Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Norwegian coast


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The eastern border of the North Sea partially runs along the south-western coast of Norway.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

This section of the coastline is characterized by fjords — narrow, long, deeply branched bays with steep edges that extend deeply into the land.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

On difficult dismembered shores, there are small, mostly rocky islands — the so-called skerries — every now and then.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

In the 1960s, geologists discovered rich oil and gas deposits on the shelf of the Norwegian and North Seas, and in 1971, equipment for the extraction of these minerals was installed on the seabed.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Norway, having become the owner of one of the most efficient hydrocarbon production complexes in the world, quickly became one of the world's ten largest energy suppliers [8].


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The coast of Denmark


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

To the south of Norway, beyond the Skagerrak Strait, the eastern part of the North Sea is bounded by the Danish peninsula of Jutland, on the western shores of which endless dunes predominate, often cut by bays or small lakes.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

To the south of the city of Esberg, a chain of North Frisian Islands stretches along the coast, which are separated from the mainland by wide watts - flooded areas at high tide.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Denmark's economy is closely connected to the sea; first of all, it is traditional fishing, which was recently supplemented by the extraction and processing of oil and gas found on the shelf.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Flora and fauna


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The Scottish coast is famous for its numerous colonies of northern gannets — snow-white seabirds with black flight feathers.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Economic importance


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Fisheries


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

In summer and autumn, fishing season begins in the North Sea.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The North Sea has significant fish reserves.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Cod, Atlantic herring, shrimp, halibut and other fish species are caught in the sea.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The North Sea is home to the famous Dogger Bank, one of the largest fishing areas in the world and Europe for centuries.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

It is quite easy to catch fish on the shallows, and there are so many fishermen that at times they literally devastate the sea; therefore, some States from time to time impose a ban on further fishing some species.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Sea routes and ports


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The North Sea is of great transport importance.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

It is here that the main crossroads of the world's sea roads are located, the main routes of communication between Europe and other continents run, and the ports of the coast handle more than 20% of the total sea of the planet's cargo traffic.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Numerous ferry lines run across the North Sea between Norway, Denmark, Great Britain, the Faroe Islands, Iceland, the Netherlands, and Belgium.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

In addition, the sea is used for both commercial and passenger coastal navigation.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The North Sea is home to the largest seaports in the world - Amsterdam and Rotterdam in Holland, Antwerp in Belgium, Hamburg, Bremen and Wilhelmshaven in Germany, London, Hull and Newcastle-upon-Tyne - in Great Britain, Oslo and Bergen are in Norway.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Offshore oil and gas fields


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The North Sea, which is still one of the most important sources of energy resources for Norway, as well as Great Britain, the Netherlands and a number of other countries of the European Union, is one of the most important in the world oil and gas bearing areas.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The most favorable conditions for the formation of offshore oil and gas fields are in shallow water, at the initial stage of sedimentary formation (the so-called sedimentation process).


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

This is exactly the place the North Sea turned out to be, almost the entire bottom of which is a number of huge gas-oil provinces.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

150 million years ago, the percentage of oxygen in the waters of this shallow reservoir was much lower than today, and this slowed down the decomposition of actively accumulated organic substances.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

At appropriate temperature, pressure, as well as due to the work of bacteria, organic matter gradually transformed into hydrocarbon deposits.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Active searches for offshore oil and natural gas fields began on the North Sea shelf almost immediately after the Second World War (in the 50s of the XX century) [9], and the first encouraging results were obtained in the late 1960s.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Since 1971, the exploitation of explored fields began, the first and richest of which was the Norwegian gas field Ecofisk, from where six years later the “blue fuel” through the gas pipeline with a length of 442 km, began to enter the German city of Emden.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Soon, the Norwegians explored several more large deposits - Frigg, Statfjord, Heimdall, Ozeberg, Gullfax (they have been developed since the 1970-80s), and then Troll, the largest in the North Sea (it is located 60 km from the coast).


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Raw gas flows ashore from drilling platforms, where it is purified and supplied to Belgium and Germany via a pipeline of 1,100 km long.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

By refusing to process gas directly at the field, specialists in the gas industry not only increased daily production to 100 million m³, but also switched the operation of the platform to automatic mode, driving it from the shore.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Norwegian gas is supplied to Germany, Belgium, Great Britain and France via two pipelines, of which the eastern one goes to Germany via three gas pipelines (Norpipe, Europipe and Europipe III), and the western branch supplies gas to Belgium (Zepype) and France (Franpipe); a gas pipeline has been built to the British Isles (Westerled).


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The total capacity of the entire system is more than 286 million m³ per day [10].


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Several oil and gas fields have also been discovered off the coast of Scotland, the first of which, Fortis, is located 180 km offshore; today, through a pipeline laid under the sea, oil from this the field enters Aberdeen, which has become the largest oil refining center on the shores of the North Sea.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The characteristic silhouettes of oil platforms can now be found on the high seas, ranging from Lehman Bank, located at the latitude of Bacton in the southern part of the North Sea, to the northernmost regions — such as the oil - bearing Beryl province at the latitude of Orkney.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The entire North Sea shelf is divided between Great Britain, Norway, Denmark, Germany and Holland into economic zones of operation.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The largest hydrocarbon deposits belong to Great Britain and Norway: each year both countries produce at least 100 million tons of oil [11] [12].


