Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

List of sites of special scientific interest in Lancashire


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

Cheshire English, which is a mixture of Lancashire, Staffordshire, Shropshire, and Derbyshire dialects


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

Notes


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

References


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

, Volume 1 (of 2), by John Roby


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

Climbing Guidebook produced by the British Mountaineering Council


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

(in English)


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

Category:Counties of England


Question: In what country is Lancashire County?

Lancashire

Category:establishments in 1182


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

“Hare Krishna Food for Life” (English: Hare Krishna Food for Life) is the world's largest humanitarian mission to distribute vegetarian food.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[1] Founded in 1974 by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) with the aim of providing vegetarian food to socially disadvantaged segments of the population, as well as people affected by natural disasters and military conflicts, regardless of their race, nationality, political or religious beliefs.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Hare Krishna Food for Life is currently active in more than 60 countries around the world.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The organization's volunteers distribute more than 1 million free meals a day.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The organization provides food for the homeless in big cities around the world, free lunches for schoolchildren in India, and meals for victims of natural disasters.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The charitable mission of Hare Krishna Food for Life is rooted in Indian culture and aims to revive the ancient Vedic custom of hospitality.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The organization's activities were praised by a number of public and charitable organizations (such as the International Rescue Committee), the media (in particular, The New York Times”) and some prominent public and political figures (such as Nelson Mandela).


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[3] [4] [5]


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

History


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Food for Life was founded by the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (ISKCON) in West Bengal in 1974 at the direct direction of Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada, who wished that within 10 miles of ISKCON temples were not hungry.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[1] Initially, the mission was called ISKCON Food Relief, operated mainly in India and funded by Bhaktivedanta Book Trust from the sale of Krishna literature.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[6] In the first years after Prabhupada's death, the mission significantly decreased its activity.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In 1982, [7] Mukunda Goswami, Director of the ISKCON Ministry of Public Relations, revived the program and gave it a new name, “Hare Krishna — Food for Life”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[6] The main goals of the program were to promote vegetarianism through the free distribution of consecrated food (prasad) [6] and improve the public image of Krishnas, [7] who suffered in the 1980s in as a result of a series of scandals and attacks by the anti - cult movement.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[6] In its first year, Food for Life began operations in the United States, Australia, England, France, Germany, Spain and Bolivia.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[6] The mission received financial support from the US authorities and positive feedback in the media.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Today, the Food for Life mission operates in more than 60 countries around the world, [1] [8] including Russia and Ukraine.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The main goal of the program is to provide vegetarian meals to those in need (regardless of their national and religious affiliation), as well as “the revival of ancient Vedic culture hospitality.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[1] Food of Life provides assistance to socially unprotected categories of citizens (refugees, disabled people, students, pensioners and children), as well as people affected by natural disasters, social, national and religious conflicts.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[1] By the early 2000s, Food for Life had distributed more than 85 million [9] free lunches to people in need around the world.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

This charitable activity has received positive feedback from a number of public and political figures.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In Russia, Krishnas have been carrying out such activities since 1988, when a group of volunteers from different cities of the USSR provided food to victims of the earthquake in Armenia.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[11] In the 1990s, the Russian branch of the Food for Life mission distributed vegetarian food in hot spots of the former USSR (Abkhazia and Chechnya), [11] as well as victims of the earthquake in Neftegorsk.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[11] During the First Chechen War, Krishnas distributed about a million portions of hot lunches in Chechnya.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[11] One of the Krishna volunteers died in Grozny as a result of shelling.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[11] Food of Life volunteers in Chechnya were positively assessed by The New York Times, which wrote that in Grozny “they have the same reputation as Mother Teresa in Kolkata: it is not difficult to find people who swear that Krishnas are holy.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Criticism and controversy


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Accusations of distributing idol-sacrificed food


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In Russia, the Food of Life mission is criticized by religious figures of Orthodoxy, Islam and Judaism.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[13] It is believed that the vegetarian food distributed by Krishnas, called prasada, is “idol-sacrificed”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

According to Ravil Gainutdin, head of the Council of Muftis of Russia, food cooked in the name of Krishna is not allowed for consumption by Muslims, and its distribution by Krishnas should be considered as “evil charity.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

According to Muhammedgali Khuzin, Deputy Chairman of the Central Spiritual Administration of Muslims of Russia, when cooking, Krishnas use water to wash the feet of Krishna idol.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[13] Khuzin believes that this contradicts the sura from the Koran called “Meal”, which prohibits the worship of idols.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

On March 30, 2004, the Coordination Center for Muslims of the North Caucasus issued a statement in which ISKCON was described as a destructive sect whose activities are “a serious challenge interreligious world”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[14] According to the authors of the statement, in the mid-1990s, Krishnas took advantage of the “plight of the Muslim population of Chechnya” and carried out “active proselytic activities” among them.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[14] The statement also claimed that in 2004, Maxim Osipov, spokesman for the Russian ISKCON, appeared in the NTV TV show “To the Barrier!” “recognized the fact that food dedicated to the pagan deity Krishna was distributed to Muslims in Grozny under the guise of humanitarian aid”, despite the fact that “the Krishnas knew that Sharia law was categorically prohibit devout Muslims from consuming products sacrificed to idols.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Nafigulla Ashirov, head of the Spiritual Administration of Muslims of the Asian part of Russia, has a different opinion.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

