Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, adherents are focused on concealing their religious affiliation when introduced into state or public structures: “When a wicked person asks you: “Are you engaged in Falun Gong?” , his question may not be answered or deviated from the answer” 133, as well as the general conclusion of the conclusion: Analysis of the doctrine of the Falun Gong religious association, the nature of attitudes, views, relations and beliefs formed among the followers of this religious association gives grounds to characterize the doctrine of the Falun Gong association as extremist and antisocial, posing a danger to individuals, society and the State that violates human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The actual or alleged persecution of Falun Gong believers in China cannot justify the illegal propaganda of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Distribution by the Falun Gong religious association of printed, audio and video materials, the content of which is aimed at inciting religious enmity and humiliating the human dignity of citizens on the basis of attitude to religion, is the basis for prohibiting the activities of this association.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

All this has nothing to do with any psycholinguistics, but it is directly related to legal religious studies, which has already been said enough.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, it is very suspicious that attempts by a number of participants to remove the text under discussion from the article released on September 21, 2018 by the Information Center are somehow very close in time Falun Dafa”, the so-called which contains the following text: However, law enforcement officers have become more frequent cases of unjustified accusations of Falun Gong followers of violating the Law “On freedom of conscience and religious associations.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They base their accusations on allegations by individuals who pursue their own goals to discredit Falun Dafa


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Appendix No. 7).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Let's go watch this app


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(first published on September 19, 2018 and amended on October 26, 2018)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and we see that it is outright attacks on both uncomfortable Ponkin and Kuznetsov personally who dared to criticize Falun Gong


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“The justification of these crimes by the authors of the Collection, whatever their motives, is a call to violence, and also contributes to the incitement of hatred and enmity”, “In the Collection, the authors purposefully insult labels Falun Gong practice


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for example, a “sect”, “cult”, etc.), are “convicted” of non-existent links with the Portal Credo website, are identified with the AUM Shinrikyo, David's Branch sects, and falsely accused of admissibility parties practicing Falun Gong manifestations of terrorism, massacres and other extremist actions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

”, “The goal of the authors is obvious: to create a negative, repulsive image of Russian citizens, followers of Falun Dafa, to compromise and discredit both the Falun Dafa movement itself and each of its adherents.”, “Another outright lie is the reason for the official statement of the founder of Falun Gong about his withdrawal from the National Research Society for the Study of Qigong named by the authors of the Collection.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

”, “In our opinion, the authors of the articles included in the Collection and its compiler pursued a certain goal: inciting hatred and xenophobia towards the system of improving Falun Gong, the basic principles which are universal values: truth, kindness, patience.”), and the ill-fated collection


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“This avalanche of lies from the first lines of the Collection deliberately attacks the reader to turn him against Falun Gong.”, “For the offensive purpose of putting defamatory labels in the text of the Collection, simple tricks.”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

By the way, this app has some very funny things.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For example: The Collection constantly arbitrarily uses the term “sect” in relation to Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

However, the Center for the Study of Problems of Religion and Society of the IE RAS Guild of Experts on Religion and Law Moscow on January 9, 2017, in its document “RELIGIOUS STUDIES”, warns against the arbitrary use of this term: “... the use of the concept of “sect” together with unreliable facts, humiliating any religious association or movement, creating an image of an anti - social, criminal organization, makes value judgments accusatory.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In practice, derogatory statements lead to provocations, to actions that sow interreligious hatred...” First, the anonymous authors of this text made Frankenstein, combining completely different ones into one two completely different organizations — Center for the Study of Problems of Religion and Society of the Institute of Europe of the Russian Academy of Sciences and the Guild of Experts on Religion and Law non-profit partnership


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“Legal address: 119180, Moscow, Polyanka B.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, 7/10 p.3, room IX; room 20; Founders


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Lunkin Roman Nikolaevich 12.07.2011, TIN 770703941090 Zagrebina Inna Vladimirovna 12.07.2011, TIN 613702674182” —; “Supervisor Lunkin Roman Nikolaevich, President Zagrebina Inna Vladimirovna, chairman board” —), although it was most likely supposed to be about R. N. Lunkin, who is associated with the data organization.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, a simple check of the source of this quote leads us to the website of the Slavic Right Center and the so-called online publication “Religion and Law”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Chief Editor Lunkin)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

the so-called “An expert study on the use of the concepts of “sect” and “sectarians” in the media in relation to believers and their associations” was made by the same Lunkin.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

About the fact that Lunkin is the author of the examination he wrote by order of Falun Gong


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“the conclusion was made in connection with the appeal of the non-profit partnership Falun Dafa Center for Spiritual and Physical Improvement”)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

has already been said more than once.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Finally, I cannot help but point out such a remarkable thing as the fact that a photo of Falun Gong activist Svetlana Polunina was surprisingly selected for Appendix No. 7, who is known not only for confessing her love to Falun Gong to the profane Gong publication Minghui: Svetlana Polunina from Moscow has been practicing Falun Gong for 11 years.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

She said, “I love Falun Gong from the bottom of my heart. It has a powerful energy. Practicing Falun Gong can improve health and moral qualities. If you follow the principles of Truth, Kindness, Patience, your life will be happy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your relationships with others will improve.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Minghui correspondent Li Xiao//Minghui, May 19, 2017, published in Falun Gong battle leaflet The Great Epoch


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for example —, and).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Let me remind you that I came to a meeting with Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales in September 2016, where I even mentioned Khroniker's colleague as a sinner on a topic of interest to us: Viewer : “Hello Jimmy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Many participants of the Russian Wikipedia are faced with the fact that there are a number of articles in which a group of administrators do not allow you to make any edits, changes and additions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Such articles are characterized by extremely negative or positive content.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

