if the blade is EXACTLY the same the why is it NOT NSF approved?
380510
My guess is likely the purpose of the knife. NSF is typical for commercial kitchens.
380511
The other model was review and "approved" by the NSF for commercial kitchens. This model even though identical was not reviewed and hence cannot claim NSF approved. This is a best guess based on the information that I saw regarding this knife. I own one and it works wonderfully well for our kitchen needs.
380512
My guess is that it costs a bit to get the NSF review and approval stamp(nothing is free). This knife is selling for appr. 20% less than the same model with a stamp that does nothing to improve the less expensive model's equal and thus excellent performance. The $ difference is better in my pocket than theirs.
634906
Ontario has a spotty record on heat treat. Had the same problem with an RD9. The blades I've had that Justin Gingrich did the treat on have never failed or had issues. OKT may be US made but their QC is abysmal. The steel is good but the RC number is meaningless without a good heat treat. The protocols they use can be vastly different and lead to the same Rockwell hardness number and one blade is amazing while the other will chip, bend, or snap.
2242280
Probably not. I would imagine that the blade hookups would be different as per manufacturer.
934806
Yes, it's the same knife. The blades both show the same number (40520) on them.
1146799
a "factory second" as theyre called would be marked with 4 X's on the blade and would not have a warranty either. This is not a factory second.
677786
it is a different shape. Don't be concerned because these blades are awesome, besides if they don't fit amazon will take returns. As long as you have the same size, and the star is the same, i think they will fit.
1546937
Not Sure I Saw the NSF Logo on the Box it came in, I don't have the box to verify.
634093
The scabbard would probably be too big and the blade would be loose inside it. As far as I know the Noble Collection blades are a bit smaller than the United Cutlery ones.
717464
Not sure how to answer that but the blade is very sturdy and not large in any dimension. Its very slim from any dimension
353063
Hi. I'm from Victorinox Swiss Army. The blades are EXACTLY the same. The three differences are 1.) the packaging an 2.) the handle and 3.) The 40520 is NSF approved. The knife usually arrives in a red and white cardboard box. The handle is more tapered than the 40520 and is designed to be more ergonomic. It has a slightly different texture applied to the handle as well, but both are gritty and slip-resistant. The 40520 was designed for commercial kitchens and is NSF approved for food safety in commercial ktichens. The 6.8063.20 was designed for the home chef who does not need that certification on the knife. Please let me know if you have any other questions.Thanks,Tracey Hi. I'm from Victorinox Swiss Army. The blades are EXACTLY the same. The three differences are 1.) the packaging an 2.) the handle and 3.) The 40520 is NSF approved. The knife usually arrives in a red and white cardboard box. The handle is more tapered than the 40520 and is designed to be more ergonomic. It has a slightly different texture applied to the handle as well, but both are gritty and slip-resistant. The 40520 was designed for commercial kitchens and is NSF approved for food safety in commercial ktichens. The 6.8063.20 was designed for the home chef who does not need that... » Read More Hi. I'm from Victorinox Swiss Army. The blades are EXACTLY the same. The three differences are 1.) the packaging an 2.) the handle and 3.) The 40520 is NSF approved. The knife usually arrives in a red and white cardboard box. The handle is more tapered than the 40520 and is designed to be more ergonomic. It has a slightly different texture applied to the handle as well, but both are gritty and slip-resistant. The 40520 was designed for commercial kitchens and is NSF approved for food safety in commercial ktichens. The 6.8063.20 was designed for the home chef who does not need that certification on the knife. Please let me know if you have any other questions.Thanks,Tracey « Show Less
1441948
If it is Made in America, Yes. There could be a Sub Contractor who makes the same modle. If there is, then it should have the same Paton # on the Box. If it's American, It is good. I have Three of them and they are made well and very sharp. They work great. Good Luck, Ron
666014
OK. Heres the deal. I ordered my blade and it was perfect. Then I ordered a Gerber Auto. When I received it the tip was slightly ground incorrectly. I called the seller, and did some research. What I learned was that Gerber can be a little loose on their quality control. Out of every ten blades one will be off. Bottom line is that if your unhappy with what you paid for then I would either return it, or exchange it. Be very clear that the tip is slightly bent, and that you would like one that isn't. That way they won't send you another that is bent. If this is a private seller than he should know exactly what your talking about, even if he's playing a little dumb. Good Luck! OK. Heres the deal. I ordered my blade and it was perfect. Then I ordered a Gerber Auto. When I received it the tip was slightly ground incorrectly. I called the seller, and did some research. What I learned was that Gerber can be a little loose on their quality control. Out of every ten blades one will be off. Bottom line is that if your unhappy with what you paid for then I would either return it, or exchange it. Be very clear that the tip is slightly bent, and that you would like one that isn't. That way they won't send you another that is bent. If this is a private seller than he should... » Read More OK. Heres the deal. I ordered my blade and it was perfect. Then I ordered a Gerber Auto. When I received it the tip was slightly ground incorrectly. I called the seller, and did some research. What I learned was that Gerber can be a little loose on their quality control. Out of every ten blades one will be off. Bottom line is that if your unhappy with what you paid for then I would either return it, or exchange it. Be very clear that the tip is slightly bent, and that you would like one that isn't. That way they won't send you another that is bent. If this is a private seller than he should know exactly what your talking about, even if he's playing a little dumb. Good Luck! « Show Less
1195770
I looked at mine and everything matches. Iknow mine is genuine. The serrations on the top and bottom at the rear of the blade are different or nonexistent on fakes. 75 percent sure it is real.
634094
I really don't know, its not like aftermarket manufacturers have set rules they go by. But if you know a friend with a united cutlery Scabbard ask them if they'll let you try it? The web site for the Noble Collection should also have the swords dimension too. I really love mine from United cutlery, But its very sharp with a thin high carbon steel blade. The scabbard fits the blade very tight. don't think I would buy one until I knew my sting would fit! it is a very nice Scabbard tho, hope I've helped?
1474029
Shouldn't be a problem, there may be a defect in the receiving portion on the knife. I'd contact the manufacturer with the concern.
1976795
It doesn't appear so. The replacement blades look specific to the manufacturer
431148
No I can't. It is a stard blade for the exactly handle. Why ask for the thickness of the blade?