How does the 5-shelf and 4-shelf units compare in stability? Could one use these inside as well as outside for a display at an event?
387730
There's a big difference - the 4-shelf unit (model 01648501, without ventilated shelves) is rated for 50 lbs per shelf. The 5-shelf unit (model 01558501, with ventilated shelves) is rated for 150 lbs per shelf. So the shelves of the 5-shelf unit are supposedly 3x as strong as the shelves that come with the 4-shelf unit.Since these shelves are entirely made of plastic, they can be used outside without worry about getting wet - nothing to rust.
387731
They're pretty stable, the number of shelves shouldn't compromise it's stability I'd think. They would be good for outside use, depending on where it would be you may need to weigh it down at the base though.
387732
There's a big difference - the 4-shelf unit (model 01648501, without ventilated shelves) is rated for 50 lbs per shelf. The 5-shelf unit (model 01558501, with ventilated shelves) is rated for 150 lbs per shelf. So the shelves of the 5-shelf unit are supposedly 3x as strong as the shelves that come with the 4-shelf unit. Since these shelves are entirely made of plastic, they can be used outside without worry about getting wet - nothing to rust.
387733
I am using my shelves indoors right now, and while they are not exactly classy, they are very sturdy and hold a lot of thing as with no problems at all. They are an excellent product for the price. Hope this helps.
1799401
I don't know if it's "commercial" or not, but mine is completely full and I haven't had any problems with it. I think the above and below shelves help stabilize.
1186010
I am using the unit for books and I have ALOT of books on it. It is very stable. It does have hole to place screws in and anchor it to the wall. The screws do not come with the unit. I plan on getting the screws to make it even more secure. The predrilled holes are also not very noticeable. Overall, I really like the unit. You can get the unit a lot cheaper from IKEA thou. I got it from amazon because I do not live anywhere close to an ikea and it's cheaper through amazon( because shipping costs from ikea are crazy ).
683662
These shelves are very sturdy and well built. I have them in my pantry using all 5 shelves spaced from top to bottom and supporting a very heavy load of goods. If you only had 3 shelves and you spaced them one on very top, one toward the middle and one about a foot and a half from the bottom, I believe it would still be sturdy and not twist. Of course, the more shelves the better. I hope this helps.
590143
I use mine for media storage and educational manuals. I am impressed with the no sag issue. I have books of all sizes some stand up some don't in any shelving. This is a 10 mostly because of the no sagging in the middle.
1529700
My two lowest shelves are full of hardbound textbooks and binders full of papers. The next two hold normal sized hardbound books and the top shelf is full of CDs and DVDs. As long as you put the heaviest on the bottom, I don't think you will have any problems. The whole unit might be light when empty, but it can really hold a lot without sagging.
2271625
Stands are heavy duty. We have 6 workstations with a 24" and 22" monitors and never had any stability issues.
2203482
It's stable. Never had a problem at all, and it does look really nice, not cheap looking at all. I found out these are the same ones they have at Hobby Lobby.
1144365
I'm not exactly sure what you mean by stability but I have two side by side in a bottom (Floor level) cabinet with no problem. I slide the shelves in and out and they remain secure and serviceable
2196153
JT, man your guess is as good as mine. I compared the two from size of shelves, weight, and fabrications and nothing seemed to stand out. As far as I was concerned, I purchased the four tier because I needed the four shelves for extra space in my bathroom. So, I think it comes down to which one will fill your needs and space to the optimum benifit.
1350473
The base shelf and middle shelf on the larger half would be good for small appliance storage. They have a little extra support in them. However, all the shelves are quite sturdy and can easily hold about 25 or 30 lbs.
2018539
I have it on it's stand and I'm confident the stand will do what it's supposed to do. You have about 78lb spread across a width of 62 inches centered at the middle of the set so of course it will wobble if you push on it; I don't see that as a problem. What I'd be more concerned about is the display falling forward in an earthquake so I have installed restraining straps on the back tethered to the table it sits on. Relax it ain't gonna fall sideways. The only way it would not wobble is if you had two stands; one at each end.
1737490
The shelves are probably stong enough, but the unit as a whole isn't stable enough that I would trust putting a TV on it. It's fine for books or plants, but not something expensive and breakable like a TV.
137890
I would caution about overloading. Yes, it is sturdy, but that is greatly affected by the total weight you place on it. I have two of these. I believe if every shelf was fully loaded with books and someone gave it a good shove from the side, it would collapse sideways, tearing itself apart. You notice that illustrations show it empty or with the fabric drawers. the manufacturer intended it for medium to lightweight storage, not as a bookshelf. It might hold the weight well for a while, then fail when additional stress is added. This unit is made from wood particles pressed together with glue, then covered with a pretty coating. It does not have the strength of solid wood.
277099
I also made shelves, as I have small children and stands would be dangerous to both the children and my speakers/entertainment center. Many others I have spoken with have mentioned that they use speaker stands, but choose wisely as these speakers are big and heavy for "bookshelf" speakers.
472012
Yes..and will be probably be more stable. Just leave off 1 shelf and 4 of the 8 posts.
2091724
Based on my experience, it depends on how they're anchored. If they're screwed Into studs, their only limit is the strength of the glass shelving. I replaced the plastic expansion sleeves that were provided, they had a bit of wobble, with much stonger metal molly bolts, and now all 7 shelves are rock solid. I'm entrusting them with $2,000 worth of vibrating surround sound speakers.