When trying to bring neutrality to the article and bring it in line with Wikipedia rules, participants are blocked.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In support of this fact, you can, for example, analyze the work of Tempus and Kinoker participants


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(illegible, possibly another spelling — Ed.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The most controversial was the article about Falun Gong


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(inaudible — editor's note).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The dispute continues for more than eight years.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Any edits to the article that make it neutral are rejected.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Translations of articles from other languages, translations of other articles about Falun Gong, documents such as the resolution of the European Parliament, the US Congress resolution on Falun Gong, and others.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Even the arbitration committee, which was appealed many times, did not help in the dispute.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the edits are still rejected, and the article is extremely negative and sharply different from the articles about Falun Gong in 49 languages.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We see extreme bias and violation of Wikipedia rules.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

How can this issue be resolved?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thanks.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So it hurts, sorry for the pun intended, the photographer's ears are peeking out in the picture.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 06:02, November 5, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The Falun Gong talk page, as well as the Faluninfo website, is publicly available and anyone can view it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus colleague, you consistently submitted requests to checkusers until your DR and Q-bit array colleagues answered you: “Frankly speaking, I don't see any reason to check here yet.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

All three participants were registered several years ago and, except for the topic “Falgun”, practically do not overlap during this period.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yes, they write about the East in general and about China in particular - but we have a lot of people writing about China.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Supporting one point of view in one discussion is not enough reason to check - otherwise 3/4 of Wikipedia participants could be verified on this basis.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—DR


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

17:58, March 4, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

PS: From now on, I would like to ask my colleague Tempus not to submit such requests for a “square-nest” check of accounting bundles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

More serious justification is required for verification.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Q-bit array


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

13:15, April 8, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Nomos


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

09:34, November 7, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So what?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Strictly speaking, nothing prevents colleagues from DR and Q-bit array from conducting an inspection again at any time, as such, if circumstances change.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

By the way, VP:MITPAPPET is not approved by the wiki community.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, this text in the Discussion looks very interesting: Falun Gong #Новый_раздел_ “Trials_in_Russia”: “Since there was information in the preamble that some Falun Gong materials are on the list of extremist literature of the Russian Federation, and I think that it is necessary to add quite significant information that numerous violations were committed during the trial of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to specialists from the Guild of Linguists Experts of the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Justice Moscow, during the examination on the book Zhuan Falun and other materials of Falun Gong, committed numerous violations of the law on the conduct of forensic examinations and exceeded the limits of competence.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

[56] [57] —Nomos


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

14:38, April 10, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)”, where footnote No. 57 stands “” together with #Рецензия “GLADYS” in the Falun Gong article on the one hand, and the fact that the so-called “” dated October 16, 2017 is attached to the already mentioned Falun Gong website, with the other side.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Continuous coincidences.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As well as the fact that the so-called “” miraculously contains the text: 1.2.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The court based its decision on written evidence presented by the prosecutor, and at the same time was critical of similar evidence presented by Falun Gong followers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At the same time, interested parties presented a number of written evidence, which contains conclusions about the absence of signs of extremist materials in the texts under consideration:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— philological opinion of Doctor of Philology, Professor of the Department of Public Relations and Social Communications of the Kuban State University Faktorovich A.L.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

dated March 31, 2009


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ld 333-351);


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— expert opinion of the Deputy Director for Research at the Krasnodar Art Museum named after V.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

F.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kovalenko, expert on cultural values of the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation Vashchenko I.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

No. 75 dated April 28, 2009


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ld 250-251);


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— response of the Heraldic Council under the President of the Russian Federation dated March 31, 2009 No. A62-2-178


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ld. 352-353);


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— research by D.I. Raskin, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Head of the Scientific Publications Department of the Russian State Historical Archive, Professor of St. Petersburg State University.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

dated 6.05.2009


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ld. 252-263);


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— conclusion of a forensic expert of the Forensic Laboratory of the Directorate of the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation for the Sverdlovsk Region Mochalova S.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

No. 197 dated June 23, 2009


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ld 450-471).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, just like 1.3.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The court granted the prosecutor's request to call specialists who conducted research at the initiative of the prosecutor, and at the same time refused a similar petition to interested parties to summon specialists who conducted research on their initiative.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At the hearing on October 21, 2011, the court granted the prosecutor's request to summon the linguist Bogomaz A.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

who conducted the study dated June 20, 2008 No. 1397/3-5/26.1 and specialist psychologist Rogozu A.G.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, which conducted research No. 1397/3-5/20.1 dated 30.06.2008.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At the same time, in a hearing of October 27, 2011, the court rejected the petition of the representative of the NP CDFS Falun Dafa to summon and interrogate specialists whose conclusions had previously been attached by the court to the case file:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Deputy Director for Research at the Krasnodar Art Museum named after V.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

F.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Doctor of Philology, Professor of the Department of Public Relations and Social Communications of the Kuban State University Faktorovich A.L.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, as did 1.4.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The court refused the interested parties to satisfy the request to attach additional evidence to the case file.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Additional evidence was submitted to the court, taking into account the instructions of the court of cassation and for a more complete and objective consideration of the case, and included:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— conclusion of Doctor of Philosophy Ivanenko S.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

on the Russian Falun Dafa Center for Spiritual and Physical Improvement dated April 11, 2009;


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— conclusion of Doctor of Philosophy, Head of the Department of History of Religions and Practical Religious Studies of the Institute of Philosophy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

