Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and only after that can sociologists, psychologists, lawyers, law enforcement agencies and everyone else talk about its dangers and totalitarianism?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The concept of a sect is related to religion, if the participants in the discussion agree with this, it may be better not to use an indefinite expression when formulating these concepts in the preamble: “pseudo-religious organization”, remove it from there altogether?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In my opinion, the preamble will not suffer from this.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Perhaps we should add a reservation to the preamble that this concept is used by some or even individual religious scholars and is not generally accepted among all theologians?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:25, July 21, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A colleague of Wlbw68, frankly speaking, this is not my topic, but remembered that he once watched a video about Dvorkin and decided to review it again, then looked at the author's channel and from new videos: I saw it from him posted interview with Massimo Introvigne - Classification of New Religious Movements You may need it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Iskatelb 15:35, July 21, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

An anonymous article by a journalist based on Internet materials


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I ask the intermediaries to assess the authority of the anonymous article “” to assert that “a universal memorial service is being held in the Orthodox Church.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Article Radonitsa.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is despite the fact that there is a different point of view:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

UNIVERSAL FUNERAL SERVICES, OR UNIVERSAL PARENTAL SATURDAYS


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Meat-empty Saturday; Trinity Parent Saturday; Parent Saturdays of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Weeks of Holy Lent.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On all of the above parental Saturdays, the service is performed according to a special charter and is placed in the Lenten and Tsvetnoy Triodes.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

MEMORIAL DAYS FOR THE DEAD IN THE RUSSIAN ORTHODOX CHURCH


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Radonitsa.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Remembrance days for Orthodox soldiers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

feast of the Beheading of John the Baptist.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dimitrievskaya Saturday


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What are Universal Parent Saturdays


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Among other parents' Saturdays


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(and there are seven in a year)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

there are Ecumenical ones, in which the Orthodox Church prayerfully commemorates all baptized Christians in general.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There are two such Saturdays: Meat-empty


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(a week before Lent)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and Troitskaya


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(on the eve of Pentecost).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On these two days, special services are held — universal panihidas.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On Trinity and Meat-Eating Saturdays, a universal funeral service is held.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Radonitsa falls on the period of the feast, so Radonitsa should not have anything specially for the departed not only at Vespers, Matins and Liturgy, but also at the Compline.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Sometimes allowed to perform a funeral service in Radonitsa with the borrowing of hymns from the service of the universal memorial Saturday before Pentecost and combining them with the service of the feast of AntiEaster, arbitrarily fabricated, has no basis in Typikon.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It does not correspond to either the letter or the spirit of the liturgical Charter of the Orthodox Church, which, in relation to its worship, is always strictly guided by the wise instruction of Ecclesiastes: “Everything has its time... a time to lament, and a time to rejoice”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Eccl. 3, 1, 4).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The Charter of the Orthodox Church does not tolerate and does not allow the mixing of the mournful funeral and the solemn festive...”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Athanasius


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Sakharov), ep.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On the commemoration of the dead under the Charter of the Orthodox Church.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

P. 47-48).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, the source under discussion, not only wrote by a layman, based on materials “from open sources”, but he even hesitated to indicate his name.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, the concept of “universal panihida” contradicts the more authoritative sources of the church itself, which clearly state that the universal funeral service is performed only on meat-eating Saturday; Trinity Parent Saturday; Parent Saturdays of the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Weeks of Holy Lent.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Vladimir Lobachev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

11:54, June 2, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The material was prepared on the basis of information from RIA Novosti and open sources” - not AI, you never know, they took information from Wikipedia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:14, December 22, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Bible Sources


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I ask the intermediaries to assess whether the books below are authoritative sources so that information can be borrowed from them:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. Bishop Veniamin of Vladivostok and Primorsky


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Pushkar): “The Sacred Biblical Story of the Old Testament”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It says:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There are seventy-seven sacred books in the Bible.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of these, 50 are books of the Old Testament and 27 are from the New Testament.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The Old Testament books are divided into canonical books, i.e.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

inspired by God, there are 39 of them, and non-canonical, i.e.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

not inspired by God, but edifying — there are 11 of them.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2. Professor P.A.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yungerov: “Introduction to the Old Testament”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It says:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The general conclusion from the quotations given on the issue of non-canonical books should be as follows: (a)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

they are not inspired by God, b)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

useful and edifying, c)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

above all ordinary works of natural mind, d)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

must be included in sacred biblical lists, and e)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

be assigned to preferential reading for those announced.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Non-canonical books of the Holy Scriptures are books not included in the canon by the church


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(see) as not inspired by God by origin, but attached to it in the codes of the Bible, as useful for piety, edifying


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It says:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Thus, the name “sacred” or “biblical canon” is now attached to the collection of those St.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

books that are accepted by the entire church as inspired by God, guides in the right faith and a virtuous life, in contrast to the books of the “non-canonical”, that is,


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

although edifying and useful, but not accepted in the canon


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

5. Associate Professor Dobykin D.G.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The name of books “non-canonical” is based on the recognition of such books as uninspired.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, non-canonical books of the Holy Scriptures can be called books that, although written by pious men, are not inspired and therefore cannot serve unchanged in all their content the rule of faith and morality, and the definitions of the Church are not included in the list of sacred books inspired by God.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

6. Archpriest, Associate Professor Vladimir Ivanov


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Non-canonical books of the Holy Scriptures are books that, although written by pious men, are not inspired by God and therefore cannot serve as an invariable rule in all their content faith and morals and definitions of the Church are not included in the list of holy inspired books.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