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The degree of technical complexity of production also depends on the depth of oil and gas, as well as natural conditions (for example, the development of the British Lehman Bank field is carried out at a depth of 30 m, Fortis - 115 m, Beryl — 125 m, and Norwegian Ekofisk — at a depth of 70 m), although almost 90% of oil from offshore fields is extracted from depths not exceeding 60 m. From a technical point of view, the most difficult section of the bottom is located between the Norwegian Ekofisk field and the coast of this country.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Large-diameter pipes are laid along the seabed to the richest oil and gas fields; some pipelines reach several hundred kilometers in length.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Depending on the topography of the bottom and sea currents, the pipelines are attached to the bottom by means of rock or concrete blocks resting on concrete supports.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

But even in these cases, there is a risk of damage to the pipeline by ship anchors or fishing gear, as well as bottom sediments moving during storms; a greater threat to the environment also represents corrosion of pipes.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

To protect such an underwater structure, the bottom along the pipeline is lined with special mats - they are also called “underwater lawns”.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Ecology


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

The waters of bays and fjords react painfully even to minor pollution from municipal, industrial or agricultural waste; for the ecological balance of marginal seas — for example, Baltic, Mediterranean or North — this danger is also quite high.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

By becoming part of the food chains of plants and animals, pollution causes their death or gradual degeneration.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

As a result of the washing off of agricultural fertilizers designed to increase yields into the sea, a mass of the smallest algae — phytoplankton — the first food link — is carried out from the Baltic Sea into the North Sea chains.


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Notes


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Literature


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

References


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

CS1 maint: BOT: original-url status unknown (link)


Question: How old is the North Sea?

North Sea

Category:Atlantic Ocean Seas


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Persecution based on religious beliefs during the military conflict in eastern Ukraine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

April 2015


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleagues, please give an answer about the possibility of using the publication as an AI:.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The report is published on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom and on the websites of organizations: en:International Partnership for Human Rights — and the Center for Hromadyanka Freedoms —.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The publication is referred to three times by a fairly high-quality source — the scientific journal “Religiina Svoboda”, and many other scientific publications.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is also mentioned by human rights organizations, for example.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I have not met any contradictions on the fact with other sources (and no one voiced, for example, uch. Tempus), the question is to challenge on a formal basis (authority of the publication).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash 09:36, January 21, 2019 (UTC) UPD. —Shamash (obs.) 13:19, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for intermediaries) A discussion of the “quality” of this source (the authors of which uncritically refer to all the garbage they found on the Internet) was, in particular, here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The publication itself on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom does not say anything, since the imprint clearly states that this is the author's development of certain little-known people who clearly gave understand that everything written is only their subjective opinion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The fact that, as many as 3 times, someone just put a footnote there again does not mean the quality of the source, because people refer to a lot of things in research, including Mein Kampf, which in itself does not say about the unconditional authority of a particular source.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The mention of a dwarf human rights organization on the website does not even deserve attention and discussion at all.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 01:41, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. The logical connection in the statement “The publication itself on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom does not say anything, since the imprint clearly states” has been broken.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The publication on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom characterizes the quality of the material.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2. The scientific journal retells the facts, referring to the report, and does not describe the report itself or the opinion of its authors.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, this proves the quality of the source in the accuracy of conveying the facts, and the method of unfair reasoning of the Reductio ad Hitlerum comment above does not apply to the issue under discussion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3. I cited a reference to one of the human rights organizations mentioning the report just as an example.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There are a lot of links to this report, and I can easily cite more.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for the organization whose official website is humanrights.org.ua, it is a fairly high-quality source in its class, which, in turn, is referred to by scientific publications (I point out two links, but there are much more citations).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

4. Yes, I saw the comment “The opinions expressed in this document are purely copyright and cannot be perceived as reflecting the official position of the International Partnership on


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Human Rights (IPHR), the Civic Solidarity Platform (CBC), the Center for Civil Liberties (CBC) or the Open Society Institute”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus either did not read it carefully or did not understand it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is a distance between this opinion and the presentation of the facts provided for by this kind of disclaimer.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The staff of related organizations were engaged in the development, editing and coordination of the report, as described on the second page of the report (Development, Editing and Coordination: TFG: Alexandra Novichkova, Maria Tomak; IPHR: Svetlana Valko, Victoria Cooper).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The report itself is published on the official websites of the relevant organizations: the IPHR — and the CSG —.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash 08:30, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. “The publication on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom characterizes the quality of the material. ” — Well, let me be clearer: posting this brochure in the database on the website of the Institute for Religious Freedom does not affect its context in any way, since its direct authors are quite certain people (Alexandra Novichkova, Maria Tomak, Svetlana Valko, Victoria Cooper) who are not employees of this organization.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2. “A scientific journal retells facts referring to the report, and does not describe the report itself or the opinion of its authors.” — It depends on what we are talking about, because no one has canceled contextual dependence.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For example, there are no references to the murder of Pentecostals in Slavyansk and the RPA.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3. “scientific publications refer (I point out two references, but there are much more citations)” — at least you check what the authors refer to.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A simple check (,) shows that both authors refer to reprints.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

4. “Employees of related organizations were exactly what they were engaged in the development, editing and coordination of the report” — But they do not pull on VP:EXPERT, because they are no one to call them.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