H.S.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Skovoroda of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Professor L.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Falun Dafa's teachings in Li Hongzhi's book Zhuan Falun;


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— information reports on awarding the authors of the texts under study, including Li Hongzhi, the Spiritual Leader Award 2009, the presentation of D. Kilguru and D. Meitas with the 2009 Human Rights Protection Award and nominations for the Nobel Peace Prize;


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— articles in Russian media, copies of diplomas, certificates of honor awarded to Falun Dafa followers in Russia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This evidence reveals the foundations of Falun Dafa's teachings, the content and meaning of the texts studied


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as the Judicial Collegium for Civil Cases of the Krasnodar Regional Court drew attention to in the cassation ruling of April 28, 2009) testify to the positive impact of the texts under study, and how investigation into the active social, socially significant and useful activities of Falun Dafa followers in the world, incl.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and Russia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Which somehow painfully coincides well with the Discussion: Falun Gong #По about the rollback of edit 74215498 by RU.disciplines participant by Tempus, Discussion: Falun Gong #Про ordered Raskin's examination, Discussion: Falun Gong #Заключение_доктора_кандидата_философских_наук_и_социолога_Лункина_Р.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

N.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

_o_book_ “Zhuan_Falun” and #Заключение of Candidate of Philosophical Sciences and Sociologist Lunkin R.N.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

about the book “Zhuan Falun” and the conclusion of a specialist - Doctor of Philology Faktorovich A.L.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I.e.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

the very things that the IRQ5 participant defended


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(a.k.a ru.disciplines), Westcoast00 member under the topic ban


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(aka Rina Romanova=Vova SPB=Eve Lvova), Andromedov member and you are a Nomos member.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 10:00, November 7, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the fact that from now on suddenly


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(which was there on November 4, because the hyperlink to avoid concealment of evidence), which was replaced, further confirms the suspicion that there may be a “Falun Gong talk page as well like Faluninfo, is publicly available and anyone can view it.”, here's just Wikipedia page:Mediation/Non-academic, Atheism and Religion/Koi, although it is located in open access, but you also need to know about its existence, as well as know that Falun Gong is being discussed here, as well as know what was stated here about what Faluninfo is posted on the Faluninfo website photograph by Falun Gong activist Svetlana Polunina.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And I can hardly believe that the Falun Dafa Information Center represented by the center's employees: Karina Safedinova, editor-in-chief of this site


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(likes to be published in the Falun Gong newspaper The Great Epoch — “”, with the source being “Television Confirmed That”, and at the bottom of the publication there is a modest postscript - “Writing an article assisted by NTD TV channel reporters”), Deputy Editor-in-Chief Larisa Demchenko


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Candidate of Technical Sciences, including published in this newspaper — “”,: “The author of the article “Invisible So Far New”, Candidate of Technical Sciences Demchenko L.S., expresses his point of view on Falun Dafa as about a new scientific phenomenon as the science of the supernatural.”), content manager Evgenia Pan, public relations officer Oksana Shchotkina, as well as some Elina Slaba, Elvina Antipova


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(noted in the comments in the publication)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and Andrey Antipov, who simply “post articles on the site”, just woke up together in the morning with one single thought “Shouldn't I replace the image in appendix number 7 “Characteristic A collection widely used by law enforcement officers, “what if someone decides to find out who this girl in yellow clothes is?” , and then we got up, went and, just like that, changed it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would like to note separately that Evgenia Pan, modestly referred to as a “content manager”, whose duties should include tracking everything related to Falun Gong, is also one of the founders


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“Founders: Denis Borisov; Evgenia Vladimirovna Pan; Tatyana Vasilyevna Petrova; Vladimir Sergeevich Sukharev”)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

the electronic periodical Falun Dafa Information Center, as evidenced by the entry in the media register of the Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, the duties of a public relations officer are exactly the same


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(i.e. PR specialists)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Oksana Shchotkina, who writes texts with a bias in jurisprudence


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(,,) similar to the ones above, as on Change.org.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yes, and in “The Great Epoch” Shchotkina likes to write


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The interesting thing about Vladimir Sukharev is that the owner of the domains and: - Falun Dafa Information Center in the Russian Federation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The hosting is located in St. Petersburg by Valuehost.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The domain is registered to Vladimir S. Sukhareva


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(VLADIMIR S SUXAREV)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

December 27, 2001 of the year.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The main iconic Internet resource”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and - A single media body in 13 languages


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Russian, Ukrainian, English, Korean, French, German, Spanish, Japanese, Hebrew, Romanian, Bulgarian, Slovak, Swedish).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The hosting is located in St. Petersburg in the company “nserver: ns20.ruweb.net”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(VLADIMIR S SUXAREV)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

December 9, 2004 of the year.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The main iconic Internet resource”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

About Denis Borisov that he is a representative of the World Organization for the Investigation of the Persecution of Falun Gong


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“Denis Borisov, Representative of the World Organization for the Investigation of the Persecution of Falun Gong. Photo: Irina Oshirova/Great Epoch”),: “To study the criminal behavior of all institutions, organizations and individuals involved in the persecution of Falun Gong”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(English: To investigate the criminal conduct of all institutions, organizations, and individuals involved in the persecution of Falun Gong).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, two logical answers suggest themselves: either one of the above persons closely monitors all movements on Wikipedia


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(VP:NU immediately suggests itself), or someone told them everything.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Because personally, I don't believe in telepathy.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 06:39, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A colleague of Tempus, apparently, you do not quite know what “legal religious studies” is, because even the most superficial acquaintance with this concept, it is immediately clear that this is a new discipline that offer religious educational institutions to train ministers of evangelical churches


