Comment on "Swarming Ring Patterns in Bacterial Colonies Exposed to   Ultraviolet Radiation"
  Commenting on the paper "Swarming Ring Patterns in Bacterial Colonies Exposed to Ultraviolet Radiation" of A.M. Delprato et al., Phys. Rev. Lett 87, 158102 (2001) we point out that their observed ring pattern formation by colonies of soil bacteria Bacillus subtilis exposed to ultra violet (UV) radiation might be caused by the artificial confinement of motile bacteria evolved to live in a 3-dimensional environment to a 2-dimensional geometry. We propose that to investigate the reaction of Bacillus subtilis to UV radiation coming from above, a seminal experiment should have a 3-dimensional setup. 
Anke Ordemann and Frank Moss