He believes that the free distribution of prasad by Krishnas to needy residents of the Caucasian republics is a “good deed”, since “there are so many people in need and hungry in the North Caucasus today that they all is equal to what kind of food to eat.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[14] He also argues that “the Koran does not prohibit the consumption of vegetarian food prepared in any special way — it only says that pork is unacceptable and that meat should be cooked in accordance with certain requirements.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Chairman of the Federation of Jewish Communities of Russia Berl Lazar believes that Krishnas distribute their vegetarian food exclusively for missionary purposes.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

He also noted that “Krishnas have a passion for attracting people of other faiths to their own, and this is a very negative trend.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Lazar added that “various sects and religious movements that feed the people and say that this is knowledge of God only reduce respect for religion, for real religious traditions.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Bhakti Vigyana Goswami (Vadim Tuneev), head of the Center for Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia, said in this regard that “the attacking side does not have serious arguments against it, and fabrications are being used.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

According to him, ISKCON represents in Russia “the oldest monotheistic religion on Earth”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Gosvami also expressed the opinion that the images of God, which are offered food in Krishna altars, “have the same meaning as icons in Christians.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Incident with the distribution of “idol-sacrificed fruits” in the Cathedral of Christ the Savior (2010)


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

On November 23, 2010, a charity holiday for disabled children “Angel Children” was held in the Hall of Church Councils of the Cathedral of Christ the Savior.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[16] The hall of church councils does not belong to the department of the Russian Orthodox Church and is often the venue for social events.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] The event was organized by the Adeli Children's Rehabilitation Center, which invited about 1,000 children with cerebral palsy to the event.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] A concert was held for the children, after which, according to the organizers, each child should receive two oranges: one for himself and the other for a friend, in order to teach children “culture donations”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] Fruits for children were paid for by the Russian Food of Life Foundation.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

According to Roman Lunkin, a religious scholar and journalist from the Slavic Legal Center, the Hall of Church Councils was handed over to the Adele Center by the Foundation of the Cathedral of Christ the Savior (HHS Foundation) for the full commercial cost “almost 1 million rubles”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[19] At the same time, the Adeli Center refused to pay for expensive food cooked in the kitchen of the HHS, and did not pay 10,000 rubles demanded by the HHS Fund for each video camera and 5,000 rubles for each media camera.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[19] A week before the event, the management of the HHS Foundation notified the Adeli Center that in case of non-payment, they would not be allowed to distribute fruits and gifts to children in the Hall of Church Councils.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[19] In response, the Adeli Center filed a complaint to the Presidential Council for Persons with Disabilities, after which the management of the HHS Foundation allowed the delivery of gifts and food and did not take money for accredited media.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

According to Tatyana Nechay, General Director of the Adele Center, shortly after the fruits and gifts were brought to the Hall of Church Councils, “a citizen called aspirated in her voice reported a “terrible secret” that oranges and apples provided by the Food of Life Charity Foundation contain the Spirit of Krishna, and in no case should they be given to children.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] Later it turned out that the call came from the Russian Association of Centers for the Study of Religions and Sects (RACIRS), an Orthodox anti-sectarian organization headed by Alexander Dvorkin.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] The indignation of the Orthodox was caused by the fact that the Krishna Foundation “Food of Life” was going to distribute fruits to children on the territory of an Orthodox church, over which, in their opinion, “rituals were performed initiations to Krishna”, which turned them into “idol-sacrificed food.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] Even before the holiday, Alexander Dvorkin appeared at the scene, accompanied by his assistants and security officers of the HHS Fund.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] Calling the distribution of “idol-sacrificed” fruits an insult to the feelings of Orthodox believers, Dvorkin and his colleagues demanded that the fruit be put out on the street.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] [19] Otherwise, they promised not to let the children who were already waiting on the street into the building.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] Fruits were put on the street, where Food of Life volunteers began distributing them to the children who came to the festival.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

However, at the entrance to the Hall of Church Councils, Dvorkin's assistants took away their “idol-sacrificed food”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] Dvorkin explained to the representatives of the Adele Center: “Even if everything is expensive here, but there is no devil, everything is consecrated.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[20] [19] When asked by parents to call a priest and sprinkle holy water on the fruit, Dvorkin and his colleagues refused.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] According to Tatyana Nechay, the “Dvorkintsy” at the same time “referred to the fact that the spirit is so strong and malicious that neither holy water nor prayer can expel it.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] Some of the Orthodox parents took their children away from the “idol-sacrificed” temptation and “tried to find out for what purpose the occult talk show of the anti-Orthodox is held at the children's party character.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[18] When asked by representatives of the Adele Center about how Alexander Dvorkin got to the closed event, and “what right he had to dispose of in the premises rented for a high price”, one of the leaders of the HHS Foundation replied that this is a “high-ranking” official who “does not need an invitation”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Valery Dolgopolov, General Director of the Food of Life Foundation, who is himself a Krishna, [21] called the arguments of the RACIRS representatives untenable and accused them of inciting religious hatred.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] Dolgopolov assured journalists on the scene that no rituals were held with fruits and that the charity event was secular.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] [21] Yuri Pleshakov, Head of the Public Relations Department of the Center for Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia, also commented on the situation.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