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for example, in or at).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That is, pastors and lawyers of Christian Baptist communities are taught the basics of legislation for the purpose of competent orientation in various conflict situations, litigation, etc.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, as Protestant churches in Russia are now facing problems.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Simply put, they teach how to protect their rights within the framework of the legislation of the Russian Federation


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

These are just courses that do not require compulsory legal education at all, and are taught by ordinary lawyers and lawyers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, the fact remains that Ponkin and Kuznetsov, being doctors of law, do not have the right to make conclusions and research in the field of psychology, linguistics or religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Falun Gong as a Hate Cult: A Collection of Materials” /Comp.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

T.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kvitkovskaya is not an authoritative source.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Umweiss


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

10:27, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“A colleague of Tempus, apparently, you do not quite know what “legal religious studies” is, because even the most superficial acquaintance with this concept, it is immediately clear that this is a new discipline that offer religious educational institutions to train ministers of evangelical churches


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(for example, in or at).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“- Judging by this discussion, you don't know that.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Thus, the fact remains that Ponkin and Kuznetsov, being doctors of law, do not have the right to make conclusions and research in the field of psychology, linguistics or religious studies. “Falun Gong as a Hate Cult: A Collection of Materials” /Comp.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

T.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

” — VP:AROUND.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 11:22, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleagues, I think a compromise is possible here, as I suggested above: instead of a quote, write a retelling: “According to Russian lawyers, doctors of law M. N. Kuznetsova and I. IN. Ponkin, the spread of the Falun Gong doctrine and following this doctrine can lead to extremist activity and other violations of the legislation of the Russian Federation, and the activities of followers of this doctrine should be the subject of increased attention of the authorities.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Scientific lawyers, of course, have the right to introduce new terms in their scientific works that are not in the current legislation or in dictionaries — for example, the same “antisocial creed”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But Wikipedia articles should be written, if possible, in such a language that they are understandable even to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And they were clear after reading the text of the article, and not only after a careful study of all the sources indicated in it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there is no reliable information about specific facts of violations of Russian law by Falun Gong supporters and that these violations were related to the implementation of the exercise, and not on their own initiative individuals have happened — any lawyer can only express his fears or assumptions that this may happen.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In any case, assumptions about opportunities should not be presented as fait accompli.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

19:33, November 11, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander, did not quite understand what source this text will refer to?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

18:47, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The same one we discuss in this topic: authors: Kuznetsov M.N.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, Ponkin I.V.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Falun Gong is a cult of hatred.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But instead of a quote with vague expressions and author's terms, I offer such a retelling in meaning that is understandable to a wide range of readers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

19:29, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“To the same one that we are discussing in this topic” — And Petrunya additionally, as a supporting VP:NVI?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 23:58, November 12, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can also put a second footnote: it is common for one AI to quote or refer to another AI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Or use it separately, if this is appropriate in the text of the article by the time of the result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The general principle here seems to be clear: whatever the AI, assumptions about the possibility of Falun Gong supporters committing illegal and other destructive actions should be written as assumptions and the fears of specific authors, without passing it off as fait accompli.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

New author terms and vague expressions, even if they are present in AI, should be avoided on Wikipedia, and everything should be retold in words that will be clearly understandable even to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

15:35, November 13, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega, you did not mention the previous secondary source


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Petrunya), and in response to a question from Uch.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus wrote about this source: “You can also put a second footnote: it is common for one AI to quote or refer to another AI.” That's why I have questions in you:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. Is it acceptable to use this controversial source


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Kuznetsov, Ponkin)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

without the accompanying second reference to the secondary AI?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If you do not quote, but briefly retell the legal part of their conclusions, as I suggested, you can.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The authors are competent as lawyers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This article was published in 2008, when there was no federal list of extremist materials yet, and there were no legally justified claims by the Russian authorities against Falun Gong supporters either


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in any case, we are not aware of such claims from AI).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kuznetsov and Ponkin mention cases of possible offenses and self-harm in China, but they themselves refuse to verify the reliability of the reports of the Chinese authorities about such cases and investigate the validity and The legality of the persecution of specific Falun Gong activists.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They chose the easiest way to research on this complex topic — exclusively by analyzing the doctrine materials posted on the Internet by Falun Gong followers themselves.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A legal researcher, of course, has the right to choose this method of work, but what could be found out in Russia in 2007 by this method?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kuznetsov and Ponkin could only speculate about the possible future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is not the establishment of facts and circumstances, it is not even a legal assessment of the already known fait accompli related to Falun Gong — these are assumptions and fears, and nothing more.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On VP: NEGUSHCHA, it is in this vein that they should be submitted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to VP:INV and VP:STYLE, we need a retelling of the article by Kuznetsov and Ponkin in such words that will be unequivocally understandable even to a layman.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Quoting this article by Kuznetsov and Ponkin in a dubious


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(more on this below)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Petruni's publications do not affect the authority of Kuznetsov and Ponkin.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2. Do you consider Petrunya's publication an authoritative VP:NVI?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It's unlikely.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This was published in a little-known online magazine that no longer exists on the Internet and is available only in.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But even in that archival copy of the magazine's website there is no imprint, nothing about which person or organization published the magazine, who is the editor-in-chief, who is responsible for the site.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On — only a webform for the message, no addresses, no phone numbers, no names.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

How can we talk about the presence of editorial control and verification of facts independent of the authors, and about the fulfillment of other requirements of the VP:NVI?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And then why is the anonymous site hypostasis.ru better than forums and blogs, and is it at all?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The content of that same article also raised a lot of questions for me.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, philosophy is a generalizing science, and in such a work you can and should refer to publications by specialists in various fields in order to make an interdisciplinary generalization, conclusions and forecasts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But most of Petruni's work is quoting and closely retelling the words of other authors, and only those that confirm Petruni's opinion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