7. Orthodox encyclopedia


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the Orthodox tradition, books that were not included in Heb.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

canon, are considered edifying and useful for reading, but there is no uniformity in their name: they may be called “deuterocanonical”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(like Catholics), “non - canonical” or “anaginoscomene”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(naginoskomenia, i.e. recommended for reading).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The name “deuterocanonical” is borrowed from Catholics and is not due to the Orthodox.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

tradition.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The most common name “non-canonical” is also not satisfactory and can only be taken as a conditional one.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

To an orthodox.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For the Church, the most important evidence of the canonicity of books is their liturgical use.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On this basis, the Book of Wisdom of Solomon or the “non-canonical” portions of Daniel read during worship cannot be considered “non-canonical”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It says here that these books are considered edifying and useful.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The fact that they are inspired by God is not written, that is, this does not contradict the above sources in any way.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksei m


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:20, May 1, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

@Aleksei m: what is your question?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Well, yes, there are canonical books and non-canonical ones.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So what?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:18, December 22, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is it possible, on the basis of these sources, to assert that non-canonical books in the Russian Orthodox Church are not inspired?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Aleksei m


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:32, December 23, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

An expert study by R. N. Lunkin to the article “Sect”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please assess the admissibility of using religious scholar R. N. Lunkin in the article “The Sect”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The argument against it is set out here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

07:09, April 27, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Video of a religious meeting


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is an article by the Kingdom Hall of Jehovah's Witnesses, and there is an official video of them of a typical weekly meeting held in such Halls


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(recording in the genre of a TV show):


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please rate the link to the entry in the relevant “Links” section as in the edit


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(in Sindhi).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

| Xerocracy


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

16:57, April 5, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

VP:NON-TRIBUNE


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(like VP:NEKATALOG)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

they say no, why this change was made.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 20:52, April 5, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The link is no longer working, but as I understand it, there was nothing there that would give additional information specifically about the Kingdom Hall of Jehovah's Witnesses


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(especially considering that such a hall can be “any rented space”, as it is written in the article).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The illustrations in the article should be enough to see how a typical meeting is held, what the room may look like, how people are located in it, etc.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There are not enough reasons for placing a link in the article, and it should not be added.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Alexandrine


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

19:53, August 25, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yasevich-Borodaevskaya


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please assess the authority in the history of Protestantism in Russia source - Yasevich-Borodaevskaya V. AND. Struggle for Faith: Historical and everyday essays and a review of legislation on Old Believers and sectarianism in its consistent development with the application of articles of the law and the highest decrees.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— State Printing House.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— SPb: Nauka, 1912.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— 656 p.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The nomination is very similar to the previous one


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Bonch-Bruevich).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The source is used in a number of Wikipedia articles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

His authority is challenged on the fact of using it in the article Pobedonostsev persecution.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The essence of the claims comes down to the fact that the materials were released at the beginning of the 20th century.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can also familiarize yourself with the claims.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can read about the author on Wikipedia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Her book is an entirely secondary source.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It is an overview of changes in legislation on the persecution of non-Orthodox Christians in the Russian Empire during the Victorious persecution period.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But it is not limited to a simple review of laws, but with a good knowledge of the material describes the actions of these legislative innovations in real life.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As in the case of Bonch-Bruevich, her book is referred to by almost all later researchers on this topic, including modern serious religious scholars.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I do not know much modern research on religious studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(on the subject of Russian Protestantism and Russian sectarianism at the end of the 19th century), which would not contain references to Yasevich-Borodaevskaya's book.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:31, March 6, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to Yu.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

E.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Reshetnikova


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(see), author of a specialized historical and legal study in the field of the legal status of Protestants in the Russian Empire


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

14:36, June 16, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Bonch-Bruevich


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please assess the authority in the history of Protestantism in Russia source Bonch-Bruevich V. D. Persecution of Baptists of the Evangelical Sect. Materials for the History and Study of Russian Sectarianism.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Issue 6. — “Free Words”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Hants, England: Cristchurch, 1902.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— 84 p.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can read about the author himself on Wikipedia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Brochure issues by V. D. Bonch-Bruevich from the series “Materials for the History and Study of Russian Sectarianism”, printed by V. G. Chertkov abroad at the Svobodny Slova publishing house is one of the most famous sources on the history of Protestantism in Russia in the 19th century.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They are primary secondary sources


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(some are the primary documents of Protestants, the other part is introductory articles, comment articles and notes by V. D. Bonch-Bruevich).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I do not know any voluminous modern research on religious studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(on the topic - the history of Russian Protestantism and sectarianism of the late 19th century), which would not contain references to the works of Bonch Bruevich.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Patriarch of Russian Religious Studies L. N. Mitrokhin in the article Protestantism.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

[Atheist's Dictionary].


