Dataset Preview
The full dataset viewer is not available (click to read why). Only showing a preview of the rows.
The dataset generation failed
Error code:   DatasetGenerationError
Exception:    TypeError
Message:      Couldn't cast array of type
struct<bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_1: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_2: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_3: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_4: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_5: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_6: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_7: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_8: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_no_9: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_no_10: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, question
...
ring>, statements: list<item: string>>, salad_hierarchy_1211: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1212: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1213: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1214: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1215: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1216: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1217: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1218: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1219: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_hierarchy_1220: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>>
to
{'expected_answer': Value('string'), 'questions': List(Value('string')), 'source': Value('string'), 'statements': List(Value('string')), 'target': Value('string')}
Traceback:    Traceback (most recent call last):
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1831, in _prepare_split_single
                  writer.write_table(table)
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/arrow_writer.py", line 714, in write_table
                  pa_table = table_cast(pa_table, self._schema)
                             ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 2272, in table_cast
                  return cast_table_to_schema(table, schema)
                         ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 2224, in cast_table_to_schema
                  cast_array_to_feature(
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 1795, in wrapper
                  return pa.chunked_array([func(chunk, *args, **kwargs) for chunk in array.chunks])
                                           ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/table.py", line 2092, in cast_array_to_feature
                  raise TypeError(f"Couldn't cast array of type\n{_short_str(array.type)}\nto\n{_short_str(feature)}")
              TypeError: Couldn't cast array of type
              struct<bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_1: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_2: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_3: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_yes_4: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, target: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_5: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_6: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_7: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_inv_8: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_no_9: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, bamboo_chicken_edge_no_10: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, question
              ...
              ring>, statements: list<item: string>>, salad_hierarchy_1211: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1212: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1213: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1214: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1215: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1216: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1217: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1218: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_edge_no_1219: struct<source: string, target: string, expected_answer: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>, Paella_hierarchy_1220: struct<expected_answer: string, source: string, questions: list<item: string>, statements: list<item: string>>>
              to
              {'expected_answer': Value('string'), 'questions': List(Value('string')), 'source': Value('string'), 'statements': List(Value('string')), 'target': Value('string')}
              
              The above exception was the direct cause of the following exception:
              
              Traceback (most recent call last):
                File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/config/parquet_and_info.py", line 1455, in compute_config_parquet_and_info_response
                  parquet_operations = convert_to_parquet(builder)
                                       ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "/src/services/worker/src/worker/job_runners/config/parquet_and_info.py", line 1054, in convert_to_parquet
                  builder.download_and_prepare(
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 894, in download_and_prepare
                  self._download_and_prepare(
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 970, in _download_and_prepare
                  self._prepare_split(split_generator, **prepare_split_kwargs)
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1702, in _prepare_split
                  for job_id, done, content in self._prepare_split_single(
                                               ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
                File "/usr/local/lib/python3.12/site-packages/datasets/builder.py", line 1858, in _prepare_split_single
                  raise DatasetGenerationError("An error occurred while generating the dataset") from e
              datasets.exceptions.DatasetGenerationError: An error occurred while generating the dataset

Need help to make the dataset viewer work? Make sure to review how to configure the dataset viewer, and open a discussion for direct support.