4.1 “The report itself is published on the official websites of the relevant organizations” — To put it simply, this only means that a certain Vasya programmer uploaded this publication to their database.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But this download does not give a drop of authority.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 10:05, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I don't really understand why you're doing this.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your position is frankly losing, and persistently defending it only characterizes the integrity of your arguments in this and similar discussions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash (obs.) 11:28, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I will say briefly: VP:NEFORUM and VP:NON-TRIBUNE.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 11:34, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I updated the text of the request, added citations of the report by scientific publications and other information.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash (obs.) 13:22, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“and many other scientific publications.” — VP:NEVERBLJ.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In general, everything is past the cash register.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Neither about the RPA, nor about the victims of the tragedy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 14:34, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You did not heed my advice to avoid allegations that may be considered unfair: your statements are irrelevant to the issue originally raised.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your last remark is completely a substitute for the thesis.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash 15:10, January 22, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Luka (Kovalenko)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Movses's colleague, of course, comes from Zaporozhye, and he knows better from the mountain from Kiev what was there and how it was in Zaporozhye.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But it seems to me that in an article about a contemporary such publications as Zaporozka Sich, 061.ua, Establishment, Depo, Peter and Mazepa do not and should not have a place.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Daphne mesereum 15:37, December 13, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Daphne mesereum, do you know anything about these sources or did you just not like them?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Have you verified the facts presented in the article and confirmed by these sources with the help of other sources?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Did you try to resolve your claims on the article's talk page before submitting it to the resellers for review?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Movses (obs.) 16:00, December 13, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I know one thing — VP:SOVR: “This article tells about a living person and therefore must comply with the rule on biographies of contemporaries. Strictly and carefully assess the authority of the sources used, do not refer to the tabloid press. If you are related to the person described in the article and need help changing it, please refer to the appropriate forum. Controversial statements about the person being described that are not supported or poorly supported by sources should be removed immediately from the article and from the talk page, especially if they may be defamatory. If they are added repeatedly or you see other problems with the article, please let other members know.” The “facts” that you Movses so zealously advocate must be corroborated by top-notch, authoritative sources.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Daphne mesereum 16:30, December 13, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Intermediaries, Movses began to demolish requests for authority of sources in the article and removed the appeal to it on the article's discussion page (quoted from the VP:SOVR rule).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Daphne mesereum 19:48, December 13, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The life of the archbishop is associated with luxury” with reference to, or unacceptable.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no such explicit statement in the text, the sources themselves are dubious (not to mention that a watch for $1,200 is as luxury as an average laptop that costs the same).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Or “Luke supports the Orthodox public organization Radomir, which provides, among other things, security services.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, it does, so what?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot 19:34, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please check the authority of sources and the correctness of the interpretation of information from sources


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please check the sources in the article Neumyvakin, Ivan Pavlovich.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Most of the links are media and samizdat.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For example, a reference to a doctoral dissertation leads to a book by Neumyvakin himself.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In my opinion, there are no independent sources at all.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Now the article is an example in VP:MAGIC.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

can be used.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Zdravamir 14:34, December 9, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is necessary to clean most of the sources there, these are primary sources of incomprehensible authority.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot (obs.) 17:52, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The author does not allow making edits, refuses to provide other sources, removes templates {unauthoritative sources} {no source}.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Everything has come to the point of absurdity.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Zdravamir 08:45, December 23, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The article is at a distance for a complex discussion of the importance of a person as a scientist.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The article has been repeatedly deleted and restored.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I think that the decision of intermediaries here will have to be postponed until the result of the CU is summed up by an experienced administrator.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I will not sum up the results there, because


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I might be letting him down here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If the article is eventually abandoned, by that time the sources in it may change more than once, and then they will need to be re-evaluated.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If it is removed by insignificance, what is the point of evaluating sources?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, if the confirmation of Neumyvakin's significance depends on the assessment of the source, please name a specific source.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega 12:14, January 30, 2019 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please check for authoritativeness


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dear colleagues!


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please check the authority of the following sources for the possibility of writing an article on the theosophical term:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

the works of authors P.F.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Belikova (works “Roerich. The Experience of Spiritual Biography”, “Nikolai Konstantinovich Roerich. Sign of the Era”),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

book by L.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shaposhnikova (“The Commands of the Cosmos”),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

books by S.R.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ableeva (“Mahatmas and Ethical Gnosis. Formation of the ideological and philosophical tradition of anthropocosmism (theosophy is a living ethics)”, “Literary and philosophical sources of the theosophical teaching of the temple”),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

works by N.E.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kovaleva (“The Way to Shambhala”, “Avatars of Shambhala” and others),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

SV


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Pakhomova (“Preface to: Karl Eckartshausen. Keys to the Mysteries of Nature”),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

G.Bibikova (I am Shaposhnikov), Marcus Osterrieder (From Synarchy to Shambhala),


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

S.YU.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kolchigin (“Philosophy of the Future”, “The Future as a Spiritual and Creative Task”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thanks!


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tatyana Mach (obs.) 16:14, November 7, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Apparently, these are representatives of theosophy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A-priori, they can be used as AI, but only to describe how the term is understood by the representatives of theosophy themselves, and only if these authors are major representatives of the direction ( the importance of the commentator must be proved to you).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For an accurate answer, you need a specific example of the term and its explanatory text.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot 20:02, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Only Pakhomov (met a familiar surname) is still not a theosopher, but according to Eastern religions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin (obs.) 22:16, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Rafinin's Wrongful Adjustment of an Article of Buddhism to Mahayana School