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Under the LS.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

ed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

L.N. Mitrokhin.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

M., 1990, pp. 56-68.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

reports on Bonch-Bruevich and his works:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“became a leading specialist in the development and implementation of the party's strategy in the religious issue.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A professional revolutionary, Bonch-Bruevich was an active participant in the revolution of 1905, the February and October revolutions of 1917.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

After October


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(until 1920) — Chancellor of the Council of People's Commissars, conducted versatile research work.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Founded


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and was the first director of the State Literary Museum, since 1946 — Director of the Museum of the History of Religion and Atheism of the USSR Academy of Sciences.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Among the numerous publications of Bonch-Bruevich, works on reformation religious and social movements in Russia stand out.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Studying the peasant question, he was increasingly aware of the role of sectarianism as a specific form of popular opposition to tsarism.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In 1901, he began publishing books about sectarians in Tolstoy's Svobodny Slovo publishing house, consistently rejecting the principle of non-resistance to evil by violence and trying to attract democratic elements of sectarianism to a revolutionary struggle, to bring social democratic consciousness to the very depths of the masses.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

He proceeded from the instructions of V. AND. Lenin in his work “What to do?” : be able to “dictate a positive program of action” and “worried students, and dissatisfied Zemstvo, and indignant sectarians, and offended public teachers...”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Full collection of works. VOL. 6. P. 86).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to the report written by Bonch-Bruevich, the II Congress of the RSDLP decided: “The II Congress draws the attention of all party members to work among sectarians in order to attract them to social democracy. The Congress instructs the Central Committee to deal with the issue of the proposal consisting in the report of T. Bonch-Bruevich”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(CPSU in Resolutions. 7th ed., 1954. H. I. P. 48).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The theoretical support of the party program required Bonch-Bruevich to revise the then prevailing concepts of sectarianism, both Orthodox-clerical and liberal-bourgeois


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(A. S. Prugavin S. P. Melgunov, etc.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It was Bonch-Bruevich who laid the foundations for a scientific understanding of religious and social movements in Russia, explained the diversity and change of sectarian movements as a reflection of various class and political interests their followers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Instead of the then dominant division of sects into mystical and rationalist, Bonch-Bruevich proposed a division into “free-thinking”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(whips, Doukhobors, Molokans, Malevans, Ilintsy Jehovah's Witnesses)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and “evangelicals”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Baptists, or Old Stundists, Pashkovtsy, Redstokists).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This classification was a step forward in the scientific understanding of sectarianism, anticipated the classification currently adopted in science to pre-reform


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(russian)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

sectarianism, which arose as a result of the reformation processes taking place in the country, and post-reform sectarianism


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(western)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— which is a gradually developing Protestant churches of the Western European model.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

From 1908 until the February Revolution, Bonch-Bruevich published 6 volumes of Materials on the History of Religious and Social Movements in Russia.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

you can get acquainted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:19, March 6, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would not use, especially in controversial cases, this is too old a source, religious studies have advanced significantly since that time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And in Soviet religious studies, old sources are also often non-neutral, have an atheistic and political orientation: “The atheist and Bolshevik-Leninist Bonch-Bruevich undoubtedly made a significant contribution to the formation of religious studies in the USSR, but it is equally certain that the main practical prerequisite of the Soviet program is that religion is studied with the aim of criticizing religion and, in the future, eliminating it as a reactionary social force, was shared by him, despite all his sympathies for representatives of domestic marginal religiosity. For more information on its activities, see Ch. “The Study of “Sects” in Soviet Religious Studies: Terminology and Approaches”.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And another interesting phrase from this chapter, where Bonch-Bruevich is put on a par with Lenin: “First, the study of sectarianism moves from the domain of theology to the domain of social sciences and clearly acquires socio-political orientation. Thanks to this, secondly, the understanding of the essence of the sectarian movement itself is changing, the basis of which is laid by V. AND. Lenin and V. D. Bonch-Bruevich, written in the late 19th - early 20th centuries”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Science of Religion, Scientific Atheism, Religious Studies: Actual Problems of Scientific Study of Religion in Russia in the 20th — Early 21st Centuries. — M.: Publishing House of PSTGU, 2014. — 263 p.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And the older the Soviet source, the more unneutral and superficial, says E.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

N. Vasilyeva: “During the Soviet period, sects were actively studied by Marxist religious scholars.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the early Soviet period of the 1920s and 1930s.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

a great contribution to the study of Old Russian sects was made by V.D.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Bonch-Bruevich.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Works by A. Lukachevsky, F.M.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Putintseva, A.I.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Klibanova


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and some other authors bore the stamp of the acute ideological and political struggle of those years.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

However, since the 1960s.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

, the study of sects has acquired a deeper research character”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(Vasilieva E. N. Weber-Trelch's “church-sect” typology and its development in Western and domestic religious studies: Abstract of diss.... Candidate of Philosophical Sciences: 09.00.13/ [Place of defense: Institution of the Russian Institute of Philosophy of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. - Moscow, 2008.- 160 p.).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Rafinin


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

15:20, March 6, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In my opinion, it is necessary to look at the situation and at the general context of the issue, especially since the rules state that “Authority is relative, specific and contextually dependent”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(WP:OAI).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As a religious scholar who has recorded the very fact of an event, he must pass as a noteworthy source.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

15:35, March 6, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I have to apologize and explain that to some extent I misled the participants and myself, as they say, “bought” the onslaught without checking the statements of my opponent, a colleague of MPowerDrive.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The fact is that in the article Pobedonostsev's persecution of Bonch-Bruevich there are only two references.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And both are not on the actual conclusions and comments of V. D. Bonch-Bruevich, but on the PRIMARY sources that were contained in his brochures.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In one case, this is written by V. G. Pavlov, a certificate of the baptism in the Orthodox Church of 7 Baptist children by deceptive and violent means.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The second is a description of the village of Giryusy, where several dozen Baptists and Stundists were exiled.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for the second case, I could confirm from other primary sources that 1)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Russian “sectarians” really referred to Giryus, 2)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

that the living conditions of the exiles there were really difficult


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(without minor details).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, if necessary, I can provide evidence that the primary documents published by V. D. Bonch-Bruevich was really exiled


