0.46984776854515076, -0.33623385429382324, 0.26102733612060547, -0.3814113736152649, 0.9183463454246521, -0.15780048072338104, -1.2542026042938232, 0.14528979361057281, -0.2947491407394409, 1.3042479753494263, -1.1127023696899414, -0.21672022342681885, 0.10326418280601501, -0.3035662770271301, -0.32488584518432617, 0.9656408429145813, -0.34878045320510864, -0.5504735708236694, 0.10174532234668732, -0.6689486503601074, -0.11691328138113022, -0.2642587125301361, -0.024183213710784912, -0.29368215799331665, -0.37441661953926086, -0.8535563945770264, 0.6033773422241211, -0.7549664974212646, -0.11278599500656128, 0.4796377718448639, 0.00270312768407166, 0.4642932116985321, 0.2253114879131317, 0.8362201452255249, -0.4296889305114746, 0.12767180800437927, -0.0964808538556099, -0.17159175872802734, 0.6749124526977539, -0.5679700374603271, 0.46926090121269226, -1.1514326333999634, 0.6033617258071899, -0.09284811466932297, -0.15848910808563232, 0.08623439818620682, 0.15322403609752655, 1.0660039186477661, -1.2255226373672485, 0.1701866239309311, -0.0324522964656353, -0.0034040387254208326, 0.5316686630249023, 0.019711490720510483, -1.2285499572753906, -0.1365983933210373, -0.4911920726299286, -0.6317343711853027, 0.5105128288269043, 0.17696157097816467, 0.18314345180988312, -0.6116523146629333, -0.9210522174835205, -0.5038586854934692, -0.5395736694335938, -0.03517572581768036, 0.12569104135036469, -0.24410803616046906, -1.0569273233413696, -0.06119995191693306, -0.5545167922973633, -0.06017708033323288, 0.21950408816337585, -0.40783703327178955, 0.10499551892280579, 0.29827117919921875, -0.13817676901817322, -0.20467185974121094, -0.613575279712677, -0.07029632478952408, 0.32037153840065, 0.43651553988456726, -0.5706496834754944, 0.6329913139343262, -0.18384461104869843, -1.0259175300598145, -0.31492310762405396, -0.6085515022277832, 0.12230096757411957, -0.12742142379283905, 0.5727589130401611, 0.29708370566368103, -0.009127141907811165, 0.11517985165119171, 0.5834410786628723, -1.4382734298706055, -0.10879676043987274, 0.8763092160224915, -0.676023542881012, -0.012067539617419243, 0.7954513430595398, 0.11959768086671829, -0.5338882207870483, -0.35416606068611145, -0.8890503644943237, -0.3012823164463043, 0.35305848717689514, 0.13547483086585999, 0.10736177861690521, -1.1562985181808472, 0.03260111063718796, -0.43545135855674744, 0.5091255307197571, 0.34854570031166077, 0.19525150954723358, 0.06494361907243729, -0.6392854452133179, -0.8659559488296509, 0.6577960252761841, 1.2027859687805176, -0.2438115030527115, -0.6064878106117249, -0.4235056936740875, -0.2382013201713562, -0.25988391041755676, -0.7333343029022217, 1.1598529815673828, -0.2958950698375702, 0.497843861579895, 0.10947341471910477, 0.22779762744903564, 0.4905126094818115, 0.0461495965719223, -0.5197004675865173, 0.030043253675103188, -0.16716019809246063, -0.8169728517532349, -0.25836440920829773, -0.7529799938201904, -0.1467266082763672, 0.2825164198875427, -0.5991029739379883, 0.089034803211689, -0.48401764035224915, -0.4538174569606781, 0.3148782551288605, -1.0035789012908936, -0.0431426540017128, -1.2756977081298828, -0.8545584082603455, -0.6186721920967102, -0.17241725325584412, 0.30535563826560974, -0.12910473346710205, -0.23183922469615936, 0.3162515163421631, -0.9432389140129089, -0.29491931200027466, -0.14908969402313232, 0.519618570804596, -0.5490314960479736, -0.7889790534973145, -0.8586990833282471, 0.4024418890476227, -0.21511274576187134, -0.1308760643005371, -0.1685972511768341, -0.21405573189258575, -0.40522849559783936, 0.3939090669155121, -0.5034440159797668, 0.9432041049003601, -0.25871503353118896, -0.9211399555206299, 0.0847591832280159, -0.348621129989624, -0.4083976745605469, 0.2905551791191101, -0.5352900624275208, 0.673765242099762, 0.06120077893137932, 0.07607103884220123, -0.3734869658946991, -0.9865537881851196, -0.6459006071090698, 0.0596434511244297, -0.5617846846580505, -0.018617931753396988, -0.24615955352783203, -0.9446254372596741, 0.48918458819389343, -0.7125845551490784, -1.0411802530288696, 0.8208506107330322, -0.282766193151474, -0.14403913915157318, -0.012711494229733944, 0.48476433753967285, 0.5216516852378845, 0.15391182899475098, -0.0929841622710228, 1.1258219480514526, -0.5047593712806702, 0.5069026947021484, -0.23044103384017944, 0.5450873970985413, 0.34514230489730835, 0.7274335622787476, 0.20901115238666534, -0.37149032950401306, -0.1832655817270279, 0.6733760833740234, -0.5860726833343506, 0.03706440329551697, -0.04667780548334122, -0.6426177620887756, -0.31604012846946716, 0.4742729961872101, -0.22715753316879272, 0.3878443241119385, 0.5636253356933594, -0.4245530962944031, -0.1493285596370697, -0.4972170889377594, -0.5883806943893433, 0.37868058681488037, -1.337070107460022, -0.2387915551662445, -0.08073709160089493, -0.06876512616872787, -0.0482618622481823, -0.04772243648767471, -0.18750081956386566, -0.1396722048521042, 0.09667771309614182, -0.03954477980732918, 0.06324350088834763, 0.05914416164159775, -0.3028741776943207, 0.24072003364562988, -1.2388721704483032, -0.572657585144043, -0.3694261312484741, -0.0483352392911911, -0.6108300089836121, -1.249081015586853, 0.38610342144966125, 0.2672674357891083, -0.06358912587165833, 0.3198556900024414, -0.2614046037197113, -0.08528739959001541, 0.17096595466136932, 0.8289709687232971, 0.15888825058937073, -0.18545082211494446, -0.38030481338500977, 0.9437836408615112, -0.02590523473918438, 0.052952252328395844, 0.4353245496749878, -0.18104949593544006, 0.7138179540634155, -0.19788679480552673, 0.0959155336022377, 0.6271463632583618, 0.5064038038253784, -0.7126613855361938, 0.43316423892974854, 0.5756508111953735, 0.045840464532375336, -0.036436911672353745, -0.4957696795463562, 0.5787771940231323, 0.8155182003974915, 0.08900607377290726, 0.8050870299339294, 0.3045661449432373, 0.0011013195617124438, 0.8112481236457825, 0.5663585662841797, 0.01783134788274765, -0.23228593170642853, 0.18776309490203857, 0.03806477040052414, 0.06213207542896271, 0.23734010756015778, 0.4877990484237671, 0.4083772897720337, 0.08200681954622269, 0.05086281895637512, -0.4440836012363434, -0.1947837471961975, 0.27580609917640686, 0.36705127358436584, 0.17753739655017853, -0.3507317006587982, -0.636181652545929, -0.3974221646785736, 0.009140041656792164, 0.5347849130630493, 0.7152286171913147, -0.1688375174999237, 0.8708833456039429, 0.9620540142059326, 0.18301177024841309, -0.165415421128273, 0.45457038283348083, -0.020875737071037292, 1.211600422859192, 0.5558981895446777, 0.46829500794410706, 0.5958982706069946, 0.5190881490707397, -0.05757046118378639, -0.8273330926895142, 0.5677655935287476, 0.710638701915741, -1.0169768333435059, 0.1310264617204666, -1.101770281791687, 0.07709001004695892, -0.06577955186367035, -0.34817981719970703, 0.40552040934562683, -0.387917160987854, -0.3307187259197235, 0.14198708534240723, 0.0920020341873169, -0.4978073239326477, -0.2671380043029785, 0.18292450904846191, 0.47617265582084656, 0.599493682384491, -0.16938096284866333, 0.10785830765962601, 1.4245843887329102, 0.9581595063209534, 0.14976586401462555, 0.5184758901596069, 0.3060568571090698, -0.037304025143384933, 0.33479106426239014, 0.47780200839042664, -0.7655364274978638, 0.06728274375200272, 0.17832376062870026, -0.3360830247402191, 0.29925745725631714, 0.32893824577331543, 0.150554358959198, -0.14986586570739746, 0.27973973751068115, 0.6827926635742188, -0.4559589624404907, 0.15753665566444397, 0.6957681179046631, 0.6519845724105835, 0.137492373585701, -0.13129456341266632, -0.3348732888698578, -0.42704159021377563, -0.34041815996170044, -0.617281973361969, 0.8396007418632507, -0.18392817676067352, -0.6476026773452759, -0.7409864068031311, -0.2812080681324005, -0.40530654788017273, -0.8620139360427856, 0.47879859805107117, -0.11938172578811646, 0.733788013458252, 0.8807782530784607, 0.29004761576652527, 0.044924888759851456, -0.8390564322471619, -0.45044267177581787, -0.1962549090385437, 0.6799057126045227, -0.7814682126045227, -0.25075846910476685, 0.6163644194602966, -0.39521777629852295, 0.18046483397483826, 0.02745014801621437, 0.710763692855835, -0.5805848240852356, -0.023989802226424217, -0.6506952047348022, -0.23344653844833374, -0.10145334899425507, 0.03799237310886383, -0.21658021211624146, 0.4832717478275299, -0.35888028144836426, -0.6655767560005188, -0.3027859032154083, -0.019295142963528633, -0.7539037466049194, -0.028160307556390762, -0.7259133458137512, -0.12976588308811188, -0.571612536907196, -0.24565955996513367, 0.9354097843170166, -0.3972233235836029, 3.9421775341033936, 1.1622945070266724, 0.1681588590145111, 0.61368328332901, 1.0019410848617554, 1.2334879636764526, -0.9044972658157349, -0.0302716176956892, 0.01833328790962696, -0.6048173904418945, -0.15684641897678375, -0.0764625146985054, 0.05457562953233719, -0.08823445439338684, -0.07244059443473816, 1.0982290506362915, 0.09804701805114746, 0.004889242351055145, 0.2999655604362488, -0.7742892503738403, 0.11611785739660263, -0.10211925208568573, 0.1721695214509964, 0.5015792846679688, -0.4169039726257324, -0.016205932945013046, 0.6979674100875854, -0.670245885848999, -1.4352291822433472, -0.48102930188179016, -0.4504197835922241, -0.8827155828475952, 0.6510933041572571, -0.4470572769641876, -0.7401047348976135, 0.26735201478004456, -0.06419839709997177, -0.21696051955223083, 0.8902795910835266, -0.25511953234672546, -0.1916363537311554, -0.12863563001155853, 0.4031491279602051, -0.31289684772491455, -0.7737696766853333, 0.6942648887634277, 0.1007314994931221, 0.7354822754859924, 0.44072991609573364, -0.49808916449546814, 0.12888844311237335, 0.31862056255340576, 0.6345660090446472, -0.6821007132530212, -0.7094587087631226, 0.11575382202863693, -0.750065267086029, -0.05876493453979492, 0.43049851059913635, -0.06974302977323532, 0.6734393835067749, -0.5167672038078308, -0.10013362765312195, -0.2643531858921051, -0.5998073220252991, 0.17528580129146576, 0.8596165180206299, -0.09254466742277145, -0.186653733253479, -0.0522138848900795, -0.1640770435333252, 0.131092369556427, -0.17695915699005127, 0.3054889440536499, 0.7116715312004089, 0.32165512442588806, -0.08769861608743668, 0.5160344243049622, -0.6796091198921204, 0.22852498292922974, -0.5603740811347961, -0.4545307755470276, -0.010259760543704033, 0.36376792192459106, 0.8300825953483582, 0.30566084384918213, -0.2517429292201996, -0.04386713728308678, -0.42523670196533203, 1.0571125745773315, 0.1937447041273117, 0.8960256576538086, 0.6917299032211304, 0.055565543472766876, -0.466028094291687 ]
Z_N Phases in Hot Gauge Theories
We argue that the \zn phases of hot gauge theories cannot be realized as a real system with an Hermitean density matrix.
Wei Chen, Mikhail Dobroliubov, and Gordon Semenoff
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205005
cond-mat/9205006
[ 0.06202109530568123, -0.38918083906173706, 0.5644407868385315, -0.09122350811958313, 0.7129924297332764, -0.3618391752243042, 0.49616241455078125, -0.5637578368186951, -0.8227789998054504, 1.4228417873382568, 0.7240275740623474, -0.3475855886936188, 0.2583126127719879, -1.1846951246261597, -0.11810313910245895, 0.31284165382385254, -0.5562286972999573, -0.7673478722572327, -0.9009149074554443, 0.4895314872264862, 0.14153674244880676, -0.22083036601543427, -0.5915341377258301, -0.5087748765945435, -0.44920578598976135, 0.9985297918319702, 0.6264081001281738, 1.0339114665985107, 1.1404861211776733, 0.3872082829475403, 0.6289501786231995, -0.8384868502616882, 0.08424494415521622, -0.5850892663002014, 0.24838414788246155, 0.2651481330394745, -0.07004328072071075, -0.7443453669548035, 0.6331606507301331, 0.2674323618412018, 0.7081981897354126, -0.10039051622152328, 0.09417204558849335, -0.12013225257396698, -0.5194804668426514, 0.20412492752075195, -0.22758367657661438, -0.011618141084909439, 0.4917075037956238, -1.0142654180526733, -0.28990957140922546, -0.14268530905246735, 1.0670392513275146, -0.4315018653869629, 0.49148285388946533, -0.7203170657157898, 0.5693135857582092, 0.04617989808320999, 0.11429398506879807, 0.7125527262687683, -0.43214309215545654, 0.307552695274353, 1.0890882015228271, -1.1960899829864502, 0.22570420801639557, 0.20047497749328613, -0.01399216242134571, 0.9506043791770935, -0.19217444956302643, -0.7050907611846924, -0.33937615156173706, -0.39672741293907166, -0.2611841559410095, -0.46501851081848145, -1.1483463048934937, -0.018320415169000626, -0.3656193017959595, -0.9132435917854309, -0.6359186172485352, -1.0990651845932007, 0.054630305618047714, -0.6678890585899353, -0.041527535766363144, 0.7563343644142151, -0.2209828495979309, -0.24096867442131042, 0.1229926198720932, -0.2175237536430359, 0.7894806265830994, -0.014954558573663235, 0.4960345923900604, 0.6993470191955566, 0.06925466656684875, -0.2797077000141144, 0.6700318455696106, 0.6259506940841675, 0.24562683701515198, 0.5650498270988464, 0.17384815216064453, 0.36803120374679565, -0.03413590043783188, 0.8176587224006653, -0.23087191581726074, 1.160120964050293, -0.21817657351493835, 0.6688411831855774, 0.34063223004341125, -0.11146507412195206, 0.5235263705253601, -0.7339162230491638, 0.6648332476615906, -0.2963760197162628, 1.3042347431182861, 0.8721428513526917, -0.19750232994556427, 0.01982533372938633, 0.07334038615226746, 0.0996481403708458, -0.9245271682739258, 0.05446311831474304, 0.6085821390151978, -0.2554483413696289, 1.0907645225524902, 1.0885744094848633, -0.7047174572944641, -0.26565197110176086, 0.3489459753036499, 0.3863773047924042, 0.2145729660987854, 0.6025477647781372, 1.0903905630111694, -0.06166176125407219, -0.37129729986190796, 0.6122019290924072, -0.7727782726287842, 0.3271291255950928, -0.18396590650081635, 0.8197617530822754, 0.34336113929748535, -0.3083563446998596, 0.3983718156814575, -0.23076499998569489, 0.5570901036262512, 0.8797452449798584, 0.23209057748317719, 0.454830527305603, 0.5556041598320007, 0.5437769889831543, -0.11506041884422302, 0.1458943486213684, -0.5357282161712646, 0.061569325625896454, 0.1327306628227234, 0.05870404094457626, -0.010313707403838634, 0.588322639465332, -0.5800179839134216, 1.155015468597412, -1.2587839365005493, -0.4678897261619568, 0.8081054091453552, -0.5871974229812622, -0.07605726271867752, 0.23072203993797302, 0.1280125230550766, -0.08944276720285416, -0.5793326497077942, -0.6732783317565918, 0.563800036907196, -0.14827993512153625, -0.19537992775440216, 0.1618843525648117, -0.02366206794977188, 0.9245947003364563, 0.41726383566856384, 0.5063708424568176, 0.36901164054870605, -0.1585789918899536, -0.1898287981748581, 0.27210715413093567, -0.3565223217010498, -0.22629298269748688, 0.4576162099838257, 0.6991409063339233, -0.4616188406944275, -0.1925651729106903, -0.09691589325666428, -0.7772173881530762, 0.3299559950828552, -0.07808686792850494, 0.04670996218919754, 0.7604233026504517, -0.33952242136001587, 0.38720956444740295, -1.1400535106658936, 0.2750594913959503, -1.2366788387298584, 0.4347724914550781, -0.3500101864337921, -0.10555542260408401, -0.5873805284500122, 0.6823563575744629, -1.3162347078323364, -0.42479464411735535, -1.0069677829742432, 0.21927493810653687, 0.6842517256736755, 0.652298629283905, -0.2264607846736908, -0.6867167949676514, 0.18380145728588104, 0.1431761234998703, 0.14292849600315094, -0.053947847336530685, 0.34624433517456055, 0.1500614732503891, 0.025219134986400604, 0.5628847479820251, 0.35109156370162964, 0.7922835946083069, 0.28243908286094666, 0.5981125831604004, -0.35671475529670715, 0.8851770758628845, -0.7686576843261719, 0.04567002132534981, 0.07153359800577164, 0.6170213222503662, 0.19052524864673615, 0.33364585041999817, 0.3886536955833435, 0.8508970141410828, 0.0628349781036377, 0.4079538881778717, 0.5815424919128418, 0.430280476808548, 0.5735440254211426, 0.47819972038269043, 0.7144473195075989, -0.4844150245189667, 0.01757308840751648, 0.1847114861011505, 0.9322564005851746, -0.460931658744812, 0.41067931056022644, -0.011383599601686, -0.5144760012626648, -0.1125391349196434, -0.7751550674438477, 0.8289949893951416, -0.3289186954498291, -0.4527169167995453, -0.30147436261177063, -0.041716571897268295, -1.466066598892212, -0.2491304874420166, -0.026447994634509087, 0.4434531331062317, -0.06650185585021973, -0.6684398055076599, -0.4528610408306122, 0.06289886683225632, -0.05496867001056671, -0.3349147439002991, 0.01974613405764103, 0.5081990957260132, 0.07807277143001556, 0.05158494412899017, 0.7019136548042297, 0.05368508771061897, -1.9381088018417358, -0.588738739490509, -1.096954584121704, 0.182599738240242, -0.9153434634208679, 0.22988572716712952, 0.49493929743766785, -0.9046476483345032, 1.4046915769577026, 0.13016702234745026, 0.16747885942459106, 0.013056556694209576, 0.7908483743667603, 0.4068596661090851, 0.4261380136013031, -0.06759601831436157, -1.0994718074798584, 0.3611239492893219, -0.6955280303955078, 0.4978310763835907, -0.6742374300956726, 0.02672882378101349, 0.4398040175437927, -0.1384340226650238, -0.10035447031259537, -0.4486021399497986, -0.1296846717596054, 0.1916365772485733, -0.048219870775938034, -0.468805193901062, -0.15652091801166534, 0.3602537512779236, -0.4160013794898987, -0.32796624302864075, -0.1840025931596756, 0.990496039390564, 0.39811971783638, -0.33208703994750977, 0.4070488512516022, 0.4099709391593933, -0.7766690850257874, 0.15073150396347046, 0.5741686820983887, 0.45940110087394714, 0.010492238216102123, 0.307867169380188, 0.7741603851318359, -0.08441026508808136, 0.5081729292869568, -0.5269604921340942, -0.09618838131427765, 0.23015552759170532, 0.49026787281036377, -1.2847099304199219, 0.1574365496635437, 0.823486864566803, 0.3225465416908264, -0.8183640241622925, -0.18525159358978271, -1.4764180183410645, -0.1511213183403015, -0.5692349076271057, -0.9552809596061707, 0.886439323425293, -0.4050863981246948, -0.35403960943222046, -0.7876846790313721, -0.652611255645752, 1.2422901391983032, 0.1803363710641861, -0.6394386887550354, -0.6723020076751709, 0.5760365724563599, 0.1840260773897171, 0.6318063139915466, 0.510025680065155, 0.026397136971354485, -0.3071298599243164, -0.13674120604991913, 0.2957659661769867, -0.6161834001541138, 0.2648783326148987, 0.5542439222335815, 0.09485673159360886, -0.3089112639427185, 0.39653414487838745, -0.4279894530773163, -0.7449213862419128, -0.4917992353439331, -0.27206534147262573, 1.0077670812606812, 0.05413293465971947, -0.03332552686333656, 0.2653924822807312, -0.5545749068260193, -0.35371097922325134, -0.09458472579717636, -0.2393343448638916, 1.0171250104904175, -0.3777424991130829, 0.3002190887928009, 0.20631811022758484, -0.7897894382476807, 0.9722689390182495, -0.8228216171264648, 0.777433454990387, 0.31551045179367065, -0.11186382174491882, 0.7682362198829651, -0.5762719511985779, -0.1305076777935028, -1.0657236576080322, 0.8673551082611084, 0.3734176754951477, 0.5731812119483948, 0.852962851524353, -0.07283582538366318, -0.0462975949048996, -0.057028524577617645, -0.13788282871246338, -0.09306462109088898, -0.372883141040802, -0.5521238446235657, -0.20892728865146637, 0.04571329429745674, 0.010078354738652706, 0.8099132776260376, -0.10113158822059631, 0.7418739199638367, 0.1215871125459671, 1.2752866744995117, 0.7959491014480591, 0.2942619025707245, 0.6919263601303101, -0.2698708772659302, -0.6984713077545166, -0.10288750380277634, 0.28058165311813354, 0.6360976099967957, -0.21332480013370514, -0.5226441025733948, -0.3777685761451721, -0.06893876940011978, -0.4457911252975464, 0.7295477986335754, 0.7312588691711426, -0.8704299330711365, 0.4229936897754669, 0.5403195023536682, 0.21866965293884277, -0.030864235013723373, 0.5686001181602478, 0.5808795094490051, 0.933984100818634, 0.627048671245575, -0.6550538539886475, -0.12442517280578613, -0.01509612426161766, 0.35455775260925293, 0.46739786863327026, -0.4573828876018524, -1.3914064168930054, -0.4037613868713379, 0.5996503829956055, -0.551803708076477, -0.8002649545669556, 0.5740401148796082, 0.9869353175163269, 0.7826812267303467, -0.39662495255470276, -0.06033867597579956, 0.31177818775177, -0.3160149157047272, -0.482308030128479, -0.4270409345626831, 0.31049323081970215, -0.5945158004760742, 0.9740925431251526, -0.2527696490287781, -0.8664467930793762, -0.2538691461086273, -0.05708891153335571, 0.12721964716911316, -0.232392817735672, -0.5594226717948914, -0.1878124326467514, 0.30022940039634705, -0.6546538472175598, 0.5795260071754456, -0.44151240587234497, -0.4471547305583954, -0.2420579493045807, 0.06625574082136154, 0.6625379920005798, 0.10239854454994202, 0.45635440945625305, -0.6945804357528687, 0.9674409031867981, 0.8511801958084106, -0.2785700857639313, 0.05289922654628754, 0.16127148270606995, -0.3817847967147827, 0.29027289152145386, 0.39618656039237976, -0.05285067483782768, -0.2755495607852936, -0.7912002801895142, 0.19165290892124176, -0.3017263114452362, -0.5636372566223145, 0.23954714834690094, -0.11272265762090683, 0.49327895045280457, 0.24461087584495544, -0.6498019695281982, -0.26001062989234924, -0.15467838943004608, -1.4281076192855835, 0.42455926537513733, -0.3720000386238098, -0.24707022309303284, 0.33365991711616516, -0.2971442639827728, -0.1671045571565628, 0.14195558428764343, -0.28460344672203064, -0.02387334778904915, 0.05704893171787262, 0.29562005400657654, 0.05482891947031021, 0.48617127537727356, -0.2739446461200714, 0.8835648894309998, -0.814563512802124, 0.7311407923698425, -0.48233628273010254, -0.3373391330242157, -0.26825594902038574, -0.009731453843414783, 0.11309786885976791, -0.023401610553264618, 0.013591415248811245, -0.6579264998435974, -0.061752624809741974, 0.8141122460365295, -0.33160537481307983, -0.6330397129058838, -0.6666804552078247, 0.6628142595291138, -0.30671432614326477, -0.0022130340803414583, 0.23078258335590363, 1.0952380895614624, -0.1100105345249176, 0.3842609226703644, -0.13922478258609772, -0.09400256723165512, 0.7446373701095581, -0.27045750617980957, 0.8753708600997925, -1.0758510828018188, 0.3087250292301178, -0.369061142206192, -0.059703923761844635, -0.09535766392946243, 0.6936942934989929, -0.3086300492286682, -0.47126564383506775, -0.4841664135456085, -0.5610125660896301, -0.1800752431154251, 0.02194839157164097, 0.17338430881500244, -0.8463531732559204, -0.4183965027332306, -0.2576775848865509, 0.17739702761173248, -0.16064968705177307, 0.5583066940307617, 0.5817676186561584, -0.2885800004005432, 0.1554364711046219, 0.4319037199020386, -0.19064202904701233, 0.20851899683475494, -0.33096757531166077, 0.22543103992938995, -0.23307982087135315, 0.8233098387718201, -0.6431140899658203, 0.8157341480255127, -1.1344538927078247, 1.0089521408081055, 0.2663005292415619, -0.7663201093673706, 0.3179800808429718, 0.5566613078117371, 0.7319198846817017, -1.2771999835968018, 0.024226902052760124, 0.37805917859077454, -0.023252274841070175, 0.5574365854263306, 0.380896657705307, -1.2684998512268066, -0.5528189539909363, -0.555780827999115, -1.186964511871338, 0.34795719385147095, 0.2545755207538605, 0.06852249801158905, -0.1719026416540146, -0.5188590884208679, 0.43987855315208435, -0.08363019675016403, 0.8136252164840698, 0.8285375833511353, 0.746473491191864, -0.271777480840683, -0.03853609412908554, -0.29784518480300903, 0.0011866023996844888, 0.1975928694009781, 0.09593185037374496, -0.3623765707015991, 0.005853155627846718, 0.6459288597106934, -0.7966439127922058, -1.452651858329773, -0.4790847897529602, 0.45679542422294617, 0.27254748344421387, -0.3258610665798187, 0.8822415471076965, 0.17023923993110657, -0.0721120610833168, -0.16413728892803192, -0.607291579246521, -0.756870687007904, 0.06391803175210953, 1.3461670875549316, 0.46767592430114746, 0.4699963927268982, 0.2614898979663849, 1.0457985401153564, -0.9226261973381042, -0.5411059260368347, 0.15767158567905426, -0.25611385703086853, 0.0006207172991707921, 0.4447193741798401, 0.12487470358610153, -1.2394753694534302, -0.2871716320514679, -0.754421055316925, -0.0477498359978199, -0.24127443134784698, -0.9948787689208984, 0.024523811414837837, -0.2857677936553955, 0.17780429124832153, 0.03701971098780632, 0.2410622239112854, 0.1692681908607483, 0.4822646379470825, 0.4300284683704376, -0.528609573841095, 0.05284054949879646, -0.18455225229263306, 1.5887740850448608, -0.47257861495018005, -0.6255072355270386, -0.1627647876739502, 0.16368508338928223, -0.7023425698280334, 0.270036518573761, -0.01714564859867096, -0.5304984450340271, 0.01258701179176569, 0.02785227820277214, -0.18886122107505798, 0.3760295510292053, 0.9736332297325134, -0.5654839277267456, -0.3042045831680298, 0.6919670701026917, -0.8696385025978088, 0.35162079334259033, 0.07495729625225067, 0.10111930221319199, 0.13505640625953674, -0.5324230194091797, -0.6559288501739502, -0.0014036712236702442, -0.7356337904930115, -0.9551489353179932, -1.2347888946533203, -0.4693063795566559, -0.9808552265167236, -0.6108517646789551, -1.4726992845535278, -0.33096444606781006, -0.27401623129844666, 0.2804625928401947, 0.3773023188114166, -0.015346156433224678, -0.4944763481616974, -0.046286437660455704, -0.19185394048690796, -0.26128455996513367, 0.06202736124396324, -1.0133934020996094, -0.4153343737125397, -0.4017469882965088, -0.2606968879699707, -0.552619993686676, -0.31924930214881897, -0.2936655282974243, 0.08414832502603531, 0.35425102710723877, -0.25995755195617676, 0.412070631980896, -0.7935813069343567, -0.8493241667747498, 0.20929616689682007, 0.03769282251596451, -1.0504376888275146, 0.4555583596229553, 0.8810906410217285, -0.006448744330555201, -0.08827321231365204, 0.5389712452888489, -0.17176015675067902, 0.07017695903778076, -0.5910854339599609, 0.19051478803157806, -0.2967652678489685, -0.17052240669727325, -0.2684689462184906, -0.4866340160369873, 0.11764401942491531, 0.5284522175788879, -1.66357421875, 0.311419814825058, -0.04976607486605644, 0.8577048182487488, -0.36366018652915955, 0.034378163516521454, -0.10385531932115555, -0.029631847515702248, -0.6178772449493408, 1.1106024980545044, -0.07529895752668381, -0.641786515712738, -0.1301506608724594, -0.7708188891410828, -0.38593590259552, 0.2185036540031433, 0.09094031155109406, -0.39809536933898926, 0.012610215693712234, -0.11263716220855713, -0.38453349471092224, 0.4764172434806824, -0.5306768417358398, -0.49552682042121887, -0.6259458661079407, -0.29659926891326904, -0.11616160720586777, 0.4292795956134796, 0.2856970727443695, -0.39919325709342957, 0.033765897154808044, -0.23684856295585632, -1.3366440534591675, 0.4698042571544647, -0.1986156851053238, -0.12039299309253693, -0.4032599627971649, -0.4836753010749817, 0.17517003417015076, 0.02375839464366436, -0.5393692851066589, 0.0556686706840992, -0.41253089904785156, 0.9670290350914001, -0.9544048309326172, 0.17397326231002808, 0.052627697587013245, -0.21509377658367157, -0.9670218229293823, 0.12213132530450821, -0.927097737789154, 0.7562825679779053, 0.1109815239906311, -0.21694187819957733, 0.11801191419363022, 0.49934834241867065, -0.6557421684265137, 0.1422337144613266, 0.4063073694705963, 0.15043801069259644, -0.14044708013534546, 0.07953203469514847, 0.5530070066452026, -0.490421861410141, -0.3328554332256317, 0.9695526361465454, 0.1607608199119568, -0.07215277850627899, 0.008877413347363472, 0.5593636631965637, 0.012994633056223392, -0.29465022683143616, 0.16621506214141846, 0.2786872982978821, -0.4529905319213867, -1.0662084817886353, 0.4146590530872345, -0.15596041083335876, 0.130520761013031, 0.5753380656242371, -0.5811442732810974, -0.4908085763454437, 0.38917434215545654, 0.9033231139183044, 0.5997377634048462, 0.35104110836982727, 0.2850293517112732, 0.10387081652879715, 0.16230975091457367, 0.19534580409526825, 0.2204873114824295, 0.6216157078742981, 0.1885225623846054, 0.9010465145111084, -0.27908018231391907, 0.11501230299472809, -0.24847489595413208, 0.5404934883117676, -0.0958564504981041, -0.3077617585659027, -0.4635043442249298, -0.05563095957040787, 0.7255916595458984, 0.7775628566741943, -0.6488090753555298, -0.2804255187511444, 0.06043102964758873, 0.3821277618408203, 0.1184091567993164, -0.12541420757770538, 0.05104904621839523, 0.4330953359603882, 0.6772841215133667, 0.16989067196846008, -0.2996981739997864, 0.9299730062484741, 0.14936788380146027, 0.5783923864364624, 0.3730877935886383, 0.9235748648643494, 0.9429301619529724, 0.5349429845809937, -0.05841385945677757, -0.6906708478927612, -0.3418367803096771, 0.8675932884216309, -0.6901297569274902, -0.3096110224723816, 0.17666302621364594, -0.7034597992897034, -0.06283918768167496, -0.5735895037651062, 0.16374154388904572, -0.9399325847625732, 0.15465526282787323, 0.8542665243148804, -0.42836716771125793, -0.15337155759334564, 0.8798843622207642, -0.11813517659902573, 0.22364529967308044, 1.054780125617981, -0.544206976890564, 0.14478018879890442, 0.8412270545959473, 1.1188125610351562, -0.10046348720788956, 0.6913706660270691, 0.11785974353551865, -0.4555404782295227, 0.9372329711914062, 0.06637737900018692, -0.32132163643836975, 0.1353921741247177, -0.8051022291183472, 0.08388917148113251, -0.011739012785255909, 0.015508976764976978, -0.24870271980762482, 0.1133342981338501, 0.22976596653461456, 0.4610132873058319, -0.27884936332702637, 0.09681802988052368, 1.0576413869857788, 0.21951958537101746, -0.3572334349155426, -0.6875868439674377, -0.6423822641372681, -0.994414746761322, -0.6855010390281677, -0.198281928896904, 0.027478890493512154, 0.4454299211502075, 0.28634771704673767, -0.5016111731529236, -1.1084136962890625, -0.24775944650173187, -0.4698469042778015, -0.08496424555778503, -0.3393847942352295, 0.2673599421977997, 0.5772786140441895, 0.7262283563613892, 0.3224833011627197, -0.7159867286682129, -0.4708348214626312, -0.3051643371582031, 0.8641268610954285, -0.4162309169769287, -0.6390761733055115, 0.7857826352119446, 0.7851775884628296, -0.7875853180885315, 0.564996600151062, 0.4382624924182892, -1.0814582109451294, 0.8438169360160828, -0.5982095003128052, 0.23193012177944183, 0.5468295216560364, -0.5372377634048462, -0.12910586595535278, -0.4940422773361206, 0.3464757800102234, 0.07968476414680481, -0.26687777042388916, -0.3408573567867279, -0.26723727583885193, -0.383167564868927, -0.5452808141708374, 0.3068886697292328, -0.7144355177879333, 0.54364013671875, -0.007161522284150124, -0.40915772318840027, 3.773409366607666, 0.30760130286216736, 0.47409117221832275, -0.5278708338737488, 0.33158445358276367, 0.6792330741882324, 0.4215233623981476, -0.09351583570241928, 0.10388009995222092, -0.9806945323944092, -0.6663316488265991, 0.6583816409111023, 0.3820365071296692, -0.472933292388916, -0.8253489136695862, 0.5581687688827515, -0.7074060440063477, 0.4303545355796814, -0.5205280184745789, -1.0281046628952026, -0.47326746582984924, -0.20021739602088928, 0.18255402147769928, -0.4039594531059265, 0.19231554865837097, 0.41939958930015564, 0.5121787786483765, -1.2227232456207275, -0.9744825959205627, -0.2560734152793884, -0.8750067949295044, -1.130075216293335, 0.3630634546279907, -0.2098734974861145, -1.0825012922286987, -0.1003040075302124, 0.3759176433086395, -0.3307107388973236, 0.13369114696979523, 0.0833018571138382, 0.34044474363327026, -0.4765208065509796, 0.40967056155204773, -0.3269459009170532, -0.8556881546974182, 0.4132646322250366, -0.9232097268104553, 1.4646435976028442, 0.8231028318405151, -0.894298791885376, 0.36666733026504517, -0.3925333619117737, 0.025332896038889885, -0.008354381658136845, -0.9040725231170654, 0.14161433279514313, -0.7318252325057983, -0.03267807513475418, -0.2502514719963074, 0.14212390780448914, 0.5280001759529114, -0.06997368484735489, -0.10365795344114304, -0.323629766702652, 0.15655238926410675, 0.8237442374229431, 0.5443955659866333, 0.16996973752975464, -0.031095758080482483, -0.31425467133522034, -0.16333499550819397, 0.20570604503154755, -1.026235818862915, 0.3581846058368683, 0.3182409107685089, -0.043394554406404495, -0.33422693610191345, 0.3871418535709381, 0.5412098169326782, 0.3297387659549713, 0.1594199389219284, 0.09617627412080765, -0.3870850205421448, -0.14219243824481964, -0.3068043887615204, 1.075613260269165, -0.14656464755535126, -0.12963950634002686, -0.19841980934143066, 0.6444308161735535, 0.33661961555480957, 1.833639144897461, 0.009145918302237988, -0.010531282052397728, -1.2913620471954346 ]
Quaternion Generalization of the Laughlin State and the Three Dimensional Fractional QHE
The 3D state of strongly correlated electrons is proposed, which in the external magnetic field $\vec B$ exhibits the fractional quantum Hall effect, with the zero temperature conductivity tensor $\sigma_{ij} = (e^2/h)(1/m) \sum_k \epsilon_{ijk} B^k/\mid \vec B\mid $. The analog of Landau and Laughlin states in 3D are given using quaternion coordinates as generalization of complex coordinates. We discuss the notion of the fractional statistics in 3D introduced recently by Haldane.
A. V. Balatsky
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205006
cond-mat/9205007
[ -0.8094029426574707, 0.058722902089357376, 0.24285660684108734, 0.3746154308319092, -0.29256969690322876, -0.13844816386699677, 0.12489583343267441, -0.43307530879974365, -0.4838756322860718, 1.1618818044662476, 0.5858988165855408, -0.00540581252425909, 0.4859503507614136, -0.7779176831245422, -0.28105875849723816, 0.4864112436771393, -0.06413689255714417, -1.0353254079818726, -1.141470193862915, -0.042920954525470734, 0.3046673536300659, -0.43858277797698975, -0.23014669120311737, -0.45580849051475525, -0.6924198269844055, 0.10016212612390518, -0.10656726360321045, -0.013894166797399521, 0.9634898900985718, 0.7262144088745117, 0.8337641954421997, -0.37487417459487915, 0.08744767308235168, -0.9158482551574707, 0.11513562500476837, 0.013606003485620022, 0.02382229082286358, -0.39610719680786133, 1.0059945583343506, -0.6766586899757385, 0.922509491443634, 0.1312331259250641, 0.37178173661231995, 0.21425418555736542, 0.062228795140981674, 0.4278920888900757, -0.3319206237792969, -0.35025036334991455, -0.38447606563568115, -1.3690496683120728, 0.16905498504638672, 0.04238946735858917, 0.45432212948799133, -0.07842772454023361, 0.04920874536037445, 0.08619669824838638, -0.4370337426662445, -0.3340824246406555, -0.25776296854019165, 0.2943286895751953, 0.5678509473800659, -0.3163858950138092, 0.36073750257492065, -0.9082018136978149, -0.22340326011180878, 0.1798851639032364, -0.11840591579675674, 1.2247073650360107, -0.13331983983516693, -0.19316524267196655, -0.5640270709991455, -0.3629520535469055, -0.12790898978710175, -0.2047216147184372, -0.564117431640625, 0.6920462250709534, -0.2882956564426422, -0.46667614579200745, -0.838144838809967, -0.6010866165161133, -0.42468199133872986, -0.22433613240718842, -0.36079922318458557, 0.6759483218193054, 0.226035475730896, -0.4602448642253876, -0.1381945163011551, -0.8108466863632202, -0.18415814638137817, 0.11392128467559814, 0.7766358852386475, 1.2376426458358765, -0.28600263595581055, -0.6292959451675415, 0.34760424494743347, 0.33768999576568604, -0.279796302318573, 0.1590995490550995, 0.0005573075031861663, 0.35040804743766785, 0.25350531935691833, 0.2970206141471863, -0.08474922925233841, 1.0641909837722778, -0.8148327469825745, 1.1045751571655273, 0.08382466435432434, 0.4853467047214508, 0.05253589153289795, -0.6549696326255798, 0.2900649607181549, 0.5922622680664062, 0.3000011146068573, 0.5116819739341736, -0.1665729582309723, 0.6874313354492188, -0.01816997490823269, -0.28484705090522766, -0.54414963722229, -0.2861267030239105, 0.19271039962768555, -0.29555386304855347, 0.5190339088439941, 0.16759876906871796, 0.05311758443713188, -0.2628729045391083, 0.5933109521865845, 0.5636802315711975, 0.31999415159225464, -0.4831399917602539, -0.4967769384384155, -0.077128104865551, 0.468916118144989, 0.3811151683330536, -0.3188060522079468, 0.9249970316886902, -0.19574274122714996, 0.2768324315547943, 0.3234213590621948, 0.17737829685211182, 0.10812418907880783, -0.18874920904636383, -0.009098980575799942, 0.8802050352096558, 0.001917059882543981, 0.07713990658521652, 0.4151609241962433, 0.037648215889930725, -0.17160063982009888, 0.33644384145736694, -0.5730208158493042, 0.18587611615657806, -0.4864938259124756, -0.17261219024658203, -0.15744417905807495, 0.1548008918762207, -0.8361857533454895, 0.7492327094078064, -1.0472252368927002, -0.2113821655511856, 0.2446272075176239, -0.33370107412338257, 0.6181673407554626, 0.3062966763973236, -0.15800562500953674, -0.19498641788959503, -0.38058802485466003, -0.5141710042953491, 0.5035507678985596, -0.46775272488594055, 0.08158021420240402, 0.3949374556541443, -0.171865776181221, -0.07318919152021408, -0.2598409056663513, 0.054792534559965134, 0.6214629411697388, 0.04220815747976303, -0.43947547674179077, -0.04874108359217644, -0.26351937651634216, -0.6670548319816589, 0.2562749981880188, 0.31626570224761963, -0.002623495412990451, 0.3749355971813202, -0.428931325674057, 0.09978217631578445, 0.17399592697620392, 0.43139615654945374, 0.2232528030872345, 0.2505687475204468, -1.0369714498519897, -0.581950306892395, -0.8307323455810547, 0.20673871040344238, -0.9129603505134583, 1.208150863647461, -0.21866104006767273, -0.9969081878662109, -0.6053618788719177, 0.671948254108429, -1.4015816450119019, 0.3467983603477478, -1.1539027690887451, -0.22248871624469757, 0.977174699306488, 0.35668981075286865, -0.0921025350689888, -0.07541406154632568, 0.8539233207702637, 0.3864404857158661, -0.000355811818735674, 0.41270726919174194, -0.1894223988056183, 0.17500367760658264, 0.3882962465286255, 0.09993746876716614, 0.3220468759536743, 0.18026557564735413, 0.35437262058258057, -0.014982659369707108, -0.2233845740556717, 0.1063351035118103, 0.4166978597640991, -0.04152465611696243, 0.05937871336936951, 0.25115498900413513, 0.09277933835983276, -0.15240854024887085, -0.37399783730506897, 0.6860330700874329, 0.1982043981552124, 0.09246267378330231, 0.8814930319786072, 0.33958813548088074, 0.8487612009048462, 0.5306426286697388, 0.9956225156784058, 0.014820916578173637, 0.6546913385391235, 0.0783606544137001, 0.7782045006752014, 0.11427652835845947, 0.3615657091140747, 0.211202472448349, 0.10914198309183121, 0.09512781351804733, -0.5693215131759644, 0.35064497590065, -0.4186322093009949, 0.2511249780654907, 0.4655672311782837, 0.2690589725971222, -0.5283653736114502, 0.21416747570037842, -0.1822614073753357, 0.33905312418937683, -0.31307584047317505, -0.7434670925140381, 0.36727267503738403, -0.02636690065264702, -0.49528807401657104, 0.32502418756484985, 0.43500858545303345, 0.7262517213821411, 0.04453539103269577, 0.2846978008747101, -0.31251654028892517, -0.3481122851371765, -1.4025928974151611, -1.0768721103668213, -0.6970254182815552, -0.029286889359354973, -0.4496035873889923, 0.22769464552402496, 1.1385213136672974, -0.9283280968666077, 1.0788956880569458, 0.285025954246521, -0.11351055651903152, 0.3303109109401703, 0.47029656171798706, 0.5968698859214783, 0.5405766367912292, 0.40160754323005676, -1.0057640075683594, 1.1150051355361938, -0.6141048073768616, 0.0007211119518615305, -0.5063826441764832, -0.7255017161369324, 0.2913469076156616, -0.6134204864501953, 0.07513993978500366, -0.08878283947706223, -0.1960708647966385, -0.013199766166508198, -0.11067520081996918, -0.3043445944786072, -0.30947980284690857, 0.14192120730876923, -0.34040719270706177, -0.1439381092786789, -0.838538408279419, 1.1350668668746948, 0.4526151418685913, -0.22411468625068665, 0.09138406813144684, 0.3661385178565979, 0.021062396466732025, 0.512039065361023, -0.3572307825088501, -0.04282023385167122, -0.28889766335487366, 0.4546946585178375, 1.3632792234420776, 0.44462141394615173, 0.4530659317970276, -0.7849453687667847, -0.0984257385134697, 0.27077507972717285, 0.12020903080701828, -1.3363351821899414, 0.4972635805606842, 0.3844113349914551, -0.09673182666301727, -0.41859376430511475, 0.346782922744751, -0.9038347601890564, 0.1444634646177292, 0.19893747568130493, 0.18433599174022675, 0.7098600268363953, -0.38089919090270996, -0.03738301992416382, -0.6694636344909668, 0.4208642840385437, 0.5454602837562561, 0.16626495122909546, 0.5060222148895264, 0.029872750863432884, 0.2794687747955322, 0.22359533607959747, 0.5548768639564514, 0.21063318848609924, 0.40010929107666016, -0.07835251837968826, -0.5746836066246033, -0.15392658114433289, -0.6974961161613464, -0.25705277919769287, 0.22181683778762817, -0.07417117804288864, 0.22601592540740967, 0.10241302847862244, -0.24787834286689758, -0.735670804977417, -0.6438500881195068, 0.15457288920879364, 0.13283149898052216, 0.5175788402557373, -0.28940653800964355, 0.0840703621506691, -1.2638702392578125, -0.0745135024189949, -0.03565235063433647, -0.3947862982749939, 0.801049530506134, -0.48336559534072876, 0.4417911767959595, 0.08513717353343964, -0.4020121693611145, 0.007549883332103491, -0.5869113206863403, 0.5821199417114258, 0.6955011487007141, 0.951682984828949, 0.3615480363368988, -0.4024678170681, -0.8654557466506958, -0.4190479516983032, 0.6416967511177063, 0.6577537059783936, 0.7164088487625122, 0.15066467225551605, -0.47089850902557373, 0.2689592242240906, -0.24591825902462006, -0.5999597311019897, 0.20327676832675934, 0.4809437692165375, 0.08111036568880081, -0.22599825263023376, 0.10465148091316223, 0.01094833668321371, 0.4215720593929291, -0.03287363052368164, -0.3207016587257385, -0.11992164701223373, 0.4287453293800354, 0.17443031072616577, 0.3816564083099365, 0.5127751231193542, -0.7082643508911133, -0.755283534526825, -0.16018767654895782, 0.1257769614458084, -0.001626875950023532, -0.17349109053611755, -0.3992513120174408, -0.3999289572238922, -0.698043167591095, -0.20522552728652954, 0.4288175106048584, 0.005549062043428421, 0.46124348044395447, 0.30144086480140686, 0.022334586828947067, -0.34057480096817017, 0.07955486327409744, -0.14397290349006653, -0.02828799933195114, 0.7706661820411682, 0.7767873406410217, 0.022189974784851074, 0.2943011522293091, -0.4163605272769928, 0.9493308067321777, 0.250661700963974, 0.2315533608198166, -1.2560269832611084, 0.043328192085027695, 0.7100693583488464, -1.1954995393753052, -0.3368833661079407, 1.2525514364242554, 0.3285471200942993, -0.838422954082489, 0.21936586499214172, 0.16597166657447815, 0.533241868019104, -0.6594967842102051, -0.11396023631095886, -0.2013784646987915, -0.4464459717273712, -0.042779285460710526, 0.10639970004558563, 0.3150409162044525, -0.016906633973121643, -0.24596010148525238, -0.4316593110561371, 0.5967372059822083, -0.04639934375882149, -0.5302527546882629, 0.3257073760032654, -0.22035916149616241, -0.38008758425712585, 0.11648933589458466, -0.3510035574436188, 0.19525040686130524, 0.04643258452415466, -0.20648209750652313, -0.07520589977502823, -0.16413123905658722, 0.37995481491088867, 0.0852578654885292, 0.7386452555656433, 0.29218733310699463, 0.3369540572166443, 0.569123387336731, 0.03624727204442024, -0.12766188383102417, 0.12869448959827423, 0.1435191035270691, -0.15767714381217957, -0.6547983288764954, -0.6154426336288452, -0.23636531829833984, -0.34767383337020874, -0.29857754707336426, 0.5275959968566895, -0.2127869874238968, 0.9588385820388794, 0.5565614700317383, -0.5264502167701721, -0.29815366864204407, 0.5101526379585266, -0.6879269480705261, 0.2237493246793747, -0.33060935139656067, -0.16644980013370514, 0.1052129790186882, -0.37189313769340515, -0.4427401125431061, -0.0060669006779789925, -0.6888672709465027, -0.48877865076065063, 0.6757407188415527, 0.32807013392448425, -0.33694329857826233, 0.060325492173433304, 0.02835201285779476, 1.0011006593704224, 0.10034811496734619, 0.5080851316452026, 0.2503090500831604, -0.29983776807785034, -0.5829654932022095, -0.605213463306427, 0.3122204542160034, -0.4259799122810364, 0.34456774592399597, -0.17986266314983368, 0.3739490807056427, 0.4879850745201111, -0.28782638907432556, 0.5172040462493896, -0.43262138962745667, 0.6436823010444641, 0.1285179853439331, -0.8285290598869324, -0.1305834949016571, 0.5558426976203918, -0.1338966339826584, 0.5206828713417053, 0.17815925180912018, -0.5119054913520813, 0.12993493676185608, 0.013317299075424671, 0.35000601410865784, -1.0608803033828735, 0.0666382759809494, -0.7258067727088928, 0.02425997704267502, -0.3579734265804291, 0.3852413296699524, 0.0253385528922081, 0.042043402791023254, -0.7985708117485046, -0.2230728417634964, 0.1259288787841797, -0.061249028891325, 0.345453679561615, -0.6448924541473389, -1.0969619750976562, -1.2121556997299194, 0.5767946243286133, -0.660052478313446, 0.20108333230018616, 0.2053118348121643, -0.5471891164779663, 0.012485772371292114, 0.37703996896743774, 0.18166516721248627, 0.18022577464580536, -0.10109709203243256, 0.943760871887207, -0.10159817337989807, 0.13422119617462158, -0.259721964597702, 0.3094170391559601, -0.7910932302474976, 1.0602914094924927, 0.19400697946548462, -0.028889840468764305, 0.07873838394880295, -0.08779223263263702, 0.40948018431663513, -0.8669276237487793, -0.13098430633544922, -0.09611621499061584, -0.025861084461212158, 0.4476111829280853, -0.0697224959731102, -1.125443458557129, -0.6382409930229187, -0.3929191529750824, -0.8944204449653625, 0.38585197925567627, 0.055744122713804245, 0.03389753773808479, -0.6210858225822449, -0.3390301465988159, 0.15084239840507507, -0.49270209670066833, 0.2819287180900574, 0.8467565774917603, 0.062400367110967636, -0.5364784598350525, -0.06175999715924263, 0.6579148769378662, -0.1470676213502884, -0.012395729310810566, -0.016593515872955322, 0.04385307803750038, -0.27723854780197144, -0.16312523186206818, -0.020078593865036964, -1.010391116142273, -0.444560706615448, 0.7416600584983826, -0.07299625873565674, 0.16569764912128448, 0.776302695274353, -0.5279992818832397, -0.3518070578575134, 0.07336582243442535, -0.06297547370195389, -0.03898834437131882, 0.29738304018974304, 0.7960156798362732, 0.10110187530517578, -0.021979525685310364, -0.0658615306019783, 0.003562097903341055, -0.8652350902557373, -0.2408250868320465, 0.2465246021747589, -0.25592899322509766, -0.5035589933395386, 0.0047066593542695045, -0.008521081879734993, 0.06461109966039658, -0.15580929815769196, -0.45181992650032043, -0.04230470955371857, -0.5859634280204773, -0.9238241314888, -0.09873652458190918, 0.04682953655719757, -0.23354323208332062, 0.5115733742713928, 0.4057120084762573, 0.2824404239654541, 0.3655816316604614, 0.16493739187717438, -0.06948193162679672, -0.5256938934326172, -0.637787938117981, 1.1799603700637817, -0.5446057319641113, -0.48498132824897766, -0.5102596879005432, -1.0127149820327759, 0.1835152953863144, -1.0473672151565552, 0.7386332750320435, 0.0539003424346447, 0.4019913971424103, 0.19602452218532562, 0.3656079173088074, 0.2682850956916809, 0.5481088161468506, -0.19021163880825043, 0.6228022575378418, 0.3534563183784485, -1.001965045928955, -0.19032689929008484, -0.18749937415122986, 0.45569249987602234, 0.21499508619308472, -0.46516695618629456, 0.1843244433403015, -0.004769737832248211, -0.3955654501914978, -0.9633199572563171, -0.25676780939102173, -0.14183704555034637, -1.4024604558944702, -0.5497123003005981, -0.9240010380744934, -0.04882033169269562, 0.45208728313446045, 0.3716176450252533, -0.08069735020399094, -0.3885427713394165, -0.888836681842804, 0.29699569940567017, 0.10971768200397491, -0.03824588656425476, 0.4876137971878052, -0.07630367577075958, -0.8387871980667114, 0.08110424876213074, -0.3675708472728729, -0.16814370453357697, -0.33198875188827515, -0.024189382791519165, -0.4293723702430725, -0.13958494365215302, -0.6607351899147034, 0.6133445501327515, -0.15163470804691315, -0.6095145344734192, 0.15659107267856598, 0.3934767246246338, -0.007644900120794773, 0.6526769995689392, 0.08417991548776627, 0.06287785619497299, 0.43341851234436035, 0.36096012592315674, 0.9431608319282532, -0.04657147079706192, -0.9133387804031372, -0.3732488751411438, -0.5154579281806946, 0.17983444035053253, -0.19224798679351807, -0.07510508596897125, 0.2701803743839264, 0.3138415515422821, -0.809116005897522, 0.14388437569141388, -0.6176232099533081, 1.334369421005249, -0.08836362510919571, -0.6943716406822205, -0.5546362996101379, 0.1391177624464035, -0.6137279272079468, 0.6752699613571167, -0.5181325078010559, -0.4809337854385376, 0.017295172438025475, -0.27804508805274963, 0.1556871086359024, -0.4802052676677704, 0.0694148987531662, -0.4805726110935211, -0.07208201289176941, 0.34664246439933777, -0.39932167530059814, 0.8390935063362122, -0.5328464508056641, -0.0416162945330143, -0.6352046728134155, -0.6336422562599182, -0.4190289080142975, 0.33971670269966125, 0.24465316534042358, -0.7125770449638367, 0.11259511858224869, -0.7045405507087708, -0.5387524962425232, -0.44492921233177185, -0.6182184815406799, -0.12050104886293411, -0.32977014780044556, 0.5041666030883789, -0.07851172238588333, 0.07803811132907867, -0.16950015723705292, 0.2962479591369629, -0.6971538066864014, 0.7679567337036133, -0.6325263381004333, -0.0629325658082962, -0.5200525522232056, 0.5986065864562988, -1.0679553747177124, 0.37026479840278625, -0.2644202411174774, 0.5097060203552246, -0.13416366279125214, -1.1735727787017822, -0.22931191325187683, 0.04413226991891861, -0.1699722707271576, 0.11543957889080048, 0.1977313756942749, 0.14314530789852142, 0.3874499201774597, 0.6158262491226196, 0.2828993499279022, -0.44903475046157837, 0.03063066303730011, 0.992152988910675, -0.15299120545387268, -0.5874308347702026, 0.5807406306266785, 0.4952782392501831, -0.2296081781387329, -0.23345965147018433, -0.5199650526046753, 0.32646408677101135, 0.28078317642211914, -0.8970175981521606, 0.7574020028114319, 0.18784381449222565, 0.7373510599136353, 0.315103143453598, -0.35441091656684875, -0.2023380696773529, 0.17139661312103271, 0.12429337948560715, 0.8061877489089966, 0.7122660875320435, -0.029060181230306625, 0.6192132830619812, 0.3973757326602936, -0.7277069687843323, -0.08478288352489471, 0.3483126759529114, -0.1657567024230957, 0.9309905767440796, -0.1851370632648468, 0.911026120185852, 0.2659038007259369, 0.7786411643028259, 0.2661552429199219, -0.3340299129486084, 0.3841370940208435, -0.274877667427063, 0.4578953981399536, 0.39602258801460266, -0.9779579043388367, -0.05955715477466583, -0.08065098524093628, -0.2372121959924698, 0.530483603477478, -0.0005989570636302233, 0.042655494064092636, 0.22332336008548737, 0.7165555357933044, 0.2951453626155853, 1.005529522895813, 0.3115224838256836, 0.24588949978351593, 0.30143657326698303, -0.485899955034256, 0.7187505960464478, 0.8953791260719299, 0.7208448052406311, 0.5171979069709778, -1.1543124914169312, -0.030968261882662773, 0.38914862275123596, -1.9743082523345947, 0.39490368962287903, -0.5779799818992615, -0.03657645732164383, 0.13410736620426178, -0.816770613193512, 0.3398682773113251, -0.7665921449661255, 0.4057646095752716, 0.664517879486084, -0.30009138584136963, 0.20054005086421967, 0.8560308814048767, -0.09281051158905029, 0.4225468635559082, 0.7360014915466309, -0.39201533794403076, -0.17826040089130402, 0.9961787462234497, 0.39388659596443176, -0.5357949733734131, 0.0062558092176914215, -0.040622059255838394, -0.4916927218437195, -0.10887646675109863, 0.21518388390541077, 0.09552163630723953, -0.04156162589788437, -0.14578959345817566, -0.14365798234939575, 0.08890680968761444, -0.08652322739362717, 0.090404212474823, 0.3147221803665161, 0.1264275759458542, 0.9663200974464417, -0.14448675513267517, -0.1215556263923645, 0.5456265211105347, 0.25002893805503845, -0.23295283317565918, -0.6881383657455444, -0.7548933029174805, -0.3586220145225525, -0.6122667193412781, -0.8511000275611877, -0.1375931203365326, -0.16005828976631165, 0.5449095368385315, -0.4798474907875061, -0.5688767433166504, -0.3425803780555725, -0.9371973872184753, -0.0429379977285862, -0.1340213567018509, 1.0492616891860962, -0.6170299649238586, 0.2695516347885132, 0.09416854381561279, -0.3963910937309265, -0.11030589044094086, -0.13732808828353882, 0.8965324759483337, -0.19150403141975403, 0.35549595952033997, -0.06126376986503601, 0.8866174221038818, -0.7355178594589233, 0.26821368932724, 0.41879305243492126, -0.5935174822807312, 0.2303263247013092, -0.7279465794563293, -0.10080987960100174, 0.11025097221136093, 0.02578696422278881, 0.77748703956604, 0.35463935136795044, 0.09202858805656433, -0.1992170512676239, -0.6003801822662354, -0.5878934264183044, -0.9848330616950989, -0.4059353470802307, -0.44537076354026794, 0.14373311400413513, -0.2909875810146332, 0.8935969471931458, -0.07871761173009872, -0.3733381927013397, 4.270902633666992, 0.9709049463272095, 0.754295289516449, 0.3660167455673218, 0.6759721040725708, 0.2816954553127289, -0.2588697075843811, -0.47009170055389404, -0.08031407743692398, -0.8525883555412292, 0.2758287489414215, 0.45061829686164856, 0.3203413784503937, -0.17407357692718506, 0.38393130898475647, 1.0883160829544067, -0.28350868821144104, -0.4491252303123474, 0.42064833641052246, -0.5536539554595947, -0.37903743982315063, -0.21490639448165894, 0.34220749139785767, 0.24679061770439148, 0.10353899002075195, -0.2182052582502365, 0.3358193635940552, -0.5915091037750244, -0.634654700756073, -0.2534812390804291, -0.741438090801239, -0.5608764290809631, 0.4754280149936676, -0.183684840798378, -0.23510237038135529, 0.3786652684211731, -0.11883679032325745, -0.14065951108932495, 0.2851737439632416, 0.021855534985661507, -0.5886494517326355, -0.21078936755657196, -0.17527729272842407, 0.2703115940093994, -1.1315345764160156, 0.9199004173278809, -0.4153277277946472, 1.3560699224472046, 0.5116937160491943, -0.6601170301437378, 0.046432897448539734, 0.08006973564624786, -0.022937800735235214, -0.49042606353759766, -1.1649774312973022, 0.24884942173957825, -0.24814841151237488, -0.5771721601486206, -0.5280566215515137, 0.3215753734111786, 0.7162609696388245, -0.19621707499027252, -1.0229955911636353, -0.0897911936044693, -0.050280798226594925, 0.4372101426124573, 0.46147599816322327, 0.25027889013290405, -0.23397089540958405, 0.37655383348464966, -0.1511821150779724, -0.47834983468055725, -0.7691794037818909, -0.16439153254032135, 0.492294579744339, 0.1273416429758072, -0.1281536966562271, 0.9465206265449524, 0.0007775347912684083, 0.020113980397582054, 0.08524765819311142, -0.019345711916685104, -0.5028075575828552, 0.4649738669395447, 0.14984606206417084, 0.646574854850769, 0.13587155938148499, 0.28359782695770264, -0.5849947333335876, 0.6522087454795837, 0.8156440854072571, 1.3535715341567993, 0.005822482984513044, -0.24809010326862335, -0.7358027696609497 ]
Theory of Thermodynamic Magnetic Oscillations in Quasi-One-Dimensional Conductors
The second order correction to free energy due to the interaction between electrons is calculated for a quasi-one-dimensional conductor exposed to a magnetic field perpendicular to the chains. It is found that specific heat, magnetization and torque oscillate when the magnetic field is rotated in the plane perpendicular to the chains or when the magnitude of magnetic filed is changed. This new mechanism of thermodynamic magnetic oscillations in metals, which is not related to the presence of any closed electron orbits, is applied to explain behavior of the organic conductor (TMTSF)$_2$ClO$_4$.
Victor M. Yakovenko
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205007
cond-mat/9205008
[ 0.5241566300392151, 0.030038295313715935, 0.5979099273681641, 0.5403905510902405, -0.0006820783019065857, -0.5978187322616577, 0.0234384685754776, -0.42119300365448, -1.0160638093948364, 1.0710813999176025, 0.7418633699417114, -0.22280456125736237, 0.539145290851593, -0.7569305896759033, -0.3801577687263489, 0.4742424190044403, -0.6809069514274597, -0.6117914319038391, -1.5230555534362793, 0.3208697736263275, -0.254163920879364, -0.5374182462692261, -0.8070749044418335, -0.2294248789548874, -0.6476550698280334, 0.5983278155326843, -0.29273921251296997, 0.860048234462738, 0.6839296817779541, 0.26385602355003357, 0.6227405667304993, -0.6136220097541809, 0.0886688083410263, -0.6667963862419128, -0.3778378367424011, 0.645161509513855, 0.1820693463087082, -0.017351502552628517, 0.36890435218811035, 0.10637994855642319, 0.9395278096199036, -0.1502591073513031, 0.14930348098278046, -0.2192019522190094, -0.4555557668209076, 0.48057296872138977, -0.28364303708076477, -0.147909015417099, -0.0013131628511473536, -1.5584123134613037, 0.11109718680381775, 0.3985140323638916, 0.48768487572669983, -0.5062166452407837, -0.1241709515452385, -0.24855667352676392, -0.020327014848589897, -0.027570828795433044, -0.09241192787885666, -0.08823709934949875, -0.14105863869190216, -0.06980032473802567, 0.7235894799232483, -0.3728577792644501, -0.05443264916539192, 0.45716264843940735, -0.08607996255159378, 1.16461181640625, -0.06163657456636429, 0.016696106642484665, -0.8436408042907715, -0.331868439912796, 0.19751928746700287, 0.2610921263694763, -0.35095930099487305, 0.16099298000335693, 0.0049135033041238785, -0.9431792497634888, -0.4778824746608734, -0.6493682861328125, 0.11992707848548889, -0.04232098534703255, -0.14705823361873627, 0.44157880544662476, 0.010476389899849892, -0.3022305965423584, -0.13394048810005188, 0.11083591729402542, 0.20278088748455048, 0.49978768825531006, 0.6063096523284912, 0.7688925862312317, -0.39084067940711975, -0.09573119133710861, 0.6573482751846313, 0.8667935132980347, 0.21079111099243164, -0.1631694734096527, 0.2780459523200989, 0.566234290599823, 0.22787527740001678, 0.9242860078811646, -0.26791924238204956, 0.4863903522491455, -0.6761170625686646, 0.7751690149307251, 0.005593371577560902, -0.0677548199892044, 0.31068506836891174, -0.5989450216293335, 0.08981853723526001, -0.11411991715431213, 0.9979005455970764, 0.7526960372924805, 0.4661303460597992, 0.7583011984825134, -0.2370847463607788, -0.3120407462120056, -0.6837161779403687, -0.3233586251735687, 0.10532471537590027, -0.1825408786535263, 0.5746954679489136, 0.8948306441307068, -0.5002782344818115, -0.29150283336639404, 0.5467033982276917, 0.4766434133052826, 0.11426902562379837, -0.050552740693092346, 0.40463128685951233, -0.07075494527816772, -0.3300132751464844, 0.572195827960968, -0.32308274507522583, 0.532272219657898, 0.43079689145088196, 0.18621106445789337, 0.21011582016944885, 0.04007251188158989, 0.6651009321212769, -0.41537246108055115, 0.5229799151420593, 0.7147079110145569, 0.35084766149520874, -0.05703151226043701, 0.47996509075164795, 0.3713131844997406, 0.025177203118801117, 0.32171741127967834, -0.8501677513122559, 0.044106483459472656, 0.2955094873905182, -0.2217104136943817, -0.009857368655502796, 0.05022399127483368, -0.9750728011131287, 0.6041138768196106, -0.9935441613197327, -0.41424351930618286, 0.4868173599243164, -0.03450945392251015, -0.46555861830711365, -0.0017134631052613258, -0.15796536207199097, -0.06049241125583649, -0.5729104280471802, -0.5061016082763672, 0.8280746936798096, -0.11905232816934586, -0.45859038829803467, 0.6228190660476685, 0.21933989226818085, 0.39884209632873535, 0.017607687041163445, 0.061089105904102325, 0.595580518245697, 0.03896241635084152, -0.5031498074531555, 0.08510155975818634, -0.0645105391740799, 0.05449590086936951, 0.7944833040237427, 0.1097143143415451, 0.03234017267823219, 0.3844663202762604, -0.636539101600647, -0.618769645690918, 0.45877307653427124, 0.3303464949131012, 0.27881476283073425, 0.25006103515625, -0.6839267015457153, 0.4457111954689026, -0.25885432958602905, -0.059497613459825516, -0.9078732132911682, 0.4337922930717468, -0.5050649642944336, -0.07747200131416321, -0.1576450914144516, 0.6841633319854736, -0.9647014737129211, 0.07260576635599136, -1.426345944404602, -0.3278709650039673, 0.1724366992712021, -0.014073765836656094, -0.7899438142776489, -0.30288565158843994, 0.4103766679763794, -0.014730654656887054, -0.12349773943424225, -0.06440939754247665, 0.18004462122917175, 0.07946338504552841, -0.3204149901866913, 0.1992645263671875, 0.8100477457046509, 0.22961924970149994, 0.28396615386009216, -0.2249087691307068, -0.7775245308876038, 0.8956111669540405, -0.4889000952243805, -0.26675015687942505, 0.45650777220726013, 0.5342152714729309, 0.60215824842453, -0.1460195779800415, -0.21648725867271423, 0.6091379523277283, -0.519016444683075, 0.38033244013786316, 0.8711912035942078, 0.11550561338663101, 0.7016304135322571, 0.7965489029884338, -0.2012433558702469, -0.6173534393310547, -0.4587911367416382, 0.20693206787109375, 0.24525095522403717, 0.23650282621383667, -0.18733647465705872, 0.14076462388038635, -0.4950544834136963, 0.3313908576965332, -0.45373907685279846, 0.44422897696495056, -0.49825477600097656, 0.06267604231834412, -0.3994901180267334, -0.12159761041402817, -1.188585877418518, -0.18110932409763336, -0.28763511776924133, 0.4418347179889679, -0.20603330433368683, -0.5974982976913452, -0.4105650782585144, 0.16218391060829163, -0.32687461376190186, 0.33921441435813904, 0.16498227417469025, 1.0524884462356567, -0.10749763995409012, -0.1615772545337677, -0.0964265763759613, -0.37850120663642883, -1.7320538759231567, -0.2822055518627167, -0.5340951681137085, -0.09725635498762131, -0.23160113394260406, 0.29429927468299866, 0.6564131379127502, -0.3140733540058136, 0.4033708870410919, 0.18383009731769562, -0.05972094088792801, 0.4337032437324524, 0.19804394245147705, 0.4090069532394409, -0.007519712205976248, 0.20131173729896545, -0.9987118244171143, 0.26488226652145386, -0.4614904820919037, 0.5970715284347534, -0.5164663791656494, -0.2450055480003357, 0.5936122536659241, -0.09601929038763046, 0.6375135779380798, -0.152356818318367, -0.2227923423051834, -0.23184631764888763, 0.14463433623313904, -0.3783699870109558, -0.006613308563828468, 0.6638165712356567, -0.3312916159629822, -0.9661692380905151, -0.3509952127933502, 0.7606227993965149, -0.10309112071990967, -0.39185789227485657, 0.3996913433074951, -0.038966238498687744, -0.2828202247619629, -0.1653657704591751, -0.48840609192848206, 0.06876572221517563, -0.038615208119153976, 0.5554259419441223, 0.8496584296226501, 0.07876691222190857, 0.042306672781705856, -0.7152681946754456, -0.2718052566051483, 0.13018229603767395, 0.30777883529663086, -0.838129460811615, 0.1415957659482956, 0.6410093903541565, 0.21386320888996124, -0.573603093624115, 0.21471822261810303, -1.4834892749786377, -0.3584096133708954, 0.022997653111815453, -0.1759684532880783, 0.7047941088676453, -0.3522002100944519, -0.9018001556396484, -0.4518241286277771, -0.08849448710680008, 0.6426992416381836, 0.08193672448396683, -0.29366108775138855, -0.7324920892715454, 0.5779016017913818, 0.7845090627670288, 0.045007623732089996, -0.518740177154541, 0.537642240524292, -0.38482746481895447, -0.2231210172176361, 0.170905202627182, -0.9107869267463684, 0.16294921934604645, 0.34471067786216736, -0.08084394037723541, 0.17066024243831635, 0.5525712370872498, -0.6018995642662048, -1.138444185256958, -0.6950004696846008, -0.18718558549880981, 0.06465757638216019, 0.695951521396637, -0.2736271619796753, 0.4883691370487213, -0.5890128016471863, -0.2666451632976532, 0.6237169504165649, -0.0011013823095709085, 0.9951280355453491, -0.2881733477115631, 0.526345431804657, 0.21280281245708466, -0.27722078561782837, 0.528425931930542, -0.5290966629981995, 0.38346707820892334, 0.3131254315376282, 0.25809943675994873, 0.8286312818527222, -0.02132749743759632, -0.5993781089782715, -1.0547548532485962, 1.5371594429016113, 0.6028363108634949, 0.2638651430606842, 0.7186076641082764, -0.12234417349100113, 0.5881783366203308, -0.6598938703536987, -0.4839975833892822, -0.2073238492012024, -0.3594405949115753, -0.18030396103858948, -0.5318322777748108, 0.11404413729906082, 0.45537155866622925, 0.6610631942749023, -0.028009971603751183, -0.04244501143693924, -0.07211342453956604, 0.9356585741043091, 0.36204811930656433, 0.25099387764930725, 0.31511425971984863, -0.08700735867023468, -0.1798037439584732, -0.13266906142234802, -0.3640564978122711, 0.3167312741279602, 0.2729354202747345, -0.20037446916103363, -0.6771268248558044, -0.38488149642944336, -0.4993203580379486, 0.723797619342804, 0.4996289014816284, -0.4187467694282532, 0.5524275302886963, 0.27491748332977295, 0.5194827318191528, -0.5073686838150024, 0.5485474467277527, 0.7592381238937378, 0.7736933827400208, 0.409522145986557, -1.2312474250793457, 0.5310242176055908, 0.050299856811761856, 0.5595013499259949, 1.1765391826629639, -0.3615967035293579, -1.2552381753921509, -0.12360688298940659, 0.5218462944030762, -0.8936203718185425, -0.41680294275283813, 0.8842833042144775, -0.13980698585510254, 0.21830545365810394, -0.5326110124588013, -0.3966093063354492, 0.7640301585197449, -0.2751975655555725, -0.33812665939331055, -0.6506209969520569, 0.014696907252073288, -0.5177052617073059, 0.7405273914337158, -0.31248968839645386, -0.8788706064224243, -0.26632440090179443, -0.2596752643585205, 0.16262929141521454, -0.2576867341995239, -0.9696803689002991, 0.11327069997787476, -0.2886526882648468, -0.602899968624115, 1.0032498836517334, -0.7102332711219788, -0.05895286425948143, 0.32939794659614563, -0.14220258593559265, -0.06136181205511093, -0.20217648148536682, 0.4224525988101959, -0.2006216049194336, 1.1181344985961914, 0.39333632588386536, 0.08963430672883987, 0.09421195089817047, 0.4508460462093353, -0.7367281317710876, 0.389431357383728, 0.04837293550372124, -0.15612822771072388, -0.39877820014953613, -0.8025838732719421, 0.30418330430984497, -0.6578048467636108, -0.2990413010120392, 0.699444055557251, -0.023003267124295235, 1.1057326793670654, -0.12765513360500336, -0.7642982006072998, -0.1951468586921692, -0.40186452865600586, -0.47315970063209534, 0.7163467407226562, -0.6537050604820251, -0.1880863606929779, -0.3872135579586029, -0.20448559522628784, -0.5825513005256653, 0.478409081697464, -0.2206418216228485, -0.5987623929977417, 0.28343793749809265, 0.6753494739532471, -0.16418713331222534, 0.5076268911361694, -0.14572475850582123, 1.1743700504302979, -0.149879589676857, 0.35411766171455383, -0.23354242742061615, -0.42112094163894653, -0.5192805528640747, 0.09992676228284836, 0.38428163528442383, -0.3607868254184723, -0.3687695264816284, -0.08553396165370941, 0.36060386896133423, 0.7330001592636108, -0.29307252168655396, -0.45279374718666077, -1.2144938707351685, 0.3299052119255066, 0.09538257122039795, -0.32465237379074097, 0.23884710669517517, 1.0507988929748535, 0.09851505607366562, 0.47595837712287903, -0.1999754160642624, -0.9440889954566956, 0.6131922006607056, 0.4379213750362396, 0.6176191568374634, -1.110628366470337, -0.21176467835903168, -0.5450111627578735, -0.020230650901794434, 0.2102421075105667, 0.4487612843513489, -0.07526523619890213, -0.26169222593307495, -0.1818365752696991, -0.8227964639663696, -0.2445082664489746, 0.11239026486873627, -0.1613057553768158, -0.5155763626098633, -0.23765596747398376, -0.8362603783607483, 0.5004236698150635, 0.23302987217903137, 0.30350372195243835, 0.48138514161109924, -0.5546731948852539, -0.25839564204216003, 0.5682278275489807, 0.4383498430252075, 0.06496691703796387, -0.05289001762866974, 0.3194754123687744, -0.17009592056274414, 0.5842383503913879, -0.7930279970169067, 0.6524929404258728, -0.9375702738761902, 0.8194608688354492, -0.05318300053477287, -0.10634380578994751, -0.28554046154022217, 0.7315532565116882, 0.457209050655365, -0.6704310178756714, 0.1404898315668106, 0.48643234372138977, -0.2869924306869507, 1.056172490119934, 0.5793231129646301, -0.5207545161247253, -0.7499924898147583, -0.5013586282730103, -1.392085075378418, 0.6164629459381104, 0.19081881642341614, 0.06119148060679436, -0.15887941420078278, -0.2207328826189041, -0.16509650647640228, -0.4758957624435425, 0.8896673321723938, 0.7458214163780212, 0.27875468134880066, 0.005469007883220911, -0.0426594503223896, 0.3462880849838257, 0.6141108870506287, -0.010598458349704742, 0.520304799079895, -0.13388366997241974, -0.24685020744800568, 0.23494403064250946, -0.24520625174045563, -1.2245210409164429, -0.13951458036899567, 0.47708430886268616, 0.24111641943454742, -0.20753560960292816, 0.957237184047699, -0.23410269618034363, -0.536885142326355, 0.12265099585056305, -0.3635554313659668, -0.3805246949195862, 0.22451652586460114, 0.843569815158844, -0.07786784321069717, 0.2945805490016937, -0.07081913203001022, 0.6477094888687134, -0.4992852807044983, -0.1943458765745163, 0.315377414226532, -0.47890645265579224, -0.47101259231567383, 0.47278040647506714, 0.1322905719280243, -0.5657690167427063, -0.28920480608940125, -1.1462342739105225, -0.20879876613616943, -0.05833113193511963, -1.0006134510040283, 0.2667369842529297, -0.2992717921733856, -0.24372167885303497, 0.3755251169204712, 0.5115793347358704, 0.48411276936531067, -0.06376007199287415, 0.08868864923715591, -0.5069530010223389, -0.4412986636161804, -0.0056053888984024525, 1.1623473167419434, -0.07684320211410522, -0.5871817469596863, -0.5706000924110413, -0.34077170491218567, -0.5746708512306213, -0.12307515740394592, 0.4699823558330536, -0.060511525720357895, 0.931221604347229, -0.43269988894462585, 0.05254136025905609, 0.3480204939842224, 0.7459898591041565, -0.20230083167552948, -0.44227248430252075, -0.10239098221063614, -0.4251720905303955, 0.016263531520962715, -0.24219803512096405, 0.3226234018802643, 0.4461610019207001, -0.4870760142803192, -0.06039388105273247, -0.773443877696991, -0.24724362790584564, -0.7828391194343567, -0.7700592875480652, 0.05931958183646202, -1.0878961086273193, -0.37447836995124817, -0.7750138640403748, -0.24706217646598816, -0.17489860951900482, 0.054166052490472794, -0.13828930258750916, 0.1156945750117302, -0.8973018527030945, -0.2953270375728607, 0.08996562659740448, 0.16043129563331604, 0.24209032952785492, -0.8227481245994568, -1.1599974632263184, -0.013441821560263634, -0.46014779806137085, -0.14913509786128998, -0.3406452536582947, 0.3836066722869873, 0.17603342235088348, 0.04409962147474289, -0.630478024482727, 0.5687966346740723, -1.12264084815979, -0.4807531237602234, 0.24246713519096375, 0.2608703374862671, -0.6686714291572571, 0.32636696100234985, 0.024858158081769943, 0.01720113679766655, 0.04203111305832863, 0.20073162019252777, -0.23519054055213928, -0.012570972554385662, -0.7866623997688293, -0.16434448957443237, -0.696579098701477, -0.5175203084945679, -0.3800663650035858, -0.6169357895851135, 0.2541465163230896, 0.49339553713798523, -0.8061437606811523, 0.16864456236362457, -0.32488346099853516, 0.6542010307312012, -0.3365550935268402, 0.1107100397348404, -0.4050665497779846, -0.11103498935699463, -0.8648056983947754, 1.1869736909866333, -0.39000093936920166, -0.44825422763824463, 0.30864158272743225, -0.12812566757202148, -0.326491117477417, 0.32939210534095764, 0.33063068985939026, -0.25383514165878296, 0.5736631155014038, 0.48386213183403015, -0.24647830426692963, 0.08469945937395096, -0.5381126999855042, -0.14827096462249756, -0.7860885262489319, -0.11254560202360153, -0.311733216047287, 0.3331228196620941, 0.4344814419746399, -0.3775990903377533, 0.1274193972349167, -0.2286437451839447, -0.9264858961105347, 0.5860946774482727, -0.31332626938819885, -0.7321093082427979, -0.5751876831054688, -0.03573562204837799, -0.23009930551052094, -0.1565169095993042, 0.4130197763442993, 0.598337709903717, -0.1750820428133011, 0.23965728282928467, -0.7174217104911804, 0.1088760644197464, -0.17206904292106628, -0.1475725620985031, -1.0013725757598877, 0.18110595643520355, -0.6230524182319641, 0.7337608933448792, -0.023433584719896317, -0.16797006130218506, -0.5131675601005554, 0.6017792820930481, -0.23586738109588623, 0.00985852163285017, -0.2771781086921692, 0.08182181417942047, 0.04804956540465355, 0.314896821975708, -0.12908393144607544, -0.34156250953674316, 0.10758540779352188, 0.788271427154541, 0.20115981996059418, 0.2192009836435318, 0.08601296693086624, 0.3309515416622162, -0.117740198969841, -0.7034763693809509, -0.2806401550769806, 0.6985046863555908, 0.18447022140026093, -0.41705426573753357, 0.7715413570404053, -0.20861726999282837, 0.3659825325012207, 0.47174131870269775, -0.6632702350616455, -0.3769114017486572, 0.442687064409256, 0.19798992574214935, 0.6023412346839905, 0.41164636611938477, -0.02951023355126381, 0.5902795195579529, 0.38138332962989807, 0.3521539270877838, 0.2611183226108551, 0.5633783936500549, -0.07140616327524185, 0.8886116743087769, 0.2557266652584076, 0.5811480283737183, -0.10511085391044617, 0.373319536447525, -0.01666651852428913, -0.4814583659172058, -0.2966800034046173, -0.2502313256263733, 0.08489945530891418, 0.5276374816894531, -0.7625723481178284, -0.36861929297447205, -0.06453127413988113, -0.29767563939094543, 0.11515379697084427, -0.13199137151241302, -0.05360380560159683, 0.22296780347824097, 0.6405772566795349, 0.0825129970908165, 0.09969250857830048, 0.8578765392303467, 0.31815090775489807, 0.44765451550483704, -0.01824025623500347, 0.6524327993392944, 0.24761606752872467, 0.950489342212677, -0.1460132747888565, -0.6854010224342346, -0.19098232686519623, 0.7476897239685059, -1.1688729524612427, 0.6292810440063477, -0.6712749004364014, -0.3077826499938965, 0.2100522667169571, -0.47812843322753906, 0.32965534925460815, -0.544943630695343, 0.463517427444458, 1.1953740119934082, -0.3138623833656311, -0.10821254551410675, 0.8382201790809631, -0.05991438031196594, 0.16459067165851593, 0.9985584020614624, -0.2613372504711151, -0.5173534154891968, 0.9275791049003601, 0.5571849346160889, -0.2920500636100769, 0.4355955719947815, -0.19872234761714935, -0.4408237934112549, 0.24459795653820038, 0.10960879176855087, -0.32763198018074036, 0.16463696956634521, -0.538312554359436, -0.1441660374403, -0.07066061347723007, 0.12397927045822144, 0.23432697355747223, 0.6428180932998657, -0.12972034513950348, 0.1945418119430542, 0.005695623345673084, 0.020931901410222054, 0.8364697694778442, -0.11354899406433105, -0.5698226094245911, -0.900018572807312, -0.5820775628089905, -0.009259019047021866, -0.8893036842346191, 0.03475755453109741, 0.47457820177078247, 0.5409716367721558, 0.0987233817577362, -0.07422861456871033, -0.6481889486312866, -0.31502702832221985, -1.0676778554916382, -0.31661921739578247, -0.3934646546840668, 0.6566653251647949, -0.3876681327819824, 0.6742969751358032, 0.2276647537946701, -0.6505793333053589, 0.3256758749485016, -0.0002938409161288291, 1.0724682807922363, -0.04798786714673042, 0.13137488067150116, 0.45865797996520996, 0.0778743103146553, -0.5639193654060364, 0.5653673410415649, 0.7457020282745361, -0.2772964835166931, 0.6717531085014343, -0.43883076310157776, -0.03773104026913643, 0.4380855858325958, 0.11316930502653122, -0.12744393944740295, 0.06611926853656769, 0.5922606587409973, -0.21860568225383759, 0.05573807284235954, -0.18403349816799164, -0.5634046196937561, -0.6966192126274109, -0.38942480087280273, 0.4638494849205017, 0.06796838343143463, 0.6344130039215088, 0.09022480249404907, -0.2472650110721588, 4.238804817199707, 0.9428562521934509, 0.35603901743888855, -0.2955118715763092, 0.31847575306892395, 0.3000742197036743, 0.7615824937820435, -0.9138196706771851, 0.11049353331327438, -0.6065014600753784, -0.34242188930511475, 0.346771240234375, -0.15000537037849426, -0.3658924996852875, -0.6834792494773865, 0.5442593693733215, -0.040570151060819626, 0.08706986159086227, -0.32400867342948914, -0.9359665513038635, -0.2956717908382416, 0.27972692251205444, 0.41312143206596375, -0.24996961653232574, 0.08354043960571289, -0.06964081525802612, 0.7908820509910583, -0.5069272518157959, -0.628041684627533, -0.4370805621147156, -1.1477415561676025, -0.7840371131896973, 0.40482696890830994, -0.009705746546387672, -0.3300115168094635, 0.27367013692855835, 0.16714876890182495, -0.007652152329683304, 0.21116827428340912, 0.14761611819267273, 0.4274536073207855, -0.2868800163269043, -0.19173216819763184, 0.38398125767707825, -0.8978132009506226, 0.42299190163612366, -0.363698273897171, 1.030819058418274, 0.47933757305145264, -0.555333137512207, -0.046604376286268234, -0.20532359182834625, 0.08178482204675674, 0.35137438774108887, -1.2044942378997803, 0.2518426179885864, -0.238791361451149, -0.5153112411499023, -0.37155938148498535, 0.09020182490348816, 0.9754876494407654, -0.24596838653087616, -0.2184557467699051, -0.11533216387033463, -0.5369156002998352, 1.0066590309143066, 0.953666090965271, 0.2897936999797821, -0.4319274127483368, 0.33595535159111023, -0.7662808895111084, -0.38934019207954407, -0.739574670791626, 0.2415226846933365, 0.2301880121231079, -0.2697283923625946, 0.32033562660217285, -0.018451616168022156, 0.11871325969696045, -0.18552346527576447, 0.16756482422351837, 0.4009750187397003, -0.29272401332855225, 0.5549094676971436, -0.024840855970978737, 1.1114140748977661, 0.05083153024315834, 0.19189371168613434, -0.06803213059902191, 0.76869136095047, 0.06769009679555893, 1.5495768785476685, 0.3081477880477905, 0.18909209966659546, -1.428117036819458 ]
Metals in high magnetic field: a new universality class of Fermi liquids
Parquet equations, describing the competition between superconducting and density-wave instabilities, are solved for a three-dimensional isotropic metal in a high magnetic field when only the lowest Landau level is filled. In the case of a repulsive interaction between electrons, a phase transition to the density-wave state is found at finite temperature. In the opposite case of attractive interaction, no phase transition is found. With decreasing temperature $T$, the effective vertex of interaction between electrons renormalizes toward a one-dimensional limit in a self-similar way with the characteristic length (transverse to the magnetic field) decreasing as $\ln^{-1/6}(\omega_c/T)$ ($\omega_c$ is a cutoff). Correlation functions have new forms, previously unknown for conventional one-dimensional or three-dimensional Fermi-liquids.
Victor M. Yakovenko
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205008
cond-mat/9205009
[ 0.22307263314723969, 0.23899011313915253, 0.6631099581718445, -0.24771955609321594, 0.2475191056728363, -0.7865973711013794, 0.07450196146965027, -0.21349026262760162, -0.384871244430542, 2.0499048233032227, 0.658599317073822, 0.18068325519561768, -0.018992232158780098, -0.5595541596412659, -0.2941637933254242, 0.3223361670970917, -0.34489762783050537, -0.7173449397087097, -1.2350924015045166, 0.7750621438026428, 0.5454906225204468, -0.09689944982528687, -1.3541032075881958, -0.1976478099822998, -0.3446546494960785, 0.36482158303260803, 0.3190603256225586, -0.16381271183490753, 1.07763671875, 0.6499758958816528, 0.4679158627986908, -0.2338205724954605, -0.16687126457691193, -0.5047914385795593, 0.04012153297662735, 0.2938222587108612, 0.13341689109802246, -0.11158117651939392, 0.6824052929878235, -0.5063883662223816, 0.8449982404708862, 0.11963394284248352, 0.6643508076667786, 0.11950112134218216, -0.8060730695724487, -0.19289566576480865, -0.24960748851299286, 0.06964386254549026, 0.33376047015190125, -1.5594137907028198, 0.8290107846260071, 0.5706560611724854, 0.9010797739028931, -0.8356844782829285, -0.129071906208992, 0.5488758683204651, 0.09515485167503357, 0.7271866798400879, -0.013498920015990734, 0.010748142376542091, 0.02489396743476391, -0.01123939547687769, 0.2490677386522293, -0.9147043228149414, 0.5480442047119141, 0.000001496322511229664, -0.8145593404769897, 0.7795134782791138, 0.03618156537413597, 0.05424700677394867, -0.6135753989219666, -0.7027768492698669, -0.4405839145183563, -0.13814330101013184, -0.18760676681995392, 0.6765231490135193, -0.11693159490823746, -0.7641618251800537, -0.5699250102043152, -0.27442440390586853, -0.03079705871641636, 0.06729129701852798, -0.3965167999267578, 0.8297949433326721, -0.09882654249668121, -0.11542525887489319, 0.1182255819439888, -0.5109208822250366, -0.17608511447906494, -0.016160406172275543, 0.585527241230011, 0.8311812281608582, -0.17467567324638367, -0.026484958827495575, 0.5092114806175232, 0.31455934047698975, 0.24159161746501923, 0.6614007949829102, 0.21542476117610931, 0.37549227476119995, 0.30807894468307495, 0.15472814440727234, -0.12241201847791672, 1.006966233253479, -0.02037040889263153, 1.1446837186813354, -0.023295382037758827, 0.3941631019115448, -0.09788353741168976, -0.6682606935501099, 0.45244064927101135, 0.029833359643816948, 0.9300464391708374, 0.8040480613708496, 0.6035527586936951, 0.31687304377555847, 0.2630155682563782, -0.11987564712762833, -0.7538990378379822, -0.7479754090309143, 0.5508586168289185, 0.17504192888736725, 0.549299418926239, 0.38812145590782166, 0.10334952920675278, 0.11699327826499939, 0.18561850488185883, 0.22325372695922852, -0.39945876598358154, 0.038301002234220505, -0.5176151394844055, -0.06299243122339249, -0.4347487986087799, 0.4687139689922333, -0.45564892888069153, 0.2519738972187042, -0.26992642879486084, 0.1056220754981041, 0.02182995155453682, -0.5765191912651062, 0.6921003460884094, -0.3809329867362976, 0.3041812479496002, 1.1498268842697144, 0.34706491231918335, 0.41175296902656555, 0.7704218029975891, -0.7233723998069763, 0.3995590806007385, 0.43014514446258545, -0.6175108551979065, 0.3051398992538452, 0.027279965579509735, -0.13249225914478302, 0.056177686899900436, -0.11843209713697433, -0.3287171721458435, 0.17560243606567383, -0.8858890533447266, -0.35358309745788574, 0.8379421234130859, -0.2768189013004303, -0.2777777910232544, -0.025579694658517838, 0.13318508863449097, 0.19294673204421997, -0.7337572574615479, -0.4485633075237274, 0.12398526072502136, -0.5478760600090027, 0.06938683986663818, -0.06998703628778458, -0.13005922734737396, 0.6000832319259644, 0.8262192606925964, 0.5110809803009033, 0.2504763603210449, -0.9098262190818787, 0.13261157274246216, 0.30063873529434204, -0.5817153453826904, -0.28532159328460693, 1.08474600315094, 0.6558617353439331, 0.1251612901687622, 0.020092295482754707, -0.12161912769079208, -0.7733845710754395, -0.29464998841285706, 0.18892139196395874, -0.23208840191364288, 0.25746777653694153, -0.6769393682479858, 0.577620804309845, -1.2513134479522705, -0.4704379439353943, -0.38220372796058655, 0.486959308385849, -0.7419525384902954, -0.3232882022857666, 0.04161852225661278, 0.9815102219581604, -0.6438513398170471, 0.033953242003917694, -1.4418359994888306, 0.3670041263103485, 0.3489743769168854, 0.4839271903038025, -0.7962730526924133, 0.2649341821670532, 0.1323794424533844, -0.08891630172729492, 0.10236481577157974, 0.050827160477638245, -0.27048221230506897, 0.28200846910476685, 0.03173885866999626, 0.213117778301239, -0.09015139937400818, 0.22180117666721344, 0.772162675857544, 0.4186854064464569, -0.32669779658317566, 0.6781632304191589, 0.34575310349464417, -0.6689975261688232, -0.3035126328468323, 0.9801453351974487, 0.422124981880188, 0.3701820969581604, 0.2055668979883194, 0.5261377692222595, -0.06542334705591202, -0.022642020136117935, 0.28119635581970215, 0.5354591608047485, 0.7507923245429993, 0.9507697224617004, 0.6509348750114441, 0.12333665788173676, -0.6112406253814697, 0.22329066693782806, 0.7667037844657898, -0.25616541504859924, 0.049239639192819595, 0.594559371471405, -0.21062342822551727, -0.09262889623641968, -0.963024914264679, 0.4889061748981476, -0.35893961787223816, 0.9267244338989258, -0.17897427082061768, 0.7148047089576721, -1.073391318321228, -0.2024814933538437, -0.29068225622177124, 0.11153687536716461, -0.2644732892513275, -0.891340970993042, -0.17638325691223145, -0.27010563015937805, -0.0876079723238945, -0.532288134098053, -0.72320955991745, 0.9330368638038635, 0.18371863663196564, -0.5053289532661438, -0.019093984737992287, -0.5222512483596802, -1.2190207242965698, -0.16850844025611877, -0.8707268238067627, -0.2272893488407135, -0.6959753632545471, 0.18114306032657623, 0.11011108011007309, -0.8866621255874634, 0.24691583216190338, 0.49665266275405884, -0.0894317477941513, 0.32953763008117676, -0.4279330372810364, 0.50153648853302, 0.399927020072937, 0.13531500101089478, -0.9382588267326355, 0.43235865235328674, -1.056484580039978, 0.043225355446338654, 0.12904496490955353, -0.7177976965904236, 0.516139030456543, -0.4612635374069214, 0.36487844586372375, -0.2044251412153244, -0.014562220312654972, -0.06280671805143356, -0.14400716125965118, -0.49898916482925415, 0.1539270281791687, 0.28049880266189575, -0.7368516325950623, -0.3837531507015228, -1.1808702945709229, 0.6170850396156311, -0.06072190776467323, -0.4089421331882477, 0.41421759128570557, 0.3455877900123596, -0.3997129797935486, 0.6478830575942993, -0.41132652759552, -0.5353533029556274, -0.1595856100320816, 0.7306854128837585, 1.1093635559082031, 0.21197445690631866, -0.0477881133556366, -0.4556770920753479, -0.5976378917694092, 0.7250710129737854, 0.2983526289463043, -0.8666433095932007, 0.30366751551628113, 0.8203996419906616, 0.15764683485031128, -0.3307713568210602, 0.3779400587081909, -1.2191050052642822, -0.6659138798713684, -0.4109347462654114, -0.7939167618751526, -0.0005145243485458195, 0.12368655204772949, -0.47169575095176697, -0.7378804087638855, 0.3152562379837036, 0.7487950325012207, 0.6187721490859985, 0.4704064726829529, -0.10342905670404434, 0.5250581502914429, 0.5130833387374878, 0.32626163959503174, -0.13572144508361816, 0.7372616529464722, -0.19310680031776428, -0.8709487915039062, 0.3698823153972626, -0.6111987233161926, -0.3804304003715515, 0.3482170104980469, 0.27445679903030396, -0.473849892616272, 0.879770040512085, -0.7287008762359619, -0.4454892575740814, -0.9106014966964722, -0.43371906876564026, 0.5673787593841553, 0.04702400043606758, -0.49438536167144775, 0.27045944333076477, -0.4386083781719208, 0.21165888011455536, 0.21056224405765533, 0.048746850341558456, -0.018202561885118484, -1.311820387840271, 0.44262734055519104, 0.2920617163181305, -0.5140860676765442, -0.22020849585533142, -0.3345590829849243, 0.24879604578018188, 0.24279196560382843, 0.9485519528388977, 0.6225922703742981, -0.1631205976009369, -0.17789942026138306, 0.2671164274215698, 0.7215167284011841, 0.42888617515563965, 0.20096004009246826, 0.054661765694618225, -0.292288601398468, 0.14685505628585815, -0.16062422096729279, -0.6067904233932495, -0.2479153722524643, -0.47974562644958496, -0.2936372458934784, -0.6265381574630737, -0.6549635529518127, 0.09438920021057129, 0.5143349170684814, -0.08505306392908096, 0.59074866771698, -0.1424151360988617, 0.38982605934143066, 0.15268445014953613, 0.15200459957122803, 0.6897153854370117, 0.2681109309196472, -0.3027026057243347, 0.0000469129481643904, 0.5024359226226807, 0.6002377867698669, 0.32596224546432495, -0.4426538944244385, -0.8350416421890259, -0.5125309824943542, -0.7508376836776733, 0.3090634346008301, 0.9837628602981567, -0.6102319359779358, 0.7407929301261902, 0.18156805634498596, -0.23040059208869934, -0.042667023837566376, -0.20949441194534302, 0.39306899905204773, 0.6066184043884277, 0.5909395217895508, -1.3780755996704102, 0.24970553815364838, -0.17322254180908203, -0.22216159105300903, 0.1417531669139862, 0.6363326907157898, -1.021628975868225, -0.8227514028549194, 0.7759402394294739, -0.46987587213516235, 0.013830340467393398, 0.9525665044784546, 0.06696706265211105, 0.26818832755088806, -0.765855610370636, -0.09869520366191864, 0.35354769229888916, -0.6403331160545349, -0.7924820780754089, -0.31727126240730286, -0.012427173554897308, -0.07423560321331024, 1.0286860466003418, -0.6174417734146118, -0.5074866414070129, 0.04587269201874733, -0.171027272939682, 0.7516105771064758, -0.17879700660705566, -0.2419920265674591, 0.5143025517463684, 0.12815293669700623, -0.3505251407623291, 0.5712506175041199, -0.2596963942050934, -0.24879956245422363, 0.5861961841583252, -0.05118729546666145, 0.09170809388160706, -0.3665148913860321, 0.36225515604019165, 0.8187814950942993, 1.1706748008728027, 0.8530353307723999, 0.10307958722114563, 0.021847287192940712, 0.2162145972251892, -0.25901520252227783, 0.2680879533290863, -0.07348445057868958, -0.5836198925971985, -0.40331754088401794, -0.6151151657104492, -0.19694218039512634, 0.1356821358203888, -0.5002212524414062, 0.7065092325210571, -0.14379653334617615, 0.4081854224205017, 0.42242175340652466, -0.5073350071907043, 0.144229918718338, -0.17064319550991058, 0.22705329954624176, 0.48508626222610474, -0.9886485934257507, -0.81740403175354, -0.5255236625671387, -0.4932636320590973, -0.3691764175891876, 0.46910011768341064, -0.3215087652206421, -0.4164612293243408, 0.5485144257545471, -0.03176037594676018, -0.136079803109169, 0.7968025207519531, -0.19181674718856812, 0.3639899790287018, -0.3289426863193512, 0.2868911623954773, -0.49473151564598083, 0.03596433997154236, -0.5525391101837158, -0.3853285610675812, -0.37865492701530457, -0.4238235652446747, 0.03066546842455864, -0.1608433872461319, 0.27351340651512146, 0.5376321077346802, -0.12256602197885513, -0.4718087911605835, -0.600361704826355, -0.04282737150788307, 0.31212666630744934, -0.5232927799224854, 0.06512555480003357, 0.4553062915802002, -0.10204609483480453, -0.07046739012002945, 0.25165364146232605, -0.7261219024658203, 0.15006229281425476, 0.11694510281085968, 0.42356353998184204, -0.7155317068099976, -0.027911944314837456, -0.377389520406723, 0.006553923711180687, 0.5134660601615906, 0.31530624628067017, 0.39678457379341125, -0.6108511090278625, -0.8407648801803589, -0.3197213113307953, -0.13844208419322968, -0.4912475645542145, -0.0023811720311641693, -0.1637636125087738, -0.19515050947666168, -0.298058420419693, 0.7781025171279907, -0.776408851146698, -0.0384826585650444, 0.3278357684612274, -0.04683401808142662, 0.198105588555336, 0.49043139815330505, -0.05861759930849075, -0.34205812215805054, 0.2549389898777008, 0.17912176251411438, 0.28717610239982605, 0.4297564923763275, -0.499083936214447, 0.6227011680603027, -0.9624892473220825, 1.0497667789459229, -0.36362284421920776, -0.5453740358352661, -0.6819515824317932, 0.9178233742713928, 1.0589295625686646, -0.8003595471382141, 0.1674613505601883, 0.1712474822998047, -0.4167633056640625, 0.7426789402961731, 0.04283524677157402, -0.386168897151947, -1.1162188053131104, -0.8611379265785217, -0.97764652967453, 0.7126238346099854, 0.34233763813972473, 0.01844722405076027, -0.5092443823814392, -0.5030472874641418, -0.2055322378873825, -0.42675653100013733, 0.5032029747962952, 0.7448949217796326, 0.8552742004394531, 0.1480822116136551, 0.06417044997215271, 0.8391410708427429, -0.30749383568763733, -0.0836559385061264, 0.12216484546661377, -0.337272971868515, -0.4537971615791321, 0.15586411952972412, -0.29529160261154175, -1.4348641633987427, -0.6702521443367004, 0.489156037569046, 0.2316487431526184, -0.7816190719604492, 0.9404338002204895, -0.3540755808353424, -0.3276427984237671, -0.3749037981033325, 0.13221649825572968, -0.030770674347877502, 0.08276374638080597, 0.5059700012207031, -0.04044849053025246, 0.4646882712841034, -0.2048736810684204, 0.6573326587677002, -0.6870408654212952, -0.8854816555976868, 0.8255494236946106, -0.7146660089492798, -0.44331052899360657, 0.6709237694740295, 0.1489197313785553, -0.4437980353832245, -0.1312941163778305, -0.782525897026062, 0.2895749509334564, -0.3282182812690735, -0.3995960056781769, 0.6540788412094116, -0.6056851148605347, -0.8438980579376221, 0.6291428208351135, -0.013485773466527462, -0.3373102843761444, -0.1209295466542244, 0.13352714478969574, -0.07360666990280151, -0.49196532368659973, -0.12138882279396057, 1.3117845058441162, -0.5415438413619995, -0.20678207278251648, -0.45377910137176514, 0.26850801706314087, -0.7754945158958435, 0.38369864225387573, 0.2734518349170685, -0.4028913080692291, 0.03411219269037247, 0.47324755787849426, -0.3577691316604614, -0.15083841979503632, 0.5156630873680115, -0.16135162115097046, -0.06900668144226074, -0.1541370302438736, -0.6842474341392517, -0.7258831262588501, 0.13289447128772736, 0.4751439392566681, 0.37153729796409607, 0.11842364817857742, -0.004898958373814821, 0.06703773885965347, -0.25384384393692017, -0.5802820920944214, -0.8685477375984192, 0.41563019156455994, -1.2288596630096436, -0.33532825112342834, -0.5020415782928467, -0.48226985335350037, -0.013197563588619232, 0.32817012071609497, 0.20217153429985046, -0.9742065668106079, -0.1647590696811676, 0.12295703589916229, 0.2613966763019562, 0.4427907466888428, -0.4293261170387268, -0.48705726861953735, -0.8093528747558594, -0.1204637959599495, 0.177559033036232, -0.012308712117373943, -0.2375459522008896, 0.6328433156013489, -0.03348856046795845, 0.3158029615879059, -0.36024054884910583, 0.6695876717567444, -0.310263991355896, -0.7018972039222717, 0.1240096390247345, -0.07515129446983337, -0.7703514695167542, 0.5615442991256714, -0.2874971330165863, 0.5953537821769714, -0.1471526175737381, 0.28178244829177856, -0.5499735474586487, -0.511454164981842, -0.5841467976570129, 0.22393295168876648, -0.2513168156147003, 0.1564527451992035, -0.15619248151779175, -0.039043162018060684, -0.011246811598539352, -0.27587923407554626, -0.6100426316261292, 0.24691453576087952, -0.12993939220905304, 0.4406451880931854, 0.1076417863368988, 0.1905529797077179, -0.010039110668003559, -0.6563241481781006, -0.39321422576904297, 0.6672149300575256, -0.5803353190422058, -0.6413434743881226, 0.01589966006577015, 0.2528833746910095, -0.1985546499490738, 0.059086523950099945, 0.29384908080101013, -0.5198577046394348, 0.38038957118988037, 0.13117502629756927, -0.3852516710758209, 0.16248269379138947, 0.048612385988235474, -0.3930145800113678, -0.8186444640159607, 0.2625267505645752, -0.08177025616168976, 0.8768510222434998, 0.5478033423423767, -0.5976467132568359, -0.374942809343338, -0.43002596497535706, -1.0141609907150269, 0.14058001339435577, -0.8632029294967651, 0.1147833988070488, 0.20100298523902893, -0.3207765221595764, -0.016526933759450912, 0.36170297861099243, -0.5432142019271851, 0.5781133770942688, 0.07660828530788422, 0.6475871801376343, -0.5083280205726624, -0.23076656460762024, -0.29433223605155945, 0.6899687051773071, -0.5837109684944153, -0.23026064038276672, -0.2610059082508087, 0.6470000147819519, 0.13892093300819397, -0.5350744128227234, -0.3705126643180847, 0.25105661153793335, -0.5344287753105164, -0.3938943147659302, 0.17539139091968536, 0.26963913440704346, 0.13342823088169098, 0.11396800726652145, 0.3025108873844147, 0.04420353099703789, -0.14512984454631805, 0.1376716047525406, -0.4655451774597168, -0.3789064586162567, 0.09080058336257935, 0.21169643104076385, -0.2744561433792114, -0.460921972990036, 0.03086697682738304, 0.38994333148002625, 0.09542584419250488, -0.15433204174041748, 0.4323442280292511, 0.09487749636173248, 0.6132482886314392, 0.5538405179977417, -0.4787100553512573, -0.44651153683662415, 0.6966440677642822, 0.6078876256942749, 0.5544254779815674, -0.13962149620056152, -0.325386643409729, 0.724763035774231, 0.45410847663879395, -0.13122445344924927, 0.36043286323547363, 0.34574761986732483, 0.5433579683303833, 1.1095935106277466, 0.18642953038215637, -0.07476186752319336, 0.29121750593185425, -0.023688439279794693, -0.15004974603652954, 0.11359144747257233, -0.12751568853855133, -0.5583299994468689, -0.11429841816425323, -0.3605232536792755, -0.3931528925895691, -0.4475477933883667, -0.038846902549266815, -0.10571618378162384, 0.05628439038991928, 0.15149179100990295, 0.2519181966781616, 0.4974323511123657, 1.0742120742797852, 0.5380731821060181, 0.028062861412763596, 0.4714796245098114, 0.39662325382232666, 0.6717126965522766, -0.16449019312858582, 0.22893460094928741, 0.5354089736938477, 0.6367315053939819, 0.43056851625442505, -1.0252714157104492, -0.729607880115509, 0.13237881660461426, -0.9500865936279297, -0.24498839676380157, -0.22854997217655182, -0.28795182704925537, 0.06826438009738922, -0.8510787487030029, 0.3853132426738739, -0.02652679570019245, 0.17393876612186432, 0.9210892915725708, -0.682159960269928, 0.25955477356910706, 1.2570096254348755, 0.29722246527671814, 0.20619286596775055, 0.6517598628997803, 0.134097620844841, 0.3133666217327118, 1.3984073400497437, 0.5362058877944946, -0.4599320888519287, -0.09927168488502502, 0.026217790320515633, -0.5146373510360718, -0.03352714329957962, 0.7782378792762756, -0.08120837062597275, 0.3070906102657318, -0.5062167048454285, -0.04564294219017029, -0.3434264063835144, 0.011118813417851925, -1.0863834619522095, -0.10152072459459305, 0.17421075701713562, 0.24485453963279724, -0.5306873917579651, -0.21329323947429657, 0.6626091599464417, 0.7070682644844055, 0.09077958017587662, -0.40051302313804626, -0.6212730407714844, -0.9358132481575012, -0.16294251382350922, -0.6409721374511719, -0.0016685306327417493, -0.13257430493831635, -0.01860959641635418, -0.006020369008183479, 0.09543650597333908, -0.3560989499092102, -0.9433745741844177, -0.3647797107696533, -0.39311596751213074, 0.5897040963172913, 0.05750608444213867, 0.7625195980072021, 0.5719514489173889, -0.9651994705200195, -0.03321066126227379, -0.2809597849845886, 0.7570582032203674, -0.3112581670284271, 0.3204297125339508, 0.25218337774276733, 0.3032335340976715, -0.7949154376983643, 0.17869438230991364, 0.5500558614730835, -0.24469652771949768, 0.6914528012275696, -0.3701446056365967, -0.46154120564460754, 0.2989800274372101, -0.2219696044921875, 0.04086790606379509, 0.2895328104496002, -0.12049564719200134, -0.19485680758953094, -0.14505350589752197, -1.0211316347122192, -0.9796929359436035, 0.328764408826828, -0.8550938963890076, 0.5636149644851685, 0.20162150263786316, 0.43974530696868896, 0.1789640635251999, -0.5629981160163879, 4.232641696929932, 0.9252217411994934, 0.8515638113021851, 0.40000882744789124, 0.8927977085113525, 0.9663634896278381, -0.2144666612148285, -0.7941291332244873, 0.13770969212055206, -0.5264617204666138, -0.11946908384561539, 0.38065478205680847, -0.2604268193244934, 0.23719309270381927, -0.6737791299819946, 0.2118636518716812, -0.32104283571243286, 0.11430174112319946, -0.4294203519821167, -0.8850536346435547, -0.5038097500801086, 0.208785742521286, 0.6677550673484802, 0.000728215673007071, 0.12455809116363525, 0.14441633224487305, 0.4089028835296631, -0.28293469548225403, -0.029473135247826576, -0.9120027422904968, -0.4283693730831146, -0.8018550276756287, -0.3302885591983795, -0.1663716435432434, -0.3171796202659607, 0.4530494809150696, 0.05315682291984558, 0.1931207776069641, 0.29549357295036316, -0.7795424461364746, -0.0836937427520752, -0.24504287540912628, 0.5386389493942261, 0.12462256848812103, -0.6778724789619446, 0.40071773529052734, -0.32327303290367126, 0.6779342889785767, 0.5632612109184265, -0.5860569477081299, 0.652825117111206, -0.7602593302726746, 0.2236955463886261, 0.08845611661672592, -0.8210242986679077, 0.14779900014400482, -0.30525919795036316, -0.35475414991378784, -0.018492363393306732, 0.4634466767311096, 0.8083991408348083, -0.047026555985212326, -0.3663308620452881, 0.060182467103004456, -0.08130587637424469, 0.9285137057304382, 0.30178800225257874, 0.5635762214660645, -0.8171202540397644, 0.7487545013427734, -0.5290400385856628, 0.07673005014657974, -0.4697889983654022, -0.2806825041770935, 0.35632720589637756, -0.03840929642319679, -0.576631486415863, 0.20066361129283905, 0.6216474175453186, -0.0355299636721611, 0.53326815366745, 0.0030835934448987246, 0.061075855046510696, -0.2393607497215271, 0.011695414781570435, 0.703178882598877, 0.5639166235923767, 0.4471175968647003, 0.42772039771080017, 1.0901294946670532, 0.5920203328132629, 0.9338648319244385, -0.06418558955192566, -0.08479616045951843, -1.06419038772583 ]
Determinant Representation for time and temperature dependent correlation functions in the isotropic XY model in the transverse magnetic field
Astymptotics of temperature correlations is the most dificult problem of stat. mech. Recently it was solved for the impenetrable Bose Gas. The idea is to represent correlation function as $\tau$ function of calssical completely integrable differential equation. Now we start to apply this program to isotropic XY model in the trasnsverse magnetic field. In this paper we are making first step. We representing correlation function as detrminanat of an integral operator.
F. Colomo, A. Izergin, V. Korepin, V. Tognetti
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205009
cond-mat/9205010
[ -0.26375776529312134, 0.7442082166671753, 0.2703210115432739, 1.131062626838684, -0.2450217455625534, 0.015149105340242386, -0.5425603985786438, -0.7221762537956238, -0.03543737903237343, 1.6010231971740723, 0.5257522463798523, -0.158296138048172, -0.2926591634750366, -0.8398450613021851, -0.520662248134613, 0.8552826046943665, -0.37505364418029785, -1.0003759860992432, -1.0697585344314575, -0.04565095528960228, -0.5777877569198608, -0.3008550703525543, -1.091046929359436, -1.0342051982879639, -0.4002332091331482, 0.16194474697113037, -0.005540383979678154, 0.21311494708061218, 0.7585815191268921, 0.6936136484146118, 0.9718972444534302, -0.13010482490062714, -0.15537191927433014, -0.8631161451339722, -0.3577515184879303, -0.1465882807970047, 0.7696887850761414, 0.2604217529296875, 0.04769640415906906, -0.47348713874816895, 0.984210193157196, -0.004973741248250008, 0.5207558870315552, -0.28621506690979004, -0.42038166522979736, -0.2906649708747864, 0.4945608377456665, -0.187660351395607, -0.3077411651611328, -1.252719521522522, 0.4803467094898224, 0.08684738725423813, -0.06369540840387344, -0.9349227547645569, -0.4622199535369873, 0.4148714244365692, 0.09004510939121246, 0.008550884202122688, 0.019727375358343124, 0.27951857447624207, 0.05237738788127899, -0.2764325439929962, 0.7082452178001404, -0.8021062016487122, -0.4653584361076355, 0.553876519203186, -0.5810223817825317, 0.7340779900550842, 0.02321930229663849, -1.254316806793213, -0.7826126217842102, 0.0751151442527771, 0.2613278925418854, 0.5009756684303284, -0.6265544891357422, 0.7173754572868347, 0.22086355090141296, -0.13308307528495789, -0.669410765171051, 0.18785321712493896, -0.2347075343132019, -0.37568309903144836, -0.3859475255012512, 0.8405700325965881, -0.28696027398109436, -0.43419039249420166, -0.16579219698905945, 0.19475890696048737, 0.003517249831929803, 0.6858766674995422, 0.2699572741985321, 0.7187468409538269, -0.06075426563620567, -0.11173870414495468, 0.3968120813369751, 0.9337624311447144, 0.1525551676750183, 0.17642459273338318, 0.6842364072799683, 0.41544634103775024, 0.16099724173545837, 0.8507698774337769, -0.33903664350509644, 0.6640475392341614, -0.589950442314148, 1.0097099542617798, 1.0701138973236084, -0.08390866219997406, -0.7233726382255554, -0.9408700466156006, -0.11773387342691422, 0.32231709361076355, 0.3286311626434326, 0.9965956211090088, 0.03172515332698822, 0.7260962128639221, 0.6787580847740173, 0.14503294229507446, -0.3270460367202759, -0.4003840386867523, -0.14116202294826508, 0.06079094111919403, 0.3804267644882202, 0.427115797996521, -0.0180917140096426, -0.586158812046051, 0.1514679193496704, 0.5422205328941345, -0.44084617495536804, 0.11277986317873001, 0.20284521579742432, -0.17621584236621857, -0.5162661671638489, 0.8126664161682129, 0.28633275628089905, 0.5068463087081909, -0.11968990415334702, 0.32562896609306335, 0.3429361879825592, 0.2708207070827484, -0.028126468881964684, -0.7414849996566772, -0.03218130022287369, 1.0937206745147705, -0.47031694650650024, -0.32754528522491455, 0.7964045405387878, 0.21609781682491302, -0.16153639554977417, 0.6584145426750183, -0.7531185746192932, 0.388860285282135, 0.2058679312467575, 0.12340808659791946, 0.1335112303495407, 0.45047667622566223, -0.5469607710838318, 0.6058954000473022, -0.4913826882839203, -0.5633430480957031, 0.3781352937221527, 0.04289311170578003, -0.17088860273361206, -0.16559498012065887, -0.5551321506500244, 0.00026440361398272216, -0.7056330442428589, -0.5418667197227478, 0.5587011575698853, 0.3559040129184723, 0.03003510646522045, 0.37600481510162354, 0.07722856849431992, 0.5291995406150818, 0.46993139386177063, 0.20362378656864166, 0.5033319592475891, 0.4896642863750458, 0.5628933310508728, -0.017247457057237625, -0.5765672326087952, 0.08734813332557678, 0.9112725257873535, 0.06386306881904602, -0.10131625831127167, 0.013813327997922897, -0.4798952639102936, -0.02372821234166622, 0.15227465331554413, 0.19858641922473907, -0.39767226576805115, 0.6178981065750122, -0.634168267250061, 0.09340473264455795, -0.7410926818847656, -0.39244773983955383, -0.30039525032043457, 0.22209641337394714, -0.7960249781608582, -0.8392749428749084, 0.20749971270561218, -0.7528191804885864, -0.6664859652519226, -0.056753601878881454, -1.987654209136963, 0.3204989433288574, 0.7267715930938721, 0.517702579498291, -0.7378779649734497, -0.08183902502059937, 0.3271137773990631, -0.014431485906243324, 0.05705171450972557, 1.145464301109314, -0.23350898921489716, 0.005886698141694069, -0.6100340485572815, 0.19231806695461273, 1.1020455360412598, -0.2325001060962677, 0.36520761251449585, -0.1680508255958557, -0.10361873358488083, 0.478520005941391, 0.09682222455739975, -0.2664884328842163, 0.33324524760246277, 0.36869725584983826, 0.7489497661590576, -0.19911061227321625, 0.0652979239821434, 1.1557105779647827, -0.3984166383743286, 0.37242403626441956, 1.0414750576019287, 0.28375646471977234, -0.35465195775032043, 0.6747498512268066, 0.18507204949855804, 0.1076391264796257, 0.292937308549881, 0.5628389716148376, 0.263368159532547, 0.6165407299995422, -0.41374099254608154, 0.3362419605255127, -0.10721024870872498, -0.6219371557235718, -1.211761474609375, -0.1659645140171051, -0.8447599411010742, 1.0414605140686035, 0.6210911870002747, 0.17517252266407013, -0.6712802052497864, -0.10625191777944565, -0.2734571099281311, 0.29574480652809143, -0.48798805475234985, -0.026247859001159668, -0.05383805185556412, 0.2988499701023102, -0.27510401606559753, -0.3305649757385254, 0.1836361438035965, 0.38635721802711487, 0.025062503293156624, 0.3353423774242401, 0.00433251541107893, 0.18960221111774445, -1.4050023555755615, -0.45339569449424744, -0.2474709302186966, -0.06647180020809174, -0.5260682702064514, 0.05762534216046333, 0.9320991635322571, -0.5815497040748596, 1.1058729887008667, 0.43095794320106506, -0.23459197580814362, 0.22843298316001892, -0.6036120057106018, 0.16721665859222412, -0.14034771919250488, -0.4851466715335846, -0.7590862512588501, 0.5327529311180115, -0.5252759456634521, 0.7097184062004089, -0.15977934002876282, 0.10778897255659103, 0.1548425853252411, 0.05457228422164917, -0.6398632526397705, 0.1457028090953827, -0.3403039276599884, -0.5895768404006958, -0.5211914777755737, -0.739586591720581, 0.2314286082983017, -0.2617790699005127, -1.0629527568817139, -0.9472524523735046, -1.0075132846832275, 1.4927189350128174, 0.5910605192184448, -0.597394585609436, 0.5822657346725464, 0.9495668411254883, -0.38543039560317993, 0.3320827782154083, -0.18579153716564178, 0.3580654561519623, 0.03731511905789375, 1.502501130104065, 1.2647744417190552, -0.35360264778137207, 0.2098034769296646, -1.0541081428527832, -0.3193263113498688, 0.40441522002220154, 0.01600411906838417, -1.2623237371444702, 0.45725342631340027, 1.56450355052948, 0.3343883752822876, -0.7645444869995117, 0.40503811836242676, -1.1887307167053223, -0.49684277176856995, -0.0037520662881433964, 0.5725206136703491, 0.2534424364566803, 0.3866484761238098, -0.057477131485939026, -0.07086928188800812, -0.23681409657001495, -0.29866859316825867, -0.05898202955722809, 0.34520769119262695, -0.43741700053215027, 0.16816212236881256, 0.634962260723114, 0.006432717200368643, -0.12402167171239853, 0.47934532165527344, -0.671715259552002, 0.2545231580734253, 0.8934469819068909, -1.2052946090698242, -0.09897144883871078, 0.24945348501205444, 0.1921767294406891, 0.15006965398788452, -0.07446452975273132, -0.5142636895179749, -0.3165656328201294, -0.6139697432518005, -0.21553845703601837, -0.16037458181381226, 0.3774401843547821, -0.16660471260547638, -0.09747893363237381, -0.5554751753807068, -0.782836377620697, 0.1459723263978958, 0.02301214262843132, 0.4863313138484955, -0.4361531138420105, 0.44916343688964844, 0.19714577496051788, 0.2568706274032593, -0.13994863629341125, -0.2399207353591919, -0.19847296178340912, 0.4260765612125397, -0.3912903666496277, 0.7357027530670166, -0.7189182639122009, -0.8959906697273254, 0.566858172416687, 1.001206398010254, 1.4171971082687378, 1.1332730054855347, 0.6506944894790649, -0.12117159366607666, -0.18703491985797882, -0.3854084312915802, -0.3566991984844208, -0.020160404965281487, -0.29162174463272095, -0.6307045221328735, -0.30844253301620483, 0.11433687061071396, -0.2497083693742752, 0.5846391320228577, 0.3866901397705078, -0.09370921552181244, 0.4280554950237274, 0.12647512555122375, 0.1050068810582161, 0.41979601979255676, 0.4596254527568817, 0.12084536999464035, 0.2315775752067566, -0.21037226915359497, 0.2348293513059616, -0.20136885344982147, 0.28247323632240295, -0.027299029752612114, -0.5179051160812378, -0.6902487874031067, -0.43777474761009216, 0.4080309271812439, 0.06328077614307404, -0.06004694476723671, 0.5721542239189148, -0.2512117326259613, 0.3949812054634094, -0.15799707174301147, 0.04384271800518036, 0.06005135551095009, 0.6142138838768005, 0.5306584239006042, -0.9333914518356323, -0.17276909947395325, -0.4879395067691803, 0.6398305892944336, 0.2586376965045929, 0.1684710830450058, -0.6743582487106323, -0.046207766979932785, 0.20526765286922455, -0.3657441735267639, 0.1528349667787552, 0.883987307548523, 0.08834363520145416, 0.32064786553382874, -0.164158895611763, -0.24783051013946533, -0.0871099904179573, -0.6535565853118896, -0.35519376397132874, -0.01072309073060751, 0.12378234416246414, -0.48074933886528015, 0.8795955181121826, -0.38115984201431274, -0.5774234533309937, -0.33797481656074524, -0.9346487522125244, 0.24985624849796295, -0.37791576981544495, -0.04596588388085365, 0.17614269256591797, -0.24554277956485748, -0.002092125127092004, 0.8870845437049866, 0.03595636785030365, 0.4868520498275757, -0.20671111345291138, 0.04318622499704361, -0.28965577483177185, -0.2658200263977051, 0.35826435685157776, 0.04796142131090164, -0.11809925734996796, 1.1545239686965942, 0.12677589058876038, 0.7889682054519653, 0.15936604142189026, 0.1259235292673111, -0.07504960894584656, 0.3734930157661438, -0.31690073013305664, 0.35756024718284607, -0.6852791905403137, -0.33351367712020874, -0.32679834961891174, -0.4050387442111969, 0.6218422055244446, -0.05372786894440651, 0.09541827440261841, 0.6336210370063782, -0.33506402373313904, -0.3988761901855469, -0.4143376052379608, -0.32732170820236206, 0.6201176047325134, -0.48144668340682983, -0.5063565373420715, 0.32503852248191833, -0.6884653568267822, -0.7108086943626404, 0.7662844657897949, 0.11142278462648392, 0.08917734026908875, 0.25789111852645874, 0.43558186292648315, -0.2178049236536026, -0.4597741961479187, -1.2900573015213013, 1.0196341276168823, 0.12403519451618195, 0.0008788437116891146, -0.7693629264831543, -0.6115331649780273, -0.06135494261980057, -0.27524495124816895, 0.23795659840106964, -0.44476205110549927, -0.11057107150554657, 0.2839338481426239, 0.21323473751544952, 0.6954008936882019, 0.03717409819364548, -0.2269665151834488, -0.3439684808254242, 0.4959634840488434, 0.279796302318573, -0.7850139737129211, -0.09274740517139435, 1.1375372409820557, 0.185776948928833, -0.16531266272068024, -0.04901257902383804, -0.8406360745429993, -0.011169111356139183, 0.036843542009592056, 0.02020617015659809, -0.3010334372520447, -0.32297810912132263, -0.5544034838676453, 0.5294294357299805, -0.31465795636177063, 0.02704966813325882, 0.027956349775195122, -0.8801141381263733, 0.21382661163806915, -0.9531196355819702, 0.20431223511695862, 0.06130126491189003, 0.28786802291870117, -0.16010063886642456, -0.047685470432043076, -0.5797834992408752, 0.7854662537574768, -0.15959785878658295, -0.6464323997497559, 0.6849347352981567, 0.18593232333660126, 0.8662264943122864, 0.9722208976745605, -0.42890170216560364, -0.6336492896080017, -0.3102373778820038, 0.5185626745223999, 0.281406968832016, -0.022475821897387505, -1.0453568696975708, 0.21766991913318634, -1.0395028591156006, 0.6063414812088013, 0.19221240282058716, -0.201265349984169, 0.26763400435447693, -0.7552205324172974, 1.0696699619293213, -1.2994683980941772, 0.26037904620170593, 0.962454080581665, -0.03200357407331467, 1.0361428260803223, 0.3468005955219269, -0.4663209617137909, -0.5542827248573303, -0.6398276090621948, -0.744292676448822, 0.05422470346093178, -0.1122078076004982, -0.6028847694396973, -0.6069731116294861, -0.2469778209924698, 0.03900321573019028, -0.9526245594024658, 0.3576844036579132, 0.7640476226806641, 0.33240413665771484, 0.5534206032752991, 0.13768357038497925, -0.11708952486515045, 0.110493004322052, -1.1221972703933716, 0.44655758142471313, -0.08892718702554703, -0.7212788462638855, -0.31605619192123413, 0.08203423023223877, -0.9943633079528809, -0.3639930784702301, 0.6730404496192932, 0.4811210632324219, -0.3037942349910736, 0.9588074684143066, -0.17205975949764252, -0.4654668867588043, -0.635525107383728, 0.24846184253692627, -0.016033541411161423, 0.2268441766500473, 0.4291309118270874, -0.3032713532447815, -0.04526296257972717, -0.19303260743618011, -0.3712501525878906, -0.6898137927055359, -0.03946201503276825, 0.7445439696311951, -0.9844421744346619, 0.02334517054259777, 0.16896472871303558, -0.09529880434274673, -0.6185623407363892, -0.5578587055206299, -0.9988158345222473, 0.09383014589548111, 0.273397296667099, -1.2036408185958862, -0.28820255398750305, -0.3913368284702301, -0.6334700584411621, 0.17493179440498352, 0.8190711140632629, -0.46314316987991333, 0.5343115925788879, -0.2932964861392975, -0.5355359315872192, -0.7617075443267822, 0.12910187244415283, 0.943303644657135, -0.01953776925802231, -0.18789193034172058, -0.5089319348335266, -0.5537165403366089, -0.2736126780509949, -0.2107289582490921, 0.5690052509307861, -0.35344719886779785, 0.6357852816581726, -0.17256183922290802, 0.06043935939669609, 0.28446486592292786, 0.6475722789764404, 0.3165377974510193, 0.5858440399169922, 0.25631603598594666, -0.9427382349967957, -0.2508770823478699, 0.04038069769740105, 0.21353796124458313, 1.2171814441680908, -0.3903770446777344, -0.035031791776418686, -0.3875232934951782, 0.1387210637331009, -0.6264321208000183, -0.43037867546081543, 0.13423477113246918, -1.089796781539917, -0.8343474864959717, -0.7539582252502441, -1.2042326927185059, -0.7584431767463684, 0.2832638621330261, -0.28914958238601685, -0.07316919416189194, -1.4260313510894775, -0.03961192071437836, -0.0015010791830718517, 0.9323949217796326, -0.24000824987888336, -0.43856263160705566, -0.8694852590560913, -0.11812576651573181, -0.44874680042266846, -0.2897613048553467, -0.1067466214299202, 0.011706793680787086, -0.3763399124145508, -0.10501107573509216, -0.6113049387931824, 0.43931713700294495, -0.4235059320926666, -0.3491103947162628, 0.44521042704582214, -0.01320052333176136, -0.5147274136543274, 0.11913040280342102, 0.36977916955947876, 0.32756856083869934, 0.4601624310016632, -0.817518413066864, -0.07974184304475784, 0.443922221660614, -0.922156810760498, 0.17559267580509186, -0.31181082129478455, 0.20108024775981903, 0.007271352224051952, -0.3958485424518585, -0.35343438386917114, 0.6710950136184692, -0.9024527668952942, -0.24016936123371124, -0.42079225182533264, 0.14278054237365723, -0.2517339885234833, -0.3391573131084442, 0.19982847571372986, 0.5696526765823364, -0.872454822063446, 0.9909916520118713, -0.7751884460449219, -0.662756621837616, -0.21330766379833221, 0.07299654185771942, -0.7472918033599854, -0.061325013637542725, 0.6270274519920349, -0.985899031162262, 0.4681662321090698, 0.1148144081234932, -0.4766838550567627, 0.42667993903160095, -0.1474357694387436, -0.07039815932512283, -0.318454772233963, -0.5774969458580017, -0.48878684639930725, 0.6975547075271606, -0.8193191289901733, -0.3953651487827301, -0.8000420331954956, -0.24361738562583923, -0.14446081221103668, 0.11162897199392319, -0.43053150177001953, -0.20786675810813904, -0.7250881791114807, 0.4898931384086609, -0.5240359306335449, -0.22943150997161865, -0.0414789617061615, -0.057260412722826004, -0.6782328486442566, 0.392100065946579, -0.41340839862823486, 0.2442031055688858, 0.1643161028623581, 0.5255085825920105, 0.020598502829670906, 0.4053979516029358, 0.0010259582195430994, 0.404609352350235, -0.8515024781227112, -0.48012635111808777, -0.46208056807518005, 0.1732795089483261, -0.0936027243733406, -0.10153228044509888, -0.20044031739234924, 0.44524943828582764, -0.08928950875997543, 0.4852984845638275, -0.7965350151062012, 0.4397723376750946, -0.22010239958763123, 0.9621148109436035, 0.28737807273864746, -0.628902792930603, 0.3501342535018921, 0.6150124669075012, 0.5528386831283569, -0.2000037282705307, -0.39652490615844727, 0.3707866370677948, -0.21349790692329407, -0.24146409332752228, 0.2483976185321808, 0.16158032417297363, 0.6316899657249451, 0.03438546881079674, -0.4654243588447571, -0.24761691689491272, -0.33358365297317505, 0.329201877117157, 0.6418967843055725, 0.1196201890707016, 0.8156052231788635, 0.5553825497627258, -0.47172820568084717, -0.3537001311779022, 0.5488247871398926, 0.10592643916606903, 0.02598300203680992, 0.902263343334198, -0.7470507621765137, 0.453637033700943, -0.1451948881149292, 0.18254277110099792, 0.0486864298582077, -0.07857733964920044, -0.06718825548887253, 0.41041791439056396, -0.5032256841659546, 0.7160167098045349, -0.6320497989654541, -0.4965968728065491, -0.06592174619436264, -0.09180337190628052, 0.22709794342517853, 0.3590461313724518, -0.266238272190094, 0.6404255628585815, 0.6111413836479187, 0.8151922821998596, 0.11523952335119247, 0.06278004497289658, 0.1114860400557518, 0.6197644472122192, -0.19261372089385986, 0.8180365562438965, 0.26172325015068054, 0.5766231417655945, 0.6062728762626648, -0.4168092906475067, -0.2399316132068634, 1.0680339336395264, -0.8247390389442444, 0.13824869692325592, -0.4203450083732605, 0.16978488862514496, 0.057041846215724945, -0.8388509154319763, 0.5602433085441589, -0.2088836133480072, -0.23814547061920166, 0.8838832974433899, -0.10063161700963974, 0.008974356576800346, 0.9881985187530518, -0.021653875708580017, 0.5059574842453003, 0.24835845828056335, 0.4909195601940155, -0.24672947824001312, 1.4367262125015259, 1.1564580202102661, -0.4876643717288971, 0.25311529636383057, 0.43097132444381714, -0.3599301874637604, -0.488593190908432, -0.2904464900493622, -0.4139902591705322, 0.7817380428314209, -1.418961763381958, 0.08265827596187592, -0.026226064190268517, 0.29612672328948975, -0.4768432080745697, -0.5995352268218994, 0.4558408856391907, 0.33747997879981995, -0.5466356873512268, 0.09340526908636093, 0.6571469306945801, 0.3757120966911316, 0.31449854373931885, -0.21122631430625916, 0.011788361705839634, 0.19740712642669678, 0.32682326436042786, -0.2946365177631378, -0.11487356573343277, -0.5317777991294861, -0.014335494488477707, 0.030803628265857697, -0.5686942934989929, -0.8844910264015198, -1.7051678895950317, 0.27215513586997986, -0.9163450598716736, 0.8350463509559631, 0.1293615847826004, 0.989031195640564, 0.198950856924057, -0.6987069845199585, 0.6145327687263489, 0.9127654433250427, 0.9389631152153015, 0.04278893768787384, 0.3574240803718567, 0.36037641763687134, -0.35126516222953796, -0.2517196536064148, 0.8103211522102356, 0.41142216324806213, -0.5667287111282349, 0.5792523622512817, -0.282906174659729, 0.47398921847343445, -0.16003406047821045, -0.23221494257450104, 0.44961774349212646, 0.07166129350662231, 0.6984752416610718, -0.4291755259037018, -0.6751367449760437, -0.0260226558893919, -1.1979382038116455, 0.11156771332025528, -0.5536839365959167, 0.38012027740478516, 0.03402290120720863, 0.3986109495162964, 0.561972975730896, -0.5852415561676025, 3.9996774196624756, 0.4324900805950165, 0.6684430837631226, 0.15746846795082092, 0.40785691142082214, 0.7550076246261597, 0.3089565932750702, -0.7493937611579895, -0.27539709210395813, 0.004721158649772406, 0.8080824017524719, 0.23898394405841827, 0.366536408662796, 0.22307994961738586, 0.23664844036102295, 0.10395966470241547, 0.05507844686508179, 0.20813240110874176, 0.09205830842256546, -0.9464008808135986, -0.4358423948287964, 0.4176931083202362, 0.06109094247221947, -0.2660369873046875, 0.43528127670288086, 0.12083426117897034, 0.0543493777513504, -0.21328501403331757, -0.4165840148925781, -0.8533017635345459, -0.14466147124767303, -0.2881861925125122, 0.6996960043907166, 0.04460449889302254, -0.26325440406799316, 0.21712923049926758, 0.5808813571929932, -0.1527779996395111, 0.2643870413303375, 0.4628048241138458, 0.5740801692008972, -0.5892223119735718, -0.23254986107349396, -0.09339451044797897, -1.411399483680725, 0.08271470665931702, 0.2015417367219925, 1.0387970209121704, 0.26525136828422546, -0.8817786574363708, 0.16381177306175232, 0.09579204767942429, 0.2655920684337616, -0.05919557809829712, -1.4265260696411133, 0.5014767646789551, -0.4061140716075897, -0.17334140837192535, -0.641487717628479, -0.036584001034498215, 1.2907154560089111, 0.2686208486557007, -0.4874844253063202, -0.04519039765000343, -0.1741359382867813, 0.2804306745529175, 0.12418211251497269, 0.25225207209587097, -0.6336135268211365, -0.12970823049545288, -0.8339954018592834, -0.4782356917858124, -0.4836757779121399, -0.08220340311527252, 0.8533615469932556, 0.2711838185787201, -0.2385493665933609, 1.0685954093933105, 0.5209494233131409, 0.016666406765580177, 0.4822598695755005, -0.5217452645301819, -0.17052341997623444, 0.170011967420578, 0.2983405292034149, 1.205051064491272, -0.17791546881198883, 0.10094498097896576, -0.08210116624832153, 0.3131556510925293, -0.16098545491695404, 0.8870194554328918, -0.08867935836315155, 0.18291345238685608, -0.6328960061073303 ]
Elastic String in a Random Potential
We have studied numerically the dynamics of a directed elastic string in a two-dimensional array of quenched random impurities. The string is driven by a constant transverse force and thermal fluctuations are neglected. There is a transition from pinned to unpinned behavior at a critical value $F_T$ of the driving force. At the transition the average string velocity scales with the driving force. The scaling is equally well described by a power law $v_d\sim (F-F_T)^\zeta$, with $\zeta=0.24\pm0.1$, or by a logarithm, $v_d\sim1/\ln(F-F_T)$. The divergence of the velocity-velocity correlation length at threshold is characterized by an exponent $\nu=1.05\pm0.1$.