domain
string
version
string
question_clusters
dict
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'algebra' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'algebra' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'algebra' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'algebra' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'algebra'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'algebra' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'algebra' " ], "target": "algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'area of mathematics'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' " ], "target": "area of mathematics" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'boolean algebra'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'boolean algebra' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' " ], "target": "boolean algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ", "'algebra' is not necessarily a type of 'boolean algebra'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is necessarily a kind of 'boolean algebra' ", "'algebra' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' " ], "target": "boolean algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'boolean algebra' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'boolean algebra' ", "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a type of 'boolean algebra'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is necessarily a kind of 'boolean algebra' ", "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'boolean algebra' " ], "target": "boolean algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'illyrology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'illyrology' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'illyrology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'illyrology' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'illyrology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'illyrology'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'illyrology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'illyrology' " ], "target": "illyrology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'implantology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'implantology' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'implantology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'implantology' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'implantology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'implantology'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'implantology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'implantology' " ], "target": "implantology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'interdisciplinarity' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'interdisciplinarity' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'interdisciplinarity' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'interdisciplinarity' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'interdisciplinarity' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'interdisciplinarity'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'interdisciplinarity' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'interdisciplinarity' " ], "target": "interdisciplinarity" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'textile design' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'textile design' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'textile design' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'textile design' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'textile design' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'textile design'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'textile design' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'textile design' " ], "target": "textile design" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'theology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'theology' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'theology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'theology' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'theology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'theology'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'theology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'theology' " ], "target": "theology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'transportation planning' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'transportation planning' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'transportation planning' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'transportation planning' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'transportation planning' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'transportation planning'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'transportation planning' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'transportation planning' " ], "target": "transportation planning" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'victory title' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'victory title' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'victory title' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'victory title' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'victory title' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'victory title'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'victory title' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'victory title' " ], "target": "victory title" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'video game bundle' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'video game bundle' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'video game bundle' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'video game bundle' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'video game bundle' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'video game bundle'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'video game bundle' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'video game bundle' " ], "target": "video game bundle" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'viticulture' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'viticulture' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'viticulture' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'viticulture' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'viticulture' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'viticulture'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'viticulture' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'viticulture' " ], "target": "viticulture" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'volunteer computing' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'volunteer computing' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'volunteer computing' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'volunteer computing' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'volunteer computing' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'volunteer computing'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'volunteer computing' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'volunteer computing' " ], "target": "volunteer computing" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'ichnology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'ichnology' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'ichnology' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'ichnology' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is not a subconcept of 'ichnology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a type of 'ichnology'", "not every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'ichnology' ", "'boolean algebra' is not a subcategory of 'ichnology' " ], "target": "ichnology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'algebra' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'algebra' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'algebra' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'boolean algebra' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'boolean algebra' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "boolean algebra", "statements": [ "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'algebra' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'algebra'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'algebra' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'algebra' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'area of mathematics'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'boolean algebra' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'boolean algebra' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'boolean algebra' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy' " ], "target": "humanities and social sciences curriculum and pedagogy" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'humanities and tourism' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'humanities and tourism' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'humanities and tourism' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'humanities and tourism' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'humanities and tourism' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'humanities and tourism'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'humanities and tourism' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'humanities and tourism' " ], "target": "humanities and tourism" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'humor studies' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'humor studies' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'humor studies' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'humor studies' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'humor studies' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'humor studies'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'humor studies' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'humor studies' " ], "target": "humor studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'huntsmanship' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'huntsmanship' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'huntsmanship' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'huntsmanship' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'huntsmanship' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'huntsmanship'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'huntsmanship' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'huntsmanship' " ], "target": "huntsmanship" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hussite theology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hussite theology' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hussite theology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hussite theology' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hussite theology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hussite theology'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hussite theology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hussite theology' " ], "target": "hussite theology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydraulic engineering' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydraulic engineering' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydraulic engineering' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydraulic engineering' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydraulic engineering' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydraulic engineering'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydraulic engineering' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydraulic engineering' " ], "target": "hydraulic