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(without questioning their credibility)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

indisputable authorities in religious studies A. AND. Klibanov L. N. Mitrokhin and others, including the most modern ones, who are not at all affiliated with Protestants.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

What does this mean?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That the references to Bonch-Bruevich in the article Pobedonostsev's persecution are all the more authoritative, since the argument “Bonch-Bruevich made his conclusions 100 years ago and his opinion is outdated” disappears by itself.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The article does not use his conclusions, but the testimonies he collected, which are recognized as true by modern religious scholars—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

09:49, March 7, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Lev Simkin.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The American Dream of a Russian Sectarian


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Please assess the authority of the book Lev Simkin.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The American dream of a Russian sectarian.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— Moscow: Zebra, 2012.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— 384 p. — 2000 copies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— ISBN 978-5-905629-10-5.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Here it is.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Here are annotations with reviews


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

of the book itself.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On Wikipedia, the book is used as an AI in the articles Dukhobor pogrom


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(1895), Siberian Seven, Religious emigration from Russia and the USSR.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

21:34, March 3, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The claim against the AI was made here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The argument was that Simkin is a lawyer, not a historian.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

22:47, March 3, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Simkin's works on the history of Russian Protestantism were published in the magazines “Religion and Law”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and “Znamya”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Andrey dementev


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

00:42, March 4, 2017


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I looked at the book on Krotov's website.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is not a strictly academic publication, rather historical journalism, but of a high level, there is a competent reference apparatus.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The author is quite authoritative, the reviews are positive.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

With appropriate attribution, it is quite possible.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there are objections to specific episodes, you can discuss it separately.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Divot


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

17:47, December 22, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

source: S. AND. Ivanenko about the Russian Falun Dafa Center for Spiritual and Physical Improvement


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dear intermediaries, please assess the authority of the source:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Falun Gong SO discussed this source Discussion: Falun Gong #По about the rollback of edit 74215498 by RU.disciplines by Tempus


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I consider the arguments presented by my colleague Tempus unconvincing, and consensus on this issue has not been reached.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—G Dr 99


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

12:16, October 12, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“I think the arguments given by my colleague Tempus are unconvincing” — And what is their “unconvincing”?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would like to note separately that the style of this “conclusion” is simply touching: In April 1999, an article discrediting Falun Gong was published in the Chinese media.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Students in the big city of Tianjing


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(near Beijing) who were peacefully protesting against it were detained by the police and beaten.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

On April 25, 1999, 10,000 Falun Gong students lined up around the Zhongnanhai Government Residence in Beijing.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

After standing silently for several hours and receiving assurances from the Prime Minister about the positive decision of this case, the students calmly dispersed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Falun Gong was soon banned in China on the basis of a fabricated false book and videos defaming Falun Gong and its founder, Master Li Hongzhi.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is this how an objective text should be written?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And Ivanenko is under this text in the presence of a notary.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would also like to note that Ivanenko is not a Sinologist and does not speak foreign languages in order to conduct an in-depth analysis, and not a simple retelling of what the customer gave him.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And whoever ordered him was Jehovah's Witnesses, Krishnas and Scientologists.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, it is built exclusively on Falgungunov's links.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 13:07, October 12, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would like to add that the only publication of this text is a scan posted on faluninfo.ru, and the only “imprint” present in it is the seal of the personnel department (!).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That is, this “conclusion” should be considered either an unpublished manuscript or a publication of a resource directly affiliated with the topic of the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In both cases, AI does not pull.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The same applies to the personality of the author himself - a candidate's degree in Russian Orthodoxy, a doctorate in Jehovah's Witnesses - on VP: again, an expert on Falun Gong and China does not pull, even if we ignore him, say so, a pronounced author's position.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And let me remind you of AK:984's recommendation to G Dr 99 participant, which, unfortunately, he stubbornly continues to forget:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Arbitrators believe that the activities of G Dr 99 in articles about Falun Gong, to which the participant makes non-neutral changes


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(similar in essence to edits made from Westcoast00 and Eve Lvova accounts) has signs of a conflict of interest, and therefore strongly recommends that the participant focus on off-topic edits Falun Gong, and on other topics that are not conflicting and difficult, or find a mentor.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Otherwise, the continuation of violations will result in restrictions


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(ban topics and locks).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Khroniker


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

14:43, October 12, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ivanenko is quite an authoritative scientist in the field of religious studies


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

especially since his work is an examination and cannot be considered ordered.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for Raskin, your colleague made the same arguments, and reg scholar Ounby was also suspected of custom work Discussion: Falun Gong #Основа articles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In this case, I suggest checking all dissertations and scientific papers in the Falun Gong article for:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. Is the author a sinologist?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2. Is the author an authoritative scholar in the field of religious studies?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3. Where the dissertation data were published.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—G Dr 99


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

13:26, October 13, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Ivanenko is quite an authoritative scientist in the field of religious studies, especially since his work is an examination and cannot be considered ordered.” — It depends on what, since the VP: OAI says that” Authority is relative, specific, and contextually dependent. Relativity means that there are no sources for Wikipedia that are authoritative on any issue or not authoritative on any issue. Concreteness and contextual dependence means that the issue of authority is most often considered in relation to a particular statement.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Expertise by definition is a custom work, since any such work always has someone who made a request.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