M. Dong, M.C. Marchetti, A. Alan Middleton, V. Vinokur
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205010
cond-mat/9205011
[ -0.0862128958106041, 0.6170204281806946, 0.11468581110239029, 0.7218369841575623, -0.11322999745607376, 0.23975415527820587, -0.3596864938735962, -0.4213566780090332, -0.7221170663833618, 1.4309203624725342, 0.5343323945999146, -0.2624013125896454, 0.6680052280426025, -1.0290038585662842, -0.19912724196910858, 0.7134931683540344, -0.41291677951812744, -0.7087336182594299, -1.7410027980804443, 0.10040193051099777, -0.4317032992839813, -0.3936089277267456, -0.45163780450820923, -0.5649140477180481, -1.16443932056427, 0.1742781400680542, -0.17676924169063568, 0.2323499321937561, 0.9436497688293457, 0.7352080941200256, 0.2616835832595825, -0.5071057677268982, 0.07982920110225677, -0.7491579055786133, -0.17950910329818726, -0.5637114644050598, 0.3653399348258972, -0.03867034241557121, 0.4098258316516876, 0.08889360725879669, 0.8085368275642395, 0.24821539223194122, 0.40446099638938904, 0.15952037274837494, 0.07709204405546188, 0.05646917596459389, -0.23340559005737305, -0.5028047561645508, -0.474599689245224, -1.2637939453125, -0.0586584247648716, 0.36310458183288574, 0.16055041551589966, -0.7165685892105103, 0.25257742404937744, 0.6916720867156982, -0.24049673974514008, -0.12251300364732742, 0.027483060956001282, -0.13644137978553772, 0.40469852089881897, -0.556451141834259, 0.6583639979362488, -0.6728302836418152, -0.1260146200656891, 0.6383596658706665, -0.4530712068080902, 0.7311158776283264, 0.2616082727909088, 0.17543423175811768, -0.2248152196407318, 0.15640230476856232, 0.3056708574295044, 0.21583254635334015, -1.1161470413208008, 0.25412222743034363, -0.02645863965153694, -0.43093571066856384, -0.8011276125907898, -0.4070001244544983, -0.11318971961736679, -0.40425819158554077, -0.5634035468101501, 0.7914716601371765, 0.38071778416633606, -0.5605044364929199, -0.10842864215373993, 0.25186821818351746, -0.18693551421165466, 0.7553428411483765, 0.11229238659143448, 1.0841833353042603, 0.06474282592535019, 0.17678549885749817, 0.5702225565910339, 0.818057656288147, 0.1187848225235939, -0.013020526617765427, 0.4362974166870117, 0.49227508902549744, -0.058373793959617615, 1.0262926816940308, -0.422398179769516, 0.6261420249938965, -0.12068487703800201, 0.49965035915374756, 0.33795201778411865, -0.15784592926502228, 0.015572107397019863, -0.5799463987350464, 0.312613844871521, 0.1951119750738144, 0.23489707708358765, 0.9798409342765808, -0.1538703888654709, 0.5349428057670593, 0.34149274230003357, -0.21909107267856598, -0.5447252988815308, -0.559401273727417, 0.4963591992855072, -0.2690822184085846, 0.5209534764289856, 0.6854773759841919, -0.6848499178886414, -0.5787248611450195, 0.4691144824028015, 0.6350412964820862, -0.19059786200523376, -0.22148871421813965, -0.6248013973236084, -0.29744312167167664, -0.25083956122398376, 0.8685342669487, 0.20080499351024628, 0.7032809853553772, 0.15432026982307434, -0.0988302007317543, 0.21774400770664215, 0.2927868962287903, 0.02388201840221882, -0.7674564123153687, 0.15885360538959503, 0.8670161366462708, -0.6293790340423584, -0.32033830881118774, 0.36998409032821655, 0.2687646746635437, 0.3144054412841797, 0.6760629415512085, -0.7330790758132935, -0.06075354292988777, 0.3745425045490265, -0.500728189945221, -0.03660416603088379, -0.3373028337955475, -0.8676454424858093, 1.5270459651947021, -0.8142549395561218, -0.5886375308036804, 0.15131902694702148, -0.10682308673858643, 0.10317051410675049, -0.3420644700527191, -0.6887829303741455, 0.12212932109832764, -0.46621203422546387, -0.9674160480499268, 0.746313750743866, -0.11175604909658432, 0.021906467154622078, 0.4856545627117157, 0.36823809146881104, 0.14621417224407196, 0.15697740018367767, 0.3844512104988098, 0.46609804034233093, 0.22020240128040314, 0.23496299982070923, -0.14242681860923767, -0.431742787361145, -0.1164260283112526, 0.37023207545280457, 0.3021146357059479, -0.33668652176856995, 0.14985865354537964, -0.5217340588569641, -0.2656431198120117, 0.5360459089279175, 0.3009280264377594, 0.09934301674365997, 0.8564813733100891, -0.29327264428138733, -0.010126419365406036, -0.15246351063251495, -0.5673919320106506, -0.8429077863693237, 0.5379844307899475, -0.20372959971427917, -0.8609245419502258, -0.21906700730323792, 0.2748911678791046, -1.024978518486023, 0.3138653635978699, -1.1583696603775024, 0.07640255242586136, 1.296840786933899, 0.2710909843444824, -0.32961857318878174, -0.27855947613716125, 0.10686752200126648, 0.4374479353427887, -0.15240313112735748, 0.44408559799194336, -0.02964734472334385, 0.4700591266155243, -0.16414572298526764, -0.5123163461685181, 1.080406665802002, 0.013756878674030304, 0.0030224518850445747, -0.1448676884174347, -0.308998703956604, 0.7478373050689697, 0.11113946884870529, -0.4570056200027466, 0.20476484298706055, 0.3587518036365509, 0.4734746515750885, -0.399994820356369, -0.3650882840156555, 0.6065767407417297, -0.32509666681289673, 0.2665454149246216, 0.738853931427002, 0.3286200761795044, 0.6194735765457153, 0.674937903881073, -0.3666524291038513, -0.20570556819438934, 0.142324760556221, 0.3167860805988312, 0.24793343245983124, 0.03520221263170242, -0.49073731899261475, -0.2399677038192749, -0.2875690758228302, -0.33517807722091675, -0.8138624429702759, -0.4914763569831848, -1.2985109090805054, 0.8246468305587769, 0.17686228454113007, -0.07501968741416931, -0.9053018689155579, -0.5105246305465698, -0.2092655748128891, 0.6033223867416382, -0.6657477617263794, -0.26360389590263367, 0.20053070783615112, 0.15631113946437836, -0.1631828248500824, -0.40449413657188416, 0.2813919484615326, 1.247992992401123, -0.41692957282066345, 0.2629850208759308, -0.11200134456157684, -0.5932790040969849, -0.7960866093635559, -0.7517850995063782, -0.3700239360332489, 0.36910030245780945, -0.46236491203308105, 0.08506716787815094, 0.6198521256446838, -0.559616208076477, 1.0804994106292725, -0.22273218631744385, -0.09149886667728424, 0.24470214545726776, -0.14703966677188873, 0.4044208824634552, 0.11712769418954849, 0.4125206768512726, -1.1202757358551025, 0.3011552691459656, -0.13108734786510468, 0.19300788640975952, -0.050314322113990784, -0.5916755795478821, 0.15577225387096405, -0.06118946895003319, -0.06944984942674637, 0.2677696645259857, -0.11167971044778824, -0.6096919775009155, 0.01863817498087883, -0.6534284353256226, 0.2058916836977005, -0.22529396414756775, -0.7272544503211975, -0.7079912424087524, -0.6807291507720947, 0.39671263098716736, 0.19482995569705963, -0.33939117193222046, 0.945054829120636, 0.509533166885376, -0.47018054127693176, 0.24734361469745636, -0.516003429889679, 0.5619184970855713, 0.211893230676651, 1.060092568397522, 1.255527138710022, -0.17398327589035034, 0.30389174818992615, -0.5446147918701172, -0.2591969668865204, 0.24544595181941986, -0.0659252181649208, -1.2293550968170166, 0.568141520023346, 1.0906699895858765, 0.5637507438659668, -0.42256197333335876, 0.3619631230831146, -0.9436239004135132, -0.4460013210773468, -0.18288865685462952, 0.03310072049498558, 0.6252623200416565, 0.015007300302386284, -0.2653224468231201, -1.0629637241363525, 0.022194936871528625, -0.11040597409009933, 0.27586662769317627, 0.022946244105696678, -0.43182721734046936, 0.6725896000862122, 0.541567325592041, 0.290565550327301, -0.015052836388349533, 0.15043535828590393, -0.33175209164619446, -0.26404669880867004, 0.3767539858818054, -1.1958597898483276, -0.02708168514072895, 0.6488327383995056, 0.005360736977308989, 0.5307125449180603, 0.1647028625011444, -0.28840214014053345, -0.9085448384284973, -0.03533686324954033, -0.3298158645629883, 0.3244869112968445, 0.3310126066207886, 0.16849644482135773, 0.44929343461990356, -0.6132532358169556, -0.20221099257469177, 0.2851961851119995, -0.4710504412651062, 1.1869447231292725, -0.7824999690055847, 0.17444057762622833, 0.31714972853660583, -0.18749643862247467, 0.581030011177063, -0.18049143254756927, 0.2979554533958435, 0.3391128480434418, -0.08887290954589844, 1.4745475053787231, -0.8806045651435852, -0.3988144099712372, 0.5434862971305847, 1.1116234064102173, 0.7330755591392517, 0.7093095183372498, 0.6112493872642517, -0.11317187547683716, 0.34955671429634094, -0.10342951864004135, -0.18921826779842377, 0.18586882948875427, -0.3828970789909363, -0.9021279215812683, -0.8227583765983582, -0.09329389035701752, -0.49464669823646545, 0.3925417363643646, -0.08324559777975082, -0.25497862696647644, -0.07694259285926819, 0.16933736205101013, 0.28552883863449097, 0.9273570775985718, 0.6370903849601746, 0.3087364137172699, 0.16664434969425201, -0.4928717017173767, 0.3193880319595337, -0.5555697679519653, 0.20982025563716888, 0.07708734273910522, -0.5202915668487549, -0.4993596374988556, -0.3306414484977722, 0.6232290863990784, 0.41324618458747864, 0.45835843682289124, 1.0216641426086426, -0.0922585129737854, 0.18492452800273895, -0.7070735096931458, 0.022666558623313904, 0.4152306616306305, 0.21333952248096466, -0.4259209930896759, -1.356009840965271, 0.7383716106414795, -0.4601747989654541, 0.328495055437088, 0.49160340428352356, -0.4560047388076782, -0.7063379883766174, 0.09855081140995026, 0.647514820098877, -0.700123131275177, 0.20984774827957153, 0.6439972519874573, -0.09924536943435669, -0.21924179792404175, -0.5482644438743591, 0.13136054575443268, -0.0980277732014656, -0.12696850299835205, -0.5879034996032715, -0.2623309791088104, 0.18454378843307495, -0.3252749443054199, 0.34452202916145325, 0.36980608105659485, -0.4133903682231903, -0.2602788507938385, -0.33869239687919617, 0.2772793471813202, -0.29146069288253784, -0.6885724663734436, -0.09470697492361069, -0.16395467519760132, -0.35286569595336914, 0.4073629081249237, -0.3820858895778656, -0.024697132408618927, 0.2076059877872467, -0.2371262013912201, 0.09271780401468277, -1.033828854560852, 0.17553356289863586, 0.09871011972427368, 0.4065123200416565, 0.6567147970199585, 0.3646503984928131, 0.9851655960083008, 0.1341007500886917, -0.2086300402879715, 0.23473069071769714, 0.4362216591835022, -0.21159537136554718, 0.5780434608459473, -0.7012119889259338, -0.19548732042312622, -0.6017722487449646, 0.03092167153954506, 0.8304358124732971, -0.20169265568256378, 0.3319814205169678, 0.08860176801681519, -0.909966230392456, -0.10852840542793274, -0.4807167649269104, -0.7165502309799194, 0.7561768889427185, -0.4629260301589966, -0.17253096401691437, -0.10656870156526566, -0.728157103061676, -0.26464956998825073, 0.42835959792137146, -0.8263354301452637, -0.45210689306259155, 0.6556562781333923, 0.6362414360046387, -0.9947604537010193, -0.13839003443717957, -0.5959922075271606, 1.4347020387649536, -0.2327752560377121, -0.19277872145175934, -0.18357393145561218, -0.3215825855731964, -0.13031207025051117, 0.3940419554710388, -0.037686172872781754, -0.7582842707633972, -0.16073568165302277, 0.13023561239242554, 0.21430747210979462, 0.636820912361145, 0.2748633921146393, 0.32995644211769104, -0.6683475375175476, 0.5206596851348877, 0.08905429393053055, -0.8698047995567322, -0.13009308278560638, 0.9531049132347107, -0.05630161240696907, -0.012307943776249886, -0.09524597972631454, -0.8723211884498596, 0.10094255954027176, 0.7068411707878113, 0.7846770286560059, -0.21801447868347168, -0.14865320920944214, -0.5795782804489136, 0.10200796276330948, 0.20021425187587738, 0.14387178421020508, 0.07687988132238388, -0.041287001222372055, -0.21247747540473938, -0.6164517402648926, -0.1811971664428711, 0.027253270149230957, -0.016735170036554337, -0.16340318322181702, -0.3939504325389862, -0.8424786925315857, 1.1517689228057861, -0.1084073930978775, -0.38543280959129333, 0.5901167392730713, 0.17496483027935028, -0.018596066161990166, 0.7092007994651794, 0.03115185722708702, -0.5712988972663879, -0.10986372083425522, 0.45693790912628174, 0.08425312489271164, 0.4228989779949188, -0.8970447182655334, 0.8447579741477966, -0.9887062311172485, 0.15802642703056335, -0.28527167439460754, 0.6883749961853027, 0.41843006014823914, -0.11657233536243439, 0.06332114338874817, -1.1037695407867432, 0.6247636675834656, 0.4943535327911377, -0.1828630268573761, 0.7180526852607727, 0.2915146052837372, -0.45545023679733276, -0.6152721643447876, -0.8901230692863464, -1.1360864639282227, 0.9018192291259766, -0.23945017158985138, -0.24144768714904785, -0.3458949029445648, -0.354554682970047, -0.1769866794347763, -1.2285442352294922, 0.6960288286209106, 0.9265825748443604, 0.28980398178100586, 0.2299150675535202, 0.26719385385513306, 0.2596558928489685, 0.2824009358882904, -0.49573051929473877, 0.32546454668045044, -0.40092039108276367, -0.14926749467849731, 0.011004070751369, -0.238270103931427, -0.9808774590492249, -0.5142410397529602, 0.9290263056755066, 0.6698444485664368, -0.07605352997779846, 0.9523919820785522, -0.2773801386356354, -0.6868636012077332, 0.1117427796125412, 0.083054319024086, 0.3485848009586334, 0.2914297580718994, 0.8163691759109497, 0.03792068362236023, -0.2045053094625473, 0.547568678855896, -0.42111077904701233, -0.502623438835144, -0.03488516807556152, 0.4273129999637604, -0.4962484538555145, -0.4660947620868683, 0.12688308954238892, -0.1868547648191452, -0.625042200088501, -0.5305649638175964, -0.5231671333312988, -0.5463641881942749, 0.23131214082241058, -1.3102421760559082, 0.357727587223053, -0.550091028213501, -0.3644724190235138, 0.43792828917503357, 0.8586408495903015, -0.1481875777244568, 0.19641757011413574, 0.4565298557281494, -0.3600805103778839, -0.8027848601341248, -0.09638171643018723, 1.1863198280334473, -0.029757538810372353, -0.2183343917131424, -0.5997685194015503, -1.0181478261947632, -0.3572770059108734, -0.5775001049041748, 0.6266308426856995, -0.11611174792051315, 0.531720757484436, -0.26410236954689026, 0.0018028059275820851, 0.4786859154701233, 0.8328567147254944, 0.32704704999923706, 0.18432722985744476, -0.22906143963336945, -0.8329597115516663, -0.30611786246299744, -0.35592344403266907, 0.2082255780696869, 0.9961209893226624, -0.3622554540634155, -0.15631017088890076, -0.1468459814786911, -0.08974441140890121, -0.8107803463935852, -0.504044234752655, 0.34719082713127136, -0.9774290919303894, -0.7119200229644775, -0.7493836283683777, -0.7732179760932922, -0.7649449706077576, -0.3267618715763092, 0.13335344195365906, -0.36962687969207764, -0.25419268012046814, 0.2700440287590027, 0.6106743216514587, 0.5196740627288818, 0.1763763278722763, -0.36357587575912476, -1.190588116645813, -0.27990099787712097, -1.0311992168426514, -0.12015941739082336, 0.13073661923408508, 0.26642176508903503, 0.14578396081924438, -0.04550369083881378, -0.646476149559021, 0.7234113216400146, -0.3775264620780945, -0.5604983568191528, 0.3826776444911957, 0.11313139647245407, -0.2818916141986847, 0.4710438847541809, -0.5192548632621765, -0.08917753398418427, 0.3333752155303955, -0.2162027508020401, 0.3435465693473816, 0.04974984750151634, -1.2754881381988525, 0.04724188521504402, -0.1262829303741455, 0.3570406436920166, -0.08530481904745102, -0.5352700352668762, 0.4278380572795868, 0.5236909985542297, -0.7787488102912903, 0.23348678648471832, -0.7305845618247986, 0.5315535664558411, -0.6762121915817261, -0.08970099687576294, -0.07860980927944183, 0.48064857721328735, -0.021238749846816063, 0.9272090196609497, -0.20073173940181732, -0.3852245807647705, 0.217238187789917, 0.2276422381401062, -0.19128258526325226, -0.033211592584848404, 0.14433322846889496, -0.9005995988845825, 0.8249961137771606, 0.4849605858325958, -1.094391942024231, 0.13741964101791382, -0.3837270438671112, -0.3764761984348297, -0.5703127384185791, -0.16259153187274933, -0.5281750559806824, 0.5762141346931458, -0.646706223487854, -0.6199728846549988, -0.16869424283504486, -0.014709534123539925, -0.3127013146877289, 0.5712145566940308, -0.276336669921875, -0.07165401428937912, -0.8419992923736572, 0.4203411042690277, -0.3277522921562195, 0.16694821417331696, 0.2612757384777069, 0.4824335277080536, -0.7290396690368652, -0.15507084131240845, -0.2832162082195282, 0.2647061049938202, 0.22532281279563904, 0.30716344714164734, -1.050374150276184, 0.6362974643707275, -0.45336517691612244, 1.0041793584823608, -0.22120967507362366, -0.5336955189704895, -0.33706653118133545, 0.6456187963485718, -0.3569914698600769, -0.3657757043838501, -0.49474993348121643, -0.2123849242925644, 0.34268662333488464, 0.7991296648979187, -0.17164453864097595, -0.2938980162143707, -0.5746676921844482, 1.0763942003250122, 0.45578324794769287, -0.1550780087709427, 0.18754222989082336, 0.4538016617298126, 0.25707361102104187, -0.5790891051292419, -0.23635032773017883, 0.5831982493400574, 0.13863049447536469, -0.2078087478876114, 0.6554501056671143, 0.24522589147090912, 1.2206592559814453, -0.38552770018577576, 0.07555651664733887, -0.5484487414360046, -0.24082443118095398, -0.08565893769264221, 0.4582681357860565, -0.1576281189918518, 0.6817705631256104, 0.21711231768131256, -0.17812731862068176, -0.03932535648345947, 0.09030629694461823, 0.22020173072814941, -0.417490154504776, 0.8340013027191162, -0.24336926639080048, 0.5180764198303223, 0.1317233294248581, 0.5822317600250244, 0.00950792245566845, -1.0167713165283203, 0.1033516600728035, -0.266146183013916, -0.1074913740158081, 0.6466840505599976, -0.6737725138664246, -0.3189605474472046, -0.2763579785823822, 0.44666483998298645, 0.9227088689804077, -0.11854657530784607, -0.2794758677482605, 0.601408839225769, 0.517440676689148, 0.8049910068511963, -0.050762537866830826, 0.4667172431945801, 0.6652606129646301, 0.35730987787246704, -0.5607694983482361, 0.8911930322647095, 0.9661641120910645, 0.9095654487609863, 0.0865974873304367, -0.591447114944458, 0.10181596875190735, 0.9610739946365356, -1.2507448196411133, 0.24009625613689423, -0.5977732539176941, 0.18487517535686493, 0.22432009875774384, -1.0767720937728882, 0.7178353667259216, -0.7004562616348267, -0.2977087199687958, 0.7223496437072754, -0.711229145526886, 0.03301199525594711, 0.5451914072036743, -0.4154331386089325, 0.44455480575561523, 0.5129023790359497, -0.2576868236064911, -0.41103747487068176, 1.378244400024414, 0.5804721117019653, -0.732527494430542, 0.1619413197040558, -0.37385889887809753, -0.6203924417495728, -0.3811015784740448, -0.2397569864988327, -0.475574791431427, 0.7601218223571777, 0.05222191661596298, -0.11857328563928604, -0.045508284121751785, 0.01844829134643078, 0.29165971279144287, -0.2602096498012543, 0.5146965980529785, -0.27088814973831177, -0.34515219926834106, -0.22009660303592682, 0.8277971148490906, 0.17914924025535583, 0.08136531710624695, -0.12377912551164627, -0.3939254581928253, 0.22334203124046326, -0.5012719035148621, -0.006959571503102779, 0.18061795830726624, -0.5075916051864624, -0.1824011653661728, 0.11344786733388901, -0.4726640582084656, -0.6385188102722168, -0.9494951963424683, -0.2818733751773834, -0.5782492160797119, 1.3905197381973267, 0.24184966087341309, 0.5766515135765076, 0.014924067072570324, -0.2245180755853653, 1.0032951831817627, 0.5564466714859009, 1.172398328781128, -0.34714123606681824, 0.11209837347269058, 0.16694997251033783, 0.13360442221164703, 0.02378842793405056, 0.6328241229057312, 0.5332159996032715, -0.6982147693634033, 0.2981947362422943, -0.3518087565898895, -0.023905063048005104, 0.07805943489074707, 0.1821049302816391, 0.29748010635375977, 0.5798097848892212, 0.5701330900192261, -0.43027791380882263, -0.4762372076511383, -0.14370574057102203, -0.794093668460846, 0.1764470487833023, -0.16416595876216888, 0.11065860837697983, 0.22878001630306244, 0.3126414716243744, 0.8585420846939087, -0.20563989877700806, 4.085254669189453, 0.6687107682228088, 0.692445695400238, -0.620335042476654, 0.6258827447891235, -0.07064133882522583, 0.19092953205108643, -0.8996409773826599, 0.1590060591697693, -0.13321518898010254, 0.3035106360912323, 0.0027523948810994625, 0.15412594377994537, -0.4658580422401428, 0.011653630994260311, 0.23508653044700623, 0.26635077595710754, 0.3144855201244354, 0.25024840235710144, -0.8562551140785217, -0.041047826409339905, 0.490656316280365, 0.01938255876302719, -0.018905648961663246, -0.4189324378967285, 0.11207558214664459, 0.7151709794998169, -0.8153950572013855, -0.782318651676178, -0.5725947618484497, -0.6310993432998657, -0.8527711033821106, 0.087995745241642, 0.10239967703819275, -0.7494098544120789, 0.3418475389480591, 0.3464404046535492, 0.11822180449962616, 0.23863279819488525, 0.13750460743904114, 0.24536976218223572, -0.00327767850831151, -0.86448734998703, -0.009340466000139713, -1.133805751800537, 0.6276891231536865, 0.13678812980651855, 1.1444135904312134, 0.6109833717346191, -0.8106224536895752, 0.4700911045074463, 0.06367521733045578, 0.8841982483863831, 0.3716932535171509, -1.1680136919021606, 0.453818678855896, -0.4044576585292816, -0.43854111433029175, -0.47110480070114136, -0.13225647807121277, 1.103187084197998, 0.16369587182998657, -0.37168318033218384, -0.5131779909133911, -0.032316260039806366, 0.6494842767715454, 0.8090733885765076, 0.0017831034492701292, -0.3554251790046692, -0.09591617435216904, -0.46420037746429443, -0.3065302073955536, -1.3209314346313477, 0.3665596842765808, 0.2696904242038727, 0.12335899472236633, -0.24683131277561188, 0.37495097517967224, -0.33472391963005066, -0.09872780740261078, 0.03779110684990883, -0.6251389980316162, -0.7493408918380737, 0.22684799134731293, 0.6267974972724915, 0.8979523181915283, -0.4956352710723877, 0.02294227108359337, -0.514912486076355, 0.5953261852264404, 0.22453677654266357, 1.308876395225525, -0.27892279624938965, -0.22449800372123718, -0.5915603041648865 ]
Thermal Rounding of the Charge Density Wave Depinning Transition
The rounding of the charge density wave depinning transition by thermal noise is examined. Hops by localized modes over small barriers trigger ``avalanches'', resulting in a creep velocity much larger than that expected from comparing thermal energies with typical barriers. For a field equal to the $T=0$ depinning field, the creep velocity is predicted to have a {\em power-law} dependence on the temperature $T$; numerical computations confirm this result. The predicted order of magnitude of the thermal rounding of the depinning transition is consistent with rounding seen in experiment.
A. Alan Middleton
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205011
cond-mat/9205012
[ -0.3523845970630646, -0.22690565884113312, -0.04677118360996246, 0.19578061997890472, -0.8199365735054016, -0.3220537304878235, -1.2159171104431152, -0.3916833698749542, -0.6767845153808594, 0.3380501866340637, -0.19253559410572052, -0.30686500668525696, 0.15640905499458313, -1.6904919147491455, -0.623162031173706, -0.4568416476249695, 0.6100866198539734, 0.30230265855789185, -1.346622109413147, -0.4327349364757538, -0.15522652864456177, -0.31126827001571655, -1.2188506126403809, 0.049249786883592606, 0.11413967609405518, 0.7025358080863953, 0.20472265779972076, 0.7246776819229126, 0.8338235020637512, 0.060000307857990265, 0.1398869752883911, -0.9308198690414429, 0.7239326238632202, -0.6698088645935059, 0.0799604132771492, 0.011912822723388672, 0.18001750111579895, 0.2731007933616638, 0.5899277329444885, 0.0023154316004365683, 0.8781203031539917, -0.054972514510154724, 0.3814162015914917, -0.173874631524086, -0.1921810805797577, -0.5177029967308044, -0.2889077663421631, -0.09054747223854065, 0.38832753896713257, -1.0551806688308716, -0.632931113243103, 0.5932760238647461, 0.06578397005796432, -0.03117780201137066, -0.23954281210899353, 0.1159403920173645, 0.4415895640850067, -0.76046222448349, -0.40590378642082214, 0.7976065278053284, 0.7443705201148987, 0.1731022596359253, 0.35796380043029785, -0.4029301106929779, 0.07482577860355377, 1.3489151000976562, 0.06541289389133453, 0.6853066682815552, 0.3700922131538391, -0.3331388533115387, 0.43757563829421997, -1.0551915168762207, 0.8330484628677368, 0.3822685182094574, -0.4471606910228729, 0.13560694456100464, -0.2894483506679535, -0.32425206899642944, -1.3680503368377686, -0.037728000432252884, -0.5242756605148315, -0.2750740647315979, -0.8106123805046082, 0.8367900252342224, -0.39996814727783203, -0.5794652700424194, 0.3386908769607544, 0.15811333060264587, 0.38100317120552063, 0.4335272014141083, 0.3623542785644531, 1.133885145187378, -0.3527086079120636, -0.3932298719882965, 0.5088120102882385, 0.14883016049861908, -0.5203126072883606, -0.03277941420674324, 0.5033702254295349, 0.6302127838134766, 0.03548089787364006, 0.1842886060476303, 0.3700374364852905, 0.7400795221328735, -0.2964814603328705, 0.22540587186813354, 0.16757075488567352, 0.009143989533185959, 0.4088856279850006, -0.8490732312202454, 0.9139018654823303, -0.16751156747341156, 0.4345220625400543, 0.727112889289856, -0.2415163218975067, 0.4172883927822113, -0.505232572555542, -0.03481689840555191, -0.05353201553225517, 0.0006984162610024214, 0.5284735560417175, 0.03972695767879486, 0.574369490146637, 0.14399577677249908, 0.1197788193821907, -0.11079325526952744, -0.02230224199593067, 0.5393478870391846, -0.6264073252677917, -0.18482482433319092, 0.290971964597702, -0.6107182502746582, 0.2177101969718933, 0.37907811999320984, -0.4015253484249115, 0.2367551177740097, 0.3603779077529907, 0.8221853375434875, -0.2857257127761841, -0.5442171692848206, -0.24032025039196014, -0.04795418307185173, 0.23562194406986237, 1.6685198545455933, -0.9661815166473389, -0.007993451319634914, 0.3985257148742676, -0.01257468480616808, 0.26813995838165283, 0.4924573004245758, -0.16495269536972046, -0.0918271616101265, -0.3551236689090729, 0.9886974692344666, -0.06733570992946625, 0.14606201648712158, -0.7929771542549133, -0.07317071408033371, -0.9707119464874268, -0.4621454179286957, 0.40002790093421936, 0.19772596657276154, 0.8420038223266602, 0.06845242530107498, -0.5197974443435669, -0.469686359167099, -0.7589123249053955, -0.9714983105659485, 0.1465890109539032, -0.03462187573313713, -0.4466874897480011, 0.6845746040344238, 0.347085565328598, 1.394566297531128, 0.7444621324539185, -0.01287388801574707, 0.4759904146194458, -0.28104355931282043, -0.342411071062088, -0.060935258865356445, -0.33086276054382324, -0.6832523941993713, 0.3188123404979706, 1.0670557022094727, 0.5039243698120117, 0.08975672721862793, -0.7084716558456421, 0.005433648359030485, -0.2500332295894623, -0.09423228353261948, -0.37705913186073303, 0.9798214435577393, -0.8839513659477234, 0.08441769331693649, -1.2921754121780396, 0.04587024822831154, -0.5493589639663696, -0.40760552883148193, -0.3388806879520416, -0.9236939549446106, 0.35355430841445923, -0.16658265888690948, -1.1374971866607666, 0.18706433475017548, -0.8066443204879761, -0.33648088574409485, 0.9890027642250061, 0.7367281317710876, -0.47326740622520447, 0.3428598642349243, 0.8160764575004578, 0.12502236664295197, 0.29062989354133606, 0.3953968286514282, 0.3062886893749237, 0.03154337778687477, -0.13848350942134857, 0.8166165947914124, 0.55048006772995, 0.33623772859573364, 0.04751211404800415, -0.12520620226860046, 0.603241503238678, 0.6328756809234619, 0.5791001915931702, 0.25249090790748596, -0.30298593640327454, 0.7103102207183838, 0.3147237300872803, -0.4799900949001312, -0.6128751039505005, 0.4275514483451843, 0.08553402125835419, 0.7605194449424744, 0.36946502327919006, -0.14268718659877777, 1.0224145650863647, 0.4629228413105011, 0.7838308215141296, -0.6459915637969971, -0.1553943008184433, 0.38769811391830444, 0.6639220118522644, 0.015307574532926083, 0.36527857184410095, 0.08207418769598007, 0.16095751523971558, 0.2564272880554199, -0.3080712854862213, 0.5558201670646667, -0.8598926067352295, 0.5302993059158325, 0.20560194551944733, 0.008977146819233894, -1.1292833089828491, 0.3144387900829315, 0.5371362566947937, 0.22526432573795319, -0.11233264207839966, -0.37401294708251953, -0.011264488101005554, 0.29209521412849426, -0.5750770568847656, -0.7334496974945068, 0.5471018552780151, 0.8861207962036133, -0.7729644179344177, 0.8195996284484863, 0.6825363039970398, -0.11468612402677536, -1.4346058368682861, -0.17903105914592743, -0.5023297071456909, -0.04637455940246582, -0.554302453994751, 0.316350519657135, 0.8325961232185364, -0.31766313314437866, 0.2329838126897812, 0.23649166524410248, -0.156977578997612, 0.006131203379482031, -0.6333723664283752, 0.005178393796086311, 0.5727888941764832, 0.6589015126228333, -0.3019433915615082, 0.6537922024726868, -1.1004483699798584, 0.2632465660572052, -0.39579349756240845, 0.5682909488677979, 0.20939901471138, -0.20884905755519867, -0.05699140951037407, 0.028278863057494164, -0.2753053903579712, -0.23761998116970062, -0.6111400723457336, 0.4533584713935852, -0.7123051285743713, 0.23890350759029388, -0.6674902439117432, -0.1116238385438919, -0.19557009637355804, 0.40241342782974243, -0.38861775398254395, -0.11521235853433609, -0.10819468647241592, 0.3637966215610504, -0.4539528489112854, 0.6366747617721558, 0.5738806128501892, 0.5253520011901855, -0.39699435234069824, 0.335621178150177, 0.21364927291870117, -0.056301992386579514, 0.3746037781238556, -0.311030775308609, -0.24199452996253967, 0.01786995120346546, 0.4020020663738251, -0.8128271698951721, -0.3846414387226105, 0.9183610081672668, 0.4911261796951294, -0.566614031791687, 0.1481025367975235, -0.8972362279891968, -0.18920950591564178, 0.15196704864501953, -0.16993306577205658, 0.3805454671382904, 0.3474765121936798, -0.22417722642421722, -0.4975971579551697, 0.09509944915771484, 0.753363847732544, 0.2896707057952881, 0.9402577877044678, -0.346850723028183, 0.06511468440294266, 1.0824731588363647, -0.15356187522411346, -0.15050427615642548, -0.0987539067864418, 0.0614912286400795, -0.7896280288696289, 0.002950528636574745, -0.4749029874801636, -0.08472907543182373, 0.5494530200958252, -0.2717481553554535, 0.07925605773925781, 0.38685011863708496, -0.01473304908722639, -0.5186353921890259, -0.5836309790611267, -0.4383079409599304, 0.5063000321388245, 0.5927231907844543, 0.3878057599067688, -0.40837422013282776, -0.4034405052661896, 0.1417798101902008, 0.4517039656639099, -0.16423016786575317, 1.080406665802002, -0.7189895510673523, 0.5661911964416504, -0.09293804317712784, -0.896770715713501, 0.3499719798564911, -0.5040581226348877, -0.04578663408756256, 0.6448125839233398, 0.9238377213478088, 0.7474661469459534, 0.0779004767537117, -0.6694542169570923, -0.706480085849762, -0.13448494672775269, 1.0133193731307983, 0.4403664767742157, 0.15186429023742676, -0.6335251927375793, -1.092615008354187, 0.0429031141102314, -0.7194730639457703, -0.326834112405777, -0.18176501989364624, -0.7458705902099609, -0.6967409253120422, 0.39609745144844055, 0.7080764174461365, 0.7090732455253601, -0.13166427612304688, 0.05778302997350693, 0.08116761595010757, -0.0294992346316576, 0.3995016813278198, 1.1695369482040405, 0.4929155111312866, -0.17175839841365814, 0.4697570204734802, -0.19185252487659454, 0.3440544605255127, 0.17715685069561005, 0.32738378643989563, -0.858781635761261, -0.5610452890396118, -0.3784481883049011, -0.45226871967315674, 0.7780999541282654, 0.37864771485328674, 0.16063790023326874, 0.8872010707855225, 0.4796753227710724, 0.004020045045763254, 0.015953194350004196, 0.8581455945968628, 0.033735424280166626, 0.44381943345069885, 0.255229651927948, -0.25376150012016296, 0.7863415479660034, -0.7562574148178101, 0.5244070887565613, 0.9541923403739929, 0.009709901176393032, -0.9986655712127686, -0.5367357134819031, -0.3231754004955292, -0.11450102925300598, -0.2927604913711548, 1.199318289756775, 0.2809846103191376, 0.5557811260223389, 0.24597592651844025, -0.13720880448818207, 0.40222418308258057, -0.374114453792572, 0.02681691385805607, -0.34054329991340637, -0.0035633917432278395, -0.011509240604937077, -0.15519662201404572, 0.24978770315647125, -0.7901536822319031, -0.8894677758216858, -1.2181445360183716, 0.52031010389328, -0.3244575262069702, -0.11103098094463348, 0.03653756529092789, -0.19202493131160736, -0.4609606862068176, 0.29625463485717773, 0.17508193850517273, -0.023563440889120102, -0.36361268162727356, 0.11213452368974686, -0.06805223971605301, 0.01689344458281994, 0.40393826365470886, -0.40997540950775146, 1.3209129571914673, 0.3056809604167938, -0.3112039268016815, 0.5642370581626892, 0.8558406829833984, -0.4079859256744385, 0.12486544251441956, -0.0009071733802556992, -0.13607633113861084, 0.06269064545631409, -0.2582271993160248, -0.31649643182754517, -0.09290467202663422, 0.03432129696011543, 0.4384457767009735, -0.5328369140625, -0.1360408365726471, 0.8719406127929688, -0.6183260083198547, 0.1251922994852066, 0.1176261305809021, -0.9868072867393494, 0.4663020074367523, 0.03440028056502342, 0.12370730936527252, 0.7187353372573853, -0.8411298990249634, -0.4440583288669586, -0.18988890945911407, -0.8548866510391235, 0.4377893805503845, 0.8907749652862549, 0.3435158431529999, -0.16060881316661835, -0.1871916800737381, -0.9687561988830566, 1.3532286882400513, -0.5539623498916626, 0.3205452263355255, -0.2540849447250366, 0.6246428489685059, -0.008294966071844101, 0.04502218961715698, 0.41611647605895996, 0.11796505004167557, -0.583228588104248, -0.5288809537887573, -0.025438547134399414, 0.02748052030801773, -0.3895927965641022, -0.6076673269271851, -0.14716491103172302, 0.7996366024017334, 0.1702149212360382, -0.4467988908290863, -0.04124246537685394, 0.9149941205978394, -0.17842712998390198, 0.5189962387084961, -0.3657614588737488, -1.1470539569854736, 0.0723772644996643, -0.3194790780544281, 0.6376504898071289, -1.0458624362945557, -0.11970700323581696, -0.8024532198905945, -0.6771916747093201, -0.283935010433197, 0.5792882442474365, 0.05544900894165039, -0.28078150749206543, -0.009754166938364506, -0.040662046521902084, 0.09687373042106628, -0.3949941396713257, -0.023994889110326767, -0.8770322799682617, -0.5922764539718628, -0.6530498266220093, 0.6157141327857971, 0.052239567041397095, 0.1410272717475891, 0.5293245315551758, -0.21328936517238617, 0.22464892268180847, 0.2909996509552002, 0.12508714199066162, -0.3768520653247833, -0.7782259583473206, 0.28049033880233765, -0.42878463864326477, 0.21366851031780243, -0.27652060985565186, 0.5638949275016785, -0.734963595867157, 0.2174418419599533, -0.08868195116519928, 0.2771355211734772, 0.16874940693378448, 0.09289158880710602, 0.45404884219169617, -0.6276208758354187, 0.028062067925930023, 0.40145960450172424, -0.5941157937049866, 0.6878060698509216, 1.0925705432891846, -0.546606183052063, -0.31933537125587463, -0.5083450078964233, -0.7849856019020081, 0.3741507828235626, 0.2672816812992096, -0.12554313242435455, -0.3326890170574188, 0.41905081272125244, -0.7416727542877197, -0.6716826558113098, 0.9128747582435608, 0.5425271987915039, 0.008410805836319923, 0.3762633502483368, 0.046924639493227005, 0.31791600584983826, -0.3274438977241516, 0.6474953889846802, -0.08660971373319626, -0.3001011610031128, 0.30235978960990906, -0.01849520578980446, -0.9757403135299683, -1.1222995519638062, -0.7987077236175537, 0.16737540066242218, 0.032322585582733154, -0.16126903891563416, 1.2909551858901978, -0.11937554180622101, -0.11118794232606888, 0.12747269868850708, 0.8282572031021118, -0.3317025303840637, 0.08237891644239426, 0.8380664587020874, -0.228630930185318, -0.45984306931495667, 0.21118098497390747, -0.262040913105011, -0.2801862061023712, -0.05728256329894066, 0.33281409740448, -0.500662624835968, -0.47461196780204773, -0.21135658025741577, 0.2403237670660019, -0.8464187383651733, 0.249611496925354, -0.6218665242195129, -0.3237650692462921, -0.5120482444763184, -0.3490976095199585, -0.09854315966367722, -0.44965866208076477, -0.12966391444206238, -0.07057676464319229, -0.028621220961213112, 0.48019927740097046, 0.6464085578918457, -0.23917771875858307, -0.527312695980072, -1.11409330368042, -0.14740939438343048, 1.4035546779632568, -0.46478402614593506, -1.2802561521530151, -0.6808258295059204, -0.16024422645568848, -0.36110731959342957, -0.36391523480415344, 0.48524901270866394, 0.11447804421186447, 0.0005871487664990127, 0.4936928451061249, -0.17287251353263855, 0.4150717854499817, 0.5878891348838806, -0.05866234749555588, 0.5014789700508118, 0.33735862374305725, -0.536165714263916, -0.4712352752685547, 0.21096356213092804, 0.6338233947753906, 0.5118274092674255, -0.08777643740177155, -0.5392436385154724, -0.022069115191698074, -0.6585546731948853, -0.4777904152870178, 0.2578810453414917, -0.38424041867256165, -0.6483879685401917, -0.7139930725097656, -0.8601997494697571, -0.003320001531392336, -0.30845141410827637, -0.20232553780078888, -0.24898725748062134, 0.11783627420663834, -0.20218056440353394, -0.1203962191939354, -0.6446078419685364, 0.6036102175712585, -0.28304120898246765, -0.5673404335975647, -0.5472636222839355, -0.6129231452941895, 0.13780012726783752, -0.6637343764305115, -0.5371720790863037, -0.6337732672691345, 0.39821696281433105, 0.5674482583999634, -0.2444879561662674, 0.9931133985519409, -1.1523096561431885, -0.45036131143569946, -0.2749682068824768, 0.37364569306373596, 0.18392209708690643, 0.6727673411369324, 1.0481774806976318, 1.3503055572509766, -0.13039317727088928, -0.06746719777584076, 0.14977389574050903, 0.2941089868545532, -1.0562927722930908, -0.09672839939594269, -0.31652045249938965, 0.40960249304771423, -0.4295153021812439, -0.036824263632297516, 0.8206392526626587, 0.7839553952217102, -0.861519455909729, 0.2470337301492691, -0.7263700366020203, 0.7113322019577026, -0.32570913434028625, 0.12751613557338715, 0.015960335731506348, 0.39404016733169556, 0.40829524397850037, 0.7487261891365051, -0.11386919021606445, -0.20800428092479706, -0.023074688389897346, -0.22192279994487762, 0.5123074650764465, 0.22593651711940765, 0.05597635358572006, -0.4934636652469635, -0.1912441998720169, 0.18474285304546356, -0.1919778734445572, 0.2798599302768707, -0.9723456501960754, -0.030884351581335068, -0.49388986825942993, -0.49215757846832275, -0.7332489490509033, -0.35193443298339844, 0.730879008769989, -0.2934860587120056, -0.19561277329921722, 0.15866537392139435, -1.0780609846115112, 0.445712685585022, -0.3235185146331787, -1.363057017326355, -0.32322847843170166, -0.8757550120353699, 0.2822631597518921, 0.5034269690513611, -0.6268020868301392, 0.01739298552274704, -0.32782500982284546, 0.45279690623283386, 0.17029564082622528, -0.09567049890756607, -0.5132784247398376, 0.9629293084144592, -0.13845866918563843, 1.1946629285812378, -0.4987036883831024, 0.2992042303085327, -0.3226121664047241, -0.9566896557807922, 0.037534747272729874, 1.003736972808838, 0.08971735835075378, -0.24303698539733887, -0.3925365209579468, 0.2484647035598755, -0.4370456635951996, 0.000876318197697401, -1.006932020187378, -0.663768470287323, -0.6303136944770813, 0.8285433650016785, 0.29936838150024414, -0.2156786024570465, 0.4837878346443176, 0.7149606347084045, 0.2230004221200943, -0.13260680437088013, 0.08475501090288162, 0.3600008189678192, 0.32592886686325073, -0.3856290280818939, 0.5159508585929871, 0.7999491691589355, 0.3048268258571625, 0.2775132358074188, -1.1243220567703247, 0.44147640466690063, -0.0636131763458252, 0.30137619376182556, 0.7922583222389221, 0.7016260027885437, 0.09067907929420471, 0.20464494824409485, 0.13364240527153015, 0.751534640789032, 0.14020265638828278, 0.5343219637870789, -0.5030072927474976, 0.5550402998924255, -0.3742000460624695, 0.12845353782176971, -0.44637399911880493, 0.5115959048271179, 0.46638041734695435, -0.2612665891647339, -0.09203414618968964, 0.5837691426277161, 0.556056559085846, 0.3122161626815796, -1.0790119171142578, -0.25592875480651855, 0.055981043726205826, -0.05155972018837929, 0.5748900771141052, 0.549079418182373, -0.11559194326400757, 0.6509275436401367, 0.8898792266845703, 0.8172510266304016, -0.40382733941078186, 0.7067597508430481, 0.454239159822464, 0.8696165084838867, 0.2848568260669708, 0.5490720868110657, 0.02633661963045597, 0.605320394039154, -0.11103649437427521, -1.2622966766357422, -0.19870558381080627, 0.19677728414535522, -1.345636248588562, 0.625394344329834, -0.5380319952964783, 0.2912207245826721, 0.1754068285226822, -0.6318365931510925, 0.6158530116081238, -0.5644897818565369, -0.11572489142417908, 1.0087324380874634, -0.9839926362037659, 0.32578057050704956, 0.31211617588996887, -0.033697571605443954, 0.05388779565691948, 1.0255206823349, -0.035113606601953506, -1.350428819656372, 1.425038456916809, 0.9212656617164612, -0.1936713606119156, 0.3502001464366913, -0.08511898666620255, -0.7339802980422974, 0.32028287649154663, 0.11011164635419846, -0.567130446434021, 1.0537623167037964, 0.1753772795200348, -0.5642419457435608, 0.3412124216556549, -0.22395490109920502, -0.16732661426067352, -0.19536708295345306, 0.08835411071777344, 0.5722137093544006, -0.3301502764225006, 0.660412609577179, 1.1480883359909058, 0.7743546366691589, -0.20483635365962982, -0.9133172631263733, -0.32517382502555847, -0.1375565230846405, -1.1982662677764893, -0.1450715810060501, 0.4114644527435303, -0.6064367294311523, 0.35620880126953125, -0.22458547353744507, -0.6043656468391418, -0.195533886551857, -0.06475231796503067, -0.8248134255409241, -0.30046510696411133, 0.3761592507362366, -0.4883841574192047, 0.9966687560081482, 0.0681161880493164, -0.5181307196617126, 0.286486953496933, 0.18871939182281494, 1.3971014022827148, 0.1002785712480545, 0.7744612097740173, 0.11921797692775726, 0.4320167601108551, -0.5966501832008362, 0.7696394920349121, 0.42694327235221863, -1.1265085935592651, 0.3557349145412445, -0.6303187608718872, 0.09494155645370483, -0.19641077518463135, -0.591699481010437, -0.4740919768810272, 0.5256298184394836, 0.1090940460562706, 0.19005222618579865, -0.44237029552459717, 0.26759693026542664, -1.1954408884048462, -0.46473145484924316, -0.2255922108888626, 0.4012931287288666, -0.7046655416488647, -0.16713149845600128, 0.057743437588214874, -0.7520455718040466, 3.904296875, 0.41570064425468445, 0.1987193524837494, -0.18684206902980804, 0.22281137108802795, -0.07047631591558456, 0.7010955810546875, -0.660412073135376, -0.3490578532218933, -0.28494223952293396, -0.3331226706504822, -0.4836026728153229, -0.056292206048965454, 0.025997554883360863, -0.14270684123039246, 0.8619270324707031, -0.5995894074440002, -0.8434186577796936, 0.21099601686000824, -1.6367510557174683, -0.3036193549633026, -0.5150017738342285, 0.22349750995635986, 0.34516239166259766, 0.1054234728217125, -0.3504818081855774, -0.18423594534397125, 0.005593976005911827, -0.7839332222938538, 0.38042309880256653, -1.0194406509399414, -1.0701597929000854, 0.8811650276184082, 0.21070420742034912, -1.1895191669464111, 0.2640398442745209, 0.1848512589931488, 0.3433815836906433, 0.14150963723659515, 0.03900352120399475, -0.2739216685295105, 0.2676912248134613, -0.18536624312400818, -0.4320871829986572, -0.8349199295043945, 0.774042546749115, -0.3743312656879425, 0.647355318069458, 0.4791952669620514, -0.6854327917098999, 0.7466621398925781, -0.1314489096403122, 0.21908773481845856, -0.007673485204577446, -0.9741601943969727, 0.6832033395767212, -0.059139855206012726, 0.26106733083724976, 0.47899654507637024, 0.0012494202237576246, 0.47243359684944153, -0.40416157245635986, -0.6349553465843201, 0.022896315902471542, -0.6398078799247742, 0.8041513562202454, -0.6609258055686951, 0.11807490140199661, -0.6340456604957581, 0.4694431722164154, 0.17272186279296875, -0.998816967010498, -0.1674431711435318, -0.48284146189689636, -0.2700522243976593, -0.02092163637280464, 0.0704740360379219, 0.5841346383094788, -0.3056046962738037, 0.12375423312187195, 0.7873480319976807, -0.4620908796787262, -0.982077419757843, 0.20375384390354156, 0.11981313675642014, 0.7627061009407043, -0.9373390078544617, 0.49307146668434143, -0.7652987837791443, 0.7392738461494446, 0.15492255985736847, 0.556423008441925, -0.16464565694332123, -0.04707297682762146, -0.6585404276847839 ]
Dispersion of the Third-Order Nonlinear Optical Susceptibility in C_{60} Calculated with a Tight-Binding Model
The frequency dependence of third harmonic generation (THG) in C_{60} is calculated, making use of a tight-binding model for pi-electrons. The magnitudes of the THG, about 10^{-12} esu, near zero frequency, agree with those in experiments for the low-energy region. We can also explain the order of the magnitude, 10^{-11} esu, around the three-photon resonance peak due to the lowest allowed excitation, recently measured by Meth et al. At higher energies, we predict a large enhancement of the THG at 3 omega \sim 6eV as a result of double resonance enhancement.
Kikuo Harigaya and Shuji Abe (Fundamental Physics Section, Electrotechnical Laboratory, Japan)
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205012
cond-mat/9205013
[ 0.1968318670988083, 1.1205540895462036, 0.9556637406349182, 0.5213717818260193, -0.36126604676246643, 0.07837764918804169, -0.37919747829437256, -0.43891409039497375, -0.43286070227622986, 1.431834101676941, 0.1517670899629593, -0.25235992670059204, 0.2189241647720337, -0.6689530611038208, -0.11422265321016312, 0.34333479404449463, 0.14180336892604828, -0.12836213409900665, -0.9458776712417603, -0.773690938949585, -0.3590289056301117, -1.0677281618118286, -0.8903981447219849, -0.439679354429245, -0.17316366732120514, 0.2840820252895355, 0.17164212465286255, -0.029939750209450722, 1.0077242851257324, 0.3798484206199646, 0.5652235746383667, -0.2508618235588074, 0.11364374309778214, -0.696936309337616, 0.11473999917507172, 0.7151665091514587, 0.9546436667442322, -0.19749097526073456, -0.12743152678012848, -0.4508994519710541, 1.31585693359375, -0.12466692179441452, 0.6002448797225952, -0.4919431209564209, -0.05451403930783272, -0.1772611290216446, 0.2890298664569855, 0.2895793914794922, 0.2232263684272766, -0.8996927738189697, 0.10704106092453003, -0.26659590005874634, 0.33352330327033997, -0.7636123299598694, -0.6170700192451477, -0.004173722583800554, -0.34555694460868835, 0.3771095275878906, -0.17572130262851715, 0.44024986028671265, 0.1221717968583107, 0.15894575417041779, 0.1960151344537735, -0.16360905766487122, 0.33877190947532654, 0.8196753263473511, -0.6049357056617737, 0.8135150074958801, -0.6294797658920288, 0.5089398622512817, -0.20638582110404968, 0.20211225748062134, 0.19139769673347473, 0.14567893743515015, -0.3100794553756714, 0.34495362639427185, 0.7776749134063721, 0.07661107182502747, -0.0338863730430603, -0.025996891781687737, 0.00019020044419448823, 0.7750913500785828, 0.1256343126296997, 0.40602466464042664, -0.5619763135910034, -0.66347736120224, 0.19707807898521423, 0.5381622314453125, 0.537714958190918, -0.16998431086540222, 0.5157899260520935, 1.279131531715393, 0.44297468662261963, -0.5144413113594055, 0.012851853854954243, 0.2562715411186218, -0.16030599176883698, 0.3295315206050873, -0.055362630635499954, 0.3069625794887543, 0.25986096262931824, 0.8429095149040222, 0.06545833498239517, 0.38133901357650757, -0.5179389119148254, 0.3934376835823059, 0.2258385419845581, -0.0521467924118042, 0.5173659920692444, -0.5633054971694946, 0.04020465910434723, 0.274400532245636, -0.24211154878139496, -0.21944856643676758, 0.3020743131637573, -0.20647841691970825, 0.6434125304222107, 0.011405384168028831, -0.46632030606269836, -0.15621237456798553, -0.5139481425285339, -0.31715139746665955, 0.442504346370697, -0.22626683115959167, -0.873023271560669, -0.272466242313385, -0.18081752955913544, 0.27821364998817444, -0.6143060326576233, -0.5634510517120361, -0.007694796193391085, -0.7778753042221069, -0.4914158582687378, 0.44866299629211426, 0.8470399379730225, 0.48023995757102966, 0.8525394201278687, 1.0348339080810547, -0.05545797571539879, 0.13803845643997192, -0.008026281371712685, -0.8974640369415283, 0.285265177488327, 1.1631889343261719, -0.6541880965232849, 1.0153617858886719, 0.31990110874176025, -0.16247500479221344, -0.04341661185026169, 0.5180820822715759, -0.8321884870529175, 0.015354927629232407, -0.35329386591911316, -0.022666195407509804, -0.19905008375644684, 0.2475551962852478, -0.43541890382766724, 0.22671642899513245, -0.7255802750587463, -0.04313584044575691, -0.3775290250778198, -0.36460819840431213, 0.42241671681404114, 0.2899423837661743, -0.4480712115764618, 0.3185288906097412, -0.33627527952194214, -0.3856663107872009, -0.3795463740825653, -0.8452189564704895, 0.30336296558380127, -0.45986565947532654, 0.07906387001276016, 0.04659993201494217, 0.5458585619926453, 0.2546110153198242, 0.35603034496307373, 0.10883542895317078, -0.3327566683292389, 0.46833473443984985, -0.10685022175312042, -0.28794917464256287, 0.5659722089767456, 0.3627041280269623, 0.136211559176445, 0.2541666328907013, -0.49234041571617126, 0.5280839800834656, -0.4355175793170929, 0.7297733426094055, 0.36023619771003723, 1.0664721727371216, -0.944054365158081, 0.25074502825737, -0.4766911268234253, -0.6059325933456421, -0.020936284214258194, 0.1305828094482422, -0.1606035679578781, -1.1876107454299927, 0.29807525873184204, 0.31092143058776855, -0.9762336015701294, -0.2603664696216583, -0.9055679440498352, 0.4632590413093567, 0.10683415830135345, 0.6305188536643982, -0.3442472815513611, -0.6787811517715454, 0.04024112597107887, -0.2120850384235382, 0.6339600682258606, 0.6700760722160339, 0.05953672155737877, -0.1468268185853958, -0.130925714969635, -0.2831057608127594, 0.4797526001930237, -0.14783309400081635, 0.7668377161026001, -0.3006609380245209, -0.06661295890808105, 0.826116144657135, -0.06817710399627686, -0.23967376351356506, 0.06542152911424637, 0.559800386428833, 0.11233869194984436, -0.03404881805181503, 0.2845313251018524, 0.5372670888900757, -0.8618502020835876, 0.43138936161994934, 0.5670514702796936, 0.23002268373966217, 0.618320643901825, 0.198654443025589, -0.4059247374534607, -0.06247444450855255, 0.03713852912187576, 0.11108845472335815, 0.4036664068698883, 0.46747255325317383, -0.034365445375442505, 0.3939271569252014, -0.025263587012887, -0.2866186201572418, -1.0300017595291138, 0.2714160978794098, -0.7769246101379395, 0.5441017746925354, -0.0329786017537117, 0.06162874028086662, -0.25533461570739746, 0.1771363914012909, -0.2710972726345062, 0.5163834691047668, -0.5079935789108276, -0.37864378094673157, 0.6025236248970032, 0.029043370857834816, -0.4495081901550293, -0.6555848121643066, 0.01001326646655798, 0.771888792514801, 0.1741911917924881, -0.020530657842755318, -0.5408440828323364, -0.2317904233932495, -1.306286334991455, -0.598415195941925, -0.3051314651966095, -0.2571413516998291, -0.1948184370994568, -0.06613913178443909, 0.6072474718093872, -0.5011175870895386, 0.1851063221693039, -0.2246132344007492, -0.19940178096294403, 0.38633298873901367, -0.19718046486377716, -0.20782627165317535, -0.14741066098213196, -0.4512295722961426, -0.48187384009361267, 0.8799334764480591, -0.22302734851837158, 0.8731071352958679, -0.279983252286911, -0.09740915149450302, -0.5802611708641052, -0.8132548332214355, 0.0951012521982193, -0.4565170407295227, -0.08109550178050995, -0.09610807150602341, -0.20253682136535645, -0.5297208428382874, 0.001568732550367713, -1.2862900495529175, -0.18382610380649567, -1.137941837310791, -0.29806146025657654, 0.5777550339698792, -0.024181853979825974, -0.4574434161186218, 0.14551052451133728, 0.23861601948738098, -0.5407030582427979, 0.24070090055465698, -0.24164067208766937, 0.1947454810142517, -0.245188906788826, 1.554216742515564, 0.7949531078338623, -0.013252338394522667, -0.04377812147140503, -0.5874897837638855, -0.10301383584737778, -0.34060138463974, 0.6675136685371399, -1.2856589555740356, 0.12975336611270905, 1.2634130716323853, 0.5617982149124146, -0.30267491936683655, 0.9123820662498474, 0.05107738450169563, -0.1262376457452774, 0.2596842050552368, -0.22109809517860413, 0.15459230542182922, 0.41131365299224854, -0.4562370777130127, -0.005579313263297081, 0.6617721319198608, 0.42673197388648987, 0.328158974647522, 0.07291688024997711, -0.7197399735450745, 0.19803012907505035, 0.9436386227607727, -0.5921874642372131, -0.25607818365097046, 0.7973828315734863, -0.7630999088287354, 0.10014259070158005, -0.5284286737442017, -0.48918482661247253, -0.022351276129484177, 1.2109193801879883, 0.62470942735672, 0.38042011857032776, 0.20140358805656433, -0.19547916948795319, -0.48898845911026, -0.4720933139324188, 0.21448394656181335, 0.02302100509405136, 0.27952849864959717, -0.15626434981822968, -0.3718712031841278, -0.2849988639354706, 0.16234783828258514, 0.2672739326953888, 0.3171996772289276, 0.545380175113678, -1.034253716468811, 0.5736645460128784, 0.1551995873451233, -0.26777184009552, -0.18830226361751556, 0.20930248498916626, 0.24557244777679443, 0.5874583721160889, 0.7593637704849243, 0.5155081152915955, -0.06892472505569458, -0.9994478225708008, -0.4351765513420105, 0.2579681873321533, 0.2562876045703888, -0.0773775726556778, 0.192377507686615, 0.37695738673210144, -0.16595792770385742, -0.11445334553718567, -1.1318367719650269, -0.1664002388715744, -0.5569003820419312, -0.35071656107902527, -0.8830916285514832, -0.1643962413072586, -0.19243572652339935, 1.1343861818313599, -0.019479675218462944, -0.42129313945770264, 0.00530408276244998, 0.041621215641498566, -0.5875763297080994, 0.2261795997619629, -0.1507587432861328, 0.3971109688282013, -0.139981210231781, -0.5554744601249695, 0.7541895508766174, -0.153677299618721, -0.00717882439494133, -0.12228354811668396, -0.9068989157676697, 0.5354375243186951, -0.11592985689640045, 0.02125001884996891, 0.56545490026474, 0.017953529953956604, 0.2819196283817291, 0.16713733971118927, 0.23556135594844818, -0.8294516205787659, -0.5555781126022339, 0.2449740469455719, 1.0065187215805054, 0.26179614663124084, -1.128499984741211, 0.12944519519805908, -0.5539067387580872, 0.4024707078933716, 0.009182908572256565, -0.6152509450912476, -0.6009374260902405, 0.09496606141328812, 0.7627983689308167, -0.6981037259101868, 1.0295875072479248, 0.4727472960948944, -0.3113448917865753, 0.27069905400276184, 0.08484778553247452, -0.3920303285121918, 0.22402910888195038, -0.30398237705230713, -0.5383402705192566, 0.16925235092639923, -0.01012793555855751, 0.37382787466049194, 0.6301790475845337, -0.2558586895465851, -0.2393697053194046, 0.18179075419902802, -0.28080683946609497, 0.75681072473526, -0.2839468717575073, -0.13743986189365387, 0.2013980746269226, -0.23167766630649567, -0.5686472058296204, 1.1306718587875366, 0.4056375026702881, -0.49703162908554077, 0.3705720901489258, -0.3763391077518463, -0.9777721166610718, -0.9959219098091125, 0.6803273558616638, -0.15415741503238678, -0.010176251642405987, 0.5271109342575073, 0.07902483642101288, 0.22974349558353424, 0.5665081739425659, -0.3042587339878082, 0.5745666027069092, 0.9249478578567505, -0.43623173236846924, 0.3832762837409973, -0.4328228235244751, -0.03374768793582916, -0.7907284498214722, -0.7600768804550171, 0.5524429678916931, -0.18661515414714813, -0.27918580174446106, 0.04671193286776543, -0.2895181477069855, 0.04738863557577133, 0.44465500116348267, 0.09729480743408203, 0.15614748001098633, -0.6943657994270325, -0.4077252149581909, -0.636207103729248, -1.4299306869506836, -0.25495415925979614, -0.053264111280441284, 0.4833219051361084, -0.17717492580413818, 0.5434606671333313, 0.24515116214752197, -0.4417456090450287, 0.0003142394416499883, -0.8248937129974365, 0.38412368297576904, -0.34453263878822327, -0.546055018901825, -0.7371355295181274, 0.05394083634018898, -0.15953947603702545, 0.7075741291046143, -0.25115033984184265, -0.3459579050540924, -0.2582574486732483, -0.28286588191986084, -0.30250224471092224, 0.545883059501648, 0.37665873765945435, 0.3391421139240265, -0.4833439290523529, 0.6812629103660583, 0.014542332850396633, -0.8152124881744385, 0.29078447818756104, 0.7021773457527161, -0.2755621075630188, -0.09655348211526871, -0.28896164894104004, -1.0419530868530273, 0.19618691504001617, 0.46210911870002747, 0.9460152387619019, -0.9996731877326965, 0.0915912464261055, -0.4309258460998535, -0.5338693261146545, -0.20386141538619995, 0.18441137671470642, -0.003276621690019965, -0.33334049582481384, -0.436749666929245, -0.6115579009056091, 0.2945846915245056, -0.5979421734809875, 0.1925419718027115, -0.423469215631485, 0.3807685673236847, -0.8364970684051514, 0.3712631165981293, -0.9046826362609863, -0.06394320726394653, -0.11429920792579651, 0.5498692393302917, 0.5896925926208496, 0.9946166276931763, 0.22875212132930756, -0.29287582635879517, 0.36171743273735046, 0.3994317352771759, 0.11399944871664047, 0.3495236039161682, -0.33393949270248413, -0.16462232172489166, -0.7115707397460938, -0.28834331035614014, -0.2551936209201813, 0.19708439707756042, 0.10125625878572464, -0.7602112889289856, 0.8188495635986328, -0.7050396800041199, -0.04267137125134468, 0.45685672760009766, 0.06764307618141174, 0.9064154624938965, 0.07018717378377914, -0.3879929780960083, -0.2761876881122589, -0.7619020342826843, -1.0932096242904663, 0.859298825263977, -0.04684826359152794, -0.14388836920261383, 0.21562224626541138, 0.10347060114145279, 0.13086844980716705, -1.0326874256134033, 0.7591116428375244, 0.9266797304153442, 0.26796093583106995, 0.22533130645751953, -0.3435906171798706, -0.25611984729766846, 0.08115619421005249, 0.1983134001493454, 0.5871996283531189, -0.048688095062971115, -0.5919693112373352, -0.2887299656867981, -0.667445719242096, -0.6727458834648132, -0.7612741589546204, 0.4925486147403717, 0.23452985286712646, -0.4854026436805725, 1.3150525093078613, -0.1669522076845169, -0.18450519442558289, -0.2143958956003189, -0.06309005618095398, -0.39961621165275574, 0.08482422679662704, 0.9076478481292725, 0.4526362419128418, 0.1437421292066574, 0.3696116805076599, -0.4170387089252472, -0.5824056267738342, -0.4289836883544922, 0.1471083015203476, -0.8099638223648071, -0.3189278542995453, 0.029202589765191078, 0.056784890592098236, -0.33909034729003906, -0.7918676137924194, -0.6131672859191895, 0.11989080160856247, 0.6079716086387634, -0.918066680431366, -0.21066202223300934, -0.461802214384079, -0.586355447769165, -0.3732772767543793, 0.40831258893013, -0.03885576128959656, 0.528789222240448, 0.02732097916305065, -0.29844921827316284, -0.16659051179885864, 0.24634671211242676, 1.067125678062439, -0.4650835692882538, -0.2728271186351776, -0.8640137314796448, -0.7144697308540344, -0.6100823283195496, 0.12838104367256165, 0.31953316926956177, -0.3260021209716797, 0.2787713408470154, 0.09567180275917053, -0.4367885887622833, 0.19195477664470673, 1.0720055103302002, 1.2133077383041382, -0.10399015992879868, -0.43401166796684265, -0.41446590423583984, -0.46823519468307495, 0.3226589262485504, -0.007776947226375341, 0.8364282846450806, 0.24579843878746033, 0.13920672237873077, -0.39569634199142456, -0.3321578800678253, -0.4481750428676605, -1.1663575172424316, 0.23711812496185303, -0.896489143371582, -0.9641115665435791, -1.0768005847930908, -0.8707552552223206, 0.4965861737728119, -0.10850553959608078, 0.1735098958015442, 0.06971827894449234, -0.6174048185348511, 0.036606475710868835, 0.27788710594177246, 0.6727691888809204, 0.09667401760816574, 0.501227617263794, -0.8262667059898376, -0.270776629447937, -0.1677929311990738, -0.4882006049156189, -0.0880817398428917, 0.7852869629859924, -0.3523940443992615, 0.012349152937531471, -0.4971276521682739, 0.552577555179596, -0.44196057319641113, -0.5445085167884827, -0.14501126110553741, -0.4266476035118103, -1.0051212310791016, 0.1958235800266266, -0.24760957062244415, 0.7783370018005371, -0.11727804690599442, -0.3294297754764557, 0.33867400884628296, 0.1306954026222229, -0.8230075240135193, 0.2512489855289459, 0.13095740973949432, 0.14156769216060638, -0.045911755412817, -0.3439805209636688, 0.5521695017814636, 0.5205346345901489, -0.3997800052165985, -0.014605185016989708, 0.3518923223018646, 0.7091593742370605, -0.18889465928077698, 0.021748939529061317, -0.5509514808654785, 1.0436701774597168, -0.42030850052833557, 0.07911278307437897, 0.22306078672409058, -0.09099901467561722, 0.17667141556739807, -0.5744408965110779, 0.025234200060367584, -0.6989637613296509, 0.46753501892089844, -1.312103271484375, 0.807381808757782, 1.2142424583435059, -0.33896905183792114, 0.21710023283958435, 0.3938484787940979, 0.13523675501346588, -0.83266681432724, -0.03957264497876167, -0.9955331683158875, 0.9940370917320251, -0.1700596958398819, -0.2035253345966339, -0.28725144267082214, -0.43041184544563293, -0.8106542825698853, -0.29065772891044617, -0.300484836101532, -0.19632269442081451, -0.45712658762931824, -0.08489344269037247, -0.09453556686639786, 0.1397617608308792, 0.07179886847734451, 0.20623178780078888, 0.053553204983472824, 0.2658378481864929, -0.2526260316371918, 0.12653416395187378, 0.332760214805603, -0.20442773401737213, -0.9873985648155212, 0.3067772388458252, -0.1600385308265686, -0.0321572870016098, -0.5266907215118408, -0.5356221199035645, -0.253243088722229, 0.06557521224021912, -0.5530586838722229, 0.010268435813486576, -0.6535890698432922, 0.4303078055381775, 0.465849369764328, 0.17297962307929993, -0.9304085373878479, -0.23130378127098083, -0.08843874931335449, 0.4929928481578827, 0.06730340421199799, 0.047728314995765686, -0.19843615591526031, 0.831927478313446, 0.3135060966014862, 0.3094111979007721, -0.6906758546829224, 0.26692262291908264, -0.34112995862960815, -0.33108094334602356, 0.44844046235084534, 0.031107516959309578, 0.7552284002304077, -0.18411672115325928, -0.3031635284423828, -0.564175546169281, 0.57943195104599, 0.18815761804580688, 0.654212474822998, 0.10754776746034622, -0.07706819474697113, 0.009882254526019096, 0.06429258733987808, 0.0689048022031784, 0.703142523765564, 0.30003461241722107, -0.6696984767913818, 0.7040770053863525, -0.3943187892436981, 0.31432244181632996, -0.10224154591560364, 0.3279280662536621, 0.01812582090497017, -0.5860586762428284, -0.2299150973558426, 0.3872385025024414, -0.11424164474010468, 0.7454708218574524, 0.046010617166757584, -0.43086013197898865, -0.07201185077428818, 0.5588823556900024, 0.3500819802284241, -0.04728487506508827, -0.12778203189373016, 0.622784435749054, 0.9814606308937073, 0.5617121458053589, 0.17333310842514038, 0.82500159740448, 0.4319683015346527, 0.12592065334320068, -0.7402316331863403, 0.6661199331283569, 0.3365947902202606, 0.18845069408416748, -0.41284653544425964, 0.06575336307287216, -0.2649271488189697, 0.6527357697486877, -1.251092553138733, 0.26545751094818115, -0.5289496779441833, -0.3488013446331024, -0.2957128584384918, -1.1996947526931763, 0.2886087894439697, -0.6585977673530579, 0.25356602668762207, 0.9752366542816162, 0.24760445952415466, -0.25236907601356506, 0.45496511459350586, 0.011063698679208755, -0.0002627015928737819, 1.4050573110580444, 0.6020263433456421, -0.2783491313457489, 1.0623044967651367, -0.06347192823886871, 0.46664756536483765, 0.2538406550884247, 0.03866780921816826, -0.4587903320789337, 0.057728156447410583, -0.24014809727668762, 0.04473469406366348, 0.3170592784881592, 0.170374795794487, 0.13304778933525085, -0.20172299444675446, -0.16257590055465698, -0.6585726737976074, -0.7170072793960571, 0.4287723898887634, 0.36016178131103516, -0.08308276534080505, -0.1384354680776596, 0.928875744342804, 0.6120234727859497, 0.26056164503097534, -0.5736323595046997, -0.1435282677412033, -0.13558506965637207, -0.4663581848144531, 0.030530346557497978, -0.017018571496009827, -0.16051174700260162, -0.6313515305519104, -0.22922393679618835, -0.6610860824584961, 0.18919162452220917, -0.6295924186706543, -0.10970241576433182, -0.8635860681533813, 0.2030806541442871, 0.61809241771698, 1.501594066619873, 0.8360245227813721, -1.152000069618225, -0.7660242319107056, 0.47852855920791626, 0.7079896926879883, 0.24088385701179504, 0.3087526559829712, 0.3399442434310913, 0.030404578894376755, -0.3681410253047943, 0.25011494755744934, 0.6087846755981445, -0.1251891404390335, 0.086658775806427, 0.2154167741537094, -0.28467151522636414, -0.6740189790725708, 0.022662457078695297, -0.022500384598970413, 1.137877106666565, 0.38914981484413147, -0.7390085458755493, 0.17268311977386475, -0.04925481975078583, -0.7305923104286194, 0.45708125829696655, -0.7904685139656067, 0.2564198970794678, 1.1173049211502075, 0.157987579703331, -0.25068172812461853, -0.11945055425167084, 4.205458164215088, 0.7038265466690063, 0.6713905334472656, -0.16053633391857147, 0.27183687686920166, 0.8933789134025574, 0.5590833425521851, -0.6788108944892883, 0.34294500946998596, -0.2806551456451416, 0.40242838859558105, -0.4865815341472626, 0.4036841094493866, 0.3072277903556824, -0.338093638420105, 0.4011608362197876, -0.7047883868217468, -0.002480355091392994, -0.19252163171768188, -1.0058075189590454, -0.5552962422370911, -0.17150373756885529, -0.04164490848779678, -0.09383336454629898, 0.40350136160850525, 0.056507039815187454, -0.010557178407907486, 0.16000664234161377, 0.35397207736968994, -1.0511215925216675, -0.28733646869659424, -0.38759753108024597, 0.7040173411369324, -0.22515638172626495, -0.2548292875289917, 0.5490979552268982, -0.28212472796440125, 0.4155833125114441, 0.16538411378860474, 0.287440687417984, 0.016436967998743057, -0.12874023616313934, -0.40279659628868103, -0.05631674453616142, -0.6940830945968628, 0.9725920557975769, 0.30757445096969604, 0.49329784512519836, 0.7822497487068176, -0.8937007784843445, 0.3601144254207611, -0.42543694376945496, 0.2659769058227539, 0.2297278195619583, -0.38831767439842224, 0.0405903086066246, -0.30419212579727173, -1.063417673110962, -0.26894694566726685, 0.44381001591682434, 1.1585354804992676, -0.08490153402090073, -0.07605244964361191, -0.03045610710978508, 0.19656749069690704, 0.7407740950584412, 0.34966668486595154, -0.1509600281715393, -0.13411645591259003, -0.40529757738113403, -0.20288217067718506, -0.68272465467453, -0.028602533042430878, -0.37625938653945923, 0.36660364270210266, -0.17879001796245575, 0.3627263903617859, 0.25189918279647827, 0.11175691336393356, 0.038312215358018875, 0.6864116787910461, -0.2682614326477051, 0.16846995055675507, -0.12367476522922516, -0.7841397523880005, 0.5103973746299744, -0.1337292194366455, -0.35898885130882263, 0.38814008235931396, 0.6146716475486755, 0.4891284704208374, 1.2442026138305664, -0.69394451379776, 0.08338312804698944, -0.8527005314826965 ]
Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Compressible Fluid Flow in Two-Dimensional Channels
We study compressible fluid flow in narrow two-dimensional channels using a novel molecular dynamics simulation method. In the simulation area, an upstream source is maintained at constant density and temperature while a downstream reservoir is kept at vacuum. The channel is sufficiently long in the direction of the flow that the finite length has little effect on the properties of the fluid in the central region. The simulated system is represented by an efficient data structure, whose internal elements are created and manipulated dynamically in a layered fashion. Consequently the code is highly efficient and manifests completely linear performance in simulations of large systems. We obtain the steady-state velocity, temperature, and density distributions in the system. The velocity distribution across the channel is very nearly a quadratic function of the distance from the center of the channel and reveals velocity slip at the boundaries; the temperature distribution is only approximately a quartic function of this distance from the center to the channel. The density distribution across the channel is non-uniform. We attribute this non-uniformity to the relatively high Mach number, approximately 0.5, in the fluid flow. An equation for the density distribution based on simple compressibility arguments is proposed; its predictions agree well with the simulation results. Validity of the concept of local dynamic temperature and the variation of the temperature along the channel are discussed.
M. Sun and C. Ebner (Department of Physics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH)
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205013
cond-mat/9205014
[ -0.5906704068183899, -0.5495745539665222, -0.20273266732692719, 0.12065508961677551, -0.8944928646087646, 0.13494187593460083, -0.5841705203056335, -0.5390785336494446, -0.1691896617412567, 0.8333649039268494, 1.0226044654846191, -0.23237361013889313, 0.8179746866226196, -1.1083108186721802, -0.6175084114074707, -0.43672895431518555, -0.0487261600792408, 0.05882186070084572, -1.196114182472229, -0.5276525616645813, 0.09122201800346375, -0.07534603029489517, -1.1664323806762695, -0.2732410132884979, 0.04543689638376236, 0.989124596118927, 0.4013255536556244, 0.3798794746398926, 1.3457186222076416, 0.6459870934486389, 0.6451226472854614, 0.26401254534721375, 0.01855822652578354, -0.7292854189872742, -0.04155205190181732, -0.00023451799643225968, 0.10801903903484344, -0.08913682401180267, 0.7426225543022156, -0.42772576212882996, 1.5075417757034302, -0.7053691744804382, 0.5295875072479248, -0.15462015569210052, -0.5270392298698425, 0.006442139390856028, -0.801200270652771, 0.04727146774530411, -0.22522039711475372, -1.4326509237289429, -0.35473379492759705, 0.45964372158050537, 0.24920645356178284, -0.19708159565925598, 0.21629685163497925, 0.04036369547247887, -0.07678757607936859, -0.021434361115098, -0.45206305384635925, 0.1714257001876831, 0.12950854003429413, 0.12660636007785797, 0.30663856863975525, -0.4931126534938812, 0.2485225647687912, 0.5658377408981323, -0.11502642184495926, 0.8079293370246887, -0.04998321831226349, 0.03161592036485672, 0.131192147731781, -1.0157819986343384, -0.0972275361418724, -0.6776473522186279, -0.1063210517168045, 0.07604177296161652, -0.03075518272817135, -0.19013744592666626, -1.5192852020263672, 0.11409668624401093, -0.4524204432964325, 0.00044689656351692975, -0.35637855529785156, 0.6668092608451843, -0.32685860991477966, -0.5902435183525085, -0.23863770067691803, 0.22029823064804077, 0.2509404122829437, 0.40512752532958984, -0.0016430922551080585, 1.4664963483810425, 0.2423522025346756, -0.5488757491111755, 0.21957604587078094, 0.31430667638778687, -0.11450690776109695, 0.06524050980806351, 0.06803076714277267, 0.42076167464256287, 0.7884495854377747, -0.0701662227511406, 0.12169663608074188, 0.9936525225639343, -0.7185810804367065, 0.8446279764175415, -0.16680195927619934, 0.13992257416248322, -0.04755813255906105, -0.616332471370697, 0.5627073049545288, -0.22001810371875763, 0.04380623251199722, 0.958728015422821, -0.7375717163085938, 0.21309177577495575, -0.07323391735553741, 0.08120832592248917, -0.5735059976577759, -0.16522686183452606, 0.4150867462158203, -0.12205460667610168, 0.6936826109886169, 0.8853667974472046, -0.17747478187084198, 0.06943992525339127, 0.06099051609635353, 0.6521127223968506, -0.4460936188697815, -0.28763964772224426, 0.3151435852050781, -0.5971790552139282, -0.19352635741233826, 0.11597489565610886, -0.6674465537071228, 0.1450556218624115, 0.3681294620037079, 0.37791913747787476, 0.636451780796051, -0.5014891028404236, 0.27630746364593506, 0.42732369899749756, 0.6529382467269897, 1.3913002014160156, -0.4274922311306, 0.830722451210022, 0.10769766569137573, 0.25887835025787354, -0.11532771587371826, 0.05964774265885353, -0.3669098913669586, -0.6831765174865723, -0.4846353530883789, 0.5552248358726501, -0.4051496386528015, 0.8039810061454773, 0.23645761609077454, 0.48780691623687744, -0.5115346908569336, -1.149547815322876, 0.3648495078086853, -0.47512298822402954, 0.5425130724906921, 0.08631124347448349, -0.5861635804176331, -0.3492395877838135, -1.1688902378082275, 0.026908088475465775, 0.012801251374185085, -0.2246038168668747, 0.13591524958610535, 0.08435904234647751, -0.1621762067079544, 0.9268606901168823, 0.23770761489868164, -0.22857853770256042, 0.456146240234375, 0.32770198583602905, 0.2225816547870636, -0.017130479216575623, 0.00981838721781969, -0.7906372547149658, 0.5098623633384705, 0.9151585698127747, 0.5386598706245422, 0.685574471950531, -0.9759654402732849, 0.7600709199905396, -0.35097405314445496, 0.06281789392232895, 0.16726024448871613, 0.46905362606048584, -0.6179198026657104, -0.5185976028442383, -0.8166356682777405, -0.42160823941230774, -0.8482036590576172, 0.17050296068191528, -0.2771008014678955, -0.5323497653007507, 0.22955302894115448, -0.1477300226688385, -1.494275450706482, 0.2690558433532715, -1.0326862335205078, 0.08230539411306381, 0.1971079707145691, 1.0986839532852173, -0.8164728879928589, -0.11344105005264282, 0.6126724481582642, 0.3386433720588684, 1.0101698637008667, -0.4727395474910736, 0.4286775290966034, 0.41311115026474, -0.0708073154091835, 0.5511992573738098, 0.33896124362945557, 0.09257426112890244, 0.7059262990951538, 0.14472661912441254, -0.37289586663246155, 0.8260456323623657, -0.4030568301677704, 0.052730053663253784, 0.06569994240999222, 0.5613147020339966, 0.39535391330718994, -0.6166568994522095, -0.7282776236534119, 0.45453891158103943, -0.05278566852211952, 0.5526559948921204, 0.6692590713500977, 0.1987532526254654, 0.3496166169643402, 0.8581194877624512, 0.5356316566467285, -0.24165765941143036, 0.13642650842666626, 0.3695826530456543, 0.3963490128517151, -0.14724120497703552, 0.6030243039131165, -0.6545330882072449, -0.9048845171928406, 0.06494434922933578, -1.1093215942382812, 0.7402502298355103, -0.5354061126708984, 0.3053135275840759, 0.2685225307941437, -0.2180967777967453, -1.4480617046356201, 0.4501112401485443, 0.4537700116634369, -0.2265278846025467, -0.39001166820526123, -0.12952224910259247, 0.36124110221862793, 0.4016086757183075, -0.27517062425613403, -0.6331153512001038, 0.597460150718689, 0.8385529518127441, 0.4600175619125366, 0.5714987516403198, 0.5986894369125366, -0.20074254274368286, -1.0175790786743164, -0.8411856889724731, -1.1446831226348877, -0.26300978660583496, -0.9226605892181396, 0.5045056343078613, 0.8836756348609924, -0.7112994194030762, 0.29736563563346863, 0.34650254249572754, -0.24740740656852722, -0.27101680636405945, 0.10422439128160477, 0.4952949285507202, 0.5543699860572815, 0.08916711062192917, -0.757971465587616, 0.7357592582702637, -0.9881298542022705, -0.0004555179621092975, -0.4091302454471588, 0.4778478443622589, 0.6050520539283752, -0.797525942325592, -0.6395331621170044, -0.385050892829895, -0.19098840653896332, -0.3849717378616333, -0.2393471747636795, -0.014370068907737732, -1.0594698190689087, -0.054617106914520264, 0.1794511377811432, -0.34796342253685, -0.8422755599021912, 0.7453223466873169, 0.18201366066932678, -0.3698388338088989, 0.01695728302001953, 0.7046434879302979, -0.7847318649291992, 0.258548766374588, 0.6781763434410095, 0.6262040734291077, -0.3286832273006439, 0.1494939923286438, 0.8011502027511597, 0.6848283410072327, 0.5420063734054565, -0.8928509950637817, -0.7128832340240479, 0.1519574671983719, 0.24471348524093628, -0.9348692297935486, -0.3500182032585144, 0.8840078115463257, -0.06570453196763992, -0.86122065782547, -0.20856177806854248, -0.18010388314723969, -0.11969370394945145, 0.0027305015828460455, -0.6001197695732117, 0.6848909854888916, 0.03175649046897888, -0.10656527429819107, -0.5390781164169312, -0.3570025861263275, 0.8252582550048828, 0.25195857882499695, 0.6470967531204224, -0.38333651423454285, 0.23973320424556732, 0.5364199876785278, 0.5108031034469604, 0.6463845372200012, -0.13890840113162994, -0.10750583559274673, -0.09819173067808151, -0.3113177716732025, -0.7763701677322388, -0.19053660333156586, 0.522270917892456, 0.12550456821918488, 0.3196585774421692, 1.0106804370880127, -0.34663668274879456, -0.9747650027275085, -0.8789637088775635, -0.7011033892631531, -0.19409853219985962, 0.8929015398025513, 0.4713592231273651, -0.30542394518852234, -0.7669413089752197, -0.5259634852409363, 0.7071005702018738, -0.6636800765991211, 0.606932520866394, -0.4509279429912567, 0.6904857158660889, -0.28300657868385315, -1.1086972951889038, 0.29886332154273987, -0.3590843379497528, 0.2813803255558014, 0.4423494338989258, 0.859103262424469, 0.41107121109962463, -0.5613090991973877, -0.7088602781295776, -1.0583282709121704, 0.17504973709583282, 1.242968201637268, 0.4943651556968689, -0.10386001318693161, -0.9223599433898926, -0.4541526138782501, -0.4954059422016144, -0.6266064047813416, -0.30458876490592957, 0.2363719791173935, -0.40119850635528564, -0.16080528497695923, -0.11310462653636932, 0.0387781485915184, 1.4194930791854858, -0.456841379404068, 0.5124374032020569, 0.0754929631948471, -0.12999241054058075, 1.0767990350723267, 0.5266189575195312, 0.3823222815990448, -0.04806648567318916, 0.03615033999085426, -0.8455226421356201, 0.3643306791782379, -0.08437665551900864, -0.28133031725883484, -0.6610990166664124, -0.1968448907136917, -0.5996048450469971, -0.31352904438972473, 0.5076398253440857, 0.45818978548049927, -0.31408193707466125, -0.10845760256052017, 0.09629909694194794, 0.20948760211467743, -0.6503866314888, -0.5121686458587646, -0.37395715713500977, 0.37226250767707825, 0.2022293210029602, -0.20837129652500153, 0.49408385157585144, -0.2632012367248535, 1.1381704807281494, 0.32247766852378845, -0.8382614850997925, -0.8159168362617493, -0.42372244596481323, -0.1020398661494255, -0.2354731559753418, -0.310805082321167, 0.9581886529922485, 0.19292998313903809, 0.535062849521637, -0.09576497226953506, -0.10745410621166229, 0.8489015102386475, 0.05312345176935196, 0.023072674870491028, 0.19515317678451538, 0.5734219551086426, 0.14621640741825104, 0.7121554613113403, -0.4580426514148712, -0.20386870205402374, -0.7617290019989014, -1.034542441368103, 0.18153056502342224, -0.17839831113815308, 0.00502242986112833, 0.7654639482498169, -0.1523445099592209, -0.3066025972366333, 0.1937030553817749, 0.013314527459442616, 0.3968171179294586, 0.0025376086123287678, -0.12080292403697968, -0.457978755235672, -0.21223704516887665, -0.06850992143154144, 0.10333660989999771, 0.47147902846336365, 0.21854157745838165, 0.21312588453292847, 0.1316625326871872, -0.21827074885368347, 0.45621368288993835, -0.5940873026847839, 0.45170122385025024, -0.5247975587844849, -0.5255874991416931, -0.4556531012058258, -0.17006036639213562, -0.052880268543958664, -0.818411111831665, 0.19681182503700256, -0.47622814774513245, 0.1386026293039322, -0.04174362123012543, -0.8911095261573792, -0.11521144956350327, 0.0095153683796525, -0.9107366800308228, 0.3323189616203308, 0.02728721871972084, -0.24146668612957, 0.6390740871429443, -0.6147526502609253, -0.26015686988830566, -0.2897005081176758, -0.6919851899147034, -0.10490710288286209, 0.356465607881546, 0.38871946930885315, -0.030060818418860435, 0.31959599256515503, -0.8198163509368896, 0.6353350281715393, 0.22220051288604736, 0.22648628056049347, -0.5897634029388428, 0.4591253101825714, -0.009328276850283146, -0.3205764591693878, 0.24359066784381866, 0.20201003551483154, -0.25387072563171387, -0.30633488297462463, 0.23172833025455475, -0.06274714320898056, 0.4167531132698059, 0.13925385475158691, -0.5642771124839783, 0.9515613317489624, 0.020099375396966934, -0.2995792627334595, 0.03858374431729317, 0.7261214852333069, -0.018595699220895767, 0.7607531547546387, 0.3993009328842163, -0.845288097858429, -0.09347481280565262, 0.2283298224210739, 0.17249776422977448, -1.4580808877944946, 0.016845567151904106, -0.865510106086731, 0.1674124002456665, -0.2265738546848297, 0.8221767544746399, -0.1925070583820343, 0.10838295519351959, 0.12235292792320251, -0.3062507212162018, 0.49464020133018494, -0.5530060529708862, -0.3054298162460327, -0.7023360133171082, -0.8152464032173157, -0.9736762046813965, 0.7649545669555664, -0.6838157176971436, 0.31189069151878357, 0.6769109964370728, 0.02060762606561184, -0.10493168979883194, 0.25362077355384827, 0.14611637592315674, 0.28423887491226196, -0.3939290940761566, 0.7889544367790222, -0.714721143245697, 0.11114394664764404, -0.8466423153877258, 0.4293935000896454, -0.7320283651351929, 0.18943606317043304, 0.3785032331943512, 0.07655540853738785, 0.5071244239807129, 0.3770184814929962, 1.1054389476776123, -0.46530383825302124, 0.34134215116500854, -0.17999228835105896, -0.01236844900995493, 0.9754189252853394, 0.5706029534339905, -0.574483335018158, -0.5834082365036011, -1.0094482898712158, -1.1480908393859863, 0.6568019390106201, 0.3949088454246521, -0.1831921637058258, -0.621691107749939, -0.13958147168159485, -0.6500930786132812, -0.1267380267381668, 0.459531307220459, 0.8817130923271179, -0.28031817078590393, 0.32658979296684265, 0.03215109184384346, 0.13044266402721405, -0.1791018843650818, 0.5157529711723328, -0.22073698043823242, 0.5098142623901367, 0.08710848540067673, -0.009878118522465229, -0.6317578554153442, -0.7009209990501404, -0.8317210674285889, 0.40075111389160156, 0.12957754731178284, 0.31689220666885376, 0.7702910304069519, 0.09355904161930084, -0.28883567452430725, -0.02829025126993656, 0.15846356749534607, -0.3375276029109955, 0.04840010777115822, -0.03348666802048683, 0.1607428640127182, -0.29717740416526794, 0.16617995500564575, 0.5153543949127197, -0.42124614119529724, -0.1658134162425995, 0.19329385459423065, -0.4180871248245239, -0.2084023803472519, 0.7590855956077576, 0.4189547598361969, -0.46888336539268494, -0.22158031165599823, -0.5232726335525513, -0.5793625116348267, -0.13968808948993683, -0.921195924282074, 0.6969685554504395, -0.5864386558532715, -0.7040019631385803, -0.2383144497871399, 0.502305805683136, -0.1054527685046196, 0.6595866084098816, 0.04940744861960411, -0.7080022692680359, -0.7649341821670532, -0.6942474842071533, 1.260655164718628, -1.1431607007980347, -1.1648626327514648, -0.6153369545936584, -0.0315033420920372, 0.2951955795288086, -0.30234771966934204, 0.8987835645675659, -0.32483601570129395, 0.3518705666065216, 0.2484668642282486, 0.08562225848436356, 0.2964946925640106, 1.19556725025177, -0.2972506284713745, 0.2597050964832306, 0.32897230982780457, -0.658239483833313, -0.3607245981693268, 0.05367996543645859, 0.03531723469495773, 0.706996738910675, -0.20789074897766113, 0.05778523162007332, -0.1928526908159256, -0.5631608963012695, -0.5591486692428589, -0.5021955966949463, -0.8370360136032104, -1.5258781909942627, -0.7017815709114075, -0.6851423978805542, -0.411877304315567, 0.260715514421463, 0.47140923142433167, -0.5706562399864197, 0.7261683940887451, -0.66768878698349, -0.14506016671657562, 0.14847955107688904, 0.4618806838989258, 0.0039747836999595165, -0.30684685707092285, -0.6034212112426758, -0.4216310977935791, -0.18344973027706146, -0.8691933155059814, -0.4162144362926483, -0.4823947846889496, 0.03851987421512604, 0.7974062561988831, -0.6868497729301453, 0.4532685875892639, -0.847286581993103, -0.5506746172904968, -0.4228018522262573, -0.28752994537353516, -0.968576192855835, 0.5362917184829712, 1.0397186279296875, 0.6812112331390381, 0.5707707405090332, -0.17983756959438324, 0.17921634018421173, -0.14928758144378662, -0.1509356051683426, -0.12486619502305984, -0.05932251363992691, 0.07306775450706482, -0.27862274646759033, 0.2940952181816101, 0.5940713882446289, 0.17735259234905243, -1.0314973592758179, -0.491311252117157, -0.5302075743675232, 0.21279673278331757, 0.4299737811088562, -0.8826391100883484, -0.37023404240608215, 0.5694538950920105, -0.6463958621025085, 0.7585324645042419, 0.2672205865383148, 0.06621512025594711, 0.25422003865242004, 0.2683417797088623, -0.02792220190167427, 0.35660985112190247, -0.014199288561940193, -0.3036685287952423, -0.035349681973457336, 0.1938403695821762, -0.6925262212753296, 1.0104016065597534, -0.14340879023075104, -0.46304041147232056, -0.8213018178939819, -0.38387632369995117, -1.112151861190796, -0.4720461666584015, 0.3187008500099182, -0.4312395453453064, 0.3483720123767853, 0.5088558197021484, -0.825565755367279, 0.16206270456314087, 0.009601835161447525, -0.7082452178001404, -0.6224456429481506, -1.05347740650177, -0.08805400133132935, 0.034016743302345276, -0.5676102638244629, 0.22783851623535156, -0.03605499863624573, 0.275256484746933, 0.003894100897014141, 0.1962449848651886, -0.2645447254180908, 0.3807883560657501, -0.9830796718597412, 0.7339497208595276, -0.8307239413261414, -0.1843038946390152, 0.03109976276755333, -0.7568524479866028, -0.01571957767009735, 0.5036208033561707, -0.3134547770023346, -0.13169099390506744, -0.022146757692098618, 0.6454074382781982, 0.27624642848968506, -0.022194594144821167, -0.40653595328330994, -0.9216116666793823, -0.945439338684082, 0.7691690921783447, 0.3856408894062042, -0.32394659519195557, 0.4354211390018463, 0.5430988669395447, 0.8777943253517151, -0.4226471781730652, -0.40276193618774414, 0.5441737174987793, 0.6804062128067017, -0.9293211698532104, 0.5813745260238647, 0.4071963429450989, 0.34442901611328125, 0.5989251136779785, -0.7461620569229126, -0.19020619988441467, -0.2715514302253723, -0.014574472792446613, 1.1780930757522583, 0.8467966914176941, 0.3697158098220825, 0.31028732657432556, 0.19408458471298218, -0.17522868514060974, -0.024715950712561607, 0.9519316554069519, -0.020542453974485397, 0.9049288034439087, -0.5450209379196167, 0.38072675466537476, 0.2338247299194336, 0.2447110265493393, 0.13183759152889252, -0.5214821100234985, 0.12493937462568283, 0.6307496428489685, 0.6571155190467834, 0.1763938069343567, -0.6136549115180969, 0.4510112702846527, -0.09018786251544952, 0.1275705248117447, 0.5204352140426636, 0.17278607189655304, 0.03148288652300835, 0.8286576867103577, 0.8116952776908875, 0.8425577282905579, -0.10172653198242188, 0.7805543541908264, -0.018107563257217407, 0.47861233353614807, 0.07515915483236313, 0.3626175820827484, -0.03115326166152954, 0.4609818756580353, 0.22616256773471832, -0.8255810141563416, 0.05483820289373398, 1.1443190574645996, -1.6666226387023926, -0.400676429271698, -0.18430814146995544, -0.20185834169387817, 0.01342676393687725, -0.40387073159217834, 0.9315025806427002, -0.4731403589248657, 0.4579642713069916, 0.704892635345459, -0.22659891843795776, 0.05607348307967186, 0.727727472782135, -1.008488416671753, 0.3755396008491516, 1.0601954460144043, 0.41229504346847534, -0.7193987369537354, 1.5236780643463135, 1.1378670930862427, 0.8128995895385742, 0.024895260110497475, -0.3467637896537781, -0.37466636300086975, 0.36254391074180603, 0.18601444363594055, -0.6515124440193176, 0.6690239906311035, -0.3803918659687042, -0.7787904739379883, 0.28028666973114014, 0.6107732653617859, 0.02226042002439499, -0.35136678814888, 0.10739579051733017, 0.45335784554481506, 0.06500871479511261, 0.07160328328609467, 0.8488724231719971, 0.2013825923204422, -0.41510626673698425, -0.6179430484771729, -0.18364949524402618, 0.35415568947792053, -1.0428481101989746, 0.6224284172058105, 0.25332894921302795, -0.16514568030834198, 0.3329326808452606, 0.2852993607521057, -0.04291026294231415, 0.03733941912651062, -0.07017191499471664, -0.3377387225627899, -0.34515705704689026, -0.19299641251564026, -0.09112154692411423, 0.801058828830719, 0.34908977150917053, -0.2754649221897125, -0.04241780564188957, 0.34265804290771484, 1.0539659261703491, -0.19254249334335327, 0.24882972240447998, 0.5048947930335999, 0.3502953350543976, -0.18478351831436157, 1.4501451253890991, 0.30650946497917175, -0.42558208107948303, 1.0494463443756104, -1.3020269870758057, -0.11593089252710342, 0.07619179785251617, -0.27052223682403564, 0.5362930297851562, 0.9736460447311401, 0.35862088203430176, -0.6137262582778931, -0.3177523612976074, -0.13578049838542938, -1.2198220491409302, -0.08630656450986862, -0.6711275577545166, 0.1969357579946518, -0.5871309041976929, 0.23920081555843353, -0.032370537519454956, -0.6643621325492859, 3.8786206245422363, 0.9282822012901306, 0.16294895112514496, 0.5366142988204956, 0.5978671908378601, 0.4341700077056885, 0.8277240991592407, -1.1670986413955688, 0.18357811868190765, -0.21169742941856384, -0.278593510389328, 0.09416504204273224, -0.14872652292251587, -0.20293529331684113, -0.11781340837478638, 1.2251116037368774, -0.3544647693634033, -0.27419576048851013, 0.2273547202348709, -0.8577013611793518, -0.40391603112220764, -0.027453262358903885, 0.29435402154922485, 0.12371189147233963, 0.14394500851631165, 0.04253898933529854, 0.1797686517238617, -0.8472775220870972, -0.701562225818634, 0.46660080552101135, -0.8584285378456116, -0.5052616596221924, 0.7457886934280396, 0.21316397190093994, -0.5430322885513306, 0.33078888058662415, 0.7829017043113708, 0.4967264235019684, 0.3235628306865692, 0.3630404472351074, -0.5817528367042542, 0.49122747778892517, 0.05402858927845955, -0.6193244457244873, -1.0132973194122314, 1.007340908050537, -0.31182363629341125, 0.8512734174728394, 0.0326291061937809, -0.5552490949630737, 0.7923493981361389, -0.3187587857246399, -0.004886123351752758, -0.552055835723877, -0.6202259659767151, 0.5997015237808228, -0.34926098585128784, -0.1627034991979599, 0.18983064591884613, -0.24600864946842194, 0.5601933002471924, 0.020763909444212914, -1.173634648323059, -0.33367645740509033, -0.16685518622398376, -0.04010156914591789, 0.15294168889522552, 1.0117518901824951, -0.01246390026062727, 0.4694913923740387, 0.02341959998011589, -0.7693988084793091, -0.5397197604179382, -0.4718135595321655, 0.5757259130477905, 0.10539760440587997, -0.05599075183272362, 0.696827232837677, -0.009416294284164906, 0.05505833402276039, 0.3463980555534363, 0.05312923714518547, -0.7991860508918762, -0.22315996885299683, 0.1077573224902153, 0.9330386519432068, -0.6109870672225952, 0.3353041112422943, -0.17340965569019318, 0.5275052785873413, 0.6414629220962524, 0.9463299512863159, -0.607495903968811, -0.20992924273014069, -1.1224699020385742 ]
Lattice distortion and energy level structures in doped C_{60} and C_{70} studied with the extended Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model: Polaron excitations and optical absorption
We extend the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger model of polyacetylene to C_{60} and C_{70} molecules, and solve numerically. The calculations of the undoped systems agree well with the known results. When the system (C_{60} or C_{70}) is doped with one or two electrons (or holes), the additional charges accumulate almost along an equatorial line of the molecule. The dimerization becomes weaker almost along the same line. Two energy levels intrude largely in the gap. The intrusion is larger in C_{70} than in C_{60}. Therefore, ``polarons'' are predicted in doped buckminster- fullerenes. We calculate optical absorption coefficient for C_{60} in order to look at how ``polarons'' will be observed. It is predicted that there appears a new peak at the lower energy than the intergap transition peaks. It is also found that C_{60} and C_{70} are related mutually with respect to electronical structures as well as lattice geometries. (to be published in Phys. Rev. B 45, June 15 issue)
Kikuo Harigaya (Fundamental Physics Section, Electrotechnical Laboratory, Japan)
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205014
cond-mat/9205015
[ -0.30465832352638245, 0.8074583411216736, 0.6627110242843628, 0.5569691061973572, 0.13762609660625458, -0.06595807522535324, -0.09835268557071686, -0.4506107568740845, -0.14226607978343964, 1.7554609775543213, 0.3719354271888733, 0.0732918381690979, -0.008426638320088387, -0.41880321502685547, 0.010713166557252407, -0.1319565325975418, -0.4719797968864441, -1.2758862972259521, -1.144766926765442, -0.2684864401817322, -0.7270901799201965, -0.8334298729896545, -0.9177134037017822, -0.6685460805892944, -0.35365334153175354, 1.0947880744934082, 0.12947118282318115, 0.2589329779148102, 0.837120532989502, 0.9769949316978455, 0.4820788502693176, -0.12163100391626358, 0.0013016853481531143, -1.042945384979248, -0.29314377903938293, 0.2872983515262604, 0.6930832862854004, -0.3082394003868103, 0.011419819667935371, -0.9715415835380554, 1.252976417541504, -0.28092536330223083, 0.5341573357582092, -0.6426646709442139, 0.29239341616630554, -0.12414433807134628, -0.2698490619659424, 0.09966234117746353, -0.455410897731781, -1.0313984155654907, 0.4963397979736328, 0.3359680473804474, 0.03249020129442215, -0.4670731723308563, -0.7365955114364624, 0.12100432813167572, -0.011409452185034752, 0.12730537354946136, -0.45808109641075134, -0.051647428423166275, 0.11300241202116013, 0.3190871775150299, 0.36053332686424255, -0.621921718120575, -0.11182470619678497, 1.1942908763885498, -0.5726030468940735, 0.10543718934059143, -0.04109889641404152, -0.9079124927520752, -0.5877634286880493, -0.23764769732952118, 0.6094607710838318, 0.44470980763435364, -0.6227762699127197, 0.44271349906921387, 0.3808336853981018, -0.7779453992843628, -0.17815864086151123, -0.4714653193950653, -0.3573528528213501, -0.08008202910423279, -0.7008534073829651, 0.5583285689353943, 0.15748059749603271, -0.6216282844543457, -0.2244349718093872, 0.2436293512582779, 0.4094822108745575, 0.6096432209014893, 0.2115710973739624, 0.8567889332771301, 0.33611223101615906, -0.45151928067207336, 0.4738873839378357, 0.2360396534204483, -0.1516815572977066, 0.4277171194553375, 0.5031861662864685, 0.7614228129386902, 0.22784854471683502, 1.1233508586883545, -0.16207030415534973, 0.6873709559440613, -1.121179223060608, 0.36043819785118103, 0.6076400876045227, -0.20251673460006714, -0.5675016045570374, -0.5292523503303528, -0.4005138874053955, 0.4439571499824524, 0.5620688199996948, 0.34108710289001465, 0.4263646602630615, -0.09541879594326019, 0.7046122550964355, -0.12292107194662094, -1.4845093488693237, -0.12826812267303467, -0.30718857049942017, 0.7161298990249634, 0.3422742784023285, 0.5176172256469727, -0.20333261787891388, -0.6771687865257263, -0.24358640611171722, 0.78041672706604, -0.47989049553871155, 0.3663223385810852, -0.17389024794101715, -1.1263962984085083, -0.5809124112129211, 0.674384355545044, 0.7663475871086121, 0.07347835600376129, -0.01140931062400341, 0.8560483455657959, 0.4008510708808899, -0.11106789857149124, 0.4417448937892914, -0.8610215187072754, -0.07401958853006363, 1.050892949104309, -0.22252807021141052, 0.0296791959553957, 0.9442381262779236, -1.058899998664856, -0.05245871841907501, -0.6135672330856323, -0.4314331114292145, 0.2013905793428421, 0.2464551329612732, 0.053005438297986984, -0.3671512305736542, 0.2535635828971863, -0.9695668816566467, 0.3735048770904541, -0.7320066690444946, 0.3322383463382721, 0.7030780911445618, -0.13960860669612885, 0.4316665232181549, 0.1148371547460556, -0.5378926396369934, 0.5239304900169373, -0.4866567850112915, -0.29793745279312134, -0.22440116107463837, -0.7413748502731323, 0.2947462499141693, 0.15649396181106567, -0.40398260951042175, -0.05828996002674103, 0.19505345821380615, -0.02987567149102688, 0.4976055920124054, -0.13002590835094452, 0.6703274846076965, 0.3231370151042938, -0.1583852469921112, -0.3328648507595062, 0.14420761168003082, 0.2038126438856125, 0.0891643613576889, 0.3685804307460785, -0.6425603628158569, 0.3738257586956024, 0.7367250323295593, 0.034667059779167175, -0.14651881158351898, 1.0259190797805786, -0.6740739941596985, 0.08342612534761429, -0.813736081123352, -0.21352867782115936, -0.0902603417634964, 0.24044668674468994, 0.2659204602241516, -0.4113045036792755, -0.3680574595928192, 0.0642046183347702, -1.0600181818008423, 0.29846999049186707, -1.5485106706619263, 0.26140618324279785, 0.11624319851398468, 0.45368942618370056, -0.6789416670799255, -0.06989608705043793, 0.2130533754825592, -0.4665655493736267, 0.07266891747713089, 0.3406464755535126, -0.26877889037132263, -0.2083725929260254, -0.2159889042377472, -0.36177629232406616, 0.23004063963890076, -0.6491088271141052, 0.5523358583450317, -0.10514496266841888, 0.18281221389770508, 1.259276270866394, 0.6113362908363342, 0.437410444021225, 0.5406200885772705, 0.5576683878898621, 0.6489366292953491, 0.24728353321552277, 0.262716144323349, 0.8407118916511536, -0.02054561860859394, 0.18450108170509338, 0.9205096960067749, 0.6021284461021423, -0.2620123028755188, 0.9039453864097595, -0.3202148377895355, 0.09476558864116669, -0.19008773565292358, 0.40501704812049866, 0.5548740029335022, 0.4645082652568817, -0.34321293234825134, 0.9113508462905884, -0.01665273867547512, 0.21603021025657654, -0.7202946543693542, 0.27380621433258057, -0.7083266973495483, 1.0830621719360352, 0.29761824011802673, 0.04702530428767204, -0.2574547529220581, 0.013991608284413815, -0.4861656129360199, 0.5693626999855042, -0.2764602303504944, -0.2907486855983734, -0.022294368594884872, 0.012517641298472881, -0.08958637714385986, -0.6988580822944641, -0.4484774172306061, 0.7023724317550659, -0.6509162783622742, 0.3308772146701813, -0.7828588485717773, -0.41479766368865967, -1.3149535655975342, -0.14789354801177979, -0.5861234068870544, -0.4249188005924225, -0.20970533788204193, 0.23273847997188568, 0.5574217438697815, 0.2645387649536133, 0.23248426616191864, 0.4290214776992798, -0.33000314235687256, 0.5443020462989807, -0.44033312797546387, 0.14445731043815613, -0.0027965493500232697, -0.39390477538108826, -0.4502468407154083, -0.1185671016573906, -0.6824164390563965, 0.5774062275886536, -0.46736693382263184, -0.25430503487586975, -0.6901208758354187, -0.10567547380924225, -0.35552841424942017, -0.15721331536769867, -0.46523526310920715, -0.4183448553085327, -0.37338078022003174, -0.8154746294021606, -0.04420820623636246, -0.22073553502559662, -0.9133597612380981, -0.4651384949684143, -0.6833426356315613, 0.8198474645614624, -0.613506019115448, -0.4800493121147156, 0.5508829355239868, 0.16160684823989868, 0.012952940538525581, 0.14087115228176117, -0.533079206943512, 0.137727290391922, -0.4891018271446228, 0.811690628528595, 0.49746233224868774, 0.427141010761261, 0.010633234865963459, -0.3444560170173645, -0.32965829968452454, 0.07924679666757584, 0.726418137550354, -1.0056923627853394, -0.10835954546928406, 1.072849988937378, 1.060072898864746, -0.41391581296920776, 0.7543572187423706, -0.8030094504356384, -0.9805609583854675, -0.3641258180141449, -0.3002859950065613, 0.3184235692024231, 0.6110804677009583, -0.24192257225513458, -0.03350885212421417, 0.15979190170764923, 0.17948120832443237, 0.21142113208770752, 0.2507701814174652, -0.29592815041542053, -0.0916266217827797, 0.3140026330947876, -0.2769058644771576, 0.7149969339370728, 1.0440733432769775, -0.5266526341438293, -0.2340743988752365, 0.553661584854126, -0.9865773916244507, 0.12089523673057556, 0.4358825087547302, -0.013641453348100185, 0.14674386382102966, 0.04495192691683769, -0.6126468777656555, -0.08359836786985397, -0.432017058134079, -0.346065491437912, -0.04635874927043915, 0.061395395547151566, -0.4169618487358093, 0.02571122720837593, -0.34183287620544434, 0.03432312235236168, 0.7891696095466614, -0.03935123234987259, 0.6035059690475464, -0.4603394865989685, 0.27945461869239807, 0.25626063346862793, -0.5165417194366455, -0.1287723034620285, -0.00513493875041604, -0.4726979732513428, 0.15880346298217773, 0.48581475019454956, 0.8576031923294067, -0.5603097677230835, -0.6829492449760437, -0.6311779022216797, 1.0835942029953003, 0.8336859345436096, 0.8971105217933655, 0.5245217084884644, -0.6877400279045105, 0.2678966522216797, -0.5787549018859863, -0.4408230781555176, -0.09288301318883896, -0.457535058259964, -0.6972337961196899, -0.634465217590332, -0.7196260690689087, 0.13870316743850708, 0.069783516228199, 0.44885289669036865, -0.1035507395863533, 0.8400431275367737, 0.5297470688819885, 0.010841467417776585, -0.4460839033126831, 0.13112585246562958, -0.24887582659721375, 0.2512628138065338, -0.7689421772956848, 0.10196990519762039, 0.22007471323013306, -0.3301299512386322, -0.06931326538324356, -0.07132327556610107, -0.16631831228733063, -0.4770675003528595, 0.4541158080101013, 0.25404098629951477, -0.6185120344161987, 0.6830914616584778, -0.06766359508037567, 0.16294404864311218, -0.9147533178329468, -0.43760615587234497, 0.17895826697349548, 1.0328073501586914, 0.17182773351669312, -1.0531699657440186, 0.5437227487564087, -0.4950230121612549, 0.6370506286621094, 0.8733813762664795, -0.20607095956802368, -0.1364951729774475, 0.48636406660079956, 0.7287140488624573, -0.04803019016981125, 0.3935997784137726, 0.14207343757152557, 0.012525960803031921, 0.21556441485881805, -0.40678784251213074, 0.030097080394625664, 0.2431371659040451, -0.6353715658187866, -0.17287170886993408, -0.10716193914413452, 0.058544594794511795, -0.17314539849758148, -0.08424100279808044, -0.23170281946659088, -0.28419339656829834, -0.23089241981506348, -0.3290258049964905, 0.5732986927032471, -0.08182667195796967, -0.9052518010139465, 0.8399514555931091, 0.3301609456539154, -0.09697190672159195, 1.2249687910079956, -0.05720984563231468, -0.08873841166496277, 0.24435317516326904, -0.2359856367111206, 0.08833009749650955, -0.5591900944709778, 0.5014641284942627, 0.17493490874767303, 0.45361772179603577, 0.4630117416381836, 0.3458767533302307, 0.30541929602622986, 0.26431116461753845, 0.13103428483009338, 0.09157419204711914, 0.012313418090343475, -0.5143013596534729, 0.14053820073604584, -0.20202791690826416, -0.30717360973358154, -0.291728675365448, -0.25010573863983154, 0.9062002897262573, -0.10419674962759018, -0.09090666472911835, -0.4712981581687927, -0.5287665724754333, -0.2257709950208664, 0.047416917979717255, -0.4025142788887024, 0.44941264390945435, -0.4528890550136566, -0.2392469048500061, -0.6935265064239502, -0.6880184412002563, 0.1765337437391281, 0.31134459376335144, -0.3538733124732971, 0.1995638757944107, -0.060011520981788635, -0.14357127249240875, -0.29536008834838867, 0.12591694295406342, -0.9494122266769409, 0.6817237734794617, -0.43343761563301086, 0.6339928507804871, -0.5305189490318298, -0.5032434463500977, -0.48010942339897156, 0.1583584100008011, -0.04854195937514305, -0.5695309638977051, -0.10771740227937698, -0.32051020860671997, 0.10676583647727966, 0.16680558025836945, 0.4595572054386139, -0.2813512980937958, -0.13703475892543793, 0.5323227047920227, 0.013926281593739986, -1.173292636871338, -0.22841857373714447, 1.0351849794387817, 0.08204448968172073, -0.10950550436973572, -0.5488042235374451, -0.6708239912986755, 0.29814615845680237, -0.2582031786441803, -0.22278036177158356, -0.8210231065750122, -0.2799723744392395, -0.2956382930278778, 0.1527199149131775, -0.15348023176193237, -0.27769848704338074, 0.10591493546962738, -0.426084041595459, -0.14756731688976288, -0.9378207921981812, -0.3399958908557892, 0.13181191682815552, -0.1895865947008133, -0.4892394542694092, -0.0924784392118454, -0.8722681403160095, 0.47637632489204407, -0.592374861240387, -0.8734862208366394, 0.4644300639629364, 0.6208067536354065, 0.41986462473869324, 0.7524371147155762, -0.39423367381095886, -0.047418221831321716, -0.19218549132347107, 0.7579993605613708, 0.17802157998085022, 0.49608147144317627, -0.2629791796207428, 0.2803674042224884, -1.1451842784881592, 0.04137853533029556, -0.2909870147705078, 0.10961078852415085, 0.941905677318573, -0.0052153184078633785, 0.5105741620063782, -0.6687098741531372, 0.34713029861450195, 0.29634296894073486, 0.1680714190006256, 0.8741577863693237, 0.33822527527809143, -0.7405231595039368, -0.6346378326416016, -0.11036171764135361, -0.6102538108825684, 0.8245311975479126, -0.036300309002399445, -0.2642572224140167, -0.5600392818450928, -0.17021629214286804, 0.2914695143699646, 0.11784127354621887, 0.6632171869277954, 0.534353494644165, 0.012632019817829132, 0.4925481379032135, 0.19568657875061035, 0.07796098291873932, -0.1416342854499817, -0.10821431875228882, 0.5319709777832031, -0.07015272974967957, -0.9913532137870789, -0.1678711622953415, 0.26468202471733093, -1.2277897596359253, -0.23616214096546173, 0.1373860388994217, 0.13417595624923706, -0.09223625808954239, 0.7374971508979797, 0.040687259286642075, 0.2659088373184204, -0.3510432243347168, -0.023736553266644478, 0.2475278079509735, -0.10166681557893753, 0.16130754351615906, -0.4291689097881317, -0.050715576857328415, 0.26548272371292114, 0.3140859305858612, -0.6771059036254883, -0.32186180353164673, 0.5742753744125366, -0.6706647872924805, -0.6738090515136719, -0.23932060599327087, 0.37252873182296753, -0.11958245187997818, -0.27109813690185547, -0.8804166316986084, -0.33694887161254883, 0.9234396815299988, -0.2845079302787781, 0.5768654346466064, 0.3758228123188019, -0.8964880704879761, 0.7575029134750366, 0.4945621192455292, -0.46913453936576843, -0.014741231687366962, 0.04250291362404823, -0.43810316920280457, -1.0773260593414307, 0.3772417902946472, 1.1562774181365967, -0.08929163962602615, -0.3894828259944916, -0.3319571614265442, -0.9574048519134521, -0.22461332380771637, -0.42643481492996216, 0.19267329573631287, 0.6971620917320251, -0.0658676028251648, -0.00928215216845274, 0.13948900997638702, -0.1542101502418518, 0.4818798005580902, 0.7721788883209229, -0.8878278732299805, 0.13307106494903564, -0.970395028591156, -0.37900280952453613, 0.40162962675094604, -0.024379553273320198, 0.7136315107345581, -0.5268561244010925, 0.35843220353126526, -0.6165499687194824, 0.17646513879299164, -0.564231276512146, -0.9237020611763, -0.25610414147377014, -1.0322484970092773, -0.9277142882347107, -1.011077880859375, -0.9624434113502502, -0.3044956922531128, -0.22120451927185059, 0.7369585633277893, 0.22897863388061523, -0.35381510853767395, 0.13911490142345428, 0.7885217666625977, 0.7432964444160461, -0.430955708026886, -0.41105222702026367, -1.1757532358169556, -0.1468334197998047, -0.20311225950717926, 0.17738032341003418, 0.02976391837000847, 0.7322708964347839, -0.9495909810066223, 0.1668611317873001, -0.4783099889755249, 0.6829374432563782, -0.6137136220932007, -0.2940615117549896, 0.1964549720287323, -0.22081996500492096, -0.782823920249939, 0.6934254765510559, -0.7219237685203552, 0.26037418842315674, -0.6000583171844482, -0.6612286567687988, 0.2674236297607422, 0.2715127766132355, -0.5235546231269836, 0.15281996130943298, -0.4536435604095459, 0.38843849301338196, -0.22226591408252716, -0.7785432934761047, 0.41228172183036804, 0.9631220102310181, -0.8150895833969116, 0.6688680648803711, -0.39183947443962097, 0.5971888899803162, -0.3780803382396698, -0.31765466928482056, 0.31901466846466064, 0.7924811244010925, -0.11377527564764023, 0.49722960591316223, -0.7544754147529602, -0.27189937233924866, -0.197903111577034, 0.13814593851566315, -0.42447352409362793, -0.05725724250078201, 0.5452672243118286, -0.7494475841522217, 0.8796161413192749, 0.7940213084220886, -0.5105788707733154, 0.3867350220680237, 0.0032755578868091106, -0.3654778003692627, -0.09687717258930206, -0.6020509600639343, -0.8774743676185608, 0.8448342680931091, -0.3535292148590088, 0.16621148586273193, -0.7652993202209473, -0.8989362716674805, -0.24939420819282532, -0.39252254366874695, -0.3358735740184784, -0.0612148642539978, -0.3683294653892517, 0.17432160675525665, -0.5600475072860718, -0.1368483304977417, -0.7456976771354675, -0.21597687900066376, 0.029625942930579185, 0.14077000319957733, -0.09128986299037933, -0.08501792699098587, -0.09547966718673706, 0.15542727708816528, -0.5726368427276611, 0.4967329204082489, -0.23540551960468292, 0.3474225699901581, -0.2902727723121643, 0.17390935122966766, -0.11991512030363083, 0.04145069792866707, -0.3447016775608063, -0.6281037926673889, -0.12169706076383591, 0.18773327767848969, 0.04258810356259346, 0.11941270530223846, -0.45830386877059937, 0.1985514760017395, -0.21624428033828735, 0.2577912211418152, 0.5181457996368408, -0.28749653697013855, 0.05640815943479538, 0.3208213150501251, -0.1403968334197998, 0.17532365024089813, -0.19017310440540314, 0.7020142078399658, 0.0778050571680069, -0.29801568388938904, 0.5689000487327576, -0.05557440593838692, 0.6371678709983826, -0.15168000757694244, -0.18306486308574677, -0.7742029428482056, 0.6229642033576965, 0.21671131253242493, 0.3087819814682007, 0.5094932317733765, 0.3490986227989197, 0.061092909425497055, -0.611120343208313, 0.6031457185745239, 0.2212805598974228, 0.1330074518918991, 0.35216256976127625, 0.5513359308242798, -0.43999817967414856, 0.5220627784729004, -0.4584551453590393, 0.6125763654708862, -0.2613626718521118, 0.5433009266853333, 0.06897492706775665, 0.6549937129020691, 0.07525041699409485, 0.2198476493358612, -0.5510210394859314, -0.4216051995754242, -0.5228065252304077, -0.13176299631595612, -0.21239635348320007, 0.16935034096240997, 0.08032342791557312, 0.45547133684158325, 0.38757917284965515, 0.38341155648231506, -0.41476649045944214, 0.40479549765586853, 0.49708640575408936, 0.24686837196350098, -0.1211966797709465, 0.9556353092193604, 0.9569517970085144, -0.18254052102565765, -0.11708637326955795, -0.020442621782422066, -0.2559643089771271, 0.7841955423355103, -0.9518991708755493, -0.23832741379737854, 0.07082861661911011, 0.19299477338790894, 0.13745266199111938, -1.2220994234085083, 0.18048156797885895, -0.41954177618026733, 0.4577120244503021, 0.9926089644432068, -0.3457604646682739, 0.1175353080034256, 0.609748363494873, 0.0886705070734024, 0.682706892490387, 0.5824077725410461, 0.25153547525405884, -0.8475459218025208, 1.1789970397949219, 1.1775383949279785, -0.06742380559444427, 0.2512478530406952, 0.2100522220134735, 0.09022326022386551, -0.40333837270736694, -0.06662552058696747, -0.43465179204940796, 1.0432785749435425, -1.186923861503601, -0.4607861042022705, -0.1731366366147995, 0.21899931132793427, -0.10225439071655273, -0.6010028719902039, 0.5797433853149414, 0.549794614315033, -0.39645230770111084, 0.003543735947459936, 0.4283638000488281, 0.6336890459060669, 0.46731144189834595, -0.24975501000881195, -0.2907753586769104, 0.08309368044137955, -0.2951022982597351, -0.1768886297941208, 0.9304267764091492, -0.12259465456008911, -0.25416117906570435, -0.307569682598114, -0.4336126148700714, -0.44591960310935974, -0.8786692023277283, -0.4004771411418915, -0.4403257668018341, 0.4219197928905487, 0.45506367087364197, 0.9953186511993408, 0.22646261751651764, -0.48614761233329773, 0.34868186712265015, 0.9221306443214417, 0.8502422571182251, 0.4463433027267456, 0.06368231773376465, 0.7458463907241821, -0.03802752122282982, -0.38095977902412415, 0.4364488124847412, 0.7082831263542175, -0.14381572604179382, 0.4843893051147461, 0.03248029574751854, -0.0033265419770032167, 0.024774011224508286, -0.029895881190896034, 0.5065453052520752, 0.8931528925895691, 0.5412929654121399, -0.6870489120483398, -0.11880657076835632, 0.45877569913864136, -1.0714638233184814, 0.33673012256622314, -0.8711045384407043, 0.14420059323310852, 0.8377934694290161, 0.47289159893989563, 0.22097577154636383, -0.25186291337013245, 4.209737300872803, 0.896325945854187, 0.8519177436828613, 0.4477550983428955, 0.47825321555137634, 0.4729052484035492, 0.8985780477523804, -0.2941143810749054, 0.24643313884735107, -0.4483766257762909, -0.05082479864358902, -0.10765448212623596, -0.04755306616425514, -0.1067088171839714, 0.002665415173396468, 0.3312686085700989, -0.3193570375442505, 0.5749014616012573, -0.3088932931423187, -0.7928173542022705, -0.7091720104217529, 0.35627618432044983, -0.00309547851793468, 0.13471746444702148, 0.0543229915201664, -0.059808339923620224, 0.22211238741874695, -0.7884448766708374, -0.18201501667499542, -0.1682792603969574, -1.01300847530365, -0.8678132891654968, 0.27433857321739197, -0.4472837746143341, -0.8166717290878296, 0.3570619225502014, 0.21388758718967438, 0.2496481090784073, 0.015066337771713734, -0.11394897848367691, 0.3815215826034546, 0.04484283924102783, -0.10732893645763397, -0.18901711702346802, -0.8412900567054749, 0.7250638604164124, 0.05439339205622673, 0.6110498905181885, 0.1633988469839096, -0.3585280179977417, 0.43802952766418457, -0.5171917080879211, 0.38751697540283203, 0.18455351889133453, -1.1259955167770386, 0.3991806209087372, -0.17608913779258728, -1.0194398164749146, 0.18258681893348694, 0.13325029611587524, 1.0414079427719116, 0.41762128472328186, 0.1158975288271904, 0.21139059960842133, -0.08687924593687057, -0.012892311438918114, 0.5447683334350586, 0.0820150226354599, -0.40240728855133057, -0.1976659595966339, 0.24805328249931335, -0.43473130464553833, -0.29948893189430237, -0.31184813380241394, -0.03166012465953827, 0.5711507797241211, -0.7225666642189026, 0.3191019594669342, -0.41291117668151855, 0.3145931661128998, 0.4127885103225708, -0.049379829317331314, 0.24961809813976288, 0.4224957227706909, 0.737103283405304, 0.06139051914215088, -0.161760151386261, -0.47215673327445984, -0.17745430767536163, 0.6061511635780334, 0.782589852809906, 0.8957169055938721, 0.2111273556947708, 0.08146686106920242, -0.5505363345146179 ]
Dynamic scaling and quasi-ordered states in the two dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation
The process of pattern formation in the two dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation is examined through numerical and analytic methods. Dynamic scaling relationships are developed for the collective ordering of convective rolls in the limit of infinite aspect ratio. The stationary solutions are shown to be strongly influenced by the strength of noise. Stationary states for small and large noise strengths appear to be quasi-ordered and disordered respectively. The dynamics of ordering from an initially inhomogeneous state is very slow in the former case and fast in the latter. Both numerical and analytic calculations indicate that the slow dynamics can be characterized by a simple scaling relationship, with a characteristic dynamic exponent of $1/4$ in the intermediate time regime.
K.R. Elder (1), Jorge Vi\~nals (2) and Martin Grant (1) ((1) Department of Physics, McGill University, Rutherford Building...
