The "red shelf" of the Hb line in the Seyfert 1 galaxies RXS J01177+3637   and HS 0328+05
  A few Seyfert 1s have a Hb profile with a red wing usually called the "red shelf". The most popular interpretation of this feature is that it is due to broad redshifted lines of Hb and [OIII]4959,5007; we have observed two Seyfert 1s displaying a "red shelf" and showed that in these two objects the main contributor is most probably the HeI 4922,5016 lines having the velocity and width of the broad Hb component. There is no evidence for the presence of a broad redshifted component of Hb or [OIII] in any of these two objects. 
P. Veron (OHP), A.C. Goncalves (ESO) and M.-P. Veron-Cetty (OHP)