An additional confirmation of this is the seal and signature of the notary.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If Ivanenko simply wrote a study, he would publish it in a peer-reviewed journal, where there is an editorial office that checks the facts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“As for Raskin, your colleague made the same arguments, and reg scholar Ounby was also suspected of custom work Discussion: Falun Gong #Основа articles.” — Yes, Raskin has exactly the same custom work.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for Ounby, I never claimed that he wrote a commissioned work.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So don't take credit for what I didn't say.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Here I just misunderstood Timofey Vatolin, mistakenly thinking that it was about another person.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1. Is the author a sinologist?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

- Again, I advise you to consider VP:OAI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And also carefully read AK:350, where everything is clearly stated about the sources.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 15:28, October 13, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A colleague of Tempus, fully agrees that the Falun Gong article should follow the recommendations given in AK:350, some of the recommendations given in AK:350 are not followed, so the Falun Gong article lacks neutrality and balance.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The presentation of current events should be balanced, they should be considered with a certain degree of detachment.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(WP:CHNYAV #Википедия is not a means to spread new ideas).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Wikipedia should not be used as a platform or as a propaganda voice.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(VP:CHNYAV #Википедия is not a tribune)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—G Dr 99


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

21:24, October 14, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In that case, if you agree, Ivanenko says goodbye! and we close this protracted discussion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 11:45, October 15, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A Tempus colleague, as I understand it, only the mediator has the right to close the discussion when summing up the result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I still consider Ivanenko and Raskina to be authoritative scientists who can be referred to in the Falun Gong article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—G Dr 99


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

10:45, October 16, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

You can continue to count as much as you like, and articles will be written with links to normal sources of unbiased researchers, and not on the basis of low-quality orders.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I believe that there is a VP:INAUDIBLE and I ask my colleague PTQa to draw a line under the discussion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Dixi.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 11:13, October 16, 2016


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Preliminary result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

According to this source, Ivanenko S. I. was written solely on the basis of materials provided to him by Falun Gong followers “(on the material of the Falun Dafa Center for Spiritual and Physical Improvement in Russia)”, and this is also can be clearly seen from the content of this opinion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Accordingly, this source cannot be recognized as an independent secondary source according to VP:NVI, regardless of its authority.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, the source can be considered as a publication on the rights of samizdat


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(see VP:SAMIZDAT), and in these cases there are increased requirements for authority for the author, at the level of VP:EXPERT.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Ivanenko is clearly not an expert on Falun Gong, so this publication cannot be recognized as authoritative sources on Falun Gong.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Only if this source is considered by independent authoritative sources, this source can be considered as an authoritative primary source on the topic “Conclusion of Doctor of Philosophy S. AND. Ivanenko about the Russian Falun Dafa Center for Spiritual and Physical Improvement”, but not on the topic of Falun Gong in general.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Igrek


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(obs.)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

20:24, November 18, 2018


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

(UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Golden Rules of Folk Culture” by Oksana Kotovich, Yanka Kruk


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The book is written in a popular science style like advice for every day.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The authors themselves are engaged in popularizing signs and superstitions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I found where Ivan Krug broadcasts that pancakes are baked on Maslenitsa, and no one knows already that the first pancake for Maslenitsa should be put in the Red Corner.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

or for example, the pettiness of the soul because we don't know our culture.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We do not observe customs, do not pay attention to rituals, do not believe in signs.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In fact, the authors promote completely non-scientific views, such as: Have you heard what kind of accidental they beat desperately?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Note that they do not just beat — they are desperate!


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Failure to perform rituals ends with the fact that a person will be sick.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

this position does not indicate a scientific approach.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I ask the intermediaries to check for both the authority and compliance of the VP:MARG is an undesirable popularization of marginal theories.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Anahoret (obs) 07:24, October 2, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I have not seen the book, but the claims made sound strange: the popular science style is not an obstacle in itself that the book is not an authoritative source; and the authors have the right to express interview any views.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yanka Kruk is a Candidate of Philological Sciences, Head of the Department of Ethnology and Folklore of the Belarusian State University of Culture and Arts.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Moreover, we should not forget about relative authority: the important thing is not whether he believes in what he writes or not, but whether he falsifies what he writes.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is there any basis for the latter statement?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If not, there is no reason to doubt authority yet.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Beryllium (obs) 08:33, October 2, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The publishing house “Adukatsyya i vykhavanne” publishes most Belarusian textbooks, the founder is the Ministry of Education of the Republic of Belarus.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yanka (Ivan Ivanovich) Kruk is a candidate of philological sciences, rector of the Institute of Culture of Belarus, a researcher of the traditional spiritual culture of Belarusians.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

He is engaged in the reconstruction of the Slavic mythopoetic model of the world, the archaic calendar, the study of archetypes and symbols of Belarusian mythology and folklore.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

He is the author of 9 monographs, 15 brochures, more than 1000 articles.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Based on this, I see no reason to consider this book not authoritative in matters of folk culture.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Lobachev Vladimir (obs) 09:17, October 2, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The VP:STYLE rule applies to the texts of Wikipedia articles, not the texts of its sources.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If the source is written in a “lightweight” popular science style, we simply retell its contents in a scientific encyclopedic style.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This does not reduce the source's assessment.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The VP:MARG rule also applies not to the style of the source, but to its content, to the meaning of what it states.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Specialists can simplify some things for non-specialists, explain them in a popular way — and this will not be a marginal theory.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Marginal theory is something that is supported by very few, contradicts modern scientific consensus.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It contradicts precisely in the meaning of what is written, and not in style.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, scientific publications by the same authors are preferable to Wikipedia — but they are likely to be much less publicly available.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, a Wikipedia user who has difficulty accessing the scientific works of the same authors may well use popular science.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega 18:47, December 21, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Mitrokhin's opinion