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205015
cond-mat/9205016
[ -0.8653098940849304, -0.35738348960876465, 0.08921363204717636, 0.6597921252250671, -0.5566904544830322, -0.21090295910835266, -0.402727872133255, -0.32799258828163147, 0.0989779680967331, 1.0684528350830078, 0.5594761371612549, -0.6432661414146423, 1.0510499477386475, -1.1078813076019287, -0.7143381834030151, -0.22553162276744843, -0.06378892064094543, -0.19534312188625336, -1.8681033849716187, -0.5634322166442871, 0.10160255432128906, -0.6202099323272705, -0.8491076827049255, -0.5434588193893433, 0.3144758641719818, 0.49041521549224854, 0.4553099274635315, 0.4427677094936371, 0.9832454323768616, 0.45610931515693665, -0.022634373977780342, -0.4000900983810425, 0.3257841467857361, -0.8147630095481873, 0.5682926774024963, 0.318715900182724, 0.018664978444576263, 0.05915115401148796, 0.619009256362915, -0.27193668484687805, 1.451924204826355, -0.42314818501472473, 0.9456911683082581, 0.07711844891309738, -0.24287372827529907, -0.49783986806869507, -1.1248568296432495, 0.07232341170310974, -0.11602899432182312, -1.1279306411743164, -0.005672686733305454, 0.11625082790851593, 0.6929386854171753, 0.06403839588165283, 0.3369119167327881, 0.05447810888290405, -0.3391086459159851, 0.40956395864486694, -0.38932815194129944, -0.29641205072402954, 0.5129373669624329, -0.056787122040987015, 0.36685416102409363, -0.5917904376983643, 0.10820832848548889, 0.7938256859779358, -0.6102343201637268, 0.80140221118927, -0.2840971052646637, -0.09824536740779877, 0.07658975571393967, -0.5668559670448303, 0.0612456388771534, -0.6028448939323425, -0.5705525279045105, 0.13062219321727753, -0.2768440544605255, -1.1622236967086792, -1.3871930837631226, 0.07293812930583954, -0.35402539372444153, -0.28468409180641174, 0.17644625902175903, 0.6231026649475098, -0.31214869022369385, -0.5977863073348999, -0.046559520065784454, 0.23082119226455688, 0.2811379134654999, -0.2847173511981964, 0.037813324481248856, 1.4080512523651123, 0.5671236515045166, -0.4844230115413666, 0.2290484756231308, 0.053047750145196915, 0.007784288842231035, 0.3348694443702698, 0.30617260932922363, 0.2471809685230255, 0.300340473651886, -0.1193995401263237, -0.12708817422389984, 0.5871728658676147, -0.9051035642623901, 0.6996725797653198, -0.055865559726953506, -0.09678898006677628, 0.39998218417167664, -0.48843544721603394, 0.39306652545928955, -0.24229389429092407, 0.09893982112407684, 1.0626434087753296, -0.6388192176818848, 0.3985399901866913, -0.2950451076030731, -0.3477826416492462, -0.6002300381660461, -0.3654005825519562, 0.527915894985199, 0.4250345826148987, 0.610171914100647, 0.548560380935669, -0.3206274211406708, 0.26178714632987976, 0.2622796297073364, 1.205322027206421, -0.4303209185600281, -0.3371503949165344, 0.21158398687839508, -0.45214205980300903, -0.265546977519989, 0.5586146116256714, -0.5689472556114197, 0.15823598206043243, 0.2320576310157776, 0.5767630934715271, 0.675380289554596, -0.12820792198181152, 0.08101397752761841, -0.10333608835935593, 0.8712760806083679, 1.598159909248352, -0.4392200708389282, 0.44792211055755615, 0.3604198396205902, -0.09004966169595718, -0.3034100830554962, 0.3232652544975281, -0.6101122498512268, -0.34385183453559875, -0.2502063810825348, 0.6986272931098938, -0.7127604484558105, 0.7763851881027222, 0.12291593849658966, 0.44621458649635315, -0.7907109260559082, -0.9130953550338745, 0.27658382058143616, -0.3535672724246979, 0.4558385908603668, 0.05747249349951744, -0.5369127988815308, -0.11080609261989594, -0.44166895747184753, -0.5072874426841736, -0.11721070855855942, -0.11737194657325745, -0.09138818830251694, 0.3072909414768219, -0.7345458269119263, 0.9826796054840088, 0.41652122139930725, 0.06000005826354027, 0.40494537353515625, 0.062401823699474335, -0.2199033498764038, 0.6919819116592407, -0.30257362127304077, -0.5691823363304138, 0.37074270844459534, 0.8486084938049316, 0.49102190136909485, 0.2672366201877594, -1.0914130210876465, 0.5045727491378784, -0.7702072858810425, 0.21362413465976715, 0.03339960798621178, 0.7773596048355103, -0.6910570859909058, 0.10699345916509628, -0.8070827722549438, 0.11434126645326614, -0.4371173083782196, 0.3434179425239563, -0.36488187313079834, -0.28856685757637024, 0.10547015815973282, -0.47102928161621094, -1.3866832256317139, 0.16749230027198792, -0.9079161882400513, -0.6935401558876038, -0.017022671177983284, 0.8986615538597107, -0.5884490013122559, 0.3039984703063965, 0.09346775710582733, 0.5684757828712463, 0.37099024653434753, 0.1818414032459259, 0.4249855577945709, 0.24035099148750305, -0.1517484486103058, 0.08404384553432465, 0.679616391658783, -0.02783379703760147, 0.8524514436721802, 0.8140923976898193, -0.5176622867584229, 1.0880916118621826, 0.2540239095687866, 0.07536152750253677, 0.10861460119485855, 0.16554467380046844, 0.814558207988739, -0.8064818978309631, -0.8375915884971619, 0.5041086077690125, -0.17453216016292572, 0.5286092758178711, 0.8595325946807861, 0.22245492041110992, 0.9122374653816223, 0.779000997543335, 0.5982130765914917, -0.7532651424407959, 0.09306611120700836, 0.30836647748947144, 0.42882949113845825, 0.0026615532115101814, 0.2805183231830597, -0.45830196142196655, -0.6512162685394287, -0.14912335574626923, -0.5175865888595581, 0.7138132452964783, -0.4818457067012787, 0.8677423000335693, 0.017845604568719864, -0.08571486920118332, -1.7591354846954346, -0.036170028150081635, 0.33607396483421326, 0.17930279672145844, -0.3828739821910858, -0.25445178151130676, 0.03609030321240425, 0.04226280003786087, 0.04524000734090805, -0.9133686423301697, 0.3036280572414398, 1.1159977912902832, 0.11813800781965256, 0.19987066090106964, 0.192339226603508, -0.2426377534866333, -1.0495761632919312, -0.575223445892334, -0.7615272998809814, -0.5384657382965088, -1.1084188222885132, 0.9348652958869934, 0.7939072251319885, -0.7034480571746826, 0.5930905938148499, 0.21370913088321686, -0.2925974726676941, 0.5256655812263489, -0.3893319368362427, 0.8500503897666931, 0.3856067359447479, 0.6144040822982788, -0.31269583106040955, 0.4921730160713196, -1.2800096273422241, -0.16329044103622437, -0.39265263080596924, 0.20522558689117432, 0.4099650979042053, -0.8739777207374573, -0.44826290011405945, -0.8411008715629578, 0.08413252979516983, -0.36161577701568604, 0.27662789821624756, -0.06338368356227875, -0.9994313716888428, -0.06686903536319733, -0.2513083815574646, -0.5392129421234131, -0.555159866809845, 0.655186116695404, -0.011593570001423359, -0.35933297872543335, 0.16793213784694672, 0.6479620933532715, -0.8073791265487671, 0.5588498711585999, 0.4582415223121643, 0.7016311883926392, -0.30691298842430115, 0.29669228196144104, 1.008448600769043, 0.5059149861335754, 0.34250473976135254, -0.36557692289352417, -0.39725062251091003, 0.047196563333272934, -0.1996336132287979, -0.8165403604507446, -0.2889192998409271, 0.8502488732337952, 0.03124932572245598, -0.9317358732223511, -0.21073241531848907, -0.5251535773277283, -0.1541830450296402, -0.2676469087600708, -0.5439139604568481, 0.8744997978210449, -0.31186074018478394, 0.35298076272010803, -1.0090833902359009, 0.2417675405740738, 0.7670578956604004, 0.15124042332172394, 1.1195430755615234, -0.7343696355819702, 0.5553135871887207, 0.5552865266799927, 0.057955801486968994, 0.1540243774652481, 0.25695985555648804, -0.15611286461353302, -0.4085839092731476, -0.05012109503149986, -1.1001741886138916, 0.1554451584815979, 0.11876185983419418, 0.1245083212852478, 0.7080661654472351, 1.2039529085159302, -0.5943185687065125, -1.0403612852096558, -1.3870337009429932, -0.5330502390861511, 0.10786273330450058, 0.5501773953437805, 0.3874059319496155, -0.000569485011510551, -0.5765538215637207, -0.44413161277770996, 0.4768812358379364, -0.2582464814186096, 0.04185399040579796, -1.0426746606826782, 0.051486361771821976, -0.42608585953712463, -0.8877535462379456, 0.7066754102706909, -0.44597363471984863, -0.1996755599975586, 0.27953362464904785, 1.0937024354934692, 0.808375895023346, 0.23568320274353027, 0.20493243634700775, -0.9191688299179077, 0.35448992252349854, 0.7731326222419739, 0.194990336894989, -0.0755244717001915, -0.9905576705932617, 0.012633591890335083, -0.40425896644592285, -1.0652060508728027, -0.22723388671875, -0.29981449246406555, -0.36836135387420654, -0.836620569229126, -0.06850777566432953, 0.39987075328826904, 1.4622958898544312, -0.40139681100845337, 0.3062330484390259, 0.05300905928015709, 0.14352768659591675, 1.0121955871582031, 0.8047987818717957, 0.3287486732006073, -0.5355260968208313, -0.18043921887874603, -0.6548472046852112, 0.1608693152666092, 0.23771965503692627, 0.1023930236697197, -0.8330055475234985, -0.5405864715576172, -0.6630966067314148, -0.3775884807109833, 0.38589000701904297, -0.06800396740436554, -0.507149338722229, 0.43591251969337463, -0.09154550731182098, 0.039645109325647354, -0.43202653527259827, -0.2968687415122986, 0.1954026222229004, 0.04356514662504196, 0.4914165437221527, -0.32126089930534363, 0.26782795786857605, -0.28746703267097473, 1.3556803464889526, 0.8838611841201782, -0.4540441036224365, -0.37654224038124084, -0.7301861643791199, 0.6314663887023926, -0.2871270477771759, -0.3073417842388153, 0.6999125480651855, 0.5404513478279114, 0.15473563969135284, -0.1296190321445465, -0.21219076216220856, 0.37714430689811707, -0.7151412963867188, 0.28175610303878784, 0.023500433191657066, 0.5186266899108887, 0.11541122943162918, 0.427268922328949, 0.08496777713298798, 0.008526456542313099, -0.2923602759838104, -0.44727617502212524, -0.08393221348524094, -0.2481190413236618, 0.30941128730773926, 0.295391321182251, 0.350190669298172, 0.09610988199710846, 0.23660027980804443, 0.023920781910419464, 0.5326364040374756, -0.0064279185608029366, 0.06968896836042404, -0.018636440858244896, -0.4600599706172943, 0.16318464279174805, 0.7494610548019409, 0.9610483646392822, 0.6934682726860046, 0.4162510633468628, 0.12266896665096283, 0.06228942051529884, 0.6231640577316284, -0.20462316274642944, 0.2418646216392517, -0.4498178958892822, -0.21660186350345612, -0.4897898733615875, -0.05895930156111717, -0.27137991786003113, -0.9247341156005859, 0.8188844919204712, -0.4110344648361206, 0.0771789625287056, 0.21557167172431946, -0.6351561546325684, 0.03739028424024582, 0.4702078402042389, -0.8545077443122864, 0.28461650013923645, -0.46428894996643066, -0.12243663519620895, 0.5523241758346558, -0.9063740372657776, -0.11486190557479858, -0.00817542802542448, -0.7473329901695251, -0.022685188800096512, 0.9432430863380432, 0.4761714041233063, -0.6481294631958008, 0.3896360993385315, -1.080979824066162, 0.765289306640625, 0.3057820200920105, 0.29585185647010803, -0.49428296089172363, 0.5371075868606567, -0.09956872463226318, -0.4897821247577667, -0.41368868947029114, 0.18026337027549744, -0.36443859338760376, -0.13029198348522186, 0.34428319334983826, 0.49655425548553467, 0.33487534523010254, 0.44063717126846313, -0.8123237490653992, 0.6772521138191223, 0.20364603400230408, -0.12615440785884857, -0.22125011682510376, 1.1372599601745605, 0.16289372742176056, 0.6156309247016907, -0.24848665297031403, -0.8034282326698303, 0.2368873953819275, -0.02742595039308071, 0.07366279512643814, -1.6651183366775513, -0.3258998692035675, -0.7630486488342285, -0.1433403640985489, 0.1907055377960205, 0.5501360893249512, 0.2790232002735138, -0.42116665840148926, -0.37999776005744934, -0.33857160806655884, 0.16338412463665009, 0.006034905090928078, -0.02199653349816799, -1.0104107856750488, -0.26646748185157776, -0.9947776794433594, 0.6498290300369263, -0.8667629361152649, 0.7911037802696228, 0.11063945293426514, 0.161424919962883, 0.01213296502828598, 0.26880505681037903, 0.3336044251918793, 0.11692267656326294, -0.5134431719779968, 0.6990773677825928, -0.11625560373067856, -0.1330145299434662, -0.3253375291824341, 0.8601760864257812, -1.1703311204910278, 0.2918384373188019, 0.5881545543670654, 0.20779374241828918, 0.39087411761283875, 0.45149585604667664, 0.9745402932167053, -0.20362401008605957, 0.10444049537181854, -0.11493440717458725, 0.18838970363140106, 0.6140807867050171, 1.2519196271896362, -0.43680307269096375, -0.7861239910125732, -0.8336730003356934, -1.0414376258850098, 0.6229115724563599, 0.1719152182340622, -0.37886881828308105, -0.3980019688606262, -0.3277759253978729, -0.921623945236206, -0.2317822277545929, 0.737619936466217, 0.827844500541687, 0.23487313091754913, 0.15526904165744781, 0.2083817720413208, 0.34556856751441956, -0.32228735089302063, 0.5139226317405701, -0.08769763261079788, 0.004950495902448893, 0.20664723217487335, 0.047405704855918884, -0.9247888922691345, -0.890997052192688, -1.2432259321212769, 0.03605353832244873, 0.3025898039340973, -0.12327110022306442, 1.5087486505508423, 0.08769684284925461, 0.2865675985813141, 0.09370366483926773, 0.3321526050567627, -0.42103561758995056, 0.031721603125333786, -0.15623505413532257, -0.09937804192304611, -0.5230286717414856, -0.11394628882408142, 0.41671204566955566, -0.06449662148952484, -0.28175273537635803, 0.07234857231378555, -0.369867742061615, -0.44886982440948486, 0.5529853701591492, 0.43131059408187866, -0.9542041420936584, -0.14838074147701263, -0.4963468909263611, -0.022764144465327263, -0.6122809052467346, -0.9466773271560669, 0.11237826198339462, -0.016803789883852005, -0.5696139931678772, 0.34511566162109375, 0.38824477791786194, 0.08987826108932495, 0.4442674517631531, -0.03154692426323891, -0.39653220772743225, -1.2521833181381226, -0.6722820401191711, 1.5261237621307373, -1.106831431388855, -0.8034427165985107, -1.0309362411499023, -0.6654517650604248, -0.4447513520717621, 0.09900559484958649, 0.5256227850914001, -0.2088550627231598, -0.2617182433605194, 0.5371724963188171, -0.30687615275382996, 0.21648208796977997, 1.0342779159545898, -0.34523671865463257, -0.17869409918785095, 0.21984484791755676, -0.9622546434402466, -0.29408323764801025, -0.34875547885894775, 0.21674221754074097, 0.42106086015701294, -0.4357779324054718, -0.11202725023031235, -0.309985876083374, -0.242109015583992, -0.8338903188705444, -0.34080374240875244, -0.4301042854785919, -1.4071649312973022, -0.596745491027832, -1.1868118047714233, -0.48687803745269775, -0.14212048053741455, -0.10550303757190704, -0.12864115834236145, -0.1462211310863495, -0.539624810218811, 0.014029214158654213, 0.1952275037765503, 0.4854854643344879, 0.31718409061431885, 0.09671030193567276, -0.5059587955474854, -0.5453424453735352, -0.04042431712150574, -0.39574840664863586, -0.008501213975250721, 0.05796805024147034, -0.45486053824424744, 0.1585536003112793, -0.5226025581359863, 0.928895115852356, -0.5724257826805115, -0.531145453453064, -0.037409987300634384, 0.1472495198249817, -0.8100666403770447, 0.3951793313026428, 0.39629602432250977, 0.6754866242408752, 0.42452433705329895, -0.17115436494350433, 0.31662654876708984, -0.5387604236602783, -0.7426032423973083, -0.09528619796037674, -0.02912232279777527, 0.46441009640693665, -0.3539610803127289, -0.1857408881187439, 0.5814026594161987, 0.0661228820681572, -0.8358023166656494, 0.3590759038925171, -0.4170176386833191, 0.07589747756719589, 0.2024116963148117, -0.3624904453754425, -0.25543928146362305, 0.3464075028896332, -0.9965255260467529, 0.5921160578727722, 0.21841038763523102, -0.08651671558618546, -0.12211223691701889, 0.24978384375572205, -0.057369381189346313, 0.587227463722229, 0.0759606882929802, -0.656714141368866, -0.2678205668926239, 0.3310578465461731, -0.638006329536438, 0.8912401795387268, -0.4032168388366699, -0.3313874304294586, -0.9219111800193787, -0.9395241737365723, -1.3611347675323486, -0.17410176992416382, 0.12174943834543228, -0.34641459584236145, -0.14573971927165985, 0.1821518987417221, -0.7187066674232483, 0.21644091606140137, -0.19813042879104614, -0.7284187078475952, -1.1135519742965698, -1.109027624130249, 0.18375802040100098, 0.019575469195842743, -0.05675312504172325, 0.16182130575180054, -0.1860589236021042, 0.4083150029182434, -0.2788538336753845, -0.10969258099794388, -0.3027307987213135, 0.6766053438186646, -0.6359126567840576, 0.5587430000305176, -0.5200526714324951, -0.06600593775510788, -0.1831642985343933, -0.6020961999893188, 0.24675478041172028, 0.42506712675094604, 0.03838981315493584, -0.017375199124217033, -0.6354470252990723, 0.5664581060409546, 0.25064337253570557, 0.2819449305534363, 0.16212545335292816, -0.1958044320344925, -1.2886325120925903, 1.298326849937439, 0.2949056923389435, -0.16678951680660248, 0.2287866473197937, 0.2982558012008667, -0.00748701486736536, 0.16970644891262054, -0.30835437774658203, 0.49543359875679016, 0.3782004714012146, -0.9376575350761414, 0.7156262397766113, -0.08312595635652542, 0.22846560180187225, 0.4740695357322693, -0.8008381128311157, -0.4797445237636566, 0.06022964045405388, 0.232132226228714, 0.850045919418335, 0.5854083895683289, 0.39125651121139526, -0.31702375411987305, -0.09382625669240952, 0.3050422966480255, 0.2725561559200287, 1.1377148628234863, 0.07520028203725815, 0.5675581097602844, -0.41990330815315247, 0.16995570063591003, 0.5870019197463989, 0.5753234624862671, 0.33299240469932556, -0.3084544539451599, -0.019634656608104706, 0.8311524987220764, 0.19085639715194702, -0.0824768990278244, -0.34511199593544006, 0.32022738456726074, 0.13077303767204285, 0.02856622077524662, 0.14940211176872253, 0.2551119923591614, 0.33181655406951904, 0.8463313579559326, 0.654459536075592, 0.8960825800895691, -0.11996722966432571, 0.5607732534408569, 0.3561953008174896, 0.5146932601928711, -0.3229331970214844, 0.3781251907348633, 0.7033810019493103, 0.4660908579826355, -0.24018782377243042, -1.0737082958221436, 0.28401604294776917, 0.8942584991455078, -1.827976942062378, -0.003964501433074474, -0.3482320308685303, -0.15000776946544647, 0.18518638610839844, -0.882859468460083, -0.012309153564274311, -0.6504684686660767, 0.386839896440506, 0.7172126173973083, 0.05108274519443512, 0.27122417092323303, 0.6662415862083435, -0.5792666077613831, 0.40081343054771423, 1.114133358001709, 0.23981377482414246, -0.829735517501831, 0.7939721345901489, 0.7408612966537476, 0.03805769979953766, -0.3617092967033386, -0.562303900718689, -0.7300054430961609, 0.15427929162979126, 0.18379513919353485, -0.4734404385089874, 0.6028724908828735, -0.5182728171348572, -0.4993880093097687, 0.7940865755081177, 0.9132760763168335, -0.10404583811759949, -0.384519100189209, 0.22741813957691193, 0.43867844343185425, -0.4666309654712677, 0.7529523968696594, 0.7980944514274597, 0.9293851852416992, -0.2964554727077484, -0.7923939228057861, -0.6789865493774414, 0.07855173200368881, -0.9311961531639099, -0.00927913747727871, 0.5921534299850464, -0.008774769492447376, -0.3011719882488251, 0.08146741986274719, 0.6514542698860168, -0.13214734196662903, -0.07520266622304916, 0.06265819817781448, -0.48016902804374695, -0.1100035160779953, -0.2130224108695984, 0.7760354280471802, 0.4634605050086975, -0.32601335644721985, 0.23971284925937653, 0.33526280522346497, 2.0100457668304443, 0.06609457731246948, 0.5942866802215576, 0.3567350506782532, 0.5645354986190796, 0.04240034893155098, 0.5384305715560913, 0.12348666042089462, -0.597165048122406, 0.9198453426361084, -0.5625191330909729, -0.12196001410484314, 0.01104959100484848, -0.10245732218027115, 0.4687539041042328, 1.0643311738967896, 0.2968626916408539, -0.4495527744293213, -0.14757530391216278, -0.12567080557346344, -1.4631446599960327, 0.009286320768296719, -0.7648468613624573, 0.2437765896320343, -0.3501759171485901, -0.008036414161324501, 0.19326940178871155, -0.8139302134513855, 3.815255880355835, 0.8520089387893677, 0.7202584147453308, 0.07490245997905731, 0.06413304060697556, 0.25769826769828796, 0.03296159952878952, -0.5421803593635559, -0.5365517139434814, -0.6873443126678467, 0.18905110657215118, 0.6677846908569336, 0.017842983826994896, -0.4561612606048584, -0.095116525888443, 0.7742338180541992, -0.2680228054523468, 0.08417131751775742, 0.2518066167831421, -0.9752386808395386, -0.38183262944221497, -0.28119590878486633, 0.5349491834640503, 0.06451336294412613, 0.15398149192333221, 0.168178990483284, 0.07834236323833466, -0.4518471360206604, -0.6554397940635681, 0.1521265208721161, -0.7714360952377319, -0.9703846573829651, 0.41336384415626526, -0.05900544300675392, -0.32747939229011536, 0.8040441274642944, 0.7548465132713318, 0.08872939646244049, 0.23163311183452606, -0.32850182056427, -0.38351601362228394, 0.25302809476852417, 0.1517569124698639, -0.13122908771038055, -0.9782373309135437, 1.150438904762268, -0.3017517328262329, 0.9027488231658936, 0.15742477774620056, -0.4780222177505493, 0.9436962604522705, -0.3229229152202606, 0.5706670880317688, -0.6091383695602417, -0.7050967812538147, 0.28301864862442017, -0.5584756731987, 0.16729924082756042, 0.253540575504303, -0.24005471169948578, 1.330930471420288, 0.2752017676830292, -0.970323920249939, -0.41541552543640137, -0.23951515555381775, 0.2725036144256592, 0.30484339594841003, 0.9964703321456909, -0.18760915100574493, 0.3112850487232208, 0.020672734826803207, -0.21712438762187958, -0.4704139828681946, 0.311965674161911, 0.6913479566574097, -0.20057101547718048, -0.2755524218082428, 0.7348465323448181, -0.36282551288604736, -0.0077115572057664394, 0.7177483439445496, -0.2992120385169983, -0.7883991003036499, -0.052805498242378235, 0.3392403721809387, 0.7065201997756958, -0.7810803651809692, 0.1252935826778412, 0.004897600039839745, 0.6285880208015442, 0.9054232239723206, 1.3096158504486084, -0.4373273253440857, 0.10704962909221649, -0.8605872988700867 ]
C_{60} with O defects: Localized states in the gap and oxygen clustering
We propose a Su-Schrieffer-Heeger type electron-phonon model for C_{60} with O defects and solve by the adiabatic approximation. Two new properties are obtained. (1) The dimerization becomes weaker around the oxygen. Two localized states appear deep in the gap. Optical transition between them is allowed. This accords with the recent optical absorption data. (2) Oxygens are predicted to cluster on the surface of $\soc$. PACS numbers: 3640, 7155, 6165, 3120P
Kikuo Harigaya (Fundamental Physics Section, Electrotechnical Laboratory, Japan)
cond-mat
May
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9205016
cond-mat/9206001
[ -0.11466128379106522, 0.9828382730484009, 0.6809361577033997, 0.6826037764549255, 0.09030502289533615, -0.46128538250923157, -0.4024370312690735, -0.25117525458335876, -0.14292700588703156, 1.9263246059417725, 0.3802606165409088, 0.3844646215438843, -0.3008684515953064, -0.9387657046318054, -0.27328377962112427, 0.3903758227825165, -0.17258821427822113, -0.6778102517127991, -0.7452929615974426, -0.24929724633693695, -0.1421663761138916, -0.3980516493320465, -0.3810354173183441, -1.0923118591308594, -0.5671507716178894, 0.5340916514396667, 0.5688837170600891, -0.17405106127262115, 0.9106574058532715, 1.086045742034912, 0.6319877505302429, -0.3129630386829376, 0.30869805812835693, -0.9737329483032227, -0.32553714513778687, -0.005685732699930668, 0.8931834697723389, -0.9082006216049194, -0.14533989131450653, -0.22461621463298798, 1.0038036108016968, -0.4916887879371643, 0.28345489501953125, -0.9442834258079529, 0.14780524373054504, -0.25550371408462524, 0.4463069438934326, 0.04370485991239548, 0.013720937073230743, -1.003189206123352, -0.08439904451370239, 0.6366860270500183, -0.07084782421588898, -0.7807892560958862, -0.22009554505348206, -0.1593971997499466, 0.18358758091926575, 0.649330198764801, 0.01584186777472496, 0.19160281121730804, 0.47155889868736267, 0.00530113885179162, 0.2737988829612732, -0.7060309052467346, -0.40907835960388184, 0.9231626391410828, -0.1874885857105255, 0.4355336129665375, -0.15335725247859955, -0.3881000876426697, -1.865260124206543, -0.5090844035148621, 0.1222827211022377, 0.397611528635025, -0.1892480105161667, 1.3089394569396973, 0.276394248008728, -0.2852686941623688, -0.18973025679588318, -0.14677788317203522, -0.41215646266937256, -0.2423100769519806, -0.2803139388561249, 0.7830377817153931, -0.14717300236225128, -0.18882018327713013, -0.04886501654982567, -0.09436449408531189, 0.014973976649343967, -0.25524067878723145, 0.5218263268470764, 0.609803318977356, -0.005390177480876446, 0.03737429901957512, 0.8943987488746643, 1.0767942667007446, -0.4611024856567383, 0.3145069479942322, 0.18025894463062286, 0.08205698430538177, 0.25603851675987244, 1.5258413553237915, 0.01542869582772255, 0.9003186821937561, -0.9074965715408325, 0.4085180461406708, 0.18011917173862457, 0.07787220180034637, -0.4712389409542084, -0.35474416613578796, -0.5370137095451355, 0.5603196620941162, 0.9463773965835571, 0.5247026085853577, 0.9783596992492676, 0.765084445476532, 0.3945164382457733, 0.06386207044124603, -0.9668296575546265, 0.3461483418941498, 0.284313827753067, 0.03407524898648262, 0.1721716672182083, 0.07030701637268066, -0.20556770265102386, -0.5123009085655212, 0.0817309021949768, 1.1121071577072144, -0.6161641478538513, 0.009374705143272877, 0.4081977903842926, -0.6168947815895081, -0.2487390786409378, 0.7171906232833862, 0.5220367908477783, 0.34981802105903625, -0.2899840474128723, 0.8926471471786499, 0.7051721215248108, 0.7364202737808228, -0.20046661794185638, -0.2859726548194885, 0.043526541441679, 1.2975698709487915, -0.23458625376224518, -0.10517705976963043, 0.3669760525226593, 0.506740391254425, -0.09541206806898117, -0.023145155981183052, -0.7796279788017273, -0.037433262914419174, 0.034878842532634735, -0.42780765891075134, -0.811679482460022, -0.3497287333011627, -0.8731496334075928, 0.5955057144165039, -0.380898654460907, 0.17321398854255676, 0.48034006357192993, -0.11114559322595596, 0.4187729060649872, 0.9548735022544861, -1.400614619255066, 0.7771525979042053, -0.9255402684211731, -0.13719542324543, -0.7714701294898987, 0.15001974999904633, -0.11615732312202454, -0.3212226927280426, -0.1468149721622467, -0.10638324171304703, 0.8551574945449829, 0.2980411648750305, 0.23923063278198242, 0.4446646571159363, -0.18737564980983734, 0.13218837976455688, -0.162195086479187, -0.39849236607551575, 0.029028013348579407, 1.2508295774459839, 0.00673046475276351, -0.18777132034301758, 0.15115676820278168, -0.17729449272155762, 0.4521854817867279, -0.08709094673395157, 0.32465049624443054, 1.1748523712158203, -1.0175350904464722, 0.0847826898097992, -0.23886947333812714, -0.09096372127532959, -0.05756698548793793, 0.5191505551338196, -0.22267559170722961, -0.43168944120407104, 0.011451475322246552, -0.02058521658182144, -0.7525432705879211, 0.357306569814682, -2.048579454421997, 0.08080942928791046, -0.266964316368103, 0.8187128305435181, -0.7373341917991638, -0.03237639367580414, 0.8755246996879578, -0.21037724614143372, 0.29491347074508667, 0.27505555748939514, 0.2642037272453308, 0.13886365294456482, -0.494516521692276, -0.34542450308799744, 0.7883234024047852, -0.8939719200134277, 0.4842897653579712, -0.354115754365921, -0.1364210546016693, -0.06068234518170357, 0.04592461884021759, -0.30837857723236084, -0.40034639835357666, 0.22916178405284882, 0.4951116144657135, 0.8080105185508728, 0.8339148759841919, 0.6014528870582581, -1.030300259590149, 0.3204205334186554, 0.838496744632721, -0.09340222924947739, 0.22380730509757996, 0.3892355263233185, -0.4007233679294586, 0.11333741992712021, 0.9212052226066589, 1.135032296180725, 0.605663537979126, 0.17756852507591248, -0.6389944553375244, 1.2518751621246338, -0.5417210459709167, 0.43444305658340454, -0.6792258620262146, -0.27466219663619995, -0.22244831919670105, 1.3125462532043457, -0.08303162455558777, -0.06073339283466339, -0.6319268345832825, 0.39441150426864624, 0.30730581283569336, 0.27379339933395386, -0.08006945997476578, -0.7449945211410522, 0.236942857503891, 0.564399242401123, 0.6547427177429199, -0.7869803309440613, -0.4630623757839203, 0.6285186409950256, -0.3205210566520691, 0.033753156661987305, -1.004682183265686, -0.645990788936615, -0.9251036643981934, -0.12597201764583588, -0.6433956623077393, -0.3452926278114319, -0.36905068159103394, -0.16348889470100403, 0.08636151999235153, -0.38844162225723267, 0.4443261921405792, 0.016266535967588425, -0.5250098705291748, -0.30327337980270386, -0.6351536512374878, 0.07369081676006317, 0.12717914581298828, -0.20602551102638245, -0.8189400434494019, -0.13791821897029877, 0.14865437150001526, 0.2721291780471802, 0.3683256506919861, -0.4656729996204376, -0.6682636141777039, 0.44895705580711365, -0.6587882041931152, 0.43498316407203674, 0.29650449752807617, 0.0743534117937088, -0.9311936497688293, -0.572849690914154, -0.008081651292741299, -0.4003705084323883, -0.7477067112922668, -0.1261778473854065, -0.2123517394065857, 0.8558956980705261, -0.09465527534484863, -0.7486208081245422, 0.6886909008026123, 1.194441556930542, -0.48656541109085083, -0.7438536882400513, -0.47426342964172363, 0.23342186212539673, -0.3007074296474457, 1.2807140350341797, 1.3830822706222534, 0.28205981850624084, -0.034642186015844345, -0.25095900893211365, -0.10432168841362, 0.35450196266174316, 0.2250489741563797, -0.2842350900173187, -0.1308729648590088, 1.2232565879821777, 0.6501917243003845, -0.5381799936294556, 0.531200647354126, -0.6920381784439087, -0.44127678871154785, 0.23077253997325897, -0.4515405595302582, 0.6008412837982178, 0.7673217058181763, -0.4317376911640167, -0.2233719527721405, -0.3634580075740814, 0.004525440279394388, 0.7401915192604065, -0.09873516112565994, -0.26939356327056885, 0.3353623151779175, 0.12836141884326935, 0.11169546842575073, -0.2513662576675415, 1.4174963235855103, -0.1950160712003708, 0.2650192379951477, 0.03659498691558838, -1.1310080289840698, 0.33780503273010254, 0.3108152151107788, -0.3515836298465729, -0.1902199238538742, -0.10964424163103104, -0.50594562292099, -0.04574060067534447, -0.7076399922370911, -0.3068176507949829, 0.011398909613490105, -0.10583007335662842, -0.27566567063331604, 0.4702461361885071, -0.41484177112579346, 0.33973756432533264, 0.48932620882987976, 0.5749977827072144, 0.503342866897583, -1.0232621431350708, -0.10823725908994675, -0.441986083984375, -0.42058008909225464, 0.4304562509059906, -0.5886369347572327, -1.0056743621826172, 0.5130367875099182, -0.2393948882818222, 0.5310912728309631, -0.9642192125320435, 0.2287011444568634, -0.6374310851097107, 0.6594043970108032, 0.649422824382782, 0.9685170650482178, 0.33175215125083923, -0.6158122420310974, 0.021334439516067505, -0.524642288684845, -0.31229957938194275, -0.05066780745983124, -0.5250073075294495, -0.8519871830940247, -0.8590467572212219, -0.2927744686603546, -0.3423214852809906, 0.6546443104743958, 0.9273573160171509, -0.2858181297779083, 0.45017141103744507, 0.8520002961158752, -0.26518556475639343, -0.21679624915122986, 0.8581365942955017, -0.3052941858768463, 0.5094419717788696, -0.23742446303367615, 0.4697782099246979, 0.005733666010200977, -0.38286346197128296, -0.5131159424781799, -0.5565425157546997, 0.4352356791496277, 0.058645594865083694, 0.7800854444503784, 0.09029003232717514, -0.7405321002006531, 0.06986035406589508, -0.4553937613964081, 0.2969384491443634, -0.7963917255401611, -0.05882996320724487, 0.25849220156669617, 1.2202345132827759, 0.4408439099788666, -0.6859036087989807, -0.37198397517204285, -0.6044895052909851, 0.913560688495636, 0.39945822954177856, 0.24853768944740295, -0.8431881070137024, 0.38688063621520996, 0.39503249526023865, -0.4476037323474884, 0.09779727458953857, 0.5760225653648376, -1.1421054601669312, 0.3287866711616516, -0.6070532202720642, 0.216336190700531, 0.22116678953170776, -0.06517160683870316, 0.1814650297164917, -0.12986977398395538, 0.22536469995975494, -0.8448544144630432, 0.07782046496868134, -0.6431306600570679, -0.36793291568756104, 0.36984074115753174, 0.34700459241867065, 0.4568693935871124, -0.1813131868839264, -0.30631306767463684, 0.3780454993247986, -0.3090747594833374, 0.4067583978176117, 0.36780640482902527, -0.4610867202281952, -0.10893185436725616, -0.022834619507193565, -0.37633275985717773, -0.5876941084861755, -0.6392998695373535, 0.5604147911071777, 0.7127828598022461, 0.36794400215148926, 0.6771342158317566, 0.37925922870635986, 0.11728794127702713, 0.3909720182418823, -0.10267873108386993, -0.2976172864437103, 0.8824198246002197, -0.6115640997886658, 0.000545058399438858, -0.344279944896698, -0.09189528971910477, -1.1671850681304932, -0.696910560131073, 0.4642563760280609, 0.24308477342128754, 0.2253236174583435, -0.2507459819316864, -0.5118306279182434, 0.167199045419693, 0.2923084497451782, -0.2049708515405655, 0.7175467610359192, 0.5327287912368774, 0.27800118923187256, -0.3318164348602295, -0.4771677553653717, -0.03503799811005592, 0.27815932035446167, 0.24776144325733185, 0.443489134311676, -0.28395000100135803, 0.19278380274772644, -0.18978212773799896, 0.2165098488330841, -1.1911818981170654, 0.16627629101276398, 0.1266222447156906, 0.24244210124015808, -0.33805012702941895, -0.037759654223918915, -0.3727627098560333, -0.04555215314030647, -0.15243226289749146, -0.6290856599807739, 0.14523059129714966, 0.04854732006788254, 0.5492916703224182, 0.436862975358963, -0.59881991147995, 0.2788228988647461, -0.3084537088871002, 0.23421619832515717, -0.39858371019363403, -0.6358685493469238, -0.0282182227820158, 0.63656085729599, -0.22936609387397766, 0.41597700119018555, -0.08427342027425766, -1.164053201675415, -0.07652018219232559, -0.4585475027561188, 0.5444963574409485, -0.6912371516227722, 0.010459738783538342, -0.1231304258108139, 0.328490287065506, -0.27894967794418335, 0.13648392260074615, 0.7614264488220215, -1.069313883781433, 0.14668919146060944, -0.49914127588272095, 0.21841676533222198, -0.5628999471664429, -0.9311884641647339, -0.47530031204223633, -0.12059269845485687, 0.288469135761261, 0.6955815553665161, 0.37095656991004944, -1.1072815656661987, 0.22210286557674408, 0.5870354771614075, -0.5797795653343201, 0.25771287083625793, -0.5105014443397522, -0.22663070261478424, -0.15509751439094543, 0.44649961590766907, 0.12105565518140793, 0.7556456923484802, -0.5056428909301758, 0.12243157625198364, -0.6365926265716553, -0.22129006683826447, -0.18732646107673645, 0.09765785932540894, -0.13878829777240753, -0.7687634825706482, 0.8205018043518066, -0.956026017665863, -0.11802870035171509, 0.26646968722343445, 0.016657592728734016, 0.7075185775756836, -0.10473557561635971, -0.7811599969863892, -0.02768167480826378, -0.6187779903411865, -0.89151531457901, 0.3390183448791504, 0.14849425852298737, 0.0034298591781407595, -1.0120080709457397, -0.07056408375501633, 0.2836157977581024, -0.07680104672908783, 0.5488470196723938, 1.0171167850494385, 0.04593628644943237, 0.15433210134506226, 0.22928160429000854, 0.13838835060596466, -0.2521441578865051, -0.20488914847373962, 0.3466375470161438, 0.7900307178497314, -0.9743334054946899, -0.15638701617717743, 0.007258503697812557, -0.8388645052909851, -0.2231132835149765, 0.1880953311920166, 0.21221163868904114, 0.003384467214345932, 0.9011270403862, -0.8742302656173706, -0.06496724486351013, -0.2378097027540207, 0.0728941336274147, -0.1862572282552719, 0.05226033553481102, 0.4129221439361572, 0.3085893988609314, 0.1895032376050949, -0.3040120303630829, 0.7129340767860413, -1.208113193511963, -0.2061040699481964, 1.0865200757980347, -0.7756397128105164, -0.6032417416572571, 0.16602075099945068, 0.07945834845304489, -0.380366712808609, -0.48178908228874207, -1.1606378555297852, -0.1096685379743576, 1.111833930015564, -0.40854594111442566, 0.12222177535295486, -0.8069385290145874, -0.5524445176124573, 0.31641602516174316, 0.7515071630477905, -0.05830344557762146, -0.11378702521324158, 0.5446873903274536, 0.4915587604045868, -0.6395252346992493, 0.4427267909049988, 0.9321897029876709, 0.16375072300434113, 0.02814546227455139, -0.9921621680259705, -0.2185436487197876, 0.16324776411056519, -0.5399825572967529, 0.9650703072547913, -0.686825692653656, 0.6246099472045898, -0.5991957783699036, 0.4063352942466736, 0.2912556231021881, -0.2833265960216522, 0.644699215888977, 0.14943459630012512, -0.2798786759376526, -0.8430826663970947, -1.0945727825164795, 0.1339353621006012, 0.07302012294530869, 1.1150593757629395, -0.42543524503707886, 0.13268880546092987, -0.3928069770336151, -0.7331379652023315, -1.166111707687378, -1.1029386520385742, 0.11900308728218079, -1.1896884441375732, -0.9747901558876038, -1.7383008003234863, -0.4760783016681671, 0.3194710314273834, 0.3976600468158722, 0.36272749304771423, 0.40116220712661743, -0.6064421534538269, 0.2672814428806305, 0.42254695296287537, 0.6648410558700562, -0.23164649307727814, -0.7725762128829956, -1.236100435256958, -0.3343158960342407, -1.1302622556686401, 0.3951461613178253, 0.03762076795101166, 0.843849778175354, -0.5325922966003418, -0.057621490210294724, 0.06825406104326248, 0.40970727801322937, -0.24766138195991516, -0.5151796936988831, 0.6294260621070862, -0.3267850875854492, -0.8572279214859009, 0.10934244841337204, -0.6215782165527344, 0.3583161532878876, 0.07575660198926926, -0.3864089846611023, -0.12653017044067383, -0.3155853748321533, -0.5226120948791504, -0.08360826969146729, 0.30251848697662354, 0.07912487536668777, 0.09826388210058212, -0.5605985522270203, -0.04608101025223732, 0.5581568479537964, -1.3794816732406616, -0.12096784263849258, 0.08333103358745575, 0.5837917923927307, 0.25762462615966797, -0.2183058261871338, 0.3456295132637024, 1.1216464042663574, -1.0895805358886719, 0.00004981744132237509, -0.798078179359436, -0.016638878732919693, -0.1358703374862671, 0.2611645758152008, -0.7653923630714417, -0.1654873788356781, 0.4227672219276428, -0.6368716955184937, 0.14462190866470337, 0.17903006076812744, -1.2452424764633179, 0.20220538973808289, -0.3535010814666748, -0.4454883635044098, -0.5762420296669006, -0.49447888135910034, -0.5645539164543152, 0.8166950345039368, -0.22170469164848328, 0.13895849883556366, -0.5422790050506592, -0.6965567469596863, -0.72968989610672, -1.1061688661575317, -0.7213047742843628, -0.45690789818763733, -0.21591584384441376, 0.22532735764980316, -0.892625093460083, 0.32514455914497375, -0.29282811284065247, 0.3558838665485382, -0.5624139308929443, 0.3894941508769989, -0.3877711296081543, 0.2444194257259369, -0.3640039563179016, 0.5341155529022217, -0.7165104746818542, -0.013975661247968674, 0.364259272813797, 0.34731820225715637, -0.21786119043827057, -0.5236122012138367, -0.3560534119606018, 0.21453413367271423, -0.8788414001464844, -0.6796796917915344, -0.7372870445251465, -0.2431516796350479, 0.03356122598052025, -0.6495491862297058, -0.21772418916225433, 0.09080195426940918, -0.5070584416389465, -0.10516154766082764, 0.9327412843704224, -0.4893342852592468, -0.07141921669244766, 0.17784497141838074, 0.3941401541233063, 0.031078830361366272, -0.5524816513061523, 0.2557421326637268, 0.9262968897819519, -0.37644094228744507, 0.5594808459281921, 0.3244874179363251, 0.8488737344741821, -0.020065218210220337, 0.2916334867477417, -0.6577843427658081, 1.2737315893173218, 0.46626999974250793, 0.018440600484609604, 0.7411800026893616, 0.09051083028316498, 0.47676753997802734, 0.11065345257520676, 0.22208233177661896, 0.39935365319252014, 0.17455539107322693, -0.3067032992839813, 0.6439939737319946, -0.17689210176467896, 1.0701066255569458, -0.2601538300514221, -0.11349212378263474, 0.02444903738796711, 0.08596973866224289, -0.4938209354877472, 0.44322261214256287, -0.6376239657402039, 0.8310424089431763, -0.08808275312185287, -0.47726044058799744, -0.05798274278640747, -0.173601433634758, -0.1572352647781372, 0.17651496827602386, -0.23342016339302063, -0.24409028887748718, 0.9559259414672852, 0.18576306104660034, -0.04223209619522095, 0.7508873343467712, 0.41038134694099426, 0.5563250780105591, -0.03841983899474144, 1.0188549757003784, 0.6042156219482422, -0.700486958026886, 0.5835093259811401, 0.40153881907463074, -0.048799652606248856, 0.538389265537262, -1.1912739276885986, -0.008976100943982601, 0.2819353938102722, -0.6936007738113403, -0.18380247056484222, -0.9258453845977783, 0.6241814494132996, -0.7063300013542175, -0.21431079506874084, 1.1200971603393555, 0.13692378997802734, -0.42494451999664307, 0.430745393037796, 0.03903781622648239, -0.06617692112922668, 0.30904924869537354, 0.5391825437545776, -0.11536067724227905, 0.9354656934738159, 1.1282504796981812, -0.09336894750595093, 0.7707959413528442, -0.8107314109802246, -0.7026762962341309, -0.17868904769420624, -0.19278205931186676, -0.47165918350219727, 0.32646045088768005, -0.6931829452514648, -0.2550885081291199, -0.04189285635948181, 0.02425270527601242, -0.19542743265628815, 0.17275327444076538, 0.40757179260253906, 1.418580174446106, -0.3604072332382202, -0.06110011041164398, 0.3960455358028412, 0.20368033647537231, 0.25277772545814514, -0.4341338872909546, -0.14329566061496735, 0.2914527654647827, 0.8053651452064514, -0.8397578001022339, 0.12110961228609085, 0.02755274996161461, -0.32756567001342773, 0.019898954778909683, -0.7235100865364075, -0.3401290774345398, -0.42030301690101624, -0.1997205764055252, -0.7236115336418152, 0.5958607792854309, 0.5609921813011169, 0.48783257603645325, 0.44006863236427307, -0.7542722821235657, -0.19927993416786194, 0.8539933562278748, 1.2599588632583618, 0.029904259368777275, 0.7976321578025818, -0.023568999022245407, 0.04980626329779625, -0.3288368582725525, 0.7712942957878113, 0.3324224054813385, 0.21962623298168182, 0.11145751923322678, 0.026291726157069206, 0.04850119724869728, -0.47543349862098694, -0.8097627758979797, 0.666832447052002, 0.2592275142669678, 0.6224760413169861, -0.6108172535896301, -0.4887158274650574, 0.16252122819423676, -1.0070030689239502, -0.05788523703813553, -0.8001364469528198, 0.2642112672328949, 0.509123682975769, -0.10812301188707352, 0.1701706498861313, 0.23053210973739624, 3.8710548877716064, 1.115185260772705, 0.40850377082824707, -0.00977715291082859, 0.6504918336868286, 1.1808110475540161, 0.47327956557273865, -0.53081876039505, 0.7282530069351196, -0.10629897564649582, -0.0698644369840622, 0.08538782596588135, 0.362751841545105, -0.5219724178314209, 0.1392356902360916, 0.18664486706256866, -0.6602321267127991, 1.005121111869812, 0.1910068541765213, -0.7517024278640747, -0.7827831506729126, 0.7707788348197937, -0.023295840248465538, -0.24720638990402222, 0.28620240092277527, -0.016612593084573746, 0.7366405129432678, -0.7678321599960327, -0.6358224749565125, 0.30979621410369873, -0.4349985718727112, -0.24916203320026398, 0.06483032554388046, 0.7366617321968079, -0.8767727017402649, 0.3544459342956543, 0.07736407965421677, 0.4222373068332672, -0.24332192540168762, 0.17791397869586945, 0.4186646044254303, -0.4056463837623596, 0.5305365324020386, -0.3180294632911682, -0.07695288956165314, 0.8948964476585388, 0.49474066495895386, 0.4689355492591858, 0.22730205953121185, -0.3226572871208191, 0.2728175222873688, 0.16444309055805206, 0.7615489959716797, 0.3995892107486725, -0.7101768851280212, -0.35309675335884094, -0.3214862644672394, -0.5062819719314575, -0.06681805104017258, -0.10035475343465805, 0.9686751365661621, 0.3037308156490326, 0.08822609484195709, -0.23671241104602814, 0.29468387365341187, -0.4946174919605255, 0.5991038680076599, -0.41367706656455994, -0.29534706473350525, 0.4349874258041382, -0.19041462242603302, -0.6520945429801941, -0.9943713545799255, -0.03258099406957626, -0.02303256094455719, 0.2632802724838257, -0.7520616054534912, 0.6109768748283386, 0.08216109871864319, 0.3725198209285736, -0.2984068691730499, -0.7161383032798767, 0.7970065474510193, -0.26069995760917664, 0.32230737805366516, 1.2755005359649658, -0.08369795978069305, -0.09577155858278275, 0.2258985936641693, 0.4124300479888916, 0.25903478264808655, 0.35053515434265137, 0.160349503159523, 0.21715132892131805, -0.06347882002592087 ]
Self Organization and a Dynamical Transition in Traffic Flow Models
A simple model that describes traffic flow in two dimensions is studied. A sharp {\it jamming transition } is found that separates between the low density dynamical phase in which all cars move at maximal speed and the high density jammed phase in which they are all stuck. Self organization effects in both phases are studied and discussed.
Ofer Biham, A. Alan Middleton and Dov Levine
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206001
cond-mat/9206002
[ -0.14169655740261078, -0.23811523616313934, 0.3259240686893463, -0.006772228050976992, 0.04338498413562775, -0.9785473346710205, -0.016403567045927048, -0.431635320186615, -0.9890767335891724, 1.4050188064575195, 0.841763436794281, -0.1335454285144806, 0.433623343706131, -0.5691861510276794, -0.45851778984069824, 0.3690682053565979, 0.25591322779655457, -0.5730095505714417, -1.6982629299163818, 0.17600716650485992, 0.3344520926475525, -0.2766215205192566, -0.5214046835899353, -0.5037552118301392, -0.11468888074159622, 1.1867536306381226, 0.18235276639461517, 0.6805077195167542, 1.0377428531646729, 0.9109616279602051, 0.37840214371681213, -0.5524187684059143, 0.13708709180355072, -0.5408810377120972, -0.7526920437812805, 0.02221250720322132, -0.19679412245750427, -0.5042845010757446, 1.0443098545074463, -0.3832465410232544, 1.1248911619186401, -0.14027608931064606, 0.14247483015060425, 0.32984790205955505, -0.4438127875328064, -0.03786361590027809, -0.5119333863258362, 0.4803497791290283, 0.02999856323003769, -1.7814077138900757, -0.02739546075463295, 0.057791560888290405, 0.47268760204315186, -0.22020146250724792, -0.0034785170573741198, -0.5652845501899719, -0.45938047766685486, 0.22246211767196655, -0.250586599111557, 0.26383528113365173, 0.21781869232654572, -0.04443149268627167, 0.31795722246170044, -0.7000283598899841, 0.04282205551862717, 0.9631080031394958, -0.37719103693962097, 0.7945951819419861, -0.38061997294425964, -1.246788740158081, -0.5389492511749268, -0.1089346781373024, -0.031161891296505928, 0.06067493185400963, -0.7115924954414368, 0.4070270359516144, -0.04918059706687927, -0.37257471680641174, -0.8345739841461182, -0.4330204427242279, -0.1578163057565689, -0.06210043653845787, -0.4898075461387634, 0.17262296378612518, 0.20393840968608856, -0.21080267429351807, -0.3944636285305023, -0.47967445850372314, 0.09655621647834778, 0.1608894020318985, 0.21854539215564728, 0.8808907270431519, -0.3120129704475403, 0.007453895639628172, 0.18746469914913177, 0.6152520179748535, 0.055007703602313995, 0.07676655054092407, 0.39262479543685913, 0.2200838029384613, -0.24589860439300537, 1.0010223388671875, -0.5528580546379089, 0.5469141006469727, -0.9065736532211304, 0.36200791597366333, -0.002164379460737109, 0.48888978362083435, -0.6115298867225647, -0.3559441864490509, 0.012135102413594723, -0.5649951696395874, 0.2847725450992584, 0.6733120083808899, 0.22423015534877777, 0.6089968085289001, -0.21451421082019806, 0.026363976299762726, -0.5554150342941284, 0.3003784418106079, 0.15241606533527374, -0.4449871778488159, 0.6749387979507446, 0.4712791442871094, -0.6097622513771057, -0.20964163541793823, 0.2356301099061966, 0.34088683128356934, -0.46943050622940063, 0.522554874420166, 0.029834533110260963, 0.3790452778339386, 0.11586831510066986, 0.024516645818948746, -1.0637397766113281, 0.7395651936531067, -0.3132559657096863, 0.5046296119689941, 0.5251743197441101, -0.22249752283096313, 0.4505920112133026, -0.7769115567207336, 0.3010580837726593, 0.8375637531280518, 0.2943126857280731, 0.49553170800209045, 0.4667303264141083, 0.016962356865406036, 0.10833234339952469, 0.11665493249893188, -0.2394883632659912, -0.29851680994033813, -0.06796372681856155, 0.26386579871177673, -0.29518505930900574, 0.3781259059906006, -0.7289217114448547, 0.07179111987352371, -0.9524277448654175, -0.23573417961597443, 0.2849416434764862, -0.21727429330348969, -0.2858911454677582, 0.605820894241333, -0.12198711931705475, 0.12178243696689606, -0.43491971492767334, -0.8548307418823242, 0.23491615056991577, -0.2709093689918518, -0.17142370343208313, 0.2692324221134186, -0.11419206112623215, 0.6601616144180298, -0.29933616518974304, -0.04551079124212265, 0.07348502427339554, 0.01793367601931095, 0.09483703225851059, -0.25151994824409485, -0.42020371556282043, -0.328995019197464, 0.039509136229753494, 0.3220245838165283, -0.3183943033218384, 0.3537284731864929, -0.2883443236351013, -0.42239728569984436, -0.1362314373254776, 0.15424460172653198, -0.09470901638269424, 0.5385050773620605, -0.6635206341743469, 0.48297441005706787, -0.32377520203590393, 0.6324278116226196, -0.7809268236160278, 0.36220744252204895, -0.3927459716796875, -0.32167890667915344, -0.35433855652809143, 0.6195534467697144, -0.7818349599838257, -0.12392779439687729, -1.3553482294082642, -0.20358037948608398, 0.48609989881515503, 0.43551045656204224, -0.12432125955820084, -0.47297102212905884, -0.3396296203136444, -0.268557608127594, 0.4209177792072296, -0.04887336120009422, 0.02378474362194538, 0.11673886328935623, 0.06960057467222214, 0.5152278542518616, 0.8045899868011475, 0.04101267829537392, 0.5636870265007019, 0.11681810766458511, -0.6792798638343811, 1.0701122283935547, -0.42534276843070984, -0.3851633071899414, 0.42810434103012085, 0.5360446572303772, 0.6979286670684814, -0.34165892004966736, -0.20921668410301208, 0.8347724676132202, 0.1202324703335762, 0.25424614548683167, 0.7632513642311096, 0.47586965560913086, 0.22770746052265167, 0.609634518623352, 0.18445566296577454, 0.11058208346366882, 0.1552281379699707, -0.12153845280408859, 0.8647175431251526, -0.1316298097372055, -0.11164533346891403, 0.5086231827735901, -0.30261239409446716, 0.4161449074745178, -0.5217310786247253, 0.614414632320404, -0.5611903667449951, 0.15093396604061127, -0.09429697692394257, -0.06468658894300461, -0.6828458905220032, -0.3346986472606659, 0.12452902644872665, 0.036206673830747604, -0.10044542700052261, -0.8497487306594849, 0.1273660957813263, -0.103017657995224, -0.17705070972442627, -0.42277851700782776, -0.10920848697423935, 0.8968181610107422, 0.44483545422554016, 0.10550319403409958, -0.05192739516496658, 0.27166762948036194, -1.0475280284881592, 0.10164430737495422, -0.33744436502456665, 0.11454354971647263, -0.5228609442710876, 0.5185081958770752, 0.5948663353919983, -0.8984795808792114, 0.9516611695289612, -0.3161748945713043, -0.23065240681171417, 0.4923058748245239, -0.5080317258834839, 0.8462316393852234, 0.3293653726577759, 0.05316450074315071, -0.6155544519424438, 0.24669866263866425, -0.9063265919685364, 0.14733652770519257, -0.1692793071269989, -0.19843877851963043, 0.7071496248245239, 0.11528357118368149, 0.567327082157135, -0.27072352170944214, -0.23678816854953766, -0.2760612666606903, 0.39697182178497314, -0.5100674033164978, -0.0889880433678627, 0.6222883462905884, 0.13037432730197906, -0.20845147967338562, -0.8630344867706299, 0.6498374342918396, 0.2981779873371124, -0.3962014615535736, 0.8951922059059143, -0.06337647885084152, -0.4615084230899811, -0.16025568544864655, -0.4341064393520355, -0.03451840579509735, -0.4991845488548279, 0.736129879951477, 0.8002201318740845, 0.08852639049291611, 0.1975322663784027, -0.4780173599720001, -0.5536953210830688, 0.012146997265517712, 0.30498969554901123, -0.915337860584259, 0.16848425567150116, 0.5395050048828125, 0.15509197115898132, -0.2765669822692871, 0.4450792968273163, -0.9108482003211975, -0.054131731390953064, 0.07964123785495758, -0.25022757053375244, 0.8657661080360413, -0.011557362973690033, -0.05621248111128807, -0.12288541346788406, -0.025500498712062836, 0.8995009660720825, 0.338856965303421, 0.12877173721790314, 0.20053508877754211, 0.6042703986167908, 0.40644964575767517, 0.555619478225708, -0.4653303027153015, 0.7037829756736755, -0.0647905245423317, -0.3249683082103729, 0.16344888508319855, -0.8089957237243652, 0.3801308572292328, 0.37271252274513245, -0.12485431134700775, 0.16153982281684875, 0.2783057987689972, -0.5213497281074524, -0.02691984549164772, -0.9057572484016418, 0.04296537861227989, -0.18600942194461823, 0.34206897020339966, 0.027498465031385422, -0.047472961246967316, -0.4011346399784088, -0.7419341802597046, 0.11430944502353668, -0.2381385713815689, 0.7037308812141418, -0.3705814778804779, 0.5827726721763611, -0.4442683458328247, -0.20017845928668976, 0.1837397664785385, -0.4375116229057312, 0.3413473963737488, 0.19680041074752808, 0.2941356301307678, 0.9583734273910522, -0.2284182906150818, -0.16112449765205383, -0.3710979223251343, 1.2174372673034668, 0.5045355558395386, 0.8698005676269531, 0.46508023142814636, -0.21882331371307373, -0.0725499764084816, -0.3727132976055145, -0.7315281629562378, -0.21392998099327087, 0.07945844531059265, 0.047218114137649536, -0.8157232403755188, -0.28989994525909424, -0.21132738888263702, 0.7881942987442017, -0.014020705595612526, 0.32947203516960144, 0.01260427851229906, 0.7146511077880859, 0.554106593132019, 0.34203270077705383, 0.4598703980445862, -0.3169933557510376, -0.08786484599113464, -0.619607150554657, 0.1970217525959015, 0.3364558517932892, 0.00897403247654438, -0.5064144730567932, -0.23257412016391754, -0.018492665141820908, -0.634051501750946, 0.3376843333244324, -0.13398832082748413, -0.5202350616455078, 0.7358839511871338, 0.39218470454216003, 0.6685665249824524, -0.2537437677383423, -0.1634504497051239, 0.7765769958496094, 0.8665845394134521, 0.30221930146217346, -0.36498644948005676, 0.5213783383369446, 0.06835278123617172, 0.32177406549453735, 0.5255221724510193, -0.6158097386360168, -1.0079177618026733, -0.43451830744743347, 0.31428849697113037, -1.1217937469482422, -0.476676344871521, 0.7205410003662109, -0.06658927351236343, -0.21992994844913483, 0.21920402348041534, 0.09474790841341019, 0.5296990871429443, -0.6902668476104736, -0.988781213760376, -0.4483484923839569, -0.012612768448889256, 0.26010650396347046, 0.5918269753456116, -0.48194894194602966, -0.7730134725570679, -0.27268800139427185, -0.22936700284481049, 0.06415309011936188, -0.5422175526618958, -0.7325038909912109, 0.2576133608818054, 0.16219462454319, -0.6229196786880493, 0.5936678647994995, 0.03907652199268341, -0.3135460913181305, -0.010825328528881073, -0.20286992192268372, 0.4290913939476013, -0.736130952835083, 0.12952274084091187, -0.15716449916362762, 0.8612819910049438, 0.5764017701148987, 0.39792394638061523, 0.19121909141540527, -0.0761774480342865, -0.24118320643901825, -0.0019540200009942055, 0.30388298630714417, 0.0884946808218956, -0.542417585849762, -0.34795546531677246, 0.20642824470996857, -0.5270001888275146, -0.22493678331375122, 0.07102217525243759, -0.18069535493850708, 1.1390280723571777, 0.00827561691403389, -0.4291246831417084, -0.2883078455924988, -0.3658279478549957, -0.8284505605697632, 0.6751339435577393, -0.4347991347312927, -0.38742420077323914, 0.10480065643787384, 0.009367112070322037, -0.23139914870262146, -0.13336579501628876, -0.6846692562103271, -0.37451493740081787, 0.5622172355651855, 0.3349039554595947, 0.18784268200397491, 0.9509109258651733, -0.14479738473892212, 0.6761600375175476, -0.7577825784683228, 0.44830211997032166, 0.3535759150981903, -0.31116655468940735, -0.7059454321861267, -0.19032710790634155, -0.19544541835784912, -0.7134314179420471, -0.20408125221729279, 0.2156606763601303, 0.2632952034473419, 0.8198909163475037, -0.2814101576805115, 0.19326436519622803, -0.39115193486213684, 0.49355846643447876, -0.07914403080940247, -0.4821816086769104, 0.30025169253349304, 1.297438144683838, -0.1030890941619873, 0.31766584515571594, 0.1856483668088913, -0.7326390147209167, 0.2597711682319641, -0.008508311584591866, 0.7268673777580261, -1.0294631719589233, -0.5074989795684814, -0.09693490713834763, -0.2919605076313019, 0.18133068084716797, 0.3098776042461395, 0.16802772879600525, -0.1999393254518509, -0.4705289602279663, -0.3616436719894409, -0.2049793004989624, -0.08728408068418503, 0.050351183861494064, -0.5532313585281372, -0.2952348589897156, -0.9683748483657837, 0.38986334204673767, -0.43211454153060913, 0.4858300983905792, 0.8412859439849854, -0.2694495618343353, -0.003100140020251274, 0.2817809283733368, 0.17474663257598877, 0.21879491209983826, -0.05271035432815552, 0.6786985993385315, 0.09288565814495087, 0.5907087922096252, -0.6041257977485657, -0.0472739040851593, -0.822692334651947, 1.0493611097335815, -0.5300729870796204, -0.7599902749061584, -0.1408378928899765, 0.30173569917678833, 0.5104349255561829, -0.5816765427589417, 0.3541989028453827, 0.26792216300964355, -0.049073681235313416, 0.691417396068573, 0.1990727335214615, -0.8515319228172302, -0.48262444138526917, -0.5592502355575562, -1.1679198741912842, 0.254252552986145, -0.012516451999545097, 0.09519696980714798, -0.6047601103782654, -0.2667662799358368, 0.2280309498310089, -0.4167642295360565, -0.05489077419042587, 0.6246895790100098, 0.1362827569246292, 0.10262274742126465, -0.480165958404541, -0.3786763548851013, -0.10161388665437698, 0.09229779988527298, -0.17509417235851288, -0.676009476184845, -0.5256310701370239, 0.3885524570941925, 0.2730697989463806, -1.1573028564453125, 0.0019953574519604445, 0.58851158618927, 0.09363660961389542, -0.2092922031879425, 0.7920793294906616, -0.8155383467674255, -0.1291871815919876, 0.026416003704071045, -0.09622657299041748, 0.10658875852823257, 0.3308798670768738, 0.4356268644332886, 0.23342804610729218, 0.1418222337961197, -0.22394758462905884, 0.5558454990386963, -0.4573186933994293, -0.47596436738967896, 0.22803722321987152, -0.45743024349212646, -0.004730284679681063, 1.0506805181503296, -0.17635680735111237, -0.8435186147689819, -0.03376399353146553, -0.42983323335647583, -0.5168126821517944, -0.036964692175388336, -0.04130108281970024, -0.18033334612846375, -0.4615989923477173, 0.16112323105335236, 0.19714808464050293, 0.7080851197242737, 0.1104845181107521, 0.07536523789167404, 0.03911522403359413, -0.3933059573173523, 0.03558054193854332, -0.2529051601886749, 1.2882589101791382, -0.08354146033525467, -0.5822495222091675, -0.4853266477584839, -0.18418379127979279, -0.18950620293617249, -0.22829578816890717, 0.2821708917617798, -0.12378335744142532, 0.13390596210956573, 0.3534572720527649, 0.3827216327190399, 0.37109658122062683, 0.39507871866226196, 0.11282897740602493, -0.06016125902533531, 0.395486980676651, -0.733352780342102, -0.0750548392534256, -0.3143628239631653, 0.1630832403898239, 0.6686609387397766, -0.568726658821106, -0.12325127422809601, 0.11689303815364838, -0.8173809051513672, -0.9605754017829895, -1.1789500713348389, -0.20564232766628265, -1.2727246284484863, -0.49707934260368347, -1.0499974489212036, -0.34921592473983765, -0.061892297118902206, 0.43592771887779236, -0.2849785089492798, 0.25939589738845825, -1.3981531858444214, 0.1075737252831459, 0.2532472312450409, 0.10274310410022736, -0.3690376579761505, -0.7766495943069458, -0.4660658538341522, -0.8160513043403625, 0.010931899771094322, -0.31076696515083313, -0.05157911777496338, -0.2192719578742981, -0.2716998755931854, 0.2025933563709259, -0.7862164378166199, 0.6846413612365723, -0.6067538857460022, -0.8029913306236267, 0.2009904831647873, -0.006454948335886002, -0.8181349635124207, 0.5686911940574646, 0.5617357492446899, 0.26524463295936584, 0.44142600893974304, -0.35057660937309265, -0.11367035657167435, -0.23259790241718292, -0.7545520067214966, -0.04115883260965347, -0.4774942398071289, -0.20374718308448792, -0.2583874464035034, -0.6559845209121704, 0.5242629647254944, 0.5023822784423828, -0.6085752248764038, 0.10303483158349991, -0.26774829626083374, 0.032271213829517365, -0.08112300932407379, 0.055906154215335846, -0.3262281119823456, 0.02031206712126732, -0.45681658387184143, 0.8048710227012634, -0.625777006149292, 0.03866737708449364, -0.04922466725111008, -0.10734184086322784, -0.242420494556427, 0.6717236042022705, 0.07900391519069672, -0.31899508833885193, -0.09874188154935837, -0.03264465928077698, -0.29726552963256836, 0.2119336873292923, -0.4731661379337311, -0.07596424221992493, -0.6831811666488647, -0.48312363028526306, -0.9628273844718933, 0.30217763781547546, 0.9849782586097717, -0.598045825958252, -0.14572319388389587, -0.3646009862422943, -0.636727511882782, 0.09470426291227341, -0.7083892822265625, -0.16624552011489868, -0.5765376687049866, 0.14742465317249298, 0.282680481672287, -0.3223104178905487, 0.30401021242141724, 0.12526154518127441, 0.05367902293801308, 0.6716912984848022, -0.7923370599746704, -0.07586180418729782, -0.1830819994211197, 0.5069758892059326, -0.783368706703186, 0.19542807340621948, -0.47814494371414185, 0.8494812250137329, -0.6926488876342773, -0.533390462398529, -0.632673978805542, -0.37216347455978394, -0.2599295377731323, 0.1140904575586319, -0.22903777658939362, -0.1514085829257965, 0.22077104449272156, 0.3435204327106476, -0.2393810749053955, -0.203970268368721, -0.7154092788696289, 0.4337644577026367, 0.000009220093488693237, -0.5198653340339661, 0.49438410997390747, -0.11370640248060226, -0.17322342097759247, -0.5876169800758362, -0.22237160801887512, 0.792158305644989, 0.07677177339792252, -0.32511186599731445, 1.0035003423690796, 0.0918421745300293, 0.15780183672904968, 0.2120688259601593, -0.4251176118850708, -0.3082737326622009, 0.22395531833171844, 0.3930737376213074, 0.5980976223945618, 0.8523467183113098, 0.16836640238761902, 0.39502936601638794, 0.4523142874240875, 0.25975698232650757, 0.19458025693893433, 0.6128374934196472, 0.07423955947160721, 0.8000032901763916, -0.14773045480251312, 0.2954576313495636, 0.03789889067411423, 0.5959529280662537, 0.1656925231218338, 0.021453412249684334, -0.08224598318338394, 0.4438560903072357, 0.2673892676830292, 0.11400759965181351, -0.25653284788131714, -0.043759074062108994, -0.5911756753921509, -0.5275242924690247, 0.2729772925376892, 0.10517759621143341, -0.09070830047130585, 0.24639160931110382, 0.5919307470321655, 0.4111698567867279, 0.3175184428691864, 0.82142573595047, 0.485745370388031, 0.7296327352523804, -0.11063853651285172, 0.8522240519523621, 0.6754469275474548, 0.27013731002807617, 0.2829064726829529, -0.6751932501792908, 0.3643774092197418, 0.4683399200439453, -1.9131684303283691, -0.018573500216007233, -0.8219279646873474, 0.17234466969966888, 0.4311699867248535, -0.8682998418807983, 0.41993197798728943, -0.14254824817180634, 0.2620893716812134, 0.7231786847114563, 0.17178677022457123, 0.06594742089509964, 0.6908247470855713, -0.46912309527397156, 0.4871002435684204, 0.34678035974502563, -0.15502645075321198, -0.005202552303671837, 0.6001107692718506, 1.530661940574646, -0.053743790835142136, 0.6364933848381042, 0.19434882700443268, 0.025516677647829056, 0.6037135124206543, 0.8877699971199036, -0.3940926492214203, 0.35587066411972046, -0.7890645265579224, 0.007506979629397392, 0.14504091441631317, 0.4442666172981262, -0.3622080981731415, 0.44833001494407654, 0.17232435941696167, 0.30509456992149353, -0.46168601512908936, -0.35993409156799316, 0.8758619427680969, 0.15665259957313538, -0.4606054127216339, -1.0068705081939697, -0.42811450362205505, 0.20365582406520844, -0.0023765431251376867, -0.5567446351051331, 0.39502084255218506, -0.21792426705360413, -0.014583093114197254, 0.1519843190908432, -1.0165091753005981, -0.36221006512641907, -1.0338633060455322, -0.07832363247871399, -0.4844290018081665, 0.5147468447685242, 0.32557061314582825, 0.15792351961135864, 0.22051946818828583, -0.8460677266120911, -0.3141177296638489, 0.19196178019046783, 1.093717098236084, 0.12554354965686798, -0.06044525280594826, 0.285148024559021, 0.32959768176078796, -0.5673882365226746, 0.9959030747413635, 0.7265331149101257, -0.8610961437225342, 1.2839241027832031, -0.6865552067756653, 0.18215465545654297, 0.3539276123046875, 0.0498884841799736, 0.03150278702378273, 0.03752569481730461, 0.8530886769294739, -0.34309765696525574, -0.5046801567077637, -0.27850407361984253, -0.833004355430603, 0.12506097555160522, -0.8732174634933472, 0.35766324400901794, -0.18386520445346832, 0.1592237502336502, -0.09578096121549606, -0.3212421238422394, 4.328904628753662, 0.9282479286193848, 0.544224739074707, 0.27744799852371216, 0.5949039459228516, 1.0027673244476318, -0.26299288868904114, -0.5206109285354614, 0.09696020931005478, -0.6819759607315063, -0.11262593418359756, -0.17629364132881165, 0.47016260027885437, -0.13808991014957428, -0.41533273458480835, 1.1411514282226562, -0.36896878480911255, 0.488009512424469, 0.12147220969200134, -0.6725502014160156, -0.8650743961334229, 0.13097958266735077, 0.5035332441329956, 0.1301487535238266, -0.2180044800043106, 0.24249517917633057, 0.06532981246709824, -1.106650471687317, -0.7514607906341553, -0.0489361546933651, -0.8807041645050049, -0.5768248438835144, 0.7912482619285583, -0.09124627709388733, -0.883293867111206, 0.5263991355895996, 0.16505195200443268, -0.08285167813301086, 0.517758309841156, 0.04854300245642662, -0.33018139004707336, -0.18549758195877075, 0.3007802963256836, 0.016862550750374794, -0.7237056493759155, 0.6928301453590393, -0.49793556332588196, 0.9444171190261841, 0.5174320936203003, -0.1657842993736267, 0.2590042054653168, 0.10371200740337372, 0.20792324841022491, 0.12149673700332642, -0.8133321404457092, 0.1983959823846817, 0.2359614372253418, 0.06571369618177414, -0.24324190616607666, -0.07005756348371506, 0.8171370029449463, -0.12564803659915924, -0.1843041032552719, -0.16371527314186096, 0.06546561419963837, 0.8211219906806946, 0.49011003971099854, 0.636242687702179, -0.11878585070371628, -0.02027701586484909, -0.03914868086576462, -0.40580207109451294, -0.32532674074172974, -0.35162824392318726, 0.4604128301143646, 0.05453573167324066, -0.3334001898765564, 0.6837167739868164, 0.17036764323711395, -0.0375189408659935, 0.07888654619455338, -0.49717187881469727, -0.6907155513763428, 0.4378502368927002, -0.15738430619239807, 1.0190922021865845, 0.0743226408958435, -0.23271098732948303, -0.3996155261993408, 0.4800756573677063, 0.3823995292186737, 1.5282275676727295, -0.00405918899923563, 0.18042905628681183, -0.8801780343055725 ]
Twisted Boundary Conditions and the Adiabatic Ground State for the Attractive XXZ Luttinger Liquid
The one-dimensional attractive lattice fermion gas equivalent to the Heisenberg-Ising spin 1/2 chain is studied for a ring geometry threaded by magnetic flux. We find that for charged fermions having interaction strength $\Delta=\cos(\pi / p)$ with $p$ {\it noninteger}, the adiabatic ground state is periodic in the magnetic flux threading the chain, with period 2 flux quanta, as found by Shastry and Sutherland for the repulsive case. We find that, at particular values of the threading field, a sequence of initially zero-energy bound states form at the Fermi surface during the adiabatic process, the largest containing $[p]$ (the integer part of $p$) fermions. This largest bound state moves around to the other Fermi point and sequentially unbinds. We find Berry's Phase for the whole process to be $[p] \pi$. For $p$ {\it integer}, as $\Phi$ increases, eventually all the particles in the system go into bound states of size $[p]$. The period in this case is of order the size of the system.
Naichang Yu and Michael Fowler
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206002
cond-mat/9206003
[ 0.01982194371521473, 0.15552562475204468, 0.0008379172068089247, 0.7268112897872925, -0.49439606070518494, -0.03623552247881889, -0.22273333370685577, -0.27397382259368896, -0.6606276631355286, 1.6817235946655273, 0.8528497815132141, -0.4083333909511566, 0.6595463156700134, -1.4975122213363647, -0.3664405941963196, 0.22954674065113068, -0.6376516222953796, -0.6106402277946472, -1.2417875528335571, -0.08231735229492188, 0.052312158048152924, -0.1613267958164215, -0.9982356429100037, -0.6532818078994751, -0.30615514516830444, 0.2984395921230316, -0.34033694863319397, 0.6377415657043457, 0.6025506258010864, 0.35849466919898987, 0.8754013180732727, -0.77836674451828, 0.00134369102306664, -0.7034012079238892, -0.05481235310435295, 0.6861616969108582, 0.016136474907398224, 0.16831158101558685, 0.7876665592193604, 0.05416150391101837, 0.9543843865394592, -0.2712585926055908, 0.08903206139802933, 0.2032359540462494, 0.2365885078907013, -0.24543124437332153, -0.5901081562042236, -0.45433467626571655, -0.6991932392120361, -1.637438416481018, -0.20898555219173431, 0.05320551618933678, 1.010067105293274, 0.32391899824142456, 0.1685778796672821, -0.27198269963264465, -0.1432005763053894, -0.24891000986099243, -0.04121148958802223, -0.2836085855960846, 0.2262134850025177, -0.5067703723907471, 0.5130237936973572, -0.6159284710884094, 0.1672426164150238, 0.24536487460136414, -0.016983620822429657, 1.2903159856796265, -0.19694799184799194, -0.06011700630187988, -0.4517861604690552, 0.17642676830291748, -0.09921536594629288, -0.12977467477321625, -0.6466713547706604, 0.2553344666957855, 0.1866956353187561, -0.8591950535774231, -1.3428949117660522, 0.14399588108062744, -0.24293993413448334, -0.22317738831043243, -0.026823466643691063, 0.37238046526908875, -0.13847075402736664, -0.4118545353412628, -0.4821208715438843, -0.2996329665184021, -0.4781547784805298, 0.14985577762126923, 0.40933987498283386, 0.9144105315208435, -0.18976318836212158, -0.027357598766684532, 0.44033652544021606, 0.4751617908477783, 0.29773861169815063, 0.1405225694179535, 0.23501746356487274, 0.32295235991477966, 0.28074008226394653, 0.3196597397327423, -1.0480600595474243, 0.6634820699691772, -0.14177027344703674, 0.8275576829910278, -0.10435756295919418, 0.2732585370540619, 0.5028728246688843, -0.6067244410514832, -0.041367076337337494, -0.05781550705432892, 0.3920243978500366, 0.7352182865142822, -0.4972083866596222, 1.1003574132919312, -0.024156102910637856, 0.13523007929325104, -0.7307020425796509, -0.48114416003227234, 0.1864163726568222, 0.27701056003570557, 1.2482398748397827, 0.6066135168075562, -0.018358809873461723, -0.09331127256155014, 0.7152537703514099, 0.5832927227020264, -0.46040821075439453, -0.3722403347492218, 0.3554356098175049, 0.1904139369726181, 0.16293685138225555, 1.0430912971496582, -0.7130897045135498, 0.45300954580307007, -0.3266642391681671, 0.4043128192424774, 0.3394586443901062, 0.06628039479255676, 0.5071415305137634, -0.5009661316871643, 0.10223884880542755, 0.9758532643318176, -0.5818201899528503, 0.1251436322927475, 0.5561463832855225, -0.04828241467475891, -0.13593381643295288, 0.23585128784179688, -0.8848051428794861, 0.1108071431517601, -0.2982215881347656, 0.4357285797595978, -0.30607399344444275, 0.11350001394748688, 0.057578254491090775, -0.010687514208257198, 0.05317409709095955, -0.6190652847290039, 0.10716967284679413, -0.014656209386885166, 0.24941618740558624, -0.013880960643291473, -0.6086944341659546, 0.03629345819354057, -0.6017241477966309, -0.3810628354549408, 0.8768839836120605, -0.23833662271499634, -0.6757519841194153, 0.42164847254753113, -0.35231316089630127, 0.6365434527397156, 0.13013747334480286, 0.27235984802246094, 0.782771646976471, -0.030693750828504562, 0.21131306886672974, -0.37938356399536133, 0.38714799284935, 0.22143669426441193, 0.7339946031570435, -0.10957188904285431, 0.4015696942806244, 0.45305126905441284, -0.3751450479030609, -0.3445805013179779, -0.10083221644163132, 0.18031178414821625, -0.14044174551963806, -0.28920671343803406, 0.027388598769903183, -0.06265730410814285, -0.197179913520813, -0.21491578221321106, -0.8848532438278198, 0.3681422472000122, -0.4597180187702179, -0.33325520157814026, -0.4565746486186981, 0.06113174930214882, -1.0627732276916504, 0.8263843655586243, -0.989668607711792, -0.27330872416496277, 0.4202214479446411, 0.44503849744796753, -0.36525458097457886, 0.10679525882005692, 0.22872169315814972, 0.17342045903205872, -0.17147667706012726, 0.44661104679107666, 0.5680007338523865, 0.40087422728538513, -0.5410400629043579, 0.711943507194519, 0.5671276450157166, 0.4017413258552551, 0.16156448423862457, 0.0604483000934124, -0.25098147988319397, 0.8383432626724243, -0.021688126027584076, -0.5193673968315125, 0.45198267698287964, 0.2852318584918976, 0.48816797137260437, -0.4029816687107086, -0.2743229568004608, 0.5615788698196411, -0.3429872989654541, 0.5614925026893616, 0.588223397731781, -0.022036418318748474, 0.2927880883216858, 0.6798363924026489, 0.3372519314289093, 0.05195559561252594, -0.48848414421081543, -0.22354969382286072, -0.05019395425915718, -0.010635355487465858, 0.22740671038627625, -0.6253343224525452, -0.7436872124671936, 0.0241477619856596, -0.3378323018550873, 0.17006756365299225, -0.21180789172649384, -0.1526322066783905, 0.034105945378541946, 0.25881868600845337, -0.9919293522834778, -0.20681564509868622, 0.08990860730409622, -0.0034528705291450024, -0.29891183972358704, 0.47338950634002686, 0.04883037880063057, -0.1719357818365097, -0.13943535089492798, -0.42131632566452026, 0.40824905037879944, 0.6286528706550598, -0.044073354452848434, 0.3835257589817047, 0.10056652128696442, 0.013273579068481922, -1.4094501733779907, -0.38796675205230713, -0.3542609214782715, -0.13889014720916748, -0.7408408522605896, 0.32007861137390137, 0.7784585356712341, -1.4189462661743164, 0.6031754016876221, -0.28438159823417664, -0.043480034917593, 0.7766324281692505, -0.5604807138442993, 0.7368516325950623, 0.14897394180297852, 0.6186739802360535, -0.37473437190055847, 0.416640967130661, -0.23218034207820892, 0.4861525595188141, -0.4026201665401459, 0.00744091160595417, 1.0014081001281738, -0.7046281099319458, 0.6793671250343323, -0.3911602795124054, 0.06330100446939468, 0.04331125691533089, 0.12913261353969574, -0.2807096242904663, -0.2962562143802643, 0.1833498477935791, -0.08465012162923813, -0.5992716550827026, -0.5574677586555481, 0.4745355546474457, -0.15520720183849335, -0.5074349641799927, 0.3543466031551361, -0.05535099282860756, -1.2200040817260742, 0.4007719159126282, -0.23027518391609192, -0.014796992763876915, -0.04408722743391991, 0.7135772705078125, 0.5512089133262634, 0.1393052488565445, -0.3219008147716522, -0.982890784740448, -0.4202773869037628, 0.5516459941864014, -0.10147664695978165, -0.5671806931495667, -0.1259968876838684, 0.8209749460220337, 0.10065300762653351, -0.05044390633702278, 0.10298686474561691, -1.3299224376678467, 0.25440701842308044, 0.24999311566352844, -0.2931269705295563, 1.126362919807434, -0.3540317416191101, -0.33102700114250183, -0.40092432498931885, -0.34028926491737366, 1.0374860763549805, 0.18632929027080536, 0.46229758858680725, -0.5913188457489014, 0.9867828488349915, 0.6994844079017639, 0.11145752668380737, -0.0349823534488678, -0.1251819133758545, -0.24281513690948486, -0.8241921067237854, 0.23727838695049286, -0.6819198131561279, 0.07331859320402145, 0.621438205242157, 0.23153914511203766, 0.3383636772632599, 1.1081382036209106, -0.5755376815795898, -1.1030949354171753, -0.3611131012439728, 0.024553222581744194, -0.24550963938236237, 1.0545860528945923, -0.10787315666675568, -0.251630038022995, -0.8015932440757751, -0.3613666296005249, -0.16492623090744019, -0.058144401758909225, 0.34999147057533264, -0.05897844210267067, -0.04197414219379425, -0.020823359489440918, -0.7816830277442932, 0.5259559154510498, -0.2721395492553711, 0.10922690480947495, 0.6462007164955139, 1.181007981300354, 0.6910247802734375, -0.34678396582603455, 0.009884906001389027, -0.058733195066452026, 1.3509846925735474, 0.5474703311920166, 0.8578739762306213, 1.019131064414978, -0.16142579913139343, 0.7412645816802979, -0.10842686891555786, -0.9974534511566162, 0.04168311133980751, -0.3058604300022125, -0.2547013759613037, -0.3867514729499817, 0.019067559391260147, 0.4214387834072113, 0.4928313195705414, -0.3022828996181488, 0.10525673627853394, 0.150619775056839, 0.5675370097160339, 0.9069358706474304, 0.7131131291389465, -0.07262157648801804, -0.7286397218704224, 0.014378943480551243, -0.405479371547699, -0.18565700948238373, -0.3662818670272827, -0.12716089189052582, -0.2098071128129959, -0.6248440742492676, -0.9281970262527466, -0.3476291596889496, 0.760345995426178, 0.607472836971283, -0.08127913624048233, 0.5976453423500061, 0.2915922999382019, 0.7335200905799866, -0.9260590672492981, -0.06116865575313568, 0.6605015397071838, 0.17441120743751526, 0.013624492101371288, -0.8919903039932251, 0.31045249104499817, -0.48560830950737, 0.9268168210983276, 0.597456693649292, -0.9286728501319885, -0.6687062382698059, -0.016743825748562813, 1.2624428272247314, -0.647432267665863, -0.5031813979148865, 0.7467204928398132, 0.9802875518798828, -0.0053254892118275166, -0.8424201011657715, -0.16387420892715454, 0.686002790927887, -0.7085776925086975, 0.20110303163528442, -0.5835453867912292, -0.18979181349277496, -0.2667132318019867, 0.5124837756156921, -0.12907271087169647, -0.49613824486732483, -0.12673340737819672, -0.364700049161911, -0.28958043456077576, -0.40252524614334106, -0.7182219624519348, -0.08266489952802658, -0.12631787359714508, -0.1744503676891327, 0.7393358945846558, 0.2978290319442749, -0.04821009188890457, -0.1320137083530426, -0.4262392520904541, -0.40952104330062866, -0.2953624725341797, -0.053093321621418, -0.5572312474250793, 0.7163692116737366, 0.5884928107261658, -0.171030655503273, 0.27847689390182495, 0.049945682287216187, -0.041195258498191833, -0.12188085168600082, 0.11583702266216278, -0.10116274654865265, -0.41102153062820435, -0.5782479047775269, -0.49004971981048584, -1.0719940662384033, -0.910477876663208, 0.4103092849254608, -0.13688775897026062, 0.4130370318889618, 0.4300294518470764, -0.6021980047225952, -0.10321112722158432, -0.20742474496364594, -0.9279108047485352, 0.6077136397361755, -0.4572221040725708, 0.4072202146053314, -0.24248285591602325, -0.2402106076478958, -0.36309492588043213, 0.07769911736249924, -0.4875265955924988, -0.7433862686157227, 0.5920603275299072, 0.42549002170562744, -0.032442331314086914, 0.00446073105558753, -0.6326562762260437, 0.7683187127113342, 0.05544009059667587, 0.486127644777298, -0.08412312716245651, 0.003821104299277067, -0.42723721265792847, -0.35950273275375366, 0.24916358292102814, 0.2133495807647705, -0.3169798254966736, -0.10652393102645874, 0.01593574695289135, 0.10566551983356476, 0.19589634239673615, 0.09044837206602097, -1.2008851766586304, 0.33661365509033203, 0.1979203075170517, -0.044563181698322296, 0.007464359514415264, 0.6357432007789612, -0.1594679355621338, 0.6802676320075989, 0.234900563955307, -1.0648565292358398, 0.6377682089805603, 0.034845367074012756, 0.4764275848865509, -1.100514531135559, 0.24526850879192352, -0.5601829886436462, 0.31753939390182495, 0.4089924991130829, 0.6739429831504822, 0.05771098658442497, 0.31420204043388367, -0.12856604158878326, -0.00043099105823785067, -0.15338677167892456, -0.07664405554533005, 0.004060864914208651, -0.3279881477355957, -0.2627163231372833, -0.7842361330986023, 0.6614922881126404, -0.5163228511810303, 0.2231433093547821, 0.35576367378234863, -0.32001355290412903, 0.16070492565631866, 0.15960179269313812, 0.5277221202850342, -0.09885480999946594, -0.1788335144519806, 0.5110424160957336, -0.4393126666545868, -0.024746496230363846, -0.8511710166931152, 0.5162351131439209, -1.41765296459198, 0.6751769781112671, -0.0025002704933285713, -0.3136831223964691, -0.14145120978355408, 0.7080550789833069, 0.36875471472740173, -0.4501895308494568, 0.1415151208639145, 0.1344008594751358, 0.12347640842199326, 0.4501844644546509, 0.7468355298042297, -0.5302982926368713, -0.42546534538269043, -0.7154342532157898, -1.1182283163070679, 0.28987473249435425, 0.1822638362646103, -0.39677825570106506, -0.4512045681476593, -0.40983372926712036, -0.5422914624214172, -0.24578185379505157, 0.4132596552371979, 0.7608838081359863, 0.03497060760855675, 0.1503617763519287, 0.2482631951570511, 0.6595789194107056, 0.043153420090675354, -0.13721370697021484, 0.09240642189979553, -0.3754895031452179, 0.3095635771751404, 0.69462651014328, -0.6452226638793945, -0.6085045337677002, -0.25759947299957275, 0.12612269818782806, 0.22983820736408234, -0.035719335079193115, 0.7815496921539307, -0.24007417261600494, 0.1299130916595459, 0.019421562552452087, 0.051674842834472656, 0.16500569880008698, 0.092672199010849, 0.6750284433364868, -0.002848760923370719, -0.14496052265167236, -0.05196857824921608, 0.08561303466558456, -0.42574480175971985, -0.0007838043384253979, 0.07184000313282013, -0.8018602132797241, -0.6469248533248901, 0.8308150172233582, 0.22062738239765167, -0.7527490258216858, -0.024578528478741646, -0.5541165471076965, -0.3076789975166321, -0.023840775713324547, -0.15818078815937042, 0.23717741668224335, -0.4618968665599823, -0.6504032015800476, 0.2831602096557617, 0.6322546601295471, 0.15239135921001434, 0.8628650307655334, -0.11579820513725281, -0.12069174647331238, -0.7049030065536499, 0.24414746463298798, 1.282775640487671, -0.5956535935401917, -0.6493001580238342, -0.4792371690273285, 0.11881642043590546, -1.0978420972824097, -0.11912832409143448, 0.7421313524246216, -0.11109969019889832, 1.015776515007019, -0.0046607013791799545, 0.2763524353504181, 0.6137822866439819, 0.4154960513114929, -0.1789640635251999, 0.09422311186790466, 0.16615235805511475, -0.9996192455291748, -0.22434359788894653, -0.47180476784706116, 0.1024971455335617, 0.5400707721710205, -0.22136811912059784, 0.33053359389305115, -0.23013827204704285, -0.021663783118128777, -0.2979939877986908, -0.5698676705360413, 0.0750933364033699, -0.58476322889328, -0.5029012560844421, -0.4105212092399597, -0.041761260479688644, 0.14412082731723785, 0.5079895853996277, -0.4359085261821747, -0.27049699425697327, -0.4976736307144165, -0.020925909280776978, -0.2538556754589081, 0.4988478720188141, 0.33455875515937805, -0.35665786266326904, -0.5974701046943665, 0.049710214138031006, -0.14801472425460815, -0.16035272181034088, -0.3617191016674042, 0.012903537601232529, 0.2830067276954651, 0.7155181169509888, -0.7114361524581909, 0.7074328064918518, -0.7523708343505859, -0.45070680975914, -0.02076875790953636, 0.07185754925012589, -0.724433422088623, 0.21643441915512085, 0.48487910628318787, 0.008376809768378735, -0.2141007035970688, -0.010216224938631058, 0.42794281244277954, -0.29217538237571716, -0.6565324068069458, 0.06690747290849686, -0.15794919431209564, -0.07166352868080139, 0.19987809658050537, -0.5530353784561157, -0.058854203671216965, 0.8267849087715149, -0.7063096761703491, 0.22232012450695038, -0.8334382176399231, 0.12015925347805023, -0.5957004427909851, -0.10286594182252884, -0.7298942804336548, 0.04515351355075836, -0.4965180456638336, 0.831649661064148, 0.24190838634967804, -0.4393000602722168, 0.0013266445603221655, 0.5864545106887817, -0.31806427240371704, 0.48180437088012695, 0.17538903653621674, -0.11020500957965851, 0.18087229132652283, 0.3812951147556305, -0.32504984736442566, 0.8267129063606262, 0.22078897058963776, -0.34562087059020996, -0.8335157036781311, -0.26257115602493286, -0.9471817016601562, 0.05282961204648018, -0.23973588645458221, -0.629496693611145, 0.22347702085971832, -0.037183813750743866, -0.29420122504234314, 0.47528401017189026, -0.8028007745742798, -0.5974154472351074, -0.67430579662323, -0.5159631967544556, -0.8292737007141113, -0.38786837458610535, -0.14308151602745056, 0.7378202080726624, 0.09725012630224228, 0.1619659662246704, -0.16121314465999603, -0.02468719705939293, -0.34561029076576233, 0.3340645134449005, -1.025744915008545, 0.34911009669303894, -0.9991349577903748, 0.08930205553770065, -0.643826425075531, -0.6652976870536804, 0.15511645376682281, 1.2758255004882812, -0.16492319107055664, -0.19284984469413757, -0.7846174836158752, 0.0022557105403393507, -0.17775537073612213, -0.394339919090271, 0.21901603043079376, -0.7187725305557251, -0.40523484349250793, 0.6927099823951721, 0.038944412022829056, 0.09286203980445862, 0.2479628622531891, 0.6224640607833862, 0.2612167000770569, -0.4219758212566376, -0.37614116072654724, 0.9789698719978333, 0.4178605377674103, -0.7939174175262451, 0.9574609994888306, 0.09954748302698135, 0.533661425113678, 0.5679615139961243, -0.7831749320030212, -0.3899960219860077, 0.2677883803844452, 0.31142619252204895, 0.8333279490470886, 0.38603729009628296, 0.1322539895772934, 0.012875057756900787, -0.23166413605213165, -0.07478363811969757, 0.1396869719028473, 0.3614032566547394, -0.3420984447002411, 0.6834415793418884, -0.14722274243831635, 0.6426138877868652, 0.08451669663190842, 0.04465771093964577, 0.15489561855793, -0.5260665416717529, -0.09501110762357712, -0.08241921663284302, 0.2460026741027832, 0.10785321146249771, -0.93181973695755, 0.3926366865634918, -0.06742427498102188, -0.4945715367794037, 0.05790006369352341, 0.41494259238243103, -0.2838127315044403, 0.16956353187561035, 0.4026344120502472, 0.3997848331928253, 0.45402759313583374, 0.27211466431617737, -0.12647894024848938, 0.6671764850616455, 0.1806337833404541, 1.0890690088272095, 0.05527384206652641, 0.8547835946083069, -0.13660107553005219, -0.6126238107681274, 0.17380863428115845, 0.420246958732605, -1.230775237083435, 0.2438085675239563, -0.4125353991985321, -0.33349233865737915, -0.2717032730579376, -0.08087287098169327, 0.46740686893463135, -0.6397910714149475, -0.15742738544940948, 1.0472722053527832, -0.9309400916099548, 0.012727372348308563, 0.5786156058311462, -0.39605873823165894, -0.06258740276098251, 0.9221917390823364, 0.25103846192359924, -1.1029257774353027, 1.2126652002334595, 0.6249309778213501, 0.07651912420988083, 0.22811071574687958, 0.1364123672246933, -0.4889903664588928, -0.31366434693336487, -0.058281950652599335, -1.0725085735321045, 0.486605167388916, -0.6743316054344177, -0.4210417568683624, 0.2558734118938446, -0.16832952201366425, 0.0771341323852539, 0.1897963434457779, 0.17026972770690918, 0.029254181310534477, -0.22829210758209229, -0.0281035415828228, 1.1132498979568481, 0.7368375658988953, -0.55289626121521, -0.9524577260017395, -0.3975191116333008, 0.5050206184387207, -0.5195608139038086, -0.22886329889297485, 0.017166443169116974, 0.35361963510513306, -0.028474146500229836, 0.1780850887298584, 0.21590332686901093, -0.18488512933254242, -0.5309962034225464, -0.35648655891418457, -0.9985225200653076, -0.1992201954126358, -0.2639121413230896, 0.49967822432518005, 0.15574315190315247, -0.3019910156726837, 0.5831857919692993, -0.30256178975105286, 1.234696626663208, -0.08731476962566376, 0.4428059160709381, 0.1386210322380066, -0.08091754466295242, 0.30622780323028564, 0.8466188907623291, 0.4462481737136841, -1.2712736129760742, 0.8364714980125427, -0.7109358310699463, 0.33284270763397217, 0.7642778754234314, 0.25641950964927673, -0.14956329762935638, 0.36785629391670227, 0.038509488105773926, -0.3192330300807953, -0.01125757023692131, -0.35781535506248474, -1.0514707565307617, 0.27321353554725647, -0.3901602327823639, 0.09213003516197205, -0.3417375981807709, 0.27164578437805176, 0.8394240736961365, -0.5893100500106812, 4.192637920379639, 0.9895309805870056, 0.8043426275253296, -0.09277781844139099, 0.13325488567352295, 0.29307201504707336, -0.04462567716836929, -0.06141476705670357, 0.11995017528533936, -0.9791187047958374, 0.19703684747219086, 0.03619224205613136, 0.013838324695825577, -0.33937567472457886, -0.6005010604858398, 1.3643112182617188, -0.09176298975944519, 0.17635038495063782, -0.17574769258499146, -0.90287184715271, -0.3054872155189514, 0.05368245765566826, 0.2998773455619812, 0.24518486857414246, -0.11135357618331909, 0.4028970003128052, 0.09912867099046707, -0.029124027118086815, -0.6405758857727051, -0.40413352847099304, -1.1519006490707397, -0.648284375667572, 0.3283333480358124, -0.5607413649559021, -0.4189325273036957, 0.8178105354309082, 0.47578415274620056, 0.0931716039776802, 0.013410301879048347, -0.8253495097160339, -0.10399995744228363, -0.6977288722991943, 0.0045932745561003685, -0.0029109627939760685, -1.0201150178909302, 0.34887534379959106, -0.1492232382297516, 1.0458767414093018, 0.9569230079650879, -0.6890996098518372, 0.24820826947689056, -0.530238151550293, -0.03298003971576691, -0.024791203439235687, -0.7092651724815369, 0.19866324961185455, -0.5692283511161804, -0.12503445148468018, 0.20457203686237335, -0.21535152196884155, 1.0125014781951904, -0.14312075078487396, -0.17445653676986694, -0.6379700303077698, -0.020185615867376328, 0.7018073797225952, 0.8998801112174988, 0.19622425734996796, -0.061041492968797684, 0.05317099392414093, -0.32653218507766724, -0.284187376499176, -0.4449760317802429, 0.4034106135368347, 0.32350438833236694, -0.00825544260442257, 0.24974314868450165, 0.15719160437583923, 0.44089528918266296, -0.1726149618625641, 0.0910554900765419, 0.11545172333717346, -0.43206554651260376, 0.41024988889694214, -0.2550705373287201, 1.5870393514633179, -0.42761000990867615, -0.15634305775165558, 0.005579854361712933, 0.9462921023368835, 0.5650811791419983, 1.342031717300415, 0.37933480739593506, -0.13279421627521515, -1.1598180532455444 ]
Interactions for odd-omega gap singlet superconductors
A class of singlet superconductors with a gap function $\Delta({\bf k}, \omega_n)$ which is {\it odd} in both momentum and Matsubara frequency was proposed recently \cite{ba}. To show an instability in the {\it odd} gap channel, a model phonon propagator was used with the $p$-wave interaction strength larger than the $s$-wave. We argue that the positive scattering matrix element entering the Eliashberg equations leads to a constraint on the relative strength of $p$- and $s$-wave interactions which inhibits odd pairing. However, a general spin dependent electron-electron interaction can satisfy all constraints and produce the odd singlet gap. A possibility which may lead to an odd gap is a strongly antiferromagnetically correlated system, such as a high-$T_c$ material.
Elihu Abrahams(Rutgers), Alexander Balatsky(Los Alamos), J.R. Schrieffer(NHMFL), Philip B. Allen(SUNY)
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206003
cond-mat/9206004
[ 0.3155826926231384, 0.3576638400554657, 0.4110794961452484, -0.08545666933059692, 0.34741538763046265, -0.5943790674209595, -0.007859833538532257, -0.3720704913139343, -1.11658775806427, 1.7307854890823364, 0.7723321914672852, -0.2302110344171524, 0.7610360383987427, -0.859137237071991, 0.08250179886817932, 0.1702735722064972, -0.278696209192276, -1.2215101718902588, -0.13677802681922913, -0.03770060837268829, 0.2224780172109604, 0.059537433087825775, -1.0877127647399902, -0.9358665347099304, -0.11498760432004929, 0.5060516595840454, -0.7531542778015137, -0.05615588650107384, 1.405303716659546, 1.2172412872314453, 0.05476890504360199, -0.6842268705368042, -0.32306796312332153, -0.3162466883659363, -0.25679418444633484, -0.36657336354255676, 0.13059945404529572, 0.41915392875671387, 0.7888188362121582, -0.6635609269142151, 0.927142858505249, -0.002608679234981537, 0.8826544880867004, -0.37936392426490784, -0.8766706585884094, 0.035537734627723694, -0.20565514266490936, -0.051578719168901443, -0.08287891745567322, -1.0822758674621582, 0.23070114850997925, -0.00507403165102005, 0.12854766845703125, -0.3473634719848633, -0.4333367645740509, -0.518744707107544, 0.32953691482543945, 0.26593971252441406, -0.8158666491508484, -0.16596615314483643, 0.5827319622039795, -0.1665314882993698, 1.21318781375885, -0.9824399352073669, 0.4055372178554535, 0.6368213295936584, -0.5623024702072144, -0.0037449451629072428, 0.11302048712968826, -0.688774049282074, -0.9980849623680115, -0.9253838658332825, 0.13256625831127167, -0.12833186984062195, -0.502914309501648, 0.8128381967544556, 0.013479451648890972, -0.3792766332626343, -1.6327815055847168, -0.49532413482666016, -0.915040910243988, -0.21135874092578888, -0.24202723801136017, 0.34803298115730286, 0.05462644621729851, -0.04455122724175453, 0.19903059303760529, 0.010712274350225925, 0.2067205011844635, 0.5661917328834534, 0.5472666621208191, 1.2393920421600342, 0.5810564756393433, -0.4043232202529907, 0.11851996928453445, 1.253553867340088, 0.1260727345943451, 0.11962555348873138, 0.4891279637813568, -0.06446545571088791, -0.5833850502967834, 1.0283430814743042, -0.8803462386131287, 0.11803402006626129, -0.8075321912765503, 0.1369171142578125, 0.5571252703666687, -0.5021424889564514, -0.4695267081260681, -0.4424748420715332, -0.13054709136486053, 0.4800626337528229, 0.6088963150978088, 0.40679413080215454, -0.2323756217956543, 0.4457623064517975, -0.07750384509563446, 0.3661859929561615, -0.7697204351425171, -0.5263147354125977, -0.06381160020828247, 0.0899261087179184, -0.099952831864357, 0.13622026145458221, -0.06692533940076828, -0.20111429691314697, 0.32456064224243164, 1.0680543184280396, -0.7602640390396118, 0.284682035446167, -0.18007881939411163, -0.4551893174648285, 0.17750561237335205, 1.0702894926071167, 0.12619386613368988, 0.4208222031593323, -0.2583322525024414, 0.5021805763244629, 0.3391803205013275, -0.3054669499397278, 0.5174420475959778, -0.38639095425605774, 0.08600671589374542, 0.9440446496009827, 0.2508798837661743, -0.24920718371868134, 0.808021605014801, -0.5315544605255127, 0.08788927644491196, 0.017018357291817665, -0.5590521693229675, 0.4577917456626892, -0.2953423857688904, 0.19498780369758606, -0.08760365098714828, 0.3641670346260071, -1.1733367443084717, 0.8515577912330627, -1.043103575706482, -0.6492601037025452, 0.8242073059082031, -0.3037099540233612, -0.1869930773973465, 0.08290067315101624, -0.8298566937446594, 0.6633340120315552, -0.37766557931900024, -0.3174937665462494, -0.07402024418115616, -0.6841862201690674, 0.5000160932540894, 0.15281757712364197, -0.190244659781456, 0.18268074095249176, -0.2016448974609375, 0.2511773109436035, 0.5912718176841736, -0.38987845182418823, 0.20825277268886566, 0.48763203620910645, -0.9638383388519287, -0.15281008183956146, 1.1364127397537231, -0.0743778795003891, -0.41823139786720276, 0.4731937050819397, -0.11228939145803452, -0.45921260118484497, 0.5455813407897949, 0.1666812300682068, -0.2583498954772949, 0.5844696760177612, -0.3612114191055298, -0.046390432864427567, -0.5385168790817261, -0.18740497529506683, -0.6877213716506958, 0.4248267114162445, -0.7037705183029175, -0.6530454754829407, -0.8076380491256714, 0.13056804239749908, -0.44984325766563416, 0.7854769825935364, -1.6647971868515015, 0.23626559972763062, 0.25964969396591187, -0.4956474304199219, -0.993943452835083, 0.011562191881239414, 0.28932082653045654, 0.45662921667099, 0.5015866160392761, 0.13764013350009918, -0.0980909913778305, 0.2763240337371826, -0.4878336489200592, -0.16288530826568604, 1.3231449127197266, -0.40352195501327515, 0.8174552321434021, -0.09616366773843765, 0.11179427057504654, 0.8106540441513062, 0.05888324975967407, -0.2680134177207947, 0.2844242453575134, 0.6131490468978882, 0.7760167121887207, -0.1987576186656952, -0.3366485834121704, 1.032779574394226, -0.32218509912490845, 0.40871500968933105, 0.9517745971679688, 1.1801519393920898, 0.6092256903648376, 0.9651878476142883, 0.13259056210517883, -0.15647365152835846, 0.22714467346668243, -0.07480696588754654, 1.0989439487457275, 0.5107331275939941, 0.1245458647608757, 0.48258712887763977, -0.39632540941238403, -0.3547230064868927, -0.10463403910398483, 0.6350478529930115, -0.37023651599884033, 1.2429721355438232, 0.3646559715270996, -0.13174347579479218, -0.3952939510345459, 0.2434343844652176, 0.2663390040397644, 0.5363390445709229, -0.2816195785999298, -0.1259615272283554, -0.18511717021465302, 0.466084748506546, -0.10303468257188797, -0.515053391456604, -0.6665040254592896, 1.1725484132766724, -0.1899258941411972, 0.02534208633005619, -0.07122735679149628, -0.2670365869998932, -1.3024598360061646, -0.14434705674648285, -0.5194666385650635, -0.27610334753990173, -0.34789830446243286, 0.30555906891822815, 1.3620498180389404, -0.5866474509239197, 0.20556479692459106, -0.16363635659217834, -0.5302809476852417, 0.7080518007278442, 0.13267333805561066, 0.793390154838562, 0.6971942782402039, 0.12383691966533661, -1.049714207649231, -0.20365650951862335, -0.16946618258953094, 0.44979128241539, 0.10374954342842102, 0.3517821431159973, 0.4229905307292938, -0.2600657343864441, -0.30217912793159485, -0.6777276396751404, -0.6141527891159058, -0.3045106530189514, 0.1488560438156128, -0.481421560049057, 0.21142540872097015, 0.3018496632575989, -0.1923879086971283, -0.5910688042640686, -0.4840410649776459, 1.6017471551895142, 0.28147682547569275, -0.19069276750087738, 0.8107891082763672, 0.42440536618232727, 0.3267197906970978, 0.2529366910457611, -0.5485442876815796, -0.054110411554574966, 0.4567573368549347, 0.7489355206489563, 0.6316990256309509, 0.026314906775951385, 0.29808056354522705, -0.2573305666446686, -0.026925431564450264, 0.02280106581747532, -0.3710404634475708, -0.5167539715766907, -0.1327710598707199, 0.6592932343482971, 0.4029463529586792, -1.4046823978424072, 0.21869224309921265, -0.6788491010665894, -0.5439777970314026, 0.10055108368396759, -0.23052778840065002, 1.0364991426467896, 0.4428538978099823, -0.2061236947774887, -0.3056465685367584, 0.4053669273853302, -0.030277108773589134, 0.3749930262565613, 0.28611648082733154, -0.36267319321632385, 0.1942475587129593, 0.5153356790542603, 0.3256114423274994, 0.4283161759376526, 0.14673450589179993, 0.002760580973699689, -0.1723284274339676, 0.7293375134468079, -0.967659592628479, -0.0012365547008812428, 0.5262914896011353, 0.6963699460029602, 0.09474146366119385, 0.38908079266548157, -0.4071711003780365, -0.4733874797821045, -0.4365525245666504, -0.47711381316185, 0.7603573799133301, 0.6341203451156616, -0.4838523268699646, 0.2272762805223465, -0.3741622269153595, -0.08402152359485626, 0.42666909098625183, -0.02918306738138199, 0.7093901038169861, -0.7418358325958252, 0.469474196434021, 0.898216724395752, 0.3785937428474426, -0.30279144644737244, -0.538445234298706, 0.1802479326725006, 0.5112008452415466, -0.016483686864376068, 0.7958965301513672, -1.1056499481201172, -0.5401268601417542, -0.2701992988586426, 1.558090090751648, 0.8035199046134949, 0.9949899911880493, 0.7185801267623901, -0.40932542085647583, -0.0213176179677248, -0.2740888297557831, -0.6109276413917542, -0.20225121080875397, -0.5329490303993225, -0.4672647714614868, -0.6103395819664001, -0.7399232387542725, 0.01567460224032402, 0.3516997992992401, 1.0600504875183105, 0.9422570466995239, -0.1773967742919922, 0.8719636797904968, 0.1834244728088379, 0.13641390204429626, 0.7513218522071838, -0.08987793326377869, -0.14256449043750763, -1.3167760372161865, 0.2723467946052551, -0.013218577951192856, 0.31582698225975037, -0.04819120466709137, -0.18610841035842896, -0.6461886167526245, -1.2145692110061646, 0.708236813545227, -0.07889682054519653, 0.016515234485268593, 0.8154988884925842, -0.7616450786590576, -0.4809427559375763, -0.11492813378572464, -0.6585202813148499, 0.11448072642087936, 0.41935890913009644, 0.12778781354427338, -0.8112643957138062, 0.43407174944877625, -0.6351361274719238, 0.5072904825210571, 0.7650960087776184, -0.3047216236591339, -0.7092862129211426, -0.29012444615364075, 0.04996560513973236, -0.7955026030540466, -0.6480023264884949, 0.6918172240257263, 0.04895726963877678, -0.4472455084323883, -0.46951210498809814, -0.060968056321144104, 0.05653781816363335, -0.7028276324272156, -0.4003826081752777, 0.06532181054353714, -0.6314859390258789, -0.17066612839698792, 0.09732475876808167, -0.03571350872516632, 0.05069470405578613, 0.10058091580867767, -0.4032486379146576, -0.13598300516605377, -0.29979848861694336, -0.9152200222015381, -0.3247069716453552, -0.9411506652832031, -0.45663779973983765, 0.3010743260383606, -0.4462193250656128, 0.052739694714546204, 0.16003315150737762, 0.4524058401584625, -0.24138715863227844, -0.4999649226665497, 0.2170001119375229, 0.5168560147285461, 0.7497553825378418, 0.9074609279632568, 0.27417483925819397, 0.6836873292922974, 0.6962575316429138, 0.0861312747001648, 0.181094229221344, 0.19601799547672272, 0.6085324883460999, 0.23567555844783783, -0.49189212918281555, 0.35789307951927185, -0.6078031659126282, -0.33842626214027405, 0.807468831539154, -0.3375425636768341, 0.956511914730072, -0.25306591391563416, -0.5826362371444702, -0.13518917560577393, -0.6398322582244873, -0.739383339881897, 0.38655200600624084, -0.44389140605926514, -0.4139205813407898, 0.6904821395874023, -0.7087317705154419, -0.11253479868173599, 0.20312291383743286, -0.2373710721731186, -0.38086920976638794, 0.058695439249277115, 0.02997349388897419, -0.2729761600494385, 0.3614307641983032, -0.7011163830757141, -0.13224634528160095, -0.691702127456665, 0.21945466101169586, -0.26691433787345886, -0.8098338842391968, -0.17622020840644836, -0.17001870274543762, -0.39348912239074707, -0.518123209476471, 0.03454585373401642, 0.14583782851696014, 0.8407939076423645, -0.6121623516082764, -0.13105826079845428, 0.006374305114150047, -0.6065012216567993, 0.8770546913146973, 0.16512209177017212, -0.9596176743507385, 0.15641462802886963, 0.5514145493507385, -0.01678399369120598, -0.22628511488437653, -0.039357878267765045, -0.48058372735977173, -0.1655421257019043, -0.2403089553117752, -0.23462428152561188, -0.8614100217819214, 0.4457681477069855, -0.21887876093387604, -0.660675585269928, 0.09326756000518799, -0.1673705279827118, 0.24498221278190613, 0.36581340432167053, 0.03564217686653137, -0.5408607721328735, -0.08391585946083069, -0.5352990031242371, -0.06950978934764862, -0.3394348919391632, -0.3697754442691803, -0.6612523198127747, 0.512897789478302, -0.25421378016471863, -0.016690392047166824, 0.5397012233734131, -0.20074644684791565, -0.5531195402145386, 0.843686044216156, 0.010927695780992508, -0.2254459708929062, 0.17994551360607147, 0.5577422380447388, -0.2766188085079193, -0.2149926722049713, -1.0974125862121582, 0.7081132531166077, -1.1052087545394897, 0.9389171004295349, -0.036199815571308136, -0.45765992999076843, -0.3820172846317291, -0.16268034279346466, 0.8938484787940979, -0.6794568300247192, 0.6778852939605713, 0.47396817803382874, -0.476757675409317, 0.524226725101471, 0.28989914059638977, -0.653570294380188, -0.7048578858375549, -0.448903888463974, -1.0494381189346313, 1.0539166927337646, -0.06484916061162949, -0.14469394087791443, -1.0453401803970337, -1.4621286392211914, 0.2771393954753876, -0.0907260999083519, 0.5915644764900208, 0.3418613374233246, -0.19120429456233978, 0.062232714146375656, 0.2934035062789917, -0.0876002311706543, -0.39127954840660095, -0.2976737916469574, 0.4999929368495941, -0.33791378140449524, -0.595113217830658, -0.6508423686027527, -0.24631011486053467, -1.2579662799835205, 0.01961374841630459, 0.3949974775314331, 0.10462947189807892, 0.009922252967953682, 0.5655983686447144, -1.169859766960144, -0.50635826587677, -0.884304940700531, 0.08647159487009048, -0.1630530208349228, 0.09909816831350327, 0.5960456132888794, -0.3323690593242645, 0.4112129807472229, -0.28555965423583984, 0.78256756067276, -1.0448836088180542, 0.24572575092315674, 0.212741881608963, -0.2530662417411804, -0.6049248576164246, 0.7924485206604004, 0.15681466460227966, -0.6004490256309509, -0.870745062828064, -0.6722118854522705, -0.6851125955581665, -0.16583609580993652, -0.38357478380203247, 0.7060959339141846, 0.2771821916103363, 0.28651943802833557, 0.4297662675380707, 0.3212811350822449, -0.33028626441955566, -0.14266805350780487, 0.008796755224466324, -0.6816074848175049, -0.4550708532333374, -0.45943304896354675, 0.7694476246833801, 0.12296317517757416, -0.19548337161540985, -0.7761014103889465, -0.31126606464385986, -0.31868258118629456, 0.16125249862670898, -0.2558215856552124, -0.35711804032325745, 0.38963666558265686, 0.3845269978046417, 0.5879601836204529, 0.3203360140323639, 0.17215488851070404, 0.050230663269758224, 0.05313701555132866, 0.1416807472705841, -0.9022162556648254, -0.8407628536224365, -0.1051386371254921, 0.15776227414608002, 0.9441528916358948, -0.49315664172172546, 0.3858658969402313, 0.34753936529159546, -0.6709198951721191, -0.46848833560943604, -0.7051980495452881, 0.6470790505409241, -1.531667947769165, -0.6084598302841187, -0.6050370931625366, -0.7339122891426086, 0.1944315880537033, 0.8270102143287659, 0.44080159068107605, -0.30174317955970764, -1.0176571607589722, 0.12252388894557953, 0.7166336178779602, 0.11204801499843597, 0.23458531498908997, -0.6372654438018799, -1.4847759008407593, -0.24233654141426086, -0.2685277760028839, 0.1937314122915268, -0.05413045734167099, 0.2177053838968277, -0.5698375701904297, 0.26532867550849915, -0.2744167447090149, 0.9761216640472412, -0.2728418707847595, -0.47492823004722595, -0.18548770248889923, 0.03887878730893135, -0.2243855595588684, -0.33313408493995667, -0.4601520895957947, -0.12981538474559784, -0.4870448112487793, -0.386356383562088, 0.4361807405948639, 0.27040475606918335, -0.8229518532752991, -0.8108073472976685, -0.5946994423866272, 0.3298363983631134, -0.34319037199020386, -1.1506013870239258, 0.6513597369194031, -0.6099536418914795, -0.8140923976898193, -0.039589233696460724, -0.7762452960014343, -0.14729070663452148, -0.45920729637145996, 0.008609428070485592, -0.15539903938770294, 0.8568137288093567, -0.7556927800178528, 0.658358097076416, -0.45249202847480774, -0.2566351890563965, -0.3297266662120819, 0.1785193681716919, -0.7377117872238159, 0.7180131673812866, 0.21785613894462585, -0.55267333984375, 0.2130889594554901, 0.5028920769691467, -0.2851651906967163, 0.18336710333824158, -0.5797280669212341, -0.5310888886451721, 0.023894937708973885, -0.11219125241041183, -0.28670573234558105, 0.5906121730804443, 0.1286737620830536, -0.6321515440940857, -0.7026090621948242, -0.5735262036323547, -0.8476177453994751, 0.0067322575487196445, -0.4092896580696106, -0.23633232712745667, 0.019660724326968193, -0.3490261435508728, 0.22314366698265076, -0.10630516707897186, 0.6473382115364075, 0.6039432287216187, 0.36242425441741943, 0.04115781560540199, -0.2747953534126282, -0.05008848384022713, 0.18574218451976776, 0.331947386264801, -0.6914907097816467, -0.6251913905143738, -0.2674632966518402, 0.3866947293281555, -0.2556890547275543, -0.8027303814888, -0.907063364982605, 0.5395466685295105, 0.012042790651321411, -0.3354042172431946, -0.24351009726524353, -0.2927752137184143, 0.01779627799987793, 0.0849204808473587, -0.4370797276496887, -0.05241953209042549, 0.13821183145046234, 1.0238643884658813, 0.14829561114311218, -0.8770784735679626, 0.6878332495689392, -0.0020918624941259623, 0.23742011189460754, -0.19880402088165283, -0.2936709225177765, 0.23171938955783844, 0.5212512612342834, -1.1863197088241577, 1.054696798324585, 0.19203557074069977, 0.9834000468254089, 0.1515318602323532, -0.10654596984386444, 0.08995810896158218, 0.418430894613266, 0.5724475979804993, 0.43060216307640076, 1.0431493520736694, -0.03183159604668617, -0.06503117084503174, -0.48642659187316895, 0.2646997272968292, -0.026371881365776062, 0.6354943513870239, -0.03902658075094223, 0.9945530295372009, -0.5098715424537659, 0.6984425187110901, -0.5483430624008179, 0.6063862442970276, -0.07354574650526047, 0.0009896435076370835, 0.28206971287727356, 0.14540815353393555, 0.6011533141136169, 0.6973736882209778, -0.21849891543388367, -0.6375332474708557, -0.3483051359653473, 0.5732861161231995, -0.47842228412628174, 0.4164755940437317, -0.15252737700939178, 0.2040426880121231, 0.20521605014801025, 0.290907084941864, 0.2169591784477234, 0.46731629967689514, 0.7859024405479431, 0.2640071213245392, 0.7990392446517944, 1.1715054512023926, 0.5304722785949707, -0.12517260015010834, 0.5815414786338806, -1.074135661125183, -0.18036730587482452, 0.655920147895813, -1.5707626342773438, 0.21241621673107147, -0.08262007683515549, 0.05453391373157501, 0.13348710536956787, -0.7410128116607666, 0.3382608890533447, -0.4678190350532532, 0.9480422139167786, 1.1849716901779175, 0.055016979575157166, 0.6799123883247375, 0.5202296376228333, -0.13572466373443604, 0.883677065372467, 0.4989716112613678, 0.021950112655758858, -0.35347017645835876, 1.071575403213501, 1.3432347774505615, -0.5173352360725403, 0.5377949476242065, -0.25932109355926514, -0.7591620087623596, 0.27959105372428894, 0.11545916646718979, 0.2873852550983429, 1.4070600271224976, -0.6199719309806824, -0.4456767737865448, 0.4608289897441864, 0.06755366176366806, -0.28992313146591187, -0.07490222156047821, -0.12340626120567322, 0.7934607863426208, -0.5190702080726624, -0.4211840331554413, 1.2282918691635132, 1.1530324220657349, -0.4006470739841461, -0.12592285871505737, 0.34667330980300903, -0.004392652306705713, 0.2968282103538513, -0.8360168933868408, 0.3179548382759094, 0.8547643423080444, 0.5586331486701965, -0.3789140582084656, -0.5385282635688782, -0.5570359230041504, -0.7488173842430115, 0.16775144636631012, -0.7918722629547119, 0.8201522827148438, -0.3063597083091736, 0.6091980338096619, 0.4292179346084595, -0.5609310269355774, 0.32838720083236694, 0.3116648495197296, 0.7140362858772278, -0.2902286946773529, 0.2981315553188324, 0.9018532633781433, 1.0390311479568481, -0.7064711451530457, 0.40193668007850647, 1.092781662940979, -0.17034591734409332, 0.5118549466133118, -0.028663409873843193, -0.1451755166053772, -0.3088560998439789, 0.003633167129009962, 0.5839274525642395, -0.04283919185400009, 0.2635878920555115, -0.6469550132751465, -0.34103643894195557, -0.36761474609375, -0.8925082683563232, -0.1509402096271515, -0.8510864973068237, 0.030867882072925568, -0.38609325885772705, 1.0498535633087158, 0.23841051757335663, 0.01385368313640356, 3.7883458137512207, 0.8923959732055664, 0.4933168292045593, 0.04546094685792923, 0.3804958760738373, 0.4213695228099823, 0.2656157910823822, -0.32840895652770996, 0.4965442717075348, -0.4494297206401825, 0.19119702279567719, 0.06962712854146957, 0.8493521213531494, -0.1335727721452713, 0.19398844242095947, 0.05084063857793808, -0.29433366656303406, 0.4302408993244171, 0.2608310878276825, -1.459652304649353, -0.3630260229110718, 0.5972700119018555, 0.17968016862869263, 0.1339520364999771, 0.37456777691841125, 0.22212471067905426, 0.13018374145030975, -1.0003286600112915, 0.050864651799201965, 0.051465004682540894, -0.7771236896514893, -0.5111713409423828, -0.19935785233974457, -0.34454524517059326, -0.2896098792552948, 0.8256409764289856, 0.1390945315361023, -0.4523521959781647, 0.3440713584423065, 0.5050676465034485, 0.37087997794151306, 0.27618253231048584, 0.06625303626060486, 0.40322309732437134, -1.4131072759628296, 1.182511568069458, 0.4864026606082916, 0.7355595231056213, -0.015509889461100101, -0.620938777923584, 0.33105283975601196, 0.3299494683742523, 0.7085058093070984, -0.06124672293663025, -1.0799564123153687, 0.15849502384662628, -0.8101037740707397, -0.7599542140960693, 0.5747487545013428, 0.525565505027771, 0.748565137386322, -0.05222519114613533, -0.29078274965286255, 0.12378736585378647, -0.5988825559616089, 0.7697838544845581, 0.18827052414417267, -0.24970582127571106, -0.6364587545394897, 0.09475938975811005, 0.3326498866081238, -0.464010089635849, -1.3164234161376953, -0.1951843798160553, 0.026797335594892502, -0.15008078515529633, -0.3697778582572937, 0.9340824484825134, -0.27087485790252686, 0.15917329490184784, 0.16823428869247437, -0.654022216796875, -0.10232922434806824, 0.9054647088050842, -0.10652347654104233, 0.717982828617096, -0.16537107527256012, 0.45820942521095276, -0.07303908467292786, -0.00386189017444849, -0.005145186558365822, 1.320008635520935, 0.21898768842220306, -0.871313214302063, -0.8456556797027588 ]
New Dynamic Monte Carlo Renormalization Group Method
The dynamical critical exponent of the two-dimensional spin-flip Ising model is evaluated by a Monte Carlo renormalization group method involving a transformation in time. The results agree very well with a finite-size scaling analysis performed on the same data. The value of $z = 2.13 \pm 0.01$ is obtained, which is consistent with most recent estimates.
Martin-D. Lacasse (1), Jorge Vinals (2), Martin Grant(1) ((1) Centre for the Physics of Materials and Department of Physic...