With the exception of Brzezinski, with whom Petrunya constantly argues, trying to refute.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There are conspiracy theories, conspiracy theories — all sorts of “global and transatlantic elites”, whose existence and power are presented not as a hypothesis, but as an undeniable fact.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Where is scientific research, where is the synthesis of new knowledge and the expansion of existing ones?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Petruni's own conclusions are only global forecasts about the division of Russia and the world into two zones of influence — Anglo-Saxon and Chinese.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Over the past few years, these predictions have not been in a hurry to come true.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It turned out to be something between a bad essay and the former Marxist-Leninist propaganda, and not research work.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is generally about Petruni's article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The same thing in it, as for Falun Gong, is again only quoting; Petrunya clearly did not independently study the teachings and activities of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

He quotes the same Ponkin-Kuznetsov and more


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(old URL).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Devyatov expresses the version that the introduction of Falun Gong in China was a cunning action of Western special services


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(without specifying which services in which countries).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, this version can also be briefly mentioned somewhere in the Falun Gong article — with a direct reference to Devyatov himself.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Petruny only adds about Falun Gong on his own behalf that Kuznetsov and Potkin allegedly exposed false anti-Chinese propaganda in Europe and the United States.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Neither Petruni nor Kuznetsov can understand what kind of propaganda we are talking about.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kuznetsov and Potkin accuse the Russian portal Credo of false propaganda.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ru.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They somehow silently extend Russian anti-extremist legislation to China and the whole world — they present everything as if in Russia some Falun Gong texts may be recognized as extremist and banned — and Falun Gong followers are criminals all over the world, and any persecution of them will be lawful and do not violate human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The very facts of the persecution of Falun Gong in China are not refuted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But in the US, Canada, and many European countries, adherence to radical doctrine cannot be a crime in itself


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(if it did not result in specific wrongful acts).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is not clear whose specific statements are refuted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So, even if Petruni's work is considered AI, it does not provide any new information for the Falun Gong article, only quotes other sources, and only briefly mentions Falun Gong in it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander, just a little clarification about “this was published in a little-known online magazine that no longer exists on the Internet and is only available in.” in INION RAS journal.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 13:04, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, then the above claims against the publisher on non-compliance with the VP:NVI do not apply to the journal “Actual Problems of Europe”: this scientific journal is published by one of the institutes of the Russian Academy of Sciences, which means that it is independent of There are probably a professional editorial board of authors of articles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And it is true about this article by Petruni that Falun Gong is not a topic of research, it is mentioned only in passing and only in quoting and retelling other AI's.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Despite the authority of both this publisher and the author, this article by Petruni does not provide new information for the Falun Gong article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

17:03, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3. How your proposal to write a retelling is compatible with your own predicot above “Thus, Falun Gong is a cult of hatred” cannot be used as a source of facts for the article


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(this collection is too far from neutrality and impartiality), nor as a source of positions of the parties involved


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(the authors are not and are not authorized to represent them), nor as outside opinions/evaluations/criticisms


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(authors go beyond their legal competence).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The legal part of their conclusions, which I proposed to retell and leave, is not a report of facts or even assessments and opinions about something that exists, but fears and assumptions about the possible in the future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Perhaps I was not clear enough, so I can write a second preliminary result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

4. Have you considered in this case the competence of the authors in religious studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(not legal)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

topics, in connection with their assessment of doctrine


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(not actions)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

this organization?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Or do you consider this assessment as legal, not related to competence in religious studies?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As legal — since the quote and reference were in the Falun Gong article section on persecution by the authorities.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Accordingly, it is primarily about legal issues — the validity and legality of the persecution of Falun Gong in China, as well as the possible persecution of Falun Gong supporters in other countries.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Whether Kuznetsov and Ponkin can be considered competent in matters of religious analysis of the doctrine of Falun Gong itself and the possible consequences of its spread in society is a separate controversial issue, which has already had a lot of discussion above.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That is why, as a compromise, I proposed in the section “Persecution of Falun Gong” instead of quoting a retelling of the legal part of Kuznetsov and Ponkin's conclusions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

5. In your preliminary summary, you focused on evaluating the quote, while the request was about the source as a whole


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“I also believe that referring to this source in the Falun Gong article is a violation of VP:NTZ and VP:EXPERT, we ask the mediators to evaluate this source and summarize this discussion”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your conclusion: “Thus, Falun Gong is a Hate Cult cannot be used either as a source of facts for an article


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This quote should definitely be removed, others from the same source — must be considered separately and just as strictly” is not entirely clear, or the source can not be used at all, or only in connection with this a quote.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your last suggestion to allow this source to be used to retell the quote adds even more uncertainty.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Can you be more specific about the topic in which it is permisble/unacceptable to use this source?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 14, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(this collection is too far from neutrality and impartiality), nor as a source of positions of the parties involved


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(the authors are not and are not authorized to represent them), nor as outside opinions/evaluations/criticisms


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(authors go beyond their legal competence).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 14, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Now I can only say what I have already written above: it is possible to use it as an assumption by Russian lawyers about the possible socially dangerous consequences of the spread of the Falun Gong doctrine in the future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for the admissibility of using their analysis of the Falun Gong doctrine, I still think... Alexander Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A retelling instead of a quote is unlikely to be a compromise, since the question remains: why do lawyers do