engineering" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydro-oceanography' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydro-oceanography' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydro-oceanography' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydro-oceanography' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydro-oceanography' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydro-oceanography'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydro-oceanography' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydro-oceanography' " ], "target": "hydro-oceanography" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydrochemistry' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydrochemistry' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydrochemistry' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydrochemistry' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydrochemistry' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydrochemistry'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydrochemistry' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydrochemistry' " ], "target": "hydrochemistry" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydroclimatology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydroclimatology' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydroclimatology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydroclimatology' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydroclimatology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydroclimatology'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydroclimatology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydroclimatology' " ], "target": "hydroclimatology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydroecology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydroecology' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydroecology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydroecology' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydroecology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydroecology'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydroecology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydroecology' " ], "target": "hydroecology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'hydrogeology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'hydrogeology' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'hydrogeology' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'hydrogeology' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not a subconcept of 'hydrogeology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a type of 'hydrogeology'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'hydrogeology' ", "'academic discipline' is not a subcategory of 'hydrogeology' " ], "target": "hydrogeology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'academic discipline' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'academic discipline' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'academic discipline' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'algebra' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'algebra' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ", "'algebra' is a type of 'area of mathematics'", "every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ", "'algebra' is a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' " ], "target": "area of mathematics" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'algebra' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'algebra' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'algebra' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'algebra' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'algebra'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'algebra' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'algebra' " ], "target": "algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'algebra' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'algebra' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'algebra' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'algebra' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'algebra' ", "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a type of 'algebra'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is necessarily a kind of 'algebra' ", "'area of mathematics' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'algebra' " ], "target": "algebra" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural management' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural management' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural management' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural management' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural management' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural management'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural management' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural management' " ], "target": "cultural management" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural mediation' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural mediation' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural mediation'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural mediation' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural mediation' " ], "target": "cultural mediation" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural production and landscape studies'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural production and landscape studies' " ], "target": "cultural production and landscape studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural psychology' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural psychology' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural psychology'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural psychology' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural psychology' " ], "target": "cultural psychology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural science' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural science' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural science' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural science' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural science' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural science'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural science' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural science' " ], "target": "cultural science" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural studies' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural studies' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural studies' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural studies' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural studies' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural studies'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural studies' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural studies' " ], "target": "cultural studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural studies of nation and region'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural studies of nation and region' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural studies of nation and region' " ], "target": "cultural studies of nation and region" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cultural well-being' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cultural well-being' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cultural well-being' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cultural well-being' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cultural well-being' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cultural well-being'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cultural well-being' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cultural well-being' " ], "target": "cultural well-being" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'cashback reward program' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'cashback reward program' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'cashback reward program' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'cashback reward program' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'cashback reward program' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'cashback reward program'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'cashback reward program' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'cashback reward program' " ], "target": "cashback reward program" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'catechesis' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'catechesis' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'catechesis' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'catechesis' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'catechesis' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'catechesis'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'catechesis' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'catechesis' " ], "target": "catechesis" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'child health' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'child health' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'child health' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'child health' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is not a subconcept of 'child health' ", "'algebra' is not a type of 'child health'", "not every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'child health' ", "'algebra' is not a subcategory of 'child health' " ], "target": "child health" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'algebra' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'algebra' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'algebra' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'algebra' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "algebra", "statements": [ "'algebra' is a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ", "'algebra' is a type of 'area of mathematics'", "every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ", "'algebra' is a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ", "'algebra' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'algebra' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'algebra' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'algebra' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of mathematics' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of mathematics' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'area of mathematics' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'area of mathematics' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'area of mathematics'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'area of mathematics' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'area of mathematics' " ], "target": "area of mathematics" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'speech science' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'speech science' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'speech science' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'speech science' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'speech science' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'speech science'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'speech science' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'speech science' " ], "target": "speech science" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spherical geometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spherical geometry' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spherical geometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spherical geometry' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spherical geometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spherical geometry'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spherical geometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spherical geometry' " ], "target": "spherical geometry" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spherical trigonometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spherical trigonometry' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spherical trigonometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spherical trigonometry' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spherical trigonometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spherical trigonometry'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spherical trigonometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spherical trigonometry' " ], "target": "spherical trigonometry" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spider anatomy' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spider anatomy' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spider anatomy' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spider anatomy' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spider anatomy' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spider anatomy'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spider anatomy' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spider anatomy' " ], "target": "spider anatomy" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spike maul and claw bar' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spike maul and claw bar' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spike maul and claw bar' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spike maul and claw bar' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spike maul and claw bar' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spike maul and claw bar'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spike maul and claw bar' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spike maul and claw bar' " ], "target": "spike maul and claw bar" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spin geometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spin geometry' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spin geometry' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spin geometry' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spin geometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spin