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206004
cond-mat/9206005
[ 0.3587750494480133, -0.1888553649187088, 0.0022095446474850178, 0.4049752950668335, 0.3759969174861908, -0.2966182827949524, 0.69803786277771, -0.2538066506385803, -0.9561852812767029, 1.4008291959762573, 0.7640758752822876, 0.09977840632200241, 0.6478220224380493, -1.111965537071228, -0.16683654487133026, 0.40510472655296326, -0.1237282007932663, -0.8682337999343872, -1.734507441520691, -0.17663151025772095, 0.02307836338877678, -0.4670449197292328, -0.8191293478012085, -0.09746941924095154, -0.44025570154190063, 0.5428175330162048, 0.3026554584503174, 0.20390953123569489, 0.8437731862068176, 0.8840091824531555, 0.4558448791503906, -0.022291256114840508, 0.009162704460322857, 0.022531861439347267, -0.07929211854934692, 0.11234240978956223, -0.256580650806427, -0.4702693521976471, 0.09270968288183212, -0.4200464189052582, 0.7585048675537109, -0.5255163908004761, -0.14293308556079865, 0.05425029247999191, -0.2279052734375, 0.5179104208946228, -0.18089710175991058, 0.31644684076309204, -0.2314440757036209, -1.573378324508667, 0.18427571654319763, 0.3144591748714447, 0.6279169321060181, 0.22326508164405823, -0.2012600600719452, 0.24533115327358246, -0.03515828028321266, -0.20574387907981873, -0.5091174244880676, -0.34956905245780945, 0.16000832617282867, -0.3697737455368042, 0.5212352275848389, -0.6181279420852661, -0.01445494219660759, 0.31537580490112305, -0.7264861464500427, 0.753623902797699, -0.1809684783220291, -0.3228254020214081, -0.47933757305145264, -0.07206456363201141, -0.4823862314224243, -0.1344422847032547, -0.45660334825515747, 0.9733040928840637, 0.07301969081163406, -0.5626853704452515, -1.3772865533828735, -0.44204336404800415, -0.06129419803619385, -0.22369705140590668, -0.7990965843200684, 0.29425397515296936, 0.3003937304019928, -0.2943545877933502, -0.15575064718723297, -0.4253329932689667, 0.026588154956698418, 0.22987119853496552, 0.14849038422107697, 0.9344766139984131, -0.0700133889913559, 0.13356584310531616, 0.7731720209121704, 0.8105066418647766, 0.10837344825267792, 0.7191457748413086, -0.23790854215621948, 0.06824181228876114, -0.0010998366633430123, 0.8308436274528503, -0.5515710711479187, 0.8799756765365601, -0.39074018597602844, -0.028670378029346466, -0.19295260310173035, 0.28402280807495117, 0.004926963709294796, -0.7044196724891663, -0.263511598110199, -0.429470419883728, 0.18700842559337616, 0.6666731238365173, -0.025231100618839264, -0.038559529930353165, -0.055861879140138626, 0.2608395218849182, -1.3059792518615723, 0.2276943176984787, 0.5044390559196472, -0.1999644637107849, 0.9910933971405029, 1.0118454694747925, -0.7178619503974915, -0.17667700350284576, 0.1977979689836502, 0.707553505897522, -0.6280742883682251, 0.35513508319854736, 0.10771917551755905, 0.02547907456755638, -0.06197509169578552, 0.43682998418807983, -1.0650864839553833, 0.31948214769363403, -0.18067194521427155, 0.7224493622779846, 0.7430148720741272, 0.63865065574646, 0.728614866733551, -0.7319567203521729, 0.2325403392314911, 0.5152449607849121, 0.023307180032134056, 0.11583513021469116, 0.9499675631523132, 0.03962632641196251, -0.2192300260066986, 0.20300748944282532, -0.6676647067070007, 0.0040204343385994434, -0.43536263704299927, 0.6999517679214478, -0.1283455789089203, 0.4865627884864807, -0.3465723395347595, 0.36406320333480835, -0.20998933911323547, -0.17353445291519165, 0.26009228825569153, -0.587369441986084, 0.13001251220703125, 0.479959100484848, -0.7765181660652161, 0.12594173848628998, -0.5527746081352234, -0.08216635137796402, 0.36059126257896423, -0.22364944219589233, -0.35714924335479736, 0.40187355875968933, -0.2758564054965973, 1.097802996635437, 0.5745120048522949, 0.4333333671092987, 0.4322926700115204, 0.08339575678110123, 0.4885886311531067, 0.14991843700408936, 0.07751265913248062, -0.5191362500190735, 0.44754764437675476, 0.4649416506290436, 0.10377148538827896, 0.3191051781177521, 0.08936828374862671, -0.2759595811367035, 0.11504683643579483, 0.25123903155326843, 0.010818827897310257, 0.3933780789375305, -0.19250352680683136, 0.09101249277591705, -0.845986008644104, 0.4582476317882538, -0.7586250901222229, 0.7812215089797974, -0.9196731448173523, -0.2348695546388626, 0.06422850489616394, 0.3134017288684845, -1.3846207857131958, 0.35806894302368164, -1.5623393058776855, 0.46116381883621216, 0.5739411115646362, 0.4336974620819092, 0.21175096929073334, -0.25377580523490906, 0.34533488750457764, -0.05102107301354408, 0.40870311856269836, -0.249521404504776, -0.2798849940299988, 0.397950679063797, 0.22423145174980164, 0.6534612774848938, 0.19089192152023315, -0.4225604236125946, 0.37635013461112976, 0.46153050661087036, -0.33076798915863037, 0.8390095829963684, 0.12717680633068085, -0.5535996556282043, 0.4481966197490692, 0.71506667137146, 0.32270413637161255, 0.1148662120103836, -0.1125938892364502, 0.10872206091880798, 0.08784844726324081, 0.65038001537323, 0.8596155643463135, 0.2899831235408783, 0.8155266046524048, 0.25661489367485046, 0.5537489056587219, -0.1286473423242569, 0.2211993783712387, 0.34455406665802, 0.43632495403289795, -0.2936675548553467, -0.3657025992870331, 0.17329388856887817, -0.4665806293487549, 0.005902461241930723, -0.7501342296600342, 0.3067898452281952, -1.217597246170044, 0.4515702724456787, -0.27946165204048157, 0.01673339307308197, -1.1669591665267944, -0.217753067612648, 0.3653547465801239, 0.34857359528541565, -0.4200148284435272, -0.35248705744743347, 0.20426328480243683, -0.2580464482307434, -0.21650002896785736, -0.40861421823501587, 0.2922837734222412, 1.3421698808670044, 0.1401095688343048, 0.26278287172317505, -0.02087079919874668, -0.06120721623301506, -1.5879721641540527, -0.3984036147594452, -0.8568318486213684, -0.029785877093672752, -0.48511847853660583, 0.35154882073402405, 0.7561140060424805, -0.39432528614997864, 0.6531620025634766, -0.32578542828559875, -0.3749787211418152, 0.29053834080696106, -0.17999573051929474, 0.34727743268013, 0.06878583878278732, 0.2230808287858963, -0.7735106945037842, 0.5325478911399841, -0.27983519434928894, 0.13030700385570526, -0.03163130581378937, -0.20681680738925934, 0.6888845562934875, -0.3396281898021698, 0.29314133524894714, -0.11852958053350449, -0.4976547956466675, 0.2333063781261444, 0.1287698596715927, -0.6392297744750977, -0.2561529874801636, 0.2430100291967392, -0.4679841995239258, -0.19421371817588806, -0.36893993616104126, 0.9118632078170776, 0.31251418590545654, -0.7551704049110413, 0.8642207384109497, 0.08814290165901184, -0.6021256446838379, 0.2318526655435562, -0.09682472795248032, -0.11294927448034286, -0.18284262716770172, 0.7433780431747437, 0.7227081060409546, 0.08084549754858017, 0.020793898031115532, -0.3568277359008789, -0.5781378149986267, 0.3278788626194, 0.20167818665504456, -0.5982899069786072, 0.13378967344760895, 0.9737915396690369, -0.09227433055639267, -0.2893523871898651, 0.7083441019058228, -0.8856126070022583, -0.5352228283882141, -0.4714856743812561, -0.8650910258293152, 0.12674309313297272, -0.09565419703722, 0.324515700340271, -0.4962889850139618, -0.2702253758907318, 0.7457587122917175, 0.4291730225086212, 0.16191479563713074, -0.5626328587532043, 0.6078642010688782, -0.002332290168851614, 0.9620837569236755, -0.6457929015159607, 0.2384340614080429, -0.1560080349445343, -0.05227700248360634, 0.08683846145868301, -0.3631221652030945, 0.35944026708602905, 0.17205239832401276, -0.030504945665597916, -0.0596630685031414, 0.48677393794059753, 0.08293529599905014, -0.38283345103263855, -0.7781491279602051, 0.057537831366062164, -0.11442465335130692, 0.36302775144577026, -0.005524342879652977, -0.11538144201040268, -0.8578764200210571, -0.44571611285209656, 0.2904517650604248, -0.16350558400154114, 1.3443158864974976, -0.753617525100708, 0.678564190864563, 0.044253818690776825, -0.4472277760505676, 0.2544400990009308, -0.6777888536453247, 0.5097550749778748, 0.07658190280199051, 0.3334672451019287, 0.5768071413040161, -0.9443362355232239, -0.7317402362823486, -0.1417182832956314, 1.0176886320114136, 0.4248276650905609, 1.0726561546325684, 0.3735681176185608, -0.17219741642475128, 0.08152409642934799, -0.326264351606369, -0.047837819904088974, -0.12502793967723846, -0.22406990826129913, -0.2903999090194702, -0.7074488401412964, -0.37250715494155884, 0.2031930685043335, 0.7543938159942627, -0.2015136182308197, 0.42887645959854126, -0.055966999381780624, 0.8184005618095398, 0.6934167742729187, 0.39970314502716064, 0.968174159526825, -0.2641003429889679, -0.3482165038585663, -0.72052001953125, -0.21335983276367188, 0.29517051577568054, 0.03136700019240379, -0.5738256573677063, -0.4559171795845032, -0.368164986371994, -0.652877688407898, 0.5811684727668762, -0.09780903905630112, -0.9027557969093323, 0.3119952976703644, 0.18553632497787476, 0.48501452803611755, -0.10546860098838806, -0.557935893535614, 0.7489425539970398, 0.769152820110321, 0.3649037778377533, -0.911933422088623, 0.5498587489128113, -0.2543405294418335, 0.7587640285491943, 0.7751845121383667, -0.1706942319869995, -1.0792179107666016, -0.1922946721315384, 0.5513395667076111, -0.8306693434715271, -0.08129823207855225, 1.3285070657730103, 0.42243215441703796, -0.3129681646823883, -0.2823951542377472, 0.15497861802577972, 0.6210784316062927, -1.0020358562469482, -0.8076183199882507, -0.058465249836444855, 0.12905775010585785, -0.38469943404197693, 0.23086299002170563, -0.17757076025009155, -0.14072783291339874, -0.5870516300201416, -0.05235612392425537, -0.24182581901550293, -0.12009933590888977, -0.45134440064430237, 0.3209995627403259, -0.4941128194332123, -0.08359764516353607, 0.37928521633148193, 0.4393925666809082, -0.4467749297618866, 0.017478883266448975, 0.059141580015420914, 0.11163218319416046, 0.0799521654844284, 0.10524744540452957, 0.3475854694843292, 0.8158698081970215, 0.3992391526699066, 0.17942938208580017, -0.23241771757602692, -0.2441704422235489, 0.15032635629177094, -0.3802468180656433, 0.40199142694473267, 0.3318193256855011, -0.6621042490005493, -0.6254631876945496, -0.12097086012363434, -0.23064084351062775, -0.6504981517791748, 0.5309702754020691, -0.29051029682159424, 0.4618825316429138, 0.548143744468689, -0.5927644968032837, -0.5232235789299011, -0.3297267258167267, -1.0557118654251099, 0.36048808693885803, 0.15093940496444702, -0.07098274677991867, 0.11258738487958908, -0.5851084589958191, 0.3478794991970062, -0.019775791093707085, -0.47532790899276733, -0.033013492822647095, 1.0535361766815186, 0.6325978636741638, 0.024191152304410934, 0.35904645919799805, -0.6272359490394592, 0.5728197693824768, -0.43008944392204285, 0.9353247284889221, -0.17047064006328583, -0.31698742508888245, -0.24593991041183472, -0.162246972322464, 0.029264304786920547, -0.4514412581920624, -0.12221132218837738, -0.1552337259054184, 0.5295001268386841, 0.4515152871608734, 0.23623459041118622, -0.2654363214969635, -0.6086065173149109, 0.7490376234054565, 0.07531856000423431, -0.3460887670516968, 0.24844415485858917, 0.347378134727478, 0.5508543848991394, 0.05106094479560852, 0.4203326106071472, -0.86068195104599, 0.23667742311954498, -0.060871247202157974, 0.764940083026886, -1.237847924232483, -0.16600947082042694, -0.3263233006000519, 0.027632609009742737, 0.40863531827926636, 0.6771628260612488, 0.11650189012289047, 0.08953162282705307, -0.6340120434761047, -0.09906188398599625, 0.08441603183746338, -0.2778480052947998, 0.18419286608695984, -0.47949057817459106, -0.7563197612762451, -0.2261761724948883, 0.6698653101921082, -0.024138059467077255, 0.04418439790606499, 0.23243899643421173, 0.30468395352363586, 0.284932941198349, 0.15150733292102814, 0.5715201497077942, 0.09110470861196518, -0.6602140069007874, 0.30101174116134644, -0.20484545826911926, 0.5405634641647339, -0.4817650020122528, 0.5595727562904358, -1.0618007183074951, 0.5999820828437805, -0.48394832015037537, -0.07991419732570648, 0.29067108035087585, 0.13066978752613068, 0.4676316976547241, -0.7628543972969055, 0.3608071506023407, -0.08937527984380722, -0.2905690670013428, 0.576765775680542, 0.04301847144961357, -0.9909721612930298, -0.754429042339325, -0.7160692811012268, -0.758620023727417, 0.5987188220024109, -0.09228512644767761, -0.12374860793352127, -0.42883357405662537, -0.6328359246253967, 0.21459132432937622, -0.19068968296051025, -0.3292068541049957, 1.1552878618240356, 0.02721622958779335, 0.4780396819114685, 0.28639447689056396, -0.2278410941362381, -0.3748888075351715, -0.09408185631036758, 0.2793024778366089, 0.019598841667175293, -0.04270760715007782, 0.2708752453327179, -0.17688369750976562, -0.7926392555236816, -0.2893466055393219, 0.49382278323173523, 0.05950536951422691, -0.16816964745521545, 0.8977456092834473, -0.07452120631933212, -0.3260500431060791, -0.1860392540693283, -0.09026532620191574, -0.09047552943229675, 0.575901448726654, 0.3940742015838623, 0.39591139554977417, 0.16420480608940125, -0.6166048049926758, 1.0597621202468872, -0.7302099466323853, -0.12389438599348068, 0.1946384757757187, -0.8544860482215881, -0.3868056833744049, 0.6648298501968384, -0.1413389891386032, -0.4389224052429199, -0.3514347970485687, -0.48180902004241943, 0.08293244242668152, -0.27455171942710876, -0.10951629281044006, 0.3415087163448334, -0.4390564262866974, -0.05904296040534973, 0.44116199016571045, 0.3380372226238251, -0.03756675496697426, 0.20165997743606567, 0.14348946511745453, -0.3101990818977356, -0.11787661910057068, 0.04076520726084709, 1.0113385915756226, -0.6415079236030579, -0.5341109037399292, 0.005460493732243776, 0.1001967117190361, -0.3255361318588257, -0.4046945869922638, 0.946434497833252, 0.2579745650291443, 0.5392558574676514, 0.20913109183311462, 0.1431100070476532, 0.495049387216568, 0.5659716725349426, 0.02535625547170639, -0.2821577489376068, -0.4216107428073883, -0.6432254910469055, -0.19197052717208862, -0.7354380488395691, 0.12693461775779724, 0.6660783886909485, -0.3125530183315277, 0.3775083124637604, 0.5309615731239319, -0.32682332396507263, -0.8337376117706299, -1.2312265634536743, -0.21561068296432495, -1.7179441452026367, -0.7043790817260742, -1.2911442518234253, -0.31199920177459717, 0.35160595178604126, 0.7724071145057678, -0.3102300465106964, -0.22244395315647125, -0.4464298486709595, 0.22709882259368896, 0.14766107499599457, 0.23755566775798798, 0.1694357544183731, -0.8874373435974121, -0.5939187407493591, -0.7575408816337585, -0.6985026597976685, -0.05259040370583534, -0.38222452998161316, 0.04197155684232712, -0.11306267231702805, 0.1556474268436432, -0.21220365166664124, 0.6389790177345276, -0.6011799573898315, -0.741024911403656, -0.06054407358169556, 0.13949988782405853, -0.9055139422416687, 1.0842616558074951, 0.3471390902996063, 0.5094576478004456, 0.5164914131164551, 0.09336254745721817, -0.274046927690506, 0.21829213201999664, -0.6539842486381531, -0.15139131247997284, 0.011576314456760883, -0.40444493293762207, -0.5718266367912292, -0.44934600591659546, 0.31577780842781067, 0.5977699160575867, -1.0249460935592651, 0.30448827147483826, -0.7248706817626953, 0.24141106009483337, -0.8542856574058533, -0.04319163039326668, -0.4113657474517822, -0.33276671171188354, -0.16845819354057312, 0.7137253284454346, -0.3753306269645691, -0.5704910159111023, -0.3114820420742035, 0.21167801320552826, -0.37092721462249756, 0.4109635055065155, -0.2908775806427002, -0.3852882385253906, -0.0171643178910017, 0.17212051153182983, -0.8638791441917419, 0.5784472227096558, -0.07596258819103241, -0.5126839280128479, -0.8063883781433105, -0.6351227164268494, -0.2731352746486664, 0.32689717411994934, 0.44179484248161316, -0.596698522567749, 0.10439803451299667, -0.37035834789276123, -0.3654099702835083, 0.12428716570138931, -1.0187894105911255, -0.3879093825817108, -0.5302061438560486, -0.047415416687726974, 0.02307421900331974, -0.369148313999176, -0.22772400081157684, 0.06914036720991135, -0.19180844724178314, 0.7353315949440002, -0.21313129365444183, -0.2871820628643036, -0.5471000671386719, 0.31179362535476685, -1.1804468631744385, 0.4579215943813324, -0.4013935923576355, -0.07943014055490494, -0.5941788554191589, -0.9569464325904846, -0.9097291231155396, 0.7694254517555237, -0.12061302363872528, -0.3298579752445221, -0.05109760910272598, 0.3604317605495453, 0.16113099455833435, 0.0963473916053772, 0.4111311435699463, -0.23978590965270996, -0.9223349690437317, 0.10308755189180374, 0.10297072678804398, -0.571344792842865, 0.22505079209804535, 0.1950678825378418, 0.0036903999280184507, -0.28363528847694397, 0.1344921737909317, 1.2436729669570923, 0.27978020906448364, -0.09547288715839386, 0.5552435517311096, -0.08674709498882294, 0.44998666644096375, 0.44129472970962524, -0.12833888828754425, -0.02020951546728611, 0.309002161026001, 0.31029725074768066, 0.7203149199485779, 0.2899914085865021, 0.05011872947216034, -0.10277608782052994, 0.14809681475162506, -0.8138613104820251, -0.23332133889198303, 0.7016966342926025, 0.40271323919296265, 0.4445882737636566, -0.24155190587043762, 0.3634112775325775, -0.36928924918174744, 0.18737922608852386, -0.07721306383609772, -0.2752898037433624, -0.37225833535194397, 0.40297603607177734, 0.11152751743793488, 0.3034832179546356, -0.8080106973648071, 0.4611234962940216, -0.3680005371570587, 0.05137384682893753, 0.012444984167814255, -0.17294496297836304, -0.6877850890159607, 0.1761450469493866, 0.948889434337616, 0.5747002959251404, 0.5787391066551208, 0.8994041681289673, 0.16966383159160614, 0.5514196157455444, 0.0956854298710823, 0.913344144821167, 0.7790008187294006, 0.37353262305259705, -0.0994495376944542, -0.7391842007637024, -0.6811699867248535, 0.3861149549484253, -1.6279546022415161, -0.19562840461730957, -0.5728035569190979, -0.07771272957324982, 0.11413468420505524, -0.7316633462905884, 0.18576689064502716, -0.38927656412124634, 0.42576128244400024, 1.0511890649795532, -0.25241586565971375, -0.3340241312980652, 0.2727314829826355, -0.2743335962295532, 0.3673788011074066, 0.2767643332481384, -0.3978268802165985, -0.13009627163410187, 0.9809536933898926, 0.8544593453407288, -0.674140453338623, 0.5522371530532837, -0.10048650205135345, -0.27992939949035645, 0.25126615166664124, 0.5052052140235901, -0.20980942249298096, 0.378116637468338, -1.2584749460220337, -0.5399611592292786, 0.07723553478717804, 0.24557903409004211, -0.21315231919288635, 0.04413466900587082, 0.3143876791000366, 0.24933680891990662, -0.9098705649375916, -0.23238639533519745, 1.301069974899292, 0.8019431233406067, -0.5330871939659119, -0.34679272770881653, -0.21423138678073883, -0.07079444080591202, 0.05462274327874184, -0.8628718256950378, 0.026597341522574425, -0.32394737005233765, -0.013498112559318542, 0.3975844979286194, -0.46463069319725037, 0.22953540086746216, -0.5424349904060364, -0.6117732524871826, -0.08281707763671875, 0.4685019552707672, 0.34247615933418274, 0.21711744368076324, 0.059935059398412704, -0.35713258385658264, -0.2806797921657562, 0.3811146020889282, 0.8824057579040527, -0.5883773565292358, 0.5742892622947693, 0.5632630586624146, -0.04082709178328514, -0.8932770490646362, 0.3393019437789917, 0.3442617654800415, -0.8641355037689209, 0.5389103293418884, -0.5009341835975647, 0.06377600878477097, 0.3302045464515686, -0.4061811864376068, -0.09667892754077911, -0.012027168646454811, 0.8496888875961304, -0.24269910156726837, 0.21266718208789825, -0.4182162582874298, -1.07915461063385, 0.166918084025383, -0.4250454306602478, 0.27214398980140686, -0.3011728525161743, 0.46817687153816223, 0.3378980755805969, -0.43322423100471497, 4.204244136810303, 0.9577575922012329, 1.210888385772705, 0.20483002066612244, 1.0217289924621582, 1.2627629041671753, -0.6524531841278076, 0.2922256588935852, 0.597470223903656, -0.9578500986099243, -0.21102964878082275, 0.32303759455680847, 0.5412068963050842, -0.1833658367395401, -0.4932657480239868, 0.6646071076393127, -0.3954496681690216, 0.8152285218238831, -0.2085193693637848, -0.8086588978767395, -0.6137641668319702, 0.2408752739429474, 0.5845213532447815, 0.1351463496685028, 0.08428733050823212, 0.40502604842185974, 0.9489259719848633, -1.137778878211975, -0.4882027506828308, -0.30781424045562744, -0.6012739539146423, -0.6573911905288696, 0.16696994006633759, -0.4026746451854706, -0.4729299545288086, 0.14964978396892548, 0.2572331428527832, 0.09987547248601913, -0.2114376425743103, 0.01591244339942932, -0.23419880867004395, 0.3910616636276245, 0.30472487211227417, -0.1680770218372345, -0.358229398727417, 0.7114107608795166, -0.5043532252311707, 1.091431736946106, 0.27867254614830017, -0.34092578291893005, 0.5235259532928467, -0.476343035697937, 0.5015686750411987, -0.3938177525997162, -0.4252663850784302, -0.28070899844169617, -0.6833706498146057, -0.2378120720386505, 0.3151266276836395, 0.08665835857391357, 0.5031088590621948, -0.21860940754413605, -0.3747848868370056, 0.04107930138707161, 0.1385508030653, -0.1708896905183792, 0.8801208734512329, 0.028151486068964005, -0.4009108543395996, -0.0974828228354454, -0.5363052487373352, -0.27337777614593506, -0.5441821813583374, -0.33165180683135986, -0.2187950760126114, -0.19847683608531952, 0.009229631163179874, 0.7583326697349548, -0.14579452574253082, 0.003617366775870323, -0.4111137092113495, -0.532793402671814, 0.24767450988292694, 0.19943645596504211, 0.07526609301567078, 1.121139407157898, 0.14638307690620422, -0.17759914696216583, -0.3405785858631134, 0.5284554958343506, 0.8065264821052551, 1.7219704389572144, 0.3429127633571625, -0.1463550478219986, -1.0763847827911377 ]
Dimensional Reduction of a Generalized Flux Problem
A generalized flux problem with Abelian and non-Abelian fluxes is considered. In the Abelian case we shall show that the generalized flux problem for tight-binding models of noninteracting electrons on either $2n$ or $2n+1$ dimensional lattice can always be reduced to a $n$ dimensional hopping problem. A residual freedom in this reduction enables to identify equivalence classes of hopping Hamiltonians which have the same spectrum. In the non-Abelian case the reduction is not possible in general unless the flux tensor factorizes into an Abelian one times an element of the corresponding algebra.
Alexander Moroz
cond-mat hep-lat hep-th
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206005
cond-mat/9206006
[ -0.2408958375453949, 0.025108283385634422, 0.1765306442975998, 0.2862209677696228, -0.3713403344154358, -0.5327964425086975, 0.6629210710525513, -0.7533584833145142, -0.8057287931442261, 1.4448853731155396, 0.7951149940490723, 0.32904472947120667, 0.3274335563182831, -0.7327755093574524, -0.46810242533683777, 0.43163180351257324, -0.2727023661136627, -0.8120186924934387, -1.341425895690918, -0.1540786176919937, -0.2647594213485718, -0.3548088073730469, -0.9388555884361267, -0.5232133269309998, -0.4132063686847687, 0.7083448171615601, -0.3330893814563751, 0.41853395104408264, 0.8857848048210144, 0.3805195093154907, 0.3496328592300415, -0.40248093008995056, -0.5537542104721069, -1.1066865921020508, -0.08366785198450089, 0.03158470243215561, 0.3529919683933258, 0.0021552047692239285, 0.4099040925502777, -0.6303994059562683, 1.3109523057937622, -0.1710275113582611, 0.7872816324234009, -0.23533223569393158, -0.5334718823432922, 0.15796437859535217, -0.10253721475601196, -0.16800136864185333, -0.27612581849098206, -1.5217570066452026, 0.23944135010242462, 0.5847097635269165, 0.7734585404396057, -0.0628775805234909, 0.05609923601150513, 0.14989055693149567, 0.026233697310090065, 0.6202377676963806, -0.1383422166109085, -0.331179141998291, 0.051496170461177826, -0.07214656472206116, 0.7696868777275085, -0.6892585754394531, 0.06597806513309479, 0.9386177659034729, -0.22960305213928223, 0.9602294564247131, -0.013269282877445221, -0.43310630321502686, -0.16726462543010712, -0.3983589708805084, 0.30314427614212036, 0.13856106996536255, -0.3651357889175415, 0.4147578477859497, -0.29730600118637085, -0.2987692356109619, -1.0741941928863525, -0.17836272716522217, -0.12403228133916855, 0.16137483716011047, -0.4181751608848572, 0.9929819703102112, 0.05813667178153992, -0.2670488655567169, -0.21426482498645782, 0.23854424059391022, 0.14372283220291138, 0.629659116268158, -0.12863145768642426, 0.8610779643058777, -0.20333106815814972, 0.05945194140076637, 0.5895572900772095, 0.2378523051738739, 0.10258100926876068, 0.4087096154689789, 0.094643734395504, 0.4665108025074005, 0.4698706269264221, 1.0376392602920532, -0.2945284843444824, 0.6255224943161011, -0.9383147358894348, 0.5194926261901855, 0.293231338262558, 0.4559566080570221, -0.4288226366043091, -0.33042290806770325, -0.08084974437952042, 0.28447553515434265, 0.37808549404144287, 0.7525754570960999, 0.2471054047346115, 0.12305580824613571, 0.16717404127120972, 0.026725847274065018, -1.2141435146331787, -0.3400501310825348, 0.2010263055562973, 0.21756964921951294, 0.5388274192810059, 0.19914351403713226, 0.26495254039764404, -0.5639422535896301, 0.8150809407234192, 0.3723333775997162, 0.22950667142868042, 0.393275648355484, 0.20119570195674896, -0.3495519459247589, -0.4299805164337158, 0.23182761669158936, -0.2248157560825348, 0.23778551816940308, -0.41740506887435913, 0.3485821485519409, 0.34719645977020264, 0.16927090287208557, -0.12942861020565033, -0.7208922505378723, 0.2253946214914322, 0.5007642507553101, 0.3576691150665283, 0.13168123364448547, 0.22175946831703186, -0.014983154833316803, 0.16680674254894257, -0.015376637689769268, -0.22924694418907166, 0.15369996428489685, 0.13149574398994446, 0.0972331240773201, -0.11291777342557907, 0.47865545749664307, -0.3502972722053528, 0.7851433157920837, -0.28503909707069397, -0.5460415482521057, 0.5938006043434143, -0.5183754563331604, -0.048802029341459274, 0.46773141622543335, -0.390579491853714, 0.11154340207576752, -0.5201454162597656, -0.17724643647670746, -0.2988682687282562, 0.10522450506687164, 0.17872415482997894, 0.16052964329719543, 0.27698126435279846, -0.10061026364564896, 0.22812172770500183, -0.22176697850227356, 0.6851860880851746, 0.28211984038352966, -0.14602340757846832, -0.10653573274612427, -0.1899050772190094, -0.6063795685768127, 0.5342079997062683, -0.02017842046916485, -0.18536719679832458, -0.03927139937877655, -1.0282034873962402, 0.12152737379074097, 0.001058907830156386, 0.32865819334983826, -0.40782415866851807, 0.20540280640125275, -0.5077402591705322, -0.10211137682199478, -0.6933690905570984, -0.6656573414802551, -0.47664836049079895, 0.6954702734947205, -0.1649240255355835, -0.21140965819358826, -0.37547457218170166, 0.7066166996955872, -1.3574942350387573, 0.25226467847824097, -1.92110013961792, 0.3447483479976654, 0.8070030212402344, 0.6507589221000671, -0.8808715343475342, -0.20809723436832428, 0.5806905031204224, -0.10624484717845917, -0.3526160418987274, -0.06560733169317245, -0.24970515072345734, -0.3570815324783325, -0.7610127329826355, -0.05864112079143524, 0.5280925631523132, -0.19228005409240723, 0.5124766826629639, 0.12816785275936127, -0.019662711769342422, 0.8370217680931091, 0.14764472842216492, -0.2825915813446045, -0.0011134149972349405, 0.6319869160652161, 0.38028690218925476, 0.02681219018995762, 0.10008715838193893, 0.9557732343673706, -0.3266766369342804, 0.2240384817123413, 1.109378695487976, 0.6502511501312256, 0.1295866072177887, 0.8785998225212097, 0.3580940365791321, 0.14405664801597595, 0.7275731563568115, 0.03584904223680496, 0.23392339050769806, 0.02402285672724247, -0.4907795488834381, 0.29144152998924255, -0.7442834973335266, -0.10151682794094086, -0.8675803542137146, 0.33231285214424133, -0.4685269594192505, 0.7469363808631897, 0.20742037892341614, 0.5429104566574097, -1.1176406145095825, -0.2902456521987915, -0.21424153447151184, 0.04348369315266609, -0.264472633600235, -0.3340320587158203, 0.40462690591812134, 0.02390747331082821, -0.24751628935337067, -0.06760751456022263, -0.1513945460319519, 0.36854320764541626, -0.20775341987609863, 0.15132462978363037, -0.03260773420333862, -0.16107693314552307, -1.2144904136657715, -0.49053433537483215, -0.7161651849746704, -0.2588142156600952, -0.335205614566803, 0.20418067276477814, 0.7027471661567688, -1.0923603773117065, 1.1018102169036865, 0.5729225277900696, -0.2647358775138855, 0.030498893931508064, 0.1550060212612152, 0.11183662712574005, 0.3252210021018982, 0.19884392619132996, -0.7876070737838745, 0.08515266329050064, -0.4274229407310486, 0.6032619476318359, -0.22484295070171356, 0.4590032994747162, -0.35328203439712524, -0.17631734907627106, -0.03383362665772438, 0.13417424261569977, -0.898952066898346, -0.49035221338272095, -0.6489999890327454, -0.8769641518592834, -0.48524537682533264, 0.10367657244205475, -0.5575436949729919, 0.16010287404060364, -0.5170305371284485, 1.36394464969635, -0.16192063689231873, -0.684539794921875, 0.43141257762908936, 0.3348506689071655, -0.7508100271224976, 0.4503719210624695, -0.14793385565280914, 0.42423513531684875, -0.2075139731168747, 1.0688427686691284, 0.5814542174339294, 0.4702932834625244, 0.5449051856994629, -0.2538033723831177, -0.447103887796402, 0.331435889005661, 0.26773273944854736, -0.9207137227058411, -0.0902988612651825, 0.7529894113540649, 0.17968995869159698, -0.7963573932647705, 0.7410736680030823, -0.9088765382766724, -1.0903749465942383, -0.1744619905948639, -0.7895092964172363, 0.31203165650367737, -0.2308100014925003, -0.2583829462528229, -0.7457040548324585, -0.14707447588443756, 0.22130462527275085, 0.21973000466823578, 0.27169159054756165, -0.15115217864513397, 0.0018683552043512464, -0.06048249453306198, 0.13277272880077362, 0.33179518580436707, 0.6580621004104614, -0.394741028547287, 0.014528190717101097, 0.3868766129016876, -0.6279767155647278, 0.21058766543865204, 0.5460119247436523, 0.2535763680934906, -0.3307828903198242, 0.3839667737483978, -0.4982229471206665, -0.519585132598877, -0.9774358868598938, 0.08476711064577103, 0.23373167216777802, 0.3807898163795471, -0.19711919128894806, -0.5153846740722656, -0.7653586864471436, -0.43422752618789673, 0.6488637924194336, -0.28697171807289124, 0.8560752868652344, -0.5153388381004333, 0.5748468041419983, 0.44593846797943115, -0.26204660534858704, -0.35127148032188416, -0.48263582587242126, 0.3068380653858185, 0.07816621661186218, 0.619484007358551, 1.0683609247207642, -1.3932247161865234, -0.7812148928642273, -0.5323643088340759, 1.411680817604065, 0.6080070734024048, 0.49755677580833435, 0.7542572617530823, -0.36256325244903564, 0.4226563572883606, -0.8671590685844421, -0.29387959837913513, -0.12935613095760345, -0.14801666140556335, -0.5227028131484985, -0.48401087522506714, 0.13907213509082794, 0.44409072399139404, 0.18936429917812347, 0.3715544641017914, -0.45076900720596313, 0.18307189643383026, 0.5082099437713623, 0.7152966260910034, 0.07766786217689514, 0.5084967017173767, -0.12950000166893005, -0.25262612104415894, -0.4106692969799042, -0.14504095911979675, 0.049349188804626465, -0.38191813230514526, 0.034681353718042374, -0.6774635314941406, -0.3517559766769409, -0.4591119885444641, 0.49872517585754395, 0.4983763098716736, -0.4068728983402252, 0.2308223694562912, -0.02464386261999607, 0.03443991020321846, -0.6270521879196167, -0.37227728962898254, 0.15280982851982117, 0.7647529244422913, 0.23897841572761536, -0.7708609104156494, 0.06452615559101105, -0.24945303797721863, 0.6189865469932556, 0.555953860282898, -0.7858009934425354, -0.638232409954071, -0.6077173352241516, 0.12077338248491287, -0.597707986831665, -0.2589465081691742, 1.1902685165405273, 0.06876500695943832, 0.3695233166217804, -0.4247365891933441, -0.9925016760826111, 0.7468580007553101, -0.31464195251464844, 0.23715068399906158, -0.2416439652442932, 0.21701742708683014, -0.030176175758242607, 0.5156208276748657, -0.19477196037769318, -0.8477916717529297, -0.578568160533905, -0.30824917554855347, 0.14259324967861176, -0.048675283789634705, -0.1536097228527069, 0.19929146766662598, -0.4779294729232788, -0.36428573727607727, 0.93866366147995, 0.06154296547174454, 0.2635209560394287, 0.39661744236946106, 0.42119064927101135, -0.6554908752441406, -0.39930781722068787, 0.04910143092274666, 0.37957102060317993, 0.384052038192749, 0.5047913193702698, 0.36716145277023315, -0.048886727541685104, 0.16900302469730377, 0.0165039524435997, 0.03348977118730545, 0.4259447157382965, -0.35569578409194946, -0.6908615231513977, -0.33616453409194946, -0.561824381351471, -0.9296294450759888, -0.7261088490486145, 0.47442153096199036, -0.0012933185789734125, 1.0618412494659424, 0.6554846167564392, -0.7561572790145874, -0.4288734197616577, -0.24281631410121918, -0.4734300673007965, -0.035072531551122665, -0.5373418927192688, -0.02118474617600441, 0.47062933444976807, -1.0372895002365112, -0.4188401699066162, 0.5337733030319214, -0.07209395617246628, -0.3155067563056946, 0.28401926159858704, -0.2830386757850647, -0.30307433009147644, 0.00602013198658824, -0.08949777483940125, 0.8181250691413879, -0.04332564026117325, 0.3285805284976959, -0.2223074585199356, -0.29533588886260986, -0.33113494515419006, -0.24097803235054016, 0.46675875782966614, -0.4417770802974701, -0.3034736216068268, -0.14492201805114746, 0.14297309517860413, 0.32830220460891724, -0.19270378351211548, -0.46105480194091797, -0.7831369042396545, 0.5597476959228516, -0.13676851987838745, -0.528656542301178, 0.12122797220945358, 1.1143989562988281, 0.020799869671463966, -0.2584787905216217, 0.03580699861049652, -0.7341170907020569, 0.25690585374832153, 0.12776543200016022, 0.17342987656593323, -0.671499490737915, -0.39433181285858154, -0.2117462158203125, 0.41205552220344543, 0.20603792369365692, 0.5210489630699158, -0.2776279151439667, -0.5045811533927917, -0.1750633269548416, -0.4708271026611328, 0.05232095718383789, -0.31769877672195435, -0.10167322307825089, -0.2805675268173218, -0.36341094970703125, -1.1585026979446411, 0.8877536654472351, -0.31564298272132874, -0.1305917650461197, 0.427068293094635, 0.16579872369766235, 0.17910708487033844, 0.9026690125465393, 0.3775516748428345, -0.11276377737522125, -0.47073987126350403, 0.3698466122150421, -0.44857051968574524, 0.44540873169898987, -0.8606219291687012, 0.16206695139408112, -1.32306969165802, 0.6484460830688477, -0.39714184403419495, -0.32861074805259705, 0.07048686593770981, -0.1395663470029831, 1.3330614566802979, -0.7064159512519836, 0.22608715295791626, 0.3748128414154053, 0.4273225963115692, 0.7386949062347412, 0.18506652116775513, -0.7079032063484192, -0.5551447868347168, -0.4584973156452179, -0.7862139940261841, 0.6657441854476929, 0.4063364565372467, 0.22199594974517822, -0.3713591694831848, -0.44597965478897095, 0.4843442738056183, -0.09747381508350372, 0.5620582103729248, 0.05118342489004135, -0.20002661645412445, -0.09041037410497665, 0.20008410513401031, -0.2342318296432495, -0.0366642139852047, -0.4055056571960449, -0.07433590292930603, -0.24616912007331848, -0.3504973351955414, 0.1540038138628006, -0.08920486271381378, -1.1580572128295898, -0.5689685940742493, 0.6894745230674744, 0.8077682256698608, -0.046386606991291046, 0.5482794046401978, 0.0473148413002491, -0.7692461609840393, -0.44397109746932983, 0.09512632340192795, -0.4398622214794159, 0.6917728185653687, 0.45617589354515076, -0.009024572558701038, 0.21000133454799652, 0.3915885090827942, 0.16929906606674194, -0.14620231091976166, 0.12925009429454803, 0.5718264579772949, -0.17150555551052094, -0.3442878723144531, 0.21642577648162842, 0.33451247215270996, -0.38477471470832825, -0.24914582073688507, -0.8004168272018433, -0.4361925721168518, 0.6380935311317444, -0.5063216090202332, -0.027199996635317802, -0.17931540310382843, -0.22628939151763916, -0.12102892994880676, 0.8540984988212585, 0.1966964155435562, 0.06969448924064636, -0.1736794412136078, -0.8254432678222656, -0.31101083755493164, -0.5869872570037842, 1.6011425256729126, -0.5696690082550049, -0.6205781102180481, -0.06975259631872177, -0.40015679597854614, -0.8598899245262146, -0.049506813287734985, 0.06974324584007263, 0.40264514088630676, 0.46489548683166504, 0.11847858130931854, 0.32468777894973755, 0.34725329279899597, 0.6808046698570251, 0.26564061641693115, -0.16712631285190582, -0.018929164856672287, -0.7077071070671082, 0.037623293697834015, -0.04359498992562294, 0.2295127511024475, 0.18389002978801727, -0.48644641041755676, 0.18575435876846313, -0.15403136610984802, -0.22408007085323334, -0.11908616125583649, -0.9910377264022827, 0.0888885036110878, -0.9855945110321045, -0.4006405472755432, -0.632681667804718, -0.4140152633190155, 0.07584928721189499, 0.23249314725399017, -0.3289251923561096, 0.04553159698843956, -1.1736397743225098, -0.12443041056394577, 0.5874413251876831, 0.4774922728538513, -0.2578675448894501, -0.6490076184272766, -0.9523552656173706, 0.23918846249580383, -0.17175038158893585, 0.1159684956073761, -0.20694614946842194, 0.32583120465278625, -0.3440702557563782, 0.17812131345272064, -0.10429392755031586, 0.7885022163391113, -0.5404796004295349, -0.414588063955307, 0.31135472655296326, 0.10376115143299103, -0.214791402220726, 0.3951214849948883, 0.3491474986076355, 0.2187088131904602, 0.15009135007858276, -0.6397740840911865, 0.3506309688091278, 0.5575782656669617, -0.8667652010917664, -0.35160037875175476, -0.06933004409074783, 0.21272225677967072, 0.13651159405708313, -0.8730833530426025, 0.42036449909210205, 0.6547861695289612, -0.7571266293525696, 0.23131918907165527, 0.08236610889434814, 0.46045535802841187, -0.20654109120368958, -0.47254085540771484, -0.08746738731861115, 0.6419216990470886, -0.6789020895957947, 0.8086669445037842, -0.5827999711036682, -0.6906265020370483, -0.07055168598890305, -0.22769899666309357, -0.4172191321849823, 0.0283754114061594, 0.5853532552719116, -1.4166181087493896, 0.07126155495643616, 0.3063804507255554, -0.367704302072525, 0.41097739338874817, 0.24962522089481354, -0.2520028054714203, -0.7230002284049988, -0.5082465410232544, -0.5331728458404541, 0.47756069898605347, 0.262902170419693, -0.34103021025657654, -0.31729835271835327, -0.7608891725540161, -0.3849429786205292, -0.2077573537826538, -0.11532816290855408, -0.0875655859708786, -0.31324175000190735, -0.11574579030275345, -0.6265908479690552, -0.30010029673576355, -0.22966261208057404, 0.2450571209192276, 0.2114495486021042, 0.1630396693944931, -0.3989240229129791, -0.02482840232551098, -0.5522649884223938, 0.03670718893408775, -1.2350724935531616, 0.24906030297279358, -0.18954351544380188, 0.8526806235313416, 0.22656412422657013, -0.37055477499961853, -0.30186909437179565, 0.3408176302909851, -0.2861994206905365, -0.12902125716209412, 0.1300203949213028, 0.058807387948036194, -0.2411513328552246, -0.18432728946208954, 0.42471590638160706, -0.18543630838394165, -0.19813211262226105, 0.7457348108291626, 0.07532312721014023, -0.6393956542015076, 0.6594851016998291, 0.17026667296886444, 0.13477247953414917, -0.21784503757953644, -0.08517534285783768, 0.5140421986579895, 0.026612479239702225, -0.7131115198135376, 0.2782255709171295, 0.2215961366891861, 0.5087601542472839, 0.010289299301803112, -0.6027930378913879, -0.14450296759605408, 0.23745262622833252, 0.2643892467021942, 0.6392022371292114, 0.4768957495689392, 0.1968952715396881, 0.6144692301750183, 0.13969987630844116, 0.14800481498241425, -0.2839895784854889, 0.45409640669822693, -0.3127007484436035, 0.6720138788223267, 0.07349343597888947, 0.960374653339386, 0.057983171194791794, 0.18127484619617462, 0.3642060160636902, -0.049360647797584534, -0.23539376258850098, 0.692392885684967, 0.3721810281276703, 0.7172195911407471, -0.8106906414031982, -0.061496805399656296, -0.312554270029068, -0.1665915846824646, -0.00667468411847949, 0.5327005982398987, 0.35680535435676575, 0.38460513949394226, 0.9075440764427185, 0.3861471712589264, -0.21595598757266998, 0.3696756958961487, 0.8196560144424438, 0.63772052526474, 0.4176402986049652, 0.5409846305847168, 0.7535973787307739, 0.6006917953491211, 0.08640221506357193, -0.45862293243408203, -0.19552655518054962, 0.9716636538505554, -0.8872148990631104, 0.07190519571304321, -0.14237836003303528, -0.1283876597881317, -0.14204050600528717, -0.9668557643890381, 0.26421239972114563, -0.741910994052887, 0.486569881439209, 1.1171656847000122, -0.46267515420913696, 0.38090789318084717, 0.4474943280220032, 0.009325835853815079, 0.5071269273757935, 0.8056294322013855, 0.14768041670322418, -0.49538302421569824, 1.1162008047103882, 0.9357550740242004, 0.37586137652397156, 0.4491179585456848, 0.3630669116973877, -0.5212274789810181, -0.0748998299241066, -0.04828278347849846, -0.8620505332946777, 0.7437487244606018, -0.6107563972473145, -0.36790356040000916, 0.6476389169692993, 0.45397236943244934, -0.152536079287529, 0.21794062852859497, 0.0986555889248848, 0.4601217210292816, -0.11304300278425217, -0.4341440796852112, 1.2186527252197266, -0.018308263272047043, 0.2706291675567627, -0.11953337490558624, 0.04642268642783165, 0.3475741147994995, -0.4345475137233734, -0.2802707850933075, 0.10849259793758392, 0.40774646401405334, 0.6096013784408569, 0.0964297205209732, -0.5751401782035828, -0.5749703645706177, -1.1748837232589722, -0.465251624584198, -0.5339570045471191, 0.446941077709198, 0.09501199424266815, 0.9116338491439819, -0.2563007175922394, -0.8744502663612366, -0.14110945165157318, 0.009998499415814877, 0.8402469158172607, -0.1508508324623108, -0.010820689611136913, 0.41759124398231506, 0.28419339656829834, -0.581488847732544, 0.8307034969329834, 0.9200239777565002, -0.5306702256202698, 0.5122847557067871, -0.6020504832267761, 0.45614147186279297, 0.4690271317958832, -0.550024688243866, 0.06804212182760239, 0.2175099104642868, 1.1400253772735596, -0.3652611970901489, -0.6904097199440002, -0.148390993475914, -0.6830337047576904, -0.10935286432504654, -1.001489520072937, 0.16471290588378906, 0.3103550374507904, 0.31783270835876465, 0.6125324964523315, -0.26185300946235657, 4.27134895324707, 0.3764984607696533, 0.672568678855896, 0.361125111579895, 0.621429979801178, 0.7965205311775208, 0.030472470447421074, -0.5929417014122009, 0.7068921327590942, -0.32930344343185425, -0.3885352909564972, 0.5077386498451233, -0.166238471865654, -0.30710461735725403, -0.2618087828159332, 0.4022377133369446, -0.1441422402858734, 0.0676547959446907, -0.173870250582695, -0.9474624991416931, -0.10811764746904373, -0.3176257014274597, 0.0918409675359726, -0.22298447787761688, 0.224568173289299, 0.27781322598457336, -0.030183790251612663, -0.4645973742008209, -0.7638587355613708, -0.7214014530181885, -0.44706714153289795, -0.6129405498504639, 0.28354349732398987, -0.05480778217315674, -0.490958571434021, 0.30745697021484375, 0.4561971426010132, -0.04271189868450165, 0.6573083400726318, 0.7305456399917603, -0.17279167473316193, -0.9131250977516174, 0.009237890131771564, -0.11041967570781708, -1.0085649490356445, 0.2895794212818146, -0.6475207209587097, 1.1887292861938477, 0.026902437210083008, -0.6141632795333862, 0.6647794842720032, -0.1383756697177887, -0.09365607053041458, 0.23609711229801178, -1.0549784898757935, 0.12211386859416962, -0.6756157875061035, -0.557682454586029, -0.2525981068611145, -0.08996126055717468, 1.1241744756698608, 0.05273280665278435, -0.3702108561992645, 0.48513519763946533, -0.16409832239151, 0.27012303471565247, 0.32319381833076477, 0.16638851165771484, -0.15723244845867157, 0.2940117418766022, -0.5022861361503601, -0.048253994435071945, -0.6388287544250488, -0.08889827132225037, 0.11254581809043884, -0.03246982768177986, 0.07418863475322723, 0.5106207132339478, 0.04154592007398605, 0.46463486552238464, 0.5367195010185242, -0.16530661284923553, -0.40524011850357056, 0.03531573340296745, 0.3390977084636688, 0.9507788419723511, -0.5393919348716736, -0.05222175642848015, -0.6409037709236145, 0.5285153985023499, 0.5100013017654419, 1.1446754932403564, -0.22496025264263153, 0.40624335408210754, -0.7354605793952942 ]
Directed Polymer Blends and Quantum Critical Phenomena
The statistical mechanics of directed line-like objects, such as directed polymers in an external field, strands of dipoles in both ferro- and electrorheological fluids, and flux lines in high-$T_{\tiny C}$ superconductors bears a close resemblance to the quantum mechanics of bosons in $2+1$ dimensions. We show that single component and binary mixture critical phenomena in these systems are in the universality class of three dimensional uniaxial dipolar ferromagnets and ferroelectrics. Our results also apply to films of two superfluid species undergoing phase separation well below their $\lambda$-points near $T=0$. In the case of directed polymers and electrorheological fluids we analyze the effects of free ends occurring in the sample as well as a novel directionally-dependent compressibility.
Randall D. Kamien and David R. Nelson
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206006
cond-mat/9206007
[ 0.3721899092197418, 0.14342370629310608, 0.36353957653045654, -0.03970896825194359, 0.6100487112998962, -0.6904499530792236, 0.2813825309276581, -0.5576504468917847, -1.0292558670043945, 1.501849889755249, 1.152260661125183, -0.6330989003181458, 0.6563068628311157, -1.0235322713851929, -0.3026715815067291, 0.3202429413795471, -0.1676284670829773, -0.6422065496444702, -1.0479110479354858, 0.09748485684394836, 0.317420095205307, -0.0215211920440197, -0.635780930519104, -0.7274211049079895, -0.8198930621147156, 0.33038830757141113, 0.20884063839912415, 0.47606346011161804, 1.1405792236328125, 0.37148594856262207, 0.22891497611999512, -0.7818412184715271, -0.07294056564569473, -0.5504663586616516, -0.14494584500789642, 0.06597807258367538, 0.0027389577589929104, -0.2471812218427658, 0.7632208466529846, -0.05299624055624008, 1.1400837898254395, 0.06361140310764313, 1.0101478099822998, 0.36810237169265747, -0.8882227540016174, -0.12815816700458527, -0.8335137367248535, 0.43083637952804565, -0.15194763243198395, -1.188370943069458, 0.2873256206512451, 0.10312257707118988, 0.6411001086235046, -0.3248891234397888, -0.09275676310062408, -0.2121203988790512, 0.2279587835073471, -0.31738489866256714, 0.4152633547782898, -0.4277029037475586, 0.2821294367313385, -0.49603840708732605, 0.7640454173088074, -0.6983502507209778, 0.00014048904995433986, 0.45632317662239075, -0.4603710472583771, 0.936021625995636, -0.39083999395370483, -0.6420586109161377, -0.4187264144420624, -0.29756203293800354, -0.37249231338500977, 0.17470042407512665, -1.0407463312149048, 0.056417226791381836, 0.030443314462900162, -0.3965148627758026, -1.6994551420211792, -0.40202897787094116, -0.03967079520225525, -0.07641401886940002, -0.3101087510585785, 0.27058446407318115, 0.22947506606578827, 0.32005906105041504, -0.3634064793586731, -0.4982496500015259, -0.1785072535276413, 0.1884697675704956, 0.35747790336608887, 0.8339831829071045, -0.10847324132919312, -0.050663601607084274, 0.578120768070221, 0.8715341687202454, 0.1174740344285965, 0.1590908169746399, 0.04783377796411514, 0.29154786467552185, -0.19785639643669128, 0.1502290815114975, 0.17902185022830963, 1.0945311784744263, -0.4017620384693146, 0.6816707253456116, 0.22238515317440033, 0.14300160109996796, 0.07162103801965714, -0.6941796541213989, 0.0237931776791811, -0.11709209531545639, 0.7822300791740417, 0.7513545751571655, -0.3147027790546417, 0.3966209292411804, 0.19447070360183716, 0.0831373780965805, -1.195469856262207, -0.13326428830623627, 0.18838346004486084, -0.5097706317901611, 1.112683653831482, 0.8168972730636597, -0.4839749336242676, -0.20338907837867737, 0.8580108284950256, 0.6565970778465271, -0.5438650846481323, 0.43290743231773376, 0.3079491853713989, 0.09480927139520645, 0.6941820383071899, 0.4528602361679077, -1.0411536693572998, 0.5389760136604309, -0.32494187355041504, 0.28969958424568176, 0.3545469045639038, -0.28618332743644714, 0.8017769455909729, -0.9029431939125061, 0.7371219992637634, 0.4935377240180969, -0.2309032380580902, 0.01991831324994564, 0.8235816359519958, 0.09457845240831375, 0.08398891240358353, 0.37587225437164307, -0.0869232565164566, -0.38359203934669495, 0.039073240011930466, 1.0665168762207031, 0.1367058902978897, 0.5871768593788147, -0.13981401920318604, 0.41246429085731506, -0.5637719631195068, -0.8349021673202515, 0.49099767208099365, -0.12200203537940979, -0.21556363999843597, 0.2518135905265808, 0.1847062110900879, 0.14253447949886322, -0.21694910526275635, -0.45976004004478455, 0.14041638374328613, -0.41788771748542786, 0.14372007548809052, 0.19576098024845123, -0.055951181799173355, 0.8038213849067688, -0.1303691267967224, -0.08139684051275253, 0.8890427350997925, -0.20868290960788727, -0.08259645104408264, -0.0506000891327858, -0.8192027807235718, 0.17596395313739777, 1.348044753074646, 0.10460927337408066, -0.462672621011734, -0.5128881931304932, -0.3813195526599884, -0.34926939010620117, 0.120622418820858, 0.1901404708623886, -0.2620946168899536, 0.03758350759744644, -0.07815013825893402, 0.23826879262924194, -0.5125644207000732, -0.20687410235404968, -1.0521053075790405, 0.6889464855194092, -0.624234676361084, -0.7400952577590942, -0.753114640712738, 0.30889394879341125, -0.9227262139320374, 0.1244707703590393, -1.5199121236801147, 0.23441632091999054, 0.2980099618434906, 0.7495666742324829, -0.40702661871910095, 0.03537396714091301, 0.22849997878074646, -0.05690228193998337, 0.6875041127204895, -0.4062858521938324, 0.06385540962219238, 0.2669735550880432, 0.2817894518375397, 0.21478092670440674, 0.2869049310684204, 0.022284042090177536, 0.4664574861526489, 0.3347199559211731, -0.15499372780323029, 1.093837857246399, -0.252547025680542, -0.41298046708106995, 0.5051344633102417, 0.841214656829834, 0.25848856568336487, -0.15707670152187347, 0.4071931838989258, 0.5026504993438721, 0.08709554374217987, 0.1529620736837387, 0.521735429763794, 0.3603838086128235, -0.20941615104675293, 0.5594257116317749, 0.7229158282279968, 0.15484654903411865, -0.4607691168785095, -0.4129912257194519, 0.1949152946472168, 0.014302985742688179, 0.00496064405888319, -0.4282027781009674, -0.7902749180793762, 0.2870877981185913, -0.8555896878242493, 0.747342050075531, -0.310967355966568, -0.015631554648280144, -0.7482928037643433, 0.3052414655685425, -1.496137261390686, -0.1924210637807846, 0.043681446462869644, 0.018249964341521263, -0.5268391370773315, 0.1511634886264801, 0.4215492606163025, 0.44579023122787476, -0.6054200530052185, -0.5715687870979309, 0.17736279964447021, 0.5689842104911804, 0.2570911645889282, 0.24767367541790009, -0.5606473088264465, -0.49692970514297485, -0.6229261755943298, -0.4381308853626251, -1.0816378593444824, -0.12705250084400177, -1.1631215810775757, -0.13702571392059326, 0.43484944105148315, -1.3591525554656982, 0.7390169501304626, 0.1515224128961563, -0.3308291733264923, 0.8301118612289429, -0.024168021976947784, 0.7700170278549194, 0.3828445076942444, 0.2125857174396515, -0.8221877813339233, -0.20379246771335602, -0.6528076529502869, 0.32086655497550964, -0.08182338625192642, 0.13706016540527344, 1.210598111152649, -0.06426873058080673, 0.6690026521682739, -0.8887101411819458, -0.7158815860748291, 0.028092844411730766, 0.023309694603085518, -0.2729218304157257, -0.025918005034327507, 0.7212010622024536, -0.21814695000648499, 0.25715771317481995, -1.0957608222961426, 1.1968305110931396, -0.11311066895723343, -0.815901517868042, 0.36482924222946167, 0.15719106793403625, -0.47124379873275757, 0.443196564912796, 0.03894408419728279, -0.31302976608276367, 0.0674477070569992, 0.38451072573661804, 0.24388279020786285, -0.44328150153160095, -0.5957494378089905, -0.7060468792915344, -0.15866701304912567, 0.47190526127815247, -0.15528425574302673, -0.5758760571479797, -0.2682298421859741, 0.9377871155738831, 0.5364929437637329, -0.079238660633564, 0.1295759230852127, -1.502837896347046, -0.6166466474533081, -0.4316585063934326, -0.4052937626838684, 0.4499734044075012, -0.20390693843364716, 0.6157812476158142, -0.7432878017425537, 0.07066576927900314, 1.1886829137802124, 0.6576405167579651, 0.2751455008983612, -0.25078219175338745, 0.6102420091629028, 0.26982274651527405, 0.3461924195289612, -0.10976516455411911, 0.10423639416694641, -0.49687060713768005, -0.549907386302948, 0.20141993463039398, -0.21159161627292633, 0.290055513381958, 0.2738799750804901, 0.17668595910072327, 0.5514740943908691, 0.81344074010849, -0.8677521347999573, -0.19086390733718872, 0.15334060788154602, 0.4008413255214691, 0.7644487023353577, 0.8102148771286011, -0.18368194997310638, 0.07825016230344772, -0.9839208126068115, 0.5370208024978638, -0.0009728462318889797, 0.5462103486061096, 0.4043867588043213, -0.12414103001356125, 1.03342866897583, -0.023913737386465073, -0.6980839967727661, 0.4752325117588043, 0.02206149883568287, 0.08041896671056747, 0.4394606351852417, 0.6760652661323547, 0.925852358341217, -0.7721253633499146, -0.18469493091106415, -0.2464076727628708, 1.9248332977294922, 0.49975377321243286, 0.5977179408073425, 0.7358604669570923, 0.25043025612831116, -0.32101815938949585, -1.0561736822128296, -0.4052927494049072, -0.40355533361434937, 0.06207992136478424, -0.5400517582893372, -0.5475942492485046, 0.23464690148830414, -0.2994367182254791, 0.5140273571014404, 0.1629885882139206, 0.619185745716095, -0.21524861454963684, 1.154152274131775, 0.9642860889434814, 0.10596522688865662, 0.7447939515113831, -0.583113968372345, -0.508330762386322, -0.5021845698356628, 0.3333144783973694, 0.28691011667251587, 0.39165201783180237, -0.3409867584705353, -0.32369086146354675, -0.2296382635831833, -0.49031469225883484, 0.08625800162553787, 0.43998390436172485, -0.059818822890520096, 0.6672916412353516, 0.5107885003089905, 0.7175456881523132, -0.5804663896560669, 0.09586240351200104, 0.11504748463630676, 0.3863764703273773, 0.6042633056640625, -0.853445291519165, 0.09092778712511063, -0.22634060680866241, 0.6930116415023804, 1.000618815422058, -0.6682459712028503, -0.9496985673904419, -0.4594942033290863, 0.7013156414031982, -0.20767605304718018, -0.5565204620361328, 1.0808184146881104, 0.5473111271858215, 0.5191932320594788, -0.22249023616313934, -0.10617702454328537, 1.0321221351623535, -0.8776057362556458, -0.27797558903694153, -0.42892420291900635, -0.34293121099472046, -0.6893129944801331, 0.010670751333236694, -0.07107636332511902, -0.22366762161254883, -0.3476986885070801, -0.46324622631073, -0.5410155057907104, -0.5066099762916565, -0.7873774766921997, -0.3301108777523041, -0.036329369992017746, -0.7886427640914917, -0.2411620169878006, 0.5019123554229736, -0.12192530930042267, -0.32818859815597534, 0.5357303023338318, -0.01986013539135456, -0.4992721974849701, 0.00879698060452938, 0.45441892743110657, 1.0469845533370972, 0.8192991018295288, 0.6381739377975464, 0.5713003873825073, 0.42513152956962585, 0.25455254316329956, 0.42862144112586975, 0.41101372241973877, -0.03802589327096939, -0.43642449378967285, -0.5477741956710815, 0.0660708025097847, -0.6778134107589722, -0.9971954822540283, -0.1433742344379425, -0.37769651412963867, 0.41649913787841797, 0.6581500172615051, -0.38309118151664734, -1.1536645889282227, -0.3989275395870209, -1.472118616104126, -0.1631428301334381, -0.45167484879493713, -0.5404229164123535, 0.2783468961715698, 0.4020737111568451, -0.5900694727897644, 0.04149323329329491, -0.6585545539855957, -0.3914066255092621, -0.03981957212090492, 0.5729804039001465, 0.28167903423309326, 1.2172117233276367, 0.17278796434402466, 0.43202298879623413, -0.587671160697937, 0.5480279922485352, -0.3149771988391876, -0.6500112414360046, -0.4607190489768982, -0.35296252369880676, -1.1333082914352417, -0.1267903745174408, -0.3997032046318054, -0.2501594126224518, 0.08851495385169983, 0.011646037921309471, -0.20092381536960602, -0.5161292552947998, -1.1350250244140625, 0.15909123420715332, 0.17684701085090637, -0.0877724140882492, -0.09392557293176651, 0.35148173570632935, 0.31540539860725403, -0.2145315706729889, 0.08497777581214905, -0.5583698153495789, 0.4145500659942627, 0.24293671548366547, 0.5206660032272339, -1.641263484954834, 0.10168690234422684, -0.6721780300140381, -0.4509952962398529, -0.32710403203964233, 0.5833307504653931, -0.03691093996167183, -0.2128283679485321, -0.01228181179612875, -0.4443640112876892, -0.7439228892326355, -0.6028331518173218, -0.07129517197608948, -0.16223181784152985, -0.683708131313324, -0.7102271318435669, 0.3740885853767395, -0.006375154014676809, 0.4344956874847412, 0.9520677924156189, -0.6935387849807739, -0.2262479066848755, 0.6971625685691833, 0.18893001973628998, 0.21309800446033478, -0.5826860666275024, 0.4222180247306824, 0.3129171133041382, -0.15603435039520264, -0.49551573395729065, 0.35338956117630005, -1.3102858066558838, 1.1716026067733765, -0.41121676564216614, -0.28593870997428894, 0.27932655811309814, 0.7428726553916931, 0.5388461947441101, -0.7314983606338501, 0.0453340969979763, -0.1405147910118103, 0.1559111326932907, 0.473918080329895, -0.1742439717054367, 0.09740375727415085, -0.6579837203025818, -0.635240375995636, -0.923231840133667, 0.8955518007278442, 0.28583407402038574, 0.5264981389045715, -0.18098804354667664, -0.5672380328178406, 0.2655819058418274, 0.08404193818569183, 0.15310914814472198, 0.26567739248275757, 0.2853931486606598, -0.23047637939453125, -0.4625794589519501, 0.1550653576850891, -0.12153516709804535, -0.6137025356292725, -0.6545622944831848, -0.12213913351297379, -0.25847768783569336, 0.6652716398239136, -0.21612493693828583, -0.6181658506393433, -0.3305796682834625, 0.3066164553165436, -0.02068297006189823, -0.27809688448905945, 0.4590557813644409, -0.17820033431053162, 0.11954347789287567, -0.21687547862529755, -0.10345616936683655, -0.021894723176956177, 0.3755507171154022, 0.41247570514678955, 0.39486685395240784, 0.9596610069274902, -0.26543259620666504, 1.0314316749572754, -0.11613985896110535, 0.20525482296943665, 1.0625070333480835, -0.6437204480171204, 0.18142005801200867, 0.4841422438621521, 0.2700157165527344, -1.0246318578720093, -0.16589246690273285, -0.5716570615768433, -0.1657237857580185, 0.244829922914505, -0.8114843964576721, -0.26148709654808044, -0.7428761720657349, -0.4803716540336609, 0.19330723583698273, 0.5422520637512207, 0.2602144479751587, 0.20913849771022797, 0.262843519449234, -0.328671932220459, -0.36711400747299194, -0.1188606396317482, 0.8840405344963074, -0.49078884720802307, -0.5532674789428711, -0.4600898027420044, -0.3353438079357147, -0.6817703247070312, -0.015589503571391106, 0.8215807676315308, -0.051856301724910736, 0.611312210559845, 0.6227283477783203, 0.04121360927820206, 0.38852065801620483, -0.15995101630687714, -0.14333538711071014, -0.6702782511711121, -0.26932308077812195, -0.33176955580711365, -0.9532678723335266, -0.8210446834564209, 0.6116427183151245, 0.2551412582397461, -0.7576291561126709, 0.06633804738521576, -0.1178826242685318, -0.643883228302002, -0.19242186844348907, -0.9096624255180359, 0.08013268560171127, -1.5470051765441895, -0.3715256452560425, -0.8451219201087952, -0.42872440814971924, 0.11391092091798782, 0.8131604790687561, -0.5412644147872925, 0.10056431591510773, -1.1938925981521606, -0.5622649192810059, -0.057151634246110916, 0.15157292783260345, -0.29476428031921387, -0.7307227253913879, -0.6852511167526245, 0.227369487285614, -0.09527339041233063, 0.5146356225013733, 0.0898047685623169, -0.8862679600715637, 0.265779584646225, 0.6493834853172302, -0.20088699460029602, 1.012726068496704, -0.6071965098381042, -0.6135572195053101, 0.22108058631420135, -0.42818132042884827, -1.051376223564148, -0.14992345869541168, 0.1466236412525177, 0.26485252380371094, -0.39372748136520386, 0.47757408022880554, 0.5946465730667114, -0.3800874352455139, -0.4706971049308777, 0.11273856461048126, -0.5351184606552124, -0.3871687650680542, -0.0661441758275032, -0.7437558770179749, 0.018615247681736946, 0.4548989236354828, -0.6193406581878662, 0.04721774905920029, -0.5072908997535706, -0.4957558512687683, -0.02104560285806656, 0.11087774485349655, -0.02517598681151867, -0.07358931005001068, 0.07596859335899353, 0.8201616406440735, 0.036872051656246185, -0.20392097532749176, 0.21720397472381592, 0.5010946393013, -0.3361559510231018, 0.9154464602470398, 0.17989541590213776, 0.12904320657253265, -0.10945776849985123, 0.12014821916818619, -0.44738444685935974, 0.6091610789299011, 0.23811762034893036, -0.20026595890522003, -0.6524056196212769, -0.5627146363258362, -0.25742965936660767, 0.08741672337055206, 0.11800272017717361, -0.6587734818458557, -1.1541386842727661, -0.3027108907699585, -0.6240206360816956, -0.3308752179145813, -0.7305150628089905, -0.1635582447052002, -0.18541857600212097, -0.680173933506012, -0.05841052904725075, -0.1752694696187973, -0.2915947139263153, 0.796535313129425, 0.12235569208860397, 0.6090954542160034, 0.010871031321585178, -0.014230087399482727, -0.185199573636055, 0.309457004070282, -0.847895085811615, -0.2899317443370819, -0.7059029340744019, 0.20968672633171082, 0.0020012708846479654, -1.171364665031433, 0.050179362297058105, 0.5887627005577087, -0.19062592089176178, -0.27034083008766174, -0.004474349785596132, -0.4290597438812256, -0.1653105765581131, 0.5389785170555115, -0.007351966574788094, 0.029761865735054016, 0.07013067603111267, 0.9789142608642578, 0.13468864560127258, 0.32719817757606506, 0.6801228523254395, 0.6137353777885437, -0.5523588061332703, -0.3788139224052429, -0.090976282954216, 1.196597695350647, 0.3380773365497589, -0.38015231490135193, 1.026370644569397, -0.3315274119377136, 0.7314555048942566, 0.11675857752561569, -0.22694824635982513, -0.08019835501909256, 0.7128869295120239, 0.11190082877874374, 0.8808054327964783, 0.6814713478088379, -0.015574313700199127, 0.5530931949615479, 0.15620675683021545, 0.13821165263652802, 0.5170615911483765, 0.8077932596206665, 0.4983298182487488, 0.7026941776275635, -0.397701621055603, 0.07536545395851135, -0.21826104819774628, 0.46149852871894836, -0.00023801271163392812, 0.3315350115299225, -0.18704622983932495, 0.03687044978141785, 0.2631560266017914, 0.15680359303951263, -0.5041712522506714, -0.21698199212551117, -0.40225934982299805, -0.30018290877342224, -0.12956932187080383, 0.5544392466545105, 0.5568200945854187, 0.40148669481277466, 0.4272773861885071, 0.009737711399793625, 0.46785324811935425, 0.7221556901931763, 0.34737318754196167, 0.42475637793540955, 0.5753862857818604, 0.9219358563423157, 0.5434522032737732, 0.486859530210495, 0.37369999289512634, -0.4553000330924988, -0.02970261685550213, 0.5342045426368713, -1.1864656209945679, -0.04752587899565697, -0.23718217015266418, -0.605878472328186, 0.22287362813949585, -0.814085066318512, 0.07676849514245987, -0.31499630212783813, 0.2963225543498993, 0.4076291620731354, -0.27374574542045593, 0.08432625979185104, 0.6481860876083374, 0.044322870671749115, 0.29220131039619446, 0.5633490085601807, 0.3842426538467407, -0.11384309083223343, 0.7558748126029968, 1.125223159790039, -0.5604947209358215, 0.6500241756439209, 0.7854027152061462, -0.3509044945240021, -0.223392054438591, 0.119833804666996, -0.024346573278307915, 0.8086135983467102, 0.029167016968131065, -0.7950076460838318, 0.5362600684165955, 0.8772721290588379, 0.016000527888536453, 0.5107702016830444, 0.46014654636383057, 0.5588529706001282, -0.745858907699585, -0.03751717880368233, 1.1914138793945312, 0.2513662874698639, -0.27644437551498413, -0.6449469923973083, -0.4179331362247467, -0.35245174169540405, 0.04253023862838745, -1.3036396503448486, 0.953123152256012, 0.12604840099811554, -0.10527072846889496, 0.07460200041532516, -0.48853152990341187, 0.009241197258234024, -1.1406900882720947, 0.163377046585083, -0.7524433135986328, 0.0559164434671402, 0.1818496733903885, 0.14171534776687622, -0.3548039197921753, -0.7903873920440674, -0.055496469140052795, 0.24447020888328552, 1.06318199634552, -0.4283347725868225, -0.11240750551223755, 0.43011024594306946, 0.1604546159505844, -0.08893391489982605, 0.5931217670440674, 0.5569823384284973, -0.3847796320915222, 0.7518751621246338, -0.7620201706886292, 0.03515555337071419, 0.03572721406817436, 0.1421046108007431, -0.026727324351668358, -0.49465250968933105, 0.3247916102409363, 0.08680600672960281, -0.014034065417945385, -0.0657956674695015, -0.48167261481285095, -0.2479739785194397, -0.5372622013092041, -0.015405610203742981, -0.3007301092147827, 0.2328515201807022, -0.3695365786552429, -0.008616864681243896, 3.940183401107788, 1.4591362476348877, 0.8011911511421204, 0.5830998420715332, 0.9104453921318054, 1.092644214630127, -0.4918852150440216, -0.052888426929712296, -0.07694835960865021, -0.8711397647857666, -0.7090310454368591, 0.20836496353149414, 0.3191350996494293, -0.1792120337486267, -0.497694194316864, 0.7510053515434265, 0.1424603909254074, 0.5862128138542175, -0.16771499812602997, -0.7029653787612915, -0.357505738735199, 0.2879459857940674, 0.48700231313705444, -0.9827437400817871, 0.09550289809703827, 0.22812534868717194, 0.22094371914863586, -0.874459981918335, -0.3406023681163788, -0.33134925365448, -1.0075607299804688, -0.9452457427978516, 0.25388482213020325, -0.23459570109844208, -0.27213403582572937, 0.1532968133687973, -0.12714038789272308, -0.376226544380188, 0.16475315392017365, 0.5149110555648804, -0.4895091950893402, -0.4587792456150055, 0.01673206500709057, -0.22250820696353912, -1.1655985116958618, 0.6395002603530884, -0.5064022541046143, 1.0480209589004517, 0.2547205686569214, -0.7611055374145508, 0.3087131381034851, -0.4040665328502655, 0.3987973630428314, -0.7303578853607178, -0.5465371012687683, 0.38377976417541504, -0.6675271391868591, -0.09783140569925308, 0.28089770674705505, -0.07452951371669769, 0.6202424168586731, -0.07149624824523926, -0.25176921486854553, 0.021311484277248383, 0.39342302083969116, 0.5897954106330872, 0.6584110856056213, -0.16037264466285706, -0.29392337799072266, 0.0033113809768110514, -0.6155719757080078, -0.2806657552719116, -0.7265090346336365, 0.4414910674095154, 0.5003048181533813, 0.3219713568687439, -0.6386544108390808, 0.7965699434280396, 0.45888954401016235, -0.3655884861946106, -0.34883084893226624, -0.4495319128036499, -0.330436646938324, -0.24792806804180145, 0.11459950357675552, 0.6791221499443054, 0.018587158992886543, 0.29568496346473694, -0.298166960477829, 0.6554992198944092, 0.2742336690425873, 1.7143158912658691, 0.3699210286140442, -0.06271277368068695, -1.4802051782608032 ]
New Fermionic Description of Quantum S = 1/2 Antiferromargnet
A novel approach to S =1/2 antiferromagnets with strong fluctuations based on the representation of spin-1/2 operators as bylinear forms of real (Majorana) fermions is suggested. This representation has the advantage of being irreducible without any constraints on the fermionic Hilbert space. This property allows to derive an effective Hamiltonian for low-lying excitations in the spin liquid state. It is proven that these excitations are S = 1 real fermions.
A. M. Tsvelik
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206007
cond-mat/9206008
[ -0.1374695748090744, 0.589418351650238, -0.13794562220573425, 0.5099944472312927, 0.11174056679010391, -0.49620792269706726, 0.09369806945323944, -0.736447811126709, 0.23170459270477295, 1.6149218082427979, 0.07169882953166962, 0.2592325806617737, 0.5433605313301086, -1.0854601860046387, -0.04074470326304436, 0.47799456119537354, -0.5917185544967651, -0.9708110690116882, -1.801500916481018, 0.014332432299852371, -0.45222464203834534, -0.5223003625869751, -0.6681661009788513, -1.3226056098937988, -0.5086859464645386, 0.7133480310440063, -0.27982786297798157, 0.46555793285369873, 0.23449641466140747, 1.0328408479690552, 0.290902704000473, -0.23137058317661285, 0.14790280163288116, -1.1209148168563843, -0.11905800551176071, 0.5538116097450256, -0.03983789309859276, -0.029980279505252838, 0.34972143173217773, -0.5951021313667297, 0.5889442563056946, -0.29997485876083374, 0.6071521043777466, 0.2035304456949234, 0.08380334824323654, 0.5010138750076294, -0.05910045653581619, -0.41539594531059265, -0.27641576528549194, -1.1572868824005127, -0.21240004897117615, 0.6844972372055054, 0.2424164116382599, -0.2890526354312897, -0.015967924147844315, 0.21124117076396942, -0.30282384157180786, -0.13773544132709503, -0.4357689619064331, 0.1340031921863556, 0.3759540319442749, 0.0008184686303138733, 1.1268653869628906, -0.5438578128814697, -0.0461343452334404, 0.8154386878013611, -0.32098859548568726, 0.7844175100326538, -0.21253833174705505, -0.16536426544189453, -1.0033332109451294, 0.037230487912893295, 0.6201001405715942, -0.12692604959011078, -0.6941710710525513, 0.9049065113067627, 0.3579980134963989, -0.7178940773010254, -0.40480148792266846, -0.7441574931144714, -0.03139863163232803, -0.024618644267320633, -0.43215373158454895, 0.6523604989051819, -0.14823566377162933, -0.07447785884141922, -0.20475682616233826, -0.32678961753845215, -0.005103548523038626, 0.582291841506958, 0.652012050151825, 1.1875702142715454, -0.34817561507225037, 0.056090112775564194, 0.20350559055805206, 0.5358248949050903, -0.6033955812454224, 0.3425402045249939, 0.42552611231803894, 0.6467589139938354, 0.12170515954494476, 0.7204232215881348, -0.43247273564338684, 0.37431252002716064, -0.8031460046768188, 0.46690940856933594, 0.6958609819412231, 0.4137040078639984, -0.15529605746269226, -0.6834008693695068, -0.34986022114753723, 0.21959984302520752, 0.2964841425418854, 0.6232092380523682, 0.11221135407686234, 0.1355021893978119, 0.5394962430000305, -0.130445197224617, -1.3746602535247803, -0.5965892672538757, -0.32941409945487976, 0.5053939819335938, 1.007812738418579, 0.19113308191299438, -0.6809823513031006, -0.4756148159503937, 0.12549400329589844, 0.4407337009906769, -0.4377940893173218, 0.2922005355358124, -0.5792602896690369, -0.32635071873664856, -0.2680436670780182, 0.7032566070556641, 0.1336906999349594, 0.5138983726501465, -0.08783632516860962, 0.6837784647941589, 0.42701566219329834, 0.622187077999115, 0.05322718992829323, -0.5717028379440308, -0.3302820026874542, 0.8051937222480774, -0.18979999423027039, 0.061187099665403366, 0.7769172191619873, 0.43906813859939575, -0.01118292473256588, 0.3823886513710022, -0.8427383899688721, -0.3021990656852722, 0.8226279020309448, -0.024960530921816826, -0.14608871936798096, 0.35438424348831177, -0.7702644467353821, 0.39241400361061096, -0.5067303776741028, -0.25725388526916504, -0.05020614713430405, 0.20382606983184814, 0.5880460739135742, 0.3994092643260956, -0.46163326501846313, 0.1820109337568283, -0.5633408427238464, -0.7136353850364685, 0.23499822616577148, -0.18654075264930725, -0.6239757537841797, -0.017423570156097412, 0.2878059446811676, -0.15400852262973785, 0.6302130222320557, 0.49615490436553955, 0.5181939601898193, 0.17013613879680634, -0.09266403317451477, -0.06601756066083908, 0.2960750162601471, -0.2923315167427063, 0.4105236828327179, 0.5388578176498413, 0.08403471857309341, 0.3885294497013092, -0.5463352799415588, -0.5795234441757202, 0.5575670599937439, 0.2543914020061493, -0.2917676866054535, 0.8986022472381592, -0.07735175639390945, -0.06379280239343643, -0.23250222206115723, -0.12097437679767609, -0.3683050870895386, -0.0373554490506649, 0.36038270592689514, -0.5591511726379395, 0.0859808474779129, 0.5505924224853516, -1.2901804447174072, 0.2832200527191162, -1.7635189294815063, 0.48961693048477173, 0.5374003052711487, 0.7227404117584229, -0.5141600370407104, -0.1255977898836136, 0.7958053350448608, 0.13827326893806458, -0.22465842962265015, -0.03053024597465992, 0.014951350167393684, -0.31110963225364685, -0.26681578159332275, -0.02536616288125515, 0.8842934966087341, -0.734681248664856, 0.24985119700431824, -0.35579797625541687, 0.23413847386837006, 0.8559823036193848, 0.13253435492515564, -0.49417731165885925, -0.31818079948425293, 0.3903001844882965, 0.12265266478061676, -0.10621995478868484, -0.1372278481721878, 1.245355486869812, -0.7153462767601013, 0.3562539219856262, 0.8179524540901184, 0.42932578921318054, -0.35220056772232056, 0.3070231080055237, -0.29579856991767883, -0.5324512124061584, 0.2976081967353821, 0.6635035276412964, 0.6708963513374329, 0.17106132209300995, -0.5853275060653687, -0.2582467198371887, -0.8192145824432373, -0.17426754534244537, -0.7325173020362854, 0.45020270347595215, -1.2965123653411865, 0.009048661217093468, 0.4210706949234009, 0.09758516401052475, -0.459307998418808, 0.09311115741729736, -0.10538481920957565, 0.20372894406318665, 0.14334960281848907, -0.41491955518722534, 0.25056159496307373, 0.25665321946144104, -0.10039404779672623, -0.16714055836200714, 0.6794770359992981, 0.6838162541389465, -0.385779470205307, 0.22133196890354156, -0.13200098276138306, -0.3053625524044037, -0.9761425256729126, -0.6834290623664856, -0.6588919758796692, -0.37397095561027527, -0.6254085302352905, 0.07764862477779388, 0.7674975395202637, -0.3926718831062317, 0.9064388871192932, 0.23714786767959595, -0.17396442592144012, 0.017936691641807556, -0.21413351595401764, 0.09042102098464966, -0.37930765748023987, 0.021917933598160744, -1.0514322519302368, 0.1908261775970459, -0.9650651216506958, 0.7524442076683044, -0.3127344846725464, -0.14648494124412537, 0.05599730461835861, -0.1889173537492752, 0.09046423435211182, 0.2418782263994217, 0.13820436596870422, 0.04110589250922203, -0.30444395542144775, -0.5272960066795349, -0.4797699749469757, -0.39490726590156555, -0.8473837375640869, -0.6046156883239746, -0.5667910575866699, 0.9122539758682251, -0.7132636308670044, -0.5456147193908691, 0.7175036072731018, -0.1866925060749054, -0.40164634585380554, 0.42837515473365784, -1.1272163391113281, -0.1546793282032013, -0.06409648805856705, 1.1276955604553223, 0.7976242899894714, 0.056141890585422516, 0.2948721647262573, -0.10147988051176071, -0.38534486293792725, 0.37520357966423035, 0.42737382650375366, -1.066105842590332, 0.0607633963227272, 1.0177515745162964, 0.625413715839386, -0.23280023038387299, 0.19060960412025452, -1.08387291431427, -0.39191141724586487, -0.3008749783039093, -0.06350520998239517, 0.6619812250137329, 0.20218154788017273, -0.49009642004966736, -0.34748512506484985, -0.20559529960155487, 0.5514584183692932, 0.32119786739349365, -0.05246787890791893, 0.12033819407224655, 0.2658267021179199, 0.5491464138031006, -0.13384900987148285, 0.17875568568706512, 0.9493526816368103, -0.9149168729782104, 0.2363509237766266, -0.3627132475376129, -1.1933451890945435, -0.2732942998409271, 0.5833000540733337, -0.17230737209320068, 0.2207646518945694, 0.1094096451997757, -0.9198509454727173, -0.3332842290401459, -0.0890994518995285, 0.044045571237802505, 0.24953211843967438, 0.5495118498802185, 0.07815933972597122, -0.6442569494247437, -1.0278642177581787, -0.10765793174505234, 0.5649948120117188, 0.06826825439929962, 0.7742549180984497, -0.33391904830932617, 0.6570529937744141, 0.48688095808029175, -0.8007643222808838, 0.1371852457523346, -0.6654799580574036, -0.3746125102043152, -0.07442198693752289, 0.05958286300301552, 0.8092482089996338, -0.8875894546508789, -0.6205219626426697, -0.732373058795929, 1.5857629776000977, 0.6904126405715942, 0.7457727789878845, 0.6835379004478455, -0.17597965896129608, 0.5162636637687683, -0.44343751668930054, -0.5896854996681213, 0.6830824613571167, -0.1583203226327896, -0.6231536269187927, -0.42786431312561035, 0.07972836494445801, 0.14822258055210114, 0.05690746009349823, 0.6330051422119141, 0.16421885788440704, 0.08584572374820709, 0.6929975152015686, -0.14373496174812317, 0.459364652633667, 0.28557196259498596, 0.24694328010082245, -0.18169859051704407, -0.49933457374572754, 0.0035816121380776167, 0.684136152267456, -0.2295515090227127, -0.29271847009658813, -0.33308228850364685, -0.1363505870103836, 0.2742278575897217, 0.6674838066101074, 0.17665614187717438, -0.07651536166667938, 0.21458281576633453, 0.3442161977291107, 0.5084829330444336, -1.0845816135406494, 0.04238247126340866, 0.5642011165618896, 0.7734258770942688, 0.683202862739563, -0.8274630308151245, 1.0661840438842773, -0.5181717276573181, 0.7164818644523621, 0.9983309507369995, -0.3539217710494995, -0.40620124340057373, 0.3976098597049713, 0.9787508845329285, -0.7925986051559448, 0.1328967958688736, 0.646935224533081, 0.029329704120755196, 0.01798224449157715, -0.18522028625011444, -0.22846542298793793, 0.792104959487915, -0.7161738276481628, -0.11970620602369308, -0.027877166867256165, 0.1691199094057083, -0.2907972037792206, 0.3492434024810791, -0.7965631484985352, -0.22709040343761444, -0.39746159315109253, -0.6274904608726501, 0.8251463770866394, -0.06361520290374756, -0.44976723194122314, 0.3468409478664398, -0.528942883014679, 0.39868465065956116, 1.3993371725082397, 0.3133663237094879, -0.3009435534477234, 0.12534217536449432, 0.35201478004455566, -0.6442568302154541, -0.5757522583007812, 0.131128191947937, -0.05717691034078598, 0.6858927607536316, 0.40094879269599915, 0.10317220538854599, 0.22055716812610626, 0.4798295497894287, -0.4435790777206421, -0.16370366513729095, -0.15968449413776398, -0.26770448684692383, -0.5401087403297424, -0.1632881909608841, -0.13563627004623413, -0.8273797035217285, -0.21657897531986237, 0.8195781111717224, -0.28369131684303284, 0.642320454120636, 0.36234185099601746, -0.33322539925575256, -0.3599730432033539, 0.028605785220861435, -0.34492626786231995, 0.1998976618051529, -0.2745286226272583, -0.46079006791114807, 0.04674117639660835, -0.8454402089118958, -0.09429816156625748, 0.025910120457410812, -0.1426011323928833, -0.1652378886938095, 0.10638615489006042, -0.6280323266983032, -0.6833644509315491, -0.13153429329395294, -0.5673304796218872, 0.7233070135116577, -0.5905444622039795, 0.6151981949806213, -0.6456964015960693, -0.16885259747505188, -0.5230522751808167, -0.08633416891098022, 0.6033255457878113, -0.0984901711344719, -0.290275514125824, -0.2192474752664566, 0.24464644491672516, 0.24048495292663574, -0.4399225413799286, 0.5463382601737976, -0.45032641291618347, 0.2659609615802765, 0.14510665833950043, -0.6277592778205872, 0.26499804854393005, 0.9900370240211487, -0.120219387114048, -0.1736609786748886, -0.0374973826110363, -1.0122841596603394, 0.5402044653892517, 0.18494421243667603, 0.6452568769454956, -0.9533897638320923, -0.3778077960014343, -0.30428624153137207, -0.11563409119844437, 0.21759213507175446, 0.21785451471805573, -0.29765602946281433, -0.49363604187965393, -0.05325907841324806, -0.1579720675945282, -0.09547924995422363, -0.1526450663805008, 0.41299617290496826, -0.22653521597385406, -0.7405192852020264, -0.5150489807128906, 1.0045167207717896, -0.4409194886684418, 0.21351665258407593, 1.4299094676971436, 0.17361998558044434, -0.000044960859668208286, 0.3057628273963928, -0.2562505006790161, -0.6933230757713318, -0.37000271677970886, 0.5875563621520996, -0.515190601348877, 0.43363380432128906, -0.4735492169857025, 0.3308713138103485, -0.6159352660179138, 0.4422197639942169, -0.36915040016174316, -0.14326030015945435, -0.012294632382690907, 0.11816457659006119, 0.9493364095687866, -1.1638532876968384, 0.7871044278144836, 0.7122162580490112, 0.7010715007781982, 0.6444403529167175, 0.4212685525417328, -0.5370762348175049, -0.10132063925266266, -0.9460371136665344, -0.7775689959526062, 0.7439732551574707, -0.03383919596672058, -0.22768326103687286, -0.17603866755962372, -0.541006863117218, -0.49683186411857605, -0.012490948662161827, 0.25905656814575195, 0.399913489818573, 0.32760825753211975, 0.19023333489894867, -0.1557270735502243, 0.12893414497375488, 0.5855026841163635, 0.03802676498889923, 0.7116565108299255, -0.26549720764160156, -0.540947675704956, 0.14435911178588867, -0.08726604282855988, -1.1077979803085327, -0.10481386631727219, 0.486050009727478, 0.3636494576931, -0.5380285978317261, 0.9186301827430725, 0.1641242951154709, -0.5937316417694092, -0.17884325981140137, -0.43982237577438354, -0.252849817276001, 0.7207480072975159, 0.6082534790039062, 0.14343678951263428, 0.11626647412776947, 0.19517706334590912, 0.17796939611434937, -0.5348955988883972, 0.3090839385986328, 0.31250616908073425, -0.9831040501594543, -0.2877184748649597, 0.2989639639854431, 0.10067254304885864, -0.47137174010276794, -0.8816289901733398, -0.5085667967796326, -0.000556741957552731, 0.30666908621788025, -0.7924612760543823, -0.22669148445129395, -0.47385093569755554, -0.31267082691192627, -0.01604575105011463, 0.552931010723114, 0.44845980405807495, 0.38524147868156433, 0.02620556205511093, -0.9323572516441345, -0.5088322162628174, 0.0535273477435112, 1.4337095022201538, 0.016351545229554176, -0.770869791507721, -0.3321796655654907, -0.7991167306900024, -0.6422436833381653, -0.3629671037197113, 0.925177812576294, 0.3907623291015625, 0.6576856374740601, -0.21399787068367004, -0.6256004571914673, 0.5830405950546265, 0.532669186592102, 0.09473183006048203, -0.02890900708734989, 0.10938569158315659, -0.826339840888977, -0.03928151726722717, 0.1516294628381729, 0.42919865250587463, 0.08084417879581451, -0.7733385562896729, 0.1240786612033844, -0.5909600853919983, 0.16291174292564392, -0.5180212259292603, -0.8339908123016357, -0.7869306802749634, -0.8630210757255554, -0.6630128622055054, -0.6844486594200134, -0.2512519061565399, -0.3877990245819092, 0.7318466901779175, -0.06652866303920746, -0.019543269649147987, -0.9131872057914734, -0.06287776678800583, 0.5976874828338623, 0.23840436339378357, -0.26538220047950745, -0.438820481300354, -1.3734207153320312, -0.2724626362323761, -0.7962167859077454, 0.01142159290611744, -0.07049717754125595, 0.2605401277542114, -0.5798723101615906, -0.002491739811375737, -0.03938604146242142, 0.5822319388389587, -0.4630686044692993, -0.8170015215873718, 0.09632496535778046, 0.3405272662639618, -0.1744689643383026, 0.6990374326705933, -0.24186283349990845, 0.11272654682397842, 0.058627791702747345, -0.012208130210638046, 0.4818838834762573, 0.24372972548007965, -1.3124949932098389, 0.4412415623664856, 0.2474861890077591, -0.08959489315748215, 0.13079817593097687, -0.46437108516693115, -0.06105884164571762, 1.1751925945281982, -0.8890359401702881, 0.30842214822769165, 0.050576791167259216, 0.7616617679595947, -0.457106351852417, -0.28326600790023804, -0.6732173562049866, 0.376365065574646, -0.30991676449775696, 1.2829856872558594, -0.04338926449418068, -0.5258492827415466, 0.18476802110671997, -0.30063551664352417, 0.025054631754755974, -0.12250617891550064, -0.06946159899234772, -0.766406238079071, 0.3900569677352905, 0.4144188463687897, -0.7115522623062134, 0.842117428779602, 0.17885877192020416, 0.4611460566520691, -1.0330690145492554, -0.902161180973053, -0.5974703431129456, 0.531670868396759, 0.40158334374427795, -0.1100640669465065, 0.18127332627773285, -0.7266436815261841, -0.480459988117218, -0.22865135967731476, -0.1852170079946518, -0.5117481350898743, -0.2226247638463974, -0.2818189263343811, -0.9827953577041626, -0.2720263600349426, 0.07958517968654633, 0.33667078614234924, -0.009020437486469746, 0.5090262293815613, -0.33503788709640503, -0.06212181970477104, -0.4182603359222412, -0.2744427025318146, -0.9244157671928406, 0.39904820919036865, -0.18571071326732635, 0.41712456941604614, 0.04851377010345459, -0.7347279191017151, 0.010692969895899296, 0.5124382972717285, -0.07110521197319031, -0.8269631862640381, -0.07638721168041229, 0.04033425450325012, -0.7562950849533081, 1.1003555059432983, 0.14511394500732422, -0.03942648321390152, 0.020174888893961906, 0.7102862000465393, 0.7347179651260376, -0.2733341455459595, 0.4054827392101288, 0.6547176241874695, -0.020856795832514763, -0.05374165624380112, -0.0891687348484993, 0.9119643568992615, 0.046503983438014984, -0.534523606300354, 0.4234379231929779, -0.12831968069076538, 0.5246807336807251, 0.17090889811515808, -0.5868799090385437, -0.9887421131134033, -0.15367762744426727, 0.5681403279304504, 0.5909199714660645, 0.5285894870758057, 0.5113401412963867, 0.20797733962535858, -0.1700190156698227, -0.10591473430395126, -0.05813661590218544, 0.23557732999324799, -0.6838534474372864, 0.31598806381225586, -0.7626678943634033, 1.074394702911377, -0.7649200558662415, 0.6646872758865356, 0.10331535339355469, 0.2792152762413025, -0.2741008698940277, -0.08874529600143433, -0.2654739320278168, 0.15020236372947693, -0.8709413409233093, -0.18038178980350494, -0.6717880964279175, -0.2193748503923416, -0.16782379150390625, 0.2669006586074829, 0.20368260145187378, 0.37152764201164246, 0.9092016220092773, 0.4454159438610077, 0.3919581174850464, -0.11292139440774918, 0.5710934400558472, 0.2491374909877777, 0.12353232502937317, 1.1237279176712036, 1.0037950277328491, 0.6480552554130554, 0.2802538573741913, -0.3850128650665283, -0.36480093002319336, 1.1488922834396362, -1.149454951286316, -0.44196656346321106, 0.09450968354940414, 0.0792609304189682, 0.18830353021621704, -1.0535708665847778, 0.7148129940032959, -0.0924828052520752, -0.05047345161437988, 0.955573558807373, -0.3874972462654114, -0.49201828241348267, 0.5007658004760742, -0.13276468217372894, 0.1473386138677597, 0.7874708771705627, 0.3060454726219177, -0.9722517728805542, 0.8446608781814575, 0.7441694140434265, -0.11782097071409225, 0.10690180212259293, 0.30794885754585266, -0.38124024868011475, -0.22724588215351105, 0.3815983831882477, -0.8594895005226135, 0.627493679523468, -0.5505615472793579, -0.5512658357620239, 0.21092315018177032, -0.0694533959031105, -0.3168985843658447, 0.3313269317150116, 0.2569945752620697, 0.5427224636077881, -0.10120832175016403, -0.08344825357198715, 0.4060342609882355, 0.1546575427055359, -0.1670694202184677, -0.3131640553474426, -0.4993520975112915, 0.5691640377044678, -0.7078972458839417, 0.34231653809547424, 0.42420244216918945, 0.22850742936134338, 0.16415958106517792, -0.20643971860408783, -0.3138846457004547, -0.3869559168815613, -1.09035062789917, -0.27347370982170105, -0.9150791764259338, 0.16996720433235168, 0.5388302206993103, 1.0955809354782104, -0.1176542267203331, -0.3799366354942322, 0.02744903787970543, 0.8105365633964539, 0.7829678058624268, 0.3490487039089203, 0.4577013850212097, 0.6389803886413574, -0.43015530705451965, -0.5045289993286133, 0.14471308887004852, 0.6220900416374207, -0.5573013424873352, 0.12525203824043274, -0.305280864238739, 0.3301900327205658, -0.0818052589893341, -0.273294061422348, -0.4718922972679138, 0.4128783047199249, 1.0142016410827637, -0.35121434926986694, -0.6364455819129944, -0.06111922860145569, -0.7367926239967346, -0.3804548978805542, -0.6649119257926941, 0.751867949962616, 0.6470062732696533, -0.3060767352581024, 0.5257827043533325, -0.18948204815387726, 4.05448579788208, 0.22125282883644104, 0.6866490244865417, 0.0811174288392067, 0.6893693208694458, 0.49559688568115234, 0.5400267839431763, -0.3388879597187042, 0.3470190465450287, -0.3687867820262909, -0.022779341787099838, -0.11969348788261414, 0.32549571990966797, -0.05579947680234909, 0.12599550187587738, 0.6175611019134521, 0.20633290708065033, 0.19068725407123566, -0.2525411546230316, -0.6420621871948242, 0.08740321546792984, 0.2233974039554596, 0.4073238968849182, -0.0316503532230854, 0.09588952362537384, 0.5119560956954956, -0.011789047159254551, -0.8757039904594421, -0.5151183009147644, -0.7763000130653381, -1.064225435256958, -0.2546032965183258, 0.4583163261413574, -0.3286781907081604, -0.9133496284484863, 0.3920801281929016, 0.39331597089767456, 0.6105021834373474, 0.2328556925058365, 0.5062947869300842, 0.31504979729652405, -0.41849130392074585, -0.5639086365699768, -0.24706271290779114, -0.12562577426433563, 0.1893307864665985, -0.4119861423969269, 1.4088221788406372, 0.025867659598588943, -0.6592161655426025, 0.5795765519142151, -0.3182324171066284, 0.061526138335466385, 0.195052832365036, -0.8848040103912354, 0.29263612627983093, -0.08699651062488556, -1.062423825263977, -0.7835670709609985, -0.2040020376443863, 1.502179503440857, 0.3146187961101532, 0.06448107957839966, 0.044030170887708664, -0.30950552225112915, 0.44845718145370483, 0.6424219012260437, -0.3403739631175995, -0.42871803045272827, -0.051884330809116364, -0.6977329254150391, 0.03642594814300537, -0.690784752368927, -0.21283456683158875, 0.30960243940353394, -0.004994403570890427, -0.2703539729118347, 0.24114541709423065, 0.10175800323486328, 0.4491405785083771, 0.028534037992358208, -0.6862270832061768, -0.5686697959899902, 0.624993085861206, 0.30920079350471497, 0.7210928201675415, -0.3088916540145874, -0.738884449005127, -0.46749570965766907, 0.6406079530715942, 0.29826346039772034, 1.1787995100021362, 0.2285049855709076, 0.7208595871925354, -0.5809087753295898 ]
The Nonequilibrium Dynamics of Driven Line Liquids
We study the nonequilibrium dynamics of line liquids as realized in the nonlinear motion of flux lines of a superconductor driven by an applied electric current. Our analysis suggests a transition in the dynamics of the lines from a smooth, laminar phase at small driving forces, to a rough, turbulent phase when the drive is increased. We explore the nature of these phases and describe interesting analogies to driven diffusion and growing interfaces.
Terence Hwa
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206008
cond-mat/9206009
[ -0.11614266037940979, -0.04219227284193039, -0.006088193506002426, -0.11457821726799011, 0.31315165758132935, -0.3838721513748169, 0.4476761817932129, -0.18212248384952545, -1.4584604501724243, 1.3845993280410767, 0.7268556952476501, 0.08121835440397263, 0.1327582150697708, -0.18101491034030914, -0.24875959753990173, 0.3320567309856415, -0.3208199739456177, -0.6287174224853516, -1.4711744785308838, 0.4967743158340454, 0.3666422665119171, -0.06069782003760338, -1.1735663414001465, -0.4553767144680023, -0.6748713254928589, 0.7428373694419861, 0.6628355979919434, 0.13165216147899628, 0.8681035041809082, 0.5194078087806702, 0.20766505599021912, 0.021872106939554214, -0.4483681917190552, -0.3380836844444275, -0.4059733748435974, -0.10982169955968857, -0.34893810749053955, -0.8141108155250549, 0.9009367227554321, -0.06390870362520218, 1.107030987739563, 0.046547990292310715, 0.2907274067401886, -0.5266382694244385, -0.39861777424812317, 0.3403363823890686, -0.23927441239356995, 0.2509869337081909, -0.6398503184318542, -1.1214158535003662, -0.16401351988315582, 0.3287445902824402, 0.09017816931009293, -1.7113419771194458, -0.3370150029659271, 0.2112882286310196, 0.0009954991983249784, 0.45619189739227295, -0.36629411578178406, -0.5588445067405701, 0.17805194854736328, 0.3108285963535309, 0.28369268774986267, -0.14743156731128693, 0.7078334093093872, 0.9745035171508789, -0.22017958760261536, 0.45203879475593567, 0.20323951542377472, -0.8214308619499207, -0.24554263055324554, -0.4045712649822235, -0.849257230758667, -0.1626170426607132, -0.8120821118354797, -0.11101508140563965, -0.06503529101610184, -0.19786572456359863, -0.5272771716117859, -0.511849582195282, 0.7542409896850586, 0.138201043009758, -0.9282947778701782, 0.5089669227600098, -0.7059542536735535, -0.45711949467658997, 0.21686001121997833, 0.10081804543733597, 0.604364812374115, 0.5497603416442871, 0.10961361974477768, 0.31061068177223206, 0.4375535249710083, -0.47519078850746155, 0.20014801621437073, 1.020064115524292, 0.3824768364429474, 0.4138198792934418, 0.0861811712384224, 0.2499803751707077, 0.0038855751045048237, 0.5019567012786865, -0.1540440320968628, 0.13695788383483887, -0.8453851938247681, 0.9260178208351135, -0.6500876545906067, -0.07329960912466049, -0.31299924850463867, -1.2506515979766846, -0.1289294958114624, -0.14144712686538696, 1.1225231885910034, 0.29660746455192566, 0.5768017768859863, 0.6466917991638184, 0.022015100345015526, 0.10405638068914413, -0.76813143491745, -0.3512491285800934, 0.2371634542942047, 0.419701486825943, 0.37908029556274414, 0.3066798746585846, -0.29004254937171936, -0.7157740592956543, 0.47877031564712524, 0.4119221270084381, -0.5936545133590698, 0.11415664851665497, -0.12121095508337021, -0.9116036295890808, -0.7360290884971619, 0.3251885175704956, -0.11531668156385422, 0.43511974811553955, -0.5722811818122864, -0.09590944647789001, -0.44561710953712463, -0.07264737039804459, 1.289324164390564, -0.3159850537776947, 0.4000847041606903, 0.8639046549797058, 0.07980184257030487, 0.0006748399464413524, 0.4246954917907715, -0.1764708161354065, -0.6951161026954651, 0.3070073127746582, -0.32871609926223755, -0.2331191748380661, -0.02037828601896763, -0.10713224112987518, 0.10359703004360199, -0.13409115374088287, -1.2485636472702026, 0.11296457052230835, -0.11840640008449554, -0.323879599571228, 0.48748332262039185, -0.6073868870735168, -0.553508996963501, 1.3169561624526978, -0.14640171825885773, 0.49347057938575745, -0.2224089503288269, 0.04604733735322952, 0.23555955290794373, -0.8681668639183044, 0.158270463347435, 0.595730185508728, -0.03268720954656601, 0.5414615273475647, 1.007840633392334, 0.4430338144302368, 0.6534876823425293, -0.5307493805885315, -0.16835537552833557, 0.3951888084411621, -0.6335646510124207, -0.5867523550987244, 0.9207751154899597, 0.8480886816978455, -0.6695244908332825, -0.332137793302536, 0.1632758378982544, 0.41792774200439453, -0.21871528029441833, 0.2934029996395111, -0.7737696766853333, 0.16778407990932465, -0.641024649143219, 0.7126891613006592, -0.7966474294662476, -0.10000796616077423, -0.7591024041175842, 0.2820465862751007, -0.4389384984970093, -0.5948452949523926, -0.11366768926382065, 0.24540063738822937, -1.0195894241333008, 0.5896733403205872, -0.9011116623878479, 0.20484447479248047, 0.4346486032009125, 0.23569689691066742, -0.5386926531791687, 0.22017259895801544, 0.7730629444122314, -0.4094458818435669, 0.11244744807481766, -0.11675096303224564, 0.4850311577320099, 0.029333988204598427, 0.19795434176921844, 0.36776429414749146, 0.2787664830684662, 0.5372390747070312, 0.8479936718940735, 0.5408682227134705, -0.5876837372779846, 0.863042950630188, -0.05858257785439491, -0.3941292464733124, -0.44316038489341736, 0.7533377408981323, -0.10579819232225418, -0.253506600856781, -0.23707152903079987, 0.26990222930908203, 0.20327669382095337, 0.7929590940475464, 0.7371746897697449, 0.26623424887657166, 1.1375792026519775, 0.41291722655296326, 0.8099862933158875, 0.07792732864618301, 0.28159448504447937, 0.03197656199336052, 0.25277620553970337, 0.3663276433944702, -0.664421558380127, 0.30304527282714844, -0.2779081165790558, 0.02525988593697548, -0.010203942656517029, 0.9239765405654907, -0.25467443466186523, 0.7278574705123901, 0.1574200838804245, 0.2022218406200409, -0.8891801238059998, -0.14279010891914368, -0.28772246837615967, 0.3170083165168762, -0.022397087886929512, -0.05940474569797516, 0.7231335639953613, 0.24083544313907623, -0.1348797231912613, -0.48647892475128174, -0.8420177698135376, 0.6598120331764221, 0.0744774118065834, 0.19313348829746246, 0.6772010326385498, -0.16466349363327026, -0.4730096161365509, 0.050540946424007416, -1.5507978200912476, 0.06052593141794205, -0.421499639749527, 0.26671063899993896, 0.8665338158607483, -0.2943854033946991, -0.011082551442086697, -0.002044050255790353, 0.20456281304359436, 0.9503560662269592, -0.14664936065673828, 0.18791022896766663, 0.21248601377010345, -0.37648773193359375, -0.7980984449386597, 0.1641455739736557, -0.7596309185028076, -0.5617307424545288, -0.14843393862247467, -0.35988348722457886, 0.5699447989463806, -0.7326998710632324, 0.3656749725341797, 0.12371314316987991, -0.5150935053825378, 0.174415722489357, 0.10001201927661896, -0.3186626434326172, 0.21751412749290466, -0.02210608310997486, -0.2072882056236267, -0.4466991424560547, -1.282082438468933, 0.9965850114822388, 0.3929659128189087, -0.25293630361557007, 0.6264488101005554, -0.10820163786411285, -0.6775387525558472, 0.2455877810716629, -0.16755926609039307, 0.2490483671426773, -0.23817987740039825, 1.0847476720809937, 0.8961760997772217, -0.2862933576107025, 0.17456787824630737, -0.28007280826568604, 0.1203906238079071, 0.14632649719715118, 0.4018486738204956, -0.5651529431343079, 0.273436039686203, 0.6658445000648499, 0.22902509570121765, -0.6612132787704468, 0.21192364394664764, -0.8312893509864807, -1.0245288610458374, -0.4177130460739136, -0.5633993744850159, 0.1878572255373001, 0.005166415590792894, 0.4930233359336853, -0.7844734191894531, 0.042898133397102356, -0.20850761234760284, 0.45400598645210266, 0.4031819701194763, -0.4020479619503021, 0.5737478137016296, 0.11433083564043045, 1.076685905456543, 0.15075808763504028, 0.25758057832717896, -0.41397222876548767, -0.24741187691688538, 0.029030384495854378, -0.22666306793689728, 0.5926483273506165, 0.181256502866745, -0.26154759526252747, -0.41470685601234436, 0.3626362383365631, -0.7537723779678345, -0.3708683252334595, -1.151084065437317, -0.27054545283317566, 0.09137916564941406, 0.7364801168441772, -0.22128988802433014, 0.2823587656021118, -0.942592203617096, 0.13807354867458344, 0.16541863977909088, -0.06988215446472168, 0.5538567304611206, -0.4456782042980194, -0.004859549459069967, -0.14833399653434753, -0.12125549465417862, -0.3000602722167969, -0.07827178388834, 0.6391156911849976, 0.8095643520355225, 0.6112031936645508, 0.5474793314933777, 0.19214266538619995, -0.9244629144668579, -0.15754152834415436, 0.46903178095817566, 0.49945834279060364, 0.7484410405158997, -0.39571046829223633, 0.2211657166481018, -0.11303654313087463, -0.5606478452682495, -0.03397111967206001, -0.25687792897224426, -0.1936654895544052, 0.1994176059961319, -0.23760487139225006, -0.2427220493555069, 0.2634897530078888, -0.015988990664482117, 0.3783996105194092, 0.13216306269168854, 0.18303890526294708, 0.22536875307559967, 0.6703577041625977, 0.6086800694465637, 0.892193615436554, -0.579619288444519, -0.06500080972909927, -1.0080971717834473, 0.4032285809516907, 0.1487949639558792, 0.36116713285446167, 0.018253061920404434, -0.150429368019104, 0.015341362915933132, -0.4962421953678131, 0.12351378053426743, 0.4016876220703125, -1.080910563468933, 0.14893539249897003, 0.23519541323184967, -0.08547373116016388, 0.07688175141811371, 0.31553399562835693, 0.9466999769210815, 0.08336451649665833, 0.31720927357673645, -0.8973260521888733, 0.23898473381996155, -0.3211880028247833, 0.13097970187664032, 0.3555564880371094, -0.4259762763977051, -1.1769274473190308, -0.682276725769043, 0.19344326853752136, -0.01771705225110054, -0.2057989090681076, 0.7311425805091858, 0.2859356701374054, 0.03545919433236122, -0.3563079535961151, -0.28224465250968933, 1.4437552690505981, -0.42872151732444763, -0.7383641004562378, -0.2901645004749298, 0.26958906650543213, 0.13757148385047913, 0.8074250817298889, -0.061434295028448105, -1.0823688507080078, 0.40941646695137024, -0.5422031879425049, 0.1379423588514328, 0.11087901145219803, -1.1089380979537964, -0.3641156256198883, -0.30372869968414307, -0.14362789690494537, 0.5380365252494812, 0.08143439143896103, -0.2905478775501251, 0.06840993463993073, -0.009356861934065819, -0.19648464024066925, 0.10942906886339188, 0.11142395436763763, 0.7313361763954163, 0.8348163962364197, 0.496527761220932, 0.5055213570594788, 0.23648899793624878, 0.5291343331336975, 0.6096726059913635, -0.2112308293581009, -0.07080879807472229, -0.427876353263855, -0.40528935194015503, -0.4337294399738312, -0.5876702666282654, -0.6466357111930847, -0.41640913486480713, 0.12657473981380463, -0.5727776885032654, 0.6200763583183289, 0.27412426471710205, -0.4798143208026886, -0.7218695282936096, -0.6056278944015503, -0.6560975909233093, 0.9664644598960876, -0.2101922631263733, -0.023433281108736992, 0.6134644150733948, -1.166334629058838, 0.3207275867462158, -0.15167176723480225, -0.003505568951368332, -0.5341575145721436, 0.2955626845359802, 0.29074764251708984, 0.19716499745845795, 0.593876302242279, -0.14162763953208923, 0.23437049984931946, -0.3150010108947754, 0.2613183557987213, -0.7449814081192017, -0.5342360138893127, -0.6566728949546814, -0.3603544235229492, 0.6686589121818542, -0.22291015088558197, 0.0831369087100029, -0.22883257269859314, -0.34733712673187256, 0.8778655529022217, -0.46140339970588684, -0.8831294775009155, 0.4647572636604309, 0.90439772605896, 0.5827885270118713, -0.8144098520278931, -0.058731187134981155, 0.15489663183689117, 0.17447102069854736, 0.23191440105438232, -0.1334964632987976, -0.09560912102460861, 0.4893190860748291, -0.44576895236968994, 0.6277264356613159, -0.901730477809906, -0.20765550434589386, -0.18896406888961792, -0.6629018187522888, 0.3368677496910095, 0.2575143277645111, 0.010110309347510338, -0.23327557742595673, -0.5827546119689941, -0.5214887261390686, 0.8955907821655273, -0.6028292179107666, 0.051923416554927826, -0.5068305730819702, -0.03502729535102844, -0.34257209300994873, 0.4404432773590088, -0.2176721841096878, 0.6881959438323975, 0.3532249927520752, -0.1517920196056366, 0.03649941459298134, 0.22344280779361725, 0.5131577849388123, 0.11843416094779968, -0.8088530898094177, 0.0975508764386177, 0.6722696423530579, 0.2321172058582306, -0.5389821529388428, 0.5397790670394897, -0.8153508305549622, 1.5211843252182007, -0.6995092034339905, 0.006897758226841688, -0.010899560526013374, -0.04378408193588257, 0.379575252532959, -0.6411364078521729, 0.4552176296710968, 0.5138764381408691, 0.1528692990541458, -0.067763552069664, 0.00227999035269022, -0.634736180305481, -0.5823729634284973, -0.5102478265762329, -0.5796680450439453, 0.48834288120269775, -0.5260528326034546, 0.12927332520484924, -0.4217331111431122, -0.6488378047943115, 0.2601317763328552, 0.12503132224082947, 0.30021440982818604, 0.06004913151264191, 0.31867241859436035, 0.2312738597393036, -0.3593084514141083, 0.32966724038124084, -0.5852656960487366, 0.15187440812587738, -0.30262553691864014, -0.262162983417511, 0.28755953907966614, -0.07855319231748581, -0.5994366407394409, -0.577285647392273, -0.37868285179138184, 0.09864988178014755, 0.22548392415046692, -0.520449161529541, 0.6202310919761658, -0.5961779952049255, -0.6440591216087341, -0.3108223080635071, -0.21375548839569092, 0.39113691449165344, 0.1684143990278244, 0.06911635398864746, 0.009797532111406326, 0.4692573845386505, -0.02619655430316925, 0.019330060109496117, -0.25090667605400085, -0.6597158908843994, 0.27691754698753357, -0.8407219052314758, -0.7399580478668213, 0.40553081035614014, -0.041143614798784256, -0.6712109446525574, -0.7156555652618408, -1.1290072202682495, -0.14517056941986084, -0.30885016918182373, -0.575178325176239, 0.10448702424764633, -0.3611498773097992, -0.34017595648765564, 0.3260158896446228, 0.9867419600486755, -0.03607911244034767, 0.4020316004753113, 0.41868552565574646, -0.4051697850227356, -0.2215055525302887, 0.10672837495803833, 1.0007586479187012, -0.29800838232040405, -0.9756396412849426, 0.504390299320221, 0.6728693246841431, -0.0782749354839325, 0.017844952642917633, 0.28529462218284607, 0.019701212644577026, -0.10063787549734116, 0.14128701388835907, -0.007194521836936474, 0.05312030389904976, 0.38737252354621887, 0.0653255358338356, -0.03771892935037613, -0.6528404951095581, -0.7934165000915527, -0.0545419305562973, -0.1415378898382187, 0.32649895548820496, 0.44108396768569946, 0.008770047686994076, 0.1359253078699112, 0.0323481522500515, 0.07537519186735153, -0.9648998975753784, -1.1138685941696167, -0.6900479197502136, -1.061510682106018, 0.06294562667608261, -1.055475115776062, -0.4193764626979828, 0.030924057587981224, 1.1009248495101929, -0.36976367235183716, 0.43752050399780273, -0.34338751435279846, 0.19242092967033386, -0.09260830283164978, 0.0483689159154892, -0.2269328534603119, -0.27206042408943176, 0.08684386312961578, 0.1849256157875061, 0.0007284061284735799, -1.0950324535369873, -0.5032612681388855, 0.2688577175140381, 0.41255754232406616, 0.37814149260520935, -0.4283986985683441, 0.22337956726551056, -0.9082309007644653, -0.3433273732662201, -0.03818482533097267, 0.086820587515831, -0.41931822896003723, 0.9215095043182373, -0.04498738422989845, 0.7811157703399658, -0.10691531747579575, 0.28120294213294983, -0.15244367718696594, 0.6398985981941223, -0.9097427129745483, 0.406948059797287, -0.3368552327156067, 0.19342394173145294, 0.38611263036727905, -0.4132073223590851, -0.0842553973197937, -0.49599796533584595, -0.577016294002533, -0.012717916630208492, -0.5936304926872253, 0.7833212018013, -0.40153494477272034, 0.19209130108356476, 0.7540685534477234, -0.20444010198116302, 0.2550734281539917, 0.5059158205986023, -0.006187157239764929, -0.09009648859500885, 0.02301783114671707, 0.01965729519724846, -0.11582503467798233, -0.23052535951137543, 0.7848795056343079, -0.7539941668510437, 0.1723301112651825, 0.4080175757408142, -0.24303264915943146, 0.09426126629114151, -0.10309289395809174, -0.6034984588623047, -0.3736562728881836, 0.2066698968410492, -0.339114785194397, 1.057491660118103, 0.019832029938697815, -0.4274502992630005, 0.09410490095615387, -0.618869423866272, -0.4924878776073456, 0.28300321102142334, -0.6478534936904907, -0.39851129055023193, 0.25436559319496155, -0.2681560516357422, -0.41555628180503845, 0.5123859643936157, -0.2890898287296295, 0.350055992603302, -0.2621881067752838, 0.38459816575050354, 0.6580508947372437, -0.017996538430452347, 0.17697705328464508, -0.15513493120670319, -1.108556866645813, 0.32651486992836, -0.3746107816696167, 0.6540865302085876, -1.1061832904815674, -0.7922691106796265, -0.10452010482549667, 0.3234556317329407, 0.12185095250606537, 0.3596879243850708, -0.08716347813606262, -0.06085600331425667, 0.05455294996500015, -0.1026054173707962, 0.13882693648338318, 0.05017848312854767, -0.5928657650947571, 1.0832747220993042, 0.1280292570590973, -0.4891056418418884, 0.1701735109090805, 0.0785885751247406, -0.06632634997367859, -0.03141656517982483, 0.10007692873477936, 0.7618406414985657, -0.32609668374061584, -0.7673416137695312, 0.609441876411438, -0.08716826140880585, 0.49837949872016907, 0.2044038474559784, -0.8826299905776978, 0.15620659291744232, 0.41178688406944275, 0.8412694334983826, 0.37566229701042175, 0.29414811730384827, 0.6542193293571472, 0.07122939825057983, 0.6362741589546204, -0.13600194454193115, -0.2919600009918213, 0.261503666639328, 0.001580122741870582, 0.825019359588623, -0.6222605109214783, 0.055771537125110626, 0.06693784147500992, 0.8107529282569885, 0.17094868421554565, -0.6824345588684082, -0.09622485190629959, -0.585736095905304, 0.7696281671524048, 0.32703739404678345, -0.15458838641643524, -0.7931593656539917, -0.44219303131103516, 0.07484214752912521, 0.4782118797302246, -0.07764898985624313, 0.21191275119781494, 1.265312910079956, 0.5758349299430847, 0.2558053135871887, -0.27695736289024353, 0.8539714217185974, 0.1545635312795639, 0.2780809700489044, 0.9992623329162598, 0.3507999777793884, 0.7399997115135193, 0.05786275118589401, -0.24103498458862305, -0.9779442548751831, -0.0507667139172554, 0.2724708616733551, -0.6954340934753418, 0.05119069293141365, -0.16096358001232147, 0.14391134679317474, -0.8507362008094788, -0.7384727001190186, 0.3283947706222534, -0.6495477557182312, 0.5296691060066223, 0.2334223985671997, -0.47155818343162537, 0.04970139265060425, 0.8809128999710083, -0.11843947321176529, 0.244031623005867, 0.4870961606502533, -0.05467573553323746, 0.10981368273496628, 0.5716742277145386, 0.8658728003501892, 0.4955148696899414, 0.09768477827310562, -0.18872632086277008, -0.3803347051143646, 1.19008469581604, 0.20548997819423676, 0.4392310678958893, 0.3394968509674072, -0.7728239297866821, 0.1234465166926384, -0.2585309147834778, 0.14895842969417572, -0.2440582662820816, -0.28249621391296387, 0.3765385150909424, 0.489755779504776, -0.29912373423576355, -0.5701751112937927, 0.8193744421005249, 0.07493241876363754, -0.07744114100933075, -0.14294806122779846, 0.2950103282928467, -1.0624605417251587, -0.37547188997268677, -1.103506326675415, 0.21678096055984497, 0.0659724771976471, 0.5079135894775391, -0.12096532434225082, -0.7245369553565979, -0.5784764289855957, -0.9323915839195251, 0.10242706537246704, -0.5848227143287659, 0.6106716394424438, 0.5125544667243958, -0.026034187525510788, 0.33852946758270264, -0.9116603136062622, -0.23401027917861938, 0.16633489727973938, 0.6406715512275696, 0.4165938198566437, -0.1603740155696869, 0.17596206068992615, 0.2634044289588928, -1.0302120447158813, 0.5459466576576233, 0.9655614495277405, -0.4048285186290741, -0.021058883517980576, -0.3484388291835785, 0.371077299118042, 0.5079057812690735, 0.558683454990387, 0.33862367272377014, -0.614764928817749, 0.14186914265155792, 0.12258967012166977, -0.6809004545211792, 0.103718601167202, -0.9121397733688354, -0.6705943942070007, -0.44724732637405396, 0.030232325196266174, 0.612160325050354, 0.508969247341156, 0.2524327039718628, -0.4742618501186371, 4.202398777008057, 0.5451784729957581, 0.6504003405570984, 0.009766282513737679, 1.064696192741394, 0.7365438938140869, -0.45706990361213684, -0.4538533091545105, 0.35187965631484985, -1.2650874853134155, -0.3280492424964905, 0.3959197402000427, 0.058766257017850876, -0.7613183856010437, 0.32788631319999695, 0.6969466805458069, -0.13243262469768524, -0.04832194745540619, -0.01824941113591194, -0.2712395489215851, -0.4653531312942505, 0.3008730411529541, 0.5670034885406494, -0.030406760051846504, 0.36352837085723877, 0.5925243496894836, 0.178457111120224, -0.00010625306458678097, -0.3807412385940552, -0.5206956267356873, -0.4405807852745056, -1.0674059391021729, 0.16717450320720673, -0.4261528253555298, -0.9125855565071106, 0.9613774418830872, -0.6026616096496582, -0.34404924511909485, 0.2703239917755127, -0.04421941190958023, 0.5752311944961548, -0.9789150953292847, 0.10727512091398239, -0.013644916005432606, -0.2983361482620239, 1.1560922861099243, -0.0577298179268837, 0.3388470411300659, 0.7300240993499756, -0.43267711997032166, 0.2901897132396698, -0.2562579810619354, 0.2963606119155884, -0.20699140429496765, -0.8616812825202942, -0.47598472237586975, -0.0911344513297081, -0.10314629971981049, -0.20564568042755127, 0.06482324749231339, 0.5346493124961853, -0.11846529692411423, -0.22338464856147766, 0.6579409837722778, -0.247104212641716, 0.22925905883312225, -0.3155973255634308, 0.2454865574836731, -0.03451840206980705, 0.08955849707126617, -0.5196493268013, -0.21743009984493256, 0.0811208188533783, -0.47530168294906616, 0.4204704761505127, -0.21041499078273773, 0.3637232482433319, 0.7722597718238831, -0.4351523518562317, 0.2585064470767975, -0.29616227746009827, -0.18401449918746948, -0.0786905363202095, 0.7581632733345032, -0.22287745773792267, 0.2574023902416229, -0.5882816314697266, -0.09484726190567017, -0.36857864260673523, 0.6683418154716492, 0.32012665271759033, 1.1564759016036987, -0.6139740943908691, -0.029369506984949112, -0.31721583008766174 ]
Quantum Field Theories on Manifolds with Curved Boundaries: Scalar Fields
A framework allowing for perturbative calculations to be carried out for quantum field theories with arbitrary smoothly curved boundaries is described. It is based on an expansion of the heat kernel derived earlier for arbitrary mixed Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions. The method is applied to a general renormalisable scalar field theory in four dimensions using dimensional regularisation to two loops and expanding about arbitrary background fields. Detailed results are also specialised to an $O(n)$ symmetric model with a single coupling constant. Extra boundary terms are introduced into the action which give rise to either Dirichlet or generalised Neumann boundary conditions for the quantum fields. For plane boundaries the resulting renormalisation group functions are in accord with earlier results but here the additional terms depending on the extrinsic curvature of the boundary are found. Various consistency relations are also checked and the implications of conformal invariance at the critical point where the $\beta$ function vanishes are also derived. The local Scr\"odinger equation for the wave functional defined by the functional integral under deformations of the boundary is also verified to two loops. Its consistency with the renormalisation group to all orders in perturbation theory is discussed.
D.M. McAvity and H. Osborn
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206009
cond-mat/9206010
[ -0.43950721621513367, -0.7127122282981873, 0.04627186059951782, -0.04157537966966629, -0.06419128179550171, 0.0572996661067009, -0.35570552945137024, -0.3808269202709198, -0.4411492645740509, 1.3265180587768555, 1.118512749671936, -0.22784996032714844, 0.9815014004707336, -0.9890127182006836, -0.609329879283905, -0.21632020175457, -0.005850834306329489, -0.0036570162046700716, -1.0456386804580688, -0.314920037984848, 0.30463841557502747, -0.5588973164558411, -0.8789061307907104, -0.661079466342926, 0.1554815024137497, 0.5063533186912537, -0.02290435880422592, 0.47889548540115356, 1.300428032875061, 0.935401439666748, 0.48728322982788086, -0.9994800090789795, -0.12873947620391846, -0.4063132405281067, -0.30730095505714417, -0.2685169279575348, -0.36358752846717834, -0.03945612162351608, 1.0941205024719238, -0.37208640575408936, 0.6709816455841064, -0.26743361353874207, 0.9742898941040039, 0.0738605335354805, -0.5339782238006592, 0.33011141419410706, -0.8047564625740051, -0.12421829253435135, -0.053531914949417114, -1.0859763622283936, 0.09230927377939224, 0.26263707876205444, 0.6104378700256348, 0.3136195242404938, 0.5214764475822449, -0.011991984210908413, -0.042017895728349686, 0.18456056714057922, -0.678642749786377, -0.177725151181221, 0.9676475524902344, -0.5677427053451538, 0.5500233173370361, -0.5554686188697815, 0.31279054284095764, 0.6009907722473145, -0.5154001712799072, 0.543713390827179, 0.17023809254169464, -0.5009737610816956, -0.40394166111946106, -0.7921197414398193, 0.047216325998306274, -0.1454702615737915, -0.16134442389011383, 0.4814073145389557, -0.17318998277187347, -0.15364035964012146, -1.7640677690505981, 0.07464449852705002, -0.2948305606842041, 0.2342592179775238, -0.11052174866199493, 0.2862735986709595, 0.1194169893860817, -0.5382187366485596, 0.009544719941914082, 0.3541777729988098, -0.392523854970932, 0.1891728937625885, 0.1785411834716797, 0.9394572377204895, 0.270181268453598, 0.07186594605445862, 0.5769339799880981, 0.3900490999221802, -0.37979644536972046, 1.0163503885269165, 0.09620430320501328, 0.39828839898109436, 0.344205379486084, -0.008955337107181549, -0.006294371094554663, 0.8544377684593201, -0.7478477954864502, 0.5644437670707703, -0.8390094041824341, 0.26883596181869507, 0.0192588958889246, -0.9905915260314941, 0.826168417930603, -0.03192861005663872, 0.2841160297393799, 0.6298462748527527, -0.47321924567222595, -0.1393076479434967, -0.6899421215057373, 0.09963778406381607, -0.748676061630249, -0.2072259783744812, 0.38826799392700195, -0.5478047132492065, 0.48708775639533997, 0.23468346893787384, -0.06530824303627014, 0.13813668489456177, 0.2864762842655182, 0.9726983308792114, -0.48761072754859924, -0.021022990345954895, 0.3690893352031708, -0.16098441183567047, -0.015846125781536102, -0.2093183696269989, -0.6825968027114868, -0.08496394008398056, 0.20072747766971588, 0.12357558310031891, 0.32044535875320435, -0.5305983424186707, 0.32786986231803894, 0.23005977272987366, 0.5895931720733643, 0.7877310514450073, 0.14938797056674957, 0.19331857562065125, 0.3440295457839966, -0.11567966639995575, 0.05894779413938522, 0.5665733218193054, -0.22043415904045105, -0.2699664831161499, -0.07576281577348709, 0.4329036772251129, -0.265217661857605, 0.6829507350921631, -0.6081684827804565, 0.5080345869064331, -0.48864275217056274, -0.5512648224830627, 0.26195770502090454, 0.14691604673862457, -0.08613505959510803, 0.18838898837566376, -0.7391987442970276, -0.23226186633110046, -0.45858293771743774, -0.1483931988477707, 0.0027171247638761997, -0.6340646147727966, -0.3301021158695221, 0.3048034608364105, -0.5877159833908081, 1.0283849239349365, 0.44770529866218567, -0.05065523460507393, 0.5153009295463562, 0.3212330639362335, -0.08873838931322098, 0.3527822494506836, 0.11817608028650284, -0.6981790065765381, 0.7188915014266968, 0.6828845739364624, -0.24199378490447998, 0.35287758708000183, -0.7320982217788696, 0.34155142307281494, -0.2514018416404724, 0.4507233202457428, -0.2799335718154907, 0.08335354924201965, -0.5444838404655457, 0.26999032497406006, -0.19340193271636963, 0.10631003975868225, -1.8546663522720337, 0.5446277856826782, -0.7541813254356384, -0.2735055685043335, -0.3644024431705475, 0.5076419711112976, -1.478841781616211, 0.3381393253803253, -1.2937957048416138, 0.01081855222582817, 0.2506740391254425, 0.5366255044937134, -0.6349464058876038, -0.4165330231189728, 0.34870749711990356, 0.45289871096611023, 0.9556543827056885, -0.5057375431060791, 0.06617513298988342, 0.3155171871185303, -0.53831946849823, 0.24220995604991913, 0.5872074365615845, -0.1636480689048767, 0.6410413980484009, 0.40734875202178955, -0.32399192452430725, 0.8960364460945129, -0.25442051887512207, -0.18507404625415802, 0.5510098338127136, 0.370562881231308, 0.25047004222869873, -0.26306211948394775, -0.23534266650676727, 0.7463440299034119, -0.2641935646533966, 0.2921369671821594, 0.7220624685287476, 0.5660653710365295, 0.45421862602233887, 0.7533414363861084, 0.6872730255126953, 0.09629911184310913, -0.09959949553012848, -0.09036087989807129, 0.7142948508262634, -0.676504373550415, 0.08069910109043121, -0.5008641481399536, -0.5184755325317383, 0.4972759783267975, -0.6763371825218201, 0.6343849897384644, -0.5921097993850708, 0.30621710419654846, 0.3936108946800232, 0.025185035541653633, -1.3053257465362549, 0.610873281955719, 0.3264145851135254, -0.03897269442677498, -0.6814791560173035, -0.7404718399047852, 0.22263962030410767, -0.07311393320560455, -0.3920864760875702, -0.6372002959251404, 0.1147984117269516, 0.9077410101890564, 0.38526973128318787, 0.6742767095565796, 0.41753870248794556, -0.21786782145500183, -1.104793906211853, -0.2156323343515396, -1.0328201055526733, 0.001078739413060248, -0.3080235719680786, 0.0191812664270401, 0.12361342459917068, -0.7216491103172302, 0.6579113006591797, 0.8933429718017578, -0.16863425076007843, 0.43972617387771606, -0.10948363691568375, 0.8120071291923523, 0.6309035420417786, 0.6202998757362366, -0.4403945803642273, 0.5388748645782471, -0.7238519191741943, 0.11616166681051254, -0.4488167464733124, 0.36131545901298523, 0.5019727945327759, -0.35170409083366394, 0.4494876563549042, -0.5778374075889587, -0.08652292191982269, -0.367132306098938, -0.08663929998874664, 0.12379002571105957, -0.08366649597883224, 0.09582335501909256, -0.3006097376346588, 0.20823508501052856, -0.35214802622795105, 0.4813928008079529, -0.2141556441783905, -0.21458937227725983, 0.025966012850403786, 0.4413510262966156, -0.27191361784935, 0.493719220161438, -0.07322379946708679, 0.36701077222824097, -0.11168350279331207, 0.9635980129241943, 0.9487482309341431, 0.42425116896629333, 0.2676403224468231, -1.0895129442214966, -0.3306209444999695, 0.23375505208969116, -0.08854731172323227, -0.762108564376831, -0.09890620410442352, 0.9362342357635498, -0.0989236980676651, -0.7950835824012756, 0.013284028507769108, -0.6165559887886047, -0.4914820194244385, -0.2788454592227936, -0.8739847540855408, 0.4342498779296875, -0.4404227137565613, -0.24183213710784912, -0.9338122606277466, 0.2545276880264282, 0.8810453414916992, 0.38449588418006897, 0.16646167635917664, -0.11845119297504425, 0.3937267065048218, 0.36225426197052, -0.0357455238699913, -0.21457546949386597, -0.1181132048368454, -0.22874756157398224, -0.0649828314781189, -0.010661532171070576, -0.2550971806049347, 0.24773027002811432, 0.6360448598861694, 0.28167861700057983, 0.3591199219226837, 0.7810224890708923, -0.2555822730064392, -0.5908092856407166, -0.7981701493263245, -0.4695517420768738, 0.04110899940133095, 0.8345054388046265, 0.315801739692688, -0.18496115505695343, -0.5225574970245361, -0.4977242052555084, 0.5647408962249756, 0.020635191351175308, 0.18574826419353485, -0.9756557941436768, 0.44295573234558105, 0.14667339622974396, -0.6484271287918091, 0.19462113082408905, -0.6902126669883728, -0.12116086483001709, 0.03323431313037872, 0.6554121375083923, -0.14000684022903442, -0.615909218788147, -0.025658128783106804, -1.161264419555664, 0.7327634692192078, 1.0347990989685059, 0.393517404794693, 0.43071770668029785, -0.8183481693267822, -0.052446261048316956, -0.22069954872131348, -0.4537564516067505, -0.18706390261650085, 0.057737186551094055, 0.06304307281970978, -0.5158438682556152, 0.11663825064897537, 0.5069953203201294, 1.1118764877319336, 0.21850235760211945, 0.4185852110385895, -0.41708970069885254, 0.6472402811050415, 0.664857029914856, 0.3148443102836609, 0.33832165598869324, -0.24108785390853882, -0.1864486187696457, -0.7967100143432617, 0.7380545139312744, 0.17233312129974365, -0.28546109795570374, -0.23993003368377686, -0.29003670811653137, -0.6291298866271973, -0.7589289546012878, 0.3317306935787201, 0.11398613452911377, -0.5045884847640991, 0.7355084419250488, 0.5450587272644043, 0.28176233172416687, -0.8562071323394775, -0.04728887602686882, 0.14103133976459503, 0.37774693965911865, 0.7886041402816772, -0.3014582097530365, 0.25820887088775635, -0.4035170376300812, 0.872890055179596, 0.6523573994636536, -0.5812458395957947, -0.9011963605880737, -0.6698065996170044, 0.028632760047912598, -0.5252653360366821, -0.08406748622655869, 1.3799939155578613, -0.07842939347028732, -0.2132905125617981, 0.16734300553798676, -0.41740837693214417, 0.5169001817703247, -0.23981255292892456, -0.2380400449037552, -0.3693102300167084, -0.06582563370466232, -0.03411499410867691, 0.09845133870840073, -0.19832712411880493, -0.6209984421730042, -0.4533732831478119, -0.5019934773445129, -0.35728588700294495, -0.26905637979507446, -0.2572650909423828, -0.04220975562930107, -0.37684011459350586, -0.7401458024978638, 0.2932822108268738, 0.14318522810935974, 0.21930761635303497, 0.3700069487094879, 0.39324963092803955, -0.08639740198850632, -0.17081084847450256, 0.15468038618564606, 0.23374240100383759, 0.8895206451416016, 0.542044460773468, 0.1702287346124649, 0.12954731285572052, 0.2679733633995056, 0.3551138639450073, 0.04437852278351784, 0.31875738501548767, 0.3934311866760254, -0.5813719630241394, -0.25463882088661194, -0.38570839166641235, -0.5798477530479431, -1.2950371503829956, 0.34603404998779297, -0.05722849443554878, 1.017817735671997, 0.3650880753993988, -0.5350961685180664, -0.16386494040489197, 0.04221240058541298, -1.0041707754135132, 0.33570605516433716, -0.5823325514793396, 0.23289667069911957, 0.4447762668132782, 0.03561461716890335, -0.823976993560791, 0.016588620841503143, -0.7402222752571106, -0.10184342414140701, 0.06602878123521805, 0.35331103205680847, 0.11878849565982819, 0.6635339260101318, -0.12207742035388947, 0.7429244518280029, -0.09119318425655365, 0.7745943069458008, -0.2612152695655823, 0.33785268664360046, -0.4836493134498596, 0.11117064952850342, 0.209047332406044, -0.08265402168035507, -0.1342828869819641, -0.2178322821855545, 0.10018649697303772, -0.3484717309474945, 0.05717682093381882, 0.5668947100639343, -0.8911707401275635, 0.35158538818359375, 0.12127723544836044, -0.5125513076782227, 0.781737744808197, 0.971946120262146, 0.1277076154947281, 0.7585288882255554, -0.027225174009799957, -0.63604736328125, -0.45115765929222107, 0.21913054585456848, 0.4308846592903137, -1.2956936359405518, -0.24056991934776306, -0.4768334925174713, -0.21653510630130768, -0.18434695899486542, 0.5670773386955261, -0.11639168858528137, 0.1866038590669632, -0.052388228476047516, -0.29923999309539795, -0.07533649355173111, -0.3770686984062195, -0.4757143557071686, -0.79753178358078, -0.45353201031684875, -1.1307507753372192, 0.6897481083869934, -0.5751065015792847, 0.49795204401016235, 0.38443776965141296, -0.48158690333366394, -0.012640712782740593, 0.4385855197906494, -0.02634906955063343, -0.01660546287894249, -0.6193205714225769, 0.17570635676383972, -0.4519054889678955, 0.1672602742910385, -0.04941361024975777, -0.07319172471761703, -0.9332021474838257, 0.6088638305664062, -0.22177143394947052, -0.34544897079467773, -0.03553041070699692, 0.31600087881088257, 1.0164307355880737, -0.5564780831336975, 0.3234042227268219, 0.26940664649009705, 0.17825016379356384, 0.8670111298561096, 0.41518110036849976, -0.5806182622909546, -0.5216776728630066, -0.3700394928455353, -1.24582839012146, 0.5032786726951599, 0.33322837948799133, 0.09589321166276932, -0.635482668876648, -0.4703357517719269, -0.5083743333816528, -0.2840563654899597, 0.02097497321665287, 0.19971045851707458, -0.4195556044578552, -0.43881669640541077, -0.08727729320526123, 0.7792119979858398, -0.6516622304916382, 0.2377002239227295, -0.341126412153244, -0.3633319139480591, -0.04440947622060776, -0.10247256606817245, -0.7297919392585754, -0.7885143756866455, -0.6961405873298645, 0.19354231655597687, 0.0018659066408872604, 0.4520154893398285, 0.4962112605571747, -0.4896809458732605, -0.25099921226501465, -0.5750879645347595, 0.09792937338352203, -0.7358516454696655, 0.10875829309225082, 0.2798309624195099, 0.3107197880744934, -0.11691311001777649, -0.7083507776260376, 0.594849169254303, -1.1464588642120361, -0.22327610850334167, 0.3975948095321655, -0.20556750893592834, -0.41783809661865234, 0.8148605227470398, 0.14362487196922302, -0.406723290681839, -0.18635296821594238, -0.845708966255188, -0.5143077969551086, 0.3214717209339142, -0.4982013702392578, 0.480607807636261, -0.9255307912826538, -0.5112811923027039, -0.2033064365386963, 0.5051793456077576, 0.19153368473052979, -0.10338963568210602, -0.15415361523628235, -0.09188314527273178, -0.393837571144104, -0.759888231754303, 1.1317437887191772, -0.5280877947807312, -0.5684223771095276, -0.5610873103141785, -0.7447819709777832, 0.05867202579975128, 0.5081427693367004, -0.06690143048763275, -0.34846869111061096, -0.030933985486626625, 0.14251373708248138, 0.7817577123641968, 0.4194442927837372, 0.39792758226394653, -0.10264761000871658, -0.10088558495044708, 0.12851212918758392, -0.46630939841270447, -0.5079578161239624, -0.32830944657325745, 0.5314062833786011, 0.3178013861179352, -0.3292560279369354, 0.016128065064549446, -0.058355625718832016, -0.5102785229682922, -0.6309726238250732, -0.5846728682518005, -0.21456390619277954, -1.8174108266830444, -0.3179776668548584, -0.6254804134368896, 0.24582111835479736, 0.09802515804767609, 0.47768962383270264, -0.633891224861145, 0.22779910266399384, -0.6135997772216797, 0.06758052110671997, -0.10873999446630478, 0.4149976372718811, 0.10835792124271393, -0.19982118904590607, -1.1813899278640747, -0.13828910887241364, 0.2700945734977722, 0.006367129273712635, -0.09764447063207626, -0.5694453120231628, -0.11202047765254974, 0.9600412249565125, 0.010934119112789631, 0.9022308588027954, -1.0481791496276855, -0.549283504486084, -0.5002825856208801, -0.2344905287027359, -0.25923314690589905, -0.06931597739458084, 0.7855043411254883, 1.0684478282928467, 0.18394631147384644, 0.368275910615921, 0.4820334315299988, -0.3854219615459442, -0.9061590433120728, -0.31226128339767456, 0.27988401055336, -0.13052129745483398, -0.456734299659729, -0.1215728223323822, 0.23833532631397247, 0.2344048023223877, -1.3241950273513794, 0.10031288862228394, -0.1603105664253235, 0.4702129364013672, -0.23757284879684448, 0.07963459193706512, -0.2980072498321533, 0.9104474782943726, -0.5647863745689392, 0.368561327457428, -0.34252437949180603, -0.05395151302218437, 0.22782184183597565, 0.12330739200115204, 0.37805700302124023, 0.2813575565814972, -0.6442803740501404, -0.46146291494369507, -1.0241167545318604, -0.07002203911542892, -0.5220484137535095, 0.2591280937194824, -0.9530156254768372, 0.059088610112667084, -0.4560810625553131, -0.20843294262886047, -0.6852234601974487, -0.04019233584403992, 0.5939940810203552, -0.6006441712379456, -0.19327427446842194, -0.14917907118797302, -0.7327842712402344, -0.1853313446044922, -0.42624151706695557, -0.11881250143051147, -0.5895638465881348, -0.6413699388504028, 0.12083053588867188, -0.25635290145874023, -0.35536229610443115, 0.3447708785533905, 0.04968329891562462, 0.11361772567033768, -0.31492045521736145, 0.00217020814307034, -0.5134632587432861, 0.49485644698143005, -0.9057885408401489, 0.4945409297943115, -0.6003583073616028, 0.46485385298728943, 0.04220354184508324, -0.6827870607376099, 0.11942586302757263, 0.6124767661094666, 0.1141972467303276, 0.7691470384597778, -0.010880298912525177, 0.6091979742050171, 0.10386202484369278, 0.040955282747745514, -0.1337340921163559, -0.4164813756942749, -0.5597630739212036, 0.8879030346870422, 0.4056246876716614, -0.4728701412677765, 0.25306421518325806, 0.32450059056282043, 0.018588511273264885, -0.4424225687980652, -0.08913873881101608, 0.37155038118362427, 0.3236953318119049, -0.875328540802002, 0.7590349316596985, 0.23278966546058655, 0.09701132029294968, -0.15155383944511414, -0.4854031801223755, 0.47914552688598633, 0.5320897102355957, 0.47854331135749817, 0.6570700407028198, 0.7792519330978394, 0.13066524267196655, 0.4344770610332489, 0.2722374200820923, 0.3872852027416229, -0.061548203229904175, 0.5910494923591614, 0.09113109856843948, 0.9444122314453125, 0.5698265433311462, 0.4977206885814667, 0.3089558184146881, 0.21238447725772858, 0.48466336727142334, 0.15514080226421356, 0.0499979704618454, 0.3302702009677887, 0.5985209941864014, 0.21372152864933014, -0.5393151044845581, 0.3225128650665283, -0.22991517186164856, -0.28233203291893005, 0.8644169569015503, 0.3617558777332306, 0.37269845604896545, 0.5681871771812439, 0.9695838093757629, 0.959203839302063, -0.007498371414840221, 0.5558472871780396, 0.3680161237716675, 0.3379443883895874, 0.055400021374225616, 0.7924596667289734, 0.3388180136680603, 0.310844749212265, 0.24748094379901886, -1.3132785558700562, -0.11067813634872437, 0.5237504243850708, -1.886671543121338, 0.4937440752983093, -0.30584609508514404, 0.045412588864564896, -0.23701216280460358, -0.6591693758964539, 0.3704417645931244, -0.41573619842529297, 0.22005592286586761, 0.24755454063415527, -0.20594118535518646, 0.7439090013504028, 0.3837096393108368, -0.15440873801708221, 0.35089752078056335, 1.0581541061401367, -0.2214139997959137, -0.20177535712718964, 1.047483205795288, 0.8956329822540283, 0.05410869047045708, 0.8009592890739441, 0.09444426000118256, -0.8376210331916809, 0.5522026419639587, 0.4673389196395874, -0.13656404614448547, 0.13833095133304596, -0.13059751689434052, -1.318654179573059, 0.11946892738342285, 0.9456527233123779, 0.03130893036723137, -0.3417050838470459, -0.5080453753471375, 0.19185636937618256, -0.4667150676250458, 0.09309554845094681, 1.627742886543274, 0.7140696048736572, -0.1507551223039627, -0.8973958492279053, 0.012249820865690708, -0.13260118663311005, -0.39404818415641785, -0.5324122905731201, -0.023256894201040268, -0.11164379119873047, 0.18385370075702667, 0.08415751159191132, -0.6838345527648926, 0.058347269892692566, -0.5266281962394714, -0.5679049491882324, -0.9485630989074707, 0.37103888392448425, -0.5483571887016296, 0.5003443360328674, 0.7284325957298279, -0.47271960973739624, -0.02787388116121292, -0.05411728471517563, 1.4207773208618164, -0.08683604001998901, 0.5351197719573975, 0.5908057689666748, 1.1194944381713867, -0.5477687120437622, 1.149109959602356, 0.5787509083747864, -0.6397663950920105, 0.49469253420829773, -0.795961856842041, -0.3966984450817108, 0.10353796929121017, -0.21938373148441315, 0.7374401688575745, 0.3947785794734955, 0.7409172654151917, -0.023320360109210014, -0.3279596269130707, -0.3560069501399994, -0.9907021522521973, -0.5256229043006897, -0.9150795340538025, 0.1461779922246933, -0.3482506275177002, 0.13878563046455383, 1.1098835468292236, -0.6411260366439819, 4.048859119415283, 1.389328956604004, 0.27626004815101624, 0.4314209222793579, 0.639711320400238, 0.5437014698982239, 0.2127852737903595, -0.27527305483818054, 0.2738713026046753, -0.5201573371887207, -0.3153685927391052, 0.12252963334321976, 0.2332880198955536, -0.5712442398071289, -0.41812068223953247, 1.3406579494476318, -0.37401461601257324, 0.015691252425312996, -0.04131319746375084, -1.089897632598877, -0.23483319580554962, -0.25503405928611755, -0.10123703628778458, -0.2740715444087982, -0.02116675302386284, -0.2935386300086975, -0.03988014534115791, -0.4997895061969757, -1.6553962230682373, 0.19982455670833588, -0.8338541984558105, -0.9098263382911682, -0.12081622332334518, -0.05921339988708496, -0.7570837736129761, 0.48577290773391724, 0.21778054535388947, -0.011401872150599957, 0.5334627628326416, 0.4077605605125427, -0.7066011428833008, -0.41542887687683105, -0.0618925616145134, -0.4099346101284027, -1.538967251777649, 0.6536063551902771, -0.5247566103935242, 1.3465960025787354, 0.18261446058750153, -0.202435702085495, 0.5678726434707642, 0.2708805203437805, 0.636829674243927, -0.14472076296806335, -0.7182572484016418, 0.496484637260437, -0.35816946625709534, 0.12506642937660217, 0.2554043233394623, -0.36843886971473694, 0.7361059784889221, -0.25567662715911865, -0.5852839350700378, -0.25700363516807556, 0.13967537879943848, 1.066650152206421, 0.04896586015820503, 0.31058380007743835, -0.15542814135551453, 0.07062201201915741, -0.04762277752161026, -0.30528584122657776, -0.31519079208374023, 0.10948476940393448, 0.5943914651870728, 0.23549693822860718, -0.12445641309022903, 0.9749279022216797, -0.06727863103151321, 0.5958242416381836, 0.031624626368284225, -0.33028626441955566, -0.5255813598632812, 0.06368681788444519, 0.03538835421204567, 1.0107812881469727, -0.13848698139190674, 0.22293877601623535, -0.5232136249542236, 0.8472288250923157, 0.8186230063438416, 1.4258636236190796, -0.6487686038017273, 0.04623199626803398, -0.663680374622345 ]
Magnetic Properties of Undoped $C_{60}$
The Heisenberg antiferromagnet, which arises from the large $U$ Hubbard model, is investigated on the $C_{60}$ molecule and other fullerenes. The connectivity of $C_{60}$ leads to an exotic classical ground state with nontrivial topology. We argue that there is no phase transition in the Hubbard model as a function of $U/t$, and thus the large $U$ solution is relevant for the physical case of intermediate coupling. The system undergoes a first order metamagnetic phase transition. We also consider the S=1/2 case using perturbation theory. Experimental tests are suggested.