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

All references and revisions of Buddhism that do not satisfy the Rafinin participant's vision of his position regarding the Theravada School are removed by him.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, even when referring to authoritative sources, for example, the following edit was recently added to the article Buddhism:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Theravada, sthaviravada (pali: theravāda, skt. Theravāda IAST;, sthāviravāda IAST “teaching of the elders” /"teaching of the oldest” or “teaching of the elders”) is the oldest surviving school of Buddhism, one of the eighteen early Buddhist schools.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Lysenko V. G. Theravada//New Philosophical Encyclopedia/V. S. Stepin et al. — 2nd ed. — M.: Thought, 2010. — ISBN 978-5-244-01115-9.) This school is quite conservative, and is generally closer to early Buddhism than other existing Buddhist traditions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Gethin, Rupert. The Foundations of Buddhism, p1. Oxford University Press, 1998.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As you can see, there are authoritative sources, but the participant deleted this paragraph along with authoritative sources.43.250.242.141 07:12, August 20, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

correct, it removed the duplicate text.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Disclose the etymology of the word “sthaviravada” in an article devoted to this concept.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot 19:11, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please rate the source “Falun Gong Hate Cult”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dear mediators, please evaluate the source of “Falun Gong — a Cult of Hatred”, authors: Kuznetsov M.N.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, Ponkin I.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, originator: T.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kvitkovskaya.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Quote from the source:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Analysis of printed and electronic (on the Internet) materials publicly and openly distributed by the Falun Gong religious association among an unlimited number of people, the nature of attitudes, views, relationships and beliefs formed among the followers of this religious association gives grounds to assess the doctrine of the Falun Gong association as extremist and antisocial, posing a danger to the individual , society and the State that violates human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The title of the collection “Falun Gong - a Cult of Hate” indicates the lack of a neutral academic approach to the subject under study.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This name in itself directly discriminates against a group of Falun Gong adherents, inciting hostility and hatred against them.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The content of the text of the collection is also far from neutrality and, in fact, is a subjective personal assessment of the main ideas set out in the materials of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would like to note that the authors Ponkin and Kuznetsov are doctors of law.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, when evaluating Falun Gong, they have the right to touch only on issues within their competence.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The statement that “the doctrine of the Falun Gong association is “extremist and antisocial” should be supported by research by authoritative religious scholars, psychologists, sinologists, linguists, etc.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As you can imagine, a legal assessment alone is not enough to comprehensively describe a phenomenon like Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I also think that referring to this source in the Falun Gong article is a violation of VP:NTZ and VP:EXPERT, we ask the mediators to evaluate this source and summarize this discussion - Umweiss (obs.) 01:13, July 16, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Preliminary result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Russian Doctors of Law M. N. Kuznetsov and I. IN. Ponkin in the above quote really go beyond their legal competence and give psychological and sociological assessments of the teachings of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In Wikipedia articles on controversial and conflict issues, in order to maintain a neutral point of view, we place the views of both parties to the conflict, as well as outside experts in the field.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

M. N. Kuznetsov and I. IN. Ponkin is not authorized to represent any of the parties to the conflict — neither Falun Gong nor the Chinese authorities.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If their legal specialization is Chinese law, they could analyze the legality of persecuting Falun Gong supporters under Chinese law, but in this work they clearly doing the wrong thing.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This evaluation quote is also not suitable because it is completely vague in meaning.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What do the authors see as the danger of Falun Gong, what specific negative consequences for the individual, society and the state has the spread of the Falun Gong movement led to, and what can it lead to?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What is a “creed that violates human rights”?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is complete nonsense from a legal point of view.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The subject of a human rights violation may be another person, a group of people, an organization or a state.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Those specific figures who, by their actions, violated the rights and freedoms of others.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A creed, religion, ideology, faith or idea cannot act as violators of human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If these lawyers mean the violation of human rights by Falun Gong supporters, then it is not the materials they distribute that should be analyzed, but their specific cases.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Which Falun Gong supporters whose rights were violated, and how?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, Falun Gong, a Cult of Hatred cannot be used either as a source of facts for the article (this collection is too far from neutrality and impartiality), nor as a source of positions of those involved parties (authors are not and are not authorized to represent them), nor as opinions/assessments/criticisms of outside experts (authors go beyond their legal competence).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This quote should definitely be removed, others from the same source should be considered separately and just as strictly.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega (obs.) 14:11, October 28, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander, did you read the whole discussion carefully or just ran diagonally?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 16:00, October 28, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I've read the discussion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The background summed up this particular quote; it may be possible to use the same source in a different way, as I noted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Taken out of its original context and placed on Wikipedia, this quote is full of vague expressions that Wikipedia should avoid.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The main reason why such a quote should not be on Wikipedia is not so much the non-neutrality of the authors, but the uncertainty of the expressions in the quote.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If the same source is not quoted, but retold in your own words, for example, like this: “According to M. N. Kuznetsova and I. IN. Ponkin, spreading the Falun Gong doctrine and following this doctrine can lead to extremist activity and other violations of Russian legislation” — something else is possible.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is simply no general definition of the concept of “extremism”; the definition of extremism in Russian legislation, although broadly, is still not enough to talk about “extremist doctrine”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the Russian Federation, extremist can be either specific acts of people, groups or organizations (extremist activity), or specific information materials that exist in an objective form and are included in Federal List of Extremist Materials.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of all Falun Gong publications, as far as I remember, only two are included in it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If Kuznetsova and Ponkin believe that the rest of Falun Gong's materials deserve to be there, then this should be written about it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And “extremist creed that violates human rights” is, no matter how you look at it, it turns out to be a completely vague expression.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega (obs.) 13:05, October 30, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Oh, well, that's another conversation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is only necessary to take into account that we are not talking about 2018, but about 2006, when there was no mention of the FSEM yet.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, the opinion expressed in the quoted text should be understood with an adjustment precisely for the middle of the “2000s”, and not for the outcome of the “tenths”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 15:36, October 30, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleague, I am afraid that the position “we place the points of view of both sides of the conflict, as well as outside experts in this field.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