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

an opinion on a doctrine that lies outside their area of competence?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Authors of the Kvitkovskaya Collection


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Ponkin and Kuznetsov)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— lawyers do not do legal, but religious studies, psychological-linguistic research.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

After reading the content of the collection, you can easily see the falsification of “facts”, as well as simply unreliable information about Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Such material cannot be an authoritative source for Wikipedia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Nomos


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

09:14, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Authors of the Kvitkovskaya Collection


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Ponkin and Kuznetsov)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

” - Again VP:AROUND.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“After reading the content of the collection, you can easily see the falsification of “facts”, as well as simply unreliable information about Falun Gong. Falun Gong is credited with something that it does not contain in principle.” — Please, evidence to the studio.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And please, something fresher than what was stated in the Falun Gong anonymous.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 10:06, 15 November 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If we do as I suggest, the question of why lawyers make a religious conclusion will be a question only for Ponkin and Kuznetsov, and not for us.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Wikipedia will simply state the fact that in 2008, two Russian lawyers suggested that the spread of Falun Gong could lead to extremist activity and other violations of Russian legislation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They did say this, and the fact that such a collection of articles was published and its belonging to these authors is not disputed by anyone.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Nothing more so far.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We have no information about specific offenses in Russia and other countries committed by Falun Gong supporters in connection with the implementation of this doctrine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:30, November 15, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Preliminary total-2


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Taking into account the above arguments of the participants, here is a new version of the preliminary result, for quote and for the source as a whole:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Quote


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the Falun Gong Ban in China section of the Falun Gong article, the quote discussed


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Analysis of print and electronic


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(on the internet)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

materials publicly and openly distributed by the Falun Gong religious association to an unlimited number of people, the nature of the attitudes, views, attitudes and beliefs formed among followers of this religious association, gives grounds to assess the doctrine of the Falun Gong association as extremist and antisocial, posing a danger to the individual, society and the state, violating human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

from Kuznetsov M. N., Ponkin I. IN. /Comp.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

T. A. Kvitkovskaya.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— M.: Public Committee on Human Rights, 2008.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

should not remain in this form, because it, when taken out of its original context and placed on Wikipedia, contains vague expressions and will not be unequivocally understandable to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to VP:INV, Wikipedia should avoid undefined expressions, even if such expressions are used in the AI you use.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And perhaps even if in a quote from the source — except when this particular quote with vague expressions is needed to illustrate something, for example, to show that a religious text cannot be interpreted unequivocally.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Legal scientists, like other researchers, can introduce their own original terms and expressions, author's neologisms.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the article by Kuznetsov and Ponkin, this is the expression “extremist and antisocial creed that violates human rights”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no definition of the concept of “extremist creed” either in dictionaries or in the legislation of the Russian Federation


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(both 2008 and currently in force).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Despite all the “rubbery” of Russian legal definitions of extremism, they are not unlimited.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In 2008, only the activities of specific people, groups or organizations could be recognized as extremist


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“extremist activity”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the future, extremist information materials included in the relevant federal list were added.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But these can only be specific information materials, and not creeds, ideologies or ideas.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Equally incomprehensible to Wikipedia readers will be the phrase “a creed that violates human rights”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

With all the variety of ideas about human rights and freedoms, another person, group, organization or state can be the subject of human rights violations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But how can a creed, even if radical and inhumane, violate human rights in itself, if no one forces anyone to accept it by force, if the followers of this doctrine do not Are they trying to subject everyone else to their own rules?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This will not be unequivocally understandable for a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to the rules of VP:INV, VP:STYLE, VP:AI, VP:PROV and others, Wikipedia articles should be written in a scientific style, but in words that will be clearly understandable even to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the meaning of what is written should be clear to the reader after reading the Wikipedia article itself, and not only after a close study of all the sources listed in the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kuznetsov and Ponkin in their collection “Falun Gong — a Cult of Hatred” conduct a study that can be considered both legal and religious studies at the same time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the quote under discussion is in the section “Ban on Falun Gong in China”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On the topic of this section


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as well as a separate article Persecution of Falun Gong), it is the legal justification for the existing persecution of Falun Gong supporters by the Chinese authorities or possible persecution of others by their own authorities states.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This means that in these places Wikipedia should convey the legal part of the results of the study conducted by Ponkin and Kuznetsov.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the interpretation and analysis of the Falun Gong doctrine is the topic of another section of the Falun Gong article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, in 2008, Falun Gong information materials in Russia were not yet recognized as extremist, and as far as we know, the Russian authorities did not have any complaints against Falun Gong at that time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We still have no information about specific violations of Russian legislation by Falun Gong supporters.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for violations of Chinese law, the connection of these violations with the doctrine of Falun Gong, the legality of persecution and punishment for it, the reality or imaginary brutal repression against Falun Gong — Kuznetsov and Ponkin do not conduct their own research on this topic, as they themselves admit in the collection.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

All they said new about Falun Gong was just fears and assumptions about the possible future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to VP:NEGUSHCHA and VP:AI, this should be conveyed in such a way that fears and assumptions are not presented as facts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So, the quote under discussion should be replaced by a retelling of the content of the publication by Ponkin and Kuznetsov, for example, as follows:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In 2008, Russian lawyers, Doctors of Law M. N. Kuznetsov and I. IN. Ponkin, after studying the information materials of the Falun Gong movement on the Internet, expressed their concerns about the possible socially dangerous consequences of the spread of the Falun Gong doctrine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They said that this could lead to extremist activity and other violations of the laws of the Russian Federation, that Falun Gong practitioners can harm themselves and others, and therefore their activities should arouse increased interest of public authorities.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Other formulations are possible, but this should be written in such a way that its meaning is clearly understandable to a Wikipedia reader who does not have special knowledge in the field of religious studies, jurisprudence, or of other sciences.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Since we are retelling only the legal part of the conclusions of Kuznetsov and Ponkin here, one link to this collection of articles may be enough.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no point in giving another link to Petruni's article, which quotes them — quoting their work by Petrunya does not affect the authority of Kuznetsov and Potkin as lawyers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Source as a whole