geometry'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spin geometry' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spin geometry' " ], "target": "spin geometry" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spirituality' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spirituality' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spirituality' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spirituality' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spirituality' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spirituality'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spirituality' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spirituality' " ], "target": "spirituality" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'split-and-stitch video encoding'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'split-and-stitch video encoding' " ], "target": "split-and-stitch video encoding" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'spongiology' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'spongiology' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'spongiology' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'spongiology' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'spongiology' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'spongiology'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'spongiology' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'spongiology' " ], "target": "spongiology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'sport and health education' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'sport and health education' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'sport and health education' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'sport and health education' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'sport and health education' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'sport and health education'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'sport and health education' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'sport and health education' " ], "target": "sport and health education" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'sport management' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'sport management' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'sport management' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'sport management' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is not a subconcept of 'sport management' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a type of 'sport management'", "not every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'sport management' ", "'area of mathematics' is not a subcategory of 'sport management' " ], "target": "sport management" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'area of mathematics' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'area of mathematics' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of mathematics' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "area of mathematics", "statements": [ "'area of mathematics' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of mathematics' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'area of mathematics' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of mathematics' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'banking law' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'banking law' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'area of law' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'area of law' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'area of law' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'area of law' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is a subconcept of 'area of law' ", "'banking law' is a type of 'area of law'", "every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'area of law' ", "'banking law' is a subcategory of 'area of law' " ], "target": "area of law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'banking law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'banking law' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'banking law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'banking law' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'banking law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'banking law'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'banking law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'banking law' " ], "target": "banking law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'banking law' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'banking law' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'banking law' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'banking law' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'banking law' ", "'area of law' is not necessarily a type of 'banking law'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is necessarily a kind of 'banking law' ", "'area of law' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'banking law' " ], "target": "banking law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'educational sciences' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'educational sciences' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'educational sciences' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'educational sciences' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'educational sciences' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'educational sciences'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'educational sciences' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'educational sciences' " ], "target": "educational sciences" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'educommunication' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'educommunication' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'educommunication' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'educommunication' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'educommunication' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'educommunication'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'educommunication' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'educommunication' " ], "target": "educommunication" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'effects of climate change on humans' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'effects of climate change on humans' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'effects of climate change on humans' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'effects of climate change on humans' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'effects of climate change on humans' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'effects of climate change on humans'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'effects of climate change on humans' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'effects of climate change on humans' " ], "target": "effects of climate change on humans" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'ego psychology' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'ego psychology' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'ego psychology' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'ego psychology' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'ego psychology' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'ego psychology'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'ego psychology' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'ego psychology' " ], "target": "ego psychology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'egocentric reference system' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'egocentric reference system' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'egocentric reference system' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'egocentric reference system' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'egocentric reference system' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'egocentric reference system'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'egocentric reference system' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'egocentric reference system' " ], "target": "egocentric reference system" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'elasticity theory' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'elasticity theory' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'elasticity theory' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'elasticity theory' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'elasticity theory' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'elasticity theory'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'elasticity theory' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'elasticity theory' " ], "target": "elasticity theory" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'election offence' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'election offence' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'election offence' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'election offence' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'election offence' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'election offence'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'election offence' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'election offence' " ], "target": "election offence" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'electoral geography' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'electoral geography' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'electoral geography' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'electoral geography' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'electoral geography' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'electoral geography'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'electoral geography' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'electoral geography' " ], "target": "electoral geography" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'electoral law' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'electoral law' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'electoral law' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'electoral law' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'electoral law' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'electoral law'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'electoral law' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'electoral law' " ], "target": "electoral law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'electrical and computer engineering' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'electrical and computer engineering' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'electrical and computer engineering' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'electrical and computer engineering' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'electrical and computer engineering' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'electrical and computer engineering'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'electrical and computer engineering' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'electrical and computer engineering' " ], "target": "electrical and computer engineering" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'electrical circuits and systems' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'electrical circuits and systems' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'electrical circuits and systems' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'electrical circuits and systems' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is not a subconcept of 'electrical circuits and systems' ", "'banking law' is not a type of 'electrical circuits and systems'", "not every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'electrical circuits and systems' ", "'banking law' is not a subcategory of 'electrical circuits and systems' " ], "target": "electrical circuits and systems" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'area of law' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'area of law' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'area of law' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'area of law' ?", "is 'banking law' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'banking law' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'banking law' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'banking law' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "banking law", "statements": [ "'banking law' is a subconcept of 'area of law' ", "'banking law' is a type of 'area of law'", "every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'area of law' ", "'banking law' is a subcategory of 'area of law' ", "'banking law' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'banking law' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'banking law' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'banking law' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of law' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of law' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'area of law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'area of law' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'area of law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'area of law' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'area of law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'area of law'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'area of law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'area of law' " ], "target": "area of law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural ecology' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural ecology' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural ecology' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural ecology' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural ecology' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural ecology'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural ecology' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural ecology' " ], "target": "cultural ecology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural economics' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural economics' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural economics' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural economics' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural economics' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural economics'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural economics' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural economics' " ], "target": "cultural economics" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural engineering' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural engineering' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural engineering' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural engineering' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural engineering' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural engineering'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural engineering' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural engineering' " ], "target": "cultural engineering" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural geography' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural geography' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural geography' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural geography' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural geography' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural geography'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural geography' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural geography' " ], "target": "cultural geography" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural history' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural history' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural history' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural history' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural history' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural history'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural history' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural history' " ], "target": "cultural history" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural management' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural management' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural management' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural management' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural management' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural management'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural management' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural management' " ], "target": "cultural management" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural mediation' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural mediation' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural mediation' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural mediation'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural mediation' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural mediation' " ], "target": "cultural mediation" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural production and landscape studies'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural production and landscape studies' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural production and landscape studies' " ], "target": "cultural production and landscape studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural psychology' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural psychology' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural psychology' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural psychology'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural psychology' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural psychology' " ], "target": "cultural psychology" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural science' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural science' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural science' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural science' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural science' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural science'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural science' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural science' " ], "target": "cultural science" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'cultural studies' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'cultural studies' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'cultural studies' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'cultural studies' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not a subconcept of 'cultural studies' ", "'area of law' is not a type of 'cultural studies'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'cultural studies' ", "'area of law' is not a subcategory of 'cultural studies' " ], "target": "cultural studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of law' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'area of law' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'area of law' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": null }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'academic discipline' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'academic discipline' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'academic discipline' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is a subconcept of 'academic discipline' ", "'intellectual property law' is a type of 'academic discipline'", "every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'academic discipline' ", "'intellectual property law' is a subcategory of 'academic discipline' " ], "target": "academic discipline" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "yes", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'area of law' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'area of law' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'area of law' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'area of law' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is a subconcept of 'area of law' ", "'intellectual property law' is a type of 'area of law'", "every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'area of law' ", "'intellectual property law' is a subcategory of 'area of law' " ], "target": "area of law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'academic discipline' a subconcept of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a type of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is every kind of 'academic discipline' also a kind of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is 'academic discipline' a subcategory of 'intellectual property law' ?" ], "source": "academic discipline", "statements": [ "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'intellectual property law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a type of 'intellectual property law'", "not every kind of 'academic discipline' is necessarily a kind of 'intellectual property law' ", "'academic discipline' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'intellectual property law' " ], "target": "intellectual property law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'area of law' a subconcept of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is 'area of law' a type of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is every kind of 'area of law' also a kind of 'intellectual property law' ?", "is 'area of law' a subcategory of 'intellectual property law' ?" ], "source": "area of law", "statements": [ "'area of law' is not necessarily a subconcept of 'intellectual property law' ", "'area of law' is not necessarily a type of 'intellectual property law'", "not every kind of 'area of law' is necessarily a kind of 'intellectual property law' ", "'area of law' is not necessarily a subcategory of 'intellectual property law' " ], "target": "intellectual property law" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'box set' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'box set' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'box set' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'box set' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'box set' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'box set'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'box set' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'box set' " ], "target": "box set" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'branch of geography' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'branch of geography' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'branch of geography' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'branch of geography' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'branch of geography' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'branch of geography'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'branch of geography' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'branch of geography' " ], "target": "branch of geography" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'branch of history' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'branch of history' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'branch of history' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'branch of history' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'branch of history' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'branch of history'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'branch of history' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'branch of history' " ], "target": "branch of history" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'biblical studies' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'biblical studies' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'biblical studies' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'biblical studies' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'biblical studies' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'biblical studies'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'biblical studies' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'biblical studies' " ], "target": "biblical studies" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'discounts and allowances' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'discounts and allowances' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'discounts and allowances' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'discounts and allowances' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'discounts and allowances' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'discounts and allowances'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'discounts and allowances' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'discounts and allowances' " ], "target": "discounts and allowances" }
academic_disciplines
V2
{ "expected_answer": "no", "questions": [ "is 'intellectual property law' a subconcept of 'branch of literature' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a type of 'branch of literature' ?", "is every kind of 'intellectual property law' also a kind of 'branch of literature' ?", "is 'intellectual property law' a subcategory of 'branch of literature' ?" ], "source": "intellectual property law", "statements": [ "'intellectual property law' is not a subconcept of 'branch of literature' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a type of 'branch of literature'", "not every kind of 'intellectual property law' is also a kind of 'branch of literature' ", "'intellectual property law' is not a subcategory of 'branch of literature' " ], "target": "branch of literature" }
End of preview.

