will stacking filters on Canon 24-105 lS USM lens cause vignetting Can I add this B&W polarizing filter on TOP of a B&W protective filter without causing vignetting? I am purchasing the Canon 24-105 f/4 IS USM for my 50D... will stacking filters on Canon 24-105 lS USM lens cause vignetting Can I add this B&W polarizing filter on TOP of a B&W protective filter without causing vignetting? I am purchasing the... » Read More will stacking filters on Canon 24-105 lS USM lens cause vignetting Can I add this B&W polarizing filter on TOP of a B&W protective filter without causing vignetting? I am purchasing the Canon 24-105 f/4 IS USM for my 50D... « Show Less
1753205
Thanks for taking the time to reply. I suspected as much, so I have just been using one at a time. Nice to know that I needed to, and should continue to, in the wide angle range.
682108
Yes you will see vignetting near the 24mm range and maybe in the 30mm range. If you use the polarizing filter take off the UV filter first. You do not need both on and the more you stack the worse the vignetting will get.
630853
You have a superb, professional quality lens. I'm old school, and believe filters should match the quality of the glass. Hence, I use B & W regular neutral density filter. I'm away from my office, and can't give you all the details off the box. I haven't found a thin filter is necessary for what I do with this lens--principally interior and exterior shots of buildings and their details with a Nikon D700 at complete range of F stops and focus lengths. Good luck with your shooting.
759242
If anyone is interested I have a 24-70L 2.8 Canon Lens. I only use it about 5 times total. 6 weeks after I bought it I purchase the 24-105 IS Canon Lens because I shoot mostly Wedding & Party's. The 24-105 IS works much better for the type of photography I do. I would sell it for $900.00 and include the B&W; UV Filter which is the top of the line brand filter which is made in Germany. Plus $25.00 for shipping. You can email me at rjgphoto@sbcglobal.net if anyone is interested.
1545908
The Polarizer is made in Japan, the filter is thin compared to cheaper ones. i have not had any problem with Vignetting using the Nikkor 18-105; i have also used it with the 70-300 VR, and never noticed any problems.Steve
1545905
The Hoya HD has "Made in Japan" printed on the edge. With the Nikkor 18-105 there are no vignetting problems. Do you have other filters stacked or possibly a lens hood causing your problem? The other possibility is the zoom stop may not have have been adjusted correctly from the factory and it goes a little wider than it should.
88551
Hi - Just double-checked a couple of OM lenses on my Sony a7r using this adapter. I want to make sure I'm completely understanding the question: if you're asking whether there will be any vignetting of the image, the answer is no (except to the extent that a specific lens shows some light falloff at the edges, but that's not an adapter issue, and you'd have the same phenomenon on an OM film body). If the question is whether or not the image will be cropped (using the term to refer to the so-called "crop factor" associated with smaller-than-24x36 sensors): again, the answer's no. OM lenses are full-frame lenses, the a7 is a full-frame body - so no cropping of the image. Hope that's helpful! Hi - Just double-checked a couple of OM lenses on my Sony a7r using this adapter. I want to make sure I'm completely understanding the question: if you're asking whether there will be any vignetting of the image, the answer is no (except to the extent that a specific lens shows some light falloff at the edges, but that's not an adapter issue, and you'd have the same phenomenon on an OM film body). If the question is whether or not the image will be cropped (using the term to refer to the so-called "crop factor" associated with smaller-than-24x36 sensors): again, the answer's no.... » Read More Hi - Just double-checked a couple of OM lenses on my Sony a7r using this adapter. I want to make sure I'm completely understanding the question: if you're asking whether there will be any vignetting of the image, the answer is no (except to the extent that a specific lens shows some light falloff at the edges, but that's not an adapter issue, and you'd have the same phenomenon on an OM film body). If the question is whether or not the image will be cropped (using the term to refer to the so-called "crop factor" associated with smaller-than-24x36 sensors): again, the answer's no. OM lenses are full-frame lenses, the a7 is a full-frame body - so no cropping of the image. Hope that's helpful! « Show Less
1869388
Assuming you have a 58mm lens, yes. However if your lens is 18mm you will get slight vignetting despite what they claim
1923730
My Lens adapter ring is 67mm and the filter holder inside diameter is approx. 1/2 larger than the adapter ring. I've used an 18-105 lens with the gnd's and haven't experienced vignetting, however, I haven't "tested" the lens for vignetting through the whole range of the focal length. I'm new to gnd's but with the large opening for the filter opening I don't foresee any problems with vignetting. So far I'm well pleased with the filter system, Hope this helps. Pete P.
122416
The extender will not work on a 24-105, generally it only works on lenses that go past 135mm (with some exceptions see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_Extender_EF for a list of compatible lenses).If you put it on a lens with max aperture of F/4 it will change it to f/5.6.
1279246
the stacking of filters may cause vignetting, but should not affect sharpness.
1252947
I use it on a Canon 5D Mark II with a 24mm lens and don't see any noticeable vignetting. Because of it's thin profile, you should be able to use it on very wide lenses without any problem.
581471
Yes. It has other problems, like causing flare (not blackened enough plastic), the autofocus never finding its mark correctly with Canon 35/2 IS, I'm not sure image stabilization even works with this lens (I see no difference between On/Off settings) -- but vignetting is not one of them.
642636
I'm guessing you mean a 'thin mount' filter? The only reason to use a thin mount filter would be to avoid vignetting. I have not used a filter with this lens at all. Unless I absolutely have to have one, I stay away from anything but the actual lens glass itself. Occasionally (very occasionally) I'll put a CPL on, but that is about the only case.
88042
I bought this specifically so I can use it with that lens which I plan to buy soon. Though I do not have the actual lens right now, I believe it will not cause vignetting because the glass is much larger than the 82mm ring size. Its actually offset a bit to avoid vignetting
1060548
As long as it stays on the lens and doesn't drop off you are probably OK. A polarizing filter needs to turn, that's how you adjust it to the maximum effect.
1569849
According to Canon, the 24-70 II has an 82mm filter size so it should fit. However, this is a fairly thick filter in that it uses two polarizers stacked so you may get vignetting at 24mm. I bought the 82mm with a step-down ring to use on my 77mm lenses for this reason.
720195
Yes, thus is one of the low cut filters, I'm not sure of the height, but works good with wide angle lenses without vignetting.