M. N. Kuznetsov and I. IN. Ponkin are not authorized to represent any of the parties to the conflict — neither Falun Gong nor the Chinese authorities” will be difficult to agree with the AK:350 decision: “We should avoid as much as possible the use, let alone direct quoting sources, on the one hand, directly related to the Falun Gong religious movement, and on the other hand, with the authorities of the People's Republic of China.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The use of such sources is possible only as a last resort to demonstrate how these opposing sides characterize their own behavior or the actions of the opposite sides.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

- “cannot be used either as a source of facts for an article” - again, “However, the fact that an individual or group of individuals holds this opinion is a fact that can be published in Wikipedia (provided that this fact is verified, that is, if a reliable source is provided, from which it follows that the person or group really holds this opinion, and of its sufficient significance”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(WP:AI).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Let me remind you that Ponkin's quote in the article hangs for a reason, but as a secondary quote from k.f.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Mr. Petruni, in a very academic publication - this, in my opinion, is a reliable source and significance.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

- “What do the authors see as the danger of Falun Gong, what specific negative consequences for the individual, society and the state has the spread of the Falun Gong movement led to, and what can it lead to?” - I think to answer these questions it is worth reading the entire source, not just the last paragraph quoted from the conclusions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

- “authors go beyond their legal competence” - I cannot agree, extremism and violations of rights are quite a legal category, even when it comes to extremism of religious teaching/ organizations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Where it is necessary to make assessments outside the competence, the authors directly write that they use the signs and assessments of religious psychologists and other specialists


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(p. 6).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Another thing is that they should put detailed links here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

- In general, I think that in the results we should refrain from wording like “complete nonsense”, and statements about the bias and bias of the source should be argued in detail.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Especially when this is a trial result for an intermediary.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khroniker


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:54, October 28, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“extremism and violations of rights are quite a legal category” — a category is one thing, but assessments are another.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Expertise on extremism is not usually carried out by lawyers at all:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Paragraph 23 of Resolution No. 11 of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated June 28, 2011 “On Judicial Practice in Criminal Cases on Crimes of an Extremist Nature” states that in order to determine the target the direction of information materials may be assigned to the production of linguistic expertise.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, the main type of examinations carried out in the category of cases under consideration is forensic linguistic examination.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the knowledge of an expert linguist is not always sufficient to establish the circumstances that are important for the consideration and resolution of the case.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As a result, comprehensive examinations are often appointed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is also reflected in this resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which draws attention to the fact that specialists in the relevant field of knowledge can also be involved in the examination


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(psychologists, historians, religious scholars, anthropologists, philosophers, political scientists, etc.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Comprehensive expertise involves the involvement of persons with special knowledge in various expert specialties.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Most often, psychologists and/or religious scholars are included in the commission.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Podkatilina M. L.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Candidate of Legal Sciences, Lecturer, Department of Forensic Expertise, O.E.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kutafin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(MSAL))


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

//Bulletin of the University named after O.E.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kutafin, 2014).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

17:05, October 28, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The fact of the matter is that “dated 28.06.2011”, while the text under discussion was written much earlier


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, in this case, the law does not have retroactive effect.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, let us pay attention to the context: 23.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If necessary, a linguistic examination may be scheduled to determine the target orientation of information materials.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition to linguists, specialists in the relevant field of knowledge may also be involved in the examination


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In this case, a comprehensive examination is appointed. Thus, the question of what “is not carried out by lawyers at all” is open.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, the detention was carried out privately


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as in the case of Lunkin and Faktorovich and the review of Gladys), and not by appointment by the court.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, in the last two cases, not just the private opinion of people who wanted to sit down at their leisure and express their point of view about Falun Gong was presented, but texts that directly carry the seal “Whoever pays orders music”, which was shown with the facts in hand.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 01:40, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I do not understand, do you have at least one review source that directly indicates that conducting such forensic examinations for lawyers, after 2011 or before, is a common thing in which they can be involved in court?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And privately, anyone can conduct any examination in any field, which does not automatically make this person an expert in this field, and the examination is good and worthy attention.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For example, here is another source, in which I also do not see lawyers: “Examination of extremist materials, taking into account the specifics and volume of the objects presented


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(media)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

is complex and provides for the participation of experts from various specialties in its production: linguists, psychologists, videophonographers


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in the study of video and sound recordings), specialists in the field of computer technology


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(when disseminating material via the Internet).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If necessary, representatives of other areas of special knowledge — religious scholars, ethnologists, historians, sociologists, political scientists, etc., can be involved in conducting the most complex complex examinations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Lesnikova P. G., Deputy Head of the Federal Budgetary Institution Privolzhsky RTSSE of the Ministry of Justice of Russia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

//Theory and practice of forensic examination, No. 2


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

03:36, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“I don't understand, do you have at least one review source that explicitly indicates that conducting such forensic examinations for lawyers, after 2011 or before, is a common thing in which they can be involved in court?” — Do you have one that shows that lawyers


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(including those with specialization in legal religious studies)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

can't do this a priori?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“And privately, anyone can conduct any examination in any field, which does not automatically make this person an expert in this field, but the examination is good and worthy attention.” — Not necessary.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Especially when it comes not to “any person” or “expertise in any field”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“For example, here is another source in which I do not see lawyers either” — And now, based on their sources provided by you, show me where the resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court says at least a word about videophonographers and “computer technology specialists”?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, since this area is close to me, I do not see something in the same list of cultural scientists, although, well known to you, a candidate of cultural studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(specialty historical and cultural studies)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

N. IN. Shaburov, who initially specializes in Gnosticism, calmly writes an examination on extremism.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 06:46, 29 October 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shaburov, like Khoruzhy, Doctor of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, did a lot to be called a religious scholar at the AI, if only because he is the director of the Educational and Research Center for the Study of Religions of the Russian State University for the Humanities.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is not clear to me which institute religious centers are Kuznetsov and Ponkin, as well as which AI call them religious scholars.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

