**Principle-Specific Preferences.** We evaluate the preference function value for each principle as in Def. 5, averaged
over the Anthropic HH-RLHF dataset (refer to Fig. 10) and over the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset (refer to Fig. 11). Our
results show that the seed principles from Constitutional AI are, most of the time, irrelevant or indifferent for the
choice of a preferred response, indicated by indifference being larger than 50% for every principle in both datasets.
This suggests a gap between the stated principles and annotator preferences. Recent work [77, 60, 41] have tried
to decrease the gap between principles and human preferences by obtaining a set of principles; however, further
investigation focusing in more fine-grained principles that may arise in specific contexts (e.g., ‘ _Reject Conspiracy_
_Theories_ ’) is needed.
**Principle Prioritization.** Figure 12 shows the principle prioritization for different annotators in the PKU dataset (refer
to Fig. 5 for the principle priorities in the HH dataset). The fine-tuned reward models mirror human annotators well.
Yet, stark differences can still be observed, e.g., Mistral RM gives the principle ‘ _support democracy_ ’ far more priority
than by the human annotator. The principle priority differs more for the most downloaded reward model per dataset,
as these were also trained on other datasets. As we observed in Sec. 6.2, the LLMs fine-tuned using these reward
models clearly prioritize principles differently, suggesting a poor consistency with human discretion.
**Principle Rankings.** Figures 13a and 13b illustrate the ranking of principles based on their priority weights. As discussed before, the trained reward models were able to closely capture the ranking of principles found in the preference
dataset.
**Principle Supremacies.** Figures 4 and 14 illustrate the principle supremacies for the human annotator over the HH and
PKU datasets respectively, as measured using Def. 8, providing a detailed view of inter-principle conflicts and their
resolutions. By capturing the dynamics of agreement and disagreement among principles, the principle supremacy
matrix offers a clear representation of the annotator’s implicit valuation of these principles in each preference dataset.
Interestingly, the number of conflicts varies significantly across principle pairs. For example, ‘Avoid human-like
identity’ and ‘Be helpful’ are one of the most conflicting pairs of principles in the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset while
‘Reject cruelty’ and ‘Support democracy’ never conflict.
AI Alignment at Your Discretion
Figure 10: Principle-specific preferences (Def. 5) averaged over the Anthropic HH-RLHF dataset. The proportion
of indifference indicates how often a principle is indifferent to the choice of response. The proportion of agreement
indicates how often a principle agrees with the annotator’s labels while the proportion of disagreement measures how
often a principle disagrees with the annotator’s labels.
AI Alignment at Your Discretion
Figure 11: Principle-specific preferences (Def. 5) averaged over the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset. The proportion of
indifference indicates how often a principle is indifferent to the choice of response. The proportion of agreement
indicates how often a principle agrees with the annotator’s labels while the proportion of disagreement measures how
often a principle disagrees with the annotator’s labels.
Figure 12: Principle priorities (Def. 9) for each annotator of the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset, excluding the base LLMs. Each plot represents an independent system
of principle priorities specific to an annotator, so values are not comparable across subplots. Bars are shaded by principle ranking, with x-axis scales adjusted per
annotator to reflect their full range. Red asterisks indicate principles that are never prioritized (i.e. with weight of negative infinity) while white asterisks indicate
principles that are always prioritized (i.e. with weight of positive infinity). The principles, of which the full description is given in Tab. 3, were interpreted in a
broad sense – principles like ‘ _support democracy_ ’ can generally refer to a preference for responses that avoid subversion of the government.
AI Alignment at Your Discretion
|Reject conspiracy theories 1
Avoid racism and sexism 2
Reject cruelty 3
Avoid harm 4
Avoid threatening humanity 5
Be non-threatening 6
Be confident in responses 7
Respect non-Western views 8
Respect human rights 9
Value human equality 10
Prioritize common good 11
Support democracy 12
Avoid professional advice 13
Balance both sides 14
Value individual liberty 15
Rectify systemic bias 16
Avoid human-like identity 17
Support marginalized groups 18
Be helpful 19
Be obedient 20
Protect free speech 21|2|1 9 21 1|7 19 17 17|15|1|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|4|2
15 13
6|11 11 17|3|4|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|7|5
8
8
4|5
13 17|8
|1|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|7|5
8
8
4|5
13 17|8
||
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|1|4
3
11
8|6
14 10|11|13|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|3|8
1
7
5|2
15
6|4|5|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|6
|11
4
15 1|1
9
19
9|12|14|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|5|3
13 19 1|5 13 21 12|20|17|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|5|3
13 19 1|5 13 21 12|20||
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|8
|18
2
9
2|1
7
17|13|21|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|8
|18
2
9
2|1
7
17|13||
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|9|7
6
4
2|3
12 17|2|3|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|13|6
7
5
7|7
9
17|5|6|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|
 12
|12 11
6
9

