Dynamics of the breakdown of granular clusters
  Recently van der Meer et al. studied the breakdown of a granular cluster (Phys. Rev. Lett. {\bf 88}, 174302 (2002)). We reexamine this problem using an urn model, which takes into account fluctuations and finite-size effects. General arguments are given for the absence of a continuous transition when the number of urns (compartments) is greater than two. Monte Carlo simulations show that the lifetime of a cluster $\tau$ diverges at the limits of stability as $\tau\sim N^{1/3}$, where $N$ is the number of balls. After the breakdown, depending on the dynamical rules of our urn model, either normal or anomalous diffusion of the cluster takes place. 
Francois Coppex, Michel Droz, and Adam Lipowski