D. Coffey and S. A. Trugman
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206010
cond-mat/9206011
[ -0.10774702578783035, 0.041269250214099884, 0.40994879603385925, -0.1953476518392563, -0.15785282850265503, 0.28274041414260864, -0.3710165321826935, -0.3604918122291565, -0.6051130890846252, 1.0477265119552612, 1.0957235097885132, -0.3376599848270416, 0.3454717695713043, -1.0940186977386475, -0.6291177868843079, 0.3211413323879242, -0.04193585738539696, -0.033427949994802475, -0.8356806039810181, 0.031614143401384354, 0.5259336233139038, -0.27887868881225586, -1.212914228439331, -0.12816745042800903, 0.2133977711200714, 0.7875352501869202, 0.11982804536819458, 0.5859072804450989, 1.2747175693511963, 0.5130775570869446, 0.09478548914194107, -0.6646464467048645, 0.27116766571998596, -0.7758182287216187, -0.2090325802564621, 0.23262403905391693, 0.2779688239097595, 0.35188090801239014, 1.0866061449050903, -0.4584342837333679, 0.7569835186004639, 0.4590323865413666, 0.8995996117591858, -0.13329169154167175, -0.22610139846801758, -0.14706556499004364, -0.42013123631477356, -0.19706128537654877, 0.07547734677791595, -1.361266851425171, 0.2703685462474823, 0.4528074860572815, 1.0842030048370361, -0.22836251556873322, 0.011268753558397293, -0.5316720008850098, -0.09052491933107376, 0.024078745394945145, 0.11498890072107315, 0.34375789761543274, 0.8160141706466675, -0.35575634241104126, 0.6775944232940674, -0.9148736000061035, 0.5687347054481506, 0.3225361704826355, -0.38698363304138184, 0.6048890948295593, -0.09774993360042572, -0.279983252286911, -0.3179932236671448, -0.6953288316726685, -0.23844459652900696, -0.41696974635124207, -0.3571409285068512, 0.5699131488800049, -0.051903437823057175, -0.24761822819709778, -1.7192775011062622, 0.14247597754001617, -0.465481698513031, -0.2176302671432495, -0.1361406147480011, 0.31222063302993774, 0.3115193545818329, -0.5455937385559082, -0.11727133393287659, 0.4634818732738495, -0.1045389249920845, 0.004668709356337786, 0.23270288109779358, 0.7875949740409851, 0.11536037921905518, 0.15016056597232819, 0.5294973850250244, 0.3057432770729065, -0.12492690980434418, 0.7502329349517822, 0.6442796587944031, 0.6405192017555237, -0.17794106900691986, 0.325600266456604, -0.11207902431488037, 0.861112654209137, -0.42721444368362427, 0.44175228476524353, -0.1171528548002243, -0.1314394176006317, 0.010089590214192867, -0.5426753759384155, 0.8950902223587036, -0.20366732776165009, 0.9179890155792236, 0.6483959555625916, -0.3211900591850281, 0.19933050870895386, -0.578376293182373, 0.0613231360912323, 0.24705255031585693, -0.19780200719833374, 0.16762007772922516, -0.6355777978897095, 0.3027305603027344, 0.2567996680736542, -0.15087062120437622, 0.050310224294662476, 0.5042831897735596, 0.24082361161708832, -0.8992456197738647, -0.4563077986240387, 0.13972637057304382, -0.0653206929564476, 0.056364718824625015, 0.2544499337673187, -0.901043176651001, 0.38400524854660034, -0.11576630920171738, 0.6365637183189392, 0.18074065446853638, -0.6610202193260193, 0.32042190432548523, -0.5197442173957825, 0.666023850440979, 0.8226525783538818, 0.17809689044952393, 0.5997591018676758, 0.10461708158254623, -0.10502829402685165, 0.0668109878897667, 0.666816771030426, -0.4341401159763336, -0.33379289507865906, -0.6316418647766113, 0.3188304305076599, 0.014429527334868908, -0.04494895786046982, -0.5712903738021851, 0.6150640249252319, -0.8817206621170044, -0.9082360863685608, 0.34773069620132446, 0.05020132288336754, 0.550548791885376, -0.1662243902683258, -0.6896374225616455, 0.1584128588438034, -0.5830214619636536, -0.6447194218635559, -0.15399478375911713, -0.12576189637184143, -0.04105453938245773, 0.298350989818573, -0.10341192036867142, 0.8926961421966553, 0.6728267669677734, 0.004644861910492182, 0.33783280849456787, -0.08219510316848755, 0.14356732368469238, 0.5172566175460815, -0.3005931079387665, -0.650456428527832, 1.5607705116271973, 0.1894945502281189, -0.35526028275489807, -0.08056658506393433, -0.7616426944732666, 0.21062250435352325, -0.520815372467041, 0.42296093702316284, -0.5347198843955994, 0.09492982923984528, -0.5594892501831055, 0.6189901232719421, -0.7799491882324219, -0.18251682817935944, -1.6539610624313354, 0.8873172998428345, -0.5586256980895996, -0.3995107412338257, -0.2047746777534485, 0.35770368576049805, -0.992843747138977, -0.2321111261844635, -1.3151984214782715, -0.3577873408794403, 0.41303765773773193, 0.4410955011844635, -0.40916481614112854, 0.004541515838354826, 0.32952824234962463, 0.01513654924929142, 0.5418282151222229, 0.20325900614261627, -0.011477818712592125, 0.19161885976791382, -0.13845571875572205, 0.19736230373382568, 0.7594401240348816, 0.05412999913096428, 0.7289220690727234, 0.7313007712364197, -0.5644107460975647, 0.986892580986023, 0.171603724360466, 0.321887344121933, 0.16773098707199097, 0.6175376176834106, 0.3523848056793213, -0.3748661279678345, -0.17579308152198792, 0.2247398942708969, 0.20793934166431427, -0.014183217659592628, 0.5334838628768921, 0.4892711341381073, 0.34255024790763855, 0.31787756085395813, 0.6260486841201782, 0.161452978849411, -0.3776712417602539, -0.35491713881492615, 0.3969689905643463, -0.25858643651008606, 0.5442771911621094, -0.2319963127374649, -0.03625873848795891, 0.7153724431991577, -0.8790321946144104, 0.5118774771690369, -0.7530472874641418, 0.9167903661727905, -0.12766502797603607, 0.2643139660358429, -0.69575035572052, -0.021755298599600792, 0.6257643103599548, -0.14019213616847992, -0.36956003308296204, -0.38732680678367615, 0.06741155683994293, -0.19811995327472687, -0.23347961902618408, -0.519550621509552, -0.06859395653009415, 0.7532199025154114, 0.47843435406684875, 0.3569057285785675, 0.4704740047454834, -0.3099270761013031, -1.181293249130249, -0.5043495893478394, -1.0276854038238525, -0.10713456571102142, -0.3718459904193878, 0.051885586231946945, 0.7973288297653198, -0.9585473537445068, 0.5765959024429321, 0.16978810727596283, 0.18813291192054749, 0.5852267742156982, 0.10237506031990051, 0.6377512216567993, 0.4247440993785858, 0.038450438529253006, -0.4941342771053314, 0.3893500566482544, -1.1101654767990112, 0.4364843964576721, -0.37115660309791565, 0.4513755738735199, 0.6932648420333862, -0.42716890573501587, 0.4310881197452545, -1.071983814239502, -0.4782920479774475, -0.23394273221492767, 0.10647479444742203, 0.13866043090820312, -0.4374313950538635, 0.498220294713974, -0.15313075482845306, 0.0970572754740715, -0.48545610904693604, 0.951083779335022, 0.33652743697166443, -0.312065452337265, 0.09899512678384781, 0.4155510663986206, 0.03330887109041214, 0.7276338338851929, 0.18152695894241333, 0.09135553985834122, -0.02529960684478283, 0.8823422789573669, 1.051709771156311, 0.3416244089603424, 0.1920538693666458, -1.2140876054763794, -0.658135712146759, 0.4709834158420563, -0.14562667906284332, -1.0195354223251343, -0.3216162323951721, 0.6906676292419434, -0.4943942427635193, -0.7294507026672363, -0.22201474010944366, -1.1061705350875854, -0.38871315121650696, 0.08181541413068771, -0.3620724380016327, 0.7366504073143005, -0.8461248874664307, -0.4470807611942291, -0.7244492173194885, 0.24275939166545868, 0.914186418056488, 0.07994482666254044, 0.10219328105449677, -0.35034090280532837, 0.39802610874176025, 0.029802590608596802, -0.11067930608987808, 0.07526151090860367, -0.07851557433605194, -0.013315564952790737, -0.5352029800415039, 0.3083720803260803, -0.2991269528865814, 0.1745719611644745, 0.42514026165008545, 0.580793559551239, 0.43755513429641724, 0.9586514234542847, -0.31517744064331055, -0.7596192359924316, -0.5256554484367371, 0.1359783113002777, 0.3173270523548126, 0.30204036831855774, -0.048549819737672806, 0.004854438826441765, -0.8590033650398254, -0.7327297925949097, 0.18113817274570465, -0.1782221496105194, 0.09941817820072174, -0.5047664046287537, 0.10913187265396118, 0.1945214867591858, 0.2023506909608841, 0.5685204267501831, -0.7232127785682678, -0.4254634380340576, -0.03765273839235306, 0.3683364987373352, 0.29398298263549805, -0.12210007756948471, -0.19869783520698547, -0.10435520857572556, 0.5595970749855042, 0.7202515602111816, 0.7035667300224304, -0.184840589761734, -0.11710759252309799, 0.05604548007249832, 0.06470238417387009, -0.3913191556930542, -0.4554406702518463, -0.15532998740673065, -0.7355102896690369, -0.5827900171279907, -0.3980899155139923, 0.37572434544563293, 0.5887463688850403, -0.20752273499965668, 0.4207020401954651, -0.08089505136013031, -0.022390007972717285, 1.0118412971496582, 0.7306485772132874, 0.5359480381011963, -0.2993796169757843, 0.15794967114925385, -0.6065874695777893, 0.4058831036090851, 0.25885695219039917, -0.051347266882658005, -0.28705254197120667, -0.5267400741577148, -0.43614163994789124, -0.3402257263660431, 0.7034549117088318, 0.20292679965496063, -0.38473063707351685, 0.8592198491096497, 0.3126310706138611, 0.1642419695854187, -0.17598114907741547, -0.2406834363937378, 0.3015514314174652, 0.12865692377090454, 0.2982328236103058, -0.49198082089424133, -0.008918491192162037, -0.48848584294319153, 0.4666464328765869, 0.5798800587654114, -0.5346744656562805, -0.8371745944023132, -0.9202108383178711, -0.0007328062783926725, -0.9477925300598145, 0.14021894335746765, 1.0015250444412231, 0.26493605971336365, -0.0030673507135361433, -0.2484252005815506, -0.640277087688446, -0.12220096588134766, -0.39672818779945374, -0.5111983418464661, 0.11881615966558456, -0.27638840675354004, -0.22524817287921906, 0.3557339310646057, 0.15539339184761047, -0.07248550653457642, -0.27158820629119873, -0.5574907064437866, -0.2932235598564148, -0.5982216000556946, -0.08438118547201157, -0.23941653966903687, 0.09446903318166733, -1.1293284893035889, 0.5398159623146057, -0.2526930570602417, 0.4538888931274414, 0.2769259512424469, 0.0818590521812439, 0.0726233720779419, -0.39403200149536133, 0.3450257182121277, -0.46782633662223816, 0.4337749779224396, 0.7912752032279968, -0.00015827754396013916, 0.16085094213485718, 0.635234534740448, -0.021604064851999283, 0.25244179368019104, 0.6535869836807251, -0.1561078578233719, 0.14658372104167938, -0.25430357456207275, -0.5221502184867859, -0.454560786485672, -1.0052180290222168, 0.25273948907852173, -0.08256609737873077, 0.846092164516449, -0.12486104667186737, -0.21449415385723114, -0.36022862792015076, -0.1958804726600647, -1.2215049266815186, 0.09397780150175095, -0.5009745359420776, -0.5670140385627747, -0.11742634326219559, -0.14737637341022491, -1.0813932418823242, 0.5212041735649109, -0.9642465114593506, -0.45639917254447937, 0.7101004123687744, 0.377397358417511, 0.26947057247161865, 1.0513187646865845, -0.28391340374946594, 0.6109756231307983, 0.12873858213424683, 0.576344907283783, -0.4879852831363678, -0.1177717000246048, -0.4830344617366791, 0.34970682859420776, -0.5236298441886902, -0.18643157184123993, -0.2962152361869812, -0.22836048901081085, 0.14705340564250946, 0.23497150838375092, 0.611770749092102, 0.09271606057882309, -0.8869059681892395, 0.7557323575019836, 0.24451130628585815, -0.02945454604923725, 0.45372146368026733, 0.8909659385681152, -0.06336402893066406, 0.4458927512168884, -0.3544004559516907, -0.7360820770263672, -0.1296955645084381, 0.15313102304935455, -0.08492985367774963, -1.334576964378357, -0.5982175469398499, -0.3858201801776886, -0.6190610527992249, 0.17245011031627655, 0.755418062210083, -0.033530354499816895, 0.07182639837265015, -0.39907488226890564, -0.3071824014186859, -0.4096568524837494, -0.17421241104602814, -0.31944090127944946, -0.8242219090461731, -0.3033471703529358, -0.7597289085388184, 0.7055325508117676, -0.5475453734397888, 0.3389827609062195, 0.5283139944076538, -0.4220358729362488, 0.05301659554243088, 0.7185280919075012, 0.1018708348274231, -0.0714389979839325, -0.23151865601539612, 0.4957102835178375, -0.13729143142700195, -0.22197918593883514, -0.7824520468711853, 0.4441995620727539, -1.105065107345581, 0.8718201518058777, -0.00545480428263545, -0.23558276891708374, -0.08638186752796173, 0.07727263122797012, 0.6186087131500244, -0.39514175057411194, -0.40904223918914795, -0.04725180193781853, -0.11105624586343765, 0.6765307188034058, 0.19062969088554382, -0.6777746081352234, -0.8502992391586304, -0.4704801142215729, -1.1196566820144653, 0.3595564663410187, 0.26553982496261597, -0.12031558901071548, -0.7730963826179504, -0.07750442624092102, 0.2294510453939438, -0.457227498292923, 0.728064775466919, 0.4163367450237274, -0.14727990329265594, -0.015204259194433689, 0.22412578761577606, 0.2088780701160431, -0.4831131398677826, -0.28740742802619934, -0.2143717110157013, -0.5254645943641663, -0.057251837104558945, 0.2733928859233856, -0.9157019853591919, -1.055129051208496, -0.41943708062171936, -0.2658383846282959, -0.039614997804164886, -0.14797870814800262, 0.8455010652542114, 0.0060685486532747746, 0.06070563197135925, -0.18525084853172302, 0.6084976196289062, -0.7726779580116272, 0.33568620681762695, 0.6108666658401489, -0.08748670667409897, -0.08124882727861404, -0.442685067653656, 0.6284521818161011, -0.5943888425827026, -0.3935618996620178, 0.42548972368240356, -0.3357982337474823, -0.2637912929058075, 0.13446108996868134, -0.20186041295528412, -1.2545619010925293, -0.00452820397913456, -0.47645819187164307, -0.5017227530479431, 0.03499086946249008, -0.6914540529251099, 0.5161709189414978, -0.676641583442688, -0.7738739252090454, 0.26772576570510864, 0.5096029043197632, -0.08168720453977585, -0.38437390327453613, -0.6290117502212524, -0.18456895649433136, -0.22978635132312775, -0.5763216614723206, 1.4020382165908813, -0.6607133150100708, -0.6324909925460815, -0.3893048167228699, -0.15236708521842957, -0.30646899342536926, 0.5764852166175842, -0.06014271080493927, -0.5100486278533936, 0.15959957242012024, 0.42626211047172546, 0.9446611404418945, 0.4255176782608032, 0.1672203093767166, -0.16009671986103058, 0.08517418801784515, 0.23041974008083344, -0.7610503435134888, -0.839853823184967, -0.170962393283844, 0.3476238548755646, 0.34918010234832764, -0.5152905583381653, -0.3589133620262146, 0.46325746178627014, -0.19562764465808868, -0.46834734082221985, -0.49527665972709656, 0.23825009167194366, -1.03846275806427, -0.34644457697868347, -0.5174127817153931, -0.5375171303749084, 0.21086721122264862, 0.18470291793346405, -0.15328718721866608, -0.37638774514198303, -1.0973678827285767, 0.2020970582962036, -0.3390176296234131, 0.7814226150512695, 0.016830449923872948, -0.47007665038108826, -0.8884215950965881, 0.06282796710729599, 0.3165053129196167, -0.316110223531723, -0.40506279468536377, -0.24399062991142273, 0.1141253113746643, 0.3219749331474304, -0.24070730805397034, 0.7020775675773621, -0.617836058139801, -0.39187708497047424, -0.24900375306606293, -0.12962715327739716, -0.4408605992794037, 0.23135271668434143, 0.38073602318763733, 0.45510199666023254, -0.05799419432878494, 0.4620610773563385, 0.05130770802497864, 0.204866424202919, -0.6483902335166931, -0.2172207087278366, -0.4102543890476227, 0.06024576351046562, -0.060706090182065964, 0.06057446822524071, -0.051449425518512726, 0.2080659419298172, -0.8252286911010742, -0.04515419527888298, -0.008894396014511585, 0.32893630862236023, -0.14682506024837494, -0.09989092499017715, -0.2929598391056061, 0.7479561567306519, -0.7621262669563293, 0.39872685074806213, -0.6197827458381653, -0.7085091471672058, -0.16787400841712952, 0.23287759721279144, -0.19579800963401794, 0.14646685123443604, -0.0836358368396759, 0.22054177522659302, -0.911253035068512, 0.41624075174331665, -0.032639212906360626, 0.4717084467411041, -0.8307645320892334, 0.27302849292755127, -0.5864259600639343, -0.07123453170061111, -0.4258286952972412, 0.07950736582279205, 0.341728150844574, -0.5630130171775818, -0.677033007144928, -0.17576085031032562, -0.8954156637191772, 0.5236951112747192, -0.5650856494903564, -0.694320023059845, -0.2822420001029968, -0.5163893103599548, 0.20043648779392242, -0.10670245438814163, -0.5100625157356262, 0.5346941947937012, 0.264682799577713, 0.47464945912361145, 0.01641015335917473, -0.04676051437854767, -0.22862036526203156, 0.671478271484375, -0.4422917664051056, -0.16972002387046814, -0.7721337676048279, -0.05547451600432396, -0.7960234880447388, -0.5820444822311401, 0.21596650779247284, 0.9561598896980286, -0.08326790481805801, 0.6349153518676758, -0.31787365674972534, 0.08416695892810822, 0.6956745386123657, 0.3962244391441345, 0.00451856991276145, 0.16162557899951935, -0.31155768036842346, 0.8501167893409729, -0.55762779712677, -0.07413242012262344, 0.20912772417068481, 0.407541424036026, 0.5671850442886353, 0.06103896349668503, -0.30973657965660095, 0.055767811834812164, 0.0591512955725193, -0.5405088663101196, 0.9848340153694153, 0.570436418056488, 0.3544602394104004, 0.19588465988636017, -0.6205158233642578, 0.5317466259002686, 0.40126216411590576, 0.5760313272476196, 0.5120317935943604, 0.24685505032539368, 0.07329431176185608, -0.08224465698003769, 0.4116271734237671, 0.6394174695014954, -0.07304447889328003, 0.650719165802002, 0.3923448622226715, 1.0590544939041138, 0.3325093686580658, -0.08500485867261887, 0.626397430896759, -0.03287535160779953, -0.08355177938938141, -0.17526307702064514, -0.28126904368400574, 0.34873995184898376, 0.5273870825767517, 0.28894007205963135, -0.2501741647720337, 0.3131711781024933, -0.0971042811870575, -0.16147419810295105, 0.5412496328353882, 0.3957166373729706, 0.028225483372807503, 0.33872273564338684, 1.214821219444275, 0.9546151757240295, 0.19463756680488586, 0.7041050791740417, 0.6033776998519897, 0.28910723328590393, -0.41324061155319214, 0.8735311031341553, 0.4052763283252716, 0.8354946374893188, 0.12017554044723511, -0.9593627452850342, 0.1407131850719452, 0.13873498141765594, -1.1368474960327148, 0.21236857771873474, -0.5053841471672058, -0.1351960003376007, -0.5060855150222778, -0.40820086002349854, 0.1751411408185959, -0.15305033326148987, 0.6385115385055542, 0.26873886585235596, 0.09081223607063293, 0.3990577757358551, 0.5669165849685669, 0.024275097995996475, 0.41072186827659607, 1.1774567365646362, 0.13766223192214966, 0.15879902243614197, 0.8679618239402771, 0.6096125841140747, -0.009101024828851223, 0.7484397888183594, 0.07896478474140167, -0.5395104885101318, 0.40676993131637573, 0.1234322115778923, 0.19262951612472534, 0.6720811724662781, 0.13719044625759125, -0.5368374586105347, -0.1396145075559616, 0.9528716206550598, -0.08410472422838211, -0.23495395481586456, -0.09256523102521896, 0.2027616649866104, -0.47981300950050354, 0.6076480746269226, 1.4541528224945068, 0.36882326006889343, -0.3080182373523712, -1.0719486474990845, -0.2666700780391693, -0.08204004168510437, -0.33205947279930115, -0.8357505798339844, 0.36026376485824585, 0.3327564001083374, -0.12969733774662018, -0.3186398446559906, 0.22410978376865387, -0.022533534094691277, -0.626937210559845, -0.5079606771469116, -1.1900194883346558, 0.23850348591804504, -1.1383371353149414, 0.4611271023750305, 0.28700363636016846, -0.7181820869445801, -0.09618925303220749, -0.4785056710243225, 0.7290442585945129, -0.23110714554786682, 0.38144657015800476, 0.5379686951637268, 0.7419127225875854, -0.43686744570732117, 0.49198758602142334, 0.6922950744628906, -0.9176031351089478, 0.5881162285804749, -0.33987879753112793, 0.12342947721481323, -0.05055065080523491, -0.23985978960990906, 0.2265806943178177, 0.096329465508461, -0.006218054797500372, -0.1451311856508255, 0.19038830697536469, -0.33704474568367004, -0.6144887804985046, 0.05180143564939499, -0.5526928901672363, 0.377405047416687, -0.09401142597198486, 0.2781450152397156, 0.43642473220825195, -0.4949565529823303, 4.229252338409424, 1.174686074256897, 0.29492872953414917, -0.16068920493125916, 0.7202524542808533, 0.9015858173370361, 0.05441833660006523, -0.6853269934654236, -0.20350563526153564, -0.45768100023269653, -0.10932880640029907, 0.049769867211580276, 0.2231634259223938, -0.48157355189323425, -0.27990293502807617, 0.8724895715713501, -0.26594677567481995, -0.31211793422698975, -0.2055475115776062, -1.2044848203659058, -0.43475010991096497, -0.3063318133354187, 0.6375346779823303, -0.32490259408950806, 0.09226582199335098, 0.030456041917204857, 0.08017819374799728, -0.11395293474197388, -0.8180352449417114, -0.009044193662703037, -0.27714118361473083, -0.8854643106460571, 0.08017778396606445, -0.33684083819389343, -0.614408016204834, 0.46869441866874695, -0.04580976814031601, -0.465350866317749, 0.0221854280680418, -0.008920464664697647, -0.2939823865890503, 0.5666407942771912, -0.5469211339950562, -0.048108674585819244, -1.0198053121566772, 0.8435623049736023, -0.6611946225166321, 1.0233538150787354, 0.5062761902809143, -0.5285900235176086, 0.38515862822532654, -0.32103991508483887, 0.6834105849266052, -0.08780331909656525, -0.9599857330322266, 0.15594127774238586, -0.42659229040145874, 0.6696454882621765, 0.6363080739974976, 0.20723097026348114, 0.6294094920158386, 0.19424280524253845, -0.5724977254867554, -0.363970011472702, 0.07082366943359375, 1.0709046125411987, 0.48216891288757324, 0.6238391399383545, -0.23791557550430298, -0.03377177566289902, 0.0008044994319789112, -0.45437532663345337, -0.8623675107955933, 0.12502159178256989, -0.029356202110648155, 0.385305255651474, -0.5045301914215088, 0.4554486572742462, 0.38363227248191833, 0.2907196581363678, 0.22090013325214386, -0.004937154706567526, -0.37007665634155273, -0.2262863963842392, -0.14671896398067474, 1.2755824327468872, 0.14261531829833984, -0.19283472001552582, -0.044015079736709595, 0.43949779868125916, 0.4207487404346466, 1.2894285917282104, 0.11744362860918045, -0.380565345287323, -0.5109943151473999 ]
Correlations for the S=1/2 Antiferromagnet on a Truncated Tetrahedron
The antiferromagnetic Heisenberg Hamiltonian is investigated on a truncated tetrahedron, which is a closed 12 site system. We find that the ground state has many similarities to that of $C_{60}$. We study 2- and 4-spin correlations in the classical ground state of the truncated tetrahedron and calculate the same correlations in the exact S=1/2 ground state. We find that the classical correlations survive for a range of bond strengths in the Heisenberg Hamiltonian and that one can construct a good trial wavefunction based on the classical ground state. This suggests that the correlations present in the classical ground state of $C_{60}$ also survive in the exact ground state of that system, for a range of bond strengths about the physically relevant $J_2 \approx J_1$. We calculate the momentum-space correlation function $S ( q )$, which is measurable by neutron scattering, for both $C_{12}$ and $C_{60}$. We also calculate correlations at finite temperature.
D. Coffey and S. A. Trugman
cond-mat
June
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9206011
cond-mat/9207001
[ -0.0031538251787424088, 0.15468405187129974, 0.6234885454177856, 0.29626864194869995, -0.2788195312023163, -1.0690258741378784, -0.6753764748573303, -0.322248250246048, -0.4393325746059418, 1.607729196548462, 0.48100462555885315, 0.17024880647659302, 0.09312363713979721, -0.48615729808807373, -1.231821060180664, 0.38369590044021606, -0.09846463799476624, -0.532889187335968, -1.5357868671417236, -0.07817558944225311, -0.24022968113422394, -0.491655558347702, -1.1823768615722656, -0.10541293770074844, -0.24181364476680756, 0.8236258625984192, 0.3841473162174225, 0.22974362969398499, 0.866495668888092, 0.6391658186912537, 0.6733192801475525, -0.138692706823349, 0.5108740925788879, -1.158954381942749, 0.32545995712280273, 0.041111160069704056, 0.6326584219932556, -0.7546969652175903, 0.1958780288696289, -0.09103042632341385, 1.2927124500274658, 0.13751566410064697, 0.5603318810462952, -0.1508188396692276, -0.22623027861118317, 0.25780442357063293, -0.01307135820388794, 0.22175273299217224, -0.14711283147335052, -1.1039619445800781, 0.211274653673172, 0.10660901665687561, 0.36421680450439453, -0.7889561653137207, -0.4961315095424652, -0.6461195349693298, -0.3624231517314911, 0.9112367630004883, 0.31063494086265564, 0.14683786034584045, 0.390421599149704, 0.22419051826000214, 0.2915470600128174, -0.27182480692863464, -0.48952987790107727, 1.1138187646865845, 0.0500929169356823, 0.7113175988197327, 0.09221606701612473, -0.028995255008339882, -0.2595844268798828, -0.5134199261665344, -0.14681832492351532, 0.6026877164840698, -0.8870416879653931, 1.0150697231292725, 0.07897618412971497, -0.34650397300720215, -0.9303304553031921, -0.14249710738658905, 0.7251082062721252, -0.45484572649002075, -0.3366481363773346, 0.7811711430549622, -0.17699167132377625, -0.18871697783470154, 0.7529423832893372, -0.14545471966266632, 0.3618052303791046, 0.7487621903419495, 0.1964927762746811, 0.7802989482879639, -0.11652781814336777, -0.38363075256347656, 0.4461138844490051, 0.6105272769927979, -0.3240814805030823, 0.14286229014396667, 0.49540749192237854, 0.19786839187145233, -0.053238287568092346, 0.5494487881660461, -0.36835992336273193, 0.3052756190299988, -0.6151352524757385, 0.1045454740524292, 0.2417702078819275, 0.3889131247997284, 0.2854914367198944, -0.6567642688751221, 0.045316725969314575, -0.5108140110969543, 0.13633276522159576, 0.6933110952377319, 0.352495402097702, 0.5015641450881958, 0.4430406987667084, 0.024968568235635757, -0.848240077495575, 0.3044417202472687, 0.42912402749061584, 0.41254493594169617, 0.6213534474372864, 0.7440863251686096, 0.08274733275175095, -0.4690014719963074, -0.0219500083476305, 0.4300432801246643, -0.3154287338256836, 0.27947062253952026, 0.04526932165026665, -0.08960449695587158, -0.6535031795501709, 0.43684127926826477, 0.07264488190412521, 0.35623040795326233, 0.28113415837287903, 0.8657004833221436, 0.43925681710243225, -0.32814913988113403, -0.04108283296227455, -0.6271924376487732, -0.37244176864624023, 0.9030085802078247, -0.2241138070821762, 0.5774341225624084, 0.13800786435604095, 0.5953481793403625, -0.4139391779899597, 0.13662223517894745, -1.1139137744903564, -0.29967552423477173, -0.10033576190471649, 0.5109110474586487, -0.44975215196609497, 0.1836874783039093, -0.660153329372406, -0.0019515121821314096, -1.0116324424743652, -0.6700834631919861, -0.019573071971535683, -0.7147917747497559, 0.5263166427612305, 0.6873867511749268, -0.424645334482193, 0.3769240975379944, -1.1638152599334717, -0.6712181568145752, -0.5274431109428406, -0.19586656987667084, -0.029449211433529854, -0.5429778099060059, 0.40175002813339233, 1.031211018562317, 0.7104068398475647, 0.5935171246528625, 0.11170129477977753, -0.5371885895729065, -0.1097259372472763, 0.26367342472076416, 0.17366524040699005, -0.1739538460969925, -0.0002946363529190421, 0.5560935139656067, 0.09632552415132523, -0.320809543132782, -0.5633541941642761, -0.5184924006462097, -0.34815457463264465, 0.44038474559783936, -0.16764579713344574, 1.0321848392486572, -1.106217622756958, 0.2834772765636444, -0.5672096610069275, 0.26430147886276245, -0.23766560852527618, 0.7598250508308411, -0.09310153871774673, -0.2897557318210602, 0.5849521160125732, 0.11892819404602051, -1.2617521286010742, -0.03669587895274162, -1.3674606084823608, 0.18214111030101776, 0.8046854138374329, 0.7047115564346313, -0.4987950921058655, -0.5303145051002502, 0.19914790987968445, -0.21321356296539307, 0.3157239854335785, -0.6102004051208496, -0.3765893876552582, 0.37992700934410095, 0.17268826067447662, 0.05850552022457123, -0.16068053245544434, -0.2921545207500458, 0.31815218925476074, -0.5240381360054016, -0.7145575284957886, 0.7192094326019287, -0.10449358075857162, -0.7493499517440796, -0.4589894413948059, 0.4421960115432739, 0.6185721755027771, 0.034476835280656815, 0.022469639778137207, 0.4822230637073517, -0.6059873104095459, 0.4425894320011139, 0.009852503426373005, -0.2949025630950928, 0.5964224338531494, 0.6294504404067993, 0.1033949926495552, 0.0946313887834549, 0.42977792024612427, 0.33652064204216003, 0.6263405680656433, 0.0719791129231453, 0.29908618330955505, 1.4996711015701294, -0.10196398943662643, 0.22158126533031464, -0.9425922632217407, 0.48783501982688904, -0.48313260078430176, 0.612918496131897, -0.18142661452293396, 0.46690529584884644, -0.25884389877319336, 0.14630554616451263, 0.06620032340288162, 0.32950741052627563, -0.17741647362709045, -0.6092840433120728, -0.6042948961257935, -0.00349158956669271, -0.7813513875007629, -0.8417516350746155, 0.07562591880559921, 1.3169236183166504, -0.34503933787345886, 0.09894438087940216, 0.19189415872097015, -0.3119031488895416, -1.3793686628341675, -0.12975740432739258, -0.6090891361236572, -0.3560023903846741, -0.06385394930839539, -0.6471856236457825, 0.5779523849487305, -0.3621193468570709, 0.6206921339035034, -0.2772328555583954, -0.3395358622074127, 0.3643988370895386, -0.09250766783952713, 0.48778650164604187, -0.18535353243350983, 0.15159036219120026, -1.047595500946045, 0.17392656207084656, -0.5349027514457703, 0.18439973890781403, -0.19145597517490387, -0.5834875702857971, 0.14186415076255798, 0.24943265318870544, -0.2731114625930786, 0.4533342719078064, 0.14442138373851776, 0.5064803957939148, -0.2038620114326477, -0.35829105973243713, -0.012064645066857338, 0.8998619914054871, -0.2173522561788559, -0.33753839135169983, -0.6881232857704163, 0.569739818572998, -0.0945364460349083, -1.0708701610565186, 0.7320913672447205, 0.3180171549320221, -0.6231972575187683, 0.37231770157814026, -0.9982197284698486, 0.4797821640968323, -0.2818984389305115, 0.7749408483505249, 0.5826935172080994, 0.3336259424686432, 0.5110332369804382, -0.3450411558151245, -0.3256780803203583, -0.04964854195713997, 0.3668937385082245, -0.6440151929855347, 0.03200395405292511, 0.7478064298629761, 0.046544965356588364, -0.07663492113351822, 0.7794005870819092, -0.28070032596588135, -0.44259557127952576, 0.513270378112793, -0.1065584123134613, 0.13413935899734497, 0.17039816081523895, -0.4599277377128601, -0.6315848231315613, -0.42109230160713196, 0.6183785200119019, 0.23070836067199707, 0.6957643628120422, -0.6362801790237427, 0.32261380553245544, 0.5048643350601196, 0.9694563150405884, -0.3815755546092987, 1.0075132846832275, -0.09770992398262024, -0.34878671169281006, 0.30797046422958374, -0.8007047176361084, 0.12737815082073212, 0.15634213387966156, 0.3122699558734894, -0.029999596998095512, 0.37132176756858826, -0.27809396386146545, -0.30272990465164185, -0.32588186860084534, -0.23849555850028992, 0.28857511281967163, 0.725508451461792, -0.14154189825057983, -0.1653536707162857, -0.4956658184528351, -0.27102917432785034, 0.9658176302909851, -0.6524568200111389, 0.9155828356742859, -1.1702873706817627, 0.45867905020713806, 0.06319805234670639, -0.3940100073814392, 0.14904792606830597, -0.2995681166648865, 0.2606954574584961, 0.6116418838500977, 0.33141976594924927, 1.194773554801941, -0.4557686746120453, -0.4841817021369934, -0.4763250946998596, 0.7763849496841431, 0.8046848773956299, 0.6803794503211975, 0.6149303913116455, -0.3359750807285309, 0.44758665561676025, -0.47006547451019287, -0.7224563360214233, -0.2997521460056305, -0.6827450394630432, -0.4867832064628601, -1.00951087474823, -0.286708265542984, -0.09165339916944504, 0.6892529726028442, 0.3781535029411316, -0.1330159455537796, 0.13984660804271698, 0.11034610867500305, -0.4583747684955597, 0.17313134670257568, 0.6414123773574829, 0.25904014706611633, 0.40104568004608154, -0.9598897099494934, 0.14994631707668304, 0.47259286046028137, 0.15941600501537323, -0.5300233364105225, -0.3341158926486969, 0.020199906080961227, -0.3662359416484833, 0.9904825091362, -0.012860629707574844, -0.6723049283027649, 0.40128859877586365, 0.18816889822483063, 0.3312956392765045, -0.10967709124088287, -0.5581845641136169, 0.5157180428504944, 0.9186233282089233, 0.0571305975317955, -1.577425479888916, 0.10621052235364914, -0.17842775583267212, 0.7778846025466919, 0.475271075963974, 0.16668418049812317, -0.4254741966724396, -0.6349138617515564, 0.2126590758562088, -0.7878182530403137, 0.25223055481910706, 0.4535447359085083, 0.4025256931781769, 0.2526988387107849, -0.08553093671798706, -0.3894984722137451, 0.7405326962471008, -0.4140515923500061, -0.3851616084575653, -0.022676177322864532, 0.7393777370452881, -0.15516206622123718, 0.5325742959976196, -0.44577866792678833, -0.5186867117881775, -0.5787376761436462, -0.08585462719202042, 0.721231997013092, -0.5390746593475342, -0.4893674850463867, 0.39376357197761536, 0.11803121119737625, -0.23084011673927307, 1.3023494482040405, -0.34746313095092773, -0.3704419732093811, -0.5355405807495117, 0.039490338414907455, -0.9007718563079834, -0.4705408215522766, 0.2598497271537781, -0.020180299878120422, 0.34788113832473755, 0.34757837653160095, -0.20677244663238525, -0.1439775973558426, -0.1430048793554306, -0.12039842456579208, 0.1238250881433487, 1.4257301092147827, -0.19353815913200378, -0.30929622054100037, -0.0598810613155365, -0.10490556061267853, -0.6420230865478516, -0.033728450536727905, -0.2521772086620331, -0.02870684117078781, 0.13964127004146576, 0.10779408365488052, -0.855175256729126, -0.08870846033096313, -0.1274663209915161, -0.5050824880599976, 0.21300002932548523, -0.2962374687194824, -0.02001587115228176, -0.6413189172744751, 0.019889704883098602, -0.20805826783180237, 0.5039613246917725, -0.1969006359577179, -0.29137423634529114, 0.13737910985946655, -0.21959201991558075, -0.6060197949409485, 0.7269077301025391, -0.5792434215545654, 0.9351126551628113, 0.08735563606023788, 0.19634975492954254, -1.0983468294143677, -0.9664234519004822, 0.16001009941101074, 0.027680791914463043, -0.40625062584877014, -0.25596868991851807, -0.07003310322761536, -0.16022393107414246, 0.43859580159187317, 0.36800819635391235, -0.11015593260526657, -0.21332745254039764, -0.46239084005355835, 0.4929496645927429, -0.5280609130859375, -0.5311201810836792, 0.2596801519393921, 0.5207899212837219, -0.05134123936295509, -0.4348311722278595, 0.5884948372840881, -1.4798147678375244, -0.12486689537763596, -0.2239554226398468, 0.422709196805954, -0.6062793135643005, -0.18474967777729034, -0.17888641357421875, -0.3715600073337555, -0.1326713263988495, 0.07392582297325134, 0.12402939051389694, -0.6006684899330139, -0.6195862293243408, -0.9584813714027405, -0.3091302812099457, 0.013506703078746796, -0.21173273026943207, -0.7072526216506958, 0.14133039116859436, -0.09252534061670303, 0.6786455512046814, -0.6012579202651978, -0.3214452266693115, 0.6896742582321167, 0.3076068162918091, -0.09812033921480179, 0.7658910751342773, -0.3443421721458435, -0.20461750030517578, -0.22134694457054138, 0.1106385812163353, 0.14962299168109894, 0.7395894527435303, -1.0806642770767212, 0.32600730657577515, -0.9483808279037476, 0.28142231702804565, -0.6459117531776428, -0.09782499074935913, -0.25468429923057556, -0.3476230502128601, 0.47484713792800903, -0.9987848401069641, 0.15068823099136353, 0.3891066014766693, 0.15256774425506592, 1.0321881771087646, 0.6054444313049316, -0.5179998278617859, -0.14218853414058685, -0.9244251847267151, -1.22963547706604, 0.8882947564125061, 0.1073380559682846, 0.26142773032188416, -0.4184851050376892, -0.02645687945187092, 0.42507922649383545, -0.596845805644989, 0.20599372684955597, 1.0569190979003906, -0.009609144181013107, 0.3398187458515167, 0.11972863972187042, 0.2678009271621704, -0.1940477192401886, -0.33827221393585205, 0.42773136496543884, 0.298016220331192, -0.3273266851902008, -0.5001286268234253, -0.13776345551013947, -1.0432730913162231, -0.6068756580352783, 0.7915465235710144, 0.4638368487358093, -0.424022376537323, 1.1610369682312012, -0.6578518152236938, -0.39117667078971863, -0.4146523177623749, 0.018742574378848076, -0.16480666399002075, 0.6765117645263672, 0.31296437978744507, -0.3876425623893738, -0.0023186434991657734, -0.054950494319200516, 0.5738428831100464, -0.39130961894989014, -0.18308989703655243, 1.0031059980392456, -0.80591881275177, 0.07720331847667694, 0.7725821733474731, -0.4424857497215271, -0.9833211898803711, -0.11878698319196701, -0.5727248191833496, 0.40268203616142273, -0.08869745582342148, -0.7262082099914551, -0.3552452325820923, -0.3534304201602936, -0.20288611948490143, 0.07053685188293457, 0.905086874961853, -0.07497411221265793, 0.568556547164917, -0.16728878021240234, -0.06924252957105637, -0.4050000011920929, 0.26018714904785156, 0.8835077285766602, 0.127013698220253, -0.5677318572998047, -0.6181477904319763, -0.20600281655788422, -0.1970175951719284, -0.24249888956546783, 0.7485291957855225, 0.8282703757286072, 0.7474193572998047, 0.028658537194132805, 0.5331324338912964, 0.3655128479003906, 0.1491399109363556, -0.36752498149871826, 0.06462623178958893, -0.47200965881347656, -0.6289856433868408, -0.11179045587778091, -0.29157954454421997, -0.003845640690997243, 1.1494379043579102, 0.2787671983242035, -0.1309814602136612, -0.9039579033851624, -0.7185457348823547, -0.6154083609580994, -0.9642821550369263, -0.20324717462062836, -1.070877194404602, -0.6004517078399658, -1.1804349422454834, -0.413552463054657, -0.055296897888183594, 0.2578244209289551, 0.7132440209388733, 0.5772825479507446, -0.90015709400177, -0.3159252405166626, 0.10716662555932999, 0.595203161239624, 0.2236059457063675, -0.8754259347915649, -0.817916750907898, -0.3665606677532196, -0.8545435667037964, -0.4090884029865265, -0.5533527135848999, 0.3026227355003357, -0.045242127031087875, 0.6563184261322021, -0.5307247638702393, 0.40133556723594666, -0.17959028482437134, -0.5999486446380615, 0.22070161998271942, -0.38000601530075073, -1.09566068649292, 0.6208434104919434, -0.039199456572532654, 0.5220640897750854, 0.7782244086265564, -0.6198326349258423, -0.2933964729309082, 0.32599082589149475, -1.2051665782928467, 0.27267682552337646, -0.17768123745918274, 0.161978617310524, -0.2544405162334442, -0.5645729303359985, 0.5453933477401733, 0.41350361704826355, -1.1386569738388062, -0.01706581562757492, -0.48589152097702026, 0.4722203016281128, -0.3472917973995209, 0.1998056322336197, 0.07216086983680725, 0.3431362509727478, -0.33198389410972595, 0.9837582111358643, -0.7842718958854675, -0.3274378776550293, -0.3176076114177704, 0.22783972322940826, -0.5632297992706299, 0.3889133632183075, 0.2569514811038971, -0.10993922501802444, -0.16792511940002441, 0.7058101892471313, 0.0590500570833683, 0.5831258893013, -0.5124320983886719, -0.5341057777404785, -0.2714707553386688, -0.08776283264160156, -1.2707226276397705, 0.635055422782898, 0.1542218029499054, -0.36526554822921753, 0.5040729641914368, -0.5103580951690674, -0.6507740020751953, -0.5775943994522095, -0.7157089710235596, -0.1881977617740631, -0.547726035118103, -0.28511810302734375, -0.07842307537794113, 0.4090587794780731, -0.2764931917190552, -0.13432057201862335, 0.06702884286642075, 1.0726048946380615, -0.5866912007331848, -0.5450547933578491, -0.7043741345405579, 0.5661870837211609, -1.0256530046463013, -0.01827126182615757, -0.6918546557426453, 0.2645024061203003, -0.6892899870872498, -0.47514787316322327, -0.6514756679534912, 0.5790589451789856, -0.5948426723480225, -0.770702600479126, -0.11749435216188431, 0.2242559790611267, 0.315615177154541, 0.10222242772579193, -0.6655194163322449, -0.3416735529899597, -0.5223197937011719, 0.17796480655670166, 0.7084323763847351, -0.568026602268219, 0.1714029759168625, 0.3123304545879364, 0.44086188077926636, 0.24105989933013916, -0.27689892053604126, 0.5740817785263062, 0.20022514462471008, -0.4028310775756836, 0.5305945873260498, 0.1050516813993454, 0.9190117716789246, 0.4504556953907013, -0.20462043583393097, -0.3775046169757843, 0.663631021976471, -0.030627090483903885, 0.5327572226524353, 0.10837190598249435, -0.20803767442703247, 0.26986560225486755, 0.3879101574420929, -0.0019721752032637596, -0.16916754841804504, 0.32346704602241516, -0.39723289012908936, 0.4973340332508087, 0.029195686802268028, 0.047302909195423126, -0.004990923684090376, 0.5682646036148071, -0.16029313206672668, -0.20683741569519043, 0.016754964366555214, 0.10086328536272049, 0.04643820598721504, -0.1232556477189064, -0.7576276063919067, -0.16468000411987305, -0.36791107058525085, 0.27292710542678833, -0.12894295156002045, 0.27778926491737366, -0.13431856036186218, 0.17578892409801483, 1.1978492736816406, 0.40180525183677673, -0.7034528255462646, 0.4552003741264343, 0.08728592097759247, 0.6817889213562012, -0.2623574137687683, 0.9017136693000793, 0.5206370949745178, 0.5557749271392822, 0.432760626077652, -0.4630870819091797, 0.15096281468868256, 0.12317217886447906, -1.2763671875, -0.13790185749530792, -0.09195578098297119, -0.48741164803504944, 0.082821786403656, -0.6248976588249207, 0.49645549058914185, -0.31126195192337036, 0.413654088973999, 1.5128592252731323, -0.4909232258796692, -0.14118842780590057, 0.09741046279668808, 0.05853614956140518, 0.711846649646759, 0.2940259277820587, 0.018590202555060387, -0.05954334884881973, 1.1654845476150513, 0.9346503019332886, -0.3084200322628021, 0.5530588030815125, 0.019378716126084328, -0.19928357005119324, 0.13519400358200073, 0.26758071780204773, -0.7091801166534424, 0.8983310461044312, -0.6005197763442993, 0.10381864011287689, -0.06269465386867523, 0.20298102498054504, -0.38677650690078735, 0.13399767875671387, 1.0129166841506958, 0.47797736525535583, -0.40013301372528076, -0.23312366008758545, 0.7238516807556152, 0.5234577059745789, 0.1041714996099472, -0.36564332246780396, 0.26522231101989746, -0.05800918862223625, -0.1859678030014038, -0.3006944954395294, 0.5892926454544067, -0.3859139084815979, -0.16963455080986023, 0.1706566959619522, -0.5406387448310852, -0.3128972351551056, -1.3186335563659668, -0.6742200255393982, -0.24434532225131989, 0.5345810651779175, 0.6596419811248779, 0.6242709755897522, 0.9905267357826233, -0.44225186109542847, -0.22423726320266724, 0.5159086585044861, 0.6984736919403076, 0.2450214922428131, 0.3964122533798218, 0.22254794836044312, -0.019291948527097702, -0.3094448745250702, 0.8463372588157654, 0.8692266345024109, -0.09658684581518173, 1.5431461334228516, -0.4446900486946106, 0.23786573112010956, -0.0013970040017738938, -0.502975344657898, 0.22625961899757385, 0.600568950176239, 0.42001110315322876, -0.34827980399131775, -0.8458433151245117, -0.15078116953372955, -0.9585585594177246, -0.25094854831695557, -1.0547895431518555, 1.3501551151275635, 0.38539037108421326, -0.3271748721599579, 0.35016393661499023, 0.06676279008388519, 4.018250942230225, 0.6356198787689209, 0.8388773798942566, -0.036365918815135956, 0.6105968952178955, 0.6744332313537598, 0.0194522887468338, -0.8778310418128967, 0.521236002445221, -0.028628243133425713, -0.11468597501516342, -0.6131017208099365, 0.6706008315086365, 0.03796497359871864, 0.17809128761291504, 0.8240739703178406, 0.19634050130844116, 0.6739650964736938, 0.11632592231035233, -1.0307903289794922, -0.3667754828929901, 0.5384280681610107, 0.4229779839515686, -0.1193387359380722, 0.4535866379737854, 0.0017026019049808383, 0.8528608083724976, -0.8596490025520325, -0.5070978403091431, -0.5535427331924438, -0.7363983392715454, -0.8204963207244873, 0.42357760667800903, -0.42959365248680115, -0.6767994165420532, 0.4349285364151001, -0.36091089248657227, -0.13070158660411835, 0.4369266629219055, -0.11560343205928802, -0.13806383311748505, 0.05118080601096153, -0.18738962709903717, -0.2139018476009369, 0.009550797753036022, 1.281675100326538, -0.514487624168396, 0.6589663028717041, 0.6995245814323425, -1.0656667947769165, 0.3611680269241333, -0.12697941064834595, 0.5071547627449036, 0.5456358194351196, -1.2723509073257446, -0.17160379886627197, 0.16034629940986633, -0.48674777150154114, 0.01236129179596901, 0.185682475566864, 1.0531800985336304, 0.3695703446865082, 0.05084880068898201, 0.3191722333431244, -0.31660139560699463, 0.44987985491752625, 0.7418495416641235, -0.3021933436393738, -0.8625624775886536, 0.949857234954834, -0.6297686696052551, -0.37116479873657227, -0.7119832634925842, -0.5944089889526367, 0.12214543670415878, -0.4806389808654785, -0.09566784650087357, 0.48219841718673706, 0.45671382546424866, 0.21050246059894562, -0.3308405876159668, -0.33253684639930725, 0.07736945897340775, 0.13657186925411224, 0.18585047125816345, 0.9243505001068115, 0.20176781713962555, -0.14747793972492218, -0.3003546893596649, -0.0991111546754837, 0.46093520522117615, 0.9139629602432251, 0.21133829653263092, 0.11231499910354614, -0.3635658323764801 ]
Exact Results for a Three-Body Reaction-Diffusion System
A system of particles hopping on a line, singly or as merged pairs, and annihilating in groups of three on encounters, is solved exactly for certain symmetrical initial conditions. The functional form of the density is nearly identical to that found in two-body annihilation, and both systems show non-mean-field, ~1/t**(1/2) instead of ~1/t, decrease of particle density for large times.
Vladimir Privman
cond-mat hep-lat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207001
cond-mat/9207002
[ 0.08611045777797699, 0.0847310721874237, 0.532736599445343, 0.35186663269996643, 0.395801305770874, 0.01915818639099598, -0.3021255135536194, -0.48496776819229126, -0.6671489477157593, 1.437686562538147, 0.6623143553733826, -0.03639886528253555, 0.8214658498764038, -1.0313655138015747, -0.1925053596496582, 0.40149298310279846, -0.2479240894317627, -0.612483561038971, -1.2287291288375854, -0.30056142807006836, 0.17210222780704498, -0.2807537019252777, -1.0657696723937988, -0.7582557201385498, -0.0026747824158519506, 0.5710963010787964, -0.17391172051429749, 0.34409299492836, 1.3344268798828125, 0.9086587429046631, 0.2200431227684021, -0.9687839150428772, -0.030307000502943993, -0.5119712948799133, -1.0607010126113892, -0.23306462168693542, 0.5920830965042114, -0.1898825466632843, 0.4764660894870758, -0.18476852774620056, 1.3352313041687012, -0.23898853361606598, 0.7912641167640686, 0.23833318054676056, -0.16570061445236206, 0.2966267764568329, -0.06392452865839005, -0.5446306467056274, -0.2668097913265228, -0.9312942028045654, 0.5355826020240784, -0.08614033460617065, 0.4596860408782959, -0.8311858177185059, -0.43705105781555176, -0.42604368925094604, 0.13308973610401154, -0.011562669649720192, -0.17968635261058807, 0.2913862466812134, 0.5234025120735168, 0.418362021446228, 0.7794688940048218, -0.6731350421905518, 0.26719799637794495, 1.3111430406570435, -0.3189155161380768, 0.47796812653541565, 0.40547314286231995, -0.7414214611053467, -0.8089861869812012, -1.007305383682251, -0.1724507361650467, 0.41930297017097473, -0.6779422760009766, 0.42590630054473877, 0.1018952950835228, -0.49483734369277954, -1.060512900352478, -0.4281376302242279, 0.0884329229593277, -0.4674520492553711, -0.5539022088050842, 0.3549194037914276, -0.41389891505241394, -0.49276891350746155, 0.18014390766620636, 0.4497990310192108, -0.05925597622990608, 0.3123762607574463, 0.011475348845124245, 0.5964859127998352, 0.6598123908042908, -0.4268452227115631, 0.7838385701179504, 0.9592270255088806, 0.14317955076694489, 0.38815775513648987, 0.24088352918624878, 0.2690171003341675, -0.3058840334415436, 0.8559786677360535, -0.8569697141647339, 0.0592578649520874, -1.139159083366394, 0.4558931589126587, 0.5312239527702332, 0.2272970974445343, -0.4924651086330414, -0.2591557502746582, 0.057512253522872925, 0.10770522058010101, 0.17070651054382324, 0.7298567891120911, 0.5770564675331116, 0.9655253291130066, -0.09282238781452179, -0.2710413932800293, -0.9198116064071655, 0.027192285284399986, -0.04925414174795151, 0.22002851963043213, 0.29346948862075806, 0.3954964280128479, 0.471090704202652, -0.4294452369213104, 0.4639468193054199, 0.8301141858100891, 0.013583040796220303, -0.35733938217163086, -0.30343151092529297, -0.35603633522987366, -0.3385622799396515, 0.8478479385375977, 0.3524891436100006, 0.08980703353881836, -0.032008688896894455, 0.2839388847351074, 0.6198378801345825, -0.5665435791015625, 0.8451549410820007, -0.7613660097122192, 0.34534502029418945, 1.0071018934249878, 0.06447742879390717, 0.341796338558197, -0.3006639778614044, -0.7274471521377563, -0.06413735449314117, -0.08306747674942017, -1.0131562948226929, 0.14574024081230164, -0.09343313425779343, 0.3483223021030426, 0.1544029861688614, 0.36558735370635986, -0.880089282989502, 0.7734923958778381, -0.7809393405914307, -1.0861520767211914, 0.2277172952890396, -0.7553414106369019, -0.3285142183303833, 0.28278306126594543, -0.8891520500183105, 0.08831015229225159, -0.4144062399864197, -0.06383039057254791, -0.40266019105911255, -0.3956948220729828, -0.11993426084518433, 0.43103209137916565, -0.6713637709617615, 1.0465387105941772, 0.1788596659898758, 0.39945903420448303, 0.2951328456401825, -0.42719852924346924, 0.5257518291473389, 0.10654706507921219, -0.20850913226604462, -0.42084819078445435, -0.12598323822021484, 0.4318799674510956, 0.25259754061698914, 0.13875247538089752, -0.6461877822875977, -0.299033522605896, 0.3116185665130615, 0.10873012989759445, 0.21278980374336243, 0.5971402525901794, -0.8427943587303162, 0.4773614704608917, -0.16083218157291412, -0.31229478120803833, -0.585416316986084, 0.17648378014564514, -0.25553303956985474, -0.28463008999824524, -0.34377753734588623, -0.07681489735841751, -0.5019828081130981, 0.13172070682048798, -1.630370020866394, 0.596587598323822, 0.2982526123523712, 0.6086241602897644, -0.4735986292362213, -0.18610984086990356, 0.35410669445991516, 0.06439507007598877, 0.3809506297111511, 0.1582767367362976, 0.22824393212795258, -0.01985960640013218, -0.27563902735710144, 0.7019491195678711, 1.2152996063232422, -0.38513776659965515, 0.23364050686359406, -0.2271382063627243, -0.39560434222221375, 1.0134371519088745, -0.39715903997421265, -0.045755211263895035, 0.4619652032852173, 0.4598197638988495, 0.6922441720962524, -0.2665085196495056, -0.19465744495391846, 1.063111424446106, -0.7481415271759033, 0.4611269235610962, 0.8597679138183594, 0.5183411836624146, 0.4932617247104645, 0.9188302755355835, -0.1957405060529709, 0.6480934619903564, 0.06600241363048553, -0.0030880162958055735, 0.6286008358001709, 0.5633950233459473, 0.1808282434940338, 0.5687695741653442, -0.5651397109031677, 0.14555802941322327, -1.2268342971801758, 0.7212793231010437, -0.9077169299125671, 1.3919079303741455, 0.49568068981170654, -0.3438354432582855, -1.016868233680725, -0.2959207594394684, -0.057208169251680374, 0.3021887540817261, -0.6979390382766724, -0.5283823609352112, -0.19947530329227448, -0.09683879464864731, 0.15824486315250397, -0.27371475100517273, 0.11559028178453445, 0.6693712472915649, -0.19102825224399567, 0.8136990070343018, -0.5433339476585388, -0.11266779154539108, -1.3774548768997192, -0.2015591412782669, -0.76078861951828, -0.6553951501846313, -0.39070624113082886, -0.2677353620529175, 0.9822413325309753, -0.5039064288139343, 0.8260458707809448, 0.48707911372184753, -0.8599197268486023, 0.7102422714233398, -0.17734211683273315, 1.3306912183761597, 0.4725777804851532, -0.18918314576148987, -0.8307805061340332, -0.04608262702822685, -0.7779281139373779, 0.3686716854572296, 0.000879238243214786, 0.4442771375179291, 0.4147976338863373, -0.1479419320821762, 0.041897352784872055, -0.019127344712615013, -0.38779520988464355, -0.21347516775131226, 0.33568671345710754, -0.5595427751541138, -0.23112159967422485, 0.17895187437534332, -0.6258728504180908, -0.5604946613311768, -0.9221407175064087, 0.7996929287910461, 0.030999429523944855, -0.5496315956115723, 1.2301487922668457, 0.3956526219844818, -0.37511467933654785, 0.40175381302833557, -0.6787286400794983, 0.6021589040756226, 0.1264447569847107, 1.1528089046478271, 0.7350290417671204, 0.5025110244750977, -0.021463166922330856, -0.854358434677124, -0.4016791880130768, 0.15193568170070648, -0.3279252052307129, -0.6177307963371277, -0.2621012032032013, 0.9580722451210022, 0.40509554743766785, -0.6996158361434937, 0.29120442271232605, -1.0055091381072998, -0.7397347688674927, 0.49338391423225403, -0.42020469903945923, 0.6335218548774719, -0.06683427095413208, 0.04953443631529808, -0.8260457515716553, -0.10120563954114914, 0.30046117305755615, 0.4410623013973236, 0.55647873878479, -0.03987221419811249, 0.6802502274513245, 0.20790976285934448, 0.4215262830257416, 0.294686883687973, 0.8469541072845459, -0.2813173532485962, 0.5167239904403687, 0.41078731417655945, -0.5131000876426697, 0.21224582195281982, 0.5248872637748718, -0.22760330140590668, 0.22131742537021637, 0.1544768214225769, -0.8919625282287598, -0.37276601791381836, -0.9791682958602905, -0.5363999605178833, 0.27231118083000183, 0.23098881542682648, -0.7908780574798584, 0.12683799862861633, -0.5309980511665344, -0.180323988199234, 1.2548991441726685, -0.058326635509729385, 0.6949964165687561, -0.9241945147514343, 0.4799281060695648, -0.32179662585258484, -0.27569329738616943, 0.1834113746881485, -0.1667860597372055, -0.07628239691257477, 0.18772877752780914, -0.22710256278514862, 0.8454777002334595, -0.6424691081047058, -0.7216604948043823, -0.18635237216949463, 1.1319406032562256, 0.9051342010498047, 1.2335190773010254, 0.9900332093238831, -0.4155827760696411, 0.696254551410675, -0.609690248966217, -0.4083392024040222, -0.1413370966911316, -0.1217765137553215, -0.6266087293624878, -0.8699224591255188, -0.14531931281089783, -0.02019110508263111, 0.5893442630767822, 0.8714922666549683, 0.5165276527404785, -0.001697693602181971, -0.11725489050149918, 0.021509762853384018, 0.9048517346382141, 1.162998914718628, 0.5991575121879578, 0.48290392756462097, -1.0469294786453247, 0.49341443181037903, 0.3125218451023102, 0.005012038163840771, -0.16180038452148438, -0.09440865367650986, -0.39859890937805176, -0.7644963264465332, 0.9270476698875427, -0.20326051115989685, -0.7414472103118896, 0.38400763273239136, 0.015279130078852177, 0.4860667884349823, -0.1319393366575241, -0.1432913839817047, 0.2158212512731552, -0.10813295096158981, -0.6548654437065125, -0.6382179260253906, 0.0844990611076355, -0.053745679557323456, 1.0165390968322754, 0.460090696811676, -0.6312142610549927, -0.6913933753967285, -0.21902334690093994, 0.3813101649284363, -0.4192531704902649, 0.002297972096130252, 0.8875704407691956, -0.19111120700836182, 0.05654723569750786, -0.21816259622573853, -0.6384013891220093, -0.016212807968258858, -0.29351693391799927, -0.5120339393615723, -0.05661340430378914, 0.40610694885253906, -0.32737836241722107, 0.7359185218811035, -0.12714779376983643, -0.6398213505744934, -0.2027081400156021, 0.18339359760284424, -0.1884118914604187, -0.22869226336479187, -0.7998464107513428, -0.06079474836587906, -0.6700878739356995, -0.15106923878192902, 1.1949994564056396, 0.11150097846984863, 0.438999205827713, -0.1723441183567047, -0.24408292770385742, -0.20525367558002472, -0.6858744025230408, 0.24721714854240417, -0.021683255210518837, 0.259285569190979, 0.6178674101829529, 0.9656407237052917, -0.008638301864266396, -0.25489118695259094, 0.06472044438123703, -0.34827595949172974, 0.9642912149429321, 0.3112492561340332, 0.0842786356806755, 0.04560606926679611, -0.24523986876010895, -0.7833718061447144, -0.5088496804237366, 0.006238389760255814, -0.11509359627962112, 1.4043830633163452, 0.08288729190826416, -0.5335301160812378, 0.3637789487838745, -0.01970382034778595, -0.3856043815612793, 0.31444746255874634, -0.074526846408844, -0.26771649718284607, 0.02410052716732025, -0.10656698048114777, -0.07982849329710007, 0.01808556541800499, 0.3466978967189789, -0.38201820850372314, -0.22716179490089417, 0.3150591552257538, -0.5119776725769043, 0.6685592532157898, -1.2956632375717163, 0.08046311885118484, -0.36713290214538574, 0.5365169644355774, 0.049996666610240936, -0.865101158618927, -0.02585640363395214, -0.33456549048423767, -0.9805203676223755, -0.8102526664733887, -0.5189688205718994, -0.5454958081245422, 0.49935805797576904, -0.19151625037193298, -0.22811685502529144, 0.22288689017295837, -0.38190019130706787, 0.5872098207473755, -0.17860062420368195, -0.6410516500473022, 0.6380392909049988, 1.2631648778915405, 0.046760011464357376, -0.12212812900543213, 0.06818974763154984, -0.4590676426887512, -0.07459665834903717, -0.041470061987638474, -0.004852065816521645, -0.8936331868171692, -0.1511424034833908, -0.2693517506122589, -0.07376062124967575, 0.4103148877620697, 0.5231274962425232, 0.26234856247901917, 0.12506863474845886, 0.15357528626918793, -1.1107033491134644, -0.5560088753700256, -0.43030279874801636, -0.6829248070716858, -0.3657955825328827, 0.06794843077659607, -0.9622622728347778, 0.44179245829582214, 0.033485427498817444, 0.18878868222236633, 0.4787612557411194, 0.5513473153114319, 0.1310003399848938, 0.7614265084266663, -0.5413126945495605, 0.14949071407318115, 0.13858038187026978, 0.7759466171264648, -0.2754747271537781, -0.0805000513792038, -1.0669281482696533, 0.5751736164093018, -0.8557820320129395, 0.792982280254364, -0.33230096101760864, -0.13039687275886536, 0.3218725621700287, 0.24622388184070587, 0.590346097946167, -0.658443808555603, 0.11202096194028854, 0.5459288358688354, 0.07490953058004379, 0.47058090567588806, 0.4562046527862549, -0.7010425329208374, -0.3833230435848236, -0.7839710116386414, -1.5535320043563843, 0.551225483417511, -0.14245806634426117, -0.2128869891166687, -0.7159210443496704, -0.4288957715034485, -0.1762804538011551, -0.704420268535614, 0.6328222155570984, 0.43993502855300903, -0.5394141674041748, 0.27484816312789917, 0.3249194025993347, 0.34480375051498413, -0.5201207399368286, -0.1372743844985962, 0.696410059928894, -0.20352323353290558, -0.7459350228309631, -0.05634159967303276, -0.4178471863269806, -1.344789743423462, -0.2785341143608093, 0.5022121071815491, 0.15240922570228577, 0.07471789419651031, 0.8369508981704712, -0.5665022730827332, -0.34777387976646423, 0.010271032340824604, -0.06186491623520851, -0.4320047199726105, -0.12812918424606323, -0.01093550305813551, -0.5281310677528381, 0.07810144871473312, -0.33810192346572876, 0.3977680206298828, -0.6419084072113037, 0.1708805412054062, 0.5672271847724915, -0.01375518087297678, -0.40128859877586365, 0.4234939217567444, 0.0266201701015234, -0.6848233342170715, -0.24961617588996887, -0.17626352608203888, 0.1549951732158661, -0.0018072176026180387, -0.6649998426437378, 0.28717100620269775, -0.19639995694160461, -0.699255645275116, 0.4805794954299927, 0.3388950824737549, -0.6562669277191162, 0.06301240622997284, 0.08311957865953445, -0.43344059586524963, -0.7219645380973816, 0.2517172694206238, 1.4316233396530151, -0.40515628457069397, -0.48971256613731384, 0.007648766040802002, -0.21365095674991608, 0.23426532745361328, 0.505833625793457, 0.2543242275714874, -0.28577619791030884, 0.3696247637271881, 0.31513839960098267, 0.8557660579681396, -0.22464291751384735, 0.1522422432899475, 0.577255129814148, 0.16542544960975647, 0.32593128085136414, -1.0734350681304932, -0.36659160256385803, -0.3985113799571991, 0.3585847020149231, 1.0304406881332397, -0.39420318603515625, 0.3915162682533264, -0.5951209664344788, -0.9380576014518738, -0.4608609080314636, -0.8936880230903625, 0.5085468292236328, -1.2792952060699463, -0.4754956364631653, -1.3786280155181885, -0.544438898563385, 0.3584069013595581, 0.14731405675411224, 0.5055159330368042, -0.293759286403656, -1.0344672203063965, -0.033647503703832626, 0.9015677571296692, 0.5029147267341614, -0.06486418098211288, -0.9156452417373657, -1.0083599090576172, -0.6196720600128174, -0.16949571669101715, 0.23243644833564758, 0.10866396129131317, 0.3737294673919678, -0.5276385545730591, 0.5447807908058167, -0.442413866519928, 0.006151750683784485, -0.6398447155952454, -0.23651807010173798, 0.28039249777793884, -0.5580952167510986, -0.7771162390708923, 0.07949315756559372, -0.5341552495956421, 0.24306222796440125, 0.2773890793323517, -0.6270403265953064, -0.7708783149719238, 0.2532344162464142, -1.0890318155288696, -0.14226923882961273, -0.2564358115196228, 0.41932669281959534, -0.472056120634079, -0.796882688999176, 0.6252942085266113, 0.10581330955028534, -1.3349626064300537, 0.16587193310260773, -0.7144086956977844, -0.04917013272643089, -0.295175701379776, 0.05416170880198479, 0.5565230250358582, 0.6644939184188843, -0.2563377618789673, 0.9586920738220215, -0.06821641325950623, -0.16394951939582825, -0.41616111993789673, 0.672913670539856, -0.40948522090911865, 0.36501675844192505, -0.333929181098938, -0.3154852092266083, 0.10108327865600586, 0.17041465640068054, 0.17523372173309326, 0.6350762844085693, -0.7124916911125183, -0.6064368486404419, -0.5981854796409607, -0.024451131001114845, -0.8829757571220398, 0.5704346299171448, 0.07896400988101959, -0.35310956835746765, -0.2314976453781128, -0.8244945406913757, -0.5893031358718872, 0.4237886965274811, -0.4730788767337799, -0.24008101224899292, -0.4730266332626343, -0.5767358541488647, -0.3868759572505951, -0.5926077365875244, -0.14380893111228943, 0.4088346064090729, 0.2780229151248932, 0.1953381597995758, -0.48404818773269653, -0.2572789788246155, -0.07801021635532379, 0.27511993050575256, -0.999961256980896, 0.18512755632400513, -0.5777952671051025, 0.4505546987056732, -0.47370198369026184, -0.3239573836326599, -0.2444601058959961, 0.4341287910938263, -0.11972430348396301, -0.6101114749908447, -0.4068690836429596, 0.021524451673030853, 0.6375267505645752, 0.08633869886398315, -0.8275319933891296, 0.48778975009918213, -0.2871045172214508, 0.24862204492092133, 0.24197496473789215, -0.6468837857246399, -0.017373457551002502, 0.2878487706184387, 0.18044884502887726, -0.04978173226118088, -0.47449034452438354, 0.90119469165802, 0.18597982823848724, -0.27970796823501587, 1.3653249740600586, -0.5931175947189331, 0.688957691192627, 0.1867409348487854, 0.03905488923192024, -0.19942910969257355, 0.2423333078622818, 0.8144131302833557, 0.3773072063922882, 1.0599957704544067, 0.33061254024505615, 0.2675119638442993, -0.08530626446008682, 0.26770976185798645, 0.10809991508722305, 0.5551252365112305, -0.05958215147256851, 0.5142104625701904, -0.08575791865587234, 0.4455161392688751, -0.23539812862873077, 0.5193720459938049, -0.1359287053346634, 0.15723800659179688, -0.1243014857172966, 0.0005577238043770194, 0.24598069489002228, -0.16231855750083923, -0.5165364742279053, -0.10999589413404465, 0.0031003220938146114, 0.10339785367250443, -0.16221953928470612, 0.4295254647731781, -0.08391787111759186, 0.5031150579452515, 0.5295889377593994, 0.4503838121891022, -0.14701718091964722, 0.22756531834602356, 0.3175032436847687, 0.1847231686115265, 0.10669313371181488, 0.7461486458778381, 0.9510875344276428, 0.3534255921840668, 0.19997352361679077, -1.0782016515731812, 0.18852797150611877, 1.0177620649337769, -1.9042868614196777, 0.2669803500175476, 0.06557708233594894, -0.10022418200969696, -0.5144056677818298, -1.1197748184204102, 0.17646820843219757, -0.5405133366584778, 0.27999264001846313, 1.14795982837677, -0.16723299026489258, 0.33096426725387573, 0.814769983291626, -0.5509241819381714, 0.6429814100265503, 0.7731785774230957, -0.02263632044196129, -0.366127073764801, 0.890008270740509, 1.608363151550293, 0.19098760187625885, 0.24045820534229279, 0.036215681582689285, -0.4588842988014221, -0.020522212609648705, 0.2420703023672104, -0.6587679982185364, 1.153497338294983, -0.6440809369087219, -0.576239824295044, 0.14897388219833374, 0.8623476028442383, -0.1000063344836235, -0.16386517882347107, 0.2958754897117615, 0.48672881722450256, -0.5550709962844849, -0.2897443175315857, 0.8623846769332886, 0.6344700455665588, -0.19749166071414948, -0.06534000486135483, -0.12511128187179565, 0.1507682502269745, 0.28804558515548706, -0.05345914140343666, 0.09474325180053711, 0.2295922487974167, 0.4118569493293762, 0.06637316197156906, -0.48192957043647766, -0.37957730889320374, -1.0622466802597046, -0.15343554317951202, -0.7546128034591675, 0.6836984753608704, 0.23219871520996094, 0.6967931985855103, 0.19790197908878326, -1.193900465965271, 0.1222098246216774, 0.5589463114738464, 1.421157956123352, 0.25483691692352295, 0.13410429656505585, 0.8399288654327393, 0.43361541628837585, -0.6322083473205566, 1.300704002380371, 0.703088641166687, -0.44371098279953003, 0.28329381346702576, -0.6754235029220581, -0.0307816993445158, 0.2598264515399933, -0.48611170053482056, 0.9264909625053406, 0.2363065630197525, 0.6193495988845825, -0.35682350397109985, -0.09666695445775986, -0.1447761207818985, -1.2261346578598022, 0.027205239981412888, -0.9286320805549622, 0.6453796625137329, 0.20613741874694824, -0.24049219489097595, 0.8252664804458618, -0.12370210886001587, 3.828002452850342, 1.020432949066162, 0.9079601764678955, -0.11607933044433594, 0.826843798160553, 0.5096786618232727, 0.14994993805885315, -0.6734880208969116, 0.20936219394207, -0.42972084879875183, -0.09864655137062073, 0.2358480989933014, 0.5894865393638611, -0.23339901864528656, 0.11039065569639206, 0.6438406109809875, -0.4089762270450592, 0.5410787463188171, 0.30773288011550903, -1.2802814245224, -0.7197649478912354, 0.32306280732154846, 0.058012109249830246, -0.27927955985069275, 0.1822374165058136, -0.09612901508808136, 0.43729743361473083, -1.0727180242538452, -0.7403039932250977, 0.29711949825286865, -1.0477380752563477, -1.0925112962722778, 0.5016273856163025, -0.3254108726978302, -0.8220216631889343, 0.6235184669494629, 0.16590411961078644, -0.1521163284778595, 0.0693899393081665, 0.24174468219280243, -0.072417713701725, -0.17393004894256592, -0.5696811676025391, -0.2779659628868103, -0.5859936475753784, 0.889053225517273, 0.16870485246181488, 0.6524720788002014, 0.07882202416658401, -0.35268130898475647, 0.9098870158195496, -0.2932307720184326, 0.549286961555481, -0.0415957011282444, -1.7597066164016724, -0.26990413665771484, -0.17916586995124817, -0.49858933687210083, 0.29379037022590637, -0.06156428903341293, 1.3065533638000488, 0.1382172703742981, -0.554986298084259, 0.2777336835861206, -0.1059611588716507, 0.49902933835983276, 0.5484487414360046, 0.4823836386203766, -0.9092848300933838, 0.17916201055049896, -0.11408388614654541, -0.5321617126464844, -0.4438289403915405, 0.09074316173791885, 0.2676887512207031, -0.0709536001086235, -0.39659789204597473, 0.8401083946228027, 0.05524282529950142, 0.12744835019111633, -0.3193555772304535, -0.36807897686958313, -0.08738287538290024, 0.13569700717926025, 0.14089728891849518, 0.9569976329803467, -0.23394353687763214, -0.7843441367149353, -0.58640056848526, 0.0018829028122127056, 0.28302791714668274, 1.6466602087020874, -0.03232055902481079, -0.15824700891971588, -0.7398225665092468 ]
Model of Cluster Growth and Phase Separation: Exact Results in One Dimension
We present exact results for a lattice model of cluster growth in 1D. The growth mechanism involves interface hopping and pairwise annihilation supplemented by spontaneous creation of the stable-phase, +1, regions by overturning the unstable-phase, -1, spins with probability p. For cluster coarsening at phase coexistence, p=0, the conventional structure-factor scaling applies. In this limit our model falls in the class of diffusion-limited reactions A+A->inert. The +1 cluster size grows diffusively, ~t**(1/2), and the two-point correlation function obeys scaling. However, for p>0, i.e., for the dynamics of formation of stable phase from unstable phase, we find that structure-factor scaling breaks down; the length scale associated with the size of the growing +1 clusters reflects only the short-distance properties of the two-point correlations.
Vladimir Privman
cond-mat hep-lat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207002
cond-mat/9207003
[ -0.26254352927207947, 0.39705970883369446, 0.861961305141449, -0.10421431809663773, -0.29355910420417786, 0.544972836971283, -0.49369680881500244, -0.9133437275886536, -0.1074533686041832, 1.5606086254119873, 0.27816909551620483, -0.20368434488773346, -0.03187435120344162, -1.0826468467712402, 0.18385060131549835, 0.1165609359741211, 0.045407067984342575, -0.26946043968200684, -1.1536865234375, -0.3490597605705261, -0.48597267270088196, -0.1694106012582779, -0.8143068552017212, -1.3136186599731445, -0.6196965575218201, 0.9085403680801392, -0.2928667664527893, -0.09133969992399216, 1.0061393976211548, 1.035940170288086, -0.29920944571495056, 0.17202751338481903, 0.2462754100561142, -1.0391976833343506, 0.1142524778842926, 0.022189881652593613, 0.3231198191642761, 0.19546832144260406, -0.10545621067285538, -0.6752373576164246, 0.9744700789451599, -0.07720760256052017, 0.05514303594827652, -0.16409823298454285, 0.0987967848777771, 0.18183797597885132, -0.46658584475517273, 0.04936162754893303, -0.47666627168655396, -1.185598611831665, 0.23182661831378937, 0.4276886582374573, 0.5339816212654114, -0.42275553941726685, -0.49605461955070496, 0.6492098569869995, -0.6819054484367371, -0.3132556974887848, -0.06876136362552643, 0.10017015039920807, 0.48632436990737915, -0.03601354733109474, 0.5079625248908997, -0.39234498143196106, 0.8479483723640442, 1.2253820896148682, -0.42828643321990967, 0.30677562952041626, 0.12470383197069168, -0.23447668552398682, -1.0422110557556152, 0.16323713958263397, -0.016350792720913887, -0.6629469394683838, -0.5289689898490906, 0.4216405153274536, -0.07552855461835861, 0.14983990788459778, -0.3813510835170746, -0.12960641086101532, -0.11177492886781693, 0.35304561257362366, -0.7063910961151123, 0.3102681636810303, -0.49665603041648865, -0.14461322128772736, -0.38381391763687134, 0.6998263001441956, 0.4202635884284973, 0.059289731085300446, 0.23003216087818146, 1.0727096796035767, -0.5836531519889832, 0.04398787394165993, 0.17607702314853668, 0.24652549624443054, 0.2780056297779083, 0.7515033483505249, 0.08701004832983017, 0.6875109672546387, 0.561255693435669, 1.2074830532073975, -0.9066331386566162, 0.523402988910675, -0.10250920057296753, 1.1263433694839478, 0.49192482233047485, 0.44570738077163696, -0.16946901381015778, -0.3811261057853699, -0.6504712700843811, -0.027802936732769012, 0.6044554114341736, 0.6784659624099731, 0.07811492681503296, 0.5359032154083252, 0.6041589975357056, -0.16461816430091858, -0.3658536374568939, 0.008833559229969978, 0.1648522913455963, 0.32585522532463074, 0.6703749895095825, 0.08800587058067322, -0.6297852993011475, -0.4280158281326294, 0.1547478586435318, 0.7770927548408508, 0.40257999300956726, 0.09403304010629654, -0.22018055617809296, -0.4757530391216278, -0.29138436913490295, 0.9780852198600769, -0.40611883997917175, 0.44679296016693115, 0.4948144257068634, 0.6202101111412048, 0.5456727743148804, 0.17658425867557526, 0.08379794657230377, -0.5001627802848816, 0.40284937620162964, 0.9933346509933472, -0.07857519388198853, 0.5246435403823853, 0.44359663128852844, -0.4686400890350342, 0.20376774668693542, -0.3428170084953308, -0.8062009811401367, 0.7308908700942993, -0.1383320689201355, -0.17676691710948944, 0.30509254336357117, 0.23942014575004578, -0.7036153078079224, 0.8052269816398621, -0.5271568894386292, -0.6640371084213257, 0.12977933883666992, -0.6406204700469971, -0.5850345492362976, -0.4193843603134155, -0.6695384383201599, -0.4372076094150543, -0.05855521932244301, -0.5312932729721069, 0.07213757187128067, 0.14032652974128723, 0.7403305172920227, 0.06868276745080948, -0.038898635655641556, 0.17261822521686554, -0.010580429807305336, 0.19392293691635132, 0.4343770742416382, 0.5846028327941895, -0.030426057055592537, 0.019840870052576065, -0.09686963260173798, -0.6895861029624939, 0.02214946784079075, 0.47910767793655396, 0.3728426694869995, 0.06826125085353851, -0.8890697360038757, -0.15528161823749542, 0.3176427185535431, 0.5274255871772766, 0.08137261867523193, 0.36514151096343994, -0.29649174213409424, 0.14876866340637207, -0.9292359352111816, 0.01217572670429945, 0.06623658537864685, 0.970198929309845, -0.41758546233177185, -0.6363476514816284, -0.17821644246578217, 0.06877642124891281, -1.0045558214187622, 0.2538314759731293, -1.016005277633667, 0.10394345968961716, 0.8044377565383911, 0.09327398985624313, -0.8107332587242126, 0.09717021137475967, 0.3855348229408264, 0.26318538188934326, 0.20754458010196686, 0.19106529653072357, -0.06770592927932739, -0.16860175132751465, -0.4981430470943451, 0.23341861367225647, 0.23684296011924744, 0.21124602854251862, 0.4035991132259369, -0.1891130805015564, -0.21536071598529816, 0.7231151461601257, -0.3812747299671173, -0.016541212797164917, -0.357871413230896, 0.2537636160850525, 0.3108636438846588, -0.09661699086427689, 0.09679762274026871, 0.6954708099365234, -0.756519079208374, 0.5660711526870728, 1.5125401020050049, 0.9510470628738403, 0.4797179102897644, 0.619024932384491, 0.10318632423877716, -0.284158855676651, -0.04252177104353905, 0.31614813208580017, 0.3076620101928711, 1.206601619720459, -0.3278057873249054, -0.3411348760128021, -0.8253291249275208, -0.41461384296417236, -0.09568450599908829, 0.5140286684036255, -0.9703449606895447, 0.9118860960006714, 0.6953081488609314, 0.15495717525482178, -1.1417323350906372, -0.38314804434776306, 0.34631842374801636, 0.5727613568305969, -0.2061423361301422, -0.04076095670461655, -0.08946830779314041, 0.30029553174972534, -0.030567295849323273, 0.023359155282378197, 0.3104233741760254, 0.4050595462322235, -0.3413547873497009, 0.5608696341514587, -0.5185383558273315, -0.332149475812912, -1.5700716972351074, -0.5370674133300781, -0.9138913750648499, -0.26364603638648987, -0.6939999461174011, -0.06487740576267242, 0.7526021003723145, -0.722672700881958, 1.475026249885559, 0.4202365577220917, -0.3713316321372986, 0.14388135075569153, -0.7479252815246582, 0.5690065026283264, 0.6530022025108337, -0.3690035939216614, -0.6337711215019226, 0.21800169348716736, -0.194830060005188, 0.5117952823638916, -0.30650559067726135, 0.2692745327949524, -0.2218874990940094, -0.5922497510910034, -0.6185094714164734, -0.3295972943305969, -0.30220311880111694, -0.6076486706733704, -0.10646795481443405, -0.380574107170105, -0.5492897629737854, -0.45127472281455994, -0.6505599617958069, -0.5737758874893188, -0.7414550185203552, 1.3761825561523438, 0.23681727051734924, -0.16126489639282227, 0.7318044900894165, 0.06974038481712341, -0.41613829135894775, 0.6019203662872314, -0.06680838018655777, 0.5979863405227661, -0.19382785260677338, 0.8652952909469604, 1.0444813966751099, -0.3375259041786194, 0.4120788872241974, -0.8147752285003662, -0.427738219499588, 0.21002231538295746, 0.41550034284591675, -1.1079211235046387, -0.45749562978744507, 0.9762598276138306, 0.5850092172622681, -0.4927516281604767, 0.1583142727613449, -0.7574063539505005, -0.7538151144981384, -0.13210849463939667, -0.4415021538734436, 0.4224667251110077, 0.21594519913196564, -0.1775408685207367, -0.3518756031990051, -0.1515778750181198, 0.4019053876399994, 0.13691648840904236, -0.11043549329042435, -0.36952537298202515, 0.2556860148906708, 0.37673264741897583, 0.2513374984264374, -0.04760727286338806, 0.8450813293457031, -0.7751972079277039, 0.09152048826217651, 0.013744551688432693, -0.769993782043457, -0.2507339119911194, -0.03103805147111416, 0.6652030944824219, -0.11276119947433472, 0.7918043732643127, -0.7482534050941467, -0.06066310405731201, -0.4375624656677246, -0.28256306052207947, 0.2802535891532898, 0.5385889410972595, -0.2937881648540497, 0.16537734866142273, -1.0717709064483643, -0.4862835705280304, 0.0006421743892133236, -0.07926017045974731, 1.1088855266571045, -1.06001615524292, 0.4867425560951233, -0.050329774618148804, -0.6356756091117859, 0.2367764413356781, 0.15775644779205322, 0.45547792315483093, 0.7380437254905701, 0.6775190830230713, 0.9209610223770142, -1.1469652652740479, -0.8254294991493225, 0.19533969461917877, 0.759662389755249, 1.0113775730133057, 0.37398165464401245, 0.3247147798538208, -0.8264713883399963, 0.055021874606609344, -0.49674373865127563, -0.4817410707473755, 0.05618124082684517, 0.0729384794831276, -1.1337248086929321, -0.16235610842704773, 0.12975186109542847, -0.08085952699184418, 0.774305522441864, 0.4938235878944397, 0.37610533833503723, 0.849981427192688, 0.1840638667345047, 0.2997284233570099, 0.8177074193954468, 0.4110974669456482, -0.30825814604759216, -0.8694664239883423, -0.4280276894569397, 0.5897924900054932, -0.634873628616333, -0.24165774881839752, -0.26825782656669617, -0.2704663872718811, -0.5258222818374634, -0.3477556109428406, 0.10046616196632385, 0.5433475971221924, -0.49136361479759216, 0.420683890581131, 0.23891469836235046, 0.27855184674263, 0.05675597861409187, -0.43007439374923706, -0.12095747888088226, 0.6414391994476318, 0.30883651971817017, -0.35658636689186096, 0.2780061364173889, -0.3987739086151123, 0.5248165726661682, 0.33024948835372925, -1.2887169122695923, -0.6639164686203003, 0.03611624985933304, 0.6400057673454285, -1.276894450187683, 0.18953628838062286, 0.807860791683197, -0.4755924344062805, -0.02697022631764412, -0.2339196354150772, -0.309386283159256, -0.06769667565822601, -1.0691980123519897, 0.20935222506523132, -0.1857721358537674, 0.2604478895664215, -0.344850093126297, 0.47216108441352844, 0.29271653294563293, -0.19519676268100739, -0.2516840100288391, -0.3594973385334015, 0.09392154961824417, -0.07756616175174713, -0.5008521676063538, 0.18289580941200256, -0.29721951484680176, -0.32298871874809265, 0.9007027745246887, 0.3523434102535248, -0.07129039615392685, 0.36545035243034363, -0.044454872608184814, -0.40507403016090393, -0.8522006869316101, 0.012948282063007355, 0.3002415597438812, 0.38350188732147217, 0.748589813709259, 0.3148980140686035, 0.3968135714530945, -0.11454842239618301, 0.54471755027771, -0.06036088615655899, -0.05430701747536659, -0.163559690117836, 0.23969821631908417, -0.30774176120758057, -0.15258930623531342, -0.3826933205127716, -0.6983397603034973, 0.8704070448875427, -0.24680989980697632, 0.3778732419013977, -0.0982125774025917, -0.15711010992527008, -0.05182988569140434, 0.016030674800276756, -0.862779438495636, 0.723824679851532, -0.0200892835855484, -1.0265777111053467, 0.4570355713367462, -1.085395336151123, 0.14956149458885193, -0.12802362442016602, 0.3112284243106842, -0.32650741934776306, -0.0450766459107399, -0.1804347038269043, -0.769478976726532, 0.3651389479637146, -0.44543948769569397, 0.5400432348251343, -0.28273817896842957, 0.03770388290286064, -0.629641056060791, 0.4306778907775879, 0.10852368921041489, -0.6413890719413757, 0.09734585136175156, -0.3373924493789673, -0.310255765914917, -0.062007129192352295, 0.5069339871406555, 0.05251535773277283, -0.017119567841291428, 0.571782112121582, -0.27145588397979736, 0.3201713263988495, -0.14405393600463867, -0.3832806348800659, -0.3030032515525818, 1.3909193277359009, 0.3240455687046051, 0.27897486090660095, 0.13657663762569427, -0.6721643805503845, -0.13179630041122437, 0.22104617953300476, 0.709602415561676, -0.45816126465797424, -0.628488302230835, -0.8560727834701538, 0.45429569482803345, 0.12357159703969955, 0.6974675059318542, -0.16705602407455444, -0.32787591218948364, 0.21983453631401062, -0.8410413861274719, 0.5784046053886414, -0.39887696504592896, -0.4634849429130554, -0.3487783670425415, 0.2806178629398346, -1.046865463256836, 0.6633445024490356, -0.5426151156425476, -0.29801031947135925, 0.53873610496521, 0.10147494077682495, 0.3538612425327301, 0.6998112797737122, 0.4099494218826294, -0.7416888475418091, -0.04507435858249664, 0.5276322364807129, -0.122842937707901, 0.30615299940109253, -1.1484214067459106, 0.5393711924552917, -1.0656052827835083, 0.3497253358364105, -0.29336488246917725, 0.10281159728765488, 0.6695026159286499, -0.7730366587638855, 1.0164000988006592, -0.7671425938606262, 0.3007071912288666, 0.20156225562095642, 0.33735036849975586, 0.29407089948654175, 0.23211683332920074, -0.6368392109870911, -0.5637673735618591, -1.228006362915039, -0.6672868132591248, 0.3109700679779053, -0.1417175978422165, -0.9234768748283386, -0.5778640508651733, -0.24215418100357056, -0.3873584568500519, -0.19176535308361053, 1.1345996856689453, 0.5717368721961975, -0.5144293308258057, 0.6555906534194946, -0.2607960104942322, -0.01184861920773983, 0.643311083316803, -0.2876279354095459, 0.6232100129127502, 0.1502121239900589, -0.34681016206741333, 0.41269800066947937, -0.8279781937599182, -1.2546460628509521, -0.7586331367492676, 0.40293142199516296, 0.27666398882865906, -0.46009334921836853, 0.2622939944267273, -0.16275057196617126, -0.5631943941116333, -0.18979184329509735, 0.6814188361167908, -0.27941378951072693, -0.08910887688398361, 0.27881482243537903, -0.3789497911930084, 0.15858083963394165, 0.044959235936403275, 0.0595894418656826, -0.4829324185848236, -0.3419504463672638, 1.0026527643203735, 0.09048057347536087, -0.8673005700111389, -0.5122665762901306, -0.008771874941885471, -0.4505234360694885, -0.7701996564865112, -0.804411768913269, 0.2667573392391205, -0.010915997438132763, -0.8968689441680908, -0.09724688529968262, -0.6559286713600159, -0.6803236603736877, 0.4458265006542206, 0.54722660779953, 0.0454278439283371, -0.4953274726867676, 0.1614210158586502, -1.1550143957138062, -0.9639343619346619, 0.2812466025352478, 1.492211937904358, 0.06588713079690933, -0.08477797359228134, -0.07720287144184113, -0.6988555192947388, -0.43309882283210754, 0.8888391852378845, 0.44001829624176025, -0.167091965675354, -0.0021481383591890335, 0.4443628489971161, -0.2881369888782501, 0.43356528878211975, 1.1048171520233154, 0.5537284016609192, -0.04441779479384422, 0.44208580255508423, -0.8961195945739746, -0.4204988479614258, 0.3752842843532562, 0.8566970229148865, 0.27957355976104736, -0.8922831416130066, 0.6018178462982178, -0.3961371183395386, 0.2548059821128845, -0.0486801378428936, -0.658152163028717, -0.296859472990036, -1.1663553714752197, -0.673492431640625, -1.434259057044983, -0.4084985554218292, -0.2072855830192566, 0.18139487504959106, 0.03561347723007202, 0.2112453579902649, -0.44570109248161316, 0.27108490467071533, 0.7210809588432312, 0.8232061862945557, -0.0018842320423573256, 0.18093463778495789, -0.7220646142959595, -0.7535613775253296, -0.5194645524024963, 0.3226543366909027, -0.29064008593559265, -0.0588463731110096, 0.0499061644077301, -0.21726427972316742, -0.16732832789421082, 0.6403022408485413, -0.546927273273468, 0.05582303926348686, 0.4475400745868683, -0.06227719038724899, -0.6289867758750916, 0.07982886582612991, -0.6410544514656067, 0.4537559747695923, -0.22753547132015228, -0.41971418261528015, -0.10129501670598984, 0.896984338760376, -0.5862026810646057, -0.0967068299651146, 0.09469636529684067, 0.869874894618988, 0.0820934921503067, -0.2983397841453552, 0.23398227989673615, 0.13540810346603394, -0.39753982424736023, 0.27086153626441956, 0.15794016420841217, -0.26214441657066345, -0.18017971515655518, 0.14028051495552063, 0.12592580914497375, 0.5475946664810181, -0.2177792489528656, 0.7847278118133545, -0.23296833038330078, -0.3670485019683838, 0.643351137638092, -0.27345845103263855, -0.15926918387413025, -0.6382278800010681, 1.2267206907272339, -1.6678658723831177, 0.5161924958229065, 0.7025834321975708, -0.7864193916320801, 0.5561850666999817, -0.691685140132904, -0.28960394859313965, -0.43534743785858154, -0.6914905309677124, -0.4402746856212616, 0.855876088142395, -0.7431803941726685, -0.19303585588932037, -0.005989221855998039, -0.24850700795650482, 0.19678854942321777, 0.8275356292724609, -0.8128789067268372, -0.40328842401504517, 0.10575694590806961, -0.25971752405166626, -0.9111849069595337, -0.6521357297897339, -0.2374953031539917, 0.2130431830883026, -0.5266221165657043, 0.14387905597686768, -0.1506863385438919, -0.022893404588103294, 0.5201928019523621, 0.5348307490348816, -0.1538463830947876, 0.09320388734340668, -0.058911703526973724, 0.5999260544776917, -0.37193989753723145, -0.6580671072006226, 0.24106933176517487, 0.34949228167533875, -0.5980329513549805, -0.13165616989135742, -0.3010241389274597, 0.5556257963180542, 0.5241765975952148, 0.15124039351940155, 0.16838623583316803, -0.17658083140850067, -0.5166396498680115, 0.9397496581077576, 0.14086157083511353, -0.7968387007713318, 0.455098032951355, 0.19233867526054382, 0.33162954449653625, -0.07187755405902863, -0.6878180503845215, 0.6208018064498901, 0.5176177620887756, -0.2566930949687958, 0.7463214993476868, -0.24705448746681213, 0.9795046448707581, -0.1552799642086029, -0.3608194887638092, -0.4848962426185608, -0.06613825261592865, 0.7686560750007629, 0.49814027547836304, 0.49991628527641296, 0.17966173589229584, 1.1095157861709595, 0.44705623388290405, 0.08060181885957718, 0.3053000867366791, 0.3445742428302765, -0.5782656073570251, 0.8590841889381409, -0.6851829290390015, 0.6091066002845764, -0.15824230015277863, 0.271655797958374, -0.6223899722099304, -0.1860373169183731, -0.5994715094566345, 0.42311975359916687, -0.04709387198090553, 0.2680509686470032, -0.2637847661972046, 0.09766329079866409, -0.13687428832054138, 0.017574643716216087, -0.011061940342187881, -0.1868996024131775, 0.08737502992153168, 0.8452526926994324, 0.0034631332382559776, 0.6760735511779785, 0.10400612652301788, 0.12117024511098862, 0.22901740670204163, -0.06941958516836166, -0.24792250990867615, 1.330711007118225, 1.0726479291915894, 0.15999780595302582, 0.31377142667770386, -0.32047683000564575, -0.6630761027336121, 0.8648686408996582, -1.6927454471588135, -0.3025211989879608, -0.1194087341427803, -0.27358829975128174, -0.22517310082912445, -0.6186462044715881, 0.304281622171402, -0.6767784953117371, -0.594176173210144, 0.37120622396469116, -0.35080114006996155, -0.253427118062973, 0.641836404800415, -0.42140746116638184, 0.3738953769207001, 0.7978507876396179, 0.2912387251853943, -0.6449983716011047, 0.988760769367218, 0.6821167469024658, 0.29138991236686707, -0.36905598640441895, 0.3541625440120697, -0.10229100286960602, -0.49419358372688293, -0.11255515366792679, -0.0021423213183879852, 1.0421905517578125, -0.21404004096984863, -0.4931521415710449, 0.4296191334724426, 0.38561713695526123, -0.24958130717277527, -0.7629870772361755, -0.07360541820526123, 0.32800742983818054, -0.507173478603363, -0.03953663259744644, 0.7860336303710938, 0.47246089577674866, 0.14121854305267334, -0.07770848274230957, -0.5115585327148438, -0.2649790644645691, -0.28122425079345703, -0.2492256462574005, 0.14949911832809448, 0.5437459945678711, -0.1797032505273819, -0.5433776378631592, -0.43862825632095337, -0.2857326567173004, -0.1160600334405899, 0.09111982583999634, -1.0196655988693237, 0.5994046330451965, -0.07657960802316666, 1.1891765594482422, -0.47473734617233276, -0.8132467865943909, -0.5693215131759644, 0.29392701387405396, 1.4566272497177124, 0.9199901223182678, 1.150828242301941, -0.01337276492267847, -0.06610489636659622, -0.46288949251174927, 0.22105346620082855, 0.48860985040664673, -0.48985594511032104, 0.49900200963020325, -0.6136291027069092, -0.0037027946673333645, -0.35989972949028015, -0.2944832444190979, 0.5948532819747925, 0.8412505388259888, -0.10483157634735107, -0.35696011781692505, -0.21721722185611725, 0.3061622083187103, -1.3459478616714478, 0.7641619443893433, -0.6320254802703857, 0.21359528601169586, 1.1693435907363892, 0.23382042348384857, 0.3534911572933197, -0.281953901052475, 3.935119390487671, 0.7468261122703552, 0.7286247611045837, -0.5907068252563477, 0.4978848695755005, 0.640164315700531, -0.014112202450633049, -0.39588648080825806, 0.41855934262275696, -0.786247730255127, 0.24068249762058258, -0.1191130205988884, 0.21753311157226562, 0.10058849304914474, 0.4187736213207245, 0.20379431545734406, -0.20024451613426208, -0.09881448745727539, -0.35303086042404175, -1.0621933937072754, -0.6877902150154114, 0.5462648868560791, 0.32839226722717285, -0.5440874695777893, 0.216562882065773, 0.05312056466937065, 0.26899436116218567, -0.217202290892601, -0.4015497863292694, -0.14585720002651215, -0.6571885943412781, -0.8792417049407959, -0.06061601638793945, -0.7643243670463562, -0.700175940990448, 0.3615124225616455, 0.46716970205307007, -0.028405001387000084, -0.23652434349060059, 0.9867185950279236, -0.22389556467533112, -0.29024559259414673, -0.26002657413482666, 0.35676640272140503, -0.48622098565101624, 0.8881468176841736, -0.17498086392879486, 0.7625780701637268, 0.398898720741272, -0.9511185884475708, 0.4981210231781006, -0.7220820784568787, 0.622147262096405, -0.6245242953300476, -1.4996976852416992, 0.3235972225666046, -0.9710394144058228, -0.2879539132118225, 0.13882705569267273, 0.1510688066482544, 1.0153487920761108, 0.5781847238540649, -0.6815359592437744, 0.1775399148464203, 0.0931825265288353, 0.5731578469276428, 0.1705240160226822, 0.06766816973686218, 0.3597790598869324, -0.33319059014320374, -0.5232499837875366, -0.4306553900241852, -0.28528597950935364, -0.07806334644556046, 0.5430437922477722, 0.41753801703453064, 0.4161604344844818, 0.7727277874946594, 0.2109106183052063, 0.007177106104791164, -0.3049516975879669, -0.04791777953505516, -0.29125383496284485, -0.1570170521736145, 0.18378566205501556, 0.7085097432136536, -0.7827044725418091, -0.5235298275947571, -0.08202960342168808, 0.6753681898117065, -0.04160115122795105, 1.861405849456787, 0.03169368952512741, -0.4798840582370758, -0.4034275412559509 ]
Fluctuating Interfaces, Surface Tension, and Capillary Waves: An Introduction
We present an introduction to modern theories of interfacial fluctuations and the associated interfacial parameters: surface tension and surface stiffness, as well as their interpretation within the capillary wave model. Transfer matrix spectrum properties due to fluctuation of an interface in a long-cylinder geometry are reviewed. The roughening transition and properties of rigid interfaces below the roughening temperature in 3d lattice models are surveyed with emphasis on differences in fluctuations and transfer matrix spectral properties of rigid vs. rough interfaces.
Vladimir Privman
cond-mat astro-ph hep-lat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207003
cond-mat/9207004
[ -0.5051391124725342, -0.1948496401309967, 0.3268512785434723, 0.693644642829895, 0.23961441218852997, -0.1225367933511734, -0.36406490206718445, -1.1929829120635986, -0.3071761727333069, 0.9883800745010376, 0.4625036418437958, -0.3538176715373993, 0.4260466694831848, -0.5629578232765198, -0.49105218052864075, 0.6567114591598511, -0.3947467505931854, -0.45511049032211304, -1.0384016036987305, -0.4266452193260193, 0.1735028773546219, -0.36115625500679016, -0.8211564421653748, -0.2384261190891266, -0.6540561318397522, 0.6921983361244202, 0.059209294617176056, 0.24530674517154694, 1.4604169130325317, 1.1916755437850952, -0.13846679031848907, -0.2900829613208771, -0.12486156821250916, -1.2013046741485596, -0.26058894395828247, -0.37427207827568054, 0.1708196997642517, -0.4939132630825043, 0.47257065773010254, -0.03872542083263397, 1.7546411752700806, -0.47641316056251526, 0.45197629928588867, 0.029075752943754196, -0.1954742670059204, 0.3756285309791565, -0.09588406980037689, -0.4626363217830658, -0.6397538781166077, -0.6875203847885132, -0.0938190147280693, 0.21992456912994385, -0.5044726133346558, -0.24384526908397675, -0.2421666979789734, 0.22450590133666992, -0.34878379106521606, 0.22230564057826996, 0.17519806325435638, 0.2595529854297638, 0.6897499561309814, 0.11526630818843842, 0.3041533827781677, -0.9594071507453918, 0.6716722846031189, 1.7848941087722778, -0.21560758352279663, 0.6812660694122314, 0.2790290415287018, 0.016279418021440506, -0.2638612389564514, -0.43728747963905334, 0.1477520614862442, 0.08020748943090439, -0.32877352833747864, 0.38764986395835876, -0.4583069682121277, -0.3398100435733795, -0.5637606978416443, -0.46788766980171204, -0.04324563965201378, 0.016508132219314575, -0.6379978656768799, 0.7789798974990845, -0.051975954324007034, -0.4277620315551758, -0.46643590927124023, 0.3118344843387604, 0.3641631305217743, 0.2150547355413437, 0.3582678735256195, 1.6190476417541504, 0.6767809987068176, -0.6297791600227356, -0.35333171486854553, 0.9278850555419922, 0.19497071206569672, 0.42195001244544983, 0.2144223004579544, 0.6866675615310669, 0.11947610229253769, 1.3949075937271118, -0.9376078248023987, 0.530442476272583, -0.8219748139381409, 0.36627379059791565, 0.20421960949897766, 0.11196842789649963, -0.22831395268440247, -0.826671302318573, 0.32898131012916565, -0.12234529107809067, -0.15109753608703613, 0.5211846828460693, 0.5800893306732178, 0.42061224579811096, 0.6038711071014404, 0.5099706649780273, -0.11256590485572815, 0.02292185090482235, 0.3383199870586395, 0.34507015347480774, 0.8087342381477356, 0.3349047601222992, -0.19802865386009216, -0.8234336972236633, 0.13682866096496582, 0.6641656756401062, 0.11433383822441101, -0.46526965498924255, -0.1525656282901764, -0.37416762113571167, -0.030682368203997612, 0.7828310132026672, -0.4351046085357666, 0.5861254334449768, -0.06402851641178131, 0.24745433032512665, 0.5899169445037842, -0.3284860849380493, 0.7091485261917114, -0.5120989680290222, -0.11660423129796982, 1.0872910022735596, -0.4768611192703247, 0.4989146888256073, -0.06364116072654724, -0.4913926422595978, -0.3344888389110565, -0.05078335478901863, -1.3667175769805908, -0.08712654560804367, 0.018380217254161835, 0.3293377161026001, -0.5619819760322571, 0.39811792969703674, -0.4243473410606384, 0.28816866874694824, -0.894217312335968, -0.5037153959274292, 0.21122588217258453, -0.6778696179389954, 0.2243628352880478, 0.39099496603012085, -0.6450750827789307, -0.10463104397058487, -0.8619173765182495, -0.05822290480136871, -0.19570599496364594, -0.44248872995376587, 0.17087318003177643, -0.34367069602012634, -0.38855865597724915, 0.2476729154586792, 0.3554786443710327, 0.7681803107261658, 0.92525714635849, -0.1383751630783081, 0.8924679756164551, 0.012407748028635979, 0.01719753071665764, -0.1223469153046608, -0.043996017426252365, 0.679328441619873, 0.513443112373352, 0.3931807577610016, -1.668028712272644, 0.9886175394058228, 0.2571491599082947, 0.5854719877243042, 0.3111042082309723, 0.6573426127433777, -0.4707222580909729, 0.1953214406967163, -0.593923807144165, 0.28343966603279114, -0.09530089795589447, 0.6729615330696106, -0.25103697180747986, -1.1681268215179443, -0.08237670361995697, -0.26719585061073303, -1.0031406879425049, 0.32533928751945496, -0.993366539478302, 1.463884949684143, 0.6661835312843323, 0.4078218638896942, -0.8525018692016602, -0.08281083405017853, 0.34514665603637695, -0.24679139256477356, 0.05470765754580498, 0.24541062116622925, 0.003804601728916168, -0.3198290467262268, 0.12157460302114487, 0.3589179813861847, 0.34227225184440613, 0.03570361062884331, 0.6989535093307495, 0.028301334008574486, -0.41472071409225464, 0.37111812829971313, 0.07779373228549957, 0.34596115350723267, 0.05178588628768921, 0.7448158264160156, 0.5253147482872009, -0.3428320586681366, -0.2708373963832855, 0.16732166707515717, -0.5409682989120483, 0.5707270503044128, 0.7971230745315552, 0.618293821811676, 0.8514071702957153, 0.7375385761260986, -0.27999287843704224, 0.36400264501571655, 0.2611957788467407, 0.4029383063316345, 0.9877997636795044, 0.21474064886569977, 0.05765199288725853, 0.3886721134185791, -0.5555078983306885, -0.12120065838098526, -1.0362036228179932, 0.2714839577674866, -0.15272197127342224, 1.19077730178833, 0.4977830648422241, 0.34545931220054626, -0.5661717653274536, -0.43127700686454773, 0.31234583258628845, 0.5079808235168457, -0.8539838194847107, -0.25063377618789673, 0.23333215713500977, 0.553745687007904, -0.15381155908107758, 0.2655709981918335, 0.6254161596298218, 1.2340822219848633, -0.6324621438980103, 0.3051633834838867, -0.39962005615234375, -0.10473867505788803, -1.6337319612503052, -1.0800596475601196, -0.710052490234375, -0.04791190102696419, -0.4255127012729645, -0.5307999849319458, 1.1330655813217163, 0.21884837746620178, 0.6942892074584961, 0.30378788709640503, -0.09022606909275055, 0.18622799217700958, -0.4082183241844177, 0.8091095089912415, 0.6691780686378479, 0.040161821991205215, -0.4320547580718994, 0.9270297288894653, -0.30579590797424316, 0.4743496775627136, 0.09957633167505264, -0.3973601758480072, -0.3421339690685272, -0.6124647259712219, -0.5249141454696655, 0.01616314798593521, -0.19778390228748322, -0.181338831782341, 0.0024183832574635744, 0.14872081577777863, 0.015607279725372791, -0.23542743921279907, -0.5957475304603577, -0.7089537978172302, -0.43479475378990173, 0.6311762928962708, -0.24590174853801727, -0.5673612356185913, 0.9304038286209106, 0.246616393327713, -0.9006885290145874, 0.7286496758460999, -0.3944767117500305, 0.97638338804245, -0.15047137439250946, 1.1208463907241821, 1.1926857233047485, 0.10518209636211395, 0.42300117015838623, -0.6764279007911682, -0.8849261403083801, 0.06778740137815475, 0.06797169893980026, -1.2507480382919312, -0.39361435174942017, 0.7262087464332581, 0.19073255360126495, -0.4464285671710968, 0.1930575668811798, -0.7857663035392761, -0.3710283041000366, 0.03589673712849617, -0.10633891820907593, 0.12751995027065277, -0.3068992793560028, 0.09153030067682266, -0.6671686768531799, 0.3182700574398041, -0.14801710844039917, 0.1082516610622406, 0.6366823315620422, -0.3995736241340637, 0.3096625804901123, -0.02719443291425705, 0.5303447842597961, 0.577947199344635, 0.9022982120513916, -0.758773922920227, -0.025273490697145462, 0.7458130717277527, -0.3822583258152008, 0.12635000050067902, 0.3082345426082611, 0.3937210738658905, 0.24060852825641632, 0.38858211040496826, -0.6836767792701721, -0.6291483640670776, -0.3500165343284607, 0.3430856466293335, 0.37924644351005554, 0.36273613572120667, -0.14258210361003876, -0.14471536874771118, -0.27574723958969116, -0.7253779172897339, 0.9790576696395874, -0.431520938873291, 1.163265347480774, -1.5860388278961182, 0.2078741490840912, -0.5090029239654541, 0.03355656936764717, -0.27721554040908813, -0.24363641440868378, -0.3456410765647888, -0.13670872151851654, 0.38944515585899353, 1.4895563125610352, -0.7818071842193604, -0.6104888916015625, -0.4691096842288971, 0.7906063199043274, 0.8772122859954834, 0.5228757858276367, 0.20768789947032928, -0.23905733227729797, 0.6201991438865662, -0.17118355631828308, -0.5713614821434021, 0.44458267092704773, -0.3687021732330322, -0.6674723625183105, -0.7739070653915405, -0.6668956875801086, -0.29246222972869873, 0.8158730864524841, 0.38817447423934937, -0.32174021005630493, 0.08167901635169983, -0.06991267204284668, 0.4388941526412964, 0.9905866980552673, 0.7627599239349365, 0.2433094084262848, 0.03397629037499428, -1.1336853504180908, 0.37625810503959656, 0.04207997769117355, 0.10168681293725967, -0.3959541618824005, -0.17189249396324158, -0.8287749290466309, 0.3448748290538788, 0.5144984126091003, 0.42173323035240173, -0.5663080811500549, 0.38554051518440247, 0.0837339237332344, 0.524824857711792, 0.13121061027050018, -0.37813931703567505, -0.19940491020679474, 0.15961682796478271, 0.11714240163564682, -0.7752489447593689, -0.0483541265130043, 0.06619441509246826, 0.6254607439041138, 0.30757611989974976, 0.27278900146484375, -0.751007616519928, -0.38711684942245483, 0.8716899752616882, -0.665404200553894, 0.9859896898269653, 0.6170817613601685, -0.2696872353553772, 0.13195259869098663, 0.07606904208660126, 0.01888028159737587, -0.2504864037036896, -0.32247400283813477, -0.3457569181919098, -0.257317453622818, 0.6287603378295898, 0.005768768023699522, 0.7002197504043579, -0.21219293773174286, -0.22663511335849762, -0.08662384003400803, -0.04447013512253761, 1.0963269472122192, -0.1757221668958664, -0.73305344581604, 0.49060750007629395, -0.4857335388660431, 0.0675303265452385, 0.7454605102539062, 0.19655628502368927, -0.25877147912979126, 0.2984263002872467, 0.44050660729408264, -0.6486839652061462, -0.586493194103241, 0.3424920439720154, -0.6415347456932068, -0.040500957518815994, 0.1162700355052948, 0.5453271865844727, 0.06679747998714447, -0.08307578414678574, 0.6113846302032471, -0.8409178256988525, 0.8225529193878174, 0.044531092047691345, -0.11270323395729065, -0.627264142036438, -0.36397629976272583, -0.37337005138397217, -0.5264222621917725, 0.5583951473236084, -0.22146537899971008, 0.8341296911239624, 0.02149791829288006, -0.0044530238956213, -0.3533957004547119, -0.2641269266605377, -0.774192750453949, 0.5301411747932434, 0.3165413439273834, -1.0090125799179077, -0.7174243927001953, -0.800891101360321, 0.10125008970499039, -0.0186755508184433, -0.3246791362762451, -0.28838977217674255, 0.3097723424434662, 0.42022207379341125, -0.9850088953971863, 0.7765480279922485, -0.6300946474075317, 1.0245038270950317, -0.8620254397392273, 0.4338178038597107, -0.33432045578956604, -0.6136631965637207, 0.07964492589235306, -0.47031357884407043, -0.4387308657169342, -0.4162410497665405, 0.42817598581314087, -0.35741615295410156, 1.097896933555603, 0.37463316321372986, -0.02588799223303795, 0.35273444652557373, -0.39101642370224, 0.4451945126056671, -0.5055679678916931, -0.6149531602859497, -0.3503273129463196, 0.7205594778060913, 0.166732057929039, 0.00498679094016552, 0.1520766168832779, -0.8250554203987122, -0.48418572545051575, -0.145904541015625, 0.5138908624649048, -1.0214241743087769, -0.3137860894203186, -0.4344658851623535, -0.09161311388015747, 0.033828601241111755, 0.4442112445831299, 0.4847896695137024, -0.1509714126586914, 0.18893778324127197, -0.5948890447616577, 0.011773509904742241, 0.31795743107795715, -0.2010667473077774, -0.5875392556190491, -0.6186872720718384, -0.7059261202812195, 0.9453359842300415, -0.658604085445404, -0.6662753224372864, 0.5258839726448059, 0.9094142317771912, 0.3656790554523468, 0.19307941198349, 0.12057094275951385, -0.32651737332344055, -0.12214793264865875, 0.5648858547210693, -0.6792609691619873, 0.41044676303863525, -1.160518765449524, 0.43008965253829956, -1.115833044052124, 0.9223782420158386, -0.6343486905097961, -0.2795063555240631, 0.15992404520511627, -0.7708413600921631, 0.5218024253845215, -1.0288546085357666, 0.18404081463813782, -0.09841209650039673, 0.701105535030365, 0.37687090039253235, 0.6260403394699097, -0.9687828421592712, -0.6439798474311829, -1.375497817993164, -0.9431376457214355, 0.5927414894104004, -0.2698206901550293, -0.061375342309474945, -0.6066855192184448, -0.6850516200065613, 0.01636514998972416, -0.21780163049697876, 0.5264608263969421, 1.2353131771087646, -0.038943905383348465, 0.013297487050294876, 0.06656891852617264, 0.3179329037666321, -0.08774670213460922, -0.3357410728931427, 0.632710874080658, 0.37592217326164246, -0.44010263681411743, 0.11986938118934631, -0.552700400352478, -1.3246062994003296, -0.6803631782531738, 0.6206234693527222, 0.08173830807209015, -0.36391738057136536, 0.473288357257843, -0.30544233322143555, -0.3302023410797119, 0.09590466320514679, -0.05112078785896301, -0.36336642503738403, 0.45002278685569763, -0.1388491839170456, -0.5590871572494507, 0.21291470527648926, -0.37277090549468994, -0.005406292155385017, -0.8462936282157898, 0.10963240265846252, 0.973435640335083, 0.013115373440086842, -0.33731940388679504, 0.3030128479003906, -0.14218617975711823, -0.1469596028327942, -0.4040628671646118, -0.05186689645051956, -0.0941842719912529, -0.3418373167514801, -1.1791117191314697, 0.7440764307975769, -0.11896241456270218, -0.6444858312606812, -0.019562749192118645, 1.2149678468704224, -0.29597383737564087, -0.32056909799575806, 0.15131035447120667, -0.5602859854698181, -0.3190282881259918, -0.22285133600234985, 0.6577457189559937, 0.13692572712898254, -0.49310600757598877, 0.23397640883922577, -0.879116952419281, -0.3070060908794403, 0.38609105348587036, 0.05778719112277031, 0.2695121765136719, 0.43990030884742737, 0.2850777804851532, 0.3002786338329315, 0.4184141159057617, 0.2928180396556854, 0.20117472112178802, -0.17488259077072144, 0.025915825739502907, -1.349047064781189, -0.47674691677093506, 0.6702297925949097, 0.5438628792762756, 0.473467081785202, -0.9208226203918457, 0.216278538107872, -0.31278789043426514, -0.6809101104736328, -0.46765294671058655, -1.1974780559539795, -0.21456724405288696, -0.8973034024238586, -0.6703260540962219, -1.459710955619812, -0.8993954062461853, -0.2770775258541107, 0.2998165786266327, 0.3002525269985199, -0.20547175407409668, -0.8159204125404358, 0.3452434837818146, 0.9809733033180237, 0.2587076723575592, 0.1914610117673874, 0.0023017972707748413, -0.8705062866210938, -0.7563673257827759, -0.5204180479049683, -0.03474605083465576, 0.06785468012094498, 0.37332573533058167, -0.2920781075954437, 0.04215481877326965, -0.346435546875, 0.2747531533241272, -0.6687583923339844, -0.4846991002559662, -0.11186190694570541, -0.7387343645095825, -0.6309402585029602, 0.6646317839622498, -0.33842119574546814, 0.5551428198814392, 0.4998634457588196, -0.675847053527832, -0.2670319080352783, 0.3856266438961029, -0.9413596987724304, -0.26446083188056946, -0.1920449435710907, -0.009798146784305573, -0.12536877393722534, -0.38062623143196106, 0.5939470529556274, 0.7934464812278748, -0.9562399387359619, 0.10925603657960892, 0.14977508783340454, 0.20504717528820038, 0.008313675411045551, -0.21697744727134705, 0.4955141246318817, 0.8907639384269714, 0.14877261221408844, 0.21369744837284088, -0.28867438435554504, -0.06199060380458832, 0.4249848425388336, -0.25130829215049744, -0.5716739296913147, 0.28576895594596863, 0.35699427127838135, -1.2875436544418335, 0.48266085982322693, 0.09410063922405243, -0.8463631868362427, 0.23815995454788208, -0.9737439751625061, 0.09959398955106735, -0.06184845417737961, -0.2813720703125, -0.41612938046455383, 0.5720074772834778, -0.40081867575645447, 0.19115950167179108, -0.42673999071121216, -0.7544021606445312, 0.017047850415110588, -0.2281510978937149, -0.9565430879592896, -0.769294023513794, -0.5029826164245605, -0.7138479948043823, -0.22526344656944275, -0.0843939259648323, -0.7483396530151367, -0.1857856661081314, -0.10110166668891907, -0.3583196997642517, -0.9530319571495056, 0.34265562891960144, 0.36274388432502747, 0.04601491242647171, -1.475770354270935, 0.2660523056983948, -0.5065978169441223, 0.26542600989341736, -1.052856683731079, -0.4712485671043396, -0.23309728503227234, 0.2551337778568268, -0.43660515546798706, 0.03142504394054413, -1.0290131568908691, 1.0457559823989868, 0.538413941860199, 0.3769221901893616, -0.05052991211414337, 0.015472152270376682, -0.5563092827796936, 0.988457441329956, 0.4421679973602295, -0.3667501211166382, 0.5556696057319641, 0.3871099352836609, -0.0652925968170166, 0.4499984085559845, 0.04977839067578316, 1.061273217201233, -0.11600523442029953, -1.0392506122589111, 1.206829309463501, -0.34929054975509644, 0.9058409333229065, 0.15322430431842804, -0.33857297897338867, -0.3585496246814728, -0.18557976186275482, 0.6059849858283997, 0.8422606587409973, 0.4629569947719574, 0.1796148270368576, 0.773277759552002, 0.13514278829097748, 0.15429942309856415, 0.124799944460392, 0.5716380476951599, 0.12295711040496826, -0.2537382245063782, -0.21032442152500153, -0.27449482679367065, -0.4913032352924347, 0.48977094888687134, -0.4755285680294037, -0.7901656031608582, -0.07699532061815262, 0.10315335541963577, 0.36497563123703003, 0.13798928260803223, -0.5987648963928223, 0.1402560919523239, -0.4200109839439392, -0.4503808319568634, 0.11554528772830963, 0.44238296151161194, -0.08371740579605103, 0.7412078976631165, 1.0892630815505981, 0.4553227126598358, -0.3096557855606079, 0.5235859751701355, -0.18213942646980286, 0.1348186731338501, -0.33037275075912476, 0.8358957767486572, 1.0055521726608276, 0.7131874561309814, 0.11080244183540344, -0.14800810813903809, -0.16352877020835876, 0.8692061305046082, -1.6190448999404907, -0.28431540727615356, -0.5591002106666565, -0.1493595987558365, -0.366686075925827, -0.7009965777397156, 0.6972896456718445, -0.42893531918525696, 0.19780273735523224, 1.378713846206665, -0.04059390351176262, -0.1570875644683838, 0.7631961703300476, -0.014866435900330544, 1.1789617538452148, 0.7576655149459839, 0.24021272361278534, -0.35982146859169006, 1.241362452507019, 1.2384729385375977, 0.0873819887638092, -0.12083710730075836, 0.005761822685599327, -0.5619171261787415, -0.03519212454557419, 0.3803428113460541, -0.5669766068458557, 0.6921660304069519, -0.6698625683784485, 0.04802750051021576, -0.18088474869728088, 0.9054602980613708, -0.18714886903762817, -0.6107197403907776, 0.5240931510925293, 0.3706477880477905, -0.39448225498199463, -0.4983459413051605, 1.193277359008789, 0.19190357625484467, 0.5750904679298401, 0.17588311433792114, -0.0036004134453833103, 0.08429688960313797, -0.07247035950422287, -0.287200927734375, -0.4687556326389313, -0.2757657468318939, 0.1826537400484085, -0.2908921241760254, -1.0951828956604004, -0.5844227075576782, -0.47028419375419617, -0.2588590085506439, -0.37338411808013916, 0.5381697416305542, -0.1643362045288086, 0.9970926642417908, 0.129221573472023, -0.7958831787109375, 0.3248249292373657, 1.019350528717041, 1.4515511989593506, 0.39704009890556335, 0.7911837100982666, 0.6770322918891907, 0.6351262927055359, -0.5715431571006775, 1.533644437789917, 0.9291099309921265, -1.0568794012069702, 0.32810306549072266, -0.34697645902633667, 0.1860872507095337, -0.3476178050041199, -0.20409172773361206, 0.5160590410232544, 0.7356240153312683, 0.6578908562660217, -0.8608594536781311, -0.4766087234020233, -0.003773205215111375, -1.6043648719787598, 0.32826194167137146, -0.8948116898536682, 0.4772040545940399, 0.40380188822746277, 0.6507281064987183, 0.1202334314584732, -0.10557876527309418, 3.7137649059295654, 1.0406631231307983, 0.41549235582351685, -0.3846973478794098, 0.9019765257835388, 0.2858528792858124, 0.26522091031074524, -0.8859937191009521, 0.3317418694496155, -0.3333137035369873, -0.2370765656232834, 0.19224922358989716, 0.05387146398425102, -0.7050442099571228, 0.4234423339366913, 0.3947533071041107, 0.17236261069774628, 0.29069626331329346, -0.5636156797409058, -0.9340610504150391, 0.08862322568893433, 0.13938966393470764, 0.5454833507537842, -0.4047159254550934, 0.20352120697498322, -0.15944837033748627, 0.7929622530937195, -0.8125331997871399, -0.505164384841919, -0.018162662163376808, -0.5485364198684692, -0.6758445501327515, 0.38387441635131836, -0.8308088779449463, -0.7506915926933289, 0.21930408477783203, 0.2642790973186493, 0.29212141036987305, 0.6922691464424133, 0.36016327142715454, -0.08598454296588898, -0.07361523061990738, -0.2746540606021881, 0.14727751910686493, -0.39647942781448364, 0.39116302132606506, -0.6428602933883667, 1.041738748550415, -0.12528719007968903, -0.6155291795730591, 1.078897476196289, -0.5538285374641418, 0.1669462025165558, -0.4073367118835449, -1.3478684425354004, -0.4715716540813446, 0.12180130183696747, -0.8122133612632751, 0.34510451555252075, -0.14677679538726807, 1.042026400566101, 0.7100879549980164, -0.283307820558548, -0.46736183762550354, 0.21306011080741882, 0.48533889651298523, 0.6479958295822144, -0.2906665802001953, -0.6526589393615723, 0.12916921079158783, 0.11360136419534683, 0.02083180844783783, -0.3240933418273926, -0.371442049741745, 0.48960080742836, -0.2570728659629822, -0.4054372310638428, 0.7102974057197571, -0.47871658205986023, -0.19417652487754822, -0.4780872166156769, -0.8460893630981445, -0.17829661071300507, 0.055921658873558044, 0.21751634776592255, 1.048675298690796, -0.3641572594642639, -0.4455050528049469, -0.5022878646850586, 0.4318043887615204, 0.379780650138855, 1.3415825366973877, -0.40459442138671875, -0.929768979549408, 0.07749205082654953 ]
Random Sequential Adsorption on a Line: Mean-Field Theory of Diffusional Relaxation
We develop a new fast-diffusion approximation for the kinetics of deposition of extended objects on a linear substrate, accompanied by diffusional relaxation. This new approximation plays the role of the mean-field theory for such processes and is valid over a significantly larger range than an earlier variant, which was based on a mapping to chemical reactions. In particular, continuum-limit off-lattice deposition is described naturally within our approximation. The criteria for the applicability of the mean-field theory are derived. While deposition of dimers, and marginally, trimers, is affected by fluctuations, we find that the k-mer deposition kinetics is asymptotically mean-field like for all k=4,5,..., where the limit k->infinity, when properly defined, describes deposition-diffusion kinetics in the continuum.
