High Resolution X-Ray Spectroscopic Constraints on Cooling Flow Models   of Clusters of Galaxies and Gaseous Haloes Around Elliptical Galaxies
  In many clusters of galaxies, the cooling time at the core of the intracluster medium is much less than the age of the system, suggesting that the the gas should continually lose energy by radiation. Simple thermodynamic arguments then require that the expected "cooling flow" should exhibit a specific spectroscopic signature, characterized by a differential emission measure distribution that is inversely proportional to the cooling function of the plasma. That prediction can be quantitatively tested for the first time by the Reflection Grating Spectrometer (RGS) experiment on XMM-Newton, which provides high resolution X-ray spectra, even for moderately extended sources like clusters. We present RGS data on 14 separate cooling flow clusters, sampling a very wide range in mass deposition rate. Surprisingly, in all cases we find a systematic deficit of low temperature emission relative to the predictions of the cooling flow models. However, we do see evidence for cooling flow gas at temperatures just below the cluster background temperature, $T_0$, roughly down to $T_0/2$. These results are difficult to reconcile with most of the possible explanations for the cooling flow problem that have been proposed to date. We also present RGS data on the massive elliptical galaxy NGC 4636. In this case, we detect evidence for resonance emission line scattering of high oscillator strength Fe L-shell emission lines within the gaseous halo of the galaxy. The detection of that effect leads to very tight constraints on physical conditions within the halo. However, here again, the expected signature of a cooling flow is not detected, perhaps suggesting some fundamental uncertainty in our understanding of radiative cooling in low density cosmic plasmas. 
S. M. Kahn, J. R. Peterson, F. B. S. Paerels, H. Xu, J. S. Kaastra, C.   Ferrigno, T. Tamura, J. A. M. Bleeker, J. G. Jernigan