He explained that the Food of Life Foundation was originally under the jurisdiction of Krishnas, but for many years it has been an autonomous organization that employs people of various faiths, including Orthodox Christians and Jews.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Alexander Dvorkin expressed the opinion that the organizers of the event joined religion to the charity event and turned the holiday “into a trade in children's souls”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] Dvorkin also told reporters that by the decision of the Bishops' Council of the Russian Orthodox Church of 1994, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness was declared a totalitarian sect and therefore Orthodox Christians did not can cooperate with him, and Krishnas cannot be on the territory of an Orthodox church.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[22] Dvorkin's associate, lawyer Alexander Korelov, called the distribution of fruits by Food of Life volunteers to children “a propaganda action by the Society for Krishna Consciousness”, but at the same time noted that “sincerely to a believer, “idol-sacrificed food “cannot harm”.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[17] A similar point of view was expressed by Priest Georgy Roschin, deputy head of the Synodal Department for Church and Society Relations, who commented on the incident to the Izvestia newspaper: “Christianina It is not what comes into his mouth that defiles, but what comes from them, as the Apostle Paul wrote. The call to avoid eating idol-sacrificed food should emphasize the difference between Christianity and paganism, but food alone cannot cause harm.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Roman Lunkin expressed the opinion that this incident revealed a serious problem of “strict capitalist rules” that guide the HHS Fund in its activities, [19] and Alexander Frolov this story reminded the scene with Father Ferapont from The Brothers Karamazov.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

[20] Frolov noted: “Nevertheless, the story in the KhHS happened, I remind you, not in Skotoprigonyevsk of the century before last, but in Moscow of the 21st century, near the Kremlin.”


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Interesting facts


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In 2002, the world's largest lacto-vegetarian cake was able to be tasted by everyone who came to the Palace of Culture.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Korolev in Kiev on this day.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

The 1080 kg cake, made by volunteers of “Hare Krishna — Food for Life”, was registered in the “Book of Records of Ukraine” as the largest cake in the history of the country.


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Notes


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Literature


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In Russian


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

In English


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

CS1 maint: extra text (link)


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

References


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Video


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

(in English)


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Category:Organizations established in 1974


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Category:International Society for Krishna Consciousness


Question: Do they distribute free food to the homeless in Moscow for June 2019?

Hare Krishna — Food for Life

Category:Vegetarianism


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

#2 - Preamble: Key Features of Living Ethics


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Problem statement


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I ask the mediators to resolve a fundamental issue that causes the main contradictions and disputes in the Roerich theme - what is the teaching of the Living Ethics (according to the available AI).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

There are two main understandings of this issue:


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The proposed and conducted in the article Living Ethics is a narrower understanding of the participant Q Valda that this is a religious and philosophical doctrine and nothing more.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

At the same time, a disproportionately strong emphasis is placed on the religious component of teaching and on religious sources: by the end of the preamble, religiosity is emphasized twice more - in the penultimate paragraph The Living Ethics is already becoming the basis of the “new religious movement”


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(contrary to the AI, which notes the predominance of cultural, educational and scientific-pedagogical orientation in the Roerich movement); and in the last paragraph generally refers


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(the teaching itself!)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

to New Age religious teachings, or “new age” religions


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(based on questionable sources).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The second, broader understanding belongs to me - I believe that on the basis of the existing AI, we can talk about the Living Ethics as a spiritual teaching that includes, in addition to religious and philosophical components, - the dominant ethical component, as well as sociological, cultural, pedagogical, aesthetic and psychological components.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In addition, the practical orientation of the exercise is important, which should be noted in the preamble.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

My arguments, as well as the counterarguments of my opponents, are presented in the discussion on the WU - Wikipedia:Forum/Archive/Attention to participants/2011/05 #Лазейка in VP:NTZ - which has not yet been summed up.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I do not abandon the idea I proposed there of three alternative definitions of the Living Ethics in the preamble of the article.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

But since then, I have come up with a more optimal proposal, in my opinion, to combine all three definitions into one generalizing definition:


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Living Etica, or Agni Yoga, is a spiritual teaching, mainly of an ethical orientation, which contains other components of the sphere of spiritual being: philosophical, religious, cultural, sociological, aesthetic, pedagogical, psychological, as well as practical instructions for the spiritual and moral improvement of a person.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Additional reasoning:


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

All three definitions I have proposed are not mutually exclusive - they complement each other, focusing on different aspects or components of the teaching of the Living Ethics, each AI on its own depending on their specialization - religious studies, philosophy, cultural studies, pedagogy, etc.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“Spiritual teaching” is the broadest concept that includes all other particular definitions.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The definition of the Living Ethics as a spiritual teaching is found in several AIs