Vladimir Privman and Mustansir Barma
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207004
cond-mat/9207005
[ 0.4005546569824219, -0.21616053581237793, 1.1046682596206665, 0.35241982340812683, -0.16224491596221924, -0.9015586376190186, -0.004717687610536814, 0.15754002332687378, -1.0765830278396606, 1.5374454259872437, 1.3740251064300537, -0.039840757846832275, 0.27828529477119446, -0.004999081138521433, -0.5025755167007446, 0.4893292188644409, 0.2486686110496521, 0.09369964897632599, -1.3466527462005615, 0.13064256310462952, 0.1536228507757187, -0.059014465659856796, -1.6457993984222412, -0.3950274884700775, -0.4295722544193268, 0.49918219447135925, 0.7164784073829651, 0.16458472609519958, 1.3283801078796387, 0.1418023407459259, 0.4099805951118469, -0.9978747963905334, 0.46702247858047485, -0.43725019693374634, -0.0632866621017456, 0.14692409336566925, 0.3506455719470978, -0.015603337436914444, 0.8135784864425659, -0.02484883740544319, 1.1331040859222412, 0.12236222624778748, 0.04512652009725571, -0.22401295602321625, -0.9928341507911682, -0.13606047630310059, -0.5367574691772461, 0.8059550523757935, -0.44024595618247986, -1.4331324100494385, -0.27634114027023315, -0.4908684492111206, 0.8913257718086243, -1.169686198234558, -0.050196170806884766, -0.10742518305778503, -0.16066619753837585, 0.7691377997398376, 0.16463693976402283, -0.29076796770095825, -0.01418357901275158, 0.34137389063835144, 0.9278375506401062, -0.4957084059715271, -0.0626424178481102, 0.19196009635925293, -0.4794565439224243, 0.6271966695785522, 0.022772325202822685, -0.10531511902809143, 0.510483980178833, -0.3826988935470581, -0.8292467594146729, 0.25510120391845703, -0.9216381907463074, 0.6077244877815247, -0.008542248979210854, -0.296214759349823, -0.7499698996543884, -0.39031046628952026, 0.5061557292938232, -0.45796772837638855, -0.673947811126709, 0.5158449411392212, -0.42108431458473206, -0.6156525015830994, -0.2400696724653244, -0.3860545754432678, -0.5174285769462585, 0.5522482991218567, 0.14929726719856262, 0.9953368306159973, -0.05287085846066475, -0.7470802664756775, 0.35302186012268066, 1.0117075443267822, 0.19679544866085052, 0.5535659790039062, 0.015513584949076176, 0.07498443126678467, -0.1450577825307846, 0.8670015931129456, 0.07181912660598755, 0.4332788586616516, 0.15929067134857178, 0.8451001644134521, -0.06381291151046753, 0.5263355374336243, -0.1392531543970108, -0.8045514822006226, 0.19847682118415833, -0.792832612991333, 0.2987498641014099, 0.2290540188550949, -0.22935432195663452, 0.44982701539993286, 0.13685967028141022, -0.4019061326980591, -0.8592721223831177, -0.43401995301246643, 0.6049519777297974, 0.16563516855239868, 1.0053678750991821, 0.6410050988197327, -0.05365631729364395, -0.4921146035194397, 0.23164954781532288, 0.0629153922200203, -0.4288131594657898, 0.25120967626571655, 0.41315028071403503, 0.0649738609790802, -0.8098532557487488, -0.3472096025943756, -0.18645182251930237, 0.6088581085205078, 0.11497022211551666, 0.19133171439170837, -0.2866550087928772, -0.5214136242866516, 0.8795007467269897, -0.5142720341682434, 0.03714115917682648, 0.9970294833183289, -0.34188058972358704, 0.7266018986701965, 0.6320909261703491, -0.050866082310676575, -0.0480007566511631, 0.7803122401237488, -0.2444489300251007, -0.023081345483660698, -0.6626190543174744, 0.3340130150318146, 0.32085302472114563, 0.14788155257701874, -0.2136254906654358, 0.5639883279800415, -0.879023015499115, -0.31878572702407837, -0.10385366529226303, -0.53634113073349, -0.1476532369852066, 0.14276908338069916, 0.03299893066287041, 0.17248499393463135, -0.39014050364494324, -0.3054269552230835, 0.26343947649002075, -0.47416332364082336, -0.17735075950622559, 0.0745309591293335, -0.26731353998184204, 0.8117175102233887, 0.8862543702125549, 0.45170828700065613, -0.09148894250392914, -0.7150301337242126, -0.42312949895858765, -0.38172125816345215, 0.06522949039936066, -0.5341067910194397, 0.899337112903595, 0.2877354621887207, -0.5564469695091248, -0.10078231245279312, -0.5757368803024292, 0.3035660982131958, -0.7961764931678772, 0.18036437034606934, -0.184686079621315, 0.44446679949760437, -0.4511585235595703, 0.4862486720085144, -0.7109652757644653, 0.0583147294819355, -0.669382631778717, 0.5083349943161011, -0.27539587020874023, -0.587356448173523, 0.03233692795038223, -0.03308756276965141, -1.0694583654403687, -0.045023586601018906, -1.3333665132522583, 0.5088309049606323, 0.6389361619949341, 0.025348631665110588, -0.09014973044395447, -0.06375998258590698, 0.21092069149017334, 0.01826770044863224, 0.37592360377311707, -0.24227453768253326, -0.02590050920844078, -0.359965443611145, -0.14148367941379547, 0.26229578256607056, -0.06013807654380798, 0.07280483096837997, 0.046189483255147934, 0.26555874943733215, -0.45484867691993713, 0.891340970993042, -0.0966268852353096, -0.43482255935668945, 0.46080318093299866, 0.7477143406867981, -0.3076694905757904, 0.23168571293354034, -0.07186755537986755, 0.42213231325149536, 0.09908236563205719, 0.7624896168708801, 0.6326293349266052, -0.13768510520458221, 1.3902865648269653, 0.2706490755081177, 0.4630753993988037, -0.30723312497138977, -0.1945521980524063, -0.0565321259200573, -0.20326556265354156, 0.28153952956199646, 0.11319469660520554, 0.3849659264087677, -0.7297734618186951, 0.6314610242843628, -0.6121800541877747, 0.5648587346076965, -0.839754581451416, 0.8880029320716858, 0.1523086428642273, 0.2545609176158905, -0.7470272779464722, -0.28642356395721436, -0.05008065700531006, 0.04003771021962166, -0.7061983346939087, -0.5476571321487427, -0.25579947233200073, 0.4300265908241272, -0.5852909088134766, -0.4362475872039795, -0.4535583555698395, 1.2496471405029297, 0.3156716227531433, -0.7032696008682251, 0.2560541033744812, -0.14107660949230194, -1.4283549785614014, -0.2427358329296112, -0.46709051728248596, 0.03464863449335098, -0.3140459656715393, 0.6884422302246094, 0.6248531937599182, -0.1269654482603073, 0.8367125391960144, 0.4414609372615814, -0.45034533739089966, 0.4012548327445984, 0.17963844537734985, 0.1311759352684021, 0.09845788031816483, -0.27358710765838623, -0.23888225853443146, 0.5413271188735962, -0.9182081818580627, -0.27488869428634644, 0.08472971618175507, -0.9028688073158264, 0.7904685735702515, -0.11056692898273468, 0.15063713490962982, -0.09353101253509521, -0.6386594176292419, 0.3728828430175781, -0.03699962794780731, -0.1586833894252777, -0.5285884737968445, 0.35327449440956116, -0.15459319949150085, -0.5595207214355469, -1.0296666622161865, 0.5874601006507874, 0.4594191312789917, -0.6250494718551636, 0.5324510931968689, -0.0809735432267189, -0.6588117480278015, 0.5399544835090637, -0.02636033482849598, 0.011327508836984634, -0.2767472565174103, 0.5900585651397705, 0.4681469202041626, 0.2686084806919098, 0.3492498993873596, -0.37528589367866516, -0.3976341187953949, 0.18333978950977325, 0.23599207401275635, -0.672723114490509, 0.2717241644859314, 0.9273169636726379, -0.2446119636297226, -0.7136449217796326, 0.5542600750923157, -0.8406369686126709, -0.16285501420497894, -0.0903046652674675, -0.3505030870437622, -0.10363250225782394, -0.3082350194454193, -0.17274834215641022, -0.867748498916626, -0.057991597801446915, 0.3258192241191864, 0.48292890191078186, 0.40841880440711975, -1.1572645902633667, 0.09537672251462936, 0.0025461323093622923, 0.329850971698761, -0.2670930027961731, 0.27414655685424805, -0.2630667984485626, -0.7143075466156006, 0.38011324405670166, -0.42162230610847473, 0.16414792835712433, 0.21892155706882477, 1.0940136909484863, 0.28273674845695496, -0.4183254837989807, -0.5017128586769104, -0.6309763193130493, -0.9930067658424377, -0.14743322134017944, 0.1431111842393875, 0.9482301473617554, -0.2042943388223648, 0.3504065275192261, -1.016550064086914, -0.9322143793106079, 0.3583664298057556, -0.10888856649398804, 1.0691035985946655, -0.8135257363319397, 0.38820788264274597, -0.08073293417692184, -0.36484530568122864, 0.13682423532009125, -0.361610472202301, 0.29408738017082214, 0.19966930150985718, 0.3720190227031708, 0.718907356262207, -0.42870032787323, -0.8412860035896301, -0.5545381307601929, 0.5769055485725403, 1.1283172369003296, 0.6603026986122131, 0.45897990465164185, -0.7903944849967957, -0.050739239901304245, 0.16889037191867828, -0.6173213720321655, -0.14319847524166107, -0.5382190942764282, 0.060959991067647934, -0.5839802622795105, 0.22364290058612823, -0.15881021320819855, 0.11065075546503067, -0.4909135401248932, 0.25210216641426086, 0.10269341617822647, -0.09144651889801025, 0.36588621139526367, 1.0052430629730225, 0.2644765079021454, 0.35337284207344055, 0.0536862351000309, -0.37364259362220764, 0.34898054599761963, 0.44010835886001587, 0.5532492399215698, -0.6037638187408447, -0.8753768801689148, -0.24348574876785278, -0.40536201000213623, 0.7281492352485657, 0.4724067151546478, -0.4231967628002167, 0.24430008232593536, 0.2903229892253876, -0.08874513953924179, 0.19591791927814484, -0.2533365786075592, 0.48161956667900085, 0.27893802523612976, 0.4212009310722351, -0.8133947849273682, 0.06421804428100586, -0.23964358866214752, 0.9093631505966187, 1.0238919258117676, -0.5861980319023132, -1.1789648532867432, -1.15351140499115, 0.4963114857673645, -0.7000095844268799, 0.563044011592865, 0.6805533170700073, -0.24158601462841034, 0.49317023158073425, -0.5410364866256714, -0.12016510218381882, 0.5935882329940796, -0.1621997356414795, 0.16426968574523926, 0.5987157821655273, -0.23796981573104858, 0.12913601100444794, 0.7435261011123657, 0.38991445302963257, -0.6814411878585815, 0.24680249392986298, -0.058758534491062164, 0.24071460962295532, -0.27708733081817627, -0.2230897843837738, -0.4286969304084778, 0.0427229143679142, -0.8584830164909363, 0.5717872381210327, 0.3260595500469208, 0.03438479080796242, 0.20504027605056763, 0.20086446404457092, -0.43033307790756226, 0.1427607536315918, 0.3662097454071045, -0.2619720995426178, 0.6685237884521484, 0.604286253452301, 0.5341880321502686, -0.18047450482845306, 0.03783917427062988, -0.12611718475818634, -0.3070213496685028, 0.9464825987815857, -0.15363912284374237, -0.030181052163243294, -0.26681190729141235, -0.10909231752157211, -0.09674607962369919, -0.7091559767723083, -0.0998699739575386, 0.12782371044158936, 0.7429148554801941, 0.2713923156261444, -0.6795857548713684, -0.20745302736759186, -0.347355455160141, -0.5983489751815796, 0.3123382031917572, -0.608762264251709, -0.21686366200447083, 0.3282938599586487, -1.056909203529358, 0.8002198338508606, 0.352568119764328, 0.07398288697004318, -0.24866551160812378, 0.47726118564605713, 0.48930126428604126, 0.07299593836069107, 1.2149546146392822, -0.4460105001926422, 0.7000060081481934, 0.06608206778764725, -0.02687034383416176, -0.5140226483345032, -0.6566749215126038, 0.5143416523933411, -0.47082990407943726, 0.011706266552209854, -0.711420476436615, -0.4258164167404175, -0.24565492570400238, -0.20021545886993408, 0.4750085473060608, 0.41382405161857605, -0.9197734594345093, 0.0033075616229325533, 1.4106533527374268, 0.1940806806087494, -0.48885640501976013, 0.15522366762161255, 0.5552018284797668, -0.3616357743740082, -0.3345769941806793, -0.2840627431869507, -1.1840914487838745, 0.3182797133922577, -0.07685010135173798, 0.4776350259780884, -1.028446078300476, -0.2426118552684784, 0.2160855084657669, -0.6173821091651917, 0.13144083321094513, 0.43238964676856995, 0.19464550912380219, -0.08630193769931793, 0.024108318611979485, -0.05126456171274185, 0.31982046365737915, 0.13705600798130035, -0.4654095768928528, -0.07058943063020706, 0.13985112309455872, -0.5363259315490723, 0.09439409524202347, -0.3351365923881531, -0.22809109091758728, 0.10426981747150421, 0.22047118842601776, 0.009645618498325348, 0.5812950134277344, 0.19817857444286346, -0.3551748991012573, -0.08318038284778595, 0.3532333970069885, 1.149619221687317, 0.3027117848396301, -0.38886237144470215, 0.6276775002479553, -0.8785801529884338, 1.170271396636963, -0.0008600458968430758, -0.23629941046237946, -0.02839536964893341, -0.6562843322753906, 1.105026125907898, -0.36161741614341736, -0.1775573492050171, 0.03568948805332184, -0.1375787854194641, 0.6857327818870544, 0.1421903818845749, -0.33931681513786316, -0.4632263481616974, -0.650038480758667, -0.8319038152694702, 0.6027784943580627, -0.07345760613679886, 0.23649325966835022, 0.03312446177005768, -0.48736852407455444, 0.42356637120246887, -0.41880732774734497, -0.056964512914419174, 0.5594218969345093, 0.26931440830230713, 0.01073151733726263, -0.21979112923145294, -0.15894338488578796, -0.3882163465023041, -0.5692530870437622, -0.4442572593688965, 0.0714048519730568, -0.11012720316648483, -0.1236078217625618, -0.9541095495223999, -0.9272795915603638, -0.9939045906066895, 0.5395060777664185, 0.2556129992008209, -0.2161627560853958, 1.4312728643417358, 0.3308136463165283, -0.3305770754814148, -0.04746231064200401, -0.45746734738349915, -0.004769409075379372, 0.5370556116104126, 0.35529738664627075, 0.3065199553966522, -0.09747013449668884, 0.05223691835999489, -0.06915386766195297, -0.11149083822965622, -0.5009692311286926, 0.5628423094749451, -0.6161310076713562, -0.42701104283332825, 0.33824145793914795, -0.19533005356788635, -0.45654943585395813, 0.2932254672050476, -0.6944660544395447, 0.1748659312725067, -0.32793429493904114, -0.9500910639762878, -0.5660843849182129, -0.6209337711334229, -0.4799339473247528, 0.3768388032913208, 0.4444917142391205, 0.029610926285386086, 0.9688712358474731, -0.5050870180130005, 0.028958842158317566, -0.3783268332481384, 0.3946649730205536, 0.7600171566009521, -0.4134517312049866, -0.9812997579574585, -0.036283787339925766, 0.2514406144618988, -0.28361544013023376, 0.05989191681146622, 0.37504470348358154, 0.4690587818622589, -0.09802041947841644, 0.3310857117176056, 0.4623916745185852, 0.018923524767160416, 1.103506326675415, 0.19074252247810364, -0.3850947618484497, -0.23473605513572693, -0.530567467212677, 0.12848256528377533, -0.45989111065864563, -0.09267601370811462, 0.6364944577217102, -0.15803103148937225, 0.1737731248140335, -0.42019012570381165, -0.3833056390285492, -0.39123988151550293, -1.5241650342941284, 0.05566880479454994, -0.9357118010520935, -0.3375832438468933, -0.9634864926338196, -0.7413434386253357, 0.6571721434593201, -0.24959349632263184, -0.14211928844451904, 0.15214988589286804, -0.8493404984474182, -0.2227146178483963, -0.3385424315929413, 0.3424244225025177, -0.0013873259304091334, 0.06767614930868149, -0.2369367778301239, -0.060253508388996124, -0.2492242306470871, -0.21750079095363617, -0.557499885559082, -0.2158157229423523, -0.31557732820510864, 0.523727297782898, -0.8990351557731628, 0.6714944243431091, -0.7922742962837219, -1.118802785873413, 0.6991317868232727, -0.13228946924209595, -0.8213119506835938, 0.34231293201446533, -0.06228092312812805, 0.3463626503944397, 0.18583635985851288, 0.25478091835975647, -0.9876629114151001, 0.021978095173835754, -1.0558451414108276, -0.016583174467086792, 0.25852927565574646, -0.12486759573221207, -0.3510255813598633, -0.05133429169654846, 0.8029792308807373, -0.07336515188217163, -1.102529764175415, 0.7675684690475464, -0.27338799834251404, 0.4270746409893036, -0.28651341795921326, -0.36156001687049866, 0.39634639024734497, 0.24120880663394928, -0.40806320309638977, 0.7059146165847778, 0.49228718876838684, -0.7256380915641785, -0.4172345697879791, -0.25417935848236084, -0.218778595328331, 0.6184688806533813, -0.3984082341194153, -0.3820481598377228, -0.2757852077484131, 0.961432933807373, -0.26616883277893066, 0.5128982067108154, -0.01951517164707184, -0.5276119112968445, -0.41692715883255005, -0.38400107622146606, -0.5095310807228088, 0.5923638343811035, 0.7993459701538086, -0.6694730520248413, -0.5381034016609192, -0.004447292070835829, -0.567619264125824, 0.2559907138347626, -0.815267026424408, -0.09740494936704636, -0.169994056224823, -0.08678320795297623, -0.2262766808271408, 0.41895362734794617, -0.34692662954330444, 0.19132721424102783, 0.7014726996421814, 0.21253445744514465, -0.49765026569366455, -0.588944137096405, 0.015518700703978539, -0.23873014748096466, -1.3275049924850464, 0.009916163980960846, 0.28181740641593933, 0.7639712691307068, -0.6216490864753723, -0.2310873121023178, -0.07961806654930115, 0.6023066639900208, 0.14316882193088531, 0.10958777368068695, -0.18789196014404297, 0.01323492918163538, 0.3920455873012543, 0.25833359360694885, -0.1721583753824234, -0.24252572655677795, 0.22077448666095734, 0.6752768754959106, -0.46799540519714355, -0.5829274654388428, 0.508846640586853, 0.36475804448127747, 0.3723693788051605, 0.30594250559806824, -0.5188926458358765, 0.6628464460372925, 0.030326493084430695, -0.665795087814331, 0.3769163191318512, 0.4519270658493042, 0.4503505229949951, 0.042966414242982864, -0.7227810621261597, 0.7253064513206482, 0.130035400390625, 1.0707058906555176, 0.7646191716194153, -0.36945435404777527, -0.24576793611049652, 0.45629459619522095, 0.8190383911132812, 0.22202178835868835, 0.2562542259693146, 0.3636546730995178, 0.32468709349632263, 0.13482564687728882, 0.16776494681835175, 0.012447047047317028, 0.410429447889328, 0.02234383299946785, -0.7398754954338074, -0.22743673622608185, -0.31473490595817566, 0.3748393952846527, 0.39720478653907776, 0.4488992393016815, -0.3251001536846161, -0.267540842294693, -0.12447600811719894, 0.7510645389556885, 0.33514171838760376, 0.1626693457365036, -0.10048002004623413, 1.2615798711776733, 1.348445177078247, -0.1999485343694687, 0.04606190696358681, 0.8103033304214478, 0.08188457787036896, 0.15215571224689484, 0.18709847331047058, 0.6059383749961853, 0.9093062877655029, 0.8673276305198669, 0.3019193112850189, -0.27902650833129883, -0.24020609259605408, 0.006845046300441027, -1.259425163269043, -0.22578386962413788, -0.6937987804412842, -0.38367193937301636, -0.3316992521286011, -1.0279970169067383, 0.6472031474113464, -0.49467435479164124, 0.702601969242096, 1.0558289289474487, -0.014499356970191002, 0.37742236256599426, 0.5201233625411987, 0.03214172273874283, 0.6583625078201294, 0.5460888743400574, -0.40981051325798035, 0.1402675211429596, 0.998467743396759, 1.5329031944274902, -0.325682669878006, -0.5043238401412964, 0.35094454884529114, -0.3178827464580536, 0.6027552485466003, -0.0108628636226058, -0.29090407490730286, 0.4034135043621063, -0.3010442554950714, 0.4700876772403717, -0.48558923602104187, 0.5010273456573486, 0.24596627056598663, -0.18059661984443665, 0.23200145363807678, 0.4192507266998291, -0.4763004779815674, -0.16638754308223724, 1.2605010271072388, 0.49904659390449524, -0.6067858338356018, -0.33911266922950745, -0.2698468267917633, -0.48251357674598694, -0.28885507583618164, -0.34843143820762634, 0.4282051920890808, 0.20996935665607452, -0.16803312301635742, -0.1724175363779068, -0.7536800503730774, -0.3511456251144409, -0.932163417339325, -0.47894003987312317, -0.472311794757843, 0.6329030990600586, 0.6066078543663025, 0.7064120769500732, 0.17305508255958557, -0.7971239686012268, -0.03131482005119324, 0.40046754479408264, 0.8396729230880737, -0.6631963849067688, -0.17037220299243927, 0.27508798241615295, 0.13012395799160004, 0.2965620160102844, 0.7169732451438904, 0.8307986259460449, -0.8920214772224426, 0.8851380944252014, 0.024137821048498154, 0.5396397113800049, 0.16268390417099, 0.25548186898231506, -0.2564503848552704, 0.06512697041034698, 0.1015092208981514, -0.5935065150260925, -0.45258933305740356, -0.08042804896831512, -0.9340419173240662, -0.12623143196105957, -0.6534110307693481, 0.5229968428611755, -0.4990116357803345, 0.5685650110244751, -0.023584067821502686, -1.1567970514297485, 4.026490688323975, 0.828150749206543, 0.6815527081489563, -0.49082037806510925, 1.0809739828109741, 0.8021712899208069, -0.4521925151348114, -0.7377756237983704, -0.03155020624399185, -0.6760643720626831, -0.5862990021705627, 0.09399496018886566, -0.028047040104866028, -0.5371909737586975, -0.28909721970558167, 0.7136362195014954, 0.04947410151362419, 0.17190206050872803, 0.3742593228816986, -0.8951060175895691, -0.9416602253913879, 0.43496212363243103, 0.6323222517967224, 0.15962199866771698, -0.5644195675849915, 0.6304768323898315, 0.608309268951416, -0.679965078830719, -0.40221306681632996, -0.7019014358520508, -0.3369287848472595, -1.2890777587890625, 0.399112731218338, -0.22243031859397888, -0.915077269077301, 0.5634692311286926, 0.4374106824398041, -0.6695014238357544, 0.11213803291320801, -0.598298192024231, 0.5197767019271851, 0.3454025387763977, 0.5093265771865845, -0.41948363184928894, -1.0739400386810303, 0.9147547483444214, -0.45830869674682617, 0.8474675416946411, 0.20273254811763763, -0.5637214183807373, 0.8060395121574402, 0.0036349608562886715, 0.7037690281867981, -0.38933777809143066, -1.0527557134628296, -0.6209759712219238, -0.41128355264663696, -0.198682501912117, -0.47843748331069946, 0.18441656231880188, 0.4179651439189911, -0.3576553463935852, 0.3750385642051697, 0.5761095285415649, 0.26111093163490295, 0.8624675869941711, 0.6528182029724121, -0.04709680750966072, -0.06933002918958664, 0.11325842887163162, -0.7677432298660278, -0.6862310171127319, -0.0711483433842659, -0.15137307345867157, -0.2725735306739807, -0.5684903860092163, -0.4383390545845032, 0.04950271546840668, 0.37296462059020996, 0.2128249555826187, 0.06486784666776657, 0.16274835169315338, -0.32062801718711853, -0.44126105308532715, -0.3998383581638336, 0.7004044651985168, -0.02498621493577957, -0.11832685768604279, 0.22291044890880585, 0.1674695760011673, 0.606589674949646, 1.4122713804244995, -0.2939017117023468, -0.013681196607649326, -0.6978126764297485 ]
On the Harmonic Oscillator Regularization of Partition Functions
A convenient way to calculate $N$-particle quantum partition functions is by confining the particles in a weak harmonic potential instead of using a finite box or periodic boundary conditions. There is, however, a slightly different connection between partition functions and thermodynamic quantities with such volume regularization. This is made explicit, and its origin explained to be due to the system having a space-varying density in an external potential. Beyond perturbation theory there is a potential pitfall with the method, which is pointed out.
K{\aa}re Olaussen
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207005
cond-mat/9207006
[ 0.2581114172935486, -0.017911329865455627, 0.6579076647758484, 0.26409319043159485, 0.07926688343286514, 0.34875208139419556, -0.11122363060712814, -0.5365432500839233, -0.1332618147134781, 1.3194409608840942, 0.7901695370674133, -0.27401384711265564, 0.030133528634905815, -0.13623210787773132, -0.03869101032614708, 0.6610361933708191, 0.11842085421085358, -0.8740128874778748, -0.1694238930940628, -0.9998492002487183, 0.3042869567871094, -0.4761542081832886, -0.8829039335250854, -1.0130144357681274, -0.08752895146608353, 0.5152953267097473, -0.20384910702705383, -0.21470150351524353, 1.1103707551956177, 0.6718955039978027, -0.2286362200975418, -0.1539442539215088, 0.9849452376365662, -1.1739287376403809, 0.03423985093832016, -0.4494941234588623, 0.6418062448501587, -0.6233863830566406, 0.5978087782859802, -0.2669577896595001, 1.2532671689987183, -0.4388398230075836, 0.6174017190933228, -0.23636245727539062, 0.14484363794326782, -0.3672051429748535, -0.37291669845581055, -0.2535798251628876, -0.12695720791816711, -0.8999091386795044, 0.7011415958404541, 0.2719530463218689, 0.7487242221832275, 0.32134103775024414, -0.4080495536327362, 0.319498747587204, -0.006732199341058731, 0.007664250675588846, -0.8074819445610046, 0.011379762552678585, 0.45556461811065674, -0.04738546907901764, 0.24356701970100403, -1.3077278137207031, 0.13179050385951996, 1.6992148160934448, -0.7499146461486816, 0.4501113295555115, 0.8659789562225342, -0.5604797005653381, -0.40134772658348083, -0.5482949018478394, 0.28764277696609497, -0.3797711730003357, -0.7356117367744446, -0.08006986230611801, -0.07131495326757431, -0.5083936452865601, -0.25789815187454224, -0.48984459042549133, -1.0074633359909058, -0.7035672068595886, 0.07680623978376389, 1.4296848773956299, 0.0962434932589531, 0.27058732509613037, -0.38515493273735046, 0.7231528162956238, 0.48077496886253357, 0.7914611101150513, 0.2827826142311096, 0.89993816614151, -0.07862633466720581, -0.5817678570747375, -0.7839855551719666, 0.7746745944023132, -0.13759814202785492, 0.3596663177013397, 0.3772095739841461, 0.8649463653564453, 0.2246086746454239, 1.0641086101531982, -0.731979250907898, 0.4883643090724945, -0.7469792366027832, 0.03882613405585289, 0.785178005695343, -0.2219180464744568, -0.3254225552082062, -0.37227869033813477, -0.40909281373023987, 0.40456637740135193, -0.2266210913658142, 0.18006953597068787, 0.44904497265815735, 0.14392977952957153, 0.16519170999526978, 0.4586140215396881, -0.9968993067741394, -0.1106657162308693, -0.07711134105920792, 0.5210380554199219, 0.1858528107404709, -0.2192423939704895, 0.4131530821323395, -0.0933774784207344, 0.779668927192688, 0.869483470916748, 0.1075948104262352, 0.9575902223587036, -0.3063690662384033, -0.8142804503440857, 0.3587442934513092, 0.43882185220718384, 0.300089955329895, 0.10298065096139908, -0.04347679018974304, 0.538194477558136, 1.019346833229065, -0.4065708518028259, 0.3574943244457245, -0.2639288604259491, 0.3638406991958618, 0.9930681586265564, 0.08551009744405746, -0.29079723358154297, -0.0363260917365551, -1.167930245399475, -0.030880076810717583, -0.07829775661230087, -1.416041612625122, 0.5001769661903381, -0.08020909130573273, 0.49972137808799744, 0.3587995767593384, 0.37335044145584106, -0.38622748851776123, 0.6695576906204224, -0.6429709792137146, -0.7950693964958191, -0.20300157368183136, -0.9829249978065491, -0.5739845037460327, 0.5023878216743469, -0.7456194162368774, -0.484566867351532, 0.347206711769104, 0.15389102697372437, -1.1728551387786865, -0.4121403396129608, 0.15244388580322266, 0.38446715474128723, -0.6934629678726196, 0.7281946539878845, 0.0619191937148571, 0.43186020851135254, 0.9958112239837646, -0.11249322444200516, -0.1769363284111023, 0.6116208434104919, -0.27460387349128723, 0.35256001353263855, -0.6871877312660217, 0.8576985001564026, 0.4164096415042877, 0.3173832893371582, -0.7122770547866821, 0.43355005979537964, -0.5623601675033569, 0.49241936206817627, 0.051164839416742325, 0.9879857301712036, -0.6404526829719543, -0.15425057709217072, -0.5969666242599487, -0.4563705325126648, -0.12593777477741241, 0.49188944697380066, -0.6995888352394104, -0.1287960559129715, -0.7857442498207092, 0.1571073979139328, -0.7075741291046143, -0.259537011384964, -1.67361581325531, 0.4796013832092285, 0.5575615763664246, -0.3385714888572693, -0.7191666960716248, -0.07592015713453293, 0.2724951505661011, 0.3342045545578003, 0.15784914791584015, -0.7065543532371521, -0.3631402254104614, 0.02230738289654255, -0.2776227593421936, -0.017285967245697975, 1.305131435394287, -0.4782426059246063, 0.25256866216659546, -0.4159979224205017, -0.30734744668006897, 0.58808434009552, -0.6106026768684387, -0.2578524053096771, 0.4806324243545532, 0.40020933747291565, -0.8735050559043884, -0.011502908542752266, -0.17770585417747498, 0.6563141942024231, 0.00774715980514884, 0.12657615542411804, 0.7278677225112915, 0.6888011693954468, 0.8968179225921631, 1.0017952919006348, 0.4343308210372925, -0.10508076101541519, 0.5113866925239563, 0.03595683351159096, -0.01991329714655876, 0.7697480916976929, 0.7758126258850098, 0.04047780483961105, -0.34100767970085144, 0.32385364174842834, -0.948865532875061, 0.5619331002235413, -0.69185471534729, 1.291815161705017, 0.7174352407455444, 0.8495050668716431, -0.7031233310699463, -0.21451742947101593, -0.22474828362464905, 0.30554577708244324, -0.8300445079803467, -0.8331552743911743, -0.07248210906982422, 0.19599378108978271, -0.7709397077560425, 0.1965775191783905, -0.1710142195224762, 0.9770179986953735, -0.003944756463170052, 0.41388633847236633, -0.36314085125923157, -0.29697978496551514, -1.1235296726226807, -0.7704437971115112, -1.0445854663848877, 0.20062409341335297, -0.5099772214889526, -0.763865053653717, 0.39341217279434204, -1.0210943222045898, 1.0173550844192505, 0.4645809531211853, -0.3867356479167938, 0.13030703365802765, -1.1452484130859375, 0.7752243280410767, 0.9775998592376709, -0.01333878468722105, -0.636481761932373, -0.009742986410856247, -0.5505646467208862, 0.40762051939964294, -0.07501434534788132, 0.08538930118083954, 0.08297032117843628, -0.6396241784095764, -0.21134053170681, 0.07733430713415146, -1.4773460626602173, -0.23643480241298676, -0.2029145509004593, -0.027991939336061478, 0.11752701550722122, 0.9998699426651001, -0.010932727716863155, 0.06743057817220688, -0.23821157217025757, 1.0405195951461792, -0.41669824719429016, -0.3214928209781647, 0.9327113628387451, -0.23142686486244202, 0.1411847472190857, 0.5855454802513123, -0.04002483934164047, 0.20383888483047485, -0.3263006806373596, 0.9505779147148132, 0.9946063756942749, 1.1724475622177124, 0.028638798743486404, -0.7282248735427856, -0.5070087909698486, -0.10087106376886368, 0.11029078811407089, -0.8402922749519348, -0.7668570876121521, 0.5875087976455688, 0.6016424894332886, -0.9144302606582642, 0.5243838429450989, -0.44939205050468445, -0.9534458518028259, -0.4437960386276245, -0.2775723934173584, 0.14178943634033203, -0.05059482529759407, 0.49275344610214233, -1.1897271871566772, 0.4704809784889221, 0.45440903306007385, -0.005399943329393864, 0.3716023862361908, 0.10617033392190933, 0.2885477840900421, 0.2820156216621399, 0.5239890813827515, 0.2955888509750366, 0.7249492406845093, -0.4245873987674713, -0.05785609409213066, 0.6496095061302185, -0.6321220993995667, 0.6011030673980713, 0.6198230385780334, 0.8617095947265625, -0.40041571855545044, 0.43151620030403137, -0.33006787300109863, -0.8610026240348816, -0.04785173386335373, -0.4540090560913086, 0.1267872005701065, 0.04172578454017639, -0.5808947682380676, 0.2979165315628052, 0.07866228371858597, -0.2130732536315918, 1.7190922498703003, -0.1751439869403839, 0.7595736384391785, -1.5292115211486816, 0.7724270224571228, -0.1622832715511322, -0.07406332343816757, 0.16004690527915955, -0.46060898900032043, -0.3361051678657532, -0.05312366038560867, 1.239272952079773, 1.4442188739776611, -1.2114319801330566, -1.2562308311462402, -0.19153232872486115, 1.530953288078308, 1.9712296724319458, 0.5651634335517883, 0.3080974519252777, -0.5961775183677673, 0.2828260064125061, -0.6003775596618652, -0.6931748986244202, -0.3354373276233673, -0.010224402882158756, -0.055327706038951874, 0.008798954077064991, -0.3794105052947998, -0.12378907203674316, -0.3644103407859802, 0.3991326093673706, 0.28857550024986267, 0.9934543967247009, 0.14495053887367249, 0.313721626996994, 0.2901454567909241, 0.5054932832717896, -0.10601042211055756, -0.49932029843330383, -0.6003259420394897, 0.4721250534057617, -0.21348629891872406, -0.29341331124305725, -0.3139820992946625, -0.33699941635131836, 0.009290744550526142, 0.012984196655452251, 0.5604819059371948, 0.40060344338417053, -0.5098727941513062, 0.6654883623123169, -0.6651278734207153, 0.47999441623687744, -0.04532526805996895, -0.8642520308494568, -0.13686218857765198, 0.7984711527824402, -0.3917655944824219, -0.5784052610397339, -1.1202144622802734, -0.4265766739845276, 0.5409348607063293, 0.3616005778312683, -1.0534577369689941, -0.31504783034324646, -0.593260645866394, 0.1557077020406723, -1.6160213947296143, 0.6044173836708069, 1.2251440286636353, -0.10995416343212128, 0.3200088143348694, -0.698511004447937, -0.4194575250148773, 0.39772355556488037, 0.3112061023712158, 0.009083881974220276, -0.32814350724220276, 0.09968376904726028, 0.1291481852531433, 0.1185050681233406, -0.14744386076927185, -0.29661446809768677, -0.15820229053497314, -0.20199838280677795, 0.3705701231956482, -0.08664311468601227, -0.976414144039154, 0.1779995560646057, -0.40728577971458435, -0.09662113338708878, 0.9470173120498657, 0.09874976426362991, 0.5946391820907593, 0.12352517247200012, 0.40477222204208374, -0.6740565896034241, -0.3114483654499054, 0.3531680107116699, 0.007075272034853697, 0.9021633863449097, 0.7953189611434937, 0.524925708770752, -0.07025714218616486, 0.5571022033691406, 0.37702271342277527, -0.35296598076820374, -0.019044365733861923, 0.5513890385627747, -0.057933732867240906, -0.11154598742723465, -0.5963745713233948, -0.7928715348243713, -1.3695762157440186, 0.48094403743743896, -0.6955158710479736, 0.20887242257595062, 0.6187407374382019, -0.5908995270729065, 0.32876893877983093, -0.26612886786460876, -0.3093518912792206, -0.5565101504325867, 0.2596837878227234, -0.5353037118911743, 0.4095269739627838, -0.29505327343940735, -0.16144728660583496, -0.38357308506965637, 0.2975558340549469, -0.17310677468776703, -0.38707247376441956, -0.025306517258286476, 0.3304327428340912, 0.7982897758483887, -0.7386046648025513, 0.7561075687408447, -0.42758989334106445, 0.4285523295402527, 0.21785791218280792, -0.3858320415019989, -0.8861455917358398, -0.7752985954284668, -0.2759518623352051, -0.3268129825592041, -0.10506115853786469, -0.40744566917419434, 0.955438494682312, -0.39483967423439026, -0.4030710756778717, 0.27688026428222656, -0.8621186017990112, 0.5333691239356995, -0.610244631767273, -0.618304431438446, -0.36619704961776733, 1.2176347970962524, 0.48155295848846436, -0.0482846237719059, 0.41278964281082153, -0.6061711311340332, -0.04348193109035492, 0.14150841534137726, -0.5439329743385315, -0.5094974040985107, -0.8001460433006287, -0.1473027467727661, -0.22588911652565002, 0.29449087381362915, 0.8150390982627869, 0.3846452832221985, -0.47236835956573486, 0.1350100338459015, -1.004863977432251, -0.3648228347301483, -0.3152371942996979, -0.945662260055542, -0.538837194442749, -0.45024073123931885, -0.9000239372253418, 0.8249602913856506, -0.7534908056259155, -0.6791648268699646, -0.2736360728740692, 1.1704515218734741, 0.3051103353500366, 0.5912086963653564, 0.41849249601364136, -0.2633988559246063, 0.6632483601570129, 0.2443658411502838, -0.6609947085380554, 1.2495743036270142, -0.5967607498168945, 0.49415290355682373, -1.2770185470581055, 1.2172038555145264, -1.1221836805343628, 0.0831814855337143, 0.18127727508544922, -0.916290819644928, 0.732588529586792, 0.02468838356435299, 0.4094550907611847, -0.21153712272644043, 0.7585128545761108, 0.665158212184906, 0.6317014694213867, -0.8376363515853882, -0.12019737809896469, -0.8303025960922241, -1.5684936046600342, 0.9280620217323303, -0.05650653317570686, -0.2556699216365814, -0.909106433391571, -0.6005508899688721, -0.08548415452241898, -0.06656374782323837, 0.5381235480308533, 1.0192675590515137, -0.5829834342002869, 0.10773390531539917, 0.28910210728645325, 0.763540506362915, 0.040582116693258286, -0.4192678928375244, 0.3152199983596802, 0.03880242630839348, -0.3822796046733856, -0.7772995233535767, -0.7835641503334045, -1.180507779121399, -0.7008705139160156, 0.8918495774269104, 0.20960791409015656, 0.12291594594717026, 0.2970399260520935, -0.41708412766456604, -1.0016521215438843, -0.4227451682090759, 0.4201061725616455, -0.3230708837509155, 0.13645966351032257, 0.597832441329956, -0.3505137860774994, 0.14459003508090973, -0.4753636121749878, 0.10843945294618607, -0.5611192584037781, 0.06757454574108124, 0.6515325307846069, 0.6911283135414124, -0.4681245684623718, 0.07087846845388412, 0.4634642004966736, -1.127312421798706, -0.6094123721122742, -0.6110626459121704, 0.39137130975723267, -0.2816842496395111, -0.12845398485660553, 0.7289347648620605, 0.2989780306816101, -0.6288778185844421, 1.0208028554916382, 0.6778425574302673, -0.5119643807411194, -0.37407562136650085, -0.22986042499542236, -0.5046108961105347, -0.536803662776947, -0.3539769947528839, 1.5048545598983765, -0.21704868972301483, -0.24009285867214203, -0.35565462708473206, -0.8704645037651062, -0.22074952721595764, 0.3610735535621643, -0.3889543414115906, 1.0272597074508667, 0.24870745837688446, 0.26307323575019836, 1.1029837131500244, 0.3854406177997589, -0.14022114872932434, 0.4435686767101288, -0.7965489029884338, 0.3336302936077118, -1.2347972393035889, -1.140249490737915, 0.5005598068237305, 0.07717610150575638, 0.37789681553840637, -0.6745561957359314, 0.8318184018135071, -0.4837656617164612, -0.4655958414077759, -0.4833371043205261, -0.6510885953903198, -0.29327717423439026, -1.0157352685928345, -0.7284255027770996, -1.1873544454574585, -0.518281102180481, 0.28624480962753296, 0.43962183594703674, 0.19685830175876617, 0.09788459539413452, -0.8230772614479065, 0.43716666102409363, 0.785115122795105, 0.045645296573638916, 0.11522837728261948, -0.48088547587394714, -1.1509974002838135, 0.18907107412815094, -0.06395800411701202, -0.010830455459654331, -0.17370595037937164, 0.5291852355003357, -0.3055075407028198, 0.28576257824897766, -0.5766900181770325, 0.4547421336174011, -0.2937863767147064, 0.0016166005516424775, -0.17230001091957092, -0.7613773345947266, 0.12391481548547745, -0.342397540807724, -0.37960880994796753, 0.5258306264877319, -0.27959224581718445, -0.8510019183158875, -0.5436609387397766, 0.6248688101768494, -0.40513741970062256, -0.49629372358322144, -0.3544110059738159, 0.5954186916351318, -0.05810437351465225, -1.1334822177886963, 0.34733137488365173, 0.7055507898330688, -1.587625503540039, 0.9305803179740906, -0.3242782652378082, 0.1214718297123909, 0.14288252592086792, -0.049177441745996475, 0.3488216996192932, 0.915121853351593, -0.666117250919342, 0.5738738179206848, 0.28982657194137573, 0.20412959158420563, 0.5785874724388123, 0.3683750331401825, -0.8621797561645508, -0.4083120822906494, 0.21133700013160706, -1.559117317199707, 0.4745447039604187, 0.6718972325325012, -0.5521795153617859, 0.3866131901741028, 0.537068784236908, -0.4042104482650757, -0.3396766781806946, -0.8936309814453125, -0.8353891372680664, 0.606782078742981, -0.33916306495666504, -0.3622713088989258, -0.6116711497306824, -0.9975569248199463, 0.023443464189767838, -0.1160682961344719, -1.0803966522216797, 0.6625497937202454, 0.44279298186302185, -0.6977393627166748, -0.7610737085342407, -0.5493865609169006, -0.17399077117443085, 0.3764907419681549, -0.08943195641040802, -0.15979330241680145, -0.28098803758621216, 0.03737006336450577, -0.10827703773975372, -0.018432646989822388, -0.9461411833763123, -0.10519658774137497, -0.4925604462623596, 0.5472081899642944, -0.2648787796497345, -0.380205899477005, -0.4187868535518646, -0.011645672842860222, 0.3509937822818756, 0.46827760338783264, 0.0985105112195015, 0.09951381385326385, 0.052371490746736526, -0.06547315418720245, -0.7080994248390198, 0.07557819038629532, -0.1924709975719452, 0.31505149602890015, 0.5258193016052246, -0.5271155834197998, 0.4040340483188629, 0.2127476930618286, -0.5959574580192566, 0.6242197751998901, -0.42040711641311646, 1.11484694480896, 0.19968214631080627, -0.43940889835357666, 1.6084433794021606, 0.007763267029076815, 0.5422219038009644, -0.08369939774274826, -0.5540369153022766, 0.024551767855882645, 0.127488911151886, 0.72442227602005, 0.38913965225219727, 0.9671042561531067, -0.2626090347766876, 0.7541950941085815, 0.09857024252414703, 0.34316977858543396, 0.6482303738594055, 0.5470753312110901, 0.39202791452407837, 0.8106442093849182, -0.2551177144050598, 0.5651351809501648, 0.043486181646585464, 0.13249090313911438, -0.5871022939682007, 0.3238602578639984, 0.04514104500412941, 0.5068371295928955, 0.44921112060546875, 0.23470646142959595, -0.9794117212295532, -0.6753588914871216, -0.34840941429138184, -0.24838973581790924, -0.01088680885732174, 0.7996188402175903, 0.45623719692230225, 0.21006843447685242, 1.3264808654785156, 0.42848721146583557, 0.20720766484737396, 0.5909642577171326, -0.07845666259527206, -0.011110961437225342, 0.16140587627887726, 0.6347886323928833, 0.8187894225120544, -0.2845684885978699, -0.2370823472738266, -0.7210460305213928, -0.31394875049591064, 1.0664798021316528, -1.8154107332229614, 0.30998003482818604, -0.11722398549318314, -0.46747609972953796, -0.35074582695961, -0.2947494089603424, -0.03179109841585159, -0.8681219816207886, -0.13855253159999847, 1.0754103660583496, -0.22853931784629822, 0.2272299826145172, 0.6960055828094482, -0.3687143921852112, 1.3476494550704956, 0.17415452003479004, 0.05014384165406227, -0.6668840646743774, 0.6743423938751221, 1.23555326461792, 0.547748863697052, -0.09295332431793213, 0.7768056988716125, 0.05162789672613144, -0.0912531390786171, -0.3740030825138092, -0.6598415374755859, 1.3673136234283447, -0.3288789689540863, -0.41308829188346863, 0.10575124621391296, 0.39326977729797363, -0.5657030940055847, -0.7053747177124023, 0.35453885793685913, 0.5738059878349304, 0.1268293708562851, 0.0488363616168499, 0.9732843041419983, 0.6621058583259583, 0.5743178725242615, -0.24630115926265717, -0.24537815153598785, 0.1715307980775833, 0.19907993078231812, -0.7064389586448669, 0.11307517439126968, 0.5072851777076721, 0.61957186460495, 0.1588539034128189, -0.5196654796600342, -0.39730262756347656, -1.1012871265411377, -0.3877580165863037, -1.0433801412582397, 0.6407175064086914, 0.022485649213194847, 1.0557749271392822, -0.38210994005203247, -0.777086615562439, -0.3558599650859833, 0.44483911991119385, 1.0382534265518188, 1.0833172798156738, 0.6107540726661682, 0.5303910374641418, 0.19411876797676086, -0.5723332166671753, 0.7173836827278137, 1.3453909158706665, -0.8299616575241089, 0.2626286745071411, -0.5889800190925598, 0.3592582941055298, -0.2002287656068802, -0.03998994827270508, 0.616460919380188, 0.67644202709198, 0.694328248500824, -0.8770328760147095, -0.12359092384576797, -0.21025322377681732, -1.056106686592102, 0.5366504192352295, -0.9515949487686157, 0.050738438963890076, 0.8999536037445068, 0.20746663212776184, 0.13344065845012665, 0.019068418070673943, 3.27898907661438, 0.8878196477890015, 0.554966926574707, -0.5128023028373718, 0.7551233172416687, -0.16314375400543213, 0.9590554237365723, -1.0029865503311157, 0.5218658447265625, -0.46157750487327576, -0.7478295564651489, 0.01517068687826395, 0.5620696544647217, 0.16666443645954132, -0.05030571296811104, 0.9902697205543518, -1.114505410194397, 0.043359167873859406, 0.06368730962276459, -1.482979416847229, -0.34590944647789, 0.7206556797027588, 0.20070144534111023, -0.04485901817679405, 0.6066427826881409, -0.37689313292503357, 0.26895609498023987, -0.7628865838050842, 0.1549144983291626, -0.028155578300356865, -1.0589131116867065, -1.2271971702575684, 0.3539028763771057, -0.04991196468472481, -0.25739574432373047, 0.3376053273677826, -0.014219816774129868, -0.7366583347320557, 0.532476544380188, 0.6009460091590881, -0.5498595237731934, 0.3313056230545044, -0.2428731918334961, 0.4470880329608917, -0.8496658205986023, 0.26932641863822937, -0.5490707755088806, 0.4640243947505951, -0.03529834374785423, -0.6368139386177063, 1.2771881818771362, -0.679949164390564, 0.8161755204200745, -0.1920398473739624, -1.7942253351211548, 0.14250561594963074, -0.11625932902097702, -0.7258822321891785, 1.2114062309265137, -0.2712721526622772, 1.5445853471755981, 0.4170406460762024, 0.3089945614337921, -0.0979851633310318, -0.3339521884918213, 0.0016352899838238955, 0.5307714939117432, 0.10872474312782288, -0.0009446805925108492, -0.05180668830871582, -0.15795095264911652, -0.6350922584533691, -0.5387336611747742, 0.13753414154052734, 0.39123594760894775, 0.1539730578660965, 0.20436757802963257, 0.8731403350830078, -0.3124992251396179, 0.12066544592380524, -0.6199809312820435, -0.4364229440689087, -0.2703506648540497, 0.16344596445560455, 0.6553301215171814, 1.0293786525726318, -0.5902432799339294, -0.464830219745636, -0.08861801028251648, 0.3345043659210205, 0.44296160340309143, 0.4979287087917328, -0.24749942123889923, -0.6348145604133606, -0.566486120223999 ]
Phase Diagram of a Lattice Microemulsion Model in Two Dimensions
The phase diagram of a lattice microemulsion model proposed by Ciach, H{\o}ye and Stell is studied using mean-field theory and Monte Carlo simulations. Surfactant directional degrees of freedom are summed out exactly before mean-field theory is applied, and the resulting phase diagrams are much improved compared with previous mean-field results. The critical line and tricritical point is located using Monte Carlo simulations and finite size scaling.
Per Arne Slotte
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207006
cond-mat/9207007
[ 0.2762924134731293, 0.3651582896709442, 0.10907602310180664, 0.36618417501449585, -0.5278162360191345, -0.41464218497276306, 0.29876038432121277, -0.3636721968650818, -0.7152689695358276, 1.440496563911438, 0.5490546822547913, -0.21929918229579926, 0.44281575083732605, -0.86309814453125, -0.7627424001693726, -0.2913716733455658, -0.33109965920448303, -0.18056230247020721, -1.1777408123016357, -0.2629730999469757, -0.5994964838027954, -0.44294461607933044, -0.2676467001438141, -0.29264554381370544, -0.7354642748832703, 0.8412858247756958, 0.08930115401744843, 0.03619425743818283, 0.45121750235557556, 0.5094960331916809, 0.3660053610801697, -0.5356364846229553, 0.2190554291009903, -0.7921165227890015, 0.3112386465072632, -0.6445779800415039, 0.4344046115875244, -0.4585747718811035, 0.4684407413005829, -0.49252235889434814, 1.1418442726135254, -0.3531476557254791, -0.09560602903366089, -0.14786311984062195, -0.4009409248828888, 0.2837778925895691, -0.4181893467903137, -0.674306333065033, -0.7975195050239563, -1.6959757804870605, -0.19867362082004547, 0.384777307510376, 0.013301853090524673, 0.445108562707901, 0.27279606461524963, -0.2875182628631592, -0.6505669355392456, -0.3808354437351227, -0.057996202260255814, 0.37272801995277405, 0.4150964617729187, -0.21698646247386932, 1.4287517070770264, -0.6195017099380493, -0.18985456228256226, 0.7277354598045349, -0.0684254989027977, 0.943253219127655, 0.09430801868438721, 0.2986848056316376, -0.32094529271125793, -0.33863356709480286, -0.20340397953987122, -0.9137765169143677, -0.5334503054618835, 0.4453473389148712, 0.4753207862377167, -0.07862769067287445, -0.5865241885185242, -0.6680915951728821, 0.44416528940200806, -0.4890515208244324, -0.5388551950454712, -0.07880394905805588, -0.3953939974308014, -0.2370365560054779, -0.23148228228092194, -0.4416787922382355, -0.053273770958185196, 0.33720338344573975, 0.443445086479187, 1.14644455909729, 0.48072680830955505, -0.40988150238990784, 0.424153596162796, 0.49768954515457153, -0.06114717200398445, -0.3362625241279602, -0.01723596826195717, 0.5387427806854248, 0.20253609120845795, 0.9534812569618225, -0.40921881794929504, 0.677710235118866, -0.09872911125421524, 0.36172160506248474, 0.34979304671287537, -0.0905260443687439, 0.18336446583271027, -1.159525752067566, -0.3593013286590576, -0.12158577889204025, -0.6916136145591736, 0.21290209889411926, -0.7560341358184814, 1.0134326219558716, -0.1090473011136055, -0.17630837857723236, -0.47685906291007996, -0.08836601674556732, -0.31905537843704224, 0.03238517791032791, 1.2152459621429443, 0.9067944288253784, -1.0585788488388062, -0.22926053404808044, -0.39222750067710876, 0.3072374165058136, 0.2631753981113434, -0.3516867160797119, -0.1931573748588562, 0.054665397852659225, 0.004429712425917387, 0.909491777420044, -1.119494080543518, 0.7993913888931274, 0.13400743901729584, 0.5192772746086121, 0.7798394560813904, 0.42617735266685486, 0.07354066520929337, -0.3797966539859772, 0.04490154981613159, 0.5682823657989502, -0.065268874168396, 0.8992331624031067, -0.015401539392769337, 0.6708073616027832, -0.21186363697052002, -0.32818537950515747, -1.2937983274459839, -0.28148308396339417, -0.09829811751842499, 0.24614621698856354, 0.31421780586242676, 0.225307434797287, -0.17883430421352386, 0.5291528105735779, -0.745786190032959, -0.7372453212738037, 0.1352757215499878, 0.7744251489639282, 0.4943413734436035, 0.1556716412305832, -0.22553107142448425, -0.3776163160800934, -1.049180030822754, -0.8464890122413635, 0.33964309096336365, -0.660540759563446, 0.11114109307527542, 0.5824835896492004, 0.14297974109649658, 0.43005457520484924, 0.1864510029554367, -0.05667651444673538, 0.4823247492313385, 0.2862555980682373, -0.04962293058633804, 0.027172071859240532, -0.23072564601898193, 0.0018415154190734029, 0.12560033798217773, 0.5567525625228882, 0.5748112201690674, 0.11908838152885437, -0.3497874438762665, -0.03034958429634571, -0.256558895111084, 0.7604923248291016, 0.3361794948577881, 1.269262433052063, -0.575084388256073, -0.07800458371639252, -0.1274256706237793, 0.5274736881256104, -0.7411335110664368, 0.42502158880233765, 0.5202029943466187, -0.976770281791687, -0.24624857306480408, -0.19780491292476654, -0.8608089089393616, 0.9919525384902954, -1.313908576965332, 0.09808550029993057, 1.0186667442321777, 0.8749695420265198, -0.12680360674858093, -0.2579502463340759, -0.007129983510822058, 0.4417654871940613, 0.5143206119537354, 0.6133473515510559, 0.17837923765182495, -0.3530164361000061, 0.4483391344547272, 0.6923409104347229, 0.16577304899692535, -0.23004475235939026, 0.2522219121456146, -0.4334956109523773, -0.045700911432504654, 0.6424688100814819, -0.5673139691352844, -0.11863458901643753, 0.10476728528738022, -0.4361652135848999, 0.4877435266971588, -0.47361695766448975, -0.43835023045539856, 1.4425950050354004, -0.9725176095962524, 0.3953154981136322, 0.6172910928726196, -0.3838474154472351, 0.14008353650569916, 0.22264021635055542, -0.3751285970211029, -0.2134355902671814, -0.14592118561267853, 0.3460075259208679, 0.6116259098052979, -0.14064079523086548, 0.3114035129547119, -0.42231285572052, -0.7170842885971069, -0.011539177037775517, -0.6831702589988708, 0.374419242143631, -0.2698879539966583, 0.25330427289009094, -0.4192865192890167, -0.22657816112041473, -0.6318955421447754, 0.19036594033241272, 0.5317642092704773, 0.8683158159255981, 0.10999982059001923, -0.30956804752349854, -0.7498838305473328, 0.5067980289459229, -0.6992263793945312, -0.5340242385864258, 0.6447121500968933, 1.2587147951126099, -0.14693109691143036, 0.24141915142536163, -0.1264519840478897, -0.43092450499534607, -1.3487308025360107, -0.5041506290435791, -0.7469221353530884, -0.02785252220928669, -0.8440661430358887, -0.5018966197967529, 0.8987030982971191, 0.28148069977760315, 0.6919021606445312, -0.13330289721488953, -0.1933579444885254, 0.17486312985420227, -0.02424750104546547, 0.7739462852478027, 0.5075986981391907, -0.0647834986448288, -1.1659749746322632, 0.6777166128158569, -0.11505292356014252, 0.40101170539855957, 0.21986714005470276, -0.8676583170890808, -0.6449726223945618, -0.4926457405090332, -0.35859453678131104, -0.0778602734208107, 0.21372823417186737, 0.6736430525779724, -0.21812020242214203, 0.16059860587120056, -0.46154654026031494, 0.23088477551937103, 0.04974668100476265, -0.9963040947914124, -0.3313729763031006, 0.7275995016098022, 0.4815402030944824, -0.8835068941116333, 0.4572388529777527, 0.38759908080101013, -0.3511415123939514, 0.02202710323035717, -0.5273450016975403, 0.13252806663513184, 0.25189080834388733, 1.1215771436691284, 0.4406123161315918, -0.5183795094490051, 0.7251765131950378, -0.4338897466659546, -0.3062027394771576, 0.38060611486434937, 0.1061420887708664, -0.5170777440071106, 0.12071330845355988, 0.5782279968261719, 0.049770038574934006, -0.3065304458141327, 0.0023319898173213005, -0.9837082624435425, 0.1856987476348877, 0.47155219316482544, -0.08786483854055405, 0.3328229784965515, -0.4984394311904907, -0.4824528098106384, -0.13207033276557922, -0.24127916991710663, 0.8264062404632568, 0.2331124246120453, 0.39513882994651794, -1.1165266036987305, 0.11699170619249344, 0.27318909764289856, 0.8086996078491211, -0.0631299614906311, 0.6588069796562195, -0.4547777771949768, -0.6022265553474426, -0.07914251834154129, -0.8560675382614136, 0.26516175270080566, -0.02310384064912796, -0.05617334321141243, 0.7079936861991882, 0.3696816563606262, -0.6994827389717102, -0.5358775854110718, 0.2623535096645355, -0.01031513325870037, -0.25894367694854736, 0.5569483637809753, -0.23465421795845032, 0.2999758720397949, -1.21738600730896, -0.12691298127174377, 0.5117909908294678, -0.5570939779281616, 1.2302662134170532, -0.4570685029029846, 0.35897231101989746, -0.24100254476070404, -0.6391347646713257, 0.8564434051513672, -0.13450516760349274, 0.47419992089271545, 0.22250255942344666, 0.5794664025306702, 0.9567315578460693, -0.4498625695705414, -0.5075019598007202, -0.5417857766151428, 0.7107144594192505, 1.0187664031982422, 0.38953739404678345, 1.0289992094039917, -0.448559045791626, 0.8466246128082275, -0.2353319227695465, -0.3740706741809845, 0.5663760900497437, -0.6010435819625854, -0.4265086352825165, -0.6663439273834229, -0.26213130354881287, 0.37185123562812805, 0.9109509587287903, -0.01877666264772415, -0.2485586553812027, -0.11901538819074631, 0.24876154959201813, 0.5876098275184631, 0.4276305139064789, 0.707737922668457, 0.11087536066770554, -0.10595293343067169, -0.3610212206840515, 0.5640755295753479, -0.8131662011146545, 0.2782914340496063, -0.6292464733123779, -0.8334618806838989, -0.19779102504253387, -0.0962577685713768, 0.8019784688949585, -0.11386772990226746, 0.24268986284732819, 0.25935500860214233, 0.4806092083454132, 0.47935518622398376, -0.030659297481179237, -0.08508294075727463, -0.25033533573150635, 0.44444501399993896, 0.2417362481355667, -0.7821314930915833, 0.613159716129303, -0.3362867832183838, 1.1526362895965576, 0.8346603512763977, -0.11410921066999435, -0.7955225110054016, -0.28772979974746704, 0.6180067658424377, -0.8814396858215332, 0.08298604190349579, 1.1414800882339478, 0.33556222915649414, -0.6213684678077698, -0.16396275162696838, 0.30662405490875244, 0.3199629485607147, -0.7234423160552979, -0.5876782536506653, -0.5625289678573608, 0.44622769951820374, -0.3915064334869385, -0.1778068244457245, -0.4063180685043335, 0.1702902466058731, -0.09347570687532425, -0.34778034687042236, 0.3652021586894989, 0.22668838500976562, 0.046827223151922226, -0.004310128279030323, -0.652662456035614, 0.40371495485305786, 0.8120467662811279, 0.11185141652822495, -0.2641548216342926, -0.12584058940410614, 0.09084906429052353, -0.6009120941162109, -0.8751097321510315, -0.41893044114112854, -0.17701324820518494, 0.12734411656856537, -0.02678249217569828, 0.2610167860984802, 0.054498422890901566, 0.03646176680922508, -0.5268140435218811, -0.5721079111099243, 0.6106428503990173, -0.3679138720035553, -0.017501693218946457, 0.08989492803812027, 0.275948703289032, -0.15356555581092834, -0.5153612494468689, 0.44498544931411743, 0.054228849709033966, 0.5744815468788147, -0.5766211152076721, -0.7533202767372131, 0.1591360718011856, 0.1714552491903305, -0.9018958806991577, 0.7229267358779907, -0.37945497035980225, -0.7307651042938232, -0.3932284414768219, 0.8043859004974365, 0.8176851272583008, 0.3145737051963806, -0.27467992901802063, -0.18081967532634735, 0.9869924783706665, 0.1380174458026886, -0.2749417722225189, 0.22719545662403107, -0.678453803062439, 0.2956688404083252, -0.6493898630142212, 0.5537543892860413, -0.6060173511505127, -0.2572003901004791, -0.22084683179855347, -0.7059327363967896, -0.48394009470939636, -0.07459650188684464, 0.10953131318092346, -0.5171330571174622, 0.28775298595428467, 0.6610464453697205, 0.41330423951148987, 0.5865674018859863, -0.9831160306930542, 1.0254523754119873, -0.2838342487812042, -0.767875611782074, -0.22806613147258759, 0.8592966198921204, -0.31877756118774414, 0.6686632037162781, 0.3670912981033325, -0.9519240260124207, 0.48189350962638855, 0.4918595850467682, 0.9886823296546936, -0.7670975923538208, 0.23737289011478424, -0.7201197147369385, 0.2043699026107788, -0.6921643018722534, 0.7152984142303467, -0.05552848055958748, 0.4677998423576355, -0.10872401297092438, -0.3122600018978119, 0.3099939823150635, 0.4283674359321594, 0.12021278589963913, -0.07109392434358597, -0.09586737304925919, -0.5975624918937683, 0.23186229169368744, -0.13799993693828583, 0.01950332522392273, 0.6140384078025818, 0.13354556262493134, 0.3022766411304474, 0.07053269445896149, -0.03506944701075554, 0.6480333209037781, 0.17281293869018555, 0.7997353076934814, -0.061104532331228256, -0.015282906591892242, -0.8105351328849792, 0.08457046002149582, -0.7258613705635071, 0.20209068059921265, -0.652262270450592, 0.06756527721881866, 0.9453666806221008, 0.39424821734428406, 0.4613220691680908, -0.5603959560394287, 0.2645033001899719, -0.21876630187034607, 0.3859051764011383, -0.21829131245613098, 0.015906577929854393, -0.36751624941825867, -0.6473822593688965, -1.6606261730194092, -1.0211044549942017, 0.9765660762786865, -0.10921195894479752, -0.5490963459014893, -0.49641239643096924, -0.022756826132535934, -0.20078200101852417, -0.4922170341014862, 0.5003796815872192, 1.0463521480560303, 0.2509925067424774, 0.34149739146232605, -0.5460299849510193, 0.6258244514465332, 0.26004311442375183, 0.16338402032852173, 0.4241430461406708, 0.1678883284330368, -0.01891777291893959, -0.04037423059344292, -0.4097730815410614, -0.5167362689971924, -0.3602329194545746, 0.711146354675293, 0.04296401888132095, 0.1300780326128006, 0.9319095611572266, 0.3297039568424225, -0.2500725984573364, 0.4447697103023529, 0.15195336937904358, -0.26070302724838257, -0.004447403829544783, 0.8118826150894165, -0.15531431138515472, 0.23087497055530548, -0.2351216971874237, 0.0497935526072979, -0.8582714200019836, 0.15532410144805908, 0.28727713227272034, -0.14604386687278748, 0.11741159111261368, 0.6654084920883179, -0.28727030754089355, -1.2113864421844482, -0.3753567337989807, -0.13970406353473663, 0.357684463262558, -0.5720119476318359, -1.231077790260315, -0.17186591029167175, -0.008506824262440205, -0.13086716830730438, 0.2477046698331833, 0.610102653503418, 0.03278804570436478, 0.7723137736320496, 0.9054781794548035, -0.1159677729010582, -0.3865472376346588, -0.09459763020277023, 1.238762378692627, 0.09147731214761734, -0.7508171796798706, -0.6468198299407959, -0.2097572684288025, -0.5897464156150818, -0.09597168862819672, 1.1088193655014038, 0.11247282475233078, 0.6042457222938538, 0.06765710562467575, -0.2962275445461273, 0.5113211274147034, 0.6293146014213562, 0.5943747162818909, 0.6101090908050537, 0.19633609056472778, -0.7966378927230835, 0.13812513649463654, 0.25272318720817566, 0.42991864681243896, 0.4302304685115814, -0.5043536424636841, -0.058581072837114334, -0.07430650293827057, -0.2270125150680542, -0.36862725019454956, 0.021903371438384056, -0.2802857756614685, -1.335503101348877, -0.9124538898468018, -1.629931092262268, -0.41039034724235535, 0.2579629123210907, 0.40121570229530334, -0.18127766251564026, -0.10033058375120163, -0.27728280425071716, -0.11232005804777145, -0.31063759326934814, 0.7339498996734619, 0.08992061764001846, -0.3045828342437744, -0.8740689158439636, -0.8398994207382202, -0.779780924320221, 0.05944731831550598, -0.8564857244491577, 0.043844301253557205, -0.358376681804657, 0.2613416016101837, -0.8817565441131592, -0.40085679292678833, -1.027680516242981, -0.5208016633987427, -0.22734923660755157, 0.049515824764966965, -0.772986888885498, 0.1332613080739975, 0.46889203786849976, -0.5410054922103882, -0.31400206685066223, 0.1275424361228943, 0.40972334146499634, -0.7330829501152039, -0.7475302815437317, -0.13205993175506592, -0.5521517395973206, -0.20541658997535706, -0.10070674866437912, 0.17800673842430115, 0.5150267481803894, 0.8891641497612, -0.9661070108413696, -0.03654621168971062, -0.6610591411590576, 0.4483166038990021, -0.5140694975852966, -0.4851609766483307, -0.6955534219741821, 0.510736346244812, -0.910180389881134, 1.0263195037841797, 0.2679623067378998, -0.6011922359466553, 0.3043929636478424, 0.07522071152925491, -0.11763586103916168, 0.6119629144668579, 0.2929742932319641, -0.26209738850593567, -0.17387764155864716, -0.052285872399806976, -0.7243178486824036, 0.8171929717063904, -0.7129318118095398, 0.10999865084886551, -0.9360841512680054, -0.21868900954723358, -1.165861964225769, -0.161492720246315, 0.39073795080184937, -0.36890965700149536, 0.3882282078266144, -0.461385041475296, -0.7283757328987122, 0.00013673835201188922, -1.2056435346603394, -0.695450484752655, -0.8416610360145569, -0.642512321472168, -0.8313269019126892, -0.3884868621826172, -0.27987733483314514, -0.012865958735346794, 0.21530357003211975, 0.5463959574699402, -0.8448114991188049, 0.05488383397459984, -0.0016900697955861688, 0.22656472027301788, -0.6276798844337463, 0.31491249799728394, -0.8684332966804504, 0.6442305445671082, -0.5007503628730774, -0.6372429132461548, -0.15562132000923157, 1.159544825553894, -0.9220202565193176, -1.2087663412094116, -0.8416211605072021, 0.46373793482780457, 0.21687090396881104, 0.26611465215682983, -0.41473156213760376, -0.48265036940574646, -0.37456056475639343, 0.671356737613678, 0.5933122038841248, 0.6277499794960022, 0.40945670008659363, 0.8741905093193054, 0.9974128007888794, 0.34046077728271484, 0.3886442482471466, 1.0866211652755737, -0.025911444798111916, 0.04549296572804451, 1.0568643808364868, -0.4022260904312134, 0.7123615741729736, 0.5003628134727478, 0.4002969563007355, -1.2862449884414673, -0.21828237175941467, 0.3421506881713867, 0.5372843742370605, 0.3950941562652588, 0.557807445526123, 0.5542159676551819, -0.4528057277202606, -0.5808731913566589, 0.700558602809906, 0.7803802490234375, -0.97274249792099, 0.6977899670600891, -0.6432471871376038, 0.6415069103240967, -0.36271291971206665, 0.32183220982551575, -0.7360503077507019, -0.4300353527069092, -0.098195880651474, 0.5500457286834717, -0.09645775705575943, 0.6457209587097168, -0.07655156403779984, 0.9012095332145691, -0.6042167544364929, -0.18246705830097198, 0.050510089844465256, 0.2923746109008789, -0.33017146587371826, 0.05135366693139076, 0.8578387498855591, 0.772682785987854, 0.3957642614841461, 0.3657735288143158, -0.6035348176956177, 0.3418372869491577, -0.41858166456222534, 0.7882356643676758, 0.8329415321350098, 0.34297415614128113, 0.3402756154537201, -0.5635277032852173, -0.0782199427485466, 0.7669682502746582, -1.1412233114242554, -0.038641925901174545, -0.3340781331062317, -0.8656490445137024, -0.2957080602645874, -0.07693959027528763, 0.7254742383956909, -0.5885245203971863, -0.28001633286476135, 1.380989909172058, -0.03301217034459114, -0.7479974031448364, 0.0548841767013073, -0.535946249961853, -0.46759387850761414, 1.2313306331634521, 0.6405060291290283, -0.6851263642311096, 0.24954238533973694, 0.7685635089874268, -0.7928215265274048, 0.23691125214099884, 0.08480589836835861, -0.2920803129673004, -0.0059850397519767284, 0.17850929498672485, -0.8143905997276306, 0.7435178160667419, -0.40013420581817627, -0.4588504135608673, -0.1579979807138443, -0.23385649919509888, -0.03222711384296417, 0.08041618764400482, 0.07290903478860855, 0.08186603337526321, -0.3241584897041321, 0.33211711049079895, 0.8099012970924377, -0.019354546442627907, -0.2963469624519348, -0.783230185508728, -0.6258634328842163, 0.5501117706298828, -0.2142474353313446, 0.5622732639312744, 0.02248878963291645, -0.20829987525939941, 0.08688179403543472, 0.2809295952320099, -0.3187580704689026, -0.480642706155777, -0.43844911456108093, -0.21830840408802032, -0.06791634857654572, 0.9231680631637573, 0.3079056143760681, 0.7409136295318604, -0.21744708716869354, 0.2038830667734146, 0.06475403159856796, 0.7740686535835266, 1.61952805519104, -0.2901361584663391, 0.19627881050109863, 0.22189106047153473, 0.09905528277158737, -0.04424167051911354, 1.0841196775436401, 0.2598372995853424, -0.24826854467391968, -0.029910322278738022, -0.5572011470794678, -0.012323785573244095, 0.27954429388046265, 0.0079823462292552, 0.0860527977347374, 0.13222835958003998, -0.18983334302902222, -0.46105214953422546, -0.012041219510138035, -0.3463558852672577, -0.837190568447113, 0.21646015346050262, -0.467229425907135, 0.8618120551109314, -0.4631056785583496, -0.13102489709854126, -0.056482478976249695, -0.9117581844329834, 3.822517156600952, 0.8762331604957581, 0.4229457378387451, -0.43825283646583557, 0.5118554830551147, 0.7215534448623657, -0.00557703385129571, -0.564382016658783, 0.5048295259475708, 0.09593654423952103, 0.1654234677553177, 0.02802993729710579, -0.05470171943306923, 0.20501938462257385, 0.1011601909995079, 1.3526209592819214, -0.018782945349812508, -0.14904670417308807, 0.44000479578971863, -0.6133676171302795, -0.521105170249939, 0.4065167307853699, 0.6173648834228516, 0.11652188003063202, -0.4441416561603546, 0.5318476557731628, 0.35697269439697266, -0.9018563032150269, -0.7379364967346191, -0.15170440077781677, -1.0779253244400024, -0.2401117980480194, 0.7987337112426758, -0.7293652296066284, -0.8479416966438293, -0.3376012444496155, -0.17378659546375275, 1.1548432111740112, -0.6354240775108337, 0.5156639814376831, 0.500415563583374, 0.594448447227478, -0.6105754971504211, -0.42988428473472595, -0.42728546261787415, 0.5869956612586975, -0.8386808037757874, 1.1930896043777466, 1.0678685903549194, -1.1810970306396484, 0.7824987173080444, -0.28612416982650757, 0.7752115726470947, -0.3771090507507324, -0.49661362171173096, 0.3998865485191345, 0.14398249983787537, -0.8311997652053833, -0.5776171088218689, 0.42733508348464966, 1.0429104566574097, 0.032493095844984055, -0.16958457231521606, -1.0785099267959595, 0.23177923262119293, 0.45740965008735657, 0.8566042184829712, 0.46840399503707886, -0.5177209377288818, 0.42453765869140625, -0.36964985728263855, -0.4878314137458801, -0.7029127478599548, -0.48486462235450745, 0.14988678693771362, -0.3505290448665619, 0.15776808559894562, 0.3836333155632019, 0.1623028814792633, -0.04194319248199463, -0.3014926314353943, -0.06228220462799072, -0.005984832067042589, 0.34296268224716187, 0.0030043055303394794, 1.6559110879898071, 0.15487442910671234, -0.08902560919523239, -0.6213408708572388, 0.4144270122051239, 0.485897034406662, 1.0841031074523926, 0.08132368326187134, 0.1295652538537979, -1.0409499406814575 ]
Low voltage conductance of small tunnel junctions
A discrete charge transfer in a small tunnel junction where Coulomb interactions are important can excite electron-hole pairs near the Fermi level. We use a simple model to study the associated nonequilibrium properties and found two novel effects: (i) for junctions with electrodes of the same electronic properties, a leakage current exists within the Coulomb gap even when the environmental impedance is infinite; (ii) for junctions with electrodes of different electronic properties, the differential conductance diverges when a net interaction between conduction electrons is attractive, and it is strongly suppressed for a net repulsive interaction.
F. Guinea and M. Ueda
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207007
cond-mat/9207008
[ 0.009140009060502052, -0.0414261631667614, 0.1956796646118164, 0.22418062388896942, 0.23762765526771545, -0.35909461975097656, 0.4393153190612793, -0.9828521013259888, -0.3585132360458374, 1.7774219512939453, 0.6505325436592102, -0.18992452323436737, 0.6139458417892456, -1.0795859098434448, -0.003937274683266878, 0.11249930411577225, -0.6128329038619995, -1.125837802886963, -1.0746948719024658, -0.07700300961732864, -0.2688080370426178, -0.4885038137435913, -1.1192327737808228, -1.1080256700515747, -0.1435321569442749, 0.5314662456512451, -0.46253660321235657, 0.356173038482666, 0.4375067353248596, 0.49766549468040466, -0.1031712219119072, -0.3426989018917084, -0.14961984753608704, -0.9862916469573975, -0.11665576696395874, 0.35888537764549255, -0.1407451182603836, 0.25694987177848816, 0.577483057975769, -0.41240158677101135, 0.6686874628067017, -0.7543449401855469, 0.402412086725235, -0.2703620493412018, -0.13716332614421844, 0.23860202729701996, -0.7171673774719238, -0.08402176946401596, 0.31431302428245544, -1.319555640220642, 0.3714941143989563, 0.8967187404632568, 0.7271777391433716, -0.055028434842824936, -0.10460423678159714, 0.42337551712989807, 0.12519367039203644, -0.2541087567806244, -0.22074975073337555, -0.28369632363319397, 0.5971558094024658, -0.012043910101056099, 0.6231429576873779, -0.8305641412734985, 0.5053452253341675, 0.16024014353752136, -0.3389430344104767, 1.0621228218078613, -0.11720525473356247, 0.1321485936641693, -0.930946946144104, 0.07516254484653473, 0.5293548107147217, -0.24319015443325043, -0.5533410906791687, 0.1612561047077179, -0.06431367248296738, -1.0514532327651978, -1.1531739234924316, -0.48170092701911926, 0.022219384089112282, -0.21067741513252258, -0.30698293447494507, 0.6295158863067627, 0.0322478711605072, 0.01279523503035307, -0.16073109209537506, 0.020950723439455032, 0.07422366738319397, 0.8805617094039917, 0.5276437401771545, 0.7706845998764038, -0.3515752851963043, 0.2079649418592453, 0.1900983303785324, 0.10664162784814835, 0.030299978330731392, 0.6900292038917542, 0.38570353388786316, 0.3647657632827759, 0.041018787771463394, 0.8389066457748413, -0.648461103439331, 0.7284418344497681, -0.546485185623169, 0.24931155145168304, 0.48501354455947876, 0.38796424865722656, 0.26364174485206604, -0.26475948095321655, 0.1526467353105545, 0.5581796765327454, 0.6401254534721375, 0.37801045179367065, -0.16592790186405182, 0.24752336740493774, 0.12278853356838226, -0.27169057726860046, -1.458765983581543, -0.568971574306488, 0.03573497384786606, 0.1546543836593628, 0.6235144138336182, 0.35681629180908203, -0.400623083114624, -0.21494586765766144, 0.9858396649360657, 0.5684236288070679, -0.47594571113586426, 0.4811480939388275, 0.00584466103464365, 0.2902132272720337, -0.46228092908859253, 1.0340174436569214, -0.60076904296875, 0.21928700804710388, 0.11449120938777924, 0.8051663041114807, 0.09495797753334045, 0.21245326101779938, 0.5144497156143188, -0.7784872651100159, 0.40247803926467896, 0.7029650807380676, 0.06936588883399963, -0.37445223331451416, 0.4864486753940582, -0.030088473111391068, 0.3067421317100525, 0.3823324143886566, -0.6436704397201538, -0.03360413387417793, 0.5924431681632996, 0.3039630055427551, 0.23168154060840607, 0.18469905853271484, -0.7736514806747437, 0.8516237139701843, -0.5663667321205139, -0.8300849199295044, 0.7368476390838623, 0.6266354322433472, -0.17680180072784424, -0.1791330724954605, -0.6028748750686646, 0.544448971748352, -0.18791157007217407, -0.321228563785553, -0.08114175498485565, -0.2756333351135254, -0.44765034317970276, 0.09980855882167816, 0.13150061666965485, 0.2826973795890808, -0.21449540555477142, 0.42976173758506775, 0.7583295702934265, -0.5990840792655945, 0.03963898494839668, -0.1864761859178543, 0.11493796110153198, -0.23240815103054047, 0.6289247274398804, 0.09443403035402298, 0.5495046377182007, 0.2697368264198303, -0.671001136302948, -0.5958284139633179, -0.2938145101070404, 0.48185285925865173, -0.47112762928009033, 0.6440570950508118, 0.3825806677341461, 0.23508216440677643, -0.5203521847724915, -0.871168851852417, -0.24829797446727753, 0.27965477108955383, -0.43039360642433167, -0.005722750909626484, -0.0806470736861229, 0.7805482745170593, -1.073894739151001, 0.7631425261497498, -1.7882099151611328, 0.04937460273504257, 0.4354262948036194, 0.696312427520752, -0.9223584532737732, 0.32347986102104187, 0.27559906244277954, -0.3231871426105499, -0.10472766309976578, -0.27782687544822693, 0.06593427807092667, -0.04549106955528259, -0.30700844526290894, -0.480622261762619, 1.2283681631088257, -0.07711601257324219, 0.5164625644683838, -0.12803594768047333, -0.04595578834414482, 0.4687151312828064, -0.6964868903160095, -0.2557332217693329, 0.31646639108657837, 0.5171029567718506, 0.052197251468896866, -0.2911754250526428, 0.1854228973388672, 1.0588611364364624, 0.045017097145318985, 0.3871675431728363, 1.191650152206421, 0.39200863242149353, -0.18816910684108734, 0.649347186088562, 0.26050955057144165, -0.16675464808940887, -0.8395920991897583, 0.14160630106925964, 0.2117312103509903, 0.4077374339103699, 0.015855785459280014, -0.8318189382553101, -1.2809866666793823, 0.4333976209163666, -0.42924824357032776, 0.3542337119579315, -0.7130893468856812, 0.21213731169700623, -0.401621550321579, 0.48492303490638733, -0.9281865954399109, -0.23922373354434967, -0.16706277430057526, -0.18655303120613098, -0.09090433269739151, -0.6278513073921204, 0.09673332422971725, 0.3509500026702881, -0.33319589495658875, -0.3501529395580292, 0.22267940640449524, 0.7135979533195496, -0.024105902761220932, -0.1740596741437912, 0.2681332528591156, -0.4337288439273834, -0.6465595960617065, -0.17612211406230927, -1.146851897239685, -0.504557728767395, -0.4284018874168396, 0.276054710149765, 0.9971811771392822, -1.5163617134094238, 0.7764098644256592, -0.6433599591255188, 0.16697271168231964, 0.28566038608551025, -0.39518555998802185, 0.8160203099250793, 0.3031214773654938, 0.47706666588783264, -0.864081621170044, 0.21089807152748108, -0.6288191676139832, 0.6483359932899475, -0.7103836536407471, 0.11975559592247009, 0.5855554938316345, -0.5504508018493652, 0.22426846623420715, -0.32591691613197327, -0.7662564516067505, -0.5571934580802917, 0.035167671740055084, -0.4834316670894623, -0.2613413333892822, -0.1565312147140503, -0.9860405921936035, -0.5337768793106079, -0.5768312215805054, 0.6763788461685181, -0.08854732662439346, -0.13177718222141266, 0.17673978209495544, 0.3284410834312439, -0.3076344430446625, 0.10939832776784897, -0.4680004417896271, -0.1700514405965805, 0.3994523286819458, 0.9857157468795776, 0.7911399602890015, 0.6904475092887878, 0.1333230584859848, -0.17449547350406647, -0.386992484331131, 0.7286511659622192, 0.04582127556204796, -0.43081948161125183, -0.2149432897567749, 1.0945243835449219, 0.6580272912979126, -0.3083833158016205, 0.3528449535369873, -1.7302541732788086, -0.13758935034275055, 0.2473379671573639, -0.5499652624130249, 0.8673487305641174, -0.4364696741104126, -0.5709133148193359, -0.911492645740509, -0.2933129072189331, 0.6649740934371948, 0.1916404366493225, 0.5258103013038635, 0.1751050502061844, 0.5004016757011414, 0.3628508448600769, 0.56610107421875, 0.2911796271800995, 0.14282278716564178, -0.6384676098823547, -0.483617901802063, -0.22643731534481049, -0.9652270674705505, -0.13515529036521912, 0.7728849053382874, 0.37194526195526123, 0.32161015272140503, 0.3037532567977905, -0.9062902331352234, -0.7566599249839783, 0.06780395656824112, -0.25361549854278564, 0.902916431427002, 0.14910399913787842, -0.45559367537498474, -0.03161948546767235, -0.29513683915138245, 0.2380715161561966, 0.5524731278419495, 0.09482748061418533, 0.796781599521637, -0.31662264466285706, 0.5962430834770203, 0.4490053355693817, -0.4938388764858246, 0.4010871350765228, -0.06546150147914886, -0.4541347622871399, 0.1575072854757309, 0.46833768486976624, 1.2607381343841553, -0.6478129625320435, -0.5794652700424194, -0.4508325755596161, 1.7657915353775024, 0.8108459711074829, 0.5785942673683167, 0.7424123883247375, -0.09016892313957214, 0.21683092415332794, -0.3374289572238922, -0.18399199843406677, 0.08837871253490448, 0.33505550026893616, -0.5848631262779236, -0.009135120548307896, -0.015672482550144196, 0.20707325637340546, 0.07119222730398178, 0.6386252641677856, 0.18333977460861206, 0.2083362191915512, 0.9482467174530029, 0.5447647571563721, 0.46258243918418884, 0.5122155547142029, -0.07415586709976196, 0.234495609998703, -0.4236257076263428, -0.1908530294895172, 0.3797095715999603, -0.14170973002910614, -0.61297607421875, -0.6572834849357605, -0.4782044291496277, -0.39497822523117065, 0.5326691269874573, 0.8520640134811401, -0.00344086647965014, 0.7862730622291565, 0.27267685532569885, 0.9154471755027771, -1.0494115352630615, 0.3248530626296997, 0.6449432969093323, 0.9376184344291687, 0.035208046436309814, -0.8039776682853699, 0.572339653968811, -0.2026691883802414, 0.37125757336616516, 0.42496180534362793, -0.6855749487876892, -0.39585253596305847, 0.16690893471240997, 0.6527791619300842, -0.5759754776954651, -0.2757795751094818, 0.9342266917228699, 0.3327120840549469, 0.505108118057251, -0.3410854935646057, -0.38997071981430054, 0.4482809007167816, -0.396129310131073, -0.22434385120868683, -0.020444486290216446, -0.2646118998527527, 0.021651290357112885, 0.5430877208709717, -0.22709845006465912, 0.17584198713302612, -0.726570188999176, -0.8135412931442261, 0.20027869939804077, -0.43901491165161133, -0.47022080421447754, -0.6463937759399414, -0.5085018277168274, -0.21458700299263, 0.5629861354827881, 0.18212050199508667, 0.2815772294998169, 0.3315528631210327, 0.11167318373918533, -0.6811026334762573, -0.4729933738708496, -0.001764975837431848, 0.056839339435100555, 1.0876805782318115, 0.5736017227172852, -0.006263270042836666, 0.43701454997062683, 0.48306208848953247, 0.24732401967048645, 0.601462721824646, -0.6745890378952026, 0.06098105013370514, -0.12683363258838654, -0.4012644290924072, 0.2601480185985565, -1.263806939125061, -0.5858285427093506, 0.4633015990257263, -0.25288325548171997, 0.3201778531074524, 0.27769041061401367, 0.00644492544233799, 0.06553715467453003, -0.024756209924817085, -0.6028342247009277, 0.0484715960919857, -0.6021447777748108, -0.8024591207504272, 0.3102010488510132, -0.6926649212837219, -0.7451649904251099, 0.6018284559249878, -0.30922916531562805, -0.4616686999797821, -0.038814157247543335, 0.38039544224739075, 0.08862848579883575, 0.420889288187027, -0.6109037399291992, 0.9976872205734253, -0.3891575038433075, 0.3144714832305908, -0.6638562083244324, 0.11423779278993607, -0.6055511832237244, -0.013483087532222271, 0.16602815687656403, -0.05173230171203613, -0.5945083498954773, -0.5701397657394409, -0.0666034072637558, 0.13176189363002777, -0.2748805284500122, 0.3773660361766815, -0.987480640411377, -0.3660084307193756, -0.042580511420965195, -0.4165153503417969, 0.21418496966362, 0.42375993728637695, -0.07814792543649673, 0.05485580861568451, 0.3704710006713867, -0.972172200679779, 0.9217628836631775, 0.21180637180805206, 0.5979841351509094, -0.8830475807189941, 0.49553894996643066, -0.46518003940582275, -0.2696269154548645, 0.28316327929496765, 0.4872734248638153, -0.243661567568779, -0.03341759368777275, -0.30693408846855164, -0.14455285668373108, 0.08763846755027771, -0.211338073015213, -0.11394726485013962, -0.03883196786046028, -0.8978886008262634, -0.6439334750175476, 0.540884792804718, -0.29593709111213684, -0.10049431771039963, 0.5659537315368652, -0.0503566674888134, -0.3571135997772217, 0.07144136726856232, 0.17145779728889465, -0.5484497547149658, -0.1460869163274765, 0.6831547617912292, -0.9630118012428284, 0.6409096717834473, -0.4927455186843872, 0.16582109034061432, -0.9168075919151306, 0.2965170741081238, -0.6591803431510925, -0.21923565864562988, 0.3682437241077423, 1.1080397367477417, 0.46552711725234985, -0.7786375284194946, 0.990361213684082, 0.6141913533210754, 0.24228549003601074, 0.8941693305969238, 0.5352001786231995, -0.2554025948047638, -0.43988579511642456, -0.5119279026985168, -0.8780966997146606, 0.8275829553604126, -0.23955155909061432, -0.4424537420272827, -0.4988088309764862, -0.5856214761734009, -0.477864146232605, 0.11072807759046555, 0.18045610189437866, 0.3553500175476074, -0.10321879386901855, 0.32283347845077515, 0.007957026362419128, 0.47077009081840515, 0.1643732488155365, -0.11495990306138992, 0.3620395362377167, -0.46144911646842957, -0.2290390431880951, 0.5386102199554443, -0.1426125466823578, -1.0041818618774414, 0.04928998649120331, 0.682828962802887, 0.36933133006095886, -0.5255085229873657, 0.8136546611785889, -0.4642568528652191, -0.35951656103134155, -0.20123012363910675, -0.5029784440994263, 0.1596122533082962, 0.4426042139530182, 0.9039360284805298, -0.33600813150405884, -0.04543923959136009, -0.14948120713233948, 0.9416196346282959, -0.5138592720031738, 0.015904152765870094, 0.5480119585990906, -0.44838064908981323, -0.2174566686153412, 0.3710111677646637, 0.19156712293624878, -0.6236793398857117, -0.695401668548584, -1.0414313077926636, -0.1977035254240036, 0.36025121808052063, -0.5238543748855591, 0.31640344858169556, -0.18115870654582977, -0.6483821868896484, 0.5586317777633667, 0.8723004460334778, 0.2691640555858612, -0.2053004801273346, -0.10669497400522232, -1.2815628051757812, -0.20152530074119568, -0.17349232733249664, 1.273024559020996, -0.2945411801338196, -0.493645042181015, -0.7415426969528198, -0.5671997666358948, -1.0788966417312622, -0.03966248780488968, 0.6433377265930176, -0.38916027545928955, 0.583231508731842, -0.18563716113567352, 0.24688002467155457, 1.0101155042648315, 0.41918718814849854, 0.3381829559803009, -0.5303976535797119, -0.14315195381641388, -1.0736252069473267, -0.2774331271648407, -0.1949676126241684, 0.03409907966852188, 0.3244374096393585, -0.509205162525177, 0.6314300298690796, -0.2167530208826065, -0.2153947949409485, -0.7015444040298462, -1.0510714054107666, -0.01693623699247837, -1.1099865436553955, -0.1481998711824417, 0.07257971167564392, -0.5481718182563782, -0.6116491556167603, 0.6241777539253235, -0.05567771941423416, -0.5916491150856018, -0.537288248538971, 0.2543289363384247, 0.9020106196403503, 0.11581628769636154, -0.28196147084236145, -0.9498693346977234, -1.0050866603851318, 0.3532625734806061, -0.4440706670284271, 0.070327028632164, -0.18665467202663422, 0.6047738790512085, -0.2064305990934372, 0.05267448350787163, -0.2121698558330536, 1.2050065994262695, 0.005066950339823961, -0.5663335919380188, 0.11307347565889359, -0.09000139683485031, -0.3696014881134033, 0.2142038494348526, -0.24749532341957092, 0.11795338988304138, -0.3038777709007263, -0.26788464188575745, 0.30937227606773376, 0.19615201652050018, -0.8001357913017273, 0.2799699604511261, 0.5615215301513672, -0.002454996109008789, -0.0008378613274544477, -0.5456528067588806, 0.08836261928081512, 1.094085454940796, -1.371254801750183, 0.6641483306884766, -0.10063183307647705, 0.12512315809726715, 0.01629384607076645, 0.24021044373512268, -0.18448157608509064, 0.5110812783241272, -0.0927475094795227, 1.178823709487915, -0.07664703577756882, -0.703148603439331, 0.6482283473014832, 0.16488294303417206, -0.6799094676971436, -0.1447533220052719, 0.008793856017291546, -0.1059097871184349, 0.4426853060722351, 0.24753694236278534, -0.7354378700256348, 0.3001088500022888, 0.433440238237381, -0.15655091404914856, -0.7737554907798767, -0.7013474702835083, -0.08575409650802612, -0.12384490668773651, 0.17715106904506683, -0.7214990854263306, -0.4002915918827057, -0.5847314596176147, -0.4041580855846405, 0.3657779097557068, -0.10803542286157608, -0.26063284277915955, -0.14418098330497742, -1.040861964225769, -0.24615976214408875, -0.30579718947410583, -0.06715745478868484, 0.3300405740737915, -0.2602844834327698, 0.5017597079277039, -0.3893357217311859, 0.1567482352256775, -0.02074391581118107, -0.29507189989089966, -1.0734316110610962, -0.1662990301847458, -0.5907871127128601, 0.4805906414985657, 0.0027815040666610003, -0.5327973365783691, -0.3282325565814972, 0.5053121447563171, 0.11551429331302643, -0.32685208320617676, -0.40411287546157837, -0.08743437379598618, -0.7031069397926331, 0.31201112270355225, 0.19505305588245392, -0.46428313851356506, 0.0292512159794569, 0.6162408590316772, -0.13489960134029388, -0.27571412920951843, 1.1172393560409546, 0.33478254079818726, -0.1476300209760666, -0.5902073979377747, -0.7615758776664734, 0.700928807258606, 0.13568006455898285, -0.5601266622543335, 0.7663772106170654, -0.24718166887760162, 0.19513970613479614, 0.46482664346694946, -0.5039454102516174, -0.2959216833114624, -0.284720778465271, 0.7723162770271301, 0.7054179310798645, 0.4275800585746765, 0.21810705959796906, 0.4314916133880615, 0.22037479281425476, -0.14004944264888763, 0.47892066836357117, 0.21812757849693298, -0.2691018283367157, 0.8052247166633606, -0.3528795540332794, 0.8036864399909973, 0.0767141804099083, 0.18587437272071838, -0.055362947285175323, -0.28753793239593506, 0.11118576675653458, 0.4115421175956726, -0.25278162956237793, 0.08634517341852188, -0.6491315364837646, -0.022375019267201424, -0.555301308631897, -0.39190471172332764, 0.09173174947500229, -0.06541203707456589, 0.016021322458982468, 0.26516038179397583, 0.21195879578590393, -0.02136186882853508, 0.8419728875160217, 0.4231005012989044, 0.45424503087997437, 0.3410325050354004, -0.11542737483978271, 1.3825421333312988, 0.23035508394241333, 0.37254461646080017, 0.7392886281013489, -0.4668084979057312, 0.04660586640238762, 0.8246893882751465, -1.0733007192611694, 0.16461633145809174, -0.02612246200442314, -0.23294149339199066, -0.09281004220247269, -0.23379671573638916, 0.3685908019542694, -0.41319024562835693, 0.06365259736776352, 0.9110792875289917, -0.4939538240432739, 0.14681647717952728, 0.4961422383785248, -0.05098198354244232, 0.07198069989681244, 1.0807764530181885, -0.12457764893770218, -0.7969685792922974, 1.2377150058746338, 0.9591698050498962, 0.04634037986397743, 0.21428517997264862, 0.3174213469028473, -0.4236927032470703, -0.5763581395149231, 0.5421377420425415, -0.563888669013977, 0.9379358887672424, -0.15768544375896454, -0.3992675542831421, 0.4386522173881531, -0.1893802285194397, -0.20276053249835968, 0.11453800648450851, -0.30796533823013306, 0.12557798624038696, 0.09166886657476425, -0.18863068521022797, 1.1562453508377075, 0.33230382204055786, -0.10461631417274475, -0.2786996066570282, -0.4076153039932251, 0.4607197046279907, -0.6609193086624146, 0.1892424374818802, 0.2632974684238434, 0.8349239826202393, 0.30375149846076965, 0.22956669330596924, -0.16339918971061707, -0.6143231391906738, -1.0162816047668457, -0.05561911687254906, -1.1372994184494019, 0.27102962136268616, 0.25751549005508423, 0.9088410139083862, -0.3270084857940674, -0.4700976014137268, 0.5143988728523254, -0.13840033113956451, 0.8938666582107544, 0.009998919442296028, 0.26531729102134705, 0.6483129858970642, -0.20111292600631714, -0.6604657173156738, -0.1104934960603714, 0.38448649644851685, -0.28187480568885803, 0.3027809262275696, -0.3405369520187378, -0.040737539529800415, 0.5554948449134827, -0.04093533009290695, -0.7740100026130676, 0.24817773699760437, 0.41934433579444885, -0.8431697487831116, -0.2595846951007843, -0.3998454511165619, -0.605410635471344, 0.0011980083072558045, -0.36799103021621704, -0.3614290654659271, 0.42195311188697815, 0.27215415239334106, 0.49187979102134705, -0.3432489335536957, 4.039095401763916, 0.5516576170921326, 0.6228341460227966, -0.14840848743915558, 0.26172924041748047, 0.15790657699108124, 0.49574142694473267, -0.22999407351016998, 0.4875970184803009, -0.13211651146411896, -0.4639923572540283, 0.3929326832294464, -0.09527217596769333, -0.3899741768836975, -0.8952429890632629, 0.8583902716636658, -0.4494406282901764, 0.05033431947231293, -0.6438957452774048, -0.5377312898635864, 0.037497613579034805, 0.3251382112503052, -0.10616064816713333, -0.7460424304008484, -0.07929154485464096, -0.2225194126367569, 0.2710570991039276, -0.6297943592071533, -0.7887079119682312, -0.5815463662147522, -1.054352045059204, -0.7445700168609619, -0.27484363317489624, -0.4444866478443146, -0.05647255480289459, 0.5015156269073486, 0.7685368061065674, 0.16158699989318848, 0.4236784279346466, -0.04368499666452408, 0.24739420413970947, -0.5015444159507751, -0.4087144136428833, -0.24939201772212982, -1.3893120288848877, 0.10364136099815369, -0.5148181319236755, 0.9317399859428406, 0.43167948722839355, -0.2944732904434204, 0.5256705284118652, -0.2283673733472824, 0.2351953536272049, 0.2191808670759201, -0.7609462141990662, 0.03617813438177109, -0.6444353461265564, -0.5505706071853638, -0.2121509462594986, -0.0562618225812912, 0.8463217616081238, 0.0873701423406601, 0.1185813844203949, -0.14979484677314758, -0.801961362361908, 0.698995053768158, 0.27262890338897705, 0.46214890480041504, -0.06566021591424942, -0.33563685417175293, -0.18796628713607788, -0.1471901684999466, -0.8088594079017639, 0.47785046696662903, 0.13881182670593262, 0.2193189114332199, -0.5164926052093506, 0.6099624633789062, 0.1629546731710434, 0.06541115045547485, 0.07089819014072418, -0.12872591614723206, -0.8035563826560974, 0.6199401021003723, 0.298689603805542, 0.8153707385063171, -0.10913532972335815, -0.39023083448410034, -0.20524753630161285, 0.7512995600700378, 0.2835674583911896, 1.5051043033599854, 0.6382014751434326, 0.10831547528505325, -0.9295797348022461 ]
Vortex Line Fluctuations in Model High Temperature Superconductors
We carry out Monte Carlo simulations of the uniformly frustrated 3d XY model as a model for vortex line fluctuations in a high Tc superconductor. A density of vortex lines of f=1/25 is considered. We find two sharp phase transitions. The low T phase is an ordered vortex line lattice. The high T normal phase is a vortex line liquid with much entangling, cutting, and loop excitations. An intermediate phase is found which is characterized as a vortex line liquid of disentangled lines. In this phase, the system displays superconducting properties in the direction parallel to the magnetic field, but normal behavior in planes perpendicular to the magnetic field.
Ying-Hong Li (ITP Utrecht) and S. Teitel (U of Rochester)
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207008
cond-mat/9207009
[ -0.21807368099689484, 0.745307981967926, 0.04565451666712761, 0.47116926312446594, -0.11594191938638687, -0.03984050452709198, 0.3784814476966858, -0.4830973148345947, -0.1074971854686737, 0.7942889928817749, 0.2604009807109833, 0.08494126796722412, 0.40350139141082764, -1.41531240940094, -0.1896122843027115, 0.20893219113349915, -0.509965717792511, -0.16737769544124603, -1.5227609872817993, -0.3406830430030823, -0.3012814521789551, -0.17827913165092468, -0.9842608571052551, -1.0661484003067017, -0.2668740153312683, 0.00018816399096976966, -0.00486123887822032, 0.3317267596721649, 0.61285799741745, 0.5281721353530884, -0.39725664258003235, -0.3982173800468445, 0.20566435158252716, -1.4943634271621704, 0.07269740849733353, 0.10641215741634369, 0.16350850462913513, -0.06208613142371178, 0.6845468282699585, -0.5897279381752014, 0.9756946563720703, 0.36004936695098877, 0.20775456726551056, -0.1911582201719284, -0.014202792197465897, 0.1912926435470581, -0.5049108266830444, -0.8336499333381653, -0.8391420841217041, -1.4409266710281372, 0.03528529405593872, 0.7722869515419006, 0.6987443566322327, -0.23591549694538116, -0.4130443036556244, 0.1250448375940323, -0.36423081159591675, -0.31725844740867615, -0.7146169543266296, -0.44801095128059387, 0.28311580419540405, 0.123890720307827, 0.6736264228820801, 0.033666059374809265, 0.07044488936662674, 0.9930152297019958, 0.007887771353125572, 0.9704004526138306, 0.05151423066854477, 0.5944848656654358, -0.5760625004768372, 0.285320520401001, 0.029588710516691208, -0.45775869488716125, -0.36097079515457153, 0.16293780505657196, 0.059119757264852524, -0.5640765428543091, -0.5494548678398132, -0.8113853335380554, 0.2732796370983124, 0.5755987763404846, 0.11216606944799423, 0.7393114566802979, -0.11040198802947998, -0.2980228364467621, -0.042960815131664276, -0.6962380409240723, 0.3888947069644928, 0.00628825556486845, -0.07570962607860565, 1.3311400413513184, -0.10846817493438721, 0.40896710753440857, 0.20911674201488495, 0.4548989236354828, 0.004942592699080706, 0.3589989244937897, 0.4295036196708679, 0.6728777289390564, 0.5554172396659851, 0.9998423457145691, -0.7987396717071533, 0.030080243945121765, -0.43436771631240845, 0.6971704959869385, 0.06291742622852325, 0.23744529485702515, 0.591098427772522, -0.6083944439888, 0.09656967967748642, 0.711200475692749, 0.291419118642807, 0.6421532034873962, -0.5996375679969788, 0.1526346355676651, 0.27561628818511963, -0.3723278045654297, -1.0295941829681396, -0.476767361164093, -0.7219418287277222, 0.891335129737854, 0.45404380559921265, 0.5706636309623718, -0.873384416103363, -0.8660233020782471, 0.7418741583824158, 0.028340307995676994, 0.35667040944099426, -0.42941588163375854, -0.08566813170909882, 0.2162521779537201, 0.06302428990602493, 1.2318506240844727, -0.5694787502288818, 0.12316852807998657, 0.2233937829732895, 0.11399485170841217, 0.2605779767036438, 0.224421426653862, 0.5215463638305664, -0.5843331813812256, -0.23891223967075348, 1.0924925804138184, -0.5029454231262207, 0.0004015842278022319, 0.6723380088806152, 0.3741987943649292, -0.16029863059520721, 0.423473596572876, -0.5210393667221069, -0.5536351799964905, 0.1400921642780304, -0.26940739154815674, 0.7097105383872986, 0.49091440439224243, -0.5863036513328552, 0.27006176114082336, -0.31957393884658813, -0.47380587458610535, 0.2855183780193329, 0.14148448407649994, 0.48324283957481384, 0.5221922993659973, -0.37007227540016174, -0.11698611080646515, -0.29554545879364014, -0.9167025089263916, 0.7138729691505432, -0.19902384281158447, -0.4507823586463928, 0.10358882695436478, 0.4307953715324402, 0.1546792834997177, 0.5194171071052551, 0.6970113515853882, 0.4652688503265381, 0.4082725942134857, -0.48346006870269775, 0.259284645318985, 0.7241600155830383, -0.06790588796138763, 1.0948543548583984, 0.2550158202648163, -0.28355637192726135, 0.18869085609912872, -0.3975330591201782, -0.4021614193916321, 0.06895069032907486, -0.0637517049908638, -0.034991100430488586, 0.06597927957773209, 0.1883508563041687, 0.49355635046958923, -0.8065620064735413, -0.04270916432142258, -0.43390366435050964, 0.04867294803261757, -0.13166707754135132, -0.7005091905593872, -0.010923025198280811, 1.1142174005508423, -1.271801471710205, 0.6542432904243469, -1.4883610010147095, 0.04427311569452286, 1.4947580099105835, 0.5025806427001953, -0.5985420346260071, -0.10908429324626923, 0.7279651165008545, 0.07014986872673035, -0.10194665938615799, 0.5869194865226746, 0.5297234654426575, -0.04872945696115494, -0.14987605810165405, 0.16305974125862122, 0.024882368743419647, 0.2211785763502121, 0.008634493686258793, 0.1333230584859848, -0.6510220766067505, 0.6690530180931091, 0.1153196468949318, -0.29309406876564026, 0.0426705963909626, 0.5169602036476135, -0.22798945009708405, -0.6615692377090454, -0.4281606376171112, 0.6928424835205078, 0.16750532388687134, 0.02710891142487526, 1.0529762506484985, 0.1203833594918251, -0.21220675110816956, 0.7515200972557068, 0.43386703729629517, -0.46630367636680603, -0.181309312582016, -0.07889201492071152, 0.550571084022522, 0.0037893312983214855, -0.3541968762874603, -0.4571209251880646, -0.17267481982707977, -0.22876471281051636, -0.676514208316803, 0.13842743635177612, -0.30999523401260376, 0.5722559094429016, -0.05912698432803154, 0.7332060933113098, -0.8781926035881042, -0.5989155173301697, -0.3853227198123932, 0.8055778741836548, -0.35314851999282837, -0.6024600267410278, 0.42637205123901367, -0.020359843969345093, -0.32876941561698914, -0.1019650548696518, 0.9490878582000732, 0.4362560510635376, -0.2516500651836395, -0.2396443635225296, 0.12104484438896179, -0.6382917165756226, -0.9928513169288635, -0.7063065767288208, -0.48682743310928345, -0.22927747666835785, -0.8356469869613647, -0.28200623393058777, 0.6733223795890808, -0.8033240437507629, 0.5740974545478821, -0.6898133754730225, -0.16430389881134033, 0.12193562835454941, -0.6627668142318726, -0.32953035831451416, 0.1455286145210266, 0.0648902952671051, -0.8632298707962036, 0.643578290939331, -0.7335000038146973, 1.0696598291397095, -0.5456276535987854, -0.5205262303352356, 0.5728191137313843, -1.3580025434494019, 0.3159695267677307, -0.16218774020671844, -0.512586236000061, -0.04240388795733452, -0.05795987322926521, -0.3263605535030365, 0.09476760774850845, 0.03485403209924698, -0.6594089269638062, 0.18913809955120087, -0.08485046029090881, 1.0053609609603882, -0.2986670434474945, -0.019890855997800827, 0.5346582531929016, 0.37167268991470337, -0.573786735534668, 0.27287718653678894, -0.41451138257980347, -0.3088141083717346, -0.1277625858783722, 0.4944759011268616, 0.8701063394546509, 0.039248909801244736, -0.021821681410074234, 0.03639700263738632, -0.8150972127914429, 0.21014311909675598, 0.4697076976299286, -0.785560667514801, -0.1508198380470276, 0.8070313930511475, 0.1951719969511032, -0.21182583272457123, 0.042194005101919174, -1.2959365844726562, -0.13189147412776947, -0.28512710332870483, 0.051435437053442, 1.2100696563720703, -0.2914927899837494, -0.4309121370315552, -0.15871667861938477, 0.22809332609176636, 0.4707264304161072, -0.11093524098396301, 0.24807876348495483, -0.09320343285799026, 0.7898989319801331, 0.16216614842414856, 0.0679277554154396, -0.08353810757398605, 0.2580135464668274, -0.2587927579879761, -0.35350918769836426, 0.04914456605911255, -1.057074785232544, -0.18836931884288788, 0.31632402539253235, -0.09618198871612549, -0.13538412749767303, 0.7364215850830078, -0.09641983360052109, -0.3263304829597473, -0.3507510721683502, 0.036503709852695465, 0.41260167956352234, 0.9691542387008667, 0.3372748792171478, -0.037383414804935455, -1.0242152214050293, -0.35513633489608765, -0.32235071063041687, -0.06470753252506256, 0.10724560171365738, -0.02004951424896717, 0.24832554161548615, 0.8439072370529175, -0.035852983593940735, 0.12448590993881226, -0.07879307866096497, 0.04461374133825302, 0.2833295464515686, 0.41075339913368225, 1.0391700267791748, -0.684246301651001, -0.21768975257873535, 0.18290534615516663, 1.2434375286102295, 0.10821852087974548, 0.711669921875, 0.3171798586845398, -0.04400604963302612, 0.40031376481056213, -0.1540055125951767, -0.8459631204605103, -0.021143104881048203, 0.07433924823999405, 0.11604693531990051, -0.2358960509300232, -0.04872846230864525, 0.3063644766807556, -0.03636743873357773, 0.3175892233848572, 0.07849529385566711, 0.05754128098487854, 0.11055614054203033, 0.3832594156265259, 0.7280039191246033, 0.31279563903808594, -0.4285195469856262, -0.8252077102661133, -0.5921208262443542, -0.3074277639389038, 0.2589934170246124, -0.018023241311311722, -0.3865661919116974, -0.42264267802238464, -0.3968425691127777, 0.5083785057067871, 0.4042934775352478, 0.603313148021698, -0.12298000603914261, 0.18511702120304108, 0.05069343000650406, 0.6984735727310181, -0.5826005339622498, -0.46941614151000977, 0.7033371329307556, 0.16737335920333862, 0.9812332987785339, -1.0643781423568726, 0.6999390721321106, -1.0032191276550293, 0.20961208641529083, 0.11427783966064453, -0.17567500472068787, -1.0864222049713135, -0.27285853028297424, 0.46221619844436646, -0.5187570452690125, 0.3457053601741791, 0.9513884782791138, 0.8688030242919922, 0.07909660786390305, -0.34459182620048523, -0.36197763681411743, 0.5704638957977295, -0.9121967554092407, -0.5299383401870728, -0.24543017148971558, 0.22131216526031494, -0.13863614201545715, 0.5008466243743896, -0.559347927570343, -0.5503783822059631, 0.09100257605314255, -0.2961921691894531, 0.6779358386993408, 0.10901971906423569, -0.8177139163017273, 0.1256488859653473, -0.24458158016204834, 0.11324571073055267, 1.1149870157241821, -0.2225295752286911, -0.007762667257338762, 0.29427266120910645, 0.012041511945426464, -0.7761028409004211, -0.7858522534370422, -0.1340336799621582, 0.021957840770483017, 0.2546996772289276, -0.04003994166851044, -0.1352928727865219, 0.3432285785675049, 0.34982895851135254, -0.08194541186094284, 0.5376812219619751, 0.23318947851657867, -0.12997660040855408, -0.22840552031993866, -0.18878011405467987, -0.5398913025856018, -0.878928542137146, -0.17981009185314178, 0.5651097893714905, -0.4151918590068817, 0.5143299698829651, 0.09838522225618362, -0.7178333401679993, -0.19175437092781067, 0.24522805213928223, -0.9255810379981995, 0.7089300155639648, -0.06237048655748367, -0.598796546459198, -0.038869645446538925, -0.9966524839401245, 0.21906843781471252, 0.115436851978302, 0.21106484532356262, -0.3395409882068634, 0.6201856732368469, -0.41141703724861145, -0.37478625774383545, 0.25797608494758606, -0.28058749437332153, 0.9547380208969116, -0.02994687668979168, 0.05031369626522064, -0.7562160491943359, -0.19646558165550232, -0.8269577026367188, -0.02952684834599495, 0.4930569529533386, -0.1782480776309967, -0.04983670637011528, 0.15645642578601837, -0.11338701844215393, 0.5536778569221497, -0.08810276538133621, 0.06242360919713974, -0.8467988967895508, 0.3340049684047699, 0.20516151189804077, -0.16349324584007263, -0.01904866099357605, 0.6497764587402344, 0.23227356374263763, -0.030184976756572723, 0.2913408875465393, -0.43307405710220337, 0.23569515347480774, -0.02281641773879528, 1.0789592266082764, -0.9668799042701721, -0.5479957461357117, -1.0849274396896362, -0.6323347091674805, -0.3733231723308563, 0.5197787284851074, -0.6403229832649231, -0.41049349308013916, -0.6648849248886108, -0.29317066073417664, 0.11868944019079208, 0.16671264171600342, 0.12241686135530472, -0.6226716041564941, -1.0229692459106445, -0.4637506902217865, 1.0870248079299927, -0.5854575037956238, -0.33547019958496094, 1.0797067880630493, 0.010856478475034237, 0.0904240682721138, 0.6978154182434082, 0.6615620851516724, -0.5391197204589844, -0.526793897151947, 0.6936514377593994, -0.2840697765350342, 0.4649411141872406, -0.5318533182144165, 0.6121404767036438, -1.1409779787063599, 1.0918720960617065, -0.2674471437931061, 0.20827017724514008, -0.11356652528047562, -0.0006949256639927626, 0.6846866607666016, -0.6223211884498596, 0.21807347238063812, 0.8577361106872559, 0.2329198122024536, 0.7813906073570251, 0.7123402953147888, -0.06861928850412369, -0.837521493434906, -0.7897585034370422, -0.8355320692062378, 0.7433203458786011, -0.0033563862089067698, 0.012756400741636753, -1.0732004642486572, -0.6743771433830261, -0.38291454315185547, 0.08908412605524063, 0.8408801555633545, 0.4407053291797638, 0.28991302847862244, 0.39896026253700256, -0.15244294703006744, 0.24270202219486237, -0.19108039140701294, 0.09886561334133148, 0.8219327330589294, -0.7048336267471313, -0.34018728137016296, 0.40207329392433167, -0.7878627181053162, -0.9495079517364502, -0.4459635317325592, 0.6928751468658447, 0.16933409869670868, -0.46557387709617615, 0.6084811687469482, -0.46141400933265686, -0.3787258565425873, -0.22826573252677917, -0.06870412081480026, -0.0793396532535553, 0.6821334362030029, 0.8864741325378418, 0.11818528920412064, 0.0022182296961545944, -0.22747907042503357, 0.14158648252487183, -0.10796555876731873, -0.08748804032802582, 0.03307719901204109, -0.5192385315895081, -0.22734037041664124, 0.12784934043884277, 0.508798360824585, -0.6900379061698914, -0.9841026663780212, -0.6213213205337524, 0.21221210062503815, -0.4317207336425781, -1.2244312763214111, -0.40548786520957947, 0.0690462663769722, -0.3911886215209961, 0.27608609199523926, 0.7979481816291809, 0.9394556879997253, 0.32023781538009644, 0.1704493910074234, -0.4830678701400757, -0.04539081081748009, 0.09570135921239853, 1.5617495775222778, 0.17133189737796783, -0.9497748613357544, -0.13581755757331848, -0.8738933801651001, -1.0900362730026245, 0.10651008039712906, 0.8542138338088989, 0.1619839370250702, 0.6334068179130554, -0.04412131384015083, 0.19848115742206573, 1.0776304006576538, 0.8122705817222595, 0.12119023501873016, 0.16242435574531555, -0.1302550882101059, -1.1659587621688843, -0.28222498297691345, 0.0674070343375206, 0.2035559117794037, 0.12160568684339523, -0.3359552323818207, 0.34617307782173157, -0.4709952175617218, 0.42992278933525085, -0.34441545605659485, -0.7497383952140808, 0.07916533946990967, -0.38987526297569275, -0.07701683789491653, -0.09466353058815002, 0.14528656005859375, -0.09340883791446686, 0.7239121794700623, -0.4750765264034271, -0.3601836562156677, -1.096006989479065, 0.5050537586212158, 0.3639777600765228, 0.1250556856393814, -0.03815024718642235, -0.38153836131095886, -0.7678727507591248, 0.06456223875284195, -0.3133834898471832, -0.4045509696006775, -0.2921147644519806, -0.1725115329027176, -0.16675812005996704, 0.14456282556056976, -0.2258545458316803, 0.3859666585922241, -0.3177494406700134, -0.47349289059638977, -0.16214770078659058, 0.6118567585945129, -0.5772026181221008, 0.4707254469394684, -0.028435321524739265, 0.1508294939994812, 0.38622236251831055, 0.46232596039772034, 0.35354068875312805, 0.6600062251091003, -1.0046594142913818, 0.8208803534507751, 0.5501469969749451, 0.48847779631614685, 0.05639657378196716, -0.06521744281053543, -0.09085922688245773, 1.0761109590530396, -0.6621478199958801, 0.41152891516685486, -0.0378437377512455, 0.5051594376564026, 0.25862208008766174, -0.05502801015973091, -0.34394630789756775, 0.28312137722969055, -0.11135832220315933, 0.5086256861686707, -0.19573689997196198, 0.14141210913658142, 0.13134507834911346, 0.2819359600543976, -0.27527230978012085, -0.3965120315551758, 0.9055154323577881, -0.5248717665672302, 0.0025171118322759867, 1.0304216146469116, -0.8222646713256836, 0.7553644180297852, 0.10365401208400726, 0.07579557597637177, -0.5196966528892517, -0.3441142737865448, -0.606809139251709, 0.8407798409461975, -0.023016298189759254, -0.1592639535665512, 0.8364170789718628, -0.3149119019508362, -0.6860277652740479, 0.7616704106330872, -0.34916380047798157, -0.7989188432693481, 0.02752797305583954, -0.7507869005203247, -0.3597879111766815, -0.7928315997123718, -0.44198110699653625, 0.5703560709953308, -0.5171040296554565, 0.2628423571586609, 0.020673029124736786, -0.11101949959993362, -0.3299499750137329, -0.3417091369628906, -0.8520971536636353, 0.1739853173494339, -0.7708166837692261, 0.4337303936481476, -0.6846938133239746, -0.9946777820587158, -0.6982068419456482, 0.7620689868927002, -0.22940215468406677, -0.3852931261062622, -0.5315549373626709, 0.04195690527558327, -0.3082212209701538, 0.2571907341480255, 0.3820090889930725, -0.691491425037384, 0.09734556823968887, 0.6277565956115723, -0.10815385729074478, -0.41594916582107544, 0.808838963508606, 0.4260253310203552, 0.22056682407855988, -0.33366912603378296, -0.2589320242404938, 1.0849336385726929, -0.004371383227407932, -0.23385803401470184, 1.0498930215835571, 0.24815499782562256, 0.5846284031867981, -0.15369533002376556, -0.9476675391197205, -0.07948543131351471, 0.32846349477767944, 0.41353920102119446, 0.8969011306762695, 0.4226011335849762, 0.38658902049064636, 0.7154785990715027, 0.3829004764556885, -0.5239115357398987, -0.5151029825210571, 0.15725459158420563, -0.7988105416297913, 0.4454752206802368, -0.501436173915863, 0.7488981485366821, 0.2761288583278656, 0.6015269160270691, -0.05402978137135506, -0.6551709175109863, -0.18551518023014069, -0.42687854170799255, -0.5466360449790955, -0.12537378072738647, -0.3801276683807373, -0.059526581317186356, -0.3877812325954437, 0.2622852027416229, 0.1303294152021408, -0.34800803661346436, -0.2967076599597931, 0.31455162167549133, 0.5177514553070068, 0.5592888593673706, -0.03227168694138527, 0.6240819096565247, -0.3618503212928772, 0.6745025515556335, 0.38890060782432556, 0.8107204437255859, 0.41818633675575256, 0.402545690536499, 0.20041663944721222, -1.1430120468139648, 0.026470696553587914, 0.4166632890701294, -0.577503502368927, 0.5256918668746948, -0.2600582540035248, -0.16880486905574799, -0.20117689669132233, 0.29771196842193604, 0.7355479001998901, -1.0725427865982056, 0.0073688155971467495, 0.9732077717781067, -0.21661823987960815, -0.055908411741256714, 0.8268212080001831, 0.15448980033397675, 0.3615224361419678, 1.1134066581726074, 0.09664902091026306, -0.08223965018987656, 0.8203660249710083, 0.4948412775993347, 0.07119474560022354, 0.20135419070720673, -0.22713403403759003, -0.9693326950073242, 0.05812711641192436, -0.28921034932136536, -0.6790011525154114, 0.4408201575279236, -0.8144120573997498, -0.07296149432659149, -0.3686779737472534, -0.012649966403841972, 0.04322999343276024, 0.11994393914937973, 0.6291333436965942, -0.035911109298467636, -0.5105518698692322, -0.2646835446357727, 0.6320602297782898, -0.005330493673682213, -0.32493942975997925, -0.9283546805381775, 0.05097274109721184, 0.16530807316303253, -0.7154403328895569, -0.20272457599639893, 0.22573520243167877, 0.4388531744480133, 0.18201923370361328, -0.6122883558273315, -0.3984651267528534, -0.33159345388412476, -0.259030818939209, -0.19768765568733215, -0.3561309576034546, 0.11012357473373413, 0.12178404629230499, 0.37341535091400146, -0.02777191810309887, -0.3149053752422333, 0.01863556168973446, 0.3138529658317566, 0.6692548394203186, 0.3233984410762787, 1.1580133438110352, 0.5945435166358948, -0.08154182136058807, -0.4790891408920288, 0.5990278124809265, 0.4423119127750397, -1.0791983604431152, 0.9309305548667908, -0.35650238394737244, -0.41015756130218506, 0.3826494514942169, -0.2584001421928406, -0.12103725224733353, 0.03508840501308441, 0.3412705063819885, -0.38868141174316406, -0.7912828922271729, -0.13065005838871002, -0.6486848592758179, -0.32805418968200684, -0.5004369616508484, 0.735814094543457, 0.5495433807373047, -0.06795796751976013, 0.15091517567634583, -0.7117176055908203, 4.0796637535095215, 0.3703080117702484, 0.4558798670768738, -0.1162213608622551, 0.2731870710849762, 0.683464527130127, 0.04423241689801216, -0.053211357444524765, 0.29950377345085144, -0.7163143754005432, -0.17120598256587982, 0.4518970549106598, 0.1821841299533844, -0.020644498988986015, -0.030864456668496132, 0.7835681438446045, 0.12283385545015335, -0.407084584236145, -0.06937236338853836, -0.5401708483695984, -0.3407440185546875, -0.06568361818790436, 0.41285404562950134, -0.11347898095846176, 0.43451011180877686, 0.6274875402450562, -0.10126562416553497, -0.2047625631093979, -0.5617157816886902, -1.0775104761123657, -0.6448285579681396, -0.65743088722229, 0.07035516202449799, -0.9831792712211609, -0.43733522295951843, 0.7817021608352661, -0.00788013357669115, -0.11869002878665924, -0.17693060636520386, -0.2864148020744324, -0.08091849088668823, -0.14302146434783936, -0.011409147642552853, 0.07702761143445969, -0.6080877184867859, 0.4655914902687073, -0.22303736209869385, 1.3249684572219849, 0.7568784952163696, -0.9212989211082458, -0.1270238757133484, 0.08730970323085785, -0.04373573884367943, 0.09635672718286514, -0.8277221918106079, -0.27704375982284546, -0.48122555017471313, -0.6070643663406372, -0.6387532353401184, -0.24907056987285614, 1.1210441589355469, -0.06153165549039841, -0.5215849876403809, -0.43365922570228577, -0.6828808784484863, 0.18022316694259644, 0.8536245226860046, -0.06648977100849152, -0.1147463247179985, 0.46245574951171875, -0.44583988189697266, 0.2715141773223877, -0.24992378056049347, 0.11752920597791672, 0.27769243717193604, 0.12321862578392029, 0.38920262455940247, 0.5304619669914246, 0.39712581038475037, -0.14567896723747253, -0.422858327627182, 0.004825822077691555, -0.7301477789878845, 0.6616224050521851, -0.34946921467781067, 0.7914953827857971, -0.3740687370300293, -0.6528825163841248, -0.42541638016700745, 0.9596315622329712, 0.2778741121292114, 0.9834561944007874, -0.05807730555534363, -0.07565052807331085, -1.0988483428955078 ]
Modification of the Magnetic Flux-Line Interaction at a Superconductor's Surface
The pair interaction between magnetic flux lines in a semi-infinite slab of an anisotropic type-II superconductor in an external field is derived in the London limit. The case where the applied field is normal to the superconductor/vacuum interface is considered. The presence of stray fields near the surface leads to an additional contribution to the repulsive interaction between flux lines that vanishes exponentially with the distance from the interface. The pair interaction is used to obtain the continuum elastic energy of a distorted semi-infinite flux-line array. The presence of the superconductor/vacuum interface yields surface contributions to the compressional and tilt elastic constants.