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If somewhere it is necessary to compare the teachings of Fapun Gong with Russian legislation, this work by Kuznetsov and Ponkin can be used.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At the same time, it is necessary to attribute everything in such a way that it is clear that lawyers wrote this in 2008 in accordance with the Russian legislation in force at that time


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as the current one may differ).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, even there, Ponkin and Kuznetsov's assumptions about possible future offenses on the part of Falun Gong followers in connection with their practice should not be presented as fait accompli facts of violations of the law.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Other Wikipedia rules, including avoiding vague expressions, must also be followed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If another quote from the same collection, taken out of its original context, turns out to be ambiguously understood by Wikipedia readers, then such a quote should be replaced by a retelling.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The religious part of the work of Kuznetsov and Ponkin is more difficult.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to the decision of AK:350, “the presentation, characteristics and assessments of certain provisions of the doctrine of the creator of Falun Gong, Li Hongzhi, should be based as much as possible on secondary sources - religious scholars”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is religious scholars, and not related specialists.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Such legal specializations and topics as legislation on freedom of conscience, legal regulation of religious activity, state-confessional relations, “legal religious studies” are not is the same as religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, in this collection, the authors do not engage in a comprehensive study of the teachings of Falun Gong, and do not set themselves such a task.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They look exclusively for “legal negativity”, consider only passages in the scriptures that theoretically could provoke or justify destructive, immoral or illegal behavior, and do not are exploring something else that can stimulate socially approved behavior of Falun Gong followers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Even if Ponkin and Kuznetsov can be considered competent in the field of religious studies, the main provisions of Falun Gong's teachings are already quite well described in the relevant section of the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, the use of this source in the Falun Gong Teaching section is generally undesirable, and can only be permissible if it is really necessary and there is no alternative in the form of more neutral AI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the criticism section, this source can be used, but, again, with appropriate attribution — so that fears, assumptions, opinions and attitudes do not seem reliable to the reader facts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:48, November 16, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A couple of clarifications on the proposed text: 1)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

not only Falun Gong materials from the Internet were analyzed, but also printed materials 2)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

both are not just D.Yu.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

n.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, as well as professors of the Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In general, in my opinion, the background can be called quite balanced.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 02:58, November 17, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I agree with the result in this form.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khroniker


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:27, November 17, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I confirm “Preliminary Result-2”, since during the week there were no objections to it from other mediators and other participants.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus's remark is quite reasonable, given its retelling of the source instead of a quote, will be slightly different.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

19:49, November 23, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Quote


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the Falun Gong Ban in China section of the Falun Gong article, the quote discussed


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Analysis of print and electronic


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(on the internet)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

materials publicly and openly distributed by the Falun Gong religious association to an unlimited number of people, the nature of the attitudes, views, attitudes and beliefs formed among followers of this religious association, gives grounds to assess the doctrine of the Falun Gong association as extremist and antisocial, posing a danger to the individual, society and the state, violating human rights.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

from Kuznetsov M. N., Ponkin I. IN. /Comp.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

T. A. Kvitkovskaya.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— M.: Public Committee on Human Rights, 2008.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

should not remain in this form, because it, when taken out of its original context and placed on Wikipedia, contains vague expressions and will not be unequivocally understandable to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to VP:INV, Wikipedia should avoid undefined expressions, even if such expressions are used in the AI you use.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And perhaps even if in a quote from the source — except when this particular quote with vague expressions is needed to illustrate something, for example, to show that a religious text cannot be interpreted unequivocally.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Legal scientists, like other researchers, can introduce their own original terms and expressions, author's neologisms.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the article by Kuznetsov and Ponkin, this is the expression “extremist and antisocial creed that violates human rights”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no definition of the concept of “extremist creed” either in dictionaries or in the legislation of the Russian Federation


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(both 2008 and currently in force).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Despite all the “rubbery” of Russian legal definitions of extremism, they are not unlimited.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In 2008, only the activities of specific people, groups or organizations could be recognized as extremist


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(“extremist activity”).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the future, extremist information materials included in the relevant federal list were added.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But these can only be specific information materials, and not creeds, ideologies or ideas.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Equally incomprehensible to Wikipedia readers will be the phrase “a creed that violates human rights”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

With all the variety of ideas about human rights and freedoms, another person, group, organization or state can be the subject of human rights violations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But how can a creed, even if radical and inhumane, violate human rights in itself, if no one forces anyone to accept it by force, if the followers of this doctrine do not Are they trying to subject everyone else to their own rules?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This will not be unequivocally understandable for a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to the rules of VP:INV, VP:STYLE, VP:AI, VP:PROV and others, Wikipedia articles should be written in a scientific style, but in words that will be clearly understandable even to a layman reader.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the meaning of what is written should be clear to the reader after reading the Wikipedia article itself, and not only after a close study of all the sources listed in the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Kuznetsov and Ponkin in their collection “Falun Gong — a Cult of Hatred” conduct a study that can be considered both legal and religious studies at the same time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the quote under discussion is in the section “Ban on Falun Gong in China”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Related to this topic