11:41, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is nothing more than an administrative position, which in itself does not mean that a person “did a lot of things”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The same Khoruzhiy is the director of which religious studies center is?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 12:22, 29 October 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khoruzhiy, as a professor of philosophy at the Institute of Philosophy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, is more in philosophy, so he is not the director of the religious studies center,


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can have any opinion on the position, but religious specialists do not have such a dismissive attitude towards the position, this is one of the criteria: “The fourth question is about the criteria for professional affiliation of religious scholars.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As they say, there is an opinion


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(and the author tends to share it mainly), that a researcher can be fully called a religious scholar, in total: 1)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

who received a special religious education in a specialized educational institution; 2)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

working in a scientific or educational institution where research is conducted


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(and/or teaching)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

activities in religious studies, in the official status associated with this activity; 3)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

personally engaged in scientific work “in the specialty”, confirmed by relevant speeches, publications and other accepted results, including possession of academic degrees and titles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the “Russian case”, however, it is difficult for many to respond to these signs in full impeccably.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Those who entered the path of religious studies before the turn of the 1980s and 1990s have, at best, specialized training in the patterns of Soviet “religious studies” — scientific atheism, obtained within the framework of more broad specialties


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in history, or in philosophy, which was taught as Marxist-Leninist).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Along with these specialists, scientists of other humanitarian specialties conducted scientific study of various aspects of religion


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ethics, aesthetics, theory and history of culture, art history, philology, etc.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The employment of most of them before and now is most often not associated with institutions where they “know” religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Nevertheless, in this environment there were and are the deepest experts in the subject under study.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Actually, vocational education in Russia in the specialty or direction of “Religious Studies” began only in the mid-1990s.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Smirnov M. //III International Internet Conference on Religious Studies: Religion and Everyday Life).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:48, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It can be seen from the text that the key here is “in aggregate”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, Shaburov immediately disappears from the first point.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, “etc.” leaves the issue open with lawyers, especially within the framework of legal religious studies, because what Kuznetsov and Ponkin do is exactly what Kuznetsov and Ponkin are doing.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As well as the fact that “the employment of most of them before and now is most often not associated with institutions where they are “in charge” of religious studies.” Tempus/obs 13:36, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It seems that we have read different texts, because culturologists were especially noted in my version of the text.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In any case, if this issue is so important to you, could you discuss it in another topic dedicated to Shaburov?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

13:45, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“It seems that we have read different texts, because culturologists were especially noted in my version of the text.” — It is quite possible, because Smirnov also writes the following:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(second)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

there will be a question about the composition of religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The desire for a legitimate stay in the structure of socio-humanitarian knowledge requires the fixation of stable characteristics that distinguish religious studies as something relatively independent among others components of this knowledge.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is followed by some variations that have a debatable tone: 1)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

or to declare religious studies a holistic complex science


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(with its own theoretical concepts and categories, methods and methods, history); 2)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

or see it as an interdisciplinary integration of knowledge about religion obtained from all sciences that study religion in one way or another


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(i.e. perceive as a kind of “academic field”); 3)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

or to construct a “corporate” model of religious studies on the basis of special disciplines


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(they are also the “directions” of religious studies — history of religions, philosophy of religion, phenomenology of religion, psychology of religion, sociology of religion, anthropology of religion, comparative religious studies, political science religions, geography of religions, cognitive religious studies, etc.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the latter case, depending on the “direction” chosen as the leading one, different models of religious studies are formed for it with appropriate modifications of the scientific apparatus


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for criticism, reflections and suggestions in this regard, see: Kostylev. 2006, Pismanik. 2006).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It should be noted that preferences can be influenced not only by the education and scientific inclination of the researcher, but also by his “departmental” affiliation, nature of activity


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(scientific, teaching), status, etc.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

everyday factors.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On this path, there are, for example, constructs such as “judicial religious studies”, “human rights religious studies”, “military religious studies”, etc. “In any case, if this issue is so important to you, could you discuss it in another topic dedicated to Shaburov?” — No question, but it was you who supported the conversation about Shaburov, while I pointed out Shaburov only as an example of the fact that if in some open list, as in the case of the resolution The Plenum of the Supreme Court does not directly list the specialty, then statements like “Expertise on extremism is not usually carried out by lawyers at all” and “directly indicating that such judicial expertise for lawyers, after 2011 or before, is a common thing in which they can be involved by the court” is quite lightweight, because cultural scientists with video phonographers and computer technologists are there are not directly mentioned.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

By the way, Falikov is also a teacher of foreign languages by education, and his candidate's thesis is written on general history, which did not prevent him from being an expert.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 14:16, 29 October 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“On this path, there are, for example, constructs such as “judicial religious studies”, “human rights religious studies”, “military religious studies”, etc.” — so what?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Any constructs can meet.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If a construct was created exclusively by lawyers who do not have a serious religious education or experience, then is it in demand in this form among recognized religious scholars or at least simply in court?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“In our opinion, there is no “judicial religious studies” as a scientific and educational discipline and cannot be


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in contrast to the religious expertise carried out by competent religious scholars appointed by the court), since the simple extension of a number of names of applied disciplines with the adjective “judicial” such as “forensic accounting” [i], “forensic gynecology”, “forensic obstetrics” [ii]... etc.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

is simply not in demand by the practice of modern Russian legal proceedings”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Davydov I. P., Candidate of Philosophical Sciences, Associate Professor of the Department of Philosophy of Religion and Religious Studies of the Faculty of Philosophy of the Lomonosov Moscow State University.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