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(in discussion at TR and quoted below)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- both “in its pure form” and with an additional dominant characteristic: “spiritual and moral teaching”, or “spiritual and ethical teaching”, or “spiritual and philosophical teaching”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The dominant ethical orientation of the teaching is noted in the vast majority of AI - religious studies, philosophical, cultural studies, etc.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In some AIs


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(see below)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

directly speaks about the diversity and diversity of the components of the teachings of the Living Ethics, and lists them.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The practical orientation of the exercise is also noted in several sources of various specializations.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In the sources below, I primarily draw attention to quotes from Simanzhenkova's dissertation and Yablokov's textbook - since during previous discussions they were recognized by all opponents to a high degree by authoritative sources.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Additional sources of definitions


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Simanzhenkova T. K. The movement of followers of the Roerichs teachings in modern Russia: philosophical origins and trends of evolution//Dissertation for the degree of Candidate Philosopher.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

sciences.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Omsk.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

— Krasnoyarsk: Siberian State Technological University, 2006.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The complexity and versatility of the Roerichs' teachings, which includes cultural, ethical, religious and philosophical components...


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... unlike theosophy, the teachings of the Roerichs work out in more detail the ethical side, i.e.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

attention is focused on issues of spiritual and moral improvement of a person and problems of culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The teachings of “Agni-Yoga” are supplemented with essential provisions related to the new geopolitical realities.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Of all the variety of ethical, philosophical, social ideas of teaching...


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Many pages of the doctrine and its two main parts, Community and Brotherhood, are devoted to the search for the ideal social form of dormitory.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Particular attention in the teaching is paid to culture as a means of raising the spiritual level of the people.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The peculiarity of this doctrine is its pronounced ethical and practical orientation.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The teaching develops in detail the goals and methods of spiritual practice and moral and spiritual principles, psychophysiological conditions for self-improvement and methods of psycho-spiritual protection.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Fundamentals of religious studies.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Ch. XVII. Non-confessional syncretic religious philosophy)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

/Y.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

F. Borunkov and I. N. Yablokov et al.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

; Ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND. N. Yablokova.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

— M.: Vyssh.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

shk.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

, 1994. 368 p. ISBN 5-06-002849-6


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Agni Yoga, or Living Ethics, is a philosophical and ethical teaching aimed at revealing the higher psychic abilities of a person with the aim of his inner transformation and mastering cosmic energy - Agni, stimulating the evolution of man and humanity to ever higher forms of cosmic existence.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

It is no coincidence that Agni Yoga is also called the Living Ethics.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

She pays great attention to the inner work of a person on himself, examines in detail the process of self-improvement and ascent to higher forms of being and consciousness.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... An important aspect of Agni Yoga's ethical theory is the affirmation of universal human values in earthly life...


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Fatkhitdinova Yana Yuryevna.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

THE LATEST HISTORY OF THE ROERICH MOVEMENT IN RUSSIA.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The author's abstract of the dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Historical Sciences


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

So since the mid-90s. In the twentieth century, mainly in the dissertation councils of Moscow and St. Petersburg, dissertations were defended on various aspects of the philosophy of Agni Yoga


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(E.A. Trofimova, N.E. Samokhina, D.A. Sharov, S.R. Ableev, A.M. Khachatryan); creativity, cultural and aesthetic views of the Roerichs


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(N.V. Tyutigina, M. Tkhakur, I.A. Zhernosenko, V.V. Volkov, E.P. Yakovleva, A.O. Bukin, O.A. Kozina, L.V. Korotkina); pedagogical ideas of the Living Ethics and the work of E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich: A.G.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Andreyeva


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Andreyeva Angelina Gavrilovna. Pedagogical foundations of spiritual education in the Teaching of the Living Ethics. Dissertations for the candidate of pedagogical sciences. M., 1996 //Moscow State Open Pedagogical University. - M., 1996), L.N.Osipova


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Osipova Lyubov Nikolaevna.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Public educational activities and pedagogical views of Y.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(1879 — 1955).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Pedagogical Sciences.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Saransk, 1999), S.M.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Kudryavtseva


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Kudryavtseva Svetlana Mikhailovna.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Methodology of musical and aesthetic education of schoolchildren by means of an integrative approach to teaching


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(based on the Roerich concept of aesthetic education).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Dissertations for the degree of Candidate of Pedagogical Sciences.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Moscow, 2000.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

//Moscow State Open Pedagogical University), N.D.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Lashchenko


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Nataliia Laschenko. Philosophical and pedagogical views of E.I. Roerich. Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Pedagogical Sciences. Belgorod, 2001. //Belgorod State University), Kozlova P.P.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Shlemova Natalya Anatolyevna.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Aesthetic views in the Living Ethics Teaching.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Philosophical Sciences Moscow, 2006.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Moscow State University of Service.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The Living Ethics is a spiritual and philosophical teaching, i.e.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

it combines knowledge and moral and practical conclusions from it.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Mikhail Yu. Shishin.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The noospheric concept of culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The abstract of the dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Specialty 24.00.01 - Theory and History of Culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Barnaul — 2003 Altai State University