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We ask respected mediators to evaluate this opinion for the section Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Kiev Patriarchate #Современное state and structure Sociologist of Religion and historian, researcher Center for the Study of Eastern Europe at the University of Bremen N. A. Mitrokhin in May 2016, in an interview with the Religious Information Service of Ukraine, following his observations during a trip to the south of the country, noted that “the number of parishes of the UOC of the Kiev Patriarchate outside Western Ukraine, about 50-70% less than officially registered ones”, while for the “UOC (MP) it is about 12-15%” [4].


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Commenting on the UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate, he said that “there is a complex dynamics of the growth of the pro-Ukrainian part, the redistribution of forces, intellectual growth, and the reassessment of theological heritage, etc.” I believe that only the first sentence is needed, as it is directly related to the topic of the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The second sentence added by Shamash, on the contrary, is inappropriate, since it does not apply to this article at all.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 03:12, August 28, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Your opponent did not dispute the source, and therefore the presentation of the discussion at the KOI is surprising, especially since you did not initiate a discussion related to this fragment and did not try to listen to the opinion other participants.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, you ignored the direct presence of the fragment in the article (see the edit description).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Now, on the merits:


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The insertion of Mitrokhin's opinion comes out of nowhere and it is not clear why.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is no related narrative in the article to which his opinion can be linked.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is the reason why the template was installed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

<i data-parsoid='{"dsr":[287935,287940,2,2]}'>The fragment I added is taken from the same interview and has the right to exist no less, if not more, for the simple reason that the article</i> affects the relationship between the UOC of the Kiev Patriarchate and the UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It will not be difficult for me to choose a more suitable section of the article and describe Mitrokhin's idea in detail and on the case.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

By the way, before school.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus, both fragments were stylistically better connected, in my opinion.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Although the article is not flawless, it does provide facts on the whole.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would not like to fill it with journalism, interviews and opinions of the format “based on the results of my observations during a trip to the south of the country, I noted...” (not to mention the fact that it is not clear what the south is fundamental, why are the center and the north not discussed, for example?).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In general, without challenging Mitrokhin's authority in his subject area, I am still extremely skeptical about the theses of the form “for the most part in the post-Soviet space, pastors are former criminals or workers...”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is he authoritative in everything he claims (in particular, in statistics)?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The interview contains statements like “Of course, there were a number of priests of the UOC (MP) who took part in terrorist or underground pro-Russian activities. All of them campaigned for support of Russia's aggression in Ukraine, but they accounted for a very small share of the clergy of local dioceses. Yes, they enjoyed the support, explicit or not, of local bishops. Again, how many bishops from the total number of the UOC (MP) explicitly or secretly supported the aggression? About five of all who are now serving” and to one degree or another, these statements will be in the article as a result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would not like to translate this article into the UKR-PIC plane with the discussion on the pages of this mediation.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Is this exactly what the school wants?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash (obs) 18:39, August 28, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Is he authoritative in everything he claims (in particular in statistics)?” — In this case, Mitrokhin, as a sociologist, cites certain figures that he received during his trip to southern Ukraine (in other words, he conducted field research there).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So far, you can't see any of the researchers catching him by the hand.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If they will, then we'll discuss it.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The fragment I added is taken from the same interview and has the right to exist no less, if not more, for the simple reason that the article touches on the relationship between the UOC of the Kiev Patriarchate and The UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate.” — The text you inserted, no matter how much you want it, is completely inappropriate in the article about the UOC-KP.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Regarding “translating this article into the UKR-POS plane”, I would not advise, since you are well aware of VP: PAPA.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, since we are talking about a religious organization, the issue should be considered in this area, and not in the state geographical area.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Regarding the issue of journalism, let me remind you that in the article The Murder of Pentecostals in Slavyansk, the level of journalism goes off scale, not to say that it is entirely journalism.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And I also remember you on the SO (Discussion: Murder of Pentecostals in Slavyansk #Удаление source and Discussion: Murder of Pentecostal people in Slavyansk #Основной text) defended the importance of marginal and biased statements by journalists Fionika and Musafirova, who, unlike Mitrokhin (VP:EXPERT), are neither specialists nor scientists ever.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Quod licet Jovi, non licet bovi?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For the rest, I think that respected intermediaries should sum up the result.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Tempus/obs 07:13, August 29, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1) Your statement about field research should probably inspire respect and be taken for granted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As well as Mitrokhin's statement about the majority of pastors from criminals (also statistics in his presentation).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I ask you to either provide links to statistics studies, or there is nothing to do in the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2) Your claim about the “irrelevance of the text” should probably also be taken for granted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