|10 10
8

|7
|9
|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|15|17 12
1
|4
8
17|1|1|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|14|10 14 18 2|0 15 20 11|19|15|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|14|10 14 18 2|0 15 20 11|19||
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|10|15
5
16 1|6 14 18 17|16|18|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|18|14 18 10 1|8 17
5
2|18|19|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|16|13 19
3
1|2 12
6
17|6
|10|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|11|16 10 17 1|9 16 16
7|17|16|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|17|9
17 12 1|3 20
4
5|10|8|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|19|19 16
2
1|0
8
3
2|9|7|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|21|21 21 20 2|1 21
1
2|21|20|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|20|20 20 14 1|4 18
2
2|14|12|
|Reject conspiracy theories
Avoid racism and sexism
Reject cruelty
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Avoid professional advice
Balance both sides
Value individual liberty
Rectify systemic bias
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Support marginalized groups
Be helpful
Be obedient
Protect free speech
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21|20|20 20 14 1|4 18
2
2|14||
(a) Principle ranking based on the priority weights of the HHRLHF dataset.
(b) Principle ranking based on the priority weights of the PKUSafeRLHF dataset.
Figure 13: Comparison of the ranking of principles based on their priority weights across the HH-RLHF and PKUSafeRLHF datasets. The two visualizations highlight agreements and divergences in how annotators evaluate and
prioritize principles in different datasets.
AI Alignment at Your Discretion
|Be helpful 57% 48% 56% 55% 55% 61% 62% 68% 65% 72% 69% 72% 73% 73% 81% 82% 67% 86% 85% 87%|48% 56% 55% 5|55% 61%|% 62% 6|68% 65% 72% 69% 72%|73% 73% 81% 82% 67%|86% 85|5% 8|87%|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|25)

(78)

(239)

(1

|13)

(106

|)

(23)

(2

|76)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

|(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

|(247)

(1

|47)

(

|47)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|0%
20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)

(

|%
44)
71
(40)

||0%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)

|100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)

|100%
(50)
8
(

|%
26)
9
(

|3%
12)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|75%
(5)
25%
(10)
5
(

|7%
6)
56
(7)

|50%
(2)
1

|0%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)

|0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)

|50%
(15)
5
(

|%
14)
7
(

|5%
1)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|5%
(5)
67%
(45)
6
(
5%
33%
|7%
23)
50
(24)
0%
25|50%
(4)

(
|8%
19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
0%
71%
0%|50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
50%
100%
75%
62%
83%|75%
(74)
7
(
100%
8|5%
34)
1
(
%
8|0%
9)
8%|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|10)

(45)

(

|41)

(43)
||(1)

(132)

(6)

|(71)

(10)

(55)

(28)

(27)

|(129)

(1

|50)

(

|17)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|3%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)

|50
(13)
|57%
(2)

(

|5%
43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)

|100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)

|80%
(48)
7
(

|%
76)
9
(

|0%
10)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|4%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
5
(

|0%
13)

|57%
(2)

