When resetting the password from the console, reset the username to "admin".
When resetting the password from the console, reset the username to "admin".

Needless to say I waisted way more time than I should have finding this issue.

BlackstarGroup/pfsense,pfsense/pfsense,dennypage/pfsense,ptorsten/pfsense,brunostein/pfsense,BlackstarGroup/pfsense,phil-davis/pfsense,pfsense/pfsense,BlackstarGroup/pfsense,NewEraCracker/pfsense,jxmx/pfsense,ch1c4um/pfsense,ch1c4um/pfsense,phil-davis/pfsense,dennypage/pfsense,dennypage/pfsense,NewEraCracker/pfsense,NOYB/pfsense,ptorsten/pfsense,NOYB/pfsense,pfsense/pfsense,dennypage/pfsense,BlackstarGroup/pfsense,pfsense/pfsense,jxmx/pfsense,ch1c4um/pfsense,phil-davis/pfsense,brunostein/pfsense,NewEraCracker/pfsense,NewEraCracker/pfsense,NOYB/pfsense,ptorsten/pfsense,jxmx/pfsense,phil-davis/pfsense,brunostein/pfsense,ch1c4um/pfsense