15:16, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“so what? Any constructs can meet.” — And the fact that Davydov expressed his private opinion, like Smirnov above.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, the latter does not deny such constructs to exist.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“If a construct is created exclusively by lawyers who do not have a serious religious education or experience, then is it in demand in this form among recognized religious scholars or at least simply in court?” — At your leisure, read Tikhonravov, Pchelintsev and Pogasiy, who, along with Ponkin and Kuznetsov, are engaged in what can be designated as legal religious studies/judicial religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can argue as much as you like about the form, but the content will not disappear from this.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 15:49, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At your leisure, you can read about Tikhonravov and at the same time the opinion of the commentator “Anatoly Pogasy” in the above article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I will not say that this is 100% him, but it is quite possible, because he cooperates with Religiopolis.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In any case, I think he can figure out what he does without your help.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And legal religious studies can be adequate if religious scholars specialize in it, and no one argues with this.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:18, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“At your leisure, you can read about Tikhonravov and at the same time the opinion of the commentator Anatoly Pogasy in the above article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

” — I read and also advise you to carefully learn the article Repayment 2016 in your free time


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Pogasiy, A. Legal religious studies: current state and prospects. Religion and Law, 2016, no. 2, pp.34-36)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“In any case, I think he will figure out what he is doing without your help.” — Or rather, Ponkin and Kuznetsov without yours.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 16:26, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I have already read something else here, from Pchelintsev, whom you advise me: “We do not have certification of religious scholars in our country, an authoritative center for religious studies. There are not enough qualified personnel. Our law enforcement agencies do not always know where to go for expertise, and sometimes come to random people. In practice, there are cases when psychiatrists, pathologists, museum workers, primary school teachers, etc. carried out religious expertise, that is, people far from scientific religious studies. Even when an examination is carried out by a religious scholar, he must be a specialist in his field of religious studies. For example, an examination, for example, on Islam, should be carried out by an Islamic scholar, and not a Buddhologist or a specialist in Jewish studies. Sometimes the examination is assigned to random and biased people, the so-called sector experts. Their examinations are unscientific and are carried out from the standpoint of one confession.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:32, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“I will not say that this is 100% him, but it is quite possible, because he cooperates with Religiopolis.” — Yeah, probably because Sitnikov reprints for himself.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“I have already read something else here, from Pchelintsev, whom you advise me” — I advised you to read his thematic literature, and not lengthy reasoning in a single interview.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, he spoke about this just in the paragraph above: It is indicative that legal religious studies are successfully taught here - a new interdisciplinary direction in science and education that is worth at the intersection of jurisprudence and religious studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in 2014, the Department of Religious Studies opened a new master's program “Legal Religious Studies” - author's note).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I think this is a unique experience with a great future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At one time, I devoted more than one work to this topic, proving the importance and necessity of this discipline in the training of modern specialists.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, you have known both Pchelintsev and Lunkin who works for him for a long time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 16:40, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 16:26, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, when the Department of Religious Studies is engaged in this, of course, it will be good and important for training future religious scholars for forensic examinations, no one argues.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:51, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, this once again confirms that legal religious studies exist, as there are specialists who, as such, deal with it, and whose names I have listed above.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ponkin's scientific publications on legal and religious studies additionally confirm that he is really professionally engaged in it, as well as state-confessional relations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 17:05, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleague Rafinin, your position on this issue is well known, and I am not even going to waste your time trying to prove anything to you fruitless.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

However, Alexander summed up this result of the colleague precisely as a trial result for the mediator, and the mediator must at least have a common language with both sides of the stalled discussion, a clear logic of actions and some credit of trust from both of them.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It makes sense otherwise?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khroniker


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

09:22, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well known?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I did not participate in that discussion at all and decided to ask lawyers about review sources.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Because if they exist, my position, well known to you, will be adjusted, since the court has repeatedly considered those whom you consider to be experts in the relevant field of knowledge.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They don't exist, they don't.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for the common language, it is unlikely that with the position of “I am not even going to waste your time trying to prove anything to you” in relation to me, you can demand anything more from the mediator, reading the arguments of the parties.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I understand the logic of the result, the main argument is incompetence, while a credit of trust from a party that does not suit the result can hardly be expected.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

11:41, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dear colleagues, I would like to draw your attention to the fact that in this case the issue of expertise on extremism of religious organizations is very controversial


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(see,,).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, there can be no unambiguous conclusions on this topic.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And in disputable cases, according to the NTRP, all significant authoritative opinions are given.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the question here is whether this study can be considered a full-fledged examination of extremism or simply an author's assessment of a religious organization.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the second case, the status of this study is completely different.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is just a private opinion of a specialist or a layman.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

04:34, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yes, Ponkin's publication does not seem to be a forensic examination and does not pretend to be.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What is everyone arguing about in this case?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is it really unclear the difference between VP:EXPERT


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(including law)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and a forensic expert?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khroniker


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

09:22, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In my opinion, Alexander in vain undertook to sum up such a difficult result right away.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As a preliminary result, I do not see a full assessment of the authority, neutrality and significance of this source as primary or secondary, both in religious and legal topics.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And this is very important - this source is assessed as primary or secondary, and in relation to what topic it is considered.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Although I agree with some statements, in general, I think the result is not very detailed, and for this reason there will be complaints against it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The source analyzes both the doctrine and the actions of the organization.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