My argument, according to which the article, among other things, describes the relationship between the two Orthodox churches in Ukraine, was completely ignored.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3) The statement about the marginality and partiality of journalists in an article about Pentecostals in Slavyansk (what does this have to do with it?) simply unsubstantiated, there is nothing to discuss here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They are journalists, they describe the events according to eyewitnesses, and they described it flawlessly accurately.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As a result: you did not answer the key arguments on the merits of the question (No. 1 and No. 3), the answers to the rest are unsubstantiated or erroneous.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash (obs) 07:35, August 29, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The interview contains statements of the kind” — Why didn't you have any skepticism about the statistics here?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Interestingly, this statement by Mitrokhin is a little higher in the text (this is to the question about the article about the murder of Pentecostal people): I had to answer questions about the so-called “Russian for a year and a half Orthodox Army”, which fought in the East.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For a year and a half, I told people that there are no obvious connections between them and the Russian Orthodox Church.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

That is, a marginal group refers to the majority based on its rational factors.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This is all to attract external sponsors, although in fact it is part of the movement “Russian National Unity”, which is headed by pseudo-schemer Alexander Barkashov, who lives with a couple of wives near Moscow.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

We will not use the harsh wording that this is a “pseudo-Orthodox” group, but we can state that this movement definitely has nothing to do with the official organizations of the Russian Orthodox Church.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 07:42, August 29, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“and Mitrokhin's statement about the majority of pastors from criminals (also statistics in his presentation). I ask you to either provide links to statistical studies, or there is nothing to do in the article.” — We discuss the statistics of parishes, not criminals, among Protestant pastors.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Mitrokhin also said a little differently: “Is this not the result of pressure from the authorities?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

— No, the situation is quite real.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Who are Protestants?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

For the most part, pastors in the post-Soviet space are former criminals or workers.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I do not know what condition the same pastors are in today in Ukraine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

More precisely, in its different regions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Why didn't they initially take an active part in Donbass when it was just beginning... And you can still see other opinions on this matter — about the post-Soviet space?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Mitrokhin said directly and honestly about Ukraine that he did not know what pastors are here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And “the same pastors” means that we are talking about Protestant pastors as such, and not about what environment they came from.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The argument according to which the article, among other things, describes the relationship between the two Orthodox churches in Ukraine was completely ignored.” — Where are any statistics discussed there at all?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“The statement about the marginality and partiality of journalists in an article about Pentecostals in Sloviansk (what does this have to do with it?) simply unsubstantiated, there is nothing to discuss here. They are journalists, they describe the events according to eyewitnesses, and they described it impeccably accurately.” — Evidence of the partiality of Fionika and Musafirova was shown at the relevant SO.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And about “and they described it flawlessly accurately” should of course be taken on faith, or were you standing next to you and shining a flashlight when they wrote it down in a notebook?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“As a result, you did not answer the key arguments on the merits of the question (No. 1 and No. 3), the answers to the rest are unsubstantiated or erroneous.” — 100% exactly the opposite.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 07:45, August 29, 2016 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Preliminary result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Nikolai Mitrokhin, although not a religious scholar by profession, but an archivist historian, seriously studied the history of the Orthodox Church.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

So the first proposal - his assessment of the real number of parishes of the UOC-KP - is appropriate in this section.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But the second proposal concerns only the dynamics of processes in the UOC-MP, and by themselves, and not in comparison with the same processes in the UOC-KP.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Therefore, the second sentence is in the article about the UOC-MP, and not about the UOC-KP.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there are no reasoned objections within a week, the preliminary result will be final.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega 18:21, December 21, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Colleague, there's only one objection.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

More than two years have passed since the request of the KOI was made and the situation has changed a lot, in particular, after the creation of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the current situation, extremely controversial statements of a journalistic nature tied in time to the events of the past should not be in the review article at all, there are no objective reasons for this, more because the information is out of date.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It's not relevant at all.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash (obs.) 19:05, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I will add to this the following: the UOC (KP) no longer exists (since December 15, 2018), by merging it with another Orthodox Church, the Ukrainian Orthodox Church was created, to which parishes began to move UOC (Moscow Patriarchate).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But these are precisely the events described in the fragment “At the same time, he said that in the UOC of the Moscow Patriarchate “there is a complex dynamics of the growth of the pro-Ukrainian part, the redistribution of forces, intellectual growth, reassessment of theological heritage, etc. “”, which you propose to remove, but it has retained its relevance, as evidenced by the transfer of parishes.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Taking into account all this, I see the point in general to remove the entire fragment in the first and second parts as irrelevant and meaningless for the review article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In addition, about a religious organization that does not legally exist, and on the basis of which another Orthodox Church was created.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash 19:21, December 22, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Information about the past is stored on Wikipedia, only the text of the article is rewritten in the past tense and with attribution: according to such data, for such a year... Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a reference organizations.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Unlike directories, there is no task here that only information that is relevant today is contained, and outdated information is replaced or deleted.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Since encyclopedic significance does not lose over time, articles about organizations that no longer exist (as well as other subjects of the past) on Wikipedia are preserved and can be supplemented after publication new AI's about them.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If there is a more authoritative source with information about the number of the UOC-KP during the entire existence of this organization, then it can be used instead of Mitrokhin or instead.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the meantime, since there is no more complete and newer data on this issue, what is left is.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega (obs.) 10:22, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

1) Colleague, you misunderstood me.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

A slice of data for 2016 (in itself controversial), based on unrepresentative observations of one person (it clearly states in the text that the conclusions were drawn by one person based on a trip to the south Ukraine. The south of Ukraine is not the whole of Ukraine, why exactly the south, not the center, not the north?).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is a fundamental difference between journalism, which is the source and the fragment itself, and scientific representative information, which makes sense to present in the article.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