M. Cristina Marchetti (Syracuse Univ.)
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207009
cond-mat/9207010
[ -0.6840425133705139, 0.3884814977645874, 0.24616843461990356, -0.1468457132577896, 0.6355047225952148, 0.09676019102334976, -0.42656806111335754, -0.05838591232895851, -0.3349418342113495, 1.0757291316986084, 0.8744890093803406, -0.1465487778186798, -0.6733970046043396, -0.6457416415214539, -0.47034481167793274, 0.8429747819900513, -0.3614712357521057, -1.146992802619934, -1.4423353672027588, 0.07738421112298965, 0.28008317947387695, -0.5082294940948486, -1.0412368774414062, -1.1778773069381714, -0.08575635403394699, 0.8393133878707886, 0.5031760931015015, 0.5049864053726196, 0.9758131504058838, 0.8698737025260925, 1.2302309274673462, -1.2957208156585693, 0.002036013174802065, -0.4737069010734558, 0.09052693098783493, 0.08115261793136597, 0.22425922751426697, -0.05064694955945015, 0.03847117722034454, -0.8213390707969666, 0.45723429322242737, -0.24749436974525452, 0.27820584177970886, 0.22606199979782104, 0.39709874987602234, -0.2816470265388489, 0.08589760959148407, 0.2403903752565384, 0.2637723982334137, -1.0893044471740723, -0.029145104810595512, -0.18498393893241882, -0.21197256445884705, -0.26640915870666504, -0.3303700089454651, -0.0881834402680397, -0.0017590977950021625, 0.13537007570266724, -0.4393886923789978, 0.08058033883571625, 0.358333945274353, 0.5596426725387573, 0.00972906593233347, -0.7277747392654419, -0.341850608587265, 0.3862239718437195, -0.25716280937194824, 0.07492583990097046, 0.26198863983154297, -1.3765506744384766, -0.3257065415382385, -0.1984550803899765, -0.22960005700588226, 0.09768325835466385, -0.8254660367965698, 1.317885160446167, -0.1968550980091095, -0.6823703646659851, -1.1090621948242188, -0.2656930685043335, -0.5012165307998657, -0.023416263982653618, -0.8424322605133057, 0.37025561928749084, -0.09300839155912399, -0.5993744730949402, 0.9304418563842773, -0.41970765590667725, 0.40398848056793213, -0.16247978806495667, 0.743012547492981, 0.8382001519203186, 0.28747716546058655, -0.6971727609634399, 0.49968671798706055, 0.2952636778354645, -0.04895734041929245, 0.3473532199859619, 0.5204028487205505, 0.6871867775917053, -0.6625697612762451, 0.6132489442825317, 0.025051837787032127, 1.2513011693954468, -0.38896098732948303, 0.18493527173995972, 0.10450834780931473, 0.21386833488941193, -0.34769898653030396, -0.9975864291191101, -0.3603544533252716, -0.19751131534576416, 0.6148489713668823, 0.6712265014648438, 0.18292906880378723, 0.7966071367263794, 0.1298638880252838, -0.3907966613769531, -0.6630568504333496, -0.3653382360935211, 0.22315849363803864, 0.11365453153848648, 0.6596306562423706, 0.39555492997169495, -0.0988737940788269, -0.4293656051158905, -0.47090789675712585, 0.39386412501335144, -0.8446521759033203, 0.14213982224464417, -0.42510440945625305, -0.3855425715446472, -0.28446298837661743, 0.4652126431465149, 0.07048464566469193, 0.495477557182312, -0.15752869844436646, 0.7948962450027466, 0.5712523460388184, -0.7001848816871643, 0.9950478076934814, -0.6106294989585876, 0.6859372854232788, 1.1151822805404663, -0.8019818663597107, 0.7336841225624084, 0.4959058463573456, 0.764861524105072, 0.3184680640697479, 0.4360085725784302, -0.3025241196155548, -0.1952947974205017, -0.3640454113483429, 0.6625795960426331, 0.3717378079891205, -0.08800216019153595, -1.1130282878875732, 0.6281408071517944, -0.6829783320426941, 0.5183929800987244, 0.1698603630065918, -0.06663528829813004, -0.2996126711368561, -0.12627072632312775, 0.009946257807314396, 0.02171831578016281, -0.5011898875236511, -0.9101669788360596, 0.7352350354194641, -0.14049610495567322, 0.13749031722545624, -0.7423503994941711, 0.1142844706773758, 0.4810274541378021, 0.469536691904068, 0.5976075530052185, 0.13317719101905823, -0.29440855979919434, 0.3741900324821472, -0.008811105042696, -0.26777413487434387, -0.4528278112411499, 0.9197221994400024, 0.7873938679695129, -0.05402247980237007, -0.48378467559814453, -0.22486986219882965, -0.06286002695560455, -0.3451046645641327, 0.49215978384017944, -0.05333874002099037, 0.9482532739639282, -0.4233262836933136, 0.38041168451309204, -0.48631593585014343, -0.005498859100043774, -0.5709868669509888, 0.4923800826072693, -0.7792803645133972, -0.5878453850746155, 0.18895958364009857, 0.26687341928482056, -1.1840784549713135, 0.1869417428970337, -0.6353562474250793, -0.2014199197292328, 0.3728351891040802, 0.2730364501476288, -0.6348823308944702, -0.35530129075050354, 0.5850846767425537, 0.2980489432811737, 0.056733641773462296, -0.06280384212732315, -0.044186148792505264, 0.11268629878759384, -0.04359589144587517, 0.5618546605110168, 0.5209969878196716, -0.03405006602406502, 0.36888599395751953, 0.5271243453025818, -0.47675731778144836, 0.28627505898475647, 0.3033730685710907, -0.26707813143730164, 0.26114484667778015, 0.7918998003005981, 0.40279990434646606, 0.4235873818397522, 0.007486032322049141, 1.06452476978302, -0.2596086263656616, 0.20015038549900055, 0.8286936283111572, -0.1638859063386917, 0.011349573731422424, 0.33223065733909607, 0.3614090383052826, -0.3651256263256073, 0.4856153726577759, 0.5778477191925049, 0.656126856803894, 0.6402035355567932, -0.1996341049671173, 0.9278594255447388, 0.1707305759191513, 0.6520366668701172, -1.176312804222107, 0.6495456695556641, -0.8741593360900879, 1.2010455131530762, 0.2084091603755951, -0.012266332283616066, -0.5832903385162354, 0.2694770395755768, -0.3775414824485779, 0.4267335534095764, -0.010659870691597462, -0.5926456451416016, 0.010808460414409637, -0.02569810301065445, 0.18555662035942078, -0.7287566661834717, -0.1322191059589386, 0.9281997084617615, -0.2046571671962738, -0.05016901716589928, 0.07159219682216644, -0.0746283158659935, -1.7234065532684326, -0.5311921238899231, -0.4918508529663086, -0.0637269914150238, -0.3619266748428345, -0.3165877163410187, 0.7707362771034241, 0.09235317260026932, 0.8182699680328369, -0.2408253401517868, 0.05089220404624939, 0.5719901323318481, 0.4298155903816223, 0.5519093871116638, -0.10867583751678467, -0.26132798194885254, -0.4960915744304657, -0.04669177159667015, -0.5080099701881409, -0.007430531550198793, -0.2710096538066864, 0.049874767661094666, 0.0738474577665329, -0.3586328625679016, 0.18361255526542664, 0.04841562733054161, -0.5460226535797119, 0.01721443235874176, 0.02830006368458271, -0.30279025435447693, -0.713174045085907, 1.0441995859146118, 0.3072524070739746, -0.19869762659072876, -0.7931855320930481, 1.0328328609466553, -0.2717493176460266, -0.7748075127601624, 0.46661698818206787, 0.16587655246257782, -0.7333921790122986, 0.006901934742927551, -0.3011532127857208, 0.009322366677224636, -0.3136603832244873, 0.9716721773147583, 0.6301640868186951, -0.07571641355752945, 0.17968320846557617, -0.2761822044849396, -0.26095589995384216, -0.4230474531650543, 0.8116948008537292, -0.8851656317710876, 0.004062513820827007, 0.9008898735046387, 1.0736913681030273, -0.5323143005371094, 0.3459426760673523, -0.6550382375717163, -0.8189885020256042, 0.19653651118278503, -0.47070613503456116, 0.09331571310758591, 0.03235127031803131, 0.37744370102882385, 0.023034635931253433, -0.1406119167804718, 0.6180870532989502, 0.8669618964195251, 0.28869861364364624, -1.1433970928192139, 0.43460598587989807, 0.7074852585792542, -0.24378590285778046, 0.10787791758775711, 0.48870766162872314, -0.0747780129313469, -0.5246590971946716, 0.21953605115413666, -1.0502948760986328, -0.23627977073192596, -0.0872223898768425, 0.0949072316288948, 0.44196170568466187, -0.05989590659737587, -0.8102099299430847, 0.36039677262306213, -0.4103584885597229, 0.11445967853069305, 0.21878241002559662, 0.32091009616851807, 0.18751244246959686, -0.5791347026824951, -0.5222007036209106, -0.7874908447265625, 0.24219690263271332, 0.5011010766029358, 1.3628560304641724, -0.5676865577697754, 0.7478919625282288, -0.40219685435295105, 0.556625485420227, 0.3980041742324829, -0.6933557987213135, 0.441770076751709, 0.28048378229141235, 0.13532258570194244, 0.6579650044441223, -0.3738881051540375, -0.49982696771621704, -0.4673767387866974, 0.9805276393890381, 0.4900546669960022, 0.4135848879814148, -0.0877639502286911, -0.17197518050670624, -0.8551247119903564, -0.1670733094215393, -0.307151734828949, -0.4017897844314575, -0.3467121720314026, -0.443062424659729, -0.7748459577560425, -0.4642495810985565, -0.0913003534078598, 0.4907720685005188, 0.9126729369163513, 0.39126378297805786, 0.020231129601597786, 1.002274751663208, 0.10851265490055084, 0.30118271708488464, 0.8287580609321594, -0.09541212022304535, 0.17217278480529785, -0.31789466738700867, 0.4818792939186096, 0.11506123095750809, -0.10561008006334305, -0.17428338527679443, 0.44504469633102417, -0.056029096245765686, -0.5157597064971924, 0.6983819007873535, 0.5173383355140686, -0.13980050384998322, 0.2434813231229782, -0.5203181505203247, 0.2484455406665802, -1.0839710235595703, -0.3366236388683319, 0.3673146963119507, 1.376414179801941, 0.41972434520721436, -0.5566138029098511, -0.1213599368929863, -0.36223235726356506, 0.7172736525535583, 0.7918002605438232, 0.040051404386758804, -0.8324229121208191, -0.769953727722168, 0.3932971656322479, -0.5479718446731567, 0.3181128203868866, 0.9784746766090393, -0.2179897278547287, 0.06777022778987885, -0.16751565039157867, 0.15515169501304626, -0.10146638751029968, -0.6799713373184204, -0.6034813523292542, 0.6548141837120056, -0.08555100113153458, -0.10155811905860901, 0.21445366740226746, -0.5242331027984619, -0.10354001820087433, -0.09228835254907608, -0.7258670926094055, 0.48805102705955505, -0.08742224425077438, -0.5391193628311157, 0.17722837626934052, 0.20031695067882538, -0.2260817587375641, 0.3743843734264374, -0.07599247246980667, 0.01910819113254547, -0.7810500264167786, -0.11360040307044983, -0.5044844746589661, 0.0981975793838501, 0.4056841731071472, -0.7707109451293945, 1.428076982498169, 0.13603772222995758, -0.05352205038070679, 0.16952292621135712, -0.18760158121585846, 0.04788300395011902, 0.29305076599121094, 0.22578103840351105, -0.6898435354232788, 0.08833662420511246, -0.7034841179847717, -0.25598615407943726, -0.1736474335193634, 0.24602699279785156, 0.9045990109443665, -0.24551035463809967, 0.08406785130500793, 0.5919087529182434, -0.4730181097984314, 0.1409362554550171, 0.007571749854832888, -0.9539452791213989, 0.2908945381641388, -1.2970540523529053, -0.2016044408082962, 0.1422756165266037, -0.35367822647094727, -0.05639493092894554, -0.16898344457149506, -0.5638659596443176, 0.7005536556243896, -0.10739941149950027, 0.18199856579303741, -0.2875392436981201, 0.8016098141670227, -0.6574133038520813, -0.12310322374105453, 0.1799827516078949, 0.20181390643119812, -0.9615321159362793, -1.2031755447387695, 0.07325812429189682, 0.017446642741560936, -0.5538052916526794, -0.5207647681236267, -0.21877281367778778, 0.29254040122032166, 0.1999279409646988, 0.14462265372276306, 0.34255003929138184, -0.5000430941581726, -0.5802193284034729, 0.3248712718486786, 1.0488523244857788, -1.1092392206192017, -0.4297136962413788, 1.2554835081100464, -0.8154933452606201, 0.23086321353912354, 0.00909907091408968, -0.5541817545890808, 0.3382006883621216, -0.3655928075313568, 0.6645194888114929, -1.0455735921859741, -1.1940522193908691, -0.8647441267967224, -0.8467180132865906, -0.940030038356781, -0.2812977433204651, 0.126029372215271, -0.6948491334915161, -0.3037475347518921, -0.896573543548584, -0.2533787786960602, 0.20121730864048004, 0.3352411091327667, -0.47017914056777954, -0.5527980923652649, -0.5024223923683167, 0.056783080101013184, -0.17308206856250763, -0.06028899550437927, 0.7514134049415588, 0.06616417318582535, 0.09409449994564056, -0.11337945610284805, -0.6110631227493286, -0.7118142247200012, 0.041053883731365204, 0.4734664559364319, 0.2959820330142975, 0.4843866527080536, -0.30466607213020325, 0.0999869778752327, -0.9102686643600464, 0.14912402629852295, 0.22441737353801727, 0.17751333117485046, 0.3667754530906677, 0.09919971227645874, 0.8613988161087036, -0.7215629816055298, 0.04737725853919983, 0.6098920106887817, -0.024985866621136665, 0.21498547494411469, -0.21298599243164062, -0.7776504158973694, -0.5327365398406982, -0.6008919477462769, -1.475290298461914, 0.27302104234695435, 0.08685991168022156, 0.03876990079879761, -0.14593349397182465, -0.18225881457328796, 0.35540348291397095, -0.13749085366725922, 0.02463061362504959, 0.7164336442947388, 0.224290668964386, 0.5895020961761475, -0.3499775230884552, 0.052625872194767, -0.047034475952386856, -0.3852960765361786, 0.18948663771152496, 0.1999950259923935, -0.5080752372741699, 0.31113454699516296, -0.04833728075027466, -0.9870439767837524, -0.30043601989746094, 0.4800288677215576, 0.6362037658691406, -0.09977029263973236, 0.5389696955680847, -0.14710594713687897, -0.48556849360466003, -0.869583010673523, -0.07619224488735199, 0.28245723247528076, 0.5518710613250732, 0.43747082352638245, 0.011853456497192383, -0.08570028841495514, -0.8321544528007507, 1.3066177368164062, -0.19806423783302307, -0.10501600801944733, 0.9294043183326721, -0.5752110481262207, -0.3828097879886627, 0.23407769203186035, 0.28775522112846375, -0.4706210196018219, -0.030336815863847733, -0.7907329797744751, -0.009854326955974102, 0.09127669036388397, -0.41149473190307617, -0.3591746687889099, -0.5244005918502808, -0.24561409652233124, 0.04576221480965614, 0.4726307690143585, -0.5209768414497375, 0.0841444656252861, -0.472617506980896, -0.2045530527830124, -1.2716913223266602, 0.757896363735199, 1.189461350440979, 0.31517618894577026, -1.0347990989685059, -0.7622033953666687, -0.2204650491476059, 0.5910993218421936, -0.5111587047576904, 0.25368595123291016, -0.1281748265028, 0.9646934866905212, 0.24126426875591278, 0.1580192893743515, 0.04650070145726204, 0.3712840974330902, 0.1413094401359558, -0.10197179764509201, 0.05232226103544235, -1.0895875692367554, -0.6059384346008301, 0.08179184794425964, 0.022782456129789352, 1.2707788944244385, -0.4115466773509979, 0.45528265833854675, -0.3164803981781006, -0.49856916069984436, -0.6082961559295654, -1.3293788433074951, 0.24839641153812408, -1.414084553718567, -0.9332910776138306, -0.8088330626487732, -0.3340145945549011, -0.13729619979858398, 0.17626994848251343, -0.14499998092651367, 0.256521075963974, -0.7506110072135925, -0.2626722753047943, 0.34308329224586487, 0.8229219317436218, -0.3888404965400696, -0.3392992317676544, -1.354828119277954, 0.24228563904762268, -0.6279261112213135, -0.3905371427536011, -0.26715564727783203, 0.20120136439800262, 0.4556620121002197, 0.3330865800380707, -0.3044588267803192, 1.37380850315094, -0.6707196831703186, -0.3601415157318115, 0.42322346568107605, -0.27361002564430237, -1.070369005203247, 0.3430324196815491, -0.5592781901359558, 0.838405966758728, 0.07620185613632202, 0.6671744585037231, 0.38304999470710754, 0.11391633749008179, -0.5055189728736877, 0.04129321873188019, -0.5553996562957764, 0.0005914329085499048, -0.7326619029045105, -0.8915351033210754, 0.6657283306121826, 0.09007911384105682, -0.8741642236709595, 0.3526347279548645, -0.07091019302606583, 0.3197921812534332, -1.0083627700805664, -0.46143707633018494, 0.6150736808776855, 0.9792718291282654, -0.6829484701156616, 0.2967335879802704, -0.630158007144928, -0.33947238326072693, -0.20601260662078857, 0.25112801790237427, 0.03213699162006378, 0.4623125493526459, -0.0541299432516098, -0.3005794882774353, -0.33615127205848694, 0.023732811212539673, -0.21640703082084656, 0.12280204892158508, -0.1975553035736084, -0.859228789806366, -1.0574015378952026, -0.4082470238208771, -0.9088868498802185, 0.34549981355667114, -0.5395903587341309, -0.1381155252456665, -0.12853486835956573, -0.4715293049812317, -0.708949863910675, -0.7383540272712708, -1.0344312191009521, -0.45099467039108276, -0.239609494805336, -0.6438043713569641, -0.3345515727996826, 0.5496032238006592, -0.7061987519264221, -0.3520578145980835, 0.1427917778491974, 1.2770715951919556, -0.08271414786577225, 0.09872648119926453, -0.49745747447013855, 0.3574095070362091, -0.4926266372203827, 0.32572972774505615, -0.9488522410392761, 0.09428619593381882, -0.22745607793331146, -0.17781364917755127, 0.3575345575809479, 1.1344640254974365, 0.0815650150179863, 0.1751326620578766, -0.11121492832899094, -0.14732305705547333, 0.3914374113082886, -0.4521873891353607, -0.15910787880420685, 0.4099750220775604, -0.5448931455612183, 0.3886238634586334, 0.1661222130060196, 0.18184585869312286, 0.15307718515396118, 0.22290582954883575, 0.056022025644779205, 0.4668702483177185, -0.011852340772747993, 0.7011209726333618, -0.19050218164920807, -0.31480562686920166, 0.8047046661376953, 0.5827363133430481, 0.5379664301872253, 0.29132989048957825, -0.27188748121261597, 0.22939075529575348, -0.2701319754123688, 0.4135483503341675, 1.095996618270874, 0.6181035041809082, 0.5738050937652588, 0.04586796090006828, 0.10167769342660904, 0.5747870206832886, 0.22781632840633392, 0.2164321392774582, 0.16785742342472076, 0.7439327836036682, -0.7503386735916138, 0.5125020146369934, -0.3706064224243164, 0.7657944560050964, 0.9713655114173889, 0.3506845235824585, 0.17840033769607544, -0.09682522714138031, 0.006068862974643707, 1.0281344652175903, -0.6350732445716858, -0.5287606120109558, -0.28171277046203613, 0.02156744711101055, 0.0029276940040290356, -0.6244966983795166, 0.42367023229599, -0.045795947313308716, 0.398664265871048, 0.18170619010925293, -0.24060030281543732, 0.661882758140564, 0.4579160511493683, 0.15924625098705292, 0.17290374636650085, 1.0939797163009644, 0.225555419921875, 0.8032746315002441, -0.19821928441524506, -0.5193619728088379, -0.3812728226184845, 0.4574096202850342, -0.7225160598754883, -0.08814887702465057, -0.15529416501522064, -0.25946351885795593, 0.8607177734375, -0.8576896786689758, 0.6724172830581665, 0.24901370704174042, 0.06959053874015808, 0.8253464102745056, 0.17005884647369385, -0.27710089087486267, 0.6651504039764404, -0.2973732054233551, 0.20575164258480072, -0.6609002947807312, 0.6546399593353271, -0.1618218868970871, 0.8707552552223206, 1.4844309091567993, -0.251089483499527, -0.0637146383523941, -0.08393727242946625, 0.3190944492816925, -0.04042115435004234, -0.1426810920238495, 0.10279576480388641, 0.572895884513855, -0.681830883026123, 0.3313814699649811, -0.5273556709289551, -0.2144545167684555, -0.7554066777229309, 0.06814483553171158, 0.798619270324707, 0.5336949229240417, -0.3837510347366333, 0.28187891840934753, 0.467448353767395, -0.03602460399270058, 0.12974601984024048, -0.47931069135665894, -0.10928945243358612, -1.0586602687835693, -0.4362974464893341, -1.272921085357666, 0.062015101313591, -0.37473273277282715, -0.29609301686286926, -0.49538087844848633, -0.16143614053726196, -0.20839639008045197, -0.4132692217826843, -0.10285432636737823, -0.875175952911377, 0.22153881192207336, 0.6120290160179138, 0.441987544298172, 1.0020402669906616, -0.5103194713592529, -0.8697027564048767, -0.1121673658490181, 1.3517451286315918, 0.022130319848656654, 0.38033363223075867, 0.737146258354187, 0.5990918278694153, -0.5323654413223267, 0.3643178641796112, 0.5502763986587524, -0.9433028101921082, 1.2126576900482178, -0.731112539768219, -0.11250591278076172, -0.24857643246650696, -0.854832112789154, 0.1918795108795166, -0.03723539412021637, 0.8056941628456116, -0.4961048364639282, -0.6208841800689697, 0.24161764979362488, -0.13923563063144684, 0.674514651298523, -0.7289107441902161, 0.016242945566773415, 0.3055913746356964, 0.04852830618619919, -1.0370831489562988, -0.5025203824043274, 3.888104200363159, 0.33565670251846313, 0.9578999280929565, 0.1868721842765808, 0.5171710252761841, 0.27431732416152954, 0.42418918013572693, 0.13878002762794495, 0.3550654351711273, -0.36680805683135986, -0.19170421361923218, 0.5785881280899048, 0.5094462037086487, 0.2947564721107483, 0.09121973067522049, 0.9667196869850159, 0.19149567186832428, 0.6822030544281006, 0.470095694065094, -1.4530938863754272, -0.7203970551490784, -0.10118615627288818, 0.22618164122104645, -0.34827688336372375, 0.1251363903284073, -0.15970441699028015, 0.8778530359268188, -0.37309420108795166, -0.2800540030002594, -0.13374832272529602, -0.9004994034767151, -0.38586941361427307, 0.25402262806892395, 0.17277830839157104, -0.732258141040802, 0.43081578612327576, -0.5998731255531311, -0.12887190282344818, 0.13236252963542938, -0.09308189898729324, 0.888696551322937, 0.2457905262708664, 0.14803726971149445, -0.42804646492004395, -0.041168875992298126, 0.9230191111564636, 0.029765957966446877, 0.9711169600486755, 0.4620216488838196, -0.7214082479476929, -0.0900309830904007, -0.4768058955669403, 0.967369794845581, 0.4776274263858795, -1.1776134967803955, -0.4490923583507538, 0.013350283727049828, -0.797660768032074, 0.5161282420158386, 1.1314760446548462, 0.687590479850769, -0.11886639147996902, -0.05899319425225258, -0.5393950939178467, -0.1554420292377472, 0.3080264627933502, 0.1606505960226059, -0.5718891620635986, 0.27000921964645386, 0.6698039174079895, -0.3146631419658661, -0.100755974650383, -0.7513386011123657, -0.005389407277107239, 0.2536415755748749, 0.512727677822113, -0.31414148211479187, 0.23168227076530457, -0.03847431764006615, -0.015172470360994339, -0.16880086064338684, -0.2630798816680908, -0.04831155017018318, 0.6724372506141663, 0.5409296751022339, 0.4840652048587799, 0.17280633747577667, 0.09351661801338196, -0.10544566065073013, 0.43196263909339905, 0.5192640423774719, 1.356524109840393, 0.480400413274765, 0.21777747571468353, -1.1080214977264404 ]
Unstable Periodic Orbits in the Stadium Billiard
A systematic numerical technique for the calculation of unstable periodic orbits in the stadium billiard is presented. All the periodic orbits up to order $p=11$ are calculated and then used to calculate the average Lyapunov exponent and the topological entropy. Applications to semiclassical quantization and to experiments in mesoscopic systems and microwave cavities are noted.
Ofer Biham and Mark Kvale
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207010
cond-mat/9207011
[ -0.06271366029977798, 0.7768471240997314, 0.7699164748191833, 0.35314440727233887, -0.3511168956756592, 0.003391627687960863, 0.16930904984474182, -0.13395807147026062, 0.19633857905864716, 1.9195376634597778, 0.18330353498458862, 0.19295795261859894, 0.0697617307305336, -0.39358168840408325, -0.2912411093711853, -0.08804295212030411, -0.27889177203178406, -1.0970934629440308, -1.219534158706665, -0.08718235790729523, -0.5898374915122986, -0.9507487416267395, -0.9901690483093262, -0.8202304244041443, -0.2530190050601959, 0.9198668003082275, 0.19486315548419952, -0.247588112950325, 0.6751566529273987, 0.8089780807495117, 0.47640255093574524, -0.5762935876846313, 0.31740131974220276, -0.8375980257987976, -0.797062337398529, 0.9679643511772156, 0.6850314736366272, -0.8511763215065002, 0.18232464790344238, -0.6801226139068604, 1.1413706541061401, -0.4795684814453125, 0.4244437515735626, -0.7306462526321411, 0.2850547432899475, 0.11585719883441925, -0.4598022699356079, 0.4175094962120056, -0.2553194463253021, -0.3734165132045746, 0.25423458218574524, 0.354480504989624, 0.1827758401632309, -0.8784044981002808, -1.1342095136642456, -0.2389346957206726, 0.09999609738588333, -0.09455052763223648, -0.5219093561172485, -0.1371026486158371, -0.16369865834712982, 0.40853482484817505, 0.32867416739463806, -0.17994418740272522, -0.42506304383277893, 0.7689336538314819, -0.613495409488678, -0.17905700206756592, -0.05540093779563904, -0.621208667755127, -0.6857860088348389, -0.11193948239088058, 0.9162341952323914, 0.5886057615280151, -0.4390263259410858, 0.12439803779125214, 0.1612941324710846, -1.038700819015503, -0.1354093849658966, -0.554008960723877, -0.4495353102684021, 0.5283570289611816, -0.664857029914856, 0.6033201217651367, -0.1109100803732872, -0.5476924180984497, -0.14418935775756836, 0.453200101852417, 0.7126861214637756, 0.44237220287323, 0.5123683214187622, 0.8255581259727478, -0.20683246850967407, -0.263642281293869, 0.7981184124946594, -0.14013853669166565, -0.36714163422584534, 0.8251942992210388, 0.07132118195295334, 1.0449141263961792, 0.6610335111618042, 1.3680260181427002, -0.5351637005805969, 0.7432114481925964, -1.1750208139419556, 0.3399057686328888, 0.24838876724243164, 0.4222007095813751, -0.1535683423280716, -0.5029593110084534, -0.7243562936782837, 0.7887974977493286, 0.441995769739151, 0.2218511700630188, 0.5864078402519226, 0.3002055883407593, 0.7070559859275818, -0.15031562745571136, -1.173514723777771, -0.14808982610702515, -0.407696932554245, 0.6566110253334045, -0.08763929456472397, 0.11011200398206711, -0.2488979995250702, -0.41262921690940857, -0.3423733711242676, 0.9164507389068604, -0.5548397898674011, 0.09740614145994186, -0.13991831243038177, -0.8757099509239197, -0.5380727052688599, 0.18618759512901306, 0.3982316255569458, -0.03281951695680618, 0.0110396733507514, 0.7490041851997375, 0.051673900336027145, 0.17987056076526642, 0.37504658102989197, -0.9600285291671753, -0.025523601099848747, 1.189475178718567, 0.02354036457836628, -0.07930931448936462, 1.0104538202285767, -1.5065357685089111, -0.6223725080490112, -0.8582817316055298, -0.3511101007461548, -0.3924298882484436, 0.24564261734485626, 0.24004586040973663, -0.5640405416488647, -0.06055469065904617, -0.7389836311340332, 0.0878584235906601, -0.7025108933448792, 0.5339324474334717, -0.1895846277475357, -0.31322553753852844, 0.541360080242157, 0.47832635045051575, -0.7976607084274292, 0.5272490382194519, -0.6406954526901245, 0.448406457901001, -0.5710873007774353, -0.8697452545166016, 0.3365056812763214, 0.285393625497818, -0.2870897948741913, -0.5450235605239868, 0.652073085308075, 0.26712286472320557, 0.14429211616516113, -0.469969242811203, 0.27991825342178345, 0.593212902545929, 0.03221480920910835, -0.3176388740539551, -0.15604929625988007, 0.11524681746959686, 0.3567226231098175, 0.5777108669281006, -0.5143548250198364, 0.1259249895811081, 0.395829975605011, 0.4499471187591553, -0.0876384750008583, 0.8500295877456665, -1.3473821878433228, 0.18766288459300995, -1.1587666273117065, -0.09748425334692001, 0.28998130559921265, 0.6561440229415894, 0.20181670784950256, -0.14442387223243713, -0.08327439427375793, 0.6154364347457886, -1.2786450386047363, -0.06006800755858421, -1.4047447443008423, 0.13614247739315033, 0.10849710553884506, 0.548496663570404, -0.7311258912086487, -0.13093866407871246, -0.08164419233798981, -0.26995453238487244, -0.27687132358551025, 0.1935027837753296, -0.06079692021012306, -0.11853212863206863, -0.2959780693054199, -0.2767237424850464, -0.005238246638327837, -0.3646528124809265, 0.62016761302948, -0.009538707323372364, -0.31598907709121704, 1.2762070894241333, 0.1462862193584442, 0.7369937300682068, 0.32884159684181213, 0.4982544183731079, 0.5623355507850647, 0.6749340295791626, -0.25476133823394775, 0.5840305089950562, -0.6246626973152161, 0.07608213275671005, 0.9992756247520447, 0.7003853917121887, 0.06124567613005638, 0.7687122225761414, -0.20929689705371857, 0.3552640378475189, 0.3103128671646118, -0.12391386926174164, 0.7747349739074707, 0.484173059463501, -0.23585908114910126, 0.8879988193511963, -0.47727537155151367, 0.004554088693112135, -0.20280109345912933, 0.46819502115249634, -0.9630428552627563, 1.2561304569244385, 0.2687007486820221, -0.5070747137069702, 0.0754566639661789, 0.3814057409763336, -0.29343390464782715, 0.5586249232292175, -0.18149612843990326, -0.30260565876960754, 0.4646088778972626, -0.02339121699333191, -0.6389828324317932, -0.27182310819625854, -0.6590697765350342, 0.9667838215827942, -0.018233463168144226, 0.1061750203371048, -0.44736891984939575, -0.49959903955459595, -1.6284948587417603, -0.3064846694469452, -1.0150938034057617, -0.25780537724494934, -0.16797713935375214, 0.5251920223236084, 0.8423207998275757, -0.24412287771701813, 0.29431116580963135, 0.02912321500480175, -0.6144844889640808, 0.3438040614128113, -0.9115423560142517, 0.657798707485199, -0.0013589009176939726, -0.011243694461882114, -0.1873304396867752, 0.06205615773797035, -0.23246057331562042, 0.6113486886024475, -0.5006367564201355, -0.6411683559417725, -0.22968384623527527, -0.15610118210315704, -0.1226360872387886, 0.06824755668640137, 0.008166956715285778, -0.16926908493041992, -0.552051842212677, -0.7461320757865906, -0.3218172490596771, -0.24602055549621582, -0.6656301617622375, -0.640156626701355, -0.550624668598175, 0.6443715691566467, -0.759001612663269, -0.17431148886680603, 0.33657321333885193, 0.17851918935775757, -0.36286938190460205, 0.503460168838501, -0.733418345451355, -0.01865513250231743, -0.5303010940551758, 0.9887075424194336, 0.6851545572280884, 0.5862948298454285, -0.3060437738895416, -0.5880737900733948, -0.39406779408454895, 0.20920857787132263, 0.8482601642608643, -0.844630241394043, -0.557906985282898, 0.9518647193908691, 0.7812397480010986, -0.5549142956733704, 0.7185832858085632, -0.8026509284973145, -0.4883624315261841, -0.02491711638867855, -0.3642082214355469, 0.14622698724269867, 0.33718645572662354, -0.08870645612478256, -0.03829389810562134, 0.4529624581336975, 0.2613242566585541, 0.21657437086105347, -0.002912827767431736, -0.294320672750473, 0.32372987270355225, 0.9324562549591064, -0.20681755244731903, 0.1019134372472763, 0.6578693985939026, -0.4168086647987366, -0.2867996096611023, 0.31147390604019165, -0.6401426196098328, -0.1023356094956398, 0.4938746392726898, -0.15090683102607727, 0.05976567417383194, 0.7742870450019836, -0.5569759607315063, -0.28095996379852295, -1.081566333770752, -0.39434176683425903, -0.23032261431217194, 0.10667406767606735, -0.15417367219924927, -0.4909406304359436, -0.5157329440116882, -0.11191868036985397, 0.9073964953422546, 0.5418606996536255, 0.5997458696365356, -0.5137103199958801, 0.2860642075538635, 0.02369633875787258, -0.44149938225746155, -0.4710453152656555, -0.0965106189250946, -0.3003167510032654, 0.5851417779922485, 0.5897877812385559, 0.515222430229187, -0.008911910466849804, -0.5074143409729004, -0.8459109663963318, 0.574029803276062, 0.27584779262542725, 0.23231622576713562, 0.5669745206832886, -0.6316022276878357, 0.18508347868919373, -0.6358245611190796, -0.6540793776512146, -0.29193517565727234, -0.8668344616889954, -0.2602914273738861, -0.7139418125152588, -0.6946908235549927, 0.18335603177547455, 0.14434780180454254, 0.6829686760902405, -0.0907636284828186, 1.0019270181655884, 0.5976773500442505, -0.0021820617839694023, -0.28481000661849976, -0.21168962121009827, -0.6148239970207214, 0.01855289377272129, -0.5372817516326904, 0.028520701453089714, 0.4165623188018799, -0.6958414316177368, -0.415085107088089, -0.449029803276062, 0.32965704798698425, 0.14731107652187347, 0.43439748883247375, 0.14026933908462524, -0.9102857708930969, 1.0903288125991821, -0.14470243453979492, 0.6510000824928284, -1.1864469051361084, -0.2402050644159317, 0.44372454285621643, 0.8883234262466431, 0.1283964365720749, -0.5658897757530212, 0.24649152159690857, -0.445156067609787, 0.4932681918144226, 0.4117596447467804, -0.4696289896965027, -0.2986300587654114, 0.5744543671607971, 0.8069071173667908, -0.3751349151134491, 0.02648216299712658, 0.5896442532539368, -0.7315514087677002, 0.09278944134712219, -0.1419341117143631, 0.061260636895895004, 0.3123309910297394, -0.29854869842529297, -0.2606927156448364, -0.05894411355257034, 0.2623654901981354, -0.003225834108889103, 0.20237107574939728, -0.5777792930603027, -0.40525561571121216, -0.10042593628168106, -0.41576164960861206, 0.9237896800041199, -0.08542027324438095, -0.8026571869850159, 0.4801182746887207, 0.2030477225780487, -0.18782193958759308, 0.851252555847168, 0.06126239523291588, -0.3184378743171692, 0.6183473467826843, -0.670040488243103, -0.14582429826259613, -0.6010948419570923, 0.2138054519891739, 0.22127972543239594, 0.6757916808128357, 0.4018329381942749, 0.4546012580394745, 0.29089611768722534, 0.0856618657708168, 0.23328541219234467, -0.466379314661026, -0.20752444863319397, -0.3690339922904968, -0.40136927366256714, -0.013213001191616058, -1.0728904008865356, -0.2522163987159729, -0.664890706539154, 0.786300003528595, -0.313867449760437, -0.05714162811636925, -0.3577979803085327, 0.0898282527923584, 0.007631923072040081, -0.021054167300462723, -0.21924136579036713, 0.24817457795143127, -0.18002235889434814, 0.3381344974040985, -0.5896092057228088, -0.934576690196991, -0.06638974696397781, 0.03527231514453888, -0.1596061736345291, -0.10482606291770935, -0.03884923458099365, -0.39113596081733704, -0.3173265755176544, 0.31215065717697144, -0.95374596118927, 0.5791095495223999, 0.4206414222717285, 0.4522256553173065, -0.5065784454345703, -0.4615236818790436, -0.4793955683708191, -0.20913591980934143, -0.49124330282211304, -0.3805555999279022, -0.5895629525184631, -0.5338330864906311, -0.04936365410685539, 0.012712149880826473, 0.28868186473846436, 0.21250435709953308, -0.27920255064964294, 0.6706803441047668, -0.11294827610254288, -1.2656126022338867, -0.22167372703552246, 1.1869642734527588, 0.12145121395587921, 0.4034174680709839, -0.35985317826271057, -0.8778873682022095, 0.056122373789548874, -0.01521423738449812, -0.4190610349178314, -1.0175243616104126, -0.5269264578819275, -0.026112312451004982, 0.006073962897062302, 0.1268683671951294, -0.3118691146373749, 0.11709117889404297, -0.7592113018035889, -0.37540239095687866, -0.6256372332572937, -0.24858951568603516, -0.36840981245040894, -0.45062577724456787, -0.30705174803733826, 0.11841088533401489, -0.7388714551925659, 0.8712789416313171, -0.595421314239502, -0.38864248991012573, 0.34503787755966187, 0.5182161927223206, 0.4336158335208893, 0.9287598729133606, -0.22265376150608063, -0.1801874190568924, 0.06533005088567734, 0.8996293544769287, -0.15029233694076538, 0.45678895711898804, -0.06819334626197815, 0.35566654801368713, -1.2614332437515259, 0.12486772239208221, -0.13615740835666656, 0.162301704287529, 0.7117056250572205, 0.5944944620132446, 0.5533998608589172, -0.8543466329574585, 0.12720735371112823, 0.23968423902988434, 0.2732202410697937, 0.7806203961372375, 0.617310643196106, -0.4672152101993561, -0.521279513835907, 0.4038686156272888, -1.2848128080368042, 0.5619695782661438, -0.04505109041929245, -0.07624074816703796, -0.854854941368103, -0.2694842517375946, 0.16586120426654816, 0.19175973534584045, 0.43983209133148193, 0.8422289490699768, 0.20042450726032257, 0.5840470790863037, 0.1582985669374466, -0.2246936559677124, 0.1354067325592041, 0.0592566654086113, 0.3975563645362854, 0.22685804963111877, -1.1435341835021973, 0.10538411885499954, 0.10611063241958618, -1.2893521785736084, -0.6868634223937988, 0.3761811852455139, 0.26969265937805176, -0.5105634927749634, 0.9752158522605896, -0.16014637053012848, -0.08860964328050613, -0.41813981533050537, -0.19114264845848083, 0.32500651478767395, 0.14162945747375488, 0.19409820437431335, -0.1518814116716385, -0.2714066803455353, 0.4181590974330902, -0.46529626846313477, -0.9394965767860413, -0.088017538189888, 0.45910394191741943, -0.7194522023200989, -0.6227782368659973, -0.15693137049674988, 0.10904231667518616, 0.16074921190738678, -0.25094351172447205, -0.32098057866096497, -0.2617514431476593, 0.7755205035209656, -0.14966830611228943, 0.41749313473701477, 0.45848986506462097, -0.9822514057159424, 0.6619141101837158, 0.6714073419570923, -0.3090706467628479, 0.121145099401474, -0.2893798351287842, -0.04933032765984535, -0.686465322971344, 0.4023568034172058, 1.297161340713501, -0.42931151390075684, -0.4720331132411957, -0.4794674813747406, -1.1980868577957153, -0.23543277382850647, -0.16615426540374756, 0.10834092646837234, 0.7115636467933655, -0.008921460248529911, 0.1631225198507309, -0.35606423020362854, 0.14013339579105377, 0.666170060634613, 0.4242740571498871, -0.584904134273529, 0.003416770836338401, -0.7857241034507751, -0.6435936689376831, -0.047993164509534836, 0.27530455589294434, 0.8007940649986267, -0.4559077024459839, 0.31325775384902954, -0.6927379965782166, 0.003613758832216263, -1.167032241821289, -0.7041996121406555, -0.44762951135635376, -1.1365904808044434, -0.9949178099632263, -0.7495156526565552, -0.2685856819152832, -0.08681686967611313, -0.30829304456710815, 0.5051745772361755, 0.14015884697437286, -0.07681388407945633, 0.18917204439640045, 0.7505507469177246, 1.0695430040359497, -0.13578000664710999, -0.22711041569709778, -0.9088977575302124, -0.2842859923839569, -0.30173221230506897, -0.31026148796081543, 0.21820314228534698, 1.2230544090270996, -0.8735824227333069, -0.049104634672403336, -0.36649492383003235, 0.8756701350212097, -0.6186050176620483, -0.16994322836399078, 0.6780306100845337, -0.42815130949020386, -0.8697969913482666, 0.7649919986724854, -0.37136968970298767, 0.3584655821323395, -0.31129691004753113, -0.6654782891273499, 0.08570512384176254, 0.09233667701482773, -0.42225563526153564, 0.18269209563732147, -0.21336516737937927, 0.682998538017273, -0.7424593567848206, -0.09303250908851624, 0.322393000125885, 0.7774061560630798, -0.9229970574378967, 1.0660576820373535, 0.22019514441490173, 0.9790314435958862, 0.24118579924106598, -0.1378381848335266, 0.2453938126564026, 0.8754705786705017, -0.35803303122520447, 0.6266710162162781, -0.8852109909057617, -0.09711676090955734, -0.027743572369217873, 0.20814499258995056, -0.2863676846027374, -0.5753848552703857, 0.2168598175048828, -1.049872636795044, 0.8428399562835693, 0.7516409754753113, -0.21491530537605286, 0.34035930037498474, 0.033905986696481705, -0.3391091823577881, -0.399096816778183, -0.3773649334907532, -0.6999728679656982, 0.7097512483596802, -0.11047037690877914, 0.11161921173334122, -0.05950195714831352, -0.5711763501167297, -0.1622183620929718, -0.3889080286026001, -0.6887802481651306, -0.307852566242218, -0.19174741208553314, 0.010059117339551449, -0.43099725246429443, 0.18090377748012543, -0.3662831783294678, -0.30171507596969604, -0.10707896947860718, 0.2937264144420624, -0.46413344144821167, -0.14627552032470703, -0.1617525815963745, 0.17856615781784058, -0.9659857749938965, 0.613129198551178, -0.04265403375029564, 0.22594168782234192, -0.2520754933357239, 0.036874063313007355, -0.0034949821420013905, -0.009489379823207855, -0.41973981261253357, -0.3231153190135956, -0.014757639728486538, 0.11374574899673462, -0.3432750701904297, 0.3340943157672882, 0.20208413898944855, 0.45605775713920593, -0.7127537727355957, 0.2139294594526291, 0.40900376439094543, -0.06991544365882874, 0.06335940212011337, 0.7130643725395203, -0.10714777559041977, -0.18222732841968536, -0.4715961813926697, 0.4618411362171173, 0.19774183630943298, -0.45026281476020813, 0.6000574827194214, 0.25289252400398254, 0.5904127359390259, -0.09875303506851196, -0.3812839090824127, -0.5276423692703247, 0.7806663513183594, 0.271357923746109, 0.16303685307502747, 0.37671589851379395, 0.12843148410320282, 0.1762782633304596, -0.42675501108169556, 0.3547337055206299, -0.03253142163157463, -0.004258404485881329, 0.6682787537574768, 0.8701366186141968, 0.043654441833496094, 0.4041750729084015, -0.2715713381767273, 0.7280539274215698, -0.4674097001552582, 0.3778080940246582, 0.18744459748268127, 0.34651196002960205, -0.05851100757718086, -0.1640048623085022, -0.22200189530849457, -0.5562258958816528, -0.5267524719238281, -0.20967784523963928, 0.025611432269215584, 0.23340550065040588, 0.6479700803756714, 0.6310370564460754, 0.6344218254089355, 0.6509761214256287, -0.05184624344110489, 0.6236885786056519, 0.07439323514699936, -0.09703589230775833, -0.2623162567615509, 1.0550161600112915, 1.0057951211929321, 0.4235174059867859, -0.10662582516670227, 0.006365692708641291, -0.47695183753967285, 0.5884274840354919, -1.2672545909881592, 0.2341064214706421, 0.3347623646259308, -0.1369408816099167, 0.0900639072060585, -0.8422480821609497, 0.4307471811771393, -0.3511381447315216, 0.6227744221687317, 0.9706111550331116, -0.31017637252807617, -0.31838250160217285, 0.38861986994743347, -0.1706542670726776, 0.5421063899993896, 0.7426694631576538, 0.31371939182281494, -1.0321179628372192, 0.8941185474395752, 0.9887241125106812, 0.22924846410751343, -0.1140083372592926, 0.21811021864414215, -0.5921142101287842, -0.5155278444290161, 0.19764210283756256, -0.579205334186554, 0.560782790184021, -0.8078131079673767, -0.7665567994117737, 0.12295737117528915, 0.525657057762146, -0.13235950469970703, -0.3349330425262451, 0.4670049250125885, 0.9569584727287292, 0.19902430474758148, -0.019235705956816673, 0.1682678908109665, 0.23881325125694275, 0.32116150856018066, -0.23694740235805511, -0.28245702385902405, -0.08482468873262405, -0.11091085523366928, -0.473073810338974, 0.7112604975700378, -0.36020442843437195, -0.4889952838420868, -0.6298195719718933, -0.24105939269065857, 0.02071581780910492, -0.6624526381492615, -0.46515899896621704, -0.7883039712905884, 0.18318943679332733, 0.6039330959320068, 1.1300865411758423, 0.5362606644630432, -0.7943868637084961, 0.04463177174329758, 0.6165635585784912, 0.8013228178024292, 0.6135517358779907, 0.056076738983392715, 0.5894981622695923, 0.2814612090587616, 0.22943107783794403, 0.07256953418254852, 0.34862232208251953, 0.41178783774375916, 0.24832655489444733, 0.34055644273757935, -0.20701947808265686, 0.025453636422753334, -0.22118279337882996, 0.46537524461746216, 1.2818340063095093, 0.6921864748001099, -0.7303817272186279, 0.0420658253133297, 0.09413708001375198, -1.164692759513855, 0.1373203843832016, -0.6361729502677917, 0.21201926469802856, 1.0974410772323608, -0.10903364419937134, 0.5959634184837341, -0.5757770538330078, 4.000168323516846, 1.0210081338882446, 0.7670374512672424, -0.07538343966007233, 0.3375728726387024, 0.5393974184989929, 0.6618676781654358, -0.43939322233200073, 0.06946113705635071, -0.4329591393470764, -0.03527709096670151, -0.2248811423778534, 0.2103964239358902, -0.06985384970903397, -0.043642591685056686, 0.6963191628456116, -0.6069295406341553, 0.3732081651687622, -0.011991212144494057, -0.5462523102760315, -0.4619513154029846, 0.10296783596277237, 0.31215324997901917, 0.12233046442270279, 0.14452265202999115, 0.09203093498945236, -0.12723280489444733, -0.56513911485672, -0.02140430174767971, -0.6611819267272949, -1.295304775238037, -0.8168054819107056, -0.10875251144170761, 0.09865133464336395, -0.5663139224052429, 0.9738206267356873, -0.07151495665311813, 0.3374190926551819, 0.09789726883172989, -0.2791842222213745, 0.14919747412204742, -0.8372541666030884, -0.13981680572032928, 0.10758663713932037, -0.8017865419387817, 0.4457511007785797, 0.2366681545972824, 0.2659178376197815, 0.5334179401397705, -0.11250588297843933, 0.06501881033182144, -0.6695963740348816, 0.4010382294654846, -0.08761388063430786, -0.9556822776794434, -0.04164012894034386, 0.02262897789478302, -1.1227514743804932, 0.8522737622261047, 0.19768157601356506, 0.8459055423736572, 0.6380705237388611, -0.15456829965114594, 0.6855813264846802, -0.04658002033829689, 0.19629652798175812, 0.5902768969535828, 0.39349159598350525, -0.13837511837482452, -0.006774526555091143, 0.6702828407287598, -0.818423867225647, 0.5274834632873535, 0.11020328104496002, 0.14551666378974915, 0.6511855721473694, -0.5083916783332825, 0.44079622626304626, -0.7486242651939392, 0.49217694997787476, 0.41369304060935974, -0.09220639616250992, 0.10723258554935455, 0.9863610863685608, 0.06836366653442383, 0.38484975695610046, 0.042150601744651794, -0.6969583630561829, -0.12251570075750351, 0.8173134922981262, 1.0808063745498657, 1.1974961757659912, 0.034918162971735, 0.510890543460846, -0.5656123161315918 ]
Numerical study of pattern formation following a convective instability in non-Boussinesq fluids
We present a numerical study of a model of pattern formation following a convective instability in a non-Boussinesq fluid. It is shown that many of the features observed in convection experiments conducted on $CO_{2}$ gas can be reproduced by using a generalized two-dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation. The formation of hexagonal patterns, rolls and spirals is studied, as well as the transitions and competition among them. We also study nucleation and growth of hexagonal patterns and find that the front velocity in this two dimensional model is consistent with the prediction of marginal stability theory for one dimensional fronts.
Hao-wen Xi, Jorge Vinals and J.D. Gunton
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207011
cond-mat/9207012
[ 0.32794833183288574, -0.07187434285879135, 0.1983189433813095, -0.07512515038251877, 0.03253462165594101, -0.7997111082077026, 0.00685405358672142, -0.4762870669364929, -0.7640424966812134, 1.0565550327301025, 1.1591695547103882, -0.23721745610237122, 0.818252444267273, -1.0947452783584595, -0.35791146755218506, 0.5661267638206482, -0.018177246674895287, -0.1644730567932129, -1.3357532024383545, 0.04915009066462517, 0.04148093983530998, -0.3373648226261139, -1.1282341480255127, -0.7788206338882446, -1.2182517051696777, 0.4262467920780182, -0.6539596915245056, 0.6739656925201416, 0.8212806582450867, 0.6658709645271301, 0.5240418314933777, -0.4817749559879303, -0.0721597671508789, -0.4819522202014923, -0.27723535895347595, -0.014265019446611404, -0.067182257771492, -0.3815701901912689, 0.6241664290428162, 0.04208235442638397, 1.1289502382278442, -0.2133074253797531, 0.3663463294506073, -0.08382835239171982, -0.4566613435745239, 0.3737853169441223, -0.1672879457473755, -0.42084789276123047, 0.05545913055539131, -1.1145364046096802, 0.1020733118057251, 0.4376273453235626, 0.809459388256073, -0.13464926183223724, 0.17690303921699524, -0.19603858888149261, -0.24407249689102173, 0.20663157105445862, -0.09467708319425583, -0.7207978963851929, 0.6181021332740784, -0.5540044903755188, 0.9155784845352173, -0.7929865717887878, -0.016159620136022568, 0.38226625323295593, -0.014139502309262753, 1.1982179880142212, 0.15997764468193054, 0.3444298505783081, -0.5012975335121155, -0.6926143765449524, -0.44146057963371277, -0.31899553537368774, -0.23633311688899994, 0.23017841577529907, 0.1092548668384552, -0.3781481683254242, -1.1644635200500488, -0.37948477268218994, -0.2795863449573517, -0.14697441458702087, -0.4104127287864685, -0.01343501079827547, -0.004192177206277847, -0.29715192317962646, 0.24681156873703003, 0.051558107137680054, 0.461232453584671, -0.039524443447589874, 0.66202312707901, 0.6479356288909912, 0.6786223649978638, 0.13510878384113312, 0.2697616219520569, 0.3495524823665619, 0.23379836976528168, 0.616337776184082, 0.5907042622566223, 0.13400016725063324, -0.05395679548382759, 0.6509805917739868, -0.5051525235176086, 0.8294105529785156, -0.4782599210739136, 0.12127041816711426, -0.06932377070188522, 0.8676426410675049, 0.08888033777475357, -0.38501518964767456, 0.36168932914733887, -0.15231627225875854, 0.4314669072628021, 0.21365563571453094, -0.1588570475578308, 0.44561654329299927, -0.15055298805236816, 0.3592527210712433, -0.8804374933242798, -0.33646366000175476, 1.1020936965942383, -0.7058324217796326, 0.6134510636329651, 0.5027463436126709, -0.497210294008255, -0.5657360553741455, 0.00019438329036347568, 1.0308600664138794, 0.06758908927440643, -0.2560080289840698, 0.4765614867210388, -0.24399890005588531, 0.2663581073284149, 0.19204552471637726, -0.48507770895957947, 0.24076434969902039, -0.27904585003852844, 0.41111552715301514, 0.8833437561988831, 0.5204734206199646, 0.5865490436553955, -0.6866656541824341, 0.2227187156677246, 0.449628621339798, -0.10141628235578537, 0.521172821521759, 0.31137681007385254, 0.8256409168243408, -0.09466590732336044, 0.28494420647621155, -0.9163597822189331, -0.09477066248655319, 0.027499767020344734, 0.1937713772058487, -0.2826368808746338, 0.3090287744998932, -0.41293177008628845, 0.9655129313468933, -0.8084874749183655, -0.7571189999580383, 0.3858679533004761, 0.14307129383087158, -0.5140524506568909, -0.042218226939439774, -0.9372772574424744, -0.10979844629764557, -0.7625404000282288, -0.42026612162590027, 0.3762257397174835, -0.6884695291519165, 0.05968675762414932, -0.37465354800224304, -0.3329925835132599, 0.3660052418708801, 0.22777879238128662, 0.27852267026901245, 0.5060681104660034, -0.23835034668445587, 0.33578482270240784, 0.23802196979522705, -0.4292054772377014, 0.08557484298944473, 0.3879290521144867, 0.06500667333602905, 0.12191168963909149, -0.1282823532819748, -0.623738706111908, -0.476094514131546, 0.027361135929822922, 0.4075556695461273, 0.30080994963645935, 0.07772528380155563, -0.3988838195800781, 0.4745051860809326, 0.07251165062189102, -0.176405668258667, -1.1042760610580444, 0.9265202283859253, -0.9220572710037231, 0.0336524099111557, -0.19334913790225983, 0.07487975060939789, -1.1045989990234375, 0.546552836894989, -0.9318283200263977, 0.18792754411697388, -0.01180714275687933, 0.5635839104652405, -0.8769963979721069, -0.5251691937446594, 0.5112779140472412, -0.036765407770872116, 0.9620622396469116, 0.37303903698921204, 0.12418424338102341, 0.0077856737188994884, -0.11893533170223236, 0.18415144085884094, 0.5467580556869507, 0.18125726282596588, 0.2897247076034546, 0.028924986720085144, -0.0020298503804951906, 0.7044814825057983, -0.9601833820343018, -0.218451589345932, 0.6654055118560791, 0.6227041482925415, 0.19851113855838776, -0.13148902356624603, -0.25066807866096497, 0.50005704164505, 0.10804658383131027, 0.2547609210014343, 0.6136946082115173, 0.03765716031193733, 0.7966518998146057, 0.6967083811759949, -0.02578018419444561, 0.1293077915906906, -0.687119722366333, -0.08013878762722015, 0.3855905830860138, -0.378324031829834, -0.05571247264742851, -0.3444693684577942, -0.7307800650596619, 0.5958676338195801, -0.7955294847488403, 0.8583143949508667, -0.11739113926887512, 0.07277712225914001, 0.19012437760829926, 0.21093948185443878, -0.9074395298957825, 0.09249421209096909, -0.06203494966030121, 0.0022039031609892845, -0.48105254769325256, -0.32738423347473145, -0.022385189309716225, 0.15024752914905548, -0.04120320826768875, -0.44945013523101807, 0.20351000130176544, 0.4825349450111389, 0.7405405044555664, 0.273316890001297, 0.0875808596611023, -0.30567696690559387, -1.314536452293396, -0.4022883474826813, -0.5213584899902344, 0.5723262429237366, -0.6931375861167908, -0.14626863598823547, 0.6084195375442505, -0.9030473232269287, 0.22130435705184937, -0.47920092940330505, 0.5744184255599976, 0.8116909265518188, 0.4160083830356598, 0.7565984129905701, 0.371269166469574, -0.05320590361952782, -0.8671078085899353, 0.41461724042892456, -0.5112903714179993, 0.19488191604614258, 0.19276879727840424, 0.05800248682498932, 0.9964755773544312, -0.2672019898891449, 0.0745341032743454, -0.5049229264259338, -0.29943180084228516, 0.07261557877063751, 0.522216260433197, -0.37703219056129456, 0.22915107011795044, 0.37115278840065, -0.49848228693008423, -0.3896714150905609, -0.5454981923103333, 1.2080104351043701, 0.1077440083026886, -0.03111896477639675, 0.010486460290849209, 0.10098110139369965, -0.42632198333740234, 0.7447988986968994, -0.3650835454463959, 0.33141955733299255, 0.1398152858018875, 0.46828362345695496, 0.5892404317855835, -0.17626075446605682, -0.04635896533727646, -0.9239215850830078, -0.4746844172477722, 0.4701833128929138, 0.2540816366672516, -0.960435688495636, -0.39713090658187866, 0.7182572484016418, -0.3857388496398926, -0.5834355354309082, -0.04891010373830795, -1.2537550926208496, -0.5306538939476013, -0.0020363566000014544, -0.7691518664360046, 0.6892394423484802, -0.6748476028442383, -0.0010167196160182357, -0.5470359325408936, -0.02279553934931755, 0.8314999341964722, -0.059184979647397995, 0.0841158777475357, -0.6358966827392578, 0.4091229736804962, 0.20632041990756989, 0.667855978012085, -0.4262259304523468, 0.006085953209549189, -0.1710527390241623, 0.6205911636352539, 0.3900451362133026, -0.6462051272392273, 0.6551634073257446, 0.09857447445392609, -0.2055773288011551, 0.13352316617965698, 0.343697726726532, -0.515034556388855, -0.6013944745063782, -0.4305664896965027, -0.4016217887401581, 0.396270215511322, 0.7226396799087524, -0.4455685615539551, 0.4171532690525055, -0.34238201379776, -0.47502681612968445, 0.6348459720611572, 0.24793462455272675, 0.7416350841522217, -1.1778792142868042, 0.3822682499885559, -0.19991515576839447, -0.5182680487632751, 0.4168646037578583, -0.2512094974517822, 0.3754090368747711, 0.3987596333026886, 0.3295932114124298, 0.3401384651660919, -0.7057644128799438, 0.01846528798341751, -0.7792565822601318, 1.435521125793457, 0.37296414375305176, 0.647796630859375, 1.007126808166504, 0.3534855544567108, -0.032027777284383774, -0.3461640477180481, -0.7935478091239929, -0.38963180780410767, 0.1627652794122696, -0.4563654959201813, -0.8083916902542114, -0.2697240710258484, -0.32544660568237305, 1.0723079442977905, 0.31663545966148376, 0.532282292842865, 0.130710169672966, 0.6260336637496948, 0.2706950902938843, 0.2983662486076355, 0.40001630783081055, 0.05443611741065979, -0.1252712905406952, -1.0100722312927246, 0.3313096761703491, -0.01930461823940277, 0.6471028923988342, -0.09199066460132599, -0.9490906596183777, -0.7356870174407959, -0.751409649848938, 0.4928026497364044, -0.3881281018257141, -0.31916412711143494, 0.7717432379722595, 0.03875347971916199, 0.5018117427825928, -0.33090463280677795, 0.25189271569252014, -0.036810435354709625, 0.12112279236316681, 0.5192616581916809, -1.2637336254119873, -0.18546590209007263, 0.39219918847084045, 0.8992003202438354, 1.0724745988845825, -0.02299658954143524, -1.2527376413345337, -0.47280019521713257, 0.47516927123069763, -0.8065992593765259, -0.378359317779541, 0.9448760151863098, 0.31130287051200867, 0.08554524928331375, 0.07667918503284454, 0.1510329693555832, 0.43432366847991943, -0.7517176270484924, -0.49563875794410706, -0.48554593324661255, -0.17378747463226318, -0.6730554103851318, 0.3547765612602234, 0.012145847082138062, -0.20442362129688263, -0.22364309430122375, -0.06309529393911362, -0.517609715461731, -0.39300891757011414, -0.6873571872711182, 0.537222683429718, -0.4851715564727783, -0.38254863023757935, 0.6032121181488037, 0.07360096275806427, -0.1431802362203598, -0.29534220695495605, 0.44219717383384705, -0.22407974302768707, -0.07110511511564255, 0.6446357369422913, 0.4374676048755646, 0.5888177156448364, 0.28712406754493713, 0.46808233857154846, -0.023586424067616463, 0.5793641209602356, 0.026617879047989845, -0.22618940472602844, 0.3229694962501526, 0.1779671609401703, -0.5643584132194519, -0.7250486016273499, 0.23511968553066254, -0.7237353324890137, -0.7809440493583679, 0.16118070483207703, 0.2867555320262909, 1.0790668725967407, 0.3584918975830078, -0.8753790855407715, -0.10862412303686142, -0.16742472350597382, -0.9933308362960815, 0.4070674777030945, 0.04711685702204704, -0.32868507504463196, 0.20222239196300507, 0.04461054876446724, -0.5331612229347229, 0.21440976858139038, -0.06046811491250992, -0.38107359409332275, 0.49029773473739624, 0.35920488834381104, -0.11657492816448212, 0.7116551399230957, -0.6180737018585205, 0.2230430394411087, -0.4863710105419159, 0.4683546721935272, 0.029879555106163025, -0.13677959144115448, -0.09713384509086609, 0.3160026967525482, -0.2831028699874878, -0.42468565702438354, -0.14873778820037842, -0.4299902021884918, -0.08643905818462372, 0.052016161382198334, 0.22919268906116486, 0.10101427882909775, -1.1175035238265991, 0.8909651637077332, 0.368010550737381, -0.5796732306480408, 0.006555249448865652, 0.5013341307640076, 0.2931946814060211, 0.6835004687309265, 0.024030586704611778, -0.31610164046287537, 0.7190749645233154, -0.35836127400398254, 0.6814485788345337, -1.0473041534423828, -0.3071674704551697, -0.30099624395370483, -0.2962704598903656, -0.1667981743812561, 0.6018174290657043, -0.07576027512550354, 0.30960315465927124, -0.1746797263622284, 0.10489185154438019, -0.26411956548690796, -0.19526386260986328, 0.011138586327433586, -0.3853100836277008, -0.9138288497924805, -0.6841043829917908, 0.14315296709537506, -0.19834963977336884, 0.3163416385650635, -0.030051881447434425, -0.2780950665473938, -0.4065428376197815, 0.4076528549194336, 0.10661255568265915, 0.7663877606391907, -0.21653856337070465, -0.10245975106954575, -0.4956034719944, 0.3697868883609772, -0.4591469168663025, 0.4972218871116638, -0.7867744565010071, 0.8369873762130737, -0.5515044927597046, -0.43281090259552, -0.1099989116191864, 0.20087622106075287, 0.3330655097961426, -1.2321364879608154, 0.32813334465026855, 0.4156259000301361, -0.005794057156890631, 0.5916489362716675, 0.1194903701543808, -0.6135198473930359, -0.39713162183761597, -0.605272114276886, -1.066335916519165, 0.44167500734329224, -0.35367968678474426, -0.0805390328168869, -0.25007516145706177, -0.5785940885543823, -0.34798502922058105, 0.16470958292484283, 0.5547121167182922, 0.6397843956947327, -0.011165984906256199, -0.6531843543052673, 0.2555774748325348, 0.022705107927322388, -0.28926894068717957, -0.3374868929386139, 0.056147072464227676, -0.1844005584716797, 0.24097828567028046, -0.03999141976237297, -0.8992784023284912, -0.7558805346488953, -0.26615315675735474, 0.5469791293144226, 0.03677750378847122, -0.06431286782026291, 0.5748237371444702, -0.3338809013366699, -0.07992333173751831, -0.11895371228456497, -0.5441442131996155, -0.5417097210884094, 0.4074963629245758, 0.9326546788215637, 0.4352458119392395, 0.18156754970550537, 0.018477708101272583, 0.7328731417655945, -0.45633113384246826, -0.56482994556427, -0.07400002330541611, -0.35086366534233093, 0.047184400260448456, 0.9513062238693237, 0.06321031600236893, -0.8920782208442688, -0.5299308896064758, -0.6849421262741089, 0.15747609734535217, -0.7374047636985779, -0.820686399936676, -0.11177138239145279, -0.6081219911575317, -0.7061024308204651, 0.3824942708015442, 0.8348593711853027, 0.27322423458099365, 0.20411400496959686, -0.03915587067604065, 0.004849891643971205, -0.17549455165863037, -0.3603740930557251, 1.3700933456420898, -0.1708478331565857, -0.5860052108764648, -0.08891776949167252, -0.32539165019989014, -0.22769315540790558, 0.8319110870361328, 0.5016998648643494, -0.31194010376930237, 0.5572586059570312, -0.022337714210152626, 0.3632965385913849, 0.8142521381378174, 0.1363639384508133, -0.15349584817886353, -0.36621564626693726, -0.01843390241265297, -0.9061384797096252, -0.18475760519504547, -0.5647310018539429, 0.5927117466926575, 0.6490376591682434, 0.05325520783662796, 0.5570513606071472, -0.1430167704820633, -0.4865230619907379, -0.749859631061554, -0.6975928544998169, -0.2739771008491516, -1.3752936124801636, -0.4955527186393738, -0.7108151316642761, -0.33300307393074036, 0.21956676244735718, 0.48336344957351685, 0.04187297448515892, 0.09859084337949753, -1.0633091926574707, -0.15975908935070038, 0.11442845314741135, -0.5073522329330444, 0.3861593008041382, -0.20446215569972992, -1.2540955543518066, 0.14252153038978577, -0.16504423320293427, 0.5231558680534363, -0.6329701542854309, -0.17999224364757538, 0.11458417028188705, 0.4852316379547119, -0.5507100820541382, 0.6400205492973328, -0.7123550176620483, -0.7654374837875366, 0.22226232290267944, 0.3243945240974426, -0.5673933029174805, -0.07778026908636093, 0.4913206994533539, -0.024276813492178917, 0.6308120489120483, -0.25534787774086, -0.12667794525623322, -0.32745131850242615, -0.8455362319946289, -0.158316507935524, -0.5468363165855408, -0.49574539065361023, -0.08287660777568817, -0.48872047662734985, 0.3333244323730469, 0.8857150077819824, -1.2114362716674805, -0.004799913614988327, -0.6006121039390564, 0.24007876217365265, -0.2322462648153305, -0.08929029852151871, -0.4237259030342102, 0.36718907952308655, -0.4994405210018158, 0.8359103202819824, -0.12063124030828476, -0.040852971374988556, 0.16413092613220215, -0.021502774208784103, -0.39261534810066223, 0.6374265551567078, -0.4603559970855713, 0.5466040968894958, -0.4397869408130646, 0.2519155442714691, -0.6411813497543335, 0.7327464818954468, -0.5176647305488586, -0.29105255007743835, -0.601262092590332, -0.5238125920295715, -0.3569178581237793, 0.4213198125362396, 0.2758603096008301, -0.6989343762397766, 0.21952933073043823, -0.7044063806533813, -0.8108488917350769, 0.11548434942960739, -0.21489198505878448, -0.11534078419208527, -0.6370288729667664, -0.9823071360588074, -0.02426530234515667, 0.26549285650253296, 0.10038124769926071, 0.5522465109825134, 0.6217866539955139, 0.3173756003379822, -0.6648823618888855, 0.18771085143089294, -0.554671049118042, 0.09706582129001617, -0.9630240797996521, -0.2507879137992859, -0.19948142766952515, 0.056963928043842316, -0.3333118259906769, -0.7298160791397095, -0.03604166954755783, 0.714876651763916, -0.22356410324573517, 0.0005713698919862509, -0.1864270269870758, 0.48281604051589966, 0.3478146195411682, 0.442015141248703, 0.11184269189834595, 0.010848894715309143, 0.30337801575660706, 0.7992498874664307, 0.1723049432039261, 0.03601213917136192, 0.8660861253738403, 0.5751680135726929, 0.05655989050865173, -0.07964178174734116, -0.48452678322792053, 0.5954694151878357, 0.20229069888591766, -0.7703408002853394, 1.0070468187332153, -0.3474889099597931, 0.8762018084526062, 0.32456785440444946, -0.08347304165363312, 0.012632305733859539, 0.7486480474472046, 0.48903700709342957, 0.7382766604423523, 0.3181988298892975, 0.11366013437509537, 0.33903735876083374, 0.10904651135206223, 0.20514151453971863, 0.2763306200504303, 0.9272025227546692, 0.4164891242980957, 1.0601458549499512, 0.12046143412590027, -0.32540076971054077, 0.09021024405956268, 0.19115076959133148, -0.022772587835788727, -0.2693205177783966, -0.21417385339736938, 0.014263259246945381, -0.17807161808013916, 0.7296521663665771, -0.89211505651474, 0.06010495871305466, 0.023829583078622818, -0.07552817463874817, 0.38299286365509033, 0.35581815242767334, -0.5701562166213989, 0.41495805978775024, 0.6163942217826843, 0.608444333076477, 0.2587188482284546, 0.47359079122543335, 0.1241861954331398, 0.2936922609806061, 0.09162089973688126, 0.8131043910980225, 0.5512018799781799, 0.3215676248073578, 0.7618833780288696, -1.2246555089950562, 0.23510439693927765, 0.6406761407852173, -1.323225736618042, 0.263737291097641, -0.11631529778242111, -0.6107721924781799, -0.08723076432943344, -0.07693216949701309, 0.6462396383285522, -0.792868435382843, 0.30554065108299255, 0.924235463142395, 0.15654224157333374, 0.6378637552261353, 0.3641718029975891, -0.009626362472772598, -0.24567824602127075, 1.105014443397522, -0.4056522846221924, 0.3173903822898865, 0.9472382664680481, 1.112661600112915, -0.7558740973472595, 0.7609221339225769, 0.45550867915153503, 0.1111270859837532, 0.4578709006309509, 0.28545552492141724, -0.035992223769426346, 0.05041060969233513, -0.21781423687934875, -1.007658839225769, 0.2896108627319336, 0.09850575029850006, -0.028594113886356354, 0.1722669154405594, -0.01844131387770176, 0.3414236009120941, -0.5977550745010376, -0.2987822890281677, 1.238050937652588, 0.13878725469112396, -0.16732490062713623, -0.07435335218906403, -0.7102499008178711, -0.3077455163002014, 0.0734085664153099, -0.5805875062942505, 0.7562878131866455, 0.15382643043994904, 0.319320410490036, 0.19899457693099976, -1.018389344215393, -0.3431690037250519, -0.9167295098304749, 0.15304534137248993, -0.12090924382209778, 0.45482054352760315, 0.2543559670448303, 0.5423303246498108, 0.24195517599582672, -0.2908706068992615, 0.13548071682453156, 0.3235321640968323, 1.2350575923919678, -0.1568550318479538, 0.22377203404903412, 0.1649147868156433, 0.6366796493530273, -0.20159749686717987, 1.1185276508331299, 0.4986824095249176, -0.7549490332603455, 0.547492504119873, -0.3597604036331177, -0.0072433375753462315, 0.24815241992473602, -0.12109142541885376, 0.3121504783630371, -0.13020946085453033, -0.2022944837808609, -0.177413210272789, -0.06766662001609802, -0.932279646396637, -0.6487780213356018, -0.3882794678211212, -0.935224175453186, 0.12875553965568542, -0.7220542430877686, 1.0218578577041626, 0.07711493968963623, -0.34412941336631775, 4.131654739379883, 1.0632102489471436, 0.44300541281700134, 0.018858501687645912, 0.8224073648452759, 0.36450842022895813, -0.24113677442073822, -0.6017799377441406, 0.26339730620384216, -0.9035438895225525, -0.07490652799606323, -0.2960394620895386, 0.04342532902956009, -0.5460758209228516, -0.3821355700492859, 0.993698000907898, 0.09056052565574646, 0.315570205450058, -0.29855743050575256, -0.6234563589096069, -0.14181089401245117, 0.26361092925071716, -0.10010918229818344, -0.07963971048593521, 0.12377376109361649, -0.3427394926548004, 0.4246220886707306, -1.039713740348816, -0.9308662414550781, -0.5961124300956726, -0.3255578875541687, -0.8968819379806519, -0.3172485828399658, -0.8403213024139404, -0.5976689457893372, 0.28043124079704285, 0.22561614215373993, 0.13031324744224548, 0.44991999864578247, 0.13245998322963715, -0.2273768037557602, -0.48224514722824097, -0.21444286406040192, 0.18831203877925873, -1.1305193901062012, 0.8097441792488098, -0.7144269943237305, 1.5573972463607788, 0.18917584419250488, -0.4588392972946167, 0.6909719705581665, -0.30087652802467346, 0.20661723613739014, -0.4733485281467438, -0.6313775777816772, 0.383486807346344, -0.2664697766304016, 0.01675654947757721, -0.29254642128944397, 0.08772821724414825, 0.8921307325363159, -0.06011654809117317, -0.5551838874816895, -0.00913067813962698, 0.4512559473514557, 0.7660208344459534, 0.44596508145332336, 0.18156231939792633, -0.21128937602043152, 0.277323454618454, -0.27742183208465576, -0.07960652559995651, -1.0982847213745117, 0.10220690071582794, 0.5763278603553772, -0.25843673944473267, -0.5632330179214478, 0.2728179693222046, 0.09064734727144241, -0.3994700312614441, -0.26734817028045654, -0.5556747913360596, -0.3353738486766815, 0.03411776199936867, -0.7578009366989136, 1.2333980798721313, -0.29339367151260376, 0.19502432644367218, -0.0924113467335701, 0.4517832100391388, 0.09812519699335098, 1.6578114032745361, 0.10701510310173035, -0.4367635250091553, -0.882644534111023 ]
Magnetic and Dynamic Properties of the Hubbard Model in Infinite Dimensions
An essentially exact solution of the infinite dimensional Hubbard model is made possible by using a self-consistent mapping of the Hubbard model in this limit to an effective single impurity Anderson model. Solving the latter with quantum Monte Carlo procedures enables us to obtain exact results for the one and two-particle properties of the infinite dimensional Hubbard model. In particular we find antiferromagnetism and a pseudogap in the single-particle density of states for sufficiently large values of the intrasite Coulomb interaction at half filling. Both the antiferromagnetic phase and the insulating phase above the N\'eel temperature are found to be quickly suppressed on doping. The latter is replaced by a heavy electron metal with a quasiparticle mass strongly dependent on doping as soon as $n<1$. At half filling the antiferromagnetic phase boundary agrees surprisingly well in shape and order of magnitude with results for the three dimensional Hubbard model.
M. Jarrell and Thomas Pruschke
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207012
cond-mat/9207013
[ -0.3504519760608673, -0.6110219359397888, -0.10646338760852814, -0.22158391773700714, 0.493949830532074, -0.277062326669693, -0.0876847431063652, 0.03726636618375778, -1.0628365278244019, 1.6766862869262695, 1.225398302078247, 0.0797693058848381, 0.6039467453956604, -0.33476701378822327, -0.3203429579734802, 0.3944297432899475, -0.38939887285232544, -0.7477132081985474, -1.3222393989562988, 0.901947557926178, 0.2750310003757477, 0.18444064259529114, -1.2288435697555542, -0.5838028192520142, -0.46405228972435, 0.8375856876373291, 0.6312786340713501, 0.7669764757156372, 0.9863189458847046, 0.20556610822677612, 0.2331438660621643, -0.7788079380989075, 0.04871486499905586, -0.23807357251644135, -0.4340449273586273, -0.5892686247825623, -0.26419830322265625, -0.08760418742895126, 1.1664406061172485, -0.15844538807868958, 0.9119793772697449, 0.083594910800457, 0.678578794002533, -0.29847487807273865, -0.9232467412948608, 0.2942671775817871, -0.6969327926635742, 0.21901483833789825, -0.24296188354492188, -1.2945176362991333, 0.5703253149986267, 0.1434207558631897, 0.7185192704200745, -0.3444248139858246, -0.2645997107028961, -0.13622993230819702, 0.5633665919303894, 0.01600346714258194, -0.7138159871101379, 0.018082953989505768, 0.3017824590206146, 0.16088134050369263, 0.6788936257362366, -0.874703586101532, 0.2066456377506256, 0.5455437302589417, -0.6237801313400269, 0.2811517119407654, -0.2751944959163666, -0.8101153373718262, -0.23823866248130798, -0.12743666768074036, -0.6617525219917297, 0.11384287476539612, -1.1644258499145508, 0.11221233755350113, -0.05573860928416252, -0.5823699831962585, -1.2019424438476562, -0.12756116688251495, 0.07519900798797607, 0.51503986120224, -0.4327510595321655, 0.3352775573730469, 0.10424574464559555, 0.3714710772037506, 0.14409133791923523, -0.3140327036380768, -0.27587682008743286, -0.0999714583158493, 0.0831085592508316, 0.953649640083313, 0.09636922180652618, -0.24433565139770508, 0.9301664233207703, 0.4993162155151367, 0.06989431381225586, 0.45501425862312317, 0.06294455379247665, -0.02876937761902809, -0.10133381187915802, 0.4176994562149048, 0.6215667128562927, 1.0225367546081543, -0.9693341851234436, 0.3478071391582489, -0.15251198410987854, 0.07592464983463287, -0.26853498816490173, -0.5926512479782104, 0.7891555428504944, -0.17668205499649048, 1.1304813623428345, 0.17457301914691925, 0.028681814670562744, 0.3342878222465515, 0.25986379384994507, 0.287282258272171, -1.2085590362548828, -0.31330227851867676, 0.02198820188641548, -0.30571112036705017, 0.8069481253623962, 0.6643680930137634, -0.39049285650253296, -0.7909004092216492, 0.7782127261161804, 0.42674899101257324, -0.6458733677864075, 0.38404709100723267, 0.7057593464851379, -0.20640863478183746, 0.16131529211997986, 0.3059099018573761, -0.9155635237693787, 0.264037549495697, -0.527121901512146, 0.05088605731725693, 0.4422041177749634, 0.11597242206335068, 0.9893456697463989, -0.7468301057815552, 0.7568240761756897, 0.2972554564476013, 0.04689282551407814, -0.0035506202839314938, 0.8076174259185791, 0.17281921207904816, -0.41111046075820923, 0.2629204988479614, -0.11363402754068375, -0.6298247575759888, -0.004424527287483215, 0.18038572371006012, 0.16181975603103638, 0.2978944480419159, 0.09937543421983719, 0.3254198431968689, -0.10839725285768509, -0.24776442348957062, 0.6608098745346069, -0.025370191782712936, -0.11172761768102646, 0.795695960521698, 0.30331042408943176, 0.41245898604393005, -0.20576150715351105, -0.8675599694252014, 0.2911047339439392, -0.1828666776418686, -0.026561830192804337, 0.2217700332403183, -0.29775041341781616, 0.7550240159034729, 0.21580855548381805, 0.03862984851002693, 0.576901912689209, -0.5001657605171204, 0.04217614233493805, 0.9342987537384033, -0.0228995643556118, -0.4400462210178375, 1.6756616830825806, 0.4301895201206207, -1.0984718799591064, -0.44615909457206726, 0.3054758906364441, -0.7251617312431335, -0.15751151740550995, 0.07121387869119644, 0.11621794104576111, 0.25914961099624634, 0.10549695789813995, 0.26443615555763245, -1.0001704692840576, 0.6481483578681946, -1.8563152551651, 0.20549629628658295, -0.2250373214483261, -0.4698600471019745, -0.5394905209541321, 0.27293288707733154, -0.8066525459289551, 0.233422189950943, -1.7050373554229736, 0.1453128159046173, 0.40398550033569336, 1.036011815071106, -0.3990049362182617, 0.2737322747707367, 0.4804956316947937, -0.4334612190723419, 0.7992643713951111, -0.37698206305503845, 0.21366100013256073, 0.3077038824558258, -0.4568047821521759, 0.5449059009552002, -0.18961603939533234, 0.44943591952323914, 0.44848886132240295, 0.9665884375572205, -0.37167635560035706, 0.9262082576751709, -0.23527269065380096, -0.14595144987106323, 0.07442757487297058, 0.8445320129394531, 0.037289902567863464, 0.1723092496395111, 0.3304060101509094, 0.07774379849433899, 0.7396109700202942, 0.4070453345775604, 0.3552643358707428, 0.5022547245025635, -0.26908954977989197, 0.6525595188140869, 0.963629424571991, 0.16139338910579681, -0.15639519691467285, -0.7011974453926086, 0.5983012914657593, -0.4504275918006897, -0.25374677777290344, 0.0735718235373497, -0.5754362344741821, 0.4960832893848419, -0.5141292810440063, 0.5685580968856812, 0.07864776998758316, 0.1417701244354248, -0.06699728220701218, 0.5653316974639893, -1.0527905225753784, 0.14594562351703644, 0.058601778000593185, 0.11782006919384003, -0.751957356929779, -0.4905218780040741, 0.18056747317314148, 0.22548818588256836, 0.01629452034831047, -0.7419813275337219, -0.37662473320961, 0.09297488629817963, -0.07263904809951782, -0.11663027107715607, -0.13786077499389648, -0.25102168321609497, -1.352765679359436, -0.4140737056732178, -1.1172096729278564, -0.09563467651605606, -1.0803096294403076, 0.3836596608161926, 0.5251004695892334, -0.9971761703491211, 0.7303170561790466, 0.01884228177368641, -0.036834217607975006, 0.23093397915363312, -0.25839707255363464, 0.2520049810409546, 0.7720409631729126, 0.39623695611953735, -0.8141643404960632, 0.04437839612364769, -0.9168136119842529, 0.2421485036611557, -0.32897448539733887, 0.060716141015291214, 1.3586413860321045, 0.3570851683616638, 0.3685711920261383, -0.6613478064537048, -0.7557480931282043, -0.5219827890396118, 0.48869842290878296, -0.5564306378364563, -0.10469158738851547, 0.3742293417453766, -0.00700482027605176, 0.5926735401153564, -0.7247330546379089, 0.9852793216705322, -0.18117231130599976, -0.7511357069015503, 0.6181638240814209, 0.4112054705619812, -0.7574071288108826, 0.5262696146965027, 0.06155706197023392, -0.01583576574921608, -0.028144098818302155, 0.5092688798904419, 0.5808353424072266, -0.17603136599063873, -0.21547053754329681, -0.4822922646999359, 0.07704465091228485, 0.5125454664230347, -0.33537280559539795, -0.8689953088760376, -0.11920829117298126, 0.4410460293292999, 0.073813796043396, -0.21877910196781158, -0.3363173007965088, -1.2758100032806396, -0.481781005859375, -0.16337703168392181, -0.5582662224769592, 0.3617708384990692, -0.26085540652275085, 0.7540577054023743, -0.7706524133682251, 0.5419725775718689, 0.2318340241909027, 0.485331267118454, 0.3038783669471741, -0.6153897643089294, 0.3862569332122803, -0.22673331201076508, 0.8939697742462158, -0.15847620368003845, 0.30269381403923035, -0.07880565524101257, -0.45662856101989746, 0.19565248489379883, 0.25334790349006653, 0.5681828260421753, 0.21682989597320557, -0.29404953122138977, 0.25209707021713257, 0.3802124261856079, -0.29960131645202637, -0.5168063640594482, -0.32777705788612366, -0.18581269681453705, 0.13803264498710632, 0.2954222559928894, 0.03043578751385212, -0.8434188365936279, -0.7512651681900024, -0.4107089340686798, 0.08428455144166946, 0.5286293625831604, 0.30166637897491455, -0.09733208268880844, 0.7699114084243774, 0.6392673850059509, -0.29817995429039, 0.6032919883728027, 0.06708788871765137, 0.6004117131233215, 0.4759770631790161, 0.9827077984809875, 0.16786080598831177, -0.7991795539855957, -0.3795554041862488, 0.33571791648864746, 1.5323244333267212, -0.30194613337516785, 0.9335018992424011, 0.13578800857067108, 0.25525522232055664, -0.005061418283730745, -0.9363993406295776, 0.10468132048845291, -0.27457746863365173, -0.32056212425231934, -0.19013480842113495, -0.2860181927680969, 0.3369603753089905, -0.18457722663879395, 0.05915619432926178, -0.11777979135513306, 0.5621775984764099, -0.05997323989868164, 1.1025211811065674, 1.2407665252685547, 0.34829750657081604, 0.5008897185325623, -0.9205664992332458, -0.6939913630485535, -0.4015188217163086, 0.44375085830688477, 0.5522797107696533, 0.21163634955883026, -1.0628689527511597, -0.06076735258102417, -0.2525654137134552, -0.1529179811477661, 0.019255341961979866, 0.11794430762529373, -0.3048095107078552, 0.397127628326416, 0.1727294921875, 0.5853348970413208, -0.3474246561527252, 0.1573648601770401, 0.3993421792984009, 0.46592947840690613, 1.1542315483093262, -0.35282614827156067, -0.33340200781822205, -0.5651160478591919, 0.27580755949020386, 0.761617124080658, 0.241197407245636, -0.6033177375793457, -0.7841918468475342, 0.46073082089424133, -0.6617759466171265, -0.44523417949676514, 1.2037650346755981, 1.1520187854766846, 0.022681765258312225, -0.5606580376625061, 0.1663815826177597, 0.5730406641960144, -0.7087625861167908, -0.20831634104251862, -0.40284043550491333, -0.8295873403549194, -0.0056623900309205055, 0.5655720829963684, -0.16408532857894897, -0.16693341732025146, 0.1458890587091446, -0.052498605102300644, -0.6555039882659912, -0.01270737498998642, -0.08767450600862503, -0.43354007601737976, -0.15432703495025635, -0.5653523206710815, 0.20308691263198853, 0.6862617135047913, -0.26047971844673157, -0.0731310024857521, 0.44205981492996216, 0.032936323434114456, -0.5298969149589539, 0.09956551343202591, 0.1342235654592514, 0.7880268692970276, 0.44927704334259033, 0.8302556276321411, 0.12713997066020966, 0.1267113983631134, -0.3280753791332245, -0.19947239756584167, 0.39775532484054565, -0.11694587022066116, -0.4506182372570038, 0.23484019935131073, -0.11297223716974258, -0.5193843841552734, -0.29892411828041077, 0.09031042456626892, 0.2754613757133484, 0.8220476508140564, 0.9921437501907349, -0.8352446556091309, -0.3607155680656433, 0.1773671656847, -1.356581449508667, -0.21089278161525726, -0.5793248414993286, 0.11417774111032486, 0.23685817420482635, -0.06044965609908104, -0.4911818206310272, -0.2490164190530777, -0.4580564796924591, -0.8032415509223938, -0.32831186056137085, 0.5243667960166931, 0.555850625038147, 1.1066854000091553, 0.11618731915950775, 0.06863383203744888, -0.35025566816329956, 0.6773151159286499, -0.5870598554611206, -0.4248443841934204, 0.04609042406082153, -0.5603940486907959, -0.04533086717128754, -0.1537378430366516, 0.06957010179758072, -0.42527925968170166, 0.04913763329386711, -0.09098520874977112, 0.33509063720703125, -0.29020655155181885, -0.6873776912689209, 0.29490864276885986, 0.33038127422332764, -0.1277405172586441, 0.06531628221273422, 0.3377276360988617, 0.4940912425518036, -0.1946404129266739, -0.5139223337173462, -0.4653630256652832, -0.2533469498157501, -0.3352132737636566, 0.5156808495521545, -1.678931713104248, -0.27390143275260925, -0.4635526239871979, 0.00724259577691555, 0.06839856505393982, 0.7304263710975647, -0.32772958278656006, -0.8904051780700684, -0.2687793970108032, -0.7338042259216309, -0.717522919178009, -0.574532687664032, -0.4246613383293152, -0.6743079423904419, -1.1535086631774902, -0.18291981518268585, 0.5449061989784241, -0.16861461102962494, 0.6442143321037292, 0.410550981760025, -0.568915843963623, 0.000699981115758419, 0.6258001327514648, 0.31839606165885925, -0.06308099627494812, -0.3505620062351227, 0.6512776017189026, 0.02997899055480957, -0.0022738943807780743, -0.6979524493217468, 0.44455063343048096, -1.3242334127426147, 1.202375888824463, -0.3829527199268341, -0.38796526193618774, 0.27343636751174927, 0.41283148527145386, 0.44753196835517883, -1.0414495468139648, -0.12619571387767792, -0.19604314863681793, -0.10406792908906937, 0.6975820064544678, 0.22307543456554413, 0.1395174115896225, -0.6113432049751282, -0.3668890595436096, -0.7920750379562378, 0.3643242418766022, 0.20919795334339142, 0.5774975419044495, -0.6368770003318787, -0.7036430239677429, 0.6661118865013123, -0.05019405111670494, 0.5934799313545227, 0.4091482162475586, 0.7150850892066956, -0.17165252566337585, -0.298918217420578, 0.07308991998434067, -0.36600401997566223, -0.605225682258606, -1.0793373584747314, -0.5083048343658447, -0.3895178437232971, 0.825924277305603, -0.518290102481842, -0.685577929019928, -0.13420985639095306, -0.12234313786029816, -0.051616717129945755, -0.5952253937721252, 0.16187742352485657, -0.35245782136917114, -0.048205554485321045, -0.17095354199409485, 0.31913089752197266, 0.1365111619234085, 0.35902199149131775, 0.4032498598098755, 0.4152815043926239, 0.3880728483200073, -0.2674948275089264, 0.5681086182594299, -0.17275536060333252, 0.022631926462054253, 0.7661629915237427, -0.7218958735466003, -0.04276702553033829, 1.1871055364608765, 0.6737521886825562, -1.012171745300293, -0.8230323791503906, -1.0514076948165894, -0.6154336929321289, -0.17953352630138397, -0.5739967226982117, -0.3493013381958008, -0.08229850977659225, -0.5204207897186279, -0.3880923390388489, 0.6400635242462158, 0.7714982628822327, 0.10576154291629791, 0.026516245678067207, 0.06542328745126724, -0.0400361642241478, -0.24810349941253662, 0.7223355770111084, -0.522434413433075, -1.3007317781448364, -0.16417457163333893, 0.20251786708831787, -0.4489765167236328, 0.1482376903295517, 0.3609418272972107, 0.0005201344611123204, 0.2087438404560089, 0.4098125398159027, 0.6148359775543213, 0.7773005366325378, -0.3461497128009796, 0.0550810769200325, -0.41593074798583984, -0.2975580096244812, -0.5020914673805237, -1.026320457458496, -0.7996810674667358, 0.5874962210655212, 0.0590120404958725, -0.3259233236312866, -0.12607376277446747, 0.41735002398490906, -0.2766980230808258, -0.23041203618049622, -0.7569898366928101, 0.16150037944316864, -1.5592619180679321, -0.011184129863977432, -0.5872204899787903, 0.5665529370307922, 0.567033052444458, 0.7461289167404175, -0.5451276898384094, -0.1168377697467804, -1.1622285842895508, -0.28061962127685547, -0.2344440519809723, 0.4354953467845917, -0.7501023411750793, -0.3894003629684448, -0.8161421418190002, -0.4521219730377197, -0.13219544291496277, 0.052937109023332596, -0.6680741310119629, -0.44705989956855774, -0.12939289212226868, 0.3516298532485962, 0.22000598907470703, 1.0397083759307861, -0.6596320867538452, -0.8857678771018982, -0.08416596800088882, -0.2696225941181183, -0.8096911907196045, 0.2918492555618286, 0.05088990926742554, 0.9288038015365601, -0.2452741116285324, 0.5338208079338074, 0.334236741065979, -0.12570439279079437, -0.6611457467079163, 0.0415775440633297, -0.2373623102903366, -0.3825366199016571, 0.13375495374202728, -0.772678792476654, -0.01225897204130888, -0.4434768557548523, -0.4726996123790741, -0.017290282994508743, -0.17058724164962769, -0.410991907119751, 0.1996455043554306, 0.0012108397204428911, 0.024061257019639015, -0.15242637693881989, -0.16052493453025818, 0.6787508726119995, 0.036487482488155365, 0.14637906849384308, -0.22152547538280487, 0.4482574462890625, -0.49859070777893066, 1.0422025918960571, -0.21113529801368713, 0.7057235836982727, 0.08111979067325592, 0.08560040593147278, -0.09512849152088165, 0.6775109767913818, -0.025665709748864174, -0.854438841342926, -0.4808538258075714, -0.29049602150917053, -0.05001678317785263, 0.2998118996620178, 0.8735355138778687, -0.0309397354722023, -0.035028647631406784, -0.8017846941947937, -1.2764867544174194, -0.8633456826210022, -0.7568987011909485, -0.5174160003662109, -0.2757454216480255, -0.6024758219718933, 0.1432255059480667, 0.06424887478351593, -0.3861720860004425, 0.6405796408653259, -0.09966898709535599, 0.5983679890632629, 0.14128433167934418, -0.9219257831573486, -0.3199828863143921, 0.1216249093413353, -1.1191695928573608, -0.4483150541782379, -0.32742828130722046, 0.6486712098121643, -0.055749353021383286, -1.126867413520813, 0.027424495667219162, 0.0018573491834104061, -0.18132518231868744, -0.3346116840839386, 0.11214268207550049, -0.39384618401527405, 0.06475899368524551, 0.08711084723472595, 0.12173201888799667, 0.055862896144390106, -0.28453314304351807, 0.5335242748260498, -0.422895610332489, -0.545294463634491, 0.7254341840744019, 0.10350004583597183, -0.18318234384059906, -0.15182137489318848, -0.08137169480323792, 1.1488391160964966, 0.482671320438385, -0.21520479023456573, 0.3654327392578125, 0.07497666031122208, 0.46525898575782776, 0.348577618598938, -0.40094074606895447, 0.1867000311613083, 0.45663022994995117, 0.37201976776123047, 1.2769255638122559, 0.25389382243156433, -0.40496230125427246, 0.220879927277565, -0.07160545140504837, 0.14126728475093842, 0.032805923372507095, 0.46225205063819885, 0.3944469094276428, 1.0727415084838867, 0.11937959492206573, -0.11212097853422165, 0.08596459776163101, 0.230826273560524, 0.6483410596847534, 0.48029735684394836, -0.31186044216156006, 0.1362166702747345, 0.09437968581914902, 0.26767614483833313, -0.7732677459716797, -0.08571807295084, -0.6920024752616882, -0.3047308921813965, -0.19828000664710999, 0.2353338897228241, 0.4605056047439575, 0.42071348428726196, 1.2383240461349487, 0.17883186042308807, 0.2776402235031128, 0.7109144330024719, -0.06630031019449234, 0.5093016624450684, 0.5292125344276428, 0.5816934704780579, 0.6727068424224854, 0.9166405200958252, -0.19705893099308014, -1.0699851512908936, -0.2708095908164978, 0.5417125821113586, -1.2095704078674316, -0.009021294303238392, -0.03154010698199272, -0.0741167888045311, -0.17439649999141693, -0.40754199028015137, 0.15731856226921082, -0.5003425478935242, 0.2892600893974304, 0.49062567949295044, -0.7322413325309753, 0.07757929712533951, 1.1808871030807495, -0.23482263088226318, 0.20761696994304657, 0.6078413724899292, 0.36460328102111816, 0.0903470516204834, 0.7456884980201721, 1.0069142580032349, -0.03143966943025589, 1.2169479131698608, 0.5403757691383362, -0.8400828838348389, 0.5299095511436462, 0.24981579184532166, -0.17915309965610504, 0.6067267656326294, 0.14601178467273712, -0.5016802549362183, 0.366102397441864, 0.24770870804786682, -0.039848778396844864, 0.25143033266067505, 0.4036366939544678, 0.2508088946342468, -0.17851170897483826, 0.002526066731661558, 1.5506576299667358, 0.8728002905845642, -0.5409420132637024, -1.0177621841430664, -0.44698071479797363, -1.2261961698532104, 0.48635295033454895, -1.099171757698059, 0.7898779511451721, 0.24393010139465332, -0.019049007445573807, -0.2458355575799942, -0.6961418986320496, -0.10552568733692169, -0.48533007502555847, 0.41756483912467957, -0.5153353810310364, 0.32995864748954773, 0.052998386323451996, -0.21948061883449554, -0.0756450742483139, -0.6601573824882507, -0.2636380195617676, 0.564591109752655, 0.7452096939086914, -0.3577234447002411, 0.008295583538711071, 0.582683265209198, 0.290475994348526, -0.5917031764984131, 0.6458271741867065, 0.3477798104286194, -0.6723424792289734, 0.6577156782150269, -0.7550220489501953, -0.04028961434960365, 0.17169329524040222, 0.01352472323924303, 0.3292030096054077, -0.3185153305530548, 0.2069995105266571, 0.14524391293525696, 0.02448253333568573, -0.1332332342863083, -0.6222383975982666, 0.14770370721817017, -0.7379065752029419, -0.008349615149199963, -0.493196964263916, 0.6351034045219421, 0.5354682803153992, -0.8564956188201904, 3.8551111221313477, 1.40117609500885, 0.8829436898231506, 0.8141006827354431, 0.6784929633140564, 1.4079585075378418, -0.8693199753761292, -0.07634251564741135, 0.38252368569374084, -1.3369027376174927, -0.3863147497177124, -0.15690061450004578, 0.4142213761806488, -0.2414373755455017, -0.9257946610450745, 0.2971053719520569, 0.03059753030538559, 0.5972863435745239, -0.17134760320186615, -0.9455699324607849, -0.5864821672439575, -0.6930516958236694, 0.22676533460617065, -0.4191807806491852, 0.48434317111968994, 0.44267964363098145, 0.2749115824699402, -1.1326833963394165, -0.2886941432952881, -0.059946730732917786, -0.7857638597488403, -0.1467272788286209, 0.21504512429237366, -0.761378824710846, -0.4400051236152649, 0.018090205267071724, 0.02044263295829296, -0.4887341558933258, 0.38611459732055664, -0.11498807370662689, 0.32986336946487427, -0.6490194201469421, 0.5009682178497314, -0.37608078122138977, -0.7815379500389099, 0.5176913738250732, -0.780259370803833, 0.8351292610168457, 0.052198730409145355, -0.7664452791213989, 0.08259905874729156, 0.3121185898780823, 0.5639076232910156, -0.7886793613433838, 0.006851742975413799, -0.09967835992574692, -0.8406028747558594, 0.273943156003952, 0.6725698709487915, -0.0878162533044815, 0.006401762831956148, 0.17487305402755737, 0.04538968205451965, 0.15353766083717346, -0.46185722947120667, 0.782453179359436, 0.3023343086242676, 0.5153028964996338, -0.8395189642906189, -0.054325491189956665, 0.31403711438179016, -0.8432081341743469, -0.6599656939506531, 0.5144296884536743, 0.18063698709011078, 0.542431652545929, -0.13972978293895721, 1.017992377281189, 0.43490487337112427, 0.18236902356147766, -0.2651332914829254, -0.3260587453842163, -0.1860956996679306, -0.9346250295639038, -0.007426104042679071, 0.5118947625160217, -0.08013495057821274, 0.3407537341117859, -0.009140802547335625, 0.6126499772071838, 0.5490942597389221, 1.6581498384475708, 0.40029236674308777, -0.18588219583034515, -1.3133679628372192 ]
The Majorana Fermions for Quantum S=1/2 Antiferromagnet?
Recently it has been suggested by A. M. Tsvelik that quantum S=1/2 antiferromagnet can be described by the Majorana fermions in an irreducible way and without any constraint. In contrast to this claim we shall show that this representation is highly reducible. It is a direct sum of four irreducible fundamental representations of $su(2)$ algebra.
Alexander Moroz
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207013
cond-mat/9207014
[ -0.7960394620895386, 0.41241657733917236, 0.7578004598617554, 0.12812241911888123, 0.5076147317886353, 0.3925252854824066, -0.32597506046295166, -0.3670121431350708, 0.7334520816802979, 0.5828280448913574, 0.26798784732818604, 0.025785353034734726, 0.7660916447639465, -0.2882453203201294, -0.6666120886802673, 0.9505079388618469, 0.01207640953361988, -0.17808157205581665, -1.1292810440063477, -0.34216904640197754, -0.04150563105940819, -0.32232409715652466, -0.7483240365982056, -0.8090631365776062, -0.1357332319021225, 0.4831368625164032, 0.03583800047636032, 0.02443373203277588, 1.2305021286010742, 1.0890750885009766, 0.08286798745393753, -0.09949081391096115, 0.55512934923172, -1.197431206703186, -0.31666335463523865, -0.05509822443127632, 0.6253818273544312, -0.3734070956707001, 0.49079766869544983, -0.20799927413463593, 1.857167363166809, -0.0322909951210022, 0.592094361782074, 0.11668179929256439, 0.1423604041337967, 0.1525316834449768, 0.13264010846614838, -0.0006704078987240791, -0.675068736076355, -0.5969781875610352, 0.1298707127571106, 0.3478384017944336, -0.2710331976413727, -0.8344932794570923, -0.17621047794818878, -0.03247516229748726, -0.6084182858467102, 0.3222748339176178, 0.19148583710193634, 0.2952594459056854, 0.6450185775756836, 0.17743028700351715, 0.21438607573509216, -0.5107658505439758, 0.5058943033218384, 1.5442436933517456, 0.15001682937145233, 0.17107948660850525, 0.48843634128570557, 0.4038636088371277, -0.8129655718803406, 0.3439885973930359, 0.14107343554496765, -0.12180252373218536, -0.19874078035354614, -0.14507761597633362, -0.318897008895874, -0.33127346634864807, -0.4662598967552185, -0.47539404034614563, -0.1863933950662613, -0.13179293274879456, -0.3334342837333679, 0.8234896063804626, -0.1849890798330307, -0.057080186903476715, -0.040342267602682114, 0.6824406981468201, 0.4344593584537506, 0.27277013659477234, 0.1958170384168625, 1.1639469861984253, 0.2714996933937073, -0.2636609673500061, 0.1855005919933319, 0.5447531938552856, -0.3184047341346741, 0.6449564099311829, 0.3397076427936554, 0.31204310059547424, 0.523118793964386, 1.0602190494537354, -0.7632036805152893, 0.005947427824139595, -0.7203465104103088, 0.9387064576148987, 0.38896989822387695, 0.1347966343164444, -0.14908067882061005, 0.031176699325442314, 0.6073744893074036, -0.17653530836105347, -0.14567779004573822, 0.19932083785533905, 0.13195586204528809, 0.8165379762649536, 0.8327283263206482, 0.38989323377609253, -0.48412027955055237, 0.2554558217525482, 0.04508208483457565, -0.12078312039375305, 0.06510287523269653, -0.2936108112335205, -0.6392028331756592, -0.6522149443626404, -0.22848045825958252, 0.8862863183021545, 0.06378639489412308, -0.5009719133377075, 0.03539581969380379, -0.4268593192100525, -0.7313603162765503, 0.750623345375061, -0.3321644365787506, 0.4619189500808716, 0.3339269459247589, 0.7641996145248413, 0.7152960896492004, -0.08565255999565125, 0.3126426935195923, -0.389072060585022, 0.09151508659124374, 1.431803584098816, -0.4520860016345978, 0.6586493849754333, -0.32188326120376587, -0.04536542296409607, -0.6514500379562378, -0.10616035014390945, -0.8771201372146606, -0.3871593773365021, -0.05260761082172394, -0.20578236877918243, 0.09701772034168243, 0.5896589159965515, -0.2079661786556244, 0.4235745668411255, -0.2632174789905548, -0.46516507863998413, 0.13850578665733337, -0.6583613753318787, 0.21137860417366028, 0.5658622980117798, -0.20714342594146729, 0.2048301100730896, -0.5189875960350037, 0.20582017302513123, -0.3711520731449127, -0.2005581557750702, 0.4642128348350525, -0.5869308710098267, -0.07630074769258499, -0.0924178808927536, 0.7889285683631897, 0.6997861862182617, 0.3470169007778168, 0.13957469165325165, 0.46810081601142883, 0.7651053071022034, -0.027532674372196198, -0.6826791763305664, -0.047829657793045044, 1.186354160308838, 0.25644010305404663, 0.12910214066505432, -1.385217547416687, 0.36005377769470215, -0.05098069831728935, -0.03839494287967682, 0.07771037518978119, 0.9921987652778625, -0.679774820804596, -0.1891505867242813, -0.6684195399284363, 0.28614342212677, 0.47317978739738464, 0.9559803605079651, -0.5132976174354553, -0.6499960422515869, 0.04832926765084267, -0.32229509949684143, -0.8901726603507996, -0.22237010300159454, -0.7903518676757812, 0.8142464756965637, 0.3949679136276245, 0.7105075120925903, -0.9620010852813721, -0.6461919546127319, 0.43178892135620117, -0.05223997309803963, -0.37581926584243774, -0.24237455427646637, 0.03671521693468094, -0.6466246247291565, -0.3071956932544708, -0.27147728204727173, 0.18444937467575073, -0.39525914192199707, 0.3084520399570465, -0.31446772813796997, -0.23528827726840973, 0.7606245875358582, 0.09261038154363632, 0.3191952705383301, -0.37827929854393005, 0.0979747325181961, 0.22386005520820618, -0.21756763756275177, 0.4360106587409973, 0.9904382228851318, -0.45432716608047485, 0.07994275540113449, 0.6691009998321533, 0.6150372624397278, 0.9051739573478699, 0.5001667737960815, -0.4176994562149048, 0.452719509601593, 0.5918245315551758, 0.7878353595733643, 0.063412606716156, -0.2850745618343353, -0.4586308002471924, 0.9950790405273438, -0.7038952112197876, 0.3195197284221649, -0.8023409843444824, 0.511896550655365, -0.19224722683429718, 0.6098540425300598, 0.04705854877829552, 0.17102321982383728, -0.8060612082481384, -0.7137934565544128, -0.403918981552124, -0.2644248902797699, -0.8439235687255859, -0.8225393891334534, -0.07464104145765305, 0.6637409925460815, 0.009900338016450405, -0.03969250246882439, 0.28029853105545044, 1.077194094657898, -0.5972033143043518, 0.35512515902519226, -0.2107459455728531, 0.08979499340057373, -1.519423246383667, -0.7151155471801758, -0.3853585720062256, -0.055757708847522736, -0.3880121111869812, -0.573441207408905, 1.099797248840332, 0.21643410623073578, 0.8257346749305725, -0.4712821841239929, -0.35099777579307556, 0.07943864166736603, -0.12400291115045547, 0.13083593547344208, 0.12961459159851074, 0.05714472755789757, -0.6229537725448608, 0.3787480294704437, -0.29129064083099365, 0.40859511494636536, -0.3997000753879547, -0.22402708232402802, -0.4227806031703949, -0.3488950729370117, -0.4140339195728302, 0.3231552541255951, 0.1789899468421936, -0.5631808042526245, -0.15444907546043396, -0.0658784732222557, -0.31468501687049866, -0.17913268506526947, -0.2688787877559662, -0.5289294123649597, -0.27142366766929626, 0.479542076587677, -0.10143674165010452, -0.6651734113693237, 0.8624722957611084, 0.1106942668557167, -0.2705616056919098, 0.36094367504119873, -0.5656979084014893, 0.689524233341217, -0.6146387457847595, 1.244011402130127, 1.113181471824646, 0.2364422231912613, 1.027078628540039, -0.506013810634613, -0.4904215931892395, 0.05683458223938942, 0.2454555779695511, -0.913862943649292, -0.042300187051296234, 0.7929666638374329, 0.015393169596791267, -0.40393930673599243, 0.5383285284042358, -0.5345768332481384, -0.13195210695266724, -0.1724584549665451, 0.18124531209468842, 0.5061219334602356, -0.07169708609580994, -0.2860868275165558, -0.0467149056494236, 0.05749806389212608, -0.3329353928565979, -0.09685244411230087, 0.41876935958862305, -0.36612793803215027, -0.15806947648525238, 0.18835806846618652, 0.41083523631095886, 0.39783456921577454, 1.0008397102355957, -0.753248393535614, 0.35566985607147217, -0.07665205001831055, -0.6825515627861023, -0.10200919210910797, 0.172637939453125, -0.2995626628398895, 0.23021861910820007, 0.07795322686433792, -0.42485442757606506, -0.025866469368338585, -0.38365232944488525, 0.06805384159088135, 0.38906413316726685, 0.4407902657985687, 0.048917677253484726, -0.13096626102924347, -0.46185263991355896, -0.7613052129745483, 0.9505059719085693, -0.33606579899787903, 0.7498515248298645, -0.7103390693664551, -0.010691513307392597, -0.8907943964004517, -0.3672957122325897, -0.0995606929063797, -0.3313719928264618, -0.7055029273033142, 0.2778407633304596, 0.15245436131954193, 0.8239709138870239, -0.49613216519355774, -0.3022973835468292, -0.2559794783592224, 0.6192725896835327, 0.5881495475769043, 0.4868662357330322, 0.4012249708175659, 0.1987573355436325, 0.2830893099308014, -0.3976801931858063, -0.4897097647190094, 0.5629740357398987, -0.6400872468948364, -0.7598917484283447, -0.28560298681259155, -0.3700912892818451, -0.08878380805253983, 0.45414024591445923, 0.4413640797138214, -0.09052672237157822, 0.43188461661338806, 0.12267167121171951, -0.1383236050605774, 0.23142603039741516, 0.35474464297294617, 0.02687798999249935, 0.15772701799869537, -0.9459956288337708, 0.04015900939702988, 0.11401260644197464, -0.7985438704490662, -0.4575239419937134, -0.25261637568473816, -0.546820878982544, 0.6878514289855957, 0.6332585215568542, 0.09934252500534058, -0.5181976556777954, 0.5105147957801819, -0.5450478792190552, 0.26520559191703796, -0.05136300250887871, -0.5994652509689331, 0.05025538057088852, 0.8381394743919373, 0.3959289789199829, -0.4627256691455841, -0.34685054421424866, -0.3330136835575104, 0.5815883278846741, -0.10519178956747055, -0.368564248085022, -0.4570963978767395, -0.6053710579872131, 0.44063708186149597, -0.9882699847221375, 0.7379152774810791, 0.7237434387207031, -0.23338522017002106, 0.7104855179786682, 0.1339038908481598, -0.42326560616493225, -0.2759957015514374, -0.021513260900974274, -0.3267748951911926, 0.13487549126148224, 0.5496777892112732, -0.024591613560914993, 0.9163413047790527, -0.28146037459373474, -0.44381794333457947, -0.47077497839927673, -0.01618071459233761, 0.3734843134880066, -0.22769847512245178, -0.2020336389541626, 0.46808525919914246, -0.062401726841926575, -0.06361144036054611, 1.2671326398849487, -0.0802452489733696, 0.109562948346138, -0.36694374680519104, 0.11068961769342422, -0.5878332853317261, -0.9244863390922546, 0.5717056393623352, -0.04614615440368652, -0.17514652013778687, 0.331913560628891, 0.54170161485672, -0.3183939456939697, -0.3734240233898163, 0.6498402953147888, -0.5394197106361389, 0.9895539283752441, -0.19202212989330292, 0.10663557797670364, -0.01925351843237877, -0.509712815284729, -0.2057104855775833, -0.28516438603401184, 0.6847277283668518, -0.06909140944480896, 0.19616475701332092, 0.30567771196365356, -0.494174599647522, 0.12877419590950012, 0.7159596681594849, -0.7676752805709839, -0.05944231152534485, -0.3420089781284332, -0.6895325183868408, -0.3135954737663269, -0.7734434008598328, -0.07471203804016113, 0.0080656036734581, -0.0388091579079628, 0.054912690073251724, -0.16753078997135162, -0.0427326001226902, -0.8126984238624573, 0.32010596990585327, -0.983646035194397, 0.6621944904327393, -0.3240596652030945, -0.03223441541194916, -0.5287741422653198, -0.3109930753707886, 0.06276699155569077, 0.2474175989627838, -0.7370807528495789, -0.018833622336387634, -0.09197700768709183, -0.25197723507881165, 0.5525229573249817, 0.9000440835952759, 0.28476205468177795, 0.17689085006713867, -0.031033650040626526, 0.20557032525539398, -0.23459306359291077, -0.632623553276062, -0.3808996081352234, 1.5681370496749878, 0.1688055694103241, -0.3172573745250702, 0.03855321928858757, -0.7843268513679504, -0.4529987573623657, -0.5349855422973633, 0.4203745424747467, -0.6961647272109985, -0.7461166381835938, -0.38608092069625854, -0.2793065309524536, -0.06584574282169342, 0.11354438215494156, 0.39635294675827026, -0.3113367557525635, -0.158983513712883, -0.7485336065292358, -0.008812512271106243, 0.016705229878425598, -0.5287571549415588, -0.5917523503303528, -0.5118369460105896, -1.1428742408752441, 0.9084623456001282, -0.739249587059021, -0.5551416277885437, 0.044380951672792435, 1.3400633335113525, 0.30276668071746826, 0.5267638564109802, -0.019570868462324142, -0.23036977648735046, 0.05212843418121338, 0.7435815334320068, -0.6482886075973511, 0.7723352313041687, -0.9969578385353088, 0.31840839982032776, -0.5137073993682861, 0.2644617557525635, -0.49721911549568176, -0.005581446923315525, 0.788233757019043, -0.6921858191490173, 1.0531638860702515, -1.1252453327178955, 0.2682240903377533, 0.43135732412338257, 0.4565548300743103, 0.19577772915363312, 0.07569659501314163, -0.5626419186592102, -0.3391309678554535, -0.8323912620544434, -0.6627418994903564, 0.3181431293487549, -0.4167315363883972, -0.2408936619758606, -0.5236347317695618, -0.344433456659317, 0.29776787757873535, -0.437648743391037, 1.121562123298645, 1.0657190084457397, -0.10370511561632156, 0.42636343836784363, 0.022051164880394936, -0.36843979358673096, 0.15577413141727448, -0.10602711141109467, 0.2819785475730896, 0.19441623985767365, -0.6303747296333313, 0.18880212306976318, -0.4236094057559967, -0.9091690182685852, -0.6482546329498291, 0.8514522314071655, 0.14032228291034698, -0.15426743030548096, 0.11029895395040512, -0.5433782935142517, -0.030248763039708138, -0.08027773350477219, -0.3142088055610657, -0.40377774834632874, 0.4664819538593292, -0.12118004262447357, -0.3339689075946808, -0.32896924018859863, -0.10349880903959274, 0.026293812319636345, -0.31289368867874146, -0.21211330592632294, 0.9024946093559265, -0.23661476373672485, -0.7222189903259277, 0.08360128849744797, -0.20418740808963776, 0.11345583200454712, -0.21013572812080383, -0.7480493783950806, -0.5573112964630127, -0.029291322454810143, -0.49355167150497437, 0.20077963173389435, -0.41052573919296265, -0.927818775177002, 0.14926669001579285, 0.6881629824638367, -0.5635096430778503, -0.41454583406448364, -0.3435121774673462, -0.1367369145154953, -0.5055857300758362, -0.587308406829834, 1.1974217891693115, 0.06297310441732407, -0.028900813311338425, -0.023956112563610077, -0.7703831791877747, -0.18691052496433258, 0.22158220410346985, 0.3559979200363159, 0.04530586674809456, 0.5803607702255249, 0.22287173569202423, 0.45501697063446045, 0.6400493383407593, 0.42271071672439575, 0.1220850721001625, 0.2183418869972229, -0.28300416469573975, -0.8372786045074463, -0.6846648454666138, 0.6587116122245789, 0.3354475498199463, 0.6451252102851868, -0.5966916084289551, 0.15687185525894165, 0.018635014072060585, -0.034988678991794586, -0.3706880509853363, -1.0553128719329834, -0.42134782671928406, -0.7793699502944946, -0.6402133703231812, -1.0185199975967407, -0.7601344585418701, 0.2099902331829071, -0.008305821567773819, 0.5800708532333374, 0.027868982404470444, -0.4053897559642792, 0.9744623899459839, 0.5472436547279358, 0.511296808719635, 0.021622883155941963, 0.15694524347782135, -0.7056238651275635, -0.42888954281806946, -0.4779619872570038, 0.07123973965644836, 0.11493880301713943, 0.7380543351173401, -0.5621785521507263, 0.06006575748324394, 0.056551333516836166, 0.48526161909103394, -0.2274947613477707, -0.25033655762672424, 0.20142605900764465, -0.2495807260274887, -0.966422975063324, 0.3058289885520935, -0.4404997229576111, 0.4464513659477234, 0.6491705775260925, -1.2663766145706177, -0.4427775740623474, 0.7343911528587341, -1.0889949798583984, 0.36465713381767273, 0.2507222592830658, 0.8864338994026184, -0.3233715295791626, -0.25063279271125793, 0.6072490215301514, 0.8248026371002197, -0.7510632276535034, 0.22453927993774414, 0.5092844367027283, -0.11245422810316086, 0.23479579389095306, -0.15466542541980743, 0.3412865400314331, 1.225585699081421, 0.14491066336631775, 0.6528729200363159, -0.556701123714447, 0.3353991210460663, 0.19225187599658966, 0.1744598001241684, 0.010271153412759304, -0.808724582195282, 0.8792276978492737, -0.8778210282325745, 0.6432685256004333, 0.2982577085494995, -0.18511666357517242, 0.3040007948875427, -0.42055144906044006, 0.4639962315559387, -0.24773874878883362, -0.20978978276252747, -0.7189321517944336, 0.7316392064094543, -0.6277294158935547, 0.3588951826095581, -0.02445978671312332, -1.2305023670196533, 0.09833643585443497, 0.37104448676109314, -0.7555596232414246, -0.8860908150672913, -0.18984900414943695, -0.46797576546669006, 0.10359340161085129, -0.2675245404243469, -0.6596382856369019, -0.5655215978622437, 0.17660413682460785, -0.09921293705701828, -0.655266284942627, 0.021119220182299614, 0.28488823771476746, 0.3226461112499237, -1.0090527534484863, 0.33809688687324524, -0.07648538798093796, 0.48614501953125, -0.8041329979896545, -0.603421151638031, -0.10720052570104599, -0.10794036835432053, -0.5872374773025513, -0.7822686433792114, -0.841911256313324, 0.3918580412864685, 0.836377739906311, -0.3566959798336029, -0.17923305928707123, -0.15965698659420013, -0.6877290606498718, 0.9069643020629883, 0.8465901613235474, -0.42208507657051086, 0.4257831871509552, 0.6907235383987427, 0.4031352400779724, -0.17821745574474335, -0.4202321767807007, 0.4619470536708832, 0.2804197669029236, -0.1012582778930664, 0.521701991558075, -0.4058719873428345, 0.6209517121315002, -0.13380683958530426, 0.08014290034770966, -0.16942301392555237, 0.33470088243484497, 0.1221437007188797, 1.1472519636154175, 0.6551060080528259, -0.03156886249780655, 0.32061439752578735, 0.2590916156768799, -0.5139873623847961, -0.2662879526615143, -0.016220053657889366, 0.09039246290922165, 0.26356205344200134, -0.31522995233535767, 0.07090609520673752, -0.01820298656821251, 0.578467071056366, -0.6437734961509705, -0.6108061075210571, -0.2542785108089447, 0.6246117949485779, 0.4603186547756195, 0.244981050491333, -0.9998844265937805, 0.17265267670154572, -0.38478705286979675, -0.20716117322444916, 0.2770077586174011, 0.2637632489204407, -0.4646797180175781, 0.3100849390029907, 0.8403895497322083, 0.8046331405639648, -0.43690550327301025, 0.12726011872291565, -0.03355265408754349, 0.12828119099140167, -0.5563763380050659, 0.8788946270942688, 0.8608713746070862, 0.14298754930496216, 0.3392023742198944, -0.22928552329540253, -0.2058715969324112, 1.0012489557266235, -1.1251055002212524, 0.03534763678908348, 0.15242110192775726, -0.5206837058067322, -0.617080569267273, -0.9736546277999878, 0.5496671199798584, -0.562273383140564, 0.356869637966156, 0.9897782802581787, 0.23692646622657776, -0.18849973380565643, 0.4910701811313629, -0.5052328705787659, 0.6117884516716003, 1.1925629377365112, 0.4358830153942108, -0.23574410378932953, 0.8648348450660706, 0.7798100113868713, 0.21891547739505768, 0.3134629726409912, 0.07036405801773071, -1.0081883668899536, 0.13245661556720734, 0.4644167721271515, -0.583595335483551, 0.17529579997062683, -0.8583682775497437, 0.008591447956860065, -0.3485383093357086, 0.7931647300720215, -0.024959273636341095, -0.02140934206545353, 0.4794881045818329, 0.3059753477573395, -0.3402825891971588, -0.21036848425865173, 0.4122943580150604, 0.36452603340148926, 0.7803497910499573, 0.18131016194820404, 0.14843471348285675, 0.3412139415740967, -0.11405660957098007, -0.1747339516878128, -0.22396467626094818, -0.5808594822883606, 0.004899408668279648, -0.31267619132995605, -0.9933422803878784, -0.32899996638298035, -0.2219957709312439, -0.053979430347681046, -0.8218578100204468, 0.21205812692642212, 0.45440858602523804, 0.7024997472763062, 0.04192700609564781, -0.28652894496917725, -0.5593937635421753, 0.8162228465080261, 0.8984547853469849, 0.6199123859405518, 0.4107849895954132, 0.14997826516628265, 0.627044141292572, -0.4119093418121338, 0.7459813356399536, 0.41232696175575256, -0.9239485859870911, 0.22925904393196106, -0.30536478757858276, 0.36101335287094116, -0.4440787732601166, -0.7946816086769104, 0.27432358264923096, 0.582025945186615, 0.7183998823165894, -0.7510998845100403, -0.455973356962204, -0.07143189758062363, -0.683384895324707, 0.4795249402523041, -0.6501745581626892, 0.4041019678115845, 1.0240659713745117, -0.006785184144973755, 0.21450185775756836, -0.37725502252578735, 4.135924339294434, 0.8824173808097839, 0.41483694314956665, -0.041688017547130585, 0.5418910980224609, 0.22288666665554047, 0.6880943179130554, -1.0199400186538696, -0.029807230457663536, -0.22180955111980438, -0.0276658833026886, -0.1236470490694046, 0.2901412844657898, 0.2399149239063263, 0.24707268178462982, 0.24034160375595093, -0.5076229572296143, -0.07069944590330124, 0.5288985967636108, -0.667970597743988, -0.23419363796710968, 0.15880504250526428, 0.15205025672912598, -0.10402648150920868, 0.26883256435394287, -0.07813572883605957, 0.3297084867954254, -0.8820410370826721, -0.9457429051399231, -0.04172145202755928, -0.29854097962379456, -0.55882328748703, -0.01423765067011118, -0.6335439085960388, -0.8255340456962585, 0.4602307677268982, 0.5709729790687561, 0.3122054636478424, -0.1934628039598465, -0.073370061814785, -0.22944554686546326, -0.08941975235939026, -0.6067261099815369, -0.42101141810417175, -0.1628054827451706, 0.48512572050094604, -0.6616439819335938, 0.9299351572990417, 0.1489318311214447, -0.775239109992981, 0.6574738025665283, -0.414229154586792, 0.31766727566719055, -0.02596702054142952, -1.291133165359497, -0.4112771153450012, -0.10204713046550751, -0.6919273734092712, -0.2060646414756775, -0.1899411678314209, 1.1930699348449707, 0.0505710169672966, -0.5392894744873047, 0.18679927289485931, -0.11597947031259537, -0.09755677729845047, 0.4164240062236786, -0.01909208856523037, 0.06773410737514496, 0.0035699938889592886, -0.3528549075126648, -0.12478872388601303, -0.40461188554763794, -0.38388168811798096, 0.8792815208435059, 0.17759215831756592, -0.33451852202415466, 0.4234432280063629, -0.43886303901672363, 0.29166141152381897, -0.43101197481155396, -0.33180564641952515, -0.3791339099407196, -0.23750105500221252, 0.5341631174087524, 0.36290740966796875, -0.12640006840229034, -1.2725639343261719, -0.3064331114292145, 0.3019962012767792, 0.1737900674343109, 0.8162787556648254, -0.2945495843887329, -0.13315153121948242, -0.1649438589811325 ]
Morphology of Amorphous Layers Ballistically Deposited on a Planar Substrate
We report numerical simulation of the deposition of spherical particles on a planar surface, by ballistic, straight-line trajectory transport, and assuming irreversible adhesion on contact with the surface or previously deposited particles. Our data indicate that the deposit formed has a loosely layered structure within few diameters from the surface. This structure can be explained by a model of growth via chain formation. Away from the surface we found evidence of a monotonic, power-law approach to the bulk density. Both density and contact-statistics results suggest that the deposit formed is sparse: the space-filling fraction is about 15%, and the average number of contacts is 2. The morphology of the deposit both near the surface and in the bulk seems to be a result of competition of screening and branching; nearly half of all the spheres are either single-contact dangling ends, or branching nodes with more than two contacts.
B. D. Lubachevsky, V. Privman, S.C. Roy
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207014
cond-mat/9207015
[ 0.29690060019493103, -0.1791941374540329, 0.2703149914741516, 0.17832420766353607, 0.15833228826522827, -0.6139785647392273, -0.8315901756286621, -0.621615469455719, -0.4979332387447357, 1.4522833824157715, 0.5191934704780579, 0.04039129242300987, 0.4870172441005707, -0.6271094083786011, -0.9895495176315308, -0.003631947562098503, 0.01295511145144701, -0.24675165116786957, -0.7406085133552551, -0.4867643713951111, 0.30444449186325073, -0.48566147685050964, -1.3343199491500854, -0.280850350856781, -0.2197023630142212, 0.5258954167366028, 0.3954393267631531, -0.45324593782424927, 1.1656726598739624, 0.3063998818397522, 0.3405821919441223, -0.4535437226295471, -0.01725776493549347, -1.9351598024368286, 0.09357564151287079, -0.295727401971817, 0.8162866234779358, -0.5648853182792664, -0.1294245421886444, -0.30968189239501953, 1.2780475616455078, -0.40546977519989014, 0.4065607488155365, -0.21522606909275055, -0.3534523546695709, 0.6600683331489563, -0.554768443107605, -0.12006205320358276, 0.3460828959941864, -0.6172276735305786, 0.035957783460617065, 0.2214832752943039, -0.08771885931491852, -0.6491002440452576, -0.3810095489025116, -0.20443937182426453, 0.0017410637810826302, 1.0170575380325317, -0.16887974739074707, 0.07281716912984848, 1.0862061977386475, -0.1803765445947647, 0.41771766543388367, -0.30997228622436523, -0.005532801616936922, 1.5444190502166748, 0.07658246904611588, 0.8539314866065979, 0.025129279121756554, -0.18449455499649048, -0.5522313117980957, -1.0751152038574219, -0.8677038550376892, 0.04881438985466957, -0.48833611607551575, 0.7379139065742493, 0.12153291702270508, -0.16458332538604736, -0.7576149106025696, -0.13171769678592682, 0.5354340076446533, -0.05386434867978096, -0.025927456095814705, 0.44005391001701355, -0.3206791579723358, -0.3041847050189972, 0.2278396040201187, 0.0998254343867302, -0.12253038585186005, 0.4776614010334015, 0.4588792324066162, 0.9352580904960632, 0.4357091188430786, -0.7549604773521423, 0.1391235589981079, 0.5191884636878967, 0.0618961863219738, 0.516516387462616, 0.005331381689757109, 0.5064545273780823, 0.3844107985496521, 0.7829289436340332, -0.9870538115501404, 0.3397701382637024, -0.6103556752204895, -0.08140698820352554, 0.5013507604598999, -0.20672443509101868, 0.09810389578342438, -0.9391353130340576, 0.2201434224843979, -0.5768567323684692, -0.2071905881166458, 0.49356114864349365, 0.22135032713413239, 0.7114692330360413, 0.9392402172088623, -0.0531478188931942, -0.1413806527853012, 0.4811880886554718, 0.49607640504837036, 0.2520407736301422, 0.6835200786590576, 0.6562192440032959, 0.06050306186079979, -0.3599169850349426, -0.04971673712134361, 0.6573242545127869, -0.0678253173828125, -0.4225689470767975, -0.29510271549224854, -0.2823215126991272, -0.1618664264678955, 0.621991753578186, 0.2108979970216751, 0.2904245853424072, 0.3336297869682312, 0.29507291316986084, 0.47241470217704773, -0.7540866136550903, 0.15501193702220917, -1.0625702142715454, 0.2050200253725052, 1.3583166599273682, -0.5378130674362183, 0.27268752455711365, -0.2404061257839203, 0.24240711331367493, -0.528393566608429, -0.1389496624469757, -1.8485329151153564, -0.290171355009079, 0.15934525430202484, 0.4391680657863617, -0.41183459758758545, 0.3342207372188568, 0.3011546730995178, -0.027832558378577232, -0.9040808081626892, -1.1431854963302612, 0.35418930649757385, -0.4768266975879669, 0.16819623112678528, 0.19687309861183167, -0.8601170778274536, 0.14878244698047638, -1.0284188985824585, -0.396304190158844, -1.0000590085983276, -0.8342729806900024, 0.28562840819358826, -0.5249298810958862, 0.13642238080501556, 0.8576924204826355, 0.6851938962936401, 0.602044939994812, 0.325517863035202, -0.48523953557014465, -0.08608505874872208, 0.4099484384059906, 0.2292223423719406, -0.12009885162115097, -0.2574136257171631, 0.4568186402320862, 0.4106985032558441, -0.13297787308692932, -0.6955007314682007, -0.05568163841962814, -0.35843533277511597, 0.992952287197113, -0.16937634348869324, 0.29991865158081055, -0.5885419845581055, 0.04668290168046951, -0.5530190467834473, 0.055344853550195694, -0.08014577627182007, 0.7191551923751831, 0.023302454501390457, -0.9452211856842041, 0.6546727418899536, -0.03750506043434143, -1.04067862033844, -0.4793024957180023, -1.2678606510162354, 0.4762343168258667, 0.38722458481788635, 0.9390114545822144, -0.8335781097412109, -0.005072031635791063, 0.24883317947387695, -0.44473859667778015, 0.400249719619751, -0.4582243859767914, -0.48122796416282654, -0.049469366669654846, 0.14485295116901398, 0.1959667056798935, -0.05354076623916626, -0.04659659042954445, 0.9721208214759827, -0.40718674659729004, -0.4339192807674408, 0.8099485039710999, 0.30843639373779297, -0.5939231514930725, -0.4045608937740326, 0.6774945259094238, 0.6768102049827576, -0.15858194231987, -0.31275078654289246, 0.15074411034584045, -0.1696377992630005, 0.6045702695846558, -0.2710728347301483, 0.34545379877090454, 1.3169834613800049, 0.6969306468963623, 0.3818804621696472, 0.45411571860313416, 0.2616380751132965, -0.06156245991587639, 0.6980595588684082, 0.7054258584976196, 0.41923630237579346, 0.7773606181144714, -0.33441710472106934, -0.22018733620643616, -0.7354450821876526, 0.2898625135421753, -0.15968431532382965, 1.1852432489395142, 0.11130096018314362, 0.36378124356269836, -0.4132271111011505, -0.3092404901981354, 0.44195425510406494, 0.3571552634239197, -0.7368726134300232, -0.06605780869722366, 0.020274925976991653, 0.15651780366897583, -0.325614869594574, -0.3767188489437103, -0.2429174929857254, 1.8804807662963867, -0.8725985884666443, 0.16018183529376984, 0.15612851083278656, -0.008746008388698101, -0.826005220413208, -0.3494208753108978, -0.9821898937225342, -0.562199056148529, -0.5112394094467163, -0.5965211391448975, 1.2801660299301147, -0.20870628952980042, -0.06682831794023514, -0.04468012601137161, -0.30473077297210693, 0.3468513786792755, 0.12984655797481537, 0.27226048707962036, 0.02549242042005062, 0.0888863205909729, -0.5398149490356445, 0.7740866541862488, -1.0693988800048828, 0.05165763571858406, 0.03040725737810135, 0.01908259652554989, -0.13449078798294067, -0.05709780007600784, -0.30330348014831543, 0.29099172353744507, -0.023634161800146103, 0.28490009903907776, 0.14723902940750122, -0.5884878039360046, 0.24031665921211243, 0.42804139852523804, -0.5298106670379639, -0.8515368103981018, -1.1760101318359375, 0.21028071641921997, -0.02507452666759491, -0.7292536497116089, 0.6726346611976624, 0.44314029812812805, -0.6205176115036011, 0.4797128736972809, -0.6464008092880249, 0.47345054149627686, -0.5198605060577393, 1.228353500366211, 1.243473768234253, 0.008226314559578896, 0.18217022716999054, -0.740134596824646, -1.1178874969482422, 0.27638426423072815, -0.15598636865615845, -0.7940473556518555, -0.3293438255786896, 1.0820906162261963, -0.06912947446107864, -0.3844393789768219, 0.8936788439750671, -0.33762550354003906, -0.7981977462768555, 0.7933815717697144, -0.17198549211025238, 0.6082951426506042, 0.030225710943341255, -0.11778944730758667, -1.0935105085372925, -0.3968546986579895, 0.5158986449241638, 0.4463452100753784, 1.274672508239746, -0.626061201095581, 0.4898450970649719, 0.4566749632358551, 0.6616437435150146, -0.2957296073436737, 0.8383164405822754, 0.04286402836441994, -0.45258966088294983, 0.09488842636346817, -0.4473998248577118, 0.27572470903396606, 0.12169399857521057, 0.27911439538002014, -0.26358920335769653, 0.6641579866409302, -0.7057283520698547, -0.24629415571689606, -0.05574354901909828, -0.07378102093935013, 0.3822671175003052, 0.8366011381149292, -0.18793191015720367, 0.09611783176660538, -0.5738845467567444, -0.7772770524024963, 1.3310694694519043, -1.0500541925430298, 0.4899919927120209, -2.023411750793457, 0.4482933282852173, -0.6270788311958313, -0.23230139911174774, 0.19239552319049835, 0.3568781912326813, 0.040187425911426544, 0.2735580503940582, 0.5595303177833557, 1.6141422986984253, -0.535677433013916, -0.664526104927063, -0.32417479157447815, 0.6384280323982239, 0.7502368688583374, 0.8685131072998047, 0.5290454626083374, -0.016924578696489334, 0.6790686845779419, -0.46160373091697693, -0.5123627781867981, -0.2888646721839905, -0.7372779846191406, -0.4764735996723175, -0.7099577188491821, -0.6807457804679871, -0.43850111961364746, 0.6141349673271179, 0.9618521332740784, 0.10442376881837845, 0.41392672061920166, -0.00009422400034964085, -0.1525236964225769, 0.33035969734191895, 0.664364218711853, 0.6516164541244507, 0.5311809182167053, -1.0304628610610962, 0.15971346199512482, 0.29149332642555237, 0.27709120512008667, -0.5152077674865723, 0.05065085366368294, -0.36350852251052856, -0.2634395658969879, 0.6846802830696106, -0.2668288052082062, -0.49475786089897156, 0.2753100097179413, 0.3961472511291504, 1.1263588666915894, 0.23671689629554749, -0.6189576983451843, 0.5656598210334778, 0.6881952285766602, -0.03793005272746086, -1.375879168510437, -0.27408820390701294, -0.17278841137886047, 0.8022313117980957, 0.5540250539779663, 0.11497987061738968, -0.5960073471069336, -0.8265302777290344, 0.3316718637943268, -1.2217470407485962, 0.18812622129917145, 0.6799129247665405, 0.43187350034713745, 0.2708297073841095, -0.2416604608297348, -0.1204514130949974, 0.18274033069610596, -0.1779358983039856, -0.43263036012649536, 0.15222980082035065, 0.47781166434288025, -0.7767461538314819, 0.7657061815261841, -0.5504044890403748, -0.2699091136455536, -0.2736046314239502, 0.04260561242699623, 0.9220767617225647, -0.3030300736427307, -0.6082474589347839, 0.5058283805847168, -0.11910326778888702, -0.2193550169467926, 1.1073260307312012, 0.07734876126050949, -0.530161440372467, -0.4716464579105377, 0.47180429100990295, -0.7493375539779663, -0.525193989276886, 0.5014373660087585, 0.1441669464111328, 0.6373711228370667, 0.6101794242858887, 0.20158308744430542, 0.1652679294347763, 0.004073630087077618, -0.07195615023374557, -0.7617879509925842, 1.2239958047866821, -0.3940501809120178, 0.07068793475627899, -0.24947814643383026, -0.19392478466033936, -0.5114910006523132, -0.10444790869951248, 0.4005568027496338, -0.2898052930831909, 0.31647107005119324, -0.1454024761915207, -0.4796760678291321, -0.12640491127967834, -0.12758542597293854, -0.2684635519981384, 0.33764925599098206, 0.16909073293209076, -0.5653831362724304, -0.5504958629608154, -0.11912910640239716, -0.17705442011356354, 0.6565939784049988, -0.25119373202323914, -0.44103002548217773, 0.5062355995178223, -0.19339331984519958, -0.30990397930145264, 0.6040725111961365, -1.4460707902908325, 0.6836315989494324, -0.5406991839408875, 0.25360485911369324, -0.8337786793708801, -1.0157668590545654, 0.44515544176101685, -0.517952561378479, -0.44277384877204895, -0.016787031665444374, 0.23630525171756744, -0.41586631536483765, 0.6488379836082458, 0.20636065304279327, -0.0647791400551796, -0.4840591251850128, -0.6351442337036133, 0.3889974057674408, -0.5838844776153564, -0.7855722308158875, 0.0388261154294014, 0.24638137221336365, 0.07567311823368073, 0.05318840593099594, 0.7198315858840942, -1.4754769802093506, -0.39715325832366943, 0.060559168457984924, 0.1315467804670334, -1.0610750913619995, -0.24357254803180695, 0.007235151249915361, -0.7054340839385986, -0.5047327280044556, 0.3128077983856201, 0.5383256673812866, -0.3583265244960785, -0.49024537205696106, -0.884709358215332, -0.022942660376429558, 0.24384374916553497, -0.7802689075469971, -0.8074467182159424, -0.3834393620491028, -0.22996194660663605, 0.6523469686508179, -0.9952266216278076, 0.0943959429860115, 0.2978037893772125, 0.28530073165893555, -0.01758369617164135, 0.22009159624576569, -0.18779954314231873, -0.35169902443885803, 0.09832265228033066, 0.4777423143386841, -0.33027973771095276, 0.8216515779495239, -0.9583348631858826, 0.607209324836731, -1.1830294132232666, 0.3638664782047272, -0.5340299010276794, -0.24071869254112244, -0.3726297914981842, -0.4140128493309021, 0.38063544034957886, -1.0005472898483276, 0.2530764937400818, 0.32999715209007263, 0.16164134442806244, 0.28045159578323364, 0.8254192471504211, -0.5978359580039978, -0.4292319118976593, -1.2337963581085205, -1.4817769527435303, 1.2166293859481812, -0.14694294333457947, 0.17622774839401245, -0.3049967885017395, -0.5150543451309204, 0.13215729594230652, -0.7896396517753601, 0.7018631100654602, 0.9707974195480347, -0.1043657511472702, 0.3517797589302063, 0.0044998424127697945, 0.6256600022315979, -0.2587108314037323, -0.4302244484424591, 0.6159402132034302, 0.4404400587081909, -0.3164413273334503, -0.40052828192710876, -0.03728381171822548, -0.9625298380851746, -0.7671446204185486, 0.2404947280883789, 0.6963474154472351, -0.4695819616317749, 1.2887282371520996, -0.35869264602661133, -0.21492645144462585, -0.5674400329589844, -0.03235038369894028, -0.16729672253131866, 0.44855520129203796, 0.14082475006580353, -0.5131158232688904, 0.5731925964355469, 0.016562482342123985, 0.7825592160224915, -0.2606225907802582, -0.7313961982727051, 1.5522327423095703, -0.8235436081886292, -0.3601222634315491, 0.7989150285720825, 0.3519527018070221, -0.6116869449615479, -0.11822067201137543, 0.018480170518159866, 0.48061949014663696, -0.3054303824901581, -0.7435623407363892, -0.0116770314052701, -0.39449360966682434, -0.5874239802360535, 0.09124347567558289, 0.3469565808773041, -0.4274941682815552, 0.06875784695148468, -0.018937736749649048, 0.1759977489709854, -0.7133392691612244, -0.03635229542851448, 0.7431793808937073, -0.004787241108715534, -0.3100344240665436, -0.4045124650001526, -0.31120169162750244, -0.5196442604064941, 0.3710647225379944, 0.5477666258811951, 0.24453797936439514, 0.35668179392814636, 0.346354216337204, 0.0802740752696991, 0.5590915083885193, 0.5088467001914978, 0.21820685267448425, 0.04610423371195793, -0.24799533188343048, -0.7773155570030212, -0.517439067363739, -0.02714678831398487, 0.14404156804084778, 1.0834197998046875, -0.04242163524031639, -0.14748069643974304, -0.8135232329368591, -0.9362388253211975, -0.2890831232070923, -1.0210891962051392, 0.012456493452191353, -0.8917528390884399, -1.4145187139511108, -0.9321938157081604, -0.5656987428665161, -0.16324017941951752, 0.6000465154647827, 0.7655116319656372, -0.08422135561704636, -1.1823656558990479, -0.16258792579174042, 0.8926832675933838, 0.06619741767644882, 0.2386334389448166, -0.2676723301410675, -0.5523906946182251, -0.5017543435096741, -1.2002609968185425, 0.27046048641204834, -0.24486398696899414, 0.17061801254749298, -0.08866370469331741, 0.9282547235488892, -0.34350064396858215, 0.09706521034240723, -0.2448512315750122, -0.23971351981163025, 0.05271098390221596, -0.8613792061805725, -0.992419421672821, 0.6372212171554565, -0.47879114747047424, 0.2686619162559509, 0.5841630101203918, -0.7847506403923035, -0.42395371198654175, 0.3600078523159027, -0.7147315740585327, 0.49583595991134644, -0.4408159852027893, 0.639385998249054, -0.28327974677085876, -0.4513750374317169, 0.3503608703613281, 0.689978837966919, -1.5695723295211792, -0.38658154010772705, -0.7890207767486572, 0.6032536029815674, -0.17636674642562866, 0.27696219086647034, 0.9055503606796265, 0.6519032716751099, -0.04256322607398033, 0.7534962892532349, -0.6271872520446777, 0.1037532389163971, 0.2076629102230072, 0.1808094084262848, -0.4745202660560608, 0.6343514919281006, -0.3610742688179016, -0.6958043575286865, -0.3175030052661896, 0.4520609676837921, 0.02446206472814083, 0.5996127724647522, -0.8362583518028259, -0.5390116572380066, -0.4238235056400299, -0.16779862344264984, -1.2144594192504883, 0.7408508062362671, 0.06290926784276962, 0.17402492463588715, 0.3976720869541168, -0.34183594584465027, -0.5417724847793579, 0.21754004061222076, -1.1942752599716187, -0.16438540816307068, -0.6253976821899414, -0.7404131889343262, -0.16772960126399994, 0.0068064299412071705, -0.19194737076759338, -0.3635307848453522, 0.06972216814756393, 0.5853820443153381, 0.006008922588080168, -0.4187738001346588, -0.4138738214969635, 0.6647982597351074, -1.1562750339508057, -0.11683008819818497, -1.1954288482666016, 0.24453595280647278, -1.3829880952835083, -0.38222798705101013, -0.47281184792518616, 0.6576870679855347, -0.10714910924434662, -0.5557413697242737, -0.0705723986029625, 0.3784952759742737, 0.6923107504844666, -0.1226288378238678, -0.6382544636726379, 0.21236854791641235, 0.10471242666244507, 0.23670527338981628, 0.5533446669578552, -0.4106990694999695, -0.0649738684296608, 0.17286735773086548, 0.19542831182479858, 0.3493419587612152, -0.44827505946159363, 0.4795330762863159, 0.4574732482433319, -0.6884120106697083, 1.1755589246749878, 0.0994630679488182, 0.9840879440307617, 0.11557210981845856, -0.10624881088733673, -0.18047252297401428, 0.04472505301237106, 0.08796443045139313, 0.6610371470451355, 0.16706439852714539, 0.2493758350610733, 0.548247218132019, -0.17178621888160706, -0.0877014771103859, 0.1786160171031952, 1.0464993715286255, -0.15525507926940918, 0.20324131846427917, 0.030047737061977386, 0.06289709359407425, -0.2848799526691437, 0.14584901928901672, -0.0035769427195191383, -0.5004941821098328, 0.282598078250885, 0.07663409411907196, 0.018887978047132492, -0.24910679459571838, -0.4407418668270111, -0.7974063754081726, 0.0056206234730780125, 0.05433237925171852, 0.08950088173151016, 0.36968275904655457, 0.18549500405788422, 0.5883792042732239, 1.312714695930481, 0.25745269656181335, -0.4439447820186615, 0.6589809656143188, -0.19669322669506073, 0.7281275987625122, -0.2713542878627777, 0.9816625118255615, -0.0020661442540585995, 0.6222808361053467, 0.6594857573509216, -0.24771107733249664, 0.3419322967529297, 0.4470474421977997, -1.6310898065567017, 0.2646160125732422, 0.1641046106815338, -0.17327994108200073, -0.4898225665092468, -0.641974925994873, 0.8430119156837463, -0.2412632405757904, -0.22453418374061584, 1.9432647228240967, -0.17624062299728394, 0.03823898360133171, 0.6250945925712585, 0.16516776382923126, 1.2921985387802124, 0.6402112245559692, 0.0010907533578574657, -0.19334809482097626, 1.3345125913619995, 1.489668369293213, 0.11604853719472885, 0.685904324054718, 0.24260419607162476, -0.08994247019290924, -0.15230490267276764, -0.14131510257720947, -0.25103944540023804, 0.9699655771255493, -0.23405413329601288, 0.1694115549325943, -0.3391382396221161, 0.32223549485206604, -0.08355142921209335, -0.46883976459503174, 1.040664792060852, 0.34405261278152466, -0.33559340238571167, -0.6822656989097595, 1.0869805812835693, 0.6966363191604614, 0.1484113484621048, -0.05719804763793945, 0.32644665241241455, 0.029772143810987473, -0.09165304899215698, 0.00836481899023056, 0.4202742874622345, -0.5141684412956238, 0.017843134701251984, 0.22872203588485718, -0.17640429735183716, -0.21621236205101013, -0.7552598118782043, -0.423651784658432, 0.00583291333168745, 0.34182125329971313, 0.7710280418395996, 1.1945619583129883, 0.4100090563297272, -1.1203714609146118, -0.1650664508342743, 0.7685151696205139, 0.3854140639305115, 0.1901734620332718, 0.5393419861793518, 0.5668270587921143, 0.07316464930772781, -0.4000359773635864, 0.9246072173118591, 0.9741408824920654, -0.5319411158561707, 0.8498438000679016, -0.42247816920280457, 0.025443224236369133, 0.0516829751431942, -0.86952143907547, 0.8472344875335693, 0.4750450849533081, 0.38311851024627686, -0.4721200466156006, -0.4030827283859253, -0.06726613640785217, -1.1632968187332153, 0.05517446622252464, -1.321333885192871, 1.2659908533096313, 0.11121204495429993, -0.13178499042987823, 0.5860074162483215, 0.06681260466575623, 3.578690767288208, 0.6891101598739624, 0.9769729971885681, -0.40653303265571594, 0.8181840777397156, 0.6981154084205627, 0.06355040520429611, -1.055198311805725, 0.549268901348114, -0.3051879107952118, -0.37873610854148865, -0.04211194068193436, 0.7967549562454224, 0.23159483075141907, 0.4925532639026642, 0.7307241559028625, 0.0914546325802803, 0.2825733423233032, 0.09895580261945724, -1.3363940715789795, -0.0021505355834960938, 0.5844075083732605, 0.4336334764957428, -0.37917885184288025, 0.6942496299743652, -0.028302108868956566, 0.8263385891914368, -0.32917913794517517, 0.46755433082580566, -0.3487391471862793, -0.6625267267227173, -0.8199864625930786, 0.31413155794143677, -0.3442142903804779, 0.019639432430267334, 0.6050837635993958, -0.19766730070114136, -1.0179611444473267, 0.6036586761474609, -0.19168424606323242, -0.2363574057817459, -0.344115674495697, -0.38587847352027893, 0.03777991980314255, -0.2939668893814087, 1.2241936922073364, -0.7548819184303284, 0.5413624048233032, 0.05082723870873451, -0.7774493098258972, 0.9420610070228577, -0.6314727067947388, 0.10452094674110413, 0.08938177675008774, -1.3640589714050293, -0.21623662114143372, 0.2775459587574005, -0.9605014324188232, -0.15114717185497284, 0.4045427739620209, 0.9300404787063599, 0.393108606338501, -0.2420843541622162, -0.06863078474998474, -0.2518879175186157, 0.47816532850265503, 0.6248841285705566, -0.5737350583076477, -0.6467103958129883, 0.4137769043445587, -0.3713199198246002, -0.3151845335960388, -0.6425417065620422, -0.4421670138835907, 0.28034961223602295, -0.5189067721366882, -0.23765982687473297, 0.5729119777679443, -0.06620624661445618, -0.2900601327419281, -0.06821268796920776, -0.7927345037460327, -0.06072324514389038, 0.1489839106798172, 0.33636343479156494, 0.7253714203834534, -0.20258252322673798, -0.31440573930740356, 0.36703813076019287, -0.09174754470586777, 0.7940429449081421, 1.6093761920928955, -0.03240744397044182, -0.1571822166442871, -0.2269740104675293 ]
Fast-diffusion mean-field theory for k-body reactions in one dimension
We derive an improved mean-field approximation for k-body annihilation reactions kA --> inert, for hard-core diffusing particles on a line, annihilating in groups of k neighbors with probability 0 < q <= 1. The hopping and annihilation processes are correlated to mimic chemical reactions. Our new mean-field theory accounts for hard-core particle properties and has a larger region of applicability than the standard chemical rate equation especially for large k values. Criteria for validity of the mean-field theory and its use in phenomenological data fits are derived. Numerical tests are reported for k=3,4,5,6.