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

It is also noted that the noospheric concept is related to the original philosophical and ethical doctrine “Living Ethics” associated with the names of N.K.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

and E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND. Roerich, which many authors also refer to the direction of Russian cosmism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Sergey Khomuttsov.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Spirituality, its similarities and antipodes in culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Specialty 24.00.01 — Theory and History of Culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

BARNAUL, 2009


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Original ideas reflecting the creative potential of spirituality are set out in the teachings of... N.K.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich and E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich et al.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

These authors creatively used the experience of spiritual searches of the East, relied on the ideas of synthesizing various areas of cognitive activity.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Novikov Aleksandr Anatolyevich.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The concept of a new person in the teaching of living ethics: dissertation... Candidate of Philosophical Sciences: 09.00.13 Moscow, 2006


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The teaching of the Living Ethics is a synthesis of various philosophical concepts of East and West, scientific knowledge, religious experience of people and art.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Amalia Khachatryan.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The problem of women and family in the philosophy of the Living


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(socio-philosophical aspect).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Specialty 09.00.1 I.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- social philosophy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Abstract of the Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Philosophical Sciences.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Moscow -1998


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The knowledge system of the Living Ethics teachings synthesizes philosophical approaches in the development of ethical, social, anthropological, psychological problems.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... Spiritual and Philosophical Teaching of the Living Ethics


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Agni Yogi), 14 books of which were recorded by E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(1879-1955), is a further development of the ideas of the “Secret Doctrine” by E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

P.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Vlavatskaya


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Both works are based on the same sources, combine the traditions of Eastern and Western philosophy, esoteric and modern scientific knowledge of the world and represent a unique spiritual phenomenon.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Nikolay Konstantinovich Roerich/Cultural Studies.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

20th century.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Encyclopedia.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- St. Petersburg: University Book, 1998.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

S.YA.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Leviticus.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ISBN 5-7914-0029-2


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... the creator of an original moral, philosophical and religious and aesthetic teaching, at the center of which is culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Roerich N.K.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

/Philosophers of Russia XIX-XX centuries.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Biographies, ideas, works.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- 3rd ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- Moscow: Academic Projects, 1999.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

P.V.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Alekseev.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ISBN 5-8291-0003-7


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... the spiritual doctrine proclaimed by E.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AND.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

and N.K.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The Roerichs, is called Agni Yoga


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(or “Living Ethics”).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Ethics: Encyclopedic dictionary/ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

R.G


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Apresyan and A.A.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Huseynova.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- M.: Gardariki, 2001.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Institute of Philosophy RAS.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ISBN 5-8297-0049-2


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The Living Ethics, or Agni Yoga, is a spiritual and moral doctrine that arose in the 1920s within the framework of the occult-theosophical tradition of knowledge and esoteric wisdom of the East.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... In place of mediumistic and magical occultism, the elements of which were so widely represented in Blavatsky's work, the teaching of the Living Ethics puts a kind of ethical occultism that emanates from the central position of ethics in the spiritual synthesis of knowledge.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... “Ethical occultism” is expressed in the development of spirituality through everyday moral asceticism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 11:28, January 4, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

O.A.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Lavrenova.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Through mountains and deserts /Science in Russia.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- Publishing House of the Presidium of the RAS.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- #5, 2011.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- page 73-82


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In this source, in a note to the article made by the editorial staff of the magazine, the following definition is given: “The Living Ethics, or Agni Yoga, is a philosophical doctrine that indicates a single spiritual and energy basis universe and considering the spiritual and moral aspects of being.”


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 05:30, February 3, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Scan copy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 05:34, February 3, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Authority of sources


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

1. Shlemova Natalya Anatolyevna.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Aesthetic views in the Living Ethics Teaching.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Philosophical Sciences Moscow, 2006.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Moscow State University of Service.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

According to her own, she did not have publications in refereed journals at the time of defending her dissertation, only some collections.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

She defended herself according to the monograph, the review of it is here: P.S.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Gurevich/ New books by our colleagues// Personality.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Culture.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Society.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Volume 9.Vol. 4.- M.: IF RAS, 2007.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

It would be nice to get it.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 20:45, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

2. Amalia Khachatryan.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The problem of women and family in the philosophy of the Living


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(socio-philosophical aspect).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Specialty 09.00.1 I.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- social philosophy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Abstract of the Dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Philosophical Sciences.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Moscow -1998


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

It's even worse here: 1


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(in words — one)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

collection, 1


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(in words — one)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

newspaper article


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(sic!!!) , 1


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(in words — one)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

article deposited with INION RAS.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“I love it!” —Melirius 20:55, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Uv.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Melirius, in this topic, the usual method of assessing sources is not fully suitable.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

First of all, it is necessary to check whether this is an adept of the doctrine and whether it is not a functionary of one of the Roerich organizations.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