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as well as a separate article Persecution of Falun Gong), it is the legal justification for the existing persecution of Falun Gong supporters by the Chinese authorities or possible persecution of others by their own authorities states.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This means that in these places Wikipedia should convey the legal part of the results of the study conducted by Ponkin and Kuznetsov.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the interpretation and analysis of the Falun Gong doctrine is the topic of another section of the Falun Gong article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, in 2008, Falun Gong information materials in Russia were not yet recognized as extremist, and as far as we know, the Russian authorities did not have any complaints against Falun Gong at that time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We still have no information about specific violations of Russian legislation by Falun Gong supporters.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for violations of Chinese law, the connection of these violations with the doctrine of Falun Gong, the legality of persecution and punishment for it, the reality or imaginary brutal repression against Falun Gong — Kuznetsov and Ponkin do not conduct their own research on this topic, as they themselves admit in the collection.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

All they said new about Falun Gong was just fears and assumptions about the possible future.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to VP:NEGUSHCHA and VP:AI, this should be conveyed in such a way that fears and assumptions are not presented as facts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So, the quote under discussion should be replaced by a retelling of the content of the publication by Ponkin and Kuznetsov, for example, as follows:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In 2008, Russian lawyers, doctors of law, professors of the RANEPA under the President of the Russian Federation M. N. Kuznetsov and I. IN. Ponkin, after studying the information materials of the Falun Gong movement, expressed their concerns about the possible socially dangerous consequences of the spread of the Falun Gong doctrine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They said that this could lead to extremist activity and other violations of the laws of the Russian Federation, that Falun Gong practitioners can harm themselves and others, and therefore their activities should arouse increased interest of public authorities.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Other formulations are possible, but this should be written in such a way that its meaning is clearly understandable to a Wikipedia reader who does not have special knowledge in the field of religious studies, jurisprudence, or of other sciences.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Since we are retelling only the legal part of the conclusions of Kuznetsov and Ponkin here, one link to this collection of articles may be enough.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no point in giving another link to Petruni's article, which quotes them — quoting their work by Petrunya does not affect the authority of Kuznetsov and Ponkin as lawyers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Source as a whole


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If somewhere it is necessary to compare the teachings of Fapun Gong with Russian legislation, this work by Kuznetsov and Ponkin can be used.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At the same time, it is necessary to attribute everything in such a way that it is clear that lawyers wrote this in 2008 in accordance with the Russian legislation in force at that time


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(as the current one may differ).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, even there, Ponkin and Kuznetsov's assumptions about possible future offenses on the part of Falun Gong followers in connection with their practice should not be presented as fait accompli facts of violations of the law.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Other Wikipedia rules, including avoiding vague expressions, must also be followed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If another quote from the same collection, taken out of its original context, turns out to be ambiguously understood by Wikipedia readers, then such a quote should be replaced by a retelling.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The religious part of the work of Kuznetsov and Ponkin is more difficult.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to the decision of AK:350, “the presentation, characteristics and assessments of certain provisions of the doctrine of the creator of Falun Gong, Li Hongzhi, should be based as much as possible on secondary sources - religious scholars”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is religious scholars, and not related specialists.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Such legal specializations and topics as legislation on freedom of conscience, legal regulation of religious activity, state-confessional relations, “legal religious studies” are not is the same as religious studies.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, in this collection, the authors do not engage in a comprehensive study of the teachings of Falun Gong, and do not set themselves such a task.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They look exclusively for “legal negativity”, consider only passages in the scriptures that theoretically could provoke or justify destructive, immoral or illegal behavior, and do not are exploring something else that can stimulate socially approved behavior of Falun Gong followers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Even if Ponkin and Kuznetsov can be considered competent in the field of religious studies, the main provisions of Falun Gong's teachings are already quite well described in the relevant section of the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, the use of this source in the Falun Gong Teaching section is generally undesirable, and can only be permissible if it is really necessary and there is no alternative in the form of more neutral AI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksandr Rumega


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

19:49, November 23, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I will allow myself to support the outcome a little bit.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The source is extremely doubtful, because the authors from the very beginning give in the text “Hysteria is fueled both in the media and in international organizations” or “This site


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(- mine)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

has long established itself as an information resource that promotes extremist and other marginal sects, promotes homosexuality and other human vices.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“. This is obvious propaganda, not a scientific work, so the regalia of the authors in this case can be neglected. Well, or “In the same way, this propaganda of the Falun Gong sect is illegal under the legislation of the Russian Federation, the USA, France, Germany, and almost all countries of the world” - delusional from the point of view jurisprudence statement. Even Nazi propaganda is not prohibited “in almost all countries of the world”, to say nothing of Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I have little idea of the level of lawyers who make such statements.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

18:35, December 22, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ama


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ayurveda)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

How legitimate is the removal of the {{affiliate sources}} template by a member of Morihei Tsunemori?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

He refers to the CO and supposedly the mediator's decision, but I do not see any outcome or anything on the CO that could prevent the article from having this template.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tucvbif???


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

* 07:12, July 5, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The intermediary on the SO clearly wrote that the use of non-independent sources is permissible if the information is undisputed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What kind of information do you doubt?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What rule has been broken?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there is no doubt and hanging the template was purely formal, then there is nothing to discuss, sorry moi, there is nothing to discuss.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Morihėi


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

10:02, July 5, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

First, the question is not the possibility of using sources, but a warning that independent sources are not given at all.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

With regard to the NEAC template, what is the objection to installing it?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And in principle, the article can be put up for deletion altogether, because.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

according to the VP:MARG rule, if independent sources do not show attention to this particular topic, then it is insignificant.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tucvbif???


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

* 10:31, July 5, 2018