(

|5%
60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)

|69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)

|64%
(66)
7
(

|%
75)
8
(

|1%
10)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|0%
(2)
50%
(4)
4
(
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
4
(
0%
(2)
30%
(7)
4
(|3%
2)
43
(2)
5%
43)
35%
(60)
4%
13)
35%
(13)|(

60%
(14)

50%
(5)
6
|0%
14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
2%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)|100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)|75%
(17)
8
(
77%
(170)
8
(
77%
(14)
8
(|2%
15)
8
(
1%
94)
9
(
0%
7)
8
(|8%
0)
0%
26)
8%
4)|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
3
(
3%
10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
5
(

|0%
0)
27%
(0)
2%
92)
36%
(97)

|0%
(2)
5

25%
(38)
4
(1

|7%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
8%
03)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)

|100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)

|100%
(4)
6
(
100%
(124)
6
(

|0%
8)
1
(
4%
29)
8
(

|00%
0)
0%
33)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|0%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
3
(
0%
50%
50%
|8%
4)
38
(7)
%
31|35%
(2)

(

0%
|7%
26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
4%
25%
0%
43%
17%|83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
40%
86%
68%
80%|64%
(16)
7
(
100%
8|2%
34)
8
(
%
8|7%
1)
5%|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|(1)

(19)

(71)

(

|19)

(30)

|(9)

(

|62)

(6)

(4)

(97)

(7)

|(11)

(28)

(10)

(12)

|(102)

(

|97)

(

|12)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|3%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
5
(
5%
10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
2
(|4%
10)
38
(8)
9%
34)
27%
(31)|33%
(2)

25%
(2)
3
(|6%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
3%
39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)|60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)|71%
(9)
8
(
50%
(46)
6
(|%
14)
7
(
8%
72)
8
(|9%
6)
7%
23)|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|6%
11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
3
(

|1%
23)
35%
(22)

|32%
(3)
2

|7%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)

|32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)

|86%
(22)
7
(

|2%
39)
5
(

|6%
10)
|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|5%
10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)

(
0%
25%
0%
2|1%
18)
32
(17)
0%
36|27%
(9)

25%
2|4%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
3%
23%
0%
0%
36%|20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
0%
29%
50%
14%
33%|67%
(28)
6
(
3|%
3)
3
(
3%
7|8%
11)
5%|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|15)

(74)

(129)

(
0%
25%
17%
2|48)

(66)
6%
21|(17)

(1

18%
|70)

(14)

(4)

(124)

(16)
9%
20%
40%
36%
28%|(102)

(9)

(46)

(22)

(28)
13%
13%
32%
28%
33%|(1
67%|95)

(
3|23)
9%|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|14)

(34)

(150)

(
5%
0%
12%
|76)

(75)
0%
19|(15)

(

12%
|94)

(7)

(8)

(29)

(34)
0%
12%
0%
20%
13%|(97)

(14)

(72)

(39)

(3)
15%
21%
13%
44%
62%|(195)
25%
6|(
%|34)|
|Be helpful
Reject cruelty
ect non-Western views
Rectify systemic bias
ect conspiracy theories
rt marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
void racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
d threatening humanity
Be non-threatening
 confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
oid human-like identity
Be obedient
oid professional advice
Be helpful
Reject cruelty
Respect non~~-~~Western views
Rectify systemic bias
Reject conspiracy theories
Support marginalized groups
Prioritize common good
Support democracy
Respect human rights
Value human equality
Avoid racism and sexism
Balance both sides
Avoid harm
Avoid threatening humanity
Be non~~-~~threatening
Be confident in responses
Value individual liberty
Protect free speech
Avoid human~~-~~like identity
Be obedient
Avoid professional advice

(29)

(25)

(78)

(239)

(113)

(106)

(23)

(276)

(22)