At the same time, if approached in good faith, it is better to either throw away sources, even with suspicions of “infection”, or use them with extreme caution.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Van Helsing 21:00, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I understand, but even the usual methods reveal such abyss here.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 21:08, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

3. Roerich N.K.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

/Philosophers of Russia XIX-XX centuries.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Biographies, ideas, works.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- 3rd ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- Moscow: Academic Projects, 1999.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

P.V.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Alekseev.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ISBN 5-8291-0003-7


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Article author A. IN. Ivanov, a respectable doctor of philology But, as you can easily see, he is an active participant in the Roerich movement


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(proofs:,,).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 21:08, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

4. Ethics: Encyclopedic dictionary/ed.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

R.G


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Apresyan and A.A.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Huseynova.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

- M.: Gardariki, 2001.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Institute of Philosophy RAS.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

ISBN 5-8297-0049-2


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The article's author V. N. Nazarov, he is also the author of the textbook


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(sic!!!)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“Introduction to Esotericism,” written, I quote from, so


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(my highlight):


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“The textbook has been prepared in line with the third generation standards.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

This is the first textbook on esotericism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Its purpose is to analyze esoteric teachings based on the criteria for the reliability of esoteric knowledge:


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

a)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

superhuman source


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

b)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

initiative experience,


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

c)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

symbolic language.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Isn't it honey?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 21:39, January 19, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

IN. N. Nazarov said.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The approach to assessing the authority of all sources should be unified and equal, regardless of the preferences of Wikipedia editors.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

But you probably didn't know that A.A.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Gritsanov, in addition to being the editor-in-chief of the “Newest Philosophical Dictionary” - on the basis of which a definitive “religious and philosophical doctrine” is included in the preamble of the Living Ethics - is also editor-in-chief of the encyclopedia “Esotericism”, in which he gives vent to his philosophical interest in esotericism and occultism is no more materialistic than Nazarov does in his textbook.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

And if we question the authority of the academic dictionary, in which Nazarov is just a peer-reviewed author of the article, then it is all the more necessary to question the authority of the dictionaries edited Gritsanov, and 100% remove the definitive “religious and philosophical” from the preamble.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

AV


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Ivanov is not just a doctor of philosophical sciences - he is the head of the Department of Philosophy of Altai State Agrarian University, has many scientific publications, the author and co-author of several philosophical monographs, he is invited to write articles for academic dictionaries - i.e.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

he is a very prominent and respected academic philosopher of the RAS system.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The fact that one of his professional philosophical interests is the Living Ethics does not detract from his merits as an academic philosopher.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

And the fact that the editorial staff of the Institute of Philosophy of the Russian Academy of Sciences invited him to write an article on the Roerichs in this respected philosophical dictionary only confirms my idea.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

This suggests that the mainstream of philosophical science in Russia is aware of his interest in the Roerichs and, at the same time, trusts his high professionalism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 15:20, January 20, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

OK, we will record the absence of complaints about the lack of authority of Shlemova and Khachatryan's dissertations.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Will you cross them out yourself or should I do it?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

1. We're not talking about A. A. Gritsanov — we are discussing V. N. Nazarova.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Since Nazarov is deeply marginal as an epistemologist, I cannot recognize his definition as authoritative if I want to.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Ksta-ati,


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(the highlight is mine)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“AGNI YOGA or Living Ethics, the Teaching of Life is a religious and philosophical doctrine that claims to synthesize the ancient thought of the East, as well as scientific achievements and spiritual and practical experience of modern mankind.” Why didn't you give this definition?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

2. All of the above regalia A. IN. Ivanov does not mean anything compared to his affiliation, and since GE is not mainstream, nothing


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(neither in philosophy, nor in religion, nor in poorly defined “spiritual teachings”), then as a result, his views fall under VP:MARG.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 16:10, January 20, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“All of the above regalia by A. IN. Ivanov does not mean anything compared to his affiliation” - I especially ask you to note that painting Ivanov's regalia on 2 kb Alexander Ustimenko a)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

acts in disregard of decisions on claims 537 and 346.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

b)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

acts in ignoring Discussion: Living Ethics #Новая philosophical encyclopedia, articles by A.V.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Ivanova is an affiliated source.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I don't think it is necessary to explain why this is bad.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Is it necessary to explain that it is bad to constantly read Alexander Ustimenko's proposals to cut down the “religious and philosophical”?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Van Helsing 18:35, January 20, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Shlemova and Khachatryan's dissertations are secondary to me, so I have not yet analyzed your claims on them.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I'll come back to them later.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

No, dear colleague, a scientific approach requires the development of common criteria for assessing sources.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

You proposed a criterion - the author is interested in esotericism and wrote a textbook on esotericism, in which you did not like something there.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I say that the same criterion is one hundred percent suitable for withdrawing all Gritsanov's dictionaries - he is interested in esotericism, collected and published the encyclopedia “Esotericism”, in which, in particular, he defines esotericism as another type of rationality in culture, along with science and religion.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Which, as far as I remember, you didn't like much either.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