By the way, the quality of the source with the conclusions a-la “for the most part in the post-Soviet space, pastors are former criminals or workers” does not stand up to criticism in academic terms (but this is already so, little things).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

2) It makes sense to write data about the past in the context of other data on the subject.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The unsewn outdated opinion for 2016 looks ridiculous and hanging in the air.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Such things should either be stated normally, in the dynamics of events, or even removed altogether.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

3) As a person involuntarily involved in a number of conflicts on topics at the intersection of NEARC-LGBT people in the past, I will share with you my opinion as a new mediator: avoid journalism as a source at any cost.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Journalism is unscientific, non-neutral, conflictogenic.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Any result based on journalism is the laying of deliberate conflicts in the topic between participants for a long time.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash (obs.) 11:13, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Avoid journalism as sources at any cost” — Dear colleague, but what about #Фионик, around which so many copies have been broken?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Not to mention other sources in the article Murder of Pentecostals in Slavyansk, around which passions for Discussion: The Murder of Pentecostals in Slavyansk were in full swing.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Or have you had any changes in your assessment since then?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Or I misunderstand everything, but these (“Journalism is unscientific, non-neutral, conflictogenic. Any result based on journalism is the laying of deliberate conflicts in the topic between the participants for a long time.”), in general, reasonable things were said just for the beauty of the syllable?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 13:14, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I was expecting your comment with a reference to the events in Slavyansk.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is a fundamental difference between a journalistic investigation in hot pursuit with a presentation of facts and unrepresentative information from an opinion based on a sample of one person and the volume research (?) on a sample from one region of Ukraine.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The key concept is the reliability and relevance of information, which is not available in this case.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash (obs.) 14:08, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It's clear.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Unfortunately, some things/people don't change.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

As for the issue under discussion, Fionique does not present any “fact”, but not the private opinion of one unknown person supported by anything.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Reliability is close to zero there.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If he interviewed several people and compared their opinions, then there would be something to talk about.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

While Mitrokhin, firstly, is quite satisfied with VP:EXPERT (and not just some “one person”), secondly, if necessary, he is probably able to document his conclusions, as well as is due to a sociologist.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 14:48, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

There is a distance between the author of a serious publication and the interviewer, which sometimes does not fit well with the requirements for the source, even if it is about the same person.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Bloopers about “criminal pastors” are simple proof of this.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I don't think it's possible to discuss your opinion of Fionica with you here.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

The conversation was with the mediator, in which the preliminary outcome intended for discussion was discussed.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

—Shamash (obs.) 15:10, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“There is a distance between the author of a serious publication and the interviewer, which sometimes does not fit well with the requirements for the source, even if it is the same person.” — However, you can't see there is no distance at all between an interview with a well-known researcher and an unknown resident of Slavyansk, who may be anyone.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

“Blunders about “criminal pastors” are simple proof of this” — Not quite so: “For the most part, pastors in the post-Soviet space are former criminals or workers.”


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

And given the widespread emphasis among some Protestant movements on social service in prisons and the rehabilitation of drug addicts, Mitrokhin said is not very surprising.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 15:41, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I can once again remind you of my request not to copy fragments of my own messages above in response.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

and further on in the section.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

At this point, I will withdraw from the dialogue with you, if you allow me.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash (obs.) 15:45, December 24, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, if you have better AI for the same facts, it is better not to use journalism and news reports.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

But since on the question of how much the real number of active parishes of the UOC-KP differed from the officially announced one, there have been no better sources yet - Mitrokhin's opinion with appropriate attribution is given, used in the absence of a better alternative.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega (obs.) 23:59, December 28, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

They exist, and I would like to point out here: In other words, these are more modern data.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Here is the analysis of this information, and in dynamics, since the process continues and the appointment of the tomos is expected in a week.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

I would also like to draw your attention to the fact that the author separately mentions registered parishes and the number of senior clerics correlated with the real state of local leadership.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

This publication has been reprinted on the InoSMI website.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

ru, which characterizes the quality of the material.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Roumega, this is a quick search.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

If necessary, I can add a large number of relevant analytics (over the past year).


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

These are new, previously unaccounted data when considering the old request of the KOI.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash 09:12, December 29, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

It's a good thing you have.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

When you remake the section on the number of the Russian Orthodox Church KP for these and other best AI, you will show the dynamics of the official and expected real number of members and parishes of the Russian Orthodox Church KP on them - Mitrokhin will not be possible cite as unnecessary.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

In the final result, I will take this into account: I will write that this link to Mitrokhin may remain until it is replaced by a more neutral and more reliable AI that confirms the same information.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega (obs.) 13:10, December 29, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Yes, thanks.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Question: What do you mean to describe this information?


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Since it may not be confirmed, but challenged, or described in a different aspect, as presented in the sources, and that Mitrokhin does not affect.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Shamash (obs.) 13:38, December 29, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Only a big request is to pre-propose the text on the CO of the relevant article, and not immediately add it to the article in order to save both someone else's and your time, and not spend it on long and tedious discussions.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Tempus/obs 14:44, December 29, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Of course, with regard to VP:NTZ, if there are disagreements between the AI, we must do so.


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Alexander Rumega 17:31, December 29, 2018 (UTC)


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Result


Question: What is the first work written by Roman Nikolaevich Lunkin?

KOI

Nikolai Mitrokhin, although not a religious scholar by profession, but an archivist historian, seriously studied the history of the Orthodox Church.