(11)

(52)

(33)

(245)

(21)

(83)

(43)

(9)

(247)

(147)

(47)
43%
(29)
50%
(20)
0%
(8)
100%
(38)
0%
(44)
71%
(40)
50%
(5)
50%
(3)
50%
(7)
100%
(14)
75%
(7)
100%
(16)
75%
(7)
78%
(50)
80%
(34)
56%
(5)
100%
(50)
87%
(26)
93%
(12)
52%
(25)
50%
(20)
75%
(5)
25%
(10)
57%
(6)
56%
(7)
50%
(2)
100%
(5)
80%
(2)
100%
(1)
57%
(10)
70%
(1)
0%
(1)
67%
(3)
55%
(10)
64%
(11)
75%
(10)
50%
(15)
50%
(14)
75%
(1)
44%
(78)
100%
(8)
25%
(5)
67%
(45)
67%
(23)
50%
(24)
50%
(4)
68%
(19)
70%
(7)
73%
(4)
53%
(60)
64%
(15)
50%
(19)
54%
(3)
70%
(26)
62%
(13)
80%
(14)
75%
(74)
75%
(34)
100%
(9)
45%
(239)
0%
(38)
75%
(10)
33%
(45)
40%
(41)
25%
(43)
0%
(1)
71%
(132)
0%
(6)
50%
(71)
100%
(10)
75%
(55)
62%
(28)
83%
(27)
100%
(129)
83%
(150)
88%
(17)
45%
(113)
100%
(44)
43%
(6)
33%
(23)
60%
(41)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
55%
(43)
56%
(13)
70%
(0)
48%
(92)
62%
(4)
100%
(19)
46%
(10)
71%
(34)
69%
(23)
79%
(18)
80%
(48)
74%
(76)
90%
(10)
39%
(106)
29%
(40)
44%
(7)
50%
(24)
75%
(43)
50%
(13)
57%
(2)
65%
(60)
65%
(13)
73%
(0)
64%
(97)
62%
(7)
69%
(30)
62%
(8)
73%
(31)
65%
(22)
68%
(17)
64%
(66)
79%
(75)
81%
(10)
38%
(23)
50%
(2)
50%
(4)
43%
(2)
43%
(2)
40%
(14)
50%
(5)
100%
(2)
75%
(38)
65%
(2)
100%
(9)
67%
(2)
75%
(2)
68%
(3)
73%
(9)
75%
(17)
82%
(15)
88%
(0)
32%
(276)
50%
(5)
0%
(5)
32%
(19)
45%
(43)
35%
(60)
60%
(14)
38%
(4)
43%
(8)
52%
(103)
63%
(26)
86%
(62)
54%
(8)
67%
(39)
73%
(8)
76%
(8)
77%
(170)
81%
(94)
90%
(26)
35%
(22)
50%
(3)
20%
(2)
30%
(7)
44%
(13)
35%
(13)
50%
(5)
62%
(4)
33%
(1)
50%
(6)
54%
(1)
75%
(6)
57%
(2)
63%
(10)
67%
(8)
67%
(3)
77%
(14)
80%
(7)
88%
(4)
28%
(11)
50%
(7)
0%
(1)
27%
(4)
100%
(1)
30%
(0)
27%
(0)
0%
(2)
57%
(8)
67%
(1)
55%
(6)
70%
(2)
100%
(4)
40%
(4)
100%
(5)
79%
(3)
70%
(6)
100%
(4)
60%
(8)
100%
(0)
31%
(52)
0%
(14)
43%
(10)
47%
(60)
29%
(132)
52%
(92)
36%
(97)
25%
(38)
48%
(103)
50%
(6)
45%
(6)
53%
(70)
57%
(97)
38%
(6)
44%
(23)
77%
(12)
60%
(3)
100%
(124)
64%
(29)
80%
(33)
28%
(33)
25%
(7)
30%
(1)
36%
(15)
100%
(6)
38%
(4)
38%
(7)
35%
(2)
37%
(26)
46%
(1)
30%
(2)
47%
(70)
83%
(7)
69%
(1)
80%
(4)
66%
(2)
67%
(10)
64%
(16)
72%
(34)
87%
(1)
27%
(245)
0%
(16)
100%
(1)
50%
(19)
50%
(71)
0%
(19)
31%
(30)