And, by the way, Gritsanov's dictionary is the only AI that directly, and not indirectly, defines the Living Ethics as a religious and philosophical doctrine.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I gave a definition from Gritsanov's dictionary - there is a link to the discussion on the WU at the top, which contains the main body of sources on the Living Ethics.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

On this page, I have listed only additional sources that were not taken into account in the discussion on the TR.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In general, I have a big suspicion that interest in esoteric and oriental teachings as a different type of rationality, additional to the scientific type of rationality, is mainstream in modern philosophy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I have already cited you, at the SO selection of intermediaries, a quote from the work of Academician Stepin: “He


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(Russian cosmism, which includes the Living Ethics - A.U.)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

is able to play a positive role in the synthesis of ideas developed in the Western European cultural tradition and in Eastern philosophical systems, where a person was initially considered as an integral part space.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Accordingly, the ideas of cosmism are organically included in the development of a new metaphysics, which could become the philosophical basis of the post-non-classical stage of development of science, ensuring further development general scientific picture of the world in line with the ideology of global evolutionism, ideas about “human-sized”, historically developing systems and the ideals of “anthropocosmism”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The open nature of the modern scientific picture of the world reveals its amazing proportionality not only to the principles of the philosophy of Russian cosmism, but also to many ideological ideas developed in traditional oriental cultures.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“. About this is what Gritsanov says in his encyclopedia “Esotericism”. Similar thoughts are expressed by S.V. Khomuttsov, Doctor of Philosophy, in his previously quoted dissertation in connection with the concept of spirituality: “On the basis of the traditional division of human culture into the eastern and the Western justifies the possibility of distinguishing the Eastern and Western types of spirituality with new arguments for this division.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... Achieving a spiritual balance between Eastern and Western spirituality in a specific socio-cultural situation is of particular importance.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... The cultural-philosophical approach to the study of spirituality is substantiated, which makes it possible to integrate the constantly growing experience of understanding and expressing spirituality in the cultures of mankind.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Based on the achievements of various areas of modern knowledge, the cultural and philosophical approach creates a single research space and allows us to comprehend spirituality in all the variety of its forms manifestations.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

... In this situation, there is a need to synthesize the spiritual achievements of different cultures and traditions, diverse spheres of spiritual existence


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(religion, art, science, philosophy, etc.)...” I think this is a general trend in philosophy in general and in the philosophy of science in particular.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

2. WITH AV


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Ivanov has two “shackles”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

1. He is an academic philosopher and is not affiliated with any Roerich organization.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

His interest in the Living Ethics is clearly visible - but it is also clear that this interest does not go beyond his professional interests as a philosopher, in line with the trend in philosophy I wrote about above.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

2. And I already wrote this in my answer to Vajrapani: philosophical dictionaries are not collections of author's articles; they are a collective work of many authors under the guidance and censorship of an authoritative editorial board.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Authors of individual articles of authoritative dictionaries are not free to unleash their imagination or personal preferences - because responsibility and control for the reliability and scientific adequacy of each article the editorial board carries in the dictionary.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 08:02, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“And, by the way, Gritsanov's dictionary is the only AI that directly, and not indirectly, defines the Living Ethics as a religious and philosophical doctrine.” - Well, challenge Gritsanov - you will only be left with religious, no question.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

All participant constructions according to A.V.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I leave Ivanov with frames and channels without attention.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Van Helsing 08:12, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I think you've already refused to discuss it with me, haven't you?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 08:58, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Twenty-five again.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“Russian cosmism, which includes the Living Ethics” — please decide whether ZhE treats cosmism this way or not, otherwise I have already heard both from you, if my memory serves me correctly.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I will highlight the key words of the quote in bold: “Accordingly, the ideas of cosmism are organically included in the development of a new metaphysics, which could become the philosophical basis of the post-non-classical stage of development science, ensuring the further development of the general scientific picture of the world in line with the ideology of global evolutionism, ideas about “human-sized”, historically developing systems and ideals” anthropocosmism.” — that is, I have not yet become, VP: NEGUSHCHA, how many times do I repeat?


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 15:32, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Some authors attribute Living Ethics to Russian cosmism, some do not consider it.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

One author refers to the conceptual core of Russian cosmism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Sources


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(part)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

are listed on the SO Living Ethics.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

According to Stepin and other philosophers, they note a clearly defined trend in modern philosophy and science.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I.e.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

the study of issues related to this trend may well be the mainstream in modern philosophy.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

A professional philosopher could answer this question more precisely.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

There is one among our intermediaries.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 06:25, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Sad: VP:NEGUSHCHA.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

The renaming of Belarus → Belarus was turned into AK, despite the “clearly defined trend”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

So until this trend becomes mainstream — “everyone to the garden”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 12:45, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

After all, we are talking about assessing sources and “outside”


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(from Wikipedia)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

the worldviews of their authors, and not about the reasons for adding information to the article


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(where VP:NEGUSHCHA works).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 06:38, January 27, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

And I'm talking about the same thing: you can only evaluate sources as mainstream when they become mainstream, but not earlier.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 08:57, January 27, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

1. No problem, I'll refer to Yablokov.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Let's exclude Gritsanov with his marginal type of rationality — I don't mind.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 15:32, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