V. Privman, M. D. Grynberg
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207015
cond-mat/9207016
[ 0.08571616560220718, -0.607123076915741, 0.0415000393986702, 0.6558352112770081, 0.026543058454990387, -0.5143834948539734, -0.08835987746715546, -0.8598845601081848, -1.0756871700286865, 1.0903584957122803, 0.9062819480895996, 0.2854161560535431, 0.43387913703918457, -0.6629372239112854, -0.6878780126571655, 0.35918116569519043, -0.16833916306495667, -0.7874484062194824, -1.0890278816223145, -0.05553409829735756, 0.594048261642456, -0.23247051239013672, -1.2848529815673828, -0.3746614456176758, -0.8778113722801208, 1.3257646560668945, -0.004095472861081362, 0.44198134541511536, 0.7960289120674133, 0.2020774483680725, 0.5900884866714478, -0.5580341219902039, 0.18472665548324585, -0.2925738990306854, -0.4081759452819824, -0.4622906446456909, 0.10114168375730515, -0.2030847668647766, 0.6912810802459717, -0.5429940223693848, 0.8890699744224548, -0.6474955677986145, 0.4286063015460968, 0.26880356669425964, -1.0913180112838745, 0.38336628675460815, -0.4939895272254944, 0.13158702850341797, 0.3662359118461609, -1.2129929065704346, 0.33412545919418335, 0.14619149267673492, 0.5535557866096497, 0.45457708835601807, -0.5509788990020752, -0.02138613723218441, -0.2022235095500946, -0.11391784250736237, -0.602644681930542, -0.24629096686840057, 0.9907785058021545, -0.6290290951728821, 0.467810720205307, -1.013300895690918, 0.3827823996543884, 0.7211189866065979, -0.30977320671081543, 0.1801104098558426, 0.2082657665014267, -0.9415444135665894, -0.030489562079310417, -1.087230920791626, -0.3532291352748871, -0.41163983941078186, -0.2995394766330719, 0.21859629452228546, -0.6280520558357239, -0.1907159984111786, -1.2707552909851074, -0.198256716132164, 0.2485595941543579, -0.20419549942016602, -0.42121440172195435, 0.24804839491844177, 0.26631227135658264, 0.19881105422973633, -0.09435620158910751, 0.17075294256210327, -0.18654541671276093, 0.5666691064834595, 0.3723621070384979, 1.103731632232666, 0.6225676536560059, 0.07940246164798737, 0.001247781328856945, 0.8925981521606445, 0.5388936400413513, 1.0118027925491333, 0.26635244488716125, 0.4463958144187927, -0.1449805051088333, 0.9371885061264038, -0.9746970534324646, 0.2797468304634094, -0.5236449837684631, 0.07119333744049072, 0.2436818927526474, -0.3072703182697296, -0.2769063413143158, -0.18455839157104492, 0.05376186594367027, -0.042828794568777084, -0.15036292374134064, 0.4334487020969391, -0.6762380599975586, 1.0452160835266113, -0.3410961329936981, -0.012237482704222202, -0.7015779614448547, 0.3462311625480652, 0.3606753349304199, -0.22224977612495422, 0.7000573873519897, 0.24319803714752197, 0.6154568791389465, -0.20895887911319733, 0.264204740524292, 0.8616857528686523, -0.0015101402532309294, 0.046270955353975296, 0.0013094388414174318, -0.21528826653957367, 0.1252654790878296, 0.7332834601402283, -0.6887763738632202, -0.04550269618630409, -0.37876760959625244, 0.40850830078125, 0.8961167931556702, 0.03042086400091648, 0.719861626625061, -0.36401140689849854, 0.24119572341442108, 0.7059310078620911, -0.16351696848869324, 0.24494338035583496, 0.2464875429868698, -0.06883210688829422, 0.24792078137397766, -0.2373306006193161, -0.8819221258163452, -0.23243436217308044, -0.013015855103731155, 0.6414792537689209, 0.13048450648784637, 0.4087691605091095, -0.5282923579216003, 1.366464614868164, -1.329833745956421, -0.8595472574234009, 0.07840625196695328, -0.07680051773786545, -0.3205510675907135, 0.06472064554691315, -0.43954065442085266, -0.2558560371398926, -0.3029467761516571, -0.4162721335887909, 0.3764594793319702, -0.7823124527931213, 0.1973223239183426, 0.6245083808898926, -0.28170791268348694, 0.4401271641254425, -0.7469644546508789, 0.255390465259552, 0.6368639469146729, 0.3427432179450989, 0.4164585471153259, -0.47672271728515625, -0.21912293136119843, 0.07115568220615387, 1.0519760847091675, -0.25730058550834656, -0.17010697722434998, 0.11195103079080582, -0.8519826531410217, -0.5461876392364502, -0.44689926505088806, 0.5383833050727844, 0.4884366989135742, -0.07010557502508163, -0.35181277990341187, 0.5656729340553284, 0.36016643047332764, -0.17967334389686584, -0.39787396788597107, 0.5875900983810425, -0.17129281163215637, -0.4934181272983551, -0.6360913515090942, 0.37938040494918823, -0.7093381881713867, 0.9025555849075317, -0.7758785486221313, 0.36505192518234253, -0.0786791741847992, -0.06002584099769592, -0.12171534448862076, 0.010346893221139908, 0.06889507919549942, 0.01864394173026085, 0.6941614747047424, -0.6776039600372314, 0.09161780029535294, -0.021528271958231926, 0.024639006704092026, 0.477125346660614, 0.16693143546581268, 0.03719955310225487, 1.152016043663025, 0.11014637351036072, 0.2050177901983261, 0.555965781211853, -0.9695626497268677, -0.46690699458122253, 0.3452387750148773, 0.47839099168777466, 0.3538951575756073, -0.39276912808418274, -0.004972132388502359, 0.15591758489608765, 0.4853729009628296, 0.7363687753677368, 0.9043118357658386, 0.8228185772895813, 0.6356185078620911, 0.8306775689125061, 0.004101657308638096, 0.011831114068627357, -0.15177273750305176, -0.08212380111217499, 0.8806672692298889, 0.06614669412374496, 0.8903235197067261, -0.15116360783576965, -0.9005463123321533, -0.005862758029252291, -0.5172299742698669, 0.4562428891658783, -0.3167724311351776, 0.5508149862289429, -0.1720043420791626, 0.15590417385101318, -0.8161118626594543, -0.010199173353612423, -0.02048654295504093, 0.31436336040496826, -0.5710107684135437, -0.5795696377754211, -0.03967699036002159, 0.25906604528427124, -0.6144063472747803, -0.42080387473106384, -0.0760599672794342, 0.6434642672538757, 0.17001919448375702, -0.02464359812438488, 0.18182383477687836, -0.7951886057853699, -1.2651642560958862, -0.19419626891613007, -0.7441803216934204, -0.0258120559155941, -0.3637896180152893, 0.19638441503047943, 0.8702969551086426, -0.2908201217651367, 0.39926910400390625, 0.11022580415010452, 0.09298978745937347, 1.008912205696106, -0.07684476673603058, 0.6777641177177429, 0.7093610167503357, 0.13180704414844513, -0.49052688479423523, 0.27552372217178345, -0.2233339250087738, -0.024148939177393913, -0.5530860424041748, 0.20130442082881927, 0.8295237421989441, -0.6138623356819153, 0.5443674325942993, -1.0435328483581543, -0.6372449994087219, 0.030010193586349487, 0.7445709109306335, -0.6234732270240784, -0.512768566608429, 0.5654380917549133, -0.17680083215236664, 0.0039172726683318615, -0.46505194902420044, 0.7862930297851562, 0.33267638087272644, -0.31194597482681274, 0.4844561815261841, 0.7161503434181213, -0.379568487405777, 0.06608790904283524, -0.41750726103782654, -0.256879985332489, -0.06666738539934158, 0.7881935834884644, 0.8768096566200256, -0.14056584239006042, 0.07932062447071075, -0.8687718510627747, -0.9034498929977417, 0.3581394851207733, -0.34306517243385315, -0.6013191342353821, -0.01616186648607254, 0.5915320515632629, -0.4253544211387634, -0.4712998867034912, 0.4897725284099579, -1.0036208629608154, -0.38502201437950134, -0.2672663927078247, -0.5567941665649414, 1.2628620862960815, -0.8272994756698608, 0.11773979663848877, -0.46084606647491455, -0.03842165693640709, 1.0352380275726318, 0.2909395694732666, 0.5291854739189148, -0.3994843065738678, 0.6414682269096375, 0.2480906993150711, 1.062820315361023, -0.5714858174324036, 0.544097363948822, 0.051515839993953705, 0.09940657764673233, 0.22138835489749908, -0.5638657212257385, 0.4717024564743042, 0.5765941739082336, 0.6959798336029053, -0.3043784201145172, -0.0848175510764122, -0.5187216401100159, -0.5871677994728088, -0.40931957960128784, -0.2725709080696106, 1.1278587579727173, 0.3648361563682556, -1.0344361066818237, 0.19163121283054352, -0.3267316520214081, -0.3962249457836151, 0.4208386242389679, -0.05352746322751045, 0.6582940220832825, -0.6054071187973022, 1.110971450805664, -0.5603868961334229, -0.6858872175216675, 0.5214254260063171, -0.16163700819015503, 0.6136652231216431, 0.11896310746669769, 0.24283964931964874, 0.9894950985908508, -1.14639151096344, -0.511551022529602, -0.23088295757770538, 0.9387334585189819, 0.9135122895240784, 0.6398886442184448, 0.7715972661972046, 0.6656209230422974, -0.3825003504753113, -0.4918237030506134, -0.7521699666976929, 0.45287296175956726, 0.10760137438774109, -0.3412296772003174, -0.40432673692703247, -0.3853026032447815, -0.2931257486343384, 0.7163758873939514, 0.10934219509363174, 0.09841613471508026, -0.09231211990118027, 0.9478658437728882, 0.9184525012969971, 0.9766316413879395, 0.8202313184738159, -0.1883573830127716, -0.07560975104570389, -0.38861799240112305, 0.49506938457489014, 0.021794717758893967, 0.3853037655353546, -0.599583089351654, -0.08188236504793167, -0.3919641971588135, -0.6798048615455627, 0.38067495822906494, 0.128098726272583, 0.1655147224664688, 0.9388182759284973, 0.15785308182239532, 0.3228302597999573, 0.0497693233191967, 0.22446389496326447, 0.17677472531795502, 0.5582395792007446, -0.004844921641051769, -0.7500275373458862, 0.06598478555679321, 0.11437629908323288, 0.9535549283027649, 0.4905722439289093, -0.7730988264083862, -0.9351297616958618, -0.47821059823036194, 0.5604066252708435, -0.5408124327659607, -0.4870404899120331, 1.0843685865402222, -0.4859209358692169, 0.48475727438926697, 0.03628557175397873, -0.27477243542671204, 0.28203967213630676, -0.25654274225234985, -0.5912918448448181, -0.5670191645622253, 0.0059786029160022736, -0.42142748832702637, 0.372984379529953, 0.17148295044898987, -0.34783944487571716, -0.2898925542831421, -0.17828623950481415, -0.4948389530181885, -0.4428258240222931, 0.2217259556055069, 0.5799769759178162, -0.5571399331092834, -0.4572024643421173, 0.3645392954349518, 0.3370230793952942, 0.5565046668052673, -0.3407147526741028, -0.025566963478922844, 0.08462239801883698, -0.4964548349380493, 0.22382211685180664, 0.3418348729610443, 0.41636091470718384, 0.5431677103042603, 0.42919856309890747, 0.12604224681854248, 0.41536757349967957, 0.275971919298172, 0.28103792667388916, 0.19601793587207794, -0.01145225390791893, -0.30776864290237427, -0.86445152759552, 0.6847550272941589, -0.8254104256629944, -1.4025704860687256, -0.146602064371109, -0.47296416759490967, 1.303389310836792, 0.0786856934428215, -0.6646479368209839, -0.3123723864555359, 0.323106050491333, -1.1080456972122192, 0.5912631750106812, -0.5283650159835815, -0.39009276032447815, 0.048082754015922546, -0.09542690217494965, -0.0534425750374794, 0.025473477318882942, -0.1864670217037201, -0.1428528130054474, 0.5106423497200012, 0.6016796827316284, -0.528163492679596, 0.5979232788085938, -0.039404965937137604, 0.5636260509490967, -0.33310627937316895, 0.7097945213317871, 0.4175800681114197, -0.7100095152854919, 0.061108093708753586, -0.48067426681518555, -0.5416986346244812, -0.6053681969642639, 0.146473228931427, 0.14195580780506134, 0.29473045468330383, 0.06284939497709274, -0.7202305793762207, 0.1511545032262802, -0.6565897464752197, 0.7821617126464844, -0.27322497963905334, -0.7109352350234985, -0.11675667017698288, 0.4374624192714691, 0.25317102670669556, 0.720520555973053, -0.19385507702827454, -0.3648633062839508, 0.2890653610229492, 0.1643858104944229, 0.15515992045402527, -1.1512129306793213, -0.1457023024559021, -0.6370311379432678, -0.5424215793609619, -0.4426094889640808, 0.4305403232574463, -0.38587304949760437, 0.33480706810951233, -0.502520740032196, 0.0437014177441597, -0.02030971087515354, -0.30551818013191223, -0.29203328490257263, -0.33383655548095703, -0.4442051947116852, -0.8241021037101746, 0.18432579934597015, -0.26406967639923096, 0.905472457408905, -0.1810077279806137, -0.11880814284086227, -0.015681561082601547, 0.14253219962120056, 0.24093890190124512, 0.4261121451854706, 0.03980134427547455, 0.6066689491271973, -0.3450963497161865, 0.4065227210521698, -0.8069815635681152, 0.45460885763168335, -1.347361445426941, 0.7941922545433044, -0.6053212285041809, -0.15913833677768707, -0.537156343460083, 0.5311529040336609, -0.06805150210857391, -0.9891736507415771, 0.19387125968933105, -0.19757996499538422, 0.04256429895758629, 0.8598942756652832, 0.24269059300422668, -0.3598150312900543, -0.8082546591758728, -0.6718141436576843, -0.9456302523612976, 0.5427452325820923, -0.2387121021747589, -0.7043861746788025, -0.534723162651062, -0.6885756850242615, -0.055760256946086884, -0.06526394933462143, 0.050226371735334396, 0.22087183594703674, -0.472408652305603, -0.5555340051651001, -0.15828430652618408, 0.16352134943008423, -0.07097847014665604, -0.2952005863189697, -0.44946983456611633, 0.2740603983402252, -0.6908363699913025, 0.39613959193229675, 0.2442704141139984, -1.709434986114502, -0.32211047410964966, 0.59763503074646, -0.05479618161916733, 0.4236612319946289, 0.5766333937644958, -0.8371523022651672, -0.15880538523197174, 0.3096964359283447, 0.19463054835796356, -0.13780304789543152, -0.03047090210020542, 0.7977808713912964, 0.05817252770066261, 0.39042186737060547, -1.0066722631454468, 0.25887006521224976, -0.16443504393100739, 0.18621978163719177, 0.24766623973846436, -0.2983107566833496, 0.11902853101491928, 1.0087082386016846, 0.14792579412460327, -1.0091524124145508, -0.4666796624660492, -0.952201247215271, 0.004638804588466883, -0.7252065539360046, -0.5480977296829224, 0.48407095670700073, -0.19066324830055237, 0.20566798746585846, 0.3821878433227539, 0.385664701461792, -0.4175713062286377, -0.4715234041213989, 0.41586077213287354, -0.6485726237297058, -0.5805842876434326, -0.11439311504364014, 0.9845334887504578, -0.26084285974502563, -0.13271509110927582, -0.5787199139595032, -0.5387983322143555, -0.2591499388217926, 0.2161254584789276, 0.372000515460968, -0.531449556350708, 0.736647367477417, 0.3213120996952057, 0.7449904084205627, 0.3530711531639099, 0.6925358772277832, 0.7246829271316528, 0.30374205112457275, 0.3266695737838745, -0.825425386428833, -0.47292447090148926, -0.19325578212738037, 0.12297230958938599, 0.7508627772331238, -0.530112087726593, 0.6756580471992493, 0.13017426431179047, -1.2654930353164673, -0.43451163172721863, -0.6526975631713867, 0.017060132697224617, -1.103817343711853, -0.2051105946302414, -0.676162838935852, -0.18964308500289917, 0.300729364156723, 0.47339510917663574, 0.39966633915901184, -0.7999252676963806, -1.1505953073501587, 0.0121163884177804, 0.43820804357528687, -0.9237196445465088, 0.06449642032384872, -0.630696177482605, -1.0691331624984741, -0.9407427906990051, -0.2347409427165985, 0.0024427997414022684, -0.2558757960796356, -0.0709901824593544, -0.3797866106033325, -0.046150680631399155, -0.6774406433105469, 0.39738696813583374, -0.3083701431751251, -0.3395594358444214, -0.09010270982980728, -0.044430896639823914, -0.6304469704627991, -0.3484646677970886, 0.18408626317977905, 0.04356110468506813, 0.2057303637266159, 0.009562483057379723, 0.4745030701160431, -0.16065584123134613, -1.2234870195388794, -0.21958619356155396, -1.0957313776016235, -0.1652812510728836, -0.5118792057037354, -1.0904496908187866, 0.7650285363197327, 0.1620454043149948, -0.7426481246948242, 0.21494075655937195, -0.13048487901687622, -0.07899966835975647, 0.2790381908416748, -0.12039763480424881, 0.07689963281154633, 0.3474735915660858, -0.25267404317855835, 1.1165310144424438, -0.15740449726581573, -0.19025446474552155, 0.06480994820594788, -0.05106925591826439, -0.3536161482334137, 0.7487580180168152, -0.1802269071340561, -0.3881095051765442, -0.8063175678253174, 0.2788814306259155, -0.0329352430999279, 0.045640286058187485, -0.4369412958621979, -0.6279294490814209, -0.650028645992279, -0.5817810297012329, -0.6316084265708923, 0.12635304033756256, 0.26317912340164185, -0.7896144986152649, -0.7355340719223022, -0.7782708406448364, -0.3134499192237854, 0.16574905812740326, -0.9278802275657654, -0.2956104874610901, -0.7273198366165161, -0.343234121799469, -0.30799564719200134, -0.8307945728302002, -0.13284403085708618, 0.5332480072975159, 0.6216302514076233, 0.3812365233898163, -0.8610661029815674, 0.19740507006645203, -0.09698539972305298, 0.28056973218917847, -0.6992433071136475, -0.2254476249217987, -0.5282207727432251, 0.42028602957725525, -0.314987450838089, -0.7666640877723694, -0.7611569166183472, -0.10400882363319397, -0.16685423254966736, -0.08922053128480911, -0.5160386562347412, 0.20157362520694733, 0.5862959623336792, 0.16805464029312134, -0.3850826919078827, 0.3460182249546051, 0.5747995972633362, 0.19984902441501617, -0.20012250542640686, -0.19688959419727325, 0.8352054357528687, 0.6701259613037109, 0.4580487608909607, -0.4024600088596344, 0.0011585613247007132, 0.8299547433853149, 0.23985187709331512, -0.9183158278465271, 1.3440861701965332, -0.5317012071609497, 0.43812915682792664, 0.4864739775657654, 0.5412074327468872, 0.16280975937843323, -0.14566205441951752, 0.16980141401290894, 0.4390449821949005, 0.5797126889228821, 0.08038271963596344, 0.3260102868080139, 0.30087512731552124, -0.23990070819854736, -0.02945677749812603, 1.0833356380462646, 0.19713349640369415, 1.0298774242401123, -0.1448115110397339, -0.07027514278888702, 0.21973153948783875, 0.07839063555002213, 0.038004614412784576, -0.2476138025522232, 0.3693382740020752, 0.34241795539855957, -0.023644989356398582, 0.613797128200531, -0.3351677358150482, -0.20032984018325806, -0.5497606992721558, 0.2580134868621826, -0.09676777571439743, 0.316423237323761, -0.2610597610473633, -0.34617453813552856, 0.5781941413879395, 0.7600524425506592, 0.7077435255050659, 1.0677648782730103, 0.7622886896133423, -0.10892832279205322, 0.21611975133419037, 1.0843420028686523, 0.8653923869132996, 0.4314040243625641, 0.10370828956365585, -1.1062655448913574, 0.3905252516269684, 0.15753400325775146, -1.7628886699676514, 0.05147138983011246, 0.00849112682044506, -0.0522625669836998, -0.12197404354810715, -0.8010649681091309, -0.0030004826840013266, -1.2792819738388062, 0.24674873054027557, 1.1666761636734009, 0.5513914227485657, -0.3790263235569, 0.1782802939414978, -0.2200724482536316, -0.13239040970802307, 1.158392071723938, 0.2903597056865692, 0.23007173836231232, 0.7482273578643799, 0.9498021006584167, -0.34742841124534607, 0.5337706208229065, 0.4780212938785553, 0.21421754360198975, -0.014037160202860832, 0.533750057220459, -0.03306660056114197, 0.8589655756950378, -0.10238873958587646, -0.20437580347061157, 0.04406255483627319, 0.6216533780097961, -0.49460381269454956, 0.5987940430641174, -0.01363674458116293, 0.49638962745666504, -0.10175956040620804, -0.5645559430122375, 0.9345568418502808, 0.30498871207237244, -0.23959499597549438, -0.3200140595436096, -0.780814528465271, 0.4504437744617462, 0.195407435297966, -0.1742338240146637, 0.2717355489730835, 0.04716114699840546, 0.5780347585678101, -0.10824421793222427, -0.7274028062820435, -0.11113674193620682, -0.8376012444496155, -0.09318768978118896, -0.4933376908302307, 0.5499045848846436, 0.020931681618094444, 0.44130367040634155, -0.5070427060127258, -0.6827517747879028, 0.38575905561447144, 0.2850404679775238, 1.0962125062942505, -0.07982347160577774, -0.01885860413312912, 0.9242691397666931, 0.6703544855117798, -0.8877648711204529, 1.2336310148239136, 0.4742152988910675, -0.712602972984314, 0.6021171808242798, 0.05701722204685211, -0.22745651006698608, 0.5695618391036987, -0.24563610553741455, 0.19693635404109955, -0.054643481969833374, -0.09246741235256195, -0.6513077020645142, -0.32107388973236084, -0.619687557220459, -0.6902483105659485, 0.7020258903503418, -0.8291744589805603, 0.3482314944267273, -0.6149933338165283, 1.1984628438949585, -0.36315038800239563, -0.3161044418811798, 3.923485517501831, 1.096359133720398, 0.6806548833847046, 0.14977321028709412, 0.9282402396202087, 0.9600556492805481, -0.14973755180835724, -0.47079262137413025, 0.43216511607170105, -0.4570339024066925, 0.2879970669746399, 0.15434761345386505, -0.5218900442123413, -0.35603392124176025, -0.7880898714065552, 0.5084260702133179, 0.03919176757335663, 0.7631343603134155, 0.4265124797821045, -0.9411464929580688, -0.48387959599494934, 0.5230230689048767, 0.6882984042167664, -0.059933315962553024, -0.775972843170166, 0.2951330244541168, 0.4409801661968231, -0.7109052538871765, -0.4061444103717804, -0.4861076772212982, -0.5452470779418945, -0.7910767793655396, 0.06667405366897583, -0.13884460926055908, -0.20695219933986664, -0.04971839115023613, -0.05951237305998802, -0.001914764055982232, 0.004898492246866226, 0.08030631393194199, 0.1287217140197754, -0.08225846290588379, -0.18293297290802002, 0.15932480990886688, -1.2214453220367432, 0.4954136610031128, -1.0820499658584595, 0.849287211894989, 0.24210427701473236, -0.5687856674194336, 0.8702664375305176, -0.3017052412033081, 0.5450071692466736, -0.019589027389883995, -0.7632545828819275, 0.00997933093458414, -0.20557020604610443, -0.4706595242023468, -0.3234855532646179, 0.0990615040063858, 0.4404590129852295, -0.0022978009656071663, -0.6347008347511292, 0.026471920311450958, 0.2315986305475235, 0.5040751695632935, 1.0233962535858154, 0.16258230805397034, -0.08515004068613052, 0.7027425169944763, -0.0848863273859024, -0.16107483208179474, -0.9602564573287964, 0.15422122180461884, 0.06234005093574524, -0.1472516506910324, 0.018829133361577988, 0.6359198093414307, -0.3240152597427368, -0.37664660811424255, -0.13135506212711334, -0.48696231842041016, -0.023113101720809937, 0.7198304533958435, -0.3084607720375061, 1.0389072895050049, 0.472009539604187, -0.09083884954452515, 0.06892870366573334, 0.737378716468811, 0.24221305549144745, 1.3037660121917725, -0.04900820925831795, -0.7628549337387085, -0.6511951088905334 ]
Ferromagnetism of the 1-D Kondo Lattice Model: A Quantum Monte Carlo Study
The one dimensional Kondo lattice model is investigated using Quantum Monte Carlo and transfer matrix techniques. In the strong coupling region ferromagnetic ordering is found even at large band fillings. In the weak coupling region the system shows an RKKY like behavior.
Matthias Troyer and Diethelm W\"urtz
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207016
cond-mat/9207017
[ 0.39268574118614197, 0.2710462808609009, -0.0817539319396019, 0.7849605083465576, 0.007102888077497482, 0.16399072110652924, 0.03528544306755066, -0.8905559182167053, -0.5723983645439148, 1.1697245836257935, 0.24107910692691803, 0.44539791345596313, 0.810513973236084, -1.6709339618682861, 0.15244071185588837, 0.08232526481151581, -0.43549320101737976, -1.0030736923217773, -1.8256994485855103, 0.11485514044761658, -0.4174073338508606, -0.35280749201774597, -0.6353990435600281, -0.71025151014328, -0.6886793971061707, 0.23619982600212097, 0.13494718074798584, 0.22714544832706451, 0.5767223834991455, 0.2815971076488495, 0.2789325714111328, -0.013373633846640587, -0.27894002199172974, -0.8060541749000549, 0.04413123428821564, 0.7293525338172913, 0.045809097588062286, -0.05760147422552109, 0.4786818325519562, 0.2796410918235779, 0.4889763593673706, -0.5001632571220398, 0.2722896635532379, -0.2000764012336731, -0.07180162519216537, 0.9986252784729004, -0.27498844265937805, -0.3191382884979248, 0.1787828952074051, -1.6211941242218018, -0.1922784149646759, 0.333938330411911, 0.399677574634552, -0.25133249163627625, 0.1261884570121765, 0.1864704191684723, -0.3828709125518799, -0.1375865340232849, -0.5571454763412476, -0.1764662265777588, 0.3691326081752777, -0.15641549229621887, 0.6496368050575256, -0.5575756430625916, 0.14105521142482758, 0.22972345352172852, -0.011406884528696537, 1.130578637123108, -0.1011452004313469, -0.13032139837741852, -0.24260543286800385, -0.07422890514135361, 0.05385766178369522, -0.08439374715089798, -0.41283565759658813, 0.35110872983932495, 0.11085395514965057, -1.0876028537750244, -0.7005038261413574, -1.166354775428772, 0.017619961872696877, -0.2781904935836792, 0.06475476920604706, 0.22506709396839142, -0.18712159991264343, -0.5875735878944397, -0.5356375575065613, -0.757246196269989, 0.1870354562997818, 0.3370001018047333, 0.4370284080505371, 1.0760972499847412, 0.2825617492198944, 0.022762738168239594, 0.6780954003334045, 0.6785501837730408, 0.21334239840507507, 0.1387084424495697, -0.08540496975183487, 0.3413163125514984, 0.002900132443755865, 0.7255508899688721, -0.5462207794189453, 0.44666510820388794, -0.495449960231781, 0.7393878102302551, 0.3243195116519928, -0.0534779354929924, 0.14905641973018646, -0.7593681812286377, -0.46840420365333557, 0.37659549713134766, 0.6940540075302124, 0.3798690736293793, 0.01176570262759924, 0.16070762276649475, 0.43671128153800964, -0.21160854399204254, -1.6190191507339478, -0.49894776940345764, 0.25109416246414185, 0.17328906059265137, 0.6182438135147095, 0.6705325245857239, -0.8884686231613159, -0.583879828453064, 0.7415555119514465, 0.6613170504570007, -0.041501596570014954, -0.2466742992401123, -0.29153600335121155, -0.1836436539888382, -0.48168256878852844, 1.129618525505066, 0.028139149770140648, 0.5410489439964294, -0.5009999871253967, 0.2214186042547226, 0.7173051238059998, 0.22509238123893738, 0.38090771436691284, -0.8947637677192688, 0.39982712268829346, 0.6054718494415283, -0.23835963010787964, 0.07109157741069794, 0.6576921343803406, 0.01126523781567812, 0.08038563281297684, 0.6665318012237549, -0.9411845207214355, -0.5055291652679443, -0.4612172245979309, -0.22005629539489746, 0.1794929802417755, 0.2722698152065277, -1.134681224822998, 0.7827221155166626, -0.4291078448295593, -0.3518373668193817, 0.7073447108268738, -0.3041909337043762, -0.04984453320503235, 0.42988190054893494, -0.4909000098705292, 0.15296709537506104, -0.18950745463371277, -0.5770747661590576, 0.947337806224823, -0.24146030843257904, -0.7401291131973267, 0.30115121603012085, 0.7357538938522339, -0.0048106820322573185, 0.5504953265190125, 0.47849223017692566, 0.7720571160316467, 0.26126283407211304, -0.24632161855697632, -0.18144477903842926, 0.20624397695064545, -0.01265409030020237, 0.9780504107475281, 0.22099079191684723, -0.3623075485229492, 0.28766554594039917, -0.37102842330932617, -0.6054961681365967, 0.7552710175514221, 0.5191439390182495, -0.2047569751739502, 0.31556910276412964, 0.014435524120926857, -0.08995382487773895, -0.6375507712364197, -0.17664116621017456, -0.7382596135139465, -0.24174505472183228, -0.04520172253251076, -0.3074793219566345, -0.4085601270198822, 0.9019901156425476, -1.1515015363693237, 0.8333284854888916, -1.251307725906372, 0.6240012645721436, 1.0756245851516724, 0.3680100440979004, -0.3693104684352875, -0.607201874256134, 0.6619247794151306, -0.04565727710723877, 0.38976815342903137, 0.18096208572387695, 0.4730053246021271, 0.16799086332321167, -0.20190683007240295, -0.026545163244009018, 0.4016270935535431, -0.04567350819706917, 0.24673204123973846, -0.07798315584659576, -0.4447636008262634, 0.1871582567691803, -0.11839614808559418, -0.3945430517196655, 0.04848724976181984, 0.5248111486434937, -0.15853986144065857, -0.5054948329925537, 0.07970272749662399, 0.1360827088356018, -0.6096476912498474, 0.13676440715789795, 0.8299679160118103, 0.13251416385173798, 0.2906081974506378, 0.5069178938865662, -0.29360055923461914, -0.4201834499835968, -0.04874909296631813, -0.013605378568172455, 0.8616037368774414, -0.10048363357782364, -0.7034767270088196, -0.0003155663434881717, -0.9337642788887024, -0.05144321545958519, -0.6084632873535156, -0.1165020689368248, -0.5036404728889465, 0.019674591720104218, -0.19954456388950348, -0.145848348736763, -0.6513580083847046, -0.18248875439167023, -0.6207892298698425, 0.34770438075065613, 0.40759843587875366, -0.8188055753707886, 0.3799803853034973, -0.037907060235738754, -0.015170186758041382, -0.5124475359916687, 0.06611844897270203, 1.168987512588501, -0.30690884590148926, -0.2129300832748413, -0.14299659430980682, -0.30780500173568726, -1.4075442552566528, -0.49356356263160706, -0.798960268497467, -0.0738031342625618, -0.7271809577941895, -0.05662425607442856, 0.9072213172912598, -0.6269241571426392, 0.22450998425483704, -0.3155924081802368, 0.3135981559753418, 0.2977108955383301, -0.7000709176063538, 0.13041478395462036, -0.12700237333774567, 0.3533267378807068, -1.285952091217041, 0.36575326323509216, -0.8335698246955872, 0.03452026844024658, -0.4942888021469116, -0.0564083568751812, 0.2601292133331299, -0.472206175327301, 0.513958752155304, 0.03137445077300072, -0.4675886929035187, 0.09938038885593414, -0.16002807021141052, -0.49892115592956543, 0.05208790302276611, 0.07319715619087219, -0.36181312799453735, -0.6425695419311523, -0.4399465322494507, 0.8560341596603394, -0.5001875758171082, -0.1378583163022995, 0.6728818416595459, 0.037664368748664856, -0.2827366292476654, -0.05081277713179588, -0.37885281443595886, -0.3865337371826172, -0.07901116460561752, 0.5116437077522278, 1.1740704774856567, -0.23405632376670837, -0.4731435477733612, -0.1117110550403595, 0.06115315109491348, 0.40834519267082214, 0.6488993763923645, -1.13267183303833, 0.2968134880065918, 0.8419591188430786, 0.21446698904037476, -0.15522043406963348, 0.13203781843185425, -1.4460372924804688, -0.34669485688209534, 0.0834103375673294, -0.15641853213310242, 0.6577497720718384, 0.1771395057439804, -0.4074733257293701, -0.9026263952255249, -0.1485457867383957, 0.717311680316925, 0.00596109963953495, 0.1367022842168808, -0.13782255351543427, 0.8932337164878845, 0.5970756411552429, 0.12771742045879364, -0.30167409777641296, 0.13053672015666962, -0.04262900352478027, -0.6714527606964111, 0.12979437410831451, -0.9917142987251282, 0.16083575785160065, 0.6134185791015625, 0.3734753727912903, 0.20530392229557037, 0.4093673825263977, 0.08494485169649124, -0.6931272149085999, -0.29464206099510193, 0.31121671199798584, 0.6295461058616638, 0.6108318567276001, 0.33128008246421814, 0.06778503954410553, -0.8004553318023682, 0.18637163937091827, 0.046815648674964905, 0.12464193254709244, 1.018625259399414, -0.6258688569068909, 0.36752599477767944, 0.4037341773509979, -0.29794585704803467, 0.34395599365234375, -0.43566781282424927, 0.6815534234046936, -0.1440543234348297, 0.6498468518257141, 1.078652024269104, -0.4811857044696808, -0.5808654427528381, -0.1445104330778122, 1.5399274826049805, 0.21152597665786743, 0.6129968762397766, 0.45013555884361267, -0.32448941469192505, 0.5520998239517212, -0.179069384932518, -0.5753908753395081, 0.4166125953197479, 0.2498854547739029, -0.3794456720352173, -0.08667649328708649, 0.1025983914732933, 0.21114632487297058, 0.14121577143669128, 0.07600029557943344, -0.17219144105911255, 0.21265679597854614, 0.5955196022987366, 0.6498957872390747, 0.7561720609664917, 0.3454015552997589, -0.09735650569200516, -0.6528239846229553, -0.45555299520492554, -0.33860960602760315, 0.34212347865104675, 0.4105752110481262, -0.0971534252166748, -1.2168580293655396, -0.1341700553894043, -0.02251593954861164, 0.5620595216751099, 0.7692252397537231, -0.052252575755119324, 0.0957513228058815, 0.49147629737854004, 0.7041071653366089, -0.6419718265533447, -0.21154549717903137, 1.1782877445220947, 0.35690954327583313, 0.614218533039093, -0.9890391826629639, 0.3018437922000885, -0.28960272669792175, -0.05693112686276436, 0.8429844379425049, -0.6238119602203369, -0.8656845688819885, 0.06204722449183464, 0.9881213307380676, -0.8578969240188599, -0.2488415539264679, 0.9751359224319458, 0.48904818296432495, -0.06529199331998825, -0.08366847783327103, 0.21814729273319244, 1.2477281093597412, -0.8986185193061829, -0.6331503391265869, -0.7040793895721436, -0.06369104981422424, -0.05433420091867447, 0.2790147364139557, -0.7372810244560242, -0.3519006669521332, -0.10873612016439438, -0.24049469828605652, 0.7998629212379456, 0.3125390112400055, -0.8366379737854004, 0.13437974452972412, -0.8460232019424438, -0.06409475952386856, 0.9845299124717712, -0.08495175838470459, -0.6656007170677185, 0.2238815426826477, -0.027301600202918053, 0.040441710501909256, -0.5114076733589172, -0.028697403147816658, 0.048120129853487015, 1.0378910303115845, 0.4965292811393738, -0.016398558393120766, 0.7115047574043274, 0.17074333131313324, -0.5584433078765869, 0.4280906617641449, -0.2198939323425293, 0.18736636638641357, -0.12052121758460999, -0.7136595249176025, -0.14758896827697754, -0.9060273170471191, 0.010084579698741436, 1.0300557613372803, -0.01318390667438507, 0.8736445307731628, 0.1327410340309143, -0.7846295833587646, -0.1070418506860733, -0.2666378915309906, -0.7294216752052307, 0.6489468216896057, -0.1166289672255516, -0.42121005058288574, -0.1755073070526123, -0.6911047101020813, -0.31244513392448425, 0.0027977237477898598, 0.10842327028512955, -0.6318728923797607, 0.4907230734825134, -0.11079411208629608, -0.10093972831964493, -0.2893921434879303, -0.18037983775138855, 0.8793665170669556, -0.3145221173763275, 0.08551250398159027, -0.45478320121765137, -0.37528112530708313, -0.8030334115028381, 0.20447367429733276, 0.8769189119338989, -0.4425767660140991, -0.04000767320394516, -0.07235824316740036, -0.2182609587907791, 0.3599655330181122, -0.5204359292984009, 0.17079728841781616, -0.7923517823219299, 0.1330672949552536, 0.07710286229848862, -0.39281871914863586, 0.21641811728477478, 0.47096413373947144, -0.2789522111415863, -0.05816783756017685, 0.20884329080581665, -0.7225746512413025, 0.6181290149688721, 0.37824124097824097, 1.1612348556518555, -1.1376789808273315, -0.2736077904701233, -0.6324286460876465, -0.36276450753211975, 0.27857524156570435, 0.36980754137039185, -0.42315322160720825, 0.006516735535115004, -0.3842129111289978, 0.1435311883687973, 0.033022090792655945, 0.05761491134762764, 0.3269417881965637, -0.5873725414276123, -0.9120991230010986, -0.9392017126083374, 0.7726837992668152, -0.26942238211631775, 0.7501076459884644, 1.1481889486312866, -0.3906234800815582, -0.27932998538017273, 0.45272478461265564, 0.016024576500058174, -0.3704286813735962, -0.32716652750968933, 0.5984439253807068, -0.05237424746155739, 0.9293975830078125, -0.7278519868850708, 0.36172470450401306, -1.0086637735366821, 1.0294513702392578, -0.07154937088489532, -0.03663822263479233, -0.6088902950286865, 0.423438161611557, 0.34884846210479736, -0.7271592617034912, 1.0141326189041138, 0.5182268023490906, -0.3275037109851837, 0.4004676043987274, 0.2557445466518402, -0.43196719884872437, -0.7611520290374756, -0.5841426253318787, -0.9977832436561584, 1.3294482231140137, 0.0934121161699295, 0.07995592057704926, -0.37064650654792786, -0.6757703423500061, 0.04820460453629494, 0.09815174341201782, 0.33449599146842957, 0.8783373832702637, 0.4586212635040283, 0.15485021471977234, 0.2543780207633972, 0.5256913304328918, 0.2937339246273041, 0.6102945804595947, 0.5038073062896729, -0.6008378267288208, 0.06624430418014526, 0.2693217694759369, -0.008489773608744144, -1.082826852798462, -0.22494801878929138, 0.4303019940853119, -0.09744852781295776, -0.4509561359882355, 0.9193347692489624, -0.34534820914268494, -0.3382681608200073, -0.15294596552848816, -0.3725096881389618, -0.6483715772628784, 0.34900033473968506, 1.1335768699645996, 0.5063150525093079, 0.5287238359451294, -0.11070067435503006, 0.38555192947387695, -0.45532768964767456, -0.06991095840930939, -0.29168638586997986, -0.8211449980735779, -0.4678652584552765, 0.06768521666526794, 0.3229595124721527, 0.04369829222559929, -0.7621527910232544, -0.6053056120872498, -0.5317277908325195, 0.29837796092033386, -0.7504395842552185, 0.17617611587047577, -0.0919339582324028, -0.1792638748884201, -0.06087781488895416, 0.5930389165878296, 0.0024802975822240114, 0.3538251519203186, 0.5750536322593689, -1.2882483005523682, -0.07546485960483551, 0.044014714658260345, 0.8052698969841003, 0.027446091175079346, -0.6622795462608337, -0.2155916392803192, -0.5673380494117737, -0.9077128171920776, -0.3276827931404114, 0.8436299562454224, 0.039486490190029144, 0.3244854211807251, -0.18763770163059235, -0.32806193828582764, 0.600937008857727, 0.7594676613807678, 0.37881019711494446, -0.28184494376182556, -0.4194534420967102, -0.7436884045600891, -0.08242543786764145, -0.47921526432037354, 0.2781839072704315, 0.23095789551734924, -0.1859280914068222, 0.6184512972831726, -0.013613075949251652, -0.6450797915458679, -0.5162338614463806, -0.8361846804618835, 0.08317506313323975, -0.5838119983673096, -0.5573582649230957, -0.8344418406486511, -0.24634011089801788, -0.09292403608560562, 0.5256996750831604, -0.256716251373291, -0.5196024775505066, -0.41537314653396606, 0.12657400965690613, 0.7573909163475037, -0.3344353139400482, 0.46744248270988464, -0.5325736403465271, -1.0871660709381104, -0.213785320520401, -0.7309750914573669, -0.34428897500038147, 0.11843660473823547, 0.03250034898519516, -0.18443766236305237, -0.038951363414525986, -0.8531367182731628, 0.8649036288261414, -0.6537721157073975, -0.9776976108551025, -0.1287805289030075, 0.48591041564941406, -0.09220731258392334, 0.4932117164134979, 0.0956927090883255, -0.2884872257709503, 0.18213270604610443, 0.07488305121660233, 0.6958854794502258, 0.5423259735107422, -1.0366066694259644, 0.5262933969497681, 0.31951767206192017, -0.10385189205408096, 0.042735755443573, -0.35824131965637207, 0.3240189850330353, 1.3058192729949951, -1.0860352516174316, 0.3305134177207947, -0.5985826253890991, 0.8829566836357117, -0.19446364045143127, -0.07057590782642365, -0.2230273336172104, -0.20057517290115356, -0.5519260764122009, 0.8586238026618958, -0.15298381447792053, -0.2771700620651245, 0.07485497742891312, 0.1828819364309311, -0.6300221085548401, -0.16101379692554474, 0.09255680441856384, -0.7170299291610718, 0.4378563463687897, 0.5202227830886841, -0.4841793477535248, 0.1421150118112564, 1.0563749074935913, -0.009983357973396778, -0.8839752674102783, -0.038631174713373184, -0.5305108428001404, 0.5086274743080139, 0.2602742612361908, 0.1480780690908432, 0.19520358741283417, -0.4871933162212372, -0.2856011390686035, 0.1342819184064865, -0.614099383354187, 0.30119672417640686, -0.5067413449287415, -0.441133052110672, -0.23436610400676727, -0.5857582092285156, 0.06519362330436707, 0.9814841747283936, 0.08832289278507233, 0.6019087433815002, -0.24641405045986176, -0.1609671711921692, -0.28343862295150757, -0.7358585000038147, -1.1896628141403198, 0.5207507014274597, -0.9307157397270203, 0.4292168617248535, -0.1337241530418396, -0.7369081377983093, -0.38092952966690063, 0.736892819404602, -0.22348514199256897, -0.2752791941165924, -0.5043206810951233, -0.22034963965415955, -0.3460000455379486, 0.158075749874115, 0.2705381512641907, -0.864905834197998, 0.20533299446105957, 0.9634479284286499, 0.25582483410835266, -0.4676589369773865, 0.11060143262147903, 0.2829573154449463, -0.4334779679775238, -0.12014207243919373, -0.19291208684444427, 0.975408136844635, 0.43639105558395386, -0.7377838492393494, 0.9541876912117004, 0.00046234382898546755, 0.5317894220352173, 0.19510656595230103, -0.274161159992218, -0.9474599361419678, 0.4413864016532898, 0.31263992190361023, 0.7565181851387024, 0.1973385214805603, -0.0834333598613739, 0.23055897653102875, -0.04005133733153343, -0.12374407052993774, 0.027189744636416435, 0.17024819552898407, -0.5441200137138367, 0.7726593017578125, -0.5572218894958496, 1.0625466108322144, -0.21220813691616058, 0.635405957698822, -0.08728595077991486, -0.30000579357147217, -0.6028605103492737, -0.6984801292419434, -0.16722221672534943, 0.27505001425743103, -0.83257657289505, 0.19106543064117432, -0.185397207736969, 0.06677018105983734, 0.20952707529067993, -0.6350032687187195, 0.002877086866647005, 0.5703796744346619, 0.5121845602989197, -0.18021227419376373, 0.4931645393371582, 0.714988648891449, 0.048546306788921356, 0.3140895366668701, 0.45197775959968567, 0.9064355492591858, 0.7149450778961182, 0.7769573330879211, -0.12226933985948563, -0.9907898902893066, -0.26527291536331177, 0.6254837512969971, -0.984158992767334, 0.10025843232870102, -0.27546635270118713, 0.061167873442173004, 0.5307279825210571, 0.06557930260896683, 0.6387766003608704, -0.8911817669868469, -0.4081641435623169, 1.2759220600128174, -0.13872022926807404, -0.4949270188808441, 0.7781097888946533, -0.05153113603591919, 0.06700976938009262, 0.8061143755912781, -0.3208923041820526, -0.4621645212173462, 0.7570553421974182, 0.8958144187927246, -0.37349626421928406, 0.32351335883140564, -0.11967094987630844, -0.46493834257125854, -0.1722172349691391, 0.3133649230003357, -0.5629130005836487, 0.5532612204551697, -0.41495415568351746, 0.21975812315940857, -0.35936781764030457, -0.6404159665107727, 0.13060075044631958, 0.39690229296684265, 0.18256260454654694, -0.11087707430124283, -0.3111080825328827, -0.3561684489250183, 1.3237154483795166, 0.25804403424263, -0.6434747576713562, -1.0947803258895874, -0.01485024020075798, 0.14544987678527832, -0.835170328617096, 0.34096452593803406, -0.034399326890707016, 0.41935214400291443, 0.02257695235311985, -0.15126924216747284, -0.32392194867134094, 0.15686708688735962, -0.43721920251846313, -0.2417992800474167, -0.45836785435676575, 0.5938682556152344, 0.2662746012210846, 0.8440911769866943, -0.09947121888399124, -0.2734646797180176, -0.27888667583465576, -0.14369326829910278, 0.5423085689544678, -0.22063882648944855, 0.3243601620197296, 0.40247389674186707, 0.2165665179491043, -0.41622859239578247, 0.3530316650867462, 0.7280405759811401, -0.7681052684783936, 0.5019634962081909, -0.13592731952667236, -0.41727909445762634, 0.725744366645813, 0.3608226478099823, -0.5644852519035339, 0.4273516535758972, 0.9323914647102356, -0.08546606451272964, -0.2816467583179474, -0.2699205279350281, -0.7801905274391174, -0.04067784175276756, -0.2848193049430847, 0.29406794905662537, 0.2291383296251297, 0.2763391435146332, 0.35177022218704224, -0.3119232952594757, 3.992610216140747, 0.20840142667293549, 1.0470430850982666, -0.6096951961517334, 0.48594653606414795, 0.7834084630012512, 0.19439199566841125, -0.2473975121974945, 0.34348365664482117, -0.5288420915603638, -0.2502334713935852, 0.4102328419685364, -0.02418499067425728, -0.28582802414894104, -0.10225514322519302, 1.001889705657959, 0.383876234292984, 0.24497392773628235, -0.5238622426986694, -0.7159640192985535, -0.17497247457504272, 0.043273650109767914, 0.1740921437740326, 0.14078719913959503, 0.027425633743405342, 0.1870107799768448, -0.02748582512140274, -0.30096009373664856, -0.5714374780654907, -1.115930199623108, -0.6970120668411255, -0.6634861826896667, 0.30292001366615295, -0.40743380784988403, -0.22766628861427307, 0.7128326296806335, 0.7369027733802795, 0.4662730097770691, 0.30562466382980347, -0.5829350352287292, -0.0027799964882433414, -0.7189428806304932, -0.26926541328430176, -0.30477574467658997, -0.8890742659568787, 0.5172334909439087, 0.060660090297460556, 1.549127221107483, 0.6955974102020264, -0.6896741986274719, -0.10417775064706802, 0.13483098149299622, 0.04511891305446625, 0.19553105533123016, -0.5037434697151184, 0.023494822904467583, -0.5687147974967957, -1.1964919567108154, -0.8513900637626648, -0.02803780511021614, 1.1331818103790283, -0.05011305212974548, 0.14645862579345703, -0.09200969338417053, -0.28438860177993774, 0.9425391554832458, 0.6943449378013611, -0.19541870057582855, -0.2733812630176544, -0.0926394835114479, -0.4451551139354706, -0.10317278653383255, -0.7035467028617859, 0.5305928587913513, 0.2861163020133972, 0.3727587163448334, 0.4614248275756836, 0.31475815176963806, -0.00892519298940897, 0.17805573344230652, -0.0481814481317997, -0.03153154253959656, -0.3496255874633789, 0.3760583996772766, -0.201512411236763, 0.6113106608390808, -0.5990586280822754, -0.4058879017829895, -0.2960815727710724, 1.0174442529678345, 0.49292388558387756, 1.567983865737915, -0.015103875659406185, 0.4956211447715759, -0.9717590808868408 ]
Transport Properties and Fluctuations in Type II Superconductors Near $H_{c2}$
We study the flux-flow Hall effect and thermomagnetic transport near the upper critical field \hctwo\ in extreme type-II superconductors starting from a suitable generalization of the time dependent Ginzburg-Landau equations. We explicitly incorporate the effects of backflow into the calculations of the local electric field and current, leading to a current which is properly divergenceless. The Hall conductivity calculated from this current agrees with other mean-field calculations which assume a uniform applied electric field (the Schmid-Caroli-Maki solution), thereby vindicating these simplified treatments. We then use these results to calculate the transverse thermomagnetic effects (the Ettingshausen and Nernst effects). The effects of thermal fluctuations and nonlocal elasticity of the flux lattice are incorporated using a method recently developed by Vecris and Pelcovits [G. Vecris and R. A. Pelcovits, Phys. Rev. B {\bf 44}, 2767 (1991)]. Our results, taken together with those of Vecris and Pelcovits, provide a rather complete description of the transport properties of the flux lattice state near \hctwo, at least within the framework of time dependent Ginzburg-Landau theory.
Robert J. Troy and Alan T. Dorsey
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207017
cond-mat/9207018
[ 0.14605097472667694, 0.619001030921936, -0.1264277696609497, 0.7086161375045776, 0.004757910966873169, -0.15960171818733215, 0.4136364758014679, -0.6069697141647339, -0.6792085766792297, 1.4244388341903687, 0.26899001002311707, 0.24187776446342468, 0.9527749419212341, -1.1797618865966797, -0.3730820119380951, 0.1995733082294464, -0.31893131136894226, -0.9556562304496765, -1.9001893997192383, 0.16762706637382507, 0.029322724789381027, -0.2523159980773926, -0.28977465629577637, -0.8730587959289551, -0.4280281960964203, 0.5657533407211304, 0.0019195735221728683, 0.14886775612831116, 0.4504961371421814, 0.4429025948047638, 0.7226038575172424, -0.43412864208221436, -0.16625656187534332, -1.1587615013122559, -0.08261309564113617, 0.7519350051879883, -0.26407405734062195, 0.034977566450834274, 0.6322667002677917, 0.014963670633733273, 0.5426357984542847, -0.16265586018562317, 0.14169295132160187, -0.1428152173757553, 0.2166992872953415, 0.5601363182067871, -0.37993407249450684, -0.2558523714542389, 0.0655854269862175, -1.2533942461013794, 0.2789577543735504, 0.35844263434410095, 0.3192523419857025, -0.5498726963996887, 0.10650418698787689, -0.03150763362646103, -0.15785838663578033, 0.17933829128742218, -0.27854037284851074, 0.07512827217578888, 0.560452938079834, 0.03692476078867912, 1.0257998704910278, -0.5220534801483154, 0.1660947948694229, 0.6386577486991882, -0.11137720942497253, 1.1105009317398071, -0.2802667021751404, -0.22325493395328522, -0.36595165729522705, 0.0918600857257843, 0.36477941274642944, -0.04897770285606384, -0.7456544041633606, 0.6583741307258606, 0.09499640762805939, -0.7930231094360352, -0.7677239775657654, -0.8365516066551208, -0.16212984919548035, -0.4710423946380615, 0.003442025976255536, -0.12896764278411865, -0.0787929892539978, -0.6574662327766418, -0.672216534614563, -0.40418165922164917, 0.36078184843063354, 0.7878643870353699, 0.49332210421562195, 1.1050118207931519, -0.2976234555244446, -0.10038217902183533, 0.5840465426445007, 0.3119240701198578, -0.10437282919883728, 0.26182031631469727, 0.4311444163322449, 0.20538052916526794, 0.2845686376094818, 0.9026461243629456, -0.708558976650238, 0.3588173985481262, -0.42170146107673645, 0.6002264022827148, -0.09530656784772873, 0.170789897441864, -0.19233889877796173, -0.8648089170455933, 0.1812509000301361, 0.49053144454956055, 0.23345139622688293, 0.6943787336349487, 0.10224656015634537, 0.384933739900589, 0.6807895302772522, 0.2630215585231781, -1.1120822429656982, -0.6010007858276367, 0.1159571185708046, 0.15099665522575378, 0.7473921179771423, 0.19465728104114532, -0.7369927763938904, -0.3278023600578308, 0.43078717589378357, 0.6949717402458191, -0.19568820297718048, 0.26588118076324463, -0.03096276894211769, 0.055416565388441086, -0.6215336918830872, 0.7080477476119995, 0.45570582151412964, 0.862023651599884, -0.5049430131912231, 0.2043827623128891, 0.419669508934021, 0.4361453950405121, -0.017523858696222305, -0.6843583583831787, -0.24741624295711517, 0.5808534622192383, -0.3131157457828522, 0.20274701714515686, 0.6491118669509888, 0.3703521490097046, 0.1899857521057129, 0.3861845135688782, -0.7313255071640015, -0.6740936636924744, -0.1253482550382614, -0.17047789692878723, -0.08012860268354416, 0.17480240762233734, -0.7416198253631592, 0.6334013342857361, -0.5891159176826477, -0.25971007347106934, 0.5535692572593689, -0.1844954490661621, 0.5322868824005127, 0.13667862117290497, -0.30397722125053406, 0.0012466132175177336, -0.19658911228179932, -0.9681052565574646, 0.5383053421974182, -0.5694860219955444, -0.6956951022148132, 0.3860989212989807, 0.4410029649734497, -0.02387406677007675, 0.26441940665245056, 0.6248586773872375, 0.5331245064735413, 0.006534406449645758, -0.4399646520614624, -0.012287499383091927, -0.11649305373430252, -0.13792674243450165, 0.9701299071311951, 0.4689493775367737, 0.23104456067085266, -0.2839479446411133, -0.03842829912900925, -0.32180333137512207, 0.549350380897522, 0.4509233832359314, 0.03607584536075592, 0.2646905481815338, -0.029700003564357758, -0.16345937550067902, -1.0112277269363403, -0.044218458235263824, -0.46846210956573486, -0.21273928880691528, 0.22658152878284454, -0.1480190008878708, -0.0062234532088041306, 0.19390054047107697, -1.1963083744049072, 0.5768712759017944, -1.398169994354248, 0.2562349736690521, 0.8771506547927856, 0.6689860224723816, -0.04598233848810196, -0.13249658048152924, 0.4199996292591095, -0.30514204502105713, 0.17862290143966675, -0.40971875190734863, 0.6980215311050415, 0.22958731651306152, -0.0744018629193306, 0.041657913476228714, 0.46638384461402893, 0.03119422309100628, 0.7723989486694336, -0.08622194081544876, -0.18909499049186707, 0.13704288005828857, -0.19248954951763153, -0.17470231652259827, 0.1959596425294876, 0.43897125124931335, 0.46573111414909363, 0.2207079976797104, -0.028780439868569374, 0.5089003443717957, -0.5706961154937744, 0.3311636745929718, 0.6719500422477722, 0.27384284138679504, -0.22796988487243652, 0.6455344557762146, 0.05340227857232094, -0.25863581895828247, 0.16857992112636566, 0.14836320281028748, 0.6653521060943604, -0.2453070431947708, -0.5744795203208923, -0.3530919551849365, -0.7424028515815735, -0.3057776093482971, -0.9840937256813049, 0.09293975681066513, -0.6073033809661865, 0.19269727170467377, -0.03571661561727524, 0.09504491090774536, -0.2239828258752823, -0.1038040891289711, 0.28399422764778137, -0.08047840744256973, 0.11188466846942902, -0.5757883191108704, 0.7226670384407043, -0.15269185602664948, 0.12988808751106262, -0.9032497406005859, 0.21835874021053314, 1.0500563383102417, -0.36794403195381165, -0.15842731297016144, -0.0003464836336206645, 0.0057683843187987804, -0.8959567546844482, -0.26002174615859985, -0.7918551564216614, -0.24606019258499146, -0.580036997795105, 0.058682311326265335, 0.6134476661682129, -0.5518602132797241, 1.1011162996292114, -0.5398500561714172, 0.2158590853214264, 0.34256985783576965, -0.3581295311450958, 0.4628247320652008, -0.510210394859314, 0.5189810395240784, -1.0922980308532715, 0.2015223354101181, -1.0787842273712158, 0.409714013338089, -0.6175971031188965, -0.03293123096227646, 0.37217265367507935, -0.5181446671485901, 0.10255110263824463, -0.0019002747721970081, -0.18484410643577576, 0.15623733401298523, -0.5332838296890259, -0.44162797927856445, -0.2468782514333725, 0.15156760811805725, -0.579109787940979, -0.47984760999679565, -0.5397734045982361, 0.5416005253791809, -0.6420363783836365, -0.3377282917499542, 0.45632728934288025, 0.16938932240009308, -0.6883218884468079, 0.3105063736438751, -0.42051011323928833, -0.20916981995105743, 0.005411494057625532, 0.7315939664840698, 1.173349380493164, 0.31043708324432373, 0.12590265274047852, -0.32091110944747925, -0.008001142181456089, 0.46076321601867676, 0.06763111799955368, -0.8548359870910645, 0.008464621379971504, 0.6554537415504456, 0.22373320162296295, 0.021261578425765038, 0.09179859608411789, -1.2584967613220215, -0.10790194571018219, 0.041670385748147964, 0.10904450714588165, 0.6170325875282288, -0.0032650998327881098, -0.6477459669113159, -0.7608773708343506, -0.4576958417892456, 0.5172696113586426, 0.4808238744735718, -0.11790299415588379, -0.12978681921958923, 0.731396496295929, 0.2062039077281952, 0.27939572930336, 0.1905566304922104, 0.012728843837976456, -0.7777717113494873, -0.4479726254940033, -0.0063795242458581924, -1.3370015621185303, -0.27494534850120544, 0.5591433048248291, -0.472286581993103, 0.009533056989312172, 0.6449962854385376, -0.7701953053474426, -0.5686720013618469, -0.15715733170509338, 0.3266875743865967, 0.8038614392280579, 0.792106568813324, -0.062010589987039566, -0.876916229724884, -0.5365872979164124, -0.0785776674747467, 0.3456583619117737, -0.0633038803935051, 0.7273347973823547, -0.5378351807594299, 0.3717438280582428, 0.15983068943023682, -0.8337528705596924, 0.14928948879241943, -0.2353040874004364, 0.4539322555065155, 0.34620562195777893, 0.2600319981575012, 0.8446105122566223, -0.516133725643158, -0.1313048154115677, -0.4310150742530823, 1.2716447114944458, -0.19457601010799408, 0.6188288331031799, 0.3721851706504822, -0.16478505730628967, 0.17815330624580383, -0.16153492033481598, -0.09878876060247421, 0.46371543407440186, -0.27878424525260925, -0.5347651243209839, -0.11196444928646088, 0.3773312568664551, 0.3094421327114105, 0.3697591722011566, -0.055150024592876434, -0.3033573627471924, -0.012985650449991226, 0.9579336047172546, 0.670982837677002, 0.33721715211868286, 0.010222426615655422, -0.029603997245430946, 0.10109178721904755, -0.46135151386260986, -0.253450483083725, 0.3267964720726013, 0.4881247580051422, -0.28018060326576233, -0.8622743487358093, -0.29577797651290894, 0.309357225894928, 0.7374408841133118, 0.4002389907836914, -0.1438635140657425, 0.3848894536495209, 0.2558858394622803, 0.36082011461257935, -0.8568410277366638, 0.05608018860220909, 0.7705202698707581, 0.5732786655426025, 0.8306448459625244, -0.6979776620864868, 0.9511880278587341, -0.6296110153198242, 0.28816428780555725, 0.4850901663303375, -0.4501776695251465, -0.261788934469223, 0.5702735781669617, 1.2919683456420898, -0.721454381942749, -0.13456115126609802, 0.9039867520332336, 0.5694940090179443, -0.2206077128648758, -0.06261668354272842, 0.3339518904685974, 0.2481108456850052, -1.0196369886398315, -0.2667703628540039, -0.6124511361122131, 0.10178500413894653, -0.6240113377571106, -0.012855869717895985, -0.5188881754875183, 0.04136144369840622, -0.01636454463005066, -0.10149124264717102, 0.6104763150215149, 0.08262231945991516, -0.6380563378334045, 0.18228036165237427, -0.573164165019989, -0.06766914576292038, 0.9394286870956421, 0.2828536927700043, -0.3987884223461151, -0.004012741148471832, -0.08893965184688568, -0.1032281294465065, -0.5910044312477112, -0.13562487065792084, 0.4590078592300415, 1.2923616170883179, 0.6559052467346191, 0.033782992511987686, 0.5065130591392517, 0.39051759243011475, -0.35847193002700806, 0.14413891732692719, -0.29191353917121887, -0.14821064472198486, -0.41575247049331665, -0.10662959516048431, 0.012748237699270248, -0.8837264180183411, -0.24952898919582367, 0.9535359144210815, 0.001527226879261434, 0.5737125873565674, -0.08243358880281448, -0.6928403377532959, -0.2641599178314209, -0.5159746408462524, -0.3125554323196411, 0.28059250116348267, -0.3624439537525177, -0.18059436976909637, -0.46072056889533997, -0.7109371423721313, -0.4501434862613678, 0.08163990080356598, -0.24331186711788177, -0.6272377371788025, 0.33026689291000366, -0.23153534531593323, -0.013539728708565235, -0.5491849780082703, -0.31288743019104004, 0.8016330599784851, 0.14673590660095215, 0.36538034677505493, -0.3199853003025055, -0.44468075037002563, -0.11915623396635056, 0.02937929704785347, 0.40919116139411926, -0.11080300062894821, -0.23892635107040405, -0.23915615677833557, 0.06745252758264542, 0.11921750009059906, -0.1135215312242508, -0.04650348052382469, -0.8596826195716858, 0.31272533535957336, 0.06318248063325882, -0.5124940276145935, -0.026368139311671257, 0.11071045696735382, -0.4830480217933655, 0.40711140632629395, 0.4035620391368866, -0.8856114745140076, 0.4424760341644287, 0.027677126228809357, 0.9657110571861267, -0.8774811625480652, -0.08629130572080612, -0.49768730998039246, -0.5531320571899414, -0.015212585218250751, 0.18652352690696716, -0.09450601786375046, 0.1446523815393448, -0.42996659874916077, 0.1611279547214508, 0.0785849317908287, -0.1158798485994339, 0.2570582330226898, -0.22653234004974365, -0.9651259183883667, -0.8435236811637878, 0.7704604268074036, -0.2942388355731964, 0.3341808617115021, 1.0145701169967651, -0.08661515265703201, -0.3471681475639343, 0.4107280373573303, 0.002287450945004821, -0.7042279839515686, -0.7023711204528809, 0.7783520221710205, -0.6654646992683411, 0.20946460962295532, -0.7942119836807251, 0.1657743752002716, -0.8630772233009338, 0.9230069518089294, -0.07107263058423996, -0.7531483173370361, -0.00009703751129563898, 0.11600412428379059, 0.3886848986148834, -0.9955158233642578, 0.6318267583847046, 0.41392362117767334, 0.280528724193573, 0.48982104659080505, 0.24600200355052948, -0.5126278400421143, -0.48112934827804565, -1.0130763053894043, -0.8047657012939453, 1.04645836353302, -0.04837414249777794, 0.2363116443157196, -0.4811803996562958, -0.3304484188556671, -0.2934623956680298, -0.1416749358177185, 0.31523397564888, 0.34549546241760254, 0.29533010721206665, 0.46741747856140137, 0.09781074523925781, 0.357982873916626, 0.2574317157268524, 0.8588829636573792, 0.8829681873321533, -0.22289448976516724, -0.1805162876844406, 0.23188258707523346, 0.19518601894378662, -0.7616702318191528, 0.3099075257778168, 0.23012742400169373, 0.23856815695762634, -0.16680456697940826, 1.0141191482543945, -0.30971840023994446, -0.04842301458120346, -0.09021854400634766, -0.007158451713621616, 0.35603758692741394, 0.5012734532356262, 0.7856623530387878, 0.0383574552834034, 0.3808867037296295, -0.0436444953083992, 0.1691034883260727, -0.2939629852771759, 0.09271173924207687, 0.17969255149364471, -0.9860248565673828, -0.10941062867641449, 0.284855455160141, 0.23597711324691772, -0.4676359295845032, -0.7649181485176086, -0.66776043176651, -0.39485177397727966, 0.2005503624677658, -0.38549619913101196, 0.2703896462917328, -0.29104524850845337, -0.4996306002140045, -0.1525345891714096, 0.3161654472351074, 0.2840840518474579, 0.15660759806632996, 0.32024866342544556, -0.5936319828033447, -0.06393036991357803, -0.3276911675930023, 1.0843164920806885, -0.31151577830314636, -0.6391825675964355, -0.48213842511177063, -0.37063977122306824, -0.9134040474891663, -0.05655360221862793, 1.147499680519104, 0.33352333307266235, 0.6817301511764526, -0.3929598927497864, -0.3841246962547302, 0.8255349397659302, 0.936079204082489, -0.1966850310564041, -0.12306609749794006, -0.14646990597248077, -0.6854255795478821, 0.08657842129468918, -0.041593458503484726, 0.306243896484375, -0.3598310053348541, -0.10535972565412521, -0.3870279788970947, -0.27041715383529663, -0.2554384469985962, -0.8744746446609497, -0.840619683265686, -0.44071531295776367, -0.990394651889801, -0.2869364619255066, -0.45595091581344604, -0.35822659730911255, -0.06209098547697067, 0.7129892706871033, -0.2682695686817169, -0.6338514685630798, -0.5220555067062378, 0.4143070876598358, 0.8275756239891052, -0.15000639855861664, -0.04440278187394142, -0.5776698589324951, -1.3747152090072632, -0.19582173228263855, -0.7342161536216736, -0.2985087037086487, -0.07579445838928223, 0.13847367465496063, -0.46812301874160767, -0.4882156252861023, -0.7934541702270508, 0.580858051776886, -0.3202420771121979, -0.7535726428031921, 0.2965584695339203, 0.27527159452438354, -0.6056873798370361, 0.9188085794448853, 0.3021579086780548, -0.22451700270175934, 0.22703169286251068, 0.11613352596759796, 0.42633774876594543, 0.22556285560131073, -1.1245758533477783, 0.95742267370224, 0.22512352466583252, 0.0287580918520689, 0.004982072860002518, -0.20282424986362457, 0.10358576476573944, 1.3187671899795532, -1.0508570671081543, 0.13757911324501038, -0.17607495188713074, 0.8485856056213379, -0.5819336175918579, -0.05590873211622238, -0.4954240620136261, -0.30505311489105225, 0.019764618948101997, 0.9074546694755554, -0.33942654728889465, -0.8962990641593933, -0.14649273455142975, -0.1236627846956253, -0.3279803991317749, 0.33921870589256287, -0.2132900059223175, -0.49179622530937195, 0.3225657343864441, 0.38142699003219604, -0.5749401450157166, 0.33790192008018494, 0.398147851228714, -0.10433174669742584, -1.148563027381897, -0.3521829843521118, -0.3115582764148712, 0.38240528106689453, 0.2869735360145569, -0.4814165234565735, 0.3355542719364166, -0.7179431915283203, -0.6441676616668701, 0.22224870324134827, -0.19586743414402008, 0.018795611336827278, -0.6699841022491455, -0.3505939841270447, -0.7037796378135681, -0.674155056476593, 0.0373053103685379, 0.25248074531555176, -0.07586599141359329, 0.8948092460632324, -0.250181645154953, -0.2963922619819641, -0.8041556477546692, -0.10749343037605286, -0.8277283906936646, 0.489748477935791, -0.6472979784011841, 0.32921385765075684, 0.25525838136672974, -0.6162165999412537, -0.4118008315563202, 0.6756694912910461, -0.288873553276062, -0.7053638696670532, -0.7989295125007629, -0.21361646056175232, -0.7980044484138489, 0.5202749967575073, 0.29729315638542175, -0.594140887260437, 0.16024139523506165, 1.001882553100586, 0.01512228325009346, -0.5529874563217163, 0.5614972114562988, 0.6737537384033203, 0.03912273049354553, -0.37238168716430664, -0.3365733027458191, 0.9306235313415527, -0.05873594060540199, -0.7620941996574402, 0.5106393694877625, 0.05554492399096489, 0.014878125861287117, 0.27614426612854004, -0.7292635440826416, -0.9791269898414612, 0.1991729587316513, 0.6044284701347351, 0.4251825213432312, 0.19728343188762665, 0.3776063024997711, 0.2035471349954605, -0.3610072135925293, -0.37457677721977234, 0.25718188285827637, 0.23936037719249725, -0.342154324054718, 0.946496844291687, -0.6201978921890259, 0.9319653511047363, -0.29127195477485657, 0.7531238198280334, 0.037919238209724426, -0.22989334166049957, -0.3041582405567169, 0.13160927593708038, -0.36739760637283325, 0.3636215925216675, -0.6232141256332397, -0.21318861842155457, -0.3951638340950012, -0.2759290635585785, 0.18818284571170807, -0.10461616516113281, 0.28571817278862, 0.5894585251808167, 0.6551972031593323, -0.010729325003921986, 0.3914194107055664, 0.16779473423957825, 0.22349706292152405, 0.6258252263069153, 0.2974209189414978, 0.7773574590682983, 0.5349336266517639, 0.849515438079834, 0.32798290252685547, -0.48835718631744385, -0.1745428889989853, 1.0658482313156128, -0.8215942978858948, -0.08003804087638855, -0.34298810362815857, 0.027771536260843277, 0.7970141768455505, -0.4703019857406616, 0.7072704434394836, -0.4696810245513916, -0.34716156125068665, 0.9418138265609741, -0.25022274255752563, -0.1967376172542572, 0.63829505443573, -0.20780514180660248, -0.0026340698823332787, 0.19065290689468384, -0.08474867045879364, -0.7584095597267151, 0.5346635580062866, 1.1080405712127686, -0.5089898705482483, 0.41316765546798706, -0.15997087955474854, -0.13197407126426697, -0.11795166879892349, 0.6307297348976135, -0.7074297070503235, 0.5557892322540283, -0.17497771978378296, -0.08634079247713089, -0.3981861472129822, -0.13315576314926147, -0.5495333671569824, 0.6545158624649048, 0.619987428188324, -0.07207288593053818, -0.20299139618873596, -0.077387236058712, 0.8571116924285889, 0.14606982469558716, -0.5342565178871155, -0.8635795712471008, 0.14061656594276428, 0.18695738911628723, -0.8513928651809692, 0.4290289282798767, 0.4090028703212738, 0.42668646574020386, 0.21839283406734467, -0.18979512155056, -0.4087344706058502, -0.4447803199291229, -0.4092753827571869, -0.24339403212070465, -0.5712501406669617, 0.23550891876220703, 0.6924766898155212, 0.9910086393356323, -0.1772191971540451, 0.006880801171064377, 0.04580233246088028, -0.3438284993171692, 0.6005149483680725, 0.16921652853488922, 0.4411528706550598, 0.3581264317035675, -0.11659110337495804, -0.2495412826538086, 0.3276156783103943, 0.3828130066394806, -0.29713761806488037, 0.39087072014808655, 0.03814390301704407, 0.07448406517505646, 0.4034824073314667, -0.17259716987609863, -0.722885012626648, 0.6083137392997742, 0.437485009431839, -0.20989160239696503, 0.06813905388116837, -0.09188105911016464, -0.5544950366020203, 0.11878303438425064, -0.3443586230278015, 0.29563960433006287, 0.3953905999660492, -0.15383003652095795, 0.301123708486557, -0.34122705459594727, 4.249975681304932, 0.6197052001953125, 0.9987565279006958, -0.28256484866142273, 0.46365270018577576, 0.6040529012680054, 0.2445170283317566, -0.09892356395721436, 0.5107369422912598, -0.6458972692489624, -0.4123155474662781, 0.20919948816299438, -0.2731921672821045, -0.23842786252498627, -0.007148297969251871, 0.8156989812850952, -0.13473676145076752, 0.22825294733047485, -0.2983863651752472, -0.5462594032287598, -0.05166931822896004, 0.21005713939666748, -0.17194218933582306, -0.2000328153371811, 0.02478046342730522, 0.23866555094718933, -0.2274622619152069, -0.4874436855316162, -0.42189544439315796, -0.5227652788162231, -0.9081249237060547, -0.2995828688144684, 0.09887554496526718, -0.373138964176178, -0.3715956509113312, 0.35161203145980835, 0.5249960422515869, 0.5479652881622314, -0.20359180867671967, -0.27728164196014404, 0.34559446573257446, -0.6596357822418213, -0.2165764719247818, -0.565322756767273, -0.7009065747261047, 0.21677349507808685, -0.30860963463783264, 1.2577736377716064, 0.7298819422721863, -0.4046522080898285, 0.004151863977313042, 0.15084101259708405, -0.06094486266374588, 0.2789760231971741, -0.6561017632484436, 0.44091102480888367, -0.09571328014135361, -0.7164033055305481, -0.9499653577804565, -0.05572313815355301, 1.0843651294708252, 0.17847782373428345, -0.05383697524666786, -0.44567060470581055, -0.21514421701431274, 0.47621598839759827, 0.2917199730873108, 0.6128088235855103, -0.5589649081230164, 0.08033362776041031, -0.42915570735931396, -0.2562147378921509, -0.38796913623809814, 0.25921550393104553, 0.7417330145835876, 0.09483043849468231, -0.20808011293411255, 0.503926157951355, 0.01929503306746483, 0.08254332840442657, 0.3743123710155487, -0.3700675368309021, -0.6801188588142395, 0.3670194149017334, -0.29599085450172424, 0.8091281652450562, -0.21297070384025574, -0.12580899894237518, -0.25991320610046387, 0.5409273505210876, 0.6535710096359253, 1.4010586738586426, 0.3230797052383423, -0.1271953582763672, -1.1517995595932007 ]
Vortex motion and the Hall effect in type II superconductors: a time dependent Ginzburg-Landau theory approach
Vortex motion in type II superconductors is studied starting from a variant of the time dependent Ginzburg-Landau equations, in which the order parameter relaxation time is taken to be complex. Using a method due to Gor'kov and Kopnin, we derive an equation of motion for a single vortex ($B\ll H_{c2}$) in the presence of an applied transport current. The imaginary part of the relaxation time and the normal state Hall effect both break ``particle-hole symmetry,'' and produce a component of the vortex velocity parallel to the transport current, and consequently a Hall field due to the vortex motion. Various models for the relaxation time are considered, allowing for a comparison to some phenomenological models of vortex motion in superconductors, such as the Bardeen-Stephen and Nozi\`eres-Vinen models, as well as to models of vortex motion in neutral superfluids. In addition, the transport energy, Nernst effect, and thermopower are calculated for a single vortex. Vortex bending and fluctuations can also be included within this description, resulting in a Langevin equation description of the vortex motion. The Langevin equation is used to discuss the propagation of helicon waves and the diffusional motion of a vortex line. The results are discussed in light of the rather puzzling sign change of the Hall effect which has been observed in the mixed state of the high temperature superconductors.
Alan T. Dorsey
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207018
cond-mat/9207019
[ -0.25702619552612305, 0.41723310947418213, -0.20422139763832092, 0.6156417727470398, 0.1811901330947876, 0.08720783144235611, 0.1377960592508316, -0.30225449800491333, -0.44108471274375916, 1.3689426183700562, 0.46661901473999023, 0.07724311947822571, 0.39381173253059387, -0.9320725202560425, -0.3914804458618164, 0.7274765968322754, -0.23677338659763336, -0.7618027329444885, -1.0153534412384033, 0.17441175878047943, 0.11843090504407883, -0.14894163608551025, -0.6686461567878723, -0.7413728833198547, -0.4362432658672333, 0.9257709383964539, 0.5320393443107605, 0.6030387282371521, 1.2858375310897827, 0.6586508750915527, 0.8210146427154541, -0.2931777238845825, -0.15295498073101044, -0.7827297449111938, -0.3969663381576538, 0.03934567794203758, -0.2973426282405853, -0.037378162145614624, 0.18692465126514435, -0.26866012811660767, 0.7606195211410522, 0.47836387157440186, 0.19445225596427917, -0.38614147901535034, -0.238425150513649, -0.21711939573287964, -0.35087040066719055, -0.2633412778377533, -0.5226110219955444, -1.0493543148040771, -0.06974002718925476, -0.08325906842947006, 0.6952099204063416, -0.4707745909690857, -0.35849645733833313, -0.15877199172973633, 0.13510920107364655, 0.43966102600097656, -0.25267109274864197, -0.1917751431465149, 0.08820820599794388, -0.09336146712303162, 0.6149685382843018, -0.6741147041320801, 0.3552553355693817, 0.92905193567276, -0.6384541392326355, 0.8816620707511902, -0.14772410690784454, -0.8289594650268555, -0.9186745882034302, 0.07856328785419464, -0.7178319096565247, -0.14794199168682098, -1.2477363348007202, 0.0019510176498442888, -0.23740263283252716, -0.9103100895881653, -0.6500644087791443, -0.8149943351745605, -0.15900345146656036, -0.7961709499359131, -0.5513372421264648, 0.7329217791557312, 0.02034168876707554, -0.7452308535575867, -0.07825031876564026, -0.3192058503627777, 0.5167464017868042, 0.32119107246398926, 0.807503342628479, 1.0236753225326538, 0.4413401484489441, -0.5102035403251648, 0.3223387897014618, 1.0886880159378052, -0.04956376925110817, 0.43982741236686707, 0.3612379729747772, -0.08706814795732498, -0.331977903842926, 0.8749845623970032, -0.3040355145931244, 1.0252763032913208, -0.6661043167114258, 0.6944418549537659, 0.017509832978248596, -0.17393076419830322, 0.3269573152065277, -1.1959625482559204, 0.1718970239162445, -0.3564460873603821, 0.46969106793403625, 0.6305169463157654, -0.019502585753798485, -0.28280532360076904, -0.16004297137260437, -0.04187048226594925, -0.20601925253868103, -0.5537864565849304, -0.3410956561565399, -0.45650017261505127, 1.18312406539917, 0.49356886744499207, -0.824060320854187, -0.770108699798584, 0.007980026304721832, 0.3826335072517395, -0.50812828540802, 0.5309397578239441, 0.4312904179096222, -0.011224819347262383, -0.20570455491542816, 0.636479377746582, -0.75855553150177, 0.20159794390201569, -0.2629076838493347, 0.11728453636169434, 0.265185683965683, 0.4091529846191406, 0.47275927662849426, -0.2251184731721878, -0.005970180034637451, 1.1075023412704468, -0.06336385011672974, 0.6006062626838684, 0.5448286533355713, 0.33083170652389526, -0.2096087634563446, 0.3836674988269806, -0.07929001748561859, 0.08657315373420715, -0.18695461750030518, 0.31900325417518616, 0.06447067111730576, 0.2494773268699646, -0.761866569519043, 1.1323858499526978, -0.7240971922874451, -0.3957681357860565, 0.1977338343858719, -0.04374478757381439, 0.08691366016864777, 0.2911061942577362, -0.6448400020599365, -0.021200548857450485, -0.1279469132423401, -0.5119319558143616, 0.9272454977035522, -0.09137355536222458, -0.1143450066447258, 0.5489281415939331, -0.2358146756887436, 0.11587336659431458, 0.485971063375473, 0.38447847962379456, 0.510572612285614, 0.3448798656463623, -0.039345063269138336, 0.23155401647090912, 0.10951263457536697, -0.3748656213283539, 0.2665049731731415, 0.5881719589233398, -0.08733706176280975, -0.33497270941734314, -0.6045923829078674, -0.5336992740631104, 0.3780709207057953, -0.006627208087593317, -0.6524885892868042, 0.7051082849502563, -0.46666786074638367, 0.2053079754114151, -0.919223964214325, 0.866618275642395, -1.1115869283676147, 0.2881878614425659, 0.04595554620027542, -0.36446255445480347, 0.025560230016708374, 0.13160867989063263, -1.071935772895813, -0.11130264401435852, -0.9670160412788391, 0.5168092250823975, 0.6911363005638123, 0.32871773838996887, -0.6066333055496216, 0.0077965399250388145, 0.2903764247894287, 0.09129098057746887, 0.06514471024274826, -0.3542490005493164, 0.2595467269420624, -0.10989813506603241, 0.42868006229400635, 0.7206897735595703, 0.37562400102615356, 0.4323766231536865, 0.033760301768779755, 0.4948345720767975, -0.27103665471076965, 0.4817020297050476, -0.859066367149353, -0.2436194121837616, 0.05967411771416664, 0.42095857858657837, 0.3922569751739502, 0.07684369385242462, 0.14017994701862335, 0.5295931100845337, 0.13271935284137726, 0.3418024778366089, 0.6379307508468628, 0.1869467943906784, 0.15628287196159363, 0.3073379397392273, 0.6457446813583374, -0.43711209297180176, 0.42889687418937683, -0.03513088449835777, 0.49927520751953125, -0.308773398399353, -0.4321281611919403, -0.20855921506881714, -0.33827465772628784, -0.5171139240264893, -1.0626753568649292, 0.5482904314994812, -0.33496999740600586, 0.6104021668434143, 0.20291578769683838, 0.2136855572462082, -0.7334769368171692, 0.04943361133337021, -0.3128220736980438, 0.29624584317207336, -0.1556309312582016, 0.07949108630418777, 0.37918856739997864, 0.11849743127822876, -0.481886088848114, -0.2979947030544281, 0.18748457729816437, 1.1820467710494995, 0.360372930765152, -0.029326949268579483, 0.6760531067848206, -0.0872437134385109, -1.4335815906524658, -0.6043323874473572, -0.5583928823471069, 0.4370727241039276, -0.45375362038612366, 0.36081185936927795, 1.057610034942627, -0.4461202919483185, 1.2338122129440308, 0.1443566530942917, -0.002913852920755744, 0.39440077543258667, 0.2375228852033615, 0.338143527507782, 0.22136147320270538, -0.3311856687068939, -0.6263953447341919, 0.40611687302589417, -0.6769728660583496, 0.26016318798065186, -0.5648214221000671, 0.30987945199012756, 0.44117990136146545, -0.23867343366146088, 0.1417750120162964, -0.05151648074388504, -0.1668965220451355, 0.006101273000240326, 0.17189618945121765, -0.3120932877063751, -0.08729276806116104, 0.1454966515302658, 0.05518205463886261, -0.3835282027721405, -0.7774384021759033, 1.4855750799179077, 0.22119976580142975, -0.8025274872779846, 0.26489466428756714, 0.41495704650878906, -0.525515079498291, 0.0931665301322937, 0.15894529223442078, -0.05125441774725914, -0.022129306569695473, 1.2368296384811401, 0.8573334813117981, 0.0735481008887291, 0.6460946798324585, -0.30805158615112305, -0.39742058515548706, -0.30945080518722534, 0.7999307513237, -0.7774880528450012, -0.1020263135433197, 0.8107315301895142, 0.20362620055675507, -0.8513293862342834, -0.3159104883670807, -0.6645054221153259, -0.2225194275379181, -0.5832321047782898, -0.11235373467206955, 1.1985576152801514, 0.05687692388892174, -0.4490562677383423, -0.4467999339103699, -0.5494427680969238, 0.6844384074211121, 0.3333945572376251, -0.6706564426422119, -0.22965331375598907, 0.3875003159046173, -0.17101190984249115, 0.8460646867752075, 0.1656162291765213, -0.1251094490289688, -1.0073240995407104, -0.2606101632118225, 0.4603070914745331, -0.8467398285865784, 0.30620744824409485, -0.13996630907058716, -0.7808958292007446, 0.1574712097644806, 0.213055819272995, -0.5240452289581299, -0.4716311991214752, -0.9192025661468506, 0.43907710909843445, 0.4771568179130554, 0.6104739308357239, -0.24467156827449799, 0.21474984288215637, -0.8838420510292053, -0.33079999685287476, -0.23370984196662903, 0.20909588038921356, 0.859965443611145, -0.2201777547597885, 0.48926177620887756, 0.09128479659557343, -0.06290508806705475, 0.5762056112289429, -0.6365298628807068, 0.47654446959495544, -0.006874818354845047, -0.1092686802148819, 0.5881497859954834, -0.3570069670677185, -0.6694054007530212, -0.8080446720123291, 1.5415351390838623, 0.41268190741539, 0.8592151999473572, 0.4228142499923706, -0.22048577666282654, 0.2610682547092438, -0.1889750063419342, 0.00810016505420208, -0.002751436084508896, -0.12055375427007675, -0.16082488000392914, -0.40097421407699585, 0.10878810286521912, 0.6268228888511658, 0.4212210774421692, 0.17582967877388, 0.026423946022987366, -0.07538517564535141, 1.0057215690612793, 1.365422248840332, 0.8557429909706116, 0.28133249282836914, -0.6520341634750366, -0.42204248905181885, -0.5861099362373352, 0.04519258812069893, 0.33021554350852966, 0.3331778943538666, -0.8328943848609924, -0.3192667067050934, -0.6127151250839233, 0.05942469835281372, 0.6565538048744202, 0.2724878489971161, -0.4372529685497284, 0.10207855701446533, 0.365744948387146, 0.3431210517883301, -0.3698110282421112, 0.24934443831443787, 0.8351562023162842, 0.29529523849487305, 0.9371380805969238, -0.43216851353645325, 0.48176226019859314, -0.0851672813296318, 0.2113284021615982, 0.7951725721359253, -0.7656604051589966, -1.123362421989441, -0.1749880164861679, -0.09572739154100418, -1.0955315828323364, 0.0274878591299057, 0.5540407299995422, 0.3212410807609558, 0.2552146315574646, -0.431113064289093, 0.12537632882595062, 0.48975440859794617, -0.4336724877357483, -0.2018900215625763, -0.05986829102039337, -0.14735907316207886, -0.1736404448747635, 0.7715359926223755, 0.11415991932153702, -0.5445318222045898, -0.08453457057476044, -0.40290722250938416, 0.311335027217865, -0.006919137667864561, -0.48786258697509766, -0.0028677107766270638, -0.3931752145290375, -0.1496770828962326, 1.0947048664093018, -0.23776906728744507, -0.5085116624832153, 0.41349273920059204, 0.46967440843582153, -0.07056290656328201, 0.11469350755214691, 0.586556077003479, -0.028081079944968224, 0.8343510627746582, 0.327128142118454, 0.1876237988471985, -0.02610219269990921, 0.05746244266629219, 0.023717140778899193, -0.5829105973243713, 0.002840900095179677, -0.0033709148410707712, 0.15397852659225464, -0.904591977596283, -0.09569457918405533, -0.45284131169319153, -0.7441105842590332, 0.3187452554702759, -0.41847696900367737, 0.5157583355903625, 0.5123345851898193, -0.639556348323822, 0.03299446403980255, -0.874572217464447, -1.157041311264038, 0.7834445834159851, 0.059763506054878235, -0.03848658502101898, 0.6032294631004333, -0.5417805314064026, 0.20446138083934784, -0.3172263205051422, -0.2362755686044693, -0.2018190324306488, 0.5250787734985352, 0.4592144191265106, 0.010481076315045357, 0.3438464105129242, -0.25516441464424133, 0.5665767788887024, -0.46430107951164246, 0.9250536561012268, -0.2965864837169647, -0.6117110252380371, -0.6871650218963623, -0.30155932903289795, 0.5794781446456909, -0.03498479351401329, 0.32569432258605957, -0.08857941627502441, 0.28187039494514465, 0.11515186727046967, 0.16012175381183624, -0.5542853474617004, -0.5191342830657959, 0.772843599319458, -0.24172109365463257, -0.27446484565734863, 0.10844870656728745, 1.1819862127304077, 0.14729297161102295, 0.2897054851055145, 0.15089669823646545, -0.28664514422416687, 0.05733196437358856, 0.004436707589775324, 1.051608681678772, -0.8394361734390259, -0.2706180810928345, 0.22767852246761322, -0.5874736905097961, 0.22329004108905792, 0.06324253231287003, -0.6889960765838623, -0.7123550176620483, -0.1848958283662796, -0.13319653272628784, 0.0364985354244709, 0.8339414000511169, 0.0594804622232914, -0.5510970950126648, -0.3539845049381256, 0.01395327690988779, 0.4179847836494446, 0.017523013055324554, 0.2629479765892029, 0.8249720335006714, -0.08060480654239655, -0.12356504052877426, 0.356147438287735, 0.07281189411878586, -0.4242589771747589, -0.3041079342365265, 0.5738434195518494, -0.546852171421051, 0.3489045202732086, -0.9385660290718079, 0.3638828992843628, -0.9881030321121216, 0.6797057390213013, -0.3986504077911377, -0.5276741981506348, 0.3501538038253784, 0.09091764688491821, 0.1826566457748413, -0.938671886920929, -0.35906314849853516, 0.2679271697998047, -0.01849709451198578, 0.4211743474006653, 0.6835982203483582, -0.9319025874137878, -0.4097781181335449, -1.2885535955429077, -0.6876662373542786, 0.714948832988739, 0.1740543246269226, 0.22582434117794037, -0.3993964195251465, -0.4722903370857239, 0.4757470190525055, 0.09196484088897705, 0.5971355438232422, 0.5744474530220032, -0.007197697181254625, 0.26454097032546997, 0.03840557485818863, -0.2864876389503479, -0.5660600662231445, -0.03010939434170723, -0.16940832138061523, 0.2574532926082611, 0.5230686664581299, 0.26455408334732056, -0.7145376205444336, -0.8652082085609436, 0.159387469291687, 0.35907992720603943, 0.02471327781677246, -0.29868289828300476, 0.6188158392906189, -0.09183437377214432, -0.60779869556427, -0.358061820268631, -0.478261798620224, -0.12391553819179535, 0.7187331914901733, 0.24243204295635223, 0.4290817081928253, -0.0035339260939508677, 0.003366837976500392, 0.46122103929519653, -0.2143397182226181, -0.4162943959236145, 0.3867531418800354, -0.3921303451061249, -0.10771026462316513, 0.5243361592292786, 0.22102080285549164, -0.8746146559715271, -0.4457569420337677, -0.6484931707382202, -0.08242274075746536, -0.14189407229423523, -0.31557774543762207, -0.33831048011779785, -0.40706026554107666, 0.2828701138496399, 0.28881916403770447, 0.7489379644393921, 0.6266109347343445, -0.08527778834104538, 0.27270928025245667, -0.35552576184272766, 0.11202798783779144, -0.15142039954662323, 1.4085050821304321, -0.6075774431228638, -0.3093162775039673, -0.22588452696800232, -0.3156886100769043, -0.4767557680606842, -0.27564093470573425, 0.06090933829545975, 0.048644840717315674, 0.13668061792850494, -0.05882309749722481, -0.09441316872835159, 0.765997052192688, 0.3391839861869812, -0.1969258338212967, -0.36294564604759216, 0.5312985777854919, -0.9445639252662659, 0.16319715976715088, -0.1865362524986267, 0.31886017322540283, 0.48692625761032104, -0.20037299394607544, -0.2254459112882614, 0.36581239104270935, -0.5476853251457214, -0.777228057384491, -1.7375876903533936, -0.22813628613948822, -1.2825506925582886, -0.7492800951004028, -1.4989477396011353, -0.5128734111785889, -0.24068143963813782, 0.524782121181488, -0.17661695182323456, 0.261157363653183, -0.554523229598999, -0.011362917721271515, -0.18021702766418457, -0.07884903997182846, -0.4571753144264221, -0.40468040108680725, -0.9816127419471741, -0.36352765560150146, 0.0489954948425293, -0.2947457432746887, -0.2135942131280899, -0.6208261251449585, -0.3057776987552643, -0.39647170901298523, -0.4773520529270172, 0.42038631439208984, -0.8052932024002075, -0.6149214506149292, -0.08987809717655182, -0.09104866534471512, -0.957111120223999, 0.13096466660499573, 0.521056056022644, -0.27011922001838684, 0.2829829752445221, 0.21978744864463806, 0.013839516788721085, 0.9893092513084412, -0.9393694400787354, -0.03123275749385357, -0.17353874444961548, 0.02974453568458557, -0.44219106435775757, -0.4976610541343689, 0.19480226933956146, 0.4525834023952484, -0.969496488571167, 0.16470864415168762, -0.6643893718719482, 0.8148936629295349, -0.33121171593666077, -0.1405792087316513, -0.5927055478096008, 0.2686728537082672, -0.09126158058643341, 1.396398663520813, 0.26871806383132935, -0.3873682916164398, 0.12405694276094437, -0.31626445055007935, -0.04674961045384407, 0.490907222032547, 0.16076233983039856, -0.3404015004634857, -0.020453253760933876, 0.01399530004709959, -0.39492443203926086, 0.5495530366897583, -0.6151003241539001, -0.4787715971469879, -0.5609380006790161, -0.18718189001083374, -0.5360885858535767, 0.3589594066143036, -0.14910592138767242, -0.9364107251167297, 0.09464476257562637, -0.1947822868824005, -0.6051009893417358, 0.21647684276103973, -0.29405835270881653, -0.5867717266082764, -0.5037119388580322, -0.2808411419391632, 0.24824799597263336, 0.2591871917247772, 0.17106983065605164, -0.24345168471336365, -0.048473525792360306, 0.7289900183677673, -0.6516314744949341, -0.007330265827476978, -0.06747068464756012, 0.0461079366505146, -0.3671543002128601, 0.6526187062263489, -0.9160103797912598, 0.350500226020813, -0.4984809458255768, -0.7068935036659241, 0.10497446358203888, 0.13972049951553345, -0.21278327703475952, 0.09557867050170898, 0.10302715748548508, 0.4140051305294037, 0.40108057856559753, 0.30221179127693176, -0.14280082285404205, -0.07145475596189499, -0.472861647605896, 0.6569636464118958, 0.8187353610992432, -0.15037541091442108, 0.5144124031066895, 0.3288411498069763, 0.3661801517009735, -0.1947563737630844, 0.05670228600502014, 0.776775598526001, -0.37062084674835205, -0.8382198214530945, 0.7565365433692932, 0.18251633644104004, -0.16351230442523956, 0.26119381189346313, -0.7600235342979431, -0.3819349706172943, 0.07591990381479263, 0.8049346804618835, 0.893084704875946, 0.4586731493473053, 0.646156370639801, 0.2292073667049408, 0.5366202592849731, 0.063351571559906, 0.0933852344751358, 0.7732875347137451, -0.24091410636901855, 1.0253421068191528, -0.41958796977996826, 0.2068619281053543, -0.01829051785171032, 0.7962461709976196, -0.21369501948356628, -0.2324247807264328, -0.21010388433933258, 0.009986533783376217, 0.1639316827058792, 0.48692837357521057, -0.6187124252319336, -0.5282252430915833, -0.42959898710250854, -0.2568913400173187, 0.3711787760257721, -0.6051222681999207, -0.26014193892478943, 0.7600869536399841, 0.8206078410148621, 0.29863765835762024, 0.019103510305285454, 0.9806446433067322, -0.0985037237405777, 0.4835608899593353, 0.4034459888935089, 0.641274094581604, 1.20805823802948, 0.5892300605773926, -0.3013571500778198, -0.5116813778877258, -0.2735488712787628, 0.8221222162246704, -1.256951093673706, -0.2737351357936859, -0.3822581171989441, -0.4182697534561157, 0.046833645552396774, -0.8587552309036255, 0.6173814535140991, -0.45470547676086426, 0.27907344698905945, 0.7740104794502258, 0.18713121116161346, -0.4436853229999542, 0.6611406207084656, -0.3324097692966461, 0.2872287929058075, 0.3998761773109436, -0.4897891879081726, -0.770629346370697, 0.6622380018234253, 0.7315646409988403, -0.2376878410577774, 0.9377558827400208, -0.14995519816875458, -0.7637657523155212, 0.8385432362556458, -0.019115641713142395, 0.037334736436605453, 0.4220629930496216, -0.7578156590461731, -0.18123196065425873, -0.003439638763666153, 0.38274911046028137, -0.6838532090187073, -0.2349492460489273, 0.2366647869348526, 0.10107327252626419, -0.39773499965667725, -0.06739538162946701, 1.5397018194198608, 0.08900845050811768, -0.4051767587661743, -0.5290705561637878, 0.016252590343356133, -0.03427520766854286, -0.49952951073646545, -0.3657478094100952, 0.14568646252155304, 0.49555811285972595, -0.013150844722986221, 0.16470405459403992, -1.425028681755066, -0.3890274167060852, -1.2901086807250977, -0.27914994955062866, -0.6980864405632019, 0.2650831341743469, 0.36560091376304626, 0.3859996199607849, -0.07473884522914886, -0.31249985098838806, 0.0021435192320495844, -0.057123638689517975, 1.1637307405471802, 0.020514387637376785, 0.5090372562408447, 1.022753119468689, 0.04684443026781082, -0.5654522180557251, 0.008814223110675812, 0.5254022479057312, -1.3473154306411743, 0.8630974292755127, -0.3959128260612488, 0.5543184876441956, 0.5675532221794128, -0.17756271362304688, 0.008269955404102802, -0.4812525808811188, 0.2687748372554779, -0.5171113610267639, -0.4847128093242645, -0.0005643190816044807, -1.074326515197754, 0.2067205011844635, -0.44318297505378723, -0.20853747427463531, -0.07824285328388214, 0.6601130366325378, 0.11499334871768951, -0.18501733243465424, 4.061284065246582, 0.6366373300552368, 0.5263025760650635, -0.17837481200695038, 0.5037336349487305, 1.0620958805084229, 0.2602168619632721, 0.03832980617880821, -0.009980260394513607, -0.9340129494667053, -0.3028401732444763, 0.7629261016845703, 0.21477611362934113, -0.7475232481956482, -0.23405498266220093, 0.5999245643615723, -0.17205005884170532, 0.3526743948459625, -0.39341747760772705, -1.0257610082626343, -0.5403206944465637, 0.08611279726028442, 0.9951785206794739, -0.18686474859714508, 0.3907656967639923, 0.9488024711608887, 0.06615334004163742, -0.63728266954422, -1.1096824407577515, 0.04791424423456192, -0.7259342670440674, -0.9099152684211731, 0.437964528799057, -0.48825737833976746, -1.279581904411316, 0.5352652072906494, 0.41575026512145996, -0.3806438744068146, -0.038459692150354385, 0.8636141419410706, 0.4377046525478363, 0.09223035722970963, 0.2889689803123474, -0.5108935236930847, -0.8139325380325317, 0.30398672819137573, -0.6001148819923401, 1.0312227010726929, 0.6340891122817993, -1.0347665548324585, -0.37300950288772583, -0.43707534670829773, 0.3813523054122925, -0.3510742783546448, -0.5815767645835876, 0.10192786157131195, -0.6308802366256714, -0.29043489694595337, -0.35699164867401123, 0.3683404326438904, 0.7881070971488953, 0.09458199888467789, -0.13303828239440918, -0.34428703784942627, -0.035141684114933014, 0.6253694295883179, 0.810955822467804, 0.23311175405979156, -0.11909154057502747, -0.10370975732803345, -0.48089444637298584, -0.513340950012207, -0.8232151865959167, 0.23010069131851196, 0.6952103972434998, -0.02027823217213154, -0.10273963212966919, 0.8610183596611023, 0.12612271308898926, 0.7223392724990845, 0.3180256187915802, -0.5089424848556519, -0.5249271988868713, 0.2423192411661148, -0.47337883710861206, 0.7426421642303467, -0.38779139518737793, -0.4874906539916992, -0.23548057675361633, 0.8775268197059631, 0.47001713514328003, 1.590537667274475, -0.4239584803581238, -0.6520083546638489, -0.7596710920333862 ]
Duality in Multi-layered Quantum Hall Systems
The braid group dynamics captures the fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) as a manifestation of puncture phase. When the dynamics is generalized for particles on a multi-sheeted surface, we obtain new tools which determine the fractional charges, the quantum statistics, and the filling factors of the multi-layered FQHE. A many-quasi-hole wavefunction is proposed for the bilayered samples. We also predict a $\nu = 5/7$ FQHE for triple-layered samples. The viability of {\em 3-dimensional} FQHE and the application of the concept of generalized duality to anyonic superconductivity are discussed.
C. Ting
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207019
cond-mat/9207020
[ -0.010676674544811249, 0.22111965715885162, 0.3630833625793457, 0.28996315598487854, 0.7742419242858887, -0.129800483584404, 0.22748126089572906, -0.2927502393722534, -0.5896559357643127, 1.5598715543746948, 0.47722628712654114, 0.12577901780605316, 0.05246103182435036, -0.8120270371437073, -0.4978693127632141, 0.5338531136512756, -0.18323005735874176, -0.871275782585144, -0.9816368818283081, 0.1843358427286148, 0.040177300572395325, -0.11681697517633438, -0.6337390542030334, -0.2976822555065155, -0.5162220597267151, 0.9549490213394165, 0.9566249847412109, 0.7789823412895203, 1.0572396516799927, 0.5655585527420044, 0.9765867590904236, -0.1435393989086151, -0.013447703793644905, -1.2650983333587646, -0.022433485835790634, 0.08351636677980423, 0.012946291826665401, -0.7851330041885376, 0.11749423295259476, -0.567836582660675, 0.9257125854492188, 0.23531170189380646, 0.3748311698436737, -0.5641021132469177, -0.5777220726013184, -0.04739931598305702, -0.2311408370733261, -0.08436234295368195, -0.018929384648799896, -1.221846580505371, -0.11551133543252945, -0.33382320404052734, 0.46285077929496765, -0.4839484989643097, 0.03425680100917816, -0.2888612151145935, 0.07486169785261154, 0.2698492705821991, -0.3272826373577118, 0.026920173317193985, 0.18959364295005798, -0.2891879975795746, 0.7424520254135132, -1.3084708452224731, 0.392594575881958, 1.0938653945922852, -0.46780848503112793, 0.8983335494995117, -0.18177488446235657, -0.8117077350616455, -0.19931109249591827, -0.2836286127567291, -0.8063051104545593, -0.003059682436287403, -1.097087025642395, 0.4568447470664978, -0.17683184146881104, -0.7170529961585999, -0.6377328634262085, -0.5452837944030762, 0.3119669258594513, -0.5296890735626221, -0.37692269682884216, 0.6763700842857361, -0.4194468557834625, -0.4857827425003052, 0.12591974437236786, -0.1510223150253296, 0.4275260865688324, 0.1220080628991127, 0.7529448866844177, 0.8649062514305115, 0.451610803604126, -0.5326484441757202, 0.5344122648239136, 0.9673995971679688, -0.03063175082206726, 0.5023393630981445, 0.13460125029087067, 0.5050053596496582, 0.33365482091903687, 0.8062249422073364, -0.2511313259601593, 1.0508135557174683, -0.8678711652755737, 0.6535585522651672, 0.18815094232559204, 0.22342826426029205, 0.18575502932071686, -0.7784332633018494, 0.2495083212852478, -0.2685217559337616, 0.8095293045043945, 0.4589300751686096, 0.23717699944972992, -0.1887097954750061, 0.2797774374485016, -0.020827721804380417, -0.8715546727180481, -0.3578328788280487, -0.411996454000473, -0.2771069407463074, 1.3077555894851685, 0.4734216332435608, -1.1077162027359009, -0.6915361881256104, 0.3094882369041443, 0.2958012521266937, -0.4067333936691284, 0.4427778422832489, 0.743927001953125, -0.10485363751649857, -0.34870290756225586, 0.5109133124351501, -0.7765302062034607, -0.10739190876483917, -0.01577889733016491, 0.5349075198173523, 0.44829511642456055, -0.34386661648750305, 0.4745461940765381, -0.013293339870870113, 0.16849727928638458, 1.0883386135101318, 0.24975897371768951, 0.5256765484809875, 0.7576730847358704, 0.09615286439657211, -0.6599133610725403, 0.027772249653935432, -0.14030557870864868, 0.32576361298561096, -0.26630744338035583, 0.40531831979751587, -0.10744860023260117, 0.3265337646007538, -0.7903013229370117, 0.8150380253791809, -0.6053487062454224, -0.36311087012290955, -0.15945909917354584, -0.276155948638916, 0.17722487449645996, 0.1723441630601883, -0.30891555547714233, 0.3752095699310303, -0.5380712747573853, -0.6590741276741028, 0.5107294917106628, -0.19572465121746063, -0.20111747086048126, -0.14066524803638458, -0.37514594197273254, 0.3869084417819977, 0.7069085240364075, 0.17233462631702423, 0.4316026270389557, 0.354766309261322, -0.1046038344502449, 0.6814600825309753, 0.07544732838869095, -0.42181986570358276, 0.4023928642272949, 0.5829445719718933, -0.26355281472206116, -0.8638795614242554, -0.7153065204620361, -0.7373289465904236, -0.007512508425861597, -0.10921231657266617, -0.38397324085235596, 0.8033248782157898, -0.889479398727417, 0.8210453391075134, -0.7367877960205078, 0.49801772832870483, -0.9075530767440796, 0.34739670157432556, -0.14575143158435822, -0.08915553987026215, -0.2858615815639496, 0.30509087443351746, -1.3131844997406006, -0.08613023906946182, -1.0152568817138672, 0.4642121195793152, 0.6976975798606873, 0.35275790095329285, -0.9666624665260315, 0.024137703701853752, 0.42415738105773926, -0.3296695649623871, 0.00924781896173954, -0.21471965312957764, 0.45174333453178406, -0.06204424798488617, 0.07592561841011047, 0.5930676460266113, -0.1294480264186859, 0.31937772035598755, 0.22991633415222168, 0.7307416200637817, -0.029538096860051155, 0.646055281162262, -0.7609395980834961, -0.29206275939941406, 0.0761309564113617, 0.7371200323104858, 0.333965003490448, 0.385212242603302, 0.2357153445482254, 0.8246791362762451, 0.30805301666259766, 0.03613667190074921, 0.7534769773483276, 0.14661692082881927, 0.2019238919019699, 0.3976151645183563, 0.7130156755447388, -0.3886035680770874, 0.13954788446426392, -0.004472657572478056, 0.39575231075286865, -0.2879006862640381, 0.023591356351971626, 0.31211793422698975, -0.3733949661254883, -0.17851793766021729, -0.8544583916664124, 0.43571099638938904, 0.26208245754241943, 0.7452345490455627, 0.42483392357826233, -0.015175794251263142, -0.7024006843566895, -0.20383897423744202, -0.2590773403644562, 0.34881284832954407, -0.2421063780784607, -0.016128644347190857, 0.029636647552251816, 0.15732476115226746, -0.6172178983688354, -0.36535364389419556, -0.2604321837425232, 0.6435558795928955, 0.4770841896533966, -0.26748138666152954, 0.40116769075393677, -0.14290247857570648, -1.5419918298721313, -0.3422759473323822, -1.0521928071975708, 0.17835570871829987, -0.5050325393676758, 0.09030044823884964, 0.9042667150497437, -0.5168769955635071, 1.3424869775772095, 0.3589300215244293, -0.4703795611858368, 0.33363765478134155, -0.012656347826123238, 0.33627909421920776, 0.099449522793293, -0.7658606767654419, -0.6602295637130737, 0.26260700821876526, -0.48930710554122925, 0.37411558628082275, -0.36002716422080994, 0.13532742857933044, 0.07533878087997437, -0.34551283717155457, 0.12186659872531891, -0.4954356849193573, 0.032384034246206284, 0.07749909907579422, -0.0323244072496891, -0.6516769528388977, -0.4005562365055084, 0.149673193693161, 0.11752206087112427, -0.3927338421344757, -0.7208538055419922, 1.0267070531845093, 0.18364208936691284, -0.507934033870697, 0.4644312262535095, 0.4753033518791199, -0.5966820120811462, 0.18445150554180145, 0.4203440845012665, 0.013654899783432484, -0.3995157778263092, 1.064414620399475, 0.6528846621513367, -0.090626560151577, 0.634146511554718, -0.21046355366706848, -0.39099448919296265, -0.4222787618637085, 0.696560263633728, -1.0976779460906982, -0.1602872908115387, 1.0479176044464111, 0.3963784873485565, -0.9835352301597595, 0.004341743886470795, -0.8020155429840088, -0.5333625078201294, -0.4365823566913605, -0.46761104464530945, 0.8141129612922668, -0.03063865378499031, -0.307955265045166, -0.36234304308891296, -0.49833473563194275, 0.869820237159729, 0.4807760417461395, -0.2076362669467926, -0.4917018413543701, 0.43624821305274963, -0.1146220862865448, 0.38546323776245117, -0.24125656485557556, 0.4137338399887085, -0.6781210899353027, -0.25741255283355713, 0.329619824886322, -0.5119810104370117, 0.30645573139190674, 0.1947460174560547, -0.13250461220741272, -0.3415905833244324, 0.9290534853935242, -0.2550560534000397, -0.1980329155921936, -0.9869810938835144, -0.15118083357810974, 0.21064187586307526, 0.64306640625, -0.27090534567832947, 0.2433837205171585, -0.762412965297699, -0.6076744794845581, -0.23520848155021667, -0.057166531682014465, 1.1711325645446777, -0.39940476417541504, 0.5663424730300903, -0.031159687787294388, 0.01268315501511097, 0.7252543568611145, -0.7350051999092102, 0.36547309160232544, 0.26372238993644714, 0.17005795240402222, 0.7481526732444763, -0.4719431698322296, -0.7954975962638855, -0.4683206379413605, 0.9069672226905823, 0.4226647615432739, 0.7295829653739929, 0.21915848553180695, -0.4014865458011627, 0.16304714977741241, -0.15941692888736725, -0.11072197556495667, -0.23087680339813232, -0.26888999342918396, -0.6432129144668579, -0.266263872385025, -0.0718500092625618, 0.35682886838912964, 0.4172295331954956, 0.09377012401819229, -0.23846447467803955, 0.13299858570098877, 1.2859350442886353, 1.1946566104888916, 0.6935761570930481, 0.34203097224235535, -0.9081329107284546, -0.5296175479888916, -0.43857136368751526, 0.4151180684566498, 0.2719789147377014, -0.4826374053955078, -0.6537111401557922, -0.11843008548021317, -0.18259048461914062, -0.34173834323883057, 0.7723966240882874, 0.5761657357215881, -0.5940553545951843, 0.1989307403564453, -0.14851278066635132, 0.3081039786338806, -0.09874080866575241, 0.05433603376150131, 0.7657012343406677, 0.49975669384002686, 1.0826436281204224, -0.7414786219596863, 0.45131126046180725, 0.4162139594554901, 0.12485389411449432, 1.0105094909667969, -0.6756752729415894, -1.256736397743225, -0.5609384179115295, 0.23977234959602356, -0.6748611927032471, -0.18390429019927979, 0.7430659532546997, 0.394854336977005, 0.6035323739051819, -0.712480902671814, 0.10425346344709396, 0.20059801638126373, -0.47052276134490967, -0.07018684595823288, -0.16031800210475922, 0.3734016716480255, -0.2602517604827881, 1.3351298570632935, -0.0005486929439939559, -0.6707754135131836, 0.18473650515079498, -0.299811452627182, -0.012606505304574966, 0.36273476481437683, -0.3051331043243408, 0.514601469039917, -0.04390668123960495, -0.09932359308004379, 1.0297937393188477, -0.4729510545730591, -0.5037489533424377, 0.22508950531482697, 0.5368436574935913, -0.4469638168811798, 0.03636198490858078, 0.7056987285614014, -0.13919733464717865, 0.6267910003662109, 0.5751184225082397, 0.4058946967124939, 0.05690323933959007, 0.03548523038625717, 0.07258916646242142, -0.4123770296573639, 0.37289318442344666, 0.0570073202252388, 0.07602929323911667, -1.2382625341415405, -0.08853697031736374, -0.21396693587303162, -0.7962895035743713, 0.30767980217933655, -0.11410515010356903, 0.844292938709259, 0.16871938109397888, -0.4657718241214752, -0.15355592966079712, -0.48095428943634033, -0.9717504382133484, 0.5636627078056335, -0.199172705411911, -0.10861022770404816, 0.14536680281162262, -0.6281773447990417, 0.36617812514305115, -0.04452379047870636, -0.05603591352701187, -0.23564881086349487, -0.11395982652902603, 0.06954784691333771, 0.06254777312278748, 0.5789478421211243, -0.07199520617723465, 0.7931238412857056, -0.09566305577754974, 0.7687987685203552, -0.8198197484016418, -0.3653087913990021, -0.6868963837623596, -0.7010366916656494, 0.3951515853404999, -0.5398428440093994, 0.5777430534362793, -0.14436104893684387, 0.5462837815284729, 0.2966698706150055, -0.041717346757650375, -0.6882244944572449, -0.6715012788772583, 0.639277458190918, -0.40597888827323914, -0.4144899249076843, -0.20249676704406738, 0.9161708354949951, -0.010077141225337982, -0.14868183434009552, 0.19898606836795807, -0.403158038854599, 0.19460414350032806, -0.09758391976356506, 0.940924346446991, -0.5507274866104126, -0.051288921386003494, -0.31304168701171875, 0.16406035423278809, -0.13882359862327576, 0.6932892799377441, -0.5450229644775391, -0.7961604595184326, -0.15965043008327484, -0.33321863412857056, 0.1964164674282074, 0.8254675269126892, -0.24630557000637054, -0.7270445227622986, 0.12327908724546432, -0.20064294338226318, 0.28005680441856384, -0.18448707461357117, 0.15030767023563385, 0.39419257640838623, -0.0316757895052433, 0.27636459469795227, 0.6290968060493469, 0.07682507485151291, -0.357779860496521, -0.3053121268749237, 0.6764288544654846, -0.13959141075611115, 0.4673059582710266, -0.64154052734375, 0.6169472932815552, -1.102889895439148, 0.7923658490180969, -0.8013889193534851, -0.3155357539653778, 0.11270221322774887, 0.4562399983406067, 1.0844963788986206, -1.0051791667938232, -0.36368709802627563, 0.12542743980884552, 0.342641144990921, 0.13672533631324768, 0.27791205048561096, -0.9607419967651367, -0.8430402874946594, -1.4080712795257568, -0.5584642291069031, 0.6880886554718018, 0.20050951838493347, 0.26207461953163147, -0.3234111964702606, -0.25919508934020996, 1.058432936668396, -0.17908254265785217, 0.8093109130859375, 0.5998770594596863, 0.06884182244539261, 0.23555658757686615, 0.04093005880713463, -0.6426244974136353, -0.3197318911552429, -0.2962428629398346, 0.22171621024608612, 0.08144262433052063, 0.22024643421173096, 0.02061505615711212, -1.0430494546890259, -1.1418622732162476, -0.3606322407722473, 0.10768716782331467, 0.09491018950939178, -0.18122728168964386, 0.4778207242488861, -0.02633988857269287, -0.3835389316082001, -0.30837440490722656, -0.08391711115837097, -0.26895081996917725, 0.10970313847064972, 0.45063188672065735, 0.507438063621521, 0.08033790439367294, 0.0009649430285207927, 0.3310719132423401, -0.6582053303718567, -0.8166924715042114, 0.5708823800086975, 0.09901082515716553, 0.10586061328649521, 0.5223055481910706, 0.484022319316864, -1.0980685949325562, -0.2656573951244354, -0.702436089515686, -0.17126914858818054, -0.19714942574501038, -0.6920944452285767, -0.5952962636947632, 0.016160262748599052, 0.022432977333664894, 0.24438516795635223, 0.6061790585517883, 0.2541198134422302, 0.24598614871501923, 0.4774743318557739, -0.11975884437561035, -0.02106473408639431, 0.3478833734989166, 1.48057222366333, -0.3046795725822449, -0.3672298192977905, -0.27607592940330505, -0.45509395003318787, -0.769453763961792, 0.025521716102957726, 0.17178577184677124, -0.12075966596603394, -0.009608413092792034, 0.2653844356536865, 0.050423938781023026, 0.4316982328891754, 0.5982793569564819, -0.03770060837268829, -0.6118004322052002, 0.30816471576690674, -0.804417610168457, -0.2545858323574066, 0.20019006729125977, -0.12447299063205719, 0.435962051153183, -0.044394779950380325, -0.22173745930194855, 0.05096353963017464, -0.31198355555534363, -0.42432671785354614, -1.6629501581192017, -0.2929569184780121, -1.158484935760498, -0.8075551390647888, -1.5563194751739502, -0.30977097153663635, -0.13167959451675415, 0.46945029497146606, -0.19913654029369354, 0.3137650191783905, -0.5570060610771179, 0.082102470099926, -0.06623772531747818, 0.31863489747047424, -0.40022581815719604, -0.345615029335022, -0.7369319200515747, -0.06524363905191422, -0.1202625259757042, -0.3346816301345825, -0.14092965424060822, -0.26323479413986206, 0.0731082335114479, -0.44332846999168396, -0.453215628862381, 0.21420542895793915, -0.7569742798805237, -0.4772747755050659, 0.22322827577590942, -0.6315879821777344, -1.39078688621521, 0.20008118450641632, 0.3441098630428314, 0.0937531515955925, -0.34568795561790466, 0.13733087480068207, -0.19526736438274384, 0.5273340344429016, -1.0093215703964233, -0.15932290256023407, -0.5804896354675293, 0.015081420540809631, -0.19087836146354675, -0.23898611962795258, -0.19564040005207062, 0.3273494243621826, -1.1039718389511108, 0.3192608952522278, -0.1444506198167801, 0.22660377621650696, -0.22022759914398193, -0.16209858655929565, -0.1205279752612114, 0.2086448073387146, -0.3633948862552643, 1.0963681936264038, 0.026728691533207893, -0.3342297375202179, 0.1180117130279541, -0.4379722774028778, -0.5222882628440857, 0.3734826147556305, 0.621643602848053, -0.9141376614570618, -0.18897119164466858, 0.37850630283355713, -0.35175758600234985, 0.5646597146987915, -0.6821697354316711, -0.43462875485420227, -0.665618360042572, -0.0583120621740818, -0.5651916861534119, 0.6924179196357727, 0.099039725959301, -0.5629071593284607, -0.18697282671928406, -0.43425655364990234, -0.6177706718444824, 0.2486281394958496, -0.4858117997646332, 0.08034362643957138, -0.2699429988861084, 0.10501208901405334, -0.0734778642654419, 0.028690960258245468, -0.2335188090801239, 0.06364715099334717, 0.18455524742603302, 0.2524960935115814, -0.9199711680412292, 0.2121216058731079, -0.2386913001537323, 0.084480881690979, -0.5168392062187195, 0.4822618067264557, -0.9739870429039001, 0.7377572059631348, -0.21909719705581665, -0.7212968468666077, 0.190482497215271, 0.3781670033931732, -0.1470804363489151, -0.11571814119815826, 0.3467780351638794, 0.33498913049697876, 0.17252275347709656, -0.17494530975818634, 0.15593238174915314, -0.17524203658103943, -0.4004332721233368, 0.5003858804702759, 0.6607829928398132, -0.37786638736724854, 0.184224471449852, 0.26278722286224365, 0.2639658451080322, -0.5186076164245605, 0.30107805132865906, 0.8917108178138733, -0.22509345412254333, -0.7207909822463989, 0.13757583498954773, -0.10508202761411667, 0.0766737088561058, 0.42104390263557434, -0.6830477714538574, -0.4024590849876404, 0.15604574978351593, 0.8686680197715759, 0.8992152810096741, 0.017137868329882622, 0.5468336939811707, 0.5290483832359314, 0.5516273379325867, -0.0004515980544965714, 0.42914700508117676, 0.3456507921218872, -0.20386084914207458, 0.8733536601066589, -0.48145920038223267, 0.5400377511978149, 0.07023236155509949, 0.5113027095794678, -0.2530299127101898, 0.06412053108215332, -0.5461007952690125, -0.08975762873888016, 0.03690778464078903, 0.5157378911972046, -0.5273223519325256, -0.4620453417301178, -0.23100942373275757, 0.22650659084320068, 0.49093058705329895, -0.029325097799301147, -0.0016928898403421044, 0.518251895904541, 1.1842319965362549, 0.07293938100337982, 0.2249756008386612, 0.8488226532936096, 0.055010613054037094, 0.2618691325187683, 0.02430104650557041, 0.6178917288780212, 1.398960828781128, 0.616931676864624, -0.3430533707141876, -0.8570691347122192, -0.2963412404060364, 0.7520049214363098, -1.0923856496810913, -0.04555130749940872, -0.04669725522398949, -0.6371431946754456, -0.016979428008198738, -1.1353638172149658, 0.18186762928962708, -0.7032923698425293, 0.30278244614601135, 0.7683476805686951, 0.1972658932209015, -0.11006945371627808, 0.8124514818191528, -0.17917591333389282, 0.6111820340156555, 0.49387848377227783, -0.47534069418907166, -0.28462210297584534, 0.7985577583312988, 1.2143633365631104, 0.027471911162137985, 0.6449795365333557, -0.02635808102786541, -0.3147602081298828, 0.5488254427909851, -0.12502983212471008, -0.22935782372951508, 0.5574340224266052, -0.40824002027511597, 0.020586276426911354, -0.11086297035217285, 0.1907440423965454, -0.5854456424713135, -0.06671597063541412, 0.5314686298370361, 0.3253133296966553, -0.4591425359249115, 0.03424055129289627, 1.7863881587982178, 0.22700507938861847, -0.6837247014045715, -0.6680666208267212, -0.3798198699951172, -0.41740185022354126, -0.6324604153633118, -0.4376962184906006, 0.07853761315345764, 0.4896479845046997, -0.023472854867577553, -0.08861291408538818, -1.3808526992797852, -0.2119087427854538, -0.9219928979873657, -0.0369274839758873, -1.0659948587417603, 0.42597609758377075, 0.34760749340057373, 0.8973569273948669, 0.23345710337162018, -0.9190374612808228, -0.18637801706790924, 0.09193365275859833, 0.9794823527336121, -0.23481017351150513, 0.5885726809501648, 1.0870561599731445, 0.3266441524028778, -0.8055391311645508, 0.6300879716873169, 0.22442877292633057, -0.7585557103157043, 1.2838244438171387, -0.7134444713592529, 0.150712788105011, 0.525961697101593, -0.2282031625509262, 0.0736728087067604, -0.1755569726228714, 0.8321647047996521, -0.14500686526298523, -0.2785671055316925, -0.036245331168174744, -1.0168734788894653, 0.31744396686553955, -0.940780758857727, 0.17730391025543213, 0.3243909478187561, 0.726659893989563, -0.072417251765728, -0.08824849873781204, 3.9966399669647217, 0.6077637672424316, 0.6303574442863464, -0.20571450889110565, 0.8096650838851929, 1.2122290134429932, 0.04663883522152901, 0.13169074058532715, 0.12001214176416397, -0.4452851414680481, -0.5841225385665894, 1.2681429386138916, 0.29844585061073303, -0.38464248180389404, -0.12097486108541489, 0.04146569222211838, -0.4985755980014801, 0.4831150770187378, -0.5414832830429077, -0.9287862181663513, -0.6898314952850342, -0.00791036244481802, 0.8230652213096619, -0.4951039254665375, 0.7119232416152954, 0.3877948522567749, 0.0714397132396698, -0.8430837392807007, -0.6427939534187317, -0.012527844868600368, -0.5935623049736023, -0.9333704113960266, 0.34504687786102295, -0.9308558106422424, -1.118077039718628, 0.31364020705223083, 0.15094615519046783, -0.16781163215637207, 0.28040456771850586, 0.46713632345199585, -0.007157802581787109, 0.09878706187009811, 0.44904327392578125, -0.5549291968345642, -0.58433997631073, 0.4168626070022583, -0.7639142870903015, 0.9725347757339478, 0.1147371158003807, -1.0796030759811401, 0.19396065175533295, -0.39088916778564453, 0.23880378901958466, -0.5851690173149109, -1.1063212156295776, 0.182979017496109, -0.67029869556427, -0.3596140146255493, -0.4316723346710205, 0.37048324942588806, 0.4865993559360504, 0.1706944704055786, 0.03343791514635086, -0.07627606391906738, 0.32085883617401123, 0.7193546295166016, 0.4364134967327118, 0.23696254193782806, -0.01401210855692625, 0.35227933526039124, -0.11965739727020264, 0.041684091091156006, -0.4764595031738281, 0.04857881739735603, 0.5705128312110901, -0.34641730785369873, -0.2706208825111389, 1.1153525114059448, 0.45786142349243164, 0.7333247661590576, -0.10109921544790268, -0.27713945508003235, 0.17413607239723206, 0.11603041738271713, -0.3705946207046509, 0.7060838341712952, -0.6339934468269348, -0.9294353723526001, -0.21770943701267242, 0.5289801359176636, 0.40654557943344116, 1.2736396789550781, -0.321015328168869, -0.31464385986328125, -1.1525126695632935 ]
Mutual statistics, braid group, and the fractional quantum Hall effect
We show that the notion of mutual statistics arises naturally from the representation theory of the braid group over the multi-sheeted surface. A Hamiltonian which describes particles moving on the double-sheeted surface is proposed as a model for the bilayered fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) discovered recently. We explicitly show that the quasi-holes of the bilayered Hall fluid display fractional mutual statistics. A model for 3-dimensional FQHE using the multi-layered sample is suggested.
C. Ting
cond-mat
July
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9207020