What it is:

Each dataset in this delivery is made up of query clusters that test an aspect of the consistency of the LLM knowledge about a particular domain. All the questions in each cluster are meant to be answered either 'yes' or 'no'. When the answers vary within a cluster, the knowledge is said to be inconsistent. When all the questions in a cluster are answered 'no' when the expected answer is 'yes' (or viceversa), the knowledge is said to be 'incomplete' (i.e., maybe the LLM wasn't trained in that particular domain). It is our experience that incomplete clusters are very few (less than 3%) meaning that the LLMs we have tested know about the domains included here (see below for a list of the individual datasets), as opposed to inconsistent clusters, which can be between 6%-20% of the total clusters.

The image below indicates the types of edges the query clusters are supposed to test. It is worth noting that these correspond to common sense axioms about conceptualization, like the fact that subConceptOf is transitive (4) or that subconcepts inherit the properties of their parent concepts (5). These axioms are listed in the accompanying paper (see below)

image/png

How it is made:

The questions and clusters are automatically generated from a knowledge graph from seed concepts and properties. In our case, we have used Wikidata, a well known knowledge graph. The result is an RDF/OWL subgraph that can be queried and reasoned over using Semantic Web technology. The figure below summarizes the steps used. The last two steps refer to a possible use case for this dataset, including using in-context learning to improve the performance of the dataset.

image/png

Types of query clusters

There are different types of query clusters depending on what aspect of the knowledge graph and its deductive closure they capture:

Edge clusters test a single edge using different questions. For example, to test the edge ('orthopedic pediatric surgeon', IsA, 'orthopedic surgeon), the positive or 'edge_yes' (expected answer is 'yes') cluster is:

  "is 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' a subconcept of 'orthopedic surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' a type of 'orthopedic surgeon' ?",
  "is every kind of 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' also a kind of 'orthopedic surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' a subcategory of 'orthopedic surgeon' ?"

There are also inverse edge clusters (with questions like "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subconcept of 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' ?") and negative or 'edge_no' clusters (with questions like "is 'orthopedic pediatric surgeon' a subconcept of 'dermatologist' ?")

Hierarchy clusters measure the consistency of a given path, including n-hop virtual edges (in graph's the deductive closure). For example, the path ('orthopedic surgeon', 'surgeon', 'medical specialist', 'medical occupation') is tested by the cluster below

  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subconcept of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a type of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is every kind of 'orthopedic surgeon' also a kind of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subcategory of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subconcept of 'medical specialist' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a type of 'medical specialist' ?",
  "is every kind of 'orthopedic surgeon' also a kind of 'medical specialist' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subcategory of 'medical specialist' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subconcept of 'medical_occupation' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a type of 'medical_occupation' ?",
  "is every kind of 'orthopedic surgeon' also a kind of 'medical_occupation' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subcategory of 'medical_occupation' ?"

Property inheritance clusters test the most basic property of conceptualization. If an orthopedic surgeon is a type of surgeon, we expect that all the properties of surgeons, e.g., having to be board certified, having attended medical school or working on the field of surgery, are inherited by orthopedic surgeons. The example below tests the later:

  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subconcept of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a type of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is every kind of 'orthopedic surgeon' also a kind of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is 'orthopedic surgeon' a subcategory of 'surgeon' ?",
  "is the following statement true? 'orthopedic surgeon works on the field of  surgery' ",
  "is the following statement true? 'surgeon works on the field of  surgery' ",
  "is it accurate to say that  'orthopedic surgeon works on the field of  surgery'? ",
  "is it accurate to say that  'surgeon works on the field of  surgery'? "

List of datasets

To show the versatility of our approach, we have constructed similar datasets in the domains below. We test one property inheritance per dataset. The Wikidata main QNode (the node corresponding to the entities) and PNode (the node corresponding to the property) are indicated in parenthesis.

domain top concept WD concept main property WD property
Academic Disciplines "Academic Discipline" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q11862829 "has use" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P366
Dishes "Dish" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q746549 "has parts" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P527
Financial products "Financial product" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q15809678 "used by" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P1535
Home appliances "Home appliance" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q212920 "has use" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P366
Medical specialties "Medical specialty" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q930752 "field of occupation" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P425
Music genres "Music genre" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q188451 "practiced by" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P3095
Natural disasters "Natural disaster" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8065 "has cause" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P828
Software "Software" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q7397 "studied in" https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Property:P7397

The size and configuration of the datasets is listed below

domain edges_yes edges_no edges_in hierarchies property hierarchies
Academic Disciplines 52 308 52 30 1
Dishes 197 519 197 62 121
Financial product 112 433 108 40 32
Home appliances 58 261 58 31 13
Medical specialties 122 386 114 55 63
Music genres 490 807 488 212 139
Natural disasters 45 225 44 21 22
Software 80 572 79 114 4

Want to know more?

For background and motivation on this dataset, please check https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20163 Also to be published in COLM 2024,

@inproceedings{Uceda_2024_1,
  title={Reasoning about concepts with LLMs: Inconsistencies abound},
  author={Rosario Uceda Sosa and Karthikeyan Natesan Ramamurthy and Maria Chang and Moninder Singh},
  booktitle={Proc.\ 1st Conference on Language Modeling (COLM 24)},
  year={2024}
}

Questions? Comments?

Please contact [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] or [email protected]

Downloads last month
80