There are problems with Gritsanov - his “Newest Philosophical Dictionary” on Wikipedia is noted among the sources that deserve the greatest trust.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

To be more precise, the quote: “On this page, we collect links to sources that are very likely to be trusted. There are not many links, but this is the situation where “less is more”.” Despite his interest in esotericism.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Personally, I am against the withdrawal of academic sources according to such far-fetched criteria - the professional interests of professional philosophers should not become a reason for the withdrawal of their works.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In addition, the mainstream in philosophy does not have to correspond to the worldview preferences of Wikipedia editors.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

No problem, this is the definition in parallel to me.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I will neither defend nor reject it, although IMHO Gritsanov's views are not mainstream.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 12:45, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

2. If a philosopher writes articles in the spirit of “How do we reorganize Rabkrin</s> ORTHODOXY AND LIVING ETHICS: THE ESSENCE OF DISCREPANCIES AND PROSPECTS FOR DIALOGUE” and others cited, he is such an interested person that none of his works can be considered credible secondary sources for housing and communal services.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

This has already been dealt with, including by the Arbitration Committee.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 15:32, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

All right, let's put this question to the mediators.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In a more general form: how to assess the authority of academic dictionaries and encyclopedias - in general, based on the authority of the editorial board; or for each article separately, regardless of the authority of the encyclopedia as a whole.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

But before that, let's do a thought experiment.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Let's write a letter to the Institute of Philosophy of the Russian Academy of Sciences, to the editorial board of the dictionary we are discussing.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Approximately the following: “Dear Editorial Board! We, the editor of Wikipedia and such, have found in your dictionary a dubious author - Doctor of Philology Ivanov, who, according to our information, is a supporter of the ideas of the Living Ethics. In this regard, we have a question for you: is the respected editorial board fully responsible for the accuracy and adequacy of the information in the articles of this author in your dictionary? Or do these articles reflect Ivanov's author's point of view, with which the respected editorial board may not agree?” Try first to say what the most likely answer of the respected editorial board will be.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

If it differs from mine, which I have already voiced in general terms, then we will ask the mediators the same question.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 06:25, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

It is quite acceptable both.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Errare humanum est, and: “It was decided not to make a single mistake. Twenty proofreads were kept. And still, the title page read: “Encyclopodia Britannica.”


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(AND. Ilf, Notebooks)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

So I will not guess for the editorial office, and I am for a question to the mediators.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Nevertheless, the issue was dealt with by the AK with a general conclusion about special caution in this case.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 12:45, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I liked the joke... But we are not talking about grammatical errors, but about the responsibility of the editorial board for the adequate semantic content of the articles in its dictionary.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In addition, if we evaluate the authority of each article separately, and not the entire dictionary as a whole, then articles by authors who do not have a scientific degree will not be authoritative according to VP:AI.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

But let's wait for what the middlemen say.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 16:18, January 26, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

3. According to Shlyomova's dissertation.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Quote: “The main provisions of the dissertation were set out in a report made in the Aesthetics sector of the Institute of Physics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, and scientific publications


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(with a total volume of 7 a.l.)...” is a volume that is quite sufficient to defend a candidate's dissertation.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In addition, it is allowed to defend dissertations in the form of a monograph - and as far as I remember, you put the authority of monographs almost higher than all other scientific publications.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 08:58, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“You're confusing me with someone else.” Fundamental monographs by recognized experts in the field with a huge number of citations a la Fock's Theory of Space, Time and Gravity are yes, it is “cooler than Goethe's Faust”.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Other monographs are at the level of the articles on which they are based, as well as dissertations.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In general, philosophy is defended in a different way — with such a list of publications in physics, they would be wrapped up at once.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 15:32, January 22, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

As far as I remember from my experience, in mathematics, the following requirements are at least three articles in peer-reviewed scientific journals outlining the main ideas of the dissertation.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Either 1


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(alone!)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

monograph.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Naturally, candidate dissertations have less weight than academic dictionaries and encyclopedias, or textbooks for universities - the former reflect the author's position more strongly, and secondly, generalizing the mainstream opinions.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

But it is also impossible to completely ignore candidate dissertations - they show the existing range of opinions on the problem under study.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

In addition, if a dozen candidate dissertations have a similar idea - for example, the Living Ethics is a philosophical system - then this group of dissertations already has quite a lot of weight for articles.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

I evaluate doctoral dissertations at the level of a good monograph.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Alexander Ustimenko 06:25, January 25, 2012


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(UTC)


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

Candidate dissertations “show the existing range of opinions on the problem under study.” — UTC zh. Only opinions can come from an interested source and be quite marginal, even by a whole group


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

(“a similar idea can be traced in a dozen candidate dissertations”).


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

“I evaluate doctoral dissertations at the level of a good monograph.” — Oh, not a fact.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

There are also doctoral theses that a graduate student should be ashamed to defend.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

No one has canceled the citation index yet.


Question: How many directions in the Roerich movement are currently distinguished?

Preamble

—Melirius 12:45, January 25, 2012