<p>There are many sources available where you can find export data like UNCOMTRADE, WITS.
Using HS codes, you can identify the products that are exported for first time, make sure to consider the concordance of HS Codes. 
But this proxy can suffer from the problem like FTAs, liberalisation, Bilateral agreements. For an example: market produces jewellery from quite long time , but it entered in the international market when government provided export subsidy. There is no innovation, it's just opening of the market. You must mention in your paper, from what problems do the proxy suffer.
As mentioned by others, patent would be the good proxy to understand the technology adoptions and innovations.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-09-03T21:43:53.780Z
2019-09-03T21:43:53.780Z
Saloni Khurana
<p>UN COMTRADE has export data by country-product at the HS 6-digit level. What you could do to find out when the product was first exported is to get data for a country's export for product, say, with HS code 123456, from as far back as possible, and see when was the first year that the export of this product is not zero.</p>

<p>I've seen number of patents filed used as a proxy for product innovation in some papers. That might work for your paper as well?</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-09-03T16:31:18.900Z
2019-09-03T16:31:18.900Z
Art
<p>My objective is to prove that international trade leads human capital formation which leads to economic growth. I am regressing GDP on multiple variables among which Human capital is one. According to a paper, I've read, new lines of product provide more learning by doing opportunities for workers and hence accumulation of human capital. Since panel data on product innovation is not available, it uses 'first time export' of a commodity as an indicator of product innovation. The source for the data is <a href="https://comtrade.un.org/db/" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https://comtrade.un.org/db/</a>
But I don't understand how to identify first time exported commodities.
i need suggestion for what other variables can be used as a proxy for product innovation.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-09-03T17:27:47.047Z
Did you look at what patent data is available? If you do use patents, be sure to look at weighting them by the number of citations the receive. Unweighted patents are known to be a poor indicator of innovation.
Ubiquitous
<econometrics><economic-growth><applied-econometrics><time-series><development-economics>
what can be the proxy variable for measure of product innovation?
Shoaib Ashraf
# what can be the proxy variable for measure of product innovation?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2019-09-02)

My objective is to prove that international trade leads human capital formation which leads to economic growth. I am regressing GDP on multiple variables among which Human capital is one. According to a paper, I've read, new lines of product provide more learning by doing opportunities for workers and hence accumulation of human capital. Since panel data on product innovation is not available, it uses 'first time export' of a commodity as an indicator of product innovation. The source for the data is <https://comtrade.un.org/db/>
But I don't understand how to identify first time exported commodities.
i need suggestion for what other variables can be used as a proxy for product innovation.

**Tags:** econometrics, economic-growth, applied-econometrics, time-series, development-economics
> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Did you look at what patent data is available? If you do use patents, be sure to look at weighting them by the number of citations the receive. Unweighted patents are known to be a poor indicator of innovation.  

---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_2 on 2019-09-03. Score: 1 | Accepted answer

There are many sources available where you can find export data like UNCOMTRADE, WITS.
Using HS codes, you can identify the products that are exported for first time, make sure to consider the concordance of HS Codes.
But this proxy can suffer from the problem like FTAs, liberalisation, Bilateral agreements. For an example: market produces jewellery from quite long time , but it entered in the international market when government provided export subsidy. There is no innovation, it's just opening of the market. You must mention in your paper, from what problems do the proxy suffer.
As mentioned by others, patent would be the good proxy to understand the technology adoptions and innovations.


---

### Answer by username_3 on 2019-09-03. Score: 1

UN COMTRADE has export data by country-product at the HS 6-digit level. What you could do to find out when the product was first exported is to get data for a country's export for product, say, with HS code 123456, from as far back as possible, and see when was the first year that the export of this product is not zero.

I've seen number of patents filed used as a proxy for product innovation in some papers. That might work for your paper as well?


---