0%
(9)
14%
(62)
25%
(6)
0%
(4)
43%
(97)
17%
(7)
40%
(11)
86%
(28)
68%
(10)
80%
(12)
100%
(102)
87%
(97)
85%
(12)
27%
(21)
25%
(7)
33%
(3)
46%
(3)
0%
(10)
54%
(10)
38%
(8)
33%
(2)
46%
(8)
43%
(2)
60%
(4)
62%
(6)
31%
(1)
60%
(11)
21%
(7)
74%
(4)
71%
(4)
71%
(9)
87%
(14)
79%
(6)
19%
(83)
22%
(50)
45%
(10)
30%
(26)
25%
(55)
29%
(34)
27%
(31)
25%
(2)
33%
(39)
37%
(10)
0%
(5)
56%
(23)
20%
(4)
14%
(28)
79%
(7)
56%
(15)
75%
(14)
50%
(46)
68%
(72)
87%
(23)
18%
(43)
20%
(34)
36%
(11)
38%
(13)
38%
(28)
31%
(23)
35%
(22)
32%
(3)
27%
(8)
33%
(8)
21%
(3)
23%
(12)
34%
(2)
32%
(10)
26%
(4)
44%
(15)
33%
(10)
86%
(22)
72%
(39)
56%
(10)
33%
(9)
44%
(5)
25%
(10)
20%
(14)
17%
(27)
21%
(18)
32%
(17)
27%
(9)
24%
(8)
33%
(3)
30%
(6)
40%
(3)
33%
(10)
20%
(12)
29%
(4)
25%
(14)
67%
(10)
67%
(28)
67%
(3)
38%
(11)
14%
(247)
0%
(50)
50%
(15)
25%
(74)
0%
(129)
20%
(48)
36%
(66)
25%
(17)
23%
(170)
23%
(14)
0%
(4)
0%
(124)
36%
(16)
0%
(102)
29%
(9)
50%
(46)
14%
(22)
33%
(28)
33%
(195)
75%
(23)
15%
(147)
13%
(26)
50%
(14)
25%
(34)
17%
(150)
26%
(76)
21%
(75)
18%
(15)
19%
(94)
20%
(7)
40%
(8)
36%
(29)
28%
(34)
13%
(97)
13%
(14)
32%
(72)
28%
(39)
33%
(3)
67%
(195)
39%
(34)
13%
(47)
7%
(12)
25%
(1)
0%
(9)
12%
(17)
10%
(10)
19%
(10)
12%
(0)
10%
(26)
12%
(4)
0%
(0)
20%
(33)
13%
(1)
15%
(12)
21%
(6)
13%
(23)
44%
(10)
62%
(11)
25%
(23)
61%
(34)|(1)

(9)

(17)

(|10)

(10)|(0)

(|26)

(4)

(0)

(33)

(1)|(12)

(6)

(23)

(10)

(11)|(23)

(|34)||
Figure 14: Principle supremacy matrix for the human annotator of the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset. The ( _i, j_ ) entry
indicates the proportion of times that the _i_ [th] principle ‘wins’ over the _j_ [th] principle. A win is considered when the
principles conflict, and the _i_ [th] principle agrees with the human label whereas the _j_ [th] principles disagrees with the
human label. We also note the total number of cases of conflict per pair of principles. Empty entries indicates that the
pair have never been in conflict. The principles are sorted in descending order of their priority weights, reaffirming
that principles with higher priority weight are more likely to ‘win’ over a principle with lower weight.