These are completely different topics.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the author's authority in these topics is completely different.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As a result, it is advisable to consider the arguments of both sides and point out their fairness or inapplicability in this situation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The conclusion “this collection is too far from neutrality and impartiality” should be based on AI, and there are no references to them in the end.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Question “What is a “creed that violates human rights”?” does not consider the understanding of this issue in other AIs, so evaluating this quote gives the impression of orissa.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would not take up such a predictor, and if I did, it would take me days, not hours.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there is no time for a detailed result, then this is often enough.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But in this case, there may be complaints and questions about the result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

22:48, October 28, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

From the fact that a person crossed the stream, it is difficult to know whether he will be able to cross the sea.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, I think that Alexander was right not afraid to take on such a difficult issue.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleague, I agree with you that more time is needed on this topic.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But it should be borne in mind that Alexander summed up the results within the time, which is still allocated not for full-fledged mediation, but so far only for an “interview”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Regards IRQ5


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:56, October 29, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

To the end


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to Ponkin's authority, there is already one result of the intermediary: Wikipedia:K_mediation/non-academicity/live_ethics/Archive #Статья Kuznetsova M.N.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and Ponkina I.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

which confirms the level of experts for these authors in the “declared field”, which also applies to the topic of religion in terms of meaning, except for legal issues.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, we have discussions on Ponkin's authority on Falun Gong, back in the past mediation


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(e.g.: On Arbitration Discussion: About Pnkv Participant's Activities in Falun Gong Article, search for “Ponkin”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

During the last mediation, Ponkin's credibility was not summed up, as the mediation was interrupted before the AI issue was discussed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I consider the question of Ponkin's authority in religious topics


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(and in particular at the intersection of religion and legal issues)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

quite complicated, it is necessary to take into account not only previous discussions and results, Ponkin has an impressive list of publications on both religious and legal topics


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and his publications are used as AI in Wikipedia articles, including under the pseudonym Igor Kulikov.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On the other hand, the list of criticisms against him is also impressive.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In my opinion, the result on this issue should answer the questions of Ponkin's authority both in religious studies and in legal


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(religious and legal)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

topic.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If we consider this source as samizdat, then according to VP:SAMIZDAT, such publications in some cases can be considered as AI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The issue of the neutrality of Ponkin's publications is also important, going beyond the result on this issue.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Since both Ponkin's dissertations


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Doctor of Law)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

are devoted to the issues of legal regulation of relations between the state and religious associations, the competence or authority of the author in this topic should be carefully considered.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is not the case when the result can be without detailed justification and references to sources supporting the conclusions of the author of the result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Given the complexity of the issues under consideration, the best option would be to sum up the outcome by more than one mediator.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In any case, this task for an inexperienced, novice intermediary can be quite difficult, and the result is not very high-quality and not indisputable


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(which does not give rise to objections or comments).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

11:32, November 2, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thank you for distinguishing between religious studies and legal


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(religious and legal)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

topics that some colleagues can not do, but “To the End” usually involves something more, at least some initial draft of the result that other mediators can discuss.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the argument “publications are used as AI in Wikipedia articles” is not very good because anything is used as AI in articles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For example, even the newspaper Zhizn.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

13:05, November 2, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In this case, “publications are used as AI in Wikipedia articles” is not an argument at all, but an indication of the relationship of the outcome of this discussion with other topics.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If Ponkin, according to the result, is not allowed as an author in such a topic, then this may lead to the removal of links to his publications in other articles, with reference to this result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And if the result limits its scope of competence or recognizes its non-neutrality, then this will also affect the subsequent results and actions of the participants.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In this case, the mediator's result, which is indicated in the link above, according to which Ponkin is an expert in this topic, remains valid.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If this total does not apply to this case, it is necessary to distinguish between these situations or point out that the previous total is incorrect.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Here I just pointed out some points related to summing up this result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And I do not offer my own version of the outcome due to the complexity of this issue.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This may be at the level of discussing Dvorkin's authority, on which there were many discussions before summing up the results of mediation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

13:15, November 2, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“If this total does not apply to this case, it is necessary to distinguish between these situations or point out that the previous total is incorrect.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I realized that the result was about this source: and the discussion was open from this source: “Falun Gong is a Cult of Hate: A Collection of Materials.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the source “Civil Law and Criminal Law Protection of Morality: Collection of Materials”, Ponkin conducts an analysis not alone, but in a company with psycholinguists Abramenkova V.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, Slobodchikov V.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And even in fact, the very name of the source indicates its legal orientation


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Civil and criminal law protection...).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That is, the participation of lawyer Ponkin in the work is quite justified.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But in Falun Gong, the Cult of Hate: A Collection of Materials, Ponkin conducts a psycholinguistic analysis together with Kuznetsov, while both are doctors of law and do not have the appropriate competence for such assessments of something, in this case Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Umweiss


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

00:39, November 5, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“But in Falun Gong, the Cult of Hate: A Collection of Materials, Ponkin conducts a psycholinguistic analysis together with Kuznetsov, while both are doctors of law and do not have the appropriate competencies for such assessments of something, in this case Falun Gong.” — VP:CIRCLE, as this has already been discussed in Discussion: Falun Gong #К removed the source “Falun Gong is a Cult of Hate”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would like to note separately that the work is called “Ponkin I.V. Conclusion dated August 21, 2006 on the content and orientation of the doctrine and activities of the Falun Gong religious association”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(followers of Li Hongzhi)”, and the subject of research is the following: The subject of this conclusion was the content and orientation of the doctrine and activities of a religious association” Falun Gong”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(a religious association of followers of Li Hongzhi).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Let us pay attention, for example, to this statement Given the inhumane and asocial nature of the doctrine and practice of the Falun Gong religious association, education authorities should pay special attention to the timely detection and prevention of the illegal invasion of this sect into state and municipal educational institutions.